instruction
stringlengths
147
1.1k
output
stringclasses
2 values
generator
stringclasses
3 values
<question> What does 'out of service cars' mean in the context of reporting requirements for rail equipment accidents/incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA's requirement for a detailed narrative description enhance the understanding of accident causes and consequences, and what are the implications for railroad safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How should railroads handle cases where the cause of injury or fatality is unclear and may involve suicide or attempted suicide? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> This question involves the following sequence of events: Employee A drives to work, parks her car in the company parking lot, and is walking across the lot, when she is struck by a car driven by Employee B, who is commuting to work. Both employees are seriously injured in the accident. Is either worker considered to be an employee on duty? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> What is the process for a railroad to determine the nature and severity of injuries sustained by highway users in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What forms are required to be submitted to the FRA for reporting railroad injuries and illnesses, and what information must be included on these forms? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the specific criteria for reporting a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident, and what forms must be used? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential consequences for railroads that fail to comply with the regulations outlined in Form FRA F 6180.107? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do I report the number of derailed locomotives and cars if the consist was involved in a collision that resulted in a derailment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if an injury occurring in the company parking lot before the employee officially starts their shift is work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps must a railroad take if it is unable to obtain a response from a potentially injured highway user after sending the required Form FRA F 6180.150 and cover letter? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Does this mean that I must report all cuts, lacerations, punctures, and scratches? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> Under what circumstances is telephonic notification required for railroad accidents or incidents according to the flowchart in Appendix M? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> During a derailment involving multiple railroads, the reporting railroad is responsible for the locomotive, but not the track maintenance. The derailment resulted in the release of hazardous materials from cars owned by another railroad. How should the reporting railroad complete Items 2, 3, 8, 9, and 10 on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How might the classification system outlined in the FRA guide impact the overall safety analysis of a railroad company? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a PLHCP recommends that an employee work restricted duty for one calendar day, but the employee works unrestricted, how should this be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee initially reported as injured later dies within 180 days of the injury, what steps must the railroad take to amend the report, and within what timeframe should this be done? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the potential consequences of failing to adhere to the FRA's guidelines on contradictory information in accident/incident reports, and how does this impact railroad safety and the integrity of the reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In the event of a rail equipment accident/incident involving a collision, what specific information must be included in the Rail Equipment Accident/Incident Report, and how might this impact the subsequent investigation and safety protocols? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the significance of the "reportable injury" classification, and how does it impact the railroad's investigation and reporting process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A railroad employee was found deceased on the tracks. Preliminary investigation suggests it might be a suicide. What specific steps must the railroad take to confirm and report this incident as a suicide, and what forms must be used for reporting? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is an injury sustained by an employee while walking from a company parking lot to the workplace reportable under FRA regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a railroad report an injury or illness that occurs to an employee who is working on a joint operation with another railroad, and what forms are required? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad alleges that an employee's action or physical condition was a primary or contributing cause of a rail equipment accident/incident, what form must the railroad complete and provide to the employee, and what rights does the employee have in this process? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the legal definition of "serious injury" in the context of train accidents, and how does it impact the reporting requirements under § 225.9? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In a joint operation scenario, if one railroad's damages are below the reporting threshold but the total damages from all railroads involved exceed the threshold, is the railroad with damages below the threshold still required to report the accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How can railroad companies effectively communicate the importance of drug/alcohol testing to employees, especially in light of potential legal consequences for refusal, to ensure a safer work environment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a railroad chooses to submit its monthly accident/incident reports to FRA electronically, what are the specific requirements for submitting a signed Form FRA F 6180.55? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was walking down a hallway at work and suddenly felt a sharp pain in their back. There were no visible hazards, and the employee did not trip or slip. The employee subsequently visited a PLHCP, who diagnosed a muscle strain and recommended rest and over-the-counter pain medication. Is this injury considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What steps must a railroad take to determine the nature and severity of injuries sustained by highway users in a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the naming of employees on FRA forms relate to the concept of "pre-judging," and what are the potential consequences for railroad safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the requirements for providing FRA with access to records and reports within four business hours, and what are the options for submitting these reports electronically? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the context of railroad safety, how does the FRA guide define "hazardous materials" and "HAZMAT release," and what are the reporting requirements for each? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the process for calculating the average number of workers employed during the report year for Form FRA F 6180.56? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of a 'siding' in the context of railroad tracks? