question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I would love to get some advice regarding the following please!</p> <p>I am involved in a study that is looking at cognition across 3 separate groups (1= the clinical group of interest; 2= clinical control group; 3=healthy control group). All participants completed a range of cognitive tests. Preliminary analysis on the entire sample (n=51) showed that there was a general intellect difference between groups (grp 3 was higher than grps 1+2), which meant that any subsequent analysis showing differences on the cognitive tests could be due to intellect alone rather than a true difference. So the sample was specifically matched on IQ, resulting in an adjusted sample size of n=33 (11 per group). </p> <p>I was originally instructed to perform repeated measures ANOVAs on the refined sample for each of my cognitive tests. As such, the layout of my SPSS datafile shows 11 rows, so there are 3'groups' per variable (e.g., test1_group1; test1_group2; test1_group3). </p> <p>Now, there were no significant differences for any of these cognitive tests. However, there was a significant difference in terms of mood, and so I would be interested in running a repeated measures ANCOVA to investigate how much mood is impacting on the cognitive results. However, given the layout of my variables, I am becoming confused at how to run the repeated measures ANCOVA using SPSS, as my variable options re: the mood questionnaire produces 3 options (e.g., Mood_group1; mood_group2; mood_group3) - do I choose the mood variable for the group with the significant difference only, or use all 3 variables as covariates (which complicates the output somewhat!)</p> <p>To add yet another layer of complexity, I consulted with some friends about my analyses. They were confused why I was analysing using repeated measures and suggested I instead alter the layout of my SPSS datasheet so that I would have 33 rows (to match the n=33), and run a series of independent one-way ANOVAs, which would seem to solve my 3 variables per 'person' dilemma re: performing an ANCOVA, but leaves me extremely confused as this seems to make sense, but is not in line with what I was told originally.</p> <p>I'm sorry this has turned into a longer post than I had intended but hopefully it provides enough background in order for some well-needed advice to be thrown my way!! Any input/ideas would be greatly appreciated!</p>
73,563
[ -0.03649158403277397, 0.019341636449098587, -0.01707264967262745, 0.007024588994681835, 0.06514692306518555, 0.030021486803889275, -0.006367098074406385, -0.041638366878032684, -0.005988636985421181, -0.02273806370794773, 0.01884826458990574, 0.01933896727859974, 0.0319448746740818, -0.0012862045550718904, 0.015747979283332825, -0.014555067755281925, 0.021419920027256012, 0.0025302765425294638, -0.00812588632106781, 0.012306543998420238, -0.016326507553458214, -0.004216175992041826, 0.010091729462146759, 0.012084852904081345, -0.010701469145715237, 0.04481426253914833, 0.03506084159016609, -0.07931625097990036, 0.007224628236144781, 0.026196306571364403, -0.04046858847141266, -0.03235488757491112, -0.019199125468730927, 0.010001298040151596, 0.0035148290917277336, -0.008344604633748531, -0.0020805515814572573, 0.005732502788305283, -0.006371638737618923, 0.03723491355776787, -0.011723884381353855, 0.016275664791464806, -0.045308083295822144, 0.03587031364440918, -0.01774093322455883, 0.01702210307121277, -0.009929253719747066, -0.01437810342758894, 0.005702202208340168, -0.05851805582642555, 0.037801776081323624, 0.01176731288433075, 0.029882311820983887, 0.0524936281144619, 0.027122342959046364, -0.022235896438360214, 0.06263823807239532, 0.02884560078382492, 0.018981391564011574, -0.0417521670460701, -0.0012298432411625981, -0.016229914501309395, -0.005141064058989286, 0.0024892271030694246, -0.025543315336108208, 0.017977120354771614, 0.012281345203518867, -0.005793215706944466, 0.05219074711203575, -0.016217323020100594, 0.04973175376653671, 0.033631663769483566, 0.023378297686576843, -0.008282152935862541, 0.02202809974551201, -0.026920199394226074, 0.027550507336854935, -0.002467081183567643, 0.05259578302502632, 0.05052759870886803, 0.03554932400584221, 0.022846896201372147, -0.01320650614798069, 0.04233681038022041, 0.019446831196546555, -0.0059824129566550255, 0.06821252405643463, -0.06058518961071968, 0.00295250304043293, 0.01798044517636299, -0.00597994402050972, 0.011827699840068817, 0.04716430604457855, 0.032891467213630676, -0.013657883740961552, 0.03161998838186264, -0.04977664351463318, 0.021493947133421898, -0.03426172584295273, 0.012940163724124432, -0.016669854521751404, -0.014949949458241463, 0.014030617661774158, 0.02129552699625492, -0.007868211716413498, 0.004625055473297834, -0.02334536984562874, 0.01024616789072752, 0.02742183580994606, -0.05672783777117729, 0.013464641757309437, 0.023353170603513718, -0.007138634566217661, -0.020294802263379097, 0.008080190978944302, -0.015076184645295143, 0.004539480898529291, 0.006620312575250864, 0.025359855964779854, 0.060859497636556625, 0.027984116226434708, -0.027570169419050217, 0.021076610311865807, -0.0416606143116951, -0.03121064603328705, 0.00515392329543829, -0.001958826556801796, -0.00890524871647358, -0.018790554255247116, 0.07107122987508774, -0.009831241331994534, 0.01084754429757595, 0.04851456731557846, -0.0015962347388267517, 0.009950564242899418, 0.009678342379629612, -0.08422703295946121, -0.059475209563970566, 0.031653448939323425, 0.023253846913576126, 0.008010732010006905, -0.04079340398311615, -0.00821132492274046, 0.016892654821276665, 0.06445854157209396, 0.012579058296978474, 0.03419899567961693, 0.028441131114959717, 0.04317566379904747, 0.05105854198336601, -0.010509032756090164, 0.03042348101735115, -0.06941666454076767, -0.027465099468827248, -0.028752487152814865, -0.08662613481283188, 0.04461710900068283, 0.009405039250850677, 0.02304198034107685, -0.011742895469069481, 0.008845982141792774, -0.010027867741882801, -0.013493136502802372, -0.010249567218124866, 0.027383195236325264, 0.01601294055581093, 0.032091736793518066, -0.03758780658245087, 0.01283374521881342, 0.022325854748487473, 0.00038086975109763443, 0.008309401571750641, -0.02020813524723053, 0.05070636048913002, 0.044906724244356155, -0.020915931090712547, 0.007890278473496437, -0.01095185149461031, -0.0001957324711838737, 0.03688358888030052, -0.02661888487637043, -0.03806641325354576, -0.042978230863809586, -0.009410086087882519, 0.057894885540008545, 0.06104395166039467, -0.01513498555868864, 0.01264931820333004, 0.06115858629345894, 0.006174558773636818, -0.04597032815217972, -0.04212944209575653, 0.04249393939971924, -0.00017136051610577852, -0.049937836825847626, 0.06233746185898781, -0.029521387070417404, 0.02453984133899212, 0.02430875040590763, -0.030182380229234695, 0.006609224248677492, 0.02026602067053318, 0.048067137598991394, -0.03591844439506531, 0.032589495182037354, 0.03075079806149006, -0.009618562646210194, -0.02839847467839718, 0.045188628137111664, -0.028299368917942047, -0.015561309643089771, -0.0011977810645475984, -0.016270387917757034, 0.06728924810886383, -0.019381364807486534, -0.0010342205641791224, 0.003164153778925538, 0.05304315313696861, -0.05241614952683449, 0.05239888280630112, -0.06354653090238571, 0.06166033819317818, 0.0609414204955101, -0.018752848729491234, 0.005045606289058924, 0.03278091177344322, 0.028832577168941498, 0.010475083254277706, -0.019516175612807274, 0.0118250185623765, -0.04638221114873886, -0.013886706903576851, 0.05087066814303398, -0.018493149429559708, -0.019250936806201935, -0.02196035347878933, 0.03642889857292175, 0.02148568443953991, -0.0005741206696256995, 0.041497647762298584, 0.014363519847393036, -0.03669630363583565, 0.0040895710699260235, 0.03647303208708763, 0.029069481417536736, 0.008375410921871662, -0.006838964764028788, -0.0035563637502491474, 0.026034412905573845, 0.041563332080841064, 0.01805756986141205, 0.05203988403081894, 0.010338382795453072, 0.00039734889287501574, -0.02062549814581871, -0.017489837482571602, 0.03355255722999573, -0.04122228920459747, -0.011135046370327473, 0.06256107240915298, 0.018130894750356674, -0.052551720291376114, 0.006285377312451601, -0.0353228822350502, 0.006509924307465553, 0.034898146986961365, -0.015261111781001091, -0.0022974838502705097, -0.0017316365847364068, -0.017470069229602814, 0.019732864573597908, -0.0031008473597466946, -0.019338106736540794, -0.023209216073155403, 0.018756087869405746, -0.0017200350994244218, -0.017328711226582527, 0.019594550132751465, -0.0392221175134182, 0.04981660842895508, 0.022031482309103012, 0.004066417459398508, 0.03436273708939552, -0.011371869593858719, -0.06799190491437912, -0.022298339754343033, -0.010681349784135818, 0.0006815292872488499, 0.00455506844446063, -0.011565938591957092, -0.011177594773471355, 0.031527064740657806, -0.00019803777104243636, -0.04922662675380707, -0.014125059358775616, -0.018497837707400322, 0.007848567329347134, -0.028015373274683952, -0.039756033569574356, 0.06529895216226578, 0.03514702245593071, -0.06831682473421097, -0.003557306481525302, 0.016181908547878265, 0.008789925836026669, 0.026395821943879128, -0.004392795730382204, -0.004505291115492582, 0.014785794541239738, 0.008872140198946, 0.012637563981115818, -0.013294809497892857, -0.047732166945934296, -0.04535938799381256, -0.056200288236141205, 0.00560685945674777, 0.011283660307526588, 0.03765232861042023, -0.04064527526497841, -0.0002636260469444096, 0.0721014067530632, 0.01773601956665516, -0.017548557370901108, -0.0702657550573349, -0.014555332250893116, -0.007689513731747866, -0.023731136694550514, 0.038854680955410004, 0.03661199286580086, -0.007431581616401672, -0.0003508299414534122, -0.0395875982940197, 0.03184070438146591, 0.04145278409123421, 0.02641952969133854, -0.01309209130704403, 0.044044651091098785, 0.010285302065312862, -0.018234096467494965, 0.012712467461824417, -0.006429783534258604, -0.01584944687783718, -0.01768597960472107, 0.008105085231363773, 0.02096216008067131, -0.007747340947389603, -0.03441339358687401, 0.039383504539728165, -0.03612518683075905, 0.026285141706466675, -0.040825266391038895, -0.004649531561881304, 0.02459605596959591, -0.04144233837723732, -0.01628483459353447, 0.00874146819114685, 0.03299163281917572, -0.04139154776930809, -0.013232998549938202, 0.03880045935511589, 0.005432868376374245, 0.019074615091085434, -0.014027856290340424, -0.03920396417379379, -0.024094363674521446, 0.017900224775075912, -0.03498617187142372, -0.004679558798670769, 0.00940167997032404, 0.047608911991119385, 0.02848106250166893, 0.0062983473762869835, -0.05422551929950714, -0.00756965484470129, -0.09823616594076157, -0.004620397463440895, -0.054395101964473724, 0.02584785409271717, 0.01538552064448595, 0.036162834614515305, 0.013055042363703251, -0.029768818989396095, -0.02088792435824871, 0.009649110026657581, -0.05085422098636627, 0.015032087452709675, -0.018254617229104042, 0.018150141462683678, 0.05194815248250961, -0.029584651812911034, 0.007904469966888428, -0.03621067479252815, 0.01043866015970707, 0.0018905148608610034, 0.020389655604958534, 0.009187545627355576, -0.019441962242126465, -0.0062295496463775635, 0.020053481683135033, 0.001412157085724175, 0.037269383668899536, 0.011167498305439949, -0.020310061052441597, -0.015009170398116112, 0.0078119393438100815, -0.004567921627312899, -0.019637154415249825, 0.005646732170134783, -0.003977171145379543, 0.03288617357611656, 0.057149119675159454, 0.0017282437765970826, 0.04396143928170204, -0.0034102285280823708, 0.015552741475403309, -0.017577987164258957, -0.019054383039474487, 0.02893354557454586, -0.024104278534650803, -0.038198135793209076, -0.025171946734189987, -0.018134817481040955, 0.009201288223266602, 0.043082963675260544, 0.011781588196754456, 0.006378810852766037, 0.014233888126909733, 0.012573042884469032, -0.054991427809000015, 0.004808424506336451, 0.029229681938886642, -0.0009543481282889843, -0.03728863224387169, -0.040404558181762695, 0.016351930797100067, -0.015300511382520199, -0.022854145616292953, 0.0546162985265255, 0.008557833731174469, -0.009795249439775944, -0.020674999803304672, 0.04705136641860008, -0.03914647921919823, -0.036323271691799164, 0.01697227731347084, 0.027304157614707947, 0.027421317994594574, 0.05921296402812004, -0.03317346051335335, 0.01092015951871872, 0.014268086291849613, 0.01539847906678915, 0.0056084017269313335, -0.0011732246493920684, -0.08821108192205429, -0.0031486700754612684, 0.05719034746289253, 0.03896830603480339, -0.017184380441904068, -0.0005857948563061655, 0.014310017228126526, -0.0161331407725811, 0.009964955039322376, -0.04959191381931305, -0.0027882352005690336, -0.015233630314469337, 0.013718676753342152, -0.09473256021738052, -0.03346101567149162, -0.02717212401330471, 0.0010143339168280363, -0.006234718952327967, 0.027600517496466637, 0.03384000435471535, 0.012132351286709309, -0.030942967161536217, -0.023292019963264465, 0.01657610945403576, 0.030105015262961388, -0.03640946373343468, -0.0173477865755558, 0.04482067748904228, 0.014741676859557629, -0.02046314626932144, -0.05948393791913986, 0.015389868058264256, -0.01310539897531271, 0.00398971838876605, 0.05812869966030121, 0.010389141738414764, -0.02984069474041462, -0.0004094363539479673, 0.01405731588602066, 0.006067248061299324, 0.018881797790527344, -0.03358892723917961, 0.07361922413110733, -0.002279298845678568, -0.03161708265542984, 0.06573916971683502, 0.03138343617320061, 0.003127759089693427, 0.04419390484690666, -0.036219190806150436, -0.015890751034021378, -0.06894922256469727, -0.047975730150938034, -0.03892606124281883, -0.00932931900024414, -0.018167411908507347, 0.050887368619441986, -0.009244421496987343, 0.04342488572001457, -0.014730933122336864, -0.02582477778196335, 0.029590580612421036, 0.012059515342116356, 0.04000246152281761, 0.026072179898619652, 0.00022779012215323746, -0.004135425668209791, 0.004391547292470932, -0.0346187986433506, 0.010645333677530289, -0.03191226348280907, -0.008572615683078766, 0.01632259413599968, -0.06256239116191864, -0.01570121943950653, -0.01624579168856144, -0.046473272144794464, 0.006773934233933687, -0.014527454040944576, 0.010185150429606438, -0.022118758410215378, 0.025356603786349297, 0.015923574566841125, -0.04787937551736832, -0.02359502948820591, 0.05978214740753174, -0.022574735805392265, 0.003320682793855667, 0.008961057290434837, 0.0384310781955719, -0.015499448403716087, -0.00017381882935296744, -0.07776376605033875, -0.02177746221423149, 0.026698671281337738, -0.006319304462522268, -0.0020111193880438805, 0.012850767001509666, -0.013743403367698193, 0.0016083460068330169, 0.0011350562563166022, -0.03177006542682648, 0.05347299203276634, -0.014537062495946884, -0.021158581599593163, -0.025897806510329247, 0.021159326657652855, 0.07336832582950592, -0.02170220948755741, 0.021153241395950317, 0.004704669117927551, -0.031293269246816635, -0.021023621782660484, -0.02925202064216137, -0.03395707532763481, -0.01753925532102585, -0.02628238871693611, -0.04867559298872948, 0.018928566947579384, 0.028523828834295273, -0.013690990395843983, -0.03026198223233223, 0.004886442329734564, -0.029444921761751175, 0.009731513448059559, -0.043871305882930756, -0.018080255016684532, -0.008608204312622547, -0.004770760890096426, -0.039718590676784515, -0.0025038206949830055, -0.018327053636312485, 0.013905799947679043, 0.019451916217803955, -0.009893516078591347, -0.04400402680039406, 0.013175223022699356, 0.05313568562269211, 0.01265199389308691, -0.013543079607188702, -0.018314283341169357, -0.02234588749706745, 0.017292408272624016, 0.012408789247274399, -0.0017271044198423624, -0.01825752668082714, 0.02952512353658676, -0.007055348251014948, 0.0016039748443290591, -0.06024517863988876, -0.008516051806509495, 0.05616220459342003, 0.03022649697959423, 0.006937780417501926, 0.05558030307292938, -0.011867661960422993, -0.020357724279165268, -0.028055325150489807, 0.011276484467089176, -0.028373006731271744, 0.027939165011048317, 0.06374560296535492, -0.006818027701228857, -0.009164177812635899, -0.005133519414812326, 0.027806850150227547, -0.002237969310954213, 0.042782217264175415, 0.005084937438368797, 0.03444801643490791, 0.03133246302604675, -0.012800009921193123, -0.06647773087024689, 0.038111042231321335, -0.01583007350564003, 0.0017576483078300953, -0.04851279407739639, -0.06376739591360092, 0.020064132288098335, 0.06805472820997238, -0.0018977751024067402, -0.052846528589725494, -0.029973546043038368, -0.04722929745912552, 0.010600040666759014, 0.022665303200483322, -0.04373103752732277, 0.027713308110833168, 0.020322246477007866, 0.007054464891552925, 0.011129907332360744, -0.01905362866818905, -0.002635907381772995, -0.08388404548168182, -0.027801768854260445, 0.015668770298361778, -0.047978632152080536, 0.061182208359241486, -0.035269636660814285, -0.03790835291147232, 0.007471921853721142, -0.041007399559020996, 0.027310585603117943, -0.0013872153358533978, 0.02058625966310501, -0.009632334113121033, 0.03620576113462448, -0.03539372980594635, 0.022865569218993187, 0.006587283220142126, 0.002515138126909733, 0.11561734974384308, 0.07943467050790787, 0.049517977982759476, -0.07784692198038101, 0.049347031861543655, 0.028656287118792534, 0.02109537459909916, 0.011800272390246391, 0.03317004069685936, -0.009396428242325783, -0.05235965549945831, 0.03153559938073158, 0.07130736112594604, 0.019762292504310608, 0.001208798261359334, 0.03811201453208923, 0.0033987618517130613, -0.008145567029714584, 0.020627403631806374, 0.007035910617560148, 0.015245276503264904, -0.022254081442952156, 0.007478940766304731, 0.02767433226108551, -0.02061310037970543, -0.026651477441191673, -0.010376261547207832, -0.011736924760043621, 0.009147342294454575, 0.004528914112597704, -0.008992199786007404, 0.02842041850090027, -0.029756760224699974, 0.005175619386136532, -0.0337967611849308, -0.008074122481048107, 0.011960373260080814, -0.0727815330028534, -0.003979829140007496, 0.033216118812561035, -0.024857308715581894, -0.010370093397796154, -0.028220657259225845, 0.011374679394066334, -0.0444495752453804, -0.038032516837120056, -0.009256314486265182, 0.05070262774825096, -0.02381477691233158, -0.06121090427041054, -0.01899019256234169, 0.017674678936600685, 0.011996183544397354, -0.05918756127357483, -0.04973406717181206, -0.0007204155554063618, 0.009531600400805473, -0.028049852699041367, -0.027316510677337646, -0.010535742156207561, -0.039982736110687256, 0.009890718385577202, 0.04735315218567848, 0.014104250818490982, -0.01910264603793621, -0.01888955570757389, -0.04120340570807457, -0.010283706709742546, 0.042313024401664734, 0.023697199299931526, 0.01650814898312092, 0.009236631914973259, -0.021931590512394905, -0.05838862434029579, 0.02038736455142498, 0.054985757917165756, 0.001984315225854516, -0.024946266785264015, -0.016886040568351746, -0.053084682673215866, -0.025891080498695374, 0.024014625698328018, -0.04237016290426254, -0.008736595511436462, -0.021538371220231056, 0.030264338478446007, 0.02975653111934662, 0.05672597885131836, 0.03992609307169914, 0.007112493272870779, 0.007740260101854801, 0.03605061396956444, 0.025248762220144272, -0.0525658018887043, 0.007702433504164219, 0.005802980624139309, -0.02703101560473442, -0.024045178666710854, -0.039214570075273514, 0.06549777090549469, -0.009443496353924274, 0.007053022272884846, -0.0167060736566782, 0.04101654142141342, 0.01131577230989933, 0.014406953938305378, 0.016792239621281624, -0.04242200404405594, 0.0015157324960455298, -0.013624870218336582, 0.022372040897607803, -0.008621969260275364, -0.0208791084587574, -0.04591112583875656, -0.023006118834018707, 0.01972242258489132, -0.037182752043008804, 0.007646883372217417, -0.012972882017493248, 0.019536331295967102, 0.014856723137199879, -0.02051672898232937, -0.025573136284947395, -0.054635677486658096, -0.01636277325451374, -0.04700040817260742, -0.007686936762183905, 0.016845904290676117, -0.010704999789595604, 0.023069385439157486, 0.004303666763007641, 0.06133314594626427, -0.0032565465662628412, 0.04562246799468994, -0.01567178964614868, 0.008466142229735851, 0.003206139663234353, 0.03404437378048897, 0.018748871982097626, -0.033397823572158813, 0.021458107978105545, -0.04408261552453041, -0.021489331498742104, 0.022255614399909973, 0.015288285911083221, 0.014292227104306221, 0.05570076033473015, 0.006899451836943626, -0.023879215121269226, 0.06758639216423035, 0.005232032388448715, -0.037299852818250656, -0.00571398064494133, -0.013365966267883778, 0.009864093735814095, -0.02640439383685589, -0.00491808308288455, 0.03969607874751091, -0.019660573452711105, 0.0693940743803978, 0.0611741729080677, 0.019788824021816254, -0.0033795074559748173, -0.010441256687045097, -0.02668067254126072, 0.023268844932317734, -0.0026541072875261307, -0.02176629565656185, 0.02229415252804756, 0.033375442028045654, -0.02378319576382637, 0.02739998884499073, -0.0002387495624134317, 0.018354125320911407, -0.04248585179448128, -0.027527611702680588, -0.009733835235238075, 0.0290769524872303, 0.013851572759449482, -0.04246935620903969, 0.006939766928553581, 0.03818772733211517, -0.034353505820035934, 0.017188653349876404, 0.00947624258697033, 0.012484410777688026, -0.002086707390844822, 0.014788210391998291, -0.039230525493621826, -0.013646936975419521, 0.014311900362372398, 0.0058385105803608894, 0.03151518851518631, 0.0443071685731411, 0.008821243420243263, -0.06302272528409958, 0.013930406421422958, 0.019242487847805023, 0.016415409743785858, -0.06609625369310379, -0.01559414342045784, -0.0449349544942379, -0.04312913119792938, 0.025551464408636093, 0.007916322909295559, 0.02109123207628727, 0.05102409049868584, 0.056968849152326584, 0.025025757029652596, 0.06662039458751678, 0.038018688559532166, -0.002739911898970604, 0.030041679739952087, -0.026406647637486458, 0.016926992684602737, 0.019047753885388374, 0.018674097955226898, 0.018196117132902145, 0.033985018730163574, -0.022923167794942856, -0.00941462442278862, 0.0007165299612097442, -0.017203491181135178, -0.016763923689723015, -0.033175379037857056, -0.04205489903688431, 0.04693584889173508, -0.013891162350773811, -0.008478703908622265, -0.06261086463928223, 0.015901103615760803, 0.015035383403301239, 0.0045604282058775425, 0.008390768431127071, 0.03269529715180397, -0.01779736392199993, -0.02286614663898945, -0.0017559131374582648, -0.020552752539515495, -0.016649900004267693, -0.061274196952581406, 0.00760863721370697, 0.0065881237387657166, -0.007936050184071064, -0.014325438998639584, 0.030300553888082504, -0.009025055915117264, 0.040828630328178406, -0.042182616889476776, -0.015159881673753262, -0.001180228660814464, -0.018963899463415146, 0.006327210925519466, -0.06834453344345093, 0.03831323981285095, 0.012960347346961498, -0.04564159736037254, -0.06655669957399368, 0.004059013910591602, -0.026522507891058922, 0.0568222813308239, 0.09002866595983505, -0.014322205446660519, -0.005664036609232426, -0.012103889137506485, 0.03889377415180206, 0.013561256229877472, -0.018040811643004417, 0.04934854060411453, 0.015596851706504822, -0.009079414419829845, 0.01041388139128685, 0.014962497167289257, -0.02348753623664379, -0.0072929151356220245, 0.02013733610510826, -0.04109582304954529, 0.027122363448143005, 0.01363502349704504, -0.009687620215117931, 0.018073810264468193, -0.006300678942352533, -0.0671243742108345, 0.030019182711839676, -0.032937321811914444, -0.018783792853355408, 0.05124833062291145, 0.007061521057039499, -0.041952867060899734, 0.0040160613134503365, -0.017745014280080795, -0.008457989431917667, -0.0047773318365216255, 0.005172122735530138, 0.02691594325006008, -0.07216876745223999, 0.015922432765364647, -0.009237593971192837, -0.06420563906431198, -0.013488705269992352, 0.06513886898756027, 0.00888301245868206, 0.01957409642636776, -0.0000908920555957593, 0.030592981725931168, -0.00048074484220705926, 0.003637029556557536, 0.053856998682022095, 0.02385863848030567, 0.03469398245215416, 0.01387876458466053, -0.035651933401823044, 0.05159543827176094, -0.028581077232956886, 0.04203343391418457, 0.014525835402309895, 0.032532718032598495, -0.03144102171063423, 0.008839085698127747, 0.025689641013741493, -0.037683650851249695, 0.04018530249595642, -0.0029117281083017588, 0.0026661502197384834, 0.06961274892091751, -0.07021750509738922, 0.007013083901256323, -0.0025132487062364817, -0.009873171336948872, -0.039613064378499985, 0.020756911486387253, 0.0393795371055603, 0.03937658667564392, 0.029767611995339394, -0.00710364431142807, 0.0077281249687075615, -0.024059776216745377, 0.02007376402616501, -0.018941018730401993, 0.008441091515123844, 0.018774336203932762, -0.014924952760338783, -0.048902083188295364, -0.0075875758193433285, -0.03623066842556, -0.020130954682826996, 0.02641889825463295, -0.007288492750376463, 0.03144838660955429, -0.015605567954480648, -0.030039848759770393, 0.034645453095436096, 0.06344130635261536, -0.030967066064476967, -0.050922948867082596, -0.02057899907231331, 0.020240599289536476, -0.013373633846640587, -0.023133235052227974 ]
<p>Say I have the following model:</p> <p>$$\text{Poisson}(\lambda) \sim \begin{cases} \lambda_1 &amp; \text{if } t \lt \tau \\ \lambda_2 &amp; \text{if } t \geq \tau \end{cases} $$</p> <p>And I infer the posteriors for $\lambda_1$ and $\lambda_2$ shown below from my data. Is there a Bayesian way of telling (or quantifying) if $\lambda_1$ and $\lambda_2$ are the <strong>same or different</strong>? </p> <p>Perhaps measuring <strong>the probability that $\lambda_1$ is different from $\lambda_2$</strong>? Or perhaps using KL divergences? </p> <p>For example, how can I measure $p(\lambda_2 \neq \lambda_1)$, or at least, $p(\lambda_2 \gt \lambda_1)$?</p> <p>In general, once you have the posteriors shown below (assume <strong>non-zero</strong> PDF values everywhere for both), what is a good way of answering this question?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/jb5HU.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <h2>Update</h2> <p>It seems that this question can be answered in two ways:</p> <ol> <li><p>If we have samples of the posteriors, we could look at the fraction of the samples where $\lambda_1 \neq \lambda_2$ (or equivalently $\lambda_2 &gt; \lambda_1$). @Cam.Davidson.Pilon included an answer that would address this problem using such samples.</p></li> <li><p>Integrating some sort of difference of the posteriors. And that's an important part of my question. <strong>What would that integration look like?</strong> Presumably the sampling approach would approximate this integral, but I would like to know the formulation of this integral.</p></li> </ol> <p><strong>Note:</strong> The plots above come from <a href="http://nbviewer.ipython.org/github/CamDavidsonPilon/Probabilistic-Programming-and-Bayesian-Methods-for-Hackers/blob/master/Chapter1_Introduction/Chapter1_Introduction.ipynb" rel="nofollow">this material</a>.</p>
73,564
[ -0.008230268023908138, 0.0009950513485819101, 0.028547126799821854, -0.016338322311639786, 0.015341832302510738, 0.025793036445975304, 0.017533067613840103, -0.044119808822870255, 0.02874547615647316, -0.010702164843678474, 0.038334812968969345, 0.050107549875974655, 0.06633441150188446, 0.032173041254282, -0.00004425783845363185, 0.015743838623166084, -0.006853119935840368, 0.007887143641710281, -0.016154548153281212, 0.0013254794757813215, 0.00044290945515967906, 0.005176696926355362, -0.008124788291752338, 0.004207008983939886, -0.03899223357439041, 0.03438865393400192, 0.04293859377503395, -0.04099756479263306, -0.02116302400827408, 0.08658967912197113, -0.048133451491594315, -0.01042894460260868, 0.020214198157191277, 0.04569403827190399, -0.020090946927666664, 0.014735707081854343, -0.0395745187997818, -0.04153008386492729, -0.0007539851358160377, 0.05799752101302147, -0.045984137803316116, -0.008142446167767048, 0.009750296361744404, 0.036863312125205994, -0.026548277586698532, 0.01649177074432373, -0.013320805504918098, -0.06871403753757477, 0.05682879313826561, -0.018588727340102196, 0.013714880682528019, 0.008674155920743942, 0.031029637902975082, 0.07240641117095947, -0.00013326876796782017, -0.023777225986123085, 0.040594857186079025, 0.06876812130212784, 0.0024499516002833843, -0.0594024620950222, -0.027301302179694176, -0.019078627228736877, 0.0008025572751648724, -0.0010704996529966593, -0.0389874093234539, 0.023418297991156578, -0.006686474196612835, -0.03959124907851219, -0.011373011395335197, -0.033850353211164474, 0.01621115580201149, 0.014407970942556858, 0.017484841868281364, -0.001332246814854443, 0.011964143253862858, -0.02382076159119606, -0.02553875930607319, 0.07552973926067352, 0.04780176654458046, 0.030941935256123543, 0.015917768701910973, -0.0429648794233799, 0.04395055025815964, 0.053823959082365036, 0.022782275453209877, -0.030315503478050232, 0.07232224941253662, 0.0003980889159720391, -0.010339602828025818, -0.009303511120378971, -0.03961288928985596, 0.014795077033340931, 0.026306750252842903, -0.030470628291368484, -0.02610052563250065, 0.03955207020044327, -0.002766001969575882, 0.01991516724228859, -0.021655026823282242, -0.009250391274690628, -0.0266514141112566, -0.024581266567111015, 0.027199218049645424, 0.07729674130678177, -0.0032412928994745016, -0.018283376470208168, 0.0062441714107990265, -0.014925878494977951, -0.03833799064159393, -0.03922690078616142, -0.03935402259230614, 0.05712215602397919, 0.023277558386325836, -0.006545281037688255, -0.02373454160988331, -0.02634468860924244, 0.006043483503162861, -0.0370912030339241, 0.08082246780395508, 0.0768023356795311, 0.06597225368022919, -0.01791870780289173, 0.006849345751106739, -0.012701270170509815, -0.04171908274292946, -0.004279711749404669, 0.027038563042879105, -0.015373719856142998, -0.029132863506674767, 0.04678146541118622, -0.02088155969977379, -0.006787569727748632, 0.04129381850361824, 0.025219686329364777, 0.017439009621739388, 0.0009534544078633189, -0.03711486980319023, -0.033401940017938614, 0.04079923778772354, -0.0018060717266052961, -0.01623724028468132, -0.03824597969651222, -0.002206172328442335, 0.0540907196700573, 0.04062555730342865, 0.00350612192414701, 0.019193505868315697, 0.009582885541021824, -0.0013351861853152514, 0.0017354747978970408, -0.03753377124667168, -0.024725809693336487, -0.03678000718355179, 0.04229328781366348, -0.020798321813344955, -0.09071256965398788, -0.01766459085047245, 0.031240858137607574, -0.0042957826517522335, 0.0025104195810854435, 0.039628107100725174, 0.028806131333112717, -0.006304206792265177, -0.02788635529577732, 0.04903893545269966, -0.04478947073221207, 0.04839719086885452, 0.010302109643816948, 0.00989285483956337, -0.003034360008314252, -0.02035508118569851, 0.010831030085682869, -0.015389390289783478, -0.0037338172551244497, 0.037808630615472794, -0.017175419256091118, -0.011579178273677826, -0.00791506003588438, 0.005679873283952475, 0.0003824384184554219, -0.025486791506409645, -0.005328917410224676, -0.04951154813170433, -0.02067706175148487, 0.022310635074973106, 0.020542526617646217, 0.00848726648837328, -0.01673482358455658, 0.004418786149471998, -0.01826600544154644, -0.06643330305814743, -0.047130946069955826, -0.011661999858915806, 0.0062177665531635284, -0.03185277804732323, 0.06932072341442108, -0.012541130185127258, -0.007044737692922354, -0.02102084457874298, -0.001362251932732761, -0.02691160887479782, -0.015870152041316032, 0.02465665526688099, -0.013189420104026794, 0.019105535000562668, 0.04429226741194725, 0.06761843711137772, -0.00974200014024973, 0.056968603283166885, -0.03156610205769539, -0.04505590349435806, -0.013381881639361382, -0.04235096275806427, 0.005866535007953644, -0.026457447558641434, 0.007553979754447937, 0.007655781228095293, -0.010806366801261902, -0.009895495139062405, 0.008744467049837112, -0.06239856034517288, 0.048731084913015366, 0.06431091576814651, -0.007647015154361725, -0.008473576977849007, 0.026701875030994415, -0.010597741231322289, 0.03996364399790764, 0.00657659862190485, -0.019083727151155472, -0.039123643189668655, -0.024948908016085625, 0.052722182124853134, 0.03610238432884216, -0.027211688458919525, 0.00831756740808487, 0.027987778186798096, -0.002825898351147771, 0.004635902587324381, 0.026294125244021416, 0.004492244217544794, -0.044011812657117844, 0.034374259412288666, -0.007504519075155258, 0.0026902207173407078, 0.007629232946783304, 0.04635133594274521, -0.023181505501270294, 0.046844277530908585, -0.0195325780659914, -0.017101269215345383, 0.049548082053661346, 0.011713040061295033, 0.029803253710269928, -0.03475818783044815, -0.01448759064078331, 0.038763150572776794, 0.034966833889484406, -0.00301889656111598, 0.044758837670087814, 0.024436507374048233, 0.0063089048489928246, -0.007607836741954088, -0.006732809357345104, 0.025584310293197632, 0.04801539331674576, -0.03309579938650131, 0.022734854370355606, 0.019689686596393585, -0.02681247517466545, 0.03718620166182518, -0.015174537897109985, -0.04044310003519058, -0.020829293876886368, 0.010110241360962391, 0.032713115215301514, -0.006427038926631212, -0.02128203772008419, -0.040946003049612045, -0.048060692846775055, 0.01971680484712124, 0.019389024004340172, -0.017521850764751434, 0.01753835752606392, -0.06006557494401932, 0.013077594339847565, -0.004659915808588266, 0.002142887795343995, 0.0013207627926021814, 0.018324611708521843, -0.01719934679567814, 0.028950190171599388, -0.007017333060503006, -0.07624921947717667, -0.027397001162171364, -0.019315848127007484, 0.0011019579833373427, -0.028555868193507195, -0.021466609090566635, 0.02200615406036377, 0.051799871027469635, -0.04070502519607544, 0.014438283629715443, -0.019488336518406868, -0.04965991899371147, -0.00998908095061779, 0.011812698096036911, 0.04478131979703903, 0.006491971667855978, 0.023311788216233253, 0.037194568663835526, -0.0008119351114146411, -0.02408617176115513, -0.0855662077665329, -0.028260163962841034, 0.02322576381266117, -0.004880592226982117, 0.03840293735265732, -0.02110377885401249, -0.01601286232471466, 0.07330452650785446, 0.02344171330332756, -0.0013452814891934395, -0.0055257538333535194, 0.00656988425180316, -0.03472299128770828, -0.01475386880338192, 0.0004547438002191484, -0.029708901420235634, -0.018182916566729546, 0.039827633649110794, -0.0005131592624820769, 0.05108578875660896, 0.02725120633840561, 0.009062419645488262, 0.017906758934259415, 0.05299381911754608, 0.01807801052927971, -0.005925046745687723, 0.020685046911239624, 0.015486097894608974, -0.05191250517964363, 0.02294871211051941, -0.010180121287703514, 0.004403311759233475, 0.023854533210396767, -0.04311971366405487, 0.02268785610795021, 0.019861001521348953, -0.024937819689512253, -0.03670759126543999, 0.058945994824171066, 0.033770930022001266, -0.05293453112244606, -0.011533906683325768, 0.022530928254127502, 0.031740911304950714, -0.011753646656870842, 0.007418678607791662, 0.06564602255821228, 0.04793120548129082, 0.0068315183743834496, -0.026572035625576973, -0.01604207418859005, 0.0050518810749053955, 0.0012194931041449308, -0.036041684448719025, -0.011097133159637451, 0.0265697930008173, 0.050295617431402206, 0.00850980170071125, -0.027376482263207436, -0.003440486965700984, -0.0213090181350708, -0.035393450409173965, -0.0034472562838345766, -0.007884613238275051, 0.05644672363996506, -0.0002727073442656547, 0.04634683579206467, 0.030410457402467728, 0.027597276493906975, 0.0005184761248528957, 0.001822908641770482, -0.06985698640346527, 0.030854960903525352, 0.009467454627156258, -0.022055083885788918, -0.0025671934708952904, -0.0163725595921278, 0.046231575310230255, -0.055820293724536896, 0.007583474740386009, -0.03968704864382744, 0.019338000565767288, -0.04199730604887009, 0.014620896428823471, -0.04798145592212677, -0.007806750014424324, -0.006128370296210051, 0.021944839507341385, 0.005651791114360094, 0.0063772196881473064, 0.02568987011909485, 0.032593801617622375, 0.007404791656881571, 0.01297225896269083, -0.038751792162656784, 0.018228605389595032, -0.016636652871966362, 0.047822341322898865, 0.028224634006619453, 0.052325982600450516, -0.016748709604144096, 0.03691153973340988, 0.04367182403802872, 0.06999196112155914, 0.046401459723711014, -0.012058187276124954, 0.01740262098610401, -0.029755130410194397, -0.03153746575117111, -0.028167981654405594, 0.057209424674510956, -0.03837362676858902, -0.05042971298098564, 0.037639930844306946, 0.04124640300869942, -0.0037761693820357323, 0.001750116003677249, 0.01482054591178894, 0.017201241105794907, 0.00031831071828491986, -0.0372312068939209, -0.02481228858232498, -0.014463528990745544, 0.007375976536422968, 0.015230848453938961, -0.011475419625639915, 0.019200151786208153, 0.004501765593886375, 0.02111334539949894, -0.02089853212237358, -0.04294472932815552, -0.01777854561805725, -0.00988570787012577, -0.001846910105086863, 0.01446902472525835, -0.035157062113285065, 0.022469215095043182, 0.033004552125930786, 0.05614519491791725, 0.013670514337718487, 0.01805906556546688, -0.06870752573013306, -0.05968831479549408, 0.0193013958632946, 0.023000212386250496, -0.024011706933379173, 0.0004262649454176426, -0.06028639152646065, -0.035601258277893066, 0.0479535348713398, -0.00005118148328620009, 0.0001615742949070409, 0.005430737975984812, 0.015276440419256687, 0.0042373924516141415, -0.012203570455312729, -0.03514959663152695, 0.017677275463938713, -0.007948105223476887, -0.006579724606126547, -0.03875328227877617, 0.015194874256849289, -0.005959497299045324, 0.031406402587890625, -0.0007736351690255105, 0.05139238014817238, -0.028806746006011963, -0.02121613174676895, -0.0065502990037202835, -0.00002713090907491278, -0.010929717682301998, -0.07135530561208725, 0.04102620109915733, 0.01053539663553238, -0.01297545526176691, 0.030284373089671135, -0.045993734151124954, -0.04526061192154884, 0.0361655168235302, -0.000563989335205406, -0.008605892769992352, 0.038637083023786545, -0.029739635065197945, 0.04601365327835083, 0.013357515446841717, 0.022839291021227837, 0.047638144344091415, 0.034940455108881, 0.0330946110188961, 0.005927609745413065, -0.01787055842578411, 0.0029241670854389668, -0.03922087326645851, -0.013994358479976654, -0.08128219097852707, 0.004322326276451349, -0.028503401204943657, 0.042421769350767136, 0.001081775757484138, 0.0487532839179039, 0.02072186768054962, -0.045057713985443115, 0.024393504485487938, 0.016038373112678528, 0.04072093218564987, -0.004922841209918261, -0.04015038534998894, -0.005730785895138979, -0.01938542164862156, 0.017215309664607048, -0.0021114195697009563, -0.04145609959959984, 0.0038292284589260817, -0.028863131999969482, -0.037444889545440674, 0.036881592124700546, -0.03238889202475548, 0.018927525728940964, 0.029568590223789215, -0.003701220266520977, 0.036443840712308884, 0.022780517116189003, 0.04134718328714371, -0.011116426438093185, -0.022572727873921394, -0.00010031549027189612, 0.030802935361862183, 0.016977567225694656, 0.031812071800231934, -0.004423676989972591, 0.04380163550376892, -0.012858452275395393, -0.018502715975046158, -0.050478581339120865, 0.011940904892981052, 0.0011447619181126356, -0.003108541015535593, -0.02574828267097473, -0.04028310999274254, 0.005277459509670734, 0.023481231182813644, -0.023062925785779953, -0.005974650848656893, 0.06663752347230911, 0.0007349596126005054, -0.0066421483643352985, -0.005993055645376444, 0.0253439974039793, 0.07139717042446136, 0.007709843572229147, 0.0079770153388381, 0.006118061952292919, -0.02393834851682186, -0.018378188833594322, 0.0016623843694105744, 0.019576894119381905, -0.017346981912851334, -0.017453104257583618, -0.028034958988428116, 0.02074114978313446, 0.022572407498955727, -0.008884953334927559, -0.029749931767582893, 0.014238577336072922, -0.006042802706360817, 0.0038536174688488245, -0.02944347821176052, -0.02638104185461998, 0.01023436151444912, 0.02945462241768837, -0.04510720819234848, 0.0008819829672574997, 0.02535995841026306, -0.02764112316071987, 0.04950839653611183, -0.023792454972863197, -0.00889868289232254, -0.0030290435533970594, 0.046368446201086044, -0.017824828624725342, 0.019388781860470772, 0.0073894355446100235, 0.017297444865107536, 0.053589943796396255, -0.009795917198061943, 0.007072830107063055, 0.05545965954661369, 0.0200102087110281, -0.030659601092338562, -0.007797089871019125, -0.075169138610363, -0.019498620182275772, 0.08050020784139633, -0.002146168379113078, 0.053093135356903076, 0.021553684026002884, -0.007654970977455378, 0.01623782515525818, -0.03156469017267227, 0.005172847304493189, -0.02575376257300377, -0.015887556597590446, 0.03121177665889263, -0.05157509073615074, -0.007057565730065107, 0.0671466737985611, 0.008697576820850372, 0.024160310626029968, 0.030246024951338768, -0.024929365143179893, 0.04390684887766838, 0.0430416502058506, -0.03502446413040161, -0.03577413409948349, 0.03262724354863167, -0.05857270583510399, -0.004949840251356363, -0.029917964711785316, -0.03381635993719101, 0.06936218589544296, 0.04823620989918709, 0.02158237248659134, -0.048854436725378036, -0.015819277614355087, -0.07013620436191559, 0.017978021875023842, 0.023195039480924606, 0.015588952228426933, 0.007346677593886852, -0.016314804553985596, 0.044856779277324677, -0.03724713250994682, 0.009430521167814732, -0.046439677476882935, -0.08286852389574051, -0.021452423185110092, -0.010479853488504887, -0.0013254001969471574, 0.016144325956702232, -0.01350340060889721, -0.024710291996598244, 0.03234517201781273, -0.03372197225689888, 0.004095572978258133, 0.008734324015676975, 0.01146248821169138, -0.06152641400694847, 0.047918252646923065, -0.04360474646091461, 0.06023359298706055, -0.05596732348203659, -0.0012539576273411512, 0.1212928518652916, 0.06597874313592911, 0.013169925659894943, -0.04667488858103752, 0.018346497789025307, 0.032300494611263275, 0.005979614332318306, -0.048561278730630875, 0.007636201102286577, 0.04332461208105087, -0.05478176474571228, 0.009244127199053764, 0.07484292984008789, 0.0013907995307818055, -0.024288514629006386, 0.03929280862212181, -0.03006342239677906, -0.0018490551738068461, 0.003486988600343466, 0.01669115200638771, -0.014936300925910473, -0.021557478234171867, -0.020054388791322708, 0.0201251357793808, 0.001162989647127688, 0.019575847312808037, -0.02561432681977749, -0.016965841874480247, -0.03236164152622223, -0.01613137125968933, -0.006971842609345913, -0.011836150661110878, 0.03329762443900108, -0.0034504125360399485, 0.020278101786971092, -0.019963815808296204, 0.010742327198386192, -0.03818730264902115, 0.027103615924715996, 0.05539857968688011, 0.014862515963613987, -0.006488614249974489, 0.0017655990086495876, 0.034393537789583206, -0.026268338784575462, -0.03917107358574867, -0.04063917323946953, 0.03500789776444435, 0.007006495259702206, 0.014381573535501957, -0.026043476536870003, -0.0023622072767466307, 0.006796637084335089, -0.006834524683654308, -0.008219310082495213, 0.022531475871801376, 0.01396765187382698, 0.0017645345069468021, -0.013396225869655609, -0.024524038657546043, 0.03238271176815033, 0.005255397874861956, 0.03854252025485039, -0.005988460965454578, -0.04426177591085434, -0.07391873002052307, 0.012115483172237873, 0.03136010468006134, 0.020384345203638077, 0.01890542358160019, -0.00610846932977438, -0.020021433010697365, -0.006711452268064022, 0.01778852567076683, -0.019734878093004227, -0.011462933383882046, 0.03141077235341072, 0.004127115476876497, -0.023643694818019867, -0.014464189298450947, -0.05954982712864876, 0.016032367944717407, -0.016740357503294945, 0.04868752509355545, -0.008778522722423077, 0.0038271562661975622, 0.024684809148311615, 0.022553155198693275, 0.041218649595975876, -0.0032647482585161924, 0.02754177898168564, 0.07564816623926163, 0.01957894116640091, -0.025524146854877472, -0.04411856457591057, -0.0025485733058303595, -0.032482512295246124, -0.01825648359954357, -0.03713937848806381, 0.043443601578474045, -0.0034880281891673803, 0.03954967111349106, 0.00797986052930355, -0.028436120599508286, -0.031224986538290977, 0.02227831445634365, -0.00041708649951033294, -0.060185957700014114, -0.041509438306093216, 0.01829681545495987, 0.013442541472613811, -0.0006568804383277893, 0.01278347335755825, -0.008057249709963799, -0.017322415485978127, 0.023702140897512436, -0.01846548169851303, -0.04724466800689697, 0.0024753285106271505, 0.0007277079857885838, -0.008466470055282116, -0.02367742918431759, -0.01660969853401184, -0.000879168976098299, -0.016979996114969254, -0.019480472430586815, 0.022299135103821754, 0.0012079128064215183, 0.0357356071472168, -0.0029108847957104445, -0.025642042979598045, 0.036094747483730316, -0.026583662256598473, 0.02811046503484249, -0.0000847972696647048, 0.004692687653005123, 0.0011340378550812602, 0.009253579191863537, 0.0058345007710158825, -0.034233275800943375, 0.0656762570142746, -0.016181234270334244, -0.028171980753540993, 0.030573038384318352, 0.012935386039316654, 0.030609387904405594, 0.02365235425531864, -0.020651867613196373, -0.038359057158231735, 0.009737839922308922, -0.0374583899974823, -0.01717989705502987, -0.00022475933656096458, -0.001942819100804627, -0.019532660022377968, -0.03303749859333038, 0.008853446692228317, 0.03175806626677513, 0.02121300995349884, 0.00408221036195755, 0.006442585028707981, -0.022637654095888138, -0.03192584589123726, -0.004813981242477894, -0.036869462579488754, 0.024223193526268005, -0.016757093369960785, 0.01946651190519333, 0.02770131453871727, 0.043353524059057236, -0.012588960118591785, 0.019153770059347153, -0.015591030940413475, -0.0071318624541163445, -0.10132281482219696, 0.00985621940344572, 0.03202590346336365, 0.01057046465575695, 0.025061307474970818, -0.037139520049095154, 0.015699807554483414, 0.03529411926865578, -0.026949457824230194, 0.022974127903580666, 0.010408904403448105, 0.03959205374121666, -0.06104619801044464, 0.007938103750348091, -0.04901488870382309, 0.030369317159056664, -0.003526035463437438, 0.012268739752471447, 0.03898797556757927, 0.06953954696655273, 0.029698703438043594, 0.008541070856153965, -0.022154081612825394, -0.005036435555666685, 0.000909383874386549, -0.04869233816862106, 0.02362433262169361, -0.026690427213907242, -0.028320446610450745, 0.026275740936398506, 0.014948154799640179, 0.00015873086522333324, -0.032549843192100525, 0.020781442523002625, 0.02780410833656788, 0.004017611965537071, 0.020135939121246338, 0.022150028496980667, -0.0004197738890070468, -0.018113352358341217, -0.005918500479310751, 0.0004938465426675975, -0.03276962414383888, -0.005051883403211832, 0.05509427189826965, -0.04387315362691879, -0.014047976583242416, 0.024390125647187233, 0.006904627662152052, -0.0225070808082819, 0.023434853181242943, 0.0062172189354896545, 0.0030838456004858017, -0.0009628763073123991, 0.014513985253870487, -0.07018116116523743, 0.016484256833791733, 0.04815535992383957, 0.03194321691989899, -0.036813974380493164, 0.006145095452666283, -0.04248388111591339, -0.04440953955054283, 0.026505764573812485, 0.009338516741991043, -0.02791539579629898, -0.08692045509815216, -0.02806943468749523, -0.02324129454791546, 0.013404542580246925, -0.037398889660835266, -0.008951062336564064, -0.0660477951169014, 0.016440054401755333, -0.04989437758922577, 0.01469036191701889, -0.02866194024682045, 0.021240949630737305, 0.013637908734381199, -0.08526566624641418, 0.034597452729940414, -0.025844570249319077, -0.03395102173089981, -0.020858408883213997, -0.025744542479515076, -0.040622882544994354, 0.037439968436956406, 0.053454093635082245, 0.043796613812446594, 0.003382990136742592, 0.025983251631259918, 0.010703331790864468, 0.024256639182567596, -0.053031791001558304, 0.021485475823283195, -0.026596909388899803, -0.00402693310752511, 0.0016352224629372358, -0.009963469579815865, 0.0405953973531723, 0.05267401412129402, 0.05117941275238991, -0.0334966666996479, 0.0033410305622965097, -0.006402364932000637, -0.002704474376514554, 0.006882807239890099, -0.004212992265820503, -0.0006702945684082806, 0.03648225963115692, -0.01815529353916645, 0.01462126336991787, -0.0092331413179636, -0.005275284871459007, -0.07833083719015121, 0.019952962175011635, -0.022224141284823418, -0.07771025598049164, 0.014220384880900383, 0.012963034212589264, 0.0010414054850116372, -0.05798528715968132, -0.02537531964480877, 0.010052746161818504, -0.058438077569007874, 0.033184561878442764, 0.02726835198700428, 0.037358358502388, 0.05538753420114517, 0.01378311961889267, 0.04193701222538948, 0.02091970667243004, -0.00848324690014124, 0.0037326563615351915, 0.004410898312926292, 0.04647717997431755, -0.014710444957017899, 0.012476401403546333, 0.004050474613904953, -0.003010490443557501, 0.03308948129415512, -0.03368135541677475, 0.03034883365035057, -0.02994757890701294, -0.016929998993873596, 0.023127077147364616, -0.006895556580275297, 0.002029664348810911, -0.0028139993082731962, 0.0218200720846653, 0.0652795061469078, -0.03492065519094467, -0.018544934689998627, -0.004369435366243124, 0.019573045894503593, -0.02779977209866047, 0.020237619057297707, 0.040512192994356155, 0.02570917271077633, 0.028684386983513832, -0.0017707161605358124, -0.012278638780117035, -0.03884308785200119, -0.009551557712256908, -0.030816854909062386, 0.026644619181752205, 0.03220197185873985, -0.035676222294569016, -0.017600009217858315, -0.02906131185591221, -0.02612709440290928, -0.023005155846476555, 0.018675005063414574, -0.0005716858431696892, 0.05296020582318306, -0.02644764445722103, -0.05710189789533615, -0.004890097305178642, 0.0005770878633484244, -0.05625699833035469, -0.007821686565876007, -0.028255783021450043, -0.005757785867899656, 0.021365826949477196, -0.058613162487745285 ]
<p>from what you have read or heard about, which is a good book on fuzzy logic/sets/systems? I'm interested in basic of fuzzy systems, fuzzification/defuzzification etc.</p> <p>Thanks, Lucian</p>
47,395
[ -0.01524719875305891, -0.06017417460680008, 0.027531245723366737, 0.012359335087239742, 0.03706376999616623, 0.0345950722694397, 0.002106043277308345, -0.03157496079802513, 0.02042507380247116, -0.013718916103243828, 0.009009570814669132, 0.06944437325000763, 0.03665793314576149, 0.014369064942002296, -0.000936701602768153, -0.034833937883377075, -0.006266911048442125, -0.017403796315193176, -0.04384530335664749, 0.0032937030773609877, 0.0008835378685034811, 0.01099539827555418, 0.02440519630908966, 0.010570390149950981, -0.03046453185379505, 0.023529959842562675, 0.017125297337770462, 0.022357644513249397, 0.037606898695230484, 0.05794849619269371, -0.040246132761240005, -0.024284347891807556, -0.04109116643667221, 0.004589482210576534, 0.010989424772560596, -0.026613591238856316, -0.0011313409777358174, -0.02488809823989868, -0.022134188562631607, -0.021823855116963387, -0.032374974340200424, -0.05487840250134468, 0.02207462675869465, 0.0415472686290741, -0.023354193195700645, 0.002324650762602687, -0.043089162558317184, -0.028647921979427338, 0.0012335204519331455, -0.08499175310134888, 0.04950178787112236, 0.0048218416050076485, 0.03791660815477371, 0.06487903743982315, 0.06521882861852646, 0.028047939762473106, 0.05404292419552803, 0.06823763251304626, -0.034659046679735184, -0.04982952028512955, -0.017899582162499428, -0.05730464681982994, 0.007512899115681648, -0.03356722369790077, -0.053180351853370667, 0.038687434047460556, -0.04687218368053436, -0.040251970291137695, 0.03914939612150192, 0.021465059369802475, -0.012366042472422123, 0.030707059428095818, 0.012916087172925472, -0.028511356562376022, -0.0063013434410095215, -0.030839312821626663, 0.007332459092140198, 0.014049788005650043, 0.034545451402664185, 0.033429067581892014, 0.03247770294547081, 0.04510216787457466, -0.013814234174787998, 0.024298658594489098, 0.01351085864007473, -0.04095369204878807, 0.10283531248569489, 0.0070486715994775295, -0.029276253655552864, -0.012139067985117435, -0.030842028558254242, -0.011073991656303406, 0.004721281584352255, -0.011868701316416264, -0.013352468609809875, 0.054507385939359665, 0.015908528119325638, 0.05405394732952118, -0.010775238275527954, -0.021992379799485207, 0.027825582772493362, -0.024520505219697952, 0.02585780620574951, 0.035505544394254684, -0.025040317326784134, -0.0361107774078846, -0.002594711259007454, 0.00511308154091239, -0.01338464580476284, -0.023652490228414536, 0.0211483146995306, 0.03172994777560234, -0.005528421141207218, 0.013057079166173935, 0.02062739059329033, -0.0070461705327034, 0.029141006991267204, -0.007552755996584892, 0.026987193152308464, 0.05896180123090744, 0.05470089241862297, -0.05267038196325302, 0.03513079136610031, -0.006568734534084797, -0.05969816446304321, 0.04125993326306343, 0.027823613956570625, -0.020021729171276093, -0.01889866217970848, 0.04109061509370804, -0.01130874827504158, -0.017615756019949913, 0.02096499688923359, 0.000027154048439115286, 0.03615981340408325, 0.035148460417985916, -0.07385415583848953, -0.03958462178707123, 0.04059650003910065, -0.0592326782643795, 0.007174049038439989, -0.04840812832117081, 0.025903571397066116, 0.043834131211042404, 0.048208121210336685, 0.03476648032665253, 0.004557786043733358, 0.0060595739632844925, 0.011555585078895092, -0.016412533819675446, -0.028740394860506058, -0.042468439787626266, 0.02355952560901642, -0.018232963979244232, 0.03361494466662407, -0.04444647207856178, 0.045500002801418304, 0.021553214639425278, -0.0020471573807299137, -0.05035727843642235, 0.05606218799948692, 0.02461995929479599, -0.007186820264905691, 0.006745006889104843, 0.0011099301045760512, 0.011261479929089546, 0.07083509862422943, -0.027073390781879425, 0.020463256165385246, 0.04815720394253731, -0.004892892669886351, 0.014186185784637928, 0.0161130353808403, 0.04451598599553108, 0.05247253179550171, -0.016398146748542786, -0.034500252455472946, -0.029723376035690308, -0.006393085699528456, 0.016946185380220413, -0.01022256538271904, -0.01898922026157379, 0.013361006043851376, 0.01079770177602768, 0.002558229025453329, 0.020834144204854965, -0.005779867526143789, -0.027269290760159492, 0.05166669189929962, -0.04550924152135849, -0.030019711703062057, -0.061252411454916, 0.016587501391768456, -0.022624123841524124, -0.02470880001783371, 0.053486648947000504, 0.0010524532990530133, 0.012269208207726479, -0.05921285226941109, -0.041371703147888184, -0.031309355050325394, -0.0013256832025945187, 0.0036367469001561403, -0.026137109845876694, 0.0377347432076931, 0.08044605702161789, 0.014387596398591995, -0.042608585208654404, 0.00734179001301527, -0.03938135504722595, -0.08441220968961716, -0.008571662940084934, -0.01361743826419115, 0.021708952262997627, -0.05409017950296402, -0.009152865968644619, 0.010896727442741394, 0.004940907005220652, -0.022673390805721283, 0.001770386821590364, -0.03608938679099083, 0.03372889384627342, 0.04148564487695694, 0.013336499221622944, 0.024080462753772736, 0.02240733429789543, -0.001698690582998097, -0.0012280539376661181, 0.018136145547032356, -0.022401459515094757, -0.030906084924936295, 0.025817522779107094, 0.0277994517236948, 0.03335270658135414, -0.006320844404399395, 0.007569626439362764, 0.017164887860417366, 0.020658642053604126, 0.02772757038474083, 0.02392687276005745, -0.027865979820489883, -0.02177744172513485, -0.01053768489509821, 0.007940903306007385, 0.005797820631414652, 0.028240621089935303, -0.016661476343870163, 0.050746507942676544, -0.0003311848849989474, -0.021443817764520645, -0.029197610914707184, 0.05965820699930191, -0.00995468720793724, 0.0056344387121498585, 0.010689640417695045, -0.04407352954149246, 0.005307644605636597, -0.023044735193252563, -0.020029282197356224, -0.022366466000676155, -0.020934872329235077, 0.020998738706111908, -0.002505771815776825, -0.0268408115953207, -0.002921692095696926, 0.017282206565141678, -0.027803631499409676, -0.0002949470654129982, 0.04071380943059921, -0.03578722104430199, -0.0018512704409658909, 0.006019535008817911, 0.013147792778909206, -0.04416545107960701, -0.029257789254188538, 0.014728494919836521, 0.0006209288258105516, 0.017723727971315384, 0.016132913529872894, -0.005390295293182135, -0.011997044086456299, -0.04382077604532242, 0.03381207957863808, -0.0116023700684309, -0.043439485132694244, -0.001245664432644844, -0.005136606749147177, -0.030258312821388245, 0.050798967480659485, -0.004816390573978424, 0.00827784277498722, 0.007627865299582481, 0.022466490045189857, -0.06567776948213577, -0.00808106828480959, -0.030867302790284157, -0.0014511117478832603, 0.025000590831041336, -0.030453216284513474, 0.004521623719483614, -0.01969265379011631, -0.042033564299345016, 0.01155811082571745, -0.056478433310985565, -0.0299356859177351, -0.03486057370901108, 0.022967008873820305, 0.024691466242074966, -0.032590169459581375, -0.023060834035277367, 0.041493650525808334, -0.04407685622572899, -0.0035105394199490547, -0.029304051771759987, -0.05559840798377991, 0.014880011789500713, 0.03154727816581726, 0.048805683851242065, 0.005693419836461544, -0.03854630887508392, 0.059494078159332275, 0.011861545033752918, -0.040937695652246475, 0.004393099341541529, -0.004823093302547932, -0.002798564499244094, -0.018542995676398277, -0.006205383222550154, 0.008273511193692684, 0.006074925884604454, 0.029486708343029022, 0.018157638609409332, 0.01207447238266468, 0.056123558431863785, 0.06168774515390396, -0.000004838373570237309, 0.013286195695400238, -0.004731438122689724, -0.010822247713804245, 0.0214827973395586, 0.030939998105168343, -0.03717966377735138, 0.017235897481441498, 0.0099837277084589, 0.03364074230194092, 0.023054245859384537, -0.0045294007286429405, 0.05025387555360794, -0.01605307124555111, 0.0017765036318451166, -0.003666598116979003, 0.03438498452305794, -0.014753571711480618, -0.0207197405397892, 0.014712806791067123, 0.03299962729215622, 0.014033976942300797, -0.03535595163702965, 0.015111862681806087, 0.0801105871796608, -0.00006613264849875122, -0.04388437420129776, -0.022995376959443092, -0.004216988570988178, -0.030753476545214653, 0.02308051660656929, -0.03794608265161514, 0.014935851097106934, 0.053044334053993225, 0.047475699335336685, 0.019150422886013985, 0.012609386816620827, -0.031033344566822052, 0.0022604812402278185, -0.07218261808156967, -0.01918034814298153, -0.0005554801900871098, 0.06956511735916138, 0.0037099700421094894, 0.02720756083726883, -0.005010591354221106, 0.012950635515153408, -0.002608570270240307, 0.00917509850114584, -0.06997822225093842, 0.03678872808814049, -0.04487559571862221, 0.022464193403720856, -0.021227823570370674, 0.03192923218011856, 0.018560752272605896, 0.01964590884745121, -0.027564652264118195, -0.053859926760196686, -0.0007724741008132696, -0.05008159205317497, -0.0036772913299500942, -0.04291587695479393, -0.015614364296197891, -0.007183431647717953, 0.022152051329612732, -0.007024860009551048, -0.05308108031749725, 0.029164815321564674, 0.0048878681845963, -0.021749330684542656, -0.018500160425901413, -0.002468878636136651, 0.019691426306962967, 0.03650467097759247, 0.008307999931275845, 0.017537200823426247, 0.04546310752630234, -0.04077516496181488, 0.02093689888715744, 0.026058033108711243, 0.05948382988572121, -0.002139164600521326, -0.034643448889255524, -0.04266280308365822, -0.04255644977092743, -0.03676465153694153, -0.007089592050760984, 0.0421421080827713, 0.0054368372075259686, 0.031274136155843735, 0.04756760597229004, -0.012481492944061756, -0.069101482629776, 0.0418068952858448, 0.04553753137588501, -0.006429823115468025, -0.04385852813720703, 0.018797380849719048, -0.01278811227530241, -0.04121316596865654, -0.008514819666743279, 0.04030586779117584, 0.03426473215222359, -0.014966803602874279, -0.018626069650053978, 0.03153112158179283, 0.0006303144618868828, -0.026241522282361984, -0.015230907127261162, 0.03737572580575943, -0.009617768228054047, 0.004748207982629538, -0.02892131730914116, 0.007474142592400312, 0.031956642866134644, 0.052486613392829895, 0.03981960564851761, -0.018520934507250786, -0.03573278710246086, 0.02436056360602379, 0.06258610635995865, 0.044442709535360336, -0.045311227440834045, 0.01832561381161213, -0.06549306213855743, -0.07761028409004211, 0.07822401821613312, -0.05102695897221565, 0.0331432968378067, -0.05119926482439041, -0.024267101660370827, -0.04512951150536537, 0.011139214038848877, 0.013836939819157124, -0.0044082957319915295, 0.02945731021463871, 0.03986288234591484, 0.010662681423127651, 0.017331479117274284, -0.0610019713640213, 0.013482816517353058, 0.031371768563985825, 0.03296990692615509, 0.030278757214546204, 0.005754135083407164, -0.0017714016139507294, 0.052231550216674805, -0.031906139105558395, -0.03770062327384949, 0.007382035255432129, 0.014105174690485, -0.009900986216962337, 0.015683762729167938, -0.011456167325377464, -0.02789861336350441, -0.0075991274788975716, -0.03286264091730118, -0.027259552851319313, -0.025592248886823654, -0.025924349203705788, 0.011328248307108879, 0.010978582315146923, 0.021912600845098495, 0.05023643374443054, -0.006174478679895401, -0.04495604708790779, 0.020219149067997932, -0.021392250433564186, 0.008371289819478989, -0.0695032849907875, -0.03156082704663277, -0.03015086241066456, -0.013029352761805058, -0.044007375836372375, 0.04632144421339035, -0.007101995870471001, 0.0026496245991438627, -0.03223653510212898, -0.005801746621727943, -0.021005943417549133, 0.02448168396949768, 0.016862107440829277, 0.02860167808830738, 0.008835434913635254, 0.00902273878455162, 0.006289180833846331, -0.009575223550200462, 0.0012886186596006155, -0.01494173426181078, 0.008038935251533985, -0.006672845687717199, -0.033616382628679276, 0.03723956272006035, -0.04711022228002548, -0.017542794346809387, 0.0003996356390416622, -0.006028384901583195, 0.07987607270479202, 0.01578586921095848, 0.004194941371679306, 0.017053833231329918, -0.06605225056409836, -0.039429690688848495, 0.030814314261078835, 0.028819099068641663, 0.005734072532504797, -0.055502597242593765, 0.02717636711895466, -0.01607559062540531, 0.008514844812452793, -0.03931722417473793, -0.07571911811828613, 0.003618997521698475, -0.026749201118946075, -0.03543725982308388, -0.05140472203493118, 0.0666564330458641, -0.009830121882259846, -0.029981456696987152, -0.037926990538835526, 0.05723320320248604, -0.0065595172345638275, -0.006743928417563438, 0.02209952287375927, -0.02630082704126835, 0.03518862649798393, 0.056244004517793655, 0.005116978660225868, 0.006978993304073811, 0.003466798225417733, -0.006032672245055437, -0.007137152832001448, 0.017213493585586548, -0.0162658728659153, 0.014756464399397373, -0.013525275513529778, 0.007428001146763563, 0.02465835213661194, -0.004494599532335997, 0.04027508944272995, 0.01334275770932436, 0.031027698889374733, -0.04112503305077553, 0.0019314975943416357, 0.017763551324605942, -0.024537913501262665, 0.013139932416379452, 0.011746814474463463, -0.006432761438190937, -0.008277100510895252, -0.002577068516984582, 0.018353119492530823, 0.010086105205118656, 0.008571619167923927, 0.017948465421795845, 0.030647195875644684, 0.007040923461318016, 0.005913678556680679, 0.02095804177224636, -0.02065868116915226, 0.021006569266319275, -0.02232660911977291, 0.007899435237050056, 0.01003363449126482, 0.018154602497816086, 0.005868614185601473, -0.0170521792024374, 0.004111547954380512, 0.01276550441980362, 0.04022178053855896, -0.01609354466199875, 0.045567836612463, 0.06649850308895111, 0.019083164632320404, -0.014266539365053177, -0.013014434836804867, -0.043137144297361374, 0.0137739647179842, 0.01470025535672903, 0.041183292865753174, -0.02890213578939438, 0.04328107088804245, 0.004520036280155182, 0.03556796535849571, 0.027891160920262337, -0.0036917950492352247, 0.01329199131578207, 0.057719290256500244, 0.0026959567330777645, -0.04424886405467987, -0.0686926618218422, 0.04879629239439964, -0.0431474894285202, 0.008259590715169907, 0.021235505118966103, -0.031683389097452164, 0.045470841228961945, 0.01043595653027296, 0.023268122225999832, -0.005387620534747839, 0.008170309476554394, -0.022355535998940468, 0.013875306583940983, -0.000856610422488302, 0.02110154740512371, -0.014616585336625576, 0.009026175364851952, 0.012031902559101582, -0.018598726019263268, 0.03293615207076073, -0.020707618445158005, -0.07314697653055191, -0.028304051607847214, -0.0032061913516372442, -0.03674166277050972, 0.01802801713347435, 0.007505130022764206, -0.037893619388341904, 0.005682187620550394, -0.035284943878650665, 0.03127551078796387, 0.017590101808309555, 0.014464284293353558, -0.0027407719753682613, 0.05043577775359154, -0.04270255193114281, 0.015188015066087246, 0.02547577954828739, -0.013227881863713264, 0.11081048846244812, 0.0338478647172451, -0.0028906678780913353, -0.0944405347108841, 0.04213623329997063, -0.02545931749045849, 0.022070936858654022, -0.01941674016416073, 0.03765100985765457, 0.022570351138710976, 0.02750745788216591, 0.03786686435341835, 0.04905277490615845, 0.02429136261343956, -0.019304687157273293, 0.08227657526731491, -0.028444603085517883, -0.05542432516813278, -0.00547933392226696, 0.0023916885256767273, -0.022831885144114494, -0.027885064482688904, -0.06995538622140884, -0.00199203472584486, 0.0036374370101839304, 0.01727449521422386, -0.021900154650211334, -0.00831582024693489, 0.048769377171993256, -0.0099605992436409, -0.03363160043954849, -0.022642800584435463, -0.020641827955842018, -0.003024314995855093, -0.020633967593312263, 0.017175661399960518, 0.01938207633793354, -0.03168662637472153, 0.013381335884332657, 0.021268755197525024, 0.027912326157093048, 0.007908155210316181, -0.00024214327277150005, 0.0048914020881056786, -0.037233203649520874, 0.0024633181747049093, -0.05225047841668129, 0.006294146180152893, -0.0022534511517733335, 0.05097388103604317, 0.010186065919697285, 0.06016474589705467, 0.006838263478130102, -0.06223130226135254, -0.03709549829363823, 0.03596587851643562, 0.04327454790472984, -0.016923891380429268, -0.042343609035015106, -0.051483865827322006, 0.06344282627105713, -0.03956066817045212, 0.014557311311364174, 0.012246289290487766, -0.0581720732152462, 0.001985993003472686, 0.016778798773884773, -0.009760808199644089, -0.0015674663009122014, 0.016072992235422134, -0.026714852079749107, 0.01706048659980297, -0.008584290742874146, -0.0007972443127073348, 0.0017740228213369846, 0.005075575318187475, 0.05694403871893883, -0.011673099361360073, -0.005203297361731529, -0.0036796287167817354, -0.023566680029034615, 0.03595626726746559, -0.015443661250174046, 0.043163251131772995, -0.006180254276841879, -0.02270740456879139, 0.04884186014533043, 0.02044859156012535, 0.01832149736583233, 0.028130436316132545, -0.014818414114415646, -0.042563147842884064, 0.025941355153918266, -0.042101290076971054, 0.036900151520967484, -0.010432186536490917, -0.048250552266836166, 0.014671186916530132, -0.04843588173389435, 0.03968888521194458, 0.05938921868801117, 0.00040839423309080303, -0.006139947567135096, 0.030687326565384865, 0.002921891864389181, 0.003270464250817895, 0.005847145803272724, -0.043485842645168304, -0.02248331531882286, 0.01786993443965912, 0.048927996307611465, -0.038377419114112854, -0.04871366173028946, -0.020511602982878685, -0.009892834350466728, -0.010836295783519745, 0.014933262951672077, -0.04411815106868744, 0.025393588468432426, 0.006204989273101091, 0.03082389384508133, -0.012644432485103607, -0.013227714225649834, -0.046235404908657074, 0.005145289469510317, 0.006671367213129997, -0.040578149259090424, -0.01770954206585884, 0.001981284935027361, -0.021981189027428627, -0.00764932855963707, 0.019516421481966972, -0.01282865647226572, 0.0010799603769555688, 0.004163824021816254, -0.015797121450304985, -0.04411778599023819, 0.0465267188847065, -0.02710011415183544, 0.013284874148666859, 0.03570709377527237, -0.03637101873755455, -0.05079476162791252, 0.019612200558185577, 0.009072545915842056, 0.019181989133358, 0.025410296395421028, -0.030316269025206566, -0.04678576812148094, 0.045336976647377014, -0.00201409962028265, -0.012337617576122284, 0.005707181990146637, 0.037124473601579666, -0.013419690541923046, 0.024575982242822647, -0.013204177841544151, -0.01967087760567665, -0.029261955991387367, -0.018555384129285812, 0.0519070103764534, -0.007365715224295855, 0.00468047708272934, 0.011253530159592628, -0.0085466792806983, 0.016346104443073273, 0.010777076706290245, 0.0052376301027834415, 0.03492959588766098, -0.006464598700404167, -0.01617533713579178, 0.006638463120907545, -0.008751261979341507, 0.023448022082448006, -0.08384031802415848, 0.01507478766143322, -0.0030996801797300577, 0.03953922912478447, 0.02147834002971649, -0.06314237415790558, -0.026542630046606064, 0.030937550589442253, -0.05275930091738701, 0.011375095695257187, -0.03876011446118355, -0.018999172374606133, 0.021016225218772888, -0.01869359239935875, -0.02195773832499981, 0.04149206727743149, -0.010193642228841782, -0.0029228897765278816, 0.02691897191107273, 0.004799012094736099, -0.002062850631773472, -0.005880706012248993, 0.010125447995960712, 0.03146231174468994, 0.003300121519714594, -0.03543427959084511, 0.025783613324165344, -0.03735613450407982, -0.04247349873185158, 0.0005698645254597068, 0.004770567640662193, 0.011414699256420135, -0.00007330365042435005, 0.035117294639348984, 0.015094186179339886, 0.04226186126470566, -0.007884382270276546, -0.010887397453188896, -0.009529977105557919, 0.00248711952008307, 0.022082312032580376, 0.053260039538145065, -0.03371105343103409, -0.008682283572852612, 0.03860042989253998, -0.03513990342617035, -0.06758031994104385, 0.013992567546665668, -0.012751881964504719, -0.02424994483590126, 0.0069313314743340015, -0.012312188744544983, 0.011864869855344296, -0.04285860434174538, 0.010380730964243412, -0.015441020019352436, 0.002659605583176017, 0.021801946684718132, -0.012743102386593819, 0.06166109815239906, 0.029059365391731262, 0.025734759867191315, -0.02292160503566265, 0.00434791948646307, 0.00619315542280674, 0.02278665080666542, -0.0436861626803875, 0.008966909721493721, 0.004609392024576664, 0.002080987673252821, -0.019280293956398964, -0.04166998341679573, -0.03583437576889992, 0.020583363249897957, -0.024146277457475662, -0.0045579569414258, 0.030736327171325684, -0.02179189771413803, -0.00386344944126904, -0.03194209933280945, 0.07227268815040588, 0.01824474148452282, -0.009506822563707829, -0.020093822851777077, 0.00019625708227977157, -0.016545884311199188, -0.005514850839972496, 0.015885062515735626, -0.02505328133702278, -0.02352498099207878, -0.0295950286090374, 0.032937876880168915, 0.06569252163171768, -0.01602267473936081, 0.03716885298490524, -0.028861353173851967, -0.021929044276475906, -0.035936273634433746, -0.029467808082699776, -0.020059453323483467, 0.009875240735709667, 0.017211230471730232, 0.025601934641599655, 0.009333046153187752, -0.05449957773089409, -0.026368146762251854, 0.060517292469739914, 0.047821201384067535, 0.019264092668890953, 0.06368205696344376, -0.04744475334882736, 0.02993166632950306, 0.022695891559123993, -0.00915729533880949, -0.011708409525454044, 0.04523699730634689, -0.02017693966627121, 0.00914784800261259, -0.02256009913980961, -0.012270125560462475, -0.015048923902213573, -0.047911982983350754, 0.02246106043457985, 0.03485121205449104, -0.03584263101220131, -0.002097944263368845, 0.04065306857228279, 0.00975364912301302, 0.03704554960131645, 0.0169860627502203, -0.0009293147595599294, 0.03330019488930702, 0.00018316837667953223, -0.013716703280806541, 0.016191504895687103, 0.05542181432247162, 0.04280972108244896, 0.014344445429742336, 0.04849513620138168, -0.01122860237956047, 0.05607830733060837, -0.01950463093817234, 0.01767124980688095, -0.03511253371834755, 0.0040394822135567665, -0.002926334273070097, 0.002492925152182579, 0.02045617066323757, 0.025443706661462784, -0.051092371344566345, 0.07598952203989029, -0.07235603779554367, 0.015435824170708656, -0.035548631101846695, 0.007424503564834595, -0.05085059255361557, -0.017338033765554428, 0.017918331548571587, 0.06106521189212799, -0.03642810881137848, 0.03161885216832161, -0.018768711015582085, 0.017270158976316452, 0.05107450857758522, -0.029189307242631912, 0.03725941479206085, 0.0024985892232507467, 0.018430860713124275, -0.029113709926605225, -0.003470832481980324, -0.024984115734696388, -0.006709077395498753, 0.018329668790102005, 0.07000403106212616, 0.031890299171209335, -0.028873464092612267, -0.01975075528025627, -0.04269139841198921, 0.039506711065769196, -0.05345621705055237, 0.004251527599990368, -0.024900037795305252, -0.023205555975437164, -0.019710829481482506, -0.007290663197636604 ]
<p>I do have a big list of numeric values (including duplicates) and I do want to group them into ranges in order to see if how do they distribute.</p> <p>Let's say there are 1000 values ranging from 0 to 2.000.000 and I do want to group them. </p> <p>How can I achieve this, preferably in Excel or SQL.</p>
73,565
[ -0.021403037011623383, -0.011410313658416271, -0.012631455436348915, -0.009797224774956703, 0.03008449263870716, -0.015941333025693893, 0.0141749931499362, -0.011009922251105309, 0.027120577171444893, -0.030028047040104866, 0.04467617720365524, 0.01180416438728571, 0.024738773703575134, -0.0034714771900326014, 0.02026635967195034, 0.00724800257012248, -0.014177967794239521, 0.01611354388296604, 0.021935991942882538, -0.019992992281913757, -0.016147824004292488, -0.0031206277199089527, 0.019743027165532112, -0.018870418891310692, -0.016303295269608498, 0.014303688891232014, 0.04763997346162796, -0.006640094798058271, 0.008020427078008652, 0.06402662396430969, -0.0459611713886261, -0.04724963381886482, 0.04533541947603226, 0.06728443503379822, 0.01923685148358345, 0.00013027024397160858, -0.044941145926713943, -0.04425955191254616, -0.05222531035542488, 0.0011902004480361938, -0.05595799908041954, -0.009619788266718388, 0.013332183472812176, 0.02279042638838291, -0.018430041149258614, -0.011028261855244637, -0.019957901909947395, -0.025922896340489388, -0.021147163584828377, -0.05521058663725853, 0.060363538563251495, -0.006187306717038155, 0.0811815932393074, 0.014260413125157356, -0.013699390925467014, 0.036885686218738556, 0.029648665338754654, 0.08838548511266708, -0.000711977481842041, -0.026528092101216316, 0.01265794225037098, -0.019307825714349747, 0.004071467090398073, -0.021963007748126984, -0.0327918715775013, 0.019638456404209137, -0.03894886001944542, -0.03958890214562416, 0.0002554690872784704, 0.00516390148550272, 0.006692655384540558, 0.046632759273052216, 0.0460520014166832, -0.03359365090727806, 0.012835249304771423, -0.06468068063259125, 0.034218061715364456, -0.040013741701841354, 0.08685686439275742, 0.05430510640144348, -0.010816510766744614, 0.028004268184304237, 0.015237328596413136, 0.013887474313378334, 0.012724218890070915, -0.027699433267116547, 0.06107918545603752, -0.04907699674367905, 0.015446366742253304, 0.018961012363433838, -0.017915423959493637, -0.004985833074897528, 0.0074034081771969795, 0.02365482971072197, -0.035624127835035324, 0.04524420574307442, -0.007921688258647919, 0.028332678601145744, 0.002413572045043111, -0.004945320542901754, 0.034605786204338074, -0.026613734662532806, 0.015962403267621994, 0.05453106760978699, -0.029296770691871643, 0.016433220356702805, -0.012995224446058273, -0.01853453367948532, 0.016263864934444427, 0.0181843601167202, 0.01403060369193554, -0.009118129499256611, 0.015264257788658142, -0.018361639231443405, 0.03239407762885094, 0.02941267564892769, -0.003214895259588957, -0.025783205404877663, 0.014393247663974762, 0.03942665830254555, 0.020075108855962753, -0.02559090033173561, 0.04863867163658142, 0.004122499376535416, -0.03215912729501724, 0.003784704953432083, 0.004468798637390137, 0.002821918111294508, -0.056411534547805786, 0.053595516830682755, -0.04820626974105835, -0.00927438959479332, 0.0742843747138977, -0.019666122272610664, 0.020548667758703232, -0.02109820581972599, -0.07646777480840683, -0.026194386184215546, -0.0001489293499616906, 0.00374009576626122, 0.017828641459345818, -0.03185683488845825, 0.036671947687864304, 0.008022473193705082, -0.008649124763906002, 0.03669008985161781, 0.01742604561150074, 0.02518283575773239, 0.02021133340895176, 0.03625476732850075, -0.01947740465402603, -0.029413845390081406, 0.015225815586745739, -0.021004194393754005, 0.03230039402842522, -0.0510539785027504, -0.013905901461839676, 0.012064036913216114, 0.01151243969798088, -0.027714230120182037, -0.005118624307215214, -0.010335137136280537, 0.012348279356956482, -0.022897308692336082, 0.035850562155246735, 0.011224697344005108, 0.07145226001739502, -0.0008628073264844716, 0.024205947294831276, 0.026257934048771858, 0.009634447284042835, 0.00392443872988224, 0.02550552971661091, 0.021736394613981247, 0.04727180674672127, 0.011269592680037022, 0.011329042725265026, -0.014228572137653828, 0.006026048678904772, 0.02659725211560726, -0.0209034513682127, -0.04007107764482498, 0.020195772871375084, 0.011859336867928505, 0.03518129140138626, 0.024596629664301872, -0.004656673409044743, -0.03987681120634079, -0.0007821347680874169, -0.03549439087510109, -0.006665512919425964, -0.07157271355390549, 0.029888557270169258, 0.00010494743037270382, -0.015169000253081322, -0.015669014304876328, 0.01602066494524479, 0.010211317799985409, 0.005118390545248985, -0.03628687933087349, -0.05609269440174103, -0.018326273187994957, 0.04587927833199501, -0.07294058799743652, 0.000963723286986351, 0.08090361207723618, 0.039557114243507385, -0.037877049297094345, 0.07076316326856613, -0.046889856457710266, -0.04979332163929939, 0.0009434454841539264, -0.033977970480918884, 0.03835327550768852, -0.01834430918097496, -0.004609459545463324, 0.013864018954336643, 0.014606512151658535, -0.018855806440114975, 0.03808767348527908, -0.03756619244813919, 0.05082150921225548, 0.06751172244548798, 0.033653758466243744, -0.0098522137850523, -0.04325530678033829, 0.03658363223075867, -0.031827691942453384, 0.025827761739492416, -0.04554392769932747, -0.05407508462667465, 0.01593434438109398, 0.02738875523209572, 0.026617905125021935, -0.04730243608355522, 0.004691723734140396, 0.05433046072721481, 0.043468374758958817, 0.01599637232720852, 0.024888567626476288, -0.05323677882552147, 0.04913352429866791, 0.036982461810112, 0.026804635301232338, 0.041164565831422806, 0.006609699223190546, 0.013019346632063389, 0.04789715260267258, 0.021000223234295845, -0.028368307277560234, 0.010408671572804451, 0.03173607587814331, 0.02905444987118244, 0.013888840563595295, -0.0015462797600775957, -0.03874567896127701, 0.03831746429204941, -0.0267178975045681, -0.002502830931916833, 0.023109370842576027, 0.010487457737326622, -0.041273389011621475, 0.030436506494879723, -0.041537538170814514, 0.004045726731419563, 0.0664728432893753, -0.055897194892168045, -0.023353343829512596, 0.016324985772371292, -0.036846909672021866, 0.040866669267416, -0.006628541741520166, -0.03176615387201309, -0.07445428520441055, 0.02330847643315792, 0.06925152987241745, 0.009557722136378288, 0.007885392755270004, -0.03802073746919632, -0.02218821831047535, -0.04034280776977539, -0.010167800821363926, -0.04432347044348717, -0.030819471925497055, -0.04867656156420708, -0.011808249168097973, 0.04175379499793053, -0.04124343767762184, 0.044877346605062485, 0.0038184490986168385, -0.016147762537002563, 0.02759331837296486, -0.018967213109135628, -0.056055933237075806, -0.012376234866678715, -0.036578185856342316, 0.015902921557426453, -0.026046739891171455, -0.010675478726625443, 0.037516284734010696, 0.010924064554274082, -0.05755903944373131, 0.01582619920372963, -0.061411213129758835, -0.0020946369040757418, -0.07001934945583344, 0.013297944329679012, 0.03392111882567406, -0.018837178125977516, -0.00305551546625793, -0.0044828541576862335, -0.003972700797021389, 0.009960758499801159, -0.03551286831498146, -0.037984028458595276, -0.019532373175024986, -0.003051169915124774, 0.013636245392262936, 0.024498555809259415, -0.018132047727704048, 0.06591582298278809, 0.0012701238738372922, -0.04701158404350281, -0.057130757719278336, -0.024454955011606216, 0.012265238910913467, -0.010961952619254589, 0.054702188819646835, -0.000666782958433032, -0.042673323303461075, -0.021548200398683548, 0.004274722654372454, 0.045006223022937775, 0.03396636247634888, -0.004234480671584606, 0.003699417458847165, 0.009789119474589825, 0.0016380723100155592, 0.005274102091789246, 0.001886776415631175, 0.02045777067542076, -0.03016001358628273, 0.033916547894477844, 0.0058652316220104694, 0.037501201033592224, 0.015206367708742619, -0.02974616177380085, 0.00004020003689220175, -0.016621308401226997, 0.026802225038409233, -0.011197935789823532, 0.013598368503153324, -0.015342765487730503, -0.024777429178357124, 0.03264373168349266, 0.04574541375041008, 0.04196356236934662, -0.019632326439023018, -0.021737633273005486, 0.03670826554298401, 0.06540265679359436, -0.04503379389643669, -0.001952471793629229, 0.0005069596809335053, -0.007110645994544029, -0.005642121657729149, -0.012654254212975502, -0.0030710259452462196, 0.007523936685174704, 0.03536739572882652, 0.02928199991583824, 0.02319723553955555, -0.019932283088564873, 0.018985776230692863, -0.06550736725330353, -0.015452319756150246, -0.029660113155841827, 0.0838022381067276, 0.001596790156327188, 0.08691372722387314, 0.02569425292313099, -0.00796167366206646, 0.04285847768187523, 0.028664197772741318, -0.01637234166264534, 0.013755633495748043, -0.01666160672903061, 0.009743434377014637, -0.011541900224983692, 0.0015755572821944952, -0.018094627186655998, -0.010084065608680248, -0.003328848397359252, -0.00883281696587801, -0.0004214675282128155, -0.02657436579465866, -0.017875131219625473, 0.003893692744895816, -0.0015046772314235568, -0.01259534154087305, 0.017261607572436333, 0.007719072513282299, 0.008561213500797749, 0.05333218723535538, 0.025377308949828148, -0.0074470811523497105, -0.020353302359580994, -0.019439207389950752, 0.024665378034114838, -0.0009885580511763692, 0.050492651760578156, -0.029331810772418976, 0.020456409081816673, -0.036215316504240036, 0.0023402415681630373, -0.05178207531571388, 0.04917963594198227, 0.018639996647834778, -0.015999512746930122, -0.00044840635382570326, -0.0028391415253281593, 0.002399585209786892, -0.0038274554535746574, 0.006923474371433258, -0.018194710835814476, 0.01356332004070282, 0.05227107182145119, 0.02489905059337616, -0.05733974650502205, 0.041633617132902145, 0.10937981307506561, 0.04197860136628151, -0.017707595601677895, 0.010692991316318512, -0.01300276443362236, -0.01834622584283352, -0.015056722797453403, 0.0010645576985552907, 0.02672090381383896, -0.002713410649448633, 0.023619994521141052, 0.036027707159519196, -0.017527181655168533, -0.048370588570833206, -0.0202759001404047, 0.022837907075881958, 0.06434118002653122, -0.030470291152596474, -0.021917663514614105, 0.040310438722372055, -0.0024500172585248947, 0.031507957726716995, 0.01987038180232048, 0.001189082395285368, -0.1394665241241455, 0.003295810893177986, 0.031068963930010796, 0.010400361381471157, -0.04895820841193199, -0.03451834246516228, -0.01497973408550024, -0.008975842967629433, 0.0589204840362072, -0.06424570828676224, 0.027488280087709427, -0.028358735144138336, 0.022370409220457077, 0.0001895103050628677, -0.01404334232211113, 0.009010326117277145, 0.0357014536857605, -0.0007701842114329338, 0.030122512951493263, 0.010871187783777714, 0.0018949357327073812, -0.05790603160858154, 0.03744223341345787, 0.026776911690831184, 0.05593610927462578, -0.007714774925261736, 0.008761434815824032, 0.010371253825724125, -0.010033377446234226, -0.04177258536219597, -0.04167835786938667, 0.008391438983380795, 0.0037844430189579725, 0.0015364144928753376, 0.05099964141845703, -0.027837935835123062, -0.05405179038643837, 0.006523400079458952, 0.008919445797801018, 0.024948645383119583, -0.010259103029966354, -0.011879404075443745, 0.05255170166492462, 0.038731448352336884, 0.010792428627610207, 0.05849352478981018, 0.027843143790960312, -0.01406511478126049, 0.0029041548259556293, -0.031958773732185364, 0.005798396188765764, -0.007594073656946421, -0.046748533844947815, -0.043106503784656525, 0.012491162866353989, -0.02824929915368557, -0.0009715846972540021, -0.04045797139406204, 0.004890285898000002, -0.02923819050192833, -0.019336240366101265, -0.01817518286406994, 0.04135841131210327, 0.02386070415377617, -0.005608060397207737, -0.002463514683768153, 0.03849570453166962, 0.008111132308840752, -0.018747754395008087, 0.04772255942225456, 0.004414614289999008, -0.0025694663636386395, -0.01748128980398178, -0.01024426519870758, -0.0087689608335495, -0.05856446549296379, -0.01617753505706787, -0.0029588607139885426, -0.01949881948530674, 0.055023107677698135, -0.0018387289019301534, 0.023871609941124916, 0.019805796444416046, -0.04397200047969818, -0.01973157748579979, 0.020337380468845367, 0.002913922071456909, 0.029771391302347183, -0.04964947700500488, 0.08148986846208572, 0.0039976816624403, -0.026784947142004967, -0.08610132336616516, -0.08146476000547409, 0.037099696695804596, -0.0189497247338295, 0.009836774319410324, -0.05462706461548805, -0.0020462663378566504, -0.004962590057402849, 0.008002933114767075, -0.030775902792811394, 0.037979576736688614, 0.005920137744396925, -0.0257888101041317, 0.0037469607777893543, 0.00032763404306024313, 0.0835561603307724, 0.04324055463075638, -0.03501766175031662, 0.017870444804430008, 0.029236290603876114, -0.0188448466360569, -0.01639830879867077, 0.002726905979216099, -0.04495726525783539, -0.0037173365708440542, -0.008752399124205112, -0.011343754827976227, 0.06919004768133163, -0.03848974406719208, 0.042091235518455505, 0.0014373307349160314, 0.013596847653388977, 0.016752518713474274, -0.02027262933552265, 0.023269301280379295, -0.01846189983189106, 0.0016552367014810443, -0.04564698413014412, 0.0015354165807366371, -0.038892485201358795, 0.008228105492889881, 0.007558664306998253, 0.013947752304375172, 0.0005341776995919645, 0.020264586433768272, 0.03835640102624893, -0.0002094539231620729, 0.01399499736726284, -0.02511812001466751, -0.01538426335901022, 0.04386444762349129, 0.027242500334978104, -0.028092380613088608, 0.00020775760640390217, 0.020741386339068413, -0.007675583474338055, 0.009230195544660091, -0.019199904054403305, -0.02856423519551754, 0.05726410821080208, -0.007658552844077349, 0.03986106067895889, 0.04464287683367729, 0.030584760010242462, 0.01784513331949711, -0.02922329492866993, 0.019798897206783295, -0.011434254236519337, 0.023367544636130333, 0.04498692601919174, -0.01553367543965578, 0.025093160569667816, -0.006215199828147888, 0.009401896968483925, 0.029985640197992325, 0.0335560217499733, 0.003951865714043379, -0.023182900622487068, 0.00429946556687355, -0.015306753106415272, -0.016191933304071426, 0.017844146117568016, -0.04315752908587456, -0.0011773984879255295, -0.003218403784558177, -0.04717104882001877, -0.0019058953039348125, -0.027570931240916252, -0.037946540862321854, -0.000282911176327616, -0.04335350543260574, -0.016730813309550285, 0.02260575443506241, -0.027307800948619843, -0.00980053748935461, 0.007956046611070633, 0.01881829835474491, 0.021965408697724342, 0.011211466044187546, -0.013128293678164482, 0.010497975163161755, -0.04809723421931267, -0.009340580552816391, -0.016213146969676018, -0.07689335197210312, 0.006599503569304943, 0.031020335853099823, -0.02447991818189621, -0.0015305455308407545, -0.006369937676936388, -0.015701789408922195, 0.002957124961540103, 0.029457245022058487, -0.03528142720460892, 0.07798031717538834, 0.03065015934407711, 0.02590622566640377, 0.01941944658756256, -0.015566530637443066, 0.09361793100833893, 0.06517291814088821, 0.036187853664159775, -0.05425425246357918, 0.0058985217474401, -0.004222769755870104, -0.007812722586095333, -0.0032792515121400356, 0.011704199016094208, -0.0007402802584692836, 0.0061222766526043415, 0.048916734755039215, 0.06390143185853958, -0.008005079813301563, 0.03846175968647003, 0.06702949851751328, 0.003540795063599944, -0.011476743966341019, 0.008217662572860718, 0.02789575606584549, 0.01836506836116314, -0.012563818134367466, -0.06337538361549377, 0.05207968130707741, -0.001657659187912941, -0.008300979621708393, -0.042204633355140686, -0.016677189618349075, 0.025965191423892975, 0.023769913241267204, -0.021128764376044273, 0.01741124503314495, 0.03421091288328171, -0.020721707493066788, 0.0010884130606427789, -0.03273447975516319, 0.00655553350225091, -0.029414473101496696, -0.0037496150471270084, 0.015568322502076626, -0.002188716549426317, -0.0012838359689339995, -0.042572982609272, 0.01922130025923252, -0.03744010627269745, -0.028723908588290215, -0.019378487020730972, -0.029896961525082588, -0.026456022635102272, -0.01315716840326786, -0.011391487903892994, 0.026540666818618774, -0.03720910847187042, -0.028498705476522446, -0.02529625967144966, 0.04392297565937042, 0.019050130620598793, -0.015925532206892967, -0.02757973223924637, -0.012382551096379757, 0.0009018474374897778, -0.0609804168343544, 0.01992044784128666, 0.005142577458173037, -0.013374017551541328, -0.007666761986911297, -0.05482620373368263, 0.01628369465470314, -0.03992587327957153, 0.010570082813501358, -0.026982715353369713, -0.0449928417801857, -0.03499714285135269, -0.03371760994195938, 0.010834290646016598, 0.017881661653518677, -0.009675425477325916, 0.026096200570464134, 0.020968882367014885, -0.00714695081114769, -0.003197725862264633, 0.03339404612779617, 0.01103945542126894, -0.014193715527653694, -0.02290796861052513, -0.004650691989809275, 0.030234038829803467, 0.024786559864878654, 0.026458928361535072, 0.025962412357330322, -0.030371971428394318, 0.03367042541503906, 0.024180971086025238, -0.04478628188371658, -0.01687057875096798, 0.01509800460189581, -0.028874602168798447, 0.055756825953722, 0.006734709721058607, 0.06490348279476166, 0.005532125476747751, -0.022676365450024605, 0.021896246820688248, 0.022568251937627792, -0.03257763013243675, 0.03814803063869476, 0.0017477023648098111, -0.06400637328624725, 0.012349819764494896, 0.009863329119980335, -0.00814005360007286, -0.00838722474873066, -0.008971234783530235, -0.010672279633581638, -0.013172397390007973, 0.015213774517178535, 0.010846349410712719, -0.01405044924467802, 0.018479321151971817, -0.037392567843198776, 0.006379381287842989, -0.036255963146686554, 0.002650406677275896, -0.03594541549682617, -0.013108869083225727, -0.0193148422986269, -0.0046579232439398766, -0.03270935267210007, 0.008621213026344776, -0.009692342951893806, 0.023941121995449066, 0.047026220709085464, 0.003969354555010796, 0.008817198686301708, 0.012840056791901588, 0.009231717325747013, -0.015922408550977707, 0.050972577184438705, -0.05628078803420067, -0.009168789722025394, 0.047702349722385406, -0.02777240239083767, -0.00792714674025774, 0.02684110775589943, -0.03558408096432686, 0.01938074454665184, 0.02053966000676155, -0.03407099097967148, -0.04378177970647812, 0.050232451409101486, -0.02159859426319599, -0.03992689773440361, -0.004334682133048773, 0.01297710370272398, 0.06182118132710457, 0.03941332921385765, -0.022154483944177628, 0.0016110263532027602, -0.049597498029470444, -0.006126025225967169, 0.04798430949449539, 0.03248653933405876, -0.0455237552523613, 0.006444124970585108, 0.017415383830666542, 0.041287560015916824, 0.028313636779785156, -0.007901311852037907, 0.044181838631629944, 0.03581865504384041, -0.04774021357297897, 0.026274152100086212, -0.04626694321632385, 0.011889119632542133, -0.03827318176627159, -0.0319584384560585, -0.0021175777073949575, -0.03140698000788689, 0.019319532439112663, -0.03407008573412895, -0.0425829216837883, 0.011778300628066063, -0.03776998445391655, 0.05753304064273834, -0.017963649705052376, 0.00886572990566492, 0.0018783368868753314, 0.013768303208053112, -0.030521860346198082, 0.03262406215071678, 0.043733566999435425, 0.026249036192893982, 0.0012566702207550406, 0.007612403482198715, 0.045109689235687256, -0.027782686054706573, 0.006437783595174551, -0.020972376689314842, 0.026108786463737488, -0.018832117319107056, 0.0011004842817783356, -0.005097998771816492, -0.04126161336898804, 0.026554279029369354, -0.05263133347034454, 0.02838992513716221, 0.05039823800325394, 0.02005646377801895, -0.025165792554616928, 0.06327874958515167, -0.004316872451454401, 0.02352256327867508, -0.02310437150299549, 0.012249791994690895, 0.008903685957193375, 0.037040162831544876, 0.020332811400294304, 0.010112284682691097, 0.05967125669121742, 0.0020673824474215508, -0.03934864327311516, 0.04008759930729866, 0.005808196496218443, -0.020643629133701324, -0.023842530325055122, -0.005532174836844206, 0.029524367302656174, -0.030234983190894127, 0.009301246143877506, -0.025135647505521774, 0.01969202049076557, 0.03182712942361832, -0.008804377168416977, 0.012447110377252102, 0.04546382650732994, 0.021631458774209023, -0.033567216247320175, -0.013954817317426205, 0.03509974107146263, -0.010832209140062332, -0.04790196567773819, 0.002157994080334902, 0.022440368309617043, -0.015493563376367092, -0.01009229477494955, -0.03810862824320793, 0.0095448549836874, 0.051671262830495834, -0.00845201313495636, 0.017073115333914757, 0.05452270805835724, 0.009957735426723957, -0.02863175980746746, -0.06578049063682556, 0.05143566429615021, 0.031688202172517776, -0.010618387721478939, -0.04051041230559349, -0.015639496967196465, -0.04287015646696091, 0.02529296651482582, 0.022112688049674034, 0.013935139402747154, 0.02309664711356163, -0.062225159257650375, 0.016691824421286583, 0.019087115302681923, -0.04593586549162865, 0.01923028565943241, -0.008313382044434547, -0.08176668733358383, -0.01787569746375084, -0.012077437713742256, -0.012122368440032005, -0.037933044135570526, 0.010278154164552689, -0.03135019540786743, -0.02731536515057087, 0.0001607411977602169, 0.012737972661852837, 0.019305579364299774, 0.028347881510853767, -0.018480027094483376, 0.04071611166000366, -0.025025639683008194, -0.0017475658096373081, 0.01992122270166874, 0.011415915563702583, -0.042315222322940826, 0.03826476261019707, -0.07062897831201553, 0.007944585755467415, -0.010344846174120903, 0.023635342717170715, 0.014873209409415722, -0.06315216422080994, 0.0289283636957407, -0.00738937733694911, -0.017616013064980507, 0.012711457908153534, 0.03990815952420235, 0.015741130337119102, 0.038331493735313416, -0.0055831968784332275, 0.018454840406775475, -0.004049563780426979, -0.009537010453641415, 0.041321445256471634, 0.0076076313853263855, 0.021898025646805763, -0.012876416556537151, 0.006694206967949867, 0.027416931465268135, 0.021462270990014076, 0.02516879327595234, 0.0030323523096740246, 0.012107295915484428, -0.006908622570335865, -0.009010685607790947, 0.011344612576067448, -0.07630918174982071, 0.030258093029260635, 0.009787031449377537, -0.030753422528505325, 0.03665716573596001, -0.06245981901884079, 0.007799916435033083, -0.0739605501294136, -0.01625465601682663, -0.007879937067627907, 0.010699554346501827, -0.011149161495268345, 0.020580440759658813, -0.04525135084986687, 0.005991170182824135, 0.021224603056907654, 0.010423320345580578, 0.012022117152810097, 0.002132650464773178, 0.020020315423607826, -0.04548749327659607, 0.0047357953153550625, -0.04588085040450096, -0.02820773422718048, -0.030238499864935875, 0.005992267280817032, 0.020278917625546455, 0.012610170058906078, 0.023055117577314377, -0.001624804106540978, -0.005114707630127668, -0.011501960456371307, -0.011157513596117496, -0.04017803445458412, -0.03514336049556732, -0.07251673936843872, -0.00033811453613452613, -0.022175872698426247, -0.0302946288138628 ]
<p>Although I know how to calculate many of the statistical values, I have some difficulties understanding which one should I use in a specific situation. Here is my example:</p> <p>In my experiment I tried to find out how fast does the Water evaporate from 8 different nonvowen Materials. To achieve this I prepared 4 Testobject's for each Material (that makes a total of 32) and moisturized them. Afterwards i let them dry in a controled enviroment (Laboratory was airconditioned and the Temperature and rel. air humidity was recorded). Every hour I measured the weight of each Testobject. I calculated the relation betwen weight of water and weight of a dry Testobject to be able to compare the results to each other and presented them in a diagram (Water/dry ratio to time diagramm). I made a linear Trendline for each of 32 Testobjects with gaussian least square method. The slope of the Graph represents the Evaporative rate per hour of a given Object. I used Excel to calculate.</p> <p>I can approximate the observational error for measured Weight and the corresponding measurement time. Given that </p> <p>-calculated trendline is defined as:</p> <p>$ m = a \times t + b$</p> <p>-the measured weight and time are </p> <p>$m_{i}$ and $t_{i}$</p> <p>and the vertikal distance between measured data and the trendline is defined as:</p> <p>$ e_{i} = a \times t_{i} + b - m_{i}$</p> <p>one can calculate the error of the slope <code>a</code> with following equation:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/BpwGw.png" alt="Error of Slope of a trendline"></p> <p>So here comes my problem: I have 4 trendlines for each material with 4 slopes each. I calculated an average for each material. All of the slopes have their error. Also each average has its statistical dispersion. I would like to presents those averages with some kind of +- range, like standard deviation or something. What kind of measure of statistical dispersion should i use? </p>
73,566
[ 0.0034902486950159073, -0.03620106354355812, -0.030373824760317802, -0.00011966275633312762, 0.021066345274448395, 0.0032726211939007044, 0.0021510240621864796, -0.002271086908876896, -0.01599966548383236, -0.005982434377074242, 0.038578201085329056, 0.046167902648448944, 0.03162011131644249, 0.021433385089039803, 0.02879963628947735, 0.0038196779787540436, -0.039678364992141724, 0.009509459137916565, 0.013313989154994488, -0.010811848565936089, 0.044647593051195145, -0.009200451895594597, -0.019920574501156807, -0.016079340130090714, -0.01950923353433609, 0.012254996225237846, 0.02428508922457695, -0.022046474739909172, 0.006617124192416668, 0.03944183886051178, -0.0528569221496582, -0.06505243480205536, -0.00003944306808989495, -0.01889953948557377, 0.014961719512939453, 0.0218501053750515, -0.019920557737350464, -0.013587051071226597, -0.003983359783887863, 0.052106574177742004, -0.015888243913650513, -0.01889067329466343, 0.009712942875921726, 0.017290448769927025, -0.0017319897888228297, -0.0015260052168741822, 0.019709397107362747, -0.014911745674908161, 0.020504683256149292, -0.021540969610214233, 0.06651628017425537, 0.003234108444303274, 0.028826717287302017, 0.029001081362366676, -0.007899800315499306, -0.004186656791716814, 0.03891589120030403, 0.039808060973882675, -0.02064337395131588, -0.0631805807352066, -0.01323844213038683, 0.002679619938135147, -0.007951049134135246, -0.009384175762534142, -0.006364023312926292, -0.012374545447528362, -0.008646910078823566, 0.01020937692373991, 0.05806111544370651, 0.0007992533501237631, 0.022062599658966064, -0.014232047833502293, 0.04059942439198494, -0.02473541535437107, 0.01896326057612896, 0.011748590506613255, 0.00448337709531188, 0.06692638248205185, 0.037973664700984955, 0.03421983867883682, 0.004863595124334097, 0.03730178251862526, 0.016090039163827896, 0.0136632164940238, -0.005052194464951754, -0.013033416122198105, 0.05295972898602486, -0.018694113940000534, 0.015735331922769547, 0.01579081267118454, 0.01614307053387165, 0.026885608211159706, 0.01140450406819582, 0.0032893556635826826, -0.00006278970977291465, -0.0059998114593327045, 0.019035177305340767, -0.013961566612124443, -0.017637789249420166, 0.01076101791113615, 0.011404713615775108, -0.024041688069701195, 0.005695079918950796, 0.073898546397686, -0.01757611334323883, 0.0025405888445675373, 0.009024389088153839, 0.015471396967768669, -0.02988058142364025, -0.045475758612155914, -0.029338078573346138, 0.0018594724824652076, 0.028340185061097145, 0.03152229264378548, -0.011949458159506321, -0.042068783193826675, 0.013901881873607635, -0.016018711030483246, 0.031088465824723244, 0.032260868698358536, 0.03227616474032402, -0.014292307198047638, 0.026361463591456413, -0.01243896409869194, -0.04776627570390701, 0.013952826149761677, 0.0038063398096710443, -0.03728675842285156, -0.03706323727965355, 0.04479861259460449, 0.00736768264323473, -0.02437409572303295, 0.04926072061061859, -0.0175071582198143, 0.0009237091871909797, 0.01653992384672165, -0.09427351504564285, -0.06838415563106537, 0.07331863790750504, -0.006667155772447586, 0.003202252322807908, -0.04815332219004631, -0.007785023655742407, 0.029885873198509216, -0.00773657439276576, 0.04037230461835861, 0.011364616453647614, -0.0012783292913809419, 0.05331447347998619, 0.015094483271241188, -0.029632899910211563, -0.004304989241063595, 0.008593857288360596, -0.026966886594891548, 0.0126402098685503, -0.05023610591888428, -0.0004328523646108806, 0.0438532680273056, -0.029128747060894966, 0.018084613606333733, 0.03713706135749817, 0.016446953639388084, -0.01338078174740076, 0.0037632333114743233, 0.010449211113154888, -0.015033337287604809, 0.019494105130434036, -0.007031688932329416, 0.02070719376206398, 0.017095962539315224, 0.008075586520135403, -0.012142544612288475, -0.004630041308701038, 0.025453345850110054, 0.07893232256174088, -0.01609458029270172, 0.0010112383170053363, -0.026345426216721535, -0.057566795498132706, 0.023821355774998665, -0.0530104823410511, -0.048837266862392426, -0.004537625703960657, -0.010348803363740444, 0.028255891054868698, 0.043679703027009964, -0.005942041054368019, 0.014768095687031746, 0.029561204835772514, -0.03985204920172691, -0.03896978497505188, -0.05361463874578476, -0.004068885929882526, 0.04223908856511116, -0.018131744116544724, -0.007427024655044079, -0.0541599877178669, -0.006334859412163496, 0.018217908218503, 0.0030135896522551775, -0.000610386545304209, 0.012611600570380688, 0.013392352499067783, -0.035459741950035095, 0.016013801097869873, 0.05205034092068672, 0.03303399682044983, -0.01635162904858589, -0.008914990350604057, -0.04462694004178047, 0.002218525391072035, -0.005287115462124348, -0.03509381040930748, 0.00009226725524058565, 0.009651390835642815, -0.05312729626893997, 0.0033431958872824907, -0.004226838704198599, -0.0021387103479355574, 0.016810592263936996, -0.02869349718093872, 0.055937714874744415, 0.10434393584728241, 0.0012720173690468073, -0.025401700288057327, -0.001352633349597454, -0.003175899852067232, 0.04380252584815025, -0.029772181063890457, -0.01987980678677559, -0.044327497482299805, -0.0032821071799844503, -0.04237310588359833, 0.04420802742242813, -0.02729787863790989, -0.010453524067997932, 0.02956370636820793, 0.02449141815304756, -0.006230885628610849, 0.048564404249191284, -0.019106056541204453, -0.033014532178640366, 0.02282758057117462, 0.04024217650294304, 0.023469727486371994, 0.025454649701714516, -0.005016683135181665, 0.01160425879061222, 0.04954373463988304, -0.013136237859725952, 0.024122966453433037, 0.023203711956739426, 0.009984816424548626, -0.005766941234469414, -0.0244312547147274, 0.0059510101564228535, 0.013951653614640236, -0.054984789341688156, -0.02070748805999756, 0.05542447417974472, 0.011138812638819218, 0.005936422850936651, -0.013218712992966175, -0.03187047690153122, 0.02869413048028946, 0.021274251863360405, -0.004149876534938812, -0.031199583783745766, 0.01143146213144064, -0.029475174844264984, 0.023633331060409546, -0.03432886675000191, -0.03465583175420761, -0.0017534714424982667, 0.012213439680635929, 0.023810148239135742, 0.005405813921242952, -0.0038338827434927225, -0.013848815113306046, -0.02049865573644638, -0.02406475879251957, -0.04013165459036827, -0.0002278542669955641, -0.0012290687300264835, -0.041466519236564636, 0.008800031617283821, -0.04748305678367615, -0.021550485864281654, 0.0301764365285635, -0.010242614895105362, -0.04739362746477127, 0.07566780596971512, 0.03217911347746849, -0.01534939557313919, -0.0353122353553772, -0.028548652306199074, -0.011346381157636642, -0.01931159384548664, -0.005525568965822458, 0.05808696150779724, -0.03159511461853981, -0.022627461701631546, 0.06834471225738525, -0.06866508722305298, -0.021225474774837494, -0.023374618962407112, -0.024742910638451576, -0.02815181016921997, 0.027349676936864853, 0.0036981317680329084, -0.0026696426793932915, 0.003090926678851247, -0.03392326086759567, -0.0728265717625618, -0.0479782409965992, 0.030708830803632736, -0.01219935156404972, 0.04526366665959358, 0.0005580781726166606, -0.004506914410740137, 0.08387743681669235, 0.03578772768378258, -0.0552961491048336, -0.021408546715974808, -0.013730298727750778, -0.020111801102757454, -0.06237221136689186, 0.025913771241903305, 0.01889760047197342, 0.008658514358103275, -0.02051059901714325, -0.016723601147532463, 0.026811838150024414, 0.06444153934717178, -0.029592018574476242, 0.04217633977532387, -0.021359508857131004, 0.014582311734557152, -0.008734587579965591, 0.06535344570875168, 0.017268147319555283, -0.010663219727575779, 0.0026065625716000795, -0.014994957484304905, 0.05070561543107033, 0.026533719152212143, -0.07923511415719986, 0.019627735018730164, -0.033093973994255066, 0.01834392547607422, -0.042066022753715515, 0.022764902561903, 0.012004002928733826, -0.005207761190831661, -0.01707027293741703, -0.005933366250246763, 0.07438071072101593, -0.019453264772892, 0.008850008249282837, 0.07073532789945602, 0.061317574232816696, -0.012450724840164185, -0.0072240340523421764, 0.004683949518948793, -0.007475956808775663, 0.06295187026262283, -0.046507954597473145, -0.05101291835308075, 0.03410851210355759, 0.04573158174753189, -0.0246671661734581, 0.0005746996612288058, -0.039930641651153564, 0.0034238824155181646, -0.009838901460170746, -0.004222322721034288, -0.001936961431056261, 0.06997522711753845, 0.0180391613394022, 0.05549949035048485, -0.003335200948640704, -0.038188010454177856, -0.00034709961619228125, -0.042022883892059326, -0.03569243475794792, 0.0428466722369194, -0.007895312272012234, -0.047040920704603195, 0.011413377709686756, -0.021903879940509796, 0.02245260588824749, -0.0222322978079319, 0.026947222650051117, 0.021582214161753654, 0.06629246473312378, -0.02435414120554924, 0.01690334640443325, -0.0000873298486112617, -0.008353891782462597, -0.035403117537498474, 0.026643570512533188, 0.029855573549866676, -0.060214363038539886, 0.060534097254276276, 0.008676000870764256, -0.01405250746756792, -0.01522477250546217, -0.04971164092421532, 0.008127408102154732, 0.03679356724023819, 0.019120097160339355, 0.011999430134892464, 0.01553267426788807, -0.06161259859800339, 0.017006652429699898, 0.02823018655180931, 0.040974222123622894, 0.005251996219158173, -0.02607761137187481, -0.04003782570362091, -0.009491505101323128, -0.0043958877213299274, 0.019424783065915108, 0.051733437925577164, 0.025012090802192688, -0.0018692297162488103, 0.005671313963830471, 0.013293009251356125, -0.02497098781168461, 0.06061399355530739, 0.021477513015270233, -0.01603413186967373, 0.07623861730098724, -0.039506442844867706, -0.03419455885887146, 0.008155308663845062, -0.014589017257094383, 0.03910497948527336, 0.030610831454396248, 0.0009862525621429086, -0.024934271350502968, 0.04411938786506653, 0.03154454007744789, -0.008989478461444378, 0.041075967252254486, 0.05907085910439491, 0.010281151160597801, 0.0040972610004246235, -0.018162403255701065, -0.012997214682400227, 0.031064368784427643, 0.04572642967104912, 0.006988348439335823, 0.0498080737888813, -0.09817556291818619, -0.03144800290465355, 0.026490608230233192, 0.02464601770043373, -0.028013167902827263, -0.000861551146954298, -0.008556765504181385, -0.004479780327528715, 0.03937533125281334, -0.006110366899520159, 0.03891078382730484, -0.004260487388819456, 0.06493481993675232, -0.062238652259111404, -0.029837407171726227, -0.03547344356775284, -0.005990824196487665, -0.015994271263480186, 0.017017943784594536, -0.018335038796067238, -0.0349477156996727, -0.009920046664774418, -0.0007472723955288529, 0.0013478875625878572, 0.051813721656799316, -0.07294323295354843, -0.009637992829084396, 0.02543644979596138, -0.004090448841452599, -0.013346782885491848, -0.03983711823821068, -0.00969320721924305, -0.021255630999803543, -0.007748197298496962, 0.0431198850274086, 0.013221010565757751, -0.021966978907585144, 0.03368665277957916, 0.04055022448301315, -0.003123708302155137, -0.025518182665109634, -0.0477660708129406, 0.04327347129583359, 0.05271851643919945, -0.030814457684755325, 0.023234959691762924, 0.02180473692715168, 0.009632797911763191, 0.014907702803611755, -0.040636397898197174, 0.01756417192518711, -0.035146474838256836, -0.027946582064032555, -0.05067567527294159, -0.006894506514072418, -0.02666962333023548, 0.02347160503268242, -0.020525675266981125, 0.015070253983139992, -0.03917519748210907, -0.016842368990182877, 0.04205144941806793, 0.014939534477889538, -0.020796913653612137, 0.00592025788500905, 0.01477455347776413, 0.0029741358011960983, -0.006245063152164221, -0.021418167278170586, 0.0014012078754603863, -0.015974611043930054, -0.0017543858848512173, 0.012965179048478603, -0.019201554358005524, 0.01861197128891945, -0.017791731283068657, -0.011560820043087006, 0.0028468878008425236, -0.043239157646894455, 0.04272904992103577, 0.010690068826079369, 0.0072603486478328705, 0.0008391097653657198, -0.024550167843699455, -0.01927902176976204, 0.010882816277444363, 0.0057103438302874565, 0.0158624816685915, -0.057525575160980225, -0.015779132023453712, -0.021939296275377274, 0.046779390424489975, -0.05822926014661789, -0.021178187802433968, 0.01714939996600151, 0.01749768666923046, -0.06075749173760414, -0.008996588177978992, -0.044116321951150894, -0.019876591861248016, -0.030002547428011894, -0.014725008979439735, 0.04416029527783394, -0.0178389772772789, -0.013590022921562195, -0.018479812890291214, 0.07363462448120117, 0.09404774010181427, -0.02322153002023697, 0.012066147290170193, -0.03087584488093853, -0.01862914487719536, -0.027338635176420212, -0.012518580071628094, 0.018187616020441055, -0.039808809757232666, 0.011815259233117104, 0.007861370220780373, -0.004703863058239222, 0.03990692272782326, 0.002161147305741906, -0.011312711983919144, 0.01257999986410141, 0.03114178404211998, -0.026347864419221878, -0.02482554502785206, 0.03125831484794617, 0.0011326639214530587, 0.0023127661552280188, -0.042473599314689636, -0.033102456480264664, -0.012586666271090508, -0.00946551188826561, -0.004495244473218918, 0.003249398898333311, -0.06808013468980789, 0.033102504909038544, 0.07273397594690323, -0.035913508385419846, 0.004101063124835491, 0.007878378033638, -0.044473905116319656, 0.01827947609126568, 0.0265373382717371, -0.008017333224415779, 0.02057311125099659, -0.033849604427814484, -0.014683588407933712, 0.004124063067138195, -0.06396953016519547, 0.009205938316881657, 0.10439849644899368, 0.013990811072289944, 0.07947088778018951, 0.026496702805161476, 0.036794524639844894, -0.0012138370657339692, -0.036017537117004395, -0.04137508571147919, 0.026868203654885292, 0.004755786620080471, 0.02288074418902397, -0.012780723161995411, -0.03432776406407356, 0.005632385611534119, -0.016885988414287567, 0.0031580617651343346, 0.030795417726039886, -0.018937110900878906, 0.02261917106807232, -0.019102586433291435, -0.015204472467303276, -0.035247236490249634, 0.017237424850463867, -0.0399557426571846, 0.05511525273323059, -0.03772784769535065, -0.016318202018737793, 0.02314799465239048, 0.020414171740412712, -0.02919902466237545, -0.07188855856657028, -0.020692188292741776, -0.055938251316547394, 0.019403686746954918, 0.015728246420621872, -0.0093074981123209, 0.026129847392439842, 0.03255784511566162, 0.008943842723965645, -0.030156781896948814, 0.0428566038608551, -0.04152209684252739, -0.06397917866706848, -0.0104933250695467, -0.013106415048241615, -0.055165983736515045, 0.05488795042037964, -0.02081640437245369, -0.052933577448129654, -0.023437494412064552, -0.03139949589967728, 0.04387006163597107, -0.012353073805570602, 0.005917330738157034, 0.011298089288175106, 0.06432447582483292, -0.0028524950612336397, 0.017534984275698662, 0.02340044640004635, 0.022026071324944496, 0.1349966675043106, 0.05844965949654579, 0.01817987486720085, -0.023728620260953903, 0.008232933469116688, 0.0037518346216529608, -0.003072570776566863, -0.03817461058497429, 0.027005622163414955, 0.008035087026655674, 0.002333172596991062, 0.04757103696465492, 0.0330551452934742, 0.00043956845183856785, -0.0017556909006088972, 0.04454757645726204, -0.02768704481422901, -0.015483659692108631, -0.005657675210386515, -0.009218542836606503, -0.012082439847290516, -0.002781396731734276, 0.016601936891674995, 0.019567880779504776, -0.02065206691622734, 0.0016532777808606625, -0.022834312170743942, -0.01587660051882267, 0.014403828419744968, -0.00620229821652174, 0.00009802473505260423, 0.03129200637340546, 0.006471495609730482, -0.019788512960076332, -0.047401897609233856, 0.013747353106737137, -0.005381645634770393, -0.026626812294125557, 0.010858005844056606, 0.009233181364834309, 0.002561569679528475, -0.019838178530335426, 0.043671391904354095, 0.012390527874231339, -0.045412253588438034, -0.027836721390485764, -0.06225376948714256, 0.027031654492020607, 0.0004145269049331546, -0.022136026993393898, 0.02379799261689186, -0.019053982570767403, -0.006476971320807934, -0.0345216765999794, -0.002529874676838517, 0.01161808893084526, 0.030303310602903366, -0.03986614942550659, 0.008591072633862495, -0.011940278112888336, 0.005708223674446344, 0.015823660418391228, 0.0010472274152562022, 0.06780734658241272, -0.00188680540304631, -0.023864034563302994, -0.024310193955898285, 0.0627826526761055, -0.012039244174957275, 0.018748823553323746, -0.010300886817276478, -0.0014839399373158813, -0.0026121826376765966, -0.013440964743494987, 0.0021543067414313555, 0.007875987328588963, 0.01277072075754404, 0.009957432746887207, -0.021640442311763763, -0.012955544516444206, -0.03782880678772926, 0.029985206201672554, 0.014853370375931263, -0.02088172920048237, -0.036048565059900284, 0.010073541663587093, 0.013512068428099155, 0.042514052242040634, 0.01663767546415329, 0.02683855965733528, 0.012382910586893559, 0.07402978092432022, 0.03468722105026245, -0.058279212564229965, -0.01590866781771183, -0.014432167634367943, -0.007909168489277363, -0.036412253975868225, -0.008582423441112041, 0.05067070201039314, 0.05820144712924957, 0.020996609702706337, -0.007496423553675413, 0.01874018833041191, 0.009654555469751358, -0.0013228333555161953, 0.0049880146980285645, -0.016746027395129204, 0.04984917491674423, 0.009629877284169197, -0.01922900229692459, -0.040302492678165436, -0.0008946779416874051, -0.04224714636802673, -0.03315145522356033, 0.019391052424907684, -0.0313316248357296, -0.017045434564352036, 0.009574663825333118, -0.02820775844156742, 0.030716191977262497, -0.036983177065849304, -0.029133113101124763, -0.025681642815470695, -0.005534159019589424, -0.021638868376612663, 0.046625394374132156, -0.022381750866770744, 0.05154794454574585, -0.030083447694778442, 0.003425281262025237, 0.054289378225803375, 0.03798229992389679, 0.025242982432246208, -0.0270089078694582, 0.01085997000336647, -0.005548118147999048, 0.07065218687057495, 0.012195033021271229, -0.021807974204421043, -0.0047584823332726955, 0.001992882927879691, -0.03127910941839218, 0.046604011207818985, 0.036670710891485214, -0.003352714003995061, 0.0005173583049327135, 0.0026580162812024355, -0.026471491903066635, 0.06648854911327362, 0.0018088638316839933, 0.014322892762720585, -0.03373901546001434, -0.0817117765545845, -0.001848291140049696, -0.03312775865197182, 0.0015263878740370274, 0.037100955843925476, 0.02944805659353733, -0.003703848924487829, 0.016844043508172035, 0.006677353288978338, -0.019790751859545708, -0.009996889159083366, -0.0145126236602664, 0.0010516371112316847, 0.012373063713312149, -0.02908274345099926, 0.03992758318781853, 0.08335492014884949, -0.014236933551728725, -0.012505510821938515, -0.017393287271261215, 0.023602358996868134, -0.0530676543712616, 0.0012244355166330934, 0.04112919047474861, 0.03265842795372009, 0.025148315355181694, -0.035619884729385376, 0.004622454289346933, 0.04959338530898094, -0.0049422443844377995, 0.028927545994520187, -0.03170379251241684, -0.0019526941468939185, -0.010248750448226929, 0.014392033219337463, 0.0025142375379800797, 0.013736627995967865, 0.026333635672926903, 0.03592491149902344, 0.031009333208203316, 0.0501115545630455, 0.0074873026460409164, -0.0480925627052784, -0.003471916075795889, 0.03363151103258133, 0.020076794549822807, -0.08256247639656067, 0.010184455662965775, -0.019556038081645966, 0.002780978102236986, -0.008254662156105042, -0.015383940190076828, 0.008473611436784267, 0.015328556299209595, 0.03269262611865997, -0.023152481764554977, 0.06067749857902527, 0.015532877296209335, 0.0026776441372931004, 0.007301421370357275, -0.019390318542718887, 0.009222191758453846, 0.005262040998786688, -0.004565073177218437, 0.021545587107539177, 0.022813044488430023, 0.00048035531654022634, -0.034260671585798264, 0.0008093264768831432, -0.020576683804392815, -0.04328331723809242, 0.007120105903595686, -0.007282838691025972, 0.039408162236213684, -0.0647188127040863, -0.009229945950210094, -0.004151585977524519, 0.00411219010129571, 0.04678763449192047, 0.031010398641228676, -0.03442058712244034, 0.037495020776987076, 0.010039826855063438, -0.04722808673977852, -0.043639637529850006, -0.015620412304997444, -0.03212939575314522, -0.04144897684454918, 0.002068182220682502, -0.01861656829714775, -0.01555869821459055, -0.027647316455841064, 0.0012518397998064756, -0.02442995086312294, 0.03378699719905853, -0.017804253846406937, -0.0275571271777153, 0.0048802741803228855, -0.01578928902745247, 0.022890979424118996, -0.10207979381084442, 0.05759058892726898, -0.015137380920350552, -0.05765484645962715, -0.025132033973932266, 0.002896857215091586, -0.035339564085006714, 0.017090540379285812, 0.0746399387717247, 0.029224881902337074, 0.005266327876597643, -0.002672355156391859, 0.016081595793366432, -0.0059105404652655125, -0.05835651978850365, 0.04555340111255646, 0.01954740472137928, 0.00035834164009429514, 0.01922844909131527, -0.00538228265941143, -0.0014303396455943584, 0.02802923507988453, 0.03549567610025406, -0.0003939371381420642, 0.0399978831410408, 0.042732734233140945, 0.004702806938439608, 0.01738503947854042, -0.017289379611611366, -0.04150907322764397, 0.05956137552857399, -0.018430599942803383, 0.010541753843426704, 0.0536012277007103, -0.015264571644365788, -0.048106599599123, 0.020818864926695824, -0.026828235015273094, 0.011078676208853722, 0.024736328050494194, -0.016200708225369453, 0.0046620238572359085, -0.11164184659719467, 0.001725957845337689, -0.01767837256193161, -0.011522289365530014, 0.01012517511844635, 0.04498392716050148, 0.007443909998983145, 0.0100884223356843, -0.018721260130405426, 0.044890809804201126, -0.00838589109480381, -0.037402309477329254, 0.02971458248794079, 0.022226985543966293, 0.021656403318047523, -0.020689938217401505, 0.02757611870765686, -0.008692833594977856, -0.03371359780430794, 0.023795323446393013, 0.001263073063455522, 0.004485501442104578, 0.01814955659210682, -0.012197167612612247, 0.038657017052173615, -0.001406226772814989, -0.0498165637254715, 0.025189267471432686, -0.025109199807047844, 0.05338236689567566, -0.04014301672577858, 0.0010721224825829268, -0.04022460803389549, -0.0084327207878232, -0.026074472814798355, 0.016781220212578773, -0.0245963241904974, 0.014369475655257702, 0.04678281769156456, 0.029985757544636726, 0.021668046712875366, -0.01119300164282322, -0.049446675926446915, -0.015025806613266468, 0.043101415038108826, 0.013835988938808441, -0.008328179828822613, 0.001538578188046813, -0.053439054638147354, -0.03773495927453041, -0.015713877975940704, 0.03656725212931633, 0.02051195316016674, 0.01170252077281475, -0.01691877283155918, -0.03491067886352539, 0.029786119237542152, 0.03499152511358261, -0.06449072062969208, -0.009346507489681244, 0.002539426553994417, 0.0022138578351587057, 0.031881436705589294, -0.04636606201529503 ]
<p>[I'm a stats noob, so please correct if I am going wrong somewhere!]</p> <p>We run a survey of our customers based on certain events or touchpoints. The responses vary significantly by these touchpoints, so I would like to weight the responses by post stratification.</p> <p>However, I have no responses from customers who didn't have an "event", and these customers make up more than 60% of the portfolio population! Is there a workaround to this problem - how do I accommodate for non-sampled segments in my analysis? Is imputation a possible solution?</p> <p>For example:</p> <p>Let us assume - we are a telephony services provider, and we survey our customers to find out how satisfied they are with certain elements of our service. We have oversampled customers with "dropped calls", because that is more of a "problem area". In addition, we randomly survey some customers who have 3G connections but do not have a dropped call.</p> <p>Let's add some numbers to this - 1000 customers, 600 with 3G, 400 without. Of these, 100 customers with 3G have a dropped call, and 100 customers without 3G have a dropped call.</p> <p>In our survey, let us assume we have responses from 150 customers - 50 with 3G and a dropped call, 50 with 3G and no dropped call, and 50 without 3G and dropped calls. If we wanted to understand how satisfied the portfolio of customers is, we could stratify the responses with the following weights:</p> <pre><code>Customers with 3G and Dropped call (100/1000)/(50/150) = 0.3 Customers with 3G and no Dropped call - ((600-100)/1000)/(50/150) = 1.5 Customers without 3G and Dropped call - (100/1000)/(50/150) = 0.3 Customers without 3G and no Dropped call - ???? </code></pre> <p>If we do not have responses from this segment, how would we extrapolate the survey to understand the portfolio's satisfaction?</p> <p>The only thing I can think of is imputing responses from a few customers based on the responses from the other 3 segments - maybe there is a baseline response for a customer, given certain predictor variables, and the presence/absence of 3G and dropped calls will change that response for a given customer? This is an extremely vague idea and I am worried about adding responses to my survey which are "made up"!</p> <p>Please help! Thanks!</p>
73,567
[ -0.03528797626495361, -0.01009533554315567, 0.021655132994055748, -0.026224598288536072, 0.03845004364848137, 0.007071744650602341, -0.009322840720415115, -0.05291050300002098, 0.02208397537469864, -0.010634281672537327, 0.03057074546813965, 0.029836667701601982, 0.03261689469218254, -0.007810231298208237, -0.009951122105121613, 0.007302028127014637, -0.010816526599228382, 0.006095412652939558, 0.0016229248140007257, -0.029097190126776695, -0.01889514923095703, 0.030133558437228203, 0.009024355560541153, -0.016149522736668587, -0.05585314333438873, 0.007694851607084274, 0.037288106977939606, -0.03789345547556877, 0.003270005341619253, 0.01877521723508835, -0.04898356273770332, 0.00714474031701684, 0.03114597499370575, 0.04236629605293274, 0.02413553185760975, 0.05081229284405708, -0.023764220997691154, -0.0114661930128932, -0.041981469839811325, 0.008238375186920166, -0.00901640672236681, 0.05693630874156952, 0.006501347292214632, -0.014475692063570023, 0.004946981091052294, -0.011680486612021923, -0.029047155752778053, -0.027081038802862167, 0.016569407656788826, -0.04530039802193642, 0.04972865805029869, -0.023017002269625664, -0.01914270780980587, -0.0010872340062633157, -0.025064364075660706, -0.03511565178632736, 0.060368653386831284, 0.053851544857025146, 0.011414390057325363, -0.03276936337351799, 0.009626789949834347, -0.0070608314126729965, 0.0016027626115828753, -0.02172144688665867, -0.011557001620531082, 0.03955022245645523, 0.011263296008110046, -0.028382621705532074, 0.05815316364169121, -0.045512016862630844, 0.017992883920669556, -0.01195116899907589, 0.024211710318922997, 0.02375844679772854, 0.017937736585736275, -0.04264312610030174, -0.022416483610868454, 0.021321339532732964, 0.0536690354347229, 0.02645927667617798, -0.014236174523830414, 0.018338507041335106, 0.015185588970780373, 0.04248658940196037, 0.027265023440122604, -0.013210107572376728, 0.07240238785743713, -0.04738342761993408, 0.019034162163734436, 0.01589258387684822, -0.0145217040553689, -0.03937869518995285, 0.01389220729470253, -0.002352086827158928, -0.028390079736709595, 0.018435686826705933, -0.007705880329012871, 0.031134115532040596, -0.011401395313441753, 0.0018130355747416615, -0.01622620038688183, -0.020258557051420212, 0.009279636666178703, 0.05946440249681473, -0.016442537307739258, 0.027227947488427162, -0.019970424473285675, -0.014138545840978622, -0.044040579348802567, -0.0036197227891534567, -0.010456870310008526, 0.0012838027905672789, -0.019803611561655998, -0.029163546860218048, 0.0018972144462168217, 0.007141735404729843, 0.011734030209481716, -0.016605284065008163, 0.05335844308137894, 0.08617671579122543, 0.0406961590051651, -0.018189743161201477, 0.011205732822418213, -0.03686416149139404, -0.08062879741191864, -0.01810641586780548, 0.010588470846414566, 0.015314234420657158, -0.02791896089911461, 0.022502020001411438, -0.019126247614622116, 0.0026250621303915977, 0.05199937894940376, -0.011563306674361229, 0.011904541403055191, -0.008828961290419102, -0.08084511011838913, -0.04530908912420273, -0.00013760571891907603, -0.015837958082556725, 0.002902035601437092, -0.024647949263453484, -0.01915249414741993, 0.04962204024195671, 0.026001418009400368, 0.0352986641228199, 0.05438843369483948, 0.040405407547950745, 0.012770771980285645, 0.04458756744861603, 0.00014979364641476423, -0.010529101826250553, -0.06023115664720535, 0.028557756915688515, -0.02271891012787819, -0.0344788134098053, 0.027261795476078987, 0.026106391102075577, -0.00886584259569645, -0.005352029111236334, -0.016685515642166138, 0.03366340696811676, -0.07122686505317688, -0.02820778079330921, 0.011001992039382458, -0.02451162599027157, 0.07461346685886383, -0.004666291642934084, 0.02012048102915287, -0.009058335795998573, -0.0009958172449842095, 0.023547906428575516, 0.01237673033028841, 0.013274649158120155, 0.020122848451137543, -0.034485768526792526, 0.0038344613276422024, -0.01818872056901455, 0.028904054313898087, 0.020967168733477592, -0.026464149355888367, -0.03763183206319809, -0.015299035236239433, 0.034130968153476715, -0.008861244656145573, -0.012708636000752449, 0.023540819063782692, -0.03161157667636871, 0.0899341031908989, -0.05431418865919113, -0.06806518882513046, -0.00037896487629041076, -0.01264082919806242, 0.02286725491285324, -0.006488283630460501, -0.012010075151920319, -0.016820775344967842, -0.021530257537961006, -0.005924877244979143, -0.030612746253609657, 0.029722949489951134, -0.00926422979682684, 0.09647490829229355, -0.019726278260350227, -0.017628034576773643, 0.05600767582654953, 0.01556147076189518, -0.015433583408594131, 0.015927201136946678, -0.017714034765958786, -0.027795370668172836, -0.029500693082809448, -0.047740016132593155, 0.005624627228826284, -0.011656644754111767, -0.01570182293653488, 0.0070328074507415295, 0.00446336530148983, -0.014545677229762077, 0.0292038656771183, -0.06144361570477486, 0.0751357153058052, 0.0827980563044548, -0.01916973665356636, -0.011906092055141926, -0.0011990974890068173, -0.02248266339302063, 0.03964050114154816, -0.02561006508767605, 0.034132055938243866, -0.04858354479074478, -0.02428414486348629, 0.04461684823036194, -0.020027298480272293, -0.024318695068359375, -0.04623319208621979, 0.0724833533167839, 0.0027289462741464376, 0.00834279228001833, 0.042364008724689484, 0.0323362834751606, -0.019658442586660385, 0.02937178686261177, -0.015546070411801338, 0.02739953249692917, -0.01184555422514677, -0.004466131329536438, -0.014742924831807613, -0.014692209661006927, -0.012207544408738613, 0.01974474824965, 0.0127588314935565, 0.026794489473104477, -0.0089179128408432, -0.020113008096814156, -0.0005304686492308974, 0.02634422294795513, -0.024187419563531876, 0.03579004108905792, 0.027339482679963112, -0.01911051757633686, 0.00867233145982027, 0.01984710991382599, -0.01872500218451023, 0.0050710649229586124, 0.0020068178419023752, -0.01921040751039982, 0.017038483172655106, 0.017629845067858696, -0.03633942827582359, 0.002357763471081853, -0.0021322534885257483, -0.03773071989417076, -0.040178049355745316, 0.029426002874970436, 0.06710624694824219, 0.008086776360869408, 0.02613326907157898, -0.04496406018733978, -0.030844470486044884, -0.02333463728427887, 0.05444256216287613, 0.014929745346307755, 0.039153728634119034, -0.048578474670648575, 0.003133416874334216, 0.02331077866256237, -0.009550959803164005, 0.001132866833359003, -0.003402301110327244, -0.017524635419249535, 0.03578466922044754, 0.00038195058004930615, -0.03579695150256157, 0.01127526257187128, -0.0009385200100950897, 0.0317360945045948, -0.027141889557242393, -0.013972412794828415, 0.09347956627607346, 0.05700451135635376, -0.07308509200811386, 0.011653373949229717, -0.04210205376148224, -0.02728419005870819, -0.04011079668998718, -0.02278996631503105, -0.009493035264313221, -0.06135832518339157, 0.010919603519141674, 0.00822684820741415, 0.003053374122828245, 0.0008693745476193726, -0.0619429387152195, -0.05539356544613838, -0.005150653887540102, -0.025938604027032852, 0.05029233545064926, 0.014235196635127068, -0.004570785444229841, 0.1032445877790451, 0.036795977503061295, -0.027027718722820282, 0.0113607719540596, -0.009324936196208, -0.006840729154646397, -0.011901778168976307, 0.019488127902150154, 0.00464449031278491, 0.017837464809417725, -0.014406343922019005, -0.007812293246388435, 0.047202710062265396, 0.05794038996100426, 0.04561106860637665, 0.03446011245250702, 0.017742326483130455, -0.024521948769688606, 0.003979158587753773, 0.07719606906175613, 0.026186568662524223, -0.04824163392186165, -0.007336451672017574, -0.023179396986961365, 0.030199604108929634, 0.03126007691025734, -0.060981571674346924, -0.028720561414957047, -0.01491086557507515, 0.0012899297289550304, -0.02531418204307556, 0.049495358020067215, 0.028302863240242004, -0.03516961634159088, -0.02559712529182434, -0.008913522586226463, 0.05621875450015068, -0.02135448344051838, -0.007719187997281551, 0.07737386971712112, 0.0455610565841198, -0.025769362226128578, -0.04169634357094765, 0.002281050430610776, -0.020476264879107475, 0.03604285418987274, -0.03500048443675041, -0.0287230983376503, 0.014249316416680813, 0.06643247604370117, 0.010993557050824165, -0.03292335197329521, -0.031759459525346756, 0.01202905923128128, -0.03834578022360802, 0.012847310863435268, -0.031300775706768036, 0.06713169813156128, -0.011832763440907001, 0.05697105824947357, 0.015441443771123886, 0.0042009917087852955, -0.008312377147376537, 0.01580343022942543, -0.07382898777723312, 0.017212849110364914, 0.019370531663298607, -0.04164073243737221, 0.012103643268346786, -0.03524798899888992, 0.03497691452503204, -0.005164753179997206, -0.004996178671717644, -0.016041601076722145, 0.03909954056143761, -0.043936651200056076, 0.03566356748342514, -0.011518096551299095, 0.032055795192718506, 0.024455025792121887, 0.013084548525512218, 0.028911691159009933, 0.02054750733077526, 0.045528050512075424, 0.02512781135737896, 0.006020377390086651, -0.03634202480316162, 0.003264286322519183, 0.0009854919044300914, -0.006395898759365082, 0.06159362569451332, 0.02402988076210022, 0.06279435753822327, -0.008873054757714272, 0.026708872988820076, 0.01202479749917984, 0.01660050079226494, 0.03364068642258644, -0.0264026690274477, 0.006415317300707102, -0.03511343523859978, -0.06976709514856339, -0.00393254728987813, -0.0029266388155519962, 0.011079675517976284, -0.0437028668820858, 0.023007765412330627, -0.0022344286553561687, -0.02611517906188965, -0.003228292101994157, 0.01672452688217163, 0.030927764251828194, -0.026319380849599838, -0.03970475494861603, 0.031837545335292816, 0.004216027446091175, 0.0016470414120703936, 0.03216072916984558, 0.040302567183971405, 0.012773408554494381, -0.007707733660936356, 0.03836647793650627, 0.00041936853085644543, -0.0394258052110672, 0.006253255531191826, 0.045552823692560196, -0.003161009168252349, 0.01983187161386013, -0.05347096174955368, 0.060662295669317245, 0.0019790097139775753, 0.019955184310674667, 0.05277086794376373, 0.003232051385566592, -0.1073218584060669, -0.026452502235770226, 0.04226033762097359, 0.019388817250728607, -0.01351045910269022, -0.0043906779028475285, -0.026853354647755623, 0.03198561817407608, -0.026989461854100227, -0.03168546035885811, -0.012210463173687458, -0.031347449868917465, 0.036172445863485336, -0.012229527346789837, -0.036093853414058685, -0.026572810485959053, 0.029512843117117882, -0.032014328986406326, 0.0013184422859922051, -0.01750539243221283, -0.04914532229304314, -0.007307516876608133, 0.017630232498049736, 0.04190053790807724, 0.0792795717716217, -0.01782286912202835, 0.009615426883101463, 0.00022283438011072576, 0.030918750911951065, -0.01522127352654934, -0.06564663350582123, 0.004882503766566515, 0.0015336796641349792, 0.005046599544584751, 0.053557056933641434, -0.015391511842608452, -0.028608810156583786, 0.057452891021966934, 0.04404781013727188, -0.02880978398025036, 0.02088339254260063, -0.03565770387649536, 0.034951116889715195, 0.013655790127813816, 0.025330904871225357, 0.037323493510484695, 0.017636291682720184, 0.017102349549531937, 0.031481415033340454, -0.029607219621539116, -0.015895769000053406, -0.03436103090643883, -0.004741862881928682, -0.0009114390704780817, -0.0220038965344429, -0.01345414575189352, 0.0005536448443308473, 0.03660881146788597, 0.0322117879986763, 0.011491531506180763, -0.03163902461528778, 0.011057304218411446, -0.009898029267787933, -0.0015667857369408011, 0.03511631116271019, -0.025933900848031044, -0.0019509237026795745, 0.01610472798347473, 0.0161002054810524, 0.01588374935090542, -0.022707710042595863, -0.0026931599713861942, 0.025775494053959846, -0.05773600935935974, -0.02287723496556282, -0.04309000447392464, 0.0007594730122946203, 0.014910237863659859, 0.015864232555031776, 0.026401061564683914, -0.00588449090719223, 0.07704587280750275, -0.006610198877751827, 0.015426162630319595, -0.0049752951599657536, -0.013350301422178745, 0.012937153689563274, 0.02057480812072754, -0.03492724150419235, 0.01940660923719406, 0.0032659845892339945, -0.004599868319928646, -0.06172584369778633, -0.0479448065161705, 0.04096116125583649, 0.0264535341411829, -0.04238908365368843, -0.026129040867090225, -0.012515587732195854, 0.016983825713396072, -0.03755153343081474, 0.021208439022302628, 0.018890343606472015, 0.008860011585056782, -0.004756577778607607, 0.005170781631022692, 0.028737599030137062, 0.09098245203495026, -0.03898227959871292, -0.006229231134057045, 0.020574510097503662, -0.01147543452680111, -0.003715894650667906, 0.0010337934363633394, -0.0015385113656520844, -0.021659310907125473, -0.05348886176943779, -0.007512524724006653, -0.0135319409891963, 0.0319000743329525, -0.049309100955724716, -0.03717070445418358, -0.02650526352226734, -0.005242284387350082, 0.00964516494423151, -0.02627989836037159, 0.000788786041084677, -0.0067028081975877285, -0.001206416287459433, -0.04228426516056061, -0.006141221150755882, -0.024462658911943436, 0.0389220267534256, 0.0012731639435514808, 0.008993967436254025, -0.030883248895406723, 0.000033691234420984983, 0.048789478838443756, 0.01999128982424736, -0.015271113254129887, 0.011087787337601185, -0.02090911567211151, 0.055907897651195526, -0.022948427125811577, -0.025170011445879936, -0.010782137513160706, 0.049090951681137085, -0.015290148556232452, -0.013929363340139389, -0.046385087072849274, -0.006433088332414627, 0.04743984341621399, 0.021538328379392624, 0.059948261827230453, 0.027678262442350388, -0.005314727313816547, 0.0009106525685638189, -0.02266586758196354, -0.0036376884672790766, 0.013237315230071545, -0.016991855576634407, -0.0017946623265743256, 0.015468495897948742, 0.035264063626527786, 0.02076362445950508, -0.0007161497487686574, 0.018312500789761543, 0.022918440401554108, -0.010483699850738049, 0.024579156190156937, 0.03339914605021477, -0.0650167241692543, -0.02655639685690403, -0.010218010284006596, -0.04933340474963188, -0.01564973033964634, -0.031677037477493286, -0.03283661603927612, 0.034438904374837875, 0.02518690750002861, -0.018233560025691986, -0.017763003706932068, 0.022275755181908607, -0.1037871390581131, -0.027001071721315384, 0.013865293003618717, 0.029464779421687126, 0.040828246623277664, -0.0031308799516409636, 0.06564439833164215, -0.02919415757060051, 0.036384113132953644, -0.0015680331271141768, -0.07076878845691681, -0.06662962585687637, -0.02043772116303444, -0.06871668249368668, 0.015397888608276844, -0.006797655485570431, -0.011105399578809738, 0.011670256964862347, -0.03885823115706444, 0.057831790298223495, 0.014790352433919907, 0.023717714473605156, -0.03435199335217476, 0.07952724397182465, 0.023659002035856247, 0.05983423441648483, -0.012364260852336884, -0.0047675385139882565, 0.14430442452430725, 0.07729017734527588, 0.06137988716363907, -0.04982440918684006, 0.03057955950498581, 0.012069229036569595, 0.022997688502073288, -0.049270302057266235, 0.0012078718282282352, -0.009021111764013767, -0.008141104131937027, 0.02874929830431938, 0.01433646958321333, -0.0038413344882428646, -0.019374283030629158, 0.05299387127161026, -0.014606107026338577, -0.014713921584188938, 0.004604893270879984, 0.024368125945329666, 0.03236721456050873, -0.025695379823446274, -0.0842931717634201, 0.02457696758210659, 0.02369123324751854, -0.018055018037557602, -0.02217002585530281, -0.025435831397771835, -0.00796732772141695, -0.019549552351236343, -0.012723369523882866, 0.0016008199891075492, 0.0339452363550663, 0.009725463576614857, 0.029243284836411476, -0.029857700690627098, 0.0003689727163873613, -0.049532778561115265, -0.01852378435432911, 0.027996832504868507, -0.008920437656342983, -0.029462406411767006, -0.013991599902510643, 0.06677837669849396, -0.06430820375680923, -0.02259542979300022, -0.028491491451859474, 0.025325831025838852, -0.011067391373217106, -0.02796364016830921, -0.02110825851559639, -0.001352213672362268, 0.0005365562974475324, -0.022440999746322632, -0.006968196947127581, 0.029364407062530518, -0.007260881830006838, -0.023536130785942078, -0.04482932388782501, 0.03372126817703247, -0.019346507266163826, -0.0034342461731284857, 0.008361462503671646, 0.010599547065794468, 0.003483029082417488, -0.037729304283857346, -0.00151881854981184, 0.024029167369008064, -0.014571819454431534, 0.0046121058985590935, 0.033335380256175995, -0.002722741337493062, -0.016746873036026955, -0.03292601928114891, 0.0009950995445251465, 0.01655297726392746, 0.03883678466081619, -0.009798465296626091, -0.005370949395000935, -0.020022764801979065, -0.002483784221112728, 0.007223771885037422, -0.036834485828876495, -0.029955463483929634, -0.04579237475991249, 0.017189903184771538, -0.045785773545503616, 0.03968024253845215, 0.046854544430971146, -0.010846895165741444, -0.00016268837498500943, 0.08197175711393356, -0.008045630529522896, -0.024190982803702354, -0.03134719282388687, 0.0019956985488533974, -0.06631125509738922, 0.019019559025764465, 0.03728650510311127, 0.07413959503173828, 0.012020968832075596, 0.013078246265649796, -0.0260174423456192, 0.007503809407353401, 0.015268790535628796, -0.014275896362960339, -0.012470132671296597, -0.04668273776769638, 0.007276346907019615, 0.005798002704977989, 0.021101923659443855, -0.04376646503806114, -0.006207671016454697, -0.004678627476096153, -0.004123569931834936, 0.02076956257224083, 0.017715707421302795, -0.03105858527123928, 0.024397211149334908, -0.021196644753217697, 0.014248830266296864, -0.02436869591474533, 0.007483471184968948, -0.005983573384582996, -0.03768572211265564, -0.0684145912528038, -0.02832888625562191, 0.010419299826025963, -0.03936484456062317, -0.04533388838171959, -0.00011543431173777208, 0.014091999270021915, -0.01038515754044056, 0.001453771605156362, 0.011103961616754532, 0.020413359627127647, -0.009994463063776493, 0.0018800218822434545, -0.007409900892525911, 0.04831256717443466, 0.04623561352491379, -0.04802500084042549, -0.0076987724751234055, 0.008588576689362526, -0.003713340265676379, 0.0770673155784607, 0.027358677238225937, -0.019822806119918823, -0.0023294587153941393, 0.034543074667453766, -0.018184751272201538, -0.046704161912202835, -0.016963116824626923, 0.036774855107069016, 0.03601297736167908, 0.010647059418261051, -0.01501868013292551, 0.004565835930407047, 0.014998799189925194, -0.018875285983085632, 0.04675579443573952, -0.010088718496263027, -0.00803964864462614, 0.009419632144272327, -0.01280168816447258, 0.01957409642636776, -0.018094247207045555, 0.01272723451256752, 0.013110815547406673, 0.04103900119662285, -0.024153832346200943, 0.007236692123115063, -0.01946914568543434, 0.00864886399358511, -0.04160503298044205, -0.04103629291057587, 0.03054036945104599, -0.023968642577528954, 0.045487649738788605, -0.02866317518055439, 0.034324876964092255, 0.011757698841392994, -0.053218450397253036, 0.044724058359861374, 0.016290808096528053, 0.016618957743048668, -0.02351989410817623, 0.028841331601142883, -0.02804289385676384, -0.020448941737413406, 0.021217426285147667, 0.01015156414359808, -0.012587125413119793, 0.025023972615599632, -0.00785303395241499, 0.003682888811454177, -0.03785400092601776, -0.00718600582331419, -0.009629416279494762, -0.024063553661108017, 0.019110651686787605, -0.03135022148489952, 0.022617418318986893, 0.03135727718472481, -0.009209961630403996, 0.02398528903722763, 0.01994469203054905, 0.01880832016468048, 0.008453382179141045, 0.02201448567211628, 0.02669498138129711, 0.0033225943334400654, 0.019369611516594887, 0.008269297890365124, 0.021392859518527985, 0.021206334233283997, -0.003808478359133005, 0.0438634492456913, 0.06789247691631317, -0.004727264866232872, 0.02351607382297516, 0.012717503122985363, -0.042770177125930786, -0.005264744162559509, 0.0034233247861266136, -0.017411889508366585, -0.004018150735646486, -0.01528685912489891, -0.007276292424649, -0.020962152630090714, 0.0014269622042775154, 0.033727459609508514, 0.0014644410694018006, -0.02028392069041729, -0.029597410932183266, -0.029820991680026054, -0.05107031390070915, 0.020275335758924484, -0.024124709889292717, -0.02422032691538334, -0.035878986120224, -0.018600262701511383, -0.008216321468353271, 0.021382464095950127, -0.015051492489874363, 0.0035137163940817118, -0.020271286368370056, 0.09351322054862976, -0.018227919936180115, -0.017921920865774155, 0.02376401610672474, -0.005037195049226284, 0.03343086317181587, -0.10035938024520874, 0.054139893501996994, 0.008717375807464123, -0.011789637617766857, -0.028240730985999107, -0.03625856712460518, -0.037300955504179, 0.047052882611751556, 0.06303315609693527, -0.009106487035751343, -0.008715630508959293, -0.011700727045536041, 0.022593911737203598, -0.00468643382191658, -0.04620179906487465, 0.0382176898419857, 0.016932867467403412, -0.003774830373004079, -0.02145947329699993, 0.0003997476596850902, 0.00872268620878458, -0.003574047004804015, -0.008431665599346161, -0.005947379395365715, 0.026410482823848724, -0.03124459646642208, 0.006799263879656792, 0.034469906240701675, -0.00475164083763957, 0.0033461295533925295, 0.020770616829395294, -0.007529275957494974, -0.027347881346940994, 0.014541621319949627, 0.0014768526889383793, -0.08210358023643494, 0.040663089603185654, -0.029010478407144547, 0.005611531902104616, 0.0031340692657977343, 0.02675207145512104, 0.030317138880491257, -0.041137222200632095, -0.010521583259105682, 0.010116427205502987, -0.027727514505386353, -0.0076351165771484375, 0.06042192503809929, 0.018587101250886917, -0.0043904441408813, -0.002300738589838147, -0.01002143882215023, 0.000018059605281450786, -0.038872942328453064, 0.04781670495867729, -0.014946871437132359, 0.01647147536277771, 0.0141000896692276, 0.023890187963843346, 0.01568836346268654, 0.007616168353706598, 0.014287940226495266, -0.007809588219970465, 0.012776529416441917, -0.044243428856134415, -0.027593644335865974, 0.033827971667051315, 0.03413751348853111, -0.004364791791886091, 0.0387142114341259, 0.010604065842926502, 0.04523344710469246, -0.017055651172995567, 0.016246628016233444, -0.04425980523228645, -0.010571811348199844, 0.004961782600730658, 0.001123437425121665, -0.010277574881911278, 0.03624030202627182, -0.0026062345132231712, -0.0010418150341138244, -0.009643049910664558, 0.0053125726990401745, -0.008540800772607327, -0.009039348922669888, 0.015948854386806488, -0.02978247031569481, 0.020202428102493286, -0.017103275284171104, -0.08132680505514145, -0.01858089119195938, 0.030613461509346962, -0.0019311219220981002, 0.024762505665421486, 0.027946650981903076, -0.007128047291189432, -0.01616641692817211, -0.02967950515449047, 0.03321133926510811, -0.021765606477856636, -0.009762455709278584, -0.06693021208047867, 0.013081192970275879, 0.01693929359316826, 0.004029837902635336 ]
<p>I'm currently trying to use Newey-West standard errors accounting for Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation with the sandwich package in R, but i lack understanding as i can not fully grasp the instructions provided in the manual.</p> <pre><code>library(sandwich) ## fit investment equation data(Investment) fm &lt;- lm(RealInv ~ RealGNP + RealInt, data = Investment) summary(fm) ## Newey &amp; West (1994) (Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelationconsistent; HAC) ## Covariance Matrix Estimation NeweyWest(fm) ## The Newey &amp; West (1987) estimator requires specification ## of the lag and suppression of prewhitening NeweyWest(fm, lag = 4, prewhite = FALSE) </code></pre> <p>Unfortunately that's all the information the authors provide. I understand that it is only the estimated HAC Variance-Covariance Matrix but how do you proceed from there to obtain valid standard errors and t-statistics? And is my assumption correct that if you don't specify the lag, the bwNeweyWest function automatically selects the number of relevant lags? </p>
73,568
[ 0.0022104503586888313, -0.00489571038633585, 0.0008020405075512826, 0.0335470587015152, 0.06458283960819244, 0.0004626918525900692, -0.017878295853734016, 0.0033222620841115713, 0.017392363399267197, -0.019824689254164696, 0.010230250656604767, 0.018959736451506615, 0.03689342737197876, 0.018053049221634865, 0.006237995810806751, -0.008466786704957485, 0.004256576299667358, -0.015002114698290825, 0.024657227098941803, -0.005597039591521025, 0.014650905504822731, -0.0010706515749916434, -0.020616859197616577, -0.014029781334102154, -0.016803758218884468, 0.006951955147087574, 0.011955749243497849, 0.01747254654765129, 0.010707312263548374, 0.043213870376348495, -0.049634408205747604, -0.0297348964959383, 0.017994726076722145, 0.0031903896015137434, -0.013746128417551517, 0.03176557272672653, -0.014414304867386818, -0.06747472286224365, 0.012149550952017307, 0.0335431732237339, -0.015508782118558884, 0.017693256959319115, -0.011440522037446499, 0.04061209410429001, -0.01354891899973154, 0.013409191742539406, -0.007869094610214233, -0.0495171844959259, 0.015081552788615227, -0.0073198298923671246, 0.07786815613508224, 0.022366484627127647, 0.01814674213528633, 0.02886601723730564, -0.0019317902624607086, 0.016359400004148483, 0.07737240195274353, 0.01808551885187626, -0.002989936387166381, -0.029617518186569214, -0.037006258964538574, -0.026232875883579254, 0.0015304496046155691, -0.03646669536828995, -0.009882980957627296, 0.005524818319827318, -0.015740755945444107, -0.04235905781388283, 0.04549504816532135, -0.045164573937654495, 0.019110262393951416, -0.004640723578631878, 0.015370100736618042, -0.013728455640375614, 0.020074883475899696, -0.034658532589673996, -0.0071841273456811905, 0.023256618529558182, 0.027796871960163116, 0.05318259447813034, 0.0044629937037825584, 0.001178864506073296, 0.0007042071665637195, 0.05449221283197403, 0.032861411571502686, 0.00632347259670496, 0.05365775525569916, -0.028796028345823288, 0.028487099334597588, 0.024021226912736893, -0.013655769638717175, 0.02206156961619854, 0.04621109366416931, 0.04537888988852501, -0.009614660404622555, 0.037386782467365265, -0.033903662115335464, 0.0525142140686512, -0.007669597864151001, -0.04273046553134918, -0.01953141763806343, -0.04511594399809837, 0.02987872250378132, 0.02081046812236309, -0.009842806495726109, -0.009054221212863922, -0.010374102741479874, -0.00027349372976459563, -0.020052917301654816, -0.057563457638025284, -0.03213592618703842, -0.007953327149152756, -0.062030479311943054, 0.005806232336908579, 0.025705205276608467, -0.013494395650923252, -0.009834351018071175, 0.037036698311567307, 0.04850974306464195, 0.06681113690137863, 0.06724809110164642, 0.019182080402970314, 0.041892848908901215, -0.026571674272418022, -0.08741391450166702, 0.04673365131020546, 0.010295280255377293, -0.028448380529880524, -0.023128889501094818, 0.06770510226488113, 0.014940999448299408, -0.04152694717049599, 0.014735916629433632, 0.004088840913027525, 0.049216192215681076, 0.013101743534207344, -0.10584408044815063, -0.07742877304553986, 0.016764070838689804, 0.002014854457229376, 0.012647117488086224, -0.08171124756336212, 0.00038998384843580425, -0.027361582964658737, 0.06626173108816147, -0.012500042095780373, 0.03547234833240509, 0.04485457390546799, 0.02047150209546089, 0.0018170702969655395, -0.081135094165802, -0.018146006390452385, -0.027069823816418648, -0.020655790343880653, -0.04143051430583, -0.10712695866823196, 0.011495476588606834, -0.00013726619363296777, -0.009530442766845226, -0.0004686464089900255, 0.05262700468301773, 0.008188572712242603, -0.020965903997421265, -0.0002441248798277229, -0.022392481565475464, -0.027953533455729485, 0.0599018931388855, -0.015291653573513031, -0.017451269552111626, 0.004828413482755423, -0.039689697325229645, -0.01056019775569439, -0.030457235872745514, 0.05457981303334236, 0.028454657644033432, -0.017297403886914253, 0.023678133264183998, 0.0023210812360048294, -0.00021175999427214265, 0.008389047347009182, -0.02709878422319889, -0.019581548869609833, 0.0027832682244479656, -0.007754113059490919, -0.008645602501928806, 0.04906051978468895, 0.00973754096776247, 0.013413315638899803, 0.03301281854510307, -0.05824713781476021, -0.06739156693220139, -0.07366514950990677, -0.016904063522815704, 0.010206959210336208, -0.005221232306212187, 0.025595469400286674, -0.02642412669956684, 0.008020388893783092, 0.006328098475933075, 0.001882807002402842, -0.021156443282961845, 0.04579131305217743, 0.04328034445643425, -0.018727704882621765, 0.00607089651748538, 0.03700440376996994, 0.07555869221687317, 0.0031073216814547777, 0.040844984352588654, -0.025860261172056198, -0.015436049550771713, 0.02834603190422058, -0.0382879264652729, 0.045167598873376846, -0.0013909307308495045, -0.02645675279200077, 0.026126233860850334, -0.012722776271402836, 0.01579204387962818, 0.041093550622463226, -0.05357144773006439, 0.022474557161331177, 0.07013767212629318, 0.03294915333390236, 0.008669584058225155, 0.029569681733846664, -0.005443345755338669, 0.02348121628165245, -0.050848741084337234, 0.008644157089293003, -0.04070419818162918, -0.00010276908869855106, 0.06036146357655525, -0.014118259772658348, -0.03392450138926506, 0.019037703052163124, 0.04817519709467888, -0.005265496205538511, 0.030490120872855186, 0.03812352940440178, 0.005120743997395039, -0.020567093044519424, 0.01376947108656168, 0.014832931570708752, 0.03841741755604744, 0.006479350849986076, -0.01944633759558201, 0.03158588334918022, 0.05371936038136482, 0.03346365690231323, -0.011596687138080597, 0.07019569724798203, 0.018398765474557877, -0.03189995139837265, -0.009065472520887852, -0.021475672721862793, 0.028788527473807335, -0.0018258383497595787, 0.0282145868986845, 0.03393005579710007, 0.05409761145710945, -0.015205965377390385, 0.003935520071536303, -0.011606534011662006, 0.0041176509112119675, 0.018535055220127106, -0.002187450183555484, 0.020978515967726707, -0.004187153652310371, -0.030863981693983078, 0.052215397357940674, -0.05733851343393326, -0.0004602707049343735, -0.05320586636662483, -0.0016787238419055939, -0.007115156855434179, 0.02645680122077465, 0.06926558166742325, -0.02877289243042469, -0.021811824291944504, 0.01854037307202816, -0.001306965365074575, 0.0395125150680542, -0.0028646509163081646, -0.03454134985804558, 0.01139639038592577, -0.04385942593216896, -0.0038809524849057198, 0.02460174635052681, 0.0019293647492304444, -0.011824111454188824, 0.04483531787991524, -0.0029614497907459736, -0.03342758119106293, -0.020001869648694992, 0.005358665715903044, -0.006470587570220232, -0.025987893342971802, -0.018342511728405952, 0.04538499936461449, -0.017362510785460472, 0.009728704579174519, 0.034607622772455215, -0.06088186800479889, 0.0030004396103322506, -0.020680783316493034, -0.024623224511742592, -0.050975218415260315, -0.016198940575122833, -0.015582358464598656, 0.020529672503471375, -0.031398408114910126, -0.005939556751400232, -0.042366404086351395, -0.06475094705820084, -0.002621806226670742, 0.02829185128211975, 0.011515173129737377, -0.02014545165002346, -0.03218475356698036, 0.055351272225379944, 0.01663960888981819, -0.017240649089217186, -0.04583681374788284, -0.02006392739713192, -0.01212643925100565, -0.055025093257427216, 0.030439186841249466, 0.021129632368683815, 0.023868124932050705, -0.0006948282243683934, -0.022148841992020607, 0.0517808236181736, 0.07195983827114105, -0.010488474741578102, 0.01668217033147812, -0.007900863885879517, -0.04682609438896179, 0.002311830874532461, 0.03025316819548607, 0.0000998683026409708, 0.043641261756420135, -0.019451605156064034, -0.0043523237109184265, 0.004519353155046701, -0.006531433202326298, -0.0568002425134182, 0.011564833112061024, -0.020412184298038483, -0.00618479261174798, -0.04884568229317665, 0.031153695657849312, -0.02474038489162922, -0.04449896141886711, -0.012238920666277409, -0.039521001279354095, 0.0243001077324152, -0.014712919481098652, 0.0043358881957829, 0.013889635913074017, -0.019751232117414474, -0.009586440399289131, 0.037750493735075, -0.006857607048004866, -0.028139010071754456, -0.014658440835773945, -0.02824125438928604, -0.039873190224170685, 0.03905928507447243, 0.01131303422152996, -0.005509784910827875, 0.007530714385211468, -0.03751017525792122, 0.04886166378855705, -0.04558560624718666, 0.0013127486454322934, -0.020827459171414375, 0.05585198476910591, -0.0041537294164299965, 0.05034349113702774, 0.0169682577252388, -0.03908002749085426, 0.018046187236905098, -0.05035361275076866, -0.05366743355989456, 0.025515815243124962, -0.030671073123812675, -0.012747959233820438, 0.004315908066928387, -0.030464978888630867, 0.039761610329151154, -0.030429141595959663, 0.05357283726334572, -0.029333002865314484, 0.027094919234514236, -0.023389386013150215, 0.027550915256142616, -0.009098034352064133, -0.02129221521317959, -0.007724440190941095, -0.028361456468701363, 0.035309210419654846, 0.0017842951929196715, 0.03894925117492676, 0.06844262778759003, -0.014317619614303112, 0.00475978571921587, -0.03828306123614311, 0.030019275844097137, 0.03431706130504608, 0.017639024183154106, 0.046499911695718765, 0.03174678236246109, -0.034118715673685074, -0.004734158981591463, 0.012108143419027328, 0.03562460467219353, 0.06752921640872955, 0.0052015273831784725, -0.023544317111372948, -0.021901600062847137, 0.0050384411588311195, 0.01389095839112997, -0.023373398929834366, 0.012158328667283058, 0.002668878063559532, 0.10658154636621475, 0.050042733550071716, -0.0033379807136952877, 0.032711829990148544, 0.05673025920987129, 0.038540903478860855, -0.009707331657409668, -0.05710044130682945, -0.006481710821390152, 0.018170449882745743, 0.004398993216454983, 0.03712533786892891, 0.008660987950861454, 0.04649610072374344, 0.018106892704963684, 0.026315268129110336, -0.06015743687748909, 0.00249938084743917, 0.022809049114584923, 0.02465900406241417, 0.035931479185819626, -0.018871184438467026, -0.0025929007679224014, 0.01633428782224655, 0.011971510946750641, -0.0031876503489911556, 0.027890825644135475, -0.01397734135389328, -0.08512351661920547, 0.029086535796523094, 0.023832740262150764, 0.017868252471089363, -0.041640110313892365, -0.026825567707419395, -0.059542346745729446, 0.009559988044202328, 0.00823155790567398, -0.0202005784958601, 0.038292378187179565, -0.023327914997935295, 0.006240296643227339, -0.03454336151480675, -0.006560560781508684, -0.015981458127498627, 0.017813323065638542, 0.0012182267382740974, 0.022138137370347977, -0.03344178572297096, -0.021065739914774895, -0.007712400518357754, -0.002829410135746002, 0.02718743495643139, 0.018802914768457413, -0.03615127131342888, 0.013577868230640888, 0.03790304437279701, 0.05358827859163284, -0.012559891678392887, -0.040729206055402756, 0.016010163351893425, 0.011410016566514969, 0.02991086058318615, 0.055056653916835785, 0.017775189131498337, -0.002043638378381729, 0.03328954428434372, 0.02204379439353943, -0.04305759444832802, -0.02466421201825142, -0.05077393352985382, 0.03254076838493347, 0.0014389631105586886, 0.017766399309039116, 0.05833573639392853, -0.0011251195101067424, 0.0030661942437291145, 0.029806599020957947, -0.017629684880375862, 0.048059795051813126, -0.01885349303483963, -0.0036252192221581936, -0.08190256357192993, -0.003828763496130705, -0.02273193560540676, -0.0007325313636101782, 0.0071665504947304726, 0.017600370571017265, -0.03897584229707718, -0.016164936125278473, 0.035874754190444946, 0.05560166388750076, -0.023463569581508636, 0.013877702876925468, -0.004832103382796049, 0.002314354293048382, 0.0010431678965687752, -0.005321781616657972, 0.010466055944561958, -0.03976389020681381, 0.006342512555420399, 0.02497798204421997, -0.029213212430477142, 0.005657931789755821, -0.01820557378232479, -0.044967349618673325, 0.01008798461407423, -0.023396974429488182, 0.004428332205861807, 0.021895917132496834, 0.045320577919483185, -0.027028359472751617, -0.03643536567687988, -0.016757816076278687, 0.013749013654887676, -0.009516473859548569, 0.014019003137946129, -0.030754350125789642, 0.02174237184226513, -0.0002434991765767336, -0.0036270790733397007, -0.058872878551483154, -0.064250648021698, -0.00015348399756476283, -0.012293106876313686, -0.030466293916106224, -0.021184640005230904, -0.002873730845749378, -0.02105414681136608, -0.026956595480442047, -0.022449737414717674, 0.040765855461359024, -0.005727200768887997, 0.008935200981795788, -0.011827182024717331, 0.01266460120677948, 0.08320395648479462, -0.0016221471596509218, 0.027717117220163345, 0.008301646448671818, -0.03746611997485161, -0.014158124104142189, 0.022688040509819984, 0.019819801673293114, -0.024654826149344444, 0.005502251908183098, -0.027075063437223434, 0.0020156316459178925, 0.05778985098004341, -0.01352568157017231, -0.026871031150221825, -0.0013058217009529471, 0.010290538892149925, -0.005106635857373476, -0.054079193621873856, 0.02312380261719227, -0.009824711829423904, 0.001428545219823718, -0.030776100233197212, -0.005595144350081682, -0.031546901911497116, -0.012578316032886505, 0.04031256213784218, -0.025281082838773727, -0.01590903289616108, 0.027654383331537247, 0.08537283539772034, -0.005171391647309065, -0.012761100195348263, 0.00403326191008091, -0.0304209366440773, 0.0245159063488245, 0.02193547785282135, -0.004896269645541906, 0.0001269761414732784, 0.005191323347389698, -0.04047785699367523, -0.05243340879678726, -0.047828394919633865, 0.047515928745269775, 0.08481795340776443, -0.03187796100974083, 0.0435500331223011, 0.053810566663742065, -0.022727329283952713, -0.02916143834590912, -0.02215290442109108, -0.04047304019331932, 0.057194408029317856, 0.01870976760983467, 0.03620193898677826, -0.020770104601979256, -0.01680113561451435, 0.04869409650564194, 0.010651813820004463, 0.02859385311603546, 0.04002303257584572, -0.01259505096822977, 0.02413417212665081, -0.020244823768734932, 0.0059474073350429535, -0.051882851868867874, 0.034832291305065155, -0.007581521291285753, 0.008607829920947552, -0.04503331333398819, 0.0009330043685622513, 0.035056982189416885, 0.04158274084329605, 0.007359014358371496, -0.05000951513648033, -0.02753198705613613, -0.03142251446843147, 0.01278894953429699, 0.06251414120197296, -0.036493126302957535, 0.04419993609189987, 0.03579049929976463, 0.029667532071471214, 0.0025330507196485996, 0.01198273804038763, -0.007436799351125956, -0.08538608998060226, -0.023897474631667137, -0.04753069579601288, 0.0010537691414356232, 0.01671869494020939, -0.03385183960199356, -0.02772923745214939, -0.005513531621545553, -0.05874955654144287, -0.022731995210051537, 0.003576532006263733, 0.0444108210504055, 0.0013137114001438022, 0.10077982395887375, -0.02041124925017357, 0.0026409048587083817, -0.02305622212588787, -0.046264007687568665, 0.12883763015270233, 0.08553419262170792, 0.029440706595778465, -0.07187405973672867, -0.0063209617510437965, 0.015046337619423866, -0.020089464262127876, -0.01912001706659794, 0.01743590645492077, -0.021053843200206757, -0.002547589596360922, 0.016124418005347252, 0.026579437777400017, 0.012956525199115276, 0.005483593791723251, 0.035900913178920746, -0.023030750453472137, -0.02354123257100582, 0.009773403406143188, 0.02946309745311737, 0.0008282428607344627, -0.042645957320928574, -0.03802124038338661, 0.020836353302001953, -0.020776251330971718, -0.011715901084244251, -0.0002940903650596738, -0.011966428719460964, -0.021479463204741478, 0.03788701072335243, -0.021325265988707542, -0.003187078284099698, 0.00972635205835104, 0.01636517234146595, -0.003301649820059538, 0.017683694139122963, 0.01950608193874359, -0.0154434684664011, 0.06283001601696014, 0.01411835104227066, 0.010685275308787823, -0.00731802498921752, 0.007772968616336584, -0.003922765608876944, -0.07008307427167892, -0.034588202834129333, 0.00947196688503027, 0.02967800572514534, -0.012749582529067993, 0.00898689404129982, -0.03066163882613182, -0.006296845152974129, 0.032603517174720764, -0.04134053736925125, -0.012534219771623611, 0.016281524673104286, -0.006869379431009293, -0.02793332375586033, 0.003759713377803564, -0.050452642142772675, -0.007723350077867508, -0.016145717352628708, 0.029948599636554718, 0.03872302547097206, -0.04141858220100403, -0.01941024512052536, -0.03191230818629265, 0.032165296375751495, -0.021159615367650986, 0.01620350405573845, -0.018284320831298828, -0.01820865459740162, -0.03537675365805626, 0.016103677451610565, 0.01408088393509388, 0.047879915684461594, 0.011994918808341026, -0.05030522122979164, -0.026685692369937897, 0.00898962002247572, -0.025663763284683228, -0.0021706814877688885, -0.02308674342930317, -0.04607469588518143, -0.02414626255631447, -0.013723738491535187, 0.031294986605644226, 0.05047232285141945, -0.016969725489616394, 0.02143022045493126, -0.002376641845330596, 0.0508960597217083, 0.03141607344150543, -0.07347804307937622, -0.004809820093214512, 0.019512100145220757, -0.014871749095618725, -0.028175368905067444, -0.005073727108538151, 0.05355837568640709, 0.004705213475972414, 0.0511203408241272, -0.022362833842635155, 0.012630808167159557, 0.00358082284219563, 0.003025391371920705, 0.012323278933763504, -0.03205094113945961, -0.002618226921185851, -0.030140813440084457, -0.007742234971374273, -0.028505753725767136, 0.004845064599066973, -0.004297008737921715, -0.047806039452552795, 0.00932361651211977, 0.010657529346644878, -0.025133861228823662, 0.011844035238027573, 0.005871385335922241, 0.023166432976722717, -0.04795040190219879, 0.011358723044395447, -0.015712536871433258, 0.028157616034150124, -0.006491687148809433, -0.00392988882958889, -0.003985505551099777, -0.009803175926208496, -0.02539905533194542, -0.007732894271612167, 0.04538081958889961, -0.028956996276974678, 0.010421846993267536, -0.009512205608189106, 0.0009171564597636461, -0.005968770943582058, 0.03957914561033249, -0.019062820822000504, -0.033133845776319504, -0.027094842866063118, -0.023981094360351562, -0.02925545908510685, 0.03944104537367821, 0.0388900488615036, 0.036363739520311356, 0.014325752854347229, -0.0197010301053524, -0.0431094653904438, 0.04712696000933647, -0.05017431452870369, 0.023190973326563835, 0.0274533499032259, 0.041506078094244, 0.02003161422908306, 0.006422507110983133, -0.005771809723228216, 0.015777545049786568, 0.028402261435985565, 0.015060637146234512, 0.03523881733417511, 0.04112162068486214, 0.010280858725309372, 0.013526706956326962, -0.03382568061351776, -0.00687767006456852, -0.013243627734482288, 0.04158329218626022, -0.0016544994432479143, 0.035891082137823105, 0.0075029232539236546, 0.00862864125519991, -0.001271395361982286, 0.033561721444129944, -0.03362611308693886, 0.02194260247051716, -0.012570681050419807, 0.00937956664711237, 0.05515819415450096, -0.03865310177206993, 0.021341772750020027, 0.024814436212182045, -0.022855456918478012, 0.013312725350260735, 0.013671847060322762, 0.008071938529610634, -0.03841795399785042, -0.030532872304320335, -0.006745847407728434, 0.00495316693559289, 0.03837628662586212, -0.005668803118169308, 0.026040419936180115, 0.008025999180972576, 0.017400545999407768, -0.03544576093554497, -0.02531762793660164, -0.017349842935800552, 0.012408651411533356, -0.051122501492500305, -0.00387170584872365, 0.006561059504747391, -0.05313638970255852, 0.02594129554927349, -0.04337810352444649, 0.004162761382758617, 0.004906068556010723, 0.02560112625360489, 0.01681612804532051, 0.03225787356495857, 0.02414228953421116, -0.007628406397998333, 0.033334214240312576, -0.015853915363550186, 0.023073531687259674, 0.02914956584572792, -0.051128748804330826, 0.017289744690060616, 0.007525692693889141, -0.03321756422519684, -0.06294970959424973, 0.018596559762954712, -0.010060028173029423, 0.008902833797037601, -0.031352315098047256, -0.027857564389705658, 0.015311410650610924, -0.02320118434727192, 0.014263038523495197, -0.001717485603876412, -0.010482821613550186, 0.07408592104911804, 0.047698020935058594, -0.05223996937274933, 0.008237630128860474, -0.03677317500114441, -0.027000876143574715, 0.023581404238939285, 0.030139286071062088, -0.023948607966303825, -0.08212020248174667, -0.03182608261704445, 0.0007683049188926816, -0.024058548733592033, -0.04710831120610237, 0.02592284046113491, -0.05146225541830063, 0.05545536056160927, -0.02944960445165634, 0.0002731912536546588, 0.004528980702161789, -0.025358721613883972, 0.040265731513500214, -0.04806024208664894, 0.061642829328775406, -0.0005617680144496262, -0.02790660224854946, 0.013444666750729084, -0.014245026744902134, -0.04789797216653824, 0.028463976457715034, 0.03783463314175606, -0.006013865116983652, 0.008064014837145805, 0.0007828666130080819, 0.012095709331333637, 0.02147308923304081, -0.043254394084215164, 0.0765102356672287, 0.007830207236111164, -0.013019238598644733, 0.005002383608371019, -0.03446697071194649, -0.006139636971056461, -0.0018132233526557684, -0.006636158097535372, 0.014115787111222744, 0.01740361750125885, 0.04477814584970474, -0.02998775616288185, 0.04185251519083977, -0.003629769664257765, -0.021819179877638817, 0.04025237262248993, -0.009071946144104004, 0.0043356153182685375, 0.039200469851493835, 0.0031271264888346195, -0.007480817846953869, 0.017859244719147682, -0.0037075032014399767, -0.031685926020145416, 0.0018269697902724147, -0.009246524423360825, 0.04935916140675545, -0.04864826798439026, 0.014885971322655678, 0.029453586786985397, 0.0043090092949569225, -0.008776082657277584, 0.029449978843331337, -0.009087941609323025, -0.012703927233815193, -0.010384940542280674, -0.01142852008342743, 0.030655639246106148, -0.011962974444031715, 0.043686479330062866, 0.02240464650094509, -0.0002068907197099179, 0.007960566319525242, 0.03141431510448456, 0.0007816462893970311, -0.0073018427938222885, 0.04279207065701485, -0.028713511303067207, 0.06424883753061295, -0.0073251379653811455, -0.06669957935810089, -0.011511038988828659, 0.010543485172092915, 0.04371184855699539, -0.02197747491300106, -0.0069183893501758575, 0.0444011390209198, -0.0334937758743763, 0.0037077011074870825, 0.010493269190192223, 0.004804014228284359, 0.002510006306692958, 0.011131975799798965, -0.014025411568582058, 0.007220201659947634, -0.012939710170030594, 0.026273243129253387, 0.00007889801054261625, 0.00886367354542017, -0.00208554370328784, -0.02895401418209076, -0.01687360368669033, 0.010049059987068176, -0.009644162841141224, -0.00023602605506312102, -0.005401033442467451, -0.008197112940251827, -0.000005717212388844928, 0.009934843517839909, 0.039468370378017426, -0.017177050933241844, -0.07050155848264694, -0.012303517200052738, -0.011124196462333202, 0.03951892629265785, -0.06459355354309082, -0.0030016854871064425, -0.035583026707172394, -0.0419001430273056, -0.024360282346606255, -0.015827082097530365 ]
<p>I'm trying to classify my set of data into two classes (introvert / extrovert). I was thinking of using a decision tree at first, but I don't have any potential known results in order to create my decision tree model. Thus I decided to use a <em>k</em>-means clustering algorithm with <em>k</em> = 2.</p> <ol> <li><p>Since the clustering algorithm accepts only numeric values, can I use the decision tree algorithm to transform some type of values I have into numeric ones at first (based on some rules I define within the tree) before I start clustering?</p></li> <li><p>Let's suppose at the end of the algorithm I get my 2 clusters: cluster 1 and cluster 2. How can I classify these two clusters based on my 2 classes? Am I supposed to use supervised or semi-supervised clustering? (I don't know how semi- and supervised clustering work).</p></li> <li><p>Is there any other simple and efficient classification technique that can satisfy my needs?</p></li> </ol> <p>P.S. I'm new to this domain and all your advice and remarks are appreciated.</p>
35,966
[ -0.041089534759521484, -0.029233036562800407, -0.019653474912047386, -0.005750912707298994, 0.005786608438938856, 0.007314550690352917, -0.0214382391422987, -0.011646286584436893, 0.0038886687252670527, -0.018925199285149574, 0.02941874787211418, 0.022520264610648155, 0.024272002279758453, 0.05531032383441925, 0.013836494646966457, 0.017840217798948288, -0.005833356641232967, -0.010929901152849197, -0.0032221870496869087, 0.01082969456911087, -0.03568040579557419, -0.01567704789340496, 0.015315549448132515, -0.009091055020689964, -0.05370302498340607, 0.0548347532749176, 0.03148670122027397, -0.01689266227185726, 0.016369810327887535, 0.008099760860204697, -0.01875528134405613, -0.018400313332676888, 0.0050386651419103146, 0.015085111372172832, 0.006887852679938078, -0.009899215772747993, -0.026427455246448517, -0.017990631982684135, -0.027890119701623917, 0.00833311676979065, -0.013737414963543415, -0.035038355737924576, 0.017556028440594673, 0.00732981413602829, 0.007742905057966709, 0.004345226101577282, -0.006556659936904907, -0.045929260551929474, 0.006225778721272945, -0.066795714199543, 0.09063403308391571, -0.02170371264219284, 0.0414833128452301, 0.05490025505423546, -0.005086258519440889, 0.004041207022964954, 0.04168418049812317, 0.07044069468975067, -0.03012867085635662, -0.041729215532541275, -0.032762203365564346, 0.0023100553080439568, -0.02875741757452488, -0.013824192807078362, -0.05852789804339409, 0.019792499020695686, 0.008213984780013561, -0.002046429319307208, 0.0321757011115551, 0.0004537228378467262, 0.03769228607416153, 0.00882643274962902, 0.06206730008125305, -0.023396475240588188, 0.02045266516506672, -0.011349780485033989, -0.0018157379236072302, 0.03046226128935814, 0.07156293839216232, 0.008062820881605148, 0.03888586163520813, 0.016936887055635452, 0.044213034212589264, 0.009038668125867844, 0.02106279693543911, -0.018533404916524887, 0.04948951303958893, -0.024056660011410713, 0.0030228185933083296, 0.043130140751600266, 0.0070754364132881165, 0.00489586079493165, 0.0517725944519043, -0.019962240010499954, -0.026496030390262604, 0.04266608878970146, -0.003113481914624572, 0.05589532107114792, 0.013728377409279346, -0.003001308999955654, -0.015469372272491455, -0.016364432871341705, 0.03090454824268818, 0.052676789462566376, -0.025127509608864784, -0.0145816495642066, -0.02625216543674469, -0.0034026827197521925, -0.007884951308369637, -0.00930831953883171, 0.015119284391403198, 0.0053929053246974945, 0.007003714796155691, 0.01680070534348488, 0.04990866780281067, -0.04273382946848869, -0.04130660742521286, -0.02347317337989807, 0.009108036756515503, 0.0420951247215271, 0.04868925362825394, -0.042642321437597275, 0.010782314464449883, -0.010840196162462234, -0.058304689824581146, -0.0050901747308671474, 0.002592187374830246, 0.0005466839065775275, -0.048865802586078644, 0.04771203547716141, -0.041903819888830185, -0.0020638597197830677, 0.02723611518740654, -0.03153543546795845, 0.019648324698209763, 0.001445471658371389, -0.058929502964019775, -0.024793716147542, -0.02354012429714203, -0.0014595825923606753, 0.010999016463756561, -0.05249952897429466, 0.009407665580511093, 0.02539575845003128, 0.03914153203368187, 0.04463497921824455, 0.03556617721915245, 0.01587306708097458, 0.01763559877872467, 0.0033063674345612526, -0.006503209006041288, -0.017857640981674194, -0.029579250141978264, -0.0036183223128318787, -0.00009787720046006143, -0.07400671392679214, 0.0033205831423401833, 0.016959011554718018, -0.007843196392059326, -0.020152833312749863, 0.023580338805913925, -0.011860519647598267, -0.03764756768941879, 0.01896115392446518, 0.00543195428326726, -0.02898169495165348, 0.07134081423282623, 0.01310635544359684, 0.060806211084127426, -0.002288985997438431, -0.0033654500730335712, 0.02546830102801323, 0.016845250502228737, 0.02885506860911846, 0.028423182666301727, 0.019448263570666313, -0.033284131437540054, -0.023104414343833923, 0.05232273042201996, 0.0030112427193671465, -0.038124583661556244, -0.056693099439144135, -0.016945673152804375, 0.0220677200704813, 0.00990450382232666, 0.01053753960877657, -0.0145259452983737, -0.023182693868875504, 0.023036755621433258, -0.019628023728728294, -0.031310975551605225, -0.054170385003089905, 0.005450117867439985, -0.024929963052272797, 0.0010652835480868816, 0.010646280832588673, 0.01461914461106062, 0.023250794038176537, -0.0007029735716059804, -0.03450639173388481, -0.05342935025691986, -0.013795260339975357, 0.06653532385826111, -0.026655253022909164, 0.0035408136900514364, 0.05455731227993965, -0.006098140496760607, -0.015540430322289467, 0.05694016069173813, -0.0560428760945797, -0.08311653882265091, -0.00981979351490736, -0.04207313805818558, -0.006530663929879665, -0.012965652160346508, 0.02063155174255371, 0.02187432162463665, 0.032820526510477066, -0.0504450760781765, 0.008996184915304184, -0.057675037533044815, 0.08645977079868317, 0.061926767230033875, 0.022561710327863693, 0.005342167802155018, -0.008364726789295673, -0.028561072424054146, 0.02164435014128685, -0.02337857149541378, -0.007125128526240587, -0.04287366196513176, -0.005697920452803373, 0.05708857998251915, -0.000968144100625068, -0.0459345243871212, 0.030093349516391754, 0.008958867751061916, 0.02893618680536747, -0.00790245458483696, 0.009817035868763924, -0.037941183894872665, 0.01895398087799549, 0.01794205605983734, 0.02288844995200634, 0.01706373691558838, 0.008107572793960571, 0.022358912974596024, -0.027805587276816368, 0.025994140654802322, -0.026069894433021545, -0.023737819865345955, 0.07645963132381439, 0.01962384581565857, 0.0033312970772385597, 0.015786007046699524, -0.0218012947589159, 0.04247486591339111, -0.019613811746239662, -0.014141222462058067, 0.028854040428996086, 0.000086868109065108, 0.01868356764316559, 0.016761744394898415, -0.008432170376181602, 0.016107402741909027, 0.07478371262550354, -0.0008375789038836956, 0.037252407521009445, 0.01474215742200613, -0.034699227660894394, 0.020737923681735992, 0.0027017148677259684, -0.055504992604255676, -0.03511907532811165, 0.0019066628301516175, 0.026353968307375908, 0.0016010244144126773, 0.00783580169081688, -0.023784371092915535, -0.017764167860150337, 0.00224467390216887, -0.05041852593421936, -0.002835607621818781, 0.028205158188939095, -0.044884853065013885, 0.009712952189147472, -0.010068031027913094, -0.022837059572339058, 0.016269350424408913, 0.008490256033837795, -0.03422349691390991, 0.0012975384015589952, 0.017641251906752586, -0.06412363797426224, -0.03098810836672783, -0.02443608082830906, 0.033330194652080536, -0.009789718315005302, -0.03015565127134323, 0.01238802820444107, 0.006044725421816111, -0.03476175665855408, 0.011797641403973103, -0.037124089896678925, -0.03211049363017082, -0.030629953369498253, -0.030657852068543434, 0.020458592101931572, -0.0077863819897174835, -0.01176407653838396, 0.026461951434612274, -0.005983459763228893, -0.018135422840714455, -0.06248033419251442, -0.05690033733844757, 0.025862328708171844, -0.003218807280063629, -0.005104398354887962, 0.021666890010237694, -0.02325163222849369, 0.07099085301160812, 0.0012263000244274735, -0.0343523733317852, -0.04623107239603996, -0.024021239951252937, -0.0516001433134079, 0.0035443101078271866, -0.008882288821041584, 0.019672218710184097, 0.007967786863446236, -0.02399219386279583, 0.026840146631002426, 0.02003154158592224, 0.04374679550528526, -0.03978988900780678, -0.034675776958465576, 0.03282427042722702, 0.012873654253780842, -0.013397135771811008, 0.054739199578762054, 0.027335356920957565, -0.055680982768535614, 0.05263577029109001, -0.038819652050733566, -0.021249642595648766, 0.04319782555103302, -0.026360198855400085, 0.028697235509753227, -0.023106124252080917, 0.0413263738155365, -0.05699637532234192, 0.030005566775798798, 0.006050954107195139, -0.03528691083192825, 0.007480662316083908, 0.0013433009153231978, 0.048174500465393066, -0.029510710388422012, -0.023680971935391426, 0.04995482414960861, 0.04991530254483223, 0.009089218452572823, -0.03149360790848732, 0.01134240347892046, -0.02773612178862095, 0.016981134191155434, 0.009937983937561512, 0.018189653754234314, 0.0333724319934845, 0.06131952255964279, 0.03972584381699562, -0.0010263316798955202, -0.03268362209200859, -0.004492830019444227, -0.054296284914016724, 0.004678870551288128, -0.05441277474164963, 0.04857047647237778, -0.00840738695114851, 0.04443390667438507, 0.03568907454609871, -0.020428713411092758, 0.03312282636761665, 0.02443290501832962, -0.05326545983552933, 0.008420449681580067, -0.018660569563508034, 0.0019168124999850988, 0.001447073882445693, -0.01811061054468155, 0.035424891859292984, -0.006688621826469898, 0.00278073619119823, 0.027056792750954628, 0.02904343046247959, -0.02482414059340954, -0.012407106347382069, -0.04081472381949425, 0.006910594645887613, -0.0035649926867336035, 0.014525244943797588, 0.021680906414985657, 0.0008672585245221853, 0.04445277154445648, 0.037247925996780396, -0.0094439797103405, 0.0016382975736632943, -0.028076710179448128, -0.0008598940912634134, 0.008218101225793362, 0.02767014503479004, -0.00962662510573864, 0.005429955665022135, -0.003767620772123337, 0.01600317284464836, 0.010630211792886257, 0.041700173169374466, 0.020827343687415123, 0.002536854473873973, -0.00537418108433485, -0.0248587504029274, -0.03045528568327427, -0.020754704251885414, 0.025194980204105377, 0.004879145883023739, 0.008261018432676792, 0.01796337589621544, 0.024300532415509224, -0.06211452558636665, -0.005565514322370291, 0.07834026962518692, 0.016360828652977943, -0.047472938895225525, -0.03629746288061142, 0.006417812313884497, 0.0014222842874005437, -0.008228710852563381, 0.029350275173783302, 0.012928045354783535, 0.012607241980731487, 0.0310016181319952, 0.04370790719985962, -0.0036004092544317245, -0.0359620675444603, 0.010102263651788235, 0.018087100237607956, 0.04651140421628952, -0.02373192273080349, -0.05765868350863457, 0.012206836603581905, 0.06412291526794434, 0.058049965649843216, -0.000884216686245054, 0.012911034747958183, -0.11004910618066788, 0.006807525176554918, 0.02659151516854763, 0.03984615206718445, -0.03516591340303421, -0.008966858498752117, -0.026262391358613968, 0.010385565459728241, 0.011307299137115479, -0.032557740807533264, 0.04559880495071411, -0.0016913004219532013, -0.0007878052419982851, 0.0007923578377813101, 0.01310552004724741, -0.046392448246479034, 0.023671675473451614, -0.024902144446969032, 0.08068209886550903, 0.011653940193355083, -0.023902518674731255, -0.05059675872325897, 0.013975793495774269, -0.0014457845827564597, 0.04550279304385185, -0.05594674497842789, -0.03126337006688118, 0.01621229015290737, -0.002836222294718027, -0.016032056882977486, -0.05742061883211136, -0.009360437281429768, 0.022281790152192116, 0.0035245874896645546, 0.03684200718998909, -0.029958898201584816, -0.03675580024719238, -0.0016352386446669698, 0.0019336123950779438, -0.03306649252772331, -0.010702540166676044, 0.01427614875137806, 0.053964778780937195, 0.01763317547738552, 0.0041375248692929745, 0.06969445943832397, 0.03404906764626503, 0.008345278911292553, 0.02105727791786194, -0.04984399303793907, -0.003151277080178261, -0.02539787068963051, -0.0006531423423439264, -0.023129599168896675, -0.015751998871564865, -0.03058725781738758, 0.007107534445822239, -0.016515063121914864, 0.055086731910705566, -0.03029831312596798, -0.017879663035273552, -0.025212785229086876, 0.014235654845833778, -0.02416865900158882, -0.013983727432787418, -0.012359743006527424, 0.03926835209131241, -0.032443344593048096, -0.00863589346408844, 0.020375821739435196, -0.02220136858522892, 0.017957424744963646, -0.0009028878412209451, -0.05090176686644554, -0.010740164667367935, -0.033730264753103256, -0.020466424524784088, 0.010242223739624023, -0.010335318744182587, 0.05040069669485092, -0.018772467970848083, 0.024186471477150917, 0.04391034319996834, -0.036198388785123825, -0.027896713465452194, -0.008998001925647259, 0.006009421776980162, 0.01903853937983513, -0.0501144602894783, 0.05195978656411171, 0.005150739569216967, -0.028044816106557846, -0.04265931621193886, -0.022242054343223572, 0.010664262808859348, -0.024546390399336815, -0.012717513367533684, -0.054069604724645615, 0.019482772797346115, -0.0037129423581063747, -0.03314574807882309, 0.005904303397983313, 0.0842144712805748, 0.007749567739665508, -0.025200339034199715, 0.0035182246938347816, 0.03669310733675957, 0.06430552154779434, 0.043640200048685074, 0.0035581253468990326, 0.013234149664640427, 0.00045713712461292744, -0.03022262454032898, 0.02095968835055828, 0.02406120114028454, -0.01968267373740673, -0.003922030795365572, -0.032225023955106735, 0.02373824641108513, 0.06081685051321983, 0.0027802661061286926, -0.027465058490633965, 0.015219721011817455, 0.040146179497241974, -0.0015857418766245246, -0.027474885806441307, 0.018916118890047073, 0.018694913014769554, 0.005970151163637638, -0.028335126116871834, 0.005902602802962065, -0.03806907683610916, 0.010880306363105774, 0.043763261288404465, 0.010885452851653099, 0.0008542998693883419, 0.03514324501156807, 0.05126519873738289, -0.01540802139788866, -0.00015281162632163614, 0.0009960740571841598, -0.03827332705259323, 0.008722729049623013, -0.022587060928344727, -0.003889111801981926, -0.001947476645000279, 0.05548951402306557, -0.01629108190536499, -0.013406540267169476, -0.007433169987052679, -0.013623076491057873, 0.04784740135073662, 0.020264679566025734, 0.06299005448818207, 0.0636030063033104, 0.012493436224758625, 0.014409954659640789, -0.05379900708794594, -0.018554747104644775, -0.035919710993766785, 0.014594929292798042, 0.03982115536928177, 0.028695855289697647, 0.010976556688547134, 0.03637878596782684, 0.010668286122381687, -0.014522786252200603, 0.035000935196876526, 0.04659507796168327, 0.04763340950012207, -0.020523516461253166, -0.07064395397901535, -0.028575090691447258, 0.016045136377215385, -0.034846652299165726, 0.017871279269456863, -0.007288675755262375, -0.029494723305106163, 0.0569298192858696, 0.05464782193303108, 0.01647244580090046, -0.04273008555173874, 0.0076325987465679646, -0.06319046765565872, 0.007018858566880226, -0.016633249819278717, -0.04261058196425438, 0.007456276100128889, 0.019772930070757866, 0.04746541753411293, 0.010032403282821178, -0.007073954679071903, -0.012095075100660324, -0.10269849747419357, -0.046300482004880905, -0.03557422012090683, -0.059794943779706955, 0.04854070395231247, 0.012266161851584911, -0.07950381934642792, 0.04904593527317047, -0.03873205557465553, 0.024727696552872658, 0.026445012539625168, 0.044157274067401886, -0.01364154927432537, 0.018143435940146446, -0.0033995930571109056, 0.017383607104420662, 0.0007474588346667588, -0.002743528224527836, 0.12147564440965652, 0.055934078991413116, 0.01622139848768711, -0.03988715633749962, 0.011920026503503323, 0.017856381833553314, -0.0002523931616451591, -0.019455453380942345, 0.013701805844902992, -0.009449747391045094, 0.014661078341305256, 0.031030146405100822, 0.021605901420116425, 0.009413874708116055, -0.02937694825232029, 0.04549092426896095, 0.016024144366383553, -0.06253290176391602, 0.004777358379215002, -0.013176973909139633, 0.010093053802847862, -0.0073376488871872425, -0.04874627664685249, 0.026201337575912476, 0.011118614114820957, -0.005167465656995773, -0.012305805459618568, -0.005546103697270155, 0.05717957392334938, -0.039012111723423004, -0.023193422704935074, 0.014562794007360935, 0.03067697584629059, 0.008196726441383362, -0.009045873768627644, 0.015394864603877068, -0.007185681257396936, -0.02898457646369934, 0.01637776754796505, 0.04264909774065018, 0.023451434448361397, -0.035979680716991425, -0.008627679198980331, -0.009976389817893505, -0.07065299153327942, -0.025259988382458687, -0.046104710549116135, 0.038727179169654846, 0.025192203000187874, -0.0021898187696933746, 0.001238831551745534, 0.012514480389654636, -0.007369203492999077, -0.026810061186552048, 0.0025776498951017857, 0.014143746346235275, 0.036456555128097534, -0.0292233694344759, -0.021753869950771332, -0.06262336671352386, 0.028491327539086342, -0.00547109404578805, -0.0048728627152740955, 0.0044670565985143185, 0.01528298668563366, -0.014485765248537064, -0.03997279331088066, 0.013147440738976002, -0.012270449660718441, 0.006192624568939209, -0.007378240115940571, 0.0005717413732782006, -0.00841001607477665, 0.013338727876543999, -0.030337242409586906, -0.0010770136723294854, 0.023795699700713158, 0.014781578443944454, -0.011548091657459736, -0.03868759050965309, -0.02961832284927368, -0.011650843545794487, 0.001953476807102561, -0.023002799600362778, -0.019096557050943375, 0.024627435952425003, 0.002740676747635007, 0.04610508680343628, 0.03367014229297638, 0.020198771730065346, 0.0410272590816021, -0.009606890380382538, -0.02128179371356964, -0.05571066215634346, -0.03343106061220169, -0.004247890319675207, -0.04520853981375694, 0.03310875967144966, -0.009647236205637455, 0.06201300024986267, 0.019549807533621788, 0.011387240141630173, -0.033021338284015656, -0.003541087731719017, -0.015143219381570816, 0.036316003650426865, 0.005395546555519104, -0.04014584794640541, 0.0018808674067258835, -0.01130153238773346, 0.021068664267659187, -0.03805338218808174, -0.052720654755830765, -0.026470838114619255, -0.020747758448123932, 0.018070783466100693, -0.01712321676313877, -0.010152003727853298, 0.004143166355788708, -0.05443805083632469, 0.036369018256664276, -0.05623757094144821, -0.021643061190843582, -0.014155550859868526, -0.0010454568546265364, -0.008280975744128227, -0.011184332892298698, -0.006045250687748194, 0.015545602887868881, 0.038123082369565964, 0.04031140357255936, 0.0426691435277462, 0.03578862547874451, 0.009740689769387245, 0.02192726358771324, -0.012185952626168728, -0.051893141120672226, 0.03386491537094116, -0.0093209408223629, -0.009592981077730656, 0.02964431419968605, -0.056988805532455444, -0.017702501267194748, -0.005883590318262577, 0.008126338943839073, 0.042170267552137375, 0.02626618929207325, -0.028519494459033012, -0.00466185063123703, 0.056868776679039, -0.03171255439519882, -0.0778685137629509, -0.014030766673386097, -0.008225669153034687, -0.018053250387310982, 0.0016658534295856953, 0.007632452063262463, 0.035102635622024536, -0.03086424618959427, 0.0216927882283926, 0.015439762733876705, 0.011818673461675644, -0.028582217171788216, 0.001426977221854031, 0.05315590649843216, 0.022250518202781677, -0.0022032223641872406, -0.0026148376055061817, 0.050630781799554825, 0.01998138427734375, -0.051061343401670456, 0.041370194405317307, -0.0009286773856729269, 0.020586302503943443, -0.077115997672081, -0.026968939229846, 0.01831609383225441, -0.005112954415380955, 0.056067608296871185, -0.040278900414705276, 0.007670925464481115, 0.04047244414687157, -0.03235958144068718, 0.014246031641960144, 0.031430043280124664, -0.0018387752352282405, -0.023872582241892815, 0.0233071930706501, -0.04615944251418114, 0.03768812492489815, 0.03365251421928406, 0.017384372651576996, 0.004772875923663378, 0.030122535303235054, 0.027507904917001724, 0.01333395205438137, -0.02656184881925583, 0.0014279582537710667, 0.004422227386385202, -0.04340868443250656, 0.03338873013854027, -0.054415129125118256, -0.02121131122112274, 0.029287952929735184, -0.037445105612277985, 0.010247317142784595, 0.09214194118976593, -0.003088893136009574, -0.0032485565170645714, 0.03919105976819992, 0.023650189861655235, -0.01104442123323679, -0.01402188092470169, 0.03328598663210869, 0.0027272047009319067, 0.011437293142080307, 0.010333271697163582, -0.010195045731961727, 0.0024407710880041122, -0.017991138622164726, 0.0009906531777232885, 0.006025796756148338, -0.03979161009192467, -0.03152938187122345, -0.020272333174943924, -0.02675500512123108, -0.02531377598643303, -0.003324872115626931, -0.004473630338907242, -0.01908731646835804, -0.01202502939850092, 0.023182909935712814, -0.005872419103980064, 0.04249212518334389, 0.008028739131987095, -0.027427034452557564, -0.055226363241672516, 0.024798864498734474, 0.02734312415122986, -0.01168910413980484, -0.057691339403390884, -0.008350575342774391, 0.025813331827521324, 0.008254843764007092, -0.012926246039569378, -0.010791395790874958, 0.04210665076971054, 0.07445401698350906, -0.03374738618731499, 0.045056626200675964, 0.046182405203580856, -0.008169175125658512, -0.026067763566970825, -0.10864797979593277, 0.07171633094549179, 0.023167893290519714, 0.0026091986801475286, -0.026938188821077347, 0.0180974118411541, -0.05202963575720787, 0.04093454033136368, 0.07471232116222382, 0.025721004232764244, 0.006437294185161591, -0.03815551474690437, 0.0025518175680190325, -0.015746165066957474, -0.07038848847150803, 0.02872639335691929, -0.005714975297451019, 0.0010907786199823022, 0.015278028324246407, -0.019675640389323235, -0.0006556165753863752, 0.0003847343905363232, 0.03014521300792694, 0.0007325807237066329, -0.020889082923531532, -0.00023922741820570081, -0.012749132700264454, 0.018859747797250748, -0.022387497127056122, 0.018806010484695435, 0.010731619782745838, -0.01599530130624771, -0.009487742558121681, 0.041595835238695145, -0.009190624579787254, -0.02569064311683178, 0.06062877178192139, -0.04866445064544678, -0.021627269685268402, -0.006504861172288656, 0.005826047156006098, -0.0019534293096512556, -0.06626992672681808, -0.021243173629045486, 0.026679368689656258, -0.04279867187142372, 0.016493165865540504, 0.04840463399887085, 0.016247926279902458, 0.06431154906749725, 0.003914492204785347, 0.05050376057624817, 0.005256801377981901, -0.014697220176458359, 0.06366600096225739, -0.00689571350812912, 0.024401269853115082, 0.010752649046480656, -0.008631456643342972, 0.0027056951075792313, 0.018360529094934464, 0.02124127559363842, -0.022739795967936516, 0.012233227491378784, -0.010902903974056244, -0.0029918812215328217, 0.044226642698049545, 0.01332036592066288, 0.00592963257804513, 0.03157208114862442, -0.010271947830915451, 0.04890085756778717, -0.05608687922358513, -0.02520943433046341, -0.043573927134275436, -0.04446176812052727, 0.0005947656463831663, 0.011217445135116577, 0.027708619832992554, 0.025356782600283623, 0.028903933241963387, 0.037128131836652756, -0.016321180388331413, -0.018330812454223633, 0.04340171068906784, -0.016504589468240738, 0.03119981847703457, 0.0051081497222185135, -0.0429987907409668, -0.007455459795892239, -0.01123039610683918, -0.03467453271150589, -0.050719570368528366, 0.027692442759871483, 0.052662789821624756, 0.02379407361149788, -0.012601974420249462, -0.03495938703417778, -0.010845077224075794, 0.023868290707468987, -0.027460424229502678, 0.010224608704447746, -0.04275233671069145, 0.006640642881393433, -0.00796477496623993, -0.05440341681241989 ]
<p>I would like to analyze my results which have 3 groups with 5 possible outcomes (they are ordinal data by the way) and the expected cell counts are less than 5. Seems like it is not possible to run a analysis larger than a 2X2 tables in SPSS. </p> <p>Does anyone has a solution to it? Or should I consider using other tests like ordinal regression?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,569
[ -0.028298523277044296, -0.01684509590268135, -0.01580335944890976, 0.047041188925504684, 0.03880295157432556, 0.009623897261917591, -0.0010062307119369507, -0.035367149859666824, 0.01908906176686287, 0.014641699381172657, 0.039570022374391556, 0.022200830280780792, 0.02539191022515297, 0.01592252403497696, 0.0022398142609745264, 0.0302940234541893, -0.005631295498460531, 0.02109752595424652, -0.02500692382454872, 0.0007459865882992744, -0.0045546586625278, 0.02875874936580658, -0.008215940557420254, -0.04923255369067192, -0.00955191720277071, 0.043773114681243896, 0.015857771039009094, -0.03353558108210564, 0.018028130754828453, 0.02986164577305317, -0.017417674884200096, -0.018849851563572884, 0.01138591393828392, 0.02948828972876072, 0.019882936030626297, 0.014281712472438812, -0.013744370080530643, -0.007452331017702818, -0.00988794770091772, -0.030933452770113945, -0.0009129820391535759, 0.0038033316377550364, 0.005078673828393221, 0.022927867248654366, -0.007020798046141863, 0.0022807468194514513, -0.0045306142419576645, -0.02045128308236599, -0.01196148619055748, -0.04617878422141075, 0.0742606595158577, -0.0051220678724348545, 0.043271731585264206, 0.028740733861923218, 0.012872878462076187, 0.004040481522679329, 0.016344178467988968, 0.054948966950178146, 0.007002141792327166, -0.023987000808119774, -0.013975531794130802, -0.01037517935037613, 0.0020793492440134287, -0.019440049305558205, -0.03721216693520546, 0.0193166583776474, -0.010988530702888966, -0.020083030685782433, 0.045733656734228134, 0.027805905789136887, 0.03090210072696209, 0.023920852690935135, 0.07028476893901825, -0.02022618055343628, 0.011944000609219074, -0.008670125156641006, 0.03490559756755829, -0.021881571039557457, 0.021854231134057045, 0.05944865196943283, 0.0009336283546872437, 0.03957225754857063, 0.010388215072453022, 0.002522567054256797, 0.004450269043445587, -0.024806497618556023, 0.035521380603313446, -0.029540494084358215, -0.013588464818894863, 0.034125227481126785, -0.022110218182206154, -0.002800315385684371, 0.05397313833236694, 0.050982680171728134, -0.00924060121178627, 0.0016860231989994645, -0.03807678073644638, 0.06170050427317619, -0.011199664324522018, 0.02123010717332363, -0.0034708103630691767, -0.03519395738840103, 0.026955174282193184, 0.06432898342609406, -0.02647978439927101, 0.014594758860766888, -0.01833702251315117, -0.02795916609466076, -0.0042006089352071285, 0.005739367101341486, 0.03810640797019005, 0.0020513858180493116, 0.06215842813253403, -0.009440237656235695, 0.01050932239741087, 0.019068267196416855, -0.02517707459628582, -0.0029625140596181154, 0.012232502922415733, 0.06490287184715271, 0.04418753832578659, -0.010725336149334908, 0.0401492603123188, -0.03753364086151123, -0.046517498791217804, 0.019009839743375778, -0.017408229410648346, -0.025889001786708832, -0.026304658502340317, 0.034013472497463226, 0.023247504606842995, 0.02548617497086525, 0.04789354279637337, -0.012525666505098343, 0.04322262108325958, -0.021084005013108253, -0.0693037360906601, -0.06348925828933716, 0.044596996158361435, 0.025948798283934593, 0.010750595480203629, -0.04166227951645851, 0.003275446593761444, 0.0018634229199960828, 0.027375083416700363, 0.015847546979784966, 0.027331313118338585, 0.0033759449142962694, -0.00637600664049387, 0.016283703967928886, -0.03208153694868088, 0.043955426663160324, -0.06779522448778152, -0.014403601177036762, 0.031032491475343704, -0.10293661057949066, 0.04586464911699295, 0.005126103758811951, 0.024357013404369354, -0.0017943715211004019, 0.01802685856819153, 0.01624470390379429, -0.016614878550171852, -0.046388253569602966, 0.020948750898241997, 0.007574807852506638, 0.04797422140836716, -0.01935257390141487, 0.011868228204548359, 0.023469535633921623, 0.004499516449868679, 0.04643591120839119, 0.00908932089805603, 0.06673327088356018, 0.04076554626226425, 0.01908213645219803, 0.01674320176243782, -0.007303415797650814, 0.031162800267338753, 0.005182960070669651, -0.060856904834508896, 0.0017490313621237874, -0.004298689309507608, 0.011713570915162563, 0.022083885967731476, 0.027645308524370193, -0.0013489981647580862, -0.040410686284303665, -0.018609730526804924, -0.01907053403556347, -0.08890803903341293, -0.0746779814362526, 0.026895927265286446, 0.03634297475218773, -0.02760431542992592, 0.016032762825489044, -0.006497500464320183, 0.002169316867366433, -0.0009235931793227792, -0.022563017904758453, -0.07405532896518707, 0.028564346954226494, 0.02283315919339657, -0.04957982897758484, 0.00821717083454132, 0.06651019304990768, 0.05309256166219711, -0.015468806028366089, 0.01897543855011463, -0.03391671180725098, -0.02073185332119465, -0.012037193402647972, -0.014680083841085434, 0.010074753314256668, -0.0005957955145277083, -0.04171047732234001, 0.010587652213871479, 0.02693912759423256, -0.026208119466900826, 0.06081105023622513, -0.05499613657593727, 0.09072235226631165, 0.05019359290599823, 0.019174659624695778, 0.0033998466096818447, -0.04067313298583031, -0.004079391248524189, -0.02983202040195465, -0.033496979624032974, 0.013939029537141323, -0.03420482203364372, 0.029063250869512558, 0.013349419459700584, -0.031326934695243835, -0.047127194702625275, 0.006209821440279484, 0.06887691468000412, 0.004577018320560455, -0.009106026031076908, 0.03874703496694565, -0.02322121150791645, -0.02425806224346161, -0.009660233743488789, 0.0022626009304076433, 0.036599550396203995, 0.02547263167798519, -0.003547890344634652, 0.025063125416636467, 0.02301655150949955, 0.02827642299234867, -0.00374455819837749, 0.008997551165521145, 0.00856388546526432, 0.019126571714878082, 0.0028552438598126173, -0.004471853841096163, 0.04000606760382652, 0.00984820257872343, 0.010364254005253315, 0.03209422528743744, 0.004227474797517061, -0.022848350927233696, 0.008893720805644989, -0.009603501297533512, 0.010936982929706573, 0.029090456664562225, -0.035499006509780884, 0.021892501041293144, 0.02405725233256817, -0.011521847918629646, 0.0027028496842831373, 0.016580866649746895, -0.018310874700546265, -0.07072308659553528, 0.007175762206315994, 0.04330186918377876, -0.0070706638507544994, 0.06152140721678734, -0.010581321083009243, -0.0026490602176636457, 0.01386762224137783, 0.006820101290941238, 0.053012169897556305, -0.004984149243682623, -0.039828959852457047, -0.02364717237651348, -0.01592816412448883, -0.023036528378725052, 0.03396608307957649, -0.042139023542404175, -0.008893261663615704, 0.02553624100983143, -0.0019227440934628248, -0.03192833811044693, -0.0055165947414934635, 0.014475754462182522, 0.008601989597082138, -0.0038205392193049192, -0.00948136392980814, 0.030847175046801567, 0.05149824917316437, -0.06424253433942795, 0.0007224230212159455, -0.05660190060734749, -0.016260068863630295, -0.033734727650880814, 0.03565594181418419, -0.010057524777948856, 0.00408200453966856, 0.0052515664137899876, 0.00533023988828063, -0.013408130966126919, 0.0010164693230763078, -0.041006095707416534, -0.0347590371966362, 0.008783242665231228, -0.009533686563372612, 0.05922725796699524, -0.038276176899671555, -0.014711393043398857, 0.06683705747127533, -0.001452009310014546, -0.03796890750527382, -0.009521756321191788, -0.03629183769226074, -0.032229140400886536, 0.0009769154712557793, 0.027883222326636314, 0.005871590692549944, 0.02100987732410431, -0.001835256116464734, -0.015252877026796341, 0.027846267446875572, 0.06551192700862885, -0.019975177943706512, -0.018287673592567444, 0.015584859997034073, 0.009033063426613808, -0.01895207352936268, 0.03152792155742645, 0.02194955013692379, -0.013024264946579933, 0.01934962347149849, -0.0009052458335645497, -0.0025078230537474155, -0.022313492372632027, -0.05568340793251991, -0.022031152620911598, -0.02793673239648342, 0.03908665478229523, -0.020090581849217415, 0.03392675891518593, 0.036662764847278595, -0.031504008919000626, -0.013021322898566723, 0.041226036846637726, 0.02364553138613701, -0.02297382988035679, -0.009922962635755539, 0.04841671139001846, 0.03504972532391548, 0.0007608002633787692, -0.015029609203338623, -0.004916048143059015, -0.0003108766977675259, 0.006325250957161188, 0.001918790745548904, -0.04891889542341232, 0.0248892642557621, 0.05538458749651909, 0.028233366087079048, 0.020186560228466988, -0.012205935083329678, 0.008601690642535686, -0.05952407047152519, -0.028170255944132805, -0.042321424931287766, 0.04850804805755615, 0.037248868495225906, 0.013995883986353874, 0.005369649268686771, -0.020928118377923965, -0.0003532459959387779, -0.007567121181637049, -0.07249853014945984, 0.00109758204780519, -0.009012328460812569, 0.004255669191479683, 0.025270851328969002, -0.009038809686899185, 0.05116966739296913, -0.00651328032836318, -0.0006654884200543165, 0.004306489136070013, 0.02749691717326641, -0.016418421640992165, -0.00640629418194294, 0.01358649879693985, 0.01813228614628315, 0.02922639809548855, 0.012237275019288063, 0.00852285698056221, 0.005079577211290598, 0.016707520931959152, -0.01496526412665844, -0.03617003932595253, -0.06061161309480667, 0.013378354720771313, 0.01095567923039198, 0.008856088854372501, 0.029288699850440025, 0.011720339767634869, 0.039492227137088776, -0.03132928907871246, 0.007568527013063431, -0.027514386922121048, 0.02309412695467472, 0.04411366209387779, 0.021265622228384018, -0.018053121864795685, -0.032360658049583435, 0.015772491693496704, 0.010887960903346539, 0.02599034272134304, 0.0042426614090800285, -0.010156339965760708, 0.03092893399298191, 0.030794454738497734, -0.05237310752272606, 0.03176925331354141, 0.05043056607246399, 0.016745610162615776, -0.026294700801372528, -0.03092430718243122, -0.024346498772501945, -0.023278411477804184, -0.03355199098587036, 0.04290532320737839, 0.006557008251547813, 0.0005068880273029208, -0.01512090489268303, 0.03472527489066124, -0.02448253519833088, -0.025682441890239716, 0.019558662548661232, -0.054296933114528656, 0.023094508796930313, 0.029013194143772125, -0.017479827627539635, 0.038603540509939194, 0.03008439391851425, -0.002331492956727743, 0.038875188678503036, -0.020873144268989563, -0.08326645940542221, 0.02635173313319683, 0.05969909951090813, 0.07297568023204803, -0.04135068878531456, 0.012010067701339722, -0.009828954935073853, 0.021737975999712944, 0.06296053528785706, -0.06418729573488235, 0.026052245870232582, -0.014455878175795078, -0.0031829471699893475, -0.03835369274020195, -0.006610081996768713, -0.03295367583632469, -0.02631238102912903, -0.01670483686029911, 0.042747557163238525, 0.008493669331073761, -0.014662470668554306, -0.06887419521808624, 0.018422823399305344, 0.004144384991377592, 0.02091250754892826, -0.02422046661376953, -0.018840748816728592, -0.007378818467259407, 0.04354187473654747, -0.019719278439879417, -0.03762546554207802, 0.0410483255982399, -0.026316747069358826, 0.01346038281917572, 0.06632371991872787, -0.02825259603559971, -0.051932934671640396, 0.012953335419297218, -0.003302441444247961, -0.005012343637645245, -0.023340513929724693, -0.0370882973074913, 0.024322809651494026, -0.0036658563185483217, 0.012884967029094696, 0.030796194449067116, 0.012724352069199085, -0.0017729231622070074, 0.011329748667776585, -0.014387519098818302, 0.000377042219042778, -0.04523178189992905, -0.014165806584060192, -0.02605017088353634, -0.003544540610164404, 0.003337614005431533, 0.008315675891935825, 0.010013798251748085, 0.029530564323067665, -0.009474392980337143, -0.04041149094700813, 0.027731740847229958, 0.04098623991012573, 0.02710684761404991, 0.010854297317564487, -0.026153048500418663, 0.005873893853276968, 0.03736665099859238, -0.05844976752996445, 0.03418117016553879, -0.024803640320897102, 0.026212090626358986, -0.003071496495977044, -0.010308537632226944, -0.02685225009918213, -0.043736085295677185, -0.020792724564671516, 0.007477323524653912, -0.04872142896056175, 0.0368785485625267, -0.030804669484496117, 0.06811079382896423, -0.008025947958230972, -0.01498622540384531, -0.034888628870248795, 0.04108851030468941, -0.030308935791254044, 0.01176391914486885, -0.033675242215394974, 0.07779353111982346, -0.0041199009865522385, -0.03025120683014393, -0.11398078501224518, -0.051907945424318314, 0.00554866436868906, 0.0009694680920802057, -0.0185239240527153, -0.0329139307141304, -0.03565268963575363, 0.0020568545442074537, -0.028487034142017365, 0.000029088265364407562, 0.04013103246688843, -0.0006502809701487422, -0.01720457710325718, -0.017703603953123093, -0.016288571059703827, 0.08226576447486877, 0.015096331015229225, -0.020789537578821182, 0.021208062767982483, -0.05354322865605354, -0.007249027024954557, -0.012554172426462173, -0.02928088791668415, -0.04397162050008774, -0.013077205047011375, -0.022164426743984222, 0.0006688442663289607, 0.003890436142683029, -0.037991635501384735, -0.01678072102367878, -0.0005427336436696351, -0.026290249079465866, 0.02498018927872181, -0.04642195627093315, -0.004575855564326048, -0.018312687054276466, -0.0055203670635819435, -0.011838551610708237, 0.004632334690541029, -0.031513430178165436, 0.02018323540687561, -0.00818369910120964, 0.025160862132906914, -0.006687919609248638, 0.041437648236751556, 0.07630335539579391, 0.012674977071583271, 0.011169718578457832, -0.009709510020911694, -0.010246491990983486, 0.04753388091921806, 0.03376869484782219, -0.005106983706355095, -0.02076251059770584, 0.06762292981147766, -0.04900794103741646, -0.03197081759572029, -0.03205716982483864, 0.0014421006198972464, 0.01666809804737568, 0.0037910158280283213, 0.024813104420900345, 0.05834323540329933, -0.014424797147512436, -0.03832469880580902, -0.015614782460033894, 0.013485451228916645, 0.006291311699897051, 0.036200493574142456, 0.06066334247589111, -0.027211597189307213, 0.041694290935993195, 0.012279263697564602, 0.05490276217460632, 0.013806015253067017, 0.08581557869911194, 0.04051721468567848, -0.001581947784870863, 0.035215385258197784, -0.021254369989037514, -0.043076906353235245, 0.010346343740820885, -0.03461771458387375, 0.005925343371927738, -0.059011589735746384, -0.03878771886229515, 0.031797144562006, 0.0413987822830677, -0.0058177774772048, -0.059365320950746536, -0.025679979473352432, -0.062477532774209976, 0.019205957651138306, 0.002523561706766486, -0.009299678727984428, 0.016619492322206497, -0.004037238657474518, 0.008890699595212936, -0.002750217681750655, 0.013205413706600666, -0.019794756546616554, -0.07278209924697876, -0.012501866556704044, -0.035100117325782776, -0.07292230427265167, 0.020634103566408157, 0.0054312278516590595, -0.007195665501058102, -0.013161581009626389, -0.028535446152091026, -0.004256844520568848, 0.015556410886347294, 0.059499721974134445, 0.01209423691034317, 0.03949145972728729, 0.02308686263859272, -0.014577915892004967, 0.03021857887506485, 0.004211006686091423, 0.10610178858041763, 0.09528500586748123, 0.014942648820579052, -0.039777740836143494, 0.05681142956018448, -0.0023739635944366455, 0.01796099543571472, -0.012430902570486069, 0.02926117740571499, -0.03140432760119438, -0.027796149253845215, 0.03129491209983826, 0.08097896724939346, 0.007770068943500519, 0.013937125913798809, 0.04031037911772728, -0.024208324030041695, -0.03338226303458214, 0.025801101699471474, -0.017481327056884766, -0.00158977834507823, -0.0308647733181715, -0.007852279581129551, 0.007305412087589502, 0.03851410001516342, -0.032248999923467636, -0.03333397954702377, 0.009302479214966297, -0.004772444721311331, 0.022433804348111153, -0.05268516018986702, -0.0027367176953703165, 0.030231453478336334, 0.027157215401530266, -0.07965434342622757, -0.022663842886686325, 0.00416441448032856, -0.04318016767501831, 0.0043494259007275105, 0.050157010555267334, -0.028502829372882843, -0.022924810647964478, 0.002536370884627104, 0.034805238246917725, -0.04121589660644531, -0.022393714636564255, -0.004573321435600519, 0.05051456019282341, -0.020347287878394127, -0.03465646132826805, -0.012470805086195469, 0.022350506857037544, -0.0007216624217107892, -0.059631578624248505, -0.0187314972281456, -0.006467942148447037, 0.02915288507938385, -0.029008258134126663, -0.01540856622159481, -0.029898161068558693, -0.005458385217934847, 0.009740124456584454, 0.014244570396840572, 0.05335594341158867, 0.019468123093247414, -0.020064793527126312, -0.040319208055734634, 0.04743792861700058, -0.003661084920167923, 0.027547523379325867, -0.0019582551904022694, -0.01320783793926239, -0.01643754541873932, 0.007839525118470192, -0.0017203034367412329, 0.03048643469810486, 0.008303436450660229, -0.0053543346002697945, -0.035451967269182205, -0.035279758274555206, -0.02377483807504177, -0.002653747098520398, -0.04777836054563522, -0.015514404512941837, -0.01991070620715618, 0.04864799603819847, 0.001380632515065372, 0.0362938828766346, -0.0086067458614707, 0.015934713184833527, -0.0014434198383241892, 0.055353712290525436, 0.04143416881561279, -0.028585346415638924, -0.0014949034666642547, -0.033475544303655624, -0.025463376194238663, -0.004840105306357145, -0.006021631881594658, 0.08910118043422699, -0.03453589230775833, 0.00321639864705503, 0.04309222474694252, 0.035176727920770645, 0.012272262945771217, 0.011640352196991444, 0.00800852756947279, -0.08373064547777176, 0.024909159168601036, -0.013975821435451508, 0.015230490826070309, -0.006968614645302296, -0.013140958733856678, -0.036198947578668594, -0.03791263699531555, 0.031047947704792023, -0.021844837814569473, -0.03597968816757202, -0.006408912595361471, -0.015124993398785591, 0.05440297722816467, 0.002866371301934123, -0.0008138044504448771, -0.03204640373587608, -0.025963563472032547, 0.010251837782561779, -0.0012042224407196045, -0.015519498847424984, -0.0020129766780883074, -0.007154176943004131, 0.0053762211464345455, 0.014015465043485165, 0.006736693438142538, 0.005704504903405905, -0.008487440645694733, 0.014179154299199581, 0.0038241108413785696, 0.043057240545749664, -0.0348844937980175, 0.008186561986804008, 0.02413260191679001, -0.06651977449655533, -0.009723869152367115, 0.04447314143180847, -0.07154376804828644, 0.07138456404209137, 0.020073745399713516, -0.007897207513451576, -0.03083343803882599, 0.06934642046689987, -0.03320420905947685, -0.06226930767297745, -0.02595364861190319, 0.033791638910770416, 0.007219906430691481, 0.004796582739800215, -0.05296170711517334, 0.004440747667104006, -0.01934218592941761, 0.02519344538450241, 0.04444653540849686, 0.015205228701233864, -0.012187973596155643, 0.01713845692574978, 0.023642970249056816, 0.05234404280781746, -0.01771278865635395, -0.0155290262773633, 0.017198454588651657, 0.04533880949020386, -0.05977397784590721, 0.03992050141096115, -0.009857071563601494, 0.02235724963247776, -0.08039822429418564, -0.025310184806585312, -0.027107374742627144, 0.004701175261288881, 0.01778670772910118, -0.04233229532837868, 0.0021639815531671047, 0.03011064976453781, -0.06031601130962372, -0.006782976444810629, 0.01209721714258194, -0.03995837643742561, -0.059415653347969055, -0.005663652904331684, -0.03025454469025135, -0.011375345289707184, 0.03199906274676323, 0.04164395108819008, 0.019451994448900223, 0.01677480898797512, -0.00999502558261156, -0.0847209095954895, -0.01199754886329174, 0.007924984209239483, -0.0016895082080736756, -0.0472547747194767, -0.005503715015947819, -0.04796728864312172, -0.006960039958357811, 0.013739495538175106, -0.010951511561870575, 0.019538668915629387, 0.05091850832104683, 0.027687977999448776, -0.027309026569128036, 0.05435517057776451, 0.011824282817542553, -0.039684876799583435, -0.01922565884888172, -0.008301209658384323, -0.03415617719292641, -0.0038026149850338697, -0.027244118973612785, 0.051360420882701874, 0.05705683305859566, -0.031989552080631256, -0.006658310070633888, 0.014891758561134338, -0.015778498724102974, -0.03163198009133339, -0.019222043454647064, -0.03779280185699463, 0.06209492310881615, -0.003957637120038271, 0.0028434661217033863, -0.0378832183778286, 0.015134675428271294, 0.0011361553333699703, 0.04252380505204201, 0.0041184332221746445, 0.0006737060029990971, 0.0051289391703903675, -0.011774780228734016, -0.010675273835659027, 0.004014795646071434, -0.01765865460038185, -0.05968957021832466, 0.006227000616490841, 0.0011849204311147332, -0.024400684982538223, -0.013104520738124847, -0.02262640930712223, -0.022429734468460083, 0.04144120216369629, -0.029179826378822327, 0.006618996150791645, 0.05649856477975845, 0.014193377457559109, 0.036534346640110016, -0.058744873851537704, 0.05935974046587944, -0.015721596777439117, -0.004032664000988007, -0.03275709226727486, -0.05523361638188362, -0.023348717018961906, 0.008130933158099651, 0.043198395520448685, 0.022616883739829063, 0.0036695811431854963, -0.02972675859928131, 0.04280324652791023, 0.006385252811014652, -0.0027889572083950043, 0.02548961155116558, 0.005115867126733065, -0.03884256258606911, -0.040611714124679565, -0.003928429447114468, 0.05415702238678932, -0.01689530909061432, 0.0243067666888237, -0.017118379473686218, -0.00033133395481854677, -0.0030348203144967556, -0.019461408257484436, 0.019398283213377, -0.012845047749578953, -0.012577690184116364, 0.04959782585501671, -0.0060257078148424625, -0.010395070537924767, 0.027251940220594406, 0.03652859851717949, -0.015660718083381653, 0.047222837805747986, -0.028695115819573402, -0.017937008291482925, -0.026890520006418228, 0.033350128680467606, -0.02476796694099903, -0.05445571616292, 0.004683621693402529, 0.026176298037171364, -0.03216341882944107, 0.00546375522390008, 0.030961811542510986, 0.02230105735361576, 0.023199284449219704, -0.008180063217878342, 0.02414693869650364, -0.00040054702549241483, -0.02495342679321766, 0.03569217771291733, 0.0024628564715385437, 0.012576045468449593, 0.024928918108344078, 0.024406708776950836, 0.045087773352861404, -0.039696093648672104, 0.03598392382264137, -0.0022997120395302773, 0.0008835000335238874, 0.0034097812604159117, -0.003582935780286789, -0.010601960122585297, -0.026899300515651703, 0.05016780644655228, -0.021246232092380524, -0.01399060059338808, 0.048946935683488846, -0.026448510587215424, -0.0043676006607711315, -0.0466170497238636, -0.020459525287151337, -0.03612978011369705, 0.004368739668279886, 0.011078272014856339, 0.0382116325199604, 0.000573769910261035, 0.027529114857316017, 0.007036648225039244, 0.009003820829093456, 0.03611791878938675, -0.02310684323310852, 0.012907383032143116, -0.035533029586076736, -0.0054943799041211605, -0.022769490256905556, -0.01533236913383007, 0.02339199371635914, 0.005517855286598206, 0.02480170503258705, 0.02010398730635643, 0.03368162736296654, -0.04322785884141922, -0.015927914530038834, 0.0472487211227417, 0.0299464650452137, 0.004252410493791103, -0.06717915832996368, -0.048979006707668304, 0.006987231317907572, -0.014924411661922932, -0.02347475104033947 ]
<p>Suppose I run some models with following format.The dependent variable as the sum of realized values of a binary random variable over multiple trials, that is "number of yes votes on bills":</p> <pre><code> Coef. SE z (Constant) 0.467 0.239 1.950 SPD 0.094 0.174 0.541 #parties -0.218 0.100 -2.192 $\gamma$ 0.012 0.009 1.374 logL -41.21 </code></pre> <p>and I would like to calculate the first difference effect of increasing the number of parties by one on the expected number of times a state approves of the federal government’s proposal out of 103 votes. How can I do that based on my regression output?</p>
73,570
[ -0.0009274423937313259, -0.0257146917283535, 0.016575301066040993, 0.026256371289491653, 0.0033484967425465584, 0.027345942333340645, -0.008753566071391106, -0.04385562613606453, 0.04482273384928703, -0.02137623354792595, 0.038070518523454666, 0.01796593703329563, 0.05502109229564667, -0.01437588781118393, 0.05412650853395462, 0.017620310187339783, 0.015599356032907963, 0.033019132912158966, 0.01277181413024664, 0.005617442540824413, -0.006436465308070183, 0.03256470337510109, 0.027006126940250397, 0.009746132418513298, 0.029316069558262825, 0.07497862726449966, 0.023443004116415977, -0.007652367930859327, -0.011640767566859722, 0.030054159462451935, -0.011940359137952328, -0.04336772486567497, -0.0033963166642934084, 0.024478886276483536, 0.024674685671925545, 0.015372279100120068, -0.027209151536226273, -0.03996694087982178, -0.021570367738604546, 0.017675181850790977, -0.009908693842589855, -0.013462151400744915, -0.0026036053895950317, 0.04049254581332207, -0.009325327351689339, -0.0012362705310806632, -0.0024713827297091484, -0.0352630577981472, 0.03500859811902046, -0.003566920990124345, 0.058366309851408005, -0.02358601801097393, 0.03836054354906082, 0.019767114892601967, -0.029380934312939644, 0.0008717533200979233, 0.024739691987633705, 0.03919723629951477, 0.009798822924494743, -0.04762212932109833, -0.02347402088344097, -0.03631419688463211, 0.022397255524992943, -0.02763233706355095, -0.030418654903769493, -0.01467866450548172, -0.02325418032705784, -0.03258415684103966, 0.011793458834290504, -0.03420295566320419, -0.005928539205342531, 0.012629657052457333, 0.0531185008585453, -0.010128703899681568, -0.0059105828404426575, -0.03825419396162033, -0.001124118804000318, 0.023320170119404793, 0.029253775253891945, 0.05049964785575867, -0.038910191506147385, 0.0126716373488307, 0.0258171409368515, 0.04612843692302704, 0.022646896541118622, 0.0019491586135700345, 0.039519667625427246, -0.053893767297267914, 0.06958179175853729, 0.033292971551418304, -0.007516258396208286, 0.01781948283314705, 0.10209960490465164, 0.018610568717122078, -0.031152311712503433, 0.03906303644180298, -0.03204873204231262, 0.04474622383713722, 0.020824303850531578, 0.004930716939270496, -0.027169954031705856, -0.06769558042287827, 0.01670467108488083, -0.0013564678374677896, -0.0014464363921433687, -0.003998917527496815, -0.019416814669966698, -0.014333056285977364, -0.02627585642039776, -0.047061726450920105, -0.0073853484354913235, 0.009766741655766964, -0.017265560105443, -0.010763337835669518, 0.032122451812028885, -0.019628049805760384, -0.05096297338604927, -0.0030982906464487314, 0.03137508034706116, 0.0502237007021904, 0.04525655880570412, -0.02101150155067444, 0.025437599048018456, -0.02283184789121151, -0.043254952877759933, -0.006944447290152311, 0.014490221627056599, -0.011880924925208092, -0.04661785438656807, 0.0390998050570488, -0.021463697776198387, -0.052077095955610275, -0.0010225463192909956, 0.005716379266232252, 0.02179841510951519, 0.04809538647532463, -0.04974498227238655, -0.047088537365198135, 0.003319966606795788, -0.004446362145245075, 0.029545800760388374, -0.03406105935573578, 0.022516239434480667, 0.0031621495727449656, 0.0785498172044754, 0.014073992148041725, 0.05950523912906647, 0.02364797703921795, 0.047868821769952774, 0.03290572762489319, -0.02066187933087349, -0.015619177371263504, -0.026081319898366928, -0.020547905936837196, -0.0208763275295496, -0.056745339184999466, 0.04983242601156235, -0.01978309080004692, -0.007299352437257767, 0.005291546694934368, 0.04484337568283081, -0.0017816309118643403, -0.01613140106201172, 0.007423772010952234, -0.005418332293629646, -0.03893681615591049, 0.08185698091983795, -0.001000834396108985, 0.000845596136059612, 0.0011928550666198134, 0.003522702492773533, -0.015416126698255539, -0.013240487314760685, 0.030565952882170677, 0.04162265360355377, 0.0020387524273246527, -0.024523094296455383, -0.027056870982050896, 0.007419976405799389, 0.010487574152648449, -0.007023395039141178, -0.021211247891187668, -0.040209267288446426, 0.005943323951214552, 0.007378492038697004, 0.022784603759646416, 0.0295098964124918, -0.004672868177294731, 0.03302496671676636, -0.06010685861110687, -0.03098687157034874, -0.0892714187502861, -0.0033598216250538826, 0.0019258601823821664, -0.0012915150728076696, 0.020887942984700203, 0.019184734672307968, 0.025288568809628487, 0.010954285971820354, -0.026154380291700363, -0.04799728840589523, -0.008941145613789558, 0.04676244780421257, -0.043882228434085846, -0.024470258504152298, 0.02735235169529915, 0.08961506932973862, -0.014657198451459408, 0.08650536835193634, -0.04427029937505722, -0.017052141949534416, 0.012118409387767315, -0.05168011784553528, -0.025884931907057762, 0.012634324841201305, -0.0037746040616184473, 0.011642604134976864, -0.020510289818048477, -0.018098752945661545, 0.0016699912957847118, -0.04847155138850212, 0.0480964295566082, 0.11740127950906754, 0.0283188596367836, 0.004996452480554581, -0.0000658661374473013, 0.010392395779490471, -0.005728411953896284, -0.024556728079915047, -0.018084527924656868, -0.06336916983127594, -0.024673182517290115, 0.012468783184885979, 0.0007211772026494145, -0.04228660836815834, -0.003245206782594323, 0.05352945253252983, -0.005879546981304884, 0.03962129354476929, 0.04598737135529518, -0.007683993317186832, -0.01720057800412178, 0.03856613487005234, 0.007347885984927416, 0.04290859401226044, -0.003557654097676277, 0.03699704632163048, 0.013559333048760891, 0.02665439061820507, 0.015061674639582634, 0.01581578515470028, 0.017077868804335594, -0.014734743162989616, 0.00004145369166508317, 0.006391197443008423, -0.022623173892498016, 0.05061783269047737, -0.01815495453774929, -0.014765785075724125, 0.04168403148651123, -0.0023752052802592516, -0.0014891286846250296, 0.01262714248150587, -0.02817484550178051, -0.01713591441512108, 0.04208670184016228, -0.06676147878170013, 0.013996882364153862, 0.027630988508462906, -0.045776378363370895, 0.02078530564904213, -0.009916611015796661, -0.026888824999332428, -0.07201363146305084, 0.028004614636301994, 0.008931131102144718, -0.002504515228793025, -0.0121407276019454, -0.014478115364909172, -0.02943732775747776, 0.009852648712694645, -0.01941680908203125, 0.025686051696538925, -0.007468170020729303, -0.07907050848007202, 0.013401145115494728, -0.015206604264676571, -0.023913774639368057, -0.0126582570374012, 0.0056594661436975, -0.015811588615179062, 0.041883766651153564, 0.014391744509339333, -0.01676427572965622, -0.0348391979932785, -0.019930599257349968, -0.0012749709421768785, -0.02023843489587307, -0.016516653820872307, 0.015594812110066414, -0.015723470598459244, -0.02742454782128334, -0.010837947949767113, -0.028713641688227654, 0.032032184302806854, -0.026535797864198685, -0.0017670002998784184, -0.019182054325938225, 0.009594608098268509, -0.0006758790696039796, -0.00021097727585583925, -0.022860122844576836, -0.0050385333597660065, -0.11252494901418686, -0.034529898315668106, -0.0018737659556791186, 0.01024643238633871, 0.037178996950387955, -0.022999776527285576, -0.03035583905875683, 0.046142835170030594, 0.03456154093146324, -0.022370614111423492, -0.06885704398155212, 0.002820531139150262, -0.028932780027389526, -0.030940670520067215, 0.005790776573121548, 0.029058145359158516, -0.014961885288357735, 0.04444023221731186, 0.03335598111152649, 0.03145422786474228, 0.05613217502832413, 0.007605765946209431, 0.0019517953041940928, 0.004756547510623932, -0.016552381217479706, 0.0020111941266804934, 0.02794170379638672, 0.014912161976099014, -0.0098824268206954, 0.03668472543358803, 0.019561490043997765, 0.016109196469187737, -0.013935795053839684, -0.05814860761165619, -0.003799047553911805, 0.03334590047597885, -0.021184485405683517, -0.05065896362066269, 0.05815146118402481, 0.032836999744176865, -0.03215454891324043, -0.009110833518207073, 0.018668700009584427, 0.04726120084524155, -0.04575834423303604, 0.004213358741253614, 0.015133434906601906, 0.028393900021910667, 0.012004033662378788, -0.03170027956366539, -0.03324711695313454, -0.026733990758657455, -0.015110642649233341, -0.03331027179956436, -0.007141065318137407, 0.05931391566991806, 0.04674369841814041, 0.04302113130688667, -0.02744477428495884, -0.048650629818439484, -0.006038255989551544, -0.04188006371259689, -0.01632394827902317, -0.015501454472541809, 0.07906699925661087, 0.03171144798398018, 0.022589396685361862, -0.01585473120212555, 0.003488389076665044, 0.02455058880150318, -0.07086218148469925, -0.07373258471488953, 0.049088843166828156, 0.003947095014154911, -0.006274406332522631, 0.00939690601080656, -0.01601116545498371, 0.03257972374558449, -0.0319308377802372, 0.03465285152196884, 0.019237326458096504, 0.010432353243231773, -0.020607149228453636, -0.01634654588997364, -0.019575616344809532, -0.017561737447977066, -0.004538540728390217, -0.0141011206433177, 0.00589188514277339, -0.03952991962432861, 0.013221930712461472, 0.014281351119279861, 0.0005842478130944073, -0.013917160220444202, -0.06149524822831154, 0.030410056933760643, 0.010062562301754951, 0.056756939738988876, 0.08076056092977524, 0.014961253851652145, -0.01505042053759098, 0.04443724453449249, -0.009273211471736431, 0.04764827340841293, 0.07551641017198563, 0.02001173608005047, -0.010532266460359097, -0.055686283856630325, -0.009372922591865063, 0.004355623386800289, 0.028160829097032547, 0.021743331104516983, 0.017436085268855095, 0.03467602655291557, 0.04379940778017044, -0.028466302901506424, 0.016207892447710037, 0.05834593251347542, -0.0034411209635436535, 0.010069097392261028, -0.037278853356838226, 0.023436807096004486, 0.0045634363777935505, -0.0026278586592525244, 0.014144117012619972, 0.01883094012737274, -0.0003620862844400108, 0.015868978574872017, 0.024896716699004173, -0.028877444565296173, -0.010685073211789131, -0.03135613352060318, -0.003166445530951023, 0.02432977221906185, 0.020459456369280815, -0.049851782619953156, -0.011061024852097034, 0.07414349168539047, 0.004734301008284092, -0.008308914490044117, 0.013790428638458252, -0.10414693504571915, 0.012744569219648838, 0.03690194711089134, 0.023817772045731544, -0.04988890141248703, -0.026074662804603577, -0.01645214855670929, 0.009227411821484566, 0.03281750902533531, -0.028666414320468903, 0.03563382104039192, 0.02136382833123207, 0.017575275152921677, 0.0014115771045908332, -0.030627163127064705, -0.08545928448438644, 0.06372970342636108, -0.02680199220776558, 0.032873619347810745, -0.02379979006946087, -0.05917087197303772, -0.04214830696582794, 0.0007153013139031827, 0.013151356019079685, 0.044728927314281464, -0.03844708576798439, -0.02088654227554798, 0.004253034014254808, 0.038456179201602936, -0.04302181676030159, -0.01980818249285221, 0.015095211565494537, -0.0051153600215911865, 0.01164976879954338, 0.024136919528245926, 0.04470598325133324, -0.0007978883222676814, 0.02677108533680439, 0.02436303161084652, -0.023906385526061058, -0.027272967621684074, 0.00029985266155563295, 0.046194326132535934, 0.04030634090304375, -0.01193423941731453, 0.03491124138236046, 0.038907844573259354, 0.00296800397336483, 0.026447398588061333, -0.003095705062150955, -0.010029522702097893, -0.0038715670816600323, 0.014093726873397827, -0.026195110753178596, 0.028444183990359306, 0.02477205917239189, 0.0006935411947779357, -0.04137742146849632, -0.017558012157678604, -0.03265180066227913, 0.027990128844976425, -0.020061351358890533, 0.025576984509825706, -0.03507198393344879, -0.017610961571335793, 0.012383095920085907, 0.01700645685195923, -0.02415250428020954, -0.0469832606613636, 0.011465906165540218, -0.05045071989297867, -0.010466779582202435, -0.011562702246010303, -0.041809435933828354, 0.0333755724132061, 0.013822164386510849, -0.009980122558772564, 0.031430602073669434, -0.02557399682700634, 0.006781858392059803, 0.003667422104626894, 0.022774286568164825, -0.0050742169842123985, -0.017456231638789177, -0.010559112764894962, 0.015350502915680408, -0.00029493507463485, -0.014102294109761715, -0.06128659471869469, 0.02935495786368847, -0.0010463090147823095, -0.047192689031362534, -0.07088745385408401, -0.04644925519824028, 0.05460939183831215, -0.00423031859099865, -0.01269256230443716, -0.009540418162941933, -0.04560970887541771, 0.0011584401363506913, -0.014090455137193203, -0.009879035875201225, 0.025976883247494698, -0.007667212281376123, 0.0038261222653090954, -0.004061601590365171, 0.0333406962454319, 0.056478921324014664, -0.015324418433010578, -0.030219990760087967, 0.014218655414879322, -0.06246281787753105, -0.03877861425280571, 0.015064527280628681, -0.013321113772690296, -0.05213113874197006, 0.019780447706580162, 0.0011834986507892609, -0.007504596374928951, 0.039418239146471024, 0.008293649181723595, -0.0012413000222295523, 0.027469592168927193, 0.011599289253354073, 0.022021783515810966, -0.03841037303209305, -0.03537309169769287, -0.022806230932474136, 0.01973399519920349, -0.004485187586396933, 0.0013171025784686208, -0.006176800467073917, -0.0005301879136823118, 0.0063902041874825954, 0.018723538145422935, -0.008204826153814793, -0.0022165891714394093, 0.09303467720746994, -0.00709457928314805, 0.022119183093309402, 0.05102824047207832, 0.00046428744099102914, 0.04499850422143936, -0.002193099819123745, -0.010582199320197105, 0.02721600979566574, 0.0085429223254323, -0.050761375576257706, -0.012612712569534779, -0.002617770805954933, -0.024633152410387993, 0.04220625385642052, -0.022175481542944908, 0.04547087103128433, 0.03788932040333748, -0.009172052145004272, 0.020383350551128387, -0.030038435012102127, -0.02888450212776661, -0.030104029923677444, 0.005006118677556515, 0.04684315621852875, -0.004189847037196159, -0.014372197911143303, 0.04644721746444702, 0.03287970647215843, -0.006882938556373119, 0.06265949457883835, 0.009720167145133018, -0.0187221746891737, 0.02415410429239273, -0.01671762764453888, -0.015091356821358204, 0.04050087183713913, -0.04196667671203613, -0.0011230981908738613, -0.08587048947811127, -0.020851781591773033, 0.02979166805744171, 0.038640376180410385, -0.012882847338914871, -0.047995515167713165, -0.028864732012152672, -0.072214275598526, 0.04109116271138191, 0.015602787025272846, -0.023160066455602646, 0.06552890688180923, 0.009943568147718906, 0.06471020728349686, 0.008108347654342651, 0.038864653557538986, -0.04952602460980415, -0.040818195790052414, -0.0024910401552915573, -0.03854154422879219, -0.00762550625950098, 0.0259088184684515, -0.008109189569950104, -0.0076148840598762035, 0.04910585656762123, -0.032499101012945175, 0.006265401840209961, 0.018007483333349228, 0.020868605002760887, 0.018104443326592445, 0.07188445329666138, 0.006027605850249529, 0.01148494053632021, 0.013598332181572914, -0.02248966693878174, 0.1133425384759903, 0.1015876904129982, 0.03789175674319267, -0.04501930624246597, 0.029103849083185196, 0.054748158901929855, -0.005382711999118328, -0.015340540558099747, -0.011995792388916016, 0.014344786293804646, 0.0027601246256381273, 0.040204811841249466, 0.04913319647312164, 0.008928216993808746, 0.011575339362025261, 0.04290274158120155, -0.05536770075559616, -0.00035318121081218123, 0.02046726644039154, 0.01707496866583824, 0.02065960317850113, -0.032728321850299835, -0.056776393204927444, 0.007173433899879456, -0.0019841415341943502, -0.014739717356860638, -0.023592399433255196, -0.02247500978410244, -0.006182655692100525, -0.01794864796102047, -0.013912941329181194, 0.006389576476067305, 0.037477776408195496, 0.03178887069225311, -0.043225716799497604, 0.015117944218218327, 0.06476385146379471, -0.028735550120472908, 0.009879945777356625, 0.007280812598764896, 0.0031306608580052853, 0.025093264877796173, -0.03541465103626251, 0.022468777373433113, -0.03446543216705322, -0.002625089604407549, -0.02519248053431511, 0.04151276871562004, 0.004227024037390947, 0.007422625552862883, -0.02659241296350956, -0.011456392705440521, 0.006951937451958656, 0.008748904801905155, -0.014991877600550652, -0.00543557433411479, -0.019308406859636307, 0.003798761870712042, -0.004431437235325575, -0.007702165748924017, 0.014626337215304375, 0.006723092868924141, -0.0029564069118350744, 0.03891247883439064, -0.03163374587893486, -0.018161233514547348, -0.058073993772268295, 0.07229871302843094, -0.022903943434357643, -0.03472084552049637, 0.011141904629766941, -0.010648159310221672, -0.048255596309900284, -0.02456717938184738, -0.006013158243149519, -0.0070517174899578094, -0.009011945687234402, -0.007831042632460594, -0.01724129170179367, -0.053891707211732864, 0.0033880206756293774, -0.003945272881537676, -0.02196897566318512, 0.021380463615059853, -0.04010329395532608, 0.002048426540568471, 0.028884558007121086, 0.02247045747935772, 0.008710176683962345, -0.011314652860164642, 0.000692569010425359, 0.08583497256040573, 0.01015498023480177, -0.0435609444975853, -0.030221479013562202, -0.03203943744301796, -0.027156483381986618, 0.004303324967622757, -0.012581023387610912, 0.041928961873054504, 0.0002114857197739184, -0.018874382600188255, -0.025984210893511772, 0.043538983911275864, -0.04047048091888428, 0.022584471851587296, 0.01109636016190052, -0.0512508898973465, -0.02607746049761772, 0.007943451404571533, -0.005178732331842184, -0.0008157372358255088, 0.02411005087196827, -0.01686244085431099, -0.03588598594069481, 0.05397012084722519, -0.04381466284394264, -0.05021273344755173, 0.006945802364498377, -0.01857595518231392, 0.028358185663819313, 0.0010082408552989364, -0.015486803837120533, -0.03516367822885513, -0.008180459029972553, 0.014734896831214428, -0.0010671726195141673, -0.006836930755525827, 0.04384457319974899, 0.013420691713690758, -0.0035737149883061647, 0.009537787176668644, 0.041915200650691986, 0.06818497180938721, -0.01298443041741848, 0.04701502248644829, 0.01848272979259491, 0.057411737740039825, -0.020032072439789772, -0.02924446016550064, 0.025543734431266785, -0.0680481493473053, 0.0020527520682662725, 0.034938178956508636, 0.019812844693660736, 0.03964700922369957, 0.002262537134811282, 0.019925249740481377, -0.003577008144930005, 0.026272371411323547, -0.007985087111592293, 0.0056679691188037395, -0.024023929610848427, 0.0013489675475284457, 0.010332717560231686, -0.027473149821162224, 0.004934587981551886, -0.007601848337799311, -0.0029726882930845022, -0.002158573130145669, 0.05204129219055176, -0.015058972872793674, -0.004847259260714054, -0.016712747514247894, 0.007818052545189857, -0.012563749216496944, 0.006799174007028341, -0.022228030487895012, 0.036574020981788635, 0.042701803147792816, -0.024797845631837845, -0.0025888741947710514, -0.0083677489310503, 0.026473358273506165, -0.0683792233467102, -0.0057834843173623085, -0.01630663126707077, -0.0057535674422979355, 0.012708671391010284, -0.03924303129315376, 0.07039368152618408, 0.004244927782565355, -0.009527868591248989, -0.04179364815354347, -0.01012514904141426, 0.021969500929117203, -0.024925218895077705, 0.05899214744567871, -0.027299445122480392, 0.02394881844520569, 0.05551695451140404, 0.02499651350080967, 0.05295037850737572, 0.0004582539258990437, 0.03881016746163368, -0.025927770882844925, -0.009046721272170544, 0.005685171112418175, 0.03161875158548355, -0.05971859395503998, 0.0007238374673761427, -0.0654025599360466, -0.016952969133853912, 0.037589456886053085, -0.041673511266708374, 0.03280580788850784, -0.02428532764315605, 0.03135259449481964, -0.005973064806312323, 0.060536906123161316, 0.017463531345129013, 0.00940730981528759, -0.015302683226764202, -0.026553772389888763, -0.013686684891581535, -0.03718741238117218, 0.0022425635252147913, 0.032326165586709976, 0.0327737033367157, 0.02012951299548149, 0.00909618940204382, -0.0050867656245827675, 0.01334949117153883, -0.011232532560825348, -0.017279863357543945, 0.012654990889132023, 0.007093450520187616, 0.010443564504384995, 0.007237243000417948, -0.07243379950523376, 0.031039251014590263, 0.02902531810104847, -0.0023211005609482527, -0.030862754210829735, -0.0037767880130559206, -0.02658500149846077, -0.05160019174218178, 0.01869889162480831, -0.019913125783205032, -0.019984565675258636, -0.04023337736725807, -0.0250217504799366, -0.010703925974667072, 0.0058241854421794415, -0.011164172552525997, 0.01259139459580183, -0.0432891808450222, 0.03402404114603996, -0.03840929642319679, -0.023768017068505287, -0.004641205072402954, 0.02453044056892395, 0.07232707738876343, -0.06154576316475868, 0.042746976017951965, 0.013189303688704967, -0.013364993035793304, -0.010015706531703472, -0.0023729288950562477, -0.020019201561808586, 0.01354245562106371, 0.05551742762327194, 0.007972221821546555, 0.0009669221471995115, 0.00039365229895338416, 0.03350009396672249, 0.007044553756713867, -0.039148472249507904, 0.030715813860297203, -0.03891224414110184, -0.007664589211344719, -0.017597826197743416, 0.0062457239255309105, 0.022497886791825294, 0.011283393017947674, 0.02125970646739006, -0.007917756214737892, -0.013380863703787327, -0.013660449534654617, -0.015662148594856262, 0.007994115352630615, 0.010611544363200665, -0.02509245276451111, 0.029702546074986458, -0.006619594059884548, 0.016345079988241196, 0.019776778295636177, 0.03217436373233795, -0.0682293251156807, 0.02273636683821678, -0.05343002453446388, -0.0369638055562973, 0.004549449775367975, -0.03647485002875328, -0.010033599101006985, -0.059202246367931366, 0.027110692113637924, 0.0216929130256176, -0.020134374499320984, 0.035348691046237946, 0.03629438951611519, -0.02047463320195675, 0.00792095996439457, -0.00870792381465435, 0.025849515572190285, -0.004422018304467201, -0.025404449552297592, 0.0023333902936428785, 0.023594388738274574, 0.0009327579173259437, 0.018724657595157623, 0.011691877618432045, 0.02871171571314335, -0.01739504560828209, 0.052158866077661514, -0.015481469221413136, -0.007029891014099121, -0.008842685259878635, -0.014266391284763813, 0.01590435765683651, 0.04304516687989235, -0.0006728944135829806, 0.00665296008810401, 0.01386330183595419, -0.0014936699299141765, -0.036673229187726974, 0.013777168467640877, -0.05634498968720436, -0.008742522448301315, -0.013052845373749733, -0.01862434484064579, 0.028629101812839508, 0.04207474738359451, 0.02564864791929722, 0.006260203663259745, 0.01823684573173523, -0.0278268214315176, 0.0031300694681704044, -0.021577589213848114, 0.02293105609714985, -0.007330518681555986, -0.032132815569639206, 0.02514003776013851, -0.03060700185596943, -0.027193646878004074, -0.02223784476518631, 0.0274679996073246, 0.008893916383385658, 0.011833702214062214, 0.008160275407135487, -0.06343129277229309, 0.005624195095151663, 0.059981636703014374, -0.04454061761498451, -0.07147720456123352, -0.02934226766228676, 0.01413662824779749, -0.00709979934617877, -0.00968571100383997 ]
<p>Suppose I have random variables $X_i$ which are Poisson distributed with mean $\mu$. I m interested in the sampling distribution of the variable $\frac{X_1+...+X_n}{n}$. We now that as $n$ goes to infinity, the distribution of mean is Gaussian. Assuming that I know the underlying distribution which is Poisson, is there a way to compute a bound for $n$ say $N$ such that if $n&gt;N$ then we have convergence with some small error $\epsilon$ ?</p>
35,967
[ -0.0010079668136313558, -0.02523079700767994, 0.012618811801075935, -0.033421870321035385, 0.0325823649764061, 0.019927863031625748, -0.0035005523823201656, -0.030895844101905823, 0.008388994261622429, -0.033783961087465286, 0.04303824529051781, 0.04864814132452011, 0.038868337869644165, 0.013135416433215141, 0.023864170536398888, 0.005613138433545828, -0.04527799040079117, 0.003990985918790102, 0.003080688649788499, -0.0165406484156847, -0.016578590497374535, 0.08427400887012482, 0.03121647611260414, -0.02337634190917015, -0.051684316247701645, 0.021890586242079735, 0.06737296283245087, -0.025484666228294373, 0.0071568721905350685, 0.07166942209005356, -0.010026281699538231, -0.00019112987502012402, 0.05035180225968361, 0.06257502734661102, 0.02737235277891159, -0.001846077386289835, -0.0049491021782159805, -0.03931322693824768, 0.024110300466418266, -0.016419341787695885, -0.044153936207294464, 0.0006660391227342188, 0.011032745242118835, 0.007045967038720846, -0.004902957007288933, 0.035007767379283905, -0.019288720563054085, -0.07316095381975174, 0.031255658715963364, -0.03917206823825836, 0.05519133061170578, -0.010788503102958202, 0.0395965576171875, 0.022716043516993523, 0.041721608489751816, -0.012643376365303993, 0.0454285591840744, 0.08306177705526352, 0.02760356478393078, -0.06037997081875801, 0.007414848543703556, -0.03684115409851074, -0.0015010257484391332, -0.0357724130153656, -0.04117199406027794, 0.017360521480441093, -0.04314941540360451, -0.025364723056554794, -0.00818618293851614, 0.002581726759672165, -0.014395704492926598, 0.018069637939333916, 0.030616166070103645, 0.023868024349212646, -0.04208221659064293, 0.013707970269024372, 0.011710923165082932, -0.020808150991797447, 0.040760017931461334, 0.027701303362846375, 0.03051029145717621, 0.011540239676833153, 0.02924259938299656, 0.02415315993130207, 0.02312730997800827, -0.035025112330913544, 0.05719361826777458, -0.02897028438746929, -0.005283109378069639, 0.014338353648781776, -0.01762707717716694, -0.008564841002225876, 0.04472435265779495, -0.021045653149485588, -0.034574203193187714, 0.027625348418951035, -0.03609038144350052, -0.014872693456709385, 0.00039200441096909344, -0.027380725368857384, -0.011540289968252182, -0.04437237232923508, 0.015503098256886005, 0.06710188835859299, -0.015228050760924816, 0.008435460738837719, 0.00757225975394249, -0.00643818499520421, -0.006903346162289381, -0.02945452183485031, -0.02053900435566902, 0.0042761522345244884, 0.009493938647210598, 0.01933920383453369, -0.0035082863178104162, 0.01815786212682724, 0.002522143768146634, -0.03784654662013054, 0.022038472816348076, 0.09469685703516006, 0.033499691635370255, 0.004161780700087547, 0.0444042906165123, -0.015641702339053154, -0.0603044219315052, 0.015017775818705559, 0.02460491470992565, 0.002733829664066434, -0.06781260669231415, 0.04840288311243057, 0.026087502017617226, -0.02717471867799759, 0.03301229700446129, 0.01333292480558157, 0.07387978583574295, 0.01011321134865284, -0.06190744787454605, -0.013288917019963264, 0.035571034997701645, -0.042521312832832336, -0.008364696986973286, -0.06653165817260742, -0.00019324001914355904, 0.06292217969894409, 0.03298517316579819, 0.05169904977083206, 0.03776578605175018, -0.021502889692783356, 0.028327301144599915, 0.01697157695889473, -0.02208971232175827, -0.016714928671717644, -0.030613919720053673, 0.016299504786729813, -0.004235531203448772, -0.07001884281635284, 0.0254654623568058, 0.020224185660481453, -0.01621312089264393, -0.03419973701238632, 0.009927965700626373, -0.009007895365357399, 0.01162203773856163, -0.06281090527772903, 0.007367632817476988, -0.03326496481895447, 0.057982608675956726, 0.019952358677983284, 0.025825345888733864, -0.02579377591609955, 0.003318049479275942, 0.0331110879778862, 0.01742183417081833, 0.013709831051528454, 0.07841256260871887, -0.044386476278305054, 0.00015932867245282978, -0.02688860520720482, 0.0019016553414985538, 0.05556252598762512, 0.010310363955795765, 0.004027302842587233, -0.023059101775288582, -0.0004814544226974249, 0.04082637280225754, 0.006093339063227177, 0.034430984407663345, 0.0014686492504552007, -0.01030811108648777, -0.05754860118031502, -0.008600566536188126, -0.06223759800195694, 0.0025031412951648235, 0.04289941117167473, -0.007315381895750761, 0.029578762128949165, -0.004551030229777098, -0.01059337891638279, -0.0280489269644022, -0.03921746835112572, -0.0071157412603497505, -0.008701452985405922, 0.008612551726400852, -0.06577291339635849, 0.0029232902452349663, 0.01238911971449852, 0.030978303402662277, 0.008293072693049908, 0.06509575247764587, -0.018188180401921272, -0.031556226313114166, -0.004773181863129139, -0.011718119494616985, 0.02243398316204548, 0.003918713424354792, 0.039698462933301926, 0.032290466129779816, -0.01245594397187233, -0.007490223273634911, 0.027886223047971725, -0.04302093759179115, 0.039125774055719376, 0.06237797439098358, 0.053487636148929596, -0.023351171985268593, -0.00743086077272892, 0.04256231337785721, -0.017581595107913017, -0.024327781051397324, -0.04192444682121277, -0.01789245754480362, 0.02699950896203518, 0.021842023357748985, 0.07141788303852081, -0.058611731976270676, 0.00941056851297617, 0.057333383709192276, 0.015128902159631252, 0.03604324534535408, 0.025600703433156013, -0.01631040684878826, -0.012294991873204708, -0.000059241068811388686, 0.00735256914049387, 0.012693548575043678, 0.01607866771519184, 0.04071734845638275, 0.0003204566310159862, 0.007429894059896469, -0.0033063325099647045, -0.00467671500518918, 0.007069965824484825, 0.005112939048558474, -0.000933582428842783, -0.005217154044657946, -0.033406104892492294, 0.016430644318461418, -0.013063880614936352, 0.022723069414496422, 0.006891234777867794, 0.011478250846266747, -0.0035411289427429438, -0.02698824740946293, -0.03175722062587738, 0.020625028759241104, 0.0073144868947565556, -0.05466855689883232, -0.02646620199084282, 0.02408515103161335, -0.054584864526987076, 0.024077706038951874, -0.03784041106700897, -0.019464125856757164, -0.0005536620737984776, -0.0006500384188257158, 0.020993784070014954, 0.0020658024586737156, -0.010251388885080814, 0.0006938999285921454, 0.006484050303697586, -0.009955856949090958, 0.016855735331773758, 0.00919968169182539, 0.008646409958600998, -0.025941794738173485, -0.005825914442539215, 0.009527850896120071, -0.03554495424032211, 0.012287567369639874, 0.010902824811637402, 0.011264552362263203, 0.03831386938691139, 0.004737196955829859, -0.03817274793982506, 0.031126519665122032, -0.0007363810436800122, -0.014751151204109192, -0.042780183255672455, 0.0016358214197680354, 0.03508557006716728, 0.026719432324171066, -0.010983195155858994, 0.027291562408208847, -0.018923955038189888, -0.05849025398492813, -0.05278676375746727, 0.015205071307718754, 0.022507155314087868, 0.001179323298856616, 0.05703048035502434, 0.03924225643277168, 0.0074879988096654415, -0.00603844877332449, -0.05549190193414688, -0.07626910507678986, 0.027580825611948967, -0.015081251971423626, 0.048723574727773666, 0.024241918697953224, -0.0004208960453979671, 0.04944314435124397, 0.03429853171110153, 0.011669574305415154, -0.0038931008893996477, 0.019076189026236534, 0.006643183063715696, -0.02436016872525215, 0.027769459411501884, -0.010549151338636875, -0.02660640887916088, 0.017407948151230812, 0.02917078696191311, 0.019588032737374306, 0.024390537291765213, -0.009883950464427471, 0.016517819836735725, -0.0024171664845198393, -0.028790486976504326, 0.043221887201070786, 0.009426833130419254, 0.007828912697732449, -0.0412820540368557, 0.0062848725356161594, 0.03163471445441246, 0.03445969521999359, 0.006862082984298468, -0.018432289361953735, 0.011024019680917263, -0.016143783926963806, -0.0017436629859730601, -0.018889551982283592, 0.05266674607992172, 0.009440002031624317, -0.022519292309880257, -0.0021598786115646362, 0.04943637549877167, -0.0019102211808785796, -0.040235087275505066, 0.02173314429819584, 0.03283463791012764, 0.05050616338849068, -0.03332151100039482, -0.020207097753882408, -0.024028263986110687, -0.02875717729330063, -0.001788482186384499, -0.02429727092385292, -0.012057844549417496, -0.012342657893896103, 0.04731743037700653, -0.016726847738027573, -0.003129712538793683, 0.015110903419554234, 0.009778175503015518, -0.03267965838313103, -0.03721650317311287, 0.01631208509206772, 0.053966693580150604, 0.01022936962544918, 0.05868280678987503, 0.0018698013154789805, -0.016094114631414413, -0.0012145617511123419, 0.01465971115976572, -0.08476780354976654, 0.011002957820892334, -0.03462926298379898, -0.046047843992710114, -0.007972568273544312, -0.018711905926465988, 0.0016302018193528056, -0.006845284253358841, 0.04054298996925354, -0.01895330287516117, 0.021260591223835945, -0.021824205294251442, -0.006089276634156704, -0.03308839350938797, -0.012255291454494, -0.002070321934297681, 0.030915431678295135, 0.017855187878012657, -0.03812817484140396, 0.011014796793460846, -0.004160344135016203, -0.012164228595793247, -0.0738450139760971, -0.008262931369245052, 0.0537741556763649, -0.019595857709646225, 0.044571150094270706, 0.006190369371324778, 0.04315416142344475, -0.008613652549684048, 0.019365744665265083, -0.0036234064027667046, 0.06783649325370789, 0.025665652006864548, 0.00032824298250488937, 0.020049607381224632, -0.040291231125593185, -0.029901273548603058, 0.014255734160542488, 0.017195051535964012, 0.014978731982409954, 0.002586574060842395, 0.06796447932720184, -0.0034969004336744547, -0.05814941227436066, 0.003540997626259923, 0.0681329146027565, -0.00683152861893177, 0.005584521684795618, -0.02810245007276535, 0.02521495893597603, -0.04020727798342705, 0.016082730144262314, 0.025896871462464333, -0.019290337339043617, -0.007889318279922009, 0.01584690809249878, 0.025278301909565926, 0.015399713069200516, -0.03070681542158127, -0.017762457951903343, 0.02351086400449276, 0.02543940395116806, 0.035056594759225845, -0.01497100293636322, 0.014550735242664814, 0.017384810373187065, 0.038865383714437485, 0.00645458186045289, 0.0035612776409834623, -0.05988342687487602, -0.028244629502296448, 0.03086889162659645, 0.012813274748623371, -0.01093536801636219, 0.01800026372075081, -0.06645195931196213, 0.029810909181833267, 0.06684332340955734, -0.032059699296951294, 0.027036551386117935, -0.03372820466756821, 0.036928918212652206, 0.0034347784239798784, -0.03241945803165436, -0.05987386405467987, -0.010419231839478016, -0.004801552277058363, 0.017328748479485512, -0.046109918504953384, 0.021817589178681374, -0.035266321152448654, 0.01859014853835106, 0.015138113871216774, 0.09319867938756943, -0.003155610291287303, -0.012048762291669846, 0.00036832346813753247, 0.021557914093136787, 0.005139497108757496, -0.07600992172956467, 0.05431812256574631, 0.0011759018525481224, 0.0005422107642516494, 0.017510617151856422, -0.04983178898692131, -0.06467030197381973, 0.08574079722166061, -0.007535875309258699, -0.03091561049222946, -0.004666697699576616, -0.026610858738422394, 0.04585032910108566, 0.009841078892350197, 0.012904848903417587, 0.0664820596575737, 0.03320715203881264, 0.0274718776345253, 0.03480907902121544, -0.01639375649392605, -0.0021429904736578465, -0.015432173386216164, -0.014810576103627682, -0.04404217749834061, -0.012835457921028137, -0.01136354822665453, 0.014203928411006927, -0.012677144259214401, 0.03140779212117195, 0.03829902410507202, 0.008031003177165985, 0.016117295250296593, 0.025111837312579155, 0.03028995916247368, 0.025631839409470558, 0.02979782596230507, -0.0014983861474320292, -0.007887983694672585, -0.009029895067214966, 0.04399750754237175, -0.00033685858943499625, 0.0026488294824957848, 0.04479529336094856, -0.04002842307090759, -0.02193443849682808, -0.032364267855882645, 0.0035555462818592787, -0.006813326850533485, -0.024812696501612663, 0.07321053743362427, -0.03828590735793114, 0.016830220818519592, 0.008979642763733864, 0.0017397432820871472, -0.015440596267580986, 0.03221307694911957, -0.014156111516058445, 0.021238338202238083, -0.0423763133585453, 0.025884823873639107, 0.00009791424236027524, 0.01237315684556961, -0.06363406032323837, -0.031864020973443985, 0.018575703725218773, -0.006517802830785513, -0.006018584128469229, -0.09799101948738098, -0.014421679079532623, -0.022496502846479416, -0.0008537498069927096, -0.0031474814750254154, 0.021206453442573547, 0.0034738315735012293, -0.03280537948012352, -0.015956390649080276, 0.016881421208381653, 0.07989472150802612, -0.04240820184350014, -0.0015899299178272486, 0.024941930547356606, -0.02469520829617977, -0.016297493129968643, -0.019288979470729828, 0.023521391674876213, -0.016422655433416367, 0.0003259312070440501, -0.019193056970834732, -0.025514215230941772, 0.017188427969813347, -0.039968475699424744, -0.04901275411248207, 0.0346381850540638, 0.0012281907256692648, 0.03996236249804497, -0.019855359569191933, -0.02006729319691658, 0.014613048173487186, 0.0138383898884058, -0.025075234472751617, -0.009260209277272224, 0.047701526433229446, 0.007283080834895372, 0.04207484796643257, 0.056044843047857285, 0.02198435738682747, 0.03175261989235878, 0.043390434235334396, -0.007082634139806032, -0.05610291287302971, 0.02841714397072792, 0.01632246933877468, 0.046424027532339096, -0.02104901149868965, -0.014022352173924446, 0.005834999959915876, 0.04671243950724602, -0.03044235147535801, -0.04248169809579849, -0.038595765829086304, -0.01824873872101307, 0.037471503019332886, 0.010382852517068386, 0.03898918256163597, 0.01093091256916523, 0.0047926874831318855, -0.029842020943760872, 0.019548581913113594, -0.025660082697868347, -0.01985713467001915, -0.04587262123823166, 0.03145582228899002, -0.022618435323238373, 0.014451728202402592, 0.0032652048394083977, 0.001449792762286961, -0.01322221476584673, 0.02871774137020111, -0.036285798996686935, 0.0038405023515224457, 0.01571466587483883, -0.03749512881040573, -0.01259456854313612, 0.02356954850256443, -0.07782848179340363, 0.007107152137905359, -0.03699222579598427, -0.043852053582668304, 0.02218886837363243, 0.022692091763019562, -0.01870719902217388, -0.010411091148853302, -0.034834422171115875, -0.02608497440814972, -0.0008135076495818794, 0.01432550698518753, -0.0029205274768173695, 0.019697751849889755, 0.013460719957947731, 0.004203105345368385, 0.00863801222294569, 0.04085515812039375, -0.015269258990883827, -0.06428878754377365, -0.005080944858491421, -0.01821793243288994, -0.05302363634109497, -0.009264680556952953, 0.02156843990087509, -0.013709130696952343, 0.025481313467025757, -0.002640336751937866, 0.04333535209298134, -0.006395758595317602, 0.008928623050451279, -0.04062545299530029, 0.06672793626785278, 0.01238595973700285, 0.03952958434820175, -0.007670226972550154, 0.029781104996800423, 0.11967954784631729, 0.044328782707452774, 0.007139914203435183, -0.04427463561296463, 0.02715316228568554, -0.007838645949959755, -0.03520229458808899, -0.07068774104118347, 0.013716333545744419, 0.02001313306391239, -0.02133837342262268, 0.007739146705716848, 0.06180012598633766, -0.04180794581770897, -0.023361198604106903, 0.04049023985862732, -0.023754430934786797, -0.005469118244946003, 0.025250446051359177, 0.008643852546811104, 0.013098365627229214, 0.035582397133111954, -0.0356290303170681, 0.04832272604107857, -0.013958798721432686, 0.0007380975293926895, -0.039463285356760025, 0.009136146865785122, -0.02215893194079399, -0.0007758900173939764, -0.03426714614033699, -0.020355328917503357, 0.011306027881801128, -0.020672613754868507, 0.01926816627383232, -0.0043961969204247, 0.004796688910573721, -0.03224371373653412, 0.012833830900490284, 0.03286094218492508, 0.0356723815202713, 0.06922066956758499, 0.0011232286924496293, -0.0006915888516232371, -0.02160412259399891, -0.019716862589120865, -0.03482609614729881, -0.00758097879588604, -0.018723757937550545, 0.019335893914103508, 0.016918674111366272, 0.02534167282283306, 0.014117510989308357, -0.03272296488285065, -0.03368489444255829, 0.0075998976826667786, 0.027926359325647354, -0.027644498273730278, -0.018145615234971046, 0.014633908867835999, 0.053700774908065796, 0.040333785116672516, 0.013993456028401852, 0.02238510176539421, -0.054685793817043304, 0.00425541028380394, 0.012014815583825111, 0.014047671109437943, 0.009449434466660023, -0.04177587851881981, 0.018069425597786903, -0.04431605711579323, 0.014164628461003304, 0.01744960993528366, -0.004289837088435888, -0.03175406903028488, 0.03454679250717163, -0.008158179000020027, -0.0009582521161064506, 0.022307883948087692, -0.053691234439611435, 0.023701531812548637, -0.046490784734487534, 0.00810643844306469, -0.03308751806616783, -0.04312623292207718, 0.00973518192768097, 0.04321328550577164, 0.003632203908637166, -0.0019228163873776793, 0.027160322293639183, 0.08135812729597092, 0.032129473984241486, 0.019725125283002853, 0.018040787428617477, -0.05281670764088631, -0.043750349432229996, 0.042668912559747696, -0.028049930930137634, 0.051482610404491425, 0.042558375746011734, 0.05167632922530174, 0.020254282280802727, 0.004734431859105825, -0.05005519837141037, 0.024181468412280083, -0.00216615735553205, -0.025727275758981705, -0.006690992508083582, 0.013680865988135338, 0.02144627273082733, -0.028492964804172516, -0.010901164263486862, -0.025684339925646782, -0.00584834162145853, -0.01597510278224945, -0.025809308513998985, -0.016063785180449486, 0.002370263449847698, -0.017787696793675423, 0.0004793876432813704, 0.008170217275619507, -0.01361184474080801, 0.00009786688315216452, -0.014638702385127544, -0.027089020237326622, -0.027667958289384842, -0.031114300712943077, -0.006192936096340418, -0.004675980657339096, -0.011978860013186932, 0.04553648829460144, 0.004090548027306795, 0.01940278150141239, -0.011519579216837883, 0.016514917835593224, -0.01922426000237465, 0.03268299624323845, -0.03832745552062988, 0.01201480533927679, 0.0800781324505806, -0.05061299353837967, -0.004686021711677313, 0.032540347427129745, 0.019543390721082687, 0.00931505672633648, -0.008724725805222988, -0.023380061611533165, -0.04628647118806839, 0.03124602511525154, -0.03456975147128105, -0.007515078876167536, 0.0012294978369027376, 0.010086760856211185, -0.015370330773293972, 0.006566990632563829, 0.010722280479967594, 0.0008233720436692238, 0.019153395667672157, -0.012852510437369347, 0.028463847935199738, -0.006762227974832058, -0.024210579693317413, 0.016406182199716568, -0.04242987930774689, -0.014774402603507042, 0.02270415797829628, 0.008602126501500607, 0.0510932020843029, 0.06010977923870087, -0.028741084039211273, -0.0018714680336415768, -0.05516595020890236, -0.017173931002616882, -0.10309299826622009, -0.04146617650985718, 0.03157568350434303, 0.015127075836062431, 0.046498268842697144, -0.04498216509819031, -0.02270178124308586, 0.01630283147096634, -0.059055790305137634, 0.018154077231884003, -0.008774691261351109, -0.016896482557058334, -0.037363503128290176, 0.017885295674204826, -0.03322116285562515, -0.011050038039684296, 0.02001749910414219, 0.04125697538256645, 0.01095941849052906, 0.04387195408344269, -0.010077722370624542, -0.04408382624387741, -0.033486612141132355, -0.002983232494443655, -0.012864337302744389, -0.07027213275432587, 0.02958099916577339, -0.029504504054784775, -0.032807495445013046, 0.00585423968732357, -0.020301733165979385, -0.00045872590271756053, 0.016545800492167473, 0.045396365225315094, 0.010379614308476448, 0.06755636632442474, 0.0068941120989620686, 0.011168860830366611, 0.016457844525575638, 0.005858976393938065, 0.014642586000263691, 0.002413382986560464, -0.05315928906202316, -0.02312423288822174, 0.060833483934402466, 0.006431686691939831, -0.0657723993062973, 0.02798204869031906, 0.014053812250494957, -0.05863555893301964, 0.023868700489401817, 0.03709546476602554, 0.009993335232138634, -0.05494484305381775, 0.04311864823102951, -0.038665637373924255, -0.0029417662881314754, 0.020246772095561028, 0.05255502462387085, -0.03340347483754158, -0.01609579659998417, 0.00492522120475769, -0.03289394453167915, 0.0004290914221201092, -0.00377107341773808, -0.010575057938694954, -0.07673782110214233, 0.003503733314573765, 0.02114991843700409, -0.009333329275250435, -0.031287334859371185, -0.03967302292585373, -0.01723686046898365, 0.02986772730946541, 0.03358950838446617, 0.04090225696563721, -0.010322066955268383, 0.001058719353750348, -0.0012059916043654084, -0.09017350524663925, 0.011872990988194942, -0.012434691190719604, -0.0075232600793242455, -0.0286368727684021, -0.003838885109871626, -0.035300612449645996, -0.013917636126279831, 0.06771290302276611, -0.017811516299843788, -0.000410230306442827, 0.020052088424563408, 0.0377446785569191, 0.021193427965044975, -0.028699755668640137, -0.0010731323854997754, -0.04951813071966171, -0.04006129130721092, -0.048148710280656815, -0.04226350411772728, -0.009871273301541805, 0.005506282206624746, -0.024123510345816612, 0.012726523913443089, -0.02322295494377613, -0.012504225596785545, 0.004910661838948727, 0.030175257474184036, 0.052773017436265945, -0.0020034045446664095, 0.0250764898955822, -0.03381135314702988, -0.010856223292648792, -0.016252096742391586, 0.006841757334768772, -0.06595804542303085, 0.015003412030637264, -0.03232857212424278, -0.032268065959215164, -0.04511817544698715, 0.00024067892809398472, -0.039782144129276276, -0.03939775377511978, 0.02132078818976879, 0.052521318197250366, -0.05158369615674019, 0.021068690344691277, 0.048825349658727646, 0.005106677766889334, 0.03223118931055069, 0.00610496336594224, 0.0069872294552624226, 0.010639823041856289, 0.008479670621454716, 0.009790370240807533, 0.031404078006744385, -0.0035487341228872538, -0.061706166714429855, 0.0006193438312038779, 0.020892787724733353, 0.016077913343906403, 0.02549850568175316, 0.02027950808405876, 0.025292376056313515, -0.01954442448914051, -0.004323265980929136, -0.0034590112045407295, -0.039062898606061935, 0.01571625843644142, 0.01589026488363743, -0.020871685817837715, 0.07576990872621536, -0.011173092760145664, 0.03567294776439667, 0.02737562172114849, 0.002175836358219385, -0.011007377877831459, -0.0031859746668487787, -0.04049881547689438, 0.029883187264204025, -0.047830741852521896, -0.001228217501193285, -0.008340688422322273, 0.005004537291824818, 0.028509698808193207, -0.03280993551015854, 0.0009520620806142688, 0.04481091350317001, 0.02444811537861824, -0.04366711154580116, -0.020463718101382256, -0.014272035099565983, 0.005794936791062355, 0.00715671107172966, 0.024567736312747, 0.006610679905861616, 0.026664961129426956, -0.00871705636382103, -0.015852678567171097, 0.03501059114933014, -0.07019825279712677, -0.002733222208917141, -0.05083181709051132, -0.021289996802806854, -0.017555637285113335, -0.035132333636283875 ]
<p>I have already solved this question, but I need some feedback.</p> <blockquote> <p>A new method for measuring blood pressure in laboratory mice using radiotelemetry has been proposed. How does this compare with the existing method? You apply both methods to a sample of 16 mice and use <strong>________</strong>.</p> </blockquote> <p>I believe a matched-pairs <em>t</em>-test should go in the blank. Am I right or wrong? Thanks.</p>
35,968
[ -0.050624966621398926, -0.038514941930770874, 0.013342959806323051, -0.021345708519220352, 0.03891054540872574, 0.0015997710870578885, 0.05055554583668709, -0.020247049629688263, 0.02157328836619854, 0.03275568410754204, 0.09377921372652054, 0.04792266711592674, -0.0022915827576071024, 0.013176861219108105, 0.0065586683340370655, 0.009177176281809807, -0.05326700583100319, -0.006879726890474558, -0.018415963277220726, -0.04442871734499931, -0.009449701756238937, 0.0006481746095232666, -0.024303246289491653, 0.013434480875730515, -0.008152946829795837, 0.06455430388450623, 0.0029982689302414656, -0.03554925695061684, -0.0317256823182106, 0.04607762023806572, -0.05515056103467941, -0.0239607784897089, 0.011076332069933414, -0.009577480144798756, 0.02169443480670452, 0.015191630460321903, -0.0740424245595932, -0.04463783651590347, -0.010727889835834503, 0.05232083424925804, -0.0031541157513856888, -0.002704530954360962, -0.03100127913057804, 0.01960870623588562, -0.004133391659706831, 0.015555702149868011, 0.01049929577857256, -0.020916344597935677, 0.00040973679278977215, -0.05464824289083481, 0.054736193269491196, -0.01739463023841381, 0.06330570578575134, 0.016211945563554764, -0.018917202949523926, -0.04128573089838028, 0.04958103597164154, 0.06403470039367676, -0.02423769235610962, -0.04406185448169708, 0.013663267716765404, -0.02518766187131405, 0.015770679339766502, -0.021688716486096382, -0.016042247414588928, 0.003146599745377898, -0.0014194610994309187, -0.0022843291517347097, 0.03973489999771118, -0.017678750678896904, 0.013789166696369648, 0.020087886601686478, 0.03641209378838539, -0.0026605662424117327, 0.020299309864640236, -0.0038612785283476114, -0.010547756217420101, 0.060448482632637024, 0.06412912905216217, 0.015497940592467785, -0.02225732058286667, 0.015064164996147156, 0.028126779943704605, 0.055690571665763855, 0.006354242097586393, -0.046069711446762085, 0.04412272572517395, -0.013817992992699146, -0.02151382714509964, 0.035908136516809464, 0.002114152302965522, -0.008211886510252953, 0.015073470771312714, 0.03595178574323654, -0.011762358248233795, 0.017503874376416206, -0.009005396626889706, 0.06620055437088013, -0.009525900706648827, -0.009233579970896244, -0.01590149849653244, -0.06453204154968262, 0.04988562688231468, 0.06793460994958878, -0.03413918614387512, -0.01639641635119915, -0.03302397206425667, -0.021303629502654076, 0.012982940301299095, 0.01497904397547245, -0.044280558824539185, 0.007270533125847578, -0.024209871888160706, -0.004387884866446257, 0.02812723070383072, -0.04260191693902016, -0.0000018955772702611284, 0.011006387881934643, 0.08396705985069275, 0.044593047350645065, 0.049953751266002655, -0.008956560865044594, 0.0023252081591635942, -0.022364255040884018, -0.07632797211408615, 0.017996517941355705, -0.002719754818826914, -0.002089777262881398, -0.005517433863133192, 0.045108385384082794, 0.023297004401683807, -0.009560472331941128, 0.02943572588264942, -0.03185079246759415, 0.055952250957489014, -0.025356760248541832, -0.08591049909591675, -0.07780135422945023, 0.06221170723438263, -0.008438441902399063, -0.030653389170765877, -0.04277235269546509, 0.010962709784507751, -0.010751289315521717, 0.039874713867902756, 0.0028624406550079584, 0.03331436589360237, -0.022124631330370903, 0.006504471879452467, 0.03452188894152641, 0.025529267266392708, -0.00231927540153265, -0.025216830894351006, -0.032191064208745956, -0.014910848811268806, -0.061422958970069885, -0.013248051516711712, -0.014992829412221909, -0.03730185702443123, 0.023498205468058586, 0.02375434711575508, -0.017799416556954384, 0.01739545539021492, -0.027899134904146194, -0.01654805801808834, -0.027697985991835594, 0.06892359256744385, -0.006072491407394409, -0.001357358880341053, -0.0025134598836302757, -0.013859909027814865, 0.022073155269026756, 0.009186490438878536, 0.011677897535264492, 0.02058236673474312, -0.008847387507557869, -0.0060813697054982185, 0.011062368750572205, -0.01996244303882122, 0.023661235347390175, -0.0011014622868970037, -0.03310074284672737, 0.012105527333915234, 0.0041422457434237, 0.009875641204416752, 0.021045057103037834, 0.008601426146924496, -0.01824030838906765, 0.05904211848974228, -0.053058795630931854, -0.03485102206468582, -0.0625394731760025, -0.014229790307581425, -0.014701739884912968, 0.009034626185894012, -0.010241726413369179, -0.04199112951755524, -0.003877882845699787, -0.012788194231688976, -0.022732261568307877, 0.012846378609538078, 0.004159623757004738, 0.0778936892747879, 0.008339651860296726, 0.005429079290479422, 0.057187482714653015, 0.014585490338504314, -0.034750960767269135, -0.002629978582262993, -0.030854834243655205, -0.009908489882946014, 0.0001309882354689762, -0.026429705321788788, 0.017102397978305817, 0.0056460266932845116, -0.04019907861948013, -0.014874975197017193, 0.028236323967576027, -0.029768766835331917, 0.040308449417352676, -0.05214281007647514, 0.06858497858047485, 0.027456514537334442, 0.0025615172926336527, 0.03924812003970146, 0.00788942538201809, 0.052450284361839294, 0.04895918443799019, -0.014844720251858234, -0.002762534888461232, -0.07373750954866409, 0.0005619293660856783, 0.02539101056754589, 0.011272366158664227, -0.05297141894698143, 0.038075193762779236, 0.032256051898002625, -0.0011523173889145255, 0.0049737319350242615, 0.01716076023876667, 0.037058014422655106, 0.00589748565107584, 0.006731042172759771, 0.023427465930581093, -0.008403973653912544, -0.026209775358438492, 0.0026959041133522987, 0.014215883798897266, 0.029275013133883476, 0.0031703689601272345, 0.015022535808384418, 0.043988388031721115, -0.008573810569941998, 0.011532939039170742, -0.03725014999508858, -0.03159347549080849, 0.0376516617834568, -0.02088894508779049, 0.030248843133449554, 0.02862752415239811, 0.0029202669393271208, -0.019628601148724556, 0.021456388756632805, -0.007942519150674343, -0.016868583858013153, 0.033492714166641235, -0.017315536737442017, -0.001479895319789648, 0.026712672784924507, -0.10573921352624893, -0.012157888151705265, -0.01209724135696888, 0.004949358757585287, -0.02630864642560482, -0.015000504441559315, -0.0034122096840292215, -0.00497785909101367, 0.03325454145669937, -0.03252328559756279, 0.002237766981124878, -0.018832333385944366, -0.02545291744172573, 0.011523187160491943, 0.00784196238964796, -0.05925752595067024, -0.02212909422814846, -0.06715937703847885, -0.025382190942764282, 0.004619923885911703, 0.006615090183913708, -0.022059334442019463, 0.03504961356520653, 0.006079977843910456, -0.04004122316837311, -0.03406583145260811, -0.05141187831759453, 0.021163156256079674, -0.0020719878375530243, -0.010255027562379837, 0.0676342323422432, 0.020639704540371895, -0.004421588499099016, 0.01579531840980053, -0.02911253832280636, -0.030758904293179512, -0.003705234033986926, -0.014893404208123684, -0.030292849987745285, 0.003381524235010147, -0.0036954605020582676, 0.03816375881433487, -0.03665858879685402, -0.011816270649433136, -0.07270757108926773, -0.06334475427865982, 0.04204971715807915, 0.03559288755059242, 0.05023421719670296, 0.027891887351870537, -0.025929000228643417, 0.08635998517274857, -0.015193672850728035, -0.04480927065014839, -0.036699868738651276, -0.011531967669725418, -0.06420467793941498, -0.04896986857056618, 0.030896859243512154, 0.04929783195257187, 0.02277589961886406, 0.02102976106107235, 0.04352964833378792, 0.034047726541757584, 0.04712865129113197, 0.022443629801273346, -0.024320097640156746, 0.010748198255896568, 0.006459124851971865, -0.024600304663181305, 0.07439857721328735, 0.020401576533913612, -0.042485736310482025, 0.0030469554476439953, 0.0007526311092078686, -0.026269135996699333, 0.012257535010576248, -0.048098303377628326, 0.022980358451604843, 0.011154353618621826, -0.0010481365025043488, -0.031998198479413986, 0.03911779820919037, 0.005746642593294382, 0.02838374860584736, -0.04070265591144562, 0.040258172899484634, 0.05082032456994057, -0.04205957055091858, -0.004175393842160702, 0.07561271637678146, 0.026721403002738953, -0.02040446735918522, -0.01482769288122654, -0.0032317701261490583, -0.02724539488554001, 0.016033919528126717, -0.028853969648480415, -0.03252418339252472, 0.045878466218709946, 0.02093450352549553, 0.046017732471227646, 0.026796232908964157, -0.020763186737895012, -0.04230612888932228, -0.04094984754920006, -0.005525506101548672, -0.006539228372275829, 0.06595827639102936, 0.0007455734303221107, 0.07152128964662552, 0.021954618394374847, 0.0019073305884376168, 0.029056554660201073, -0.003158625215291977, -0.023553578183054924, 0.014887039549648762, -0.003993317950516939, -0.038476429879665375, 0.05641452968120575, -0.035177215933799744, 0.0036257952451705933, -0.033806201070547104, 0.0016137628117576241, -0.013253545388579369, -0.0004053845186717808, -0.022382697090506554, 0.027147356420755386, -0.031923383474349976, -0.029514558613300323, -0.04015357419848442, 0.019314507022500038, 0.0008763120858930051, -0.035379569977521896, 0.03925010561943054, 0.06443826109170914, 0.00832128245383501, 0.001628328813239932, -0.024142639711499214, 0.034363165497779846, 0.05472660809755325, 0.03534405678510666, 0.025700993835926056, -0.007227427791804075, -0.04207858070731163, 0.001305541256442666, -0.0002909096656367183, 0.007569808512926102, 0.019339710474014282, -0.002021030755713582, -0.018717840313911438, -0.027359461411833763, -0.0389285609126091, -0.0024420006666332483, 0.02289775386452675, 0.02686152048408985, -0.02392525039613247, 0.01177932694554329, 0.015097464434802532, -0.03884860500693321, 0.0328170508146286, 0.022352224215865135, 0.007426058873534203, -0.006223008036613464, -0.013580363243818283, -0.014985587447881699, -0.014500114135444164, -0.01984957791864872, 0.02850593626499176, 0.0010382728651165962, -0.008532782085239887, 0.004530380479991436, 0.04901283606886864, 0.008011305704712868, -0.01721900887787342, 0.01833287626504898, -0.011783747933804989, 0.0037182604428380728, 0.003089264500886202, -0.01009485311806202, -0.006574783008545637, 0.008437934331595898, -0.006156301591545343, 0.017818106338381767, -0.03200705721974373, -0.06837983429431915, -0.009243745356798172, 0.034647874534130096, 0.041725464165210724, -0.030565928667783737, -0.006517371162772179, -0.030066657811403275, 0.009151656180620193, 0.018755044788122177, -0.0577818788588047, 0.016853928565979004, -0.013464103452861309, -0.0013013948919251561, -0.0605957917869091, -0.030639350414276123, -0.055158596485853195, -0.002501843962818384, 0.024135099723935127, 0.0014565400779247284, 0.005715041421353817, -0.013764716684818268, 0.021673236042261124, -0.016485078260302544, 0.022114768624305725, 0.046601273119449615, -0.04994036257266998, -0.020722219720482826, 0.021266218274831772, -0.004130700137466192, -0.04576503857970238, -0.05884106084704399, 0.02056530863046646, -0.0044282409362494946, 0.02747197076678276, 0.02090906724333763, -0.022222187370061874, -0.03934474661946297, 0.030430646613240242, -0.010246939957141876, -0.04016093164682388, 0.021237149834632874, -0.04163913428783417, 0.07248019427061081, 0.07093249261379242, -0.029460208490490913, 0.06193797290325165, 0.04579621180891991, 0.023186953738331795, 0.03342477232217789, -0.007217124570161104, -0.017315639182925224, -0.04627716541290283, -0.014108117669820786, -0.021236933767795563, 0.0013941848883405328, -0.047985341399908066, 0.034619227051734924, -0.0022631967440247536, 0.018147515133023262, -0.025742707774043083, -0.037519507110118866, 0.020603958517313004, 0.03450895473361015, 0.009208961389958858, -0.00419076019898057, 0.01869579777121544, 0.015346341766417027, -0.02435280755162239, -0.04041598364710808, 0.016064956784248352, -0.046248920261859894, 0.011091304011642933, 0.013111121952533722, -0.022932926192879677, 0.004340800456702709, -0.012013424187898636, 0.018025599420070648, 0.023080000653862953, -0.06171392649412155, 0.052498627454042435, -0.01496423501521349, 0.010325762443244457, 0.0025478017050772905, 0.004757110960781574, -0.01775394380092621, 0.025708969682455063, 0.02208029478788376, -0.0066924444399774075, -0.05351567640900612, 0.05567353591322899, 0.01275385171175003, -0.025981782004237175, -0.036061037331819534, -0.040433552116155624, 0.032878194004297256, -0.0028987755067646503, 0.0018100958550348878, -0.01077656913548708, -0.019167296588420868, -0.007973307743668556, -0.011817888356745243, -0.0325760543346405, 0.036970313638448715, -0.0023156986571848392, -0.05311553180217743, -0.01543316151946783, -0.003581904573366046, 0.028818218037486076, 0.03842243552207947, -0.008062765002250671, -0.003009145613759756, -0.024957764893770218, -0.0186768788844347, -0.007322853896766901, 0.009987590834498405, -0.044480327516794205, -0.028884612023830414, -0.016205577179789543, -0.009579685516655445, 0.0662759318947792, 0.018223034217953682, 0.0008318076143041253, 0.03036145307123661, -0.04403749853372574, -0.04584866017103195, -0.06692738085985184, 0.0015563127817586064, 0.013070262037217617, -0.029529133811593056, -0.026719577610492706, 0.022717026993632317, -0.0014231100212782621, -0.005319991614669561, 0.020986905321478844, 0.0225807074457407, -0.03759336471557617, -0.0123212905600667, 0.0771980881690979, 0.0033670892007648945, 0.0072599598206579685, -0.0008771668071858585, -0.04026978090405464, 0.016661783680319786, 0.012956907972693443, -0.001131805474869907, -0.019382918253540993, 0.07009128481149673, -0.044235482811927795, -0.03900184482336044, -0.03171445429325104, -0.0188611950725317, 0.06204763799905777, 0.0020729568786919117, 0.056000784039497375, 0.027745628729462624, -0.013703625649213791, 0.023016059771180153, 0.02004011906683445, 0.009428361430764198, -0.02286684140563011, 0.008860272355377674, 0.029821883887052536, -0.02763868309557438, 0.030458437278866768, 0.018963437527418137, 0.019704733043909073, 0.03308119252324104, 0.03733169287443161, 0.048726584762334824, 0.004690010100603104, 0.010253227315843105, -0.02393319271504879, -0.021082507446408272, 0.010080075822770596, -0.04284471645951271, 0.026065591722726822, 0.008279560133814812, 0.002303890883922577, 0.05882282182574272, 0.030544525012373924, -0.0003973488346673548, -0.04002782329916954, 0.012491223402321339, -0.0463017001748085, -0.019164497032761574, 0.006196732632815838, -0.006915230769664049, 0.025592107325792313, -0.004938213154673576, 0.06261111795902252, 0.021253015846014023, 0.019571835175156593, -0.05874549224972725, -0.032516494393348694, 0.005337618291378021, -0.0016612722538411617, -0.05089225247502327, 0.07368596643209457, -0.0026346384547650814, -0.016811657696962357, 0.04366344213485718, -0.01829712651669979, 0.0039511146023869514, 0.012022408656775951, -0.00316988630220294, -0.054181668907403946, 0.058862969279289246, 0.018719835206866264, -0.00678987056016922, 0.012119272723793983, -0.0059868348762393, 0.09741093963384628, 0.08241262286901474, 0.047050248831510544, -0.05445197597146034, 0.041936565190553665, 0.021597592160105705, 0.04358110949397087, -0.022222504019737244, 0.00356059311889112, 0.031093141064047813, 0.07115544378757477, 0.03521852567791939, 0.07701962441205978, 0.019417859613895416, -0.006799232680350542, 0.04337824881076813, -0.02103574387729168, -0.006615479476749897, 0.008540745824575424, 0.011047905310988426, -0.0167224183678627, -0.022467290982604027, 0.011996768414974213, 0.027095353230834007, -0.00464579276740551, -0.013680394738912582, -0.00824175588786602, -0.0017251298995688558, 0.003950078971683979, 0.032566819339990616, -0.01890406757593155, 0.022719137370586395, -0.01206899806857109, -0.0016918758628889918, -0.04706014320254326, 0.022335458546876907, 0.019572800025343895, -0.001564508187584579, 0.024973062798380852, 0.023435000330209732, 0.027722734957933426, -0.02557242102921009, 0.029803600162267685, 0.02180401235818863, -0.02101624757051468, -0.011875341646373272, -0.022271016612648964, 0.03716075420379639, -0.03401831164956093, -0.055061452090740204, 0.01558141689747572, 0.0015788974706083536, -0.03262830153107643, -0.05471363291144371, -0.0010819118469953537, 0.02327210083603859, 0.029683614149689674, -0.012584605254232883, -0.012300005182623863, -0.0498335100710392, 0.03354017809033394, -0.026178164407610893, -0.013081406243145466, 0.02301139198243618, -0.008897881023585796, -0.024451203644275665, -0.03223952278494835, 0.03811850771307945, 0.0008164063910953701, 0.014609421603381634, 0.006550982128828764, -0.01711161993443966, -0.052582379430532455, -0.0055673979222774506, -0.005506138317286968, 0.016118738800287247, 0.0313832052052021, 0.017249496653676033, 0.010087109170854092, -0.008012506179511547, -0.05119125917553902, 0.04246005415916443, -0.0337003692984581, -0.011576974764466286, -0.04129445552825928, -0.04009627550840378, 0.002113326685503125, 0.03842433542013168, 0.014144682325422764, 0.029073014855384827, -0.006914908066391945, 0.04462478682398796, 0.02693282440304756, -0.06132660433650017, -0.029480941593647003, 0.017178097739815712, -0.024490365758538246, -0.0017443198012188077, 0.007191985379904509, 0.04933585226535797, 0.054693736135959625, 0.06110057234764099, -0.02465827204287052, -0.02619508095085621, -0.012798765674233437, -0.019137756898999214, 0.00035846419632434845, -0.05757730454206467, -0.037850577384233475, -0.013618036173284054, -0.002852932084351778, -0.013097189366817474, -0.019935831427574158, -0.05289235711097717, -0.038585953414440155, 0.05244076997041702, -0.0036203733179718256, -0.0020593926310539246, -0.01101633906364441, -0.02810402400791645, -0.01447631698101759, -0.03747572377324104, 0.03487671911716461, -0.03093784861266613, -0.05467003956437111, -0.009454342536628246, -0.023670407012104988, -0.02683044783771038, 0.023033959791064262, -0.043917588889598846, 0.03406780958175659, 0.05868857353925705, -0.009453624486923218, -0.014697292819619179, 0.02800748683512211, 0.0113845719024539, 0.00848925206810236, 0.012200242839753628, 0.005109626799821854, -0.010222957469522953, 0.04411166161298752, -0.02831944450736046, 0.024300673976540565, 0.01480166893452406, 0.013035045936703682, 0.03772548958659172, 0.016474230214953423, 0.014605497010052204, -0.001961995381861925, 0.02673128992319107, -0.04409193992614746, -0.02810581400990486, 0.0019725540187209845, -0.02220710553228855, 0.045347582548856735, 0.006169529631733894, 0.003883789759129286, 0.020811259746551514, 0.006401673424988985, 0.021239053457975388, 0.051028940826654434, 0.03612072020769119, 0.028321726247668266, -0.02222220040857792, 0.016508499160408974, 0.013872073031961918, 0.0067569538950920105, -0.029890766367316246, 0.03778567165136337, 0.02117335982620716, -0.01811542548239231, 0.01979007013142109, -0.045666392892599106, 0.00009948023944161832, -0.06236323341727257, 0.017047950997948647, -0.0009558401652611792, 0.020750606432557106, 0.017991285771131516, -0.037629760801792145, -0.00006327551091089845, -0.0005745440721511841, -0.019115231931209564, -0.01290891319513321, 0.020435556769371033, -0.03220947086811066, -0.027605412527918816, 0.039083801209926605, -0.02720734290778637, 0.013622219674289227, -0.0012957148719578981, 0.04473210126161575, 0.0074481843039393425, 0.0380517803132534, 0.04911677911877632, 0.00205406965687871, -0.012432191520929337, 0.016829628497362137, 0.05520033836364746, -0.06916903704404831, 0.03314860165119171, -0.02678397111594677, -0.014086021110415459, 0.02779197506606579, -0.013769500888884068, 0.039438795298337936, 0.003004105994477868, 0.013438602909445763, -0.002138643991202116, 0.06233792379498482, 0.011134711094200611, -0.005566000007092953, 0.0075244358740746975, 0.003946948330849409, 0.0050124796107411385, 0.03314141556620598, -0.0026953057385981083, 0.006262133829295635, 0.025138316676020622, -0.005985635332763195, -0.002336459932848811, 0.00944808591157198, -0.03429289907217026, -0.021412232890725136, 0.026499437168240547, 0.003488305490463972, 0.003341484349220991, -0.04310379922389984, -0.056198637932538986, -0.03400770574808121, 0.01776716485619545, 0.049162931740283966, 0.03555262088775635, -0.04089765623211861, -0.012315010651946068, -0.01798608899116516, -0.028327908366918564, 0.005859465338289738, -0.0081346295773983, -0.0016477430472150445, -0.04470662400126457, -0.005928953643888235, 0.00236544874496758, 0.035972960293293, -0.023284252732992172, 0.0012873259838670492, 0.0016304785385727882, 0.025878971442580223, 0.027818789705634117, 0.016695139929652214, 0.008717709220945835, -0.0007314031245186925, 0.03129858523607254, -0.08265623450279236, 0.04747907072305679, -0.003984595648944378, -0.015693770721554756, -0.019952954724431038, -0.030066609382629395, -0.04426804557442665, 0.04829872027039528, 0.06097475066781044, 0.042826153337955475, 0.0020697431173175573, -0.011366157792508602, 0.0021425229497253895, 0.012245727702975273, -0.05657746270298958, 0.042766883969306946, 0.013841206207871437, 0.018100151792168617, 0.019535861909389496, 0.013031692244112492, 0.006162111181765795, 0.032622482627630234, 0.06489679217338562, -0.01025147270411253, 0.008024459704756737, -0.019892718642950058, -0.015702195465564728, -0.004586443770676851, 0.0009090692037716508, -0.013132276013493538, 0.05645914375782013, -0.02022448368370533, 0.016517266631126404, 0.0068521215580403805, -0.029724689200520515, -0.06424382328987122, 0.027549222111701965, -0.04906836897134781, 0.016510410234332085, 0.020923204720020294, -0.000018605853256303817, -0.024333229288458824, -0.07472141832113266, -0.00827682577073574, 0.023708678781986237, -0.022561904042959213, -0.023842066526412964, 0.049325525760650635, 0.054845403879880905, -0.010626928880810738, -0.031948015093803406, 0.041755739599466324, -0.001317749498412013, -0.05492205545306206, -0.00012211028661113232, 0.03844017535448074, 0.06800520420074463, -0.026288501918315887, -0.0005870256572961807, 0.020449677482247353, -0.02952425926923752, 0.003951170481741428, 0.035962145775556564, 0.029893439263105392, -0.007125518750399351, -0.034587882459163666, -0.006795466877520084, -0.007200451102107763, 0.0011829559225589037, 0.00809383112937212, -0.006149151362478733, 0.06062989681959152, -0.03527249023318291, 0.0012425724416971207, -0.0315701924264431, -0.007386956829577684, -0.03971997648477554, 0.02503405138850212, 0.03419281169772148, 0.004666524473577738, -0.010166791267693043, 0.022623181343078613, 0.02924116887152195, -0.04254386946558952, -0.0016842123586684465, -0.03717182204127312, 0.016772763803601265, -0.02594144083559513, 0.003217952558770776, -0.037882670760154724, -0.005527290981262922, -0.01873626559972763, 0.010525050573050976, 0.03941236436367035, 0.020758701488375664, -0.010067813098430634, -0.04506174847483635, -0.005429078359156847, -0.007615052629262209, 0.03377886861562729, -0.07742545008659363, -0.01457466371357441, -0.04505522921681404, 0.010994402691721916, 0.010232893750071526, -0.030802717432379723 ]