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How might the deferred notification policy on medical grounds impact the overall investigation process and the railroad's ability to identify and address safety concerns? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If an employee is injured while walking to their assigned work location on railroad property, is this injury considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the difference between 'medical treatment' and 'first aid' in the context of reporting injuries and illnesses under Part 225? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is an injury that occurs in the company parking lot or on the walkway to the work building before the start of the work shift considered work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Does an impact between on-track railroad equipment and a pedestrian on a railway sidewalk at a grade crossing qualify as a highway-rail grade crossing accident/incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an accident occurs on a siding rather than a main track, do I still need to report the annual gross tonnage over the track? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a rail equipment accident/incident is caused by an employee human factor, and the employee involved has since passed away, is the railroad still required to complete and file Form FRA F 6180.81, the Employee Human Factor Attachment? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the purpose of the Remarks Section in the FRA reporting forms? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA guide define a "casualty" in the context of railroad operations, and what are the implications for reporting and classification? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the potential consequences for railroads if they fail to amend cause codes (e.g., M505) once their investigation is complete and the cause is determined? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> An employee suffers a minor cut on their hand while working on the tracks. The company's on-site medical team cleans the wound, applies a bandage, and provides an over-the-counter antibiotic ointment. Is this considered first aid or medical treatment, and what are the reporting requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Is the injury reportable if the employee slips and falls on the company's parking lot or sidewalk before officially starting their shift? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the jurisdictional overlap between FRA and OSHA affect a railroad's obligations for maintaining and reporting employee injury and illness records? Specifically, if a railroad complies with FRA's regulations, are they also in compliance with OSHA's requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A derailment occurred on a joint operation track, and both railroads were involved. The total damage exceeded the reporting threshold, but each railroad’s individual damage did not. How should the railroads proceed with their reporting responsibilities? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A non-employee trespasser was injured when they were struck by a train. The injury required medical treatment beyond first aid. Is this incident reportable, and if so, on which form? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train derailed, and the railroad incurred costs for the replacement of damaged track and signals. The replacement track was secondhand, and the total cost of the new materials and labor to repair the track and signals was $8,500. The labor costs include hourly wages, transportation, and hotel expenses for the repair crew. Is this derailment reportable under FRA regulations, and if so, how should the costs be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the detailed reporting requirements outlined in the passage contribute to enhancing railroad safety and effective incident management? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the definition of a "new case" impact the reporting and management of injuries and illnesses in railroad operations, and what are the potential consequences of misreporting or underreporting these incidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A train derailment occurred, causing significant damage to the track and signals. The damages totaled $10,000. Is this incident reportable, and if so, on which form should it be reported? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What specific information must be included in the alternative railroad-designed record to ensure it meets FRA requirements? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> After a highway-rail grade crossing accident, what steps must a railroad take to contact and obtain information from potentially injured highway users, and what information must be included in the cover letter accompanying Form FRA F 6180.150? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad sends the Form FRA F 6180.150 to a highway user who was involved in a grade crossing incident, but the highway user does not respond, is the railroad required to take any further action to determine if the injury was reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the penalty for a willful violation of the failure to accurately report an accident, injury, or occupational illness under § 225.11(c)? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What criteria determine whether a casualty resulting from a suicide or attempted suicide must be included in the casualty counts in boxes 46, 49, and 52? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the specific criteria that require reporting of a needlestick or sharps injury to a railroad employee? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do the Occupation/Responsibilities Codes in the FRA guide influence the safety measures and procedures for different railroad worker roles? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> A highway vehicle was struck by a train at a crossing that was barricaded and marked as closed. The vehicle was attempting to cross the tracks despite the barricades. Is this incident reportable, and if so, which form should be used to report it? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a railroad report the train-miles and hours worked when its equipment is being operated by another railroad's crew? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Our mechanical department personnel reported that they fixed a broken trainline bracket on a box car. It appears that the bracket broke because of normal wear and tear, and was not the result of an accident. Would events like this qualify for an Initial Rail Equipment Accident/Incident Record? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
Yes
human