<p>In my current dataset I have quite a few categorical variables. Most have decent distributions between the categories. 30:40:30 splits etc. where these are percentage of dataset members per category</p> <p>dataset is ~2000 members</p> <p>But a fair few have either (I feel) useless or difficult distributions.</p> <p>Some have distributions like 97:2:1 - to me there are so few members in the low populated categories I would just leave this variable out. There may only be 10-20 members in the 1% category.</p> <p>Others have distributions where I am not sure what to do. 80:10:5:5 etc if it makes real world sense, with this option is combining the 10:5:5 portion into one group viable? Ie the new variable has 2 categories comprising 80:20 split in members.</p> <p>With decision trees I do not think this is too much of a problem as it will effectively do the combining itself. With other modelling methods where dummy variables are created is the combining (or even removal) of variables an encouraged method as it also helps reduce dimensionality?</p>
73,571
[ -0.024618934839963913, 0.05563150346279144, 0.020830703899264336, -0.03382710739970207, 0.04293587803840637, -0.013460450805723667, -0.02338157407939434, -0.017735784873366356, 0.041523270308971405, -0.03925010934472084, 0.02920532412827015, 0.019572127610445023, 0.03390919417142868, 0.007535955868661404, 0.009330867789685726, 0.005651019047945738, 0.022094182670116425, -0.02056911215186119, 0.014622674323618412, 0.013374701142311096, -0.030176864936947823, 0.013100726529955864, 0.01294522825628519, -0.01610136404633522, -0.0232943594455719, 0.07373356819152832, 0.03677675873041153, -0.02080409787595272, 0.01263164822012186, 0.029402093961834908, -0.01870732754468918, -0.02192259579896927, 0.006747896317392588, 0.07375101745128632, 0.006904720328748226, -0.04171474650502205, 0.011070906184613705, -0.04102282598614693, -0.032412089407444, 0.031926918774843216, -0.025399740785360336, 0.04205005243420601, -0.011961414478719234, 0.005843657068908215, 0.01299460418522358, 0.03574175387620926, -0.0073281158693134785, -0.013053914532065392, 0.007033830974251032, -0.05125250294804573, 0.06470274180173874, 0.014257636852562428, 0.023906907066702843, 0.045145243406295776, -0.012933994643390179, 0.025075046345591545, 0.05483927205204964, 0.06522535532712936, -0.0035870650317519903, -0.03443317487835884, -0.0008898513624444604, -0.015847181901335716, 0.015495211817324162, -0.0018774979980662465, -0.033639948815107346, 0.05092784762382507, -0.01289400365203619, -0.003338679438456893, 0.025941895321011543, 0.0007783477194607258, 0.03401778265833855, 0.00009347357990918681, 0.040524326264858246, 0.024613529443740845, 0.028038498014211655, -0.011768023483455181, 0.024811316281557083, 0.014673572964966297, 0.06403397023677826, 0.04079394042491913, 0.0054987575858831406, -0.010181066580116749, 0.016415588557720184, 0.016610322520136833, 0.01792985200881958, -0.003406534204259515, 0.0846787691116333, -0.06697306782007217, 0.006849495694041252, 0.005922366864979267, -0.030486546456813812, -0.01207062415778637, 0.06427697837352753, 0.027265118435025215, -0.051763515919446945, 0.0579238124191761, -0.016532883048057556, 0.027511579915881157, 0.013904698193073273, -0.00037644992698915303, -0.017912663519382477, -0.008882797323167324, 0.008796180598437786, 0.06390326470136642, -0.03770958632230759, -0.007022827863693237, -0.02147819474339485, -0.013209636323153973, -0.0036075864918529987, -0.05344405770301819, -0.01989992894232273, -0.00734705850481987, 0.018097195774316788, -0.010435580275952816, 0.01129941362887621, -0.025115352123975754, 0.0012382327113300562, -0.028022969141602516, 0.054076239466667175, 0.04186444729566574, 0.016243772581219673, -0.05393213406205177, 0.02677510492503643, -0.0016794669209048152, -0.048735760152339935, -0.00814628042280674, 0.004204354714602232, 0.022458847612142563, -0.045499637722969055, 0.05574139952659607, -0.03813758119940758, -0.04432230070233345, 0.08344117552042007, -0.009045747108757496, 0.008563777431845665, 0.00433432636782527, -0.09666747599840164, -0.02397937700152397, -0.00068767269840464, -0.06755285710096359, 0.01911839284002781, -0.033901751041412354, 0.007316931616514921, 0.021104300394654274, 0.03566899523139, 0.0072683896869421005, 0.03387782722711563, 0.006864063907414675, 0.0488746203482151, -0.00013909662084188312, -0.020157907158136368, -0.02289051003754139, -0.031166253611445427, -0.017748836427927017, -0.01603267528116703, -0.08796045929193497, 0.01356576383113861, 0.01698167435824871, -0.011956246569752693, 0.016786715015769005, -0.008178608492016792, -0.014082470908761024, -0.014604588970541954, 0.029666515067219734, 0.0291733555495739, -0.004577919840812683, 0.04697093740105629, -0.03151198849081993, 0.07523086667060852, 0.017963441088795662, 0.011607279069721699, 0.001908783451654017, 0.056704770773649216, 0.058984849601984024, -0.00668571749702096, 0.009822449646890163, 0.0032327838707715273, -0.030136650428175926, 0.019508544355630875, 0.00007954239117680117, -0.02685348130762577, -0.028609715402126312, -0.03802208602428436, 0.004559970926493406, 0.03780166804790497, 0.019924016669392586, 0.005130617413669825, -0.03675065562129021, 0.04715387895703316, -0.05477648600935936, -0.044617246836423874, -0.06362681835889816, 0.00020368449622765183, -0.045978132635354996, -0.0033739737700670958, 0.011910044588148594, 0.03158460557460785, 0.016847705468535423, -0.010650353506207466, -0.028464078903198242, -0.05235707387328148, -0.026175137609243393, 0.023517396301031113, -0.05948909372091293, -0.010052894242107868, 0.03523777797818184, 0.021139930933713913, -0.041550129652023315, 0.047859784215688705, -0.007092474494129419, -0.10034267604351044, -0.003590372623875737, -0.017076175659894943, 0.03923420608043671, -0.005790863651782274, 0.020286312326788902, 0.042623959481716156, 0.004122686106711626, -0.0510784350335598, 0.014154522679746151, -0.06642434000968933, 0.09300701320171356, 0.06693851202726364, 0.0023586503230035305, -0.012324605137109756, 0.03420979902148247, 0.008442485705018044, 0.007772681303322315, 0.01065288856625557, 0.0018994343699887395, -0.05033466964960098, 0.03683920577168465, 0.03913049399852753, 0.014365186914801598, -0.022076020017266273, 0.015110551379621029, 0.022009313106536865, 0.021966513246297836, 0.015262488275766373, 0.00964813120663166, -0.0017092293128371239, 0.006909689400345087, 0.01996363140642643, 0.0030492080841213465, 0.008980062790215015, -0.023938043043017387, 0.004906591959297657, -0.023639706894755363, 0.03689273074269295, 0.01885167881846428, -0.024659018963575363, 0.039987921714782715, 0.009454428218305111, 0.01874195784330368, 0.0050332206301391125, -0.029634788632392883, 0.030981753021478653, -0.04533631354570389, 0.005246775224804878, 0.041481513530015945, 0.020557256415486336, -0.007690477650612593, 0.03306477144360542, -0.013902314938604832, 0.018115000799298286, 0.06866981089115143, -0.04815889149904251, 0.017127450555562973, 0.007668765727430582, -0.03871100768446922, -0.0003257398202549666, -0.017470477148890495, -0.040417976677417755, -0.039716195315122604, 0.04639756679534912, 0.04972430691123009, -0.015370375476777554, 0.04496293142437935, -0.006069099996238947, -0.0037385202012956142, -0.03126096352934837, -0.0037756324745714664, 0.025465400889515877, 0.020149847492575645, -0.05170951411128044, -0.017130374908447266, -0.058822162449359894, -0.033344924449920654, 0.031389202922582626, -0.036347273737192154, -0.013289561495184898, -0.00039581992314197123, -0.016394617035984993, -0.03834226354956627, -0.015962667763233185, -0.012325280345976353, 0.0239382516592741, -0.010136600583791733, -0.036160748451948166, -0.017748119309544563, -0.019964339211583138, -0.02327623777091503, -0.014299232512712479, -0.03442489728331566, -0.05092313885688782, -0.0191454216837883, -0.010757753625512123, 0.024476265534758568, 0.008928636088967323, -0.019758423790335655, 0.04060010239481926, -0.004078345838934183, 0.017797667533159256, -0.07954301685094833, -0.061669811606407166, 0.00946593377739191, 0.0014113521901890635, 0.0215385053306818, 0.036966338753700256, -0.004404982551932335, 0.07838339358568192, 0.02792283520102501, -0.032553937286138535, 0.020078452304005623, -0.0016502932412549853, -0.02058149315416813, 0.01310915220528841, 0.02317536063492298, 0.012521338649094105, 0.008137130178511143, 0.01264888420701027, 0.0030614307615906, -0.0007017443422228098, 0.0494559183716774, 0.016150744631886482, -0.03732319921255112, 0.04775233566761017, 0.0003216770419385284, -0.0016116813058033586, 0.008810725063085556, 0.025200214236974716, -0.016239693388342857, 0.01278653834015131, -0.03894419223070145, 0.04252956062555313, 0.011694188229739666, -0.029474709182977676, 0.002227379474788904, -0.029317233711481094, 0.023271026089787483, -0.007784284185618162, 0.02750059962272644, 0.010424730367958546, -0.059190861880779266, 0.015462641604244709, 0.04719780385494232, 0.052237801253795624, -0.021062327548861504, -0.005157721694558859, 0.06113734468817711, 0.034079745411872864, 0.010460779070854187, -0.008815641514956951, -0.004567365627735853, -0.004827751312404871, 0.05259031057357788, -0.026331668719649315, 0.007926504127681255, 0.012246238067746162, 0.044412463903427124, 0.04513482749462128, -0.014466806314885616, -0.039993252605199814, 0.01840519718825817, -0.0992511510848999, 0.014339602552354336, -0.021793529391288757, 0.046082254499197006, 0.031121045351028442, 0.03906968608498573, 0.002024896675720811, -0.015344544313848019, -0.019707439467310905, 0.008982406929135323, -0.021068541333079338, 0.01062946580350399, 0.015244442969560623, 0.019656427204608917, -0.002883205423131585, -0.02622690051794052, 0.010519560426473618, -0.012115026824176311, -0.02086913026869297, -0.03330107778310776, 0.022828077897429466, -0.015623742714524269, -0.007958803325891495, 0.0058235302567481995, -0.0212009996175766, -0.007995925843715668, -0.01844410039484501, 0.007847865112125874, 0.0176278967410326, 0.02546791546046734, 0.03749317675828934, 0.03800879791378975, -0.03471117839217186, -0.019071439281105995, 0.030897319316864014, 0.022626137360930443, 0.04163496196269989, 0.014936842955648899, 0.0347653403878212, -0.03908660262823105, 0.015271434560418129, 0.006170741282403469, 0.061761293560266495, 0.01417363341897726, -0.041723787784576416, 0.0006097442237660289, -0.03233012184500694, -0.039643459022045135, -0.025828426703810692, 0.017674267292022705, -0.009022212587296963, -0.007097697351127863, 0.04799676686525345, 0.045181889086961746, -0.05928472802042961, 0.002461315831169486, 0.06110590696334839, 0.013037238270044327, -0.04692240431904793, -0.01207800954580307, -0.004201460164040327, -0.00492892786860466, -0.00010532565647736192, 0.03386472165584564, 0.007720304187387228, -0.004419371485710144, 0.008034373633563519, 0.05953217297792435, -0.0015028787311166525, -0.047373224049806595, 0.007545360829681158, 0.02816822938621044, 0.028332678601145744, 0.0012493174290284514, -0.024253902956843376, 0.03167206794023514, 0.021414460614323616, 0.0013283052248880267, 0.03921184688806534, -0.0041003115475177765, -0.09449879825115204, 0.039586141705513, 0.02797292172908783, 0.02453836426138878, -0.058228060603141785, -0.017149031162261963, -0.040294062346220016, -0.010041272267699242, 0.004644259810447693, -0.030332347378134727, 0.001293947920203209, -0.008021376095712185, 0.014751800335943699, -0.01539712492376566, -0.046588730067014694, -0.012795280665159225, 0.031065190210938454, -0.010449024848639965, 0.02841634675860405, 0.018163174390792847, -0.03747706115245819, -0.0336272232234478, 0.047263626009225845, 0.014599367044866085, 0.03623777627944946, -0.011895510368049145, -0.0696800947189331, 0.009145158343017101, 0.016449948772788048, -0.008265325799584389, -0.07614466547966003, 0.0041723791509866714, 0.0008091546478681266, -0.03967444971203804, 0.04189246520400047, -0.014965757727622986, -0.03594008460640907, 0.0020482169929891825, 0.007434748578816652, 0.0025316292885690928, 0.011359449476003647, 0.00486745685338974, 0.06010781601071358, 0.002056059893220663, -0.007363568991422653, 0.049647968262434006, 0.02744179405272007, -0.02512640319764614, 0.02000364661216736, -0.03401217237114906, 0.009247858077287674, -0.006982899270951748, -0.025507250800728798, -0.0471477210521698, -0.01697360910475254, 0.011283410713076591, 0.007205458823591471, -0.0013238136889413, 0.0366390086710453, -0.0160051342099905, -0.040875572711229324, 0.004555588122457266, 0.02363060601055622, 0.02370457723736763, -0.030032189562916756, 0.034715160727500916, 0.026007870212197304, -0.005751855205744505, -0.0054146540351212025, 0.031634747982025146, -0.005249869078397751, -0.013875204138457775, 0.003453173441812396, -0.03711756318807602, 0.005614733323454857, -0.02848016656935215, -0.017258010804653168, 0.006017975974828005, 0.0013938389020040631, 0.01381632499396801, -0.011610347777605057, 0.056430019438266754, -0.03258763253688812, -0.03101964481174946, -0.0020102597773075104, 0.014972402714192867, 0.020464472472667694, 0.05550932139158249, -0.05667080730199814, 0.0565287284553051, -0.05077525973320007, 0.01690242625772953, -0.0641879066824913, -0.0466732382774353, 0.011697699315845966, 0.013983987271785736, -0.042737673968076706, -0.04591676965355873, 0.025535505264997482, -0.032115377485752106, -0.021452434360980988, -0.0029753167182207108, 0.07049679011106491, -0.017342830076813698, 0.013240576721727848, -0.03567948564887047, 0.009299938566982746, 0.0873972475528717, 0.007930539548397064, -0.01945248432457447, 0.020248349756002426, -0.024909524247050285, 0.028278646990656853, 0.008969792164862156, -0.002185456920415163, -0.028379924595355988, 0.0016128753777593374, -0.004927471745759249, 0.005539508070796728, 0.026978807523846626, -0.026318863034248352, 0.0015381178818643093, 0.012438293546438217, -0.008171969093382359, 0.017848851159214973, -0.011072278954088688, 0.05577249079942703, -0.031267110258340836, -0.008916497230529785, -0.007645173463970423, 0.05142646282911301, -0.005401472561061382, 0.0016574906185269356, 0.02180654928088188, -0.012971279211342335, -0.03118416853249073, 0.020614169538021088, 0.06554881483316422, -0.018675586208701134, 0.035082291811704636, -0.025514252483844757, -0.046453770250082016, 0.03548099473118782, -0.0006182697252370417, -0.025352127850055695, 0.018304921686649323, 0.01905171573162079, 0.027939436957240105, -0.003049522405490279, -0.03285655006766319, -0.011400565505027771, 0.031325165182352066, -0.016944896429777145, 0.053194668143987656, 0.03974160924553871, 0.028801998123526573, 0.013649094849824905, -0.05444272607564926, -0.0033202175982296467, -0.011278649792075157, 0.0073306080885231495, 0.05524616315960884, 0.023633668199181557, -0.001304703182540834, 0.025526778772473335, 0.014142721891403198, 0.013553562574088573, 0.055791884660720825, 0.0039762998931109905, 0.022701755166053772, 0.015378143638372421, -0.030397184193134308, -0.057268112897872925, 0.010877510532736778, -0.06633532792329788, -0.0017489173915237188, -0.033808592706918716, -0.04087759181857109, 0.007442179135978222, 0.015267121605575085, -0.009753544814884663, -0.0460982471704483, -0.030866099521517754, -0.014875256456434727, -0.005796593613922596, -0.010571124032139778, 0.00670944107696414, 0.027109947055578232, -0.011598842218518257, 0.014614964835345745, 0.014934046193957329, 0.04334219545125961, -0.01860482059419155, -0.07697074115276337, -0.0697663351893425, -0.016101408749818802, -0.034445252269506454, 0.015454191714525223, 0.00006673808820778504, -0.007793426513671875, 0.006034274119883776, -0.0525105856359005, 0.023127088323235512, -0.04091135039925575, 0.040530141443014145, 0.005062700714915991, 0.059148166328668594, 0.012897261418402195, 0.01831064559519291, 0.0018662700895220041, -0.0006315004429779947, 0.12200909107923508, 0.07003534585237503, 0.05519638955593109, -0.03492109477519989, 0.026082461699843407, 0.031417619436979294, -0.006385405082255602, -0.01305919699370861, -0.009437894448637962, 0.002842149930074811, 0.01826775074005127, 0.046166613698005676, 0.038403429090976715, 0.016363386064767838, -0.017257455736398697, 0.06906890869140625, -0.006879790686070919, -0.010603112168610096, 0.020293110981583595, 0.014400126412510872, 0.025022152811288834, -0.029015984386205673, -0.03852374851703644, -0.007614827714860439, 0.018838858231902122, -0.015536239370703697, 0.0033802310936152935, -0.0014785483945161104, -0.010299786925315857, -0.027647145092487335, -0.03902152553200722, 0.018623407930135727, 0.017494235187768936, -0.001885144505649805, 0.022562313824892044, -0.015043798834085464, 0.01450191531330347, -0.0381048247218132, -0.015176606364548206, 0.02783643826842308, -0.02205839566886425, -0.013552072457969189, -0.014475906267762184, 0.06769973039627075, -0.04728924483060837, -0.034086599946022034, -0.03499893471598625, 0.018525123596191406, -0.04498627781867981, 0.011620694771409035, -0.036461107432842255, -0.01058779377490282, 0.024467037990689278, -0.015393287874758244, -0.02124720811843872, 0.012390386313199997, 0.04443099722266197, 0.0028225984424352646, -0.03338853269815445, -0.040861018002033234, 0.020982883870601654, 0.006686457898467779, 0.045569706708192825, -0.01597295142710209, -0.024529285728931427, -0.038769710808992386, 0.01958552934229374, 0.05175909399986267, 0.03119080141186714, 0.006909034214913845, -0.01296968013048172, -0.009177585132420063, -0.019117414951324463, 0.00196411763317883, 0.0043035587295889854, 0.024436751380562782, 0.011628888547420502, -0.025974003598093987, -0.025815458968281746, -0.03171945735812187, -0.031719982624053955, -0.005544715095311403, 0.018497563898563385, -0.004152596462517977, -0.04591001197695732, 0.022382797673344612, 0.006089173723012209, 0.023124629631638527, 0.011241747066378593, 0.010610658675432205, -0.0003560529148671776, 0.04867302626371384, -0.026793604716658592, -0.02598787099123001, -0.006208687089383602, -0.03155716136097908, -0.045959170907735825, 0.013446365483105183, -0.012090731412172318, 0.06396479159593582, -0.0020595865789800882, -0.00021655272576026618, -0.014892787672579288, 0.03299088031053543, 0.037085045129060745, 0.039778631180524826, 0.002165604615584016, -0.09410781413316727, 0.013287629932165146, -0.001812799135223031, 0.005828594323247671, -0.04529384523630142, -0.0015983813209459186, -0.02960207685828209, -0.040101949125528336, 0.009448328986763954, -0.02522319182753563, -0.03700265288352966, 0.013505110517144203, -0.010467182844877243, 0.02250373177230358, -0.02539721690118313, -0.018357913941144943, -0.03544238582253456, -0.010274368338286877, -0.04872773215174675, -0.07191795855760574, 0.003119110129773617, -0.010849766433238983, 0.006287895143032074, 0.015188988298177719, 0.045143015682697296, 0.0362740084528923, 0.009007623419165611, -0.017795149236917496, 0.023056283593177795, 0.01976212114095688, 0.05808190256357193, -0.030052419751882553, -0.008851812221109867, 0.019897138699889183, -0.027779608964920044, -0.026452679187059402, 0.034051649272441864, -0.00138830894138664, 0.06181095540523529, 0.0015890344511717558, -0.025513198226690292, -0.033650606870651245, 0.027680186554789543, -0.026781875640153885, -0.04217160865664482, 0.0015840311534702778, 0.008421560749411583, 0.008905626833438873, -0.006063082721084356, -0.0339045487344265, 0.013569236733019352, -0.029745137318968773, 0.032743584364652634, 0.031473129987716675, 0.01994737610220909, -0.044025223702192307, 0.049338776618242264, -0.025357037782669067, 0.05265137553215027, 0.01624811626970768, -0.017834648489952087, 0.025644592940807343, 0.05060512572526932, -0.03185589611530304, 0.0028096779715269804, -0.012326699681580067, 0.03984487056732178, -0.08186736702919006, -0.07254638522863388, 0.03556596487760544, 0.00969821959733963, 0.01855476200580597, -0.04706741124391556, 0.030356915667653084, 0.02074103243649006, -0.04670403525233269, 0.03149333968758583, -0.01783444732427597, -0.00481322780251503, -0.02137836068868637, 0.0022274479269981384, -0.044695138931274414, 0.006138296332210302, 0.025399543344974518, 0.02097180485725403, 0.010809160768985748, 0.008768323808908463, 0.025863150134682655, -0.036747127771377563, -0.02085874415934086, -0.01372421532869339, -0.00886738020926714, -0.062106866389513016, 0.08385555446147919, -0.038370754569768906, -0.06598126143217087, 0.03802650421857834, -0.023448046296834946, 0.012088777497410774, 0.07362714409828186, -0.0021294390317052603, 0.002435859991237521, 0.017749497666954994, 0.05066612362861633, 0.001634353306144476, -0.04335129261016846, 0.04048958420753479, 0.027283627539873123, 0.02014833875000477, 0.004203468561172485, 0.01168760471045971, 0.05292283371090889, -0.01673969440162182, -0.015873640775680542, 0.010622242465615273, -0.024097653105854988, -0.0031333821825683117, -0.007819510996341705, -0.004562283866107464, -0.00034372307709418237, -0.013655344024300575, 0.02061726525425911, -0.042452774941921234, -0.0046297223307192326, 0.030556904152035713, -0.019529331475496292, 0.011678091250360012, 0.020285895094275475, -0.04227888956665993, -0.043478257954120636, -0.0345214419066906, 0.02290506288409233, 0.025961237028241158, -0.023588085547089577, 0.017842242494225502, 0.01920607127249241, 0.0058266534470021725, 0.00432827603071928, -0.03665914759039879, -0.024620791897177696, 0.06457193940877914, -0.05743275210261345, 0.043494075536727905, 0.035663653165102005, -0.024599246680736542, 0.005361496936529875, -0.06465387344360352, 0.04213537648320198, 0.018023524433374405, -0.008674233220517635, -0.027451882138848305, -0.008635501377284527, -0.05406519025564194, 0.004348632413893938, 0.02724258415400982, 0.0037205300759524107, 0.014473211020231247, -0.027906378731131554, 0.05182291939854622, 0.00017723823839332908, -0.04369447007775307, 0.011810602620244026, -0.02405492216348648, -0.023668916895985603, -0.05238233134150505, -0.010071898810565472, 0.020985150709748268, -0.034412600100040436, 0.032123252749443054, -0.031255412846803665, 0.03204770013689995, 0.0009990074904635549, 0.004003175999969244, 0.047186996787786484, -0.008332005701959133, -0.027769019827246666, -0.012684669345617294, -0.009742881171405315, -0.02497081458568573, 0.0008702718187123537, -0.0010254202643409371, -0.025948094204068184, 0.009334706701338291, -0.0012029721401631832, -0.02341149002313614, -0.020902331918478012, 0.044516317546367645, -0.012409609742462635, -0.03639505058526993, -0.0037541466299444437, 0.015806162729859352, -0.0371125191450119, 0.03950987011194229, 0.023219553753733635, -0.014944871887564659, 0.04516161233186722, -0.001214867690578103, 0.00884572695940733, -0.008262841030955315, -0.0038717351853847504, 0.014821923337876797, -0.004494478460401297, -0.004979199729859829, 0.002709030406549573, -0.01399843581020832, -0.010122324340045452, 0.0032771530095487833, 0.04055986553430557, 0.002397114410996437, 0.04799545183777809, -0.018394706770777702, -0.013220701366662979, 0.02655676379799843, -0.0025107781402766705, 0.03251993656158447, 0.03163183480501175, -0.017975037917494774, 0.05007098242640495, -0.007053093519061804, -0.019048204645514488, -0.03241650015115738, -0.047065217047929764, 0.0014718367019668221, -0.003210166236385703, -0.002035788493230939, 0.09599335491657257, 0.011726553551852703, -0.007204017136245966, -0.03539023548364639, -0.0074752504006028175, 0.015574589371681213, -0.02082851156592369, 0.04866096004843712, -0.04330671951174736, -0.0071806409396231174, 0.0034372119698673487, -0.017649734392762184, -0.026072002947330475, -0.028883397579193115, 0.01508987508714199, 0.04717572405934334, 0.04051283374428749, -0.03193642199039459, -0.029647529125213623, 0.016011036932468414, 0.00470244325697422, -0.022451618686318398, -0.03823986276984215, -0.020636646077036858, 0.006100055295974016, -0.003999870736151934, -0.009660081937909126 ]
<p>Ideally, I would like to know the fraction of the mean of $x$ over the sum of the mean of $x$ and the mean of $y$:</p> <p>$$\text{Fraction of interest} = \frac{\bar{x}}{\bar{x}+\bar{y}}$$</p> <p>where $$\bar{x} = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^I x_i }{I}$$.</p> <p>However, I have the fraction of the geometric mean of $x$ over the sum of the geometric mean of $x$ and the geometric mean of $y$:</p> <p>$$\text{Fraction I have} = \frac{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}}{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}+\prod_{i=1}^I{y_i}}$$.</p> <p>Is there a good interpretation for the fraction I have? I lose intuition when it comes to geometric means. Alternatively, is there a way to connect the two fractions?</p> <p>Note (thanks to comments notice that): $x_i, y_i, i=1,\ldots,I$ always $&gt;0$.</p> <p>To further add to this, $x_i$ and $y_i$ are observations from an experiment. It is assumed that $log(x_i)$ and $log(y_i)$ follow a normal distribution. I'm interested in the difference between $x_i$ and $y_i$, across replicates (i.e., I have $R$ experiments where in each I measure $x_i$'s and $y_i$'s) hence it is convenient for me to model $log(x_i/y_i)$ as a normally distributed random variable (with mean and variance as the sample mean and sample variance of $log(x_i/y_i)$ over $I$). I then use a regression model (without going into too much details) where the response in every experiment $r$ of $R$ is the mean $log(x_i/y_i)$ over $I$ (roughly, $\sum_{i=1}^I log(x_i/y_i)/I = \alpha + \beta X$). </p> <p>Having estimated $\alpha$ (i.e., the mean response) I would like to express $\frac{\bar{x}}{\bar{x}+\bar{y}}$ as a function of $\hat\alpha$. </p> <p>So what I have is: $\hat\alpha = \sum_{i=1}^I log(x_i/y_i)/I = log(\frac{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}}{\prod_{i=1}^I{y_i}})$</p> <p>Therefore, $e^{I\alpha} = \frac{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}}{\prod_{i=1}^I{y_i}}$</p> <p>Adding 1 to both sides and skipping a few steps gets me that:</p> <p>$\frac{e^{I\alpha}}{1 + e^{I\alpha}} = \frac{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}}{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}+\prod_{i=1}^I{y_i}}$</p> <p>So basically I'm trying to either get an intuition of how $\frac{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}}{\prod_{i=1}^I{x_i}+\prod_{i=1}^I{y_i}}$ relates to $\frac{\bar{x}}{\bar{x}+\bar{y}}$ or some function to connect the two.</p>
28,559
[ -0.014004954136908054, 0.036484863609075546, 0.005732019431889057, -0.040059320628643036, 0.010280688293278217, 0.029249627143144608, -0.007187387906014919, -0.02718953602015972, 0.015112335793673992, -0.03322288766503334, 0.05239947512745857, 0.016860423609614372, 0.04942324012517929, 0.0036825586576014757, 0.05892035737633705, 0.015851717442274094, -0.03808080404996872, 0.03159660845994949, -0.006589323282241821, -0.01881115697324276, 0.022150427103042603, 0.016749795526266098, 0.009283525869250298, 0.0173953864723444, -0.01721775345504284, 0.06195905804634094, 0.02563510648906231, -0.01357267890125513, -0.043940912932157516, 0.08257760107517242, -0.0036362065002322197, -0.006029538344591856, -0.014490226283669472, 0.035484254360198975, 0.0036907277535647154, -0.004853350110352039, 0.021858109161257744, 0.0033699499908834696, 0.021648678928613663, 0.030821621417999268, -0.014512927271425724, -0.00971006415784359, 0.01273574773222208, 0.000715593050699681, 0.03144888952374458, 0.04888926073908806, -0.03211735188961029, -0.06980683654546738, 0.027488335967063904, -0.05276426300406456, 0.06112193316221237, -0.023035310208797455, 0.03133568540215492, 0.04919133707880974, 0.01331786997616291, 0.00885082222521305, 0.06145552545785904, 0.060442741960287094, 0.010924244299530983, -0.08379864692687988, -0.0016386869829148054, -0.028980599716305733, 0.009084323421120644, 0.00556259136646986, -0.025267450138926506, -0.012478972785174847, -0.006967666558921337, -0.01588488556444645, 0.025142300873994827, -0.02619599550962448, 0.049325332045555115, 0.057059936225414276, 0.02968188375234604, 0.0073302993550896645, 0.01348698977380991, 0.012354157865047455, -0.019794782623648643, 0.025087686255574226, 0.05876992270350456, 0.03966546058654785, 0.024940485134720802, 0.004370229318737984, 0.04100049287080765, 0.01851358637213707, -0.012996705248951912, -0.012738830409944057, 0.08186420798301697, -0.011144881136715412, 0.06565732508897781, 0.024675117805600166, -0.0017554390942677855, -0.007030230946838856, 0.0559728629887104, -0.016576319932937622, -0.035080038011074066, 0.04233241453766823, -0.015167983248829842, -0.007211445830762386, -0.008921194821596146, -0.002202475443482399, -0.004587406758219004, -0.06513677537441254, -0.005253009498119354, 0.0860891342163086, 0.0011549650225788355, -0.023740848526358604, -0.009600562043488026, 0.018463220447301865, 0.01037178747355938, -0.042337607592344284, 0.016968954354524612, 0.04213646054267883, 0.018601588904857635, 0.012860863469541073, 0.000681680568959564, -0.024292007088661194, 0.007706901989877224, -0.05047371983528137, 0.07847622781991959, 0.04272299259901047, 0.03821435943245888, -0.0291901882737875, -0.018910139799118042, 0.01048086117953062, -0.012188172899186611, 0.028647325932979584, 0.019775042310357094, -0.007618989795446396, -0.020742712542414665, 0.04908689484000206, 0.006807025987654924, -0.01194781344383955, 0.05384008213877678, 0.030702482908964157, 0.0441242977976799, -0.008448799140751362, -0.06611443310976028, -0.029009627178311348, 0.07086972147226334, 0.01649620570242405, 0.00333592901006341, -0.05160187557339668, -0.03874204680323601, 0.03668597340583801, 0.026308780536055565, 0.033878859132528305, 0.03390937298536301, 0.015254940837621689, 0.027083221822977066, 0.020013175904750824, -0.018749861046671867, -0.04215329512953758, 0.003399919718503952, -0.0570574589073658, -0.0014652488753199577, -0.05622195824980736, 0.005703151226043701, 0.042048174887895584, -0.05707336962223053, 0.011732249520719051, 0.029580008238554, 0.025691593065857887, -0.012972457334399223, 0.03205395117402077, -0.0010005607036873698, -0.03351527824997902, 0.06625670939683914, -0.0101113710552454, 0.04547959938645363, 0.023151066154241562, 0.002906679641455412, -0.00895433034747839, 0.015878649428486824, 0.04960232228040695, 0.06447957456111908, -0.016937224194407463, 0.014097829349339008, -0.031585898250341415, 0.0003536269359756261, 0.04995133727788925, -0.06738907098770142, 0.012629302218556404, -0.045040156692266464, 0.015394652262330055, 0.047778692096471786, 0.058180131018161774, 0.0027411666233092546, -0.0046559893526136875, 0.019851919263601303, -0.018540114164352417, -0.03252500295639038, -0.055747512727975845, -0.04665429890155792, -0.01324007473886013, -0.03792522847652435, -0.006480618845671415, -0.0069216410629451275, 0.009012578055262566, 0.021845825016498566, -0.002259110799059272, 0.03178930655121803, -0.003727809526026249, 0.052769504487514496, -0.03263179212808609, 0.023040197789669037, 0.03169970586895943, 0.044864580035209656, -0.009179719723761082, 0.029222330078482628, -0.037504322826862335, -0.005727787502110004, -0.028062885627150536, -0.04326162114739418, -0.0000036390383684192784, -0.014322184957563877, -0.019751880317926407, -0.0011611820664256811, -0.03699756786227226, -0.015143370255827904, 0.0222032368183136, -0.05833223834633827, 0.036530833691358566, 0.0705018863081932, -0.030718067660927773, -0.036703601479530334, -0.004365222062915564, 0.012252540327608585, 0.03059682995080948, -0.04666682332754135, -0.038920700550079346, -0.035800643265247345, -0.01037677749991417, 0.041168686002492905, 0.04654715210199356, -0.020919715985655785, 0.01295890100300312, 0.058034755289554596, 0.0192282535135746, -0.012595806270837784, 0.014851570129394531, -0.005623626988381147, -0.027233991771936417, 0.021312743425369263, 0.004942596890032291, 0.018205877393484116, -0.008479813113808632, -0.001169699477031827, -0.000946762622334063, 0.04077369347214699, -0.014022535644471645, 0.0011600293219089508, 0.04158588871359825, 0.02324923500418663, 0.004291418474167585, 0.004059160128235817, 0.002548329997807741, 0.032516464591026306, -0.012522799894213676, -0.01057132426649332, 0.021673938259482384, 0.01294899731874466, -0.00914272665977478, -0.005524112842977047, 0.0013809931697323918, -0.012627560645341873, 0.025383835658431053, -0.03004690818488598, -0.023318612948060036, 0.008963479660451412, -0.03574969246983528, 0.0038299972657114267, -0.026268359273672104, -0.05752502754330635, 0.009486548602581024, -0.05032213032245636, 0.010687927715480328, 0.01832938939332962, -0.023447642102837563, -0.04397410899400711, -0.018602095544338226, -0.012224375270307064, -0.016976820304989815, 0.011564884334802628, -0.026683136820793152, -0.04101189970970154, -0.011367164552211761, -0.03544981777667999, 0.0381012000143528, -0.01907527446746826, -0.026709942147135735, 0.002017546445131302, 0.020248308777809143, -0.017254073172807693, -0.06816312670707703, -0.03328902646899223, -0.049563199281692505, 0.020580213516950607, -0.029004110023379326, -0.018263954669237137, 0.0403401218354702, 0.02760058268904686, -0.05879073962569237, 0.019738199189305305, -0.040972016751766205, -0.0040726931765675545, -0.028515789657831192, 0.019734079018235207, 0.03771861270070076, 0.011655403301119804, 0.023954380303621292, -0.0036815074272453785, -0.04293272644281387, -0.033588238060474396, -0.08786836266517639, -0.05719225853681564, 0.003906514961272478, 0.0004787701182067394, 0.04861833155155182, 0.021075112745165825, -0.04801451042294502, 0.09056831151247025, 0.02102329023182392, 0.010328042320907116, -0.03134205937385559, 0.03729594871401787, 0.013036267831921577, -0.013648812659084797, 0.03384776413440704, -0.0046257213689386845, -0.008982752449810505, 0.038852814584970474, -0.005656154826283455, 0.014799755066633224, 0.013043366372585297, 0.02093755640089512, -0.025058738887310028, -0.0026223340537399054, -0.0014675124548375607, 0.01753571443259716, 0.039799440652132034, 0.06454718112945557, -0.0008582264417782426, 0.004698473960161209, -0.014108722098171711, 0.051661331206560135, 0.017264824360609055, -0.08472242951393127, 0.032166335731744766, -0.007722914218902588, -0.018474319949746132, 0.02729644440114498, 0.03173768147826195, 0.024947870522737503, -0.05464300140738487, -0.030660493299365044, 0.0015780108515173197, 0.010270937345921993, -0.01290691364556551, 0.008189135231077671, 0.03197488188743591, 0.054860178381204605, 0.009389727376401424, -0.005394402425736189, -0.006554638501256704, -0.05056401714682579, 0.02533925324678421, -0.013743824325501919, 0.002959385048598051, 0.025419145822525024, 0.04507606104016304, -0.01345719862729311, -0.04174504429101944, -0.022939158603549004, -0.04589702934026718, -0.07041163742542267, 0.008701333776116371, -0.019345231354236603, 0.022565189749002457, 0.02885751612484455, 0.028500255197286606, -0.001173312310129404, -0.0536176860332489, 0.005423544906079769, -0.01255479920655489, -0.043561067432165146, 0.013829000294208527, -0.0157896988093853, -0.002000453881919384, 0.00004602653280016966, -0.025799697265028954, 0.045739367604255676, -0.033043939620256424, 0.023285936564207077, -0.012751493602991104, -0.007382531184703112, -0.04292185977101326, 0.013878196477890015, -0.02308567427098751, -0.02668912708759308, -0.011761500500142574, 0.01913953758776188, -0.0039741056971251965, 0.007797221187502146, -0.005448353011161089, -0.006116209551692009, 0.011224993504583836, -0.01477388571947813, -0.04453910514712334, -0.023617688566446304, 0.02423248253762722, 0.04932514578104019, 0.012110662646591663, 0.020381540060043335, -0.034171074628829956, 0.04423912614583969, 0.015223285183310509, 0.051353469491004944, 0.03735330328345299, -0.020212873816490173, -0.027753761038184166, -0.015749642625451088, -0.028759049251675606, -0.03008153662085533, 0.034202706068754196, -0.008080416359007359, -0.01349533163011074, 0.053106870502233505, 0.0379580594599247, -0.025372091680765152, 0.00877762958407402, 0.04959172010421753, 0.027713391929864883, -0.01954922452569008, -0.03633449226617813, -0.0059369755908846855, -0.019609764218330383, 0.006508317776024342, -0.0072791012935340405, -0.018105298280715942, -0.008569847792387009, -0.022613970562815666, 0.04977019131183624, 0.041308119893074036, -0.004325579386204481, -0.019671669229865074, 0.026989584788680077, 0.04083583131432533, 0.00001582885488460306, -0.0554189495742321, 0.002765179146081209, 0.05814604461193085, 0.024421202018857002, 0.025668201968073845, 0.025377845391631126, -0.020372595638036728, 0.0017078635282814503, 0.00823893491178751, 0.042275816202163696, -0.0350029282271862, 0.0002961959398817271, 0.003423403948545456, -0.016531258821487427, 0.009915700182318687, -0.008190741762518883, 0.012012030929327011, -0.042176831513643265, -0.005304590333253145, 0.02046322636306286, 0.003592219902202487, -0.10391209274530411, 0.01960407942533493, -0.014122482389211655, -0.0017909001326188445, -0.02828345075249672, -0.011074945330619812, -0.05114828795194626, -0.017804188653826714, 0.0014729175018146634, 0.04820944741368294, -0.05247168242931366, -0.012063559144735336, 0.023507099598646164, 0.037562400102615356, 0.03106224536895752, -0.07100013643503189, 0.04153202101588249, 0.0026476106140762568, 0.010003299452364445, 0.024197755381464958, -0.024893473833799362, -0.07170380651950836, 0.029462704434990883, 0.016572410240769386, -0.0031167841516435146, 0.0053682937286794186, -0.01815650798380375, 0.014241739176213741, 0.06336646527051926, -0.0005908817402087152, 0.05249844118952751, 0.036721501499414444, -0.008403231389820576, -0.01787647046148777, -0.042091500014066696, 0.006215229630470276, -0.02690165862441063, -0.03863433375954628, -0.034439485520124435, 0.003632088890299201, 0.025671618059277534, -0.013958867639303207, -0.05152234435081482, 0.05387096479535103, -0.045399151742458344, -0.053003232926130295, 0.011244465596973896, 0.004309874959290028, -0.0009262613020837307, -0.01412407960742712, -0.013160865753889084, 0.02955176681280136, 0.020702892914414406, -0.008868725970387459, -0.015182086266577244, -0.0033554094843566418, 0.0005897820228710771, 0.018095264211297035, -0.008783104829490185, -0.008088404312729836, -0.04199228808283806, -0.003177541308104992, 0.002815531799569726, 0.01607380621135235, -0.00447066267952323, -0.03204711154103279, 0.01277200784534216, -0.0017075312789529562, -0.03268371522426605, -0.005999953486025333, 0.0019404042977839708, 0.02255597524344921, 0.027606338262557983, -0.035627126693725586, -0.01962597668170929, -0.01756066083908081, -0.0017534800572320819, -0.06296509504318237, -0.028394928202033043, 0.018016614019870758, -0.006536168046295643, -0.012120839208364487, -0.03419598937034607, -0.00014778031618334353, -0.006081931758671999, -0.053485892713069916, -0.0025033343117684126, 0.0791495069861412, -0.0494525246322155, -0.012844993732869625, -0.03647243231534958, 0.06495769321918488, 0.06587909162044525, -0.04350999370217323, -0.016698576509952545, 0.024338524788618088, -0.0036897792015224695, -0.036579813808202744, 0.010202300734817982, 0.012732666917145252, -0.04719262942671776, 0.012758562341332436, -0.017190366983413696, -0.04505947232246399, 0.02621622569859028, -0.01588134653866291, -0.05021500959992409, 0.019157009199261665, 0.006936237215995789, 0.00819955300539732, 0.005967417266219854, 0.000049506048526382074, 0.03821064159274101, 0.026813572272658348, -0.01186002604663372, -0.003989439457654953, -0.02658381499350071, 0.012186156585812569, 0.05140028893947601, -0.001273568719625473, 0.0004943846724927425, 0.029232624918222427, 0.06311337649822235, 0.006944883149117231, -0.014005337841808796, -0.010936371050775051, -0.014480543322861195, 0.027835456654429436, 0.001618197187781334, 0.01370906364172697, 0.0346706360578537, 0.009472697041928768, -0.02996790036559105, -0.024733398109674454, -0.037372052669525146, -0.026167601346969604, 0.03931927680969238, -0.019322369247674942, 0.028384611010551453, 0.0015838838880881667, -0.00035565788857638836, -0.007656930014491081, -0.028637953102588654, -0.02216055430471897, 0.014746543951332569, 0.0020561611745506525, 0.02790123224258423, -0.03675508871674538, -0.057892147451639175, 0.029901603236794472, 0.03456859663128853, -0.002626513596624136, 0.011593809351325035, -0.004320214036852121, 0.019213778898119926, -0.002743308199569583, -0.04071277379989624, -0.05870305746793747, 0.07548002153635025, -0.03813575953245163, 0.027174022048711777, -0.043602652847766876, -0.04225553199648857, 0.05329950898885727, 0.06036209315061569, 0.004613648634403944, -0.05097069963812828, -0.02048652432858944, -0.04743845760822296, 0.01902266964316368, 0.0393826849758625, -0.016026610508561134, 0.04546179622411728, -0.020944051444530487, 0.02327675186097622, -0.034533530473709106, 0.030863136053085327, -0.00010743038001237437, -0.08046317845582962, 0.0032882089726626873, 0.02485337108373642, -0.030020352452993393, 0.03021426312625408, -0.003664458403363824, -0.024264438077807426, 0.005814064759761095, -0.012967678718268871, 0.016314303502440453, 0.001198129146359861, 0.0060942391864955425, -0.014749693684279919, 0.044968437403440475, 0.02053624577820301, -0.01314435712993145, -0.019799772650003433, -0.022425418719649315, 0.12141154706478119, 0.0387338250875473, 0.01659192517399788, -0.04443347081542015, 0.016468916088342667, 0.0025964651722460985, 0.022940555587410927, -0.015932682901620865, -0.00904850848019123, 0.033691588789224625, 0.012550345622003078, 0.05876647308468819, 0.04494393616914749, -0.011334025301039219, -0.014067184180021286, 0.03932342305779457, -0.019540203735232353, -0.012950018979609013, 0.02373555675148964, 0.0027154884301126003, 0.014242544770240784, -0.00504148518666625, -0.03046562522649765, 0.03431987762451172, -0.00314212660305202, -0.006817813962697983, -0.03700682148337364, -0.02714180387556553, -0.011333008296787739, 0.0029973883647471666, -0.013058477081358433, 0.014028229750692844, -0.008135953918099403, 0.01266754325479269, -0.0005347858532331884, -0.020500661805272102, 0.02995484136044979, -0.03630747273564339, 0.01772984117269516, -0.0016861438052728772, -0.015566171146929264, 0.016206825152039528, 0.03050960600376129, 0.02637922391295433, -0.06797374039888382, -0.033925861120224, -0.01634993404150009, 0.04637760668992996, -0.01841539703309536, 0.03990471363067627, -0.03133980557322502, -0.004298154264688492, -0.01528795063495636, 0.00044365954818204045, 0.0034898980520665646, 0.04382704198360443, 0.00747698824852705, -0.057303715497255325, -0.016579613089561462, -0.017927931621670723, 0.005355203989893198, 0.005055148620158434, 0.06910976767539978, 0.02548336610198021, -0.0478934682905674, -0.04400111362338066, 0.00515679270029068, 0.04753690958023071, -0.0021289719734340906, 0.0013063702499493957, -0.0026642868760973215, -0.03271712362766266, 0.00029560329858213663, -0.02341517247259617, 0.014416930265724659, -0.025784695520997047, 0.062092412263154984, 0.014665486291050911, -0.022332437336444855, -0.012469504028558731, -0.0165372584015131, 0.0076273903250694275, -0.0236560869961977, 0.03780227527022362, -0.06574808061122894, -0.018520595505833626, 0.025945059955120087, 0.044953446835279465, 0.008117186836898327, 0.009259004145860672, 0.006555359810590744, 0.06006432697176933, 0.008704704232513905, -0.008284643292427063, -0.041086144745349884, 0.046943966299295425, -0.04337133467197418, -0.011872571893036366, -0.013833231292665005, 0.04229527339339256, 0.028164664283394814, 0.03732806444168091, -0.014536128379404545, 0.025152528658509254, -0.021341584622859955, 0.01634226366877556, -0.017068758606910706, -0.03610912337899208, 0.037622954696416855, 0.023694254457950592, 0.04198644682765007, -0.013939731754362583, 0.004207020625472069, 0.006664813496172428, -0.04645721614360809, 0.006962743122130632, -0.03615415841341019, 0.0041323015466332436, 0.0010852399282157421, -0.014877608977258205, 0.0058288611471652985, 0.016616664826869965, -0.05630352348089218, -0.02745242230594158, -0.008244683034718037, 0.011603434570133686, 0.011835274286568165, 0.000019494571461109444, 0.0350702665746212, 0.017431432381272316, 0.013788792304694653, 0.05982159450650215, 0.021209290251135826, 0.029302995651960373, -0.039665427058935165, 0.016493050381541252, 0.006650533992797136, 0.046958889812231064, -0.00980638712644577, -0.041195303201675415, 0.056250520050525665, -0.0073873549699783325, -0.04443858563899994, 0.01497387420386076, 0.005030155181884766, 0.0321672223508358, 0.020769506692886353, 0.026363449171185493, -0.06376064568758011, 0.012714886106550694, -0.031197449192404747, 0.032621946185827255, -0.04932873696088791, -0.005685038864612579, 0.030271245166659355, -0.04750730097293854, 0.029567304998636246, 0.028408022597432137, -0.0075025358237326145, 0.023262210190296173, -0.005555512849241495, -0.051827479153871536, 0.027031077072024345, 0.012858809903264046, 0.02625352516770363, -0.02731657773256302, -0.02752728760242462, 0.015722759068012238, 0.018391426652669907, 0.020392777398228645, -0.04572341963648796, 0.013711892999708652, -0.04038429260253906, -0.012549721635878086, -0.07663460075855255, -0.05428658425807953, 0.01723983883857727, 0.015993362292647362, 0.016724348068237305, -0.010227549821138382, -0.04411047697067261, 0.02269415184855461, -0.03746896609663963, -0.01823895238339901, 0.014064520597457886, -0.06027847155928612, -0.03809920698404312, 0.014425639063119888, 0.004637823905795813, -0.018298285081982613, 0.022793438285589218, 0.04523506388068199, 0.005499795079231262, 0.05454033613204956, 0.004067305941134691, -0.030487505719065666, -0.0206866767257452, 0.015644975006580353, -0.0037933490239083767, -0.05750386789441109, 0.029801534488797188, -0.02599407732486725, 0.021392909809947014, 0.027805129066109657, 0.010205983184278011, 0.021877214312553406, -0.01490649301558733, 0.030232293531298637, 0.0046203164383769035, 0.04966309666633606, 0.006482485216110945, 0.006598223466426134, -0.02767307311296463, 0.01679486781358719, 0.030385276302695274, 0.03278253227472305, -0.05430928245186806, -0.010244169272482395, 0.04901988431811333, 0.013665747828781605, -0.04198213294148445, -0.0004883115761913359, -0.004543705377727747, -0.016352126374840736, 0.013955985195934772, 0.014690200798213482, -0.012345775030553341, -0.05266245827078819, 0.04040098190307617, -0.06891392171382904, 0.005780169274657965, 0.045476384460926056, 0.007811794988811016, -0.022011134773492813, 0.021913954988121986, 0.0005833358154632151, -0.0030039711855351925, 0.013750774785876274, 0.02776520699262619, -0.008241748437285423, -0.054630305618047714, 0.00880498718470335, -0.00760080199688673, 0.0009324876591563225, -0.011538698337972164, -0.012427246198058128, -0.018312660977244377, 0.020416416227817535, -0.008347805589437485, 0.0184929296374321, -0.029528871178627014, -0.003992973826825619, 0.004506577271968126, -0.07142242789268494, 0.04960526525974274, 0.033015165477991104, -0.011603855527937412, -0.026944592595100403, -0.015505618415772915, -0.03420940414071083, -0.014815199188888073, 0.09601568430662155, 0.042436666786670685, 0.000668297812808305, 0.01619441993534565, 0.03539344295859337, 0.01979992352426052, -0.04622402787208557, 0.024478867650032043, -0.03470717370510101, -0.010130690410733223, -0.020723367109894753, 0.01044400967657566, -0.024484701454639435, 0.02198854833841324, 0.04264724999666214, -0.012866328470408916, -0.015361213125288486, -0.020067626610398293, -0.006714773830026388, 0.0469353012740612, 0.012453540228307247, -0.0048642451874911785, 0.06172415614128113, -0.002614178229123354, 0.008356559090316296, 0.05081014335155487, -0.0026887902058660984, -0.07015825808048248, 0.0019116679904982448, -0.05651789903640747, -0.03657747432589531, 0.003767845220863819, 0.028075288981199265, 0.026409335434436798, -0.008962553925812244, 0.002371645299717784, 0.03367973491549492, -0.037390369921922684, -0.021228002384305, 0.023274356499314308, 0.021790774539113045, 0.0472668819129467, 0.010722890496253967, 0.015944581478834152, 0.0016678335377946496, -0.01074917521327734, 0.01416411530226469, -0.03322697430849075, 0.024238279089331627, 0.02937890961766243, -0.044110313057899475, 0.019716763868927956, 0.0005607594503089786, 0.03657007962465286, -0.029872724786400795, 0.025463374331593513, -0.04357520490884781, -0.02760549634695053, 0.024836407974362373, -0.05564846843481064, -0.019608089700341225, -0.01471629273146391, 0.015608604066073895, 0.07178515195846558, -0.01743018627166748, -0.007443880662322044, -0.03917349874973297, -0.028906747698783875, -0.0042841495014727116, -0.01872727833688259, -0.005266616586595774, -0.007668205536901951, 0.00455743120983243, 0.005657144356518984, -0.0050843339413404465, -0.02217377908527851, 0.01840704306960106, 0.013570473529398441, 0.0268852636218071, 0.01065630093216896, 0.0019522840157151222, -0.016949541866779327, -0.047707099467515945, -0.04879693314433098, -0.000408560415962711, 0.04631026089191437, 0.012337561696767807, 0.006194371730089188, -0.013835790567100048, -0.023132367059588432, 0.03037629835307598, 0.07109850645065308, -0.06907585263252258, -0.04264681786298752, -0.011938158422708511, 0.02547287940979004, 0.025200577452778816, -0.04041575267910957 ]
<p>Deas,</p> <p>One assumption for Spearman's correlation is that data have to be monotonic .. I tried to do scatterplot in spss, but I get the following graph that I couldn't decide if it is monotonic .. What is the solution please ? Note: my data are ordinal variables.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/RZOUG.jpg" alt="Scatterplot gragh"></p>
35,970
[ -0.04751921445131302, 0.007895846851170063, 0.03639958053827286, 0.01348569244146347, 0.038209330290555954, 0.021060777828097343, -0.0030344875995069742, -0.013402190990746021, 0.0351429209113121, -0.03850279748439789, 0.04553527384996414, -0.009518340229988098, 0.046925973147153854, 0.05259746313095093, 0.022087106481194496, 0.008480139076709747, 0.01805981434881687, 0.008760228753089905, -0.0032171804923564196, 0.007023896090686321, 0.015588308684527874, 0.0019480257760733366, -0.009071684442460537, -0.00037424603942781687, -0.026580728590488434, 0.07851473987102509, -0.01856214553117752, -0.032205287367105484, 0.003973709885030985, 0.05282001197338104, -0.020573442801833153, -0.012529402039945126, 0.0289007518440485, 0.043084871023893356, 0.06618943065404892, 0.013837821781635284, -0.004703096579760313, 0.014637294225394726, -0.0495184063911438, -0.005969176534563303, -0.014099542051553726, -0.021951016038656235, 0.0016896878369152546, 0.02943403273820877, -0.01236235722899437, 0.02413145639002323, 0.003230154514312744, -0.0065267616882920265, 0.03207991644740105, -0.03179914504289627, 0.06006203591823578, -0.03783078119158745, 0.045049622654914856, 0.03947119042277336, -0.016473593190312386, 0.005536569282412529, 0.036662328988313675, 0.03069918416440487, 0.0027639970649033785, -0.06228990852832794, -0.0043779700063169, -0.0402982234954834, 0.00041696298285387456, 0.00015153975982684642, -0.03306758776307106, 0.035477250814437866, 0.030401740223169327, -0.02744746021926403, 0.026389598846435547, 0.0006952249677851796, -0.006803445052355528, -0.0005859476514160633, 0.02177669107913971, -0.030450714752078056, -0.009245170280337334, -0.050312403589487076, 0.03294728696346283, -0.0057022059336304665, 0.04158914089202881, 0.0358804389834404, 0.05283723026514053, 0.024098940193653107, -0.005518270190805197, 0.024236366152763367, 0.04037533327937126, 0.002646607579663396, 0.058259814977645874, 0.00009350972686661407, -0.014180898666381836, 0.027535894885659218, 0.0006573706632480025, 0.0031953449361026287, 0.03353013098239899, 0.01582052744925022, -0.013490691781044006, 0.005338937975466251, -0.03530304133892059, -0.008941007778048515, -0.011852928437292576, -0.011595111340284348, -0.0073692696169018745, -0.02263534814119339, -0.00028591087902896106, 0.030153822153806686, 0.010448900051414967, 0.011369998566806316, -0.032712940126657486, 0.009475930593907833, -0.0223678108304739, -0.05494656413793564, -0.03406360000371933, 0.044398605823516846, 0.05921614542603493, 0.033320341259241104, 0.00015498347056563944, -0.042822033166885376, -0.004012350458651781, 0.0052908919751644135, 0.022446397691965103, 0.06114880368113518, 0.04214811697602272, -0.010065617971122265, 0.0524815134704113, 0.01416190154850483, -0.02669926919043064, 0.026980211958289146, 0.018786931410431862, -0.016670627519488335, -0.029411446303129196, 0.05007694289088249, 0.020135991275310516, 0.001003182609565556, 0.05308906361460686, -0.02357354201376438, 0.04972166568040848, 0.00449715182185173, -0.08522213250398636, -0.06051928550004959, 0.025074182078242302, 0.03171490132808685, 0.03481215611100197, -0.04189582169055939, 0.008801363408565521, 0.029365450143814087, 0.03742916136980057, 0.0053298864513635635, 0.018460649996995926, 0.001818180433474481, 0.02679247222840786, 0.030553346499800682, -0.005386041942983866, -0.0015311972238123417, -0.017191406339406967, -0.06354116648435593, 0.01520567201077938, -0.08142515271902084, -0.010704298503696918, 0.007495500147342682, 0.02117598056793213, -0.025601251050829887, 0.032329972833395004, 0.03598804399371147, -0.016635458916425705, -0.024477379396557808, -0.007724970579147339, -0.0018150198739022017, 0.06449034065008163, -0.02338247187435627, 0.03923458606004715, -0.021428769454360008, -0.028128625825047493, 0.0326402522623539, -0.025883132591843605, 0.06271927803754807, 0.04694367200136185, -0.016919029876589775, -0.01891719177365303, -0.02434622123837471, -0.022839762270450592, 0.01943562738597393, -0.05893644690513611, -0.010764428414404392, -0.07641567289829254, -0.006160353776067495, 0.026021098718047142, 0.04242415353655815, -0.0003942741604987532, 0.007578331511467695, 0.010217351838946342, -0.047514770179986954, -0.07117532193660736, -0.07826562225818634, -0.0007941625081002712, -0.014768675900995731, -0.04730191081762314, 0.0199806559830904, 0.024699440225958824, 0.02635915018618107, 0.005310609936714172, -0.002041555941104889, -0.010661349631845951, -0.006576202344149351, 0.06073801591992378, -0.0662950947880745, 0.01945640705525875, 0.03961292281746864, 0.038639750331640244, -0.04046519845724106, 0.023739755153656006, -0.036544326692819595, -0.016184870153665543, 0.03742355480790138, -0.006149724591523409, -0.01036161370575428, 0.00339111196808517, -0.007296367548406124, 0.014260051771998405, 0.03525734692811966, -0.04485001415014267, 0.043154966086149216, -0.03274812176823616, 0.03596096485853195, 0.07092272490262985, 0.009693813510239124, 0.012936712242662907, -0.002082908758893609, 0.030545148998498917, 0.02101661078631878, -0.018355879932641983, 0.006122802384197712, 0.00017624680185690522, 0.008577648550271988, 0.008550588972866535, 0.02469283901154995, -0.023205533623695374, -0.008310793898999691, 0.08001513034105301, 0.008282656781375408, -0.007737009320408106, 0.03091125749051571, -0.031693510711193085, -0.01906627230346203, 0.006834954489022493, -0.00853181816637516, 0.03825446963310242, 0.03175502270460129, 0.008711217902600765, -0.014135797508060932, 0.027119670063257217, 0.026570407673716545, -0.021099761128425598, 0.02800684981048107, 0.003641227725893259, 0.00618225522339344, -0.01398483570665121, -0.010351164266467094, 0.0550246499478817, -0.012697070837020874, 0.012425265274941921, 0.04855098947882652, -0.0038959470111876726, -0.023230966180562973, 0.010812723077833652, -0.010241089388728142, -0.019411368295550346, 0.043131228536367416, -0.018609188497066498, -0.00651256088167429, 0.020705830305814743, -0.044033654034137726, -0.017489219084382057, -0.010810187086462975, -0.017743507400155067, -0.05455119535326958, -0.0013568190624937415, 0.07289142906665802, -0.002942149294540286, 0.03704017773270607, -0.05665271356701851, -0.020924963057041168, 0.005220428109169006, 0.007331452798098326, 0.023814769461750984, -0.007321541663259268, -0.04917801544070244, -0.0252046100795269, 0.018748367205262184, 0.004146380349993706, 0.019133098423480988, -0.02514190785586834, -0.014808340929448605, 0.04999975115060806, 0.039400577545166016, -0.031889013946056366, -0.053813837468624115, 0.00016870936087798327, -0.03625031188130379, -0.03935649245977402, -0.02092764340341091, -0.005148611962795258, 0.004758465103805065, -0.047079093754291534, -0.015821076929569244, -0.05900083854794502, -0.03608926385641098, -0.014448734000325203, -0.004105530679225922, 0.018866702914237976, -0.013494737446308136, 0.03907144069671631, -0.009698054753243923, -0.027725303545594215, -0.026394540444016457, -0.0686674565076828, -0.05624661222100258, 0.0288967564702034, -0.006857671309262514, 0.020938193425536156, 0.010834809392690659, -0.047691479325294495, 0.05823615565896034, 0.022213302552700043, -0.017355112358927727, -0.05825832486152649, -0.02552187070250511, -0.022653531283140182, -0.006966347806155682, 0.02206580340862274, 0.016701634973287582, 0.08253449201583862, 0.0054733604192733765, -0.04100210964679718, 0.05368584021925926, 0.029820052906870842, -0.025898294523358345, 0.00312103983014822, 0.032163046300411224, -0.014172863215208054, -0.03362630680203438, 0.06442832946777344, 0.025363776832818985, -0.06781438738107681, 0.027129219844937325, -0.018042374402284622, -0.011006241664290428, -0.02716982178390026, -0.054506488144397736, 0.020497074350714684, -0.00250690127722919, 0.05524664744734764, -0.04400792345404625, 0.030243543907999992, 0.035631198436021805, -0.007398614194244146, -0.03250307962298393, 0.005703015252947807, 0.01713595725595951, -0.0016811526147648692, -0.007460550870746374, 0.040146440267562866, 0.02784257009625435, -0.019813288003206253, 0.012868855148553848, -0.012201028876006603, -0.02124219387769699, 0.017274197190999985, -0.013445025309920311, -0.01124291867017746, 0.02569490671157837, 0.04658075049519539, -0.009032614529132843, 0.03627309948205948, -0.017853302881121635, 0.0019561874214559793, -0.04030876234173775, 0.003989836201071739, -0.030752094462513924, 0.04247990995645523, 0.020879842340946198, 0.03213047981262207, 0.02905973419547081, 0.011158249340951443, -0.018310939893126488, -0.016182322055101395, -0.031091779470443726, 0.0663452073931694, 0.0021752750035375357, 0.002264590235427022, 0.061079371720552444, -0.04981030523777008, -0.0009861667640507221, -0.05346114933490753, 0.012267443351447582, 0.024967052042484283, 0.060844484716653824, -0.04398180916905403, -0.006083664949983358, -0.02260654978454113, 0.007307254709303379, -0.015201560221612453, 0.010395713150501251, 0.0020231297239661217, -0.02735341526567936, 0.06147357076406479, 0.04960402846336365, 0.018351126462221146, -0.008546054363250732, -0.012679144740104675, -0.008714666590094566, 0.027328187599778175, 0.026727674528956413, -0.0025061469059437513, 0.012161413207650185, -0.004786592908203602, 0.06606876850128174, -0.01509907841682434, 0.025989467278122902, 0.025226589292287827, -0.018707940354943275, 0.009049327112734318, -0.008210193365812302, -0.011233930476009846, -0.014600012451410294, 0.0361516997218132, 0.05826825276017189, 0.00032752356491982937, 0.02915899083018303, -0.012841369956731796, -0.05752965435385704, 0.017793353646993637, 0.06888438016176224, 0.042680658400058746, 0.003518811659887433, -0.04369645565748215, -0.04791317507624626, -0.030540868639945984, 0.027006492018699646, 0.030083896592259407, 0.01328160148113966, -0.0249483585357666, 0.03451119735836983, 0.042812008410692215, -0.011177734471857548, -0.039643239229917526, 0.010078423656523228, 0.0017372953006997705, 0.03954170644283295, -0.004082391504198313, -0.04515412822365761, 0.02806316502392292, 0.013125663623213768, 0.019966673105955124, 0.015391758643090725, -0.016773080453276634, -0.0759115144610405, -0.015023413114249706, 0.03274102136492729, 0.05061229690909386, -0.036078084260225296, -0.009953895583748817, -0.004500535782426596, 0.015154585242271423, 0.05780544877052307, -0.010901423171162605, 0.0368269719183445, 0.01517049316316843, 0.034822121262550354, -0.0440051294863224, -0.05552339926362038, -0.050336919724941254, 0.006630885414779186, -0.010049042291939259, 0.027205679565668106, 0.01445720810443163, -0.03373360261321068, -0.06288764625787735, -0.04382865130901337, -0.009462250396609306, 0.04418974742293358, -0.037463948130607605, -0.022578218951821327, -0.024571549147367477, 0.012184683233499527, -0.0034373176749795675, -0.061147939413785934, 0.06888215243816376, -0.024798285216093063, -0.0005171188386157155, 0.056778643280267715, 0.019674917683005333, -0.006402830593287945, -0.014988369308412075, -0.019854987040162086, -0.01793389394879341, 0.015749702230095863, -0.029491735622286797, 0.052100393921136856, 0.01094892993569374, -0.03506891056895256, 0.008966343477368355, 0.028977544978260994, -0.01646909862756729, -0.014154590666294098, -0.03429638594388962, 0.011246931739151478, -0.05451701581478119, -0.015785284340381622, -0.05975267291069031, -0.014869336038827896, -0.046817321330308914, 0.023517951369285583, -0.007204033434391022, 0.025113515555858612, -0.0005655621062032878, 0.007661483716219664, 0.007317699957638979, 0.01807941496372223, -0.019082827493548393, 0.024279586970806122, 0.015118726529181004, -0.0029187011532485485, -0.0003993554855696857, -0.05244210362434387, -0.009416612796485424, -0.01701350510120392, -0.025223197415471077, -0.012858686968684196, -0.030949678272008896, -0.024241991341114044, 0.0029166731983423233, -0.047195885330438614, -0.0010422113118693233, -0.07024058699607849, 0.038778431713581085, 0.009804765693843365, 0.02506045252084732, 0.014770696870982647, -0.02252085506916046, -0.02793751284480095, 0.06391014903783798, -0.006204654462635517, -0.01699976995587349, -0.04279826208949089, 0.04207088425755501, 0.00664860475808382, -0.019268659874796867, -0.04839881882071495, -0.0523558184504509, 0.02177494950592518, -0.033605776727199554, -0.027728082612156868, 0.004640724044293165, 0.01320822723209858, 0.006777039263397455, -0.020758386701345444, 0.015035263262689114, 0.06273937970399857, -0.0006739080999977887, 0.0018293904140591621, -0.018129751086235046, -0.029790515080094337, 0.05492536723613739, 0.008459381759166718, 0.002268439158797264, -0.0045396387577056885, -0.027085166424512863, -0.029137328267097473, -0.008976125158369541, 0.007235805504024029, -0.01780928485095501, -0.022809436544775963, -0.03266095742583275, 0.008814885281026363, 0.007073116023093462, -0.0250917449593544, -0.021938107907772064, -0.04221421107649803, -0.030618613585829735, -0.004738030023872852, -0.037652887403964996, -0.008235211484134197, -0.012653498910367489, 0.026692088693380356, -0.000892810698132962, -0.0033724713139235973, -0.04149018973112106, -0.0032231525983661413, 0.0010209857719019055, 0.02734978124499321, -0.013569589704275131, 0.03834427520632744, 0.039932627230882645, 0.047668978571891785, -0.020804259926080704, 0.0008517763344570994, 0.014081432484090328, 0.009274276904761791, 0.02642139606177807, 0.005321836099028587, -0.017552558332681656, 0.03998648375272751, -0.036713842302560806, 0.015561110340058804, -0.010463504120707512, -0.0072333295829594135, 0.06873707473278046, 0.016549769788980484, 0.027393052354454994, 0.02351071499288082, -0.0397501178085804, -0.003603018121793866, -0.007861856371164322, -0.00043162022484466434, 0.009159838780760765, 0.015600069426000118, 0.03626661002635956, -0.03647792339324951, 0.005188691895455122, 0.01599040813744068, 0.059354014694690704, 0.007478233892470598, 0.04881773889064789, 0.03514804691076279, 0.012829301878809929, 0.05351382866501808, -0.04385272040963173, -0.061223674565553665, 0.02423088066279888, 0.01079102698713541, 0.028217699378728867, -0.025146789848804474, -0.052488554269075394, 0.0003789815818890929, 0.03640875965356827, 0.001822182210162282, -0.07231054455041885, -0.00880252756178379, -0.015450832433998585, -0.014156177639961243, -0.013307983987033367, -0.042428240180015564, 0.011005998589098454, 0.023871809244155884, 0.013642540201544762, -0.03323390334844589, 0.05357435345649719, -0.01115467119961977, -0.06688892841339111, -0.007166595663875341, -0.013183580711483955, -0.052138552069664, 0.05405542999505997, -0.04026242718100548, -0.02096765860915184, -0.00782822910696268, -0.014649701304733753, -0.009192836470901966, 0.020315218716859818, -0.007693340070545673, 0.021164199337363243, 0.03777046501636505, 0.020490968599915504, 0.026457292959094048, 0.005260803736746311, -0.00534664373844862, 0.12190339714288712, 0.07433400303125381, 0.02652740105986595, -0.011280671693384647, 0.018018875271081924, -0.0024323484394699335, 0.014543871395289898, -0.009782795794308186, 0.00792514719069004, 0.0059583755210042, -0.023220479488372803, 0.032293375581502914, 0.057731177657842636, 0.018061498180031776, 0.02400418370962143, 0.057237930595874786, -0.0387786440551281, -0.013230969198048115, -0.016348455101251602, 0.014375339262187481, -0.007378924172371626, 0.005623877514153719, -0.02963298000395298, -0.004660081584006548, 0.010720799677073956, -0.04695117101073265, -0.030391981825232506, 0.01798251084983349, 0.015797872096300125, 0.018802715465426445, -0.037290479987859726, -0.02455340512096882, 0.045841917395591736, -0.011504248715937138, -0.013726949691772461, 0.002655747113749385, 0.002422402612864971, -0.08109341561794281, 0.02585899643599987, 0.006907701957970858, -0.010359701700508595, -0.009917727671563625, 0.009382233954966068, 0.0029114694334566593, -0.04395362734794617, 0.009205816313624382, 0.007396801840513945, 0.04645344987511635, -0.004439142066985369, -0.00142299709841609, -0.02514498122036457, 0.03523506224155426, 0.015549070201814175, -0.05239473283290863, -0.039976660162210464, -0.0038974732160568237, 0.02505890093743801, -0.03661966696381569, -0.05808484926819801, -0.04607081040740013, -0.08514274656772614, -0.029922256246209145, 0.02168882265686989, 0.01366393268108368, -0.005278491415083408, -0.029242146760225296, -0.03435252979397774, 0.04802979901432991, 0.0038290470838546753, -0.01721523329615593, 0.02410084940493107, -0.016686709597706795, -0.015277085825800896, 0.02614692412316799, -0.00830043200403452, -0.011083812452852726, 0.026668690145015717, 0.03882599622011185, -0.04310961067676544, -0.05801434442400932, -0.03891247138381004, 0.02381548099219799, -0.058073535561561584, -0.01532940287142992, -0.047972891479730606, -0.010794132947921753, 0.025257809087634087, 0.030538270249962807, 0.011312740854918957, 0.014306697994470596, -0.008820335380733013, 0.039282746613025665, 0.06439115107059479, -0.02934829518198967, -0.022730808705091476, 0.0023397922050207853, -0.04572046548128128, -0.01098385639488697, 0.014906655997037888, 0.04711814969778061, 0.035300493240356445, 0.027279362082481384, -0.02448650635778904, -0.003102048533037305, 0.019530100747942924, 0.014052062295377254, 0.023053210228681564, -0.06629947572946548, 0.025303462520241737, 0.007473111152648926, -0.03708481788635254, -0.04379912465810776, 0.004163769073784351, -0.03125271946191788, -0.0068963742814958096, -0.014588020741939545, -0.00831698626279831, -0.01266304962337017, 0.005529502872377634, -0.012990722432732582, 0.034869831055402756, 0.002467540092766285, 0.013550817966461182, -0.04201523959636688, -0.026541437953710556, 0.009742309339344501, 0.06238674372434616, -0.030083203688263893, 0.06194354593753815, 0.0047791204415261745, 0.06323615461587906, 0.0294575747102499, 0.028398776426911354, 0.011956734582781792, 0.01941872574388981, 0.009091589599847794, 0.03320428356528282, 0.0406922772526741, 0.016630854457616806, 0.03062531165778637, 0.020058322697877884, -0.06364931166172028, -0.019886212423443794, -0.006666748784482479, 0.006822400726377964, 0.029923168942332268, -0.03253603354096413, -0.018140234053134918, -0.011060590855777264, 0.03669244423508644, -0.043505676090717316, -0.00907005276530981, -0.03331226855516434, 0.0021552075631916523, 0.025833524763584137, -0.009725144132971764, -0.039021361619234085, 0.03202174976468086, -0.029917124658823013, 0.011251506395637989, 0.03577851504087448, -0.009788323193788528, -0.020473189651966095, 0.020147815346717834, -0.04253354296088219, -0.004515002015978098, 0.006470288150012493, -0.024424010887742043, 0.013329299166798592, 0.04505092278122902, -0.07469113916158676, 0.0447893962264061, 0.02003687620162964, -0.025200190022587776, -0.0636846199631691, 0.017959726974368095, -0.012837625108659267, 0.0024454009253531694, 0.05057409778237343, -0.039323244243860245, 0.0006898084538988769, 0.002181177493184805, -0.04019738733768463, 0.021859370172023773, -0.0023681181482970715, -0.009580045007169247, -0.05170254409313202, 0.015913328155875206, -0.0015119508607313037, 0.05778290331363678, 0.02076558768749237, 0.03693630173802376, 0.02634585089981556, -0.00030171836260706186, 0.002807906363159418, -0.01277970615774393, -0.04655354097485542, 0.013618522323668003, 0.023615868762135506, -0.09148471802473068, 0.025816405192017555, -0.06539744138717651, 0.04600099101662636, 0.03693411126732826, -0.007752165198326111, 0.010918982326984406, 0.016784772276878357, 0.04190404340624809, -0.016318688169121742, 0.039159733802080154, -0.023085283115506172, -0.040823303163051605, -0.021022284403443336, 0.0339883416891098, 0.014077987521886826, 0.03163336589932442, -0.042355939745903015, 0.030912915244698524, 0.03942764550447464, -0.031709346920251846, 0.022682171314954758, 0.0253585334867239, -0.02244504541158676, -0.0033161244355142117, 0.0039827716536819935, -0.05062706023454666, 0.013069440610706806, 0.009796044789254665, 0.0415763258934021, -0.054561715573072433, -0.005500376224517822, 0.031265318393707275, 0.004763432778418064, -0.029727868735790253, 0.012349319644272327, -0.002499278634786606, -0.031164880841970444, -0.01670338772237301, -0.0030646128579974174, -0.013565469533205032, -0.02665053680539131, 0.002289224648848176, -0.0423571951687336, -0.029893750324845314, -0.004962610546499491, 0.011611204594373703, 0.010748813860118389, 0.06655837595462799, -0.0075571052730083466, -0.03194958344101906, 0.03848620876669884, -0.029553648084402084, 0.02384466677904129, -0.06391274183988571, 0.03297283500432968, 0.03790901228785515, -0.0253209937363863, -0.03834182396531105, -0.005896738264709711, -0.029316788539290428, 0.0012484363978728652, 0.0558863990008831, 0.0014985493617132306, 0.006029695738106966, -0.027624182403087616, 0.034140318632125854, -0.0036433993373066187, -0.028113124892115593, 0.024939481168985367, 0.025692123919725418, -0.02070937119424343, 0.005929938983172178, 0.0018503157189115882, 0.043922774493694305, -0.00010834732529474422, -0.001162623055279255, -0.05765518918633461, 0.006063678301870823, 0.016232900321483612, -0.03839738294482231, -0.016406452283263206, -0.0027234740555286407, -0.03494986519217491, 0.03728065639734268, -0.009472991339862347, -0.02151152305305004, 0.056896548718214035, 0.020170776173472404, -0.04181104153394699, 0.008058706298470497, -0.003648314392194152, -0.021061435341835022, 0.00489993067458272, 0.021815139800310135, -0.017347652465105057, -0.07075485587120056, 0.015263155102729797, 0.012930343858897686, -0.006514553911983967, -0.014918830245733261, 0.03683675453066826, -0.0006759410025551915, 0.017178043723106384, 0.0009249021532014012, 0.021013081073760986, -0.059556782245635986, -0.006620392668992281, 0.05197871848940849, 0.03324856609106064, 0.021672356873750687, 0.02994452230632305, -0.008586833253502846, 0.024218901991844177, -0.030762339010834694, 0.03870481997728348, 0.009177563712000847, 0.03286384418606758, -0.003209169954061508, -0.0014548614853993058, 0.0475291945040226, 0.007761847227811813, 0.04477440565824509, 0.028621455654501915, 0.004802627954632044, 0.015340317040681839, -0.040372226387262344, 0.02657207101583481, -0.011114613153040409, 0.002612851792946458, -0.08131234347820282, 0.028239574283361435, 0.024684077128767967, -0.004636529367417097, 0.012590127065777779, -0.00031661693355999887, 0.013472733087837696, 0.02330869995057583, 0.035040631890296936, -0.01799025759100914, 0.02758130244910717, 0.01669594831764698, -0.028108537197113037, -0.010121732950210571, -0.010121071711182594, 0.0005881697870790958, -0.01462890300899744, 0.059032320976257324, 0.005813539028167725, 0.0020245295017957687, 0.002508543198928237, 0.005176577251404524, -0.014235910959541798, 0.01896064542233944, -0.04919745400547981, -0.04660234600305557, -0.04461400955915451, 0.0035647035110741854, 0.016260989010334015, 0.0070262509398162365 ]
<p>This might be a question in general: due to computational burden, I have to use a subset of my complete data (say, 1,000 out of the complete 10,000 observations) to get a p-value of a test. The test itself is from Monte Carlo simulations. My question is, is there a way to quantify the uncertainty of the p-value <strong>due to the use of a subset of the 1,000 observations instead of using the complete dataset?</strong> Thanks!</p>
73,572
[ -0.0037819179706275463, 0.005902295466512442, -0.008894836530089378, -0.011371055617928505, 0.03520059585571289, 0.04485953971743584, 0.0017813605954870582, -0.040728405117988586, -0.0022893473505973816, -0.02727518603205681, 0.04144970700144768, 0.058348506689071655, 0.04395145922899246, 0.00386059726588428, 0.0011663999175652862, 0.01515210047364235, -0.01834503561258316, 0.018162395805120468, 0.004622580949217081, -0.027022182941436768, -0.000227728218305856, 0.023695021867752075, -0.003153787227347493, -0.015724623575806618, -0.03217510133981705, 0.051273077726364136, 0.028253138065338135, -0.02582591027021408, 0.015398779883980751, 0.07121331244707108, -0.06846094876527786, -0.04814884811639786, 0.04909336566925049, 0.06295998394489288, 0.030537450686097145, -0.018277503550052643, -0.03241615369915962, -0.022641174495220184, -0.018644900992512703, 0.02055446244776249, -0.03880249336361885, -0.0067145866341888905, 0.01195809431374073, 0.026590313762426376, 0.019828710705041885, 0.008159903809428215, -0.001858115429058671, -0.013986257836222649, 0.04103947430849075, -0.02858773246407509, 0.051498424261808395, -0.01021385844796896, 0.05579816922545433, 0.029871122911572456, -0.010639184154570103, -0.01101960800588131, 0.055912263691425323, 0.08181305974721909, -0.038767989724874496, -0.04333699122071266, 0.007273840717971325, -0.05172158032655716, 0.026620078831911087, -0.0216375645250082, -0.04038316756486893, 0.03649589791893959, -0.01819319650530815, -0.032540421932935715, 0.0370505228638649, 0.002681139623746276, 0.00777512276545167, 0.007931452244520187, 0.02136051282286644, -0.029636673629283905, 0.01915259286761284, -0.009941485710442066, 0.022578315809369087, 0.024047140032052994, 0.053794015198946, 0.01934141293168068, -0.019776389002799988, 0.017633063718676567, 0.042854949831962585, 0.034019287675619125, 0.022184768691658974, -0.023170230910182, 0.021572913974523544, -0.03164983168244362, 0.022236861288547516, -0.014019003137946129, -0.02476220577955246, -0.021898675709962845, 0.05638176202774048, 0.001914108288474381, -0.051210060715675354, 0.021563660353422165, -0.02490193396806717, 0.05221332237124443, -0.02735109254717827, -0.009650157764554024, 0.01229654811322689, -0.037392642349004745, 0.039893824607133865, 0.07462053000926971, -0.031641364097595215, 0.0068681207485497, 0.013041670434176922, 0.0001559825468575582, 0.00870683416724205, -0.017663078382611275, 0.025503451004624367, 0.015720147639513016, 0.021533537656068802, 0.0022704587318003178, 0.05147793889045715, -0.012311246246099472, -0.011680904775857925, -0.03346136584877968, 0.02526256814599037, 0.06810014694929123, 0.052640609443187714, -0.01575024239718914, 0.009793378412723541, -0.03581758216023445, -0.057813458144664764, 0.04158061742782593, 0.013008477166295052, -0.021937526762485504, -0.05300198122859001, 0.044826265424489975, -0.009279691614210606, -0.03627323359251022, 0.05977964773774147, -0.018984265625476837, 0.05532769486308098, -0.03156912326812744, -0.09064498543739319, -0.036641303449869156, 0.009028434753417969, -0.008285166695713997, -0.0351557694375515, -0.05645529180765152, 0.021523118019104004, 0.05795116350054741, 0.01599854603409767, 0.011550495401024818, 0.04153762012720108, -0.010229303501546383, 0.03321193531155586, 0.023797759786248207, -0.006428934633731842, -0.02333757095038891, 0.011504855006933212, -0.01203234028071165, -0.00415613129734993, -0.10396093875169754, 0.041002508252859116, 0.036428339779376984, 0.0037876239512115717, -0.004243383649736643, 0.017625441774725914, -0.002927938476204872, -0.004166314844042063, -0.03267433121800423, 0.014112619683146477, -0.014181682839989662, 0.07655235379934311, 0.0011846941197291017, 0.0219808928668499, 0.011111030355095863, -0.014409632422029972, -0.00521155446767807, 0.031011680141091347, 0.011656948365271091, 0.036383818835020065, -0.029611727222800255, 0.010709836147725582, -0.007475686725229025, 0.04491779953241348, 0.02894725650548935, -0.0075373160652816296, 0.0073057557456195354, -0.003359372727572918, 0.00484287878498435, 0.022669868543744087, 0.045446429401636124, 0.02832859382033348, -0.06979008764028549, 0.029658881947398186, -0.03957458585500717, -0.048402879387140274, -0.041339389979839325, -0.01859002560377121, -0.001014646957628429, -0.018935907632112503, -0.006693997420370579, 0.017869826406240463, 0.01000705175101757, 0.009838750585913658, -0.03908940404653549, -0.025169260799884796, -0.042460013180971146, 0.04248468205332756, -0.06709303706884384, -0.0038614687509834766, 0.03272875398397446, 0.057490523904561996, -0.017110947519540787, 0.05951249971985817, -0.025851434096693993, -0.05398498848080635, -0.029965613037347794, -0.06616666167974472, 0.003902965458109975, 0.02243352308869362, -0.028772961348295212, 0.013969236053526402, -0.028097497299313545, -0.010696962475776672, 0.033814750611782074, -0.0019887646194547415, 0.06441500782966614, 0.06439212709665298, 0.022975096479058266, -0.006971408613026142, -0.015751706436276436, -0.0059830681420862675, -0.031539805233478546, -0.019534168764948845, -0.024792412295937538, -0.04510168731212616, 0.030294038355350494, 0.027669938281178474, -0.010355469770729542, -0.029123082756996155, -0.022218260914087296, 0.04778418689966202, -0.015807747840881348, 0.04485567286610603, 0.03180282190442085, -0.011014016345143318, -0.028321966528892517, 0.03403351455926895, 0.03715043514966965, 0.04767994210124016, -0.0014989725314080715, 0.0005959064001217484, 0.00915013812482357, 0.01934371143579483, 0.010011511854827404, 0.015099568292498589, 0.005122183356434107, -0.014254740439355373, -0.014360555447638035, -0.037217505276203156, -0.0478183813393116, 0.03627660498023033, -0.025139890611171722, 0.026818372309207916, 0.016212012618780136, -0.011388068087399006, 0.009068825282156467, 0.007273264229297638, -0.03574392572045326, 0.037281982600688934, 0.037748947739601135, -0.02092885971069336, -0.0036409972235560417, 0.026084285229444504, -0.017183752730488777, -0.009615170769393444, -0.03691038861870766, -0.022377200424671173, -0.050655826926231384, 0.021886806935071945, 0.04436240717768669, -0.012250845320522785, 0.032196294516325, -0.016331303864717484, -0.04430021345615387, -0.027267567813396454, 0.0012665799586102366, -0.024615954607725143, 0.019563855603337288, -0.05108477175235748, 0.002756360685452819, 0.005845979321748018, -0.024721331894397736, 0.00884247850626707, -0.016442913562059402, -0.027979262173175812, 0.0077035813592374325, -0.005160104483366013, -0.019596010446548462, -0.001415481441654265, -0.026432009413838387, -0.018754107877612114, -0.012749696150422096, -0.028788097202777863, 0.0002728082472458482, 0.03019961155951023, -0.038722507655620575, 0.02783961221575737, -0.00366028631106019, -0.01625887304544449, -0.03803786635398865, -0.00672312593087554, 0.013286327943205833, -0.016168134286999702, 0.011642481200397015, 0.03803737461566925, 0.013492020778357983, -0.0008955966331996024, -0.04251900315284729, -0.08387979865074158, 0.015827329829335213, 0.008602327667176723, 0.016651052981615067, -0.002832902828231454, -0.035275157541036606, 0.10343119502067566, 0.038627739995718, -0.03306780755519867, -0.007109242491424084, 0.008494937792420387, -0.01881142519414425, -0.00899401493370533, -0.013721024617552757, -0.023502761498093605, 0.0021734358742833138, 0.012684754095971584, -0.017902858555316925, 0.00428246334195137, 0.019617030397057533, 0.02612173557281494, 0.019455470144748688, 0.025549056008458138, -0.005216740071773529, 0.013005555607378483, 0.021822040900588036, 0.0035967063158750534, -0.0324397087097168, 0.033560749143362045, -0.017026802524924278, 0.03991025686264038, 0.02732379548251629, -0.0665702074766159, 0.03789464384317398, -0.014810597524046898, 0.007220232393592596, -0.05102625489234924, 0.059930745512247086, 0.011490888893604279, -0.011267611756920815, 0.025423819199204445, 0.03878342732787132, 0.008619369938969612, -0.006179213989526033, -0.011129232123494148, 0.05780323967337608, 0.042023688554763794, -0.018114127218723297, -0.016027677804231644, -0.004213255364447832, -0.0011589037021622062, 0.01174782682210207, -0.015298616141080856, -0.03272048011422157, 0.03830498456954956, 0.04948927089571953, 0.021996455267071724, -0.013083690777420998, -0.023190965875983238, 0.02147284895181656, -0.05657147988677025, -0.004069962538778782, -0.03284662961959839, 0.06393879652023315, 0.008904076181352139, 0.0523369126021862, 0.024613192304968834, -0.024137018248438835, -0.02998802810907364, 0.04181090369820595, -0.02129443921148777, 0.06717044115066528, 0.008712946437299252, -0.05836192145943642, -0.017441168427467346, -0.027502406388521194, 0.025445083156228065, -0.03411472588777542, 0.013978846371173859, -0.0065065608359873295, 0.022321630269289017, -0.04259927570819855, 0.004047406371682882, 0.0003921420138794929, 0.020707648247480392, -0.03065663017332554, 0.06527121365070343, 0.016900699585676193, -0.010007165372371674, 0.008127132430672646, 0.0247582346200943, 0.005513481795787811, -0.004853030201047659, -0.02347056195139885, 0.021044855937361717, -0.003836929565295577, 0.0576656199991703, 0.0349162220954895, 0.04411347210407257, -0.044121261686086655, 0.022553041577339172, -0.01012142188847065, 0.05757325142621994, 0.03982958942651749, -0.01266846340149641, -0.00020638258138205856, -0.018811114132404327, -0.00299037154763937, 0.023298025131225586, 0.005040085408836603, -0.024500835686922073, -0.0037485226057469845, 0.06458897888660431, 0.011854074895381927, -0.07484801858663559, 0.016761505976319313, 0.04592316970229149, -0.009773556143045425, -0.004633658565580845, -0.054784614592790604, -0.010422084480524063, -0.04561837390065193, -0.007471135817468166, 0.007548382040113211, 0.04942593723535538, 0.010093932040035725, 0.013163481839001179, 0.02685612626373768, -0.0016418006271123886, -0.06848301738500595, -0.008761761710047722, 0.023272253572940826, 0.051052894443273544, 0.00891384668648243, -0.0005455554346553981, 0.039342254400253296, 0.03458070009946823, -0.009614808484911919, 0.025901280343532562, 0.0229756198823452, -0.09214892983436584, 0.006748817395418882, 0.04256629943847656, 0.032547857612371445, -0.012701313942670822, 0.016940481960773468, -0.04058413952589035, 0.008825695142149925, 0.06598389893770218, -0.015721891075372696, 0.013277110643684864, -0.006052512209862471, 0.00455786008387804, -0.0031357193365693092, -0.01358411367982626, -0.0463244765996933, 0.009339508600533009, -0.04310334846377373, 0.009746094234287739, -0.07722458243370056, 0.0088355652987957, -0.018552307039499283, 0.014480618759989738, 0.03715572506189346, 0.07022210210561752, -0.018214328214526176, -0.015520158223807812, -0.0038784437347203493, 0.0033236679155379534, -0.007801172789186239, -0.082288458943367, 0.011039730161428452, -0.005283128470182419, 0.0014268856029957533, 0.04055148735642433, -0.04454798996448517, -0.03653351962566376, 0.05600597336888313, -0.0035019717179238796, 0.001728465431369841, -0.016407087445259094, -0.023269498720765114, 0.030607232823967934, 0.0360860638320446, -0.009571478702127934, 0.05656077340245247, 0.03136393055319786, 0.026535876095294952, 0.03433724492788315, -0.008728801272809505, 0.025451060384511948, -0.0431007519364357, -0.008947556838393211, -0.04053732380270958, -0.01613106019794941, -0.017227735370397568, 0.031933438032865524, -0.001288046594709158, 0.032241396605968475, 0.036606743931770325, -0.044057585299015045, -0.013234280049800873, 0.036080699414014816, 0.016682617366313934, -0.008849497884511948, -0.02692675031721592, -0.0009866973850876093, -0.0007153738988563418, 0.012194384820759296, 0.0013818521983921528, 0.004901890177279711, 0.018943363800644875, -0.008809836581349373, -0.06572769582271576, 0.04114555940032005, -0.058940671384334564, -0.027841733768582344, 0.013883024454116821, -0.019679684191942215, 0.04128849878907204, -0.02155633084475994, 0.019356338307261467, -0.025794001296162605, -0.06568990647792816, -0.013855175115168095, 0.01581963151693344, 0.028709758073091507, 0.04789694771170616, -0.04763578996062279, 0.03879129886627197, -0.036446426063776016, 0.014117257669568062, -0.07896032929420471, -0.02710314467549324, 0.0013208109885454178, 0.03797793388366699, -0.0247956570237875, -0.04582269862294197, -0.006613148842006922, 0.016131369397044182, 0.00611636508256197, -0.01485421136021614, 0.0369599349796772, 0.006982026621699333, -0.016149092465639114, 0.006841940339654684, -0.03501811996102333, 0.06682626903057098, -0.03161020576953888, 0.0005648130318149924, 0.03578618913888931, -0.03933998569846153, -0.00041484602843411267, 0.01877197064459324, 0.013602674007415771, -0.03770400583744049, -0.009278346784412861, -0.01457823533564806, 0.022784052416682243, 0.03096066042780876, -0.0318400114774704, 0.0011273522395640612, 0.009513028897345066, -0.021158356219530106, 0.041771456599235535, 0.008021241053938866, -0.008756034076213837, -0.00868222862482071, 0.00011963688302785158, -0.0065743159502744675, 0.03485841304063797, 0.00815628282725811, -0.010862257331609726, 0.004968983121216297, 0.01139358151704073, -0.021073900163173676, 0.026622623205184937, 0.07358092069625854, 0.025311078876256943, -0.021352680400013924, -0.016433844342827797, -0.03270762786269188, 0.028179850429296494, 0.013974434696137905, -0.019940992817282677, -0.008453280664980412, 0.03729468584060669, -0.04181098937988281, -0.0077856965363025665, -0.019536688923835754, -0.049168359488248825, 0.032398369163274765, -0.012131369672715664, 0.04594364017248154, 0.03530725836753845, 0.011755144223570824, -0.016504324972629547, -0.015601197257637978, 0.0039081997238099575, 0.022428104653954506, 0.013658118434250355, 0.034842588007450104, 0.03369372338056564, -0.0047480701468884945, 0.013292460702359676, -0.013044352643191814, 0.007920595817267895, 0.036516785621643066, -0.012234415858983994, 0.02751992456614971, 0.031398970633745193, -0.007135471329092979, -0.0230542179197073, 0.02157096192240715, -0.04893091320991516, -0.0024899588897824287, -0.01708124205470085, -0.019397711381316185, 0.018615029752254486, 0.005856906529515982, 0.0343267023563385, 0.010867621749639511, -0.009926813654601574, -0.04598623514175415, 0.02629079855978489, 0.005972778424620628, 0.010484028607606888, 0.035882096737623215, 0.00557086942717433, 0.009065543301403522, -0.0207133200019598, 0.009301690384745598, -0.004256742540746927, -0.04267770051956177, -0.05900552496314049, -0.019102169200778008, -0.025813499465584755, 0.0004214620857965201, 0.005385716911405325, -0.014110584743320942, 0.02520524337887764, 0.006458071991801262, 0.03851187974214554, -0.0040881880559027195, 0.03466305509209633, -0.0351208820939064, 0.0576058030128479, 0.011782032437622547, 0.04102484881877899, -0.02139970473945141, 0.000930331414565444, 0.10109192878007889, 0.04334548860788345, 0.05790361016988754, -0.0510159432888031, 0.005041138269007206, -0.0238980520516634, 0.015667404979467392, -0.018159715458750725, 0.017130572348833084, 0.050942037254571915, -0.030613061040639877, 0.025286277756094933, 0.05070437490940094, -0.0315881073474884, -0.01428904477506876, 0.06084846705198288, -0.030830178409814835, -0.012010657228529453, -0.0035848033148795366, 0.008732324466109276, 0.0005878288066014647, -0.07642050832509995, -0.054689254611730576, 0.022223234176635742, 0.0007647926104255021, -0.019824961200356483, -0.009967179968953133, -0.023568352684378624, 0.0010363277979195118, 0.0019365022890269756, -0.005188482813537121, -0.004065559245646, 0.006043486762791872, 0.021214822307229042, -0.0025611119344830513, -0.007753223180770874, 0.025561217218637466, -0.013098402880132198, -0.015276224352419376, 0.04073692485690117, -0.019062044098973274, 0.0087179746478796, -0.041529636830091476, 0.024881284683942795, -0.01973654329776764, -0.04805015027523041, -0.03420049697160721, 0.042492110282182693, 0.0071442159824073315, 0.0025108791887760162, -0.01639530248939991, -0.011511600576341152, -0.010439454577863216, -0.02656007744371891, -0.006313006859272718, 0.03546937182545662, -0.01219196431338787, -0.003222883678972721, -0.046692073345184326, -0.01197473332285881, 0.005135939922183752, -0.04747520014643669, 0.01835441216826439, 0.03749499097466469, -0.03055938147008419, -0.04384893923997879, 0.02741680108010769, 0.010665825568139553, 0.005747194867581129, -0.01747126691043377, 0.0023696732241660357, -0.04206766188144684, -0.014911558479070663, -0.003183215158060193, 0.030679097399115562, -0.021318497136235237, 0.010805629193782806, -0.020671023055911064, 0.006315786391496658, -0.0009582691127434373, -0.025113292038440704, -0.00045085680903866887, -0.04701528325676918, -0.014794736169278622, -0.03434768691658974, -0.03075692243874073, 0.03130731359124184, 0.03261880576610565, 0.0168452225625515, -0.0002890432660933584, -0.005288069602102041, 0.04600472003221512, 0.009490687400102615, -0.058268070220947266, -0.029052674770355225, -0.007521116174757481, -0.05143623799085617, 0.03270904719829559, 0.016857758164405823, 0.06976553052663803, 0.0010041549103334546, 0.015472856350243092, 0.01431526243686676, 0.005928556900471449, 0.014577572233974934, 0.025234252214431763, 0.0096186064183712, -0.053056009113788605, -0.02819317951798439, -0.005968873854726553, -0.03513652831315994, -0.031328219920396805, -0.013152378611266613, -0.04891711473464966, -0.016485413536429405, 0.0006802382413297892, -0.024730022996664047, -0.0282832533121109, 0.010341457091271877, -0.0034475133288651705, -0.04217865690588951, -0.010983566753566265, 0.0308302603662014, -0.05854049324989319, -0.0632372498512268, -0.016926754266023636, -0.030056297779083252, 0.01728890836238861, -0.01946801319718361, -0.013546943664550781, 0.010555592365562916, 0.06747052818536758, 0.015605885535478592, 0.016063736751675606, 0.015209726057946682, 0.024264313280582428, 0.023911740630865097, 0.04837934300303459, -0.07210449874401093, -0.003533771261572838, 0.06866807490587234, -0.08637656271457672, -0.03637142851948738, 0.05830500274896622, -0.004166289698332548, 0.057995181530714035, 0.04217700660228729, -0.015132824890315533, -0.028944052755832672, 0.04623048007488251, -0.040390316396951675, -0.04354101046919823, 0.01516663283109665, 0.023707617074251175, -0.005099317524582148, -0.004156482871621847, 0.010095536708831787, 0.0057314722798764706, 0.007798028644174337, 0.016014324501156807, 0.025687076151371002, 0.01927747018635273, -0.02735668607056141, -0.009307431057095528, 0.02065455913543701, 0.04327009618282318, 0.022452274337410927, -0.010388001799583435, 0.0068710907362401485, 0.05226203799247742, -0.01719886064529419, 0.027222607284784317, -0.0029073499608784914, 0.024956541135907173, -0.10302677005529404, -0.04789810627698898, -0.017536237835884094, 0.013826015405356884, 0.0233103409409523, -0.05621318891644478, 0.023339444771409035, 0.04420550912618637, -0.03104218654334545, -0.0009752372861839831, -0.015770357102155685, 0.012264089658856392, -0.048869065940380096, -0.0016081203939393163, -0.014420408755540848, 0.024082297459244728, 0.039213474839925766, 0.016638988628983498, 0.03572661429643631, -0.007034775801002979, 0.004739030729979277, -0.0015876810066401958, -0.01519707776606083, 0.028483211994171143, -0.010644867084920406, -0.056193891912698746, 0.018899695947766304, -0.03775002062320709, -0.07544828206300735, 0.025553178042173386, -0.01414613425731659, 0.02241896092891693, -0.012537404894828796, 0.053934402763843536, 0.02167852781713009, 0.041303087025880814, 0.03421124815940857, 0.012426351197063923, 0.010134371928870678, 0.025450361892580986, 0.01990407519042492, 0.013806000351905823, -0.03252262622117996, 0.03543262556195259, 0.030797643586993217, -0.01864183321595192, -0.017084037885069847, 0.04254578426480293, 0.017248034477233887, -0.0027270272839814425, -0.018915528431534767, 0.011549260467290878, -0.0016848334344103932, -0.04657503217458725, 0.03773350641131401, -0.059922873973846436, 0.0382695347070694, 0.04383210465312004, 0.029489420354366302, -0.052564412355422974, 0.018451428040862083, -0.01996726170182228, -0.05591105297207832, 0.015093643218278885, -0.007756824139505625, -0.03548393398523331, -0.07553642988204956, -0.02036147750914097, 0.02619307115674019, 0.004803113639354706, -0.008485357277095318, -0.026310788467526436, -0.028742434456944466, 0.04522571712732315, -0.04260871559381485, -0.002192269079387188, 0.02142912894487381, -0.0033843964338302612, -0.001573729095980525, -0.09343627840280533, 0.05750638619065285, 0.01713443174958229, 0.02289196103811264, -0.013876483775675297, 0.006076155696064234, -0.028207072988152504, -0.018972763791680336, 0.02767203003168106, 0.03494729846715927, 0.012661371380090714, -0.008200912736356258, -0.0170979555696249, 0.007349788211286068, -0.05917892977595329, 0.002676301635801792, -0.045914679765701294, -0.008546176366508007, -0.03102455474436283, -0.017227550968527794, 0.02135273441672325, -0.006292465142905712, 0.027054527774453163, 0.006957523990422487, 0.006129775661975145, -0.010449732653796673, 0.022352803498506546, 0.06523393094539642, 0.002065937966108322, -0.00810376275330782, 0.03192661330103874, -0.006018726620823145, 0.033560413867235184, 0.01583808660507202, 0.02468944899737835, -0.05054571107029915, 0.04225196689367294, -0.029278269037604332, -0.04311738908290863, 0.02911175787448883, 0.028136461973190308, -0.02731470763683319, -0.053410984575748444, 0.005984694231301546, 0.010702695697546005, -0.03839363157749176, 0.020618053153157234, 0.02526886947453022, 0.012724536471068859, 0.019436433911323547, 0.0027009728364646435, 0.01916670799255371, 0.015354647301137447, -0.023645104840397835, -0.0012041006702929735, 0.005929733160883188, 0.008501747623085976, 0.008444210514426231, 0.034934502094984055, 0.029897043481469154, -0.015261192806065083, 0.0005951326456852257, 0.023605043068528175, 0.029104402288794518, -0.031671907752752304, -0.022273119539022446, 0.003019839059561491, -0.019150957465171814, 0.013853625394403934, -0.033846788108348846, -0.0012275200570002198, 0.05307270213961601, -0.023695796728134155, 0.011663423851132393, -0.042248863726854324, 0.014786451123654842, 0.015404140576720238, 0.028111867606639862, -0.008139115758240223, 0.04805707186460495, -0.019007926806807518, -0.011067071929574013, -0.01197380293160677, 0.02312256582081318, 0.031969405710697174, -0.053807299584150314, 0.03934086114168167, -0.03888504579663277, 0.013211453333497047, -0.03843466565012932, -0.0002770444843918085, -0.02462933212518692, -0.01650862582027912, -0.002921792445704341, 0.023411044850945473, 0.0158008374273777, 0.004547905642539263, -0.055539436638355255, -0.021408986300230026, 0.039671141654253006, -0.030116230249404907, 0.0209895521402359, -0.04237814620137215, 0.043729692697525024, -0.051161181181669235, -0.030896596610546112 ]
<p>I'm doing a statistics paper in which I have to correlate the clinical diagnosis with the hystopathological one. So, basically I have one group of people with 2 different diagnosis: 1. clinical 2. hystopathological Normally these two must be identical, but due to some clinical errors sometimes they aren't. My job is to calculate how many have the same diagnosis , how many have different diagnosis. What statistical test do I need to use? Thank you ! </p>
73,573
[ -0.09019311517477036, -0.05585388094186783, -0.04516688361763954, 0.00011008984438376501, 0.013344267383217812, 0.015132032334804535, 0.015997983515262604, 0.005075972527265549, 0.030541691929101944, 0.02867162600159645, 0.07425399124622345, 0.006987452041357756, 0.03709527477622032, 0.013640989549458027, 0.020926794037222862, 0.001294321147724986, 0.024105295538902283, 0.004731379449367523, 0.003863115329295397, 0.01002955436706543, 0.029483990743756294, -0.03293845057487488, 0.007521555293351412, -0.007198760751634836, -0.04702616110444069, 0.03492250293493271, 0.012302414514124393, -0.03745156526565552, 0.04688996449112892, 0.02629191428422928, -0.07218514382839203, -0.022111548110842705, 0.02629147842526436, 0.038590554147958755, -0.007029358763247728, -0.030616894364356995, -0.023889539763331413, -0.003551557194441557, -0.02002502791583538, 0.05308407545089722, -0.04629117250442505, -0.016143102198839188, -0.013951093889772892, 0.03849932178854942, -0.017075190320611, -0.00160317518748343, -0.00816368032246828, -0.03374258428812027, 0.0007500656065531075, -0.06253122538328171, 0.07372059673070908, -0.008152193389832973, 0.05804494395852089, -0.014396403916180134, -0.010118141770362854, 0.012206068262457848, 0.03540975973010063, 0.06472641974687576, 0.009769960306584835, -0.06507468968629837, -0.042660001665353775, -0.00456587178632617, 0.03214208036661148, -0.03185950219631195, -0.04446000978350639, 0.03895775228738785, -0.008133620023727417, -0.04832188040018082, 0.026418540626764297, 0.023763230070471764, 0.011678407900035381, 0.050219904631376266, 0.0819002017378807, -0.045159608125686646, 0.009945155121386051, -0.04969119653105736, 0.014123387634754181, 0.028532303869724274, -0.003747264388948679, -0.005277681164443493, -0.00465971976518631, -0.008247846737504005, 0.02734890580177307, 0.07561949640512466, 0.023800702765583992, -0.02648751623928547, 0.03678397834300995, -0.005428783129900694, 0.012386842630803585, 0.038984548300504684, -0.03207296133041382, -0.01111534982919693, 0.05264803394675255, 0.017003728076815605, -0.021742774173617363, 0.025552362203598022, -0.03367861360311508, 0.06153418496251106, 0.013449862599372864, 0.012608644552528858, 0.013003494590520859, -0.04002135619521141, 0.03602481633424759, 0.05208684504032135, -0.009973226115107536, 0.015620307065546513, -0.010871278122067451, -0.010194450616836548, -0.0036752382293343544, 0.02801322191953659, -0.001780005288310349, 0.0055716633796691895, 0.02664165571331978, 0.02888232283294201, 0.012891008518636227, 0.026145152747631073, -0.03659679368138313, 0.007129393517971039, 0.04390937462449074, 0.08435215801000595, 0.04419346898794174, -0.0133487144485116, 0.026899415999650955, -0.03214450925588608, -0.014139498583972454, -0.014733448624610901, 0.014768022112548351, -0.04371880739927292, -0.008756098337471485, 0.0530327633023262, -0.02029171586036682, -0.021389514207839966, -0.004543085116893053, -0.02117796428501606, 0.05072089284658432, -0.005399022717028856, -0.08498383313417435, -0.04442251846194267, 0.012053576298058033, 0.0004908698028884828, -0.023590274155139923, -0.01655551791191101, 0.011766738258302212, 0.04692856967449188, 0.03211669251322746, -0.012110992334783077, 0.04277101531624794, 0.024284223094582558, 0.04411229118704796, 0.011005313135683537, -0.017571911215782166, -0.017051542177796364, -0.0018116665305569768, -0.002755355089902878, -0.014357326552271843, -0.07282846421003342, -0.008741420693695545, -0.016455737873911858, -0.024106549099087715, -0.03817921504378319, -0.017940524965524673, -0.013917412608861923, 0.004914300516247749, 0.02451642043888569, 0.02861083298921585, 0.006338504608720541, 0.05623679608106613, -0.010075675323605537, -0.013191664591431618, 0.007918184623122215, -0.015159077011048794, 0.03943823277950287, 0.01519181951880455, 0.054351966828107834, 0.017233528196811676, -0.014165104366838932, 0.006795796100050211, 0.003282253397628665, 0.016427259892225266, 0.01482647005468607, -0.011541822925209999, 0.00411779060959816, -0.010057632811367512, -0.0009916884591802955, -0.00827388372272253, 0.04711147025227547, 0.005059150047600269, -0.03492128476500511, 0.04588146135210991, -0.03331868723034859, -0.020963672548532486, -0.027718067169189453, -0.011557765305042267, -0.014062616974115372, -0.03938742354512215, 0.02463160827755928, 0.019225191324949265, 0.04046330600976944, -0.03450828418135643, -0.0130221638828516, -0.04797699674963951, -0.00346676935441792, 0.02823452651500702, -0.03250604867935181, 0.007067848462611437, 0.029156137257814407, 0.06880201399326324, -0.03699779510498047, 0.061435189098119736, -0.0509820282459259, -0.023590177297592163, 0.018629180267453194, -0.04726140946149826, 0.040418654680252075, -0.018062524497509003, 0.0027187620289623737, 0.021254325285553932, 0.002648772671818733, -0.01961583085358143, 0.05195336788892746, -0.05202675983309746, 0.04730629175901413, 0.05935690551996231, -0.014454934746026993, 0.0067107463255524635, -0.0407363697886467, -0.02325557917356491, 0.025168372318148613, 0.0016168518923223019, -0.009501034393906593, -0.026049042120575905, -0.007893849164247513, 0.0011508682509884238, 0.007825045846402645, -0.044430483132600784, 0.013221603818237782, 0.06001313775777817, 0.024665195494890213, -0.027894996106624603, 0.023435432463884354, 0.0132822310552001, -0.036567989736795425, -0.006171850021928549, 0.03849190101027489, 0.0032667771447449923, 0.017040926963090897, 0.01032402366399765, 0.0216092299669981, 0.060885295271873474, 0.02223302610218525, -0.0051945908926427364, 0.08067143708467484, -0.050721537321805954, 0.02598506212234497, -0.014028647914528847, -0.02052810788154602, 0.05292261019349098, -0.018496058881282806, 0.03335957229137421, 0.022924337536096573, -0.025365794077515602, -0.006318314932286739, 0.021729646250605583, -0.01775868982076645, 0.015844831243157387, 0.04281217232346535, -0.016534697264432907, 0.02166634239256382, 0.027464931830763817, -0.04229322820901871, 0.009827746078372002, -0.0017228156793862581, -0.02874351106584072, -0.026524679735302925, 0.02612556703388691, 0.025040864944458008, -0.00620088167488575, 0.04152010381221771, -0.0008009803132154047, -0.02496691420674324, 0.013503829017281532, -0.02911958284676075, 0.014802801422774792, 0.0069388882257044315, -0.05758257955312729, -0.017062615603208542, -0.011339058168232441, -0.023722071200609207, 0.03189785033464432, -0.02011099085211754, -0.017014531418681145, 0.02407797798514366, 0.007522485218942165, -0.04687536135315895, -0.02390551008284092, -0.03498797491192818, 0.027588453143835068, -0.017526254057884216, 0.008916997350752354, 0.029507478699088097, 0.011301079764962196, -0.053754597902297974, 0.005101743619889021, -0.04159912094473839, -0.029056712985038757, 0.004274616949260235, -0.014417022466659546, 0.04972761124372482, -0.02496807649731636, -0.0045238458551466465, 0.05381227657198906, -0.03645196557044983, -0.027235854417085648, -0.049265772104263306, -0.07711555063724518, 0.06417079269886017, -0.010013915598392487, 0.05132369324564934, -0.022407343611121178, -0.04023311659693718, 0.05456409975886345, 0.04598388075828552, -0.03885160759091377, -0.0022380680311471224, 0.014554623514413834, -0.03863535821437836, -0.02001344785094261, 0.023048236966133118, 0.021496836096048355, 0.013448243029415607, 0.03704720363020897, 0.03104345127940178, 0.012500637210905552, 0.060842081904411316, 0.016407977789640427, -0.012376409024000168, -0.004423814360052347, 0.033963292837142944, -0.012667600996792316, 0.019310664385557175, -0.0023588710464537144, -0.03518407419323921, 0.011822327971458435, -0.007379111368209124, 0.014703181572258472, 0.004483826458454132, -0.04314069449901581, 0.01496411394327879, 0.007953494787216187, -0.010850542224943638, -0.0222486425191164, -0.019970647990703583, 0.06034129858016968, -0.022824173793196678, -0.020428461953997612, 0.03507178649306297, 0.001437148079276085, -0.017784563824534416, -0.004331960808485746, 0.04949951171875, 0.04246366024017334, -0.016353141516447067, -0.0010947610717266798, -0.018093327060341835, -0.0030456511303782463, 0.050174809992313385, -0.04944454878568649, -0.022174976766109467, 0.04281434789299965, 0.006170235108584166, 0.00014372833538800478, 0.012033049948513508, -0.030978962779045105, 0.0015495350817218423, -0.06765235215425491, -0.021118950098752975, 0.002158594783395529, 0.00839434377849102, -0.020200027152895927, 0.003283548401668668, 0.042393121868371964, 0.009175396524369717, 0.002389315515756607, -0.0021333754993975163, -0.056229520589113235, 0.03679308667778969, -0.011248338036239147, 0.0027015286032110453, 0.017386889085173607, -0.015950938686728477, 0.02489163540303707, -0.027508506551384926, -0.006276199594140053, 0.026575429365038872, 0.03656613826751709, -0.027885479852557182, 0.01231447048485279, -0.008207529783248901, -0.0030452958308160305, -0.007963139563798904, 0.036969780921936035, 0.012677735649049282, 0.027527907863259315, 0.0013512008590623736, 0.013082996010780334, -0.007319658529013395, -0.015087381936609745, -0.027955466881394386, 0.01772621087729931, 0.017166193574666977, 0.049987901002168655, 0.04086482152342796, 0.05414028838276863, -0.037292029708623886, 0.015676850453019142, -0.01193943154066801, 0.014661978930234909, 0.04197672754526138, 0.00770174665376544, 0.019124764949083328, -0.022417034953832626, -0.023319963365793228, -0.029562225565314293, 0.029792115092277527, 0.0014049739111214876, -0.009509789757430553, 0.039940569549798965, -0.0009610401466488838, -0.035444971174001694, 0.007455367594957352, 0.06679297238588333, 0.01425523217767477, 0.00487549789249897, -0.008617517538368702, -0.012861385941505432, -0.007868113927543163, -0.0253154169768095, 0.01783694326877594, 0.038100190460681915, -0.027165891602635384, -0.021685607731342316, 0.04356233775615692, -0.014520344324409962, -0.03361976891756058, -0.028675705194473267, -0.009252291172742844, 0.030909843742847443, 0.04711402207612991, -0.050631411373615265, 0.02633379027247429, 0.016913756728172302, 0.0016538531053811312, 0.027206704020500183, -0.012175912037491798, -0.09102100133895874, 0.012343958020210266, 0.04455281049013138, 0.027334431186318398, -0.03442288562655449, -0.05073779821395874, -0.015434570610523224, 0.047367583960294724, 0.04316041246056557, -0.04641414061188698, -0.018971452489495277, 0.0025208948645740747, 0.011501021683216095, -0.001244522980414331, -0.01747172139585018, -0.05569152906537056, 0.04050463065505028, 0.011190362274646759, 0.011025408282876015, -0.02696896158158779, -0.020922131836414337, -0.03910396620631218, -0.013897383585572243, 0.023424142971634865, 0.042201682925224304, -0.0176351647824049, 0.013791389763355255, 0.01152009330689907, 0.049689024686813354, -0.04305299371480942, -0.024386832490563393, -0.002988286782056093, 0.04144961014389992, -0.003734862431883812, 0.05679439753293991, -0.02902797795832157, 0.008673983626067638, -0.01836470328271389, -0.02953004278242588, -0.024096615612506866, 0.004242387600243092, 0.02777966856956482, 0.03528948128223419, 0.032611701637506485, 0.03129814565181732, 0.04156530275940895, -0.039404358714818954, 0.008897866122424603, -0.02690216712653637, -0.0402783639729023, 0.002873223042115569, -0.04419726878404617, -0.0316845066845417, -0.0325666144490242, 0.00812610238790512, 0.0004737037525046617, 0.035531964153051376, -0.004537800792604685, 0.030867332592606544, -0.003671577898785472, 0.008901258930563927, 0.011991498060524464, -0.019800696521997452, 0.0010684216395020485, 0.0377688892185688, 0.018281925469636917, 0.00953643023967743, 0.01926491968333721, -0.013741557486355305, 0.033102795481681824, -0.034273866564035416, -0.012095053680241108, 0.013841088861227036, -0.030101854354143143, 0.010103174485266209, -0.020468411967158318, -0.020090408623218536, 0.03245142847299576, -0.045302946120500565, -0.0078549450263381, -0.023871973156929016, 0.05248459428548813, -0.002580408239737153, -0.05167219042778015, -0.01835813745856285, 0.008321285247802734, 0.010506547056138515, 0.04564199596643448, 0.00822678953409195, 0.018095972016453743, 0.002726668259128928, -0.035341374576091766, -0.07629617303609848, -0.05441368371248245, 0.046804945915937424, 0.03147024288773537, -0.026361964643001556, -0.034506481140851974, 0.026199089363217354, -0.008427316322922707, -0.01507861353456974, 0.0014771095011383295, 0.07017357647418976, 0.025846000760793686, -0.01467457041144371, -0.004534517880529165, 0.01582222990691662, 0.1115189716219902, 0.013420808129012585, -0.029912607744336128, -0.013465313240885735, -0.000032515585189685225, -0.01769646443426609, -0.004638273268938065, -0.024830631911754608, -0.028466645628213882, -0.032727986574172974, -0.05096948519349098, 0.02763540670275688, 0.02236413024365902, -0.03569013625383377, -0.015801915898919106, -0.025060998275876045, 0.017514757812023163, -0.008277186192572117, -0.04833696782588959, 0.010755330324172974, -0.05409149453043938, 0.021055685356259346, -0.0333380326628685, -0.002453795401379466, 0.002127871150150895, -0.04350379481911659, -0.023991843685507774, 0.03166131675243378, -0.04590838775038719, 0.04979323223233223, 0.03922731801867485, -0.006808319129049778, 0.0037503724452108145, 0.004885804373770952, -0.02230750024318695, 0.0031767955515533686, 0.004896372091025114, -0.0005567307816818357, -0.03330934792757034, 0.048439331352710724, -0.01825534738600254, -0.009942686185240746, -0.02835082821547985, 0.038613300770521164, 0.04905499517917633, 0.029880447313189507, 0.0490521602332592, 0.06788144260644913, 0.04882223531603813, -0.004519039765000343, 0.008381526917219162, 0.008707227185368538, -0.008503429591655731, -0.0072233849205076694, 0.05534451827406883, 0.014430027455091476, -0.0008501484990119934, 0.03358249366283417, 0.04099561646580696, -0.008618049323558807, 0.045121271163225174, 0.023124871775507927, 0.010586739517748356, 0.051511455327272415, 0.0012840143172070384, -0.03371751308441162, 0.031021231785416603, -0.020393723621964455, 0.015167313627898693, -0.05769900605082512, -0.0037618461064994335, 0.03772170469164848, 0.039361853152513504, 0.01405596174299717, -0.025518635287880898, -0.04116760566830635, -0.03919006511569023, 0.045197390019893646, 0.01344422809779644, -0.007802886422723532, 0.040012482553720474, 0.016437947750091553, 0.025804823264479637, -0.0020862105302512646, 0.05657600238919258, -0.02128785103559494, -0.10856262594461441, -0.013752751052379608, -0.029727112501859665, -0.04402727633714676, 0.01659402810037136, 0.011778533458709717, -0.013893648982048035, 0.030414065346121788, -0.014756043441593647, -0.005546089261770248, 0.022253021597862244, 0.04561758041381836, 0.007743248250335455, 0.02771068550646305, -0.0056740520521998405, 0.03638531640172005, 0.0036704554222524166, 0.005181199871003628, 0.1007993146777153, 0.0741427019238472, 0.05244787409901619, -0.05265546590089798, 0.022662831470370293, 0.014292686246335506, 0.007824011147022247, -0.02419067732989788, 0.07025931030511856, 0.037786729633808136, -0.027184488251805305, 0.08610282838344574, 0.051757656037807465, 0.013847366906702518, -0.007299950812011957, 0.08059109002351761, -0.0011208145879209042, -0.045108240097761154, -0.011586388573050499, 0.009095744229853153, 0.006702492479234934, 0.0025618174113333225, 0.021390069276094437, 0.020564675331115723, 0.004297435749322176, -0.015576537698507309, -0.043115872889757156, -0.01629512757062912, 0.035713259130716324, 0.023532509803771973, -0.01698239892721176, 0.005956193432211876, 0.007756417151540518, -0.005319530144333839, -0.06871160119771957, -0.053235121071338654, -0.0022879396565258503, -0.03623204305768013, -0.012927327305078506, 0.016820520162582397, 0.013734870590269566, -0.007394849322736263, -0.0095308106392622, 0.02312445268034935, -0.03280213475227356, -0.03637197986245155, -0.014852999709546566, 0.03131846711039543, -0.008441852405667305, -0.00757993571460247, -0.012725159525871277, -0.031282879412174225, -0.030875368043780327, -0.03158321604132652, -0.0381169468164444, -0.0278360303491354, 0.006955430842936039, -0.04744238033890724, 0.00847718957811594, -0.06797962635755539, 0.055130332708358765, 0.01509343832731247, 0.03511466458439827, 0.012416757643222809, -0.019056672230362892, -0.025380292907357216, -0.0008324633818119764, 0.019813863560557365, 0.007846564054489136, -0.01248116884380579, -0.002321734791621566, -0.008722547441720963, -0.011815091595053673, 0.00697339465841651, -0.010599744506180286, 0.02712756022810936, 0.02980683743953705, 0.031401000916957855, -0.03751629963517189, -0.009801105596125126, -0.024176878854632378, 0.004282061476260424, -0.005166100803762674, -0.014054829254746437, -0.02882140688598156, 0.015065471641719341, 0.050385598093271255, 0.030852731317281723, 0.013422006741166115, 0.020893260836601257, 0.024169186130166054, 0.02742842212319374, 0.019835317507386208, -0.06891421973705292, 0.0009432406513951719, -0.04078676924109459, -0.01221760455518961, -0.026872806251049042, -0.04482513666152954, 0.03755709528923035, 0.018367934972047806, 0.030242962762713432, 0.008330033160746098, 0.011563709005713463, 0.0075608729384839535, 0.029619408771395683, -0.015040144324302673, -0.06614949554204941, -0.04393507540225983, 0.0053493063896894455, -0.009127157740294933, -0.04420576989650726, -0.037132322788238525, -0.009214567951858044, -0.02576284296810627, 0.009906894527375698, -0.004214610904455185, -0.03960545361042023, 0.00021308069699443877, -0.004941681865602732, 0.018669363111257553, 0.0024430351331830025, 0.03409784287214279, -0.01890873908996582, -0.020346220582723618, 0.04439093917608261, -0.01333933137357235, -0.004078222904354334, -0.005597281735390425, 0.014045126736164093, -0.009510351344943047, 0.020643888041377068, 0.00556287681683898, 0.014234081842005253, 0.029999567195773125, 0.01075653824955225, 0.004662565421313047, 0.02457124926149845, -0.019973209127783775, 0.03949644789099693, 0.00945402029901743, -0.0605289600789547, -0.01409299485385418, 0.05472773686051369, 0.017111286520957947, -0.01756775751709938, 0.030153831467032433, -0.013714675791561604, 0.008578459732234478, 0.039542075246572495, -0.06983987987041473, -0.03051200695335865, -0.04946061596274376, 0.0347851887345314, -0.04721039533615112, 0.0075310911051929, 0.005621026270091534, 0.0483790822327137, -0.01262242067605257, 0.011787638068199158, 0.04141475260257721, 0.023771554231643677, -0.005793920252472162, -0.0046430169604718685, 0.01023520715534687, 0.06023117154836655, -0.004346443805843592, 0.004643774125725031, 0.04882632941007614, 0.054489415138959885, 0.0009870247449725866, 0.01980331353843212, 0.0017036658246070147, 0.0077669620513916016, -0.08495564758777618, -0.035271935164928436, 0.027140993624925613, -0.015367090702056885, 0.026055343449115753, -0.035534366965293884, -0.012188012711703777, 0.051925353705883026, -0.042204730212688446, 0.0009449878707528114, -0.015253324061632156, -0.02544131875038147, -0.05079507827758789, -0.021209117025136948, -0.020499901846051216, 0.048485733568668365, 0.026391245424747467, 0.012744162231683731, 0.01811041496694088, 0.03304173797369003, -0.009860231541097164, 0.0009233444579876959, -0.03183210641145706, 0.0006557978922501206, 0.009690992534160614, -0.08391941338777542, 0.02246297150850296, -0.058933768421411514, -0.07643388211727142, 0.00984260905534029, -0.04023400694131851, 0.019609903916716576, 0.05136243253946304, 0.032869014889001846, -0.003500995459035039, 0.03544450178742409, 0.004870617762207985, -0.00545702688395977, -0.04213429614901543, 0.014947663061320782, -0.012743416242301464, 0.03746557608246803, -0.05344714969396591, 0.030070506036281586, 0.03566749021410942, -0.03566440939903259, -0.005118867848068476, 0.034026991575956345, -0.006795584689825773, -0.027920054271817207, -0.004648339003324509, -0.06196574494242668, 0.01318605337291956, 0.028057275339961052, -0.014578651636838913, -0.025590717792510986, 0.026852643117308617, 0.03683886304497719, 0.04277043044567108, -0.027321597561240196, 0.02509274333715439, -0.036608509719371796, -0.061343591660261154, 0.0017594111850485206, -0.010684503242373466, -0.04432717710733414, -0.04784049466252327, -0.0031233876943588257, -0.026992853730916977, 0.027212627232074738, -0.0247956495732069, -0.03810390084981918, -0.026460004970431328, 0.05111033469438553, -0.01705443672835827, -0.011835859157145023, 0.015211142599582672, 0.007295598275959492, 0.015469248406589031, -0.03565723076462746, 0.009752311743795872, 0.030908940359950066, -0.04296717047691345, -0.03151552379131317, 0.0033496632240712643, -0.04354891926050186, 0.015327466651797295, 0.04921255633234978, 0.004869677126407623, 0.016024593263864517, -0.02102646417915821, -0.01551789790391922, -0.020236777141690254, -0.049867674708366394, -0.013092936016619205, -0.0493725910782814, -0.05017416924238205, -0.02937953732907772, 0.005944931413978338, 0.015655897557735443, 0.007824708707630634, 0.022413404658436775, -0.03377045691013336, 0.011433928273618221, -0.008336619473993778, 0.010835842229425907, 0.020497415214776993, -0.0319315530359745, -0.014537828043103218, 0.06085176020860672, -0.02326316572725773, 0.007306649815291166, -0.0027136264834553003, -0.002614692086353898, -0.034166499972343445, 0.04690052568912506, -0.011069976724684238, -0.016451489180326462, 0.006827869918197393, -0.013615604490041733, -0.021167658269405365, -0.08557227998971939, -0.0015143181663006544, -0.0023694774135947227, 0.010786188766360283, -0.022102385759353638, 0.003891272470355034, 0.03719956800341606, -0.00486483471468091, -0.02628062479197979, 0.011757820844650269, 0.001095413463190198, -0.026599353179335594, 0.011503411456942558, 0.020260216668248177, 0.012796000577509403, 0.019892949610948563, 0.005365301389247179, -0.00195794808678329, -0.02070627175271511, 0.02800908125936985, -0.0002650454989634454, 0.027949005365371704, -0.017991751432418823, 0.007590741850435734, -0.015250607393682003, -0.006575525272637606, 0.057292018085718155, 0.011286144144833088, -0.015622859820723534, 0.04010283946990967, -0.04583066701889038, 0.007391729392111301, -0.029344111680984497, -0.0124620720744133, -0.03579409793019295, -0.04105236753821373, 0.02823047526180744, 0.014187387190759182, 0.010720768943428993, -0.007366704288870096, 0.03021901845932007, 0.005510814022272825, 0.022216973826289177, 0.008212389424443245, 0.029822545126080513, -0.038885656744241714, -0.00022819431615062058, -0.017756344750523567, 0.005038123577833176, -0.05332902446389198, -0.009141610004007816, 0.019558701664209366, 0.04129404574632645, 0.0444430410861969, -0.0307763759046793, -0.03489816561341286, -0.007959546521306038, 0.026122314855456352, -0.06570956856012344, -0.026408886536955833, -0.0685211792588234, -0.0011372759472578764, 0.01838345266878605, -0.04367228224873543 ]
<p>I have a homework assignment about implementing the adaboost algorithm.<br> We are following this <a href="https://www.cs.princeton.edu/picasso/mats/schapire02boosting_schapire.pdf" rel="nofollow">article by Schapire</a>. I'm not exactly sure what they mean in the assignment by :</p> <blockquote> <p>Let the training patterns and their labels in dataset D be denoted xi and yi, respectively and let Wk(i) be the kth (discrete) distribution over all these training samples. We initialize these weights Wk to to be uniform in iteration k=1.</p> </blockquote> <p>Do I just make an array of ones?</p> <p><code>Wk = ones((size(H(x)))</code> </p> <p>Then updated it accordingly on each iteration.</p>
35,972
[ -0.009676976129412651, -0.02217315137386322, 0.04726593941450119, -0.013968590646982193, 0.0344182588160038, -0.0007755145779810846, 0.017965100705623627, 0.002546162810176611, -0.015860114246606827, -0.011938429437577724, 0.06652136892080307, 0.022874493151903152, 0.019616758450865746, 0.014034687541425228, 0.036963220685720444, 0.00624226126819849, -0.002896759659051895, -0.0158587284386158, -0.02435062639415264, -0.002547859912738204, 0.005582110956311226, 0.04222002997994423, -0.02003723569214344, 0.0006816397653892636, -0.050492651760578156, 0.015093620866537094, -0.00027031509671360254, -0.013511155731976032, 0.059909868985414505, 0.05097675323486328, -0.06429889798164368, 0.0034485275391489267, -0.005730218719691038, -0.001381170004606247, 0.022567857056856155, -0.01031525433063507, -0.04340791702270508, -0.03965131565928459, -0.011377864517271519, 0.0000195996599359205, -0.020091842859983444, -0.023759547621011734, -0.006155298091471195, 0.030733622610569, -0.011462931521236897, 0.0008437139913439751, -0.04315798357129097, -0.04278552532196045, 0.018931811675429344, -0.007579941768199205, 0.06499528884887695, -0.0008564845775254071, 0.04686436429619789, 0.033440638333559036, -0.012611404061317444, 0.00836825929582119, 0.02838476374745369, 0.019722674041986465, 0.0006247590063139796, -0.024181995540857315, 0.018437454476952553, -0.05787454545497894, 0.0029995988588780165, -0.012701336294412613, -0.007238034158945084, 0.018774185329675674, 0.002176475478336215, -0.03573285788297653, 0.028187839314341545, -0.001987326191738248, 0.0637039914727211, 0.029156779870390892, 0.012539786286652088, -0.03569120913743973, 0.01720341108739376, 0.0019919835031032562, -0.015405557118356228, 0.015988489612936974, 0.08728691190481186, 0.015448193065822124, 0.02385290525853634, 0.013504577800631523, 0.011525653302669525, 0.03604181483387947, 0.03697832301259041, -0.0308652613312006, 0.08414775133132935, 0.005638746544718742, 0.007481095381081104, 0.034477099776268005, -0.010841079987585545, -0.0016849968815222383, 0.045770127326250076, 0.010459095239639282, -0.03328150883316994, 0.018139194697141647, -0.01753111556172371, 0.01627855747938156, -0.00081837666220963, 0.0004959080833941698, 0.02275782637298107, -0.0866289809346199, 0.01072144415229559, 0.030667295679450035, -0.03776315227150917, -0.007307298015803099, -0.02576012723147869, 0.0046863737516105175, -0.02160869538784027, -0.004971071612089872, -0.04348158463835716, 0.02561255916953087, -0.021814553067088127, -0.006733600050210953, 0.04200756549835205, 0.037817906588315964, -0.008692288771271706, 0.05892680585384369, 0.00989797804504633, 0.04388229921460152, 0.025104131549596786, -0.04550269618630409, 0.031954746693372726, -0.03423197567462921, -0.058764729648828506, 0.041973792016506195, -0.010148338973522186, -0.014352604746818542, -0.06265177577733994, 0.05700014904141426, -0.016988294199109077, -0.015377700328826904, 0.0425604023039341, 0.026805024594068527, 0.01584066078066826, -0.01708749681711197, -0.10811043530702591, -0.07970866560935974, 0.019022135064005852, -0.03337624669075012, 0.018634889274835587, -0.05649329721927643, 0.015905456617474556, 0.020881040021777153, 0.05627688765525818, 0.019507434219121933, 0.04899872839450836, 0.014262441545724869, -0.0051225037313997746, 0.0011813874589279294, -0.02483954280614853, -0.023814886808395386, -0.012711519375443459, -0.03846495598554611, -0.030561549589037895, -0.07196631282567978, 0.007790767587721348, 0.014963884837925434, 0.011705626733601093, -0.05002829059958458, 0.021684112027287483, -0.029584243893623352, 0.004680511076003313, 0.003990114666521549, -0.033164579421281815, -0.018765052780508995, 0.0750785768032074, -0.0024583388585597277, 0.05778944864869118, 0.020527776330709457, -0.047188784927129745, 0.007941852323710918, 0.0057042445987463, 0.03243851661682129, 0.05763064697384834, 0.01803482696413994, -0.014477290213108063, -0.048271194100379944, 0.03136949613690376, 0.0048784841783344746, 0.010099648497998714, -0.057298898696899414, 0.016356462612748146, 0.0014107138849794865, 0.011168146505951881, 0.04683346673846245, 0.01577562466263771, 0.028531450778245926, 0.012914426624774933, -0.028768273070454597, -0.05065862461924553, -0.051700472831726074, 0.023726245388388634, -0.026431383565068245, 0.008716882206499577, 0.0038832679856568575, -0.0007631703047081828, -0.014126677997410297, 0.0257995817810297, -0.009906125254929066, -0.026415375992655754, -0.021776288747787476, 0.017183581367135048, -0.036675915122032166, -0.012712517753243446, 0.039024610072374344, 0.007949023507535458, -0.018964292481541634, 0.057324934750795364, -0.04967771843075752, 0.01903156191110611, -0.004823546856641769, -0.022017827257514, -0.02253747545182705, -0.024685248732566833, 0.03658031299710274, 0.03180543705821037, 0.03857937082648277, -0.007185892201960087, -0.01073756255209446, -0.056747764348983765, 0.036260396242141724, 0.057298969477415085, -0.008999497629702091, 0.017089972272515297, 0.008892162702977657, -0.007049779407680035, -0.0016006303485482931, -0.00784069113433361, -0.01389250811189413, -0.04152914136648178, 0.004850695375353098, 0.023029761388897896, 0.027027014642953873, -0.031792718917131424, -0.02085733413696289, 0.08098457753658295, 0.02551652118563652, 0.0008575241663493216, 0.05111708864569664, -0.004453497007489204, 0.030827421694993973, 0.024276260286569595, 0.01483776606619358, 0.06440072506666183, 0.0026000570505857468, 0.021656500175595284, 0.012903323397040367, 0.015451362356543541, 0.010697463527321815, 0.0014556957175955176, 0.03903065249323845, -0.018900984898209572, 0.03534894436597824, -0.04222254827618599, -0.044165126979351044, 0.023524783551692963, -0.0268408190459013, -0.0005915883812122047, 0.0318012498319149, -0.02551836334168911, 0.00479323323816061, 0.0007508586859330535, -0.01933743618428707, -0.01639884151518345, 0.06458137929439545, 0.006051935255527496, -0.021134471520781517, 0.0091561209410429, -0.045786917209625244, 0.01951659470796585, -0.0050445315428078175, -0.030709750950336456, -0.027145622298121452, 0.02601437084376812, 0.05792412534356117, 0.056479908525943756, 0.012356715276837349, -0.061453208327293396, -0.026461930945515633, -0.010730478912591934, -0.007883832789957523, 0.03253727778792381, 0.014497518539428711, -0.04110633581876755, 0.0028727075550705194, -0.02130027301609516, -0.006679289974272251, 0.047172315418720245, 0.008849303238093853, -0.037423331290483475, 0.026676632463932037, -0.011033894494175911, -0.018059857189655304, -0.04116978123784065, -0.057478196918964386, 0.0507107749581337, -0.029339326545596123, 0.006331158801913261, 0.0738709345459938, 0.020439887419342995, -0.04957858845591545, 0.028516750782728195, 0.01136045902967453, -0.020859431475400925, -0.055240798741579056, -0.023247096687555313, -0.013463015668094158, 0.025712857022881508, 0.021650167182087898, 0.017912421375513077, 0.001454781275242567, -0.012084108777344227, -0.04914598912000656, -0.07723657786846161, 0.02588101103901863, -0.0013460625195875764, 0.00170361646451056, 0.03426765650510788, 0.001964119728654623, 0.10949160903692245, -0.00016582506941631436, -0.01187858171761036, -0.007748507894575596, 0.009984062053263187, -0.04104967415332794, -0.00915949884802103, 0.03473805636167526, 0.016619335860013962, 0.004346715286374092, -0.02912003919482231, -0.005375536158680916, 0.03173927590250969, 0.08459357172250748, -0.017000069841742516, 0.012934460304677486, 0.0005210124072618783, -0.0211603082716465, -0.04268711432814598, 0.07162997871637344, 0.016272516921162605, -0.04453439265489578, 0.0025845528580248356, 0.00031896945438347757, -0.042721569538116455, 0.03566741943359375, -0.030749555677175522, 0.03981691598892212, -0.000400903751142323, -0.0025082307402044535, -0.04133486747741699, 0.009757799096405506, 0.01600269414484501, -0.0391717255115509, -0.021364863961935043, -0.0013822519686073065, 0.06326874345541, -0.04101615399122238, -0.026500513777136803, 0.021365826949477196, 0.03038383089005947, -0.013693202286958694, -0.004063105210661888, 0.01571446843445301, -0.0073930444195866585, 0.02191254310309887, -0.03377804160118103, -0.002646075328812003, 0.012717355042696, 0.049426399171352386, 0.028107265010476112, 0.04213399812579155, -0.0847063809633255, -0.01621251180768013, -0.05220054090023041, 0.02082720585167408, 0.004711275454610586, 0.08767803758382797, -0.00468717236071825, 0.028803430497646332, 0.027934227138757706, 0.020689548924565315, 0.01883426122367382, -0.009580133482813835, -0.030354686081409454, 0.0005842980463057756, 0.0377434603869915, -0.005412335507571697, 0.013776448555290699, -0.06979107856750488, 0.03390207514166832, -0.04434476047754288, 0.029309550300240517, 0.025655265897512436, -0.003380715847015381, -0.029511509463191032, 0.0163866076618433, -0.02632679045200348, -0.039866138249635696, -0.05353726074099541, 0.011015264317393303, 0.028905421495437622, -0.025027355179190636, 0.041125815361738205, -0.011320189572870731, -0.0079802880063653, -0.006717512849718332, -0.0167356226593256, 0.010583695024251938, 0.02463058941066265, 0.01953173242509365, 0.003518297802656889, 0.03199639171361923, -0.02844727598130703, 0.004879762418568134, 0.039887744933366776, 0.06964852660894394, 0.01844344474375248, -0.01958186738193035, 0.013976940885186195, -0.036266352981328964, -0.03021949715912342, 0.01260938961058855, 0.03529094532132149, -0.012286859564483166, 0.014685621485114098, 0.052923910319805145, 0.01635885052382946, -0.06299612671136856, 0.0007285792962647974, 0.08964806795120239, 0.006615383550524712, 0.0024061035364866257, -0.03274506703019142, 0.02861628495156765, 0.003933844622224569, 0.019665539264678955, 0.009419163689017296, 0.002492521656677127, 0.012242920696735382, 0.01240141224116087, 0.010236930102109909, -0.015765665099024773, -0.0347026102244854, -0.022305544465780258, -0.0030678354669362307, 0.06053780019283295, -0.025338998064398766, -0.009501194581389427, 0.01315465196967125, 0.021008362993597984, 0.043779660016298294, 0.024034643545746803, -0.0006917496211826801, -0.07204566150903702, -0.020688407123088837, 0.019595948979258537, 0.03684334084391594, -0.03244806081056595, 0.013299012556672096, -0.045524124056100845, 0.0296731349080801, 0.03354152292013168, -0.04895751550793648, 0.033044323325157166, 0.009241991676390171, 0.013457657769322395, -0.008411719463765621, -0.011150138452649117, -0.04937894269824028, 0.017813967540860176, -0.0475124791264534, 0.07065156102180481, -0.013335909694433212, -0.032574307173490524, -0.02772393263876438, 0.018162254244089127, 0.01700405590236187, 0.05802582576870918, -0.05295867100358009, 0.020275430753827095, 0.001899762311950326, 0.02225889265537262, -0.008163897320628166, -0.10202992707490921, 0.012307187542319298, 0.019482141360640526, 0.013515649363398552, 0.04460199922323227, -0.03059356100857258, -0.05095561221241951, 0.007613981142640114, 0.02558831311762333, -0.03615889325737953, -0.036099985241889954, -0.06156482174992561, 0.020047757774591446, 0.05842972546815872, -0.004681391175836325, 0.033028893172740936, 0.02305457927286625, 0.005694628693163395, 0.03742527961730957, -0.03791821002960205, 0.005046908278018236, -0.021488433703780174, 0.010778561234474182, -0.05611664801836014, 0.009557628072798252, -0.03428095579147339, 0.027641622349619865, 0.036882054060697556, 0.07054466009140015, -0.04682730883359909, -0.050737861543893814, 0.0034947539679706097, 0.010987813584506512, -0.0326632596552372, -0.024934664368629456, -0.02532110922038555, 0.034895703196525574, -0.004255376756191254, -0.035730991512537, -0.01835664175450802, -0.044475264847278595, 0.0029665164183825254, 0.010610615834593773, -0.017641475424170494, -0.008367707952857018, -0.0354187898337841, -0.01518311258405447, 0.023384438827633858, -0.04827921837568283, 0.00931758526712656, 0.011447037570178509, 0.027689306065440178, 0.029795562848448753, -0.027956312522292137, -0.008478615432977676, 0.006486140191555023, 0.0071601299569010735, 0.028014319017529488, -0.0440608374774456, 0.05127367749810219, 0.00391377555206418, -0.0034928617533296347, -0.05261986702680588, -0.007152070757001638, 0.01542727742344141, 0.002237291308119893, -0.008652531541883945, -0.01887437328696251, 0.02342180162668228, -0.016912231221795082, -0.018868668004870415, -0.007109952159225941, -0.016570154577493668, -0.01481365691870451, -0.013340291567146778, 0.016207344830036163, 0.002603097353130579, 0.0482606515288353, 0.026306120678782463, -0.004028568509966135, 0.01416486594825983, -0.005206073168665171, -0.03468954563140869, -0.0003363171126693487, -0.011057878844439983, -0.034637339413166046, -0.003386826254427433, -0.04944626986980438, 0.018529148772358894, 0.03210954740643501, -0.0017304773209616542, -0.012315139174461365, -0.01143807452172041, -0.02112407237291336, -0.024274809285998344, -0.03411416709423065, -0.016921788454055786, -0.022658631205558777, -0.04594845697283745, -0.010658221319317818, 0.022597188130021095, -0.02147352136671543, 0.01425272785127163, 0.035745471715927124, 0.025152413174510002, 0.018523411825299263, 0.026842229068279266, 0.05840021371841431, -0.059106647968292236, 0.012904679402709007, 0.0007081986404955387, -0.05842002108693123, 0.014288609847426414, 0.03293866291642189, 0.0036522001028060913, -0.01720549166202545, 0.026136387139558792, -0.012322504073381424, 0.0027381654363125563, -0.05081966891884804, 0.031013311818242073, 0.03823857009410858, 0.03061630018055439, 0.05435451865196228, 0.04866382107138634, 0.017259880900382996, 0.011298045516014099, -0.009982519783079624, -0.03582846373319626, -0.008501885458827019, -0.01252223551273346, 0.0542263388633728, 0.008670274168252945, -0.0368807278573513, 0.05949394404888153, 0.0025363017339259386, 0.03868033364415169, -0.0035297677386552095, 0.019896965473890305, 0.02398843877017498, -0.007635245565325022, -0.032882388681173325, -0.04484463483095169, 0.03935820981860161, -0.006638915278017521, 0.020867181941866875, 0.02458537369966507, -0.04255032166838646, 0.058796513825654984, 0.04036175459623337, 0.011232188902795315, -0.0703386515378952, -0.041276682168245316, -0.037608545273542404, 0.019649803638458252, 0.00651960214599967, -0.009074496105313301, 0.01674436405301094, 0.015712285414338112, 0.021825388073921204, 0.04059690982103348, 0.010724364779889584, -0.028469635173678398, -0.035423923283815384, -0.04557299613952637, -0.011489582248032093, -0.03573056682944298, 0.0019304498564451933, -0.001962635898962617, -0.06378913670778275, 0.0004047238908242434, -0.030289191752672195, 0.04091571643948555, 0.03781501203775406, 0.03345299884676933, 0.014152097515761852, 0.06999228149652481, 0.010549483820796013, 0.019360993057489395, 0.008278953842818737, 0.009134645573794842, 0.1237398013472557, 0.08204726129770279, 0.04122709482908249, -0.04283216968178749, -0.005533330608159304, -0.014775172807276249, -0.034350816160440445, -0.021995117887854576, 0.01708379201591015, 0.005154778249561787, -0.0037153149023652077, -0.012078377418220043, 0.010916552506387234, 0.015719255432486534, 0.004251637030392885, 0.0108192665502429, -0.03713376820087433, -0.023298319429159164, 0.013790640980005264, -0.010059325955808163, 0.018284713849425316, -0.01789085380733013, -0.03882799297571182, 0.022235551849007607, 0.019826289266347885, -0.016997043043375015, 0.021292468532919884, -0.01465329434722662, 0.013041562400758266, 0.030957713723182678, 0.013520647771656513, 0.012806187383830547, -0.033808525651693344, -0.014736520126461983, 0.016376277431845665, 0.055503759533166885, -0.006357163656502962, -0.04260626435279846, 0.028085535392165184, 0.03363228589296341, 0.034986767917871475, -0.019935626536607742, 0.0016881028423085809, 0.004038057290017605, -0.023570889607071877, -0.016297616064548492, -0.04794267565011978, 0.03660175949335098, -0.01943921111524105, -0.0010649708565324545, -0.008932523429393768, 0.013846549205482006, -0.005259873811155558, -0.0878148078918457, 0.033652596175670624, 0.03995072469115257, 0.009278688579797745, -0.014598767273128033, -0.03454914316534996, -0.02548317052423954, -0.017983589321374893, -0.03773966804146767, 0.01208148431032896, 0.01692156307399273, -0.03701796010136604, -0.013162760064005852, -0.05228444188833237, 0.013188363052904606, -0.026053205132484436, -0.01947764679789543, -0.017563311383128166, -0.010341314598917961, -0.03411408141255379, -0.02305584028363228, -0.029785994440317154, -0.048092328011989594, 0.02483494207262993, -0.009907986037433147, -0.027122793719172478, -0.030378270894289017, -0.041381143033504486, -0.015013140626251698, -0.002738324226811528, -0.029479214921593666, -0.023244917392730713, -0.007027611136436462, 0.023690126836299896, 0.03631550818681717, 0.03594177961349487, -0.01779904030263424, 0.022588185966014862, 0.017366992309689522, 0.011003679595887661, -0.035194333642721176, -0.002444780897349119, 0.03510193154215813, -0.027462169528007507, 0.0050504086539149284, -0.008069507777690887, 0.06972401589155197, 0.06297526508569717, 0.008937199600040913, 0.007292832713574171, 0.04285111650824547, -0.005842441692948341, 0.021953899413347244, -0.0028543267399072647, -0.04764619469642639, -0.011617613025009632, 0.0000676106137689203, -0.02098803222179413, -0.08066380023956299, -0.04126260429620743, -0.0182795450091362, 0.0033367841970175505, -0.017671087756752968, 0.00895868893712759, -0.017777958884835243, -0.002732068533077836, -0.001972346566617489, 0.025612767785787582, -0.003050323808565736, 0.0005630945670418441, -0.00367760076187551, 0.000695729861035943, 0.018368912860751152, -0.00847562961280346, -0.01152960304170847, 0.028308263048529625, 0.001543449703603983, 0.023186946287751198, 0.04366348311305046, 0.008246158249676228, 0.01967684179544449, 0.018584677949547768, -0.017696095630526543, -0.032498206943273544, 0.022370293736457825, 0.00027172802947461605, -0.01786542683839798, 0.04014657065272331, -0.043528322130441666, 0.003330560401082039, 0.021430987864732742, 0.003394010942429304, 0.029710834845900536, 0.03544881194829941, -0.010200941935181618, -0.02498537488281727, 0.04652921482920647, -0.04121558740735054, -0.01516190730035305, 0.02020631544291973, -0.01747576706111431, 0.02290855534374714, 0.0132698193192482, 0.03423522785305977, 0.021366121247410774, 0.02016918733716011, 0.013115682639181614, 0.012952904216945171, -0.023716073483228683, -0.038998205214738846, 0.01108577661216259, 0.017293980345129967, 0.017429957166314125, -0.017595279961824417, -0.00648937001824379, 0.006749705411493778, 0.033301081508398056, -0.040410567075014114, 0.01911216974258423, -0.04677269980311394, -0.00035097255022265017, -0.08340603858232498, -0.025009922683238983, 0.007309967651963234, -0.008309331722557545, 0.028894364833831787, -0.04174743965268135, -0.013935474678874016, 0.0012878653360530734, -0.03705238550901413, 0.01718113012611866, 0.010625460185110569, -0.016722358763217926, -0.05549972876906395, 0.06456641852855682, -0.02146032638847828, 0.00739632360637188, 0.018914757296442986, 0.014525430276989937, 0.01947559043765068, 0.0058638728223741055, 0.0026469032745808363, -0.034721508622169495, -0.003133834572508931, 0.0527835413813591, 0.011849997565150261, -0.050145190209150314, 0.05015187710523605, -0.028213944286108017, -0.02300252951681614, 0.04895516484975815, -0.004929414950311184, -0.03899318352341652, 0.048300039023160934, 0.027324378490447998, 0.02916855551302433, 0.05565207824110985, 0.020158560946583748, -0.0017040179809555411, -0.00020538660464808345, -0.026628747582435608, 0.018007343634963036, -0.005358810070902109, 0.014420508407056332, 0.0418439581990242, 0.03335494548082352, -0.042019929736852646, -0.02925753779709339, 0.03385629504919052, -0.004437718074768782, -0.018565434962511063, 0.008464490063488483, 0.006729830522090197, -0.003630168503150344, -0.021843602880835533, -0.012996785342693329, -0.010697866789996624, 0.030073348432779312, 0.018671689555048943, 0.013449307531118393, -0.021144183352589607, -0.014460655860602856, -0.002658967860043049, -0.03547848388552666, 0.006415550597012043, 0.003754862118512392, -0.06258368492126465, -0.06834033876657486, -0.029579943045973778, -0.027478110045194626, -0.0006476705311797559, -0.009959601797163486, -0.01762162707746029, -0.004674309398978949, 0.018277807161211967, -0.022135557606816292, -0.017742589116096497, 0.015963498502969742, -0.0055337040685117245, -0.010212970897555351, -0.09309420734643936, 0.0820850059390068, 0.01641485095024109, -0.04572097957134247, -0.04279499128460884, -0.014403480105102062, -0.061434853821992874, 0.01914641074836254, 0.04177399352192879, 0.022876542061567307, 0.004332969430834055, -0.022185202687978745, -0.01012625452131033, 0.015479578636586666, -0.04567616060376167, 0.03787314146757126, -0.014432557858526707, 0.009352183900773525, -0.013168281875550747, 0.007216691039502621, 0.018059933558106422, -0.002764839446172118, 0.009730527177453041, -0.021821366623044014, 0.012204005382955074, 0.0004965563421137631, -0.018464015796780586, -0.007473096251487732, 0.02327326498925686, -0.004434073343873024, 0.051644258201122284, 0.037038225680589676, 0.017626486718654633, 0.03559065982699394, -0.0027614848222583532, -0.050514835864305496, 0.012619327753782272, -0.040672097355127335, 0.04165990650653839, 0.0019863913767039776, 0.023622674867510796, 0.013621597550809383, -0.05712072178721428, -0.05587667226791382, 0.00880926102399826, -0.0002839463413693011, -0.003791390685364604, 0.04121270403265953, 0.028039956465363503, 0.001467013033106923, 0.02099943347275257, -0.003849413013085723, -0.028567137196660042, 0.007684851996600628, -0.037325169891119, 0.029789021238684654, 0.02441960759460926, -0.021351249888539314, 0.049525611102581024, -0.0030495196115225554, 0.011367429047822952, 0.013436444103717804, -0.005172656383365393, 0.026040589436888695, -0.006770841311663389, 0.008204006589949131, -0.007502032443881035, -0.005545704625546932, -0.03884116932749748, 0.011001532897353172, -0.023950941860675812, 0.08366047590970993, -0.042557939887046814, 0.018400020897388458, -0.023147037252783775, -0.03767457976937294, 0.008807256817817688, 0.02578963339328766, 0.04064515233039856, 0.0628805160522461, -0.009575210511684418, -0.012826184742152691, 0.024030407890677452, -0.0011225729249417782, 0.003481522900983691, -0.08173017203807831, 0.0359928123652935, 0.007493688724935055, -0.0042304773814976215, 0.007396797649562359, 0.019173966720700264, -0.0064486307092010975, 0.008757340721786022, 0.000756189227104187, 0.034429289400577545, 0.013081668876111507, -0.02624131180346012, -0.024521872401237488, 0.0023080601822584867, 0.04190227389335632, 0.00045856504584662616, -0.019112002104520798, -0.0370587594807148, 0.03547505661845207, 0.009284849278628826, -0.012124941684305668 ]
<p>From Berger&amp;Casella, Chapter 8, Problem 8.5, page 402 for 2nd edition.</p> <p>The problem is: A random sample, $X_{i}$ is drawn from a Pareto population with pdf $$ f(x|\theta,v)=\frac{\theta v^{\theta}}{x^{\theta+1}}I_{[v,\infty)}(x),\theta&gt;0,v&gt;0 $$ Show that the LRT of $$ H_{0}:\theta=1; H_{1}:\theta\not=1, $$ with $v$ unknown has critical region of the form $$ \{x:T(x)\le c_{1}; T(x)\ge c_{2}\} $$ where $0&lt;c_{1}&lt;c_{2}$ and $$ T=\log[\frac{\prod^{n}_{i=1}X_{i}}{(\min_{i}X_{i})^{n}}] $$ Show that, under $H_{0}$, $2T$ has a chi squared distribution, and find the number of degrees of freedom. (Hint: Obtain the joint distribution of the $n-1$ non-trivial terms $\frac{X_{i}}{\min_{i} X_{i}}$ conditional on $\min_{i}X_{i}$. Put these $n-1$ terms together, and notice that the distribution of $T$ given $\min_{i}X_{i}$ does not depend on $\min_{i}X_{i}$, so it is the unconditional distribution of $T$).</p> <p>After finishing the first part, I tried to compute the distribution of $T$, but after several hours of efforts I plainly got to nowhere. Here is what I did:</p> <p>Since we know $$ T=\log[\frac{\prod^{n}_{i=1}X_{i}}{(\min_{i}X_{i})^{n}}] $$ We have to use Jacobian method. We want to compute the distribution of $A=\sum \log[X_{i}]$ and $B=n\log[X_{(1)}]$. Now, if $X$ has distribution $f_{X}[x]$, then $\log[X]$ has distribution $$ f_{Y}(y)=f_{X}(e^{y})*e^{y}=\frac{v}{e^{y}}I_{[\log[v],\infty)}(y)=ve^{-y}I_{[\log[v],\infty)}(y) $$ On the other hand $$ Z=\log[X_{(1)}] $$ has distribution coming from $X_{(1)}$. We know $X_{(1)}$'s pdf is $$ nf_{X}(x)(1-F_{X}(x))^{n-1} $$ We know that $$ f_{X}(x)=\frac{v}{x^{2}}I_{(v,\infty)}(x) $$ Therefore $$ F_{X}(x)=\int^{x}_{v}\frac{v}{t^{2}}dt=v(-\frac{1}{t})^{x}_{v}=v(-\frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{v})=1-\frac{v}{x} $$ Therefore $$ f_{X_{(1)}}(x)=n\frac{v}{x^{2}}I_{(v,\infty)}\frac{v^{n-1}}{x^{n-1}}=\frac{nv^{n}}{x^{n+1}}I_{(v,\infty)} $$ and if $\log[X_{(1)}]=z$, then we have $$ f_{Z}(z)=\frac{nv^{n}}{e^{(n+1)z}}e^{z}I_{(\log[v],\infty)}=\frac{nv^{n}}{e^{nz}}I_{(\log[v],\infty)} $$ Now it is suffice to compute the distribution of $$2(\sum_{i=1}^{n}\log[X_{i}]-n\log[Z])$$</p> <p>Since $\log[X_{i}],\log[X_{j}]$ are independent, by Jacobian method we have $$ Z=X+Y, W=Y; f_{Z,W}(z,w)=f_{X,Y}(Z-W,W)=f_{X}(Z-W)f_{Y}(W) $$ So we have $$ f_{(Z,W)}=ve^{-(z-w)}ve^{-w}=v^{2}e^{-z} $$ where we have $$ w\ge \log[v], z-w\ge \log[v]\rightarrow z\ge 2\log[v] $$ Therefore $$ \log[X_{i}]+\log[X_{j}]\sim v^{2}e^{-z}I_{(2\log[v],\infty)} $$ Proceed inductively we have $$ f_{\sum^{n}_{i=1}\log[X_{i}]}(s)=v^{n}e^{-s}I_{(n\log[v],\infty)} $$ On the other hand we want to compute the pdf of $f_{n\log[X_{(1)}]}$. From the cdf we have: $$ \log[X_{(1)}]\le t\leftrightarrow n\log[X_{(1)}]\le nt $$ Therefore $$ F_{n\log[X_{(1)}]}(t)=F_{\log[X_{i}]}(\frac{t}{n}) $$ This implies $$ f_{n\log[X_{(1)}]}(t)=f_{\log[X_{i}]}(\frac{t}{n})*\frac{1}{n}=\frac{v^{n}}{e^{t}}I_{(n\log[v],\infty)}=v^{n}e^{-t}I_{(n\log[v],\infty)} $$ Let $S=\sum^{n}_{i=1}\log[X_{i}],T=n\log[X_{(1)}]$. Then $S,T$ are independent because of Basu's theorem. But I cannot separate $f_{S,T}$ due to the restriction of the domain, as I have $S+T\ge n\log[v],T\ge n\log[v]$ does not imply $S\in (0,\infty)$. Also the resulting distribution is not $\chi^{2}$. So I think I need some help. </p>
73,574
[ -0.022073714062571526, -0.035342998802661896, 0.03579665720462799, -0.014369240961968899, 0.04030539467930794, -0.014862445183098316, -0.034571610391139984, -0.01851165108382702, 0.0022307392209768295, -0.059563253074884415, 0.04665273800492287, 0.028416763991117477, 0.005490442272275686, 0.06479544937610626, 0.01339856255799532, 0.0215986929833889, -0.04426996782422066, 0.013552394695580006, -0.0007270774221979082, 0.002685914281755686, -0.00581380957737565, -0.0015750575112178922, 0.021654482930898666, -0.03192749619483948, -0.07198425382375717, 0.040622346103191376, -0.02442917227745056, -0.03852592408657074, -0.038821592926979065, 0.0964142307639122, -0.05549038201570511, -0.008702415972948074, 0.0010751859517768025, -0.022752750664949417, -0.013301022350788116, 0.02591700106859207, -0.026701008901000023, -0.023290559649467468, 0.015409407205879688, 0.02284594438970089, -0.03565501794219017, 0.015024427324533463, -0.01598414033651352, -0.010988902300596237, -0.0047005596570670605, 0.03314991295337677, -0.012307098135352135, -0.04595109447836876, 0.03754091635346413, -0.04489481821656227, 0.07323571294546127, 0.046436309814453125, 0.0004850813711527735, -0.01150580681860447, -0.011422461830079556, -0.024566320702433586, -0.0010648221941664815, 0.05794534087181091, 0.008914186619222164, -0.04772825539112091, -0.032845135778188705, -0.039516009390354156, -0.012416188605129719, -0.03511771559715271, -0.035877153277397156, -0.012250307947397232, 0.0030634277500212193, 0.003969104029238224, 0.005668628960847855, -0.03989098221063614, 0.026991572231054306, 0.022609665989875793, 0.019656816497445107, 0.01457384042441845, -0.006754934322088957, 0.028389470651745796, 0.012607370503246784, 0.007820985279977322, 0.01510144304484129, 0.0355214923620224, 0.022077172994613647, 0.02258894219994545, 0.03092658519744873, 0.022279638797044754, -0.02304675057530403, -0.016308045014739037, 0.10340810567140579, -0.022075612097978592, 0.02063189074397087, 0.013971421867609024, -0.018512975424528122, 0.003042366588488221, 0.03899571672081947, -0.0330829992890358, -0.03381972759962082, 0.02915913797914982, -0.008330420590937138, 0.014638248831033707, -0.021887779235839844, -0.0027680688071995974, -0.012343691661953926, -0.05023154243826866, -0.02138371579349041, 0.04249606654047966, -0.026514530181884766, -0.007071078289300203, -0.009174182079732418, 0.0032468298450112343, -0.021424004808068275, -0.013705591671168804, -0.01727406308054924, 0.037361931055784225, -0.017129970714449883, 0.018969472497701645, -0.009570328518748283, 0.018986376002430916, 0.006749523803591728, -0.004705867264419794, 0.06232011690735817, 0.02632870525121689, 0.03265008702874184, -0.02223805896937847, 0.016419613733887672, -0.011087511666119099, -0.04011658951640129, 0.033420246094465256, 0.010824893601238728, -0.01159101165831089, -0.05664749816060066, 0.01982738822698593, -0.0011825219262391329, 0.00470080878585577, 0.01602230966091156, 0.05168752744793892, -0.010903749614953995, -0.006552289705723524, -0.08446664363145828, -0.023909561336040497, 0.04504323750734329, -0.0296560600399971, -0.006074321921914816, -0.049879249185323715, -0.005147507414221764, 0.03899671137332916, 0.05053597688674927, -0.0553201325237751, 0.05594123899936676, 0.005253136157989502, 0.008010012097656727, 0.04093772545456886, -0.02761201187968254, 0.007101821713149548, -0.03172359988093376, -0.033841412514448166, 0.006948371417820454, -0.05832688510417938, 0.05595925822854042, 0.029766561463475227, -0.00997106358408928, -0.04257463291287422, 0.019021999090909958, 0.012818412855267525, -0.014238736592233181, -0.013027001172304153, 0.0002767872647382319, -0.01842671073973179, 0.06538741290569305, 0.007562666200101376, 0.027745626866817474, -0.01375920232385397, 0.005490219220519066, 0.006632593460381031, -0.006564496085047722, 0.04059506952762604, 0.03505021333694458, -0.018952470272779465, -0.004090779460966587, -0.014622923918068409, -0.024620026350021362, 0.004953854251652956, -0.006748910993337631, -0.014092521741986275, -0.02611776627600193, 0.03758405148983002, 0.02608584240078926, 0.054134391248226166, 0.011399617418646812, 0.0005382857052609324, 0.03028143383562565, -0.03567826747894287, -0.006740960758179426, -0.035358574241399765, -0.018600016832351685, 0.0407656729221344, -0.06814365088939667, 0.020612381398677826, -0.008598655462265015, 0.004149710293859243, 0.0003272989415563643, 0.0025886190123856068, -0.012671827338635921, 0.018464338034391403, 0.04013524949550629, -0.03847344592213631, 0.025214752182364464, 0.06807424873113632, 0.04879865422844887, 0.05052236095070839, 0.07549753785133362, -0.03035554103553295, -0.019552776589989662, 0.03516889736056328, -0.01725669577717781, 0.06249750778079033, -0.018022632226347923, 0.015272344462573528, -0.00796680711209774, -0.01230890303850174, -0.016035787761211395, 0.017369486391544342, -0.044369351118803024, 0.010143815539777279, 0.07331392168998718, 0.00766155868768692, 0.007880715653300285, 0.0174973513931036, 0.005291159730404615, -0.009154665283858776, -0.03095746785402298, 0.012085971422493458, -0.055624913424253464, -0.02515513263642788, 0.041387468576431274, 0.05515254661440849, -0.022153131663799286, 0.0005016283830627799, 0.06982652097940445, 0.013579324819147587, 0.03817266598343849, 0.011718511581420898, -0.0242350734770298, -0.017492741346359253, 0.048374615609645844, 0.020153991878032684, 0.009978045709431171, -0.006083264946937561, 0.01755174808204174, 0.015442265197634697, 0.02892032079398632, -0.0252686757594347, -0.019871382042765617, 0.03112167865037918, 0.028714966028928757, -0.029161764308810234, -0.05009401962161064, 0.028459934517741203, 0.06549257785081863, 0.005845602136105299, -0.02127273939549923, 0.03137953206896782, -0.010198774747550488, 0.031263768672943115, 0.017694849520921707, -0.03619759902358055, 0.03595024719834328, 0.03198022022843361, -0.02740306966006756, 0.007608913350850344, 0.028580056503415108, -0.04526880383491516, -0.027716876938939095, -0.012292223051190376, -0.051330361515283585, 0.016724636778235435, -0.008840372785925865, 0.03906012699007988, -0.007715082727372646, 0.0025295824743807316, -0.002976665273308754, 0.012196896597743034, -0.0023317269515246153, 0.002985810860991478, 0.04872879385948181, -0.00934917014092207, -0.051122959703207016, -0.02651316672563553, -0.025446785613894463, -0.010452047921717167, 0.015975989401340485, 0.030500339344143867, -0.006844096351414919, 0.030257074162364006, -0.031420640647411346, -0.04289071634411812, -0.017155291512608528, -0.012580997310578823, -0.014559824019670486, -0.027713293209671974, -0.006551465019583702, 0.029968708753585815, 0.02574935369193554, -0.03377708047628403, 0.01930181309580803, -0.008604996837675571, -0.05054645240306854, -0.055008288472890854, 0.0398670919239521, 0.021475529298186302, -0.010591012425720692, 0.04056233540177345, 0.010583304800093174, 0.0631159320473671, -0.009509512223303318, -0.06132328510284424, -0.05303625762462616, -0.023206988349556923, 0.0076021840795874596, 0.02470662072300911, 0.006268793251365423, -0.027174189686775208, 0.07910048216581345, 0.035059887915849686, 0.005603959318250418, -0.0190004613250494, -0.00686216913163662, 0.006460736505687237, -0.004278441425412893, 0.06320776790380478, 0.0271821990609169, -0.02597794309258461, 0.004156949929893017, -0.0203009732067585, 0.02075313590466976, 0.07777637243270874, -0.014463396742939949, 0.011539529077708721, 0.04293912276625633, -0.005259382538497448, -0.03672296553850174, 0.022906547412276268, 0.016597801819443703, 0.01510311383754015, 0.004004023503512144, 0.013864947482943535, 0.049414098262786865, -0.00436938414350152, -0.045469142496585846, 0.041300028562545776, -0.023602090775966644, -0.0022099451161921024, -0.022959955036640167, 0.04599977284669876, 0.037651367485523224, -0.05360286682844162, 0.0036542469169944525, 0.00256705773063004, 0.03321214020252228, -0.04246896877884865, -0.0007886476232670248, 0.005856389179825783, 0.024989748373627663, 0.012709062546491623, -0.025438768789172173, -0.0168246291577816, -0.00019436521688476205, 0.01102659571915865, -0.01179088931530714, -0.030171392485499382, 0.005287793464958668, 0.060738321393728256, 0.004313623998314142, 0.0009570636320859194, 0.023604726418852806, 0.02392198145389557, 0.01828905940055847, 0.0198751799762249, -0.0440615639090538, 0.058496538549661636, -0.0037210658192634583, 0.03775199130177498, -0.024892503395676613, 0.003138527739793062, -0.029091592878103256, 0.005296728573739529, -0.07227330654859543, 0.036632608622312546, -0.00606214115396142, -0.010887693613767624, 0.0023010559380054474, 0.009567002765834332, 0.06842631101608276, 0.007706418167799711, 0.020875437185168266, 0.005147416610270739, 0.04041348025202751, -0.036928337067365646, 0.037461262196302414, -0.037556905299425125, 0.0036812620237469673, 0.005845818668603897, 0.03320716321468353, 0.023020148277282715, -0.011067808605730534, 0.0321018248796463, 0.030486656352877617, 0.021605394780635834, 0.03763337433338165, -0.015980994328856468, 0.0066694095730781555, 0.030294552445411682, 0.05318232253193855, -0.0318790078163147, -0.013363796286284924, 0.008177033625543118, 0.004300212487578392, -0.02924373187124729, 0.05820469930768013, 0.06365612149238586, 0.02624523639678955, 0.006979081779718399, -0.03727607801556587, -0.005482008680701256, 0.03206103667616844, 0.013317173346877098, -0.01695149578154087, 0.03449847549200058, 0.05180773511528969, 0.0033805721905082464, -0.038095034658908844, 0.008026652969419956, 0.045623473823070526, -0.007040473632514477, 0.01646512746810913, -0.0270147193223238, -0.013072283938527107, -0.00538030406460166, 0.008558646775782108, -0.01440013013780117, 0.005531259346753359, -0.017683636397123337, -0.03339026868343353, 0.05942058935761452, 0.03913552314043045, -0.04139857366681099, 0.013516559265553951, 0.024480575695633888, 0.05288560688495636, -0.0018557347357273102, -0.0375664122402668, 0.013163364492356777, -0.009533874690532684, 0.030862830579280853, -0.01689286343753338, 0.016702663153409958, -0.026449447497725487, -0.03332775458693504, 0.0242291409522295, 0.029825929552316666, -0.025097806006669998, -0.0001024778830469586, -0.048686183989048004, 0.0029319259338080883, -0.024980934336781502, -0.04056093469262123, 0.046695735305547714, 0.0036824389826506376, 0.01657719537615776, -0.0013505847891792655, -0.05646171793341637, -0.062068987637758255, -0.00833034049719572, -0.004137656185775995, 0.03457861393690109, -0.05431567132472992, -0.005387131590396166, -0.029977981001138687, -0.021094849333167076, 0.05699726566672325, 0.04765823110938072, 0.0106072211638093, -0.03870240971446037, 0.0014864890836179256, 0.038951627910137177, -0.039930738508701324, -0.04830477759242058, 0.03857461363077164, -0.0057960874401032925, 0.009187311865389347, 0.057505685836076736, -0.02339010499417782, -0.03566143289208412, 0.057938624173402786, 0.008277558721601963, -0.03740687668323517, 0.00863154511898756, 0.005589531268924475, 0.05037513002753258, 0.04045671969652176, 0.03417613357305527, 0.07073541730642319, 0.025708302855491638, -0.007623236160725355, 0.0006874764803797007, -0.03211338818073273, 0.016578134149312973, -0.006669506896287203, -0.019743239507079124, -0.049158040434122086, -0.0018014723900705576, 0.002879044506698847, 0.05328787490725517, -0.003425915027037263, 0.02625225856900215, 0.007776184473186731, -0.015228645876049995, -0.021428707987070084, 0.025092612951993942, 0.010599799454212189, 0.012394380755722523, 0.008615320548415184, 0.03930576145648956, 0.02466556988656521, 0.009053029119968414, 0.03375113010406494, -0.020211994647979736, -0.00253276526927948, 0.0241354089230299, -0.040852028876543045, -0.013670334592461586, -0.07976928353309631, -0.022975096479058266, -0.03796561062335968, -0.02196185663342476, 0.0226832777261734, 0.02139536291360855, 0.033492524176836014, 0.01577134244143963, -0.000009253461030311882, -0.03990264981985092, -0.007260101847350597, 0.026308661326766014, 0.027886459603905678, -0.01739286631345749, -0.012914306484162807, -0.01105489581823349, -0.017167720943689346, -0.06887025386095047, 0.022523803636431694, 0.009032557718455791, 0.0063476478680968285, 0.007313608657568693, -0.04277603700757027, -0.02683113142848015, 0.0133022740483284, -0.0809360221028328, -0.010247214697301388, 0.07492446154356003, 0.011005022563040257, 0.007863708771765232, -0.06430726498365402, 0.03678189218044281, 0.04188353940844536, -0.02422534115612507, -0.04775935783982277, 0.0436684787273407, -0.014998462982475758, -0.027940861880779266, -0.008151900954544544, 0.027587804943323135, -0.02851594053208828, 0.01929781772196293, 0.01992887817323208, 0.009406236931681633, -0.012373368255794048, 0.00028426700737327337, -0.055098142474889755, 0.015014635398983955, -0.005282414145767689, -0.021420540288090706, 0.0008501647389493883, -0.06328152120113373, 0.03595660254359245, 0.016519082710146904, -0.006584641523659229, 0.0029152545612305403, -0.011616584844887257, -0.03066759556531906, 0.017298830673098564, -0.01848534867167473, 0.02135019749403, 0.0158081091940403, 0.06724387407302856, -0.004807676188647747, -0.010430662892758846, -0.012062002904713154, 0.018509680405259132, 0.014884107746183872, 0.030687198042869568, -0.0023125028237700462, -0.01761755533516407, 0.012001164257526398, -0.03784569352865219, 0.015378016047179699, -0.05201500281691551, 0.02769089862704277, 0.05360445752739906, 0.0008180771837942302, 0.026915472000837326, 0.007075975649058819, 0.002432442968711257, -0.004257704131305218, -0.02057524211704731, -0.03237009420990944, -0.041243571788072586, 0.013299207203090191, 0.002714608097448945, -0.006294231861829758, -0.06028931215405464, 0.07568342238664627, -0.02277788706123829, -0.011268610134720802, 0.0235081035643816, -0.010217860341072083, 0.016132384538650513, -0.01839529164135456, -0.057948142290115356, -0.05446172505617142, 0.029553836211562157, -0.020946772769093513, 0.0269089974462986, -0.025489438325166702, -0.0015105347847566009, 0.02790967933833599, 0.05353819951415062, 0.009654411114752293, -0.03371340036392212, -0.06634180247783661, -0.02403424307703972, -0.005244163330644369, 0.004028115887194872, -0.04401210695505142, 0.02616780996322632, -0.009244991466403008, 0.015187093988060951, -0.0060929227620363235, 0.006599882151931524, -0.03350193053483963, -0.008443589322268963, 0.008248595520853996, 0.018939225003123283, -0.07137830555438995, 0.027066826820373535, 0.008244038559496403, -0.02161129005253315, 0.012471700087189674, -0.02072053961455822, 0.005473098251968622, -0.02261304296553135, 0.03564317524433136, 0.005310805048793554, 0.08828836679458618, 0.009497500024735928, 0.057476989924907684, 0.0030669253319501877, -0.004630221053957939, 0.14855395257472992, 0.04787834361195564, 0.007509767543524504, -0.03894398361444473, 0.014648216776549816, -0.011474495753645897, 0.0015921063022688031, -0.038297589868307114, -0.006780571304261684, 0.04486149549484253, -0.02748509868979454, 0.004183419514447451, 0.0030730676371604204, 0.0011754881124943495, -0.011273279786109924, 0.03844090551137924, -0.002386802341789007, -0.050716083496809006, -0.03953316807746887, 0.01429731585085392, -0.035728104412555695, -0.01941584050655365, -0.008565530180931091, -0.010196935385465622, -0.020869215950369835, 0.0017741264309734106, -0.032468684017658234, -0.033990729600191116, -0.0043723504059016705, -0.03788795694708824, -0.031816594302654266, -0.031126948073506355, 0.04517778754234314, -0.02670053206384182, 0.005867724306881428, -0.002523937029764056, -0.026917247101664543, -0.009939217008650303, 0.037222571671009064, 0.04717366024851799, -0.029283937066793442, 0.02368197590112686, 0.04211876168847084, -0.004775723908096552, -0.04277247190475464, -0.005309165921062231, -0.04449668899178505, 0.03525726869702339, -0.021484918892383575, -0.017246071249246597, -0.01304339524358511, -0.015669165179133415, -0.014801484532654285, 0.007935048080980778, -0.02332577481865883, 0.005155662074685097, 0.03639211878180504, -0.026825543493032455, -0.01349824108183384, -0.014720355160534382, 0.027102027088403702, 0.02600543014705181, 0.021835343912243843, 0.037035271525382996, -0.05452050268650055, -0.0510343499481678, -0.013466369360685349, 0.03185237571597099, 0.010518737137317657, -0.0033173151314258575, -0.03661609813570976, -0.01013270951807499, -0.0011010004673153162, -0.03993473947048187, -0.013966391794383526, 0.009650303050875664, 0.03901037201285362, 0.023760246112942696, -0.05943606048822403, -0.04634980112314224, -0.034440718591213226, -0.001459170482121408, -0.015620057471096516, -0.0030862856656312943, -0.04725756496191025, 0.004501110874116421, -0.02031696029007435, 0.02897637151181698, -0.0063249822705984116, -0.009109529666602612, 0.01863080821931362, 0.059432871639728546, 0.025641480460762978, -0.03525509685277939, -0.026330385357141495, -0.006867630872875452, -0.01769520342350006, -0.02950425259768963, -0.007095640525221825, 0.05156251788139343, 0.026890626177191734, 0.0492810495197773, 0.0014099633553996682, 0.01164721418172121, -0.005270109977573156, 0.022819124162197113, 0.04499733820557594, -0.034961093217134476, 0.03146654739975929, 0.05692419037222862, 0.04086478799581528, -0.02544487453997135, -0.031990304589271545, 0.0026830544229596853, -0.03128413110971451, -0.00357647892087698, -0.028904834762215614, -0.03370771184563637, -0.04828927665948868, -0.016430122777819633, 0.022461939603090286, 0.010993287898600101, 0.013919583521783352, 0.030908534303307533, 0.020399952307343483, -0.04141203686594963, 0.015525449067354202, -0.003540324280038476, 0.006264719180762768, -0.000511197664309293, 0.00411405460909009, 0.024865103885531425, 0.026634590700268745, 0.028628915548324585, -0.03796888887882233, -0.011872852221131325, 0.011679350398480892, 0.020555276423692703, 0.02634689211845398, -0.029437579214572906, 0.07076302170753479, -0.0446007214486599, -0.0643511489033699, 0.03634568676352501, 0.018143795430660248, 0.06448594480752945, 0.0004446283564902842, -0.01815825328230858, -0.024106312543153763, 0.019137941300868988, -0.02331698313355446, -0.0014475727220997214, -0.014414715580642223, -0.003058334579691291, 0.018003568053245544, -0.028963031247258186, -0.01246873289346695, -0.010446460917592049, 0.01678856462240219, 0.03420707583427429, 0.0390009768307209, -0.03557565063238144, -0.016263358294963837, 0.012210526503622532, -0.030905378982424736, 0.02866590954363346, 0.022959616035223007, 0.007187222130596638, 0.03773663938045502, 0.05160979554057121, -0.010560543276369572, 0.023688681423664093, -0.03384442627429962, -0.00019033809076063335, -0.08319370448589325, -0.07260938733816147, 0.010868384502828121, 0.03808204457163811, 0.05068988353013992, -0.016040721908211708, -0.02282729744911194, 0.04664537310600281, -0.048490509390830994, -0.0005115830572322011, 0.027081387117505074, -0.006019734311848879, -0.029882509261369705, 0.008297453634440899, -0.038999855518341064, 0.01494503952562809, 0.030838416889309883, 0.015237407758831978, 0.051466505974531174, 0.01190091297030449, -0.03140408918261528, -0.028008492663502693, 0.025296716019511223, 0.012097571976482868, -0.005539108999073505, -0.054324910044670105, 0.023937614634633064, -0.04106835275888443, -0.008057914674282074, 0.04940967634320259, 0.016185160726308823, 0.00280605792067945, -0.019243942573666573, 0.021441614255309105, 0.02087249606847763, 0.07420321553945541, 0.027985705062747, -0.004557691048830748, 0.03183622285723686, 0.02838786691427231, 0.03181667625904083, 0.020608216524124146, -0.03468957915902138, -0.0176976528018713, 0.038208894431591034, 0.010601134970784187, -0.033039357513189316, 0.01577305607497692, -0.03148440644145012, -0.0290687158703804, -0.012003419920802116, -0.034833066165447235, -0.027647871524095535, -0.024218523874878883, 0.04909539967775345, -0.04281674697995186, -0.03218470886349678, 0.010814156383275986, 0.01494916807860136, -0.0014124213485047221, -0.01760413497686386, -0.021948592737317085, -0.062340717762708664, 0.02351241745054722, 0.01463374774903059, -0.02479843981564045, -0.0072596934624016285, -0.035705190151929855, -0.010779149830341339, 0.03320939838886261, -0.014612803235650063, 0.012986667454242706, -0.06943975389003754, -0.0004583808477036655, 0.013592973351478577, 0.01049101073294878, -0.06462059170007706, 0.03154047951102257, -0.012009423226118088, -0.07787667214870453, 0.0239705853164196, 0.0029303892515599728, -0.03138525411486626, -0.01786123588681221, -0.03382847458124161, -0.03762579336762428, 0.004296786617487669, 0.018107237294316292, 0.011752857826650143, -0.002570612356066704, -0.0001400461478624493, 0.04012509807944298, 0.020526835694909096, -0.049618955701589584, 0.013753172941505909, -0.012133044190704823, -0.014080122113227844, -0.035107214003801346, 0.007764991372823715, 0.010921118780970573, -0.020466720685362816, 0.01809590496122837, 0.03944951295852661, 0.002534360159188509, -0.0016307828482240438, 0.011442888528108597, 0.04280585050582886, -0.01037244126200676, -0.024961229413747787, 0.04571235552430153, -0.02785009704530239, 0.02484886534512043, 0.030657965689897537, 0.013441206887364388, -0.05440938472747803, -0.01351500116288662, -0.058345139026641846, -0.026446569710969925, 0.009364723227918148, 0.011005730368196964, 0.019318658858537674, -0.022137802094221115, 0.04320835694670677, 0.0429997518658638, -0.025254322215914726, -0.03283937647938728, 0.00015541657921858132, 0.030521713197231293, 0.022694261744618416, -0.01939140446484089, 0.008828721009194851, -0.0019365512998774648, -0.012550105340778828, 0.04416722059249878, 0.005435537546873093, -0.0075925723649561405, -0.03392080217599869, -0.0011042463593184948, 0.01774660497903824, -0.05967756360769272, 0.012694248929619789, -0.025835402309894562, 0.022795353084802628, -0.002845220034942031, -0.04327060654759407, 0.04868356138467789, -0.021653199568390846, -0.03315532207489014, -0.0016734674572944641, -0.03973903879523277, 0.0570087693631649, 0.019082266837358475, 0.032126765698194504, -0.05706867203116417, 0.04160323366522789, -0.002972514135763049, -0.017156226560473442, 0.027208080515265465, 0.06925260275602341, -0.02826649695634842, 0.0026806232053786516, 0.009025407955050468, -0.0009043178870342672, 0.031205570325255394, -0.027612905949354172, -0.0017086606239899993, 0.0607408806681633, 0.010218256153166294, -0.02064324915409088, -0.066381074488163, 0.004076278302818537, -0.04347217082977295, 0.016040492802858353, 0.008550993166863918, 0.005136895924806595, 0.009343987330794334, -0.00906176958233118, -0.032182127237319946, 0.08794521540403366, -0.015144473873078823, -0.01279573142528534, -0.04329238086938858, -0.001229845336638391, -0.009446601383388042, -0.016502205282449722 ]
<p>In R, is it true that: </p> <p><code>pt(q,df=Inf)</code> $=$ <code>pnorm(q)</code>? </p> <p>Or in words, can I supply <code>df=Inf</code> in the cummulative t-distribution to get to the standard normal distribution function in R, as I should in theory?</p>
35,974
[ -0.03699098899960518, -0.052475541830062866, 0.01818007603287697, -0.00475347600877285, 0.021685399115085602, 0.008459740318357944, 0.00970139168202877, -0.007901377975940704, 0.02881183847784996, -0.04134872928261757, 0.009134295396506786, 0.051143232733011246, 0.05298937112092972, 0.0278544332832098, 0.04292253404855728, 0.02207159250974655, -0.043583065271377563, -0.004440369084477425, -0.008469954133033752, -0.003800681559368968, 0.004021023865789175, 0.05283298343420029, 0.0013486744137480855, -0.046432048082351685, -0.00490760151296854, 0.06749596446752548, -0.0040224227122962475, -0.012556289322674274, -0.01144123449921608, 0.06369084864854813, -0.006635782774537802, -0.026451297104358673, 0.0342559851706028, 0.037813372910022736, 0.04434860125184059, 0.012138588353991508, -0.04076279699802399, 0.0013871777337044477, -0.002912728115916252, 0.008223106153309345, -0.05622869357466698, -0.019882990047335625, -0.00018020244897343218, 0.041111063212156296, 0.027909358963370323, 0.03148556500673294, -0.016574397683143616, -0.005777015350759029, 0.0007146283751353621, -0.029360679909586906, 0.06763637065887451, 0.00747542642056942, 0.025819404050707817, 0.026380110532045364, -0.03173590451478958, -0.009000594727694988, 0.0920737162232399, 0.03955352306365967, 0.007211331278085709, -0.06721276044845581, 0.036974236369132996, -0.03302193433046341, -0.0222691148519516, -0.003658904926851392, -0.04049522429704666, -0.027444619685411453, 0.011958470568060875, -0.02831013686954975, -0.001371814520098269, -0.060563813894987106, -0.01807536371052265, 0.0409277118742466, 0.030533695593476295, -0.04084765538573265, 0.034638479351997375, -0.02281654253602028, 0.04500086233019829, -0.009302286431193352, 0.02362082339823246, 0.020854145288467407, 0.031879059970378876, 0.019340921193361282, 0.015877142548561096, 0.042073383927345276, 0.02884414978325367, 0.015747951343655586, 0.0466853566467762, -0.03405212610960007, 0.01267943624407053, 0.058721959590911865, -0.023532969877123833, 0.003139713080599904, 0.04785913601517677, -0.026570472866296768, -0.022230951115489006, 0.03696358948945999, -0.010297232307493687, 0.04891384392976761, -0.012571379542350769, -0.03218013420701027, 0.005715549923479557, -0.04574683681130409, 0.01052100770175457, 0.02006804384291172, -0.02088809944689274, -0.02844315394759178, -0.007260922808200121, -0.023295879364013672, 0.0033050368074327707, 0.000314928445732221, -0.05416923388838768, 0.025195423513650894, -0.026413483545184135, -0.016410239040851593, 0.021308356896042824, -0.04086393117904663, -0.012139396741986275, 0.0152780432254076, 0.04177471250295639, 0.0705508291721344, 0.00945117138326168, -0.0033096629194915295, 0.036179907619953156, -0.03218752145767212, -0.03807932510972023, 0.027004575356841087, 0.026171492412686348, 0.014536944217979908, -0.07008109241724014, 0.026965849101543427, -0.008433554321527481, -0.017462709918618202, 0.03381499648094177, 0.00708699319511652, 0.008748331107199192, -0.0014324334915727377, -0.08087289333343506, -0.0415361113846302, -0.0024982497561722994, -0.005113379564136267, 0.016736773774027824, -0.07424189895391464, -0.0014757418539375067, 0.016789525747299194, 0.004725371487438679, 0.017387673258781433, 0.08356193453073502, -0.03140953928232193, 0.00524548115208745, 0.009034267626702785, 0.008010740391910076, -0.030321720987558365, 0.008996511809527874, -0.06633087247610092, -0.00754638621583581, -0.10443900525569916, 0.01894565485417843, 0.017139311879873276, 0.03385080769658089, 0.002111363923177123, 0.04095251113176346, -0.04300038889050484, -0.014902493916451931, -0.02756437286734581, -0.0011623888276517391, -0.0529157817363739, 0.05750357359647751, 0.009079845622181892, 0.0361621268093586, -0.002969702472910285, 0.016734763979911804, 0.014508936554193497, -0.011412440799176693, 0.02297329716384411, 0.02808721363544464, -0.0529237762093544, 0.0029032358434051275, -0.024597229436039925, 0.06245625019073486, 0.009954496286809444, -0.02893802709877491, 0.01808939129114151, -0.0032904476393014193, 0.0015966257778927684, 0.0213946383446455, 0.03833895921707153, 0.0028446337673813105, -0.01396589633077383, 0.07050561159849167, -0.017968423664569855, -0.023373810574412346, -0.011788539588451385, 0.020070694386959076, -0.022751573473215103, -0.019772063940763474, -0.005281826481223106, 0.04301862418651581, 0.08199594914913177, 0.0010759648866951466, 0.011374043300747871, -0.018028004094958305, -0.018183229491114616, 0.04805748164653778, -0.060742780566215515, 0.014865490607917309, 0.006950846873223782, 0.04488902911543846, 0.008414260111749172, 0.028773022815585136, -0.04964730143547058, -0.0484575480222702, 0.015839699655771255, -0.05724683776497841, 0.009186440147459507, 0.008557755500078201, -0.029089201241731644, 0.013735602609813213, 0.009070060215890408, -0.008333971723914146, 0.043516263365745544, -0.05511488392949104, 0.06757380068302155, 0.052471477538347244, 0.04541458934545517, -0.021085062995553017, -0.03668924793601036, 0.003959229215979576, 0.015027741901576519, -0.005570769309997559, -0.009876365773379803, -0.03494628518819809, -0.041887033730745316, 0.058183830231428146, -0.011104119941592216, -0.03697687014937401, 0.012757129967212677, 0.03777917101979256, -0.0377998948097229, 0.02302173711359501, 0.04662230610847473, -0.0012767624575644732, -0.025260305032134056, 0.01729685626924038, 0.03659902885556221, 0.019913552328944206, 0.01596786081790924, 0.028940783813595772, -0.03566539287567139, 0.027592990547418594, -0.009575005620718002, 0.013800215907394886, 0.02869396097958088, -0.04610854759812355, -0.010797616094350815, -0.022177867591381073, -0.03181399777531624, 0.02388819120824337, -0.036263853311538696, 0.015241135843098164, 0.007428270298987627, -0.012682605534791946, -0.003322949633002281, -0.00942268781363964, -0.03525612875819206, 0.005351105239242315, 0.046055421233177185, -0.02710675820708275, -0.006406486500054598, 0.010810978710651398, -0.04051617905497551, 0.0015118109295144677, -0.021336110308766365, -0.017556484788656235, -0.04609406739473343, 0.028548141941428185, 0.021249229088425636, 0.01316140778362751, -0.0024350660387426615, -0.05845390260219574, -0.030720749869942665, -0.0016299450071528554, 0.0008128876215778291, -0.00962990801781416, -0.009165909141302109, -0.0762471929192543, -0.027322828769683838, -0.01016946230083704, -0.04037472605705261, 0.032725751399993896, -0.0117780277505517, 0.024429116398096085, -0.0014219313161447644, -0.03636033833026886, -0.04197869449853897, 0.027584722265601158, -0.02687140740454197, 0.006696739234030247, -0.0019248274620622396, -0.021562829613685608, 0.0317513532936573, 0.00210026977583766, -0.05411957949399948, -0.007869156077504158, -0.039231207221746445, -0.027293531224131584, -0.03419366851449013, -0.024317771196365356, 0.02018570341169834, -0.021463986486196518, 0.029166828840970993, 0.02456740476191044, -0.057766977697610855, -0.009184880182147026, -0.06886942684650421, -0.04149403050541878, 0.025933945551514626, 0.008294258266687393, 0.022574350237846375, 0.028732141479849815, -0.06637604534626007, 0.10201133042573929, 0.038334764540195465, -0.05468888580799103, -0.015675682574510574, -0.004333326127380133, 0.002852286444976926, -0.007762720808386803, 0.008179515600204468, 0.010464810766279697, 0.009285388514399529, 0.02695324271917343, 0.026928311213850975, 0.013129698112607002, 0.04654083028435707, 0.026797069236636162, -0.0018047795165330172, 0.025159886106848717, 0.015397779643535614, -0.015838157385587692, 0.04711250215768814, 0.041125424206256866, -0.010992621071636677, 0.015775443986058235, -0.023599615320563316, 0.0007938412600196898, 0.007644819561392069, -0.0005562023143284023, -0.0017439776565879583, 0.006186071317642927, 0.018323102965950966, -0.05012833699584007, 0.030963478609919548, 0.017108149826526642, -0.012028045952320099, -0.0030686771497130394, 0.0447436086833477, 0.03871656209230423, -0.04032688960433006, -0.024096056818962097, 0.06334731727838516, 0.03417773172259331, -0.007454202510416508, 0.012964124791324139, 0.023784641176462173, -0.03256610408425331, 0.02299346961081028, -0.028989380225539207, -0.03913116082549095, 0.054472245275974274, 0.05426826700568199, 0.0583709292113781, 0.019722893834114075, 0.023277170956134796, 0.024176396429538727, -0.08042244613170624, 0.00927967019379139, -0.01233723759651184, 0.04911099374294281, 0.03548532351851463, 0.05816388875246048, 0.05245908722281456, 0.015761861577630043, -0.00593269569799304, 0.01216453779488802, -0.05767149478197098, 0.016826342791318893, -0.003554290859028697, -0.02158113569021225, 0.011781021021306515, -0.04850982874631882, 0.04280652478337288, 0.026573708280920982, -0.004542539827525616, -0.012232264503836632, -0.013404293917119503, -0.05129672959446907, 0.01112460158765316, -0.011156623251736164, -0.06251895427703857, -0.015198243781924248, -0.0071103074587881565, 0.03701646253466606, -0.01661064475774765, 0.02598639763891697, 0.04537982866168022, 0.0058304849080741405, -0.017268052324652672, -0.018342524766921997, 0.015604582615196705, -0.0011530702468007803, 0.04610403999686241, 0.035979367792606354, 0.03145141899585724, -0.04476960748434067, 0.02209140919148922, -0.004678883124142885, 0.06286279112100601, 0.04574090987443924, -0.01750357076525688, -0.01832640916109085, -0.029552076011896133, -0.013957560993731022, 0.019830552861094475, -0.006189906969666481, -0.0009308551670983434, -0.0041067516431212425, 0.037960611283779144, 0.022467682138085365, -0.02352207899093628, 0.012132265605032444, 0.06297116726636887, 0.008144952356815338, 0.010409063659608364, -0.06149444729089737, -0.014914454892277718, -0.03384444862604141, 0.0021367210429161787, 0.02520965225994587, 0.052650924772024155, 0.016944248229265213, 0.023784799501299858, 0.032489702105522156, -0.027629289776086807, 0.009094329550862312, -0.01419768761843443, 0.012369753792881966, 0.015172540210187435, -0.03901573643088341, 0.0025330916978418827, 0.005451247561722994, 0.03687610849738121, 0.04027429595589638, 0.04071500897407532, -0.022562062367796898, -0.05904020741581917, -0.0018097453285008669, 0.033076122403144836, 0.028412340208888054, -0.020824676379561424, -0.019595637917518616, -0.02920329011976719, -0.01141891535371542, 0.03611421212553978, -0.02856047824025154, 0.021705444902181625, 0.009511071257293224, -0.018187319859862328, 0.008334769867360592, -0.029187066480517387, -0.02583373710513115, 0.02808583714067936, -0.023850832134485245, 0.005559837911278009, 0.016493702307343483, -0.04895990341901779, -0.03392777591943741, 0.02641347050666809, 0.029366130009293556, 0.032683115452528, -0.035102516412734985, -0.05144030600786209, -0.02411065623164177, 0.010631676763296127, -0.00687611335888505, -0.01945727877318859, 0.02270587906241417, -0.02963244915008545, 0.012344684451818466, 0.03916958346962929, -0.007811267860233784, -0.025527559220790863, 0.048898354172706604, 0.036379896104335785, -0.010661040432751179, 0.03402728587388992, -0.03383580595254898, 0.057806454598903656, 0.032078687101602554, -0.009018557146191597, 0.050299979746341705, 0.03637082502245903, 0.037312231957912445, -0.009687133133411407, -0.07621532678604126, 0.023245258256793022, -0.03412269800901413, -0.023776205256581306, -0.03604321926832199, -0.009972273372113705, 0.008758937008678913, 0.006591900251805782, 0.034249644726514816, -0.005961665417999029, -0.024099525064229965, -0.02021431177854538, 0.014594915322959423, 0.0010549193248152733, -0.008185064420104027, -0.004001489840447903, 0.00613022968173027, 0.026047784835100174, 0.0026457859203219414, -0.019223123788833618, -0.017825575545430183, -0.028978707268834114, 0.001007994171231985, 0.0019706874154508114, -0.005639189388602972, 0.011512089520692825, -0.004278453532606363, -0.024231374263763428, 0.024184662848711014, -0.007962088100612164, -0.0103585384786129, 0.015877490863204002, 0.016631657257676125, -0.03213540092110634, -0.019417624920606613, 0.003305746242403984, 0.017282653599977493, -0.004622998647391796, 0.0351237878203392, -0.07373784482479095, 0.06131453812122345, -0.0012439833953976631, -0.009930719621479511, -0.057618398219347, -0.0572684109210968, 0.06584649533033371, -0.01591990515589714, 0.005496372934430838, -0.062042493373155594, -0.038567494601011276, -0.026112832129001617, -0.023826664313673973, 0.006203830242156982, 0.03129403665661812, -0.020950503647327423, 0.004600015468895435, -0.025718411430716515, -0.020260663703083992, 0.08186206966638565, 0.013672471977770329, 0.026466598734259605, 0.03418874368071556, 0.003669625148177147, -0.022326435893774033, 0.010960443876683712, -0.0016273981891572475, -0.037486303597688675, 0.0021555658895522356, -0.04185664653778076, -0.016309209167957306, 0.027148982509970665, 0.006611602380871773, -0.009819719940423965, 0.022433210164308548, -0.03643488138914108, 0.012333325110375881, -0.03610578924417496, -0.033370330929756165, -0.013747093267738819, 0.010828686878085136, -0.05771161988377571, -0.008322793059051037, 0.008739758282899857, 0.02068113349378109, 0.017968274652957916, -0.018740054219961166, -0.0015153103740885854, 0.013918684795498848, 0.06296559423208237, -0.020587412640452385, 0.00697238277643919, -0.016156839206814766, -0.029263915494084358, -0.0007116046035662293, 0.0014454079791903496, -0.017974112182855606, 0.008921725675463676, 0.02464853599667549, -0.007666090968996286, -0.0016788175562396646, -0.04905662685632706, 0.004283634014427662, 0.03360443562269211, 0.0241288710385561, 0.05817347764968872, 0.039497215300798416, 0.000288458977593109, -0.035102833062410355, 0.011178155429661274, -0.028658103197813034, 0.00752930948510766, -0.004231662955135107, 0.030457140877842903, 0.016615379601716995, 0.009623893536627293, 0.04961255192756653, 0.014286099933087826, 0.001038669142872095, 0.06096701696515083, -0.0007560794474557042, 0.005145265720784664, 0.021903900429606438, -0.010692712850868702, -0.03500048443675041, 0.019131051376461983, -0.025486411526799202, 0.025636576116085052, -0.013305334374308586, -0.0090191550552845, 0.04319331794977188, 0.010863346979022026, 0.004868883173912764, -0.03994151949882507, -0.029497068375349045, 0.00009917941497405991, -0.004800505004823208, 0.00423100171610713, -0.013338795863091946, 0.02585732378065586, -0.026602469384670258, 0.04822126030921936, -0.022271059453487396, 0.015870431438088417, -0.04883361980319023, -0.07187888771295547, -0.040449582040309906, -0.03379828482866287, -0.04190768674015999, 0.02225564979016781, -0.0236495528370142, 0.01901448518037796, 0.016561001539230347, -0.0505305714905262, 0.04396744444966316, 0.007180353626608849, 0.03927875682711601, -0.027295581996440887, 0.0762711763381958, -0.011293672025203705, -0.00025053194258362055, -0.003418980399146676, -0.023765569552779198, 0.12406918406486511, 0.06253601610660553, 0.026973549276590347, -0.059208355844020844, 0.008530882187187672, 0.01629873365163803, 0.05550900101661682, -0.0005256772274151444, -0.034415096044540405, 0.02791597694158554, -0.03012748435139656, 0.04669898748397827, 0.05511075630784035, 0.03326385095715523, -0.009017917327582836, 0.053550537675619125, -0.04899429902434349, -0.009883488528430462, -0.0006784293218515813, 0.035715606063604355, 0.010056855157017708, -0.043817486613988876, -0.061742134392261505, -0.010180114768445492, 0.024081211537122726, 0.04252929240465164, -0.02962898276746273, -0.001292760600335896, -0.024921301752328873, -0.00023726772633381188, -0.015338439494371414, -0.04646647721529007, 0.026749253273010254, 0.001852482440881431, 0.03281164914369583, -0.012644746340811253, 0.018445847555994987, -0.039625007659196854, -0.012046055868268013, 0.043438903987407684, 0.02129949815571308, 0.022082600742578506, 0.012568763457238674, -0.011944754049181938, -0.04718685522675514, 0.023150460794568062, -0.01857992634177208, -0.007501984480768442, -0.054890863597393036, 0.034411780536174774, 0.006994606461375952, -0.006702305283397436, -0.007813377305865288, -0.03948105499148369, -0.011957271955907345, 0.02131258323788643, 0.013954030349850655, 0.03094342164695263, 0.01610233448445797, 0.0061177778989076614, 0.009065567515790462, 0.0018674235325306654, 0.04747258126735687, 0.03426453843712807, -0.02963983453810215, 0.02301989309489727, -0.02608834020793438, 0.0456833578646183, -0.040097497403621674, -0.012275590561330318, -0.03682320564985275, -0.021171510219573975, -0.0279596708714962, -0.03193976730108261, 0.008912676014006138, 0.008851870894432068, 0.027521228417754173, -0.008298516273498535, 0.026490913704037666, -0.008047166280448437, -0.02136318013072014, 0.027782168239355087, -0.022374877706170082, -0.015937523916363716, -0.025355743244290352, 0.01409462746232748, -0.0142948804423213, 0.06658538430929184, -0.009934656322002411, 0.06187356635928154, 0.02050330676138401, 0.06058308854699135, 0.008571702055633068, -0.04796336591243744, 0.005575925577431917, 0.025446409359574318, -0.030876632779836655, -0.0002039160899585113, 0.017329728230834007, 0.022526992484927177, 0.056651465594768524, 0.02566250041127205, -0.04074830189347267, 0.0018472940428182483, -0.0007081966614350677, -0.006417231634259224, -0.04133579134941101, -0.015992827713489532, 0.011690252460539341, 0.005930241663008928, 0.03238373249769211, -0.01586858183145523, 0.006919702049344778, -0.014925613068044186, -0.03678585961461067, 0.02036585845053196, -0.0035334427375346422, -0.0724174752831459, -0.02505534701049328, 0.019300328567624092, 0.003108751028776169, -0.015264675952494144, 0.014876823872327805, -0.04214179888367653, -0.03214521333575249, -0.00479163508862257, -0.012194907292723656, -0.02510729432106018, 0.017410775646567345, -0.026403026655316353, -0.007966980338096619, 0.0339813306927681, -0.012946197763085365, -0.026380101218819618, -0.02147660218179226, -0.01748720370233059, 0.02353012003004551, 0.044429536908864975, -0.003913106396794319, 0.024824805557727814, 0.05278276652097702, -0.03187793865799904, -0.05079665407538414, 0.023786820471286774, 0.008004385977983475, 0.031034043058753014, 0.01349411066621542, -0.0026262146420776844, 0.00953212846070528, 0.04236547648906708, -0.0008159407298080623, 0.0013583425898104906, 0.03507501259446144, -0.004805779084563255, 0.056325484067201614, -0.007912341505289078, 0.028270386159420013, 0.007388456258922815, -0.01983572170138359, 0.015179425477981567, 0.05411460995674133, -0.0038268924690783024, -0.011252188123762608, 0.015979567542672157, 0.007744502276182175, 0.03276569023728371, -0.01525304839015007, 0.003423015121370554, 0.03787904605269432, 0.037552498281002045, -0.013899813406169415, -0.00778597965836525, -0.054096780717372894, 0.0023598773404955864, -0.09796569496393204, -0.018200958147644997, 0.03781089186668396, 0.005397516302764416, 0.03519358113408089, -0.004055642522871494, 0.001265965634956956, 0.0014861521776765585, -0.05869261547923088, 0.04747379571199417, 0.005381464026868343, -0.04305298626422882, -0.042196568101644516, 0.05887999385595322, -0.027160950005054474, -0.004087047651410103, 0.053732339292764664, 0.0014594999374821782, 0.0480908565223217, 0.0127126295119524, 0.023366175591945648, 0.00240409467369318, -0.02681572735309601, -0.0008428934379480779, 0.03384579345583916, -0.03998391702771187, 0.05648374557495117, -0.04789102077484131, -0.01203384529799223, 0.0028057433664798737, -0.02477223426103592, 0.04658431559801102, -0.0319221168756485, -0.009730502963066101, 0.03021068684756756, 0.01879001408815384, 0.0358034186065197, -0.011821877211332321, -0.0163319930434227, 0.006548304110765457, 0.05699017271399498, 0.0010814504930749536, -0.04593614488840103, 0.003448597388342023, -0.004734353628009558, -0.002396484138444066, -0.02400888316333294, 0.011466511525213718, -0.018707869574427605, -0.022106343880295753, -0.02521035075187683, 0.01828736998140812, 0.02364489436149597, -0.015537077561020851, -0.011012617498636246, -0.08529804646968842, 0.017686987295746803, 0.017047343775629997, 0.009357988834381104, 0.002537128981202841, 0.009730923920869827, 0.0007330556982196867, -0.04954691231250763, 0.020168330520391464, 0.01572324149310589, -0.03487991914153099, -0.029090499505400658, 0.006484400946646929, -0.011668650433421135, 0.01945166289806366, 0.012227315455675125, -0.023611515760421753, -0.06134224310517311, 0.031344395130872726, -0.0287365410476923, 0.03261302784085274, 0.002770175924524665, 0.02422594465315342, 0.018849320709705353, -0.04986660182476044, 0.052283044904470444, -0.014813707210123539, 0.001313479500822723, -0.04415981471538544, -0.0016292459331452847, -0.02339143678545952, 0.0018099751323461533, 0.029241546988487244, 0.02857898734509945, -0.015233787707984447, -0.009707278572022915, 0.035388752818107605, 0.000049826703616417944, -0.05975368246436119, 0.01367871556431055, -0.0208931565284729, -0.037888526916503906, -0.03223114088177681, 0.04149293527007103, 0.01937142387032509, 0.0074470750987529755, -0.025553736835718155, -0.001195021322928369, 0.03674256429076195, -0.011324437335133553, -0.027090447023510933, 0.02233024314045906, 0.0036438987590372562, -0.01161876693367958, 0.053145550191402435, 0.004760580137372017, 0.018077705055475235, 0.05310241878032684, -0.019664278253912926, -0.045660071074962616, 0.011954535730183125, -0.047533076256513596, -0.06346641480922699, -0.0038749929517507553, 0.0017920351820066571, -0.0006429691566154361, -0.03887714445590973, -0.029557103291153908, 0.031658194959163666, 0.006266431882977486, -0.03337699547410011, 0.004331287927925587, 0.021898996084928513, 0.06601697951555252, -0.026200367137789726, 0.011746447533369064, -0.023576663807034492, -0.023908112198114395, 0.002520442707464099, -0.002004473702982068, 0.02664375677704811, -0.04260115325450897, 0.00882559735327959, 0.009372239001095295, -0.05339505895972252, -0.014760678634047508, 0.0021443443838506937, 0.05256325751543045, -0.04272417724132538, -0.0338011309504509, 0.024923011660575867, 0.007656584959477186, 0.03761918470263481, 0.003894006134942174, -0.04297839477658272, 0.031426627188920975, -0.02659938484430313, 0.019107777625322342, -0.034389249980449677, -0.0008568058256059885, -0.02931171841919422, 0.01711222343146801, -0.027885625138878822, 0.027943698689341545, 0.004541031084954739, -0.0037543880753219128, 0.009580619633197784, -0.005299045704305172, 0.028349146246910095, -0.03400413691997528, -0.010999954305589199, -0.0492805652320385, 0.021262671798467636, 0.01998022571206093, -0.0013218563981354237, -0.05092371627688408, -0.017737548798322678, 0.02804495021700859, 0.023229137063026428, 0.04043447598814964, -0.05056605115532875, -0.022261328995227814, 0.023086799308657646, 0.06165025755763054, -0.032108332961797714, -0.00973579753190279, -0.03771881014108658, -0.01144574023783207, 0.05412453040480614, -0.04502653703093529 ]
<p>I am not clear about how exactly the p values and t values are used. I know how to calculate them but I am not clear about the basic concept behind them.</p> <p>Any help ?</p>
49,294
[ -0.013732688501477242, -0.05294053629040718, -0.0159133393317461, -0.03387293592095375, 0.04037065804004669, 0.004233259242027998, 0.01010823342949152, 0.00466291606426239, 0.01291574165225029, -0.010534713976085186, 0.032582297921180725, 0.05220497399568558, 0.012535670772194862, 0.029415633529424667, 0.00006679879152216017, 0.0045998902060091496, -0.01224612258374691, -0.009561757557094097, 0.0009308774024248123, -0.011777753941714764, 0.012291396968066692, 0.01609819568693638, -0.00935314130038023, 0.007013756316155195, -0.027473432943224907, 0.04939104989171028, 0.0503774955868721, -0.008172906935214996, 0.03284043073654175, 0.05532708764076233, -0.03351713716983795, -0.038242243230342865, 0.02609570510685444, 0.03602733835577965, 0.023827677592635155, 0.01244870200753212, -0.0497758574783802, -0.015322856605052948, -0.028323983773589134, 0.03418285772204399, -0.005892727058380842, -0.03097892366349697, 0.002451958367601037, 0.010893543250858784, -0.011985196731984615, 0.012098946608603, -0.005698019172996283, -0.027580300346016884, 0.020448289811611176, -0.07578819990158081, 0.06548644602298737, 0.019153693690896034, 0.04116266220808029, 0.023780565708875656, -0.0187318604439497, 0.0027352566830813885, 0.08714994788169861, 0.04829594865441322, -0.03133542090654373, -0.08965562283992767, 0.013122660107910633, -0.03385757654905319, -0.005463068373501301, -0.026615964248776436, -0.01289711706340313, -0.004642678890377283, 0.0027283430099487305, -0.038277409970760345, 0.04025328904390335, -0.01928485743701458, 0.01890910044312477, 0.019642019644379616, 0.04238742217421532, -0.021198643371462822, 0.03315522521734238, -0.05629492551088333, 0.02908979542553425, -0.01403723657131195, 0.04497351124882698, 0.03066738322377205, 0.016577474772930145, 0.01201169565320015, 0.018640102818608284, 0.05751475691795349, -0.011739679612219334, -0.0054123071022331715, 0.05379261448979378, -0.0005345881218090653, 0.008431817404925823, 0.014288756996393204, -0.009622788056731224, -0.0005980923888273537, 0.04636703431606293, -0.021916378289461136, -0.03723132982850075, 0.01592906005680561, -0.021567413583397865, 0.06369351595640182, 0.0012961773900315166, 0.010942401364445686, 0.0175311416387558, -0.04138866811990738, 0.016463015228509903, 0.04111455753445625, -0.03127017244696617, -0.011278237216174603, -0.007568662986159325, -0.006572790443897247, 0.026306243613362312, -0.014793060719966888, -0.03226203843951225, 0.019371824339032173, 0.011778280138969421, -0.0063322470523417, 0.03373812511563301, -0.0219468642026186, -0.010480936616659164, -0.025856072083115578, 0.056471116840839386, 0.0209436547011137, 0.03866439685225487, -0.021885843947529793, 0.039467934519052505, 0.0005612408858723938, -0.08504465967416763, -0.006037776358425617, 0.027445629239082336, 0.0003203728992957622, -0.024797622114419937, 0.056848373264074326, -0.03503919020295143, -0.02203148603439331, 0.04353869706392288, -0.0010164187988266349, 0.0373360738158226, -0.01029867585748434, -0.07488057017326355, -0.05325569212436676, 0.018859703093767166, -0.019968440756201744, -0.016950301826000214, -0.09237710386514664, 0.001655713189393282, 0.03923581540584564, 0.02590644545853138, -0.0036950584035366774, 0.01686265878379345, -0.00349940313026309, 0.01803981512784958, 0.024427780881524086, -0.048310257494449615, -0.019988970831036568, 0.0007552261231467128, -0.01980084925889969, -0.002315481659024954, -0.08648532629013062, -0.005743673071265221, 0.02166610397398472, -0.0084129823371768, -0.00029433489544317126, 0.01937350258231163, -0.04234681650996208, -0.03596875071525574, 0.010751799680292606, -0.013347547501325607, -0.004635966848582029, 0.05457441136240959, -0.006356372497975826, 0.013879448175430298, 0.035105153918266296, -0.015617363154888153, 0.029380876570940018, 0.02769617550075054, 0.047969020903110504, -0.00029924645787104964, -0.005424358416348696, -0.015441801398992538, -0.01898689568042755, 0.014345836825668812, -0.004740199074149132, -0.040460795164108276, -0.025490086525678635, 0.01298124622553587, 0.024193625897169113, 0.020834051072597504, 0.026141107082366943, -0.004627318121492863, -0.00009739585948409513, 0.02196800522506237, -0.022188646718859673, -0.04439857602119446, -0.07557506859302521, 0.02975410409271717, -0.03201884403824806, 0.007523169741034508, 0.0137422950938344, 0.019784048199653625, 0.008158686570823193, -0.02987894043326378, -0.02014533057808876, -0.0378895178437233, 0.004509270191192627, 0.03768451139330864, -0.05462227016687393, 0.013663368299603462, 0.08477357774972916, 0.04521383345127106, 0.0016422037733718753, 0.05040918290615082, -0.04548429697751999, -0.010860612615942955, 0.004792843945324421, -0.05386127158999443, 0.0074660093523561954, -0.009983719326555729, -0.047326911240816116, -0.008970513008534908, 0.005015949252992868, 0.010690237395465374, 0.030934005975723267, -0.04048191010951996, 0.09955748915672302, 0.06012178957462311, 0.04468818008899689, -0.017415018752217293, -0.00007515503239119425, -0.011612518690526485, 0.0283167976886034, -0.020910758525133133, 0.0005097054527141154, -0.04657295346260071, 0.0071914601139724255, 0.033239662647247314, 0.00959849264472723, -0.01760544627904892, 0.009710733778774738, 0.05768990516662598, 0.020339934155344963, 0.02144039422273636, 0.04686763137578964, -0.011895760893821716, -0.013201563619077206, 0.009122950956225395, 0.0437205545604229, 0.010376740247011185, 0.014305377379059792, 0.029802167788147926, 0.006749837659299374, 0.043046120554208755, -0.007103301584720612, 0.0045738546177744865, 0.046474091708660126, -0.02179001085460186, 0.011034474708139896, -0.033540885895490646, -0.03178597614169121, 0.031704261898994446, -0.016552213579416275, 0.013289726339280605, 0.02827163226902485, -0.0005283097852952778, -0.006291508674621582, 0.0008774283924140036, -0.027238478884100914, 0.023555347695946693, 0.03164069354534149, -0.02841748110949993, -0.004252149723470211, 0.03487669304013252, -0.008959000930190086, 0.023670202121138573, 0.002039449755102396, -0.04087238013744354, -0.04873652011156082, -0.012560681439936161, -0.002667866414412856, 0.00546608492732048, 0.05789054185152054, -0.02318805456161499, -0.03832259401679039, -0.011502433568239212, -0.04022064059972763, -0.020346201956272125, -0.02714916691184044, -0.05089133605360985, 0.00445790309458971, -0.01833219826221466, -0.025727685540914536, 0.028555981814861298, -0.005279270466417074, -0.03079228103160858, 0.011857578530907631, -0.00866794865578413, -0.01461396086961031, -0.03052831068634987, -0.013603719882667065, 0.012510538101196289, -0.018825823441147804, 0.005897244904190302, 0.0298068318516016, -0.00929866824299097, -0.00481343874707818, 0.06363756209611893, -0.061957649886608124, -0.012468710541725159, -0.06232289969921112, -0.0055122035555541515, -0.012973679229617119, -0.019913220778107643, 0.010590803809463978, 0.02111237123608589, -0.0605878122150898, 0.003974746912717819, -0.044691286981105804, -0.06541097909212112, 0.010739997960627079, 0.008367427624762058, 0.031788431107997894, 0.007428241893649101, -0.04832011088728905, 0.08688724786043167, 0.024418717250227928, -0.03762476518750191, -0.029674772173166275, 0.008253432810306549, -0.03277665004134178, 0.0006719845696352422, 0.04403466358780861, 0.047772422432899475, -0.023221127688884735, 0.010249704122543335, 0.012608625926077366, 0.011328602209687233, 0.061639949679374695, 0.006747707724571228, -0.006276636850088835, 0.03089349903166294, 0.01937217265367508, -0.030798325315117836, 0.06086307764053345, 0.03892906755208969, -0.027283983305096626, 0.0256756991147995, -0.00997184682637453, 0.02901677042245865, 0.014147323556244373, -0.025648975744843483, 0.00753790233284235, 0.004758128430694342, -0.02010253816843033, -0.044675786048173904, 0.05473371967673302, -0.025208353996276855, -0.0058179316110908985, 0.004468896891921759, 0.001088363816961646, 0.04149429127573967, -0.023324301466345787, -0.018805183470249176, 0.04600512236356735, 0.06179267168045044, -0.028270041570067406, -0.02863915078341961, 0.007102672941982746, -0.0023405682295560837, 0.03179026395082474, -0.03119424730539322, -0.01536489650607109, 0.07139839977025986, 0.029423555359244347, 0.024794109165668488, -0.00613587349653244, -0.03580186143517494, -0.004992273636162281, -0.07239768654108047, 0.007158756721764803, -0.024001946672797203, 0.04973774030804634, 0.0002456234360579401, 0.09432639926671982, 0.01794985868036747, -0.0009435949614271522, 0.042028095573186874, 0.00367368059232831, -0.029077401384711266, 0.05013145133852959, -0.014463765546679497, -0.04544678330421448, -0.006644322536885738, -0.006470661610364914, 0.02674447000026703, -0.04012817144393921, 0.013306024484336376, -0.001870493870228529, 0.006536234635859728, -0.043454136699438095, -0.0017308049136772752, -0.0026296102441847324, 0.0142172547057271, -0.026938235387206078, 0.031156200915575027, 0.01586199179291725, -0.015952488407492638, 0.025327451527118683, 0.07954896986484528, -0.03197787329554558, -0.01648346334695816, -0.007690322585403919, 0.01211993582546711, 0.032943595200777054, 0.03376584127545357, 0.057944901287555695, 0.018681209534406662, -0.050916582345962524, 0.018084822222590446, -0.00772992754355073, 0.07381894439458847, 0.059549909085035324, 0.009713519364595413, -0.03581066429615021, -0.011778272688388824, -0.015048922039568424, -0.002043499145656824, 0.012668858282268047, -0.01928475685417652, -0.0032246203627437353, 0.04123985767364502, 0.015437263064086437, -0.04955189675092697, 0.026110248640179634, 0.0360802598297596, 0.01672927476465702, -0.005303172394633293, -0.044805340468883514, -0.036377303302288055, -0.031091617420315742, 0.0006471911328844726, 0.018855798989534378, 0.024958906695246696, -0.013008368201553822, 0.010220641270279884, 0.05902159959077835, -0.029791949316859245, -0.031522154808044434, -0.02817254327237606, 0.018805421888828278, 0.03702794760465622, -0.008932944387197495, -0.03449072688817978, 0.05496813729405403, 0.027227910235524178, 0.03123975358903408, 0.01650761440396309, -0.005413415376096964, -0.08511582016944885, -0.009622300043702126, 0.03315139561891556, 0.01551190298050642, -0.00732096703723073, -0.017616497352719307, -0.01799246482551098, 0.018037451431155205, 0.045677550137043, -0.03098924085497856, 0.0472492054104805, 0.022543050348758698, -0.025687362998723984, -0.017093857750296593, -0.024469833821058273, -0.04175247251987457, 0.02502557821571827, -0.040391210466623306, 0.023415323346853256, -0.0468304269015789, -0.022718461230397224, -0.04602108150720596, 0.01780865155160427, 0.010818631388247013, 0.07235418260097504, -0.04351057857275009, 0.017001139000058174, -0.011537669226527214, 0.0014213839313015342, -0.02674100734293461, -0.0486660934984684, -0.0005785822868347168, -0.0026801242493093014, 0.01426026038825512, 0.05374523252248764, 0.0015039449790492654, -0.018246490508317947, 0.03350893780589104, 0.015221895650029182, -0.006079991348087788, -0.015606542117893696, -0.024774160236120224, 0.013398279435932636, 0.01785355806350708, 0.000852951139677316, 0.061651378870010376, 0.006805875804275274, -0.00917405728250742, -0.028205102309584618, -0.03282114118337631, 0.05318119004368782, -0.0017141880234703422, 0.024177761748433113, -0.04729938134551048, -0.005868376698344946, -0.0294917244464159, 0.021296672523021698, 0.026250522583723068, -0.010039814747869968, -0.03992810472846031, -0.017255254089832306, -0.0019357993733137846, 0.011878089979290962, 0.04192613810300827, 0.007509573828428984, 0.004826140124350786, 0.015249968506395817, 0.0014873913023620844, -0.024978503584861755, 0.022407446056604385, -0.02709968015551567, 0.02496814727783203, 0.001048757811076939, -0.03605783358216286, 0.041652094572782516, -0.026133863255381584, -0.04622621461749077, 0.025689691305160522, -0.021715113893151283, 0.027086036279797554, -0.0017518241656944156, 0.009656338021159172, 0.018768778070807457, -0.03312394395470619, -0.02121385559439659, 0.017398225143551826, 0.012358549982309341, 0.07437726855278015, -0.048563893884420395, 0.06694856286048889, -0.020842943340539932, 0.017108330503106117, -0.048709169030189514, -0.021474646404385567, 0.06285400688648224, 0.013857690617442131, -0.056878745555877686, -0.02596278488636017, 0.013485967181622982, -0.01998271606862545, -0.03769081458449364, -0.016802692785859108, 0.049688827246427536, 0.005246988032013178, -0.035220276564359665, -0.0060758767649531364, 0.018799914047122, 0.07851751148700714, 0.025743918493390083, -0.0050458465702831745, 0.009529936127364635, -0.005053723696619272, -0.0051989867351949215, -0.0000750576873542741, 0.027986539527773857, -0.04293062537908554, -0.003265275387093425, -0.021544035524129868, 0.049944423139095306, 0.03734990209341049, -0.03178711235523224, 0.00990433432161808, -0.02046244964003563, 0.008891834877431393, -0.0076215541921556, -0.04243844747543335, 0.007151774130761623, -0.02623424120247364, 0.02882515639066696, -0.008171006105840206, -0.0034555341117084026, -0.0242338664829731, 0.008641721680760384, 0.007365562953054905, 0.014656673185527325, -0.01879170723259449, 0.016188278794288635, 0.07983085513114929, -0.0015968711813911796, 0.02025117538869381, -0.021998031064867973, -0.024396806955337524, 0.03239256888628006, 0.050863418728113174, -0.04798835143446922, 0.006751317996531725, 0.007783512584865093, -0.04098893329501152, 0.005537976045161486, -0.04085593670606613, -0.013807442039251328, 0.07455089688301086, -0.02277478575706482, 0.06275428831577301, 0.05378532037138939, 0.024824922904372215, -0.0034299897961318493, 0.004889757838100195, 0.0005798093043267727, 0.01271288562566042, 0.02322639897465706, 0.012566009536385536, -0.0007747267954982817, -0.014843223616480827, 0.03568679466843605, 0.013307379558682442, -0.014402482658624649, 0.011732438579201698, 0.04401801526546478, -0.018697278574109077, 0.01449719537049532, -0.04602453485131264, -0.00860138051211834, 0.04397384449839592, -0.04037472978234291, 0.017831698060035706, -0.047025952488183975, -0.0035755238495767117, 0.04674690216779709, 0.02139653079211712, -0.008522510528564453, -0.043874453753232956, -0.026459259912371635, -0.02870342694222927, -0.0016701488057151437, 0.027070948854088783, -0.04090123623609543, 0.005810994189232588, 0.028039759024977684, 0.03474831581115723, -0.008555172011256218, 0.01775464229285717, -0.020432425662875175, -0.035112831741571426, -0.035527437925338745, -0.035013165324926376, -0.06808739900588989, 0.01874341070652008, 0.006220319774001837, -0.032954104244709015, 0.018686216324567795, -0.02919202297925949, 0.026262717321515083, -0.013888812623918056, 0.05709899589419365, -0.052276868373155594, 0.09266962110996246, 0.03174153342843056, 0.001435005571693182, 0.0031111324205994606, -0.026139667257666588, 0.11332707107067108, 0.0685194730758667, 0.01687106490135193, -0.07819727808237076, 0.006914119236171246, -0.01694532297551632, 0.03741413727402687, 0.011887921020388603, 0.021732373163104057, 0.035213351249694824, -0.009292793460190296, 0.03178170695900917, 0.013027431443333626, 0.013125778175890446, -0.006462284829467535, 0.07736288011074066, -0.03648853674530983, -0.033717669546604156, -0.0019599320366978645, -0.0006850910140201449, -0.03634202480316162, -0.04388195648789406, -0.03849015384912491, 0.004422096069902182, -0.01184077374637127, -0.012261122465133667, -0.01829415000975132, -0.044621121138334274, -0.007737141102552414, -0.02456466294825077, -0.023320304229855537, -0.004700056742876768, 0.01167271751910448, 0.015956442803144455, -0.040967486798763275, 0.0008857183274812996, 0.00853997003287077, -0.020637251436710358, 0.016178565099835396, 0.06956258416175842, 0.01316807046532631, -0.023063432425260544, 0.0013993667671456933, 0.024988912045955658, -0.03736964985728264, -0.0424959622323513, -0.01051971223205328, 0.06502706557512283, -0.005967712961137295, -0.0421721525490284, -0.003189287381246686, 0.0224627573043108, 0.0012447013286873698, -0.01740894466638565, -0.036592014133930206, 0.020429518073797226, 0.007132509723305702, -0.030255548655986786, 0.010841860435903072, -0.029774386435747147, -0.002339321421459317, -0.04453658685088158, 0.03781707212328911, 0.037903089076280594, -0.023924702778458595, 0.013024182058870792, -0.03641212359070778, 0.04136256128549576, -0.039172250777482986, 0.019586889073252678, -0.021579420194029808, -0.021198386326432228, -0.028735045343637466, -0.004975142888724804, 0.014413098804652691, 0.017432421445846558, -0.016941118985414505, -0.0003898844588547945, -0.003778331447392702, -0.009923161938786507, -0.019938966259360313, 0.037702083587646484, -0.028526432812213898, -0.025864580646157265, -0.04665084555745125, -0.016604138538241386, 0.04440982639789581, 0.06245150789618492, 0.014987771399319172, 0.04467608779668808, -0.015915175899863243, 0.032014232128858566, 0.014293723739683628, -0.07090695947408676, -0.02741389535367489, 0.039043448865413666, -0.010723313316702843, -0.0040981583297252655, 0.012376662343740463, 0.06187250092625618, 0.02717474102973938, 0.028366481885313988, 0.0007005736115388572, -0.00001263767626369372, -0.01669142208993435, 0.0008932552300393581, -0.018862619996070862, -0.06440074741840363, -0.028637884184718132, 0.00039720977656543255, 0.0004599774838425219, 0.004446268547326326, -0.010429570451378822, -0.03137465566396713, -0.00238800048828125, 0.02733130194246769, 0.004794218111783266, -0.019505174830555916, 0.0034254868514835835, -0.022951681166887283, -0.00673605827614665, -0.03791315481066704, 0.03095409646630287, -0.017072416841983795, -0.01896102912724018, 0.0020673542749136686, 0.01681801863014698, -0.03294652700424194, 0.0026283718179911375, -0.020793715491890907, 0.02533765695989132, 0.05725935101509094, -0.012673421762883663, 0.007087952923029661, 0.0061105843633413315, 0.009068761020898819, -0.010150967165827751, 0.04659896343946457, -0.0003771790361497551, -0.04041411727666855, 0.0408419594168663, -0.06464322656393051, 0.002452206565067172, 0.006771516054868698, 0.002959531033411622, 0.0332106277346611, 0.010094794444739819, 0.003963562659919262, -0.010095462203025818, 0.04666103050112724, -0.026047084480524063, -0.06335076689720154, -0.009704451076686382, -0.018775805830955505, 0.0070725916884839535, 0.011821086518466473, 0.011237060651183128, -0.004613610915839672, 0.0009665362886153162, -0.00477609084919095, 0.030470555648207664, -0.012521928176283836, 0.006519377697259188, -0.00032220603316091, 0.027085112407803535, 0.010486392304301262, 0.0290373507887125, -0.031208714470267296, 0.015725279226899147, 0.05483333393931389, 0.019040197134017944, 0.03349381685256958, -0.027870269492268562, 0.02048151195049286, -0.0787380263209343, 0.002054403070360422, -0.01131468079984188, -0.03639094904065132, 0.05549614131450653, -0.047368019819259644, 0.006563802249729633, 0.03967556729912758, -0.03423142805695534, 0.044574983417987823, -0.009721632115542889, -0.009705061092972755, -0.005724063143134117, 0.0031894887797534466, 0.010291283018887043, 0.07032644003629684, 0.02987814135849476, 0.011135092005133629, 0.04512166604399681, -0.006229079328477383, -0.013135346584022045, -0.01870131865143776, 0.01704580895602703, 0.04291283339262009, 0.007528862450271845, -0.06379693001508713, 0.026766197755932808, -0.027111412957310677, -0.040612298995256424, 0.02558576688170433, -0.014460785314440727, 0.03673484921455383, 0.0030612980481237173, 0.03488747030496597, 0.0072990525513887405, 0.04816660284996033, 0.03117993287742138, 0.011823665350675583, -0.0175473690032959, 0.01433828566223383, -0.021010465919971466, 0.014720393344759941, -0.020253146067261696, 0.0006943825865164399, 0.01234440691769123, -0.050016507506370544, -0.039989572018384933, 0.00047676556278020144, -0.007624309044331312, -0.013619991950690746, 0.023721875622868538, 0.002938030054792762, 0.010077123530209064, -0.044414252042770386, 0.011447247117757797, -0.0328194797039032, -0.003008016850799322, 0.042079661041498184, 0.0010102087398990989, -0.008756004273891449, 0.02160286158323288, -0.041433095932006836, -0.0429384782910347, 0.01784815452992916, -0.003583296900615096, -0.02262144349515438, -0.061976924538612366, 0.016712969169020653, 0.01965641789138317, -0.011718692258000374, -0.04333407059311867, -0.007244414649903774, -0.0353475846350193, 0.012368137948215008, -0.010989510454237461, -0.008293233811855316, 0.009915805421769619, -0.03672405704855919, 0.008513209410011768, -0.06265123188495636, 0.07458217442035675, -0.02955387346446514, -0.01212266180664301, -0.06494857370853424, -0.0016318249981850386, -0.043157950043678284, 0.02974690869450569, 0.035936783999204636, 0.006005006842315197, -0.001521310885436833, -0.00390789145603776, -0.010600539855659008, 0.0035592650528997183, -0.109233058989048, 0.030400479212403297, -0.008639669977128506, -0.03571087867021561, -0.026220882311463356, 0.0006397793185897171, 0.0200868658721447, 0.009085523895919323, 0.02198878861963749, -0.02634620852768421, 0.018483078107237816, -0.010904600843787193, 0.012600697576999664, 0.0269320011138916, 0.0013930369168519974, -0.0042376406490802765, 0.06059328466653824, 0.0015762349357828498, 0.029926318675279617, 0.0350823812186718, 0.005347621161490679, -0.053360845893621445, 0.043607402592897415, -0.027524664998054504, -0.00950805563479662, 0.0195611584931612, -0.02204415388405323, 0.004247148521244526, -0.07108426839113235, 0.00786232016980648, 0.017448466271162033, -0.019210224971175194, -0.014871410094201565, 0.03900422528386116, 0.05455601587891579, 0.036436714231967926, -0.07539472728967667, 0.015262480825185776, -0.004652961622923613, -0.052212633192539215, -0.017016345635056496, 0.04770515859127045, 0.020484888926148415, -0.01094957534223795, 0.03441736102104187, 0.007205524016171694, -0.008252968080341816, 0.01984499767422676, 0.01540798507630825, 0.023457711562514305, -0.018959997221827507, -0.026109974831342697, 0.008562995120882988, -0.013184143230319023, 0.03731713071465492, 0.02315700612962246, -0.012811697088181973, 0.06209603697061539, -0.029740706086158752, 0.0015244695823639631, -0.017507823184132576, 0.0016919043846428394, -0.0058854613453149796, -0.016149118542671204, 0.0466218926012516, 0.006756279617547989, -0.01865541748702526, 0.014279707334935665, 0.008834640495479107, 0.0018578901654109359, 0.022886380553245544, -0.023906592279672623, 0.030753107741475105, -0.010099576786160469, -0.005486200097948313, -0.037167739123106, 0.004640202037990093, -0.047402795404195786, -0.008953345939517021, 0.007645401172339916, -0.00985810998827219, -0.0015244197566062212, -0.011320109479129314, -0.0002712662681005895, -0.010942365042865276, 0.025873059406876564, -0.049998242408037186, -0.014054629020392895, -0.05512365326285362, 0.029217705130577087, -0.0176114309579134, -0.036600735038518906 ]
<p>A typical approach to solving a classification problem is to identify a class of candidate models, and then perform model selection using some procedure like cross validation. Typically one selects the model with the highest accuracy, or some related function that encodes problem specific information, like <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F1_score" rel="nofollow">$\text{F}_\beta$</a>. </p> <p>Assuming the end goal is to produce an accurate classifier (where the definition of accuracy is again, problem dependent), in what situations is it better to perform model selection using a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scoring_rule" rel="nofollow">proper scoring rule</a> as opposed to something improper, like accuracy, precision, recall, etc? Furthermore, let's ignore issues of model complexity and assume a priori we consider all the models equally likely.</p> <p>Previously I would have said never. We know, in a formal sense, classification is an easier problem than regression [1], [2] and we can derive tighter bounds for the former than the later ($*$). Furthermore, there are cases when trying to accurately match probabilities can result in incorrect <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/50325/6248">decision boundaries</a> or <a href="http://yaroslavvb.blogspot.com/2007/06/log-loss-or-hinge-loss.html" rel="nofollow">overfitting</a>. However, based on the conversation <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/90705/6248">here</a> and the voting pattern of the community in regards to such issues, I've been questioning this view.</p> <ol> <li>Devroye, Luc. <a href="http://www.szit.bme.hu/~gyorfi/pbook.pdf" rel="nofollow">A probabilistic theory of pattern recognition.</a> Vol. 31. springer, 1996., Section 6.7</li> <li>Kearns, Michael J., and Robert E. Schapire. <a href="http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~mkearns/papers/pconcepts.pdf" rel="nofollow">Efficient distribution-free learning of probabilistic concepts.</a> Foundations of Computer Science, 1990. Proceedings., 31st Annual Symposium on. IEEE, 1990.</li> </ol> <p>$(*)$ This statement might be a little sloppy. I specifically mean that given labeled data of the form $S = \{(x_1, y_1), \ldots, (x_n, y_n)\}$ with $x_i \in \mathcal{X}$ and $y_i \in \{1, \ldots, K\}$, it seems to be easier to estimate a decision boundary than accurately estimate conditional probabilities.</p>
28,579
[ -0.040069833397865295, -0.011128890328109264, -0.02138596959412098, -0.03437480330467224, 0.03281968832015991, 0.02018677070736885, -0.020547043532133102, 0.010760997422039509, 0.0411868691444397, -0.0009040736476890743, 0.010962073691189289, 0.013090853579342365, 0.055681366473436356, 0.04318145662546158, 0.007715864107012749, 0.012640956789255142, 0.01540069654583931, 0.0042784977704286575, -0.03444020450115204, -0.00028615997871384025, 0.02127487026154995, 0.0160786472260952, 0.004657515790313482, -0.018834475427865982, -0.019518069922924042, 0.03602013736963272, 0.04445551335811615, -0.01100756973028183, -0.005528694484382868, 0.036380864679813385, -0.03414544090628624, 0.023522548377513885, 0.006459785625338554, 0.05802856385707855, 0.02184920944273472, 0.010018357075750828, 0.014190912246704102, 0.0011173938401043415, -0.019910506904125214, 0.02328459918498993, -0.006576955784112215, -0.018170924857258797, 0.015701133757829666, 0.03860480338335037, -0.0008348007104359567, 0.00862825196236372, -0.03181489557027817, -0.021489251405000687, 0.004768806509673595, -0.030407926067709923, 0.028554430231451988, -0.011747212149202824, 0.02479911409318447, 0.027240239083766937, -0.006703228689730167, -0.03510598838329315, 0.05391281470656395, 0.10567646473646164, -0.030388040468096733, -0.036596041172742844, -0.047577206045389175, -0.01945854350924492, 0.02739456109702587, -0.030404092743992805, -0.02562521956861019, 0.042880505323410034, 0.006072998512536287, -0.010868147946894169, 0.04867773503065109, -0.011116641573607922, -0.019699562340974808, -0.006328066345304251, 0.018410230055451393, -0.0023651982191950083, 0.048456449061632156, -0.0127517469227314, 0.006512488704174757, 0.05736464262008667, 0.02854948677122593, 0.038127437233924866, 0.016198722645640373, 0.0024049757048487663, 0.05407975986599922, 0.033385150134563446, 0.010855094529688358, -0.010571879334747791, 0.05331621691584587, -0.023277707397937775, 0.00372820976190269, 0.0006052113021723926, -0.019337769597768784, -0.021993400529026985, 0.03846251964569092, -0.033466558903455734, -0.00048121166764758527, 0.059522517025470734, -0.006795716937631369, 0.014760884456336498, 0.04578489810228348, -0.026718663051724434, -0.017919115722179413, -0.03039509989321232, -0.00664193881675601, 0.062456488609313965, -0.03695265203714371, -0.01147359050810337, -0.03652719780802727, -0.04141317680478096, -0.017878107726573944, -0.049334000796079636, -0.024718668311834335, 0.04204053431749344, -0.01982923224568367, 0.01740480400621891, 0.020540066063404083, -0.0015098468866199255, 0.0019519244087859988, -0.03442568704485893, 0.0680277943611145, 0.027848651632666588, 0.043279457837343216, -0.0368008017539978, -0.020236216485500336, -0.02866150625050068, -0.00987289845943451, -0.023690929636359215, 0.0359693318605423, 0.019898956641554832, -0.011574137955904007, 0.012984695844352245, -0.005195158533751965, -0.016359971836209297, 0.026702243834733963, -0.020312555134296417, -0.00474539352580905, -0.005025363061577082, -0.07963357865810394, -0.025364072993397713, 0.0526004284620285, 0.027168188244104385, -0.010959155857563019, -0.05052344873547554, -0.05428197607398033, 0.025017503648996353, 0.04875437542796135, 0.040598317980766296, 0.05971232056617737, 0.022620050236582756, 0.054973430931568146, -0.040261927992105484, 0.0031792395748198032, -0.023445531725883484, -0.01662934012711048, -0.012311936356127262, -0.03201202675700188, -0.06621795147657394, 0.0011637373827397823, -0.020023010671138763, -0.02210480347275734, -0.003826027736067772, 0.02290818840265274, -0.006866858806461096, -0.009189126081764698, -0.022037215530872345, 0.015926524996757507, 0.0009764909045770764, 0.03985994681715965, 0.0009862129809334874, 0.06031174957752228, 0.0340157151222229, -0.04061216488480568, 0.014483543112874031, 0.013819143176078796, 0.027595335617661476, 0.07026474177837372, -0.017946891486644745, -0.012701816856861115, -0.042412225157022476, 0.018358198925852776, -0.0243208110332489, -0.03175764158368111, -0.024127958342432976, -0.019938934594392776, 0.018027812242507935, 0.011582435108721256, 0.04342464730143547, 0.026461876928806305, -0.01518398616462946, 0.06132351607084274, -0.036883823573589325, -0.05147980898618698, -0.03586171567440033, -0.012436870485544205, -0.02306116558611393, -0.0028338280972093344, 0.051500916481018066, -0.018031226471066475, -0.015703925862908363, -0.01823105663061142, 0.0027429182082414627, -0.0539461225271225, 0.023125912994146347, 0.04138151928782463, -0.041509754955768585, 0.01120815984904766, 0.053270820528268814, 0.016421521082520485, -0.04596667364239693, 0.04503125697374344, -0.040435854345560074, -0.07816599309444427, -0.02048663981258869, -0.02870423160493374, 0.005862434394657612, -0.03758310154080391, -0.03394262120127678, 0.028217459097504616, -0.016785776242613792, -0.018009936437010765, 0.025219159200787544, -0.056002192199230194, 0.05772559717297554, 0.05018078163266182, 0.013312466442584991, -0.016682617366313934, 0.01663598045706749, -0.016882743686437607, 0.022412650287151337, -0.03672875836491585, 0.0030571268871426582, -0.07208777964115143, -0.014701955951750278, 0.05436912178993225, 0.025555677711963654, -0.03940804675221443, 0.003217705525457859, 0.03359416127204895, 0.0029261817689985037, -0.007027825340628624, 0.013308661058545113, -0.020410342141985893, -0.030128533020615578, -0.008607239462435246, 0.027376485988497734, -0.014142757281661034, 0.005488556809723377, 0.027734952047467232, -0.009552066214382648, 0.02365255542099476, -0.019256174564361572, -0.000722752243746072, 0.056166160851716995, -0.0006916518905200064, -0.007008818909525871, 0.03217954561114311, -0.010937326587736607, 0.026453498750925064, -0.02157120779156685, 0.024680254980921745, 0.016584429889917374, 0.01387705747038126, 0.028826190158724785, 0.014192038215696812, -0.0062791029922664165, 0.03934196010231972, 0.03618975728750229, -0.02472667023539543, -0.01493066269904375, 0.03390036150813103, -0.05028459429740906, 0.0026861599180847406, -0.02218734659254551, -0.037802666425704956, -0.003515587653964758, 0.007031964138150215, 0.0024580489844083786, -0.00199028174392879, 0.006851091515272856, -0.013029079884290695, -0.003226639935746789, 0.0031417219433933496, -0.02880813367664814, 0.04387568682432175, 0.012590835802257061, -0.04911850765347481, -0.03135252743959427, -0.058653440326452255, 0.002563304966315627, 0.012860163114964962, -0.010780136100947857, -0.029790399596095085, -0.022399108856916428, 0.023818237707018852, -0.05357817932963371, -0.039690207690000534, -0.019170057028532028, 0.018498824909329414, -0.019570153206586838, -0.026994753628969193, 0.012169623747467995, 0.0027197804301977158, -0.09926281869411469, 0.0676705539226532, -0.021039551123976707, -0.06378156691789627, -0.025211116299033165, -0.004205753095448017, 0.0039006629958748817, -0.004789275582879782, 0.03668998181819916, 0.027526073157787323, -0.003016349859535694, -0.009856401942670345, -0.08295828849077225, -0.0484689436852932, 0.029868939891457558, -0.037464406341314316, 0.04000060632824898, 0.022221030667424202, -0.004571464844048023, 0.07086913287639618, 0.05800262838602066, -0.02724515274167061, -0.006923761684447527, 0.02378891035914421, -0.030307507142424583, -0.0017121921991929412, 0.017911497503519058, 0.016014782711863518, 0.0035036993212997913, 0.023805037140846252, -0.002361952792853117, 0.02195281721651554, 0.028595246374607086, -0.012744972482323647, 0.023646041750907898, 0.012014404870569706, 0.007238582707941532, -0.012358972802758217, 0.023397883400321007, 0.00002987178049806971, 0.009130618534982204, 0.03415490314364433, -0.019684841856360435, 0.0019231174373999238, 0.04822639748454094, -0.03342346101999283, 0.02310032956302166, -0.03892068564891815, 0.014299698173999786, -0.02287921868264675, 0.01418430358171463, 0.020107917487621307, -0.02777266502380371, 0.000012217228686495218, 0.01169899944216013, 0.029635416343808174, -0.01798519305884838, -0.0037010519299656153, 0.039031121879816055, 0.04884440079331398, 0.02692723646759987, -0.013960828073322773, -0.02416522428393364, -0.027829326689243317, 0.01966698281466961, -0.0029412375297397375, -0.013522597961127758, 0.03227924183011055, 0.057279329746961594, -0.0053875502198934555, -0.0022832502145320177, -0.019756795838475227, -0.018290353938937187, -0.05675949528813362, -0.018704550340771675, -0.04361122474074364, 0.049456529319286346, 0.008719358593225479, -0.002200472867116332, -0.007385047618299723, -0.03968151658773422, -0.002466053469106555, 0.029460694640874863, -0.05068863928318024, 0.01382962055504322, -0.012033343315124512, 0.01268649660050869, -0.03156905993819237, -0.05655096471309662, 0.05260615423321724, -0.017644640058279037, 0.018472259864211082, -0.031900327652692795, 0.050450123846530914, -0.03189240023493767, 0.0040098149329423904, -0.010547850281000137, -0.03662526607513428, -0.013841924257576466, 0.012964552268385887, 0.0180937722325325, 0.007302696816623211, 0.039781756699085236, 0.02514645643532276, 0.0020667409989982843, -0.02649456076323986, -0.0016303237061947584, 0.03466394171118736, 0.022831901907920837, 0.02950347401201725, 0.010315386578440666, 0.034061841666698456, -0.0661555603146553, 0.01946166716516018, -0.011133872903883457, 0.020896611735224724, 0.04086494818329811, -0.024840325117111206, -0.036236196756362915, -0.046928007155656815, -0.03471941500902176, 0.013031124137341976, 0.03551411256194115, -0.03052785061299801, 0.0011104620061814785, 0.054572612047195435, -0.006914286874234676, -0.0389249287545681, 0.00654678326100111, 0.06385131925344467, -0.00045590687659569085, -0.0029003717936575413, -0.015347657725214958, 0.0010078789200633764, 0.012426722794771194, -0.0007873513968661427, 0.007763603702187538, 0.007754283491522074, 0.0011501306435093284, -0.01943616196513176, 0.052488405257463455, -0.013348840177059174, -0.06325797736644745, -0.0017413493478670716, 0.0450921431183815, 0.00801575742661953, 0.0331125371158123, -0.05724652484059334, -0.01781497523188591, 0.06583119183778763, 0.07019536197185516, 0.027047468349337578, 0.028459865599870682, -0.06388441473245621, -0.031310029327869415, 0.0626717060804367, 0.024233000352978706, -0.05120661109685898, -0.017145469784736633, -0.027288109064102173, -0.009531835094094276, 0.024064339697360992, -0.023763488978147507, 0.035628944635391235, -0.02853904291987419, 0.013844974339008331, -0.03024924360215664, -0.03345382586121559, -0.051246870309114456, 0.012977991253137589, 0.028716066852211952, 0.040011338889598846, -0.035140637308359146, 0.0013813385739922523, -0.04641356319189072, -0.007555586285889149, 0.028037896379828453, 0.04115884751081467, -0.04078773036599159, -0.02406863495707512, 0.024692967534065247, -0.004057409707456827, -0.010072044096887112, -0.06767392158508301, -0.031197333708405495, 0.0027059882413595915, -0.02104581519961357, 0.006061180029064417, 0.009162439964711666, -0.046149250119924545, 0.024111980572342873, 0.013288174755871296, -0.03221869096159935, 0.016567278653383255, 0.004355237353593111, 0.04034609720110893, 0.03729523345828056, 0.020577872171998024, 0.06744284182786942, 0.052835121750831604, 0.01591351442039013, -0.00007464194641215727, -0.03862786293029785, -0.03220997750759125, -0.015286821871995926, -0.02335677295923233, -0.019090306013822556, -0.009657279588282108, -0.02909231185913086, -0.003278713673353195, -0.0063694496639072895, 0.028836704790592194, -0.0014499911339953542, -0.032993584871292114, -0.030719293281435966, -0.006813444197177887, -0.03394318372011185, 0.0077793532982468605, 0.015162036754190922, 0.03574959561228752, -0.029719719663262367, 0.026133762672543526, 0.02851976454257965, 0.014499982818961143, 0.02858131192624569, 0.036808162927627563, -0.04294979199767113, -0.0028628173749893904, -0.02205035649240017, -0.016215678304433823, 0.002533779013901949, -0.020344341173768044, 0.06657605618238449, 0.027289869263768196, 0.01979268714785576, -0.012711857445538044, -0.04154453054070473, -0.04675893485546112, 0.011536777019500732, 0.012005885131657124, 0.029017746448516846, -0.020335258916020393, 0.017611609771847725, -0.021407710388302803, -0.005176958627998829, -0.04167618975043297, -0.006083695683628321, 0.015817562118172646, 0.018870534375309944, -0.042667265981435776, -0.012101378291845322, 0.03539402037858963, -0.007965044118463993, -0.017215369269251823, -0.02114441804587841, 0.04395762085914612, -0.02467440813779831, -0.01472710631787777, 0.014851823449134827, 0.011550018563866615, 0.07442492991685867, 0.002797989873215556, 0.03313697129487991, 0.024507202208042145, -0.009315015748143196, -0.006007511634379625, 0.019905826076865196, 0.0023487473372370005, -0.043838150799274445, -0.010090303607285023, -0.02128307707607746, -0.0018571116961538792, 0.03225063160061836, 0.009952902793884277, -0.024716699495911598, 0.017277831211686134, -0.017810029909014702, -0.0032023333478718996, -0.01023906096816063, 0.03558103367686272, -0.00425882451236248, 0.0005562419537454844, -0.02088143117725849, 0.01790452003479004, 0.030793657526373863, -0.001825234154239297, 0.0321262925863266, -0.026319781318306923, -0.022043097764253616, 0.00867549516260624, 0.043814484030008316, -0.04314716160297394, 0.02109619788825512, 0.011876339092850685, -0.02990869991481304, 0.06484410166740417, -0.022049086168408394, 0.020611045882105827, -0.002256350126117468, 0.055795781314373016, -0.007982185110449791, -0.04892862215638161, -0.03744598478078842, -0.010537692345678806, 0.037523116916418076, 0.011108053848147392, 0.03130374103784561, 0.029536359012126923, 0.021138088777661324, -0.022284692153334618, -0.08196885138750076, -0.018702711910009384, -0.02496524713933468, 0.024456815794110298, 0.04364348575472832, -0.031039386987686157, -0.008959685452282429, 0.03869757056236267, -0.028267081826925278, 0.015271085314452648, 0.03028564527630806, -0.005642978474497795, 0.02407102659344673, 0.017920779064297676, -0.05968857556581497, -0.054389894008636475, 0.015503715723752975, -0.055948302149772644, -0.007663934491574764, 0.0009650794672779739, -0.0546836331486702, 0.03166377171874046, 0.025181885808706284, 0.024097977206110954, -0.03691583499312401, 0.015734771266579628, -0.06231427192687988, 0.016100630164146423, 0.010323060676455498, -0.01663585752248764, 0.04727386683225632, -0.032716792076826096, 0.020072277635335922, 0.009215611033141613, 0.03639434278011322, -0.013856210745871067, -0.08095015585422516, -0.024312922731041908, -0.009255844168365002, -0.07232542335987091, 0.014752838760614395, 0.01284908689558506, -0.06659090518951416, 0.011464099399745464, -0.018491435796022415, 0.006186876446008682, 0.0034266673028469086, 0.021552959457039833, -0.04162389039993286, 0.02877158485352993, -0.011361661367118359, 0.002299367683008313, 0.0169183649122715, -0.013827725313603878, 0.13269665837287903, 0.0822051465511322, 0.061418138444423676, -0.03416392207145691, 0.03752703592181206, 0.0037007969804108143, 0.004634200129657984, -0.05016740411520004, 0.010728062130510807, 0.03359336033463478, -0.004633132368326187, 0.02188190072774887, 0.04693673923611641, 0.023067818954586983, -0.03389295935630798, 0.07643590867519379, -0.037315212190151215, 0.011463207192718983, 0.02122998796403408, 0.02073870785534382, 0.024075822904706, 0.017673658207058907, 0.013881108723580837, -0.011099823750555515, 0.024760592728853226, -0.025887930765748024, 0.011758344247937202, -0.003224165178835392, -0.0013490956043824553, -0.015154276043176651, 0.00033414954668842256, 0.009101532399654388, 0.014169329777359962, 0.01904350146651268, -0.039495799690485, -0.0030772448517382145, -0.0246613509953022, -0.042774371802806854, 0.012164261192083359, 0.011464334093034267, -0.006542727816849947, -0.004832705948501825, 0.020362183451652527, -0.0022706252057105303, -0.0730660930275917, -0.031860996037721634, -0.0675537958741188, 0.026456039398908615, 0.002200045855715871, 0.01349536795169115, 0.004163113422691822, -0.02587985247373581, 0.03388363495469093, -0.02404956892132759, -0.016329806298017502, 0.021547188982367516, 0.03915613144636154, -0.012135623022913933, -0.03966006264090538, -0.027108697220683098, 0.047855544835329056, -0.0013692323118448257, 0.016723234206438065, 0.005742230452597141, -0.05292636528611183, -0.03238873556256294, -0.005776297766715288, 0.017170675098896027, 0.04565462842583656, 0.013165859505534172, -0.001949900295585394, 0.02312145009636879, -0.03741796314716339, -0.018694603815674782, 0.013336023315787315, 0.02741154655814171, 0.04000147432088852, 0.019530901685357094, 0.012545018456876278, -0.02666248381137848, -0.05302714556455612, 0.0012662239605560899, -0.028791038319468498, 0.0028330401983112097, -0.06764713674783707, 0.016685981303453445, 0.0025050435215234756, 0.024903154000639915, 0.03665965795516968, 0.0030200323089957237, 0.013958331197500229, 0.02298559434711933, -0.011672609485685825, -0.03980667516589165, 0.015829313546419144, 0.009165641851723194, -0.05263056233525276, 0.038719292730093, 0.004079601261764765, 0.054211489856243134, 0.03252020850777626, 0.03165668249130249, -0.0029583622235804796, 0.01920483633875847, 0.010810399428009987, 0.01486952044069767, -0.0017891026800498366, -0.045232273638248444, -0.005694672465324402, -0.021280184388160706, 0.02972208335995674, -0.04579291120171547, -0.037682436406612396, -0.04769204929471016, -0.037533238530159, 0.03516160696744919, -0.013836250640451908, -0.04076138883829117, 0.021752459928393364, -0.023712074384093285, 0.0348098948597908, -0.03870604187250137, -0.015712281689047813, 0.0030022922437638044, -0.010651461780071259, -0.04852701723575592, -0.026427188888192177, 0.013173664920032024, 0.0054046595469117165, -0.0021029955241829157, -0.016489064320921898, 0.056061096489429474, 0.03125513345003128, -0.004088886082172394, 0.0010280454298481345, 0.021308565512299538, -0.015983369201421738, 0.0510074645280838, -0.009660846553742886, 0.01784118264913559, 0.02337123267352581, -0.05360616371035576, -0.054379794746637344, 0.02082667127251625, -0.004534400999546051, 0.02349608577787876, 0.016949376091361046, 0.0009363577119074762, -0.01676693931221962, 0.023572666570544243, -0.02115601673722267, -0.016426801681518555, 0.011330641806125641, 0.020418506115674973, 0.011845744214951992, 0.012823684141039848, 0.01031212043017149, 0.02944214455783367, 0.011762456968426704, -0.018413495272397995, 0.0249245036393404, 0.0006671276059933007, -0.04143867641687393, 0.0171244777739048, -0.03980625793337822, 0.027156008407473564, -0.018016671761870384, 0.011323796585202217, 0.0010622558183968067, 0.03798486664891243, -0.013683268800377846, 0.04941682890057564, 0.029736192896962166, 0.008213528431952, -0.0993754044175148, -0.05296442285180092, 0.04651711881160736, 0.06157586723566055, 0.03110952116549015, -0.050348762422800064, 0.027777215465903282, 0.015613837167620659, -0.05561445653438568, 0.01272720005363226, 0.0025343105662614107, 0.026738155633211136, -0.031098973006010056, -0.0034094129223376513, -0.05781247839331627, -0.0038947018329054117, 0.018524425104260445, 0.017408188432455063, 0.021003013476729393, 0.04908204823732376, -0.022904176265001297, -0.008275090716779232, -0.008450107648968697, 0.040652330964803696, -0.021691182628273964, -0.06603659689426422, 0.0611705482006073, -0.025244133546948433, -0.038734715431928635, 0.017563918605446815, 0.02155303955078125, 0.02234303392469883, 0.0452241487801075, 0.016444392502307892, 0.029810765758156776, 0.001417931285686791, 0.05238623172044754, -0.045999638736248016, -0.02649795264005661, 0.04130968451499939, 0.013030247762799263, 0.020427651703357697, -0.0029327315278351307, 0.0012612189166247845, 0.0023083894047886133, -0.008853747509419918, -0.05651746317744255, -0.0019810365047305822, -0.008137132041156292, -0.013631924986839294, -0.008400684222579002, -0.01593055948615074, -0.022147798910737038, -0.01010312233120203, -0.0255537498742342, -0.02053326740860939, 0.02220890298485756, 0.04004446417093277, 0.03339836746454239, -0.007287007290869951, 0.017879856750369072, -0.023614551872015, -0.06049598380923271, 0.03806360810995102, -0.017253313213586807, -0.0029049008153378963, -0.062412187457084656, 0.0033076643012464046, 0.013081985525786877, -0.033042632043361664, -0.03118393011391163, -0.012848736718297005, -0.03140079975128174, 0.04972846060991287, -0.042072877287864685, 0.03945041447877884, 0.015666063874959946, -0.054450374096632004, 0.023126959800720215, -0.1270095258951187, 0.07052390277385712, -0.02313252165913582, -0.010637412779033184, -0.017155960202217102, 0.01728462614119053, -0.007459304295480251, -0.007243826519697905, 0.06844159960746765, -0.002141577424481511, 0.013292855583131313, -0.019457457587122917, 0.02867341786623001, -0.009886613115668297, -0.02558220364153385, 0.047522109001874924, -0.02667517587542534, -0.003187525784596801, -0.018784740939736366, -0.02331714518368244, -0.013120387680828571, 0.016021044924855232, 0.048661813139915466, -0.004296685103327036, 0.002496082102879882, 0.029589474201202393, -0.004322091117501259, 0.06397587060928345, 0.00039264289080165327, 0.0422375425696373, 0.04331737384200096, 0.030580589547753334, 0.01907130889594555, 0.014914081431925297, -0.025026898831129074, -0.03096696175634861, 0.006982267368584871, -0.022852720692753792, -0.039155084639787674, 0.004884141962975264, 0.037495069205760956, -0.008822819218039513, -0.04905976727604866, -0.001747550442814827, 0.05757517367601395, -0.009183375164866447, -0.013645756058394909, 0.010427967645227909, -0.013035486452281475, 0.05013146623969078, -0.017493123188614845, 0.039940495043992996, 0.01847590133547783, -0.016546590253710747, 0.006006267387419939, -0.018275940790772438, 0.07691919803619385, -0.00823474582284689, 0.03622135519981384, 0.020873362198472023, 0.02216457575559616, 0.015588076785206795, 0.008254941552877426, 0.0454849973320961, -0.029718581587076187, 0.00296687800437212, 0.03837768733501434, -0.009764597751200199, -0.006812391337007284, 0.008591189049184322, -0.026820598170161247, 0.07939226180315018, -0.023813234642148018, -0.005443144124001265, -0.03962365910410881, -0.041212767362594604, -0.007596448063850403, -0.010911528952419758, -0.006951641757041216, 0.02197451703250408, 0.011042888276278973, 0.024696677923202515, -0.012654528021812439, 0.034841835498809814, 0.028119027614593506, 0.011829935945570469, 0.026665987446904182, 0.014750810340046883, 0.007186311297118664, -0.02665887214243412, 0.0021478706039488316, -0.004839948378503323, -0.01329732034355402, 0.026404516771435738, 0.049307093024253845, 0.018230333924293518, -0.01058192178606987, -0.025530081242322922, -0.027350222691893578, 0.047636568546295166, -0.04916703701019287, 0.008261878974735737, -0.04655440151691437, 0.011113660410046577, 0.0010624349815770984, -0.028171321377158165 ]
<p>I have data that looks like this </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/2CdaI.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I just want to predict the rest of 2013. What is the best way of doing this. </p> <p>I used Excel's Forecast formula which uses linear regression. </p> <p>I only have minor/very little knowledge in stats.</p>
140
[ -0.0036551537923514843, -0.05529674142599106, -0.012353071011602879, 0.015479170717298985, 0.04960062354803085, 0.009588086977601051, -0.0054137385450303555, -0.017657997086644173, 0.03340283781290054, -0.015499292872846127, 0.03512317314743996, 0.04055693745613098, 0.0060647716745734215, 0.013801860623061657, 0.008745476603507996, 0.024007432162761688, -0.0036534969694912434, 0.0008168371277861297, -0.030561283230781555, -0.0032499937806278467, 0.0023848051205277443, -0.014290664345026016, -0.021499695256352425, 0.014044602401554585, -0.046057429164648056, 0.06893253326416016, 0.05508372187614441, 0.005556138698011637, 0.037563033401966095, 0.0466177873313427, -0.0023601881694048643, -0.04386965557932854, 0.03942754492163658, 0.04831443727016449, 0.028329821303486824, 0.0038533031474798918, 0.0054625533521175385, -0.03735945001244545, 0.01422970276325941, 0.03207140415906906, -0.026342744007706642, -0.011495126411318779, 0.0007746787741780281, 0.03551812097430229, -0.039626844227313995, 0.014579295180737972, -0.021367868408560753, -0.03891471028327942, 0.045705027878284454, -0.04636668786406517, 0.07775377482175827, -0.000014182717677613255, 0.044315584003925323, 0.052354950457811356, -0.010328046977519989, -0.021071193739771843, 0.03559060022234917, 0.09029573202133179, 0.012843546457588673, -0.042168885469436646, 0.01950717344880104, -0.01305400487035513, -0.026720719411969185, -0.027433212846517563, -0.038486868143081665, 0.029637398198246956, -0.02791893482208252, 0.008579202927649021, 0.013054423965513706, -0.006967312190681696, 0.016778411343693733, 0.005979700013995171, 0.04850465804338455, -0.008959410712122917, 0.015909599140286446, -0.052542585879564285, 0.010675094090402126, 0.021613750606775284, 0.025583572685718536, 0.027765654027462006, 0.01618529111146927, 0.034134745597839355, 0.038376227021217346, 0.02164449542760849, 0.02641880512237549, 0.008347621187567711, 0.07152938097715378, -0.01430461648851633, 0.003064712742343545, 0.05141441896557808, -0.033678505569696426, 0.0031633777543902397, 0.055735327303409576, -0.013060479424893856, -0.03221968933939934, 0.023355161771178246, -0.026119543239474297, 0.04064672812819481, 0.006321181543171406, -0.01170607004314661, 0.019272224977612495, 0.00976601429283619, -0.023183539509773254, 0.05359652638435364, -0.022746114060282707, -0.03872010484337807, -0.044956907629966736, -0.026481157168745995, 0.013109846971929073, -0.051496703177690506, -0.021463152021169662, 0.028477683663368225, 0.0034981081262230873, -0.0261481124907732, 0.00651152990758419, -0.018671346828341484, -0.004544753581285477, -0.0221254825592041, 0.002076963195577264, 0.0471893735229969, 0.0011283739004284143, -0.03843727335333824, 0.03920905664563179, -0.045510198920965195, -0.017585666850209236, 0.02673201635479927, -0.022196471691131592, -0.025519652292132378, -0.028226973488926888, 0.055269915610551834, -0.02235211618244648, -0.03249760717153549, 0.0372680127620697, 0.010020504705607891, 0.031517915427684784, 0.023625249043107033, -0.07584796100854874, -0.02625841647386551, 0.0462677888572216, -0.013946887105703354, 0.019751591607928276, -0.03829894959926605, -0.006925409659743309, -0.008903274312615395, 0.037545815110206604, 0.017736978828907013, 0.047668375074863434, 0.041727788746356964, 0.012854231521487236, -0.00787605531513691, -0.027148371562361717, -0.012551449239253998, -0.011801189742982388, -0.03301751986145973, 0.010924932546913624, -0.06872332096099854, 0.0005854868213646114, 0.010403327643871307, 0.011310216039419174, -0.01018128264695406, 0.052281662821769714, 0.016807297244668007, -0.02623762935400009, -0.003881721757352352, 0.02319118194282055, -0.04737474396824837, 0.07841485738754272, 0.010529856197535992, 0.010055916383862495, 0.028707917779684067, -0.004694333299994469, 0.017960306257009506, 0.030615894123911858, 0.022618088871240616, 0.049248047173023224, 0.024851493537425995, 0.00021771917818114161, -0.0088632358238101, -0.018535101786255836, -0.03332042694091797, -0.049151767045259476, -0.04132102429866791, 0.006194934248924255, -0.006121527403593063, 0.03131360933184624, 0.07849622517824173, 0.015486223623156548, -0.016219407320022583, 0.042677536606788635, -0.031854450702667236, -0.04428687319159508, -0.05325961858034134, -0.006452762987464666, -0.01657233014702797, -0.00337115372531116, -0.0070239282213151455, 0.008097969926893711, 0.050383273512125015, -0.007867949083447456, -0.006265383679419756, -0.020197579637169838, 0.016130365431308746, 0.04935329034924507, -0.03542003035545349, -0.009211111813783646, 0.07244614511728287, 0.053783174604177475, -0.02137753553688526, 0.013109988532960415, -0.07699880748987198, -0.021204916760325432, 0.013529255986213684, -0.04179537668824196, 0.019043194130063057, -0.022925574332475662, -0.02373376674950123, 0.03293421491980553, 0.026858197525143623, -0.00759986974298954, 0.011146443895995617, -0.017072832211852074, 0.055408816784620285, 0.053155481815338135, 0.0033979015424847603, 0.014541413635015488, -0.035478852689266205, 0.018032319843769073, 0.033216461539268494, -0.04374409466981888, -0.02161392755806446, -0.031896546483039856, 0.0124557139351964, 0.02687087655067444, -0.0006890753866173327, -0.023299328982830048, 0.02779177390038967, 0.05760111287236214, -0.0006204884266480803, 0.026454733684659004, 0.02621304616332054, -0.02265634387731552, 0.02277679182589054, -0.0156718660145998, -0.019032254815101624, -0.01307152770459652, -0.0002573601668700576, 0.03194298967719078, 0.021652348339557648, 0.01907009445130825, 0.006719827186316252, -0.02084646373987198, 0.07898944616317749, 0.009496822021901608, 0.014611305668950081, -0.011626014485955238, -0.03449006378650665, 0.04378056526184082, -0.03072356805205345, -0.03424052521586418, 0.030774086713790894, 0.005028903484344482, -0.029295485466718674, 0.009707685559988022, -0.03315575420856476, -0.0002432878245599568, 0.06037919595837593, -0.04655081778764725, -0.01937326043844223, 0.016031183302402496, -0.019428329542279243, 0.04615027830004692, -0.011636764742434025, -0.014811339788138866, -0.041560057550668716, 0.0018369322642683983, 0.05862254276871681, 0.005007381550967693, -0.004629380535334349, 0.0008120666025206447, -0.05643324553966522, 0.021818045526742935, -0.02735750935971737, -0.011526198126375675, -0.0016485163941979408, -0.041820425540208817, -0.019065437838435173, -0.013990157283842564, -0.0394953116774559, 0.03959827125072479, 0.012503329664468765, 0.00039859526441432536, 0.03860056772828102, -0.0322808139026165, -0.04454859346151352, -0.06347218155860901, -0.023025166243314743, 0.013743880204856396, -0.01653462089598179, -0.04626656696200371, 0.050822317600250244, 0.0019922328647226095, 0.003527385648339987, -0.013182162307202816, -0.044257186353206635, 0.0056342193856835365, -0.019902843981981277, 0.000746891659218818, -0.019238756969571114, -0.023789452388882637, 0.03221936151385307, -0.004645905923098326, 0.0050559439696371555, 0.005830453708767891, -0.07070400565862656, -0.02517971210181713, 0.030315209180116653, 0.012634971179068089, 0.013480671681463718, 0.004665988497436047, -0.02781614102423191, 0.048476506024599075, 0.001123244408518076, -0.002628438174724579, -0.032044753432273865, -0.021380314603447914, -0.016670353710651398, -0.039926934987306595, 0.03289822116494179, 0.023329908028244972, 0.0019186956342309713, -0.010306520387530327, -0.030725693330168724, 0.006192693021148443, 0.024013156071305275, 0.02996615134179592, 0.007731616962701082, 0.0013945348327979445, -0.008711769245564938, 0.0001999082596739754, 0.023239178583025932, 0.01471331249922514, -0.02173263020813465, -0.0005525523447431624, -0.0055135986767709255, 0.017790449783205986, 0.020587805658578873, -0.06549757719039917, -0.00881215836852789, -0.045356761664152145, 0.0386926494538784, -0.04111812636256218, 0.03669457882642746, -0.00346201891079545, -0.01026180386543274, -0.006032588426023722, -0.026814382523298264, 0.03150075674057007, 0.02893073670566082, 0.019038863480091095, 0.05599156767129898, 0.014403525739908218, -0.029386255890130997, -0.002813712228089571, -0.03013814426958561, -0.006304970011115074, 0.018314726650714874, 0.017585333436727524, -0.012908200733363628, 0.0679287314414978, 0.04303307458758354, 0.023393264040350914, 0.021758193150162697, -0.04579637199640274, 0.00669685797765851, -0.04426814243197441, 0.004362587351351976, -0.022396666929125786, 0.053428053855895996, -0.007745278067886829, 0.032940205186605453, 0.02784070186316967, 0.009412526153028011, 0.0819886103272438, 0.021174825727939606, -0.0763208419084549, 0.05749395117163658, 0.03351712226867676, 0.007299472112208605, -0.01659492589533329, -0.006725642364472151, 0.021625787019729614, -0.018980029970407486, 0.029542965814471245, -0.005707892123609781, -0.013012888841331005, -0.026041844859719276, -0.0006272216560319066, 0.002701057121157646, 0.04075593501329422, -0.021573735401034355, -0.005322923883795738, 0.01286214217543602, -0.006088970694690943, 0.029019851237535477, 0.04162715747952461, -0.005877739749848843, -0.05081966891884804, 0.013186805881559849, 0.008654570206999779, 0.043872397392988205, 0.0020208721980452538, 0.0036882178392261267, -0.01278203446418047, -0.04476241022348404, 0.03346572816371918, -0.006740046665072441, 0.015226881951093674, -0.004483967088162899, 0.01455151941627264, -0.019029604271054268, -0.031881507486104965, 0.0275574978441, 0.011094068177044392, -0.002650747075676918, 0.017680585384368896, 0.033473048359155655, 0.05358920246362686, 0.002817299449816346, -0.07287668436765671, 0.032891061156988144, 0.0919443890452385, -0.002974183764308691, 0.02069409191608429, -0.014195156283676624, 0.010285308584570885, -0.004202628508210182, -0.02489425614476204, 0.038379501551389694, -0.01921236328780651, 0.01086839847266674, 0.023176953196525574, 0.025580696761608124, -0.022216904908418655, -0.033305179327726364, -0.0031709338072687387, -0.012216687202453613, 0.059235621243715286, 0.0034541108179837465, -0.06381141394376755, 0.02463669329881668, 0.060358285903930664, 0.03627270832657814, 0.01494537852704525, 0.03398962318897247, -0.1310483068227768, -0.008952565491199493, 0.04683384671807289, 0.05153440684080124, -0.06672178953886032, -0.027013231068849564, -0.06494452059268951, -0.0439654104411602, 0.04230456426739693, -0.04493078216910362, 0.019240645691752434, 0.007577721960842609, -0.003892549080774188, -0.0051857829093933105, -0.045235611498355865, -0.05668137967586517, 0.0029080433305352926, -0.00949493981897831, 0.05410649627447128, 0.006464061792939901, -0.009931664913892746, -0.04113313555717468, -0.010208435356616974, 0.03139456361532211, 0.033924832940101624, -0.0036070116329938173, 0.0030223566573113203, 0.012101786211133003, 0.014987057074904442, -0.018120674416422844, -0.0349968746304512, -0.0217629075050354, 0.009861391969025135, -0.0412786565721035, 0.05280681326985359, -0.024024536833167076, -0.04886768385767937, -0.006749194581061602, 0.004698717966675758, -0.014801005832850933, -0.03985992819070816, -0.03081003576517105, -0.011652729474008083, 0.00403220159932971, -0.008928155526518822, 0.0629638135433197, 0.06794554740190506, 0.009834595955908298, -0.000950862537138164, -0.03525124862790108, 0.016693584620952606, 0.0021282373927533627, -0.04257272556424141, -0.01573699340224266, -0.031365785747766495, -0.03604263812303543, 0.0010433380957692862, -0.021522238850593567, 0.04413507878780365, -0.02187291719019413, -0.03188346326351166, -0.004932701122015715, 0.029882291331887245, 0.012687643989920616, 0.010758600197732449, 0.0021464237943291664, -0.005745261907577515, -0.01602131873369217, -0.019311055541038513, 0.00009255865006707609, 0.01421826146543026, 0.025377551093697548, 0.027130048722028732, -0.04571004956960678, 0.020405543968081474, -0.01203475333750248, -0.02098703570663929, -0.008181151933968067, -0.023824460804462433, 0.027042459696531296, -0.0035524622071534395, 0.015465977601706982, 0.011182270012795925, -0.05435919016599655, 0.008028536103665829, 0.02068544179201126, -0.0038530416786670685, 0.055047955363988876, -0.00039072605432011187, 0.033754613250494, 0.0050927200354635715, -0.022454306483268738, -0.04685022309422493, -0.08828456699848175, 0.0059113213792443275, 0.021968044340610504, -0.04021059349179268, -0.03157561644911766, 0.027161715552210808, -0.05505964159965515, -0.0021213972941040993, -0.046586763113737106, 0.022719083353877068, -0.025312894955277443, -0.021386774256825447, 0.019216718152165413, -0.010823973454535007, 0.07916092127561569, 0.011451901867985725, -0.0026039951480925083, 0.007814537733793259, -0.023842403665184975, -0.03150375559926033, -0.04097514599561691, 0.03132458031177521, -0.04266788065433502, 0.00354010914452374, -0.026342492550611496, -0.014531654305756092, 0.06974314153194427, -0.020782597362995148, 0.013835742138326168, 0.002555348677560687, 0.048735082149505615, -0.012875191867351532, -0.05413856729865074, 0.008042441681027412, 0.008182886056602001, -0.018121883273124695, -0.04256801679730415, 0.012626411393284798, -0.018551450222730637, -0.010685605928301811, 0.009380502626299858, 0.006346896290779114, 0.027861038222908974, 0.011592421680688858, 0.04117007181048393, 0.022153040394186974, 0.009746003895998001, -0.007708647754043341, -0.02451857551932335, 0.010534955188632011, 0.04905830696225166, 0.021960487589240074, 0.04155803844332695, 0.03194942697882652, -0.04922286421060562, -0.04625283554196358, -0.04553041234612465, -0.006326115690171719, 0.047064151614904404, -0.02605207823216915, 0.02656261995434761, 0.03274766728281975, 0.039075665175914764, 0.017069706693291664, -0.057598505169153214, 0.0070090508088469505, 0.006776395253837109, -0.014469468966126442, 0.04984125867486, 0.013703356496989727, 0.022320572286844254, 0.006753191351890564, -0.021045785397291183, 0.0031520742923021317, 0.058103758841753006, 0.040675535798072815, 0.023502644151449203, -0.0033006772864609957, -0.019935637712478638, -0.0285895224660635, 0.010779190808534622, -0.02418682537972927, 0.021345345303416252, -0.03372513875365257, -0.010570059530436993, 0.029398398473858833, 0.02290157601237297, 0.010499143041670322, -0.052441228181123734, -0.01557105127722025, -0.05576859042048454, 0.0060859122313559055, 0.03834525868296623, -0.008888153359293938, 0.035844024270772934, 0.027725910767912865, 0.05285973474383354, 0.009812995791435242, 0.014606970362365246, -0.037937287241220474, -0.08209963142871857, 0.002961787860840559, -0.02624882012605667, -0.035451699048280716, 0.0091311726719141, 0.0024435652885586023, 0.0025514825247228146, -0.008467772975564003, -0.0019239694811403751, -0.007157851941883564, -0.01248322706669569, 0.06335372477769852, 0.021704604849219322, 0.07978282123804092, 0.001939375069923699, -0.027076708152890205, 0.0014234158443287015, 0.008435297757387161, 0.11605238169431686, 0.08184023946523666, 0.02646186761558056, -0.0694989264011383, 0.02880854532122612, 0.007066607940942049, -0.012357082217931747, -0.05117685720324516, 0.0021927431225776672, -0.022373251616954803, -0.02631751447916031, 0.052106935530900955, 0.04819830134510994, -0.01627102494239807, 0.015230481512844563, 0.04309634119272232, -0.009955160319805145, -0.00047874951269477606, -0.01033457089215517, 0.0003978634485974908, -0.00501996511593461, 0.006191857159137726, -0.09759150445461273, 0.04038575664162636, -0.04639255627989769, -0.03189500793814659, -0.033066533505916595, -0.01293538510799408, -0.0006558856111951172, 0.003870895365253091, -0.03192497044801712, -0.005254907067865133, 0.00837001483887434, 0.03952726349234581, -0.0025083136279135942, -0.003865861799567938, 0.010019354522228241, -0.047800227999687195, 0.037588365375995636, 0.011410367675125599, -0.010749610140919685, -0.0032096849754452705, -0.010178891941905022, -0.026680810377001762, -0.02125447988510132, 0.007256195414811373, -0.04675011336803436, 0.05467856675386429, 0.02136184088885784, -0.025574930012226105, -0.022326746955513954, 0.03140886500477791, -0.016281163319945335, -0.025481658056378365, 0.010694297961890697, 0.02543056011199951, 0.03165186196565628, -0.040910154581069946, -0.034941814839839935, -0.03323888033628464, -0.04006803780794144, -0.007911390624940395, 0.024568060413002968, 0.036592885851860046, 0.003935458604246378, 0.007830092683434486, -0.05331696942448616, 0.03827102109789848, 0.005275938659906387, 0.015393550507724285, 0.0021012446377426386, -0.006770335603505373, -0.03112032078206539, -0.019116491079330444, 0.028432805091142654, -0.021052604541182518, -0.012068276293575764, 0.0010322248563170433, 0.025324882939457893, -0.01980418711900711, -0.05435711890459061, 0.030572690069675446, 0.009908836334943771, 0.008946816436946392, -0.036731090396642685, 0.02015010081231594, 0.02785714715719223, 0.052506763488054276, -0.017180608585476875, -0.0011698012240231037, 0.015394922345876694, 0.06478015333414078, 0.015601009130477905, -0.046255797147750854, -0.022286968305706978, -0.03302767872810364, -0.03810103237628937, 0.03286955505609512, -0.005134256090968847, 0.0797748938202858, 0.020116545259952545, 0.0034303083084523678, -0.01571914181113243, 0.017769627273082733, -0.025632139295339584, 0.03985867276787758, -0.019830049946904182, -0.055067989975214005, -0.014215980656445026, -0.008410335518419743, -0.019581301137804985, -0.02730904147028923, -0.02162323333323002, 0.004249997437000275, -0.02311098203063011, 0.02460862137377262, -0.02257978543639183, -0.040296316146850586, 0.05689115822315216, 0.0045027099549770355, 0.02935243956744671, -0.036781929433345795, 0.0033888639882206917, -0.04924728721380234, 0.0033547584898769855, -0.005694100633263588, -0.049216900020837784, -0.0033644833602011204, 0.03728977590799332, -0.007969868369400501, 0.0049941702745854855, 0.07071057707071304, -0.004394773859530687, 0.011251096613705158, -0.023873694241046906, 0.03888203203678131, -0.0388505756855011, 0.06701706349849701, -0.0341450534760952, -0.03458646312355995, 0.03487853705883026, -0.03347444534301758, -0.02249741740524769, -0.002190997125580907, -0.00006048689829185605, 0.059387654066085815, 0.010989665053784847, 0.007091202773153782, -0.0019028817769140005, 0.023749198764562607, -0.0024593728594481945, 0.0073436712846159935, -0.02313344180583954, 0.0015961481258273125, 0.031655412167310715, 0.032168906182050705, -0.005591355264186859, 0.005204578395932913, -0.03327678516507149, -0.004367433022707701, 0.055288247764110565, 0.01706021837890148, -0.034183796495199203, -0.009725101292133331, 0.01087475661188364, 0.011862198822200298, -0.00369174568913877, -0.0026652526576071978, 0.041579317301511765, 0.042429592460393906, -0.03876152262091637, 0.01572260446846485, -0.01154263410717249, -0.017865275964140892, -0.06111050024628639, -0.029179971665143967, 0.026651067659258842, -0.03652534633874893, 0.025552304461598396, -0.028596343472599983, -0.017005223780870438, 0.041204530745744705, -0.007859583012759686, -0.0009776445804163814, 0.021569732576608658, 0.009707153774797916, -0.019239287823438644, 0.00248690671287477, 0.002173857530578971, 0.017348848283290863, 0.04955552518367767, 0.06227317079901695, 0.010210419073700905, 0.03491063788533211, 0.027989789843559265, -0.04485601559281349, 0.013605072163045406, 0.012992520816624165, 0.03601071611046791, -0.03775602951645851, 0.02505645342171192, -0.02698049508035183, -0.018644262105226517, 0.05805731192231178, -0.04294652119278908, 0.045585040003061295, 0.01293147448450327, -0.011049867607653141, -0.04730790853500366, 0.037228554487228394, 0.009248859249055386, -0.041367992758750916, 0.029871491715312004, 0.004417374264448881, 0.014053269289433956, 0.04425886645913124, 0.033423442393541336, 0.010699773207306862, -0.02504434995353222, -0.013029517605900764, -0.03415779024362564, -0.007312926463782787, -0.006726996507495642, 0.011834092438220978, 0.017379872500896454, -0.007786167785525322, -0.0022355145774781704, -0.03484364226460457, 0.012126206420361996, 0.0007042394718155265, 0.01771250180900097, 0.05046673119068146, 0.019981607794761658, -0.016892695799469948, 0.006126114167273045, -0.008345928974449635, -0.03431743010878563, 0.030739611014723778, -0.0010427183005958796, -0.010368535295128822, -0.040840305387973785, 0.011258590035140514, 0.028321342542767525, -0.012061010114848614, -0.054262757301330566, -0.008657763712108135, -0.04342024028301239, 0.042889028787612915, 0.011068237945437431, 0.021667195484042168, 0.03580817952752113, -0.023222196847200394, -0.000948101922404021, -0.06527616083621979, 0.06785202771425247, 0.0031110416166484356, -0.02244727872312069, -0.013245941139757633, -0.0220223069190979, -0.029102962464094162, -0.021527089178562164, 0.06374650448560715, -0.00853979866951704, 0.02962651476264, -0.02940882369875908, 0.0058162701316177845, 0.001068117213435471, -0.04034042730927467, 0.010123233310878277, -0.04219627380371094, -0.013852777890861034, -0.03643510490655899, -0.0037063199561089277, 0.012044738978147507, -0.023437893018126488, -0.015277665108442307, -0.003201946383342147, 0.029024705290794373, 0.025333808735013008, -0.002324625849723816, 0.012384854257106781, 0.023608708754181862, -0.038024794310331345, 0.058484483510255814, -0.014751031994819641, -0.009418558329343796, 0.030088424682617188, 0.010686040855944157, -0.04740824177861214, 0.027407806366682053, -0.05960544943809509, -0.004714569076895714, -0.022447897121310234, -0.015524978749454021, -0.01392182894051075, -0.05783173814415932, 0.009526955895125866, 0.02977665141224861, 0.01087592076510191, 0.023278551176190376, 0.029361238703131676, -0.011303583160042763, 0.03330457583069801, -0.02438250184059143, 0.04106280952692032, 0.017332278192043304, -0.012514258734881878, -0.0013232940109446645, -0.020891409367322922, 0.011739406734704971, -0.005963198374956846, 0.03091820888221264, 0.04736470431089401, 0.04030037671327591, 0.019459564238786697, -0.006091419607400894, 0.029033686965703964, -0.03279499709606171, 0.0007261363789439201, -0.004624968394637108, -0.020290886983275414, 0.016601737588644028, 0.01990063488483429, 0.013269327580928802, 0.02475523017346859, -0.0713086873292923, -0.017136529088020325, -0.047678858041763306, -0.04146618768572807, -0.043594229966402054, 0.019935615360736847, -0.006906303111463785, 0.01698114536702633, -0.019955236464738846, 0.0147345419973135, 0.018823113292455673, 0.020228851586580276, 0.02923695184290409, 0.009964590892195702, 0.023641614243388176, -0.03965103626251221, -0.02293352596461773, -0.014374235644936562, -0.023576155304908752, -0.02478889189660549, -0.02439042739570141, 0.027169721201062202, 0.054938606917858124, -0.004402834456413984, 0.008100920356810093, 0.0019652917981147766, -0.01462149154394865, 0.008808714337646961, -0.06176616623997688, -0.028712568804621696, -0.0801558569073677, 0.011774305254220963, -0.009288007393479347, -0.036114487797021866 ]
<p>I have a situation where I want to test for differences between rows and columns in my data frame:</p> <pre><code> ID Cond1A Cond1B Cond2A Cond2B Sample1 2000 2311 2323 2324 Sample2 2424 1313 2324 4546 Sample3 1213 3413 2342 3353 </code></pre> <p>How do I test if Sample1 is different from Sample 2 and 3 across Condition 1 and 2 (where A and B are replicates). I prefer to do it in R, but really don't find a good way.</p>
73,575
[ -0.028842110186815262, -0.010008936747908592, -0.02057681791484356, 0.01977366767823696, 0.01143506821244955, -0.001840507728047669, 0.002723932499065995, 0.001340270391665399, 0.013167131692171097, 0.012967047281563282, 0.03444749489426613, 0.03685929253697395, 0.05354120582342148, 0.003976157866418362, 0.05134982988238335, 0.009880454279482365, 0.022974098101258278, -0.012601269409060478, -0.012191306799650192, 0.020355982705950737, -0.004420035053044558, -0.023963328450918198, 0.007838565856218338, 0.008622676134109497, 0.0005481991684064269, 0.03233456239104271, 0.07223343104124069, 0.0002919226244557649, 0.015168635174632072, 0.048173706978559494, -0.08576606959104538, -0.02601100690662861, 0.002699709264561534, 0.04278099909424782, 0.006588638760149479, 0.024812299758195877, -0.010724532417953014, -0.047818657010793686, -0.00931998249143362, 0.016476236283779144, -0.01730794832110405, 0.011299161240458488, -0.007823959924280643, 0.0384896881878376, -0.011705332435667515, 0.03481611609458923, 0.013318879529833794, 0.025698989629745483, -0.0030784294940531254, -0.03325860574841499, 0.08137593418359756, -0.02189633809030056, 0.05818469449877739, 0.015281584113836288, -0.04125673323869705, 0.009187908843159676, 0.03437815234065056, 0.04159680753946304, -0.01994749903678894, -0.05444062873721123, -0.036727115511894226, -0.0521082729101181, 0.03268343210220337, 0.006099169608205557, -0.05261431261897087, 0.01983959972858429, -0.01587159000337124, -0.04046295955777168, 0.012308190576732159, -0.03125419840216637, 0.0043702442198991776, 0.023197589442133904, 0.011440022848546505, -0.0204880703240633, -0.014426645822823048, -0.031160391867160797, 0.010819452814757824, -0.0038873152807354927, 0.038585495203733444, 0.04445478320121765, -0.03052719309926033, 0.026914730668067932, 0.0033457160461694, 0.02611839398741722, 0.05982302874326706, -0.02384953573346138, 0.048872727900743484, -0.03078039363026619, -0.00004718641866929829, 0.027924973517656326, -0.0030696941539645195, -0.01973145268857479, 0.04183273762464523, 0.03131873533129692, -0.03578581288456917, 0.014987345784902573, -0.010986072942614555, 0.021585676819086075, -0.011914700269699097, -0.002881465945392847, -0.0221537034958601, -0.05334286391735077, 0.05393797904253006, 0.011548694223165512, -0.02129642479121685, 0.003978925757110119, -0.019505197182297707, -0.03559298440814018, -0.0065112849697470665, 0.028170431032776833, 0.025153659284114838, 0.02524997480213642, 0.014597639441490173, 0.0006869504577480257, 0.02344481088221073, -0.04196974262595177, -0.022221000865101814, 0.025300273671746254, 0.05961852893233299, 0.06821930408477783, 0.05475344508886337, -0.024740375578403473, 0.03994344547390938, -0.04107514023780823, -0.045622289180755615, 0.002017203252762556, 0.019961941987276077, -0.012293025851249695, -0.02531891129910946, 0.057392917573451996, -0.04787240922451019, -0.029615366831421852, 0.008428056724369526, -0.017757462337613106, 0.05533984676003456, 0.009897984564304352, -0.07834631949663162, -0.05772779509425163, 0.04908723756670952, -0.020989572629332542, -0.018339529633522034, -0.016790522262454033, 0.040281567722558975, 0.012644686736166477, 0.02834104374051094, 0.02758597955107689, 0.036751650273799896, 0.007127111777663231, -0.034017164260149, 0.0404750220477581, -0.026227358728647232, -0.017764698714017868, 0.007384541444480419, 0.010264239273965359, -0.018247665837407112, -0.038195978850126266, -0.0015670194989070296, 0.0075365775264799595, -0.012428912334144115, 0.029065942391753197, 0.050293076783418655, -0.005451389122754335, 0.006102246232330799, -0.00008981919381767511, -0.02277117781341076, -0.03723132982850075, 0.0583062581717968, -0.01886497437953949, 0.008669234812259674, 0.03220393881201744, -0.03195329010486603, 0.012779949232935905, -0.03165365383028984, 0.019589466974139214, 0.06057901680469513, -0.0030513678211718798, -0.0020960248075425625, -0.006523185409605503, 0.03623463213443756, 0.008484414778649807, -0.024245750159025192, -0.01015095878392458, -0.0019700254779309034, -0.0269609522074461, 0.004699556156992912, 0.02377062290906906, -0.002269621007144451, -0.007003910839557648, 0.038737643510103226, -0.04005173221230507, -0.025047997012734413, -0.062049780040979385, 0.012873772531747818, 0.013980694115161896, -0.054097943007946014, -0.006143327336758375, 0.0289390217512846, 0.006938517559319735, 0.014475291594862938, -0.026927564293146133, -0.04530211165547371, -0.008163881488144398, 0.014436225406825542, -0.035378240048885345, -0.030465684831142426, 0.012801376171410084, 0.0419413186609745, -0.025120651349425316, 0.06845174729824066, -0.01352474745362997, -0.025186121463775635, 0.02276461198925972, -0.036356255412101746, -0.007144625298678875, 0.01881064660847187, -0.008179775439202785, 0.022993559017777443, 0.0264979787170887, -0.050409719347953796, 0.037666141986846924, -0.058836571872234344, 0.02193555235862732, 0.05203636735677719, 0.0655326321721077, 0.008055105805397034, -0.0686769038438797, 0.01797211356461048, 0.005154088139533997, -0.00896406639367342, -0.024115411564707756, -0.04156041890382767, 0.009113348089158535, 0.017163481563329697, -0.03088061325252056, -0.01072732638567686, -0.0007420618203468621, 0.06580133736133575, -0.016959695145487785, -0.008940077386796474, 0.03669317439198494, -0.007353533059358597, -0.024577245116233826, -0.006245865486562252, -0.010540932416915894, 0.05253312364220619, 0.011636326089501381, 0.024621402844786644, 0.03187912330031395, 0.08139023184776306, 0.012377219274640083, 0.005238570272922516, 0.006954337935894728, -0.006138246972113848, -0.022660527378320694, 0.017863977700471878, -0.030923491343855858, 0.014718348160386086, 0.02444777823984623, 0.014179266057908535, 0.015359765850007534, 0.01616206206381321, -0.013980366289615631, 0.007718183100223541, -0.020058412104845047, 0.012390034273266792, 0.053396813571453094, -0.04730924591422081, -0.000918372708838433, 0.030733196064829826, -0.054299261420965195, 0.02214415743947029, 0.007762777619063854, -0.0313568152487278, -0.06863834708929062, 0.01670778915286064, 0.014409714378416538, -0.02356053702533245, 0.03457793965935707, -0.02723015286028385, -0.0035115208011120558, 0.010974258184432983, -0.037870898842811584, 0.012108010239899158, -0.04430533945560455, -0.03366890549659729, 0.007567661814391613, -0.030030803754925728, -0.0173190888017416, 0.034014005213975906, 0.00820180308073759, -0.021481463685631752, 0.026870878413319588, 0.01902913488447666, -0.022620586678385735, 0.017556821927428246, -0.042860254645347595, 0.023846490308642387, -0.0012143555795773864, -0.0048952242359519005, 0.05019377917051315, 0.009158218279480934, -0.061465322971343994, 0.002269207267090678, -0.054662711918354034, 0.0024132663384079933, -0.0306317750364542, 0.005200638435781002, 0.032585225999355316, -0.01913670264184475, -0.010965104214847088, 0.06462560594081879, -0.005308591760694981, -0.009965894743800163, -0.03991303592920303, -0.05740281939506531, -0.004542432259768248, 0.03977346792817116, 0.018428707495331764, 0.008275849744677544, -0.037594325840473175, 0.056059829890728, 0.03367668762803078, -0.027705181390047073, -0.053924839943647385, -0.008105750195682049, -0.08355274796485901, -0.05694623664021492, 0.012031315825879574, -0.00967811793088913, 0.016918733716011047, 0.023174718022346497, 0.017002485692501068, 0.04180794209241867, 0.03452087193727493, -0.010104455053806305, -0.018772263079881668, 0.007335827685892582, 0.03668218106031418, -0.027210520580410957, 0.0352882519364357, 0.008578518405556679, -0.021421073004603386, 0.010753646492958069, 0.012325131334364414, 0.02134968340396881, -0.015841824933886528, -0.032129935920238495, 0.002632411429658532, -0.00867706723511219, 0.04635760933160782, -0.01579996384680271, 0.03091939352452755, 0.0031834347173571587, 0.009047308936715126, 0.0166874248534441, 0.04234210029244423, 0.029758881777524948, -0.012805812992155552, -0.006568457931280136, 0.049581483006477356, 0.021032370626926422, -0.04411937668919563, 0.05103142186999321, -0.023026593029499054, -0.013224627822637558, -0.015394868329167366, -0.040743689984083176, -0.04134970158338547, 0.06097906455397606, 0.03575363755226135, 0.017772838473320007, 0.025266475975513458, -0.02570497989654541, -0.004460782278329134, -0.040206510573625565, 0.03539283201098442, 0.005092567764222622, 0.05139746144413948, 0.022274024784564972, 0.08601421862840652, 0.047123391181230545, 0.000553770165424794, 0.012022918090224266, -0.007066934369504452, -0.0627349466085434, 0.038421399891376495, -0.0042175306007266045, 0.009867182932794094, -0.014454387128353119, -0.03493392840027809, 0.011222361586987972, -0.0041296761482954025, 0.0239245668053627, 0.02455979771912098, -0.01248188503086567, -0.03186037018895149, -0.003387624863535166, 0.007824479602277279, 0.02010851353406906, -0.013506727293133736, 0.0377814806997776, 0.03147159516811371, 0.018074674531817436, 0.061277203261852264, 0.012873655185103416, -0.03733908012509346, 0.0036684884689748287, 0.012681631371378899, 0.013771899044513702, 0.00020059641974512488, 0.04664560407400131, 0.009892432950437069, -0.0009179878979921341, -0.02329862304031849, 0.010369219817221165, -0.0064017013646662235, 0.042803648859262466, 0.052780333906412125, -0.002902650274336338, -0.013589968904852867, -0.019743574783205986, 0.006207211408764124, -0.020181987434625626, 0.0097428597509861, -0.00027751506422646344, -0.008392183110117912, 0.021452439948916435, 0.05887351185083389, -0.03484322875738144, 0.008869906887412071, 0.10297994315624237, 0.016109609976410866, -0.01639888435602188, -0.018067220225930214, -0.031256239861249924, -0.016223110258579254, -0.014401158317923546, 0.02403998002409935, 0.015713529661297798, 0.00010856377048185095, 0.008908022195100784, 0.01114102452993393, -0.02428578771650791, -0.02870296500623226, 0.02456670068204403, -0.007290705572813749, 0.02634984813630581, -0.023159096017479897, -0.031471677124500275, 0.018295446410775185, 0.034993089735507965, 0.0063294232822954655, 0.028402676805853844, -0.004477843642234802, -0.10221032053232193, -0.0085023557767272, 0.053579844534397125, 0.04545766860246658, -0.052434198558330536, -0.07651414722204208, -0.05277193337678909, 0.013383476063609123, 0.06757745891809464, -0.06997253745794296, 0.02317642606794834, -0.029430262744426727, 0.020980900153517723, -0.051169831305742264, -0.007077170070260763, -0.014387638308107853, 0.03262634575366974, -0.025646982714533806, 0.006447494495660067, 0.006383259780704975, -0.030004069209098816, -0.03889329358935356, -0.015569585375487804, -0.003073745174333453, 0.046172577887773514, -0.08215209096670151, -0.005786360707134008, 0.012431222945451736, 0.007814745418727398, -0.032045766711235046, -0.03399863839149475, 0.001699492335319519, 0.004860629327595234, -0.014316952787339687, 0.022388815879821777, -0.015542745590209961, -0.021197086200118065, 0.027306245639920235, -0.012176486663520336, 0.01276582945138216, 0.0265219546854496, 0.014113573357462883, -0.007653363049030304, 0.013349521905183792, -0.005589650012552738, 0.020738445222377777, -0.0064863660372793674, 0.028735868632793427, 0.0015107252402231097, -0.053099628537893295, 0.009905953891575336, -0.03085244446992874, -0.02689151093363762, -0.05921373516321182, -0.02635599672794342, -0.0598592571914196, 0.021741414442658424, -0.0014143575681373477, 0.02513323351740837, -0.046242423355579376, 0.0042607965879142284, 0.025699807330965996, 0.04312419518828392, -0.011355577036738396, -0.04085398092865944, -0.0030315921176224947, -0.014331144280731678, -0.0533452145755291, -0.015445909462869167, 0.03930871561169624, -0.02963179536163807, -0.018712889403104782, -0.018464019522070885, -0.045027244836091995, 0.031240375712513924, -0.017712783068418503, -0.021741440519690514, -0.004012880381196737, -0.028409916907548904, 0.016364216804504395, -0.010994800366461277, 0.045867882668972015, 0.00411496264860034, -0.017374886199831963, 0.019513754174113274, 0.05573735386133194, -0.0363602340221405, 0.0035598338581621647, -0.03679186478257179, 0.08107825368642807, -0.01926238276064396, -0.048190414905548096, -0.08443354815244675, -0.06550528109073639, 0.058655522763729095, 0.01085430383682251, -0.03421059250831604, -0.05953911691904068, -0.03919821232557297, -0.004888880532234907, -0.01061748806387186, -0.03808616101741791, 0.03659164533019066, -0.016870178282260895, -0.002589631825685501, -0.022574137896299362, -0.004710088949650526, 0.07357233762741089, 0.0020150437485426664, 0.019434120506048203, 0.010380726307630539, -0.018191566690802574, 0.006213375832885504, 0.026194194331765175, 0.004590537864714861, -0.01747441478073597, -0.013113106600940228, -0.03426318243145943, 0.0034013206604868174, 0.04162028431892395, -0.020612485706806183, -0.024535538628697395, -0.011212578974664211, -0.007004126440733671, 0.01658693142235279, -0.06532029807567596, 0.040275610983371735, -0.025788510218262672, 0.005421291571110487, -0.0830504521727562, -0.008025134913623333, -0.03744116052985191, 0.023599160835146904, -0.0027588445227593184, 0.024647554382681847, 0.0019003608031198382, 0.026730598881840706, 0.06974466890096664, 0.001313425018452108, 0.003659716574475169, -0.0133522879332304, -0.027869058772921562, 0.0515291653573513, -0.025382544845342636, -0.008723105303943157, 0.009779088199138641, 0.025160767138004303, -0.03598347306251526, -0.003091925522312522, -0.0013573747128248215, -0.008605845272541046, 0.038876425474882126, 0.01384219340980053, 0.04749608412384987, 0.08066118508577347, 0.03594933822751045, 0.0037097118329256773, 0.004496573004871607, -0.008319778367877007, -0.007379355374723673, 0.0265418142080307, 0.06470987945795059, -0.003613909939303994, 0.009606179781258106, 0.0411568358540535, 0.009096340276300907, 0.042358189821243286, 0.0361068956553936, 0.024283532053232193, 0.002231153892353177, 0.038340914994478226, -0.011195029132068157, 0.006178847048431635, -0.012772797606885433, -0.05042106658220291, 0.018248718231916428, -0.05358124151825905, -0.020247215405106544, 0.04378547519445419, 0.03442014008760452, -0.020452171564102173, -0.020726444199681282, -0.05032404512166977, -0.07291802018880844, 0.01668444648385048, 0.05087399482727051, 0.005906389560550451, 0.03880917653441429, 0.00426632771268487, 0.0547187514603138, -0.04169655591249466, 0.01734301447868347, -0.04708622768521309, -0.08296315371990204, 0.0020545623265206814, -0.019996277987957, -0.016037501394748688, 0.0371931716799736, 0.01450504269450903, -0.021839041262865067, 0.020641140639781952, -0.028310421854257584, 0.02452946826815605, 0.020284809172153473, 0.03245137259364128, -0.017771627753973007, 0.04067553952336311, -0.011966959573328495, 0.03140650689601898, -0.022977877408266068, -0.038836050778627396, 0.1103995218873024, 0.06893299520015717, 0.030102048069238663, -0.08674244582653046, 0.04166306182742119, 0.02893804758787155, -0.025463050231337547, -0.013152017258107662, -0.010139559395611286, 0.014067472890019417, 0.028772277757525444, 0.05811774730682373, 0.049561601132154465, 0.021749692037701607, 0.001732931355945766, 0.013593252748250961, -0.021637259051203728, -0.033055730164051056, 0.009399243630468845, 0.01328657753765583, -0.018606869503855705, -0.05737496539950371, -0.04958604648709297, 0.0007967748679220676, 0.048103753477334976, -0.024943921715021133, -0.05631560832262039, 0.001117600710131228, 0.004096971824765205, 0.01312174927443266, 0.012573672458529472, 0.0313795804977417, -0.0007411776459775865, 0.012853595428168774, -0.03590380400419235, -0.01134679839015007, 0.003684371942654252, -0.019588207826018333, 0.020691445097327232, 0.022115672007203102, -0.0005245976499281824, -0.019066855311393738, -0.026648782193660736, 0.04523690044879913, -0.01714296080172062, -0.03532906249165535, -0.03295130655169487, 0.015666447579860687, 0.012208662927150726, -0.027021994814276695, -0.004532120190560818, 0.04511408135294914, -0.027401169762015343, -0.04729686304926872, -0.03300880268216133, 0.031708426773548126, -0.016120312735438347, -0.05336349084973335, -0.008685599081218243, -0.03722845017910004, 0.03815809637308121, -0.03258548676967621, 0.02132434956729412, 0.005151737481355667, 0.0202215313911438, 0.008745798841118813, -0.01672828383743763, 0.07300350069999695, -0.009703400544822216, 0.022989151999354362, 0.013313732109963894, -0.0000863115128595382, -0.022177251055836678, 0.007811318151652813, 0.0119269834831357, 0.005359950941056013, 0.018706675618886948, -0.022732077166438103, 0.0013957871124148369, -0.002195849781855941, 0.004836085718125105, 0.05294102430343628, -0.02056921273469925, 0.013116855174303055, -0.02082841843366623, 0.012423127889633179, 0.0527801550924778, 0.024597717449069023, 0.028997303918004036, 0.02399255707859993, 0.006565261632204056, 0.058030616492033005, 0.0076394216157495975, -0.04238620027899742, -0.04235164076089859, 0.003374662483111024, -0.02818547934293747, -0.0181446373462677, -0.05424561724066734, 0.058801762759685516, 0.05331236496567726, 0.002774034393951297, 0.011184776201844215, -0.024136077612638474, -0.0373450368642807, 0.018229644745588303, 0.012190206907689571, -0.03409814462065697, -0.011482343077659607, 0.021046273410320282, 0.0037717767991125584, 0.00020320324983913451, -0.005864997860044241, -0.031737301498651505, -0.05110551416873932, 0.0015986646758392453, -0.00718095013871789, -0.02147146500647068, 0.0004944126703776419, 0.025782139971852303, -0.015660516917705536, 0.0007334529655054212, 0.004036412574350834, -0.0516018308699131, -0.013044235296547413, 0.010431496426463127, -0.005908406339585781, -0.01806372031569481, 0.016236962750554085, -0.025952095165848732, 0.006444127764552832, 0.033239010721445084, -0.006693757604807615, 0.013057677075266838, 0.022803151980042458, 0.010207404382526875, 0.011725403368473053, 0.021696509793400764, -0.017421895638108253, -0.023456018418073654, 0.027779052034020424, -0.04304071143269539, -0.013457417488098145, 0.01755811832845211, -0.014078420586884022, 0.022311879321932793, 0.018702184781432152, -0.013104959391057491, 0.027505701407790184, 0.06171543151140213, -0.0014922216068953276, 0.006193259265273809, -0.016452323645353317, -0.01158493384718895, 0.001935782260261476, 0.009026873856782913, 0.025191569700837135, -0.023421645164489746, -0.023060308769345284, 0.032145604491233826, 0.0669035017490387, 0.02135751210153103, -0.00017671989917289466, -0.006252836901694536, 0.024949951097369194, -0.0005600490258075297, 0.010195652022957802, -0.018379222601652145, -0.002990367589518428, 0.05472130700945854, -0.03546961024403572, 0.020498845726251602, -0.015471301972866058, 0.0006953969714231789, -0.08938205242156982, -0.009078267961740494, 0.003241476370021701, -0.00912182591855526, 0.03566847741603851, -0.07868415862321854, 0.01110230665653944, 0.01601949706673622, -0.018089534714818, -0.0017562351422384381, -0.012076244689524174, -0.006317781284451485, 0.0031594897154718637, 0.055068518966436386, -0.002018297789618373, 0.03154841065406799, 0.02703816071152687, 0.009176869876682758, 0.02524716407060623, 0.01904679834842682, 0.017461558803915977, -0.0670376643538475, -0.002526385011151433, 0.009221569634974003, 0.026822509244084358, -0.05890953913331032, 0.0018610096303746104, -0.02023470774292946, -0.018849678337574005, 0.0208301804959774, -0.0475132018327713, 0.026547618210315704, 0.022590870037674904, 0.0271599143743515, 0.0008190074004232883, 0.05344102531671524, 0.030267223715782166, 0.017301063984632492, -0.0347103476524353, -0.00260171783156693, 0.006773934233933687, -0.0063924407586455345, -0.036430880427360535, 0.01943332515656948, 0.054888490587472916, 0.0006352710188366473, 0.020865852013230324, 0.03904075175523758, 0.00020989820768591017, -0.0039882538840174675, -0.044870320707559586, 0.008177216164767742, 0.030690118670463562, -0.01658051088452339, -0.016949709504842758, -0.05087150260806084, 0.061409708112478256, 0.0560365691781044, 0.0211593359708786, -0.03062782622873783, 0.0195600688457489, -0.011292892508208752, -0.02477097325026989, -0.008381576277315617, -0.004730964079499245, -0.009159250184893608, -0.05842304974794388, -0.024103254079818726, -0.016962498426437378, 0.022656751796603203, -0.035799603909254074, -0.0022829801309853792, 0.002438443945720792, 0.04251154884696007, -0.002696023788303137, -0.020600492134690285, 0.04316963627934456, 0.009600277990102768, 0.02174462005496025, -0.04800279811024666, 0.02680611051619053, 0.02443351224064827, -0.03531285375356674, -0.04776061698794365, -0.018962888047099113, -0.0994216725230217, 0.0415201410651207, 0.04745738208293915, 0.02640637569129467, 0.02918221801519394, -0.027343107387423515, 0.027635617181658745, -0.025738677009940147, -0.060891613364219666, 0.06415493786334991, -0.009805398993194103, -0.0411624051630497, 0.005847437772899866, -0.0017074444331228733, 0.007668003439903259, 0.005757989827543497, -0.003978412132710218, -0.03488609194755554, -0.007235873490571976, 0.025501364842057228, -0.029483027756214142, 0.027283012866973877, -0.026860177516937256, -0.002531906822696328, 0.041954584419727325, -0.007193304598331451, 0.0031723633874207735, 0.03326520696282387, 0.04025528207421303, -0.009517498314380646, 0.06040655076503754, -0.060724180191755295, -0.005303291603922844, 0.03117438778281212, 0.0062909736298024654, -0.012156711891293526, -0.047838907688856125, 0.018423330038785934, -0.02838711440563202, -0.03845605254173279, 0.0024259292986243963, 0.023946305736899376, 0.036910783499479294, 0.04305186867713928, -0.0076279714703559875, -0.012998750433325768, -0.03127192333340645, 0.00045596397831104696, 0.004072562791407108, -0.004799406509846449, 0.006567231845110655, -0.014496149495244026, 0.010739371180534363, 0.018795689567923546, -0.031125148758292198, 0.0341307669878006, -0.030936555936932564, 0.04378189891576767, 0.005732723046094179, -0.006695109885185957, 0.009921249933540821, -0.03737147897481918, 0.007421852555125952, -0.004876673687249422, -0.028154436498880386, 0.03770216181874275, -0.03496629744768143, 0.02140694670379162, -0.023267211392521858, -0.0008641383028589189, -0.02869979478418827, 0.013858304359018803, 0.021530933678150177, -0.0027456749230623245, -0.02580220438539982, 0.008352545090019703, 0.019419090822339058, 0.006116056349128485, -0.010532337240874767, -0.0038096450734883547, 0.04606212303042412, -0.03428175672888756, -0.0024925211910158396, -0.01973329856991768, -0.006633346900343895, -0.03643537685275078, 0.028900206089019775, 0.01457879226654768, -0.010665422305464745, 0.02204946242272854, -0.04803665354847908, -0.007632214110344648, 0.017347311601042747, -0.012211068533360958, -0.027264971286058426, -0.05585560202598572, -0.04803543537855148, 0.03680098056793213, 0.014360596425831318, -0.017363661900162697 ]
<p>While studying relevance feedback(Pseudo relevance feedback), I have learn that the model can go horribly wrong for some queries. Can anyone give reasons why this is?</p>
73,576
[ -0.027539189904928207, -0.035318270325660706, 0.01883448101580143, -0.021317198872566223, 0.04027507081627846, 0.046667538583278656, -0.006382258143275976, 0.013679864816367626, 0.017139896750450134, -0.025746440514922142, 0.01919279620051384, 0.05598554015159607, 0.052167266607284546, -0.00046910697710700333, -0.0011873497860506177, 0.010758118703961372, 0.02345723658800125, 0.002077706390991807, -0.0007256598910316825, 0.005686281248927116, 0.01304684579372406, 0.057635579258203506, 0.025369640439748764, -0.011924120597541332, -0.010409376583993435, -0.01767018437385559, 0.04481697455048561, 0.00039271567948162556, 0.05267617851495743, 0.03756512701511383, -0.018287111073732376, 0.012317603453993797, -0.009320798330008984, 0.00956844724714756, 0.022289538756012917, -0.010517369955778122, -0.027868663892149925, -0.0415227934718132, -0.022894781082868576, 0.026899047195911407, -0.012138636782765388, -0.019295912235975266, -0.005268541630357504, 0.05276669189333916, -0.02104986272752285, 0.013945073820650578, -0.030931519344449043, -0.01993303932249546, 0.046805113554000854, -0.05568737909197807, 0.059220168739557266, 0.009093038737773895, 0.04086475446820259, 0.0634465292096138, -0.03630899265408516, 0.03487370163202286, 0.08224764466285706, 0.09054441750049591, -0.025789862498641014, -0.05183291435241699, 0.0021147087682038546, -0.03404845669865608, 0.0063899303786456585, 0.004909771028906107, -0.01644737273454666, 0.03870667144656181, 0.02970309741795063, -0.02021503448486328, 0.05481905862689018, 0.02987459860742092, 0.0038304852787405252, 0.005250709131360054, 0.024886049330234528, 0.0067147319205105305, 0.041810542345047, -0.0397593192756176, 0.014373631216585636, 0.012066845782101154, 0.06183239072561264, 0.015450912527740002, -0.0010529911378398538, 0.01894468627870083, 0.012739182449877262, 0.06804171204566956, -0.013094908557832241, -0.011454283259809017, 0.036379411816596985, -0.018943222239613533, -0.010883722454309464, 0.039241474121809006, -0.052378252148628235, 0.01465427316725254, 0.0012880997965112329, 0.002395446179434657, -0.028758862987160683, 0.0512792244553566, -0.007514703553169966, 0.049988459795713425, 0.010781742632389069, -0.028145097196102142, -0.003986044321209192, -0.01715710200369358, 0.00044722651364281774, 0.022795353084802628, -0.05698833242058754, -0.02088325284421444, -0.04558241367340088, -0.01140387263149023, -0.02041175402700901, 0.0034696946386247873, -0.01965325139462948, 0.013168569654226303, -0.010492337867617607, 0.008752752095460892, 0.023342639207839966, -0.0732542872428894, -0.0006419585552066565, -0.04083358123898506, 0.048038460314273834, 0.04933701083064079, 0.014097814448177814, -0.025836637243628502, 0.01568762958049774, -0.03512045368552208, -0.05774015188217163, -0.01753958687186241, 0.02712828293442726, -0.028863338753581047, -0.03862667456269264, 0.04374168813228607, -0.008928901515901089, -0.030098455026745796, 0.05194646120071411, -0.02423715963959694, 0.04158388078212738, -0.004472009371966124, -0.08029723167419434, -0.04792746901512146, 0.022306576371192932, 0.00677898433059454, -0.01637180522084236, -0.08234290033578873, 0.002044382505118847, 0.04139407351613045, 0.037276413291692734, 0.020833877846598625, 0.018333347514271736, 0.021741732954978943, 0.016621405258774757, -0.009449745528399944, -0.02430398389697075, -0.04346505552530289, -0.02280709333717823, -0.009930175729095936, -0.00315847503952682, -0.07981370389461517, 0.037810102105140686, -0.01428692415356636, -0.009553867392241955, -0.0212715957313776, 0.012478129006922245, -0.01938345842063427, -0.004282605834305286, -0.03205813840031624, 0.043924480676651, -0.012191587127745152, 0.11672661453485489, 0.02908623404800892, 0.024083668366074562, 0.025726106017827988, -0.01563565619289875, 0.002881476189941168, 0.0233926884829998, 0.016773387789726257, 0.018848644569516182, -0.018535587936639786, -0.009665088728070259, -0.03318367525935173, 0.04775795340538025, 0.020208904519677162, -0.019269369542598724, -0.03406905755400658, 0.012974029406905174, 0.019413722679018974, -0.011284956708550453, 0.018915308639407158, -0.004587898030877113, -0.01858242228627205, 0.03965894877910614, -0.05162973329424858, -0.02114192210137844, -0.04783884435892105, 0.015992257744073868, -0.004551379010081291, 0.016091030091047287, 0.032307133078575134, 0.005929566919803619, -0.016162889078259468, -0.004225639160722494, -0.03029199317097664, -0.00891802553087473, -0.020091932266950607, 0.03717959299683571, -0.035579465329647064, 0.01304193027317524, 0.04458682984113693, -0.008125049993395805, -0.02098872885107994, 0.03365645930171013, -0.04249381273984909, -0.07092437893152237, -0.01666899025440216, 0.026812097057700157, 0.02918880246579647, -0.03124123439192772, -0.031126568093895912, 0.002378839999437332, 0.014257537201046944, -0.009482036344707012, 0.015171931125223637, -0.04960500821471214, 0.07108082622289658, 0.05134275555610657, 0.02698468416929245, -0.012046807445585728, 0.024984318763017654, 0.010295122861862183, 0.016893599182367325, -0.023412592709064484, -0.046674493700265884, -0.03398650884628296, -0.009807327762246132, 0.056476276367902756, 0.021694215014576912, -0.03943663090467453, 0.021243875846266747, 0.031970586627721786, 0.030227117240428925, 0.03277386352419853, 0.022843586280941963, -0.0062594907358288765, -0.009583731181919575, 0.03863898292183876, 0.020984968170523643, 0.020971715450286865, 0.01888531818985939, 0.017271993681788445, -0.022151587530970573, 0.0013305238680914044, -0.023943664506077766, -0.010248756967484951, 0.03518737107515335, 0.0024886655155569315, -0.014889915473759174, -0.015054142102599144, -0.016202915459871292, 0.02157600224018097, -0.02745221182703972, 0.004979714285582304, 0.03842656686902046, 0.008860267698764801, 0.04389459267258644, -0.02532125450670719, -0.010153433308005333, 0.016636071726679802, 0.033588796854019165, -0.03411710262298584, -0.02089115045964718, 0.035864729434251785, -0.017099205404520035, 0.014211643487215042, -0.029983842745423317, 0.003467883914709091, -0.04440357908606529, 0.021178698167204857, 0.006873083300888538, -0.028110725805163383, 0.02584179677069187, -0.016734302043914795, -0.010201336815953255, 0.0024558701552450657, -0.03108774498105049, 0.0009418252739124, -0.022946221753954887, -0.03440803289413452, 0.017551980912685394, -0.0144461365416646, -0.002747279591858387, 0.05397936701774597, -0.01016722247004509, 0.025419017300009727, -0.00948081910610199, -0.041547346860170364, -0.02628335729241371, -0.04393254593014717, -0.0661468654870987, 0.016577843576669693, -0.016503693535923958, -0.007902582176029682, 0.048108696937561035, -0.00537919532507658, -0.06505639851093292, 0.03700821474194527, -0.0011887031141668558, -0.04172873497009277, -0.022358475252985954, -0.004359622485935688, -0.01184672862291336, -0.028123104944825172, 0.01397103350609541, 0.029155468568205833, -0.03912385553121567, 0.0029504660051316023, -0.04351126402616501, -0.06593278795480728, 0.038020264357328415, -0.014392123557627201, 0.038497213274240494, -0.0161974485963583, -0.009135126136243343, 0.07905101776123047, 0.002394711598753929, -0.01631937175989151, -0.028298206627368927, 0.0027458742260932922, -0.03679976984858513, -0.023556973785161972, -0.00614085141569376, 0.009661482647061348, -0.04109276086091995, 0.03141505643725395, -0.010080038569867611, 0.04954254627227783, 0.03164391592144966, 0.02970435656607151, -0.05414612963795662, 0.03190496191382408, 0.007062912452965975, -0.011957922019064426, 0.006935362704098225, 0.03644072264432907, -0.04252654314041138, 0.005668357014656067, 0.010147735476493835, 0.03131629526615143, 0.000675024522934109, -0.01942290924489498, 0.04239145293831825, -0.024871550500392914, 0.018425244837999344, 0.006211024709045887, 0.03717949613928795, 0.011047608219087124, -0.016661180183291435, -0.04331555590033531, 0.015671301633119583, 0.04088158532977104, -0.03503875806927681, 0.008343072608113289, 0.07007233798503876, 0.03130869194865227, -0.03984014689922333, -0.00008311770943691954, -0.03313742205500603, -0.036516375839710236, 0.013508176431059837, -0.010502493008971214, -0.013494112528860569, 0.0632520467042923, 0.0402827262878418, -0.006354788318276405, 0.0005391249433159828, -0.036095909774303436, -0.0036389529705047607, -0.07199496775865555, -0.007666044402867556, -0.025406859815120697, 0.05171043053269386, 0.007339137606322765, 0.007249226327985525, 0.022421417757868767, -0.003926150035113096, -0.014125767163932323, 0.052410151809453964, -0.05838064104318619, -0.007656315341591835, -0.03353947401046753, 0.0007968707359395921, -0.0013968934072181582, -0.021071022376418114, 0.019069915637373924, -0.020480051636695862, -0.03783337026834488, 0.005748769734054804, 0.02960905060172081, -0.03804156184196472, 0.01198556087911129, -0.013558505102992058, 0.0050047594122588634, -0.0291286651045084, 0.004169054329395294, 0.02709682285785675, 0.02002253755927086, 0.024438461288809776, 0.04651941731572151, -0.012712005525827408, -0.02008965238928795, -0.03849497437477112, 0.015056626871228218, 0.05690666660666466, 0.05166494846343994, 0.0040318164974451065, 0.02688191831111908, -0.066912442445755, 0.05113932490348816, 0.013326471671462059, 0.015670018270611763, 0.038749754428863525, -0.010224426165223122, -0.025695547461509705, -0.05681464448571205, -0.035759005695581436, 0.020053688436746597, 0.05280858650803566, -0.002034461824223399, 0.014448915608227253, 0.003813469782471657, 0.01641106978058815, -0.041184112429618835, -0.012292944826185703, 0.03811418637633324, 0.04664042219519615, -0.029287993907928467, -0.00783277116715908, 0.01224139891564846, -0.0021639016922563314, 0.009157572872936726, 0.007771823089569807, -0.008280912414193153, -0.020787155255675316, -0.02764100395143032, 0.01835932768881321, -0.06567392498254776, -0.029313696548342705, 0.0005642546457238495, 0.0001352051185676828, -0.003125810297206044, 0.008812117390334606, 0.0059293354861438274, 0.02833964303135872, 0.05419420450925827, 0.0707395151257515, -0.01841449737548828, 0.008460772223770618, -0.09474463015794754, -0.013867034576833248, 0.0768183246254921, 0.03751213848590851, -0.023270122706890106, -0.0069337827153503895, -0.05937438830733299, -0.010737978853285313, 0.031756702810525894, -0.03140784054994583, 0.019488375633955002, -0.004644451662898064, -0.00013381446478888392, 0.005581989418715239, -0.020176537334918976, 0.01825035735964775, -0.006008405238389969, -0.022277962416410446, 0.04616893082857132, -0.007382301148027182, -0.01616944558918476, -0.06362120807170868, -0.021125080063939095, 0.016507906839251518, 0.027983209118247032, -0.007799878716468811, -0.00016595679335296154, -0.002112671500071883, 0.01987324468791485, -0.05147895961999893, -0.05614640191197395, 0.014823216013610363, -0.022830696776509285, 0.013409851118922234, 0.05017444118857384, -0.035017602145671844, -0.009097432717680931, 0.015967335551977158, 0.025521304458379745, -0.02481253258883953, -0.02861015312373638, -0.04123026877641678, -0.018933651968836784, 0.033595405519008636, -0.016018884256482124, 0.07018621265888214, 0.015082692727446556, 0.007141205482184887, -0.023175016045570374, -0.009851825423538685, 0.03764393553137779, -0.03470807522535324, -0.01646214909851551, -0.025666791945695877, -0.016388271003961563, -0.033020008355379105, 0.04325428977608681, 0.002013459103181958, 0.033393971621990204, -0.043202098459005356, -0.012966570444405079, -0.006157767493277788, 0.009840348735451698, 0.012549723498523235, 0.012890185229480267, 0.010216658003628254, 0.014176243916153908, 0.00513841025531292, -0.0026782993227243423, 0.031109461560845375, -0.03334818035364151, -0.01460940856486559, 0.04593399912118912, -0.027864038944244385, 0.010974557138979435, -0.018578918650746346, 0.01664893515408039, 0.015484340488910675, 0.011975542642176151, 0.011221915483474731, 0.0019215474603697658, 0.00290911877527833, 0.0035586992744356394, -0.037477362900972366, 0.004399193916469812, -0.013374307192862034, -0.02200479246675968, 0.018425213173031807, -0.040808022022247314, 0.02372945286333561, 0.011236791498959064, -0.002177438698709011, -0.08482150733470917, -0.034942954778671265, 0.05312851816415787, -0.015865884721279144, -0.03966483101248741, -0.01604432985186577, -0.0028863612096756697, -0.0007155309431254864, -0.05226973444223404, -0.022838402539491653, 0.04727393388748169, 0.009119843132793903, -0.017638549208641052, 0.011501161381602287, -0.00505213625729084, 0.038122355937957764, 0.01258659828454256, -0.00084225635509938, 0.030248107388615608, -0.017174260690808296, -0.022774208337068558, -0.036822594702243805, 0.04222133755683899, -0.04865257814526558, -0.03718078136444092, -0.047148581594228745, 0.0025549044366925955, 0.045023463666439056, -0.03651999309659004, 0.036276984959840775, 0.005836975760757923, -0.0256218109279871, 0.007693650666624308, -0.006426145322620869, 0.004479201976209879, 0.017962895333766937, -0.01423572190105915, -0.001998784253373742, 0.015901196748018265, 0.012658760882914066, -0.002185102552175522, 0.027101952582597733, -0.014141330495476723, 0.0380513072013855, -0.004910497926175594, 0.0944385677576065, -0.03306957706809044, -0.0007915452006272972, -0.00005577872434514575, -0.031374242156744, 0.014913350343704224, 0.03504807874560356, -0.006484447978436947, 0.008752643130719662, 0.0354478545486927, -0.03961396589875221, -0.02770179696381092, 0.008127812296152115, 0.011414018459618092, 0.06663791090250015, -0.02932482771575451, 0.01747540757060051, 0.011943007819354534, 0.007417052518576384, -0.0033742059022188187, -0.0005416612839326262, -0.03255460411310196, -0.013969835825264454, -0.019595924764871597, 0.038751307874917984, -0.025636611506342888, 0.02043546549975872, 0.011377905495464802, 0.011488448828458786, 0.058375284075737, 0.011276183649897575, 0.03741532191634178, 0.045230962336063385, 0.025802956894040108, -0.025689737871289253, -0.07268302887678146, 0.036404043436050415, -0.05225396156311035, 0.017304029315710068, 0.003962163347750902, -0.04288502410054207, 0.05112842470407486, 0.00940785463899374, 0.0212884321808815, -0.020452408120036125, -0.018575293943285942, -0.023296190425753593, 0.01310138963162899, -0.020533669739961624, 0.028047850355505943, 0.012514401227235794, 0.02072073332965374, 0.025504153221845627, 0.023954732343554497, 0.030148770660161972, 0.01113265473395586, -0.11686196178197861, -0.055227044969797134, -0.004833347164094448, -0.05330105498433113, 0.00909541454166174, 0.02802390232682228, -0.02185366488993168, 0.009205479174852371, -0.03162343055009842, 0.006017549429088831, 0.0050662788562476635, 0.02739460952579975, -0.019678309559822083, 0.008973891846835613, 0.020009871572256088, 0.013420553877949715, 0.004227043595165014, -0.02911851741373539, 0.12122602015733719, 0.08148398250341415, 0.03812306746840477, -0.08966924250125885, 0.032547079026699066, -0.012891517020761967, 0.012350893579423428, -0.023151051253080368, 0.05323057249188423, 0.0109674371778965, 0.03049330972135067, 0.05071773752570152, 0.03473946079611778, 0.024415437132120132, -0.008352489210665226, 0.01534594688564539, -0.04745161160826683, -0.04363146424293518, 0.04346635192632675, 0.00382852740585804, 0.007260290440171957, -0.005948612466454506, -0.020476413890719414, 0.01594533585011959, 0.004448972176760435, 0.022756798192858696, -0.01216376293450594, -0.02416788600385189, -0.030806250870227814, 0.01523043867200613, -0.023966867476701736, 0.0020957679953426123, -0.0054902564734220505, 0.025323959067463875, -0.000130884611280635, 0.032323114573955536, 0.01814410649240017, 0.0033266395330429077, 0.016364969313144684, 0.03925322741270065, 0.007550152018666267, -0.01150666642934084, 0.0077070072293281555, 0.010030986741185188, -0.043302010744810104, -0.02422328293323517, -0.011610916815698147, 0.01945444382727146, -0.02552562765777111, 0.027879178524017334, -0.004531483631581068, -0.002617496531456709, -0.01503993570804596, -0.03946353495121002, -0.03752603754401207, 0.0442066453397274, 0.031157050281763077, -0.023518918082118034, -0.0662674829363823, -0.02356916479766369, 0.04589254781603813, -0.045804429799318314, 0.04630213603377342, 0.030439231544733047, -0.039798904210329056, -0.015016410499811172, -0.0507199764251709, 0.008076497353613377, 0.006913277320563793, 0.01249872986227274, -0.013391686603426933, 0.007558534853160381, -0.00977632962167263, -0.022086434066295624, 0.0038253876846283674, 0.010883834213018417, 0.051392123103141785, -0.02567135915160179, -0.002146510872989893, -0.024850666522979736, -0.08365907520055771, 0.0015978884184733033, -0.02690563164651394, -0.010939383879303932, -0.0909506306052208, 0.009739524684846401, 0.051075972616672516, 0.024027349427342415, 0.013769514858722687, 0.0502023808658123, -0.03491219878196716, 0.03463185578584671, 0.0005892978515475988, -0.030664758756756783, -0.033415473997592926, -0.01376160979270935, -0.04411552473902702, -0.024063782766461372, 0.02682109735906124, 0.021267598494887352, 0.025034980848431587, 0.02237848937511444, -0.012757963500916958, 0.012409977614879608, -0.00117547158151865, 0.012971991673111916, 0.034726303070783615, -0.05641116201877594, 0.004834095016121864, -0.005694614723324776, 0.01327173039317131, -0.03073231503367424, -0.03254552558064461, -0.03873874619603157, -0.01135407853871584, 0.027650561183691025, 0.02449687570333481, 0.013004987500607967, -0.0233161598443985, -0.011216871440410614, 0.029483212158083916, -0.019844932481646538, 0.003756962949410081, -0.05197732895612717, 0.030279550701379776, -0.013484375551342964, -0.0507991760969162, -0.02932167425751686, 0.00026698363944888115, -0.008124971762299538, -0.006028725765645504, 0.01227553840726614, -0.0003492650866974145, -0.017451133579015732, 0.003186870599165559, 0.03392624855041504, 0.01829538494348526, 0.06069475784897804, -0.05140864476561546, -0.023326702415943146, 0.043021030724048615, -0.04674384370446205, -0.03882342204451561, 0.024884341284632683, 0.0002213320112787187, 0.03443796560168266, 0.011334294453263283, -0.0010425575310364366, -0.013469441793859005, 0.09191077202558517, -0.030934056267142296, -0.02746916003525257, 0.04220001772046089, 0.008654498495161533, 0.046452026814222336, -0.0000632063383818604, 0.01199710089713335, -0.009690315462648869, -0.009387822821736336, 0.009407407604157925, 0.046446021646261215, -0.005074306391179562, -0.008797092363238335, -0.006439148914068937, -0.03179797902703285, 0.043402936309576035, 0.008085459470748901, 0.02288982830941677, -0.007634350098669529, 0.005114649422466755, -0.03810376301407814, 0.030546747148036957, 0.015519856475293636, 0.033952031284570694, -0.06180279329419136, 0.01434964407235384, 0.01404366921633482, -0.001781524857506156, 0.024578116834163666, -0.030696814879775047, 0.030631691217422485, 0.05421534180641174, -0.05475790053606033, 0.01072885561734438, -0.0011452730977907777, -0.022326787933707237, -0.03525131195783615, -0.011371421627700329, -0.027493497356772423, 0.028760118409991264, 0.06506648659706116, 0.01552173774689436, 0.023989694193005562, -0.010154463350772858, -0.03309685364365578, -0.03130542114377022, -0.03656882792711258, 0.05772527679800987, -0.062013983726501465, 0.0005268793320283294, 0.021106677129864693, -0.02680186927318573, -0.031426165252923965, 0.010768864303827286, -0.0035762335173785686, 0.009866013191640377, 0.03416156396269798, 0.026841090992093086, 0.023702792823314667, 0.0073752133175730705, 0.07437416911125183, -0.0194595605134964, -0.006505185272544622, 0.039276838302612305, -0.004495779052376747, 0.03421179577708244, -0.018403103575110435, 0.0391029417514801, 0.0015531033277511597, -0.03367443382740021, -0.037474341690540314, 0.02170608378946781, -0.01592237502336502, -0.02740323357284069, 0.020591145381331444, -0.011078180745244026, 0.036541715264320374, -0.06038576364517212, 0.01998700574040413, -0.030904540792107582, -0.009528705850243568, 0.03614654764533043, 0.03486066684126854, -0.010081966407597065, 0.005430419929325581, -0.0024502668529748917, -0.0424976572394371, 0.01173023134469986, -0.002880400512367487, 0.006219097413122654, -0.06566503643989563, 0.022067947313189507, 0.006303179543465376, -0.014987455680966377, -0.030671540647745132, -0.028113000094890594, -0.007936482317745686, 0.0446276031434536, -0.0057767401449382305, 0.003219537204131484, 0.026268161833286285, -0.03607252985239029, -0.031657036393880844, -0.07785225659608841, 0.0621529147028923, -0.01648821495473385, -0.03580146282911301, -0.014309539459645748, -0.016767704859375954, -0.03211785480380058, -0.0020544808357954025, 0.05362183600664139, -0.039429422467947006, -0.025068212300539017, -0.005940103903412819, 0.01768643781542778, 0.015236994251608849, -0.0062305862084031105, 0.012540340423583984, 0.002042951760813594, 0.0012418535770848393, -0.03998205438256264, -0.007342509459704161, 0.011128687299787998, -0.002366394270211458, -0.00044518616050481796, 0.0066328090615570545, 0.0012396437814459205, -0.00398871349170804, -0.009763686917722225, 0.03142116218805313, 0.025612371042370796, 0.02934691309928894, 0.06853529810905457, 0.02220444567501545, 0.02368338219821453, 0.03685138002038002, 0.021121026948094368, -0.04515701159834862, 0.032902173697948456, -0.019198622554540634, -0.002756737405434251, -0.0014993634540587664, 0.028440171852707863, -0.028751274570822716, -0.035747189074754715, -0.02000480517745018, 0.04964223876595497, -0.030451150611042976, 0.006030912511050701, 0.026878872886300087, 0.012889821082353592, 0.038897521793842316, 0.006279231980443001, 0.012249423190951347, 0.011166460812091827, 0.0052018784917891026, -0.0017396574839949608, 0.045129336416721344, 0.0037625243421643972, -0.014002978801727295, 0.027536481618881226, 0.041820261627435684, -0.0452883206307888, 0.04320120811462402, -0.03222107142210007, 0.055326808243989944, -0.06082186475396156, 0.0002185312332585454, 0.0062887235544621944, -0.028716852888464928, 0.012464826926589012, 0.02435530163347721, -0.006935425102710724, 0.0767979845404625, -0.03864964842796326, 0.044519294053316116, -0.04881441965699196, 0.004234895575791597, -0.00385592901147902, 0.007591144647449255, 0.008348056115210056, 0.04698723927140236, 0.006489619147032499, -0.02448478899896145, 0.01254354976117611, -0.0017516262596473098, 0.039976321160793304, 0.009379428811371326, -0.036354463547468185, -0.02282412350177765, -0.00535487150773406, -0.04037909582257271, -0.011573233641684055, -0.011346781626343727, 0.017469553276896477, 0.05863971263170242, 0.02226024493575096, 0.01574212685227394, 0.0031986194662749767, -0.024121399968862534, -0.022102538496255875, 0.04223794862627983, -0.08133019506931305, -0.0017201026203110814, -0.024148575961589813, 0.01844809018075466, -0.010256482288241386, -0.04586813971400261 ]
<p>I am using WEKA to do classification. I wish to compare with an existing paper that uses the Precision and Recall Break-Even performance as their results.</p> <p>Can someone please help in order for me to determine this Break-Even performance? More preferably - if possible - with WEKA. If not, a formula I can use.</p>
73,577
[ -0.000012263349162822124, -0.025318697094917297, -0.011373722925782204, -0.011129101738333702, 0.03822782263159752, 0.007280913647264242, -0.034976813942193985, 0.00666885357350111, 0.011459571309387684, -0.021903222426772118, 0.0650053396821022, 0.03477683663368225, 0.03783749043941498, 0.0412171296775341, 0.018873944878578186, -0.015353342518210411, -0.032415490597486496, -0.010676148347556591, 0.01998889446258545, -0.0043488601222634315, -0.01923106424510479, 0.023470498621463776, -0.0114694032818079, 0.0036218150053173304, -0.04124855250120163, 0.024649009108543396, 0.015033426694571972, 0.009580307640135288, -0.006465801503509283, 0.05298672616481781, 0.004373286385089159, -0.023576736450195312, 0.046954743564128876, 0.05628158152103424, -0.010810642503201962, 0.010089414194226265, -0.0602644607424736, -0.07081962376832962, -0.01873975805938244, 0.02229773811995983, -0.042184315621852875, -0.005772935692220926, 0.0073186736553907394, 0.009847399778664112, -0.015040996484458447, 0.020825129002332687, -0.005649378057569265, -0.07316377013921738, 0.0038706480991095304, -0.04233906418085098, 0.05568888038396835, 0.016694732010364532, 0.05822842940688133, 0.02620234712958336, -0.02476368471980095, 0.008101812563836575, 0.017254389822483063, 0.06733956933021545, 0.04050838202238083, -0.04541631042957306, -0.0077248974703252316, -0.05198819190263748, 0.007519192527979612, -0.03717418015003204, -0.03802048787474632, 0.05169219151139259, -0.019176052883267403, -0.05802958831191063, 0.014659976586699486, 0.00048758467892184854, 0.019019832834601402, 0.010366469621658325, 0.0027548307552933693, -0.025477221235632896, 0.03821876645088196, -0.018705256283283234, -0.004937975201755762, 0.05142626538872719, 0.03387173265218735, 0.022512519732117653, -0.0320795439183712, 0.009204134345054626, 0.007524317130446434, 0.04679983854293823, 0.006788510363548994, -0.02183719538152218, 0.04971608147025108, -0.0038260980509221554, 0.03546016663312912, 0.024987854063510895, -0.010362384840846062, 0.008551017381250858, 0.05940908566117287, 0.030191833153367043, -0.027484571561217308, 0.016984591260552406, 0.026760105043649673, 0.03669316694140434, -0.011076335795223713, -0.03034256398677826, 0.01193536352366209, -0.05542507395148277, 0.0034071069676429033, 0.089528389275074, -0.04123803973197937, -0.014089916832745075, -0.04069283604621887, -0.040873218327760696, -0.021592868492007256, -0.019426019862294197, -0.002878396539017558, 0.013116280548274517, 0.033077653497457504, -0.03267925977706909, 0.026465728878974915, 0.016255924478173256, -0.01737087592482567, 0.0060343206860125065, 0.06309419125318527, 0.05812523141503334, 0.05125614255666733, -0.03226727619767189, 0.018081942573189735, -0.023329565301537514, -0.026882875710725784, 0.02759128250181675, 0.011320983059704304, -0.03675052896142006, -0.0785357877612114, 0.048826683312654495, -0.037774547934532166, -0.05130467191338539, 0.05402785539627075, -0.03525075316429138, 0.025017311796545982, -0.004445842932909727, -0.036226898431777954, -0.028717532753944397, 0.024659084156155586, -0.006806183140724897, 0.0099010756239295, -0.09353212267160416, 0.02346576564013958, 0.017155947163701057, 0.05785664543509483, 0.0064090099185705185, 0.056725166738033295, 0.04655969887971878, 0.02240040898323059, 0.0031080537009984255, -0.06516601890325546, -0.0076987482607364655, -0.005014765542000532, 0.004341169260442257, -0.049785107374191284, -0.04163645952939987, -0.04152727499604225, 0.0127145666629076, -0.022163862362504005, -0.013397078961133957, 0.02055785432457924, 0.009102130308747292, -0.01967875100672245, 0.014274983666837215, -0.01317475363612175, -0.03177826851606369, 0.04787224903702736, 0.006481143180280924, 0.08101975917816162, -0.011835802346467972, -0.013798834756016731, 0.0322178490459919, 0.048647113144397736, 0.024836989119648933, 0.0528520792722702, -0.024425463750958443, 0.020323380827903748, -0.020125210285186768, 0.006357445381581783, 0.008746464736759663, -0.04605386033654213, -0.010752802714705467, -0.015915634110569954, -0.017010264098644257, -0.008230547420680523, 0.03947269544005394, -0.02352544106543064, 0.011750971898436546, 0.0262190792709589, -0.013303625397384167, -0.044154368340969086, -0.046541012823581696, 0.02151688002049923, -0.019610648974776268, -0.02591492235660553, 0.03097856417298317, 0.0016065632225945592, 0.01257919892668724, 0.014835634268820286, -0.018641088157892227, -0.04276273027062416, 0.001243850216269493, 0.025815406814217567, -0.025676093995571136, -0.005362051539123058, 0.028331315144896507, 0.01829073764383793, -0.031823866069316864, 0.02907094731926918, -0.02293778955936432, -0.0692867711186409, 0.014602401293814182, -0.033127136528491974, 0.015872115269303322, -0.001552447909489274, -0.020662447437644005, 0.063280388712883, 0.02970193326473236, 0.024368340149521828, 0.03815034031867981, -0.03112640418112278, 0.050146494060754776, 0.061315104365348816, 0.029562178999185562, 0.00859640073031187, -0.02326469123363495, 0.0157014187425375, 0.010583081282675266, -0.01635177806019783, 0.00011979046394117177, -0.026521487161517143, -0.00009051026427187026, 0.019346032291650772, 0.02022191882133484, -0.009593339636921883, 0.024059319868683815, 0.0364934466779232, -0.024195024743676186, 0.03397652134299278, 0.017833691090345383, 0.0010881006019189954, -0.0028149886056780815, 0.00219600647687912, 0.03397907689213753, 0.0008384512038901448, -0.02011362835764885, -0.012860281392931938, -0.007228735834360123, 0.040659673511981964, -0.01306790579110384, -0.027719611302018166, 0.044450413435697556, -0.03712479770183563, 0.010624093934893608, -0.03324546292424202, -0.05627037212252617, 0.06662288308143616, -0.03631002455949783, 0.033755749464035034, 0.03447544202208519, -0.0008426889544352889, -0.004855983890593052, -0.008492054417729378, -0.007914206944406033, 0.02280278131365776, 0.011656521819531918, -0.029884537681937218, -0.008023275062441826, 0.020457664504647255, -0.029802463948726654, 0.03997097164392471, 0.0038939521182328463, 0.025331908836960793, -0.04239172860980034, 0.01820254698395729, 0.02971637435257435, -0.012623395770788193, 0.00538732809945941, 0.0013198640663176775, 0.0009347512968815863, 0.032555364072322845, -0.01954687014222145, 0.021471640095114708, -0.0014257936272770166, -0.05627255514264107, 0.016019081696867943, 0.021031688898801804, 0.014164645224809647, 0.03739627078175545, -0.005341445095837116, -0.02910921722650528, 0.0375240184366703, -0.006839555688202381, -0.0021145755890756845, -0.0034757875837385654, -0.030086832121014595, 0.03243417665362358, -0.015516784973442554, -0.0007420516340062022, 0.019100099802017212, -0.006717081647366285, -0.03410164266824722, 0.0242404043674469, -0.01319508720189333, -0.05471465364098549, -0.01350710354745388, -0.0017706319922581315, -0.00398793863132596, -0.01044357381761074, 0.032232753932476044, 0.014754523523151875, -0.042650554329156876, -0.007879416458308697, -0.0704571083188057, -0.07452358305454254, 0.0435495525598526, -0.03370804712176323, 0.03594479337334633, 0.0037539866752922535, -0.025327324867248535, 0.06359775364398956, 0.0370892658829689, -0.02825472690165043, -0.05057619884610176, 0.001338012982159853, -0.045338887721300125, -0.0115255331620574, 0.001209748792462051, 0.02861141227185726, -0.006303279660642147, 0.010475151240825653, -0.043959036469459534, 0.001953383209183812, 0.0618668831884861, 0.005415807943791151, -0.04475563019514084, 0.010047835297882557, -0.0032639962155371904, -0.02390117198228836, 0.02753308229148388, 0.030991045758128166, -0.03230374678969383, 0.024957090616226196, 0.012258903123438358, 0.009959380142390728, 0.030842280015349388, -0.016357799991965294, 0.01746128685772419, -0.02799936570227146, 0.009368259459733963, -0.03932737186551094, 0.024351410567760468, 0.003011561231687665, -0.004502195864915848, 0.014562883414328098, -0.002534928498789668, 0.014381366781890392, 0.00021247898985166103, 0.0008317959145642817, 0.03777751699090004, 0.03972868248820305, -0.01597687602043152, -0.00457641901448369, -0.04487496614456177, -0.04202109947800636, 0.012715831398963928, -0.004235456697642803, -0.02017318271100521, 0.04009890928864479, 0.019008483737707138, 0.005734364036470652, 0.01105368323624134, -0.02498510293662548, -0.01822117157280445, -0.04774262011051178, -0.026554135605692863, -0.010582802817225456, 0.023343881592154503, 0.008952404372394085, 0.006179359275847673, -0.033020004630088806, -0.015364466235041618, -0.0037976540625095367, -0.005266433581709862, -0.030880682170391083, 0.011048032902181149, -0.00873440783470869, -0.01575499214231968, 0.04129783436655998, -0.02602786384522915, 0.004750301130115986, -0.01895320974290371, 0.005996569059789181, 0.000058185498346574605, 0.04991156980395317, -0.052471138536930084, 0.05273064970970154, 0.005448148585855961, -0.01869824156165123, -0.03490132465958595, -0.0038450751453638077, 0.00604933500289917, -0.011506406590342522, 0.06758008897304535, 0.03754410892724991, -0.03450174629688263, -0.015057915821671486, 0.018240131437778473, 0.027812601998448372, 0.013573115691542625, 0.011249508708715439, 0.04566879943013191, 0.019591623917222023, -0.06869682669639587, 0.05591152608394623, -0.0029305345378816128, 0.04539293795824051, 0.03033447265625, 0.004853029735386372, -0.0025996551848948, -0.07235226780176163, -0.03453011438250542, -0.01966623030602932, 0.014619001187384129, -0.024816224351525307, -0.025782186537981033, 0.04139867052435875, 0.025486405938863754, -0.05229378491640091, 0.021988552063703537, 0.09550925344228745, 0.00389154814183712, 0.0009612952708266675, -0.05471839755773544, -0.004148420877754688, 0.01882069557905197, -0.02095562405884266, 0.029495004564523697, -0.010069883428514004, -0.009218092076480389, -0.010240986943244934, 0.028892243281006813, -0.0669829472899437, -0.039039965718984604, 0.018048707395792007, 0.0018255386967211962, 0.02666051685810089, 0.013161856681108475, -0.054347917437553406, 0.006046575959771872, 0.04759141430258751, 0.026949290186166763, 0.016237620264291763, 0.03829451650381088, -0.0818566232919693, -0.008559005334973335, 0.05465319752693176, 0.031204815953969955, -0.01768156699836254, -0.003678269684314728, -0.02965659089386463, -0.008853555656969547, 0.024423839524388313, -0.005443707574158907, 0.06038828566670418, 0.02117869257926941, 0.025574294850230217, -0.003986687865108252, -0.005980580113828182, -0.009719137102365494, 0.02455252967774868, 0.010173510760068893, 0.05488686263561249, -0.01496044173836708, -0.016146602109074593, -0.018430260941386223, -0.020388776436448097, 0.016630908474326134, 0.07293061912059784, 0.024615084752440453, 0.01617126353085041, 0.011371217668056488, 0.002832358703017235, -0.02287321910262108, -0.09809811413288116, 0.010372444055974483, -0.03637053444981575, -0.0035675212275236845, 0.027150338515639305, -0.037315625697374344, -0.0007177630322985351, 0.037678495049476624, 0.007862216793000698, -0.04756220802664757, -0.06780655682086945, -0.014785061590373516, 0.03541424125432968, 0.06107277423143387, 0.0014713448472321033, 0.0637926533818245, 0.007205802481621504, 0.0060402099043130875, 0.001883702352643013, 0.005824573803693056, -0.002997596515342593, -0.02636755257844925, 0.02980370819568634, -0.011502193287014961, 0.00453432509675622, -0.05197903886437416, 0.022752316668629646, 0.006272702012211084, 0.07883651554584503, -0.044598814100027084, -0.005432104226201773, -0.028459900990128517, -0.0026831086724996567, -0.020966004580259323, -0.0289267897605896, 0.02612878940999508, 0.03732898831367493, -0.0111635010689497, -0.012433766387403011, 0.032450154423713684, -0.017421463504433632, -0.002864767564460635, -0.013308042660355568, -0.006558517459779978, 0.022471437230706215, -0.03179817274212837, -0.02067691460251808, -0.023467471823096275, -0.03189444541931152, 0.048480406403541565, -0.03265693038702011, 0.02004181407392025, 0.009103660471737385, -0.05083995684981346, -0.03502756729722023, 0.010093341581523418, 0.026677334681153297, 0.08248024433851242, -0.0184041578322649, 0.034990523010492325, 0.001360896392725408, -0.02438296005129814, -0.06165698915719986, -0.047812320291996, 0.02361096441745758, 0.014916912652552128, -0.0475274994969368, -0.015075331553816795, 0.037269484251737595, -0.009439039044082165, -0.016081374138593674, -0.014192883856594563, 0.03328530862927437, -0.010411239229142666, -0.006565292831510305, -0.00046639362699352205, 0.014104652218520641, 0.05801717936992645, -0.0029801176860928535, 0.009802384302020073, -0.0061848158948123455, -0.02080358937382698, -0.015972187742590904, 0.006259134970605373, 0.017758924514055252, -0.04949605092406273, -0.01577824354171753, -0.013200794346630573, -0.0051962994039058685, 0.03120553493499756, -0.013800700195133686, -0.0095444917678833, 0.02158091403543949, -0.02022923156619072, 0.0011931064072996378, -0.0050682611763477325, 0.008699825033545494, 0.01436546165496111, -0.0030429093167185783, -0.013204311020672321, -0.016164282336831093, -0.025685306638479233, 0.014330845326185226, -0.004924587439745665, 0.00008734074071981013, -0.0332992859184742, -0.041224200278520584, 0.07644150406122208, -0.026896856725215912, 0.013744131661951542, 0.025076264515519142, -0.0274711474776268, 0.014784553088247776, 0.016577372327446938, 0.00034933857386931777, -0.01460154540836811, -0.0017086109146475792, -0.039890993386507034, 0.005834680050611496, -0.041618186980485916, 0.0188798438757658, 0.07038576900959015, 0.009727655909955502, 0.03575466200709343, 0.058835193514823914, 0.03104904107749462, -0.001354158972389996, -0.024449117481708527, 0.005222347564995289, -0.01126550417393446, -0.01460122037678957, 0.03971917927265167, 0.000060596736147999763, -0.011293728835880756, 0.05666027590632439, 0.02723291888833046, 0.008558508940041065, 0.017687587067484856, 0.01962605118751526, -0.007744399830698967, 0.05835409462451935, -0.008843800984323025, -0.02696416899561882, 0.028626736253499985, -0.04491880163550377, 0.0016763617750257254, -0.015128840692341328, -0.039431359618902206, 0.06396246701478958, 0.028574295341968536, -0.007291923277080059, -0.02094373293220997, -0.045416731387376785, -0.05298731476068497, 0.010365750640630722, 0.0033319033682346344, -0.05028148368000984, 0.03993901237845421, 0.05023988336324692, 0.01758289523422718, -0.00034566945396363735, 0.034478165209293365, -0.010859458707273006, -0.04429249465465546, 0.006986147724092007, -0.014550515450537205, -0.08048465102910995, -0.023902494460344315, -0.013466879725456238, -0.03434107080101967, 0.030673278495669365, -0.01152307540178299, 0.026709428057074547, 0.012704107910394669, 0.06494314968585968, 0.012915078550577164, 0.042532555758953094, 0.0014134506927803159, 0.02882774919271469, 0.042238228023052216, 0.004729364532977343, 0.11631655693054199, 0.07721557468175888, 0.021992595866322517, -0.06434480100870132, 0.030685171484947205, 0.004516230430454016, -0.0028271612245589495, -0.04305542632937431, 0.028250064700841904, 0.03352021425962448, -0.021382424980401993, 0.05925246700644493, 0.03510143235325813, 0.018051549792289734, -0.02405530959367752, 0.004648386966437101, -0.06477415561676025, -0.02625088579952717, 0.044776394963264465, -0.007641183212399483, 0.023465869948267937, -0.004639103077352047, -0.020330458879470825, 0.010330542922019958, -0.011549201793968678, -0.05035015940666199, -0.009931482374668121, -0.01756460964679718, 0.03177967667579651, -0.010554257780313492, -0.001987103372812271, -0.0034574230667203665, -0.034682925790548325, 0.03572787716984749, 0.0014241730095818639, -0.01662011817097664, 0.005156476981937885, -0.006099421065300703, 0.005102947819977999, 0.039532411843538284, 0.027489371597766876, -0.039311375468969345, 0.01673518866300583, 0.032199833542108536, -0.02703160047531128, -0.017498061060905457, -0.05044201388955116, 0.0343908928334713, -0.020860210061073303, 0.008891302160918713, -0.016150541603565216, -0.011729060672223568, 0.01348964124917984, -0.0454365611076355, -0.009656769223511219, 0.049360305070877075, -0.020951688289642334, -0.04682093486189842, -0.04208182916045189, -0.0025589915458112955, 0.02137843705713749, -0.03841259330511093, 0.030701400712132454, -0.03377694636583328, -0.0507928840816021, -0.019792087376117706, -0.014232703484594822, 0.008196299895644188, 0.0024646143428981304, 0.007469210773706436, -0.005108286626636982, -0.01593041978776455, -0.03656783327460289, -0.01669422537088394, -0.0007566534331999719, 0.012373426929116249, 0.005421781912446022, 0.006061175372451544, -0.007759400177747011, -0.0032985121943056583, -0.07386719435453415, 0.009647363796830177, -0.023876817896962166, -0.012275991030037403, -0.06510814279317856, 0.016284141689538956, 0.053731709718704224, 0.01969359628856182, 0.028126703575253487, -0.004299212712794542, -0.012525182217359543, 0.016011644154787064, 0.03088567592203617, -0.0303359292447567, 0.00721573643386364, 0.010999651625752449, -0.07812158018350601, -0.0008363121305592358, -0.017108535394072533, 0.07738006114959717, 0.03299752250313759, -0.004440084099769592, 0.0011390055296942592, -0.012987950816750526, -0.01190967857837677, -0.003054406028240919, -0.0005553032387979329, -0.0485701858997345, -0.0013830121606588364, 0.006751640699803829, -0.013467567972838879, -0.005299593787640333, -0.009661294519901276, -0.04440804198384285, -0.010461119934916496, 0.0018090070225298405, 0.01864374615252018, -0.005816644988954067, 0.02986731193959713, -0.0005587810301221907, 0.013899508863687515, -0.011189820244908333, 0.02123844437301159, -0.0023046834394335747, 0.01685372181236744, -0.0022602020762860775, 0.016455212607979774, -0.012218696065247059, -0.014251267537474632, 0.03899092599749565, 0.005895907990634441, 0.06201144680380821, 0.0125073017552495, -0.020116614177823067, 0.003119714092463255, -0.01732764206826687, -0.017066096886992455, 0.03700947016477585, -0.02226894348859787, 0.001970356097444892, 0.053885072469711304, -0.06378509849309921, -0.027017921209335327, -0.0038833031430840492, -0.00897733960300684, 0.03396615758538246, 0.03207762911915779, 0.0040808748453855515, -0.02943659946322441, 0.0584784634411335, -0.005515296943485737, -0.016888119280338287, 0.042191874235868454, -0.004167160019278526, 0.013513798825442791, 0.0402076281607151, 0.012383771128952503, -0.013376845978200436, -0.026520250365138054, -0.012193573638796806, 0.03854292258620262, -0.01402417290955782, -0.020903896540403366, 0.020949624478816986, -0.02978452667593956, -0.006977852433919907, 0.04514608904719353, -0.046512067317962646, 0.02196890488266945, 0.04145814850926399, -0.023024434223771095, 0.030937083065509796, -0.03836595267057419, -0.005386549513787031, -0.10063860565423965, -0.02683391608297825, 0.031167494133114815, 0.04305644333362579, 0.05104781314730644, -0.05225755646824837, 0.04954134672880173, 0.049447931349277496, -0.033379316329956055, 0.026538465172052383, 0.0017799936467781663, -0.0018511456437408924, -0.05327498912811279, 0.004752264358103275, -0.009366797283291817, 0.012536867521703243, 0.03184576332569122, 0.006960047874599695, 0.01745385117828846, 0.012221088632941246, -0.021185535937547684, -0.023929109796881676, -0.012974328361451626, 0.008299694396555424, -0.025540126487612724, -0.04810865968465805, 0.0021385266445577145, -0.03718199208378792, -0.05325007066130638, 0.028775159269571304, -0.03602069988846779, 0.01352118980139494, 0.04589604213833809, 0.03051011823117733, 0.012607291340827942, 0.03222299739718437, 0.01061681192368269, -0.01178867369890213, 0.022769838571548462, 0.0013163392432034016, 0.014250235632061958, -0.018272146582603455, -0.018358055502176285, 0.02391958422958851, 0.05098119378089905, 0.02539954148232937, -0.04784698784351349, 0.04087592661380768, -0.004285424016416073, -0.02125760354101658, 0.008418008685112, -0.003062052419409156, 0.024238862097263336, -0.02244909107685089, 0.03055497072637081, -0.037735771387815475, 0.012680643238127232, 0.027399083599448204, 0.026462312787771225, -0.023058850318193436, 0.008756321854889393, -0.021236564964056015, -0.02678091637790203, 0.0021793521009385586, 0.011476743035018444, -0.011114952154457569, -0.04401550814509392, 0.014834309928119183, 0.023335032165050507, -0.04037681221961975, -0.021992873400449753, -0.05666515231132507, -0.027014050632715225, 0.03634621575474739, -0.029901539906859398, -0.014197989366948605, 0.042899683117866516, 0.032119061797857285, 0.016185196116566658, -0.0980643704533577, 0.03828774020075798, -0.016690265387296677, 0.0010941359214484692, 0.012218756601214409, -0.017384858801960945, -0.05683079734444618, 0.015394632704555988, 0.052296243607997894, -0.008690541610121727, -0.023460788652300835, -0.02635153755545616, -0.01967923901975155, 0.009620143100619316, -0.05349151790142059, 0.03721432015299797, -0.055136095732450485, -0.008077945560216904, -0.03435215726494789, -0.04122455418109894, 0.021071383729577065, 0.0395381934940815, -0.008126606233417988, -0.01769191026687622, -0.008416307158768177, -0.00169470370747149, 0.017431002110242844, 0.041303202509880066, -0.0014899956295266747, 0.03448091074824333, 0.06930282711982727, 0.008887297473847866, 0.020510181784629822, -0.010639317333698273, 0.005243841093033552, -0.03878187760710716, 0.02385616861283779, -0.02471650391817093, -0.023589804768562317, -0.02159261330962181, 0.050006281584501266, -0.005308836232870817, -0.07179513573646545, 0.0016709642950445414, 0.017030995339155197, -0.005318772979080677, -0.016948232427239418, 0.0700831487774849, 0.03320305049419403, 0.021361403167247772, -0.022810304537415504, 0.006771626882255077, 0.013856079429388046, 0.012637967243790627, -0.027877675369381905, 0.04358069971203804, 0.03402464836835861, 0.020109467208385468, 0.04283913969993591, 0.03422389551997185, -0.031021570786833763, 0.036804504692554474, 0.0028763930313289165, 0.04271552339196205, 0.008871212601661682, 0.015425270423293114, -0.005797895137220621, 0.008631684817373753, 0.020525475963950157, 0.006505789700895548, -0.020446153357625008, 0.06798745691776276, 0.008540011011064053, 0.02182573266327381, -0.06650383025407791, -0.017872706055641174, -0.05016849935054779, -0.02341453731060028, 0.015185236930847168, 0.018905185163021088, -0.005416763015091419, -0.02696530893445015, -0.014820490032434464, -0.0007790990639477968, 0.04981938377022743, -0.024950861930847168, 0.016901658847928047, -0.009916658513247967, -0.0038348219823092222, -0.06261330097913742, -0.014418641105294228, -0.02065775729715824, -0.021541858091950417, 0.005285428371280432, 0.038892485201358795, 0.012206987477838993, 0.004943594802170992, -0.030065244063735008, -0.00992328580468893, 0.07717742025852203, -0.04800020158290863, -0.0018618067260831594, -0.05717991292476654, 0.03170378506183624, -0.008497253991663456, -0.022686336189508438 ]
<p>I wonder , if someone know the open source anomaly detection algorithm on computer log ? For an example , computer log look like as mentioned below :</p> <p>"value UL-CCCH-Message ::= { integrityCheckInfo { messageAuthenticationCode 0, rrc-MessageSequenceNumber 0 }, message cellUpdate : { u-RNTI { srnc-Identity 232, s-RNTI 178710 }, startList { { cn-DomainIdentity ps-domain, start-Value 58 } }, am-RLC-ErrorIndicationRb2-3or4 FALSE, am-RLC-ErrorIndicationRb5orAbove FALSE, cellUpdateCause cellReselection, rb-timer-indicator { t314-expired FALSE, t315-expired FALSE }, measuredResultsOnRACH { currentCell { modeSpecificInfo fdd : { measurementQuantity cpich-Ec-N0 : 24 } } } }"</p> <p>there is way , i could extract features from logs and apply anomaly detection on time series data but there is also one other way is that i will discover general pattern from log automatically and make rule/ criteria , if future log belong to general pattern , if not not then its anomaly . I want to know any algoritm to find automatic pattern discovery in logs . </p> <p>Please share your ideas, if you have expertise in it.</p> <p>Thanks Kind Regard, Sash</p>
35,983
[ -0.013893515802919865, 0.009934207424521446, -0.014245004393160343, -0.01713409647345543, 0.009488431736826897, -0.0055974735878407955, 0.003247041255235672, -0.006775485351681709, 0.013393787667155266, -0.03935295715928078, 0.04242078587412834, 0.046219754964113235, 0.021611174568533897, 0.05400877445936203, 0.04780983552336693, -0.05592181533575058, -0.030997131019830704, 0.014792199246585369, -0.01203864999115467, -0.014848909340798855, 0.0005692612612619996, -0.029361378401517868, -0.005790822207927704, -0.0052665830589830875, -0.026743104681372643, 0.025457482784986496, 0.01804094761610031, -0.009245256893336773, 0.025494521483778954, 0.06870563328266144, -0.019403288140892982, 0.0072662183083593845, -0.017671896144747734, -0.005436988081783056, 0.020896675065159798, -0.0229670237749815, -0.03179369866847992, 0.009789091534912586, -0.002326594665646553, 0.04242567718029022, -0.028838373720645905, -0.03503265604376793, 0.007738333661109209, 0.06029806658625603, -0.00376780959777534, -0.030988486483693123, -0.0230863019824028, -0.006301018875092268, 0.04270090535283089, -0.08317974209785461, 0.07554828375577927, -0.04456867650151253, 0.07694894075393677, -0.016444697976112366, -0.02043592929840088, -0.003097622422501445, 0.03924107924103737, 0.07878482341766357, -0.02427714131772518, -0.03724577650427818, -0.042463354766368866, 0.0038410744164139032, 0.010803286917507648, -0.030015988275408745, -0.04731447622179985, 0.057237815111875534, -0.04873690381646156, -0.030260693281888962, 0.04679656773805618, 0.00440044654533267, -0.008332563564181328, -0.010730253532528877, 0.024665018543601036, -0.019916033372282982, -0.000036365960113471374, -0.04635053873062134, -0.007616864982992411, 0.013631481677293777, -0.013585221953690052, 0.04856092482805252, 0.01946180872619152, 0.010152902454137802, -0.015801772475242615, 0.007425324525684118, 0.039526551961898804, 0.013353916816413403, 0.10599199682474136, -0.05195760726928711, 0.010235488414764404, 0.02893696539103985, -0.00513239111751318, -0.0013190797762945294, 0.04145131632685661, 0.02210741676390171, -0.043412189930677414, 0.010029343888163567, 0.009704643860459328, 0.03289828076958656, -0.011890931986272335, -0.011394414119422436, 0.025967590510845184, -0.02124125137925148, -0.005681887734681368, 0.03413473814725876, -0.06284289807081223, 0.023870039731264114, -0.049427229911088943, 0.01843595691025257, -0.0007766321650706232, 0.021454742178320885, -0.01757633313536644, -0.0008122908184304833, 0.0034196011256426573, -0.027287304401397705, -0.006453437730669975, 0.009216218255460262, -0.022372014820575714, -0.016507014632225037, 0.02767140418291092, 0.050604548305273056, 0.03970196470618248, -0.0013040390331298113, 0.024804579094052315, -0.0581958144903183, -0.02815077267587185, 0.02803725004196167, 0.013031127862632275, -0.029247494414448738, -0.015089965425431728, 0.04558371752500534, -0.022290542721748352, -0.07741619646549225, 0.03177981451153755, -0.019590100273489952, 0.05524623766541481, -0.03410026803612709, -0.08710034936666489, -0.036610446870326996, 0.045724399387836456, 0.017401715740561485, 0.027836963534355164, -0.026079177856445312, -0.02023269794881344, 0.055712997913360596, 0.053190212696790695, 0.04485858976840973, 0.017999891191720963, 0.035438891500234604, -0.03560589998960495, 0.0019540272187441587, -0.027808688580989838, -0.017873838543891907, -0.0016369418008252978, -0.023655496537685394, 0.009242645464837551, -0.054312143474817276, 0.006736248265951872, -0.02038794755935669, -0.027734242379665375, 0.0018402807181701064, 0.01105903834104538, 0.037186149507761, -0.025661034509539604, 0.002129884669557214, 0.03192617744207382, -0.02856634557247162, 0.07545606791973114, -0.03046186827123165, 0.020462580025196075, 0.040471259504556656, -0.004205404315143824, 0.020144665613770485, 0.03174123167991638, 0.011580980382859707, 0.057616639882326126, -0.010560641065239906, -0.05690519139170647, 0.0038603025022894144, -0.009997442364692688, -0.02320091985166073, -0.020488454028964043, -0.05002462863922119, 0.0052245683036744595, -0.004545710515230894, -0.00879669189453125, 0.019611842930316925, -0.011981911957263947, -0.030518602579832077, 0.057785242795944214, -0.053746215999126434, -0.009591122157871723, -0.037186797708272934, 0.018248992040753365, -0.029088307172060013, -0.0021526177879422903, 0.0468251071870327, -0.01389304082840681, 0.009166435338556767, -0.015417637303471565, -0.02575722523033619, -0.01747749000787735, -0.01348218321800232, 0.0040280516259372234, -0.04237319156527519, -0.007030878681689501, -0.005886301398277283, -0.012273699976503849, -0.0517103485763073, 0.018913306295871735, -0.018283456563949585, -0.0354682058095932, -0.012004501186311245, -0.05937192589044571, 0.0008714683935977519, -0.024484125897288322, 0.014574921689927578, 0.038690682500600815, -0.0016681012930348516, -0.012862658128142357, -0.02070191688835621, -0.002924196422100067, 0.06073298305273056, 0.048144690692424774, 0.06715651601552963, -0.005447654984891415, -0.010935989208519459, 0.01561372634023428, -0.022577742114663124, -0.014814275316894054, -0.015972448512911797, -0.06613258272409439, -0.03991221264004707, 0.03263425827026367, 0.03598598763346672, -0.02971472032368183, 0.0380234532058239, 0.04003384709358215, 0.02437620982527733, -0.0026108440943062305, 0.03614187613129616, -0.02292446792125702, 0.007460405584424734, -0.005077782552689314, 0.04792946204543114, -0.007963352836668491, 0.004193905740976334, 0.02620732970535755, 0.019262276589870453, 0.020833350718021393, -0.015437664464116096, -0.04207118600606918, 0.01125060673803091, -0.0172566045075655, 0.0370374470949173, -0.0028118041809648275, -0.039404768496751785, 0.026000957936048508, -0.008282875642180443, 0.004994428250938654, 0.011769675649702549, 0.010940485633909702, 0.03210704028606415, 0.011642140336334705, -0.008101672865450382, -0.013137507252395153, 0.0064714946784079075, -0.033507898449897766, -0.02374240756034851, 0.013881810940802097, -0.051678236573934555, 0.0196809321641922, 0.004359782673418522, 0.0021467660553753376, -0.0668804794549942, 0.022614944726228714, 0.039833687245845795, -0.0018034522654488683, -0.0035139466635882854, 0.01595061458647251, -0.02628202550113201, 0.019349418580532074, -0.04092279076576233, -0.0010693382937461138, -0.001788079272955656, -0.022944219410419464, 0.03353255242109299, 0.015101035125553608, -0.012291055172681808, 0.018478214740753174, -0.011111914180219173, 0.027621300891041756, 0.005289506632834673, 0.01035545114427805, -0.06715568155050278, -0.026554126292467117, 0.0032296422868967056, 0.02046571671962738, -0.0015622829087078571, 0.009846768341958523, 0.028293905779719353, 0.01200982928276062, -0.049335964024066925, 0.013526794500648975, -0.04563843831419945, -0.01325540617108345, -0.02704106643795967, -0.03158451244235039, 0.0009236710029654205, -0.008961034007370472, 0.03147846460342407, -0.015456178225576878, -0.04282015934586525, 0.01868683472275734, -0.03955182805657387, -0.025726882740855217, 0.01527024433016777, 0.0112478481605649, 0.033086106181144714, 0.0076760826632380486, -0.023272084072232246, 0.009021352045238018, 0.034463051706552505, -0.06869073957204819, -0.05662361532449722, -0.029217422008514404, -0.04387379437685013, -0.04116715490818024, 0.035101521760225296, 0.03389275074005127, 0.03488508611917496, -0.005634286906570196, 0.021747799590229988, 0.008337864652276039, 0.03657523915171623, 0.05819278210401535, -0.04106324911117554, 0.025189604610204697, 0.021815797314047813, -0.019760459661483765, 0.023367203772068024, 0.0008079208782874048, 0.003835679730400443, 0.0015009689377620816, 0.025048699229955673, -0.004677559249103069, 0.05374092236161232, -0.02704092301428318, 0.01663636974990368, -0.008257032372057438, 0.0033369518350809813, 0.007308315951377153, -0.015551665797829628, 0.0034724611323326826, -0.0011524541769176722, -0.013822315260767937, 0.023083433508872986, 0.010269686579704285, -0.019884446635842323, 0.011418535374104977, 0.07838573306798935, 0.004559657070785761, -0.021291276440024376, -0.03595120832324028, -0.024243474006652832, -0.05422914773225784, 0.017313804477453232, -0.05038612335920334, -0.021505922079086304, 0.0339994952082634, 0.054012101143598557, 0.053229667246341705, -0.01455322839319706, -0.039332419633865356, 0.016461580991744995, -0.06400703638792038, -0.007684500887989998, -0.00927735585719347, 0.10311581939458847, -0.008142968639731407, 0.013005412183701992, 0.057003203779459, -0.03615879267454147, 0.04450855404138565, -0.019842591136693954, -0.08376599848270416, 0.04143967106938362, -0.0010481985518708825, -0.006415264215320349, 0.006532137282192707, -0.03295353427529335, 0.012875485233962536, 0.001332287210971117, -0.015060771256685257, 0.008655773475766182, 0.035019438713788986, -0.046168483793735504, 0.02445087395608425, -0.03048020415008068, -0.0041573019698262215, -0.022807925939559937, -0.0024275225587189198, 0.008627437055110931, -0.0034269795287400484, 0.021126504987478256, 0.023119047284126282, 0.018325962126255035, -0.042725659906864166, -0.038094207644462585, 0.01426333375275135, -0.0010035039158537984, 0.052553847432136536, 0.0075409929268062115, -0.004250994883477688, -0.06556330621242523, 0.017071859911084175, -0.03638619929552078, 0.005810556001961231, 0.013551604934036732, 0.0199337936937809, -0.012768269516527653, -0.026296475902199745, 0.0097330491989851, 0.016613557934761047, 0.027148684486746788, 0.0013728456106036901, 0.03225881978869438, 0.020922837778925896, -0.02578473649919033, -0.054834552109241486, 0.035888321697711945, 0.08428977429866791, 0.028208380565047264, -0.03893111273646355, -0.003986107651144266, -0.010363385081291199, 0.014542228542268276, -0.025912463665008545, 0.0021116561256349087, -0.01820812001824379, -0.03183380514383316, -0.019338341429829597, 0.010508614592254162, -0.024278104305267334, -0.03488998860120773, -0.028126675635576248, 0.04659326747059822, 0.013419052585959435, 0.031465787440538406, 0.011200170032680035, 0.04099756479263306, 0.006411787122488022, 0.0547526478767395, 0.03281811997294426, 0.0060942997224628925, -0.10235374420881271, 0.03257983922958374, 0.0656295195221901, 0.04667183756828308, -0.01604420505464077, -0.000478825211757794, -0.021267972886562347, -0.001540313707664609, 0.04441705718636513, -0.026901457458734512, 0.022981522604823112, -0.04220336675643921, 0.0273786298930645, -0.0136455949395895, 0.01295346487313509, -0.005414481274783611, 0.025482606142759323, 0.013103812001645565, 0.015210778452455997, -0.04600674286484718, -0.03720638155937195, -0.04060075804591179, -0.010087946429848671, 0.016024231910705566, 0.04905641824007034, 0.007226668298244476, 0.009249581955373287, -0.002556689316406846, 0.039348162710666656, -0.023592179641127586, -0.045862387865781784, -0.01096566766500473, 0.004351977724581957, 0.0147633021697402, 0.023949768394231796, -0.009045435115695, 0.012999170459806919, -0.03697464242577553, 0.006353574804961681, -0.03335287794470787, -0.058702509850263596, 0.002291332231834531, 0.033482976257801056, 0.0509408600628376, -0.007674101740121841, 0.033979058265686035, 0.054148320108652115, 0.01711650751531124, -0.010963888838887215, -0.014924115501344204, 0.026533454656600952, -0.05057466775178909, 0.0006827422766946256, -0.012480214238166809, 0.033887192606925964, -0.026152685284614563, 0.06266633421182632, -0.0018799635581672192, 0.019284306094050407, -0.02250928059220314, 0.003119124798104167, -0.02320195734500885, 0.03734371438622475, -0.019088290631771088, 0.015621925704181194, 0.020794294774532318, 0.04239315912127495, -0.025749454274773598, -0.0194206815212965, -0.005736385937780142, -0.03656164929270744, -0.011646401137113571, 0.0013138167560100555, -0.015629764646291733, 0.019040949642658234, 0.002174561843276024, 0.009463077411055565, -0.0014187423512339592, -0.017208924517035484, 0.048909205943346024, 0.010444428771734238, 0.02248166874051094, 0.036940380930900574, -0.040119294077157974, 0.011992358602583408, 0.03693004325032234, -0.0038967325817793608, 0.03931454196572304, -0.03806626796722412, 0.03950178623199463, -0.01346642803400755, -0.01866975612938404, -0.10273031145334244, -0.07038473337888718, 0.02789892442524433, -0.015633314847946167, -0.040766630321741104, -0.019591938704252243, -0.00914851576089859, 0.014527898281812668, -0.008168191649019718, 0.0011911052279174328, 0.03453846275806427, 0.00027629928081296384, -0.015431488864123821, 0.04172800853848457, 0.020609907805919647, 0.06428483128547668, 0.012730696238577366, 0.04283323511481285, -0.04095866158604622, 0.015315364114940166, -0.015846244990825653, 0.0070121618919074535, -0.018936870619654655, -0.023010998964309692, -0.025005629286170006, -0.032578207552433014, 0.015222853049635887, 0.009789908304810524, -0.03475058823823929, 0.010340718552470207, 0.014076171442866325, 0.05105273425579071, -0.005006834864616394, -0.021310703828930855, 0.008099649101495743, 0.017414318397641182, -0.02821079082787037, 0.0047591920010745525, -0.02032100223004818, -0.016399797052145004, -0.03202356770634651, 0.006359717343002558, 0.017212076112627983, 0.01808750256896019, 0.04232921451330185, 0.014301580376923084, -0.007523751351982355, -0.02272600494325161, 0.004697274882346392, -0.0003397283726371825, 0.0018362511182203889, -0.03412466123700142, 0.004443279001861811, -0.008212498389184475, -0.006198911461979151, -0.035537637770175934, -0.050004687160253525, 0.000059903984947595745, -0.019737303256988525, 0.04608624801039696, 0.003371403319761157, 0.05313549190759659, 0.02724323607981205, 0.02460864558815956, -0.01982833445072174, -0.025390753522515297, -0.014635090716183186, 0.007467591669410467, 0.02810874581336975, 0.02403765730559826, -0.02543327771127224, 0.0267792958766222, -0.006238741800189018, 0.017644697800278664, 0.008029326796531677, 0.057693492621183395, 0.045314572751522064, 0.054022252559661865, 0.05829523131251335, 0.00022983059170655906, -0.042745064944028854, -0.004419181030243635, -0.040821678936481476, -0.00037972538848407567, 0.019076714292168617, -0.020544085651636124, 0.05519784614443779, 0.02928852289915085, -0.030964545905590057, 0.006067746318876743, -0.0006648317212238908, -0.05330170318484306, 0.03291803598403931, 0.0183249544352293, -0.005895519163459539, 0.04079011455178261, 0.016259003430604935, 0.04407639801502228, 0.040337298065423965, 0.009504804387688637, -0.012067977339029312, -0.07812672853469849, -0.04394238814711571, -0.01269601285457611, -0.04624316096305847, 0.03380516171455383, -0.0004440109769348055, -0.04613598808646202, 0.008242545649409294, 0.022671928629279137, 0.01954534836113453, 0.05606871843338013, 0.0737445130944252, 0.0022548725828528404, 0.06394826620817184, -0.025700941681861877, -0.00034129820414818823, -0.008972959592938423, -0.003537215292453766, 0.10709405690431595, 0.08962628990411758, 0.02265729382634163, -0.09753385931253433, -0.0013623035047203302, -0.0036942597944289446, -0.000052448114729486406, -0.0562463141977787, 0.04507889226078987, -0.006031539291143417, -0.002153039211407304, 0.050401654094457626, 0.03921518102288246, 0.0070806629955768585, 0.04220708832144737, 0.06972644478082657, -0.0075048841536045074, -0.02980033867061138, 0.0052086301147937775, 0.03272687643766403, -0.015666795894503593, 0.017993811517953873, -0.07943931967020035, 0.04505496099591255, 0.00669292826205492, -0.0359155535697937, 0.008249402046203613, -0.0312918983399868, 0.01952093280851841, 0.0037913371343165636, -0.00955403596162796, 0.02133585326373577, -0.00974842719733715, -0.003252434078603983, -0.009405266493558884, -0.016726287081837654, -0.008307510055601597, 0.008866099640727043, 0.006809552665799856, 0.01129539217799902, 0.061606764793395996, -0.054038964211940765, 0.007778888568282127, 0.006476555950939655, -0.026093821972608566, 0.0015207770047709346, -0.030069522559642792, 0.0352918840944767, -0.008693997748196125, -0.014973567798733711, -0.006158142816275358, -0.0314265713095665, -0.027135564014315605, -0.01859399490058422, -0.01180970948189497, -0.015002136118710041, 0.04396272078156471, -0.024659138172864914, -0.04071817919611931, -0.023000434041023254, 0.0006256792112253606, -0.01197156310081482, 0.03720124065876007, -0.011610993184149265, -0.013014376163482666, -0.02759876474738121, -0.02636145055294037, -0.0009621583158150315, -0.006310885772109032, 0.0015664820093661547, 0.01811438985168934, -0.00956412497907877, -0.012835364788770676, -0.019773194566369057, 0.02539823204278946, 0.023211028426885605, 0.0345761701464653, 0.02158663049340248, -0.015025942586362362, 0.012217126786708832, -0.04461321234703064, 0.016194893047213554, -0.051406435668468475, 0.008362178690731525, -0.05545587092638016, -0.005261261947453022, 0.05659613385796547, 0.0355338528752327, 0.015209986828267574, -0.0002757824840955436, 0.010687854140996933, 0.03974590077996254, 0.01277643721550703, -0.03359779715538025, -0.04838068038225174, -0.011093760840594769, -0.03817043825984001, 0.0027737056370824575, -0.019254880025982857, 0.03730245679616928, 0.04054286330938339, -0.030091766268014908, -0.007873409427702427, 0.0416036881506443, -0.026560883969068527, 0.00950845517218113, -0.0002574594400357455, -0.007988759316504002, -0.036760114133358, -0.021717317402362823, -0.0017212125239893794, -0.01502999383956194, -0.052029043436050415, -0.027386732399463654, 0.00019962865917477757, 0.02849145419895649, 0.023171627894043922, -0.05462183803319931, 0.02854842133820057, -0.011127938516438007, 0.0028571123257279396, -0.030778793618083, 0.021463992074131966, -0.019018836319446564, -0.018583698198199272, -0.026137087494134903, -0.04269608482718468, -0.01594369299709797, 0.026569964364171028, -0.01745223067700863, -0.011962306685745716, 0.04015568643808365, 0.026908528059720993, -0.0030364447738975286, 0.02138449251651764, 0.0021309833973646164, -0.052259739488363266, 0.029194381088018417, -0.03001479245722294, -0.029209235683083534, 0.034844424575567245, -0.08707904815673828, -0.015365028753876686, 0.040447574108839035, 0.00383678637444973, 0.006223001517355442, 0.03592783957719803, 0.008624428883194923, 0.029181381687521935, 0.05541174113750458, 0.005086556077003479, 0.008148491382598877, -0.014949425123631954, 0.030483542010188103, -0.0038494737818837166, 0.031260572373867035, 0.031080441549420357, -0.009318419732153416, -0.026237180456519127, -0.019484754651784897, 0.06131827458739281, 0.033348191529512405, 0.00019213931227568537, 0.0162460096180439, 0.01408364623785019, 0.0185906570404768, 0.011608703061938286, -0.004905558191239834, 0.04200303182005882, 0.027192430570721626, -0.04143531993031502, 0.014591793529689312, 0.009758466854691505, 0.00678282231092453, -0.04546143114566803, 0.005137382075190544, 0.008222117088735104, 0.013090412132441998, 0.012251215986907482, -0.033482521772384644, 0.010482930578291416, 0.050320301204919815, -0.0035409575793892145, -0.021767960861325264, -0.01942884549498558, -0.02376859076321125, -0.007025869097560644, 0.019316045567393303, -0.03052888996899128, 0.009023376740515232, 0.020981067791581154, 0.026757122948765755, 0.04290067404508591, 0.031069042161107063, -0.021404339000582695, -0.020945588126778603, -0.014658651314675808, 0.006750840228050947, 0.06355085223913193, -0.018758399412035942, 0.03762056678533554, -0.06168210506439209, -0.02267821878194809, 0.021113863214850426, -0.02773125097155571, 0.012261115945875645, 0.04490291699767113, 0.015509160235524178, 0.000624965294264257, 0.037508849054574966, -0.002392237540334463, -0.03987891972064972, -0.0039189597591757774, 0.0007475560996681452, -0.004157691262662411, 0.030650489032268524, 0.0005917748203501105, 0.03707496449351311, -0.0019221606198698282, -0.012544354423880577, -0.004904086235910654, 0.003574450733140111, -0.0017171549843624234, -0.015585055574774742, -0.012652658857405186, 0.0020087799057364464, 0.006064615212380886, -0.012706466019153595, -0.01753656566143036, -0.019300470128655434, 0.016639623790979385, 0.036884650588035583, 0.05018846318125725, -0.01961272396147251, 0.0016260751290246844, -0.002505512908101082, -0.04644240066409111, 0.05135886371135712, 0.012518754228949547, -0.011043928563594818, -0.0620003342628479, 0.008313002996146679, -0.054622210562229156, -0.023545289412140846, -0.013044594787061214, 0.014224644750356674, 0.008819321170449257, 0.0784829705953598, -0.019260959699749947, -0.005076452624052763, 0.055549267679452896, -0.007411572616547346, 0.018600130453705788, -0.03628568351268768, 0.07043390721082687, -0.018484674394130707, -0.004766021389514208, -0.01931431144475937, -0.016991373151540756, -0.03309181332588196, 0.01905723661184311, 0.02501588873565197, -0.03951607644557953, 0.018675897270441055, -0.05454782396554947, 0.03524331375956535, -0.02033303491771221, -0.012008165940642357, 0.04255756735801697, -0.013593933545053005, -0.046002306044101715, 0.028727145865559578, -0.044607874006032944, -0.0035362665075808764, 0.003563150530681014, 0.015615294687449932, -0.013679003342986107, -0.03485461324453354, -0.0001318264548899606, -0.047165267169475555, 0.018405098468065262, 0.014367963187396526, -0.0022536879405379295, 0.06877756863832474, -0.03947410732507706, -0.015455175191164017, 0.020948421210050583, 0.011499130167067051, -0.030491309240460396, 0.04737057909369469, -0.055718258023262024, -0.003910955972969532, 0.03090924769639969, 0.021732596680521965, 0.015812769532203674, -0.05803339555859566, -0.027059709653258324, 0.020447997376322746, 0.007115515414625406, 0.012036171741783619, 0.05211036279797554, -0.02522154524922371, 0.05023609846830368, 0.014719280414283276, 0.04008733481168747, 0.01196548156440258, -0.01818525232374668, -0.010583301074802876, 0.044007547199726105, -0.010361704975366592, -0.02436855621635914, 0.04850088059902191, 0.012287904508411884, -0.0009234141325578094, 0.045642632991075516, -0.0012219914933666587, 0.015721118077635765, -0.006351396907120943, 0.00029806647216901183, 0.01542117353528738, -0.0341029055416584, 0.020696355029940605, 0.004862592089921236, -0.054355770349502563, 0.06877385079860687, -0.06002330407500267, 0.008788597770035267, -0.0650375634431839, -0.043186090886592865, -0.03271915018558502, 0.015676535665988922, 0.0094258151948452, 0.015279396437108517, -0.0022441567853093147, 0.05032775178551674, 0.056900203227996826, 0.026918064802885056, 0.033707618713378906, -0.018864357843995094, 0.012242133729159832, -0.0457034595310688, 0.023287242278456688, 0.018550949171185493, -0.06017160415649414, -0.030212251469492912, -0.03682517632842064, 0.01335412822663784, 0.034696418792009354, 0.02833125740289688, -0.010183821432292461, -0.011588635854423046, -0.03592035919427872, 0.05210244655609131, -0.06279075890779495, 0.030397066846489906, -0.02338721789419651, 0.001991947880014777, -0.036203209310770035, -0.015218427404761314 ]
<p>I have general statistical question concerning the analysis of two-factorial experiments. I would like to compare several response variables (biovolume, richness etc.) of two experiments (homogeneous and heterogeneous) with the same factorial combination (dispersal x disturbance).</p> <p>I guess a ANOVA or nested ANOVA is not the appropriate method, since both experiments are conducted seperately from each other... </p> <p>Has somebody an idea what would be the best way to realize it in R? </p> <p>Thanks in advance,</p> <p>Nils </p>
73,578
[ -0.029099851846694946, -0.027694661170244217, 0.007854080758988857, 0.04734332859516144, 0.013412362895905972, -0.020464777946472168, 0.034268852323293686, -0.009055716916918755, 0.049240581691265106, -0.023991892114281654, 0.013603636994957924, 0.05038588494062424, 0.07735178619623184, 0.03336593508720398, 0.016533682122826576, -0.017159879207611084, -0.031456056982278824, -0.0006054780096746981, 0.000503973220475018, -0.0006341521511785686, -0.0013696181122213602, -0.027189211919903755, -0.0035825525410473347, -0.00205555884167552, -0.021819088608026505, 0.06837870925664902, 0.018694572150707245, -0.007731389254331589, 0.007526622153818607, 0.055327158421278, -0.05485013872385025, -0.01656159944832325, -0.018487822264432907, 0.036873698234558105, 0.017103927209973335, -0.002347682137042284, -0.03117130510509014, -0.005695946980267763, -0.030096206814050674, 0.018953032791614532, -0.03475593402981758, -0.05562485009431839, -0.006220132578164339, 0.03051851876080036, 0.004430775996297598, 0.027870146557688713, -0.0015937209827825427, 0.005267712753266096, 0.06493812799453735, -0.03877873718738556, 0.07112386077642441, 0.029269319027662277, 0.025471432134509087, 0.050207287073135376, 0.01007801666855812, 0.013911401852965355, 0.0628473311662674, 0.036725953221321106, -0.008542129769921303, -0.06479950994253159, -0.028653280809521675, -0.05224476009607315, 0.016515173017978668, -0.009204737842082977, -0.047922518104314804, 0.010245105251669884, -0.0188986174762249, -0.03429071977734566, 0.06086016818881035, -0.013749190606176853, 0.021336080506443977, -0.02209925651550293, 0.058489926159381866, 0.00042078911792486906, 0.0032549838069826365, -0.012206311337649822, 0.032312892377376556, 0.013585107401013374, -0.010562931187450886, 0.03342309594154358, -0.02319757454097271, 0.03559534624218941, 0.004842916037887335, 0.026934148743748665, 0.024795986711978912, -0.02104795351624489, 0.04969393461942673, -0.04451139643788338, -0.008527088910341263, -0.006383802276104689, -0.03168736398220062, -0.02829577587544918, 0.08384662121534348, 0.03269965946674347, -0.03166605904698372, 0.013030247762799263, -0.015362736769020557, 0.020175136625766754, -0.013543796725571156, -0.015500280074775219, -0.00888840388506651, -0.018535440787672997, 0.044546179473400116, 0.04891304671764374, -0.004255614243447781, -0.005687743425369263, -0.06390242278575897, -0.011705523356795311, -0.03156303986907005, -0.018163062632083893, -0.004842584952712059, 0.042384929955005646, 0.0057030655443668365, 0.004535096697509289, 0.024894822388887405, -0.039671555161476135, -0.030893972143530846, -0.013388797640800476, 0.08686912059783936, 0.10040423274040222, 0.0380270816385746, -0.03525944799184799, 0.03740428388118744, -0.022453157231211662, -0.04162822663784027, 0.004828896839171648, 0.044864267110824585, 0.020707201212644577, -0.017598843201994896, 0.07662881910800934, -0.014112422242760658, 0.002485468750819564, 0.030759841203689575, -0.009670840576291084, 0.010927608236670494, -0.019430069252848625, -0.08460602909326553, -0.06996352970600128, 0.019267214462161064, -0.017952071502804756, 0.02030206471681595, -0.06597863882780075, 0.0007365758647210896, 0.0024588413070887327, 0.04381076619029045, 0.011404087767004967, 0.038896068930625916, -0.005425455514341593, 0.03724901005625725, 0.02730950154364109, -0.015729177743196487, -0.0325106717646122, -0.01646202616393566, -0.02417643554508686, -0.003514473093673587, -0.0938754454255104, 0.005808304063975811, -0.01833118125796318, 0.013833796605467796, 0.03126395121216774, 0.06736565381288528, -0.006191811989992857, -0.007437914609909058, -0.020510807633399963, 0.030705401673913002, 0.01745089702308178, 0.06069662794470787, -0.021244477480649948, 0.032445136457681656, 0.016764428466558456, -0.022788790985941887, 0.00046487650251947343, 0.022209491580724716, 0.021873097866773605, 0.007378180976957083, -0.021109482273459435, 0.0014910412719473243, -0.03028287924826145, 0.0023598901461809874, 0.03530212864279747, -0.016525395214557648, -0.005398490000516176, -0.029417745769023895, -0.02452596090734005, 0.03175458684563637, 0.04425608366727829, -0.0012839604169130325, -0.013937145471572876, 0.03225177899003029, -0.020282510668039322, -0.02755422331392765, -0.07433945685625076, -0.0018219894263893366, 0.012786288745701313, -0.02749241143465042, 0.025998713448643684, 0.022183500230312347, 0.016815107315778732, 0.0036468931939452887, -0.0066895983181893826, -0.046346478164196014, 0.007503641303628683, 0.021175509318709373, -0.035543762147426605, 0.0053902254439890385, 0.025803659111261368, 0.054251205176115036, -0.03355834633111954, 0.05255721136927605, -0.019523197785019875, -0.051860321313142776, -0.007310166954994202, -0.028660355135798454, 0.0016440775943920016, 0.019170254468917847, -0.03012659400701523, 0.009781827218830585, 0.021724965423345566, -0.03273683413863182, 0.033127933740615845, -0.06804311275482178, 0.05745180323719978, 0.08962801098823547, 0.04535834118723869, 0.034988678991794586, 0.009017382748425007, 0.0014267036458477378, 0.03604471683502197, -0.04523766040802002, 0.002182454103603959, -0.024981394410133362, 0.03136248514056206, 0.04813595861196518, 0.025057824328541756, -0.019227875396609306, 0.01903524249792099, 0.009544636122882366, -0.0013546559493988752, 0.038483716547489166, 0.05821533128619194, 0.01789463311433792, -0.008805923163890839, 0.008810881525278091, 0.06194855272769928, 0.0043877046555280685, 0.012462406419217587, 0.04123816266655922, -0.022355178371071815, 0.049464594572782516, -0.02608017437160015, 0.010285922326147556, 0.04281298816204071, -0.008486855775117874, 0.020700158551335335, -0.031070679426193237, 0.015924258157610893, 0.03654443100094795, -0.013742465525865555, 0.006583952810615301, 0.045393601059913635, 0.013823424465954304, -0.029973691329360008, 0.010148434899747372, 0.018953898921608925, 0.035655029118061066, 0.009087720885872841, -0.02231474220752716, 0.000958406541030854, 0.015626447275280952, -0.043396953493356705, 0.02294357679784298, -0.021510567516088486, -0.0022639473900198936, -0.04233430698513985, -0.003829103661701083, 0.038832228630781174, 0.012995545752346516, 0.016301510855555534, -0.011952931992709637, -0.02526424080133438, -0.011235669255256653, -0.04538940265774727, 0.0016342122107744217, 0.008549284189939499, -0.03932686895132065, 0.018942655995488167, -0.027054859325289726, 0.01758052408695221, 0.01813448779284954, -0.02089683897793293, -0.031223086640238762, 0.041881099343299866, 0.007315217517316341, -0.04492601007223129, -0.015039239078760147, -0.028742585331201553, 0.0037482960615307093, -0.011664632707834244, -0.018467865884304047, 0.03257351368665695, 0.013475952669978142, -0.022412454709410667, -0.0017577637918293476, -0.022359924390912056, -0.018579233437776566, 0.014837217517197132, -0.018049996346235275, 0.007514919154345989, 0.011789883486926556, 0.008375345729291439, 0.026123598217964172, -0.049577564001083374, -0.016964299604296684, -0.08551833778619766, -0.05613524839282036, 0.0016746720066294074, 0.002981242025271058, 0.03525705263018608, -0.024346541613340378, -0.003960629925131798, 0.03590518608689308, 0.01995186321437359, -0.029724162071943283, -0.06475106626749039, -0.03761235252022743, -0.03153509646654129, 0.016144270077347755, 0.02473120577633381, -0.026552869006991386, -0.004241825081408024, 0.03422308713197708, 0.006907852832227945, 0.03309684619307518, 0.03013947792351246, 0.03423691913485527, -0.014033927582204342, 0.028070705011487007, 0.029002182185649872, -0.04269633814692497, 0.011985319666564465, 0.01147828996181488, -0.0193796306848526, 0.021808214485645294, -0.012747994624078274, 0.001389949000440538, 0.002601642394438386, -0.009069278836250305, -0.023022709414362907, 0.004452498629689217, 0.03240972384810448, -0.022554416209459305, 0.00405380642041564, 0.005417932290583849, -0.0035896925255656242, 0.005916313733905554, -0.0018455305835232139, 0.0640227273106575, -0.021500563248991966, -0.004695278592407703, 0.06406658887863159, 0.07648510485887527, -0.0233798585832119, -0.012524799443781376, -0.01531556248664856, 0.009451480582356453, 0.00215745996683836, 0.004043086897581816, -0.012265990488231182, 0.036597102880477905, -0.0045966580510139465, 0.018501585349440575, -0.021658942103385925, -0.014146946370601654, 0.024329228326678276, -0.0599590428173542, 0.03169217333197594, -0.07321479916572571, 0.05577521026134491, -0.016543710604310036, 0.009138633497059345, -0.002287898911163211, -0.011403960175812244, -0.0022056582383811474, -0.028971798717975616, -0.052097007632255554, 0.042956870049238205, 0.009810586459934711, 0.010159273631870747, 0.010315238498151302, -0.00652060704305768, 0.009041832759976387, -0.007258214987814426, 0.04266535863280296, 0.0114259859547019, 0.023325100541114807, -0.001642451505176723, 0.001603223499841988, -0.004311435390263796, -0.04640708863735199, -0.0382964089512825, -0.002554770093411207, -0.0005531044444069266, -0.0281473770737648, 0.024430306628346443, 0.005306737031787634, -0.024479808285832405, 0.01418667659163475, -0.01638544350862503, -0.005244547501206398, 0.019250692799687386, 0.04818081483244896, -0.0029886404518038034, 0.04046323895454407, -0.038259852677583694, 0.0533733107149601, 0.014078236185014248, 0.05722795054316521, 0.004480442963540554, 0.029702167958021164, -0.014627967961132526, -0.0030427498277276754, -0.011177361011505127, -0.005429940763860941, -0.005153687205165625, -0.022713547572493553, -0.01975982077419758, 0.04303111135959625, 0.04514769837260246, -0.04231473058462143, 0.03075277991592884, 0.032189734280109406, 0.011698552407324314, -0.0018595806322991848, -0.011735660955309868, -0.0014215476112440228, 0.006269458681344986, 0.0005353851593099535, 0.02935309335589409, 0.023716473951935768, 0.01052856259047985, -0.008261281996965408, 0.06920188665390015, -0.010648703202605247, -0.05270940437912941, 0.029142091050744057, -0.0022540981881320477, 0.0149501608684659, -0.024360425770282745, -0.06827359646558762, -0.042835742235183716, 0.04237182438373566, 0.0424928218126297, 0.018764035776257515, -0.01078278198838234, -0.08384238928556442, -0.01035354658961296, 0.03213907778263092, 0.00757531588897109, -0.01488183718174696, -0.012253553606569767, -0.01429151464253664, -0.05491561070084572, 0.009889003820717335, -0.0438997820019722, 0.019582996144890785, -0.04231720790266991, 0.009790787473320961, -0.003433381440117955, 0.003291250439360738, -0.052333712577819824, 0.008831190876662731, -0.0012084380723536015, 0.004524598363786936, 0.01677953079342842, 0.0006880351575091481, -0.06371946632862091, 0.01879536733031273, 0.020811231806874275, 0.06331636756658554, -0.011388595215976238, -0.021184435114264488, 0.020001763477921486, -0.010299206711351871, 0.00781719945371151, -0.0021780405659228563, 0.054703325033187866, 0.00912794191390276, -0.022507844492793083, 0.0614987276494503, -0.000019333327145432122, -0.03766101226210594, 0.03655654564499855, 0.023460756987333298, -0.006779287476092577, 0.006735087372362614, -0.005462482571601868, 0.03335234895348549, 0.0253768153488636, 0.019801350310444832, 0.08926377445459366, 0.015284942463040352, -0.012439489364624023, 0.0035759254824370146, -0.017647085711359978, 0.011596787720918655, -0.03106161393225193, -0.058741550892591476, -0.04080332815647125, -0.004535085987299681, -0.030193688347935677, 0.02080499194562435, 0.030898183584213257, 0.04353010281920433, -0.032093096524477005, -0.019434286281466484, 0.013827295042574406, 0.016882525756955147, -0.030169876292347908, -0.031591445207595825, 0.029950188472867012, -0.0016885874792933464, 0.017836978659033775, -0.03524967283010483, 0.021244440227746964, -0.0035835281014442444, -0.013014711439609528, -0.0015669536078348756, -0.04681326448917389, 0.051028087735176086, -0.04088506102561951, -0.028715569525957108, 0.0018628147663548589, 0.0006212172447703779, 0.04500991851091385, -0.011533119715750217, 0.05148975923657417, -0.00920164491981268, -0.06331027299165726, -0.015063214115798473, 0.030563263222575188, 0.0140176797285676, 0.009627699851989746, -0.03544791787862778, 0.037232257425785065, -0.01125411782413721, -0.031554967164993286, -0.10541608929634094, -0.024539602920413017, -0.011225356720387936, 0.02117324061691761, 0.0024505024775862694, -0.04116680845618248, -0.01644798181951046, -0.01704009622335434, 0.029980478808283806, -0.04777645692229271, 0.05593162775039673, -0.033003538846969604, -6.477002330029791e-7, -0.004010283388197422, 0.027752084657549858, 0.08216357976198196, -0.0009263974498026073, -0.0002961180580314249, -0.03676258772611618, -0.013161404989659786, -0.036003392189741135, 0.0012450534850358963, -0.005194034427404404, -0.04734225571155548, -0.004540607333183289, -0.017084583640098572, -0.0002171789383282885, 0.034408144652843475, 0.00861402042210102, -0.024839188903570175, 0.026884833350777626, -0.015605361200869083, -0.0000931186368688941, -0.08174902945756912, 0.0004901913343928754, -0.01291217003017664, -0.007623694371432066, -0.03859676420688629, 0.0025826673954725266, -0.029073845595121384, -0.029953695833683014, 0.006682844832539558, -0.02888394519686699, -0.01650008000433445, 0.016698017716407776, 0.06697963178157806, 0.005079326685518026, 0.009497256018221378, 0.04351002350449562, -0.0026784127112478018, 0.010251031257212162, -0.030189234763383865, -0.024675458669662476, 0.05167119950056076, 0.04553357884287834, -0.026515575125813484, -0.029429277405142784, -0.017970163375139236, 0.024333756417036057, 0.04627648741006851, -0.03007132187485695, 0.04664726182818413, 0.054459381848573685, 0.012103401124477386, 0.005382874049246311, -0.01338152028620243, -0.009972545318305492, -0.006196699570864439, 0.045369576662778854, 0.0733928307890892, -0.020364783704280853, 0.007161835208535194, 0.029430994763970375, 0.018185459077358246, 0.006499898619949818, 0.058531198650598526, -0.0010590231977403164, 0.03846094757318497, 0.005036953371018171, -0.007049270439893007, -0.04005881026387215, 0.03206418454647064, -0.04311377927660942, 0.02364429645240307, -0.05115968734025955, -0.04300514981150627, 0.053630996495485306, 0.048113271594047546, -0.012682020664215088, -0.059430528432130814, -0.02080681174993515, -0.04979664832353592, 0.01510829571634531, 0.022877061739563942, -0.009203816764056683, 0.02528153918683529, 0.04283441975712776, 0.033831287175416946, -0.028150375932455063, 0.005778037942945957, -0.0106562664732337, -0.06417585164308548, 0.004315332043915987, -0.0362764410674572, -0.04136364161968231, 0.017577124759554863, -0.006140875164419413, -0.02366657741367817, 0.04080870747566223, -0.02556828409433365, -0.009461477398872375, 0.006734421476721764, 0.033976830542087555, -0.003954700659960508, 0.021319078281521797, 0.02410915493965149, 0.004487586673349142, 0.012905146926641464, 0.015860162675380707, 0.09304796159267426, 0.07161840051412582, 0.04293988645076752, -0.06851907074451447, 0.0433807373046875, -0.004269191063940525, 0.0284955482929945, -0.01469077356159687, -0.007412986364215612, 0.034928057342767715, -0.0075089531019330025, 0.07821851223707199, 0.03954094648361206, 0.0280597060918808, 0.027714742347598076, 0.03582003340125084, -0.012683257460594177, -0.03649475798010826, 0.0016199917299672961, 0.005092198494821787, -0.006353507749736309, -0.010941464453935623, -0.023939503356814384, -0.004641784355044365, 0.02519896812736988, -0.010866746306419373, 0.0010900122579187155, -0.0037483209744095802, 0.004422261845320463, 0.0001565969578223303, -0.027820169925689697, 0.0038432241417467594, -0.0035644005984067917, -0.003762005129829049, -0.02021104283630848, -0.0024159238673746586, 0.004289060831069946, -0.056243859231472015, 0.005809734109789133, 0.04247712716460228, 0.015661127865314484, 0.004422164522111416, -0.014851576648652554, 0.033488888293504715, -0.03497115522623062, -0.011454110033810139, -0.03360395506024361, 0.042817529290914536, -0.019184214994311333, -0.008281949907541275, -0.010774198919534683, 0.008399107493460178, -0.0007674449007026851, -0.02163040265440941, -0.01633358560502529, 0.028620107099413872, 0.043318357318639755, -0.030148539692163467, -0.015460711903870106, -0.04425935819745064, 0.009502148255705833, -0.011980501934885979, 0.046227917075157166, 0.04047391563653946, -0.02560543455183506, -0.035234156996011734, -0.03477420657873154, 0.060274891555309296, -0.02003643661737442, -0.02714487724006176, -0.01300257071852684, 0.006219513714313507, -0.016136351972818375, -0.0010898933978751302, -0.03127885237336159, 0.028097929432988167, 0.017371665686368942, -0.04260262846946716, -0.05298365280032158, -0.0031259560491889715, -0.04901488870382309, 0.022159190848469734, -0.03573150187730789, 0.002050969749689102, -0.02128327079117298, 0.01812153309583664, 0.03128160908818245, 0.010561753064393997, 0.004117151256650686, 0.015176880173385143, -0.0007237445097416639, 0.033961933106184006, 0.028097758069634438, -0.0701935738325119, -0.005474384408444166, -0.0077489581890404224, -0.017178678885102272, -0.0525529570877552, -0.03695518523454666, 0.044340938329696655, -0.00249910238198936, 0.022692250087857246, -0.012601647526025772, 0.028321757912635803, -0.03501665219664574, 0.03956035524606705, 0.027560127899050713, -0.03206169232726097, -0.005749788135290146, -0.014100359752774239, -0.010969672352075577, -0.008843057788908482, -0.01707976870238781, -0.03650888055562973, -0.04757576808333397, 0.007165389135479927, -0.03609367460012436, -0.023539401590824127, -0.0047634984366595745, -0.02536260150372982, 0.03219355642795563, -0.037079859524965286, 0.010124842636287212, -0.053883135318756104, -0.01495746336877346, 0.025491774082183838, -0.01850845292210579, 0.0006313482881523669, 0.037753645330667496, -0.03348386660218239, -0.00856003724038601, 0.046122994273900986, -0.008391999639570713, 0.059318333864212036, -0.013165685348212719, 0.01365099847316742, 0.014954401180148125, 0.058185357600450516, 0.02755075693130493, 0.006791602820158005, 0.028105271980166435, -0.052154116332530975, -0.028063939884305, -0.006499290466308594, -0.022209275513887405, 0.04354501888155937, -0.008243763819336891, -0.02333487942814827, -0.0241757333278656, 0.06710217893123627, 0.002389201894402504, -0.02615603618323803, -0.02611391805112362, -0.013518508523702621, -0.00162497500423342, -0.018694868311285973, 0.008192341774702072, 0.008941429667174816, -0.021464001387357712, 0.012700166553258896, 0.027667604386806488, 0.029870958998799324, -0.003416597144678235, -0.027670489624142647, -0.043325673788785934, 0.0350845530629158, -0.028769340366125107, -0.060949262231588364, 0.04327533766627312, 0.10639243572950363, -0.022285521030426025, -0.014489706605672836, -0.03409774973988533, -0.0035277409479022026, -0.0682889074087143, -0.01994672417640686, 0.0020266121719032526, 0.031523287296295166, 0.03072807751595974, -0.0577847994863987, 0.04348555952310562, 0.012134501710534096, -0.01697397045791149, -0.014040783978998661, -0.006205440033227205, 0.0070088570937514305, -0.03107936680316925, -0.01533532328903675, -0.05630011484026909, -0.012692240998148918, 0.01961163431406021, 0.03134596347808838, 0.05238422378897667, 0.010766780003905296, -0.02036493830382824, -0.01887262426316738, 0.02756478823721409, -0.007010708097368479, 0.004524955991655588, -0.06408046931028366, 0.02920307032763958, -0.00012017822882626206, -0.03933745622634888, 0.0016401066677644849, -0.01783679984509945, 0.022882908582687378, 0.03711867332458496, 0.05104302614927292, 0.03203047439455986, 0.027367690578103065, -0.005277617368847132, -0.020520009100437164, -0.014601633884012699, 0.0008845879347063601, -0.029565420001745224, -0.01683853007853031, -0.03389609977602959, 0.016050424426794052, 0.05888381972908974, 0.011762316338717937, -0.006085071712732315, 0.019366804510354996, -0.02849850431084633, -0.030075624585151672, -0.02448773942887783, -0.03318559378385544, 0.03778604045510292, -0.005094747059047222, -0.0033883361611515284, -0.027437148615717888, 0.0034005737397819757, 0.04432108625769615, 0.008867120370268822, -0.05663467198610306, 0.003836953081190586, 0.01136020291596651, -0.04816266521811485, -0.00041845254600048065, 0.008827882818877697, 0.013559464365243912, -0.06440338492393494, -0.04064152389764786, 0.006503349635750055, -0.000349603098584339, -0.03544197231531143, -0.0371931828558445, -0.03754081949591637, 0.03708871081471443, -0.031048836186528206, 0.0053600650280714035, 0.014120250940322876, 0.01098411250859499, 0.026690471917390823, -0.08290708810091019, 0.07114153355360031, 0.015326458029448986, -0.015778476372361183, -0.043000515550374985, 0.005485169589519501, -0.026071196421980858, 0.017295891419053078, 0.02172008343040943, -0.007491522468626499, -0.00929164607077837, 0.014816192910075188, 0.04240669310092926, 0.012316715903580189, -0.05439785122871399, 0.046436864882707596, -0.0193440243601799, -0.022143039852380753, -0.017354555428028107, -0.02537812665104866, 0.013654363341629505, 0.006635943427681923, 0.011717415414750576, -0.005911751184612513, 0.010597378946840763, 0.018667150288820267, -0.025428136810660362, 0.008819492533802986, -0.025829622521996498, -0.0047677988186478615, 0.04522344842553139, 0.003193130949512124, -0.0014429796719923615, 0.01573082245886326, 0.010934797115623951, -0.00556941656395793, 0.038222379982471466, -0.02826695516705513, -0.006330758333206177, 0.012540745548903942, 0.028522009029984474, -0.01725064218044281, -0.06719186902046204, 0.011175178922712803, -0.0026106040459126234, -0.0499541349709034, 0.008298034779727459, 0.01242986973375082, 0.02528432197868824, 0.050380151718854904, -0.023760279640555382, 0.018465198576450348, 0.009969406761229038, -0.01773983985185623, -0.006254868116229773, 0.03228453919291496, 0.0186229906976223, 0.024891991168260574, -0.002573599573224783, -0.004797265864908695, -0.010382425971329212, 0.020611917600035667, -0.020285146310925484, 0.039748962968587875, -0.0019913366995751858, 0.014070573262870312, 0.03001035563647747, -0.031852561980485916, 0.009083220735192299, -0.016578100621700287, -0.03222213312983513, 0.053787004202604294, -0.050982460379600525, 0.00706637604162097, -0.020419076085090637, -0.02909833751618862, -0.0037126459646970034, 0.013825144618749619, 0.017787078395485878, 0.05634239315986633, 0.0118063073605299, 0.05463172495365143, 0.02539077401161194, -0.03910944238305092, 0.04484766349196434, -0.00903962180018425, 0.05494066700339317, -0.03722173348069191, -0.02484789304435253, -0.01250437367707491, 0.012633102014660835, -0.021860340610146523, -0.04164309799671173, 0.040781714022159576, 0.0221408698707819, 0.01820547692477703, -0.014721150510013103, -0.042859941720962524, 0.010758774355053902, 0.057729315012693405, -0.07319065183401108, -0.012005013413727283, -0.04687151685357094, -0.0013282286236062646, 0.013956278562545776, -0.0007425508229061961 ]
<p>I am conducting a study for analyzing male involvement in Family planning. It is of interest to develop an index for the involvement of male. I am currently having difficulties fitting an IRT model since my data has a lot of missing values and answers like "don't know" and some confusing answers. Note that my variables are all dichotomous in nature. </p> <p>Any suggestions for handling this kind of problem regarding missing values in IRT model?Thanks</p>
35,985
[ -0.017778005450963974, -0.015169704332947731, -0.00011757094762288034, 0.04646415263414383, 0.06543900817632675, -0.0032436728943139315, -0.006275797262787819, -0.026089586317539215, 0.011943578720092773, 0.010914173908531666, 0.02085648849606514, 0.011340527795255184, 0.06443723291158676, 0.02206404320895672, -0.00017807178664952517, 0.012427509762346745, -0.005381220486015081, -0.03508845716714859, 0.0001566197315696627, -0.00010611010657157749, -0.015535806305706501, 0.030538173392415047, 0.010341506451368332, 0.009248925372958183, -0.004215849097818136, 0.06709626317024231, 0.02620881423354149, -0.020434647798538208, 0.018905241042375565, 0.026452558115124702, -0.04268914833664894, -0.013994700275361538, -0.0229012630879879, 0.017051665112376213, -0.00607199827209115, -0.01059057004749775, -0.027848925441503525, -0.0030579734593629837, 0.0034291353076696396, 0.03952694684267044, -0.013440916314721107, 0.0030176532454788685, -0.024745842441916466, 0.02819708175957203, -0.0032915472984313965, 0.015313650481402874, -0.01594799943268299, -0.02983451820909977, 0.0236484557390213, -0.01316933985799551, 0.03192178159952164, 0.012837827205657959, -0.0022136394400149584, 0.00891889352351427, -0.04458669573068619, -0.028610438108444214, 0.062295909970998764, 0.07533574849367142, -0.010014643892645836, -0.04535245895385742, -0.020755840465426445, -0.01295897364616394, 0.018053283914923668, -0.030148858204483986, -0.04356209561228752, 0.0410093255341053, -0.02697928063571453, 0.002068036003038287, 0.05393659323453903, -0.017224503681063652, 0.014824439771473408, 0.03223993629217148, 0.015426909551024437, -0.026147516444325447, 0.01873677223920822, -0.05274181067943573, -0.006642031483352184, 0.05093333125114441, 0.013076264411211014, 0.01590767502784729, -0.014016200788319111, 0.03902251645922661, 0.030270999297499657, 0.03816412389278412, -0.0008789567509666085, -0.04680391401052475, 0.03783559799194336, -0.006166246719658375, 0.018150800839066505, 0.022262072190642357, -0.03553394973278046, 0.026596061885356903, 0.01991545967757702, 0.027598120272159576, -0.04254227876663208, 0.037310175597667694, -0.033037468791007996, 0.05608348548412323, 0.003675224957987666, -0.034318532794713974, -0.009463402442634106, -0.01645607128739357, 0.041175127029418945, 0.06459969282150269, -0.01718759723007679, -0.04046431556344032, -0.020432844758033752, 0.009807824157178402, 0.02412690967321396, -0.030064744874835014, 0.0025777623523026705, 0.030393552035093307, 0.0273171104490757, 0.006480466108769178, 0.06057288870215416, 0.002139931544661522, -0.025864996016025543, -0.055435992777347565, 0.04381709173321724, 0.05859903246164322, 0.017000796273350716, -0.017305970191955566, 0.03818823769688606, 0.0012149717658758163, -0.0666346624493599, -0.014914200641214848, 0.023734748363494873, -0.008839569985866547, 0.00229236064478755, 0.039376143366098404, 0.017656072974205017, -0.001349943457171321, 0.023082535713911057, -0.001052618375979364, 0.06396133452653885, 0.0008701584883965552, -0.05948619171977043, -0.06504427641630173, -0.009392092935740948, -0.003660638350993395, -0.028009429574012756, -0.048540838062763214, -0.02145395614206791, 0.014146014116704464, 0.05986933782696724, -0.011054622940719128, 0.04048290103673935, 0.016335347667336464, 0.007856534793972969, 0.061455659568309784, -0.045994315296411514, -0.02353726327419281, -0.005696812644600868, -0.000049860915169119835, -0.0145349046215415, -0.0683462917804718, 0.029094481840729713, 0.020694999024271965, -0.034837644547224045, -0.020066311582922935, 0.01798878237605095, 0.013828063383698463, -0.04559357836842537, 0.011980218812823296, 0.044027894735336304, -0.017076732590794563, 0.06687772274017334, -0.018266107887029648, 0.031057877466082573, 0.01960490643978119, 0.01564505696296692, 0.050652969628572464, 0.009952248074114323, 0.0454891212284565, 0.07279958575963974, 0.0052109370008111, -0.05599267780780792, 0.005481242667883635, 0.02363276295363903, 0.014267723076045513, -0.02369135618209839, -0.03323006257414818, -0.01571046933531761, 0.011040333658456802, -0.00022985776013229042, 0.007791183423250914, 0.023848354816436768, -0.04491071030497551, 0.045331332832574844, -0.0395534485578537, -0.03749672323465347, -0.041823916137218475, 0.03549489378929138, 0.005768992006778717, 0.0016099956119433045, -0.008397696539759636, -0.04303326457738876, 0.03926549479365349, 0.01968514174222946, -0.01484616193920374, -0.07191623747348785, -0.030332110822200775, 0.038512710481882095, -0.00528718950226903, -0.007086488418281078, 0.0424274317920208, 0.027605663985013962, -0.031084954738616943, 0.005513810086995363, -0.03646879643201828, -0.0314895436167717, -0.0038507196586579084, -0.01710195094347, 0.020633313804864883, -0.044291894882917404, -0.04188249260187149, -0.028102906420826912, -0.00389408809132874, -0.0167623832821846, 0.02220558002591133, -0.06275444477796555, 0.0746694952249527, 0.06003763899207115, -0.005791745614260435, -0.032094232738018036, -0.003010581014677882, 0.006785196717828512, 0.013065418228507042, -0.03502696007490158, -0.024953022599220276, -0.07707486301660538, 0.024222586303949356, 0.013716239482164383, -0.027807071805000305, -0.051745228469371796, -0.006032820325344801, 0.05444888025522232, 0.0039124758914113045, -0.028467116877436638, 0.0032925221603363752, -0.023288089781999588, -0.002310538198798895, 0.01922287419438362, 0.009135497733950615, 0.0009452485828660429, 0.013176359236240387, 0.0027011760976165533, -0.01580466330051422, 0.035843051970005035, -0.00365363503806293, 0.0227583646774292, 0.04510953649878502, -0.01871173456311226, -0.008931977674365044, -0.008037685416638851, -0.01518193632364273, 0.0384775772690773, -0.029727499932050705, -0.03045404888689518, 0.071346715092659, 0.01467716135084629, -0.027848102152347565, 0.035949256271123886, 0.006601584609597921, 0.027886096388101578, 0.03449893370270729, -0.013851556926965714, -0.009354609996080399, 0.02233731932938099, -0.03702780604362488, -0.008165668696165085, -0.028780564665794373, -0.030243849381804466, -0.03938973695039749, -0.03221036493778229, 0.03187378868460655, 0.025952991098165512, 0.005565884057432413, -0.030057061463594437, 0.0034256563521921635, -0.037746284157037735, 0.010539257898926735, -0.005412369035184383, 0.030644964426755905, -0.04816962033510208, -0.03760213777422905, 0.010878030210733414, -0.01336247380822897, 0.009344476275146008, -0.04560453072190285, -0.02907736599445343, 0.009633268229663372, -0.02534637413918972, -0.01393372192978859, -0.028362847864627838, -0.015543590299785137, 0.01591547392308712, -0.034193236380815506, 0.003290015971288085, 0.003401725320145488, 0.004502356983721256, -0.013307894580066204, 0.02670980803668499, -0.06275350600481033, -0.0035161362029612064, -0.01226644404232502, -0.00887090340256691, 0.054125893861055374, -0.009273377247154713, -0.004627686459571123, -0.005923497956246138, 0.0001275039103347808, 0.04658033698797226, -0.08231711387634277, -0.07137120515108109, 0.018573464825749397, 0.01185637153685093, 0.008312918245792389, 0.022178659215569496, 0.01791791431605816, 0.027052298188209534, 0.02912753075361252, -0.03981003910303116, -0.05286876857280731, -0.00740239629521966, -0.003516164142638445, 0.019467545673251152, 0.048540111631155014, 0.020217835903167725, 0.042367469519376755, -0.004041888751089573, -0.013929987326264381, 0.03769092634320259, 0.024936720728874207, 0.03480121120810509, 0.014512809924781322, 0.02484666183590889, -0.02769390679895878, -0.01223717350512743, 0.042134661227464676, 0.011868077330291271, -0.014949018135666847, 0.0238037146627903, -0.045517947524785995, 0.03946709260344505, 0.04257252812385559, -0.04734361544251442, -0.003448359901085496, -0.03143833950161934, -0.018636297434568405, -0.01291180495172739, 0.028269603848457336, 0.013625417836010456, 0.014170457608997822, -0.02517247572541237, -0.012204444967210293, 0.021680030971765518, -0.025644974783062935, -0.0018857581308111548, 0.07493297755718231, -0.012961097992956638, 0.005036909598857164, 0.03481340780854225, -0.029100315645337105, 0.0017918621888384223, 0.021915076300501823, -0.026536576449871063, 0.00007353278488153592, 0.0348232164978981, 0.08280548453330994, 0.0012068640207871795, -0.0041319881565868855, -0.03407040610909462, 0.016746947541832924, -0.04370121285319328, -0.01517567690461874, -0.012293742038309574, 0.05066924914717674, -0.013653802685439587, 0.022414430975914, 0.04515271633863449, 0.030752472579479218, -0.011263505555689335, 0.01658378355205059, -0.06798839569091797, 0.03282564878463745, -0.02231360413134098, 0.010684703476727009, 0.011068674735724926, 0.020395444706082344, 0.044321153312921524, -0.01945265755057335, -0.02240040898323059, 0.016650179401040077, 0.015854094177484512, -0.05702013522386551, 0.042484283447265625, 0.006031701806932688, 0.009967220947146416, 0.00979554932564497, 0.011885209940373898, -0.001876506838016212, -0.004566555842757225, 0.026955770328640938, 0.04590094834566116, 0.03721311688423157, -0.03540179505944252, 0.009681424126029015, -0.018801774829626083, 0.012173591181635857, 0.03299930319190025, 0.018787959590554237, 0.02208494208753109, -0.013103089295327663, 0.03966192901134491, 0.020938092842698097, 0.03416562080383301, 0.04659142717719078, 0.0020550915505737066, -0.020749101415276527, -0.02509334310889244, 0.004993070382624865, -0.03969305753707886, 0.014101240783929825, -0.005069984123110771, 0.024261154234409332, 0.06922183185815811, 0.03402376174926758, -0.03850599378347397, 0.004629379604011774, 0.00756049994379282, 0.03726932033896446, 0.00642547570168972, -0.029071688652038574, -0.00994289293885231, -0.038858089596033096, -0.014510632492601871, -0.002372887684032321, 0.026597313582897186, 0.009081821888685226, -0.005939096678048372, 0.0861794501543045, 0.010093707591295242, -0.037097394466400146, 0.00619183573871851, -0.013020618818700314, 0.0012289638398215175, -0.0030171358957886696, -0.05309690535068512, 0.04124097898602486, 0.030124345794320107, 0.026037922129034996, -0.00018809124594554305, 0.012280389666557312, -0.0954647809267044, 0.01506846398115158, 0.04288867861032486, 0.056481581181287766, -0.05221353843808174, -0.03121359646320343, -0.03388009965419769, -0.02000490017235279, 0.013873942196369171, -0.029553379863500595, -0.031244881451129913, -0.03140656277537346, 0.008176433853805065, -0.03901560232043266, -0.04213954880833626, -0.03316924348473549, 0.005758671555668116, -0.03155955672264099, 0.0475311279296875, -0.011790127493441105, -0.030381489545106888, -0.027038946747779846, 0.008951998315751553, 0.03908240422606468, 0.06275338679552078, -0.0006924284971319139, 0.00006112617847975343, 0.021536869928240776, 0.04285787045955658, -0.037495069205760956, -0.027698099613189697, -0.012090181931853294, -0.008361799642443657, -0.003156892256811261, 0.07070617377758026, -0.006209216546267271, -0.024227553978562355, -0.0013216029619798064, 0.0430140383541584, 0.004678260535001755, 0.02505299635231495, -0.08025207370519638, 0.014107898809015751, -0.03008713386952877, 0.006220149341970682, 0.030151594430208206, 0.026406172662973404, -0.013311493210494518, -0.015660852193832397, -0.050714217126369476, -0.01247674785554409, -0.02975562959909439, -0.021402141079306602, -0.015207279473543167, -0.023225491866469383, 0.011281898245215416, 0.012628107331693172, -0.004217630717903376, 0.004050578456372023, -0.04873673617839813, 0.010140538215637207, 0.004180342890322208, 0.008617019280791283, -0.030196692794561386, 0.021274106577038765, 0.005942444317042828, 0.02426765114068985, 0.003291023662313819, 0.0014674984849989414, 0.01215919479727745, -0.00345106259919703, -0.01941644959151745, 0.0041901832446455956, -0.020682452246546745, 0.031793538480997086, -0.036554004997015, -0.0416683666408062, 0.018628735095262527, 0.004672604147344828, 0.019848620519042015, -0.010953947901725769, 0.0030801089014858007, 0.0026341662742197514, -0.0357411690056324, -0.013084761798381805, 0.0008963085128925741, 0.013389664702117443, 0.030491067096590996, -0.01034296490252018, 0.02222149446606636, -0.04012429341673851, -0.011678164824843407, -0.059617213904857635, -0.06280520558357239, 0.03648653253912926, 0.009685670956969261, -0.05330824851989746, 0.00772927887737751, 0.03798345476388931, -0.02248697727918625, -0.027347128838300705, 0.0033596549183130264, 0.06763005256652832, 0.00430978462100029, -0.0047201854176819324, -0.014876858331263065, 0.009996449574828148, 0.053364191204309464, 0.0030513738747686148, -0.017174584791064262, 0.016041375696659088, -0.02534390613436699, -0.04278160631656647, -0.016127843409776688, -0.00766595546156168, -0.02604297176003456, -0.06352932751178741, 0.013678399845957756, 0.033215075731277466, 0.033678725361824036, -0.002398180076852441, 0.005279948469251394, -0.012634496204555035, -0.012991633266210556, -0.032926201820373535, -0.02897728979587555, -0.011129663325846195, -0.0067102364264428616, -0.011611999943852425, -0.01888216659426689, 0.007484132889658213, -0.045769207179546356, -0.007282824721187353, 0.027219677343964577, -0.038628894835710526, -0.00420350069180131, -0.005877847317606211, 0.021972250193357468, -0.004243121482431889, 0.03388992324471474, 0.03549681603908539, 0.007749754935503006, 0.04657917097210884, 0.02881813980638981, -0.01583554968237877, -0.042230915278196335, 0.015453603118658066, -0.03173154592514038, -0.0390416756272316, -0.003923992160707712, -0.00590392155572772, 0.06035324186086655, -0.00044093086034990847, 0.003420526161789894, 0.0255352184176445, -0.012889297679066658, -0.013935133814811707, 0.0022334351669996977, 0.0576414093375206, -0.00574318366125226, 0.03266846388578415, 0.0191353727132082, -0.024102212861180305, 0.020031142979860306, 0.0375194326043129, 0.04441196843981743, 0.01861877180635929, 0.053472843021154404, 0.04197235777974129, 0.006387146655470133, 0.026757022365927696, -0.03331207111477852, -0.056804269552230835, -0.030315151438117027, -0.024266423657536507, 0.014932777732610703, -0.004789344500750303, -0.02781856805086136, 0.034459035843610764, 0.031120914965867996, 0.05809662118554115, 0.00022682842973154038, -0.030530186370015144, -0.04003307595849037, 0.0064701177179813385, 0.006762232631444931, -0.04204243794083595, 0.026936059817671776, 0.014530759304761887, 0.0557759627699852, -0.02278260700404644, 0.028480887413024902, -0.016126833856105804, -0.10315228998661041, -0.007870560511946678, -0.004382156301289797, -0.0332661010324955, 0.025862256065011024, -0.03377959504723549, 0.0017450915183871984, -0.00831370335072279, -0.002508678240701556, 0.0009884736500680447, -0.011553943157196045, 0.009928678162395954, -0.015717560425400734, 0.061671338975429535, -0.030468396842479706, -0.0033385385759174824, 0.0022220786195248365, 0.03114272467792034, 0.11455140262842178, 0.06530599296092987, 0.037859465926885605, -0.06403125077486038, 0.02728147618472576, -0.005135239101946354, -0.003553335554897785, 0.0030562691390514374, 0.015030443668365479, 0.038175877183675766, -0.04349714517593384, 0.05781882256269455, -0.008356161415576935, -0.010097392834722996, 0.04263710230588913, 0.060600511729717255, -0.02048313617706299, -0.06747222691774368, -0.005080684088170528, 0.020790619775652885, 0.020035317167639732, -0.0316024087369442, -0.009700244292616844, 0.002461837837472558, 0.009402459487318993, -0.01474057324230671, -0.026043066754937172, -0.04503781348466873, 0.038492996245622635, 0.02849285490810871, -0.021016795188188553, 0.03424610197544098, 0.01563752070069313, 0.04595554247498512, -0.008621458895504475, -0.006587552838027477, 0.02341906540095806, -0.0298551507294178, -0.008000616915524006, 0.02206108160316944, -0.020209714770317078, -0.0028961431235074997, 0.010177899152040482, -0.005251648835837841, -0.04549612104892731, -0.0056602731347084045, -0.03678744658827782, 0.03371109813451767, 0.009604807011783123, -0.043747153133153915, -0.03822972998023033, 0.004180721007287502, -0.032726436853408813, -0.057806797325611115, -0.03871344029903412, 0.06004205718636513, 0.06182112172245979, -0.02580462582409382, -0.0326940193772316, 0.004664530977606773, -0.03660473972558975, -0.006723268888890743, 0.04550036042928696, 0.008984828367829323, -0.0333617702126503, -0.021689359098672867, -0.021614236757159233, 0.03538788482546806, -0.02844529040157795, -0.0019053908763453364, 0.0017986292950809002, -0.019807305186986923, 0.010705904103815556, -0.02540307119488716, 0.008142853155732155, 0.041217971593141556, 0.05447441712021828, -0.028744902461767197, 0.015839992091059685, -0.030353279784321785, -0.018201252445578575, -0.0019282656721770763, -0.031786590814590454, -0.01510576345026493, -0.049399442970752716, -0.011850548908114433, 0.019590239971876144, 0.036232125014066696, 0.03664342314004898, 0.008797600865364075, 0.003748649498447776, 0.06003797426819801, 0.03774309903383255, -0.05283639580011368, -0.028690727427601814, -0.038130052387714386, -0.039131347090005875, 0.011425022035837173, -0.033114977180957794, 0.0017808078555390239, 0.023868190124630928, 0.03933729976415634, 0.010759050957858562, -0.0020409489516168833, 0.0057759713381528854, 0.014629270881414413, -0.019708843901753426, -0.05033538118004799, -0.04070466011762619, -0.007569366600364447, 0.0183265283703804, -0.04411008208990097, 0.0066733164712786674, -0.006474944297224283, -0.03551965579390526, 0.02854914776980877, -0.016353609040379524, -0.05309479683637619, 0.03267805278301239, -0.029996315017342567, -0.0015052577946335077, 0.015569538809359074, 0.03252924606204033, -0.04520845785737038, -0.03659456968307495, 0.004496386740356684, -0.02539440616965294, -0.02058655396103859, -0.009266620501875877, -0.031062737107276917, 0.03211080655455589, 0.04252799600362778, -0.005634611006826162, -0.00472529511898756, 0.03452051058411598, 0.027089087292551994, 0.010671457275748253, 0.06004803627729416, -0.058676112443208694, -0.014644389972090721, 0.017637846991419792, -0.058490365743637085, 0.0058122072368860245, 0.014946972019970417, -0.014288780279457569, 0.03872065991163254, 0.010176324285566807, -0.01810450851917267, 0.00755927711725235, 0.032331302762031555, -0.041687387973070145, 0.005096764303743839, -0.010112442076206207, 0.04562704637646675, 0.011499742045998573, 0.01623079925775528, -0.04532136023044586, 0.01695162057876587, -0.03329368680715561, 0.03905453532934189, 0.09005650877952576, 0.04180971160531044, 0.0027861467096954584, 0.04450952634215355, -0.01194723043590784, -0.0029562734998762608, -0.017184989526867867, 0.0013062740908935666, 0.0376366525888443, 0.04087702929973602, -0.018047459423542023, 0.01026308536529541, 0.00000900716804608237, 0.029309649020433426, -0.06837119907140732, -0.029119495302438736, -0.017309529706835747, 0.040574364364147186, 0.057595718652009964, -0.004800794180482626, 0.004036033060401678, 0.012727373279631138, -0.03576677665114403, 0.039319515228271484, -0.01124352216720581, 0.011155444197356701, -0.012686247937381268, -0.013476718217134476, -0.047605276107788086, -0.010578925721347332, 0.032432328909635544, 0.0188008900731802, -0.0013060453347861767, -0.0009526485810056329, 0.0030247303657233715, -0.051297809928655624, -0.00759339751675725, 0.02678641676902771, 0.014064394868910313, -0.045767687261104584, 0.015074636787176132, -0.027387946844100952, -0.047452207654714584, 0.01356315053999424, -0.004426178056746721, 0.062149129807949066, 0.02705969288945198, 0.014575106091797352, 0.012989962473511696, 0.09576676785945892, 0.0072006843984127045, -0.026730574667453766, -0.009283879771828651, 0.009324007667601109, 0.03065754473209381, 0.018073970451951027, -0.00797423068434, 0.030395163223147392, 0.051691729575395584, -0.013926250860095024, 0.0251979511231184, -0.009205259382724762, -0.03256972134113312, 0.012762513011693954, 0.004247989971190691, -0.06375055015087128, 0.02519919164478779, -0.0512990839779377, -0.004841769579797983, -0.038871947675943375, -0.018491579219698906, 0.01180338952690363, 0.03225957229733467, -0.028434770181775093, -0.018475830554962158, -0.009703870862722397, -0.0822892114520073, 0.013471203856170177, 0.008490449748933315, -0.0067007713951170444, -0.046868521720170975, -0.003617077600210905, -0.00785445049405098, 0.0072310855612158775, -0.008847221732139587, 0.012814115732908249, 0.0030056594405323267, 0.05428098142147064, -0.04552488029003143, -0.05098346248269081, 0.023592444136738777, -0.025284364819526672, 0.04241780936717987, -0.05991092696785927, 0.07128901779651642, 0.020405959337949753, -0.005999330896884203, -0.032202497124671936, -0.018179168924689293, -0.0455084852874279, -0.0013536512851715088, 0.08193804323673248, -0.036249496042728424, -0.015277566388249397, -0.013626359403133392, 0.006939741317182779, 0.009445596486330032, -0.04328518733382225, 0.04660048708319664, 0.009206045418977737, 0.002086062915623188, -0.03183433786034584, 0.005551320966333151, 0.019296376034617424, -0.013413071632385254, 0.0242910198867321, -0.0008673524134792387, 0.048432983458042145, -0.008161495439708233, -0.0023752273991703987, -0.012850175611674786, 0.028827181085944176, -0.004596040118485689, 0.025966059416532516, 0.0019856244325637817, 0.022172024473547935, 0.08369599282741547, -0.0065676383674144745, -0.06366296857595444, 0.021607354283332825, -0.01147688552737236, -0.027053967118263245, 0.022202035412192345, -0.017081761732697487, -0.00964509416371584, -0.069607675075531, -0.0023323961067944765, 0.058866195380687714, 0.00010630764154484496, 0.013602019287645817, 0.027195729315280914, 0.013432886451482773, 0.045669618993997574, 0.0066723814234137535, 0.006432038731873035, 0.04173313081264496, -0.050247956067323685, 0.041459910571575165, 0.04336978495121002, 0.036442313343286514, 0.03854662925004959, 0.009628001600503922, 0.017412321642041206, -0.021710200235247612, 0.02491624467074871, -0.002805554773658514, 0.0076394095085561275, -0.0189356729388237, -0.0011859640944749117, 0.02987060882151127, -0.00019484700169414282, 0.01211470365524292, 0.021722713485360146, -0.004601289052516222, 0.05568185821175575, -0.010249690152704716, 0.024979786947369576, -0.062509685754776, -0.02219521999359131, -0.0499257855117321, 0.01074196770787239, 0.036157287657260895, 0.025262797251343727, 0.04466785117983818, 0.009882406331598759, -0.00045061713899485767, -0.03291353955864906, 0.028473062440752983, -0.04766591265797615, 0.00374024361371994, -0.006108779460191727, -0.015082795172929764, -0.010986821725964546, -0.0478086844086647, -0.003493238240480423, 0.016307031735777855, 0.053432896733284, 0.029275745153427124, 0.01572246477007866, -0.06766791641712189, -0.014337384141981602, -0.003959146328270435, 0.045058075338602066, -0.04954248294234276, -0.01766330748796463, -0.05833671987056732, 0.0096206683665514, 0.0021545293275266886, -0.02432016283273697 ]
<p>I have a single time series which will be divided on the date of the policy change before and after. I want to compare the variances between the two time sections and I am told to do an F test of residual sum of squares. How do I construct the F stat? Do I run ARMA and get the residual sum of squares of the two time sections and get an F stat of the ratio of the two residual sum of squares or a ratio of two error variances? Or do I do simple F test of the equality of variance of data in each of the two time sections? Thanks a lot.</p>
73,579
[ 0.006064961664378643, 0.0002103125734720379, -0.05542892590165138, -0.005312192719429731, 0.03351311385631561, 0.01563536562025547, 0.019582806155085564, -0.02805771306157112, 0.026956722140312195, -0.010947022587060928, 0.03581422567367554, 0.013070685788989067, 0.04671367630362511, 0.004618641920387745, 0.00274493801407516, -0.03734615817666054, -0.02561015449464321, 0.030270136892795563, 0.01825004070997238, -0.023935046046972275, -0.021608132869005203, -0.003211034694686532, 0.007233884185552597, 0.004523759707808495, -0.04315892234444618, 0.04591062664985657, 0.03205183520913124, 0.00031200546072795987, 0.029191164299845695, 0.07041634619235992, -0.0496872141957283, -0.0489359013736248, -0.028708169236779213, 0.05994528532028198, 0.004719390068203211, -0.007447886746376753, -0.01575065776705742, -0.06019379198551178, -0.008768649771809578, 0.08568139374256134, -0.024975575506687164, 0.0028600883670151234, 0.024553410708904266, 0.0026518923696130514, -0.023603355512022972, -0.01735295169055462, -0.021053718402981758, -0.012747811153531075, 0.028116758912801743, -0.047763675451278687, 0.082725390791893, -0.013966290280222893, 0.04920659959316254, 0.046652425080537796, -0.006109744776040316, -0.004019302781671286, 0.023225393146276474, 0.04317937418818474, 0.001663755625486374, -0.025836670771241188, -0.04604346677660942, -0.013469619676470757, -0.0004301759472582489, -0.033124323934316635, -0.056534089148044586, 0.01567276567220688, -0.04584336653351784, -0.038999661803245544, 0.02464843913912773, -0.026092417538166046, 0.006487682461738586, 0.018897585570812225, 0.0014362825313583016, -0.02532912790775299, 0.0067562381736934185, -0.00700171897187829, 0.0043443720787763596, 0.02398289553821087, 0.0343024842441082, 0.03615923598408699, -0.006780977360904217, 0.02141355350613594, 0.044422730803489685, 0.05163569003343582, 0.03551102429628372, 0.013201512396335602, 0.04191695526242256, -0.013990632258355618, 0.02196117676794529, 0.013296933844685555, -0.003496438032016158, -0.0028364364989101887, 0.05688987299799919, -0.005735477898269892, -0.054066214710474014, -0.0024720304645597935, -0.013611890375614166, 0.022325681522488594, 0.014878837391734123, 0.010400176048278809, 0.006619573105126619, -0.05958539620041847, -0.006970356218516827, 0.03137665241956711, -0.021826861426234245, -0.0032886744011193514, 0.021449469029903412, -0.0059655033983290195, -0.005994006991386414, -0.023521406576037407, -0.017435844987630844, 0.011892870999872684, -0.016213739290833473, 0.0060949199832975864, 0.042050622403621674, 0.002187954494729638, -0.03755625709891319, 0.0005468330928124487, 0.08155939728021622, 0.048505716025829315, 0.07173196971416473, 0.018676692619919777, 0.010516497306525707, 0.010234732180833817, -0.036336831748485565, 0.012152929790318012, -0.009399023838341236, 0.005481877829879522, -0.053288500756025314, 0.08377224951982498, -0.02477601170539856, -0.07623039186000824, -0.001501346006989479, -0.019939053803682327, 0.012849340215325356, 0.03063853085041046, -0.10032039880752563, -0.05830897390842438, 0.03791321441531181, -0.013860732316970825, 0.012181783095002174, -0.052525997161865234, 0.0073940325528383255, 0.014761896803975105, 0.049937654286623, 0.010077210143208504, 0.030256573110818863, 0.026222677901387215, 0.03597286343574524, 0.0151020847260952, -0.0404176190495491, -0.024112161248922348, -0.01889236457645893, 0.004315473139286041, -0.02432107739150524, -0.020931921899318695, 0.012164869345724583, 0.034854743629693985, -0.027249004691839218, 0.006130664609372616, 0.037331923842430115, 0.06677360832691193, -0.005830095615237951, 0.029612001031637192, -0.0427154079079628, -0.004462582059204578, 0.05023276433348656, -0.00889219343662262, -0.018284901976585388, 0.06017226725816727, -0.006483140401542187, -0.030569126829504967, -0.002913133939728141, 0.02538204751908779, 0.06604332476854324, -0.01706145517528057, -0.014750294387340546, -0.0033335459884256124, -0.03226447477936745, 0.01789362169802189, -0.04150807857513428, -0.0030595799908041954, -0.003860409138724208, -0.03451015427708626, 0.01598341390490532, 0.06430519372224808, -0.007734089624136686, 0.0008695699507370591, 0.013598705641925335, -0.09369063377380371, -0.06029696390032768, -0.03224332258105278, -0.010273721069097519, -0.04557623341679573, -0.04858720675110817, 0.021029727533459663, 0.009865679778158665, 0.053481485694646835, -0.0075067076832056046, -0.0282606054097414, -0.0128671545535326, -0.0010836947476491332, 0.0400555282831192, -0.029681948944926262, 0.010557802394032478, 0.03254516050219536, 0.04380985349416733, -0.0186983123421669, 0.07199915498495102, -0.03380977362394333, -0.03479844331741333, 0.01527595054358244, -0.058553632348775864, 0.02096792496740818, -0.0015117635484784842, 0.016095535829663277, 0.010306710377335548, 0.014483560808002949, -0.0083580007776618, 0.005494894925504923, -0.04427197575569153, 0.04255029559135437, 0.07420515269041061, 0.008762755431234837, 0.01058566477149725, -0.01036341767758131, 0.0025699378456920385, 0.021836115047335625, -0.027093250304460526, 0.019350659102201462, -0.030945751816034317, -0.0012378282845020294, 0.016510533168911934, 0.021533330902457237, -0.0027483950834721327, 0.011267321184277534, 0.12551693618297577, -0.006707292515784502, 0.01957831345498562, 0.028358863666653633, -0.0030689516570419073, -0.02329937182366848, 0.008093781769275665, 0.017650935798883438, -0.0033301732037216425, 0.0043586608953773975, 0.006409038789570332, -0.007022784557193518, 0.01927124708890915, 0.03672650456428528, -0.012936742976307869, 0.043359555304050446, 0.0024540505837649107, 0.010646472685039043, 0.008271188475191593, -0.034043438732624054, 0.0023719111923128366, -0.024894217029213905, -0.014256785623729229, 0.026442889124155045, 0.008771423250436783, -0.020984923467040062, -0.00009277438948629424, -0.013885642401874065, 0.03283248469233513, -0.029737044125795364, 0.0018340392271056771, -0.0056687006726861, 0.02224193513393402, -0.012805882841348648, 0.00578803475946188, -0.005570182576775551, 0.005075060296803713, -0.02829314023256302, -0.021899636834859848, 0.010956857353448868, -0.0160356517881155, -0.014077218249440193, 0.002992908703163266, 0.0005063380231149495, 0.005976819433271885, -0.009746700525283813, 0.04072777181863785, 0.0016579926013946533, -0.051460061222314835, 0.011754581704735756, -0.013228346593677998, -0.002283650916069746, 0.044597312808036804, 0.005796583369374275, 0.0026134015060961246, 0.062023673206567764, 0.031083466485142708, -0.028753384947776794, -0.023035192862153053, -0.013620821759104729, 0.008858202025294304, -0.028466707095503807, -0.019178930670022964, 0.020829157903790474, 0.006000318098813295, -0.048782940953969955, 0.016349615529179573, -0.07067321985960007, 0.04349466413259506, -0.047054339200258255, 0.0031394721008837223, 0.018674248829483986, -0.0212356336414814, 0.03360940143465996, 0.01789131388068199, -0.014794551767408848, -0.01009481679648161, -0.0555599108338356, -0.038188692182302475, -0.0067396266385912895, 0.03571872040629387, 0.005593231413513422, -0.03280872106552124, -0.04626161977648735, 0.04678363725543022, 0.01975461095571518, 0.0011745512019842863, -0.03270997479557991, 0.022935617715120316, -0.01396007277071476, -0.05057802423834801, 0.0207431111484766, 0.014507122337818146, 0.002116054529324174, 0.010412796400487423, -0.0051061976701021194, 0.038849931210279465, 0.055698905140161514, 0.012616031803190708, 0.007777090650051832, 0.03167883679270744, 0.005017342511564493, 0.023119380697607994, 0.06320985406637192, 0.005843034945428371, -0.008491705171763897, -0.011351807042956352, 0.016748923808336258, 0.01930982805788517, 0.036548491567373276, -0.027242809534072876, 0.014146051369607449, -0.01588958129286766, 0.0009358191746287048, -0.03066094033420086, 0.03615020588040352, -0.0012932999525219202, 0.007869898341596127, -0.0060973623767495155, -0.007339120376855135, 0.0150105906650424, -0.01714509166777134, 0.036866143345832825, 0.04878716170787811, 0.06529203802347183, 0.01579694263637066, -0.051032472401857376, -0.03788038715720177, -0.017888830974698067, 0.050731536000967026, -0.05360184982419014, -0.024786191061139107, 0.038423918187618256, 0.018684914335608482, 0.051136765629053116, -0.01875084452331066, -0.04390529543161392, -0.010048795491456985, -0.054664935916662216, -0.0020612513180822134, -0.014193171635270119, 0.07813779264688492, -0.005184341222047806, 0.046503946185112, 0.010587118566036224, -0.005483423359692097, 0.007446018513292074, -0.03372640907764435, -0.04569338634610176, 0.07419107109308243, 0.02241949923336506, -0.009972849860787392, -0.006088833324611187, 0.0014066367875784636, -0.007742627058178186, -0.05134163796901703, 0.021014375612139702, -0.02901659533381462, 0.003287751693278551, -0.04217735305428505, -0.010399005375802517, -0.04847957193851471, 0.017094245180487633, 0.0004676087701227516, 0.029125714674592018, 0.034141331911087036, -0.028705419972538948, 0.0333123505115509, 0.014826211147010326, -0.009517638944089413, -0.015250059776008129, -0.02122384123504162, 0.0282517708837986, 0.017381533980369568, 0.026016591116786003, 0.059712283313274384, 0.028223801404237747, -0.03168409317731857, 0.02756175398826599, 0.021700572222471237, 0.04893387481570244, 0.02942763827741146, 0.0048702736385166645, -0.01947679929435253, -0.01011673454195261, -0.03244549036026001, -0.014154225587844849, 0.0159818846732378, 0.031132744625210762, -0.04135148599743843, 0.030496343970298767, 0.03920847922563553, -0.04654109477996826, 0.04330245032906532, 0.09789487719535828, -0.01106960792094469, 0.020601648837327957, -0.04012018442153931, -0.029248738661408424, -0.01077207736670971, -0.012745924293994904, 0.03163817152380943, -0.00909136701375246, -0.00472015468403697, 0.023037107661366463, 0.0280842836946249, -0.03984397277235985, -0.028735045343637466, -0.0019280569395050406, 0.037528395652770996, 0.03942176327109337, 0.04532811790704727, -0.014351666904985905, 0.03494330868124962, 0.017117038369178772, 0.0372290164232254, 0.054694563150405884, 0.021548887714743614, -0.07755501568317413, 0.031162694096565247, 0.025604119524359703, 0.012606131844222546, -0.008338780142366886, -0.01618494652211666, -0.02167847566306591, -0.008125471882522106, 0.030435461550951004, -0.030795110389590263, 0.03419385105371475, -0.0061835334636271, 0.018493013456463814, -0.027094582095742226, -0.028971044346690178, -0.045323457568883896, 0.025697264820337296, 0.006225150544196367, 0.05779701843857765, -0.008682913146913052, -0.0340641550719738, -0.053563278168439865, -0.030285563319921494, 0.013296451419591904, 0.04423382505774498, -0.000012565028555400204, -0.012155230157077312, 0.0013206633739173412, 0.07185233384370804, -0.04554847255349159, -0.06978422403335571, 0.005336526315659285, -0.0021660951897501945, -0.006359441205859184, 0.039971500635147095, -0.001337250811047852, -0.015047786757349968, 0.010590813122689724, -0.021291222423315048, -0.01029356848448515, 0.03584722429513931, -0.010636798106133938, 0.029576601460576057, 0.026622628793120384, 0.014394969679415226, 0.06843042373657227, 0.006326351780444384, 0.011864556930959225, 0.008728167973458767, -0.004123994614928961, 0.04169584438204765, -0.021392296999692917, -0.04947621002793312, -0.019607558846473694, 0.008834290318191051, -0.0184848103672266, 0.03114272654056549, -0.03958374634385109, 0.034846507012844086, -0.041323889046907425, -0.014345047995448112, -0.010925705544650555, 0.02294478565454483, -0.0037423819303512573, -0.040781356394290924, -0.0108548104763031, 0.03235473111271858, -0.04760673642158508, 0.005708898417651653, 0.005913642700761557, -0.027617311105132103, -0.008101614192128181, 0.011186993680894375, -0.01810183748602867, 0.002275017788633704, 0.014275508001446724, -0.045842915773391724, 0.006726045161485672, 0.013161350041627884, 0.030060898512601852, -0.004613589495420456, 0.007284974213689566, 0.001443578745238483, -0.04267774894833565, 0.0017059354577213526, 0.0521683469414711, 0.02001061663031578, 0.04607667773962021, -0.04178724065423012, 0.023066675290465355, 0.008696830831468105, -0.04270224645733833, -0.08781903237104416, -0.02979850210249424, 0.0023050056770443916, 0.02722962386906147, -0.05166308954358101, -0.009703017771244049, 0.02552032470703125, -0.008252144791185856, -0.006170809268951416, -0.06322609633207321, 0.06377770006656647, -0.03627431020140648, -0.026202458888292313, -0.006435750052332878, 0.010522199794650078, 0.06992217898368835, -0.019662003964185715, 0.024503735825419426, -0.012427812442183495, -0.06713932752609253, -0.027182677760720253, -0.012163595296442509, 0.015425832010805607, -0.022201798856258392, 0.027661988511681557, -0.04127196595072746, -0.0037813992239534855, 0.034637972712516785, -0.02872111089527607, -0.006299698259681463, 0.02111782319843769, 0.02797999419271946, 0.02237384207546711, -0.04876065254211426, 0.0239389780908823, -0.061636365950107574, 0.007882941514253616, 0.006635539699345827, -0.010221929289400578, -0.015832951292395592, -0.016632026061415672, 0.004486922640353441, -0.01861974224448204, -0.009947618469595909, 0.01688670739531517, 0.07852356135845184, -0.030332930386066437, -0.010122264735400677, 0.026389745995402336, 0.025499394163489342, 0.035285815596580505, -0.011378086172044277, 0.014119555242359638, -0.005850488319993019, -0.0013818092411383986, -0.040489617735147476, -0.019693614915013313, 0.009295336902141571, 0.008169298991560936, 0.09306387603282928, -0.023195255547761917, 0.03827047720551491, 0.07250901311635971, 0.031068993732333183, 0.017535431310534477, -0.0489906445145607, -0.006073007360100746, -0.007429941091686487, -0.016652343794703484, 0.04167693853378296, -0.010616254061460495, -0.0013532974990084767, 0.01218620128929615, 0.005538307595998049, 0.021482106298208237, 0.03567754849791527, 0.04097447544336319, 0.016410009935498238, 0.032846856862306595, -0.013822244480252266, -0.032115388661623, 0.023787057027220726, -0.04350836202502251, 0.020852738991379738, -0.03435429930686951, 0.009072680957615376, 0.06261525303125381, 0.018802963197231293, -0.005737549625337124, -0.05707605555653572, -0.033051393926143646, -0.06286178529262543, 0.018857968971133232, 0.029103022068738937, -0.03492490574717522, 0.028519954532384872, 0.018854433670639992, 0.07667627930641174, -0.018373243510723114, 0.03533338010311127, -0.034787654876708984, -0.05105813965201378, -0.0637621283531189, 0.0096852732822299, -0.005062091164290905, 0.03395041078329086, -0.028204770758748055, -0.028125207871198654, -0.011498132720589638, -0.007149030454456806, -0.0034855366684496403, 0.009010490961372852, 0.030551724135875702, -0.013788696378469467, 0.08207886666059494, -0.02793148159980774, 0.042430367320775986, -0.016250004991889, -0.01279924251139164, 0.09974296391010284, 0.06301342695951462, 0.03764035552740097, -0.05183142423629761, 0.031473785638809204, 0.006539174821227789, 0.009486210532486439, -0.009504202753305435, 0.012683144770562649, 0.007434675935655832, 0.002521729562431574, 0.052359506487846375, 0.05858217924833298, -0.004707645159214735, -0.018533840775489807, 0.06831331551074982, -0.005913459695875645, 0.001314986264333129, -0.010074330493807793, 0.02414216287434101, 0.013184756971895695, 0.02363414503633976, -0.049332693219184875, -0.012962663546204567, -0.022408543154597282, -0.01179843582212925, -0.020665980875492096, -0.008006220683455467, 0.0005062835407443345, -0.013010288588702679, -0.037071794271469116, 0.02180972322821617, 0.031767331063747406, 0.03907769173383713, -0.036227136850357056, -0.02252369187772274, -0.011022759601473808, -0.039539504796266556, 0.005686410702764988, 0.050930481404066086, 0.017974989488720894, -0.03753477707505226, -0.0017971673514693975, 0.0040332116186618805, -0.05134977772831917, 0.003450727555900812, -0.04981394112110138, 0.04139479622244835, -0.00012117440201109275, -0.031082695350050926, -0.025528311729431152, -0.009951148182153702, -0.01906731352210045, -0.04874904453754425, -0.011605446226894855, 0.017793690785765648, 0.02726723812520504, -0.04640677571296692, -0.008505010977387428, -0.03954792767763138, 0.033590614795684814, -0.015502468682825565, -0.0018501125741750002, 0.020391477271914482, -0.03901083022356033, -0.012961874715983868, -0.009968970902264118, 0.0504731647670269, -0.0383504293859005, -0.011252868920564651, 0.028148483484983444, 0.004707577638328075, -0.024131013080477715, 0.005944392643868923, 0.006154077593237162, -0.015604228712618351, 0.02477763220667839, -0.02166938968002796, -0.004905817098915577, 0.006181987933814526, -0.0647614374756813, 0.01488497480750084, -0.023814991116523743, 0.02250278927385807, -0.03526419773697853, -0.019866960123181343, 0.0645628347992897, -0.008534839376807213, 0.003391843754798174, -0.009970931336283684, -0.019283995032310486, 0.06409045308828354, 0.0021478342823684216, -0.046601396054029465, -0.008474042639136314, 0.006541148759424686, -0.010950570926070213, -0.013120622374117374, -0.09719903022050858, 0.05533789098262787, 0.05432712659239769, -0.009004276245832443, -0.010041773319244385, 0.016739558428525925, -0.02177688479423523, -0.002092651091516018, 0.02199099212884903, -0.048857394605875015, -0.018062686547636986, 0.03258591517806053, 0.009331601671874523, -0.045041050761938095, -0.011683453805744648, -0.03419257700443268, -0.026391178369522095, 0.0098212705925107, -0.031154200434684753, -0.024795008823275566, 0.023378495126962662, -0.011511140502989292, 0.005933310836553574, -0.042558830231428146, 0.012383240275084972, -0.005381343886256218, -0.01326826773583889, 0.012974074110388756, -0.028375396504998207, -0.029840026050806046, 0.031747572124004364, -0.009333744645118713, -0.006227484438568354, 0.02291843295097351, -0.011674623936414719, 0.025928428396582603, -0.011329562403261662, -0.003600098891183734, -0.008652357384562492, 0.03218134492635727, -0.003249487839639187, 0.002837437903508544, 0.028659477829933167, -0.06816712766885757, -0.04995165392756462, 0.03993752971291542, 0.04003612697124481, 0.041610583662986755, -0.016244689002633095, 0.004547633696347475, -0.002658379264175892, 0.010893091559410095, -0.014186279848217964, 0.005361910909414291, -0.05436167120933533, 0.024179760366678238, 0.0034612880554050207, -0.015751134604215622, 0.025473175570368767, -0.0025148531422019005, 0.01173730380833149, -0.01977759413421154, 0.035602983087301254, -0.0476672425866127, -0.0070464126765728, 0.004227174445986748, -0.033507175743579865, -0.020648373290896416, -0.0016618019435554743, -0.02204195410013199, 0.03765810281038284, 0.04028947278857231, 0.003946536220610142, -0.03021545335650444, -0.05855419114232063, 0.015913477167487144, -0.030686339363455772, -0.023046527057886124, 0.018820745870471, -0.0026564605068415403, 0.02250959910452366, -0.02628667838871479, -0.014162580482661724, 0.027625825256109238, -0.04708506911993027, -0.00633700005710125, -0.02426103502511978, 0.005630264524370432, -0.018523892387747765, -0.007829932495951653, 0.0015870961360633373, 0.06166664510965347, -0.007081175688654184, -0.002652074908837676, 0.04384969547390938, 0.019046317785978317, 0.005846966058015823, -0.006528697907924652, 0.005629794206470251, 0.012099742889404297, 0.05419017747044563, -0.07437942177057266, 0.02152535319328308, -0.02031988836824894, -0.018186964094638824, 0.017647527158260345, -0.002675558440387249, 0.04121033474802971, -0.007846426218748093, 0.03026735410094261, 0.007743750233203173, 0.03744000941514969, -0.01117047481238842, 0.024811528623104095, -0.00202968530356884, -0.011740104295313358, 0.016571005806326866, 0.006237163674086332, -0.016692033037543297, -0.01856665126979351, 0.02856620028614998, -0.03414317965507507, 0.00912875309586525, -0.030892517417669296, 0.0047308714129030704, -0.017552567645907402, 0.010295066982507706, -0.0025820122100412846, 0.002745996927842498, -0.023966846987605095, -0.0004556253261398524, 0.012784724123775959, 0.004370739683508873, 0.04844502732157707, 0.025393769145011902, -0.02332257851958275, -0.00001557199539092835, -0.012978114187717438, -0.03179619088768959, 0.03569897264242172, -0.02876296266913414, 0.010117857716977596, -0.015416055917739868, -0.018898312002420425, 0.0007892984431236982, 0.023204302415251732, -0.04771033301949501, -0.007822657003998756, -0.013181454502046108, 0.006471380591392517, -0.015758855268359184, -0.01437467336654663, 0.003941750153899193, -0.00931596104055643, 0.03968265652656555, -0.08825267851352692, 0.037998687475919724, 0.05276321619749069, -0.05957449600100517, 0.022627104073762894, 0.01940857246518135, -0.07553183287382126, 0.0037677022628486156, 0.03512567654252052, 0.014557763002812862, 0.005296815186738968, -0.017322786152362823, 0.013939780183136463, 0.014482270926237106, -0.06755699217319489, 0.07794869691133499, -0.019248483702540398, -0.02483334019780159, -0.014330659061670303, -0.015405590645968914, 0.017347771674394608, 0.000555638165678829, 0.008321506902575493, 0.012691126205027103, -0.022041330114006996, -0.012201717123389244, -0.008190853521227837, 0.008208680897951126, -0.01024539116770029, -0.008002814836800098, 0.006887513212859631, -0.014879917725920677, 0.016049645841121674, 0.02973194234073162, 0.024565836414694786, -0.04121210053563118, 0.014562174677848816, -0.06307017803192139, 0.013259094208478928, -0.007689326070249081, 0.005880219861865044, -0.012159259058535099, -0.04878615215420723, -0.014096732251346111, 0.0386529304087162, -0.06396997720003128, 0.014164458028972149, 0.057334091514348984, 0.03613603860139847, 0.01793569326400757, -0.0008633672841824591, 0.03204912319779396, -0.01572367735207081, 0.014040774665772915, -0.029836373403668404, 0.007749056909233332, 0.075920470058918, -0.0069000679068267345, -0.005429729353636503, 0.0383114218711853, -0.03242369368672371, 0.04930046573281288, -0.048837486654520035, 0.03977534919977188, -0.020786849781870842, -0.00114679045509547, 0.005110570695251226, 0.025536449626088142, 0.009638500399887562, 0.02613445371389389, -0.019765842705965042, 0.0307516660541296, -0.06695633381605148, -0.004970150999724865, -0.020649857819080353, -0.017436161637306213, -0.047985807061195374, -0.006475950591266155, 0.03543424233794212, 0.04291946813464165, -0.012032796628773212, 0.029187330976128578, -0.002923638792708516, -0.00032051317975856364, 0.013356697745621204, -0.0216385405510664, 0.028649603947997093, -0.006105631589889526, 0.001525892992503941, -0.02444039098918438, -0.014092725701630116, -0.06146276742219925, -0.006124303210526705, 0.01941932924091816, 0.03734457865357399, 0.019824426621198654, -0.013418435119092464, -0.03950595110654831, -0.004301611799746752, 0.012633858248591423, -0.05903637036681175, -0.038219671696424484, -0.005335529800504446, 0.029012009501457214, 0.014575095847249031, 0.019187014549970627 ]
<p>What's the entropy of the following generalized probability distributions?</p> <p>$P_1(x) = \delta(x)$</p> <p>$P_2(x,y) = \delta(x+y)$, for $0\le x\le 1$, and $P_2(x,y)=0$ otherwise.</p> <p>Integrals of the type $-\int \delta(x) \ln\delta(x) \mathrm{d}x$ seem to diverge to $-\infty$ (see <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/q/625966/10063">here</a>). But entropy is supposed to be positive. What's going on here? How can I compute the entropy of these distributions? Is there a way to define entropy for these distributions?</p>
73,580
[ -0.022962190210819244, -0.019870039075613022, 0.01328363735228777, -0.0046684290282428265, 0.02179643139243126, 0.028685297816991806, -0.02944646216928959, -0.02439154125750065, 0.026805702596902847, -0.0497175008058548, 0.04856798052787781, 0.0371941477060318, 0.029451681300997734, 0.04075999930500984, 0.05449701473116875, -0.004650078248232603, -0.01616567187011242, 0.007514115888625383, 0.007666030898690224, -0.021911490708589554, -0.0009420301648788154, 0.04118781164288521, 0.04007742926478386, -0.0018468140624463558, -0.05192168429493904, 0.04179968684911728, 0.0118582583963871, -0.006857912056148052, 0.021767642349004745, 0.1107698529958725, -0.026440056040883064, -0.005688623525202274, -0.0017622445011511445, 0.04987255111336708, -0.017827415838837624, -0.012819277122616768, -0.039901796728372574, -0.027071692049503326, -0.020885005593299866, 0.02546994760632515, -0.08821523934602737, -0.03666498884558678, -0.006960997823625803, 0.02549595758318901, -0.033340081572532654, -0.004106645006686449, -0.0034496611915528774, -0.049572981894016266, 0.01652119867503643, -0.03783395141363144, 0.06576293706893921, -0.008610027842223644, 0.051912423223257065, 0.04401623457670212, 0.0004410426481626928, -0.0078087677247822285, 0.044951919466257095, 0.07584530115127563, 0.001916686538606882, -0.061993345618247986, -0.022997470572590828, -0.04355794936418533, 0.0064904042519629, -0.009519766084849834, -0.026856932789087296, 0.031561337411403656, 0.018892936408519745, -0.05243378132581711, 0.015847178176045418, 0.002515235682949424, 0.011099576018750668, 0.02664259821176529, 0.02203747071325779, -0.023977939039468765, 0.04214676469564438, -0.0025961617939174175, 0.019916562363505363, 0.00017419207142665982, 0.04910070449113846, 0.057255152612924576, 0.02000889927148819, 0.028437407687306404, 0.01363020483404398, 0.006178086623549461, 0.010308364406228065, -0.04753486067056656, 0.09452465921640396, 0.020394163206219673, -0.0037109646946191788, 0.00788796041160822, -0.0173668060451746, -0.0003558166208676994, 0.005207046866416931, -0.042357105761766434, -0.027956005185842514, 0.06346458196640015, -0.018621819093823433, 0.02277597226202488, 0.003883756697177887, -0.06446710973978043, -0.006646857131272554, -0.04818146675825119, 0.02236180379986763, 0.06613879650831223, -0.019373806193470955, 0.008882877416908741, -0.01772504672408104, 0.021574201062321663, -0.0059086838737130165, 0.001355196232907474, -0.014428903348743916, 0.01374321524053812, 0.019606880843639374, -0.01671737991273403, -0.009039947763085365, -0.018574168905615807, -0.0227616298943758, -0.011299817822873592, -0.00724035082384944, 0.06073469668626785, 0.03685898706316948, -0.005634952802211046, 0.04545797035098076, -0.015248122625052929, -0.047813933342695236, 0.017314836382865906, 0.028821201995015144, 0.02302713319659233, -0.034493379294872284, 0.04012353718280792, -0.02060684561729431, -0.023048035800457, 0.027200844138860703, 0.010308011434972286, 0.02357109636068344, -0.026830710470676422, -0.06946435570716858, -0.05569163337349892, 0.04495937004685402, 0.00841522216796875, -0.02634064108133316, -0.04089737683534622, 0.003756004385650158, 0.03767172992229462, 0.04181215539574623, -0.0005438450607471168, 0.04433687776327133, -0.003683144226670265, 0.016656214371323586, 0.019528208300471306, -0.03172820061445236, -0.030903741717338562, -0.027137910947203636, -0.0005373966414481401, -0.007512853946536779, -0.08476682007312775, 0.031118368729948997, 0.033929407596588135, -0.03900710120797157, -0.031831294298172, 0.03429064527153969, -0.010358312167227268, -0.003398628905415535, -0.018893470987677574, 0.02278323285281658, -0.027538100257515907, 0.08552652597427368, 0.02496378868818283, 0.010493372566998005, 0.033050261437892914, 0.004462110809981823, 0.023139214143157005, -0.013667993247509003, 0.047735679894685745, 0.06477285176515579, -0.01697913371026516, -0.026116181164979935, -0.03300092741847038, 0.01802845299243927, 0.0334642268717289, -0.025708697736263275, -0.005149017553776503, -0.04386626183986664, -0.03819222003221512, 0.024707991629838943, 0.007119701709598303, 0.05922577530145645, -0.030172137543559074, 0.04321564733982086, -0.050454169511795044, -0.018640827387571335, -0.07981038093566895, 0.032248757779598236, 0.01834629289805889, -0.029812920838594437, 0.03158842399716377, 0.033128343522548676, 0.04506389796733856, -0.03264482691884041, -0.009438502602279186, -0.014579130336642265, 0.018879493698477745, 0.019128669053316116, -0.022074595093727112, -0.01866241544485092, 0.04835651442408562, 0.05756518989801407, -0.0038153743371367455, 0.041130393743515015, -0.020927589386701584, -0.043890275061130524, -0.018650557845830917, -0.015659311786293983, 0.03428865969181061, -0.02569580264389515, -0.03378741815686226, 0.011506267823278904, 0.03139360994100571, 0.019874561578035355, -0.0008558902190998197, -0.028548788279294968, 0.04260220751166344, 0.04693449288606644, 0.030592065304517746, -0.03436806797981262, 0.01938507705926895, 0.01310549397021532, 0.02037057653069496, -0.04623971879482269, -0.03920472040772438, -0.03287116438150406, -0.01532669086009264, 0.04856162890791893, 0.0599624328315258, -0.03375722095370293, 0.007010416127741337, 0.030956123024225235, 0.015459476970136166, 0.022292008623480797, -0.001994660124182701, 0.00487913005053997, -0.03664017468690872, -0.006355170160531998, -0.005089467391371727, 0.016795381903648376, -0.0028859651647508144, 0.040582649409770966, -0.007882025092840195, 0.037618912756443024, 0.003857671981677413, -0.02352471649646759, 0.044057972729206085, -0.012296232394874096, 0.020881177857518196, 0.0003982310008723289, -0.004530288279056549, 0.03337869793176651, 0.007259204983711243, -0.0011769256088882685, 0.019985534250736237, 0.01644764468073845, -0.0016033576102927327, 0.019428221508860588, -0.004651483613997698, 0.0012953273253515363, 0.036869198083877563, 0.009271991439163685, -0.04000452533364296, 0.0058044432662427425, -0.007854086346924305, 0.023616597056388855, 0.018525391817092896, -0.017909856513142586, -0.030192827805876732, 0.026820369064807892, 0.022884827107191086, -0.013670755550265312, 0.020618705078959465, -0.04547778517007828, -0.04819316416978836, 0.011858191341161728, -0.0015175605658441782, 0.01770530454814434, 0.012264745309948921, -0.048208460211753845, 0.014957079663872719, -0.01248554140329361, -0.012376879341900349, 0.055476151406764984, -0.015257571823894978, 0.012508402578532696, -0.02226199023425579, -0.038394078612327576, -0.04746672511100769, 0.0035363228525966406, -0.03809879720211029, 0.05308733507990837, -0.051816124469041824, 0.00334284920245409, 0.05084172636270523, -0.03978528082370758, -0.04838697239756584, 0.023288531228899956, -0.05752526596188545, -0.04814280569553375, -0.024532750248908997, 0.021679814904928207, 0.026344146579504013, 0.0011442422401160002, 0.03775368258357048, 0.00963230524212122, -0.04092564806342125, -0.02655775472521782, -0.05608683079481125, -0.04244889318943024, 0.030012723058462143, -0.03315538167953491, 0.0030191736295819283, 0.0037114713340997696, -0.024809010326862335, 0.061395566910505295, 0.040959376841783524, -0.003089276375249028, -0.001379495020955801, -0.005238063167780638, -0.01686553843319416, 0.015887608751654625, -0.004041834734380245, 0.0053908140398561954, 0.005947434809058905, 0.06385967135429382, 0.019930768758058548, 0.03984265401959419, 0.03262081369757652, -0.02530827187001705, -0.038215771317481995, 0.06383365392684937, -0.002457113703712821, 0.002138328505679965, 0.032377004623413086, 0.04266596958041191, -0.01282078679651022, 0.01670062728226185, 0.0241328664124012, 0.0009172717691399157, 0.008897438645362854, -0.022027652710676193, 0.05176934227347374, 0.022274386137723923, -0.005056390073150396, -0.041842035949230194, 0.03995634987950325, -0.015538329258561134, -0.05713962763547897, -0.01501929946243763, 0.009892097674310207, 0.028533974662423134, -0.019258689135313034, 0.030686642974615097, 0.02719889208674431, 0.049990568310022354, -0.02884743921458721, -0.03284892067313194, -0.014291513711214066, -0.003218601690605283, 0.034388795495033264, -0.018145928159356117, -0.0070617906749248505, 0.023863937705755234, 0.04274222254753113, -0.02616043947637081, -0.016176434233784676, -0.029057590290904045, 0.006189669482409954, -0.0623062364757061, -0.000017018312064465135, -0.019897393882274628, 0.05864095687866211, 0.004975451622158289, 0.06063609942793846, 0.02248643897473812, 0.013914198614656925, 0.042710985988378525, -0.01728612370789051, -0.06198970600962639, 0.058667466044425964, -0.037652548402547836, -0.025392329320311546, -0.003338149981573224, 0.033548928797245026, 0.07271101325750351, -0.022427404299378395, -0.01979398913681507, -0.022339528426527977, -0.006769020576030016, -0.051071468740701675, -0.034121427685022354, -0.03201322257518768, -0.05714661628007889, -0.006841483060270548, 0.03692249953746796, 0.008354305289685726, -0.031786657869815826, 0.039041321724653244, 0.036636389791965485, -0.013580975122749805, 0.013689390383660793, -0.00050451880088076, -0.018039219081401825, 0.021519726142287254, 0.018839189782738686, 0.018842356279492378, 0.020812425762414932, 0.03213699162006378, 0.01634708233177662, -0.028630854561924934, 0.07340049743652344, 0.020461546257138252, -0.04819393530488014, 0.008738170377910137, -0.05444846674799919, 0.0024623519275337458, -0.009567655622959137, 0.03719498962163925, -0.010900123044848442, 0.039183713495731354, 0.04531162977218628, 0.03244505077600479, -0.031426187604665756, 0.0070925247855484486, 0.037745922803878784, -0.033842675387859344, -0.02153180167078972, 0.021830931305885315, -0.01600540243089199, -0.047628745436668396, -0.027816355228424072, 0.008049676194787025, -0.012038808315992355, -0.04291905090212822, 0.00595681369304657, 0.004329324699938297, -0.00735859340056777, -0.015041152015328407, -0.04612205922603607, 0.024308571591973305, 0.014429464936256409, -0.006554919760674238, -0.022604312747716904, 0.03310246393084526, 0.013653849251568317, 0.026381434872746468, 0.0044682142324745655, 0.016624867916107178, -0.04392843320965767, 0.011243882589042187, 0.03957508131861687, 0.0527312234044075, 0.018659068271517754, 0.0030207084491848946, -0.032103292644023895, -0.03246406093239784, 0.03932434320449829, -0.017010025680065155, 0.02530486509203911, 0.002591295400634408, 0.007143469527363777, 0.00018189426918979734, -0.031258344650268555, -0.03909602761268616, 0.002883825683966279, 0.007300936616957188, 0.010471161454916, -0.025085389614105225, -0.02883346751332283, -0.05322744697332382, 0.004901949781924486, 0.0005216680001467466, 0.05604012683033943, -0.04126732423901558, -0.011115772649645805, -0.00305342604406178, 0.030521968379616737, 0.025284625589847565, -0.0940864235162735, 0.03471403941512108, 0.02352728322148323, -0.022866228595376015, 0.06166130676865578, -0.032031718641519547, -0.03114211931824684, 0.039830055087804794, -0.009325273334980011, 0.012138779275119305, 0.04487384110689163, -0.023201754316687584, 0.06475664675235748, 0.055305302143096924, 0.020571423694491386, 0.03066197596490383, 0.04102197289466858, -0.013541978783905506, 0.018990706652402878, -0.03378719091415405, 0.04089900851249695, -0.039761945605278015, -0.002584116766229272, -0.062361862510442734, 0.011197217740118504, -0.027790969237685204, 0.03974968194961548, -0.0012136072618886828, 0.02811054140329361, 0.009442862123250961, -0.04176158085465431, -0.004985328763723373, 0.026910092681646347, 0.036245543509721756, 0.02824590727686882, 0.01882072351872921, 0.017516441643238068, 0.0305683184415102, -0.01906752772629261, 0.02030886895954609, -0.0001447018003091216, 0.0044587706215679646, -0.00015677549527026713, -0.039468951523303986, 0.004669921938329935, -0.029564673081040382, -0.030924569815397263, -0.0010738944401964545, -0.016892485320568085, 0.04774671047925949, 0.03989722579717636, 0.021863680332899094, 0.01725454069674015, -0.015591944567859173, -0.030167829245328903, 0.004774932749569416, 0.007714488077908754, 0.046352557837963104, -0.046271126717329025, 0.03440365195274353, -0.02092875726521015, -0.04078095778822899, -0.06261644512414932, -0.015399135649204254, 0.006383453495800495, -0.0028359219431877136, -0.04036629572510719, -0.07507213205099106, 0.016781920567154884, -0.012251107022166252, -0.011274517513811588, -0.022983290255069733, 0.04463058337569237, -0.01292387768626213, 0.009196612052619457, 0.016258686780929565, 0.0016327248886227608, 0.06180955097079277, -0.017416607588529587, 0.007848058827221394, 0.02022675797343254, 0.006191966589540243, -0.033487770706415176, 0.024472808465361595, -0.00028239458333700895, -0.03432535380125046, -0.022405704483389854, 0.02293551340699196, 0.004278408829122782, 0.03834284469485283, -0.0368645004928112, 0.002960073994472623, -0.010764675214886665, 0.008472518995404243, -0.02117975987493992, 0.006020071916282177, 0.01202296745032072, 0.004395535681396723, -0.0040919664315879345, -0.041912343353033066, -0.02220732904970646, -0.02205771394073963, -0.041509177535772324, 0.01872979663312435, -0.02004561945796013, 0.0070405262522399426, 0.012529105879366398, 0.04444009065628052, 0.02147883176803589, -0.006419491954147816, 0.019380319863557816, 0.02423686906695366, 0.05370517820119858, -0.022480027750134468, -0.006860245950520039, 0.014302249066531658, 0.01822522096335888, -0.019017765298485756, -0.03975360468029976, -0.06762457638978958, -0.026910865679383278, 0.03930233418941498, -0.0037316628731787205, 0.06326949596405029, 0.03547779470682144, 0.0013415428111329675, 0.00037743657594546676, -0.017060695216059685, -0.025103522464632988, 0.033428844064474106, -0.013837037608027458, 0.028481770306825638, -0.02458803541958332, -0.016166117042303085, 0.02084665186703205, -0.005615993868559599, -0.03145285323262215, 0.0008425580454058945, -0.015783675014972687, 0.00346703571267426, 0.02614099718630314, -0.028206227347254753, -0.03647937253117561, 0.03096749447286129, -0.027142958715558052, 0.015486948192119598, -0.0067038629204034805, -0.04159436747431755, 0.06951980292797089, -0.003007459919899702, -0.007323801517486572, -0.055140264332294464, -0.0032631203066557646, -0.010477461852133274, -0.015072970651090145, 0.03015979379415512, 0.014932040125131607, 0.015967318788170815, -0.008075596764683723, 0.00295543996617198, 0.000819792621769011, 0.004925000946968794, 0.004719668999314308, -0.07994536310434341, -0.011237743310630322, -0.008381156250834465, -0.05210478976368904, 0.007080420386046171, 0.007330501452088356, -0.01098368875682354, -0.008728529326617718, -0.0522109679877758, 0.020881857722997665, 0.03710345923900604, 0.02301914244890213, -0.009443514049053192, 0.06546495854854584, -0.027316603809595108, 0.038358744233846664, -0.023851241916418076, -0.027243902906775475, 0.10451668500900269, 0.03297240287065506, 0.029681505635380745, -0.08156975358724594, 0.0022354351822286844, -0.007146008778363466, -0.0042578051798045635, -0.02233687788248062, 0.03715233504772186, 0.03789952024817467, 0.009235953912138939, 0.01275873277336359, 0.06990742683410645, -0.004443824756890535, -0.02681930549442768, 0.018872492015361786, -0.025684798136353493, -0.017758730798959732, 0.03495030850172043, 0.02149125374853611, -0.03515785187482834, 0.01443807315081358, -0.06554174423217773, 0.0113444859161973, -0.0022156222257763147, 0.03545041382312775, -0.06691697984933853, -0.05507051199674606, 0.03670703247189522, -0.02146802470088005, -0.0007858634926378727, -0.012223713099956512, 0.017143312841653824, -0.019847389310598373, 0.027068400755524635, 0.005573620088398457, 0.01445944607257843, 0.004137479234486818, -0.005013040732592344, 0.04849418252706528, 0.027336308732628822, 0.014473773539066315, 0.013536722399294376, -0.0018305183621123433, -0.05414198711514473, -0.06331360340118408, -0.031965892761945724, 0.04503166303038597, -0.03767623007297516, 0.019959749653935432, -0.010356036014854908, -0.0043866075575351715, -0.03628469258546829, -0.04353281855583191, -0.029024818912148476, 0.0034990382846444845, 0.044341955333948135, -0.002466154983267188, -0.02404870092868805, -0.021264782175421715, 0.01391454879194498, -0.019292257726192474, 0.04525681957602501, -0.04576869308948517, -0.035885345190763474, 0.017953136935830116, 0.006824154406785965, 0.03176594525575638, 0.017275100573897362, 0.005441394168883562, -0.045224424451589584, -0.0011958155082538724, -0.0318109504878521, 0.02045298181474209, -0.012711399234831333, -0.03240388259291649, 0.02980251982808113, 0.03626823425292969, -0.00712192989885807, -0.012250187806785107, -0.057807184755802155, 0.02358700893819332, -0.03681409731507301, 0.015094791539013386, -0.0313299335539341, -0.010399569757282734, 0.04342891275882721, 0.05278244987130165, 0.03833219036459923, -0.005334703717380762, 0.0004390084068290889, 0.023634137585759163, 0.018414504826068878, -0.010129082016646862, 0.005381161347031593, 0.003932055551558733, -0.030624790117144585, -0.015174368396401405, 0.00927619356662035, 0.048542268574237823, 0.03588524088263512, 0.029716774821281433, 0.004994046874344349, 0.00719635933637619, -0.01631254144012928, -0.0034122432116419077, 0.0010009307879954576, -0.036480411887168884, -0.02085418812930584, 0.01147332601249218, 0.00902172364294529, -0.014643877744674683, -0.026465047150850296, 0.001500617479905486, -0.0011377480113878846, 0.0162044744938612, 0.02891881763935089, -0.04340236634016037, -0.035663049668073654, -0.014509563334286213, 0.04678049311041832, -0.017558041960000992, 0.008292799815535545, -0.003322832752019167, -0.0024524694308638573, -0.009769204072654247, 0.01653875596821308, -0.027274394407868385, 0.00914906244724989, 0.0010535978944972157, -0.012423778884112835, 0.03681153059005737, 0.04789440333843231, -0.008081138134002686, -0.01911100745201111, 0.015195004642009735, -0.008232434280216694, 0.0236485805362463, -0.019736606627702713, -0.035828765481710434, 0.05872122943401337, -0.03495490550994873, -0.05311502516269684, 0.030219953507184982, 0.031492337584495544, 0.04997935891151428, 0.026969192549586296, -0.021676624193787575, -0.04891699552536011, 0.0380757637321949, -0.02202255092561245, -0.010186227038502693, -0.02045280486345291, -0.012768625281751156, -0.006071557756513357, 0.005094373598694801, 0.03113209828734398, -0.01415277924388647, 0.01599324680864811, 0.011363505385816097, 0.01270336750894785, -0.01890243962407112, -0.005580977536737919, 0.023668725043535233, 0.0013857180019840598, 0.043347056955099106, 0.013512902893126011, -0.02556406892836094, 0.05176974833011627, 0.048204537481069565, -0.020413745194673538, 0.05704161524772644, 0.006866136100143194, 0.004248757380992174, -0.0824999138712883, 0.027399376034736633, 0.017448851838707924, 0.0011877967044711113, 0.02198433130979538, -0.10094676166772842, -0.008549937978386879, 0.0509684793651104, -0.02209341526031494, 0.02217433787882328, -0.009628592990338802, -0.006981028709560633, -0.0170951746404171, 0.033735472708940506, -0.02297956682741642, 0.06364873051643372, 0.044378072023391724, 0.061809904873371124, 0.011701356619596481, 0.01975729502737522, -0.019954323768615723, -0.0038390131667256355, -0.0357322134077549, -0.011797063052654266, 0.0014009360456839204, -0.029424088075757027, 0.05173753574490547, -0.04559001326560974, -0.02793457917869091, 0.014263034798204899, -0.0060997214168310165, -0.029450297355651855, -0.01020075660198927, 0.0229309294372797, 0.05135741084814072, 0.02879302203655243, 0.028382308781147003, -0.009594285860657692, -0.0016346490010619164, 0.02023426629602909, 0.017886707559227943, -0.0007498411578126252, -0.014873174950480461, -0.008300183340907097, 0.023780457675457, -0.025065168738365173, -0.0022328111808747053, 0.04365507885813713, 0.000461775460280478, -0.027520334348082542, 0.02010980062186718, -0.022718414664268494, 0.016345471143722534, -0.02036195993423462, 0.04456203803420067, -0.047911472618579865, -0.024147454649209976, 0.010381380096077919, 0.0031827676575630903, -0.01582426019012928, 0.013281747698783875, 0.0077530634589493275, -0.05133651942014694, 0.01319857407361269, -0.005802710074931383, -0.003194306278601289, -0.057429876178503036, 0.005181279499083757, -0.009474397636950016, -0.003686747048050165, 0.0049974252469837666, -0.03866913914680481, -0.07346946746110916, -0.002806619042530656, -0.025025561451911926, 0.013561427593231201, -0.004496077075600624, -0.042618528008461, -0.02172207646071911, -0.07776646316051483, 0.012278315611183643, 0.020140891894698143, -0.003807998728007078, -0.05807582661509514, 0.0022309590131044388, -0.05228200927376747, -0.00028073054272681475, 0.04613374546170235, 0.03142483904957771, -0.02943473681807518, 0.028006603941321373, 0.024953728541731834, 0.06025130674242973, -0.044811733067035675, -0.0048051271587610245, -0.04934556409716606, -0.010633643716573715, -0.0089930584654212, -0.010645074769854546, 0.0060174958780407906, 0.012787992134690285, 0.03186536207795143, -0.05208369344472885, -0.038072455674409866, -0.00027379661332815886, -0.020755793899297714, 0.039248861372470856, -0.0019335522083565593, -0.017833784222602844, 0.05140925571322441, -0.024127861484885216, 0.012302822433412075, -0.005573209375143051, 0.006369850132614374, -0.047831933945417404, 0.028537411242723465, 0.0065232450142502785, -0.04303032532334328, -0.013646163046360016, -0.011769534088671207, 0.018209081143140793, -0.042096249759197235, -0.04049409553408623, 0.05282852426171303, -0.026834744960069656, -0.027424590662121773, 0.028253035619854927, 0.038871485739946365, 0.04325849562883377, -0.0039906809106469154, 0.01269739493727684, 0.00982576236128807, 0.01069535780698061, -0.020895887166261673, 0.03662390261888504, 0.04945189878344536, -0.041049208492040634, 0.011362455785274506, -0.008620086126029491, -0.04666738957166672, 0.027819523587822914, 0.024404074996709824, 0.037394650280475616, -0.041266702115535736, -0.022732941433787346, -0.007195637561380863, -0.012936878949403763, 0.018807174637913704, -0.013849277049303055, -0.025422558188438416, 0.05841541290283203, -0.0027282345108687878, 0.04910779371857643, -0.036450933665037155, -0.012157874181866646, -0.033619098365306854, -0.016522591933608055, 0.016935214400291443, 0.03076917491853237, 0.0022571340668946505, 0.01036812737584114, -0.02099701575934887, -0.017126698046922684, 0.030280673876404762, -0.06493373960256577, 0.030463391914963722, -0.0009208336705341935, -0.010047181509435177, -0.012298776768147945, -0.025826187804341316, -0.005027592182159424, -0.037280648946762085, 0.00465567409992218, 0.07295194268226624, 0.035016488283872604, -0.0028591975569725037, -0.024134401232004166, -0.012001757510006428, 0.05430598929524422, -0.04927434027194977, 0.005284510087221861, -0.036593955010175705, 0.017520548775792122, 0.017119744792580605, -0.021057046949863434 ]
<p>I am studying the Rocchio alorithm. I understand how it works. And typically we set Positive feedback is more valuable than negative feedback (so, set β &lt; γ; e.g. γ = 0.25, β = 0.75). <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/cIH7x.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> And many sytems allow only positive feedback which means γ = 0.0. My question why those systems don't consider the non-relevant documents? And what are those systems? Thanks.</p>
35,987
[ -0.016802804544568062, -0.025339683517813683, 0.005951737519353628, -0.009870382957160473, 0.0160759836435318, 0.017893146723508835, 0.008234510198235512, -0.019951026886701584, 0.013552841730415821, -0.006039825268089771, 0.016291694715619087, 0.000651369511615485, 0.06256937980651855, 0.05123811215162277, -0.015439053066074848, -0.02458270825445652, -0.02588820829987526, -0.008993060328066349, -0.012968559749424458, -0.011659681797027588, -0.01309209130704403, 0.026188388466835022, -0.0013443924253806472, 0.02319752611219883, -0.004106454085558653, 0.03376290947198868, -0.0031545686069875956, -0.019883548840880394, 0.006849505938589573, 0.018177824094891548, -0.06396964192390442, -0.020333755761384964, -0.024442533031105995, -0.0034080850891768932, 0.0360705628991127, 0.01055813953280449, -0.06396876275539398, -0.031454265117645264, 0.0069862110540270805, 0.0226944237947464, -0.015179792419075966, -0.0016839919844642282, 0.020099183544516563, 0.013092835433781147, -0.005847383756190538, -0.0020397603511810303, -0.006372940260916948, -0.005873285233974457, 0.05874725431203842, -0.03984536975622177, 0.02956763096153736, -0.000214743209653534, 0.01771872118115425, 0.0751430094242096, 0.0180397666990757, 0.01062803715467453, 0.02019982598721981, 0.06971002370119095, 0.00230526109226048, 0.009883283637464046, -0.02071799710392952, -0.01763378456234932, -0.00917954370379448, 0.007268418557941914, 0.014987035654485226, -0.004386029671877623, 0.026262566447257996, -0.010354303754866123, 0.08317749202251434, 0.01889129728078842, -0.012751755304634571, 0.007805274333804846, 0.018238907679915428, -0.0004351989773567766, 0.023858020082116127, -0.04519229009747505, 0.022585591301321983, -0.032901208847761154, 0.04255397990345955, 0.02236892655491829, -0.00036944064777344465, -0.023676836863160133, 0.022963043302297592, 0.05887433886528015, 0.009025512263178825, -0.014173551462590694, 0.04342614859342575, -0.054353874176740646, 0.027903195470571518, 0.00820149015635252, -0.0025762170553207397, -0.03599949926137924, 0.023260261863470078, -0.007324705831706524, -0.00013377933646552265, 0.025939244776964188, 0.012505190446972847, 0.03475155681371689, -0.01156333927065134, -0.013111386448144913, -0.011914038099348545, -0.05559060722589493, 0.029442261904478073, 0.0541766881942749, -0.018526827916502953, -0.0217417124658823, 0.0070455195382237434, -0.02031967043876648, -0.00846900139003992, -0.013826273381710052, 0.014961128123104572, -0.03575493022799492, -0.0184079147875309, 0.014623024500906467, 0.020978610962629318, -0.013905521482229233, 0.01578173041343689, -0.0044950623996555805, 0.04563068598508835, 0.029461268335580826, 0.05037517845630646, 0.012122968211770058, -0.028870271518826485, -0.052605804055929184, -0.07535924017429352, 0.012589981779456139, 0.015171553008258343, -0.01975042000412941, -0.044974517077207565, -0.00004053415614180267, 0.03341708332300186, -0.017512870952486992, 0.04776933044195175, -0.03184704855084419, 0.015586824156343937, 0.02817591279745102, -0.07873107492923737, -0.023425620049238205, 0.01093306578695774, 0.042770542204380035, -0.007055952679365873, -0.08924423903226852, -0.026148589327931404, 0.056497037410736084, 0.07454115152359009, -0.011189603246748447, -0.006401370279490948, 0.03412313014268875, -0.0030122350435703993, -0.023239871487021446, -0.02489442750811577, -0.02287960797548294, -0.02174772135913372, -0.024381663650274277, -0.03807911276817322, -0.04145614802837372, 0.06814497709274292, -0.02834446169435978, 0.0024074530228972435, 0.01225086860358715, -0.005353050772100687, -0.0032284408807754517, 0.0027878519613295794, -0.015277736820280552, -0.019952621310949326, -0.037021785974502563, 0.09275374561548233, 0.0423927903175354, -0.00645804638043046, 0.0009833580115810037, 0.020314114168286324, 0.01532040536403656, -0.0068123540841042995, 0.010769013315439224, 0.05352044478058815, -0.007832569070160389, -0.019258346408605576, -0.05895288288593292, 0.040506716817617416, 0.002187653910368681, -0.0346863828599453, -0.01477624848484993, 0.0008552428334951401, 0.05023173242807388, 0.014564025215804577, 0.011401284486055374, -0.02898670919239521, 0.009016705676913261, 0.050240762531757355, -0.0396256223320961, -0.01678558439016342, 0.007105582393705845, 0.037439342588186264, -0.02907981537282467, -0.017059745267033577, 0.04482850804924965, -0.009055860340595245, -0.036309998482465744, -0.022343996912240982, 0.028972366824746132, 0.003516466123983264, 0.005466802045702934, 0.055824924260377884, -0.04397302120923996, 0.004310534801334143, 0.003620746312662959, 0.05723236873745918, -0.040032338351011276, 0.01343933679163456, -0.060485467314720154, -0.06422677636146545, -0.025074180215597153, 0.022354330867528915, -0.003324513090774417, -0.0025895803701132536, -0.02411433309316635, -0.018090298399329185, 0.009691226296126842, -0.01817779615521431, 0.011852788738906384, -0.06446963548660278, 0.07151772826910019, 0.06483208388090134, 0.01707327552139759, 0.015234269201755524, 0.03898352384567261, -0.007761551067233086, 0.06371983885765076, -0.010232172906398773, -0.05807109549641609, -0.03126075491309166, 0.006333424709737301, -0.0037077993620187044, -0.0021972127724438906, -0.03612281009554863, -0.008222897537052631, 0.04791310057044029, -0.006871148943901062, 0.0002858530206140131, 0.03200403228402138, 0.012415829114615917, 0.006802213843911886, 0.013780040666460991, 0.00959828495979309, 0.048707421869039536, 0.007400007918477058, 0.02517862245440483, 0.015534281730651855, 0.04804796352982521, -0.01275994349271059, 0.003820385318249464, 0.0016915175365284085, 0.019214218482375145, -0.00438647111877799, -0.022270308807492256, 0.012496444396674633, 0.04928203672170639, -0.01281831692904234, 0.02653382532298565, 0.041889533400535583, -0.001416598679497838, 0.009335020557045937, 0.02497561275959015, -0.008284825831651688, -0.0006258852081373334, -0.008156400173902512, -0.024082837626338005, -0.040892936289310455, 0.01984643004834652, -0.046240851283073425, 0.032139915972948074, 0.004661994054913521, -0.0159650519490242, -0.01738058030605316, 0.0022648382000625134, 0.05928971245884895, -0.002224865136668086, 0.041126128286123276, -0.008885226212441921, -0.010633265599608421, -0.03204828500747681, -0.009126001037657261, 0.0028970239218324423, 0.005094446241855621, -0.025725409388542175, -0.02723078802227974, -0.005787533707916737, 0.030662544071674347, 0.0393746979534626, 0.006822007708251476, -0.007604425307363272, 0.04505031928420067, -0.006212190259248018, -0.06706669181585312, -0.043543796986341476, -0.03972380608320236, -0.05540744215250015, 0.003219685982912779, -0.03732599690556526, 0.060796111822128296, 0.0435650609433651, -0.06398023664951324, 0.040587037801742554, -0.037162262946367264, -0.0400310717523098, -0.015892205759882927, -0.017861004918813705, -0.02912302501499653, -0.032007649540901184, -0.00638814689591527, -0.005404531490057707, -0.02080567367374897, -0.012034530751407146, -0.03638707846403122, -0.07314988970756531, -0.019144807010889053, -0.017116213217377663, 0.032450076192617416, 0.011125710792839527, -0.030961938202381134, 0.06758289784193039, 0.02727753110229969, -0.0442824587225914, -0.04426092654466629, -0.02196061983704567, -0.048627059906721115, -0.06171334907412529, -0.034477222710847855, 0.028700321912765503, 0.014555659145116806, 0.012444266118109226, -0.0007746363407932222, 0.040480706840753555, 0.01137411780655384, 0.028972340747714043, -0.017668478190898895, 0.01811710000038147, 0.05520155280828476, -0.014402003958821297, 0.014640957117080688, 0.05110219866037369, -0.01387699693441391, 0.02920779213309288, -0.010701235383749008, 0.045949164777994156, 0.029113883152604103, -0.01981530152261257, 0.010150196962058544, 0.02355288714170456, -0.001507817069068551, 0.005983955226838589, 0.01158875785768032, 0.01690990850329399, -0.0249614380300045, -0.03682183101773262, -0.011826804839074612, 0.032091110944747925, -0.03976254165172577, -0.00794277898967266, 0.03906942903995514, 0.0035303838085383177, -0.02367464452981949, -0.005314459092915058, -0.023661067709326744, 0.01926293969154358, -0.00605565682053566, -0.055737532675266266, 0.032329268753528595, 0.052267301827669144, 0.026226913556456566, -0.021154506132006645, -0.02036920376121998, -0.029770081862807274, -0.036873042583465576, -0.07002312690019608, -0.007180733140558004, -0.03897567838430405, 0.06600926071405411, -0.017838161438703537, 0.020695967599749565, -0.0019108133856207132, 0.04123375192284584, 0.02466384321451187, 0.02745913527905941, -0.025269068777561188, 0.021513301879167557, -0.06371273845434189, 0.01878492720425129, 0.04071258753538132, -0.008867737837135792, 0.026757225394248962, -0.010647991672158241, -0.03018021397292614, -0.01811128482222557, 0.029134295880794525, -0.038685642182826996, -0.011303347535431385, -0.026297014206647873, -0.022711385041475296, -0.062043942511081696, 0.033454809337854385, -0.013393276371061802, -0.02925659902393818, 0.03698146343231201, 0.055732611566782, 0.0073228091932833195, 0.0034558346960693598, -0.048258423805236816, 0.033081021159887314, 0.04277714714407921, 0.04281006008386612, 0.03507168963551521, -0.013037905097007751, -0.09706799685955048, 0.04359984025359154, 0.057894736528396606, 0.013880967162549496, 0.031250279396772385, 0.01728120818734169, -0.03280824050307274, 0.004133319482207298, -0.02843545377254486, 0.013655249960720539, 0.011416483670473099, -0.009668131358921528, -0.0014881123788654804, 0.025692034512758255, -0.004559949040412903, -0.0012264352990314364, -0.0012175592128187418, 0.04295889288187027, 0.009000124409794807, -0.0017611435614526272, -0.02432231791317463, 0.001791165443137288, -0.00007694095256738365, -0.005466077011078596, -0.03168248385190964, 0.04783215373754501, -0.0072421720251441, -0.026921555399894714, 0.01894559897482395, -0.02163071371614933, -0.01935007981956005, 0.009821423329412937, 0.008530749939382076, -0.018715741112828255, -0.0317949578166008, -0.004210153128951788, 0.06160705164074898, 0.04509568214416504, 0.043943051248788834, -0.007739201653748751, 0.02972264401614666, -0.05775604769587517, -0.03078397735953331, 0.029672745615243912, 0.022994212806224823, 0.010941741056740284, -0.014449696987867355, -0.09776865690946579, 0.001372367492876947, 0.017652157694101334, -0.050416249781847, 0.03654012829065323, -0.03114093281328678, 0.04212320223450661, -0.0014560219133272767, -0.03964138776063919, 0.030116111040115356, 0.010919190011918545, 0.009240243583917618, 0.013417249545454979, 0.03045317344367504, -0.02055039256811142, -0.04654692858457565, -0.04535335674881935, 0.0018405349692329764, 0.026040997356176376, -0.01659482531249523, -0.01230083592236042, 0.044977378100156784, 0.0344385989010334, -0.03926173970103264, -0.06854204833507538, 0.014375632628798485, -0.015084318816661835, 0.00339920399710536, 0.06844255328178406, 0.003151542041450739, -0.004797664936631918, 0.01814456097781658, 0.04325178638100624, -0.047165073454380035, -0.010812627151608467, -0.04876197502017021, 0.05243794620037079, 0.0730670690536499, 0.047507334500551224, 0.0281026940792799, 0.049404434859752655, -0.038382597267627716, -0.005275472532957792, -0.04250968247652054, 0.028352316468954086, -0.018429407849907875, 0.031115833669900894, -0.044867970049381256, 0.014464501291513443, -0.022811448201537132, 0.012539124116301537, 0.007331429980695248, 0.021846259012818336, 0.0111697381362319, -0.015725592151284218, 0.0249867495149374, 0.0028631449677050114, -0.020231051370501518, 0.0026337846647948027, 0.04157605022192001, 0.03402922675013542, -0.002053528092801571, -0.01878342218697071, 0.023183628916740417, -0.07273998856544495, -0.0332641527056694, 0.03772550821304321, -0.02434696815907955, -0.03973327577114105, -0.02316790632903576, -0.0007542649400420487, -0.01623529940843582, 0.02647032029926777, 0.0016786822816357017, 0.025123462080955505, 0.02039683237671852, -0.021214192733168602, 0.0027395726647228003, 0.0038709607906639576, 0.0622357502579689, -0.02141699008643627, 0.046123240143060684, -0.06691359728574753, 0.053535833954811096, 0.012366531416773796, 0.0059869615361094475, -0.05264747142791748, -0.012018186040222645, 0.03823743015527725, 0.0058426810428500175, -0.028308656066656113, -0.019457628950476646, -0.02119632624089718, 0.009134591557085514, -0.04230697453022003, -0.001075400854460895, -0.002929673995822668, -0.006489416118711233, -0.036758504807949066, 0.035426050424575806, 0.00039603584446012974, 0.03829583898186684, -0.04346190392971039, 0.01097545400261879, 0.030227679759263992, 0.00797189399600029, 0.00941537320613861, -0.0010647117160260677, -0.014636514708399773, -0.015789484605193138, -0.02409367822110653, -0.03732181712985039, 0.011144667863845825, 0.004260729067027569, -0.01025222148746252, 0.03343027085065842, 0.02655782736837864, 0.011049129068851471, -0.021481072530150414, -0.01869564689695835, 0.0015185194788500667, -0.031785864382982254, -0.017893392592668533, -0.003681403351947665, 0.004091459792107344, -0.034572016447782516, -0.02272121049463749, 0.008678123354911804, 0.005852316506206989, 0.00385483936406672, 0.019637448713183403, 0.07959365844726562, -0.0046253204345703125, -0.020213831216096878, 0.028226030990481377, 0.008610380813479424, 0.029687901958823204, -0.0030817834194749594, -0.015059784054756165, -0.013416734524071217, 0.010295640677213669, -0.00600028969347477, -0.0431567020714283, -0.022067537531256676, 0.01917385123670101, 0.06721276044845581, -0.010358894243836403, 0.002717967377975583, -0.012860221788287163, 0.009082820266485214, -0.011321273632347584, -0.030415004119277, -0.0341336652636528, -0.03539872169494629, -0.02046407386660576, 0.03752264752984047, -0.05323100462555885, -0.012094439007341862, 0.029828175902366638, 0.023864902555942535, 0.00445131491869688, -0.015135603956878185, 0.03317432478070259, 0.03159140795469284, 0.028985271230340004, -0.08036145567893982, -0.025600142776966095, 0.06630721688270569, -0.04801499843597412, 0.041772279888391495, 0.020656827837228775, -0.05650635063648224, 0.024344006553292274, 0.02888616733253002, 0.011848313733935356, -0.11511176824569702, -0.0024861579295247793, -0.03473297134041786, 0.0058450051583349705, 0.01971151866018772, -0.02186308242380619, -0.0073901591822505, -0.007810303475707769, 0.04847009852528572, -0.022093482315540314, 0.021480899304151535, -0.006562730297446251, -0.052448805421590805, -0.040733687579631805, -0.04104990512132645, -0.029148491099476814, 0.027240058407187462, 0.004949165973812342, -0.030006710439920425, -0.020385554060339928, -0.03028693050146103, 0.059127748012542725, 0.0042193979024887085, 0.035216908901929855, 0.031611405313014984, 0.028665702790021896, -0.042947832494974136, 0.045036058872938156, 0.007020718418061733, -0.01690748892724514, 0.15513776242733002, 0.07696666568517685, -0.002068143105134368, -0.07777389138936996, -0.02713153325021267, 0.012796008959412575, 0.049883149564266205, 0.004899142775684595, 0.020083045586943626, 0.019794994965195656, -0.012690084055066109, 0.006744398735463619, 0.04275689274072647, 0.03706829249858856, -0.018993889912962914, 0.043833211064338684, -0.06124396622180939, -0.01735379546880722, 0.02074168249964714, -0.019086068496108055, -0.008532535284757614, -0.03088071197271347, -0.03158160299062729, 0.006606645882129669, 0.035221125930547714, 0.013165666721761227, -0.008041076362133026, -0.03893253207206726, 0.003932533320039511, 0.03744260594248772, 0.03169027343392372, 0.014118107967078686, -0.00749211898073554, 0.055866461247205734, 0.03469887375831604, 0.006410004571080208, 0.04629696533083916, -0.007550020236521959, 0.025581495836377144, 0.05855367332696915, 0.03014788217842579, 0.014385635033249855, -0.0077028400264680386, 0.03918485715985298, -0.017734479159116745, -0.0037820839788764715, -0.03262162208557129, 0.024318411946296692, -0.0018772867042571306, 0.0056732455268502235, -0.007111412473022938, -0.007911772467195988, -0.001610583276487887, 0.004550863988697529, -0.05415653809905052, 0.03460979834198952, -0.012241327203810215, 0.006260287947952747, -0.05294090509414673, 0.02094571478664875, 0.005583455320447683, -0.02168571576476097, 0.0415620431303978, 0.04212076961994171, -0.0816754475235939, -0.043182410299777985, -0.0008481211843900383, 0.030672933906316757, -0.006204309873282909, -0.0129640381783247, -0.005306870676577091, 0.006690416485071182, -0.012443316169083118, -0.01995372213423252, -0.009509049355983734, 0.037933118641376495, 0.002549805212765932, -0.02526823617517948, -0.006444028578698635, -0.017275424674153328, -0.00014699874736834317, 0.03418715298175812, -0.02346923016011715, -0.02823437564074993, -0.04688122123479843, -0.062038354575634, 0.0030429845210164785, 0.020223325118422508, -0.012880301102995872, -0.005502984393388033, 0.005811501294374466, 0.036914143711328506, -0.003166560549288988, -0.04445789381861687, -0.03199589625000954, 0.058689095079898834, -0.05736246332526207, 0.0090866694226861, 0.0025008120574057102, 0.06238436698913574, 0.005480024963617325, 0.007898742333054543, 0.001899076160043478, 0.054551828652620316, -0.023500269278883934, -0.0046396623365581036, 0.047773007303476334, -0.059106361120939255, 0.013381978496909142, 0.013742459006607533, -0.002861875109374523, -0.041542068123817444, 0.01687740720808506, -0.033099766820669174, -0.005010529421269894, 0.013283079490065575, 0.02270498313009739, -0.012063255533576012, -0.026628857478499413, -0.0037331851199269295, 0.029137231409549713, 0.02433127537369728, -0.004168807994574308, -0.023106304928660393, 0.04195808991789818, 0.005097847897559404, -0.022128166630864143, -0.012600229121744633, 0.020405245944857597, -0.0074452245607972145, -0.017314383760094643, 0.012046245858073235, 0.0034873224794864655, -0.04635903611779213, -0.020820068195462227, -0.036832284182310104, 0.00699531938880682, 0.03023180179297924, -0.023230208083987236, -0.005122509319335222, 0.009327827021479607, -0.03655551001429558, -0.057796280831098557, 0.03337712585926056, -0.0055421157740056515, -0.00395237235352397, 0.01668659597635269, -0.021887242794036865, -0.024300022050738335, 0.07491691410541534, -0.02463158778846264, -0.008865750394761562, 0.03946675360202789, -0.0017799129709601402, 0.0157686285674572, -0.01048025768250227, 0.025636065751314163, -0.011892073787748814, -0.018860088661313057, 0.01214613951742649, 0.032206758856773376, -0.007185219321399927, -0.0027451631613075733, -0.017724890261888504, -0.02660503052175045, -0.04427473619580269, 0.015262912027537823, 0.013706966303288937, 0.021216081455349922, 0.037041980773210526, -0.04204601049423218, 0.0013930010609328747, 0.041991282254457474, 0.0385318361222744, -0.028887266293168068, 0.004715570714324713, 0.029927246272563934, 0.00612903106957674, 0.003204484935849905, -0.029350541532039642, 0.02033764310181141, 0.022355956956744194, -0.04291669651865959, 0.016683528199791908, -0.029481524601578712, -0.008768968284130096, -0.049085479229688644, 0.003107752650976181, -0.04860646277666092, 0.01881888508796692, 0.009546097368001938, 0.003791947616264224, 0.028060324490070343, -0.024648334830999374, -0.052140817046165466, 0.0010419712634757161, -0.049022067338228226, 0.008216400630772114, -0.028558185324072838, 0.0023665577173233032, 0.003196299308910966, -0.044642481952905655, -0.042539846152067184, 0.012731138616800308, -0.05855020508170128, -0.03482532501220703, 0.0040222397074103355, 0.016280094161629677, 0.019009724259376526, 0.05104471743106842, 0.05895727872848511, -0.016466312110424042, 0.0052397907711565495, 0.013160773552954197, 0.03200499713420868, 0.04251793026924133, -0.001284924685023725, 0.040073975920677185, 0.018350966274738312, 0.009361443109810352, -0.0005827574641443789, 0.019065553322434425, -0.017361139878630638, -0.01648947224020958, -0.00867937970906496, 0.026024281978607178, -0.018060266971588135, -0.04083165526390076, -0.0229521244764328, -0.010124527849256992, 0.004979380872100592, 0.0029365287628024817, 0.04079553484916687, 0.019624335691332817, -0.034199245274066925, -0.029640132561326027, -0.065994493663311, 0.022683696821331978, 0.026546424254775047, -0.01229870319366455, -0.024002021178603172, 0.0017024967819452286, -0.014697933569550514, 0.009224415756762028, -0.017937030643224716, 0.015517789870500565, -0.027576394379138947, 0.05103610083460808, -0.028680959716439247, 0.023728540167212486, 0.003289535641670227, -0.04097294434905052, 0.027749069035053253, -0.06911029666662216, 0.05802297592163086, 0.01417943462729454, 0.020961696282029152, -0.024360673502087593, -0.006949638016521931, -0.046873558312654495, 0.0025937482714653015, 0.031043849885463715, -0.0015382302226498723, -0.024502906948328018, 0.007900136522948742, -0.033598851412534714, -0.008643325418233871, 0.003459878731518984, 0.035084135830402374, -0.04297685995697975, -0.00773193035274744, -0.013911421410739422, 0.03074541687965393, -0.027994871139526367, -0.009249329566955566, 0.003346995683386922, -0.014944430440664291, -0.018192652612924576, -0.01446229312568903, -0.026176802814006805, 0.004006699193269014, 0.02883181720972061, 0.03681495785713196, 0.06669721007347107, 0.02396143414080143, 0.03234495967626572, 0.03421323746442795, -0.0000015262232864188263, -0.07485788315534592, 0.022678419947624207, 0.0025033748243004084, -0.039862070232629776, 0.007507393602281809, -0.006135133095085621, 0.017444109544157982, -0.006657357327640057, 0.016004519537091255, 0.07718043774366379, -0.03161085024476051, -0.013425217941403389, 0.0021510387305170298, 0.035120561718940735, 0.026891181245446205, 0.013717252761125565, 0.02224961668252945, 0.00997728481888771, -0.027859952300786972, 0.0012564740609377623, 0.006938832812011242, -0.009296673350036144, 0.02649874985218048, 0.024716729298233986, 0.06218074634671211, -0.027408462017774582, 0.05293373763561249, -0.004979921504855156, 0.08014524728059769, 0.012500942684710026, 0.014982003718614578, 0.019643574953079224, -0.004009061958640814, 0.008554570376873016, 0.029423100873827934, 0.02304626628756523, 0.057945653796195984, -0.04976040497422218, 0.024099666625261307, -0.04292623698711395, 0.0070898812264204025, 0.0060190767981112, 0.01852947659790516, 0.011630738154053688, 0.04257071018218994, -0.014755199663341045, 0.004326161462813616, 0.011913334019482136, -0.017844421789050102, 0.01812947914004326, -0.029409322887659073, 0.013167009688913822, 0.022953476756811142, 0.0149915786460042, 0.031888920813798904, -0.02265053056180477, -0.027866918593645096, -0.04574684426188469, 0.05318939685821533, 0.004454178735613823, 0.016807880252599716, -0.018968850374221802, -0.04843464493751526, 0.017454765737056732, 0.03930704668164253, -0.015596766024827957, 0.001579195843078196, -0.012543542310595512, 0.009258231148123741, 0.002274914411827922, -0.004101735074073076 ]
<p>To avoid reinventing the wheel, which approaches are known to extract product / service data from previously unknown webpages via machine-learning?</p> <p>Which keywords in a search engine might give me better results about this topic?</p>
35,988
[ -0.027131563052535057, -0.03705133870244026, 0.0018267235718667507, -0.003630254650488496, -0.020134257152676582, 0.0028210000600665808, -0.03792436420917511, 0.0018891391810029745, 0.02684306725859642, -0.02619997225701809, 0.013657651841640472, 0.04246389493346214, 0.024862678721547127, 0.009607863612473011, -0.015313493087887764, 0.04251711443066597, -0.009544246830046177, 0.00524657778441906, -0.0003827472683042288, -0.008085398003458977, 0.019006112590432167, -0.029896844178438187, -0.01320401020348072, 0.015228849835693836, -0.006907795090228319, 0.012456008233129978, 0.028098875656723976, -0.02423839271068573, 0.013980948366224766, 0.01156730204820633, -0.01496120821684599, 0.015872448682785034, 0.01638806425035, 0.014742827042937279, -0.014233666472136974, -0.018209287896752357, -0.07285705208778381, -0.047245025634765625, -0.024022920057177544, 0.015641910955309868, -0.024253621697425842, 0.010594879277050495, 0.008020322769880295, 0.02374662645161152, -0.024415478110313416, -0.0018755646888166666, -0.014639616943895817, -0.05042124167084694, -0.022898172959685326, -0.0647067204117775, 0.05461888387799263, -0.024539396166801453, 0.0016433888813480735, 0.0242242980748415, -0.0335339717566967, -0.0010687143076211214, 0.05734506994485855, 0.04516623914241791, -0.007611553184688091, -0.07769869267940521, -0.04789844527840614, 0.00721387006342411, -0.011039640754461288, -0.03388342633843422, -0.07233818620443344, 0.05008973926305771, 0.01652994565665722, -0.003359011607244611, 0.05581076815724373, -0.00702245207503438, 0.01702454872429371, 0.021760061383247375, 0.048182155936956406, 0.016073642298579216, -0.008665503934025764, -0.0320034958422184, -0.006036051549017429, 0.044619664549827576, 0.04220612719655037, 0.023813309147953987, 0.0287322998046875, -0.03415151312947273, 0.01996617577970028, 0.036315836012363434, 0.024491947144269943, 0.00021430380002129823, 0.08661556988954544, -0.0256491769105196, -0.0002878829836845398, 0.0314328558743, 0.020268462598323822, -0.009709796868264675, 0.040267691016197205, -0.01192049216479063, -0.03518678992986679, 0.014071553014218807, -0.01013787928968668, 0.03263990581035614, 0.03590855002403259, -0.022339412942528725, 0.0037240053061395884, -0.018202414736151695, -0.01894126646220684, 0.08636584132909775, -0.02420227974653244, 0.0022078328765928745, -0.01550325658172369, 0.00547217670828104, 0.0010446762898936868, 0.014327525161206722, -0.03502257168292999, 0.01250437181442976, -0.009192027151584625, -0.00560357328504324, 0.01991799846291542, 0.003156582824885845, -0.06304323673248291, -0.014779792167246342, 0.07944497466087341, 0.09938085824251175, 0.003738067112863064, -0.0178788211196661, 0.019026245921850204, -0.0072128791362047195, -0.017326198518276215, 0.012944526970386505, 0.02727961540222168, -0.017871180549263954, -0.03767700865864754, 0.01196985598653555, -0.025840841233730316, -0.02137913554906845, 0.03386082500219345, -0.028395699337124825, 0.004420510493218899, 0.044325705617666245, -0.05977620929479599, -0.0521891824901104, 0.02402454987168312, -0.003072932595387101, 0.007473430130630732, -0.004823936615139246, 0.022288993000984192, 0.013030230067670345, 0.057683538645505905, 0.022819021716713905, 0.037883929908275604, 0.01721840724349022, 0.004172223620116711, -0.004279327113181353, -0.016264310106635094, -0.032200559973716736, -0.001952208811417222, 0.02043679729104042, 0.005923243705183268, -0.05068559572100639, 0.011424409225583076, 0.036319561302661896, -0.006272512953728437, -0.014470338821411133, 0.0362798236310482, 0.02244986966252327, -0.016905104741454124, -0.012260750867426395, 0.04133644327521324, -0.006182801444083452, 0.03639601171016693, -0.009741650894284248, 0.047713275998830795, 0.021999666467308998, -0.027383403852581978, 0.014573480002582073, 0.016079481691122055, 0.010792172513902187, 0.0413614958524704, 0.01028548926115036, -0.012502686120569706, 0.014206340536475182, 0.04008181765675545, 0.0005199015140533447, -0.019422246143221855, -0.047474607825279236, -0.005003391765058041, 0.039035748690366745, 0.026153139770030975, 0.0664188489317894, 0.012981466948986053, -0.03004421480000019, 0.052282337099313736, -0.05256325751543045, 0.0049592903815209866, -0.04774290323257446, -0.014690382406115532, -0.013144610449671745, -0.018435893580317497, 0.02666367031633854, -0.008901220746338367, -0.008116056211292744, -0.053196899592876434, -0.02054135501384735, 0.005500080529600382, 0.00239454279653728, 0.03535814955830574, -0.014515581540763378, -0.01785942167043686, 0.050450727343559265, 0.006788837723433971, -0.031574547290802, 0.03133160620927811, -0.05062052235007286, -0.06241456791758537, -0.005818663164973259, -0.009491946548223495, 0.027993422001600266, -0.049467749893665314, -0.029713086783885956, 0.000669037108309567, 0.02395312860608101, -0.047626420855522156, 0.013738369569182396, -0.04364185035228729, 0.05738078057765961, 0.05599140748381615, 0.059327635914087296, 0.004738209303468466, -0.013101000338792801, 0.025665057823061943, 0.029793936759233475, -0.02995281293988228, -0.013716344721615314, -0.1079486683011055, -0.0264658834785223, 0.05639880150556564, 0.029707180336117744, -0.03487553820014, -0.010839554481208324, 0.042756106704473495, 0.031045127660036087, 0.03763539716601372, 0.018032366409897804, -0.052540406584739685, 0.001989257289096713, 0.058312732726335526, 0.025215160101652145, 0.005976173561066389, 0.016055865213274956, 0.004910369869321585, 0.01732822321355343, 0.048389095813035965, 0.01145129557698965, 0.028048301115632057, 0.03570737689733505, 0.01821891963481903, -0.02265124022960663, 0.00586154218763113, -0.027177145704627037, 0.043456900864839554, -0.041475195437669754, -0.026895727962255478, -0.010900464840233326, 0.04314330220222473, 0.019856786355376244, -0.007063652854412794, -0.024351008236408234, 0.017451681196689606, 0.03637078404426575, -0.02099519409239292, 0.028315724804997444, 0.04332996532320976, -0.053312309086322784, 0.010007001459598541, 0.0042790863662958145, -0.004241344053298235, -0.02544790878891945, 0.03234628587961197, 0.010009447112679482, -0.02651812881231308, 0.02834387868642807, -0.023399274796247482, -0.034585047513246536, 0.015728402882814407, -0.026987772434949875, -0.01333095133304596, 0.01740579679608345, -0.02306731976568699, -0.0027582973707467318, -0.00851703342050314, -0.028681587427854538, 0.03963546082377434, 0.010915988124907017, -0.01727835088968277, -0.0005710010300390422, 0.005942430812865496, -0.07089003175497055, 0.007134174462407827, -0.019536960870027542, 0.06629548966884613, -0.00998238567262888, -0.02495591528713703, 0.012279434129595757, 0.006753964349627495, -0.03868655487895012, 0.015009414404630661, -0.006548319011926651, -0.04917436093091965, -0.013154421001672745, -0.0011945102596655488, -0.0031829315703362226, -0.025693926960229874, 0.01254252903163433, 0.025327904149889946, 0.02967495657503605, 0.03318362310528755, -0.04598529636859894, -0.06742636114358902, 0.03179839253425598, -0.024455010890960693, 0.005499951541423798, 0.03794657066464424, 0.010666120797395706, 0.09710048139095306, 0.006187974009662867, -0.06436297297477722, -0.025575507432222366, -0.029940975829958916, 0.010655123740434647, -0.02272307686507702, 0.0013978650094941258, 0.007695456966757774, -0.00720228860154748, 0.02234707586467266, 0.01631743647158146, 0.0279212836176157, 0.0424705371260643, 0.03553161770105362, -0.03405052796006203, 0.02573583275079727, 0.007012852933257818, -0.014597958885133266, 0.01690361462533474, 0.04021250456571579, -0.03718748688697815, 0.016326146200299263, 0.008301926776766777, 0.024543872103095055, 0.02965371496975422, -0.031941644847393036, 0.011232227087020874, -0.023651782423257828, -0.03970559686422348, -0.0029327510856091976, 0.02698558382689953, 0.0034213203471153975, -0.04231281206011772, -0.04107821732759476, 0.007554853800684214, 0.017508434131741524, -0.014496959745883942, 0.0038605488371104, 0.04228940233588219, 0.026870906352996826, -0.05672411620616913, -0.02852438949048519, -0.04155105724930763, -0.03401579335331917, 0.011407475918531418, 0.02217261493206024, 0.002752619097009301, 0.00571099016815424, 0.04758642241358757, 0.01875237002968788, 0.03371241316199303, -0.03649839386343956, 0.011177399195730686, -0.09182989597320557, -0.020174840465188026, -0.030991334468126297, 0.0492987260222435, -0.01611378975212574, 0.048411883413791656, 0.0218451377004385, -0.0262333732098341, 0.017772231251001358, 0.016033552587032318, -0.06880592554807663, 0.041672203689813614, -0.031473010778427124, 0.0010678633116185665, -0.005349063780158758, -0.034930769354104996, 0.004751545377075672, -0.0303347185254097, -0.025556934997439384, -0.03066575527191162, 0.010892319492995739, -0.04048987478017807, 0.0014874825719743967, -0.021458614617586136, -0.022324923425912857, 0.03923095390200615, 0.0012629796983674169, 0.0005135746905580163, 0.0180378295481205, 0.023523710668087006, 0.027915187180042267, -0.01349659264087677, 0.011501431465148926, -0.02671331912279129, 0.022959422320127487, -0.03381228446960449, 0.0373317152261734, -0.0024697063490748405, 0.0379781536757946, -0.0279531329870224, 0.035138022154569626, -0.0025696605443954468, 0.024950455874204636, -0.0014568985207006335, 0.002584877423942089, -0.04652118310332298, -0.03170783817768097, -0.023546390235424042, 0.041796162724494934, 0.02746247686445713, 0.018126361072063446, 0.004393986891955137, 0.004423958249390125, 0.03533055633306503, -0.062430255115032196, -0.000984628451988101, 0.08453605324029922, 0.02359485812485218, -0.010626007802784443, -0.00972757302224636, -0.008322888985276222, -0.002720119431614876, -0.0221713799983263, 0.033346034586429596, 0.0061640613712370396, -0.016946787014603615, -0.04169298708438873, -0.006855033338069916, -0.007935882546007633, -0.05319449305534363, 0.0035271956585347652, 0.02273108810186386, 0.014123600907623768, 0.0004667911271099001, -0.05882451310753822, 0.029398217797279358, 0.053839389234781265, 0.094936303794384, 0.017866425216197968, 0.007784406188875437, -0.10858873277902603, 0.017668038606643677, 0.08516320586204529, 0.0510491319000721, -0.04286443069577217, -0.05387460067868233, -0.048681631684303284, -0.00027222043718211353, 0.015381764620542526, -0.00707236910238862, 0.010132228955626488, -0.01494240015745163, -0.012080295942723751, -0.022900287061929703, 0.011157774366438389, -0.016957247629761696, 0.009111709892749786, -0.037961047142744064, 0.05079823359847069, -0.03389725834131241, -0.018937774002552032, -0.04490882158279419, 0.01070764847099781, 0.008584187366068363, 0.0401880145072937, -0.0040474263951182365, 0.0021947375498712063, -0.02200082130730152, 0.046726759523153305, -0.026760410517454147, -0.03796568140387535, -0.004418570082634687, 0.009089075028896332, -0.041718095541000366, 0.0035205131862312555, -0.01255819108337164, -0.03688524663448334, 0.027878006920218468, 0.020057478919625282, -0.022692549973726273, 0.015860356390476227, -0.004845099523663521, -0.023825639858841896, 0.04179982468485832, 0.03856167197227478, 0.046942275017499924, 0.02182869426906109, 0.017940325662493706, -0.003941950388252735, 0.008919849060475826, 0.01511911116540432, -0.059412308037281036, -0.009066511876881123, -0.02380990795791149, -0.0016495471354573965, -0.04246879741549492, 0.015941370278596878, 0.028867807239294052, 0.0629671961069107, -0.055201128125190735, -0.03929561749100685, -0.03725573047995567, 0.054340463131666183, -0.013549392111599445, -0.02018667757511139, 0.00891190767288208, 0.013812379911541939, -0.04094155132770538, 0.027403825893998146, 0.018658919259905815, 0.006846284959465265, 0.027515530586242676, -0.014813011512160301, -0.0174100324511528, 0.030478984117507935, -0.04474230483174324, -0.010803313925862312, 0.02835540659725666, 0.004797962959855795, 0.08370614796876907, 0.003277299227192998, 0.0333358570933342, 0.038276463747024536, -0.06261783093214035, 0.02202397771179676, -0.020626194775104523, 0.01592346467077732, 0.009152297861874104, -0.030140472576022148, 0.0372081883251667, -0.0249395240098238, -0.040591053664684296, -0.036669470369815826, -0.05215829983353615, 0.04307292029261589, 0.003894027089700103, -0.039452869445085526, -0.015520535409450531, 0.0372503325343132, -0.004710260778665543, -0.010998634621500969, -0.034141574054956436, 0.06189533323049545, -0.029695991426706314, -0.013629071414470673, 0.008746204897761345, 0.03804934769868851, 0.05398734658956528, 0.015901880338788033, -0.01367198582738638, -0.011212022975087166, 0.016935821622610092, 0.027645660564303398, -0.006149521097540855, -0.011057499796152115, -0.024609919637441635, -0.0010879483306780457, -0.06325256079435349, 0.006007631774991751, 0.03758241608738899, -0.030530177056789398, 0.04992028698325157, 0.015394020825624466, 0.014052282087504864, -0.04231484606862068, -0.028034036979079247, 0.024972165003418922, -0.01842961087822914, -0.0012526552891358733, -0.012802723795175552, 0.0063927858136594296, 0.018644003197550774, 0.03250288963317871, 0.029919909313321114, 0.0010988154681399465, -0.010634721256792545, -0.00799043569713831, 0.05163514241576195, -0.03285926580429077, -0.012933208607137203, 0.013342704623937607, -0.032701585441827774, 0.0425620973110199, 0.025356505066156387, 0.02828889712691307, -0.006051367148756981, 0.03670533746480942, -0.03879886493086815, -0.029627308249473572, -0.009593288414180279, -0.03677212446928024, 0.054419007152318954, -0.02114551141858101, 0.05686578527092934, 0.04808170348405838, 0.010184195823967457, 0.0012035530526190996, -0.016847850754857063, -0.01218182872980833, 0.007754857651889324, -0.02040528506040573, 0.03914830833673477, 0.021086866036057472, 0.011516377329826355, 0.0048522851429879665, -0.03050285391509533, -0.0026521978434175253, -0.005974365398287773, 0.02626132033765316, 0.045523010194301605, 0.04246188700199127, -0.06006835401058197, -0.03673243522644043, -0.03137969225645065, -0.04485226422548294, 0.013604678213596344, -0.02317769266664982, -0.022959217429161072, 0.06270413845777512, 0.015999626368284225, 0.011786703020334244, -0.020684445276856422, -0.01968361996114254, -0.044119738042354584, 0.021823924034833908, 0.032664693892002106, 0.0052957674488425255, 0.02301071584224701, 0.021865179762244225, 0.006183757446706295, 0.007347527425736189, 0.00565082672983408, 0.01739940047264099, -0.05410059541463852, -0.03416163846850395, -0.014068787917494774, -0.034488432109355927, 0.02400907501578331, 0.012058368884027004, -0.0352204293012619, 0.04189860820770264, -0.049110639840364456, -0.0031381684821099043, 0.00020219427824486047, 0.04145050421357155, -0.054215624928474426, 0.03775343298912048, -0.020065829157829285, 0.03842221572995186, 0.022484486922621727, -0.011326353065669537, 0.09806100279092789, 0.07791540026664734, 0.02764662355184555, -0.08463677763938904, 0.029941285029053688, -0.0029815167654305696, -0.010271066799759865, -0.02478996105492115, 0.016479287296533585, -0.007638454437255859, 0.024289032444357872, 0.04639114812016487, 0.015603209845721722, 0.0030561794992536306, 0.02444557473063469, 0.04556286334991455, -0.05451936647295952, 0.0181420985609293, 0.025015752762556076, 0.00048567872727289796, 0.008254080079495907, 0.007492692209780216, -0.06699459254741669, 0.009357842616736889, -0.014768068678677082, -0.03661591187119484, 0.02165987715125084, -0.07401202619075775, 0.037147074937820435, -0.004526296630501747, -0.0012525254860520363, 0.02280341647565365, 0.023618295788764954, 0.023766571655869484, 0.00829458236694336, 0.02076408453285694, 0.01543057058006525, -0.013780270703136921, 0.020957639440894127, 0.035993900150060654, 0.07021795213222504, -0.0553165003657341, 0.010525679215788841, 0.010115981101989746, -0.05187869444489479, 0.001060119946487248, -0.033103153109550476, 0.01445106789469719, -0.040908847004175186, 0.015326017513871193, -0.005885469261556864, -0.026811974123120308, -0.008524034172296524, -0.03949256241321564, -0.011620204895734787, 0.04075266420841217, 0.02666294015944004, -0.012772836722433567, -0.013772768899798393, -0.019337549805641174, 0.027265038341283798, 0.007701630238443613, 0.012685618363320827, -0.029240326955914497, 0.006611006800085306, 0.0021830815821886063, 0.011179068125784397, -0.005078910384327173, 0.008580699563026428, -0.0191603135317564, -0.01603742130100727, -0.030255835503339767, 0.012545131146907806, 0.008504164405167103, -0.007362795993685722, -0.012950476258993149, 0.014916883781552315, -0.023308897390961647, 0.016176173463463783, -0.03665930777788162, -0.025255730375647545, 0.02296210452914238, -0.013970747590065002, 0.026791542768478394, -0.037572477012872696, 0.013754031620919704, 0.025533830747008324, 0.020006723701953888, 0.03717644885182381, 0.04652317240834236, 0.019107872620224953, 0.036123428493738174, 0.0034220959059894085, -0.029256880283355713, -0.014317499473690987, -0.016656896099448204, -0.022833438590168953, -0.020314758643507957, -0.003077162429690361, 0.03104225918650627, 0.03195098787546158, -0.00542964693158865, -0.03847089782357216, -0.03452065959572792, 0.005025600083172321, 0.03306356444954872, -0.0004415292351040989, -0.039025869220495224, -0.018474850803613663, -0.013975732959806919, 0.01298314705491066, -0.03141844645142555, -0.048071254044771194, 0.005600388161838055, -0.039715688675642014, 0.01561061479151249, 0.01110099721699953, 0.0247937124222517, 0.03736766800284386, -0.008870944380760193, 0.05368626117706299, -0.0249861441552639, -0.019613023847341537, -0.051542218774557114, -0.008630065247416496, -0.00622831704095006, -0.009902747347950935, 0.0036138936411589384, 0.021958621218800545, 0.007610930595546961, 0.01755930669605732, 0.010292710736393929, 0.028950156643986702, -0.033598173409700394, 0.003578393254429102, -0.007684650365263224, -0.053758393973112106, 0.02868393436074257, -0.05787016451358795, -0.0356084406375885, 0.02316567301750183, -0.04861865192651749, 0.01182276476174593, 0.01224946603178978, -0.012320091016590595, 0.058250587433576584, 0.011252311058342457, -0.011162405833601952, 0.011561506427824497, 0.018328171223402023, -0.009601442143321037, -0.009519817307591438, -0.0019917215686291456, 0.004300073720514774, 0.03132777661085129, 0.01225766260176897, 0.0096758883446455, 0.004539078567177057, -0.02210763841867447, 0.002709104912355542, 0.015924405306577682, 0.04704330489039421, -0.027270516380667686, 0.023251380771398544, -0.006181223317980766, 0.0413920059800148, 0.016747239977121353, 0.011916570365428925, 0.05118454247713089, 0.014764522202312946, -0.010447898879647255, 0.023922836408019066, 0.028411924839019775, -0.014506584033370018, -0.0518396757543087, -0.009701218456029892, 0.018833335489034653, -0.017039336264133453, 0.04140124469995499, -0.06766345351934433, 0.04194355756044388, 0.000018354194253333844, -0.07436425983905792, 0.0380280427634716, 0.019566170871257782, -0.00996218342334032, -0.01235112827271223, 0.034869465976953506, 0.01656753569841385, 0.023771505802869797, 0.04763614013791084, 0.04174158722162247, 0.014920493587851524, 0.04102594405412674, 0.0046464488841593266, -0.00041394232539460063, -0.01284154411405325, 0.01834774762392044, 0.006592120509594679, -0.06096839904785156, 0.023714503273367882, -0.04999876767396927, -0.0534391850233078, 0.02004682458937168, -0.0006466790800914168, 0.0895766094326973, 0.02760406583547592, -0.00962661299854517, -0.015555838122963905, -0.012764690443873405, 0.04216403886675835, -0.01632111333310604, -0.00322238658554852, 0.006918421946465969, -0.0015166130615398288, 0.06927213072776794, -0.006074650678783655, 0.02024390734732151, 0.008437851443886757, -0.016041791066527367, -0.03711947053670883, 0.020427951589226723, -0.05402897670865059, -0.05061862990260124, 0.0045738136395812035, 0.01943417638540268, 0.014702849090099335, 0.010445366613566875, 0.011499956250190735, -0.06617645919322968, 0.02662511169910431, 0.03849613666534424, -0.044806960970163345, -0.008744207210838795, 0.028744947165250778, -0.02623622864484787, -0.05120282992720604, 0.048887141048908234, -0.03284312039613724, -0.020328888669610023, -0.07889746129512787, 0.019564973190426826, 0.025759728625416756, -0.02192642353475094, -0.022176532074809074, -0.024210747331380844, 0.005659019108861685, 0.04236322268843651, 0.04273912310600281, -0.0062567624263465405, 0.05185385048389435, -0.021040579304099083, 0.007048482540994883, -0.05029322952032089, 0.06294367462396622, 0.01919136382639408, -0.04996933788061142, 0.018546324223279953, -0.032897692173719406, -0.010313959792256355, -0.01687428541481495, 0.048667099326848984, -0.06844812631607056, 0.025123920291662216, -0.04613979905843735, 0.025524554774165154, 0.01128337625414133, -0.028026439249515533, 0.0750371664762497, -0.010656340979039669, -0.010098893195390701, -0.010249595157802105, 0.012264742515981197, -0.007642301730811596, 0.014592660591006279, 0.02995416522026062, 0.019063284620642662, 0.030052796006202698, 0.009079892188310623, -0.005705916788429022, 0.02205093577504158, 0.010780527256429195, 0.026354128494858742, 0.03292418271303177, 0.00857267901301384, 0.022320987656712532, 0.003361388808116317, 0.014577321708202362, -0.04958590865135193, 0.05907412990927696, -0.021286269649863243, -0.009917796589434147, -0.011973785236477852, 0.001339492155238986, -0.008178374730050564, -0.07097513973712921, -0.01935061439871788, 0.03102414496243, -0.009841704741120338, 0.012476191855967045, 0.018380943685770035, -0.005381854251027107, 0.021480891853570938, -0.01994212716817856, 0.00654906639829278, 0.0060158600099384785, -0.04457655921578407, -0.02591993845999241, 0.0215440783649683, 0.03453947976231575, -0.0003602018696255982, -0.004769222345203161, 0.02062835916876793, -0.0005304273799993098, -0.004539616871625185, -0.043938737362623215, 0.033255722373723984, -0.06423937529325485, -0.01506852451711893, 0.010751794092357159, -0.004990311339497566, -0.01967451721429825, -0.004893118981271982, -0.04022875800728798, 0.04168140888214111, -0.008322054520249367, 0.004503351636230946, -0.07333982735872269, 0.008289266377687454, -0.016844406723976135, -0.005177696701139212, -0.01607075147330761, 0.033554982393980026, 0.04571801424026489, -0.016001038253307343, 0.009378344751894474, 0.013464679010212421, 0.007262897677719593, -0.014020184054970741, 0.011093913577497005, -0.029985172674059868, -0.003913009539246559, -0.022589048370718956, -0.07412520796060562, -0.02759615145623684, -0.013913200236856937, 0.03371233493089676, 0.03548000007867813, 0.00201937323436141, 0.012568234466016293, 0.007384002208709717, -0.03508095070719719, 0.009747645817697048, -0.06380070745944977, 0.03474843129515648, -0.03424171358346939, -0.012026338838040829, -0.012214775197207928, -0.04008244723081589 ]
<p>This one is bothering me for a while, and a great dispute was held around it. In psychology (as well as in other social sciences), we deal with different ways of dealing with numbers :-) i.e. <strong>the levels of measurement</strong>. It's also common practice in psychology to standardize some questionnaire, hence transform the data into percentile scores (in order to assess a respondent's position within the representative sample).</p> <p>Long story short, if you have a variable that holds the data expressed in percentile scores, how should you treat it? As an ordinal, interval, or even ratio variable?!</p> <p>It's not ratio, cause there no real 0 (0<sup>th</sup> percentile doesn't imply absence of measured property, but the variable's smallest value). I advocate the view that percentile scores are ordinal, since P<sub>70</sub> - P<sub>50</sub> is not equal to P<sub>50</sub> - P<sub>30</sub>, while the other side says it's interval. </p> <p>Please gentlemen, cut the cord. Ordinal or interval?</p>
73,581
[ -0.029629508033394814, -0.011600657366216183, 0.0010971951996907592, -0.018370041623711586, 0.024518517777323723, 0.016899438574910164, -0.014410474337637424, -0.010675491765141487, 0.03398681804537773, 0.0051124440506100655, 0.03369111195206642, 0.022153228521347046, 0.04608072340488434, 0.012141508050262928, 0.008391370065510273, 0.002872858429327607, -0.004200201481580734, 0.009623567573726177, -0.030863061547279358, 0.011119449511170387, 0.016741011291742325, 0.032483287155628204, 0.0005691726109944284, -0.01765046827495098, -0.028580939397215843, 0.05185766890645027, 0.04002896323800087, -0.013460963033139706, 0.017573539167642593, 0.08523742109537125, 0.01775125414133072, -0.02585110440850258, 0.03148231655359268, 0.03185809403657913, 0.027508584782481194, -0.00446248659864068, -0.013959921896457672, 0.0038672557566314936, -0.05469861626625061, 0.014506039209663868, -0.03546764701604843, -0.0019524715607985854, 0.026672689244151115, 0.003679916262626648, -0.010352200828492641, 0.0025899859610944986, 0.006864454597234726, -0.045428063720464706, -0.013248883187770844, -0.04873637482523918, 0.055409956723451614, 0.002341674640774727, 0.0027985242195427418, 0.03165844827890396, 0.009128833189606667, -0.008770902641117573, 0.06950559467077255, 0.05611646547913551, -0.02607705630362034, -0.06346988677978516, -0.04197479039430618, -0.0007051913416944444, 0.018962249159812927, 0.008572065271437168, -0.010349668562412262, 0.036648645997047424, 0.0014752302085980773, -0.03340967372059822, 0.05168016999959946, -0.028192143887281418, -0.026192717254161835, 0.04613867029547691, 0.06899075955152512, -0.021838363260030746, 0.02557786926627159, -0.05603474751114845, 0.03579413890838623, 0.015277151018381119, 0.06375297904014587, 0.06926257163286209, -0.0075589921325445175, -0.012678832747042179, 0.024209273979067802, 0.029288534075021744, 0.028394825756549835, -0.02733501046895981, 0.06503293663263321, -0.03424437344074249, -0.00007986126729520038, 0.02617722935974598, -0.009909437038004398, 0.00047465958050452173, 0.007315934170037508, -0.015093393623828888, -0.01992429606616497, 0.02509479783475399, -0.009728115983307362, 0.035622488707304, -0.017921941354870796, -0.008561236783862114, 0.0028674628119915724, -0.008141432888805866, 0.04156278446316719, 0.06192673370242119, -0.04124591872096062, -0.002669519977644086, -0.03338807076215744, 0.007969291880726814, 0.033737748861312866, -0.031668197363615036, 0.015723297372460365, 0.052008021622896194, 0.009919113479554653, 0.03747127950191498, 0.02045517787337303, -0.016298804432153702, 0.013194209896028042, 0.006278689019382, 0.07520827651023865, 0.019391676411032677, 0.04206256568431854, -0.02489480748772621, 0.04318464547395706, 0.004353718366473913, -0.06348440796136856, 0.021877633407711983, 0.026883771643042564, -0.010350629687309265, -0.03807579725980759, 0.017185471951961517, -0.011505191214382648, -0.004637425299733877, 0.06027764081954956, -0.009603059850633144, 0.06285695731639862, 0.014344070106744766, -0.0810563862323761, -0.03690468892455101, 0.023229500278830528, 0.03348548337817192, -0.026258300989866257, -0.036182742565870285, 0.008221263997256756, 0.03129442781209946, 0.022057803347706795, 0.033006854355335236, 0.05081235244870186, 0.010795610956847668, 0.0030495994724333286, 0.021728383377194405, -0.025588298216462135, -0.03292660787701607, 0.005511668976396322, -0.06876255571842194, 0.0019067106768488884, -0.06438902765512466, 0.00950764212757349, 0.02758285216987133, 0.006061014253646135, -0.022346453741192818, 0.04244740679860115, -0.008117013610899448, -0.014387063682079315, 0.0015597027959302068, 0.024570144712924957, 0.013754981569945812, 0.05655822530388832, -0.03184395655989647, 0.046253323554992676, 0.04909206181764603, 0.031057389453053474, 0.01689818874001503, 0.05629441514611244, 0.03410259634256363, 0.05534401163458824, -0.012018577195703983, -0.014370557852089405, -0.043052807450294495, -0.016154997050762177, 0.011139201000332832, -0.0769643634557724, -0.009805024601519108, -0.0035244051832705736, -0.006186649668961763, 0.026057567447423935, 0.014081664383411407, 0.010233537293970585, -0.013409610837697983, 0.042569249868392944, -0.025795234367251396, -0.05684516951441765, -0.07634124904870987, 0.00454331748187542, 0.01386529766023159, -0.024420171976089478, 0.05204108729958534, -0.0031457722652703524, -0.013209550641477108, -0.045736804604530334, -0.017526693642139435, 0.009693493135273457, 0.02348766289651394, 0.04535074904561043, -0.05493926629424095, 0.025004606693983078, 0.07534191757440567, 0.026415592059493065, -0.007972868159413338, 0.0289907269179821, -0.00727047398686409, -0.07839666306972504, -0.0018512564711272717, -0.005050690844655037, 0.04972894862294197, -0.03410758078098297, -0.027666248381137848, 0.018158603459596634, -0.019003283232450485, -0.04251401871442795, 0.05396344140172005, -0.0664297565817833, 0.07005053758621216, 0.049126576632261276, -0.010419705882668495, -0.03726192191243172, 0.00509270466864109, -0.007357059512287378, -0.0009199575870297849, -0.016810111701488495, -0.009291504509747028, -0.03258415684103966, 0.014442198909819126, 0.02842886745929718, 0.025719081982970238, -0.014864896424114704, 0.010982634499669075, 0.03780907392501831, 0.06655389815568924, 0.011667685583233833, 0.03629753738641739, 0.003066076198592782, -0.02503262087702751, -0.04714004322886467, -0.011123331263661385, 0.019814757630228996, 0.03403492271900177, -0.017548376694321632, 0.011274296790361404, 0.0340094268321991, 0.0029147446621209383, 0.028497297316789627, 0.02208789251744747, 0.012808764353394508, 0.029433563351631165, 0.00044501994852907956, 0.0033501507714390755, 0.03407250717282295, -0.045500725507736206, 0.025752676650881767, 0.023073839023709297, 0.005382969509810209, -0.015671906992793083, 0.01911970227956772, 0.005207850597798824, -0.01612640917301178, 0.04448122903704643, -0.05940323695540428, 0.032333288341760635, 0.009195267222821712, -0.0026451549492776394, -0.02916334569454193, -0.06547101587057114, -0.012663951143622398, -0.04816653952002525, -0.008929195813834667, 0.027790836989879608, 0.013373516499996185, 0.03678714483976364, -0.013182743452489376, -0.006642368622124195, 0.0043749441392719746, -0.016918879002332687, 0.0029833889566361904, -0.0142286978662014, -0.05434417352080345, -0.009803815744817257, -0.028855731710791588, -0.02093915455043316, 0.014544207602739334, -0.0031731126364320517, -0.006240049842745066, 0.0028952602297067642, 0.007363991346210241, -0.03861965239048004, -0.028319209814071655, -0.041067853569984436, 0.01665312983095646, -0.03556942567229271, -0.02550429478287697, 0.03897077962756157, 0.0073429192416369915, -0.027893733233213425, 0.01802639849483967, 0.005491623654961586, -0.06654351949691772, -0.023328790441155434, 0.002759035211056471, 0.04281629994511604, 0.008906838484108448, -0.0025852308608591557, 0.016151325777173042, -0.04044261574745178, -0.027290640398859978, -0.0623108334839344, -0.08172162622213364, 0.006218207534402609, -0.013439012691378593, 0.026729455217719078, 0.020403558388352394, -0.016940239816904068, 0.09790349006652832, 0.017562152817845345, 0.013668415136635303, -0.040550362318754196, 0.021322399377822876, 0.009084546007215977, 0.01560327596962452, 0.004440370947122574, 0.010478460229933262, 0.0167331974953413, 0.006754877511411905, -0.00916953757405281, 0.03908133879303932, 0.03848472610116005, 0.01406391616910696, -0.007207740098237991, 0.0025900383479893208, 0.009920959360897541, -0.025154398754239082, 0.011180752888321877, 0.007497104816138744, -0.04519869387149811, 0.04438558965921402, -0.00804123468697071, 0.0397057943046093, -0.0042296238243579865, -0.03454216569662094, 0.01608411781489849, -0.03170562535524368, 0.020224615931510925, -0.021754678338766098, 0.03853913024067879, 0.00043864408507943153, -0.005483361892402172, -0.018386375159025192, 0.027384914457798004, 0.02043778821825981, -0.049713633954524994, 0.004616827238351107, 0.0624476857483387, 0.040087878704071045, -0.016246812418103218, 0.005898342002183199, 0.03237173333764076, -0.03501538559794426, 0.043583910912275314, -0.037990011274814606, -0.005997182335704565, 0.047451939433813095, 0.040418677031993866, 0.05112114176154137, -0.007651444524526596, -0.03697747364640236, 0.026329901069402695, -0.08261875808238983, 0.003753114026039839, -0.008737298659980297, 0.04628569260239601, 0.000019237239030189812, 0.06321839243173599, 0.00409724609926343, -0.014227278530597687, -0.011647162958979607, 0.015938250347971916, -0.04933575540781021, 0.0025567098055034876, -0.04548691585659981, 0.007993565872311592, -0.016631921753287315, 0.008239051327109337, 0.015245867893099785, -0.016670769080519676, 0.013187003321945667, -0.03162238746881485, 0.00561408931389451, -0.006996003445237875, 0.01142719853669405, -0.027936415746808052, -0.006727899424731731, 0.011144967749714851, -0.007050045300275087, 0.0024075163528323174, -0.03120073489844799, 0.028876084834337234, 0.04940859600901604, 0.013535781763494015, -0.013111316598951817, -0.04676346480846405, -0.012788196094334126, 0.030728058889508247, 0.0525025948882103, 0.01109400950372219, 0.009151180274784565, -0.04222302511334419, 0.053362876176834106, -0.031058628112077713, 0.048822492361068726, 0.030464360490441322, -0.04357784986495972, -0.005998534616082907, -0.02422996424138546, -0.03649821877479553, -0.002854509511962533, 0.019596708938479424, 0.003994038328528404, -0.003330460051074624, 0.06259503960609436, -0.0027818791568279266, -0.04982808977365494, 0.03600769490003586, 0.060800157487392426, 0.0050971354357898235, -0.03160356357693672, -0.04334278032183647, -0.032927047461271286, -0.03393172472715378, -0.023623885586857796, 0.029024625197052956, 0.010352379642426968, 0.02873682603240013, -0.010571517050266266, 0.07008056342601776, -0.024542182683944702, -0.01849077083170414, -0.027941076084971428, 0.016003210097551346, 0.009364176541566849, 0.010409888811409473, -0.04496854916214943, 0.030025627464056015, 0.0505995936691761, 0.04019010812044144, 0.021685998886823654, 0.0013524963287636638, -0.08408546447753906, 0.049074381589889526, 0.03171948343515396, 0.04278502240777016, -0.05811179056763649, -0.012310527265071869, -0.010391050018370152, 0.008431012742221355, 0.030896762385964394, -0.053936444222927094, 0.020960520952939987, -0.04214897006750107, -0.007056881207972765, -0.020461639389395714, -0.019831515848636627, -0.015999142080545425, 0.011728870682418346, 0.004728388041257858, 0.024002188816666603, 0.01135716587305069, 0.0070786140859127045, -0.06058698147535324, 0.033585622906684875, 0.021213173866271973, 0.04546922445297241, -0.02066408284008503, -0.0386035330593586, 0.012684895657002926, -0.0002792845480144024, -0.02745543047785759, -0.08660117536783218, 0.01464238204061985, 0.024016346782445908, 0.030521219596266747, 0.022539684548974037, 0.016609232872724533, -0.059747885912656784, 0.009304665960371494, 0.01078271958976984, -0.0290533397346735, 0.06522925198078156, -0.0023656643461436033, 0.08642653375864029, 0.01740468479692936, 0.014787553809583187, 0.03520820289850235, 0.06859632581472397, 0.005020354874432087, -0.005833277944475412, -0.02641427144408226, -0.006090572569519281, -0.0646633580327034, -0.025592023506760597, -0.041166819632053375, 0.010152692906558514, -0.020630571991205215, 0.026742203161120415, -0.005948070902377367, -0.006482190918177366, -0.02814365364611149, -0.021388987079262733, -0.012268428690731525, 0.009811417199671268, -0.00704119261354208, 0.010680442675948143, 0.021601425483822823, -0.00023547466844320297, 0.019220642745494843, -0.020086685195565224, 0.0023611076176166534, -0.006304105743765831, -0.00013089159619994462, 0.04233400896191597, -0.05242418870329857, 0.004205933306366205, -0.03925241529941559, -0.03828565031290054, 0.004590821918100119, -0.01464370172470808, 0.03493962064385414, -0.04341732710599899, -0.011353861540555954, -0.0019028035458177328, -0.008953521028161049, -0.04758366942405701, 0.009200685657560825, 0.010806111618876457, 0.03299383074045181, -0.03837304562330246, 0.03966877982020378, 0.0008581988513469696, -0.002121072029694915, -0.09412609040737152, -0.051706742495298386, 0.019037257879972458, 0.001619006972759962, -0.0566679872572422, -0.01561400480568409, 0.030422277748584747, 0.0066887615248560905, -0.03035043552517891, 0.005512159783393145, 0.07473007589578629, 0.00034466476063244045, -0.031536929309368134, -0.04985480383038521, -0.003972616512328386, 0.10198701173067093, -0.006292008329182863, -0.019279494881629944, -0.005736938677728176, 0.000016543010133318603, 0.011579474434256554, 0.009009336121380329, 0.012499635107815266, -0.02054646797478199, 0.00564996711909771, -0.015342656522989273, -0.032783787697553635, 0.0069863018579781055, 0.014021402224898338, -0.016234003007411957, 0.005105779506266117, -0.04424898698925972, 0.0036749648861587048, -0.003953463863581419, 0.02461482770740986, -0.012360312044620514, -0.00906620267778635, -0.019326530396938324, 0.01010528951883316, -0.02655065432190895, 0.009032316505908966, 0.027950773015618324, 0.03137395158410072, -0.044689275324344635, 0.003460224252194166, 0.07214540243148804, -0.010560834780335426, 0.008892402984201908, 0.006232548970729113, -0.02026997320353985, 0.043817274272441864, 0.04248906299471855, -0.009019339457154274, -0.025049012154340744, 0.03334810584783554, -0.02173624373972416, -0.0018123098416253924, -0.03318079188466072, -0.026999441906809807, 0.04564950615167618, -0.003156953491270542, 0.0031426362693309784, 0.03239395096898079, -0.02501591295003891, 0.005019200965762138, -0.024915728718042374, -0.030070118606090546, -0.004440603777766228, -0.007397310808300972, 0.040377430617809296, -0.0271122045814991, 0.017212331295013428, -0.0004322215390857309, 0.03955531492829323, 0.013493637554347515, 0.04313474893569946, 0.02063378132879734, 0.03537895902991295, 0.04581957682967186, -0.023157935589551926, -0.01896473579108715, 0.033559639006853104, -0.037278059870004654, 0.003313301829621196, -0.03337975963950157, -0.043973520398139954, 0.034617431461811066, -0.010343492031097412, -0.011695764027535915, -0.050519444048404694, 0.0001832786510931328, -0.02495194599032402, -0.009086132980883121, -0.003566788975149393, -0.01915789023041725, 0.03180207312107086, -0.043051864951848984, 0.0197148434817791, -0.0076484475284814835, 0.01851314678788185, -0.013922593556344509, -0.04456938058137894, -0.03818872570991516, -0.013579306192696095, -0.04856223613023758, 0.014106210321187973, -0.019377844408154488, -0.02439338155090809, 0.018579918891191483, -0.02719522826373577, -0.04614967852830887, 0.00861106812953949, 0.02722259797155857, -0.047339003533124924, 0.04372026026248932, 0.024924837052822113, -0.005580380093306303, 0.014703964814543724, -0.014980022795498371, 0.1274978518486023, 0.07177472859621048, 0.026662031188607216, -0.05009985715150833, 0.0724526196718216, 0.017040826380252838, 0.012943140231072903, 0.014130537398159504, 0.0004223909927532077, -0.0003174076846335083, -0.01952184922993183, 0.058426763862371445, 0.0623314268887043, 0.024901963770389557, -0.0027837634552270174, 0.06397996097803116, -0.04221496358513832, -0.015282146632671356, 0.0000696580609655939, -0.00020930892787873745, 0.010044061578810215, -0.0072728958912193775, 0.0037745987065136433, -0.0022223598789423704, 0.019853919744491577, 0.035794325172901154, -0.013893158175051212, -0.027551449835300446, -0.006164270453155041, 0.013558748178184032, -0.030540956184267998, -0.011927880346775055, 0.026197358965873718, 0.017452986910939217, -0.03694601729512215, -0.008147349581122398, 0.004100429825484753, -0.025202326476573944, -0.013645092956721783, 0.03148535639047623, 0.0023048128932714462, 0.00015614360745530576, 0.023142898455262184, 0.03433900326490402, -0.07540316134691238, -0.025147855281829834, -0.023238904774188995, 0.005393289495259523, 0.0036807016003876925, 0.017537128180265427, -0.022268585860729218, -0.02284442074596882, -0.0023874833714216948, -0.05484931543469429, -0.007263591978698969, 0.01588630862534046, 0.029356863349676132, 0.007202873006463051, -0.035564061254262924, -0.009047654457390308, -0.005458514671772718, -0.0063110534101724625, 0.04603307321667671, 0.026905609294772148, -0.03652398660778999, -0.01809263415634632, -0.00018896147958002985, 0.03526845574378967, 0.007208046969026327, 0.014437447302043438, 0.015102717094123363, 0.0018448584014549851, -0.04297079145908356, 0.01624584011733532, -0.00947073195129633, 0.0038264975883066654, 0.020912963896989822, -0.005161588545888662, -0.010453958064317703, -0.0497867651283741, -0.009175353683531284, 0.02979748137295246, -0.010507969185709953, -0.002159937284886837, -0.04815366491675377, -0.0010035001905635, 0.010706592351198196, 0.026762790977954865, 0.0014466389548033476, 0.022393781691789627, -0.02726583741605282, 0.0519682802259922, -0.01585659384727478, -0.04687180370092392, -0.0011880680685862899, -0.009026523679494858, -0.03786005824804306, 0.0041242679581046104, 0.005084005184471607, 0.038951579481363297, 0.026929209008812904, 0.026470033451914787, -0.01815701834857464, 0.037739288061857224, -0.0012916771229356527, 0.009348679333925247, 0.026156483218073845, -0.05151873826980591, -0.000022999480279395357, 0.011307992041110992, 0.02559621073305607, -0.05761808902025223, -0.04105598106980324, -0.08176381140947342, -0.02279244363307953, -0.022930145263671875, -0.0201291274279356, -0.02238578535616398, -0.04108583182096481, -0.009425952099263668, 0.010731307789683342, -0.02440236322581768, -0.04923555999994278, -0.04557962343096733, -0.023794962093234062, 0.009275135584175587, -0.01947423443198204, -0.017626820132136345, -0.013415350578725338, 0.0030042279977351427, 0.0005198233411647379, 0.042367663234472275, 0.00970681756734848, 0.0048998030833899975, -0.006333061493933201, 0.003546199295669794, 0.014572187326848507, 0.018611537292599678, -0.034968506544828415, -0.03298196569085121, 0.027584753930568695, -0.029049696400761604, -0.050383251160383224, 0.07426506280899048, -0.011755198240280151, 0.019316213205456734, 0.018309378996491432, 0.00891447626054287, -0.003975695930421352, 0.031907834112644196, -0.0007634442881681025, -0.03584495186805725, -0.021783294156193733, 0.017888139933347702, -0.02578808180987835, -0.00857869815081358, -0.006409320514649153, 0.013113726861774921, -0.03227454423904419, 0.024072488769888878, 0.030772266909480095, -0.018269816413521767, 0.03498367965221405, -0.0024675612803548574, 0.01082479115575552, 0.02285824716091156, -0.017031097784638405, -0.002931666560471058, 0.01625504344701767, 0.002351132221519947, -0.05473397299647331, 0.02990150637924671, -0.004875670652836561, 0.009171362966299057, -0.0703761950135231, -0.005971091799438, -0.011971688829362392, 0.028807107359170914, 0.017704416066408157, -0.06632348150014877, 0.01734786294400692, 0.004986189305782318, -0.08374001085758209, 0.012189997360110283, -0.017941970378160477, -0.02467421442270279, -0.011639823205769062, -0.007791533134877682, -0.042029011994600296, 0.027523372322320938, 0.012513807974755764, 0.02476213313639164, -0.0014390179421752691, 0.013546662405133247, 0.01207241415977478, -0.021421652287244797, -0.039002127945423126, 0.026357825845479965, -0.0017102296696975827, -0.06236919015645981, 0.03112822212278843, -0.038919925689697266, -0.023182163015007973, 0.04319886863231659, -0.007873594760894775, 0.03777024894952774, 0.04202873632311821, 0.035957783460617065, 0.010308557190001011, 0.031853269785642624, 0.005567761138081551, 0.0003730327298399061, -0.04742351174354553, 0.02552332915365696, 0.006440830882638693, 0.060292139649391174, -0.03812859207391739, -0.0012294655898585916, 0.07613055408000946, -0.009673455730080605, -0.041118115186691284, -0.00615267688408494, -0.020744454115629196, -0.0013799163280054927, -0.011963995173573494, 0.007890374399721622, -0.003770282259210944, -0.03840967267751694, 0.04753579944372177, -0.056394174695014954, -0.029604416340589523, 0.03160436078906059, 0.0022871869150549173, -0.004953350871801376, 0.006475147791206837, -0.023820528760552406, -0.02787429466843605, 0.00217782543040812, -0.0028854175470769405, 0.02253086492419243, -0.0727483332157135, -0.01294185221195221, -0.029416603967547417, -0.011842683888971806, -0.0032295123673975468, -0.001893346314318478, -0.0012839450500905514, 0.038848020136356354, -0.018389517441391945, 0.018315037712454796, -0.012704255059361458, -0.023429609835147858, 0.025504549965262413, -0.08493006229400635, 0.057929784059524536, 0.005746128503233194, -0.0018956221174448729, -0.027883365750312805, 0.00804369617253542, -0.024899473413825035, 0.007366046775132418, 0.05557962507009506, 0.04957546293735504, 0.0022098373156040907, -0.014927978627383709, 0.004645600914955139, 0.00444805109873414, -0.04843149706721306, 0.00012996760779060423, 0.008632993325591087, -0.00662684440612793, -0.017005475237965584, -0.025764115154743195, -0.03140086308121681, 0.00032798873144201934, 0.06207437440752983, 0.009797469712793827, 0.027086889371275902, -0.04107687994837761, 0.00030704544042237103, 0.04460761696100235, 0.006844624876976013, -0.03639229014515877, 0.019925612956285477, 0.012157865799963474, 0.020272012799978256, 0.024537991732358932, 0.013246919959783554, -0.0402706116437912, 0.013810722157359123, 0.0032182016875594854, 0.022630034014582634, 0.00353632727637887, 0.05842265114188194, -0.008816571906208992, -0.06343208253383636, -0.013660055585205555, 0.059421055018901825, -0.04591044783592224, -0.01446842122823, 0.02294386737048626, 0.029404276981949806, 0.01550864428281784, 0.019411753863096237, 0.014132940210402012, 0.016659924760460854, -0.038119688630104065, 0.011674940586090088, 0.00024722691159695387, 0.045020777732133865, 0.031216004863381386, 0.006822901777923107, 0.009655721485614777, 0.008859335444867611, 0.035721588879823685, 0.02161158248782158, 0.05406712740659714, 0.01995917782187462, -0.029367603361606598, 0.0236391332000494, -0.036147478967905045, 0.04009260609745979, -0.003055873326957226, -0.0004174033529125154, 0.05660657957196236, 0.0038662725128233433, 0.00969315692782402, -0.03665308281779289, -0.03803547844290733, -0.029662998393177986, -0.022436128929257393, 0.04978073015809059, 0.01018255390226841, -0.009768473915755749, -0.011020565405488014, -0.038474876433610916, -0.007168570067733526, 0.016422122716903687, -0.01738119311630726, 0.03209878131747246, -0.01843555085361004, -0.008612037636339664, -0.038146693259477615, -0.030415449291467667, -0.0364876314997673, 0.021412966772913933, 0.05459218472242355, -0.0035184696316719055, 0.05518622696399689, -0.013717353343963623, -0.03265303373336792, 0.00960735883563757, 0.031752340495586395, -0.03906824812293053, -0.017433956265449524, -0.014697355218231678, 0.010313175618648529, -0.006003270391374826, -0.05696048587560654 ]
<p>I have a large set of data points received by experimentation and each point has n ,or let's say 8 in this case, independent variables and one output/dependent variable.</p> <p>(x1, x2, x3, ...., xn) = y --> some measured output </p> <p>How would I fit a "curve" through these points or interpolate with the data points? I am not too sure where to start with this. If there area any general formulas or keywords that anyone can pass along to get me started in the right direction, that would be much appreciated. </p>
73,582
[ -0.015148515813052654, 0.0070656356401741505, -0.016018806025385857, -0.009606211446225643, 0.022797292098402977, 0.014226291328668594, -0.016749080270528793, -0.00910368375480175, 0.02509729377925396, -0.027449630200862885, 0.04600658267736435, 0.055956512689590454, 0.06371048837900162, 0.006444344762712717, 0.004678718280047178, -0.00010724765161285177, -0.024327581748366356, 0.0377802811563015, -0.0028580150101333857, -0.028968676924705505, 0.01978282444179058, 0.0034129696432501078, -0.012094571255147457, -0.026362372562289238, -0.03298058733344078, 0.02987843193113804, 0.04179210960865021, -0.01079079695045948, 0.0207828301936388, 0.05923090875148773, -0.004149200394749641, -0.05603492632508278, 0.002096317010000348, 0.05040604993700981, -0.011826230213046074, -0.003221220104023814, -0.033211588859558105, -0.02720155008137226, 0.026667756959795952, 0.0414070226252079, -0.06355134397745132, -0.021006440743803978, -0.01162599865347147, 0.012379513122141361, 0.003457491286098957, 0.016962751746177673, 0.013533484190702438, -0.05033284053206444, 0.03738706186413765, -0.05100540444254875, 0.12433784455060959, 0.004893455654382706, 0.02962275594472885, 0.04101749509572983, -0.03174801170825958, 0.001707734540104866, 0.08493764698505402, 0.03914596885442734, -0.025796260684728622, -0.0536813847720623, -0.022023240104317665, -0.026708045974373817, -0.0025465446524322033, -0.0014644584152847528, -0.02449151501059532, 0.01728268899023533, -0.020468849688768387, 0.006319012958556414, 0.008296370506286621, -0.029766065999865532, 0.02273237146437168, 0.0491049587726593, 0.060751400887966156, -0.007488300558179617, -0.014324486255645752, -0.0321761853992939, 0.032229047268629074, 0.004384441301226616, 0.04870115593075752, 0.02543364092707634, -0.021042531356215477, 0.04311579465866089, 0.027066528797149658, 0.04145989567041397, -0.008181778714060783, -0.003425175789743662, 0.06097609922289848, -0.022063421085476875, 0.03233455494046211, 0.032065726816654205, -0.022018013522028923, -0.01062008086591959, 0.06991855055093765, 0.018468182533979416, -0.03339040279388428, 0.0019960314966738224, -0.008098249323666096, 0.051898203790187836, -0.0009892263915389776, -0.0002886014699470252, -0.0007654378423467278, -0.055727049708366394, -0.017428886145353317, 0.06186727434396744, -0.016891710460186005, -0.0180394034832716, 0.0071847038343548775, 0.01084593404084444, -0.0026464236434549093, -0.012334578670561314, -0.007123698014765978, 0.005872583482414484, 0.032261770218610764, 0.011595891788601875, 0.05208653211593628, -0.02055140770971775, -0.02659633755683899, -0.001979815075173974, 0.03172103315591812, 0.05411906540393829, 0.020559165626764297, -0.058580879122018814, 0.07166274636983871, 0.012296626344323158, -0.05971182882785797, 0.01254554558545351, 0.016087733209133148, -0.018212655559182167, -0.014502442441880703, 0.012086858972907066, -0.014623058028519154, -0.010728836990892887, 0.03332831338047981, 0.012658904306590557, 0.04854859784245491, 0.0032958160154521465, -0.07309567183256149, -0.06123637035489082, 0.018379850313067436, -0.027445027604699135, 0.017503894865512848, -0.051727693527936935, 0.023658862337470055, 0.046554084867239, 0.08011080324649811, -0.0018139217281714082, -0.009858015924692154, 0.006950560491532087, 0.0419318750500679, -0.009283117949962616, -0.011525178328156471, -0.019491849467158318, -0.01188916340470314, -0.03490079194307327, -0.006074335891753435, -0.060679998248815536, 0.06017954647541046, 0.045839086174964905, -0.018391719087958336, -0.028068000450730324, 0.0460173562169075, 0.026514168828725815, -0.026830442249774933, 0.0007030339329503477, 0.020876528695225716, -0.026079071685671806, 0.0674230307340622, -0.009875143878161907, -0.006805372424423695, 0.022027574479579926, -0.007912256754934788, 0.04077867791056633, 0.007120700087398291, 0.027904726564884186, 0.05313011631369591, -0.014946414157748222, -0.009687112644314766, 0.009759379550814629, -0.00979960523545742, 0.053359199315309525, -0.01739148236811161, -0.02759375423192978, -0.017923207953572273, -0.008209098130464554, 0.02376820147037506, 0.04381510615348816, 0.0007493295124731958, -0.020920749753713608, 0.03171239420771599, -0.0429937019944191, -0.01644817925989628, -0.08125820755958557, 0.022624202072620392, 0.002103996928781271, -0.014596027322113514, 0.01988714560866356, 0.030319156125187874, -0.013300146907567978, -0.03548148646950722, -0.0649813562631607, -0.02479770965874195, -0.0203916747123003, 0.039932433515787125, -0.01971338875591755, -0.01256569568067789, 0.08206998556852341, 0.04385336861014366, -0.030742453411221504, 0.05306708440184593, -0.04510946199297905, 0.01601640321314335, -0.007435388397425413, -0.03359159454703331, 0.011636452749371529, -0.01133352518081665, -0.02981862612068653, -0.017888464033603668, 0.007032462861388922, 0.0020531266927719116, 0.05647258833050728, -0.050423573702573776, 0.06972233206033707, 0.06279023736715317, 0.0064723314717411995, -0.008759419433772564, -0.002325166016817093, -0.01042605098336935, 0.05363236740231514, -0.0239162165671587, -0.022510170936584473, -0.07260715961456299, -0.006390987895429134, 0.0016880256589502096, 0.04011787846684456, -0.045731015503406525, -0.045123908668756485, 0.06383749842643738, 0.027229534462094307, 0.022293079644441605, 0.02351401187479496, -0.009177036583423615, 0.019700931385159492, -0.009203046560287476, 0.011002372950315475, 0.001486759865656495, 0.0038340238388627768, -0.027873385697603226, 0.054625920951366425, 0.034084830433130264, 0.0009137651068158448, 0.0072938851080834866, 0.027905890718102455, -0.020606528967618942, 0.008130781352519989, 0.004561529494822025, 0.001849080086685717, 0.0411209836602211, 0.0019349122885614634, -0.01186763308942318, 0.019825085997581482, -0.005372245330363512, 0.005471985787153244, 0.011638127267360687, 0.006500158458948135, 0.011134827509522438, 0.017591852694749832, -0.022127090021967888, -0.002944367937743664, 0.019392551854252815, -0.021467722952365875, 0.01411360315978527, -0.04286699742078781, -0.032221779227256775, -0.040738485753536224, 0.025095198303461075, 0.0004510932194534689, 0.02898765355348587, 0.017339717596769333, -0.021342910826206207, -0.01983591727912426, -0.00964394211769104, -0.026871519163250923, 0.04508486017584801, 0.011481042951345444, -0.05661988630890846, -0.02834274061024189, -0.01422712579369545, -0.024146514013409615, 0.03637563809752464, -0.028369810432195663, 0.0036915461532771587, 0.03200747072696686, -0.010157561860978603, -0.05847979336977005, -0.011128134094178677, -0.02719629928469658, 0.000007531827577622607, -0.017196401953697205, -0.0038025968242436647, 0.02621271088719368, -0.0005065881996415555, -0.034464720636606216, 0.044061917811632156, -0.020702579990029335, 0.01280167605727911, -0.04863579198718071, 0.004845451097935438, 0.031586192548274994, 0.014843793585896492, 0.0307693500071764, 0.045789096504449844, -0.0054068537428975105, -0.0003649163991212845, -0.05865086615085602, -0.06787648051977158, 0.017200177535414696, 0.00967339612543583, 0.03427184373140335, 0.018691182136535645, -0.013284438289701939, 0.07065702974796295, -0.00350342714227736, -0.06366268545389175, -0.03611508011817932, -0.006146710366010666, -0.009111938998103142, -0.014537882059812546, 0.05455612391233444, 0.016501810401678085, 0.001287235296331346, 0.023996295407414436, -0.011925040744245052, 0.011557810008525848, 0.050508253276348114, 0.002470660489052534, 0.0239422544836998, 0.012399974279105663, -0.003049878403544426, -0.017792657017707825, 0.015459286980330944, 0.046170540153980255, -0.05223136395215988, 0.018622787669301033, 0.008850784972310066, -0.00869161169975996, 0.03659369796514511, -0.021059582009911537, -0.008323024027049541, 0.004685867112129927, 0.006319176405668259, -0.031672403216362, 0.0183597169816494, -0.0040283408015966415, -0.021394632756710052, -0.004718493204563856, 0.05981076508760452, 0.0509306862950325, -0.0051021152175962925, -0.006455233320593834, 0.05753908306360245, 0.0033519004937261343, -0.02534145675599575, -0.016017012298107147, -0.02903003990650177, -0.0018030456267297268, -0.019504263997077942, -0.02610120363533497, -0.03158579394221306, 0.04907764494419098, 0.02342311665415764, 0.0183380376547575, -0.009980900213122368, -0.026714909821748734, 0.041172515600919724, -0.04164624586701393, 0.0067888591438531876, -0.02502143569290638, 0.05590339004993439, -0.010237760841846466, 0.08067294210195541, 0.010723958723247051, -0.0229310542345047, 0.05253880098462105, -0.0010842802003026009, -0.0701596736907959, 0.06345845758914948, -0.029115311801433563, -0.03869539126753807, -0.006419174373149872, 0.001908152480609715, 0.027192452922463417, -0.02719307132065296, 0.006080457009375095, 0.008718556724488735, 0.02178783528506756, -0.0479389987885952, -0.03304116055369377, -0.03271304816007614, 0.0017471866449341178, 0.003914141561836004, 0.051447153091430664, 0.029386606067419052, -0.047061651945114136, 0.012757394462823868, 0.047775525599718094, -0.007205507252365351, -0.048346273601055145, -0.02620513364672661, 0.0098646879196167, 0.006354209966957569, 0.04555268585681915, 0.011592337861657143, 0.04140937700867653, -0.01994188129901886, 0.03247159719467163, -0.0231762807816267, 0.05537662282586098, 0.05959901213645935, -0.01843092031776905, -0.01461405586451292, -0.0494934506714344, -0.000706275983247906, 0.011813409626483917, 0.049821048974990845, 0.03085201606154442, 0.006649042014032602, 0.031731680035591125, 0.009423642419278622, -0.0616072341799736, 0.014858217909932137, 0.04458346590399742, 0.0332554392516613, -0.0024069175124168396, -0.030782368034124374, -0.0004978525685146451, -0.004375271499156952, 0.023146143183112144, -0.00680162850767374, 0.007361976895481348, -0.02400532364845276, 0.004500209353864193, 0.030842874199151993, 0.003083262126892805, -0.0016894293949007988, 0.0006196065805852413, 0.0002211560495197773, 0.052169036120176315, -0.01262916810810566, -0.06112106889486313, 0.037531934678554535, 0.048698484897613525, 0.02544724941253662, 0.025935830548405647, -0.015077484771609306, -0.13474853336811066, 0.013811694458127022, 0.03884919732809067, 0.020421352237462997, -0.033031146973371506, -0.008724180981516838, -0.038322679698467255, 0.012815814465284348, 0.06236211955547333, -0.029944680631160736, -0.005900239571928978, -0.014759626239538193, 0.007809470873326063, -0.05411117151379585, -0.0018266194965690374, -0.0668189749121666, 0.020926790311932564, -0.04726656526327133, 0.027449913322925568, -0.03817914053797722, -0.01181028876453638, -0.018253512680530548, 0.034568462520837784, 0.02788168378174305, 0.08799778670072556, 0.027369510382413864, -0.011731773614883423, 0.015146780759096146, 0.04389405623078346, -0.005219936836510897, -0.011763743124902248, 0.023299288004636765, 0.019648874178528786, -0.03907550126314163, 0.034665852785110474, 0.0015150762628763914, -0.036867864429950714, 0.011025085113942623, -0.006441418081521988, 0.0019493349827826023, 0.013274481520056725, -0.0217332374304533, 0.03438419848680496, 0.018251970410346985, -0.007307401858270168, 0.041929129511117935, 0.03640555962920189, -0.010254308581352234, -0.023266881704330444, -0.004353353753685951, 0.019152266904711723, 0.00743776373565197, -0.03604517877101898, -0.04437026008963585, 0.017114661633968353, -0.008226295933127403, 0.018830575048923492, -0.002178899710997939, 0.022798975929617882, -0.04612485691905022, -0.0261747594922781, 0.012293800711631775, 0.03857964649796486, 0.016835873946547508, 0.01382203958928585, 0.01649291440844536, 0.016332875937223434, 0.027386512607336044, -0.046120911836624146, -0.0018598278984427452, 0.02369449846446514, -0.00032886024564504623, 0.014688190072774887, -0.035477977246046066, -0.006279257126152515, -0.05946698412299156, -0.024337418377399445, 0.03430640697479248, -0.055980004370212555, 0.027162820100784302, 0.0003248878347221762, 0.04283859580755234, 0.012928856536746025, -0.028475476428866386, 0.0038503301329910755, 0.014971306547522545, -0.0029735686257481575, 0.04850062355399132, -0.06434711068868637, 0.013612918555736542, -0.05259523540735245, 0.01607317477464676, -0.05447956547141075, -0.06829711049795151, 0.04717421904206276, -0.035045504570007324, -0.018014714121818542, -0.02411082573235035, -0.018497617915272713, -0.007027266547083855, -0.01643124222755432, -0.023832330480217934, 0.03641524538397789, -0.026285504922270775, -0.010784551501274109, 0.003089415840804577, -0.006426772568374872, 0.056026045233011246, -0.011230992153286934, -0.011316782794892788, 0.019649775698781013, -0.0046194735914468765, -0.026317069306969643, 0.0035211839713156223, -0.007452020887285471, -0.051052577793598175, -0.0013691519852727652, -0.030021436512470245, 0.004131097812205553, 0.03175598755478859, -0.045743003487586975, -0.0006320028332993388, -0.004392250906676054, 0.019804151728749275, -0.03596099838614464, -0.016442863270640373, 0.014004617929458618, -0.02266392484307289, -0.013874463737010956, -0.009247219190001488, 0.002305398229509592, -0.018672430887818336, 0.02174983359873295, 0.026605859398841858, 0.025575431063771248, -0.003996093757450581, 0.005615456495434046, 0.045324914157390594, 0.03368094936013222, -0.008800246752798557, -0.011413411237299442, 0.003076517255976796, 0.03715129941701889, 0.02149263396859169, -0.017305614426732063, -0.011584002524614334, 0.041635144501924515, -0.06675772368907928, -0.04442315548658371, -0.026300206780433655, -0.012355867773294449, 0.07705147564411163, -0.03351684659719467, 0.03696897625923157, 0.06826787441968918, 0.023872744292020798, -0.0036031787749379873, -0.004589477553963661, -0.004072269890457392, -0.0170806385576725, -0.007384766358882189, 0.07229700684547424, 0.01797715201973915, -0.03251463174819946, -0.002835698891431093, -0.015684882178902626, 0.0032784517388790846, 0.006344965659081936, -0.04157768562436104, 0.03956288844347, -0.0028345498722046614, 0.0005995607934892178, -0.030213670805096626, 0.012170479632914066, -0.03610345348715782, 0.017370708286762238, -0.019264696165919304, -0.01066751591861248, 0.027994221076369286, 0.02019640803337097, 0.028748851269483566, -0.007966187782585621, -0.011984603479504585, -0.04756416752934456, 0.0002848191652446985, 0.008574831299483776, -0.01982070319354534, 0.0033180387690663338, 0.02975304238498211, 0.02016114443540573, -0.01216275803744793, 0.021891988813877106, -0.04043790325522423, -0.06624757498502731, -0.01583753526210785, -0.02650376223027706, -0.048556119203567505, 0.01576414331793785, 0.01514389831572771, -0.03892506659030914, 0.042837876826524734, 0.004129219334572554, 0.027508651837706566, -0.01627000980079174, 0.017442725598812103, 0.002890640404075384, 0.06939324736595154, -0.023906512185931206, -0.014252042397856712, -0.024133263155817986, 0.0012591846752911806, 0.0794040784239769, 0.10755325853824615, -0.01778949424624443, -0.09514109045267105, 0.03607664257287979, -0.012088456191122532, -0.03738781437277794, -0.009764260612428188, 0.022853052243590355, 0.037632618099451065, -0.01663929596543312, 0.02957438863813877, 0.016265880316495895, 0.014319222420454025, 0.032252535223960876, 0.09064935147762299, -0.007041569333523512, -0.032782524824142456, -0.009797460399568081, -0.0038438199553638697, -0.015346297062933445, 0.009195731021463871, -0.05348767712712288, 0.02056759037077427, -0.029887206852436066, -0.04068779945373535, -0.019662100821733475, -0.01991392858326435, 0.03942243754863739, 0.022281818091869354, -0.022989284247159958, 0.015495698899030685, 0.005589652340859175, 0.01795792207121849, -0.032864559441804886, 0.017054583877325058, 0.016993587836623192, -0.03198157623410225, 0.011319364421069622, 0.019012607634067535, 0.0045869238674640656, -0.005034170113503933, -0.02677770145237446, -0.010462884791195393, -0.010590397752821445, -0.051973581314086914, -0.02654813602566719, 0.03643052279949188, -0.007308817934244871, -0.021915506571531296, -0.010327274911105633, 0.03703665733337402, 0.016732897609472275, -0.052464358508586884, -0.016778606921434402, 0.040267832577228546, -0.0010651246411725879, -0.052886880934238434, -0.011148322373628616, -0.020141184329986572, -0.012554540298879147, -0.020686283707618713, 0.019756468012928963, 0.011717320419847965, -0.007204852532595396, 0.015376736409962177, -0.04647020623087883, 0.0569876953959465, 0.007998780347406864, -0.0175178125500679, 0.004118883982300758, -0.029720179736614227, -0.016135849058628082, 0.011510936543345451, 0.0363054983317852, 0.013798636384308338, -0.005433403421193361, 0.0032899940852075815, 0.00814914982765913, -0.02419421263039112, -0.007586961146444082, 0.028633737936615944, -0.03545417636632919, 0.02161140739917755, -0.04649771377444267, 0.00381925655528903, 0.03811461851000786, 0.04659193381667137, 0.02556506358087063, -0.011998271569609642, -0.032654572278261185, 0.03978857398033142, 0.029202429577708244, -0.06006183475255966, -0.01947726681828499, 0.007280812598764896, -0.040544211864471436, -0.012642953544855118, 0.0010710392380133271, 0.07319808006286621, 0.012859591282904148, 0.007263618987053633, -0.009760413318872452, 0.029354725033044815, -0.03227191045880318, 0.004857190418988466, -0.0015700048534199595, -0.04381818696856499, 0.04269025847315788, -0.026019588112831116, 0.0109360720962286, -0.05349474772810936, 0.007058068178594112, -0.03091410920023918, -0.014929044060409069, -0.01829105243086815, -0.016094094142317772, -0.00965936854481697, 0.04962173104286194, -0.01095118373632431, -0.009939420036971569, -0.020813891664147377, 0.03314144164323807, -0.029794704169034958, -0.022265030071139336, -0.010426085442304611, 0.018204880878329277, -0.006444831844419241, -0.02980724722146988, -0.03929022699594498, 0.005747030023485422, 0.037640493363142014, 0.001779851852916181, 0.022190691903233528, -0.011388201266527176, 0.00308208167552948, 0.00448262644931674, 0.042572420090436935, -0.043941009789705276, -0.017340904101729393, 0.010713824070990086, -0.0471007414162159, -0.046269726008176804, -0.0022959650959819555, -0.02184324711561203, 0.05880741775035858, 0.029982764273881912, -0.033001698553562164, -0.0315316766500473, 0.047021642327308655, 0.0034136550966650248, 0.0105374064296484, -0.007873843424022198, 0.004653275478631258, 0.01783151738345623, 0.023801147937774658, 0.029951058328151703, -0.01560746319591999, 0.014700308442115784, 0.028899777680635452, 0.04292541369795799, 0.019190441817045212, -0.0024741841480135918, 0.02208954654633999, 0.0012420968851074576, 0.006178779993206263, 0.009244964458048344, -0.030598698183894157, 0.05842633917927742, 0.0409277118742466, -0.04661763086915016, 0.013153314590454102, -0.0017694949638098478, 0.04578843340277672, -0.07405585795640945, 0.003236290067434311, -0.014953204430639744, -0.028927525505423546, 0.036407776176929474, -0.06565412878990173, -0.011443521827459335, 0.0006628668634220958, -0.04295091703534126, 0.0035571667831391096, -0.0019373712129890919, -0.0064392355270683765, -0.002006742637604475, 0.024949349462985992, -0.005462861154228449, 0.0264341551810503, 0.04915224015712738, 0.06153849884867668, 0.015036043711006641, 0.004714433569461107, -0.017152145504951477, -0.011025513522326946, -0.013811660930514336, -0.003055279841646552, 0.052850592881441116, -0.07004626840353012, 0.013489030301570892, -0.060843680053949356, -0.009781508706510067, 0.03802238032221794, -0.02679808996617794, 0.05093977600336075, -0.004854589235037565, -0.008114829659461975, -0.019150657579302788, 0.05218634754419327, 0.012348481453955173, -0.007000586949288845, -0.004733500070869923, -0.0006594164879061282, 0.021194731816649437, 0.0011678485898301005, -0.012822841294109821, 0.021343039348721504, 0.04025771841406822, -0.016868367791175842, -0.03348564729094505, -0.0018738984363153577, 0.008465060032904148, -0.025623731315135956, 0.009730108082294464, 0.0033293236047029495, -0.01356301736086607, -0.03571596369147301, 0.014698843471705914, -0.03672875836491585, -0.006434784270823002, 0.02847304195165634, 0.006280998233705759, -0.014287455007433891, -0.011210476979613304, -0.018950743600726128, -0.04068104177713394, -0.009204896166920662, -0.015385552309453487, 0.0006249126745387912, -0.08413262665271759, -0.005501907784491777, 0.014410155825316906, -0.03407591953873634, -0.016545969992876053, -0.011467227712273598, -0.00693207373842597, 0.023008625954389572, 0.01390231866389513, -0.021204445511102676, 0.01966417208313942, -0.022330008447170258, -0.023178521543741226, -0.056609343737363815, 0.073300801217556, 0.005712778307497501, -0.019301777705550194, -0.06246327981352806, -0.0034349067136645317, 0.015106203965842724, 0.002556563587859273, 0.03298208862543106, -0.01544645894318819, -0.006866983138024807, -0.008870458230376244, 0.026798738166689873, 0.0077597410418093204, -0.03956383094191551, 0.03685254231095314, 0.020365213975310326, -0.022830139845609665, -0.00939930323511362, -0.003439438994973898, 0.0037877506110817194, -0.00030957849230617285, 0.010328014381229877, 0.006644533481448889, 0.029816625639796257, 0.0015153808053582907, -0.04453285038471222, -0.01259783748537302, -0.005527162924408913, -0.023253001272678375, 0.04674049839377403, -0.020328311249613762, -0.007705259136855602, 0.031308140605688095, 0.002210590522736311, -0.07518138736486435, 0.00974976271390915, -0.04188982769846916, -0.014522644691169262, -0.026466893032193184, 0.010857590474188328, -0.013612390495836735, -0.08196307718753815, 0.010759144090116024, 0.013443063013255596, -0.04501478374004364, -0.015250050462782383, 0.04861249402165413, 0.024788537994027138, 0.0083952397108078, -0.035565778613090515, 0.007629430387169123, 0.013134443201124668, -0.014323899522423744, 0.01533506065607071, 0.008816602639853954, 0.07512494921684265, 0.008401217870414257, 0.005047531798481941, 0.015738992020487785, -0.019690288230776787, 0.03225361555814743, 0.00350396241992712, 0.04079873487353325, -0.026213092729449272, -0.02536936290562153, 0.024273226037621498, -0.01952926255762577, 0.029247647151350975, 0.016507716849446297, -0.022014696151018143, 0.0513443760573864, -0.037036702036857605, 0.0019814451225101948, -0.051028959453105927, -0.004697700031101704, -0.01220795325934887, 0.009718763642013073, -0.010267107747495174, 0.05590732395648956, -0.0029279899317771196, 0.02816704660654068, 0.014189056120812893, -0.01669524796307087, 0.01474144496023655, -0.007232706993818283, 0.028426840901374817, -0.03902086243033409, 0.012683741748332977, -0.014098391868174076, -0.025354694575071335, -0.029275229200720787, -0.012547883205115795, 0.04467092454433441, 0.03470911830663681, -0.0003184473898727447, 0.010909521020948887, 0.02024739794433117, -0.014018240384757519, 0.06584744900465012, -0.07586780190467834, -0.020923510193824768, -0.006148563232272863, 0.018499914556741714, -0.009623966179788113, -0.0235028974711895 ]
<p>I'm designing a multi class classifier (for 4 classes) using <strong>Discrete HMMs with States N and Symbols M</strong> for each of the HMM.</p> <p>However, I found that recognition performance(i.e highest log likelihood) of a specific class depends upon the <strong>N and M</strong> with which it was trained.</p> <p>Most of the literature I found on the web suggests <strong>use of same of number of states, symbols across all the HMMs</strong>. </p> <p><strong>I was wondering if it need not be so?</strong> i.e. HMM1 can have 4 states, 18 symbols and HMM2 can have 5 states, 20 symbols............</p>
73,583