<question> How can railroads ensure they collect sufficient information to determine reportable injuries while respecting the voluntary nature of the form and the user's privacy? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How does the "Employee Human Factor Attachment" contribute to enhancing railroad safety and accountability, and what are the key steps railroads should take to effectively utilize this tool? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> In the scenario where an employee is injured in the company parking lot before clocking in, such as slipping on ice or getting into a physical altercation, how does the FRA determine whether the injury is considered work-related and reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Is it mandatory for a highway user to respond to the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form, or is it voluntary? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If an employee experiences a sudden onset of back pain while lifting a heavy object at work, is this injury considered work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the definition of 'reportable damage' in the context of railroad equipment and infrastructure? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the use of cause codes M599, M505, and M507 impact the FRA's ability to analyze accident trends and improve safety measures? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Are there any other codes or instructions that must be followed when reporting a Passenger Station Platform Gap incident, aside from Code Number 18? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What are the criteria for determining whether an injury or illness is 'accountable' and must be recorded on Form FRA F 6180.98? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What is the process for handling and documenting claimed occupational illnesses for which the railroad has not received sufficient information to determine work-relatedness? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How has the interpretation of "safety-sensitive functions" evolved, and what are the implications for railroad managers and supervisors regarding their reporting responsibilities? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> With the presence of hazardous material residue, what specific actions must railroads take to mitigate the risks associated with residual hazardous materials during transportation and handling? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What is the significance of Item 18 in the accident/incident report, and how does it relate to the overall understanding of highway-rail grade crossing accidents? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Is the injury reportable if the employee slipped and fell on the company's parking lot and sidewalks while walking to the office to report to work, even though the parking lot and sidewalks are not within the controlled access points? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA's role in making final decisions on reportability ensure compliance with safety regulations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How can railroads effectively manage the process of contacting highway users and collecting information while ensuring confidentiality and avoiding potential legal issues? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How might the presumption of reportability for injuries on railroad premises impact the railroad's liability and insurance claims? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> If a contractor is hired to repair a section of track damaged in a derailment, and the total labor hours charged by the contractor are 100 hours at a loaded rate of $100 per hour, what costs should be reported for labor, and how should the costs be calculated? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What are the specific design requirements for an electronic record-keeping system used to retain accident/incident records as required by this part? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> When multiple railroads are involved in an incident, and the responsible railroad's identity is unknown, what measures does the FRA employ to ensure that the correct railroad takes responsibility for reporting the incident, and how does this process contribute to overall railroad safety? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> How do I estimate the labor costs for damage repair in a train accident report, especially when using contractor services? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How does the FRA determine which accidents/incidents warrant an investigation, and what are the criteria for prioritizing these investigations? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> Is an injury that occurs in the company parking lot or on the sidewalk leading to the work location considered to be in the 'work environment' for the purpose of determining work-relatedness? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> In the event of a workplace altercation resulting in injury, what factors determine whether the incident is considered work-related and thus reportable? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
cohere-command-r
<question> What should a railroad do if a highway user refuses to provide information on the Highway User Injury Inquiry Form (Form FRA F 6180.150) after the railroad has made reasonable efforts to contact them? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad supervisor is found to have intimidated an employee to prevent them from reporting a work-related injury, what actions should the railroad take according to the Internal Control Plan, and how must these actions be documented and communicated? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a vehicle is stopped on a crossing and struck by a train, how should the speed and position of the vehicle be reported on Form FRA F 6180.54? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A train strikes a car at a highway-rail grade crossing, and a second car, coming from the opposite direction, cannot stop in time and collides with the first car. How should this incident be reported on Form FRA F 6180.57? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How would an incident be classified if a railroad locomotive strikes a pedestrian at a location that is not a designated highway-rail grade crossing, such as a private crossing or a pathway not explicitly authorized for use? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How do I determine if an incident involving a passenger boarding or alighting a train at a high-level platform is reportable as a Passenger Station Platform Gap Incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> An employee was walking through a warehouse and felt a sudden pain in his lower back while picking up a small tool. There were no visible hazards or defects in the area, and the employee did not slip, trip, or fall. How should the employer determine if this injury is work-related? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> Which forms are used to report rail equipment accidents, injuries, and occupational illnesses, and what are their specific purposes? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> What should a railroad do if it cannot contact a highway user or the user refuses to provide information for Form FRA F 6180.150? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> A highway-rail grade crossing collision occurred, resulting in injuries to both the driver of the vehicle and a passenger. The on-track equipment was also damaged, with estimated costs exceeding the current reporting threshold. What forms need to be completed and submitted to FRA for this incident? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> If a railroad employee is involved in a rail equipment accident/incident and the railroad attributes the cause to an 'employee human factor,' what steps must the employee take if they wish to submit a statement supplementing the railroad's accident report? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b
<question> How should a railroad handle a situation where there is doubt about the reportability of an accident or incident involving a contractor or volunteer on railroad property? </question> Was this question written by a human domain expert? Answer only "Yes" or "No".
No
qwen-2.5-72b