[ -0.01689709722995758, -0.015330715104937553, -0.003390879835933447, -0.008890784345567226, 0.0011903553968295455, 0.009093423373997211, -0.0054185353219509125, -0.03291924297809601, 0.016545504331588745, 0.010712269693613052, 0.02647608146071434, 0.002880083629861474, 0.051120009273290634, 0.007000577170401812, 0.009033005684614182, -0.0015717045171186328, 0.008707176893949509, -0.0240034107118845, -0.0007776205311529338, 0.0011341656791046262, -0.023243270814418793, 0.028825076296925545, 0.013343539088964462, -0.018654191866517067, -0.008515222929418087, 0.05722816661000252, 0.04041143134236336, 0.009456871077418327, 0.053185660392045975, 0.02066071704030037, -0.01957934908568859, -0.021191922947764397, 0.009668455459177494, 0.08446323126554489, 0.010530725121498108, -0.021841607987880707, -0.066358283162117, -0.029883258044719696, -0.012878322042524815, 0.04134334623813629, -0.02045287936925888, -0.00674959272146225, -0.005084596574306488, 0.030521852895617485, -0.027051961049437523, 0.026368405669927597, -0.011515813879668713, 0.0007363907061517239, 0.014617727138102055, -0.06205681711435318, 0.07102834433317184, -0.03130395710468292, 0.04554036632180214, 0.06450890004634857, -0.01727159507572651, -0.01970543898642063, 0.06757360696792603, 0.09265656024217606, 0.02191193215548992, -0.033873721957206726, 0.006836480461061001, -0.023300983011722565, 0.048513032495975494, -0.046112310141325, -0.024927541613578796, 0.00883818231523037, 0.01586773432791233, -0.0018428388284519315, 0.029976090416312218, 0.011649150401353836, 0.01308666542172432, -0.0022529575508087873, 0.07989209145307541, -0.03273630887269974, 0.02246394008398056, 0.009830390103161335, 0.039722662419080734, 0.03205437958240509, 0.02517651952803135, 0.03228604793548584, -0.015710841864347458, 0.00024079919967334718, 0.022213313728570938, 0.02692200243473053, 0.003697266336530447, -0.021677399054169655, 0.04293518513441086, -0.019918471574783325, 0.03713962435722351, 0.006082731764763594, -0.00039213511627167463, 0.001390404417179525, 0.06227350980043411, 0.02588704600930214, -0.060690101236104965, 0.009702660143375397, -0.015418619848787785, 0.005364042241126299, 0.030108561739325523, -0.006757475435733795, -0.015165219083428383, -0.029332958161830902, 0.023815535008907318, 0.031648870557546616, -0.02140914648771286, 0.023755555972456932, -0.0423056036233902, -0.026325544342398643, 0.0010914021404460073, 0.013087245635688305, -0.026381898671388626, 0.007874508388340473, 0.003977282904088497, -0.017210261896252632, 0.006358202546834946, -0.029084106907248497, -0.016797194257378578, 0.019997626543045044, 0.02835129015147686, 0.05139949917793274, 0.005324780009686947, -0.06292134523391724, 0.0035256408154964447, -0.046064343303442, -0.050519492477178574, 0.03252463787794113, -0.011211118660867214, 0.0038936538621783257, -0.047821905463933945, 0.05632920563220978, -0.024843506515026093, 0.012103494256734848, 0.026225771754980087, 0.001769028021954, 0.026985157281160355, 0.004625680390745401, -0.08558797836303711, -0.030239112675189972, 0.02641652710735798, -0.033806782215833664, 0.019836269319057465, -0.04335995391011238, 0.011713187210261822, 0.0663793534040451, 0.05496489629149437, -0.02351911924779415, 0.04788940027356148, 0.03790557384490967, 0.027479972690343857, 0.0031213792972266674, -0.027802281081676483, 0.010503909550607204, -0.05122481659054756, -0.008373325690627098, -0.03727845475077629, -0.07867425680160522, 0.008982454426586628, 0.012232611887156963, -0.008975280448794365, -0.007863357663154602, 0.014336221851408482, -0.004992109257727861, 0.007663827855139971, -0.01921524479985237, 0.027519388124346733, -0.05032581463456154, 0.06136345863342285, 0.014107778668403625, 0.05676817521452904, 0.002119302749633789, -0.018305080011487007, -0.021464429795742035, -0.007312112953513861, 0.04332946985960007, 0.04891607165336609, -0.02951986901462078, -0.02509339712560177, -0.0018346093129366636, 0.047117140144109726, 0.003772529773414135, -0.019830774515867233, -0.030729681253433228, -0.03325736150145531, 0.026507679373025894, -0.05432591587305069, -0.029356271028518677, 0.0028174223843961954, 0.0005810766597278416, 0.011614073067903519, -0.03453981876373291, -0.0427890382707119, -0.03850657865405083, 0.023838402703404427, -0.05522678419947624, -0.021352283656597137, 0.05707218497991562, -0.0035505814012140036, 0.012084188871085644, 0.0026425172109156847, -0.02992500178515911, -0.04551263153553009, -0.04473637789487839, -0.0086548225954175, -0.02854148857295513, -0.005840516649186611, 0.026667872443795204, 0.0003414069360587746, -0.01894516311585903, 0.07161031663417816, -0.03251955658197403, -0.05012460798025131, 0.03535684570670128, -0.023394178599119186, 0.01641377992928028, 0.002799274865537882, -0.010179822333157063, 0.04173173010349274, -0.012962613254785538, -0.05265471339225769, 0.03280257433652878, -0.06452152878046036, 0.09489219635725021, 0.05352684110403061, -0.012270589359104633, -0.0158797949552536, -0.0011746608652174473, 0.007356158457696438, 0.007779399864375591, -0.008151361718773842, -0.013778867200016975, -0.05886726453900337, -0.013303973712027073, 0.011224149726331234, 0.01880558952689171, -0.0722586065530777, 0.02570273168385029, 0.029016967862844467, 0.044798124581575394, -0.012828639708459377, 0.012720114551484585, -0.00022817004355601966, -0.031045937910676003, 0.019946083426475525, 0.04400009289383888, -0.000018446869944455102, 0.017316805198788643, 0.012994402088224888, 0.011675200425088406, 0.024076763540506363, 0.006553856190294027, -0.02272479422390461, 0.033736974000930786, -0.024088958278298378, 0.007910037413239479, -0.03391581028699875, -0.05082673951983452, 0.003030382329598069, -0.04760494828224182, 0.04339684173464775, 0.03944382816553116, -0.014848191291093826, -0.010625998489558697, -0.0002533262886572629, -0.027583645656704903, -0.010420512408018112, 0.042577970772981644, 0.012850163504481316, 0.01404502708464861, 0.028491944074630737, -0.056653209030628204, 0.003976671025156975, -0.01591159962117672, -0.03234494850039482, -0.004099475219845772, 0.032050587236881256, 0.03707423433661461, -0.024071326479315758, 0.02752070128917694, -0.03915952146053314, -0.025323575362563133, -0.03379390761256218, -0.009885044768452644, 0.02669808268547058, -0.02493554912507534, -0.07942042499780655, -0.025657806545495987, 0.0023639563005417585, -0.0547705739736557, 0.04078727588057518, -0.012106319889426231, -0.025221189484000206, -0.014175871387124062, -0.02543170191347599, -0.04789934307336807, -0.04153618589043617, -0.014248413033783436, 0.03988850116729736, -0.010306870564818382, -0.016123050823807716, 0.05920858308672905, 0.01570751890540123, -0.042801596224308014, -0.04135200008749962, -0.021182995289564133, -0.04070713371038437, -0.02816164679825306, -0.0033006302546709776, 0.03040243871510029, -0.0072086285799741745, 0.0020021144300699234, 0.06545671820640564, -0.034198030829429626, -0.041453130543231964, -0.05125758796930313, -0.0660400241613388, 0.02987879328429699, -0.02813929319381714, 0.046864546835422516, -0.006049710791558027, -0.0008585107862018049, 0.06358027458190918, 0.02877742238342762, -0.03381507843732834, -0.012469177134335041, -0.017208989709615707, -0.035461828112602234, -0.041390977799892426, -0.005566256120800972, 0.037334833294153214, -0.026859499514102936, 0.022081781178712845, 0.005795587785542011, -0.026644792407751083, 0.07002998143434525, -0.04572708159685135, -0.005498480051755905, 0.011116056703031063, -0.002112808870151639, -0.0434279665350914, 0.05182892829179764, 0.012065931223332882, -0.024431318044662476, -0.004727997817099094, -0.02620701491832733, 0.018639078363776207, 0.002937019569799304, -0.007570081856101751, 0.052064474672079086, -0.02860337868332863, 0.015089607797563076, -0.05337514355778694, -0.0007250890485011041, 0.0003723448025994003, -0.029128147289156914, -0.030399711802601814, 0.03520892187952995, 0.022634923458099365, -0.03848743438720703, -0.009239068254828453, 0.051175154745578766, 0.03319443017244339, 0.0010013425489887595, -0.02092358097434044, -0.0006542880437336862, -0.016714274883270264, 0.011584390886127949, -0.014996515586972237, 0.0028930208645761013, 0.010226050391793251, -0.0027701896615326405, 0.040740612894296646, 0.03448224067687988, -0.05735251307487488, -0.008731055073440075, -0.09909770637750626, 0.00511531624943018, -0.004866303410381079, 0.04525205120444298, 0.013543963432312012, 0.007127915974706411, -0.002867259318009019, -0.01343211904168129, 0.03045959398150444, 0.0023863238748162985, -0.0814187154173851, -0.011189982295036316, -0.007669568527489901, -0.011425036936998367, 0.03943830356001854, -0.061707302927970886, 0.025678828358650208, -0.058992307633161545, -0.003513037459924817, 0.007044661324471235, 0.0268193818628788, -0.06989289075136185, 0.02072131633758545, -0.029638566076755524, 0.005488434340804815, -0.019231490790843964, 0.037373751401901245, -0.009900372475385666, 0.00752427289262414, 0.006697765085846186, 0.03534819185733795, -0.01870337501168251, 0.025818010792136192, -0.030725428834557533, 0.052305661141872406, 0.014635017141699791, 0.045906852930784225, 0.030144140124320984, 0.06410281360149384, -0.03266827017068863, 0.02659299038350582, 0.0036124391481280327, 0.06679380685091019, 0.01198777835816145, -0.010116073302924633, -0.0027367030270397663, -0.04210373014211655, -0.05251883715391159, 0.026965104043483734, 0.05485914275050163, 0.001397827290929854, -0.019204193726181984, 0.023011084645986557, 0.018122931942343712, -0.06564703583717346, 0.003046756610274315, 0.08047845214605331, 0.005406016018241644, -0.029159031808376312, -0.015858208760619164, 0.00361339352093637, -0.005643933080136776, 0.004911207128316164, -0.005205565597862005, 0.01645072177052498, -0.03166331723332405, 0.010500318370759487, 0.022282373160123825, -0.035567834973335266, -0.03514505550265312, 0.0026364971417933702, 0.014151573181152344, 0.018227383494377136, -0.005354875698685646, -0.009220867417752743, -0.015027695335447788, 0.014158735983073711, 0.0019188603619113564, 0.023884309455752373, 0.0036894914228469133, -0.08469586074352264, -0.00818974431604147, 0.03749825432896614, 0.023983977735042572, -0.018599966540932655, 0.00190276640933007, -0.02026023156940937, -0.011543533764779568, 0.017900848761200905, -0.015222116373479366, 0.0347386933863163, 0.005987972021102905, -0.00006908451905474067, -0.04262706637382507, 0.010328269563615322, -0.027167195454239845, 0.02630595862865448, -0.00010149254376301542, 0.04384872317314148, -0.004466587677598, 0.019147010520100594, -0.02136097103357315, 0.005482845474034548, 0.014433739706873894, 0.06236295402050018, -0.02596164122223854, -0.009836200624704361, 0.003695337101817131, 0.046454887837171555, -0.025014648213982582, -0.05252647399902344, 0.013388143852353096, -0.009894156828522682, 0.005787630565464497, 0.01567501574754715, -0.007776523008942604, -0.055698808282613754, -0.018448257818818092, -0.0008449777960777283, -0.025415027514100075, -0.026218628510832787, 0.02469567209482193, 0.01627797819674015, 0.019270949065685272, -0.008218961767852306, 0.019046146422624588, -0.006257596891373396, 0.009094668552279472, 0.018258556723594666, -0.011442398652434349, 0.033257611095905304, -0.07632555067539215, -0.027141036465764046, -0.008474421687424183, 0.017798898741602898, -0.0402366928756237, 0.060570865869522095, -0.021971043199300766, 0.04481746256351471, -0.010890215635299683, -0.03598197177052498, -0.021703967824578285, 0.020865002647042274, -0.011858277954161167, -0.001609365688636899, 0.005870695225894451, 0.03412530943751335, -0.014973375014960766, 0.014810318127274513, 0.025374760851264, -0.024544082581996918, -0.0036458459217101336, 0.031543005257844925, -0.021861394867300987, 0.0055714077316224575, -0.03347345441579819, -0.006113728974014521, -0.004766625352203846, -0.007587309926748276, 0.016486050561070442, 0.010767270810902119, 0.05407510697841644, 0.01521566417068243, -0.05831864848732948, 0.01763991452753544, 0.04100382700562477, -0.017956392839550972, 0.01858680136501789, -0.027896543964743614, 0.04841211065649986, -0.02067389525473118, 0.022277556359767914, -0.03692728653550148, -0.04180934652686119, 0.002226825337857008, 0.016824157908558846, -0.016891498118638992, -0.00258914683945477, 0.010487101972103119, -0.011413032189011574, -0.014471327885985374, -0.01335365790873766, 0.03008824773132801, 0.014981675893068314, -0.019556580111384392, 0.04338403418660164, 0.019331255927681923, 0.08553618937730789, 0.04872202128171921, 0.01261640153825283, -0.0020925893913954496, 0.0025833388790488243, 0.014918097294867039, -0.00850885733962059, 0.01422770693898201, -0.01399929914623499, -0.04183321073651314, -0.027678167447447777, 0.043612316250801086, 0.04576379433274269, -0.010627567768096924, 0.010387806221842766, -0.005405695177614689, -0.02611171267926693, 0.011241030879318714, -0.05324847996234894, 0.010294431820511818, -0.03472325578331947, -0.01622352935373783, -0.004065875429660082, 0.009729187935590744, -0.01580251380801201, -0.00039579402073286474, -0.011891272850334644, 0.009813790209591389, -0.0012744846753776073, 0.023318873718380928, 0.03707069531083107, -0.036032166332006454, -0.010176582261919975, 0.004752983804792166, -0.05342298001050949, 0.06576686352491379, -0.013134137727320194, 0.00853416696190834, 0.0039309789426624775, 0.009474856778979301, -0.021533450111746788, -0.02231166511774063, -0.018364204093813896, -0.0062373629771173, 0.020674116909503937, -0.0012601240305230021, 0.0305789727717638, 0.01785779558122158, 0.002126692095771432, 0.03130070120096207, -0.026701312512159348, -0.03791109845042229, -0.016162119805812836, -0.01841661147773266, 0.061345163732767105, 0.005252254195511341, -0.01620505005121231, 0.02083747461438179, -0.0012306257849559188, 0.048456791788339615, 0.015794696286320686, 0.013832150027155876, 0.013203155249357224, 0.0353081151843071, -0.01885152794420719, -0.014666002243757248, 0.052957721054553986, -0.05233505740761757, -0.0004356502031441778, -0.011751951649785042, 0.02170383371412754, 0.01746615767478943, 0.027255065739154816, 0.04126457870006561, -0.026692871004343033, -0.006324535235762596, -0.0365949422121048, 0.03863945230841637, 0.030977783724665642, -0.0027137373108416796, 0.02459045499563217, 0.010088947601616383, 0.042687881737947464, 0.02342725545167923, 0.042364753782749176, -0.04526528716087341, -0.09806135296821594, -0.0557914637029171, -0.010748951695859432, -0.027469340711832047, 0.04493921995162964, -0.003287524450570345, -0.03329170122742653, 0.008615479804575443, -0.00687201414257288, 0.07091627269983292, 0.009868470020592213, 0.046375952661037445, 0.010360823012888432, 0.04275960102677345, 0.016352739185094833, 0.04281206801533699, 0.018279211595654488, -0.009809480048716068, 0.1408439576625824, 0.0725439116358757, 0.04891188070178032, -0.03916117921471596, 0.02307852916419506, 0.0023324228823184967, -0.00034486872027628124, -0.014424764551222324, 0.03231985494494438, 0.051649268716573715, 0.005460173357278109, 0.000906691828276962, 0.014275236055254936, -0.007789020426571369, -0.026198046281933784, 0.030033202841877937, -0.034748125821352005, -0.036296647042036057, 0.01280613336712122, 0.04214957728981972, 0.0008927216986194253, 0.008606701157987118, -0.0441146194934845, -0.006635075435042381, -0.003034731140360236, -0.03163153678178787, 0.025066103786230087, -0.01094289030879736, 0.005210180301219225, 0.012927815318107605, 0.02114427089691162, -0.0017691063694655895, 0.010640177875757217, -0.009108289144933224, -0.02801135554909706, -0.014288502745330334, -0.03313792496919632, -0.0025024223141372204, 0.0055083902552723885, 0.04857702925801277, 0.021514588966965675, -0.02294943854212761, 0.005440023262053728, -0.013754147104918957, -0.032607875764369965, -0.01377914473414421, -0.06252892315387726, 0.03057233989238739, -0.0017539865802973509, 0.011372772976756096, 0.005629544146358967, 0.028153307735919952, 0.010305535979568958, -0.05834032595157623, -0.02559269592165947, -0.005043391138315201, 0.022997070103883743, -0.0384453721344471, -0.04983154684305191, -0.039777401834726334, 0.03860372304916382, 0.041046980768442154, -0.01171926036477089, -0.03970872238278389, -0.01726173423230648, -0.006302118767052889, -0.030649246647953987, 0.013255760073661804, 0.01646355912089348, 0.008557898923754692, 0.003336649388074875, 0.044456597417593, -0.04920266941189766, -0.007342994678765535, -0.009594335220754147, -0.00556951854377985, 0.020678171887993813, 0.0301889069378376, -0.02339421771466732, 0.018622318282723427, -0.03347417339682579, 0.012428940273821354, -0.02487298846244812, -0.010180681943893433, -0.006093018222600222, 0.0021025880705565214, 0.027446215972304344, 0.01381052564829588, 0.0038121717516332865, 0.04863991588354111, 0.024461206048727036, 0.022899145260453224, -0.001515710260719061, -0.05806785821914673, 0.004373402334749699, 0.002112525049597025, -0.06329122930765152, -0.009570656344294548, -0.004963892977684736, 0.05760810524225235, 0.014899488538503647, 0.026273569092154503, 0.0020695067942142487, 0.07704848796129227, 0.02311691641807556, -0.01975424960255623, -0.010265283286571503, -0.04492568224668503, -0.0016935220919549465, 0.019141772761940956, -0.012391995638608932, -0.03772043436765671, -0.019493194296956062, -0.03989972174167633, -0.015135803259909153, 0.022944269701838493, -0.033138059079647064, -0.03178241476416588, 0.03918401896953583, -0.06354917585849762, 0.01090065948665142, -0.009046121500432491, 0.007718830835074186, -0.008652269840240479, 0.011773875914514065, -0.01548790093511343, -0.012426547706127167, -0.024785228073596954, -0.011491195298731327, -0.0336902029812336, -0.012248718179762363, 0.061507366597652435, 0.024183282628655434, 0.015355528332293034, -0.0325477235019207, 0.017565377056598663, 0.0034125724341720343, 0.04520801827311516, -0.03671739250421524, 0.003277072450146079, -0.007147060241550207, -0.014699248597025871, -0.006804738659411669, 0.007281369995325804, -0.038027822971343994, 0.027618316933512688, 0.03935276344418526, 0.03028484247624874, -0.03300577774643898, 0.039705049246549606, -0.030320126563310623, 0.022116724401712418, 0.00614711781963706, 0.020067116245627403, 0.021524779498577118, 0.0010967616690322757, -0.008941825479269028, 0.044578295201063156, -0.00479543674737215, 0.010313494130969048, 0.047190118581056595, 0.05142289027571678, -0.010065091773867607, -0.0030250740237534046, 0.003977939486503601, 0.06556135416030884, 0.0007080485811457038, 0.012060663662850857, 0.04961913079023361, 0.006169789005070925, -0.014944685623049736, -0.0045890905894339085, 0.022406162694096565, 0.023540493100881577, -0.09067380428314209, 0.0015513765392825007, 0.028128547593951225, 0.017677923664450645, 0.03345208242535591, -0.056126657873392105, 0.03523910790681839, 0.011894029565155506, -0.06554845720529556, 0.0005753962323069572, -0.00546159828081727, 0.0023710562381893396, -0.0538698174059391, -0.0029764114879071712, 0.0032162279821932316, 0.047458671033382416, -0.0005432262551039457, 0.03166698291897774, 0.016218900680541992, 0.03174892067909241, -0.014739982783794403, 0.013467066921293736, -0.07146813720464706, 0.013088040053844452, 0.01539203617721796, -0.05867264047265053, 0.05746793374419212, -0.03675399720668793, -0.06943923979997635, 0.02214881032705307, -0.0456354133784771, 0.015498553402721882, 0.05976050719618797, 0.026894602924585342, 0.03951322287321091, 0.0074922023341059685, 0.0632624700665474, -0.055173110216856, 0.020388288423419, 0.003908080980181694, -0.002369985682889819, -0.0036303724627941847, -0.04362870007753372, -0.011327181942760944, -0.0043201264925301075, -0.03271231800317764, -0.05233132839202881, -0.001876364229246974, -0.011785969138145447, -0.01555950939655304, -0.028118666261434555, 0.013869315385818481, 0.00863583479076624, -0.01663297973573208, 0.014311795122921467, -0.035613056272268295, 0.0021541076712310314, 0.008704202249646187, 0.03145718574523926, 0.021549995988607407, -0.016261130571365356, -0.005045334808528423, -0.03685060888528824, -0.020448820665478706, 0.017890984192490578, -0.040162913501262665, -0.03263784945011139, 0.0496797114610672, 0.029391823336482048, 0.00028350023785606027, -0.028672130778431892, -0.0200947318226099, -0.0273112989962101, 0.024820197373628616, -0.017765512689948082, 0.05953983962535858, 0.0048707942478358746, -0.022918976843357086, -0.008110810071229935, -0.0726747214794159, 0.0434454046189785, 0.016411300748586655, 0.021152859553694725, -0.029710903763771057, 0.01259115245193243, -0.016157548874616623, -0.004250203259289265, 0.06121490150690079, 0.013203594833612442, 0.014257291331887245, 0.00884476862847805, 0.021269666031003, -0.0017847244162112474, 0.002191205509006977, 0.01416313461959362, -0.040224846452474594, -0.014086943119764328, -0.01193619892001152, -0.022105008363723755, 0.007028521969914436, 0.012463315390050411, 0.021823866292834282, -0.05363904684782028, -0.016863059252500534, 0.005784608423709869, -0.003806177293881774, 0.010930837132036686, -0.03350675478577614, -0.015524139627814293, 0.02773604914546013, -0.023388899862766266, 0.0027850461192429066, 0.013722866773605347, 0.005382867995649576, -0.06006891280412674, 0.0020241462625563145, 0.01357946265488863, -0.044632602483034134, 0.007286056876182556, 0.02470683865249157, 0.017919857054948807, -0.017607033252716064, 0.0010619745589792728, 0.02211705595254898, -0.034891750663518906, 0.020497700199484825, 0.05057317018508911, 0.04529757425189018, 0.050253916531801224, 0.018249399960041046, 0.031042350456118584, 0.011686132289469242, -0.030236264690756798, 0.0060290200635790825, 0.014371009543538094, 0.008177419193089008, -0.003269353648647666, 0.04431647062301636, 0.01413577701896429, -0.005823495797812939, 0.027558134868741035, 0.026076147332787514, 0.04192435368895531, -0.010698814876377583, 0.0014178327983245254, 0.027176475152373314, 0.01823129691183567, 0.0002885913127101958, -0.0006089453818276525, 0.0005103527219034731, 0.0672561377286911, -0.030792411416769028, -0.00533205084502697, -0.03796235844492912, -0.02156975120306015, -0.014684470370411873, -0.03490658849477768, -0.004859554581344128, 0.03389822691679001, 0.0049542891792953014, 0.030279748141765594, 0.024701392278075218, -0.017225878313183784, 0.028306273743510246, -0.0737718790769577, 0.01774599775671959, -0.038551464676856995, 0.014602519571781158, 0.015969881787896156, 0.01374796312302351, -0.022934122011065483, -0.024874655529856682, 0.026457684114575386, 0.08501458168029785, 0.05265309661626816, -0.03057914227247238, -0.06210978329181671, 0.0016657995292916894, 0.016215695068240166, -0.020629756152629852, 0.010949342511594296, -0.07391826063394547, 0.006751573644578457, 0.039961375296115875, -0.018910249695181847 ]
<p>I am looking for a good and modern Kernel Regression package in R, which has the following features:</p> <ol> <li>It has cross-validation </li> <li>It can automatically choose the "optimal" bandwidth</li> <li>It doesn't have random effect - i.e. if I run the function at different times on the same data-set, the results should be exactly the same...</li> </ol> <p>I am trying "np", but I am seeing:</p> <pre><code>Multistart 1 of 1 | Multistart 1 of 1 | ... </code></pre> <p>It looks like in order to do the optimization, it's doing multiple-random-start optimization ... Am I right?</p> <p>Could you please give me some pointers?</p> <p>I did some google search but there are so many packages that do this... I just wanted to find the best/modern one to use...</p>
35,990
[ -0.0011594172101467848, 0.0011330257402732968, 0.013135160319507122, 0.010455829091370106, 0.015448451973497868, -0.0069917649962008, 0.010831217281520367, -0.0038074112962931395, 0.030757084488868713, -0.013433681800961494, 0.026115410029888153, 0.04450363293290138, 0.05054163560271263, 0.032381825149059296, 0.006220890209078789, -0.002770898398011923, -0.010881844907999039, -0.008959287777543068, -0.02516845054924488, -0.048431385308504105, 0.014996691606938839, -0.006986874621361494, -0.0032064381521195173, -0.0078050303272902966, -0.03986051678657532, 0.04401272162795067, 0.002231180900707841, -0.02986089140176773, -0.00947948731482029, 0.03432473540306091, -0.03641917183995247, -0.03284473717212677, -0.008318380452692509, 0.06378795206546783, 0.017825204879045486, -0.0014818174531683326, -0.05404367297887802, -0.02439483068883419, 0.0026599278207868338, 0.017215514555573463, 0.015950074419379234, -0.02443334087729454, -0.007582541089504957, 0.02583554945886135, 0.033870089799165726, 0.03869292885065079, 0.026310468092560768, -0.00801394134759903, 0.05734361708164215, -0.0391915962100029, 0.05655680596828461, -0.0375799722969532, 0.008760739117860794, 0.015081788413226604, -0.04632563143968582, 0.01475441176444292, 0.0599617175757885, 0.09383633732795715, -0.012904644943773746, -0.04340139776468277, 0.00024369356106035411, -0.01345390360802412, 0.014353851787745953, -0.007801802363246679, -0.03428836539387703, 0.037351708859205246, 0.014190240763127804, 0.0011281655170023441, 0.0061781578697264194, -0.015064551495015621, 0.019982794299721718, -0.008571046404540539, 0.03448966145515442, -0.031708236783742905, 0.004221240058541298, 0.02119002677500248, 0.0018625877564772964, 0.0021069785580039024, 0.06110018491744995, 0.03246918320655823, -0.01765071041882038, 0.011552893556654453, 0.016339410096406937, 0.017079535871744156, 0.02586887776851654, 0.02691139094531536, 0.08281078189611435, -0.007080740761011839, 0.038728758692741394, 0.059480514377355576, -0.03539517894387245, 0.016001269221305847, 0.04964176565408707, 0.015629250556230545, -0.028536630794405937, 0.028850343078374863, -0.008083434775471687, 0.02182132564485073, -0.00025601027300581336, -0.037919893860816956, 0.025890644639730453, -0.035531558096408844, -0.011683366261422634, 0.04324640333652496, -0.029907546937465668, -0.0025075681041926146, -0.03398800641298294, 0.0021425564773380756, -0.010972395539283752, -0.014933504164218903, -0.035623446106910706, 0.02560836635529995, 0.0007163218106143177, -0.0013944819802418351, 0.013372864574193954, -0.03236730769276619, -0.01994352601468563, 0.012564870528876781, 0.01780744642019272, 0.06873522698879242, 0.039072342216968536, -0.021538808941841125, 0.005424429662525654, -0.04050010070204735, -0.009979193098843098, 0.0473690927028656, 0.017272699624300003, -0.013665388338267803, -0.038195353001356125, 0.04266871139407158, -0.029406938701868057, -0.03668104112148285, 0.03182688727974892, -0.00667556980624795, 0.01808866858482361, 0.014529526233673096, -0.10758703947067261, -0.0451614111661911, 0.04080312326550484, -0.024563726037740707, 0.021116962656378746, -0.03975721076130867, 0.003956870641559362, -0.016978805884718895, 0.06897269189357758, 0.010754020884633064, 0.0208670012652874, 0.031334955245256424, 0.02224327065050602, -0.034137096256017685, -0.06108589097857475, -0.01833925023674965, -0.015764841809868813, 0.010541081428527832, -0.0016228877939283848, -0.08956549316644669, -0.0035131610929965973, 0.010793921537697315, 0.0038765117060393095, 0.04295150190591812, 0.046862922608852386, -0.014241962693631649, -0.02841557189822197, -0.03771680220961571, 0.006937271449714899, -0.03922426700592041, 0.06517978757619858, 0.028823019936680794, 0.02901567332446575, -0.01377787534147501, -0.032007478177547455, -0.016045071184635162, 0.0176096111536026, 0.03629639744758606, -0.0009795303922146559, -0.02600882761180401, 0.016754349693655968, -0.020286113023757935, 0.016509652137756348, 0.026652632281184196, -0.008390054106712341, -0.02767135202884674, 0.012433179654181004, -0.009683825075626373, -0.005254759918898344, 0.05037272348999977, 0.002627034205943346, 0.00818104762583971, 0.06665388494729996, -0.057842906564474106, -0.021852249279618263, -0.01304920669645071, -0.018047044053673744, -0.019157253205776215, -0.03579751029610634, -0.01113783847540617, 0.021278202533721924, 0.012502963654696941, -0.01567879132926464, -0.0057305810041725636, -0.008380935527384281, 0.017442360520362854, 0.059151723980903625, 0.004313135519623756, -0.0043730284087359905, 0.03732357174158096, -0.006553330924361944, -0.04147060588002205, 0.0112057626247406, -0.015077087096869946, -0.039216283708810806, 0.018806559965014458, -0.05982224643230438, 0.019706903025507927, -0.05613017827272415, 0.018209435045719147, 0.037347711622714996, 0.0011105905286967754, 0.010554573498666286, -0.006198011338710785, -0.0905134305357933, 0.04339878261089325, 0.0554933063685894, 0.02616407349705696, -0.0047698188573122025, 0.015054058283567429, -0.007033304776996374, 0.002123024081811309, -0.02312980778515339, -0.015420541167259216, -0.037958089262247086, -0.0075171575881540775, 0.07176671922206879, -0.007009112276136875, 0.012920432724058628, 0.02326282113790512, 0.09951253235340118, -0.015240450389683247, 0.03524608910083771, 0.02609207294881344, -0.01779579184949398, -0.016034908592700958, 0.024843508377671242, 0.023635415360331535, -0.004246331285685301, 0.017944935709238052, 0.004954914096742868, 0.016693728044629097, 0.019019631668925285, 0.002192737301811576, -0.007766861468553543, 0.03426266089081764, 0.015202685259282589, -0.026035355404019356, -0.01835121028125286, -0.012142572551965714, 0.05735410004854202, -0.029727181419730186, 0.018112298101186752, 0.030573613941669464, 0.028541628271341324, -0.007341792341321707, 0.0006010486977174878, -0.00920190755277872, 0.013160030357539654, 0.025478240102529526, -0.03430153429508209, 0.019906343892216682, 0.02305964194238186, -0.058213554322719574, 0.012588863261044025, -0.02158415876328945, 0.01917709968984127, -0.05679739639163017, -0.0007538077188655734, 0.027187999337911606, 0.02715258114039898, 0.004654104821383953, -0.02562834694981575, 0.010999325662851334, 0.004369290079921484, -0.03267991542816162, 0.03995285555720329, 0.0019043103093281388, -0.013231178745627403, 0.008791008032858372, 0.03705167770385742, 0.0006683217943646014, 0.07346504926681519, -0.004393826238811016, -0.008732115849852562, 0.00933757983148098, 0.004247333388775587, -0.06873758882284164, -0.01955472119152546, -0.04560915380716324, 0.017012298107147217, 0.005582300014793873, -0.030175553634762764, 0.049463555216789246, 0.00884963758289814, -0.06400740146636963, 0.02195838838815689, -0.030012601986527443, 0.006687318906188011, -0.0062252674251794815, 0.012160459533333778, 0.006861196365207434, -0.002118153730407357, -0.008736991323530674, 0.057151492685079575, 0.010798845440149307, 0.0015459907008334994, -0.060773368924856186, -0.0748254731297493, 0.043387170881032944, -0.030400272458791733, 0.021608687937259674, 0.013997613452374935, -0.01814350299537182, 0.03410729765892029, 0.04508300870656967, -0.024640029296278954, -0.08759208768606186, 0.035209544003009796, -0.043234243988990784, -0.029400315135717392, 0.04163369536399841, 0.011591310612857342, 0.024389704689383507, 0.0030122383031994104, 0.012974546290934086, 0.014695106074213982, 0.05852559953927994, -0.004843107424676418, 0.0019761675503104925, -0.003651723498478532, -0.0234850961714983, -0.01767698861658573, 0.01790790446102619, 0.024484016001224518, 0.0002392699825577438, -0.0016325406031683087, -0.028333285823464394, -0.021503746509552002, -0.0031544638331979513, -0.04551904276013374, 0.00332116917707026, 0.007640552241355181, 0.0029199153650552034, -0.01790119893848896, -0.019883226603269577, 0.001502273720689118, -0.05673696845769882, -0.010136096738278866, 0.021186286583542824, 0.013279503211379051, -0.01805492676794529, 0.03134967014193535, 0.030457256361842155, -0.004124416969716549, -0.003734313417226076, 0.011011668480932713, -0.019214386120438576, -0.008156782016158104, -0.002226396230980754, -0.018315514549613, -0.017717262730002403, 0.01312992163002491, 0.006117954850196838, 0.019399281591176987, 0.004778500646352768, -0.05948875471949577, 0.017615405842661858, -0.07710658758878708, 0.00338567397557199, -0.03834841027855873, 0.07153468579053879, 0.020901333540678024, 0.028432572260499, -0.002202719682827592, -0.020892690867185593, 0.023523811250925064, 0.0012631554855033755, -0.09764426946640015, 0.02656230330467224, 0.003841493045911193, 0.005906159523874521, 0.021695096045732498, 0.003969523590058088, 0.01654243655502796, -0.020584991201758385, 0.010846423916518688, 0.015429865568876266, 0.009073041379451752, -0.027298497036099434, 0.011908508837223053, -0.02449011243879795, -0.02467317320406437, -0.01759350672364235, -0.012679997831583023, 0.034975916147232056, 0.015201515518128872, 0.030343517661094666, 0.032761331647634506, -0.000885524379555136, 0.012297403998672962, -0.010954596102237701, 0.019801931455731392, -0.00873484741896391, 0.031767237931489944, 0.022840479388833046, 0.027884451672434807, -0.03541012853384018, 0.030440542846918106, -0.03294026106595993, 0.007990866899490356, 0.042938653379678726, 0.013965348713099957, -0.036496397107839584, -0.05254584178328514, 0.0027448805049061775, -0.002785198390483856, 0.004876350983977318, 0.004808989353477955, -0.02277805656194687, 0.07408060878515244, 0.02586275525391102, -0.05078522861003876, -0.008602323941886425, 0.0629156306385994, -0.00851516705006361, -0.004680615849792957, -0.020963387563824654, -0.0036256108433008194, 0.017131859436631203, -0.01892942376434803, 0.03290850296616554, -0.00010627701703924686, -0.01088209543377161, -0.0013414948480203748, 0.018795032054185867, -0.008956643752753735, 0.015952348709106445, 0.028459424152970314, 0.03865205496549606, 0.0647130236029625, -0.025815147906541824, -0.02976987324655056, -0.040316030383110046, 0.04635585471987724, 0.03706018254160881, 0.015702832490205765, -0.02518833801150322, -0.0925932303071022, -0.0031070541590452194, 0.04517561197280884, 0.041086215525865555, -0.029260775074362755, -0.008875050581991673, -0.07139851897954941, -0.013532467186450958, 0.040774401277303696, -0.03088008612394333, 0.01139074843376875, 0.030033335089683533, -0.03127485141158104, -0.03835431858897209, -0.02030772715806961, -0.02817716635763645, 0.0028518715407699347, 0.0028012495022267103, 0.01984454318881035, -0.03312937170267105, -0.02052103728055954, -0.03852218762040138, 0.03802916035056114, 0.0018342575058341026, 0.04404022917151451, -0.012661042623221874, -0.03589847683906555, 0.04602875933051109, 0.0070978752337396145, -0.0019081049831584096, -0.04594375193119049, 0.015911173075437546, -0.015470829792320728, 0.009840021841228008, 0.014349259436130524, -0.008059030398726463, -0.03710620105266571, 0.00834526028484106, 0.030364708974957466, -0.048159386962652206, 0.016105584800243378, 0.010252086445689201, 0.014764162711799145, 0.025408603250980377, 0.025652825832366943, 0.044580064713954926, 0.04054746404290199, -0.0013799085281789303, -0.015305723994970322, -0.007703145034611225, 0.027043815702199936, -0.008174048736691475, -0.04492742568254471, -0.01616516523063183, -0.04430973902344704, -0.028804292902350426, 0.005021111574023962, 0.026326579973101616, 0.037364501506090164, -0.033388249576091766, -0.004019313491880894, 0.0028141990769654512, 0.06014697253704071, -0.039178792387247086, -0.0031658257357776165, 0.03192322701215744, -0.0052764927968382835, -0.038727931678295135, -0.0019396241987124085, -0.026175452396273613, 0.00584683520719409, 0.021981125697493553, 0.05965455248951912, -0.04126568138599396, 0.03196505829691887, -0.026347098872065544, -0.025150654837489128, 0.008485107682645321, -0.020238880068063736, 0.04928208515048027, 0.023019887506961823, 0.05512966588139534, 0.011108201928436756, -0.03936920687556267, -0.0055169775150716305, 0.018946535885334015, -0.03287995234131813, -0.0027082127053290606, -0.025509128347039223, 0.03948855400085449, -0.027311107143759727, -0.0110761234536767, -0.06933663785457611, -0.026576148346066475, 0.05116405338048935, -0.010352738201618195, -0.01770869269967079, -0.06297463178634644, 0.027467165142297745, -0.017930347472429276, -0.00441393768414855, -0.007688412442803383, -0.006881537847220898, 0.012816951610147953, -0.0041619702242314816, 0.010417480021715164, 0.013575282879173756, 0.04519262909889221, 0.02407023496925831, 0.019637051969766617, -0.007977624423801899, -0.012821885757148266, -0.013242383487522602, 0.005301361903548241, -0.0006890548393130302, -0.010971390642225742, 0.01601487025618553, -0.05218103528022766, 0.002564222551882267, 0.027913471683859825, 0.02274344488978386, -0.00523195369169116, 0.02041054703295231, -0.021242698654532433, 0.009992261417210102, -0.04112609103322029, -0.007344168610870838, -0.02408612333238125, -0.015635395422577858, -0.009899181313812733, 0.01277346070855856, -0.04569718986749649, -0.03291264921426773, -0.0036517016123980284, -0.017664577811956406, 0.0009963144548237324, 0.01612270064651966, 0.06863228231668472, 0.0398927740752697, -0.0024892648216336966, -0.024259407073259354, -0.026061173528432846, 0.03180530294775963, 0.015933940187096596, -0.003466094145551324, -0.03177013248205185, -0.017067745327949524, -0.05790089815855026, -0.04520471394062042, -0.016527503728866577, 0.00025859681772999465, 0.002839909167960286, -0.06841450929641724, 0.06266563385725021, 0.045038625597953796, 0.0074521685019135475, -0.012066870927810669, -0.014229441992938519, -0.01821000687777996, -0.007141054142266512, -0.027270618826150894, 0.04558735713362694, 0.01579524390399456, 0.008544672280550003, 0.036524176597595215, 0.023557640612125397, 0.03609007969498634, 0.07533509284257889, -0.014083589427173138, 0.020890839397907257, 0.044932954013347626, -0.012491329573094845, -0.038692161440849304, 0.032248061150312424, -0.01910761557519436, 0.022394606843590736, 0.004605583846569061, -0.01820283569395542, 0.05504065752029419, 0.011177772656083107, 0.03373493626713753, -0.035769928246736526, -0.011674552224576473, -0.054433539509773254, 0.01120666228234768, 0.034786272794008255, -0.037042856216430664, 0.03398510813713074, 0.02605118788778782, 0.02367704175412655, 0.04483448714017868, 0.0523248016834259, -0.03372325375676155, -0.05577075108885765, 0.002727562328800559, -0.021347006782889366, -0.03174389526247978, 0.030918477103114128, 0.03849465027451515, -0.06727652251720428, 0.04310688003897667, -0.01860426738858223, 0.02360362373292446, 0.01709933392703533, 0.0533142164349556, 0.036657895892858505, 0.06820753216743469, -0.026448845863342285, -0.030057532712817192, -0.004945083055645227, -0.02345614694058895, 0.1373123824596405, 0.08099847286939621, 0.05247977003455162, -0.0891057550907135, -0.024485314264893532, -0.0009203061345033348, -0.008493799716234207, -0.0425872765481472, -0.0015418905531987548, -0.007299364078789949, 0.023853769525885582, 0.09373780339956284, 0.012920004315674305, 0.041541434824466705, 0.028072834014892578, 0.04182261973619461, -0.035846564918756485, 0.02136058546602726, 0.02505931444466114, -0.012527825310826302, 0.04854520782828331, -0.014303618110716343, -0.07493629306554794, 0.04024592787027359, -0.005845875944942236, -0.05149061232805252, -0.02716439962387085, -0.05842199921607971, 0.03539704531431198, 0.04472528025507927, 0.01274406723678112, 0.026921149343252182, -0.01599709317088127, 0.0043176524341106415, 0.03438132628798485, 0.025066208094358444, 0.012323865666985512, -0.03291011601686478, 0.03338887542486191, 0.030983617529273033, 0.046696264296770096, -0.01800587587058544, 0.011018267832696438, -0.009276819415390491, -0.0019683886785060167, -0.004650789313018322, -0.05332137271761894, 0.043744973838329315, -0.002657144097611308, -0.006028898525983095, 0.0118547473102808, 0.006641545798629522, 0.006135153584182262, -0.04916420951485634, -0.029029376804828644, 0.008821334689855576, 0.01740076020359993, -0.047830503433942795, 0.023097258061170578, -0.03244747221469879, -0.0013518738560378551, -0.03831816464662552, 0.048054564744234085, 0.019854888319969177, -0.03334805741906166, -0.03690939396619797, -0.05131145566701889, 0.06852161884307861, -0.0054126582108438015, -0.0013303832383826375, 0.028389204293489456, -0.02072666957974434, -0.023751044645905495, -0.004612707067281008, 0.03642793372273445, -0.026274753734469414, -0.013201141729950905, -0.04059767723083496, -0.020513124763965607, -0.018455419689416885, -0.036113765090703964, -0.02176431193947792, -0.019053533673286438, -0.004589526914060116, -0.01727679930627346, -0.022958477959036827, 0.02831801399588585, 0.008359111845493317, 0.044361744076013565, -0.0023847930133342743, -0.011116617359220982, 0.026264069601893425, 0.038344405591487885, -0.0844588577747345, -0.01204356737434864, -0.04781687259674072, -0.02099759317934513, 0.006333760917186737, -0.038473062217235565, 0.07566820085048676, 0.001125464797951281, -0.009518982842564583, -0.028913026675581932, 0.006356885191053152, -0.02887912653386593, 0.021225890144705772, -0.013837394304573536, -0.06281209737062454, 0.04496990144252777, -0.011998003348708153, 0.014900747686624527, -0.013678873889148235, -0.02019531838595867, -0.043445829302072525, -0.03227543458342552, -0.0007482062210328877, -0.02870400808751583, -0.03326335921883583, 0.04341742396354675, -0.00052067288197577, -0.0012572156265377998, -0.016194216907024384, 0.021980272606015205, -0.029531121253967285, -0.006501214113086462, -0.03959314152598381, -0.0000874618417583406, 0.02709032967686653, -0.013325328007340431, -0.023537835106253624, -0.009708116762340069, 0.05355364829301834, -0.006103107240051031, 0.049910202622413635, 0.03934483230113983, 0.026443250477313995, -0.01942647062242031, 0.04565727338194847, -0.017548536881804466, -0.01662280410528183, 0.015524985268712044, -0.07863195240497589, -0.040141355246305466, 0.0033978347200900316, -0.04786303639411926, 0.03693576529622078, -0.002517156535759568, -0.023613404482603073, -0.0072624413296580315, 0.058121513575315475, -0.0046675726771354675, -0.008644112385809422, 0.011259575374424458, 0.018380239605903625, 0.0481477715075016, 0.00976253580302, -0.022306377068161964, -0.02582544833421707, -0.02000904455780983, 0.012129215523600578, 0.030371036380529404, -0.01514115184545517, -0.00621506292372942, -0.00775509886443615, -0.018900025635957718, -0.01961849071085453, 0.006927100941538811, 0.0012473833048716187, 0.0435408316552639, 0.02871103771030903, -0.04736469313502312, 0.011919704265892506, -0.014470148831605911, 0.014774068258702755, -0.09770237654447556, -0.01057274267077446, -0.025413427501916885, 0.005118128843605518, 0.0006516583380289376, -0.04041575267910957, 0.03440892696380615, 0.029771506786346436, -0.04228303208947182, 0.02367975376546383, 0.05348878353834152, 0.0050995019264519215, -0.05709684640169144, -0.008959382772445679, -0.026553502306342125, -0.03127122297883034, 0.043895378708839417, 0.0022797577548772097, 0.03182874247431755, 0.019368905574083328, -0.009695466607809067, -0.01468607597053051, -0.007056679576635361, 0.04231919348239899, 0.003854467999190092, -0.03418620303273201, 0.010853145271539688, -0.0016225430881604552, -0.02956540882587433, 0.02248913049697876, -0.0031771662179380655, 0.0021613072603940964, 0.013696640729904175, 0.01607401855289936, -0.0008482958655804396, 0.05774901434779167, 0.033737313002347946, -0.015650538727641106, -0.006201126612722874, -0.02341633476316929, 0.01526743732392788, 0.01919781044125557, -0.03972633555531502, 0.030460326001048088, 0.03573347628116608, -0.0013135266490280628, -0.03186576068401337, -0.00773916719481349, -0.00816963892430067, -0.02566259540617466, -0.006371036637574434, -0.0058484491892158985, -0.0153567586094141, -0.01435161754488945, -0.014680501073598862, -0.035487376153469086, -0.009996154345571995, 0.03583500534296036, 0.019742636010050774, -0.00784438569098711, -0.007972097024321556, -0.009924654848873615, -0.03253728151321411, 0.032441768795251846, -0.022198252379894257, 0.014538591727614403, -0.04662132263183594, -0.0041481428779661655, 0.021469729021191597, -0.010567025281488895, -0.033952850848436356, -0.03942641615867615, 0.007029158994555473, 0.02305237203836441, -0.00027411876362748444, -0.008541760966181755, 0.027944261208176613, 0.011712631210684776, 0.017643891274929047, -0.0808974951505661, 0.05951257795095444, 0.02635324001312256, 0.003182989079505205, -0.004928611684590578, -0.011516192927956581, -0.03506854921579361, 0.02148418314754963, 0.057148560881614685, 0.009870427660644054, 0.007907398976385593, -0.007761391811072826, 0.03741665929555893, 0.01678568683564663, -0.041249413043260574, 0.03989148885011673, -0.01975436508655548, -0.06469094008207321, -0.003918999806046486, -0.023449398577213287, 0.015057534910738468, 0.0017669678200036287, -0.020447198301553726, 0.0071706827729940414, 0.022049304097890854, 0.03624344244599342, -0.011262847110629082, -0.006655300501734018, -0.00016143832181114703, -0.00938380230218172, 0.031195323914289474, -0.006589972414076328, -0.012444480322301388, -0.00879954919219017, 0.024121476337313652, -0.059404052793979645, 0.030370671302080154, 0.0062932418659329414, -0.019214939326047897, -0.03411146625876427, 0.025027509778738022, -0.06182131916284561, -0.037239667028188705, -0.022605910897254944, 0.04971776157617569, -0.04717664048075676, -0.005083601456135511, 0.058372918516397476, -0.029769202694296837, 0.03884023427963257, -0.012410563416779041, 0.0147573696449399, 0.005918737500905991, -0.032362960278987885, -0.011423156596720219, 0.017372893169522285, 0.00034986904938705266, 0.008367879316210747, 0.028600890189409256, 0.044560372829437256, -0.014374968595802784, 0.03740091621875763, -0.00048347882693633437, 0.027947835624217987, -0.06463205069303513, -0.023274853825569153, 0.011920633725821972, -0.007591882720589638, -0.018929675221443176, -0.02851366065442562, -0.0008273848798125982, 0.06280587613582611, -0.027347614988684654, 0.00010871796985156834, -0.0035382534842938185, -0.010761636309325695, 0.002588191768154502, 0.012585937045514584, -0.009461927227675915, 0.035777635872364044, -0.0018685344839468598, 0.027643021196126938, 0.010660959407687187, 0.001663394970819354, 0.04085500165820122, -0.012650820426642895, 0.011714254505932331, -0.011122917756438255, -0.00032845092937350273, -0.014158595353364944, 0.006010699551552534, 0.02618340589106083, -0.028729021549224854, 0.02073799818754196, 0.04597623273730278, 0.013055532239377499, -0.012428087182343006, -0.005643378011882305, -0.003450837219133973, 0.07657545804977417, -0.11208652704954147, -0.0003307262377347797, -0.00913628563284874, -0.004829363897442818, -0.020270472392439842, 0.0058502391912043095 ]
<p>I was wondering if there under some circumstances is possible for ANN's to perform better if you prune away some connections on them as for example:</p> <p>Constructing one ANN by taking two multi-layered ANN's A and B in parallel (same input and output nodes) adding a few "communication" connections between the hidden layers of A and B?</p> <p>Could one get better generalization results?</p> <p>Is this somehow used in practice or does one always just use multi-layered fully connected networks?</p>
73,584
[ -0.03955216333270073, 0.01043816190212965, -0.017960090190172195, 0.020519336685538292, 0.04710270091891289, -0.004049898125231266, -0.011790221557021141, -0.03378790244460106, 0.03734614700078964, -0.016404084861278534, -0.005891941953450441, 0.041510969400405884, 0.005527708679437637, 0.03189952298998833, -0.0014791308203712106, -0.025343114510178566, -0.01989872008562088, -0.026172015815973282, 0.027267076075077057, -0.0271514393389225, -0.023748675361275673, 0.01969965733587742, -0.005078414920717478, -0.006744469050318003, 0.016130436211824417, 0.03505144268274307, -0.02254904992878437, -0.024978820234537125, 0.004186051897704601, 0.053162142634391785, 0.006938898004591465, -0.022914834320545197, -0.0015362916747108102, 0.06721507012844086, -0.012597087770700455, 0.006541313603520393, -0.02560395747423172, -0.03136821091175079, -0.029147211462259293, 0.02822299674153328, 0.02878960222005844, 0.012124409899115562, -0.015410973690450191, 0.033971309661865234, -0.01959274709224701, 0.0418255478143692, -0.0019261008128523827, -0.04175347462296486, -0.00760678481310606, -0.009003196842968464, 0.04008303955197334, -0.01904366724193096, 0.0036078121047466993, 0.029613032937049866, -0.016035977751016617, 0.011645366437733173, 0.06738809496164322, 0.07176545262336731, -0.003927829675376415, -0.05550515279173851, 0.028300005942583084, -0.0019352277740836143, 0.03200462833046913, -0.021370455622673035, -0.045486077666282654, 0.04434752091765404, -0.0029770685359835625, -0.014450049959123135, 0.007247626315802336, -0.032865989953279495, -0.0040041133761405945, -0.014817115850746632, 0.03668641671538353, -0.0034422336611896753, -0.036790911108255386, 0.020615804940462112, 0.004088951274752617, 0.018240120261907578, 0.043248098343610764, 0.03694456070661545, -0.012569958344101906, 0.02650435082614422, 0.020770849660038948, 0.013681533746421337, 0.02988530322909355, -0.002562410430982709, 0.06188010796904564, -0.05332494527101517, 0.012565840035676956, 0.012389247305691242, -0.016667688265442848, -0.026129618287086487, 0.038251690566539764, 0.003611278487369418, -0.032595887780189514, 0.00887802243232727, 0.022320546209812164, 0.008740627206861973, 0.030626261606812477, -0.031830672174692154, -0.007638438139110804, -0.02204563468694687, -0.03337140008807182, 0.030674299225211143, 0.0035001852083951235, -0.014014306478202343, -0.029800202697515488, 0.03537304326891899, -0.0008231206447817385, 0.013415592722594738, -0.04335475340485573, 0.005635026842355728, 0.004842265974730253, 0.01424481626600027, 0.013904953375458717, -0.00832967460155487, -0.0015819765394553542, -0.01474535558372736, 0.014467332512140274, 0.07656765729188919, 0.008777420036494732, -0.04462505504488945, 0.04862065985798836, -0.03534321114420891, -0.055997513234615326, 0.004298352636396885, 0.00018986609939020127, -0.023779189214110374, -0.031184503808617592, 0.04727339744567871, 0.01552030723541975, -0.030123421922326088, 0.01189469825476408, -0.037627801299095154, 0.04043574258685112, 0.0012427200563251972, -0.06903165578842163, -0.05474340543150902, 0.04493240639567375, -0.03739246726036072, 0.009143092669546604, -0.048729535192251205, 0.04039638489484787, 0.020646318793296814, 0.06834156066179276, 0.024298371747136116, 0.026559079065918922, 0.03125264123082161, 0.022097617387771606, 0.0056143030524253845, 0.0015986229991540313, -0.01724022999405861, -0.012709850445389748, 0.008163027465343475, -0.02587415650486946, -0.09407784789800644, 0.06301441788673401, 0.032736439257860184, 0.010746745392680168, -0.0007510339492000639, 0.0406402088701725, 0.01507262047380209, -0.0034607001580297947, 0.005226592067629099, 0.006313235964626074, -0.059422578662633896, 0.07420161366462708, -0.004349417984485626, 0.038076892495155334, 0.016213171184062958, 0.010454858653247356, 0.04759746044874191, 0.011481218971312046, 0.019789455458521843, 0.024613182991743088, 0.012065772898495197, 0.007099308539181948, -0.01818530634045601, 0.033383116126060486, 0.011511757038533688, -0.02425359934568405, -0.03795851767063141, -0.021486660465598106, 0.03526252508163452, 0.02316649816930294, 0.06434816122055054, 0.023293502628803253, -0.05174656957387924, 0.034501802176237106, -0.04066915437579155, -0.0005229315720498562, -0.06002821400761604, 0.027393924072384834, -0.015136533416807652, -0.008914479054510593, -0.01300404965877533, -0.012747104279696941, 0.013948049396276474, -0.013280563987791538, -0.024498583748936653, -0.06412626057863235, 0.010594399645924568, 0.022932467982172966, -0.030114635825157166, 0.014618471264839172, 0.035633549094200134, 0.002060488797724247, -0.006801137700676918, 0.06495067477226257, -0.06945628672838211, -0.062313735485076904, 0.03322630748152733, 0.00829819031059742, 0.012690870091319084, -0.006326192058622837, -0.03860173001885414, 0.012588259764015675, 0.0019688187167048454, -0.04743105173110962, 0.013950693421065807, -0.07117462158203125, 0.09251962602138519, 0.03776172176003456, -0.001414117286913097, 0.01943308860063553, 0.02736465074121952, 0.04806959256529808, -0.002663690596818924, 0.01970030553638935, 0.011811550706624985, -0.06972397863864899, -0.0000600221028435044, 0.04748930037021637, -0.007568678818643093, -0.04033445194363594, 0.04185130074620247, 0.04862809181213379, 0.03302959352731705, 0.016727624461054802, -0.014007813297212124, -0.01668791100382805, 0.006991421338170767, 0.004990508314222097, 0.03678269311785698, 0.019388539716601372, -0.012005376629531384, 0.021543947979807854, 0.011166906915605068, 0.005874026101082563, -0.003093471983447671, 0.007960766553878784, 0.06809882819652557, 0.028715217486023903, 0.00249611958861351, 0.010725747793912888, -0.025088367983698845, 0.0056567988358438015, -0.03366885706782341, 0.0038154840003699064, 0.009193959645926952, 0.025255873799324036, -0.0019122804515063763, 0.004955229815095663, 0.0006389599293470383, 0.011210457421839237, 0.002468083519488573, -0.027226272970438004, -0.012176214717328548, 0.03874785080552101, -0.04246964678168297, -0.01417057029902935, -0.02208605222404003, 0.017623156309127808, -0.06544291973114014, 0.040247730910778046, 0.03407709300518036, -0.004388311877846718, 0.06173727288842201, -0.03574569895863533, -0.006803144700825214, 0.010175418108701706, -0.023438673466444016, 0.006909513380378485, -0.021697837859392166, -0.026528730988502502, -0.0005338808987289667, -0.007627830374985933, -0.014955414459109306, 0.03622658550739288, -0.02668125554919243, -0.003503114450722933, 0.008762757293879986, -0.033172957599163055, -0.02165023796260357, -0.027912190183997154, -0.04497484490275383, 0.017542444169521332, 0.019413305446505547, -0.024113105610013008, 0.048633962869644165, 0.02798551879823208, -0.04308893159031868, -0.022768523544073105, 0.004698858130723238, -0.02786332368850708, -0.018118837848305702, -0.035321272909641266, 0.019371870905160904, -0.013475700281560421, -0.01834649220108986, 0.026166129857301712, -0.053221993148326874, 0.02605307288467884, -0.024581516161561012, -0.061814382672309875, 0.029733816161751747, -0.0009292522445321083, 0.026192806661128998, 0.01572161726653576, -0.010464559309184551, 0.09577863663434982, 0.009957650676369667, -0.05535314977169037, -0.019053250551223755, -0.011521351523697376, -0.029140274971723557, 0.001365160453133285, 0.03270484134554863, 0.024390550330281258, -0.01577560417354107, 0.02312149479985237, 0.020818036049604416, 0.04257460683584213, 0.06164093315601349, 0.008538130670785904, -0.007003993261605501, 0.006137627176940441, 0.021258771419525146, -0.041269928216934204, 0.005454701837152243, 0.019732272252440453, -0.016717150807380676, 0.03362845629453659, -0.011552395299077034, 0.020868798717856407, 0.025038093328475952, -0.01754036918282509, 0.04123401641845703, -0.024854622781276703, 0.025717470794916153, -0.022678518667817116, 0.013414273969829082, 0.0204820204526186, 0.019420107826590538, -0.06011265143752098, 0.03675320744514465, 0.06341589987277985, -0.035569872707128525, 0.004301887005567551, 0.03672860935330391, 0.017482465133070946, -0.012930493801832199, -0.006754794158041477, 0.011562458239495754, -0.025079738348722458, 0.01827451027929783, -0.012406773865222931, -0.0001235699892276898, 0.029696399345993996, 0.015252928249537945, 0.008195262402296066, 0.048599403351545334, -0.04172758758068085, 0.002306062960997224, -0.07489222288131714, 0.02965998649597168, -0.08826243132352829, 0.07603323459625244, -0.004739806056022644, 0.006028308533132076, -0.004652716219425201, -0.0018849398475140333, 0.0060293530113995075, -0.003009919775649905, -0.09304232895374298, 0.001985251670703292, 0.003924235701560974, -0.04021584242582321, 0.04589882865548134, -0.03316635638475418, 0.039753325283527374, -0.044502295553684235, -0.029593568295240402, -0.012295420281589031, 0.028500638902187347, -0.07884308695793152, 0.007748316042125225, -0.0044105458073318005, 0.0042684744112193584, -0.03610802814364433, -0.015117734670639038, 0.030511528253555298, 0.02522723376750946, 0.002438641618937254, 0.0009110115934163332, -0.0224019642919302, -0.020255759358406067, -0.022793859243392944, 0.00941481627523899, 0.01019200962036848, 0.023425385355949402, -0.0006069147493690252, 0.05121352896094322, -0.03221186622977257, 0.011416343972086906, 0.016076864674687386, 0.05518123134970665, 0.003067189594730735, -0.007766669150441885, -0.00476093590259552, -0.056928783655166626, -0.03605968877673149, 0.033878061920404434, 0.07083433866500854, -0.011682020500302315, -0.009214567951858044, 0.006497770082205534, 0.013984856195747852, -0.05635897442698479, -0.004603890236467123, 0.06312931329011917, -0.007799067068845034, -0.030014803633093834, -0.04243331402540207, -0.023805120959877968, -0.01772763766348362, -0.014404638670384884, 0.026327285915613174, -0.021849248558282852, -0.01181689091026783, -0.00834362767636776, 0.03237639367580414, -0.015338919125497341, -0.014706694521009922, -0.006520599126815796, 0.011068500578403473, -0.007494472432881594, 0.0017496721120551229, 0.01568509079515934, -0.005077047739177942, 0.032610274851322174, 0.05697179585695267, 0.010070648975670338, -0.00043909336091019213, -0.07358039915561676, -0.0017574861412867904, 0.06990882009267807, 0.04010511934757233, -0.018140314146876335, 0.02504154108464718, -0.043582815676927567, -0.017164219170808792, 0.03743233531713486, 0.009022390469908714, 0.042651668190956116, -0.028071751818060875, -0.0030514965765178204, -0.05117263272404671, -0.03545372188091278, 0.028896747156977654, 0.017185576260089874, -0.01158010121434927, 0.03743157163262367, -0.0007148311124183238, -0.002460021758452058, -0.04206209257245064, -0.0010153468465432525, 0.025754302740097046, 0.07274779677391052, 0.017252881079912186, -0.03278138488531113, 0.008315354585647583, 0.00489394785836339, 0.020558033138513565, -0.07768294960260391, -0.008280070498585701, -0.002280537039041519, -0.029091060161590576, 0.031282901763916016, 0.012775071896612644, -0.02077445201575756, 0.049722470343112946, 0.024837452918291092, -0.02916107513010502, -0.04033174365758896, -0.03264189511537552, 0.07163022458553314, 0.032373372465372086, -0.0012140891049057245, 0.027617478743195534, -0.003399586072191596, 0.002010209485888481, 0.020014554262161255, 0.005635290406644344, 0.011193196289241314, -0.05700100213289261, 0.0018186317756772041, -0.026793161407113075, -0.01929914392530918, 0.017057811841368675, 0.03379793092608452, 0.006990829482674599, 0.04503334313631058, -0.02056286484003067, -0.03576736897230148, 0.0030293248128145933, 0.023271402344107628, 0.007833093404769897, -0.04634883627295494, 0.04069781303405762, 0.02784920111298561, -0.023543067276477814, -0.0032907556742429733, 0.0009393023792654276, -0.0019772432278841734, 0.0253007672727108, 0.03476373106241226, -0.015374348498880863, -0.03428569808602333, -0.03931378945708275, -0.021336166188120842, 0.012696005403995514, -0.023152070119976997, 0.05932258069515228, 0.019159512594342232, 0.0059928977862000465, 0.017670616507530212, -0.029306529089808464, -0.033422987908124924, -0.00642106868326664, -0.02420053258538246, -0.009454544633626938, -0.06268485635519028, 0.0448714978992939, -0.031089456751942635, -0.031155796721577644, -0.029800454154610634, -0.03749110549688339, 0.0369127094745636, 0.017980476841330528, 0.008738958276808262, -0.02627689018845558, 0.01182722207158804, -0.0055647846311330795, -0.01874217763543129, -0.0218050517141819, 0.05955153703689575, -0.05559660121798515, 0.006408948451280594, 0.013727628625929356, 0.011693408712744713, 0.08129630237817764, 0.02631491608917713, 0.0009150325786322355, -0.026935666799545288, -0.06896629929542542, -0.006118441466242075, -0.023212850093841553, 0.008818934671580791, -0.02549169957637787, -0.007352095562964678, -0.020990649238228798, -0.00961316842585802, 0.06086206063628197, -0.00807101558893919, -0.001456845784559846, 0.031089363619685173, 0.017889617010951042, 0.00013656569353770465, 0.0026589531917124987, 0.0101625332608819, 0.012209306471049786, -0.0022001760080456734, 0.030878081917762756, 0.020061155781149864, -0.004790646024048328, -0.06518956273794174, 0.00262430589646101, 0.006877475418150425, -0.007402912247925997, 0.024575859308242798, 0.05019038915634155, -0.001344284857623279, -0.0027530365623533726, -0.021185139194130898, -0.029093533754348755, 0.06046693027019501, -0.023516837507486343, -0.00551627017557621, -0.027693353593349457, 0.04429331049323082, -0.038048215210437775, -0.013722977600991726, -0.01038641482591629, -0.021452439948916435, 0.044031769037246704, -0.017714032903313637, 0.03921528160572052, 0.03804890438914299, 0.016464155167341232, -0.04025369510054588, -0.02842738851904869, -0.0009130825637839735, -0.007278991863131523, -0.006161993835121393, 0.06206989660859108, -0.04698812961578369, -0.007878357544541359, 0.02152780257165432, 0.03543277829885483, -0.012286934070289135, 0.010347288101911545, -0.03423883020877838, 0.012837628833949566, -0.005240116734057665, -0.047308411449193954, -0.03512077406048775, 0.0036667375825345516, -0.06268084794282913, 0.0067490478977561, -0.022017182782292366, -0.008536108769476414, 0.05493125319480896, 0.02278183214366436, 0.012311450205743313, -0.026717307046055794, -0.04814562574028969, -0.04072058945894241, -0.009749404154717922, 0.01948450691998005, -0.01184460986405611, 0.020744558423757553, -0.0015313612530007958, 0.025388168171048164, -0.02179480902850628, 0.044146668165922165, -0.018440529704093933, -0.07033776491880417, -0.05651652812957764, -0.024876167997717857, -0.022699566558003426, 0.02905941568315029, 0.0008932237979024649, -0.06838613748550415, 0.02265697345137596, -0.023540785536170006, 0.07464399933815002, 0.020992306992411613, 0.04147626459598541, -0.0012859024573117495, 0.04388433322310448, -0.0070694671012461185, 0.011279668658971786, 0.045293450355529785, 0.017808621749281883, 0.11530592292547226, 0.08269967138767242, 0.012165442109107971, -0.0742642730474472, 0.04571493715047836, -0.0030782162211835384, -0.015741650015115738, -0.03812796249985695, 0.0313529446721077, 0.0037679835222661495, 0.019356757402420044, 0.014758670702576637, 0.06723672151565552, -0.024126648902893066, -0.008011167868971825, 0.05767412856221199, -0.028943844139575958, -0.045978814363479614, 0.007184440735727549, 0.01578517258167267, -0.0015736939385533333, -0.00981080625206232, -0.038791827857494354, -0.019005469977855682, -0.0032320336904376745, 0.010530428029596806, -0.015360208228230476, 0.0024956497363746166, 0.04511871561408043, 0.004843748174607754, -0.0029828809201717377, 0.0018356770742684603, 0.01844903640449047, 0.011378844268620014, 0.019793884828686714, 0.002575864549726248, 0.0031401338055729866, -0.03965000808238983, -0.007330070715397596, 0.06624113023281097, 0.05080195516347885, -0.029558449983596802, 0.00459955632686615, -0.02170131355524063, -0.04615361616015434, -0.02855791337788105, -0.0360797643661499, 0.03729930520057678, -0.010755169205367565, -0.008205476216971874, 0.028022997081279755, 0.016270704567432404, 0.008693801239132881, -0.03549864515662193, -0.019202591851353645, 0.012138857506215572, 0.004195989575237036, 0.01899772137403488, 0.009047006256878376, -0.019282782450318336, 0.022721372544765472, -0.006189694628119469, 0.021286025643348694, 0.007949571125209332, -0.011831248179078102, -0.04412238672375679, -0.025734707713127136, 0.04476628825068474, 0.0027732164599001408, -0.0063884141854941845, -0.013092352077364922, -0.004538615234196186, 0.013377801515161991, -0.038293927907943726, 0.012169688008725643, 0.023884352296590805, 0.034844473004341125, -0.021811801940202713, -0.023325031623244286, -0.028336601331830025, -0.04568984732031822, 0.016618866473436356, -0.0043924907222390175, 0.01690216362476349, -0.03257299214601517, 0.013067428953945637, 0.031482573598623276, 0.024170637130737305, 0.0472278818488121, 0.021421948447823524, 0.007438216358423233, 0.03953425958752632, 0.03992855176329613, -0.05318464711308479, -0.02618786320090294, -0.010591983795166016, -0.048097074031829834, 0.005762970540672541, -0.020411159843206406, 0.04868137463927269, 0.004044954665005207, 0.001607378595508635, -0.0022925648372620344, 0.03683427348732948, 0.02078220061957836, -0.0132225276902318, 0.018559589982032776, -0.05825528874993324, 0.02745240367949009, 0.0009255593759007752, 0.04451889172196388, -0.01085762307047844, -0.0024518973659723997, -0.013617321848869324, -0.019833693280816078, 0.028716150671243668, 0.014985243789851665, 0.0006786813028156757, 0.027297981083393097, -0.000881544197909534, 0.044257305562496185, -0.04492336884140968, 0.014746117405593395, -0.06465163081884384, -0.038786161690950394, -0.022156380116939545, -0.061585985124111176, 0.006381908431649208, -0.009202612563967705, 0.004434316884726286, -0.0218561589717865, 0.05275728926062584, 0.009661938063800335, -0.022479958832263947, -0.030318550765514374, 0.02470654807984829, -0.00923110730946064, 0.037637025117874146, -0.014535692520439625, -0.022704679518938065, 0.036436066031455994, -0.01761453039944172, -0.0056149642914533615, 0.0028277256060391665, -0.04591945558786392, 0.06071687489748001, -0.0025667184963822365, -0.0462990328669548, -0.03978314995765686, 0.07575513422489166, 0.001696862862445414, -0.018407385796308517, -0.02155744470655918, -0.01275357324630022, 0.0033585424534976482, 0.022572766989469528, -0.003894633846357465, -0.018441881984472275, -0.015634821727871895, 0.00969682727009058, 0.0174880288541317, 0.04149772226810455, -0.042764801532030106, 0.010663190856575966, -0.021634355187416077, 0.048378586769104004, -0.004957795608788729, -0.0022944605443626642, 0.028752652928233147, 0.021972212940454483, -0.02156977355480194, 0.011385994963347912, 0.026349127292633057, 0.027233311906456947, -0.09933255612850189, -0.001815187744796276, -0.00006087429937906563, 0.007946849800646305, 0.027984844520688057, -0.03788888081908226, 0.04750708118081093, -0.00473975483328104, -0.05972149968147278, 0.009174549952149391, -0.03888217359781265, 0.007154207676649094, -0.035744767636060715, 0.0057923258282244205, -0.01256830245256424, 0.03949118033051491, 0.008372402749955654, 0.04145940765738487, 0.004894692916423082, 0.005971988663077354, -0.04353104159235954, 0.0007198831299319863, -0.0776526927947998, 0.017178896814584732, -0.0005245063221082091, -0.01742432825267315, 0.04546210169792175, -0.0543382503092289, -0.04862115904688835, 0.030140109360218048, -0.04349750652909279, 0.006133106537163258, 0.01947394199669361, 0.006305840332061052, 0.054702263325452805, -0.02143097296357155, 0.03313404694199562, 0.0008573709055781364, 0.0020064529962837696, 0.03312813118100166, 0.03183210268616676, 0.009378621354699135, -0.03516264259815216, 0.016656309366226196, 0.016317205503582954, -0.011497000232338905, -0.02897191047668457, -0.03441423550248146, -0.0402771420776844, -0.020157385617494583, 0.012747236527502537, 0.0036989368963986635, 0.01675097644329071, -0.015935884788632393, 0.007855812087655067, -0.0011621235171332955, -0.0017482306575402617, 0.01768478937447071, 0.054615575820207596, -0.021236445754766464, 0.02007475309073925, 0.019448284059762955, -0.057276055216789246, 0.007451032288372517, -0.025006556883454323, 0.001427873270586133, -0.046355124562978745, -0.013219728134572506, 0.025005634874105453, -0.015489750541746616, 0.0008542953873984516, -0.0536232516169548, -0.005902925506234169, 0.028158875182271004, -0.02558099664747715, 0.04190899059176445, 0.009346647188067436, -0.02600674517452717, -0.001356454100459814, -0.048234373331069946, 0.031464479863643646, -0.006503442768007517, 0.01936442032456398, -0.038286685943603516, 0.0008561520953662694, -0.03693078085780144, 0.014975820668041706, 0.10561078041791916, -0.04181213304400444, 0.04556446522474289, -0.029946202412247658, 0.01666751690208912, 0.014610742218792439, -0.015313771553337574, 0.013648523949086666, -0.0277396272867918, -0.014349916949868202, -0.035425540059804916, -0.05233297869563103, 0.0053237020038068295, 0.008050761185586452, -0.0023239925503730774, 0.03340819850564003, -0.015506411902606487, 0.026298943907022476, 0.01684034802019596, 0.03997622802853584, 0.01632871851325035, -0.017403241246938705, 0.03795541077852249, 0.023605389520525932, -0.002475469373166561, -0.0018124108901247382, 0.0033966696355491877, -0.07023816555738449, 0.011586702428758144, 0.012800628319382668, 0.01939372532069683, -0.012661575339734554, -0.00016042975767049938, 0.005136230494827032, -0.051648687571287155, -0.004459444899111986, 0.0323905386030674, -0.012616033665835857, 0.004505061078816652, 0.059433866292238235, 0.0063219210132956505, 0.014683881774544716, -0.030400685966014862, 0.01614239253103733, -0.006241629831492901, 0.0008811168954707682, 0.039710186421871185, 0.009979024529457092, -0.02774360217154026, -0.005481433589011431, 0.031805042177438736, 0.014289585873484612, -0.019848009571433067, 0.03351188823580742, -0.050140898674726486, 0.06171923875808716, -0.06743502616882324, -0.008791795931756496, 0.030792132019996643, -0.013619394972920418, -0.04604914411902428, 0.009148218668997288, -0.016875028610229492, 0.0687568411231041, -0.022091880440711975, 0.022906016558408737, -0.004238683730363846, -0.031647104769945145, -0.002871215343475342, -0.009449006989598274, 0.008034508675336838, 0.05751698091626167, 0.020824989303946495, -0.018669093027710915, -0.019371528178453445, -0.02640140801668167, 0.04336630180478096, -0.02519487962126732, 0.02427132986485958, -0.042840924113988876, -0.015511929988861084, 0.015515877865254879, 0.021054398268461227, -0.04026054963469505, -0.02799966000020504, 0.05572342500090599, 0.06671484559774399, 0.016487641260027885, -0.016431067138910294, -0.026104774326086044, 0.0006761266267858446, 0.02813994511961937, -0.0451417900621891, -0.011701557785272598, -0.05951010063290596, 0.0026131928898394108, -0.010767812840640545, -0.01381040271371603 ]
<p>I need to conduct an experiment and use one-way ANOVA test to analyze the data. I know what the test is, but I am having difficulty figuring out an experiment to perform. Any suggestions on an experiment? Something simple I can do at home.</p> <p>Thank you</p>
29,538
[ -0.045733559876680374, -0.00284557999111712, -0.024980172514915466, 0.006380901671946049, 0.04979711398482323, -0.0015027383342385292, 0.03657744452357292, -0.0017083801794797182, -0.006219754461199045, -0.005183238536119461, 0.07118403166532516, 0.03845609724521637, 0.012223783880472183, 0.017811842262744904, 0.025087546557188034, 0.018035314977169037, -0.0078416233882308, -0.023350704461336136, 0.002495190827175975, -0.010010347701609135, -0.018415352329611778, -0.019346995279192924, -0.00043914667912758887, 0.00958876684308052, -0.007968073710799217, 0.01667010225355625, 0.03771090507507324, -0.03413043171167374, 0.027398737147450447, 0.06214961037039757, -0.0267772376537323, -0.025156937539577484, -0.025468215346336365, 0.043611589819192886, 0.00020873488392680883, -0.011108890175819397, -0.009490451775491238, -0.009440874680876732, -0.0010542013915255666, 0.03443754464387894, 0.01759365200996399, -0.031152276322245598, -0.019023112952709198, 0.04005017131567001, 0.0004541494126897305, -0.0007239208789542317, 0.011902368627488613, -0.04104633629322052, 0.05447845533490181, -0.07235809415578842, 0.05297300964593887, 0.0037454236298799515, 0.014342272654175758, 0.05668453872203827, 0.007832028903067112, 0.012941332533955574, 0.05366948992013931, 0.06282877177000046, -0.024974606931209564, -0.07380978763103485, -0.020150380209088326, -0.0370565690100193, -0.01781151257455349, -0.0008163517341017723, -0.03982793539762497, 0.016291048377752304, -0.012309174984693527, -0.007127182092517614, 0.04616907238960266, -0.01645532436668873, 0.013804924674332142, 0.023652706295251846, 0.046273455023765564, -0.009037438780069351, -0.03827497735619545, -0.011854005046188831, 0.01508340798318386, 0.013344766572117805, 0.04889572039246559, 0.04393462836742401, 0.0015818931860849261, 0.027860276401042938, -0.010027612559497356, 0.0566629059612751, 0.0032032839953899384, -0.023308925330638885, 0.08474677801132202, -0.018383542075753212, -0.02381625957787037, 0.010343209840357304, -0.04040929675102234, -0.03325068578124046, 0.050822895020246506, 0.05089883506298065, -0.0251021608710289, 0.014066588133573532, -0.03181896731257439, 0.049949467182159424, -0.009565836749970913, -0.05900523066520691, 0.011607007123529911, -0.026845784857869148, 0.031409651041030884, 0.051653314381837845, -0.001847167732194066, -0.015701012685894966, -0.011550934053957462, 0.03707178309559822, 0.027729706838726997, -0.012817216105759144, -0.00847559329122305, 0.016670946031808853, 0.01008882001042366, 0.004005047958344221, 0.032442547380924225, -0.024338800460100174, -0.022210443392395973, -0.008662019856274128, 0.061725158244371414, 0.05755859985947609, 0.048479750752449036, -0.021423954516649246, 0.036347679793834686, -0.013467789627611637, -0.038689013570547104, 0.016990117728710175, -0.0030396911315619946, -0.002614201046526432, -0.010110714472830296, 0.10706889629364014, -0.020057691261172295, -0.03983338922262192, 0.03229937702417374, -0.030588654801249504, 0.05829507112503052, -0.00354377250187099, -0.12439645081758499, -0.07083507627248764, 0.04910701513290405, -0.012151612900197506, -0.019778678193688393, -0.05702182650566101, 0.008097996935248375, 0.005185667425394058, 0.059575267136096954, 0.01774793118238449, 0.02716006338596344, -0.003370853140950203, 0.015394393354654312, 0.04019736126065254, -0.0001507542037870735, -0.027929561212658882, -0.022987328469753265, -0.03196758031845093, 0.014655651524662971, -0.05314644053578377, 0.012182191014289856, 0.0031293006613850594, -0.0014381345827132463, -0.007977088913321495, 0.014905974268913269, 0.02096153236925602, -0.020701395347714424, 0.03200698643922806, 0.0043975855223834515, -0.014399722218513489, 0.07596133649349213, -0.02497158758342266, -0.007370857987552881, 0.014863060787320137, -0.003928993828594685, 0.03404734656214714, 0.005059697665274143, 0.020134471356868744, 0.01569766364991665, -0.005947921425104141, -0.02600199170410633, -0.00201497133821249, 0.03208053857088089, 0.0203925259411335, -0.02845623530447483, -0.006435559131205082, -0.017715202644467354, 0.02420385181903839, 0.018898775801062584, 0.035339660942554474, -0.009121845476329327, -0.026178758591413498, 0.040588561445474625, -0.05610844865441322, -0.036501843482255936, -0.07475902140140533, 0.011880205012857914, -0.019610676914453506, -0.006361072883009911, -0.0019853997509926558, 0.030121058225631714, 0.025893434882164, -0.040817223489284515, -0.056222639977931976, -0.028237123042345047, -0.01471172459423542, 0.031534574925899506, -0.010835989378392696, 0.007482012268155813, 0.03269971162080765, 0.052133601158857346, -0.05468827113509178, 0.046479322016239166, -0.03905295953154564, -0.005004917271435261, -0.018546730279922485, -0.035057183355093, 0.0025912809651345015, -0.010421495884656906, -0.0103921452537179, 0.02275914140045643, 0.01919994130730629, 0.015752239152789116, 0.04339383542537689, -0.030069027096033096, 0.09383036196231842, 0.044034916907548904, 0.0014036792563274503, -0.0018079258734360337, -0.00639808364212513, 0.04129145294427872, 0.01526318397372961, -0.028737448155879974, 0.008901293389499187, -0.03402607887983322, 0.007798902690410614, 0.07585388422012329, -0.03152107074856758, -0.03531668335199356, 0.02443978376686573, 0.04698804020881653, 0.03910532593727112, 0.007585686165839434, 0.054090920835733414, 0.0023433351889252663, -0.02068600244820118, -0.02198837697505951, 0.03970881178975105, 0.039143968373537064, 0.01720290072262287, 0.04681289941072464, 0.0193314328789711, 0.0388345941901207, 0.022158941254019737, 0.01696351356804371, 0.03719443455338478, -0.016615809872746468, 0.013019791804254055, -0.008968922309577465, -0.029089104384183884, 0.009915659204125404, -0.0147155886515975, 0.01604861579835415, 0.026114147156476974, -0.008690589107573032, 0.014566827565431595, 0.017816241830587387, -0.010948934592306614, 0.03846772015094757, 0.032497867941856384, -0.004690885543823242, 0.01242834236472845, 0.027363957837224007, -0.018482211977243423, 0.025422433391213417, -0.018002422526478767, -0.0017073260387405753, -0.037931229919195175, 0.01189433690160513, 0.02501903846859932, 0.0207412987947464, 0.011226177215576172, -0.020273419097065926, -0.047929905354976654, -0.0111089451238513, -0.040896039456129074, 0.0036656565498560667, 0.004698240663856268, -0.02900036796927452, 0.0015023855958133936, -0.028371628373861313, -0.0066567049361765385, 0.04492985084652901, 0.0007155133062042296, 0.0008702072664164007, 0.05194652080535889, 0.025962993502616882, -0.03520328551530838, -0.026161806657910347, -0.029204409569501877, 0.023784678429365158, -0.039977945387363434, 0.0025644160341471434, 0.028009507805109024, 0.020034821704030037, -0.03623320907354355, 0.033780958503484726, -0.02750987559556961, -0.016962679103016853, 0.004154411610215902, -0.0013224163558334112, 0.003234272124245763, -0.02390936389565468, 0.011090515181422234, 0.011602499522268772, -0.03333066403865814, -0.005607204977422953, -0.05460960790514946, -0.0642785131931305, -0.0008554764790460467, 0.015502255409955978, 0.015425589866936207, 0.004411107394844294, -0.027255425229668617, 0.060677364468574524, -0.0007546612177975476, -0.05246767774224281, -0.04693813621997833, -0.020399244502186775, -0.03331998363137245, -0.03498511388897896, 0.056841522455215454, 0.014655695296823978, -0.025774424895644188, 0.02480124868452549, 0.03200593218207359, 0.005885330494493246, 0.04517728090286255, 0.03609615936875343, -0.011738230474293232, 0.01857488788664341, -0.006161411292850971, -0.022436928004026413, 0.018154090270400047, -0.0019531904254108667, -0.043126221746206284, -0.006233826279640198, 0.014970239251852036, 0.02516421303153038, 0.024971654638648033, -0.039871446788311005, 0.032583191990852356, -0.01619292050600052, -0.0034133344888687134, -0.050611644983291626, 0.019084613770246506, 0.013010772876441479, 0.03974650800228119, -0.02154596336185932, 0.005323215387761593, 0.02685842290520668, -0.023851731792092323, 0.008355733938515186, 0.06091475114226341, 0.039706215262413025, -0.008495651185512543, -0.030622471123933792, -0.01616032049059868, -0.009207094088196754, 0.010267733596265316, -0.0003188260307069868, -0.001819535973481834, 0.048119839280843735, 0.037066150456666946, 0.02987055480480194, 0.003889376763254404, -0.03939808905124664, 0.016932135447859764, -0.05359920114278793, 0.025056611746549606, -0.03192044422030449, 0.028766432777047157, 0.0025341534055769444, 0.0767553374171257, 0.01825704053044319, -0.014087007381021976, 0.017339464277029037, -0.01446516253054142, -0.053729936480522156, 0.05037061497569084, -0.015063248574733734, -0.02315404824912548, 0.004051536321640015, 0.00026633177185431123, 0.02226146124303341, -0.03272915631532669, 0.01100878231227398, 0.013516256585717201, 0.026627125218510628, 0.0022230222821235657, -0.002183561911806464, 0.008579535409808159, -0.010986967012286186, -0.023712458088994026, 0.032404541969299316, 0.02029004879295826, -0.002315448597073555, 0.01785500906407833, 0.013313564471900463, -0.009006621316075325, -0.02865530550479889, -0.0233335942029953, 0.005524037405848503, 0.039708320051431656, 0.05043220892548561, 0.0015639564953744411, 0.02004670351743698, -0.02925950102508068, 0.034198444336652756, -0.004789058119058609, 0.04511381685733795, 0.007050769869238138, 0.03038065694272518, -0.0098922960460186, -0.04178394749760628, -0.03142928332090378, -0.009276162832975388, 0.009391242638230324, 0.00014950305921956897, 0.022386590018868446, 0.017450444400310516, 0.008768027648329735, -0.06650154292583466, 0.007830463349819183, 0.05991588532924652, 0.0020141906570643187, -0.025382108986377716, -0.01838037557899952, -0.007247807923704386, -0.022132059559226036, -0.01179226953536272, 0.016337119042873383, 0.03708978742361069, -0.007732946425676346, -0.018247663974761963, 0.04218230023980141, 0.0322023406624794, -0.014857839792966843, -0.0034628971479833126, -0.006869737058877945, 0.019955849274992943, -0.009494057856500149, -0.033912401646375656, 0.011702099815011024, 0.05792199447751045, 0.042459264397621155, 0.004089555237442255, -0.02249143458902836, -0.09547694772481918, 0.020956553518772125, 0.05079851672053337, 0.037053920328617096, -0.05462544411420822, 0.026278365403413773, 0.016960781067609787, -0.02204526588320732, 0.03947347402572632, -0.04730575159192085, 0.038951605558395386, -0.012960572727024555, 0.016336042433977127, -0.04284561425447464, 0.00873102992773056, -0.05620146915316582, 0.0016702823340892792, -0.002204254502430558, 0.006776430644094944, -0.00383666530251503, -0.01846993900835514, -0.06083802878856659, -0.02495613880455494, 0.04533456638455391, 0.03776785731315613, -0.018607769161462784, 0.004124451894313097, 0.03716396167874336, 0.03395894169807434, -0.04368070885539055, -0.06329295039176941, 0.04309966787695885, -0.00018401748093310744, -0.013899706304073334, 0.039792560040950775, -0.027010438963770866, -0.04705841466784477, 0.012005889788269997, -0.0236790981143713, -0.017166292294859886, -0.01240510307252407, -0.012780241668224335, 0.014146070927381516, 0.00282403826713562, 0.020528025925159454, 0.07065489143133163, 0.03738576918840408, -0.006938702892512083, -0.011092773638665676, -0.0030886272434145212, 0.015470431186258793, -0.029103480279445648, -0.029668504372239113, -0.015591495670378208, -0.018006006255745888, -0.03863643854856491, 0.019960341975092888, 0.016851166263222694, 0.02331315539777279, -0.017943941056728363, -0.03887532651424408, 0.017705651000142097, 0.003650012658908963, 0.021372443065047264, -0.020295793190598488, 0.011722304858267307, -0.014237835071980953, -0.0072065987624228, -0.029369717463850975, 0.012462769635021687, -0.005626720376312733, -0.020270617678761482, -0.027372337877750397, -0.04603966325521469, 0.01349643524736166, -0.06869862973690033, -0.05964948236942291, 0.009658752009272575, -0.03978355973958969, 0.05863633751869202, -0.01988753117620945, 0.020770864561200142, 0.01080280914902687, -0.08135281503200531, -0.027903961017727852, 0.05288451537489891, 0.018116943538188934, 0.038130421191453934, -0.040323346853256226, 0.007715888787060976, -0.030064987018704414, -0.005999194458127022, -0.05798335000872612, -0.04716585576534271, 0.042637862265110016, 0.010191632434725761, -0.003697433741763234, -0.006106502842158079, -0.020679034292697906, -0.017612697556614876, -0.008543767035007477, -0.04739055782556534, 0.02626011334359646, -0.00023298764426726848, -0.00936924759298563, 0.01191031001508236, 0.006959155201911926, 0.07115301489830017, 0.02049448899924755, -0.006706103682518005, -0.027669096365571022, -0.05996117368340492, -0.013216870836913586, 0.016028093174099922, -0.01832103729248047, -0.03416912630200386, -0.014717073179781437, 0.0022633036132901907, 0.025288110598921776, 0.005324416793882847, -0.034948091953992844, -0.0037211545277386904, 0.00658183079212904, 0.030258232727646828, -0.03684298321604729, -0.06764862686395645, 0.04443877190351486, 0.0029452780727297068, 0.011628203094005585, -0.006433446425944567, 0.010128110647201538, -0.05468551442027092, -0.0098875742405653, 0.015249052084982395, -0.004794073756784201, -0.02365654893219471, 0.0010587892029434443, 0.07767406105995178, 0.0016514838207513094, -0.0004683920997194946, 0.022205371409654617, -0.006828621029853821, -0.011906773783266544, 0.028560994192957878, 0.005310100503265858, 0.006143768783658743, 0.028993118554353714, -0.04812348261475563, -0.0025775181129574776, 0.0021439383272081614, -0.029815269634127617, 0.050962552428245544, -0.01428709551692009, 0.08278343081474304, 0.07027311623096466, 0.025040393695235252, -0.0038678995333611965, 0.02271680347621441, -0.0014033508487045765, -0.003689265577122569, 0.02448214963078499, 0.0479443334043026, 0.02079581469297409, 0.008756063878536224, -0.009145422838628292, 0.045072030276060104, 0.00749414786696434, 0.05987768992781639, 0.06296700239181519, 0.04209929332137108, 0.028705451637506485, -0.013979511335492134, -0.04643336310982704, 0.03767884522676468, -0.041140101850032806, 0.025421952828764915, -0.058237746357917786, 0.01039257925003767, 0.05399138107895851, 0.041033416986465454, 0.00004498344787862152, -0.04795429855585098, -0.024175278842449188, -0.054389677941799164, 0.0243374016135931, 0.014818676747381687, -0.023308655247092247, -0.015270576812326908, 0.027099350467324257, 0.046299245208501816, -0.027986502274870872, 0.020161425694823265, -0.019175712019205093, -0.062764011323452, -0.02665288932621479, 0.008941387757658958, -0.027681317180395126, 0.043106433004140854, 0.00625657057389617, -0.047222111374139786, 0.012161921709775925, -0.0029580341652035713, -0.007836798205971718, -0.00999776553362608, 0.019462866708636284, -0.029202327132225037, 0.03738429397344589, -0.00983432587236166, 0.007596317213028669, 0.024697981774806976, 0.0297677181661129, 0.09654375165700912, 0.07072551548480988, 0.03719491511583328, -0.0829111710190773, 0.03744904324412346, -0.039548926055431366, 0.026316620409488678, -0.020198743790388107, 0.028668314218521118, -0.009306629188358784, -0.0017306727822870016, 0.05860503762960434, 0.06024091690778732, 0.0034062485210597515, 0.003630017163231969, 0.07994789630174637, -0.00982600636780262, -0.05128956213593483, -0.007211891934275627, -0.028782524168491364, -0.014511003158986568, -0.028688674792647362, -0.027833351865410805, 0.023387722671031952, -0.02136697620153427, -0.03698596730828285, -0.015109555795788765, -0.05099707096815109, 0.032997433096170425, -0.011888614855706692, 0.005954612046480179, 0.021709945052862167, 0.00784270092844963, 0.011124595999717712, -0.05745694413781166, -0.003943426068872213, 0.028516948223114014, -0.042528145015239716, 0.006774200592190027, 0.009316714480519295, 0.02127315290272236, -0.01909526437520981, 0.009701380506157875, 0.006283579394221306, -0.03909437730908394, -0.03368723392486572, 0.00036679144250229, 0.04859181120991707, 0.02684914320707321, -0.019833188503980637, -0.056926921010017395, 0.017751526087522507, -0.013787721283733845, -0.02694089524447918, -0.017047924920916557, 0.027979236096143723, 0.029000746086239815, -0.05194470286369324, -0.031330276280641556, -0.04510432109236717, 0.00348919746465981, -0.03474070131778717, 0.017656655982136726, 0.02242378517985344, -0.0020759254693984985, -0.0032319489400833845, -0.021130893379449844, 0.0547511950135231, 0.009899713099002838, -0.039722736924886703, -0.023461496457457542, -0.004838382825255394, -0.012035680934786797, 0.029058096930384636, -0.010740093886852264, 0.016979118809103966, 0.009872421622276306, -0.0006812427891418338, -0.014875683933496475, -0.002814822131767869, -0.04071113467216492, 0.021906882524490356, -0.012080973945558071, -0.017367897555232048, -0.06508684158325195, -0.014279899187386036, 0.0457620806992054, 0.057733360677957535, 0.02535722777247429, 0.012659503147006035, 0.006846478208899498, 0.03931478410959244, 0.04855940863490105, -0.055125992745161057, -0.016384679824113846, 0.0016275213565677404, -0.023761620745062828, -0.03288600593805313, -0.022928645834326744, 0.05115272477269173, 0.04023514688014984, 0.0024763953406363726, 0.014300056733191013, -0.004999083466827869, -0.05824459344148636, 0.006980825215578079, 0.017446914687752724, -0.06796872615814209, -0.004091940820217133, -0.012303085066378117, 0.007363945711404085, -0.014507351443171501, -0.06348340958356857, -0.04148457199335098, -0.026125188916921616, -0.015829840674996376, 0.0054013412445783615, -0.005331175867468119, 0.02389373630285263, -0.012488453648984432, 0.014735693112015724, -0.0395234078168869, 0.01804085448384285, -0.047418262809515, -0.03217407315969467, 0.010585566982626915, 0.0071810949593782425, 0.007165250834077597, 0.015227206982672215, 0.009923864156007767, 0.030599333345890045, 0.05520252138376236, 0.023455627262592316, 0.04443419352173805, 0.01849815435707569, 0.010341962799429893, 0.010368124581873417, 0.04357960820198059, -0.009633260779082775, -0.021593287587165833, 0.04855252429842949, -0.07764142006635666, -0.013732493855059147, 0.0002564026799518615, -0.014394943602383137, 0.05050666630268097, 0.014888815581798553, -0.03274446353316307, -0.006306348368525505, 0.05182386934757233, 0.010141419246792793, -0.054605498909950256, -0.014781499281525612, -0.03357575833797455, 0.01381070725619793, 0.02223341353237629, -0.006747044622898102, -0.019071128219366074, -0.03391250967979431, 0.04209347069263458, 0.041995055973529816, 0.028327660635113716, -0.03259995952248573, 0.0029329434037208557, 0.010759237222373486, 0.010314281098544598, 0.004478715360164642, -0.03901968523859978, 0.007467593532055616, 0.06882219761610031, -0.05282127484679222, 0.017582351341843605, -0.05231718719005585, -0.015786901116371155, -0.07518019527196884, 0.005081279668956995, -0.023071791976690292, 0.00793886836618185, 0.034643132239580154, -0.06829550862312317, 0.011351482942700386, 0.041138727217912674, -0.0407252237200737, 0.0032011657021939754, 0.005742386449128389, -0.026927586644887924, -0.030807701870799065, -0.025625208392739296, -0.0021576094441115856, 0.02878209576010704, -0.009220869280397892, 0.026222186163067818, 0.016219135373830795, 0.027002213522791862, -0.011724420823156834, -0.011847460642457008, 0.04496854543685913, 0.03845684602856636, 0.02685173600912094, -0.06786166876554489, 0.005995882675051689, -0.018263984471559525, -0.038158729672431946, 0.02697385661303997, -0.05904863029718399, 0.03205380588769913, 0.02145269699394703, 0.018702806904911995, -0.014146040193736553, 0.048626821488142014, 0.0020259201992303133, 0.0074923038482666016, -0.02326972968876362, 0.015429871156811714, 0.008061950094997883, 0.02428019605576992, -0.0015360360266640782, 0.012382419779896736, 0.0495573952794075, -0.020247386768460274, -0.04201527312397957, 0.02024216763675213, -0.03805316984653473, -0.009100541472434998, 0.0034400385338813066, -0.02450891025364399, 0.03335533291101456, -0.004061641171574593, -0.0103193623945117, -0.036643438041210175, 0.00993327610194683, 0.013800228014588356, 0.0038586773443967104, -0.031614623963832855, 0.015096202492713928, -0.022189997136592865, -0.010639255866408348, 0.025481943041086197, -0.005300384480506182, -0.009993387386202812, -0.06234675645828247, -0.017419787123799324, -0.015119856223464012, -0.0018827201565727592, -0.007399870082736015, -0.023496851325035095, 0.01991421729326248, 0.030474025756120682, -0.009669781662523746, -0.013826090842485428, 0.01846723072230816, -0.02266935631632805, -0.0008175289258360863, -0.061521753668785095, 0.07356077432632446, -0.000513677834533155, -0.03883565217256546, -0.03380714729428291, 0.0016357997665181756, -0.03677951917052269, 0.00011678565351758152, 0.05304967239499092, -0.004858011845499277, -0.022426599636673927, -0.015713214874267578, 0.01646525412797928, -0.00854073092341423, -0.07026112079620361, 0.052603475749492645, -0.015452650375664234, -0.026736142113804817, 0.013023970648646355, -0.018971117213368416, 0.013520946726202965, 0.015417875722050667, -0.0018453496741130948, -0.013868926092982292, 0.010288082994520664, -0.023561714217066765, -0.02397652342915535, 0.018756479024887085, -0.006963143590837717, -0.021088669076561928, 0.04691692069172859, -0.009767002426087856, -0.006572403479367495, 0.028564291074872017, -0.005323272664099932, -0.04159640893340111, 0.03928937017917633, -0.055556029081344604, 0.0023876852355897427, -0.006239383015781641, 0.02648632600903511, 0.007640152238309383, -0.06574320793151855, 0.0022207791917026043, 0.0011392321903258562, -0.03769603371620178, -0.011878116056323051, 0.016987260431051254, 0.04873492196202278, -0.004985589534044266, -0.03367217257618904, 0.024292564019560814, -0.026838133111596107, 0.01018131896853447, 0.007981841452419758, 0.04054068401455879, 0.013233551755547523, -0.009534618817269802, 0.0173715278506279, 0.042998626828193665, -0.006149613298475742, 0.025073597207665443, 0.001978846499696374, 0.010360567830502987, -0.0016378932632505894, 0.009508967399597168, 0.007754394318908453, -0.03839900344610214, 0.006399720441550016, 0.0034922852646559477, -0.013436426408588886, 0.05188838765025139, -0.05899253115057945, 0.006353724282234907, -0.0163127314299345, 0.008331112563610077, -0.024129843339323997, -0.010356629267334938, 0.052705585956573486, 0.045351091772317886, -0.001476330915465951, -0.004183583427220583, 0.02495482750236988, -0.011630755849182606, 0.011832415126264095, -0.01938849687576294, 0.04790245369076729, -0.015086271800100803, -0.010381956584751606, -0.041344765573740005, 0.016148174181580544, -0.029408959671854973, -0.028724968433380127, 0.03358510881662369, 0.005570536945015192, 0.0089447982609272, -0.016662849113345146, -0.021006427705287933, 0.005761379841715097, 0.06627614051103592, -0.06046299636363983, -0.03525836020708084, -0.036659419536590576, 0.033853329718112946, -0.038288772106170654, 0.0034116420429199934 ]
<p>Looking at the Heritage Health Prize, the data is structured as follows:</p> <blockquote> <p>Each of the Data Sets will be comprised of tables as follows:</p> </blockquote> <pre><code>a. Members Table, which will include: i. MemberID (a unique member ID) ii. AgeAtFirstClaim (member's age when first claim was made in the Data Set period) iii. Sex b. Claims Table, which will include: i. MemberID ii. ProviderID (the ID of the doctor or specialist providing the service) iii. Vendor (the company that issues the bill) iv. PCP (member's primary care physician) v. Year (the year of the claim, Y1, Y2, Y3) vi. Specialty vii. PlaceSvc (place where the member was treated) viii. PayDelay (the delay between the claim and the day the claim was paid for) ix. LengthOfStay x. DSFS (days since first service that year) xi. PrimaryConditionGroup (a generalization of the primary diagnosis codes) xii. CharlsonIndex (a generalization of the diagnosis codes in the form of a categorized comorbidity score) xiii. ProcedureGroup (a generalization of the CPT code or treatment code) xiv. SupLOS (a flag that indicates if LengthOfStay is null because it has been suppressed) c. Labs Table, which will contain certain details of lab tests provided to members. d. RX Table, which will contain certain details of prescriptions filled by members. e. DaysInHospital Tables - Y2 and Y3, which will contain the number of days of hospitalization for each eligible member during Y2 and Y3 and will include: i. MemberID; ii. ClaimsTruncated (a flag for members who have had claims suppressed. If the flag is 1 for member xxx in DaysInHospital_Y2, some claims for member xxx will have been suppressed in Y1). iii. DaysInHospital (the number of days in hospital Y2 or Y3, as applicable). These two Tables are intended for use by Entrants to train and validate their algorithms. DaysInHospital Tables are based on the Claims Table with admissions in Y2 or Y3, as applicable. As a privacy measure, any member who spent more than two weeks in hospital is grouped; they are treated as though they spent 15 days in hospital. f. Target - is "DaysInHospital_Y4" but doesn't include DaysInHospital. DaysInHospital data for Y4 are to be filled in by Entrants to produce entries. Seem SampleEntry.csv as an example. </code></pre> <p>So the goal is to predict the values in table f.</p> <p>Clearly the first thing to do is to do a JOIN across the tables using member IDs. </p> <p>Some of these appear to be standard discrete variables (age, sex etc) but others are much more tricky to deal with. For example, the labs index and RX index point to other tables. Also, there are many categorical types. Some of the categorical types (such as PrimaryConditionGroup) have many possible values. Normally for categorical data, these can be made into features using a binary flag for each category (simply using the index will fail as there is no ordering). However when there are many thousands of these this seems like an inefficient approach. Are there any better ways to deal with the mixture of numerical and categorical data such as this?</p>
47,432
[ -0.007794516626745462, -0.03265639394521713, -0.009602263569831848, 0.010519638657569885, 0.060176584869623184, 0.0063419402576982975, -0.03129872679710388, 0.005432670935988426, 0.04291599616408348, -0.01699189282953739, 0.09408687055110931, 0.003395872889086604, 0.01860446110367775, 0.024767247959971428, 0.026057975366711617, 0.00021984369959682226, -0.003741151187568903, 0.025117788463830948, 0.0014424130786210299, -0.02887841872870922, 0.03660567104816437, -0.008003373630344868, -0.03735988587141037, -0.010255438275635242, -0.03425788879394531, 0.030888251960277557, 0.0010485931998118758, -0.03716938942670822, -0.02851015515625477, 0.04803163558244705, -0.08466464281082153, -0.04893086850643158, -0.018700435757637024, -0.029774518683552742, 0.02131350338459015, 0.018318483605980873, -0.05455780774354935, -0.03640010952949524, 0.011039185337722301, 0.02517547830939293, -0.003217756748199463, -0.0069761499762535095, 0.011758110485970974, 0.03749573230743408, -0.0012990199029445648, 0.03783535212278366, 0.010883761569857597, 0.031825534999370575, 0.006696899887174368, -0.04312977194786072, 0.02680874802172184, -0.009858828969299793, 0.08111809194087982, -0.021152082830667496, -0.029141195118427277, 0.0126347616314888, -0.0048238784074783325, 0.0624808743596077, 0.010226367972791195, -0.04184284806251526, -0.014036768116056919, 0.016246462240815163, 0.015317711047828197, -0.04058506712317467, -0.04767930507659912, 0.014244967140257359, 0.0067406948655843735, -0.01650133915245533, 0.008106223307549953, -0.018432844430208206, 0.024740196764469147, 0.006940098013728857, -0.018705571070313454, -0.03246515616774559, 0.06405388563871384, 0.004803764168173075, -0.0529194213449955, -0.03673218935728073, -0.011466434225440025, -0.01110946387052536, 0.008663340471684933, -0.00791709590703249, -0.023361075669527054, 0.023224852979183197, 0.005593438632786274, 0.017586683854460716, 0.04675067216157913, -0.018215108662843704, 0.027432186529040337, 0.010266367346048355, 0.007150939200073481, 0.004535304382443428, 0.032276451587677, 0.017725834622979164, -0.01815943978726864, 0.026156896725296974, -0.04023881256580353, 0.020582417026162148, 0.005137945991009474, 0.011907411739230156, -0.012690521776676178, -0.07518709450960159, -0.006693366914987564, 0.0046013593673706055, -0.0035677591804414988, -0.0046775671653449535, -0.0055548022501170635, -0.06350848823785782, 0.0029915026389062405, 0.004515515174716711, -0.019830819219350815, -0.006060909945517778, -0.022411713376641273, -0.011553150601685047, -0.026850564405322075, -0.038776248693466187, -0.023629290983080864, -0.0061822328716516495, 0.022542787715792656, 0.024621667340397835, 0.07579006999731064, 0.030922729521989822, 0.005378391593694687, -0.035590726882219315, -0.06969650089740753, 0.007865744642913342, -0.020219942554831505, 0.005827076267451048, -0.03203476592898369, 0.03399408236145973, -0.020906267687678337, -0.014472927898168564, 0.05608217790722847, -0.023343438282608986, 0.02285129576921463, -0.007445531897246838, -0.09951529651880264, -0.03906114771962166, 0.0018590498948469758, 0.05248529464006424, 0.0042836326174438, -0.011629895307123661, -0.0008030143799260259, 0.011706355027854443, 0.05049040541052818, -0.007025741506367922, 0.03992333263158798, 0.035646047443151474, 0.02668214775621891, 0.013709880411624908, 0.022773997858166695, -0.011300290003418922, -0.014516960829496384, -0.002697249874472618, -0.05010216683149338, -0.07011426985263824, -0.0235001128166914, 0.003864334197714925, -0.04052272066473961, -0.010620894841849804, 0.011518995277583599, -0.01052131038159132, 0.029261326417326927, -0.008889367803931236, -0.045940954238176346, -0.016413109377026558, 0.0804157555103302, 0.02795512229204178, 0.011284610256552696, 0.05064884200692177, -0.004498904570937157, 0.06456390023231506, 0.018034368753433228, 0.03138691931962967, 0.013755187392234802, -0.01712007075548172, 0.0017641304293647408, -0.003707131603732705, 0.0036356484051793814, -0.006123005878180265, -0.01281777210533619, -0.0225538183003664, -0.014918371103703976, -0.016410501673817635, 0.05313684046268463, -0.013277976773679256, 0.017740018665790558, 0.007586678955703974, 0.03795422986149788, -0.003279647324234247, -0.053021177649497986, -0.03149832412600517, -0.012010365724563599, -0.011290379799902439, -0.046742938458919525, -0.009560435079038143, -0.0368802584707737, -0.0004602499830070883, 0.03105025924742222, -0.008120673708617687, -0.0006097322911955416, 0.027780681848526, 0.0732453465461731, -0.010019510984420776, -0.013587269932031631, 0.042570970952510834, 0.03452025726437569, -0.02156684175133705, 0.02427760511636734, -0.016462530940771103, -0.03348630294203758, 0.008268981240689754, -0.023912886157631874, 0.030921870842576027, -0.04281516373157501, 0.01983828656375408, 0.017998140305280685, 0.0050028725527226925, 0.02576347254216671, 0.007145770825445652, -0.059893541038036346, 0.04489519074559212, 0.0776355043053627, 0.024698417633771896, 0.006834958679974079, -0.029609471559524536, -0.021141882985830307, 0.01723984070122242, -0.02853112481534481, 0.009267752058804035, -0.057791825383901596, -0.02051045000553131, 0.00469385739415884, 0.006063857581466436, -0.0007619041716679931, -0.014908244833350182, 0.06830553710460663, -0.0010781895834952593, 0.02333025075495243, -0.023107163608074188, 0.024239959195256233, 0.009680524468421936, 0.04231096804141998, 0.030072558671236038, 0.022507963702082634, 0.004692617803812027, 0.01942765712738037, 0.014133799821138382, 0.004016392398625612, 0.01644238270819187, 0.018987512215971947, 0.06007825583219528, 0.013066931627690792, 0.015718000009655952, -0.031826652586460114, -0.06438431143760681, 0.042191583663225174, 0.012366299517452717, 0.029084322974085808, 0.011861365288496017, -0.023677978664636612, -0.02794831618666649, -0.0011195145780220628, -0.02574087120592594, -0.010623208247125149, 0.021585948765277863, -0.016462406143546104, 0.006195393390953541, 0.027321284636855125, -0.04096120595932007, 0.03135606646537781, -0.019934510812163353, -0.041597746312618256, -0.0298980250954628, -0.00035694887628778815, 0.028886400163173676, 0.008853251114487648, 0.021700004115700722, -0.01861441694200039, -0.026580708101391792, 0.012391132302582264, -0.0016347226919606328, 0.018707722425460815, -0.010427151806652546, -0.10649436712265015, -0.03556596487760544, -0.03379902243614197, 0.015014984644949436, 0.0638212263584137, -0.026093153282999992, -0.05489759519696236, 0.04138799011707306, 0.0004520563525147736, -0.04168428108096123, -0.007475390564650297, -0.01738375425338745, 0.017626777291297913, -0.03133627772331238, 0.011536548845469952, 0.02502620778977871, 0.047421280294656754, -0.06128991022706032, 0.00038184598088264465, -0.03866957128047943, -0.002701164921745658, 0.0034203322138637304, -0.01694636046886444, -0.011005393229424953, 0.011120970360934734, 0.019397255033254623, -0.00338393310084939, 0.0017616439145058393, 0.002227883320301771, -0.0503467321395874, -0.06655152142047882, 0.04279183968901634, -0.05085902661085129, -0.015982041135430336, -0.002466378500685096, 0.0036016618832945824, 0.02593381144106388, 0.038365088403224945, -0.03860469162464142, -0.00773897860199213, -0.00945398211479187, 0.014792189002037048, -0.05062785744667053, 0.03952651470899582, 0.024292776361107826, -0.00626772828400135, -0.03214981406927109, 0.009365691803395748, -0.0011553122894838452, 0.06696726381778717, -0.019577236846089363, -0.013258804567158222, 0.008088914677500725, 0.02242603525519371, 0.002424140926450491, 0.08223990350961685, 0.014357867650687695, 0.0000939063320402056, 0.008955367840826511, 0.00126378214918077, 0.025251993909478188, -0.029163602739572525, -0.04566190019249916, -0.009739795699715614, -0.003254324197769165, 0.03480815142393112, 0.004450616426765919, 0.010632998310029507, -0.014133177697658539, -0.0400112085044384, -0.03011399321258068, 0.020546479150652885, 0.0016507896361872554, -0.01769600622355938, 0.008145120926201344, 0.023964636027812958, 0.03039272502064705, 0.007258927915245295, 0.011406213976442814, -0.02925439365208149, -0.03751131892204285, 0.037492331117391586, -0.04531813785433769, -0.007586287334561348, -0.007483706809580326, 0.06061597540974617, 0.0004887969116680324, 0.035572998225688934, 0.005030684173107147, -0.01513177715241909, -0.061521176248788834, -0.015849202871322632, -0.016533659771084785, 0.09249760955572128, 0.005732368212193251, 0.04111453518271446, 0.001579238218255341, -0.05057382583618164, -0.017361655831336975, 0.021406561136245728, -0.02199435606598854, 0.01841975748538971, 0.010298852808773518, 0.014653516001999378, 0.026456868276000023, -0.043779026716947556, 0.03555048629641533, 0.01039525493979454, -0.000036442499549593776, 0.017164260149002075, 0.024234063923358917, -0.047798432409763336, 0.025532618165016174, 0.04270835965871811, 0.005637879483401775, 0.001954371575266123, 0.013345514424145222, 0.036714840680360794, 0.03364362195134163, 0.01590387150645256, 0.020829759538173676, 0.026796244084835052, -0.007968373596668243, -0.0007565871346741915, 0.0356740839779377, 0.019505124539136887, 0.028521019965410233, 0.007729746866971254, 0.010057020001113415, -0.0029246709309518337, -0.015121920965611935, 0.013545781373977661, 0.0021861663553863764, 0.020254414528608322, 0.03217010200023651, 0.005887509323656559, -0.05583614110946655, 0.006012253928929567, 0.0287807397544384, 0.0052157300524413586, 0.03824857994914055, -0.006216116715222597, 0.02651267871260643, 0.0260259211063385, -0.07227159291505814, -0.017505057156085968, 0.04667435586452484, 0.0402100645005703, -0.03178024664521217, -0.006334627512842417, -0.002868690760806203, 0.016852788627147675, -0.006111025344580412, 0.00577180739492178, 0.023825164884328842, -0.018523290753364563, 0.006562676280736923, 0.010556889697909355, -0.01898328773677349, -0.0493335984647274, 0.011473560705780983, -0.002672402421012521, 0.042958151549100876, -0.004437024239450693, 0.0021137292496860027, 0.05646102502942085, 0.02264917455613613, 0.017670854926109314, 0.019335512071847916, 0.009497424587607384, -0.10360389947891235, -0.0021549176890403032, 0.01435328833758831, 0.08023729175329208, -0.012464629486203194, -0.04404333233833313, -0.06330054998397827, -0.008572205901145935, 0.027735263109207153, 0.012964933179318905, 0.008087251335382462, -0.04195976257324219, -0.00801747478544712, -0.02074013091623783, -0.02660352922976017, -0.043155767023563385, -0.022623926401138306, 0.007230797782540321, 0.029229965060949326, -0.0008114872616715729, 0.020011531189084053, -0.012208172120153904, -0.0005534521187655628, -0.012109613977372646, 0.009975801222026348, -0.07263996452093124, -0.015760624781250954, 0.005173562094569206, 0.00992207508534193, -0.012466492131352425, -0.048375390470027924, 0.0015694164903834462, -0.027766387909650803, 0.015800239518284798, 0.09913951903581619, -0.013587424531579018, -0.016756480559706688, 0.0009573079296387732, 0.04291142523288727, -0.026111649349331856, 0.021289851516485214, -0.026011081412434578, 0.07672146707773209, 0.013400972820818424, 0.035549506545066833, 0.07496882975101471, 0.05505234748125076, -0.0013523278757929802, 0.020143702626228333, -0.039040520787239075, -0.013763243332505226, -0.003350537735968828, -0.0038470320869237185, -0.02555087022483349, -0.005727079231292009, -0.01993057318031788, 0.005313558969646692, 0.008152158930897713, 0.0002580083964858204, -0.031941499561071396, 0.026411274448037148, 0.010794789530336857, 0.02433912642300129, -0.031211083754897118, -0.04751322790980339, 0.004916616249829531, 0.016185319051146507, 0.03229273483157158, 0.012414689175784588, 0.0715218037366867, -0.037150751799345016, -0.000060182650486240163, -0.01607530005276203, -0.01757761836051941, 0.031769752502441406, -0.02642088755965233, -0.011432443745434284, -0.0005478423554450274, -0.01872417703270912, -0.012809441424906254, 0.02888280153274536, 0.043501511216163635, -0.006042187567800283, -0.02729901671409607, -0.0026204159948974848, -0.03130835294723511, -0.042326729744672775, -0.03864853456616402, 0.016232652589678764, 0.028741121292114258, 0.015445912256836891, -0.07062849402427673, -0.06867958605289459, 0.041684217751026154, 0.018321124836802483, 0.059495631605386734, -0.041695959866046906, -0.011600161902606487, 0.025633767247200012, -0.017236851155757904, -0.011006275191903114, 0.003404980758205056, 0.03749494627118111, -0.02104116417467594, 0.0003607819089666009, 0.02295793779194355, -0.00039649245445616543, 0.06818614900112152, 0.01770707033574581, 0.05062354356050491, -0.013940268196165562, -0.016150960698723793, 0.0018294791225343943, -0.05083969980478287, -0.0733562707901001, -0.016506101936101913, -0.024096781387925148, -0.0685952827334404, -0.013622197322547436, 0.01572238840162754, -0.007979226298630238, -0.03621780499815941, -0.05266370251774788, -0.03364570438861847, -0.014447380788624287, -0.04162721335887909, -0.007701363880187273, -0.03807424008846283, -0.002759639173746109, -0.022118395194411278, 0.029805995523929596, -0.006601979024708271, 0.0011743861250579357, -0.01566045917570591, -0.002080342499539256, -0.002340399893000722, 0.007685460150241852, 0.02479393407702446, -0.060429755598306656, 0.0029648214112967253, 0.0027671337593346834, 0.00026050390442833304, 0.033736150711774826, 0.008378485217690468, -0.024990450590848923, -0.0014006310375407338, 0.014740350656211376, -0.03985210135579109, -0.006310868542641401, -0.055347517132759094, 0.01954888552427292, 0.032589055597782135, 0.03216824308037758, -0.00887660589069128, 0.036599814891815186, -0.041838064789772034, 0.013952227309346199, -0.030479297041893005, 0.002755073131993413, 0.044200826436281204, 0.014868944883346558, 0.051201239228248596, -0.0062196445651352406, -0.028602035716176033, 0.0495484434068203, -0.02195417694747448, 0.043520860373973846, -0.001591088017448783, 0.008354526944458485, -0.010289359837770462, -0.021633323282003403, -0.06842386722564697, 0.012844880111515522, 0.024468837305903435, -0.022486872971057892, -0.01815398782491684, -0.016777025535702705, -0.03182324394583702, 0.005762078333646059, 0.028204239904880524, 0.006432776339352131, -0.020551342517137527, -0.053260430693626404, -0.0548141747713089, 0.023085374385118484, 0.024559902027249336, -0.007053412962704897, 0.016353048384189606, 0.02441393956542015, -0.013450941070914268, 0.01173343788832426, 0.047557078301906586, -0.028256479650735855, -0.04525214806199074, -0.021829506382346153, 0.02914511412382126, -0.0543714202940464, 0.06902919709682465, 0.016727222129702568, 0.0244914423674345, 0.04305648431181908, -0.010860560461878777, 0.017222993075847626, 0.007371576502919197, 0.026199238374829292, -0.006857213098555803, 0.05890047177672386, 0.022849077358841896, 0.010417609475553036, -0.0022600458469241858, 0.0014400933869183064, 0.18247070908546448, 0.10454636067152023, 0.04309709742665291, -0.05948492884635925, 0.01986423321068287, 0.052845656871795654, 0.014545442536473274, -0.011469260789453983, 0.0025004763156175613, 0.03692253679037094, -0.04486791044473648, 0.07821357995271683, 0.020933452993631363, 0.032102469354867935, 0.01167290285229683, 0.024738319218158722, 0.00969264842569828, 0.019906800240278244, 0.01828145980834961, 0.021095113828778267, 0.01219177432358265, 0.020274801179766655, -0.04481036961078644, -0.004011534154415131, 0.07446381449699402, -0.04756093770265579, 0.012668423354625702, -0.014332836493849754, 0.007504193112254143, 0.044528111815452576, -0.01015908271074295, 0.016434278339147568, -0.010084708221256733, -0.0007683433941565454, 0.030132770538330078, -0.023923490196466446, -0.006124066188931465, -0.02460288442671299, 0.020995207130908966, 0.018368514254689217, 0.00034532943391241133, 0.0023649216163903475, -0.04056919738650322, 0.05140586942434311, -0.03825293108820915, 0.00035159196704626083, -0.023376794531941414, -0.017726529389619827, -0.041310638189315796, -0.03645767271518707, -0.022431403398513794, -0.0311210248619318, 0.011241316795349121, -0.047947004437446594, -0.01271389052271843, 0.005880377255380154, -0.017630716785788536, -0.05076957866549492, -0.02411487326025963, -0.008736365474760532, 0.04314005747437477, -0.0032519048545509577, 0.004708569496870041, 0.019124047830700874, -0.035169050097465515, -0.031271085143089294, -0.04761626198887825, 0.00577075919136405, -0.033286288380622864, 0.01627354323863983, -0.009142126888036728, -0.024241605773568153, -0.024357741698622704, -0.01987590081989765, 0.009292795322835445, 0.010398500598967075, 0.0023075344506651163, 0.02909894473850727, 0.00692360382527113, -0.03823712840676308, 0.005643161945044994, -0.0029055671766400337, -0.019476143643260002, 0.0024817802477627993, -0.06932944804430008, -0.0069414409808814526, 0.013289050199091434, 0.019899459555745125, 0.015277638100087643, 0.003881291951984167, 0.03249966353178024, 0.06081900745630264, -0.022483494132757187, -0.04212656617164612, -0.005029353778809309, -0.007596959825605154, -0.051592592149972916, -0.0037108517717570066, -0.006569977384060621, 0.0685768648982048, 0.022874636575579643, 0.011470649391412735, -0.018347863107919693, 0.02716667763888836, -0.0022954950109124184, 0.02398073486983776, -0.0061538442969322205, -0.08165208250284195, -0.016440972685813904, -0.026067184284329414, 0.027130506932735443, -0.03572605550289154, 0.01601836085319519, -0.061045948415994644, -0.03930168226361275, 0.013009602203965187, 0.023507010191679, -0.05188335105776787, 0.0048199864104390144, -0.014996710233390331, 0.010092572309076786, 0.008153559640049934, 0.024626880884170532, -0.006337540224194527, -0.03090604580938816, -0.021117981523275375, -0.047921039164066315, 0.015691444277763367, -0.0023403039667755365, -0.01257872860878706, 0.00039253925206139684, -0.014640692621469498, 0.006036406382918358, -0.012243685312569141, 0.004070854280143976, 0.0066785006783902645, 0.039071109145879745, 0.031091030687093735, 0.01209611538797617, 0.021183909848332405, -0.008096341043710709, -0.047926850616931915, 0.00006929919618414715, 0.01539125107228756, -0.011178575456142426, 0.029461145401000977, 0.0116350669413805, 0.0067163803614676, -0.006158765405416489, 0.043176066130399704, -0.022303812205791473, -0.04008500277996063, -0.0016520562348887324, -0.010451185517013073, 0.050479352474212646, -0.010933874174952507, 0.010741929523646832, 0.04448956996202469, -0.02550596371293068, -0.0015037273988127708, 0.026047686114907265, 0.013510380871593952, -0.03270110487937927, -0.0022421616595238447, 0.007508245762437582, 0.02960227057337761, 0.026712503284215927, 0.013673903420567513, 0.0069269356317818165, 0.016906242817640305, 0.005613397806882858, 0.019693944603204727, -0.023211561143398285, 0.007837019860744476, -0.07819271087646484, -0.03002818115055561, 0.016833791509270668, 0.01714351400732994, 0.01632310263812542, -0.02414874918758869, 0.013060853816568851, 0.02868986502289772, -0.03743835538625717, 0.05354957655072212, -0.011289363726973534, 0.03332773968577385, -0.04526280611753464, 0.051117248833179474, -0.02307472564280033, -0.000005066714038548525, 0.0382804200053215, -0.010074316523969173, 0.036803457885980606, 0.02040030248463154, 0.008430086076259613, -0.03953593969345093, -0.03001166321337223, 0.00571634853258729, -0.015677902847528458, -0.08191130310297012, 0.043218910694122314, -0.06212113797664642, -0.009644323959946632, 0.0018602408235892653, -0.03459824249148369, 0.03553229197859764, 0.009872667491436005, -0.007100203074514866, 0.016053466126322746, 0.008088846690952778, 0.04727180674672127, 0.009375165216624737, 0.007502269931137562, -0.03644682466983795, -0.008657703176140785, 0.02405371516942978, 0.0488472618162632, 0.0323927141726017, 0.05437685176730156, 0.026099102571606636, -0.03819004073739052, 0.05483723431825638, 0.003541230456903577, -0.009833667427301407, -0.0180076751857996, -0.030394628643989563, 0.04666152596473694, -0.029687432572245598, 0.01701914519071579, -0.025365887209773064, 0.0066123418509960175, 0.05575044825673103, 0.019109081476926804, 0.014973283745348454, 0.00638102600350976, -0.006690280046314001, -0.04071155562996864, 0.034827638417482376, 0.018420569598674774, -0.03714877739548683, -0.014979435130953789, 0.03814982995390892, -0.03198419138789177, -0.016407638788223267, -0.005637646187096834, 0.03739944100379944, 0.011040211655199528, 0.01818884164094925, -0.019269263371825218, -0.02291502244770527, 0.03695239499211311, -0.0009772350313141942, 0.040719788521528244, -0.09324130415916443, 0.04893307760357857, 0.008365276269614697, -0.019481102004647255, -0.04674508050084114, -0.03722511976957321, -0.024836312979459763, 0.02320133149623871, 0.05323997139930725, 0.008698069490492344, -0.048378732055425644, -0.04044545814394951, 0.003165852278470993, -0.020307103171944618, -0.0018323849653825164, 0.045153502374887466, 0.02477847784757614, 0.025827843695878983, -0.02796206809580326, 0.025217117741703987, 0.03007221408188343, 0.00483060535043478, 0.010859224013984203, -0.019792959094047546, -0.025396481156349182, 0.023405497893691063, -0.03415515646338463, -0.04985174536705017, -0.0028388022910803556, -0.01053556427359581, 0.039967551827430725, 0.017766378819942474, -0.016271116212010384, 0.059802934527397156, 0.0012187976390123367, -0.033834051340818405, 0.0003046777273993939, -0.034428391605615616, -0.025824306532740593, 0.014156393706798553, 0.024505313485860825, -0.0033385695423930883, -0.06121682748198509, -0.0025529356207698584, 0.050702691078186035, -0.006398605182766914, -0.041484683752059937, 0.05332264304161072, 0.01656786911189556, 0.03447004780173302, -0.003590792417526245, 0.02190953865647316, -0.0345718115568161, -0.037881914526224136, 0.024832459166646004, 0.011621329933404922, 0.02735433354973793, 0.04201929271221161, 0.01709580421447754, 0.039949312806129456, -0.02375742979347706, 0.027014760300517082, 0.04190986976027489, 0.04755762219429016, 0.012842550873756409, 0.008831965737044811, 0.009659667499363422, -0.009946003556251526, 0.0192028246819973, 0.03611615672707558, -0.008630787022411823, 0.030350491404533386, -0.020129289478063583, 0.035725582391023636, -0.07935245335102081, 0.004963812418282032, -0.005854637362062931, 0.01732824742794037, 0.012793900445103645, 0.030795913189649582, -0.024249367415905, -0.011890416033565998, 0.015454690903425217, -0.0018952378304675221, -0.024429241195321083, -0.017257342115044594, 0.02365114912390709, 0.017871001735329628, -0.002699508797377348, 0.02102482318878174, -0.03247853368520737, 0.010145838372409344, -0.0011863968102261424, -0.022701391950249672, 0.03692159801721573, 0.03687462583184242, -0.03087395243346691, -0.00440021138638258, -0.02546287141740322, 0.034365635365247726, -0.04978081211447716, 0.004826426040381193, -0.022173315286636353, 0.003164447145536542, -0.011822863481938839, -0.007798648439347744 ]
<p>I know <code>glmnet(x,y)</code> generates $\lambda$ but I am very curious to know the actual formula that is behind this, generating $\lambda$. </p>
35,994
[ -0.04420853778719902, 0.015405306592583656, 0.019549967721104622, -0.025071116164326668, 0.0060854097828269005, -0.004849437158554792, -0.05360028147697449, -0.027901174500584602, 0.04642069712281227, -0.029351817443966866, 0.036042530089616776, 0.04970521107316017, 0.06234360486268997, 0.0168606024235487, 0.02872862108051777, 0.045875195413827896, -0.018757570534944534, 0.03723002225160599, 0.011578104458749294, -0.04244592413306236, 0.013910331763327122, 0.027898689731955528, -0.024398066103458405, -0.014239278621971607, -0.028906820341944695, 0.06350263208150864, 0.01083036046475172, -0.007911985740065575, 0.004616788122802973, 0.07050810009241104, -0.03291580453515053, -0.030899321660399437, 0.019428083673119545, 0.05234324559569359, -0.0021068025380373, 0.027342120185494423, -0.028636926785111427, -0.04957453906536102, -0.008798842318356037, 0.054818831384181976, -0.033106666058301926, -0.03582705184817314, 0.012145797722041607, 0.050772588700056076, -0.018336612731218338, 0.01952957548201084, -0.018518850207328796, -0.032071303576231, 0.03513885661959648, -0.014855063520371914, 0.07663696259260178, 0.016027070581912994, 0.07697664201259613, 0.02101880870759487, -0.008464707061648369, 0.03580537438392639, 0.07362981885671616, 0.03674785792827606, -0.00967326294630766, -0.05278625339269638, -0.013767469674348831, -0.03837579861283302, -0.002326761605218053, -0.025363676249980927, -0.02608337253332138, -0.0030778220389038324, -0.0011818076018244028, -0.024674424901604652, 0.010877737775444984, -0.032352298498153687, 0.019153714179992676, 0.02619546838104725, 0.02541595883667469, -0.025342965498566628, 0.006413089111447334, 0.004475561436265707, 0.03755294531583786, -0.0047058239579200745, 0.0227530337870121, -0.001461709733121097, -0.005908370483666658, 0.03622094541788101, 0.02949405275285244, 0.014600001275539398, 0.0038994925562292337, 0.015608199872076511, 0.07597775757312775, -0.01977410353720188, 0.03820931166410446, 0.023785104975104332, -0.024473553523421288, 0.023099711164832115, 0.01791388913989067, -0.016637876629829407, -0.03104342892765999, 0.06069474667310715, 0.006093435455113649, 0.025197727605700493, 0.025364570319652557, -0.014657163992524147, -0.019945284351706505, -0.0156386811286211, -0.019414709880948067, 0.05815829336643219, -0.028670042753219604, -0.018950367346405983, -0.01769063249230385, -0.0005074820364825428, -0.03874516859650612, -0.025096388533711433, -0.02245110273361206, 0.022546688094735146, 0.010873573832213879, -0.002345120767131448, 0.015782030299305916, -0.0372537262737751, 0.03415925055742264, 0.0012266257544979453, 0.040137242525815964, 0.07410653680562973, 0.036377277225255966, -0.004022875335067511, 0.0440346859395504, -0.012481256388127804, -0.03154993802309036, 0.008776706643402576, 0.008793791756033897, -0.029130563139915466, -0.03287389501929283, 0.0671931803226471, -0.0036592502146959305, -0.06396091729402542, 0.016870945692062378, 0.01629413664340973, 0.008319097571074963, 0.005213720723986626, -0.06349574029445648, -0.054050564765930176, 0.012753506191074848, -0.0511263906955719, 0.03539871424436569, -0.040671415627002716, 0.029077118262648582, 0.024283552542328835, 0.07383977621793747, 0.007251049391925335, 0.04381772130727768, 0.027159996330738068, 0.0017448720755055547, -0.0031666539143770933, -0.0064093382097780704, -0.04322463646531105, -0.014721011742949486, -0.017050260677933693, -0.017211297526955605, -0.05750293284654617, 0.006023434456437826, -0.009601601399481297, -0.018161708489060402, 0.014319908805191517, 0.04944004490971565, 0.013391675427556038, -0.02575712464749813, -0.010308820754289627, 0.02238592319190502, -0.06969751417636871, 0.04689053073525429, 0.017672937363386154, 0.02085248939692974, 0.055193133652210236, -0.053761206567287445, 0.014043429866433144, 0.015012702904641628, 0.05761335417628288, 0.03360205888748169, 0.0050795008428394794, -0.014116921462118626, -0.05239994823932648, 0.02747904509305954, 0.01854037493467331, -0.04199548438191414, -0.005517533980309963, -0.0016251213382929564, -0.005204308778047562, 0.0195931363850832, 0.039021845906972885, -0.014896717853844166, -0.009179392829537392, 0.02038855478167534, -0.030067412182688713, -0.031857047230005264, -0.034813642501831055, 0.00010206156002823263, 0.00390944629907608, -0.0011789771961048245, -0.009521612897515297, 0.019454635679721832, 0.03447481989860535, -0.0012658570194616914, -0.02480355091392994, -0.02797779068350792, 0.010247422382235527, 0.05161159485578537, -0.0037715528160333633, -0.010507673025131226, 0.05068877339363098, 0.0611535981297493, -0.025824541226029396, 0.07215628772974014, -0.021318774670362473, -0.01259772852063179, 0.015695584937930107, -0.00491009745746851, -0.009945176541805267, -0.046433497220277786, -0.036519452929496765, 0.010351233184337616, 0.025341179221868515, -0.0017258787993341684, 0.03595781698822975, -0.07386152446269989, 0.04247789829969406, 0.07156629860401154, 0.0343368798494339, 0.03583264350891113, 0.0202263742685318, -0.025387944653630257, -0.002652627183124423, -0.009160416200757027, -0.027473321184515953, -0.05557241290807724, -0.04800025373697281, 0.041666414588689804, 0.022724473848938942, -0.00531669519841671, 0.023197997361421585, 0.041366659104824066, 0.03403940796852112, 0.028407201170921326, 0.04372661933302879, -0.003240338759496808, 0.025491083040833473, -0.0003573893627617508, 0.029624290764331818, 0.01644405722618103, -0.01534563023597002, -0.003034568391740322, 0.027117546647787094, 0.03471583127975464, 0.008075544610619545, -0.028057007119059563, 0.08726279437541962, -0.005395751446485519, -0.01512148417532444, -0.032050970941782, -0.010742072947323322, 0.03695743530988693, -0.01090787723660469, -0.004472461529076099, 0.04780324921011925, 0.02408399060368538, 0.0005021686665713787, -0.023841993883252144, -0.004959175828844309, 0.029947739094495773, 0.02990904077887535, -0.05505035072565079, 0.012463616207242012, 0.020929280668497086, -0.05077870190143585, 0.05438421294093132, -0.028900299221277237, -0.0372505821287632, -0.05495419353246689, 0.018497833982110023, 0.01886456459760666, -0.002216236898675561, 0.007472815457731485, -0.02936696819961071, -0.06125163286924362, 0.01752031408250332, -0.021152596920728683, 0.028290938585996628, -0.0030852616764605045, -0.03156452625989914, -0.009485915303230286, -0.03718385472893715, -0.03397684916853905, 0.04656817391514778, -0.017025696113705635, -0.010902591980993748, 0.015098252333700657, -0.026444651186466217, -0.039074335247278214, -0.013626528903841972, -0.03590074181556702, 0.022240091115236282, 0.005914435721933842, -0.007415976841002703, 0.004752301145344973, 0.009918373078107834, -0.05790504813194275, 0.009620016440749168, -0.02711358480155468, -0.026985643431544304, -0.04200931638479233, 0.017269818112254143, 0.030157538130879402, -0.01602310501039028, 0.03980458900332451, 0.03713902458548546, -0.025939136743545532, 0.019938208162784576, -0.056821659207344055, -0.03511000797152519, 0.027144791558384895, -0.005046341568231583, 0.02052467316389084, -0.008466747589409351, -0.016062866896390915, 0.08093403279781342, 0.011021539568901062, -0.04150596261024475, -0.03102516382932663, -0.007081868126988411, 0.0331965833902359, -0.04604446142911911, 0.02882673777639866, -0.014049976132810116, 0.025749435648322105, 0.0798109769821167, 0.009199947118759155, 0.03206289932131767, 0.05999547615647316, 0.0036893051583319902, 0.0031759520061314106, 0.02927309460937977, 0.001533525181002915, -0.026790820062160492, 0.04064856097102165, 0.016885342076420784, -0.011779310181736946, 0.02040223963558674, 0.00622708722949028, 0.009534084238111973, -0.01679084822535515, -0.013601788319647312, 0.014637416228652, -0.018364593386650085, 0.0006387677858583629, -0.041359297931194305, 0.028206288814544678, 0.004739654250442982, -0.03356429561972618, -0.02671710029244423, 0.03658948093652725, 0.01746581494808197, -0.034350622445344925, 0.004049047362059355, 0.017846688628196716, 0.010432309471070766, -0.021727273240685463, -0.014772954396903515, -0.013140200637280941, -0.02721635065972805, 0.008987123146653175, -0.01164485327899456, -0.00981154851615429, 0.02686539851129055, 0.04645611718297005, -0.006767283193767071, 0.017371896654367447, -0.01809542253613472, -0.016388092190027237, -0.052392393350601196, 0.0037401365116238594, -0.011946875602006912, 0.04589243233203888, -0.031194599345326424, 0.07521910220384598, 0.007271291688084602, 0.034790217876434326, 0.00995255820453167, -0.03411129117012024, -0.046512000262737274, -0.0001035496752592735, -0.018986664712429047, -0.025387756526470184, 0.002009069314226508, -0.045134201645851135, 0.03988960385322571, -0.016100216656923294, 0.00011419301881687716, -0.013932960107922554, -0.007056572940200567, -0.04078603535890579, 0.02536875009536743, -0.015601696446537971, -0.02437012828886509, -0.0034913828130811453, 0.0030362457036972046, 0.005368120968341827, -0.030053989961743355, 0.0028504403308033943, 0.027724912390112877, 0.01822824403643608, -0.03324112296104431, -0.039685893803834915, -0.008358574472367764, -0.004914966411888599, 0.018977731466293335, 0.029088711366057396, 0.0570388026535511, -0.03671705350279808, 0.02746634930372238, 0.012590821832418442, 0.06718982756137848, 0.05208973586559296, 0.012984556145966053, -0.02034943550825119, -0.04539201408624649, -0.02846403792500496, 0.019026177003979683, 0.021888043731451035, 0.021921072155237198, 0.016664987429976463, 0.061863355338573456, 0.024506041780114174, -0.0602014996111393, 0.01231567095965147, 0.05288957059383392, -0.001132254139520228, -0.02063436433672905, -0.012269973754882812, 0.04087650403380394, -0.01571713574230671, -0.00844937190413475, 0.03616569936275482, -0.0001347560901194811, -0.01096359547227621, 0.0132741155102849, 0.01838841661810875, -0.04585620015859604, 0.007517686579376459, -0.016465846449136734, 0.016527533531188965, 0.04679034277796745, -0.04206414893269539, -0.022128168493509293, -0.035201139748096466, 0.07908635586500168, 0.06503184139728546, 0.03437963128089905, -0.01671428605914116, -0.0556320995092392, 0.0030375923961400986, 0.03131149709224701, 0.014310344122350216, -0.04268001392483711, -0.021234389394521713, -0.05727044865489006, -0.018225006759166718, 0.04366498440504074, -0.01366012915968895, 0.03689936548471451, -0.01789499819278717, -0.012695902027189732, 0.012335654348134995, 0.020156383514404297, -0.05296492576599121, 0.02366987243294716, -0.0050778076983988285, 0.04496113955974579, -0.031266022473573685, -0.01664590835571289, -0.02781704068183899, 0.004024099092930555, -0.005905045662075281, 0.03173849359154701, -0.005171110853552818, -0.027035707607865334, 0.00020178189151920378, 0.030565546825528145, 0.00009561416663927957, -0.03288329020142555, 0.012544061988592148, 0.023666907101869583, 0.010303218849003315, 0.016140222549438477, -0.015974679961800575, -0.018551044166088104, -0.009173767641186714, 0.032419394701719284, 0.009597118943929672, 0.008582988753914833, 0.001904589356854558, 0.03283843398094177, 0.025569695979356766, -0.007117423228919506, 0.07653017342090607, -0.002317343605682254, 0.00110069930087775, -0.005462816916406155, -0.038332249969244, 0.030703576281666756, -0.027249431237578392, -0.04752436280250549, -0.022698212414979935, -0.00653719250112772, -0.03445037081837654, 0.016388870775699615, 0.006764685269445181, 0.02019009180366993, -0.024002568796277046, 0.0062273358926177025, -0.007070120424032211, 0.0394165962934494, 0.016807472333312035, -0.018957313150167465, 0.031965598464012146, 0.03242461755871773, 0.025981076061725616, -0.012922828085720539, 0.009694701991975307, -0.002541328314691782, 0.019133716821670532, -0.00008798607450444251, -0.03118891641497612, 0.004229786340147257, -0.004385942127555609, -0.003996104001998901, 0.04165258631110191, -0.020534342154860497, 0.03130558133125305, 0.006779514253139496, 0.017386946827173233, 0.006666670553386211, -0.09384504705667496, -0.03556385263800621, -0.004319355823099613, -0.0016037042951211333, 0.020718896761536598, -0.01855696178972721, 0.009050233289599419, -0.013994505628943443, 0.005453838501125574, -0.05993875488638878, -0.02559305913746357, 0.01964479498565197, -0.025588523596525192, -0.0038640634156763554, -0.03954943269491196, 0.003216964192688465, -0.02607172541320324, -0.050708040595054626, -0.011448048055171967, 0.07477926462888718, -0.03595252335071564, -0.021302681416273117, -0.03610502555966377, 0.0005342832882888615, 0.05386874079704285, 0.011874023824930191, 0.033883169293403625, -0.00022567501582670957, -0.0321464017033577, -0.005246307235211134, 0.04349328577518463, 0.021012762561440468, -0.01904701068997383, -0.005668290890753269, -0.0364970862865448, -0.002347678877413273, 0.04155205935239792, -0.036971356719732285, 0.013419578783214092, 0.004968791268765926, 0.02837018109858036, -0.008017163723707199, -0.03012862801551819, 0.015545547939836979, -0.028703060001134872, 0.010013499297201633, -0.025156356394290924, -0.037469930946826935, -0.035867881029844284, 0.002395019866526127, 0.07017522305250168, 0.009432840161025524, 0.04290736839175224, -0.004021117929369211, 0.0710771232843399, -0.01050869096070528, 0.0062314546667039394, -0.008504928089678288, -0.022416898980736732, 0.033549532294273376, 0.03732500970363617, 0.005572006106376648, 0.031891968101263046, 0.025755785405635834, -0.038837093859910965, -0.014227821491658688, -0.08261540532112122, 0.020635848864912987, 0.09318236261606216, -0.04009685665369034, 0.06571348011493683, 0.03133969381451607, -0.029224833473563194, -0.004425240680575371, -0.044797491282224655, -0.012620356865227222, 0.01411263644695282, 0.0011521370615810156, 0.0422203429043293, -0.010599574074149132, -0.0018626849632710218, 0.035154789686203, 0.005798466503620148, 0.03814499452710152, 0.012566673569381237, -0.01713540032505989, 0.006595981772989035, 0.009714403189718723, -0.0009611477144062519, -0.04440769925713539, 0.03145202621817589, -0.030612824484705925, 0.011474452912807465, -0.0020308606326580048, -0.021291831508278847, 0.05276016891002655, 0.005886365659534931, -0.0046344478614628315, -0.03227207064628601, -0.01589476689696312, -0.049762558192014694, 0.002259469125419855, 0.015809636563062668, -0.01087392307817936, -0.0028548166155815125, 0.06390197575092316, -0.002592244651168585, -0.010220956057310104, 0.01613471284508705, -0.01861139014363289, -0.06325144320726395, -0.01615418680012226, -0.03867487236857414, -0.036191318184137344, 0.04762345552444458, 0.011318930424749851, -0.06298131495714188, 0.009172759018838406, -0.01623542234301567, -0.0020609444472938776, -0.0075932652689516544, 0.043930865824222565, -0.03221658989787102, 0.10130449384450912, -0.023961341008543968, 0.015860028564929962, -0.01552724838256836, 0.006496680900454521, 0.0962282344698906, 0.08541598916053772, 0.028378872200846672, -0.07784014940261841, 0.0015243787784129381, -0.042985182255506516, -0.040497101843357086, -0.01676217094063759, -0.006437772884964943, 0.01944812200963497, -0.0006834497326053679, 0.048242777585983276, 0.05652959272265434, 0.026444299146533012, 0.006958652753382921, 0.06512665003538132, -0.016342725604772568, -0.007606700994074345, 0.011667566373944283, -0.01787720061838627, 0.001837417483329773, -0.006871067453175783, -0.04664819315075874, 0.0007430873811244965, 0.0008496458176523447, -0.009753141552209854, -0.0293144341558218, -0.019067462533712387, -0.003953160718083382, 0.000655517796985805, -0.02366148680448532, -0.022746974602341652, 0.039057500660419464, 0.003576806280761957, -0.006539924070239067, -0.029193902388215065, 0.025276338681578636, -0.017665276303887367, 0.021548056975007057, 0.028685998171567917, 0.01414560992270708, 0.01813652738928795, -0.021298876032233238, -0.006657707039266825, -0.017415471374988556, -0.034393228590488434, -0.007648441009223461, 0.029435664415359497, -0.020728101953864098, -0.0020038189832121134, -0.016724221408367157, 0.018603192642331123, 0.009421639144420624, -0.02834145538508892, 0.0035606971941888332, -0.0004975597839802504, 0.03489250689744949, -0.02546459063887596, -0.023037413135170937, -0.030048348009586334, 0.005709162447601557, -0.03711322322487831, 0.04476171359419823, 0.01534401997923851, -0.03743045777082443, -0.014475691132247448, -0.018052073195576668, 0.04953563213348389, -0.003509650705382228, 0.004508388694375753, -0.02286679297685623, -0.06810864806175232, -0.0041648889891803265, -0.04286819323897362, 0.038300417363643646, -0.024754244834184647, -0.0057793278247118, -0.01975608989596367, -0.0064123827032744884, 0.003981146030128002, -0.09243656694889069, -0.004229997284710407, -0.028421670198440552, 0.015112952329218388, -0.04677125811576843, -0.0160810686647892, -0.0010631087934598327, 0.051087886095047, 0.013734071515500546, 0.02762434259057045, -0.003842784557491541, 0.015082171186804771, 0.003592969151213765, -0.05595441162586212, -0.0071715302765369415, 0.012555284425616264, -0.015297598205506802, -0.023581385612487793, -0.044125884771347046, 0.03515930846333504, 0.025820903480052948, 0.07365786284208298, -0.009698029607534409, 0.03707101568579674, -0.020756341516971588, 0.015043417923152447, -0.013421477749943733, -0.046266183257102966, 0.015123551711440086, -0.0085103465244174, -0.00828168448060751, -0.05816415697336197, -0.01753247156739235, -0.030393684282898903, -0.02879256010055542, 0.04537041857838631, -0.0011431077728047967, -0.08206705003976822, -0.031659822911024094, 0.006727092433720827, 0.021857187151908875, -0.05439591035246849, -0.016019046306610107, -0.017836472019553185, 0.016459356993436813, 0.0024470058269798756, -0.04099137708544731, -0.01877453923225403, 0.015503938309848309, 0.006479365285485983, -0.0034127531107515097, 0.031008828431367874, -0.006383011117577553, 0.00437738886103034, 0.02396721951663494, 0.0033041152637451887, -0.02027149870991707, 0.024464480578899384, -0.002191228559240699, -0.013960485346615314, 0.03187045827507973, -0.06258951127529144, -0.01205350086092949, -0.00014313109568320215, 0.012180813588202, 0.053376346826553345, 0.025644799694418907, -0.016463056206703186, -0.034883469343185425, 0.011792182922363281, -0.011530301533639431, 0.005401057656854391, -0.0164021123200655, 0.028624705970287323, 0.03211503475904465, -0.0082765594124794, 0.005345551762729883, -0.007806774228811264, -0.006114021874964237, -0.005233087111264467, 0.042650531977415085, -0.024952884763479233, -0.00579879991710186, 0.04270562157034874, -0.006026074755936861, 0.011409127153456211, 0.028629757463932037, 0.01183057390153408, -0.007647830061614513, 0.050454914569854736, -0.03814564272761345, -0.007272298447787762, -0.014575830660760403, 0.003007458057254553, -0.09606324136257172, -0.007921324111521244, 0.015137500129640102, -0.045794423669576645, 0.0497477762401104, -0.06663741916418076, 0.013866687193512917, 0.0027545669581741095, -0.0391179695725441, -0.009875549003481865, 0.021225042641162872, -0.0003659999347291887, -0.03673041984438896, 0.010942766442894936, 0.015918849036097527, 0.048847321420907974, 0.018226629123091698, 0.00815398059785366, 0.055427417159080505, 0.001278431387618184, 0.002031040145084262, -0.0075244600884616375, -0.04258709400892258, -0.0025716072414070368, 0.01580117456614971, -0.04295964911580086, 0.0307267215102911, -0.006086443085223436, -0.0482880137860775, 0.030609726905822754, -0.009630678221583366, -0.0006557851447723806, 0.005818760488182306, 0.03591614216566086, -0.01220135297626257, 0.00624734116718173, 0.03402375802397728, 0.016840705648064613, 0.03267583250999451, 0.027523063123226166, 0.025575246661901474, 0.021761037409305573, -0.005013991147279739, 0.006314616650342941, 0.012651094235479832, -0.033739615231752396, -0.03569309040904045, 0.012486075051128864, 0.005743994377553463, -0.017733365297317505, 0.01968500204384327, -0.0035828854888677597, -0.011583291925489902, -0.05007311701774597, 0.035120341926813126, -0.05399813875555992, -0.030942954123020172, 0.037714336067438126, 0.03429519385099411, -0.02721647173166275, 0.014038779772818089, -0.01695973612368107, -0.03313843533396721, 0.00464673712849617, 0.017349442467093468, 0.00100241310428828, -0.07750128209590912, -0.0036992495879530907, 0.02390380948781967, -0.015901243314146996, 0.023378878831863403, -0.03344784677028656, -0.04748952388763428, 0.03450632840394974, -0.010752887465059757, 0.0232753474265337, 0.025570744648575783, -0.040603283792734146, 0.03804797679185867, -0.03785646706819534, 0.042805761098861694, 0.004775076638907194, 0.013136515393853188, -0.041859403252601624, -0.029617438092827797, 0.011158911511301994, -0.031612470746040344, 0.058703627437353134, 0.0015588938258588314, -0.02495795674622059, -0.02212689071893692, 0.05167704075574875, 0.001363070448860526, -0.03597560524940491, 0.02739463560283184, -0.01372939720749855, -0.01411919854581356, -0.04754796624183655, -0.02131219021975994, 0.010090254247188568, 0.027752073481678963, 0.013148030266165733, 0.016356322914361954, -0.011069810949265957, -0.010059913620352745, -0.0323910266160965, 0.004539552144706249, 0.016345839947462082, 0.003918453119695187, 0.06424485892057419, -0.010952161625027657, -0.014270196668803692, 0.03645802661776543, 0.02912065014243126, -0.08050728589296341, 0.007680020295083523, -0.02939421497285366, -0.023798197507858276, 0.0017867977730929852, 0.032042574137449265, 0.008765594102442265, -0.07240864634513855, -0.021682133898139, 0.03117751143872738, -0.020069925114512444, -0.022203868255019188, 0.05455166473984718, 0.005140815861523151, 0.060392964631319046, -0.038682106882333755, -0.008722176775336266, 0.009196684695780277, 0.025159647688269615, 0.015058750286698341, 0.05337958782911301, 0.012125530280172825, -0.020067984238266945, 0.010807077400386333, 0.0053672329522669315, -0.012081829831004143, 0.08961494266986847, -0.0017184432363137603, 0.054366037249565125, -0.03345942124724388, -0.014055788516998291, -0.01201627217233181, -0.00779507914558053, 0.03413696959614754, 0.0017880197847262025, -0.028408076614141464, 0.09457145631313324, -0.040219053626060486, 0.0214218832552433, -0.011490081436932087, 0.005657578818500042, -0.027782438322901726, -0.01027648150920868, -0.01778315380215645, 0.033317044377326965, 0.014811888337135315, 0.0069273230619728565, 0.006543925032019615, -0.009924393147230148, 0.006424034480005503, -0.0005976834800094366, 0.0020827034022659063, -0.002685021376237273, 0.02287006750702858, -0.0037538716569542885, -0.009096425026655197, -0.0025248907040804625, -0.031958866864442825, 0.06261646747589111, 0.016500892117619514, 0.02436441369354725, -0.026795702055096626, -0.025522364303469658, -0.02734902873635292, 0.029286593198776245, -0.08759506791830063, -0.037097588181495667, -0.029621398076415062, -0.017101289704442024, 0.007602184545248747, -0.04608554765582085 ]
<p>I am trying to approximate a certain factor in my graph. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/mvX9h.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Following Tom Minka's tutorial what I have to do is as follows: $$ \prod_{i=1}^3 q_{w_i}(\pi_2)\approx \int p(\pi_2|w_1)q_{\pi_1}(w_1)\prod_{i=1}^3 q_{D_i}(w_1)\, dw_1\,\, q_{w_2}(\pi_2)q_{w_3}(\pi_2) $$ where $q_x(y)$ is the message that $y$ receives from $x$, $p(\pi_2|w_1)\propto \pi_2 (1-\pi_2)^{{w_1}^2}$ and the messages $q_{w_i}(\pi_2)$ are all also beta distributed and finally, $q_x(w_1)$ are all gaussians.</p> <p>My question is with the right hand side of the approximation can I do the following:</p> <p>$$ RHS \propto \int \pi(1-\pi)^{{w_1}^2}\exp\left(-\frac{1}{2\sigma^2}(w_1-\mu)^2\right)\times C_1\, dw_1\,\, C_2 \pi^{\alpha_0-1}(1-\pi)^{\beta_0-1} $$ where I've let $\pi\equiv \pi_2$, $C_1,C_2$ are constants that do not depend on $\pi$ and $\alpha_0, \beta_0$ is obtained by combining the messages from $q_{w_2}, q_{w_3}$. Similarly I've combined the Gaussians, thus giving the exponential term.</p> <p>So basically I end up with: $$ RHS \propto \pi^{\alpha_0}(1-\pi)^{\beta_0-1}\left(\frac{1}{\sigma^2}-2\ln(1-\pi)\right) $$</p> <p><strong>Can I simply moment match this with a Beta distribution</strong> to get the approximation, in this case the moments being $E(\ln \pi), E(\ln (1-\pi))$ (my interpretation of the proj operation) and divide by the LHS messages or is there more to do.</p> <p>Finally trying to find these messages for each factor seems tedious and no closed form for moments as above. <strong>Are there any tips or comments on making inference on this easier/ faster</strong>.</p>
73,585
[ 0.02675420604646206, -0.009090363048017025, -0.009699428454041481, -0.021615346893668175, 0.07245447486639023, 0.001702692243270576, -0.03754780814051628, -0.057590484619140625, 0.011135034263134003, -0.046950362622737885, 0.011382339522242546, 0.02660437300801277, 0.08388344943523407, 0.04614201560616493, 0.01032164879143238, 0.01133414264768362, -0.01126920897513628, 0.000679825316183269, -0.012400956824421883, -0.03292209282517433, 0.030179183930158615, 0.0693121924996376, 0.005879263859242201, 0.002499684225767851, -0.05676504597067833, 0.046029604971408844, 0.009981966577470303, -0.053465403616428375, -0.04296589270234108, 0.06441278755664825, -0.049808844923973083, -0.007167180068790913, 0.02898482047021389, 0.03419370576739311, 0.04399273172020912, 0.02867499180138111, -0.03020831197500229, -0.04162820056080818, 0.03059442713856697, 0.016923950985074043, -0.03163617476820946, -0.017011500895023346, 0.0012083117617294192, 0.012061930261552334, -0.0236043818295002, -0.0012729427544400096, -0.006786542013287544, -0.07237677276134491, 0.039557356387376785, -0.02223050408065319, 0.07913439720869064, 0.007616706658154726, 0.02572014555335045, 0.01855439320206642, 0.0018922158051282167, -0.0373162105679512, 0.04526667296886444, 0.07357603311538696, 0.041677623987197876, 0.0002989646454807371, -0.023062454536557198, -0.009293573908507824, -0.0006174817681312561, 0.004713083617389202, -0.004131784662604332, 0.007748106960207224, 0.03052474372088909, 0.013907823711633682, 0.011434112675487995, -0.01770511455833912, 0.02514156699180603, 0.007224825210869312, 0.05842931568622589, 0.0014029507292434573, -0.003235037438571453, 0.009359483607113361, -0.00881793349981308, 0.039156097918748856, 0.012432473711669445, 0.0022128974087536335, 0.022745637223124504, 0.037191830575466156, 0.022254690527915955, 0.01674739085137844, 0.022028358653187752, -0.016097620129585266, 0.08874186873435974, -0.03860565274953842, -0.04452820122241974, 0.04949239268898964, -0.031186752021312714, 0.039176687598228455, 0.027111288160085678, -0.028411459177732468, -0.029443537816405296, 0.03012222610414028, -0.013219883665442467, -0.033950213342905045, -0.002217671135440469, 0.004144115839153528, -0.011166180483996868, -0.04418627545237541, 0.0009145039366558194, 0.04873810335993767, -0.008003029972314835, -0.010886135511100292, -0.03429776802659035, -0.0047912076115608215, -0.04785201698541641, -0.04960722476243973, -0.043658871203660965, 0.027476580813527107, 0.004917576443403959, -0.019415603950619698, 0.0008760695345699787, -0.008300833404064178, -0.016916055232286453, 0.0004409863904584199, 0.04700104147195816, 0.046462807804346085, 0.04464491084218025, -0.025706151500344276, 0.015315700322389603, -0.03802109882235527, -0.04391709342598915, 0.03124947100877762, -0.007734343409538269, -0.00416449224576354, -0.049993935972452164, 0.0534784235060215, 0.07557304948568344, -0.024575302377343178, 0.03661708906292915, 0.02103319764137268, -0.03135911747813225, -0.023781655356287956, -0.08695541322231293, -0.0386170856654644, 0.035966504365205765, -0.03305578976869583, 0.03206709399819374, -0.06427434831857681, -0.008591284975409508, 0.09472005814313889, 0.0422765277326107, 0.03678424656391144, 0.0478234700858593, -0.012381425127387047, 0.047561559826135635, 0.027858469635248184, -0.024665700271725655, -0.021776914596557617, -0.03558843955397606, 0.007741936016827822, -0.03181580826640129, -0.06483866274356842, 0.00022456885199062526, 0.04479619860649109, -0.028228962793946266, 0.007314819376915693, 0.0414532870054245, 0.011037342250347137, -0.007976781576871872, -0.010258190333843231, -0.006385737098753452, -0.04623084515333176, 0.03864935040473938, 0.012239355593919754, -0.006482772529125214, -0.0077948071993887424, -0.03637322783470154, -0.002210814505815506, -0.00987109076231718, 0.013979105278849602, 0.07893669605255127, -0.036255791783332825, -0.029125520959496498, -0.014322369359433651, -0.013463114388287067, 0.021862437948584557, -0.004835521336644888, -0.038048114627599716, -0.058443259447813034, 0.020975308492779732, 0.018857114017009735, 0.01821519061923027, 0.02575494349002838, 0.0015754848718643188, 0.06553500145673752, -0.02639959380030632, -0.025021469220519066, -0.015914585441350937, -0.0030714499298483133, 0.02128608338534832, -0.023273030295968056, 0.026762912049889565, -0.023542696610093117, -0.010839606635272503, 0.051946550607681274, -0.021944181993603706, -0.005068974569439888, 0.011736542917788029, 0.044153548777103424, -0.013341455720365047, -0.0012574262218549848, 0.025195669382810593, 0.02767155133187771, -0.03076799027621746, 0.012160497717559338, -0.04544172063469887, -0.01774340309202671, -0.007161955814808607, -0.031947679817676544, 0.04516422748565674, -0.008432582020759583, -0.013726181350648403, 0.026159435510635376, 0.009637406095862389, -0.025624560192227364, 0.007750341668725014, -0.07061817497015, 0.0095033198595047, 0.08199069648981094, 0.006960239261388779, -0.04435040429234505, -0.009568056091666222, 0.021355213597416878, 0.02851186692714691, -0.026665139943361282, -0.04605991020798683, -0.05002439767122269, -0.03512813150882721, 0.027798740193247795, 0.01789063587784767, -0.03282884135842323, -0.005980389192700386, 0.04449335113167763, 0.031814102083444595, -0.005970603786408901, 0.018827330321073532, 0.0107886902987957, 0.021894576027989388, 0.045514751225709915, 0.02644203044474125, 0.01756240986287594, 0.0284689012914896, 0.02072964608669281, -0.024785660207271576, 0.0049132779240608215, -0.00796558242291212, -0.03562983125448227, 0.012905205599963665, -0.041670095175504684, 0.000898697879165411, -0.018827524036169052, 0.009849346242845058, 0.03012930601835251, -0.037363164126873016, 0.026821862906217575, 0.029745135456323624, -0.005778628867119551, -0.01756470836699009, 0.020529283210635185, -0.017099548131227493, 0.005712284706532955, 0.026300514116883278, 0.00045977160334587097, -0.018222393468022346, 0.01800134778022766, -0.06589829176664352, 0.0215473473072052, -0.0007129006553441286, -0.007683975622057915, 0.0013432733248919249, 0.005859594792127609, -0.008372774347662926, 0.03840741887688637, -0.00953665841370821, -0.052314117550849915, -0.047562435269355774, 0.01209344808012247, 0.023534761741757393, 0.012427634559571743, 0.019656401127576828, -0.04894251748919487, 0.02760310098528862, -0.03571375831961632, 0.02158554457128048, -0.025430915877223015, -0.01207075733691454, -0.03388135880231857, -0.00712400209158659, 0.001298351213335991, -0.06667464971542358, -0.022791443392634392, -0.05530529096722603, 0.002571679884567857, -0.026734713464975357, -0.00026840955251827836, 0.009008592925965786, 0.05188225954771042, -0.06387556344270706, -0.012767069973051548, -0.04492194578051567, -0.035933688282966614, -0.030940361320972443, -0.006129163783043623, 0.007238807622343302, -0.00017323152860626578, 0.02511002868413925, 0.022126037627458572, 0.017937179654836655, -0.0060257078148424625, -0.08890530467033386, -0.06268315017223358, 0.01403804775327444, -0.002241011941805482, 0.014070013538002968, 0.011594929732382298, 0.002121841534972191, 0.0977492555975914, 0.04842781648039818, -0.007726306561380625, 0.005156511906534433, 0.027726592496037483, -0.035969123244285583, -0.022351950407028198, 0.03268671780824661, 0.01194096077233553, -0.011965347453951836, 0.02438156120479107, 0.005515949334949255, -0.003556358627974987, 0.041975803673267365, -0.024001190438866615, -0.0019145397236570716, 0.0391504243016243, -0.012335767038166523, 0.01124635711312294, 0.07357363402843475, -0.00648444565013051, 0.015809334814548492, 0.0031665300484746695, 0.02497183531522751, 0.03822381794452667, 0.034714225679636, -0.029832670465111732, 0.003132469952106476, -0.008718390949070454, 0.030536852777004242, -0.02001253142952919, 0.06738051772117615, 0.027139635756611824, -0.05457114055752754, 0.03097912110388279, -0.014231406152248383, 0.07607472687959671, -0.01802534982562065, 0.000890726747456938, 0.06125609949231148, 0.012323729693889618, 0.003967203199863434, -0.023553797975182533, -0.045016683638095856, -0.010902944020926952, 0.0029024085961282253, -0.025707576423883438, -0.009169085882604122, 0.009298667311668396, 0.031130235642194748, -0.0037855578120797873, -0.00016461398627143353, -0.006899629719555378, -0.02980344370007515, -0.0392427034676075, 0.007192421704530716, -0.03735820949077606, 0.02514195255935192, 0.019656475633382797, 0.027283702045679092, 0.016252227127552032, -0.02882181666791439, 0.007789761293679476, 0.0009936293354257941, -0.037983547896146774, 0.029234230518341064, 0.003730782540515065, -0.0026389681734144688, 0.03609412908554077, -0.02202063612639904, 0.02150570973753929, 0.00856764242053032, -0.01865530014038086, -0.018146052956581116, 0.016985341906547546, -0.032518114894628525, -0.002656468190252781, -0.020063266158103943, -0.03284214437007904, -0.03361787647008896, 0.02112276665866375, 0.04729675501585007, -0.02274375781416893, 0.02989240176975727, 0.006672818213701248, -0.032700665295124054, 0.011196942999958992, -0.031731218099594116, -0.005322516895830631, 0.03620242327451706, 0.030380994081497192, 0.01030487660318613, 0.01601553149521351, 0.009832712821662426, -0.0029163272120058537, 0.05036386847496033, 0.013868524692952633, 0.06511848419904709, -0.0021949580404907465, 0.01509146299213171, -0.05047038570046425, -0.020151402801275253, 0.0016011224361136556, 0.03320607915520668, -0.03101911023259163, -0.009380503557622433, 0.020770462229847908, -0.0015652108704671264, -0.011300970800220966, 0.007146058604121208, 0.04575612023472786, -0.004769457038491964, -0.0072466423735022545, -0.03561998903751373, -0.024142377078533173, 0.00804965104907751, 0.0033792336471378803, -0.006106892600655556, 0.0019076007883995771, -0.0032733213156461716, -0.0057685039937496185, 0.02741212584078312, 0.03165587782859802, 0.009854265488684177, 0.03932887315750122, 0.025695661082863808, 0.023176761344075203, 0.025918778032064438, -0.043774258345365524, -0.01806742511689663, 0.025946876034140587, 0.015269209630787373, 0.024299336597323418, 0.011556615121662617, -0.046469178050756454, -0.023277828469872475, 0.032691750675439835, 0.05548284575343132, 0.026257723569869995, -0.004006726201623678, -0.05807904526591301, -0.02172039821743965, 0.003075480228289962, 0.010667975060641766, 0.030214082449674606, 0.0020124015863984823, 0.00881991721689701, -0.011220057494938374, -0.038567814975976944, -0.04477284848690033, 0.009467681869864464, -0.026450088247656822, -0.007116419728845358, -0.041843149811029434, -0.00024805389693938196, -0.051759686321020126, -0.0015111672692000866, 0.07136482745409012, 0.08116625249385834, -0.0049211750738322735, -0.016645871102809906, 0.002946300432085991, 0.019466547295451164, -0.014028561301529408, -0.07945235073566437, 0.02174411155283451, 0.016411488875746727, -0.03472211956977844, 0.059550974518060684, -0.022136768326163292, -0.007429413963109255, 0.024153580889105797, -0.004706567153334618, -0.011772786267101765, -0.008449864573776722, -0.02936205267906189, 0.08277866989374161, 0.10227004438638687, -0.012346714735031128, 0.06226932257413864, 0.08510985225439072, -0.023838995024561882, -0.0157184898853302, -0.055290669202804565, 0.0026551533956080675, 0.0033739209175109863, -0.0003915713168680668, -0.04693414270877838, 0.0021140417084097862, -0.011358624324202538, -0.0334017314016819, -0.06071018427610397, 0.04913480207324028, -0.03373335301876068, -0.028705120086669922, 0.013680348172783852, 0.016684744507074356, -0.03729759529232979, 0.04208536446094513, -0.012183751910924911, 0.03930085897445679, 0.008182103745639324, -0.011436729691922665, -0.003966588992625475, -0.04377194866538048, -0.010542698204517365, 0.00565733527764678, -0.00945486593991518, -0.010978232137858868, -0.03133464977145195, 0.0060429684817790985, -0.05714124068617821, -0.04212641343474388, 0.026584813371300697, 0.0031176747288554907, 0.01994265615940094, 0.024159787222743034, 0.006537384353578091, -0.03306116163730621, 0.004859443288296461, -0.00688772602006793, 0.01091762538999319, -0.011724638752639294, -0.037709563970565796, -0.02530711516737938, -0.01698773354291916, -0.04325473681092262, -0.015172988176345825, 0.018725980073213577, 0.009364197961986065, 0.0034382243175059557, -0.021441444754600525, 0.01135838869959116, -0.005645733326673508, -0.031749073415994644, -0.02689690701663494, 0.019078025594353676, -0.011536704376339912, 0.0364992655813694, -0.015369351953268051, 0.014012171886861324, 0.03716157004237175, -0.009456472471356392, 0.012195555493235588, 0.03304627165198326, 0.003385488875210285, -0.01775486394762993, -0.0007954962784424424, -0.007180545479059219, -0.04076065123081207, -0.009813903830945492, 0.012495788745582104, 0.006238768342882395, 0.02614741586148739, -0.02152409590780735, -0.03970742225646973, 0.0011071831686422229, 0.04853961989283562, -0.018728220835328102, 0.00044105082633905113, -0.05692179501056671, 0.052745264023542404, 0.0009120989125221968, -0.034656234085559845, -0.0000581081876589451, -0.038719404488801956, -0.003162178210914135, 0.02089139260351658, -0.028881540521979332, -0.030245378613471985, 0.031105700880289078, 0.06217733025550842, -0.0017086940351873636, -0.004028636496514082, -0.0011995865497738123, 0.008844859898090363, 0.006268743425607681, -0.023867934942245483, 0.0020691759418696165, 0.021299416199326515, -0.001952781924046576, -0.043647512793540955, -0.01135544665157795, -0.08211613446474075, 0.01430852897465229, 0.08663399517536163, 0.0038689859211444855, 0.02373274229466915, 0.008276090025901794, 0.00045796390622854233, -0.04321815446019173, -0.03178681060671806, -0.06369714438915253, -0.02306298539042473, -0.028920693323016167, 0.0033860537223517895, -0.03503140062093735, -0.038652848452329636, 0.03333986550569534, 0.013509679585695267, -0.0015210519777610898, 0.01218023244291544, -0.011833577416837215, 0.01968577690422535, -0.028889717534184456, -0.028251303359866142, -0.027634147554636, 0.007602763827890158, -0.030289726331830025, 0.013849543407559395, -0.021893519908189774, -0.03174198791384697, 0.05843784287571907, 0.019708359614014626, -0.0029652323573827744, -0.0644916370511055, -0.023864759132266045, -0.02795274741947651, 0.026436449959874153, 0.03153696656227112, 0.0005885748541913927, 0.026610612869262695, 0.006054578814655542, 0.013364210724830627, 0.025931669399142265, 0.04312894865870476, -0.01297080796211958, -0.08632519096136093, -0.025161394849419594, -0.01480988971889019, -0.05002254620194435, 0.037883296608924866, -0.029572708532214165, -0.047315627336502075, 0.027766890823841095, -0.04162842407822609, 0.060159873217344284, -0.004494406748563051, 0.027343252673745155, -0.010629601776599884, 0.03247588872909546, 0.017990825697779655, 0.021243037655949593, 0.0028614287730306387, -0.029356179758906364, 0.14018717408180237, 0.04285481199622154, 0.025317590683698654, -0.034132011234760284, -0.0070930481888353825, -0.014652438461780548, -0.008596444502472878, -0.05284077674150467, 0.014897325076162815, -0.00031610604492016137, -0.02321314811706543, 0.017144644632935524, 0.061582889407873154, -0.013433190993964672, 0.0003323900164104998, 0.0596783272922039, -0.0072104777209460735, -0.02938072197139263, -0.005206631030887365, 0.01851864531636238, -0.021298673003911972, -0.007731123827397823, -0.03658667951822281, 0.056291669607162476, -0.03223159909248352, -0.007687458302825689, -0.028382115066051483, -0.0011940848780795932, 0.031803395599126816, -0.02424800582230091, -0.01881556585431099, 0.05179871991276741, 0.0048491028137505054, -0.024036241695284843, 0.025337306782603264, 0.025033459067344666, 0.02646476775407791, -0.061001233756542206, 0.0218312107026577, 0.028083709999918938, 0.012361545115709305, 0.011093122884631157, 0.010979469865560532, -0.02343427948653698, -0.05119382590055466, -0.06400220841169357, -0.03404569625854492, 0.06186733394861221, -0.012823855504393578, -0.02713431976735592, 0.021171966567635536, 0.010891594924032688, 0.027962390333414078, -0.03950471058487892, 0.008581222966313362, 0.002229847712442279, -0.006570630706846714, -0.024450108408927917, -0.003162599168717861, 0.007751567289233208, 0.06130574271082878, 0.0009232722222805023, 0.03405114635825157, 0.005540493875741959, -0.03715577349066734, -0.050499189645051956, -0.040289320051670074, 0.054411642253398895, 0.011205197311937809, -0.020974108949303627, -0.003053440945222974, -0.007071299012750387, 0.0011351333232596517, -0.023615757003426552, -0.009744718670845032, -0.016899198293685913, 0.03696886822581291, -0.01973751373589039, -0.0037083085626363754, -0.017767416313290596, -0.035648491233587265, 0.009820896200835705, -0.022435275837779045, 0.002398968441411853, -0.006553371902555227, -0.04611698165535927, 0.045900121331214905, 0.06134554743766785, -0.00134097330737859, -0.0248101856559515, -0.009701946750283241, 0.06284836679697037, 0.04204351082444191, -0.037128008902072906, -0.04798152297735214, -0.002563517540693283, -0.030134931206703186, -0.034396011382341385, -0.018593842163681984, 0.06030016019940376, 0.02503122203052044, 0.024319488555192947, 0.02174076810479164, 0.007735489401966333, -0.022604914382100105, -0.002852601697668433, -0.013131062500178814, -0.029371798038482666, -0.0031882382463663816, 0.0037433335091918707, -0.0028083024080842733, -0.015358872711658478, 0.004119882360100746, -0.0073142992332577705, 0.008139142766594887, -0.020259039476513863, 0.012076186947524548, -0.023729786276817322, -0.00020038339425809681, -0.015488662756979465, 0.00792744942009449, -0.015199270099401474, -0.01915868930518627, 0.02114761434495449, 0.011654271744191647, -0.03810914233326912, -0.010441025719046593, -0.010092383250594139, 0.02562202885746956, 0.006222773343324661, 0.023695768788456917, 0.04565059766173363, 0.025916552171111107, 0.008914271369576454, -0.03081812709569931, 0.02118602953851223, 0.007645325735211372, 0.057542357593774796, -0.01656983233988285, -0.012109298259019852, 0.02913520112633705, -0.017824916169047356, -0.03921695426106453, 0.029708432033658028, 0.027782028540968895, 0.03367170691490173, 0.017287787050008774, 0.002300440100952983, -0.03697223961353302, 0.04305393248796463, 0.0004999793600291014, -0.02101339027285576, 0.01348367054015398, -0.026729045435786247, 0.032837752252817154, -0.014669419266283512, 0.019493676722049713, 0.03000626340508461, 0.049921464174985886, 0.006106481421738863, -0.00706233037635684, 0.005116221494972706, 0.002813833998516202, 0.0029263931792229414, -0.020802274346351624, -0.000801808899268508, -0.009657278656959534, -0.01937062107026577, 0.04915637895464897, 0.05185212939977646, 0.006561577785760164, 0.04666353017091751, 0.0021612911950796843, -0.0002749331761151552, -0.08599057048559189, -0.02018679678440094, -0.003442083951085806, 0.05030315741896629, 0.0676511600613594, -0.040593624114990234, 0.0491376668214798, 0.04909621179103851, -0.056211140006780624, 0.022250289097428322, -0.015361438505351543, -0.004904567264020443, -0.03188955411314964, 0.033826474100351334, -0.017550630494952202, 0.027365878224372864, 0.0037311078049242496, 0.018099160864949226, 0.03684219717979431, 0.05141165480017662, 0.005115324165672064, -0.03778473660349846, -0.0040810322389006615, 0.002365540247410536, 0.03617279976606369, -0.014895651489496231, 0.07251101732254028, -0.0648425966501236, -0.048806317150592804, 0.03131451830267906, 0.015364788472652435, -0.005759517662227154, -0.012389660812914371, 0.04353124275803566, 0.04423564299941063, 0.0440339595079422, 0.04882019758224487, -0.002168131060898304, 0.03464243561029434, -0.034441329538822174, 0.011988213285803795, -0.024116598069667816, -0.004203074146062136, 0.008642710745334625, 0.02214166335761547, -0.002577137900516391, -0.03296258673071861, 0.023491952568292618, 0.013400365598499775, -0.0599689707159996, -0.01894804835319519, 0.002089886460453272, -0.004516454413533211, -0.04362918809056282, 0.006714927963912487, -0.034234948456287384, 0.006902155000716448, 0.019031399860978127, 0.037527501583099365, -0.03295920416712761, -0.012169617228209972, -0.0041077621281147, -0.06753914803266525, 0.02085963264107704, 0.026318863034248352, 0.004974363837391138, -0.025067275390028954, -0.024696283042430878, -0.014725305140018463, 0.03263086453080177, 0.01246691681444645, 0.00004169815656496212, -0.04486599937081337, 0.020682618021965027, -0.041889775544404984, -0.012403478845953941, -0.003238426521420479, -0.005235088523477316, -0.00970381312072277, -0.04913609102368355, 0.019779127091169357, 0.02501477487385273, 0.0013970783911645412, -0.03795265406370163, -0.017365189269185066, -0.05650736019015312, -0.001592486398294568, 0.047329872846603394, 0.025368884205818176, 0.003583896439522505, 0.005289649590849876, 0.032227370887994766, 0.008206412196159363, -0.06836631149053574, 0.036218300461769104, -0.00924714095890522, 0.030903717502951622, 0.007791484240442514, 0.006359815131872892, -0.0029566180892288685, 0.024613389745354652, -0.0007076808251440525, -0.004625248722732067, 0.0035953358747065067, 0.013668488711118698, -0.01529622171074152, 0.01858830824494362, 0.015058928169310093, -0.015458541922271252, 0.05018724128603935, -0.010657296516001225, -0.01571439765393734, 0.03500751033425331, -0.04162883386015892, -0.06392703950405121, 0.027022168040275574, 0.032889582216739655, -0.022484004497528076, -0.009085078723728657, -0.008358240127563477, 0.01354440487921238, -0.07100385427474976, -0.019437525421380997, 0.012552556581795216, -0.027574414387345314, 0.006218493916094303, 0.0512370765209198, 0.008082864806056023, 0.03479316085577011, 0.01982959546148777, 0.05097951740026474, 0.019090669229626656, -0.016560325399041176, 0.03690647706389427, 0.003749437630176544, -0.008929808624088764, -0.032111525535583496, 0.0361175462603569, 0.04091886803507805, -0.011658789590001106, 0.016284823417663574, -0.01668480411171913, 0.025825705379247665, 0.014917934313416481, 0.019571609795093536, 0.01995685324072838, -0.012509212829172611, -0.01671258918941021, -0.003814071649685502, 0.025409121066331863, 0.054925475269556046, -0.041551295667886734, 0.015330750495195389, -0.02488667331635952, 0.020213548094034195, -0.04640604183077812, 0.051094237715005875, 0.010507442057132721, 0.023645129054784775, 0.0010497495532035828, -0.04243951663374901, -0.013166166841983795, -0.03456446900963783, -0.019310252740979195, -0.03815390542149544, -0.002029325347393751, 0.02448301576077938, 0.005483407061547041, -0.00511733815073967, -0.03028852678835392, -0.017917295917868614, -0.008053118363022804, 0.024540677666664124, 0.05482114851474762, 0.016531404107809067, 0.005408589728176594, -0.026309173554182053, -0.011102401651442051, 0.03474975749850273, -0.00883798860013485, 0.02505561150610447, -0.022869568318128586, 0.013364294543862343, 0.027199964970350266, -0.017736215144395828 ]
<p>I have a regression model with 3 different variables. One variable is only significant if I square it, and not include the linear version i.e. $Y = \beta_1X_1 + \beta_2X_2 + \beta_3X_3^2$</p> <p>How should I interpret the $X_3^2$ variable?</p>
49,477
[ -0.009455789811909199, 0.017888223752379417, -0.003053602995350957, 0.0026219701394438744, 0.052930377423763275, 0.04482443258166313, -0.01599428430199623, -0.03912240266799927, 0.03612489998340607, -0.04955677315592766, 0.03863127529621124, 0.009967692196369171, 0.0519985556602478, -0.03452043607831001, 0.03412466123700142, 0.014126249589025974, 0.01441177073866129, 0.0021410672925412655, 0.017423400655388832, 0.01724390871822834, -0.01599498838186264, 0.004950095433741808, 0.011279264464974403, 0.0023009388241916895, -0.021528851240873337, 0.06108800321817398, 0.02833353914320469, 0.006158301141113043, 0.019865594804286957, 0.01851067505776882, -0.012677984312176704, -0.020537426695227623, 0.011525403708219528, 0.0466328002512455, 0.001269125728867948, 0.0026706133503466845, 0.012753439135849476, -0.02577676810324192, 0.04335246980190277, 0.036720629781484604, -0.016660748049616814, -0.02404503896832466, -0.006985066924244165, 0.02516791969537735, 0.0009150158148258924, 0.029278350993990898, -0.016935788094997406, -0.06159403175115585, 0.04673134908080101, -0.00897267833352089, 0.09436386078596115, 0.01902473345398903, 0.03431747481226921, 0.050430577248334885, -0.019161105155944824, 0.01153260376304388, 0.05984333157539368, 0.05464151129126549, -0.0045771049335598946, -0.04327499493956566, -0.0052717747166752815, -0.002064271830022335, 0.007949784398078918, -0.010202732868492603, -0.02189672738313675, 0.026135819032788277, 0.008001125417649746, -0.0063894959166646, 0.04034827649593353, -0.014406985603272915, 0.013668824918568134, 0.015221459791064262, 0.018226243555545807, -0.01231338456273079, -0.005445220973342657, -0.019006261602044106, 0.006578244734555483, 0.037617433816194534, 0.029931742697954178, 0.02137722820043564, 0.0276558268815279, 0.0024304192047566175, 0.03505057096481323, 0.008797233924269676, -0.0037857454735785723, 0.020525947213172913, 0.04227034002542496, 0.004700280260294676, 0.026650281623005867, 0.02791055291891098, -0.0045491112396121025, 0.009171895682811737, 0.060588717460632324, 0.0006199892377480865, -0.017067579552531242, 0.014522392302751541, -0.004267562180757523, 0.022259557619690895, 0.03211669623851776, 0.015442156232893467, -0.022891923785209656, -0.02830783650279045, 0.027539154514670372, 0.0330008901655674, -0.033592674881219864, 0.016196010634303093, -0.03511118143796921, 0.02606499008834362, 0.005661812610924244, -0.07133649289608002, -0.0039721387438476086, 0.021432314068078995, 0.006103884428739548, 0.0032838224433362484, 0.03523439168930054, -0.017537515610456467, -0.006254706531763077, -0.0029255554545670748, 0.05628383904695511, 0.031997792422771454, 0.02483118698000908, -0.033515814691782, 0.021220628172159195, 0.012680613435804844, -0.020578527823090553, 0.024627504870295525, 0.008093629032373428, -0.021733636036515236, -0.039556752890348434, 0.04425763338804245, 0.013770956546068192, -0.025499073788523674, 0.0022524299565702677, -0.007444165647029877, 0.011487427167594433, -0.018192769959568977, -0.07478789240121841, -0.05694597586989403, 0.020097728818655014, -0.023998424410820007, -0.0032472829334437847, -0.03544121980667114, -0.017114507034420967, 0.07366201281547546, 0.09614961594343185, -0.020936232060194016, -0.010852905921638012, 0.044418491423130035, 0.02476653829216957, 0.00838322564959526, -0.025198079645633698, -0.0013728271005675197, -0.018952421844005585, -0.029126057401299477, 0.012712669558823109, -0.05134233087301254, 0.011518094688653946, 0.03603436052799225, 0.018357081338763237, -0.01972814090549946, 0.03282468765974045, 0.00599777651950717, -0.018439194187521935, 0.013698591850697994, -0.0008708758978173137, -0.0035704767797142267, 0.09347886592149734, -0.01780528388917446, 0.03425345569849014, 0.05205700919032097, -0.012369424104690552, 0.036910369992256165, 0.006918265949934721, 0.07900696247816086, 0.05660380423069, 0.014138884842395782, 0.011349232867360115, -0.02942134439945221, -0.004662551451474428, 0.013409449718892574, -0.08279899507761002, -0.04246295988559723, -0.023781826719641685, -0.0074316225945949554, -0.00005249052992439829, 0.06087888777256012, -0.005076592788100243, 0.005163998808711767, 0.06715822964906693, -0.0507262647151947, -0.028221026062965393, -0.04754524305462837, -0.005161930341273546, -0.008259793743491173, -0.03494172915816307, 0.018976425752043724, 0.037427667528390884, 0.005814643576741219, -0.004712358117103577, 0.0074195475317537785, 0.019326932728290558, 0.03460318595170975, 0.06822953373193741, -0.03131016716361046, 0.04346928372979164, 0.036861926317214966, 0.062319815158843994, 0.0005322417127899826, 0.02710729092359543, -0.0167468823492527, 0.009243587963283062, 0.021274760365486145, -0.013983727432787418, 0.020993683487176895, -0.06715673953294754, -0.010928214527666569, -0.011587263084948063, -0.025543488562107086, -0.0314643457531929, 0.04256885498762131, -0.06288091093301773, 0.06356795132160187, 0.03075975738465786, -0.009457146748900414, -0.0013035095762461424, -0.020386910066008568, 0.001769643509760499, 0.03693686053156853, -0.02098727785050869, -0.015152450650930405, -0.05371926724910736, -0.02581806480884552, 0.0002585252223070711, 0.03367796912789345, -0.04964089393615723, 0.006883521564304829, 0.04489745572209358, 0.01734616607427597, 0.011988766491413116, 0.02201898768544197, -0.0016157394275069237, 0.019337527453899384, -0.0046012080274522305, -0.018586596474051476, 0.00628264807164669, 0.019735630601644516, 0.006524992641061544, 0.038255251944065094, 0.04042130336165428, -0.019132491201162338, 0.00992811843752861, 0.05480923876166344, -0.02791450545191765, 0.019569069147109985, 0.007803730666637421, 0.017451729625463486, 0.03705506771802902, -0.006812969222664833, 0.00636438000947237, 0.04522719606757164, -0.006467496044933796, -0.0066156848333776, 0.03549318015575409, -0.0038510821759700775, 0.0021480489522218704, 0.02486136183142662, -0.057968832552433014, -0.0010570426238700747, 0.02078136056661606, -0.06149544194340706, 0.01953575573861599, -0.0332675501704216, -0.04531248286366463, -0.001703791436739266, -0.006150690373033285, 0.017560850828886032, 0.013039209879934788, 0.0375833734869957, -0.02181999757885933, -0.04012181982398033, -0.028259113430976868, -0.037970948964357376, 0.01807185634970665, -0.033658649772405624, -0.04246864840388298, 0.005195256322622299, -0.0503222830593586, -0.01728646084666252, 0.01405332237482071, -0.020043320953845978, -0.013020881451666355, 0.0276491716504097, -0.04001747816801071, -0.049802884459495544, -0.04281754791736603, -0.05106370151042938, 0.02195587195456028, -0.03183235973119736, -0.04675360023975372, 0.03836658596992493, -0.01035633310675621, -0.03467900678515434, -0.009171715006232262, -0.0327293686568737, -0.015584293752908707, -0.015355375595390797, -0.002090803347527981, 0.00831986777484417, 0.010901413857936859, 0.043836161494255066, 0.018529580906033516, -0.04814630374312401, 0.0027686620596796274, -0.059216491878032684, -0.07753431051969528, 0.014913605526089668, 0.007046204060316086, 0.04234444350004196, -0.030063113197684288, -0.0636913850903511, 0.08523639291524887, 0.0408451110124588, 0.0012311820173636079, -0.004935107193887234, 0.0008951147319748998, -0.013510951772332191, -0.031004296615719795, 0.026076389476656914, 0.020361537113785744, 0.03791887313127518, 0.05989353358745575, -0.008395182900130749, 0.03303327411413193, 0.03481018915772438, 0.014988483861088753, -0.016962867230176926, 0.011108445934951305, -0.010417429730296135, 0.016626693308353424, 0.02675105445086956, 0.006640152540057898, 0.004132452420890331, 0.027118435129523277, -0.013553217053413391, 0.013643644750118256, 0.025716986507177353, -0.030608754605054855, 0.01395146269351244, 0.006155022419989109, 0.011363866738975048, 0.01194055937230587, 0.02477342076599598, 0.03463268280029297, -0.031140219420194626, -0.004787307232618332, -0.005431613884866238, 0.03421537205576897, -0.017545321956276894, 0.015106567181646824, 0.023975618183612823, 0.018241021782159805, -0.013004055246710777, -0.01102929376065731, -0.02600819803774357, 0.002454529982060194, 0.022152192890644073, 0.006137340795248747, -0.013867326080799103, 0.04956783354282379, 0.02407946065068245, -0.01114334724843502, -0.01411452516913414, -0.040399592369794846, -0.01595430076122284, -0.04771300032734871, -0.024258464574813843, -0.018860921263694763, 0.011374068446457386, -0.0007289577624760568, 0.02984805218875408, 0.005394509993493557, -0.045350782573223114, 0.034986648708581924, -0.010671689175069332, -0.05483921989798546, 0.040345557034015656, -0.036625444889068604, 0.019864916801452637, 0.013875601813197136, 0.0002220363967353478, 0.016308769583702087, -0.05554335564374924, -0.009206964634358883, -0.022079067304730415, -0.003079372923821211, -0.030011242255568504, 0.001248977961950004, -0.03823695704340935, -0.015607872046530247, -0.0030484809540212154, 0.04091837257146835, 0.0010171711910516024, -0.002043374115601182, 0.010448447428643703, 0.029724353924393654, -0.021605247631669044, -0.003312345128506422, -0.03138214722275734, -0.008735453709959984, 0.03798206150531769, 0.02193869650363922, -0.0012008609483018517, 0.018976785242557526, -0.01671069860458374, 0.0047171348705887794, 0.006185304839164019, 0.012462073005735874, 0.03559068217873573, 0.037717968225479126, -0.04230871424078941, -0.041655004024505615, 0.006758676376193762, -0.004255893640220165, 0.026932580396533012, 0.015840953215956688, 0.007168704643845558, 0.0787920206785202, 0.023655904456973076, -0.040430907160043716, 0.007326535880565643, 0.03404417634010315, 0.030868589878082275, -0.0046269772574305534, -0.025333616882562637, 0.014341367408633232, 0.00025258015375584364, -0.039318472146987915, -0.004100533202290535, 0.0011210128432139754, -0.012505687773227692, -0.033822160214185715, 0.025874387472867966, -0.02421223558485508, -0.021774709224700928, 0.018279334530234337, 0.009086819365620613, 0.0416371151804924, -0.008995069190859795, -0.06710471212863922, 0.03784526512026787, 0.049969226121902466, 0.005992033984512091, 0.019898943603038788, 0.023011626675724983, -0.09189294278621674, -0.007361549884080887, 0.03668008744716644, 0.041255127638578415, -0.020838577300310135, -0.030728649348020554, -0.050922200083732605, -0.0038653186056762934, 0.01853329874575138, -0.04340939596295357, 0.03268574923276901, -0.001377121196128428, -0.0021539954468607903, -0.031957101076841354, 0.0003829484339803457, -0.10080502182245255, 0.025103861466050148, -0.03864093869924545, 0.045662399381399155, -0.02918999083340168, -0.012691602110862732, -0.04080602899193764, 0.007127279415726662, -0.006396721117198467, 0.04380963742733002, -0.002392552327364683, 0.007715745363384485, 0.024742696434259415, 0.050424035638570786, -0.013643482699990273, -0.05387243628501892, 0.03274182230234146, 0.030681047588586807, -0.02140897512435913, 0.022054582834243774, -0.011477595195174217, -0.06906835734844208, -0.005550718866288662, 0.017713800072669983, -0.002802892355248332, 0.004576155450195074, -0.006556733511388302, 0.05294797196984291, 0.04640527814626694, -0.005473031662404537, 0.06151611730456352, 0.0289962999522686, -0.006208800245076418, -0.03850419819355011, -0.03868643566966057, 0.001966116949915886, -0.03829771652817726, -0.015530114993453026, -0.06015143170952797, 0.0027117186691612005, -0.03245009481906891, 0.007566501852124929, -0.03050762042403221, 0.02381668984889984, -0.02519911900162697, -0.0259250421077013, 0.01770476996898651, 0.012768711894750595, 0.005004130769520998, -0.003301741322502494, -0.026811406016349792, 0.026487423107028008, -0.03122617118060589, -0.031122887507081032, 0.002573217498138547, -0.018433231860399246, 0.03591609001159668, 0.017759524285793304, -0.019171737134456635, 0.03174062818288803, -0.012131940573453903, -0.0022432690020650625, -0.03188413009047508, -0.05065714567899704, 0.008514578454196453, -0.0062910267151892185, 0.00919981300830841, -0.014246098697185516, -0.002716844202950597, -0.01865059696137905, 0.021078817546367645, 0.02802622690796852, 0.03562597557902336, -0.04206875339150429, 0.03662337735295296, -0.018110262230038643, 0.0008121570572257042, -0.02349991910159588, -0.07702839374542236, 0.0033082158770412207, 0.04061901569366455, 0.022634170949459076, -0.009815268218517303, 0.005173210985958576, -0.020531021058559418, -0.040340736508369446, -0.00782893504947424, 0.02029365487396717, -0.042970921844244, -0.015328275971114635, 0.00013562965614255518, 0.030321506783366203, 0.045577943325042725, -0.03597674146294594, -0.02055676095187664, 0.03207489475607872, -0.0020788253750652075, -0.025930162519216537, 0.012908782809972763, 0.016252726316452026, -0.04736880958080292, 0.004030287731438875, -0.033634573221206665, -0.016938338056206703, 0.025256125256419182, -0.0472085103392601, -0.039878323674201965, -0.009132388047873974, 0.02428172342479229, -0.017927095293998718, -0.010472416877746582, 0.006763251032680273, 0.01330755464732647, 0.009482908993959427, -0.002695112954825163, -0.0141916424036026, -0.004048403352499008, -0.008970165625214577, 0.056137826293706894, 0.016033703461289406, -0.05391441658139229, 0.005054215434938669, 0.07020703703165054, 0.02999028004705906, 0.02630634792149067, -0.03420845791697502, -0.013324626721441746, 0.05191390961408615, 0.024041425436735153, 0.006019160151481628, 0.004830265883356333, 0.06628168374300003, -0.039955634623765945, -0.02222377248108387, -0.06767712533473969, 0.015626413747668266, 0.08071240782737732, -0.06413421779870987, 0.0216218214482069, 0.05810496211051941, -0.025632282719016075, -0.0036940895952284336, -0.042629044502973557, -0.022389957681298256, -0.026096289977431297, -0.007372563239187002, 0.018901027739048004, -0.020232917740941048, -0.012893129140138626, 0.046363312751054764, 0.012070577591657639, -0.0022896400187164545, 0.014877259731292725, 0.023090030997991562, 0.008670664392411709, 0.006370435934513807, -0.011590622365474701, -0.08691839128732681, 0.03359920531511307, -0.009252654388546944, 0.023733263835310936, -0.014796166680753231, -0.020466966554522514, 0.04713943228125572, 0.03246303275227547, 0.01551867090165615, -0.07354818284511566, -0.025718173012137413, -0.06712120771408081, -0.00039471572381444275, 0.03775405138731003, -0.02381109446287155, 0.052022796124219894, 0.022053256630897522, 0.03390531986951828, 0.0002175317786168307, 0.0378999300301075, -0.05919669568538666, -0.06240575760602951, -0.00012444794992916286, -0.015696687623858452, -0.017242267727851868, 0.003929759841412306, -0.003495592623949051, -0.0577789731323719, 0.009473335929214954, -0.06814119964838028, 0.007337797433137894, -0.009824399836361408, 0.03824746981263161, -0.02286328747868538, 0.05006816238164902, -0.016667883843183517, -0.019726203754544258, 0.017753319814801216, -0.008032327517867088, 0.10082332789897919, 0.08466572314500809, 0.004848984070122242, -0.0945291593670845, 0.0538756437599659, -0.03015683963894844, -0.006168999709188938, -0.01907559297978878, -0.04102470353245735, 0.0012992677511647344, 0.010705037042498589, 0.03152349218726158, 0.053251661360263824, -0.005715747829526663, -0.00907636247575283, 0.03864500671625137, -0.031077921390533447, -0.05327265337109566, 0.0313267819583416, 0.009804143570363522, 0.00046758929966017604, -0.028468474745750427, -0.04197390750050545, 0.03155805543065071, 0.005002515856176615, -0.04532061889767647, -0.0168098546564579, -0.011925012804567814, 0.012807979248464108, 0.005445433314889669, -0.022930767387151718, 0.015018753707408905, 0.02374185621738434, 0.014837275259196758, -0.03514852747321129, 0.03460092842578888, 0.009490380994975567, -0.05218047276139259, 0.0325140617787838, 0.015347159467637539, -0.01802048087120056, 0.002590336836874485, 0.01113826222717762, -0.008244180120527744, -0.06288166344165802, -0.015397073701024055, -0.023740341886878014, 0.04622616246342659, 0.025169460102915764, -0.04635951295495033, -0.03377937898039818, 0.03055301494896412, 0.012365292757749557, -0.04714558646082878, -0.004144343547523022, 0.05104630067944527, 0.011472332291305065, -0.04256490617990494, -0.022867189720273018, 0.0039154826663434505, 0.002018231200054288, 0.00955527275800705, 0.028485609218478203, 0.0247693732380867, -0.052688319236040115, 0.004382577259093523, -0.007399003487080336, 0.05604751408100128, -0.014540321193635464, -0.01395522803068161, 0.007612546905875206, -0.030765589326620102, 0.0027213660068809986, 0.013237874023616314, 0.039061542600393295, 0.010087519884109497, 0.010279024951159954, -0.01777048222720623, -0.005270918365567923, -0.03917960450053215, -0.022274024784564972, 0.03633967787027359, -0.015124872326850891, 0.030067425221204758, -0.04270784556865692, -0.005276025272905827, 0.019609879702329636, 0.02915172092616558, 0.022433465346693993, 0.00979713536798954, 0.0023472195025533438, 0.0503634512424469, 0.015675298869609833, -0.04142182692885399, -0.01764540746808052, 0.048893630504608154, -0.03815517574548721, -0.01259134616702795, -0.05795107036828995, 0.06278716772794724, 0.03753327578306198, 0.013329857960343361, -0.013729126192629337, 0.01701037771999836, -0.018911289051175117, 0.0034342824947088957, 0.02613271027803421, -0.05853275582194328, 0.0007310782093554735, 0.03221631795167923, 0.005148728843778372, -0.015649117529392242, -0.006647581700235605, -0.018279585987329483, -0.02563294768333435, -0.0143076591193676, 0.022008338943123817, -0.037431806325912476, 0.010196846909821033, -0.00046215858310461044, 0.015684545040130615, -0.028417032212018967, -0.03360642120242119, -0.040433887392282486, 0.015436341054737568, 0.02271328493952751, -0.01981954090297222, 0.014539713971316814, 0.0011988674523308873, -0.032799918204545975, 0.026249675080180168, 0.033925991505384445, -0.023687688633799553, 0.025377150624990463, -0.03523309901356697, -0.003881664713844657, -0.022504162043333054, 0.06179695576429367, -0.05374753847718239, -0.0005855695926584303, 0.030192013829946518, -0.01930595561861992, -0.01683678664267063, 0.04109661281108856, 0.006836203392595053, 0.0590817891061306, 0.008929047733545303, 0.021198000758886337, -0.05857304111123085, 0.014498612843453884, -0.026526449248194695, 0.02100205607712269, -0.014867926016449928, 0.013880936428904533, 0.0033056328538805246, -0.02019529603421688, -0.019757501780986786, 0.022014137357473373, -0.0029610793571919203, 0.017329588532447815, 0.06876026093959808, -0.029621019959449768, -0.007349606603384018, -0.0015597863821312785, 0.01270407997071743, 0.008890996687114239, 0.007796932477504015, 0.0022724240552634, 0.04355597496032715, 0.05088812857866287, -0.03611245006322861, 0.05617394670844078, 0.019451605156064034, 0.0031534398440271616, -0.10310147702693939, -0.03199166804552078, 0.011004118248820305, 0.005746053531765938, 0.03916526585817337, -0.06036338955163956, 0.048195745795965195, 0.03715541586279869, -0.02870522066950798, 0.004035165999084711, -0.02742709219455719, -0.0005711600533686578, -0.006659507751464844, -0.007571397349238396, -0.01686662808060646, 0.03971469774842262, 0.007312405854463577, 0.005501874722540379, 0.037228699773550034, 0.05157551169395447, -0.006372681353241205, -0.029063917696475983, 0.003298877039924264, 0.013127261772751808, 0.0036816864740103483, -0.0722876563668251, 0.02336677722632885, -0.033906240016222, -0.015475524589419365, 0.05621056258678436, -0.040662024170160294, 0.03308481723070145, 0.022575557231903076, 0.022635117173194885, 0.006787757854908705, 0.057842254638671875, 0.05409197509288788, -0.0031148679554462433, -0.025934316217899323, -0.03777128458023071, 0.028919726610183716, 0.027001619338989258, -0.006361833307892084, -0.018082013353705406, 0.0072405156679451466, -0.01045345701277256, 0.015560661442577839, -0.018254490569233894, -0.018167275935411453, -0.005790341645479202, -0.00949138030409813, 0.0018434205558151007, -0.02577856183052063, -0.05104762315750122, 0.031235838308930397, -0.050940174609422684, -0.01588446833193302, 0.023251425474882126, 0.027628527954220772, -0.029573563486337662, -0.015068805776536465, -0.019650792703032494, -0.05834678187966347, -0.022255659103393555, -0.01112934947013855, 0.003246928099542856, -0.06599204242229462, -0.03508820757269859, 0.025052407756447792, -0.030407719314098358, -0.014061925932765007, -0.025677399709820747, -0.051908619701862335, 0.05165460705757141, 0.00006358561222441494, -0.009831918403506279, -0.010865898802876472, -0.05060835927724838, 0.0029368987306952477, -0.11335735023021698, 0.06607935577630997, 0.049156226217746735, -0.03453299030661583, -0.02318459376692772, 0.001060807378962636, -0.06672309339046478, 0.004293676465749741, 0.04878953844308853, 0.01919829100370407, 0.030075356364250183, -0.00456510903313756, 0.03072289191186428, 0.013965457677841187, -0.03696181997656822, 0.04256761819124222, 0.013655857183039188, 0.013432796113193035, -0.03745466470718384, 0.002920714905485511, 0.03248273581266403, 0.004249838180840015, 0.02532455138862133, -0.0067121912725269794, 0.005806197877973318, 0.002185738179832697, 0.0043810592032969, 0.0239240899682045, -0.00997079536318779, -0.0406702384352684, 0.026447484269738197, 0.01507151871919632, 0.014026223681867123, 0.045805033296346664, -0.005701979156583548, -0.052650902420282364, -0.017561733722686768, -0.02536403015255928, -0.029068661853671074, 0.00891986582428217, -0.009720261208713055, 0.009132666513323784, -0.06018761172890663, -0.0009037145064212382, -0.008325760252773762, -0.012136640027165413, -0.009159778244793415, 0.036326225847005844, 0.019578201696276665, 0.030858175829052925, 0.03476295620203018, 0.007316816598176956, 0.026987485587596893, -0.024757197126746178, 0.027328116819262505, 0.004829923622310162, 0.01875016838312149, 0.030907733365893364, -0.002099138218909502, 0.038654156029224396, -0.006163373123854399, 0.03235926851630211, 0.010432674549520016, 0.03898826241493225, -0.03197891265153885, -0.014303614385426044, -0.004436868242919445, -0.007327877916395664, 0.04501982778310776, -0.04826849326491356, 0.027456436306238174, 0.04932966083288193, -0.03721315413713455, -0.005020579323172569, -0.02194201573729515, 0.00470763398334384, 0.009217123501002789, -0.028575975447893143, 0.01924845017492771, 0.00911669246852398, 0.007817333564162254, 0.0057174284011125565, -0.006782351993024349, 0.007560235448181629, 0.007632013875991106, -0.008430007845163345, -0.016551099717617035, -0.021930351853370667, -0.008459013886749744, 0.0009674222092144191, -0.02321227826178074, -0.045249249786138535, -0.011917381547391415, 0.052892960608005524, 0.058886848390102386, 0.028514809906482697, -0.02394895628094673, -0.011176011525094509, 0.00011067128070862964, 0.037751633673906326, -0.06887547671794891, -0.028401853516697884, -0.01985066756606102, 0.026757514104247093, 0.010358432307839394, -0.02408810704946518 ]
<p>The may sound like a strange question but I was wondering if a Pseudoinverse of a matrix could be found using SVD whether there was a graphical modelling equivalent that could be used to estimate the inverse of a matrix. </p>
73,586
[ -0.01710004173219204, 0.013258255086839199, -0.013944650068879128, -0.02222248539328575, 0.025849366560578346, 0.00680132070556283, -0.04352543130517006, 0.013094263151288033, 0.04000251740217209, -0.037749674171209335, 0.0040293061174452305, 0.0019078518962487578, 0.06883589923381805, 0.02298085018992424, 0.02524404600262642, 0.027910316362977028, -0.0057155475951731205, 0.007403803989291191, -0.0027907455805689096, 0.0007532229064963758, 0.027543092146515846, 0.004006971605122089, 0.005959767382591963, -0.010325057432055473, -0.02531532198190689, 0.0335509330034256, 0.026466945186257362, -0.027394190430641174, 0.008218892849981785, 0.04572532698512077, -0.04649927467107773, -0.012525941245257854, 0.03025781363248825, 0.04579625651240349, 0.04307475686073303, 0.009425338357686996, 0.009148565120995045, -0.031167279928922653, 0.004087952896952629, 0.04615625739097595, 0.03249454125761986, 0.012838993221521378, -0.0009373774519190192, 0.0866653099656105, -0.0021874625235795975, 0.05129147320985794, -0.02428138442337513, -0.009172594174742699, 0.031703390181064606, -0.047919731587171555, 0.12239693850278854, -0.0015616825548931956, 0.03183077275753021, 0.017345530912280083, -0.02340434491634369, 0.030366478487849236, 0.05880184844136238, 0.058864351361989975, 0.02287432923913002, -0.05799815058708191, 0.01471037045121193, -0.009354057721793652, -0.01721932739019394, -0.021617475897073746, -0.03326531872153282, 0.016452249139547348, -0.005415078718215227, -0.027994897216558456, 0.03372996672987938, -0.015758056193590164, -0.049251388758420944, -0.002319467021152377, 0.0234677717089653, 0.02608618326485157, 0.017577745020389557, -0.04420400783419609, -0.005106843542307615, 0.008757779374718666, 0.017617415636777878, -0.0005065397708676755, 0.0020252021495252848, 0.033444132655858994, 0.019302349537611008, 0.05167541280388832, -0.009464778937399387, 0.0032296946737915277, 0.037486087530851364, -0.04986998811364174, 0.009144360199570656, 0.027863964438438416, -0.029926955699920654, -0.0034103754442185163, 0.036219894886016846, 0.007276803720742464, -0.06650564074516296, 0.0023649565409868956, -0.007767431437969208, 0.05256292223930359, 0.03645392134785652, -0.02314971387386322, 0.02604290284216404, -0.01852656528353691, -0.028775116428732872, 0.03623494505882263, -0.022133581340312958, -0.0204255860298872, -0.0006751837208867073, 0.015149150975048542, 0.012259081937372684, -0.019266093149781227, -0.050394754856824875, 0.010328339412808418, 0.009988714940845966, -0.02616676688194275, 0.018881944939494133, -0.019788438454270363, -0.01589796133339405, -0.03863346576690674, 0.04347127676010132, 0.07618451863527298, -0.02288084104657173, -0.030129780992865562, 0.03347635641694069, -0.03608677163720131, -0.05973909795284271, -0.01840367540717125, 0.008740998804569244, -0.010535667650401592, -0.03757907450199127, 0.05912932753562927, 0.02488984726369381, -0.07825679332017899, 0.04753919318318367, -0.03313054144382477, 0.06839326024055481, -0.00394709687680006, -0.054396603256464005, -0.05506101995706558, 0.010426115244626999, -0.018797339871525764, 0.025366727262735367, -0.051005564630031586, 0.024630948901176453, 0.02893119677901268, 0.024802347645163536, 0.01675635203719139, 0.03193502500653267, 0.014078780077397823, 0.011175939813256264, -0.03089485876262188, 0.00007163314148783684, -0.019779589027166367, -0.003564462997019291, -0.03306751325726509, -0.016499655321240425, -0.055002402514219284, 0.01716306433081627, -0.0019912663847208023, -0.05045478790998459, 0.014201072044670582, 0.015452143736183643, 0.019975952804088593, -0.004334037657827139, 0.020405789837241173, -0.003986594267189503, -0.028699757531285286, 0.03969987481832504, -0.009945027530193329, -0.0064123282209038734, 0.003883705008774996, -0.03437875956296921, -0.005132689140737057, 0.022695688530802727, 0.056100357323884964, 0.04719028249382973, -0.0010623318376019597, -0.019706524908542633, 0.030309012159705162, 0.03166721761226654, -0.0036569610238075256, -0.057685017585754395, -0.010208634659647942, 0.04321853816509247, 0.014157398603856564, 0.0316237211227417, 0.0619746558368206, -0.029222678393125534, -0.04805014654994011, 0.039009712636470795, -0.03294426575303078, 0.0006141866324469447, -0.04782606288790703, 0.020989181473851204, 0.013976983726024628, 0.027294913306832314, 0.012616713531315327, 0.05361178144812584, 0.01545885019004345, -0.029778558760881424, -0.01543392427265644, -0.029589533805847168, 0.0030166038777679205, 0.020326508209109306, -0.02607670985162258, -0.013492811471223831, 0.024004608392715454, 0.07829505950212479, -0.04605232551693916, 0.020255109295248985, -0.053309015929698944, -0.05099038779735565, -0.01373809203505516, -0.05497646704316139, 0.032521944493055344, -0.010923387482762337, -0.003553119022399187, 0.026254640892148018, -0.010955355130136013, -0.023011671379208565, 0.003513204399496317, 0.0019838192965835333, 0.040706370025873184, 0.07175050675868988, 0.03961983323097229, 0.0012357097584754229, 0.002857370302081108, 0.03313690051436424, 0.01858336664736271, 0.0028739972040057182, -0.04350632056593895, -0.010962179861962795, -0.012768085114657879, 0.026461144909262657, 0.05277455225586891, -0.060194339603185654, 0.03764985501766205, 0.07355645298957825, 0.028198836371302605, 0.012763663195073605, -0.00986397359520197, -0.038170766085386276, 0.023775529116392136, 0.006609947886317968, -0.0021068528294563293, 0.0018205121159553528, 0.018999818712472916, -0.001371946302242577, 0.029050055891275406, 0.015629883855581284, -0.02305934950709343, -0.027737701311707497, 0.014844772405922413, -0.029343167319893837, -0.022027859464287758, 0.004033377859741449, -0.023972025141119957, 0.06407487392425537, -0.008249755017459393, 0.029114292934536934, 0.020338596776127815, -0.03812175989151001, 0.03122771345078945, 0.026914803311228752, -0.028848033398389816, 0.01826515421271324, 0.013043536804616451, -0.03157980740070343, -0.005095950793474913, 0.04916004091501236, -0.039238639175891876, 0.048699282109737396, -0.0393109992146492, 0.011246372945606709, -0.06432778388261795, 0.024086929857730865, 0.024996858090162277, 0.0034325825981795788, 0.018513130024075508, -0.0019153909524902701, -0.014381659217178822, -0.019333112984895706, -0.0403003916144371, 0.0335821807384491, 0.023900268599390984, -0.06243081018328667, 0.04215659946203232, -0.052961528301239014, -0.030574189499020576, 0.0006109460373409092, -0.011397418566048145, 0.007492730859667063, 0.03791341558098793, -0.05455880984663963, -0.06402839720249176, -0.012209047563374043, -0.06392139196395874, 0.030236363410949707, 0.020154934376478195, 0.022218262776732445, 0.0045608156360685825, 0.0038420504424721003, -0.015443837270140648, 0.0011458811350166798, -0.04766802862286568, -0.04115606099367142, -0.029187407344579697, -0.004819848574697971, 0.026604151353240013, -0.02227971702814102, 0.053069617599248886, 0.07075072079896927, -0.013123258017003536, 0.028608107939362526, -0.06277187168598175, -0.04175228253006935, 0.02602505497634411, 0.013911914080381393, 0.0005396061460487545, 0.03657384589314461, -0.0348130501806736, 0.08150874823331833, 0.0315236859023571, -0.04353589192032814, -0.02665703184902668, -0.0037096943706274033, 0.005526669789105654, -0.053574517369270325, 0.012617819011211395, -0.017402485013008118, -0.00034426539787091315, 0.024890344589948654, -0.004912540782243013, 0.0023361914791166782, 0.04124807193875313, -0.008673218078911304, -0.03728654608130455, 0.014940192922949791, -0.0050249542109668255, 0.023216361179947853, 0.01708887331187725, -0.03542434796690941, -0.018190080299973488, -0.008917088620364666, 0.0013466925593093038, 0.03488685190677643, 0.002266372088342905, -0.018382655456662178, 0.008828109130263329, -0.04103315621614456, 0.034701552242040634, 0.010752489790320396, 0.03467429056763649, 0.03738509118556976, 0.007500829640775919, -0.014520402066409588, 0.0812346562743187, 0.035207320004701614, -0.006088539492338896, 0.01288325060158968, 0.04634036868810654, 0.0007329785148613155, -0.006960401311516762, 0.011530794203281403, 0.01119311898946762, -0.0004565476847346872, 0.018660156056284904, -0.02498219721019268, -0.04623479023575783, 0.06995727866888046, 0.023992937058210373, -0.013976769521832466, 0.024840498343110085, -0.03357386216521263, 0.029745956882834435, -0.04145214334130287, 0.0059446473605930805, -0.04228803887963295, 0.025941645726561546, 0.002774047665297985, 0.014626117423176765, 0.027814721688628197, 0.006761590018868446, 0.004480996634811163, 0.010398981161415577, -0.06791269034147263, 0.0040893168188631535, -0.011180603876709938, -0.0026156213134527206, -0.009866101667284966, -0.005085840821266174, 0.05577203258872032, -0.03642651066184044, -0.02399761602282524, 0.03306637331843376, -0.0008313669823110104, -0.06820006668567657, -0.007869570516049862, -0.012077506631612778, 0.0038285867776721716, -0.017009159550070763, -0.013125372119247913, 0.052889302372932434, -0.04370121657848358, 0.007312744855880737, 0.03986232355237007, -0.03216356784105301, -0.015704937279224396, -0.009026949293911457, 0.009403635747730732, 0.02413365989923477, 0.039938703179359436, 0.03235621377825737, 0.02313985861837864, -0.06279134005308151, 0.0023681174498051405, 0.008447053842246532, 0.05532601475715637, 0.020393043756484985, 0.006217408459633589, -0.0286030862480402, -0.042300768196582794, -0.03764965385198593, 0.02314077317714691, 0.02154451794922352, -0.018715878948569298, 0.038996048271656036, 0.025407778099179268, 0.03306557238101959, -0.057732291519641876, 0.011003839783370495, 0.05827806517481804, 0.055527541786432266, -0.030459603294730186, -0.00703819515183568, -0.03556331992149353, -0.0014361056964844465, -0.031895916908979416, 0.012162880040705204, -0.01578790508210659, -0.022338125854730606, -0.000053668871260015294, 0.03206643462181091, 0.029780883342027664, 0.007454417180269957, 0.029835188761353493, 0.01365458220243454, 0.039361994713544846, 0.0072273691184818745, -0.009129057638347149, 0.015374146401882172, 0.04956277832388878, 0.04169765114784241, 0.020688340067863464, -0.00616611959412694, -0.10907424986362457, -0.00984513945877552, 0.03435815870761871, 0.041613850742578506, -0.03358457610011101, -0.009400765411555767, -0.03500057011842728, -0.04465055093169212, 0.049927812069654465, -0.02142786793410778, 0.03369104489684105, -0.010421225801110268, 0.02514832839369774, -0.022453011944890022, -0.014396440237760544, -0.008362943306565285, 0.03331073746085167, -0.017417296767234802, -0.01668601855635643, -0.03190404921770096, -0.01211400143802166, -0.04647571220993996, 0.0019434216665104032, 0.043270405381917953, 0.07772863656282425, 0.01154089905321598, 0.011622597463428974, -0.0016017953166738153, 0.05344972386956215, -0.045254919677972794, -0.05324510112404823, 0.002863472793251276, 0.05053732544183731, -0.07362619042396545, 0.05919945612549782, -0.00857800617814064, -0.03679627180099487, 0.022910894826054573, -0.016779351979494095, -0.014162152074277401, 0.00844181701540947, -0.0076626562513411045, 0.011478392407298088, 0.03626255318522453, -0.02155924029648304, 0.03271691873669624, 0.04610930010676384, -0.050918567925691605, -0.02076203189790249, -0.049949292093515396, 0.020464234054088593, -0.037748776376247406, -0.047642651945352554, -0.026193762198090553, 0.0019374997355043888, -0.027604535222053528, 0.016641436144709587, 0.02501549758017063, 0.029449397698044777, -0.005376399494707584, 0.00012749798770528287, -0.011136899702250957, 0.06670591235160828, 0.012181658297777176, -0.03219766169786453, 0.005670050159096718, 0.034702666103839874, 0.001957827713340521, -0.03558340668678284, -0.020102620124816895, 0.0045280447229743, -0.016262801364064217, 0.025962939485907555, -0.02739250846207142, -0.005598036572337151, -0.0021450442727655172, -0.023901119828224182, 0.009382516145706177, -0.037883564829826355, 0.015283245593309402, -0.04212309047579765, 0.005444265902042389, -0.008007640950381756, -0.04393387958407402, 0.04082896187901497, 0.02504732646048069, -0.01133547630161047, -0.013702429831027985, 0.00033028615871444345, 0.008295645006000996, 0.0000762871204642579, 0.0017825764371082187, -0.061336394399404526, -0.030910635367035866, 0.02225458435714245, 0.003855345072224736, -0.05800246074795723, -0.022732874378561974, -0.029869532212615013, -0.003849587868899107, -0.032750602811574936, 0.0115126334130764, 0.02651463821530342, -0.0338711179792881, -0.0033042561262845993, -0.005273567046970129, -0.0014389444841071963, 0.03829459846019745, 0.009197124280035496, -0.010520263575017452, 0.012722465209662914, -0.005043937359005213, -0.015248139388859272, 0.01747208461165428, 0.011152812279760838, -0.028467364609241486, 0.03599686175584793, -0.04081893339753151, 0.012079010717570782, 0.06380842626094818, -0.0011910682078450918, 0.026113994419574738, 0.02381003275513649, 0.006525235250592232, 0.013067049905657768, -0.01797853596508503, 0.011411127634346485, -0.03701702505350113, 0.02130875736474991, 0.01649969071149826, 0.003515814198181033, -0.02073380909860134, 0.02537498064339161, 0.02192329615354538, 0.010007286444306374, -0.038793064653873444, 0.019756468012928963, 0.08314092457294464, 0.016552375629544258, 0.013304289430379868, 0.0052644326351583, -0.016322670504450798, 0.016145387664437294, -0.02118535153567791, 0.013713405467569828, 0.020909668877720833, 0.03710358962416649, -0.05267031863331795, -0.05876118317246437, -0.013589102774858475, 0.03046153485774994, 0.06775534898042679, -0.0058669475838541985, 0.057669106870889664, 0.022017665207386017, 0.01883220486342907, -0.018368761986494064, -0.02312307432293892, 0.00836312398314476, -0.010787873528897762, -0.006050168536603451, 0.029325569048523903, -0.009670993313193321, -0.006292725447565317, 0.04479525610804558, 0.02265140786767006, 0.0076956660486757755, 0.03322313353419304, -0.015812791883945465, 0.024159938097000122, 0.04400216042995453, -0.005887220613658428, -0.04813505336642265, 0.04684961959719658, -0.024651193991303444, 0.02944382280111313, -0.007223780732601881, 0.00427203020080924, 0.042426660656929016, 0.004192414227873087, 0.004948901943862438, -0.020115111023187637, -0.023935792967677116, -0.04125487059354782, 0.046251293271780014, 0.005814321804791689, 0.03274954855442047, -0.012225527316331863, -0.008729732595384121, -0.008977795019745827, -0.034195635467767715, 0.03697165101766586, -0.024195965379476547, -0.11615313589572906, -0.007575338706374168, -0.008561967872083187, -0.00876534078270197, 0.019598092883825302, 0.046292804181575775, 0.016514241695404053, 0.00649996055290103, -0.033073920756578445, 0.0008753575966693461, -0.03270284831523895, 0.059472452849149704, 0.01634322479367256, 0.05424070358276367, 0.008472408168017864, 0.014424278400838375, -0.00959191657602787, -0.02299705520272255, 0.0863717645406723, 0.0703962966799736, 0.0073988973163068295, -0.05358980968594551, 0.02551169879734516, -0.03601391613483429, 0.0075424653477966785, -0.027858445420861244, 0.035926926881074905, -0.023625224828720093, 0.004841424524784088, 0.04683120921254158, 0.04342738166451454, 0.0005352352163754404, 0.003262897953391075, 0.06002255529165268, -0.030623290687799454, -0.0004169970634393394, -0.01881629228591919, 0.012947245500981808, -0.020082609727978706, -0.010883739218115807, -0.06187254562973976, 0.05355069786310196, -0.00441919406875968, -0.01638806425035, -0.04296985641121864, -0.005499610677361488, 0.00138205720577389, -0.00958628673106432, -0.023923061788082123, -0.002853211248293519, 0.01802470162510872, 0.02061290293931961, -0.005513993091881275, 0.020525572821497917, 0.010954600758850574, 0.029071643948554993, -0.002903658663854003, 0.03465771675109863, -0.0006263504619710147, -0.004375837277621031, -0.01549380924552679, 0.0010212616762146354, -0.0436587892472744, -0.0007282011792995036, -0.004193498287349939, 0.03455847501754761, -0.012596804648637772, 0.014075124636292458, 0.0005272386479191482, -0.010468713007867336, -0.014562676660716534, -0.023668982088565826, -0.04011755809187889, -0.014545995742082596, 0.03176653012633324, -0.020326124504208565, -0.02854056842625141, -0.022310111671686172, 0.03144870698451996, -0.012415445409715176, 0.05155563727021217, 0.005541072692722082, -0.051784027367830276, -0.022033601999282837, -0.019560985267162323, 0.07174069434404373, -0.005129095166921616, -0.05243862420320511, 0.009517546743154526, -0.011231862008571625, -0.004366820678114891, -0.06383845210075378, 0.032560091465711594, 0.014096134342253208, -0.0060327122919261456, -0.01565631665289402, 0.010167699307203293, -0.01930050179362297, -0.07622829079627991, 0.012834938243031502, -0.039520688354969025, 0.021147681400179863, -0.03947954252362251, 0.026070376858115196, 0.06639442592859268, 0.035803768783807755, -0.01272127591073513, 0.0019410767126828432, 0.00015633313159924, 0.0355091392993927, 0.0030112015083432198, -0.06903096288442612, -0.048570822924375534, -0.015575652942061424, -0.04864808917045593, 0.01826527714729309, 0.013985116966068745, 0.030674831941723824, 0.04834764450788498, -0.0028035775758326054, -0.03052511438727379, 0.035473428666591644, -0.0030984689947217703, 0.016739580780267715, -0.01271489541977644, -0.07712455093860626, 0.03420569375157356, -0.030591357499361038, -0.0055014342069625854, -0.004522956442087889, 0.01855996623635292, -0.017099622637033463, 0.024278253316879272, -0.030376072973012924, 0.024285994470119476, -0.010783812031149864, 0.006020002067089081, -0.01281294971704483, 0.03877348080277443, -0.038615595549345016, -0.012795260176062584, -0.0031712630297988653, 0.007190168835222721, 0.00867520086467266, -0.052205923944711685, -0.026458555832505226, 0.0003394500818103552, -0.008745632134377956, 0.0066820490173995495, 0.01250732596963644, 0.04290670156478882, -0.010908184573054314, -0.050204068422317505, 0.00521478895097971, 0.011797575280070305, 0.03806266933679581, -0.02871773950755596, -0.04167795553803444, 0.026393182575702667, -0.04180863872170448, -0.0391092523932457, 0.04990338534116745, -0.02917901612818241, 0.010466691106557846, 0.015670064836740494, -0.024227190762758255, -0.03142639622092247, 0.015359912998974323, -0.024637799710035324, -0.009047995321452618, 0.005427604075521231, -0.008669178001582623, -0.025151986628770828, 0.0011873539770022035, 0.018766513094305992, -0.03721514716744423, 0.0010395500576123595, 0.003659712616354227, 0.013123803772032261, -0.008668476715683937, -0.0549662746489048, 0.0260482095181942, -0.0187702514231205, 0.013520858250558376, 0.04310818389058113, -0.015799490734934807, 0.032250892370939255, 0.02621784806251526, -0.033160366117954254, 0.02074018120765686, 0.036308903247117996, 0.028987674042582512, -0.10626671463251114, -0.028704214841127396, 0.02824908122420311, 0.011113998480141163, 0.038069069385528564, -0.08292069286108017, 0.03062869980931282, 0.036684177815914154, -0.10199782997369766, 0.03727336227893829, 0.005512096453458071, -0.02089189924299717, -0.008774944581091404, -0.006440681405365467, -0.022236347198486328, 0.04013464227318764, 0.009723625145852566, 0.038147296756505966, 0.028682326897978783, 0.0013259005500003695, 0.0024901553988456726, -0.026336034759879112, -0.025999082252383232, -0.00819757767021656, 0.03228137642145157, -0.05390148609876633, 0.0190882571041584, -0.042058706283569336, -0.03144697844982147, 0.004038290120661259, -0.026790646836161613, 0.037007421255111694, 0.014215139672160149, 0.03760957345366478, -0.008261919021606445, 0.03316852077841759, 0.0364157073199749, -0.004860499408096075, -0.0018340530805289745, -0.043574362993240356, -0.010528776794672012, 0.028385447338223457, -0.007069867569953203, 0.052692711353302, 0.00141299853567034, -0.0031738728284835815, -0.007868822664022446, -0.011331059038639069, -0.02346309833228588, -0.05257132649421692, -0.012762654572725296, -0.033458203077316284, -0.008099332451820374, -0.040877748280763626, 0.02107951045036316, -0.06968586891889572, 0.0032859300263226032, -0.011947611346840858, 0.021712785586714745, -0.024306876584887505, 0.02880135551095009, -0.0038300573360174894, -0.039860889315605164, 0.0495251789689064, -0.0003215318429283798, -0.0038712909445166588, -0.07727400213479996, -0.02212553098797798, 0.020635148510336876, -0.014960334636271, -0.003700443310663104, -0.046023957431316376, -0.003826051251962781, 0.07725062966346741, 0.020425476133823395, 0.006177878472954035, 0.030931083485484123, -0.012307518161833286, -0.010116473771631718, -0.04171198233962059, 0.05247769504785538, -0.006939196493476629, -0.04232367128133774, 0.01630977727472782, 0.04538414627313614, 0.005948894657194614, -0.024209892377257347, 0.02842789515852928, -0.023909496143460274, 0.0024994374252855778, 0.00120194919873029, 0.02201829105615616, -0.002873604651540518, -0.02134880982339382, 0.01250762864947319, -0.015597137622535229, -0.018630921840667725, -0.01962335780262947, -0.03607635572552681, -0.004173145163804293, 0.010356671176850796, 0.019437599927186966, -0.0026229971554130316, -0.008313865400850773, 0.01662132516503334, -0.03640510141849518, 0.031719792634248734, 0.0350656658411026, -0.015607651323080063, 0.06904645264148712, -0.020751170814037323, -0.004476860631257296, 0.021581241860985756, -0.021081842482089996, -0.016443034633994102, 0.01825944148004055, -0.00821823813021183, 0.0032592311035841703, -0.008125197142362595, -0.0012858881382271647, 0.006033045239746571, -0.04212276637554169, -0.03197663649916649, 0.03444022685289383, -0.019496941938996315, 0.020722521468997, 0.032496377825737, 0.0141812888905406, 0.011697170324623585, -0.032986558973789215, 0.029029948636889458, 0.03382648527622223, 0.008148327469825745, 0.01765969954431057, 0.022490935400128365, 0.01202654279768467, -0.0024538321886211634, 0.013246418908238411, 0.0228352639824152, -0.0013033936265856028, 0.04249989613890648, -0.01859300397336483, 0.030963104218244553, -0.022149227559566498, 0.020010603591799736, 0.031155593693256378, -0.02299877256155014, 0.020934883505105972, -0.003518091281875968, -0.026955334469676018, 0.04948592185974121, -0.027627479285001755, 0.0007212957716546953, -0.048015013337135315, 0.0032201509457081556, -0.05028446391224861, -0.026210404932498932, 0.029478710144758224, 0.03225817531347275, -0.01772029511630535, -0.0071555934846401215, 0.006715882569551468, -0.002126345643773675, 0.015909582376480103, 0.0021074507385492325, 0.0197040643543005, -0.03924528509378433, 0.008865606039762497, 0.0010641188127920032, -0.0024952073581516743, -0.04466750845313072, 0.004859598353505135, 0.025425370782613754, 0.045745715498924255, 0.011912140063941479, 0.012973049655556679, -0.013212609104812145, 0.0023767510429024696, 0.041053541004657745, -0.07949166744947433, -0.024667810648679733, 0.004663888830691576, 0.010769758373498917, -0.011659437790513039, -0.02011890336871147 ]
<p>A question from a harried doctoral candidate working on dissertation revisions.</p> <p>What is the current opinion about how to include and interpret 3-way interactions in linear models? If the p-value for a 3-way interaction is not meaningful to interpret, how does one address--both substantively and empirically--important intersections of three key variables using experimental data?</p> <p>References on already on hand: </p> <pre><code>Kam, Cindy D. and Robert J. Franzese, Jr. 2007. Modeling and Interpreting Interactive Hypotheses in Regression Analysis. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Braumoeller,Bear F. Hypothesis Testing and Multiplicative Interaction Terms International Organization , Vol. 58, No. 4 (Autumn, 2004), pp. 807-820 Article Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3877804 </code></pre>
73,587
[ -0.03277169167995453, -0.005260429345071316, 0.0015214604791253805, -0.0029159891419112682, 0.06826557964086533, 0.03206956759095192, 0.004799151327461004, -0.004941033199429512, 0.0449218712747097, 0.008602271787822247, 0.05240074172616005, -0.007658732123672962, 0.036113664507865906, -0.02058241330087185, 0.002393676433712244, 0.01655319146811962, 0.01010417565703392, -0.026119377464056015, 0.013207618147134781, -0.00235768617130816, -0.011781524866819382, 0.024719979614019394, -0.026981323957443237, 0.009471822530031204, -0.027528565376996994, 0.03278609365224838, 0.021579017862677574, 0.0025256250519305468, 0.028067268431186676, 0.013801873661577702, -0.0030823242850601673, -0.026049474254250526, 0.004135871771723032, 0.028866002336144447, -0.00568469287827611, -0.005204642191529274, 0.0001004531659418717, -0.0023085116408765316, 0.019607922062277794, 0.0692114382982254, -0.00610771868377924, 0.01737898960709572, 0.01517859660089016, 0.036195024847984314, -0.010834557935595512, 0.011520258150994778, -0.010885530151426792, -0.007480732165277004, 0.061150457710027695, -0.023740999400615692, 0.040381185710430145, 0.014870325103402138, -0.003493567230179906, 0.0051506622694432735, -0.038185909390449524, -0.0027458900585770607, 0.04124543070793152, 0.07576241344213486, 0.009774166159331799, -0.04410497471690178, 0.010986559092998505, -0.012914820574223995, 0.02081242762506008, 0.0056618331000208855, -0.0590665303170681, 0.05134603753685951, -0.00008181373414117843, -0.028422752395272255, 0.06972750276327133, -0.03449513763189316, -0.0196798425167799, -0.017133869230747223, 0.04215870425105095, 0.024691468104720116, 0.006793120410293341, -0.0075196572579443455, 0.007994205690920353, 0.015263820998370647, 0.04269242286682129, 0.02929011918604374, -0.017958367243409157, 0.007469562813639641, -0.025548679754137993, 0.052730970084667206, 0.033476367592811584, 0.007298159413039684, 0.06855307519435883, -0.037391822785139084, 0.012996954843401909, -0.019069598987698555, -0.06113789230585098, 0.005956416949629784, 0.03213942423462868, 0.0009418493718840182, -0.03501034900546074, 0.024657515808939934, -0.028769025579094887, 0.02492547035217285, 0.011501769535243511, 0.006769146770238876, -0.04453137516975403, -0.03295741602778435, -0.02146218717098236, 0.027627496048808098, -0.009963413700461388, -0.035393279045820236, -0.05718281492590904, 0.026589395478367805, 0.004052130971103907, -0.05545487627387047, -0.023357592523097992, 0.045364633202552795, 0.03651932254433632, 0.005811978131532669, 0.0244959257543087, -0.001959624933078885, 0.0027840330731123686, 0.014554467983543873, 0.06930781900882721, 0.025650715455412865, 0.05407201871275902, -0.029914425686001778, 0.023629533126950264, -0.013480667024850845, -0.06309150904417038, -0.008817250840365887, 0.018058424815535545, -0.006402605678886175, -0.036588992923498154, 0.06622812896966934, 0.034589704126119614, -0.0043504382483661175, -0.0032807206735014915, -0.017264418303966522, 0.011701150797307491, 0.018748756498098373, -0.08282479643821716, -0.040079496800899506, 0.016215408220887184, 0.010096808895468712, -0.022241560742259026, -0.08729442954063416, -0.041592787951231, 0.011075823567807674, 0.10077432543039322, -0.00033164588967338204, -0.017617041245102882, 0.012509245425462723, 0.02361239120364189, 0.04264722764492035, -0.04011444002389908, -0.025441966950893402, -0.012923263013362885, -0.0019733072258532047, -0.005126662086695433, -0.060845114290714264, -0.003752131247892976, 0.01645282469689846, 0.008057119324803352, 0.027841245755553246, 0.07757530361413956, 0.03241727128624916, -0.004899796098470688, 0.028337540104985237, 0.011104217730462551, 0.012717293575406075, 0.0655660405755043, -0.05493632331490517, 0.04127373546361923, 0.0013995397603139281, 0.03531387820839882, 0.025468962267041206, -0.019807565957307816, 0.07812479883432388, 0.029020996764302254, -0.03753138706088066, 0.014761882834136486, -0.040250152349472046, -0.033929552882909775, -0.0285266675055027, -0.04242546111345291, -0.02927137166261673, -0.019030287861824036, -0.019435372203588486, 0.007069035433232784, 0.033984679728746414, -0.00625775009393692, -0.02086082473397255, 0.019446633756160736, -0.007981406524777412, -0.047360263764858246, -0.0918947383761406, 0.01853886805474758, -0.01901155151426792, -0.05464235693216324, 0.04862746596336365, -0.009377118200063705, 0.03275587782263756, -0.024589642882347107, -0.011569937691092491, -0.006432581227272749, 0.006069179158657789, 0.03555189445614815, -0.027235334739089012, 0.015638567507267, 0.05926451459527016, 0.05773633345961571, -0.03119555674493313, -0.006502780131995678, -0.05002906545996666, -0.03721106797456741, 0.06062709912657738, -0.031410444527864456, 0.011789325624704361, -0.016762057319283485, 0.012247818522155285, -0.016701126471161842, 0.018501771613955498, -0.027929432690143585, 0.03824131190776825, -0.07423729449510574, 0.0009467627387493849, 0.04954095557332039, 0.002827655291184783, 0.022750623524188995, 0.057304054498672485, 0.01868312992155552, 0.02456044591963291, -0.012452203780412674, -0.020816471427679062, -0.03510197997093201, -0.034574784338474274, 0.006502657197415829, -0.0072260587476193905, -0.03854505717754364, 0.028441276401281357, 0.0490679070353508, 0.010314964689314365, -0.017384953796863556, 0.05084818974137306, -0.023755498230457306, 0.008331858552992344, 0.009480134584009647, 0.0021463786251842976, 0.009188405238091946, -0.003910934552550316, 0.020838914439082146, 0.002965693362057209, 0.053900618106126785, -0.0032470382284373045, -0.014824267476797104, 0.03626742959022522, -0.015388819389045238, 0.04366094619035721, -0.012864398770034313, 0.03383750468492508, 0.011314860545098782, -0.03757890686392784, 0.0069772182032465935, 0.060428570955991745, 0.015124058350920677, 0.0026991895865648985, 0.03489893674850464, -0.02524675242602825, 0.0034566749818623066, 0.016189269721508026, -0.013840321451425552, -0.0026530285831540823, 0.018523020669817924, -0.031205812469124794, 0.0011258849408477545, -0.04118068143725395, -0.025821877643465996, -0.006135451607406139, 0.014676760882139206, 0.01040272694081068, 0.006958771031349897, 0.01923869363963604, -0.051934126764535904, -0.035323817282915115, -0.017017550766468048, 0.002212424064055085, -0.0007859848556108773, -0.0007593065965920687, -0.03273852914571762, -0.03193606063723564, -0.029048319905996323, -0.001595627865754068, 0.01463507954031229, -0.02202763967216015, 0.0012388131581246853, 0.02166430838406086, -0.013613075017929077, -0.05562914162874222, -0.04541284963488579, -0.0002103108708979562, -0.0191896203905344, -0.014034070074558258, -0.0385892428457737, -0.01555995550006628, 0.004443578887730837, -0.02367260679602623, 0.030957931652665138, -0.01797512173652649, -0.02128279209136963, 0.018293648958206177, -0.0031123911030590534, -0.0007854847353883088, -0.013692976906895638, 0.007269378751516342, 0.00318711344152689, -0.008820527233183384, -0.013415437191724777, -0.07316620647907257, -0.06183110922574997, 0.009774492122232914, 0.020201358944177628, 0.017452294006943703, 0.004603653214871883, -0.02275702729821205, 0.020109182223677635, -0.006451702676713467, -0.03045913204550743, -0.006382062565535307, -0.00850993674248457, -0.029534151777625084, -0.011395757086575031, 0.03465067967772484, -0.005501330830156803, 0.016500521451234818, 0.056428615003824234, -0.03823190554976463, 0.022911731153726578, 0.003075849497690797, 0.03426116704940796, -0.008877728134393692, 0.031045008450746536, -0.001400741864927113, 0.01852673664689064, 0.006220763549208641, 0.019555697217583656, 0.005002166610211134, 0.013675837777554989, -0.03597331419587135, -0.004760411102324724, 0.03532194718718529, -0.04561404511332512, 0.03250761702656746, -0.018339015543460846, -0.0024656939785927534, -0.011005903594195843, 0.010306784883141518, 0.03184884786605835, 0.018342314288020134, 0.0017862542299553752, -0.00035324651980772614, 0.04842746630311012, -0.00843714363873005, 0.026495713740587234, 0.04881589114665985, 0.030812252312898636, -0.003157193074002862, -0.031322967261075974, -0.010359707288444042, -0.003018637653440237, -0.015895122662186623, -0.007194538600742817, 0.013614023104310036, 0.022448599338531494, 0.0368940494954586, -0.02514895424246788, -0.008044037036597729, -0.03639949858188629, -0.02305758185684681, -0.08324627578258514, 0.006599548738449812, -0.03868071362376213, -0.01157733891159296, -0.02101852558553219, 0.05323250591754913, 0.016882799565792084, -0.009785906411707401, 0.0018137397710233927, -0.02896270714700222, -0.05071740597486496, 0.061261311173439026, -0.010707922279834747, 0.015685977414250374, 0.030790360644459724, -0.007994648069143295, 0.04415307566523552, -0.03556553274393082, -0.03037128783762455, 0.0010404086206108332, 0.006688759662210941, -0.047773752361536026, 0.006697217468172312, -0.021827036514878273, -0.03088952787220478, -0.011202299036085606, 0.0577741414308548, 0.052173249423503876, -0.014774740673601627, 0.02935205213725567, 0.03785088285803795, -0.043936025351285934, -0.042096082121133804, -0.02618347480893135, -0.022523555904626846, 0.03886871412396431, 0.048157211393117905, 0.024722354486584663, 0.012010679580271244, -0.012928243726491928, 0.040767401456832886, -0.0013146997662261128, 0.02477410063147545, 0.013710805214941502, -0.007576276082545519, -0.04430489242076874, -0.03883373364806175, -0.003710738383233547, 0.0001552952453494072, 0.04258790612220764, 0.009749319404363632, 0.04177796095609665, 0.06523924320936203, 0.03039965033531189, -0.05183756351470947, 0.06635195761919022, 0.024331294000148773, 0.029984692111611366, -0.024145018309354782, -0.05627705156803131, -0.009436982683837414, -0.01145841833204031, -0.0397956557571888, 0.00885021686553955, -0.005722859408706427, 0.013074218295514584, -0.006103182211518288, 0.05043064430356026, -0.019655950367450714, -0.01707940176129341, 0.025335755199193954, 0.0045580631121993065, 0.029640018939971924, 0.002746395766735077, -0.05260758101940155, 0.020633216947317123, 0.08239790052175522, 0.02487262524664402, 0.013253883458673954, 0.004647442139685154, -0.09045787155628204, 0.038450367748737335, 0.05103137344121933, 0.09226447343826294, -0.04845993593335152, -0.011728459969162941, 0.00039673689752817154, 0.0074164592660963535, 0.011444282718002796, -0.02373996004462242, 0.02164245769381523, -0.01286573801189661, -0.00786830298602581, -0.04569654166698456, -0.03686430677771568, -0.03172263130545616, 0.008534037508070469, 0.0027841837145388126, -0.020725401118397713, -0.02412998676300049, -0.027728015556931496, -0.011226207949221134, 0.053979985415935516, 0.06897883117198944, -0.009581927210092545, -0.025123678147792816, 0.005862105172127485, 0.021372534334659576, 0.006619238294661045, -0.013810107484459877, -0.07744431495666504, 0.06349639594554901, 0.010379227809607983, -0.012646044604480267, 0.06983338296413422, 0.0007196268998086452, -0.02300107292830944, -0.011892525479197502, 0.00133882078807801, -0.02168124169111252, -0.0024274555034935474, 0.01750219613313675, 0.04545479267835617, 0.020619560033082962, 0.004936060402542353, 0.07936213910579681, 0.021708237007260323, -0.033681340515613556, -0.03486810624599457, 0.006905639078468084, 0.007708367425948381, -0.03940558806061745, 0.004715688060969114, -0.03967605531215668, 0.010445352643728256, -0.022334756329655647, 0.03037961572408676, -0.0010076025500893593, -0.01223921962082386, -0.04717015475034714, 0.014600182883441448, -0.014048431999981403, -0.015722457319498062, -0.03409653156995773, 0.0031663936097174883, -0.0012164288200438023, -0.028716910630464554, -0.008325035683810711, -0.018991619348526, 0.012843589298427105, -0.017044728621840477, 0.010549183934926987, 0.0003067432844545692, -0.018057435750961304, 0.022294431924819946, -0.020864510908722878, -0.04865320399403572, -0.00023095305368769914, -0.02060762792825699, 0.018341021612286568, -0.0329112634062767, 0.01715739257633686, -0.030131757259368896, -0.0036078598350286484, -0.005338071845471859, 0.005559761077165604, 0.031054673716425896, 0.007343977689743042, 0.00526199396699667, 0.06221912056207657, -0.032886993139982224, 0.017828531563282013, -0.027975352481007576, -0.036214448511600494, 0.04186926409602165, -0.019207287579774857, -0.018284188583493233, -0.011399210430681705, -0.013113975524902344, -0.04155634343624115, -0.0098351389169693, -0.02482723817229271, 0.060403671115636826, -0.07018621265888214, -0.031661536544561386, -0.0024655519519001245, 0.03748052567243576, 0.062363188713788986, -0.0053590633906424046, -0.021444840356707573, 0.02135973423719406, -0.004811498802155256, 0.004675181116908789, -0.02733038365840912, -0.01164417527616024, -0.004840914160013199, -0.017734717577695847, -0.021646833047270775, -0.006665181368589401, 0.03695710003376007, -0.028399940580129623, -0.015772247686982155, 0.02665058895945549, -0.011153279803693295, 0.015695594251155853, -0.007287460379302502, 0.0006971423281356692, -0.0061071207746863365, 0.014668166637420654, -0.009122729301452637, 0.020940599963068962, -0.015074548311531544, 0.027749044820666313, 0.05360562726855278, -0.021630849689245224, -0.07031681388616562, 0.021041059866547585, 0.042308736592531204, 0.04045579209923744, 0.07214541733264923, -0.005768748000264168, -0.026546020060777664, 0.046855125576257706, -0.019928062334656715, -0.008101352490484715, -0.007060815580189228, 0.012539846822619438, -0.03958498314023018, -0.03693243861198425, -0.03276142105460167, 0.0013501335633918643, 0.045807160437107086, -0.049752190709114075, 0.033692341297864914, 0.07372704148292542, -0.013459968380630016, -0.026446430012583733, -0.03844164311885834, 0.028975514695048332, -0.027100820094347, 0.04295523464679718, 0.026102272793650627, -0.03310692310333252, -0.0078886142000556, 0.06396890431642532, 0.028174228966236115, -0.0058521730825304985, 0.010001128539443016, 0.023703759536147118, 0.014964552596211433, 0.03875703364610672, -0.054538656026124954, -0.0565008819103241, 0.08193222433328629, -0.05208718404173851, 0.011275794357061386, 0.009204250760376453, -0.0016541260993108153, 0.05099530890583992, 0.025684477761387825, 0.013930892571806908, -0.05449509620666504, -0.005700329318642616, -0.03940815478563309, -0.025800641626119614, 0.0366039015352726, -0.010095714591443539, 0.020649392157793045, -0.013798519037663937, 0.06141982972621918, -0.000619305472355336, -0.006128747947514057, -0.03755158558487892, -0.08344899117946625, -0.031712550669908524, -0.013109873980283737, 0.020713182166218758, 0.019482016563415527, -0.015145251527428627, -0.0173067394644022, 0.014292404055595398, -0.021189166232943535, 0.0030852940399199724, 0.04796415939927101, 0.055868588387966156, -0.02637431211769581, 0.06565117090940475, -0.010939315892755985, 0.004802637733519077, 0.012351579032838345, -0.024279017001390457, 0.10792069137096405, 0.06514657288789749, 0.025047075003385544, -0.06458594650030136, 0.05342565476894379, -0.011377856135368347, 0.006016268394887447, -0.03505926579236984, 0.010785708203911781, 0.0012708636932075024, -0.015492022037506104, 0.03459670767188072, 0.06235088035464287, 0.018322426825761795, 0.007592509500682354, 0.0413895882666111, -0.004149870481342077, -0.049351245164871216, 0.0016332858940586448, 0.01754697598516941, -0.028814587742090225, -0.056470971554517746, -0.013259119354188442, -0.021605530753731728, -0.009699207730591297, -0.02239561639726162, -0.001387089374475181, -0.005064594559371471, 0.013686557300388813, 0.036825451999902725, -0.02508152835071087, 0.02391486056149006, 0.011384021490812302, 0.048446498811244965, -0.018433891236782074, 0.012319095432758331, -0.009823529981076717, -0.028076911345124245, -0.004336553625762463, 0.03166384622454643, -0.011849752627313137, -0.019836697727441788, 0.0008780535426922143, 0.033547114580869675, -0.0753835067152977, -0.03807268664240837, 0.03620144724845886, 0.036282166838645935, 0.012236453592777252, -0.04065721854567528, -0.06102811545133591, -0.008028862997889519, 0.007026702631264925, -0.013420600444078445, -0.047587424516677856, 0.012625674717128277, 0.014456198550760746, -0.04900987073779106, -0.03485914692282677, -0.011143522337079048, 0.00601376686245203, -0.01571856066584587, 0.02534131146967411, 0.02807854302227497, -0.02577010542154312, 0.0061256359331309795, -0.03641395643353462, 0.04593881219625473, 0.008391831070184708, 0.0036132128443568945, -0.035944677889347076, 0.02863629348576069, -0.03901029750704765, 0.009026001207530499, -0.003985625226050615, 0.012214886024594307, 0.006881576497107744, 0.012241799384355545, -0.00801913719624281, -0.038181912153959274, -0.014142499305307865, -0.004615745972841978, -0.02031926065683365, -0.008328777737915516, -0.0493592768907547, -0.007468813098967075, 0.040361188352108, -0.007726612500846386, -0.0075691211968660355, 0.009307491593062878, 0.011592922732234001, 0.03909111022949219, 0.000778369081672281, -0.058215174823999405, -0.033246543258428574, -0.0001822835620259866, -0.038255542516708374, -0.004708525724709034, -0.0072725433856248856, 0.03580058738589287, 0.009352926164865494, 0.02295519784092903, 0.0074554188176989555, 0.012702517211437225, -0.024755379185080528, -0.01270705834031105, 0.04580649361014366, -0.042623624205589294, -0.00414193794131279, 0.03701736405491829, 0.0061982013285160065, -0.00820204894989729, -0.02105390839278698, -0.0076800077222287655, -0.009264870546758175, -0.0044196415692567825, -0.05082599073648453, -0.06869266927242279, 0.0046402993611991405, -0.03621474653482437, 0.032151419669389725, -0.03695305809378624, -0.013825721107423306, -0.06879275292158127, -0.02635517157614231, 0.020405935123562813, -0.014127162285149097, 0.014294837601482868, -0.00680065480992198, -0.020447755232453346, 0.02996298298239708, 0.03068147599697113, -0.015490696765482426, -0.01140439510345459, -0.007121277507394552, 0.007015638053417206, 0.029002543538808823, 0.015907282009720802, -0.01102225948125124, -0.03551831841468811, 0.047114573419094086, -0.0436650849878788, 0.009365017525851727, -0.010719308629631996, 0.0025490333791822195, 0.06236305087804794, -0.006202090531587601, 0.010351601988077164, -0.006306759547442198, 0.010993348434567451, -0.003671669401228428, 0.020768005400896072, 0.006947767920792103, -0.023007620126008987, -0.02298683673143387, -0.011843961663544178, 0.004259723238646984, 0.008980536833405495, -0.03793109208345413, 0.025677701458334923, 0.04250373691320419, 0.00632887938991189, 0.01618785597383976, -0.027594784274697304, -0.024767540395259857, 0.01651335507631302, -0.010273212566971779, -0.031043285503983498, 0.02026158757507801, 0.05896298587322235, -0.025384938344359398, 0.04820317402482033, 0.013555964455008507, 0.005500088445842266, -0.08186966180801392, -0.0021086300257593393, -0.02814767323434353, 0.03720810264348984, 0.021978240460157394, -0.058884941041469574, 0.0006389208137989044, 0.0038236533291637897, -0.022620389237999916, 0.006414989475160837, -0.007854827679693699, -0.0287267304956913, -0.027097318321466446, -0.007606034632772207, -0.018444176763296127, 0.010435238480567932, -0.0027964285109192133, -0.0016274817753583193, -0.00568879209458828, 0.007665530312806368, -0.007158959284424782, -0.006815612781792879, 0.005644050892442465, 0.04713411629199982, 0.011956639587879181, -0.050053928047418594, 0.029889576137065887, -0.007639423478394747, -0.03640320897102356, 0.06010836362838745, 0.013768775388598442, 0.044974904507398605, 0.001907265861518681, -0.003002878511324525, -0.0007679479895159602, 0.027756787836551666, 0.06369877606630325, 0.002981023397296667, -0.028179248794913292, 0.010549619793891907, 0.01605207473039627, 0.049866825342178345, 0.00763750821352005, -0.004892075899988413, -0.004984518978744745, -0.005813200492411852, -0.029291294515132904, 0.0022586677223443985, -0.05636455491185188, 0.0029520918615162373, -0.0069555784575641155, -0.0387355200946331, 0.013854465447366238, -0.010957934893667698, 0.03786197304725647, -0.04730554297566414, -0.0412224680185318, -0.003156703896820545, 0.04846516251564026, -0.030433639883995056, 0.018218042328953743, -0.009605227038264275, -0.01590937003493309, 0.03452793508768082, -0.018367858603596687, 0.027063138782978058, -0.06266000866889954, -0.0008656096761114895, 0.0029000716749578714, -0.014573642052710056, -0.044344786554574966, -0.0063539352267980576, -0.053262859582901, 0.052228644490242004, -0.029369013383984566, -0.00837797112762928, 0.015157181769609451, -0.05304897576570511, 0.057551059871912, -0.076862633228302, 0.06528955698013306, 0.041667718440294266, 0.03278465196490288, -0.0469299778342247, -0.02418391779065132, -0.03115827776491642, -0.020214766263961792, 0.045206718146800995, 0.011136619374155998, -0.010924449190497398, -0.025295719504356384, 0.034563079476356506, 0.007722142618149519, -0.015070310793817043, 0.023175090551376343, 0.004880979191511869, 0.014897330664098263, 0.006775529123842716, -0.027577808126807213, 0.04437273368239403, 0.0032834892626851797, 0.04245474562048912, 0.02111603505909443, 0.03399094194173813, 0.04168297350406647, -0.019392555579543114, 0.03790988400578499, 0.027600130066275597, -0.0081825852394104, 0.054582301527261734, 0.0224554892629385, 0.06134405359625816, 0.05853865295648575, 0.016351910308003426, -0.04152069240808487, 0.047791458666324615, -0.009034550748765469, -0.021167129278182983, -0.00949520617723465, -0.015270764008164406, 0.005459926091134548, -0.054430749267339706, 0.009138275869190693, 0.021213306114077568, -0.035940077155828476, -0.0071023195050656796, 0.0038404965307563543, 0.019502343609929085, 0.0406845360994339, 0.008870280347764492, 0.04330696538090706, 0.029555410146713257, -0.028636004775762558, 0.019847603514790535, 0.015432116575539112, 0.04923115670681, 0.03301217406988144, -0.004576333332806826, 0.05086709186434746, -0.017743395641446114, 0.01700807362794876, 0.015508987940847874, -0.006966820918023586, 0.008113152347505093, -0.01514195092022419, 0.05431092530488968, 0.018102219328284264, 0.03279995545744896, -0.0009523508488200605, 0.022996166720986366, 0.036034464836120605, -0.026211056858301163, 0.007321447134017944, -0.006336423568427563, 0.012135500088334084, -0.029717855155467987, 0.004572241101413965, 0.02373948134481907, 0.019960911944508553, -0.023847617208957672, 0.013940312899649143, -0.0376199446618557, -0.014765891246497631, 0.0166047140955925, -0.000838243926409632, 0.018382545560598373, -0.05270654335618019, -0.004081623628735542, -0.04378635063767433, -0.02845100685954094, -0.028387080878019333, -0.037690989673137665, 0.045100707560777664, 0.028878388926386833, 0.02268190309405327, -0.05320660397410393, 0.020623892545700073, -0.014949364587664604, 0.05080358684062958, -0.06554242968559265, -0.025022456422448158, -0.050461918115615845, 0.02633768878877163, 0.033506397157907486, -0.014068379066884518 ]
<p>Suppose we have n by n covariance matrix of n normal random variables. Is there program where we plug in sample values for k of the n variables and the program, by using the covariance matrix and these k values, generates samples for the remaining n-k variables ?</p>
35,997
[ -0.02411639876663685, 0.01731163263320923, 0.010506540536880493, -0.01778879016637802, 0.051018696278333664, -0.01355407852679491, -0.045947182923555374, -0.03121265210211277, 0.018029775470495224, -0.04278505966067314, 0.01098331343382597, 0.055659931153059006, 0.031665902584791183, 0.033785268664360046, 0.02113679051399231, 0.017835361883044243, -0.030391694977879524, -0.008730556815862656, -0.0017352846916764975, -0.0208451971411705, -0.017150921747088432, 0.04194914549589157, 0.027665847912430763, -0.02543553337454796, -0.019263962283730507, 0.005352822598069906, 0.0319693349301815, -0.03526243567466736, 0.04731065034866333, 0.03547937422990799, -0.06543854624032974, 0.0006811568164266646, 0.013195529580116272, 0.07062555104494095, 0.002586039947345853, -0.005642476957291365, 0.0054087028838694096, -0.03946217894554138, 0.0031951095443218946, -0.007867961190640926, -0.046431172639131546, -0.023364311084151268, -0.020394910126924515, 0.049689341336488724, 0.025647392496466637, 0.032693050801754, -0.036025192588567734, -0.06353937089443207, 0.008983602747321129, -0.04873395338654518, 0.11503332108259201, 0.004500060807913542, 0.03722003474831581, 0.024431321769952774, -0.008011099882423878, 0.022787699475884438, 0.05967869982123375, 0.056075822561979294, 0.009693339467048645, -0.05002768710255623, 0.006149687338620424, -0.011818294413387775, -0.008201347663998604, 0.009084759280085564, -0.0381116159260273, 0.0016099035274237394, -0.01686307229101658, 0.007506521884351969, 0.024588342756032944, -0.049089279025793076, -0.023261265829205513, 0.036387134343385696, 0.03141232952475548, -0.031155280768871307, -0.017049673944711685, -0.012465367093682289, 0.0012452227529138327, -0.02683817408978939, 0.04487133398652077, -0.005446125287562609, 0.022937152534723282, 0.028426485136151314, 0.014279537834227085, 0.025712698698043823, 0.004419844131916761, -0.020923545584082603, 0.05148246884346008, -0.07673484086990356, 0.045383188873529434, 0.0434451587498188, -0.025031479075551033, -0.013146156445145607, 0.07138100266456604, 0.02259715460240841, -0.06428549438714981, 0.010767286643385887, -0.01637791097164154, 0.03863738104701042, -0.0010373241966590285, -0.012305532582104206, 0.016352087259292603, -0.03727991133928299, 0.01705365814268589, 0.03759795054793358, -0.004052399192005396, 0.013866014778614044, -0.0032274345867335796, -0.002678295597434044, 0.014280112460255623, 0.008289391174912453, -0.031543586403131485, 0.0276030283421278, 0.014190850779414177, 0.008645748719573021, 0.0468730591237545, -0.02732127346098423, -0.02070850506424904, -0.03300382196903229, 0.042604923248291016, 0.0988774448633194, 0.046851713210344315, -0.004866246599704027, 0.034174833446741104, -0.02027798630297184, -0.0810314416885376, 0.0307190902531147, -0.007986795157194138, -0.02062155306339264, -0.053295716643333435, 0.03317674249410629, -0.017057472839951515, -0.035083502531051636, 0.022314606234431267, -0.0004204879223834723, 0.038457825779914856, -0.002044311258941889, -0.1094416007399559, -0.02823742851614952, 0.01432752888649702, -0.044890742748975754, 0.00953375082463026, -0.0525350347161293, 0.04413723200559616, 0.02796694077551365, 0.04973237216472626, 0.04034650698304176, 0.055119916796684265, -0.023035982623696327, 0.025548700243234634, 0.021753719076514244, -0.007388772908598185, 0.007434915751218796, -0.02799273654818535, -0.008986502885818481, -0.00487469881772995, -0.11301402747631073, 0.03201558440923691, 0.03577075153589249, 0.0018520663725212216, 0.022782107815146446, -0.025244899094104767, 0.04215746372938156, -0.008924739435315132, -0.009395219385623932, 0.021099111065268517, -0.06033096835017204, 0.053307268768548965, -0.004137767478823662, 0.036642033606767654, -0.013648087158799171, -0.025046929717063904, 0.022600384429097176, 0.004993553273379803, 0.05311828479170799, 0.0608309730887413, -0.0270483810454607, 0.03351511433720589, 0.012495203875005245, 0.06904707103967667, 0.0012630382552742958, -0.011090569198131561, -0.02219153195619583, 0.07061003893613815, -0.0005676380242221057, 0.016843272373080254, -0.0025246180593967438, 0.021456630900502205, -0.027310704812407494, 0.03211037442088127, -0.040901068598032, -0.009636443108320236, -0.06949052959680557, 0.007123460061848164, 0.004531728103756905, -0.015449401922523975, 0.020857298746705055, 0.04804331809282303, 0.05968393385410309, 0.021970149129629135, -0.046355292201042175, -0.019645407795906067, -0.027989519760012627, 0.01767893321812153, -0.05821705237030983, -0.004643993452191353, 0.06333755701780319, 0.05792943760752678, -0.002297160681337118, 0.08813244104385376, -0.017076978459954262, -0.05216819420456886, -0.024201495572924614, -0.02407030202448368, -0.005712428130209446, 0.009355511516332626, 0.00634049903601408, 0.016998516395688057, 0.020448608323931694, 0.012747108936309814, 0.016929149627685547, -0.03998161479830742, 0.02110125683248043, 0.05991031974554062, 0.013229034841060638, 0.003180963918566704, -0.01325294841080904, 0.021761739626526833, 0.0024205995723605156, 0.0028176740743219852, -0.021921727806329727, -0.022463640198111534, 0.020283563062548637, 0.025369763374328613, 0.03894443064928055, -0.054633185267448425, 0.01331802923232317, 0.06199660524725914, 0.014486001804471016, 0.010311363264918327, 0.042725976556539536, -0.007498977705836296, 0.017202626913785934, -0.010572788305580616, 0.017461150884628296, 0.021126363426446915, 0.0113315898925066, -0.009235411882400513, 0.029130544513463974, 0.024551186710596085, 0.009044636972248554, -0.03483607992529869, 0.027034547179937363, -0.02420773357152939, -0.026021182537078857, 0.0026885531842708588, -0.04940081387758255, 0.027752958238124847, -0.008996806107461452, 0.014598970301449299, 0.025599727407097816, 0.01832871325314045, -0.0006685122498311102, 0.0063868118450045586, -0.03527379408478737, 0.024039506912231445, 0.018688203766942024, -0.006081394851207733, 0.015596863813698292, 0.02607651799917221, -0.04292726144194603, 0.042594969272613525, -0.017872218042612076, -0.015276423655450344, -0.030196160078048706, 0.02826875075697899, 0.014191275462508202, -0.012551849707961082, 0.030427969992160797, -0.020747264847159386, -0.005579159129410982, 0.034775979816913605, -0.0025416871067136526, -0.0009167214157059789, 0.02169671654701233, -0.06180579960346222, 0.022282909601926804, 0.0011688173981383443, -0.04267287626862526, 0.014044944196939468, -0.027050770819187164, 0.022403456270694733, 0.06114688143134117, -0.02560187317430973, -0.04616408050060272, 0.007077619433403015, 0.01556650921702385, 0.00004338389771874063, -0.05703454464673996, 0.0076714311726391315, 0.035469770431518555, 0.02439497970044613, -0.04323864355683327, 0.0025772936642169952, -0.043731823563575745, -0.033473215997219086, -0.06018500030040741, -0.0010002825874835253, 0.030380496755242348, -0.018061889335513115, 0.005731060169637203, 0.033738426864147186, -0.026310240849852562, -0.01752210035920143, -0.02669908106327057, -0.06765241920948029, 0.014531876891851425, 0.00883528869599104, 0.033963631838560104, 0.011896823532879353, -0.001103501534089446, 0.057793159037828445, 0.01289278082549572, -0.035484205931425095, -0.0294595118612051, 0.0002904605644289404, -0.020325731486082077, -0.03238987922668457, 0.02297615446150303, -0.026910442858934402, -0.016805417835712433, 0.024996524676680565, 0.008641263470053673, 0.00862754788249731, 0.07543545216321945, -0.02052081562578678, -0.005680409725755453, 0.029464971274137497, -0.030467169359326363, -0.012145492248237133, 0.01727885566651821, -0.02781207300722599, -0.04271292686462402, -0.010038165375590324, 0.0028097196482121944, 0.039496634155511856, 0.017181674018502235, -0.01800241321325302, 0.011662881821393967, -0.048402950167655945, 0.009278910234570503, -0.0278815645724535, 0.0027813646011054516, 0.01787242665886879, -0.03781900927424431, -0.03239235281944275, 0.07404357939958572, -0.000437622657045722, -0.032667919993400574, 0.0180607121437788, 0.038058165460824966, 0.02896612510085106, -0.030037852004170418, 0.0062665147706866264, -0.0014193407259881496, -0.025244154036045074, 0.005378217436373234, 0.0012964163906872272, 0.0005006956052966416, 0.0359342135488987, 0.04324106127023697, 0.006443217862397432, 0.010381712578237057, -0.0206594318151474, 0.02821681834757328, -0.035706885159015656, 0.011332239024341106, -0.03137617185711861, 0.034088876098394394, -0.006106533110141754, 0.08254186809062958, 0.008101962506771088, -0.008271599188446999, 0.0048666405491530895, -0.006162380799651146, -0.07746990025043488, 0.006512850988656282, -0.04380058869719505, -0.015192501246929169, 0.0014663240872323513, -0.005540602840483189, 0.033440690487623215, 0.03398353233933449, 0.010104503482580185, 0.014362655580043793, 0.011806183494627476, -0.05094347521662712, 0.0027124567423015833, -0.01808423362672329, -0.033369842916727066, 0.017184574156999588, 0.008021427318453789, 0.0393018014729023, -0.03575226292014122, 0.02757074683904648, 0.01337311789393425, -0.008812124840915203, -0.019314715638756752, -0.00007974572508828714, 0.023430967703461647, -0.010351922363042831, 0.032999634742736816, 0.02613961324095726, 0.0640736073255539, -0.02432616427540779, 0.008197648450732231, -0.04853116720914841, 0.06412307918071747, 0.013256036676466465, -0.004688046872615814, 0.01661280356347561, -0.046819474548101425, -0.01867014542222023, 0.024299345910549164, 0.025295661762356758, -0.004209821578115225, -0.01130017638206482, 0.03645787015557289, 0.0516253300011158, -0.06594067811965942, 0.003110878635197878, 0.07016156613826752, 0.0022284849546849728, -0.020501410588622093, 0.018765050917863846, 0.03096974641084671, -0.01873796433210373, -0.019560469314455986, 0.005984839983284473, -0.010225689969956875, -0.024566883221268654, 0.025773251429200172, 0.015568221919238567, -0.018601570278406143, 0.008423348888754845, 0.005185507237911224, 0.030293675139546394, 0.048301275819540024, -0.017310235649347305, -0.002581095090135932, 0.014753895811736584, 0.03391279652714729, 0.0015188328688964248, 0.03154271841049194, 0.014337379485368729, -0.08984110504388809, 0.06544388830661774, 0.03909621760249138, 0.011182691901922226, -0.04508092999458313, -0.007452739868313074, -0.038566332310438156, -0.020860958844423294, 0.03455723822116852, -0.03887777402997017, 0.0014219980221241713, -0.008191925473511219, 0.02970742993056774, -0.03268855810165405, 0.036203257739543915, -0.021489420905709267, -0.019411930814385414, -0.010401710867881775, 0.015828173607587814, -0.004902310203760862, -0.0019159953808411956, -0.014915375038981438, 0.010380072519183159, 0.04938206076622009, 0.08467084169387817, 0.01444959919899702, -0.02611703984439373, 0.009196607396006584, 0.036709707230329514, -0.02755279652774334, -0.03959430381655693, 0.028392596170306206, 0.0227359551936388, -0.025899657979607582, 0.05628287419676781, -0.0191909559071064, -0.02435259334743023, 0.03064754046499729, -0.041400808840990067, -0.006492211949080229, -0.0006164002697914839, 0.006411159411072731, 0.03738931193947792, 0.021215008571743965, 0.002050120383501053, 0.02576020173728466, 0.012293937616050243, 0.0039403499104082584, 0.017253072932362556, -0.0124063016846776, 0.03898727893829346, -0.016355538740754128, -0.03916969522833824, -0.04496585577726364, -0.025724293664097786, 0.00003150506017846055, -0.004763641860336065, 0.0008191405795514584, 0.0497317798435688, -0.0308757945895195, 0.017717815935611725, -0.005323971156030893, 0.027814095839858055, -0.005840465426445007, -0.007337277755141258, 0.009542977437376976, 0.0024485448375344276, -0.0007361610187217593, -0.03450802341103554, 0.01727675087749958, -0.0042938897386193275, 0.005844778381288052, 0.026499204337596893, -0.025288131088018417, -0.023802757263183594, -0.09180362522602081, -0.015925532206892967, 0.01380769070237875, -0.017167020589113235, 0.027987869456410408, -0.005162345711141825, 0.06071261689066887, 0.001387749332934618, -0.07451647520065308, -0.01585143245756626, 0.030885491520166397, -0.005877938121557236, 0.009280035272240639, -0.010052825324237347, 0.03337666764855385, -0.017279386520385742, 0.003344032447785139, -0.05186225473880768, -0.02897598408162594, 0.011123809963464737, -0.026568613946437836, -0.018705302849411964, -0.06692985445261002, -0.02671530842781067, -0.01705111376941204, -0.006885752081871033, -0.017543641850352287, 0.056298889219760895, 0.003283227328211069, -0.011583914048969746, -0.015933142974972725, -0.00886980164796114, 0.049858637154102325, -0.006546658929437399, 0.002641272032633424, 0.016339650377631187, -0.026864390820264816, -0.010513432323932648, 0.008193527348339558, 0.015004116110503674, -0.02225717343389988, 0.019024059176445007, -0.009616931900382042, 0.02043217234313488, 0.04258862882852554, -0.018056858330965042, 0.005281719379127026, 0.03533381223678589, -0.006011247634887695, -0.002724285004660487, -0.04182702302932739, -0.011760762892663479, -0.005304328631609678, -0.006798203103244305, -0.025343380868434906, -0.013302060775458813, 0.007412782404571772, 0.006925796624273062, 0.022298283874988556, 0.010819725692272186, 0.030542884021997452, 0.03594249114394188, 0.042759839445352554, 0.0005058361566625535, -0.032065972685813904, -0.021263636648654938, -0.027020005509257317, -0.0034950003027915955, 0.007991734892129898, -0.006479902192950249, -0.007428515236824751, 0.011956782080233097, -0.021485641598701477, -0.06517146527767181, -0.02562699466943741, -0.006491478066891432, 0.034198079258203506, -0.0072494507767260075, 0.028334561735391617, 0.07447395473718643, 0.02955923043191433, -0.021712951362133026, -0.003136436454951763, 0.0007651488995179534, -0.006591583136469126, -0.00547748664394021, 0.04509928077459335, 0.005244281142950058, -0.022534318268299103, 0.008177599869668484, 0.027417762205004692, 0.02227710746228695, 0.04837017133831978, -0.030183428898453712, 0.04536029323935509, 0.004245341289788485, -0.015169846825301647, -0.04830057919025421, 0.03377553075551987, -0.06125975772738457, 0.010149006731808186, 0.00020574328664224595, -0.04444577544927597, 0.012566274031996727, 0.017087234184145927, -0.013877118937671185, -0.03778109326958656, -0.017273887991905212, -0.04462757334113121, 0.023215580731630325, 0.007286835927516222, -0.0005265670479275286, -0.016997791826725006, 0.024080632254481316, 0.022244974970817566, 0.006957163102924824, 0.027492452412843704, -0.04283980280160904, -0.09861267358064651, -0.07484082132577896, -0.03496532514691353, -0.02216498740017414, 0.018460039049386978, 0.02085874043405056, -0.013780904933810234, 0.015083727426826954, -0.006601816043257713, 0.04682831093668938, -0.00380481849424541, 0.049166422337293625, -0.003093674313277006, 0.08437873423099518, 0.023388829082250595, 0.020539965480566025, -0.005549123510718346, 0.006622543558478355, 0.11922726780176163, 0.08255331963300705, 0.04188453033566475, -0.07031529396772385, 0.012089591473340988, -0.021337950602173805, -0.043876517564058304, -0.021505769342184067, 0.0036452580243349075, 0.015124613419175148, -0.014489804394543171, 0.021647391840815544, 0.040668733417987823, -0.01894855499267578, 0.033803846687078476, 0.06336301565170288, -0.006082174833863974, -0.033942945301532745, -0.018070267513394356, -0.01087005715817213, -0.012014205567538738, -0.007941285148262978, -0.06919144839048386, 0.043307509273290634, -0.01722182333469391, -0.02528773620724678, -0.022148344665765762, -0.01433637086302042, 0.02262132242321968, -0.003513751784339547, -0.02851226180791855, 0.01985153742134571, 0.01646583154797554, 0.03251250460743904, 0.014821266755461693, -0.009904143400490284, 0.019444264471530914, -0.009772717021405697, 0.004013965837657452, 0.0033168657682836056, 0.03221483528614044, 0.016534673050045967, -0.012653189711272717, -0.0059508648701012135, -0.019208485260605812, 0.00025306118186563253, -0.020785491913557053, 0.0300633255392313, -0.0071924165822565556, 0.006702863611280918, -0.033178847283124924, -0.0046300096437335014, -0.0007200523978099227, -0.029273832216858864, -0.008973730728030205, 0.011869481764733791, 0.02543351799249649, -0.008685261011123657, 0.0027841180562973022, -0.010220714844763279, 0.03064071759581566, -0.010078388266265392, 0.012736530043184757, -0.0038191734347492456, -0.023107819259166718, 0.009864839725196362, -0.0032682812307029963, 0.0459166020154953, -0.005036304239183664, -0.03566008806228638, -0.015807127580046654, -0.026859520003199577, 0.004052886739373207, -0.01584884710609913, 0.02312622405588627, 0.01112989243119955, 0.01883039064705372, -0.00019811082165688276, -0.010558047331869602, -0.0048735663294792175, -0.025367455556988716, -0.024579420685768127, -0.027612857520580292, -0.011147527024149895, -0.01855711080133915, -0.024872615933418274, 0.03638370707631111, 0.050771936774253845, -0.0009067102218978107, -0.009231860749423504, 0.006388573441654444, 0.04723222553730011, 0.01049750205129385, -0.04307831823825836, -0.0018562017939984798, -0.03647121042013168, -0.05664747953414917, 0.0325252041220665, -0.02979382872581482, 0.046777475625276566, 0.014059272594749928, 0.043200258165597916, -0.004926539491862059, 0.0782109946012497, -0.024255037307739258, 0.013533512130379677, 0.002131219720467925, -0.05405913293361664, 0.024781638756394386, 0.018458468839526176, -0.00940151046961546, -0.050587307661771774, -0.011622288264334202, -0.006753738969564438, -0.023405209183692932, 0.018930179998278618, -0.016297824680805206, -0.017671003937721252, 0.0016232386697083712, -0.007375019136816263, 0.0017317099263891578, -0.02250644564628601, 0.02503819577395916, -0.01977348141372204, 0.002604173496365547, -0.023146331310272217, -0.01997627504169941, -0.02702917903661728, -0.008432154543697834, -0.010578298941254616, 0.028722582384943962, 0.050355684012174606, 0.014946652576327324, 0.028181996196508408, -0.0055057755671441555, -0.0005815329495817423, 0.00406357366591692, 0.02763194963335991, -0.037358541041612625, 0.011993004009127617, 0.0675637498497963, -0.07043220847845078, -0.023874573409557343, -0.000663183513097465, 0.011225704103708267, 0.026779694482684135, 0.03488018363714218, -0.028387505561113358, -0.027547935023903847, 0.05699968338012695, -0.03623056411743164, 0.008856485597789288, -0.0032823309302330017, 0.04341639205813408, -0.016396403312683105, -0.005286964122205973, 0.01972421258687973, -0.008485253900289536, -0.04201756790280342, 0.028506265953183174, 0.062239840626716614, -0.007383024785667658, -0.0013882331550121307, 0.039969876408576965, 0.028861215338110924, 0.003928803838789463, 0.026086091995239258, -0.00466541014611721, 0.03220491111278534, 0.026808375492691994, -0.01706782542169094, 0.010322031565010548, -0.008383776992559433, 0.004349912516772747, -0.07593201845884323, -0.026580747216939926, -0.0009627005783841014, -0.017518436536192894, 0.061420589685440063, -0.03987905755639076, -0.011894343420863152, 0.008584071882069111, -0.08851263672113419, 0.006137662101536989, 0.027902470901608467, -0.01207995880395174, -0.049689266830682755, 0.05920498073101044, 0.004876543767750263, -0.0014981385320425034, 0.01608005166053772, 0.012467281892895699, 0.03668547421693802, 0.02360430732369423, 0.008059731684625149, -0.0111943818628788, -0.016652781516313553, 0.017070170491933823, 0.02025105431675911, -0.03931182622909546, 0.0032396428287029266, -0.03518720343708992, -0.056536056101322174, 0.017108254134655, 0.012725802138447762, -0.0038571699988096952, -0.007138473447412252, 0.03971629589796066, -0.003233630210161209, 0.06431113183498383, 0.041166964918375015, 0.0037321995478123426, 0.034267526119947433, 0.0021376090589910746, 0.013595744967460632, -0.01900215819478035, -0.013798058032989502, 0.02456529065966606, 0.059361331164836884, -0.04495248943567276, -0.03321071341633797, 0.011117768473923206, 0.015500843524932861, -0.03428347036242485, -0.01957516185939312, -0.010048537515103817, 0.004187320359051228, -0.043450623750686646, 0.004896100144833326, -0.06553707271814346, 0.015077796764671803, -0.02304648607969284, 0.022925958037376404, -0.023113323375582695, 0.008347135968506336, -0.018807297572493553, -0.041321128606796265, 0.010796129703521729, 0.0393829420208931, 0.00009889432112686336, -0.06874237209558487, -0.027242928743362427, 0.026195555925369263, 0.004714951850473881, -0.012026723474264145, -0.02698506973683834, -0.004668313544243574, 0.030096441507339478, -0.01608411781489849, 0.028005247935652733, 0.016932960599660873, -0.013521414250135422, 0.02533487044274807, -0.0486445426940918, 0.08115788549184799, -0.026908941566944122, 0.012855245731770992, -0.03533509001135826, 0.04570358246564865, -0.0038048794958740473, -0.0071987914852797985, 0.007303811144083738, -0.013717634603381157, 0.03691289201378822, -0.029361670836806297, 0.027763821184635162, 0.030168375000357628, -0.0747184306383133, 0.04774542897939682, -0.040863219648599625, -0.07460203021764755, -0.05898372828960419, -0.03665948286652565, 0.029408946633338928, -0.004977843724191189, -0.01537963654845953, 0.002418458927422762, -0.017071163281798363, -0.008709210902452469, -0.01351949293166399, 0.0006980468169786036, 0.02447996288537979, -0.037833716720342636, 0.023398028686642647, -0.06597737222909927, -0.005219835788011551, 0.025937220081686974, 0.02238650433719158, -0.02831186354160309, 0.027948478236794472, -0.054759785532951355, -0.030868321657180786, -0.04869706556200981, 0.004573991522192955, -0.010191074572503567, -0.05664491280913353, -0.012044129893183708, 0.04229307547211647, -0.04019148275256157, 0.013616875745356083, 0.043628301471471786, -0.0010190054308623075, 0.028234267607331276, 0.00820086058229208, 0.00034895935095846653, 0.00019481040362734348, -0.0005203763721510768, 0.0322624109685421, 0.03638415038585663, 0.010981731116771698, -0.02058316394686699, -0.02155134826898575, -0.0206905547529459, -0.030883025377988815, 0.04491036757826805, -0.012379257008433342, 0.014293879270553589, -0.038691479712724686, -0.04146895930171013, 0.011472656391561031, -0.03085150569677353, 0.04189632460474968, -0.004693154711276293, -0.025303203612565994, 0.06228819116950035, -0.01537401508539915, -0.005725541617721319, -0.03551053628325462, 0.0004478659247979522, -0.00447221240028739, -0.008210520260035992, -0.039878781884908676, 0.03045051172375679, -0.026102961972355843, -0.008705826476216316, -0.029212120920419693, 0.012359012849628925, 0.03565444424748421, -0.05023874714970589, 0.029247423633933067, -0.030007995665073395, 0.016513938084244728, -0.012347402982413769, -0.0025144668761640787, -0.04904082044959068, -0.02966873161494732, 0.03849879279732704, 0.028017528355121613, 0.019090579822659492, -0.03757788985967636, 0.004860653541982174, -0.005716555751860142, 0.01966160722076893, -0.024333946406841278, -0.011987882666289806, -0.015246588736772537, -0.002659230027347803, 0.0023250083904713392, 0.023979566991329193 ]
<p>I Have a variable (time series) which is nonstationary. I found that from the graph which seems to have a stochastic trend and the correlogram has a typical nonstationary pattern. After that, I've been asked to find the parsimonious ARMA model (using information criteria), and by following the Box-Jenkins methodology, go down till forecasting. Notice that at this point, I havent been asked to make a unit root test to check if the series is stationary or not...</p> <p>Is it possible a nonstationary series to produce a stationary ARMA model, which will give us reliable forecasting?</p> <p>After the forecasting, they ask me to make a unit root test (where of course I find that the variable is non stationary). As a next step I take the variable in 1st differences, and follow the same procedure to find an ARMA model with best information criteria. I also make some comparissons with the model that I found at the 1st step, but after that they dont ask me to follow the Box-Jenkins methodology again and make a forecast from the ARMA model produced by the differenced variable...</p> <p>So what I’m confused about is:</p> <p>Why did they ask me to find an ARMA from a non stationary variable? Can a nonstat. Variable produce stationary ARMA model and reliable forecasting?</p> <p>Wouldn’t it be normal to ask me to follow the Box Jenkins methodology in the second model (where the variable is differenced) and make a forecast from there?</p> <p>Any answer would be helpful!</p>
17,811
[ 0.011174870654940605, -0.05590616539120674, -0.009168577380478382, 0.009259404614567757, 0.02933974377810955, -0.004121705424040556, -0.026014965027570724, -0.011546834371984005, 0.030233265832066536, -0.02622799575328827, 0.036076001822948456, 0.019503245130181313, 0.04882466048002243, 0.02724212035536766, -0.00816927757114172, 0.004355954937636852, -0.028819121420383453, 0.020089751109480858, 0.01403690967708826, -0.016550909727811813, -0.0221227016299963, 0.0038225839380174875, -0.019298341125249863, -0.0026288535445928574, 0.002527273027226329, 0.03482279181480408, 0.004082977771759033, 0.009693855419754982, 0.02387399971485138, 0.049350231885910034, -0.01574897952377796, 1.7964357823530008e-7, -0.009241420775651932, 0.0433422289788723, 0.05107642337679863, 0.023335199803113937, 0.00401193555444479, -0.03173436224460602, -0.008416769094765186, 0.0714574083685875, -0.06480009853839874, -0.009228425100445747, 0.017926666885614395, 0.026599446311593056, -0.04632098972797394, 0.0077628036960959435, 0.025475898757576942, -0.008182632736861706, 0.058263517916202545, -0.03232559934258461, 0.05742177739739418, -0.04045557975769043, 0.02551713027060032, 0.05164128169417381, -0.03505673259496689, -0.02887282520532608, 0.07477551698684692, 0.06072249636054039, -0.015816977247595787, -0.045975614339113235, -0.014748605899512768, 0.030512919649481773, -0.013025845400989056, -0.041178230196237564, -0.01788265071809292, 0.018084116280078888, 0.0018040742725133896, -0.020182916894555092, 0.024551639333367348, 0.00019272549252491444, 0.015608747489750385, -0.0005608185310848057, 0.020503925159573555, -0.04517536982893944, 0.015068992972373962, -0.036612533032894135, 0.024236584082245827, 0.013501850888133049, 0.014070543460547924, 0.052246205508708954, 0.00528262834995985, 0.024673666805028915, -0.03264450654387474, 0.05735357478260994, 0.012428357265889645, 0.0014219095464795828, 0.06923148036003113, -0.04095553234219551, -0.00844614952802658, 0.03631087392568588, 0.0028177136555314064, 0.010141182690858841, 0.03412230312824249, 0.008983527310192585, -0.011227710172533989, 0.007187503390014172, -0.025459367781877518, 0.02569814771413803, -0.006625321228057146, -0.011187754571437836, -0.0023396366741508245, -0.04150960221886635, 0.033126093447208405, 0.030327094718813896, -0.005374109838157892, 0.027080437168478966, -0.01642514020204544, -0.011382381431758404, -0.024180449545383453, -0.018468603491783142, -0.039936430752277374, 0.005485104396939278, -0.029114289209246635, -0.007007605861872435, 0.04723482206463814, 0.01807139255106449, -0.02003358118236065, -0.0072564370930194855, 0.03963131085038185, 0.055689841508865356, 0.04314151778817177, -0.006032691802829504, 0.01844843290746212, -0.031317826360464096, -0.05950191989541054, -0.03149278461933136, 0.004072816111147404, 0.003553810529410839, -0.050761766731739044, 0.06431804597377777, 0.006496995687484741, 0.0017698819283396006, -0.0006602612556889653, -0.006053186021745205, 0.05741994455456734, -0.02428673580288887, -0.08820377290248871, -0.0644894614815712, 0.02507006749510765, 0.0019498990150168538, 0.017886236310005188, -0.07773075997829437, 0.010147463530302048, 0.017958756536245346, 0.050738461315631866, -0.01586240530014038, 0.031141070649027824, 0.012957537546753883, 0.03753073886036873, 0.003106539137661457, -0.013353870250284672, 0.005896716378629208, -0.011493449099361897, -0.02929072268307209, -0.0028153909370303154, -0.06200789660215378, 0.005976969841867685, 0.023481765761971474, -0.05135922506451607, -0.019045786932110786, 0.0217694453895092, 0.012495479546487331, -0.0323823057115078, 0.0028027668595314026, -0.01383903343230486, -0.015956994146108627, 0.05218100547790527, -0.005923707038164139, 0.028844762593507767, 0.03491850942373276, 0.008146154694259167, 0.026027513667941093, -0.007982071489095688, 0.032027631998062134, 0.03606457635760307, -0.015056685544550419, -0.004880688618868589, -0.020274603739380836, -0.021041948348283768, 0.021438797935843468, -0.04159637168049812, -0.008655247278511524, -0.025600306689739227, -0.009237116202712059, 0.002047475427389145, 0.06040315702557564, 0.0030505789909511805, -0.003987199626863003, 0.036492615938186646, -0.08180045336484909, -0.05338631942868233, -0.03923660144209862, -0.0017487804871052504, -0.040885962545871735, -0.0007964664837345481, 0.01564781926572323, -0.039053451269865036, 0.026582596823573112, 0.03469656780362129, 0.004893188830465078, 0.0016671993071213365, -0.0029161865822970867, 0.051297031342983246, -0.016118738800287247, -0.003054253524169326, 0.011945854872465134, 0.008982899598777294, -0.025427883490920067, 0.0026964021380990744, -0.05109180137515068, -0.043749935925006866, 0.014181841164827347, 0.00031938610482029617, 0.006254103966057301, -0.021134739741683006, 0.0004015511949546635, 0.030242223292589188, 0.015975967049598694, -0.024668650701642036, 0.02868177555501461, -0.010699794627726078, 0.009223061613738537, 0.06111980229616165, -0.008986162021756172, -0.003396201878786087, 0.03912285715341568, 0.0034357430413365364, 0.0658884346485138, -0.0037558074109256268, -0.019828855991363525, -0.05889124423265457, -0.008351446129381657, 0.04804728925228119, -0.0035519537050276995, -0.02517610788345337, 0.005584884434938431, 0.05145774036645889, -0.010736187919974327, -0.022485703229904175, 0.038795895874500275, 0.018376749008893967, 0.0005758435581810772, 0.014189882203936577, 0.011719591915607452, 0.017075253650546074, 0.015409291721880436, -0.015169103629887104, -0.009788456372916698, 0.028639454394578934, 0.006521856877952814, -0.0347740612924099, 0.07669561356306076, -0.006040931213647127, 0.008116002194583416, 0.01227656938135624, 0.004658983089029789, 0.03802945464849472, -0.038371313363313675, -0.015442397445440292, 0.035296566784381866, 0.005237442906945944, -0.028276538476347923, 0.011712671257555485, -0.017745865508913994, -0.008454564958810806, 0.02206382341682911, -0.006525371689349413, -0.00865766778588295, 0.019221942871809006, -0.04701382294297218, -0.0033587138168513775, -0.0041115074418485165, -0.01871981844305992, -0.009940993040800095, -0.014314530417323112, 0.052148107439279556, 0.005585544276982546, 0.03144608438014984, 0.007267972454428673, -0.011407171376049519, 0.004371287766844034, -0.03131609410047531, 0.0016795373521745205, -0.0009152204147540033, -0.03344280272722244, 0.047829121351242065, -0.026973498985171318, -0.0005025147693231702, 0.03369182348251343, -0.03905536234378815, -0.006270006764680147, 0.06425821036100388, -0.025978542864322662, -0.024343470111489296, -0.026629846543073654, -0.04336097836494446, 0.04501847177743912, -0.02246258035302162, -0.03583986684679985, 0.052830249071121216, 0.02549099177122116, -0.011044404469430447, -0.001848876941949129, -0.039790865033864975, -0.006616096943616867, -0.025599464774131775, 0.0011578276753425598, -0.018527811393141747, 0.004704002290964127, 0.044755514711141586, 0.013205871917307377, -0.01080666109919548, 0.006908530835062265, -0.04654901102185249, -0.05051647871732712, 0.027678241953253746, 0.0068415249697864056, 0.019006529822945595, -0.045078881084918976, -0.007334219757467508, 0.0627535954117775, 0.04528628662228584, -0.033573977649211884, -0.03446283936500549, -0.022097699344158173, -0.05460561439394951, -0.08421511948108673, -0.0015143360942602158, 0.02985796146094799, 0.0006136937881819904, 0.016803130507469177, 0.016718367114663124, 0.061698511242866516, 0.04246314615011215, -0.026737459003925323, -0.00936166848987341, 0.01960306242108345, -0.00937789585441351, 0.04569399356842041, 0.029427330940961838, 0.008986055850982666, -0.02227473445236683, 0.0022565480321645737, -0.015567361377179623, 0.0020506440196186304, 0.03144584968686104, -0.0402776338160038, 0.022904952988028526, -0.01691051945090294, 0.01942320540547371, -0.08672721683979034, 0.0015730855520814657, 0.0225747749209404, -0.06778953224420547, -0.0340583436191082, 0.009142170660197735, 0.023299919441342354, -0.004168039653450251, -0.00691870367154479, 0.06051759421825409, 0.008277210406959057, -0.0055928523652255535, -0.008517223410308361, -0.005863087717443705, -0.026137297973036766, 0.016514977440238, -0.04262826219201088, -0.039496637880802155, 0.021655945107340813, 0.014467117376625538, -0.023947976529598236, -0.008555215783417225, -0.040347564965486526, -0.026723822578787804, -0.07846502214670181, -0.007151523604989052, -0.004438420291990042, 0.10020735114812851, -0.01137788500636816, 0.034618791192770004, 0.02447384223341942, -0.021002357825636864, 0.01447220053523779, -0.008274800144135952, -0.05852675810456276, 0.0716804563999176, -0.008994272910058498, -0.00978835392743349, 0.0033033257350325584, -0.036347270011901855, 0.016387784853577614, -0.03173692524433136, 0.014230705797672272, 0.008416621014475822, 0.03468109294772148, -0.036547690629959106, -0.004055716097354889, -0.05017462745308876, -0.01825568825006485, -0.010526148602366447, -0.001040152506902814, 0.057127270847558975, -0.039149925112724304, 0.06264228373765945, 0.043243542313575745, -0.007113033439964056, -0.01852182298898697, -0.019683223217725754, 0.010360007174313068, 0.029018135741353035, 0.054649606347084045, 0.023610794916749, -0.002121416851878166, -0.03237414360046387, 0.02285284735262394, 0.027477331459522247, 0.006060803309082985, 0.011293981224298477, -0.028795631602406502, -0.05076500400900841, -0.0062016393058001995, 0.004513636231422424, 0.028207125142216682, 0.01914467103779316, 0.022522538900375366, -0.0017651498783379793, 0.016936268657445908, 0.030928878113627434, 0.0012992889387533069, 0.013947355560958385, 0.08919653296470642, -0.0003004864265676588, 0.032729845494031906, -0.006411117501556873, -0.03242301195859909, 0.03490877151489258, -0.0111260199919343, 0.035368118435144424, 0.004776223096996546, -0.01642533205449581, -0.041539665311574936, 0.020469019189476967, -0.02115488052368164, -0.031517140567302704, -0.004150232300162315, 0.054936740547418594, 0.03474487364292145, 0.010338964872062206, 0.0000701716126059182, 0.006320531480014324, 0.05265739560127258, 0.004414628725498915, 0.01466415636241436, -0.023583421483635902, -0.06874164193868637, -0.011541781015694141, 0.028545649722218513, 0.05334126576781273, -0.005283945240080357, -0.014921671710908413, -0.044790010899305344, 0.00237754313275218, 0.04974718764424324, -0.023360585793852806, 0.06968368589878082, -0.026012182235717773, 0.04645060747861862, -0.00322399172000587, -0.01396358571946621, -0.042826805263757706, 0.006560840643942356, 0.010432467795908451, 0.04235418140888214, 0.01167201902717352, -0.011223549954593182, -0.07648498564958572, -0.04833151772618294, -0.01593169942498207, 0.030006233602762222, -0.0389876626431942, 0.0006183507503010333, -0.007963329553604126, 0.023575911298394203, 0.026310956105589867, -0.05717527121305466, 0.0054821171797811985, -0.007288943510502577, -0.060467060655355453, 0.010096200741827488, 0.012709437869489193, -0.03759537264704704, 0.010199747048318386, -0.005342643242329359, 0.003034204011783004, -0.017984675243496895, -0.047585975378751755, 0.08335269242525101, 0.008630169555544853, -0.013666247017681599, 0.018981097266077995, 0.0532422736287117, -0.001320778508670628, 0.03401872515678406, -0.018964283168315887, 0.025888027623295784, 0.0190596841275692, 0.001197764533571899, -0.05643793195486069, 0.01950960047543049, -0.018547236919403076, 0.029729312285780907, -0.007845311425626278, 0.04223596677184105, -0.056664180010557175, -0.006911063101142645, 0.0168510302901268, 0.05069206282496452, -0.030236633494496346, -0.03829801455140114, -0.032425977289676666, -0.00022994691971689463, -0.04262427240610123, -0.022536486387252808, 0.029074452817440033, -0.03706949204206467, -0.020063597708940506, 0.044139567762613297, -0.036370594054460526, 0.023968033492565155, -0.023548509925603867, -0.010884534567594528, 0.014122110791504383, -0.006759994197636843, 0.020962955430150032, -0.0011474194470793009, 0.044312089681625366, 0.011897513642907143, -0.05206133797764778, -0.012710640206933022, -0.0006992409471422434, 0.005368737503886223, 0.043545473366975784, -0.054910507053136826, 0.05125783383846283, -0.0000077403028626577, -0.03584596887230873, -0.07442455738782883, -0.05907609686255455, 0.01611640304327011, 0.006937065627425909, -0.0637238621711731, -0.02133295312523842, 0.013711589388549328, -0.02561074122786522, -0.04356740415096283, -0.06897805631160736, 0.03651157394051552, -0.01840849593281746, -0.050208739936351776, 0.019514629617333412, 0.04541699215769768, 0.07410106062889099, 0.012314552441239357, 0.006665696855634451, 0.01909227855503559, -0.016938677057623863, -0.011137092486023903, -0.011375953443348408, 0.0037494641728699207, -0.027967611327767372, -0.009514550678431988, -0.023336132988333702, 0.007660858333110809, 0.05725769326090813, -0.024645041674375534, 0.000503277697134763, 0.047193098813295364, 0.009760362096130848, 0.0020969524048268795, -0.0005784517852589488, 0.0029780487529933453, -0.021199025213718414, 0.017094407230615616, -0.034414615482091904, -0.010679460130631924, 0.019369786605238914, -0.05563856661319733, 0.04718276113271713, -0.01594182662665844, 0.004765624180436134, 0.03485717251896858, 0.048067912459373474, -0.032796986401081085, 0.02171015739440918, 0.03129018470644951, -0.02278851345181465, 0.03783702850341797, 0.0047673676162958145, 0.04116124287247658, -0.022788474336266518, 0.010002922266721725, -0.029211070388555527, -0.025809315964579582, -0.011226455681025982, 0.019918177276849747, 0.07654236257076263, -0.0021007147151976824, 0.05616660416126251, 0.03964260593056679, 0.0234589334577322, -0.007496782578527927, -0.051802922040224075, -0.007903189398348331, -0.009979446418583393, 0.005876222625374794, 0.05294233560562134, -0.032987628132104874, -0.0020609970670193434, 0.03742370009422302, 0.054503750056028366, 0.018654972314834595, 0.011029350571334362, 0.006148415617644787, 0.01687888242304325, 0.012020726688206196, 0.012405863031744957, -0.053144533187150955, 0.0371793732047081, -0.011654356494545937, 0.01605149172246456, -0.021760903298854828, -0.009441892616450787, 0.023856546729803085, 0.04423151910305023, -0.010407408699393272, -0.07622196525335312, -0.005328870378434658, -0.07227317988872528, -0.02005409263074398, 0.03426862135529518, -0.028714662417769432, 0.017337940633296967, 0.04498935118317604, 0.027900105342268944, 0.0026013245806097984, 0.0031283979769796133, -0.007462413050234318, -0.06632419675588608, -0.0019016428850591183, -0.0244057048112154, -0.04230602830648422, 0.02136591076850891, -0.02014036849141121, -0.01298489049077034, 0.028098294511437416, -0.026264168322086334, 0.00944830197840929, 0.008078040555119514, 0.022285601124167442, -0.0032420167699456215, 0.11205580830574036, -0.02651788480579853, 0.03491763025522232, -0.018095767125487328, -0.0005705656367354095, 0.11179353296756744, 0.04917476326227188, 0.026776138693094254, -0.029013879597187042, 0.025075379759073257, -0.02848471887409687, 0.019115665927529335, -0.007557349279522896, 0.035278648138046265, 0.02234107255935669, -0.012679110281169415, 0.02214520052075386, 0.04164427891373634, -0.01350755151361227, 0.012082316912710667, 0.05046606808900833, -0.02218557707965374, -0.03256865218281746, 0.023122841492295265, 0.030425971373915672, 0.017025774344801903, -0.006968156900256872, -0.0032934918999671936, 0.025175070390105247, -0.004340056795626879, -0.043208878487348557, 0.02550124004483223, -0.03798142820596695, 0.013581830076873302, 0.005542389582842588, -0.012019801884889603, 0.03048444539308548, 0.06002498045563698, 0.031156349927186966, -0.045462049543857574, 0.009497926570475101, 0.002012136159464717, -0.03808176890015602, 0.03166157379746437, 0.039679139852523804, 0.0015744961565360427, -0.04803915321826935, 0.02187979221343994, 0.004732114262878895, -0.02967652678489685, -0.01731911487877369, -0.04498983174562454, 0.0021589137613773346, 0.0063911983743309975, -0.010864494368433952, -0.01701834611594677, -0.01197640411555767, 0.003446627175435424, -0.0381322056055069, -0.021832767874002457, 0.03683508560061455, 0.044625360518693924, -0.07328324019908905, -0.03510867431759834, -0.03434574976563454, -0.012121898122131824, 0.016420137137174606, 0.026475690305233, 0.04775937274098396, -0.02626296691596508, 0.025207029655575752, -0.013574553653597832, 0.04997780919075012, -0.04376770928502083, -0.0037329918704926968, 0.027280375361442566, 0.012501794844865799, -0.05368204414844513, -0.014083542861044407, 0.021375764161348343, 0.003694504266604781, 0.030046533793210983, 0.010505476035177708, 0.019200429320335388, 0.008471794426441193, -0.05070846527814865, 0.026814693585038185, -0.04800698906183243, 0.009099697694182396, -0.035706911236047745, 0.02423909492790699, 0.014793316833674908, 0.026935173198580742, 0.009388028644025326, -0.007158792112022638, 0.020439473912119865, 0.026783129200339317, 0.0449758842587471, -0.06576883047819138, -0.022772392258048058, -0.022146157920360565, -0.003912418149411678, -0.0033679003827273846, -0.005956251174211502, 0.023325202986598015, 0.04702775552868843, 0.05871763825416565, -0.041767388582229614, 0.022066732868552208, -0.004302822519093752, 0.030932698398828506, 0.007283343467861414, -0.033558059483766556, 0.018247637897729874, 0.014628440141677856, 0.04203289747238159, -0.02211281657218933, -0.001814801711589098, -0.004477350041270256, 0.01724136807024479, 0.031982503831386566, -0.02071763016283512, -0.060096438974142075, -0.02001914568245411, -0.003638048190623522, 0.04612001031637192, -0.035202063620090485, 0.022652268409729004, -0.015174477361142635, 0.03022509627044201, 0.001215971540659666, -0.019729772582650185, -0.021267611533403397, 0.006023040506988764, -0.00574879115447402, 0.0099506676197052, 0.0030531147494912148, 0.015972396358847618, 0.012875493615865707, -0.022139189764857292, 0.0035563120618462563, -0.016886228695511818, 0.03289338946342468, -0.02113102748990059, -0.01839238591492176, 0.029248178005218506, -0.008039973676204681, -0.03249325230717659, 0.053623370826244354, 0.02712911181151867, 0.008962969295680523, 0.0055666472762823105, 0.004550084006041288, 0.0014577032998204231, 0.012664681300520897, -0.021138804033398628, 0.034356750547885895, 0.017468811944127083, 0.02451452799141407, 0.037411320954561234, -0.013150505721569061, -0.007244007661938667, 0.034489549696445465, -0.013391068205237389, 0.052186962217092514, 0.05632658675312996, 0.01973722130060196, -0.02103559300303459, -0.016239680349826813, -0.030664924532175064, -0.025276068598031998, -0.02020135335624218, 0.015098294243216515, 0.049026425927877426, 0.044929251074790955, -0.001980170840397477, 0.0044824425131082535, -0.019964070990681648, -0.004888458643108606, -0.03304095193743706, -0.04440956935286522, -0.0032617729157209396, 0.012248469516634941, 0.018583618104457855, -0.049993276596069336, 0.02752087637782097, 0.049516551196575165, -0.008845677599310875, 0.0005641203606501222, -0.002906463574618101, -0.03302164003252983, -0.0005482572014443576, -0.012964793480932713, -0.04418594017624855, 0.05896681174635887, 0.07101625949144363, 0.01780848205089569, -0.0003886127087753266, -0.004755231086164713, 0.0045594642870128155, -0.006218728609383106, 0.011636542156338692, 0.021688120439648628, -0.007177305407822132, -0.031192263588309288, 0.04465925693511963, -0.03445522114634514, -0.045901108533144, 0.02937307581305504, -0.03140106052160263, 0.011094680055975914, 0.014767030254006386, -0.013925098814070225, -0.010735641233623028, 0.029773427173495293, 0.06279538571834564, 0.00023145147133618593, 0.024359608069062233, 0.0036250182893127203, 0.038773830980062485, 0.021602585911750793, 0.02299163118004799, 0.020712900906801224, -0.021781926974654198, -0.02096976712346077, -0.02670419029891491, -0.010866474360227585, -0.003284863429144025, -0.00853381771594286, 0.0020711750257760286, 0.006097262725234032, -0.035943131893873215, -0.012809490785002708, 0.016971124336123466, -0.049611520022153854, -0.004509130492806435, 0.06357409060001373, 0.0025423879269510508, -0.06610026210546494, -0.017195535823702812, -0.010054009035229683, -0.048223547637462616, 0.017137473449110985, -0.014777344651520252, 0.011180965229868889, -0.06873675435781479, -0.028873736038804054, -0.004734540358185768, -0.016899360343813896, -0.05468130111694336, -0.007989389821887016, -0.06532382220029831, 0.04878240451216698, -0.024779094383120537, 0.014503363519906998, 0.01861725002527237, -0.035989873111248016, 0.03770618885755539, -0.09247816354036331, 0.06113485246896744, 0.01633359305560589, -0.055172406136989594, -0.019281845539808273, -0.04017678275704384, -0.04839753359556198, -0.01712666265666485, 0.05462818965315819, 0.006349725648760796, 0.03466402366757393, 0.04114091023802757, -0.021393192932009697, -0.03249966725707054, 0.0010909601114690304, 0.06401773542165756, -0.009864786639809608, -0.001563969417475164, -0.0011140891583636403, -0.01692226529121399, 0.022700853645801544, -0.010496578179299831, 0.02410869486629963, -0.019791284576058388, 0.035341162234544754, 0.021149462088942528, -0.014425092376768589, -0.02055276744067669, -0.0017260740278288722, -0.010204896330833435, 0.01942780613899231, 0.008149777539074421, 0.027149001136422157, 0.02876044064760208, 0.025420084595680237, -0.03457395359873772, 0.04276932403445244, -0.04442693293094635, 0.02614928036928177, -0.025306912139058113, 0.030716730281710625, -0.002611627569422126, -0.055630020797252655, -0.0128306420519948, 0.045859821140766144, -0.019364023581147194, -0.017662731930613518, 0.05120570957660675, 0.012471047230064869, 0.019960535690188408, -0.016709521412849426, -0.009078956209123135, 0.027860675007104874, 0.032289985567331314, -0.027404827997088432, -0.027984928339719772, 0.05669543147087097, -0.010659987106919289, -0.015547706745564938, 0.02005002647638321, -0.020993884652853012, 0.05248922109603882, -0.05630025640130043, 0.019244154915213585, -0.02716594561934471, -0.03212868422269821, -0.022337686270475388, -0.005097180604934692, -0.001811639522202313, 0.00902432482689619, -0.013127378188073635, 0.06297414749860764, -0.03635874390602112, 0.001889062230475247, 0.003572931746020913, 0.0009308310691267252, -0.02897103875875473, 0.024045521393418312, 0.005377057008445263, 0.014052079990506172, 0.01312933024019003, -0.00406934879720211, -0.024148354306817055, -0.026955723762512207, 0.03484868258237839, -0.04194149747490883, -0.0343482606112957, -0.027770694345235825, -0.02401079796254635, -0.034451596438884735, -0.024350441992282867, -0.03326010704040527, -0.005367670673877001, 0.01599821448326111, 0.01078701764345169, 0.010979876853525639, -0.028747696429491043, -0.023190490901470184, -0.028950698673725128, 0.04008776322007179, -0.04121966287493706, -0.026094811037182808, -0.027073683217167854, -0.027844902127981186, 0.019114894792437553, -0.018330127000808716 ]
<p><strong>A definition before I start:</strong> </p> <p>A trajectory $t$ of length $n$ is here defined as a series of 2D coordinates $$\{(x_1,y_1), (x_2, y_2),..., (x_n, y_n)\}$$ Now I have a set comprised of such trajectories denoted by set $T=\{t_1, t_2,...,t_n\}$. </p> <hr> <p>Take $t_1$ and $t_2$ as an example: let's say a segment of $t_1$ denoted by $S_{t_1}$ overlaps with a part of $t_2$ denoted by $S_{t_2}$. But for the other parts, they do not overlap.</p> <p>All the trajectories may have such a "partially-overlapping" relationship with the others.</p> <p>Obviously in this case, we cannot treat every trajectory as a whole, find a distance metric and finally cluster them. <strong>We have to sort of cluster the trajectories by part instead of as a whole.</strong></p> <p>Is there any already-existed clustering technique that does the job? </p> <p>Any suggestions or pointers are very much welcomed.</p>
73,588
[ -0.017838792875409126, 0.006001255940645933, -0.0025665229186415672, -0.004003955516964197, 0.023002278059720993, 0.011811448261141777, 0.01942937634885311, 0.005746751558035612, 0.011388540267944336, -0.04085956886410713, 0.010275162756443024, 0.03919503465294838, 0.03169048950076103, 0.027161961421370506, 0.025539083406329155, -0.022395215928554535, -0.008816743269562721, -0.014598476700484753, -0.011464107781648636, -0.04669354110956192, 0.05551542714238167, -0.007944130338728428, 0.03504648804664612, -0.020441889762878418, -0.05678770691156387, 0.0299668051302433, -0.006489511579275131, -0.0383228100836277, 0.020074715837836266, 0.05470379441976547, -0.05195697769522667, -0.009489262476563454, 0.021353358402848244, 0.03656291961669922, -0.00925321877002716, -0.012533482164144516, -0.07820438593626022, 0.000914679141715169, -0.02314530685544014, 0.009996742010116577, -0.08110594004392624, -0.02537141554057598, -0.04511649161577225, 0.06841935217380524, -0.006549526005983353, 0.022416384890675545, -0.008051895536482334, -0.02437538467347622, 0.01725774258375168, -0.04682726785540581, 0.0938296914100647, -0.001653927261941135, 0.03135133534669876, -0.00857071578502655, -0.021950865164399147, -0.0015358704840764403, 0.05594545230269432, 0.057461436837911606, -0.01538941916078329, -0.02379154972732067, -0.009393755346536636, -0.03115074522793293, 0.039319898933172226, -0.03838483616709709, -0.04190629720687866, 0.06361761689186096, -0.01413766574114561, -0.01702735386788845, 0.00950245838612318, -0.019931061193346977, -0.023637067526578903, -0.008690256625413895, 0.03929015249013901, -0.022255001589655876, 0.007367557846009731, -0.03029949776828289, 0.014494539238512516, 0.0331183485686779, 0.05977268144488335, 0.0249516349285841, 0.009965186938643456, 0.013761299662292004, 0.038550931960344315, 0.00926329754292965, -0.01142438966780901, 0.0024282014928758144, 0.06853742897510529, -0.014139790087938309, -0.018872426822781563, 0.03221229091286659, 0.008435453288257122, -0.0032811774872243404, 0.04617348685860634, 0.023114072158932686, -0.030184375122189522, 0.03081548400223255, 0.005374262575060129, 0.023027461022138596, -0.006695117335766554, -0.008831015788018703, 0.006264419760555029, -0.0561324767768383, 0.0032607284374535084, 0.0429416261613369, -0.008282508701086044, -0.007295338436961174, -0.044289492070674896, -0.014843755401670933, -0.005889758933335543, 0.020123599097132683, -0.010616680607199669, 0.013245542533695698, 0.04614992439746857, 0.026357419788837433, 0.00471396604552865, -0.023751959204673767, -0.0071535054594278336, -0.015548350289463997, -0.017100680619478226, 0.08375653624534607, 0.04865654930472374, -0.05073785036802292, 0.027879763394594193, -0.014376751147210598, -0.07455682009458542, 0.007822735235095024, 0.04769344627857208, -0.0031868049409240484, 0.005508079659193754, 0.016987202689051628, 0.0039627100341022015, -0.007382330950349569, 0.04961016774177551, -0.015030816197395325, 0.03600645437836647, -0.007455017883330584, -0.09522923827171326, -0.032112013548612595, 0.02642088755965233, 0.032778844237327576, -0.0011360696516931057, -0.05664629116654396, 0.01973091997206211, 0.02723749168217182, 0.05776823312044144, 0.003226701868698001, 0.009461998008191586, 0.03359765559434891, -0.0035389885306358337, 0.007989500649273396, -0.033654261380434036, -0.004843680188059807, -0.0066132862120866776, -0.0546555332839489, -0.0015315331984311342, -0.04287762939929962, 0.007914895191788673, 0.04115735739469528, -0.0190157201141119, 0.006749623455107212, 0.04457147419452667, 0.00845746137201786, -0.002986349631100893, -0.009396826848387718, 0.04855755716562271, 0.004384935833513737, 0.08197372406721115, 0.03292758762836456, 0.011896577663719654, 0.012382681481540203, -0.008008956909179688, 0.03505023941397667, 0.022004196420311928, 0.029528789222240448, 0.06547330319881439, -0.002404619939625263, -0.04477149620652199, 0.04624149948358536, -0.012733529321849346, 0.0061634439043700695, -0.018263384699821472, -0.0668521448969841, -0.010615342296659946, 0.011013690382242203, 0.025184089317917824, 0.0529705174267292, 0.013615909032523632, -0.010584026575088501, 0.032593972980976105, -0.052513692528009415, -0.02297377400100231, -0.04084409400820732, 0.01593638025224209, -0.046651311218738556, -0.023194419220089912, 0.04586024582386017, -0.03333945944905281, -0.015698008239269257, 0.004939972888678312, -0.054060373455286026, -0.041853439062833786, 0.0007701293216086924, 0.0003896330017596483, -0.03375263884663582, -0.028819654136896133, 0.035222213715314865, 0.0036765087861567736, 0.005020511336624622, 0.024396566674113274, -0.017177123576402664, -0.055963486433029175, -0.030266089364886284, -0.019772032275795937, 0.023356759920716286, -0.01118486374616623, 0.006430210079997778, 0.003856207709759474, -0.030785178765654564, -0.04249895364046097, 0.0047463844530284405, -0.05142459645867348, 0.08477126806974411, 0.07113529741764069, -0.0017010041046887636, 0.0026610391214489937, 0.020972538739442825, 0.011580483056604862, -0.0026209962088614702, 0.013479292392730713, -0.02272775024175644, -0.046816181391477585, -0.007897456176578999, 0.0373329222202301, 0.043008916079998016, -0.07753939181566238, -0.01417278777807951, 0.028473298996686935, 0.026042331010103226, -0.028176655992865562, -0.003320475108921528, -0.04397637024521828, -0.024262797087430954, 0.04155166447162628, 0.014980190433561802, -0.008412444964051247, -0.02752489410340786, -0.008810173720121384, 0.0023478344082832336, 0.01146736741065979, -0.0014437867794185877, -0.02533918432891369, 0.060401551425457, 0.00935716088861227, -0.006981866434216499, 0.024634800851345062, -0.021674027666449547, 0.050218112766742706, -0.007218706421554089, 0.019457457587122917, 0.019580569118261337, 0.015972673892974854, -0.010830839164555073, 0.00816408358514309, -0.012547372840344906, 0.001051833387464285, 0.027721207588911057, -0.011700395494699478, 0.03398298844695091, 0.02080560103058815, -0.03942890837788582, 0.020912738516926765, -0.020747531205415726, -0.057527754455804825, -0.0007163762347772717, 0.029158569872379303, 0.0553755983710289, 0.02472064457833767, -0.0055282083339989185, -0.009764093905687332, 0.0008701072656549513, -0.011803997680544853, 0.005842436570674181, -0.003439856693148613, 0.009014681912958622, -0.04346831142902374, 0.009377681650221348, -0.0062208897434175014, -0.01679084450006485, 0.0032973908819258213, -0.019159827381372452, 0.004274742677807808, 0.016834132373332977, -0.009739593602716923, -0.0673474669456482, -0.0200493186712265, -0.03259412571787834, 0.018613222986459732, -0.03632131218910217, -0.01890423521399498, 0.027639107778668404, 0.02221154235303402, -0.08561644703149796, 0.03271608427166939, -0.021616265177726746, -0.008021156303584576, -0.04977988079190254, -0.03319892659783363, 0.03064650669693947, -0.021011903882026672, 0.01518581248819828, 0.04878513887524605, 0.002329788403585553, 0.004937408491969109, -0.06371216475963593, -0.06209458038210869, 0.011795499362051487, -0.00442212400957942, 0.03964191675186157, 0.027440449222922325, -0.02170456387102604, 0.08895683288574219, 0.007214445620775223, -0.02407209761440754, -0.03241582587361336, 0.002826595911756158, -0.01772443950176239, -0.001908387872390449, 0.051421869546175, 0.014397261664271355, 0.008657758124172688, -0.012763542123138905, 0.04523063078522682, 0.03225323557853699, 0.0802871584892273, -0.014181086793541908, -0.0021707871928811073, 0.006280177738517523, 0.0060548437759280205, 0.010472794063389301, 0.01915713958442211, 0.02251225896179676, -0.05029267445206642, 0.03584817424416542, -0.005248672794550657, -0.0020369531121104956, 0.0317997932434082, -0.04133051633834839, 0.010413454845547676, -0.018849488347768784, -0.012629499658942223, 0.006803820841014385, 0.03667151927947998, 0.001438995124772191, -0.04165929555892944, 0.0004925337270833552, 0.10020366311073303, 0.0352453738451004, -0.008466677740216255, -0.0028682167176157236, 0.05503463372588158, 0.0534367561340332, -0.0533406101167202, -0.013798044063150883, -0.018980154767632484, -0.02113492041826248, 0.0060807280242443085, -0.010545833967626095, -0.01841997727751732, 0.0049544451758265495, 0.02793099172413349, 0.011859730817377567, 0.005366090219467878, -0.015749048441648483, 0.018296344205737114, -0.07329516112804413, -0.022174376994371414, -0.006030928809195757, 0.07169122248888016, -0.0318315215408802, 0.022864410653710365, -0.002171914791688323, 0.004713902715593576, 0.01915331371128559, 0.04590136557817459, -0.06992947310209274, -0.012265967205166817, -0.028444496914744377, -0.0016541442601010203, -0.011483535170555115, -0.006971513852477074, 0.004565959796309471, -0.030162388458848, 0.015102711506187916, -0.025449445471167564, 0.001632218947634101, -0.0410347543656826, -0.009948696941137314, -0.013561824336647987, -0.006747519597411156, 0.01679229736328125, 0.013437905348837376, 0.05752037838101387, 0.004229260142892599, 0.047574449330568314, 0.025655388832092285, -0.018458668142557144, -0.021577121689915657, -0.009447063319385052, 0.02596091665327549, -0.0031647845171391964, 0.026029642671346664, -0.011786957271397114, 0.02960602380335331, 0.02410212531685829, -0.030131541192531586, -0.03020116500556469, 0.03683476895093918, 0.00664942990988493, 0.008221704512834549, 0.026353321969509125, -0.020747629925608635, -0.013942109420895576, 0.020260993391275406, 0.058420147746801376, -0.0022046598605811596, -0.0003035442787222564, 0.036464858800172806, 0.04440976679325104, -0.052849166095256805, 0.007616737391799688, 0.05142573267221451, 0.026791760697960854, -0.016449013724923134, -0.03584079444408417, -0.027937617152929306, 0.015543662942945957, -0.0019539035856723785, -0.007592714857310057, -0.025177834555506706, 0.009882060810923576, 0.02675987035036087, 0.023554690182209015, -0.0086646918207407, -0.07687880843877792, 0.0020248298533260822, -0.01751968078315258, 0.021970871835947037, -0.016917090862989426, -0.022095076739788055, -0.00906913261860609, 0.027588604018092155, 0.03197828680276871, 0.03779340535402298, 0.012621195055544376, -0.08395618200302124, -0.003476395271718502, 0.04851974546909332, 0.028267037123441696, 0.0059907566756010056, 0.007069526705890894, -0.011927308514714241, -0.00718259671702981, 0.05671875178813934, -0.003397864755243063, 0.03513796627521515, -0.02795431576669216, -0.026439331471920013, -0.05007690563797951, -0.02821224369108677, -0.01952042616903782, 0.023162560537457466, -0.008992310613393784, 0.0378948450088501, -0.005772157572209835, -0.0028885367792099714, -0.05189461261034012, 0.014527850784361362, 0.025728760287165642, 0.0751849040389061, 0.008700630627572536, -0.03442244604229927, -0.012444357387721539, 0.01763972081243992, -0.020110640674829483, -0.06585279107093811, 0.01254209689795971, 0.03865226358175278, -0.013846619985997677, 0.030564598739147186, -0.04244846850633621, -0.02145191840827465, 0.014201951213181019, -0.009018647484481335, 0.012478374876081944, 0.01467155572026968, -0.02375585399568081, 0.05411611869931221, 0.06108948215842247, 0.011480560526251793, -0.0005039737443439662, 0.029764749109745026, 0.024647869169712067, 0.012114224955439568, -0.010715393349528313, 0.019314752891659737, -0.03355151414871216, -0.02642236091196537, -0.026006240397691727, -0.030873382464051247, -0.05571284890174866, 0.029464805498719215, -0.03300415724515915, 0.007541687227785587, 0.011282823979854584, -0.03973469138145447, -0.03342752531170845, 0.03527314215898514, 0.006653267424553633, 0.03908076137304306, -0.017291540279984474, 0.048537399619817734, 0.014705784618854523, 0.028802363201975822, 0.021123606711626053, -0.005985823925584555, 0.0009166383533738554, 0.0156666599214077, -0.011452947743237019, -0.005011568311601877, -0.06968826800584793, 0.0062257954850792885, 0.026548704132437706, -0.012183169834315777, 0.0603950060904026, -0.034796878695487976, -0.0029252171516418457, 0.0037682983092963696, -0.06351810693740845, -0.03828109800815582, 0.009932728484272957, -0.006951343268156052, 0.013758816756308079, -0.024283725768327713, -0.0012957394355908036, 0.012575499713420868, 0.0013048012042418122, -0.06685442477464676, -0.05759099870920181, 0.018888629972934723, -0.0029145877342671156, -0.024240944534540176, -0.07191372662782669, 0.012985261157155037, -0.012205912731587887, -0.010277403518557549, -0.013321581296622753, 0.06715434789657593, -0.0003435231337789446, -0.05868712440133095, -0.000778068439103663, 0.002504563657566905, 0.06767525523900986, 0.009449543431401253, 0.0012358706444501877, 0.0143860699608922, 0.006585682276636362, 0.009968515485525131, -0.00763426348567009, 0.048496875911951065, -0.040787652134895325, -0.006461045239120722, -0.049015454947948456, 0.009826618246734142, 0.025970017537474632, -0.0512554831802845, -0.010981518775224686, -0.029863163828849792, 0.008633255958557129, 0.0022479004692286253, -0.019607998430728912, -0.021595705300569534, -0.005638216622173786, -0.037064120173454285, -0.019622327759861946, 0.04051490128040314, 0.03324989974498749, -0.04385392367839813, 0.041444435715675354, -0.0003214404277969152, -0.04121442511677742, 0.0006401182035915554, 0.008164335042238235, 0.027365077286958694, -0.02643454261124134, 0.028584197163581848, -0.01232441607862711, 0.05721399560570717, -0.004113212693482637, -0.01643686182796955, 0.029333343729376793, 0.019028570502996445, -0.00876785721629858, -0.021455343812704086, -0.012983392924070358, 0.014430844224989414, 0.04968472942709923, -0.023476652801036835, 0.04825885593891144, 0.04052967205643654, -0.000533995043952018, 0.018373947590589523, 0.013141538016498089, 0.01824059523642063, -0.030846480280160904, 0.01982598565518856, 0.03378952667117119, 0.0012944894842803478, -0.007943738251924515, 0.004479321651160717, 0.031163997948169708, -0.021334590390324593, 0.0049669803120195866, -0.00774796400219202, 0.021972114220261574, 0.03191128745675087, -0.017838040366768837, -0.060181621462106705, 0.014854670502245426, -0.010760024189949036, 0.0060790725983679295, -0.01460443064570427, -0.028323601931333542, 0.028827911242842674, 0.03860459476709366, 0.01759626343846321, 0.0006927931681275368, -0.014193707145750523, -0.05058484524488449, 0.0049326373264193535, 0.02116166613996029, -0.008006332442164421, 0.03634171560406685, -0.016150636598467827, 0.040998976677656174, 0.0010537694906815886, -0.007418555673211813, -0.013991376385092735, -0.019890883937478065, -0.028970474377274513, -0.04801231250166893, -0.031365882605314255, 0.030017854645848274, 0.013802961446344852, -0.04068661853671074, 0.012609335593879223, 0.04511721059679985, -0.0214326661080122, 0.03150951489806175, 0.034547995775938034, -0.017758505418896675, 0.05905531719326973, 0.028934326022863388, 0.05104541778564453, -0.03691703453660011, -0.012875406071543694, 0.10969524085521698, 0.055285897105932236, 0.03661724925041199, -0.04896971955895424, 0.035451341420412064, 0.01921803690493107, -0.012919937260448933, -0.04824024438858032, 0.04198991879820824, 0.04894202947616577, -0.010857733897864819, 0.007515584584325552, 0.04349341243505478, 0.00149255758151412, 0.0035207243636250496, 0.08011817187070847, -0.04997960478067398, -0.009085939265787601, -0.0066887615248560905, -0.009347588755190372, -0.029555724933743477, -0.018325068056583405, -0.07106367498636246, 0.0358598418533802, 0.020730972290039062, -0.018871178850531578, -0.022540608420968056, -0.017799025401473045, 0.015500959940254688, -0.013052642345428467, -0.019976627081632614, 0.019693857058882713, 0.019719524309039116, -0.004682519473135471, -0.03266183286905289, -0.013780757784843445, 0.0038763186894357204, -0.015975773334503174, 0.02582543157041073, 0.03205700218677521, 0.05020046606659889, 0.021671172231435776, 0.0028712893836200237, 0.003653450170531869, -0.03897881880402565, -0.04990975186228752, -0.044731006026268005, 0.04886162281036377, -0.0043349540792405605, 0.03266344964504242, -0.006983202416449785, 0.01144441682845354, 0.016469812020659447, -0.06437961757183075, -0.0037545354571193457, -0.00412054592743516, 0.0650269091129303, 0.011493178084492683, 0.002162966877222061, -0.04764556512236595, 0.019525200128555298, -0.0038204421289265156, -0.001969471573829651, 0.008077978156507015, 0.021634837612509727, 0.014190023764967918, -0.013373522087931633, 0.04043660685420036, 0.012386485002934933, -0.03555227071046829, -0.029696237295866013, 0.01871122419834137, -0.005024865735322237, -0.0012533311964944005, 0.01867002621293068, -0.013044820167124271, 0.03103414550423622, 0.025961915031075478, -0.01359226182103157, 0.0019147644052281976, -0.029651183634996414, 0.022185008972883224, -0.04754151403903961, -0.034624554216861725, -0.020712627097964287, -0.018687531352043152, 0.056378770619630814, 0.04724738001823425, 0.0167485810816288, 0.03476856276392937, -0.04331211373209953, 0.06191275641322136, 0.01587272807955742, -0.009986242279410362, -0.005751202814280987, -0.018269788473844528, -0.006287447176873684, 0.03664697706699371, 0.013499099761247635, 0.029874900355935097, 0.021221159026026726, -0.0005306635866872966, 0.0011493671918287873, 0.01734035089612007, 0.02203231304883957, 0.016644593328237534, 0.013492491096258163, -0.05427566543221474, -0.017206130549311638, 0.0034391877707093954, 0.013785437680780888, -0.052854735404253006, -0.017459020018577576, -0.003985683433711529, -0.013487542048096657, -0.0028615090996026993, -0.006219679024070501, -0.008771980181336403, 0.00466595683246851, -0.02262479066848755, -0.00408135773614049, -0.05828435346484184, 0.011674323119223118, -0.03364744409918785, -0.0071130357682704926, -0.055685266852378845, -0.01899370551109314, -0.02777267061173916, 0.0019974266178905964, -0.00447318097576499, 0.0035723401233553886, 0.05244768410921097, 0.005296026356518269, 0.0028169865254312754, -0.023810165002942085, -0.006960903760045767, -0.01262172032147646, 0.025199688971042633, -0.037669066339731216, -0.014739537611603737, 0.033013716340065, -0.04190726578235626, -0.045641686767339706, 0.009184898808598518, -0.050565898418426514, 0.040254414081573486, 0.024267926812171936, -0.0316789411008358, 0.012933281250298023, 0.01808040216565132, 0.00014131011266727, -0.02201293222606182, 0.0166619885712862, 0.020653337240219116, -0.011715761385858059, -0.029441896826028824, 0.012968777678906918, 0.007625782396644354, -0.003087265184149146, -0.017560459673404694, 0.046646855771541595, 0.014981496147811413, -0.022249439731240273, 0.016082117334008217, 0.014492695219814777, 0.03769978880882263, -0.03609176725149155, 0.008671033196151257, 0.05915699899196625, 0.031146734952926636, -0.034864652901887894, 0.015470195561647415, -0.0015799751272425056, 0.03208886459469795, -0.10072997957468033, 0.007965683937072754, 0.0014567944454029202, -0.0006603665533475578, 0.057893961668014526, -0.07763588428497314, -0.022629203274846077, 0.035505328327417374, -0.045871369540691376, 0.04287160187959671, -0.022215502336621284, 0.02927217446267605, -0.032399982213974, -0.011758571490645409, -0.08355911821126938, 0.03216011822223663, 0.05402044579386711, 0.08426512032747269, 0.003780603874474764, 0.023809706792235374, -0.02960481122136116, -0.006440139841288328, 0.00244100927375257, -0.018583178520202637, 0.003047920297831297, -0.050243671983480453, 0.05980228632688522, -0.024916157126426697, -0.04425058513879776, 0.030122684314846992, -0.010867596603929996, 0.00891613494604826, 0.01867603324353695, -0.0025254925712943077, -0.00930505245923996, 0.01388168428093195, 0.018811818212270737, -0.013036608695983887, -0.0026204343885183334, -0.002921138424426317, 0.018176443874835968, 0.02764848619699478, -0.012394164688885212, -0.012710988521575928, 0.028639715164899826, -0.019046254456043243, -0.03706898167729378, 0.04182318598031998, -0.005709752906113863, -0.01514934841543436, -0.0046882047317922115, 0.012793655507266521, -0.00928753986954689, -0.03625255450606346, -0.016355236992239952, -0.005285711959004402, 0.0019812332466244698, 0.03336506709456444, 0.006462068762630224, -0.008447369560599327, 0.005113655235618353, -0.017072875052690506, -0.06304565072059631, 0.02110995166003704, -0.006962693762034178, -0.018565425649285316, -0.07571513205766678, 0.006742557045072317, -0.0042412676848471165, 0.007696494925767183, -0.01908114179968834, -0.003030359046533704, 0.019125523045659065, 0.08462084829807281, -0.02740941010415554, 0.0031089805997908115, 0.03409193083643913, -0.012875492684543133, -0.0010406277142465115, -0.0676497370004654, 0.04410398006439209, 0.02025887742638588, 0.020510759204626083, -0.051137134432792664, -0.015007141046226025, 0.0004283090529497713, 0.020911136642098427, 0.05745117366313934, -0.014973769895732403, 0.004190520849078894, 0.013739806599915028, 0.0463547483086586, 0.020311089232563972, -0.026769204065203667, 0.018355317413806915, -0.04601991921663284, -0.029658058658242226, 0.004908142611384392, -0.03652758523821831, -0.014698745682835579, -0.012584698386490345, 0.028159717097878456, 0.0001843860954977572, -0.01760663464665413, -0.002964107785373926, -0.006391800474375486, 0.036177366971969604, -0.0008685949142090976, 0.009462581016123295, 0.03320468217134476, 0.014188666827976704, -0.011520207859575748, 0.02641146630048752, -0.029101360589265823, -0.03654114529490471, 0.017127662897109985, -0.0384192168712616, -0.06537482887506485, 0.018217576667666435, 0.006416341755539179, 0.010070495307445526, -0.05727805197238922, -0.02867877669632435, 0.0086553068831563, -0.011407268233597279, -0.015535417012870312, 0.03572802245616913, 0.04665995016694069, 0.0431031733751297, 0.009647693485021591, 0.014670752920210361, 0.03282661736011505, -0.025486823171377182, 0.028873445466160774, 0.044954147189855576, 0.044438425451517105, -0.0009713513427414, -0.0006193452863954008, -0.02775382250547409, -0.006036386825144291, -0.004222352057695389, 0.009594756178557873, 0.0630040243268013, 0.01824195683002472, -0.00321983196772635, 0.014965446665883064, -0.014485043473541737, 0.002600847976282239, 0.030856896191835403, -0.02278587594628334, 0.04196774587035179, -0.02591349370777607, 0.01562926173210144, -0.04599802568554878, -0.02746979519724846, -0.04599140211939812, 0.03200707957148552, 0.004631445277482271, 0.03735215216875076, -0.016560019925236702, 0.022333046421408653, -0.01614520139992237, 0.014784922823309898, 0.02610747702419758, 0.002299702726304531, 0.0340927317738533, -0.014015227556228638, 0.007904432713985443, -0.012799269519746304, -0.046085916459560394, -0.02171988971531391, -0.03978873789310455, 0.03047836758196354, 0.0625201016664505, 0.04498367756605148, 0.013471732847392559, -0.01854523830115795, -0.046379804611206055, 0.03419895097613335, -0.090044766664505, -0.028020251542329788, -0.056401327252388, 0.011702029034495354, -0.019184475764632225, -0.028446217998862267 ]
<p>I'm developing prediction model based on PLS (partial least squares) analysis. I'm looking into variation captured by X(R square X), R square Y, number of components and accuracy after using cross validation, in the process of model development.</p> <p>Can anybody suggest me what should be the approach to trade off among R2X, number of components and accuracy percentage of the model.</p> <p>As a best practice, What are accepted levels of R2X and accuracy, in the industry? </p> <p>Thanks a lot for your help.</p>
73,589
[ -0.02680026739835739, -0.003208459820598364, -0.012988399714231491, -0.02226920798420906, 0.06362248212099075, 0.023408079519867897, -0.000057786972320172936, -0.03189970180392265, 0.05085090175271034, -0.007821680046617985, 0.037495363503694534, 0.024931376799941063, 0.05199817568063736, 0.01941554807126522, -0.0055376021191477776, -0.000010434800969960634, 0.013152659870684147, -0.03413397818803787, 0.00023644969041924924, 0.011967957019805908, 0.005852452013641596, 0.01345121581107378, 0.014728606678545475, -0.023258697241544724, -0.006971484981477261, 0.06382711231708527, 0.05973618105053902, -0.0015661487122997642, 0.03917320445179939, 0.019409196451306343, -0.02914016880095005, 0.0014050619211047888, 0.001451779156923294, 0.0760950967669487, 0.04833687096834183, 0.002364924643188715, -0.0452040396630764, -0.03509875386953354, -0.05391842499375343, 0.03600125014781952, -0.017559126019477844, -0.001926950179040432, 0.030504468828439713, 0.013295872136950493, -0.0007020149496383965, 0.00010953195305773988, -0.013680077157914639, -0.05298740789294243, 0.03931434452533722, -0.06838382035493851, 0.08450818061828613, 0.015696795657277107, 0.045483026653528214, 0.0052777002565562725, -0.03200526535511017, 0.030064765363931656, 0.06828998029232025, 0.04466453939676285, -0.04199129343032837, -0.07385578006505966, -0.0075880130752921104, 0.0016605835407972336, 0.03638853132724762, -0.05353882163763046, -0.04691276699304581, 0.042115263640880585, -0.01237097755074501, -0.029429353773593903, 0.029859289526939392, 0.0034500735346227884, -0.00012639860506169498, 0.008007165044546127, 0.009183388203382492, 0.017291028052568436, 0.0009896069532260299, -0.027450593188405037, -0.0042121997103095055, 0.04188055917620659, 0.05204853415489197, 0.01896686851978302, -0.006320287939161062, 0.030521389096975327, 0.01298151072114706, 0.03991345316171646, 0.023413505405187607, -0.009807731956243515, 0.026353029534220695, 0.00827434379607439, -0.0076973456889390945, -0.00794241949915886, -0.002292654011398554, 0.043086014688014984, 0.04203972965478897, 0.014474314637482166, -0.02604125626385212, 0.010097214952111244, 0.007858785800635815, 0.029002679511904716, -0.002669894602149725, -0.017223026603460312, 0.03028199076652527, -0.021265003830194473, -0.006671017035841942, 0.04692154377698898, -0.02235848270356655, -0.02509237825870514, -0.015573589131236076, -0.06672152131795883, 0.00942465104162693, -0.04701285809278488, 0.0027122653555125, -0.000017381842553731985, 0.01681983843445778, 0.008135841228067875, 0.004344992805272341, 0.008736060000956059, -0.007253217976540327, 0.00046733266208320856, 0.06258496642112732, 0.056265078485012054, 0.016957085579633713, -0.018750369548797607, 0.03544187173247337, 0.01355730276554823, -0.012907018885016441, 0.0043076579459011555, -0.0022712917998433113, -0.006220929324626923, -0.058404721319675446, 0.03164920583367348, 0.014159785583615303, -0.014236155897378922, 0.028025412932038307, -0.0314951092004776, 0.014337224885821342, 0.024654291570186615, -0.08940764516592026, -0.05224426090717316, 0.0135042117908597, -0.014050973579287529, 0.0014599544228985906, -0.0324215367436409, 0.003124117385596037, 0.03656551614403725, 0.07849776744842529, 0.0015992132248356938, 0.02782933972775936, 0.016356810927391052, 0.009376857429742813, -0.017352886497974396, -0.04645215719938278, -0.04437609389424324, -0.020266953855752945, -0.016228867694735527, -0.0018209157278761268, -0.04958705976605415, -0.00931989960372448, 0.032530274242162704, -0.03863651677966118, -0.00046843892778269947, -0.009681574068963528, 0.018805820494890213, -0.02775523066520691, 0.01421094685792923, -0.00122923927847296, -0.017187152057886124, 0.050807371735572815, -0.03299802914261818, 0.042381588369607925, 0.028226342052221298, -0.016889788210392, -0.01914113201200962, 0.02233547531068325, 0.03510032221674919, 0.04296810179948807, 0.019087035208940506, -0.0033348258584737778, -0.004177481401711702, -0.015373311936855316, 0.031765952706336975, -0.09378252923488617, -0.02917882800102234, 0.0027594531420618296, 0.020542893558740616, -0.008586318232119083, 0.02394922263920307, -0.028753815218806267, -0.035177815705537796, 0.04898637533187866, -0.01700395718216896, -0.016569333150982857, -0.05993656814098358, 0.031139079481363297, -0.022618088871240616, -0.050555143505334854, 0.009400526992976665, -0.00842403993010521, -0.02543584629893303, -0.025318484753370285, 0.009024230763316154, -0.06597540527582169, 0.02962019480764866, 0.010866591706871986, -0.02261161617934704, 0.027365880087018013, 0.060908105224370956, -0.008244344033300877, -0.011887679807841778, 0.025820082053542137, -0.03266202285885811, -0.054067738354206085, -0.010231301188468933, -0.05529879406094551, -0.003489184193313122, -0.026296639814972878, -0.06321796774864197, 0.0032287975773215294, -0.008302397094666958, -0.017771536484360695, 0.023322904482483864, -0.06302662938833237, 0.050533227622509, 0.06973864883184433, 0.0007798993610776961, 0.0017708519008010626, 0.0005814167088828981, 0.0027081214357167482, 0.028000565245747566, -0.010425282642245293, 0.01199227012693882, -0.0427585206925869, 0.016878565773367882, 0.027172183617949486, 0.030634364113211632, -0.05038671940565109, -0.023559175431728363, 0.09085986763238907, 0.0046457466669380665, 0.03385206311941147, 0.01917210966348648, 0.01631457917392254, -0.04378272593021393, 0.004884318448603153, 0.022326087579131126, -0.01480103749781847, 0.01346481405198574, 0.005780154839158058, 0.009191563352942467, 0.046608615666627884, -0.01904815435409546, -0.01034950464963913, 0.039746277034282684, -0.004337394144386053, 0.017922954633831978, 0.005192338023334742, -0.032107725739479065, 0.010547216050326824, 0.0018061321461573243, -0.0004866764647886157, 0.003823805134743452, 0.0306748878210783, 0.00756334001198411, -0.01798398792743683, -0.028455356135964394, 0.005243781954050064, 0.03020360693335533, -0.04330965876579285, -0.0021681985817849636, 0.014132107608020306, -0.029119139537215233, -0.016084149479866028, -0.03852960094809532, -0.01851595938205719, -0.06495143473148346, -0.006235085893422365, 0.05622488260269165, 0.0020188912749290466, 0.0350060798227787, 0.007273637689650059, -0.02919827774167061, -0.0004991432069800794, 0.0025234692730009556, -0.011684600263834, -0.03680182620882988, -0.04704144597053528, -0.01569482497870922, -0.019529903307557106, -0.007390865124762058, 0.025652820244431496, -0.011533929035067558, -0.04970751702785492, 0.04658287763595581, 0.021222909912467003, -0.06836265325546265, -0.014883673749864101, -0.01114124059677124, -0.004036896862089634, -0.003796814475208521, -0.032998207956552505, -0.01484836358577013, -0.010411392897367477, -0.053689852356910706, 0.028820568695664406, -0.026340356096625328, -0.000683236459735781, -0.0009315157076343894, -0.0033267519902437925, -0.010769326239824295, 0.00448634522035718, 0.011764991097152233, 0.03141041845083237, -0.00323582929559052, 0.00971057265996933, -0.029200922697782516, -0.06945822387933731, 0.000493111030664295, -0.012292220257222652, 0.0701078251004219, 0.004452213179320097, -0.01123472023755312, 0.08259087055921555, 0.009473457001149654, -0.03329049423336983, -0.03652065247297287, 0.025547940284013748, -0.04859071224927902, -0.011492370627820492, 0.03870010748505592, 0.007098007947206497, 0.01182313822209835, 0.03632112219929695, -0.014905416406691074, 0.014101358130574226, 0.033339306712150574, -0.0008718813769519329, 0.005244672764092684, 0.0071166218258440495, 0.028249384835362434, -0.007268236950039864, 0.032154884189367294, 0.022382771596312523, -0.01799774542450905, 0.034494202584028244, -0.02097875438630581, 0.01698925718665123, 0.02471495233476162, -0.027160270139575005, 0.0024201066698879004, -0.05299978330731392, 0.006258833687752485, 0.010746262967586517, 0.0118664326146245, -0.0021567472722381353, -0.04806264117360115, -0.012792855501174927, 0.011079948395490646, 0.054864056408405304, 0.02638036198914051, -0.06348913162946701, 0.040766578167676926, 0.04331659898161888, 0.015005109831690788, 0.0029155814554542303, -0.008565360680222511, 0.03465740755200386, 0.042175859212875366, -0.0023772509302943945, -0.029108960181474686, 0.05464310571551323, 0.028162047266960144, 0.01735367625951767, 0.0002173074899474159, -0.02687329798936844, -0.023580648005008698, -0.05764897167682648, -0.029291300103068352, -0.03106963448226452, 0.06225929036736488, -0.0015335382195189595, 0.04984628036618233, -0.0027198265306651592, -0.06310459226369858, 0.012505399994552135, -0.012347191572189331, -0.05012260749936104, 0.032267361879348755, 0.01646827533841133, -0.003814184106886387, 0.0030136769637465477, 0.0007433033897541463, 0.0067598228342831135, -0.036247752606868744, 0.022557441145181656, 0.009740909561514854, 0.048879045993089676, -0.021449513733386993, 0.02595904842019081, 0.003036737907677889, 0.005057057831436396, -0.0190416406840086, 0.04558867961168289, -0.00393197825178504, 0.00640044966712594, 0.03019843064248562, 0.03165862709283829, -0.04028792679309845, -0.004820715170353651, -0.018111182376742363, -0.011126025579869747, 0.008138255216181278, 0.046095721423625946, 0.017591796815395355, 0.020284580066800117, -0.013674525544047356, 0.03933703526854515, 0.002614804543554783, 0.02543959580361843, 0.05067898705601692, 0.020748991519212723, -0.032728515565395355, -0.04095858335494995, -0.02792503498494625, 0.008596227504312992, 0.0318121612071991, -0.0044419956393539906, -0.017123235389590263, 0.010812865570187569, -0.009040135890245438, -0.06456878036260605, -0.03081992082297802, 0.06931954622268677, 0.026679953560233116, 0.010272222571074963, -0.016662904992699623, -0.0050052800215780735, 0.013824195601046085, -0.018307585269212723, 0.027378050610423088, 0.021665479987859726, -0.024582067504525185, -0.017309874296188354, 0.02040288783609867, -0.029157523065805435, -0.056875769048929214, 0.01516637485474348, 0.028607288375496864, 0.03232172504067421, 0.01274079643189907, -0.0227133110165596, 0.013586637564003468, 0.06577455252408981, 0.05646544694900513, 0.025536203756928444, -0.015839317813515663, -0.059708211570978165, -0.008885142393410206, 0.04888421669602394, 0.05372912436723709, -0.0536065474152565, -0.04033149406313896, -0.013284644111990929, 0.005544531624764204, 0.036419373005628586, -0.02915780059993267, 0.01222973596304655, -0.003627004334703088, -0.009488510899245739, -0.023482711985707283, -0.016732633113861084, -0.0347759872674942, -0.009350785985589027, -0.027743279933929443, 0.06021593138575554, -0.031813740730285645, -0.0152576994150877, -0.016380557790398598, 0.022598996758461, 0.01904616877436638, 0.05982860550284386, -0.01625579223036766, -0.022193260490894318, -0.03478080779314041, 0.024716798216104507, 0.012113302946090698, -0.07349752634763718, -0.009019212797284126, 0.020710663869976997, -0.01731342077255249, 0.050036393105983734, -0.0031157275661826134, -0.038029640913009644, -0.003361911280080676, 0.025169070810079575, -0.033715344965457916, -0.002887880429625511, -0.027672965079545975, 0.017033299431204796, 0.046620551496744156, 0.0015354922506958246, 0.07204965502023697, -0.013074205256998539, 0.012059671804308891, -0.009102795273065567, 0.010553420521318913, 0.01757238805294037, -0.019072486087679863, -0.04252238944172859, -0.02347688563168049, -0.021251168102025986, -0.02650476060807705, 0.021214792504906654, -0.012852052226662636, 0.07663791626691818, -0.02707020938396454, -0.020691445097327232, 0.00445669936016202, 0.07822144776582718, -0.010758970864117146, 0.0056218900717794895, 0.017606515437364578, 0.04579952359199524, -0.02404666505753994, 0.03535841032862663, -0.023494621738791466, 0.013100393116474152, 0.019048061221837997, 0.03663048893213272, 0.0164958443492651, 0.01515677385032177, -0.030676765367388725, -0.040808506309986115, -0.005608290899544954, -0.027501098811626434, 0.04586650803685188, 0.005147557705640793, 0.051584482192993164, 0.025451205670833588, -0.053030963987112045, -0.001147134811617434, 0.02777489833533764, 0.005468172486871481, 0.06108446046710014, -0.04599187895655632, 0.023118751123547554, -0.04033998027443886, 0.005722092464566231, -0.07872559130191803, -0.06935691088438034, 0.04395430535078049, 0.0218189787119627, -0.029577964916825294, 0.0060009825974702835, 0.005484886933118105, -0.016566714271903038, -0.0021120852325111628, -0.04328759014606476, 0.026670033112168312, -0.022564321756362915, -0.030099455267190933, -0.007961700670421124, 0.006711688823997974, 0.06602116674184799, -0.013330916874110699, 0.0195904653519392, 0.01448006834834814, -0.011434205807745457, -0.006507759913802147, -0.002859851811081171, -0.009549138136208057, -0.03096860460937023, -0.024138620123267174, -0.040942784398794174, 0.03022652305662632, 0.05842597782611847, -0.02281501702964306, 0.0010458598844707012, -0.0026531859766691923, 0.01369390543550253, -0.02871100604534149, 0.0013686040183529258, 0.02296103723347187, -0.0381980836391449, -0.012831440195441246, 0.004498813766986132, -0.006099896505475044, -0.03319196030497551, -0.0048738643527030945, -0.02488909848034382, -0.0061358800157904625, 0.017650747671723366, 0.004040072672069073, 0.0635717362165451, 0.007168559357523918, 0.0038865262176841497, 0.00029487075516954064, -0.04152771085500717, 0.052311286330223083, 0.0025513432919979095, 0.005149591248482466, -0.0004178833623882383, 0.02394833415746689, -0.00908204261213541, -0.044930219650268555, -0.01145642064511776, 0.0035360988695174456, 0.03541472926735878, -0.019162990152835846, 0.036928143352270126, 0.0269517470151186, 0.018463600426912308, -0.05325339734554291, -0.03131457790732384, -0.01442940067499876, -0.0009540936443954706, 0.004827999044209719, 0.06788291037082672, 0.01569533348083496, -0.04244844242930412, -0.0006193795707076788, 0.00581627432256937, 0.03150729089975357, 0.015363616868853569, 0.0046283951960504055, 0.04245483875274658, 0.022385118529200554, -0.032533202320337296, -0.053296398371458054, 0.00957387126982212, -0.031528931111097336, 0.004366829060018063, -0.020683567970991135, -0.008883604779839516, 0.04650305211544037, 0.01747427135705948, 0.024880116805434227, -0.03875899687409401, -0.010321619920432568, -0.022464659065008163, 0.00665151746943593, 0.013731393031775951, -0.011149083264172077, -0.0024238775949925184, 0.005134134087711573, 0.026034342125058174, 0.028831731528043747, 0.052514586597681046, -0.023974617943167686, -0.10282246768474579, -0.01647830195724964, 0.013635756447911263, -0.043797817081213, 0.007274551782757044, 0.030707642436027527, -0.02836630679666996, -0.009385949932038784, -0.004298479296267033, 0.025319699198007584, -0.010150907561182976, 0.023897765204310417, -0.05027494207024574, 0.0438777357339859, -0.011557883583009243, 0.02987954020500183, 0.020244721323251724, 0.03448404371738434, 0.10398756712675095, 0.10831303894519806, 0.024139324203133583, -0.022931817919015884, 0.03119843080639839, -0.03854140639305115, -0.00893794558942318, -0.04429464787244797, 0.018320444971323013, 0.023313650861382484, 0.01399716455489397, 0.03969893604516983, 0.022170018404722214, 0.008085111156105995, -0.01908770017325878, 0.0404764860868454, -0.02300840988755226, -0.011482602916657925, 0.01686449721455574, 0.014446855522692204, 0.028908757492899895, 0.02109169401228428, -0.02087814174592495, 0.00799577496945858, -0.006649185437709093, -0.04024209827184677, -0.020855523645877838, -0.021606026217341423, 0.02500724047422409, -0.0080404756590724, -0.03479357436299324, 0.003228887217119336, 0.010867862962186337, 0.029023198410868645, -0.03283832222223282, 0.01582132652401924, 0.004995512776076794, -0.01033898163586855, 0.004992784932255745, 0.02688111551105976, 0.0032055804040282965, -0.05497264117002487, 0.022609638050198555, 0.019690532237291336, -0.08185182511806488, -0.025097664445638657, -0.06851276755332947, 0.021452590823173523, 0.007506437599658966, 0.026719411835074425, 0.014509286731481552, 0.0394715890288353, 0.013288001529872417, -0.06407778710126877, -0.04170797020196915, 0.05977946147322655, 0.023380544036626816, -0.010923543013632298, -0.041771646589040756, -0.00719247804954648, 0.03938187658786774, -0.004456669557839632, 0.013290533795952797, 0.004300600383430719, -0.04399491101503372, -0.03272515535354614, -0.03479153290390968, 0.0541047677397728, -0.027863387018442154, 0.02796865999698639, -0.003595188492909074, 0.019483817741274834, -0.022427761927247047, 0.011035583913326263, 0.02567131072282791, 0.006158416159451008, 0.008934655226767063, -0.013394166715443134, 0.0034048946108669043, -0.027921436354517937, -0.045137275010347366, 0.020494535565376282, -0.010745793581008911, 0.024235205724835396, -0.047514885663986206, 0.03974423557519913, 0.02245413325726986, 0.023375671356916428, -0.0011279704049229622, 0.011065731756389141, -0.006909295916557312, 0.015031669288873672, -0.0006450663786381483, -0.03657275810837746, 0.016604280099272728, 0.021038563922047615, -0.043036043643951416, 0.00432161008939147, 0.006588930729776621, 0.032117538154125214, 0.03024314157664776, 0.009837303310632706, -0.03804517537355423, 0.029401279985904694, -0.004240302834659815, 0.0027855094522237778, 0.006387633737176657, -0.04405216500163078, -0.006269979290664196, 0.011889726854860783, 0.017794478684663773, -0.04940914735198021, -0.007200322579592466, -0.024843808263540268, -0.0475824698805809, 0.008174954913556576, -0.009019516408443451, -0.01786186546087265, 0.03592830151319504, -0.02019469067454338, 0.011953103356063366, -0.010825086385011673, 0.03249267861247063, -0.011118758469820023, 0.00391772435978055, -0.01729876734316349, -0.0305141843855381, 0.02309527061879635, -0.02056018076837063, 0.0016506962710991502, 0.0054360306821763515, 0.019672533497214317, 0.002586240880191326, 0.019215689972043037, -0.016077222302556038, -0.01906006596982479, -0.011867753230035305, 0.05098743736743927, -0.050408001989126205, -0.02187209762632847, 0.013432779349386692, -0.05621637403964996, -0.05027707666158676, 0.0294023547321558, -0.035181134939193726, 0.04695349186658859, 0.012702010571956635, 0.021002931520342827, 0.0006959406309761107, 0.04417584091424942, 0.004018915817141533, -0.017137767747044563, -0.0015886231558397412, 0.06889461725950241, 0.006710912566632032, -0.005826706998050213, 0.029257718473672867, -0.02166994847357273, 0.0058664679527282715, 0.023302407935261726, 0.03824325650930405, -0.009687008336186409, -0.02420402690768242, 0.027134794741868973, -0.05133173242211342, -0.012508906424045563, 0.013665047474205494, -0.005321475677192211, 0.04873235523700714, 0.0061931004747748375, -0.04569688439369202, 0.022647645324468613, -0.00016900605987757444, -0.0006140207988210022, -0.055174216628074646, -0.04523327201604843, 0.009450774639844894, 0.024404184892773628, 0.03144235163927078, -0.04224251210689545, 0.008692118339240551, 0.049043189734220505, -0.03529263660311699, 0.02297523245215416, -0.005621806718409061, 0.01818511262536049, -0.018050475046038628, 0.0029749316163361073, -0.04793160408735275, 0.0071291616186499596, 0.021343395113945007, -0.01567595824599266, 0.034529976546764374, 0.029225122183561325, 0.00044910662109032273, -0.03265763446688652, 0.0073933047242462635, 0.043508440256118774, -0.005295758135616779, -0.06049296632409096, 0.0272249486297369, -0.017275173217058182, -0.03378889709711075, 0.014657524414360523, -0.034845270216464996, 0.04159751534461975, -0.0006860350840725005, 0.021769966930150986, 0.011661121621727943, 0.029258746653795242, 0.026667112484574318, -0.020627470687031746, -0.01151743158698082, -0.025393635034561157, 0.0018138610757887363, 0.01736210472881794, -0.016488883644342422, 0.028497418388724327, 0.04014004021883011, -0.008167359977960587, -0.01602349430322647, 0.00867410283535719, -0.018820030614733696, -0.017686177045106888, -0.005374071653932333, 0.035952333360910416, -0.011485066264867783, -0.043162524700164795, -0.0203725453466177, -0.03090554103255272, -0.015785308554768562, 0.03934737667441368, 0.02024414949119091, -0.02008466236293316, 0.001529641100205481, -0.021045321598649025, -0.05378337204456329, 0.009875093586742878, -0.010176900774240494, -0.033116526901721954, -0.07106982916593552, 0.001163126085884869, 0.024300359189510345, -0.03890550509095192, -0.020296698436141014, -0.02355223521590233, -0.015108111314475536, 0.051250115036964417, -0.005319273564964533, -0.013982678763568401, 0.02416168339550495, -0.011928168125450611, -0.006755563896149397, -0.08889178186655045, 0.07529060542583466, 0.017172925174236298, -0.04950929433107376, -0.016270242631435394, -0.039108797907829285, -0.021667134016752243, -0.01388601679354906, 0.056885264813899994, 0.031093908473849297, -0.015858709812164307, -0.03898016735911369, 0.021174820140004158, -0.011900904588401318, -0.039182763546705246, 0.05634802207350731, -0.013807789422571659, -0.015914158895611763, -0.03744443133473396, -0.003586186096072197, 0.026613861322402954, 0.011113403365015984, 0.02539377473294735, -0.03621182590723038, 0.06270258873701096, 0.0013154674088582397, -0.02362801507115364, 0.03896644711494446, -0.01605135016143322, -0.0058282907120883465, 0.04782843589782715, 0.010443400591611862, 0.011180705390870571, 0.014231360517442226, -0.01362682320177555, -0.05264507234096527, 0.010063910856842995, -0.011156231164932251, 0.010013209655880928, 0.009261436760425568, 0.013719763606786728, 0.021673323586583138, -0.07077595591545105, -0.004517058376222849, 0.05733655020594597, -0.05201460421085358, 0.031540755182504654, 0.06404684484004974, 0.03965334594249725, 0.028389696031808853, -0.006998941767960787, 0.02833498828113079, 0.025785580277442932, -0.01081005111336708, -0.027617337182164192, -0.015691488981246948, 0.04331314191222191, 0.0303991436958313, 0.054425813257694244, 0.028369249776005745, -0.029135050252079964, 0.026783203706145287, -0.0014397844206541777, 0.022621361538767815, -0.06344101577997208, 0.03496712073683739, 0.05906762555241585, -0.02148367650806904, 0.032513536512851715, -0.01144020352512598, -0.06094801425933838, 0.07115881145000458, -0.03317289426922798, -0.03644227236509323, -0.07989618927240372, -0.030960114672780037, -0.0014612642116844654, -0.02530115470290184, 0.01671210490167141, 0.06890611350536346, 0.027145780622959137, 0.029541242867708206, -0.03756817430257797, -0.012414212338626385, 0.0373944491147995, -0.0037763684522360563, 0.018054360523819923, -0.02261248603463173, 0.025629185140132904, -0.047449029982089996, -0.017998136579990387, -0.030786002054810524, 0.0133920693770051, 0.05561662092804909, 0.04763965308666229, 0.049957435578107834, 0.013815696351230145, -0.037466902285814285, 0.023211125284433365, 0.009914252907037735, -0.041006460785865784, -0.013983658514916897, -0.0314042828977108, -0.0038970045279711485, -0.020248405635356903, -0.007466277573257685 ]
<p>I am fitting curves to my data to extract one parameter. However, I am unsure what the certainty of that parameter is and how I would calculate / express its $95$% confidence interval.</p> <p>Say for a dataset containing data that exponentially decays, I fit a curve to each dataset. Then the information I want to extract is the exponent $b$. I know the values of $t$ and the value of $a$ I am not interested in (thats a variable that comes from the population, not the process Im trying to model).</p> <p>I use non-linear regression to fit these parameters. However I dont know how to compute the $95$% confidence interval for any method, so broader answers are welcome as well.</p> <p>$$f= a\cdot e^{-bt}$$ <img src="http://www.mathworks.nl/help/releases/R2013b/matlab/math/expfun.gif" alt="example data and fit"></p> <p>Once I have my value for $b$, how do I calculate its $95$% confidence interval? Thanks in advance!</p>
25,042
[ 0.003527998458594084, -0.019508013501763344, 0.009213291108608246, 0.006211432628333569, -0.007094184868037701, 0.012285714969038963, -0.033337969332933426, 0.001058723428286612, -0.00864484440535307, -0.04627908021211624, 0.02772589400410652, 0.05573321878910065, 0.008290201425552368, 0.0052274130284786224, -0.0024179485626518726, 0.00014437113713938743, -0.02001427300274372, 0.01995672844350338, -0.016910986974835396, -0.010398400947451591, 0.01620432548224926, -0.00919969193637371, -0.004827975295484066, -0.01394614391028881, -0.04175640270113945, 0.05883856862783432, 0.02727320045232773, 0.012077766470611095, -0.012391545809805393, 0.10535470396280289, -0.008522807620465755, -0.07521168887615204, -0.0010042412905022502, 0.012672638520598412, 0.01505532767623663, 0.021895935758948326, -0.036432329565286636, -0.031049862504005432, 0.001197058823890984, 0.023327654227614403, -0.025758884847164154, -0.02445157617330551, 0.02090534195303917, 0.030603893101215363, 0.0182037390768528, 0.01060979999601841, -0.008010868914425373, -0.022090014070272446, 0.036553557962179184, -0.015777116641402245, 0.06947124749422073, -0.0005100692505948246, 0.04427248612046242, -0.0013324907049536705, -0.0038690699730068445, -0.014530930668115616, 0.02565736323595047, 0.05814078450202942, -0.01721625216305256, -0.06660334020853043, -0.023587869480252266, -0.022078771144151688, -0.006713793613016605, -0.03350398316979408, -0.019045336171984673, 0.008723090402781963, -0.0455932654440403, 0.00004725903636426665, 0.06538981944322586, -0.04383860528469086, 0.021818244829773903, 0.01189807802438736, 0.029445044696331024, -0.06370022892951965, 0.012157660908997059, -0.032818667590618134, 0.01841823384165764, 0.02954278700053692, 0.049899328500032425, 0.063046894967556, -0.031052254140377045, 0.0012282722163945436, 0.008400842547416687, 0.03969583660364151, 0.020777685567736626, 0.013696316629648209, 0.044504836201667786, -0.007355845998972654, 0.05643242225050926, 0.022027580067515373, -0.00187669915612787, -0.000018704946342040785, 0.03756285831332207, -0.0339670404791832, -0.029290994629263878, 0.03831666335463524, -0.009716724045574665, 0.04874279350042343, 0.03325311467051506, -0.01718587800860405, 0.026381302624940872, -0.03757306933403015, 0.019399013370275497, 0.04524033144116402, -0.002777665387839079, 0.01780516654253006, -0.007590423803776503, -0.024534549564123154, -0.018736302852630615, -0.04648319259285927, 0.033767443150281906, 0.03066089004278183, 0.00616585835814476, 0.003359471680596471, 0.04277689382433891, -0.00491080479696393, -0.005402036476880312, -0.0497218482196331, 0.03352733701467514, 0.023668918758630753, 0.03838873282074928, -0.007211463525891304, 0.011210236698389053, 0.013132303021848202, -0.022109616547822952, -0.027613284066319466, 0.02553565613925457, 0.03207319602370262, -0.04402098432183266, 0.03973791003227234, -0.0055609289556741714, -0.06702598929405212, 0.04279173165559769, 0.02439207397401333, 0.04352332279086113, -0.030146075412631035, -0.05019001662731171, -0.08730041980743408, 0.026837846264243126, 0.0007507865084335208, -0.01852450892329216, -0.041748031973838806, 0.005630411207675934, 0.07603941857814789, 0.06601054966449738, 0.01592036336660385, 0.015385397709906101, -0.006743327248841524, 0.04789883270859718, 0.009312138892710209, -0.028830422088503838, 0.016183312982320786, -0.01571434549987316, -0.01163136400282383, -0.010258127003908157, -0.05575405806303024, 0.01646992564201355, 0.022049371153116226, -0.02215179055929184, -0.051039598882198334, 0.04194677621126175, -0.003814753144979477, -0.01505665946751833, -0.0028166589327156544, -0.014296079985797405, -0.01591453328728676, 0.09406773746013641, -0.014353560283780098, 0.032993026077747345, -0.003405984491109848, 0.01466331072151661, 0.016927668824791908, 0.013873007148504257, 0.023513445630669594, 0.0629040002822876, -0.026825835928320885, -0.005191820673644543, -0.061243243515491486, 0.021007513627409935, 0.039667658507823944, -0.05277574807405472, -0.052129123359918594, -0.004816920962184668, -0.00805896520614624, 0.025379659608006477, 0.02459615096449852, 0.0012050520163029432, -0.01632700301706791, 0.043094199150800705, -0.06572107970714569, -0.03439117223024368, -0.06656976789236069, 0.03268304839730263, 0.011757854372262955, -0.031617194414138794, -0.010830607265233994, -0.004437792114913464, 0.005067288875579834, 0.007250630296766758, -0.010415604338049889, 0.01234836783260107, 0.022621862590312958, 0.04965772479772568, -0.044167887419462204, 0.011537511833012104, 0.04483501985669136, 0.05864696949720383, -0.01784525066614151, 0.04370972141623497, -0.03464492782950401, -0.01716369204223156, -0.005338885355740786, -0.06355994939804077, -0.013842480257153511, -0.011223078705370426, -0.06892181932926178, -0.033171750605106354, -0.033510204404592514, -0.01718059368431568, 0.006879179738461971, -0.03208990767598152, 0.039411138743162155, 0.04109602048993111, 0.049116384238004684, 0.008244914934039116, 0.013151580467820168, 0.02367609553039074, 0.044081661850214005, -0.03036409616470337, -0.03390658274292946, -0.06210958585143089, 0.0012227267725393176, 0.02657865732908249, 0.011994142085313797, -0.01734112948179245, 0.01500589121133089, 0.023644689470529556, -0.03268003836274147, 0.031065240502357483, 0.05370829626917839, -0.014157930389046669, -0.016358481720089912, -0.020951878279447556, 0.030386922881007195, 0.021490266546607018, 0.027330297976732254, -0.0017906103748828173, 0.046181488782167435, 0.05325576290488243, 0.022123202681541443, 0.03808747977018356, 0.005890923552215099, 0.016080515459179878, -0.018917996436357498, -0.03361218795180321, 0.026782143861055374, 0.03437795117497444, -0.04092524200677872, -0.025915907695889473, 0.023799801245331764, -0.019535202533006668, 0.018654631450772285, 0.013012425974011421, -0.0427120141685009, 0.019740857183933258, 0.01669209450483322, -0.04068119451403618, -0.015094246715307236, 0.008813625201582909, -0.010824676603078842, 0.004232518374919891, -0.0026139868423342705, -0.011944309808313847, 0.0029489570297300816, 0.032054603099823, 0.03345473110675812, 0.014383018016815186, 0.03820390626788139, -0.020818233489990234, -0.05980865657329559, 0.018372423946857452, -0.019283149391412735, 0.01344394963234663, -0.02236441895365715, -0.055600184947252274, -0.01093811821192503, 0.013290369883179665, -0.03165527060627937, 0.009466049261391163, 0.002285777823999524, -0.01657712645828724, -0.006920396815985441, -0.022541023790836334, -0.05390257015824318, -0.018017075955867767, -0.011121598072350025, -0.02729029208421707, 0.0029879289213567972, -0.018107980489730835, 0.025690434500575066, -0.007267652079463005, -0.016702381893992424, 0.0678768903017044, -0.0433075837790966, -0.020933616906404495, -0.012376902624964714, 0.027512146160006523, -0.0194619782269001, 0.010316004045307636, 0.04404006525874138, -0.019474001601338387, -0.004329756833612919, -0.03699621185660362, -0.07132820039987564, -0.058614905923604965, -0.0031787569168955088, 0.016132615506649017, 0.030918292701244354, -0.0020279637537896633, -0.04080259054899216, 0.08425725996494293, 0.04313969984650612, -0.04239625856280327, -0.02144707553088665, -0.025712257251143456, -0.02452177368104458, -0.0026765251532197, -0.025478703901171684, 0.024576107040047646, 0.008028806187212467, -0.00015516999701503664, -0.006724689155817032, 0.01247985940426588, 0.03825082257390022, 0.004967228975147009, 0.01867431215941906, -0.002185461111366749, 0.00886757206171751, 0.014549150131642818, 0.04405227303504944, 0.02251608669757843, 0.014275752007961273, 0.04757549613714218, -0.02919711172580719, -0.0056835985742509365, 0.030209599062800407, -0.08142935484647751, 0.0027934981044381857, -0.016016531735658646, 0.015291952528059483, -0.06329108029603958, 0.014179730787873268, -0.02614925056695938, -0.007945171557366848, 0.005017810966819525, 0.04238242655992508, 0.029189201071858406, 0.005360784009099007, -0.005532432813197374, 0.02536514215171337, 0.04131850600242615, 0.0023066154681146145, -0.033193714916706085, -0.00794365257024765, -0.006281404756009579, 0.010866853408515453, -0.011624626815319061, -0.018034232780337334, 0.04148631542921066, 0.027204904705286026, -0.0002694999857340008, -0.023151550441980362, -0.011860031634569168, -0.017891306430101395, -0.027729351073503494, -0.04750211164355278, -0.006082130130380392, 0.054779428988695145, -0.0016730105271562934, 0.036587320268154144, 0.020359454676508904, -0.013058578595519066, 0.018299773335456848, 0.028413547202944756, -0.08600615710020065, 0.06380310654640198, -0.004206369165331125, -0.05562788248062134, -0.010418140329420567, -0.009807158261537552, 0.050868164747953415, -0.02590182051062584, -0.016972854733467102, 0.005624167155474424, 0.04211148992180824, -0.04990382120013237, 0.008221222087740898, -0.03809596970677376, -0.013827592134475708, -0.030734244734048843, 0.012691543437540531, -0.006359362509101629, 0.004459352698177099, 0.034992121160030365, 0.0303916297852993, 0.010837137699127197, -0.026931989938020706, -0.004176355432718992, -0.020499268546700478, 0.03366377204656601, 0.0443425327539444, 0.040115777403116226, 0.032317645847797394, -0.033862631767988205, -0.02492067776620388, -0.01212866511195898, 0.059640735387802124, 0.04344981163740158, 0.020220614969730377, 0.01863700896501541, -0.0430392362177372, 0.012310697697103024, -0.0010953482706099749, 0.0061158365570008755, -0.009520698338747025, -0.022676391527056694, 0.05670604482293129, 0.01742217317223549, -0.05429764837026596, 0.02240266650915146, 0.03927439823746681, 0.002704025711864233, 0.01588018424808979, -0.04792073369026184, 0.009245985187590122, 0.00733523815870285, -0.001442230073735118, -0.021180005744099617, 0.010494157671928406, 0.008459031581878662, -0.046916939318180084, 0.06386066228151321, 0.00955705065280199, -0.005169046111404896, -0.024473993107676506, 0.04626414552330971, 0.062195856124162674, 0.007545396685600281, -0.03043987601995468, 0.015025784261524677, 0.021640276536345482, 0.046917714178562164, 0.010181678459048271, 0.022231463342905045, -0.0897347703576088, 0.023522013798356056, 0.01215290930122137, 0.041048042476177216, -0.0036650437396019697, -0.011701944284141064, -0.03166082873940468, -0.016314774751663208, 0.03529742732644081, 0.0014092510100454092, 0.009384389035403728, -0.004841975402086973, 0.025131257250905037, -0.03701741248369217, -0.007350902538746595, -0.0501520112156868, -0.02898513525724411, -0.03979437053203583, 0.0011067957384511828, -0.06166892126202583, -0.008077727630734444, -0.025979017838835716, 0.005594522692263126, 0.02114119939506054, 0.0813906341791153, -0.009283334016799927, -0.04461485892534256, 0.0088672935962677, -0.006060256622731686, -0.0058775413781404495, -0.02680603787302971, 0.023684335872530937, -0.016853829845786095, -0.04153725132346153, 0.0369972288608551, 0.01119707990437746, -0.04893560707569122, 0.035314012318849564, 0.009397539310157299, -0.002208198420703411, 0.006330149248242378, -0.012326815165579319, 0.03982502967119217, -0.014220558106899261, 0.014098525047302246, 0.07631362974643707, 0.0433712899684906, 0.031442418694496155, -0.0012399086263030767, -0.04014902561903, 0.010598352178931236, 0.0040639713406562805, -0.0006607577670365572, -0.03232639655470848, 0.0014781745849177241, -0.05322626233100891, 0.03742199391126633, 0.005665571894496679, -0.010272189974784851, 0.0002644750929903239, -0.010340012609958649, 0.011662652716040611, 0.01413530483841896, -0.015553951263427734, -0.0018725312547758222, 0.004868739750236273, 0.02281818725168705, -0.03095836751163006, -0.01686679571866989, -0.0008064720896072686, -0.001093361061066389, 0.03252781555056572, 0.01447345595806837, -0.060553308576345444, 0.018111102283000946, -0.013537904247641563, -0.019481893628835678, 0.025322280824184418, -0.07110338658094406, 0.009298918768763542, 0.0038110956083983183, -0.007262120489031076, -0.004022678826004267, -0.03711074963212013, -0.013663778081536293, 0.009861186146736145, 0.04677385836839676, 0.05663471296429634, -0.05560718849301338, 0.0046996669843792915, 0.0005735869635827839, -0.0324985571205616, -0.06928082555532455, -0.054703302681446075, 0.03926004096865654, 0.01197440829128027, -0.026080450043082237, -0.024137277156114578, -0.009178302250802517, -0.03275537118315697, -0.005261129233986139, -0.0185264702886343, 0.05843966081738472, 0.020114120095968246, -0.004769983701407909, 0.007698835339397192, 0.01699436642229557, 0.0464700385928154, 0.008621767163276672, 0.004351572133600712, 0.007919413968920708, 0.025390660390257835, -0.011153757572174072, 0.04401085898280144, 0.0004816254077013582, -0.004518258385360241, 0.0096622034907341, -0.012719659134745598, 0.013593880459666252, 0.03988346457481384, 0.01935052126646042, -0.047150421887636185, 0.016345206648111343, 0.05426342412829399, 0.008107723668217659, -0.001675904612056911, -0.005238963291049004, -0.00021847397147212178, 0.03885504975914955, -0.0017608465859666467, -0.014765480533242226, 0.003195207566022873, -0.026644214987754822, 0.02053208276629448, -0.005731977056711912, 0.0003573317371774465, 0.010656993836164474, 0.07065464556217194, -0.014537986367940903, -0.001927462755702436, -0.03321116417646408, -0.015427556820213795, 0.048048894852399826, 0.010613496415317059, -0.007721025962382555, 0.011686758138239384, 0.00917954184114933, -0.03997404873371124, -0.004911468829959631, -0.05086810141801834, -0.03130459785461426, 0.06810275465250015, -0.0011127243051305413, 0.06610041856765747, 0.02262207120656967, 0.03291765972971916, 0.011255931109189987, -0.014376954175531864, -0.023265613242983818, 0.00570369977504015, -0.014611877501010895, 0.009584104642271996, -0.02662496268749237, -0.005164356902241707, 0.012766506522893906, 0.032140422612428665, -0.001714595127850771, 0.07450596988201141, -0.004769488703459501, 0.03739443048834801, 0.01828727312386036, -0.007898584939539433, -0.0303861852735281, 0.026085825636982918, -0.010843183845281601, 0.03014141134917736, -0.009989632293581963, -0.002987413201481104, 0.03646814078092575, 0.0473921000957489, 0.006642235442996025, -0.021732935681939125, -0.025353016331791878, -0.06752283871173859, -0.011654319241642952, -0.0021487793419510126, -0.024675466120243073, 0.040664877742528915, 0.011009694077074528, -0.01811966486275196, -0.00041104608681052923, 0.0518539696931839, 0.004090024624019861, -0.01909727416932583, -0.007479455787688494, -0.03608313202857971, -0.06464176625013351, 0.051307015120983124, -0.006977045442909002, -0.022658998146653175, 0.0072208913043141365, -0.048434533178806305, 0.03116900846362114, 0.006318464409559965, 0.03717195242643356, 0.01475582830607891, 0.0837557315826416, -0.014588603749871254, 0.014343139715492725, 0.009011989459395409, 0.028380943462252617, 0.1030334010720253, 0.0901506170630455, 0.021971875801682472, -0.0716659277677536, 0.0005878430092707276, -0.013708766549825668, -0.006674663163721561, -0.04767293110489845, 0.004139921627938747, 0.016110120341181755, -0.007855044677853584, 0.04922325909137726, 0.04269043728709221, 0.00039221899351105094, -0.0037391262594610453, 0.0379432737827301, -0.0008197209681384265, -0.029015719890594482, 0.01874592900276184, 0.009215678088366985, 0.012852723710238934, -0.05006079748272896, -0.0193912535905838, 0.01995518058538437, -0.012333996593952179, -0.0176955945789814, -0.040831148624420166, -0.028555499389767647, 0.009598644450306892, -0.03640351817011833, -0.028744082897901535, 0.009688437916338444, 0.01605985499918461, 0.02161766029894352, -0.012815825641155243, 0.013781093060970306, 0.013927037827670574, 0.02566014602780342, 0.005229410715401173, 0.042433202266693115, 0.007878998294472694, -0.0016254419460892677, 0.007942793890833855, 0.007727791089564562, -0.037874240428209305, -0.03172287344932556, -0.056789811700582504, 0.031013518571853638, 0.0032546971924602985, 0.006860876921564341, 0.010435493662953377, -0.018785417079925537, -0.008132127113640308, -0.027575640007853508, -0.004313239362090826, 0.012555313296616077, 0.019791949540376663, -0.02491058222949505, -0.0370212160050869, -0.023527787998318672, -0.0013457423774525523, -0.00880871806293726, 0.0043347557075321674, 0.0367908701300621, -0.04944367706775665, 0.013446519151329994, -0.00326922326348722, 0.03499852493405342, -0.021257011219859123, -0.04147801920771599, 0.012044047005474567, -0.05134941264986992, -0.03075011633336544, -0.010943189263343811, 0.017558397725224495, 0.006573374383151531, 0.013431964442133904, -0.004168346989899874, -0.0011376565089449286, 0.0007819883758202195, -0.03173749893903732, 0.0035719445440918207, -0.03187216445803642, 0.018166063353419304, -0.030630923807621002, 0.008889982476830482, 0.006746301427483559, 0.014758175238966942, -0.02470359392464161, 0.005736452527344227, -0.013686724938452244, 0.0030495214741677046, 0.03220660239458084, -0.07061189413070679, -0.004719033371657133, 0.031324904412031174, -0.03424728289246559, 0.013856065459549427, -0.006773208733648062, 0.06720059365034103, -0.00171951437368989, 0.031324177980422974, -0.004683240316808224, 0.005104825831949711, -0.013322288170456886, -0.006814058404415846, -0.01103917881846428, -0.037191618233919144, 0.002200016751885414, 0.03057083487510681, -0.019109124317765236, -0.01767362467944622, 0.004497872199863195, -0.04123861342668533, -0.022427024319767952, 0.022459624335169792, 0.013211410492658615, -0.025095703080296516, -0.006965122651308775, 0.029068900272250175, -0.015390983782708645, -0.06355218589305878, -0.004737092647701502, -0.030618341639637947, 0.007206362672150135, 0.010786691680550575, 0.015129256062209606, -0.017931591719388962, -0.021834012120962143, -0.02255295403301716, 0.010850776918232441, 0.0362614206969738, 0.05100493133068085, 0.039820943027734756, -0.01805894449353218, 0.01889488659799099, -0.028706761077046394, 0.06446201354265213, -0.022893192246556282, -0.022966165095567703, 0.07629230618476868, -0.0598357617855072, -0.04638346657156944, 0.023920098319649696, 0.007020903285592794, 0.0063826823607087135, 0.02676623873412609, 0.0057540107518434525, 0.010903911665081978, 0.041596632450819016, -0.0003327528538648039, -0.018092477694153786, -0.014526989310979843, -0.027085745707154274, -0.019966231659054756, 0.008717014454305172, 0.012213300913572311, 0.00653566000983119, 0.005932584870606661, 0.009847396053373814, 0.05660593509674072, -0.01862846314907074, 0.010003107599914074, 0.030297737568616867, 0.02009746991097927, 0.03444517403841019, 0.018291184678673744, -0.004568335134536028, 0.03949671611189842, 0.08063748478889465, -0.004516964312642813, 0.014426841400563717, 0.0013757696142420173, 0.009738602675497532, -0.08394674956798553, -0.010178767144680023, -0.014532634057104588, 0.02306833304464817, 0.03951181098818779, -0.05374852940440178, -0.013681675307452679, 0.07945109903812408, -0.02317025139927864, 0.0019139882642775774, -0.02991955541074276, 0.02040308341383934, 0.003696506842970848, -0.025403525680303574, -0.03465680032968521, 0.018194591626524925, 0.0480855293571949, 0.05094944313168526, 0.055001817643642426, 0.021930476650595665, -0.011525729671120644, -0.01675466075539589, -0.0029905198607593775, 0.02619575522840023, 0.028241589665412903, -0.0902508944272995, 0.005060754716396332, 0.004615291487425566, 0.008195256814360619, 0.013888349756598473, -0.05174482986330986, 0.019117087125778198, 0.013934964314103127, 0.005933998618274927, 0.02517664059996605, 0.05030176416039467, 0.03450428694486618, -0.033063631504774094, -0.04308344051241875, -0.016259297728538513, 0.041024453938007355, 0.01776774413883686, -0.01982796937227249, 0.030804168432950974, 0.024399403482675552, -0.00851897057145834, -0.038163647055625916, 0.021299781277775764, -0.02833271026611328, -0.01100411731749773, -0.006209931802004576, -0.028680190443992615, -0.06265689432621002, -0.02934161387383938, 0.028954215347766876, -0.04438398405909538, -0.0002079200785374269, 0.026604648679494858, 0.01369562279433012, -0.021344590932130814, -0.0028322215657681227, -0.035403382033109665, -0.04873845353722572, 0.029137078672647476, -0.0016956699546426535, -0.011145040392875671, -0.02841484360396862, -0.004486227873712778, -0.027250532060861588, -0.014699236489832401, -0.014271574094891548, -0.04740741848945618, -0.05500856414437294, 0.0633954182267189, 0.02132636308670044, -0.013309914618730545, 0.00454020407050848, -0.030208397656679153, -0.0007413388229906559, -0.11310817301273346, 0.05336170271039009, -0.001333285472355783, -0.0466446578502655, -0.042357657104730606, 0.025066103786230087, 0.007842770777642727, 0.024043535813689232, 0.031938277184963226, 0.027512943372130394, 0.0017175321700051427, 0.04392603412270546, 0.021482739597558975, 0.001153626712039113, -0.0602019727230072, 0.03685230016708374, -0.03171802684664726, 0.0053877453319728374, -0.024559464305639267, 0.017685342580080032, -0.017454233020544052, 0.04337696358561516, 0.025648990646004677, -0.007942837662994862, 0.016666293144226074, 0.026350243017077446, -0.01842634193599224, 0.04678991436958313, 0.022382987663149834, -0.060153085738420486, 0.03766244277358055, 0.02569001540541649, -0.01680777408182621, 0.010689523071050644, 0.021595224738121033, -0.05857791751623154, -0.0022735765669494867, -0.01015626173466444, -0.023919198662042618, 0.002051394432783127, 0.005827634129673243, -0.039175085723400116, -0.08344714343547821, 0.013358519412577152, 0.01931854523718357, -0.04488670080900192, 0.009915060363709927, 0.011603600345551968, 0.013257787562906742, 0.054820023477077484, -0.009612005203962326, 0.02867410145699978, -0.0005805935943499207, -0.003483758307993412, -0.008408695459365845, -0.005591992754489183, 0.03121102601289749, -0.025796402245759964, 0.02563893422484398, 0.02616242878139019, -0.02265537902712822, 0.033725135028362274, -0.02061179280281067, 0.014714157208800316, -0.04417818412184715, -0.055773742496967316, 0.027759166434407234, -0.0021412840578705072, 0.009184915572404861, -0.021052267402410507, -0.022871127352118492, 0.06899497658014297, -0.056583963334560394, 0.02188795991241932, -0.03377449885010719, -0.00013816273713018745, -0.02877218835055828, 0.00950594525784254, 0.030672160908579826, -0.02597150020301342, 0.03707408532500267, 0.026690911501646042, 0.00578038627281785, 0.00044709298526868224, 0.04160182550549507, -0.021624518558382988, 0.02782321721315384, 0.007969836704432964, -0.033156801015138626, -0.04641656577587128, -0.03988705575466156, -0.03665266931056976, -0.0347343310713768, 0.03511936590075493, 0.0183811504393816, 0.023737167939543724, 0.007913246750831604, -0.048947788774967194, 0.01189605426043272, 0.05073174834251404, -0.05867042765021324, 0.004249158315360546, -0.006076415069401264, 0.004782546311616898, -0.005273123271763325, -0.033698637038469315 ]
<p>I'm new in the page and pretty new in statistics and R. I'm working on a project for college with the objective of finding the correlation between rain and water flow level in rivers. Once the correlation is proved I want to forecast/predict it.</p> <p><strong>The data</strong> I have a set of data of several years(taken every 5 minutes) for a particular rivers containing: </p> <ul> <li>Rainfall in millimetres</li> <li>River flow in cubic meters per second</li> </ul> <p>This river doesn't have snow, so the model is just based on rain and time. There are occasionally freezing temperatures, but I'm thinking on removing those periods out of the data as outliers as that situation is out of scope for my project.</p> <p><strong>Examples</strong> Here you have a couple of plots of sample data the from a rain and the rise of water a few hours later.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/ssmtM.jpg" alt="Bigger example a few days"></p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/XSkvv.jpg" alt="Shorter example just one rainfall period"></p> <p>The red line is the river flow. The orange is the rain. You can see it always rains before water raises in river. There is some rain starting again at the end of the time series, but it will affect the river flow later.</p> <p>The correlation is there. Here is what I've done in R to prove the correlation using ccf in R: </p> <ul> <li>the cross-correlation</li> <li>the leading variable</li> <li>the lag</li> </ul> <p>This is my R line used for the second example (one rainfall period):</p> <pre><code>ccf(arnoiaex1$Caudal, arnoiaex1$Precip, lag.max=1000, plot=TRUE, main="Flow &amp; Rain") </code></pre> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IT62e.jpg" alt="ccf result for small example 2"></p> <p>My interpretation is: </p> <ul> <li>that the rain leads (happens first),</li> <li>there is a significant correlation that peaks at a lag of $\approx 450$ (I can check the exact number, I know that part). </li> <li>I don't know how to find out the time that correlation affects the river flow, I think the name is “retention”. What I see is the graph follows the same shape of the first graph, when the river losing the water after the rain. I don't if based on that I can say the retention lasts from $\approx 450$ when it peaks to $\approx 800$ (I can check this in the object created in the dataframe returned by <code>ccf</code> and see when the water level comes back to the value of “before rain”. Is that right? Is there a better way to find the retention?</li> </ul> <p>Am I right?</p> <p><strong>About the time series</strong>. This time series doesn't have periodicity or seasonality. Rain can come any time and cause an effect. It does reduce in summer, but it still happens, it's an area with a lot of rain all year around.</p> <p><strong>Model and forecast.</strong> I don't know how to create a model to be able to do a forecast that tells me how much is a river going to increase the volume after a period of rain. I've been trying some <code>arima</code>, <code>auto arima</code> but haven't been very successful. Should I use <code>Arima</code>, <code>vars</code> or other different multivariate model? Any link to a example would be of great help.</p> <p>Please, let me know if you know the best way to create this prediction, what model should I use. There are a few other things I'm considering doing but taken them out of this explanation for simplicity. I can share some data if required.</p>
73,590
[ -0.013653676956892014, -0.01760934665799141, 0.005784487817436457, 0.04217222332954407, 0.03568350151181221, -0.0339188277721405, 0.020525598898530006, -0.021739279851317406, 0.03105335496366024, -0.012029008939862251, 0.047249410301446915, 0.05701015144586563, 0.012484485283493996, 0.04836960509419441, 0.03014177829027176, 0.04088665544986725, 0.0019207674777135253, 0.018063493072986603, 0.02134883962571621, 0.012550612911581993, -0.005595160182565451, 0.01127365417778492, 0.01745295710861683, -0.007553236559033394, -0.0038972680922597647, 0.05549394339323044, 0.019937898963689804, -0.009651499800384045, 0.019476329907774925, 0.051920656114816666, -0.06107376143336296, -0.045094627887010574, 0.03630198910832405, 0.04161478951573372, 0.03684297949075699, 0.027309579774737358, -0.003246934385970235, -0.03526407852768898, 0.02326204441487789, 0.02722299098968506, -0.02216043323278427, -0.017754504457116127, 0.01925596036016941, 0.032313622534275055, -0.03460676595568657, 0.02288343757390976, 0.03559106960892677, -0.013570374809205532, 0.0592217743396759, -0.014129780232906342, 0.05608585104346275, -0.019954362884163857, 0.024843884631991386, 0.016265081241726875, -0.00017994090740103275, 0.010576578788459301, 0.0676460862159729, 0.028280559927225113, 0.015870515257120132, -0.025690747424960136, -0.012035337276756763, -0.002620258368551731, -0.005015736911445856, 0.01812591403722763, -0.001656452426686883, 0.002834319369867444, -0.0243960190564394, -0.0054335156455636024, 0.019334305077791214, -0.020059267058968544, 0.025540560483932495, -0.02633601240813732, 0.03639185428619385, -0.010841469280421734, 0.006544237025082111, -0.011871587485074997, -0.013363166712224483, 0.0037378098350018263, 0.02847190573811531, 0.037498362362384796, 0.014192560687661171, 0.05373836308717728, 0.030258560553193092, 0.035050466656684875, 0.038987137377262115, 0.0036551551893353462, 0.0630895122885704, -0.007125995587557554, 0.0282016359269619, 0.0245900209993124, -0.05173428729176521, 0.012232382781803608, 0.03690025210380554, 0.02205393835902214, -0.014055348932743073, 0.004748532548546791, -0.022130943834781647, -0.005568141583353281, -0.0028602005913853645, 0.017236685380339622, -0.01393161155283451, -0.020073477178812027, 0.0014270873507484794, 0.059867024421691895, 0.0056009660474956036, -0.017335698008537292, -0.014588828198611736, -0.01948983408510685, -0.044212594628334045, -0.02285752072930336, -0.03501511365175247, -0.04999404773116112, 0.016169818118214607, -0.00006265139381866902, 0.01006303820759058, -0.0189354345202446, 0.011503092013299465, 0.02401152439415455, 0.03323908895254135, 0.056945376098155975, 0.03320795297622681, -0.0017588612390682101, -0.027221456170082092, -0.02314271219074726, -0.04393935203552246, -0.02376808226108551, -0.019895432516932487, -0.010199264623224735, -0.020200561732053757, 0.056959979236125946, -0.03923388198018074, -0.020125309005379677, 0.01073980052024126, -0.021871762350201607, 0.040865201503038406, 0.00625606207177043, -0.10397578030824661, -0.06777922809123993, 0.05174160748720169, 0.011656946502625942, 0.022246399894356728, -0.02570270374417305, 0.010538012720644474, -0.017643390223383904, 0.05017353221774101, 0.007320875767618418, 0.057803552597761154, 0.007595064118504524, -0.003643048694357276, 0.003454341785982251, -0.04527905210852623, 0.0045905280858278275, 0.004624993074685335, -0.00490643922239542, -0.026882026344537735, -0.07793329656124115, 0.014237798750400543, 0.002382194623351097, 0.02420390024781227, -0.013498203828930855, 0.008731293492019176, 0.00019118707859888673, 0.020227978006005287, -0.024219458922743797, -0.013084807433187962, -0.02650468423962593, 0.05648833140730858, -0.002568406518548727, 0.01834341511130333, 0.015254847705364227, -0.00442941440269351, -0.011906000785529613, -0.0013210858451202512, 0.02505636215209961, 0.03521344065666199, 0.004553385078907013, 0.024365369230508804, -0.014634354040026665, -0.023768216371536255, 0.02016277238726616, -0.02680261805653572, -0.01830802857875824, -0.017150450497865677, -0.03213883563876152, 0.025092510506510735, 0.05208997428417206, 0.005882804747670889, -0.03082079440355301, 0.03017297200858593, -0.0544142909348011, -0.003424574388191104, -0.027345234528183937, -0.026962483301758766, -0.02981938235461712, -0.007463542278856039, 0.028080329298973083, -0.004870036616921425, 0.05219525098800659, 0.013915196061134338, 0.0015223402297124267, -0.0628000944852829, 0.0038419219199568033, 0.03967779502272606, -0.014611081220209599, -0.001240840065293014, 0.02139437012374401, 0.035786714404821396, 0.0055907671339809895, -0.01717136800289154, -0.026961471885442734, -0.011659642681479454, 0.0016508752014487982, -0.037812527269124985, 0.016069792211055756, -0.039268843829631805, -0.027286889031529427, 0.04406231269240379, 0.017777569591999054, 0.010557460598647594, 0.015990126878023148, -0.03941059485077858, 0.06592687964439392, 0.05185621604323387, -0.007705688010901213, -0.005757541861385107, 0.005094362888485193, 0.029416505247354507, 0.00041375996079295874, -0.03315427899360657, -0.02042226493358612, -0.04653506353497505, -0.039240073412656784, 0.030120139941573143, 0.020885692909359932, 0.0031396117992699146, -0.005917562171816826, 0.0844009518623352, -0.005853962618857622, 0.017112409695982933, 0.04596106335520744, 0.017654351890087128, -0.004951589275151491, -0.006964689586311579, 0.009112909436225891, 0.012527172453701496, -0.0110364044085145, 0.023016879335045815, -0.019585171714425087, 0.05984823778271675, -0.04349704086780548, -0.025283921509981155, 0.03816346451640129, 0.023637138307094574, 0.017903244122862816, -0.007647472433745861, 0.004071283619850874, 0.035327278077602386, -0.03460298106074333, -0.04141600802540779, 0.0237649567425251, 0.026913117617368698, -0.0007543519022874534, -0.0031332524958997965, -0.009871247224509716, -0.005876721814274788, 0.044136982411146164, -0.013437911868095398, -0.004564332775771618, 0.01659148372709751, -0.06730779260396957, 0.01994263380765915, -0.03982781246304512, -0.04797063767910004, -0.054023757576942444, 0.017845304682850838, 0.05589427798986435, 0.032234031707048416, 0.00045290798880159855, -0.020584482699632645, -0.026313122361898422, -0.006440011318773031, -0.004618247505277395, 0.005247270688414574, -0.006947425659745932, -0.020614327862858772, -0.013432472944259644, -0.03358355537056923, -0.006372288800776005, 0.044672891497612, -0.006078299134969711, -0.014639537781476974, 0.037339240312576294, 0.0014319869223982096, -0.03215812146663666, -0.04530833661556244, -0.05492797866463661, -0.0006689312285743654, -0.043783288449048996, -0.05273900181055069, 0.05983074754476547, -0.030653271824121475, -0.03578818216919899, -0.031698551028966904, -0.06081458553671837, 0.014828969724476337, -0.02486586943268776, 0.013675731606781483, -0.010456053540110588, 0.010960802435874939, 0.004614995326846838, -0.0026384671218693256, -0.019713036715984344, -0.009151805192232132, -0.05135786160826683, -0.041718944907188416, 0.022585725411772728, 0.02515825815498829, 0.055801086127758026, -0.021065015345811844, -0.012499687261879444, 0.04625570401549339, 0.03398123010993004, -0.02390742488205433, -0.06685585528612137, -0.026799526065587997, -0.009293969720602036, -0.03923100605607033, 0.01568732224404812, 0.04006345570087433, -0.00016091011639218777, -0.003313090419396758, -0.009626287966966629, 0.05527142062783241, 0.024087343364953995, 0.012237465009093285, 0.03776734694838524, 0.008707690984010696, -0.029724640771746635, 0.005377758760005236, 0.04898682236671448, 0.01461500208824873, -0.03990577161312103, -0.0024685687385499477, -0.032302603125572205, 0.04289081320166588, 0.013070553541183472, -0.040155936032533646, 0.008470187894999981, 0.02121700718998909, 0.00528987031430006, -0.06931018084287643, 0.03530566766858101, 0.006765442900359631, -0.008435294963419437, -0.010814348235726357, -0.019857369363307953, 0.07147444039583206, 0.006655985489487648, 0.0007711333455517888, 0.04493704438209534, 0.03355255350470543, -0.03897380828857422, -0.007715079002082348, -0.05641084536910057, -0.001092994469217956, 0.046170543879270554, -0.060562022030353546, -0.0006034850375726819, 0.047083184123039246, 0.014394005760550499, -0.015131771564483643, 0.0029588721226900816, -0.017478415742516518, 0.009683554992079735, -0.05958297476172447, -0.02636597491800785, -0.015943437814712524, 0.04946096986532211, 0.033324647694826126, 0.08437047153711319, -0.008680649101734161, -0.012085307389497757, 0.031012125313282013, -0.02432127855718136, -0.05374656990170479, 0.021509015932679176, 0.029616020619869232, 0.004870827309787273, -0.014163645915687084, -0.015275239944458008, 0.009145574644207954, -0.04621819034218788, 0.02359282411634922, 0.02521253190934658, -0.005296448711305857, -0.013919919729232788, 0.01745450124144554, -0.02034795843064785, -0.012822354212403297, -0.050757769495248795, -0.03529048711061478, 0.07104335725307465, -0.041504837572574615, 0.051049042493104935, 0.021559035405516624, 0.030630525201559067, -0.03294576704502106, -0.018444981426000595, -0.005061241798102856, 0.061085883527994156, 0.03686962649226189, 0.023646699264645576, 0.028461964800953865, -0.03872448205947876, 0.014786952175199986, 0.03648018836975098, 0.012382454238831997, 0.03994227200746536, 0.020642491057515144, -0.009471029974520206, -0.013432231731712818, 0.022850174456834793, 0.00883395690470934, 0.0023775380104780197, 0.0208441074937582, -0.027096780017018318, 0.0241735577583313, 0.005922879558056593, -0.04213579371571541, 0.008150034584105015, 0.02893177606165409, 0.03023560531437397, 0.03257589042186737, -0.024338187649846077, -0.013134750537574291, -0.013173208571970463, 0.008265062235295773, 0.028407396748661995, 0.03917613625526428, 0.008453610353171825, 0.0038416124880313873, 0.043025314807891846, -0.017740359529852867, -0.01021531317383051, -0.014416019432246685, 0.011036032810807228, 0.06631959974765778, -0.01811431162059307, -0.027424806728959084, 0.006390457972884178, 0.04042641818523407, -0.00950795691460371, -0.013997524045407772, -0.003008664818480611, -0.09776066243648529, -0.032117102295160294, 0.07337173074483871, 0.027237989008426666, -0.02459542453289032, -0.0007798125152476132, -0.07632901519536972, -0.04744558408856392, -0.00608723284676671, -0.03724385052919388, 0.04396891966462135, 0.011858665384352207, 0.015183971263468266, -0.012605362571775913, -0.08126551657915115, -0.04128732532262802, 0.02636568620800972, -0.02005806937813759, 0.018814707174897194, -0.02128339372575283, -0.06629724055528641, -0.03484055772423744, 0.010693191550672054, 0.036316897720098495, 0.025052886456251144, -0.04336638003587723, -0.012257266789674759, 0.005770697724074125, 0.010978839360177517, 0.003322662552818656, -0.06836681813001633, 0.007415791507810354, -0.010013284161686897, -0.0011135665699839592, 0.05163565278053284, 0.012476426549255848, 0.005751927848905325, -0.012051486410200596, 0.04565826430916786, -0.021219654008746147, 0.01601991057395935, -0.06364817172288895, 0.051651086658239365, 0.018449392169713974, -0.021798420697450638, 0.04072533920407295, 0.03569912537932396, 0.0182404313236475, -0.008866814896464348, -0.03405716270208359, 0.02548445202410221, 0.019129911437630653, -0.025954727083444595, -0.05355781689286232, -0.03222176432609558, -0.024134663864970207, 0.0014654900878667831, -0.019520215690135956, 0.00601132120937109, -0.017957476899027824, 0.028610417619347572, 0.02255028486251831, 0.004510955419391394, -0.03090003877878189, -0.02001086436212063, 0.0038056038320064545, -0.018553433939814568, -0.01332138106226921, -0.013604307547211647, 0.01085855532437563, -0.035614289343357086, -0.027733227238059044, 0.039817459881305695, -0.073151133954525, -0.015928905457258224, -0.029340097680687904, -0.00023523831623606384, 0.004661645274609327, -0.027961883693933487, 0.028224432840943336, 0.014896966516971588, 0.06997352838516235, 0.0014422689564526081, -0.00511975260451436, -0.002625669352710247, 0.07761932909488678, 0.01104914490133524, -0.004839019384235144, -0.016620229929685593, 0.03580276668071747, 0.003482869593426585, 0.005122691858559847, -0.04765738546848297, -0.038515232503414154, 0.03811201453208923, 0.02358255907893181, -0.04786160960793495, -0.025418423116207123, -0.018731126561760902, -0.006949258036911488, 0.0057326629757881165, -0.019696205854415894, 0.003011798020452261, -0.03548798710107803, 0.021547988057136536, -0.029310552403330803, -0.005217690486460924, 0.08345020562410355, -0.020420324057340622, 0.01827845722436905, 0.005082662217319012, -0.019807936623692513, -0.028722966089844704, -0.00158654002007097, -0.001342127681709826, -0.020168963819742203, 0.022481516003608704, -0.004422834143042564, 0.015001542866230011, 0.01547591295093298, -0.002244785660877824, -0.0219248216599226, 0.0027324126567691565, 0.02676849253475666, -0.009046047925949097, -0.02395031228661537, -0.024324767291545868, 0.01055776048451662, 0.0023131470661610365, -0.03335561603307724, 0.008894391357898712, -0.018525538966059685, -0.046240199357271194, -0.004862606525421143, -0.04430258274078369, -0.0021640905179083347, 0.012894817627966404, 0.0653676837682724, -0.00025401765014976263, -0.015671484172344208, -0.030258748680353165, 0.0032115173526108265, 0.013615716248750687, 0.005853724665939808, -0.010429362766444683, 0.0005066202720627189, 0.014447403140366077, -0.03709503263235092, -0.014428043738007545, -0.046693552285432816, -0.013650370761752129, 0.05604696273803711, 0.0005084172007627785, 0.03687713295221329, 0.04640106111764908, -0.02202392742037773, 0.010983767919242382, -0.04704660177230835, -0.03397076576948166, -0.019777972251176834, 0.00252979202196002, 0.04568218067288399, 0.0069259279407560825, -0.01286312099546194, -0.013588950037956238, -0.004510451108217239, 0.015255502425134182, 0.04906832054257393, 0.009715007618069649, -0.007245329674333334, 0.0002917087113019079, -0.03372563049197197, -0.019248999655246735, 0.025511646643280983, -0.0318278893828392, 0.024142000824213028, -0.019875971600413322, -0.017882337793707848, 0.023563669994473457, 0.02250022627413273, -0.013551182113587856, -0.08449660241603851, -0.020705334842205048, -0.07501272857189178, 0.002535843523219228, 0.02881530486047268, -0.017869092524051666, 0.04055522754788399, 0.048691555857658386, 0.03850714489817619, -0.004505975171923637, 0.011090517975389957, -0.075812429189682, -0.05348699167370796, 0.034696757793426514, -0.04107194021344185, -0.015521250665187836, 0.06523292511701584, -0.006871551740914583, -0.03335433825850487, 0.009378790855407715, -0.02690732665359974, 0.003582076635211706, 0.011223975569009781, 0.046970341354608536, 0.0018778643570840359, 0.06255774945020676, -0.01882307417690754, 0.025448808446526527, -0.011336729861795902, 0.013711878098547459, 0.1422317922115326, 0.056022536009550095, 0.03964078426361084, -0.02611841820180416, 0.021665750071406364, 0.039565782994031906, 0.031117379665374756, -0.05450906977057457, 0.009265703149139881, 0.013744530268013477, -0.003459715750068426, 0.0524105466902256, 0.02882285974919796, 0.035061419010162354, -0.000732504646293819, 0.08887724578380585, 0.01169254258275032, 0.010324763134121895, -0.036772873252630234, 0.020131366327404976, 0.0027215208392590284, 0.0028939691837877035, -0.04035292938351631, 0.031801141798496246, -0.0316237211227417, -0.021380964666604996, -0.04025343805551529, -0.007160053122788668, 0.043592505156993866, -0.008363601751625538, -0.04355612397193909, 0.02246640995144844, 0.021010156720876694, -0.0028197031933814287, 0.014133046381175518, -0.007697024382650852, 0.06301665306091309, -0.05143631622195244, 0.04189564660191536, -0.012292158789932728, 0.005910772364586592, -0.005264439154416323, -0.008980406448245049, -0.009847920387983322, -0.024052029475569725, -0.022609420120716095, -0.06283405423164368, 0.040045179426670074, -0.0049086096696555614, -0.004765328485518694, -0.014755494892597198, 0.04251840338110924, 0.019373256713151932, -0.023138105869293213, -0.00239779194816947, 0.025485996156930923, 0.002941393293440342, -0.03351942077279091, -0.0009094254346564412, -0.07121019810438156, -0.018962593749165535, 0.013410649262368679, 0.024206766858696938, 0.05731399357318878, -0.05470585823059082, -0.028657883405685425, -0.043636031448841095, 0.06485772132873535, 0.01607472449541092, -0.007924552075564861, 0.01585737057030201, 0.01602504774928093, -0.022290397435426712, 0.0013599033700302243, 0.01811445690691471, 0.004965184256434441, 0.013117030262947083, -0.013263586908578873, -0.020938124507665634, -0.0036704204976558685, -0.046498049050569534, 0.013966875150799751, -0.00757251400500536, -0.021718094125390053, -0.006138524040579796, 0.010985808447003365, 0.008620582520961761, 0.018705304712057114, 0.03464344143867493, -0.02286716364324093, -0.02343958057463169, 0.058132145553827286, 0.047801144421100616, -0.05385865271091461, -0.029981115832924843, -0.04752633720636368, -0.018922217190265656, -0.00005281460835249163, -0.01727133058011532, 0.04493512958288193, 0.05230351537466049, -0.007970892824232578, -0.01523813046514988, 0.031440310180187225, -0.01761937141418457, 0.00953770149499178, 0.031120343133807182, -0.031647246330976486, 0.022309130057692528, -0.019212013110518456, 0.00714970612898469, -0.007188263349235058, 0.00826181098818779, -0.007773911114782095, -0.025525478646159172, 0.018228840082883835, -0.04413795843720436, -0.06091905012726784, 0.010573936626315117, -0.020694363862276077, 0.03869936987757683, -0.04648313298821449, 0.005126638803631067, -0.06434065848588943, -0.024881957098841667, -0.020651496946811676, -0.03828103840351105, -0.03238585591316223, 0.04306420311331749, -0.020511962473392487, 0.015653949230909348, 0.010213389992713928, 0.0002447933657094836, 0.030453994870185852, -0.021164629608392715, 0.040853794664144516, 0.027864981442689896, 0.06259577721357346, 0.010436015203595161, -0.02824506349861622, 0.02797873504459858, 0.0018822461133822799, -0.026052474975585938, -0.001901059178635478, -0.008426656015217304, 0.05085551366209984, -0.008696388453245163, -0.0027458551339805126, -0.00848986953496933, 0.015216927044093609, 0.006748753134161234, 0.020990833640098572, -0.022349638864398003, 0.011385601945221424, 0.05488075315952301, 0.015428084880113602, -0.0008902928093448281, 0.019657647237181664, 0.01914951391518116, 0.02044447883963585, 0.03891566023230553, 0.03993729129433632, -0.00220649060793221, -0.0055220159702003, -0.046025317162275314, -0.0032317701261490583, -0.018648678436875343, -0.01629623956978321, 0.030139533802866936, 0.06250625103712082, -0.02023790031671524, -0.008299537934362888, -0.006819918751716614, 0.03531758114695549, -0.09992145001888275, -0.0028271041810512543, 0.014803975820541382, 0.010169067420065403, 0.060511618852615356, -0.005279314238578081, 0.01437132153660059, 0.07243465632200241, -0.002872858429327607, 0.009647352620959282, -0.016406947746872902, 0.010045036673545837, -0.01607699878513813, 0.0006802335847169161, -0.032352957874536514, -0.005205890163779259, 0.05211247131228447, 0.017184991389513016, 0.03848126530647278, 0.07021542638540268, 0.037841156125068665, -0.019881881773471832, -0.04873543977737427, -0.005549498833715916, 0.017589783295989037, -0.023803586140275, 0.02735854871571064, -0.024149101227521896, 0.04106641560792923, -0.00448973523452878, -0.04368998482823372, 0.02328018844127655, -0.00898200087249279, 0.02547418139874935, -0.004855731036514044, 0.03286289423704147, 0.010138682089745998, -0.020822377875447273, 0.005458060652017593, -0.01371782273054123, 0.02497406117618084, -0.0017667857464402914, 0.005661034490913153, 0.01919478550553322, -0.0016296812100335956, -0.034100499004125595, -0.04748919606208801, 0.036622870713472366, -0.038354020565748215, 0.012129328213632107, 0.034399304538965225, -0.02035621739923954, -0.027637533843517303, -0.006095575168728828, -0.004780238494277, -0.022291991859674454, 0.006752155255526304, 0.07965975999832153, 0.034051891416311264, -0.03172949329018593, 0.01012117974460125, -0.002579855266958475, -0.02611425705254078, -0.00840064324438572, -0.014896836131811142, -0.010188733227550983, -0.046745020896196365, 0.003878745948895812, -0.04631226882338524, 0.00991227850317955, -0.03637037053704262, -0.003032492706552148, -0.05111285671591759, 0.0372735895216465, -0.01737537980079651, 0.005270726978778839, 0.009251371026039124, -0.018573680892586708, 0.00488129910081625, -0.0766129344701767, 0.07249285280704498, 0.0007733291713520885, 0.006512473803013563, -0.06192807853221893, -0.02912352979183197, -0.04686815291643143, -0.01562827080488205, 0.033615246415138245, -0.0047853924334049225, 0.013634815812110901, -0.004446444567292929, 0.058868564665317535, 0.003478879574686289, -0.04130979999899864, 0.035430580377578735, -0.022065961733460426, 0.007419433910399675, 0.03646291047334671, 0.008065082132816315, 0.027910547330975533, -0.0025838990695774555, 0.016220860183238983, -0.020993852987885475, 0.02143600769340992, 0.020396288484334946, -0.03256336227059364, 0.004751543514430523, 0.0048857941292226315, -0.04176490753889084, 0.05291883274912834, -0.0002600761945359409, -0.01016834657639265, 0.02533336915075779, -0.024319158867001534, -0.05157579854130745, 0.008833091706037521, -0.03881328925490379, 0.00349057512357831, -0.008362485095858574, -0.005839816760271788, 0.00042430125176906586, -0.08831235766410828, 0.0062298765406012535, 0.015728292986750603, 0.0019078528275713325, 0.007174938917160034, 0.06475261598825455, -0.00022461028129328042, 0.041780564934015274, -0.01384166069328785, -0.00637532165274024, -0.0327749140560627, -0.008483244106173515, -0.025089258328080177, -0.01526395883411169, 0.02196909859776497, -0.010840477421879768, 0.04827714338898659, 0.03664674609899521, 0.021993257105350494, 0.0036902092397212982, -0.02841680683195591, 0.04632261395454407, -0.024012744426727295, -0.008063951507210732, 0.019564732909202576, -0.02155519835650921, 0.04600801691412926, 0.002032739343121648, 0.015664415434002876, 0.022206110879778862, -0.05929744988679886, -0.0005380203947424889, -0.028484774753451347, -0.049545031040906906, -0.03639446571469307, 0.04873308539390564, 0.001320898300036788, -0.006606618408113718, 0.00213595200330019, 0.02569892629981041, 0.008215588517487049, 0.008234632201492786, -0.023114535957574844, -0.00781908631324768, 0.06220671907067299, -0.007184823974967003, 0.012879918329417706, -0.0004085985419806093, -0.010304855182766914, -0.009295404888689518, -0.04068082571029663, 0.03261452540755272, 0.022112296894192696, -0.0069117737002670765, -0.04090958088636398, -0.042255666106939316, 0.024202900007367134, 0.04967758432030678, -0.0832524523139, -0.020299458876252174, -0.038023024797439575, 0.04664561152458191, 0.010997536592185497, -0.03148871287703514 ]
<p>I have 17 patients who underwent cervical plating, I have calculated </p> <ol> <li>preoperative cervical measurements like angles at certain level to be operated, total cervical angles </li> <li>same parameters calculated after operation </li> <li>same parameters calculated after 2 years of operation</li> </ol> <p>Now, which test should I use, and in case it is a paired t-test whether to use equal variance or unequal variance? What happens to degrees of freedom in each case?</p>
73,591
[ -0.02539004385471344, -0.030775677412748337, -0.024252386763691902, -0.0019380395533517003, 0.05723802372813225, 0.023095209151506424, 0.0018365834839642048, 0.01305252406746149, 0.014097727835178375, -0.006312237586826086, 0.043662797659635544, 0.00739986402913928, 0.021941479295492172, 0.03739321976900101, -0.017069879919290543, 0.01141993049532175, -0.02421766147017479, -0.004039589315652847, 0.00289816758595407, -0.018946697935461998, -0.011884382925927639, 0.0004564648261293769, -0.038900285959243774, 0.004673677496612072, -0.003436311846598983, 0.04896853119134903, 0.01913790963590145, -0.05541869252920151, 0.024124594405293465, 0.04130677878856659, -0.04101903364062309, -0.036034468561410904, -0.011009391397237778, -0.019237693399190903, 0.0042076087556779385, -0.036432936787605286, -0.014825590886175632, 0.0014575901441276073, -0.018940433859825134, 0.05589527636766434, -0.032944608479738235, 0.015002242289483547, -0.029282812029123306, 0.05365750938653946, 0.017624344676733017, 0.0250942874699831, -0.03659443557262421, -0.037002090364694595, -0.0030573986005038023, -0.0664614737033844, 0.03130051866173744, -0.011711027473211288, 0.004600305110216141, -0.00898842141032219, -0.006352823693305254, -0.004502171650528908, 0.015167596749961376, 0.028620485216379166, 0.005131411366164684, -0.05997300520539284, -0.030122265219688416, -0.0417444072663784, 0.027638277038931847, -0.002751024207100272, -0.018161015585064888, -0.0011278468882665038, 0.00921774934977293, -0.030599825084209442, 0.008395791053771973, -0.024052634835243225, 0.02817276492714882, 0.05924046039581299, 0.04415559023618698, -0.003964218311011791, -0.01243661530315876, -0.018291529268026352, 0.006624279543757439, 0.02117694541811943, 0.03463191166520119, 0.032483238726854324, 0.026364199817180634, 0.0238538458943367, 0.048978134989738464, 0.05465978384017944, 0.022137504070997238, -0.03968231379985809, 0.04314447194337845, 0.022485947236418724, 0.003043531673029065, 0.015662766993045807, 0.02825167030096054, 0.02437884919345379, 0.05972882732748985, 0.016828222200274467, -0.018440937623381615, -0.008863403461873531, -0.012672124430537224, 0.05703720822930336, -0.01777973584830761, -0.001222766819410026, -0.005752935074269772, -0.018535222858190536, 0.016259122639894485, 0.060528598725795746, -0.009219598025083542, -0.014000020921230316, 0.006341024301946163, -0.015697794035077095, -0.004291537683457136, -0.007056708447635174, -0.0072233243845403194, 0.003920088522136211, 0.00783552322536707, -0.012931564822793007, 0.02373327687382698, 0.03197583928704262, -0.009988070465624332, 0.00014006721903569996, 0.05282501503825188, 0.05525185540318489, 0.05345520004630089, -0.021343057975172997, 0.008661527186632156, -0.04741794243454933, -0.019947921857237816, 0.008461910299956799, 0.038170456886291504, 0.006157148629426956, -0.03009594790637493, 0.06019539013504982, 0.0010684827575460076, -0.013789145275950432, 0.024720449000597, -0.0027195336297154427, -0.039351142942905426, 0.060617364943027496, -0.11296754330396652, -0.06298363208770752, 0.053414445370435715, -0.04026026278734207, -0.013441748917102814, -0.04321182519197464, 0.03469843789935112, -0.001568193780258298, 0.04353662207722664, -0.00800982117652893, 0.057126522064208984, -0.011331216432154179, 0.013090926222503185, 0.013483087532222271, -0.017367782071232796, -0.005666571203619242, -0.015787309035658836, -0.045640140771865845, -0.021394720301032066, -0.05508795380592346, -0.001195948338136077, 0.026124998927116394, 0.001369259087368846, -0.01107161957770586, 0.04002467170357704, -0.026252150535583496, -0.024899525567889214, -0.0017685298807919025, 0.001996356761083007, -0.02862350456416607, 0.05216678977012634, -0.003308029379695654, 0.012924985028803349, 0.032486096024513245, 0.00941826868802309, 0.018211107701063156, 0.007419252768158913, 0.010828817263245583, 0.007382484152913094, 0.007634321693331003, 0.010864759795367718, -0.0033612470142543316, 0.009649387560784817, 0.03529215604066849, -0.03866663947701454, -0.00197915593162179, -0.02752610668540001, -0.0041071586310863495, 0.014618154615163803, 0.061228469014167786, -0.011311679147183895, 0.001587699051015079, 0.06895002722740173, -0.019513553008437157, -0.040938470512628555, -0.05271056666970253, 0.013426080346107483, 0.003390712197870016, -0.057402174919843674, 0.04459027573466301, 0.013558987528085709, 0.018302835524082184, -0.010913247242569923, -0.0013108056737110019, -0.034246690571308136, 0.008857432752847672, 0.06908421218395233, -0.01276715099811554, 0.03216550871729851, 0.058471787720918655, 0.037131745368242264, 0.00007399348396575078, 0.03317825496196747, -0.03665236756205559, -0.023596078157424927, 0.009611045941710472, -0.022715548053383827, 0.011683134362101555, 0.012776972725987434, -0.03557545319199562, -0.02498449943959713, -0.018802857026457787, -0.012186300940811634, 0.04472610354423523, -0.05643564090132713, 0.06096784397959709, 0.06823195517063141, 0.015001918189227581, 0.03260045871138573, 0.008094444870948792, 0.0036152475513517857, 0.02078070677816868, 0.016355009749531746, 0.012903394177556038, -0.04853077977895737, -0.010605180636048317, 0.014226033352315426, 0.04187964275479317, -0.02680652029812336, 0.009415296837687492, 0.018703339621424675, 0.004006931092590094, -0.000593100325204432, 0.020340239629149437, -0.015761855989694595, -0.05806797370314598, 0.03242546319961548, 0.03855026140809059, -0.001155540463514626, -0.011192438192665577, -0.013200701214373112, 0.0036161099560558796, 0.011205530725419521, 0.007450580131262541, -0.007795569486916065, 0.06821305304765701, -0.004842197522521019, -0.016721203923225403, -0.021363377571105957, -0.0576644241809845, 0.02565310336649418, -0.0084083192050457, 0.02952595055103302, 0.03631039708852768, 0.02661474049091339, -0.029466956853866577, 0.002546862931922078, -0.0024546748027205467, -0.01848055049777031, 0.017266638576984406, -0.03186137601733208, -0.009459306485950947, 0.046197522431612015, -0.017280573025345802, 0.006875659339129925, -0.03146626055240631, -0.03336126357316971, -0.03859773650765419, -0.012739340774714947, 0.02521585300564766, 0.013454793021082878, 0.029598576948046684, -0.014947720803320408, -0.014546637423336506, 0.003250607755035162, -0.0024806554429233074, 0.01616831310093403, 0.028923049569129944, -0.06824730336666107, -0.020882727578282356, 0.017997855320572853, 0.018666623160243034, 0.025582686066627502, 0.011043902486562729, 0.02005128003656864, 0.0304599367082119, 0.014266573823988438, -0.06294140964746475, -0.04765675961971283, 0.024231428280472755, -0.03247449919581413, -0.006941887550055981, -0.05947178229689598, 0.004797051660716534, 0.0044549559243023396, 0.008436690084636211, 0.020752640441060066, -0.07156680524349213, -0.022583670914173126, 0.043708089739084244, 0.0321311429142952, 0.05186453089118004, 0.006531715393066406, 0.004535116255283356, 0.04970646649599075, -0.021665621548891068, -0.024939129129052162, -0.05977354571223259, -0.027486277744174004, 0.07411991059780121, -0.029097065329551697, 0.05103881284594536, -0.012809880077838898, -0.021286141127347946, 0.08868137747049332, 0.011104878969490528, -0.046128008514642715, -0.014979627914726734, 0.0034379265271127224, -0.06697754561901093, -0.0022675744257867336, 0.03673352301120758, 0.036893703043460846, 0.010778152383863926, 0.02794637158513069, 0.00805565994232893, 0.02435336448252201, 0.058542367070913315, 0.01810714788734913, 0.01889125071465969, 0.004472019150853157, 0.08478903025388718, -0.03243314474821091, 0.05618217960000038, 0.01602822355926037, -0.01724144071340561, -0.010697206482291222, 0.04148884862661362, 0.03735047206282616, -0.002414999296888709, -0.07205487042665482, 0.02519269287586212, 0.0034500330220907927, -0.003069712780416012, -0.026372386142611504, 0.028096148744225502, 0.036679886281490326, 0.0075664701871573925, -0.015652760863304138, 0.04021638259291649, 0.008701451122760773, -0.030420586466789246, -0.007976098917424679, 0.05007484182715416, 0.06233790144324303, 0.05177929252386093, -0.013207442127168179, -0.03193778917193413, 0.00624849833548069, 0.0515177845954895, -0.04761069267988205, -0.029679298400878906, 0.03634704649448395, 0.04837856814265251, 0.049501895904541016, 0.037576183676719666, -0.04048730060458183, 0.013636005111038685, -0.01605050638318062, 0.00681003462523222, -0.009984202682971954, 0.0583418644964695, -0.01274887751787901, 0.03013557381927967, 0.01587875746190548, 0.020836027339100838, -0.008256712928414345, -0.03359110280871391, -0.03578973188996315, 0.026918858289718628, 0.002152031986042857, 0.007164589129388332, 0.03370475023984909, -0.0029467607382684946, 0.024405935779213905, -0.03821603208780289, 0.0050074998289346695, 0.0204611886292696, 0.040183451026678085, 0.002885596826672554, 0.0037730287294834852, -0.030325965955853462, -0.00009783509449334815, 0.002707745647057891, 0.03409549593925476, -0.0008705239742994308, -0.028360523283481598, 0.04923941567540169, 0.04177340120077133, -0.007679820526391268, 0.00969831645488739, -0.0077017382718622684, 0.011258723214268684, -0.02418496273458004, 0.06921485811471939, 0.014458375982940197, -0.00350759644061327, -0.03182506933808327, 0.015477179549634457, 0.037756916135549545, -0.0008912128396332264, 0.015468092635273933, -0.009281267412006855, -0.024094145745038986, -0.05811147391796112, -0.03552355617284775, -0.04238639771938324, 0.03585318475961685, 0.02145436778664589, -0.005105610936880112, 0.034615252166986465, 0.005910486914217472, -0.05582850053906441, 0.0015836665406823158, 0.0487174354493618, 0.05095804110169411, 0.03145641088485718, -0.03280536085367203, -0.030577626079320908, 0.0028180028311908245, -0.02516324818134308, 0.03733287379145622, 0.027910377830266953, -0.001163400593213737, 0.01323877926915884, 0.04124646261334419, 0.008234662935137749, -0.04709187150001526, 0.002540609333664179, -0.014596732333302498, 0.05846838280558586, 0.04808334633708, -0.026806456968188286, 0.01057436503469944, 0.01232836488634348, 0.01921769790351391, 0.033244792371988297, -0.0026228101924061775, -0.07621880620718002, -0.030443226918578148, 0.051480844616889954, 0.07632885128259659, -0.039008866995573044, -0.025184761732816696, -0.010563255287706852, 0.005851971451193094, 0.012611928395926952, 0.016630392521619797, 0.007238686550408602, -0.022427700459957123, 0.01427469402551651, -0.048513248562812805, -0.007880301214754581, -0.06063064560294151, 0.042196907103061676, 0.02816600166261196, 0.01808805763721466, -0.03500879555940628, -0.04408169910311699, 0.01958940364420414, -0.03333716467022896, 0.035554468631744385, 0.05322396755218506, -0.013041431084275246, -0.013683702796697617, 0.0318087562918663, 0.028629228472709656, 0.00636848621070385, -0.024983873590826988, 0.008097279816865921, 0.041713908314704895, -0.009047388099133968, 0.07370851188898087, -0.05661480501294136, -0.01186353899538517, 0.010158794932067394, -0.03447449207305908, 0.005820604506880045, 0.020793456584215164, -0.0011972608044743538, 0.03510920703411102, -0.0008324433583766222, 0.01579415798187256, 0.08320081979036331, -0.00393613101914525, -0.017083803191781044, -0.002640574472025037, -0.012103409506380558, 0.049885619431734085, -0.018832867965102196, -0.00043846890912391245, -0.05860695615410805, -0.0014150788774713874, -0.03093448467552662, 0.04711104929447174, 0.013182912953197956, 0.06784076988697052, -0.04020097851753235, 0.020566023886203766, 0.007529762107878923, 0.038802873343229294, 0.035022903233766556, 0.002573046600446105, 0.04636594280600548, 0.015682099387049675, 0.007338454015552998, -0.02090914361178875, 0.005237511824816465, -0.056876569986343384, 0.035289548337459564, 0.006264211144298315, -0.031083831563591957, -0.0021860047709196806, -0.03684907779097557, -0.020741473883390427, 0.004398169927299023, -0.003991738427430391, -0.020794173702597618, 0.0058587221428751945, 0.03308854252099991, 0.031162671744823456, -0.05231720954179764, 0.0013727794867008924, -0.009530603885650635, 0.009093448519706726, 0.042963579297065735, -0.05165572091937065, 0.01805143803358078, 0.008889946155250072, -0.009667395614087582, -0.0517873577773571, -0.02704937942326069, 0.03238491714000702, 0.031610600650310516, -0.03312879800796509, -0.00395882548764348, 0.006568755954504013, -0.04051825776696205, -0.009668933227658272, -0.03962872549891472, 0.05408584699034691, -0.0017156564863398671, 0.01098831556737423, 0.0013164596166461706, 0.009105979464948177, 0.09756266325712204, -0.006809451151639223, -0.014846249483525753, -0.003180110128596425, -0.02639944851398468, -0.012105458416044712, 0.010347941890358925, -0.0019146895501762629, -0.025914421305060387, -0.019526124000549316, -0.024137623608112335, 0.009944467805325985, 0.07114039361476898, -0.015713423490524292, -0.017116324976086617, -0.021297849714756012, -0.008974713273346424, -0.030451087281107903, -0.014256353490054607, -0.01128218974918127, -0.021441474556922913, 0.016617730259895325, -0.016108939424157143, 0.03820864483714104, 0.004706830717623234, -0.02038063481450081, -0.0005694185965694487, -0.01427951268851757, -0.02925821952521801, -0.02055518515408039, 0.057434696704149246, 0.012331184931099415, 0.005006381776183844, -0.03144935145974159, -0.02465052902698517, 0.01978621818125248, 0.005094710271805525, 0.011966603808104992, 0.016779419034719467, 0.02851308137178421, -0.0626610517501831, -0.026090916246175766, -0.009251701645553112, 0.012331313453614712, 0.07548071444034576, 0.0034688026644289494, 0.0795987918972969, 0.06753050535917282, 0.0025414475239813328, 0.006738739088177681, -0.01966259442269802, 0.0034029544331133366, -0.022163961082696915, -0.008222696371376514, 0.009954750537872314, 0.0025975117459893227, -0.02945272997021675, 0.01763027347624302, 0.051924437284469604, -0.009136863052845001, -0.011979788541793823, 0.010866296477615833, 0.014908423647284508, 0.03544839471578598, -0.028078867122530937, -0.015566707588732243, 0.04470803961157799, -0.05827358365058899, 0.03568822145462036, -0.056077420711517334, -0.003269847249612212, 0.03450951352715492, 0.024953307583928108, 0.03167786821722984, -0.08582427352666855, -0.013799453154206276, -0.03362937644124031, 0.022472454234957695, 0.01305949967354536, -0.020711299031972885, -0.0217409897595644, 0.009293593466281891, 0.04527418315410614, -0.010014728643000126, 0.03438606485724449, -0.02484048530459404, -0.10195641964673996, -0.04964577034115791, 0.010172185488045216, -0.01413320004940033, 0.04758736118674278, -0.01782332733273506, -0.025633368641138077, 0.011228226125240326, -0.032869961112737656, 0.031650085002183914, 0.014974033460021019, 0.047259338200092316, -0.05521853268146515, 0.050488486886024475, -0.009503337554633617, 0.03579302504658699, 0.01611902564764023, -0.004309654235839844, 0.12238643318414688, 0.05205659940838814, 0.00858336966484785, -0.03993550315499306, 0.040415290743112564, -0.008886662311851978, -0.045652490109205246, 0.0027818013913929462, 0.0447392463684082, 0.021389661356806755, -0.003294294700026512, 0.04104561731219292, 0.025147343054413795, 0.049075447022914886, -0.06697262078523636, 0.05191216245293617, -0.03945446014404297, -0.023080185055732727, -0.018603529781103134, 0.019102763384580612, -0.009130492806434631, -0.0179832112044096, 0.0009177285246551037, -0.030426137149333954, 0.016884328797459602, -0.005212990567088127, -0.03163308650255203, -0.022176049649715424, 0.02001609094440937, -0.0013473433209583163, -0.024512242525815964, 0.018996234983205795, 0.008117036893963814, 0.008384146727621555, -0.08285621553659439, -0.020880108699202538, -0.013288753107190132, -0.03033672645688057, 0.004411281086504459, 0.0406038872897625, -0.0030598591547459364, -0.03510608524084091, -0.003328994382172823, 0.013292782939970493, -0.03434192016720772, -0.007595742121338844, -0.043090879917144775, 0.060011185705661774, -0.015874935314059258, -0.0012718226062133908, -0.036887265741825104, -0.019483143463730812, -0.025785425677895546, -0.04450635984539986, -0.00006970905815251172, 0.0203672144562006, 0.006218293681740761, -0.024998005479574203, 0.005482420325279236, -0.048194948583841324, -0.003287803614512086, -0.021790647879242897, 0.037223152816295624, 0.03907144069671631, -0.035011131316423416, -0.024055564776062965, -0.011834717355668545, 0.05370771884918213, -0.01901877485215664, 0.00945561844855547, -0.024018576368689537, -0.006106897257268429, -0.033193718641996384, 0.006140948738902807, -0.010161036625504494, -0.003683550748974085, 0.03750719130039215, 0.0007697524270042777, -0.043144699186086655, -0.048059962689876556, -0.017062338069081306, -0.003088252618908882, -0.01605788618326187, 0.007725000847131014, -0.05906600505113602, 0.01039406843483448, 0.019265400245785713, 0.035766929388046265, 0.020373685285449028, 0.008161859586834908, 0.024587290361523628, 0.027919458225369453, 0.03147391602396965, -0.0429031103849411, -0.025131383910775185, -0.00662126112729311, -0.008217021822929382, -0.001905594253912568, -0.05524618923664093, 0.06748856604099274, 0.01884647272527218, 0.052695028483867645, 0.004908290226012468, 0.029068652540445328, 0.006842277944087982, 0.00004181445547146723, -0.018326958641409874, -0.06797246634960175, -0.009234639815986156, 0.025796255096793175, 0.006098300218582153, -0.027012387290596962, -0.01908930204808712, -0.01972426474094391, -0.050031594932079315, 0.009417202323675156, -0.02934686467051506, -0.017868345603346825, -0.00801060814410448, -0.026034599170088768, 0.03075546771287918, -0.032011978328228, 0.02946045994758606, 0.007040828466415405, -0.007752956356853247, 0.024155547842383385, 0.012826601974666119, -0.013132994063198566, 0.04193255677819252, 0.0029120747931301594, -0.014572780579328537, 0.02929353527724743, -0.008416028693318367, -0.008046941831707954, -0.008504086174070835, -0.0009592358255758882, -0.014937206171452999, 0.028661316260695457, 0.0019415520364418626, -0.016722630709409714, 0.029453102499246597, -0.037847504019737244, -0.04382782056927681, 0.015048920176923275, 0.017382588237524033, 0.03229627385735512, 0.028059985488653183, -0.015718216076493263, -0.004153490532189608, 0.00632351404055953, -0.050368696451187134, -0.05638563260436058, -0.036945540457963943, 0.013131574727594852, 0.016294317319989204, -0.004090773407369852, -0.003961978480219841, -0.006711488123983145, -0.02657998725771904, 0.03230568766593933, 0.0219673290848732, -0.0021695857867598534, -0.02846573293209076, -0.010205401107668877, 0.0048829903826117516, 0.009427024982869625, -0.004983468446880579, 0.00698974821716547, 0.009284960106015205, 0.06953711807727814, 0.0074555473402142525, 0.027376210317015648, -0.03534872829914093, 0.02715606801211834, -0.06480810046195984, -0.05833594501018524, 0.023173678666353226, -0.03135539963841438, 0.03257692977786064, -0.04629230499267578, -0.0006299811066128314, 0.007531644310802221, -0.07637789100408554, 0.05652352795004845, -0.026536593213677406, -0.0376058965921402, -0.056283168494701385, -0.005358378402888775, -0.02171480841934681, 0.03548908978700638, -0.024747896939516068, 0.0032067925203591585, 0.027339033782482147, 0.027417518198490143, 0.020175401121377945, -0.02079685777425766, -0.006656848359853029, -0.008596956729888916, 0.04346925765275955, -0.0644068717956543, 0.009369226172566414, -0.02364548295736313, -0.07351205497980118, 0.010979854501783848, -0.020866120234131813, 0.018664630129933357, 0.014449178241193295, -0.0016050126869231462, -0.03365027904510498, 0.04654121398925781, 0.011803759261965752, -0.0066999830305576324, -0.06743311882019043, 0.006903170142322779, -0.022381087765097618, 0.015216207131743431, -0.00610778946429491, 0.03479338809847832, 0.011129072867333889, -0.01699919067323208, -0.004796204622834921, 0.00921695027500391, -0.043909527361392975, -0.0426659919321537, -0.010135921649634838, -0.00628883671015501, -0.006860223598778248, -0.010418401099741459, -0.008518618531525135, -0.037838954478502274, -0.001573443878442049, 0.004612407647073269, 0.016894740983843803, -0.015750085934996605, -0.004917339887470007, 0.01260224636644125, -0.0013176571810618043, 0.00997814442962408, 0.005612134467810392, -0.022273214533925056, -0.034681353718042374, -0.010834001004695892, -0.005183515138924122, 0.004874303005635738, -0.008139263838529587, -0.03375067934393883, -0.025618061423301697, 0.024465231224894524, -0.008212555199861526, 0.003329626517370343, 0.013132579624652863, 0.00253038527444005, 0.004912500269711018, -0.04558047279715538, 0.0383271649479866, -0.01978967897593975, -0.04488286375999451, -0.04570254310965538, -0.020498260855674744, -0.04016474634408951, 0.03893859311938286, 0.04523120075464249, 0.03863023966550827, 0.012672781012952328, -0.020137488842010498, 0.0064479815773665905, -0.0026847643312066793, -0.048013199120759964, 0.03225501626729965, -0.0066579910926520824, -0.004344214219599962, 0.0060628680512309074, 0.0025230878964066505, 0.008966595865786076, -0.0011478811502456665, 0.03547703102231026, -0.03384017199277878, 0.05879448726773262, 0.014970557764172554, 0.00536419078707695, 0.017563164234161377, -0.04020952805876732, -0.015208999626338482, 0.03449387848377228, -0.02423856221139431, 0.02983487769961357, -0.029021168127655983, -0.0009670366416685283, -0.06377935409545898, 0.02901878021657467, -0.01923929527401924, -0.025774680078029633, -0.051577128469944, 0.026273133233189583, 0.02076386660337448, -0.048864539712667465, 0.015623685903847218, 0.02500370517373085, -0.06899428367614746, 0.0017215559491887689, 0.02862762100994587, 0.041318513453006744, -0.005333438515663147, -0.04121159389615059, 0.013606696389615536, 0.0148773193359375, -0.07453671842813492, 0.01999647356569767, 0.026671789586544037, 0.01663830503821373, -0.01693987287580967, 0.028973570093512535, 0.013952359557151794, -0.02978508360683918, 0.055466365069150925, 0.002275580307468772, 0.016768790781497955, -0.03629714995622635, 0.007691263221204281, 0.0028447527438402176, 0.017753686755895615, 0.009542123414576054, 0.037963200360536575, -0.035499174147844315, 0.0411410816013813, -0.03682802617549896, -0.04364216327667236, -0.03693784400820732, -0.010968711227178574, -0.01229144912213087, -0.01516932062804699, 0.04428475350141525, 0.04005388915538788, -0.03134015202522278, -0.007810254581272602, -0.02475322224199772, -0.020397676154971123, 0.015906590968370438, -0.008621339686214924, 0.010239183902740479, -0.025576433166861534, 0.011786729097366333, 0.007156307343393564, -0.001226246589794755, -0.04912522807717323, -0.025457413867115974, 0.0415639691054821, 0.03997713699936867, 0.03699588403105736, -0.03323168680071831, -0.04619058221578598, -0.029982803389430046, 0.01721508987247944, -0.03943328186869621, -0.044412944465875626, -0.03343262895941734, 0.02750857174396515, 0.005407815333455801, -0.00006351608317345381 ]
<p>I have the following data for 10 subjects based on before and after measurements:</p> <pre><code>x &lt;- c(12.9, 13.5, 12.8, 15.6, 17.2, 19.2, 12.6, 15.3, 14.4, 11.3) y &lt;- c(12.7, 13.6, 12.0, 15.2, 16.8, 20.0, 12.0, 15.9, 16.0, 11.1) </code></pre> <p>and would like to perform a permutation test.</p> <p>I used the <code>permTS(...)</code> to perform a two-sided t-test and obtained a value of <code>0.982</code>.</p> <p>But I would like to use the <code>expand.grid(rep(x,k ))</code> by interchanging the before and after tags. Does anyone know how this can be achieved?</p> <p>Given the numbers of possible permutations it is not possible to stimulate every permutation, hence why I would like to use expand.grid to check if the same result is obtained.</p> <p>Thanks</p>
73,592
[ -0.018868153914809227, -0.014784595929086208, 0.0193630363792181, -0.009587761014699936, 0.059351127594709396, -0.011582648381590843, -0.024163519963622093, -0.02056341990828514, 0.00293060764670372, -0.013491480611264706, 0.009090537205338478, 0.028062501922249794, 0.048787251114845276, 0.018732499331235886, 0.021229036152362823, 0.006815716158598661, -0.016022436320781708, -0.0023493587505072355, -0.02298654243350029, -0.00041850245906971395, -0.003497040830552578, -0.00005107805191073567, -0.05794597789645195, 0.0014824540121480823, -0.03144579380750656, 0.027297358959913254, 0.05036016181111336, -0.030332552269101143, 0.003472092328593135, 0.08996481448411942, -0.03023218922317028, -0.029704438522458076, 0.006848376244306564, 0.025151869282126427, -0.0004140509117860347, 0.0004363289044704288, -0.016169315204024315, -0.07365638762712479, 0.0035798619501292706, 0.0022128659766167402, -0.027249621227383614, 0.0017217911081388593, -0.04068487137556076, 0.04709826037287712, -0.0032736761495471, 0.05293551832437515, -0.04747459292411804, -0.003763112472370267, 0.05233297869563103, -0.04187984764575958, 0.0908656120300293, 0.014523624442517757, 0.029978428035974503, 0.016252882778644562, -0.008840786293148994, -0.004520331509411335, 0.0590401254594326, 0.04513167217373848, 0.01297819335013628, -0.03594334051012993, 0.007448371034115553, -0.07718389481306076, -0.0037815698888152838, -0.0013015682343393564, -0.029722465202212334, 0.018069472163915634, -0.0012883265735581517, 0.00006974179268581793, 0.050309985876083374, -0.05873196944594383, 0.012815449386835098, 0.021492134779691696, 0.056326426565647125, -0.025703737512230873, 0.027899013832211494, -0.043703339993953705, 0.023048102855682373, -0.021956827491521835, -0.001770715694874525, 0.05255161598324776, 0.006111504975706339, 0.040305737406015396, 0.03457061946392059, 0.04573258012533188, 0.014723768457770348, -0.028420325368642807, 0.03328711539506912, -0.04113348200917244, 0.055028222501277924, 0.031856968998909, -0.00934565719217062, -0.00864501390606165, 0.05264017730951309, 0.0261845663189888, -0.048298101872205734, 0.009995189495384693, 0.006590604316443205, 0.018478617072105408, -0.018443500623106956, -0.01819690503180027, -0.024417681619524956, -0.05881349742412567, 0.015211829915642738, 0.03155192360281944, -0.0232013501226902, 0.015897000208497047, -0.0210550669580698, -0.03071056865155697, 0.0024445713497698307, -0.01284418161958456, 0.012064783833920956, 0.02325422130525112, -0.017310306429862976, -0.03290088474750519, 0.019766371697187424, -0.035464636981487274, -0.038309428840875626, -0.0002933052892331034, 0.07125448435544968, 0.09575413912534714, 0.03503212705254555, -0.000588442082516849, 0.026545464992523193, -0.042544446885585785, -0.030960049480199814, -0.004632744938135147, 0.011555642820894718, 0.0027659840416163206, -0.026468325406312943, 0.05969494581222534, -0.008798439987003803, -0.01506776548922062, 0.0244283527135849, -0.01398021075874567, 0.023929277434945107, 0.004532654769718647, -0.08835574984550476, -0.0750589519739151, 0.03775031492114067, -0.033615246415138245, -0.0030893986113369465, -0.03235945105552673, 0.04031703248620033, 0.029112156480550766, 0.06250900030136108, -0.003967031836509705, 0.03742397949099541, -0.0072348713874816895, 0.008402687497437, 0.02731364592909813, -0.02599407732486725, 0.014784912578761578, -0.026751957833766937, -0.023691747337579727, -0.0227728970348835, -0.07940426468849182, 0.03865676745772362, 0.026624156162142754, -0.0034738825634121895, 0.014255359768867493, 0.02563951164484024, -0.0003422871814109385, -0.011834613047540188, -0.019823314622044563, -0.022839898243546486, -0.016028527170419693, 0.06479281932115555, -0.0007921025389805436, 0.01782274805009365, 0.005106788594275713, -0.037772275507450104, 0.00751242833212018, 0.01888158544898033, 0.04910250008106232, 0.01277033518999815, -0.006703536491841078, 0.015028143301606178, 0.000452911714091897, 0.033500541001558304, 0.011196979321539402, -0.011855286546051502, 0.008065531961619854, -0.024039356037974358, -0.012212694622576237, 0.03986586257815361, 0.010453778319060802, 0.027087686583399773, -0.00299784610979259, 0.047724008560180664, -0.045648522675037384, -0.034522656351327896, -0.0551321879029274, 0.00039550726069137454, 0.0002383673854637891, -0.05517962574958801, -0.014331570826470852, 0.010528924874961376, 0.046030960977077484, 0.07163850963115692, -0.05493704974651337, -0.020777836441993713, 0.018218543380498886, 0.012786965817213058, -0.013727884739637375, -0.05005326494574547, 0.039795663207769394, 0.03591635078191757, -0.006896180100739002, 0.042223069816827774, -0.037420500069856644, -0.0024448540061712265, 0.00779710803180933, -0.05916881188750267, 0.007755602244287729, -0.005502379033714533, -0.02409963309764862, 0.014186899177730083, 0.05090627819299698, -0.04900087043642998, 0.07133053988218307, -0.043592419475317, 0.03591705486178398, 0.06842033565044403, 0.006530504208058119, 0.004510644823312759, -0.02157776616513729, 0.022864654660224915, 0.04442621394991875, -0.03876940533518791, -0.037341032177209854, -0.04172255098819733, -0.031183229759335518, 0.049175336956977844, -0.015108090825378895, -0.00791195873171091, 0.010321063920855522, 0.06299231946468353, -0.03607325628399849, -0.03387223929166794, 0.0634770616889, 0.0016836465802043676, -0.040904197841882706, 0.009184913709759712, 0.03356209397315979, 0.07778339087963104, -0.01554765086621046, 0.008614391088485718, 0.0022905839141458273, -0.0007924667443148792, 0.042761873453855515, 0.024618299677968025, -0.0006791000487282872, -0.007811728864908218, 0.01747909002006054, -0.02088930271565914, -0.040568944066762924, 0.02316536381840706, 0.015325200743973255, 0.006118869874626398, 0.032786425203084946, 0.017769360914826393, -0.019307995215058327, -0.004983941093087196, 0.005638641770929098, -0.020583532750606537, 0.02933354675769806, -0.011816035024821758, -0.013953660614788532, 0.02138572745025158, -0.035144686698913574, 0.014026175253093243, 0.023423267528414726, -0.0020139252301305532, -0.03201685845851898, 0.02553103305399418, 0.032570309937000275, 0.014549503102898598, 0.029277225956320763, -0.050306160002946854, -0.010383803397417068, 0.011627363972365856, 0.010225636884570122, 0.02302849479019642, -0.013365347869694233, -0.04108179360628128, 0.004437006078660488, 0.0016958654159680009, -0.05607307702302933, 0.013838933780789375, 0.006525530479848385, -0.05231741815805435, 0.01850297302007675, 0.006475047208368778, -0.006611234974116087, 0.010608776472508907, -0.06047454848885536, 0.02238767221570015, -0.018762212246656418, -0.023627549409866333, 0.04264640063047409, 0.027588015422225, -0.05460372194647789, 0.0030529010109603405, -0.041483256965875626, -0.00013227136514615268, -0.01791653409600258, 0.003088556695729494, 0.020720986649394035, 0.006866184528917074, -0.0059376489371061325, 0.049306441098451614, 0.0024072430096566677, -0.03978036344051361, -0.04147586598992348, -0.041350968182086945, -0.01078550424426794, 0.02247978374361992, 0.013082238845527172, 0.02020258642733097, -0.012857155874371529, 0.05946733057498932, 0.01100850198417902, -0.0212318766862154, -0.05940968543291092, -0.016128946095705032, -0.010109936818480492, -0.0036186238285154104, 0.0345219224691391, 0.04402363300323486, -0.0040013836696743965, 0.03356602042913437, -0.0015010950155556202, 0.02423117868602276, 0.07579225301742554, -0.026863152161240578, 0.002052025170996785, 0.020761292427778244, 0.03395811468362808, -0.01498757116496563, 0.013247990980744362, 0.011035123839974403, -0.019661039113998413, -0.010694199241697788, 0.010815596207976341, 0.0029057243373245, -0.007225270848721266, -0.050773195922374725, 0.007435665465891361, -0.0048222322948277, 0.03289218991994858, -0.05113159865140915, 0.06183629855513573, 0.001006763195618987, -0.04734932258725166, -0.012553823180496693, 0.05224718526005745, 0.03821799159049988, -0.0014248400693759322, 0.013538306578993797, 0.03594725579023361, 0.04902329668402672, -0.046144045889377594, 0.016202153638005257, -0.014371560886502266, -0.0003965153300669044, 0.004352071322500706, -0.03994789719581604, -0.005046332720667124, 0.04742160066962242, 0.04186826944351196, 0.02219785377383232, 0.029268989339470863, -0.01579064130783081, 0.04728744179010391, -0.01549620646983385, -0.005034057889133692, -0.020073113963007927, 0.035985108464956284, -0.0008970546186901629, 0.0706709697842598, 0.019626952707767487, 0.003998822532594204, -0.005369724705815315, 0.02637467347085476, -0.05820472911000252, 0.01577717810869217, 0.04387054592370987, 0.006721895653754473, 0.03683696314692497, -0.03326040878891945, 0.01753511093556881, -0.005568382330238819, 0.01055186241865158, 0.03252048045396805, -0.0007681795977987349, -0.062271904200315475, 0.009078788571059704, -0.005872008390724659, 0.003821316175162792, -0.009399093687534332, 0.029038146138191223, 0.03266025334596634, 0.00933137908577919, 0.04531850293278694, -0.010204908438026905, -0.015750572085380554, 0.019999613985419273, -0.000529772078152746, 0.025068864226341248, 0.01893235370516777, 0.03344550356268883, 0.021253272891044617, 0.03539516031742096, -0.014736810699105263, -0.0031860582530498505, -0.043058693408966064, 0.030304452404379845, 0.04126124456524849, 0.011965205892920494, -0.02259458228945732, -0.028099458664655685, -0.010210775770246983, -0.016253679990768433, 0.021091768518090248, -0.015272722579538822, 0.002560881432145834, 0.033867672085762024, 0.02275765687227249, -0.04858024790883064, 0.0341191366314888, 0.08640450984239578, -0.0003213228192180395, -0.0007601404213346541, -0.051615793257951736, 0.00374104967340827, -0.0059766098856925964, -0.010061262175440788, 0.02243783511221409, 0.008148078806698322, 0.027961967512965202, 0.029211977496743202, 0.01246439665555954, -0.028816603124141693, -0.018222372978925705, 0.03155675157904625, -0.020673703402280807, 0.06729653477668762, -0.022157130762934685, -0.019797667860984802, -0.0119764544069767, -0.008617551065981388, 0.02597956918179989, 0.023647168651223183, -0.03199423849582672, -0.08486282825469971, 0.0135837122797966, 0.06795330345630646, 0.064982570707798, -0.03873266652226448, -0.004652576521039009, -0.06298669427633286, -0.023966511711478233, 0.029931770637631416, -0.039121124893426895, 0.007170656695961952, -0.016407767310738564, -0.02067546546459198, -0.04236585646867752, 0.0034936105366796255, -0.030911875888705254, 0.009958935901522636, -0.03949451446533203, -0.02183421142399311, -0.025472933426499367, -0.030344177037477493, -0.013868650421500206, -0.01187788974493742, 0.024465365335345268, 0.02460940182209015, -0.04852670431137085, -0.02440115623176098, -0.001916848006658256, -0.0009088196093216538, -0.02650894597172737, -0.05124814435839653, 0.025169026106595993, 0.0010084436507895589, 0.008156463503837585, 0.07188505679368973, 0.01677653193473816, -0.021920809522271156, -0.006306193768978119, -0.006150488276034594, -0.027032895013689995, 0.00010742858285084367, 0.00743301585316658, 0.04305147007107735, 0.025629496201872826, -0.006488588638603687, 0.026785770431160927, 0.04162590205669403, 0.017806217074394226, 0.02713286690413952, -0.031575143337249756, 0.013751805759966373, -0.0022661318071186543, 0.00602775439620018, -0.04822470247745514, -0.012692485935986042, -0.01198305282741785, 0.03458410128951073, -0.010740331374108791, 0.027681147679686546, -0.030868079513311386, -0.015148088335990906, 0.02417186088860035, 0.054131727665662766, 0.006949074100703001, -0.006061573047190905, 0.01165204867720604, 0.019475117325782776, -0.0024359722156077623, 0.011462262831628323, 0.004074510652571917, -0.032772477716207504, 0.008849229663610458, 0.008064137771725655, -0.01499246433377266, 0.003864332800731063, -0.00972750224173069, -0.01948443427681923, 0.0025922448839992285, -0.009013849310576916, 0.0021631780546158552, -0.0009073367691598833, 0.028621049597859383, -0.009418612346053123, -0.02526881918311119, -0.015207692049443722, 0.02990223653614521, 0.01867395080626011, 0.01506833266466856, -0.03382743149995804, 0.062058333307504654, -0.003356841392815113, -0.00819617323577404, -0.09445841610431671, -0.0476456955075264, 0.01221020519733429, -0.011621806770563126, -0.010350349359214306, -0.0475512333214283, -0.038346510380506516, -0.03019515424966812, -0.021309932693839073, -0.013700864277780056, 0.026217710226774216, 0.005055846180766821, -0.0001000651391223073, -0.019521895796060562, -0.008646097965538502, 0.072657510638237, -0.0030420406255871058, 0.015024636872112751, 0.01557407807558775, -0.018442008644342422, 0.0024056301917880774, 0.04938506707549095, -0.01594368927180767, -0.02078806422650814, 0.009989257901906967, -0.043572746217250824, 0.04577777907252312, 0.06156988441944122, 0.00003303101038909517, -0.067975714802742, -0.020619122311472893, -0.022520996630191803, 0.029177598655223846, -0.06328966468572617, -0.005127272102981806, -0.03580368310213089, -0.00710434140637517, -0.037723612040281296, 0.021556032821536064, -0.04856007918715477, 0.01655544340610504, 0.007378533016890287, -0.03638676926493645, -0.036935195326805115, -0.009174739010632038, 0.08543719351291656, 0.0008112538489513099, -0.023590844124555588, -0.022203948348760605, -0.027745725587010384, 0.031529784202575684, 0.0063068317249417305, 0.0016759836580604315, 0.010589291341602802, -0.012173965573310852, -0.03941508010029793, -0.023938598111271858, -0.035377077758312225, -0.005455064121633768, 0.030819961801171303, 0.0004810539830941707, 0.045814454555511475, 0.05370256304740906, -0.002570180455222726, 0.02819981426000595, 0.010828081518411636, 0.03681134432554245, -0.017490839585661888, -0.0038622349966317415, 0.08185778558254242, 0.013592571951448917, -0.012724482454359531, 0.036573342978954315, 0.031052879989147186, 0.02254495583474636, 0.03143018111586571, 0.021541092544794083, -0.021205781027674675, 0.018350498750805855, -0.016814449802041054, -0.0095443706959486, 0.022962192073464394, -0.05402412265539169, 0.0031976753380149603, -0.0438038669526577, 0.0009366525919176638, 0.03552316501736641, 0.03189370036125183, -0.02697676047682762, -0.033487219363451004, -0.02864309400320053, -0.08459961414337158, -0.020819948986172676, 0.04190722107887268, -0.0016263185534626245, 0.022612454369664192, -0.0061342064291238785, 0.0526917390525341, 0.001196390250697732, 0.014269156381487846, -0.03649410605430603, -0.09150239080190659, -0.014369403943419456, -0.016292324289679527, -0.033793915063142776, 0.04037418216466904, 0.006334203761070967, 0.009166612289845943, 0.002812311751767993, -0.023822670802474022, 0.03160605952143669, 0.014552824199199677, 0.05986865982413292, -0.03394922986626625, 0.08816628903150558, -0.010157803073525429, 0.04746387526392937, -0.00900658406317234, -0.01024112943559885, 0.12051572650671005, 0.07174184173345566, 0.03842730447649956, -0.062359102070331573, 0.03453698009252548, 0.046772051602602005, -0.042284008115530014, -0.013497371226549149, 0.008291928097605705, 0.027803100645542145, -0.008504020050168037, 0.020842576399445534, 0.06746441125869751, 0.035892367362976074, -0.019671602174639702, 0.01680152304470539, -0.029346510767936707, -0.03150920942425728, 0.022150857374072075, 0.01053215004503727, -0.018629752099514008, -0.0341835618019104, -0.06547825038433075, -0.011158174835145473, 0.011126959696412086, 0.02404693327844143, -0.029604189097881317, -0.02551174908876419, -0.022373516112565994, 0.02937123365700245, -0.0024499930441379547, 0.030148306861519814, -0.007059029303491116, 0.02160451002418995, -0.013043669052422047, -0.02633698098361492, 0.017652705311775208, -0.0004886407987214625, 0.013541324995458126, 0.06964111328125, 0.013036205433309078, -0.011788466945290565, -0.020935488864779472, 0.03277284651994705, -0.03776277229189873, -0.012952227145433426, -0.0026076759677380323, 0.04769903048872948, -0.01774851605296135, -0.04583793506026268, 0.013563666492700577, 0.02402595803141594, -0.018429575487971306, -0.038824260234832764, -0.039796218276023865, 0.028046268969774246, 0.02887720800936222, -0.018751496449112892, 0.015779366716742516, -0.020878396928310394, -0.006336471065878868, -0.03134855255484581, 0.06478103250265121, 0.0307146068662405, -0.0012731340248137712, -0.006648159120231867, -0.008320811204612255, 0.06143900379538536, 0.018328450620174408, 0.01700044982135296, -0.0031917444430291653, -0.02276250720024109, -0.04475276172161102, -0.01892111264169216, -0.005219716113060713, -0.006248106248676777, 0.020755238831043243, -0.014706985093653202, -0.017794737592339516, -0.004864027723670006, 0.005636271554976702, 0.009829278104007244, -0.011172407306730747, -0.02120027504861355, -0.039527807384729385, 0.03274333104491234, 0.048710789531469345, 0.032696668058633804, -0.017382696270942688, 0.03192174434661865, 0.015699222683906555, 0.02757985331118107, 0.00022163153334986418, -0.038400761783123016, -0.037857212126255035, 0.006600410211831331, -0.010302730835974216, -0.019762391224503517, -0.015914399176836014, 0.05100154131650925, 0.02295726165175438, 0.009705676697194576, -0.026739230379462242, 0.01080821081995964, -0.011656824499368668, -0.027988729998469353, 0.0021372961346060038, -0.01861545816063881, 0.00480668805539608, 0.010128426365554333, -0.02850162610411644, -0.008203352801501751, -0.004311600234359503, -0.01864335872232914, -0.045876435935497284, 0.025524208322167397, -0.017893550917506218, -0.005578477866947651, -0.03916686773300171, 0.007856576703488827, -0.019647475332021713, -0.0015234025195240974, -0.004781274124979973, -0.022659746930003166, -0.02376977540552616, -0.03864346444606781, -0.018041299656033516, -0.015029886737465858, 0.01860712096095085, -0.04930058866739273, -0.016561826691031456, 0.06484977900981903, 0.016322391107678413, 0.018429668620228767, -0.030118132010102272, 0.004904754459857941, 0.026762817054986954, 0.03515319526195526, 0.012610347010195255, -0.03340665623545647, 0.03829945623874664, -0.08500058203935623, -0.017681533470749855, -0.023990964516997337, -0.02971339039504528, 0.04311644658446312, 0.0354933887720108, 0.014931628480553627, 0.008970123715698719, 0.015396056696772575, -0.019608380272984505, -0.011895266361534595, -0.006721952464431524, 0.0225474052131176, 0.005448655690997839, -0.021015852689743042, -0.005196964368224144, 0.0058369105681777, -0.028766579926013947, 0.0321795679628849, 0.024488044902682304, 0.018466688692569733, -0.02858315035700798, 0.013761728070676327, 0.003949186764657497, 0.029238590970635414, 0.01813492365181446, -0.03722810000181198, 0.017747309058904648, 0.038668401539325714, -0.02115551009774208, 0.015824617817997932, -0.0631340816617012, 0.005197073798626661, -0.076359823346138, -0.0024386646691709757, 0.003638975089415908, -0.008505232632160187, 0.026172053068876266, -0.03166598826646805, -0.005837358999997377, 0.0026608796324580908, -0.03755541145801544, 0.04497244581580162, 0.014216852374374866, 0.02080307900905609, 0.013047047890722752, 0.04231375455856323, -0.0032409136183559895, 0.011421353556215763, 0.040283236652612686, 0.021111255511641502, 0.03812781348824501, -0.014937746338546276, 0.006442839279770851, -0.00564871309325099, -0.014800000004470348, -0.0004565524577628821, 0.03984605148434639, -0.07480142265558243, 0.04771241918206215, -0.04080753028392792, -0.05190528556704521, -0.007381335832178593, -0.017715927213430405, 0.013461273163557053, 0.007877840660512447, 0.03370324894785881, 0.014478398486971855, 0.07538190484046936, 0.023667821660637856, -0.0005161020089872181, -0.04065820574760437, 0.030794335529208183, -0.0063872309401631355, -0.029559163376688957, -0.038077935576438904, 0.04481036216020584, 0.04434893652796745, 0.004459344316273928, 0.02873464860022068, 0.0337093286216259, -0.043433576822280884, -0.018535887822508812, 0.01616898737847805, -0.012799415737390518, 0.033531177788972855, -0.004522284027189016, -0.023441320285201073, -0.038760170340538025, 0.026125770062208176, 0.008988907560706139, 0.03429147228598595, -0.0031300976406782866, 0.02043062262237072, -0.03685326501727104, -0.04029151052236557, 0.018245063722133636, -0.013430370017886162, -0.011814775876700878, -0.04472653567790985, -0.014582721516489983, -0.014964302070438862, 0.025015030056238174, 0.006014123093336821, -0.007418936118483543, -0.008873887360095978, 0.04413007199764252, 0.0015711133601143956, 0.03241247683763504, 0.005969509016722441, 0.03047412633895874, 0.011541781015694141, -0.09059657901525497, 0.029369210824370384, -0.0014137253165245056, -0.028950953856110573, -0.04090988263487816, -0.00006826644676038995, -0.04335116222500801, 0.0536276213824749, 0.030161773785948753, 0.013767941854894161, 0.0009699877118691802, -0.04936482757329941, 0.028260981664061546, 0.016610831022262573, -0.09984316676855087, 0.05850120261311531, -0.014265578240156174, -0.007847938686609268, -0.0061151147820055485, 0.004246020223945379, 0.013434072956442833, 0.023436082527041435, -0.016731424257159233, -0.06535521149635315, -0.01644899509847164, -0.020311791449785233, -0.01183136273175478, 0.016738208010792732, -0.0030746159609407187, -0.0341203510761261, 0.009222752414643764, 0.01281555276364088, 0.022974468767642975, 0.012818912975490093, 0.03206157684326172, -0.05696450546383858, 0.05286646634340286, -0.06129142642021179, 0.01803605630993843, 0.004256709944456816, 0.026178061962127686, -0.01111676823347807, -0.03736108914017677, 0.014897014014422894, 0.00342580396682024, -0.046049777418375015, -0.011976412497460842, 0.03472365811467171, 0.03909517824649811, 0.04039539396762848, -0.028078537434339523, 0.007968892343342304, -0.0005226407665759325, -0.027310306206345558, -0.006822361145168543, 0.026991812512278557, 0.011027533560991287, 0.0031385605689138174, 0.02001974545419216, 0.00766208628192544, -0.042642742395401, 0.04477778077125549, -0.01216252613812685, 0.020662635564804077, -0.01435109693557024, 0.0017748805694282055, 0.017297757789492607, -0.020424088463187218, 0.015395818278193474, -0.015924077481031418, -0.03699545934796333, -0.007067454047501087, -0.020391911268234253, 0.024680649861693382, -0.023233897984027863, -0.03936426341533661, -0.0173263568431139, -0.022728106006979942, 0.01565837860107422, 0.023159770295023918, 0.007737783249467611, -0.0012141349725425243, -0.031238695606589317, -0.01612189970910549, 0.0052902549505233765, -0.023065008223056793, 0.019045164808630943, -0.052047137171030045, -0.009002339094877243, 0.017650365829467773, 0.008749037981033325, -0.061437491327524185, -0.03693199157714844, 0.012235132977366447, 0.01573120430111885, 0.010577953420579433, -0.04812449589371681, -0.038692496716976166, 0.019505659118294716, 0.03674197569489479, -0.016455888748168945, -0.033086132258176804, -0.05709422379732132, 0.007315187714993954, 0.004183229524642229, -0.017689557746052742 ]
<p>I have a dataset collected using an accelerometer. I am extracting the magnitudes from the signal to find the difference in running pattern between two different running surfaces. Will normalization help to improve my classification accuracy? In general, when should we normalize time series data? Any suggestions?</p>
73,593
[ 0.001163833192549646, -0.033099301159381866, -0.049168992787599564, 0.016815366223454475, 0.021313495934009552, 0.013689420185983181, -0.021617967635393143, -0.03242998570203781, 0.008582107722759247, -0.005689502693712711, 0.01853622868657112, -0.004686823580414057, 0.008022372610867023, 0.022063562646508217, 0.06501201540231705, -0.03127129003405571, -0.016105975955724716, -0.02670734003186226, -0.003555683884769678, 0.003180730389431119, -0.01803189143538475, 0.006825972814112902, 0.027999673038721085, -0.01929526962339878, -0.01615329273045063, 0.021108483895659447, 0.026544025167822838, -0.00844896212220192, -0.012519681826233864, 0.043790243566036224, -0.029042309150099754, 0.01861124485731125, -0.03236742317676544, 0.04250570014119148, 0.0007792896358296275, 0.022343585267663002, -0.03865858539938927, -0.011149385944008827, -0.029142135754227638, 0.04643084853887558, -0.017598317936062813, 0.0009454051032662392, 0.026278391480445862, 0.06124495714902878, -0.04553528502583504, 0.05234711244702339, 0.025332285091280937, -0.006208586506545544, 0.003991795238107443, -0.038714099675416946, 0.07978548854589462, -0.024637922644615173, 0.03863836079835892, 0.015440688468515873, 0.011177579872310162, -0.00534844258800149, 0.041162531822919846, 0.013186395168304443, -0.002554282546043396, -0.04790368676185608, -0.026773834601044655, -0.04180901125073433, -0.024436675012111664, -0.019016865640878677, -0.02433411031961441, 0.03779233992099762, -0.029488608241081238, -0.015129542909562588, 0.035165101289749146, -0.007640499155968428, 0.02132144384086132, 0.04860788211226463, 0.04284762218594551, -0.04150015115737915, 0.0092797065153718, -0.03742684796452522, 0.021001586690545082, 0.03507307171821594, 0.031743187457323074, 0.017768440768122673, 0.04196656867861748, -0.004061794374138117, 0.03306769207119942, 0.035493750125169754, 0.04559418931603432, -0.015349018387496471, 0.05161430314183235, -0.03868747875094414, 0.005139127839356661, 0.04156174138188362, 0.006942669861018658, 0.007732380647212267, 0.03979194909334183, 0.0016003798227757215, -0.031596843153238297, 0.05090813711285591, 0.006173472851514816, 0.004961156286299229, 0.01892969012260437, -0.0119389733299613, -0.022716619074344635, -0.03210847079753876, 0.004736528731882572, 0.022062167525291443, -0.005709560122340918, 0.03993743285536766, -0.042182814329862595, 0.009759620763361454, -0.031670209020376205, 0.00043565622763708234, -0.0466202013194561, -0.011865876615047455, 0.0110781854018569, -0.003239426063373685, 0.026515409350395203, 0.008415787480771542, -0.021617744117975235, -0.002735597314313054, 0.02543370984494686, 0.07628001272678375, 0.03462298586964607, -0.03126082941889763, 0.002632262883707881, -0.011787568219006062, -0.057205911725759506, 0.02020352892577648, -0.006486934144049883, -0.03726114705204964, -0.043851446360349655, 0.046387940645217896, -0.026342811062932014, -0.015616160817444324, 0.00046544484212063253, -0.05792611092329025, 0.028868792578577995, 0.019171597436070442, -0.07687348872423172, -0.041452646255493164, 0.04435410350561142, 0.008533063344657421, 0.02348567545413971, -0.05602588132023811, -0.0010700394632294774, 0.017865462228655815, 0.025099821388721466, 0.041093286126852036, 0.05820947885513306, 0.044163890182971954, 0.02693253941833973, 0.006268805358558893, 0.012263097800314426, -0.027231058105826378, -0.02778494544327259, -0.03673924133181572, 0.0007044426165521145, -0.05771614611148834, -0.005621644202619791, 0.024983342736959457, 0.0017050447640940547, -0.012685999274253845, 0.03995571285486221, 0.013422275893390179, -0.00853029265999794, 0.029245031997561455, 0.010679646395146847, -0.0021712875459343195, 0.04532263055443764, -0.014394516125321388, 0.05420733615756035, 0.018384456634521484, 0.03374107554554939, 0.019922558218240738, 0.03758729249238968, 0.013968506827950478, 0.030231377109885216, 0.006655936595052481, -0.010400326922535896, -0.008365750312805176, 0.02039630152285099, -0.013109330087900162, -0.03197775036096573, -0.05237589776515961, -0.03698480501770973, -0.005762537941336632, -0.011784703470766544, 0.03123079426586628, 0.01706123910844326, 0.0030306451953947544, 0.03993210569024086, -0.05102527141571045, -0.0013023156207054853, -0.09391060471534729, -0.009208708070218563, -0.041322123259305954, 0.007105350960046053, 0.03600253537297249, -0.016676699742674828, 0.0399320051074028, 0.0005349199054762721, -0.005903215147554874, 0.0000476610912301112, 0.0051823388785123825, 0.033050477504730225, -0.0627790242433548, -0.005300619639456272, 0.007207287475466728, 0.003330905456095934, -0.014094660058617592, 0.05293559283018112, -0.022065719589591026, -0.04286068677902222, -0.010172075591981411, -0.052638083696365356, -0.0007106810226105154, -0.0025120179634541273, 0.0005867793224751949, 0.01829150691628456, -0.0031196384225040674, -0.03415781632065773, 0.024344870820641518, -0.024402206763625145, 0.0973532646894455, 0.051286887377500534, -0.03396536037325859, -0.014609064906835556, 0.003318179864436388, 0.032201312482357025, -0.029241565614938736, -0.011247986927628517, -0.03440607339143753, -0.07223223149776459, -0.030039023607969284, 0.03782438486814499, 0.056776247918605804, -0.03422895446419716, 0.019200436770915985, 0.06788856536149979, 0.03737100213766098, 0.013670789077877998, 0.03077784925699234, -0.013725373893976212, -0.016784977167844772, 0.050718244165182114, 0.029716482385993004, 0.022210365161299706, -0.02583773247897625, 0.02649587392807007, -0.011040464043617249, 0.01642444171011448, -0.009363621473312378, -0.013786152936518192, 0.030715567991137505, 0.01621060073375702, 0.03751882165670395, -0.009579907171428204, -0.04476817324757576, 0.017100105062127113, -0.02126806601881981, 0.027585219591856003, 0.014280303381383419, -0.004457512870430946, 0.01344980951398611, -0.008123158477246761, -0.0017654098337516189, 0.06875520944595337, 0.017473552376031876, 0.006720439065247774, 0.00548141822218895, 0.03375358134508133, -0.0654132068157196, 0.015748105943202972, -0.049009501934051514, -0.04154317080974579, -0.04091199114918709, -0.028742248192429543, 0.05589168518781662, -0.002233585575595498, 0.05876801908016205, -0.031107192859053612, -0.01875140145421028, 0.011403916403651237, -0.0020572084467858076, 0.002678885357454419, 0.025263147428631783, -0.029167506843805313, 0.007739766966551542, -0.03490164130926132, -0.027483846992254257, 0.004484965931624174, -0.009704729542136192, 0.0035355957224965096, 0.01764209009706974, 0.006413619499653578, -0.032639842480421066, -0.049267109483480453, -0.0233153123408556, 0.03840665519237518, 0.0008093854412436485, -0.019311489537358284, 0.05499431863427162, 0.010871139355003834, -0.03961712494492531, 0.009371818043291569, -0.011881737038493156, -0.003992423415184021, -0.04658155143260956, -0.010926302522420883, 0.01625475287437439, -0.007048043888062239, -0.01151658408343792, 0.02996685728430748, -0.05919582396745682, -0.001079720095731318, -0.03414218872785568, -0.07053175568580627, 0.023627707734704018, -0.027008041739463806, 0.04290654882788658, 0.010205860249698162, -0.016632989048957825, 0.05529628321528435, 0.06245921924710274, -0.017749479040503502, -0.02173979952931404, 0.004769360646605492, -0.020251920446753502, -0.014605189673602581, -0.000742415024433285, 0.030625341460108757, 0.036081038415431976, 0.013486350886523724, 0.00425664521753788, 0.046460796147584915, 0.08415396511554718, -0.004845452029258013, -0.022938920184969902, 0.006162683479487896, 0.02053755149245262, 0.005509883631020784, 0.008483629673719406, 0.023933999240398407, -0.011927725747227669, 0.0176648311316967, 0.008857657201588154, 0.0044416869059205055, 0.02761709690093994, -0.030427945777773857, 0.036402326077222824, -0.034667789936065674, 0.01690009795129299, -0.06397388130426407, 0.01117867510765791, 0.011210803873836994, -0.012279413640499115, -0.03785853460431099, 0.01672104187309742, 0.011023038998246193, -0.029658537358045578, 0.030956631526350975, 0.04240011051297188, 0.05744197964668274, -0.019833270460367203, -0.03369351476430893, -0.016910992562770844, -0.022393865510821342, 0.02474462240934372, -0.05846636742353439, -0.012649147771298885, -0.002101094927638769, 0.027730626985430717, 0.045761700719594955, 0.020428366959095, -0.06783250719308853, 0.009765125811100006, -0.06718414276838303, -0.004331659059971571, -0.01333419419825077, 0.04115206003189087, 0.005719246808439493, -0.011893590912222862, 0.017218390479683876, -0.021131165325641632, 0.052186738699674606, -0.0105050690472126, -0.05158909782767296, 0.043248359113931656, -0.03605002164840698, -0.029521213844418526, -0.0006945175118744373, -0.024204684421420097, 0.01811411790549755, -0.03402572125196457, -0.000687415711581707, 0.0024171401746571064, 0.025071410462260246, -0.08387476950883865, -0.011438751593232155, -0.02074163779616356, -0.047528285533189774, -0.024414649233222008, -0.013571555726230145, 0.028944138437509537, 0.02126636542379856, 0.04491586983203888, 0.02529747225344181, 0.0343802310526371, -0.023141490295529366, 0.01263768132776022, 0.0008407028508372605, -0.025054333731532097, -0.0009238929487764835, 0.0037381290458142757, 0.010003677569329739, -0.030216166749596596, 0.035907432436943054, 0.0047738440334796906, 0.041314080357551575, 0.020289039239287376, -0.01761295273900032, -0.024472016841173172, -0.06671612709760666, -0.03540107607841492, 0.016534892842173576, 0.029042400419712067, 0.04219389706850052, -0.03839618340134621, 0.025997746735811234, 0.0189729705452919, -0.0678548663854599, 0.0027510393410921097, 0.10053623467683792, -0.010982802137732506, -0.01614525355398655, -0.0872587189078331, -0.03896346688270569, -0.002299031475558877, -0.015977997332811356, 0.05066903680562973, 0.005990421399474144, 0.0013640325050801039, 0.03138327971100807, 0.032928455621004105, 0.00941090751439333, -0.03584786131978035, 0.006214989814907312, 0.021716760471463203, 0.06716211885213852, 0.007226900197565556, -0.02969539724290371, 0.0022688244935125113, 0.05825675651431084, 0.0731964260339737, -0.000009807070455281064, -0.03969031944870949, -0.09175705909729004, 0.017897292971611023, 0.039223577827215195, 0.03407096117734909, -0.019739074632525444, -0.010713932104408741, 0.005343462806195021, 0.006438129581511021, 0.06562326103448868, -0.013732805848121643, 0.03511470556259155, -0.02056775987148285, -0.0018869619816541672, -0.05520632863044739, 0.023077342659235, -0.04831527918577194, 0.021483637392520905, -0.005253998562693596, 0.05103624612092972, -0.01577593758702278, -0.02498912625014782, -0.05493953451514244, 0.0030784879345446825, -0.010032884776592255, 0.02603466995060444, -0.026553139090538025, -0.005632264073938131, 0.0071535673923790455, -0.0010479736374691129, -0.010134712792932987, -0.07541459053754807, -0.024262111634016037, 0.021849963814020157, 0.021747762337327003, 0.01188303530216217, 0.02272235043346882, -0.0061492775566875935, 0.004851621109992266, 0.005514643155038357, -0.01898784749209881, -0.028498776257038116, -0.024700989946722984, 0.02840227633714676, 0.02653197944164276, -0.009492596611380577, 0.04588710144162178, 0.04642598703503609, 0.009272852912545204, 0.0009815399535000324, -0.002592953620478511, 0.023439602926373482, -0.04556266963481903, 0.006437209900468588, -0.021889016032218933, -0.0038803010247647762, -0.036852672696113586, 0.03525790944695473, -0.031189853325486183, 0.07559040933847427, -0.00040393383824266493, -0.04970087483525276, -0.036922380328178406, 0.028478479012846947, -0.006832918152213097, -0.05785705894231796, 0.01772167906165123, 0.03338288515806198, -0.023372488096356392, -0.005093964282423258, -0.04323989897966385, -0.03686920553445816, 0.02010527439415455, 0.03238166496157646, -0.005375543609261513, 0.0201761182397604, 0.00740827014669776, -0.006851273123174906, 0.013761342503130436, -0.022969994693994522, 0.038444314152002335, 0.004555622115731239, -0.0037139789201319218, 0.01309269666671753, -0.040347155183553696, -0.006064026616513729, 0.00004002432251581922, -0.020021626725792885, 0.0331471748650074, -0.07379893213510513, 0.0394078753888607, -0.005295590031892061, 0.021023698151111603, -0.05101586505770683, -0.05446956306695938, 0.018837234005331993, 0.007413849234580994, -0.013192211277782917, -0.027587637305259705, 0.02744128368794918, -0.00466644624248147, -0.030798139050602913, 0.006422554608434439, 0.05455996096134186, -0.022829702123999596, -0.016283664852380753, -0.005012440495193005, -0.02417166531085968, 0.08790814131498337, 0.01960396207869053, 0.021841146051883698, 0.031145451590418816, 0.003739546984434128, -0.03376230224967003, -0.031334925442934036, 0.05931134521961212, -0.04648582637310028, 0.0026906165294349194, -0.037248071283102036, -0.023006273433566093, 0.0410781130194664, -0.04148949310183525, -0.03562331199645996, 0.02088220790028572, 0.015199020504951477, 0.02490720897912979, -0.013966242782771587, 0.002380208345130086, -0.007030368782579899, -0.013982553035020828, 0.010792682878673077, 0.016684245318174362, 0.006212902255356312, -0.032191451638936996, 0.018181297928094864, 0.014646811410784721, -0.018948297947645187, 0.007782808970659971, 0.019225042313337326, -0.02070215530693531, 0.005475257523357868, -0.003488953225314617, -0.03867678344249725, 0.06805209815502167, 0.015462749637663364, 0.01777864247560501, 0.021475626155734062, 0.0080063845962286, -0.010601602494716644, -0.004763907752931118, -0.02444840595126152, -0.05462157726287842, 0.07608503848314285, 0.019809473305940628, 0.06760087609291077, 0.04689272120594978, 0.009781137108802795, -0.022027498111128807, -0.03154083341360092, -0.018319472670555115, 0.0015041559236124158, -0.007446772884577513, 0.015360221266746521, -0.012117047794163227, 0.01858019270002842, -0.0015792269259691238, -0.007846388965845108, -0.0007067911792546511, 0.03952290862798691, 0.03769552707672119, 0.04699891805648804, 0.003505855333060026, 0.004288800060749054, -0.06947890669107437, 0.010449466295540333, -0.019749213010072708, 0.020966842770576477, -0.0073593370616436005, 0.02074679732322693, 0.06567759811878204, 0.025994742289185524, -0.0010852303821593523, -0.04491531848907471, 0.012672059237957, -0.058697521686553955, 0.017471574246883392, 0.02671351097524166, -0.022443590685725212, 0.04319319874048233, 0.02626720629632473, 0.055599045008420944, 0.0022023124620318413, 0.016417715698480606, -0.0029513444751501083, -0.06501082330942154, -0.020301606506109238, -0.034686438739299774, -0.03721169754862785, 0.028401874005794525, -0.015827111899852753, -0.047297153621912, 0.015727205201983452, -0.02734820917248726, 0.03151413053274155, 0.0042927563190460205, 0.040377095341682434, -0.03669065982103348, 0.052678730338811874, 0.015342500060796738, -0.028001388534903526, 0.00916280597448349, 0.0012241265503689647, 0.1355847716331482, 0.0878305733203888, 0.0551973320543766, -0.008395747281610966, 0.023244189098477364, 0.019501127302646637, 0.01440311037003994, -0.03583364561200142, 0.012796356342732906, 0.018532628193497658, -0.014473935589194298, 0.01568601280450821, 0.021182041615247726, -0.0040011052042245865, -0.03299720957875252, 0.06583939492702484, -0.00401045149192214, 0.0015015611425042152, 0.023292476311326027, 0.03006652742624283, -0.014162404462695122, 0.005179379601031542, -0.04369291663169861, 0.02255137264728546, -0.03131105750799179, -0.03747488185763359, 0.0020413328893482685, -0.011618654243648052, 0.023174233734607697, -0.012454538606107235, -0.014802524819970131, 0.028365783393383026, 0.02769165299832821, 0.01654701493680477, -0.03350723162293434, 0.008390271104872227, -0.022069433704018593, -0.017646586522459984, -0.010433162562549114, 0.003587903454899788, 0.03954262658953667, -0.028572609648108482, 0.007640597876161337, -0.01915864460170269, -0.0712280422449112, -0.013570829294621944, -0.06324063241481781, 0.03134522587060928, -0.008229339495301247, 0.03053976595401764, 0.016687238588929176, 0.017453815788030624, -0.004134755581617355, -0.03568115457892418, -0.0066558257676661015, -0.017434915527701378, 0.03927113860845566, -0.02106650359928608, -0.022813517600297928, -0.05983217805624008, 0.028797905892133713, 0.011222191154956818, 0.023734847083687782, 0.011451799422502518, -0.0026399055495858192, -0.010717888362705708, 0.00802770908921957, 0.0456010065972805, -0.02890932373702526, -0.028821242973208427, -0.014401485212147236, 0.0016222086269408464, -0.0547587051987648, -0.004775892943143845, 0.020169930532574654, -0.008618553169071674, 0.029170585796236992, 0.021456260234117508, -0.032731056213378906, -0.033535100519657135, -0.04479827731847763, 0.009052055887877941, -0.024247251451015472, 0.012490848079323769, -0.020270466804504395, -0.01576095074415207, 0.03926937282085419, 0.022423138841986656, 0.014802423305809498, 0.03113194927573204, -0.016664886847138405, 0.02722446247935295, 0.03235814347863197, -0.0027707016561180353, -0.009797729551792145, -0.0021519099827855825, -0.04009130969643593, 0.03264196962118149, -0.035490214824676514, 0.05056893080472946, 0.015420249663293362, 0.014100774191319942, 0.0033301750663667917, 0.01791028119623661, 0.0025760773569345474, -0.0010171742178499699, 0.003918415866792202, -0.05293230339884758, -0.006036368198692799, 0.01764911226928234, -0.0009209085837937891, -0.04264364391565323, -0.06232264265418053, -0.021592192351818085, -0.007711067795753479, -0.0047237505204975605, 0.0048534683883190155, -0.027715682983398438, 0.018173884600400925, -0.04674100875854492, 0.04466339945793152, -0.035735469311475754, -0.001976986648514867, -0.043986208736896515, 0.006578976288437843, -0.011048931628465652, -0.023972969502210617, 0.005932467989623547, 0.00008396792691200972, 0.005734746344387531, -0.007386063225567341, 0.013454288244247437, -0.006296846084296703, 0.026722244918346405, 0.002453799592331052, 0.01124795526266098, -0.03719395026564598, 0.04089111089706421, -0.017615970224142075, 0.0019176419591531157, 0.03268956393003464, -0.06327537447214127, -0.03651825711131096, 0.03179207816720009, 0.0008692260016687214, 0.011675993911921978, -0.018327882513403893, -0.01339318323880434, -0.02134092152118683, 0.016978470608592033, -0.0043759895488619804, -0.007249911781400442, -0.015499225817620754, 0.0075065214186906815, -0.004530657082796097, 0.05236430838704109, 0.007616404443979263, 0.016721338033676147, -0.025760171934962273, 0.028928037732839584, 0.025260144844651222, 0.028092170134186745, -0.01625448651611805, -0.013235184364020824, 0.0003638582129497081, 0.008829941973090172, 0.000366325955837965, -0.024855483323335648, 0.0825997069478035, 0.030955573543906212, -0.0035827469546347857, 0.018947100266814232, -0.04039469361305237, -0.006475385278463364, -0.04629415273666382, -0.009685952216386795, 0.01022903248667717, -0.005806084256619215, 0.0253946203738451, -0.050304558128118515, 0.004355788696557283, 0.00485917879268527, -0.046273402869701385, 0.013397294096648693, -0.02352183125913143, -0.05199909955263138, -0.00917800422757864, 0.009376191534101963, 0.03779992088675499, -0.0025277389213442802, 0.04909788817167282, 0.012606064788997173, -0.031756069511175156, 0.021147044375538826, 0.0067458185367286205, 0.02134709805250168, 0.0006642105290666223, 0.03154051676392555, 0.037657927721738815, -0.05657559260725975, 0.028974376618862152, -0.047469448298215866, -0.03328141197562218, 0.03499837592244148, -0.045037560164928436, 0.002997221890836954, 0.0136707229539752, 0.024242743849754333, 0.02049407735466957, 0.03938842937350273, -0.0039940387941896915, -0.043927114456892014, -0.037106554955244064, 0.034964513033628464, 0.032942239195108414, 0.05285826697945595, -0.01061518955975771, -0.007087595295161009, -0.007955938577651978, -0.029921485111117363, -0.04312675818800926, -0.008099475875496864, -0.02177288569509983, -0.02549608424305916, -0.029900794848799706, 0.0023907821159809828, -0.0058311051689088345, 0.012065947987139225, 0.013971918262541294, 0.004848340526223183, 0.029859185218811035, 0.014342043548822403, -0.004150131717324257, -0.024349110201001167, 0.02599482610821724, 0.0061195045709609985, -0.060619011521339417, -0.00553521141409874, 0.008330773562192917, -0.020126625895500183, -0.04364478215575218, 0.01314344722777605, 0.018177499994635582, -0.039591073989868164, -0.02187228947877884, 0.003308275481685996, 0.009449117816984653, 0.045238982886075974, -0.018402667716145515, 0.03421363979578018, 0.033828284591436386, -0.025742799043655396, -0.024213576689362526, -0.08297252655029297, 0.05810163542628288, 0.02559421956539154, -0.0340290442109108, -0.016852525994181633, 0.001694395556114614, -0.04660460352897644, 0.018144000321626663, 0.0666855201125145, 0.004368790425360203, 0.003795186523348093, -0.013101071119308472, 0.01696637086570263, -0.004279229324311018, -0.007753502577543259, 0.03745313733816147, -0.016412582248449326, -0.01201996486634016, 0.009607484564185143, -0.03137202560901642, -0.009303724393248558, 0.008356528356671333, -0.01497663464397192, -0.018709488213062286, 0.026454703882336617, 0.023789098486304283, 0.014251620508730412, 0.07490554451942444, 0.009354943409562111, -0.01988205686211586, 0.05329209566116333, 0.011403084732592106, 0.011065223254263401, 0.017481505870819092, -0.029397396370768547, -0.038893409073352814, 0.041917361319065094, -0.04321691393852234, -0.01743103563785553, 0.005253789480775595, 0.03893544152379036, 0.015782197937369347, -0.07485227286815643, -0.02056794986128807, 0.03563276678323746, -0.007719618733972311, 0.03000587970018387, 0.031205644831061363, 0.03994600102305412, 0.03458390384912491, -0.020472999662160873, 0.04776700213551521, 0.020299503579735756, 0.003275661962106824, -0.0009612389258109033, 0.004742181859910488, 0.03242378309369087, -0.011694161221385002, -0.03367706015706062, 0.022295435890555382, -0.041167113929986954, 0.040232401341199875, 0.010223251767456532, 0.044517453759908676, -0.008265187032520771, -0.013865661807358265, -0.011104886420071125, -0.008897456340491772, 0.02056485414505005, 0.041101038455963135, 0.01856227032840252, 0.044289346784353256, -0.02844633162021637, -0.016732268035411835, -0.04337967559695244, -0.0761028528213501, -0.05028056353330612, -0.0008626909111626446, 0.005573734175413847, 0.02330787107348442, 0.024755991995334625, 0.0008386005065403879, -0.011658959090709686, -0.00944518856704235, 0.06295084208250046, -0.038817889988422394, 0.028692452237010002, -0.012281805276870728, -0.013892505317926407, 0.027521658688783646, 0.011523783206939697, -0.07442868500947952, -0.032172996550798416, -0.00023534959473181516, 0.04150034114718437, 0.04340625926852226, -0.005595728754997253, -0.010830552317202091, -0.00787661038339138, 0.0019454254070296884, -0.07054191082715988, -0.004998698364943266, -0.05393066629767418, 0.010511326603591442, 0.035593025386333466, -0.02620929293334484 ]
<p>Is there a term(s) for calculating the variance or standard deviation from a value other than the mean?</p> <p><strong>Example:</strong></p> <p>If I have a set of estimates for jelly beans in a jar, calculating standard deviation and variance is an operation on the mean of those estimates. However, I also want to find the "standard deviation" of the distribution from the <em>actual</em> number of jelly beans in the jar. Is this still called <strong>standard deviation</strong> even though it's not the deviation from the mean? Is there a term or specific subject area for analysis of a distribution against an independent value like this?</p>
41,344
[ -0.04176190868020058, -0.0020873823668807745, -0.007561847567558289, -0.029740503057837486, 0.015987353399395943, 0.012614591047167778, 0.00511888787150383, -0.019253522157669067, 0.03120516985654831, -0.011598355136811733, 0.05859871581196785, 0.01722998358309269, 0.07679107785224915, 0.022090505808591843, 0.03923329338431358, 0.019489912316203117, -0.0034767549950629473, 0.03144780173897743, -0.016551556065678596, -0.03028499335050583, -0.015438157133758068, -0.022804617881774902, -0.0013001200277358294, 0.00010508373088669032, -0.018868718296289444, 0.04542585089802742, 0.03360053896903992, -0.009130195714533329, 0.004680335056036711, 0.028064513579010963, -0.05787036567926407, -0.029364630579948425, 0.02645636349916458, 0.026231208816170692, 0.019504349678754807, -0.02221047505736351, -0.011568550951778889, -0.02596910297870636, -0.01624308153986931, 0.014180364087224007, -0.043135251849889755, 0.004040678963065147, -0.016189439222216606, 0.004089823458343744, -0.025049002841114998, 0.025162851437926292, -0.016024921089410782, -0.03700900450348854, 0.011351844295859337, -0.027762720361351967, 0.06922192871570587, -0.007717111147940159, 0.04720998555421829, 0.0412449836730957, -0.021352138370275497, 0.03344270586967468, 0.04843481630086899, 0.04992229491472244, 0.0004595097852870822, -0.057594019919633865, -0.007215600926429033, -0.013940987177193165, 0.011237814091145992, -0.025091372430324554, -0.023707447573542595, 0.010996626690030098, -0.025008920580148697, -0.036313824355602264, 0.03885694220662117, 0.03304878622293472, -0.007155720144510269, 0.050220560282468796, 0.03219541907310486, -0.026393907144665718, 0.007855658419430256, -0.03520979732275009, 0.019152648746967316, 0.0017847871640697122, 0.02767951972782612, 0.02510734274983406, 0.03795895725488663, 0.0009415232925675809, 0.029586181044578552, -0.0014706299407407641, -0.014560161158442497, -0.019029084593057632, 0.08665891736745834, -0.0024844277650117874, -0.01197125855833292, 0.0180440004914999, 0.014041307382285595, -0.03709913417696953, 0.060510553419589996, -0.0018670581048354506, -0.05408794432878494, 0.025845015421509743, -0.006782082840800285, 0.016301292926073074, 0.012457773089408875, -0.0166421327739954, -0.0030438934918493032, -0.057911377400159836, 0.05701051652431488, 0.06882672756910324, -0.021314386278390884, -0.03062012791633606, -0.0046155997551977634, 0.009329407475888729, 0.00513097271323204, 0.02043255604803562, 0.0013637695228680968, -0.0015936787240207195, 0.008604978211224079, -0.0015180252958089113, 0.013249204494059086, 0.01931650936603546, 0.004574345890432596, 0.0010241148993372917, 0.03558439388871193, 0.04127122089266777, 0.04776567965745926, -0.028119519352912903, 0.009050573222339153, -0.009496990591287613, -0.05443161353468895, 0.038155291229486465, 0.03160121664404869, 0.00438646599650383, -0.07198133319616318, 0.05373996123671532, 0.005462163593620062, -0.007926288060843945, 0.052883293479681015, 0.014024329371750355, -0.002065723529085517, -0.011950473301112652, -0.05134664475917816, -0.08296827226877213, 0.03587576374411583, -0.028187373653054237, -0.014133134856820107, -0.044628847390413284, 0.002424000995233655, 0.03414745256304741, -0.002797139110043645, 0.048813145607709885, 0.04892956092953682, -0.0035793576389551163, 0.02304433099925518, 0.030748801305890083, 0.0026141279377043247, -0.011533929966390133, 0.02083309181034565, -0.0316474623978138, 0.01363606471568346, -0.04695969820022583, 0.018081635236740112, 0.004193468019366264, -0.013203638605773449, -0.00942973792552948, 0.04303232580423355, -0.027503136545419693, -0.004160731099545956, 0.02234509587287903, 0.04733646288514137, -0.04764321818947792, 0.06423773616552353, 0.025498928502202034, 0.024964449927210808, 0.0017843038076534867, 0.0033401090186089277, 0.024450868368148804, -0.0036441334523260593, 0.026125874370336533, 0.06372272968292236, -0.015717387199401855, -0.0222410187125206, 0.0064101442694664, 0.026511941105127335, 0.0013266924070194364, -0.03468862548470497, 0.00918554700911045, 0.0033103530295193195, 0.009542679414153099, -0.0026265110354870558, 0.05919821560382843, -0.014286397956311703, -0.021312443539500237, 0.048543188720941544, -0.051047418266534805, -0.009279942139983177, -0.06336565315723419, -0.01657717302441597, -0.01634557917714119, -0.02384324185550213, 0.014577729627490044, 0.023207129910588264, 0.0486624650657177, -0.04513205215334892, -0.009389734826982021, -0.01708402670919895, -0.0017135640373453498, 0.03490438312292099, -0.04286731779575348, -0.008904927410185337, 0.058242544531822205, 0.04149896278977394, -0.022865191102027893, 0.03345007076859474, -0.01956458017230034, -0.08331725001335144, -0.04525051638484001, -0.0395142026245594, 0.009975350461900234, 0.018573932349681854, -0.015726422891020775, 0.02016126736998558, -0.020671136677265167, -0.010005271062254906, 0.030595192685723305, -0.013760223053395748, 0.05629735440015793, 0.07046766579151154, 0.014930209144949913, 0.002833923324942589, 0.007055126596242189, 0.011265553534030914, 0.02319810353219509, -0.013056972995400429, -0.01815391704440117, -0.03636392578482628, 0.024625902995467186, 0.027700508013367653, 0.031667351722717285, -0.04938571900129318, 0.00034324388252571225, 0.05164342746138573, 0.004699224606156349, 0.03379020094871521, 0.020758241415023804, -0.025630638003349304, -0.014852600172162056, 0.0038211236242204905, 0.015584440901875496, 0.03678878769278526, 0.033793479204177856, 0.003517393721267581, 0.03882158547639847, 0.029163783416152, 0.04439219459891319, -0.0015603606589138508, 0.032923512160778046, 0.022115612402558327, -0.013366454280912876, 0.0033483586739748716, -0.026514088734984398, 0.035030607134103775, -0.016437392681837082, 0.03468697890639305, 0.03932465612888336, -0.011118782684206963, -0.006263833958655596, 0.01701219193637371, -0.0226892177015543, 0.0033045588061213493, 0.018463142216205597, 0.0001446133537683636, 0.004478910472244024, 0.011264478787779808, -0.019830282777547836, 0.0058237058110535145, -0.020928042009472847, 0.006518842652440071, -0.012961476109921932, -0.02038426697254181, -0.002264603739604354, -0.001202631858177483, 0.038967251777648926, 0.00928476732224226, -0.036335982382297516, -0.0241682268679142, -0.033136337995529175, 0.00264279474504292, -0.009518224745988846, -0.044825367629528046, -0.0021567698568105698, -0.02469087764620781, -0.04274049401283264, 0.02207757905125618, -0.012711435556411743, -0.013458105735480785, 0.05014955252408981, 0.013494922779500484, -0.0591726191341877, 0.021641703322529793, -0.013697328977286816, 0.027124177664518356, -0.020434970036149025, -0.012932863086462021, 0.04021305590867996, -0.04057314246892929, -0.006558873690664768, 0.052118562161922455, -0.05974825844168663, -0.05465929955244064, -0.06936004757881165, -0.0007503877277486026, 0.04597785323858261, -0.004667047876864672, 0.022368697449564934, 0.044997040182352066, -0.022558998316526413, -0.031842708587646484, -0.06437348574399948, -0.041899826377630234, -0.0059516457840800285, 0.02114018052816391, 0.026985498145222664, 0.028020566329360008, -0.015915144234895706, 0.08684215694665909, 0.0005783288506790996, -0.04824559763073921, -0.026209838688373566, 0.013673382811248302, -0.009179153479635715, -0.043985478579998016, -0.03221137821674347, -0.009963183663785458, 0.004320577252656221, 0.011753552593290806, 0.0351850762963295, 0.015890834853053093, 0.036090731620788574, 0.004676291719079018, -0.01926630735397339, -0.014179852791130543, -0.02357325702905655, -0.02477392926812172, 0.05821532383561134, 0.02949655055999756, -0.01567021571099758, 0.003156691789627075, 0.005796318873763084, 0.06274236738681793, -0.0002905552682932466, -0.0445900559425354, 0.020300962030887604, 0.005672971718013287, -0.02235216647386551, -0.0361630953848362, 0.0517764650285244, 0.028307737782597542, -0.00009751642937771976, -0.0005877933581359684, 0.007978982292115688, -0.02611376903951168, -0.03051432967185974, 0.023660767823457718, 0.04174179956316948, 0.06103609874844551, -0.02788010612130165, -0.04369380325078964, -0.018290691077709198, 0.014815566129982471, 0.006467796396464109, -0.005575267132371664, -0.016003774479031563, 0.056729137897491455, 0.032885290682315826, 0.004945160821080208, 0.010972064919769764, -0.053056102246046066, 0.020157726481556892, -0.08804160356521606, -0.007506483234465122, -0.026220204308629036, 0.04946433752775192, -0.02313259430229664, 0.05462376028299332, 0.02180241234600544, -0.00028464148635976017, 0.015412845648825169, -0.018885277211666107, -0.04669840261340141, 0.05262582749128342, -0.024060772731900215, -0.03303328901529312, -0.04267449676990509, 0.0004845152434427291, -0.002648022258654237, -0.047107912600040436, 0.04490458220243454, -0.010403458960354328, 0.029513783752918243, 0.0028232417535036802, -0.00027601851616054773, 0.003228301415219903, -0.02675086073577404, 0.009903894737362862, 0.009488041512668133, 0.024507762864232063, -0.06997731328010559, 0.03916182741522789, 0.03505435958504677, 0.009447382763028145, -0.030853264033794403, -0.05052383989095688, 0.007444831542670727, 0.0022312330547720194, 0.0350475087761879, 0.0022160152439028025, 0.05417684465646744, -0.023288287222385406, 0.03747941926121712, 0.04214675351977348, 0.06196752190589905, 0.013363383710384369, -0.028084661811590195, -0.02687210775911808, -0.0371028371155262, -0.0031605164986103773, 0.02539152465760708, -0.007905417121946812, 0.01334068737924099, 0.018000295385718346, 0.022810962051153183, 0.02662784606218338, -0.054810523986816406, 0.053178559988737106, 0.06477925926446915, 0.00429929606616497, -0.011585129424929619, 0.0007651309133507311, 0.0029412098228931427, -0.023282423615455627, -0.031035784631967545, 0.03403257951140404, 0.03852321207523346, 0.012447278015315533, 0.02208106964826584, 0.0316988080739975, -0.009115269407629967, -0.02518102340400219, -0.03446240350604057, 0.0023972850758582354, 0.011364969424903393, 0.00379278976470232, -0.011941885575652122, 0.021624086424708366, 0.051744863390922546, 0.011754916980862617, 0.012691240757703781, 0.011559704318642616, -0.09657333046197891, 0.01203874684870243, 0.05586715042591095, 0.038342855870723724, -0.053599677979946136, -0.0025147502310574055, -0.011470933444797993, 0.007866498082876205, 0.048551589250564575, -0.0444386750459671, -0.010203064419329166, -0.044657863676548004, 0.023742981255054474, 0.013720707967877388, -0.010331309400498867, -0.05852761119604111, 0.013738025911152363, 0.014728295616805553, 0.023961318656802177, -0.020916732028126717, 0.02490539848804474, -0.027906879782676697, -0.029342791065573692, 0.007853833958506584, 0.030400322750210762, -0.020544739440083504, -0.00009636953473091125, -0.006148319225758314, 0.06599268317222595, -0.029090600088238716, -0.09450291842222214, -0.012827369384467602, 0.03317464515566826, -0.042066365480422974, 0.044294413179159164, -0.016463011503219604, -0.042731717228889465, 0.016499152407050133, -0.020235072821378708, -0.008919580839574337, 0.007036830764263868, 0.002678964752703905, 0.05274210497736931, 0.0532761886715889, 0.05615060776472092, 0.0687413364648819, 0.01597789116203785, -0.0016350885853171349, 0.0029409851413220167, -0.028863366693258286, 0.03255680575966835, -0.041070785373449326, -0.04411787539720535, -0.046597372740507126, -0.04202881082892418, -0.05501972883939743, 0.047922831028699875, 0.01045055128633976, 0.029227521270513535, -0.01667778007686138, -0.0022568360436707735, 0.00006130489782663062, 0.02674357406795025, 0.020124588161706924, -0.02616208791732788, 0.005573572125285864, 0.018735140562057495, 0.008533154614269733, -0.02813175693154335, 0.02540908195078373, 0.01095665618777275, -0.0030283168889582157, 0.004358528647571802, -0.06489979475736618, 0.0005378571804612875, -0.05911704897880554, -0.03229397535324097, 0.03729017451405525, -0.015352534130215645, 0.060209501534700394, -0.007602605037391186, 0.03336404636502266, 0.01462544035166502, -0.055625155568122864, -0.03231363371014595, 0.017892081290483475, 0.011524124071002007, -0.00741564529016614, -0.0626404657959938, 0.04274984821677208, -0.0010567017598077655, -0.018325990065932274, -0.06432154029607773, -0.03196001797914505, -0.0056334733963012695, 0.019390767440199852, -0.02662384882569313, -0.028564343228936195, 0.004759893752634525, -0.011222588829696178, -0.03422020748257637, -0.03788791969418526, 0.006615513004362583, -0.007510575465857983, -0.018838180229067802, 0.010197264142334461, 0.014854521490633488, 0.06134946271777153, -0.028103100135922432, 0.007733572274446487, 0.004176147282123566, 0.02009454369544983, 0.009350758977234364, 0.03500097990036011, 0.026492267847061157, -0.02012483961880207, 0.0018895160173997283, -0.000985046848654747, -0.002292612800374627, 0.005491310264915228, -0.030842391774058342, 0.005318543408066034, 0.02889305166900158, 0.0010902940994128585, -0.02114337868988514, 0.01220631878823042, 0.031129244714975357, 0.006691405083984137, 0.011247487738728523, -0.023203516378998756, 0.00412099389359355, -0.019564351066946983, 0.04176756367087364, 0.017932308837771416, 0.033147335052490234, -0.0467473529279232, 0.0029502783436328173, 0.03292177990078926, -0.025652989745140076, 0.02063433639705181, 0.01857650652527809, -0.008889051154255867, 0.03194320946931839, -0.0014771053101867437, -0.00016904166841413826, 0.018309365957975388, 0.009806951507925987, -0.0244959257543087, -0.038253091275691986, -0.016089243814349174, -0.019624223932623863, 0.08381059020757675, -0.051754072308540344, 0.05906744673848152, 0.05789365991950035, 0.0034330077469348907, 0.015730980783700943, -0.062157049775123596, -0.0225319042801857, 0.012485644780099392, 0.015734195709228516, 0.05335304141044617, 0.0032821495551615953, 0.042326390743255615, 0.03346150368452072, 0.04299886152148247, -0.030588746070861816, 0.03564010187983513, -0.003924286458641291, 0.03229489549994469, 0.0036931000649929047, -0.025257442146539688, -0.04938668757677078, 0.031910594552755356, -0.03861171379685402, 0.01036815531551838, -0.04108605906367302, -0.020623736083507538, 0.05266715958714485, -0.006836131680756807, -0.0019589653238654137, -0.059635911136865616, -0.008256591856479645, -0.05186302587389946, 0.016224784776568413, 0.005968254059553146, -0.012910127639770508, 0.0067049008794128895, -0.06047362834215164, 0.03031010366976261, -0.07203647494316101, 0.025203155353665352, -0.048193737864494324, -0.07583655416965485, -0.008743812330067158, -0.014260605908930302, -0.005017561838030815, 0.02505744993686676, -0.0012519963784143329, -0.02295079454779625, 0.011310679838061333, -0.016150888055562973, 0.0486028753221035, 0.02666069008409977, 0.036781370639801025, -0.020828742533922195, 0.07343979924917221, -0.013633343391120434, 0.02588295377790928, -0.001910314429551363, -0.021712318062782288, 0.10022562742233276, 0.0191457848995924, 0.029887018725275993, -0.02852894365787506, -0.010896805673837662, -0.04850386828184128, -0.001804808620363474, 0.015915175899863243, -0.00948706828057766, -0.0179490614682436, 0.036272548139095306, 0.048089414834976196, 0.07254616171121597, 0.012229581363499165, -0.035168904811143875, 0.056957341730594635, -0.03460213541984558, -0.018197141587734222, 0.014788087457418442, -0.006988708395510912, -0.011437077075242996, -0.005925140343606472, -0.06078091636300087, 0.020574087277054787, 0.01855718158185482, -0.02582891844213009, -0.04808734729886055, -0.011479752138257027, 0.021085135638713837, 0.02714376337826252, -0.024938073009252548, 0.02141776867210865, 0.015612252987921238, 0.006947326473891735, -0.02465343102812767, -0.022051867097616196, 0.04386601597070694, -0.03878481313586235, 0.010382789187133312, 0.04252632334828377, 0.01863151602447033, -0.01422075740993023, 0.026263399049639702, 0.006870202720165253, -0.0377039909362793, -0.024857647716999054, -0.016850901767611504, 0.020992107689380646, -0.01594940759241581, 0.022000238299369812, -0.039047349244356155, -0.021398359909653664, -0.011865625157952309, -0.027011185884475708, -0.009777980856597424, -0.023243555799126625, 0.012845506891608238, -0.03214188665151596, -0.03537364676594734, -0.04186895117163658, 0.030960364267230034, -0.032694220542907715, 0.020487764850258827, 0.030224591493606567, -0.002070266753435135, -0.020966827869415283, -0.006035400088876486, 0.026805825531482697, 0.01260671578347683, -0.034202758222818375, -0.014191942289471626, -0.016353515908122063, 0.007042521610856056, 0.034396689385175705, -0.009967402555048466, -0.005801607389003038, 0.03368702903389931, -0.00010827506048372015, -0.006598050240427256, -0.019195247441530228, -0.045017682015895844, 0.058119699358940125, -0.0335514210164547, 0.014885563403367996, -0.04971219226717949, 0.011352808214724064, 0.028616618365049362, 0.0454883947968483, 0.044051676988601685, 0.015323352999985218, -0.004677936434745789, 0.07583782821893692, 0.04020011052489281, -0.05067707970738411, -0.0015679310308769345, 0.0029297161381691694, -0.022585295140743256, -0.01336576696485281, -0.0034778709523379803, 0.05874679610133171, 0.05746045336127281, 0.023814955726265907, -0.02005971595644951, 0.011137221939861774, 0.008738572709262371, 0.00977404322475195, -0.002819310873746872, -0.042715366929769516, -0.015389494597911835, 0.006679878570139408, -0.005299634300172329, -0.01789015345275402, 0.0035873763263225555, -0.01988198608160019, -0.03420798107981682, -0.007841763086616993, 0.05265717953443527, -0.016302209347486496, 0.0006677244091406465, -0.014954580925405025, 0.014234253205358982, -0.017182670533657074, 0.028808800503611565, -0.01702403835952282, -0.05343843623995781, 0.01544902753084898, -0.014158256351947784, -0.008344695903360844, 0.024785799905657768, 0.001195751829072833, -0.0035148472525179386, 0.031146643683314323, 0.03959297761321068, 0.03019079566001892, 0.019089382141828537, 0.00689249113202095, -0.0064034475944936275, 0.022266728803515434, -0.014943737536668777, 0.011021491140127182, 0.08805353194475174, -0.05738531053066254, -0.036802832037210464, 0.03781557083129883, 0.010617585852742195, 0.029036933556199074, 0.051586881279945374, -0.0054812016896903515, -0.02165830135345459, 0.00048506222083233297, -0.028277777135372162, -0.03940244019031525, -0.019604181870818138, -0.03665190562605858, -0.019939212128520012, 0.009481128305196762, 0.011430960148572922, -0.004183346405625343, -0.02803952433168888, 0.00564549257978797, 0.030887087807059288, -0.0066462368704378605, -0.0018140323227271438, 0.03898504003882408, 0.05463811010122299, -0.005759099032729864, 0.005154000595211983, 0.028875911608338356, 0.005141259171068668, 0.06143100559711456, -0.040193602442741394, 0.029335660859942436, -0.010049642063677311, 0.006082447245717049, -0.08129826933145523, -0.012107664719223976, -0.0013926350511610508, -0.015730706974864006, 0.025238588452339172, -0.07341068983078003, 0.011835036799311638, 0.01837821863591671, -0.06697531044483185, 0.013095359317958355, -0.050551921129226685, -0.049390826374292374, 0.0002532250655349344, -0.013389548286795616, 0.0024202007334679365, 0.02809956483542919, 0.0020704977214336395, 0.015698064118623734, 0.029714204370975494, 0.03696376457810402, 0.023677580058574677, -0.03235067054629326, -0.037481002509593964, -0.01201347354799509, 0.01029648445546627, -0.07298791408538818, 0.006777234375476837, -0.04825576767325401, -0.056687939912080765, 0.046051423996686935, -0.021069927141070366, -0.0024512002710253, -0.0035785906948149204, -0.001899614930152893, 0.00009017942647915334, 0.021670520305633545, 0.023981789126992226, 0.0032304388005286455, -0.0459190309047699, 0.023599207401275635, 0.008391579613089561, 0.03274372220039368, -0.020096955820918083, -0.03408195450901985, 0.037666205316782, -0.03071736730635166, -0.04212349280714989, 0.019292794167995453, -0.026211049407720566, -0.059598490595817566, 0.007180177606642246, -0.001988668693229556, 0.033517442643642426, -0.037960294634103775, 0.02974054589867592, -0.03126153722405434, 0.032784707844257355, 0.04811719059944153, 0.003863624297082424, -0.05589355155825615, 0.005867152474820614, 0.012973199598491192, -0.037181973457336426, 0.006068691611289978, -0.0032493246253579855, -0.04422277957201004, -0.05915210396051407, 0.0005831975722685456, -0.012646359391510487, -0.006740991957485676, -0.003643944626674056, -0.011539837345480919, -0.035188350826501846, 0.03137080371379852, -0.02901691198348999, 0.002285740105435252, 0.02362009510397911, -0.020500101149082184, 0.010456113144755363, -0.04703124985098839, 0.07106360048055649, 0.049999840557575226, -0.03058856539428234, -0.04054005816578865, 0.011835640296339989, -0.0356266163289547, -0.01432697381824255, 0.05950949341058731, 0.02018691413104534, 0.015537622384727001, 0.014044521376490593, 0.019234485924243927, 0.009281334467232227, -0.056729018688201904, 0.02553142048418522, -0.0024451203644275665, -0.023793714120984077, -0.009473941288888454, 0.009267015382647514, -0.02228817529976368, -0.0017540378030389547, 0.012645058333873749, 0.013678216375410557, -0.01451696828007698, -0.018723471090197563, -0.022088028490543365, 0.04576275125145912, 0.017354052513837814, -0.030687479302287102, 0.03474308177828789, -0.013372684828937054, -0.01605183258652687, 0.02338031865656376, -0.009834980592131615, -0.03182235360145569, -0.004947957117110491, -0.0025225928984582424, -0.04092131555080414, -0.03566877543926239, 0.0154388677328825, 0.005191582255065441, -0.019934676587581635, -0.04136449098587036, 0.04609733074903488, -0.05159894749522209, -0.019269807264208794, 0.04152105003595352, 0.03620108217000961, 0.026651686057448387, 0.023208074271678925, -0.022877803072333336, 0.009629465639591217, -0.019318940117955208, 0.01727997697889805, 0.03251314163208008, 0.03255719691514969, 0.008459898643195629, 0.01955261267721653, -0.02074071392416954, 0.008939146995544434, -0.0014552291249856353, 0.018537793308496475, 0.05131028592586517, 0.003825877560302615, -0.03176463022828102, -0.01387947890907526, 0.0044891443103551865, 0.03705834969878197, -0.006051121279597282, -0.027158522978425026, 0.04270447418093681, -0.009864081628620625, -0.008450481109321117, -0.03631962090730667, -0.007518717087805271, -0.0018782500410452485, -0.0458763986825943, -0.0036242788191884756, 0.019401412457227707, 0.013031136244535446, -0.0033372275065630674, -0.010147533379495144, 0.01624351367354393, 0.04937629774212837, -0.04979443922638893, 0.06708960980176926, -0.03221377730369568, 0.007089425344020128, -0.04246407747268677, -0.018087128177285194, -0.012397386133670807, 0.013647489249706268, 0.007367745507508516, 0.026873743161559105, 0.048532579094171524, 0.001562410732731223, -0.0293098334223032, 0.015519390814006329, 0.03616835176944733, -0.07439491152763367, -0.02942262776196003, -0.025546425953507423, -0.004967952147126198, -0.01607511006295681, -0.03866589441895485 ]
<p>Objective is to predict a car's retail value based on the characteristics of mileage, make, model, engine size, interior style, and cruise control.</p> <hr> <h2>Price</h2> <p>The price of the vehicle </p> <hr> <h2>Cylinder</h2> <p>4,6,8</p> <hr> <h2>Liter</h2> <p>How many liters the engine is</p> <hr> <h2>Doors</h2> <p>4 or 2 door</p> <hr> <h2>Cruise control</h2> <p>1 if the car has, 0 if it does not</p> <hr> <h2>Leather</h2> <p>1 if the car has, 0 if it does not</p> <hr> <h2>Make</h2> <p>Buick, Cadillac, Chevrolet, Pontiac, SAAB, Saturn</p> <hr> <h2>Model</h2> <p>Century, Lacrosse, Lesabre, Park Avenue, CST-V, CTS, Deville, STS-V6, STS-V8, XLR-V8, AVEO, Cavalier, Classic, Cobalt, Corvette, Impala, Malibu, Monte Carlo, Bonneville, G6, Grand Am, Grand Prix, GTO, Sunfire, Vibe, 9_3, 9_3 HO, 9_5, 9_5 HO, 9-2X AWD, Ion, L Series</p> <hr> <h2>Trim</h2> <p>Sedan 4D, CX Sedan 4D, CXL Sedan 4D, CXS Sedan 4D, Custom Sedan 4D, Limited Sedan 4D, Special Ed Ultra 4D, DHS Sedan 4D, DTS Sedan 4D, Hardtop Conv 2D, LS Hatchback 4D, LS Sedan 4D, LT Hatchback 4D, LT Sedan 4D, SVM Hatchback 4D, SVM Sedan 4D, Coupe 2D, LS Coupe 2D, LS Sport Coupe 2D, LS Sport Sedan 4D, Conv 2D, SS Sedan 4D, LS MAXX Hback 4D, LT MAXX Hback 4D, MAXX Hback 4D, LT Coupe 2D, SS Coupe 2D, GXP Sedan 4D, SE Sedan 4D, SLE Sedan 4D, GT Sedan 4D, GT Coupe 2D, GTP Sedan 4D, AWD Sportwagon 4D, GT Sportwagon, Sportwagon 4D, Linear Conv 2D, Linear Sedan 4D, Aero Conv 2D, Aero Sedan 4D, Arc Conv 2D, Arc Sedan 4D, Arc Wagon 4D, Linear Wagon 4D, Aero Wagon 4D, Quad Coupe 2D, L300 Sedan 4D</p> <hr> <h2>Type</h2> <p>Sedan, Convertible, Hatchback, Coupe, Wagon</p> <hr> <p>I was just wondering how I should set up a model for this data set?</p> <p>This is what I was thinking so far:</p> <p>Model (dummy variables for Doors, Cylinder, Make, Model, Trim, and Type)</p> <p>Price = Mileage + Make_bui + Make_Cad+Make_Che + Make_Pon + Make_Saa + Make_Sat + Cylinder + Liter + Doors + Cruise + Leather</p>
37,451
[ -0.02314041741192341, -0.024750934913754463, 0.0006370171322487295, 0.04785068705677986, 0.022411659359931946, 0.01069517433643341, -0.031371794641017914, -0.03228616714477539, 0.04592331126332283, -0.020670415833592415, 0.022904548794031143, 0.03687198832631111, -0.002147627528756857, 0.05682658776640892, 0.00801354181021452, 0.025073425844311714, 0.010658023878932, -0.011334977112710476, 0.002669119741767645, 0.01805511862039566, -0.004682005383074284, -0.025650594383478165, 0.0007216318044811487, -0.004353889264166355, -0.038468923419713974, 0.049590352922677994, 0.04889458790421486, -0.03521360829472542, 0.0024188226088881493, 0.006072906777262688, -0.014797975309193134, 0.010567190125584602, 0.029100850224494934, 0.05648891255259514, -0.0080025065690279, 0.037319496273994446, 0.0010531628504395485, -0.031852882355451584, -0.005576625466346741, 0.019469128921628, 0.011513630859553814, 0.006165456026792526, 0.024449961259961128, 0.0487913154065609, 0.0017387672560289502, 0.016309909522533417, -0.011259308084845543, -0.009609253145754337, -0.013708332553505898, -0.07803080976009369, 0.09528496116399765, -0.00871280301362276, -0.007716174237430096, 0.009911269880831242, -0.027571069076657295, -0.005260510370135307, 0.022318454459309578, 0.07535044848918915, -0.006484919227659702, -0.061673615127801895, -0.004689574707299471, -0.022033320739865303, -0.00010528574057389051, -0.02963458001613617, -0.02974570542573929, 0.011123469099402428, 0.006632878445088863, -0.016138572245836258, 0.024398991838097572, 0.0013694314984604716, 0.0069570825435221195, -0.004224739503115416, 0.02668297477066517, 0.02615201286971569, 0.035406600683927536, -0.022227905690670013, 0.012113399803638458, 0.04448474943637848, 0.047815416008234024, 0.006584657356142998, 0.0153370825573802, 0.008554310537874699, -0.005227029323577881, -0.0014511095359921455, 0.07230254262685776, -0.0059910910204052925, 0.04801775887608528, 0.013267450034618378, 0.017258530482649803, 0.04250316694378853, 0.02304142341017723, 0.005156346596777439, 0.03054303675889969, 0.00023666706692893058, 0.011270677670836449, 0.026124482974410057, 0.005790692288428545, -0.0069151767529547215, 0.015988526865839958, -0.0452876053750515, -0.01858520321547985, 0.00317616225220263, -0.004353128373622894, 0.015393832698464394, -0.006165252532809973, -0.03039717860519886, -0.011838788166642189, -0.05282393842935562, 0.005144725553691387, -0.004568495787680149, -0.01757921278476715, 0.024270521476864815, 0.0005745421512983739, -0.0075897411443293095, -0.017454711720347404, -0.054340578615665436, -0.0379389189183712, -0.03490390628576279, 0.00990312546491623, 0.01764019764959812, 0.025699637830257416, -0.06184570863842964, -0.025649771094322205, -0.0031382290180772543, -0.033853597939014435, 0.003263491205871105, -0.006003153044730425, 0.008003050461411476, 0.01764308102428913, 0.03560579940676689, 0.0061823902651667595, -0.03127284348011017, 0.028401512652635574, -0.03000376932322979, 0.03074837476015091, 0.000576414109673351, -0.09027876704931259, -0.06405865401029587, 0.004865239840000868, -0.01661078818142414, 0.011454103514552116, -0.005275902803987265, 0.019305244088172913, -0.0025001431349664927, 0.022581318393349648, -0.01194747630506754, 0.03151635453104973, 0.07224550098180771, 0.026815539225935936, 0.011270738206803799, 0.0031428940128535032, -0.022308802232146263, -0.041251495480537415, 0.011501572094857693, -0.002924758940935135, -0.027665982022881508, 0.0032634874805808067, 0.0062627424485981464, -0.018744857981801033, -0.014384805224835873, -0.009874556213617325, -0.00658798823133111, -0.0273970365524292, 0.04490850493311882, 0.020622599869966507, -0.02967887930572033, 0.030958790332078934, 0.012060129083693027, 0.019920602440834045, -0.008974835276603699, -0.013326596468687057, 0.01867424137890339, 0.013450794853270054, 0.0021559742745012045, 0.033291030675172806, 0.026997776702046394, -0.031125929206609726, -0.022551704198122025, 0.007906201295554638, -0.008086194284260273, -0.06406106054782867, -0.06883104145526886, -0.03256119787693024, 0.014859918504953384, 0.005928087513893843, 0.014370369724929333, 0.007010220550000668, 0.006479554809629917, 0.030649321153759956, -0.026037687435746193, -0.04307800158858299, -0.03494349494576454, 0.015169714577496052, 0.029342906549572945, -0.039551571011543274, -0.011123140342533588, -0.016191929578781128, 0.02652803435921669, 0.0012112363474443555, -0.01030865591019392, -0.009121177718043327, 0.048149317502975464, 0.04267638921737671, -0.05343231186270714, 0.001111919991672039, 0.05915507301688194, 0.04855314642190933, -0.06963493674993515, 0.03258705884218216, -0.020891651511192322, -0.05363869667053223, -0.001620796974748373, -0.025519372895359993, -0.012831236235797405, -0.02672266960144043, 0.006147852633148432, 0.024836814031004906, -0.011939777061343193, 0.015138406306505203, 0.039514247328042984, -0.04536759480834007, 0.04197254404425621, 0.08564823120832443, 0.0037364137824624777, 0.01952989585697651, -0.027819715440273285, -0.052192796021699905, 0.048456765711307526, -0.05026622116565704, 0.020431896671652794, -0.039036206901073456, -0.008301392197608948, 0.02138637937605381, 0.03572263941168785, -0.031234875321388245, 0.014159423299133778, 0.08031242340803146, 0.0333571583032608, 0.03235187754034996, 0.004594789817929268, -0.0181827861815691, 0.003182559972628951, 0.02503194473683834, -0.02158837579190731, 0.05086486414074898, 0.004514795728027821, 0.030044538900256157, 0.048400457948446274, 0.04059002920985222, -0.004561868961900473, 0.0387304313480854, 0.08797317743301392, 0.03229917213320732, -0.0019137094495818019, -0.04028741642832756, -0.014672775752842426, 0.044302746653556824, -0.00890098325908184, -0.013756402768194675, 0.04598749801516533, 0.013631906360387802, -0.001861953060142696, 0.010425824671983719, -0.016203217208385468, -0.006014017853885889, 0.06164168938994408, -0.0017983777215704322, 0.019068807363510132, 0.02675202675163746, -0.01837635412812233, 0.06461723893880844, -0.0032933936454355717, 0.019319133833050728, -0.027793262153863907, 0.007966719567775726, 0.039651986211538315, -0.03254389017820358, 0.013061917386949062, 0.004076049197465181, -0.05224580317735672, 0.003995462320744991, -0.016784898936748505, -0.02862446755170822, -0.04298655688762665, -0.07516133785247803, -0.030199937522411346, -0.016550982370972633, -0.0021421448327600956, 0.05066078156232834, 0.04762326553463936, -0.06151663511991501, 0.0836787223815918, -0.019409047439694405, -0.05078402906656265, -0.034169506281614304, -0.004074416123330593, 0.03470408916473389, -0.0654664933681488, -0.005051538813859224, 0.015845978632569313, 0.016318481415510178, -0.0426994189620018, -0.013679268769919872, -0.04924752190709114, -0.010372607037425041, 0.0041819666512310505, -0.03381487727165222, -0.008824334479868412, 0.033304959535598755, 0.011306554079055786, 0.026293780654668808, -0.027693478390574455, 0.013338115066289902, -0.07463952153921127, -0.05129991099238396, 0.04575665667653084, -0.018654977902770042, 0.05053209140896797, -0.006056324578821659, -0.01979651488363743, 0.07282538712024689, 0.03911735862493515, -0.014074046164751053, -0.0208002720028162, -0.029628826305270195, -0.035685788840055466, -0.03758908808231354, -0.00652798917144537, 0.013949722982943058, -0.009049964137375355, 0.008090565912425518, 0.016501951962709427, 0.008903431706130505, 0.04348484054207802, -0.018698466941714287, -0.0030013963114470243, 0.012674225494265556, -0.029791662469506264, -0.006628542672842741, 0.058217622339725494, 0.027802597731351852, -0.03967241942882538, 0.034844253212213516, -0.01828538067638874, 0.03288290649652481, 0.00819226261228323, -0.06837929040193558, -0.003694778075441718, -0.010936007834970951, -0.008740582503378391, -0.008402968756854534, 0.010306178592145443, 0.011957766488194466, -0.04899190738797188, -0.07404552400112152, -0.004142847377806902, 0.02746928110718727, 0.009743805974721909, 0.0027514316607266665, 0.022061128169298172, 0.004194422159343958, -0.013246312737464905, -0.010160615667700768, 0.029878932982683182, -0.025758547708392143, 0.007431672886013985, -0.026081524789333344, 0.021263660863041878, 0.01994391530752182, 0.053743887692689896, 0.044478245079517365, 0.06211163476109505, -0.0024369130842387676, -0.0001460792700527236, -0.054426975548267365, 0.02377026155591011, -0.04638799652457237, 0.03581000119447708, 0.034437015652656555, 0.07805373519659042, 0.023905303329229355, -0.002612263197079301, 0.014811992645263672, -0.003743716049939394, -0.04082590714097023, 0.027012884616851807, 0.0040890988893806934, -0.004711740184575319, 0.0007512890733778477, -0.054184094071388245, -0.01562538370490074, -0.036889802664518356, 0.004725070204585791, 0.01950378715991974, 0.02810388058423996, -0.023959485813975334, -0.004334914032369852, 0.039309900254011154, -0.016234733164310455, -0.027082262560725212, -0.010830811224877834, 0.04673538729548454, 0.02299932949244976, 0.0029115600045770407, 0.06293085217475891, -0.008702359162271023, -0.014296392910182476, -0.03537362813949585, 0.010366877540946007, 0.005353209562599659, 0.053707219660282135, 0.006979630794376135, -0.023017290979623795, -0.015432830899953842, 0.016231417655944824, 0.007775879930704832, 0.023389093577861786, 0.033680424094200134, 0.024856064468622208, -0.014912071637809277, -0.029987681657075882, -0.02958601526916027, 0.007302028592675924, -0.03172793984413147, 0.015019653365015984, -0.002959562698379159, 0.04038950800895691, -0.007928992621600628, 0.003907192498445511, 0.01381598599255085, 0.07106322050094604, 0.04170425236225128, -0.013626784086227417, -0.01472051627933979, 0.0025685864966362715, 0.002540020737797022, -0.010889395140111446, 0.003278181655332446, 0.04620769992470741, 0.005226125009357929, -0.029439091682434082, -0.01560848020017147, -0.029463890939950943, -0.05970676615834236, 0.016788622364401817, -0.003970070276409388, 0.025237681344151497, -0.019561151042580605, 0.01890520378947258, 0.028470907360315323, 0.024229781702160835, 0.02882348746061325, 0.009109687060117722, -0.03450912609696388, -0.1251363605260849, -0.005404728464782238, 0.0006999708130024374, 0.05905057117342949, -0.01788337156176567, -0.05877041071653366, -0.0250267181545496, -0.012668590061366558, -0.0028155974578112364, -0.03591035678982735, 0.042649783194065094, 0.009754706174135208, 0.030370598658919334, -0.026657596230506897, -0.013723323121666908, -0.018612509593367577, 0.022085081785917282, -0.0327143669128418, 0.035585351288318634, -0.0339510515332222, -0.04013790190219879, -0.025947267189621925, 0.024187922477722168, 0.026675067842006683, 0.005673074629157782, -0.05504725128412247, -0.004718292038887739, -0.023803936317563057, 0.012778003700077534, -0.04121360555291176, -0.01572943665087223, -0.00916283018887043, 0.003918047994375229, -0.020786620676517487, 0.042389098554849625, 0.002206801436841488, -0.03033100813627243, 0.0011361382203176618, 0.0029504757840186357, -0.01711248606443405, -0.00722598098218441, -0.013836032710969448, 0.00790348183363676, 0.01127146277576685, 0.023316165432333946, 0.0251217819750309, 0.04890410602092743, -0.025185957551002502, 0.01217346079647541, -0.05673857778310776, -0.027334704995155334, 0.020808685570955276, -0.04590318351984024, -0.03150014206767082, -0.023564409464597702, -0.057248566299676895, -0.007934466935694218, -0.017485298216342926, 0.04103967547416687, -0.078765869140625, 0.030385315418243408, -0.0017850939184427261, 0.017295654863119125, -0.015614147298038006, -0.021343989297747612, -0.03868575394153595, -0.03550383821129799, -0.012524038553237915, 0.022629156708717346, 0.014642760157585144, -0.025534620508551598, 0.015016796067357063, -0.01327559445053339, -0.020963184535503387, 0.012745526619255543, 0.007642839569598436, 0.000422417011577636, -0.0005522314459085464, -0.015821579843759537, 0.042561329901218414, 0.00009735163621371612, 0.014826781116425991, 0.035301048308610916, -0.03169279545545578, -0.01737760379910469, 0.020756257697939873, 0.036189280450344086, 0.04240013659000397, -0.0016559951473027468, 0.06701525300741196, 0.008618403226137161, -0.013372337445616722, -0.013147269375622272, 0.027522435411810875, 0.02242260053753853, 0.008333530277013779, -0.007581109646707773, -0.0014922127593308687, 0.00831164512783289, -0.011353196576237679, -0.046842727810144424, -0.007961174473166466, 0.026085074990987778, 0.00013899894838687032, 0.03782060742378235, 0.02770400419831276, -0.03174012154340744, 0.08982701599597931, 0.044585540890693665, -0.004300916567444801, -0.0022003641352057457, -0.011412721127271652, -0.01351082418113947, 0.008636265993118286, -0.006334563251584768, -0.038320280611515045, -0.006078627426177263, -0.022660251706838608, -0.002735080197453499, 0.05070693418383598, -0.008253472857177258, 0.008024183101952076, -0.033960264176130295, 0.01491595059633255, -0.012040543369948864, -0.030865684151649475, -0.00515134260058403, -0.016985179856419563, -0.04303654655814171, -0.021804045885801315, -0.01042015478014946, -0.024918673560023308, 0.003174218814820051, -0.035363759845495224, -0.02052297443151474, -0.0034504367504268885, 0.014613213017582893, 0.058891940861940384, 0.0009362244745716453, 0.014093576930463314, -0.005592534318566322, -0.03841417282819748, 0.03853727504611015, 0.038471415638923645, 0.004103990271687508, 0.024385923519730568, 0.030965985730290413, -0.017456496134400368, -0.026056449860334396, -0.039431262761354446, -0.023235918954014778, 0.03976837918162346, -0.004991623107343912, 0.02020411007106304, 0.05190442502498627, 0.006016748026013374, 0.03347606584429741, -0.03690405189990997, 0.004699394106864929, 0.011935669928789139, 0.02551211602985859, 0.058216750621795654, 0.021869247779250145, -0.01183097530156374, 0.017950095236301422, -0.04019026458263397, 0.029352182522416115, -0.023535992950201035, 0.020503748208284378, -0.0037917369045317173, -0.014916517771780491, -0.07847961038351059, -0.025265999138355255, 0.053426019847393036, -0.02848834916949272, 0.018712546676397324, -0.026425497606396675, 0.03452474996447563, 0.0286557637155056, 0.028561007231473923, 0.016277728602290154, -0.046047721058130264, 0.00657567149028182, -0.047131940722465515, 0.05894433334469795, 0.04699680581688881, -0.01354908011853695, 0.0039238594472408295, 0.07598154246807098, 0.025288604199886322, -0.026885297149419785, 0.049659546464681625, -0.012394272722303867, -0.05568713694810867, 0.010887361131608486, 0.011427565477788448, -0.027553027495741844, 0.041147470474243164, 0.04644019156694412, 0.027915190905332565, 0.04084298014640808, -0.016188936308026314, 0.006888205651193857, -0.003666636301204562, 0.013442311435937881, 0.00585519103333354, 0.04845508560538292, -0.03929569944739342, -0.034273721277713776, -0.010168514214456081, -0.0034245960414409637, 0.17930489778518677, 0.06861594319343567, 0.012690921314060688, -0.013652156107127666, -0.0038665079046040773, 0.00043502412154339254, -0.002773270709440112, 0.003222488798201084, -0.012109476141631603, 0.009642125107347965, 0.02595178596675396, 0.043005507439374924, 0.02286391705274582, 0.007715387735515833, -0.005726957693696022, 0.010329178534448147, -0.03424333781003952, 0.01617247797548771, 0.02327706292271614, 0.053289495408535004, -0.016135795041918755, 0.027415284886956215, -0.03335552290081978, -0.01746714487671852, -0.0016529842978343368, -0.0004975308547727764, -0.04189026728272438, -0.026555927470326424, 0.02639048360288143, -0.043478209525346756, -0.006958550773561001, 0.006743984296917915, 0.007929571904242039, 0.012332169339060783, -0.007575537543743849, -0.014912641607224941, 0.025755563750863075, -0.00845683179795742, -0.018965555354952812, 0.032317593693733215, 0.014399959705770016, -0.018886994570493698, -0.014147421345114708, 0.031826894730329514, -0.054608363658189774, 0.00026008227723650634, -0.05689488723874092, 0.012893437407910824, -0.008840575814247131, -0.003487496403977275, -0.04705857113003731, 0.04771840199828148, 0.008854996412992477, -0.03995034471154213, -0.01786518283188343, 0.02045518346130848, 0.06821825355291367, -0.02879905328154564, -0.06003911793231964, -0.036940112709999084, 0.001530257286503911, -0.024294229224324226, -0.011238882318139076, -0.0035062977112829685, 0.024584682658314705, -0.023325888440012932, -0.053084686398506165, 0.036436986178159714, -0.015965811908245087, 0.015554343350231647, -0.023874815553426743, -0.04671766608953476, -0.04382982477545738, -0.012811318039894104, 0.006139745004475117, 0.035055339336395264, -0.007971641607582569, 0.02277679182589054, 0.016900312155485153, -0.06101927533745766, -0.057445380836725235, 0.017058374360203743, 0.0001842666242737323, -0.014467059634625912, -0.0629025250673294, 0.020444869995117188, 0.041194118559360504, 0.022326739504933357, -0.0022215477656573057, 0.03179612755775452, 0.005714749451726675, 0.0658743754029274, 0.00697604613378644, -0.04394622892141342, -0.0049336994998157024, 0.03162774071097374, -0.04144272953271866, 0.003461868967860937, 0.03485160693526268, 0.08564993739128113, 0.02721242420375347, -0.03262899070978165, -0.02843211591243744, 0.028859013691544533, -0.05230547487735748, 0.022853421047329903, 0.026135316118597984, -0.0402652882039547, -0.01731143891811371, 0.008439539931714535, 0.017391052097082138, -0.01910209096968174, -0.0007544804248027503, -0.013059452176094055, -0.0687510147690773, -0.02641037106513977, -0.0031735741067677736, -0.025700662285089493, 0.03350182622671127, -0.0020097941160202026, 0.03753038868308067, -0.0342787466943264, 0.006789420731365681, -0.016243014484643936, 0.03115953505039215, -0.004868139047175646, -0.022908182814717293, -0.010902201756834984, 0.005430087447166443, -0.005580957513302565, 0.0032528347801417112, 0.00652348855510354, 0.017012882977724075, -0.0010329252108931541, -0.028421301394701004, -0.03324167802929878, -0.01781475730240345, 0.04127335548400879, -0.032169539481401443, 0.0006471078959293664, -0.008738696575164795, -0.0280903410166502, 0.007249270565807819, -0.023919476196169853, -0.023043092340230942, 0.049609407782554626, 0.011999307200312614, 0.02959221787750721, -0.012056132778525352, 0.04527297988533974, -0.05937338247895241, 0.008715761825442314, 0.0044144741259515285, 0.03677637502551079, 0.04810216650366783, -0.02514656074345112, -0.01901082694530487, 0.04601956158876419, -0.032731108367443085, -0.012643473222851753, 0.03711235895752907, 0.008481559343636036, 0.04009787738323212, 0.015607841312885284, 0.002405781066045165, 0.00524533586576581, 0.002571456367149949, 0.005720381624996662, 0.04547416418790817, -0.010373440571129322, 0.01763065904378891, 0.07216911762952805, -0.016558727249503136, -0.009794863872230053, -0.08071388304233551, -0.04120096191763878, 0.05137012526392937, 0.014355664141476154, 0.08465857058763504, -0.0423838309943676, 0.02050534076988697, 0.03376113995909691, -0.02225753851234913, 0.019827986136078835, 0.01406084280461073, 0.019972501322627068, -0.03779786080121994, -0.030715757980942726, 0.024763692170381546, 0.018994439393281937, 0.02561410702764988, -0.010847826488316059, 0.04014894366264343, 0.007230859249830246, 0.013961437158286572, -0.03359577804803848, -0.0060020009987056255, 0.011691314168274403, -0.019248757511377335, -0.044496212154626846, 0.013639072887599468, -0.0442860908806324, 0.0030903557781130075, 0.017193477600812912, -0.023874009028077126, 0.039924755692481995, -0.002982771024107933, -0.009264716878533363, 0.02799006551504135, 0.030205095186829567, 0.02627544291317463, 0.03881160542368889, -0.017395751550793648, -0.005755626130849123, 0.0035767212975770235, 0.01957947015762329, 0.006582189816981554, 0.03097926266491413, 0.01887277141213417, -0.01395841222256422, -0.01688678003847599, 0.028135953471064568, -0.04134061187505722, 0.019708743318915367, -0.011506332084536552, -0.010905703529715538, -0.027386223897337914, -0.039544425904750824, -0.0225501861423254, -0.023083699867129326, -0.012268250808119774, 0.025992559269070625, -0.000394291098928079, 0.010448533110320568, -0.00895015336573124, 0.006837998516857624, -0.03151495009660721, 0.03537081554532051, 0.03216032683849335, -0.0289470162242651, -0.05462587997317314, 0.023154305294156075, 0.010377064347267151, -0.014584382064640522, -0.016101237386465073, 0.004548234865069389, -0.005481412634253502, 0.038642700761556625, 0.02216145023703575, -0.016111688688397408, 0.036895621567964554, -0.039617303758859634, 0.017370305955410004, -0.10385743528604507, 0.036103252321481705, -0.0021642742212861776, -0.06927108019590378, -0.030213460326194763, -0.030430205166339874, -0.023718083277344704, 0.0069452510215342045, 0.03960604965686798, -0.02416125498712063, -0.0230887271463871, -0.03705333173274994, 0.03463241085410118, -0.018277093768119812, -0.014011627994477749, 0.01557260099798441, -0.0021495376713573933, -0.005335724446922541, -0.01958911493420601, 0.01727796345949173, -0.0009371692431159317, 0.007195041049271822, 0.04262971505522728, -0.046641722321510315, 0.03159378841519356, -0.0042731924913823605, -0.014416364021599293, -0.007505242247134447, 0.013574868440628052, -0.017426328733563423, 0.045715540647506714, 0.003015405498445034, 0.0003746045986190438, 0.023988738656044006, 0.018616337329149246, -0.04381178691983223, 0.005492504686117172, -0.018362443894147873, -0.0412248857319355, -0.018712118268013, -0.01166405901312828, 0.020755723118782043, -0.03593740612268448, -0.018047891557216644, 0.037261899560689926, 0.0033247037790715694, 0.0006369191687554121, 0.08457260578870773, 0.031156999990344048, 0.04599074646830559, 0.0015821746783331037, 0.030489042401313782, -0.04105013236403465, -0.04904395714402199, 0.013936631381511688, -0.01825341023504734, 0.017655614763498306, -0.017551062628626823, 0.0010545229306444526, 0.06383153051137924, -0.004212172701954842, 0.009168769232928753, -0.05185481533408165, 0.03627047687768936, -0.008126150816679, 0.009934484027326107, 0.01878482662141323, -0.012825426645576954, 0.06791645288467407, 0.02162114530801773, -0.01483586709946394, 0.040394172072410583, -0.03565356880426407, -0.0039658332243561745, -0.056757405400276184, 0.042539458721876144, -0.028928125277161598, -0.004866506904363632, -0.02804054133594036, -0.032257694751024246, 0.01683148927986622, 0.013774735853075981, 0.03246569260954857, 0.006976252421736717, 0.04474642872810364, 0.005262312479317188, 0.004239078611135483, -0.007001121528446674, -0.004626352805644274, -0.04776371642947197, 0.002450773725286126, -0.002605538349598646, -0.020800448954105377, -0.012804054655134678, 0.029554050415754318, 0.030009988695383072, -0.07613526284694672, -0.008842474780976772, -0.0065642050467431545, 0.017274586483836174, -0.04762120172381401, -0.021717557683587074, -0.03465434908866882, -0.00037366896867752075, -0.031010078266263008, -0.06612272560596466 ]
<p>I'm looking for resources (articles, books or just suggestions) on cyclostationary time series parameter estimation. I have a 2D signal of that sort, which forms a grid. </p>
36,002
[ 0.009207014925777912, -0.04303155466914177, -0.009755898267030716, -0.010727429762482643, 0.0578848272562027, -0.002070973627269268, -0.007217240519821644, -0.02222415991127491, 0.03352592512965202, -0.038245148956775665, 0.018627215176820755, 0.06464554369449615, 0.020965220406651497, 0.007429427932947874, 0.018657898530364037, -0.010937703773379326, -0.018201187252998352, 0.023026300594210625, -0.02704276144504547, -0.029817819595336914, 0.002563831629231572, 0.013404428027570248, -0.019518664106726646, 0.013066946528851986, -0.020412901416420937, 0.04917028173804283, 0.06685744971036911, -0.00490811700001359, 0.0025650765746831894, 0.10274000465869904, -0.04357835277915001, -0.02138705551624298, -0.028952931985259056, 0.05104246735572815, 0.03329065442085266, -0.008754138834774494, -0.0525200292468071, -0.05191512405872345, -0.02289535105228424, 0.03330555558204651, -0.041035979986190796, -0.009939409792423248, -0.023148609325289726, 0.01763039082288742, -0.009653497487306595, 0.03162400424480438, 0.0006117720040492713, -0.016443457454442978, 0.003217879915609956, -0.03666549175977707, 0.10566640645265579, -0.008370506577193737, 0.020953990519046783, 0.0020536170341074467, 0.013781675137579441, 0.015244261361658573, 0.06349082291126251, 0.037708111107349396, -0.025313541293144226, -0.051864586770534515, -0.0233928132802248, -0.004061799496412277, 0.019947275519371033, -0.033342596143484116, -0.054450590163469315, 0.025289444252848625, 0.02211003750562668, -0.054960478097200394, 0.011772160418331623, -0.018755216151475906, 0.019642237573862076, -0.0030589248053729534, 0.04844793677330017, -0.0007414714782498777, -0.007433604449033737, -0.048708099871873856, 0.006905566435307264, 0.019982635974884033, 0.021125301718711853, -0.006775576155632734, 0.021517956629395485, 0.004081025253981352, -0.0013701021671295166, 0.011648171581327915, 0.0031167331617325544, 0.03027101419866085, 0.0866885706782341, -0.017113756388425827, 0.009340688586235046, 0.00699889799579978, -0.0067634196020662785, -0.027850426733493805, 0.023619504645466805, -0.013689261861145496, -0.05025459825992584, 0.0011807514820247889, 0.01692160591483116, 0.035831548273563385, 0.0038080920930951834, -0.03547490015625954, -0.019556483253836632, -0.03651364892721176, 0.0013861266197636724, 0.0520087331533432, -0.01807265542447567, 0.03203361853957176, -0.0059771002270281315, -0.00754844443872571, -0.05252223461866379, -0.0243369247764349, -0.030755290761590004, 0.009515396319329739, -0.021349560469388962, -0.008993069641292095, 0.0015565543435513973, 0.014253280125558376, -0.004398358054459095, -0.023919038474559784, 0.04555109888315201, 0.09697011113166809, 0.06351626664400101, -0.042725346982479095, -0.00858316384255886, -0.0431220717728138, -0.05437767878174782, 0.0003868628409691155, 0.013044694438576698, -0.040807731449604034, -0.06262343376874924, 0.05944054573774338, 0.035682015120983124, -0.04073148965835571, 0.011322923935949802, -0.030992917716503143, 0.017581332474946976, -0.011210031807422638, -0.06544464826583862, -0.06087559461593628, 0.039450619369745255, -0.03441460430622101, -0.006532825995236635, -0.06527236104011536, 0.031077252700924873, 0.0016168063739314675, 0.07106633484363556, -0.0205382052809, 0.017034854739904404, -0.0000526938347320538, 0.032150398939847946, 0.017152072861790657, -0.05291834473609924, -0.01284797117114067, -0.005811928305774927, -0.0234942939132452, -0.00976819172501564, -0.060559604316949844, 0.022393999621272087, 0.014330620877444744, -0.02318389341235161, -0.04183054342865944, 0.04742055758833885, 0.0505366325378418, -0.020412560552358627, 0.037121813744306564, 0.0036950279027223587, -0.024343490600585938, 0.05821681022644043, -0.03585651516914368, 0.006937794387340546, 0.011008505709469318, -0.0006991112604737282, 0.035250067710876465, 0.026727471500635147, 0.051742520183324814, 0.04167218506336212, -0.03675047308206558, -0.020638763904571533, 0.016877954825758934, -0.0010215772781521082, -0.0026240628212690353, -0.02165689691901207, -0.05258343368768692, 0.03343258425593376, 0.009211272932589054, 0.015489441342651844, 0.027380088344216347, -0.019226809963583946, -0.018405301496386528, 0.015232828445732594, -0.05122435837984085, 0.03125756233930588, -0.011666770093142986, 0.0020560980774462223, -0.032811544835567474, 0.010045944713056087, 0.0464775376021862, 0.010745215229690075, 0.03255636245012283, 0.0014539319090545177, -0.052498962730169296, -0.02346050925552845, -0.004138230811804533, 0.048501040786504745, -0.0337689109146595, -0.0036137818824499846, 0.02485492452979088, 0.015250164084136486, -0.02177298627793789, 0.04072955250740051, -0.04188831150531769, -0.039449796080589294, -0.01948150433599949, -0.0354943573474884, 0.025349145755171776, -0.007536065299063921, 0.004692446440458298, 0.00474608363583684, 0.009287049062550068, -0.024702126160264015, -0.0012485806364566088, -0.04762282222509384, 0.032769229263067245, 0.08193410933017731, 0.029650133103132248, -0.0062864371575415134, 0.012358910404145718, 0.025082239881157875, -0.0074836635030806065, -0.0037790010683238506, -0.022926529869437218, -0.04785552993416786, 0.03547210991382599, 0.06371724605560303, 0.023763958364725113, -0.03403567895293236, 0.00900240708142519, 0.045466113835573196, 0.051207076758146286, 0.02072319947183132, 0.004358725156635046, 0.005307857878506184, -0.015237591229379177, -0.010722353123128414, 0.0036092987284064293, -0.002185473218560219, 0.0003327678714413196, 0.04949778690934181, 0.012865961529314518, -0.00811539776623249, -0.0027239385526627302, -0.03773472085595131, 0.0225621797144413, 0.009795984253287315, 0.033423081040382385, -0.0012431188952177763, -0.01257840171456337, 0.02330292947590351, -0.020282607525587082, 0.0036598702426999807, -0.009857562370598316, -0.00032657841802574694, 0.027451444417238235, -0.005266509484499693, -0.0024662879295647144, 0.012234421446919441, 0.0043587940745055676, -0.02777394838631153, 0.017078109085559845, 0.04221421107649803, -0.03233536332845688, 0.023654669523239136, 0.0037527913227677345, -0.010035697370767593, -0.03447419032454491, -0.0479758158326149, 0.027082687243819237, 0.024114321917295456, 0.041678182780742645, -0.013254391960799694, -0.04109034687280655, 0.019586972892284393, -0.009763835929334164, 0.024261699989438057, 0.04018683359026909, -0.03966511785984039, 0.03863224759697914, -0.017222227528691292, -0.005014379974454641, 0.030168049037456512, -0.016999293118715286, 0.019796188920736313, -0.0006715540657751262, -0.007565311621874571, -0.04020702466368675, 0.003024772508069873, -0.03609302639961243, 0.03316860646009445, -0.044220395386219025, -0.009207977913320065, 0.04918484762310982, -0.031758636236190796, -0.03507206216454506, 0.06753681600093842, -0.059885602444410324, 0.002626588102430105, -0.03624456748366356, 0.01627865992486477, 0.011743216775357723, -0.02394849993288517, 0.010106229223310947, 0.029158348217606544, -0.03156255930662155, -0.00030457612592726946, -0.02230813540518284, -0.052140891551971436, -0.018531430512666702, 0.018102072179317474, 0.04696204140782356, 0.016831113025546074, -0.013106569647789001, 0.07010269165039062, 0.008093819953501225, -0.04402700066566467, -0.0018028785707429051, -0.006464784499257803, -0.018644746392965317, -0.050926003605127335, 0.031710948795080185, 0.022429855540394783, 0.0005383944953791797, 0.017549483105540276, 0.006503977347165346, -0.018817486241459846, 0.08568202704191208, 0.02175997756421566, -0.008992133662104607, 0.03869098424911499, -0.01566026546061039, 0.02250758931040764, 0.041563909500837326, 0.025042662397027016, -0.018049295991659164, -0.0074519007466733456, 0.005348219536244869, -0.0013768377248197794, 0.02480231039226055, -0.04153396934270859, -0.020885664969682693, -0.05480827018618584, -0.038056619465351105, -0.048960089683532715, 0.015886511653661728, -0.018232198432087898, 0.0035571621265262365, -0.008493351750075817, 0.06483533978462219, 0.0382310226559639, 0.028849026188254356, 0.01010810025036335, 0.038004517555236816, -0.005414394196122885, -0.004979306366294622, 0.00578024098649621, 0.0003935883578378707, -0.0024840214755386114, 0.04061976820230484, -0.03161899000406265, -0.003885968355461955, 0.041247908025979996, 0.001032564090564847, 0.019207235425710678, 0.013624581508338451, -0.03760123997926712, 0.018802275881171227, -0.08124867081642151, 0.01065786462277174, -0.017534583806991577, 0.040254492312669754, 0.00392066640779376, 0.044729337096214294, 0.0208952184766531, 0.001971920719370246, 0.03989158198237419, 0.027530306950211525, -0.06816872209310532, 0.013526378199458122, -0.01625959388911724, 0.017535418272018433, -0.02026093751192093, 0.010331658646464348, 0.024549078196287155, 0.0017742824275046587, 0.0005098473629914224, -0.016454586759209633, -0.0035084399860352278, -0.05623438209295273, 0.0016899468610063195, 0.005975131411105394, 0.0020808791741728783, -0.017159001901745796, 0.029988553375005722, 0.030243270099163055, -0.04671981558203697, 0.03828775882720947, 0.035729408264160156, -0.005975114647299051, -0.014583221636712551, -0.028565790504217148, 0.025366200134158134, 0.004241407383233309, 0.006662383209913969, 0.02365395985543728, 0.01855817809700966, -0.04016924649477005, 0.01963941566646099, -0.006656561512500048, 0.058133404701948166, 0.02666802518069744, -0.002920768456533551, 0.0024013975635170937, -0.033746227622032166, 0.0006461769808083773, 0.00786786898970604, 0.006261944305151701, 0.015079538337886333, -0.015398121438920498, 0.0738973394036293, -0.014204624108970165, -0.04021356999874115, 0.04418352246284485, 0.03731317073106766, -0.011344942264258862, 0.01266353391110897, -0.00008348315896000713, 0.0011382217053323984, 0.00008900403918232769, -0.014834621921181679, 0.009760446846485138, -0.01643461361527443, -0.02470054104924202, -0.003896294627338648, 0.00040746142622083426, 0.013345645740628242, -0.000953852548263967, 0.023903490975499153, 0.03611717000603676, 0.05932331830263138, -0.010114658623933792, -0.007301137316972017, 0.030090289190411568, 0.030666111037135124, 0.026614854112267494, 0.04333420470356941, -0.02194724977016449, -0.09536995738744736, 0.005465327296406031, 0.02672281488776207, 0.011763401329517365, -0.011429724283516407, -0.008520974777638912, -0.06217021867632866, -0.0425649918615818, 0.042837850749492645, -0.002981452038511634, 0.008871222846210003, -0.017195146530866623, -0.02524336613714695, -0.03187710419297218, 0.00628097215667367, 0.011772739700973034, -0.002947990084066987, 0.0017270693788304925, 0.02501663565635681, -0.018449338153004646, -0.033671267330646515, -0.033889900892972946, 0.004656259436160326, 0.02009754255414009, 0.014165511354804039, 0.006579502020031214, 0.004280445631593466, 0.02629726380109787, 0.046587519347667694, 0.00013378246512729675, -0.050849538296461105, 0.022911062464118004, 0.00000844029364088783, -0.00018299202201887965, 0.04341850057244301, 0.005267804488539696, -0.04379460960626602, -0.011795012280344963, -0.019680941477417946, -0.02517837844789028, -0.006557223852723837, -0.000383827748009935, 0.037960201501846313, 0.025074530392885208, 0.0070432513020932674, 0.05120759457349777, 0.05493606999516487, -0.016662834212183952, 0.03432290628552437, -0.004921901039779186, 0.0215668436139822, -0.03274739906191826, 0.012656372040510178, -0.016245080158114433, -0.01387458760291338, -0.03334833309054375, 0.040261805057525635, 0.00557447737082839, 0.04287833347916603, -0.0264893788844347, -0.02819153480231762, 0.00458255410194397, 0.09289584308862686, 0.0009103610063903034, 0.01516918744891882, 0.006369788199663162, 0.020470965653657913, -0.004914185032248497, -0.019534623250365257, 0.007551828399300575, -0.047215741127729416, -0.0022665937431156635, 0.02988344058394432, -0.011914323084056377, -0.00927241612225771, -0.06585317850112915, -0.039581287652254105, 0.014020495116710663, -0.01807127334177494, 0.08161566406488419, -0.025419000536203384, 0.011018270626664162, 0.038067784160375595, -0.0526159293949604, -0.010748950764536858, 0.01570933125913143, -0.004610118456184864, 0.037049513310194016, -0.046520818024873734, -0.015931379050016403, -0.006195040885359049, 0.02154959738254547, -0.058893509209156036, -0.04238639026880264, 0.054929058998823166, -0.003148849820718169, -0.0482124425470829, -0.05108874291181564, 0.03469563275575638, -0.022315656766295433, -0.03405815735459328, 0.0028077939059585333, -0.001864708261564374, 0.010936147533357143, -0.030148694291710854, 0.003311939537525177, 0.016116848215460777, 0.07410858571529388, 0.027339257299900055, 0.0043262033723294735, 0.028126586228609085, -0.01767672970890999, -0.036761075258255005, -0.014368575066328049, 0.03857478126883507, -0.02511141635477543, 0.03510221838951111, -0.0070937396958470345, 0.014428631402552128, 0.042411088943481445, -0.055737219750881195, -0.007001737132668495, 0.04282137006521225, 0.024444956332445145, 0.0018705480033531785, -0.06557437032461166, -0.013846066780388355, -0.06811551004648209, -0.003827317152172327, -0.022370032966136932, -0.019896773621439934, -0.026321982964873314, -0.003506232053041458, -0.02142249420285225, 0.013575037010014057, -0.024824563413858414, 0.007600438315421343, 0.04170779138803482, 0.021917954087257385, -0.009427128359675407, 0.01341377291828394, -0.03559909015893936, 0.002853231970220804, 0.017483605071902275, 0.037890709936618805, 0.057062771171331406, 0.02977273054420948, -0.03571626543998718, -0.060359008610248566, -0.03306959941983223, 0.031743887811899185, 0.06595258414745331, -0.0004627556190825999, 0.06568114459514618, 0.027214663103222847, 0.004656256642192602, -0.01613481156527996, -0.006699104327708483, 0.004661209881305695, 0.03237617015838623, -0.011336876079440117, 0.04566599428653717, 0.00787696335464716, 0.0250038243830204, -0.012242280878126621, 0.0010060748318210244, 0.023172738030552864, 0.015538991428911686, 0.02991190180182457, 0.0417606346309185, 0.02880409173667431, -0.016597039997577667, -0.042227309197187424, 0.018220270052552223, -0.023596199229359627, 0.0377727709710598, -0.024623829871416092, 0.04131946340203285, 0.0449894517660141, 0.05987456813454628, -0.03674604743719101, -0.008596646599471569, -0.014600412920117378, -0.043341781944036484, -0.01684030517935753, 0.0376436784863472, -0.031651370227336884, 0.017663665115833282, 0.030166473239660263, 0.05379202589392662, -0.015301819890737534, 0.03527042269706726, -0.013462894596159458, -0.0654880553483963, -0.023857614025473595, -0.00357541861012578, -0.04543052241206169, 0.0570237934589386, 0.033411554992198944, -0.024757709354162216, 0.0023653542157262564, -0.014932287856936455, 0.027705611661076546, -0.0027209464460611343, 0.045450203120708466, -0.045230716466903687, 0.09438293427228928, -0.0037165815010666847, -0.009414741769433022, -0.038250621408224106, -0.024494986981153488, 0.09748528152704239, 0.06299538165330887, 0.042495448142290115, -0.07726903259754181, 0.03312213718891144, 0.003716758219525218, 0.014354187995195389, -0.03228023648262024, 0.02722795307636261, 0.021480418741703033, 0.02244327776134014, 0.0529172457754612, 0.06186547875404358, 0.008210010826587677, -0.0013555216137319803, 0.029631024226546288, 0.014673098921775818, 0.0037047697696834803, 0.005916835740208626, 0.011980094015598297, -0.0021104919724166393, 0.006814774591475725, -0.0816839411854744, 0.031618956476449966, -0.031259216368198395, -0.027406413108110428, -0.06251652538776398, -0.041412465274333954, 0.040031712502241135, -0.022859087213873863, -0.03224143758416176, 0.020917601883411407, 0.03607168793678284, 0.023573460057377815, -0.0014954032376408577, 0.03255227208137512, 0.011637842282652855, 0.008824335411190987, 0.011076834984123707, 0.009598826989531517, 0.022190384566783905, -0.006285136565566063, -0.0010667787864804268, 0.006169518455862999, -0.004376352299004793, -0.022027673199772835, -0.04532559588551521, 0.03890576213598251, 0.00855112262070179, 0.011000905185937881, 0.015957945957779884, 0.03709831088781357, -0.0016308808699250221, -0.06426423043012619, -0.01863940805196762, -0.006764243822544813, 0.03364911675453186, -0.06352656334638596, -0.016820861026644707, -0.04891776666045189, 0.027851641178131104, -0.02960495837032795, 0.03557490557432175, 0.019749876111745834, -0.060476306825876236, -0.012904721312224865, -0.006269202567636967, 0.06243417412042618, 0.015041805803775787, -0.024858562275767326, 0.03189903497695923, -0.018768565729260445, -0.03182714432477951, -0.04855521023273468, 0.009793706238269806, -0.012370491400361061, 0.023389341309666634, 0.015206812880933285, -0.010592806152999401, 0.012128249742090702, -0.04686794430017471, -0.0008564343443140388, -0.003721362678334117, -0.0132161108776927, 0.0010087135015055537, -0.011423490941524506, 0.08280143141746521, 0.012857386842370033, -0.009261051192879677, 0.023119807243347168, -0.035520415753126144, -0.011522619053721428, 0.01805109903216362, -0.05306622013449669, 0.006487799342721701, 0.020420996472239494, -0.024686051532626152, 0.005116347223520279, -0.010865505784749985, 0.058083754032850266, 0.020439108833670616, 0.03043220564723015, -0.000673757866024971, 0.03433344513177872, -0.01748272404074669, -0.02369748055934906, -0.01580853760242462, -0.07572285085916519, -0.006412286311388016, -0.027348700910806656, 0.006722052115947008, -0.03940631076693535, -0.0074089402332901955, -0.03042827732861042, 0.017024213448166847, -0.011382387951016426, 0.023373566567897797, -0.08729638904333115, -0.0010120783699676394, -0.02005736529827118, -0.01709814928472042, -0.03777916729450226, 0.014352177269756794, -0.013208761811256409, -0.02765670046210289, -0.016381090506911278, -0.029628954827785492, 0.009287661872804165, -0.012974198907613754, -0.03340790048241615, -0.03274775668978691, 0.03696135804057121, -0.029115086421370506, 0.03533212095499039, 0.024737313389778137, 0.0023219462018460035, -0.014725795015692711, 0.03662237524986267, -0.02804678864777088, -0.012822499498724937, 0.05263086408376694, -0.02735651284456253, -0.02415510267019272, 0.012668010778725147, -0.005472602788358927, 0.013009797781705856, 0.02947394922375679, -0.026757657527923584, -0.011634222231805325, 0.029829658567905426, 0.005894191097468138, -0.0028506366070359945, -0.008473902940750122, 0.030619032680988312, 0.0018604291835799813, 0.0037169260904192924, 0.03607046231627464, -0.04766738414764404, -0.02123449184000492, 0.01229904219508171, 0.042084701359272, 0.023578638210892677, 0.00037794202216900885, 0.021819917485117912, 0.014324953779578209, 0.010370137169957161, -0.0005960700800642371, -0.02403596229851246, 0.04416107013821602, 0.015539352782070637, -0.02981789968907833, 0.01400226540863514, -0.007316626142710447, 0.016501158475875854, -0.0653449296951294, 0.03245801851153374, -0.0035848424304276705, 0.0007345731719397008, 0.04874256253242493, -0.0515255481004715, -0.03147353231906891, 0.03576476871967316, -0.03194884583353996, 0.010202700272202492, -0.014309342950582504, -0.021427247673273087, 0.005530741531401873, -0.03009427897632122, 0.0006990788970142603, 0.026035742834210396, 0.033347003161907196, -0.0037684838753193617, 0.02998919039964676, 0.013868769630789757, -0.0008347093826159835, 0.01683606207370758, 0.03449752554297447, 0.004185459576547146, 0.03237905353307724, -0.034818876534700394, 0.009603206068277359, -0.050223805010318756, -0.03727484494447708, 0.012049773707985878, -0.021967973560094833, -0.008697094395756721, -0.0334194116294384, 0.019388429820537567, -0.011489701457321644, 0.06554007530212402, 0.004496151115745306, -0.03343852981925011, -0.00500184390693903, -0.011453146114945412, 0.00627862336114049, 0.0030301513615995646, -0.019893081858754158, 0.011555175296962261, -0.0002105385938193649, -0.0015169510152190924, -0.006286472547799349, 0.015537405386567116, -0.03678015619516373, 0.009195244871079922, 0.016446957364678383, -0.03304564207792282, 0.01337326131761074, -0.004689204506576061, 0.04796941205859184, 0.00015284502296708524, -0.0005216180579736829, 0.008305788971483707, 0.01326393149793148, -0.010360095649957657, 0.0015916572883725166, 0.0058387406170368195, -0.06599684059619904, 0.056812312453985214, 0.005146250128746033, 0.0019847715739160776, -0.06771154701709747, -0.00926236342638731, 0.00890797097235918, -0.014489969238638878, -0.031959425657987595, -0.0007891500717960298, -0.004846382886171341, 0.04888371005654335, 0.03984913229942322, -0.003137424122542143, 0.013966809026896954, -0.008080342784523964, -0.00004660613922169432, -0.06412142515182495, 0.050722043961286545, 0.009127825498580933, -0.025266461074352264, -0.011290865018963814, 0.000012183598300907761, -0.004907489754259586, -0.006729248911142349, 0.04266085848212242, -0.05130058154463768, -0.0007249062764458358, -0.011439341120421886, 0.0049060555174946785, 0.015144727192819118, -0.057012833654880524, 0.03621792793273926, -0.015354561619460583, -0.061134155839681625, 0.031003085896372795, -0.06559623777866364, -0.000459139293525368, -0.015659302473068237, 0.021923189982771873, 0.024339964613318443, 0.045170411467552185, 0.012832734733819962, -0.01427860651165247, 0.02939590811729431, 0.01352707203477621, 0.0012025708565488458, 0.09240571409463882, -0.030824271962046623, 0.0003705139388330281, -0.005176150240004063, -0.030274750664830208, -0.07484563440084457, 0.04773079231381416, -0.04542974755167961, -0.005526183173060417, 0.013600746169686317, -0.004399530589580536, 0.011231977492570877, -0.03220017999410629, -0.03354324772953987, 0.02791433595120907, -0.045168474316596985, 0.012653243727982044, 0.06094484403729439, -0.005499287974089384, 0.018347973003983498, -0.0142536461353302, 0.035545237362384796, 0.05179284140467644, 0.024604272097349167, -0.006282198708504438, 0.018421022221446037, 0.01734853908419609, 0.013100305572152138, 0.0033337902277708054, 0.011043693870306015, -0.04847961291670799, 0.01339498907327652, -0.031145302578806877, 0.023464690893888474, -0.043781183660030365, -0.038022663444280624, 0.011620367877185345, -0.02822709269821644, -0.014383384957909584, -0.01654866337776184, -0.029209615662693977, 0.06331771612167358, -0.017847931012511253, -0.03671525791287422, -0.040066976100206375, -0.022163959220051765, -0.017619391903281212, -0.031043099239468575, -0.020515814423561096, 0.00604983838275075, -0.0024870375636965036, 0.04150187224149704, -0.016997238621115685, 0.000572716468013823, 0.0046399920247495174, -0.05269410088658333, 0.04182003065943718, -0.010196703486144543, 0.02510608173906803, 0.017013004049658775, 0.003794655669480562, -0.04777681455016136, -0.03831205144524574, 0.01959359459578991, 0.018913282081484795, -0.007977748289704323, -0.023823564872145653, -0.016220616176724434, 0.00892348401248455, 0.037484705448150635, -0.10091875493526459, -0.004439700394868851, -0.011342667043209076, 0.01392405666410923, 0.02203523740172386, 0.006859364453703165 ]
<p>I am using the <code>mda</code> package and in particular the <code>fda</code> routine to classify in term of gear a set of 20 trips. I preformed a flexible discriminant analysis (FDA) using a set of 151 trips. </p> <pre><code>FDAT1 &lt;- fda(as.factor(gear) ~ . , data =matrizR) </code></pre> <p>A total of 22 predictors were considered. 20 of the predictors are "numeric" and 2 are "factors/discrete" (with several levels, e.g. A,B,C and D). </p> <p>The resulting FDA rule was applied to the 20 trips and for the same predictors in order to predict the type of gear used. However a consistent error is occurring: </p> <pre><code>Error in polybasis(newdata, degree, monomial) %*% object$coef : non-conformable arguments </code></pre> <ul> <li>Is it possible that the problem is related to the 2 predictors that are discrete variables?</li> <li>Are there already available some routines to perform a discrete discriminant analysis considering continuous and discrete variables?</li> </ul> <hr> <p>When I 'traceback' this is the result: </p> <pre><code>6: predict.polyreg(object$fit, newdata) 5: predict(object$fit, newdata) 4: predict(object$fit, newdata) 3: predict.fda(FDAT1, matriz_vr) 2: predict(FDAT1, matriz_vr) 1: predict(FDAT1, matriz_vr) </code></pre> <p>Unfortunately, I'm not able to interprrt this... It is some specific error of my commands?</p>
73,594
[ 0.009465813636779785, -0.019894417375326157, -0.020123900845646858, 0.00879292469471693, 0.03190086781978607, -0.003050093771889806, -0.059750910848379135, -0.01257616188377142, 0.02204522304236889, -0.011728093959391117, 0.03940880298614502, 0.02542913146317005, 0.07707638293504715, 0.05094354599714279, 0.0070485579781234264, 0.028916295617818832, 0.008246309123933315, -0.002131722867488861, 0.033792853355407715, -0.015138053335249424, -0.012412081472575665, 0.013512363657355309, 0.007937183603644371, -0.011593648232519627, 0.02026006206870079, 0.013258279301226139, 0.048889029771089554, -0.005622521974146366, 0.015992579981684685, 0.014418638311326504, -0.030530625954270363, -0.04231336712837219, -0.006320734973996878, 0.00489812484011054, -0.010217423550784588, 0.02197878621518612, -0.006422950886189938, -0.030389800667762756, -0.008936449885368347, 0.047882284969091415, -0.021818915382027626, -0.009801364503800869, 0.004274902865290642, 0.05836533010005951, 0.03442464396357536, 0.022106867283582687, 0.025520432740449905, 0.02987746149301529, 0.09687747061252594, -0.026532627642154694, 0.09226222336292267, -0.05032198876142502, 0.020667890086770058, 0.016729429364204407, -0.05857372283935547, -0.0037175759207457304, 0.08029849827289581, 0.06901179254055023, -0.014971029944717884, -0.05596274510025978, -0.04980293661355972, -0.0705370232462883, -0.00855596549808979, -0.005160945933312178, -0.025589700788259506, 0.008235515095293522, -0.0014341798378154635, -0.03840940073132515, -0.0016520358622074127, -0.03668263182044029, 0.043346378952264786, 0.0017029070295393467, 0.02849229983985424, -0.03277658298611641, 0.030609719455242157, 0.020267294719815254, 0.006017826963216066, -0.002349535236135125, 0.04119341820478439, 0.0023298568557947874, -0.03258538618683815, 0.016461588442325592, -0.020193196833133698, 0.004718432202935219, 0.029660126194357872, -0.03390077129006386, 0.005014519672840834, -0.010831600986421108, 0.01043675560504198, -0.017082156613469124, -0.0010702169965952635, 0.00033023671130649745, 0.06945919990539551, -0.005079630762338638, -0.002396057592704892, 0.05739087611436844, 0.02278674952685833, 0.017696253955364227, -0.017692890018224716, -0.028167959302663803, 0.019137928262352943, -0.02182914689183235, 0.015437973663210869, 0.05352512747049332, -0.012627378106117249, -0.011378305964171886, -0.05988859757781029, -0.02858690731227398, -0.004427326377481222, -0.042985815554857254, 0.004177832510322332, 0.031402088701725006, 0.009981950744986534, -0.019982872530817986, -0.03364283964037895, 0.004183011129498482, -0.035915739834308624, 0.01400521770119667, 0.05433221533894539, 0.05841523036360741, 0.043328579515218735, -0.04253581911325455, 0.011062719859182835, -0.030036762356758118, -0.07937056571245193, -0.01811136305332184, 0.015973158180713654, -0.02171149104833603, 0.0041516926139593124, 0.027575429528951645, -0.0007069685379974544, -0.04741780832409859, 0.0497187077999115, -0.002420340199023485, -0.01730046421289444, -0.008392068557441235, -0.07723932713270187, -0.06531453132629395, 0.01190374419093132, -0.007434532046318054, -0.008040932938456535, -0.0619695782661438, -0.0017441969830542803, 0.014562288299202919, 0.07590623944997787, 0.0340333916246891, 0.06457899510860443, 0.024338871240615845, 0.01245918683707714, 0.001386404735967517, -0.044162433594465256, -0.0011441924143582582, -0.04959212616086006, 0.005115144420415163, -0.0494995154440403, -0.04290465638041496, 0.012419522739946842, 0.004788185469806194, -0.02759651094675064, 0.013755042105913162, 0.027618441730737686, -0.022236138582229614, -0.04671736806631088, -0.016656983643770218, -0.004740122705698013, -0.008498492650687695, 0.06192784011363983, -0.0015402587596327066, 0.030917616561055183, 0.02824820764362812, -0.007483751513063908, 0.05058564990758896, 0.002935984870418906, 0.04511633142828941, 0.05911389738321304, 0.021607641130685806, -0.017738768830895424, -0.012667903676629066, 0.014347192831337452, -0.005580355413258076, -0.015971943736076355, -0.03768646717071533, 0.0015410572523251176, -0.05698169395327568, -0.03328491747379303, 0.003092659404501319, 0.003936214372515678, -0.0111022824421525, 0.029932774603366852, -0.04824776202440262, -0.026270121335983276, -0.032995086163282394, -0.019863054156303406, -0.04545929282903671, -0.016224579885601997, 0.032562028616666794, 0.0012659940402954817, 0.03436402603983879, 0.005994563922286034, -0.007092573214322329, -0.0375826396048069, -0.023031065240502357, 0.05524730682373047, -0.021275687962770462, 0.0030565974302589893, 0.0017177800182253122, 0.07411312311887741, -0.02884192019701004, 0.05089489743113518, -0.0012858036207035184, -0.004839275032281876, 0.008823491632938385, -0.053621020168066025, 0.03407769277691841, -0.014472881332039833, -0.0062813530676066875, 0.039811983704566956, -0.004133705515414476, -0.0445389561355114, 0.05514722689986229, -0.05267638713121414, 0.03937169909477234, 0.10977863520383835, -0.0055183712393045425, -0.013702938333153725, -0.018791941925883293, -0.008520654402673244, 0.04562217369675636, -0.00865107960999012, -0.03851042315363884, -0.03281615674495697, -0.02208726853132248, 0.04360506311058998, 0.038500819355249405, -0.04270100221037865, 0.02586597017943859, 0.06550836563110352, 0.004234115593135357, 0.014182230457663536, 0.03995274379849434, 0.02827838808298111, -0.024119408801198006, 0.0408729612827301, 0.032489340752363205, 0.024394428357481956, 0.002635511802509427, 0.019304610788822174, -0.009450406767427921, 0.037638865411281586, -0.028617508709430695, 0.005977199412882328, 0.07444436103105545, -0.008784445002675056, 0.0029218881390988827, -0.018041182309389114, -0.019109681248664856, 0.05265980213880539, -0.0238506980240345, 0.042901698499917984, 0.04895732179284096, 0.034343887120485306, -0.03057515248656273, -0.0016765272011980414, -0.005196885671466589, 0.009407703764736652, 0.07020734995603561, -0.030734971165657043, 0.024147212505340576, 0.013234531506896019, -0.04974674805998802, -0.014283614233136177, -0.0368625707924366, -0.022417817264795303, -0.014415406621992588, 0.02155487984418869, -0.0015518369618803263, 0.01772826351225376, 0.03104589879512787, -0.020616328343749046, 0.031846750527620316, -0.002380924765020609, -0.026015765964984894, 0.028543878346681595, -0.011826804839074612, -0.02399945817887783, 0.010094599798321724, 0.001434558187611401, -0.004575206898152828, 0.032041072845458984, -0.007584582082927227, -0.04305063933134079, 0.03423479571938515, -0.043124206364154816, -0.04556897282600403, -0.04404821991920471, 0.018683990463614464, 0.020136035978794098, -0.035654742270708084, -0.05845440551638603, 0.01366452407091856, 0.04364693909883499, -0.019308604300022125, -0.032506413757801056, -0.029335981234908104, 0.022575819864869118, -0.009745500050485134, -0.0030416427180171013, 0.005758312530815601, -0.014838198199868202, 0.029188010841608047, 0.01724941097199917, 0.0004087580891791731, 0.01921076886355877, -0.07411901652812958, -0.061167363077402115, 0.011297515593469143, 0.022848064079880714, -0.0043335543014109135, -0.009026022627949715, 0.050040148198604584, 0.028695767745375633, 0.03554442152380943, -0.050338014960289, -0.0465894415974617, -0.0024083845783025026, -0.0597224235534668, -0.0338468924164772, -0.018355833366513252, 0.0007749760989099741, 0.02480177767574787, 0.02332061156630516, -0.017013372853398323, -0.0100215133279562, 0.057493697851896286, -0.0650545135140419, -0.015470728278160095, 0.028871286660432816, 0.022889243438839912, -0.00613015703856945, 0.028523026034235954, 0.04111010208725929, -0.017947755753993988, 0.01814291998744011, -0.02314699999988079, 0.017482539638876915, -0.0008001678506843746, -0.036435291171073914, -0.023036902770400047, 0.00641346862539649, 0.04044194519519806, -0.02007286250591278, 0.0013440659968182445, 0.01501675508916378, -0.06662805378437042, -0.013167454861104488, 0.0145187396556139, 0.03547924757003784, -0.04568812996149063, -0.008086387068033218, 0.04596839100122452, 0.02260712906718254, -0.013962766155600548, 0.003999230917543173, -0.010675502941012383, 0.0011866926215589046, 0.016847755759954453, -0.017989439889788628, -0.0005852870526723564, 0.04640057682991028, 0.021288864314556122, 0.04013771936297417, 0.03971751034259796, -0.039764150977134705, 0.04556594416499138, -0.06354086846113205, -0.005035618785768747, -0.05417719855904579, 0.07350854575634003, 0.002656226744875312, 0.018107013776898384, 0.01117696426808834, -0.010822614654898643, -0.024676181375980377, -0.0034728238824754953, -0.08389829099178314, 0.02345425635576248, -0.0033386501017957926, 0.01836848445236683, -0.004346428904682398, -0.027715696021914482, 0.009374326094985008, -0.002696648705750704, -0.011217567138373852, 0.023563839495182037, 0.028784651309251785, -0.049821652472019196, -0.013292811810970306, -0.002748739207163453, -0.016465947031974792, -0.0347362644970417, -0.007378790993243456, 0.03577706217765808, -0.0002610802766866982, 0.02151375450193882, 0.01777018792927265, -0.029574492946267128, 0.003140584332868457, -0.05486873537302017, 0.0022050458937883377, -0.002207086654379964, 0.04108170047402382, 0.000604287488386035, 0.037148334085941315, -0.0325995571911335, 0.00991773884743452, 0.0054825060069561005, 0.05149940401315689, 0.006128665991127491, -0.012542320415377617, -0.034058827906847, -0.03850487247109413, 0.002880134852603078, -0.002275014529004693, 0.001366680022329092, -0.035224687308073044, -0.03147469833493233, 0.0648733377456665, 0.018161403015255928, -0.04607081413269043, 0.035398781299591064, 0.04336830973625183, 0.03430566564202309, -0.04830993339419365, 0.00434758048504591, -0.016075165942311287, 0.005929962731897831, -0.026366164907813072, 0.023413440212607384, 0.0006390773341991007, 0.04450589790940285, -0.018923437222838402, 0.04130890965461731, -0.04255819693207741, -0.030213613063097, 0.02056499943137169, 0.0327054001390934, 0.04289202392101288, -0.011441758833825588, -0.008698835037648678, 0.012151506729424, -0.0004840809851884842, 0.028677746653556824, 0.001345688826404512, 0.030943946912884712, -0.0950322151184082, 0.010372713208198547, 0.00852111354470253, 0.08122502267360687, -0.020745398476719856, -0.027805890887975693, -0.04641938954591751, 0.0033967855852097273, 0.054137781262397766, -0.014928046613931656, 0.01842360757291317, -0.015160856768488884, 0.03325800225138664, -0.031060604378581047, -0.013613445684313774, -0.07203049212694168, -0.01440731156617403, 0.015584311448037624, 0.04764151945710182, 0.0026151107158511877, -0.0344865620136261, -0.02514522895216942, 0.05716954171657562, 0.027109980583190918, 0.03476996719837189, -0.017238108441233635, -0.0436776839196682, 0.02735617384314537, 0.0016287794569507241, 0.0077976626344025135, -0.026662321761250496, 0.019932597875595093, 0.010576976463198662, -0.002787611447274685, 0.06605897843837738, -0.018689816817641258, 0.03223581984639168, 0.002531802747398615, 0.005240046884864569, 0.004278765060007572, -0.03126361593604088, -0.03401564061641693, -0.0021858569234609604, -0.012637941166758537, -0.024814065545797348, 0.025829875841736794, 0.004873678088188171, -0.016998549923300743, -0.006552769336849451, -0.05774617940187454, 0.02089644968509674, 0.004265193827450275, -0.02700146846473217, -0.03586215153336525, -0.031228970736265182, -0.006130574736744165, 0.035258740186691284, -0.003116781357675791, 0.017737437039613724, -0.06020132079720497, -0.0010674837976694107, 0.01328964438289404, 0.053733427077531815, -0.05012771114706993, 0.01563005894422531, 0.00030881486600264907, -0.0076933675445616245, -0.022013742476701736, 0.014149046503007412, 0.026367301121354103, -0.017447270452976227, -0.005691954400390387, 0.016734665259718895, -0.01764683611690998, -0.001073397696018219, 0.0029545649886131287, -0.007252591662108898, 0.0076241097413003445, -0.008643309585750103, 0.024124953895807266, 0.005554609000682831, 0.05950243026018143, -0.016714708879590034, -0.05187569931149483, 0.015209467150270939, 0.027726462110877037, -0.009867505170404911, 0.009517914615571499, -0.019660571590065956, 0.03338482975959778, -0.020700860768556595, 0.031159155070781708, -0.05910450220108032, -0.08854538947343826, -0.004280410706996918, 0.0012197875184938312, -0.0306234173476696, -0.041392337530851364, 0.01011964213103056, -0.03532768040895462, -0.01382600236684084, -0.008505454286932945, 0.038572218269109726, -0.023783743381500244, 0.00291850115172565, 0.006243697367608547, 0.01813751645386219, 0.07171858847141266, -0.007174389902502298, -0.0001854714355431497, 0.015583234839141369, 0.037981610745191574, -0.009190008044242859, -0.003200456267222762, -0.014266882091760635, -0.03618335351347923, -0.014432886615395546, -0.0058405278250575066, 0.019780682399868965, 0.05441414192318916, -0.00990199577063322, -0.0019660203251987696, -0.03206002712249756, -0.03370935842394829, 0.046753328293561935, -0.05317667871713638, 0.008021701127290726, -0.011504891328513622, -0.03159612417221069, -0.02787390537559986, 0.009942716918885708, -0.018314996734261513, 0.009665240533649921, -0.00841047428548336, 0.004428260959684849, -0.006560028064996004, 0.034208789467811584, 0.07914213836193085, 0.0019688736647367477, 0.014786030165851116, 0.022909849882125854, -0.04755544289946556, 0.015655653551220894, 0.01648879051208496, 0.022557931020855904, 0.006929703056812286, -0.003078168723732233, -0.011628862470388412, -0.05801597610116005, -0.003304765559732914, 0.026643522083759308, 0.02658798359334469, 0.02487439475953579, 0.02347709611058235, 0.04982291907072067, -0.002625313587486744, -0.012920917943120003, -0.025763029232621193, -0.04632577300071716, 0.022001244127750397, 0.027018820866942406, 0.09243037551641464, 0.008283098228275776, -0.0025031196419149637, 0.013434721156954765, 0.017016949132084846, 0.029905149713158607, 0.02990397997200489, 0.006970715709030628, 0.035094134509563446, 0.0023465175181627274, -0.019897527992725372, -0.021381208673119545, 0.000890889554284513, -0.01628323830664158, 0.0027259544003754854, -0.017692595720291138, -0.015292223542928696, 0.03491158410906792, 0.07596268504858017, -0.004034551791846752, -0.06184069812297821, -0.019911255687475204, -0.05248398333787918, 0.015616999007761478, 0.01946267858147621, 0.007604239508509636, 0.05155041441321373, -0.025604117661714554, 0.03802734613418579, 0.006248886231333017, 0.04653260484337807, -0.013833876699209213, -0.03773276507854462, -0.0277336947619915, -0.039666034281253815, -0.03093491680920124, 0.06612367182970047, -0.008478546515107155, -0.021326424553990364, 0.004212245810776949, -0.02820999175310135, 0.0238708034157753, 0.027510078623890877, 0.02126801759004593, 0.016103914007544518, 0.03895153850317001, -0.008653250522911549, 0.03286326304078102, 0.02207925356924534, -0.005516450852155685, 0.12715013325214386, 0.07259959727525711, 0.05527829751372337, -0.04480232298374176, 0.030326850712299347, -0.008549513295292854, 0.005193975288420916, -0.031096700578927994, 0.0001421247434336692, 0.04076266288757324, -0.039155516773462296, 0.05419474095106125, 0.031065573915839195, 0.025789273902773857, 0.01615583896636963, 0.030710892751812935, -0.03490909934043884, 0.01143829245120287, 0.03722763434052467, 0.008860367350280285, -0.00016518637130502611, -0.03155050799250603, 0.0019185955170542002, 0.01741003803908825, -0.01057790033519268, 0.0019421566976234317, -0.010180246084928513, 0.0023516288492828608, 0.014885240234434605, 0.03211323916912079, 0.004416508134454489, 0.0003281559038441628, -0.011586934328079224, 0.037312135100364685, 0.03812741860747337, 0.01305987499654293, 0.019415277987718582, -0.01547566894441843, 0.006118984892964363, 0.02832791395485401, 0.014098343439400196, -0.0030409879982471466, -0.005322099197655916, 0.018520992249250412, -0.025291405618190765, -0.010146806947886944, -0.05735701322555542, 0.01578621007502079, 0.0016742604784667492, -0.025646142661571503, 0.020543809980154037, -0.001189322443678975, -0.003375461557880044, -0.06736023724079132, -0.038818106055259705, -0.002517849439755082, -0.024899737909436226, -0.010602639988064766, -0.03914525732398033, -0.014872240833938122, 0.009731270372867584, 0.028056100010871887, -0.002136919181793928, -0.012191163375973701, -0.02982376515865326, 0.010866088792681694, -0.0027640466578304768, 0.04849722608923912, -0.013508480973541737, 0.010598029009997845, 0.0008386048721149564, 0.021061990410089493, -0.026535669341683388, -0.014477813616394997, 0.0038949698209762573, 0.005126754753291607, 0.030004115775227547, 0.013934390619397163, -0.01978207193315029, -0.02399691566824913, -0.04033408313989639, -0.007112734019756317, -0.05479078367352486, -0.014164823107421398, -0.019168946892023087, 0.009085861966013908, 0.018634648993611336, 0.007344977464526892, 0.010471099987626076, 0.027002891525626183, -0.006380866747349501, 0.04507444426417351, 0.008499957621097565, -0.007257233839482069, -0.030287018045783043, 0.0006943891057744622, -0.02299346961081028, 0.016738368198275566, -0.02549825608730316, 0.0759110301733017, 0.02125144563615322, 0.017054598778486252, -0.015244686044752598, 0.05842537805438042, -0.00912948977202177, 0.05033290013670921, 0.033140216022729874, -0.012907249853014946, 0.011596712283790112, -0.003010608721524477, -0.0092361681163311, -0.04551936686038971, -0.026918862015008926, -0.07554712891578674, -0.045699868351221085, 0.022685280069708824, -0.0506807379424572, -0.06317467242479324, 0.0013846681686118245, -0.05595402419567108, -0.019067931920289993, -0.0038023842498660088, -0.0036515737883746624, -0.03367159143090248, -0.007888399995863438, -0.032281044870615005, -0.019968479871749878, -0.022882208228111267, 0.017080124467611313, -0.05151059105992317, -0.0074711511842906475, 0.008410644717514515, 0.0468791238963604, 0.01395441684871912, -0.012031462043523788, 0.0041094571352005005, -0.004169709049165249, 0.03547351062297821, 0.008298450149595737, -0.024949418380856514, -0.0035106786526739597, -0.027329670265316963, -0.04154100641608238, 0.017968880012631416, 0.0068491380661726, 0.02613886445760727, -0.0031756011303514242, 0.017012445256114006, -0.01106785424053669, 0.07818972319364548, -0.043124720454216, 0.0011941769625991583, -0.01905815675854683, 0.00992438942193985, 0.007224424742162228, -0.03886757045984268, 0.029316723346710205, 0.03483021631836891, -0.046816371381282806, 0.01461481861770153, 0.03360985964536667, 0.0629236251115799, -0.024898339062929153, 0.020766161382198334, -0.050915248692035675, 0.0058768922463059425, 0.03104645013809204, 0.0190350953489542, 0.0034981996286660433, 0.029416712000966072, -0.011584635823965073, 0.014659140259027481, -0.005525266285985708, 0.024436969310045242, -0.07905539125204086, -0.03143537417054176, 0.0012941230088472366, 0.037248726934194565, -0.009961115196347237, -0.04647486284375191, 0.0002143199963029474, 0.01935064233839512, -0.03734748065471649, -0.02452780492603779, -0.026663169264793396, -0.026733597740530968, -0.02680177241563797, 0.028469376266002655, -0.01740983873605728, -0.006656174547970295, 0.0515093170106411, 0.02000688761472702, 0.03564968332648277, 0.005821671336889267, -0.03183230385184288, -0.03793985769152641, -0.001868566614575684, -0.007707951124757528, 0.0036071771755814552, -0.047851916402578354, 0.04046529904007912, -0.03960757702589035, -0.04009205102920532, 0.03041965514421463, -0.021366367116570473, 0.009733079932630062, 0.06546813249588013, 0.03237034007906914, 0.028815431520342827, 0.036725644022226334, 0.015011364594101906, -0.004023960325866938, -0.018175270408391953, -0.012042911723256111, 0.004791230894625187, 0.012457081116735935, -0.04960476979613304, 0.018920179456472397, -0.023690011352300644, 0.0151009326800704, -0.029172291979193687, 0.03353806212544441, -0.01575174182653427, 0.016714084893465042, -0.051687370985746384, 0.007168263662606478, -0.013168868608772755, -0.026431260630488396, 0.01697094365954399, -0.0419452078640461, -0.029082152992486954, 0.028465548530220985, 0.03721358999609947, 0.02109857276082039, 0.001330057275481522, -0.01344624999910593, -0.06126267835497856, 0.008185213431715965, -0.0043632290326058865, -0.04396553710103035, -0.0268977303057909, 0.011156938038766384, 0.014610867947340012, -0.03453003987669945, -0.016375789418816566, -0.0037288223393261433, -0.009343661367893219, 0.05402251332998276, -0.013332245871424675, -0.008089891634881496, 0.04287372902035713, -0.005230265203863382, 0.04010846093297005, -0.09398496150970459, 0.054801881313323975, -0.026673007756471634, -0.047131989151239395, -0.019997671246528625, 0.007645809557288885, -0.048008497804403305, 0.020524317398667336, 0.01668049953877926, -0.013778425753116608, 0.01234747190028429, 0.02498464472591877, 0.013419863767921925, -0.025384359061717987, -0.0297392550855875, 0.05100689455866814, -0.00038819448673166335, -0.009725266136229038, -0.004942023660987616, -0.01332269236445427, 0.008668695576488972, -0.0002500326372683048, -0.007605894934386015, -0.029469845816493034, 0.013960306532680988, 0.03500795364379883, -0.016059504821896553, 0.012833353132009506, -0.06803238391876221, 0.001968516269698739, 0.02484300173819065, -0.009702791459858418, 0.015867551788687706, 0.04744544252753258, 0.01999681629240513, -0.008616418577730656, 0.04561547189950943, -0.03101504035294056, -0.0023312054108828306, 0.021771224215626717, 0.010678883641958237, -0.0162050761282444, -0.022889519110322, 0.05128074809908867, 0.026461787521839142, 0.00278702424839139, 0.012385077774524689, 0.02838662452995777, 0.045947398990392685, 0.0409628227353096, 0.0013563076499849558, 0.006934362929314375, 0.006818560883402824, -0.05063266307115555, 0.024253906682133675, 0.017927445471286774, 0.040917009115219116, -0.01679040677845478, -0.0065070344135165215, 0.03586237505078316, -0.03169221803545952, -0.003958199638873339, 0.002238364890217781, 0.04885721951723099, -0.00020995148224756122, -0.00017338852921966463, 0.003523151157423854, -0.011005011387169361, 0.0309233907610178, 0.017191771417856216, -0.04707225412130356, 0.03711722418665886, -0.03163733333349228, -0.015393574722111225, -0.044236522167921066, -0.004065795335918665, 0.009982096031308174, -0.014720608480274677, 0.005744619760662317, 0.04049141705036163, -0.011514497920870781, 0.023622773587703705, 0.018796153366565704, -0.019162235781550407, 0.02543625235557556, 0.017971361055970192, -0.01298614963889122, -0.04097609594464302, 0.00442604161798954, -0.006481815129518509, 0.001105385716073215, 0.02518932893872261, -0.052017487585544586, 0.03365667909383774, 0.06599155068397522, 0.02396639622747898, -0.05949212983250618, -0.024706177413463593, 0.014198713935911655, 0.02766578644514084, -0.04147692024707794, -0.02876482717692852, -0.012599331326782703, 0.016829924657940865, 0.004985228180885315, -0.016361849382519722 ]
<p>Suppose you had a bag with $n$ tiles, each with a letter on it. There are $n_A$ tiles with letter 'A', $n_B$ with 'B', and so on, and $n_*$ 'wildcard' tiles (we have $n = n_A + n_B + \ldots + n_Z + n_*$). Suppose you had a dictionary with a finite number of words.</p> <p>You pick $k$ tiles from the bag without replacement.</p> <p><strong>How would you compute (or estimate) the probability that you can form a given word, of length $l$ (with 1 &lt; $l$ =&lt; $k$) from the dictionary given the $k$ tiles selected?</strong></p> <p>For those not familiar with Scrabble (TM), the wildcard character can be used to match any letter. Thus the word 'BOOT' could be 'spelled' with the tiles 'B', '*', 'O', 'T'. The order in which the letters are drawn does not matter.</p> <p>Suggestion: in order to simplify the writing of answers, it might be better to just answer the question: what is the probability of having the word 'BOOT' among your possible moves after drawing 7 letters from a fresh bag.</p> <p><em>(the problem's introduction has been copied from this similar <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/3779/probability-of-not-drawing-a-word-from-a-bag-of-letters-in-scrabble">question</a>)</em></p>
73,595
[ -0.036586299538612366, -0.026532478630542755, 0.017457380890846252, 0.008160931058228016, 0.04927650839090347, 0.016793224960565567, -0.009552358649671078, 0.004750431515276432, 0.007802387233823538, -0.014697290025651455, 0.018255461007356644, 0.06236856058239937, 0.01322549395263195, 0.03629115968942642, 0.018248874694108963, 0.017348013818264008, -0.004000047221779823, -0.07074330002069473, -0.006474714260548353, 0.01880474202334881, 0.030136991292238235, 0.029884863644838333, 0.01870720088481903, -0.008796140551567078, -0.04053089767694473, 0.021556632593274117, 0.00893590971827507, -0.042363241314888, 0.04580582305788994, 0.03570890054106712, 0.0018728113500401378, -0.027438271790742874, 0.04087705910205841, 0.0265070591121912, 0.0312044695019722, 0.020786765962839127, -0.042841341346502304, -0.02664344757795334, 0.002113507827743888, 0.027356864884495735, -0.056948352605104446, -0.0523189976811409, -0.008319994434714317, 0.010813526809215546, -0.018177617341279984, 0.022512394934892654, -0.004393402487039566, -0.03847504034638405, 0.009609473869204521, -0.05384254828095436, 0.05802071839570999, 0.005114751867949963, 0.0373021699488163, 0.028774986043572426, -0.007709141820669174, -0.002102193422615528, 0.06262984126806259, 0.0879882276058197, -0.007701725233346224, -0.00653424859046936, -0.010006001219153404, -0.053408246487379074, -0.022672975435853004, -0.01865895837545395, -0.03691594675183296, 0.02193322777748108, -0.010599513538181782, 0.012636374682188034, 0.0335201621055603, -0.020533328875899315, 0.0031965477392077446, 0.0393512025475502, 0.05861259251832962, -0.034787118434906006, 0.030070655047893524, -0.009424752555787563, 0.019469203427433968, 0.08376473933458328, 0.04676723852753639, 0.019369853660464287, -0.003380832727998495, 0.012073571793735027, 0.019174180924892426, 0.01637122966349125, 0.03396715968847275, -0.022805992513895035, 0.04111398011445999, -0.023329440504312515, 0.018161524087190628, 0.016441775485873222, 0.032020531594753265, -0.015534091740846634, 0.03369506075978279, 0.00008431764581473544, -0.04550428315997124, 0.05249505117535591, -0.02443661540746689, 0.039060067385435104, -0.00648344773799181, -0.04381704330444336, -0.005969673860818148, -0.048989925533533096, 0.028244026005268097, 0.051882728934288025, -0.007125127594918013, -0.016506897285580635, -0.031924664974212646, 0.023054711520671844, -0.023422155529260635, -0.0010441663907840848, -0.005761349108070135, 0.03969365730881691, -0.008153644390404224, -0.0174954142421484, 0.009921256452798843, -0.011901135556399822, -0.026010777801275253, -0.012027156539261341, 0.03656305745244026, 0.055791452527046204, 0.0355214923620224, -0.048366256058216095, 0.041746389120817184, -0.04789074510335922, -0.060550056397914886, 0.01230704877525568, 0.02592066116631031, -0.03258601948618889, -0.04210012033581734, 0.04898031800985336, -0.04077436402440071, -0.03697074204683304, 0.012324445880949497, -0.0051455022767186165, 0.060378316789865494, 0.014522170647978783, -0.0914502888917923, -0.05553504824638367, 0.037017516791820526, -0.019621875137090683, -0.039063744246959686, -0.03456486389040947, -0.0008607939234934747, 0.04627836123108864, 0.038880228996276855, -0.02583114244043827, 0.053637683391571045, 0.023196816444396973, 0.028607139363884926, 0.024259032681584358, -0.024229353293776512, 0.01427256315946579, -0.011034817434847355, -0.046658873558044434, 0.03856071084737778, -0.06187966838479042, 0.025679493322968483, 0.00039584722253493965, 0.014429713599383831, -0.06554660201072693, 0.027235660701990128, 0.02719791606068611, -0.012572661973536015, -0.005292869638651609, 0.0015335449716076255, -0.03395894542336464, 0.08465582877397537, 0.05045722424983978, 0.01828688010573387, -0.002469098661094904, -0.011043885722756386, -0.006650508381426334, 0.0014773380244150758, -0.006911017931997776, 0.0738334059715271, -0.035049282014369965, 0.025683095678687096, 0.01427975483238697, 0.02918659895658493, -0.0330798514187336, -0.0354071706533432, -0.016011172905564308, 0.01630295254290104, 0.007587164640426636, 0.0024451876524835825, 0.013780664652585983, 0.019027002155780792, 0.008114168420433998, 0.030514679849147797, -0.02257712371647358, -0.046990104019641876, -0.07390470057725906, -0.012737426906824112, -0.0031744057778269053, -0.017756285145878792, 0.05631633475422859, -0.002156730741262436, 0.010123556479811668, -0.014551304280757904, -0.02715185284614563, -0.0058136493898928165, -0.010079720988869667, -0.005513009615242481, -0.05519533157348633, -0.020256996154785156, 0.06825566291809082, 0.014131462201476097, -0.03257114812731743, 0.06534282863140106, -0.0299089252948761, -0.0296744704246521, 0.015745896846055984, -0.007853159680962563, 0.047284651547670364, -0.00782732106745243, 0.014982127584517002, 0.03975255414843559, 0.004383441526442766, 0.014881731942296028, 0.007822898216545582, -0.0319657139480114, 0.037945784628391266, 0.05345417931675911, 0.0041226656176149845, 0.03126021474599838, 0.002767232246696949, -0.01761675998568535, 0.009644700214266777, 0.03503976762294769, -0.04847240820527077, -0.04333008825778961, -0.010466218926012516, 0.04020906984806061, 0.009648270905017853, -0.013568545691668987, 0.012538903392851353, 0.05572614446282387, -0.011709246784448624, -0.054977331310510635, 0.03189989924430847, -0.0635116770863533, 0.03227728605270386, -0.016188422217965126, 0.027479758486151695, 0.013519550673663616, -0.010965129360556602, -0.007767565082758665, -0.008866394869983196, -0.0383719839155674, 0.03960661217570305, -0.030039725825190544, -0.010304835624992847, 0.030955741181969643, 0.026836005970835686, -0.045068901032209396, -0.03686336427927017, 0.036177631467580795, -0.012042507529258728, -0.000006495648449345026, 0.06666022539138794, 0.035279881209135056, -0.012163045816123486, 0.01855221576988697, -0.0253745187073946, 0.03965222090482712, 0.0010526417754590511, -0.03332424536347389, 0.017702464014291763, 0.020903879776597023, -0.0027185690123587847, 0.02461124025285244, -0.02650478295981884, 0.012906531803309917, 0.03224368020892143, 0.03837040066719055, -0.010233275592327118, -0.026868874207139015, 0.060198020190000534, -0.015887560322880745, -0.00964954774826765, -0.012640842236578465, 0.0018686981638893485, 0.015781961381435394, 0.01967180147767067, -0.10571020841598511, 0.027208195999264717, -0.018803978338837624, -0.03329247236251831, 0.021356916055083275, 0.0020876647904515266, -0.01717238314449787, 0.032585181295871735, 0.00862026121467352, -0.007878919132053852, 0.003158627776429057, -0.013746071606874466, 0.027252214029431343, -0.04181443527340889, 0.031699080020189285, 0.05770573392510414, -0.0046643358655273914, -0.06631428748369217, 0.020620930939912796, -0.014867897145450115, -0.06461719423532486, -0.019288217648863792, -0.019272182136774063, 0.02398313768208027, -0.02835940755903721, -0.019281603395938873, -0.0299695935100317, -0.006114427465945482, -0.005830009933561087, -0.06185763329267502, -0.06682038307189941, 0.017595328390598297, -0.017557956278324127, 0.042312998324632645, -0.015141136012971401, -0.03225128725171089, 0.06516106426715851, 0.030198657885193825, -0.029896119609475136, -0.017063535749912262, -0.010728877037763596, -0.01948537304997444, -0.044552210718393326, -0.02625684067606926, 0.026478059589862823, -0.036623165011405945, 0.03630389645695686, 0.034879785031080246, 0.03740287944674492, 0.06426475942134857, 0.02232007123529911, -0.021568456664681435, 0.019613413140177727, 0.03151582553982735, 0.004314557649195194, 0.005670757032930851, 0.007314612623304129, -0.023163141682744026, 0.002649375470355153, -0.023446273058652878, -0.015213224105536938, 0.02565661631524563, -0.03786251321434975, 0.012870891019701958, -0.02924880012869835, 0.00028722098795697093, -0.005852611735463142, 0.016199281439185143, 0.015507169999182224, -0.01266067661345005, 0.045049529522657394, 0.00892372615635395, 0.03244420140981674, -0.038356244564056396, 0.041439153254032135, 0.01190862338989973, 0.06041865423321724, -0.011080366559326649, -0.04147711396217346, 0.0009900530567392707, 0.0007030623382888734, 0.02241651527583599, -0.03676806390285492, 0.017670072615146637, 0.01328810304403305, 0.04795362800359726, 0.03559926152229309, 0.010524909012019634, -0.02614431455731392, 0.015873676165938377, -0.06591486930847168, -0.027459220960736275, -0.014487077482044697, 0.0383349172770977, -0.009350146166980267, 0.03555449843406677, 0.012688050977885723, -0.0252265315502882, -0.00740575697273016, 0.041664693504571915, -0.09479491412639618, 0.02590525709092617, -0.027172140777111053, 0.0005447673611342907, -0.001537313568405807, -0.031240975484251976, 0.04014388471841812, -0.010734341107308865, 0.0018268055282533169, 0.010167155414819717, -0.005988334771245718, -0.030021928250789642, 0.006330861244350672, -0.0014812572626397014, -0.0287790484726429, -0.00408287113532424, 0.0073974584229290485, 0.018507540225982666, 0.004376152064651251, 0.022539900615811348, 0.031825169920921326, 0.005647545214742422, 0.034350741654634476, -0.021428182721138, 0.02287658490240574, 0.028696229681372643, -0.007483554072678089, 0.04802747443318367, 0.04312645643949509, 0.0034454043488949537, -0.028198443353176117, 0.01321648433804512, 0.04536757245659828, -0.0006220265640877187, 0.01205037534236908, 0.02101093716919422, -0.08336678892374039, -0.005754380952566862, 0.02260981872677803, 0.014361818321049213, -0.053138211369514465, 0.004857867956161499, 0.08258216828107834, 0.028639473021030426, -0.041140154004096985, 0.027705993503332138, 0.07010562717914581, -0.00693417526781559, -0.05008602887392044, 0.013261010870337486, 0.021163802593946457, 0.01713908091187477, 0.0011211923556402326, 0.03300194442272186, 0.007017894648015499, 0.03785242140293121, -0.010751252062618732, 0.027223268523812294, -0.013539847917854786, -0.04181603342294693, -0.008669726550579071, 0.00868714414536953, 0.007985183969140053, -0.012361101806163788, -0.03427049517631531, -0.03274821862578392, 0.02508072927594185, 0.007094198372215033, -0.001816502190195024, -0.04491988569498062, -0.04068043828010559, 0.018301071599125862, 0.06119060516357422, 0.05618824064731598, -0.02057848870754242, -0.006135561969131231, -0.013694504275918007, -0.001984185539186001, 0.017064569517970085, -0.0475209578871727, 0.02764742262661457, -0.01566404476761818, -0.003567392472177744, -0.021068191155791283, 0.0007437776075676084, -0.04688134044408798, 0.008201171644032001, 0.009556879289448261, 0.03718522563576698, -0.00357950571924448, -0.0018764473497867584, 0.014494413509964943, -0.012642771936953068, 0.05126729980111122, 0.037354614585638046, -0.012021086178719997, 0.0020943614654242992, -0.01506856083869934, 0.017062809318304062, -0.025328543037176132, -0.06063451990485191, 0.03504196181893349, -0.023930640891194344, -0.029098233208060265, 0.0018262298544868827, -0.05132121592760086, -0.07381103932857513, 0.007048142608255148, -0.0053097340278327465, 0.006477542221546173, -0.009151882492005825, -0.004655675496906042, 0.06582087278366089, 0.012058965861797333, 0.05385294556617737, 0.05349772423505783, 0.0164739191532135, 0.024477137252688408, 0.015347016975283623, -0.020922647789120674, 0.003942984156310558, -0.03110302798449993, 0.0023831992875784636, -0.037229273468256, -0.0019550384022295475, -0.05829557403922081, 0.07551632076501846, 0.008466048166155815, 0.01833692565560341, -0.022034872323274612, -0.044544365257024765, -0.05982247740030289, 0.006409120745956898, -0.020259354263544083, 0.031958166509866714, 0.016553958877921104, -0.0001931809529196471, -0.020039793103933334, -0.0022557799238711596, 0.04329681023955345, -0.00015929309302009642, 0.014480270445346832, -0.004502379801124334, -0.03863911330699921, 0.02583502233028412, -0.005348547827452421, -0.005859375465661287, 0.02052527852356434, -0.015141002833843231, 0.055788569152355194, 0.0159698948264122, 0.02194005437195301, 0.013728005811572075, -0.05869998410344124, -0.015163624659180641, 0.027561914175748825, -0.006256453227251768, 0.011964282020926476, -0.02212578058242798, 0.038827136158943176, 0.013499274849891663, -0.016050495207309723, -0.037922754883766174, -0.05378137528896332, 0.007288606837391853, 0.0043192976154387, 0.009952851571142673, -0.025759752839803696, -0.013825811445713043, -0.029167504981160164, -0.05130324140191078, -0.020384497940540314, 0.044033873826265335, -0.00976855494081974, 0.012639076448976994, 0.014777438715100288, 0.007077112793922424, 0.07091602683067322, 0.040708959102630615, -0.016971919685602188, 0.02428971789777279, -0.021650657057762146, 0.03211475536227226, -0.008573985658586025, 0.012224387377500534, -0.021590502932667732, -0.04636971279978752, -0.01119188778102398, 0.05378603935241699, 0.029070885851979256, -0.023152444511651993, -0.03664844483137131, 0.031213801354169846, 0.018090149387717247, 0.008901789784431458, -0.03285035863518715, -0.028497222810983658, 0.006940086837857962, -0.0030581159517169, -0.02687619812786579, -0.006621958687901497, -0.00016640836838632822, 0.002004039939492941, -0.018696943297982216, 0.034120697528123856, -0.022845949977636337, 0.0068260920234024525, 0.06371130794286728, -0.039941318333148956, -0.008033767342567444, 0.05075078830122948, -0.04502655938267708, 0.06066672503948212, 0.052144333720207214, -0.01610400155186653, 0.02752450853586197, 0.0018894544336944818, -0.017897043377161026, -0.007429217919707298, -0.034643180668354034, -0.0078221894800663, 0.034864213317632675, -0.02959156036376953, 0.022313449531793594, 0.018805939704179764, -0.018763836473226547, 0.01487817894667387, 0.016468144953250885, -0.03464869409799576, -0.017878729850053787, -0.00004413420901983045, 0.02932640351355076, 0.03046390414237976, 0.02109835296869278, 0.04750792309641838, 0.0023941900581121445, 0.03513025492429733, 0.01186402328312397, 0.04974251985549927, -0.0014817856717854738, 0.043358661234378815, -0.03441249579191208, -0.027148758992552757, 0.021901056170463562, -0.06099340319633484, 0.0012176254531368613, -0.00881393812596798, -0.023943588137626648, 0.052995841950178146, -0.008673103526234627, -0.014485488645732403, -0.01641634665429592, -0.027842851355671883, -0.04669103026390076, 0.013313733041286469, -0.00649442570284009, 0.010161769576370716, 0.04806609824299812, -0.005972499027848244, -0.0015326500870287418, -0.028918251395225525, 0.039952050894498825, -0.034453824162483215, -0.05314098671078682, 0.005966585595160723, -0.026105761528015137, -0.06197914481163025, -0.0021550296805799007, 0.02980109490454197, -0.006158196367323399, 0.034945618361234665, -0.027974430471658707, 0.03136061131954193, 0.012460545636713505, 0.04334995523095131, -0.024709507822990417, 0.09796452522277832, 0.010702614672482014, 0.009846294298768044, 0.025691606104373932, -0.011710829101502895, 0.10573546588420868, 0.02855760231614113, 0.07001806795597076, -0.0764194130897522, 0.005155864171683788, 0.010770497843623161, -0.018060091882944107, -0.006709700915962458, 0.018391961231827736, 0.026140151545405388, -0.01777145080268383, 0.02049795724451542, 0.04207272082567215, -0.05563918873667717, -0.012031239457428455, 0.04550892114639282, -0.07347799837589264, -0.023553047329187393, 0.003272456116974354, -0.020753096789121628, 0.013278713449835777, -0.0028257910162210464, -0.032795894891023636, -0.0010434824507683516, 0.023150775581598282, -0.02288650907576084, -0.03782447800040245, -0.025543587282299995, 0.005765387788414955, 0.02286067232489586, -0.00424939626827836, -0.01826390065252781, 0.03897899016737938, -0.01970858685672283, -0.0006791839259676635, -0.009083694778382778, 0.02555987611413002, -0.026978852227330208, 0.023920508101582527, 0.015242930501699448, 0.042151566594839096, 0.01629694551229477, 0.003874886315315962, -0.004314053803682327, -0.04691975191235542, 0.0012292383471503854, -0.0417296327650547, 0.04480137303471565, 0.004492470994591713, 0.012393768876791, -0.02806650474667549, -0.012931606732308865, -0.010466746054589748, -0.02072492055594921, -0.011784414760768414, 0.022367972880601883, 0.0441194511950016, -0.041832175105810165, -0.05283236876130104, -0.010406599380075932, 0.030350593850016594, -0.002569080563262105, 0.01671699248254299, 0.003935995977371931, -0.033692993223667145, -0.014374363236129284, -0.03921661153435707, 0.001509029301814735, 0.04314500838518143, -0.003717773361131549, -0.026869675144553185, 0.009312395937740803, -0.018274743109941483, -0.010227403603494167, -0.03201788663864136, 0.00463333772495389, 0.04194854572415352, -0.03540085256099701, -0.01464229915291071, 0.022106697782874107, -0.017291182652115822, -0.010656769387423992, -0.056419480592012405, -0.030629627406597137, -0.07348667830228806, 0.006897998973727226, -0.002410230925306678, 0.012986190617084503, -0.01965974271297455, -0.0019480130868032575, 0.005550742149353027, 0.01813402585685253, 0.0022065751254558563, -0.0497981458902359, 0.030041387304663658, -0.02647349052131176, -0.04576598480343819, -0.01648273505270481, -0.0071095372550189495, 0.048766329884529114, 0.05610060691833496, 0.008711474947631359, 0.007740182802081108, -0.009978076443076134, 0.011625154875218868, 0.00021220769849605858, 0.01650139130651951, -0.03952251747250557, -0.04571682587265968, 0.04750945419073105, -0.045577120035886765, -0.051654912531375885, -0.03952326253056526, -0.007992490194737911, -0.010213369503617287, 0.003536739619448781, -0.022875143215060234, -0.06580925732851028, -0.0020444379188120365, -0.058062680065631866, 0.0025634358171373606, 0.0013107683043926954, 0.005489036440849304, 0.010732604190707207, 0.005963239353150129, 0.001678943750448525, -0.014452742412686348, 0.017317483201622963, -0.001837585004977882, -0.02361101657152176, -0.013564427383244038, -0.0005173036479391158, 0.03497008979320526, 0.030792783945798874, -0.01778358966112137, 0.00273508089594543, -0.024305246770381927, 0.02467300184071064, -0.031964875757694244, 0.007958347909152508, 0.03636545687913895, -0.05558072403073311, -0.0072098118253052235, 0.02238600142300129, 0.010869080200791359, 0.03406759724020958, 0.03744490444660187, 0.004798568319529295, -0.004356076009571552, 0.04368362948298454, -0.04958019778132439, -0.021901676431298256, -0.0073320986703038216, 0.026030883193016052, -0.004242057912051678, -0.012497845105826855, -0.021001512184739113, 0.003623722353950143, -0.01118358876556158, -0.0035231297370046377, 0.03889944776892662, 0.014016206376254559, 0.010359966196119785, 0.045994751155376434, 0.012935705482959747, -0.0017628491623327136, -0.011821625754237175, 0.0046592713333666325, -0.015722177922725677, 0.061516158282756805, 0.023293957114219666, 0.04083419591188431, 0.011968117207288742, -0.022367103025317192, -0.08656319975852966, -0.010339115746319294, 0.03066183626651764, 0.002222561975941062, 0.05215579643845558, -0.044037826359272, -0.01007787138223648, 0.062491223216056824, -0.06609205156564713, 0.014422152191400528, 0.01345599815249443, 0.008967436850070953, -0.07158980518579483, 0.030640020966529846, -0.030591271817684174, -0.004269045311957598, 0.02828214131295681, 0.03861973062157631, 0.04695764556527138, 0.011640740558505058, -0.03540980815887451, -0.03356291353702545, 0.0005509682232514024, 0.03755304217338562, -0.013875523582100868, 0.002567089395597577, 0.0749201774597168, -0.022698581218719482, -0.05887961387634277, -0.011563831940293312, -0.007003613281995058, -0.020359158515930176, 0.030827075242996216, 0.004304738715291023, -0.005719688255339861, 0.01706390082836151, 0.0337914377450943, -0.00225984794087708, 0.0024844473227858543, 0.008312826976180077, 0.04496505483984947, 0.03605542331933975, -0.01706363447010517, 0.02754204161465168, 0.0019982855301350355, 0.0150105906650424, -0.022263867780566216, 0.02410808391869068, 0.007162328809499741, 0.024318598210811615, 0.010807876475155354, 0.007318870164453983, 0.007309135980904102, -0.023092614486813545, 0.0015203244984149933, -0.038208018988370895, 0.03677639737725258, 0.009793516248464584, -0.01582164131104946, -0.01475144736468792, 0.003895506961271167, -0.024843215942382812, -0.02356955036520958, -0.008550489321351051, -0.007675242144614458, -0.0311235710978508, -0.042149584740400314, -0.006900729611515999, 0.008654877543449402, -0.003267687978222966, 0.017162272706627846, -0.002796863904222846, -0.01790081150829792, 0.01939835026860237, -0.0035407179966568947, 0.020791176706552505, 0.00673162005841732, -0.014281358569860458, 0.01725757122039795, -0.06013812869787216, 0.048294343054294586, 0.002030082978308201, 0.011350870132446289, -0.05800345912575722, 0.0029342081397771835, -0.004590918309986591, 0.03505761921405792, 0.07310616970062256, -0.019897310063242912, -0.02434813790023327, -0.03630109131336212, 0.005917451810091734, 0.01631295308470726, -0.05572981387376785, -0.009129694662988186, -0.03620389476418495, 0.02115444280207157, -0.010215134359896183, -0.02067108266055584, 0.0017772988649085164, 0.019000789150595665, 0.016932426020503044, -0.029591495171189308, 0.0007278650882653892, 0.00774341681972146, -0.021054591983556747, 0.038577400147914886, 0.006732013542205095, -0.019166363403201103, 0.053679171949625015, 0.02036740817129612, -0.0007639777031727135, -0.0021473048254847527, -0.00302748940885067, -0.061980389058589935, 0.024375559762120247, -0.026295501738786697, -0.06319324672222137, -0.004641648381948471, 0.02852177992463112, 0.024492749944329262, -0.07151626795530319, -0.019750062376260757, 0.03731658309698105, -0.007903043180704117, -0.0177559033036232, -0.018427494913339615, 0.024288617074489594, 0.05511035770177841, -0.04775238037109375, 0.0006153659778647125, 0.009826544672250748, -0.04070005193352699, -0.007414194755256176, -0.0032139222603291273, -0.0008769310661591589, -0.03359625115990639, 0.026303263381123543, -0.017893418669700623, 0.013006770052015781, 0.015289505943655968, 0.015981599688529968, 0.04412433132529259, 0.0006079138838686049, -0.019976705312728882, 0.03684855252504349, 0.004928105510771275, 0.025951150804758072, -0.02561846561729908, -0.029168367385864258, 0.05739166587591171, 0.010134518146514893, 0.045772481709718704, -0.058355480432510376, 0.02411390282213688, -0.04913846030831337, -0.02786523848772049, -0.004482576157897711, -0.04117584228515625, -0.003241225378587842, 0.007352776825428009, -0.00445075798779726, 0.03696684539318085, 0.05069662258028984, -0.030169306322932243, 0.0020677566062659025, 0.01672969199717045, 0.003843769198283553, -0.05064741522073746, 0.0019486751407384872, -0.018287545070052147, -0.04298274219036102, 0.04811466112732887, 0.039332419633865356, 0.005280850455164909, -0.008232589811086655, -0.03196967393159866, -0.000347563938703388, 0.08460554480552673, 0.006442242302000523, 0.03323939070105553, -0.05354825407266617, 0.0128290681168437, -0.018782110884785652, -0.02193637378513813 ]
<p>What would be the MLE (Maximum Likelihood Estimator) of the given data:</p> <p>Assuming the i-th point $ {p}_{i} = ({x}_{i}, {y}_{i}) $.<br> We have the following measurements of this specific point - $ (x, y, r = \sqrt{{x}_{i}^{2} + {y}_{i}^{2}}) $.<br> Namely, we have a measurement of the x, y coordinate and the norm of the point with the following distributions:</p> <p>$$ x \sim N(0, {\sigma}_{x}), y \sim N(0, {\sigma}_{y}), r \sim N(0, {\sigma}_{r}) $$</p> <p>Given this measurement vector, what would be the MLE of $ {p}_{i} $ coordinates (${x}_{i}, {y}_{i})$? </p> <p>I know the brute force to calculate it, is there any efficient method for this specific formulation?</p> <p>What about given a set of points and their corresponding measurements?<br> Assuming the model of the set of points is linear (polynomial of degree N, etc...).</p> <p>Has anyone encountered an article or anything about this problem?<br> What about the Cramer-Rao lower bound, or better bound?</p> <p>Thank You.</p>
73,596
[ -0.038715798407793045, 0.011515561491250992, 0.008368546143174171, -0.038393355906009674, 0.02592022344470024, 0.03393205255270004, -0.009049562737345695, -0.04103783518075943, 0.02646344155073166, -0.05769560486078262, 0.028393197804689407, 0.051769454032182693, 0.0867963582277298, 0.04169498383998871, 0.00015109674131963402, -0.03600063547492027, -0.039859589189291, 0.009657619521021843, -0.030890075489878654, -0.043681610375642776, 0.017142346128821373, 0.04463602975010872, 0.025613319128751755, -0.02146425098180771, -0.05311654135584831, 0.042075105011463165, 0.028307490050792694, -0.02654401771724224, -0.006781003437936306, 0.09100967645645142, -0.07048165798187256, -0.02061295695602894, 0.002841104054823518, 0.05687455087900162, 0.00294528529047966, -0.027987176552414894, -0.02937450259923935, -0.034081216901540756, -0.003755672601982951, 0.04000358656048775, -0.04970449209213257, -0.038502585142850876, -0.0010356494458392262, 0.016060130670666695, 0.01770736277103424, 0.014770838432013988, 0.02360917255282402, -0.051115650683641434, 0.0180322527885437, -0.035488490015268326, 0.1268594115972519, 0.013489929959177971, -0.007113542407751083, -0.002270858734846115, -0.024633852764964104, -0.0018581001786515117, 0.05834829434752464, 0.07095314562320709, -0.029080422595143318, -0.034190889447927475, -0.01504467986524105, -0.03167479485273361, 0.028127171099185944, -0.02359963394701481, -0.033340223133563995, 0.006298260763287544, -0.010156925767660141, -0.01640477031469345, -0.0027106143534183502, -0.0002596293343231082, -0.01976057142019272, 0.031056106090545654, 0.046422429382801056, 0.01074405200779438, 0.015213754959404469, -0.006437267642468214, 0.011385364457964897, 0.021143583580851555, 0.027207521721720695, -0.009119060821831226, 0.005029770545661449, 0.0013575543416664004, 0.02035379223525524, 0.036754291504621506, -0.004140151664614677, -0.001378543907776475, 0.06026630848646164, -0.015672169625759125, 0.019181687384843826, -0.0020204377360641956, 0.0010814928682520986, -0.011648592539131641, 0.040825385600328445, -0.05844026058912277, -0.06313813477754593, 0.03364456817507744, -0.024732740595936775, 0.05650213360786438, 0.0014220295706763864, -0.031040046364068985, 0.008221084251999855, -0.058278050273656845, -0.017054107040166855, 0.07619354873895645, -0.017461655661463737, 0.011113068088889122, 0.006672058254480362, 0.011457615531980991, -0.01680746302008629, -0.01188122108578682, -0.03950149193406105, 0.011870671063661575, 0.020157072693109512, -0.00011646868370007724, 0.021447984501719475, -0.016166675835847855, 0.0013115201145410538, -0.016526110470294952, 0.04791426286101341, 0.07770901918411255, 0.02123955264687538, -0.006647288799285889, -0.0027334713377058506, -0.042540453374385834, -0.055490221828222275, 0.03993904963135719, 0.019455673173069954, -0.014842603355646133, -0.031356774270534515, 0.018055463209748268, 0.013784178532660007, 0.017119428142905235, 0.06530361622571945, 0.0008972501964308321, 0.018306851387023926, -0.004250551573932171, -0.12230858206748962, -0.045513324439525604, 0.03897189348936081, -0.01795780658721924, 0.03725612536072731, -0.0579415000975132, 0.01642332784831524, 0.05938032269477844, 0.0591607540845871, -0.0021553151309490204, 0.027722883969545364, 0.028985535725951195, 0.03334251791238785, -0.028244316577911377, -0.006908003240823746, -0.023778775706887245, -0.021123044192790985, -0.04206487163901329, -0.007809438742697239, -0.059457212686538696, 0.023152943700551987, 0.025818780064582825, -0.03497433662414551, -0.020019888877868652, 0.03063935786485672, 0.012196570634841919, -0.012939498759806156, -0.003369560232385993, 0.026643631979823112, -0.023340925574302673, 0.037692781537771225, 0.0158995371311903, 0.01806171052157879, 0.032989583909511566, -0.009916462004184723, 0.03844770789146423, 0.023165328428149223, 0.02314341999590397, 0.07637613266706467, -0.05088374763727188, -0.01672840490937233, -0.0016073017613962293, 0.022594047710299492, 0.03486121445894241, -0.033523380756378174, -0.0048240236937999725, -0.0012617084430530667, 0.006613219156861305, 0.04066929966211319, 0.05371585115790367, 0.010902483947575092, -0.02331162802875042, 0.02738538570702076, -0.03491717576980591, 0.017726071178913116, -0.06804691255092621, 0.015844402834773064, -0.0099521828815341, -0.03243826702237129, 0.04154909402132034, -0.016944408416748047, -0.011206324212253094, -0.04046870023012161, -0.04843350872397423, -0.0004702988953795284, -0.01560839731246233, 0.03629887476563454, -0.024220531806349754, -0.013029228895902634, 0.05323359742760658, 0.04308973625302315, 0.013839144259691238, 0.029219215735793114, -0.036755021661520004, -0.018492238596081734, -0.010541700758039951, -0.024463487789034843, 0.003526165382936597, 0.03387369215488434, -0.01025309693068266, -0.007184595335274935, -0.019927406683564186, -0.005825647618621588, -0.011416845954954624, -0.058857567608356476, 0.03972933068871498, 0.05440104380249977, 0.02637353166937828, 0.0072517697699368, 0.03314083069562912, 0.01388842798769474, 0.01668054237961769, -0.02473231963813305, -0.015002577565610409, -0.056367456912994385, -0.014745484106242657, 0.006632030941545963, 0.0705171674489975, -0.0627904161810875, 0.01543495710939169, 0.03370898962020874, 0.0446307547390461, 0.017698483541607857, 0.004230310209095478, -0.015271320939064026, -0.02041412703692913, 0.004009372089058161, -0.0025030465330928564, -0.02845150977373123, -0.004892968572676182, -0.014512382447719574, 0.00602740328758955, 0.02708282507956028, -0.0078094033524394035, -0.00005863674232386984, 0.03262894228100777, -0.022866293787956238, 0.002325391862541437, 0.001355587039142847, -0.02469753287732601, 0.00696170749142766, -0.0034731796476989985, -0.006988591980189085, 0.005984670482575893, -0.012807969935238361, 0.00718997186049819, 0.003614860586822033, 0.001365585601888597, 0.030270259827375412, 0.017746055498719215, -0.03661037236452103, 0.000007408588771795621, 0.009187828749418259, -0.03611128404736519, -0.0018830185290426016, -0.037869665771722794, -0.030549868941307068, -0.024386730045080185, 0.013616498559713364, 0.01547637302428484, -0.02990761026740074, 0.007185955066233873, -0.02833116613328457, -0.024744732305407524, -0.03696240857243538, -0.024108365178108215, 0.030694713816046715, 0.030447041615843773, -0.03469669446349144, -0.04821252450346947, -0.01995655708014965, 0.021752770990133286, -0.007613798603415489, -0.023264707997441292, 0.013133342377841473, 0.008615201339125633, -0.00876056868582964, -0.04216345399618149, -0.013537569902837276, -0.006496756337583065, 0.016335759311914444, -0.02961365506052971, -0.015259594656527042, 0.026806043460965157, -0.016110451892018318, -0.011357341893017292, 0.01988833211362362, -0.020020276308059692, -0.004930750001221895, -0.013159140944480896, -0.006287221796810627, 0.017539674416184425, -0.012761863879859447, 0.02266831509768963, 0.06232016161084175, 0.007330648601055145, -0.00681329146027565, -0.06139056757092476, -0.07228648662567139, 0.021594423800706863, -0.015186655335128307, 0.030411668121814728, 0.0031154563184827566, -0.02875961735844612, 0.08536697924137115, 0.0369664691388607, -0.021331695839762688, -0.030337361618876457, 0.021297598257660866, -0.024742502719163895, -0.01090407744050026, 0.005608840379863977, 0.016247279942035675, 0.009671398438513279, 0.07047231495380402, 0.011431857012212276, -0.03649867698550224, 0.052573107182979584, 0.020405160263180733, 0.02040550298988819, -0.006407878827303648, -0.0029329615645110607, -0.028768057003617287, 0.07324822247028351, 0.030225109308958054, -0.02341454103589058, 0.008643006905913353, 0.030221670866012573, -0.0037236104253679514, 0.032522134482860565, -0.0226154588162899, -0.016911150887608528, -0.04141906276345253, -0.013544009067118168, -0.0210450179874897, 0.03740844130516052, 0.03324337303638458, -0.024489350616931915, -0.02631743624806404, 0.04602818191051483, 0.02054443396627903, -0.0036905400920659304, -0.0014767727116122842, 0.03510959446430206, -0.0037501263432204723, -0.0016611783066764474, -0.017471324652433395, -0.0031051859259605408, 0.00952638778835535, -0.003053131978958845, -0.04072942957282066, -0.036457814276218414, 0.025040440261363983, -0.011105780489742756, 0.01951383799314499, 0.006293073296546936, -0.01422858890146017, 0.004111428279429674, -0.036066703498363495, 0.017700916156172752, -0.025264088064432144, 0.0710822343826294, 0.024231698364019394, 0.028216207399964333, 0.011627236381173134, -0.01904016174376011, 0.008261432871222496, 0.003534679301083088, -0.06948631256818771, -0.008640429936349392, -0.029420211911201477, -0.014536199159920216, 0.01275310106575489, -0.015224817208945751, 0.03274049982428551, -0.025411875918507576, 0.029834607616066933, 0.005726025905460119, 0.03156181797385216, -0.04585164040327072, 0.0017677408177405596, -0.030754363164305687, -0.01379603985697031, -0.004695130046457052, 0.04585382342338562, 0.009235812351107597, -0.02206677384674549, 0.028015486896038055, 0.03053365647792816, -0.029966255649924278, -0.00939860474318266, -0.006721673533320427, 0.023082192987203598, -0.02405455708503723, 0.023416107520461082, -0.020733783021569252, 0.024025745689868927, 0.0077911908738315105, 0.021019233390688896, -0.014782082289457321, 0.07393386214971542, 0.051010582596063614, -0.009089825674891472, 0.01762022264301777, -0.01678440347313881, -0.02342592366039753, 0.007878469303250313, 0.033249080181121826, 0.0022149537689983845, -0.0021222936920821667, 0.0596020482480526, -0.011898662894964218, -0.05101291835308075, 0.009273815900087357, 0.04080752655863762, 0.016778144985437393, 0.014648220501840115, -0.018053364008665085, -0.03637181967496872, 0.018885623663663864, 0.02116764336824417, 0.005560092628002167, -0.02402370236814022, -0.007967703975737095, -0.024245543405413628, 0.05741115286946297, -0.008975444361567497, -0.01410188339650631, 0.016615966334939003, 0.02864306978881359, 0.02891216240823269, -0.005389377474784851, -0.01376113947480917, 0.030424676835536957, 0.032190315425395966, 0.07160504162311554, 0.024597270414233208, -0.030805878341197968, -0.07654500007629395, -0.018714038655161858, 0.026066357269883156, 0.02106482908129692, 0.032331205904483795, 0.002382855862379074, -0.05152864381670952, -0.0047607626765966415, 0.03506810963153839, -0.021989773958921432, 0.02350389026105404, -0.007188278250396252, -0.028324907645583153, -0.041226014494895935, -0.03917647898197174, -0.07060643285512924, -0.00906666461378336, -0.0053567904978990555, 0.028049439191818237, -0.019258949905633926, -0.0158549714833498, -0.019730424508452415, 0.0128589803352952, 0.046786945313215256, 0.0841500535607338, 0.02518535777926445, -0.011196612380445004, -0.006770952604711056, 0.04255613684654236, -0.02665301412343979, -0.054392360150814056, 0.03194384649395943, 0.039949189871549606, -0.029041210189461708, 0.04948093369603157, -0.03985653072595596, -0.020089799538254738, 0.01901647448539734, 0.0170416422188282, -0.02604980394244194, 0.027463536709547043, -0.017033260315656662, 0.03735566884279251, 0.03938578441739082, 0.041363079100847244, 0.05882459133863449, -0.008491943590342999, 0.014101621694862843, -0.010029815137386322, -0.013833538629114628, 0.023737484589219093, -0.01588231883943081, -0.0046834684908390045, -0.04121185466647148, 0.021352356299757957, 0.014810781925916672, 0.08795945346355438, 0.0011133974185213447, 0.047701917588710785, -0.013178142718970776, -0.024245979264378548, -0.009673014283180237, 0.030695270746946335, 0.01536776777356863, 0.009681735187768936, -0.002979601500555873, 0.05182768404483795, 0.030991198495030403, -0.009762567467987537, 0.0060010869055986404, -0.0016331460792571306, 0.017952991649508476, 0.030412251129746437, -0.032633185386657715, 0.024093206971883774, -0.037988483905792236, -0.01292166393250227, 0.015732837840914726, -0.006377920042723417, 0.05852294713258743, -0.0074889762327075005, -0.004715765826404095, 0.03908785060048103, -0.0238813403993845, -0.007657562382519245, 0.018656855449080467, -0.004134897608309984, 0.05520074814558029, -0.03973739966750145, 0.011453107930719852, -0.020932922139763832, 0.024231310933828354, -0.05854018032550812, -0.032154884189367294, 0.036789584904909134, 0.010025943629443645, 0.008472943678498268, -0.059576615691185, -0.003770577721297741, -0.018973909318447113, -0.018552735447883606, -0.01152817439287901, 0.03206013888120651, -0.018369674682617188, -0.03666310012340546, -0.007974818348884583, 0.015657320618629456, 0.05868290737271309, -0.02919613942503929, -0.03168085590004921, 0.04334990307688713, -0.005962267518043518, -0.00002005405622185208, -0.008616960607469082, 0.039767321199178696, -0.03421354293823242, -0.004489589016884565, -0.056896746158599854, -0.013889728114008904, 0.035436127334833145, -0.021364104002714157, -0.018699711188673973, 0.008891981095075607, 0.0236530564725399, -0.034221101552248, -0.008665538392961025, -0.03767029568552971, -0.0035562857519835234, -0.0011629583314061165, -0.018720431253314018, -0.0010494595626369119, -0.003550158813595772, 0.016446955502033234, 0.040746208280324936, 0.02819312922656536, -0.007030073553323746, -0.012596482411026955, 0.0704641342163086, 0.009603687562048435, 0.0036687019746750593, 0.013571752235293388, 0.010936660692095757, 0.030858132988214493, 0.02689637988805771, -0.006795767229050398, 0.03098495490849018, 0.04679558798670769, -0.04111294075846672, -0.02528207004070282, -0.035633012652397156, 0.04230102524161339, 0.07278785109519958, 0.0003168522089254111, 0.03681410104036331, 0.05707544833421707, 0.010775696486234665, -0.05146302655339241, -0.030806155875325203, -0.002431282540783286, 0.013735665008425713, -0.020532861351966858, 0.04101948067545891, -0.00994593184441328, -0.022216903045773506, 0.042444340884685516, 0.012125336565077305, -0.009341671131551266, 0.011777328327298164, -0.01563301868736744, 0.04726903513073921, 0.0287074763327837, -0.06070065498352051, -0.0434715636074543, 0.04143945872783661, -0.05026799440383911, 0.01153056975454092, -0.004890174139291048, -0.029755057767033577, 0.027339689433574677, 0.025079265236854553, 0.04332439601421356, -0.025309834629297256, -0.02033819817006588, -0.027439426630735397, -0.0051979683339595795, 0.012224670499563217, -0.020951732993125916, 0.017591629177331924, -0.0015427571488544345, 0.0174469705671072, -0.014607129618525505, 0.016796134412288666, -0.026657352223992348, -0.05959303304553032, -0.040555261075496674, -0.004707564599812031, -0.042410481721162796, 0.029917702078819275, 0.030567746609449387, -0.021538814529776573, 0.04211549088358879, -0.006168200168758631, 0.028608908876776695, -0.001146903494372964, 0.02631664089858532, -0.01253283116966486, 0.07016705721616745, 0.003953501116484404, 0.008519441820681095, -0.030207408592104912, -0.01780659705400467, 0.09465856105089188, 0.08930855989456177, 0.00666832784190774, -0.039514727890491486, 0.01866713911294937, 0.0038854575250297785, -0.02074897289276123, -0.02276897057890892, 0.002019750652834773, 0.032492537051439285, 0.0031291309278458357, 0.02181585691869259, 0.042025815695524216, 0.028897827491164207, -0.02988860011100769, 0.050973642617464066, -0.04384186118841171, -0.017831329256296158, 0.0042135766707360744, -0.0008789908606559038, 0.0009856988908722997, -0.006734876427799463, -0.02134350873529911, 0.033854760229587555, -0.04944448545575142, -0.05705900490283966, -0.02484285831451416, -0.008405339904129505, 0.016162924468517303, -0.02560308389365673, -0.022380255162715912, 0.008999080397188663, 0.00590118020772934, -0.02034296840429306, -0.02819204330444336, 0.040593743324279785, -0.010720476508140564, 0.009095374494791031, 0.008771257475018501, 0.023853013291954994, 0.0025024309288710356, 0.004444617312401533, 0.008337958715856075, -0.005000733770430088, -0.03508897125720978, -0.02261480689048767, -0.05832917243242264, 0.07591105252504349, -0.035615552216768265, -0.0050318073481321335, -0.006837454624474049, -0.0041883825324475765, -0.01008286140859127, -0.057152699679136276, -0.02067774347960949, 0.005256980191916227, 0.03453901410102844, -0.014005378820002079, -0.016083382070064545, -0.0021877603139728308, 0.016235658898949623, 0.0010558220092207193, 0.030012065544724464, -0.0022244038991630077, -0.028719499707221985, -0.0239577554166317, 0.002797128167003393, 0.0714816227555275, 0.009494381956756115, 0.006034038029611111, -0.03422302380204201, -0.023133305832743645, -0.005324327852576971, -0.045410916209220886, 0.022082312032580376, -0.02526799589395523, 0.020347557961940765, 0.0024453119840472937, -0.01028487179428339, 0.006733717862516642, -0.06390044093132019, -0.0144709013402462, -0.05018603429198265, 0.0037503130733966827, -0.03592812642455101, -0.008383732289075851, 0.04495194926857948, 0.06942451000213623, 0.010528136044740677, -0.030259858816862106, -0.017330575734376907, 0.038799434900283813, 0.034830447286367416, -0.016418403014540672, -0.011996916495263577, -0.005486686248332262, -0.019746018573641777, 0.040367547422647476, 0.0011857545468956232, 0.04804496839642525, 0.028576375916600227, 0.027531323954463005, 0.021365035325288773, 0.048848506063222885, -0.03028015047311783, -0.02838754467666149, -0.003394909668713808, -0.044013265520334244, 0.016416680067777634, -0.0028511357959359884, 0.025042135268449783, -0.018539661541581154, 0.003606860525906086, -0.020165912806987762, -0.04687465727329254, -0.0016434593126177788, -0.049093738198280334, -0.007601934485137463, 0.015218251384794712, -0.020432941615581512, -0.001717939623631537, -0.01833093911409378, 0.03625841066241264, 0.013350894674658775, 0.008925147354602814, -0.025767533108592033, -0.018955785781145096, -0.025379657745361328, -0.018212923780083656, -0.03262128680944443, -0.015651294961571693, 0.01650639809668064, 0.012875141575932503, 0.008243842981755733, 0.003315926296636462, 0.002088034525513649, 0.03517051041126251, 0.05877438187599182, -0.0306254792958498, -0.007039615418761969, 0.03899087756872177, -0.07181195169687271, -0.04162302240729332, 0.058150630444288254, -0.02840518020093441, 0.05200850963592529, 0.0022666999138891697, -0.00012875218817498535, -0.03099178522825241, 0.020997479557991028, -0.004802572540938854, -0.02446797303855419, 0.00039459881372749805, 0.036746371537446976, -0.0015127324732020497, -0.0005320062045939267, 0.06749489903450012, -0.024854404851794243, -0.015591130591928959, 0.004411687608808279, 0.042938631027936935, -0.011653710156679153, 0.017509102821350098, 0.04002216085791588, -0.024726759642362595, 0.03510497510433197, 0.003612720873206854, 0.013977649621665478, 0.053939029574394226, 0.020073598250746727, -0.05106126144528389, 0.03166325390338898, -0.012681159190833569, 0.0190848708152771, -0.09215500950813293, -0.01768353581428528, 0.02576983906328678, 0.03254193067550659, 0.04775671660900116, -0.07816576957702637, -0.022411588579416275, 0.06586683541536331, -0.08325781673192978, 0.03036344423890114, 0.02011743187904358, 0.00487355375662446, -0.03582235425710678, 0.03331274166703224, -0.035350095480680466, 0.033456042408943176, 0.0076539660803973675, 0.05237967148423195, 0.033423930406570435, 0.039639443159103394, -0.011829798109829426, -0.024320872500538826, -0.0033395858481526375, -0.00017955570365302265, 0.03301810473203659, -0.07546032220125198, 0.041127000004053116, -0.04909583181142807, -0.008539417758584023, 0.005434784572571516, 0.003313411260023713, 0.032274279743433, -0.01769983023405075, 0.000005983446499158163, -0.02066049911081791, 0.05607813596725464, 0.019541215151548386, 0.00011221977911191061, 0.009264741092920303, -0.010050981305539608, -0.006994310300797224, 0.02054503746330738, -0.016952287405729294, -0.0010258926777169108, 0.009390247985720634, -0.0043084705248475075, -0.010851899161934853, 0.010752420872449875, -0.0017093971837311983, -0.015898993238806725, -0.006244052667170763, -0.0023217115085572004, -0.034147460013628006, -0.05809931457042694, 0.05086237192153931, -0.026717092841863632, -0.0062389434315264225, 0.020393654704093933, 0.035693444311618805, -0.02301253192126751, 0.012147926725447178, 0.006990788504481316, -0.058978885412216187, 0.015736298635601997, -0.02035178802907467, -0.004589522257447243, -0.10195090621709824, 0.0008383102249354124, -0.01623000204563141, -0.008988108485937119, -0.01263620238751173, -0.01276675146073103, -0.0594291053712368, 0.02123657613992691, 0.014351863414049149, -0.011940387077629566, 0.007006957195699215, 0.007818746380507946, -0.013983730226755142, -0.0932820588350296, 0.026235854253172874, 0.028101587668061256, 0.013709396123886108, -0.020107124000787735, -0.033888623118400574, -0.012166322208940983, -0.012254211120307446, 0.01767859235405922, 0.015241259709000587, -0.01497525256127119, 0.012803362682461739, 0.009813842363655567, 0.024473516270518303, -0.046561311930418015, 0.021871443837881088, -0.024095844477415085, -0.028551248833537102, -0.02735784649848938, -0.04252346605062485, 0.000796776614151895, -0.03755970299243927, 0.017731796950101852, 0.027575615793466568, -0.0015210763085633516, 0.007731211371719837, 0.006857498083263636, 0.02216477133333683, -0.00035247241612523794, 0.013792555779218674, 0.038854021579027176, 0.036343052983284, 0.00183209590613842, 0.0252097025513649, -0.02094920165836811, -0.06810269504785538, 0.006489033345133066, -0.026658324524760246, -0.032767049968242645, 0.007542942184954882, 0.0027769673615694046, -0.0047601209953427315, -0.043429527431726456, 0.0015568750677630305, 0.02865416742861271, -0.059136707335710526, -0.04380761831998825, 0.03054792433977127, -0.0020164819434285164, 0.01043018326163292, 0.009315956383943558, 0.030640700832009315, 0.018871784210205078, -0.01724935509264469, -0.0005431956960819662, 0.009786685928702354, 0.04821557551622391, -0.03362422063946724, 0.02380884438753128, 0.03423433378338814, -0.018440496176481247, 0.03437049314379692, -0.003676365362480283, 0.0659179836511612, -0.024777423590421677, -0.017350655049085617, 0.04566012695431709, -0.01523107010871172, 0.006727003492414951, 0.006921127438545227, -0.02836962603032589, 0.07716928422451019, -0.01962423138320446, -0.032784052193164825, -0.03766421228647232, -0.013780254870653152, 0.0007212663185782731, -0.0002766605466604233, 0.007151002995669842, 0.048247259110212326, 0.008537892252206802, 0.04318373277783394, -0.02882929891347885, 0.0003761956177186221, 0.021379075944423676, -0.04433344677090645, 0.02264774776995182, -0.010201952420175076, 0.0013734715757891536, -0.01242865715175867, -0.03613877668976784, -0.026418091729283333, -0.004544986877590418, 0.016196975484490395, 0.014708532951772213, 0.039736829698085785, -0.004946946166455746, -0.024966174736618996, -0.020576728507876396, 0.044899724423885345, -0.07630982995033264, -0.01185524556785822, -0.040851280093193054, 0.015546976588666439, -0.00890393927693367, -0.03002050518989563 ]
<p>I am analyzing rna-seq data in the format of counts. There is batch effect revealed by PCA. </p> <p>One method I tried called <strong>RUVseq</strong>, it estimated the variation basing on control genes, and then added it to design matrix. I don't know why simply adding a continuous variable will work.</p> <p>Here is an example, the experiment setting is:</p> <pre><code>samples groups A 1 B 1 C 1 D 2 E 2 F 2 G 3 H 3 I 3 </code></pre> <p>Then <strong>RUVseq</strong> methods could estimate the unwanted variation, for example, </p> <pre><code>B &lt;- (-0.37670272 , 2.44136463, -0.79533912, -0.05487747, 0.25014132, 0.61824329 -0.17262350 ,-2.22390027, -1.26361438) </code></pre> <p>Then combine them together:</p> <pre><code>samples groups B A 1 -0.37670272 B 1 2.44136463 C 1 -0.79533912 D 2 -0.05487747 E 2 0.25014132 F 2 0.61824329 G 3 -0.17262350 H 3 -2.22390027 I 3 -1.26361438 </code></pre> <p>Make a design matrix to fit glm, an example of design is </p> <pre><code>model.matrix( ~ 0 + groups + B) </code></pre> <p>My question is why this works? The coefficient of continuous variable means how many the read counts of genes will change of one unit of B changed, right? Then why B could be used for correcting the batch effect? </p>
73,597
[ -0.0365271121263504, 0.016894565895199776, 0.01012994721531868, 0.008102255873382092, 0.003804344218224287, 0.03149988129734993, 0.00709682097658515, -0.02568637579679489, 0.051808442920446396, -0.03477351740002632, 0.03167412802577019, 0.04289285093545914, 0.0519762858748436, -0.013503285124897957, 0.026557132601737976, 0.03682458773255348, -0.0012702812673524022, -0.006353538949042559, 0.0054961200803518295, 0.029391013085842133, -0.04086943343281746, 0.04018609970808029, 0.011858719401061535, 0.01677239127457142, -0.017372945323586464, 0.05324310064315796, 0.007093514781445265, -0.02626756578683853, -0.009928476996719837, 0.03763062134385109, -0.06731714308261871, -0.04517913982272148, 0.015050504356622696, 0.020472295582294464, 0.005416660103946924, -0.0017980376724153757, -0.0040945797227323055, -0.015213223174214363, -0.024141719564795494, 0.01284101977944374, -0.026395471766591072, 0.004810991697013378, -0.018185671418905258, 0.02833964116871357, -0.0006115143769420683, 0.025569595396518707, 0.019714439287781715, -0.025649402290582657, 0.0756027102470398, -0.027328355237841606, 0.07941948622465134, -0.022661224007606506, 0.04854446277022362, 0.02555892989039421, -0.011043231002986431, 0.008123560808598995, 0.06858081370592117, 0.045458849519491196, 0.013137859292328358, -0.03774293512105942, 0.005076826550066471, -0.046837110072374344, 0.03635505586862564, -0.017777221277356148, -0.03749028220772743, 0.014782107435166836, -0.00020826846593990922, -0.007541581057012081, 0.025685321539640427, -0.02618122473359108, 0.04648595675826073, -0.019500618800520897, 0.021956680342555046, -0.0014131393982097507, 0.03965262696146965, -0.0005129899946041405, -0.007412340957671404, 0.032247088849544525, 0.017985595390200615, 0.040697939693927765, -0.04747743159532547, 0.019773729145526886, 0.02118551731109619, 0.043253012001514435, -0.0015222481451928616, -0.014098187908530235, 0.03881353139877319, -0.07878835499286652, 0.0597773939371109, 0.018485357984900475, -0.018019596114754677, 0.01086626760661602, 0.060242097824811935, 0.05449454113841057, -0.03559394180774689, 0.06520531326532364, 0.0052893077954649925, 0.061868660151958466, -0.0008516538073308766, -0.04078495502471924, -0.015185635536909103, -0.05372975766658783, 0.0058596450835466385, 0.03263891115784645, -0.033196721225976944, 0.0012565002543851733, -0.03429798036813736, -0.0005087988683953881, -0.012700445018708706, -0.011715416796505451, 0.0022813163232058287, 0.012505348771810532, -0.03975468501448631, -0.05367254465818405, 0.028559843078255653, -0.026327555999159813, 0.008441046811640263, -0.009742086753249168, 0.09484492242336273, 0.0602961964905262, 0.05950882285833359, -0.02211541123688221, 0.014350696466863155, -0.010741209611296654, -0.038532618433237076, 0.021430714055895805, 0.021346362307667732, -0.012589830905199051, -0.04256608709692955, 0.042182426899671555, 0.030162930488586426, -0.04537373408675194, 0.03470909968018532, -0.00683001009747386, 0.010038831271231174, -0.0179220512509346, -0.06094792112708092, -0.033638209104537964, 0.06601851433515549, -0.024321507662534714, 0.014618178829550743, -0.06452751904726028, 0.02938523329794407, 0.024571940302848816, 0.07328318059444427, -0.009020071476697922, 0.039907801896333694, 0.015363814309239388, 0.005924093537032604, 0.006217280402779579, -0.018338540568947792, 0.012280912138521671, -0.03635898604989052, -0.035576652735471725, -0.06093256175518036, -0.06682135909795761, 0.03320097550749779, 0.02707640826702118, 0.009577758610248566, 0.04118550568819046, -0.009065761230885983, -0.01780647039413452, 0.010260190814733505, 0.001319989562034607, -0.034355632960796356, -0.0047073704190552235, 0.03246809542179108, 0.0005577929550781846, 0.022198116406798363, 0.05398549139499664, -0.034542858600616455, 0.04517608508467674, 0.016175204887986183, 0.05138308182358742, 0.006834317930042744, -0.012292151339352131, 0.01088770106434822, -0.03206538036465645, -0.0028710749465972185, 0.043680477887392044, -0.006066619418561459, -0.0268132071942091, -0.029522214084863663, -0.01453090738505125, 0.037675853818655014, 0.02346908301115036, -0.00978463888168335, -0.01676284335553646, 0.05013879016041756, -0.04516305401921272, -0.04545265808701515, -0.08031028509140015, 0.005473545286804438, 0.006186802405864, -0.04357709363102913, 0.006896036211401224, -0.00007626679871464148, 0.00021080752776470035, 0.007450227625668049, 0.009886729530990124, -0.03469638526439667, 0.005313715897500515, 0.022285765036940575, -0.006935215089470148, -0.018474115058779716, 0.022111866623163223, 0.06155458092689514, -0.007310890592634678, 0.06936231255531311, -0.017699379473924637, -0.04659930244088173, 0.031098488718271255, -0.022843990474939346, 0.003516013966873288, -0.021419016644358635, -0.03773301839828491, 0.00901706051081419, 0.01162815187126398, -0.03617694973945618, 0.03133825212717056, -0.07930351793766022, 0.04675546661019325, 0.09480682015419006, -0.008445537649095058, 0.03957552835345268, 0.033670131117105484, 0.0013680239208042622, 0.01312456838786602, -0.056846968829631805, 0.012053248472511768, -0.021339721977710724, -0.014589842408895493, 0.02482365071773529, -0.00009755868813954294, -0.0036376705393195152, -0.010496275499463081, 0.03675681725144386, 0.005681484006345272, 0.028370656073093414, 0.022208407521247864, 0.01018323004245758, -0.024045098572969437, 0.05600447580218315, 0.023370662704110146, 0.00818630587309599, -0.03557838127017021, -0.0017873935867100954, 0.009219521656632423, 0.05903497710824013, -0.016151420772075653, 0.004235940985381603, 0.04959573969244957, 0.001198043581098318, 0.003516936209052801, -0.01805976592004299, 0.016600366681814194, 0.028163617476820946, 0.008530594408512115, 0.04339255765080452, 0.03689452260732651, 0.003199053928256035, -0.01674625650048256, -0.009981800802052021, -0.03222758322954178, -0.01432096678763628, 0.04310537874698639, -0.04424142464995384, -0.008953121490776539, -0.0029251256491988897, -0.005734473932534456, 0.03325267881155014, -0.018620098009705544, -0.014208692125976086, -0.028886979445815086, 0.015560480765998363, -0.00007841218030080199, 0.03110482357442379, 0.04170558229088783, -0.02084508165717125, 0.01229891274124384, -0.01729305274784565, -0.01380473654717207, 0.033885274082422256, 0.0014370247954502702, -0.05348929762840271, 0.0024778747465461493, -0.041851188987493515, -0.002814314793795347, 0.046656642109155655, -0.01494266651570797, -0.052979111671447754, 0.005059821996837854, -0.0076570333912968636, -0.03927485644817352, -0.015035249292850494, -0.021316831931471825, 0.009270611219108105, 0.03259144723415375, -0.038390420377254486, 0.05100183188915253, 0.026035984978079796, -0.027206284925341606, 0.011491883546113968, -0.0341356061398983, 0.050301410257816315, -0.006708111613988876, -0.03956480324268341, -0.008834611624479294, -0.00970237422734499, -0.004607850685715675, 0.007389635778963566, -0.02361960895359516, -0.019053826108574867, -0.05344196781516075, -0.05721837282180786, 0.014880506321787834, 0.008051536045968533, 0.05408356711268425, 0.0032741758041083813, -0.01992713287472725, 0.06180326268076897, 0.013327516615390778, -0.05417775735259056, -0.032291751354932785, -0.012797607108950615, -0.04357796907424927, -0.03380853310227394, 0.021274426952004433, 0.021659038960933685, 0.05640812963247299, 0.03359628841280937, 0.016470789909362793, 0.03525317460298538, 0.06934720277786255, 0.01924697868525982, -0.03932734578847885, 0.029030606150627136, 0.007649961393326521, 0.004960240796208382, 0.00679611973464489, 0.010600768961012363, 0.029852325096726418, 0.007855742238461971, -0.004873586352914572, 0.010322335176169872, -0.038883570581674576, -0.048948563635349274, 0.009580526500940323, -0.011615634895861149, 0.02268814481794834, -0.026102442294359207, 0.02898741513490677, 0.008735490031540394, -0.04583658277988434, -0.01245050597935915, 0.031103409826755524, 0.025627056136727333, -0.06255342811346054, -0.01998005248606205, -0.003666278440505266, 0.032111313194036484, -0.03436192870140076, 0.015351256355643272, -0.008032110519707203, -0.0057489750906825066, 0.019349826499819756, -0.04602601006627083, -0.03566405177116394, 0.023090556263923645, 0.03531947731971741, -0.012940337881445885, -0.020088491961359978, -0.045901425182819366, -0.019853176549077034, -0.032824866473674774, 0.021492257714271545, 0.0024791003670543432, 0.04762446880340576, -0.01422063447535038, 0.07258834689855576, 0.00008288895332952961, -0.01195836067199707, 0.019338777288794518, -0.057983096688985825, -0.056305624544620514, 0.007457186467945576, 0.025328708812594414, -0.009067895822227001, 0.0063593522645533085, -0.03269102796912193, 0.041824378073215485, -0.008150422014296055, 0.011762632988393307, 0.011379626579582691, -0.004709148779511452, -0.009405332617461681, -0.025231190025806427, 0.02462608925998211, 0.015329286456108093, -0.03644333407282829, -0.012351364828646183, 0.027231695130467415, -0.027596140280365944, 0.03156472370028496, -0.002984141232445836, -0.009425917640328407, -0.023921191692352295, -0.031522490084171295, -0.03176181763410568, 0.04093312472105026, 0.05825174227356911, 0.06825529038906097, 0.0291147381067276, -0.03302880749106407, 0.0252786073833704, 0.02548743598163128, 0.028812887147068977, 0.04867247864603996, -0.009226320311427116, -0.02584770694375038, -0.026525387540459633, 0.00772427162155509, -0.0003582853532861918, 0.004720976110547781, 0.02445400319993496, -0.0013705722521990538, 0.05984511226415634, 0.047519393265247345, -0.0745837464928627, 0.004337163642048836, 0.07259699702262878, 0.024036020040512085, 0.014102834276854992, -0.03008718229830265, 0.03101317025721073, -0.027909355238080025, -0.010833686217665672, 0.04426461085677147, 0.01702352799475193, 0.0009377311216667295, 0.006747586652636528, 0.04667655751109123, 0.0063188043422997, -0.05568980053067207, 0.0002116277755703777, 0.008333849720656872, 0.02374473214149475, 0.011474902741611004, -0.02220747619867325, -0.03383422642946243, 0.06836851686239243, 0.003544968320056796, -0.01337064802646637, 0.001900379778817296, -0.07655102014541626, 0.015851512551307678, 0.006543165538460016, 0.03553361818194389, -0.037377309054136276, -0.008469398133456707, -0.03680194169282913, -0.02282506600022316, -0.038862574845552444, -0.05317910388112068, 0.021713735535740852, -0.04477289319038391, 0.03015245869755745, -0.0399479977786541, -0.025453386828303337, -0.05963300168514252, 0.023852363228797913, -0.021028617396950722, 0.017751004546880722, 0.0154774971306324, -0.033386245369911194, -0.013500700704753399, -0.021891091018915176, -0.024783870205283165, 0.024439239874482155, -0.05764290690422058, -0.03669002652168274, 0.038503024727106094, 0.04160899668931961, -0.029645470902323723, -0.04252082481980324, 0.02472158521413803, -0.018360329791903496, 0.012468243949115276, 0.036043960601091385, -0.014430593699216843, -0.012673159129917622, -0.0005189850344322622, 0.042339835315942764, 0.006318679079413414, -0.017336124554276466, -0.02560262382030487, 0.0294874906539917, 0.033146876841783524, -0.06294156610965729, 0.06415323168039322, 0.00423773005604744, -0.028769925236701965, 0.028105420991778374, -0.061819855123758316, 0.0008585993200540543, 0.00013533543096855283, -0.03561645373702049, -0.03876065835356712, -0.006095393095165491, 0.013558810576796532, 0.01810983568429947, 0.017316780984401703, 0.02658301778137684, -0.01778583973646164, 0.0009278931538574398, 0.037173520773649216, 0.04788957163691521, 0.005461378488689661, -0.03024519793689251, 0.02388880029320717, -0.0047582159750163555, -0.004856312181800604, -0.04221850261092186, 0.046180360019207, 0.007547801360487938, 0.011777008883655071, 0.021494807675480843, -0.03691183775663376, 0.005890503525733948, 0.010611848905682564, -0.037753183394670486, 0.026500431820750237, -0.03627776354551315, 0.01574080064892769, -0.0266529880464077, 0.0841040089726448, -0.023431919515132904, -0.038926493376493454, -0.01630992628633976, 0.015382965095341206, -0.03449930250644684, 0.003006892278790474, -0.025981033220887184, 0.03691885992884636, -0.01699673756957054, 0.0108067961409688, -0.0681949183344841, -0.05160374566912651, 0.01930282451212406, -0.017648302018642426, -0.01823114976286888, -0.028399812057614326, -0.03822031617164612, 0.0002461750991642475, 0.0054066237062215805, 0.008431831374764442, 0.053621575236320496, -0.03890480846166611, -0.046086154878139496, -0.03133496269583702, 0.03831849247217178, 0.05959146469831467, 0.012951629236340523, -0.004220281727612019, 0.04087230563163757, -0.027073204517364502, -0.005422680638730526, 0.004429051652550697, -0.02215041033923626, -0.04921405762434006, 0.0014363356167450547, -0.027754249051213264, -0.004180560819804668, 0.05132586136460304, -0.022854095324873924, -0.04104885458946228, 0.01751757599413395, -0.0177585668861866, 0.033621035516262054, -0.03586570918560028, 0.0034102629870176315, -0.04867397993803024, 0.0032287936192005873, -0.03843940049409866, 0.00005207912181504071, -0.022501487284898758, -0.007475825026631355, 0.055381085723638535, -0.016139520332217216, -0.03730301186442375, 0.017393961548805237, 0.0782446637749672, -0.005933899898082018, 0.02027142234146595, 0.005092542618513107, -0.02766438014805317, 0.011036508716642857, -0.01485315803438425, 0.02221566252410412, 0.004664365667849779, 0.021367140114307404, -0.03130194544792175, -0.000415782502386719, -0.06210630387067795, 0.021954094991087914, 0.02893936075270176, 0.008469672873616219, 0.030744051560759544, 0.04276794195175171, -0.005763499531894922, -0.026539769023656845, -0.012609163299202919, 0.0015765741700306535, 0.013488066382706165, 0.0028560247737914324, 0.05357261747121811, 0.0006093922420404851, -0.006362630520015955, 0.007666329853236675, 0.029995771124958992, 0.035949233919382095, 0.017899205908179283, 0.019968856126070023, 0.009075055830180645, -0.01609213650226593, 0.021217063069343567, -0.016715601086616516, 0.05386235564947128, -0.04200316593050957, -0.011374754831194878, -0.037726350128650665, -0.01726815663278103, 0.020599203184247017, 0.03679727390408516, -0.023527605459094048, -0.04210934415459633, -0.044260259717702866, -0.0433339849114418, 0.002999427728354931, 0.01553012989461422, -0.007015861105173826, 0.03790517896413803, -0.000051355389587115496, 0.011782769113779068, 0.007812283001840115, 0.0550265796482563, -0.052348919212818146, -0.035655464977025986, -0.043426115065813065, -0.043064918369054794, 0.006268416065722704, 0.0420420877635479, -0.010109435766935349, -0.036122314631938934, 0.013548302464187145, -0.009704810567200184, 0.01018598023802042, 0.027188612148165703, 0.029792562127113342, -0.016758637502789497, 0.04863567650318146, -0.018889065831899643, 0.029169436544179916, -0.010096993297338486, -0.023888466879725456, 0.10354440659284592, 0.07088527083396912, 0.043110016733407974, -0.08424465358257294, 0.01567886397242546, 0.03190510347485542, 0.021931970492005348, -0.03492147848010063, 0.005206651519984007, 0.03185538575053215, 0.003871656022965908, 0.026677338406443596, 0.02310798317193985, 0.03373471274971962, 0.0072698392905294895, 0.028834745287895203, -0.02414950542151928, -0.03147496283054352, 0.021867921575903893, -0.009490245021879673, 0.0012088533258065581, -0.04719531908631325, -0.03731844201683998, -0.012717814184725285, 0.04195469617843628, -0.036076221615076065, -0.0456039123237133, 0.0006026268238201737, -0.02607712708413601, 0.012576939538121223, -0.008957820013165474, 0.008045337162911892, -0.021581854671239853, 0.011853556148707867, -0.016588909551501274, -0.040730178356170654, 0.0008001846144907176, -0.002553733065724373, -0.014146954752504826, 0.023404289036989212, -0.011592655442655087, -0.016983026638627052, -0.005345688667148352, 0.05488801747560501, -0.015321957878768444, -0.03072555549442768, -0.030277421697974205, 0.0810825526714325, -0.003872619243338704, -0.003198500256985426, 0.016933433711528778, 0.003073281142860651, -0.029730455949902534, -0.030989717692136765, -0.033787358552217484, 0.02835271693766117, 0.004794659558683634, 0.004860561806708574, -0.03689299896359444, -0.02288065105676651, 0.013751788064837456, -0.009877546690404415, 0.003295466536656022, 0.06599121540784836, -0.050490330904722214, -0.016935614868998528, -0.012486533261835575, 0.04913516342639923, -0.022538358345627785, 0.025465648621320724, 0.015004776418209076, 0.010259849950671196, -0.024319486692547798, -0.023185739293694496, 0.01872280240058899, 0.03748512640595436, 0.03211226314306259, -0.014506899751722813, -0.007747193798422813, -0.013985509052872658, -0.009473659098148346, 0.0029562029521912336, -0.03595270216464996, -0.014829201623797417, -0.06065789982676506, 0.0062350258231163025, 0.008584325201809406, 0.037513118237257004, -0.011630109511315823, 0.023061515763401985, -0.016452768817543983, 0.0458596833050251, -0.0072773597203195095, -0.04431332275271416, -0.018432334065437317, 0.02062920108437538, -0.011924822814762592, -0.016444407403469086, 0.01796255260705948, 0.06930039077997208, 0.024589790031313896, 0.003595529356971383, -0.011965878307819366, 0.029289450496435165, 0.007641870994120836, -0.0026149428449571133, 0.053852081298828125, -0.04038107022643089, 0.009456146508455276, 0.03642524778842926, -0.013532361947000027, -0.007562282029539347, -0.001039785915054381, -0.03002040646970272, -0.060406289994716644, 0.008685705251991749, -0.03747556731104851, -0.035895925015211105, 0.00013998021313454956, -0.02603394351899624, 0.017002156004309654, -0.042365167289972305, -0.014105642214417458, -0.04222138226032257, -0.0029375215526670218, -0.04954173043370247, -0.03866830840706825, -0.0014718810562044382, 0.0038729419466108084, -0.001327050500549376, 0.01249115914106369, 0.0033797272481024265, -0.000835500075481832, 0.03184260055422783, -0.008504503406584263, 0.02893105335533619, 0.0038577429950237274, -0.0003781067207455635, 0.00421492662280798, -0.06583956629037857, 0.030345896258950233, -0.06129264459013939, -0.023678163066506386, 0.012447012588381767, -0.017028935253620148, 0.019708795472979546, -0.022737892344594002, -0.01199339795857668, 0.002432543784379959, 0.03476391360163689, -0.020907286554574966, -0.009777790866792202, -0.026480769738554955, 0.007383908610790968, -0.03891691565513611, -0.04944070428609848, 0.01133310329169035, 0.011873709969222546, -0.008244721218943596, 0.03977154567837715, 0.06002582982182503, 0.000940581550821662, -0.024680353701114655, 0.018878422677516937, -0.02224680595099926, 0.02453209087252617, 0.010439345613121986, 0.022590411826968193, 0.04011256620287895, 0.013459119945764542, -0.012623540125787258, 0.001915393047966063, -0.021984511986374855, 0.01708800159394741, -0.05940557271242142, -0.03985747694969177, 0.008127793669700623, 0.035280775278806686, -0.0050697773694992065, -0.07021153718233109, 0.0002317982871318236, 0.022219736129045486, -0.03873287886381149, -0.033526238054037094, -0.047747332602739334, -0.011086112819612026, -0.042128391563892365, 0.03754274174571037, -0.04450647160410881, 0.015732217580080032, 0.027965469285845757, -0.0033276344183832407, 0.06721662729978561, 0.014577834866940975, 0.010934663936495781, -0.04966428875923157, 0.007735089864581823, 0.01648731529712677, 0.055487941950559616, -0.041712529957294464, 0.028672384098172188, -0.008582035079598427, -0.0238841213285923, 0.022018494084477425, 0.017894376069307327, -0.0061865029856562614, 0.06031285971403122, 0.058875516057014465, 0.017259184271097183, 0.045854587107896805, 0.010372203774750233, 0.012439263984560966, -0.0019879378378391266, -0.0018630479462444782, 0.009168201126158237, 0.0274322722107172, -0.010065913200378418, 0.06515173614025116, 0.014973276294767857, -0.014339580200612545, 0.02432258054614067, 0.00044313177932053804, 0.006927557289600372, -0.01630364917218685, 0.0065680574625730515, 0.026292843744158745, 0.003394338069483638, -0.04663744196295738, 0.018947169184684753, -0.04800727590918541, 0.0145544009283185, 0.027574295178055763, 0.022031454369425774, -0.012136190198361874, 0.022985538467764854, 0.015556597150862217, -0.01250727940350771, 0.009192241355776787, -0.011598949320614338, 0.0008454920607618988, -0.0753331407904625, -0.022297555580735207, -0.012351468205451965, -0.021611832082271576, -0.04665670916438103, 0.01484924927353859, -0.06831548362970352, 0.05830560624599457, 0.0013412825064733624, -0.005753740668296814, -0.006696756929159164, 0.0036288504488766193, 0.03274836391210556, -0.06419011205434799, 0.09016788005828857, 0.0011250819079577923, 0.012418469414114952, -0.01822935789823532, 0.02130183018743992, -0.0597434937953949, 0.05342778190970421, 0.01853463239967823, 0.005380245856940746, 0.0026089756283909082, 0.02265027165412903, 0.056346345692873, -0.007239073049277067, -0.02533915638923645, 0.06299416720867157, -0.025921642780303955, -0.02259356714785099, -0.038640350103378296, -0.0033678796608000994, 0.006085400003939867, 0.04395397752523422, 0.0019729710184037685, -0.02672564424574375, 0.008761473931372166, -0.003858109237626195, -0.030956868082284927, 0.018457207828760147, 0.001833012094721198, -0.004102128092199564, 0.03876786679029465, 0.0020526451990008354, 0.03464994952082634, 0.04828031733632088, 0.007236822973936796, -0.024973979219794273, 0.02056400664150715, -0.03597693890333176, 0.008079095743596554, 0.03163908049464226, -0.006575123872607946, -0.005355268716812134, 0.0005921442061662674, -0.00492978235706687, 0.03512462601065636, -0.07092706114053726, 0.03361012414097786, 0.0010191850597038865, 0.006831672973930836, 0.04363790899515152, -0.007247623987495899, 0.02703692577779293, -0.005396870896220207, -0.016224876046180725, 0.006983623374253511, 0.019469277933239937, 0.047289084643125534, 0.014949892647564411, 0.01388974767178297, 0.023571748286485672, -0.04490918666124344, 0.03314077854156494, 0.007039370946586132, 0.01406168844550848, -0.0354253314435482, -0.006847474258393049, -0.016641706228256226, -0.019867926836013794, 0.016201797872781754, 0.01768137887120247, -0.009320436045527458, 0.03868101164698601, -0.04404183477163315, 0.011617830954492092, -0.013208509422838688, -0.00162801262922585, -0.0035450186114758253, 0.006710544694215059, -0.0016967005794867873, 0.061699748039245605, 0.01668635942041874, 0.008420271798968315, -0.01016924437135458, -0.03486286848783493, -0.01514608133584261, -0.013724335469305515, 0.007796301972121, -0.0163069237023592, -0.01176618505269289, -0.010229489766061306, -0.003324971068650484, 0.011780669912695885, -0.05381341651082039, 0.02832360565662384, 0.02631779946386814, 0.01102262269705534, -0.035772472620010376, -0.04604889824986458, 0.01840745098888874, 0.04831809923052788, -0.04955671727657318, -0.032957762479782104, -0.014999558217823505, 0.005304092541337013, -0.020167546346783638, -0.016499724239110947 ]
<p>This has been originally asked at <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/480703/most-common-subgroups?noredirect=1#comment1035243_480703">math.stackexchange</a> where it was suggested that I try Cross Validated.</p> <p>My background is not mathematics. This is an IT problem that may have a mathematical solution:</p> <p>I have a large amount of sets of variables. The variables belong to a distinct set of data (for example, each variable may be the age of a person in years, in which case, my potential range has about 100 values). Each set has an unspecified number of data points (for the sake of making things easier to understand, lets assume that each set is the ages of people in a restaurant table): </p> <ul> <li>set 1: {1, 100, 2, 3}</li> <li>set 2: {3, 4, 45, 2 ,1 ,34, 65, 33, 59, 32}</li> <li>set 3: {40} </li> <li>etc. etc. </li> </ul> <p>I need to identify common subsets within the data. So ideally I would like to look at a few millions of sets and determine that in 20% of these sets you can find the subset (30, 45, 50) for example. Which would then suggest that if you see a 50 year old and a 45 year old, then there is a good chance that a 30 year old will join them - or something similar)</p> <p>Can anyone provide a few pointers?</p> <hr> <p>Some more information which should make this easier to understand:</p> <p>Again, thanks to @whuber for the guidance.</p> <ol> <li>The values are not numbers. I think that the best description I can provide is something like product names. Therefore there is no error in their measurement and there is a finite number of them which is known beforehand.</li> <li>There is a possibility to associate the values to each other, i.e. 'A' may be closely related to 'B' where as 'A' may be completely unrelated to 'C'. In any case, I may not be able to quantify the relationship, so for now I have to assume that there is no connection between the values. </li> </ol>
73,598
[ -0.047764819115400314, -0.014428059570491314, 0.011689563281834126, -0.019060857594013214, 0.015921013429760933, -0.029048416763544083, -0.015370883047580719, -0.028310060501098633, 0.04454982280731201, -0.023319492116570473, 0.06033151596784592, 0.023396100848913193, 0.026388540863990784, 0.026171265169978142, 0.01136652659624815, 0.022365137934684753, 0.016404028981924057, -0.012294700369238853, -0.0022434000857174397, -0.025097167119383812, 0.04032906889915466, 0.003299785777926445, 0.00535722728818655, -0.04184097424149513, -0.03843273967504501, -0.002191627398133278, 0.011620776727795601, -0.048021990805864334, -0.01944659650325775, 0.04860205203294754, -0.05211515724658966, -0.07738321274518967, 0.036187976598739624, 0.027236929163336754, 0.03762858361005783, 0.007383737713098526, -0.011426334269344807, 0.005048352759331465, -0.02483297325670719, 0.010257554240524769, -0.050612203776836395, 0.004645253997296095, 0.0004392980190459639, 0.038203027099370956, -0.0020738253369927406, 0.008672239258885384, -0.0009217637707479298, -0.005218511912971735, 0.004136066418141127, -0.04406167194247246, 0.08120348304510117, -0.0009326633298769593, 0.044881995767354965, 0.02728126384317875, -0.02663588896393776, -0.03069918602705002, 0.03678814321756363, 0.06274166703224182, 0.01746990904211998, -0.07956572622060776, -0.031372927129268646, 0.00835635606199503, 0.0024110092781484127, 0.004560086876153946, -0.03918641433119774, 0.03377212584018707, -0.01861230470240116, 0.016603488475084305, 0.030025700107216835, -0.005469451658427715, 0.032104045152664185, 0.04642050713300705, 0.05314727872610092, -0.014188971370458603, 0.02391837351024151, -0.011620969511568546, 0.013894924893975258, -0.020685406401753426, 0.054667405784130096, 0.033466655761003494, -0.012210824526846409, -0.009524879045784473, -0.006466285325586796, 0.02171378955245018, 0.01913830265402794, -0.03401513025164604, 0.07222909480333328, -0.04321601614356041, -0.02408044971525669, 0.00352880940772593, 0.009016063064336777, -0.03351600468158722, 0.033170185983181, 0.03139747306704521, -0.03460579365491867, 0.041160617023706436, -0.032819412648677826, 0.012229741550981998, 0.004679588135331869, 0.03948502615094185, 0.019205894321203232, -0.023341717198491096, 0.008935774676501751, 0.06779924035072327, -0.011491650715470314, -0.033116016536951065, -0.02115820348262787, -0.04958892986178398, -0.004420098382979631, -0.007388726808130741, 0.023547083139419556, 0.02044125832617283, 0.0030547098722308874, 0.028329871594905853, 0.04032032564282417, -0.024888211861252785, -0.019447211176156998, -0.017339615151286125, 0.044778335839509964, 0.03708841651678085, 0.021434398368000984, -0.022824756801128387, 0.01614486239850521, -0.01876896433532238, -0.013606208376586437, 0.028025252744555473, 0.010799618437886238, 0.03361140564084053, -0.025291087105870247, 0.07238912582397461, -0.03354271501302719, -0.022457683458924294, 0.054455894976854324, -0.0022671278566122055, 0.039120256900787354, 0.009625493548810482, -0.11031461507081985, -0.03305484727025032, 0.02057502046227455, 0.03582291305065155, -0.04093999043107033, -0.04582973197102547, 0.013696953654289246, 0.04237857460975647, 0.018740717321634293, -0.014502043835818768, -0.014242749661207199, 0.04021401330828667, 0.04387853667140007, 0.04146421700716019, -0.022022567689418793, 0.0005406773998402059, 0.005180364474654198, -0.011142024770379066, -0.00142038450576365, -0.027717916294932365, 0.010485516861081123, 0.01565343700349331, -0.02283465676009655, -0.013108215294778347, -0.017749274149537086, -0.013207262381911278, -0.011591457761824131, 0.0358281135559082, 0.07162152230739594, -0.009907185100018978, 0.07665460556745529, 0.011010892689228058, 0.005775154568254948, 0.05310128256678581, -0.054145872592926025, 0.016753869131207466, 0.014320344664156437, 0.010916211642324924, 0.059830307960510254, 0.006707148160785437, 0.009863406419754028, -0.011977027170360088, -0.022490516304969788, 0.011539514176547527, -0.025191815569996834, -0.03625430911779404, -0.06999523192644119, 0.0023248535580933094, 0.06698489189147949, 0.018561435863375664, 0.009755722247064114, -0.017296409234404564, 0.047722041606903076, -0.07828023284673691, -0.006591937504708767, -0.02324672043323517, -0.024544166401028633, -0.009081032127141953, -0.03893532231450081, 0.008718705736100674, 0.0035965493880212307, -0.035192668437957764, -0.042182087898254395, -0.042981233447790146, -0.03709661588072777, -0.009079137817025185, 0.06191869452595711, -0.04838842526078224, 0.0006676283665001392, 0.028801627457141876, 0.04467169567942619, -0.060854505747556686, 0.019772104918956757, -0.03548330068588257, -0.0509716272354126, 0.01017087884247303, -0.028327981010079384, 0.018678732216358185, -0.014699667692184448, -0.0032330118119716644, 0.03395994380116463, 0.03232830762863159, -0.01841522753238678, 0.022206151857972145, -0.05892788618803024, 0.009759458713233471, 0.04806900769472122, 0.01121750008314848, 0.004126477055251598, -0.0232688020914793, 0.0004616276128217578, 0.041058722883462906, -0.021959874778985977, 0.006725214887410402, -0.10402397811412811, -0.02979941852390766, 0.02291550673544407, 0.04443180561065674, -0.010829360224306583, -0.0015552244149148464, 0.07196817547082901, 0.02638458088040352, 0.0025524015072733164, -0.003349738661199808, -0.02963593229651451, 0.006998469587415457, 0.037034302949905396, 0.021141447126865387, 0.022858887910842896, 0.03645170480012894, -0.02253062278032303, 0.021022211760282516, 0.012295164167881012, 0.01654844358563423, 0.015400532633066177, 0.011374632827937603, 0.03917400911450386, -0.012181710451841354, -0.040458645671606064, -0.0016983739333227277, 0.0391460619866848, -0.014619456604123116, -0.03005835972726345, 0.019954264163970947, 0.013943293131887913, -0.041155580431222916, 0.005113176070153713, -0.038090456277132034, -0.029386773705482483, 0.059401433914899826, -0.031533826142549515, -0.005093533545732498, 0.003661038354039192, -0.06063612550497055, -0.004078578669577837, -0.01905183121562004, -0.05206307768821716, -0.016794759780168533, 0.010819702409207821, 0.010019992478191853, -0.013393828645348549, 0.022490598261356354, -0.05361959710717201, -0.0015050878282636404, -0.013207483105361462, -0.00812150351703167, 0.007995390333235264, -0.003558345604687929, -0.05939634144306183, -0.011087041348218918, -0.01522638089954853, -0.026319917291402817, 0.018258197233080864, -0.0020636804401874542, -0.015938404947519302, 0.03877167031168938, 0.02378375455737114, -0.042763371020555496, -0.034616850316524506, -0.034600142389535904, 0.05307237431406975, -0.028222771361470222, 0.025133073329925537, 0.015764186158776283, 0.046044643968343735, -0.06463765352964401, 0.004288514610379934, -0.01165572740137577, -0.02257983386516571, -0.032496124505996704, -0.03620155528187752, 0.0040015047416090965, 0.013431472703814507, -0.04030701518058777, 0.03457530587911606, 0.031705230474472046, 0.019069189205765724, -0.06742211431264877, -0.08765757083892822, -0.003044700715690851, 0.03006906993687153, 0.049594007432460785, 0.023243309929966927, 0.0050339121371507645, 0.0447751022875309, 0.01696164533495903, -0.04614271596074104, -0.05099307373166084, -0.00754941301420331, 0.002012862591072917, -0.034595221281051636, 0.05528688058257103, 0.016991112381219864, -0.020093418657779694, 0.027682486921548843, 0.030780481174588203, 0.04541546478867531, 0.0507204607129097, -0.012521199882030487, 0.012244644574820995, 0.013738756068050861, 0.012540838681161404, -0.014824398793280125, 0.060521822422742844, 0.02230238914489746, -0.060678236186504364, -0.007220193278044462, -0.007043341640383005, 0.030868053436279297, 0.03306153044104576, -0.07707318663597107, 0.013131038285791874, -0.0339009128510952, 0.025708813220262527, -0.004339525941759348, -0.004825470969080925, 0.02304166369140148, -0.054518211632966995, -0.004087397828698158, 0.042689189314842224, 0.05922245234251022, -0.003430828219279647, -0.012193835340440273, 0.08621292561292648, 0.037890903651714325, -0.03840125352144241, -0.022767318412661552, -0.01197995338588953, -0.03601450473070145, -0.005087185651063919, 0.005669265985488892, -0.012342797592282295, -0.005554180592298508, 0.06208139657974243, -0.006908314302563667, 0.009688189253211021, -0.015261271968483925, 0.00820517260581255, -0.09095369279384613, -0.030290765687823296, -0.03845122084021568, 0.038770608603954315, 0.008321499451994896, 0.05950040742754936, 0.012002185918390751, -0.015918182209134102, -0.05041414499282837, 0.003941351547837257, -0.07585063576698303, 0.020244430750608444, -0.013950247317552567, -0.0029402754735201597, -0.010877933353185654, -0.08068155497312546, 0.03676033020019531, 0.00013484990631695837, -0.008670952171087265, -0.005547485779970884, 0.05596015229821205, -0.023095669224858284, -0.01988697424530983, -0.01278314832597971, 0.02320118062198162, 0.0033510096836835146, 0.02616281807422638, 0.03382952883839607, 0.0010520346695557237, 0.030255256220698357, 0.040803227573633194, 0.0175488144159317, -0.038892339915037155, -0.034203991293907166, -0.0018069815123453736, 0.004044227302074432, 0.046090953052043915, -0.008908172138035297, 0.013021256774663925, -0.025072071701288223, 0.00478779710829258, -0.017763666808605194, 0.01788920909166336, 0.039551205933094025, 0.00680009787902236, -0.00563242519274354, 0.02032489702105522, -0.006618245970457792, -0.001028970000334084, 0.008324271067976952, -0.021585891023278236, 0.0014991714851930737, 0.05138086900115013, 0.03871266171336174, -0.05170381814241409, 0.011332905851304531, 0.050557270646095276, 0.024680187925696373, -0.032194942235946655, -0.01970936730504036, -0.05165204405784607, 0.0041947271674871445, 0.026474183425307274, 0.00788895133882761, 0.026683736592531204, 0.023263495415449142, -0.010242310352623463, 0.061144668608903885, 0.027339624240994453, -0.09254807233810425, 0.05218349024653435, 0.014341489411890507, 0.017140185460448265, -0.04435054585337639, -0.05983848497271538, -0.011165618896484375, 0.03208370506763458, 0.04939975589513779, 0.013310502283275127, 0.01897553913295269, -0.09772682934999466, 0.003200278850272298, 0.027589233592152596, 0.07790668308734894, -0.036815300583839417, 0.0010208884486928582, -0.03172774612903595, -0.011886323802173138, 0.032443515956401825, -0.010902061127126217, 0.024644389748573303, -0.020376842468976974, -0.007277683820575476, -0.048893269151449203, -0.0689317137002945, -0.006058734375983477, -0.0236472487449646, -0.048116009682416916, 0.012470461428165436, -0.007273412775248289, -0.016685189679265022, -0.026038758456707, 0.023721424862742424, 0.02738730050623417, 0.03848478943109512, -0.009750226512551308, -0.002804673509672284, 0.02065866068005562, 0.02248183824121952, 0.002900988096371293, -0.06494583934545517, 0.042015329003334045, 0.015015987679362297, -0.019836699590086937, 0.04657229036092758, -0.017450878396630287, -0.021600380539894104, 0.006464300211519003, 0.029740547761321068, 0.002575040329247713, -0.0014001061208546162, -0.021695775911211967, 0.060396164655685425, 0.03644385188817978, 0.010358275845646858, 0.03370783478021622, 0.03230303153395653, -0.015970658510923386, 0.015108063817024231, -0.05178516358137131, -0.0016970213036984205, -0.013359635137021542, 0.0034402147866785526, -0.057710807770490646, -0.020874468609690666, -0.01930833049118519, 0.0027664746157824993, -0.03369208425283432, 0.005994517356157303, -0.018945841118693352, -0.012527277693152428, -0.007603505626320839, 0.037836864590644836, -0.0014894114574417472, 0.027293533086776733, 0.014308680780231953, 0.03473435714840889, 0.0071381982415914536, -0.014966200105845928, 0.07576286792755127, -0.0343455970287323, 0.01199127547442913, 0.007981718517839909, -0.010294443927705288, 0.013082468882203102, -0.061876922845840454, -0.013190178200602531, -0.00602019252255559, -0.003967201802879572, 0.037843458354473114, 0.004116387572139502, 0.049328189343214035, 0.030586212873458862, 0.0070635657757520676, -0.0021138377487659454, 0.020434129983186722, 0.0017274770652875304, 0.034639228135347366, 0.014142759144306183, 0.030605442821979523, -0.03113512322306633, -0.006929834373295307, -0.021596206352114677, -0.009822114370763302, 0.023081352934241295, 0.030809879302978516, -0.013862771913409233, -0.05486016720533371, -0.028463762253522873, -0.016242045909166336, -0.0067835114896297455, -0.022977730259299278, 0.06298916041851044, -0.026852289214730263, -0.0006955647841095924, 0.0007198653183877468, 0.01641441322863102, 0.07077426463365555, 0.014118012972176075, 0.005711095407605171, 0.013262693770229816, 0.05579721927642822, 0.00763460760936141, 0.003016606206074357, -0.02286534383893013, -0.034904904663562775, -0.045795194804668427, -0.016339531168341637, 0.011931579560041428, 0.02050052210688591, -0.03946612775325775, -0.008892027661204338, -0.028543947264552116, -0.011938915587961674, -0.003258694661781192, -0.005533015355467796, 0.02550744079053402, -0.011942925862967968, -0.02105209417641163, -0.018509255722165108, 0.03177165612578392, -0.02540695294737816, -0.015940792858600616, 0.01638125069439411, -0.03577466681599617, -0.04964125156402588, 0.027036240324378014, 0.06995179504156113, -0.01689717173576355, -0.014533072710037231, 0.003956956788897514, -0.025814976543188095, 0.06645402312278748, 0.007701382972300053, -0.012002313509583473, -0.016845382750034332, 0.0310736782848835, -0.019531169906258583, -0.01989034004509449, -0.03508100286126137, -0.03345342352986336, 0.05371925234794617, -0.004573171492666006, 0.042125239968299866, 0.049520667642354965, -0.02344466559588909, 0.0003382094146218151, -0.00122226367238909, 0.014261576347053051, -0.00786929577589035, -0.006395274307578802, 0.026587828993797302, -0.01224738359451294, -0.02104353904724121, 0.028025154024362564, 0.004008458461612463, 0.03313073143362999, 0.010379048064351082, 0.0001607355079613626, 0.0007764119072817266, 0.04097231477499008, -0.09014864265918732, -0.042811326682567596, -0.0006223437376320362, -0.05906641110777855, -0.011691820807754993, -0.027193114161491394, -0.04117245972156525, -0.021408556029200554, 0.054756373167037964, 0.012473896145820618, 0.03236149623990059, -0.025738080963492393, -0.03966829553246498, 0.05202380195260048, 0.045816391706466675, -0.006626573391258717, 0.014736087061464787, 0.0007492094300687313, 0.006302396766841412, 0.010275530628859997, -0.01292636338621378, -0.016358906403183937, -0.03158757463097572, -0.0008717969758436084, -0.04314505681395531, -0.045902784913778305, 0.05175801366567612, 0.004685802850872278, -0.010128258727490902, -0.007909603416919708, -0.01513118389993906, -0.00041385195800103247, 0.014292474836111069, 0.03907855972647667, -0.02795417048037052, 0.03426747769117355, 0.000200760638108477, 0.03682014346122742, -0.004040134139358997, -0.029963849112391472, 0.13674388825893402, 0.04892294853925705, 0.015269826166331768, -0.047985758632421494, 0.0061403680592775345, 0.052620891481637955, -0.03748769313097, -0.012675360776484013, -0.008462851867079735, 0.005028839688748121, 0.037099625915288925, 0.02492714114487171, 0.019797364249825478, 0.021893750876188278, 0.037049856036901474, 0.054858967661857605, -0.02003580890595913, -0.012353005819022655, 0.02941267192363739, 0.00917669665068388, -0.0031117689795792103, 0.00199633720330894, -0.04645152762532234, 0.024111617356538773, -0.005309560336172581, 0.0069810329005122185, -0.011049509979784489, -0.028970658779144287, 0.028108913451433182, -0.005733288824558258, -0.017603663727641106, 0.00925934873521328, 0.013658734038472176, -0.005475825164467096, 0.02447311393916607, 0.027121838182210922, 0.025663789361715317, -0.014669369906187057, 0.010115062817931175, -0.0006941704778000712, -0.004266917239874601, -0.009466332383453846, -0.030479557812213898, 0.024215560406446457, -0.05344519391655922, -0.04796712100505829, -0.0557093471288681, -0.006748582236468792, -0.029359115287661552, -0.03632029891014099, -0.020500892773270607, 0.0014401491498574615, -0.01499342080205679, -0.034582432359457016, 0.014546731486916542, 0.01656999997794628, 0.018992232158780098, -0.015704287216067314, -0.011293821968138218, -0.026313839480280876, 0.03402434289455414, -0.013859674334526062, 0.013416924513876438, 0.00790844764560461, -0.03184819594025612, -0.03240910917520523, -0.05116331949830055, 0.012445661239326, 0.018581412732601166, -0.00781924743205309, -0.02269555628299713, -0.03446265310049057, 0.0026759025640785694, 0.005917459260672331, 0.006397487595677376, 0.058638423681259155, 0.026192137971520424, -0.0004628049209713936, 0.012218790128827095, -0.004141293931752443, -0.010354146361351013, 0.03648141771554947, -0.02915601246058941, -0.036305587738752365, -0.0024413829669356346, -0.012688248418271542, -0.010757333599030972, 0.031102700158953667, 0.010314274579286575, 0.0008203061297535896, -0.008506378158926964, 0.08553983271121979, -0.016132831573486328, -0.043493546545505524, -0.019184336066246033, -0.009969823993742466, -0.03983408585190773, 0.015016746707260609, -0.005794757977128029, 0.0864555686712265, 0.03576631844043732, -0.010548257268965244, 0.03347305580973625, -0.009940951131284237, 0.005923479329794645, -0.002864082111045718, 0.03638027235865593, -0.06179802492260933, 0.011655786074697971, 0.009417500346899033, -0.010013804771006107, -0.017893029376864433, -0.02463158220052719, 0.0036639771424233913, -0.03538607433438301, 0.016549548134207726, -0.012997789308428764, -0.005786909256130457, -0.004632703494280577, -0.01016454678028822, -0.03641781955957413, -0.0027388306334614754, -0.001937928725965321, -0.04849113151431084, -0.03474598005414009, -0.03395191952586174, -0.014403601177036762, 0.005512351170182228, -0.018214870244264603, 0.035959046334028244, 0.030706658959388733, 0.032675039023160934, 0.03264639526605606, 0.0008636015700176358, -0.017706654965877533, 0.029954085126519203, -0.008297490887343884, 0.04559062048792839, -0.033000607043504715, -0.03363397717475891, 0.022477006539702415, -0.02142517827451229, -0.007244916632771492, 0.030407460406422615, -0.008534259162843227, 0.05391451343894005, 0.01039102952927351, -0.011905831284821033, -0.013317053206264973, 0.06086501106619835, -0.03792311251163483, -0.015081999823451042, 0.009341618977487087, 0.033357057720422745, 0.04659505560994148, 0.019343042746186256, 0.020210355520248413, 0.03751746192574501, -0.02007964998483658, 0.012124870903789997, 0.04111597314476967, 0.006771990098059177, -0.005125575233250856, 0.01167602464556694, -0.02027796395123005, -0.006867245305329561, -0.0028878238517791033, 0.015112381428480148, 0.028582729399204254, 0.043463144451379776, -0.0513196662068367, 0.038106974214315414, 0.004657554905861616, 0.018408076837658882, -0.05796590819954872, -0.019849564880132675, 0.02474755048751831, 0.03339776396751404, 0.023442866280674934, -0.037676312029361725, -0.00727905984967947, 0.051210757344961166, -0.051651835441589355, 0.049663376063108444, 0.02008342556655407, 0.04249398410320282, -0.033179525285959244, 0.013992543332278728, -0.04123473912477493, 0.01584010012447834, 0.019585933536291122, 0.05832451209425926, 0.049233295023441315, 0.029098086059093475, -0.00793159008026123, -0.08198259025812149, -0.034736473113298416, -0.006130848079919815, -0.02156568318605423, -0.05050309747457504, 0.006740213837474585, -0.0022359259892255068, -0.021172162145376205, 0.02163606323301792, -0.0029674398247152567, 0.01140738558024168, 0.004256261046975851, 0.013795756734907627, -0.002047947607934475, 0.026078857481479645, 0.034139491617679596, 0.007579630706459284, 0.0014088451862335205, -0.0015206324169412255, -0.008326205424964428, 0.06225281208753586, 0.004155122209340334, 0.005888625979423523, 0.029051117599010468, -0.00039044747245498, -0.03887907415628433, 0.029182741418480873, 0.013005901128053665, -0.01236133836209774, 0.0005547755281440914, -0.03578437119722366, -0.008552467450499535, -0.023216530680656433, -0.014458545483648777, -0.012066538445651531, 0.011155128479003906, 0.027051979675889015, -0.01143717858940363, 0.030602890998125076, 0.040685009211301804, -0.03795494884252548, -0.011982941068708897, 0.003942737355828285, 0.022496627643704414, 0.0005291398265399039, -0.05769322067499161, -0.017271744087338448, -0.020402679219841957, -0.005918387323617935, -0.024585627019405365, -0.0010764636099338531, -0.037005454301834106, 0.05312136560678482, 0.006866279989480972, -0.015964988619089127, 0.02293885312974453, 0.004786261823028326, -0.013530232012271881, -0.06189202517271042, 0.04753325507044792, 0.018635889515280724, 0.0010095536708831787, -0.05276433750987053, -0.00932781957089901, -0.04470507428050041, 0.014719033613801003, 0.008831191807985306, 0.00207576435059309, 0.024145187810063362, -0.015426299534738064, 0.006202550604939461, 0.01876215636730194, -0.0235616285353899, 0.058883000165224075, -0.027934743091464043, -0.020349549129605293, -0.008516787551343441, 0.0009593511931598186, 0.026340946555137634, -0.025606878101825714, 0.032627977430820465, -0.01815938763320446, -0.004646571818739176, 0.028880823403596878, -0.007721004541963339, 0.030148055404424667, 0.008298097178339958, -0.012822023592889309, 0.01035879086703062, 0.0260801799595356, -0.03898738697171211, 0.044432684779167175, -0.02225479856133461, -0.059650029987096786, 0.04517913609743118, -0.02193498983979225, -0.038589175790548325, 0.02307753451168537, 0.023730767890810966, -0.011113109067082405, -0.040446069091558456, 0.005129315424710512, 0.04160504415631294, -0.0006841685972176492, -0.02944527193903923, 0.034711286425590515, 0.01491278875619173, 0.03603878617286682, 0.02401614561676979, 0.028187323361635208, 0.011063292622566223, -0.07613977044820786, 0.02175385318696499, -0.009784749709069729, 0.02846190333366394, -0.00514012249186635, -0.017362812533974648, 0.014764569699764252, 0.048154424875974655, -0.01961398310959339, 0.028278140351176262, 0.027577074244618416, -0.022353438660502434, 0.0010936533799394965, 0.016252979636192322, -0.024763192981481552, 0.01617119275033474, 0.014314813539385796, -0.007810571696609259, 0.05387645587325096, -0.01916544884443283, 0.015499061904847622, -0.048345472663640976, 0.016598762944340706, -0.0025971292052417994, 0.0033718242775648832, 0.03320753946900368, -0.010725732892751694, -0.021251149475574493, -0.007673715706914663, -0.030720852315425873, 0.012178323231637478, 0.01912548951804638, 0.0159427672624588, 0.024260880425572395, 0.01219303160905838, 0.024881767109036446, -0.016242101788520813, -0.03619673103094101, -0.0357116237282753, -0.027625182643532753, 0.037006035447120667, 0.025439882650971413, 0.010224547237157822, -0.023020755499601364, -0.0010393951088190079, -0.016173260286450386, 0.03128359466791153, -0.022088194265961647, 0.0030108806677162647, -0.04642399773001671, 0.000320761144394055, -0.03411734476685524, 0.0005424820119515061 ]
<p>I am performing 5-fold cross-validation on a relatively large data set and I have noticed that the validation error for each of the 5 training sets are very similar. So I guess, in this case, cross-validation is not very useful (it would be about the same as just using one training and test set). So I was wondering if I am working with a special case, or is this the case for all large data sets. I'm thinking that perhaps if you have enough training examples, the average cross-validation score would not be very different than the score for one training and test set. Is this intuitition correct?</p>
73,599
[ -0.04375774785876274, 0.04500805214047432, -0.03515191376209259, 0.03167090192437172, 0.03589530289173126, 0.015875544399023056, -0.01827232353389263, -0.025331227108836174, 0.019419318065047264, -0.011257912963628769, 0.03985685855150223, -0.0011152622755616903, 0.038029685616493225, 0.020692098885774612, 0.0033871845807880163, 0.0011133758816868067, -0.023787640035152435, 0.012062540277838707, 0.02468646503984928, 0.0009622770012356341, 0.007648672442883253, 0.038671620190143585, 0.009912202134728432, -0.07338234782218933, -0.016373610123991966, 0.039397865533828735, 0.023614665493369102, -0.04526776075363159, 0.045911915600299835, 0.03892885148525238, -0.020858196541666985, -0.0008870211895555258, 0.01145197730511427, 0.0891869068145752, 0.018245887011289597, 0.00014364755770657212, -0.008860154077410698, -0.04615219309926033, 0.006092484574764967, 0.021904129534959793, 0.007267111446708441, -0.022872664034366608, -0.004793218336999416, 0.03900128975510597, 0.002381489844992757, -0.0042947703041136265, -0.014705603942275047, -0.03183598443865776, 0.010267358273267746, -0.0555575005710125, 0.07291647046804428, -0.0006582509959116578, 0.04652353376150131, 0.04938394948840141, -0.0012548791710287333, -0.0006087619694881141, 0.05068729817867279, 0.04133373498916626, -0.01368294470012188, -0.04307147487998009, -0.023286018520593643, -0.01579485647380352, 0.008585667237639427, -0.001982621382921934, -0.04170931503176689, 0.04913019388914108, -0.0010215332731604576, -0.01266258955001831, -0.00015535412239842117, 0.017014749348163605, 0.036910440772771835, 0.03537744656205177, 0.051479775458574295, -0.004544786177575588, -0.018158569931983948, 0.016954805701971054, 0.03788558021187782, 0.013386216945946217, 0.05670759454369545, 0.04228808730840683, -0.010879093781113625, 0.015436239540576935, 0.03571610525250435, 0.016389379277825356, 0.02470376342535019, -0.00657182140275836, 0.06978306919336319, -0.02310769073665142, -0.010265132412314415, 0.01367931067943573, -0.012754413299262524, 0.004878040868788958, 0.051670804619789124, 0.004484137985855341, -0.032453350722789764, 0.03648662567138672, -0.005433537997305393, 0.032107558101415634, 0.03599360212683678, 0.018986282870173454, 0.008750981651246548, -0.04661937430500984, 0.011341333389282227, 0.03487132489681244, -0.029192999005317688, -0.028522538021206856, -0.010529221966862679, -0.040876440703868866, 0.004592312499880791, -0.010892149992287159, -0.0029772913549095392, 0.0398903451859951, 0.016101017594337463, 0.023922545835375786, 0.01637684926390648, 0.027726782485842705, 0.015561964362859726, 0.0007422192138619721, 0.01668073609471321, 0.052688587456941605, 0.07392242550849915, -0.04163399711251259, 0.02897830866277218, -0.0331270806491375, -0.004301690962165594, -0.004102928098291159, -0.01065827626734972, -0.028376206755638123, -0.02781503275036812, 0.0618821382522583, -0.008323623798787594, -0.025778666138648987, 0.027644047513604164, -0.024439847096800804, 0.03444942831993103, 0.009977830573916435, -0.07285148650407791, -0.050276611000299454, 0.012152579613029957, -0.01675899140536785, -0.003045781748369336, -0.04144422337412834, -0.0031814631074666977, 0.011739598587155342, 0.022453412413597107, 0.01622120663523674, 0.02545645274221897, 0.025364935398101807, 0.011694254353642464, 0.01910604164004326, -0.0171752218157053, -0.037521880120038986, -0.010624510236084461, -0.0018113696714863181, -0.028310129418969154, -0.1157982274889946, 0.00444322032853961, 0.001579412491992116, -0.009678191505372524, 0.00015872696531005204, -0.023320412263274193, -0.0024257830809801817, -0.009587202221155167, -0.038627393543720245, 0.054060596972703934, -0.017506731674075127, 0.04888610914349556, 0.012947204522788525, 0.055436886847019196, 0.026130802929401398, -0.018586138263344765, -0.019491009414196014, 0.03677532821893692, 0.035183243453502655, 0.02818129025399685, 0.029316110536456108, 0.017571792006492615, -0.018133552744984627, 0.04064047709107399, -0.0000943911072681658, -0.004038562532514334, -0.020284123718738556, -0.01966124214231968, -0.0030984890181571245, -0.016378430649638176, 0.04908692091703415, 0.008068962022662163, -0.0473061166703701, 0.017921753227710724, -0.0328487753868103, -0.054496195167303085, -0.041085802018642426, 0.01108353678137064, -0.04482753574848175, -0.004966875072568655, -0.0028936490416526794, 0.00429580919444561, 0.012919115833938122, -0.010363596491515636, -0.015794292092323303, -0.03145575895905495, 0.015107410959899426, -0.004365208558738232, -0.044060107320547104, 0.010323083028197289, 0.013650162145495415, -0.005404770839959383, -0.026968376711010933, 0.048513323068618774, -0.0393306128680706, -0.057371966540813446, 0.017570003867149353, -0.028783846646547318, -0.0005403992836363614, -0.016001427546143532, -0.027397628873586655, 0.013589750044047832, -0.020718973129987717, -0.037685226649045944, 0.047813449054956436, -0.07741469889879227, 0.07622253894805908, 0.07654382288455963, -0.025725025683641434, 0.011591453105211258, -0.03291241079568863, 0.029313595965504646, 0.020324846729636192, -0.0034229508601129055, -0.029755549505352974, -0.08918090909719467, -0.008976763114333153, 0.03896188735961914, 0.004897779319435358, -0.03827783837914467, 0.026918867602944374, 0.06648150831460953, 0.01320229284465313, -0.0004624845751095563, -0.00865984708070755, 0.014981646090745926, -0.01836829073727131, 0.019383087754249573, 0.05272257328033447, 0.02549245022237301, 0.003304900601506233, 0.010974377393722534, 0.00015044295287225395, 0.026242535561323166, 0.0014530913904309273, 0.0037357965484261513, 0.047681257128715515, 0.007185861933976412, 0.00917802657932043, -0.00952943041920662, -0.010466487146914005, 0.029841577634215355, -0.003888798877596855, 0.012175558134913445, 0.0033339711371809244, 0.004777135327458382, 0.008776920847594738, -0.018180714920163155, -0.0054758149199187756, 0.0422138012945652, 0.024394566193223, -0.01954030618071556, 0.007387727964669466, 0.00823619868606329, -0.06589356064796448, -0.015190468169748783, -0.0336417518556118, -0.014618927612900734, -0.03645510599017143, 0.012076400220394135, 0.04468856751918793, -0.009284688159823418, 0.05103393271565437, -0.03930756077170372, 0.006059420760720968, -0.01562642864882946, -0.028606940060853958, 0.020568253472447395, -0.012208260595798492, -0.020266862586140633, -0.007760606240481138, -0.0394727848470211, -0.019235074520111084, 0.05954696610569954, -0.05228971317410469, -0.01149868592619896, 0.017330430448055267, 0.018582355231046677, -0.05171946808695793, -0.049117185175418854, -0.07377032190561295, 0.01925777643918991, -0.014843940734863281, -0.017502814531326294, 0.05066046118736267, 0.033231958746910095, -0.05629095435142517, 0.03351307287812233, 0.004069791175425053, -0.032522812485694885, -0.03627108037471771, -0.0114137539640069, 0.01664189249277115, -0.01799509860575199, -0.0029693138785660267, 0.051814913749694824, -0.015153538435697556, 0.00011755710147554055, -0.05111643671989441, -0.05289652943611145, 0.029945852234959602, 0.004629354923963547, 0.005904905032366514, 0.0013245446607470512, -0.014208481647074223, 0.06680037826299667, 0.03142480552196503, -0.04947632923722267, -0.046571116894483566, 0.02333163470029831, -0.02507619746029377, -0.007240752689540386, 0.004244208335876465, 0.024077557027339935, -0.0074973441660404205, 0.022938812151551247, 0.02166104130446911, 0.011324307881295681, 0.04982566460967064, -0.02734365314245224, 0.003975982312113047, -0.002867810893803835, 0.03204663097858429, -0.010383821092545986, 0.01727287471294403, 0.02279580943286419, -0.028113946318626404, 0.0001595813810126856, 0.023714730516076088, 0.010449367575347424, 0.006312921643257141, -0.021524490788578987, 0.04302573949098587, -0.03996063396334648, 0.02448570914566517, -0.04203552007675171, 0.01628040336072445, -0.009339221753180027, -0.016756916418671608, -0.025934690609574318, 0.05281393602490425, 0.02322147600352764, -0.020045358687639236, 0.012701265513896942, 0.01731451414525509, 0.014426595531404018, -0.029791008681058884, -0.04641313478350639, -0.03382762148976326, -0.00528296222910285, -0.00901169516146183, 0.024714991450309753, -0.019158171489834785, 0.06005671247839928, 0.05603265389800072, 0.034129299223423004, -0.0069687883369624615, -0.029462892562150955, 0.028768429532647133, -0.092990942299366, -0.004654747433960438, -0.03938945755362511, 0.04729204252362251, 0.036428436636924744, 0.04219770058989525, 0.010589517652988434, -0.028609218075871468, 0.02679496444761753, 0.012554117478430271, -0.05540385842323303, -0.003194752149283886, -0.01069207489490509, -0.018419072031974792, -0.025494975969195366, -0.04472235590219498, 0.053636811673641205, -0.01157163642346859, 0.008046315982937813, 0.0054080248810350895, 0.02267454005777836, -0.03125782310962677, 0.01593468338251114, 0.001441590371541679, 0.01589645817875862, 0.006160498596727848, 0.020284542813897133, -0.0027843553107231855, 0.003494726959615946, 0.004812173079699278, 0.007345224730670452, 0.0033562283497303724, -0.026936493813991547, -0.03802526742219925, 0.041882675141096115, -0.007794865407049656, 0.03811519593000412, 0.008887621574103832, 0.06391636282205582, -0.08394788950681686, 0.03634856268763542, -0.00874041486531496, 0.022620221599936485, 0.05249704048037529, -0.010053833946585655, -0.02797398902475834, -0.06159672886133194, -0.01843901164829731, 0.04045264795422554, 0.008340618573129177, -0.0027983684558421373, -0.026528097689151764, 0.029167573899030685, 0.024561481550335884, -0.06254895776510239, 0.006855389103293419, 0.06569729745388031, 0.012857477180659771, -0.012984134256839752, -0.026708675548434258, -0.015393911860883236, -0.007240109611302614, -0.030671030282974243, 0.03215625137090683, 0.018916746601462364, -0.03235049918293953, 0.0007030704291537404, 0.034981079399585724, -0.033023249357938766, -0.03817995265126228, 0.00928353238850832, 0.021093908697366714, 0.034989919513463974, -0.010897626169025898, 0.006014268845319748, 0.01368957944214344, 0.036735616624355316, 0.0637686550617218, 0.012185962870717049, -0.018640344962477684, -0.06321645528078079, 0.027843941003084183, 0.048260487616062164, 0.0370774045586586, -0.06508481502532959, -0.003055274486541748, -0.05872662737965584, 0.0012770515168085694, 0.04458954185247421, -0.039444878697395325, 0.02455129474401474, 0.017811762169003487, 0.011376664973795414, -0.023047901690006256, 0.008708863519132137, -0.0065946741960942745, 0.0029414636082947254, -0.04234013706445694, 0.0634383037686348, -0.018732378259301186, -0.010619999840855598, -0.01916654221713543, 0.03434658423066139, 0.011017706245183945, 0.06562269479036331, -0.013176945969462395, -0.004409390967339277, -0.014302963390946388, 0.026959000155329704, 0.005593101028352976, -0.056907787919044495, -0.02690957672894001, -0.030316658318042755, -0.0242740698158741, 0.02896936610341072, -0.015443215146660805, -0.056310515850782394, 0.0005964091396890581, 0.04182431474328041, -0.03266599029302597, -0.024360019713640213, -0.020769622176885605, 0.005468426737934351, 0.04656439274549484, 0.036215901374816895, 0.06869722157716751, -0.02166157029569149, 0.05054578185081482, -0.010075119324028492, 0.0002702714700717479, 0.017994502559304237, -0.04191107675433159, -0.0236965399235487, -0.0052664014510810375, -0.020789366215467453, -0.021016543731093407, 0.031841982156038284, -0.04001813009381294, 0.04380952939391136, -0.0323505625128746, -0.03602595999836922, -0.010476693511009216, 0.009093349799513817, -0.0051400442607700825, -0.02862604334950447, 0.011891898699104786, 0.033586353063583374, 0.0032912518363445997, 0.011056318879127502, -0.000986902043223381, 0.0006173402070999146, 0.014437315054237843, 0.03314508497714996, -0.015929797664284706, -0.001527203363366425, -0.03260170668363571, -0.005586931947618723, -0.0005132319638505578, -0.02328646369278431, 0.03656064346432686, 0.00903687160462141, 0.04425980523228645, 0.01725640520453453, -0.041450321674346924, 0.015738992020487785, 0.03262791410088539, 0.020516932010650635, 0.0348481647670269, -0.05107816308736801, 0.024919060990214348, -0.03542361781001091, -0.009087566286325455, -0.07964049279689789, -0.04701227322220802, 0.02991400845348835, 0.005483950022608042, -0.0058179148472845554, -0.008688261732459068, -0.03295493125915527, 0.005776708479970694, -0.020852001383900642, -0.01773925870656967, 0.07843650877475739, -0.014311186037957668, -0.02476527914404869, 0.004254787229001522, 0.007957017980515957, 0.0868791937828064, -0.009047558531165123, 0.04416336864233017, -0.002398614538833499, -0.0034251173492521048, -0.021792707964777946, 0.019266320392489433, 0.02036871947348118, -0.03857382386922836, -0.020971307530999184, -0.020105525851249695, 0.008237875066697598, 0.02700890228152275, -0.030590886250138283, -0.026277687400579453, 0.009496008977293968, -0.03590983897447586, 0.0008043305715546012, -0.002379688899964094, 0.024243302643299103, -0.007322399411350489, -0.015769897028803825, -0.009696660563349724, 0.020623857155442238, 0.006092824973165989, -0.0385885052382946, 0.020197074860334396, 0.016493508592247963, -0.014939393848180771, 0.02215990424156189, 0.08732976764440536, -0.02937622368335724, -0.016837242990732193, -0.018740173429250717, -0.06477473676204681, 0.032587941735982895, 0.0003844833408948034, -0.013852025382220745, 0.0016865971265360713, 0.038649123162031174, -0.07291974127292633, -0.014474713243544102, 0.009212118573486805, -0.00809672474861145, 0.034150417894124985, -0.008330363780260086, 0.033702973276376724, 0.05891943722963333, 0.014373797923326492, -0.018035614863038063, -0.05460000038146973, 0.003067605895921588, -0.008096707984805107, 0.014933536760509014, 0.07078946381807327, 0.005918591283261776, -0.0032735702116042376, 0.010074034333229065, 0.0196418147534132, 0.0344928540289402, 0.049031421542167664, 0.003152769058942795, 0.03203316777944565, -0.019009150564670563, -0.01615402102470398, -0.06648121029138565, 0.016717905178666115, -0.03570188581943512, 0.001823345897719264, -0.005779901519417763, -0.006189852952957153, 0.033587176352739334, 0.038761984556913376, 0.007727582473307848, -0.037267398089170456, -0.03775350749492645, -0.0313955657184124, 0.03824128583073616, 0.009363792836666107, 0.013827353715896606, 0.012802958488464355, 0.007178589701652527, 0.02556125819683075, 0.03121398389339447, 0.007521329913288355, -0.04628023877739906, -0.07192348688840866, -0.027180029079318047, -0.02040836215019226, -0.0341801680624485, 0.04184037446975708, 0.01348127145320177, -0.037669286131858826, 0.0019052494317293167, -0.03962870314717293, 0.035957999527454376, -0.0031747317407280207, 0.03597758710384369, -0.00170738878659904, 0.024616947397589684, 0.0032196850515902042, 0.02617958001792431, -0.008029533550143242, 0.03019455261528492, 0.13224264979362488, 0.08852966129779816, 0.02942117117345333, -0.013268917798995972, 0.010441172868013382, -0.028028765693306923, -0.007089510094374418, -0.029962992295622826, -0.005112587474286556, -0.00046707977890037, -0.0008262957562692463, 0.005189341027289629, 0.04170577973127365, 0.024869700893759727, -0.04414260759949684, 0.06012352555990219, -0.009743789210915565, 0.036144357174634933, 0.03621915355324745, 0.026165876537561417, 0.013184605166316032, -0.020450184121727943, -0.025539914146065712, 0.003225763328373432, -0.012694071047008038, 0.00497650308534503, -0.01530742458999157, -0.012904815375804901, 0.008345356211066246, 0.008854001760482788, 0.003909088205546141, -0.011105585843324661, 0.002593467477709055, -0.010311826132237911, -0.042412348091602325, 0.007269914727658033, -0.01173273753374815, -0.014036964625120163, 0.007794163189828396, 0.029409488663077354, 0.01627533510327339, -0.01308656670153141, 0.006980076897889376, 0.024718206375837326, -0.03532892093062401, -0.04116731509566307, -0.05375673249363899, 0.03562062233686447, 0.010403396561741829, 0.016971712931990623, 0.008389906026422977, 0.01340128667652607, 0.02339390106499195, -0.03481884300708771, -0.01329933200031519, 0.014670385979115963, -0.0027607311494648457, -0.035838186740875244, -0.019050557166337967, -0.04773472994565964, 0.06146295741200447, 0.004014960024505854, 0.009787498041987419, -0.004150707274675369, -0.017018288373947144, -0.02281997539103031, -0.014751967042684555, 0.02928430214524269, 0.003310401923954487, 0.018410878255963326, -0.017468566074967384, -0.006520319264382124, -0.022514583542943, 0.003862763522192836, 0.0067466371692717075, 0.015001559630036354, 0.027894921600818634, -0.004019713029265404, -0.023817015811800957, -0.02196366712450981, -0.057264819741249084, -0.024707229807972908, -0.0010245197918266058, 0.009046344086527824, 0.0012928653741255403, -0.017990076914429665, 0.005337873008102179, 0.01958693563938141, 0.02848309837281704, 0.024477042257785797, -0.004270606208592653, 0.034152235835790634, -0.0068558743223547935, -0.03718576207756996, 0.008961878716945648, -0.022230472415685654, -0.04733608290553093, 0.03221479803323746, -0.0010436917655169964, 0.05405053868889809, 0.012191470712423325, 0.027679631486535072, 0.00021893851226195693, 0.043916214257478714, 0.019053693860769272, 0.030850453302264214, 0.002841461915522814, -0.04355316236615181, 0.01245767530053854, 0.00521548418328166, -0.015297811478376389, -0.046680748462677, -0.018914395943284035, -0.06974213570356369, -0.0525992177426815, 0.04798875004053116, -0.0037449998781085014, -0.02860378846526146, 0.00515360152348876, -0.011514231562614441, 0.04770922288298607, -0.0264417827129364, 0.006901198532432318, -0.04223459213972092, 0.006559666711837053, -0.031430598348379135, -0.05998218059539795, -0.0011462720576673746, -0.017314499244093895, -0.024242427200078964, -0.007864942774176598, 0.05339372903108597, -0.009854597970843315, 0.0014676002319902182, -0.0013545817928388715, 0.007091898005455732, -0.01059489045292139, 0.05078696832060814, -0.05172235146164894, -0.004346583504229784, 0.05915563926100731, -0.041428130120038986, -0.012529863975942135, 0.037497542798519135, -0.01605033315718174, 0.041176315397024155, 0.029476700350642204, -0.02325201965868473, -0.03103947453200817, 0.07166372239589691, -0.01541549526154995, -0.0228823684155941, 0.007222054060548544, 0.03921893611550331, 0.05324250087141991, 0.04192046821117401, 0.016443641856312752, 0.031143778935074806, 0.013303627260029316, 0.005776809062808752, 0.008097401820123196, 0.024262994527816772, -0.02781258337199688, 0.016327496618032455, -0.005452855955809355, 0.034045588225126266, 0.007795524783432484, 0.030703337863087654, 0.004928682465106249, 0.04889918118715286, -0.02732059732079506, 0.019251512363553047, -0.007208315189927816, 0.04525735601782799, -0.09714623540639877, -0.015388748608529568, 0.01982150971889496, 0.04545590281486511, -0.013015846721827984, -0.061535052955150604, -0.0029799756594002247, 0.04347197711467743, -0.07566867023706436, 0.043852534145116806, -0.03729866072535515, -0.022803157567977905, -0.046296730637550354, -0.019386375322937965, -0.031580135226249695, -0.015587843023240566, 0.056694675236940384, -0.0004729017673525959, 0.012587742879986763, 0.04919372498989105, -0.01848083920776844, -0.02106122486293316, -0.06694861501455307, 0.038140445947647095, 0.010790704749524593, -0.03696591034531593, 0.02062903344631195, 0.01856388710439205, -0.07326941937208176, 0.01380905695259571, -0.0310226920992136, -0.0077761393040418625, 0.019327837973833084, 0.029903752729296684, 0.04410981014370918, 0.0297909677028656, 0.019027557224035263, -0.0402350053191185, -0.00561938714236021, 0.030698830261826515, -0.003909575752913952, 0.01065153256058693, -0.03170986473560333, 0.022016189992427826, 0.006131874863058329, 0.00035237130941823125, -0.04684791713953018, 0.021525973454117775, -0.014988181181252003, -0.05098188295960426, -0.023052051663398743, 0.02016408182680607, 0.008621356450021267, -0.012251991778612137, -0.00413890415802598, -0.04287746548652649, 0.019992366433143616, 0.016836129128932953, 0.02952932007610798, -0.012264302000403404, 0.011783654801547527, -0.0010684551671147346, -0.04205000400543213, 0.007905714213848114, 0.004420340992510319, -0.003994464408606291, -0.055434659123420715, -0.00838727131485939, 0.0006004687747918069, -0.028081322088837624, -0.03723900392651558, -0.038908377289772034, -0.009687590412795544, 0.03831595554947853, -0.0016369110671803355, 0.04809042438864708, 0.011255525052547455, -0.024948235601186752, -0.04152717813849449, -0.09307927638292313, 0.059039097279310226, -0.01414463110268116, -0.03351332247257233, -0.03736849129199982, -0.003396660089492798, -0.035851843655109406, -0.0293426476418972, 0.038140300661325455, 0.010935349389910698, 0.02040955051779747, -0.0045124199241399765, 0.022799935191869736, -0.02872251532971859, -0.05016683042049408, 0.03745410591363907, -0.007254407275468111, -0.02540820837020874, -0.02071457915008068, -0.025896595790982246, 0.01902228593826294, 0.00002791305450955406, 0.02557237260043621, -0.02143245004117489, 0.03243084251880646, -0.013066478073596954, 0.020039351657032967, 0.034874945878982544, 0.025654280558228493, -0.012337484396994114, 0.04406464472413063, 0.00468513835221529, -0.002251729601994157, 0.007995094172656536, -0.010503023862838745, -0.050133731216192245, 0.012236667796969414, -0.059094253927469254, -0.0268256776034832, -0.006293448619544506, 0.0657423585653305, -0.021732497960329056, -0.039508212357759476, 0.008822728879749775, 0.042724862694740295, -0.024497851729393005, -0.008586383424699306, 0.04616998881101608, 0.0504123717546463, 0.01765383407473564, -0.009688333608210087, 0.03423940762877464, 0.010898085311055183, 0.011413617990911007, -0.014721096493303776, -0.020056165754795074, 0.0044927457347512245, 0.03799709305167198, 0.03914247453212738, 0.02834095060825348, -0.02253090590238571, 0.0017823283560574055, -0.01042467076331377, 0.046931419521570206, -0.06801794469356537, -0.006635601632297039, -0.0032799141481518745, -0.016367096453905106, 0.01731901429593563, -0.002179591916501522, -0.032839950174093246, 0.06473693251609802, -0.013711901381611824, -0.03191246837377548, -0.03602189943194389, -0.027244634926319122, 0.025809941813349724, 0.0023354431614279747, 0.0092676542699337, 0.04542074352502823, 0.010662740096449852, -0.000019600531231844798, -0.030079130083322525, 0.0021615359000861645, 0.043144140392541885, -0.022142313420772552, 0.00046745658619329333, -0.010722912847995758, 0.0012579109752550721, -0.015392427332699299, -0.015783488750457764, -0.02552260458469391, 0.018455956131219864, 0.016202609986066818, 0.047609858214855194, 0.017362279817461967, -0.030014513060450554, -0.04390615597367287, 0.0211898572742939, 0.03182193636894226, -0.07012969255447388, 0.0032714498229324818, -0.051396485418081284, 0.03172360733151436, 0.02919934131205082, -0.021381769329309464 ]
<p>I'm reading Newey &amp; McFadden - Large sample estimation and hypothesis testing (in the <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0444887660" rel="nofollow">Handbook of Econometrics, Volume 4</a>, 1994, page 2178).</p> <p>My model which I'm interested in has some former estimation done before the estimation of the primary model will take place. Hence the primary model (2nd-step) includes some estimated regressors from the former step (the 1st-step).</p> <p>In order to account for the first-step variance I followed the approach from Newey &amp; McFadden here the joint GMM-conditions are defined as $\widetilde{g}\left(z,\theta,\gamma\right) = \left[g\left(z,\theta,\gamma\right),m\left(z,\gamma\right)\right]$ where $g\left(z,\theta,\gamma\right)$ are the 2nd-step conditions and $m\left(z,\gamma\right)$ are the 1st-step ones.</p> <p>The usual asymptotic GMM-variance of the GMM-estimator $\widehat{\theta}$ will look like</p> <p>$Var\left(\widehat{\theta}\right)$ = $\left(G^TWG\right)^{-1}\mathbb{E}\left(g(z,\theta)g(z,\theta)^T\right)\left(G^TWG\right)^{-1}$</p> <p>where $g(z,\theta)$ are some moment conditions, $G = \frac{\partial\mathbb{E}\left(g(z,\theta_0)\right)}{\partial \theta^T}$ and $W$ is some weight matrix.</p> <p>In order to calculate the GMM-variance for the two-step approach I need to derive $G$, $W$ and the derivative of $\mathbb{E}$.</p> <p><strong>My Question: I struggle to understand why this is true.</strong></p> <p>Let $G_\theta = \frac{\partial\mathbb{E}\left(\widetilde{g}(z,\theta_0, \gamma_0)\right)}{\partial \theta^T}$, $G_\gamma = \frac{\partial\mathbb{E}\left(\widetilde{g}(z,\theta_0, \gamma_0)\right)}{\partial \gamma^T}$, $M = \frac{\partial\mathbb{E}\left(m(z, \gamma_0)\right)}{\partial \gamma^T}$</p> <p>Then $\widetilde{G} = \frac{\partial\mathbb{E}\left(\widetilde{g}(z,\theta_0, \gamma_0)\right)}{\partial \left(\theta^T, \gamma^T\right)^T} = \begin{Bmatrix} G_\theta &amp; G_\gamma\\ 0 &amp; M\end{Bmatrix}$</p> <p>This is easy to see but why is the inverse of $G$ this</p> <p>$\widetilde{G}^{-1} = \begin{Bmatrix} G_\theta^{-1} &amp; -G_\theta^{-1}G_\gamma M^{-1}\\ 0 &amp; M^{-1}\end{Bmatrix}$</p> <p>I know that the derivative of a 2x2-Jacobian-matrix is if $J = \begin{Bmatrix} x_u &amp; x_v\\ y_u &amp; y_v \end{Bmatrix}$ where $x_u,...$ are the partial derivatives then $J^{-1} = \frac{1}{det\left(J\right)}\begin{Bmatrix} y_v &amp; -x_v\\ -y_u &amp; x_u \end{Bmatrix}$</p> <p>But then $\widetilde{G}^{-1} = M^{-1}G_\theta^{-1}\begin{Bmatrix} M &amp; -G_\gamma\\ 0 &amp; G_\theta \end{Bmatrix} = \begin{Bmatrix} M^{-1}G_\theta^{-1}M &amp; -M^{-1}G_\theta^{-1}G_\gamma\\ 0 &amp; M^{-1} \end{Bmatrix}$</p> <p>But this is not the same. <strong>What have I done wrong?</strong></p>
31,131
[ 0.004543331917375326, -0.002566348761320114, 0.03838656097650528, -0.023698357865214348, 0.045218370854854584, -0.004848000593483448, -0.030750511214137077, -0.03623834252357483, 0.01806672289967537, -0.0447964183986187, 0.056362032890319824, 0.006691540591418743, 0.08336696773767471, 0.042777013033628464, 0.05473144352436066, 0.013641571626067162, -0.006191284395754337, 0.0216282457113266, -0.0034327227622270584, 0.0068465410731732845, 0.001469354727305472, 0.030730755999684334, 0.017684275284409523, -0.04115505516529083, -0.03392568603157997, 0.006414119154214859, 0.026890141889452934, 0.006942152976989746, 0.0016385635826736689, 0.06507925689220428, -0.05414505675435066, -0.02009061723947525, -0.01712208054959774, 0.027933254837989807, -0.03716682270169258, 0.017352255061268806, -0.04403821751475334, -0.05755681172013283, 0.00006243576353881508, 0.06419125199317932, -0.0179862342774868, 0.011030778288841248, -0.06759802252054214, -0.005807123612612486, 0.003168612951412797, 0.015060431323945522, -0.018444590270519257, 0.0007452762802131474, 0.056796006858348846, -0.04160380735993385, 0.06143984943628311, -0.0006174994632601738, 0.012959680519998074, 0.029784195125102997, -0.024893231689929962, -0.013819621875882149, 0.0686788558959961, 0.10157199203968048, 0.01651649735867977, -0.018202481791377068, -0.022387761622667313, -0.03332393616437912, 0.03172982856631279, -0.06019943952560425, -0.003851543180644512, -0.01540758553892374, 0.024017253890633583, -0.02497716248035431, 0.032083697617053986, -0.025433966889977455, 0.03877704590559006, -0.010934329591691494, 0.024954600259661674, 0.0255286768078804, -0.005844021216034889, 0.01314933504909277, 0.0008087067399173975, 0.0388229638338089, 0.03247777372598648, 0.009289257228374481, 0.014436811208724976, 0.01011574175208807, 0.023063449189066887, 0.022998349741101265, 0.0046989815309643745, 0.007535532116889954, 0.09070748090744019, 0.009852390736341476, 0.017216548323631287, 0.010752842761576176, -0.029012108221650124, -0.010806656442582607, 0.03460494801402092, -0.03670543059706688, -0.02375870570540428, 0.024848785251379013, -0.04920036345720291, 0.026964617893099785, 0.019619466736912727, 0.00320611079223454, -0.05193684622645378, -0.05341552197933197, 0.005909686908125877, 0.05084620788693428, -0.029156509786844254, -0.016634363681077957, -0.002538310596719384, 0.002297023544088006, -0.029122967272996902, -0.08034385740756989, -0.03696479648351669, 0.03999548777937889, -0.034088123589754105, -0.016729796305298805, -0.0026782345958054066, 0.03383203223347664, -0.009118882939219475, -0.00106059480458498, 0.04698558524250984, 0.052695415914058685, 0.06288059800863266, -0.017090512439608574, -0.017377730458974838, -0.037538737058639526, -0.06381707638502121, 0.01070178858935833, 0.034330546855926514, -0.016329331323504448, -0.03172507509589195, 0.044508159160614014, 0.002491303253918886, -0.044500406831502914, 0.027631286531686783, 0.01135511789470911, 0.015693020075559616, -0.016344040632247925, -0.07707782834768295, -0.05293488875031471, 0.06159676983952522, -0.02813727967441082, 0.02847711369395256, -0.04624587669968605, -0.028234895318746567, 0.014588644728064537, 0.05184035748243332, -0.019568761810660362, 0.07264520227909088, 0.028849514201283455, 0.02845110557973385, 0.02093341201543808, -0.05477616935968399, -0.04724552854895592, -0.010877452790737152, 0.03335002809762955, -0.026856526732444763, -0.09262167662382126, 0.009734892286360264, 0.0019936608150601387, -0.013195062056183815, 0.014887268655002117, 0.05814550444483757, 0.019320735707879066, -0.013662911020219326, -0.017188172787427902, -0.0021084349136799574, -0.02872438356280327, 0.0526561476290226, 0.020766738802194595, 0.02027117647230625, 0.01983456499874592, 0.025014586746692657, -0.021526722237467766, -0.026910753920674324, 0.03961847722530365, 0.013274716213345528, -0.017505191266536713, 0.0035422607325017452, -0.008823098614811897, 0.002131314715370536, 0.0053879451006650925, -0.02026277966797352, 0.0017704826314002275, -0.04109328240156174, -0.04122759401798248, 0.004332967568188906, 0.006936592515558004, -0.01445725653320551, -0.011960414238274097, 0.00906691886484623, -0.05187620222568512, -0.05647965893149376, -0.06861128658056259, -0.016875235363841057, -0.018373627215623856, -0.01289749052375555, 0.019995057955384254, -0.024024616926908493, 0.014291204512119293, 0.006146625615656376, -0.045355431735515594, -0.01840953528881073, 0.017269577831029892, 0.013942859135568142, -0.04839273542165756, 0.0021555121056735516, 0.04418120160698891, 0.06411018967628479, 0.002016387414187193, 0.05854620411992073, -0.0290926992893219, -0.04158620908856392, 0.030844293534755707, -0.017955949530005455, 0.04515277221798897, 0.012469416484236717, -0.038450974971055984, 0.014312945306301117, 0.0033440047409385443, 0.009779500775039196, -0.00011285867367405444, -0.05117959901690483, -0.009835295379161835, 0.07215112447738647, 0.006858123932033777, 0.002892832737416029, 0.018387693911790848, 0.018872184678912163, 0.029491154477000237, -0.01723647490143776, 0.0012872728984802961, -0.01386344339698553, -0.030719302594661713, 0.06413779407739639, 0.01003282144665718, -0.04413403570652008, 0.03149867057800293, 0.06179138645529747, 0.03476003557443619, 0.010135133750736713, 0.025687268003821373, 0.01065639965236187, -0.056457702070474625, -0.007195472717285156, 0.04333927482366562, -0.0011508644092828035, 0.006360368337482214, -0.010476198978722095, 0.01666206680238247, 0.026255082339048386, 0.009164485149085522, -0.0013143005780875683, 0.0172372218221426, 0.00909323338419199, -0.04068484529852867, -0.0019752022344619036, -0.03227822110056877, 0.057612571865320206, -0.00661596329882741, 0.014719352126121521, 0.06178433075547218, 0.014730642549693584, -0.014016942121088505, 0.0136069655418396, -0.047649938613176346, 0.04622110724449158, 0.03135060518980026, -0.026316551491618156, 0.023648040369153023, 0.007169873919337988, -0.02933034673333168, 0.002158594783395529, -0.024302765727043152, -0.041821882128715515, -0.01343767810612917, 0.00048248140956275165, 0.009960436262190342, 0.020471706986427307, 0.0021739311050623655, -0.009005601517856121, -0.008158662356436253, 0.0007574710762128234, 0.024608520790934563, 0.03210117295384407, 0.02104131691157818, -0.027593331411480904, 0.006153860595077276, -0.020344488322734833, 0.024518100544810295, 0.05671774968504906, 0.0384303517639637, 0.004244188312441111, 0.023969784379005432, 0.029185019433498383, -0.03114597126841545, -0.04150381684303284, 0.02137554995715618, -0.02333010733127594, -0.04246873781085014, -0.012256724759936333, 0.04843796789646149, 0.025529593229293823, -0.038759537041187286, -0.009065416641533375, -0.056699953973293304, -0.027262885123491287, -0.025453072041273117, 0.007780959829688072, 0.001775937620550394, -0.013089751824736595, 0.03727704659104347, 0.0032804543152451515, -0.01644505001604557, -0.026733355596661568, -0.054874349385499954, -0.04529227316379547, 0.030677562579512596, 0.027409136295318604, 0.019037336111068726, -0.01130234356969595, -0.03543243184685707, 0.07441618293523788, 0.044029366225004196, -0.013417022302746773, -0.05695345997810364, 0.004837035667151213, -0.01319904439151287, -0.060890987515449524, 0.02211952768266201, 0.024856379255652428, -0.005166285205632448, 0.037657372653484344, -0.03369386866688728, 0.026203475892543793, 0.026913397014141083, 0.007345263846218586, 0.033337630331516266, 0.02490375004708767, 0.0012123914202675223, -0.0030554921831935644, 0.022499658167362213, -0.020511910319328308, 0.014539074152708054, -0.024017635732889175, 0.006345377303659916, 0.010201392695307732, -0.0160817950963974, -0.06498626619577408, 0.045672427862882614, -0.018811367452144623, -0.005658334121108055, -0.0351937860250473, 0.05234178528189659, 0.010278892703354359, -0.03679077699780464, -0.015266730450093746, -0.006622222252190113, 0.014390483498573303, -0.013664579018950462, 0.004392643924802542, 0.03594747558236122, 0.003864917904138565, -0.002499713096767664, 0.011569621041417122, -0.0456617996096611, -0.00905027985572815, 0.04613157734274864, -0.03454931080341339, -0.014414303004741669, 0.014531293883919716, 0.06514602899551392, -0.024386661127209663, 0.003083390649408102, -0.053078752011060715, -0.025803610682487488, -0.0052056508138775826, 0.009599161334335804, -0.01144877728074789, 0.04482421651482582, -0.001705816830508411, 0.05596116930246353, -0.017236905172467232, 0.008251920342445374, 0.021747445687651634, -0.0011281188344582915, -0.08094368129968643, 0.0049508404918015, 0.002297286642715335, -0.008054479025304317, 0.038802359253168106, -0.00980659481137991, 0.03549875691533089, -0.01836148090660572, -0.0011572202201932669, -0.04154790937900543, 0.01322798989713192, -0.0320996418595314, 0.052459798753261566, -0.034260094165802, -0.019860295578837395, 0.03200328350067139, 0.04917868971824646, 0.022320793941617012, -0.02928820624947548, -0.024711767211556435, 0.03244255855679512, -0.022204170003533363, -0.00283801113255322, -0.028079448267817497, 0.034555889666080475, 0.034209322184324265, 0.037486352026462555, 0.024678928777575493, 0.060328345745801926, -0.058701906353235245, 0.0050519909709692, 0.021726494655013084, 0.05393155291676521, 0.05368223786354065, -0.008885168470442295, -0.0020660466980189085, -0.02314453199505806, -0.04187602549791336, 0.038872603327035904, 0.003968619275838137, -0.0015029680216684937, -0.010455744341015816, 0.07588262856006622, 0.013425976037979126, -0.013671046122908592, 0.01005562487989664, 0.057388488203287125, 0.014988929964601994, 0.0024159338790923357, -0.010626301169395447, -0.003190109273418784, 0.010280092246830463, -0.01166183315217495, 0.02770814672112465, 0.0009132230770774186, -0.027767635881900787, -0.0026520832907408476, 0.030540598556399345, -0.009908037260174751, -0.024344656616449356, -0.0074256607331335545, 0.04006071016192436, 0.028546489775180817, 0.07158347219228745, -0.015873584896326065, 0.05340568348765373, 0.01108695287257433, 0.016936153173446655, 0.006676973309367895, -0.012267876416444778, -0.04152371361851692, 0.01151831354945898, 0.042453180998563766, 0.024457739666104317, -0.03155703842639923, -0.00033404433634132147, -0.05580809339880943, -0.057998113334178925, -0.016668036580085754, -0.009949727915227413, 0.05586402863264084, 0.011755438521504402, -0.012265629135072231, 0.022237442433834076, -0.05529686436057091, -0.06980571895837784, 0.03475930541753769, -0.030833633616566658, -0.006321283057332039, -0.042136549949645996, -0.030338415876030922, 0.010451116599142551, -0.008520498871803284, 0.002727836836129427, 0.03428635001182556, -0.015776749700307846, 0.004863944370299578, 0.03467513993382454, 0.03271861746907234, -0.04125044494867325, -0.04349100962281227, 0.042824648320674896, 0.00490677822381258, -0.017276311293244362, 0.025539249181747437, -0.013189619407057762, -0.06693010032176971, 0.038033902645111084, -0.0032406358513981104, 0.005659600254148245, 0.02509809285402298, 0.02722146362066269, 0.07714932411909103, 0.0002851298777386546, -0.0191829651594162, 0.07069949805736542, 0.016064034774899483, 0.004085128661245108, -0.0022667187731713057, -0.006788287777453661, 0.010025671683251858, -0.055632442235946655, -0.017493752762675285, -0.0471712127327919, -0.019819216802716255, -0.03499676659703255, 0.04779263585805893, 0.005719782318919897, 0.0074293469078838825, -0.012809245847165585, -0.017923027276992798, 0.02875574119389057, 0.003222970524802804, -0.02013382688164711, -0.010556145571172237, 0.030036229640245438, 0.01706414483487606, -0.008136529475450516, 0.007309215608984232, 0.05010257288813591, -0.029392924159765244, -0.0040368433110415936, 0.014291145838797092, -0.04243951290845871, -0.019752133637666702, -0.0327298641204834, -0.021185848861932755, -0.013596994802355766, 0.04938973858952522, 0.030423441901803017, -0.02458878420293331, 0.03975328058004379, 0.024388570338487625, -0.04299551248550415, -0.02922915108501911, 0.02617666684091091, 0.004846907686442137, -0.011824153363704681, 0.005694400053471327, -0.0052335141226649284, 0.03798048943281174, -0.006227463949471712, -0.0766831710934639, 0.008425307460129261, 0.03846544772386551, -0.018009372055530548, 0.004251719918102026, 0.00922973733395338, -0.022854316979646683, -0.007606958970427513, -0.06180227920413017, -0.03842376917600632, 0.02985447272658348, -0.002752621890977025, 0.008368534967303276, -0.015405512414872646, 0.057249415665864944, 0.0582859106361866, 0.002261995105072856, 0.004030912183225155, 0.03832174837589264, -0.07066496461629868, -0.002764316974207759, 0.06366615742444992, -0.0341852568089962, -0.011493208818137646, 0.0024029226042330265, -0.023518141359090805, 0.001268970314413309, 0.02335881069302559, -0.018525341525673866, -0.021647784858942032, 0.03730843588709831, -0.025460924953222275, 0.024579863995313644, -0.014187246561050415, -0.008656485937535763, 0.011349773965775967, -0.0010411414550617337, -0.03132319822907448, -0.012582913972437382, 0.01692468672990799, 0.0029447467532008886, 0.04896397888660431, -0.014662928879261017, -0.00282855611294508, 0.014856445603072643, 0.08901316672563553, -0.02224612608551979, -0.030154969543218613, 0.026714900508522987, -0.008833585307002068, 0.008644703775644302, -0.005728430114686489, 0.03069794550538063, 0.014141934923827648, 0.014701079577207565, -0.03373799845576286, -0.02192855253815651, 0.004030220676213503, 0.0055425167083740234, 0.06492165476083755, 0.005021037068217993, 0.05287918448448181, 0.016381802037358284, 0.0036693187430500984, -0.00423986604437232, -0.05767368525266647, 0.001742859953083098, -0.005615842528641224, 0.004207441583275795, 0.015371689572930336, -0.05809330195188522, 0.004570271819829941, 0.04098726436495781, -0.004875364247709513, 0.002892416203394532, 0.01757824420928955, 0.0007987432763911784, -0.004284575115889311, -0.007848847657442093, 0.007699987385421991, -0.03411303833127022, 0.020564716309309006, -0.03752536699175835, 0.013342451304197311, -0.0711267814040184, 0.0006658238708041608, 0.002023027278482914, 0.08514413237571716, 0.01601557247340679, -0.03999411687254906, -0.013216693885624409, -0.08119510114192963, 0.03840305283665657, 0.017909424379467964, -0.04438716173171997, 0.040330495685338974, 0.01465159934014082, 0.027554601430892944, 0.0011915273498743773, 0.03463899344205856, -0.0035472840536385775, -0.060638587921857834, 0.014798527583479881, 0.012317618355154991, -0.03975161910057068, 0.027534976601600647, -0.0231778621673584, -0.012201515957713127, 0.015576779842376709, -0.038167450577020645, -0.027472859248518944, -0.018301477655768394, 0.014291655272245407, -0.0089317187666893, 0.06757762283086777, -0.007995137013494968, 0.009002149105072021, -0.01981237344443798, -0.03614301234483719, 0.12403908371925354, 0.046718113124370575, 0.037152696400880814, -0.04960209131240845, 0.017325783148407936, 0.007688099052757025, 0.006324095651507378, -0.02974039316177368, -0.02123463898897171, 0.011180934496223927, -0.03131689131259918, 0.03571465238928795, 0.021871471777558327, -0.0166882686316967, -0.014097211882472038, 0.04381973668932915, -0.021444078534841537, -0.021843161433935165, 0.0031853558029979467, 0.02712535858154297, -0.03632009029388428, 0.0014954516664147377, -0.011673541739583015, 0.007271538954228163, 0.005114982835948467, -0.008630577474832535, -0.02997758239507675, 0.003968419972807169, -0.009372862055897713, -0.002102821134030819, -0.03504336625337601, 0.004444995429366827, 0.003286493243649602, 0.009817848913371563, -0.011754843406379223, 0.00042374443728476763, 0.030749347060918808, -0.002517192391678691, 0.016673192381858826, 0.02425619587302208, 0.00017911367467604578, -0.006076336372643709, -0.0037544909864664078, -0.029363637790083885, -0.04769187420606613, -0.03455356881022453, 0.012121828272938728, 0.061208296567201614, -0.02653077058494091, -0.015071633271872997, -0.011255905032157898, -0.036281634122133255, 0.026846978813409805, 0.0101142767816782, 0.035398419946432114, 0.030334100127220154, -0.0011364526581019163, -0.05558222159743309, -0.0025129003915935755, 0.007192476186901331, 0.01526894886046648, 0.0033015324734151363, 0.03324340283870697, -0.012603581883013248, -0.058254435658454895, -0.016767308115959167, -0.017146704718470573, 0.033950865268707275, 0.02123011276125908, -0.014034670777618885, -0.018299566581845284, -0.035377904772758484, -0.031527064740657806, -0.03845147043466568, 0.03333982452750206, -0.016764787957072258, 0.023942943662405014, 0.001199784455820918, -0.005808823276311159, -0.04291427507996559, -0.05178075656294823, 0.005943406373262405, -0.033754803240299225, -0.009616108611226082, -0.07625456899404526, -0.014742975123226643, -0.014375508762896061, 0.026221754029393196, -0.014090176671743393, -0.02702268771827221, -0.024220356717705727, 0.05787749961018562, -0.000012975749086763244, -0.04167875275015831, 0.00020715338177978992, 0.005372546147555113, -0.003032395849004388, -0.020803330466151237, -0.03854907676577568, 0.03473623842000961, 0.02478119544684887, 0.03076787106692791, -0.008476478047668934, 0.02918373979628086, -0.019812261685729027, 0.015292227268218994, 0.0331093855202198, -0.03218735009431839, -0.0269100870937109, 0.010460315272212029, 0.006725517101585865, 0.003641159273684025, 0.032396283000707626, -0.009502519853413105, -0.009393762797117233, -0.01880677044391632, -0.01470694225281477, -0.017860455438494682, 0.0022582844831049442, 0.023425420746207237, 0.06544656306505203, -0.037856943905353546, -0.021866226568818092, 0.011479213833808899, 0.018872760236263275, -0.020245973020792007, 0.03337186202406883, -0.0052192299626767635, 0.018971223384141922, -0.013651667162775993, -0.020459851250052452, 0.06987161189317703, 0.01909363642334938, 0.005963928531855345, 0.0009828215697780252, 0.010507924482226372, 0.022162094712257385, 0.04345971718430519, 0.016332771629095078, -0.030031707137823105, 0.0276498906314373, -0.03560015931725502, -0.010168811306357384, 0.03869398683309555, 0.035101182758808136, 0.050637856125831604, 0.0019654040224850178, 0.0018427643226459622, -0.061668556183576584, -0.0027988513465970755, -0.04408847168087959, 0.03378615528345108, -0.003636878216639161, 0.0257739070802927, 0.031223079189658165, -0.012946031056344509, 0.030607594177126884, 0.012475517578423023, 0.016869347542524338, 0.043526630848646164, 0.028476037085056305, 0.017678674310445786, -0.01783818192780018, 0.011261082254350185, -0.03640801087021828, -0.00911785289645195, 0.015880180522799492, -0.01992074027657509, 0.017162922769784927, 0.07309713959693909, -0.030990460887551308, 0.030123641714453697, -0.07087267190217972, 0.005483102519065142, -0.03684103116393089, -0.05628395453095436, 0.01879497617483139, 0.019080646336078644, 0.06887002289295197, -0.041232384741306305, 0.018961070105433464, 0.007269589696079493, -0.045218389481306076, -0.00787840224802494, 0.024073537439107895, 0.01691845990717411, 0.01095690205693245, -0.059542931616306305, 0.0012977543519809842, 0.03055553138256073, -0.040541477501392365, 0.023271851241588593, 0.03850652649998665, 0.019581297412514687, -0.023861011490225792, -0.07659941911697388, -0.05286926031112671, -0.013276796787977219, 0.012395092286169529, -0.025365743786096573, 0.03615638241171837, -0.01694282330572605, -0.028985770419239998, 0.009978635236620903, 0.01119500957429409, 0.035129230469465256, -0.042177002876996994, 0.04590069130063057, 0.030164550989866257, 0.03237009048461914, 0.04093243181705475, 0.06697335839271545, 0.011620618402957916, -0.005933951120823622, -0.011882416903972626, -0.010134565643966198, -0.0010253414511680603, -0.005445520859211683, 0.017887579277157784, -0.020728645846247673, -0.02446722239255905, 0.00019169141887687147, -0.023137178272008896, -0.02682778425514698, 0.03140456601977348, 0.0145976971834898, -0.03581821173429489, -0.01803489960730076, 0.020586049184203148, -0.044763751327991486, -0.015451683662831783, 0.05682246759533882, 0.029308510944247246, -0.0397321917116642, 0.019658038392663002, 0.004653476178646088, -0.017608992755413055, 0.059037432074546814, -0.015132303349673748, -0.04418027773499489, -0.06677904725074768, -0.04243891313672066, -0.010697128251194954, -0.01155532244592905, -0.019741728901863098, 0.0010996729834005237, -0.024271158501505852, 0.024110309779644012, -0.05500594899058342, 0.009456772357225418, -0.03806691989302635, -0.023814575746655464, 0.013659654185175896, -0.08072389662265778, 0.04650381952524185, -0.0036797747015953064, -0.05959131196141243, 0.0007326974300667644, -0.02078351192176342, -0.0003942135372199118, -0.011425601318478584, 0.03752146661281586, 0.010509150102734566, 0.015463361516594887, 0.016377819702029228, 0.029223212972283363, 0.0005743621732108295, -0.06253229826688766, 0.04316521808505058, -0.030948182567954063, -0.0037737505044788122, 0.00776334386318922, 0.006062126252800226, 0.03131990134716034, 0.0006613850709982216, 0.001653437502682209, -0.016534021124243736, 0.004111779388040304, 0.019272925332188606, 0.01943613402545452, 0.029774166643619537, -0.012976204976439476, 0.01672666147351265, 0.023518990725278854, -0.0368456095457077, 0.035883065313100815, 0.03823837265372276, 0.012877912260591984, -0.06978458166122437, 0.011057735420763493, -0.0146297262981534, -0.010899925604462624, -0.013970491476356983, 0.029295440763235092, 0.019166693091392517, -0.009859980084002018, -0.019043348729610443, -0.001109881210140884, 0.013394713401794434, 0.016865666955709457, 0.03855431079864502, 0.04364468529820442, 0.03131701424717903, -0.0031933460850268602, -0.023590050637722015, 0.0003055143461097032, -0.017326824367046356, 0.037769392132759094, 0.01540988776832819, 0.003334800247102976, 0.0013634947827085853, -0.020823422819375992, 0.024957286193966866, -0.01608467474579811, 0.0184320081025362, 0.015858815982937813, -0.006369728595018387, -0.016155991703271866, -0.01980844885110855, 0.040636952966451645, -0.04121757298707962, -0.012904002331197262, -0.027640456333756447, -0.018822340294718742, 0.04595150053501129, -0.02100747637450695, -0.020811036229133606, 0.0036082854494452477, 0.017224010080099106, -0.022237863391637802, 0.01803944632411003, 0.003613521112129092, 0.002585640409961343, 0.0074117667973041534, 0.013122272677719593, 0.016125941649079323, -0.024778233841061592, -0.0016320754075422883, 0.003425748785957694, 0.038390662521123886, 0.05401628836989403, 0.0285708699375391, -0.026531187817454338, -0.05643578618764877, -0.04454547539353371, -0.05479727312922478, 0.0016772318631410599, 0.015746096149086952, -0.015425735153257847, -0.0581231415271759, -0.005283633712679148, 0.007496253587305546, 0.039660416543483734, -0.048758625984191895, -0.0015696586342528462, -0.0006677628844045103, 0.015344970859587193, -0.016379747539758682, 0.001309614279307425 ]
<p>Let X, Y, Z be i.i.d. distributed Gamma random variables. What could the mode of the vector $(X, X+Y, X+Y+Z)$ be?</p> <p>Does the mode of a random vector equal the combination of the marginal modes?</p>
36,008
[ -0.012189913541078568, -0.02111849933862686, 0.03984294459223747, -0.037653107196092606, 0.055556509643793106, 0.045583028346300125, -0.026765791699290276, -0.0025141513906419277, 0.03687027841806412, -0.0337783582508564, 0.040432874113321304, 0.033327117562294006, 0.06131410971283913, 0.033079419285058975, 0.03479927033185959, -0.007375109475106001, -0.01895369216799736, 0.03307901322841644, -0.025192074477672577, -0.008438941091299057, -0.04317007213830948, 0.007782903034240007, 0.03877599537372589, 0.000671589164994657, -0.026250667870044708, 0.05066872015595436, 0.007385305594652891, -0.0009566930821165442, -0.003908091690391302, 0.047624535858631134, -0.0015415583038702607, -0.03168497979640961, 0.020638680085539818, 0.04830183461308479, -0.013179140165448189, -0.04803626611828804, -0.013760463334619999, -0.011481903493404388, -0.0035509685985744, 0.024383259937167168, -0.0610949844121933, -0.04149743169546127, -0.020386425778269768, 0.022026697173714638, -0.024923697113990784, 0.00247928942553699, -0.012051036581397057, -0.009124764241278172, 0.04520002007484436, -0.008376892656087875, 0.09154700487852097, 0.01436588540673256, 0.03145172446966171, 0.02802824229001999, -0.020288672298192978, -0.012766145169734955, 0.0485488586127758, 0.08465781807899475, 0.0353001244366169, -0.062297336757183075, 0.030351314693689346, -0.03664066642522812, 0.000019108239939669147, -0.03277501091361046, -0.025581790134310722, 0.048212818801403046, 0.000603073334787041, -0.03187240660190582, 0.007030629552900791, 0.03958187624812126, -0.020551789551973343, 0.035417359322309494, 0.03863277658820152, -0.01586851477622986, 0.004515677224844694, -0.005435312166810036, 0.0376681312918663, 0.047508660703897476, 0.03840358927845955, -0.013151440769433975, 0.023288069292902946, 0.01952653005719185, 0.028220685198903084, 0.013932629488408566, -0.001447568298317492, -0.02327902615070343, 0.09335432946681976, -0.01628122664988041, 0.01196714211255312, 0.024697406217455864, -0.010933913290500641, 0.012809015810489655, -0.0009647044353187084, -0.019491340965032578, -0.05257410928606987, 0.05879396200180054, -0.020696962252259254, 0.018111493438482285, -0.0024528615176677704, 0.016049468889832497, 0.016218526288866997, -0.039980966597795486, 0.0037701085675507784, 0.07836830615997314, -0.014837637543678284, 0.009191004559397697, -0.026018446311354637, 0.02351846545934677, -0.04767921566963196, -0.0076104504987597466, -0.05290919542312622, 0.019182147458195686, -0.002506829332560301, -0.014394758269190788, 0.031953416764736176, 0.015885503962635994, 0.025178564712405205, -0.05074244365096092, 0.0325351245701313, 0.09962940216064453, 0.03437450900673866, -0.06307801604270935, -0.009598230943083763, -0.04619891569018364, -0.055719539523124695, 0.017929894849658012, 0.014535554684698582, 0.013463187962770462, -0.03848487511277199, 0.03203654661774635, -0.01080391090363264, -0.03239982947707176, 0.03978947922587395, -0.0011593621456995606, 0.0008880406385287642, -0.023738697171211243, -0.05163549259305, -0.019331542775034904, 0.03292166814208031, -0.032921064645051956, -0.0002975814859382808, -0.04927081987261772, -0.004479509312659502, 0.034379877150058746, 0.030607812106609344, -0.0032059221994131804, 0.07591049373149872, 0.02326120249927044, 0.06342688202857971, 0.025198474526405334, -0.01219212543219328, -0.008475000970065594, -0.02615858055651188, -0.034022342413663864, 0.002602857304736972, -0.041946351528167725, 0.032006990164518356, -0.005857972428202629, -0.015916956588625908, -0.009360644966363907, 0.010288835503160954, -0.0034945865627378225, -0.026834312826395035, 0.0004922189982607961, -0.0005666995421051979, -0.053914956748485565, 0.027569357305765152, 0.014822728931903839, 0.06056394428014755, 0.016313323751091957, -0.000579488871153444, 0.008829403668642044, 0.0019287830218672752, 0.04226904734969139, 0.06285205483436584, -0.007504441775381565, -0.04862486571073532, -0.011999024078249931, 0.0008710097172297537, 0.030801856890320778, -0.030540768057107925, -0.020084865391254425, -0.035464171320199966, 0.030267629772424698, 0.004158990923315287, 0.0632818341255188, 0.014823258854448795, -0.007826069369912148, 0.0018393226200714707, -0.012310455553233624, -0.03423311933875084, -0.05506383627653122, 0.04540526494383812, -0.028097067028284073, -0.02504933997988701, 0.0019925839733332396, 0.027814697474241257, 0.03764432668685913, -0.019508713856339455, -0.006989393848925829, -0.022176124155521393, 0.002793349325656891, 0.023513879626989365, -0.013644295744597912, -0.016052646562457085, 0.0198221355676651, 0.06830941140651703, -0.014093326404690742, 0.04844259098172188, -0.006063857581466436, -0.06679579615592957, -0.002459331415593624, -0.009700638242065907, 0.00021182149066589773, -0.008913868106901646, -0.01250273548066616, 0.012264232151210308, 0.010894554667174816, -0.00625107204541564, 0.012462705373764038, -0.04622768238186836, 0.02091590315103531, 0.09983415901660919, 0.009890355169773102, 0.013502162881195545, 0.026625467464327812, -0.001472780597396195, 0.019998040050268173, -0.01817413978278637, -0.01940345950424671, -0.03707281872630119, 0.012147554196417332, 0.06074555218219757, 0.03969023749232292, -0.03648250177502632, 0.050088781863451004, 0.04257877916097641, 0.043503716588020325, 0.03225313499569893, 0.02664370648562908, 0.005533306393772364, 0.011585474014282227, 0.010058596730232239, 0.03510557487607002, 0.021399661898612976, -0.02576528489589691, 0.006025033071637154, -0.01574842259287834, 0.006289265584200621, -0.008819845505058765, -0.021630164235830307, 0.022630758583545685, -0.018847422674298286, 0.015745539218187332, -0.01811908558011055, -0.043921902775764465, 0.06806675344705582, -0.001038922811858356, 0.015378993935883045, 0.011718838475644588, -0.0003893949615303427, 0.008610489778220654, 0.03017805516719818, 0.0010697257239371538, 0.029615864157676697, 0.03764621913433075, -0.040455639362335205, -0.02484123967587948, 0.034915924072265625, -0.020053109154105186, 0.02146056666970253, -0.04069184511899948, -0.02632625214755535, -0.02879355102777481, 0.011862228624522686, 0.028282059356570244, -0.030011074617505074, 0.032342035323381424, -0.022970112040638924, -0.041587039828300476, -0.00985028501600027, -0.006857143249362707, -0.012219552882015705, -0.0003389382909517735, -0.03937274590134621, -0.0023760157637298107, -0.030195988714694977, -0.000253721431363374, 0.008072292432188988, -0.014328371733427048, 0.015321740880608559, 0.0069299121387302876, -0.03158341720700264, -0.07301732152700424, -0.002297863131389022, -0.014124566689133644, 0.016885144636034966, -0.057105910032987595, -0.006324854213744402, 0.03434976190328598, 0.00899739284068346, -0.04608788713812828, -0.012284046038985252, -0.008937069214880466, -0.05139976367354393, -0.017972206696867943, -0.01364407129585743, 0.05157550051808357, -0.015742573887109756, 0.037635866552591324, 0.07458963990211487, -0.060135167092084885, 0.03672249987721443, -0.0763092115521431, -0.04322577640414238, 0.011569199152290821, -0.021378524601459503, 0.0286252498626709, 0.01619565486907959, -0.0024173660203814507, 0.05324699357151985, 0.048333801329135895, -0.05451870709657669, 0.005416339263319969, 0.01963348127901554, 0.0021897549740970135, -0.014192577451467514, 0.03331649675965309, 0.004900586791336536, 0.02727893553674221, 0.05206318199634552, 0.0199214369058609, -0.0016044556396082044, 0.049187395721673965, 0.04614817351102829, -0.009722982533276081, 0.0032265502959489822, 0.03521578013896942, -0.02133944071829319, 0.025106586515903473, 0.031243201345205307, -0.017888382077217102, -0.02476722002029419, 0.022727424278855324, 0.04253360629081726, 0.013109719380736351, -0.018950195983052254, 0.03477182984352112, -0.005746300332248211, 0.022536486387252808, -0.01106047723442316, 0.04421772435307503, 0.07063156366348267, -0.02183235064148903, 0.0026036929339170456, -0.008542751893401146, 0.043573006987571716, -0.045527491718530655, 0.01226348802447319, 0.036009132862091064, 0.023967530578374863, -0.04986501485109329, -0.022290902212262154, -0.009613939560949802, 0.02910759672522545, -0.011156011372804642, -0.028836863115429878, -0.026580430567264557, 0.014508580788969994, 0.011575790122151375, 0.007110182195901871, -0.0015620655613020062, -0.030297068879008293, 0.0013736090622842312, -0.05246637389063835, 0.02745068445801735, -0.023871853947639465, -0.0051755281165242195, 0.031438179314136505, 0.052757009863853455, -0.002703460631892085, -0.00532637070864439, 0.011108293198049068, -0.0210537351667881, -0.07600356638431549, 0.016092563048005104, -0.02586318738758564, 0.010013613849878311, -0.025417381897568703, -0.03119753487408161, 0.028134919703006744, -0.03805231675505638, -0.01341643650084734, -0.0005077908281236887, -0.018018469214439392, -0.05907075107097626, 0.007668364327400923, -0.052366163581609726, -0.0514429435133934, 0.010396362282335758, -0.005597713869065046, 0.05014488846063614, -0.025469642132520676, 0.012067449279129505, 0.029841767624020576, 0.01823219284415245, 0.023111557587981224, -0.010952162556350231, 0.003375173080712557, -0.016529399901628494, 0.027377180755138397, -0.000008950495612225495, 0.04748021811246872, 0.03029952570796013, 0.02212655544281006, 0.0007324662292376161, 0.05571843311190605, 0.04362936690449715, -0.026491671800613403, -0.027781248092651367, -0.0040597510524094105, -0.020397750660777092, 0.019689012318849564, 0.00630949204787612, 0.016508623957633972, 0.02093026041984558, 0.06287107616662979, 0.022922802716493607, -0.04722248390316963, 0.03689570352435112, 0.027086732909083366, 0.02630508691072464, -0.05444679409265518, -0.05003573000431061, 0.010556991212069988, -0.010104878805577755, -0.03754632920026779, 0.013349121436476707, -0.019098524004220963, -0.031371522694826126, 0.018207786604762077, 0.012714257463812828, -0.02307979390025139, -0.015585575252771378, -0.00041611530468799174, 0.009610389359295368, 0.007060876116156578, 0.03092520497739315, -0.054993219673633575, -0.011870717629790306, 0.031130433082580566, 0.023706231266260147, 0.02790991961956024, -0.02466898038983345, -0.0648198053240776, 0.011056307703256607, 0.0724591463804245, 0.011665349826216698, -0.006389325950294733, 0.002217341912910342, -0.054587315768003464, 0.0037222616374492645, 0.03827453404664993, -0.037410035729408264, 0.014023355208337307, -0.06741851568222046, -0.02623717300593853, -0.018234720453619957, -0.04778110608458519, -0.0772920697927475, 0.03362292796373367, 0.03475888818502426, -0.007933862507343292, -0.0031397086568176746, -0.020211637020111084, -0.03377780318260193, 0.010945070534944534, 0.02702142298221588, 0.04133801907300949, 0.020235922187566757, 0.005577994044870138, -0.01542805414646864, 0.04106850177049637, 0.0021892536897212267, -0.09754133969545364, 0.05372348800301552, 0.03529120236635208, -0.01110354345291853, 0.03162312135100365, -0.017737925052642822, -0.04999201372265816, 0.039140570908784866, 0.014818315394222736, 0.025868307799100876, 0.044989462941884995, -0.03666869178414345, 0.06445445865392685, 0.02429967187345028, 0.034453462809324265, 0.035940226167440414, 0.026979930698871613, -0.02207881771028042, -0.042204972356557846, -0.03028005361557007, 0.028452441096305847, -0.04323054477572441, -0.00981071311980486, -0.024515824392437935, 0.01989971473813057, -0.0013321054866537452, 0.05094987526535988, 0.007301936391741037, 0.00700529245659709, -0.015185050666332245, -0.025817718356847763, -0.03692043200135231, 0.01037169061601162, 0.004921277519315481, -0.020265936851501465, -0.024948205798864365, 0.026038292795419693, -0.006107277236878872, 0.009867256507277489, 0.03426612168550491, -0.03057902120053768, 0.007482605520635843, 0.01316088531166315, -0.03520738705992699, 0.024958688765764236, -0.027675112709403038, 0.02568652853369713, -0.0017915618373081088, -0.019066721200942993, 0.04104819521307945, -0.0037552022840827703, -0.017643632367253304, 0.02041192725300789, -0.03139368072152138, -0.024836208671331406, 0.008696582168340683, 0.03213763236999512, 0.025433635339140892, -0.029508760198950768, 0.0538623072206974, -0.014957781881093979, -0.03046361170709133, -0.09097927063703537, -0.03659070283174515, 0.03067152015864849, -0.0037018766161054373, 0.030065694823861122, -0.022999094799160957, 0.03143279254436493, -0.021773645654320717, -0.05783279612660408, -0.025276144966483116, 0.00941580068320036, -0.0010303875897079706, -0.016581416130065918, 0.0010096507612615824, -0.0003768038295675069, 0.05373694375157356, 0.003409511875361204, -0.022055761888623238, 0.05293721705675125, -0.05058714747428894, 0.006123552098870277, -0.002229521982371807, 0.007270186208188534, -0.020981788635253906, -0.015102670527994633, -0.009845100343227386, 0.007356885354965925, 0.012839359231293201, -0.023053079843521118, -0.011867705732584, 0.01355123519897461, -0.03066856786608696, -0.028289975598454475, 0.0007040730561129749, -0.02495838701725006, 0.021833721548318863, 0.002406769897788763, 0.005384224466979504, -0.009260270744562149, -0.020077891647815704, -0.003086509183049202, 0.05129672959446907, -0.00433466536924243, -0.008195913396775723, 0.04788807034492493, 0.0478505976498127, -0.007121643517166376, 0.020116634666919708, -0.022002512589097023, 0.02488512173295021, 0.038983054459095, -0.012756921350955963, -0.005921737290918827, 0.013832216151058674, 0.012675615958869457, -0.02066686749458313, 0.005632193759083748, -0.05441928282380104, 0.011319441720843315, 0.06660140305757523, 0.024077968671917915, 0.028209397569298744, 0.031467657536268234, 0.008512372151017189, 0.0005436642095446587, -0.014741308055818081, 0.00928768701851368, -0.00984531082212925, -0.012019908055663109, 0.03650307655334473, -0.03681604564189911, -0.0007602070108987391, 0.029386349022388458, 0.02183610387146473, -0.03060188889503479, 0.011716571636497974, -0.005827645771205425, 0.009470419958233833, 0.02635231800377369, -0.012969668954610825, -0.04529400169849396, 0.013832448981702328, -0.049304984509944916, -0.009828208945691586, -0.03663869574666023, -0.04746076092123985, 0.024521974846720695, 0.030212754383683205, -0.006169389467686415, -0.029979776591062546, 0.014031955040991306, -0.028502648696303368, 0.007098831236362457, 0.006618734449148178, 0.011174765415489674, 0.045888904482126236, 0.02266840822994709, 0.034197404980659485, -0.014676460064947605, 0.03477806970477104, -0.0018592410488054156, -0.06577537208795547, 0.0038409295957535505, 0.00402768375352025, -0.06570347398519516, 0.010045514442026615, 0.00792483426630497, 0.0011197099229320884, 0.010018312372267246, -0.01928052306175232, 0.001206067157909274, 0.016908280551433563, 0.04735814034938812, -0.012426402419805527, 0.07634791731834412, -0.0036947333719581366, 0.017744937911629677, 0.017627600580453873, 0.00006567890523001552, 0.10653191804885864, 0.0433947928249836, 0.03904757648706436, -0.04703189432621002, 0.0264615286141634, -0.02949279360473156, -0.0050287917256355286, -0.04223811998963356, 0.015522436238825321, -0.006223754025995731, -0.015871968120336533, 0.0398460328578949, 0.03602304682135582, -0.006652343552559614, 0.00905059278011322, 0.023520832881331444, -0.05395117029547691, -0.023630846291780472, -0.013482053764164448, 0.016958927735686302, -0.002440506126731634, 0.00972010288387537, -0.03612985461950302, 0.022990111261606216, -0.01639501005411148, -0.0300140418112278, -0.029815886169672012, -0.052903834730386734, -0.010990623384714127, 0.00045847060391679406, -0.0019104492384940386, -0.029435433447360992, 0.04911595210433006, 0.007375104818493128, 0.01494714617729187, 0.014133136719465256, 0.009025678038597107, -0.011897686868906021, 0.021318890154361725, -0.010132229886949062, -0.03151842951774597, 0.006700974423438311, 0.036445654928684235, -0.0020619179122149944, -0.05401463061571121, -0.009973783977329731, -0.0035711643286049366, 0.05300747603178024, 0.006866733077913523, 0.016117142513394356, -0.06495367735624313, 0.023169754073023796, 0.011602424085140228, -0.03738008067011833, -0.029952574521303177, -0.008484662510454655, 0.04525666683912277, -0.041148263961076736, -0.04439716413617134, 0.0007570534362457693, -0.00018852174980565906, -0.03865635395050049, 0.0596299022436142, -0.007967240177094936, -0.06488129496574402, 0.002773270243778825, -0.02779190056025982, 0.060246795415878296, 0.0339355431497097, -0.014443084597587585, -0.023983629420399666, -0.05489175766706467, -0.03673926740884781, -0.02751799114048481, 0.013832573778927326, -0.006059082690626383, -0.014494826085865498, 0.0030322237871587276, -0.011173710227012634, -0.00472568953409791, -0.06655056029558182, -0.01875617913901806, -0.01347027812153101, 0.004561492707580328, -0.028623761609196663, 0.0198092982172966, 0.008258364163339138, 0.05095221847295761, -0.020557090640068054, -0.01279726903885603, -0.014269720762968063, 0.07377573102712631, -0.012561590410768986, -0.0067471694201231, -0.004366209264844656, -0.01227321196347475, -0.016540510579943657, -0.029280569404363632, 0.0008016545907594264, 0.04093165695667267, 0.0007416330045089126, 0.029349932447075844, 0.0008195378468371928, 0.02718874253332615, -0.01910916157066822, -0.0269157811999321, 0.004482231102883816, -0.05459730327129364, 0.0049839019775390625, 0.01552641112357378, 0.022575924172997475, -0.043855443596839905, -0.015560637228190899, 0.012919289059937, 0.011388257145881653, 0.003963308408856392, -0.02589571289718151, -0.012447962537407875, -0.03953989967703819, -0.003082865383476019, 0.02998649887740612, -0.008868538774549961, -0.0029464715626090765, -0.0022769179195165634, 0.02522645704448223, -0.00005976398097118363, 0.013849184848368168, 0.0066975681111216545, 0.021670985966920853, 0.00016152678290382028, -0.013871423900127411, 0.021543027833104134, 0.04502737522125244, 0.010040010325610638, -0.011971925385296345, 0.02338773012161255, 0.009211058728396893, 0.04133192449808121, -0.011097696609795094, -0.02026907354593277, 0.04142526164650917, -0.038609303534030914, 0.004218659363687038, 0.026811856776475906, -0.010112636722624302, 0.030149444937705994, 0.024164600297808647, -0.018150202929973602, -0.021627003327012062, 0.008381250314414501, -0.018126094713807106, 0.00460774963721633, 0.002260314766317606, -0.005379340145736933, -0.0239727646112442, 0.0029085397254675627, 0.0019468388054519892, 0.04156705364584923, -0.04198913648724556, 0.004573181737214327, 0.021539807319641113, -0.029882345348596573, 0.013622219674289227, 0.031097661703824997, 0.014094993472099304, 0.026432644575834274, 0.0005311854765750468, 0.003128517884761095, 0.025442946702241898, 0.07544349133968353, -0.025015905499458313, 0.04990087077021599, 0.00789086613804102, 0.01538198720663786, -0.09042399376630783, -0.04430669546127319, 0.06909865885972977, -0.011460183188319206, 0.04740823060274124, -0.039770811796188354, 0.0024240531492978334, 0.021390272304415703, -0.05945024639368057, -0.0048149581998586655, 0.045039400458335876, -0.004774495959281921, -0.0548039935529232, 0.038679175078868866, -0.00708774384111166, 0.04591718688607216, 0.008760458789765835, 0.03446997329592705, 0.04716210067272186, 0.0376754105091095, -0.05443429574370384, -0.032628342509269714, -0.036675143986940384, 0.008594175800681114, -0.005578913725912571, -0.013626260682940483, 0.07166842371225357, -0.03599970415234566, -0.03914869204163551, 0.002752862172201276, 0.044491641223430634, 0.01177492830902338, 0.009637344628572464, 0.031665343791246414, 0.002018472645431757, 0.04059147462248802, 0.04569742828607559, -0.01712869480252266, -0.012106524780392647, 0.0074074044823646545, 0.006765752099454403, 0.014932076446712017, -0.017691437155008316, 0.005061034113168716, 0.012370189651846886, 0.0005031969049014151, -0.015103382989764214, -0.020205602049827576, -0.0076645114459097385, -0.06531310081481934, -0.00951417163014412, -0.012572435662150383, -0.001920942566357553, -0.04442218318581581, 0.038853976875543594, -0.0681496188044548, -0.03536102920770645, 0.0430678054690361, 0.016405833885073662, -0.004869696218520403, -0.002881398191675544, 0.012554601766169071, -0.07802333682775497, -0.03174779564142227, 0.006647347006946802, -0.013108412735164165, -0.05853644758462906, 0.02490183711051941, 0.02363372966647148, 0.0025695485528558493, 0.00792755838483572, -0.02891731634736061, -0.0480012372136116, 0.0279337577521801, -0.00824528094381094, 0.038042329251766205, -0.0139892203733325, -0.021047409623861313, 0.0019540314096957445, -0.05572066083550453, 0.008505658246576786, 0.04526514559984207, -0.012759764678776264, -0.046034809201955795, -0.02329990640282631, -0.008140946738421917, -0.022733664140105247, 0.06187191978096962, 0.0012774498900398612, 0.0006799105904065073, 0.003274441696703434, 0.06353840231895447, 0.05500831454992294, -0.04104502499103546, -0.009350566193461418, -0.032579682767391205, -0.03988482058048248, -0.03275071084499359, 0.00827023759484291, 0.026446321979165077, -0.019400767982006073, 0.0272721778601408, -0.026020290330052376, -0.012746436521410942, -0.0009416844113729894, -0.05493422970175743, 0.04730231687426567, 0.01276379358023405, -0.026928044855594635, 0.06484919041395187, -0.03283056244254112, 0.030453534796833992, -0.009591971524059772, -0.011484289541840553, -0.06502462923526764, 0.0005599778378382325, -0.03096814826130867, 0.008849581703543663, -0.013822419568896294, 0.012233865447342396, 0.011565078049898148, -0.029392488300800323, -0.01589832827448845, 0.03834918886423111, -0.06566862016916275, 0.00376110733486712, 0.050450559705495834, 0.007594001013785601, 0.05175548046827316, 0.003820326179265976, -0.02250939980149269, 0.0185026153922081, -0.008905402384698391, 0.0009088498773053288, 0.026703229174017906, 0.010707593522965908, -0.028356611728668213, -0.028961127623915672, 0.017065051943063736, -0.03510352969169617, 0.027436137199401855, -0.02868269756436348, 0.013994776643812656, -0.017044926062226295, -0.032637566328048706, 0.020935362204909325, 0.0030405656434595585, -0.01096849050372839, 0.00011501133121782914, -0.00890872348099947, 0.06701982021331787, -0.028269650414586067, -0.0079782884567976, -0.03852594271302223, -0.04601705074310303, -0.051257770508527756, 0.010035081766545773, 0.03435882553458214, 0.015795474871993065, 0.015280306339263916, 0.0162645410746336, -0.003111190628260374, -0.039917781949043274, 0.024635951966047287, -0.039411772042512894, 0.021775925531983376, -0.022029709070920944, 0.009119597263634205, 0.028928019106388092, -0.007209468632936478, -0.04568401351571083, -0.03859148919582367, -0.025873836129903793, 0.03436138108372688, 0.032944872975349426, 0.000428220781031996, 0.0011608595959842205, -0.020307686179876328, 0.06604327261447906, -0.06546322256326675, -0.03193623200058937, -0.04928506165742874, 0.020772133022546768, 0.006061516236513853, 0.005831512622535229 ]
<p>I'm trying to understand the properties of Mahalanobis distance of multivariate random points (my final goal is to use Mahalanobis distance for outlier detection). My calculations are in python. I miss some basics here and will be glad if someone will explain me my mistake.</p> <p>Here is my code:</p> <p>First I generate 1000 multivariate (2D) random points around the origin</p> <pre><code>#imports and definitions import numpy as np import scipy.stats as stats import scipy.spatial.distance as distance chi2 = stats.chi2 np.random.seed(111) #covariance matrix: X and Y are normally distributed with std of 1 #and are independent one of another covCircle = array([[1, 0.], [0., 1.]]) circle = multivariate_normal([0, 0], covCircle, 1000) #1000 points around [0, 0] mahalanobis = lambda p: distance.mahalanobis(p, [0, 0], covCircle.T) d = np.array(map(mahalanobis, circle)) #Mahalanobis distance values for the 1000 points d2 = d ** 2 #MD squared </code></pre> <p>At this point I expect that <code>d2</code> (Mahalanobis distance values squared) to follow chi2 distribution with 2 degrees of freedom. I would like to calculate the corresponding probability distribution function (PDF) values and use them for outlier detection. To illustrate my problem, plot the calculated PDF values for values between 0 and 10 for chi-squared distribution with 2 degrees of freedom and with location and scale values equal to the mean and standard deviation of <code>d2</code>, respectively:</p> <pre><code>theMean = mean(d2) theStd = std(d2) x = linspace(0, 10) pdf = chi2.pdf(x, 2, theMean, theStd) plot(x, pdf, '-b') </code></pre> <p>Here is the plot:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hLDyO.png" alt="enter image description here"> As we can see, the PDF values that correspond to <code>X</code> values below ~2.04 are neglegible low, suggesting that there are no points that are closer than 2.04 from the origin, which is obviously not true. What am I missing?</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong> Why am I using <code>theMean</code> and <code>theStd</code> as arguments to the pdf function? As far as I understand, the distances are expected to have chi2 distribution with the given mean and stdev. That is why I use these as arguments to PDF. From a comment to this question I understand that this is not true. So what are the correct parameters of the theoretical chi2 distribution?</p>
73,600
[ -0.029651924967765808, -0.02230909839272499, 0.013888302259147167, -0.016183316707611084, 0.03670463711023331, -0.022688915953040123, -0.017534345388412476, -0.04271942004561424, 0.0007250257767736912, -0.05740871652960777, 0.04962282255291939, 0.011611606925725937, 0.061808377504348755, 0.04143856093287468, 0.02618565410375595, -0.032572317868471146, -0.015504573471844196, 0.018859513103961945, 0.045319125056266785, -0.026742273941636086, -0.003664415329694748, 0.00444113090634346, 0.060345813632011414, -0.01323121227324009, -0.04155522584915161, 0.03243216127157211, 0.013336759991943836, -0.013520506210625172, 0.012760309502482414, 0.01045044045895338, -0.0660591870546341, -0.05998799204826355, 0.03488389402627945, -0.005808067042380571, 0.022456670179963112, 0.026066748425364494, -0.03343404456973076, -0.0076896511018276215, -0.019674936309456825, 0.009183268062770367, 0.0014836364425718784, 0.013312171213328838, 0.020698416978120804, 0.045209892094135284, -0.022905344143509865, 0.007865491323173046, -0.0009533236734569073, -0.016502054408192635, 0.044833265244960785, -0.022301936522126198, 0.11119062453508377, 0.00201647006906569, 0.032830774784088135, 0.007498284801840782, -0.038680173456668854, -0.0016042799688875675, 0.02892109751701355, 0.052411485463380814, -0.01946691982448101, -0.08709961920976639, 0.00650447141379118, -0.02515813335776329, 0.016624806448817253, -0.01866726018488407, 0.01022584643214941, 0.00223154085688293, -0.012122846208512783, -0.009958073496818542, 0.045591000467538834, -0.008210389874875546, 0.0335799939930439, 0.007178549189120531, -0.013147559016942978, -0.05715527385473251, 0.023070694878697395, -0.018818577751517296, -0.0242758896201849, 0.006668149959295988, 0.03285028040409088, -0.022243477404117584, 0.035220324993133545, 0.024109341204166412, -0.005938772577792406, -0.01422035787254572, 0.05081534758210182, 0.04180680215358734, 0.03986803814768791, -0.03855603188276291, 0.00385175459086895, 0.0065882946364581585, 0.008431598544120789, 0.007959381677210331, 0.061198100447654724, 0.021868539974093437, -0.029942000284790993, 0.01376854907721281, -0.03949573636054993, 0.014811157248914242, -0.04615287855267525, -0.008446668274700642, -0.06055070087313652, -0.026387497782707214, 0.06499515473842621, 0.04169215261936188, -0.027639666572213173, -0.005828996654599905, -0.019632231444120407, 0.014153826050460339, -0.013201671652495861, -0.012330933474004269, -0.04736463725566864, 0.006143794860690832, 0.02055535651743412, 0.0074651348404586315, 0.032219137996435165, -0.0058739809319376945, 0.000674668641295284, 0.03323373571038246, 0.011037390679121017, 0.03092910908162594, 0.012640044093132019, -0.005882706958800554, 0.00009893012611428276, -0.03497282415628433, -0.03854193165898323, 0.027735326439142227, 0.0328972153365612, 0.013105844147503376, -0.02224072255194187, 0.020161086693406105, -0.008636263199150562, 0.008541500195860863, 0.00526104960590601, 0.062223318964242935, -0.00622520549222827, -0.02178334817290306, -0.10130235552787781, -0.025971191003918648, 0.034325011074543, 0.013935079798102379, 0.04608713835477829, -0.04386477544903755, -0.020456185564398766, 0.027031883597373962, 0.07023878395557404, 0.0056091658771038055, 0.026169072836637497, 0.030814189463853836, 0.028515085577964783, -0.02338518016040325, -0.024957772344350815, -0.012469509616494179, -0.03661474585533142, -0.013915267772972584, -0.03665029630064964, -0.09027639776468277, 0.02576090395450592, 0.021512938663363457, -0.02706579677760601, -0.04456993564963341, 0.012717029079794884, -0.0032962786499410868, -0.01261801365762949, -0.007614664267748594, -0.0025406270287930965, -0.04779292270541191, 0.07244209200143814, 0.026365088298916817, 0.02596883475780487, 0.02405184507369995, -0.031155003234744072, 0.00820785854011774, -0.02559463307261467, 0.03627387806773186, 0.02784365974366665, 0.01209664810448885, -0.0040821898728609085, -0.0034917069133371115, 0.052925582975149155, 0.02597023919224739, -0.058034222573041916, -0.024566790089011192, -0.05049733445048332, -0.01381086278706789, 0.018269360065460205, 0.007970951497554779, 0.011796833015978336, -0.01609761454164982, 0.01917446032166481, -0.060652948915958405, -0.023830905556678772, -0.05539820343255997, 0.0026912486646324396, 0.0044472613371908665, -0.041989389806985855, -0.020067725330591202, -0.010471781715750694, 0.02218186855316162, 0.003098652698099613, 0.0009326445870101452, -0.0276324562728405, -0.026336669921875, 0.046649545431137085, -0.02627800591289997, -0.0038245278410613537, 0.046452026814222336, 0.07656586170196533, 0.019206732511520386, 0.021684227511286736, -0.017017396166920662, 0.0047566331923007965, -0.005120277404785156, -0.007929962128400803, -0.031554922461509705, -0.0036051650531589985, 0.0012586599914357066, 0.016685456037521362, 0.018192313611507416, -0.030486101284623146, -0.0016402428736910224, -0.03601551800966263, 0.08269688487052917, 0.06478825956583023, 0.002512800507247448, -0.025357963517308235, -0.0016468893736600876, -0.01576852984726429, 0.00199984572827816, -0.03726934269070625, -0.043922584503889084, -0.0677759200334549, -0.014515516348183155, 0.019352952018380165, 0.04559563845396042, -0.03089389204978943, -0.016355443745851517, 0.05596551671624184, -0.007832610048353672, 0.008304763585329056, 0.026768352836370468, 0.013484836556017399, -0.06028389930725098, 0.03015945293009281, 0.01187717355787754, 0.000647723616566509, 0.002427652245387435, 0.02422235533595085, -0.009164111688733101, 0.030250554904341698, -0.01834145188331604, -0.022134749218821526, 0.031277671456336975, -0.03431457281112671, -0.0025066928938031197, -0.027936959639191628, 0.041143208742141724, 0.04539100453257561, 0.0250578410923481, 0.00030648571555502713, 0.04891490191221237, -0.008441288024187088, 0.03108043782413006, 0.013022963888943195, -0.029917698353528976, -0.0038429650012403727, 0.04026477038860321, -0.030876964330673218, -0.01251310482621193, 0.005089606624096632, -0.047549765557050705, 0.0010730057256296277, 0.00906412024050951, -0.04481343552470207, 0.00331205315887928, 0.015552585944533348, 0.05727274343371391, 0.038525842130184174, 0.010490722954273224, 0.014210724271833897, -0.009398950263857841, -0.06160179525613785, 0.00387610774487257, 0.026342099532485008, -0.005484385881572962, -0.05737782642245293, 0.008291437290608883, -0.022895194590091705, -0.00027149682864546776, -0.012014815583825111, -0.018518825992941856, 0.009081315249204636, 0.005160581320524216, -0.005891929846256971, -0.043450914323329926, 0.010975981131196022, 0.012883419170975685, 0.03385885804891586, -0.007937059737741947, -0.03507198765873909, 0.03673061728477478, -0.010144946165382862, -0.026830507442355156, 0.04218563064932823, 0.012863474898040295, -0.021110743284225464, -0.060838859528303146, 0.01362235564738512, 0.009150709956884384, -0.017006605863571167, 0.0333925262093544, 0.028561340644955635, 0.024188661947846413, -0.012937463819980621, -0.01881493255496025, -0.055796343833208084, -0.0020660620648413897, 0.02135336399078369, 0.035369399935007095, -0.04164653643965721, -0.003506628330796957, 0.05165872350335121, 0.028745193034410477, -0.004269877914339304, -0.007058653049170971, 0.026485012844204903, -0.05920189991593361, -0.030422784388065338, 0.016672272235155106, 0.0026992568746209145, 0.01614941656589508, -0.010796235874295235, -0.02801937237381935, 0.017699215561151505, 0.07423115521669388, -0.047803543508052826, -0.03773768991231918, 0.00861671194434166, 0.002687268191948533, -0.01960565894842148, 0.047089070081710815, 0.0027350387535989285, -0.03085234761238098, -0.00041095499182119966, 0.005384691990911961, 0.049628205597400665, -0.019050994887948036, -0.030880620703101158, 0.021973468363285065, -0.03575070574879646, 0.01757875829935074, -0.06952427327632904, 0.024708740413188934, 0.013629314489662647, -0.05371361970901489, -0.0009751843172125518, 0.0004908469272777438, 0.061290543526411057, -0.02605854719877243, -0.03689085692167282, 0.05436895415186882, 0.038214683532714844, 0.04603945463895798, 0.051503412425518036, -0.039592720568180084, 0.004737940616905689, 0.020358219742774963, -0.046352945268154144, -0.00812741369009018, 0.01491762325167656, 0.05898391455411911, -0.012111227959394455, 0.029765784740447998, -0.03457452356815338, 0.0376141257584095, -0.04078321531414986, -0.01882486417889595, -0.051621273159980774, 0.038770586252212524, 0.020656464621424675, 0.02423817105591297, 0.015214670449495316, -0.042729467153549194, -0.04750161990523338, -0.024526851251721382, -0.05358820781111717, -0.006181384902447462, 0.0023793496657162905, -0.02378893457353115, 0.013530716300010681, -0.07133851945400238, 0.004006349015980959, -0.01537063717842102, 0.02994968369603157, 0.01607818715274334, 0.00711378687992692, -0.06038481369614601, 0.013017464429140091, -0.012703873217105865, 0.013742919079959393, -0.027458595111966133, 0.033489909023046494, 0.0158174280077219, 0.0016967365518212318, 0.05724835395812988, 0.035418059676885605, -0.007459145504981279, -0.024958159774541855, -0.018915310502052307, 0.005495802033692598, 0.02804882824420929, 0.013493095524609089, -0.00627259723842144, 0.027826912701129913, -0.00644440483301878, 0.031106941401958466, -0.004345031920820475, 0.07634417712688446, 0.03944173455238342, -0.02025897614657879, 0.014575373381376266, -0.026579048484563828, -0.041593682020902634, -0.005545414984226227, 0.029507718980312347, -0.01582910120487213, 0.02921382524073124, 0.02332492545247078, -0.0032627657055854797, -0.05154506862163544, 0.009330516681075096, 0.08102760463953018, -0.02182770147919655, -0.0034786120522767305, -0.014112845994532108, -0.04970414564013481, 0.00023906491696834564, -0.01004092302173376, -0.004489149432629347, -0.0018682369263842702, -0.03904899209737778, -0.0006960910395719111, 0.05105511099100113, -0.019890977069735527, -0.03298184648156166, -0.006337328348308802, 0.03286650404334068, 0.04658399522304535, 0.005686270073056221, -0.004880742635577917, -0.0076881153509020805, 0.010050715878605843, 0.04076042026281357, 0.05847273766994476, 0.03455603867769241, -0.07417453825473785, 0.007848826237022877, 0.004609715659171343, 0.03518444299697876, 0.006213951390236616, -0.012126132845878601, -0.05130302906036377, -0.008348094299435616, -0.00572198536247015, -0.061075665056705475, 0.012473166920244694, -0.015243942849338055, 0.011880673468112946, -0.007265877909958363, -0.010700267739593983, -0.08566063642501831, 0.011480849236249924, -0.027112644165754318, 0.0274976659566164, -0.05572063848376274, -0.043051060289144516, -0.03768401965498924, -0.013745424337685108, 0.0163137074559927, 0.06966692954301834, -0.04281875863671303, -0.017436573281884193, -0.01294503454118967, 0.022260164842009544, -0.0015132706612348557, -0.053010422736406326, 0.026882704347372055, -0.002526479074731469, -0.014987342990934849, 0.06026022136211395, -0.02340460568666458, -0.016315104439854622, 0.012014731764793396, 0.015033282339572906, -0.013925268314778805, 0.03982435539364815, 0.004717111121863127, 0.027734823524951935, 0.054795436561107635, -0.0094508808106184, 0.01650693453848362, 0.01448525208979845, -0.01227877102792263, 0.0017119947588071227, -0.04471082240343094, 0.04243167117238045, -0.0066917832009494305, -0.034039318561553955, -0.06304633617401123, -0.013277383521199226, -0.0047391606494784355, 0.012978658080101013, 0.021882519125938416, 0.0287774670869112, -0.022824939340353012, -0.011157817207276821, 0.013041985221207142, 0.05121134966611862, 0.008966281078755856, 0.023419037461280823, -0.021241575479507446, 0.03785806521773338, 0.03485187143087387, -0.011121717281639576, 0.02355082891881466, -0.005266861524432898, -0.014909672550857067, 0.039372965693473816, -0.044786714017391205, -0.02114848792552948, -0.06115240976214409, -0.05141204595565796, -0.005884826648980379, -0.03251700848340988, -0.0011166746262460947, -0.0005777374026365578, 0.0116356136277318, 0.03180541843175888, -0.020538462325930595, 0.00572222052142024, 0.038418374955654144, -0.002366326516494155, 0.03653628006577492, -0.025476139038801193, 0.028622997924685478, 0.018419651314616203, -0.003983324859291315, -0.04897625371813774, -0.011405483819544315, 0.026526063680648804, -0.013785132206976414, -0.04312669485807419, -0.04082748293876648, -0.04130372405052185, 0.00019880528270732611, -0.025512488558888435, -0.018978025764226913, 0.049150314182043076, -0.031136859208345413, 0.016978248953819275, -0.013892832212150097, -0.0138442013412714, 0.05726032331585884, -0.06156231090426445, -0.010453002527356148, 0.037262290716171265, 0.02900201641023159, 0.0025576711632311344, 0.013012210838496685, 0.051816247403621674, -0.028767753392457962, -0.0026096347719430923, -0.052911415696144104, 0.05397758260369301, 0.046302612870931625, -0.008772267028689384, -0.023773055523633957, -0.043859053403139114, 0.007401562295854092, 0.024958627298474312, -0.01376707199960947, -0.037795234471559525, -0.005243163090199232, 0.005524400621652603, -0.028379077091813087, 0.004122584126889706, -0.03255254402756691, -0.016873769462108612, 0.015681114047765732, 0.006197288166731596, 0.0037182464729994535, -0.006946719251573086, 0.037982504814863205, 0.013275392353534698, 0.00975753366947174, -0.018798185512423515, 0.02231622114777565, 0.025294888764619827, -0.02114054188132286, -0.020983699709177017, -0.008797618560492992, 0.03537645936012268, -0.03432152047753334, 0.016425160691142082, -0.06735880672931671, 0.013509740121662617, 0.07990328967571259, 0.013886022381484509, 0.04115616902709007, 0.02154015377163887, -0.014238286763429642, -0.032801248133182526, -0.05625009536743164, -0.04286014661192894, -0.013031847774982452, 0.0058455634862184525, 0.020648468285799026, -0.017182648181915283, -0.01242676842957735, 0.038827698677778244, 0.02434614673256874, 0.02194516733288765, 0.024160919710993767, -0.00692244665697217, 0.00658642640337348, 0.01380927674472332, -0.022247279062867165, -0.0038860756903886795, 0.048326313495635986, -0.033552203327417374, 0.02503158710896969, -0.02247719094157219, -0.00008643751061754301, 0.03305303677916527, 0.03682572767138481, -0.023170389235019684, -0.006615271791815758, -0.015656791627407074, -0.05697153881192207, 0.0295260027050972, 0.014491459354758263, -0.015724720433354378, 0.00003207535337423906, 0.015662111341953278, 0.03811550885438919, 0.02170512266457081, 0.011493147350847721, -0.03948597609996796, -0.047188900411129, -0.04417450353503227, 0.018181856721639633, -0.016601815819740295, 0.012443375773727894, -0.0075332531705498695, -0.02858073264360428, -0.009257053956389427, -0.028238922357559204, 0.04771619662642479, -0.006859561428427696, 0.013221918605268002, -0.002159836934879422, 0.0786847174167633, 0.014949155040085316, -0.017382346093654633, -0.02648279070854187, 0.015371535904705524, 0.12361899018287659, 0.03165652975440025, 0.010839942842721939, -0.07235300540924072, 0.00614139111712575, -0.004106991924345493, 0.0007656858069822192, -0.038399625569581985, 0.0012016813270747662, 0.018769964575767517, -0.018310004845261574, 0.03822649270296097, -0.004963068291544914, 0.04023361578583717, -0.018438121303915977, 0.024080298840999603, 0.019299110397696495, -0.05479058250784874, -0.02489694207906723, 0.021270830184221268, -0.025240056216716766, 0.008722917176783085, -0.05104861781001091, 0.021006835624575615, -0.025064904242753983, -0.006870183628052473, -0.02953958325088024, -0.012411125004291534, -0.011995759792625904, 0.004925869405269623, -0.05079210177063942, 0.0026232192758470774, 0.028296642005443573, -0.010586378164589405, 0.008834783919155598, 0.020781751722097397, 0.0021703073289245367, -0.0194636732339859, 0.023550929501652718, -0.009235688485205173, -0.02097180485725403, 0.01655390113592148, 0.018023032695055008, 0.02987792156636715, -0.02058091200888157, -0.040112048387527466, -0.0481727160513401, 0.0820409432053566, -0.0019094947492703795, 0.0058332933112978935, 0.017407311126589775, 0.029651399701833725, 0.024226011708378792, -0.034138210117816925, 0.02303638495504856, -0.02317672222852707, 0.029540013521909714, 0.04062129184603691, -0.009851871058344841, -0.008540171198546886, 0.03652676194906235, 0.008604335598647594, 0.03508280590176582, 0.011399339884519577, -0.0038938671350479126, -0.02368348091840744, -0.02348826639354229, 0.05946672335267067, -0.0014105862937867641, 0.04394593462347984, -0.02479831874370575, -0.014230468310415745, 0.001012887223623693, -0.008206191472709179, 0.007281201425939798, -0.030850118026137352, 0.013497482985258102, 0.03641626238822937, -0.025806279852986336, -0.035548485815525055, -0.01860954985022545, 0.0022552914451807737, -0.032609399408102036, -0.01362489815801382, -0.014634762890636921, 0.0075355288572609425, 0.04316936805844307, 0.05480710789561272, 0.06936588138341904, 0.03312957286834717, -0.03542812168598175, 0.04861811175942421, 0.0005980859859846532, -0.04019680619239807, 0.020092574879527092, 0.021999264135956764, -0.03846421465277672, -0.022531922906637192, 0.006750245112925768, 0.020269058644771576, 0.05007524415850639, 0.04349162057042122, 0.007001524791121483, 0.038080450147390366, -0.01114543154835701, -0.009132659062743187, 0.002218193607404828, -0.0735282376408577, 0.008292225189507008, -0.009810782968997955, -0.009428630582988262, -0.011681354604661465, 0.012192566879093647, -0.028589444234967232, -0.03217174485325813, -0.011375756934285164, -0.013277065008878708, -0.020745709538459778, -0.04995524510741234, 0.0003549103275872767, 0.002590324031189084, 0.008381891995668411, 0.023098265752196312, 0.014859194867312908, 0.004938045516610146, -0.018790902569890022, -0.025425726547837257, -0.017891136929392815, 0.0369969867169857, -0.022920938208699226, 0.03131461143493652, 0.023010101169347763, 0.03078937903046608, 0.031663551926612854, -0.0060638245195150375, 0.004984100814908743, -0.01941666752099991, 0.04929159954190254, -0.012508976273238659, 0.023159533739089966, -0.006401825230568647, -0.03836806118488312, -0.03848227486014366, 0.04659940302371979, 0.051174551248550415, 0.04595367982983589, 0.027737900614738464, 0.02304874174296856, -0.03287994861602783, 0.04086365923285484, -0.0032294997945427895, -0.012840963900089264, -0.007841570302844048, -0.052397530525922775, 0.0092268455773592, -0.014685596339404583, -0.0011311648413538933, -0.026701701804995537, -0.009042956866323948, 0.04752093181014061, 0.015304094180464745, -0.02654368430376053, -0.007848585955798626, 0.011119230650365353, -0.03145419433712959, -0.01838623732328415, -0.0007473532459698617, 0.02980997785925865, 0.04042996093630791, 0.06529989093542099, 0.000852106255479157, 0.002503160620108247, -0.04883299022912979, 0.04660739377140999, -0.07949347794055939, -0.027745520696043968, 0.0277252197265625, -0.005412922706454992, 0.0658339112997055, -0.06376054137945175, 0.008018357679247856, 0.04854099079966545, -0.08092131465673447, -0.000017420485164620914, -0.0240036491304636, -0.01286526583135128, -0.021207012236118317, 0.04956311360001564, 0.013077332638204098, 0.03722889721393585, 0.03353189304471016, 0.002529953373596072, 0.05534571409225464, 0.03624126687645912, 0.0019299341365695, -0.012371744029223919, -0.029551912099123, 0.02730153128504753, 0.031066054478287697, -0.02810990996658802, -0.0002921837440226227, -0.0014122509164735675, 0.028023390099406242, 0.022531185299158096, -0.040669310837984085, -0.015769269317388535, 0.025188319385051727, 0.04809371754527092, 0.02391968108713627, 0.033494982868433, 0.026379724964499474, 0.03635934367775917, 0.013747050426900387, -0.033833201974630356, 0.042597707360982895, 0.0023813608568161726, -0.023704588413238525, 0.016091542318463326, -0.0013341379817575216, -0.01525617204606533, -0.01913297548890114, 0.004892135504633188, -0.02376154623925686, -0.030266039073467255, 0.0057810451835393906, 0.024618318304419518, 0.03177997097373009, -0.08236675709486008, 0.02667735517024994, -0.03280043229460716, -0.0036463711876422167, 0.051735758781433105, 0.042120713740587234, -0.004738065414130688, 0.00602209847420454, -0.009761800989508629, -0.026998654007911682, -0.007061885204166174, 0.02103007212281227, -0.0299819502979517, -0.03861696273088455, -0.0483824796974659, -0.016941802576184273, 0.00844632089138031, 0.025028498843312263, -0.012661037035286427, -0.03652103990316391, 0.03213471919298172, 0.005702413618564606, 0.01742406189441681, -0.01631338521838188, 0.0012482866877689958, -0.01830458827316761, -0.06400395184755325, 0.04913581535220146, -0.016441619023680687, -0.06945507228374481, -0.06611163914203644, 0.010933510959148407, -0.04730946943163872, -0.003284377045929432, 0.043868813663721085, 0.05433812364935875, 0.011069249361753464, -0.013861753046512604, 0.03499450162053108, 0.05387115478515625, -0.03949728235602379, 0.0022110547870397568, -0.01472681388258934, -0.031153591349720955, -0.012184159830212593, -0.011710739694535732, 0.006829116027802229, 0.050741709768772125, 0.03256962448358536, -0.0035882331430912018, 0.040479205548763275, 0.007587526459246874, -0.022045575082302094, 0.036364566534757614, 0.007372790481895208, -0.027192633599042892, 0.03095383755862713, -0.011372251436114311, 0.004264745395630598, 0.031100677326321602, -0.0037388745695352554, -0.026116302236914635, 0.029963362962007523, -0.0042837439104914665, -0.053415052592754364, -0.010618367232382298, 0.01818218268454075, 0.02454405650496483, -0.052586495876312256, -0.0019535485189408064, 0.015858881175518036, -0.007539298385381699, -0.025438589975237846, 0.03500092774629593, 0.01966075971722603, 0.03350874409079552, 0.009383032098412514, 0.036571603268384933, 0.004817102570086718, 0.006171618588268757, 0.07898858934640884, 0.004110902082175016, 0.01895437389612198, 0.01162277814000845, -0.048428770154714584, -0.01512560062110424, -0.024798588827252388, 0.028130175545811653, -0.057940904051065445, 0.05950908362865448, -0.006383947096765041, -0.014040015637874603, -0.011205224320292473, -0.011072046123445034, 0.024160878732800484, 0.04225394129753113, -0.01733914017677307, 0.05353134870529175, -0.049291014671325684, 0.014605425298213959, -0.009462314657866955, -0.028788669034838676, -0.027617083862423897, 0.02101457305252552, 0.043434031307697296, 0.028282146900892258, 0.017628008499741554, 0.010560705326497555, 0.024820178747177124, -0.0027304727118462324, 0.02899032086133957, -0.05278507247567177, 0.02706565149128437, -0.01552689541131258, 0.003505493514239788, -0.001850467873737216, 0.005524076521396637, 0.014545608311891556, -0.0063874972984194756, 0.0309914480894804, 0.037132907658815384, 0.009379526600241661, -0.009778509847819805, 0.003315189154818654, -0.020675646141171455, 0.04795493930578232, -0.056728217750787735, -0.026682617142796516, -0.009168034419417381, 0.010216656140983105, -0.029285157099366188, -0.01439456082880497 ]
<p>I have an explanatory variable that is transformed as suggested in footnote 25 of <a href="http://www.federalreserve.gov/pubs/feds/2013/201353/201353pap.pdf" rel="nofollow">the article</a> as follows (the explanatory variable is continuous and can take negative, zero or positive values) \begin{equation} y=\text{sign}(x)\,\log{(|x|+1)} \end{equation} where $\text{sign}(x)$ takes a value of $1$ if $x&gt;0$, $0$ if $x=0$, and $-1$ if $x&lt;0$. Let's suppose my dependent variable is $y$ (not transformed). Now I need to take the derivative of $y$ with respect to $x$ to find out the marginal effect and elasticity. </p> <p>I did this as follows: \begin{equation} \frac{\partial y}{\partial x}=\text{sign}(x)\,\frac {1}{(|x|+1)}\,\frac{\partial|x|}{\partial x} \end{equation}</p> <p>As far as I understand, $\frac{\partial|x|}{\partial x} =1$ if $x&gt;0$ and $\frac{\partial|x|}{\partial x} =-1$ if $x&lt;0$, and is not defined for $x=0$. My question is how I compute the marginal effect for the observation with the value $x=0$ with this transformation. </p>
36,010
[ -0.002169256331399083, 0.013355771079659462, -0.011710446327924728, -0.008946648798882961, 0.005605577025562525, 0.0032929559238255024, -0.027999628335237503, -0.002343189436942339, 0.025783127173781395, -0.033942028880119324, 0.001483225030824542, 0.013080631382763386, 0.04445972293615341, 0.0018450921634212136, 0.05489077791571617, 0.020798886194825172, 0.013545472174882889, 0.012398889288306236, 0.019468382000923157, -0.0067512886598706245, 0.004217111971229315, 0.006956857163459063, 0.013609752058982849, 0.032087281346321106, 0.019372455775737762, 0.018004361540079117, -0.006635440979152918, -0.05150904133915901, 0.023500481620430946, 0.04400038719177246, 0.005109811667352915, -0.02844088524580002, -0.022246740758419037, 0.02876289188861847, -0.004892266355454922, 0.0266591664403677, -0.03783971071243286, -0.03477264195680618, 0.02858404628932476, 0.03573837876319885, -0.015802616253495216, -0.02597007527947426, 0.019811775535345078, 0.05897143855690956, -0.017077764496207237, -0.022817177698016167, 0.02659553475677967, -0.018150299787521362, 0.04782227426767349, -0.030792269855737686, 0.08478178828954697, -0.013395605608820915, 0.05611609295010567, 0.040337223559617996, -0.025594964623451233, -0.04721611738204956, 0.061658039689064026, 0.058250825852155685, 0.0019251358462497592, -0.06866253912448883, -0.04642502963542938, -0.05702684447169304, -0.027413316071033478, -0.029947558417916298, -0.008650696836411953, -0.02001178078353405, -0.003004712052643299, -0.011077252216637135, 0.07806915044784546, -0.03190499171614647, 0.008428866043686867, 0.029110021889209747, 0.02589535154402256, -0.00873363483697176, 0.03271801397204399, -0.03232894837856293, 0.017202895134687424, 0.010838721878826618, 0.018212132155895233, 0.03517863154411316, -0.031109753996133804, -0.005839040502905846, 0.013257025741040707, 0.055953796952962875, -0.04130210727453232, -0.01072046346962452, 0.09809131920337677, -0.010470260865986347, 0.047598697245121, 0.016989773139357567, 0.00015673160669393837, -0.02557907998561859, 0.010897115804255009, -0.009470918215811253, -0.009868769906461239, 0.0480731800198555, -0.007663508411496878, 0.0048593818210065365, 0.008939213119447231, -0.008344199508428574, -0.008878604508936405, -0.054510779678821564, 0.019394835457205772, 0.01941634528338909, -0.018216410651803017, 0.021270642057061195, -0.006456878501921892, 0.02122422866523266, 0.015857001766562462, -0.06245460361242294, -0.014818163588643074, 0.022018540650606155, -0.004035586025565863, -0.013046937994658947, 0.045093417167663574, -0.04908432811498642, -0.03705949708819389, -0.05493747070431709, 0.018748560920357704, 0.022262131795287132, 0.059710241854190826, -0.04968392848968506, 0.04249125346541405, -0.015227705240249634, -0.06184379383921623, 0.010955827310681343, 0.021245064213871956, 0.0008942369604483247, -0.025118231773376465, 0.03629884496331215, -0.001507957698777318, -0.0491793230175972, 0.033842992037534714, 0.024188416078686714, 0.024494128301739693, -0.009980252012610435, -0.0807809978723526, -0.042696911841630936, 0.023015044629573822, 0.012781060300767422, 0.006509787868708372, -0.05785898119211197, -0.02031177654862404, 0.04409954696893692, 0.031834475696086884, -0.003400749061256647, 0.013616196811199188, 0.029503513127565384, 0.026763824746012688, 0.0019182967953383923, 0.003974778112024069, -0.0008151353104040027, -0.03803671896457672, -0.05179692059755325, -0.016432465985417366, -0.04648725315928459, -0.0038124453276395798, 0.04070192947983742, -0.05403410270810127, -0.05034676566720009, 0.08049246668815613, 0.007256301585584879, -0.004995052702724934, 0.03412221744656563, -0.028439989313483238, -0.042174141854047775, 0.07577496021986008, 0.006567750126123428, 0.01623532921075821, 0.021585842594504356, 0.016041643917560577, -0.005654436536133289, -0.024833405390381813, 0.07780316472053528, 0.054463233798742294, -0.05056770518422127, 0.0009013234521262348, -0.049472399055957794, 0.0015083861071616411, 0.018683111295104027, -0.03464141860604286, -0.007072609383612871, -0.06222452223300934, -0.03032628633081913, 0.028575971722602844, 0.04615725576877594, -0.018906915560364723, 0.014805123209953308, 0.05957493558526039, -0.03813493996858597, -0.04790058732032776, -0.044641949236392975, 0.027689723297953606, 0.027892522513866425, -0.01470150612294674, 0.023752486333251, -0.016076942905783653, 0.022175703197717667, -0.005475954152643681, 0.01276099681854248, 0.018547777086496353, -0.009213939309120178, -0.007854153402149677, -0.017478885129094124, -0.007015577517449856, 0.03024536743760109, 0.06224628537893295, 0.002467961283400655, -0.001438196050003171, -0.047558050602674484, 0.01884133741259575, 0.021009940654039383, -0.01805066503584385, 0.029866470023989677, -0.028951631858944893, -0.014018920250236988, 0.0032196228858083487, -0.04519437253475189, -0.0016662097768858075, 0.031395360827445984, -0.05773725360631943, 0.04085612669587135, 0.10772118717432022, -0.004446950741112232, -0.01110242772847414, -0.002724418183788657, -0.010701007209718227, 0.052269913256168365, -0.02309996448457241, -0.019328532740473747, -0.057130616158246994, -0.029082024469971657, 0.04557352885603905, 0.003111074911430478, 0.001966828713193536, -0.003090339247137308, 0.03430018201470375, -0.02922975830733776, 0.020598264411091805, 0.009652768261730671, 0.01222385186702013, -0.03170166164636612, 0.024195518344640732, 0.01078268513083458, 0.035532526671886444, 0.002608812414109707, 0.018516235053539276, 0.015653811395168304, 0.08382492512464523, 0.02812652476131916, 0.02369452640414238, 0.03616008162498474, -0.005768183618783951, 0.03654045984148979, 0.012936641462147236, 0.02616068348288536, 0.08096496015787125, -0.030773073434829712, 0.009128296747803688, 0.018854841589927673, -0.030904777348041534, -0.00989130325615406, 0.04220203310251236, 0.013989883475005627, 0.03141411393880844, 0.04429091885685921, -0.029106225818395615, 0.0026210853829979897, 0.0009523953776806593, 0.002189397579059005, 0.0204682145267725, -0.0013344561448320746, -0.0629068985581398, -0.005872958805412054, -0.03749775141477585, 0.03144377842545509, 0.039495036005973816, 0.025252744555473328, -0.0556677021086216, -0.01791241019964218, 0.04369485005736351, -0.028187962248921394, 0.01826014369726181, 0.02015068754553795, -0.024037597700953484, 0.0009016441181302071, -0.026142599061131477, -0.006053246557712555, 0.00605463981628418, 0.012647896073758602, -0.02624494582414627, -0.01218766812235117, -0.022289494052529335, -0.06363506615161896, -0.042806558310985565, -0.03736661747097969, -0.00558413565158844, -0.019510731101036072, -0.009447958320379257, 0.061067286878824234, 0.022036120295524597, -0.01174476370215416, 0.00818200409412384, -0.053587790578603745, -0.01854562573134899, -0.014468839392066002, 0.003783811815083027, -0.0015157294692471623, 0.004568945616483688, 0.03590567037463188, 0.0027540510054677725, -0.030419189482927322, -0.0248508770018816, -0.08441946655511856, -0.06132710352540016, 0.05146478861570358, -0.00013222460984252393, 0.0034990159329026937, 0.007662677206099033, -0.045165129005908966, 0.06230748072266579, 0.04260019212961197, -0.0334806889295578, -0.04385041072964668, -0.020818213000893593, -0.014027552679181099, -0.026924828067421913, -0.027620673179626465, 0.019450517371296883, 0.009675039909780025, 0.034318313002586365, 0.0011394846951588988, 0.07101202756166458, -0.011478680185973644, 0.013947824947535992, -0.0005564137827605009, 0.024880431592464447, -0.007488267961889505, -0.020085012540221214, 0.012882362119853497, 0.029034461826086044, 0.015109129250049591, 0.005306375678628683, -0.019885215908288956, 0.022541671991348267, 0.022617554292082787, -0.0451953299343586, 0.007749684154987335, 0.022527555003762245, -0.008277458138763905, -0.028512923046946526, 0.019071273505687714, 0.01334709394723177, -0.002486828248947859, -0.006832427810877562, 0.0179551150649786, 0.01186140812933445, -0.029454056173563004, -0.025345472618937492, 0.02979341335594654, 0.04382690414786339, -0.006626859772950411, -0.036403968930244446, 0.02081819251179695, -0.008149205707013607, 0.04631348326802254, -0.008863747119903564, 0.0004723591555375606, 0.03273004665970802, 0.015253812074661255, -0.014484196901321411, -0.04396356642246246, -0.024161385372281075, 0.02213730290532112, -0.013885839842259884, 0.026565272361040115, 0.02706524357199669, 0.035642653703689575, 0.013756253756582737, 0.02412998303771019, 0.004952637478709221, 0.0009325736318714917, -0.004903141409158707, -0.005649267230182886, -0.09095028042793274, 0.0326555110514164, -0.02151605300605297, 0.004741061944514513, -0.005425354931503534, 0.016928531229496002, 0.055291496217250824, -0.03674779832363129, 0.012479892000555992, -0.01815776340663433, 0.0079078683629632, -0.03275108337402344, -0.03540411591529846, -0.006309862714260817, -0.009788460098206997, -0.0014487223234027624, -0.016825664788484573, 0.012685898691415787, -0.004172986373305321, 0.01947212405502796, 0.047146521508693695, 0.009895270690321922, -0.004533559083938599, -0.0339474081993103, -0.016912098973989487, 0.051803719252347946, 0.06308134645223618, -0.0014768189284950495, -0.004639466758817434, -0.01009160652756691, 0.04721330851316452, -0.04098009690642357, 0.05011211708188057, 0.004994322545826435, -0.012967885471880436, -0.03728416562080383, -0.03715616464614868, -0.012464391998946667, -0.0030252765864133835, 0.018274014815688133, -0.00011387820268282667, 0.030609849840402603, 0.0635390654206276, 0.02302057482302189, -0.029878929257392883, 0.03423760086297989, 0.07340624928474426, 0.011882562190294266, -0.022985870018601418, -0.03752302750945091, 0.023030010983347893, -0.02230810932815075, 0.019442114979028702, 0.029814889654517174, -0.005326096434146166, 0.007894108071923256, -0.01745983585715294, 0.0388454832136631, 0.04059017077088356, 0.026365870609879494, -0.012900942005217075, 0.04411633685231209, 0.04895767569541931, 0.0003747969458345324, -0.0703495442867279, 0.05087215080857277, 0.055366016924381256, 0.025564124807715416, -0.006177064497023821, 0.00291365385055542, -0.09743831306695938, 0.015664661303162575, 0.025475239381194115, 0.03595495596528053, 0.004402633290737867, -0.002333648968487978, -0.04277922585606575, -0.037527959793806076, 0.031209144741296768, -0.024530671536922455, 0.014781719073653221, -0.021120363846421242, 0.027979688718914986, 0.02225436270236969, -0.03609894961118698, -0.05605720356106758, 0.038876213133335114, -0.014266633428633213, 0.01562458835542202, 0.0070663332007825375, -0.006657659076154232, -0.026172928512096405, 0.010057431645691395, -0.030025191605091095, 0.04167354106903076, -0.024092473089694977, -0.01027795672416687, 0.005129699595272541, 0.023985538631677628, -0.01826063171029091, -0.06515824049711227, 0.035873331129550934, 0.0036614215932786465, 0.004076915793120861, 0.0377279631793499, 0.05299091339111328, -0.05922834947705269, 0.05688793212175369, 0.00030673437868244946, -0.028146754950284958, -0.011406977660953999, -0.02654426544904709, 0.059970539063215256, 0.011597011238336563, -0.033668648451566696, 0.042779870331287384, 0.07431308180093765, -0.01016736775636673, -0.003605656325817108, -0.006283617578446865, 0.008764113299548626, -0.023933103308081627, 0.0004119977238588035, -0.01935228519141674, 0.03192146494984627, -0.002754412591457367, 0.017178500071167946, 0.007874872535467148, 0.02800866588950157, -0.018844034522771835, -0.004400778561830521, 0.010526156052947044, 0.0012845584424212575, -0.011700072325766087, -0.014638064429163933, -0.008073484525084496, -0.0037352871149778366, 0.010121654719114304, -0.0281155277043581, 0.003593951463699341, -0.00899197906255722, -0.008735745213925838, 0.007803804241120815, -0.06039224937558174, 0.008123530074954033, 0.0002904467692133039, -0.03279750794172287, 0.007882957346737385, -0.05702050402760506, 0.030790386721491814, -0.0025442526675760746, 0.04092513024806976, 0.005348833277821541, -0.04507823660969734, -0.004303271416574717, 0.02661590836942196, 0.031211107969284058, 0.02999415062367916, -0.06345096230506897, -0.009022693149745464, 0.008700131438672543, 0.009916914626955986, -0.06679727137088776, -0.04868096858263016, -0.0028734279330819845, -0.0019411080284044147, -0.002716445829719305, -0.01491111982613802, 0.029303427785634995, 0.00016773538663983345, -0.019477088004350662, -0.011897124350070953, 0.03860222548246384, -0.04255082458257675, -0.0194124486297369, -0.004223179537802935, 0.028522998094558716, 0.057558052241802216, -0.0317072793841362, -0.0070965285412967205, 0.028788747265934944, -0.02204870991408825, -0.053723931312561035, 0.029101978987455368, 0.046017661690711975, -0.026284081861376762, -0.017659282311797142, -0.018271056935191154, -0.01029270514845848, 0.0350467711687088, -0.024215176701545715, -0.02397622913122177, -0.025029070675373077, -0.004029841162264347, 0.0009085952769964933, -0.010295736603438854, 0.019487541168928146, -0.00003767495945794508, 0.0016960868379101157, 0.015632931143045425, 0.005167321767657995, -0.06693892925977707, -0.010580897331237793, 0.03227804973721504, -0.0007936512120068073, 0.0024749368894845247, 0.04043438285589218, 0.11525711417198181, -0.004905203357338905, -0.027371510863304138, 0.03708057478070259, -0.011931032873690128, 0.05996313318610191, 0.0006682935054413974, -0.0007988109719008207, -0.00929056666791439, -0.027497423812747, -0.055991772562265396, -0.011087413877248764, -0.042523093521595, -0.0031358627602458, 0.07052943855524063, -0.0039542075246572495, 0.014960743486881256, 0.03541069105267525, -0.034135472029447556, 0.014183410443365574, 0.0036991743836551905, 0.0006772327469661832, -0.012993068434298038, -0.016279833391308784, 0.05155770480632782, -0.0345948301255703, -0.021385889500379562, 0.020449528470635414, 0.019771631807088852, -0.02159746363759041, 0.004856288433074951, 0.017871439456939697, -0.0009682102827355266, 0.038826096802949905, -0.04112406447529793, -0.00446566566824913, 0.02742140367627144, -0.0038172451313585043, 0.022900713607668877, -0.026112578809261322, -0.03481774404644966, 0.07004335522651672, 0.014947475865483284, 0.039152469485998154, -0.0630636140704155, -0.0439758375287056, -0.05261620506644249, 0.02842027321457863, 0.022230805829167366, -0.015262298285961151, 0.057044729590415955, 0.015782663598656654, 0.030952293425798416, -0.01473164465278387, 0.058522630482912064, -0.03676580637693405, -0.05396877974271774, -0.026706112548708916, -0.0191048476845026, -0.016653968021273613, 0.03372826427221298, 0.0038457794580608606, -0.032126642763614655, 0.04146399348974228, -0.050672855228185654, 0.025567276403307915, 0.030899563804268837, 0.002695264760404825, 0.00009807459719013423, 0.0961175188422203, -0.012049536220729351, 0.022988686338067055, -0.03464696183800697, -0.014094357378780842, 0.1043669804930687, 0.0552813857793808, 0.03559793531894684, -0.07398887723684311, 0.025646202266216278, -0.018251579254865646, 0.0215518306940794, -0.03093155473470688, -0.009663291275501251, -0.010914959944784641, -0.016119323670864105, 0.004552672151476145, 0.06702776253223419, -0.004510095808655024, 0.010215012356638908, 0.02148568071424961, -0.037583332508802414, -0.045958586037158966, -0.0009471375960856676, -0.0294805895537138, -0.023575186729431152, -0.022781729698181152, -0.053750522434711456, 0.0209734458476305, -0.018630731850862503, -0.03603256866335869, -0.03505134955048561, -0.009380966424942017, 0.006557614542543888, -0.0335494764149189, -0.009877118282020092, 0.008868877775967121, 0.01052546314895153, 0.006742866709828377, -0.033457379788160324, -0.017280882224440575, 0.03621314838528633, 0.004828605800867081, 0.03330136463046074, 0.02874259278178215, -0.01649840548634529, 0.013479821383953094, 0.019358200952410698, -0.03158925846219063, -0.0359109528362751, -0.002199605805799365, -0.01417584903538227, 0.055805787444114685, 0.034557513892650604, 0.013316572643816471, -0.030577722936868668, 0.0008664168417453766, -0.032159704715013504, -0.03746544569730759, -0.024129437282681465, 0.03972509503364563, 0.039260782301425934, -0.009808339178562164, -0.006987025961279869, 0.026309369131922722, -0.004725954029709101, -0.010736897587776184, 0.024333735927939415, 0.022945353761315346, -0.023574937134981155, 0.000563285721000284, -0.027889670804142952, 0.043381232768297195, -0.03750234097242355, -0.0293398629873991, -0.0052052708342671394, -0.026036063209176064, -0.022153964266180992, -0.011955568566918373, 0.01729707233607769, -0.017889996990561485, 0.03136682137846947, -0.013500859029591084, 0.030127275735139847, -0.041415985673666, -0.043768253177404404, 0.02833125926554203, -0.006254239473491907, -0.017395084723830223, -0.04628344997763634, -0.007901765406131744, -0.008211289532482624, 0.03856275975704193, -0.005602499470114708, -0.029823917895555496, 0.032923661172389984, 0.031615760177373886, 0.005186642054468393, -0.022060612216591835, -0.04028778895735741, -0.00140277948230505, 0.005226804409176111, -0.005985342897474766, 0.007860925979912281, 0.03354817256331444, -0.014666796661913395, 0.023035746067762375, -0.018492374569177628, 0.045855723321437836, -0.053152963519096375, 0.014917394146323204, 0.0189537163823843, -0.02542142942547798, 0.0293241199105978, 0.01805895008146763, 0.030535222962498665, -0.03355248644948006, -0.038671739399433136, 0.0006760382675565779, -0.023902490735054016, -0.000015256948245223612, -0.013178054243326187, -0.016468193382024765, 0.023011181503534317, -0.01157853938639164, 0.02659258432686329, -0.015017470344901085, 0.00043377155088819563, -0.047188904136419296, -0.010721948929131031, 0.025801613926887512, -0.00510820746421814, 0.013590809889137745, 0.010913433507084846, 0.0021679888013750315, -0.008750666864216328, 0.03300334885716438, 0.03580701723694801, 0.044148724526166916, -0.01773975044488907, 0.03418756648898125, 0.0035700895823538303, 0.031106838956475258, -0.03683604300022125, -0.04474513232707977, 0.027934765443205833, -0.046581562608480453, -0.02198285050690174, 0.026625823229551315, 0.028633544221520424, 0.04533298313617706, -0.023918207734823227, 0.008733134716749191, -0.0472646988928318, 0.03596388176083565, -0.010773160494863987, 0.024754906073212624, -0.0007717724074609578, -0.014032300561666489, -0.014301711693406105, -0.00966781098395586, -0.006466418970376253, 0.003879870055243373, 0.0028676516376435757, 0.028388088569045067, 0.025617802515625954, -0.004930638242512941, -0.024904564023017883, 0.024508293718099594, 0.018412668257951736, 0.0012635645689442754, -0.0014085310976952314, 0.009320112876594067, 0.03774542734026909, 0.05668244510889053, -0.019824566319584846, 0.02193099819123745, -0.009905834682285786, 0.02033170685172081, -0.05529676377773285, -0.046561017632484436, 0.016297902911901474, 0.02400263398885727, 0.033113639801740646, -0.05559297278523445, 0.01776481419801712, 0.011413333006203175, 0.0057845707051455975, 0.009808449074625969, 0.008582920767366886, -0.010436320677399635, -0.008203527890145779, -0.01699296571314335, -0.005812094081193209, 0.06784004718065262, 0.054692186415195465, 0.05554474517703056, 0.027147265151143074, 0.028418194502592087, -0.021723249927163124, -0.04434192553162575, 0.0014179752906784415, 0.017284143716096878, 0.029500355944037437, -0.06957630813121796, 0.04466675966978073, -0.04287073761224747, -0.024985410273075104, 0.052477434277534485, -0.0005690769758075476, 0.03536731377243996, 0.006588171701878309, 0.02545095793902874, 0.005459931213408709, 0.038699980825185776, 0.05080277845263481, 0.016080614179372787, 0.013786588795483112, 0.011096117086708546, 0.018399883061647415, -0.0021382123231887817, -0.036876387894153595, -0.0026466145645827055, -0.002896158490329981, -0.03659149259328842, -0.025701230391860008, 0.005994153209030628, -0.011226571165025234, -0.015827840194106102, -0.031151367351412773, -0.014535926282405853, -0.007914504036307335, -0.02816220186650753, 0.006094316486269236, -0.038122743368148804, -0.0004968143766745925, 0.0404188297688961, 0.016566675156354904, -0.04426081106066704, 0.003097791224718094, -0.022890273481607437, -0.05581313744187355, 0.007298992481082678, -0.026688633486628532, -0.027664102613925934, -0.06890975683927536, 0.015034222975373268, -0.009603060781955719, -0.010017355903983116, -0.02835853025317192, 0.026702972128987312, -0.06528795510530472, 0.016593988984823227, -0.033925969153642654, -0.0054454198107123375, 0.011283363215625286, -0.018802983686327934, 0.007086349651217461, -0.10724185407161713, 0.0445483960211277, 0.04388795793056488, -0.04343559220433235, 0.004609669093042612, -0.013376588933169842, -0.046398863196372986, -0.01197988260537386, 0.05652100220322609, 0.005062642507255077, -0.020527463406324387, 0.012794693931937218, 0.007199847139418125, -0.0262516550719738, -0.03215561434626579, 0.022458596155047417, 0.0038989954628050327, 0.005819916725158691, -0.017017850652337074, 0.0290832482278347, -0.0030214879661798477, 0.03272218629717827, -0.010673368349671364, 0.011944107711315155, -0.02775588259100914, -0.04119293391704559, -0.01886712945997715, 0.008484813384711742, -0.014153367839753628, -0.013613653369247913, 0.052489474415779114, 0.018378831446170807, 0.008025184273719788, 0.0019808518700301647, 0.02147321030497551, -0.06484714150428772, 0.00809754803776741, -0.07064442336559296, 0.009015635587275028, 0.006848490796983242, 0.011078919284045696, 0.033805686980485916, -0.037229493260383606, 0.00554452370852232, 0.01785822957754135, -0.019012369215488434, 0.010473686270415783, 0.011478192172944546, 0.03973769024014473, 0.026165369898080826, 0.009895183145999908, -0.0028478484600782394, -0.00030176257132552564, 0.010444971732795238, 0.012893971055746078, 0.011004997417330742, 0.023406991735100746, -0.006641363725066185, -0.026676269248127937, 0.015960313379764557, -0.030586492270231247, 0.024150891229510307, 0.010630703531205654, 0.009454524144530296, -0.0030001334380358458, -0.012916133739054203, 0.02614334411919117, 0.025014983490109444, -0.04597528278827667, -0.026997173205018044, 0.005983119364827871, 0.03186073154211044, 0.012853841297328472, 0.042607102543115616, -0.012705503031611443, 0.0045810905285179615, -0.01774654909968376, 0.03451057896018028, 0.011908511631190777, 0.02453475072979927, -0.030040983110666275, 0.008357190527021885, 0.0021658616606146097, -0.049225710332393646, -0.027067234739661217, -0.0467459000647068, 0.003128747222945094, -0.0016862725606188178, -0.03168236464262009, 0.05516594648361206, -0.0418514758348465, -0.0651368498802185, -0.019596323370933533, 0.011675124987959862, 0.03024047613143921, 0.04385857284069061, -0.012747762724757195, -0.01046714372932911, -0.0197313092648983, 0.0745243951678276, -0.061918407678604126, -0.024732697755098343, -0.005631993990391493, -0.008430736139416695, -0.005800996907055378, 0.009092415682971478 ]
<p>I'm trying to understand how I might best model a variable where over time I've obtained increasingly detailed predictors. For example, consider modeling recovery rates on defaulted loans. Suppose we have a dataset with 20 years of data, and in the first 15 of those years we only know whether the loan was collateralized or not, but nothing about the characteristics of that collateral. For the last five years, however, we can break the collateral into a range of categories which are expected to be a good predictor of the recovery rate.</p> <p>Given this setup I want to fit a model to the data, determine measures such as the statistical significance of the predictors, and then forecast with the model.</p> <p>What missing data framework does this fit into? Are there any special considerations related to the fact that the more detailed explanatory variables only become available after a given point in time, as opposed to being scattered throughout the historical sample? </p>
73,601
[ -0.018336627632379532, -0.0026371567510068417, 0.0225993599742651, 0.01593685895204544, 0.050612736493349075, -0.009697942063212395, -0.011224843561649323, 0.0032123988494277, 0.040707722306251526, -0.02035132236778736, 0.013592359609901905, 0.006078653037548065, 0.0352846160531044, -0.00592480693012476, 0.0022166757844388485, 0.007495511323213577, -0.02309165708720684, -0.013163032941520214, 0.0029152424540370703, 0.011494919657707214, -0.005970858968794346, 0.016869839280843735, -0.005605297163128853, -0.019296104088425636, -0.004527254495769739, 0.03208845481276512, 0.011204349808394909, -0.015042833983898163, 0.03676581755280495, 0.014232457615435123, 0.0015627547400072217, -0.022547146305441856, 0.01367642730474472, 0.04446963593363762, 0.012929611839354038, -0.006980969570577145, -0.016606923192739487, -0.034856121987104416, 0.021768644452095032, 0.016415193676948547, -0.03243980556726456, -0.02191559597849846, 0.02189362235367298, 0.029206402599811554, -0.002607773756608367, 0.016293076798319817, -0.03430670499801636, -0.01940983347594738, 0.030915969982743263, -0.0010517605114728212, 0.08023443818092346, -0.01915833167731762, 0.03313591331243515, 0.038711510598659515, -0.019683338701725006, -0.016916008666157722, 0.0633389800786972, 0.07475366443395615, 0.003301187651231885, -0.07562188059091568, -0.04163709655404091, 0.0007107778801582754, 0.00753029016777873, -0.029826635494828224, -0.02094358019530773, 0.036667317152023315, -0.01721530221402645, -0.014222170226275921, 0.04635905474424362, -0.03687276691198349, 0.0004108893917873502, -0.001904047909192741, 0.027357017621397972, 0.02411157637834549, 0.009283366613090038, -0.023242417722940445, -0.002524878131225705, 0.03224819898605347, 0.030972886830568314, 0.012620211578905582, 0.004870763514190912, 0.007093640509992838, 0.008442698046565056, 0.027392679825425148, -0.019717847928404808, 0.01168617233633995, 0.09147939085960388, -0.05602668225765228, 0.01700083166360855, 0.05127020180225372, -0.014714939519762993, -0.001030581770464778, 0.02227623388171196, -0.007262783590704203, -0.06485695391893387, -0.00916536245495081, -0.010683160275220871, 0.023814836516976357, 0.029469510540366173, 0.02027367241680622, 0.003083376446738839, -0.043168261647224426, -0.02927638590335846, 0.039978861808776855, -0.026585089042782784, 0.017462635412812233, -0.0030709689017385244, -0.0035871011205017567, -0.0411648154258728, -0.031839508563280106, -0.01252887025475502, 0.047464776784181595, 0.007557653356343508, -0.009958193637430668, 0.008114499039947987, 0.012192030437290668, -0.016557887196540833, -0.05027351900935173, 0.009907977655529976, 0.07561030238866806, 0.034372176975011826, -0.04010092094540596, 0.019664272665977478, -0.001241415971890092, -0.042143989354372025, 0.002266411669552326, 0.0309110339730978, -0.025802379474043846, -0.01890047825872898, 0.03688936308026314, -0.012779409065842628, -0.03609355166554451, 0.05727815628051758, 0.003848733613267541, 0.05365946516394615, -0.0022804848849773407, -0.08878785371780396, -0.04395993798971176, -0.004727015271782875, -0.022002123296260834, 0.01032809168100357, -0.04363355040550232, 0.009931704960763454, 0.0044493405148386955, 0.04027150198817253, 0.012107038870453835, 0.00017975298396777362, 0.023463496938347816, 0.0344683974981308, 0.01767689362168312, -0.02496214769780636, -0.028503818437457085, -0.01837441697716713, 0.014491390436887741, -0.0597195029258728, -0.06655865162611008, 0.027364414185285568, 0.05865095928311348, 0.020757853984832764, -0.005425625015050173, 0.059632208198308945, 0.0037988987751305103, -0.05435044690966606, -0.006628482136875391, -0.015746748074889183, -0.012818929739296436, 0.048767611384391785, -0.004723592195659876, 0.042986731976270676, 0.0351749062538147, 0.03520883619785309, -0.004897342994809151, 0.027857640758156776, 0.057022396475076675, 0.0318281315267086, 0.022770149633288383, 0.012865643948316574, -0.0023864838294684887, 0.003532510483637452, 0.018900809809565544, -0.017110660672187805, -0.05020701885223389, -0.030279653146862984, -0.010897696949541569, 0.016198579221963882, 0.014266404323279858, 0.001559267402626574, -0.03937428072094917, 0.008757810108363628, -0.06964385509490967, -0.04168881103396416, -0.054995711892843246, 0.004886514972895384, -0.02131929062306881, -0.015049015171825886, 0.032989997416734695, -0.017729483544826508, 0.04369429498910904, 0.03089463710784912, 0.014223034493625164, -0.019406380131840706, -0.044072870165109634, 0.01711408607661724, -0.05362885072827339, 0.016780126839876175, -0.003807987319305539, 0.05575604736804962, 0.02417723834514618, 0.07640664279460907, -0.06908416748046875, -0.06241098791360855, -0.020144175738096237, -0.031048037111759186, 0.016948021948337555, -0.0444452203810215, -0.02471257746219635, -0.019100038334727287, -0.044881854206323624, 0.0050209444016218185, 0.019479457288980484, -0.020495258271694183, 0.037877924740314484, 0.0391496978700161, 0.007131172344088554, 0.006792756263166666, 0.01597459241747856, 0.023800984025001526, 0.03549833223223686, -0.06295663118362427, -0.026629194617271423, -0.06414304673671722, -0.020563563331961632, 0.03720005974173546, 0.03865122050046921, -0.0424322783946991, 0.029499327763915062, 0.04924793168902397, 0.03167548030614853, 0.01785890758037567, 0.028945930302143097, -0.02830907329916954, 0.0054157632403075695, 0.014725511893630028, 0.009200425818562508, 0.01778241991996765, 0.0012732383329421282, 0.02468348853290081, -0.011652538552880287, 0.00389729137532413, -0.011115477420389652, 0.04216631501913071, 0.05723651871085167, 0.018063044175505638, -0.00007649698090972379, -0.03176724538207054, -0.05178701877593994, 0.07114536315202713, -0.007945536635816097, -0.0030086475890129805, 0.014257805421948433, 0.022320933640003204, 0.0009153754217550159, -0.0002758619375526905, -0.013061020523309708, 0.04310791939496994, 0.03679845482110977, -0.036314308643341064, 0.028043320402503014, 0.011692619882524014, -0.018352210521697998, 0.01820191740989685, -0.015990765765309334, -0.030891770496964455, -0.0266557689756155, 0.009875490330159664, 0.05063985288143158, -0.00044484075624495745, 0.044979702681303024, -0.007926545105874538, -0.03862398862838745, 0.010542777366936207, -0.011242255568504333, 0.036369919776916504, 0.02188924327492714, -0.03834350407123566, -0.0190969780087471, 0.021676646545529366, -0.009260648861527443, 0.04265014827251434, -0.01237903255969286, -0.017248112708330154, -0.005634837318211794, -0.015995915979146957, -0.023975884541869164, -0.033727824687957764, -0.010841943323612213, 0.009556624107062817, -0.03450256958603859, -0.03823806345462799, 0.03112754598259926, -0.0074836332350969315, -0.022968534380197525, -0.010504262521862984, -0.05991335213184357, -0.005974814761430025, -0.012383448891341686, -0.02022324502468109, 0.007133098319172859, -0.0017788680270314217, 0.027375349774956703, 0.016396325081586838, -0.014011001214385033, 0.013521398417651653, -0.07985027134418488, -0.0809672400355339, 0.012969709932804108, -0.019355949014425278, 0.03657344728708267, -0.0027241758070886135, 0.029967602342367172, 0.10818157345056534, 0.01107522938400507, -0.008108239620923996, -0.03652086853981018, -0.028838984668254852, -0.0011080119293183088, 0.010364359244704247, 0.018761195242404938, 0.015957193449139595, 0.0167070459574461, -0.004502102266997099, -0.008787344209849834, 0.03359378129243851, 0.039876919239759445, 0.007645093835890293, 0.016691602766513824, 0.02942703664302826, 0.014025135897099972, 0.029203440994024277, -0.009790869429707527, 0.025197668001055717, -0.03270432725548744, 0.0017609767382964492, -0.0314917154610157, 0.024431822821497917, 0.03233659639954567, -0.06587644666433334, -0.022300593554973602, -0.028247185051441193, -0.006822977680712938, -0.0038048014976084232, 0.012961178086698055, -0.0004715290560852736, -0.045056942850351334, -0.03532028570771217, 0.018183359876275063, 0.0392056480050087, 0.0033721160143613815, 0.001097233616746962, 0.057306285947561264, 0.020001085475087166, -0.00009017380943987519, 0.02042621746659279, -0.026092106476426125, -0.019673997536301613, 0.040465131402015686, -0.012341623194515705, 0.019833169877529144, 0.03650622069835663, 0.006931991316378117, -0.0033647024538367987, -0.019338546320796013, -0.020265882834792137, 0.014212538488209248, -0.0756249949336052, 0.00863770954310894, -0.005288110580295324, 0.06596440821886063, 0.028896421194076538, 0.025430267676711082, -0.004995874594897032, 0.005455192178487778, 0.0009781555272638798, 0.03421270102262497, -0.08071040362119675, 0.02676370181143284, -0.025661015883088112, 0.037945706397295, 0.0005904783611185849, 0.02103145606815815, 0.08110411465167999, -0.021840354427695274, -0.02948007360100746, -0.007960960268974304, 0.02219851128757, -0.05499944090843201, -0.018232455477118492, -0.02695396915078163, -0.01165419165045023, -0.026012331247329712, -0.04187330603599548, 0.03891848027706146, 0.010675030760467052, 0.04315268248319626, 0.03138771653175354, 0.04156484827399254, -0.011472167447209358, -0.03723527863621712, -0.00020774683798663318, 0.007555545307695866, 0.059912629425525665, 0.029713507741689682, 0.04288739711046219, -0.06632781773805618, 0.026571888476610184, 0.015014105476439, 0.03707311302423477, 0.00103267771191895, 0.03514542430639267, 0.004730706103146076, -0.037954654544591904, -0.002472482854500413, 0.004220945760607719, 0.006146521307528019, 0.02757560834288597, -0.01098255068063736, 0.03249943256378174, 0.029028769582509995, -0.03382642939686775, 0.01952969841659069, 0.0556502565741539, 0.022863784804940224, 0.008726120926439762, -0.04380963742733002, 0.011610154062509537, -0.021509334444999695, 0.008199109695851803, 0.021177969872951508, 0.0047639538533985615, 0.006365188863128424, -0.008945439010858536, 0.01105530932545662, -0.03512310981750488, -0.0069962008856236935, -0.02919701486825943, 0.037987153977155685, 0.05017513781785965, 0.004427589010447264, -0.01222235057502985, 0.03864730894565582, 0.030284035950899124, 0.06945674121379852, 0.06160517781972885, 0.030770838260650635, -0.10284288972616196, -0.014910784550011158, 0.04036380723118782, 0.014104504138231277, -0.015880730003118515, -0.045854602009058, -0.04122297465801239, -0.03248526528477669, 0.046781960874795914, 0.00018232365255244076, 0.003696491476148367, -0.007166463416069746, 0.0054352376610040665, -0.020180264487862587, -0.05716332420706749, -0.038326919078826904, 0.005678476300090551, -0.02461458370089531, 0.05659407749772072, -0.02306845411658287, -0.03104246035218239, -0.06570886820554733, 0.018758133053779602, 0.001787532470189035, 0.04826865345239639, 0.04152616858482361, -0.018792202696204185, -0.0022987746633589268, -0.004949338734149933, 0.0048960791900753975, -0.0831596627831459, 0.011196251958608627, -0.007047169376164675, -0.021424492821097374, 0.027629999443888664, 0.002765827579423785, -0.03805191442370415, 0.01699594408273697, 0.004555931314826012, -0.032000359147787094, -0.005293147172778845, -0.02120361477136612, 0.03548719733953476, 0.000564589339774102, 0.02009282447397709, 0.06684612482786179, 0.0491192527115345, 0.04619910940527916, 0.02923682890832424, -0.040340766310691833, -0.002704571234062314, 0.0002983243903145194, 0.001007342361845076, -0.06214629113674164, -0.035148706287145615, -0.017304643988609314, 0.032081495970487595, 0.0013956654584035277, 0.03803170844912529, -0.005461927503347397, -0.013962258584797382, 0.02816600166261196, 0.02941926009953022, -0.0036007093731313944, -0.026791121810674667, 0.005734358448535204, 0.00605432502925396, -0.0052081807516515255, 0.007406868971884251, -0.0022864893544465303, -0.0045572929084300995, 0.01707869954407215, 0.009482310153543949, -0.03292539715766907, -0.012821489945054054, -0.03215332329273224, -0.02033323608338833, 0.050004225224256516, 0.009605184197425842, 0.024042028933763504, -0.006710511166602373, 0.023596815764904022, -0.002352704992517829, -0.04031439870595932, 0.03038814291357994, 0.0026566688902676105, 0.01080972608178854, 0.03237716853618622, -0.03567022457718849, 0.026489444077014923, -0.0302206352353096, -0.02071409486234188, -0.06843461096286774, -0.059862375259399414, 0.02867901884019375, 0.038777582347393036, -0.05941106006503105, -0.0231978427618742, 0.050868209451436996, -0.03467724844813347, -0.01934715174138546, -0.019877655431628227, 0.052477460354566574, -0.010569358244538307, -0.0388786680996418, 0.0020687372889369726, 0.02358979359269142, 0.06418580561876297, -0.03677493333816528, 0.0011376732727512717, 0.01111077144742012, -0.026106981560587883, 0.0019077996257692575, 0.005823614541441202, -0.024689292535185814, -0.040611959993839264, 0.0054609025828540325, -0.05496177077293396, 0.0163054708391428, 0.035947974771261215, -0.026252176612615585, -0.0006824492011219263, -0.00021278721396811306, -0.03917885571718216, 0.05758620426058769, -0.01613863930106163, -0.006105754990130663, -0.00797590333968401, -0.0016185480635613203, 0.004807549994438887, -0.007121392525732517, 0.01633719727396965, -0.016825223341584206, 0.01766383834183216, 0.027264297008514404, -0.00137798220384866, 0.024555567651987076, 0.02473139576613903, -0.01803559809923172, -0.0017577913822606206, 0.007630363572388887, -0.03650699183344841, 0.06929564476013184, 0.04045586287975311, 0.0053605856373906136, -0.0004537177737802267, 0.022132253274321556, -0.05691533908247948, -0.034853674471378326, -0.04268214479088783, -0.028436480090022087, 0.07035829871892929, -0.0314512737095356, 0.017203066498041153, 0.010655968450009823, -0.026526113972067833, -0.012321075424551964, -0.05382312461733818, -0.02108415588736534, 0.025121565908193588, -0.004232077393680811, 0.04802751541137695, -0.018070431426167488, 0.01605003885924816, 0.017210977151989937, -0.006279050838202238, -0.0011690874816849828, 0.05676548555493355, 0.014228031039237976, -0.002903760876506567, 0.03306303173303604, -0.035592835396528244, -0.035742826759815216, 0.017233386635780334, -0.044706910848617554, 0.0019059787737205625, 0.0023328063543885946, -0.009461289271712303, 0.033843182027339935, 0.062113482505083084, 0.00948145892471075, -0.04446278512477875, -0.028045518323779106, -0.03232951834797859, 0.003823495702818036, 0.042543940246105194, -0.002909321803599596, 0.06026173010468483, 0.02344970591366291, 0.0439775250852108, -0.018412260338664055, 0.021812867373228073, -0.009245290420949459, -0.0776316300034523, -0.024616239592432976, -0.017807764932513237, -0.015554457902908325, -0.0035882210358977318, 0.005822136066854, -0.02343907579779625, 0.0111727025359869, -0.026379987597465515, 0.014100925996899605, -0.011512094177305698, 0.03173724561929703, -0.008699306286871433, 0.04412313550710678, -0.0013421186013147235, -0.01209257822483778, 0.00030502822482958436, 0.004229222424328327, 0.1200849786400795, 0.09167066216468811, 0.03618883341550827, -0.04423649236559868, 0.021342482417821884, -0.0018464947352185845, 0.007587858941406012, -0.007717453874647617, 0.00550104258581996, -0.009583785198628902, -0.008091366849839687, 0.048414912074804306, 0.030457966029644012, -0.023672867566347122, 0.022199688479304314, 0.049209415912628174, -0.05805393308401108, -0.0017174413660541177, 0.01193604338914156, 0.007191052660346031, 0.024693474173545837, 0.0142093850299716, -0.03468108922243118, 0.010003217495977879, 0.016873860731720924, -0.049459394067525864, -0.012295161373913288, -0.001792429480701685, 0.0008843414252623916, -0.03931209072470665, 0.017046991735696793, 0.02581893466413021, 0.022678621113300323, 0.029508549720048904, -0.009959782473742962, -0.006170242093503475, 0.014904317446053028, -0.0018272873712703586, 0.008107740432024002, 0.02757088653743267, -0.008387764915823936, -0.015483924187719822, -0.00333369430154562, -0.0038444462697952986, -0.05212736874818802, -0.04069157689809799, -0.057210344821214676, 0.02698114700615406, -0.006297160871326923, -0.004708969034254551, -0.015872066840529442, -0.008086491376161575, 0.026914328336715698, -0.009404524229466915, -0.06308885663747787, 0.060421280562877655, 0.03758964315056801, -0.013457887805998325, -0.030891569331288338, 0.0039768829010427, -0.005106973461806774, -0.003070087404921651, 0.02485465817153454, 0.04000698775053024, -0.019566243514418602, -0.005402938462793827, -0.04099811986088753, 0.04644852876663208, -0.008488072082400322, -0.0008090007468126714, 0.03086605854332447, -0.011364038102328777, -0.024808619171380997, 0.008041350170969963, 0.022224312648177147, -0.0016944812377914786, -0.004689743276685476, -0.038809940218925476, -0.0037127493415027857, -0.05546368658542633, -0.024330394342541695, 0.013548857532441616, -0.00637452257797122, 0.018754543736577034, -0.05523185804486275, 0.03373771533370018, -0.012732166796922684, 0.04607689753174782, 0.030402759090065956, 0.013574794866144657, 0.023655423894524574, 0.04999201372265816, 0.03637522831559181, -0.05405372753739357, -0.0003259442455600947, -0.024837512522935867, -0.031961191445589066, 0.003093906445428729, -0.04167480766773224, 0.07631287723779678, 0.014535223133862019, 0.024068770930171013, 0.0052064694464206696, 0.046810999512672424, 0.005099690519273281, 0.023950893431901932, 0.04303288459777832, -0.057051368057727814, 0.006961336359381676, -0.015594856813549995, 0.03977764770388603, -0.0021391762420535088, -0.018194530159235, -0.001491539878770709, -0.04951822757720947, 0.01825576275587082, 0.001968163065612316, -0.03405967354774475, 0.03448605537414551, 0.025489963591098785, 0.03786950930953026, -0.03676161542534828, -0.028271883726119995, -0.07330191135406494, 0.0007760871667414904, -0.009418701753020287, -0.03236861526966095, 0.018679708242416382, 0.008916052058339119, -0.039471711963415146, 0.0033237996976822615, 0.013845105655491352, -0.007225131615996361, -0.005749660078436136, -0.01710726134479046, -0.032122161239385605, -0.016395872458815575, 0.03802299499511719, -0.03336936980485916, 0.002619748702272773, 0.015781087800860405, -0.05172686651349068, -0.01929638162255287, 0.023474136367440224, 0.02018626220524311, 0.03884095698595047, -0.004766583908349276, 0.007790124975144863, -0.02645704336464405, 0.013383348472416401, -0.020689968019723892, -0.01566784828901291, -0.03281278908252716, 0.04703942686319351, 0.005145673640072346, -0.014083490706980228, 0.01485337782651186, 0.022569242864847183, 0.018788158893585205, -0.004602054599672556, 0.04260113090276718, 0.03688356652855873, -0.033398691564798355, 0.04227354750037193, 0.0038789729587733746, 0.008940727449953556, -0.01619623228907585, 0.03842907026410103, 0.03127281740307808, 0.039020001888275146, -0.017758110538125038, 0.03720315918326378, -0.004351973533630371, 0.047930944710969925, -0.09688174724578857, -0.04232997074723244, 0.013180186972022057, 0.022423313930630684, 0.03833724558353424, -0.06137746945023537, -0.004705964121967554, 0.003977962303906679, -0.04391447454690933, 0.019885491579771042, -0.008211549371480942, 0.01531276572495699, -0.011285064741969109, -0.012995979748666286, -0.027723604813218117, 0.02257654070854187, 0.0497509241104126, 0.03208981454372406, 0.006250481586903334, 0.018358264118433, 0.00918034091591835, -0.03787653148174286, -0.0031458449084311724, -0.0024092854000627995, -0.01173851266503334, -0.06456838548183441, 0.02532106451690197, -0.012553166598081589, -0.026267601177096367, 0.03424328938126564, -0.037136148661375046, 0.049001261591911316, 0.02765784040093422, 0.01154336892068386, 0.009299018420279026, 0.03402525559067726, 0.04670413210988045, -0.03241048380732536, -0.010872657410800457, -0.006657585967332125, -0.0024144842755049467, 0.028375772759318352, -0.0011681775795295835, 0.018141495063900948, 0.007815402001142502, -0.020082561299204826, -0.016439471393823624, -0.03643369674682617, -0.013478146865963936, 0.006131984759122133, 0.03493897244334221, 0.009147773496806622, -0.028553608804941177, 0.0044991010800004005, 0.006744054611772299, -0.01589023321866989, -0.04849362000823021, 0.06675149500370026, 0.010645170696079731, -0.024550605565309525, 0.02339000441133976, -0.045118141919374466, -0.07916805893182755, -0.018181687220931053, 0.011058499105274677, -0.007801221217960119, -0.03945373371243477, -0.031800080090761185, 0.026608701795339584, -0.019066832959651947, -0.04518703743815422, 0.010088150389492512, -0.03809528052806854, 0.04878846928477287, -0.029614664614200592, 0.02394716627895832, 0.04832449182868004, -0.051249731332063675, 0.0031255593057721853, -0.06975080817937851, 0.07273513823747635, 0.010037313215434551, -0.02615142986178398, 0.003769963514059782, -0.0006923495675437152, -0.008666454814374447, -0.004627035930752754, 0.06560282409191132, -0.030843663960695267, 0.008920110762119293, -0.03358829766511917, -0.010556257329881191, 0.006708499975502491, -0.034248337149620056, 0.028597183525562286, 0.0019735556561499834, 0.02125617302954197, -0.014395085163414478, 0.0006746689323335886, 0.022267749533057213, -0.007922190241515636, 0.03768268972635269, 0.010184566490352154, -0.004014656879007816, 0.006838053930550814, 0.0015065987827256322, 0.02862069569528103, 0.019750311970710754, -0.03799348324537277, 0.0019933641888201237, -0.012283467687666416, 0.007683421019464731, -0.0089945737272501, -0.03632252290844917, -0.07185640931129456, 0.02578233927488327, -0.026482397690415382, -0.013502096757292747, 0.03601449728012085, -0.009416190907359123, -0.01581897959113121, -0.06219892576336861, -0.029067710041999817, 0.04498559981584549, -0.012904809787869453, 0.05365221947431564, 0.0338173545897007, 0.008596252650022507, 0.032199569046497345, -0.04635275900363922, -0.018407849594950676, 0.03472713381052017, -0.04062676802277565, -0.016770096495747566, 0.0003809866320807487, 0.028427891433238983, 0.03264860063791275, 0.008690740913152695, 0.0129087520763278, -0.0142075689509511, 0.00017525065049994737, -0.017644619569182396, 0.027175555005669594, -0.06675830483436584, -0.01591905951499939, -0.00936479214578867, 0.023475129157304764, 0.009269976057112217, -0.03395342454314232, -0.011424439027905464, 0.06613514572381973, -0.004035584628582001, -0.026910265907645226, -0.017013724893331528, -0.012935745529830456, -0.04178158566355705, 0.0063704573549330235, -0.0255417563021183, 0.04169268533587456, 0.029853666201233864, 0.008856047876179218, -0.008848282508552074, -0.019391147419810295, 0.0447334423661232, 0.0035641950089484453, 0.028407244011759758, 0.0020276315044611692, -0.006163624580949545, 0.006786065176129341, -0.007600846234709024, -0.07346843928098679, -0.04984980821609497, 0.028677087277173996, 0.03670452535152435, 0.041428785771131516, -0.022358538582921028, -0.03180079534649849, 0.0018857037648558617, 0.013750553131103516, -0.06419689208269119, 0.0127643384039402, -0.059298500418663025, 0.01813000813126564, -0.005238817539066076, -0.015901993960142136 ]
<p>I have a specific question about random selection, representativeness and inference. It is well known that it's necessary to use random selection to get representative samples from the population of interest. But what happens with non-random samples? </p> <p>I am working with an intentional sample. I compared the means of some of the main variables of my database with official data. And I can conclude that there aren't important differences between them. So I have a quite representative sample. However, I am confused about how to deal with this sample. When I estimate the means of some variables or the correlations between them, do I need to compute CI or p-values for this estimations? </p> <p>I guess that it's not necessary, since I got the sample without random selection. Therefore, I have no sampling error, and I can't know how my estimations differ from the population. However, I have read some papers where the authors work with non-random samples and they make estimations (they use CI's and p-values). Moreover, it's difficult to use multivariate techniques (like ANOVA or regression) without the help of statistical significance.</p> <p>Can anybody help me? I am very confused with this matter.</p>
25,048
[ -0.04609980434179306, -0.022947104647755623, 0.010282638482749462, 0.014960257336497307, 0.047453660517930984, 0.04163262993097305, -0.011669482104480267, -0.033982954919338226, -0.004740361124277115, -0.04065002128481865, 0.01641443744301796, 0.04229671135544777, 0.019834935665130615, -0.0008608739008195698, 0.01320482324808836, -0.012981834821403027, -0.024151938036084175, 0.017390845343470573, 0.010710692964494228, -0.0002951613860204816, 0.010537749156355858, 0.038551583886146545, 0.0030940778087824583, -0.011517615988850594, -0.04346608370542526, 0.04943624883890152, 0.010096666403114796, -0.002813065657392144, 0.011051204986870289, 0.037511736154556274, -0.046005796641111374, -0.009359009563922882, 0.010475579649209976, 0.05054377764463425, 0.035946015268564224, 0.008079332299530506, -0.035857029259204865, -0.009811981581151485, 0.016248712316155434, 0.0034163305535912514, -0.023338355123996735, -0.016653764992952347, 0.01981413923203945, 0.003068147227168083, -0.013933282345533371, 0.019436031579971313, -0.02014758810400963, -0.03036334551870823, 0.025248480960726738, -0.05262407660484314, 0.06513768434524536, -0.0013618115335702896, 0.02169519104063511, 0.037828993052244186, -0.009763251058757305, 0.00451821880415082, 0.03982692211866379, 0.04234004020690918, -0.02788401022553444, -0.015308492816984653, 0.01975851319730282, -0.030255764722824097, -0.009667396545410156, -0.009864600375294685, -0.0307552982121706, 0.0031189098954200745, -0.004590801429003477, -0.0038013120647519827, 0.05727519094944, 0.009856371209025383, 0.05016080662608147, 0.006771014537662268, 0.017576303333044052, -0.0032441942021250725, 0.0129797188565135, -0.017437418922781944, 0.02787064015865326, -0.012721790000796318, 0.03603169322013855, 0.025730175897479057, 0.014307633973658085, -0.01644175872206688, 0.03341418504714966, 0.03482126072049141, 0.01719479262828827, -0.017719149589538574, 0.04629041627049446, -0.03943561017513275, 0.025021325796842575, -0.01561692450195551, -0.011018600314855576, -0.03426596522331238, 0.03335287794470787, -0.007953126914799213, -0.02917606383562088, 0.009640450589358807, -0.03355516865849495, 0.06974875926971436, -0.006381431128829718, -0.00552716851234436, -0.007469759322702885, -0.029788415879011154, 0.040949393063783646, 0.04417373985052109, -0.02269737422466278, -0.010379855521023273, -0.01984175480902195, 0.020747067406773567, 0.00785749964416027, -0.037948619574308395, 0.0032563917338848114, 0.03972913697361946, 0.0268592219799757, 0.008649629540741444, 0.060132939368486404, 0.02460365928709507, 0.0036929065827280283, -0.030535651370882988, 0.11442124843597412, 0.07264521718025208, 0.039218176156282425, -0.025365252047777176, 0.03245076909661293, -0.023138629272580147, -0.014108767732977867, 0.007861847057938576, 0.00951208546757698, -0.010253782384097576, -0.03515661880373955, 0.022728826850652695, 0.009048189036548138, -0.009724006988108158, 0.03455936536192894, 0.012800061143934727, 0.024738583713769913, -0.010191787965595722, -0.07290580868721008, -0.03062533214688301, 0.03734983131289482, -0.01824747398495674, -0.012521060183644295, -0.06901891529560089, -0.004863364156335592, 0.03171848878264427, 0.03465403616428375, -0.004567509051412344, 0.03612121567130089, -0.03018040768802166, 0.03588734194636345, 0.03759260103106499, -0.011340697295963764, -0.00197986070998013, -0.020874125882983208, -0.005920090712606907, -0.027432603761553764, -0.121517114341259, 0.03267942741513252, 0.0012136504519730806, 0.02367311716079712, -0.026456307619810104, 0.01150576677173376, -0.014419532380998135, -0.02007492072880268, 0.016048753634095192, 0.038989871740341187, -0.013602777384221554, 0.08543926477432251, -0.013666206039488316, 0.043262772262096405, 0.03999610245227814, 0.027174273505806923, 0.02676098793745041, 0.009164978750050068, 0.05349331349134445, 0.05171841010451317, -0.02736281231045723, 0.013820958323776722, 0.006209449842572212, 0.01947467401623726, -0.003440345171838999, -0.028494253754615784, -0.009682999923825264, 0.0017101146513596177, -0.008385221473872662, 0.039097800850868225, 0.05375785380601883, 0.013632506132125854, -0.036043573170900345, 0.039295800030231476, -0.05058003589510918, -0.0631597489118576, -0.06600580364465714, 0.016610033810138702, 0.02554420381784439, -0.021202266216278076, 0.054328396916389465, 0.030708495527505875, 0.020074451342225075, -0.0035025777760893106, -0.01381513848900795, -0.0374448224902153, -0.012489119544625282, 0.031182097271084785, -0.05615195631980896, 0.0027936119586229324, 0.03379606083035469, 0.017526481300592422, -0.03666624799370766, 0.07123856991529465, -0.019938964396715164, -0.08499830216169357, 0.009837990626692772, -0.049497850239276886, -0.017325391992926598, -0.01618996076285839, -0.0014497556257992983, -0.0034931947011500597, 0.013743992894887924, -0.022292181849479675, 0.05537039041519165, -0.026781482622027397, 0.0811225101351738, 0.035424914211034775, -0.002770513528957963, -0.004374700598418713, 0.028285417705774307, 0.03354344889521599, 0.019222307950258255, -0.0070787216536700726, -0.004122468177229166, -0.06247463449835777, -0.032551560550928116, 0.05121636763215065, -0.017605792731046677, -0.04703237861394882, -0.01308527123183012, 0.039989955723285675, 0.03741774708032608, 0.03360831364989281, 0.03256940096616745, -0.010423273779451847, -0.010708209127187729, 0.02608349360525608, 0.01421274058520794, 0.04199923947453499, -0.004798348527401686, -0.014499673619866371, -0.024793319404125214, 0.04928860068321228, 0.014586759731173515, 0.031213875859975815, 0.041430868208408356, -0.004787411540746689, 0.004183609038591385, -0.017165254801511765, 0.012736538425087929, 0.0338822603225708, -0.01867459900677204, 0.017440075054764748, 0.03914448246359825, 0.0022672663908451796, -0.0012773025082424283, 0.029231887310743332, -0.03691580146551132, 0.041152194142341614, 0.012615667656064034, -0.06496666371822357, -0.002014672616496682, 0.007492833770811558, -0.026199938729405403, -0.002994175534695387, -0.0018509902292862535, -0.03312360867857933, -0.03833572193980217, 0.008114941418170929, -0.0035178803373128176, -0.022576116025447845, 0.028598595410585403, -0.0011253454722464085, -0.004444489721208811, -0.026991363614797592, 0.0031143829692155123, -0.01217661052942276, 0.0032916394993662834, -0.06685267388820648, -0.007211683783680201, -0.046898387372493744, -0.04287698119878769, 0.03235378488898277, -0.0349961556494236, -0.00980563648045063, 0.013340778648853302, -0.020832465961575508, -0.06415794044733047, -0.001933798659592867, -0.001603021752089262, 0.020449388772249222, -0.03037925437092781, -0.024954406544566154, 0.032762836664915085, 0.005812581162899733, -0.02299828641116619, 0.04708098620176315, -0.01573845185339451, -0.08279996365308762, -0.012932885438203812, 0.014818865805864334, 0.03504662960767746, -0.028803125023841858, 0.012772712856531143, 0.006284596864134073, -0.023480361327528954, -0.023099642246961594, -0.06321506202220917, -0.05849216505885124, 0.0022236485965549946, -0.01826624758541584, 0.021428093314170837, 0.023900384083390236, -0.01241326704621315, 0.05258403345942497, 0.0249882023781538, -0.04251934960484505, -0.006778100039809942, -0.009049508720636368, -0.031660329550504684, -0.01755712181329727, -0.0034469759557396173, 0.031236041337251663, -0.01465163379907608, 0.04136199876666069, 0.0064879185520112514, 0.05180515721440315, 0.02568879723548889, 0.017895089462399483, -0.001743576256558299, 0.025495324283838272, 0.020277291536331177, 0.017676837742328644, 0.005977260414510965, 0.012675851583480835, -0.055116668343544006, 0.042566608637571335, -0.013506531715393066, 0.020159807056188583, 0.03584778681397438, -0.02749812789261341, 0.02887880429625511, -0.036989256739616394, 0.016175733879208565, -0.030426710844039917, 0.03928122669458389, 0.009821435436606407, -0.002333755837753415, -0.0023234724067151546, -0.01052700076252222, 0.0103075560182333, -0.014977589249610901, 0.0051489537581801414, 0.03482422977685928, 0.026235507801175117, 0.015708833932876587, 0.033520471304655075, -0.013817986473441124, -0.020219765603542328, 0.026062341406941414, -0.033257920295000076, -0.030111340805888176, 0.028979945927858353, 0.06332814693450928, 0.010066254064440727, -0.0241771899163723, -0.03925280272960663, -0.003988548181951046, -0.0519724115729332, 0.02078337036073208, -0.04049140214920044, 0.03352563828229904, -0.016588369384407997, 0.02120770327746868, 0.007503891363739967, -0.01828412152826786, -0.019884994253516197, -0.03471286967396736, -0.04644513130187988, 0.042554810643196106, -0.03971477597951889, 0.0044503649696707726, -0.001970521407201886, -0.034867219626903534, 0.02808777056634426, -0.036216359585523605, 0.012736315838992596, -0.00885672029107809, 0.015572497621178627, 0.002127345884218812, 0.007093002554029226, -0.006215199828147888, -0.021000420674681664, -0.02240207977592945, 0.02504136599600315, 0.005809662863612175, -0.04180362820625305, 0.004297132603824139, 0.026416687294840813, -0.013483569025993347, -0.04886603727936745, -0.019724231213331223, 0.01095376443117857, 0.02102150395512581, 0.03428937867283821, 0.0575798936188221, 0.010396265424787998, -0.07237221300601959, 0.0211164653301239, -0.0004054794553667307, 0.0750669464468956, 0.03581661731004715, -0.009390286169946194, -0.014151385985314846, -0.04927995428442955, -0.01526718307286501, 0.005840510595589876, 0.006150633562356234, 0.0023087055888026953, -0.03530742973089218, 0.08333685994148254, -0.00248732790350914, -0.0472378171980381, -0.0018538354197517037, 0.022390836849808693, 0.010828027501702309, 0.022610677406191826, -0.04037630930542946, -0.006085155066102743, -0.003834789153188467, -0.012171242386102676, 0.043616924434900284, 0.037777889519929886, 0.01080180611461401, 0.013752619735896587, 0.04082794860005379, 0.0046924143098294735, -0.03923141956329346, -0.010905706323683262, 0.031875208020210266, 0.0481497086584568, 0.0033937690313905478, -0.03112865798175335, 0.03913890942931175, 0.025125673040747643, 0.025582406669855118, -0.009360183961689472, 0.01218207273632288, -0.060307107865810394, 0.014567553997039795, 0.05962824821472168, 0.027232056483626366, -0.05319776386022568, -0.01088163536041975, -0.037923663854599, -0.010506179183721542, 0.04972510412335396, -0.028607886284589767, -0.011465280316770077, -0.03398279845714569, -0.004063923377543688, -0.017298977822065353, -0.0136288246139884, -0.057428695261478424, -0.00648084981366992, -0.003633002517744899, 0.0155830392614007, -0.04455854371190071, -0.03073016181588173, -0.07839342951774597, 0.026889732107520103, 0.01819959469139576, 0.05813337862491608, -0.02776733785867691, 0.00232774973846972, -0.009642166085541248, 0.036688052117824554, 0.010506330989301205, -0.06475336104631424, 0.021695032715797424, -0.0004980220110155642, 0.013399126939475536, 0.027440179139375687, 0.0024281046353280544, -0.027437223121523857, 0.009176903404295444, -0.0038747626822441816, -0.006612126249819994, 0.003156344871968031, -0.037877216935157776, 0.04677685350179672, 0.013208163902163506, 0.013060851953923702, 0.08156909793615341, 0.01903759129345417, 0.015164166688919067, -0.02204703912138939, -0.03368990868330002, 0.03226403519511223, -0.05506974458694458, -0.011025652289390564, -0.06789056211709976, -0.004612377844750881, -0.02066623605787754, 0.008466912433505058, 0.018959129229187965, 0.017464056611061096, -0.01741999387741089, -0.008383982814848423, 0.001174889039248228, -0.00023474780027754605, 0.02654244378209114, -0.004574381280690432, 0.007127556949853897, 0.003953287377953529, -0.021032603457570076, -0.030239064246416092, -0.008800527080893517, 0.008394526317715645, 0.002639578655362129, 0.007517945021390915, -0.03632473945617676, -0.008666010573506355, -0.05511541664600372, -0.03839777782559395, 0.04164857417345047, -0.03581083565950394, 0.018571533262729645, -0.00006866138573968783, 0.050060831010341644, -0.00479924026876688, -0.034785207360982895, 0.0031096041202545166, 0.04349365457892418, -0.010543606244027615, 0.05158801004290581, -0.054845597594976425, 0.06338822841644287, -0.05197916552424431, 0.011361220851540565, -0.05727121978998184, -0.02204921841621399, 0.01510854996740818, 0.01684018224477768, -0.01406222302466631, -0.03310491889715195, 0.00810560118407011, 0.006609105039387941, -0.017683738842606544, -0.01051334384828806, 0.055083222687244415, -0.004896757658571005, -0.026317058131098747, -0.009247653186321259, 0.045556120574474335, 0.10912700742483139, -0.04786095768213272, -0.031195910647511482, 0.03979431837797165, -0.022657496854662895, -0.021677188575267792, -0.034889157861471176, 0.009139052592217922, -0.02003553695976734, -0.026213619858026505, -0.047488197684288025, 0.02370987832546234, 0.026994330808520317, -0.014268184080719948, 0.007886803708970547, 0.059631455689668655, -0.019555388018488884, 0.00832376442849636, -0.02948113903403282, -0.024750323966145515, 0.0162437092512846, 0.005713984835892916, -0.024644967168569565, 0.03767532855272293, -0.023589521646499634, -0.006886012852191925, 0.05413922294974327, -0.015100122429430485, -0.028995586559176445, 0.01642368733882904, 0.02693047560751438, -0.01690169982612133, 0.0318995900452137, -0.007399277295917273, -0.033017467707395554, 0.03139926865696907, 0.003095488529652357, -0.014408160001039505, -0.008029287680983543, 0.03126617893576622, -0.044728077948093414, -0.008267066441476345, -0.03203878551721573, -0.012507040053606033, 0.07364174723625183, 0.0038737200666218996, 0.04680674895644188, 0.06156889721751213, -0.00029637664556503296, -0.028856748715043068, -0.013102243654429913, 0.002175489906221628, -0.007563621737062931, 0.003686280455440283, 0.044714223593473434, -0.009568843059241772, 0.00709080696105957, 0.012438836507499218, -0.0012741362443193793, -0.01746433600783348, 0.04111611098051071, 0.04069171100854874, 0.0354720875620842, 0.010518131777644157, -0.01856951043009758, -0.00974066462367773, 0.014627771452069283, -0.05039805918931961, 0.011354726739227772, -0.013376462273299694, -0.0036648830864578485, 0.0378965325653553, 0.04122065007686615, 0.00018309193546883762, -0.04196561500430107, -0.007109127007424831, -0.02408030815422535, -0.021682459861040115, 0.0017503632698208094, -0.018657123669981956, 0.027448995038866997, -0.02212006412446499, 0.011320415884256363, -0.03614002838730812, 0.020800162106752396, -0.015595132485032082, -0.05430787801742554, -0.018361985683441162, -0.045604158192873, -0.03350130841135979, 0.02603020891547203, 0.018374204635620117, -0.02775074727833271, 0.03390524163842201, -0.04640789330005646, 0.023785125464200974, 0.001287130988202989, 0.051715899258852005, -0.03958366438746452, 0.09118429571390152, 0.0014770289417356253, 0.014473549090325832, -0.0012562215561047196, -0.01355002447962761, 0.09600883722305298, 0.061427682638168335, 0.03382682800292969, -0.06867042928934097, 0.016691282391548157, -0.02036786451935768, 0.026680845767259598, 0.0013488115509971976, -0.008435803465545177, -0.0032425248064100742, -0.02148553915321827, 0.027560584247112274, 0.043589718639850616, -0.015231415629386902, 0.01847228780388832, 0.06557033956050873, -0.05307279899716377, -0.0521138459444046, 0.0019955614116042852, 0.025667209178209305, 0.00881617795675993, -0.03496132418513298, -0.02805406041443348, 0.01053257193416357, 0.032273758202791214, 0.00014466993161477149, -0.03888564184308052, -0.014214333146810532, -0.013294334523379803, -0.011149589903652668, -0.010196015238761902, -0.0009030785877257586, 0.033500999212265015, -0.005846565123647451, -0.02897864393889904, -0.02066253311932087, 0.03495055064558983, -0.045102450996637344, 0.016357941552996635, 0.042358752340078354, -0.00279481103643775, -0.02040170505642891, -0.03241361677646637, 0.026459353044629097, -0.05545773729681969, -0.02558204159140587, -0.0198140200227499, 0.04526195675134659, -0.01108898688107729, -0.04234261065721512, -0.013369797728955746, 0.018683098256587982, -0.0008568544872105122, -0.02505154348909855, -0.02242496982216835, 0.029972948133945465, 0.03893427178263664, -0.04032064601778984, -0.04372738301753998, -0.02851281315088272, 0.01889166235923767, -0.018829507753252983, 0.02978752925992012, 0.023127879947423935, -0.07037074118852615, 0.006027552764862776, -0.02059919945895672, 0.017867008224129677, -0.00499242078512907, 0.005370811093598604, -0.00786541122943163, -0.015276467427611351, -0.03137191757559776, -0.002906518056988716, -0.0016414412530139089, -0.01079261302947998, 0.04467242211103439, -0.046213436871767044, 0.0016241874545812607, -0.007219160906970501, -0.011017424054443836, 0.029479091987013817, -0.012515316717326641, -0.014926111325621605, -0.023134268820285797, -0.008624967187643051, 0.02108357660472393, 0.03422444313764572, 0.04030465707182884, 0.004249900113791227, 0.014960670843720436, 0.009896108880639076, 0.006617438513785601, -0.04850278049707413, -0.007489565759897232, -0.024358035996556282, -0.02435649000108242, 0.0009936490096151829, -0.017726918682456017, 0.033049385994672775, 0.04202638566493988, 0.023855699226260185, 0.0005974619998596609, 0.009587571024894714, 0.004081533290445805, 0.0013681096024811268, -0.00018081857706420124, -0.08531205356121063, -0.01749156415462494, 0.008696316741406918, 0.0018969267839565873, -0.03924189507961273, -0.023788919672369957, -0.043119821697473526, -0.02615257538855076, 0.019194092601537704, -0.01187492348253727, -0.031275633722543716, 0.0037245014682412148, -0.040846340358257294, 0.04822510853409767, -0.03992984816431999, -0.02818332612514496, -0.043249133974313736, -0.004445931874215603, 0.01140042394399643, 0.013169356621801853, -0.012002751231193542, -0.0064503513276577, 0.01479250006377697, 0.022347472608089447, 0.022251930087804794, -0.02082512155175209, 0.006319283042103052, 0.004577685613185167, -0.041492924094200134, -0.05591452121734619, 0.015397327020764351, -0.039215803146362305, 0.011855323798954487, 0.06467587500810623, -0.0058487048372626305, -0.036866236478090286, 0.014772001653909683, -0.026970434933900833, 0.04530142620205879, 0.020328987389802933, -0.007254478987306356, -0.018895825371146202, 0.03532976284623146, -0.05124829709529877, -0.033308543264865875, -0.04652828723192215, 0.035669054836034775, -0.014113573357462883, 0.013887901790440083, 0.014695314690470695, -0.0009363136487081647, -0.01205514743924141, 0.05361754074692726, 0.049163952469825745, 0.02665785886347294, 0.0003927934158127755, 0.05156143382191658, 0.016941078007221222, 0.017662785947322845, 0.034392572939395905, -0.005746721755713224, 0.0010883023496717215, 0.06772460788488388, -0.007642778567969799, 0.07973658293485641, 0.017428971827030182, -0.03506701439619064, -0.06504411995410919, -0.02565787546336651, -0.01006330456584692, -0.020662203431129456, 0.03706131502985954, -0.048816025257110596, -0.02334287390112877, 0.021183591336011887, -0.055051013827323914, 0.013528631068766117, -0.02802519127726555, -0.057408858090639114, -0.04304336756467819, 0.010852688923478127, -0.03480686992406845, 0.026860689744353294, 0.042261745780706406, 0.025095416232943535, 0.03833229839801788, 0.027119992300868034, 0.00729902321472764, -0.008775368332862854, -0.026222337037324905, 0.023713909089565277, 0.013799458742141724, -0.05808991193771362, 0.033829085528850555, -0.036542635411024094, -0.02521982416510582, 0.028997080400586128, -0.01635003834962845, 0.021613117307424545, 0.009112423285841942, -0.0047928462736308575, 0.0035286531783640385, 0.0669725313782692, 0.08053882420063019, -0.00802247878164053, -0.004829053301364183, 0.004521539900451899, 0.04315875098109245, 0.02167452685534954, 0.0066812001168727875, 0.03321795165538788, 0.003562085097655654, -0.007513986434787512, 0.010481288656592369, 0.006041959393769503, -0.01144525408744812, -0.032790690660476685, 0.014947755262255669, 0.0040128338150680065, -0.007619927637279034, 0.004439507611095905, 0.06995847821235657, -0.05590420216321945, 0.001283401856198907, 0.0512947179377079, 0.037193089723587036, -0.024808770045638084, 0.023343518376350403, -0.01704861968755722, -0.03652266040444374, -0.009014849551022053, 0.019529439508914948, -0.00788964331150055, -0.07014098018407822, -0.020231038331985474, 0.01949566975235939, -0.013575653545558453, -0.024744372814893723, 0.0024075049441307783, -0.060944654047489166, 0.022233430296182632, 0.0032497216016054153, -0.016141068190336227, 0.0004070499853696674, -0.010994699783623219, -0.02794523723423481, -0.07136665284633636, 0.09040319174528122, 0.03861594945192337, -0.01810915395617485, -0.06162678822875023, -0.009177819825708866, -0.0418599508702755, 0.03715372830629349, 0.052421797066926956, 0.001084155635908246, 0.02504885382950306, 0.0010309123899787664, 0.01305336318910122, 0.007857796736061573, -0.06587506085634232, 0.04626673087477684, 0.009677604772150517, -0.02776338718831539, -0.00559566356241703, -0.0246296226978302, 0.039755214005708694, 0.024672413244843483, 0.03265542536973953, -0.01622885651886463, 0.03345727548003197, 0.018092742189764977, 0.008016074076294899, 0.06228558346629143, 0.024616990238428116, -0.0004702082951553166, -0.0016354783438146114, 0.009971937164664268, 0.022376153618097305, 0.011530372314155102, 0.01669442094862461, -0.03756825998425484, 0.02102937176823616, -0.02415107935667038, -0.05230241268873215, 0.023601286113262177, 0.009471959434449673, -0.0184168741106987, -0.03033909574151039, 0.017446815967559814, 0.015579674392938614, -0.02823590487241745, 0.008283492177724838, 0.010153675451874733, 0.024480530992150307, 0.003941425122320652, 0.007296934258192778, 0.03715384006500244, -0.0028592809103429317, -0.013106971979141235, 0.018451964482665062, 0.021011890843510628, 0.024782409891486168, -0.027240868657827377, -0.003131081350147724, 0.04522395133972168, -0.008401831611990929, 0.0568871907889843, -0.00899918656796217, 0.0445425771176815, -0.039472177624702454, -0.031141962856054306, 0.014050818979740143, -0.012848219834268093, 0.05144812911748886, 0.0011067285668104887, 0.0034374124370515347, 0.0938853994011879, -0.032264795154333115, 0.01060244906693697, -0.013019409030675888, -0.0372837632894516, -0.012447511777281761, -0.02497684396803379, 0.010008161887526512, 0.00510161928832531, -0.0009291304158978164, 0.015147057361900806, -0.010673019103705883, 0.0039287712424993515, 0.0478738434612751, -0.011249405331909657, 0.052644193172454834, -0.01654311828315258, -0.04322303459048271, -0.02679314650595188, -0.012329923920333385, -0.004945775959640741, -0.000047234108933480456, 0.018956562504172325, 0.036635465919971466, 0.02259877324104309, -0.026561792939901352, -0.03368525952100754, 0.027376428246498108, 0.01920393854379654, -0.06454252451658249, -0.002142379991710186, -0.03139409050345421, -0.002877238905057311, -0.014590759761631489, -0.004976598080247641 ]
<p>When estimating power calculations for a case control study, what does exposure of controls really mean? </p> <p>I find lots of information how how to calculate exposure for cases when you already know exposure in controls - but nothing on how the actual number is calculated for controls. </p> <p>Please enlighten me! </p>
73,602
[ -0.02809731662273407, -0.011512229219079018, 0.005172663368284702, -0.03964678943157196, 0.03541233390569687, 0.037053246051073074, -0.01834806241095066, -0.02029852755367756, 0.017001109197735786, -0.035259176045656204, 0.053253401070833206, 0.04343213886022568, 0.04525269195437431, -0.02864827588200569, -0.0117208082228899, 0.0057681347243487835, -0.037523601204156876, 0.04915737360715866, 0.0024304199032485485, 0.0012754366034641862, 0.005322432145476341, 0.042505551129579544, 0.008445939049124718, 0.010836729779839516, -0.027242101728916168, 0.06272152811288834, 0.017441274598240852, -0.03220098465681076, 0.004457949195057154, 0.03160016983747482, -0.020351896062493324, -0.037546005100011826, 0.03375484421849251, 0.016994357109069824, 0.006026211194694042, -0.005698685999959707, -0.020152468234300613, -0.01953105442225933, -0.01358990091830492, 0.0668170154094696, -0.04937465116381645, -0.027413275092840195, 0.012097466737031937, 0.003370251040905714, -0.021396730095148087, 0.02176663838326931, -0.00780079048126936, -0.057569120079278946, 0.03231395408511162, -0.06633739918470383, 0.050295181572437286, 0.0077750468626618385, 0.07459650933742523, 0.03490877151489258, -0.010891808196902275, -0.00016248261090368032, 0.07407497614622116, 0.034045081585645676, -0.02203664742410183, -0.06411091983318329, -0.027861015871167183, -0.013602985069155693, 0.002669782377779484, -0.027221348136663437, -0.02335580252110958, -0.013410304673016071, -0.007032633293420076, -0.021634342148900032, 0.0014387221308425069, 0.00959259644150734, 0.060101862996816635, 0.008179941214621067, 0.011758768931031227, 0.0009964942000806332, -0.022896533831954002, -0.02419932559132576, 0.00738754915073514, 0.04972333461046219, 0.04358530044555664, 0.04694556072354317, -0.026431234553456306, 0.007946990430355072, 0.03475967422127724, 0.005533958785235882, 0.012997177429497242, -0.023653903976082802, 0.06756112724542618, 0.014503709971904755, 0.020238997414708138, 0.02552747167646885, -0.05406874418258667, -0.003928628750145435, 0.034294866025447845, -0.01473382767289877, -0.033220332115888596, 0.017291532829403877, -0.026067862287163734, 0.05981165170669556, 0.0049161845818161964, 0.030062971636652946, -0.007614227011799812, -0.009811865165829659, 0.030498772859573364, 0.04160209745168686, -0.01903514377772808, -0.02621229737997055, -0.0076608131639659405, -0.0196063295006752, 0.007478122133761644, -0.029218889772892, -0.0019913227297365665, 0.004822030197829008, 0.011747953481972218, -0.006597551051527262, 0.028544263914227486, 0.010406957939267159, -0.02140543796122074, 0.016476700082421303, 0.057405173778533936, 0.01293233223259449, 0.04210745170712471, -0.046625081449747086, 0.0013984465040266514, -0.0071547506377100945, -0.015412797220051289, 0.023779138922691345, 0.013387015089392662, -0.002021526452153921, -0.0698271095752716, 0.05119526386260986, 0.051986414939165115, -0.026588482782244682, 0.043537966907024384, -0.008081627078354359, 0.021375739946961403, -0.0207829549908638, -0.07442519068717957, -0.027410760521888733, 0.03490476682782173, -0.021684028208255768, -0.02627462148666382, -0.06890678405761719, -0.007195919286459684, 0.006227667443454266, 0.06063002347946167, -0.0009244384127669036, 0.028215354308485985, 0.01718652807176113, 0.019694378599524498, 0.01781001314520836, 0.002983599901199341, -0.005391217768192291, -0.014840027317404747, -0.017395565286278725, -0.011545926332473755, -0.08112384378910065, 0.01969459280371666, 0.0340859554708004, -0.005728722084313631, -0.007784947752952576, 0.04267990589141846, -0.008928506635129452, -0.021054014563560486, 0.012436121702194214, 0.007937517017126083, -0.04513876512646675, 0.049176886677742004, -0.031179985031485558, 0.024373160675168037, 0.04489392042160034, 0.001614480628632009, 0.045540761202573776, -0.0004943612730130553, 0.054002657532691956, 0.014396664686501026, 0.008571900427341461, -0.0077041806653141975, -0.03262436389923096, 0.019200162962079048, 0.023189997300505638, -0.05755625665187836, 0.031167391687631607, 0.02043783664703369, 0.006811834871768951, 0.05817995220422745, 0.005812398623675108, -0.019337086006999016, -0.050913453102111816, 0.01251565758138895, -0.010021439753472805, -0.06118907034397125, -0.08682204782962799, 0.011715120635926723, -0.01187094859778881, -0.018550220876932144, 0.006934517528861761, 0.004951194394379854, 0.02261974662542343, -0.012136274017393589, -0.00783525500446558, -0.006538200192153454, -0.004576539155095816, 0.05454804748296738, -0.04128987714648247, 0.022596819326281548, 0.056583333760499954, 0.05197922885417938, -0.006325216498225927, 0.05685651674866676, -0.036932315677404404, -0.03645344823598862, 0.007305548992007971, -0.04922071471810341, 0.009172653779387474, 0.0006875517428852618, -0.035142965614795685, -0.011237719096243382, -0.023256933316588402, -0.00837908498942852, 0.05541083961725235, -0.03769417107105255, 0.08733803033828735, 0.057575907558202744, -0.01602313481271267, -0.0036858292296528816, 0.020849747583270073, 0.011876917444169521, -0.023506218567490578, -0.04241089150309563, -0.0023556204978376627, -0.048379793763160706, -0.03722570091485977, 0.016675908118486404, -0.0474831685423851, -0.016593672335147858, -0.008380915969610214, 0.04118310287594795, 0.059937648475170135, 0.035024918615818024, 0.03531670570373535, 0.027130449190735817, -0.035611823201179504, -0.025264767929911613, 0.008591795340180397, 0.009341594763100147, 0.005244072526693344, 0.02010263316333294, 0.036168284714221954, 0.04372263699769974, 0.019276505336165428, -0.01828191988170147, 0.06730742007493973, -0.00542365713045001, 0.025409922003746033, -0.010835809633135796, -0.00673678470775485, 0.040202803909778595, -0.03599345311522484, 0.029021158814430237, 0.022409219294786453, 0.00806227046996355, -0.006635965779423714, 0.013973208144307137, -0.044783905148506165, 0.029150227084755898, 0.02361900918185711, -0.07206309586763382, 0.022046096622943878, -0.00576218543574214, -0.021985966712236404, 0.01335068792104721, -0.03794924169778824, -0.04851353168487549, -0.00718636903911829, 0.0130784772336483, 0.0077863470651209354, 0.019247407093644142, 0.06327321380376816, -0.03507085517048836, -0.04029149189591408, -0.031678974628448486, 0.0037449614610522985, -0.007296579424291849, 0.009632961824536324, -0.07334359735250473, -0.006678860634565353, -0.023662229999899864, 0.007451463490724564, 0.044944651424884796, -0.029949679970741272, -0.04383805766701698, 0.04777739569544792, 0.020632777363061905, -0.051810625940561295, -0.0164658110588789, -0.013583004474639893, -0.005600645672529936, -0.0053474185988307, -0.014801309444010258, 0.028975773602724075, 0.019957859069108963, -0.035848524421453476, 0.043546684086322784, -0.000774677493609488, -0.0010132640600204468, -0.0020278606098145247, -0.0017272171098738909, 0.023730777204036713, -0.033410780131816864, -0.008427737280726433, -0.009252061136066914, -0.06668682396411896, -0.008859571069478989, -0.026820596307516098, -0.03574856370687485, 0.033805835992097855, 0.020779572427272797, 0.030076058581471443, -0.009796159341931343, -0.0037767235189676285, 0.07444129884243011, 0.017649952322244644, -0.025654826313257217, 0.010179691016674042, -0.019539417698979378, -0.018606053665280342, -0.011262010782957077, 0.027776814997196198, 0.040416475385427475, 0.006761600729078054, 0.0012000857386738062, -0.0022880607284605503, 0.028384363278746605, 0.04402891546487808, -0.00105275958776474, 0.02192814089357853, -0.006437340751290321, 0.010926459915935993, -0.017566822469234467, 0.04546848312020302, 0.014890538528561592, -0.005938658490777016, 0.025940224528312683, -0.02840203233063221, 0.05631337687373161, 0.00669434666633606, -0.050256211310625076, 0.009629225358366966, -0.001982094720005989, 0.020649036392569542, -0.024623427540063858, 0.03994885832071304, -0.008214009925723076, -0.003866198007017374, -0.017663558945059776, 0.028387418016791344, 0.02238984778523445, -0.03665749728679657, -0.021726015955209732, 0.020855827257037163, 0.09919298440217972, 0.003759186016395688, -0.011721731163561344, -0.019862744957208633, 0.0036527831107378006, 0.0061599258333444595, -0.02055651880800724, -0.02357465960085392, 0.024634389206767082, 0.06103542819619179, 0.008974515832960606, -0.027850640937685966, -0.033646244555711746, -0.011388791725039482, -0.046212486922740936, -0.013369345106184483, -0.023958029225468636, 0.02383553422987461, -0.021414384245872498, 0.054258160293102264, -0.011313701048493385, -0.026203960180282593, 0.010341491550207138, 0.0024775194469839334, -0.047313813120126724, 0.0075547234155237675, -0.0191605594009161, -0.014794455841183662, -0.030573107302188873, -0.030359840020537376, 0.05832516402006149, 0.013329248875379562, -0.011818284168839455, -0.028227711096405983, 0.013151700608432293, -0.00984601117670536, 0.022680094465613365, 0.007177241146564484, 0.004713480360805988, -0.016459312289953232, 0.05970771610736847, 0.004769995342940092, 0.006298357155174017, -0.019071297720074654, 0.030186321586370468, -0.0057067847810685635, -0.0358937606215477, -0.03508394584059715, 0.002130557084456086, 0.0027085253968834877, 0.04635388031601906, 0.027009015902876854, 0.008028864860534668, -0.077715203166008, 0.03367108106613159, 0.001269643660634756, 0.01839420571923256, 0.06024434044957161, -0.00814135279506445, -0.005297267809510231, -0.04115073382854462, -0.019251806661486626, 0.009708348661661148, -0.00573074771091342, -0.01250440999865532, 0.041831985116004944, 0.08576307445764542, -0.0025268266908824444, -0.07340358197689056, 0.02035743184387684, 0.023626651614904404, 0.06599968671798706, 0.029770085588097572, -0.06332213431596756, 0.030983582139015198, -0.043708860874176025, -0.012181103229522705, 0.023802001029253006, 0.031059803441166878, -0.0024847264867275953, 0.027186783030629158, 0.014128229580819607, -0.033463723957538605, -0.030193330720067024, 0.029855793341994286, 0.03171393647789955, 0.030730653554201126, 0.01939031295478344, -0.04190977290272713, 0.03974634408950806, 0.054143551737070084, 0.016889456659555435, 0.014956575818359852, 0.0003591927816160023, -0.07399122416973114, -0.012131336145102978, 0.03669339418411255, 0.020270681008696556, -0.02869505062699318, -0.0036335706245154142, 0.017786409705877304, 0.012800801545381546, 0.015073851682245731, -0.04181685671210289, 0.007592290174216032, -0.05280520021915436, -0.00829924363642931, -0.04386143013834953, -0.04205329716205597, -0.04431397095322609, 0.007402314338833094, -0.013110688887536526, 0.009562024846673012, -0.008859955705702305, 0.033704642206430435, -0.02099776268005371, 0.024609344080090523, 0.007438419386744499, 0.06011398509144783, -0.020333977416157722, -0.0329444482922554, 0.00495500024408102, 0.019855698570609093, -0.012977509759366512, -0.06572014838457108, -0.002592311007902026, 0.022928861901164055, 0.02378530614078045, 0.06973046064376831, -0.04629649966955185, -0.00945697259157896, 0.030368531122803688, 0.03155960887670517, 0.005300967488437891, -0.022008776664733887, -0.06897850334644318, 0.059520695358514786, 0.022154616191983223, -0.013982374221086502, 0.0926775336265564, -0.005099833942949772, -0.015600472688674927, 0.00012964889174327254, -0.029665667563676834, 0.028504079207777977, -0.02016521245241165, -0.023700574412941933, -0.034228742122650146, -0.001217630342580378, 0.0034329367335885763, 0.029265068471431732, -0.021801646798849106, 0.030514324083924294, -0.006852207239717245, 0.002652107272297144, 0.0037531580310314894, -0.0014044615672901273, 0.03363524004817009, -0.010698282159864902, 0.009306006133556366, 0.0127263143658638, -0.003131968667730689, -0.008075525984168053, 0.03371962904930115, -0.020384877920150757, 0.024431433528661728, -0.006314923986792564, -0.05086415261030197, -0.03682730719447136, -0.028926044702529907, -0.04739518091082573, 0.0192753616720438, -0.023483749479055405, 0.03580581396818161, -0.0455227829515934, -0.003938161768019199, 0.0197997335344553, -0.07233131676912308, -0.031639207154512405, 0.02137221395969391, -0.029763227328658104, 0.049255795776844025, -0.03486153855919838, 0.06413473188877106, 0.009976178407669067, 0.015354092232882977, -0.054083723574876785, -0.018889231607317924, 0.03236028552055359, 0.018848182633519173, 0.010385564528405666, -0.023523522540926933, 0.014183629304170609, -0.016864022240042686, -0.04948073998093605, -0.023134786635637283, 0.054791901260614395, -0.02920973300933838, 0.01343989185988903, -0.014115260913968086, 0.01137136947363615, 0.057585734874010086, -0.0191760566085577, -0.029723547399044037, 0.04010065272450447, -0.03964634984731674, 0.0001146996219176799, -0.006184977013617754, -0.02498982846736908, -0.016271570697426796, -0.011991169303655624, -0.03955868259072304, -0.01571018062531948, 0.037252821028232574, -0.025913584977388382, -0.007631127256900072, 0.01916334219276905, 0.024377670139074326, 0.017867151647806168, -0.04094091057777405, 0.006503001321107149, 0.006105926353484392, 0.05288763716816902, -0.017243267968297005, 0.001589512568898499, -0.05314604565501213, 0.03858334943652153, 0.02542671002447605, 0.015604434534907341, -0.013707350939512253, 0.03653515875339508, 0.05248376354575157, -0.004987909458577633, 0.05175163596868515, -0.05212092027068138, -0.02974019944667816, 0.021150408312678337, 0.019776601344347, 0.03137187287211418, 0.024772493168711662, -0.009513268247246742, -0.03692273050546646, -0.012274987064301968, -0.06868956983089447, 0.0029600525740534067, 0.041505761444568634, -0.009540724568068981, 0.05069613456726074, 0.04429105669260025, 0.007150962017476559, 0.008062617853283882, -0.01599220559000969, 0.021308936178684235, 0.006585534196346998, -0.018988676369190216, 0.04660799726843834, -0.036686599254608154, -0.03704473376274109, 0.05031370744109154, 0.01630917750298977, 0.00529226241633296, 0.02309669367969036, 0.032787635922431946, 0.008261729031801224, -0.00380884506739676, -0.022518949583172798, -0.010249059647321701, 0.0072440034709870815, -0.04301546514034271, -0.006174453068524599, -0.03532927483320236, -0.0062212576158344746, 0.04962336644530296, 0.012366781942546368, -0.002755641471594572, -0.040073212236166, -0.04139544814825058, -0.0012650397839024663, 0.002834567567333579, -0.01610463671386242, 0.0006107330555096269, 0.0015099879819899797, -0.011556419543921947, 0.03299741819500923, -0.05037996917963028, -0.0025586900301277637, -0.0050859288312494755, -0.08252277970314026, -0.022991690784692764, -0.0265091173350811, -0.04004031419754028, 0.027550822123885155, -0.009048588573932648, -0.018283631652593613, -0.00011330574488965794, -0.03768162801861763, -0.02348918654024601, -0.02035895735025406, 0.010917001403868198, -0.02962936833500862, 0.08854532986879349, 0.030819734558463097, -0.008229265920817852, 0.0034762322902679443, -0.0017360302153974771, 0.1091741994023323, 0.08833356201648712, -0.024294951930642128, -0.10197947174310684, -0.010139863938093185, -0.018051138147711754, 0.002410809975117445, -0.0233842171728611, -0.018943190574645996, 0.009764778427779675, -0.001584007404744625, 0.028943799436092377, 0.06156865134835243, 0.022262154147028923, -0.011042824946343899, 0.07370872050523758, -0.010143551975488663, -0.018293937668204308, 0.008421821519732475, -0.008598188869655132, -0.017950374633073807, -0.01627231203019619, -0.04031730443239212, 0.0020768786780536175, 0.028337879106402397, -0.010505322366952896, -0.016578340902924538, -0.013578292913734913, -0.03220636397600174, -0.0033679495099931955, -0.02980899065732956, -0.014789488166570663, 0.02527426928281784, -0.015761246904730797, -0.038384679704904556, -0.025761473923921585, 0.021070661023259163, -0.03358873724937439, -0.012992478907108307, 0.04861278831958771, -0.04915234073996544, -0.0113827520981431, 0.010003717616200447, 0.027415860444307327, -0.036303672939538956, -0.027563028037548065, -0.01440656278282404, 0.019272588193416595, -0.006471992004662752, 0.007963648997247219, 0.0060524228028953075, -0.007910089567303658, -0.049456268548965454, -0.05454753711819649, -0.020439041778445244, -0.005563311278820038, 0.020740235224366188, -0.04829949885606766, -0.02242792584002018, -0.03631434217095375, 0.012399181723594666, -0.023045124486088753, 0.06629937142133713, 0.055322952568531036, -0.01907503791153431, -0.003529180074110627, -0.023075172677636147, 0.03461827337741852, 0.015058084391057491, 0.012020271271467209, 0.01080026850104332, -0.033611129969358444, -0.03259207308292389, 0.021508818492293358, 0.028697026893496513, 0.005146072246134281, 0.030650511384010315, -0.01797267608344555, 0.016654333099722862, -0.03371778503060341, -0.044198937714099884, -0.005275702569633722, -0.012906397692859173, -0.009539601393043995, -0.049504633992910385, -0.0010378349106758833, 0.01377937477082014, 0.06987034529447556, -0.012968210503458977, 0.02181180939078331, -0.01961013302206993, 0.030769413337111473, 0.039974477142095566, -0.038285765796899796, 0.004625464323908091, 0.023174379020929337, -0.022045569494366646, 0.0024491138756275177, 0.014299341477453709, 0.05181709676980972, -0.018318692222237587, -0.017571261152625084, 0.004396127071231604, 0.008000269532203674, 0.015150121413171291, -0.015166236087679863, 0.002955478383228183, -0.05309467017650604, 0.005234601441770792, -0.003452773904427886, 0.018605023622512817, -0.026834197342395782, -0.0007541215745732188, -0.03478484973311424, -0.04759810119867325, 0.015718678012490273, -0.002795563777908683, -0.021333226934075356, 0.005982150323688984, 0.015598262660205364, 0.006042080000042915, 0.016131868585944176, -0.02334880270063877, -0.038496486842632294, 0.002916272496804595, 0.022138405591249466, 0.0004509499412961304, 0.017389455810189247, -0.01414212491363287, 0.016318771988153458, 0.04697706922888756, 0.014876419678330421, -0.00369717157445848, -0.0018780436366796494, 0.02172750048339367, 0.007281244732439518, -0.005779520608484745, 0.05734335258603096, -0.003945709206163883, -0.030947105959057808, 0.05678417533636093, -0.04157610237598419, -0.02729651890695095, 0.04046749696135521, -0.015152792446315289, 0.04275314882397652, 0.019696539267897606, 0.0047174482606351376, -0.0017556329257786274, 0.02397473156452179, -0.026904715225100517, -0.04328096657991409, -0.014214828610420227, 0.027392402291297913, -0.018918178975582123, -0.009588410146534443, 0.005597612354904413, 0.025079214945435524, 0.007288389839231968, 0.021014424040913582, 0.04140123724937439, -0.00028306609601713717, 0.025664886459708214, 0.03041876293718815, 0.031078509986400604, -0.0034548593685030937, -0.017926890403032303, 0.0040487973019480705, 0.011155698448419571, 0.04341169819235802, -0.02893928252160549, 0.04177064821124077, -0.03336130082607269, 0.0027320319786667824, -0.09672234952449799, -0.02790176309645176, -0.0037808846682310104, 0.014092751778662205, 0.00508293230086565, -0.02445235103368759, -0.004731358028948307, 0.00008902247645892203, -0.08039695024490356, 0.0024373361375182867, -0.033961519598960876, 0.018143845722079277, -0.03218132257461548, 0.027508264407515526, -0.004097733646631241, 0.05176768824458122, 0.03560089319944382, -0.0180789977312088, 0.009791627526283264, 0.03942204639315605, 0.025808967649936676, -0.03082277812063694, 0.007640739902853966, 0.016176888719201088, -0.004731610883027315, -0.05928512662649155, 0.0034667812287807465, 0.005585052073001862, -0.020672239363193512, 0.02525850012898445, 0.005528046749532223, 0.005010100547224283, 0.0010651497868821025, 0.019307876005768776, 0.009115605615079403, 0.03718056157231331, 0.015837248414754868, 0.009183813817799091, 0.00015044772590044886, -0.005261905491352081, 0.018335465341806412, 0.031070105731487274, -0.012899206019937992, 0.001740352134220302, 0.05499846860766411, -0.0026908658910542727, -0.01847224310040474, 0.002170041436329484, 0.013673266395926476, -0.026002801954746246, 0.012929437682032585, -0.004227343015372753, 0.013113925233483315, -0.026065126061439514, 0.021763546392321587, -0.0753827765583992, -0.026846108958125114, 0.0687061995267868, 0.02293727733194828, -0.01959940418601036, 0.044337671250104904, -0.010495666414499283, -0.009753048419952393, 0.020502183586359024, 0.03520022705197334, -0.018933244049549103, -0.03617027401924133, 0.033676937222480774, 0.01572180911898613, 0.015856938436627388, 0.00022727649775333703, -0.017073774710297585, -0.060020118951797485, -0.006377877667546272, -0.02439158223569393, -0.023584140464663506, 0.012389504350721836, -0.007715719752013683, 0.03621642664074898, -0.07394320517778397, 0.06172722578048706, 0.01019130740314722, -0.015306496061384678, -0.054247159510850906, -0.011066724546253681, 0.0091535160318017, 0.01069555338472128, 0.055860817432403564, 0.03370393067598343, -0.03320334479212761, -0.00022680978872813284, 0.06365491449832916, -0.010466092266142368, -0.05966619774699211, 0.027378305792808533, 0.039284463971853256, -0.040216583758592606, -0.034598372876644135, -0.0036544394679367542, -0.01122286356985569, 0.02259889803826809, -0.010567073710262775, -0.02001427300274372, 0.04541162773966789, 0.008198782801628113, 0.0015640836209058762, 0.035683758556842804, 0.045408088713884354, 0.005598804913461208, 0.04372141510248184, 0.016909509897232056, 0.008579259738326073, 0.03840751200914383, 0.007810723502188921, -0.07229247689247131, 0.022910455241799355, -0.0019645611755549908, -0.005303829442709684, 0.030169449746608734, -0.006843762472271919, 0.00015947071369737387, -0.03420094773173332, 0.007847340777516365, 0.027717409655451775, -0.03193951025605202, -0.011740028858184814, 0.04390035942196846, 0.026006920263171196, -0.008175285533070564, 0.002101007616147399, 0.031989168375730515, -0.021241510286927223, -0.011803156696259975, 0.010387241840362549, 0.004114513751119375, 0.012090975418686867, -0.024847589433193207, -0.009176288731396198, 0.038496389985084534, 0.005815017037093639, 0.054253216832876205, 0.009493584744632244, 0.051209110766649246, -0.059643324464559555, -0.026651600375771523, -0.03466315194964409, -0.023707512766122818, 0.03289974480867386, 0.015071173198521137, 0.002739587565883994, 0.05076852813363075, -0.02978576347231865, -0.015803460031747818, -0.025564691051840782, -0.021244458854198456, -0.011230770498514175, -0.050231702625751495, 0.030927812680602074, 0.05035002902150154, -0.007278153672814369, -0.0007085275137796998, -0.023666324093937874, -0.03218672052025795, 0.01312263123691082, -0.024074343964457512, 0.07113134115934372, -0.004187018610537052, -0.0032019284553825855, -0.05601973831653595, -0.013647953048348427, -0.023329537361860275, -0.00962300505489111, -0.004059526603668928, 0.04757057502865791, 0.0011378239141777158, -0.002606380730867386, -0.027325339615345, 0.02928747981786728, 0.029937773942947388, -0.06886294484138489, -0.0280863419175148, -0.016506673768162727, 0.04077700525522232, -0.0016735485987737775, 0.0011856398778036237 ]
<p>this is my first post, so I hope everything is in the right format. I have some problems with glmer and don't know how to fix it, so I hope somebody can help me out with this. I could not find an answer to this anywhere.</p> <p>My experiment: The experimental setup has eight sites, each site has a central area in which organisms get marked. From the central area, organisms have the choice to go into three different areas which are equipped with traps. The three areas are crossed with sites. The recapture rates in these three areas are very low and the sampling effort (trap days) is very high. Due to external influences, traps got destroyed to different degrees in all the sampling areas. In addition to the marked organisms, unmarked organisms of the same species get caught, too. </p> <p>The dataset looks something like this:</p> <pre><code>library(lme4) data &lt;- structure(list(site = c("A", "A", "A", "B", "B", "B", "C", "C", "C", "D", "D", "D", "E", "E", "E", "F", "F", "F", "G", "G", "G", "H", "H", "H"), area = c("I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III", "I", "II", "III"), marked = c(2, 6, 3, 5, 3, 9, 0, 8, 1, 1, 1, 18, 3, 0, 0, 1, 5, 6, 3, 0, 2, 2, 4, 5), unmarked = c(38, 78, 104, 1, 6, 10, 1, 13, 0, 13,7, 85, 7, 1, 0, 9, 4, 36, 3, 4, 3, 10, 20, 29), sampl_effort = c(9300, 9100, 8700, 9900, 9600, 8600, 9800, 9400, 10800, 11600, 11000, 13950, 10300, 9700, 9800, 10450, 10100, 10800, 9600, 9900, 9300, 11800, 11250, 9450)), .Names = c("site", "area", "marked", "unmarked", "sampl_effort"), row.names = c(NA,-24), class = "data.frame") </code></pre> <p>Now I wanted to fit a glmer. Because the amount of marked organisms may be related to the total amount of organisms, I chose to take a binomial approach, with cbind(marked, unmarked). I use area with the three treatments as explanatory variable, and site as random factor. Because the sampling effort differs between the different areas, I want to include it as an offset. The code looks like this:</p> <pre><code>mod.glmer1= glmer(cbind(marked,unmarked) ~ area + (1 | site) + offset(sampl_effort), family=binomial, data=data) </code></pre> <p>Then, I get the error:</p> <blockquote> <p>Error: (maxstephalfit) PIRLS step-halvings failed to reduce deviance in pwrssUpdate</p> </blockquote> <p>If I try the glmer without the offset, everything works out fine:</p> <pre><code>mod.glmer2= glmer(cbind(marked,unmarked) ~ area + (1 | site), family=binomial, data=data) </code></pre> <p>Out of interest, I tried a glm without the random factor and with offset:</p> <pre><code>mod.glm1= glm(cbind(marked,unmarked) ~ area + offset(sampl_effort), family=binomial, data=data) </code></pre> <p>and I get the following Warnings:</p> <blockquote> <p>Warning messages: 1: glm.fit: fitted probabilities numerically 0 or 1 occurred 2: glm.fit: fitted probabilities numerically 0 or 1 occurred</p> </blockquote> <p>By looking at the fitted values</p> <pre><code>round(cbind(data[,3:5],fits=fitted(mod.glm1)),8) </code></pre> <p>I can see that all the fitted values are 0. I now thought that the offset is just too large to get reasonable fitted value. As the sampling effort is arbitrary (instead of days, I could have taken sampling hours, weeks, etc.), I decided to divide the sampling effort by 1000. By doing this, the glm now works:</p> <pre><code>mod.glm2= glm(cbind(marked,unmarked) ~ area + offset(sampl_effort/1000), family=binomial, data=data) </code></pre> <p>However, for the glmer</p> <pre><code>mod.glmer3= glmer(cbind(marked,unmarked) ~ area + (1 | site) + offset(sampl_effort/1000), family=binomial, data=data) </code></pre> <p>I still get</p> <blockquote> <p>Error: (maxstephalfit) PIRLS step-halvings failed to reduce deviance in pwrssUpdate</p> </blockquote> <p>So my questions are basically:</p> <ol> <li><p>Am I allowed to divide the sampling effort by 1000? In my mind it should lead to the same results, as the relative differences in sampling effort stay the same (and sampling days are a arbitrary measurement). However, I of course tried it with e.g. dividing by 10000 and I get different results. </p></li> <li><p>How can I include the sampling effort in the glmer? The sampling effort is just too important to keep it out, however, I also need the sites as random factor. Is the offset the right approach and if yes, why doesn't it work.</p></li> </ol> <p>P.S.: My session information:</p> <blockquote> <p>R version 3.0.2 (2013-09-25) Platform: i386-w64-mingw32/i386 (32-bit)</p> <p>locale: [1] LC_COLLATE=English_United States.1252 LC_CTYPE=English_United States.1252<br> [3] LC_MONETARY=English_United States.1252 LC_NUMERIC=C<br> [5] LC_TIME=English_United States.1252 </p> <p>attached base packages: [1] stats graphics grDevices utils datasets methods base </p> <p>other attached packages: [1] car_2.0-19 lme4_1.0-6 Matrix_1.1-2 lattice_0.20-23</p> <p>loaded via a namespace (and not attached): [1] grid_3.0.2 MASS_7.3-29 minqa_1.2.3 nlme_3.1-111 nnet_7.3-7<br> [6] Rcpp_0.11.0 splines_3.0.2 tools_3.0.2</p> </blockquote> <p>Thanks in advance! John</p>
73,603
[ -0.0553472600877285, -0.053678542375564575, 0.028276411816477776, 0.004348357208073139, 0.006243462674319744, -0.007085781078785658, -0.026646852493286133, -0.010836007073521614, 0.02070670761168003, -0.01392326783388853, 0.03127848729491234, 0.053425319492816925, 0.053814083337783813, 0.05195833370089531, 0.018095573410391808, -0.009420221671462059, -0.009668489918112755, -0.0004165046557318419, 0.003143094480037689, -0.008350097574293613, -0.011540059000253677, 0.002625029534101486, 0.015357823111116886, -0.013942650519311428, -0.031028971076011658, 0.07765495032072067, 0.030753187835216522, -0.017314055934548378, 0.015180148184299469, 0.04959490895271301, -0.061667002737522125, -0.02853476069867611, 0.00405136588960886, 0.01460434403270483, 0.018286872655153275, -0.0022649322636425495, -0.00968583021312952, -0.006548065692186356, -0.012808788567781448, 0.040720123797655106, -0.06324445456266403, -0.001883353223092854, -0.015333964489400387, 0.02972719818353653, -0.02078889310359955, 0.03350622579455376, -0.007873249240219593, 0.005265667103230953, 0.07037424296140671, -0.036296673119068146, 0.05274682119488716, -0.007338320836424828, 0.02474445104598999, 0.005623368546366692, -0.020197371020913124, -0.03087347373366356, 0.0527772530913353, 0.04307509958744049, -0.003403034759685397, -0.03717552125453949, -0.0074177817441523075, -0.05650859698653221, 0.010768950916826725, -0.013371340930461884, -0.018711891025304794, -0.0027220859192311764, 0.0014957800740376115, -0.002675269730389118, 0.01760171726346016, -0.0264088436961174, 0.0230740737169981, 0.021739020943641663, 0.03246532008051872, -0.004314304329454899, 0.03962896019220352, -0.03924044966697693, 0.03291879594326019, 0.004543001763522625, 0.027943527325987816, -0.00018117681611329317, 0.00005426054121926427, 0.017015419900417328, 0.03161737322807312, 0.04290950298309326, 0.029800621792674065, -0.01812908612191677, 0.008028649725019932, -0.031813718378543854, 0.020125336945056915, 0.028191547840833664, 0.010732030496001244, 0.02142413519322872, 0.05661001428961754, 0.02654764987528324, -0.03654179349541664, 0.023776549845933914, 0.00843271054327488, 0.02990962378680706, 0.01816089265048504, 0.007099455688148737, -0.04178653284907341, -0.04362049698829651, -0.008525844663381577, 0.05411909893155098, -0.05577053502202034, 0.015781033784151077, -0.07143127173185349, -0.04743067920207977, -0.018289269879460335, -0.0008493424975313246, 0.025558581575751305, 0.018669137731194496, 0.01736125908792019, 0.011406810022890568, 0.006787617225199938, -0.06383005529642105, -0.01615011878311634, 0.020703861489892006, 0.03836309164762497, 0.05655781924724579, 0.05045185983181, -0.024283520877361298, 0.007937821559607983, -0.023623201996088028, -0.04479394108057022, 0.005211243871599436, 0.05136837065219879, 0.008906536735594273, -0.019913095980882645, 0.0624106228351593, 0.05632321536540985, -0.0032322052866220474, 0.03775107115507126, -0.03066696785390377, 0.030674930661916733, -0.004625450819730759, -0.09123227745294571, -0.03839120641350746, 0.06479678303003311, -0.03415410593152046, 0.016351083293557167, -0.03770015388727188, -0.04869810864329338, -0.005200064741075039, 0.04251598194241524, -0.005559713114053011, 0.00230364128947258, 0.034527480602264404, -0.007402072194963694, 0.013257615268230438, -0.006410074420273304, -0.00697358138859272, -0.03022269532084465, -0.025279950350522995, -0.03961137682199478, -0.06391879916191101, 0.03110734559595585, -0.0007769537623971701, -0.025703713297843933, 0.01184797566384077, 0.02797333523631096, 0.01322918850928545, 0.027648242190480232, -0.02892102673649788, -0.0335499607026577, -0.0074252537451684475, 0.049744103103876114, 0.006919502280652523, 0.020220322534441948, 0.006312977056950331, -0.012200863100588322, 0.06075448915362358, -0.015729300677776337, 0.010542462579905987, 0.0050941635854542255, -0.03715561702847481, 0.03121786005795002, -0.012795582413673401, -0.009237573482096195, 0.03744274377822876, -0.02855939045548439, -0.04867252707481384, 0.01588270254433155, -0.0132200438529253, 0.06431084871292114, 0.01231159083545208, 0.0033231095876544714, -0.0242344681173563, 0.05504138022661209, -0.02787376195192337, -0.05097096040844917, -0.09637764096260071, -0.0024008378386497498, 0.01571454294025898, -0.028699638321995735, -0.020966308191418648, 0.010579317808151245, 0.03491176292300224, 0.025561336427927017, -0.011774271726608276, -0.05425351858139038, 0.005937367212027311, 0.014564959332346916, -0.013127698563039303, -0.04987085238099098, 0.030316170305013657, 0.028165536001324654, -0.005738312844187021, 0.08501356095075607, -0.025757161900401115, 0.02729521133005619, 0.0157516747713089, 0.002967261476442218, 0.002395019633695483, -0.014441665261983871, -0.017733735963702202, 0.007845450192689896, 0.04287414625287056, -0.046488288789987564, 0.04293366149067879, -0.10602322965860367, 0.021171581000089645, 0.06441964954137802, -0.008049087598919868, 0.04126651585102081, -0.010305045172572136, -0.017695803195238113, 0.047866303473711014, -0.054998140782117844, -0.026377186179161072, -0.0622992105782032, -0.018729349598288536, 0.02742663025856018, -0.007422163616865873, -0.00789343100041151, -0.0071036783047020435, 0.028911514207720757, -0.002437748247757554, 0.03309856355190277, 0.05608609318733215, 0.022298697382211685, -0.00831995252519846, 0.032479893416166306, -0.0006696026539430022, 0.027429023757576942, 0.0081656314432621, 0.0550067201256752, -0.05065673217177391, 0.03485964983701706, -0.026861965656280518, 0.01562592200934887, 0.032868076115846634, -0.005614440888166428, -0.030456092208623886, -0.04638727754354477, -0.012474956922233105, 0.06284204125404358, -0.003838395932689309, 0.017697462812066078, 0.05661289393901825, 0.03678923845291138, -0.02584659308195114, -0.028519250452518463, -0.02837432734668255, 0.0053031728602945805, 0.0518193244934082, -0.02308640070259571, 0.015084723010659218, 0.033277541399002075, -0.02498149313032627, 0.04892643168568611, -0.03180399909615517, 0.0015625818632543087, -0.05932300537824631, 0.0005993966478854418, 0.012568499892950058, 0.031815167516469955, -0.026956260204315186, -0.06393183767795563, 0.0010605647694319487, -0.02290189266204834, 0.00932152010500431, 0.05376371368765831, 0.004363000392913818, -0.03224185109138489, -0.014696878381073475, -0.004164693411439657, -0.007273870054632425, 0.031041057780385017, 0.021557623520493507, -0.040727123618125916, 0.029904453083872795, 0.0220628771930933, -0.03173866868019104, -0.02074635960161686, -0.033507972955703735, -0.0023760704789310694, -0.022530782967805862, -0.010388719849288464, 0.06904134899377823, 0.021413877606391907, -0.015871407464146614, 0.017925547435879707, -0.044166404753923416, 0.0037910835817456245, -0.02994760498404503, -0.023167282342910767, 0.012754600495100021, 0.03218875825405121, -0.019890503957867622, 0.012257787398993969, -0.011570415459573269, 0.00005302249701344408, -0.034421853721141815, -0.06810130923986435, -0.01347759086638689, 0.0013790723169222474, 0.007449563592672348, 0.005844677798449993, 0.027798455208539963, 0.07356438040733337, 0.05625971034169197, 0.006805185694247484, -0.057728011161088943, -0.04697265848517418, -0.06713104993104935, -0.03039884753525257, 0.004980625119060278, -0.01796010136604309, 0.028241761028766632, 0.009137538261711597, -0.027454107999801636, 0.047080397605895996, 0.053749196231365204, -0.00976610742509365, -0.03601491451263428, 0.059214454144239426, 0.03247878700494766, -0.04100434482097626, 0.040231022983789444, 0.017967188730835915, -0.004118216689676046, -0.007708837278187275, 0.018848400563001633, -0.02450741082429886, -0.02053132653236389, -0.036191098392009735, 0.006521682720631361, -0.03510713949799538, 0.059023890644311905, 0.0072304243221879005, -0.004620020277798176, 0.02312065102159977, -0.017197957262396812, -0.018539732322096825, -0.028607375919818878, 0.09426046162843704, -0.03686301410198212, -0.005599513184279203, 0.039842639118433, 0.021835345774888992, -0.037660494446754456, 0.03101426176726818, -0.01081908494234085, -0.002388848690316081, 0.016061242669820786, -0.004521650727838278, -0.026568256318569183, 0.009603756479918957, 0.02397286333143711, 0.00007595714851049706, 0.012760425917804241, -0.023006945848464966, -0.026710161939263344, -0.023264676332473755, 0.012551565654575825, -0.015481950715184212, 0.050482433289289474, 0.0041293371468782425, 0.017450468614697456, 0.012781213037669659, -0.006794468965381384, -0.009866955690085888, 0.021096643060445786, -0.05672842636704445, 0.02331557497382164, 0.024873366579413414, -0.006019299849867821, 0.02872317284345627, -0.037014469504356384, 0.010329077951610088, 0.018206248059868813, 0.020427074283361435, 0.012964692898094654, 0.012139320373535156, -0.005247946362942457, 0.018891751766204834, -0.003245376516133547, -0.0038813557475805283, -0.041532568633556366, 0.033654481172561646, 0.0230926014482975, 0.007366643752902746, 0.007436684798449278, 0.04900597035884857, -0.029389215633273125, -0.011960603296756744, -0.04643413797020912, -0.026129260659217834, 0.043118834495544434, 0.02579759806394577, 0.004148035775870085, 0.020695418119430542, -0.02067621238529682, -0.007777985651046038, -0.0073036146350204945, 0.024629510939121246, 0.03619024530053139, 0.05093906447291374, 0.0002872515469789505, -0.0003520035243127495, -0.04385212063789368, 0.03353556618094444, 0.03425246477127075, -0.016807321459054947, 0.012088976800441742, 0.0204312801361084, 0.031616222113370895, -0.03660096600651741, 0.0023916778154671192, 0.013592810370028019, 0.016767162829637527, 0.01010757777839899, -0.03728577494621277, 0.0049112699925899506, -0.016685109585523605, 0.01013257447630167, 0.009502517059445381, 0.013230233453214169, -0.015764452517032623, -0.01650332100689411, 0.014429165050387383, 0.010646686889231205, -0.02302180975675583, 0.02645040489733219, -0.011463435366749763, -0.00013258514809422195, -0.05262324586510658, -0.040387365967035294, -0.0014881807146593928, 0.024571139365434647, 0.007109814323484898, 0.002263403031975031, -0.013944074511528015, -0.06049244850873947, -0.023618018254637718, 0.016715358942747116, 0.054496441036462784, 0.003201576415449381, -0.034171462059020996, -0.07013950496912003, -0.030252350494265556, -0.017408467829227448, -0.02568756602704525, -0.0020800114143639803, -0.03542499244213104, -0.010084765963256359, -0.027340516448020935, -0.040798112750053406, -0.07377727329730988, 0.01683169975876808, -0.03838024288415909, 0.015283707529306412, 0.02264292910695076, -0.03872956335544586, -0.02136954665184021, -0.017866656184196472, -0.014133842661976814, 0.054743994027376175, -0.02522364817559719, -0.0030324035324156284, 0.032403819262981415, -0.006467232946306467, -0.07309454679489136, -0.006210900377482176, 0.009605253115296364, -0.006295862141996622, 0.03418479859828949, 0.060401659458875656, -0.013322535902261734, 0.0036157609429210424, 0.0376252606511116, 0.04778614640235901, 0.016567012295126915, -0.017655912786722183, -0.010028845630586147, 0.00020147813484072685, 0.04890694469213486, -0.003501839004456997, 0.08094421774148941, 0.022680064663290977, -0.027543671429157257, 0.022908883169293404, -0.05842815712094307, 0.006448027212172747, -0.010339285247027874, -0.05347355455160141, -0.05449175089597702, -0.002117452211678028, 0.003921759780496359, 0.009335569106042385, 0.0227370485663414, 0.018687183037400246, -0.05653085932135582, 0.008296550251543522, 0.0006539943860843778, 0.020464107394218445, -0.046775173395872116, -0.007261363323777914, -0.011914113536477089, 0.01964138261973858, 0.007333139423280954, 0.013231875374913216, 0.029915153980255127, -0.00887226965278387, -0.006920581683516502, -0.01566682942211628, -0.037815943360328674, 0.006818084977567196, -0.03551146760582924, -0.015834642574191093, 0.010484245605766773, -0.036503974348306656, 0.002475842833518982, 0.018032729625701904, 0.05334101989865303, -0.017197446897625923, -0.022410158067941666, -0.03679664433002472, 0.029933510348200798, 0.00875060260295868, 0.008078595623373985, -0.03282460197806358, 0.060051329433918, -0.016399269923567772, 0.021971415728330612, -0.07975053042173386, 0.005002240184694529, 0.00968796294182539, 0.0019883825443685055, -0.03598840907216072, -0.03193114325404167, -0.07082532346248627, 0.015675013884902, -0.0002665544452611357, -0.03921474143862724, 0.04140747711062431, -0.05002174898982048, 0.03098429925739765, 0.02826627716422081, -0.028022222220897675, 0.06649257987737656, 0.008288048207759857, 0.006190228275954723, -0.011963793076574802, -0.03819744288921356, -0.015157034620642662, -0.009027482010424137, -0.013239256106317043, -0.038693781942129135, -0.03699396550655365, -0.008248874917626381, 0.04267078638076782, 0.035481858998537064, 0.012945604510605335, -0.015266158618032932, -0.026155604049563408, -0.0091828228905797, -0.004824894946068525, -0.04980044439435005, -0.026598738506436348, -0.0014818074414506555, -0.029065478593111038, -0.03210396319627762, 0.04371177405118942, 0.004384762141853571, -0.006051037926226854, 0.017873095348477364, -0.012288385070860386, 0.013946045190095901, -0.03443276509642601, 0.06121623143553734, -0.012660551816225052, -0.014930100180208683, 0.015274915844202042, 0.010531867854297161, 0.058341048657894135, -0.035739634186029434, -0.015784738585352898, -0.015001458115875721, 0.02416837215423584, -0.023531338199973106, -0.016189351677894592, -0.010069342330098152, 0.04484850540757179, 0.01600979082286358, 0.026166124269366264, 0.007022016681730747, 0.020899083465337753, 0.0030586961656808853, 0.03661932423710823, -0.04483306407928467, 0.004060681443661451, 0.04193124175071716, 0.004646627698093653, 0.029769781976938248, -0.0009074545814655721, -0.03142375126481056, 0.0421283133327961, -0.020650452002882957, 0.013622703962028027, 0.016604116186499596, -0.003149171592667699, -0.018080420792102814, -0.01851317286491394, -0.008618670515716076, -0.0361737422645092, 0.02555115893483162, -0.010292218066751957, 0.05303291976451874, -0.02716996893286705, -0.04868883267045021, 0.05466281995177269, 0.04843159392476082, -0.042097512632608414, -0.05801190063357353, -0.04893461614847183, -0.0689658671617508, 0.03210439532995224, 0.029215943068265915, -0.01552822720259428, 0.0319691076874733, 0.06981752067804337, 0.03311522677540779, -0.030964598059654236, -0.0030216211453080177, -0.03909387066960335, -0.026205386966466904, -0.0336088091135025, -0.046818774193525314, -0.05057871341705322, 0.033885255455970764, -0.013003361411392689, 0.014745177701115608, 0.011161794885993004, -0.010558263398706913, 0.013089546002447605, 0.0021678858902305365, 0.03140699490904808, 0.001068122568540275, 0.06966828554868698, 0.025193925946950912, -0.004072751384228468, -0.0345415361225605, 0.002166847698390484, 0.17298193275928497, 0.07578801363706589, 0.009662508033216, -0.08242663741111755, 0.045615054666996, 0.05257050320506096, -0.003891538828611374, 0.00568024069070816, -0.04193628951907158, 0.044665440917015076, -0.015855979174375534, 0.027736974880099297, -0.006233035121113062, 0.009712793864309788, 0.0013543324312195182, 0.04445281997323036, -0.038218967616558075, -0.020664379000663757, -0.014112127013504505, 0.009218445047736168, -0.04034855589270592, 0.022770322859287262, -0.03520388901233673, 0.015691684558987617, 0.039022352546453476, 0.008432328701019287, -0.05127955228090286, -0.01724787801504135, -0.04587721824645996, 0.027138447389006615, -0.0030509349890053272, -0.007832376286387444, 0.0005271386471576989, 0.0007705297903157771, -0.024133913218975067, 0.00982836727052927, 0.011041857302188873, -0.026571260765194893, 0.039111312478780746, 0.04348008707165718, -0.010732036083936691, 0.030722370371222496, -0.022939547896385193, 0.017943987622857094, -0.011512170545756817, -0.060647521167993546, -0.04234061762690544, 0.08548126369714737, -0.025394929572939873, -0.03483749181032181, 0.00641448562964797, 0.014186372049152851, 0.0313500314950943, -0.033379215747117996, -0.02198787033557892, 0.010040589608252048, 0.018353719264268875, -0.034627992659807205, -0.03262436017394066, -0.022784998640418053, 0.01200740784406662, 0.004766861908137798, 0.013936648145318031, 0.005496801808476448, -0.018178194761276245, -0.01222748588770628, -0.05114766210317612, 0.053302064538002014, 0.013609801419079304, 0.03425402566790581, 0.02065681293606758, -0.01615496724843979, 0.006539409980177879, -0.025903834030032158, -0.047009699046611786, 0.025245798751711845, 0.00975212175399065, -0.00047333029215224087, -0.035883594304323196, -0.005360287148505449, -0.019751429557800293, 0.027239657938480377, -0.017376186326146126, -0.008649475872516632, 0.0035924811381846666, -0.02803886868059635, -0.002598160644993186, 0.04853103309869766, 0.02087036520242691, 0.03630223125219345, 0.00036853092024102807, 0.04941053315997124, 0.0018696899060159922, -0.03272014483809471, -0.006787190679460764, 0.005941867362707853, -0.017572812736034393, 0.02640419267117977, 0.0018289918079972267, 0.06687948107719421, 0.005156092811375856, 0.022978534922003746, 0.016318509355187416, 0.0449540838599205, -0.00996793620288372, 0.007689208257943392, 0.017906446009874344, -0.016218623146414757, 0.011057230643928051, -0.0005494218203239143, -0.014420116320252419, -0.025694308802485466, -0.046439532190561295, -0.039547551423311234, -0.049029912799596786, -0.016827234998345375, -0.043311361223459244, -0.04604959487915039, 0.0039818743243813515, -0.042301446199417114, -0.0016318323323503137, -0.031305547803640366, 0.006165905389934778, -0.028437837958335876, -0.055695533752441406, -0.0011429524747654796, -0.008462700992822647, -0.007112546358257532, -0.024625442922115326, -0.005199054721742868, 0.03249542415142059, 0.025159895420074463, -0.031490229070186615, 0.01994926482439041, -0.01782638393342495, 0.008894119411706924, 0.02709966152906418, 0.05227726697921753, 0.038629576563835144, 0.014394695870578289, 0.01048965472728014, -0.019275587052106857, -0.03517097234725952, 0.010979987680912018, -0.0059756631962955, 0.03993914648890495, 0.0005360064096748829, -0.0027891986537724733, 0.012759680859744549, 0.07130619138479233, -0.007539082784205675, 0.025075968354940414, -0.010192068293690681, 0.015095511451363564, 0.038645174354314804, 0.0016164795961230993, 0.012018093839287758, 0.022581759840250015, -0.017182769253849983, -0.01186967920511961, 0.027559097856283188, -0.00028853153344243765, -0.00006268681318033487, 0.012985242530703545, -0.0498388446867466, 0.01636660099029541, -0.011738399975001812, -0.011202475987374783, 0.010641336441040039, 0.051902055740356445, 0.008106539957225323, 0.03557494282722473, -0.03289000317454338, 0.018709948286414146, -0.05706819146871567, 0.00032466204720549285, -0.008311823941767216, -0.005842336919158697, 0.03121514432132244, -0.03781106695532799, 0.0021965703926980495, 0.05047265812754631, -0.04100439324975014, 0.006433668080717325, 0.038190197199583054, 0.022075923159718513, -0.03671763464808464, 0.017223848029971123, -0.021181048825383186, -0.022390348836779594, 0.034091588109731674, -0.015445815399289131, 0.013938597403466702, 0.034615855664014816, 0.022495074197649956, -0.05642100051045418, -0.0026704745832830667, 0.04698983579874039, 0.03715047240257263, -0.05226272717118263, 0.03259187936782837, -0.01580393873155117, 0.016330992802977562, -0.011020475067198277, -0.009632688015699387, 0.026959801092743874, 0.03409517556428909, 0.019974254071712494, 0.008813297376036644, 0.059421468526124954, -0.0029643282759934664, 0.02644134685397148, 0.005760842468589544, 0.004823045805096626, 0.013284943997859955, -0.010536707006394863, -0.01498956885188818, 0.003675503423437476, 0.01636367477476597, 0.006633484270423651, -0.031070340424776077, 0.03251437097787857, -0.023867378011345863, 0.002485089236870408, -0.03574462607502937, -0.014309100806713104, 0.008110661059617996, -0.0604684017598629, -0.01720772124826908, -0.0082998713478446, 0.04679223522543907, 0.04561423137784004, -0.00669182138517499, -0.05843710899353027, -0.013813628815114498, 0.002208481542766094, -0.018871279433369637, -0.03270294517278671, -0.00564301572740078, 0.0015200135530903935, -0.03864974528551102, -0.0032751739490777254, -0.015238289721310139, -0.0007574036135338247, -0.01924999989569187, 0.047090381383895874, -0.06823520362377167, 0.024886632338166237, 0.011409791186451912, -0.01997470110654831, 0.00028064250363968313, 0.01119103655219078, 0.03998401388525963, -0.07055094838142395, 0.06377942115068436, 0.027020659297704697, -0.009817962534725666, -0.07967598736286163, -0.052035361528396606, -0.0054744877852499485, 0.05844179168343544, 0.015065677464008331, 0.0023341269697993994, -0.007312340661883354, 0.010845927521586418, 0.04614052176475525, 0.009097376838326454, -0.0332057811319828, 0.03613036870956421, 0.009299295023083687, -0.015589877031743526, 0.018352748826146126, 0.02827388420701027, 0.02487887069582939, 0.013107910752296448, -0.03417018800973892, -0.0018267222912982106, 0.004350558388978243, -0.00015466670447494835, -0.014127603732049465, -0.007168521173298359, -0.04132963344454765, -0.016487212851643562, 0.01955762505531311, 0.0144630903378129, 0.040021397173404694, 0.03286883980035782, -0.03701610863208771, -0.015594348311424255, 0.017489301040768623, -0.06281739473342896, 0.02321688085794449, 0.03477087989449501, 0.01651182398200035, 0.01276418473571539, -0.04834328964352608, 0.03762740641832352, -0.04106598347425461, -0.008763392455875874, 0.00017380806093569845, 0.03254753723740578, 0.0019774979446083307, 0.03343937546014786, -0.04637229070067406, 0.03873901814222336, -0.02676776796579361, 0.0031580219510942698, 0.024342278018593788, 0.037832070142030716, -0.028100166469812393, -0.04084644839167595, -0.0203289482742548, 0.009040064178407192, 0.0002439747186144814, 0.029370004311203957, 0.017606018111109734, 0.04905306175351143, 0.018869420513510704, 0.019674792885780334, 0.010120675899088383, 0.014418919570744038, -0.004086342640221119, -0.003284718841314316, 0.0053865499794483185, 0.018562156707048416, -0.01531851664185524, -0.004552516154944897, -0.036479633301496506, -0.021394629031419754, -0.019681550562381744, 0.017270542681217194, 0.006505902856588364, 0.058681387454271317, -0.010386606678366661, 0.04545890539884567, -0.008406804874539375, 0.018851488828659058, 0.026402609422802925, -0.0022751293145120144, 0.001820187084376812, 0.007492501754313707, -0.01056161429733038, 0.014998633414506912, 0.022999107837677002, -0.006686168257147074, -0.01878071203827858, 0.03310853987932205, 0.023958353325724602, 0.011350185610353947, -0.038676872849464417, 0.002408671658486128, 0.029454778879880905, 0.04524795711040497, -0.026808597147464752, -0.008735648356378078, -0.017630472779273987, 0.027636440470814705, 0.013630736619234085, -0.022602567449212074 ]
<p>I'm doing a Support Vector Regression with about 70k samples with 500 features each. I'm using sklearn implementation of SVR and my input for the train set is a sparse matrix. But, for my surprise, the training with Linear Kernel is taking a huge amount of time, a lot more than the training with RBF Kernel.</p> <p>Does someone have a hint of why that happens? For me it seems that this is against intuition, given that RBF Kernel distances seem more expensive to calculate. </p>
73,604
[ -0.02264944650232792, 0.03282805532217026, -0.007111125625669956, -0.0012703819666057825, 0.018831511959433556, -0.018081877380609512, 0.010746906511485577, -0.023702628910541534, 0.03530175983905792, 0.021467572078108788, 0.01882047764956951, 0.04148081690073013, 0.055484969168901443, -0.027882367372512817, 0.005904695950448513, -0.008283194154500961, 0.0007707216427661479, -0.013009215705096722, 0.01031087152659893, -0.019749019294977188, 0.012636706233024597, 0.018428336828947067, 0.03687005117535591, -0.00486726313829422, -0.003823834005743265, 0.03793981671333313, -0.01678251475095749, -0.005723316688090563, 0.024981100112199783, 0.022860286757349968, -0.03896890580654144, -0.017488671466708183, 0.022681282833218575, 0.005014464724808931, 0.051467929035425186, -0.014900656417012215, -0.039869967848062515, -0.053209397941827774, -0.016845226287841797, 0.03270581737160683, 0.007551518734544516, -0.013428036123514175, 0.0037124110385775566, 0.06777022778987885, 0.017228098586201668, 0.04883497208356857, 0.03799295797944069, -0.039459697902202606, 0.011751686222851276, -0.01494603417813778, 0.047192592173814774, -0.031108757480978966, 0.028394944965839386, 0.039148177951574326, -0.015091927722096443, 0.019813617691397667, 0.030792096629738808, 0.06321924179792404, -0.006407866254448891, -0.013861443847417831, 0.02261190116405487, -0.030624935403466225, -0.017229434102773666, -0.016917455941438675, -0.022891880944371223, 0.05001293495297432, 0.0065095750615000725, 0.0026119158137589693, 0.01838814653456211, -0.025184545665979385, 0.007973178289830685, 0.01106264628469944, 0.040276866406202316, -0.026524970307946205, 0.0013287882320582867, 0.00045849953312426805, -0.012958425097167492, 0.026156773790717125, 0.06143860146403313, 0.013078932650387287, 0.012148515321314335, 0.02354354038834572, 0.020536214113235474, 0.016944780945777893, 0.028891446068882942, -0.01581134833395481, 0.03749902546405792, 0.02172081544995308, -0.00032609180198051035, 0.034733597189188004, -0.0009422822040505707, 0.030763009563088417, 0.07705708593130112, 0.01300225779414177, -0.029174234718084335, 0.011653074994683266, -0.021023815497756004, 0.03621126711368561, 0.053604304790496826, -0.0237750131636858, -0.024731632322072983, -0.022141264751553535, -0.008740236051380634, 0.0421430766582489, -0.012984362430870533, -0.025350619107484818, -0.042875323444604874, 0.02270909771323204, -0.02015242539346218, -0.004998044576495886, -0.0471402183175087, -0.014214137569069862, -0.014234860427677631, 0.009074426256120205, 0.01344970054924488, -0.029814673587679863, -0.03417849913239479, -0.005442430730909109, 0.023072747513651848, 0.06281768530607224, -0.008572259917855263, -0.028858093544840813, 0.02172802947461605, -0.061269719153642654, -0.01662413962185383, 0.045007623732089996, 0.025445403531193733, -0.0523669458925724, -0.042051225900650024, 0.03784382715821266, -0.0033043527510017157, -0.044234395027160645, 0.03223121911287308, -0.048011790961027145, -0.0009420364513061941, -0.0008688608650118113, -0.0955774337053299, -0.06420491635799408, 0.04243763908743858, 0.0026710527017712593, 0.02997291088104248, -0.04168378561735153, 0.020144637674093246, -0.003572130808606744, 0.05160541832447052, 0.028587793931365013, 0.035626936703920364, 0.06524205207824707, -0.008661874569952488, -0.01782223954796791, -0.01517676655203104, -0.022861052304506302, -0.02125883288681507, 0.01377312745898962, -0.005950470454990864, -0.049404438585042953, -0.007943065837025642, -0.009329142980277538, -0.013541008345782757, -0.0021762335672974586, 0.009628559462726116, 0.015099036507308483, -0.006480542477220297, -0.0001718878629617393, 0.005061727948486805, -0.04891187697649002, 0.044608939439058304, 0.0077958968468010426, 0.06083114072680473, 0.02512430027127266, -0.04765171557664871, -0.002569792326539755, 0.04447360336780548, 0.02855922095477581, 0.025478368625044823, -0.00323244440369308, -0.01624898612499237, 0.003460618434473872, 0.024929197505116463, 0.014168080873787403, -0.07990497350692749, -0.08012823015451431, 0.0065009696409106255, 0.03069051168859005, 0.024303527548909187, 0.0904109925031662, -0.0003588661493267864, -0.04919738322496414, 0.008162470534443855, -0.04055047035217285, -0.031394634395837784, -0.041694678366184235, 0.01867663487792015, 0.00782040785998106, -0.017764676362276077, 0.0453655906021595, 0.001179512939415872, -0.012375283986330032, 0.0018352949991822243, -0.03776297718286514, -0.005430171731859446, -0.01969730295240879, 0.03761794790625572, -0.0317835733294487, 0.003476287703961134, 0.03873246908187866, 0.02257574163377285, -0.03161481395363808, 0.03348327800631523, -0.026668628677725792, -0.05815441533923149, 0.027944477275013924, -0.0024169981479644775, -0.008353679440915585, -0.03073345310986042, 0.0010351549135521054, 0.02997855469584465, 0.02930654026567936, -0.010242767632007599, 0.022001974284648895, -0.04049172252416611, 0.051584161818027496, 0.042084161192178726, 0.020251668989658356, 0.004650288727134466, 0.00493892515078187, -0.006251221522688866, -0.01937446929514408, -0.00637897988781333, -0.010647847317159176, -0.01428388711065054, -0.0325886495411396, 0.05166440084576607, 0.03257497772574425, -0.04530799016356468, 0.01177256740629673, 0.06689558178186417, 0.03475881367921829, 0.045758333057165146, 0.010870484635233879, -0.02114584669470787, -0.01970795728266239, 0.042258571833372116, 0.0001960899098776281, -0.012975708581507206, -0.03979095444083214, -0.027143023908138275, -0.013973635621368885, 0.0324501171708107, -0.007253107149153948, -0.036443013697862625, 0.04357975721359253, 0.007843106985092163, -0.01042489055544138, 0.004555718041956425, -0.022293152287602425, 0.029254112392663956, 0.0021480987779796124, -0.05015011131763458, 0.051612913608551025, -0.011153782717883587, 0.07311392575502396, -0.03294086083769798, -0.011503924615681171, 0.04248449206352234, 0.009704956784844398, -0.04105932638049126, 0.01256556622684002, 0.023269711062312126, -0.08845356851816177, 0.016240736469626427, -0.0298770722001791, -0.0051740375347435474, -0.04444042965769768, 0.01378879975527525, 0.06921718269586563, -0.004978165961802006, 0.04196533188223839, 0.004636997822672129, 0.004843845497816801, 0.0382876917719841, -0.06070340424776077, 0.06670033931732178, -0.024543577805161476, -0.04107951000332832, 0.015971647575497627, -0.01607908308506012, -0.03499899059534073, 0.053689874708652496, -0.013091105036437511, 0.005146568641066551, -0.011595889925956726, -0.02388475090265274, -0.06403061747550964, -0.03072076477110386, -0.03815561160445213, 0.034363046288490295, 0.027674255892634392, 0.012461659498512745, 0.05581226944923401, -0.024183304980397224, -0.061342474073171616, 0.015876827761530876, 0.0058595240116119385, -0.010066386312246323, -0.04430291801691055, -0.02414664626121521, -0.0035684590693563223, -0.017423653975129128, -0.030854221433401108, 0.04612848535180092, 0.0022006244398653507, 0.027803821489214897, -0.054387278854846954, -0.010812722146511078, 0.02305041439831257, -0.006223165430128574, 0.025939036160707474, 0.028991280123591423, 0.011524044908583164, 0.0761534571647644, 0.046204421669244766, -0.012044394388794899, -0.04098065569996834, -0.012391624040901661, -0.07720629125833511, -0.013568948023021221, 0.025055253878235817, 0.01319565437734127, 0.0349251925945282, 0.02913763001561165, -0.021785918623209, 0.015639428049325943, 0.07598132640123367, -0.02384408935904503, -0.022848306223750114, 0.014931570738554, -0.0426902137696743, -0.021514389663934708, 0.05145815759897232, 0.005513605661690235, -0.04529499635100365, 0.006056779995560646, 0.012216753326356411, -0.004442283418029547, 0.002661540638655424, -0.05082768574357033, -0.011412721127271652, -0.03509260714054108, 0.03967072442173958, -0.03116605617105961, -0.005524442531168461, 0.01948097161948681, -0.03036736324429512, 0.013762912712991238, 0.016660548746585846, 0.042687807232141495, -0.04086471349000931, 0.020572898909449577, 0.009435521438717842, 0.03668929263949394, -0.011013093404471874, 0.023567698895931244, -0.016317958012223244, -0.03224307671189308, 0.007131887134164572, 0.002952459966763854, -0.02535010501742363, 0.028432928025722504, 0.022434081882238388, -0.003609901061281562, -0.017673108726739883, -0.06288852542638779, 0.017129624262452126, -0.07083727419376373, -0.00528324069455266, 0.016335006803274155, 0.060618698596954346, 0.02660061977803707, 0.02095876634120941, 0.02627827227115631, -0.047315094619989395, -0.00929733831435442, -0.018163476139307022, -0.04038195312023163, -0.0006169714615680277, -0.027303822338581085, -0.02543295919895172, 0.01094669010490179, -0.02170470729470253, -0.004487418103963137, -0.0423770472407341, 0.005716540385037661, -0.004234268795698881, 0.03200029581785202, -0.05898771807551384, 0.015741175040602684, 0.0079688411206007, 0.008548873476684093, -0.036231908947229385, -0.02659159153699875, -0.00044274196261540055, -0.02299295738339424, 0.0183392446488142, 0.0336657278239727, -0.029262548312544823, 0.006948089227080345, -0.010852360166609287, 0.03086199052631855, 0.012990742921829224, 0.042053040117025375, 0.008310705423355103, 0.010918375104665756, -0.04519732668995857, 0.006586846895515919, -0.0008474307833239436, 0.024104557931423187, 0.04915052279829979, -0.004121649079024792, -0.006510942243039608, -0.0685858204960823, -0.03579535335302353, 0.005022326949983835, 0.0018685554387047887, -0.01801396533846855, 0.022843314334750175, 0.0075799524784088135, 0.02651948668062687, -0.038144953548908234, -0.020066438242793083, 0.04708860442042351, 0.0013609669404104352, -0.021466752514243126, -0.05491858348250389, -0.016394685953855515, 0.007256549317389727, -0.02192792296409607, 0.03202362731099129, -0.009998598136007786, -0.021570192649960518, -0.03176000341773033, 0.05844650790095329, -0.06819339096546173, -0.016917942091822624, 0.014706573449075222, 0.05056091398000717, 0.018015338107943535, -0.013480822555720806, -0.012819579802453518, 0.007445040158927441, 0.057866424322128296, 0.04880191758275032, 0.028526386246085167, 0.025539303198456764, -0.058349352329969406, -0.008537202142179012, 0.04381779581308365, 0.02360474318265915, -0.043001193553209305, -0.011382627300918102, -0.03593888878822327, -0.022095143795013428, 0.06002949923276901, -0.021842490881681442, 0.05958790332078934, -0.0011873769108206034, -0.008188184350728989, -0.03311308100819588, -0.025340724736452103, -0.031466782093048096, 0.021872853860259056, -0.015849685296416283, 0.04505688697099686, -0.02256382629275322, -0.0431176982820034, -0.030170850455760956, 0.017009807750582695, 0.034732770174741745, 0.039299774914979935, 0.006201200652867556, -0.014843456447124481, 0.016780415549874306, 0.035172272473573685, 0.007773652672767639, -0.06455832719802856, 0.011339928023517132, 0.0026509505696594715, -0.022053522989153862, 0.026911353692412376, -0.014591196551918983, -0.035399630665779114, 0.022083107382059097, 0.03478134050965309, -0.02764955349266529, -0.03794882446527481, -0.03697174787521362, -0.006418284494429827, 0.05331889167428017, 0.023045048117637634, 0.053106144070625305, 0.02991035021841526, -0.0118041280657053, 0.01007295772433281, -0.02567763440310955, 0.011627569794654846, -0.01282371673732996, -0.03467265143990517, 0.010598170571029186, -0.02582128718495369, -0.025235723704099655, 0.0397503487765789, 0.03416182100772858, 0.05552038550376892, -0.02597532793879509, 0.013812963850796223, -0.017954746261239052, 0.035386018455028534, -0.022681932896375656, -0.033151935786008835, -0.01592233218252659, 0.03671754151582718, 0.007260342128574848, -0.014596307650208473, -0.008951911702752113, 0.0036620870232582092, 0.024306535720825195, 0.037805598229169846, -0.011433699168264866, -0.016550928354263306, -0.03260794281959534, -0.0036877477541565895, -0.004802819807082415, -0.015974367037415504, 0.05177028477191925, 0.0004592097830027342, 0.009439429268240929, 0.011527596041560173, -0.025476064532995224, -0.0004884084919467568, -0.0033741777297109365, -0.03667248785495758, 0.030857449397444725, -0.0727328360080719, 0.026374028995633125, 0.0034853341057896614, -0.016189707443118095, -0.08467426896095276, -0.05785860866308212, 0.026044687256217003, -0.010339399799704552, -0.04284624382853508, -0.054619647562503815, 0.010349573567509651, 0.0005404776311479509, -0.00618717959150672, -0.0023444825783371925, 0.030528677627444267, -0.034592464566230774, -0.0014433960895985365, -0.015529603697359562, -0.01968892477452755, 0.01950157806277275, -0.022562365978956223, 0.013423796743154526, -0.004290302284061909, 0.011818037368357182, -0.02331552281975746, -0.0013417551526799798, 0.03971860557794571, -0.02970055863261223, 0.004213554318994284, -0.03854208439588547, -0.024230467155575752, 0.04876648634672165, 0.009496047161519527, 0.007165703922510147, 0.016103852540254593, -0.0015109434025362134, 0.03587708622217178, -0.00947563536465168, 0.012323401868343353, 0.03047250770032406, -0.02160128392279148, 0.020805584266781807, -0.018690040335059166, -0.007193527650088072, -0.02022191882133484, 0.012597398832440376, 0.01861545629799366, 0.005755266174674034, -0.016143755987286568, 0.07898358255624771, -0.05097202956676483, 0.02193283848464489, 0.000041400409827474505, -0.016687138006091118, 0.01944621279835701, 0.008051036857068539, 0.031012162566184998, -0.009258209727704525, 0.019702186807990074, -0.02693897858262062, 0.017824796959757805, -0.023499157279729843, 0.0039077200926840305, 0.0429471880197525, -0.02510599046945572, 0.0364142544567585, 0.041934240609407425, -0.0016637122025713325, -0.005180969834327698, -0.05380067229270935, -0.022166002541780472, -0.022808419540524483, -0.006970271933823824, 0.04117005690932274, 0.043517015874385834, 0.0059091211296617985, 0.057460226118564606, 0.03306117281317711, 0.032393928617239, 0.03381151705980301, -0.006230026017874479, 0.03139512240886688, 0.05153987184166908, -0.01601133495569229, -0.04364607483148575, 0.003263692604377866, 0.004323595203459263, 0.03815363720059395, 0.015331159345805645, -0.013226918876171112, 0.0748935341835022, 0.009482278488576412, 0.025288190692663193, -0.03245282545685768, 0.002459319308400154, -0.02235242910683155, -0.008279121480882168, 0.015831515192985535, -0.0360492579638958, 0.0519428625702858, 0.0383966863155365, 0.008986110799014568, 0.02462298981845379, 0.02692596986889839, -0.015227251686155796, -0.03882734477519989, -0.024019921198487282, -0.061611637473106384, -0.035845011472702026, 0.035842571407556534, -0.0047202459536492825, -0.05776956304907799, -0.00005704695649910718, -0.022035669535398483, 0.04334643483161926, -0.004934063646942377, 0.024680418893694878, -0.0020084010902792215, 0.06862954795360565, 0.027021082118153572, -0.014699622988700867, -0.006355307064950466, -0.023875590413808823, 0.10128360241651535, 0.056030597537755966, 0.010800380259752274, -0.06646359711885452, -0.00028834561817348003, -0.025512682273983955, -0.02453521639108658, -0.037293270230293274, 0.0062633357010781765, 0.005928599275648594, -0.019474323838949203, 0.027951624244451523, 0.011903684586286545, 0.03471624478697777, 0.00011072114284615964, -0.0019174831686541438, -0.03882526978850365, 0.028825633227825165, 0.008077900856733322, -0.005133077502250671, 0.04573313891887665, 0.004213640931993723, -0.04548066481947899, 0.026692846789956093, -0.03151050955057144, -0.032529156655073166, -0.045381322503089905, -0.021092519164085388, 0.04446122795343399, -0.031181495636701584, -0.008183812722563744, 0.01456780917942524, 0.019007183611392975, -0.004584373440593481, -0.017430808395147324, 0.04185689613223076, 0.03377145156264305, -0.0020089945755898952, 0.01859627477824688, 0.04149965941905975, 0.010970543138682842, 0.021024150773882866, -0.035627659410238266, -0.023530954495072365, -0.03731098398566246, -0.018272092565894127, -0.048283182084560394, 0.06319401413202286, 0.029875298961997032, -0.005388998426496983, 0.03052838332951069, 0.017316468060016632, -0.018281247466802597, -0.05849071592092514, 0.0037678873632103205, 0.01560596190392971, 0.020384185016155243, -0.01907508820295334, -0.02526523917913437, -0.03486860543489456, 0.016279717907309532, -0.01258168090134859, 0.0062484960071742535, 0.01920493133366108, -0.03790277615189552, -0.035487204790115356, -0.00592238362878561, 0.008472341112792492, -0.022643132135272026, 0.019344700500369072, -0.021007545292377472, -0.01996256783604622, 0.016550596803426743, -0.005014971364289522, 0.06855405867099762, 0.014394134283065796, 0.006607807707041502, -0.06796997785568237, -0.03968535363674164, -0.03536302223801613, -0.052292436361312866, -0.004388662986457348, 0.01683352142572403, -0.013403677381575108, -0.0295385904610157, 0.018560165539383888, 0.01973726600408554, 0.025815369561314583, 0.024329526349902153, 0.010191340930759907, 0.022888492792844772, 0.03317973390221596, -0.012247389182448387, -0.05285999923944473, -0.02001359686255455, -0.020005803555250168, 0.005332012660801411, 0.0530693382024765, 0.0049651809968054295, 0.03890610113739967, 0.04553702473640442, 0.004417435731738806, -0.015994448214769363, 0.015942677855491638, 0.005028839223086834, 0.017736459150910378, 0.0007961103110574186, -0.04782482236623764, 0.01448229793459177, -0.015212326310575008, -0.022418076172471046, -0.04862207546830177, -0.01753847301006317, -0.035039272159338, -0.015965530648827553, -0.021610304713249207, 0.021032502874732018, -0.040593069046735764, -0.012070971541106701, -0.013269796967506409, 0.0783294215798378, -0.02860858291387558, -0.007271625101566315, -0.04236596077680588, 0.03964301943778992, -0.03636714443564415, -0.04313954338431358, -0.02486269734799862, 0.007361867930740118, 0.005760075058788061, 0.00465413648635149, 0.02618793025612831, 0.022114045917987823, 0.03340516239404678, -0.017495356500148773, 0.02614673227071762, -0.028911812230944633, 0.03175321966409683, -0.05402827635407448, -0.024503344669938087, 0.03534575179219246, -0.050999220460653305, -0.040639810264110565, 0.05560780316591263, -0.006149095017462969, 0.022299805656075478, 0.006542739924043417, 0.016271676868200302, 0.00223879748955369, 0.08064072579145432, -0.0030729046557098627, 0.008966527879238129, -0.026764273643493652, 0.01634150743484497, 0.005290556233376265, 0.017545150592923164, -0.0021564147900789976, -0.027583979070186615, -0.01604769006371498, 0.005094157066196203, -0.0025387934874743223, -0.0723753422498703, 0.009614570066332817, -0.0223299041390419, -0.010091733187437057, 0.028678476810455322, -0.0012620151974260807, 0.015581854619085789, 0.05429135635495186, 0.011124294251203537, -0.024669934064149857, 0.0181533582508564, 0.007988203316926956, 0.0539274737238884, -0.07768133282661438, 0.005660542752593756, -0.02099790796637535, -0.011955038644373417, 0.0389169342815876, -0.053957920521497726, 0.008527007885277271, 0.08074694871902466, -0.08159587532281876, 0.01844552718102932, -0.011111739091575146, 0.005745431408286095, -0.07741937786340714, -0.003337730187922716, -0.001752465614117682, -0.013370263390243053, 0.042782437056303024, 0.024954112246632576, 0.048789214342832565, 0.049184657633304596, -0.0060289353132247925, -0.008642288856208324, -0.03880836069583893, 0.02525297924876213, -0.0309912022203207, -0.026698878034949303, 0.023789621889591217, -0.03435236215591431, -0.021249333396553993, 0.010576851665973663, -0.017342545092105865, -0.029535766690969467, 0.08951056748628616, 0.04891638830304146, 0.031072277575731277, 0.02884807623922825, 0.02595328912138939, -0.03651106357574463, 0.016930697485804558, -0.0204290971159935, 0.000309142837068066, 0.013917272910475731, -0.003320330288261175, 0.032887816429138184, -0.014567631296813488, -0.00925063993781805, 0.0020372148137539625, 0.02007286250591278, -0.02045402303338051, -0.03439423814415932, 0.0031057964079082012, 0.05549876019358635, 0.03259703144431114, -0.03724556416273117, 0.01787398010492325, -0.012673823162913322, -0.0008543109870515764, 0.0037234160117805004, 0.015115687623620033, -0.044573135673999786, 0.012178081087768078, -0.05233369395136833, -0.02231396920979023, -0.020329874008893967, -0.01976167783141136, 0.02431565150618553, -0.05989476293325424, -0.023194359615445137, 0.008380904793739319, -0.028359495103359222, -0.02412359230220318, -0.0012307107681408525, -0.021480584517121315, 0.07531248778104782, -0.010466179810464382, 0.034864798188209534, 0.03826618939638138, 0.033622998744249344, -0.015782227739691734, -0.08321855217218399, 0.044562045484781265, 0.00816661398857832, -0.033013686537742615, -0.0005282037891447544, 0.01607706770300865, -0.028430860489606857, -0.0256107859313488, 0.035118430852890015, 0.0075592719949781895, 0.010766577906906605, -0.03716161102056503, -0.019608989357948303, 0.03958125412464142, -0.00729518523439765, 0.013117006979882717, -0.004672137089073658, -0.012667059898376465, -0.007829861715435982, -0.029882235452532768, -0.0014568875776603818, 0.004744994919747114, 0.016957733780145645, 0.0026910582091659307, -0.018400080502033234, 0.012407626956701279, -0.00420672120526433, 0.022636882960796356, 0.031030362471938133, 0.0057284110225737095, 0.04897087439894676, 0.032019078731536865, 0.021436557173728943, 0.007310751359909773, 0.013447549194097519, -0.06180864945054054, 0.011614040471613407, 0.00428755022585392, -0.01071563083678484, 0.0193726047873497, 0.01574147865176201, 0.018796520307660103, -0.05448939651250839, -0.024644136428833008, 0.01225170586258173, -0.05006352439522743, -0.0011255480349063873, 0.03339064493775368, 0.004886054899543524, 0.023380570113658905, 0.01645681820809841, 0.047373365610837936, 0.011039184406399727, 0.0029886565171182156, 0.0021357859950512648, 0.01948443241417408, 0.0009846764151006937, 0.00952156912535429, 0.042332977056503296, 0.03548293188214302, -0.03806285932660103, 0.0488152839243412, -0.010022063739597797, 0.04194648191332817, -0.04613673314452171, -0.03057495877146721, -0.01211710274219513, -0.02281622216105461, 0.005397316534072161, 0.014171991497278214, -0.041332926601171494, 0.09268788248300552, -0.026793884113430977, -0.024502065032720566, -0.029226047918200493, -0.008626604452729225, -0.016496732831001282, 0.03215783089399338, 0.02081919275224209, 0.018753662705421448, -0.02503819577395916, 0.022136500105261803, -0.02132866531610489, 0.009330359287559986, 0.06271155923604965, -0.016144948080182076, 0.005925837904214859, -0.019386937841773033, -0.004459958057850599, 0.022634586319327354, 0.0031033067498356104, 0.04184843972325325, -0.013905028812587261, 0.041868530213832855, 0.07689260691404343, 0.020376665517687798, -0.015638036653399467, -0.02748100459575653, 0.004754339344799519, 0.021822771057486534, -0.05376221984624863, -0.009371635504066944, -0.021246863529086113, 0.012462208047509193, -0.031421881169080734, -0.02548201009631157 ]
<p>Let $X_1, \cdots, X_n$ be $iid$ normal random variables with unknown mean $\mu$ and known variance $\sigma^2$. How to find $E[\Phi(\bar X)]$, where $\bar X:=\frac{\sum_{i=1}^nX_i}{n}$, please? I guess the answer should be $\Phi(\mu)$. Here is how I started. Note that $Y:= \bar X$ is also normal with mean $\mu$ and variance $\frac{\sigma^2}{n}$.</p> <p>$$E[\Phi(\bar X)] = \int_{-\infty}^\infty \Phi(y) f_Y(y) dy,$$</p> <p>where $\Phi(\cdot)$ is the cdf for standard normal random variable. I could not proceed any further from here. Does anyone know what to do, please? Thank you!</p>
49,565
[ -0.004629339091479778, -0.024633942171931267, -0.006239745300263166, -0.009384248405694962, 0.036391496658325195, 0.018577227368950844, -0.026285378262400627, -0.05106442794203758, 0.023899972438812256, -0.047240324318408966, 0.07190096378326416, 0.01508217304944992, 0.08720351755619049, 0.04237686097621918, 0.026974553242325783, 0.011967108584940434, -0.040925007313489914, 0.00332852266728878, -0.018061699345707893, -0.05238489806652069, -0.000882728723809123, 0.06070946156978607, 0.008336378261446953, 0.0020884093828499317, -0.06095023825764656, 0.04486992210149765, 0.017932819202542305, -0.007497040089219809, 0.02066953480243683, 0.07601919770240784, -0.043922074139118195, -0.031570274382829666, 0.0005009643500670791, 0.04835284501314163, 0.015195420943200588, 0.02242353744804859, -0.015945279970765114, -0.04795931652188301, 0.008451339788734913, -0.0013530449941754341, -0.054301366209983826, -0.03200158476829529, 0.03320517763495445, 0.028090182691812515, -0.037954892963171005, 0.017599746584892273, -0.0007018179749138653, -0.0410151407122612, 0.027583278715610504, -0.06271879374980927, 0.12350590527057648, -0.014085019007325172, 0.0468817874789238, 0.013810604810714722, 0.0024752954486757517, -0.04140397161245346, 0.0062826150096952915, 0.03954711928963661, -0.004658587276935577, -0.05510125309228897, 0.013618549332022667, -0.07961535453796387, -0.014612264931201935, -0.012982392683625221, -0.016937950626015663, 0.008730608969926834, -0.016408490017056465, -0.0315384678542614, 0.018933622166514397, -0.006726567167788744, 0.01285589300096035, 0.059754371643066406, 0.0463433638215065, -0.03619394451379776, -0.0052354102954268456, -0.0048591517843306065, 0.015706004574894905, -0.012691729702055454, 0.033730648458004, 0.04100881516933441, 0.006110873073339462, 0.019482534378767014, 0.059923380613327026, 0.011280386708676815, 0.03153153136372566, -0.018472526222467422, 0.09547565877437592, 0.005041926167905331, 0.037400711327791214, 0.01985858380794525, 0.005852880422025919, 0.03051925264298916, 0.06283172219991684, -0.028172750025987625, -0.06901511549949646, 0.04563082009553909, -0.022099414840340614, 0.03700058534741402, 0.002290421398356557, -0.0333661325275898, 0.004739345051348209, -0.03663228824734688, 0.032627951353788376, 0.07232630252838135, -0.017303336411714554, -0.041271377354860306, -0.04264993220567703, 0.014500384218990803, -0.002946680411696434, 0.011977621354162693, -0.028582658618688583, 0.05382050573825836, -0.0464344397187233, -0.013958662748336792, 0.021218428388237953, 0.010773604735732079, -0.0088548194617033, -0.010299120098352432, 0.026923615485429764, 0.07695209980010986, 0.022085459902882576, 0.0006107719382271171, 0.041049037128686905, -0.004226070828735828, -0.04761232063174248, 0.028988365083932877, 0.03996117413043976, -0.0003752369375433773, -0.05330141633749008, 0.04813495650887489, 0.002169630955904722, -0.003268433967605233, 0.011070897802710533, 0.006939688231796026, 0.021357163786888123, -0.004565707873553038, -0.07507728040218353, -0.04851304739713669, 0.025110891088843346, -0.012004072777926922, -0.004879020620137453, -0.06396342813968658, 0.00009485334885539487, 0.03872784227132797, 0.051509883254766464, 0.007198816165328026, 0.05890781804919243, -0.013078325428068638, 0.018790602684020996, 0.010870883241295815, -0.01848706789314747, -0.036706335842609406, -0.01485433243215084, -0.023160774260759354, -0.0118221715092659, -0.051625970751047134, 0.03669050708413124, 0.026683922857046127, -0.03143668174743652, -0.041902437806129456, 0.03553066402673721, 0.022316427901387215, -0.00741759454831481, -0.04126767814159393, 0.011521205306053162, -0.03178844973444939, 0.0752313956618309, -0.012965659610927105, 0.0315885990858078, 0.02723362110555172, -0.010550787672400475, 0.007133411709219217, -0.029280463233590126, 0.05966821312904358, 0.07562075555324554, -0.03975963592529297, -0.02014649286866188, -0.037624068558216095, 0.009678641334176064, 0.019642861559987068, -0.010397478006780148, -0.021630287170410156, -0.02583523839712143, 0.01634412631392479, 0.032715797424316406, 0.034886252135038376, 0.03549377992749214, -0.03749583661556244, -0.0009406004683114588, -0.06501348316669464, -0.0353737436234951, -0.07542514055967331, -0.0019537252373993397, -0.016562320291996002, -0.037745870649814606, 0.008900877088308334, 0.030660055577754974, 0.05446712300181389, -0.01948407292366028, 0.016178414225578308, -0.01120208390057087, -0.003536614589393139, 0.029415225610136986, -0.043248437345027924, 0.0017673566471785307, 0.027434391900897026, 0.06254901736974716, -0.002331529511138797, 0.019753195345401764, -0.04353410378098488, -0.025367816910147667, -0.01789710856974125, -0.040346719324588776, 0.010199317708611488, 0.0037358037661761045, -0.0038666734471917152, 0.03876469284296036, -0.02902580425143242, 0.0014297077432274818, -0.0010553078027442098, -0.028084347024559975, 0.03686671704053879, 0.04677129536867142, 0.014326822012662888, -0.004226891323924065, -0.010132377035915852, 0.029106102883815765, -0.014389189891517162, -0.040141694247722626, -0.035816095769405365, -0.03290415555238724, -0.027763407677412033, 0.027480777353048325, 0.06611219048500061, -0.031130274757742882, -0.013141090981662273, 0.060189612209796906, 0.00007429541437886655, 0.03688930347561836, 0.04222434386610985, 0.002528464188799262, -0.0269734226167202, -0.011352650821208954, 0.038341764360666275, 0.011942760087549686, 0.0339888334274292, 0.028745049610733986, 0.010339994914829731, 0.04740096628665924, 0.010725993663072586, 0.005965199321508408, 0.06671305000782013, -0.014077170751988888, 0.028325779363512993, -0.007151862606406212, -0.03289978951215744, 0.01157604344189167, -0.00582840433344245, 0.004925866611301899, 0.03548853099346161, 0.012485791929066181, 0.011275618337094784, -0.012623785994946957, -0.02089189738035202, 0.005632034037262201, 0.028419634327292442, -0.018077977001667023, 0.004953882656991482, 0.025773510336875916, -0.02046126499772072, 0.012201015837490559, -0.022608382627367973, -0.02890186198055744, 0.005815018899738789, -0.01232477929443121, -0.021694032475352287, 0.021373437717556953, -0.01675601303577423, -0.012128503993153572, -0.03926372528076172, -0.0037353811785578728, 0.01501277182251215, 0.0235595740377903, -0.0013872496783733368, -0.05215250328183174, -0.019008900970220566, 0.008563671261072159, 0.001379948458634317, 0.04084590822458267, -0.03704601898789406, -0.007835802622139454, 0.0406479574739933, 0.005009001586586237, -0.07893997430801392, 0.02512560784816742, -0.010978491976857185, 0.039614807814359665, -0.029813343659043312, -0.0075605385936796665, 0.03111332468688488, 0.010143657214939594, -0.020024210214614868, 0.04955366998910904, -0.013052860274910927, -0.030297979712486267, -0.042894262820482254, 0.028744764626026154, 0.01196447666734457, 0.002227768301963806, 0.014915886335074902, -0.0010410250397399068, -0.013553197495639324, 0.0032920162193477154, -0.06578390300273895, -0.05127162113785744, -0.004235475789755583, -0.0005168679635971785, 0.0075177280232310295, 0.003413220401853323, -0.048723459243774414, 0.07610402256250381, 0.03010600060224533, -0.04280564561486244, -0.010412130504846573, 0.009270158596336842, 0.03073395974934101, -0.04364638403058052, 0.02388094551861286, -0.01230613887310028, -0.0050244708545506, 0.04370979964733124, 0.014354304410517216, -0.009884824976325035, 0.034352194517850876, 0.01154301967471838, -0.004828889388591051, 0.027813704684376717, -0.017772072926163673, -0.003108847187831998, 0.06034937500953674, 0.021425215527415276, 0.017497442662715912, -0.03510191664099693, 0.01789672113955021, 0.0010388876544311643, 0.005789593793451786, -0.029877714812755585, 0.0440477691590786, -0.023105517029762268, -0.016965853050351143, -0.04584678262472153, 0.04710552468895912, 0.00948357954621315, -0.05491504818201065, -0.002946125576272607, 0.014651562087237835, 0.006014626007527113, -0.004309622570872307, 0.03911617770791054, 0.047645747661590576, 0.02799343504011631, -0.005569853819906712, -0.02791450172662735, -0.011353850364685059, -0.03611651062965393, 0.017253458499908447, -0.037944503128528595, -0.022915000095963478, 0.005527616944164038, 0.07679083198308945, 0.005094569642096758, -0.030701274052262306, 0.0006609777919948101, 0.019833384081721306, -0.03983089700341225, 0.03095872513949871, -0.03099394589662552, 0.04922020062804222, 0.0358574353158474, 0.056233808398246765, 0.008687049150466919, -0.0049058375880122185, 0.012064031325280666, -0.02037900686264038, -0.10361699759960175, 0.024682948365807533, -0.02017674408853054, -0.012102954089641571, -0.045963965356349945, -0.014219246804714203, 0.05295658856630325, 0.020130915567278862, 0.029246345162391663, -0.025807980448007584, 0.004158385097980499, -0.03950372338294983, -0.023453110828995705, -0.0521404929459095, -0.025684479624032974, -0.002996256109327078, 0.03825294226408005, 0.008381016552448273, -0.00449945917353034, 0.00064527039648965, 0.02240513637661934, -0.006961835082620382, -0.05799546092748642, -0.021244022995233536, -0.017903584986925125, -0.00702833803370595, 0.04983517527580261, 0.014568815007805824, 0.031096557155251503, -0.01965491659939289, 0.030345985665917397, -0.009657863527536392, 0.07473394274711609, 0.02504117228090763, 0.0029898372013121843, 0.015686700120568275, -0.015718501061201096, 0.0018927856581285596, -0.013489432632923126, 0.04174402356147766, 0.0031263954006135464, -0.0043780868873000145, 0.04940998926758766, 0.02080240659415722, -0.058864839375019073, 0.02516557089984417, 0.06632326543331146, 0.03287750855088234, -0.008327208459377289, -0.023284535855054855, 0.014182155951857567, -0.057334188371896744, 0.015046844258904457, -0.009670000523328781, -0.00400982890278101, -0.011278104968369007, -0.002151387743651867, 0.020520329475402832, 0.008312871679663658, 0.04066340997815132, -0.010966925881803036, 0.020488718524575233, 0.040557876229286194, 0.023939158767461777, -0.04703925922513008, 0.04181073233485222, 0.035925813019275665, 0.04467775300145149, 0.03150167688727379, -0.017437150701880455, -0.0417909175157547, 0.029292413964867592, 0.03682518005371094, 0.03563501685857773, 0.001043415628373623, -0.015407882630825043, 0.0007959583308547735, 0.008034957572817802, 0.04343158006668091, -0.03318043798208237, -0.0004970703739672899, -0.031958725303411484, -0.019218498840928078, 0.00312281446531415, -0.027258817106485367, -0.0745718702673912, 0.002369575435295701, -0.014684311114251614, 0.03371995687484741, -0.0507998950779438, -0.009392610751092434, -0.05847039073705673, 0.01601451449096203, 0.003343676682561636, 0.07028278708457947, -0.02556075155735016, -0.0025620954111218452, 0.01316283829510212, 0.05385233461856842, 0.008630722761154175, -0.07805060595273972, 0.06385672837495804, 0.016367526724934578, -0.02152874879539013, 0.03197311609983444, -0.026404963806271553, -0.058605000376701355, 0.05748894438147545, 0.021174674853682518, 0.008888292126357555, 0.032012563198804855, -0.03586672991514206, 0.01805146224796772, 0.05474109947681427, 0.0418052040040493, 0.057297948747873306, 0.02196016162633896, -0.008690324611961842, 0.028573866933584213, -0.018295204266905785, 0.02918712981045246, -0.019663706421852112, -0.037937961518764496, -0.02289692312479019, -0.0008589809876866639, -0.0037032433319836855, 0.018982863053679466, -0.018091274425387383, 0.05475959926843643, -0.02507617697119713, -0.01647793874144554, 0.010907088406383991, 0.018811292946338654, 0.014753615483641624, -0.014578387141227722, 0.026881417259573936, 0.030387548729777336, 0.03546247258782387, -0.018699968233704567, -0.0008881855173967779, -0.0021189586259424686, -0.00693458691239357, 0.014576254412531853, 0.009061203338205814, 0.027874484658241272, -0.043948862701654434, -0.0516057014465332, 0.03150652348995209, -0.026591502130031586, 0.018803676590323448, -0.016825828701257706, 0.041630879044532776, 0.02137998677790165, -0.02406935766339302, -0.0239707063883543, 0.014261851087212563, -0.0011595733230933547, 0.01884465664625168, -0.03188995644450188, 0.028574084863066673, 0.014654011465609074, 0.015918564051389694, -0.06328856199979782, -0.05035307630896568, -0.0018232761649414897, -0.02139407955110073, -0.013820416294038296, -0.07095590233802795, 0.025333570316433907, -0.014609773643314838, -0.018260551616549492, -0.040566522628068924, 0.01286241039633751, -0.005503620021045208, 0.005397910717874765, 0.011186348274350166, -0.004418692551553249, 0.05864155292510986, -0.003625223645940423, -0.0136985769495368, 0.03519753739237785, -0.012132675386965275, -0.052976351231336594, -0.0022821577731519938, 0.021440520882606506, -0.030147327110171318, -0.017482664436101913, -0.005057930015027523, -0.02161642722785473, 0.027752786874771118, -0.002958582481369376, -0.024362998083233833, 0.021495042368769646, 0.01839440129697323, -0.002148459665477276, -0.0006048919167369604, -0.0311902966350317, -0.0204470232129097, 0.027051113545894623, -0.034513697028160095, -0.03937439247965813, 0.00155853561591357, 0.005572926718741655, 0.045572370290756226, -0.01093777921050787, 0.019109884276986122, -0.0022271310444921255, 0.06949993968009949, 0.006283942610025406, -0.012743530794978142, 0.01706223003566265, 0.005563685204833746, 0.014427726157009602, 0.02185988798737526, -0.007581160869449377, 0.020825441926717758, -0.008984331972897053, -0.024525422602891922, -0.0580112524330616, -0.04424789920449257, 0.010896970517933369, 0.04399509355425835, 0.000310685281874612, 0.030240057036280632, 0.03770148754119873, -0.00417958153411746, -0.011135702952742577, -0.02147490344941616, -0.013041888363659382, 0.008917631581425667, 0.000621878367383033, 0.03476615995168686, 0.0026622586883604527, 0.0004576947831083089, 0.006911771837621927, 0.03203378617763519, 0.002826059004291892, 0.015036370605230331, -0.0003677631902974099, 0.011199044063687325, 0.02427809126675129, -0.017571628093719482, -0.04000713676214218, 0.030619831755757332, -0.04757292941212654, 0.015346239320933819, -0.020853986963629723, -0.003592342371121049, 0.04289843887090683, 0.04664351046085358, -0.02521144412457943, -0.02616475149989128, 0.004463227465748787, -0.01036746148020029, -0.009823361411690712, 0.036674559116363525, -0.009314163587987423, 0.015383494086563587, 0.019835835322737694, -0.001958942273631692, -0.02856081910431385, 0.016212617978453636, -0.029892193153500557, -0.0822254940867424, -0.022261610254645348, -0.013606103137135506, -0.046515725553035736, 0.023886695504188538, -0.034523122012615204, -0.01935213804244995, -0.0041842688806355, -0.034196142107248306, 0.015770550817251205, -0.023600665852427483, -0.0014176854165270925, -0.020408576354384422, 0.07502038031816483, -0.0010315253166481853, 0.04087602347135544, -0.0074302200227975845, 0.022484995424747467, 0.08114483952522278, 0.06507282704114914, 0.03130476921796799, -0.06439375877380371, -0.0005758352344855666, -0.042707957327365875, -0.012974198907613754, -0.015671370550990105, -0.012210133485496044, -0.021030088886618614, 0.005633540917187929, 0.012623065151274204, 0.05768300220370293, 0.02079637534916401, -0.007873126305639744, 0.03613479807972908, -0.016707856208086014, -0.0139375114813447, 0.02406095340847969, 0.011430282145738602, -0.01768985390663147, -0.020626267418265343, -0.05227942019701004, 0.04458807781338692, -0.023556524887681007, -0.0013046105159446597, -0.032405782490968704, -0.021484967321157455, -0.001582022407092154, -0.005303958896547556, -0.010351873002946377, 0.007351355627179146, 0.007932893931865692, -0.015875456854701042, 0.02323809824883938, -0.02328532189130783, 0.04743015766143799, -0.018674025312066078, 0.04233590513467789, 0.019331693649291992, 0.006855993531644344, 0.01836104318499565, 0.03218669071793556, 0.001887754537165165, -0.028018955141305923, -0.047019727528095245, -0.0031404378823935986, 0.061651475727558136, -0.03757926821708679, 0.007900427095592022, -0.009866862557828426, -0.017140308395028114, -0.018902795389294624, -0.037113163620233536, -0.010113401338458061, 0.0006911109667271376, 0.02471257746219635, -0.03757743537425995, 0.01891704648733139, -0.03420893847942352, 0.007564522325992584, -0.0014127525500953197, 0.016340352594852448, -0.003867535851895809, -0.009674900211393833, -0.0007931386353448033, -0.0015552855329588056, 0.007743853144347668, -0.00040331599302589893, -0.015925325453281403, -0.01835085079073906, -0.07255979627370834, -0.0019145732512697577, -0.015148494392633438, 0.0024235628079622984, -0.07079991698265076, 0.0601903535425663, 0.010014700703322887, 0.012233327142894268, -0.01920527033507824, -0.04811856895685196, 0.009378727525472641, -0.02926000766456127, 0.0061631109565496445, -0.03425508365035057, -0.01739131100475788, 0.011786945164203644, 0.013132133521139622, 0.04295485466718674, -0.012245235033333302, 0.016462204977869987, 0.04845200851559639, 0.038018498569726944, -0.01698884554207325, -0.039398789405822754, -0.02863193303346634, 0.00010377490980317816, 0.023188980296254158, -0.02015460655093193, 0.011470298282802105, 0.006681681610643864, 0.02769303321838379, 0.015453255735337734, 0.02712441049516201, -0.03469641134142876, -0.005458383820950985, -0.032942548394203186, -0.05614899471402168, 0.04010656848549843, 0.03574417531490326, 0.054319679737091064, -0.03601398691534996, 0.004415956325829029, 0.0036340970546007156, -0.01949772611260414, -0.006323501467704773, 0.0052513922564685345, -0.048152562230825424, 0.012442821636795998, 0.0051558855921030045, 0.030665749683976173, 0.003483076114207506, -0.0035066541749984026, 0.005817689001560211, -0.0007359283627010882, -0.010411330498754978, 0.022495057433843613, -0.044901806861162186, 0.023474346846342087, -0.017793798819184303, -0.032552532851696014, 0.035388391464948654, 0.028107360005378723, -0.0021470936480909586, 0.0028490140102803707, 0.0028218708466738462, 0.0024809730239212513, 0.023564960807561874, -0.011606629006564617, 0.008479899726808071, 0.040017712861299515, -0.04563819617033005, 0.001458265702240169, -0.0006465340266004205, 0.07385852932929993, 0.029593108221888542, 0.0536469928920269, -0.022301098331809044, -0.025191543623805046, 0.0227761622518301, -0.029116148129105568, 0.01353601273149252, -0.032598309218883514, -0.0010535120964050293, -0.0028971219435334206, -0.004585449118167162, -0.003914449829608202, -0.00676488783210516, -0.0046395123936235905, 0.013448785990476608, 0.019964037463068962, -0.03237399086356163, -0.004934774246066809, 0.04175642132759094, 0.030623147264122963, -0.04084569215774536, -0.029401345178484917, 0.000008966289897216484, 0.01688525080680847, 0.05341654270887375, -0.02867129258811474, 0.005090749356895685, -0.08273548632860184, -0.008703767322003841, -0.07941882312297821, -0.019014433026313782, 0.014744850806891918, 0.011527293361723423, 0.02194107696413994, -0.0642530620098114, -0.02624432183802128, 0.016821498051285744, -0.04274461790919304, 0.00528734503313899, 0.021541571244597435, -0.032271042466163635, -0.03866562992334366, 0.022487984970211983, 0.011150340549647808, 0.01004281360656023, 0.02878490276634693, 0.013523273169994354, 0.022393442690372467, 0.0313568040728569, 0.002353010233491659, -0.030034326016902924, 0.002305609406903386, 0.024763084948062897, 0.00531628867611289, -0.07815805077552795, 0.034780409187078476, -0.02514459379017353, -0.02325095795094967, 0.008540953509509563, 0.008378571830689907, 0.010237234644591808, 0.008381932973861694, -0.0068798186257481575, 0.0021268269047141075, 0.07312881201505661, -0.0211681816726923, 0.023396342992782593, 0.03724212571978569, -0.003805344458669424, 0.05226680636405945, 0.006223047152161598, -0.026647809892892838, -0.019271008670330048, 0.040026139467954636, 0.002046248409897089, -0.0605231411755085, 0.018715545535087585, 0.0022081697825342417, -0.024359501898288727, 0.013214092701673508, -0.04366529732942581, -0.0063146199099719524, -0.020723974332213402, 0.013251746073365211, -0.040476519614458084, -0.045781247317790985, 0.027133380994200706, 0.017222436144948006, -0.007196028251200914, 0.018816685304045677, 0.020792469382286072, -0.06980566680431366, 0.052524011582136154, 0.027342895045876503, -0.004695449490100145, -0.03280218690633774, -0.018219204619526863, 0.011694413609802723, 0.005101633258163929, 0.040523022413253784, -0.0375741682946682, -0.052157461643218994, 0.016149796545505524, -0.022737959399819374, -0.008125643245875835, -0.00884442962706089, -0.026201903820037842, 0.0012924439506605268, -0.045610807836055756, 0.028504017740488052, 0.005445192102342844, -0.01941501721739769, -0.017464540898799896, 0.008673600852489471, -0.03674241527915001, -0.04439835622906685, 0.06596722453832626, -0.020810769870877266, -0.03530450165271759, 0.00843468401581049, 0.03543246164917946, 0.05553263798356056, -0.07626981288194656, 0.008950070478022099, -0.03300917148590088, -0.015484062023460865, -0.02267312817275524, -0.011632738634943962, 0.01331291813403368, 0.018119802698493004, 0.012439576908946037, -0.01951974257826805, 0.016430655494332314, 0.017144562676548958, -0.011607997119426727, -0.0002035985526163131, -0.007959919050335884, 0.005766119807958603, 0.04676617681980133, -0.018439684063196182, 0.005371619947254658, 0.0413580983877182, -0.0002576975675765425, -0.04519836977124214, 0.017519356682896614, -0.04819990321993828, -0.014820429496467113, 0.004478507675230503, 0.03664452210068703, -0.0017061240505427122, -0.07539208978414536, -0.020388156175613403, 0.07740406692028046, -0.013004859909415245, -0.030346151441335678, 0.0600561797618866, 0.0024215083103626966, 0.01921248435974121, 0.013176647946238518, 0.008970396593213081, -0.0027947011403739452, 0.0006509731756523252, 0.024143671616911888, 0.018427925184369087, 0.019954200834035873, -0.01862470619380474, 0.03337247669696808, 0.017338808625936508, -0.032811153680086136, 0.03733794018626213, -0.028853889554739, 0.025246184319257736, -0.0659385472536087, -0.036494024097919464, 0.02123926766216755, -0.01813565567135811, 0.014552690088748932, -0.006986972410231829, -0.024897314608097076, 0.07265158742666245, -0.04501290246844292, 0.029331820085644722, -0.01935555599629879, 0.005795318633317947, -0.025936441496014595, 0.009739336557686329, 0.00796568300575018, 0.011052273213863373, 0.01962965354323387, 0.016388101503252983, -0.03376710042357445, 0.01712937280535698, 0.02732674591243267, -0.027853723615407944, 0.020311737433075905, -0.008471683599054813, -0.00455568078905344, 0.0026592789217829704, -0.03296273201704025, -0.03497524559497833, -0.006356759462505579, 0.01850743591785431, 0.020755905658006668, 0.020874176174402237, 0.01438437681645155, -0.009089122526347637, 0.0248548686504364, 0.08122766017913818, -0.05809064581990242, -0.0009243464446626604, -0.017696015536785126, -0.018055099993944168, -0.00523420562967658, -0.01675979048013687 ]
<p>Recently, randomly browsing questions triggered a memory of on off-hand comment from one of my professors a few years back warning about the usage of ratios in regression models. So I started reading up on this, leading eventually to Kronmal 1993.</p> <p>I want to make sure that I'm correctly interpreting his suggestions on how to model these.</p> <ol> <li><p>For a model with a ratio with the same denominator on both the dependent and independent side:<br> $ Z^{-1}Y = Z^{-1}1_n\beta_0 + Z^{-1}X\beta_X + \beta_Z + Z^{-1}\epsilon $</p> <ul> <li>Regress dependent ratio on the (inverse) denominator variable in addition to the other ratios</li> <li>Weight by the (inverse) denominator variable</li> </ul></li> <li><p>For a model with dependent variable as a ratio:<br> $ Y = \beta_0 + \beta_XX + Z1_n\alpha_0 + ZX\alpha_X + Z^{-1}\epsilon $</p> <ul> <li>Regress numerator by original variables, denominator, and denominator times original variables [what about categorical variables?]</li> <li>Weight by (inverse) denominator</li> </ul></li> <li><p>For model with only independent variable ratios: $ Y = \beta_0 + X\beta_X + Z^{-1}1_n\beta_{Z^{-1}} + W\beta_W + Z^{-1}W\beta_{Z^{-1}W} + \epsilon $</p> <ul> <li>Include numerator and (inverse) denominator as main effects, ratio as interaction term.</li> </ul></li> </ol> <p>Are my interpretations here correct? Thanks.</p>
41,280
[ 0.007423935458064079, -0.04236774891614914, 0.0255628302693367, 0.016731997951865196, 0.05249635875225067, 0.0056145465932786465, -0.0010922387009486556, 0.0016051592538133264, 0.09313323348760605, -0.03898638114333153, 0.020603841170668602, 0.000582133128773421, 0.09293080866336823, 0.02800830826163292, 0.012114515528082848, 0.007000794168561697, 0.0022880348842591047, 0.0011471336474642158, -0.0002653701521921903, -0.004823360126465559, 0.014519015327095985, 0.02348252199590206, 0.014614286832511425, 0.022921307012438774, -0.007959782145917416, 0.0503215566277504, 0.039707429707050323, -0.008380560204386711, 0.02199813537299633, 0.009462467394769192, 0.048195481300354004, -0.06422566622495651, 0.006003545597195625, 0.032779283821582794, -0.006970666348934174, -0.007711443584412336, 0.00812498014420271, -0.05953299626708031, 0.005555739626288414, 0.024469031020998955, -0.01891358755528927, 0.011425908654928207, -0.010901776142418385, 0.025369102135300636, -0.01246009673923254, 0.004526261705905199, -0.02807130105793476, -0.03460518270730972, 0.016278930008411407, -0.023079194128513336, 0.04069479554891586, 0.028732240200042725, 0.03861769661307335, 0.03268972411751747, -0.005264837760478258, -0.00003484018088784069, 0.04504770785570145, 0.06016245856881142, 0.01737440750002861, -0.05664645507931709, -0.026177464053034782, -0.011060403659939766, 0.02087981253862381, 0.02237546630203724, 0.0027638589963316917, 0.009757555089890957, 0.017435895279049873, -0.009549587033689022, 0.07023420929908752, -0.03373917564749718, 0.04801167920231819, 0.019227800890803337, 0.04347856342792511, 0.009344157762825489, -0.02324719913303852, -0.011747238226234913, 0.021567435935139656, -0.0006456880364567041, 0.05500500276684761, 0.04432820528745651, -0.009494000114500523, -0.004645275883376598, 0.027408357709646225, 0.030628053471446037, 0.019294921308755875, -0.005268272943794727, 0.05927187204360962, -0.004719804972410202, 0.0032311284448951483, 0.018322328105568886, 0.0003197558398824185, 0.010602602735161781, 0.00608110474422574, -0.01174185425043106, -0.04140107333660126, 0.032251715660095215, -0.007040801458060741, 0.01185668632388115, 0.0003724629932548851, 0.02774347923696041, -0.03784933686256409, -0.038865137845277786, -0.026596922427415848, 0.0429755263030529, -0.014215400442481041, -0.004807831719517708, -0.023074524477124214, 0.023748211562633514, -0.016339337453246117, -0.09363554418087006, -0.03122192621231079, 0.021012458950281143, -0.0026984454598277807, 0.003105750074610114, -0.013094666413962841, -0.029706815257668495, -0.005280415527522564, 0.0008826773264445364, 0.06469502300024033, 0.040925364941358566, 0.03516833111643791, 0.0027687621768563986, 0.039575424045324326, -0.02121136337518692, -0.05844535306096077, -0.004580203909426928, 0.041123393923044205, -0.0014032315229997039, -0.03297083079814911, 0.03922443836927414, 0.005544430110603571, -0.028025060892105103, 0.015383231453597546, 0.02031468227505684, 0.050706762820482254, 0.03323322907090187, -0.06310419738292694, -0.06702953577041626, -0.0019353177631273866, -0.002704502083361149, 0.005046770442277193, -0.03481173887848854, -0.016769396141171455, 0.04880744218826294, 0.07110445201396942, 0.011740080080926418, 0.03414703905582428, 0.02880483865737915, 0.0014695158461108804, 0.045353882014751434, -0.04298488423228264, -0.04237552359700203, -0.02632642723619938, -0.04827922582626343, -0.012029876001179218, -0.06654530763626099, 0.04999368637800217, 0.007984986528754234, -0.018693631514906883, 0.004718234296888113, 0.05558034032583237, 0.00026657513808459044, 0.0015692884335294366, 0.04125447943806648, 0.008261431008577347, -0.039596617221832275, 0.07381845265626907, 0.03482387587428093, 0.038703493773937225, 0.03390650451183319, 0.019627032801508904, 0.002657547127455473, 0.02670859917998314, 0.06449370086193085, 0.047735296189785004, -0.011140151880681515, -0.005522036459296942, -0.0381038635969162, -0.020949047058820724, 0.04061166197061539, -0.058001551777124405, -0.036759793758392334, -0.022016718983650208, -0.0045967441983520985, -0.0036510054487735033, 0.037528906017541885, -0.029360191896557808, -0.030586736276745796, 0.06030163913965225, -0.014797406271100044, -0.053984321653842926, -0.01802172139286995, -0.005600231699645519, -0.02364264242351055, 0.02226959727704525, 0.04470648244023323, -0.019593380391597748, 0.017244935035705566, 0.016206834465265274, -0.003510967129841447, -0.00482416246086359, -0.00531294010579586, 0.04971226304769516, -0.014488170854747295, -0.0013421270996332169, 0.025590969249606133, 0.045223869383335114, -0.04115137830376625, 0.03961244225502014, -0.05871447175741196, -0.019516605883836746, 0.02817177027463913, -0.03145124018192291, 0.01502835750579834, -0.017078746110200882, -0.036831099539995193, 0.03325596824288368, -0.0019276696257293224, -0.030423136427998543, 0.0194851066917181, -0.04949859157204628, 0.020243749022483826, 0.06475678831338882, 0.002551473444327712, -0.010395338758826256, 0.0559099018573761, 0.025053154677152634, 0.030965454876422882, -0.023867754265666008, -0.027862314134836197, -0.0314413458108902, -0.004234367981553078, 0.05412711948156357, -0.0028901915065944195, -0.04112453758716583, 0.018552936613559723, 0.032793961465358734, -0.00027073471574112773, 0.01584148406982422, 0.025471678003668785, 0.002786900382488966, -0.005557301454246044, -0.01349075511097908, -0.004167801234871149, 0.06868957728147507, 0.007694924715906382, 0.016302328556776047, -0.015735067427158356, 0.04066210985183716, -0.013411950320005417, 0.002203448209911585, 0.045698732137680054, 0.011013881303369999, 0.005897206719964743, 0.02252667397260666, 0.01032971777021885, 0.04251507669687271, -0.04981238394975662, 0.023114703595638275, 0.044722672551870346, 0.007037471514195204, -0.015023226849734783, 0.03026953898370266, 0.004933266434818506, -0.04514887183904648, 0.09339577704668045, -0.0471222810447216, 0.019359709694981575, 0.01945536769926548, -0.040758877992630005, 0.02416558377444744, -0.029985446482896805, -0.05233877897262573, -0.011869578622281551, -0.004087356384843588, 0.005450001917779446, 0.030090343207120895, -0.012191270478069782, -0.005363836884498596, -0.012646964751183987, 0.0032121934927999973, -0.004791026469320059, 0.02451493591070175, 0.009603776969015598, -0.029011663049459457, -0.04064270853996277, -0.04959522932767868, 0.010903795249760151, 0.0243065245449543, 0.01040321309119463, 0.002893302822485566, -0.0064523653127253056, -0.005341427866369486, -0.07951953262090683, -0.06426119804382324, -0.04308636486530304, 0.0019129931461066008, -0.027264563366770744, -0.016006479039788246, 0.06377916038036346, 0.010561149567365646, -0.013076786883175373, -0.0036300341598689556, -0.021100886166095734, -0.04937973991036415, -0.01730090007185936, -0.021528244018554688, 0.019992193207144737, 0.0015889141941443086, 0.010031653568148613, 0.009314306080341339, -0.007035480812191963, -0.030377943068742752, -0.08603134006261826, -0.08403007686138153, 0.012479154393076897, 0.0005243196501396596, 0.05212515592575073, 0.032373517751693726, -0.016837291419506073, 0.09900892525911331, 0.028076395392417908, -0.0008763751247897744, -0.08119743317365646, 0.001874971785582602, -0.012795618735253811, -0.0674598217010498, -0.017791474238038063, 0.014951462857425213, -0.013515370897948742, 0.031736500561237335, 0.019849760457873344, 0.02181343175470829, 0.0010133557952940464, 0.04135262966156006, -0.020518938079476357, 0.06524817645549774, -0.008424270898103714, -0.03397680073976517, 0.013028714805841446, -0.004867419600486755, -0.005078921094536781, 0.027493614703416824, 0.02198287844657898, 0.04103607311844826, 0.01509264949709177, -0.0549599751830101, 0.008849973790347576, 0.009717375040054321, -0.01834079436957836, 0.01658744551241398, 0.03205543011426926, 0.007393469102680683, -0.02444228157401085, -0.00206309393979609, 0.022961115464568138, 0.03024720400571823, -0.024970348924398422, 0.014814374037086964, 0.018702218309044838, 0.05659853667020798, -0.012174609117209911, -0.006674440111964941, -0.009664270095527172, -0.018187489360570908, 0.026682699099183083, -0.020173978060483932, 0.008370432071387768, 0.01900985650718212, 0.032644495368003845, -0.003110682824626565, -0.034663911908864975, -0.0503738597035408, 0.004979312885552645, -0.07353966683149338, -0.021549871191382408, -0.03650385141372681, 0.026874898001551628, 0.004679482895880938, 0.05384844169020653, -0.012965522706508636, -0.00854223221540451, -0.0009644738747738302, -0.015392637811601162, -0.057507291436195374, 0.020635172724723816, 0.014001614414155483, -0.011723474599421024, -0.008750461973249912, 0.018319526687264442, 0.01596049778163433, -0.026852941140532494, -0.056093521416187286, -0.016752881929278374, -0.020040694624185562, -0.032609209418296814, 0.02059546858072281, -0.041996266692876816, -0.064402274787426, 0.020033536478877068, 0.024963991716504097, 0.015636110678315163, -0.037492744624614716, -0.019589269533753395, 0.0517958328127861, -0.01811782270669937, -0.02567114122211933, -0.0778198167681694, 0.011801082640886307, 0.021186457946896553, 0.047316744923591614, 0.014412112534046173, 0.010358862578868866, -0.04454025253653526, 0.03579839691519737, 0.011834802106022835, 0.004789367783814669, 0.03423985838890076, 0.0016515104798600078, -0.0716092512011528, -0.013053049333393574, -0.009467591531574726, -0.015661925077438354, 0.026732780039310455, 0.02924763597548008, 0.031725965440273285, 0.08838168531656265, 0.03236909955739975, 0.016988268122076988, 0.024677107110619545, 0.04766237735748291, 0.03322511911392212, -0.0200236514210701, -0.006219033617526293, 0.06473717093467712, 0.02151627652347088, 0.009426836855709553, -0.013010233640670776, 0.007924113422632217, 0.023665212094783783, -0.014444870874285698, 0.013181122951209545, -0.009376106783747673, 0.031162576749920845, 0.028362000361084938, 0.008257281966507435, 0.017909198999404907, -0.009933780878782272, -0.05563319846987724, 0.015944182872772217, 0.00861519854515791, 0.05878862738609314, 0.04908314719796181, -0.015684664249420166, -0.09546535462141037, 0.011352634988725185, 0.02159765549004078, 0.0401969738304615, -0.049435805529356, -0.010809033177793026, -0.02224165014922619, -0.005854343064129353, 0.010835432447493076, -0.037669647485017776, 0.04779534414410591, -0.018685678020119667, 0.014257170259952545, 0.01957797445356846, -0.05052012950181961, -0.03099745325744152, 0.0431002639234066, -0.027702325955033302, 0.01823846809566021, 0.01396977435797453, -0.00770753575488925, -0.03836630657315254, 0.020703142508864403, -0.015356265939772129, 0.0238150916993618, -0.016071917489171028, -0.0324675552546978, -0.005160799250006676, 0.022795403376221657, -0.05228620767593384, -0.07596797496080399, -0.009764104150235653, 0.0235701072961092, -0.016249848529696465, 0.04298577085137367, -0.012243221513926983, -0.048065874725580215, 0.005772250238806009, 0.035221122205257416, -0.018454473465681076, 0.0023485380224883556, -0.018074125051498413, 0.06507477909326553, 0.01931840553879738, -0.02071157842874527, 0.06752382963895798, 0.057115212082862854, -0.034322839230298996, -0.017951473593711853, -0.02780834585428238, -0.01824781484901905, -0.014628823846578598, -0.005050168372690678, -0.028887199237942696, -0.004669989924877882, 0.003929254598915577, 0.023056231439113617, -0.0004983129911124706, 0.00035873879096470773, -0.019458502531051636, -0.030096013098955154, -0.009006413631141186, 0.010876905173063278, 0.012770800851285458, -0.031034639105200768, 0.0073486086912453175, 0.02456083334982395, -0.009916880168020725, -0.017670173197984695, 0.012515928596258163, -0.0012058498105034232, 0.028291795402765274, 0.02632378600537777, -0.013219782151281834, 0.004060670267790556, -0.006820293143391609, -0.01745394617319107, 0.024805495515465736, 0.005995915737003088, 0.004155893810093403, -0.010680759325623512, -0.00279881339520216, 0.006512806750833988, -0.017136268317699432, -0.010953506454825401, -0.004379922524094582, -0.00510155875235796, -0.007671329192817211, -0.005246360320597887, 0.013222036883234978, 0.020346706733107567, -0.00954311341047287, -0.06541034579277039, -0.051681723445653915, 0.009258871898055077, 0.0014288931852206588, 0.0033714822493493557, -0.026310903951525688, -0.004381525795906782, -0.017285648733377457, -0.0548049658536911, -0.0206791702657938, 0.09169977903366089, -0.053367290645837784, -0.01888108067214489, -0.015404099598526955, 0.06770075857639313, 0.06297829747200012, 0.014612497761845589, -0.007274332456290722, 0.020311662927269936, -0.04545214772224426, 0.011517457664012909, 0.011629501357674599, 0.007790435571223497, -0.036717891693115234, -0.016436105594038963, 0.0005639019655063748, -0.015428155660629272, 0.057357221841812134, -0.024706238880753517, -0.011235280893743038, 0.041348204016685486, 0.0007951791048981249, 0.008589902892708778, 0.005114970728754997, 0.0061744083650410175, -0.03256641700863838, 0.006662972271442413, -0.01541172806173563, 0.040639832615852356, -0.03798690810799599, 0.0457831509411335, 0.033535849303007126, 0.006232036277651787, -0.018760336562991142, -0.00449912017211318, 0.07718169689178467, 0.020017551258206367, 0.015293683856725693, -0.006319794803857803, -0.035877592861652374, 0.06152583286166191, 0.03033224120736122, -0.004372394178062677, 0.026059303432703018, 0.0156251210719347, -0.016637785360217094, 0.0014884374104440212, -0.04378177970647812, -0.007996574975550175, 0.07439631223678589, -0.0068854657001793385, 0.00179864012170583, 0.013333032839000225, -0.012842128984630108, 0.021308979019522667, -0.023764152079820633, 0.01119259838014841, -0.020880188792943954, -0.02688179351389408, 0.029658915475010872, -0.0006340189720503986, -0.041594814509153366, 0.0435054637491703, 0.04584715515375137, -0.012367398478090763, -0.03265783563256264, -0.008367329835891724, 0.004524839110672474, 0.0020161846186965704, -0.034989651292562485, -0.049520157277584076, 0.024032481014728546, -0.0022353148087859154, 0.015444404445588589, -0.03592107817530632, -0.06506295502185822, 0.027866728603839874, 0.024622539058327675, 0.010457981377840042, -0.08508715033531189, -0.029907099902629852, -0.053175587207078934, 0.020772751420736313, -0.016829168424010277, 0.013507853262126446, 0.014518089592456818, -0.03268086165189743, 0.05211450159549713, 0.020079076290130615, 0.023365456610918045, -0.04026499763131142, -0.06932581961154938, -0.0008827908895909786, -0.01261367741972208, -0.045451819896698, 0.003673344850540161, -0.029894230887293816, -0.057782091200351715, 0.028556954115629196, -0.06420700997114182, -0.0023594917729496956, 0.009041820652782917, -0.011119834147393703, 0.0021065082401037216, 0.05882245674729347, 0.005746614187955856, -0.008056304417550564, -0.006072886288166046, -0.009818482212722301, 0.12889401614665985, 0.10002171248197556, 0.009125311858952045, -0.05753069370985031, 0.034025147557258606, 0.02625155821442604, -0.004969944711774588, 0.010591736063361168, -0.012114032171666622, -0.002796127926558256, 0.01747954823076725, 0.06753886491060257, 0.043766845017671585, 0.029199764132499695, 0.003972372505813837, 0.01881430856883526, -0.003553633578121662, -0.005031832959502935, 0.004937819670885801, 0.00032707760692574084, -0.013289653696119785, -0.004817870445549488, -0.03165508061647415, 0.016485651955008507, -0.011032058857381344, 0.01489504985511303, -0.04037255048751831, -0.02257695235311985, -0.012181664817035198, 0.007546006701886654, -0.010029495693743229, 0.014938321895897388, 0.00912559311836958, 0.05206933245062828, -0.013524724170565605, 0.02312607131898403, 0.06043287366628647, -0.01650664582848549, 0.013616438955068588, 0.009441938251256943, -0.014005869626998901, 0.005358837079256773, 0.010491656139492989, 0.007994729094207287, -0.06307551264762878, -0.009452296420931816, -0.026981590315699577, 0.02622811309993267, 0.0013496215688064694, -0.005210965406149626, -0.01970869116485119, -0.017837487161159515, 0.004699439276009798, -0.026917973533272743, -0.014383062720298767, 0.05641040578484535, 0.04185435175895691, -0.03638412430882454, 0.019355962052941322, 0.005988079588860273, 0.002281992929056287, 0.007924102246761322, 0.07635191828012466, 0.005865789484232664, -0.044001560658216476, -0.010484755039215088, -0.01978125609457493, 0.05542434751987457, -0.011769527569413185, 0.005231435410678387, -0.021968714892864227, 0.02376960776746273, -0.014630747027695179, -0.00591637147590518, 0.006875314749777317, 0.0009760120883584023, 0.012653656303882599, -0.012223276309669018, 0.022958744317293167, -0.05924731865525246, -0.04532746225595474, 0.020072493702173233, 0.004771036561578512, 0.029038283973932266, -0.045398030430078506, -0.001876894966699183, -0.01480179000645876, 0.02891506999731064, -0.0031292124185711145, -0.02319137565791607, -0.01597178727388382, 0.08497928082942963, -0.028585636988282204, -0.042861055582761765, 0.005597005598247051, 0.023153355345129967, -0.03975605219602585, -0.029999200254678726, -0.02420448511838913, 0.01215971726924181, 0.014148706570267677, 0.02373717725276947, -0.010222753509879112, 0.0475277379155159, -0.015850573778152466, 0.013296800665557384, 0.012290651910007, -0.08994599431753159, 0.015682632103562355, 0.0019432895351201296, 0.020219434052705765, -0.029620204120874405, -0.0469953790307045, -0.01232381071895361, -0.029234163463115692, -0.002834273735061288, -0.020737631246447563, -0.04344002157449722, -0.016573553904891014, -0.013009714893996716, 0.005199215840548277, 0.007410951890051365, -0.008276720531284809, -0.03083125315606594, 0.00023829186102375388, 0.0059676747769117355, 0.008733302354812622, 0.023368628695607185, 0.030954642221331596, -0.009897931478917599, 0.046565961092710495, -0.005601232405751944, 0.03997424989938736, -0.018316293135285378, -0.04653717949986458, -0.02102099359035492, 0.001752760261297226, 0.0003940435126423836, -0.040087152272462845, -0.052009474486112595, 0.005963214207440615, 0.0017819140339270234, 0.014798137359321117, 0.027937060222029686, 0.0013972170418128371, 0.0262521393597126, 0.008271315135061741, 0.0003519348392728716, -0.011082188226282597, 0.01898977905511856, -0.016688374802470207, 0.0007482963264919817, -0.002374473260715604, -0.008886660449206829, -0.017751546576619148, -0.02975824475288391, 0.01181114837527275, 0.049461595714092255, 0.0036919713020324707, 0.015200041234493256, 0.08071963489055634, -0.028295360505580902, -0.00837573129683733, 0.033890675753355026, -0.017703527584671974, -0.011452431790530682, -0.01808137074112892, 0.0016292661894112825, 0.014020819216966629, 0.018037108704447746, -0.05189986526966095, 0.03319677338004112, -0.038296908140182495, 0.02564338594675064, -0.07062158733606339, -0.038560476154088974, 0.03195458650588989, 0.01209663599729538, 0.03930748626589775, -0.011893563903868198, 0.02220437489449978, -0.0621647983789444, -0.04740691930055618, 0.03457729518413544, 0.00018780719256028533, -0.025668097659945488, -0.013833766803145409, -0.017978232353925705, 0.02030685916543007, 0.023330820724368095, 0.008918448351323605, 0.002983478829264641, 0.015073117800056934, 0.041744768619537354, 0.013760927133262157, -0.04410344734787941, -0.03690522164106369, -0.018409011885523796, 0.0010821734322234988, -0.01903459057211876, 0.029974522069096565, -0.028783734887838364, -0.025436149910092354, 0.026145003736019135, -0.011426378041505814, 0.026933910325169563, 0.017186129465699196, 0.0395091287791729, 0.04102424159646034, 0.042378831654787064, 0.02646026946604252, 0.008079455234110355, -0.06383683532476425, -0.0035336900036782026, 0.05614372715353966, -0.008387844078242779, 0.01645493134856224, -0.006542195100337267, 0.01227108109742403, -0.02414398081600666, -0.019485104829072952, -0.024588266387581825, -0.04179561510682106, 0.017185954377055168, 0.007547846529632807, 0.0003312261833343655, -0.0319606252014637, 0.004408645909279585, 0.02265123650431633, -0.053178686648607254, -0.013221967965364456, 0.024811914190649986, -0.02072363905608654, -0.014024713076651096, 0.01785610243678093, -0.02598627097904682, -0.025662805885076523, 0.011983183212578297, -0.016909895464777946, -0.008170196786522865, -0.03550979867577553, -0.018166612833738327, -0.007162400521337986, 0.010987699031829834, -0.05456739664077759, 0.0029537391383200884, -0.056016210466623306, 0.04596353694796562, -0.017989860847592354, 0.01843123883008957, 0.005716152489185333, -0.04313214495778084, 0.022138409316539764, -0.051991596817970276, 0.04958372190594673, 0.03671178221702576, -0.026658914983272552, -0.009533324278891087, -0.017663031816482544, -0.003882436780259013, -0.03563225641846657, 0.0559685043990612, 0.018790774047374725, -0.0024149632081389427, -0.0351601243019104, 0.030401278287172318, 0.0011755921877920628, -0.05611090734601021, 0.04422770068049431, 0.037314314395189285, -0.030230576172471046, -0.03845972940325737, 0.022916089743375778, -0.03961942344903946, -0.00002147292070731055, 0.057887397706508636, 0.0037605653051286936, -0.00923119019716978, 0.021427225321531296, -0.009898564778268337, 0.008800561539828777, -0.032981641590595245, 0.015479899011552334, 0.0451740138232708, 0.005823073443025351, 0.029984217137098312, 0.05089079961180687, -0.0005138891865499318, -0.028621448203921318, 0.03107798844575882, -0.009362799115478992, 0.008160103112459183, -0.017446836456656456, 0.010321014560759068, 0.05746355280280113, -0.03732879459857941, -0.01433003880083561, 0.006440622732043266, -0.022866886109113693, -0.02078312449157238, 0.027372043579816818, 0.03680777549743652, 0.029798246920108795, -0.0009679668000899255, -0.03056911565363407, -0.0002781802322715521, -0.01680411398410797, -0.004847115837037563, 0.016602758318185806, 0.017877480015158653, 0.004600934684276581, -0.03339223563671112, 0.030004972591996193, 0.020117925480008125, 0.01082806196063757, -0.016037816181778908, -0.020693287253379822, -0.03025708720088005, -0.02341216430068016, 0.0029411122668534517, -0.017748281359672546, 0.0165069829672575, 0.015979833900928497, 0.008998914621770382, 0.037333499640226364, -0.011290352791547775, 0.036254700273275375, -0.028883790597319603, -0.02639908529818058, -0.010996251367032528, 0.003682059235870838, 0.0033190478570759296, 0.018943525850772858, 0.01423022709786892, -0.009561359882354736, -0.01572544127702713, -0.033048115670681, -0.015107866376638412, 0.0035199704580008984, -0.02417185716331005, -0.009589828550815582, 0.025797158479690552, 0.01942407339811325, -0.05574218928813934, -0.057940877974033356, -0.03811393678188324, 0.05158941447734833, 0.027755580842494965, 0.016494236886501312, -0.019655819982290268, -0.028846098110079765, 0.002978120930492878, 0.04043734446167946, -0.03590839356184006, -0.04857567325234413, -0.007173269055783749, -0.0012090704403817654, 0.015180831775069237, -0.043259479105472565 ]
<p>I am reading a book on linear regression and have some trouble understanding the variance-covariance matrix of $\mathbf{b}$:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/RIgsS.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The diagonal items are easy enough, but the off-diagonal ones are a bit more difficult, what puzzles me is that $$ \sigma(b_0, b_1) = E(b_0 b_1) - E(b_0)E(b_1) = E(b_0 b_1) - \beta_0 \beta_1 $$</p> <p>but there is no trace of $\beta_0$ and $\beta_1$ here.</p>
73,605
[ -0.014214309863746166, -0.016547664999961853, -0.01712304726243019, -0.014902742579579353, 0.05785074830055237, 0.046236321330070496, 0.017249222844839096, 0.00951987411826849, 0.01872224546968937, -0.04955139011144638, 0.025517085567116737, 0.052454374730587006, 0.05310918763279915, 0.007897267118096352, 0.06416261941194534, 0.02505226992070675, -0.013861684128642082, 0.012278149835765362, -0.044593676924705505, 0.018512414768338203, 0.01837994158267975, 0.017954930663108826, 0.05863433703780174, 0.020957348868250847, -0.0251990407705307, 0.020530959591269493, 0.031646229326725006, -0.006086413748562336, 0.020271779969334602, 0.050846368074417114, -0.04415271431207657, -0.019879791885614395, 0.032451849430799484, 0.01061711274087429, 0.010532268323004246, -0.018590223044157028, 0.004903765860944986, -0.03478434309363365, -0.0004257538530509919, 0.015054834075272083, -0.0392533503472805, -0.03602301701903343, -0.018137002363801003, 0.05537516251206398, -0.0060209427028894424, 0.012724882923066616, -0.015801789239048958, -0.024651480838656425, 0.029424097388982773, -0.02180173061788082, 0.09248647093772888, -0.006855302955955267, 0.052609097212553024, 0.041529733687639236, -0.0018040143186226487, 0.026259243488311768, 0.06711209565401077, 0.04358489066362381, 0.008808093145489693, -0.034743599593639374, 0.007892352528870106, -0.02309560589492321, 0.010366309434175491, -0.00864128116518259, -0.04343661665916443, -0.003529239445924759, 0.0062179602682590485, -0.008406486362218857, 0.061529289931058884, -0.0012516784481704235, 0.014923362992703915, 0.03917258605360985, 0.03453569859266281, -0.020230945199728012, 0.0032166289165616035, -0.028962483629584312, 0.012089935131371021, 0.011459807865321636, 0.027786096557974815, 0.0319635383784771, 0.01127202995121479, 0.01965338923037052, 0.018484752625226974, 0.027915069833397865, 0.003271627239882946, 0.012378680519759655, 0.05963069200515747, -0.024952512234449387, 0.026624169200658798, 0.03200175613164902, -0.024691101163625717, 0.028584571555256844, 0.021976416930556297, -0.002937423763796687, -0.07221320271492004, 0.04496993124485016, -0.0000443292738054879, 0.02735762484371662, 0.018775945529341698, -0.030113492161035538, -0.00925156194716692, -0.05244927108287811, 0.021793438121676445, 0.0451163612306118, -0.0066330586560070515, -0.017899155616760254, -0.00873609073460102, 0.04614460468292236, -0.005389820784330368, -0.07599367201328278, -0.02278001978993416, 0.046441178768873215, -0.01823667250573635, -0.015384277328848839, 0.021447796374559402, -0.039962708950042725, 0.01433633267879486, 0.016574857756495476, 0.031965628266334534, 0.07115717977285385, 0.017037218436598778, -0.029373161494731903, 0.03078143298625946, 0.005332921631634235, -0.04726167023181915, 0.01908021979033947, 0.02807564288377762, -0.020769769325852394, -0.06280747801065445, 0.04624181613326073, 0.0002544934395700693, -0.02868741750717163, 0.012889032252132893, 0.009707019664347172, 0.01132240891456604, -0.009302987717092037, -0.08985056728124619, -0.06031763553619385, 0.022884855046868324, -0.03403497114777565, 0.001074473257176578, -0.06130350008606911, 0.0026985984295606613, -0.00015936908312141895, 0.06392460316419601, -0.017629535868763924, 0.03900556638836861, 0.015177174471318722, 0.011124403215944767, -0.007182578090578318, -0.0066213482059538364, -0.017287470400333405, -0.04445675387978554, -0.01229445356875658, -0.006036888808012009, -0.06914283335208893, -0.004071017261594534, 0.0007722001755610108, -0.028368836268782616, -0.031770411878824234, 0.05327604338526726, 0.029413819313049316, -0.022264039143919945, 0.00791239459067583, 0.005260569043457508, -0.007974713109433651, 0.0617930144071579, 0.014128703624010086, 0.015934085473418236, 0.04507376253604889, 0.002118136268109083, 0.005881591700017452, -0.0006902091554366052, 0.08150380104780197, 0.04494325444102287, -0.013223390094935894, -0.020888719707727432, -0.005115126725286245, 0.02977803535759449, 0.03199205920100212, -0.08970163017511368, -0.022435106337070465, -0.013124978169798851, 0.001093125669285655, -0.0015157053712755442, 0.05367693305015564, -0.005772561766207218, -0.010518420487642288, 0.009999316185712814, -0.032422177493572235, -0.00822968129068613, -0.08844101428985596, 0.003931076731532812, 0.017191627994179726, -0.020148305222392082, 0.0131412073969841, 0.024672342464327812, 0.019663268700242043, -0.016364123672246933, -0.026730723679065704, -0.018184024840593338, 0.026311639696359634, 0.029517080634832382, -0.024353373795747757, 0.016269462183117867, 0.03308357670903206, 0.0571277029812336, -0.0015230199787765741, 0.06362804770469666, -0.042915228754282, -0.016148729249835014, 0.018651751801371574, -0.04028962552547455, 0.009207013994455338, -0.02037295699119568, -0.02114555425941944, 0.017452305182814598, -0.013837166130542755, -0.0005408211145550013, 0.01989535056054592, -0.05576586723327637, -0.001462507643736899, 0.025759514421224594, 0.0201703067868948, 0.008159107528626919, 0.011103210970759392, 0.058115459978580475, 0.026292918249964714, -0.035137422382831573, -0.025327865034341812, -0.030056776478886604, 0.025788191705942154, 0.01724151521921158, 0.02125861868262291, -0.012623544782400131, 0.014501654542982578, 0.031778596341609955, 0.05605039373040199, -0.023162417113780975, 0.04405384138226509, -0.014625939540565014, 0.023609237745404243, -0.024071309715509415, -0.013674275018274784, 0.002892684191465378, 0.025997033342719078, -0.021774407476186752, 0.026733864098787308, 0.04642800614237785, 0.005942204967141151, -0.03691427782177925, 0.062226030975580215, -0.01660774089396, 0.014388161711394787, -0.006964589934796095, 0.018148154020309448, 0.03736896067857742, -0.019502339884638786, 0.016560962423682213, 0.030454689636826515, 0.008599638007581234, 0.0080056581646204, 0.007491190917789936, -0.010499839670956135, 0.024237893521785736, 0.04566613957285881, 0.0009539074962958694, 0.011803408153355122, -0.0004416297597344965, -0.012927058152854443, 0.0559227354824543, -0.02028227411210537, -0.006035215221345425, -0.0037033988628536463, 0.009841064922511578, 0.023522887378931046, 0.01859404519200325, 0.027756106108427048, -0.028729725629091263, -0.05233830213546753, -0.020097924396395683, -0.017520645633339882, 0.033360403031110764, -0.0068280817940831184, -0.04658232256770134, 0.00041833933210000396, -0.0604250431060791, 0.0158088319003582, 0.06262439489364624, 0.0074193901382386684, -0.006713340058922768, 0.03919798880815506, -0.009960098192095757, -0.03238015994429588, -0.0472952164709568, -0.0007158403168432415, -0.00680782925337553, -0.022623607888817787, -0.013303537853062153, 0.027522023767232895, -0.021651702001690865, -0.02781926654279232, 0.018270283937454224, -0.050461702048778534, -0.04947543516755104, -0.02445206791162491, -0.01590419001877308, 0.005513795185834169, 0.01473398506641388, 0.06478625535964966, 0.00020558795949909836, -0.030913518741726875, -0.017280075699090958, -0.05269059166312218, -0.04142080992460251, -0.01544959843158722, 0.00425754813477397, -0.002870692405849695, -0.011667363345623016, -0.035745881497859955, 0.08809411525726318, 0.008922167122364044, -0.004390288144350052, -0.00809079222381115, -0.009925461374223232, -0.03195221722126007, -0.06138584390282631, 0.042517732828855515, 0.031619176268577576, 0.0013567848363891244, 0.06408962607383728, -0.002924221334978938, 0.024976307526230812, 0.05947649106383324, -0.03043711930513382, -0.0199393592774868, -0.015903104096651077, -0.02925480343401432, 0.007110355421900749, 0.04395399987697601, -0.00856770109385252, 0.014262634329497814, 0.022714888677001, 0.028065083548426628, 0.06653444468975067, 0.0255888681858778, -0.03620333597064018, 0.030435431748628616, -0.03398194909095764, -0.018122639507055283, -0.05436385050415993, 0.060866598039865494, 0.02080213837325573, -0.013394597917795181, -0.005066140089184046, 0.0046162656508386135, 0.04502284154295921, -0.03125946596264839, 0.011696918867528439, 0.05120867118239403, 0.007593539543449879, -0.01871061697602272, -0.015771444886922836, -0.009839187376201153, 0.00020246458007022738, -0.00830395333468914, -0.04416588693857193, -0.027769919484853745, 0.04045793414115906, 0.0786086693406105, -0.02104884199798107, -0.028541332110762596, -0.04863986000418663, -0.01150935422629118, -0.0455477312207222, -0.0034723274875432253, 0.011381748132407665, 0.024444788694381714, -0.026996895670890808, 0.07972811907529831, -0.004227361176162958, -0.0012701177038252354, 0.0411384180188179, -0.017024017870426178, -0.025710199028253555, 0.0008978100377134979, -0.0388503223657608, -0.028817085549235344, -0.019408494234085083, -0.01363611314445734, 0.05984769016504288, -0.020497014746069908, -0.005661545787006617, -0.012759960256516933, 0.007098289206624031, -0.04533389210700989, 0.01061217486858368, -0.03198748081922531, -0.02123737707734108, -0.011591114103794098, -0.002181841991841793, 0.0054621915332973, -0.046388331800699234, 0.03603373095393181, 0.03124857507646084, -0.01312114205211401, -0.00998291652649641, -0.032765042036771774, -0.0012140892213210464, 0.032463524490594864, 0.024919642135500908, 0.03375609964132309, 0.018463080748915672, 0.0023195480462163687, 0.005582635290920734, 0.00971189048141241, 0.05842984467744827, 0.020281972363591194, -0.015783004462718964, -0.016336387023329735, -0.023890862241387367, 0.02279025875031948, -0.012804679572582245, 0.014738908968865871, 0.009352006949484348, -0.0006088062073104084, 0.08082287758588791, 0.048322971910238266, -0.04229001700878143, 0.045295994728803635, 0.04783742129802704, 0.04040330648422241, 0.0245664082467556, -0.04258817434310913, 0.01551797240972519, -0.013315627351403236, -0.024471547454595566, 0.0001646578748477623, -0.0005537982797250152, -0.030316703021526337, -0.03169582411646843, 0.06592436879873276, -0.015294985845685005, 0.00192818115465343, 0.005429969634860754, 0.026606708765029907, 0.03779691085219383, 0.009566464461386204, -0.0476258285343647, -0.012443033047020435, 0.04118965193629265, 0.06092573702335358, 0.02976052835583687, 0.027198396623134613, -0.040707990527153015, -0.017610058188438416, 0.0071338568814098835, 0.006394252646714449, -0.028231045231223106, 0.0018920453730970621, -0.04622549191117287, -0.025865623727440834, 0.03559054434299469, -0.02768770232796669, 0.02512510120868683, -0.0226577278226614, 0.015646008774638176, -0.03478175401687622, -0.004439766518771648, -0.01729166880249977, 0.0034906677901744843, 0.012425499968230724, 0.0540267638862133, -0.011192969977855682, -0.026149708777666092, -0.019572008401155472, -0.01184487622231245, 0.03651987016201019, 0.07171352952718735, -0.03510519117116928, -0.0111480001360178, 0.013400436379015446, 0.06352119147777557, -0.01113979797810316, -0.06677689403295517, 0.02304673381149769, 0.026091409847140312, -0.006101500708609819, 0.04839219152927399, -0.04033241793513298, -0.04913071170449257, -0.0035401396453380585, -0.0018368643941357732, -0.0023189433850347996, 0.008296137675642967, -0.022887106984853745, 0.05430642515420914, 0.041509877890348434, -0.00074487499659881, 0.07117469608783722, -0.011770986020565033, -0.012144573032855988, 0.0006078526494093239, -0.04489322006702423, 0.021310705691576004, -0.013032808899879456, -0.04458804428577423, -0.06072322651743889, -0.012414942495524883, -0.02783157117664814, 0.014451505616307259, 0.004002525005489588, 0.02533647231757641, -0.010429543443024158, -0.05080591142177582, 0.01219035591930151, 0.02788453921675682, -0.020301178097724915, -0.01717408373951912, 0.009678248316049576, 0.01686004363000393, -0.005920945201069117, -0.057466693222522736, 0.022486813366413116, 0.001490372815169394, 0.011193259619176388, 0.02380707859992981, -0.017543306574225426, 0.019166260957717896, -0.041900694370269775, -0.04061782360076904, -0.01211312785744667, -0.055762507021427155, 0.009663001634180546, -0.005464809946715832, 0.01610761694610119, 0.00460751261562109, -0.048773545771837234, -0.030366497114300728, 0.0105132469907403, -0.016043931245803833, 0.005239961668848991, -0.019632356241345406, 0.0080138323828578, 0.03225505352020264, -0.013827454298734665, -0.05940745025873184, -0.06137881800532341, 0.00849707517772913, 0.0005594532121904194, -0.014909761026501656, -0.01710945926606655, -0.015934225171804428, -0.009044265374541283, -0.0482325404882431, -0.005627565085887909, 0.03237800672650337, -0.03155681490898132, 0.0084420470520854, 0.01762949302792549, 0.01877177506685257, 0.08277729153633118, 0.0017996617825701833, -0.003329089842736721, 0.020369602367281914, -0.019542939960956573, -0.023001395165920258, 0.013366169296205044, 0.05549333244562149, 0.0029597494285553694, 0.019547393545508385, -0.03708641976118088, 0.02875157631933689, 0.043053995817899704, -0.03247593715786934, -0.016755903139710426, 0.006872457452118397, 0.04246706888079643, 0.016009582206606865, -0.018692966550588608, -0.018313612788915634, 0.010761672630906105, 0.024327779188752174, -0.009175945073366165, -0.0216312725096941, -0.017889147624373436, -0.04136677458882332, 0.04244362190365791, -0.013164901174604893, 0.001297054230235517, 0.008673807606101036, 0.07729212194681168, 0.002609695540741086, 0.00983896479010582, 0.0050892215222120285, -0.02200765535235405, 0.03812733665108681, 0.043465036898851395, 0.010896696709096432, 0.03259965777397156, 0.026094935834407806, -0.05313120782375336, -0.05756333842873573, -0.053029052913188934, 0.05238667502999306, 0.0692644864320755, 0.00021480170835275203, 0.03380152955651283, 0.049326349049806595, 0.021785328164696693, 0.008129781112074852, -0.0402916744351387, -0.017350491136312485, 0.0007539275102317333, -0.021905362606048584, 0.01656293496489525, -0.03280118852853775, -0.011476303450763226, 0.04442927613854408, 0.032789573073387146, -0.010753677226603031, 0.01774189993739128, 0.038597140461206436, 0.034961991012096405, 0.001013582106679678, 0.02418048121035099, -0.0639161542057991, 0.031048879027366638, -0.013957117684185505, 0.002372270217165351, -0.021348299458622932, -0.014888303354382515, 0.06373627483844757, 0.03953313082456589, 0.03073987178504467, -0.04111846163868904, -0.023876000195741653, -0.06655757129192352, 0.015848036855459213, -0.004604190122336149, 0.00015031402290333062, 0.020752858370542526, 0.0020634131506085396, 0.02620585821568966, -0.008140119723975658, 0.0021331815514713526, -0.0374070405960083, -0.09200683981180191, -0.04380912706255913, 0.0035469091963022947, -0.0141068734228611, 0.005522176157683134, -0.042924657464027405, -0.044844046235084534, -0.002403394551947713, -0.03741472586989403, 0.017988353967666626, -0.0037267154548317194, 0.02649950236082077, -0.03255617246031761, 0.066164031624794, 0.012027223594486713, -0.0015331966569647193, 0.02263813279569149, 0.01573525369167328, 0.08748158067464828, 0.05065835267305374, 0.01903769187629223, -0.0991709753870964, 0.008582040667533875, -0.0314253605902195, -0.010851969942450523, -0.017007367685437202, 0.037292324006557465, -0.004291033837944269, 0.0153014175593853, 0.013527113012969494, 0.0423751175403595, 0.04037843644618988, -0.012720967642962933, 0.025987980887293816, -0.03348739817738533, -0.04373256117105484, -0.01426640059798956, 0.0230417363345623, -0.01504384446889162, -0.012924063950777054, -0.06509383767843246, 0.0045609669759869576, -0.006275619845837355, -0.024032240733504295, -0.012712087482213974, -0.020321503281593323, -0.009153728373348713, 0.00023891040473245084, 0.0167238749563694, 0.03681120648980141, 0.010706262663006783, 0.004202699288725853, -0.008223406039178371, 0.04406636580824852, 0.038234613835811615, -0.01686418056488037, 0.04339999705553055, -0.007177331019192934, -0.04115651920437813, 0.0288680512458086, 0.02588675729930401, -0.006183108314871788, -0.028617125004529953, -0.025915026664733887, -0.019121039658784866, 0.06385989487171173, -0.046778175979852676, -0.01472829096019268, -0.030622515827417374, 0.0027648708783090115, 0.0016591401072219014, -0.08163945376873016, 0.003157325554639101, -0.009085455909371376, 0.014862347394227982, -0.049771834164857864, -0.03460950404405594, -0.02502538450062275, 0.018555907532572746, -0.023281529545783997, 0.008539656177163124, 0.03587653487920761, -0.04333190619945526, -0.021134981885552406, -0.008709079585969448, 0.06633472442626953, -0.010722503997385502, 0.005672750063240528, 0.0065448652021586895, -0.015158030204474926, -0.027424650266766548, -0.024354027584195137, 0.028647994622588158, 0.018039634451270103, 0.018849842250347137, -0.0070477742701768875, 0.0036160198505967855, 0.013400420546531677, -0.05367633327841759, 0.013369807042181492, -0.037045788019895554, -0.01285829208791256, -0.021132465451955795, 0.005324185360223055, 0.043626025319099426, 0.04085136950016022, -0.01837272197008133, 0.03451747074723244, 0.004856420215219259, 0.02612631767988205, 0.0049134125001728535, -0.044710393995046616, -0.0076635852456092834, 0.022924460470676422, 0.0032647207845002413, -0.012070725671947002, -0.015975167974829674, 0.03682835400104523, 0.042520005255937576, 0.022001687437295914, -0.0162812452763319, 0.04737342149019241, -0.014393765479326248, 0.0069304658100008965, 0.003849488915875554, -0.059878554195165634, 0.03705618157982826, 0.03439077362418175, -0.011341270990669727, -0.031327709555625916, -0.015321407467126846, -0.028336409479379654, 0.004536402877420187, 0.006236420478671789, 0.02477225847542286, -0.055361125618219376, -0.025666750967502594, -0.01635526306927204, 0.005003075581043959, -0.04396292194724083, -0.027715247124433517, -0.04069257900118828, 0.05110184848308563, 0.011764819733798504, 0.002340997103601694, -0.026582760736346245, -0.00285472278483212, -0.013738458976149559, -0.020554427057504654, 0.05853106454014778, 0.02795075625181198, 0.022753341123461723, -0.02297871932387352, 0.023182136937975883, -0.028565406799316406, 0.0317339263856411, -0.014717614278197289, 0.019638100638985634, 0.04176095128059387, -0.023373782634735107, -0.02576712891459465, -0.0012194633018225431, 0.026773521676659584, 0.044209074229002, -0.0022161866072565317, -0.020918458700180054, -0.03765973448753357, 0.03924131020903587, -0.03246086463332176, 0.019726550206542015, -0.03567175939679146, -0.004996107425540686, -0.02148319222033024, -0.034728121012449265, 0.01338214986026287, -0.014766187407076359, 0.01614518277347088, 0.015462030656635761, 0.0027789142914116383, -0.06107029318809509, 0.0051867300644516945, 0.014687816612422466, 0.013926805928349495, 0.010297246277332306, -0.016256365925073624, -0.01545774471014738, -0.0026418990455567837, 0.0615067295730114, -0.0294667799025774, 0.0426657572388649, 0.0016826821956783533, 0.011435804888606071, -0.08211047202348709, -0.027075525373220444, -0.0014940742403268814, 0.0030230015981942415, 0.036997172981500626, -0.05800517648458481, 0.01754879206418991, 0.05222600698471069, -0.011067291721701622, -0.006566546391695738, -0.011954103596508503, -0.00853503867983818, 0.0038055102340877056, -0.0023914312478154898, -0.02543366141617298, 0.023990457877516747, 0.025978658348321915, 0.016149861738085747, 0.05578272417187691, 0.0539209246635437, -0.0060645462945103645, -0.022041307762265205, -0.028579363599419594, 0.024203713983297348, -0.008180701173841953, -0.07427491247653961, 0.02852468192577362, -0.018484728410840034, -0.03113747574388981, 0.03780871629714966, 0.0020129268523305655, 0.010346890427172184, 0.021405229344964027, 0.028158564120531082, 0.013909733854234219, 0.032655246555805206, 0.027889573946595192, -0.010525005869567394, 0.004962419159710407, -0.006423922721296549, 0.026538588106632233, 0.005264227278530598, -0.014866938814520836, 0.04449199140071869, -0.0007662673597224057, -0.016199028119444847, -0.03600455820560455, -0.02315681241452694, -0.028017254546284676, -0.020715933293104172, 0.0012632396537810564, -0.012105192057788372, 0.004188767168670893, -0.044465240091085434, 0.034175239503383636, -0.05036305636167526, -0.04520973190665245, 0.030190547928214073, 0.04759804904460907, -0.04922748729586601, 0.007574256509542465, -0.004127338528633118, -0.04942205175757408, 0.030814005061984062, 0.02618098072707653, -0.026890087872743607, -0.09528401494026184, -0.01999921351671219, -0.0029412065632641315, -0.023567575961351395, -0.00794251263141632, -0.03450135141611099, -0.06391799449920654, 0.016683856025338173, 0.013362347148358822, 0.005831739399582148, -0.02457963488996029, -0.036117810755968094, -0.018304744735360146, -0.05315938964486122, 0.059591393917798996, -0.007824570871889591, -0.021761203184723854, -0.035049159079790115, -0.0013532795710489154, -0.03280618414282799, 0.004316356033086777, 0.05213732272386551, 0.022172201424837112, 0.006709075067192316, 0.012372373603284359, 0.056856073439121246, 0.01965363696217537, -0.02848309651017189, 0.06428373605012894, 0.0164260845631361, -0.02482002042233944, -0.0022790778893977404, -0.017515039071440697, -0.005848178640007973, 0.01306142471730709, -0.027754120528697968, -0.01635628379881382, 0.0005688693490810692, -0.014347326010465622, -0.018586017191410065, 0.02773135155439377, 0.020326491445302963, -0.025658031925559044, 0.043600551784038544, -0.0008168264175765216, 0.013660944066941738, 0.048813726752996445, -0.00295802834443748, -0.02772964909672737, 0.023259775713086128, 0.004603186622262001, -0.015209143981337547, -0.03055145964026451, 0.024699481204152107, 0.0025083429645746946, -0.05661146715283394, -0.012363255023956299, 0.020998911932110786, -0.01906006596982479, 0.0013823489425703883, 0.04496106877923012, -0.008999916724860668, 0.03720135614275932, -0.00826198048889637, -0.009737697429955006, 0.02379295788705349, -0.011370372958481312, 0.043659791350364685, 0.017188917845487595, 0.03628535568714142, 0.00936905574053526, 0.043547216802835464, 0.034323569387197495, -0.02094600722193718, 0.03939800709486008, -0.02548271045088768, 0.031596727669239044, -0.040801532566547394, -0.030633866786956787, 0.006536875851452351, -0.0030387872830033302, 0.026746610179543495, -0.0205615796148777, -0.04793836921453476, 0.05728819966316223, -0.057324543595314026, 0.012873642146587372, 0.005002851597964764, 0.010579714551568031, 0.0005167468334548175, -0.01555098406970501, -0.0031296575907617807, 0.01693868450820446, -0.003182745771482587, -0.003737298073247075, -0.015876993536949158, 0.0032147017773240805, 0.013099907897412777, -0.05815689638257027, 0.02970997989177704, 0.0019283276051282883, -0.019143063575029373, -0.04749343544244766, -0.01384824700653553, -0.019209761172533035, -0.01737590879201889, 0.030812900513410568, 0.03911281377077103, 0.011347698047757149, -0.02396959625184536, -0.04391461983323097, -0.003310288768261671, 0.04219342768192291, -0.0652722716331482, -0.025381742045283318, -0.036661650985479355, 0.027394460514187813, -0.04017719253897667, -0.01267291884869337 ]
<p>I'm trying to reproduce a derivation of the cokriging equations that involves the cross covariance and the cross variogram. This derivation is included in the Multivariate Geostatistics by Wackernagel. However, I can't reproduce the following result:</p> <p>\begin{align}{}\sigma_{E}^{2} &amp;= \sum_{i=1}^{N} \sum_{j=1}^{N} \sum_{\alpha=0}^{n_{i}}\sum_{\beta=0}^{n_{j}} w_{\alpha}^{i}w_{\beta}^{j}C_{ij}^{I}(x_{\alpha},x_{\beta})\\ &amp;=2\sum_{i=1}^{N}\sum_{\alpha=1}^{n_{i}}w_{\alpha}^{i}\gamma_{ii_{0}}(x_{\alpha} -x_{0})-\gamma_{i_{0}i_{0}}(x_{0} -x_{0})\\ &amp;-\sum_{i=1}^{N} \sum_{j=1}^{N} \sum_{\alpha=1}^{n_{i}}\sum_{\beta=1}^{n_{j}} w_{\alpha}^{i}w_{\beta}^{j}\gamma_{ij}(x_{\alpha} -x_{\beta})\end{align}</p> <p>The cross covariance of the increments is defined as</p> <p>$$C_{ij}^{I}= E[(Z_{i}(x_{\alpha})-Z_{i}(0))(Z_{j}(x_{\beta})-Z_{j}(0))]$$</p> <p>and the cross variogram is defined as</p> <p>$$\gamma_{ij}(h) = \frac{1}{2}E[(Z_{i}(x+h)-Z_{i}(x))(Z_{j}(x+h)-Z_{j}(x))]$$</p> <p>There are a couple of conditions for the weights $w_{\alpha}^{i}$:</p> <p>\begin{equation} \sum_{\alpha=1}^{n_{i}}w_{\alpha}^{i} = \delta_{ii_{0}}\\ w_{0}^{i} = -\delta_{ii_{0}} \end{equation}</p> <p>where $\delta_{ii_{0}} = 1$ if $i=i_{0}$ and $\delta_{ii_{0}} = 0$ otherwise.</p> <p>I think I can get to this expression that is extremely similar to the required equality</p> <p>\begin{align}{}\sigma_{E}^{2} &amp;=2\sum_{i=1}^{N}\sum_{\alpha=1}^{n_{i}}w_{\alpha}^{i}C_{ii_{0}}(x_{\alpha},x_{0})-C_{i_{0}i_{0}}(x_{0},x_{0})\\ &amp;-\sum_{i=1}^{N} \sum_{j=1}^{N} \sum_{\alpha=1}^{n_{i}}\sum_{\beta=1}^{n_{j}} w_{\alpha}^{i}w_{\beta}^{j}C_{ij}(x_{\alpha},x_{\beta})\end{align}</p> <p>Next, I tried to obtain an expression for the cross covariances of the increments $C_{ij}^{I}$ in terms of the cross variogram $\gamma_{ij}(h)$ using the trick of adding 0 (with a random variable $Z(0)$) to the products of the variogram:</p> <p>$$\gamma_{ij}(h) = \frac{1}{2}E[(Z_{i}(x+h)-Z_{i}(x)+Z_{i}(0)-Z_{i}(0))(Z_{j}(x+h)-Z_{j}(x)+Z_{j}(0)-Z_{j}(0))]$$</p> <p>which produces the following:</p> <p>$$C_{ij}^{I}(x, x+h)=-\gamma_{ij}(h)+\gamma_{ij}(x+h)+\gamma_{ij}(x)$$</p> <p>However, when I substitute this in the equation for $\sigma_{E}^{2}$, there are extra terms that should not be there. So most likely I'm making a mistake.</p> <p>I would appreciate any help.</p>
73,606
[ -0.006700862664729357, -0.012668662704527378, 0.038161683827638626, 0.01728060096502304, 0.040690306574106216, -0.008290181867778301, -0.013749184086918831, 0.0017064237035810947, 0.017483873292803764, -0.06215262413024902, 0.023403389379382133, 0.01813773810863495, 0.07469221204519272, 0.05041985958814621, 0.01763974502682686, 0.008799846284091473, -0.004549500532448292, 0.043040644377470016, -0.02121598832309246, -0.018636280670762062, 0.0029639399144798517, 0.02173612080514431, -0.023979848250746727, -0.014061584137380123, -0.038616061210632324, 0.041483182460069656, 0.004746740683913231, -0.03375633433461189, 0.005486955866217613, 0.052941687405109406, 0.0002042974520009011, -0.022081788629293442, -0.009261900559067726, 0.023264847695827484, -0.027496900409460068, 0.00532143097370863, -0.005710812751203775, -0.06270186603069305, 0.003372669918462634, 0.04830058291554451, -0.01616138406097889, -0.007997648790478706, -0.013805915601551533, 0.041071817278862, -0.035509783774614334, 0.006310395430773497, -0.027576779946684837, 0.0011739872861653566, 0.024043338373303413, 0.006509571801871061, 0.06725410372018814, 0.021860528737306595, 0.01757393591105938, 0.029993142932653427, -0.054280005395412445, -0.004038996063172817, 0.04961633309721947, 0.02783196233212948, 0.04175512120127678, -0.06276221573352814, 0.003565498860552907, 0.006915144622325897, -0.0034969919361174107, -0.04063169285655022, -0.0073237307369709015, 0.004377694800496101, 0.047187745571136475, -0.012378991581499577, -0.0003104464849457145, 0.0026649772189557552, 0.033443745225667953, -0.01173620019108057, 0.029411297291517258, -0.04096810519695282, 0.0015115684363991022, -0.013995309360325336, -0.012963179498910904, 0.03120487555861473, 0.03123418241739273, 0.0033246020320802927, 0.03438423201441765, 0.053917523473501205, 0.01519980188459158, 0.017599279060959816, -0.031713102012872696, 0.010235868394374847, 0.10132787376642227, -0.035131800919771194, 0.008966375142335892, 0.03626803308725357, 0.0032636329997330904, 0.007526229601353407, 0.026160763576626778, -0.00788481067866087, -0.007585340179502964, 0.03245306760072708, -0.01507136132568121, 0.016174685209989548, -0.017238590866327286, 0.0012077890569344163, -0.025356264784932137, -0.049421392381191254, 0.03429966792464256, 0.027182068675756454, 0.0106403399258852, 0.014828660525381565, -0.011996534653007984, 0.01157760713249445, -0.061530716717243195, -0.0651356428861618, -0.029998572543263435, 0.0379769466817379, 0.01695099286735058, -0.004409520421177149, 0.009757544845342636, -0.0039431434124708176, 0.024333925917744637, 0.0021180976182222366, 0.017927128821611404, 0.048017654567956924, 0.05235805734992027, -0.01011136919260025, 0.01849670708179474, -0.01569618284702301, -0.09789060056209564, -0.011747251264750957, -0.0029637732077389956, 0.014373298734426498, -0.04787605255842209, 0.049610819667577744, 0.032761625945568085, -0.03717194125056267, 0.0183598343282938, 0.032803576439619064, 0.010156792588531971, 0.031893450766801834, -0.10705579072237015, -0.018679143860936165, 0.03422045707702637, -0.014511565677821636, 0.060398563742637634, -0.04841648042201996, 0.017787571996450424, -0.011714916676282883, 0.05125805735588074, 0.005214546341449022, 0.0538964681327343, 0.005290442146360874, 0.03506924957036972, -0.01879388652741909, -0.020840609446167946, -0.06507445871829987, -0.026228491216897964, -0.02318645641207695, -0.04173774644732475, -0.07787591218948364, 0.03116300329566002, 0.017932862043380737, -0.04659902676939964, 0.016539640724658966, 0.04898308217525482, -0.0058374362997710705, -0.007754286751151085, -0.004604187794029713, 0.013964582234621048, -0.06566198915243149, 0.03770313784480095, 0.006232778541743755, -0.0033071134239435196, 0.018424497917294502, -0.003946093376725912, -0.019707409664988518, -0.03546097129583359, 0.05419144406914711, 0.051936909556388855, -0.0405074767768383, 0.019707702100276947, 0.022840742021799088, -0.035374730825424194, 0.04302636533975601, -0.04089998081326485, 0.002241595648229122, -0.03029971942305565, 0.013580143451690674, 0.03561077639460564, 0.025235343724489212, 0.008245659060776234, -0.019861821085214615, -0.0022914845030754805, -0.015310504473745823, -0.022045448422431946, -0.04815684258937836, -0.00868543516844511, 0.03378568962216377, -0.00827800389379263, 0.05598034709692001, -0.03921488672494888, 0.020355230197310448, 0.054821331053972244, -0.031107133254408836, 0.03773823380470276, 0.035896819084882736, 0.0365431047976017, -0.041594576090574265, -0.0038360178004950285, 0.015467011369764805, 0.07205228507518768, 0.023992376402020454, 0.05011281371116638, 0.023589596152305603, -0.02623891830444336, -0.017229240387678146, 0.003843560116365552, 0.029034096747636795, -0.018870379775762558, 0.008552963845431805, 0.011577610857784748, 0.01085134968161583, 0.02009207382798195, -0.0003984964278060943, -0.060776323080062866, 0.0032069094013422728, 0.12306535989046097, 0.032731130719184875, -0.024182023480534554, 0.02758403681218624, -0.02664337493479252, 0.020266737788915634, -0.034146200865507126, -0.02936643175780773, -0.009910394437611103, 0.024663472548127174, 0.022558463737368584, 0.03519803658127785, -0.03391873091459274, -0.020205434411764145, 0.01957811415195465, 0.043517474085092545, -0.05547834187746048, 0.03992215543985367, 0.020342791453003883, -0.01788201741874218, -0.0051782694645226, -0.0035438681952655315, 0.021208224818110466, -0.011185314506292343, -0.01650412380695343, -0.03593282401561737, 0.03490906581282616, -0.03976243734359741, -0.058726754039525986, 0.007633792702108622, -0.026864130049943924, -0.021742111071944237, -0.03918443247675896, -0.008618579246103764, 0.04106345400214195, 0.006473624147474766, 0.017508571967482567, 0.04389128461480141, 0.017281686887145042, -0.025173643603920937, -0.013540598563849926, -0.02288913168013096, 0.0068587311543524265, 0.016589555889368057, 0.013481933623552322, 0.013650509528815746, -0.01791268214583397, -0.001580520998686552, 0.032972078770399094, -0.04673995450139046, -0.041403982788324356, -0.006755312439054251, -0.03440026938915253, -0.011607053689658642, 0.059275947511196136, -0.03713139519095421, -0.013199926353991032, -0.019191041588783264, -0.02613052912056446, 0.014911172911524773, 0.07391446083784103, 0.029370825737714767, -0.03039669245481491, 0.012796827591955662, -0.04176183417439461, 0.050665516406297684, 0.05311523750424385, 0.0010145192500203848, -0.02381877414882183, 0.024540698155760765, 0.004377852659672499, -0.04857540875673294, -0.03046206198632717, -0.03678073361515999, 0.00677926791831851, -0.07370539009571075, -0.004102043807506561, 0.03613552451133728, 0.0000995380396489054, -0.042793720960617065, 0.027571283280849457, 0.004249203484505415, -0.03076951391994953, -0.033443428575992584, -0.009206182323396206, 0.007622271776199341, 0.007466861978173256, 0.017839185893535614, 0.030795389786362648, 0.010665091685950756, 0.0014124952722340822, -0.04717345908284187, -0.0859045758843422, 0.004629230592399836, -0.019489478319883347, 0.007098478265106678, -0.02163511887192726, -0.030926423147320747, 0.07687155157327652, 0.003135271603241563, 0.016105419024825096, -0.028710465878248215, 0.058139368891716, 0.0007300192955881357, -0.027496561408042908, 0.00303037092089653, -0.02616678550839424, 0.018271401524543762, 0.050646670162677765, -0.02569546364247799, 0.031376540660858154, 0.09155157208442688, -0.00850443821400404, 0.017601357772946358, 0.02446535974740982, -0.028632359579205513, 0.04051411524415016, 0.051235076040029526, -0.01000758446753025, 0.019796254113316536, 0.006151176057755947, -0.0010122602107003331, -0.01009623147547245, 0.02815956436097622, -0.07017997652292252, 0.004314865451306105, 0.0011007344583049417, 0.006226952187716961, -0.06415418535470963, 0.05349533632397652, 0.019353900104761124, -0.039085276424884796, 0.0017299295868724585, -0.0017039224039763212, 0.07353737950325012, -0.012387114576995373, -0.0049859522841870785, 0.05886518210172653, 0.006673125084489584, -0.013545186258852482, 0.001013664179481566, -0.023538434877991676, 0.00022633931075688452, 0.042952798306941986, -0.02766796201467514, -0.004519639536738396, 0.02389342524111271, 0.0068552568554878235, -0.0008157524280250072, 0.0007256973185576499, -0.024642501026391983, -0.01822737231850624, -0.054940011352300644, 0.0058340104296803474, -0.029380720108747482, 0.040413081645965576, -0.009169443510472775, 0.05026374012231827, -0.007917412556707859, -0.02980884164571762, -0.0075675370171666145, -0.013239703141152859, -0.025093741714954376, 0.0013530964497476816, 0.00526792835444212, -0.0010340196313336492, -0.007610210683196783, -0.06429898738861084, 0.010845509357750416, -0.006067127920687199, 0.027909334748983383, 0.016527296975255013, 0.014097759500145912, -0.010390673764050007, 0.02239418216049671, -0.03770795091986656, -0.047715943306684494, -0.011440879665315151, 0.03413943201303482, 0.02997862733900547, -0.036422550678253174, 0.01274743489921093, 0.007157467771321535, 0.024722563102841377, 0.027335485443472862, -0.05648620054125786, 0.013346204534173012, 0.02339138463139534, -0.02648788131773472, -0.01070429291576147, 0.010154938325285912, -0.03819965198636055, 0.01670323871076107, -0.01915832981467247, 0.038680385798215866, 0.06427071243524551, 0.0024441296700388193, 0.0007472970755770802, -0.061258185654878616, -0.008138392120599747, 0.007426525931805372, 0.04260256141424179, 0.029194703325629234, 0.035607509315013885, 0.04241684079170227, 0.04526180773973465, -0.03710759058594704, 0.06712996959686279, 0.05771903693675995, 0.0003669188008643687, 0.019759749993681908, -0.021069051697850227, -0.013412726111710072, 0.002108139218762517, -0.031023770570755005, 0.02929781563580036, -0.0026521666441112757, -0.022690825164318085, -0.012815549969673157, 0.02107258513569832, 0.008268027566373348, 0.023106172680854797, 0.02378726936876774, 0.015956154093146324, 0.020548202097415924, 0.010295412503182888, -0.0031125848181545734, -0.0020200007129460573, 0.020691711455583572, 0.019851040095090866, 0.029305996373295784, 0.010580345056951046, -0.05172169208526611, -0.04727650061249733, 0.0337144210934639, 0.0182630717754364, -0.020927131175994873, 0.00923550222069025, -0.06597010046243668, -0.014446510002017021, 0.02564660832285881, -0.02245156839489937, 0.015062040649354458, -0.01776127889752388, 0.0168254803866148, -0.001934926607646048, -0.021574461832642555, -0.06356935203075409, 0.021897954866290092, -0.04603170230984688, 0.02029074728488922, -0.023197053000330925, 0.020757004618644714, -0.029681840911507607, -0.0030658987816423178, 0.042256250977516174, 0.03878946974873543, -0.011338811367750168, -0.005720790475606918, -0.03726840764284134, 0.031585220247507095, -0.02369757927954197, -0.05221603065729141, 0.017008990049362183, -0.022480931133031845, -0.00925713311880827, 0.0467560812830925, 0.009592394344508648, -0.035178959369659424, 0.005190987605601549, 0.01573910377919674, 0.030403748154640198, 0.00872182659804821, -0.03496886044740677, 0.08142255246639252, 0.030531641095876694, -0.011923486366868019, 0.08518939465284348, 0.02546093240380287, -0.03500508517026901, 0.033162921667099, -0.046212807297706604, -0.000296754646115005, -0.02719685435295105, -0.03231390565633774, -0.05798197537660599, 0.023567281663417816, -0.014350690878927708, 0.016824139282107353, -0.04716373607516289, 0.020792128518223763, -0.04092897102236748, -0.04082896560430527, 0.04303499683737755, 0.012414704076945782, -0.047099851071834564, 0.021397041156888008, 0.01486363634467125, 0.01667049713432789, 0.02445382811129093, -0.050159040838479996, 0.0091959647834301, -0.0016258476534858346, -0.019660618156194687, 0.026510847732424736, -0.009716499596834183, -0.012230520136654377, -0.027133943513035774, 0.010111631825566292, -0.025735853239893913, -0.0020373344887048006, 0.02699718251824379, 0.002328603994101286, 0.03826959431171417, -0.008323193527758121, -0.03366732969880104, -0.016326364129781723, 0.029663072898983955, -0.024003509432077408, 0.01655336655676365, -0.029462400823831558, -0.019611412659287453, 0.02411731146275997, -0.017883189022541046, -0.09412065893411636, -0.04165205359458923, 0.04990200698375702, -0.005679254420101643, -0.027975065633654594, -0.021342601627111435, -0.016479669138789177, 0.008231790736317635, -0.05439987778663635, -0.013914907351136208, 0.046658314764499664, -0.024486958980560303, 0.013206234201788902, -0.0018184157088398933, 0.012995535507798195, 0.0844869539141655, -0.0363798588514328, 0.006172107066959143, 0.022318823263049126, -0.03138446435332298, -0.029115820303559303, 0.003370936494320631, -0.013699960894882679, -0.012401935644447803, -0.01250961609184742, 0.011661085300147533, -0.019237095490098, 0.00217303354293108, -0.026017775759100914, -0.06147398427128792, -0.025814805179834366, -0.0034288896713405848, 0.008412717841565609, -0.00789597351104021, -0.044126249849796295, 0.025691337883472443, 0.02558787539601326, -0.047084856778383255, -0.0041729663498699665, -0.044240403920412064, -0.0023746767546981573, -0.015254268422722816, -0.00817915890365839, -0.036483149975538254, 0.026393676176667213, 0.06403234601020813, -0.018944254145026207, -0.01595207303762436, 0.03279734030365944, -0.0044928439892828465, 0.01903657242655754, 0.017661886289715767, -0.012122610583901405, 0.020277371630072594, -0.009462589398026466, -0.03542141243815422, -0.015125083737075329, -0.050415150821208954, 0.028769193217158318, 0.06492868810892105, -0.01423747930675745, 0.016290094703435898, 0.03662385046482086, -0.000701027805916965, -0.0038260603323578835, -0.03711867332458496, -0.010765250772237778, -0.002400300931185484, -0.007425259333103895, 0.03357187658548355, -0.008152266964316368, -0.030833043158054352, 0.038658905774354935, 0.041414905339479446, -0.039983827620744705, 0.011945501901209354, -0.03225596249103546, 0.03731536865234375, -0.04420933499932289, 0.0045311362482607365, -0.09277500212192535, 0.03226751834154129, 0.001958607928827405, -0.014419575221836567, 0.009354745037853718, -0.04707157611846924, 0.030634477734565735, 0.03641754388809204, -0.004428402055054903, -0.049577195197343826, -0.03465796262025833, -0.02047448232769966, 0.03474821522831917, 0.026755061000585556, -0.002912233816459775, 0.014284693636000156, -0.0276031456887722, 0.024194560945034027, -0.029193472117185593, -0.00045847156434319913, -0.03361763060092926, -0.05252445116639137, 0.01730344071984291, -0.015026548877358437, -0.041800469160079956, 0.01677277311682701, -0.008676005527377129, -0.0329413078725338, -0.002699224976822734, -0.0007247139001265168, 0.05085966736078262, 0.024932345375418663, 0.007395201828330755, 0.024257510900497437, 0.058455947786569595, -0.012415481731295586, -0.0190720371901989, -0.000985131599009037, 0.005159796681255102, 0.14511729776859283, 0.05504023656249046, 0.045407358556985855, -0.029304826632142067, -0.02136983908712864, -0.018974697217345238, -0.005294898059219122, -0.007245353423058987, 0.03678233548998833, 0.0019027357921004295, -0.03650180622935295, 0.04106367751955986, 0.03679106757044792, -0.0036589624360203743, -0.007152327802032232, 0.043982721865177155, -0.011637424118816853, 0.004771576263010502, -0.020119985565543175, -0.015051502734422684, -0.03210120648145676, 0.0006421969155780971, -0.06231177598237991, -0.012628927826881409, -0.03181828558444977, -0.015456720255315304, -0.03400730341672897, -0.007010483182966709, -0.015474746935069561, 0.014398914761841297, -0.0252245906740427, 0.03029255010187626, 0.027446324005723, 0.00025443718186579645, -0.01746344566345215, 0.00668339291587472, 0.013121032156050205, -0.04670197516679764, 0.052218686789274216, 0.0037200739607214928, 0.013606814667582512, 0.02844337932765484, 0.0034451207611709833, 0.03258289769291878, -0.01976701244711876, 0.014821458607912064, -0.013968752697110176, 0.049911074340343475, -0.00728498725220561, 0.008977982215583324, -0.0006905815680511296, -0.02680785208940506, 0.012604347430169582, -0.017121268436312675, 0.038189444690942764, -0.010349603369832039, 0.007254257798194885, -0.02441975101828575, -0.02368832193315029, -0.004389546345919371, 0.0028548957780003548, 0.0028075999580323696, 0.03429895266890526, -0.0028283526189625263, -0.045986372977495193, -0.03525847569108009, -0.022187331691384315, 0.03281474858522415, 0.0034435708075761795, 0.0022114524617791176, 0.013662954792380333, -0.006752933841198683, -0.026875898241996765, -0.0231317188590765, 0.013759782537817955, -0.029701251536607742, 0.05008476600050926, 0.010848920792341232, -0.022130092605948448, -0.009640838950872421, -0.04139944911003113, -0.01828105002641678, -0.02100558578968048, -0.0008419475052505732, -0.034784190356731415, -0.012598000466823578, 0.025684146210551262, 0.06730027496814728, -0.005173151846975088, 0.012860904447734356, -0.022173896431922913, 0.06452731043100357, 0.031049514189362526, -0.03963538631796837, -0.019828112795948982, 0.013737181201577187, 0.03267711028456688, -0.034263789653778076, -0.012013114988803864, 0.014443233609199524, 0.03581710532307625, 0.04546334594488144, 0.009970838204026222, 0.04267527535557747, -0.014614615589380264, -0.0200673658400774, -0.017333969473838806, -0.021662715822458267, 0.019370414316654205, 0.019728852435946465, 0.0039121732115745544, -0.017889725044369698, 0.029636869207024574, -0.010053320787847042, -0.022972814738750458, -0.0002543804293964058, 0.004255165345966816, -0.02996019646525383, -0.047303058207035065, -0.02845034934580326, 0.004434606060385704, 0.012924258597195148, -0.01643151231110096, -0.014333673752844334, 0.022824468091130257, -0.025149811059236526, 0.0014814210589975119, -0.004857326857745647, 0.026184432208538055, -0.033253733068704605, 0.020248569548130035, 0.0632508173584938, 0.03902120888233185, 0.02025662176311016, 0.009105293080210686, 0.01773000694811344, -0.010154054500162601, 0.025883149355649948, 0.0114311333745718, 0.01512676291167736, -0.010451259091496468, 0.0033087776973843575, -0.02550628036260605, 0.004355939105153084, -0.0011278445599600673, 0.06048673763871193, 0.034057535231113434, -0.017756439745426178, -0.0711977407336235, 0.045280057936906815, -0.007692018058151007, 0.012725364416837692, -0.02004464901983738, 0.025857994332909584, -0.008559309877455235, 0.00035006715916097164, 0.03887056186795235, 0.01610710471868515, 0.01907973736524582, 0.004447246436029673, 0.011403984390199184, -0.026846993714571, -0.012029649689793587, -0.00994300376623869, -0.05017805099487305, -0.02870946004986763, 0.031148988753557205, -0.00033024762524291873, 0.01811559870839119, 0.07079100608825684, -0.02142837829887867, 0.02058563195168972, -0.010836671106517315, 0.03486839309334755, -0.088603176176548, -0.029537800699472427, 0.007856554351747036, 0.022469358518719673, 0.05194946378469467, -0.02299455553293228, 0.024598415940999985, 0.04489289969205856, -0.08445270359516144, 0.003839748213067651, 0.005062530282884836, -0.016105404123663902, -0.022542519494891167, 0.0025107995606958866, -0.01689266599714756, 0.03669285029172897, 0.046406444162130356, 0.057159390300512314, 0.018852779641747475, 0.07496345788240433, -0.061050768941640854, -0.004084977321326733, -0.041368719190359116, -0.0018179055768996477, 0.021035734564065933, -0.00938897579908371, 0.02774815261363983, -0.012999563477933407, -0.027133775874972343, 0.02146240323781967, -0.02119872346520424, -0.0443909578025341, 0.0096046794205904, 0.07489141076803207, 0.02658071368932724, 0.040503110736608505, 0.02471749670803547, 0.00060336320893839, 0.021377449855208397, -0.011126586236059666, -0.00539766438305378, -0.01481516845524311, -0.01611870527267456, 0.014381790533661842, 0.053470999002456665, -0.009503411129117012, -0.0416734553873539, 0.016574960201978683, -0.022419188171625137, -0.004527517594397068, -0.02730528824031353, 0.0247700996696949, 0.025872860103845596, -0.034124720841646194, 0.04895208030939102, -0.04271021857857704, -0.012663302943110466, 0.013402977958321571, 0.004292828496545553, -0.06366224586963654, -0.037406034767627716, -0.016025645658373833, -0.05994470790028572, -0.00862570758908987, -0.003795344615355134, -0.01786019466817379, -0.03219650313258171, -0.013851535506546497, 0.0022184145636856556, -0.020845133811235428, -0.03172491863369942, -0.021059490740299225, -0.06104714795947075, 0.011564518325030804, -0.007594582624733448, -0.008605951443314552, -0.01624976098537445, 0.006247234530746937, 0.03195059671998024, -0.05926228687167168, 0.03316207602620125, -0.018806802108883858, -0.016331780701875687, -0.02248818427324295, 0.0019167691934853792, -0.0025676225777715445, 0.004547726828604937, 0.06567095220088959, -0.00264899805188179, -0.015545849688351154, 0.012761621735990047, 0.04117526859045029, 0.005003300495445728, -0.00779753876850009, 0.06372825056314468, 0.0018322247778996825, -0.055403050035238266, 0.018321700394153595, -0.0006699445657432079, -0.022046536207199097, 0.04263812676072121, 0.00404431251809001, -0.009404986165463924, 0.012653995305299759, -0.017176881432533264, -0.045810241252183914, 0.004527769982814789, -0.008807362988591194, -0.0547645129263401, 0.07301286607980728, -0.03634953871369362, 0.0008866452844813466, 0.018012018874287605, 0.0002625996130518615, -0.023918142542243004, -0.0007298338459804654, -0.006353395059704781, -0.02933182381093502, -0.005313424859195948, 0.0657697543501854, 0.0017281238688156009, -0.028330834582448006, 0.023700106889009476, 0.02672242932021618, -0.01850615069270134, -0.03174228221178055, 0.06655243784189224, 0.019810082390904427, 0.02716483175754547, 0.01646122708916664, -0.0033845873549580574, -0.007960963062942028, -0.003904422977939248, 0.062477387487888336, 0.04096175357699394, 0.006434365175664425, -0.0074626486748456955, 0.012480580247938633, -0.005626473110169172, -0.00918376911431551, 0.031626828014850616, 0.008111451752483845, 0.0297040194272995, -0.003970119636505842, -0.023899797350168228, 0.04754530265927315, -0.012532053515315056, 0.009707639925181866, 0.003601403906941414, -0.0267214123159647, 0.08446040004491806, -0.022167377173900604, 0.03619056195020676, -0.003194698365405202, 0.0005347310216166079, -0.005422050133347511, -0.03098199889063835, -0.015397501178085804, 0.0158640518784523, 0.009356587193906307, -0.0021390425972640514, -0.05365218222141266, -0.01567133329808712, 0.015575188212096691, -0.023480845615267754, 0.010203198529779911, 0.006711852736771107, -0.00689771817997098, 0.03000287152826786, -0.021360117942094803, -0.02818377874791622, -0.009876138530671597, 0.016202641651034355, 0.005678707268089056, 0.012518975883722305, -0.0009467038908042014, 0.004118205979466438, -0.023369263857603073, 0.03917930647730827, -0.008868332020938396, -0.014288591220974922, -0.01175396516919136, 0.037550657987594604, -0.001002281322143972, -0.008948968723416328 ]
<p>What statistical analysis would I use when testing 35 participants. pre &amp; post test and checking for changes after 1 intervention and a control group with no intervention? I have one mediating variable, 3 independent variables and two dependent variables.</p>
73,607
[ -0.038509294390678406, 0.03033568151295185, -0.050252463668584824, 0.0015153755666688085, 0.0710846334695816, -0.004224970005452633, -0.00024151010438799858, -0.04948672652244568, 0.016727371141314507, -0.006781843025237322, 0.050597529858350754, 0.011499128304421902, 0.05204059183597565, -0.02471730299293995, 0.025354815647006035, 0.008063768036663532, -0.021917715668678284, 0.0020372960716485977, -0.011512303724884987, 0.020398316904902458, -0.004877588711678982, -0.011742575094103813, -0.009722054935991764, -0.0010389923118054867, -0.02644292265176773, 0.03027283400297165, 0.014096511527895927, -0.03665264695882797, 0.00468504149466753, 0.01983763836324215, -0.05389393866062164, -0.021790795028209686, -0.021990686655044556, 0.023440467193722725, -0.02648046985268593, 0.0025698512326925993, -0.019934289157390594, -0.036838382482528687, -0.0020177126862108707, 0.03198493272066116, -0.027907803654670715, 0.037272702902555466, -0.026393454521894455, 0.03120589628815651, -0.023000916466116905, 0.014270313084125519, 0.0020788770634680986, -0.062155429273843765, 0.052642058581113815, -0.02486415021121502, 0.1043921634554863, -0.019748719409108162, 0.04472651332616806, 0.006266358774155378, -0.015691375359892845, -0.012583304196596146, 0.0869738981127739, 0.030506568029522896, 0.003874448360875249, -0.05393197387456894, -0.05375794693827629, -0.016681388020515442, 0.007927916944026947, -0.013210616074502468, -0.04209691286087036, 0.027198683470487595, 0.0023506281431764364, 0.006063060835003853, 0.04462235048413277, 0.0005415728082880378, 0.030772482976317406, -0.019901882857084274, 0.05170564725995064, 0.040566977113485336, -0.041556693613529205, -0.004811626393347979, 0.020607326179742813, 0.03032446838915348, 0.0027693682350218296, 0.041181378066539764, -0.026257632300257683, -0.026610078290104866, 0.0029920823872089386, 0.0708673894405365, -0.0021028006449341774, -0.03606416657567024, 0.05901570990681648, 0.003146953647956252, 0.020903117954730988, 0.0013623990816995502, -0.05286656692624092, -0.025736533105373383, 0.0667060986161232, 0.02946503832936287, -0.04118630290031433, 0.000274231715593487, -0.04498401656746864, 0.044012244790792465, -0.0065711019560694695, 0.0007234178483486176, 0.005588142201304436, -0.038929201662540436, 0.015285550616681576, 0.0198324266821146, -0.02462427318096161, 0.021529387682676315, -0.056207772344350815, -0.009225807152688503, -0.004389134701341391, -0.019481400027871132, -0.006910508964210749, 0.018972154706716537, -0.019147388637065887, -0.01566505618393421, 0.052194587886333466, -0.004134927410632372, -0.020427793264389038, -0.021851573139429092, 0.07409150898456573, 0.0452297069132328, 0.07165071368217468, -0.04311300441622734, 0.0345195010304451, 0.000837874598801136, -0.016927655786275864, 0.0014022456016391516, -0.006337873172014952, -0.0005314901936799288, -0.009165898896753788, 0.05580110847949982, 0.0050746905617415905, -0.03354977071285248, 0.05320236086845398, -0.01122985128313303, 0.015961430966854095, 0.03382675722241402, -0.06354396045207977, -0.06099385768175125, 0.029730074107646942, -0.041340842843055725, 0.018854103982448578, -0.04576709121465683, -0.02122148498892784, 0.013822948560118675, 0.05683119595050812, -0.005157080944627523, 0.012731672264635563, 0.0055894749239087105, 0.03877280279994011, 0.03862229362130165, -0.046225808560848236, 0.0011516440426930785, -0.03171319141983986, -0.0004959735670126975, -0.008861597627401352, -0.06488245725631714, 0.013935348019003868, 0.014682422392070293, -0.02576303668320179, 0.015038318000733852, 0.03438004106283188, -0.007446420378983021, -0.004352657124400139, -0.024253614246845245, 0.028001120314002037, -0.0069026462733745575, 0.02058134600520134, -0.04294716194272041, 0.009658771567046642, 0.0010850878898054361, 0.02048630267381668, 0.034540459513664246, 0.043297216296195984, 0.0628584697842598, 0.044546399265527725, -0.015857798978686333, 0.0463305339217186, 0.010898781009018421, -0.006522636394947767, -0.017432978376746178, -0.058382030576467514, -0.023913362994790077, -0.004045102279633284, -0.011193208396434784, 0.028554348275065422, 0.03497777879238129, -0.016200168058276176, 0.004959067329764366, 0.029496517032384872, -0.02693336457014084, -0.004318983759731054, -0.08433495461940765, 0.012276390567421913, 0.02505454793572426, -0.04019100219011307, 0.02296862192451954, 0.005754968151450157, 0.047146108001470566, -0.038861487060785294, -0.028225060552358627, -0.007112124469131231, -0.0031356802210211754, 0.053785160183906555, -0.030850373208522797, -0.0008105207234621048, -0.00007192263728938997, 0.05200941115617752, -0.00281689316034317, 0.04354625195264816, -0.03485886752605438, 0.00533521082252264, 0.0020101533737033606, -0.009315639734268188, 0.031518321484327316, -0.02125399559736252, -0.019363675266504288, -0.013027533888816833, 0.0038800579495728016, -0.026163361966609955, 0.03205430880188942, -0.08301040530204773, 0.09180770814418793, 0.04390640929341316, -0.0028802899178117514, 0.028895849362015724, -0.0310217272490263, -0.0027341502718627453, 0.018060527741909027, -0.019788948819041252, -0.03964745253324509, -0.0150605458766222, -0.01568053476512432, 0.027858953922986984, -0.029871445149183273, -0.02025224082171917, 0.028874369338154793, 0.07365601509809494, -0.019966870546340942, 0.013817301020026207, 0.04910997673869133, 0.013079199008643627, -0.03646725416183472, -0.016023792326450348, 0.0591634102165699, -0.012035525403916836, -0.004214214626699686, 0.0007316068513318896, 0.01280604861676693, 0.01152784377336502, 0.039852894842624664, 0.005644405726343393, 0.03810952603816986, 0.00013092989684082568, -0.0018494048854336143, -0.0585334487259388, -0.014851110056042671, 0.01630556769669056, 0.020297886803746223, 0.009289076551795006, 0.03298679366707802, 0.041761137545108795, -0.04058924317359924, 0.014164386317133904, -0.008311021141707897, 0.025713570415973663, 0.03770044818520546, -0.05585382506251335, 0.0343342125415802, 0.03418155014514923, -0.045839328318834305, 0.050200529396533966, -0.017084451392292976, -0.037276335060596466, -0.035031355917453766, -0.0011917233932763338, 0.004369047936052084, 0.045860979706048965, 0.047094713896512985, -0.0563172847032547, -0.016943229362368584, -0.008282107301056385, 0.025661252439022064, 0.03714481368660927, 0.0009948175866156816, -0.05186605453491211, -0.004812647122889757, -0.024079816415905952, 0.014594060368835926, 0.02377857081592083, -0.02974621020257473, -0.015439608134329319, 0.05176301300525665, -0.007105900906026363, -0.03975553810596466, -0.03512515500187874, -0.013065560720860958, 0.02713150531053543, 0.0053528728894889355, -0.04004593566060066, 0.05169104039669037, 0.030875900760293007, -0.007223012391477823, 0.027896782383322716, -0.00503797410055995, -0.025416551157832146, 0.026551589369773865, -0.0040622903034091, -0.005659028422087431, 0.002425138372927904, 0.010431570000946522, 0.010148780420422554, -0.04588622599840164, 0.00282378145493567, -0.07366099953651428, -0.08585844933986664, 0.032352130860090256, 0.000056663040595594794, 0.050702475011348724, -0.008730373345315456, -0.034596458077430725, 0.041343484073877335, 0.0122717609629035, -0.014047414064407349, -0.05964243412017822, 0.017793189734220505, -0.03789231553673744, -0.0165824294090271, 0.024957241490483284, 0.015403450466692448, 0.031644273549318314, 0.022562598809599876, -0.007169685326516628, 0.004354123491793871, 0.05729018896818161, 0.02359013259410858, -0.007814650423824787, 0.039484281092882156, 0.029978325590491295, 0.03637590631842613, 0.015434595756232738, 0.030324963852763176, -0.023226790130138397, -0.0025901433546096087, 0.015781542286276817, 0.004556043539196253, -0.016563473269343376, -0.05097333714365959, -0.010639839805662632, 0.015201977454125881, 0.023326607421040535, 0.006296321749687195, -0.00042942760046571493, 0.00653497688472271, -0.016365112736821175, -0.030310435220599174, 0.020465131849050522, -0.012960337102413177, -0.03704224154353142, 0.015414303168654442, 0.037025853991508484, 0.016830580309033394, -0.011624603532254696, -0.006734705995768309, -0.01585875079035759, -0.02118692174553871, -0.008445721119642258, 0.017802046611905098, -0.03416005149483681, 0.02296142838895321, 0.022509759292006493, 0.029344091191887856, -0.011851396411657333, -0.027774512767791748, 0.014257799834012985, -0.02235976979136467, 0.027383992448449135, 0.0050857532769441605, -0.0015977860894054174, -0.021513991057872772, 0.0411527082324028, 0.008237892761826515, 0.0033584684133529663, 0.004813197534531355, -0.029221979901194572, -0.04089966043829918, 0.04759293422102928, -0.02994913049042225, 0.006094683427363634, 0.01859663799405098, -0.004146968014538288, 0.025691866874694824, -0.009607532992959023, 0.02695911005139351, -0.009464092552661896, 0.012527545914053917, 0.0029895047191530466, -0.00916651263833046, -0.02711016871035099, 0.028919583186507225, 0.015601243823766708, 0.006289395038038492, 0.021056441590189934, 0.00015212524158414453, 0.0238304752856493, 0.03081502951681614, -0.007885521277785301, -0.008660278283059597, -0.0031034096609801054, -0.04177515208721161, 0.03413686156272888, 0.04180726036429405, 0.05733785033226013, 0.024196738377213478, -0.04373474046587944, 0.05247555673122406, -0.02563568390905857, 0.02149594947695732, 0.02486208640038967, -0.02289540320634842, -0.023873206228017807, -0.006192782428115606, 0.002455581910908222, 0.0031357642728835344, 0.00792769156396389, 0.022943612188100815, -0.012861418537795544, 0.05299103260040283, 0.015029221773147583, -0.0526227205991745, 0.013429682701826096, 0.05053297430276871, 0.05876615270972252, -0.024071792140603065, -0.041643619537353516, -0.015252577140927315, 0.0325629748404026, -0.01635894738137722, 0.02909703180193901, 0.02173549495637417, 0.03185460716485977, -0.01780921220779419, 0.057684190571308136, -0.011463336646556854, -0.052797846496105194, 0.02885344810783863, -0.004758145194500685, 0.013240549713373184, 0.015626125037670135, -0.04801453649997711, 0.01892203278839588, 0.055394239723682404, -0.0005685481592081487, 0.021939095109701157, -0.002407524734735489, -0.06651278585195541, 0.02170136384665966, 0.04569758102297783, 0.053910598158836365, -0.04552627354860306, 0.006406059954315424, -0.025924162939190865, -0.02928760088980198, 0.025430953130126, -0.024862496182322502, -0.016123883426189423, 0.007073909975588322, 0.024184174835681915, -0.0383567251265049, -0.03709039092063904, -0.05957958847284317, -0.0033722675871104, -0.013559659011662006, 0.015437631867825985, 0.02038470469415188, -0.04250597208738327, -0.004264341667294502, 0.02649712562561035, 0.012738415040075779, 0.06027949973940849, -0.010034802369773388, -0.0004833123821299523, 0.025632809847593307, 0.02205219864845276, -0.013841052539646626, -0.062031473964452744, 0.022066617384552956, 0.008897004649043083, -0.002778091933578253, 0.049926143139600754, 0.019317548722028732, -0.04562653228640556, -0.007964343763887882, -0.0021335408091545105, -0.038437534123659134, -0.009264921769499779, -0.05172593146562576, 0.06324364244937897, -0.002754502696916461, 0.0008947534952312708, 0.04581542685627937, -0.0008156822877936065, -0.013044963590800762, 0.005539240315556526, 0.004245599266141653, 0.025584369897842407, -0.022952109575271606, -0.01863878034055233, -0.0380622074007988, -0.034079331904649734, 0.007483396679162979, 0.0091161597520113, 0.007782362401485443, -0.01255851425230503, -0.0015166410012170672, 0.011454099789261818, 0.036235637962818146, 0.02299783006310463, -0.013678083196282387, 0.039468515664339066, 0.014252898283302784, -0.05348280444741249, 0.0059293583035469055, -0.03805031254887581, 0.026429008692502975, -0.0473155677318573, 0.006929061841219664, 0.022622674703598022, -0.03726431727409363, -0.02211572416126728, -0.049040257930755615, -0.05325408652424812, 0.011417017318308353, -0.04322368651628494, 0.028665490448474884, -0.014185389503836632, 0.044876955449581146, -0.031137432903051376, -0.015528847463428974, -0.02425624430179596, 0.032205577939748764, -0.025426436215639114, 0.033266354352235794, -0.015280311927199364, 0.02235150896012783, -0.02338838018476963, 0.01727837696671486, -0.060197100043296814, -0.06038752570748329, 0.02063961699604988, 0.004661706741899252, -0.01609613373875618, -0.030206484720110893, 0.03133628889918327, -0.012737349607050419, -0.009804589673876762, -0.009898330084979534, 0.04104340821504593, -0.04109373316168785, -0.003235523821786046, -0.024136245250701904, -0.00299448543228209, 0.04514337703585625, -0.03088483400642872, 0.008350982330739498, 0.009046374820172787, -0.032181113958358765, -0.03841029480099678, -0.00618895934894681, -0.021449914202094078, -0.025776738300919533, 0.009775159880518913, -0.06666748970746994, 0.021207718178629875, 0.015834199264645576, -0.05957067757844925, -0.00687015475705266, -0.04302928224205971, -0.0062407879158854485, 0.014262542128562927, -0.044638555496931076, 0.0009887519991025329, -0.016966914758086205, 0.020475467666983604, 0.021601084619760513, 0.02495654672384262, -0.012142041698098183, 0.008650403469800949, 0.041488971561193466, 0.005655286833643913, -0.04303447902202606, 0.02454872615635395, 0.04798882454633713, 0.03736315667629242, 0.002422988647595048, -0.003943667281419039, -0.01489880308508873, 0.012572936713695526, -0.005839758552610874, -0.007911702618002892, 0.009609690867364407, 0.022561734542250633, -0.028553156182169914, -0.05323953926563263, -0.024946151301264763, -0.002531300764530897, 0.04879985749721527, -0.0025575661566108465, 0.037941548973321915, 0.08622033149003983, -0.0006805948214605451, 0.023935925215482712, 0.0011378140188753605, 0.018014932051301003, 0.05074061453342438, -0.00016863321070559323, 0.030508656054735184, -0.007773635443300009, 0.004060426726937294, 0.037950173020362854, 0.02838960848748684, 0.011478601954877377, 0.07237191498279572, 0.029921602457761765, 0.0060772583819925785, 0.06243478134274483, -0.05320955812931061, -0.03307982161641121, -0.015690045431256294, -0.0336582325398922, -0.00218378147110343, -0.09093417227268219, 0.02044151909649372, 0.0358627513051033, 0.05432634800672531, 0.009862629696726799, -0.014515849761664867, 0.0010310624493286014, -0.05220501869916916, 0.0037709849420934916, 0.04833627864718437, 0.00045372877502813935, 0.026969531551003456, 0.031914424151182175, 0.03688329458236694, -0.03740968182682991, 0.009831377305090427, -0.0034001488238573074, -0.0973178967833519, -0.0262477844953537, 0.008877989836037159, -0.013473812490701675, 0.04422903060913086, 0.013219209387898445, -0.032689373940229416, 0.0017015812918543816, -0.03279200196266174, -0.007500313688069582, 0.012738356366753578, -0.0037188585847616196, -0.023427322506904602, 0.08720346540212631, 0.005619616713374853, 0.004121154546737671, 0.03545958921313286, -0.030091416090726852, 0.10958578437566757, 0.06841781735420227, 0.029273943975567818, -0.09278710186481476, 0.05123908445239067, 0.03586900606751442, 0.0007446560193784535, -0.02876005508005619, 0.03655433654785156, 0.00643343199044466, -0.011582513339817524, 0.04689880087971687, 0.028098473325371742, 0.005855756811797619, 0.004121517762541771, 0.04092875123023987, -0.018873201683163643, -0.07533004879951477, 0.029569651931524277, -0.01808447204530239, 0.0062941391952335835, -0.02815592661499977, -0.0071144807152450085, 0.025478214025497437, 0.019205113872885704, -0.0197774525731802, -0.013478401117026806, 0.01474829763174057, 0.01864030957221985, 0.015879670158028603, -0.023389948531985283, 0.009922205470502377, -0.016490992158651352, 0.041829101741313934, -0.06440633535385132, -0.014132527634501457, 0.0006767867016606033, -0.0286560095846653, 0.0036990002263337374, 0.035881247371435165, -0.03130757436156273, -0.010056640021502972, -0.011892328970134258, 0.007273419294506311, -0.014746269211173058, -0.01321247685700655, -0.023666515946388245, 0.055228836834430695, 0.013769203796982765, -0.02775978110730648, -0.028643278405070305, 0.007612048648297787, -0.053116410970687866, -0.03285329043865204, -0.014663657173514366, 0.026060031726956367, 0.0063992151990532875, -0.05393553525209427, -0.0001735326077323407, -0.01145716942846775, 0.033941566944122314, 0.00879649631679058, -0.0011468916200101376, 0.05011656880378723, -0.007631910964846611, -0.030318496748805046, -0.007026628591120243, 0.06092151626944542, 0.015333692543208599, -0.027135169133543968, 0.019256390631198883, -0.007266979198902845, -0.016464989632368088, 0.05148917809128761, 0.0019225444411858916, 0.019399598240852356, 0.01503682043403387, -0.009139749221503735, -0.013985877856612206, -0.02229630947113037, -0.02201641909778118, -0.0029157816898077726, -0.01386545691639185, 0.00306094903498888, -0.021544011309742928, -0.014402884058654308, -0.004498846363276243, 0.04601236805319786, 0.021040208637714386, -0.0015541015891358256, -0.004323843866586685, 0.035367537289857864, 0.02085174061357975, -0.055017825216054916, -0.010235482826828957, -0.009763297624886036, -0.009006819687783718, -0.02848084457218647, -0.07585007697343826, 0.06465515494346619, -0.011825071647763252, -0.02041706256568432, 0.014845281839370728, 0.031797781586647034, -0.01052999310195446, 0.01368046272546053, 0.004308413714170456, -0.06874362379312515, 0.001459051389247179, -0.020501459017395973, 0.024674907326698303, -0.011397918686270714, -0.009571615606546402, -0.002766449935734272, -0.013408180326223373, -0.0007272635120898485, -0.01758037693798542, -0.0038838833570480347, 0.025233684107661247, -0.0025086281821131706, 0.006783650256693363, -0.026900533586740494, 0.010738405399024487, -0.03079903870820999, -0.02189910225570202, 0.036401379853487015, 0.02301236242055893, -0.00465403264388442, -0.024101657792925835, 0.02725520171225071, 0.005832148250192404, 0.04511209949851036, -0.02873852476477623, 0.016615908592939377, -0.00855921022593975, 0.020251646637916565, 0.003726433962583542, 0.018635230138897896, 0.010119680315256119, -0.021816186606884003, 0.03799096494913101, -0.05279628187417984, -0.02285112999379635, 0.02389049530029297, 0.007795258890837431, 0.023328838869929314, -0.016067396849393845, 0.00361113203689456, 0.0031763717997819185, 0.03137854114174843, -0.03767046332359314, -0.03932923078536987, -0.0019158873474225402, 0.0037136489991098642, -0.024345573037862778, -0.014689065515995026, 0.018527286127209663, 0.0443667434155941, -0.005497654899954796, 0.029776370152831078, 0.0504690445959568, 0.00631367601454258, -0.00452424818649888, 0.016500458121299744, -0.019013531506061554, 0.0069693089462816715, 0.0001504928950453177, -0.02670680731534958, 0.02512919157743454, 0.06214425712823868, -0.022155268117785454, 0.009146129712462425, -0.025425907224416733, 0.01452976930886507, -0.06999889016151428, -0.00016171889728866518, -0.0022834627889096737, 0.018718287348747253, 0.05997578799724579, -0.06603945791721344, 0.03377368301153183, 0.05466536432504654, -0.015386921353638172, 0.019637102261185646, -0.014076167717576027, -0.00820481963455677, -0.031762588769197464, 0.0048828418366611, -0.019213803112506866, 0.016996540129184723, -0.008952193893492222, 0.045406851917505264, 0.04092870652675629, 0.022712133824825287, 0.008262155577540398, -0.023654023185372353, 0.02047121897339821, 0.0283538606017828, 0.03173024579882622, -0.06642266362905502, 0.010144904255867004, -0.019239963963627815, -0.049983467906713486, 0.03173219412565231, 0.004839655477553606, 0.045522045344114304, 0.0017678914591670036, 0.04172082617878914, -0.0009808022296056151, 0.06946220993995667, 0.016550187021493912, -0.007132414728403091, 0.027627669274806976, -0.011611276306211948, -0.009970366023480892, 0.018827177584171295, -0.029975004494190216, 0.024712422862648964, 0.03214821591973305, 0.010385764762759209, -0.010499612428247929, 0.027661157771945, -0.011500722728669643, -0.044575661420822144, -0.033527228981256485, -0.04270053654909134, -0.0016620333772152662, -0.019481662660837173, -0.007524054031819105, -0.059429019689559937, 0.004294092766940594, 0.043434590101242065, 0.04134198650717735, -0.0591021366417408, -0.013758300803601742, -0.014590605162084103, -0.020561987534165382, -0.04296141490340233, -0.039713017642498016, 0.00589799415320158, -0.0729924663901329, -0.011946124956011772, -0.019570855423808098, -0.016791552305221558, -0.04979553818702698, 0.011001404374837875, -0.05245617404580116, 0.015721946954727173, -0.022405879572033882, -0.03067471832036972, 0.01848357543349266, -0.03542117401957512, 0.046183981001377106, -0.06979100406169891, 0.08087193220853806, 0.020010439679026604, -0.008734364062547684, -0.016713207587599754, 0.00746063282713294, -0.06149497255682945, -0.017232490703463554, 0.05447423458099365, 0.011322923004627228, -0.016127895563840866, -0.017427854239940643, 0.018116384744644165, -0.002977454336360097, -0.05138330161571503, 0.0712532252073288, -0.006851967889815569, -0.003239525482058525, -0.04273024573922157, 0.0069961859844625, 0.07002819329500198, 0.012107886373996735, -0.008865815587341785, 0.028301866725087166, 0.004353872500360012, -0.0180323775857687, -0.013257431797683239, 0.014982328750193119, -0.004175626207143068, -0.013199563138186932, 0.007093264255672693, -0.0184077937155962, 0.03354586288332939, 0.03886469081044197, -0.004918234888464212, -0.05300425365567207, 0.04633326828479767, 0.004358465317636728, -0.015156886540353298, -0.007250762544572353, -0.004785634111613035, -0.03962656855583191, -0.05375129356980324, -0.006634273566305637, -0.01352634746581316, -0.03803654760122299, 0.009504602290689945, 0.02199641615152359, 0.005311513319611549, -0.0214567631483078, 0.004074891563504934, 0.0018123749177902937, 0.021761802956461906, 0.02199004776775837, -0.02153598703444004, 0.016360636800527573, 0.026017604395747185, 0.021831383928656578, -0.0030511999502778053, 0.009196181781589985, -0.045934539288282394, 0.042587365955114365, 0.01970956288278103, 0.025926977396011353, -0.0021540012676268816, 0.008289806544780731, 0.00501602329313755, -0.02779228985309601, 0.013009141199290752, -0.020861361175775528, 0.02926570177078247, 0.03222592547535896, -0.058576300740242004, 0.004573548212647438, -0.024652093648910522, -0.010572735220193863, -0.0465819425880909, -0.00009785207657841966, 0.044264860451221466, 0.03514184430241585, -0.02107721008360386, 0.005712342448532581, 0.01687590405344963, -0.027299711480736732, 0.006962575484067202, -0.030007226392626762, 0.044520337134599686, -0.0115099111571908, -0.04808816686272621, -0.017626548185944557, -0.03290930762887001, -0.06962316483259201, -0.04023764282464981, 0.039267100393772125, 0.05007198825478554, 0.039767276495695114, -0.02587996795773506, -0.015591354109346867, -0.02028551883995533, 0.04825574532151222, -0.022589363157749176, -0.032325249165296555, -0.03695270046591759, 0.031606726348400116, 0.019592756405472755, 0.016584455966949463 ]
<p>I am playing with <code>scikit-learn</code> to find the <code>tf-idf</code> values. </p> <p>I have a set of <code>documents</code> like:</p> <pre><code>D1 = "The sky is blue." D2 = "The sun is bright." D3 = "The sun in the sky is bright." </code></pre> <p>I want to create a matrix like this:</p> <pre><code> Docs blue bright sky sun D1 tf-idf 0.0000000 tf-idf 0.0000000 D2 0.0000000 tf-idf 0.0000000 tf-idf D3 0.0000000 tf-idf tf-idf tf-idf </code></pre> <p>So, my code in <code>Python</code> is:</p> <pre><code>import nltk import string from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import TfidfVectorizer from nltk.corpus import stopwords train_set = ["sky is blue", "sun is bright", "sun in the sky is bright"] stop_words = stopwords.words('english') transformer = TfidfVectorizer(stop_words=stop_words) t1 = transformer.fit_transform(train_set).todense() print t1 </code></pre> <p>The result matrix I get is:</p> <pre><code>[[ 0.79596054 0. 0.60534851 0. ] [ 0. 0.4472136 0. 0.89442719] [ 0. 0.57735027 0.57735027 0.57735027]] </code></pre> <p>If I do a hand calculation then the matrix should be:</p> <pre><code> Docs blue bright sky sun D1 0.2385 0.0000000 0.0880 0.0000000 D2 0.0000000 0.0880 0.0000000 0.0880 D3 0.0000000 0.058 0.058 0.058 </code></pre> <p>I am calculating like say <code>blue</code> as <code>tf</code> = <code>1/2 = 0.5</code> and <code>idf</code> as <code>log(3/1) = 0.477121255</code>. Therefore <code>tf-idf = tf*idf = 0.5*0.477 = 0.2385</code>. In this way, I am calculating the other <code>tf-idf</code> values. Now, I am wondering, why I am getting different results in the matrix of hand calculation and in the matrix of Python? Which gives the correct results? Am I doing something wrong in hand calculation or is there something wrong in my Python code?</p>
36,015
[ -0.046552132815122604, -0.026012588292360306, -0.018568264320492744, -0.01888585463166237, 0.02708626538515091, 0.05118227005004883, -0.013481387868523598, -0.012492981739342213, 0.03858903795480728, -0.04896147921681404, 0.051176127046346664, 0.038742054253816605, 0.02484307624399662, 0.023849384859204292, 0.022535422816872597, -0.015160324051976204, 0.014186263084411621, -0.018017809838056564, -0.0022810627706348896, -0.04670596495270729, -0.009398652240633965, 0.043702125549316406, 0.02483626827597618, 0.03269807621836662, -0.0049909488297998905, 0.03451397642493248, 0.00900844857096672, -0.006144626531749964, 0.002673632465302944, -0.00023702444741502404, -0.005602722987532616, -0.040693581104278564, 0.016863714903593063, -0.018667789176106453, 0.024213526397943497, 0.0485452264547348, 0.0015698001952841878, 0.005891329608857632, 0.010005570016801357, -0.021654566749930382, 0.02661711350083351, -0.011725040152668953, -0.002883062930777669, 0.10002048313617706, -0.002488785656169057, 0.06755519658327103, -0.0034394224639981985, 0.005597381852567196, -0.0030156353022903204, -0.024353915825486183, 0.05594412609934807, 0.03240039199590683, 0.032511111348867416, 0.019686369225382805, -0.03090739995241165, -0.022977903485298157, 0.01268038246780634, 0.010283809155225754, 0.014473740011453629, -0.06994867324829102, -0.03711600601673126, -0.029048001393675804, -0.0008716623415239155, -0.010316616855561733, 0.011242547072470188, 0.04629603400826454, -0.03610169142484665, 0.01673426665365696, 0.08035247772932053, -0.0486677810549736, -0.02030048333108425, 0.00774616003036499, 0.04600184038281441, -0.02666938491165638, 0.013466358184814453, -0.017280062660574913, -0.00047402450582012534, 0.027063630521297455, 0.004176215268671513, 0.005953671410679817, 0.027316812425851822, 0.007338912691920996, -0.04891946166753769, 0.013034743256866932, 0.032774489372968674, 0.023317834362387657, 0.018540209159255028, -0.0249637383967638, 0.017373809590935707, 0.050182417035102844, 0.0330776609480381, 0.00010339441359974444, 0.05200782045722008, 0.04703068733215332, 0.022484075278043747, -0.0029041836969554424, -0.017786094918847084, 0.004400961566716433, 0.002153027104213834, -0.02034962922334671, -0.03154049068689346, -0.046211693435907364, 0.024652523919939995, 0.031849924474954605, -0.014534986577928066, -0.018977101892232895, -0.05457836389541626, -0.013704406097531319, -0.030612889677286148, -0.01096598245203495, -0.03490295261144638, 0.01878753863275051, 0.00708497641608119, -0.004944660700857639, -0.0041920458897948265, -0.056976061314344406, 0.01801123470067978, -0.011181174777448177, 0.03996312990784645, 0.07941260188817978, 0.0120704872533679, -0.014664859510958195, 0.047663718461990356, -0.04227525368332863, -0.03276694566011429, 0.03817298635840416, 0.023337021470069885, -0.002329080831259489, 0.014120716601610184, 0.011227977462112904, -0.026936236768960953, -0.025791725143790245, 0.039252739399671555, 0.01621975004673004, 0.018766110762953758, 0.01055172085762024, -0.038317348808050156, -0.06421586871147156, 0.021311303600668907, -0.04218028485774994, -0.0038327653892338276, -0.04102889820933342, 0.04020879045128822, 0.04008696228265762, 0.039057087153196335, 0.04342324659228325, 0.02346699684858322, 0.05566065013408661, -0.005287505220621824, -0.012558887712657452, -0.04957786202430725, -0.018749022856354713, -0.04116964712738991, 0.026651576161384583, -0.011243087239563465, -0.041211675852537155, 0.0066636246629059315, 0.005318553186953068, -0.01057142298668623, 0.02046538144350052, -0.003988561686128378, 0.02555132284760475, -0.0033283131197094917, 0.013973698951303959, -0.010878477245569229, -0.05069439858198166, 0.013624288141727448, 0.046040404587984085, 0.04438207671046257, -0.007614875212311745, -0.012262820266187191, -0.008661548607051373, -0.0006289088632911444, 0.028378084301948547, 0.034357260912656784, -0.050181061029434204, 0.0037780452985316515, 0.0011286811204627156, 0.050354477018117905, 0.0012036253465339541, -0.014612973667681217, -0.06110804155468941, -0.02265980839729309, -0.005886324681341648, 0.017718179151415825, 0.04999373108148575, 0.016071241348981857, -0.011488460935652256, 0.023850474506616592, -0.03789743781089783, 0.020827611908316612, -0.02541775070130825, 0.02072742208838463, -0.004768028389662504, -0.012700097635388374, 0.01608104072511196, 0.004235054366290569, 0.018734246492385864, 0.019146936014294624, 0.020534375682473183, -0.02771374210715294, 0.009187525138258934, 0.027633579447865486, -0.012957300059497356, -0.0047300937585532665, 0.037195466458797455, 0.05347666144371033, 0.008946100249886513, 0.0018042685696855187, 0.003955080173909664, 0.002182295545935631, -0.00022279407130554318, 0.010669640265405178, -0.007851197384297848, 0.0023897411301732063, -0.020474407821893692, 0.023390207439661026, 0.016328632831573486, 0.002252050442621112, 0.009626004844903946, -0.060537584125995636, 0.07238511741161346, 0.027046192437410355, -0.020160963758826256, 0.040230892598629, 0.0035817052703350782, -0.02345304749906063, 0.030249513685703278, -0.012287992052733898, 0.0021367147564888, -0.027799099683761597, -0.022853834554553032, 0.02773367241024971, 0.04922669380903244, -0.03882482647895813, 0.0007285350002348423, 0.10287880152463913, -0.00939179863780737, 0.041825760155916214, 0.04065121337771416, -0.020157145336270332, -0.004472706001251936, 0.02259567193686962, 0.005901034455746412, -0.009233339689671993, -0.018864789977669716, 0.009493296034634113, 0.0022408210206776857, 0.024262849241495132, -0.014164336957037449, -0.022599251940846443, -0.006314282771199942, 0.012703933753073215, -0.007085325196385384, 0.008438166230916977, -0.03972785174846649, 0.010488529689610004, 0.007336313836276531, -0.026087051257491112, 0.050937797874212265, -0.018565384671092033, -0.02274184487760067, -0.020638614892959595, -0.002855003345757723, -0.0002677350421436131, 0.034353241324424744, -0.03099246695637703, -0.005613003391772509, 0.009599567390978336, -0.07864625751972198, 0.0222272127866745, 0.03860476613044739, -0.018588226288557053, -0.018557043746113777, 0.03668792173266411, 0.02270268090069294, 0.004137236624956131, 0.0165779497474432, 0.004571172874420881, 0.009044320322573185, -0.0019047491950914264, -0.018927067518234253, 0.03200265392661095, -0.009385576471686363, -0.07424887269735336, 0.023032359778881073, -0.009773118421435356, -0.05181705579161644, 0.05741275101900101, -0.006401926279067993, -0.0060416702181100845, 0.0365879088640213, -0.046605102717876434, -0.048080816864967346, 0.026298604905605316, -0.03951612114906311, 0.03426596522331238, 0.014689598232507706, 0.02829034812748432, 0.023091983050107956, -0.00887906551361084, -0.07441401481628418, -0.004080143757164478, -0.01008440088480711, -0.06344436854124069, -0.03441502898931503, -0.010130520910024643, -0.008357292972505093, -0.04068952426314354, 0.01632935367524624, 0.022205188870429993, -0.007908735424280167, 0.004689102992415428, -0.06838914752006531, -0.0012229402782395482, -0.020149728283286095, 0.06148091331124306, 0.05118349567055702, -0.005504440516233444, -0.0073935543186962605, 0.050047554075717926, 0.040491532534360886, -0.04550375044345856, -0.04412795975804329, 0.019013646990060806, -0.00866997055709362, -0.03895144909620285, 0.015204048715531826, -0.014200911857187748, 0.014065179973840714, 0.0061918823048472404, 0.00438710069283843, 0.030364394187927246, 0.1035093292593956, -0.01927720382809639, -0.004073097370564938, -0.012122749350965023, -0.0014493648195639253, -0.015465596690773964, 0.03436661884188652, 0.02719731628894806, 0.008896032348275185, 0.03977806493639946, -0.0026491915341466665, 0.00939578004181385, -0.004688454791903496, -0.01771259494125843, -0.0005695059662684798, -0.021182917058467865, 0.02867540344595909, -0.031110325828194618, 0.014634525403380394, 0.008684800006449223, -0.05429614335298538, 0.006659511476755142, 0.03819458186626434, 0.022600725293159485, -0.03378118947148323, -0.02062360569834709, 0.0409240797162056, 0.0384383387863636, 0.0070301853120327, 0.007967549376189709, -0.04814395681023598, -0.017335070297122, -0.004872270859777927, -0.068562813103199, 0.005420882720500231, 0.02833167277276516, 0.04724137485027313, 0.05600140988826752, 0.03909091651439667, 0.0027446956373751163, 0.00042158953147009015, 0.007347106002271175, 0.008302250877022743, 0.004362118896096945, 0.04323172941803932, 0.04264844208955765, 0.07151194661855698, 0.0041602905839681625, 0.024361493065953255, 0.010947751812636852, 0.025259876623749733, -0.04548301175236702, 0.008341074921190739, 0.0023329320829361677, -0.026501482352614403, -0.0002649532980285585, -0.022560782730579376, 0.006287193391472101, -0.0025867794174700975, 0.0146483164280653, 0.03602176904678345, 0.022692374885082245, -0.0456828698515892, 0.0655682310461998, 0.001363474177196622, -0.007576890289783478, -0.016575176268815994, 0.046952035278081894, 0.057383183389902115, 0.01908494159579277, 0.026595771312713623, 0.004721176810562611, -0.010450392961502075, 0.029334986582398415, -0.016743676736950874, 0.013089043088257313, 0.018321912735700607, 0.025661835446953773, 0.05033000186085701, 0.03527315706014633, -0.05794889107346535, 0.024870380759239197, 0.005233018659055233, 0.01942361705005169, 0.057213012129068375, -0.017288807779550552, 0.012118486687541008, -0.027592159807682037, 0.002379595534875989, -0.014224793761968613, 0.031140122562646866, -0.036095596849918365, 0.024034755304455757, 0.025465140119194984, 0.026139382272958755, -0.026285039260983467, 0.02735224738717079, 0.07694682478904724, -0.014030681923031807, -0.05305460840463638, -0.033210743218660355, 0.015382508747279644, -0.008469964377582073, 0.0011861949460580945, 0.002379871904850006, 0.03329840674996376, -0.02422310598194599, -0.000007212077434815001, 0.05966979265213013, -0.035937387496232986, -0.08375198394060135, 0.04090356081724167, 0.010132729075849056, 0.004634182900190353, -0.04635930806398392, -0.06136014685034752, -0.0378129743039608, 0.06297599524259567, 0.014674535021185875, 0.007929514162242413, 0.01029254775494337, -0.10178905725479126, -0.01974051631987095, 0.0047845663502812386, 0.06300007551908493, -0.02375740371644497, -0.009292341768741608, -0.009291303344070911, -0.0077486722730100155, -0.005203436594456434, -0.03223071247339249, 0.04775593802332878, -0.018393652513623238, 0.018086491152644157, -0.0034974555019289255, 0.011890626512467861, -0.026625672355294228, 0.06439869850873947, -0.042619504034519196, 0.006397327873855829, 0.0070245773531496525, -0.06015457212924957, -0.023720646277070045, 0.010508463717997074, 0.0012412447249516845, 0.014525139704346657, -0.02211180329322815, 0.011834550648927689, 0.01725980080664158, -0.009104393422603607, 0.026477379724383354, -0.061328183859586716, 0.044627439230680466, 0.024476876482367516, -0.015348154120147228, 0.04034505784511566, -0.018220236524939537, -0.01201445423066616, 0.03034769557416439, 0.015240458771586418, 0.0015974700218066573, -0.03284331038594246, -0.029371997341513634, 0.04199686273932457, 0.035290565341711044, -0.041454561054706573, 0.018340857699513435, 0.024404801428318024, 0.0050089918076992035, 0.04314079135656357, -0.08426158130168915, -0.005195851903408766, -0.01672934554517269, 0.0012673110468313098, -0.02850942127406597, 0.011601575650274754, -0.060892727226018906, -0.0037019429728388786, -0.013285117223858833, 0.035103753209114075, -0.030268065631389618, -0.0020345787052065134, 0.010471310466527939, 0.05784843862056732, -0.029144901782274246, -0.052076537162065506, -0.005159379914402962, 0.029064927250146866, -0.013386407867074013, -0.0224323607981205, 0.00023734665592201054, -0.033210668712854385, 0.0374053530395031, 0.008780568838119507, -0.024604326114058495, -0.0012580974726006389, -0.018317272886633873, -0.020345354452729225, 0.0074686226435005665, -0.008630539290606976, -0.018535669893026352, -0.02500293403863907, -0.0011312277056276798, 0.003991178702563047, -0.009854241274297237, -0.02354673482477665, 0.01744607463479042, -0.0009333986672572792, 0.02025441825389862, -0.01932302676141262, 0.018075209110975266, 0.02091222070157528, -0.025548310950398445, -0.03455745801329613, -0.014507031068205833, 0.05280201509594917, -0.0004648375033866614, -0.061389703303575516, -0.04331013187766075, -0.016192708164453506, 0.013651954010128975, 0.009253636933863163, 0.004736106842756271, 0.028420697897672653, -0.0644795298576355, -0.0017817839980125427, -0.018072666600346565, -0.025122135877609253, 0.06128524988889694, -0.001073154853656888, 0.021403612568974495, 0.01957724615931511, 0.03061528503894806, 0.005899505689740181, 0.023647790774703026, 0.020901450887322426, -0.03373678773641586, -0.03420856595039368, -0.023708418011665344, 0.03373202309012413, 0.05162109434604645, 0.02859508991241455, 0.02276349440217018, -0.005114105995744467, -0.0032028425484895706, 0.02055596560239792, -0.018088512122631073, -0.006958427373319864, -0.019840890541672707, 0.016462082043290138, -0.03272596374154091, -0.02524389699101448, -0.007735150866210461, 0.024743082001805305, -0.02153974585235119, -0.03955076262354851, 0.019996333867311478, -0.0213147159665823, 0.0713801458477974, 0.0158205758780241, 0.009275849908590317, -0.014399670995771885, 0.01514411997050047, 0.027315380051732063, 0.008116289973258972, -0.025213589891791344, -0.006385072600096464, -0.0065852138213813305, -0.025490649044513702, -0.0009168494143523276, -0.02236681990325451, 0.013532259501516819, 0.07459001243114471, 0.027518026530742645, 0.03499886766076088, 0.04890017956495285, 0.03022700361907482, 0.015005783177912235, -0.029586922377347946, 0.009511766955256462, -0.012432298623025417, 0.00850312877446413, 0.025880318135023117, 0.012392551638185978, 0.023232581093907356, 0.07273674011230469, 0.017538277432322502, 0.050316840410232544, 0.06355040520429611, -0.005988948978483677, -0.013683337718248367, 0.03065793588757515, -0.017403267323970795, -0.008272181265056133, -0.01702730543911457, -0.043272919952869415, -0.012509049847722054, -0.014505998231470585, 0.008726176805794239, 0.032742537558078766, 0.027429653331637383, 0.004883656278252602, -0.006460538599640131, -0.017511939629912376, -0.06782284379005432, 0.032921019941568375, 0.04400261491537094, -0.011411265470087528, 0.005169553216546774, 0.03519158810377121, 0.004209546837955713, -0.02455247938632965, 0.03506401926279068, -0.04473989084362984, -0.026917990297079086, -0.03930274769663811, -0.0958133414387703, -0.026766760274767876, 0.03801976516842842, -0.00793683435767889, -0.01863679476082325, -0.0028123301453888416, -0.03906203806400299, 0.03611448407173157, 0.025382841005921364, 0.016142604872584343, -0.02143353596329689, 0.0361601747572422, 0.019428960978984833, 0.0341106541454792, 0.0013281124411150813, -0.03233383223414421, 0.13245581090450287, 0.08139771968126297, 0.03307047486305237, -0.08838201314210892, -0.019606124609708786, 0.011725977063179016, -0.026699630543589592, -0.07952943444252014, -0.007685570511966944, 0.005216530524194241, -0.014981904067099094, 0.0035216088872402906, 0.04284243658185005, 0.003915148321539164, -0.01393311657011509, -0.01709144562482834, -0.027860071510076523, 0.0052244351245462894, 0.018904194235801697, 0.018346088007092476, 0.00037518367753364146, -0.02418845146894455, -0.11806774139404297, 0.01468848530203104, 0.02751549892127514, -0.022010453045368195, -0.021280627697706223, 0.0021324006374925375, 0.010528601706027985, 0.037443265318870544, -0.03312898427248001, 0.026659373193979263, 0.00876316986978054, 0.0168005358427763, 0.031780458986759186, 0.030665751546621323, 0.03484749048948288, -0.014011337421834469, -0.025047542527318, 0.0022166697308421135, 0.021841159090399742, 0.008060247637331486, -0.02768297679722309, 0.01916183903813362, -0.017986785620450974, -0.05608576536178589, -0.06049434468150139, 0.04373122751712799, 0.005906728561967611, -0.002631880110129714, 0.0018014338565990329, 0.006356590893119574, 0.03423314541578293, -0.05752219632267952, 0.01146533340215683, 0.021354345604777336, -0.013809401541948318, 0.0038171177729964256, -0.029636098071932793, 0.0007198280072771013, -0.004388107918202877, -0.005945609882473946, 0.027438323944807053, 0.004301660694181919, 0.0047234888188540936, -0.007972130551934242, -0.03920907527208328, 0.02664986439049244, 0.044889822602272034, 0.009693395346403122, 0.003876405768096447, -0.038043905049562454, -0.01598234660923481, -0.05298209190368652, 0.008405080996453762, 0.03228196129202843, -0.0346912257373333, -0.0274798683822155, -0.016414063051342964, -0.06268701702356339, -0.002219082321971655, -0.008661491796374321, -0.02155027911067009, -0.0219286922365427, -0.05382287874817848, -0.004949318710714579, 0.04527740925550461, 0.043546728789806366, 0.00516087282449007, 0.00655393349006772, 0.02162194810807705, 0.01112661324441433, 0.020492611452937126, -0.04005803167819977, -0.050540052354335785, 0.02409173734486103, -0.017260316759347916, -0.029430711641907692, 0.0031448130030184984, 0.07412362098693848, 0.050758250057697296, -0.004806527402251959, -0.0029424589592963457, 0.029195325449109077, -0.04284317418932915, -0.028964638710021973, -0.013946245424449444, 0.0025354886893182993, -0.004865771625190973, 0.04641038551926613, -0.08778908848762512, -0.036424700170755386, 0.05121878907084465, -0.04805099591612816, -0.016286369413137436, 0.02816544845700264, 0.014012502506375313, -0.06066408008337021, 0.01953340880572796, -0.006435515824705362, 0.011259765364229679, 0.004256866406649351, 0.006998930126428604, -0.03147141635417938, 0.023958690464496613, -0.04667850583791733, -0.06562057882547379, -0.043152160942554474, 0.0030091204680502415, -0.05674997717142105, -0.008314894512295723, 0.00975130870938301, 0.04492175579071045, 0.016482973471283913, -0.025722509250044823, 0.021620402112603188, -0.025106379762291908, 0.038778532296419144, -0.016698315739631653, 0.002010880270972848, 0.011527325958013535, -0.062244560569524765, -0.007703694049268961, 0.031966663897037506, -0.017607389017939568, 0.06507215648889542, -0.020005326718091965, 0.017215242609381676, -0.019531618803739548, 0.06937279552221298, -0.015051765367388725, 0.02420947514474392, 0.011584712192416191, -0.053667500615119934, -0.009086799807846546, 0.001240820623934269, -0.003644749289378524, -0.02284753881394863, -0.03542158007621765, 0.009080586023628712, -0.0019182809628546238, 0.0073533025570213795, -0.028925739228725433, 0.041783858090639114, -0.016314933076500893, -0.019678255543112755, 0.030135992914438248, 0.0034139170311391354, -0.017848597839474678, 0.0145898861810565, -0.0014490383910015225, 0.010111300274729729, -0.025522856041789055, 0.0490470714867115, -0.08946696668863297, -0.010962500236928463, -0.0003241493250243366, 0.003955438733100891, 0.02642672508955002, -0.016562946140766144, -0.011243055574595928, 0.009438111446797848, -0.04158702492713928, 0.04032868519425392, -0.0015893648378551006, 0.01730710081756115, -0.027086950838565826, 0.053454458713531494, -0.01923508755862713, 0.0026596973184496164, 0.03753320872783661, 0.005404507741332054, 0.030513353645801544, 0.007826676592230797, -0.024088667705655098, -0.029010428115725517, -0.038055408746004105, 0.03125542774796486, -0.008237914182245731, -0.030563656240701675, 0.016163095831871033, -0.041446052491664886, -0.01829170063138008, 0.009795891121029854, -0.026929814368486404, -0.03858548402786255, 0.03077499195933342, 0.059747327119112015, 0.04081574082374573, 0.027173129841685295, 0.01290824543684721, 0.0422004871070385, -0.0008486924925819039, -0.02640344575047493, 0.008335286751389503, -0.033400166779756546, -0.02645847015082836, 0.01661013439297676, 0.029588043689727783, 0.001274376641958952, -0.035158876329660416, 0.020665466785430908, -0.001270393724553287, -0.008990648202598095, -0.045818861573934555, 0.02131839469075203, 0.034797441214323044, -0.05813051387667656, 0.0005439838860183954, -0.061863020062446594, 0.01525555644184351, -0.03052964247763157, -0.001801117556169629, -0.014730655588209629, 0.006774339824914932, -0.03171410784125328, -0.028823794797062874, -0.000999712385237217, 0.024803604930639267, -0.024527419358491898, -0.014098421670496464, -0.016765067353844643, 0.03651074320077896, -0.0034448793157935143, -0.009660350158810616, -0.0019772013183683157, -0.03674574941396713, 0.014765122905373573, -0.020947132259607315, 0.008965088985860348, 0.009023650549352169, 0.00417326670140028, 0.023590994998812675, -0.08041166514158249, 0.0069298879243433475, -0.0354127362370491, -0.07851865142583847, -0.025904761627316475, 0.02808709256350994, -0.017062736675143242, 0.025094473734498024, -0.024841485545039177, -0.007790540345013142, 0.023960424587130547, -0.06703203916549683, -0.01469007320702076, 0.05144607275724411, -0.0542893186211586, 0.014713251031935215, 0.0032349005341529846, -0.021409494802355766, -0.014097606763243675, -0.0338292270898819, -0.032643094658851624, 0.03633720427751541, 0.03929539769887924, 0.023610422387719154, -0.009377955459058285, 0.005413777194917202, 0.0006810036720708013, 0.0014979476109147072, 0.04059601575136185, 0.025179479271173477, 0.050639618188142776, -0.005726017523556948, -0.015400059521198273, 0.05368479713797569, -0.012552373111248016, -0.024589823558926582, 0.019484855234622955, -0.032736219465732574, -0.019026093184947968, -0.004556088708341122, 0.011909255757927895, 0.07940585166215897, -0.036258939653635025, -0.015407505445182323, 0.04275331273674965, -0.0015632456634193659, -0.010517831891775131, 0.018470508977770805, -0.004781306721270084, 0.016457267105579376, 0.00322977383621037, 0.07285665720701218, 0.0065043154172599316, -0.052615776658058167, 0.025706350803375244, -0.0013711248757317662, 0.01381012424826622, -0.000921861210372299, 0.05757157504558563, -0.01708599552512169, -0.03484199196100235, 0.01805127039551735, -0.03256014361977577, 0.02572815865278244, 0.014790709130465984, -0.006354902870953083, 0.0007067042752169073, 0.01263370644301176, 0.0010090389987453818, 0.017336271703243256, 0.0037198413629084826, 0.05584415793418884, -0.014552522450685501, 0.02305067703127861, -0.010122545063495636, -0.032613202929496765, -0.07826030254364014, 0.015765972435474396, 0.000839782936964184, -0.00043380167335271835, -0.012879423797130585, -0.008981820195913315, 0.0018390124896541238, -0.03986261039972305, -0.010278459638357162, -0.03744105249643326, -0.02433015964925289, -0.0337839312851429, 0.014286130666732788, 0.026447998359799385, -0.011492987163364887, -0.00945872999727726, -0.02876017801463604, 0.06446024030447006, -0.007515029516071081, -0.010717528872191906, -0.038732290267944336, -0.010229166597127914, 0.023207999765872955, 0.016234710812568665, -0.030410349369049072, 0.023936569690704346, 0.004001489840447903, -0.009151880629360676, -0.0037956719752401114, -0.02951653301715851 ]
<p>I'm working on a project and I would like to know if the following strategy is good/correct. Sorry if this is a basic/stupid idea (I'm new to this).</p> <p>The input is a dataset with 2.500 features and 1.000 instances. I have to apply a feature selection on this set. In the beginning I randomly make a learning set (which contains 70% of the original data) and a test set (with the remaining 30%). </p> <p>Now I split the learning set in 10 folds (to do cross-validation), so we've split the learning set into 10 (more or less equal) parts and now we take 9 parts out of 10 to do a feature ranking (using chi squared), then we take the best 10 features (highest ranking) to do a model evaluation (using SVM) on the remaining part of the 'splitted learning set' (and we do this 10 times, so each part will be used as a 'test set'). </p> <p>Doing this '10 folds' argument gives us 10 feature rankings (with 10 model evaluation/accuracies). Out of these 10 results we can take the best feature ranking (according to it's accuracy based on the model or to take the sum of the feature rankings) and then finally test it on the 30% test set from the beginning.</p> <p>Please give your opinion whether this is good or really stupid...</p>
73,608
[ -0.00925535336136818, 0.016155539080500603, -0.0224512480199337, -0.02337559685111046, 0.03658837080001831, -0.0033782613463699818, 0.012831708416342735, -0.03172002360224724, 0.03850574418902397, -0.008342287503182888, 0.029831092804670334, -0.007361274212598801, 0.01596110127866268, -0.02170763723552227, -0.009526927024126053, -0.0029172785580158234, -0.0524345301091671, -0.02484334446489811, -0.004419692791998386, 0.009799688123166561, 0.007088121026754379, 0.0012991538969799876, 0.015011877752840519, -0.006650770548731089, -0.04262017831206322, 0.03999236971139908, -0.009297775104641914, -0.050428424030542374, 0.019958531484007835, 0.050853997468948364, -0.019353237003087997, -0.02032368816435337, 0.015442600473761559, 0.06730115413665771, 0.04297095537185669, -0.0021052660886198282, -0.0025785991456359625, -0.020030051469802856, -0.032366782426834106, 0.04022490233182907, 0.03310972452163696, 0.0029145549051463604, -0.022722497582435608, 0.023316403850913048, -0.011754053644835949, 0.010598988272249699, -0.028105253353714943, -0.013809562660753727, 0.029804548248648643, -0.06765439361333847, 0.055362287908792496, 0.011910192668437958, 0.017471427097916603, 0.059306371957063675, 0.03691967949271202, -0.04423749819397926, 0.030697330832481384, 0.03174296021461487, -0.037209346890449524, -0.009542061947286129, 0.007478479761630297, -0.029407266527414322, -0.01660272479057312, 0.004875003360211849, -0.04779844731092453, 0.05413240194320679, 0.016614418476819992, 0.016032416373491287, 0.03684357926249504, 0.012425069697201252, -0.005014376249164343, 0.016287777572870255, 0.024819863960146904, -0.04724632948637009, 0.006470011081546545, -0.03129573538899422, 0.029695991426706314, 0.037621866911649704, 0.009792172349989414, 0.03451777249574661, 0.01760590635240078, 0.007552669383585453, 0.0007477164617739618, 0.0832749530673027, 0.04078123718500137, -0.008267572149634361, 0.05478132888674736, -0.009824041277170181, 0.013272944837808609, 0.030300486832857132, 0.00200641225092113, -0.01167318131774664, 0.06178376451134682, 0.0061038704589009285, -0.051133569329977036, 0.011666039004921913, -0.010173933580517769, 0.011345483362674713, 0.03056473284959793, 0.009192220866680145, -0.014047019183635712, -0.017673466354608536, 0.015051144175231457, 0.05460379645228386, -0.048934679478406906, 0.008999723941087723, -0.027646062895655632, 0.00924021378159523, -0.00966667477041483, -0.02017308585345745, -0.036248523741960526, 0.027509592473506927, 0.00808729324489832, 0.010629934258759022, 0.03144800662994385, -0.007919439114630222, -0.00011918985546799377, -0.03320428729057312, 0.03696994483470917, 0.040353886783123016, 0.021232524886727333, -0.05066811293363571, 0.011899582110345364, -0.042976345866918564, -0.015083972364664078, 0.020852014422416687, 0.002781972987577319, -0.03222288563847542, -0.02434283308684826, 0.04062683880329132, -0.003438093699514866, -0.008489103987812996, 0.023569410666823387, -0.012083865702152252, 0.014510353095829487, -0.01919776014983654, -0.07965419441461563, -0.03524339199066162, 0.03283863142132759, -0.009807487018406391, 0.03670342266559601, -0.015722673386335373, 0.0012079461012035608, 0.01936202310025692, 0.06167173385620117, 0.0030286640394479036, 0.033755067735910416, 0.017995594069361687, 0.04040530323982239, -0.040126197040081024, 0.004435861017554998, -0.05456302687525749, -0.02156512811779976, -0.010231314226984978, -0.034865669906139374, -0.06944671273231506, 0.023980507627129555, 0.02012922428548336, -0.021730724722146988, -0.03429361805319786, -0.0506429485976696, -0.02493823878467083, 0.015679508447647095, -0.022191544994711876, -0.004990117624402046, -0.01922355592250824, 0.05482453107833862, 0.009284178726375103, 0.04079924523830414, 0.03041699528694153, 0.010083389468491077, -0.04383481666445732, 0.03527015447616577, 0.02101314812898636, 0.028263797983527184, 0.001014040783047676, 0.042392946779727936, -0.04378676787018776, 0.025291012600064278, 0.006101783365011215, 0.018455220386385918, -0.0502198152244091, -0.025403035804629326, 0.017577877268195152, 0.04409737139940262, 0.04088263958692551, 0.004194197710603476, -0.029936406761407852, 0.06978257745504379, -0.0636005848646164, -0.05669335275888443, -0.0514131523668766, 0.02200772613286972, -0.015852190554142, -0.03832589089870453, -0.0009515206329524517, 0.0028941973578184843, 0.007297951262444258, -0.01853759214282036, -0.020355191081762314, -0.038061242550611496, -0.014044594019651413, 0.016629008576273918, -0.011876356787979603, -0.012733704410493374, 0.056132566183805466, -0.015833115205168724, -0.06747203320264816, 0.06387200951576233, -0.023910386487841606, -0.05224634334445, 0.008176290430128574, -0.013149650767445564, 0.023824427276849747, -0.01737741008400917, -0.0006122443592175841, 0.0396004356443882, -0.005456499755382538, -0.03158945590257645, 0.051604822278022766, -0.0640246793627739, 0.08089379221200943, 0.08859539031982422, -0.012789092026650906, -0.012511213310062885, -0.039099253714084625, -0.003139760345220566, 0.06760749965906143, 0.006183113437145948, -0.013567322865128517, -0.06460727751255035, 0.0010531018488109112, 0.05099160224199295, 0.0021248923148959875, -0.025790365412831306, -0.003473736811429262, 0.06560582667589188, -0.010956556536257267, 0.04435846209526062, 0.005492135416716337, 0.006940546445548534, -0.0003765147412195802, -0.010295696556568146, 0.03523322194814682, -0.006116821896284819, -0.007556527853012085, 0.020085081458091736, 0.004648490343242884, 0.015389623120427132, 0.04187221825122833, -0.0051955776289105415, 0.0573459193110466, 0.009610671550035477, -0.0008799662464298308, -0.010155572555959225, -0.009398289956152439, 0.02738010883331299, -0.02612042985856533, -0.0006003273301757872, 0.01441471092402935, 0.01266644150018692, 0.022635361179709435, -0.03745197504758835, 0.018090756610035896, 0.03313171863555908, 0.03680702671408653, -0.039913926273584366, 0.0011953054927289486, 0.028564676642417908, -0.06999686360359192, -0.024281740188598633, 0.0005513355717994273, -0.018187040463089943, -0.05897023156285286, 0.021077938377857208, 0.06272001564502716, -0.0261872299015522, 0.047787562012672424, -0.027895575389266014, -0.02506691962480545, -0.007870557717978954, -0.01390174962580204, 0.0368846096098423, -0.0032555798534303904, -0.03391028195619583, 0.004654061980545521, -0.041461437940597534, -0.02051185630261898, 0.0502832867205143, 0.010550219565629959, -0.03592030704021454, 0.012430870905518532, 0.017600219696760178, -0.03555579110980034, -0.038042813539505005, -0.07174947112798691, 0.0436914786696434, 0.0027202421333640814, -0.041336242109537125, 0.04168832674622536, 0.03839161992073059, -0.05341112241148949, 0.04066791385412216, -0.01600778102874756, -0.0301215723156929, -0.011690380983054638, -0.028078235685825348, -0.03375877067446709, -0.017866091802716255, 0.010948686860501766, 0.03278926759958267, -0.0035990295000374317, 0.012094543315470219, -0.058772459626197815, -0.06945428997278214, -0.010132157243788242, -0.013454639352858067, 0.00581344123929739, 0.013080976903438568, -0.0026815892197191715, 0.0883675366640091, 0.06224581599235535, -0.03447835519909859, -0.036680735647678375, 0.04393068328499794, -0.023643476888537407, -0.023059876635670662, 0.029203157871961594, 0.01145035121589899, -0.004412257578223944, 0.02241937816143036, -0.026020098477602005, 0.04059918224811554, 0.0559522807598114, -0.0024058129638433456, -0.021636828780174255, 0.01829044334590435, -0.0020511567126959562, 0.005305049475282431, 0.015049777925014496, 0.0037929753307253122, -0.02891213819384575, -0.012173054739832878, -0.007661723531782627, 0.03148728609085083, 0.01339675486087799, -0.05856132134795189, 0.03155146911740303, -0.015668990090489388, 0.01889302022755146, -0.0014705844223499298, 0.026775117963552475, 0.01237773522734642, -0.019366459921002388, 0.01373826339840889, 0.03220034018158913, 0.02635122276842594, -0.02162051759660244, -0.016240602359175682, 0.01546761766076088, 0.01439474057406187, 0.00395940663293004, -0.026395216584205627, -0.020644361153244972, 0.004866431932896376, 0.021343691274523735, 0.009842083789408207, -0.01839865930378437, 0.020380480214953423, 0.07853244245052338, 0.03786781430244446, 0.0015019172569736838, -0.05601885914802551, 0.03127210959792137, -0.0703655406832695, -0.026237716898322105, 0.005959678906947374, 0.060742899775505066, 0.030218452215194702, 0.024002373218536377, 0.010939795523881912, -0.03828663006424904, -0.00086915836436674, 0.014688975177705288, -0.032552894204854965, 0.0487600602209568, -0.004405660554766655, -0.026150524616241455, -0.022517262026667595, -0.030958116054534912, 0.01609964668750763, -0.01698542945086956, -0.013774828985333443, -0.017875270918011665, 0.034710682928562164, -0.048922691494226456, 0.03658432140946388, -0.034559812396764755, -0.00705973943695426, 0.0007568321307189763, 0.024519098922610283, 0.020954852923750877, 0.001104905386455357, 0.03440862149000168, 0.01694183237850666, -0.0242959912866354, 0.02841184474527836, -0.010080607607960701, 0.05287287011742592, 0.012866782955825329, 0.026132430881261826, -0.017850236967206, 0.02854236587882042, -0.09529419988393784, 0.055853236466646194, -0.023388024419546127, 0.026011433452367783, 0.032548099756240845, -0.021505285054445267, -0.0320427268743515, -0.019394535571336746, -0.034503210335969925, 0.01285740826278925, -0.007932270877063274, 0.007706386502832174, -0.026073668152093887, 0.047922082245349884, 0.007521531544625759, -0.0638207346200943, -0.010205970145761967, 0.06427457183599472, -0.01716950722038746, -0.022079555317759514, -0.05438170209527016, -0.03685914725065231, 0.007828998379409313, -0.018040204420685768, 0.026088569313287735, 0.009749148972332478, -0.042369648814201355, -0.018535813316702843, 0.024394603446125984, -0.00920013152062893, -0.048455629497766495, 0.03630891442298889, 0.02896879054605961, 0.029866516590118408, 0.0006580901681445539, -0.02611548639833927, -0.005815293174237013, 0.053211674094200134, 0.015334326773881912, 0.028187450021505356, -0.014291049912571907, -0.07439707964658737, -0.016467353329062462, 0.0481460876762867, 0.008420519530773163, -0.06717079877853394, -0.03500973433256149, -0.022566406056284904, -0.034687042236328125, 0.012652246281504631, -0.047534212470054626, 0.021392015740275383, -0.016574926674365997, -0.0001223125436808914, -0.061537351459264755, -0.014465107582509518, -0.011037914082407951, 0.013608566485345364, -0.05547614023089409, 0.062264326959848404, -0.0431087426841259, -0.03534920513629913, -0.021793479099869728, 0.03755870461463928, 0.008205519057810307, 0.04818062111735344, -0.04820268228650093, -0.05109744891524315, 0.0052470252849161625, 0.005063773598521948, -0.02372392639517784, -0.049585651606321335, -0.017617816105484962, -0.017268089577555656, -0.010447598062455654, 0.015339030884206295, -0.004042136017233133, -0.042847272008657455, 0.026525190100073814, 0.04375379905104637, -0.051139142364263535, 0.006249118130654097, -0.021914007142186165, 0.04198693484067917, 0.0473163016140461, 0.013715840876102448, 0.029829753562808037, 0.04764796420931816, 0.005372252780944109, 0.03799373283982277, 0.003795107826590538, 0.01097441092133522, -0.0367015078663826, -0.014232033863663673, -0.05679532140493393, -0.00764499930664897, -0.051086947321891785, 0.006200196221470833, -0.01978997513651848, 0.0527198500931263, -0.014899587258696556, -0.031707990914583206, 0.007764517795294523, 0.014435485936701298, -0.016698013991117477, -0.009490423835814, 0.03825356811285019, 0.05870329588651657, 0.010148362256586552, 0.016527488827705383, -0.00456606037914753, 0.0022687625605612993, -0.0029231132939457893, 0.032270610332489014, -0.024259693920612335, 0.04562729224562645, -0.027534116059541702, -0.024751419201493263, -0.011527798138558865, -0.03258677199482918, 0.03243739530444145, -0.0028839686419814825, 0.009219675324857235, -0.0027292382437735796, -0.010568118654191494, -0.010005692020058632, 0.018979933112859726, 0.027001235634088516, 0.03984837234020233, -0.05815914273262024, 0.024788012728095055, -0.016645876690745354, 0.019513411447405815, -0.05474327132105827, -0.026220783591270447, 0.01107410341501236, 0.009578049182891846, -0.03965918719768524, -0.019847949966788292, 0.027492254972457886, 0.012807839550077915, 0.008739454671740532, -0.005332400556653738, 0.015163465403020382, -0.025060193613171577, 0.023973973467946053, 0.031424716114997864, -0.009317019954323769, 0.05223613977432251, -0.0036706875544041395, 0.011623947881162167, -0.006574994418770075, -0.0037822856102138758, -0.014265951700508595, 0.03195904940366745, -0.01035157311707735, -0.0271237064152956, 0.00464591383934021, -0.038525599986314774, 0.015238549560308456, 0.02571914531290531, 0.012608582153916359, -0.010796025395393372, -0.004012351855635643, -0.017054447904229164, 0.000439692783402279, 0.006809963844716549, 0.030030103400349617, -0.005224158987402916, -0.03246819227933884, -0.006272250320762396, 0.02571828104555607, -0.004779931157827377, -0.03453909233212471, 0.016900569200515747, 0.007707706652581692, 0.0030321201775223017, -0.016833730041980743, 0.06585956364870071, -0.02507738582789898, -0.024538513273000717, -0.031482502818107605, -0.026243817061185837, 0.020889678969979286, 0.010947906412184238, 0.01308438740670681, -0.012842887081205845, 0.03438396751880646, -0.004690760280936956, 0.022742794826626778, -0.02051701955497265, -0.006862577050924301, 0.07997284829616547, -0.0276647862046957, 0.04431856423616409, 0.057795412838459015, 0.030540399253368378, 0.01269853301346302, -0.05334874615073204, 0.015634547919034958, -0.024133125320076942, 0.029356690123677254, 0.06831308454275131, 0.03732312098145485, -0.008906982839107513, 0.0572085902094841, -0.005077173002064228, 0.009680744260549545, 0.06329096853733063, 0.017630765214562416, 0.02174825221300125, 0.020238464698195457, 0.0032487253192812204, -0.051567163318395615, 0.01232437789440155, -0.06049797311425209, -0.009205497801303864, -0.023950273171067238, -0.0014195541152730584, 0.012793038040399551, 0.03561316803097725, 0.03372618556022644, -0.015570796094834805, -0.021236572414636612, -0.023503277450799942, 0.00837064441293478, -0.0008658618899062276, -0.021741699427366257, 0.04738381877541542, -0.0007249649497680366, 0.028976554051041603, 0.031444698572158813, 0.018230808898806572, -0.04397420957684517, -0.08219911903142929, -0.029126174747943878, 0.010643999092280865, -0.029943712055683136, -0.0036377590149641037, -0.0015094124246388674, -0.026596486568450928, -0.0028561828657984734, -0.0026225855108350515, 0.018213290721178055, -0.005107118748128414, 0.034275420010089874, -0.009148988872766495, 0.06213197857141495, 0.00797385536134243, 0.01784960739314556, 0.01718733459711075, -0.00767754390835762, 0.1178073063492775, 0.06150000914931297, 0.0234794020652771, -0.05830419063568115, 0.016093309968709946, 0.0023623143788427114, -0.033577337861061096, -0.0030392534099519253, 0.030063703656196594, 0.020168371498584747, 0.006971001159399748, 0.019323579967021942, 0.03130180016160011, 0.019537193700671196, -0.0026370256673544645, 0.037217333912849426, -0.01552283950150013, -0.007816593162715435, 0.03835082799196243, 0.005372362677007914, 0.00136843032669276, -0.04045609384775162, -0.044018495827913284, 0.03052171878516674, 0.0029619799461215734, -0.009494304656982422, 0.025870176032185555, -0.011529305018484592, 0.005397913046181202, -0.021346554160118103, 0.0004940367653034627, 0.019796492531895638, -0.00897081010043621, -0.026811568066477776, -0.013160393573343754, 0.004063807427883148, -0.00981927290558815, 0.012627588585019112, 0.02511643059551716, 0.03395583853125572, 0.007296065799891949, 0.008755139075219631, 0.01490963064134121, 0.01716492511332035, -0.03988362103700638, -0.031281258910894394, -0.053553830832242966, 0.08204102516174316, -0.029248671606183052, -0.04009417071938515, -0.0016943675000220537, -0.007413704879581928, 0.05022852495312691, -0.036099668592214584, 0.006920550484210253, 0.0382014662027359, 0.01867721602320671, -0.002696102252230048, -0.03925151005387306, -0.009973455220460892, 0.05827491730451584, 0.009188845753669739, 0.03428694233298302, 0.01462863851338625, -0.03167790547013283, -0.042224496603012085, 0.0051369620487093925, 0.018775440752506256, 0.03162670135498047, 0.006923477631062269, -0.003375328378751874, -0.03697434812784195, -0.0012676886981353164, 0.0014580875867977738, 0.007494701072573662, 0.008409240283071995, 0.011669853702187538, -0.047883711755275726, -0.025250144302845, -0.03773608058691025, 0.003271636087447405, -0.011596404947340488, -0.0008909148746170104, 0.01331066433340311, -0.017285339534282684, -0.004037289880216122, -0.021439457312226295, 0.047395575791597366, 0.030469931662082672, -0.00033391956822015345, 0.040072500705718994, 0.0448288768529892, -0.0323898084461689, -0.07386967539787292, -0.01501943077892065, -0.021163195371627808, -0.03229091688990593, 0.03234640508890152, 0.025043096393346786, 0.058678578585386276, 0.01048690639436245, -0.0034076939336955547, -0.03670111671090126, 0.043000053614377975, -0.00893440842628479, 0.012164273299276829, 0.0058289989829063416, -0.0710439682006836, -0.00942518562078476, -0.016573591157794, -0.0007651625201106071, -0.07103108614683151, -0.021131951361894608, -0.04569164663553238, -0.04129122197628021, 0.029846739023923874, -0.027361644431948662, -0.03789234906435013, 0.03599628806114197, 0.004117358475923538, 0.06201015040278435, 0.006348120514303446, -0.005017036572098732, -0.052316855639219284, 0.013979161158204079, -0.028071653097867966, -0.030625231564044952, -0.006167515181005001, -0.007783548906445503, 0.00743374926969409, -0.016581237316131592, 0.04550732672214508, 0.014087052084505558, 0.012818300165235996, -0.039338137954473495, 0.011293844319880009, 0.008293984457850456, 0.05889981612563133, -0.03848607838153839, 0.02457278035581112, 0.03161600977182388, -0.03380024433135986, -0.032626718282699585, 0.02785622328519821, -0.029054658487439156, 0.052601732313632965, 0.016465308144688606, -0.02053232491016388, 0.005727265030145645, 0.02200257033109665, 0.022601742297410965, -0.04115862771868706, 0.03326891362667084, 0.008271049708127975, 0.0034076266456395388, 0.018416278064250946, 0.005503910128027201, 0.009777230210602283, 0.0565602071583271, -0.01292066927999258, 0.018704857677221298, 0.008183769881725311, -0.023219693452119827, 0.00002991605651914142, -0.031469520181417465, 0.03249184787273407, 0.0059157186187803745, -0.0280326958745718, 0.023969391360878944, 0.031710054725408554, -0.05626583471894264, 0.022589534521102905, -0.010010883212089539, 0.038755252957344055, -0.033134158700704575, -0.021824974566698074, -0.004863308276981115, -0.007336316630244255, 0.019437815994024277, -0.05127738416194916, 0.010595821775496006, 0.049395132809877396, -0.03849226236343384, 0.0568234808743, -0.023662040010094643, 0.012626348063349724, -0.04151860624551773, 0.005260729696601629, -0.03780651465058327, 0.001764332759194076, 0.03337639570236206, -0.00723057147115469, 0.03505397588014603, 0.020771220326423645, -0.029093043878674507, -0.020305337384343147, -0.02326354943215847, 0.04237772524356842, -0.031108077615499496, -0.039442237466573715, 0.07088970392942429, -0.0276722963899374, -0.08906078338623047, 0.030340828001499176, -0.029434483498334885, 0.02681662142276764, 0.032599784433841705, 0.020099731162190437, 0.01860884390771389, 0.018544767051935196, 0.04751075431704521, 0.008992123417556286, 0.03684956952929497, 0.03446187078952789, 0.03144552558660507, 0.005482337437570095, -0.003064482705667615, 0.03156554698944092, 0.05414387583732605, 0.014857995323836803, -0.027482187375426292, 0.04696284979581833, -0.011353885754942894, -0.014240425080060959, -0.005792251788079739, 0.01554405689239502, 0.01959320530295372, -0.03922963887453079, -0.022730816155672073, -0.032782748341560364, -0.012204782105982304, 0.013235688209533691, 0.01337538380175829, -0.023814737796783447, -0.0009606096427887678, -0.045840904116630554, -0.04791291058063507, 0.00013190177560318261, 0.008666252717375755, 0.028690630570054054, -0.0675094872713089, 0.0073960465379059315, 0.004827447235584259, -0.025926249101758003, -0.029453402385115623, -0.0013563086977228522, -0.014454721473157406, 0.04328151419758797, -0.00014764130173716694, 0.06662483513355255, 0.01045230869203806, -0.026922965422272682, -0.012555808760225773, -0.10930565744638443, 0.05077368766069412, 0.000027851770937559195, -0.03726833313703537, -0.0012916600098833442, -0.00985552929341793, -0.03136201202869415, -0.021597927436232567, 0.011884637176990509, 0.02967735379934311, 0.014452967792749405, -0.056479815393686295, 0.03969742730259895, 0.008050409145653248, -0.051713261753320694, 0.030422300100326538, -0.0373716801404953, -0.020600171759724617, -0.024910438805818558, 0.0076768905855715275, 0.033318787813186646, -0.022729579359292984, 0.04266033694148064, 0.0005350455758161843, -0.0162777341902256, -0.012079725973308086, 0.0010186911094933748, 0.002779542002826929, 0.017474863678216934, 0.0030858118552714586, 0.022476274520158768, 0.01629617251455784, 0.0039563896134495735, 0.004204243887215853, -0.009142464958131313, -0.058710575103759766, 0.01478374283760786, -0.0542730912566185, 0.023209646344184875, -0.008395910263061523, 0.04963907226920128, -0.00371572352014482, -0.04227978736162186, -0.013003304600715637, 0.014322101138532162, -0.026928698644042015, 0.009635253809392452, 0.018536284565925598, 0.0226755253970623, -0.008363118395209312, 0.014114742167294025, 0.044958192855119705, 0.006064245011657476, 0.01110935490578413, -0.022511105984449387, 0.010673790238797665, -0.011588407680392265, 0.007417682558298111, 0.03070896491408348, 0.02179645001888275, -0.020015226677060127, 0.008891699835658073, -0.007528991438448429, 0.07573185116052628, -0.014194811694324017, 0.011831496842205524, -0.017160382121801376, -0.019368791952729225, -0.03181742876768112, -0.026221174746751785, -0.006914028897881508, 0.054363396018743515, -0.014563455246388912, -0.0029039590153843164, -0.04306872934103012, -0.042764440178871155, -0.008675952441990376, 0.041975509375333786, 0.02208738401532173, 0.06250457465648651, -0.004926023539155722, 0.0038882868830114603, -0.022930573672056198, 0.010331925004720688, 0.041455164551734924, -0.008953040465712547, 0.031334422528743744, -0.02379757910966873, -0.012757022865116596, 0.03616650030016899, -0.041862040758132935, 0.003389293560758233, -0.012637576088309288, 0.0031246363651007414, 0.03812608867883682, 0.00893315952271223, -0.014676771126687527, -0.05593244358897209, 0.0035406339447945356, 0.024989714846014977, -0.04186873883008957, -0.0162624754011631, -0.03745044767856598, 0.04646317660808563, 0.0043723611161112785, -0.016099784523248672 ]
<p>I wonder how to compute precision and recall using a confusion matrix for a multi-class classification problem. In specific, one observation can only be assigned with most probable class / label. </p> <p>I would like to compute </p> <ul> <li>Precision = TP / (TP+FP) </li> <li>Recall = TP / (TP+FN)</li> </ul> <p>for each class, and then compute the micro-averaged F-Measure.</p>
73,609
[ -0.017316529527306557, -0.02970518171787262, 0.04578951373696327, 0.0044642724096775055, 0.04335395619273186, 0.018404178321361542, -0.03451137617230415, 0.017269516363739967, 0.0028613831382244825, 0.002496500965207815, 0.018733467906713486, 0.022168880328536034, 0.06930643320083618, 0.028919324278831482, -0.0010061239590868354, 0.0030250262934714556, -0.019142286852002144, 0.003386296331882477, 0.00007430290133925155, -0.025447774678468704, -0.01296712551265955, -0.005440829787403345, 0.016503289341926575, -0.012992129661142826, -0.020712707191705704, 0.04166876897215843, 0.041173771023750305, -0.027525821700692177, 0.015225468203425407, 0.03737158328294754, -0.05048090219497681, -0.019906220957636833, 0.03530941903591156, 0.018267707899212837, 0.029822908341884613, -0.006804606877267361, -0.027662886306643486, 0.012086426839232445, -0.0649033933877945, 0.01751471497118473, -0.004648325964808464, -0.04206309840083122, 0.011902416124939919, 0.02257002890110016, 0.0145155880600214, 0.023190300911664963, -0.02808656357228756, 0.016245383769273758, 0.037435926496982574, -0.058809563517570496, 0.08376165479421616, 0.01707889325916767, 0.03514575585722923, 0.06006462499499321, -0.003936543595045805, 0.004148346371948719, 0.07048709690570831, 0.08162153512239456, 0.018122825771570206, -0.017483772709965706, -0.014034124091267586, -0.04634801298379898, 0.015157855115830898, -0.03618684038519859, -0.008334833197295666, 0.030562981963157654, -0.01863926090300083, -0.0472298339009285, 0.014748886227607727, -0.017183613032102585, -0.023137850686907768, -0.0012549996608868241, 0.01774301379919052, -0.0466027595102787, 0.06287232041358948, -0.014113766141235828, 0.026709740981459618, 0.0698719471693039, 0.04653475433588028, 0.01040444802492857, 0.0292999055236578, 0.05402594059705734, 0.008224766701459885, 0.018414698541164398, 0.015577211044728756, -0.02439928613603115, 0.06706893444061279, 0.006012552417814732, 0.016975197941064835, 0.04059278219938278, -0.024290623143315315, -0.01345138531178236, 0.038405075669288635, 0.023879077285528183, -0.047637537121772766, 0.04179889336228371, 0.01679239794611931, 0.019519807770848274, -0.0019239052198827267, -0.004811252932995558, -0.02256329171359539, -0.011815795674920082, -0.0024757487699389458, 0.04340085759758949, -0.04136763513088226, 0.01583780348300934, -0.03199313208460808, -0.03645780310034752, 0.025091690942645073, -0.013186515308916569, 0.030200181528925896, 0.024954546242952347, -0.01214731577783823, -0.0081920912489295, 0.00943476427346468, -0.02957317791879177, -0.010363832116127014, -0.03465339541435242, 0.03615410625934601, 0.0580330491065979, 0.034275975078344345, 0.013533494435250759, 0.021354392170906067, -0.019913524389266968, -0.05845142528414726, 0.011016309261322021, 0.04317184165120125, -0.0031925910152494907, -0.03710336983203888, 0.07328677922487259, -0.027068788185715675, -0.010748607106506824, 0.05091504752635956, -0.01564161293208599, -0.03312736377120018, -0.021798474714159966, -0.08278045803308487, -0.0449858158826828, 0.00966931413859129, 0.00818193331360817, -0.012308984063565731, -0.06430202722549438, -0.009247250854969025, 0.03859736770391464, 0.038414761424064636, 0.03603208810091019, 0.03548198193311691, 0.041335783898830414, 0.014898695982992649, 0.0003042739990632981, -0.021682972088456154, -0.0061387475579977036, -0.01410049106925726, 0.00799768790602684, -0.04386577382683754, -0.06117991358041763, -0.01315080001950264, 0.035120267421007156, -0.027446098625659943, 0.018528079614043236, 0.015310602262616158, -0.006309430114924908, 0.007715139538049698, 0.00041130659519694746, 0.02655276283621788, -0.021290594711899757, 0.0529545359313488, 0.004187655169516802, 0.004777724854648113, 0.0063923997804522514, -0.021106548607349396, -0.016283703967928886, 0.0195306409150362, 0.056258752942085266, 0.07595428824424744, -0.018965333700180054, -0.03185408562421799, -0.01956605538725853, 0.03244387358427048, -0.0016739226412028074, -0.019678570330142975, -0.024367453530430794, -0.04335775971412659, -0.02510431408882141, -0.008151770569384098, 0.03446657583117485, -0.016833895817399025, -0.005288536194711924, 0.0010179993696510792, -0.02479536458849907, -0.04222226142883301, -0.04542051628232002, -0.012273501604795456, -0.06575274467468262, -0.015440036542713642, 0.01068276446312666, -0.001290351152420044, 0.02283336967229843, 0.02410561963915825, -0.032907310873270035, -0.07185699045658112, -0.0015492370584979653, 0.03636855259537697, -0.05893297865986824, -0.0030157126020640135, 0.013872445560991764, 0.000609380251262337, -0.06583359092473984, 0.024198653176426888, -0.021077746525406837, -0.03980180248618126, -0.034525539726018906, -0.02670660987496376, 0.029843296855688095, -0.004350366536527872, -0.032288163900375366, 0.02599935419857502, 0.004648910369724035, -0.021301254630088806, 0.0030355616472661495, -0.02802601270377636, 0.04887520521879196, 0.0783236101269722, 0.025197602808475494, 0.012938433326780796, 0.0012261975789442658, -0.008921741507947445, 0.016888771206140518, 0.005682084243744612, -0.02646569162607193, -0.04654368385672569, -0.04482105001807213, 0.027977759018540382, 0.05786731839179993, 0.007905129343271255, -0.007685219869017601, 0.03292699530720711, -0.01374976709485054, 0.0032342018093913794, 0.0372922383248806, 0.006589412689208984, -0.01987691968679428, 0.01832878775894642, 0.06201617792248726, -0.016135603189468384, -0.01847822032868862, 0.01965361274778843, -0.006937556900084019, 0.04381583258509636, 0.026775311678647995, -0.006592608522623777, 0.04740074276924133, -0.02619764767587185, -0.004413267131894827, 0.005533577874302864, -0.050225287675857544, 0.023742007091641426, -0.015428682789206505, 0.004516843240708113, 0.0500931516289711, -0.0069947917945683, -0.0053455098532140255, 0.023834384977817535, 0.000991372624412179, 0.046350594609975815, 0.03721817582845688, -0.022518057376146317, 0.008275563828647137, 0.027832910418510437, -0.06723891943693161, 0.029877768829464912, 0.023833513259887695, -0.012250985950231552, 0.022391755133867264, 0.061428237706422806, 0.03281475231051445, -0.012638791464269161, 0.007286979816854, -0.02121853269636631, 0.0064712041057646275, -0.005881212186068296, -0.026690354570746422, 0.05188167467713356, -0.03422955796122551, -0.0785241574048996, -0.01313414890319109, -0.040870580822229385, -0.012179424054920673, 0.02539835125207901, -0.008498843759298325, -0.03178521990776062, -0.0011977488175034523, 0.011669039726257324, -0.03649553284049034, -0.033683162182569504, -0.015092872083187103, -0.009212189354002476, -0.04124118760228157, 0.03202550485730171, -0.03900367394089699, -0.008700556121766567, -0.06682386249303818, 0.024858491495251656, -0.020310701802372932, -0.044935133308172226, -0.00561872310936451, -0.048300012946128845, -0.00887172482907772, -0.025564631447196007, 0.0018030987121164799, 0.021327683702111244, -0.011456104926764965, -0.03249068558216095, -0.055175431072711945, -0.06323814392089844, 0.045919016003608704, -0.02575487643480301, 0.014767619781196117, -0.009912911802530289, -0.01881612464785576, 0.07673569023609161, 0.006862442474812269, -0.05121484771370888, -0.03523873910307884, 0.013096149079501629, -0.023903613910079002, -0.02089553512632847, 0.0034991810098290443, 0.03092198073863983, -0.027209101244807243, 0.013178545981645584, -0.006758339703083038, -0.023482397198677063, 0.06227824464440346, -0.009875647723674774, 0.008783821947872639, 0.023190952837467194, -0.023015042766928673, -0.02938806265592575, 0.007382822688668966, 0.010094370692968369, -0.017602458596229553, -0.021798644214868546, 0.002303370274603367, 0.00717657245695591, -0.01082043256610632, -0.03353585675358772, 0.01311806682497263, -0.01937711238861084, 0.010343868285417557, -0.03741789609193802, 0.02190713956952095, 0.006365781184285879, -0.011798148043453693, -0.03324227035045624, 0.03745206445455551, 0.04517450928688049, -0.023222221061587334, 0.013672837056219578, 0.0849037691950798, 0.06775542348623276, -0.01140927616506815, -0.018003754317760468, -0.011445773765444756, -0.008402585983276367, 0.031158365309238434, -0.046751610934734344, -0.01136134471744299, 0.015489392913877964, 0.047677528113126755, 0.0008571879588998854, 0.03487837687134743, -0.023128218948841095, 0.026927996426820755, -0.03826126083731651, -0.04218427836894989, -0.019686536863446236, 0.04278029501438141, 0.03020380809903145, 0.030635319650173187, -0.010529901832342148, -0.031025808304548264, 0.014554393477737904, 0.007577269338071346, -0.039796147495508194, 0.020194176584482193, 0.007902032695710659, -0.027660999447107315, 0.0382077656686306, -0.03095131926238537, 0.06172483414411545, -0.023085255175828934, 0.010669774375855923, -0.012827788479626179, 0.03703789412975311, -0.05935261771082878, 0.0022974808234721422, 0.0368071086704731, -0.013565128669142723, -0.053849030286073685, 0.03302093967795372, 0.02320687659084797, -0.007831118069589138, 0.036733563989400864, 0.01372632198035717, -0.02692892774939537, -0.03082876279950142, -0.012164960615336895, 0.02902686409652233, 0.019529029726982117, 0.025287678465247154, 0.01834719441831112, 0.055138200521469116, -0.05716605484485626, 0.03888724371790886, -0.0029549305327236652, 0.09134827554225922, 0.0363231785595417, -0.007324020843952894, -0.0355956107378006, -0.03076040744781494, -0.040315497666597366, 0.03541804105043411, 0.047538239508867264, -0.022475387901067734, -0.02059759385883808, 0.01922561787068844, 0.043357912451028824, -0.08965426683425903, 0.030537331476807594, 0.04639707878232002, -0.015355645678937435, 0.008206160739064217, -0.021164461970329285, 0.008421494625508785, -0.002555056242272258, -0.0069747199304401875, 0.048575159162282944, 0.03671292960643768, -0.0017318818718194962, -0.03742728754878044, 0.026187032461166382, -0.04020354524254799, -0.04047525301575661, -0.004235829226672649, 0.023945162072777748, -0.007560279686003923, 0.022314995527267456, -0.01223692949861288, -0.00427443441003561, 0.017614388838410378, 0.038647159934043884, 0.009842997416853905, 0.04564984142780304, -0.09057264775037766, -0.000453254790045321, 0.025972438976168633, 0.06692822277545929, -0.02485676296055317, -0.016427792608737946, -0.047185540199279785, -0.024943124502897263, 0.053405001759529114, -0.01040829997509718, 0.04900223761796951, 0.007699978072196245, 0.01807837374508381, -0.03301100432872772, 0.02286696992814541, -0.05019332841038704, 0.0029321666806936264, -0.006455444265156984, 0.03339158371090889, 0.01672518439590931, -0.022627418860793114, -0.033836036920547485, -0.0265329759567976, 0.020058512687683105, 0.0713924765586853, -0.007502949330955744, -0.019699543714523315, 0.01936511881649494, 0.0030570870731025934, -0.028499571606516838, -0.07269357144832611, -0.021752340719103813, -0.015709009021520615, -0.02304895967245102, 0.06847352534532547, 0.015496653504669666, 0.0036616495344787836, 0.030086254701018333, -0.0034837471321225166, -0.04061974212527275, -0.025957023724913597, -0.02071320451796055, 0.022730035707354546, 0.03704436495900154, 0.006394512485712767, 0.05918232724070549, 0.02167525328695774, 0.020788045600056648, 0.03130239248275757, -0.01619686745107174, 0.0054745664820075035, -0.034687116742134094, -0.015693284571170807, -0.018264170736074448, 0.023218076676130295, -0.015951022505760193, 0.02591228485107422, 0.019458414986729622, 0.037093065679073334, -0.010661594569683075, -0.02252172864973545, -0.04417179524898529, -0.008686356246471405, -0.012145754881203175, -0.012318435125052929, 0.0038452744483947754, 0.003480912186205387, -0.028385039418935776, 0.017338421195745468, 0.04297807440161705, 0.004265854600816965, 0.019867464900016785, 0.006917973980307579, -0.006882821209728718, 0.01737857237458229, -0.0051481714472174644, -0.03313169628381729, 0.01583135314285755, -0.022798310965299606, 0.041385699063539505, -0.01061782706528902, 0.023896120488643646, 0.02318774163722992, -0.04573177173733711, -0.02719898149371147, 0.0308360755443573, 0.0030823340639472008, 0.05222123861312866, -0.03180679306387901, -0.008391541428864002, 0.009397230111062527, -0.003625535871833563, -0.019996030256152153, -0.007735458202660084, 0.01725412718951702, -0.012338738888502121, -0.018855303525924683, -0.03288554400205612, -0.00934707559645176, -0.018475281074643135, -0.014304064214229584, -0.00830255076289177, 0.0447615422308445, 0.007055190391838551, -0.045837514102458954, 0.016258344054222107, 0.009551038965582848, 0.06260578334331512, 0.01919199898838997, 0.037129562348127365, 0.026572834700345993, -0.016400737687945366, -0.04607691988348961, 0.016347333788871765, 0.02630661614239216, -0.034999534487724304, -0.017124148085713387, -0.04239668324589729, 0.04516934975981712, 0.03134836629033089, -0.0008126370958052576, 0.02905217744410038, 0.013913094997406006, 0.0022900972981005907, -0.0012641430366784334, -0.04908280074596405, 0.0009693165775388479, -0.04282880574464798, -0.008004795759916306, -0.020005227997899055, 0.028098413720726967, -0.0303812138736248, 0.014443378895521164, -0.0004188049933873117, -0.034557998180389404, -0.017475949600338936, 0.01123021263629198, 0.08067790418863297, -0.002194753848016262, 0.018623918294906616, 0.03821433708071709, -0.035035207867622375, 0.02944641187787056, -0.004020216874778271, -0.01329066138714552, 0.014851655811071396, 0.025734763592481613, -0.015829019248485565, 0.020786358043551445, -0.03750581294298172, 0.000947225489653647, 0.0748736560344696, 0.0026355204172432423, 0.03205833211541176, 0.03429567441344261, 0.023923933506011963, -0.025728002190589905, 0.013730381615459919, -0.013138274662196636, 0.017406975850462914, -0.004321267828345299, 0.08561025559902191, -0.016516167670488358, -0.02937251329421997, -0.010197415947914124, -0.013047892600297928, 0.015477466396987438, 0.03383438661694527, -0.002221445320174098, 0.016794657334685326, 0.03059985861182213, -0.012152407318353653, -0.0477636344730854, 0.027803048491477966, -0.005683222785592079, 0.002312765922397375, -0.005768307484686375, -0.07131218165159225, 0.02298075705766678, 0.01954183541238308, -0.002040269784629345, 0.004237891640514135, -0.024436423555016518, -0.033414844423532486, 0.02152605727314949, 0.01303634699434042, -0.013394122943282127, 0.0018501252634450793, -0.008860060013830662, 0.053371015936136246, 0.015655744820833206, 0.029508374631404877, -0.014373295940458775, -0.05998839810490608, -0.01803193800151348, -0.01641857624053955, -0.047933731228113174, 0.027596456930041313, -0.006051914766430855, -0.03436430171132088, 0.04305317625403404, -0.003781873732805252, 0.04913674294948578, 0.018656941130757332, 0.037049323320388794, 0.008746651001274586, 0.03207201510667801, -0.0008289498509839177, 0.03484973683953285, 0.0156380794942379, -0.007174219004809856, 0.133610337972641, 0.08162257075309753, 0.04568316787481308, -0.0532691590487957, -0.028286496177315712, 0.009508646093308926, -0.0164557583630085, -0.026557210832834244, 0.037442345172166824, 0.012770980596542358, 0.006285752635449171, 0.01034759171307087, 0.04298128932714462, 0.009845312684774399, -0.012208759784698486, 0.026753734797239304, -0.005665561184287071, -0.00487836729735136, 0.03133765608072281, 0.008950476534664631, 0.047094788402318954, -0.005457641556859016, -0.0702115073800087, 0.039766956120729446, -0.0068547725677490234, -0.04012421518564224, -0.016787340864539146, 0.012930765748023987, 0.023197034373879433, -0.020025569945573807, -0.015371289104223251, 0.02072831802070141, -0.016310900449752808, 0.020003926008939743, 0.012052341364324093, 0.03811002895236015, 0.008275307714939117, 0.012621644884347916, 0.010030766017735004, 0.054248470813035965, 0.015353762544691563, 0.01758573390543461, -0.004698973149061203, 0.02369840256869793, -0.03745931386947632, -0.021251970902085304, -0.05939922481775284, 0.0492999367415905, -0.01532434206455946, -0.00549086881801486, 0.010868406854569912, -0.004950669128447771, 0.007463247515261173, -0.025400659069418907, -0.023941578343510628, 0.028315242379903793, 0.01666525937616825, -0.006696158554404974, -0.01560524757951498, -0.008196646347641945, 0.014197492972016335, -0.009137185290455818, -0.03846581280231476, 0.0025725977029651403, -0.012298837304115295, -0.04593481495976448, -0.03612356632947922, 0.02655349113047123, 0.010122837498784065, -0.000059957263147225603, -0.0106819374486804, -0.0038695349358022213, -0.014908887445926666, -0.031093444675207138, -0.006807681173086166, -0.007127399556338787, 0.01904791034758091, 0.017225680872797966, -0.022246088832616806, -0.004526431672275066, -0.07220161706209183, 0.006929035298526287, -0.024795182049274445, 0.013048755005002022, -0.045179251581430435, -0.033144522458314896, 0.047865621745586395, -0.0062485868111252785, 0.02364755980670452, 0.021662293002009392, 0.004649503622204065, 0.01929694227874279, -0.014637348242104053, -0.012848987244069576, 0.02922149933874607, -0.006615079939365387, -0.02511463314294815, 0.03760327771306038, -0.01450671162456274, 0.05809002369642258, 0.04737190157175064, 0.0070594437420368195, 0.005632598884403706, 0.022304313257336617, 0.033396124839782715, 0.002572466619312763, -0.017832156270742416, -0.019668331369757652, 0.024704350158572197, -0.0002029829629464075, 0.014800035394728184, -0.03876325115561485, 0.011434516869485378, -0.07124919444322586, -0.0319141186773777, 0.02943648025393486, 0.0064828055910766125, -0.007920928299427032, -0.010450412519276142, -0.00910299550741911, 0.026968946680426598, -0.026475651189684868, 0.011596661992371082, -0.026448074728250504, 0.0392930693924427, -0.08052541315555573, -0.007754683960229158, -0.040659308433532715, 0.01555838342756033, -0.028299206867814064, 0.009527974762022495, 0.04879433661699295, 0.00008933504432206973, -0.023260803893208504, -0.005886644124984741, 0.0029833358712494373, -0.020165521651506424, 0.03377845138311386, -0.017845461145043373, 0.018149711191654205, 0.0483655147254467, -0.07084453850984573, -0.02754533477127552, -0.0021271088626235723, -0.005769373383373022, 0.038176827132701874, 0.0633382797241211, -0.0055446987971663475, -0.014194482006132603, 0.03605460375547409, -0.012754998169839382, -0.01743193529546261, 0.010723074898123741, 0.020556677132844925, 0.006007954478263855, 0.02568661980330944, 0.01725909486413002, 0.007532039657235146, -0.03525111451745033, -0.0027863504365086555, 0.026823513209819794, 0.001080667250789702, -0.003555682487785816, 0.035255592316389084, -0.03678743913769722, 0.0244048610329628, 0.02702866494655609, -0.02444012090563774, -0.017802610993385315, 0.029020968824625015, 0.01464760210365057, -0.013331686146557331, -0.024554351344704628, 0.006141111720353365, -0.08421233296394348, -0.04035031050443649, 0.003968498203903437, 0.03644793853163719, 0.06234123185276985, -0.0326744019985199, 0.02607615664601326, 0.05179085209965706, -0.021652432158589363, 0.006291921716183424, -0.010632652789354324, -0.0034132448490709066, -0.003702716436237097, 0.004574939142912626, -0.025556182488799095, 0.017029881477355957, 0.04055862873792648, 0.00565010029822588, 0.044099025428295135, 0.001054586609825492, -0.0449097603559494, -0.043389033526182175, -0.0244506374001503, 0.03854666277766228, 0.03324347734451294, -0.06468899548053741, 0.017803847789764404, -0.021687855944037437, -0.03436960652470589, 0.024230659008026123, 0.0029241994488984346, 0.008624766021966934, 0.004950841888785362, 0.032475221902132034, -0.00005383947427617386, 0.040668852627277374, -0.015420174226164818, -0.04391186311841011, 0.02484970912337303, 0.03619925305247307, 0.008351996541023254, -0.013232285156846046, -0.016222601756453514, -0.00425658468157053, 0.03245231509208679, -0.019839301705360413, -0.04862705245614052, 0.01554240845143795, -0.0098150335252285, -0.004274266771972179, -0.03138022869825363, -0.006424446124583483, -0.006337757688015699, -0.0452968068420887, -0.004744307138025761, -0.0594949834048748, -0.003813194576650858, 0.017562976107001305, 0.0532325878739357, 0.009594133123755455, 0.03192489594221115, -0.01063829381018877, -0.03934619575738907, 0.02374986559152603, -0.005954266060143709, -0.04278905317187309, -0.04368774592876434, -0.008330725133419037, 0.013761406764388084, -0.013073504902422428, -0.0002713612047955394, -0.023895757272839546, -0.04851334169507027, 0.04555065929889679, -0.04876834154129028, -0.014526007696986198, -0.01267616730183363, -0.001046413672156632, 0.029909586533904076, -0.08559642732143402, 0.034037500619888306, 0.009029493667185307, 0.00009863304148893803, -0.0008288053795695305, 0.018029486760497093, -0.022512298077344894, 0.029675211757421494, 0.05830039829015732, 0.01410675048828125, 0.00648449407890439, -0.01662985049188137, 0.002955579198896885, 0.009068598039448261, -0.07482971251010895, 0.014433442614972591, -0.03714970126748085, -0.029997704550623894, -0.03306955471634865, -0.01582501456141472, 0.02511517144739628, -0.01880166493356228, 0.043709829449653625, -0.04300672188401222, -0.018477346748113632, -0.011810988187789917, -0.027023479342460632, 0.010531986132264137, -0.010188366286456585, -0.0015529034426435828, 0.020237253978848457, 0.012347407639026642, 0.0030712366569787264, 0.0504932664334774, 0.019240982830524445, -0.05538409203290939, 0.0023373367730528116, -0.020225567743182182, -0.009086436592042446, -0.0185879934579134, 0.05172299966216087, -0.002256097039207816, -0.10864189267158508, 0.03274860605597496, 0.019686441868543625, -0.028698448091745377, -0.0026461828965693712, 0.08270684629678726, -0.002489963546395302, 0.0543537363409996, 0.007122595328837633, 0.02843865007162094, -0.021128414198756218, -0.08286934345960617, 0.02397073432803154, 0.014317481778562069, -0.00595750380307436, -0.02065233141183853, 0.025755539536476135, 0.008884305134415627, -0.026367057114839554, 0.01644810661673546, -0.01573803462088108, 0.028323106467723846, -0.0481974296271801, 0.002559274435043335, 0.034823548048734665, 0.001613678759895265, 0.02234317734837532, 0.017288539558649063, -0.012382197193801403, 0.03611605986952782, -0.002326246118173003, -0.014493249356746674, -0.05447437986731529, -0.035996053367853165, -0.023987770080566406, 0.012716016732156277, 0.001565340906381607, 0.06640814989805222, 0.03405554220080376, 0.03250700235366821, -0.019501380622386932, -0.01044898759573698, 0.0048865885473787785, -0.032750364392995834, 0.0017634712858125567, -0.006000484339892864, 0.0009614354930818081, -0.019956963136792183, 0.0020793061703443527, -0.04492376744747162, -0.007659873925149441, 0.01800321787595749, 0.05513845384120941, 0.02657398022711277, -0.02913261018693447, -0.03157542273402214, -0.02294761873781681, 0.004969130270183086, -0.04864955320954323, 0.005507130175828934, -0.08397243171930313, 0.011879866942763329, -0.006244351156055927, -0.0018137303413823247 ]
<p>I conducted a panel OLS regression using gretl, on a balanced panel with around 25 zones and 10 time periods. I would like to use the model to forecast future values of y (dependant variable), given known future changes of x (explanatory variable).</p> <p>I would like to ask: how to deal with (a) the constant, (b) the unit dummies; (c) the time dummies when it comes to forecasting. Do i have to include any/all of the above in computing y-hat, or simply use the coefficient for the x term?</p>
73,610
[ -0.0006457777344621718, -0.014793077483773232, 0.02024194411933422, 0.028157200664281845, 0.028087852522730827, 0.028655491769313812, -0.015584269538521767, -0.03921392187476158, 0.059091318398714066, -0.03773816302418709, 0.017918389290571213, 0.07627382129430771, 0.04196683317422867, 0.0010328690987080336, 0.017911652103066444, -0.01134327333420515, -0.01901078410446644, 0.019002143293619156, -0.030756613239645958, -0.01171646174043417, -0.020009880885481834, 0.030728943645954132, -0.021696655079722404, 0.021600116044282913, 0.014996015466749668, 0.06136723607778549, 0.034849073737859726, 0.020282696932554245, 0.006558832712471485, 0.06070486456155777, -0.0013087829574942589, -0.025941234081983566, 0.015043351799249649, 0.050912439823150635, 0.02633465640246868, -0.0019489654805511236, -0.00005173037061467767, -0.06169533729553223, -0.033494699746370316, 0.01821013353765011, -0.042601004242897034, -0.002227790653705597, -0.013745002448558807, 0.03566042706370354, 0.0036023403517901897, 0.03393414989113808, 0.0019347425550222397, -0.013734940439462662, 0.0336761474609375, -0.05465804412961006, 0.07339242845773697, -0.010057032108306885, 0.00603860430419445, 0.0264657661318779, -0.03770618885755539, -0.0026398124173283577, 0.03824340179562569, 0.09381628781557083, -0.03928965702652931, -0.021548420190811157, 0.0015159560134634376, 0.0058333068154752254, 0.005849024280905724, -0.0615229457616806, -0.01971239224076271, 0.023801889270544052, -0.004497752524912357, -0.0010817846050485969, 0.021537533029913902, -0.040189288556575775, 0.05634406581521034, 0.025380421429872513, 0.041429322212934494, -0.017341790720820427, 0.00912447553128004, -0.06459259241819382, 0.0036465278826653957, 0.03715240955352783, 0.04165506362915039, 0.047015391290187836, -0.007275032345205545, 0.04908011853694916, 0.030216019600629807, 0.01992299221456051, 0.04260088875889778, 0.011656221933662891, 0.04648615047335625, -0.011282576248049736, 0.02232944592833519, 0.04485631361603737, -0.019493412226438522, 0.027442486956715584, 0.05530579015612602, -0.01914328522980213, -0.026508236303925514, 0.037070564925670624, -0.01998591236770153, 0.03019036166369915, 0.020350221544504166, 0.010860782116651535, 0.02632700838148594, -0.028910892084240913, -0.003924265969544649, 0.04193122684955597, -0.02054540067911148, -0.003544930135831237, -0.01931202970445156, -0.04390836879611015, 0.03012780100107193, -0.06301959604024887, -0.04166782274842262, 0.007193839177489281, -0.05209510400891304, -0.01111866906285286, 0.008698752149939537, -0.017571546137332916, 0.019135992974042892, 0.011144445277750492, 0.04910897836089134, 0.05372760072350502, 0.060866255313158035, -0.03819674625992775, 0.02066754549741745, -0.00032139665563590825, -0.04929482564330101, 0.020077161490917206, -0.021693484857678413, -0.007344091311097145, -0.0498991496860981, 0.048942022025585175, -0.005527415778487921, -0.030082721263170242, 0.01138425711542368, -0.008721088990569115, 0.04350990802049637, 0.012857881374657154, -0.06749474257230759, -0.09679432213306427, 0.006226643454283476, -0.013039980083703995, -0.008031115867197514, -0.06122254207730293, -0.021553106606006622, 0.0033798052463680506, 0.047563109546899796, 0.007245357614010572, 0.012632821686565876, 0.001741914078593254, 0.022285502403974533, 0.023174189031124115, -0.036793000996112823, -0.03327108547091484, -0.0010396154830232263, -0.026470880955457687, -0.00524523388594389, -0.06028948351740837, 0.019954117015004158, 0.039593275636434555, 0.027272243052721024, -0.010017989203333855, 0.05414030700922012, 0.015643350780010223, -0.02476816624403, 0.009025683626532555, -0.025009507313370705, -0.06703247874975204, 0.03992253914475441, -0.02965683676302433, 0.014886612072587013, 0.02809186466038227, 0.0254362765699625, 0.02997366525232792, 0.0035598024260252714, 0.03920263797044754, 0.04044833779335022, -0.0006457093986682594, -0.00153110281098634, -0.045659057796001434, -0.02012939564883709, 0.01817873679101467, -0.05977245420217514, -0.06687450408935547, -0.02941310405731201, -0.01249221432954073, 0.012227358296513557, 0.03359578177332878, -0.011468663811683655, 0.005888694431632757, 0.0156659297645092, -0.041082803159952164, -0.06424557417631149, -0.058723025023937225, 0.03981124982237816, 0.014526871964335442, 0.03063851222395897, 0.009998032823204994, -0.019213255494832993, 0.0015645241364836693, -0.018517928197979927, -0.061149269342422485, -0.0010977565543726087, 0.017327258363366127, 0.06450257450342178, -0.06374000012874603, 0.025388246402144432, 0.03127032145857811, 0.04685850068926811, -0.02434426359832287, 0.06156706064939499, -0.0790780633687973, -0.012373005971312523, 0.018164673820137978, -0.029851971194148064, 0.013345438987016678, -0.01315846387296915, -0.003178507322445512, -0.010283458046615124, -0.043631911277770996, -0.021579772233963013, 0.03409609943628311, -0.05262236297130585, 0.05101903900504112, 0.066865935921669, -0.010033227503299713, 0.01484964694827795, 0.012137609533965588, -0.019542908295989037, 0.04480280727148056, -0.02097955346107483, -0.013452268205583096, -0.05486353859305382, 0.0019074790179729462, 0.02447626180946827, 0.009102080017328262, 0.0001245079911313951, 0.02376534976065159, 0.0701427012681961, 0.017460422590374947, 0.008166957646608353, 0.040171362459659576, 0.019850030541419983, 0.02198527380824089, -0.0063227759674191475, -0.029070859774947166, 0.03720429539680481, 0.00982037466019392, 0.022215096279978752, 0.028114167973399162, -0.01510743796825409, 0.018975015729665756, -0.0051685054786503315, 0.06581047177314758, 0.022444769740104675, 0.013976383954286575, -0.010261984542012215, -0.009111706167459488, 0.05038242042064667, -0.03125818818807602, 0.0058763716369867325, 0.031512677669525146, 0.01889580860733986, -0.03051653504371643, 0.014387031085789204, -0.002761289244517684, -0.010079083032906055, 0.02800939977169037, -0.051473502069711685, -0.0012096109567210078, 0.02390223741531372, -0.01496156957000494, 0.018087230622768402, -0.002962857484817505, -0.024595769122242928, -0.0315629206597805, -0.035729117691516876, 0.04736272618174553, -0.004521634429693222, 0.06371276080608368, 0.002896546619012952, -0.007875503040850163, 0.021763455122709274, -0.015269255265593529, 0.017208682373166084, -0.01827053911983967, -0.019618814811110497, -0.0015570191899314523, -0.016562122851610184, -0.031139058992266655, 0.04541277885437012, -0.010999833233654499, -0.030033757910132408, 0.03400024399161339, -0.03917966037988663, -0.03211546316742897, -0.05879142880439758, -0.01915193535387516, 0.014746875502169132, -0.03009025938808918, -0.015640081837773323, 0.01241315808147192, -0.020614860579371452, -0.01753292605280876, 0.035982392728328705, -0.021428445354104042, 0.014264964498579502, -0.018134746700525284, 0.007371722254902124, -0.0005678499583154917, -0.0030931602232158184, 0.02074548229575157, -0.006904878653585911, -0.017558543011546135, 0.022681817412376404, -0.03932022675871849, -0.051454510539770126, 0.03328387811779976, 0.014360370114445686, 0.018546683713793755, 0.013939772732555866, -0.026900388300418854, 0.07918623834848404, 0.01763322204351425, 0.024273348972201347, -0.06456822156906128, -0.031185677275061607, -0.021625978872179985, -0.03334272652864456, 0.018789775669574738, 0.006864722818136215, 0.0030625408980995417, 0.008778643794357777, -0.015010836534202099, -0.00040998007170856, 0.06766144186258316, 0.021738901734352112, 0.02567315474152565, -0.012479724362492561, 0.009565278887748718, 0.040429696440696716, 0.04294683411717415, 0.02663649246096611, -0.011384021490812302, -0.014770681038498878, -0.0215667225420475, 0.02985304780304432, 0.008321073837578297, -0.016184398904442787, 0.010849932208657265, -0.016682114452123642, -0.01692190021276474, -0.0013305075699463487, 0.03479325771331787, -0.005462131928652525, -0.04204574599862099, -0.04538626968860626, -0.017136629670858383, 0.021284617483615875, -0.009755547158420086, -0.0011506115552037954, 0.029433738440275192, -0.0055539668537676334, 0.02317388914525509, 0.003369136480614543, -0.012026237323880196, -0.02077069878578186, 0.006753904279321432, -0.05168291553854942, -0.019767628982663155, 0.03944552689790726, 0.02063918672502041, -0.002553911879658699, 0.012769420631229877, -0.04250188171863556, -0.0045349556021392345, -0.07691441476345062, -0.04845738038420677, -0.0003712848701979965, 0.07776977866888046, -0.0006026895134709775, 0.038028597831726074, 0.019015105441212654, -0.005532064940780401, 0.00923656765371561, 0.0008533518412150443, -0.06327974796295166, 0.03675796091556549, -0.028294404968619347, 0.007468864321708679, 0.010446559637784958, -0.014996247366070747, 0.03770618140697479, -0.0067850640043616295, 0.02257413975894451, 0.0012814744841307402, 0.018393946811556816, -0.015049519948661327, 0.020980892702937126, -0.006939352955669165, 0.0015817295061424375, -0.026437683030962944, -0.01421455666422844, 0.04004839062690735, 0.004364259075373411, 0.01977079175412655, 0.03878489509224892, -0.014514829963445663, 0.020429115742444992, -0.033355697989463806, -0.01212345901876688, 0.029146317392587662, 0.03522585332393646, 0.02501031942665577, 0.009749254211783409, -0.0418795607984066, -0.0019047156674787402, 0.017932629212737083, 0.05281374976038933, 0.035595234483480453, -0.016803983598947525, -0.03344272822141647, -0.031380943953990936, -0.015997199341654778, 0.0346527025103569, 0.022274641320109367, 0.017293905839323997, 0.03519519791007042, 0.06163671612739563, 0.0105645302683115, -0.02976115606725216, 0.020382486283779144, 0.06366624683141708, 0.012376631610095501, -0.008979733102023602, -0.04783850908279419, 0.027966517955064774, -0.004536060616374016, 0.007254409603774548, 0.018621010705828667, -0.014789101667702198, -0.02184552699327469, -0.005342222284525633, 0.037211813032627106, 0.006815620232373476, -0.03653109818696976, 0.030106239020824432, 0.07128870487213135, 0.04897790402173996, 0.039096634835004807, -0.05305129289627075, 0.03292916342616081, 0.06704562157392502, 0.03999781981110573, 0.03312498703598976, -0.010580676607787609, -0.07146425545215607, 0.008284698240458965, 0.047828253358602524, 0.07072144001722336, -0.023867378011345863, 0.012389193288981915, -0.031047217547893524, 0.0063243890181183815, 0.03579550236463547, -0.03763400390744209, 0.00006377294630510733, -0.02377237193286419, -0.02420133911073208, -0.008655983954668045, -0.0016372009413316846, -0.07134387642145157, 0.02728547342121601, -0.029899433255195618, 0.06638457626104355, -0.02705356292426586, -0.02754894644021988, -0.051903631538152695, 0.050956521183252335, 0.023789145052433014, 0.044666893780231476, -0.013188593089580536, -0.01895929127931595, 0.01837269961833954, 0.03451049327850342, 0.007016937714070082, -0.057142358273267746, -0.015625126659870148, 0.023838220164179802, -0.012980923056602478, 0.05967111513018608, 0.022648552432656288, -0.028545191511511803, -0.017066679894924164, 0.0239548422396183, 0.0007015297887846828, -0.002953855786472559, -0.012339777313172817, 0.03342108801007271, 0.01686420477926731, -0.019228897988796234, 0.031228309497237206, -0.00034074639552272856, 0.017046716064214706, 0.045162320137023926, -0.015504137612879276, -0.008675983175635338, -0.022398771718144417, -0.000009470378245168831, -0.018543332815170288, -0.016639593988656998, 0.004533407744020224, 0.001398961991071701, -0.004532231949269772, 0.0019119620556011796, -0.04371657222509384, -0.021705446764826775, 0.01716274581849575, 0.032056160271167755, -0.034734420478343964, -0.003205913584679365, 0.00814207922667265, 0.012775398790836334, -0.031931322067976, -0.01741558499634266, -0.03246520459651947, -0.026020267978310585, 0.04186936840415001, 0.010967005975544453, -0.03225589916110039, 0.010369857773184776, -0.02196616865694523, 0.0033250506967306137, 0.007641232572495937, -0.01624632626771927, 0.019785458222031593, 0.005336134694516659, 0.012715620920062065, 0.03547218069434166, -0.03886735066771507, -0.027054470032453537, 0.006806426681578159, -0.024482985958456993, 0.049532201141119, -0.052045829594135284, 0.04282030090689659, 0.007164955139160156, 0.0019378199940547347, -0.09498206526041031, -0.04252657666802406, 0.015034533105790615, -0.0037773458752781153, -0.026776231825351715, -0.00816745962947607, -0.002799015725031495, -0.07162270694971085, -0.045114196836948395, -0.04292110726237297, 0.04013003408908844, -0.03768467158079147, 0.0013079599011689425, -0.020268462598323822, 0.016148559749126434, 0.09149495512247086, -0.00673000980168581, 0.01742807775735855, 0.008083703927695751, -0.04153135418891907, -0.04532439261674881, -0.004239147994667292, 0.0015253163874149323, -0.030647331848740578, -0.0033784247934818268, -0.01648775488138199, 0.0047549600712955, 0.053339723497629166, -0.030864767730236053, -0.02319260500371456, 0.023101776838302612, -0.005578354466706514, -0.01329277828335762, -0.017068354412913322, 0.017236433923244476, -0.061456210911273956, 0.0002221453469246626, -0.006398663390427828, -0.024961000308394432, 0.0046362788416445255, -0.01741417683660984, 0.03879017010331154, -0.005244856234639883, 0.024335140362381935, 0.0110867228358984, 0.04850387945771217, 0.0008363554370589554, -0.01455033291131258, 0.01739511638879776, -0.018702078610658646, 0.06984401494264603, -0.005313471425324678, 0.001415478065609932, -0.006491819396615028, 0.016456618905067444, -0.04109131172299385, -0.06866292655467987, -0.012158036231994629, 0.02736554481089115, 0.032026518136262894, -0.016465311869978905, 0.020309943705797195, 0.034266263246536255, -0.0029458091594278812, -0.014741003513336182, -0.04563748463988304, -0.021801702678203583, -0.029086647555232048, -0.015567189082503319, 0.018784048035740852, 0.0352114737033844, -0.011731747537851334, 0.004920336417853832, 0.050596773624420166, 0.028044722974300385, 0.04734991863369942, 0.04869534820318222, 0.025189345702528954, 0.020573463290929794, -0.023368781432509422, -0.0430578738451004, 0.03111536242067814, -0.03635428473353386, 0.003861594945192337, -0.08285066485404968, -0.011550559662282467, 0.026495937258005142, 0.05414403975009918, -0.0023383130319416523, -0.04024196043610573, -0.04863458126783371, -0.05362870544195175, 0.02643868885934353, 0.03699279576539993, -0.011260580271482468, -0.005979868583381176, 0.048301417380571365, 0.04138137772679329, 0.016236551105976105, 0.036713067442178726, 0.0003604252415243536, -0.07364674657583237, -0.0033638307359069586, -0.025271102786064148, -0.020899634808301926, 0.010620515793561935, 0.008057672530412674, 0.004089120775461197, 0.020666737109422684, -0.012089434079825878, 0.006288739386945963, -0.011155745945870876, 0.05743113532662392, 0.028972811996936798, 0.1038881242275238, -0.026566902175545692, -0.007354951463639736, -0.04647355154156685, 0.02184947580099106, 0.11064031720161438, 0.046712808310985565, 0.01675625704228878, -0.059579912573099136, -0.005873252172023058, -0.0029465635307133198, -0.01606224849820137, -0.011569208465516567, -0.0025164352264255285, -0.0016561246011406183, -0.01876128651201725, 0.05868228152394295, 0.06028491631150246, -0.036773499101400375, -0.0029858052730560303, 0.03622359409928322, -0.03427204489707947, 0.016345983371138573, 0.012897547334432602, 0.011846448294818401, -0.017128586769104004, 0.014805836603045464, -0.06311747431755066, -0.012749981135129929, -0.013413319364190102, -0.007121221628040075, -0.015133301727473736, -0.04535538703203201, 0.010695826262235641, 0.008957489393651485, -0.04831516742706299, 0.0165234562009573, 0.01073678582906723, 0.022607075050473213, -0.03167858347296715, -0.016215553507208824, 0.02221783623099327, -0.014436393044888973, -0.0000655768089927733, 0.026697391644120216, -0.02812228724360466, -0.022657951340079308, -0.007871839217841625, -0.020112482830882072, -0.021100979298353195, -0.010925807990133762, -0.015384462662041187, 0.030032984912395477, -0.017644628882408142, -0.03301585465669632, 0.02133196033537388, 0.017020301893353462, 0.015256737358868122, -0.035330820828676224, -0.011794276535511017, 0.03150346502661705, 0.052833862602710724, -0.03611871227622032, -0.008699502795934677, -0.026497799903154373, -0.025935128331184387, -0.009669560007750988, 0.009097876027226448, 0.025479495525360107, -0.029442930594086647, 0.008060351014137268, -0.03164133056998253, 0.01821093261241913, 0.0031958885956555605, -0.025608059018850327, 0.0007303126621991396, -0.02841506153345108, -0.047418300062417984, -0.05624018982052803, 0.037459660321474075, -0.01456507295370102, -0.015965016558766365, -0.005466410890221596, 0.003983486443758011, -0.015538335777819157, -0.051119398325681686, 0.011484701186418533, -0.00831665750592947, -0.015991631895303726, -0.03060542233288288, 0.038053013384342194, -0.001621397677809, 0.024699438363313675, -0.013109949417412281, 0.023679129779338837, 0.0025699923280626535, 0.012502843514084816, -0.010740475729107857, -0.05257111415266991, -0.02581895887851715, 0.0011938981479033828, -0.03087172657251358, -0.04496299847960472, 0.014354647137224674, 0.06252171844244003, 0.02023029699921608, 0.006681304890662432, -0.025806700810790062, 0.0366831049323082, -0.009547452442348003, 0.03135262802243233, 0.0231271144002676, -0.03189478814601898, -0.008645477704703808, 0.040488794445991516, 0.014086682349443436, -0.07322124391794205, -0.015008068643510342, -0.052515942603349686, -0.0036851277109235525, -0.005221053026616573, -0.015830039978027344, -0.049458764493465424, 0.06287086755037308, 0.00572167756035924, 0.040270350873470306, -0.0343438982963562, 0.011979931965470314, -0.03654342144727707, 0.03461121395230293, 0.028661146759986877, -0.036042314022779465, 0.02942098118364811, 0.014788435772061348, -0.04123328626155853, -0.0016440897015854716, 0.03547172620892525, 0.03467634320259094, 0.021530697122216225, -0.004989725537598133, -0.00391440698876977, -0.019103482365608215, 0.04909401759505272, -0.03982071951031685, -0.0334390364587307, 0.01586594060063362, -0.012940076179802418, -0.010705740191042423, 0.01593678630888462, 0.025631219148635864, 0.04081029072403908, 0.017093094065785408, 0.032197255641222, -0.0007341649034060538, 0.027535075321793556, -0.003556207288056612, 0.005171101074665785, 0.0004833342682104558, 0.007114511914551258, 0.025150055065751076, 0.0032033342868089676, 0.013907134532928467, 0.022423051297664642, 0.014709844253957272, 0.020363163203001022, 0.02855403535068035, 0.005000390112400055, -0.016688715666532516, -0.023783603683114052, -0.013587991707026958, 0.0002246871736133471, 0.016946114599704742, -0.03140043839812279, 0.020959988236427307, 0.042862873524427414, -0.06558876484632492, 0.0002564387395977974, -0.0033034642692655325, -0.008048138581216335, -0.04643760994076729, -0.04198596253991127, 0.04163177311420441, 0.00046464757178910077, 0.038992539048194885, -0.034624338150024414, -0.013387642800807953, 0.027473965659737587, -0.009246121160686016, -0.005299495533108711, -0.009771671146154404, -0.008530190214514732, -0.01052857656031847, 0.007162031251937151, 0.015684621408581734, 0.026641761884093285, 0.04272187501192093, 0.01795015297830105, -0.005744242109358311, 0.004704317543655634, 0.05401349440217018, -0.10441187024116516, -0.004061822779476643, -0.009385545738041401, 0.01138796005398035, -0.08890259265899658, 0.07097946852445602, -0.04994994401931763, 0.015429552644491196, 0.04314679279923439, -0.02627432905137539, 0.026023928076028824, 0.012690966948866844, 0.025296878069639206, 0.01251641009002924, 0.07013743370771408, 0.014302483759820461, -0.00001874961526482366, 0.030759649351239204, 0.0018293282482773066, 0.02123863995075226, 0.008634621277451515, -0.003803195198997855, 0.027321049943566322, -0.010460159741342068, -0.01588520035147667, -0.04625748470425606, 0.01484838966280222, -0.012052156031131744, 0.0027032126672565937, 0.019686901941895485, -0.01244500745087862, -0.018215497955679893, -0.02220270037651062, 0.010322862304747105, -0.0353064127266407, -0.030148154124617577, 0.01781698316335678, 0.0034304994624108076, -0.04584142193198204, -0.016174044460058212, -0.025982985273003578, -0.05374768748879433, 0.019997766241431236, 0.015652908012270927, -0.010575516149401665, -0.03593137860298157, 0.014091896824538708, 0.0338844396173954, -0.006300890818238258, -0.01417172234505415, -0.025653280317783356, -0.025781337171792984, 0.022425273433327675, -0.03418540209531784, -0.026848018169403076, -0.0005209388327784836, -0.007849976420402527, 0.03859017416834831, -0.05163944140076637, 0.04048819839954376, 0.02960166707634926, -0.05177857354283333, -0.010956315323710442, -0.023747775703668594, -0.04510492458939552, -0.02095603011548519, 0.05191999673843384, -0.0250425785779953, -0.006820092909038067, -0.010854041203856468, -0.0047393380664289, -0.026789354160428047, -0.03394392877817154, 0.041016027331352234, -0.003045648569241166, -0.03369200974702835, -0.012149777263402939, -0.013520507141947746, 0.000158562688739039, 0.01170753501355648, 0.05242374539375305, -0.0008734493749216199, 0.015400465577840805, 0.008701234124600887, -0.017757810652256012, 0.013961002230644226, 0.003740859217941761, 0.0004832630220334977, 0.031044090166687965, 0.01994672790169716, 0.03223751112818718, 0.048444200307130814, 0.015781281515955925, -0.07297229021787643, -0.004028161522001028, -0.05256124958395958, 0.004944264888763428, -0.007415220607072115, -0.0010104164248332381, -0.007133734878152609, -0.0645902007818222, -0.008465517312288284, 0.03443605452775955, -0.018120331689715385, 0.022258363664150238, 0.06332943588495255, -0.009848009794950485, 0.04309737682342529, -0.0017240621382370591, -0.018324727192521095, 0.032539285719394684, -0.012686708010733128, -0.005799308884888887, 0.010553761385381222, 0.06656137853860855, 0.03648041933774948, 0.03892887011170387, 0.0233000498265028, 0.01086081750690937, 0.046925775706768036, -0.0370669886469841, 0.0176435224711895, -0.021667489781975746, -0.013891855254769325, 0.0333542637526989, -0.020449841395020485, -0.0029465854167938232, 0.03589382395148277, 0.0060252780094742775, 0.0430343821644783, -0.07341993600130081, -0.00561693636700511, -0.013483623042702675, -0.012930840253829956, -0.024568574503064156, 0.013304180465638638, -0.0008987549808807671, 0.0342397466301918, 0.04481062293052673, 0.01571052148938179, -0.0038156379014253616, -0.031937096267938614, 0.0005529516492970288, -0.0020992644131183624, 0.00919176172465086, -0.02542033977806568, -0.007785949390381575, -0.004717736970633268, -0.03743549808859825, -0.03172162175178528, -0.014607143588364124, 0.029355237260460854, 0.027845723554491997, -0.003927912097424269, -0.012591100297868252, -0.01995556801557541, 0.00429129134863615, 0.015395775437355042, -0.07477644830942154, -0.0065413182601332664, -0.02804429829120636, 0.007314643822610378, 0.008858125656843185, -0.03394310548901558 ]
<p>Suppose I have $X,Y$, which are independent random variables. </p> <p>Why is it that $E(\frac{X}{Y}) = E(X)E(\frac{1}{Y})$? </p> <p>Also, why is it that $E(X^2Y^2)=E(X^2)E(Y^2)$? How is it that the square of an independent random variable is also independent in relation to $Y$ or $Y^2$? Thanks! </p>
73,611
[ -0.033089060336351395, 0.008853758685290813, 0.016769614070653915, -0.00577166024595499, 0.029007136821746826, 0.021621735766530037, -0.01350319478660822, -0.039148107171058655, 0.015470928512513638, -0.027543164789676666, 0.04810582473874092, 0.04149138927459717, 0.06162051483988762, -0.0012319026282057166, 0.026948869228363037, -0.01221495121717453, -0.024711651727557182, 0.004765823017805815, 0.00042767924605868757, 0.0055751255713403225, -0.020765289664268494, 0.015460783615708351, 0.04734300076961517, -0.009203484281897545, -0.02961035445332527, 0.04056959226727486, 0.023776207119226456, -0.0037270698230713606, 0.05412247031927109, 0.0843864381313324, -0.02694850228726864, -0.0316571444272995, 0.015410667285323143, 0.060764096677303314, -0.0003059521841350943, 0.015416634269058704, -0.012418431229889393, 0.0016475158045068383, 0.013550336472690105, 0.016128886491060257, -0.04816884547472, -0.011291525326669216, -0.003977302461862564, 0.0407576709985733, -0.03466258570551872, 0.013805167749524117, 0.009973856620490551, -0.05567500740289688, 0.02608508989214897, -0.03651541844010353, 0.08328453451395035, -0.038635917007923126, 0.04507368430495262, 0.05679578334093094, 0.01158361416310072, 0.03222313150763512, 0.06316953152418137, 0.028322797268629074, 0.0017988112522289157, -0.04509950056672096, -0.0014024979900568724, -0.014535855501890182, -0.010209850035607815, -0.023728270083665848, -0.01574649289250374, 0.014402813278138638, 0.0021312879398465157, -0.006128963083028793, 0.002571102464571595, -0.008556126616895199, 0.011919553391635418, 0.05405000224709511, 0.037692904472351074, -0.027766741812229156, 0.021132171154022217, -0.022981345653533936, 0.03446371480822563, 0.00023370036797132343, 0.056368015706539154, 0.012457544915378094, 0.01399998553097248, 0.02291419357061386, 0.04134053736925125, 0.00523971114307642, 0.0024544824846088886, 0.009227564558386803, 0.05689746513962746, -0.003139370819553733, 0.04162611439824104, 0.0012726569548249245, 0.003984048962593079, 0.0048403050750494, 0.04412242770195007, -0.02460656687617302, -0.0279525276273489, 0.046070318669080734, -0.02254168502986431, 0.01020857971161604, 0.007756226230412722, -0.006494120694696903, -0.007276835851371288, -0.04759340360760689, 0.02325717732310295, 0.08184517174959183, -0.030570857226848602, -0.017511790618300438, -0.060182876884937286, 0.041711147874593735, -0.01313838455826044, -0.027197465300559998, -0.00917653739452362, 0.026242351159453392, -0.00838591530919075, 0.012973643839359283, 0.02045067772269249, -0.002234620740637183, 0.010305747389793396, -0.0031152525916695595, 0.025432534515857697, 0.0466693677008152, 0.026906438171863556, -0.046829067170619965, 0.012173674069344997, -0.016825323924422264, -0.03971382603049278, 0.023038918152451515, 0.010169288143515587, -0.013317208737134933, -0.03781876713037491, 0.037917692214250565, 0.012773186899721622, -0.00985255278646946, -0.007818314246833324, 0.0400204174220562, 0.029156919568777084, 0.00684864679351449, -0.09358500689268112, -0.06574178487062454, 0.04542359337210655, -0.016424985602498055, 0.006838934496045113, -0.060091204941272736, 0.03348683938384056, 0.0354057215154171, 0.06276318430900574, -0.028043843805789948, 0.01721050590276718, 0.015523294918239117, -0.0016156511846929789, -0.003209911985322833, -0.019027842208743095, -0.03543161228299141, -0.0006694167968817055, -0.03231895714998245, 0.04671112820506096, -0.06009366363286972, 0.03309096023440361, 0.02335483580827713, -0.034575238823890686, -0.03883776441216469, 0.041819170117378235, -0.0011170284124091268, -0.024243708699941635, 0.010995034128427505, 0.027062872424721718, -0.031250689178705215, 0.10029416531324387, 0.01834721863269806, 0.051890283823013306, 0.04815411940217018, -0.005292186047881842, 0.02947431430220604, 0.013024423271417618, 0.05861138552427292, 0.024996981024742126, -0.008569176308810711, -0.06230618804693222, -0.024037431925535202, 0.014011122286319733, 0.031572479754686356, -0.06870023906230927, -0.012796317227184772, -0.030337901785969734, 0.001288801897317171, 0.003119504312053323, 0.03857581689953804, 0.02066754549741745, -0.018315685912966728, -0.008956502191722393, -0.02664591558277607, -0.03136149048805237, -0.06871270388364792, 0.0032403375953435898, 0.005915332119911909, -0.02041594125330448, 0.0008806843543425202, 0.03141673654317856, 0.016162650659680367, -0.030277641490101814, 0.006392274517565966, -0.011688267812132835, 0.031059090048074722, 0.04489584639668465, -0.03973398730158806, 0.046043217182159424, 0.05883196368813515, 0.05065621808171272, 0.025445472449064255, 0.02734251134097576, -0.02265658602118492, -0.01291265245527029, 0.007824912667274475, -0.019777318462729454, -0.004262689035385847, -0.037996161729097366, -0.01965111866593361, 0.002294020028784871, 0.0051388246938586235, -0.02399231679737568, 0.029850637540221214, -0.03165473788976669, 0.0329529345035553, 0.015354898758232594, 0.012833156622946262, -0.007462071720510721, 0.03750341385602951, 0.03473804518580437, 0.03548141196370125, -0.02370314672589302, -0.027123872190713882, -0.04633960872888565, 0.01270142663270235, 0.0104709193110466, 0.038414813578128815, -0.04587582126259804, 0.005580401048064232, 0.05024395510554314, 0.042773231863975525, -0.021398494020104408, 0.023823609575629234, -0.004199794493615627, -0.02175612561404705, -0.012955456972122192, 0.01736801490187645, 0.044326841831207275, 0.014714173041284084, -0.009102795273065567, 0.009465374983847141, 0.020569046959280968, 0.002366706496104598, -0.016656875610351562, 0.03351465240120888, -0.03174370899796486, 0.016301605850458145, 0.03107401728630066, -0.021943021565675735, 0.019908808171749115, -0.02334357611835003, -0.026444051414728165, -0.0014583173906430602, 0.011592614464461803, -0.036940231919288635, -0.025982432067394257, -0.013907862827181816, 0.018658066168427467, 0.004507974721491337, -0.05230673775076866, 0.008459221571683884, 0.031503815203905106, 0.013893739320337772, 0.03344978019595146, 0.011049337685108185, -0.0694400742650032, -0.022273890674114227, -0.00824845489114523, 0.00595290819182992, -0.0012762192636728287, 0.02471339702606201, -0.02424883469939232, -0.013507003895938396, 0.0030325220432132483, -0.03973044827580452, 0.005497640930116177, -0.03643375262618065, -0.04636022448539734, 0.03444458171725273, -0.04993988946080208, 0.01681024581193924, 0.026736672967672348, -0.0025301389396190643, -0.004021457862108946, 0.021541282534599304, 0.023658612743020058, -0.04631558805704117, -0.006900649983435869, -0.046256572008132935, 0.038721684366464615, -0.03560997173190117, -0.00660928338766098, 0.03666073828935623, -0.027513429522514343, -0.04101252555847168, 0.02284182235598564, -0.06874951720237732, -0.013677427545189857, -0.03912152349948883, -0.011837851256132126, 0.03318563848733902, -0.01047808863222599, -0.0026147400494664907, 0.02272813394665718, -0.027110129594802856, -0.014197819866240025, -0.051873646676540375, -0.06687238067388535, -0.001604702090844512, 0.0016698086401447654, 0.05016746371984482, -0.007157906424254179, -0.034532226622104645, 0.05080138146877289, 0.03507425636053085, -0.03280097618699074, -0.014114625751972198, -0.008522962220013142, -0.0005298629985190928, -0.04628070443868637, 0.04523741826415062, 0.012232950888574123, -0.04028091952204704, 0.02710164152085781, 0.020267881453037262, 0.028739916160702705, 0.019186237826943398, -0.01848607137799263, 0.0023640282452106476, -0.008794189430773258, 0.02607361227273941, -0.01331435889005661, 0.04425732046365738, 0.023355962708592415, -0.04143562540411949, 0.008802713826298714, 0.04153008386492729, 0.04770746827125549, 0.022036276757717133, -0.0038635563105344772, 0.05301907658576965, -0.024850789457559586, 0.022444874048233032, -0.05847322568297386, 0.047784365713596344, 0.03478250280022621, -0.023371312767267227, 0.019852256402373314, -0.04907715320587158, 0.03473449870944023, -0.021803759038448334, 0.022747766226530075, 0.045640479773283005, 0.024264035746455193, -0.04069288447499275, -0.02059020660817623, -0.048308972269296646, -0.019148726016283035, 0.037698715925216675, -0.012093455530703068, 0.0034296305384486914, 0.029671957716345787, 0.03351810202002525, -0.017961565405130386, -0.026698574423789978, -0.040712542831897736, 0.00043437661952339113, -0.06421574205160141, 0.009774611331522465, -0.0007066125399433076, 0.021763339638710022, 0.014405116438865662, 0.09439578652381897, -0.014301330782473087, -0.001631257706321776, 0.027750682085752487, -0.010300426743924618, -0.05217352136969566, 0.009266030043363571, -0.05086728185415268, -0.031470559537410736, -0.04065985232591629, -0.013375597074627876, 0.033894818276166916, -0.03813425078988075, -0.03564142808318138, -0.017159268260002136, -0.02767854370176792, -0.025391343981027603, 0.004446659702807665, -0.03532920405268669, -0.05457164719700813, -0.008409361355006695, 0.04118860885500908, -0.019151048734784126, -0.03202540799975395, 0.03685837239027023, 0.0420609749853611, -0.026441438123583794, -0.004224011208862066, -0.007516339886933565, -0.027929777279496193, 0.024941623210906982, 0.0137184988707304, 0.005184106063097715, 0.02245483547449112, -0.009886646643280983, 0.017755024135112762, -0.002413487993180752, 0.05028366670012474, 0.023785296827554703, -0.04553975909948349, -0.02555062249302864, -0.05057656019926071, -0.023975346237421036, -0.035915669053792953, 0.018571002408862114, -0.014828775078058243, -0.004592651501297951, 0.028743470087647438, 0.020919181406497955, -0.01402799878269434, 0.021451661363244057, 0.04505905881524086, 0.0009693614556454122, -0.017429474741220474, -0.009835426695644855, -0.026296094059944153, -0.025922421365976334, -0.01052078977227211, -0.030714374035596848, 0.007290784269571304, -0.026350999251008034, -0.007007145788520575, 0.04479909688234329, -0.003875643713399768, 0.011617053300142288, -0.035662464797496796, 0.0035079983063042164, 0.035745467990636826, -0.006930275354534388, -0.06048164889216423, -0.007809056434780359, 0.012906672433018684, -0.004334458615630865, 0.008368880487978458, -0.013024665415287018, -0.02410096302628517, 0.013974436558783054, 0.03576141968369484, 0.04759121313691139, -0.04118725284934044, 0.008797230198979378, -0.021605443209409714, -0.017454974353313446, 0.027858911082148552, -0.02137748897075653, 0.009261305443942547, -0.02377278544008732, -0.026881836354732513, 0.008039317093789577, -0.020302098244428635, -0.041715722531080246, -0.0009241375373676419, 0.009195828810334206, 0.05416042357683182, -0.01765422895550728, -0.00915592536330223, -0.08431019634008408, -0.004991337191313505, 0.044981520622968674, 0.07490701973438263, -0.024126118049025536, 0.01996994949877262, -0.024783527478575706, 0.051479268819093704, 0.013610893860459328, -0.06788244098424911, 0.03730210289359093, 0.007396072614938021, -0.008102902211248875, 0.016784803941845894, -0.02837265469133854, -0.08692478388547897, 0.0076917982660233974, -0.0017107937019318342, -0.023193765431642532, 0.047161638736724854, -0.011953686363995075, 0.035698503255844116, 0.06340949237346649, 0.02700178325176239, 0.05236346274614334, 0.03614070266485214, -0.04975506290793419, -0.03047809936106205, -0.03410948067903519, 0.03936581313610077, -0.04310457035899162, -0.03139280900359154, -0.04139711707830429, -0.013947339728474617, -0.029646819457411766, 0.005911952815949917, -0.024225948378443718, 0.03851984813809395, -0.04002099484205246, -0.033299610018730164, -0.011237828992307186, 0.049400828778743744, 0.044244084507226944, 0.008347333408892155, -0.035203754901885986, 0.017530789598822594, -0.009718355722725391, -0.030036790296435356, 0.00905026588588953, 0.041846130043268204, -0.007516736164689064, -0.007249105721712112, 0.0006832753424532712, 0.03142627328634262, -0.049379851669073105, -0.03616448491811752, 0.01627730391919613, -0.032410476356744766, 0.006001356523483992, -0.01192568987607956, 0.009987309575080872, 0.010218358598649502, -0.030295275151729584, -0.023084057494997978, 0.014105146750807762, 0.0022058228496462107, 0.026844386011362076, -0.048901867121458054, 0.030590785667300224, -0.009292746894061565, -0.013992455787956715, -0.07323360443115234, -0.04636930674314499, -0.00014460372040048242, -0.005342567805200815, -0.00814860500395298, -0.024341749027371407, 0.03663848340511322, -0.0091227563098073, -0.026315005496144295, -0.019129140302538872, 0.04821820184588432, -0.011809525080025196, -0.02417391538619995, 0.010327835567295551, 0.001928155543282628, 0.0551581047475338, -0.013332460075616837, 0.00213353568688035, 0.028714077547192574, -0.030941229313611984, -0.00811787974089384, 0.007064902223646641, 0.049480732530355453, -0.027842704206705093, -0.004702943842858076, -0.005594414658844471, -0.041971251368522644, 0.021571170538663864, -0.01670386828482151, -0.03392951563000679, 0.04212575778365135, 0.03699842467904091, -0.022132160142064095, -0.01888284645974636, 0.012917459942400455, 0.020927423611283302, 0.03338773921132088, 0.011615140363574028, -0.018025599420070648, -0.03905278071761131, -0.04014960303902626, 0.01736537553369999, -0.021229540929198265, 0.025548305362462997, -0.01117298100143671, 0.08792365342378616, -0.02476315200328827, 0.007829595357179642, -0.014063023962080479, -0.004762136377394199, 0.01597030647099018, -0.002535382052883506, -0.022204739972949028, -0.013920403085649014, 0.005377694498747587, -0.037838198244571686, -0.0037709821481257677, -0.03707169368863106, -0.004486890975385904, 0.08045734465122223, -0.026838431134819984, 0.06407226622104645, 0.047374140471220016, 0.009677562862634659, 0.026023827493190765, -0.03979772329330444, -0.030467957258224487, -0.0432276651263237, 0.003387280972674489, 0.02896822802722454, -0.00698294909670949, 0.004620448220521212, 0.05884565785527229, 0.033493466675281525, 0.0038379370234906673, 0.014819396659731865, 0.023975513875484467, 0.010538659058511257, 0.029311930760741234, -0.020657112821936607, -0.023311354219913483, 0.027254408225417137, -0.03664298355579376, -0.0033103637397289276, -0.025855937972664833, -0.019913753494620323, 0.08072677999734879, 0.03540662303566933, -0.025319328531622887, -0.04849310219287872, 0.006661958992481232, -0.03165807947516441, 0.00956594105809927, 0.01831749640405178, 0.01582321897149086, 0.017439626157283783, 0.0009930237429216504, -0.019320856779813766, -0.00064970797393471, 0.010355331934988499, -0.036065153777599335, -0.10488881915807724, -0.020234640687704086, -0.02089160494506359, -0.04579353705048561, 0.005287120118737221, -0.00022831691603641957, -0.03702603280544281, -0.020144157111644745, -0.03400097414851189, 0.017308928072452545, -0.014391642063856125, 0.02376345358788967, -0.03436613455414772, 0.056040164083242416, 0.024220939725637436, 0.04353799670934677, -0.011475924402475357, 0.010471532121300697, 0.077263243496418, 0.043400026857852936, 0.009478216990828514, -0.06334534287452698, 0.027161795645952225, -0.02512447163462639, 0.006497884634882212, -0.02646665647625923, 0.009149586781859398, -0.000020819003111682832, 0.03877701982855797, 0.060113150626420975, 0.04975272715091705, 0.026873977854847908, -0.024907294660806656, 0.03628479689359665, -0.019652893766760826, -0.05076850578188896, -0.025329457595944405, 0.057310838252305984, -0.01990377902984619, 0.03587821125984192, -0.03110308013856411, -0.0004774761328008026, -0.04561767727136612, -0.013520403765141964, -0.0323454886674881, -0.038403596729040146, 0.01384065393358469, 0.014030439779162407, -0.03163846954703331, 0.0015925985062494874, 0.05911266431212425, -0.013096547685563564, -0.02226882241666317, 0.03593813255429268, 0.02966521680355072, -0.03155769780278206, -0.009323067963123322, 0.022260326892137527, -0.006798635236918926, -0.0011779031483456492, 0.03017716109752655, -0.005191178061068058, -0.04047617316246033, -0.030507037416100502, -0.011277749203145504, 0.051411740481853485, -0.0225369855761528, 0.012475724332034588, -0.058048222213983536, -0.024869993329048157, -0.005671788472682238, -0.05122807249426842, 0.015424576587975025, 0.023510076105594635, 0.026989145204424858, -0.040402043610811234, 0.006806954741477966, -0.0315423309803009, 0.016454733908176422, -0.017727676779031754, 0.023643409833312035, 0.030318330973386765, -0.04276766628026962, -0.019743848592042923, -0.004780216608196497, 0.016527416184544563, -0.02355702593922615, -0.012519901618361473, -0.001568366540595889, -0.008996940217912197, -0.01892637275159359, -0.024263201281428337, 0.015469453297555447, 0.02576419524848461, 0.03836093097925186, -0.0056230188347399235, 0.009427331387996674, -0.0028763602022081614, -0.031163983047008514, 0.016302000731229782, -0.025848234072327614, 0.03089170902967453, -0.05038971081376076, 0.0063098277896642685, 0.04250390827655792, 0.01847095601260662, 0.029889965429902077, 0.00832910742610693, -0.02754727378487587, -0.0010146464919671416, 0.003944524563848972, -0.01190495677292347, -0.006906990893185139, 0.02036651410162449, -0.011421548202633858, -0.024264121428132057, -0.03275267034769058, 0.03881692886352539, 0.04693647474050522, 0.06049463525414467, -0.017538707703351974, 0.022205457091331482, -0.02026381343603134, 0.02269318327307701, 0.017862260341644287, -0.050335414707660675, 0.015853939577937126, 0.032932136207818985, 0.044849421828985214, -0.012756569311022758, -0.016535675153136253, 0.0163728017359972, 0.011350270360708237, -0.01612287014722824, 0.012584335170686245, -0.0352138951420784, -0.014961225911974907, -0.026143426075577736, 0.0724913477897644, -0.012149115093052387, -0.018710052594542503, -0.033007681369781494, 0.001389803714118898, 0.03283616155385971, -0.023967841640114784, -0.020916279405355453, 0.011646805331110954, 0.017740920186042786, -0.008714384399354458, 0.03309331461787224, 0.01656600460410118, 0.02060452476143837, -0.018988845869898796, 0.04680104926228523, -0.038453876972198486, 0.041889168322086334, -0.03503486514091492, -0.0033779037185013294, 0.02661188505589962, -0.02891453355550766, -0.004189603962004185, -0.0034972478169947863, 0.010918336920440197, 0.055016014724969864, 0.03794686496257782, -0.023877479135990143, -0.04089071974158287, 0.040514230728149414, -0.03252965211868286, 0.020127395167946815, -0.014324202202260494, -0.0260308850556612, 0.020631641149520874, -0.00628465274348855, 0.01232094131410122, -0.004796655382961035, -0.002081079874187708, 0.039863500744104385, 0.01977388560771942, -0.0038637297693639994, -0.00957492832094431, 0.02460123784840107, 0.04055041819810867, 0.006140679121017456, 0.018540820106863976, 0.010745348408818245, 0.05138764530420303, 0.04111344367265701, -0.00616057775914669, 0.08412231504917145, -0.01893194578588009, 0.0018551426474004984, -0.08075172454118729, -0.013032658956944942, 0.04054570570588112, 0.029716944321990013, 0.05009983107447624, -0.030817022547125816, -0.024466020986437798, 0.02355259843170643, -0.07307466864585876, 0.0036549160722643137, 0.014745110645890236, -0.0014375342288985848, -0.004401190672069788, 0.031163720414042473, -0.005078659858554602, 0.05222730338573456, 0.023196693509817123, 0.028634581714868546, 0.032891590148210526, 0.040886592119932175, -0.009642085991799831, -0.014940572902560234, -0.03520406782627106, 0.014975829049944878, -0.019795112311840057, -0.029763830825686455, 0.04113459587097168, -0.030572757124900818, 0.018845807760953903, 0.0327904187142849, 0.011050787754356861, 0.027706831693649292, 0.004660534672439098, -0.012719484977424145, 0.00916996132582426, 0.014623910188674927, -0.006505253259092569, 0.010044988244771957, -0.028733570128679276, 0.025872254744172096, 0.02012401819229126, 0.03388088196516037, -0.006939159706234932, -0.050737135112285614, 0.01727607101202011, -0.03639012575149536, -0.015794936567544937, 0.02385210245847702, -0.0001942916278494522, -0.020107384771108627, 0.02357655204832554, 0.013087781146168709, -0.01085392665117979, -0.025342755019664764, 0.05331818759441376, -0.01594589091837406, -0.03842657431960106, 0.03323030844330788, -0.0021459385752677917, 0.011580826714634895, -0.0051748850382864475, 0.007745947223156691, -0.035029251128435135, 0.02052801288664341, 0.01898781955242157, -0.007146472577005625, -0.06171315163373947, -0.005025571212172508, 0.016797464340925217, -0.01775648258626461, 0.042219847440719604, -0.03260102495551109, -0.05790207162499428, -0.0006043894100002944, 0.00889598298817873, -0.003549377666786313, -0.02945639379322529, -0.007227899972349405, -0.04738997295498848, -0.061502646654844284, 0.05765515938401222, 0.015134642831981182, -0.03658095747232437, -0.06666671484708786, -0.001833716407418251, -0.030715199187397957, -0.01431596651673317, 0.05264543741941452, 0.04628002271056175, 0.009946084581315517, 0.020262237638235092, 0.029757827520370483, 0.04588322713971138, -0.06112395226955414, 0.022052723914384842, -0.0165232066065073, 0.0011149836936965585, -0.026071395725011826, -0.0033647804521024227, 0.013496381230652332, 0.007014595437794924, 0.022985469549894333, -0.03550884127616882, 0.02530214563012123, 0.004665910732001066, 0.00037843547761440277, 0.03266851231455803, 0.008472730405628681, -0.020324425771832466, 0.061850666999816895, -0.01461730431765318, 0.013920389115810394, 0.0046830931678414345, -0.03454205393791199, -0.022475356236100197, 0.021035918965935707, -0.0621194988489151, -0.03050239197909832, -0.05177846550941467, 0.03535520285367966, 0.033883024007081985, -0.06126828491687775, -0.014457212761044502, 0.03151674196124077, -0.05887340381741524, -0.009620117023587227, 0.04103245958685875, 0.030273299664258957, 0.02410857565701008, 0.0006206721300259233, -0.0006973508279770613, -0.01227738056331873, -0.01474459283053875, 0.02809329144656658, -0.0011477208463475108, 0.041539743542671204, -0.00001801571124815382, 0.0024853248614817858, 0.0573066845536232, 0.003496654098853469, 0.04261302575469017, -0.0012934517581015825, 0.0305593553930521, -0.042203228920698166, -0.03167809918522835, 0.0025240012910217047, -0.013823946006596088, 0.024165773764252663, -0.003547009779140353, -0.040606748312711716, 0.07151918113231659, -0.03076617605984211, 0.02710467390716076, -0.03010353446006775, 0.01637432724237442, -0.018957318738102913, -0.03887520730495453, 0.027981599792838097, 0.012898561544716358, 0.012730821967124939, 0.004444684833288193, -0.02189100719988346, -0.006941019557416439, 0.04041555896401405, -0.0338829830288887, 0.040935009717941284, 0.0005809523863717914, -0.01958654075860977, -0.025608791038393974, -0.019027944654226303, -0.020858153700828552, -0.0179952010512352, 0.05181751027703285, 0.0543985515832901, 0.03617619350552559, 0.007314299698919058, -0.04365551099181175, 0.010439727455377579, 0.07788550108671188, -0.07502701133489609, 0.003849552245810628, -0.04060526564717293, 0.03664739429950714, 0.004553037229925394, -0.006084941327571869 ]
<p>I have two sets of a longitudinal data that I hypothesize to measure same latent construct.I am trying to test this hypothesis using Structural equation modelling technique. Basically, I am trying to use confirmatory factor analysis in longitudinal data using SEM. My models are relatively simple CFA models.</p> <p>The problem is that my sample size is small in term of SEM standards. We collected data only from 20 individuals for nearly two years (number of time points nearly equals 18) because the data collection is very expensive.</p> <p>I am new to SEM and I was not able to decide if SEM is right choice for me. My question is given such a small sample size, is it a good idea to use SEM based techniques to model the data and test my hypothesis? Based on my researches, I concluded that I should not fit SEM using least squares, weighted least squares or Maximum likelihood since they require large samples which I do not have. It seems that they recommend fitting SEM using Partial least squares or Baysian approaches for small sample size but the problem is my sample size is very small. Are there any articles that discuss fitting SEM using very small sample size? </p> <p>I am looking for suggestions, literatures or recomendations to fit such data with small sample size.</p>
73,612
[ -0.032953858375549316, -0.023233523592352867, -0.003389504738152027, 0.009272701106965542, 0.05424714833498001, 0.004122727084904909, -0.010572623461484909, -0.053119875490665436, 0.044602181762456894, -0.06051205098628998, 0.016465742141008377, 0.016561783850193024, 0.04729584977030754, 0.0015348547603935003, 0.01503188069909811, 0.001770245609804988, 0.018418265506625175, 0.0020701889880001545, -0.023463265970349312, 0.013023508712649345, -0.018130024895071983, -0.001992832636460662, 0.032066818326711655, -0.014204644598066807, -0.029193006455898285, 0.0361815020442009, 0.03106490708887577, -0.020687269046902657, 0.014246064238250256, 0.04655521735548973, -0.009994431398808956, -0.015825996175408363, -0.01044677384197712, 0.04204209893941879, -0.01012380700558424, -0.029182903468608856, -0.010926073417067528, -0.04447415471076965, 0.02110786736011505, 0.03182944282889366, -0.02072521299123764, -0.008895305916666985, -0.004198268987238407, 0.04026804491877556, -0.010225926525890827, 0.022175176069140434, 0.005223468411713839, -0.047490060329437256, 0.04339159280061722, -0.03260393440723419, 0.06835012137889862, 0.040207430720329285, 0.025759616866707802, 0.017783798277378082, -0.00029235653346404433, -0.020225554704666138, 0.031106844544410706, 0.05950270965695381, -0.005735635757446289, -0.0043989368714392185, -0.048008233308792114, -0.043119173496961594, 0.009212090633809566, -0.050885219126939774, -0.020304307341575623, 0.04732562229037285, -0.009172744117677212, -0.009187718853354454, 0.048020049929618835, -0.025204742327332497, 0.010814309120178223, -0.0178289245814085, 0.06275834143161774, -0.0035672388039529324, 0.020176611840724945, -0.03640124201774597, 0.01704133301973343, 0.03447990119457245, 0.04586807265877724, 0.07223426550626755, 0.010516666807234287, 0.012353735975921154, 0.008739005774259567, 0.013718336820602417, 0.011935708113014698, -0.012800863943994045, 0.06407302618026733, -0.016127727925777435, -0.022147372364997864, -0.011456314474344254, -0.0581832230091095, 0.033291295170784, 0.043321579694747925, 0.019282279536128044, -0.018568146973848343, 0.0380852185189724, -0.03420507162809372, 0.030405869707465172, 0.028494559228420258, 0.0005731656565330923, -0.026865238323807716, -0.045626405626535416, 0.009782974608242512, 0.04750092700123787, -0.01264516357332468, 0.018556050956249237, 0.012651792727410793, 0.015050122514367104, -0.04041939228773117, -0.031315069645643234, -0.02192915603518486, -0.0163187924772501, 0.022727888077497482, 0.027000514790415764, 0.009342619217932224, 0.015660909935832024, -0.03186162933707237, -0.052904583513736725, 0.07431555539369583, 0.10066872835159302, 0.02448127791285515, -0.05301012098789215, 0.007735482882708311, -0.02269820310175419, -0.04023529216647148, 0.04050041735172272, -0.019296828657388687, -0.026596875861287117, -0.024348802864551544, 0.06375958025455475, 0.012746520340442657, -0.018276754766702652, 0.0321100689470768, 0.015049904584884644, 0.04200064763426781, 0.026248332113027573, -0.07227320969104767, -0.0312642827630043, 0.0552942156791687, -0.014938545413315296, 0.01439354382455349, -0.06252343952655792, -0.009560398757457733, 0.00078999949619174, 0.05452266335487366, 0.016725368797779083, 0.03395594283938408, -0.004184151999652386, 0.040341321378946304, 0.018735051155090332, -0.04616265743970871, 0.00764866266399622, -0.03590274974703789, 0.01519107911735773, 0.005118546076118946, -0.0797029659152031, 0.0005756309838034213, 0.043041955679655075, -0.014865553006529808, 0.004206731915473938, 0.02165507711470127, 0.010882602073252201, -0.028690777719020844, -0.02658429928123951, 0.0194616187363863, -0.027406742796301842, 0.03927253186702728, -0.02543535828590393, 0.0002228505036327988, 0.01599651202559471, -0.012808210216462612, -0.023580914363265038, 0.03685694932937622, 0.01336007658392191, 0.0049104103818535805, -0.010271408595144749, 0.01180669479072094, 0.02433539181947708, 0.01628263108432293, 0.015120839700102806, -0.0598113052546978, -0.017754049971699715, -0.014919276349246502, 0.002020268701016903, 0.014561239629983902, 0.05960879102349281, 0.00009081739699468017, -0.030790580436587334, 0.00508804339915514, -0.060079384595155716, -0.07196108251810074, -0.04578633978962898, 0.043687619268894196, -0.01753738708794117, -0.03877803683280945, 0.049984872341156006, -0.0061979740858078, 0.03437648341059685, -0.014598425477743149, -0.03382253274321556, -0.026505691930651665, -0.005700741894543171, -0.004789425525814295, -0.02854614518582821, 0.02761940471827984, 0.0307600274682045, 0.04687530919909477, -0.029660526663064957, 0.017444835975766182, -0.03172798827290535, -0.06467606872320175, 0.009225739166140556, -0.031162595376372337, 0.03276780620217323, -0.027015484869480133, -0.013601444661617279, -0.029111167415976524, -0.0038110099267214537, -0.0059290193021297455, 0.06650112569332123, -0.0337987057864666, 0.07778527587652206, 0.04354964941740036, -0.019288545474410057, -0.013463014736771584, -0.0018106886418536305, 0.06305644661188126, 0.028844285756349564, -0.041445471346378326, 0.005777120124548674, -0.03854722902178764, -0.023624178022146225, 0.06944978982210159, 0.01045361440628767, -0.009064179845154285, 0.000236688822042197, 0.040329914540052414, 0.0028319736011326313, -0.00008570911450078711, -0.010382289066910744, 0.004010215867310762, -0.04952862113714218, -0.019024210050702095, 0.03626790642738342, 0.003493091557174921, 0.03330431133508682, -0.021425245329737663, 0.0024596871808171272, 0.04520484060049057, -0.001959792571142316, 0.025924528017640114, 0.06931117177009583, 0.01738697662949562, -0.0038243152666836977, -0.008126266300678253, -0.016671203076839447, 0.04613342508673668, -0.01865658536553383, 0.003318540984764695, 0.03489440307021141, 0.001198750571347773, -0.011738520115613937, 0.0012833158252760768, -0.009030379354953766, 0.0049459184519946575, 0.044010311365127563, 0.02624806948006153, 0.008672465570271015, -0.0005788048729300499, -0.018466996029019356, 0.024865344166755676, -0.027661144733428955, -0.051322855055332184, -0.048043183982372284, -0.013641327619552612, 0.033813878893852234, -0.0015858052065595984, 0.015234997496008873, -0.03862371668219566, -0.027521856129169464, 0.01245003193616867, 0.02361108548939228, -0.0010769773507490754, -0.013890253379940987, -0.062125064432621, -0.000051134345994796604, -0.00507565401494503, 0.002594748744741082, 0.03136922046542168, -0.03039317950606346, 0.022127067670226097, 0.037892866879701614, -0.012131636962294579, -0.03570757061243057, -0.03610002249479294, -0.006808585952967405, -0.014370421878993511, -0.003153442172333598, -0.03071797825396061, 0.05593542382121086, 0.02098478563129902, -0.050346992909908295, 0.004167941864579916, -0.003226247848942876, -0.0036547549534589052, -0.01955309882760048, -0.019515706226229668, -0.004277403466403484, 0.005417665932327509, -0.007087854668498039, 0.00537226302549243, -0.026537563651800156, -0.01043994165956974, -0.07060728967189789, -0.051616061478853226, 0.03912986069917679, 0.0009933218825608492, 0.04471571743488312, 0.002911950461566448, -0.0146253677085042, 0.06389244645833969, 0.03340592235326767, -0.002332663396373391, -0.05488443374633789, 0.009548700414597988, -0.01514715887606144, -0.040123894810676575, 0.024362929165363312, 0.038667358458042145, 0.01604517176747322, -0.010999875143170357, -0.0357106477022171, -0.0028714395593851805, 0.01598653569817543, 0.01385259348899126, 0.022224875167012215, 0.011818843893706799, -0.0016326215118169785, -0.033246707171201706, 0.004876240156590939, 0.03132139518857002, -0.049283143132925034, -0.012190520763397217, -0.004084612708538771, 0.02592826634645462, 0.008122874423861504, -0.042279280722141266, 0.002116360003128648, -0.033595070242881775, -0.0159577876329422, -0.035975489765405655, -0.01628006249666214, 0.019881725311279297, -0.05244043469429016, -0.003851992776617408, 0.026438850909471512, 0.0023730637039989233, 0.00983104296028614, 0.01440508384257555, 0.03694840520620346, 0.037679772824048996, -0.006086557637900114, -0.002880756976082921, -0.041308436542749405, 0.0038824337534606457, 0.017352791503071785, -0.0163875799626112, -0.032822709530591965, 0.062060169875621796, 0.07028093189001083, 0.050986193120479584, -0.017472103238105774, -0.02195144072175026, 0.0005223087500780821, -0.06106944754719734, 0.016275916248559952, -0.01261624414473772, 0.06932397931814194, 0.0011776142055168748, 0.01766236498951912, 0.024881988763809204, -0.028396761044859886, 0.006754258647561073, 0.00736486678943038, -0.07036227732896805, 0.010638907551765442, -0.0484219528734684, -0.003312973305583, 0.028362952172756195, 0.009515497833490372, 0.022662358358502388, -0.013033948838710785, 0.013770571909844875, -0.006713786628097296, 0.07569751143455505, 0.01486996840685606, 0.0012887101620435715, -0.03218634054064751, 0.013478204607963562, 0.01637667417526245, 0.025414612144231796, 0.031066790223121643, -0.02167699672281742, -0.018969716504216194, 0.04071725904941559, -0.035609886050224304, -0.02587588131427765, -0.012817785143852234, 0.009085297584533691, 0.009127959609031677, 0.010903565213084221, 0.008484851568937302, 0.03297940641641617, -0.046247296035289764, 0.03689470514655113, 0.022197701036930084, 0.010483046062290668, 0.02203020639717579, 0.0013795847771689296, -0.009866871871054173, -0.01218626368790865, -0.026912594214081764, 0.007751191966235638, 0.05147986859083176, 0.031346943229436874, 0.0019811084493994713, 0.03752078115940094, 0.023700755089521408, -0.06138530373573303, 0.006693923845887184, 0.04900044575333595, 0.04164533317089081, 0.004382134880870581, -0.05338994413614273, -0.005407501943409443, -0.0033889375627040863, -0.00992237962782383, 0.01356274913996458, -0.009709165431559086, -0.01612914353609085, -0.028836676850914955, 0.012622359208762646, -0.02666015923023224, -0.03203684464097023, -0.012926074676215649, -0.004452778957784176, 0.04102742671966553, 0.011599230580031872, -0.048709459602832794, 0.030663585290312767, 0.03697275370359421, 0.05319337919354439, 0.010468262247741222, 0.027100730687379837, -0.08324289321899414, 0.04048944264650345, 0.03155951946973801, 0.014745726250112057, -0.03669286146759987, 0.012385864742100239, -0.002245089504867792, -0.043823063373565674, 0.019737794995307922, -0.026608387008309364, 0.025531049817800522, 0.02433321624994278, 0.041398610919713974, -0.07286713272333145, -0.03173867613077164, -0.046729233115911484, 0.03301212564110756, -0.03386441990733147, 0.01613287813961506, -0.024538177996873856, -0.026435639709234238, -0.029131243005394936, -0.00019856604922097176, 0.018030373379588127, 0.0759056881070137, -0.014286522753536701, -0.015681348741054535, 0.039132554084062576, 0.01888267882168293, -0.018943240866065025, -0.07954345643520355, 0.013422133401036263, 0.011130385100841522, -0.01878459006547928, -0.005868698935955763, -0.018417460843920708, -0.06341876089572906, 0.004459432326257229, -0.008210437372326851, -0.014720157720148563, -0.011161898262798786, -0.05540497601032257, 0.045696478337049484, 0.013295301236212254, 0.008574343286454678, 0.050500743091106415, -0.0032884625252336264, -0.022833270952105522, 0.0063256933353841305, -0.03823341429233551, -0.012387693859636784, -0.05217878147959709, -0.024662984535098076, -0.031567320227622986, 0.01506582647562027, -0.022816570475697517, 0.05749855190515518, -0.016085267066955566, 0.05758776515722275, -0.019545726478099823, -0.0021370730828493834, 0.02235366404056549, 0.04449238255620003, 0.007066367659717798, -0.01113928109407425, 0.021364837884902954, 0.027653556317090988, 0.015533815138041973, -0.026249000802636147, 0.030893908813595772, -0.013962749391794205, 0.01376776210963726, 0.0052394443191587925, -0.027312476187944412, -0.02849421836435795, -0.012007270939648151, -0.057888273149728775, 0.03086024522781372, -0.03611025586724281, 0.033434223383665085, -0.04221317544579506, 0.011374901980161667, -0.008130969479680061, -0.06235651671886444, 0.01730922982096672, 0.039498407393693924, 0.00838521495461464, 0.028091654181480408, -0.029985930770635605, 0.030827293172478676, -0.011772315949201584, -0.05017925053834915, -0.06665852665901184, -0.06734175980091095, 0.012043996714055538, -0.033966243267059326, 0.01438808161765337, -0.03590131551027298, -0.004343988839536905, -0.03653867915272713, -0.04173559322953224, -0.008822941221296787, 0.039377372711896896, -0.018267745152115822, 0.00766502832993865, -0.0019973015878349543, 0.008614916354417801, 0.06484056264162064, 0.009494180791079998, -0.012854971922934055, 0.0036733648739755154, -0.03008320927619934, -0.026083283126354218, -0.016071757301688194, -0.006214700639247894, -0.027067912742495537, -0.014138290658593178, -0.043897371739149094, 0.003889618441462517, 0.04959437996149063, -0.04486582428216934, -0.023718440905213356, 0.005277971737086773, -0.028506405651569366, 0.027077242732048035, -0.03836273401975632, 0.016254961490631104, 0.03052474930882454, -0.006160135380923748, -0.008520268835127354, 0.022623900324106216, -0.04029154032468796, -0.004400722216814756, 0.03855995088815689, 0.008410953916609287, -0.007205889094620943, 0.018990540876984596, 0.019337298348546028, -0.012494411319494247, 0.026393800973892212, -0.010242735967040062, -0.009928843006491661, 0.020502567291259766, 0.01908639632165432, -0.0038145396392792463, 0.01861059106886387, 0.060528676956892014, -0.020600002259016037, -0.044585537165403366, -0.016896400600671768, -0.0021160594187676907, 0.05432882159948349, 0.020831812173128128, 0.0054112644866108894, 0.08165185898542404, -0.040637169033288956, -0.005459199659526348, -0.023269321769475937, -0.002680502599105239, -0.011479091830551624, 0.006358764600008726, 0.0567089319229126, -0.058854684233665466, -0.017193378880620003, 0.026817690581083298, 0.026646172627806664, 0.006108590867370367, 0.028872232884168625, 0.026154428720474243, 0.044463057070970535, 0.03678203001618385, -0.03274393081665039, -0.025982549414038658, 0.03281336650252342, -0.02559848316013813, 0.03421388939023018, -0.029295193031430244, 0.0026367036625742912, 0.026148807257413864, 0.06302303075790405, 0.0293109230697155, -0.050284020602703094, -0.020069098100066185, -0.02539466693997383, 0.006462736055254936, 0.04600510746240616, -0.023518124595284462, 0.0045988904312253, 0.01843482255935669, 0.028808921575546265, 0.02107974886894226, 0.03607663884758949, -0.014068637043237686, -0.06818981468677521, -0.04161709547042847, 0.00860372930765152, -0.002914347220212221, 0.03823333978652954, -0.01208261214196682, -0.012322032824158669, 0.006208776030689478, -0.03082563541829586, -0.013656114228069782, -0.040182314813137054, 0.0015974577981978655, -0.024090765044093132, 0.010320459492504597, -0.004851294215768576, 0.012647089548408985, 0.008249127306044102, 0.022360511124134064, 0.1407216191291809, 0.08579029142856598, 0.0045235068537294865, -0.021992146968841553, 0.05763748288154602, 0.014224468730390072, -0.0031725869048386812, 0.01239077840000391, 0.032203201204538345, -0.028998851776123047, -0.023898359388113022, 0.009919054806232452, 0.049436528235673904, -0.012609163299202919, -0.012974285520613194, 0.051979560405015945, -0.007714602164924145, -0.014601962640881538, -0.009849208407104015, 0.008851186372339725, -0.012547492980957031, -0.029718587175011635, 0.012580490671098232, 0.004313470795750618, -0.02029164880514145, -0.07200937718153, -0.002614092081785202, 0.001388294156640768, -0.010883632116019726, -0.019974205642938614, -0.013508143834769726, -0.008790281601250172, 0.025776609778404236, 0.00690569169819355, 0.002995107090100646, -0.03403850272297859, 0.011201862245798111, -0.013958229683339596, -0.006036467384546995, 0.05462655425071716, -0.0382126159965992, -0.010441523045301437, -0.030047530308365822, 0.012597485445439816, -0.04812924563884735, -0.06171607971191406, -0.04736806079745293, 0.035621047019958496, 0.011081439442932606, 0.007376375142484903, -0.019048968330025673, -0.015203764662146568, 0.03136376664042473, -0.008976368233561516, -0.008008061908185482, 0.07219535857439041, 0.024836288765072823, -0.04989957436919212, 0.011995375156402588, -0.026404090225696564, 0.009389685466885567, -0.012330655939877033, 0.023465344682335854, 0.0301556047052145, -0.023757845163345337, -0.015188355930149555, -0.01124480925500393, 0.0076739853248000145, 0.01916397735476494, -0.0007437707390636206, 0.02256046235561371, -0.00006285969720920548, -0.028982853516936302, 0.004407537169754505, 0.03397078812122345, 0.030906900763511658, 0.04111316800117493, -0.006169698666781187, -0.022656666114926338, -0.07465260475873947, -0.038300175219774246, 0.02215670794248581, -0.006126754451543093, -0.03891479969024658, -0.050724390894174576, 0.02706875093281269, 0.015822047367691994, 0.03306401148438454, 0.0024811672046780586, -0.002955726580694318, 0.008062069304287434, 0.004349865950644016, 0.022434456273913383, -0.0629432275891304, -0.0075527094304561615, -0.010730392299592495, -0.02927476540207863, 0.01816289871931076, -0.01614570990204811, 0.03937489539384842, 0.00432166364043951, -0.01345906313508749, 0.030127396807074547, 0.02391240932047367, -0.013828926719725132, -0.0063755507580935955, 0.01647418923676014, -0.03851355239748955, 0.00365074397996068, 0.01922493800520897, 0.004577293526381254, 0.004667053464800119, 0.003255371004343033, -0.049741100519895554, -0.021860959008336067, 0.015940796583890915, -0.007227763999253511, -0.023806758224964142, 0.03828370198607445, 0.008178450167179108, 0.03469635173678398, -0.053914036601781845, -0.0034982471261173487, -0.030753446742892265, -0.008009047247469425, -0.026472004130482674, 0.004888384137302637, -0.025910085067152977, 0.0370328314602375, -0.020927803590893745, -0.014684022404253483, 0.06075677275657654, -0.006983669474720955, 0.009342876262962818, -0.017782725393772125, 0.018356164917349815, 0.012281949631869793, 0.057383883744478226, -0.011397819966077805, -0.014346576295793056, 0.021424783393740654, -0.05244135484099388, -0.03796492889523506, 0.019715558737516403, -0.01770620048046112, 0.010259353555738926, 0.02549481950700283, 0.01832618936896324, 0.006823952309787273, 0.010800210759043694, -0.010307759046554565, -0.007546178065240383, -0.005374996457248926, 0.029096169397234917, 0.005260469391942024, -0.02262611873447895, 0.016969675198197365, 0.00886374432593584, -0.020940907299518585, 0.0352909155189991, 0.019209353253245354, 0.017957311123609543, -0.015454682521522045, 0.009206432849168777, -0.003227655543014407, -0.01516153384000063, -0.006485958583652973, -0.014072363264858723, 0.04536866396665573, 0.05832510441541672, 0.00007569917943328619, 0.055222153663635254, -0.008434266783297062, -0.008514879271388054, -0.10655981302261353, -0.025093724951148033, -0.00926054548472166, 0.03742488846182823, 0.049114491790533066, -0.04197856783866882, -0.0065554725006222725, 0.020632611587643623, -0.05102325230836868, 0.013905966654419899, -0.013883989304304123, 0.021421726793050766, -0.02821013331413269, -0.050199706107378006, -0.013471570797264576, 0.04271192476153374, -0.002358043100684881, 0.052954237908124924, 0.025004010647535324, 0.03957189619541168, 0.047363609075546265, -0.019711731001734734, -0.03586118295788765, -0.006879915948957205, 0.009104247204959393, -0.04322810471057892, 0.02473422698676586, -0.06541638821363449, 0.02081320248544216, 0.0211325790733099, 0.01151393074542284, 0.043866828083992004, 0.03985327482223511, 0.041603896766901016, 0.014988165348768234, 0.05715472996234894, 0.043374426662921906, 0.0009918082505464554, 0.003226617118343711, -0.0403544045984745, -0.04725797846913338, 0.030257420614361763, 0.00603506388142705, -0.00001183251788461348, 0.039867740124464035, -0.016680682078003883, -0.0075317141599953175, 0.011512765660881996, -0.018534228205680847, -0.005926874466240406, 0.022450091317296028, -0.03908524289727211, -0.006394352298229933, 0.0004199533141218126, 0.02470262721180916, -0.02771942876279354, -0.02314453385770321, 0.037427179515361786, 0.0384272001683712, -0.030485035851597786, 0.03818715363740921, -0.004646001849323511, -0.04549030214548111, 0.014216899871826172, -0.0060787140391767025, 0.009321467950940132, -0.06172407791018486, -0.017434053122997284, 0.021121082827448845, -0.013018717989325523, -0.06634383648633957, 0.031548596918582916, -0.05152587220072746, 0.06274086236953735, -0.0475766658782959, 0.02184724062681198, 0.028226705268025398, -0.028099702671170235, 0.036742012947797775, -0.06492413580417633, 0.05493525415658951, -0.008327072486281395, -0.00729713449254632, -0.0089491605758667, -0.003618424292653799, 0.007843272760510445, -0.014882811345160007, 0.06640193611383438, -0.03032241202890873, 0.029598359018564224, -0.006636545527726412, 0.025315145030617714, 0.02385771833360195, -0.03740900754928589, 0.015478366054594517, -0.008511066436767578, 0.01355703640729189, 0.017515994608402252, -0.03138094022870064, 0.045214761048555374, -0.024470994248986244, 0.028629858046770096, -0.033038944005966187, 0.021907635033130646, 0.004034009296447039, -0.05736025422811508, 0.031765472143888474, 0.011338386684656143, -0.024084193632006645, 0.039861541241407394, 0.0028721571434289217, 0.01981520652770996, 0.03623557090759277, -0.00809624046087265, -0.07025033980607986, -0.00011519729741849005, -0.056586142629384995, -0.013530719093978405, 0.03774178400635719, 0.0074748871847987175, 0.011068799532949924, -0.05487247183918953, 0.015983637422323227, 0.03699840232729912, -0.025069382041692734, 0.007863358594477177, 0.04212053865194321, 0.018709374591708183, -0.009183800779283047, -0.00936522800475359, 0.043805841356515884, 0.037291545420885086, -0.023518182337284088, 0.024157699197530746, 0.004131664521992207, 0.005912811495363712, -0.016260268166661263, 0.019069012254476547, 0.025165369734168053, -0.0013801873428747058, 0.019531838595867157, -0.006061325781047344, 0.006545024923980236, -0.0348418764770031, -0.024500597268342972, 0.04943561926484108, 0.00637024687603116, 0.04842642694711685, -0.015525491908192635, -0.01788868010044098, 0.0747673362493515, -0.05436650291085243, -0.015679312869906425, -0.015774065628647804, 0.03020506165921688, -0.06546226143836975, 0.045313332229852676, 0.016589729115366936, 0.04368234798312187, 0.051893457770347595, 0.013436945155262947, -0.0030837447848170996, -0.02616816572844982, -0.005376532208174467, 0.009175654500722885, 0.010467158630490303, 0.010240874253213406, -0.007036259397864342, -0.03977050259709358, -0.028238363564014435, -0.013544989749789238, -0.041811101138591766, 0.0057268342934548855, 0.03452465310692787, 0.007518651429563761, -0.021265536546707153, -0.02670750394463539, 0.01536960992962122, 0.053587157279253006, -0.06937985867261887, -0.00048512499779462814, -0.04024527221918106, -0.0029652167577296495, -0.018895991146564484, -0.008775283582508564 ]
<p>I am working with R package "muhaz" to get the kernel estimate of the hazard function. If we have the following example which is the sample of uncensored data:</p> <pre><code> x =c(0.001409591, 0.008451294, 0.019719245, 0.046626865 ,0.244813744, 0.410032119, 0.489286425, 0.697342699, 0.731541987, 0.954493031) fit = muhaz(x, rep(1, length(x)), bw.method="local", b.cor="both", n.min.grid=51, n.est.grid=101, kern="epanechnikov") </code></pre> <p>I have two questions: 1) How can I write the estimated hazard function as a formula in terms of the result of fit? How can we get the estimated hazard function for any desire value not just for grid points (fit$est.grid points)?</p> <p>2) Is it possible to get the estimated density function? because as far as I know the result does not provide it. How can we get the estimated density function for any desire value? not just for grid points (fit$est.grid points).</p>
73,613
[ -0.015925774350762367, 0.001511095673777163, 0.05556894466280937, 0.021840739995241165, 0.006505290046334267, -0.0052478983998298645, -0.05412852391600609, -0.01618289202451706, 0.02790304273366928, -0.03645958751440048, 0.014006548561155796, 0.05931790918111801, 0.05116349831223488, 0.015674205496907234, 0.03447920083999634, -0.012498764321208, -0.0011531705968081951, 0.050414130091667175, -0.01816682703793049, -0.04675289988517761, 0.005903914570808411, 0.01404894981533289, 0.004689845256507397, -0.014928003773093224, -0.020441144704818726, 0.02980082668364048, 0.0402003638446331, -0.010669712908565998, -0.00770114129409194, 0.06600453704595566, -0.004215060733258724, -0.056219883263111115, 0.01979898102581501, 0.008562569506466389, 0.033682312816381454, 0.026687128469347954, -0.05003639683127403, -0.01519069541245699, 0.021107686683535576, 0.03781545162200928, -0.04059264808893204, -0.0619463250041008, -0.006590321194380522, 0.03679026663303375, -0.019593415781855583, 0.015831472352147102, -0.01928207091987133, -0.0071546356193721294, 0.03165189549326897, -0.02832837775349617, 0.03989825025200844, -0.027754900977015495, 0.017604058608412743, 0.0302205141633749, -0.036866798996925354, -0.02497558481991291, 0.0591827891767025, 0.03966463357210159, 0.002723146928474307, -0.04929542541503906, -0.03608546778559685, -0.021010980010032654, -0.004987288732081652, -0.013216492719948292, -0.022461410611867905, -0.01651310920715332, -0.0354018397629261, -0.013756700791418552, 0.03602989390492439, -0.04741578549146652, 0.0012471263762563467, 0.006638671737164259, -0.0010016151936724782, -0.02064884640276432, 0.045555200427770615, -0.0245958399027586, -0.01789925992488861, -0.013562305830419064, 0.03993349149823189, 0.008384054526686668, -0.008420203812420368, 0.026274709030985832, 0.03540278971195221, 0.028725270181894302, 0.02013111673295498, 0.025774037465453148, 0.09611585736274719, 0.009253379888832569, 0.054417628794908524, 0.004038592334836721, -0.008388184010982513, 0.01864437945187092, 0.06454135477542877, -0.01581556349992752, -0.0070932223461568356, -0.0017662699101492763, -0.01980685070157051, 0.07245863229036331, 0.007173452526330948, -0.03139590099453926, 0.0081917280331254, -0.04981504753232002, 0.015018509700894356, 0.00551457516849041, -0.03603320196270943, -0.020049260929226875, -0.009179174900054932, -0.0157175250351429, 0.01107961218804121, -0.02427620068192482, -0.04513392224907875, 0.07321728020906448, -0.006286728661507368, -0.04940488189458847, 0.029543723911046982, -0.008665883913636208, -0.054057035595178604, -0.0029477032367140055, 0.032956745475530624, 0.07604452967643738, 0.07858137786388397, 0.01507442258298397, 0.02178293839097023, -0.05675005167722702, -0.07379350811243057, -0.007293913513422012, 0.04441428929567337, -0.013068068772554398, -0.024266768246889114, 0.02497014030814171, 0.015276892110705376, -0.012180870398879051, 0.053863320499658585, 0.028577152639627457, 0.013641699217259884, -0.009354151785373688, -0.05109018832445145, -0.05734006687998772, 0.01310824230313301, 0.027291785925626755, -0.0001571186730870977, -0.04794105514883995, 0.0020051775500178337, 0.04547462239861488, 0.07208335399627686, -0.006106504239141941, 0.0062566278502345085, -0.026154760271310806, 0.0017585995374247432, -0.017141932621598244, -0.03240448236465454, 0.0007189501775428653, -0.014131817035377026, -0.0322970412671566, -0.022605888545513153, -0.06559210270643234, 0.05590992793440819, 0.0035908168647438288, -0.023686885833740234, -0.0006190608255565166, 0.06806540489196777, -0.006700234487652779, -0.020087074488401413, -0.031018052250146866, -0.021884532645344734, -0.017695827409625053, 0.07186286151409149, -0.01469759363681078, -0.0011618969729170203, 0.005133995786309242, -0.047000251710414886, 0.011369065381586552, -0.004600090906023979, 0.020270099863409996, 0.058194708079099655, -0.023091468960046768, -0.03127945587038994, -0.017916278913617134, 0.04178129509091377, 0.02204653061926365, -0.014442718587815762, 0.000329014437738806, 0.03907810524106026, -0.015449384227395058, 0.030743377283215523, -0.008727913722395897, 0.012875232845544815, -0.002037503058090806, 0.02867097221314907, -0.00452166423201561, -0.0526888482272625, -0.06450095772743225, -0.0374208502471447, 0.012602228671312332, 0.00013126980047672987, 0.01859537698328495, 0.0184641033411026, 0.01170941162854433, 0.011454028077423573, -0.01589711382985115, -0.01018878910690546, -0.00046221676166169345, 0.043001893907785416, -0.039243146777153015, -0.04206409305334091, 0.031376633793115616, 0.07329846918582916, -0.029548300430178642, 0.04846980422735214, -0.019019242376089096, -0.01253238320350647, 0.009467065334320068, -0.07918228209018707, -0.019398940727114677, 0.013592658564448357, -0.02001536451280117, 0.008057721890509129, 0.027235304936766624, -0.012228296138346195, -0.012641921639442444, -0.06383860856294632, 0.04837482422590256, 0.08469831943511963, 0.014378507621586323, 0.01818133145570755, -0.003565504914149642, -0.0023203513119369745, -0.015504540875554085, -0.01845865324139595, -0.01585734263062477, -0.03004295751452446, -0.016931017860770226, 0.04725359007716179, -0.018001126125454903, -0.017483200877904892, 0.009143530391156673, 0.035791702568531036, -0.018886340782046318, -0.015431630425155163, 0.030888879671692848, -0.012917942367494106, -0.014716660603880882, 0.02752142958343029, 0.01963595300912857, -0.012434783391654491, 0.018742773681879044, 0.004022868815809488, 0.02798239327967167, 0.03203844651579857, -0.028239527717232704, -0.003891616128385067, 0.06530329585075378, -0.04480645805597305, -0.04191945120692253, -0.027675515040755272, 0.016134440898895264, 0.04305952414870262, -0.011833889409899712, 0.01941611059010029, 0.016578620299696922, -0.022735321894288063, 0.011496330611407757, -0.01578526757657528, -0.01956591196358204, 0.03628448396921158, 0.03514379262924194, -0.04808364808559418, -0.013681522570550442, 0.009293275885283947, -0.051433201879262924, -0.03999108448624611, 0.00720159150660038, -0.011627564206719398, -0.04059940204024315, 0.01625695824623108, 0.01649514026939869, 0.015072420239448547, -0.017880596220493317, -0.027472812682390213, -0.05269651859998703, 0.021690884605050087, 0.015209171921014786, 0.04915105551481247, 0.04718674346804619, -0.055853214114904404, 0.01294733490794897, -0.02690870687365532, -0.03242981806397438, 0.01759931817650795, 0.008129552938044071, -0.03164670616388321, 0.013110009953379631, -0.015026198700070381, -0.04223640263080597, 0.023211807012557983, -0.017326461151242256, 0.02737150527536869, -0.0219497662037611, 0.008705629035830498, 0.0022471060510724783, 0.01552296057343483, -0.0573883093893528, 0.045818112790584564, -0.05806616321206093, -0.00899208802729845, -0.0232376791536808, 0.005108313634991646, 0.02532566711306572, -0.004599729552865028, 0.04457956552505493, 0.034696318209171295, 0.004674503579735756, -0.011222313158214092, -0.04160403832793236, -0.03416032716631889, 0.02606017328798771, 0.017225248739123344, -0.0020141275599598885, 0.03293372690677643, -0.02336486056447029, 0.07780386507511139, 0.004005206748843193, -0.06992794573307037, -0.03686416149139404, -0.014391039498150349, -0.027810342609882355, -0.003911117557436228, 0.0018800686812028289, 0.01930944435298443, 0.021331802010536194, 0.013089965097606182, -0.025737686082720757, 0.03861018642783165, 0.054145388305187225, 0.013094970025122166, 0.0037643976975232363, 0.004929255228489637, 0.006731230765581131, -0.019304601475596428, 0.06109696999192238, 0.031745169311761856, 0.029863744974136353, 0.010541483759880066, -0.004552806261926889, -0.011134203523397446, -0.005109401885420084, -0.05075756087899208, 0.01946622133255005, 0.00955316610634327, 0.030095478519797325, -0.041159458458423615, 0.020791811868548393, -0.00013487662363331765, -0.034097086638212204, -0.008467906154692173, -0.007250100374221802, 0.05493859201669693, -0.008246837183833122, 0.007708527147769928, 0.018999716266989708, 0.023203415796160698, -0.03408561274409294, 0.018618334084749222, -0.023454075679183006, -0.008592337369918823, 0.011561201885342598, -0.049274034798145294, -0.04468158632516861, 0.04419165104627609, 0.051464393734931946, 0.01770300231873989, 0.02318382076919079, -0.023423271253705025, 0.036297138780355453, -0.06521089375019073, -0.015324248932301998, -0.0010800142772495747, 0.04412170499563217, 0.01079372875392437, 0.057980332523584366, 0.04581339284777641, -0.01159344706684351, -0.005151202902197838, 0.02726162225008011, -0.0895075872540474, 0.033538103103637695, 0.02348644845187664, 0.01806589961051941, -0.03791432082653046, -0.058020032942295074, 0.004717136733233929, -0.006068770308047533, -0.003303761361166835, 0.0037207261193543673, 0.007868130691349506, -0.04565412923693657, 0.007665713783353567, -0.01563805341720581, 0.03233365714550018, -0.03841817006468773, 0.041319090873003006, 0.058558057993650436, 0.016199858859181404, 0.0135231027379632, 0.028436459600925446, -0.01820187270641327, -0.01130747888237238, -0.045706454664468765, 0.004018898122012615, 0.0135202556848526, 0.05480821058154106, 0.03279193118214607, 0.007669638376682997, -0.020259888842701912, -0.011099295690655708, -0.005903633777052164, 0.05660990625619888, 0.05755070224404335, 0.01017523929476738, -0.0005149107309989631, -0.025750551372766495, -0.016679005697369576, -0.018800068646669388, 0.021287618204951286, -0.04049607366323471, 0.02695653960108757, 0.060982756316661835, 0.0084712915122509, -0.057103972882032394, 0.022932803258299828, 0.054905395954847336, 0.010266709141433239, 0.03590422868728638, -0.04141662269830704, 0.0003381711430847645, 0.00017565640155225992, -0.03419916331768036, 0.003836629679426551, 0.015171186998486519, -0.001460077241063118, -0.007621886674314737, 0.04238692671060562, 0.007766923867166042, -0.02093139849603176, -0.025234924629330635, 0.04736649617552757, 0.05818800628185272, -0.02561328187584877, -0.004091826267540455, -0.0013330725487321615, 0.03297915682196617, 0.023916497826576233, -0.01679692231118679, -0.007718668319284916, -0.08149225264787674, -0.0069178445264697075, 0.048419348895549774, 0.05085432901978493, 0.012597939930856228, -0.02065442129969597, -0.05014977231621742, -0.010936182923614979, 0.019282814115285873, -0.00687324907630682, -0.01661081425845623, 0.008158672600984573, 0.00015162209456320852, 0.02001463994383812, -0.017842242494225502, -0.045120012015104294, 0.0022446790244430304, -0.019644204527139664, -0.0030945194885134697, -0.05872771143913269, 0.018738962709903717, -0.01989482156932354, 0.04524284228682518, -0.006098171230405569, 0.07467363029718399, 0.00029867474222555757, -0.04196939617395401, -0.02268616296350956, 0.03428367152810097, -0.010482518002390862, -0.04005584865808487, 0.01739180088043213, -0.032578904181718826, 0.01796271838247776, 0.04789319261908531, -0.00037004787009209394, 0.012964179739356041, 0.022466344758868217, -0.004325898364186287, -0.04881557077169418, 0.05245675891637802, -0.0057294354774057865, 0.014383907429873943, 0.015204941853880882, 0.01988261751830578, 0.06986651569604874, 0.028522176668047905, 0.03539123386144638, 0.012295019812881947, -0.06167083978652954, 0.020479239523410797, -0.008587249554693699, -0.004983535967767239, -0.07522434741258621, -0.024029120802879333, -0.008021089248359203, -0.019358225166797638, 0.0438680574297905, 0.027091382071375847, -0.05268024653196335, 0.009638120420277119, 0.0631587952375412, 0.0409928523004055, -0.013483346439898014, 0.015538222156465054, -0.007685610558837652, 0.03547688573598862, 0.022995175793766975, -0.018147332593798637, -0.008993642404675484, 0.0013497284380719066, -0.003833462717011571, 0.0072761713527143, -0.029358375817537308, 0.027513412758708, -0.02300916239619255, -0.009592621587216854, 0.03613632172346115, -0.016939161345362663, 0.05132666230201721, -0.022089630365371704, 0.023470565676689148, -0.023202821612358093, -0.04549042135477066, 0.018837442621588707, -0.0018411858472973108, -0.005668886471539736, 0.03806556761264801, -0.022343026474118233, 0.06455478072166443, 0.011499936692416668, -0.024105779826641083, -0.07173513621091843, -0.024456338956952095, 0.03477262333035469, -0.005842048674821854, -0.04325810447335243, -0.04002738744020462, -0.014309530146420002, -0.033036235719919205, -0.03505166620016098, 0.02519793063402176, 0.022301388904452324, 0.014355078339576721, -0.012001882307231426, -0.006421096622943878, 0.0021041680593043566, 0.03602852672338486, 0.007302355021238327, -0.0037600526120513678, 0.022849973291158676, -0.017239540815353394, -0.013165883719921112, 0.02644641324877739, -0.0042866868898272514, 0.005491560325026512, -0.012151014991104603, -0.017957333475351334, -0.04007958993315697, 0.02634708769619465, 0.010537860915064812, -0.03310152515769005, 0.0012383016292005777, 0.01218256913125515, 0.013986671343445778, -0.03196767717599869, -0.014506221748888493, -0.04741711542010307, 0.008878594264388084, -0.026045940816402435, 0.010015657171607018, -0.018790487200021744, 0.016013583168387413, 0.03569439798593521, -0.0029434929601848125, -0.004674711264669895, 0.015939729288220406, 0.07967827469110489, 0.024683192372322083, -0.00946386530995369, 0.005342769902199507, -0.008406118489801884, 0.05168461799621582, 0.005763155873864889, 0.01201705727726221, 0.02356416918337345, 0.033619217574596405, -0.0574827715754509, -0.0036594721022993326, -0.07017084211111069, 0.011087130755186081, 0.05683676153421402, -0.03460047394037247, 0.06657133251428604, 0.0044208792969584465, 0.011357784271240234, -0.002304264809936285, -0.003861576784402132, -0.0065563698299229145, 0.010599978268146515, -0.0073484620079398155, 0.07561119645833969, 0.019985320046544075, 0.0036685524974018335, 0.05358028784394264, -0.0022405898198485374, 0.01641344465315342, 0.07388351857662201, 0.0028869975358247757, 0.013379025273025036, 0.00003340071634738706, -0.010127993300557137, -0.010201302357017994, 0.022303476929664612, -0.01210002414882183, -0.006027280818670988, -0.04517650604248047, -0.05578088015317917, 0.04714452475309372, -0.016168488189578056, -0.012682355009019375, -0.02535625733435154, -0.01733979396522045, -0.030018525198101997, 0.009163286536931992, 0.016733936965465546, -0.03750748187303543, 0.030706729739904404, -0.004465186037123203, 0.0018636832246556878, -0.0047342004254460335, 0.04617718234658241, -0.030544275417923927, -0.0697508305311203, -0.017924433574080467, -0.02993777208030224, -0.04377107322216034, 0.024236872792243958, 0.017337605357170105, -0.015579999424517155, 0.044450532644987106, -0.0043755341321229935, 0.03471170365810394, 0.001583862234838307, 0.02854323200881481, -0.01747395470738411, 0.07723032683134079, 0.018203523010015488, 0.022842975333333015, -0.03393706679344177, -0.017978880554437637, 0.1323489248752594, 0.0651165023446083, 0.048931755125522614, -0.0578652061522007, -0.011516504921019077, -0.013806209899485111, -0.0216362364590168, -0.001992743229493499, -0.020542321726679802, 0.018534474074840546, -0.0194707028567791, 0.04237966984510422, 0.04642677679657936, 0.03268047422170639, 0.031822752207517624, 0.00658266618847847, -0.004933468997478485, -0.04116794094443321, -0.006048447452485561, 0.043728891760110855, 0.0013199743116274476, -0.002040934981778264, -0.04703763872385025, 0.011799384839832783, 0.06432921439409256, -0.025610754266381264, -0.02808241918683052, -0.04171135276556015, -0.034906934946775436, 0.019859792664647102, -0.00019291954231448472, 0.023635124787688255, -0.0009380874107591808, 0.008940020576119423, 0.009797779843211174, 0.01764397695660591, 0.03245622292160988, -0.044485174119472504, 0.008071227930486202, 0.01676318608224392, 0.0229271799325943, -0.011172465980052948, -0.011627287603914738, 0.044730816036462784, -0.02023790217936039, -0.012570595368742943, -0.015933960676193237, 0.017430970445275307, -0.028012294322252274, -0.02107112668454647, 0.03378075361251831, -0.006329942028969526, 0.003078254172578454, -0.06666604429483414, -0.0026375306770205498, -0.009192356839776039, 0.039186421781778336, -0.018290065228939056, -0.029759706929326057, -0.018595336005091667, -0.0006116407457739115, -0.015876442193984985, 0.027196455746889114, 0.02642032504081726, -0.042638957500457764, -0.01717211678624153, -0.0171964168548584, 0.047298770397901535, -0.026775402948260307, 0.018160847947001457, -0.02445148304104805, -0.03542564809322357, -0.030837923288345337, -0.029595045372843742, 0.035410236567258835, -0.0453345961868763, 0.03148834407329559, -0.03697687387466431, 0.014220877550542355, 0.0031182768288999796, -0.03185049444437027, -0.015813948586583138, -0.05316679924726486, -0.01875445619225502, -0.0629238486289978, 0.028051257133483887, 0.035085346549749374, 0.02544223889708519, 0.00013698884868063033, -0.008638695813715458, 0.008610248565673828, 0.029221955686807632, -0.0003734612255357206, -0.07688941806554794, -0.028430622071027756, -0.013567144982516766, -0.025735080242156982, -0.017297599464654922, -0.02702796272933483, 0.039216049015522, 0.03242718055844307, 0.01422259770333767, -0.01310837734490633, 0.01338207721710205, -0.006798636633902788, 0.017112024128437042, -0.024346990510821342, -0.027393214404582977, 0.027553193271160126, -0.006384304258972406, 0.00552479550242424, -0.004972625989466906, -0.019131438806653023, -0.05003141984343529, -0.04163861274719238, 0.0022014817222952843, -0.004279267508536577, -0.03702815994620323, -0.006736801937222481, 0.022660138085484505, -0.02163616195321083, 0.014723076485097408, -0.006241288501769304, 0.006380989216268063, 0.009857933968305588, -0.02757830172777176, -0.03669310361146927, 0.005309091880917549, -0.026180407032370567, -0.020919090136885643, -0.010069423355162144, 0.04138787463307381, 0.0038406457751989365, 0.041223593056201935, -0.021389203146100044, 0.02980092540383339, 0.0035363510251045227, 0.026076873764395714, 0.0073226564563810825, 0.011212760582566261, 0.04107050597667694, -0.04645038768649101, -0.007845791056752205, -0.010185855440795422, 0.029119160026311874, 0.03906608000397682, 0.009447762742638588, 0.025742681697010994, -0.017956320196390152, 0.06393750011920929, -0.0265204980969429, 0.016881704330444336, 0.007843677885830402, -0.0010488926200196147, -0.010617068037390709, 0.012558992952108383, -0.035706162452697754, -0.014208872802555561, 0.012201997451484203, 0.01700512133538723, 0.015410787425935268, 0.019774500280618668, -0.00009435375250177458, 0.04844176024198532, 0.001280243624933064, 0.005002585239708424, 0.01106499694287777, -0.010995560325682163, 0.010017773136496544, 0.03474588692188263, -0.016075357794761658, 0.024102360010147095, -0.036422450095415115, -0.0006404175073839724, -0.05895964056253433, -0.019620588049292564, 0.021359700709581375, -0.02113257348537445, 0.02373446896672249, -0.042929477989673615, -0.006398779805749655, -0.015158397145569324, -0.016857601702213287, 0.021842116490006447, -0.006174185313284397, 0.0021452629007399082, -0.01593865267932415, 0.012458433397114277, 0.0029645427130162716, 0.018264153972268105, 0.04364371299743652, 0.047478508204221725, 0.04368886351585388, -0.020992573350667953, -0.017881764099001884, -0.022290591150522232, 0.0018531617242842913, 0.01531106699258089, 0.04225798323750496, -0.07511302083730698, 0.06059260293841362, -0.05539330467581749, -0.03858628123998642, -0.0037900502793490887, -0.02718605101108551, -0.012952161952853203, 0.01916600950062275, -0.0027154446579515934, 0.0037941609043627977, 0.055007170885801315, 0.032356079667806625, -0.023586871102452278, -0.010979284532368183, -0.013796958141028881, 0.00899158138781786, -0.004204155877232552, -0.06671402603387833, 0.02346011996269226, 0.017925992608070374, 0.011794065125286579, -0.02810569666326046, 0.04735831916332245, -0.01973511278629303, -0.020831653848290443, -0.04971204325556755, -0.016023369506001472, 0.03646475821733475, -0.021758917719125748, 0.05647580325603485, -0.03441290929913521, 0.010905284434556961, 0.031152982264757156, 0.04938925802707672, 0.00642694067209959, 0.03894340246915817, -0.005595914553850889, -0.05190145969390869, 0.05104132741689682, -0.017764104530215263, -0.012888852506875992, -0.04417923092842102, -0.0069975461810827255, 0.0006798048270866275, 0.005072678904980421, -0.007199514657258987, -0.00041840129415504634, -0.048347774893045425, 0.0203088466078043, -0.024148141965270042, -0.02423480711877346, 0.017778415232896805, 0.025599302724003792, 0.0008539938135072589, -0.08491846919059753, 0.022265050560235977, 0.01395659614354372, -0.01669161207973957, -0.02785707451403141, -0.009680810384452343, 0.017129361629486084, 0.0028826782945543528, 0.03147520124912262, -0.027044067159295082, -0.019912637770175934, 0.006516352295875549, 0.03352544456720352, 0.023234251886606216, -0.04134294018149376, 0.017665764316916466, -0.007115398533642292, -0.030682381242513657, -0.012852116487920284, 0.014312388375401497, -0.002503705443814397, 0.021238107234239578, 0.010176395997405052, -0.035332974046468735, 0.01599785126745701, -0.006642132066190243, -0.0359787754714489, 0.021370982751250267, -0.007839050143957138, -0.004683149978518486, 0.06928442418575287, -0.021284768357872963, 0.005669890902936459, 0.05840026214718819, 0.03372924029827118, -0.046502333134412766, 0.04171018674969673, -0.02624267339706421, -0.07332976907491684, 0.039481282234191895, 0.008029920980334282, -0.0031615830957889557, -0.04853490740060806, -0.03552192449569702, -0.008950409479439259, -0.023050004616379738, -0.005336181726306677, 0.031935013830661774, -0.0040449160151183605, 0.05306749418377876, -0.022617889568209648, -0.013347052969038486, -0.009766938164830208, -0.037406280636787415, 0.007839913479983807, 0.029774533584713936, 0.03657204657793045, -0.013039212673902512, 0.0491667166352272, 0.024636512622237206, -0.038676489144563675, 0.007274500094354153, -0.018855830654501915, 0.08339011669158936, -0.051238030195236206, -0.05687634274363518, 0.002507509896531701, -0.0038529071025550365, 0.012227974832057953, -0.04145149514079094, -0.030365828424692154, 0.034561581909656525, -0.036988455802202225, 0.005662079900503159, -0.01987692527472973, -0.011288296431303024, -0.06941600888967514, 0.006228257901966572, 0.025209784507751465, 0.026497168466448784, 0.013165709562599659, 0.0520811453461647, 0.010819596238434315, -0.009206876158714294, 0.04869263991713524, -0.004874191712588072, 0.008090886287391186, -0.03208666294813156, 0.01896069385111332, 0.014821212738752365, -0.019659018144011497, 0.013320167548954487, 0.012844379991292953, 0.03082946315407753, 0.013226165436208248, 0.017048295587301254, -0.009687424637377262, -0.012199831195175648, -0.007406503893435001, 0.05890117585659027, -0.05084555223584175, -0.020902028307318687, -0.0106589924544096, -0.00849424209445715, -0.013070166110992432, -0.016512980684638023 ]
<p>Almost in all texts which are discussing theorems of statistical learning, they assume analyzing arbitrary unknown distribution (the worst case). But in practice different problems (different data) have different levels of hardness, for example linear separable data is easier to learn than the data that are less (or not) separable by hyperplanes. Are there any works on formalizing the hardness of data (similar to the stuff done in complexity theory)</p> <p>Note: I am not sure if the same as analyzing VC-dimension or not, but I think it is not. </p>
73,614
[ -0.05122683569788933, -0.03702147677540779, 0.014750543050467968, -0.011037039570510387, 0.032555073499679565, 0.04464941844344139, 0.01544525008648634, 0.015310319140553474, 0.021696314215660095, -0.04572858288884163, 0.0398724265396595, 0.00786656979471445, 0.06287756562232971, 0.03840862587094307, 0.00850983802229166, 0.011092321015894413, -0.04854092746973038, 0.009900991804897785, -0.04372929781675339, 0.018980970606207848, 0.03054669126868248, 0.022368989884853363, 0.021465925499796867, -0.04014236107468605, -0.05775094032287598, 0.014334113337099552, 0.022671181708574295, 0.0070906528271734715, 0.015503463335335255, 0.06219722703099251, -0.02437436394393444, -0.01811712048947811, 0.028259335085749626, 0.044989388436079025, 0.03377031534910202, 0.0031888464000076056, -0.03307286649942398, -0.018839053809642792, -0.003148071002215147, 0.031152110546827316, -0.026210788637399673, -0.005924313794821501, -0.018769193440675735, 0.04600359499454498, -0.004643986001610756, 0.0425458662211895, -0.016671257093548775, -0.05065120384097099, -0.0016462357016280293, -0.02606763318181038, 0.08704491704702377, -0.020583001896739006, -0.00015058059943839908, 0.0083619998767972, 0.006803105119615793, 0.010901258327066898, 0.03775159269571304, 0.06590533256530762, 0.006100933067500591, -0.04393840953707695, -0.01488866563886404, -0.0042732153087854385, 0.023756587877869606, -0.02472206950187683, -0.02791113220155239, 0.030186140909790993, 0.017624564468860626, 0.004090587142854929, 0.037213943898677826, 0.004536998923867941, -0.0040993052534759045, 0.013907491229474545, 0.0306208748370409, 0.01760961301624775, -0.018462620675563812, 0.039301663637161255, 0.013575755059719086, 0.03259405493736267, 0.029468389227986336, 0.015821246430277824, 0.02312578447163105, 0.029075579717755318, -0.021290527656674385, 0.014740698039531708, 0.004384408704936504, -0.0224049910902977, 0.061701174825429916, -0.016077259555459023, -0.00913692731410265, 0.02187025360763073, 0.00549541600048542, -0.0227479487657547, 0.015322641469538212, -0.04074517637491226, -0.08882707357406616, 0.022512514144182205, 0.004539356101304293, 0.02670207992196083, 0.010637837462127209, -0.03454605117440224, 0.01036521140486002, -0.02860387973487377, -0.0013969666324555874, 0.06122523918747902, -0.035323984920978546, -0.024957099929451942, -0.03422120213508606, 0.022326596081256866, 0.0003140118205919862, -0.004523829557001591, -0.012040394358336926, 0.029116099700331688, 0.03652755543589592, 0.014141298830509186, 0.008149820379912853, -0.001307804137468338, 0.010535774752497673, -0.0037814893294125795, 0.03981458768248558, 0.07344677299261093, 0.03711653873324394, -0.042926207184791565, 0.03969965875148773, -0.03347529470920563, -0.05879362300038338, 0.009937688708305359, 0.033045317977666855, -0.04259125888347626, -0.01888463646173477, 0.03778529912233353, -0.022283993661403656, -0.005515842232853174, 0.052263811230659485, -0.01486413273960352, -0.014374027960002422, -0.02355794422328472, -0.05953707918524742, -0.06448272615671158, 0.02499612420797348, 0.009229498915374279, -0.029739677906036377, 0.005557710770517588, 0.013545630499720573, 0.020512398332357407, 0.004126494750380516, -0.01240648701786995, 0.09316690266132355, 0.004937800578773022, 0.008224972523748875, 0.019325321540236473, -0.022027481347322464, -0.021865729242563248, 0.02491433545947075, 0.005085910204797983, -0.021426154300570488, -0.048378296196460724, 0.030420495197176933, 0.01662510260939598, 0.005532878451049328, -0.021513381972908974, 0.020976176485419273, -0.014335032552480698, -0.025027399882674217, -0.009517981670796871, 0.013313389383256435, -0.0246640183031559, 0.05874911695718765, 0.0026660258881747723, 0.093293696641922, 0.040536507964134216, -0.019692139700055122, 0.027580812573432922, 0.019502507522702217, 0.015344641171395779, 0.08108493685722351, -0.019225945696234703, -0.04990575462579727, 0.01184803806245327, 0.04023318365216255, 0.013183671049773693, -0.015521648339927197, 0.0011068398598581553, -0.024760685861110687, 0.03556235134601593, -0.004700316581875086, 0.02489427849650383, 0.02535315416753292, -0.01955908164381981, 0.021442200988531113, -0.0523371547460556, -0.0426783487200737, -0.047675881534814835, 0.003843681886792183, -0.021514926105737686, -0.04107460752129555, 0.03605889901518822, -0.01005242858082056, -0.003151184180751443, -0.03722500801086426, -0.04100283980369568, -0.02383492700755596, -0.006257383152842522, 0.02054239995777607, -0.0494253933429718, 0.000019790490114246495, 0.022807909175753593, 0.026189496740698814, -0.025221651419997215, 0.08268431574106216, -0.023961428552865982, -0.08630844950675964, -0.0036836774088442326, -0.01915510557591915, 0.025141512975096703, 0.012281030416488647, 0.017537979409098625, 0.006420903839170933, -0.003985888324677944, -0.03550434485077858, 0.028545694425702095, -0.05150948092341423, 0.04760300740599632, 0.049118831753730774, 0.0351589135825634, -0.025217946618795395, 0.036877792328596115, -0.006347293499857187, 0.005650151986628771, 0.003777526319026947, 0.00883027259260416, -0.03964938223361969, 0.015486969612538815, 0.04591139033436775, 0.06217430159449577, -0.02513883076608181, 0.0037661264650523663, 0.06389377266168594, 0.03800579160451889, 0.024082880467176437, 0.03562629222869873, -0.02936727926135063, -0.01910519041121006, 0.022199947386980057, -0.00598161481320858, 0.03233122080564499, -0.006151596549898386, -0.0040913051925599575, 0.008497686125338078, 0.0028460996691137552, 0.02259463258087635, -0.006731345318257809, 0.07326488941907883, -0.013194791041314602, -0.033573634922504425, 0.00045706555829383433, -0.010240377858281136, 0.03435635566711426, -0.04547237232327461, 0.026279015466570854, 0.02407158352434635, -0.0008508673054166138, 0.009242057800292969, -0.006646919064223766, -0.003643154865130782, 0.05413554236292839, 0.013894102536141872, -0.014251315966248512, 0.008899111300706863, 0.04043896868824959, -0.031848516315221786, 0.019345209002494812, 0.002178720198571682, -0.029265813529491425, -0.007396210450679064, 0.036571841686964035, 0.026574840769171715, -0.058160584419965744, 0.010125463828444481, -0.009876539930701256, -0.004243318922817707, 0.017826460301876068, -0.020712096244096756, 0.028069408610463142, 0.015793072059750557, -0.03035789169371128, 0.023405540734529495, -0.03385994955897331, -0.039060547947883606, 0.035104721784591675, -0.034261465072631836, -0.001279322663322091, 0.005513425916433334, -0.010898266918957233, -0.03364092856645584, 0.012539442628622055, -0.027366936206817627, 0.00696822302415967, -0.033060766756534576, 0.030953295528888702, 0.01780024915933609, 0.016455553472042084, -0.014515487477183342, 0.022759364917874336, -0.0018322768155485392, -0.03927421569824219, -0.023290328681468964, -0.019687306135892868, 0.01656562276184559, -0.01570025272667408, 0.01798688992857933, 0.043724801391363144, -0.008333287201821804, -0.013833876699209213, -0.06780219078063965, -0.04771478474140167, 0.013891877606511116, -0.01810593716800213, 0.03723253309726715, 0.02383420616388321, 0.010617639869451523, 0.0851520374417305, 0.04498136788606644, -0.012407264672219753, -0.008064600639045238, 0.009353922680020332, -0.01912846975028515, 0.019647926092147827, 0.020467424765229225, -0.002313390374183655, -0.004412899725139141, -0.0027623572386801243, 0.00489297928288579, 0.00976213812828064, 0.03334898501634598, -0.008402387611567974, -0.0017996706301346421, 0.03965234383940697, 0.005952004808932543, 0.005016279872506857, 0.003309236839413643, 0.035608213394880295, -0.025410685688257217, 0.0340043343603611, 0.01694953814148903, 0.03224484249949455, 0.05144164711236954, -0.024365322664380074, -0.027635928243398666, -0.0031111198477447033, 0.053309109061956406, -0.05241180211305618, 0.016310539096593857, -0.0017510472098365426, 0.009246631525456905, 0.021362964063882828, 0.03990281745791435, 0.002910046838223934, -0.029010068625211716, 0.0020866412669420242, 0.047866955399513245, 0.05526982247829437, -0.004940211307257414, -0.018154636025428772, -0.013700222596526146, 0.009448305703699589, 0.0063815731555223465, -0.03171217069029808, -0.0186481811106205, 0.03948615863919258, 0.014647727832198143, 0.014378044754266739, 0.037101734429597855, -0.04519510269165039, 0.02148415334522724, -0.0382133424282074, -0.006551472004503012, -0.017606742680072784, 0.05158860981464386, 0.00035213795490562916, 0.007757324259728193, 0.009192894212901592, 0.0010749043431133032, -0.010675785131752491, 0.006623833905905485, -0.08176951110363007, -0.04181203618645668, -0.01655646599829197, -0.01734265126287937, 0.016515586525201797, -0.02395564690232277, 0.02639787830412388, -0.04250031337141991, -0.028051013126969337, -0.019066980108618736, 0.03923740237951279, -0.057709865272045135, 0.008789394982159138, 0.001382780959829688, -0.03633749857544899, -0.020669611170887947, 0.024571310728788376, 0.02989671379327774, -0.005240066442638636, 0.015009439550340176, 0.017285292968153954, -0.0297953262925148, -0.0056315758265554905, 0.004758990835398436, 0.007965166121721268, 0.02190142124891281, 0.05626297742128372, -0.06687496602535248, 0.04093964770436287, -0.02927462011575699, 0.00309028965421021, -0.016696183010935783, 0.029861025512218475, 0.01969682052731514, -0.036246124655008316, -0.003097291337326169, -0.06576554477214813, -0.021031014621257782, -0.0039022660348564386, 0.035943541675806046, 0.007123151328414679, 0.02261943370103836, 0.0319901667535305, 0.003139785025268793, -0.08590292185544968, 0.002655895659700036, 0.04606153070926666, 0.0009881757432594895, 0.00961656030267477, -0.009464649483561516, -0.04064963385462761, -0.011844190768897533, 0.0025640225503593683, 0.007232507225126028, 0.005373629275709391, 0.00788791198283434, 0.022607892751693726, 0.03311307355761528, -0.007590295746922493, -0.020382575690746307, -0.007044523023068905, 0.019447386264801025, -0.0018220908241346478, 0.004293277859687805, -0.0028516880702227354, 0.035914745181798935, 0.030947668477892876, 0.06005731597542763, 0.04641898348927498, 0.006238468457013369, -0.05680866912007332, 0.0035274408292025328, 0.06577219069004059, 0.013878555968403816, 0.009671838954091072, -0.025590967386960983, -0.02412472851574421, -0.0007211692864075303, 0.046911485493183136, -0.005133971571922302, 0.02506277523934841, -0.005660934839397669, -0.005985490046441555, -0.028355930000543594, -0.004928888753056526, -0.04263509064912796, -0.024431409314274788, 0.008325032889842987, 0.07219526171684265, 0.020372852683067322, -0.03062770515680313, -0.06689989566802979, -0.014088591560721397, 0.04320916160941124, 0.02054446190595627, -0.003338103648275137, -0.03170708194375038, -0.021018266677856445, 0.03802921250462532, -0.060156796127557755, -0.06168515980243683, 0.024162404239177704, 0.0209184717386961, -0.008420439437031746, 0.03296563774347305, -0.03864031285047531, -0.042581140995025635, 0.016489535570144653, 0.01014734711498022, -0.026109181344509125, 0.019390419125556946, 0.0016866280930116773, 0.06424777209758759, 0.018920371308922768, 0.026345448568463326, 0.05922728404402733, 0.0015756248030811548, 0.010880379937589169, -0.008340946398675442, -0.015722576528787613, 0.025441041216254234, -0.05612722411751747, -0.004090018104761839, -0.05892623960971832, -0.001535716699436307, 0.006166825536638498, 0.01593552716076374, 0.017237216234207153, 0.024379251524806023, -0.00905078835785389, -0.03285582363605499, -0.022696731612086296, 0.006676230579614639, 0.018961308524012566, -0.02826247364282608, -0.03016386553645134, 0.05376940220594406, -0.033677078783512115, 0.012046275660395622, 0.029544364660978317, 0.009835815988481045, 0.016065426170825958, 0.013846665620803833, -0.02798580378293991, 0.001015682122670114, -0.06678703427314758, -0.012141126208007336, 0.03279682621359825, -0.02084936574101448, 0.0684700533747673, -0.015508178621530533, 0.0015251691220328212, 0.028000401332974434, -0.018156904727220535, 0.01618967577815056, 0.01538627129048109, -0.041447412222623825, 0.032914478331804276, -0.027578003704547882, -0.00477630365639925, -0.045093148946762085, -0.006642365828156471, -0.0817866325378418, -0.040967583656311035, 0.005237853154540062, -0.005488113965839148, -0.02521524764597416, -0.02561403065919876, 0.04923729971051216, -0.003698104526847601, -0.033582866191864014, -0.015189907513558865, 0.03480496630072594, 0.006226762663573027, 0.01584210805594921, 0.00807623378932476, 0.012940594926476479, 0.04125986993312836, -0.011707121506333351, 0.036523111164569855, -0.026459302753210068, 0.00046207968262024224, 0.02258332259953022, -0.016268718987703323, -0.011054054833948612, -0.03409004956483841, 0.014506889507174492, -0.011011064983904362, -0.00865577906370163, 0.021751757711172104, -0.017592329531908035, 0.006641152780503035, 0.012213814072310925, -0.015463235788047314, -0.02898225001990795, -0.008753040805459023, 0.01889314316213131, 0.008988242596387863, 0.0011644052574411035, -0.040285371243953705, -0.03065788559615612, -0.019539138302206993, -0.021324940025806427, 0.039197422564029694, -0.0033792960457503796, 0.0032935962080955505, 0.027686594054102898, 0.020700177177786827, -0.014897645451128483, 0.004994540475308895, -0.006818291265517473, -0.04056333750486374, 0.006642321590334177, -0.009075588546693325, 0.0010078249033540487, 0.025183219462633133, 0.01702776551246643, -0.03593982011079788, -0.05077286437153816, -0.05687445402145386, 0.011872374452650547, 0.06004896014928818, 0.04336107522249222, 0.06107058748602867, 0.03440021350979805, -0.010201486758887768, -0.023282919079065323, -0.058211129158735275, -0.029745958745479584, -0.013005832210183144, 0.02630997821688652, 0.04018593952059746, 0.016584670171141624, 0.003400385146960616, 0.03049740195274353, 0.0270497165620327, -0.01700003631412983, 0.06387381255626678, -0.0038156784139573574, -0.0029487209394574165, 0.06498075276613235, -0.06210678070783615, -0.06282857805490494, 0.02784358710050583, -0.0478496290743351, -0.010818840935826302, -0.030272556468844414, -0.01244770921766758, 0.04398278146982193, 0.029734915122389793, 0.014826938509941101, -0.07418733090162277, -0.040388576686382294, -0.04138032719492912, 0.03916032612323761, 0.022849122062325478, -0.000046499881136696786, 0.04444565251469612, -0.010875649750232697, 0.007074981927871704, -0.02256222814321518, 0.018348975107073784, 0.004464125260710716, -0.045720648020505905, -0.040589410811662674, -0.03030291572213173, -0.032471511512994766, 0.004085494205355644, 0.03911331295967102, -0.030667392536997795, -0.0068061137571930885, -0.05449860915541649, 0.050255343317985535, 0.02950271964073181, 0.04047026112675667, 0.02506335824728012, 0.04230128228664398, -0.027515269815921783, 0.021045198664069176, -0.006454543676227331, 0.012792314402759075, 0.10464978218078613, 0.07776977866888046, 0.042475659400224686, -0.07151497900485992, 0.03594793379306793, -0.00854325108230114, -0.017391661182045937, -0.03977391496300697, 0.0059120869264006615, 0.012982443906366825, 0.01275831088423729, 0.03205046057701111, 0.04115336760878563, -0.004533954430371523, -0.02634315751492977, 0.03255688026547432, -0.04477645829319954, -0.005770234391093254, 0.0019511020509526134, 0.007773871533572674, -0.007188195828348398, 0.017432386055588722, -0.040516890585422516, -0.002017551101744175, 0.02514464035630226, -0.029391946271061897, -0.006599560845643282, -0.026912841945886612, 0.017852870747447014, 0.005541783757507801, -0.031912196427583694, 0.013265579007565975, 0.03903324156999588, -0.015490788035094738, -0.03201139718294144, 0.008482317440211773, -0.0155573058873415, -0.0204603374004364, -0.017046157270669937, 0.02092970348894596, 0.0037935874424874783, -0.011162553913891315, -0.008912564255297184, 0.0075631821528077126, -0.025786612182855606, -0.060046322643756866, -0.043662816286087036, 0.030712617561221123, -0.028367869555950165, -0.016793932765722275, 0.021423812955617905, -0.028859611600637436, 0.002490788698196411, -0.030345652252435684, -0.001306746737100184, 0.012425181455910206, 0.03855437412858009, -0.02012268640100956, -0.011208602227270603, 0.006506708450615406, 0.021918172016739845, -0.03376308083534241, -0.010836235247552395, 0.028714580461382866, -0.03257153183221817, -0.018701300024986267, -0.012975400313735008, 0.04537900537252426, 0.018748309463262558, -0.0194588340818882, -0.01819547638297081, -0.01820952072739601, 0.01119031198322773, -0.03384481742978096, -0.0029991636984050274, -0.007111395709216595, 0.010402278043329716, -0.030039381235837936, -0.02547803521156311, -0.0030721579678356647, -0.030585145577788353, -0.0003513870178721845, -0.053247783333063126, -0.005912173073738813, -0.027884669601917267, 0.019294919446110725, 0.024575533345341682, 0.061330266296863556, 0.04926345497369766, -0.0016626844881102443, 0.008641638793051243, 0.00018121598986908793, 0.013178415596485138, -0.06057063490152359, 0.0028405413031578064, -0.010436061769723892, -0.03580259531736374, 0.001135713537223637, 0.025083908811211586, 0.055322226136922836, 0.05601822957396507, 0.019559908658266068, 0.0025478224270045757, 0.028865020722150803, 0.01037440076470375, 0.01942591182887554, 0.02243458852171898, -0.059660814702510834, 0.01900585927069187, -0.03136655315756798, 0.011455094441771507, -0.046733368188142776, -0.045338794589042664, -0.044406235218048096, -0.009873462840914726, -0.021147169172763824, 0.0014357233885675669, -0.03191284462809563, 0.01594904437661171, 0.01104335580021143, 0.03379375487565994, -0.01457718200981617, -0.020592503249645233, 0.0187570508569479, -0.002299235202372074, -0.02965516783297062, -0.006059463135898113, 0.011135471984744072, 0.014917045831680298, -0.014653557911515236, -0.0020623374730348587, -0.0048328847624361515, 0.026422053575515747, -0.0024649393744766712, -0.013590419664978981, 0.04521884024143219, -0.004887241404503584, 0.06634029000997543, -0.031901031732559204, 0.006375285796821117, 0.026308154687285423, -0.06277726590633392, -0.06618307530879974, 0.02231040596961975, -0.026301568374037743, 0.01643317937850952, 0.02311152033507824, 0.014101620763540268, -0.029699452221393585, 0.017606221139431, -0.013902273960411549, -0.007153570652008057, 0.008591931313276291, 0.008018877357244492, -0.02511695772409439, 0.029891133308410645, 0.023503558710217476, 0.002291139680892229, -0.014423046261072159, -0.0019539264030754566, -0.011887568049132824, 0.03685120493173599, -0.016625231131911278, 0.0284644216299057, -0.007238438818603754, 0.06385638564825058, 0.021048253402113914, 0.007188661489635706, 0.06320293992757797, 0.050968144088983536, -0.032929498702287674, 0.0588470958173275, -0.0010477951727807522, 0.0013312733499333262, -0.12363823503255844, -0.02321402169764042, 0.010495411232113838, 0.01933368295431137, 0.037136260420084, -0.08445665240287781, 0.01426718756556511, -0.0052594589069485664, -0.09756772965192795, 0.017541345208883286, -0.044558167457580566, 0.0043611121363937855, -0.05650895833969116, 0.03027416579425335, -0.03382949158549309, 0.046351633965969086, -0.003129937220364809, 0.013499206863343716, 0.02271711826324463, 0.03141547366976738, -0.02252008020877838, -0.013937951996922493, -0.04174185171723366, 0.018662424758076668, -0.017043204978108406, -0.0553608201444149, 0.05963483080267906, -0.024822844192385674, -0.013591868802905083, 0.001583274221047759, -0.013350646942853928, 0.018742496147751808, 0.02964255027472973, 0.03444424644112587, 0.03968068212270737, 0.029146181419491768, 0.04673536494374275, -0.03665489703416824, -0.004951332695782185, 0.0067139011807739735, -0.038017258048057556, 0.014238948933780193, 0.014606919139623642, 0.020190637558698654, 0.017450420185923576, -0.0232070479542017, -0.013968058861792088, -0.005360642913728952, 0.0010214761132374406, -0.04811301827430725, -0.03363556042313576, -0.0010931786382570863, 0.0038514763582497835, -0.0016306985635310411, 0.0743207111954689, -0.0423760712146759, 0.03651316091418266, 0.030853023752570152, 0.03283654525876045, -0.021115057170391083, 0.009955126792192459, -0.025773178786039352, -0.06166042387485504, -0.010940691456198692, 0.024824807420372963, 0.013982337899506092, -0.060607630759477615, -0.011228173039853573, 0.0007984654512256384, -0.010321936570107937, -0.012720925733447075, -0.036987219005823135, -0.05643051490187645, 0.04692865163087845, 0.007377678994089365, 0.025073634460568428, -0.0034690520260483027, -0.05339551344513893, 0.03945698216557503, -0.08278167247772217, 0.07065888494253159, -0.01635795086622238, 0.009296134114265442, -0.012416244484484196, -0.002709839725866914, -0.026643209159374237, -0.034887220710515976, 0.03461562469601631, -0.021353712305426598, 0.0008514376822859049, -0.038004010915756226, 0.014934271574020386, -0.001548776519484818, -0.023679932579398155, 0.007498635444790125, -0.04325580969452858, -0.028722576797008514, -0.023692836984992027, -0.03440571203827858, 0.01153451669961214, -0.03310823068022728, 0.013950165361166, 0.009858928620815277, -0.012949896045029163, 0.003741349559277296, -0.005753071513026953, 0.048502083867788315, 0.04348687455058098, 0.02626984752714634, 0.03261084482073784, -0.00835700798779726, 0.020043520256876945, -0.010941606014966965, -0.0050636278465390205, -0.04102909564971924, 0.02172071672976017, -0.039968423545360565, -0.047662198543548584, -0.004396030679345131, 0.024261148646473885, 0.021607626229524612, -0.029257304966449738, -0.036699626594781876, 0.028816163539886475, -0.021202849224209785, 0.00675004068762064, 0.020745478570461273, 0.005352636333554983, 0.03543473035097122, -0.01682490110397339, -0.014964749105274677, 0.008997738361358643, -0.0052419183775782585, 0.021037854254245758, 0.008402288891375065, 0.031579241156578064, 0.0021264790557324886, 0.034650031477212906, 0.06371359527111053, -0.06265103816986084, 0.04276399686932564, 0.024109739810228348, 0.03398825600743294, -0.0558309443295002, -0.02128423936665058, 0.0002773893647827208, -0.0069836885668337345, -0.011545228771865368, -0.014613046310842037, -0.04229668527841568, 0.07924214005470276, -0.015537062659859657, 0.004197170026600361, -0.06473317742347717, -0.018733862787485123, -0.019251354038715363, 0.00017172480875160545, 0.0003712268662638962, 0.05537070706486702, 0.0035181965213268995, 0.04623426869511604, 0.00441289646551013, 0.03460937365889549, 0.04951268434524536, -0.014635825529694557, 0.035363808274269104, -0.010747024789452553, 0.004832559730857611, -0.006188410799950361, -0.026590192690491676, -0.003768794471397996, -0.011609606444835663, -0.004561602137982845, 0.028662685304880142, 0.032534483820199966, 0.008393825963139534, -0.004815239459276199, -0.016895471140742302, 0.015341958962380886, -0.09597725421190262, 0.005415067076683044, -0.05649775266647339, 0.04576664790511131, -0.032840073108673096, -0.001167566399089992 ]
<p>With respect to post <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/7977/how-to-generate-uniformly-distributed-points-on-the-surface-of-the-3-d-unit-sphe">(1)</a> and post <a href="http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/87230/picking-random-points-in-the-volume-of-sphere-with-uniform-probability">(2)</a>, I generated a large number of uniformly distributed points inside the ball of radius $R$ using $\frac{R_s U^{1/3}}{\sqrt{X_1^2 + X_2^2 + X_3^2}} (X_1, X_2, X_3)$, where $U$ is uniformly distributed between 0 and 1, and $X_1, X_2, X_3$ are independent normal random variables with mean 0 and variance 1. The following figure shows a uniform spherical distribution obtained by this method using 10000 independent draws in a sphere of radius 10. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/kzBDU.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>By computing the nearest neighbour distance $d_i$ of every point, I observed that the diagnostic plot of nearest neighbour distances does not follow a uniform distribution. Does this non-uniform distribution mean that one can cluster the points? Does it mean points dont have spatial randomness? If so, then how can I generate random points with uniform nearest neighbour distances.</p> <hr> <p>Temporary images for @Anony-Mousse consideration: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/txV1K.png" alt="enter image description here"> <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/1wLfB.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
73,615
[ -0.05068003013730049, -0.01564100570976734, 0.009395536966621876, -0.045503757894039154, 0.019254939630627632, -0.02428453043103218, -0.036723628640174866, -0.029231149703264236, -0.00000962465946940938, -0.07821828871965408, 0.041519563645124435, 0.031229114159941673, 0.07137306779623032, 0.05680680647492409, 0.001955928048118949, -0.012947237119078636, -0.01808779314160347, -0.00009676787885837257, -0.015428821556270123, -0.043341685086488724, 0.023252028971910477, 0.025515634566545486, 0.018082736060023308, -0.037034306675195694, -0.034368786960840225, 0.02328045479953289, 0.013982138596475124, -0.015834935009479523, 0.011457385495305061, 0.05178428068757057, -0.04564495012164116, -0.0024427869357168674, 0.03204099461436272, 0.023824632167816162, 0.0017056989017874002, 0.009578242897987366, -0.01627200096845627, -0.020929520949721336, -0.0007844990468584001, -0.008608744479715824, -0.04541650786995888, -0.03249238431453705, -0.020244359970092773, 0.050313305109739304, -0.006669382099062204, 0.016084130853414536, 0.01066537480801344, -0.047398269176483154, 0.019377270713448524, -0.040172029286623, 0.07400267571210861, 0.029865406453609467, 0.023710180073976517, 0.03181050717830658, -0.02026083692908287, -0.014433558098971844, 0.03584127128124237, 0.088884137570858, -0.04864762723445892, -0.03202409669756889, 0.010766960680484772, -0.03765805438160896, 0.009091801941394806, -0.017151812091469765, -0.030935565009713173, 0.03263137489557266, -0.007535671815276146, -0.012733954936265945, 0.030915962532162666, -0.031236756592988968, 0.02442515455186367, 0.022865083068609238, 0.029133623465895653, -0.04278560355305672, 0.0010414893040433526, 0.02465805411338806, 0.017690550535917282, -0.01630478724837303, 0.04712093621492386, 0.02031497284770012, 0.00714603066444397, 0.00882522203028202, 0.042838096618652344, -0.0033504783641546965, 0.015133542008697987, 0.010426439344882965, 0.052700258791446686, -0.020811287686228752, 0.01792186312377453, 0.030896566808223724, 0.0045751892030239105, -0.013722279109060764, 0.03017246350646019, -0.01174668874591589, -0.0327896811068058, 0.039701372385025024, -0.028519466519355774, 0.05406942963600159, -0.024597151204943657, -0.022287383675575256, -0.006586133502423763, -0.04881395772099495, 0.05978299304842949, 0.04210565239191055, -0.022322768345475197, -0.03270728141069412, -0.03922155126929283, 0.020153822377324104, -0.013302603736519814, 0.018138045445084572, -0.02583952061831951, 0.04001941531896591, 0.012885913252830505, -0.029065389186143875, 0.04021124169230461, -0.0054116398096084595, 0.004514325875788927, -0.00011236052523599938, 0.02295790985226631, 0.0353119894862175, 0.022941017523407936, -0.013371823355555534, 0.024746868759393692, -0.07087838649749756, -0.03684470057487488, 0.035446882247924805, 0.042857494205236435, -0.009429387748241425, -0.026453237980604172, 0.01577683724462986, -0.02009413205087185, 0.01429565530270338, 0.029368383809924126, 0.01168376300483942, 0.03949267789721489, -0.007789365481585264, -0.07983653247356415, -0.04020388796925545, 0.06030089035630226, 0.0002810718142427504, 0.006420579273253679, -0.05739974603056908, -0.02324008382856846, 0.030224451795220375, 0.02046169713139534, 0.012166019529104233, 0.022647004574537277, -0.01791401579976082, 0.07421277463436127, 0.003762845415621996, -0.021384024992585182, 0.0072966450825333595, -0.039206214249134064, -0.07390334457159042, -0.007142919115722179, -0.06887675821781158, 0.0568329319357872, 0.027066033333539963, 0.021257199347019196, -0.028717419132590294, 0.05457218736410141, 0.010718311183154583, 0.02597922831773758, -0.011775195598602295, 0.009579108096659184, -0.0002124891325365752, 0.08821370452642441, 0.022155212238430977, 0.015880873426795006, 0.036174725741147995, -0.03745999187231064, 0.0504048615694046, 0.007593718357384205, 0.018457025289535522, 0.04313847795128822, -0.015491776168346405, 0.006641201674938202, 0.009312650188803673, 0.026500144973397255, 0.010251217521727085, -0.0294968094676733, 0.01608513481914997, 0.011189167387783527, -0.012011373415589333, -0.00054873654153198, 0.030682293698191643, -0.0026506944559514523, -0.01969616301357746, 0.02739071473479271, -0.029347466304898262, -0.017187360674142838, -0.05516161024570465, 0.01658572256565094, 0.017258813604712486, -0.028586458414793015, 0.05149809271097183, 0.002870992524549365, -0.0000710486710886471, 0.02527269348502159, -0.04240505024790764, -0.03854716569185257, 0.006742638535797596, 0.05099363625049591, -0.014814370311796665, 0.005336372647434473, 0.07414009422063828, 0.028201874345541, -0.02190127968788147, 0.02688538283109665, -0.02359955944120884, -0.04405764862895012, 0.0023052243050187826, -0.007428141310811043, 0.034446824342012405, 0.00016499026969540864, 0.005964371375739574, 0.019556839019060135, 0.06075820326805115, -0.02572127804160118, 0.01799997314810753, -0.04537004977464676, 0.06336531043052673, 0.056647609919309616, 0.0261131189763546, -0.020454207435250282, 0.01426228042691946, 0.015951007604599, 0.00158263451885432, 0.01272045448422432, -0.0299635361880064, -0.07087355107069016, -0.016717758029699326, 0.06158104166388512, 0.04374948516488075, -0.04550344496965408, 0.0029405122622847557, 0.025969907641410828, 0.04437576234340668, 0.014554373919963837, -0.0035262545570731163, -0.0019335807301104069, -0.02370976097881794, 0.011945860460400581, 0.021427631378173828, 0.00775536336004734, -0.021489664912223816, -0.010599219240248203, -0.0012272247113287449, 0.019731992855668068, 0.006946523208171129, -0.001084818271920085, 0.04368629679083824, -0.03498180955648422, -0.011164764873683453, -0.008140971884131432, 0.028598828241229057, 0.02194872871041298, 0.006742832250893116, -0.02835102751851082, 0.03120332397520542, 0.03448794037103653, -0.0011184299364686012, -0.0004912294098176062, -0.026831530034542084, 0.03068212978541851, 0.03765038400888443, -0.040991879999637604, -0.0019972596783190966, 0.0072715552523732185, -0.0344403013586998, -0.006158811505883932, -0.011494367383420467, -0.03409532457590103, -0.02327910251915455, 0.020571157336235046, 0.019597312435507774, 0.009163441136479378, -0.0211274903267622, -0.019112639129161835, -0.017375223338603973, -0.0024353114422410727, 0.006641754414886236, -0.007632930297404528, 0.021397698670625687, -0.06264947354793549, -0.020715229213237762, -0.0250778179615736, 0.029802192002534866, -0.006373425479978323, -0.02495950646698475, -0.013043024577200413, 0.010668277740478516, -0.000977695221081376, -0.044241197407245636, -0.021487915888428688, -0.034052152186632156, 0.03960955888032913, -0.021541453897953033, -0.011929054744541645, 0.04674641415476799, 0.005632073152810335, -0.04240337759256363, 0.044193241745233536, -0.041522733867168427, -0.04986933618783951, -0.01932203210890293, 0.00852190051227808, 0.06151781976222992, -0.05333128198981285, 0.013489902950823307, 0.034648433327674866, -0.040737394243478775, -0.009927337057888508, -0.06558888405561447, -0.08317024260759354, 0.011534427292644978, -0.02198297716677189, 0.06353596597909927, -0.02171868085861206, -0.03858255594968796, 0.04737561196088791, 0.014705812558531761, -0.03982860967516899, -0.003926557023078203, 0.009294269606471062, -0.04302109405398369, -0.014065654948353767, -0.022442763671278954, -0.0014207985950633883, 0.010321253910660744, 0.0231314804404974, 0.056325607001781464, 0.03399727866053581, 0.061769355088472366, -0.007273704279214144, -0.011307872831821442, 0.0008559513953514397, -0.009507501497864723, -0.046910401433706284, 0.03778931871056557, -0.0010828456142917275, -0.06389591097831726, -0.005693347193300724, -0.016084983944892883, 0.018936850130558014, 0.028395794332027435, -0.04205543175339699, 0.02648809179663658, -0.03467712551355362, 0.037101760506629944, -0.03411424905061722, 0.02797497622668743, 0.0030667290557175875, -0.04669211804866791, 0.004052313975989819, 0.02096005342900753, 0.0443863607943058, -0.010898065753281116, -0.003288891166448593, 0.025496339425444603, 0.052876051515340805, 0.007339837029576302, 0.009402488358318806, -0.01046166941523552, -0.004388747736811638, 0.02455543354153633, 0.00594601035118103, 0.003294359426945448, 0.019889146089553833, 0.032217904925346375, 0.01399263646453619, 0.0017406163970008492, -0.035421740263700485, 0.0006096619763411582, -0.03645845130085945, 0.01686081662774086, -0.06003623083233833, 0.03520297631621361, -0.005513823591172695, 0.012784813530743122, 0.01417833287268877, -0.04929983988404274, -0.0029656519182026386, 0.006047426722943783, -0.04901953041553497, 0.018053965643048286, -0.011729391291737556, -0.018444890156388283, -0.007336357608437538, -0.04662508890032768, 0.01810489594936371, 0.011272076517343521, 0.009313739836215973, 0.01893562637269497, 0.03556589409708977, -0.07516973465681076, -0.006282809190452099, -0.02001485787332058, -0.02916901372373104, -0.030837466940283775, 0.036930762231349945, 0.008718276396393776, -0.027239641174674034, 0.038024403154850006, 0.03308633714914322, -0.009634699672460556, -0.007336599286645651, 0.01446410734206438, 0.01796768419444561, -0.002641647821292281, 0.007443362381309271, -0.0007487297407351434, 0.020927472040057182, 0.006919162813574076, 0.00654279300943017, -0.0034591839648783207, 0.07068454474210739, 0.038099247962236404, -0.01766376756131649, -0.017582399770617485, -0.06671011447906494, -0.02369694411754608, 0.02675570361316204, 0.03705917298793793, -0.02655971236526966, 0.012899516150355339, 0.04332856088876724, -0.01811046525835991, -0.03246184438467026, 0.013030411675572395, 0.05898016318678856, -0.008027066476643085, -0.029949769377708435, -0.029187334701418877, -0.03156409040093422, 0.028881428763270378, -0.020334819331765175, 0.06434183567762375, -0.0034567355178296566, -0.0068436008878052235, 0.007996616885066032, 0.0426192469894886, -0.006319536827504635, -0.014266444370150566, -0.03841676935553551, 0.006170399487018585, 0.03663785755634308, -0.006220999639481306, -0.01843865029513836, 0.0069909775629639626, -0.004118696786463261, 0.05106800049543381, 0.034818798303604126, -0.032715506851673126, -0.05854867398738861, -0.0010673009091988206, 0.03826148062944412, 0.03247513249516487, -0.012951626442372799, 0.01784057728946209, -0.07384899258613586, 0.027344705536961555, 0.05965374410152435, -0.04738733544945717, 0.02232636697590351, -0.005011484492570162, -0.011422601528465748, -0.008012065663933754, -0.030562231317162514, -0.04698540270328522, 0.004785027354955673, 0.004464651923626661, 0.04606384038925171, -0.041683800518512726, 0.0007335392874665558, -0.03411493077874184, 0.015182535164058208, 0.005114220082759857, 0.084095299243927, -0.016618551686406136, -0.009284835308790207, -0.0018666846444830298, 0.002937267767265439, 0.0031832861714065075, -0.053673550486564636, 0.02230382338166237, 0.04247863218188286, -0.035110779106616974, 0.052895061671733856, -0.06319376826286316, -0.0431058444082737, 0.013292452320456505, 0.0060941306874156, 0.024046344682574272, 0.02836298756301403, -0.015338347293436527, 0.05708885192871094, 0.029113292694091797, 0.018526582047343254, 0.0639004111289978, 0.02900090627372265, 0.04585963860154152, -0.016283230856060982, -0.04966042935848236, 0.016845135018229485, -0.03486701846122742, -0.014074325561523438, -0.010867303237318993, -0.0031265297438949347, -0.014625024050474167, 0.019901275634765625, 0.005848337430506945, -0.010367067530751228, -0.050668612122535706, -0.052645545452833176, 0.0011007556458935142, 0.030045805498957634, 0.03427470847964287, 0.05191276594996452, -0.011149187572300434, 0.012434394098818302, 0.016729990020394325, -0.010437622666358948, 0.0003272725152783096, 0.0015047136694192886, 0.034022241830825806, 0.0011178849963471293, -0.004543189890682697, -0.006499998737126589, -0.027348414063453674, 0.02803964540362358, 0.00991310365498066, -0.06606899946928024, 0.059746675193309784, 0.008042915724217892, 0.02988843247294426, 0.02854626253247261, -0.056287068873643875, 0.0034936179872602224, -0.011477750726044178, -0.0068341707810759544, 0.04836995527148247, -0.02394367754459381, 0.028745165094733238, -0.02029269188642502, 0.030684513971209526, -0.07838129997253418, -0.02973751164972782, 0.027463337406516075, 0.006987894419580698, -0.009903018362820148, -0.04162992909550667, -0.02046472206711769, -0.01593252830207348, -0.015347530134022236, -0.01681739091873169, 0.05763596296310425, -0.02571594901382923, -0.05590745806694031, 0.005814895033836365, 0.039356425404548645, 0.07869931310415268, -0.03015061281621456, -0.0037614447064697742, 0.04350344091653824, 0.0168917216360569, 0.017951080575585365, -0.015694931149482727, 0.06142352148890495, -0.04236948862671852, -0.03178881108760834, -0.03510040044784546, -0.013812577351927757, 0.0348033681511879, -0.048161767423152924, -0.050898049026727676, 0.01126178726553917, -0.0024397065863013268, 0.012940309010446072, -0.004967190325260162, 0.005202428437769413, -0.010365800932049751, -0.03236711397767067, -0.06894537806510925, 0.009422872215509415, 0.003146436531096697, 0.01744961552321911, 0.04273822903633118, 0.0021006527822464705, 0.006015429738909006, 0.015401200391352177, 0.03504323586821556, 0.020295972004532814, 0.008495972491800785, -0.00868242233991623, 0.006319593638181686, 0.01910199597477913, 0.0046259318478405476, -0.00946107693016529, 0.012762690894305706, 0.022768883034586906, -0.013221624307334423, -0.012154034338891506, -0.06304176896810532, 0.020006919279694557, 0.06379867345094681, -0.017314482480287552, 0.03593042865395546, 0.08099585771560669, 0.004116416443139315, 0.0056869154796004295, -0.04268020763993263, -0.004553968086838722, -0.045166607946157455, 0.013751015067100525, 0.03651027753949165, -0.0211335439234972, 0.024765530601143837, 0.005094626452773809, 0.03420904651284218, -0.003600161289796233, 0.03883766382932663, -0.001000458956696093, 0.0162346251308918, 0.024384984746575356, -0.028993656858801842, -0.03720363229513168, 0.017203647643327713, -0.05461809039115906, 0.036287516355514526, 0.018561750650405884, -0.025564540177583694, 0.031044190749526024, 0.0019320138962939382, -0.004061335697770119, 0.005309826694428921, -0.012864003889262676, -0.04598955437541008, 0.013331398367881775, 0.0016625885618850589, -0.0016501180361956358, 0.004180135205388069, -0.02192920260131359, 0.0066234758123755455, 0.015483482740819454, 0.0056162127293646336, -0.031985849142074585, -0.06314711272716522, -0.027529574930667877, -0.026107868179678917, -0.05273562669754028, 0.025579605251550674, 0.016596779227256775, -0.05417722091078758, 0.03480946272611618, -0.034004803746938705, 0.03736204281449318, -0.003797645913437009, 0.005239573772996664, -0.038487546145915985, 0.08429083228111267, 0.01651715487241745, 0.04157974570989609, -0.01730070635676384, -0.0009546048240736127, 0.11335474252700806, 0.023718660697340965, 0.01750274747610092, -0.05006282031536102, 0.015289473347365856, -0.011657040566205978, -0.007228660397231579, -0.024545514956116676, -0.020542239770293236, -0.021192047744989395, -0.020027901977300644, 0.0367228165268898, 0.05430370941758156, -0.026367930695414543, 0.02741781808435917, 0.05221129581332207, -0.04392368346452713, -0.05046309158205986, 0.009383105672895908, 0.0058163972571492195, 0.020143933594226837, -0.00007635315705556422, -0.023065466433763504, 0.031492143869400024, 0.006165866274386644, -0.013791114091873169, -0.036221444606781006, -0.02879014052450657, 0.017498943954706192, 0.03310011699795723, -0.02001054212450981, 0.010573344305157661, 0.016244402155280113, -0.023508314043283463, -0.012238123454153538, 0.004032019525766373, 0.02150498516857624, -0.05841807276010513, 0.023101313039660454, 0.03530498966574669, -0.0077002691105008125, 0.0033724242821335793, 0.012753752060234547, -0.010690180584788322, -0.05417075753211975, -0.020786115899682045, -0.02332240343093872, 0.04738321900367737, -0.04255058988928795, 0.0005164911272004247, -0.027618292719125748, 0.01811179146170616, 0.006628596689552069, -0.043575312942266464, 0.012714309617877007, -0.011268393136560917, 0.05801745131611824, -0.005525520537048578, -0.05098378658294678, -0.009171782061457634, 0.021712373942136765, -0.015843592584133148, 0.039790522307157516, 0.004772894084453583, -0.011801323853433132, -0.013277209363877773, 0.002919023158028722, 0.03961212933063507, 0.005732233636081219, 0.004539703484624624, -0.05912613496184349, 0.013928794302046299, -0.014304141514003277, -0.0002640536695253104, -0.008686205372214317, 0.011543842032551765, 0.07165685296058655, 0.02366805262863636, 0.012761342339217663, 0.02259003557264805, -0.06181929260492325, 0.00430868798866868, -0.045628804713487625, -0.02069867216050625, -0.03995222598314285, 0.008639920502901077, 0.016277074813842773, 0.044978465884923935, 0.04853314161300659, -0.0005944879376329482, -0.016300203278660774, 0.05453066527843475, -0.011487969197332859, 0.000011434752195782494, -0.007273449562489986, 0.009152108803391457, -0.044278260320425034, 0.013633515685796738, -0.015706509351730347, 0.021975597366690636, 0.029198452830314636, 0.008234009146690369, 0.02351202815771103, 0.03109651617705822, -0.001850818400271237, 0.010220181196928024, -0.008340300992131233, -0.06568527221679688, 0.013452821411192417, 0.015615386888384819, -0.040272098034620285, -0.03719780221581459, -0.027452655136585236, 0.00022764228924643248, -0.043358054012060165, 0.01028690580278635, -0.025421930477023125, -0.007564474828541279, -0.033935390412807465, -0.032416265457868576, 0.0012834385270252824, -0.023447640240192413, -0.0076264808885753155, 0.0009622577344998717, -0.006955661345273256, -0.03694403916597366, -0.010096672922372818, -0.001783474232070148, 0.020732218399643898, 0.014903184026479721, 0.02002282626926899, 0.03764811530709267, 0.015584885142743587, 0.015097065828740597, -0.0005138657870702446, -0.022462772205471992, -0.005332547705620527, 0.06188780814409256, -0.048562657088041306, -0.055707912892103195, 0.020503196865320206, -0.037985432893037796, -0.06476554274559021, -0.004206853918731213, 0.0011193436803296208, 0.02465510554611683, 0.024882391095161438, -0.004008939024060965, -0.02867681346833706, 0.07945851236581802, -0.04022713378071785, 0.000526153133250773, 0.00885613914579153, 0.0126716997474432, 0.010712732560932636, -0.00013980729272589087, 0.01359512284398079, -0.0009829993359744549, -0.009751738980412483, 0.018305577337741852, 0.03307895362377167, -0.02250080555677414, 0.017777709290385246, 0.033537670969963074, -0.022987540811300278, 0.0055724093690514565, -0.00141730229370296, 0.021116359159350395, 0.07123163342475891, 0.06785375624895096, -0.061056219041347504, 0.05008872225880623, -0.020117338746786118, -0.005339077208191156, -0.10002105683088303, -0.025375092402100563, 0.014778189361095428, -0.010103214532136917, 0.007448423653841019, -0.06327471882104874, -0.016150623559951782, 0.04424440488219261, -0.08231444656848907, 0.03625034913420677, -0.01624029316008091, -0.01650744117796421, -0.06594771146774292, 0.021769871935248375, -0.014735420234501362, -0.00764601631090045, 0.013223368674516678, 0.047796737402677536, 0.01121512707322836, 0.06049445644021034, -0.017473632469773293, 0.00048290492850355804, -0.0132374819368124, 0.028927713632583618, -0.009914605878293514, -0.02280311845242977, 0.026051854714751244, -0.005130462814122438, 0.003666413016617298, -0.002177596790716052, -0.033588867634534836, -0.01609545387327671, 0.02182045392692089, -0.013047258369624615, -0.01592010259628296, 0.01807270385324955, 0.05406814441084862, 0.01246008649468422, -0.003080007154494524, -0.008875716477632523, 0.02884589694440365, 0.010442502796649933, -0.0038158337119966745, 0.013498641550540924, 0.019113831222057343, -0.012052697129547596, -0.025363683700561523, 0.04358053579926491, -0.02003617025911808, -0.018152929842472076, 0.02890622988343239, 0.013458295725286007, 0.00798545777797699, -0.0183007400482893, 0.018085552379488945, -0.03426976129412651, -0.019821951165795326, 0.04463493451476097, 0.01349723618477583, 0.009681511670351028, -0.0002596761332824826, -0.03192930668592453, -0.05717868357896805, -0.02078726328909397, -0.022723307833075523, -0.016039015725255013, -0.06767842918634415, -0.011930884793400764, 0.007892947643995285, -0.006109965033829212, 0.0007005587685853243, -0.021273786202073097, -0.0012200424680486321, 0.05104949325323105, 0.023217733949422836, 0.006652908865362406, 0.011619273573160172, -0.010399772785604, -0.05337074398994446, -0.08255918323993683, 0.044646043330430984, 0.0000796044259914197, -0.015129689127206802, -0.060125675052404404, 0.004588741809129715, -0.034101054072380066, 0.03153834119439125, 0.03620997071266174, 0.01811547391116619, 0.046346407383680344, 0.020818516612052917, 0.021065998822450638, 0.05557870864868164, -0.03794479742646217, 0.033387359231710434, -0.016262393444776535, 0.008421880193054676, 0.0024490386713296175, -0.024880845099687576, -0.0004737837007269263, 0.025301586836576462, 0.04288472980260849, -0.03137725219130516, -0.021992739289999008, -0.012197403237223625, -0.000403672136599198, 0.029551982879638672, 0.004250895697623491, 0.007117385510355234, 0.046807657927274704, 0.011686353944242, -0.012016689404845238, 0.028151657432317734, 0.01125380676239729, -0.004927470814436674, 0.019568761810660362, -0.027887631207704544, -0.06054176762700081, -0.020655546337366104, -0.010961025953292847, 0.014041883870959282, -0.043955184519290924, -0.01998257264494896, 0.023199068382382393, -0.047819457948207855, -0.011265527456998825, 0.01196692232042551, 0.021593542769551277, 0.01683766581118107, 0.0248885340988636, -0.002235002350062132, 0.013050947338342667, 0.002731878776103258, 0.04058898240327835, 0.011460484005510807, 0.042537711560726166, -0.01842835545539856, -0.0332077331840992, 0.007361328694969416, -0.018226614221930504, 0.04923931136727333, 0.008795253001153469, 0.07519755512475967, 0.006568191573023796, -0.026848377659916878, 0.0027732900343835354, -0.014305169694125652, 0.021951226517558098, 0.023048752918839455, -0.004187284968793392, 0.07746962457895279, 0.007496279664337635, -0.017808320000767708, -0.036669135093688965, -0.06161890923976898, -0.009637517854571342, 0.014477889984846115, 0.005389698781073093, 0.04051656648516655, -0.015511256642639637, -0.02186853624880314, -0.005587852094322443, 0.019133612513542175, 0.04174413904547691, -0.023676913231611252, 0.020799361169338226, -0.0018184188520535827, 0.039620887488126755, -0.00995925534516573, -0.02051829919219017, 0.02570256032049656, -0.004840000532567501, 0.02590232901275158, 0.02333836257457733, 0.03017021343111992, -0.014058457687497139, -0.014809386804699898, -0.019966019317507744, 0.05300288647413254, -0.05002867057919502, -0.030131788924336433, -0.030824312940239906, 0.0005108345649205148, -0.0030361837707459927, -0.024549731984734535 ]
<p>For example, the standard deviation is known to have bias that depends on the number of samples observed. If I wanted to do Bayesian inference on the SD of samples from two populations, and have unequal sample sizes from each, would the resulting inference take this bias into account?</p> <p>(Yes, I'm aware that the bias in the standard deviation doesn't really manifest discernibly unless you have very small N, but I'm more interested in the theoretical question. Plus, I do have hierarchical data with lots of units of observation, but few observations within each unit and a systematic bias for more observations in one particular experimental condition than another, causing me trepidation in my desired analysis of the SD within each level of unit-crossed-with-condition.)</p>
25,055
[ -0.05931081250309944, -0.010916282422840595, 0.008784775622189045, 0.014414789155125618, 0.03738988935947418, 0.027399776503443718, -0.004263375885784626, -0.031069356948137283, 0.023246364668011665, -0.059075307101011276, 0.0462215431034565, 0.027462102472782135, 0.061746176332235336, 0.02098231390118599, 0.04463263973593712, 0.016759242862462997, -0.013144324533641338, 0.019846629351377487, 0.0008872838225215673, -0.06558306515216827, -0.005810412112623453, 0.01525882538408041, 0.02040993794798851, -0.03128881752490997, -0.027205606922507286, 0.04599327966570854, 0.035682979971170425, -0.031178399920463562, 0.017780890688300133, 0.027267957106232643, -0.009834008291363716, -0.014520206488668919, 0.009669983759522438, 0.0702848955988884, 0.025328200310468674, -0.03609617054462433, -0.015146322548389435, -0.04876654967665672, -0.026205353438854218, 0.03740537166595459, -0.07159817963838577, -0.005707507487386465, -0.013830372132360935, -0.002862408058717847, -0.02111200802028179, 0.018449652940034866, 0.018401842564344406, -0.050380632281303406, 0.035038869827985764, -0.03254017233848572, 0.05853632837533951, -0.007601462304592133, 0.04087168723344803, 0.04633597284555435, -0.041961297392845154, -0.01532832346856594, 0.05715645104646683, 0.0547826886177063, -0.003929613158106804, -0.027337100356817245, -0.03304658457636833, -0.01592525653541088, -0.005672689527273178, -0.01994512788951397, -0.044198136776685715, 0.014622625894844532, 0.0012650055577978492, -0.0427490696310997, -0.01708444021642208, -0.009633153676986694, 0.04050643742084503, 0.0077711972407996655, 0.027061287313699722, 0.0009609849075786769, 0.013706938363611698, -0.01992754638195038, 0.025320054963231087, 0.03593657538294792, 0.03671638295054436, 0.018240658566355705, -0.0029749474488198757, -0.004262691829353571, 0.04785623028874397, 0.03867855295538902, 0.016415899619460106, -0.023174315690994263, 0.04911249503493309, -0.03988301381468773, 0.005603406112641096, -0.005908950697630644, -0.03522777184844017, -0.0062338863499462605, 0.07923662662506104, -0.008872881531715393, -0.05439947545528412, 0.028720054775476456, -0.010005546733736992, 0.039082493633031845, -0.02979123964905739, 0.0015263373497873545, -0.03095163218677044, -0.045216307044029236, 0.02114318683743477, 0.07759234309196472, -0.01628801040351391, -0.02767542190849781, 0.01591010019183159, 0.02794954739511013, -0.03213592991232872, 0.0143715376034379, -0.02070917934179306, 0.011000201106071472, -0.0024634397123008966, 0.004829618148505688, 0.030637864023447037, 0.01495357882231474, -0.004650735296308994, -0.03500726819038391, 0.07636348903179169, 0.06739888340234756, 0.06552446633577347, -0.033097557723522186, 0.03974214568734169, -0.0202214103192091, -0.07715222984552383, 0.034192681312561035, 0.0007100951042957604, -0.038668010383844376, -0.04104026407003403, 0.03441134840250015, 0.022768942639231682, -0.029743364080786705, 0.03826167434453964, -0.009366647340357304, 0.012947130016982555, -0.003999486565589905, -0.07904978096485138, -0.05550786107778549, 0.016286320984363556, 0.013827023096382618, -0.010310489684343338, -0.06332336366176605, 0.00241941143758595, 0.036701757460832596, 0.017819734290242195, -0.007692640647292137, 0.0498131588101387, -0.007343320641666651, 0.03013317659497261, 0.0296702329069376, -0.007211627438664436, 0.007139543537050486, 0.0010085990652441978, 0.02494744583964348, -0.027339715510606766, -0.09938233345746994, 0.01821589097380638, -0.002315005986019969, 0.001784282736480236, 0.0028045030776411295, 0.02847748063504696, -0.007579307071864605, 0.011367576196789742, -0.005807576701045036, 0.04175567999482155, -0.017031658440828323, 0.09199997782707214, -0.0023360277991741896, 0.027441726997494698, 0.011797590181231499, 0.012939605861902237, 0.006978390738368034, 0.014980881474912167, 0.058854106813669205, 0.05026478320360184, -0.018437441438436508, 0.008440272882580757, 0.012181825004518032, 0.030837127938866615, -0.008273022249341011, -0.015579327940940857, -0.01548265665769577, -0.011989514343440533, -0.047517985105514526, 0.004931390751153231, 0.027506668120622635, 0.009293824434280396, 0.0010236036032438278, 0.00836537778377533, -0.0467558316886425, -0.04165315255522728, -0.08653578162193298, -0.032173797488212585, 0.0006639279308728874, -0.0536072701215744, 0.06994566321372986, -0.010799230076372623, 0.02010095864534378, -0.05519785359501839, -0.051723871380090714, -0.039862144738435745, -0.010298597626388073, 0.029792511835694313, -0.044018346816301346, 0.006765290629118681, 0.032223060727119446, 0.05584448203444481, -0.004298990126699209, 0.061341021209955215, -0.025461958721280098, -0.05954786762595177, 0.0034848947543650866, -0.04318588972091675, 0.026568710803985596, 0.00491742417216301, 0.00020576907263603061, 0.0021330751478672028, -0.02746141143143177, -0.013948415406048298, 0.08516925573348999, -0.04727662354707718, 0.08010939508676529, 0.07111317664384842, -0.0003372086212038994, 0.014856790192425251, 0.06756465137004852, 0.0269610732793808, 0.0074345688335597515, -0.0322960689663887, -0.014497141353785992, -0.07522837072610855, -0.007943637669086456, 0.013767361640930176, 0.00024680205387994647, 0.0032534480560570955, 0.0038099889643490314, 0.015666771680116653, 0.017882388085126877, -0.00040479161543771625, 0.00044236209942027926, 0.008085579611361027, -0.030506091192364693, -0.013425135985016823, 0.008141109719872475, 0.037844061851501465, 0.03082975186407566, 0.020232917740941048, -0.0011430189479142427, 0.04748988151550293, -0.025174910202622414, -0.0008539649425074458, 0.028163600713014603, -0.009525199420750141, 0.025772053748369217, -0.013379128649830818, -0.037637654691934586, 0.01934758573770523, -0.016561733558773994, 0.019205577671527863, 0.020178427919745445, 0.0095992311835289, -0.028714176267385483, 0.00857801828533411, -0.005303721409291029, 0.041809070855379105, 0.01293279230594635, -0.019101910293102264, 0.022193845361471176, 0.03421155363321304, -0.039956748485565186, 0.005907799582928419, 0.01009254902601242, -0.02866891399025917, 0.0004038609331473708, -0.01692613959312439, 0.016289804130792618, -0.017419666051864624, 0.041585810482501984, -0.01880582980811596, -0.0380672924220562, -0.005221555009484291, -0.005658457055687904, 0.013242845423519611, -0.02592899464070797, -0.06108878552913666, 0.03403415158390999, -0.009817350655794144, -0.040408264845609665, 0.0018206611275672913, -0.0197670366615057, 0.00468401936814189, 0.042674023658037186, 0.0150859160348773, -0.0265339408069849, -0.028457747772336006, -0.0041365292854607105, -0.016044501215219498, -0.011752044782042503, -0.029121993109583855, 0.03603394329547882, 0.04171832650899887, -0.026327285915613174, 0.017685597762465477, -0.02309015579521656, -0.04014996066689491, -0.03324371203780174, -0.0006728844018653035, -0.005509063135832548, 0.013107453472912312, 0.019956570118665695, 0.04196124151349068, -0.022603001445531845, -0.012185096740722656, -0.04660285636782646, -0.08361034840345383, 0.03122883103787899, 0.02466835454106331, 0.049247950315475464, 0.011983796022832394, 0.008787528611719608, 0.062243714928627014, 0.02138233184814453, 0.008177059702575207, 0.010292927734553814, -0.0009888354688882828, -0.018412165343761444, 0.015538306906819344, 0.022116029635071754, -0.0053403181955218315, -0.02613622322678566, 0.014429902657866478, 0.020083103328943253, 0.022483116015791893, 0.006724397651851177, 0.001882040873169899, 0.003404597518965602, 0.00862834881991148, -0.010541162453591824, -0.01735931634902954, 0.015626363456249237, 0.023817244917154312, -0.013404535129666328, -0.00039414121420122683, -0.009380207397043705, 0.037000492215156555, 0.0034931041300296783, -0.018769411370158195, 0.009316766634583473, 0.01489884965121746, 0.025734756141901016, -0.061188846826553345, 0.042969152331352234, 0.037129957228899, -0.024407515302300453, -0.008380233310163021, 0.026496615260839462, 0.017332768067717552, -0.033056508749723434, 0.008302497677505016, 0.07216760516166687, 0.039140306413173676, -0.01394337322562933, -0.031146066263318062, -0.00389061844907701, 0.019558830186724663, 0.010800733231008053, -0.02180509641766548, -0.03429572284221649, 0.013264133594930172, 0.03947305306792259, 0.014590179547667503, -0.010827572084963322, -0.06237148866057396, 0.031853340566158295, -0.06788824498653412, -0.005899916868656874, -0.04272262752056122, 0.04286301136016846, -0.012202120386064053, 0.026352740824222565, -0.011026730760931969, 0.002215390093624592, -0.008980032987892628, -0.00109779869671911, -0.04427531734108925, 0.02245796099305153, -0.03706483542919159, -0.038029950112104416, -0.004158880095928907, -0.04643890634179115, 0.040750350803136826, -0.021081959828734398, 0.026168780401349068, 0.0018483406165614724, 0.013353043235838413, -0.010956131853163242, -0.0011590620269998908, -0.06292906403541565, -0.015467728488147259, 0.01297491230070591, 0.024897396564483643, 0.008263248018920422, -0.025514446198940277, 0.00923056248575449, 0.013836528174579144, -0.027735039591789246, -0.008642674423754215, -0.03829820081591606, 0.057356320321559906, 0.005729956552386284, 0.036579012870788574, 0.024798013269901276, 0.023504633456468582, -0.048987459391355515, 0.03853609040379524, 0.01932668685913086, 0.06607142835855484, 0.04140007868409157, -0.0312200840562582, -0.004432006739079952, -0.03412165865302086, -0.03410084545612335, 0.03613301366567612, 0.02316245064139366, 0.005495711695402861, -0.03668152168393135, 0.0361173190176487, 0.016757911071181297, -0.0731220692396164, 0.024935340508818626, 0.046919792890548706, 0.006780078634619713, 0.013457562774419785, -0.048932600766420364, -0.015325149521231651, -0.015237964689731598, -0.015624812804162502, 0.014722657389938831, 0.037265341728925705, -0.020253079012036324, 0.003475733334198594, 0.02116364985704422, 0.0069579752162098885, -0.042389024049043655, 0.01743626780807972, 0.01725596748292446, 0.06214848533272743, 0.03733881562948227, -0.044943444430828094, 0.039116907864809036, 0.030473293736577034, 0.029141705483198166, 0.025086605921387672, 0.02563975751399994, -0.08495121449232101, 0.01835216023027897, 0.02650601789355278, 0.01026525255292654, -0.04135982692241669, 0.020072907209396362, -0.03657754510641098, -0.002542247762903571, 0.037256840616464615, -0.002992803929373622, 0.008588653989136219, -0.032952338457107544, 0.02349790930747986, -0.007217968814074993, -0.028348488733172417, -0.04525670409202576, 0.013046372681856155, -0.021468084305524826, 0.024668250232934952, -0.01926560513675213, -0.00774470204487443, -0.015743888914585114, 0.00494422996416688, 0.03025628812611103, 0.053408797830343246, -0.03604589030146599, -0.022684160619974136, 0.005212073680013418, 0.02166035957634449, -0.013620560988783836, -0.08793238550424576, 0.022711453959345818, -0.005519841331988573, -0.004503103904426098, 0.03639420494437218, -0.026670999825000763, -0.05130951479077339, 0.04931558668613434, -0.010207260958850384, -0.03223031014204025, 0.0035162484273314476, 0.006870340555906296, 0.05177956074476242, 0.027541019022464752, 0.03856901824474335, 0.06391581147909164, -0.006532842293381691, 0.018128223717212677, 0.010908466763794422, -0.006656769663095474, 0.04368976503610611, -0.05860061198472977, 0.0018770216265693307, -0.04549343138933182, -0.002757415408268571, -0.012922690249979496, 0.033439941704273224, 0.01956895738840103, 0.056541841477155685, 0.01502898521721363, -0.03823894262313843, 0.014449008740484715, 0.015321445651352406, 0.029648616909980774, -0.011266035959124565, -0.023718085139989853, 0.04231426119804382, -0.011868966743350029, -0.02907070331275463, 0.006671409588307142, -0.004431858193129301, 0.017950231209397316, -0.04237997531890869, -0.052489273250103, 0.004312435630708933, -0.04466012865304947, -0.0358315035700798, 0.0638749748468399, -0.024568377062678337, 0.030721763148903847, -0.01872972771525383, 0.056363530457019806, -0.003741644788533449, -0.03513914346694946, -0.014785830862820148, 0.039391808211803436, -0.026255620643496513, 0.05394245311617851, -0.060615211725234985, 0.026686429977416992, -0.027703462168574333, -0.013275322504341602, -0.08383054286241531, -0.017951522022485733, -0.002553546102717519, 0.016973374411463737, 0.033965688198804855, -0.04298383370041847, 0.020081574097275734, -0.0008979772683233023, -0.015503591857850552, -0.01899954304099083, 0.056261323392391205, -0.017456689849495888, -0.0255721528083086, -0.02362021803855896, 0.01816527172923088, 0.06662026792764664, -0.010792520828545094, 0.0047210464254021645, -0.014501470141112804, -0.044193804264068604, 0.002227599499747157, -0.012625782750546932, 0.01614854484796524, -0.023355184122920036, 0.00021182328055147082, -0.006271475460380316, 0.01210273988544941, 0.02719537727534771, -0.04455350339412689, -0.039332665503025055, 0.009149692952632904, -0.006970459129661322, 0.05737065523862839, -0.016346894204616547, 0.01905914396047592, -0.012094258330762386, -0.002568039344623685, -0.06074048951268196, 0.013987749814987183, 0.013279006816446781, -0.026642030104994774, 0.016851700842380524, 0.04310521110892296, -0.04430373013019562, 0.0373944528400898, 0.021340541541576385, -0.033003538846969604, -0.000813415041193366, -0.002979845739901066, 0.013815917074680328, 0.04627640172839165, -0.01630638912320137, -0.002477083122357726, 0.024463050067424774, 0.01674603298306465, -0.01565169356763363, -0.016698509454727173, -0.026023227721452713, 0.00668502738699317, 0.06756903976202011, -0.01857615076005459, 0.02779424749314785, 0.07834260910749435, -0.029807498678565025, 0.015202824957668781, -0.057285577058792114, 0.0032420437783002853, -0.02642124332487583, -0.006004505790770054, 0.0353628471493721, -0.028283020481467247, 0.007444530259817839, 0.033702120184898376, 0.00801460724323988, 0.013515469618141651, 0.012782342731952667, 0.003760464023798704, 0.02635156363248825, 0.027995536103844643, -0.035096894949674606, -0.048338256776332855, 0.03965786471962929, -0.049989040940999985, -0.010188627056777477, -0.07588870078325272, -0.0184656772762537, 0.047327227890491486, 0.05974973365664482, 0.02145134098827839, -0.034035030752420425, -0.03903734311461449, -0.05246522277593613, 0.020034609362483025, 0.020717600360512733, 0.024693187326192856, -0.0035788274835795164, 0.0019066508393734694, 0.026943035423755646, -0.038513049483299255, -0.011451744474470615, -0.04472909867763519, -0.05610136687755585, -0.07216399908065796, -0.03550494462251663, -0.022573912516236305, 0.03973131626844406, 0.01114613376557827, -0.019655589014291763, 0.01570594310760498, -0.008328758180141449, 0.024595217779278755, 0.0021480759605765343, 0.035958919674158096, -0.02050669677555561, 0.03030131198465824, 0.010183099657297134, 0.018102793022990227, 0.00288888206705451, 0.007781905122101307, 0.10092923045158386, 0.06638623774051666, 0.05360375717282295, -0.014512845315039158, 0.03651611879467964, -0.009613493457436562, -0.01708735153079033, 0.00018376496154814959, 0.022497190162539482, -0.0019207247532904148, -0.01320866122841835, -0.0068122572265565395, 0.04689578339457512, 0.03402404114603996, -0.04780412092804909, 0.06395673006772995, -0.016622480005025864, 0.003215162083506584, 0.019579319283366203, 0.02045488730072975, -0.016274524852633476, -0.006351375952363014, -0.03184162825345993, -0.004254499450325966, -0.0012177262688055634, -0.02267199568450451, -0.01914648711681366, 0.008161747828125954, -0.029888052493333817, 0.021826520562171936, -0.013676980510354042, -0.028873343020677567, 0.015186655335128307, -0.019926538690924644, -0.0330573134124279, -0.01743476465344429, 0.027871351689100266, -0.05864891782402992, 0.01500846166163683, 0.04332127049565315, -0.024258185178041458, 0.0033639385364949703, -0.046977948397397995, -0.0016539229545742273, -0.015164664015173912, -0.0042448691092431545, -0.002992447232827544, 0.04212523251771927, -0.016240194439888, -0.012364364229142666, 0.007180838380008936, -0.016463177278637886, 0.021954337134957314, -0.034387290477752686, -0.002892197808250785, 0.014100298285484314, 0.02262352593243122, -0.03635929897427559, -0.016863850876688957, 0.007349591702222824, 0.03183382749557495, 0.00008140980935422704, 0.0017938291421160102, 0.02225143276154995, -0.05653401091694832, -0.03923341631889343, -0.020098553970456123, 0.036127008497714996, 0.019357118755578995, -0.02720671147108078, 0.040183912962675095, -0.020871730521321297, -0.05761345475912094, -0.004770193248987198, 0.045063551515340805, 0.03292002156376839, 0.017398718744516373, -0.015117560513317585, -0.024191007018089294, 0.00502143194898963, -0.023006053641438484, 0.003248385153710842, -0.040863581001758575, -0.006143976002931595, -0.019690923392772675, 0.011208154261112213, 0.0010628476738929749, 0.021355660632252693, 0.020999725908041, 0.0220708716660738, 0.013332818634808064, 0.015293312259018421, 0.01420388650149107, -0.07119788229465485, 0.004605091642588377, -0.01771271787583828, -0.049469221383333206, 0.0033016172237694263, 0.00816709827631712, 0.05671725794672966, 0.0006292565958574414, 0.018262764438986778, 0.005130914505571127, 0.04332200437784195, 0.006466928403824568, 0.011920069344341755, 0.01175869069993496, -0.06919581443071365, 0.012246976606547832, 0.02484329417347908, -0.018179861828684807, -0.011430304497480392, -0.03313156217336655, -0.0228743813931942, -0.02039446122944355, 0.005469719413667917, -0.040855199098587036, -0.017111243680119514, 0.002635347656905651, -0.01226417813450098, -0.0026523489505052567, 0.015187231823801994, 0.023961007595062256, -0.006842135917395353, -0.01230079960078001, -0.013779278844594955, 0.0035329668316990137, 0.024224797263741493, 0.010987982153892517, -0.05273072421550751, -0.01926567405462265, 0.02271602675318718, -0.007686292286962271, 0.011231784708797932, -0.006498063914477825, 0.02054174430668354, 0.02066274918615818, 0.020498601719737053, 0.005585824605077505, -0.016403162851929665, 0.028442367911338806, -0.05619730055332184, -0.013565327040851116, 0.03241163119673729, -0.019302023574709892, 0.033363912254571915, 0.028337392956018448, 0.010719784535467625, -0.030045388266444206, 0.028943561017513275, -0.051366616040468216, -0.025155043229460716, -0.002613704651594162, 0.0021804249845445156, -0.0065077682957053185, -0.03328841179609299, 0.044715944677591324, 0.02956378273665905, 0.0005375832552090287, 0.049621645361185074, 0.008978799916803837, 0.008766650222241879, -0.010375159792602062, -0.010330249555408955, -0.031068453565239906, 0.018810521811246872, 0.00580334197729826, -0.01603809930384159, 0.016148831695318222, 0.07133498042821884, -0.03940200060606003, 0.042459528893232346, 0.025467146188020706, 0.010190466418862343, -0.12360090017318726, -0.05573858693242073, 0.026865750551223755, 0.03532589226961136, 0.024672282859683037, -0.039948541671037674, -0.004716455936431885, -0.0005028966697864234, -0.055497583001852036, 0.019581828266382217, 0.0059297652915120125, 0.007025764789432287, -0.04452067241072655, -0.02182719111442566, -0.0390302799642086, 0.007902543991804123, -0.014611465856432915, 0.005616179201751947, 0.015053599141538143, 0.00011752172576962039, 0.018184037879109383, -0.03541615977883339, -0.045326318591833115, -0.0019469271646812558, 0.022568633779883385, -0.0679948627948761, -0.0007595967617817223, -0.047341130673885345, -0.003572945948690176, 0.03956255689263344, 0.030157100409269333, 0.019441038370132446, -0.002678260440006852, 0.020528644323349, 0.011563697829842567, 0.04964625462889671, 0.00699832895770669, 0.008164595812559128, -0.007120410446077585, 0.016684506088495255, -0.003689110977575183, 0.020683186128735542, -0.017902370542287827, 0.0016946959076449275, 0.03119662217795849, -0.031367868185043335, 0.003593748901039362, 0.023120876401662827, -0.02659946121275425, -0.012263061478734016, 0.005505566950887442, 0.006468193605542183, 0.02350126951932907, -0.00038813360151834786, 0.04448831453919411, -0.05924442037940025, 0.02764824405312538, 0.040063418447971344, 0.021611088886857033, -0.02981879748404026, 0.0014580471906811, -0.009149663150310516, -0.017089111730456352, -0.00007723968155914918, -0.0004324590554460883, -0.007387423887848854, -0.06302075833082199, 0.01735883206129074, 0.003396780462935567, -0.03374311700463295, -0.017057958990335464, -0.007934680208563805, -0.055902544409036636, 0.022635485976934433, -0.005796058103442192, 0.028839891776442528, 0.012356888502836227, -0.02509033866226673, 0.009587284177541733, -0.061558905988931656, 0.09748534113168716, -0.013648439198732376, 0.034145455807447433, -0.011415054090321064, -0.0047422125935554504, -0.052105940878391266, -0.014803707599639893, 0.054541055113077164, 0.03001227229833603, 0.016668226569890976, 0.020778696984052658, 0.003435141174122691, 0.012287958525121212, -0.0166938416659832, 0.05699827894568443, -0.022700529545545578, -0.0007871630950830877, -0.012356367893517017, -0.029156342148780823, 0.026092607527971268, 0.010635981336236, -0.01917317323386669, -0.02416331321001053, 0.021756645292043686, 0.01258987095206976, -0.01364350039511919, 0.03134838864207268, 0.014325655996799469, 0.012650412507355213, 0.029407942667603493, -0.0087078046053648, 0.03244403377175331, 0.008248009718954563, 0.02211330085992813, -0.07684501260519028, 0.012029225006699562, -0.015462759882211685, -0.01983185112476349, 0.006800870876759291, -0.00755271827802062, -0.03605499118566513, -0.014944720081984997, 0.015465491451323032, 0.008612881414592266, -0.045446574687957764, 0.02504780888557434, 0.029521143063902855, 0.032084133476018906, 0.025688083842396736, -0.050562720745801926, -0.0010092646116390824, 0.02601783722639084, -0.029416121542453766, 0.05395961552858353, 0.01720154471695423, 0.01718303933739662, 0.006007608026266098, 0.03300803154706955, 0.03893890604376793, -0.011203180067241192, 0.015837881714105606, -0.004249322693794966, 0.02329765446484089, -0.012724664062261581, -0.025499077513813972, -0.0109493937343359, 0.011303882114589214, 0.019220124930143356, -0.029824700206518173, -0.009188122116029263, 0.07111626863479614, 0.02929922193288803, -0.01845734566450119, -0.052684757858514786, 0.010766695253551006, 0.002890743548050523, 0.006873760838061571, 0.0046659852378070354, 0.05160118266940117, 0.003459866624325514, 0.004788141697645187, -0.009771245531737804, -0.004259627312421799, 0.040017157793045044, -0.0466240756213665, 0.0431736558675766, -0.014785995706915855, 0.001808641362003982, -0.007252722978591919, 0.0011081751435995102, -0.01017991453409195, -0.03231306001543999, 0.028428656980395317, 0.03822311758995056, 0.04669445753097534, 0.008411213755607605, -0.04123670235276222, 0.015200257301330566, 0.004344636108726263, -0.03929101303219795, -0.037987120449543, -0.057794924825429916, 0.04245559871196747, -0.013954279012978077, -0.007618511561304331 ]
<p>This is a real small business problem, not a homework problem.</p> <p>A monthly production goal is 60000. We want to be sure that say 95% of months meet this goal. The goal is a minimum, so we want to be sure we aren't under this, but we don't care how much we are over.</p> <p>We want to use daily production as a check on whether we are likely to meet the monthly production goal. We don't really care how low one day's production is as long as other days make up for it, but if we are too low one day it should be a signal that there will be a problem in meeting the monthly production goal.</p> <p>How do we determine what is too low for daily production?</p> <p>The simplest approach is to just divide the monthly production by the number of workdays (say 16) to get daily production goals. This works, in the sense of if you meet each daily production goal you will meet the monthly production goal, but it ignores the natural variability in daily production. It is too severe. We should be able to have daily production that is some amount less than this without having to be worried yet.</p> <p>You can assume a normal distribution of daily production with errors that are independent from day to day, and that we have a history of daily production from which we can estimate the variance in daily production.</p> <p>Thanks for your help.</p>
73,616
[ -0.022558366879820824, -0.008935550227761269, -0.03843482583761215, -0.009526289068162441, 0.03397296741604805, -0.025888865813612938, 0.007892230525612831, 0.012262162752449512, 0.029430119320750237, 0.01995626464486122, 0.0354575514793396, 0.054073624312877655, 0.060349609702825546, 0.03761399909853935, 0.0032939037773758173, -0.006600633263587952, -0.043102797120809555, -0.01848060078918934, -0.0034031665418297052, -0.02284136600792408, -0.009124260395765305, 0.022778857499361038, 0.022534962743520737, 0.005471206735819578, -0.038828860968351364, 0.016184058040380478, 0.028969906270503998, -0.019483301788568497, 0.008825354278087616, 0.05684180557727814, -0.05019659921526909, -0.05715915188193321, 0.008563760668039322, 0.06830901652574539, 0.035246893763542175, 0.017711875960230827, 0.0005969017511233687, -0.017678283154964447, -0.0343867652118206, 0.03251050040125847, -0.041137684136629105, 0.05437581613659859, 0.0318908654153347, 0.016452252864837646, 0.00146225665230304, 0.020648956298828125, -0.012343122623860836, -0.015344134531915188, 0.03530411422252655, -0.05925275385379791, 0.04604433476924896, -0.026816153898835182, 0.02190220169723034, 0.02017262578010559, -0.007918189279735088, -0.04093044996261597, 0.057731740176677704, 0.08053569495677948, -0.008939397521317005, -0.016873488202691078, -0.02076559327542782, -0.031971629709005356, 0.004340974148362875, -0.03186282888054848, -0.023344574496150017, 0.006692794617265463, -0.03831172361969948, -0.0006370978080667555, 0.027139738202095032, -0.035704463720321655, 0.01191175077110529, 0.030273733660578728, 0.032908063381910324, 0.041275493800640106, -0.002273247577250004, -0.029745129868388176, 0.004832218401134014, 0.017514241859316826, 0.0156403761357069, 0.04265701025724411, 0.0037668589502573013, 0.05001336336135864, 0.015690617263317108, 0.054490670561790466, 0.037980686873197556, -0.029617466032505035, 0.051033809781074524, -0.01831131801009178, 0.028486313298344612, 0.044499337673187256, 0.007711633574217558, 0.000703849014826119, 0.07311710715293884, -0.0054464018903672695, -0.07608215510845184, 0.004495617002248764, -0.0023380343336611986, -0.015251307748258114, -0.022610176354646683, -0.017497707158327103, 0.016088828444480896, -0.055534012615680695, 0.03898442164063454, 0.05411646515130997, -0.02105284109711647, -0.011372492648661137, 0.006863886024802923, -0.01912824995815754, -0.003800805425271392, -0.0035579402465373278, 0.003891304600983858, 0.009270718321204185, 0.028256213292479515, -0.04863110929727554, 0.005895139649510384, 0.008556717075407505, -0.03639756143093109, -0.027139710262417793, 0.03830442950129509, 0.019580364227294922, 0.06135522946715355, 0.008631165139377117, 0.05023365840315819, -0.04558224603533745, -0.022004080936312675, 0.030687320977449417, 0.008954509161412716, -0.02315906248986721, -0.030661646276712418, 0.05196513235569, 0.025898661464452744, -0.0035444165114313364, 0.04018101096153259, 0.009364504367113113, 0.028645453974604607, -0.006264880765229464, -0.05620456486940384, -0.04422951862215996, 0.039193324744701385, 0.017689401283860207, -0.006059678271412849, -0.06895001232624054, -0.006329779978841543, 0.031591128557920456, 0.03610670939087868, -0.0037134564481675625, 0.026592208072543144, 0.017771223559975624, -0.010706423781812191, -0.009552490897476673, -0.03300624340772629, 0.013711514882743359, 0.009965235367417336, -0.03681596741080284, 0.006008661352097988, -0.06537516415119171, 0.034037958830595016, 0.007684084586799145, -0.012803771533071995, -0.03633742406964302, 0.02294466830790043, 0.02954842895269394, -0.06180824339389801, -0.003869822947308421, 0.01619270071387291, -0.044279612600803375, 0.08148565888404846, 0.01569453440606594, -0.013607804663479328, 0.008028358221054077, 0.004331134259700775, 0.013642187230288982, 0.018730252981185913, 0.029677802696824074, 0.06024446338415146, 0.00837182067334652, 0.01669112592935562, -0.016502270475029945, 0.022300435230135918, 0.015993239358067513, -0.0557955801486969, -0.011176900938153267, -0.04605456069111824, 0.016003279015421867, 0.017993668094277382, 0.0647679790854454, -0.010437488555908203, -0.0030168620869517326, 0.025615980848670006, -0.032438162714242935, -0.06868498772382736, -0.04538734629750252, 0.00537842744961381, -0.02882777526974678, -0.05247450992465019, -0.008665913715958595, -0.01306045800447464, -0.007010157220065594, -0.016672184690833092, -0.009427168406546116, 0.031021084636449814, -0.010730648413300514, 0.025408677756786346, -0.053040191531181335, 0.004055417608469725, 0.048622794449329376, 0.03393498808145523, -0.02579635940492153, 0.04482364282011986, -0.06789889186620712, -0.03810920566320419, -0.01694170944392681, -0.05969323590397835, 0.013002218678593636, 0.023243414238095284, -0.009201756678521633, 0.07086624205112457, -0.002787148579955101, 0.010065636597573757, 0.004382318817079067, -0.029599986970424652, 0.03490617871284485, 0.045199163258075714, -0.011807938106358051, 0.005793445743620396, -0.019755147397518158, 0.021650874987244606, 0.015724482014775276, 0.0012548977974802256, -0.025149287655949593, -0.03610975295305252, 0.0027937409467995167, 0.005736749153584242, 0.018957778811454773, -0.026120929047465324, 0.014242411591112614, 0.05880042910575867, 0.027317186817526817, 0.0067053791135549545, 0.06392891705036163, -0.006550515536218882, 0.04527738317847252, 0.0224981140345335, 0.012709478847682476, 0.01016472652554512, 0.035092081874608994, -0.007649451494216919, 0.05186721682548523, -0.005428615026175976, -0.0005660096067003906, -0.006765230558812618, 0.022790830582380295, 0.022002119570970535, 0.018410632386803627, 0.004202889744192362, -0.03738437592983246, 0.039028018712997437, -0.017438124865293503, -0.0012927739880979061, 0.04583639279007912, -0.005982843693345785, 0.021577319130301476, 0.024676993489265442, -0.056025851517915726, 0.04402250424027443, 0.01685931161046028, -0.03177459537982941, -0.00032001250656321645, 0.019503943622112274, -0.007447115611284971, 0.010661333799362183, -0.026965996250510216, -0.03356555476784706, -0.027920691296458244, -0.004813181236386299, 0.04690326377749443, 0.015283487737178802, 0.049640953540802, -0.020180264487862587, 0.015215501189231873, -0.004922371823340654, 0.008851993829011917, 0.02418755739927292, -0.004381009843200445, -0.04477119818329811, -0.018537510186433792, 0.03856515884399414, -0.031273894011974335, 0.04850269481539726, -0.01068849302828312, 0.03287452459335327, 0.05332517996430397, 0.021734610199928284, -0.0432039238512516, -0.003290071152150631, -0.0283961221575737, 0.0117561100050807, -0.024421166628599167, -0.029799465090036392, 0.004494341090321541, 0.010824865661561489, -0.06046886369585991, 0.010324837639927864, -0.06362482160329819, -0.045177195221185684, -0.04622645303606987, -0.009089183062314987, -0.017329281195998192, -0.0004844571521971375, 0.015631655231118202, 0.01709822006523609, -0.014432928524911404, -0.01931673102080822, -0.0807519480586052, -0.08223985135555267, -0.04415920749306679, -0.01797499507665634, 0.041695836931467056, 0.01361958310008049, -0.020049460232257843, 0.052202191203832626, 0.021220698952674866, -0.04978452995419502, -0.02430165745317936, 0.003314624773338437, -0.029320629313588142, -0.04859739914536476, 0.0027163145132362843, 0.014478810131549835, 0.0038749785162508488, 0.0410362146794796, -0.009856739081442356, 0.012027809396386147, 0.06317613273859024, 0.010486910119652748, -0.014765351079404354, -0.02508770115673542, -0.03028658777475357, 0.015163175761699677, 0.009184017777442932, 0.009053362533450127, 0.03304024785757065, 0.010485595092177391, -0.03206644579768181, 0.033828236162662506, -0.001446717418730259, -0.05024247244000435, 0.009848203510046005, -0.043143466114997864, -0.008688570000231266, -0.024671757593750954, -0.002015188569203019, -0.0010894343722611666, -0.03545060008764267, 0.0029079639352858067, -0.013963031582534313, 0.03039352223277092, -0.020775649696588516, -0.01246611401438713, 0.0554121658205986, 0.05079241096973419, 0.006879473105072975, -0.0422213189303875, -0.036839187145233154, 0.008615916594862938, 0.021903134882450104, -0.03893429413437843, -0.0005260155885480344, 0.049880824983119965, 0.05136525630950928, 0.0686420276761055, -0.05472154915332794, -0.04314029961824417, -0.011543488129973412, -0.0440136194229126, 0.000763129850383848, -0.04092371463775635, 0.04724231734871864, 0.03922634199261665, 0.03955301269888878, 0.022069619968533516, -0.003354129381477833, 0.0019169263541698456, -0.0011447240831330419, -0.0331871435046196, 0.030977658927440643, -0.012213394977152348, 0.004725270438939333, 0.019141264259815216, -0.030452348291873932, 0.007906562648713589, -0.025029730051755905, -0.003059364389628172, 0.00034805084578692913, 0.06355132162570953, -0.006499933544546366, 0.007515553385019302, -0.015135075896978378, -0.019707825034856796, -0.015521851368248463, 0.00043365993769839406, 0.01882372424006462, 0.0066110482439398766, 0.02072557620704174, 0.02067263238132, -0.0008131290087476373, -0.025837531313300133, -0.03468647971749306, -0.0016306474572047591, 0.003926136996597052, 0.06224100664258003, -0.014650369994342327, 0.04619761183857918, 0.00017257053696084768, 0.01566525362432003, 0.017930706962943077, 0.06291532516479492, 0.03689121454954147, 0.027477838099002838, -0.03432072699069977, -0.03307049348950386, -0.03138279914855957, 0.05374014377593994, -0.021942099556326866, -0.006435006391257048, 0.004163071513175964, 0.048883866518735886, -0.008207423612475395, -0.05803348496556282, 0.003235524520277977, 0.10173813998699188, -0.02424677461385727, -0.020894097164273262, -0.026527414098381996, -0.04501573368906975, 0.00046542257769033313, 0.03393473103642464, 0.02850033901631832, -0.0035392811987549067, 0.0238810945302248, -0.018255511298775673, 0.035344142466783524, -0.044404998421669006, -0.040983300656080246, 0.02678682655096054, 0.0012511728564277291, 0.05725766718387604, 0.022557761520147324, -0.010393495671451092, 0.047437556087970734, 0.03302577883005142, 0.032560016959905624, 0.02867468260228634, 0.03380690515041351, -0.07542077451944351, -0.027359090745449066, 0.027855416759848595, 0.050601594150066376, -0.01870754547417164, -0.01518157497048378, -0.055632151663303375, -0.03329097479581833, 0.06123746931552887, -0.01295777689665556, 0.03355253115296364, -0.014909469522535801, 0.046395525336265564, -0.014150770381093025, -0.03383270651102066, -0.05054214596748352, -0.009290536865592003, -0.02850363962352276, 0.03837566822767258, 0.011837106198072433, -0.018701724708080292, -0.034923210740089417, -0.013138905167579651, 0.007161998655647039, 0.07062577456235886, -0.011312935501337051, -0.02847355604171753, 0.0009439167333766818, -0.005713022314012051, -0.01917792484164238, -0.045583855360746384, -0.01990310661494732, 0.01901821978390217, 0.005637616850435734, 0.03434830531477928, -0.029757734388113022, -0.005804694723337889, 0.040329575538635254, -0.006376173347234726, -0.046108219772577286, -0.02329958789050579, -0.00003657263732748106, -0.00977354310452938, 0.02474680170416832, 0.01921257935464382, 0.0493902713060379, -0.007580638397485018, -0.0007466666284017265, 0.017323410138487816, -0.022517111152410507, 0.032366812229156494, 0.005227559711784124, -0.030341805890202522, -0.039378684014081955, -0.019675588235259056, 0.002260548295453191, -0.0047537172213196754, 0.02111513540148735, 0.034653063863515854, -0.017864014953374863, -0.05322984606027603, -0.018267471343278885, -0.009521523490548134, 0.010444528423249722, -0.019394297152757645, 0.011501654051244259, 0.032525110989809036, 0.004577999003231525, -0.0024242636281996965, 0.013345767743885517, -0.00836372934281826, 0.026162974536418915, 0.002279011532664299, -0.014987286180257797, -0.0018516024574637413, -0.05641493201255798, -0.0377175509929657, 0.01272660307586193, 0.002276178216561675, 0.028951400890946388, 0.0010894049191847444, 0.06348609924316406, 0.012632472440600395, -0.014265590347349644, 0.011099038645625114, 0.016081560403108597, 0.01175615657120943, 0.0540129691362381, -0.013228691183030605, 0.020503511652350426, -0.030675673857331276, 0.016101788729429245, -0.07105739414691925, -0.01645437441766262, 0.03971670940518379, 0.02999495342373848, -0.031143274158239365, -0.02606075629591942, -0.052364882081747055, 0.016258036717772484, -0.011755621060729027, -0.02941783331334591, 0.010273709893226624, 0.010254722088575363, -0.02831614576280117, 0.011048774234950542, 0.03472281992435455, 0.09105374664068222, -0.02670559659600258, 0.004622325301170349, 0.015848543494939804, -0.020451467484235764, -0.038364678621292114, -0.011951216496527195, 0.013347596861422062, -0.0566551499068737, -0.03503744304180145, -0.015778711065649986, 0.009451929479837418, 0.05770563706755638, -0.05269430950284004, -0.0064978706650435925, 0.01825433224439621, 0.009615681134164333, -0.0073754373006522655, -0.008594934828579426, 0.019875558093190193, 0.00808724295347929, 0.028189120814204216, -0.023496154695749283, -0.02508547343313694, -0.00813799723982811, -0.0168145801872015, 0.011357222683727741, -0.017889630049467087, -0.01261787861585617, 0.03896882385015488, 0.0573677122592926, 0.003210514783859253, -0.029445666819810867, 0.021355390548706055, 0.004065163433551788, 0.02361253648996353, 0.02709587849676609, 0.010963160544633865, 0.03932007774710655, 0.0029252779204398394, -0.04299036040902138, -0.05444405972957611, -0.024891218170523643, -0.00020884585683234036, 0.05705300346016884, -0.017071811482310295, 0.026630718261003494, 0.009586104191839695, 0.04093698784708977, -0.024855878204107285, -0.04097861424088478, -0.04158680513501167, -0.026072662323713303, 0.0053736069239676, 0.038817763328552246, 0.004104970023036003, 0.008213578723371029, 0.00893728993833065, -0.020147332921624184, 0.030771883204579353, 0.027802377939224243, 0.02541637234389782, 0.016621200367808342, 0.009862985461950302, -0.06501968950033188, -0.05540544539690018, 0.01244037039577961, -0.03958098217844963, 0.026979098096489906, -0.01649489626288414, 0.0029790429398417473, 0.021344510838389397, 0.004056084901094437, -0.039566922932863235, -0.02771332673728466, -0.010611911304295063, -0.02711651101708412, 0.03091065213084221, 0.05275549367070198, -0.045108284801244736, 0.030571162700653076, 0.01532862987369299, 0.044920727610588074, -0.049160219728946686, 0.012692735530436039, -0.012130754068493843, -0.04724615812301636, -0.012269668281078339, -0.029513822868466377, -0.0711328461766243, 0.015973271802067757, 0.009658866561949253, -0.009022809565067291, -0.0013239099644124508, 0.035799816250801086, -0.012915601953864098, 0.005496537778526545, 0.04452815279364586, 0.009885799139738083, 0.05289051681756973, 0.028122808784246445, 0.0013320312136784196, -0.008924176916480064, 0.012202943675220013, 0.13309305906295776, 0.09066364914178848, 0.023042241111397743, -0.03694209083914757, 0.027620594948530197, -0.04858643561601639, -0.011885843239724636, -0.01759120263159275, 0.045974213629961014, -0.01675240881741047, -0.011390564031898975, 0.04488418996334076, 0.030879929661750793, -0.0008573973900638521, 0.009490668773651123, 0.07965223491191864, -0.018602745607495308, -0.046958643943071365, -0.0023264321498572826, 0.04733811691403389, 0.05540122091770172, -0.013984596356749535, -0.00971462856978178, 0.0442972406744957, 0.008953975513577461, -0.03156057745218277, -0.005967236589640379, -0.007363323587924242, 0.0013799734879285097, 0.02195580303668976, 0.003699047490954399, 0.03810381144285202, 0.02954193577170372, 0.014294694177806377, -0.00752855883911252, -0.03892562538385391, 0.009434170089662075, -0.05458144098520279, 0.00786749180406332, 0.030793946236371994, 0.019644958898425102, -0.00681737344712019, 0.007814164273440838, 0.005865875631570816, -0.059292394667863846, -0.02883785031735897, -0.03223676607012749, 0.014010641723871231, -0.020703226327896118, 0.009169073775410652, -0.03089810721576214, -0.026897314935922623, 0.010812883265316486, -0.026505121961236, -0.010493251495063305, 0.021597547456622124, 0.016758805140852928, -0.037744756788015366, -0.02609868161380291, -0.00889682024717331, 0.02978425845503807, 0.020366009324789047, -0.0022527258843183517, 0.04629131034016609, -0.02288459986448288, -0.030226338654756546, -0.0017558438703417778, 0.05966733768582344, 0.023410851135849953, 0.0028336080722510815, 0.009208225645124912, -0.009654161520302296, -0.016375744715332985, 0.017473381012678146, 0.01675385609269142, -0.030113279819488525, 0.017662636935710907, -0.016431249678134918, -0.018998408690094948, 0.01848362386226654, -0.03836638107895851, 0.029085997492074966, -0.041846323758363724, -0.015402516350150108, -0.05157320946455002, 0.024696635082364082, 0.021757151931524277, 0.04147731140255928, 0.04155293479561806, -0.0011429304722696543, -0.02658919058740139, 0.07570625096559525, 0.005923100747168064, -0.018403926864266396, 0.009590206667780876, -0.01451940182596445, -0.041721418499946594, 0.023084871470928192, 0.008415223099291325, 0.09381312876939774, 0.027073195204138756, 0.010373247787356377, -0.02267937920987606, 0.0072474004700779915, -0.028109487146139145, 0.02763003669679165, 0.033372730016708374, -0.06975076347589493, -0.014959979802370071, 0.017478585243225098, -0.0032798524480313063, -0.06418963521718979, 0.011844142340123653, -0.02357896789908409, -0.023585105314850807, 0.008603100664913654, -0.010584951378405094, 0.00878079328685999, 0.0002696401788853109, -0.01989486813545227, 0.01180982030928135, -0.04222646728157997, 0.007333026267588139, 0.0034493214916437864, -0.03647643327713013, 0.004128392785787582, 0.020164143294095993, 0.0014791821595281363, -0.01600337028503418, -0.007153836078941822, -0.017839940264821053, 0.02585795521736145, -0.0025625720154494047, 0.028327705338597298, 0.010014544241130352, 0.013021865859627724, 0.012404019944369793, 0.021823447197675705, -0.04067861661314964, -0.024505343288183212, 0.041747573763132095, -0.00580646051093936, -0.03221296891570091, 0.052077680826187134, 0.016620703041553497, 0.057744670659303665, 0.005998969078063965, -0.04271526634693146, -0.030372286215424538, 0.026958689093589783, -0.04556944966316223, -0.014923893846571445, -0.025007067248225212, 0.04486467316746712, 0.032526034861803055, -0.002397169591858983, -0.0024484642781317234, 0.009528521448373795, 0.025238217785954475, 0.005043431185185909, 0.03345075249671936, 0.013954855501651764, -0.011595755815505981, 0.03082038275897503, 0.007569626905024052, -0.04284387826919556, 0.0160199087113142, -0.016967574134469032, 0.021038295701146126, 0.013404293917119503, -0.018650483340024948, -0.008896076120436192, -0.027506200596690178, -0.028069883584976196, -0.05903321132063866, -0.03978830203413963, 0.005233812145888805, 0.007445001509040594, 0.029469948261976242, -0.024236023426055908, -0.01661106012761593, 0.017161374911665916, -0.007111434359103441, -0.019547756761312485, -0.02120434120297432, 0.0033789766021072865, -0.016656501218676567, 0.003142718458548188, -0.014805139042437077, 0.00022462784545496106, -0.03768178075551987, 0.006365190260112286, 0.04874292388558388, 0.04500757157802582, -0.004094769712537527, -0.047881778329610825, 0.02090749517083168, 0.0010811242973431945, 0.030218377709388733, -0.041671473532915115, 0.02333546057343483, -0.03673135116696358, -0.037039291113615036, 0.021427763625979424, -0.046894047409296036, 0.03473568707704544, -0.016162395477294922, 0.026226775720715523, 0.013043996877968311, 0.055978141725063324, 0.029346881434321404, 0.04610178619623184, -0.016266241669654846, 0.005280795972794294, 0.02946455590426922, 0.028676848858594894, -0.005023360252380371, -0.015466224402189255, 0.04603756219148636, -0.02020515874028206, -0.022624075412750244, 0.0025669638998806477, 0.02829541452229023, -0.03217662498354912, 0.010452657006680965, 0.0006212639855220914, 0.01619476079940796, -0.030894994735717773, 0.025705287232995033, -0.013652891851961613, -0.002045427681878209, 0.039761196821928024, 0.04958748072385788, -0.05452416464686394, -0.0019446167862042785, -0.0027400366961956024, -0.048712167888879776, 0.029921967536211014, 0.008876770734786987, -0.045521967113018036, -0.04697450250387192, -0.004690060392022133, -0.029093753546476364, -0.01961987465620041, -0.012272680178284645, -0.004864370450377464, -0.028694845736026764, 0.040222711861133575, -0.024137631058692932, 0.004306199494749308, 0.010091543197631836, -0.0245278999209404, 0.0056350501254200935, -0.07033634930849075, 0.06136602908372879, 0.004997433163225651, 0.00706156762316823, -0.02949267253279686, -0.06017443910241127, -0.030242227017879486, -0.0018853071378543973, 0.01624245010316372, 0.013390455394983292, -0.0019093792652711272, -0.016752049326896667, -0.013083732686936855, 0.0026480653323233128, -0.06831678748130798, 0.05530604347586632, -0.03407420590519905, -0.046500034630298615, -0.031533099710941315, -0.047218430787324905, 0.006992905400693417, -0.028135966509580612, 0.003765090834349394, 0.013565843924880028, -0.02735809236764908, 0.02295548841357231, -0.0034934079740196466, -0.0004573082842398435, -0.006565518211573362, 0.00167169701308012, 0.04526716098189354, -0.002403134247288108, 0.024432100355625153, 0.021173281595110893, 0.009474731981754303, -0.0834091380238533, 0.05727999657392502, -0.06085147708654404, -0.027931971475481987, 0.013058501295745373, 0.038633793592453, 0.02367226406931877, -0.05113176628947258, -0.03297657519578934, 0.03735162690281868, 0.008499903604388237, 0.021507272496819496, 0.05626033619046211, 0.021515250205993652, 0.05588923767209053, -0.02330099605023861, -0.0083999615162611, 0.04784885793924332, -0.009337903000414371, 0.010994302108883858, -0.003691893769428134, 0.004880869761109352, 0.0021906367037445307, -0.032610341906547546, 0.0495791882276535, 0.0034175452310591936, 0.022950265556573868, 0.014493278227746487, 0.013037825003266335, -0.004317462909966707, -0.039690904319286346, -0.005424154456704855, -0.0007760117878206074, 0.002814196515828371, 0.00901106372475624, -0.0013610856840386987, 0.04621148481965065, 0.0017402825178578496, -0.009470389224588871, -0.058481063693761826, -0.015449561178684235, -0.0036913703661412, -0.03459635004401207, 0.011299878358840942, 0.037747569382190704, -0.03825616464018822, -0.0006206513498909771, 0.019952328875660896, 0.05437908694148064, 0.004248915705829859, -0.0029243098106235266, 0.011087188497185707, -0.002362453145906329, 0.008250406943261623, -0.04140520095825195, -0.04221127927303314, -0.05924149975180626, -0.03203843533992767, 0.029433267191052437, 0.040269747376441956, 0.014779546298086643, 0.04433177039027214, -0.04378727823495865, 0.01241016574203968, 0.010021663270890713, -0.05761130526661873, -0.0007416884182021022, -0.046927664428949356, 0.00034000977757386863, -0.0460042804479599, -0.029975617304444313 ]
<p>Suppose $a_1 = b + c_1$ and $a_2 = 2b + c_2$ where $b, c_1, c_2$ are all $N(0,1)$</p> <p>Find $E[b|a_1,a_2]$</p> <p>My attempt: As $E[b] = 0$, I assume $E[b|a_1, a_2] = 0$. Is this a logical assumption?</p>
73,617
[ -0.0008952743373811245, -0.008828016929328442, 0.0009686951525509357, -0.013939681462943554, 0.005051634274423122, 0.0070810578763484955, -0.005100626032799482, 0.009146399796009064, -0.006571777630597353, -0.02455247938632965, 0.07515677809715271, 0.02140035107731819, 0.022853577509522438, 0.022570200264453888, 0.028091616928577423, -0.0089659933000803, -0.03964799642562866, -0.009845632128417492, -0.010557173751294613, -0.005020098760724068, 0.000366052845492959, 0.04450464993715286, 0.0640348270535469, -0.006721249781548977, -0.05270736292004585, 0.026490051299333572, 0.02068162150681019, -0.012340744957327843, -0.003525014501065016, 0.10013178735971451, -0.027873050421476364, -0.07838565856218338, 0.021699953824281693, 0.03129955381155014, 0.002196867950260639, 0.027516024187207222, -0.041568152606487274, -0.03958849608898163, 0.020383907482028008, 0.0057371496222913265, -0.016186384484171867, -0.018449170514941216, 0.013328393921256065, 0.010301975533366203, -0.0325489267706871, 0.003285082522779703, 0.025810573250055313, -0.010362623259425163, -0.009276323951780796, -0.04556175321340561, 0.10175884515047073, -0.02186538092792034, 0.03449851647019386, 0.013330611400306225, -0.020338019356131554, -0.02691401168704033, 0.017037436366081238, 0.05106494575738907, 0.027884911745786667, -0.008216573856770992, -0.009156853891909122, -0.02353602461516857, 0.0009001234429888427, -0.03621542453765869, -0.06991969794034958, 0.01910950243473053, 0.02757657691836357, -0.02208561822772026, 0.006824444979429245, 0.011501132510602474, -0.03184693306684494, 0.00925084576010704, 0.025131162256002426, -0.021153859794139862, -0.005482986103743315, -0.024884214624762535, 0.020875420421361923, 0.007665339391678572, 0.03211916983127594, 0.05498669669032097, -0.0015298784710466862, 0.024272967129945755, 0.0234067440032959, 0.022975172847509384, 0.02698707953095436, -0.02712804451584816, 0.06260170042514801, -0.004092991352081299, 0.030201643705368042, -0.021846137940883636, -0.009153085760772228, -0.010379364714026451, 0.010259939357638359, -0.032815542072057724, -0.04911927506327629, 0.032927531749010086, -0.00592549704015255, 0.01577712595462799, 0.004002403933554888, -0.06438124924898148, -0.029570698738098145, -0.020867280662059784, 0.024440377950668335, 0.056652672588825226, -0.04384739324450493, 0.012998945079743862, -0.0524321012198925, 0.060784757137298584, -0.014609943144023418, 0.01465052179992199, -0.003825039602816105, 0.056074708700180054, -0.014266371726989746, 0.01840624026954174, 0.03486841171979904, -0.009123965166509151, 0.0116196284070611, 0.01783480867743492, 0.039567772299051285, 0.029601382091641426, 0.03440503776073456, -0.03744126856327057, 0.04838545247912407, 0.0011960373958572745, -0.04679231718182564, -0.012011449784040451, 0.004923210013657808, 0.0028793823439627886, -0.05276162922382355, 0.04992752894759178, 0.0031136367470026016, -0.027631405740976334, -0.021604066714644432, 0.012552332133054733, 0.014310324564576149, -0.009323760867118835, -0.04935552552342415, -0.07698731124401093, 0.018284980207681656, -0.06953847408294678, 0.027703935280442238, -0.08033166825771332, 0.0293252132833004, 0.042094919830560684, 0.06929745525121689, -0.019767707213759422, 0.04710907116532326, 0.032029833644628525, 0.020983045920729637, 0.02343275025486946, -0.023570111021399498, -0.03137316182255745, -0.014295833185315132, -0.03281646594405174, -0.0165804922580719, -0.05513789504766464, 0.001427043927833438, 0.02516143023967743, -0.020677540451288223, -0.01156335324048996, 0.04905371367931366, 0.0067883566953241825, 0.01140658650547266, 0.00783208291977644, 0.022602630779147148, -0.020944062620401382, 0.07253897190093994, -0.006346386391669512, 0.030654247850179672, 0.04068640246987343, -0.008190757595002651, 0.02861671894788742, 0.03353280574083328, 0.02543950453400612, 0.06710954755544662, -0.04332301393151283, -0.024201780557632446, -0.018431680276989937, 0.03080303780734539, 0.012728026136755943, -0.03226779028773308, -0.02217419445514679, -0.0046071987599134445, -0.005333650857210159, -0.01282228622585535, 0.07031869143247604, 0.017469678074121475, -0.0352771133184433, 0.001201233477331698, 0.014348541386425495, 0.04041038826107979, -0.06141287088394165, 0.0023382341023534536, 0.037707507610321045, -0.018673749640583992, 0.012704171240329742, -0.0007821401813998818, 0.005600282922387123, -0.03162384405732155, -0.012784353457391262, -0.009585870429873466, 0.009279211051762104, -0.007532219402492046, -0.021167214959859848, -0.004251174628734589, 0.03619430586695671, 0.035380564630031586, 0.01817605458199978, 0.06751830130815506, -0.04836855083703995, -0.0013576544588431716, 0.013900909572839737, 0.005376959685236216, 0.012577012181282043, -0.02595621347427368, 0.03083922527730465, 0.015094025060534477, 0.0074046277441084385, -0.0020542549900710583, 0.051131606101989746, -0.04103529080748558, 0.021726330742239952, 0.017021991312503815, 0.06523509323596954, -0.00923546776175499, 0.014993340708315372, 0.05616874620318413, -0.005319601856172085, -0.021495794877409935, -0.039258383214473724, -0.05960004776716232, 0.03718569502234459, 0.01996678113937378, 0.02745540626347065, -0.04504133388400078, 0.009790576994419098, 0.03864404559135437, 0.04712527245283127, -0.005458137486129999, 0.039898887276649475, -0.022191010415554047, 0.023993615061044693, 0.03571578487753868, 0.038142602890729904, 0.026583231985569, 0.001345639699138701, 0.006270325742661953, 0.0006288351723924279, 0.042120352387428284, 0.025188446044921875, -0.013311073184013367, 0.05048862844705582, 0.00028532001306302845, 0.0046502770856022835, 0.008354658260941505, 0.006149055436253548, -0.0018282359233126044, -0.012449278496205807, 0.041491273790597916, 0.008968683890998363, 0.01051252894103527, -0.0345773808658123, 0.017026491463184357, -0.01505520660430193, 0.027928082272410393, 0.010800080373883247, -0.04340030997991562, -0.014556263573467731, 0.05387764424085617, 0.00021212256979197264, 0.028461391106247902, 0.002419732976704836, -0.053802743554115295, 0.00013742054579779506, -0.025547606870532036, -0.009186824783682823, -0.028221122920513153, 0.027581043541431427, -0.05944545939564705, -0.0061627645045518875, -0.0348622128367424, -0.036398451775312424, 0.027471626177430153, -0.004133920650929213, -0.029855603352189064, 0.009961026720702648, -0.01599735952913761, -0.003063949290663004, 0.04191724956035614, -0.010347004979848862, 0.03156999871134758, 0.06266747415065765, -0.02976495400071144, -0.04832339659333229, -0.014774437062442303, -0.04651588574051857, 0.022249415516853333, -0.053530629724264145, -0.007528198882937431, 0.03107510879635811, 0.02379637397825718, -0.05093681439757347, 0.019178474321961403, -0.027964388951659203, -0.03463655710220337, -0.03421865776181221, -0.016382846981287003, 0.040239524096250534, -0.013965067453682423, 0.05157458782196045, 0.011963474564254284, -0.007168330252170563, -0.019115682691335678, -0.09864218533039093, -0.08979172259569168, 0.020488645881414413, -0.026125239208340645, 0.0002997256233356893, -0.0027789559680968523, -0.04671264439821243, 0.05893711373209953, 0.049169447273015976, -0.007208748254925013, -0.0156964473426342, -0.023555077612400055, 0.02556784078478813, -0.008086328394711018, 0.008112426847219467, 0.009664267301559448, -0.00007367752550635487, 0.04286446422338486, 0.012130677700042725, 0.023692328482866287, 0.07405491173267365, -0.012971838004887104, 0.012907365337014198, 0.021520061418414116, 0.010988699272274971, -0.0030877261888235807, 0.03370051831007004, 0.028037305921316147, -0.00586431659758091, 0.01185749564319849, 0.026455126702785492, 0.03119647689163685, 0.01869853027164936, -0.03968072310090065, 0.014243517071008682, -0.04632231593132019, 0.02046128176152706, -0.0012251840671524405, 0.0636846199631691, 0.02271183207631111, -0.01262539904564619, 0.0017046148423105478, -0.012796100229024887, 0.017969369888305664, -0.04126830771565437, 0.032999295741319656, 0.07175127416849136, 0.008417428471148014, -0.06773171573877335, -0.03884073346853256, 0.017454808577895164, 0.005752938333898783, 0.006276951637119055, -0.012849302031099796, -0.043139033019542694, 0.010110434144735336, 0.05797325447201729, 0.00844036228954792, 0.013508560135960579, -0.033378876745700836, 0.0004189032770227641, -0.07119818031787872, -0.01739071123301983, 0.006731335539370775, 0.053683239966630936, -0.030005665495991707, 0.05207901820540428, -0.012369900941848755, 0.03811780363321304, 0.03222393989562988, 0.009384348057210445, -0.07984283566474915, -0.03082738071680069, -0.022532779723405838, -0.005898273549973965, -0.018001245334744453, -0.07305555045604706, 0.03458018973469734, -0.036110833287239075, 0.003235115436837077, -0.035063765943050385, 0.024835430085659027, -0.05178472772240639, -0.014066161587834358, -0.03288719803094864, -0.04714272916316986, 0.001042216899804771, 0.002938624005764723, 0.03596171736717224, -0.032274290919303894, 0.04618529602885246, 0.02751678042113781, -0.009049872867763042, -0.02691398561000824, 0.006472935434430838, -0.01823992095887661, -0.016366321593523026, 0.025874074548482895, 0.0004201486590318382, 0.02371354214847088, 0.0008359821513295174, 0.008058309555053711, -0.0038222100120037794, 0.06936658173799515, 0.006972132716327906, -0.0044707017950713634, -0.01306729856878519, -0.014587674289941788, -0.047852370887994766, -0.02128981053829193, 0.03427105396986008, -0.011213073506951332, 0.009649605490267277, 0.036020711064338684, 0.024459687992930412, -0.018551278859376907, 0.01650593802332878, 0.06223748251795769, 0.043316490948200226, -0.013883396051824093, -0.012160521000623703, -0.0071744355373084545, -0.036363035440444946, -0.001160477171652019, 0.030462859198451042, -0.04788142442703247, -0.022354470565915108, -0.035782940685749054, 0.06449386477470398, 0.019993677735328674, -0.007587932050228119, 0.030239470303058624, 0.01682356372475624, 0.0034796001855283976, 0.009140082634985447, -0.05042487382888794, 0.024040529504418373, 0.029086077585816383, -0.011302493512630463, 0.0216242503374815, -0.01759897544980049, -0.054559916257858276, 0.03103468008339405, 0.04904370754957199, 0.0158427432179451, 0.011650215834379196, -0.01606607623398304, -0.05139460414648056, 0.010412346571683884, 0.01461618859320879, -0.01785590685904026, 0.05263194441795349, -0.004283220507204533, 0.02297796867787838, -0.04137653484940529, -0.026603026315569878, -0.015290426090359688, 0.02485271543264389, -0.009322117082774639, 0.04479867219924927, -0.011412348598241806, -0.03654279559850693, 0.007323289290070534, -0.004482626914978027, 0.06739702075719833, 0.07122830301523209, -0.04392397403717041, -0.015599238686263561, 0.0072545199654996395, 0.04889359325170517, -0.013644438236951828, -0.0732136070728302, 0.03029327467083931, -0.006073347758501768, -0.0014025847194716334, 0.029866505414247513, -0.03002924658358097, -0.025064248591661453, 0.007866487838327885, -0.027534829452633858, 0.013538354076445103, 0.03666502609848976, -0.02002018876373768, 0.060712866485118866, 0.007593842688947916, 0.020891277119517326, 0.06329988688230515, 0.03668387234210968, 0.023628152906894684, 0.02453521639108658, -0.025413641706109047, -0.010546648874878883, -0.04466667026281357, -0.008843758143484592, -0.008002003654837608, -0.023427173495292664, -0.02202501893043518, 0.02194405347108841, -0.024987561628222466, 0.022806130349636078, -0.0006021658191457391, -0.024892883375287056, -0.01463510561734438, -0.000856503495015204, 0.040173355489969254, 0.024047762155532837, -0.037859831005334854, 0.0063110096380114555, -0.010723895393311977, -0.03722361847758293, 0.006177195813506842, -0.01317119412124157, -0.00600607693195343, 0.00938994437456131, -0.006025032140314579, 0.02751019597053528, -0.04168596863746643, -0.004158463329076767, 0.005437670741230249, -0.0417068749666214, 0.0267709381878376, 0.004012223798781633, 0.028938444331288338, 0.022352924570441246, -0.013314221054315567, -0.015308692120015621, 0.013357151299715042, 0.012635970488190651, 0.015781916677951813, -0.06522966176271439, 0.007488662842661142, 0.03189609944820404, -0.019836554303765297, -0.043148238211870193, -0.0481116808950901, 0.009951074607670307, 0.015181181952357292, 0.009178148582577705, -0.05467766523361206, -0.008798213675618172, 0.005332981701940298, -0.046928707510232925, -0.01402461901307106, 0.03903045132756233, 0.0031414127442985773, -0.03474496677517891, 0.040139198303222656, -0.006981879938393831, 0.026390688493847847, 0.06133800745010376, 0.018466297537088394, 0.03873903676867485, -0.011833857744932175, 0.0048140874132514, -0.01345617976039648, 0.013361666351556778, 0.009317850694060326, -0.029467668384313583, -0.0655604898929596, -0.015291767194867134, 0.026532048359513283, -0.02537382021546364, -0.0020764220971614122, 0.04545794054865837, 0.023547613993287086, -0.01276374515146017, -0.01625383459031582, -0.04138730838894844, -0.014754578471183777, 0.0077726696617901325, -0.003886535530909896, -0.01772184669971466, -0.00014078154345043004, -0.014839562587440014, -0.006153967697173357, 0.004495336674153805, -0.014624974690377712, -0.02146420069038868, 0.09379229694604874, -0.0035632194485515356, -0.02005559392273426, 0.028813645243644714, -0.005319247022271156, 0.04433164745569229, -0.01577742211520672, -0.047686800360679626, -0.012647454626858234, 0.03296089917421341, -0.013916599564254284, -0.011026511900126934, -0.026112038642168045, 0.00967346504330635, 0.05405806005001068, 0.006726779043674469, 0.05158242583274841, 0.045622341334819794, 0.017880938947200775, -0.007167380303144455, 0.008731598034501076, -0.00389970769174397, -0.0066437446512281895, 0.0008306094678118825, 0.019722314551472664, -0.0247236005961895, 0.025054700672626495, 0.05707108601927757, 0.03215966746211052, 0.019048744812607765, 0.014618588611483574, 0.03560905158519745, -0.000860482279676944, 0.036874786019325256, 0.018157992511987686, -0.05699964240193367, 0.01606937311589718, -0.0649261623620987, -0.02171976864337921, -0.020663511008024216, -0.040864575654268265, 0.03451792895793915, 0.005419332068413496, -0.010078507475554943, -0.02335493080317974, -0.04110657796263695, -0.023407576605677605, -0.01539807952940464, -0.002127920277416706, -0.007845832034945488, 0.03343688324093819, 0.010539872571825981, -0.002169419312849641, -0.008557889610528946, 0.01218677219003439, -0.013015597127377987, -0.06841061264276505, 0.007097786758095026, -0.05918405205011368, -0.016550272703170776, -0.018203334882855415, 0.01756165362894535, 0.025310911238193512, 0.017630385234951973, 0.005365327466279268, 0.026189981028437614, 0.047313883900642395, 0.04516058787703514, -0.0414535254240036, 0.06162148714065552, 0.028110036626458168, 0.003974218852818012, -0.02510109543800354, 0.0002689608372747898, 0.12006755918264389, 0.03524061292409897, 0.041744787245988846, -0.08424278348684311, 0.027979491278529167, -0.006791329011321068, -0.010577811859548092, -0.032992709428071976, 0.003364815143868327, -0.023401666432619095, 0.0267014242708683, 0.010791439563035965, 0.04489606246352196, 0.04494975879788399, -0.019461972638964653, 0.01876998506486416, -0.02315438538789749, -0.0416947640478611, 0.04567593336105347, 0.0304122157394886, -0.01466578058898449, -0.012889580801129341, -0.05029091238975525, 0.009783362038433552, -0.004063478671014309, -0.015467027202248573, -0.03899350017309189, -0.0061447820626199245, 0.022932205349206924, -0.004086995031684637, -0.019288429990410805, -0.002171041676774621, 0.07797640562057495, -0.03724244236946106, -0.014436691999435425, 0.004549361765384674, 0.018878314644098282, -0.0329371802508831, 0.024840710684657097, 0.004357290919870138, 0.02797403186559677, -0.013429567217826843, 0.029698386788368225, -0.018506910651922226, -0.031247049570083618, -0.003879572032019496, -0.016708383336663246, 0.04572725296020508, -0.03356008976697922, 0.015004022978246212, -0.01342272199690342, -0.03419199213385582, 0.02260250225663185, -0.04701005667448044, -0.003938696812838316, -0.020654762163758278, -0.01504814438521862, 0.006027973257005215, -0.016637571156024933, -0.03954309597611427, 0.010006621479988098, -0.006379736587405205, -0.010535835288465023, 0.034719519317150116, -0.04270968958735466, 0.012078400701284409, 0.019324613735079765, 0.043662313371896744, -0.018013237044215202, -0.005026566796004772, -0.03745978698134422, -0.06235964223742485, -0.03297136723995209, -0.050699714571237564, 0.0020215590484440327, -0.016404328867793083, 0.039700575172901154, 0.0098717100918293, -0.018498988822102547, 0.02973797731101513, -0.06993566453456879, -0.02885124273598194, -0.03277084603905678, -0.015106053091585636, -0.04100066423416138, 0.023413974791765213, 0.02807033248245716, 0.039828576147556305, 0.008202222175896168, -0.03318734094500542, 0.03369980677962303, 0.034442029893398285, 0.02924373745918274, -0.019990041851997375, 0.028097622096538544, -0.03873884677886963, -0.017466498538851738, 0.00817446131259203, -0.04362158477306366, 0.042111314833164215, -0.0048285056836903095, 0.03446640446782112, -0.0031496859155595303, -0.004071126226335764, -0.03656797483563423, 0.010022280737757683, -0.014490071684122086, -0.03131925314664841, 0.02152421325445175, 0.04150325059890747, 0.04207713529467583, -0.01570647768676281, 0.005206760950386524, -0.01211455836892128, 0.02520160749554634, 0.03258701413869858, -0.04060833901166916, -0.07973612844944, -0.047785814851522446, -0.018613768741488457, 0.013175133615732193, -0.03501792624592781, -0.0027524996548891068, -0.010650580748915672, -0.015344062820076942, 0.03435538336634636, -0.011433265171945095, -0.05670323967933655, -0.00914186891168356, -0.0006014613900333643, -0.02341516688466072, 0.06764108687639236, -0.0009276694036088884, -0.011090276762843132, 0.005335759837180376, 0.020319821313023567, -0.029754314571619034, 0.03965383023023605, -0.028582174330949783, -0.01814310811460018, 0.05555279180407524, -0.04145241528749466, 0.005143315996974707, -0.016406182199716568, 0.024585016071796417, 0.037439536303281784, 0.0471353605389595, -0.03079868294298649, -0.03393265977501869, 0.04007001221179962, -0.015107754617929459, 0.01766938716173172, 0.00782826542854309, -0.014328970573842525, -0.007569030858576298, 0.023849599063396454, -0.022620076313614845, 0.008572239428758621, -0.0031962417997419834, 0.026860734447836876, -0.018689464777708054, 0.01264242921024561, -0.04035632312297821, 0.014699391089379787, 0.06000677868723869, 0.002624270273372531, 0.011600950732827187, -0.030176661908626556, -0.0003619070921558887, 0.048088639974594116, -0.0382816419005394, 0.017511354759335518, -0.022863682359457016, -0.0054417266510427, -0.04248988628387451, -0.026366909965872765, 0.03629561513662338, -0.001657092827372253, 0.00399722158908844, -0.019138187170028687, 0.015652574598789215, 0.023238403722643852, -0.029859470203518867, -0.015430347993969917, 0.01672736182808876, -0.046122532337903976, -0.04934202507138252, 0.04433484002947807, -0.06805939972400665, 0.009966108947992325, 0.007587634027004242, 0.04601188749074936, 0.022305607795715332, -0.006835854612290859, -0.022985322400927544, -0.034898459911346436, -0.022207550704479218, -0.0021663315128535032, 0.007728085853159428, -0.04705667868256569, 0.037691548466682434, -0.012640955857932568, -0.005299777258187532, 0.04264140874147415, -0.0031074935104697943, -0.03510163724422455, 0.0045855422504246235, 0.028139768168330193, 0.003278137184679508, 0.06433946639299393, -0.012757224030792713, -0.03313528746366501, -0.006174618843942881, -0.01057139877229929, -0.018105121329426765, 0.007350059226155281, -0.009729104116559029, -0.010322966612875462, 0.01306923944503069, 0.007855791598558426, -0.07617070525884628, 0.009850269183516502, 0.026695892214775085, -0.027188710868358612, 0.012723876163363457, -0.02464079111814499, -0.01202963013201952, -0.02547350339591503, 0.0510672889649868, -0.01215401291847229, 0.011476419866085052, 0.025873886421322823, 0.038388315588235855, -0.04480923339724541, 0.01945428177714348, 0.02614014968276024, -0.056324463337659836, 0.010741958394646645, 0.03862551227211952, -0.022574594244360924, -0.032858848571777344, 0.0022312537766993046, -0.00500720739364624, 0.00812423974275589, -0.004685576073825359, -0.06896375119686127, -0.056339435279369354, 0.024311762303113937, -0.016285518184304237, 0.008475018665194511, -0.00004601918044500053, -0.013733922503888607, -0.05023321509361267, -0.05472763255238533, 0.06497698277235031, 0.040249645709991455, 0.05051647871732712, -0.06402821838855743, 0.002220133086666465, -0.0720139816403389, 0.008648506365716457, 0.05062215030193329, 0.011686363257467747, -0.010204303078353405, 0.0005708139506168664, 0.02280944213271141, 0.05186775326728821, -0.014009078033268452, 0.021128587424755096, -0.011408372782170773, -0.0007394776330329478, -0.04024335369467735, -0.003556751413270831, -0.016160689294338226, 0.0074079809710383415, 0.010419690981507301, -0.0003016840491909534, -0.01258239895105362, -0.009157691150903702, 0.0076577612198889256, 0.022896192967891693, 0.010064908303320408, 0.03171202540397644, 0.09158146381378174, -0.01429760456085205, 0.026220567524433136, -0.020251696929335594, -0.007278957404196262, -0.03269295021891594, 0.03836502879858017, -0.055843811482191086, 0.0069722142070531845, -0.016179678961634636, 0.025078333914279938, 0.037153344601392746, -0.04815484583377838, -0.02925286814570427, 0.017885571345686913, -0.02881651744246483, -0.011965611949563026, 0.008214938454329967, -0.002849032636731863, 0.026462657377123833, -0.00590748805552721, 0.05342457816004753, -0.0013487626565620303, 0.01484321616590023, 0.041253235191106796, 0.03252555802464485, 0.006915131583809853, -0.004743351601064205, 0.02997324988245964, 0.060346491634845734, -0.030720742419362068, 0.024566050618886948, -0.009543321095407009, 0.008603849448263645, -0.004199332557618618, -0.03410342335700989, 0.029057787731289864, 0.0075391000136733055, 0.007559374440461397, -0.004413233604282141, -0.0417158305644989, 0.06285465508699417, -0.03375643491744995, 0.05090244859457016, -0.004865783732384443, -0.011526859365403652, 0.010630322620272636, -0.010594217106699944, 0.02297051064670086, -0.03240761160850525, 0.001662420341745019, 0.0009994441643357277, 0.017866816371679306, -0.017029551789164543, 0.014952156692743301, -0.03302966430783272, -0.008129559457302094, -0.008644825778901577, -0.027469342574477196, -0.009852414950728416, 0.025647137314081192, 0.001151965232565999, -0.01514066755771637, -0.008383032865822315, 0.038954392075538635, 0.015093683265149593, -0.017111357301473618, 0.008761103264987469, -0.002537141088396311, 0.043416574597358704, -0.04163554310798645, -0.01081114448606968, -0.025086499750614166, -0.014693974517285824, 0.015989990904927254, -0.04753934219479561 ]
<p>I'm reproducing an example from <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0470073713" rel="nofollow">Generalized, Linear, and Mixed Models</a>. My MWE is below:</p> <pre><code>Dilution &lt;- c(1/128, 1/64, 1/32, 1/16, 1/8, 1/4, 1/2, 1, 2, 4) NoofPlates &lt;- rep(x=5, times=10) NoPositive &lt;- c(0, 0, 2, 2, 3, 4, 5, 5, 5, 5) Data &lt;- data.frame(Dilution, NoofPlates, NoPositive) fm1 &lt;- glm(formula=NoPositive/NoofPlates~log(Dilution), family=binomial("logit"), data=Data) summary(object=fm1) </code></pre> <hr> <p><strong>Output</strong></p> <hr> <pre><code>Call: glm(formula = NoPositive/NoofPlates ~ log(Dilution), family = binomial("logit"), data = Data) Deviance Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -0.38326 -0.20019 0.00871 0.15607 0.48505 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) (Intercept) 4.174 2.800 1.491 0.136 log(Dilution) 1.623 1.022 1.587 0.112 (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1) Null deviance: 8.24241 on 9 degrees of freedom Residual deviance: 0.64658 on 8 degrees of freedom AIC: 6.8563 Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 6 </code></pre> <hr> <p><strong>Code</strong></p> <hr> <pre><code>anova(object=fm1, test="Chisq") </code></pre> <hr> <p><strong>Output</strong></p> <hr> <pre><code>Analysis of Deviance Table Model: binomial, link: logit Response: NoPositive/NoofPlates Terms added sequentially (first to last) Df Deviance Resid. Df Resid. Dev Pr(&gt;Chi) NULL 9 8.2424 log(Dilution) 1 7.5958 8 0.6466 0.00585 ** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 </code></pre> <hr> <p><strong>Code</strong></p> <hr> <pre><code>library(aod) wald.test(b=coef(object=fm1), Sigma=vcov(object=fm1), Terms=2) </code></pre> <hr> <p><strong>Output</strong></p> <hr> <pre><code>Wald test: ---------- Chi-squared test: X2 = 2.5, df = 1, P(&gt; X2) = 0.11 </code></pre> <p>Estimated coefficients are perfectly matching with the results given in the book but SE's are far apart. Based on LRT test the slope is significant but based on Wald and Z-test slope coefficient is insignificant. I wonder if I miss something basic. Thanks in advance for your help.</p>
73,618
[ -0.018905723467469215, 0.030643895268440247, 0.024171512573957443, -0.0036982945166528225, 0.03636559844017029, 0.004672388546168804, -0.008998891338706017, -0.05888277664780617, 0.0064667826518416405, -0.026933006942272186, 0.0551237128674984, 0.04657075181603432, 0.07877151668071747, 0.014470714144408703, 0.041568826884031296, -0.004557995591312647, 0.024194398894906044, 0.01967449299991131, 0.0439874567091465, -0.002742279786616564, -0.026769667863845825, 0.015364913269877434, 0.010007370263338089, -0.0037391798105090857, -0.019265642389655113, 0.05960362032055855, 0.031712695956230164, -0.012785164639353752, -0.006033493671566248, 0.05858960747718811, -0.10068169981241226, -0.00856212992221117, -0.0021887144539505243, 0.001975943334400654, -0.0067055863328278065, 0.043077535927295685, -0.01912773586809635, -0.0005863573751412332, 0.008438586257398129, 0.005753364413976669, -0.001081732101738453, 0.0014348390977829695, -0.006078979466110468, 0.027853982523083687, 0.004081060644239187, -0.0014275213470682502, 0.020021377131342888, 0.001164277084171772, 0.07046201825141907, -0.027628229930996895, 0.05547046288847923, -0.018530206754803658, 0.03848976641893387, 0.05742926523089409, -0.024693384766578674, 0.01156906969845295, 0.04744267836213112, 0.06646165996789932, -0.022268502041697502, -0.06969591230154037, -0.017725342884659767, -0.041913118213415146, 0.017837533727288246, -0.009397951886057854, -0.027854235842823982, -0.02197064831852913, 0.014106015674769878, -0.021588385105133057, 0.023464322090148926, -0.020356034860014915, 0.029668426141142845, 0.010980730876326561, 0.03670242801308632, -0.008411053568124771, 0.043390486389398575, -0.0017404792597517371, -0.03332258388400078, -0.02780844457447529, 0.010011808946728706, 0.04436052590608597, -0.019487928599119186, 0.01723959669470787, -0.004821786191314459, 0.015711354091763496, -0.011149798519909382, -0.0035775157157331705, 0.04201569780707359, -0.030877720564603806, 0.02553388476371765, 0.038128312677145004, -0.023349199444055557, 0.01691347546875477, 0.06701774150133133, 0.037201642990112305, -0.006696208380162716, 0.036737121641635895, -0.02023453637957573, 0.028060633689165115, 0.006535325665026903, -0.025800365954637527, -0.0450933538377285, -0.05283288657665253, 0.003404218703508377, 0.025205431506037712, -0.04670098051428795, 0.005492318421602249, -0.04283829778432846, -0.033998601138591766, 0.010672032833099365, -0.048124760389328, 0.0004019276238977909, 0.057791899889707565, -0.014920777641236782, 0.0034706604201346636, 0.008240736089646816, -0.0731896385550499, -0.02426925301551819, -0.00015243310190271586, 0.07131686061620712, 0.035040028393268585, 0.03902435675263405, -0.01159209106117487, 0.008859346620738506, -0.012363470159471035, -0.02312173694372177, 0.0074320523999631405, 0.012776732444763184, 0.021815385669469833, 0.017474355176091194, 0.05812983587384224, -0.007868560962378979, -0.032558225095272064, 0.036290764808654785, 0.026258079335093498, 0.016590245068073273, 0.00009826871246332303, -0.08290074020624161, -0.06927432864904404, 0.04394030198454857, -0.019423160701990128, 0.022237157449126244, -0.041045453399419785, 0.011928776279091835, 0.041386328637599945, 0.026258213445544243, 0.013727093115448952, 0.04490421712398529, 0.029438422992825508, 0.03380008786916733, 0.0021605812944471836, -0.010238380171358585, -0.01942293345928192, -0.057415544986724854, 0.006326002534478903, -0.027722174301743507, -0.07796011120080948, 0.009552542120218277, 0.010526638478040695, -0.025013042613863945, 0.024000048637390137, 0.013926939107477665, 0.003474607365205884, -0.008036203682422638, 0.0024354998022317886, -0.0186296533793211, -0.030842941254377365, 0.08226878196001053, -0.021359434351325035, 0.02224217727780342, 0.052363019436597824, -0.04488628730177879, -0.011899148114025593, -0.036548927426338196, 0.04319833219051361, 0.02833797037601471, -0.0100044971331954, 0.0034579515922814608, -0.03176493942737579, 0.02636287361383438, 0.042165108025074005, -0.03804083913564682, 0.0025897410232573748, -0.023112129420042038, -0.03974669799208641, 0.04249466210603714, 0.005156154278665781, -0.002307809889316559, -0.026067007333040237, 0.059454623609781265, -0.04760565981268883, -0.0338955819606781, -0.04336234927177429, -0.0040951501578092575, 0.03119698539376259, -0.012644385918974876, 0.0007885762606747448, 0.003965468145906925, 0.03878984972834587, 0.012535925954580307, 0.028523052111268044, -0.04155609756708145, 0.005888466723263264, 0.03257448226213455, -0.029904356226325035, -0.018382694572210312, 0.02980864979326725, 0.037372879683971405, -0.020635457709431648, 0.03970248997211456, -0.0444779247045517, 0.005594109650701284, -0.003080024616792798, -0.028217719867825508, 0.016878079622983932, -0.006660331506282091, -0.02590826526284218, -0.008851774036884308, -0.005569957662373781, -0.005555325653403997, 0.03798303008079529, -0.04576583579182625, 0.059408724308013916, 0.06493257731199265, 0.0067341565154492855, -0.01614491641521454, -0.018140481784939766, -0.017493274062871933, 0.0551602728664875, -0.0504852831363678, 0.015582982450723648, -0.031331416219472885, -0.03397011011838913, 0.05192198604345322, 0.018257413059473038, -0.032229989767074585, -0.015274927951395512, 0.03595660626888275, -0.037516772747039795, 0.02579103782773018, 0.04738609865307808, 0.00046444812323898077, -0.04159286618232727, 0.03274737298488617, 0.02596406079828739, 0.017944470047950745, 0.004363476764410734, 0.01669500395655632, -0.02017734758555889, 0.05178532004356384, -0.005418736953288317, 0.050479527562856674, 0.03153816610574722, 0.01657656952738762, -0.0350198857486248, -0.033014096319675446, 0.016247762367129326, 0.03673238307237625, 0.017723236232995987, -0.00560804596170783, 0.0674210712313652, 0.029566215351223946, -0.029314342886209488, 0.002292277989909053, -0.018254773691296577, 0.020646419376134872, 0.03460879623889923, -0.023054737597703934, 0.01479202788323164, 0.011679611168801785, -0.025002043694257736, 0.03735208511352539, -0.03932458907365799, -0.022899335250258446, -0.02801898866891861, 0.004640602972358465, 0.006413895636796951, 0.0015021605649963021, -0.014890645630657673, -0.034488894045352936, -0.015746859833598137, -0.020461253821849823, -0.006335254292935133, 0.02899746596813202, -0.0039839050732553005, -0.032897111028432846, -0.03184407204389572, -0.021730028092861176, 0.013663365505635738, 0.001053755870088935, 0.02293906919658184, -0.053456321358680725, 0.016045479103922844, -0.0008079212275333703, -0.04200303182005882, -0.048052433878183365, 0.0074601261876523495, 0.012417647987604141, -0.002049541100859642, -0.005490100011229515, 0.03886675834655762, -0.01436334103345871, -0.040598008781671524, -0.006054979283362627, -0.03921853005886078, 0.005329058971256018, -0.003395351581275463, 0.01057756133377552, 0.018106624484062195, 0.024521667510271072, 0.04653922840952873, 0.023315947502851486, -0.016828730702400208, -0.004158081486821175, -0.06274949759244919, -0.01939775049686432, -0.01489256601780653, -0.003315491136163473, 0.015595685690641403, -0.020624836906790733, -0.03969063609838486, 0.05590248480439186, 0.06058133766055107, -0.029960257932543755, -0.06572479009628296, -0.02613874524831772, -0.0020255346316844225, -0.05842723697423935, 0.024475662037730217, 0.0015142967458814383, 0.009491524659097195, 0.040084172040224075, -0.02770448662340641, 0.021516546607017517, 0.021541917696595192, 0.0052812243811786175, 0.019219620153307915, 0.031086431816220284, -0.010006384924054146, -0.06565307080745697, 0.055844224989414215, 0.031421516090631485, -0.0037743765860795975, 0.03128862380981445, -0.007688819896429777, 0.03310350328683853, -0.02911556139588356, -0.07011096924543381, -0.014302577823400497, 0.00764744495972991, 0.018316512927412987, -0.035415731370449066, 0.05904562026262283, 0.031212791800498962, -0.05972001701593399, -0.02698560804128647, -0.007179091684520245, 0.03359316289424896, -0.013327082619071007, -0.012969299219548702, 0.04056398943066597, 0.014633857645094395, -0.00958533026278019, 0.029362061992287636, -0.011124121025204659, -0.007281364873051643, -0.004309447482228279, -0.0056083593517541885, 0.011311046779155731, 0.03898587077856064, 0.018621256574988365, 0.0020193541422486305, -0.002291139680892229, -0.0231139175593853, 0.016455991193652153, -0.020554354414343834, 0.026073848828673363, -0.02769075147807598, 0.020202193409204483, -0.007219268474727869, 0.035817570984363556, -0.022127646952867508, -0.020713355392217636, -0.009950289502739906, -0.04038572683930397, -0.03418026864528656, 0.037138644605875015, -0.007731434889137745, 0.0007916545146144927, -0.0017405212856829166, -0.043080884963274, 0.016627179458737373, -0.03602565452456474, 0.017131701111793518, 0.02730274759232998, 0.01058997493237257, -0.011155220679938793, 0.016502628102898598, -0.0006169314729049802, -0.0024226768873631954, -0.006556944455951452, 0.0035950627643615007, -0.0064896163530647755, -0.004671173635870218, 0.024559013545513153, 0.030624227598309517, 0.004533530678600073, 0.009308382868766785, -0.01725040376186371, 0.022497497498989105, 0.03543940186500549, 0.05416485667228699, 0.00767685379832983, -0.0038774211425334215, -0.022033879533410072, 0.0486128069460392, 0.0012019086861982942, 0.02907794713973999, 0.05507984384894371, 0.00858582928776741, 0.004429703112691641, -0.02321925014257431, -0.016736634075641632, 0.012681136839091778, 0.0011291946284472942, -0.010551432147622108, 0.03209828585386276, 0.04035099223256111, 0.02103298157453537, -0.02367078699171543, 0.031076349318027496, 0.04275760427117348, -0.0011057555675506592, -0.009923082776367664, -0.004843788221478462, -0.015961725264787674, 0.0013256407110020518, 0.005821011494845152, 0.022331051528453827, 0.02259303815662861, 0.004799149464815855, 0.010015534237027168, 0.027557387948036194, -0.016253791749477386, -0.03607185184955597, -0.002259255852550268, 0.04861316457390785, 0.03098510578274727, -0.004690664820373058, -0.032307062298059464, -0.022691458463668823, 0.033568091690540314, 0.031589411199092865, 0.012944615446031094, 0.006444685161113739, -0.07646840810775757, 0.006282447371631861, 0.04549645632505417, 0.0541112907230854, -0.0015895996475592256, 0.024693863466382027, -0.04159802198410034, -0.058187149465084076, -0.009838609024882317, -0.04214287921786308, 0.025682561099529266, -0.002406977815553546, 0.025433477014303207, 0.006784348748624325, -0.0067516956478357315, -0.09059817343950272, -0.01548253744840622, -0.022057216614484787, -0.016357140615582466, -0.008086052723228931, -0.0123509606346488, -0.03158422186970711, -0.008919449523091316, -0.022753316909074783, 0.02389342524111271, -0.0698801800608635, -0.014465050771832466, 0.03437532112002373, 0.02077401429414749, -0.002702191472053528, -0.013827769085764885, 0.022535216063261032, -0.023274773731827736, 0.0007849496905691922, 0.05080650374293327, -0.0028539407067000866, -0.01332078780978918, 0.005622349679470062, 0.035843443125486374, -0.005884355399757624, 0.030436638742685318, -0.026813173666596413, 0.03023645654320717, 0.0021915852557867765, -0.02185189165174961, 0.05543166399002075, 0.017855780199170113, -0.03259332850575447, 0.04024340212345123, -0.0779789462685585, 0.024168366566300392, -0.036229196935892105, -0.02679572068154812, -0.04497303068637848, -0.017084291204810143, -0.010443965904414654, 0.026450857520103455, 0.0022940621711313725, 0.03674637898802757, -0.026397474110126495, -0.018423374742269516, 0.045428402721881866, 0.006297321990132332, -0.002811237471178174, 0.015366577543318272, 0.04843619093298912, -0.008185393176972866, -0.00790650025010109, 0.008207852952182293, 0.01903727650642395, -0.023732809349894524, -0.00570647232234478, -0.012015038169920444, -0.08619020879268646, 0.002099914476275444, -0.004448190797120333, -0.012925457209348679, -0.024987325072288513, 0.02973274514079094, 0.00229766801930964, 0.031337592750787735, 0.058708369731903076, -0.016659844666719437, -0.066783607006073, 0.002418489893898368, 0.034825850278139114, 0.0019321796717122197, 0.020826430991292, -0.007949571125209332, 0.004413987509906292, -0.015299888327717781, -0.03960628807544708, -0.04658825322985649, -0.018760783597826958, -0.01318203005939722, -0.018153931945562363, -0.043252360075712204, -0.03135926276445389, -0.07725198566913605, 0.0223513375967741, 0.01946227066218853, -0.03362508863210678, 0.056580815464258194, -0.019730014726519585, 0.005685539450496435, 0.020867999643087387, 0.010761196725070477, 0.05330692231655121, 0.001206209883093834, 0.006059044506400824, 0.0035362360067665577, -0.038076985627412796, -0.03323204815387726, 0.010936109349131584, -0.015225471928715706, -0.04064837098121643, -0.04536133632063866, -0.008030406199395657, -0.009430298581719398, 0.02346833609044552, 0.0169806070625782, -0.03293314203619957, -0.012321868911385536, 0.0064998045563697815, 0.043803296983242035, -0.06285644322633743, 0.014660247601568699, -0.021185027435421944, 0.016893187537789345, -0.03427959978580475, 0.026878898963332176, -0.022688722237944603, 0.002877510152757168, 0.03879018500447273, -0.04957790672779083, -0.010064286179840565, -0.0020257497671991587, 0.07514968514442444, -0.013727011159062386, -0.0045564016327261925, 0.02672005072236061, -0.014185513369739056, 0.02121356502175331, 0.0007200352847576141, 0.020799806341528893, 0.0031166968401521444, 0.02240339107811451, -0.035845089703798294, 0.010886827483773232, -0.02362406626343727, 0.01046679075807333, 0.017335260286927223, 0.017212294042110443, -0.006002346053719521, 0.043353546410799026, -0.019936546683311462, -0.002032448071986437, -0.015827486291527748, -0.011506262235343456, 0.0000296789930871455, 0.02409982495009899, 0.07810427248477936, -0.019487855955958366, -0.01422811672091484, 0.04394455999135971, 0.007600075099617243, 0.006424159277230501, 0.000291250878944993, -0.006080735474824905, -0.0063125672750175, 0.0009963370393961668, 0.017881572246551514, -0.01497715525329113, 0.045372478663921356, -0.04343871399760246, 0.020208831876516342, -0.04827458783984184, -0.030178828164935112, 0.0380292683839798, 0.022224100306630135, 0.021401163190603256, -0.04140162095427513, -0.024879029020667076, -0.04175465181469917, 0.019521230831742287, 0.006634564604610205, -0.025294100865721703, 0.010262023657560349, -0.003926192410290241, 0.04203447327017784, -0.018755236640572548, 0.03035433404147625, -0.044080253690481186, -0.07854863256216049, -0.014011534862220287, 0.0123594980686903, -0.012309210374951363, 0.05865143612027168, -0.010506785474717617, -0.03382031247019768, -0.005053333006799221, -0.024680526927113533, 0.004928079899400473, 0.013775897212326527, 0.018369942903518677, 0.0038834114093333483, 0.07759532332420349, -0.013131700456142426, -0.005315237212926149, 0.0025937415193766356, -0.026452932506799698, 0.1504618227481842, 0.06202827766537666, 0.0530172735452652, -0.06977256387472153, 0.002140289405360818, 0.023011041805148125, -0.005739825312048197, -0.008847963996231556, -0.03052661195397377, 0.01508873701095581, -0.029686249792575836, 0.06347642093896866, 0.05044051632285118, 0.049107372760772705, 0.006121452897787094, 0.04313485324382782, -0.045830316841602325, -0.03193846344947815, -0.03606171905994415, 0.019596880301833153, -0.004949280526489019, -0.0252827238291502, -0.04874750226736069, -0.01272539421916008, 0.04263169318437576, -0.01948624663054943, -0.037619926035404205, -0.0067307669669389725, 0.005932008381932974, -0.01877225749194622, -0.02748841978609562, -0.01031297817826271, -0.004055465571582317, -0.0137713011354208, 0.015676354989409447, -0.038232676684856415, 0.05076950043439865, -0.049621760845184326, 0.027622180059552193, 0.06700184941291809, -0.021115334704518318, 0.02986619807779789, 0.015111136250197887, 0.003454475197941065, -0.03193250671029091, -0.024831825867295265, -0.013498431071639061, 0.03045514225959778, -0.0372193269431591, -0.020283592864871025, 0.014925907365977764, -0.026775233447551727, -0.013726286590099335, -0.0398419089615345, -0.01596716418862343, 0.031710442155599594, 0.012496662326157093, 0.002390739507973194, -0.04237863048911095, -0.0140327587723732, 0.022732198238372803, -0.008118044584989548, 0.0383487306535244, 0.021325288340449333, 0.015376919880509377, -0.0505632720887661, -0.04789124056696892, 0.024837933480739594, -0.005755915306508541, 0.009201452136039734, -0.012318363413214684, -0.004903941880911589, 0.005307603627443314, -0.023775573819875717, 0.01357932761311531, 0.018078509718179703, -0.008002587594091892, -0.005614425987005234, -0.0032759944442659616, -0.024125777184963226, -0.05901661887764931, 0.028805594891309738, -0.04542119428515434, -0.018836786970496178, -0.03999032452702522, -0.025766581296920776, 0.01046198420226574, 0.04818897694349289, 0.012273399159312248, 0.012407406233251095, -0.02700192481279373, 0.05420748144388199, -0.011212524957954884, -0.035826217383146286, -0.03578206151723862, 0.052096348255872726, -0.026734236627817154, -0.03621773049235344, -0.008439768105745316, 0.056420646607875824, 0.005336771719157696, 0.027454620227217674, -0.016097908839583397, 0.02431660331785679, -0.028781553730368614, 0.009932625107467175, 0.022773027420043945, -0.029537640511989594, 0.022762268781661987, 0.00006897922867210582, -0.025954101234674454, -0.004120348021388054, -0.017199281603097916, -0.03323986381292343, -0.05357460677623749, 0.03219246864318848, -0.03921030834317207, -0.031616680324077606, -0.005259152501821518, -0.00564195029437542, 0.02562384307384491, -0.025500038638710976, -0.011507455259561539, -0.008626220747828484, -0.020541345700621605, -0.02179219201207161, -0.023977989330887794, -0.014011058956384659, 0.01638927310705185, -0.029031405225396156, 0.02850482612848282, 0.03289014846086502, 0.0006203451775945723, 0.05866500362753868, -0.020369866862893105, 0.017790868878364563, 0.024957314133644104, 0.03745414689183235, 0.00788467563688755, -0.011694868095219135, 0.021302280947566032, -0.06856799125671387, -0.029064025729894638, 0.0009900492150336504, -0.0033565738704055548, 0.03220871090888977, 0.016374114900827408, 0.007647492922842503, -0.05885063111782074, 0.04935337230563164, -0.016533272340893745, -0.004038888029754162, -0.014826754108071327, 0.00878018420189619, 0.020885353907942772, -0.03831489756703377, -0.004465262871235609, 0.028456110507249832, -0.03433794900774956, -0.0044195083901286125, 0.05797453597187996, 0.0016964368987828493, -0.016013696789741516, 0.048424363136291504, -0.040213264524936676, 0.001887091319076717, -0.0024698167107999325, 0.009369640611112118, 0.022349530830979347, 0.05371309071779251, -0.03197135776281357, 0.043443337082862854, -0.04941779375076294, 0.02783597633242607, -0.09554675221443176, -0.03399929404258728, 0.005169794894754887, 0.055057208985090256, 0.04161253198981285, -0.03145093843340874, -0.015356451272964478, 0.01502683013677597, -0.010027606971561909, 0.003435716964304447, 0.017927782610058784, 0.006427137181162834, -0.0536642000079155, 0.041215598583221436, -0.018580500036478043, 0.01753503829240799, 0.04031522199511528, 0.015433792024850845, 0.060112785547971725, 0.000006197641141625354, 0.01807401143014431, -0.03823994845151901, -0.018320640549063683, -0.010792652145028114, 0.030956346541643143, -0.05668289586901665, -0.00025685562286525965, -0.03709997236728668, 0.0007510914583690464, 0.0007254217052832246, 0.009889553301036358, 0.03147865831851959, 0.01949491910636425, 0.029534008353948593, 0.006679078564047813, 0.06758494675159454, -0.01893855258822441, 0.0391349233686924, -0.0062682656571269035, 0.01949392259120941, 0.029801975935697556, 0.0014936730731278658, -0.07793963700532913, 0.004984095226973295, 0.024012988433241844, -0.0014380557695403695, 0.0010342698078602552, 0.04286344721913338, -0.012078879401087761, 0.0007712062797509134, -0.009535985998809338, 0.04162093997001648, 0.010742438957095146, -0.012113364413380623, -0.0019225672585889697, -0.03120221011340618, 0.06780574470758438, 0.04117002710700035, 0.06846795231103897, -0.02828042209148407, 0.03073529154062271, -0.017259065061807632, -0.02549605816602707, -0.0060462444089353085, -0.017104316502809525, -0.04225744307041168, -0.027559418231248856, -0.039191629737615585, -0.014457331039011478, -0.0024647661484777927, 0.022061578929424286, 0.0369190089404583, -0.02535833790898323, 0.03906555473804474, -0.04757841303944588, -0.0035769115202128887, 0.0004825470387004316, 0.03190729394555092, 0.005482673645019531, -0.10939426720142365, 0.04674167558550835, 0.008860169909894466, -0.029040038585662842, -0.06601603329181671, 0.0047001647762954235, -0.045519642531871796, 0.06606964766979218, 0.031345490366220474, 0.03185713663697243, 0.0017917522927746177, -0.001723503228276968, 0.03506874293088913, 0.01211308129131794, -0.039222896099090576, 0.06615709513425827, 0.002175988396629691, -0.00023144084843806922, -0.004882040899246931, 0.020446734502911568, -0.019173534587025642, 0.02139999344944954, 0.012229873798787594, -0.01665237732231617, -0.01703927293419838, 0.008863775990903378, -0.038359757512807846, 0.026659948751330376, -0.002536339219659567, -0.04038238525390625, 0.028208034113049507, -0.04864978417754173, -0.007880285382270813, 0.06293109059333801, 0.025687379762530327, -0.05146199092268944, 0.01764015480875969, -0.03140978887677193, -0.02148246206343174, 0.011041044257581234, -0.007533131167292595, -0.0025505530647933483, -0.0668078362941742, 0.04395940899848938, 0.018132299184799194, -0.025493228808045387, 0.009217264130711555, 0.01746378093957901, 0.010479154996573925, 0.05551934242248535, -0.019660208374261856, 0.011238225735723972, -0.038275495171546936, -0.026576349511742592, 0.02954581007361412, 0.0244316216558218, 0.027043160051107407, -0.02461603283882141, 0.011328681372106075, 0.028909185901284218, 0.0036276604514569044, 0.05403490364551544, -0.01913500390946865, 0.061236001551151276, -0.016188131645321846, 0.005515133496373892, 0.03174431249499321, -0.028253775089979172, 0.020499469712376595, 0.035901010036468506, -0.0004834231222048402, 0.037307433784008026, -0.05253322795033455, -0.0022211188916116953, -0.030457302927970886, -0.04260764643549919, -0.02361225336790085, 0.016249598935246468, 0.010356609709560871, 0.03477933257818222, 0.014241587370634079, 0.042121436446905136, 0.05285950005054474, -0.0405561700463295, 0.011290106922388077, -0.0031838081777095795, 0.0379367396235466, 0.00861619133502245, -0.019646156579256058, -0.023582888767123222, -0.03361968323588371, -0.0028736302629113197, -0.011641815304756165, 0.010682739317417145, 0.00956313218921423, 0.0019012214615941048, -0.09010721743106842, -0.024646254256367683, 0.012864642776548862, 0.007575908675789833, -0.015198457054793835, 0.011417634785175323, -0.0017447989666834474, 0.01996290683746338, -0.0008685302454978228, -0.03743656724691391 ]
<p>I own a url shortening service. I want to deliver only legitimate statistics to my clients. There are possible scenarios that a particular user writes a script to automatically open the shortened URL, thus making the statistics look bad. What are the approaches one can follow to detect if a click is legitimate or not? Please point me to appropriate resources like tools or research papers. The very basic approach that I can think of is to monitor the IP address of the user and block if the number of requests exceed a threshold.</p>
73,619
[ -0.025602668523788452, -0.031118646264076233, -0.012401190586388111, -0.01533771213144064, 0.04576002061367035, 0.02211485058069229, 0.017977099865674973, -0.018478961661458015, 0.009264778345823288, 0.023421918973326683, 0.06236251816153526, 0.05396885424852371, 0.016698487102985382, 0.04787053167819977, -0.02580980211496353, 0.003829275257885456, -0.044523026794195175, -0.017413727939128876, -0.0026823938824236393, -0.01568492129445076, 0.035559289157390594, -0.03439047187566757, 0.007641996722668409, -0.02198398858308792, -0.027762122452259064, -0.020295120775699615, 0.017048927024006844, -0.026953009888529778, 0.023483844473958015, 0.040809448808431625, -0.03439910709857941, -0.0006679788348264992, 0.007215794641524553, 0.037285346537828445, -0.01704493910074234, -0.01290151197463274, -0.0628100335597992, -0.0007036791648715734, -0.014105078764259815, 0.018302731215953827, -0.028757445514202118, 0.02710716985166073, 0.009096618741750717, 0.02904808707535267, -0.011188704520463943, -0.021672621369361877, -0.025888631120324135, -0.024157196283340454, 0.028276978060603142, -0.053967416286468506, 0.06602238118648529, -0.01309880055487156, 0.014468980953097343, -0.02300063893198967, 0.008504298515617847, 0.027357861399650574, 0.046869147568941116, 0.05707273632287979, -0.05814370512962341, -0.04731997102499008, -0.016322441399097443, 0.023717351257801056, 0.021474504843354225, -0.038703955709934235, -0.034478023648262024, 0.040434904396533966, -0.014603511430323124, 0.008716790936887264, 0.028932660818099976, 0.02139916829764843, -0.009605249390006065, -0.01566270925104618, -0.018768250942230225, 0.05133384093642235, 0.01008808147162199, -0.04070819169282913, 0.0034898463636636734, 0.04775005951523781, 0.0583665668964386, 0.04320041090250015, 0.0048513212241232395, -0.02252231538295746, 0.01137107890099287, 0.05635984241962433, 0.03357500582933426, -0.0008479607058688998, 0.05211108177900314, -0.0402592234313488, 0.012570266611874104, 0.033621061593294144, -0.0530419684946537, -0.04830623418092728, 0.014440062455832958, -0.007110899314284325, -0.025975625962018967, 0.010159606114029884, -0.024254905059933662, 0.06420242786407471, 0.005170431919395924, 0.0027768081054091454, 0.0009081569733098149, -0.022914206609129906, -0.015343166887760162, 0.02447337843477726, -0.06312400102615356, -0.016398021951317787, -0.03510579839348793, -0.031376857310533524, -0.02187274768948555, 0.0022277021780610085, -0.04934972524642944, -0.0009603810613043606, 0.04129072278738022, 0.009162019938230515, 0.04167914763092995, -0.013615025207400322, -0.0007702572620473802, -0.037193965166807175, 0.03758317977190018, 0.016120431944727898, 0.061023905873298645, -0.014057228341698647, 0.017970658838748932, -0.04397023096680641, -0.010144708678126335, -0.011513966135680676, 0.023606715723872185, -0.05582510679960251, -0.03576007857918739, 0.0535750612616539, -0.004734307527542114, -0.04378022998571396, 0.0010061700595542789, -0.017378078773617744, 0.039285723119974136, 0.035649850964546204, -0.06549939513206482, -0.04757273942232132, 0.03578505292534828, 0.029845070093870163, 0.0019367029890418053, -0.0718936175107956, -0.020318781957030296, 0.0256216898560524, 0.023634647950530052, 0.04966775327920914, 0.027051793411374092, 0.013029046356678009, -0.028409017249941826, -0.02045629732310772, -0.04359181225299835, 0.009972180239856243, -0.021019667387008667, 0.01730077899992466, -0.007564501836895943, -0.0442199781537056, 0.001630632672458887, -0.018657710403203964, -0.013887162320315838, -0.03221721574664116, 0.02478143945336342, 0.018261902034282684, -0.03118712082505226, -0.009257188998162746, 0.01973368041217327, 0.016135690733790398, 0.10105924308300018, 0.004174538888037205, 0.0072512575425207615, 0.026524962857365608, -0.0411946102976799, 0.024182865396142006, 0.04498371109366417, -0.006981004029512405, 0.01895706169307232, 0.0057538952678442, -0.012300725094974041, -0.012138959020376205, 0.034926168620586395, 0.0023832933511584997, 0.019990773871541023, -0.006396450102329254, -0.005002025980502367, 0.012836753390729427, 0.019403260201215744, 0.017828265205025673, -0.0019191167084500194, -0.0015203867806121707, 0.05730928108096123, -0.05606347694993019, -0.024351533502340317, -0.08054516464471817, 0.01184761244803667, 0.007017455529421568, -0.017560968175530434, 0.031723037362098694, -0.0427941270172596, -0.012146705761551857, -0.03184257447719574, 0.020234057679772377, -0.008853656239807606, -0.0056579760275781155, 0.05217120796442032, -0.04969935491681099, -0.006526424083858728, 0.01003684476017952, -0.010316574014723301, -0.022445833310484886, 0.02497061714529991, -0.026368657127022743, -0.06293010711669922, -0.033082764595746994, -0.007154389284551144, -0.01738087460398674, -0.018326323479413986, 0.001333946012891829, 0.02846340462565422, 0.0020553406793624163, -0.0030965334735810757, -0.004352407995611429, -0.03467654064297676, 0.06315451115369797, 0.013199199922382832, 0.01851220242679119, -0.016641203314065933, -0.004940404556691647, 0.022245435044169426, -0.00944602582603693, -0.002890227595344186, -0.03960031643509865, -0.08075035363435745, -0.015919992700219154, 0.04162544384598732, -0.002437752904370427, -0.049769651144742966, -0.0037977818865329027, 0.07430799305438995, 0.00887314509600401, 0.02605867013335228, 0.02492203563451767, -0.01850593462586403, -0.008042125962674618, 0.03779362887144089, 0.059958137571811676, 0.004768170416355133, 0.05977039411664009, -0.03596465662121773, 0.016301369294524193, 0.01491004228591919, 0.01672915555536747, 0.004796402063220739, -0.002644922584295273, -0.04064265638589859, -0.011793240904808044, -0.0038403591606765985, 0.0025417327415198088, 0.015490178018808365, -0.0054428535513579845, -0.01099670771509409, 0.019540635868906975, 0.0069406782276928425, -0.021701909601688385, 0.02159850299358368, -0.0142308808863163, 0.03491593897342682, 0.0001087221535271965, -0.05108341947197914, -0.04098065569996834, 0.02470947802066803, -0.016239944845438004, 0.020952189341187477, -0.010063729248940945, -0.04035082459449768, -0.04365389049053192, -0.0030967325437813997, 0.023919980973005295, 0.006666426546871662, 0.015350530855357647, 0.009945336729288101, -0.03762068971991539, -0.003107119584456086, -0.030575545504689217, 0.005000926088541746, 0.01151613425463438, -0.006656143348664045, -0.000566575676202774, 0.020969904959201813, 0.008044402115046978, 0.05567252263426781, -0.02160385437309742, 0.05380665883421898, 0.009928771294653416, 0.022671740502119064, -0.024094965308904648, -0.02040662057697773, -0.043810874223709106, 0.02908039465546608, 0.0031517331954091787, -0.010137840174138546, 0.019596876576542854, 0.020014405250549316, -0.0166187584400177, 0.08860496431589127, -0.00284951226785779, -0.02908339723944664, -0.026301497593522072, -0.03920143470168114, -0.010035878978669643, -0.016240155324339867, 0.020660270005464554, 0.02191413752734661, -0.016503816470503807, 0.009152939543128014, -0.040270883589982986, -0.08920051902532578, 0.01769409328699112, 0.01040110643953085, 0.015216280706226826, 0.030897898599505424, -0.03842957317829132, 0.06388525664806366, 0.03490116819739342, -0.014475760981440544, -0.04677810147404671, -0.0369756780564785, -0.011220305226743221, -0.023917071521282196, -0.023598967120051384, 0.01050611399114132, -0.04664304479956627, -0.007378916721791029, 0.03855957090854645, 0.0093924505636096, 0.033307336270809174, 0.021786687895655632, -0.033418599516153336, 0.013100458309054375, -0.027021603658795357, -0.003543674014508724, 0.01454237662255764, 0.055884335190057755, -0.02441558614373207, -0.005424707196652889, 0.0041429088450968266, 0.015459316782653332, 0.01716373674571514, -0.019501104950904846, -0.02020065300166607, 0.011056064628064632, -0.0037626465782523155, 0.010082373395562172, -0.003391261212527752, -0.014368611387908459, -0.03912302106618881, -0.011741193011403084, 0.025805050507187843, 0.012694349512457848, -0.022855035960674286, 0.029785411432385445, 0.06757944077253342, 0.07218372821807861, -0.054778046905994415, -0.054094716906547546, -0.023160265758633614, -0.049288563430309296, 0.024719173088669777, 0.005647189915180206, -0.031906116753816605, 0.04668274149298668, -0.004939028061926365, -0.003442325396463275, 0.0125803267583251, 0.003502767765894532, 0.02935863845050335, -0.07521586865186691, 0.006998250726610422, -0.023344192653894424, 0.03083590790629387, 0.004273115657269955, 0.006168787833303213, 0.022954626008868217, 0.018773706629872322, 0.01169344037771225, 0.05167998746037483, -0.05159859359264374, 0.0223383866250515, -0.05928895249962807, -0.00826482754200697, -0.008398928679525852, -0.03730710595846176, -0.024046918377280235, -0.017280198633670807, 0.036268625408411026, -0.0008435521158389747, 0.04117763042449951, -0.032814718782901764, -0.0009679009090177715, -0.011961834505200386, -0.00029701870516873896, -0.002040553605183959, 0.003681106260046363, -0.010111883282661438, 0.03967644274234772, 0.01708122529089451, 0.018625935539603233, 0.00973713118582964, -0.02305302955210209, -0.015800096094608307, -0.010882740840315819, 0.02192578837275505, 0.028961725533008575, 0.002446640282869339, 0.02322254329919815, -0.04204385355114937, 0.02069617621600628, -0.038928769528865814, 0.01472831517457962, 0.03660319373011589, 0.022678803652524948, -0.04587199166417122, -0.06271786242723465, -0.01856303960084915, 0.027026697993278503, -0.006259811110794544, -0.018112387508153915, 0.03046787902712822, 0.020516464486718178, -0.0033273184671998024, -0.049769748002290726, 0.03378317132592201, 0.08311308175325394, 0.0451994352042675, -0.006353453267365694, -0.01291591115295887, -0.025191225111484528, 0.014026804827153683, -0.012011290527880192, -0.015501483343541622, 0.03583648055791855, 0.015018218196928501, 0.030349070206284523, -0.005294822622090578, -0.030976444482803345, -0.02096240222454071, 0.033641424030065536, 0.006178399082273245, 0.043063219636678696, 0.004748237319290638, -0.009387931786477566, 0.0586392804980278, 0.024060670286417007, 0.015759790316224098, 0.022116409614682198, -0.027709322050213814, -0.09607996791601181, -0.00008402164530707523, 0.08654028922319412, 0.055234674364328384, -0.029627488926053047, 0.004458039067685604, -0.04097704961895943, -0.004827822558581829, 0.04164600744843483, -0.04839517921209335, 0.04987776279449463, -0.00024006716557778418, 0.005245491396635771, -0.005291280336678028, 0.03257398679852486, -0.02232980728149414, -0.00754037918522954, -0.03774048015475273, 0.0041793882846832275, -0.039484359323978424, 0.0031099405605345964, -0.04443644359707832, 0.006292067468166351, 0.006979679223150015, 0.04149452969431877, -0.019167913123965263, -0.020979879423975945, 0.006716927979141474, 0.0010901934001594782, -0.0256658885627985, -0.05370327830314636, 0.014664658345282078, 0.02273033931851387, 0.020835671573877335, 0.04926932603120804, 0.009266477078199387, -0.025640469044446945, 0.01765582337975502, 0.007746843155473471, -0.041524555534124374, 0.03217232972383499, 0.0035420029889792204, 0.00023937968944665045, 0.034081049263477325, 0.027516355738043785, 0.0434214286506176, 0.02508723735809326, 0.03841355815529823, 0.006930789444595575, -0.009981309063732624, 0.04492237791419029, -0.040038857609033585, -0.05376427620649338, -0.040168941020965576, 0.018440937623381615, -0.019578946754336357, 0.056799616664648056, 0.0174242053180933, 0.02778426744043827, -0.01671363227069378, 0.0019514287123456597, 0.00183986930642277, 0.04422180727124214, -0.000264276925008744, 0.019297238439321518, 0.01906810700893402, 0.010318033397197723, -0.05464516952633858, 0.013838077895343304, -0.009920508600771427, -0.02669260837137699, 0.04217877984046936, 0.007371304556727409, -0.033261749893426895, 0.01653655618429184, -0.0318593829870224, -0.0005938656977377832, 0.02985036000609398, -0.04851634055376053, 0.0894184336066246, 0.02267809771001339, 0.022553127259016037, 0.020290557295084, 0.007111423183232546, 0.04058372974395752, 0.0355093814432621, -0.004844467621296644, 0.024814195930957794, -0.032654255628585815, 0.047164153307676315, -0.024342501536011696, -0.007692656479775906, -0.04663434252142906, -0.044004861265420914, 0.032292261719703674, 0.01626625470817089, -0.039214953780174255, -0.04432918131351471, -0.008421659469604492, -0.004982395563274622, -0.006743098143488169, -0.039655786007642746, 0.0018683868693187833, 0.011609690263867378, -0.02782035805284977, 0.007614225149154663, -0.012302106246352196, 0.04436657577753067, 0.01649547927081585, -0.010956513695418835, -0.008297471329569817, 0.01933204010128975, -0.03555315360426903, 0.0011555126402527094, 0.012767715379595757, -0.022351529449224472, -0.029512900859117508, -0.0699668824672699, 0.01427144929766655, -0.00007735925464658067, -0.022879311814904213, 0.018123552203178406, -0.026478717103600502, 0.04090026021003723, 0.010667016729712486, -0.03047151304781437, -0.0020080129615962505, 0.019899656996130943, 0.024576805531978607, 0.020276686176657677, -0.013985364697873592, 0.007253080606460571, 0.005043680313974619, 0.02304181456565857, 0.038226135075092316, -0.017175666987895966, 0.007563730236142874, 0.05535494536161423, 0.0015862423460930586, 0.0105844521895051, -0.04076648876070976, -0.02425636537373066, 0.029828017577528954, -0.01994956284761429, 0.0006072866381146014, 0.031262703239917755, 0.005124010611325502, -0.02994002215564251, -0.048964723944664, -0.03854004666209221, -0.006796100176870823, 0.036660850048065186, -0.003471854841336608, 0.03666102513670921, 0.05331581085920334, 0.015539994463324547, -0.03671688586473465, -0.012564573436975479, -0.035548463463783264, -0.0543036162853241, 0.06243905797600746, 0.012695403769612312, 0.016720691695809364, 0.03252088651061058, 0.04138077422976494, -0.023380421102046967, 0.0200496856123209, 0.039155032485723495, 0.05235610902309418, 0.0404413603246212, 0.047339826822280884, -0.0820457860827446, -0.03542964532971382, 0.040998999029397964, -0.046885013580322266, 0.026230547577142715, 0.024644069373607635, -0.02103942073881626, 0.0049303676933050156, 0.016084466129541397, 0.016283078119158745, -0.008016673848032951, -0.0033490024507045746, -0.02268352545797825, 0.02442951314151287, 0.02402428723871708, -0.03353263810276985, 0.019356759265065193, -0.009008463472127914, 0.010642493143677711, -0.009817774407565594, 0.04876057058572769, -0.037954285740852356, -0.05499003455042839, -0.011832907795906067, -0.048560284078121185, -0.04566368833184242, 0.04258636757731438, 0.03552550822496414, -0.020091095939278603, 0.02412407100200653, -0.025873742997646332, 0.020985426381230354, 0.01581849530339241, 0.01636485569179058, -0.019701862707734108, 0.04540424421429634, 0.03075822815299034, 0.01973215490579605, 0.017711210995912552, 0.007242257706820965, 0.10608045011758804, 0.06387747824192047, 0.016098786145448685, -0.07109575718641281, -0.011384813115000725, 0.036991577595472336, 0.0016850305255502462, -0.04579085111618042, 0.015911785885691643, 0.010481784120202065, -0.01190227922052145, 0.08231300860643387, -0.01400970108807087, -0.01499183103442192, 0.015096203424036503, 0.08921118080615997, 0.0023177063558250666, -0.03671863675117493, 0.04412476345896721, 0.0014232073444873095, -0.01789734698832035, -0.008978325873613358, -0.07213862985372543, 0.038403455168008804, 0.009073679335415363, -0.020272597670555115, 0.0037523519713431597, -0.0018476508557796478, -0.004286931362003088, 0.04722759872674942, -0.04411632940173149, -0.010525094345211983, 0.02667864039540291, -0.009068084880709648, -0.00014515728980768472, -0.0036015883088111877, -0.028967006132006645, 0.0038346992805600166, -0.0006399120902642608, 0.06456021219491959, 0.04676234722137451, -0.036673396825790405, 0.009066772647202015, 0.01882028952240944, -0.035575833171606064, -0.03765573352575302, -0.034945253282785416, -0.02220706269145012, -0.018592631444334984, 0.030628761276602745, -0.030878670513629913, 0.013546459376811981, -0.025218740105628967, -0.04663926735520363, -0.002465780358761549, 0.019745344296097755, 0.00437642028555274, -0.031186940148472786, 0.00394618371501565, -0.04245690628886223, 0.02718699537217617, 0.0018704362446442246, 0.006749602034687996, 0.004507281351834536, -0.012702049687504768, -0.008147296495735645, -0.02312629297375679, 0.02604261226952076, 0.0028880855534225702, -0.0348387211561203, 0.022618303075432777, 0.0012015770189464092, 0.008736597374081612, 0.025282220914959908, 0.0003503448679111898, -0.003155503887683153, -0.014324097894132137, -0.008350983262062073, 0.0013010298134759068, -0.00771693792194128, -0.03364700451493263, 0.0390111543238163, -0.04208847135305405, -0.028242770582437515, -0.02906174771487713, -0.029961397871375084, 0.03356742486357689, -0.009910449385643005, 0.021246641874313354, 0.006685925181955099, -0.030578529462218285, 0.017992742359638214, 0.035373661667108536, -0.025574708357453346, -0.01885390095412731, -0.00529231084510684, -0.010553235188126564, 0.008202960714697838, 0.001500009442679584, 0.0587700717151165, 0.05858989432454109, 0.006524944212287664, -0.013184139505028725, -0.03945225849747658, -0.007387966383248568, 0.0033378805965185165, -0.011072270572185516, -0.036001816391944885, -0.007624014746397734, -0.029872702434659004, 0.016150139272212982, -0.040231235325336456, -0.05243002623319626, -0.0124506875872612, -0.015414262190461159, 0.04802955687046051, 0.009733815677464008, 0.006166460923850536, 0.03001626953482628, -0.007465100847184658, -0.018364524468779564, -0.04259610176086426, -0.009019549936056137, -0.03458305820822716, -0.015976563096046448, -0.035234443843364716, -0.009018930606544018, 0.0168501865118742, -0.004688139073550701, -0.008827568031847477, -0.006527708377689123, -0.0044173807837069035, 0.04618687182664871, -0.014688475988805294, 0.0259935911744833, 0.026800157502293587, -0.025410892441868782, 0.04329488426446915, -0.05334242433309555, -0.04181075468659401, 0.021658003330230713, -0.042292218655347824, -0.024389320984482765, 0.007060306612402201, -0.047567229717969894, 0.01178630068898201, 0.01333694625645876, -0.025767451152205467, 0.010461561381816864, 0.044035717844963074, -0.0061867316253483295, -0.06414040178060532, 0.01580796204507351, 0.037573885172605515, 0.03227942809462547, 0.06930965930223465, 0.030848372727632523, -0.016011547297239304, 0.005910094361752272, 0.011525093577802181, 0.03903086856007576, -0.0172593854367733, -0.00007878269389038906, 0.03659283369779587, 0.01679801009595394, 0.008267304860055447, -0.007014949340373278, -0.018475258722901344, 0.053573574870824814, 0.02879892848432064, -0.011013155803084373, 0.020946020260453224, -0.03884166479110718, 0.014868813566863537, -0.06323599070310593, -0.004117616452276707, 0.013986301608383656, 0.006494669709354639, 0.032762784510850906, -0.02656637690961361, 0.007779616396874189, 0.034085437655448914, -0.06473321467638016, -0.005771168507635593, -0.02620014175772667, -0.031978342682123184, -0.03809855505824089, 0.0034037120640277863, -0.01920684613287449, 0.02838883176445961, -0.006986815948039293, 0.006412438116967678, 0.024448268115520477, 0.014803146943449974, -0.0397263765335083, 0.0009742366964928806, -0.020727213472127914, 0.032436370849609375, 0.014167653396725655, -0.04887443035840988, 0.05500100553035736, -0.03074202872812748, -0.03491354361176491, 0.0893382802605629, 0.007316466886550188, 0.03158671036362648, 0.03176646679639816, 0.014128308743238449, 0.01822659559547901, 0.008202665485441685, 0.036096829921007156, -0.0020535120274871588, -0.006321588531136513, 0.013375463895499706, -0.006159199867397547, 0.08731640130281448, -0.006779426708817482, 0.02613997831940651, 0.005572873167693615, -0.019273830577731133, -0.005966042168438435, 0.018112726509571075, -0.0330691821873188, -0.047150980681180954, -0.00452385563403368, -0.012090916745364666, 0.04283783212304115, -0.05646989122033119, 0.04120659828186035, -0.03648373857140541, 0.01017711404711008, 0.05326676368713379, 0.008786914870142937, -0.011567509733140469, 0.03557191416621208, -0.044733926653862, -0.05306144431233406, 0.022376826032996178, 0.00691092386841774, -0.04516591131687164, -0.051804207265377045, 0.03760026767849922, -0.018038276582956314, -0.0011105374433100224, -0.0016934532904997468, -0.011715320870280266, 0.03281194344162941, 0.0634397640824318, -0.000008764978701947257, -0.006569278426468372, 0.01770823262631893, -0.013381757773458958, -0.013316817581653595, -0.08028743416070938, 0.06131656467914581, 0.01724800281226635, 0.011125494726002216, -0.03806360438466072, -0.0019025910878553987, -0.01032672356814146, -0.045726001262664795, 0.05271301791071892, -0.002761031035333872, -0.011203375644981861, -0.027450604364275932, 0.015712209045886993, -0.0428825318813324, -0.061195485293865204, 0.02663339488208294, -0.022290309891104698, -0.004257696680724621, -0.033689092844724655, -0.004255380947142839, 0.00993332825601101, 0.020223505795001984, -0.018603382632136345, 0.030257193371653557, -0.026429597288370132, -0.013944593258202076, -0.05189381539821625, 0.02963206171989441, 0.00563328480347991, 0.038160208612680435, 0.027413923293352127, -0.0098526356741786, 0.018607504665851593, 0.013742943294346333, 0.0007192886550910771, -0.021037984639406204, 0.07994694262742996, -0.019811931997537613, -0.003854345763102174, -0.02573619782924652, 0.007612479850649834, -0.00758296437561512, -0.05615846812725067, -0.01178471464663744, 0.03133004903793335, -0.005420343484729528, 0.04605690389871597, 0.0034583313390612602, 0.015897752717137337, 0.0319364108145237, 0.005713530350476503, 0.011674605309963226, 0.024291999638080597, -0.0003436947881709784, -0.021967047825455666, 0.021203627809882164, -0.002133699133992195, -0.00249165459536016, 0.03977704048156738, 0.020111216232180595, 0.0011322086211293936, 0.06710130721330643, 0.05331919714808464, 0.07015451043844223, -0.03497609496116638, -0.007701186463236809, 0.027105610817670822, -0.023049525916576385, 0.0015911210794001818, 0.012002420611679554, -0.00528447050601244, 0.015363907441496849, -0.013251475989818573, 0.041878633201122284, -0.07962141931056976, -0.044838421046733856, -0.039821844547986984, -0.018911365419626236, 0.015338940545916557, 0.002946567954495549, -0.006864635273814201, -0.012169662863016129, 0.01735483855009079, 0.06866040825843811, 0.03176429122686386, 0.0021202557254582644, 0.01801956072449684, -0.023407159373164177, -0.00471568014472723, 0.013279027305543423, -0.0643266886472702, -0.04237877577543259, 0.019108351320028305, 0.03825186565518379, 0.03803892806172371, 0.0382918044924736, 0.022773193195462227, 0.004689622204750776, -0.028322560712695122, 0.03046770952641964, -0.10279560089111328, -0.005053776782006025, 0.008685469627380371, 0.018659044057130814, 0.0004635501536540687, -0.010363674722611904 ]
<p>From <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/epiR/epiR.pdf" rel="nofollow">epiR manual</a> for <strong><em>epi.2by2</em></strong> function:</p> <blockquote> <p>units: multiplier for prevalence and incidence estimates.</p> </blockquote> <p>In examples it is set to 100, <code>units=100</code>. What does it mean?</p> <p><strong>Note:</strong> I am working on ~5K case ~5K control data, no stratas, outcome vs exposure - 2by2 tables.</p> <p><strong>Update:</strong> This <a href="http://www.medicalbiostatistics.com/prevalenceincidence.pdf" rel="nofollow">PDF</a> might be relevant.</p>
73,620
[ -0.04133976250886917, -0.010405031964182854, 0.003720678621903062, 0.018419869244098663, 0.03562348335981369, -0.008099288679659367, 0.0015653648879379034, -0.05013355612754822, 0.026427777484059334, -0.039753276854753494, 0.06980740278959274, 0.05509776622056961, 0.07052933424711227, 0.0017925634747371078, -0.0028011994436383247, 0.024106841534376144, 0.02558157965540886, 0.022276833653450012, -0.01013246551156044, 0.009774785488843918, 0.01192063931375742, -0.01763984002172947, 0.008198639377951622, 0.0012335729552432895, -0.0229567252099514, 0.059066977351903915, 0.030255122110247612, -0.025011857971549034, -0.001552711590193212, 0.05675041675567627, -0.04416130110621452, -0.032868392765522, 0.025463892146945, -0.02492549829185009, 0.015400903299450874, 0.009821176528930664, -0.03252776712179184, -0.018245361745357513, -0.009907281026244164, 0.05861245095729828, -0.02261759340763092, -0.021224696189165115, 0.03356894105672836, 0.04140578955411911, -0.01984231173992157, 0.05084767937660217, 0.012893246486783028, 0.014513884671032429, 0.030441798269748688, -0.015088709071278572, 0.02380291372537613, 0.03192433714866638, 0.061298612505197525, 0.017694711685180664, -0.04937954619526863, -0.02659538760781288, 0.09013888239860535, 0.05121399089694023, 0.0033776219934225082, -0.06232082471251488, -0.02200489677488804, -0.03375125303864479, -0.002989871660247445, -0.022123705595731735, -0.036172203719615936, 0.0039330399595201015, 0.009783927351236343, -0.007685058284550905, 0.0045129782520234585, 0.0003057209250982851, 0.07436872273683548, -0.014940435998141766, 0.017817523330450058, -0.01952352561056614, -0.015207266435027122, -0.03872661665081978, 0.024084432050585747, 0.01637822762131691, 0.007493689656257629, 0.05897007882595062, -0.006187403108924627, -0.0007203347631730139, 0.016003841534256935, 0.015717698261141777, 0.020125459879636765, -0.01176956295967102, 0.06687331199645996, 0.004963218700140715, 0.027267316356301308, -0.012325659394264221, -0.033147815614938736, 0.005341357085853815, 0.05118787661194801, -0.004022564273327589, -0.00046177409240044653, 0.026398375630378723, -0.022847415879368782, 0.058923881500959396, -0.011259210295975208, 0.01941237784922123, 0.01967613399028778, -0.01791992038488388, 0.037452150136232376, 0.05905284732580185, -0.04362906515598297, -0.038835130631923676, -0.030801061540842056, -0.04542834311723709, -0.009384019300341606, 0.02712513692677021, -0.011534059420228004, 0.013939298689365387, -0.0026568674948066473, -0.047192592173814774, 0.012339923530817032, -0.005292046815156937, -0.0011395523324608803, 0.02200671099126339, 0.01694968342781067, 0.06305696815252304, 0.06871695816516876, -0.0041003176011145115, 0.02334047108888626, -0.024423420429229736, -0.07381384074687958, 0.05756738781929016, -0.00064300955273211, 0.005114469677209854, -0.04693138226866722, 0.03751915320754051, -0.004411785397678614, -0.04097906872630119, 0.0693994089961052, 0.0020865860860794783, 0.029461516067385674, -0.0227313544601202, -0.05931777134537697, -0.04929402843117714, 0.009368540719151497, -0.0001576752110850066, -0.018726592883467674, -0.04520704969763756, 0.005832276307046413, -0.008655508048832417, 0.049965307116508484, 0.004711778834462166, 0.032773058861494064, 0.0097990483045578, -0.0025549994315952063, 0.00810621865093708, -0.039709750562906265, -0.002066371263936162, -0.03915126249194145, -0.026983194053173065, -0.0017257735598832369, -0.07668280601501465, 0.011368554085493088, 0.0004953168099746108, 0.009908654727041721, -0.026724547147750854, 0.041237734258174896, -0.02842630445957184, -0.031186986714601517, -0.02235911786556244, -0.017269741743803024, -0.020028861239552498, 0.07982198894023895, -0.055156443268060684, 0.04094457998871803, 0.038355257362127304, -0.036697324365377426, 0.04669009894132614, 0.0105314115062356, 0.023136986419558525, 0.013057026080787182, 0.012215973809361458, -0.021844884380698204, -0.05350388586521149, 0.012243958190083504, 0.0401836633682251, -0.04126085713505745, -0.015854332596063614, -0.025319509208202362, -0.07714757323265076, 0.03533342853188515, -0.014566042460501194, -0.012869886122643948, -0.027844427153468132, 0.0013682653661817312, -0.060103826224803925, -0.07180634140968323, -0.10864981263875961, 0.01854902319610119, 0.03522977605462074, -0.019169418141245842, 0.01307804323732853, -0.02717968076467514, -0.015851808711886406, 0.008007745258510113, 0.010683389380574226, -0.06195554882287979, -0.008905312977731228, 0.05060239136219025, -0.0060739666223526, -0.03176254406571388, 0.020722955465316772, 0.04234835505485535, -0.030646461993455887, 0.011871397495269775, -0.05132865160703659, -0.0007100071525201201, -0.006511371582746506, -0.021166006103157997, 0.009531909599900246, -0.029048871248960495, -0.05271708965301514, -0.02056718058884144, -0.006745310965925455, 0.0190526582300663, 0.029312487691640854, -0.08558156341314316, 0.0642205998301506, 0.07224364578723907, 0.0007503334782086313, 0.002011752687394619, 0.005453925579786301, 0.006282545626163483, -0.03743639215826988, -0.014758585952222347, -0.025146035477519035, -0.08341512829065323, 0.016746843233704567, 0.005293042864650488, 0.00039365064003504813, -0.01493322104215622, 0.006355966906994581, -0.006746046710759401, 0.007916701026260853, -0.008774497546255589, 0.009439019486308098, -0.03332945704460144, -0.03755570948123932, 0.002104580169543624, -0.007031026296317577, 0.021401936188340187, 0.024617284536361694, 0.04590782895684242, 0.0421530157327652, 0.053920503705739975, -0.008194871246814728, 0.015442968346178532, 0.03575373813509941, -0.0030448215547949076, 0.005915818270295858, -0.00495309941470623, 0.010778931900858879, 0.03156765550374985, -0.02479804866015911, 0.020910153165459633, 0.030939029529690742, -0.002474677748978138, 0.0009421810391359031, 0.021397268399596214, -0.02860603854060173, 0.014041409827768803, 0.015247929841279984, -0.02460293285548687, -0.0029906502459198236, 0.01956220157444477, -0.042199671268463135, -0.002521505579352379, 0.0016671171179041266, -0.04483881592750549, -0.03380893915891647, 0.001721030566841364, 0.03885899484157562, 0.030901076272130013, 0.01639697700738907, -0.05124851316213608, -0.016680721193552017, -0.009780763648450375, -0.01245118398219347, 0.019444577395915985, -0.006501886527985334, -0.02800062671303749, 0.026493385434150696, -0.019134582951664925, 0.01782231591641903, 0.022668320685625076, -0.017209559679031372, -0.054519664496183395, 0.029031937941908836, 0.00791915226727724, -0.058150578290224075, -0.020027756690979004, 0.0008774108719080687, 0.0393802672624588, -0.014093754813075066, -0.03916652128100395, 0.021976057440042496, -0.0023823787923902273, 0.0036788431461900473, -0.008890178054571152, -0.0632099136710167, 0.01689821667969227, -0.05816515162587166, 0.0004954656469635665, 0.02486286126077175, 0.00027988682268187404, -0.005333880893886089, 0.00944566074758768, 0.011006193235516548, -0.025996726006269455, -0.06406780332326889, -0.02459459938108921, 0.007721540983766317, 0.007105888333171606, 0.05902948975563049, -0.0012448871275410056, 0.010718977078795433, 0.04345222935080528, -0.0010232749627903104, -0.002423439873382449, -0.03497302904725075, -0.03417100012302399, -0.01889737881720066, -0.07317868620157242, 0.012604836374521255, 0.027598874643445015, 0.025124505162239075, 0.0033592798281461, 0.0003545793006196618, 0.03051750361919403, 0.081355020403862, 0.02456202171742916, -0.01438114047050476, 0.02117552049458027, -0.009609222412109375, -0.031480465084314346, 0.05314847081899643, 0.04617510735988617, -0.006524550728499889, 0.06022535637021065, -0.044711481779813766, 0.01028401218354702, -0.019027693197131157, -0.029149143025279045, 0.003318520961329341, 0.006918200291693211, 0.010109168477356434, -0.034755390137434006, 0.009855055250227451, 0.014969348907470703, -0.026793653145432472, -0.009051598608493805, 0.00929457601159811, 0.059909988194704056, -0.03958669304847717, -0.02816825360059738, 0.027398012578487396, 0.07150174677371979, 0.014454667456448078, 0.0006073022377677262, 0.0059364610351622105, 0.002916116500273347, -0.007486050948500633, -0.037943173199892044, -0.010749438777565956, 0.023900046944618225, 0.05624169483780861, -0.016389664262533188, 0.033824265003204346, -0.05969053879380226, 0.02282685972750187, 0.002839050954207778, -0.009222223423421383, -0.019369829446077347, 0.039066288620233536, -0.0001820232137106359, 0.04388478025794029, -0.030384618788957596, -0.023685645312070847, 0.0023807052057236433, -0.003289481857791543, -0.01911543309688568, -0.008473025634884834, -0.00229941145516932, -0.007241842802613974, 0.025957884266972542, -0.029768142849206924, 0.03494961932301521, 0.039999835193157196, 0.017595842480659485, -0.009928549639880657, 0.011525570414960384, -0.00895857997238636, 0.01627170480787754, 0.011478415690362453, -0.0013331189984455705, -0.029819145798683167, 0.010235724970698357, 0.036646243184804916, 0.02505892887711525, 0.0007946809637360275, 0.015862828120589256, 0.013521699234843254, -0.001226917840540409, -0.0024548950605094433, -0.012218785472214222, 0.028556084260344505, 0.048278868198394775, -0.010357044637203217, -0.004371189512312412, -0.03506271913647652, 0.006159674841910601, 0.032432712614536285, 0.03665807098150253, 0.04864213615655899, 0.008106976747512817, -0.026323318481445312, 0.017131851986050606, 0.014311551116406918, -0.011502604931592941, 0.023306120187044144, -0.006172985769808292, 0.005211647599935532, 0.07182512432336807, 0.061750154942274094, -0.03181504085659981, 0.006087508983910084, 0.0689731314778328, 0.008475573733448982, 0.013745488598942757, -0.03297460451722145, -0.013260185718536377, -0.0007747928029857576, -0.03777730464935303, -0.012785183265805244, 0.011693895794451237, -0.015377374365925789, -0.006588978227227926, 0.04724038392305374, 0.0061731114983558655, -0.046828337013721466, 0.0223968718200922, 0.0024570422247052193, 0.02846217155456543, 0.005958430469036102, -0.02966577745974064, -0.004929923452436924, 0.061018045991659164, -0.012537606060504913, 0.016781745478510857, -0.004634391982108355, -0.08883506059646606, 0.021219400689005852, 0.010088409297168255, 0.08620738238096237, -0.009091909043490887, -0.03918744996190071, -0.04950433224439621, -0.02128586918115616, 0.04998115077614784, -0.030008872970938683, -0.01262599229812622, -0.03450161591172218, -0.0009716408094391227, 0.010726838372647762, -0.06185967102646828, -0.04069795459508896, 0.006777989212423563, -0.04404370114207268, 0.03220546618103981, 0.022376112639904022, 0.005033181514590979, -0.013751893304288387, 0.029139921069145203, -0.034481972455978394, 0.04333027824759483, -0.09485915303230286, -0.009744128212332726, 0.007470282725989819, -0.004253714811056852, 0.012052411213517189, -0.0211733840405941, 0.0371062308549881, -0.011313565075397491, 0.014575709588825703, 0.04968179389834404, -0.015452592633664608, 0.03001740761101246, 0.020602678880095482, 0.0005769068375229836, -0.030213933438062668, 0.003149905242025852, -0.008500654250383377, 0.026386836543679237, 0.04358459264039993, 0.0036055385135114193, 0.09200794249773026, 0.00042525972821749747, 0.002014311496168375, 0.01549727376550436, -0.07596711814403534, 0.010813822969794273, -0.016240648925304413, -0.026883898302912712, -0.022538214921951294, -0.0015930493827909231, -0.02356528677046299, 0.022583289071917534, 0.029986567795276642, 0.02500038780272007, -0.02811175398528576, 0.007672624662518501, 0.015298379585146904, 0.06271783262491226, -0.03287690877914429, 0.0068474323488771915, 0.02125154808163643, -0.004197303671389818, 0.019915591925382614, -0.042509328573942184, 0.03660297393798828, -0.010876988060772419, 0.007750567048788071, 0.001590566011145711, -0.04598791524767876, 0.011633661575615406, -0.01450953260064125, -0.05757448822259903, 0.016420388594269753, -0.046050190925598145, 0.03336860612034798, -0.026043513789772987, 0.026898810639977455, -0.00749499537050724, -0.03531816229224205, -0.037853021174669266, 0.03701810911297798, -0.0021789981983602047, 0.02190791815519333, -0.008223546668887138, 0.06885203719139099, -0.0011147713521495461, 0.01782859116792679, -0.05008785426616669, -0.026310846209526062, 0.03564095497131348, -0.007725885137915611, -0.011428088881075382, -0.018368393182754517, -0.023129643872380257, 0.007427595090121031, -0.02003185637295246, 0.002590883057564497, 0.055770136415958405, -0.02422841265797615, -0.022419903427362442, -0.024459930136799812, 0.0012589504476636648, 0.058952510356903076, -0.019684089347720146, -0.019776539877057076, 0.03225797787308693, 0.01691516675055027, 0.010763232596218586, -0.004286168608814478, -0.01212777104228735, -0.04524146020412445, -0.035543426871299744, -0.008315765298902988, -0.001583398669026792, 0.013625593855977058, -0.009832456707954407, -0.007864738814532757, 0.028674660250544548, -0.0020979992114007473, 0.033580608665943146, -0.03532606363296509, 0.00973993819206953, -0.0279863104224205, 0.03914394602179527, -0.009248838759958744, -0.0005287299281917512, -0.038040388375520706, 0.00677330419421196, 0.022493988275527954, 0.017337113618850708, 0.005262851249426603, 0.042290717363357544, 0.05176512897014618, -0.021166464313864708, 0.06334765255451202, -0.022445911541581154, -0.018841778859496117, 0.05369653180241585, 0.007041738834232092, -0.017443522810935974, -0.00475147133693099, 0.02887752652168274, -0.010748895816504955, -0.02326825074851513, -0.051904212683439255, 0.01994939334690571, 0.028434332460165024, -0.005601246375590563, 0.0016937382752075791, 0.05375074967741966, -0.022274641320109367, 0.036350317299366, -0.01906728744506836, -0.006467996630817652, 0.00443163700401783, 0.009069353342056274, 0.03349139541387558, -0.029622860252857208, -0.024811992421746254, 0.05435861647129059, 0.03784993663430214, 0.03836524859070778, 0.03629377484321594, -0.013693944551050663, 0.01003321260213852, 0.027304600924253464, -0.05722583457827568, -0.015350393019616604, 0.03197609260678291, -0.05578745901584625, -0.008332003839313984, -0.03880956768989563, -0.05632011592388153, 0.059791143983602524, -0.0010159178636968136, -0.01695512793958187, -0.0470893532037735, -0.013968918472528458, -0.04313136264681816, -0.008239302784204483, 0.014428704977035522, -0.03814044967293739, -0.006899069994688034, -0.032607950270175934, 0.00999402068555355, -0.0059335120022296906, 0.018776260316371918, -0.03497874736785889, -0.051899634301662445, -0.02404147945344448, -0.0063250805251300335, -0.03291432932019234, 0.03281617909669876, 0.0028404348995536566, -0.022535258904099464, 0.004234574735164642, -0.04189544543623924, -0.004466899670660496, 0.022598538547754288, 0.05234627425670624, -0.0015462000155821443, 0.06474576890468597, 0.0122383963316679, 0.017206352204084396, -0.018931211903691292, -0.042095642536878586, 0.12245673686265945, 0.07122181355953217, 0.04309797286987305, -0.06468448787927628, 0.0075160241685807705, 0.013438434340059757, 0.01830459013581276, 0.0012488928623497486, -0.022207217290997505, 0.03144465386867523, -0.014295050874352455, 0.056462567299604416, 0.08113346248865128, 0.03866369649767876, 0.005351928994059563, 0.033440787345170975, 0.0063375853933393955, -0.0409078374505043, -0.0038569848984479904, 0.013847234658896923, -0.0010567912831902504, 0.009116427972912788, -0.042532794177532196, -0.016303127631545067, 0.04973894730210304, -0.013600258156657219, -0.018059417605400085, -0.002573993057012558, 0.005479654297232628, 0.05243029072880745, -0.0198320671916008, -0.02140241302549839, 0.019314667209982872, -0.006864596623927355, 0.03402179852128029, -0.03114839270710945, 0.035750407725572586, -0.03587735816836357, -0.002415986731648445, 0.01850484125316143, 0.0018322195392102003, 0.005382230971008539, -0.015829505398869514, 0.019710058346390724, -0.05205998942255974, -0.01403786614537239, -0.016470858827233315, 0.01622685417532921, -0.01511137094348669, -0.03275783732533455, 0.0060353646986186504, 0.01005641371011734, -0.007310826331377029, 0.000769553822465241, -0.016393860802054405, 0.031995464116334915, 0.005244988948106766, -0.01819847896695137, -0.0014327055541798472, -0.05166882276535034, 0.0013430181425064802, -0.004829874262213707, 0.04668724164366722, 0.041715357452631, -0.004145530518144369, -0.04359324276447296, -0.0338013581931591, 0.029368357732892036, -0.027870768681168556, 0.043849579989910126, 0.040407445281744, -0.03918140381574631, -0.051397718489170074, -0.033734098076820374, 0.03003217838704586, 0.04011799022555351, 0.023150095716118813, -0.014883460476994514, 0.001973337261006236, -0.035441804677248, -0.05935349315404892, -0.007693007588386536, -0.038139279931783676, -0.016760705038905144, -0.024602282792329788, -0.02109045349061489, 0.0030831284821033478, -0.031575143337249756, -0.023525085300207138, 0.003568727523088455, -0.02218824438750744, 0.04430939257144928, 0.023163186386227608, -0.03881208598613739, -0.002761531388387084, -0.010925943031907082, -0.00004809543679584749, -0.010550063103437424, -0.036598362028598785, 0.038576655089855194, -0.009574624709784985, 0.006347439717501402, 0.042233504354953766, 0.010761657729744911, -0.023423416540026665, -0.02420264296233654, 0.006492675747722387, -0.07678060233592987, 0.004772307816892862, -0.0026544914580881596, 0.003244120394811034, -0.019712014123797417, 0.04114030674099922, -0.05830718204379082, -0.0325203537940979, -0.02000552788376808, 0.01950552873313427, -0.05836130678653717, 0.030903223901987076, -0.021233512088656425, 0.013669530861079693, -0.001707682036794722, 0.023547889664769173, -0.016551412642002106, -0.025483040139079094, 0.03130987659096718, 0.015855014324188232, 0.020940428599715233, -0.0047833602875471115, -0.013713758438825607, 0.02905755676329136, 0.002219347283244133, 0.005494360812008381, 0.01104368269443512, 0.027853358536958694, 0.025885026901960373, 0.006322364788502455, 0.04851508513092995, -0.01645597070455551, -0.005902205128222704, 0.0431843176484108, -0.027642592787742615, -0.00806280318647623, 0.05575854703783989, -0.00168590247631073, 0.0270056314766407, 0.005725651513785124, -0.014672663994133472, -0.03622308745980263, 0.04367699846625328, -0.05123481526970863, -0.018990106880664825, -0.0033617415465414524, 0.003310819622129202, 0.02606622315943241, -0.0025898413732647896, -0.03030424565076828, 0.029940487816929817, 0.009196372702717781, 0.018095897510647774, 0.028415268287062645, 0.010607070289552212, -0.011206123977899551, -0.004299592226743698, 0.01427214965224266, 0.044037602841854095, -0.026525255292654037, 0.004238939844071865, 0.04665956646203995, 0.032510362565517426, -0.03921353444457054, 0.04583968222141266, -0.01882139965891838, 0.018280377611517906, -0.0996580645442009, -0.03368989750742912, -0.015702538192272186, 0.02198861725628376, 0.0479959100484848, -0.0010829188395291567, 0.0009835860691964626, 0.014042063616216183, -0.05282137170433998, 0.00818230863660574, -0.020743999630212784, 0.011550742201507092, -0.010643004439771175, 0.005609753541648388, -0.04265532270073891, 0.013313469476997852, 0.051197316497564316, 0.03216225281357765, 0.021149512380361557, 0.058362413197755814, 0.021858686581254005, -0.09608138352632523, -0.026570545509457588, 0.027786726132035255, 0.02216787450015545, -0.03206351399421692, 0.022648120298981667, 0.0009326728177256882, 0.015821488574147224, 0.01883220113813877, -0.03987863287329674, 0.019612042233347893, 0.03331586718559265, 0.03167755529284477, 0.013502407819032669, 0.06834542751312256, 0.011008362285792828, 0.03884391859173775, -0.043349772691726685, -0.009433675557374954, -0.006321310997009277, -0.005271220114082098, -0.03256390243768692, 0.024471191689372063, 0.045349642634391785, 0.02235950343310833, 0.0061870478093624115, 0.020801987498998642, -0.005413659382611513, -0.04355554282665253, 0.01065468043088913, -0.028463317081332207, 0.0306448582559824, -0.02402361109852791, 0.024148747324943542, -0.058660320937633514, -0.0020368865225464106, 0.0475182831287384, 0.00034255656646564603, 0.008212782442569733, 0.03211677819490433, -0.005382453091442585, -0.03124646469950676, 0.03917872533202171, -0.01242183055728674, -0.03207502141594887, -0.034755151718854904, -0.000851117423735559, 0.012652435339987278, -0.013758193701505661, 0.006783981341868639, -0.011232850141823292, -0.05654801055788994, 0.0026160702109336853, -0.006108037196099758, -0.0342954583466053, 0.02125602215528488, 0.0008775258320383728, 0.021417319774627686, -0.062473952770233154, 0.07277066260576248, 0.003989816643297672, -0.010015820153057575, -0.03762947767972946, -0.03670870512723923, 0.015535451471805573, 0.03297208994626999, 0.04959384724497795, 0.025084134191274643, -0.01266244612634182, 0.010851542465388775, 0.057627975940704346, -0.01619480364024639, 0.017476117238402367, 0.024898935109376907, 0.007951758801937103, -0.0522569864988327, -0.02753457985818386, 0.03482373058795929, 0.022910557687282562, 0.007653634063899517, 0.006788771133869886, -0.01342128124088049, -0.0007207090384326875, 0.0004860940098296851, -0.034438036382198334, 0.025834521278738976, 0.030574144795536995, -0.008807649835944176, 0.057310882955789566, 0.01088819932192564, 0.026757800951600075, 0.03838261961936951, 0.003663310082629323, -0.02810584381222725, 0.027539798989892006, -0.006594768725335598, -0.0013080021599307656, 0.0374804325401783, 0.015814756974577904, -0.030043436214327812, -0.05755436420440674, 0.0049312179908156395, 0.004093306139111519, -0.01179156731814146, -0.007261283695697784, 0.05209927633404732, 0.03814167529344559, 0.04461889714002609, 0.013119868002831936, -0.008560659363865852, -0.018777482211589813, -0.03846341371536255, 0.03053007833659649, -0.01193368062376976, 0.012058991938829422, -0.04422962665557861, 0.03331969678401947, 0.040127433836460114, -0.02949804812669754, 0.020573094487190247, -0.010419423691928387, 0.02225625514984131, -0.025400783866643906, -0.0129220737144351, -0.03564811125397682, -0.014133375138044357, 0.012111448682844639, -0.006842660717666149, -0.030033620074391365, 0.06106989085674286, -0.02051331102848053, 0.020943060517311096, -0.016326414421200752, -0.04187031835317612, -0.031191591173410416, 0.0018698637140914798, 0.029355594888329506, 0.01914932206273079, -0.025846324861049652, -0.003031159518286586, -0.03371567651629448, -0.01959635689854622, 0.004332652781158686, 0.0025390596129000187, -0.006585373543202877, -0.016061320900917053, -0.016385890543460846, -0.02977512963116169, 0.011439934372901917, 0.031713299453258514, -0.01249062642455101, 0.007606386207044125, 0.015723753720521927, 0.035588473081588745, -0.033653464168310165, -0.029501210898160934, 0.027628939598798752, -0.008972740732133389, -0.055780213326215744, 0.010932705365121365, -0.028676260262727737, 0.011292951181530952, -0.013251201249659061, -0.03467851132154465 ]
<p>I know this might be a little ropey, statistically, but this is my problem.</p> <p>I have a lot of range data, that is to say the minimum, maximum and sample size of a variable. For some of these data I also have a mean, but not many. I want to compare these ranges to each other to quantify the variability of each range, and also to compare the means. I have a good reason to assume that the distribution is symmetrical around the mean, and that the data will have a Gaussian distribution. For this reason I am thinking I can justify using the mid-point of the distribution as a proxy for the mean, when it is absent.</p> <p>What I want to do is reconstruct a distribution for each range, and then use that to provide a standard deviation or standard error for that distribution. The only information I have is the max and min observed from a sample, and the mid-point as a proxy for the mean.</p> <p>In this way I hope to be able to calculate weighted means for each group, and also to work out the coefficient of variation for each group as well, based on the range data I have and my assumptions (of a symmetrical and normal distribution).</p> <p>I plan to use R to do this, so any code help would be appreciated as well.</p>
73,621
[ -0.02466961368918419, -0.002083325060084462, -0.0260553490370512, 0.013296176679432392, 0.012710163369774818, 0.07099944353103638, 0.004839465022087097, -0.03318438678979874, -0.002703507896512747, -0.03298524394631386, 0.039878301322460175, 0.018390003591775894, 0.040447041392326355, 0.014274923130869865, 0.02289413847029209, -0.013043497689068317, -0.03540198877453804, -0.014237278141081333, -0.010056477971374989, -0.058702461421489716, 0.0034670329187065363, 0.009248437359929085, -0.01250592153519392, -0.023986486718058586, -0.0401131734251976, 0.004182289354503155, 0.037767089903354645, -0.013905863277614117, -0.02111276239156723, 0.07109770178794861, -0.04140942543745041, -0.05022549256682396, -0.025604568421840668, 0.03191281855106354, 0.0038211075589060783, 0.0048965890891849995, -0.027758415788412094, 0.00018543752958066761, 0.001256761490367353, 0.03886283561587334, -0.062395937740802765, 0.008977317251265049, -0.01794576831161976, 0.01731041818857193, 0.009210830554366112, 0.01387636736035347, -0.031117824837565422, -0.014778523705899715, 0.016978153958916664, -0.05743018165230751, 0.09104609489440918, 0.028210781514644623, 0.050352998077869415, -0.0103386165574193, -0.008134735748171806, 0.009801888838410378, 0.041934315115213394, 0.08574359863996506, 0.015156037174165249, -0.06747309118509293, -0.009613364934921265, -0.03999635949730873, -0.010680901817977428, -0.00244036503136158, -0.037167537957429886, -0.007682324852794409, -0.003729471005499363, -0.015596731565892696, 0.030627930536866188, -0.003953471779823303, 0.005322276148945093, 0.016591638326644897, 0.02622874453663826, -0.0012496773852035403, 0.015837818384170532, -0.02908908948302269, 0.028379663825035095, -0.019304653629660606, 0.039009127765893936, 0.03509388864040375, 0.01397265400737524, 0.01796552911400795, -0.00690590962767601, 0.012600849382579327, 0.005788485053926706, -0.00927959568798542, 0.08367987722158432, -0.01424481812864542, 0.012956811115145683, 0.05241519212722778, -0.0011178868589922786, -0.026865405961871147, 0.07128109782934189, 0.012306423857808113, -0.054150547832250595, 0.01789279468357563, -0.008224819786846638, 0.004879572428762913, -0.01470413338392973, 0.024474946781992912, 0.004667032044380903, -0.03727945685386658, 0.01386620569974184, 0.07669069617986679, -0.02637442946434021, -0.005997767671942711, 0.0011230094823986292, -0.0069861155934631824, 0.018588600680232048, 0.008273842744529247, 0.010202684439718723, 0.015072173438966274, 0.007989027537405491, -0.00208696979098022, 0.03100559674203396, 0.00672959117218852, 0.009707295335829258, -0.04008488729596138, 0.06210063770413399, 0.043870456516742706, 0.036229364573955536, -0.04181254655122757, 0.0246697049587965, -0.04166658967733383, -0.04752955585718155, 0.012344665825366974, -0.007341998629271984, -0.009598851203918457, -0.04923968389630318, 0.041638512164354324, 0.0014385742833837867, -0.011594602838158607, 0.06490374356508255, -0.013898937962949276, 0.004472618922591209, -0.0040092431008815765, -0.05492904409766197, -0.05339968204498291, -0.028080493211746216, -0.03376488387584686, -0.009539980441331863, -0.05395224317908287, -0.009159407578408718, 0.019756970927119255, 0.004228577949106693, 0.024973107501864433, 0.0331873781979084, 0.010080941021442413, 0.051125142723321915, 0.032477859407663345, -0.008358590304851532, -0.005794169381260872, -0.011363676749169827, -0.037985481321811676, -0.011882148683071136, -0.08618434518575668, 0.009461917914450169, -0.025553997606039047, -0.03736807033419609, 0.010635590180754662, 0.04091155529022217, -0.0020033761393278837, 0.0001790625974535942, -0.02159474976360798, 0.030952589586377144, 0.0003804568841587752, 0.059826117008924484, 0.002425816375762224, 0.02725095860660076, -0.008683460764586926, -0.0008911985787563026, 0.013531061820685863, 0.03226574510335922, 0.03747943788766861, 0.057060208171606064, -0.04203857481479645, 0.0014394172467291355, -0.007803994696587324, 0.0022489181719720364, 0.03806846961379051, -0.024079641327261925, -0.0005416888161562383, 0.021410593762993813, -0.01731676422059536, 0.021667158231139183, 0.04466203972697258, -0.005079092923551798, -0.012266967445611954, 0.07043356448411942, -0.031495027244091034, -0.0014205612242221832, -0.03741484135389328, -0.013152163475751877, -0.01805971935391426, -0.0693594366312027, -0.002443745732307434, 0.034780267626047134, 0.03792877122759819, 0.0051393634639680386, -0.07004377990961075, 0.0038901956286281347, -0.013258212246000767, 0.038892097771167755, -0.021396076306700706, 0.0010223014978691936, 0.0292966328561306, 0.05533142015337944, -0.027384694665670395, 0.04719920828938484, -0.0020338348113000393, -0.036978840827941895, -0.015974774956703186, -0.061160363256931305, 0.023894425481557846, 0.018903521820902824, 0.003536878153681755, 0.010484356433153152, 0.008702646940946579, -0.012184186838567257, 0.030925657600164413, -0.034935250878334045, 0.07122273743152618, 0.096593476831913, -0.017869820818305016, -0.007394478190690279, -0.03081037849187851, -0.012031912803649902, 0.029013194143772125, -0.018944529816508293, -0.007147110532969236, -0.04867430403828621, -0.0145037230104208, 0.009636478498578072, 0.005106404889374971, -0.016391253098845482, 0.01837257109582424, 0.0310590211302042, -0.02318868786096573, 0.05346598103642464, 0.020025081932544708, 0.03008817322552204, -0.00022350874496623874, 0.005428381729871035, 0.02873082645237446, 0.041164882481098175, 0.005840301048010588, 0.01251826249063015, 0.01769857667386532, 0.03002948872745037, -0.005479344632476568, 0.00956325139850378, 0.048550233244895935, 0.03642629086971283, 0.013599982485175133, -0.022879574447870255, -0.020825078710913658, 0.056759513914585114, -0.026397932320833206, 0.02347186766564846, 0.07255162298679352, -0.020202046260237694, -0.03308321535587311, 0.03860090672969818, -0.024560077115893364, 0.016961872577667236, 0.034221310168504715, -0.024486487731337547, 0.023666301742196083, -0.0022097353357821703, -0.022007552906870842, 0.02347530610859394, -0.03125911206007004, -0.00789895374327898, -0.025233952328562737, -0.02384602278470993, 0.025781596079468727, 0.022696763277053833, 0.016195982694625854, -0.02346678078174591, -0.015943432226777077, 0.0024090148508548737, 0.01085139811038971, 0.012377801351249218, 0.0006961002363823354, -0.038450274616479874, 0.001759247505106032, -0.03064081259071827, 0.012127607129514217, -0.02156517468392849, 0.007060014642775059, 0.004492312669754028, 0.009392103180289268, 0.017770247533917427, -0.022320952266454697, 0.0016856746515259147, -0.03998158127069473, 0.012342526577413082, -0.003453665180131793, 0.01169606763869524, 0.03347913920879364, 0.006468836683779955, -0.0368419885635376, 0.06733765453100204, -0.036403972655534744, -0.02713906019926071, -0.040895067155361176, 0.007997038774192333, -0.004354642704129219, -0.0030568258371204138, 0.017170242965221405, 0.0317804254591465, -0.016576096415519714, -0.018841058015823364, -0.04814980551600456, -0.052148692309856415, 0.03484278544783592, 0.015002584084868431, 0.03580310195684433, 0.018799301236867905, 0.013916423544287682, 0.06613263487815857, 0.035437438637018204, -0.03554599732160568, -0.020708568394184113, 0.011055736802518368, -0.013505704700946808, 0.02435298264026642, 0.025755587965250015, -0.019159391522407532, -0.03884347900748253, -0.009138566441833973, 0.013486343435943127, -0.005481652449816465, 0.06746158003807068, 0.009229264222085476, -0.01612970046699047, -0.004912361968308687, -0.02783872000873089, -0.007464365102350712, 0.06862236559391022, 0.028217891231179237, 0.02526022493839264, 0.01859891787171364, -0.003396968124434352, 0.02516716532409191, -0.0009042193414643407, -0.05174718424677849, -0.006144167389720678, -0.0004858897882513702, 0.014911551028490067, -0.0303485207259655, 0.0404345728456974, 0.011373301036655903, -0.007414987310767174, 0.011436548084020615, 0.06019682437181473, 0.0322326123714447, -0.014953232370316982, -0.03700827434659004, 0.04372391477227211, 0.0684797614812851, -0.019803939387202263, -0.007960669696331024, -0.006483503617346287, -0.00609631510451436, -0.018416214734315872, -0.027621272951364517, -0.053620025515556335, 0.033336009830236435, 0.03443426266312599, 0.020816707983613014, 0.008157770149409771, -0.08514361828565598, 0.01792360097169876, -0.035012442618608475, 0.01887468807399273, -0.02517331764101982, 0.04273942857980728, -0.0027718471828848124, 0.04788504168391228, 0.036166854202747345, -0.011895271949470043, -0.03475362807512283, -0.02910851687192917, -0.0525876022875309, 0.054461412131786346, -0.040021367371082306, 0.016112713143229485, -0.0019786618649959564, -0.009653051383793354, -0.013405019417405128, -0.025005299597978592, 0.040398430079221725, -0.010178247466683388, 0.01204504631459713, -0.008443532511591911, -0.012805172242224216, -0.022379156202077866, -0.037225380539894104, -0.005589486099779606, 0.03507848456501961, 0.018913911655545235, -0.010702070780098438, 0.0419231653213501, 0.012524131685495377, -0.019535191357135773, -0.04428926482796669, -0.031101321801543236, 0.03813505172729492, -0.018162623047828674, 0.08508061617612839, -0.0003065295168198645, 0.01737942360341549, -0.00013548917195294052, -0.0027148458175361156, -0.03265978395938873, 0.07148006558418274, 0.028261177241802216, -0.014132604002952576, 0.002425477607175708, -0.030590340495109558, -0.010518984869122505, 0.021374953910708427, 0.0006675176555290818, -0.028139380738139153, -0.007875322364270687, 0.020078375935554504, 0.028197841718792915, -0.11411163210868835, 0.020260905846953392, 0.03859953582286835, 0.03356088697910309, -0.0033605594653636217, -0.06581217050552368, -0.0006869094795547426, 0.0031261532567441463, -0.047575294971466064, 0.0140739306807518, 0.0069632213562726974, 0.008859573863446712, 0.005980316083878279, 0.018042612820863724, -0.01021938119083643, -0.0296759232878685, -0.00986794289201498, 0.019015280529856682, 0.06440486013889313, -0.011476438492536545, 0.002969539724290371, 0.02119407057762146, -0.001146977418102324, 0.01891854777932167, 0.006347509566694498, 0.021857064217329025, -0.10402563214302063, 0.01431058906018734, 0.020176950842142105, 0.059836819767951965, 0.0075027006678283215, -0.019605474546551704, -0.02274247445166111, -0.004835975356400013, 0.063457190990448, -0.03550943359732628, 0.04235847666859627, -0.019145717844367027, -0.008882553316652775, -0.030556319281458855, -0.02087024785578251, -0.030957989394664764, -0.0030557517893612385, -0.025540200993418694, 0.010000295005738735, -0.019823042675852776, -0.012700660154223442, -0.04552425444126129, 0.018913064152002335, 0.00197198404930532, 0.05680510774254799, -0.01902906224131584, -0.015362017787992954, 0.027943158522248268, 0.042714305222034454, -0.001973358215764165, -0.03137308731675148, -0.029456311836838722, 0.03514374420046806, 0.006983182393014431, 0.06033587083220482, 0.0001919326896313578, -0.03477763384580612, 0.0666017010807991, 0.00467289611697197, -0.019516294822096825, 0.00009233399759978056, 0.026146329939365387, 0.04710114002227783, 0.049693964421749115, -0.003025700803846121, 0.07536382973194122, 0.037400051951408386, -0.015789898112416267, -0.01525852270424366, -0.04082133248448372, 0.043738953769207, 0.0045355623587965965, -0.06453398615121841, -0.06942455470561981, -0.03901585191488266, -0.019278448075056076, 0.008223970420658588, 0.010739285498857498, 0.039518918842077255, -0.015459876507520676, 0.021310176700353622, 0.03417908400297165, 0.011522014625370502, 0.007495192810893059, 0.0028544042725116014, 0.0417897030711174, 0.004140752367675304, 0.004857994150370359, -0.016977550461888313, 0.01585952378809452, 0.011220515705645084, -0.03893548995256424, -0.009277223609387875, -0.06611621379852295, 0.0013160475064069033, -0.0775211974978447, -0.019329417496919632, -0.011817739345133305, -0.01916898414492607, 0.03256963565945625, -0.016494544222950935, 0.043970659375190735, 0.02947603538632393, -0.016159934923052788, -0.023665744811296463, 0.025355646386742592, -0.017299450933933258, -0.006493085063993931, -0.01692117564380169, 0.009862679988145828, -0.0011638614814728498, 0.03308571130037308, -0.1010403260588646, -0.022530507296323776, -0.005724442191421986, 0.018944310024380684, -0.016372937709093094, -0.06723787635564804, 0.0018190594855695963, 0.011536992155015469, 0.0031852431129664183, -0.005269279237836599, 0.031171279028058052, 0.00709660304710269, -0.01657755859196186, -0.035860825330019, 0.004964470863342285, 0.08332262933254242, -0.015309441834688187, -0.004473449196666479, 0.015919378027319908, 0.0073096537962555885, -0.042225174605846405, 0.005474868696182966, 0.029068568721413612, -0.037047263234853745, 0.01595710776746273, -0.013347840867936611, 0.008817095309495926, 0.05883678421378136, -0.03364928066730499, -0.02864902839064598, 0.0029249549843370914, -0.010200055316090584, 0.02826116606593132, -0.05186142399907112, 0.01758151687681675, -0.02446925640106201, -0.02040332928299904, -0.0773368775844574, 0.001266018021851778, -0.013827714137732983, 0.02526978775858879, 0.009776919148862362, 0.00195683422498405, -0.029260149225592613, -0.009990443475544453, 0.07315215468406677, 0.016360878944396973, 0.004263099282979965, -0.002578482963144779, -0.04049815237522125, 0.013772865757346153, -0.004942665807902813, -0.021765226498246193, 0.04827052354812622, 0.01225158479064703, -0.052970241755247116, 0.026538357138633728, -0.05150698125362396, 0.02174084261059761, 0.04613186791539192, 0.012841743417084217, 0.05893366411328316, 0.06390907615423203, -0.010832034051418304, 0.005214926786720753, -0.03380069136619568, -0.027947669848799706, 0.015931792557239532, 0.0021428593900054693, 0.06750072538852692, 0.0065862503834068775, 0.0008796044276095927, 0.040768589824438095, -0.006925323512405157, -0.011100427247583866, 0.05479562655091286, -0.016377966850996017, 0.01743641495704651, 0.028298206627368927, 0.0002063263818854466, -0.01380915381014347, 0.006748482119292021, -0.00701651768758893, 0.02811269834637642, -0.024856677278876305, -0.017034363001585007, 0.026959478855133057, -0.006728847976773977, 0.00025831980747170746, -0.030118688941001892, -0.03622300177812576, -0.053727757185697556, 0.0243742223829031, 0.024607134982943535, -0.017004912719130516, 0.012674925848841667, 0.03969414532184601, 0.04255950450897217, -0.03913426026701927, 0.020110372453927994, -0.043243784457445145, -0.0681060180068016, 0.007848905399441719, -0.010139941237866879, -0.041770078241825104, 0.03690653666853905, -0.008312986232340336, -0.0019362716702744365, 0.04027390852570534, -0.02880244143307209, 0.01849432848393917, -0.0027711556758731604, 0.02763676829636097, -0.01095947902649641, 0.08625580370426178, 0.01821064203977585, 0.016508284956216812, 0.005851428490132093, -0.03247617185115814, 0.13745899498462677, 0.04655946418642998, 0.01997586525976658, -0.0446343757212162, 0.028881337493658066, 0.004170512314885855, -0.016276484355330467, 0.012058870866894722, 0.014319803565740585, -0.0010456086602061987, 0.003299763659015298, 0.05282500386238098, 0.044701769948005676, -0.02016623504459858, 0.01839013770222664, 0.059495314955711365, -0.010104400105774403, 0.0044961473904550076, 0.02246842347085476, 0.011887161992490292, -0.010947726666927338, -0.03041062317788601, -0.043110836297273636, 0.04968653619289398, -0.0013836963335052133, -0.005438799038529396, -0.035762932151556015, -0.02366711013019085, -0.002895330311730504, 0.011626011691987514, -0.012965244241058826, 0.027164706960320473, 0.013022692874073982, -0.0029294691048562527, -0.0038791117258369923, -0.002976593328639865, 0.025496836751699448, -0.023515596985816956, -0.010617840103805065, 0.03009365312755108, -0.007055757567286491, 0.023474054411053658, -0.014727822504937649, 0.027442103251814842, -0.028667552396655083, -0.03879464045166969, -0.06269403547048569, 0.014005497097969055, -0.004631825722754002, 0.020864997059106827, 0.010762916877865791, 0.005714796483516693, 0.01173925120383501, -0.04300443455576897, -0.01570052094757557, 0.0127696692943573, 0.03762500733137131, -0.02986278012394905, 0.01920377090573311, 0.013435572385787964, 0.02425215020775795, -0.0066149877384305, 0.025140754878520966, -0.007994024083018303, -0.031061289831995964, -0.056788962334394455, -0.052534688264131546, 0.040115293115377426, -0.008632058277726173, -0.031761568039655685, 0.008626502007246017, -0.06287752836942673, -0.0030949462670832872, -0.024363528937101364, 0.044438812881708145, -0.010599764063954353, 0.017513232305645943, 0.003873607376590371, -0.016293520107865334, 0.0057144854217767715, -0.03824710473418236, 0.010039737448096275, -0.047023121267557144, 0.0015711323358118534, -0.013483879156410694, -0.0010372090619057417, 0.033271778374910355, 0.02037716656923294, 0.038674596697092056, 0.006810673978179693, 0.0033221994526684284, 0.035355135798454285, 0.006480035372078419, -0.05691216140985489, -0.017034020274877548, 0.0187201127409935, -0.03515445441007614, 0.016153255477547646, -0.010702092200517654, 0.07542940974235535, 0.01267752144485712, 0.015629932284355164, -0.02371637523174286, 0.031123917549848557, -0.015840670093894005, 0.027007699012756348, -0.012256138026714325, -0.05308562517166138, 0.0111983772367239, -0.03762787953019142, 0.0108946543186903, -0.030421627685427666, -0.015725834295153618, -0.013627303764224052, -0.07333862036466599, 0.010227533988654613, -0.0148045988753438, -0.019915755838155746, 0.00303901475854218, 0.001742191263474524, -0.011991238221526146, -0.0017477679066359997, -0.01414379570633173, -0.011880027130246162, -0.02167842909693718, -0.03842762112617493, -0.008785726502537727, 0.01864590495824814, 0.013614052906632423, 0.003984528128057718, -0.0018633768195286393, 0.045297447592020035, 0.0054583740420639515, 0.05048050731420517, -0.0076649864204227924, 0.014087132178246975, 0.006663200445473194, 0.05899087339639664, -0.0031336317770183086, 0.006637612823396921, 0.03674285113811493, -0.027875099331140518, -0.0297259334474802, 0.03105030581355095, 0.010807248763740063, 0.03251650556921959, -0.009530934505164623, 0.0012009252095595002, -0.03664236515760422, 0.05229011923074722, -0.01832323707640171, -0.017327016219496727, -0.04582897201180458, -0.0065391696989536285, 0.045886747539043427, -0.0031887830700725317, 0.014943978749215603, -0.018893344327807426, -0.0129313413053751, 0.006035961210727692, 0.0039858100935816765, -0.0238993838429451, -0.009673228487372398, 0.008651439100503922, -0.00005400878580985591, 0.005871165078133345, -0.002813047729432583, -0.007993143051862717, 0.046705372631549835, 0.03788250312209129, -0.01949135959148407, 0.01753656007349491, -0.035069163888692856, 0.025782553479075432, -0.0702221542596817, -0.04577265679836273, 0.03339516744017601, -0.015836309641599655, 0.028871988877654076, -0.058830004185438156, -0.002440498676151037, 0.03310055658221245, -0.009738127700984478, 0.030808374285697937, -0.021429430693387985, -0.00713919335976243, -0.034921370446681976, 0.029231004416942596, -0.016192814335227013, -0.020291509106755257, 0.0036789411678910255, 0.03160736709833145, 0.05323335528373718, 0.01048141811043024, 0.013886095955967903, -0.03455887734889984, -0.037069130688905716, -0.014352367259562016, 0.037376098334789276, -0.06823853403329849, 0.02625885233283043, -0.03202352672815323, -0.030385242775082588, 0.05984414368867874, -0.012372308410704136, 0.026295796036720276, -0.0041189310140907764, 0.02306872047483921, -0.01926446333527565, 0.07278674095869064, 0.014026383869349957, 0.040949221700429916, -0.025660697370767593, -0.02538205124437809, 0.023685112595558167, 0.012851406820118427, -0.03463580831885338, 0.010994169861078262, 0.0272295530885458, -0.019332095980644226, -0.024947514757514, 0.03895474597811699, -0.010005281306803226, -0.02448761835694313, -0.026941463351249695, -0.004765726625919342, 0.021450472995638847, -0.03088863380253315, 0.006964674685150385, -0.058675557374954224, 0.013294392265379429, 0.033692073076963425, 0.03457149118185043, -0.025593191385269165, 0.021714724600315094, 0.0016794002149254084, -0.04432427138090134, -0.034803908318281174, 0.013045907951891422, -0.04072640836238861, -0.03135598450899124, -0.009673255495727062, -0.016797704622149467, 0.019159182906150818, -0.007049560081213713, 0.013020736165344715, -0.0508117750287056, 0.036356888711452484, -0.03204603120684624, 0.028081147000193596, 0.01411424670368433, 0.008640583604574203, 0.013846461661159992, -0.08026088029146194, 0.050552334636449814, 0.012758889235556126, -0.022131040692329407, -0.04234813153743744, -0.013460223563015461, -0.03683095797896385, 0.013405447825789452, 0.03879312053322792, 0.0072043281979858875, -0.0007852185517549515, -0.018532685935497284, 0.015802113339304924, 0.009352916851639748, -0.06441208720207214, 0.030617404729127884, -0.015613837167620659, -0.05024370551109314, -0.003675247309729457, -0.008709796704351902, -0.01665252447128296, 0.0006361263222061098, -0.023475054651498795, -0.02485683374106884, -0.015038646757602692, -0.009849745780229568, 0.008505727164447308, 0.020793726667761803, -0.029545413330197334, -0.0664525181055069, 0.010560392402112484, -0.010370106436312199, -0.019828174263238907, 0.007648508530110121, 0.046554457396268845, -0.02664756029844284, 0.03729228675365448, -0.01789056323468685, -0.033354148268699646, -0.00604207394644618, 0.030635681003332138, 0.0033889170736074448, -0.07298672944307327, 0.0071290023624897, 0.03664163872599602, -0.03073890693485737, 0.02108706161379814, 0.057034946978092194, -0.006837238557636738, 0.04632074758410454, -0.0019652966875582933, 0.02634480781853199, -0.0032434514723718166, -0.03853223845362663, 0.04618307575583458, 0.027092859148979187, -0.002871859585866332, 0.020741168409585953, -0.03658446669578552, 0.002683805301785469, -0.02428492344915867, 0.01993451826274395, 0.013222988694906235, 0.0476398766040802, -0.026929184794425964, -0.016262715682387352, 0.02711384743452072, -0.0418744720518589, 0.024913525208830833, 0.006678561680018902, -0.030293578281998634, 0.03459491953253746, 0.007259725593030453, 0.0065024178475141525, -0.08910589665174484, -0.005519172176718712, -0.006268137134611607, -0.003464791225269437, 0.009293525479733944, 0.023147854954004288, -0.018795443698763847, 0.04678494483232498, 0.0036677378229796886, -0.01330256275832653, 0.018407205119729042, -0.006831038277596235, 0.06007102131843567, -0.028461040928959846, -0.0067433821968734264, 0.008793562650680542, -0.03272556513547897, -0.06118420511484146, 0.0021643347572535276, 0.003994090482592583, 0.03587351739406586, 0.054063037037849426, 0.015240639448165894, -0.019176814705133438, 0.006257414352148771, 0.0302201509475708, -0.06136498600244522, -0.04631275683641434, -0.027822116389870644, -0.015551893971860409, -0.028094448149204254, -0.017741117626428604 ]
<p>Give the following table</p> <pre><code> Male | Female | Total Likes 10 | 3 | 13 Indifferent 20 | 20 | 40 Dislikes 10 | 9 | 19 Total 40 32 72 </code></pre> <p>Here the independent variable is gender which is nominal. The dependent variable which is ordinal is either likers, indifferent, or dislikes. I can use the Chi Square test or Exact Fisher to determine if a H0 such as <em>men and women are equally likely to be likers</em> should be rejected.</p> <p>However, the question I would like to answer after this is: <strong>which gender is significantly more likely than the other to be a liker? And, by how much?</strong></p> <p>For example: Men are x% significantly more likely than Women to be likers. </p> <p>I thought that the next step would be to perform a test between liker and each group: i.e. males and likers. But I got stumped because I thought I should be comparing males to females with respect to likers. </p> <p>Is there any standard way of approaching this question?</p>
73,622
[ -0.013225683942437172, -0.04516921564936638, 0.0053286124020814896, 0.015086369588971138, 0.046384047716856, 0.01826952025294304, 0.006279469467699528, -0.012807808816432953, 0.039684735238552094, 0.012804032303392887, 0.05236833915114403, 0.022668391466140747, 0.08687353879213333, 0.009412377141416073, 0.017664438113570213, -0.003045423189178109, -0.012461782433092594, -0.00006878206477267668, 0.017076868563890457, 0.0011131344363093376, -0.023444846272468567, 0.012776689603924751, 0.019905857741832733, 0.00040252378676086664, -0.013698220252990723, 0.03992161527276039, 0.028688965365290642, -0.018011514097452164, -0.006605551112443209, 0.02622550167143345, -0.021645568311214447, -0.026395341381430626, -0.0020358881447464228, -0.004056084435433149, 0.014769142493605614, 0.008907631039619446, -0.001003239769488573, 0.02301383577287197, -0.04442335292696953, 0.013828889466822147, -0.027198685333132744, 0.019911741837859154, -0.01126831490546465, 0.009976654313504696, -0.009787150658667088, -0.005943786818534136, 0.009929532185196877, -0.017958953976631165, 0.019461574032902718, -0.0507357120513916, 0.0567878857254982, 0.009531895630061626, 0.05271513760089874, 0.0320819690823555, 0.0027534582186490297, -0.04235054925084114, 0.0443723127245903, 0.04902271553874016, -0.03119060955941677, -0.035686809569597244, -0.034733615815639496, -0.05108853057026863, 0.007057182490825653, -0.0275740884244442, -0.04661489278078079, 0.0038040413055568933, -0.026075880974531174, -0.038343384861946106, 0.020793534815311432, -0.03227033466100693, -0.013344649225473404, 0.051964595913887024, 0.05021461471915245, -0.0022517878096550703, 0.004720832221210003, -0.02690000645816326, 0.0348857045173645, 0.021882135421037674, 0.0235998947173357, 0.04269123077392578, 0.004957393743097782, 0.022937972098588943, 0.02761196158826351, 0.053850457072257996, 0.04165034741163254, -0.04463819041848183, 0.031506627798080444, 0.005383354611694813, -0.027244392782449722, 0.044006336480379105, -0.01863829791545868, -0.012357879430055618, 0.047522928565740585, 0.03687744587659836, -0.06181634962558746, 0.017123108729720116, -0.00690750777721405, 0.04550187662243843, 0.025741877034306526, -0.012517699971795082, -0.026472553610801697, -0.013080320321023464, 0.051050879061222076, 0.05977405607700348, -0.0203452967107296, -0.0059247734025120735, -0.05439933016896248, -0.007727333810180426, -0.002521779853850603, -0.014222498051822186, 0.012394752353429794, 0.03510589897632599, 0.012541452422738075, 0.0077463663183152676, 0.028109200298786163, -0.011879978701472282, -0.02391139231622219, -0.051225077360868454, 0.08242564648389816, 0.03984256461262703, 0.016183817759156227, 0.0075006610713899136, 0.06567893177270889, -0.009840263985097408, -0.03243829682469368, 0.02912003919482231, 0.021361887454986572, -0.01802183873951435, -0.00045906109153293073, 0.04053128883242607, -0.0478631854057312, 0.016813741996884346, 0.037970881909132004, 0.027035150676965714, 0.0019230720354244113, -0.019557785242795944, -0.07556245476007462, -0.047846175730228424, 0.00758453318849206, -0.00527271069586277, 0.027263818308711052, -0.060561757534742355, -0.0024557162541896105, 0.06495252251625061, 0.026953669264912605, -0.0011344626545906067, 0.044545527547597885, 0.016137471422553062, -0.02850494347512722, 0.042096178978681564, -0.03798960521817207, -0.03534848615527153, -0.03250544145703316, -0.016864998266100883, -0.02008800394833088, -0.07520901411771774, 0.0018743379041552544, -0.01046781800687313, -0.02762177772819996, -0.011690598912537098, 0.023358894512057304, -0.015557876788079739, -0.03501519188284874, 0.013463051989674568, -0.0037410520017147064, -0.022897789254784584, 0.09285402297973633, -0.009301313199102879, 0.01855550706386566, -0.000689308566506952, -0.004787510260939598, 0.016789348796010017, 0.0021251451689749956, 0.03078494220972061, 0.054799772799015045, 0.013298636302351952, -0.01968648098409176, -0.024388346821069717, 0.009671143256127834, -0.018632445484399796, -0.04576945677399635, -0.03912167251110077, -0.01937023550271988, -0.01644737832248211, -0.0052556367591023445, 0.0048850965686142445, 0.010662325657904148, -0.02644447796046734, 0.008358600549399853, -0.026003802195191383, -0.06376133114099503, -0.09218411892652512, -0.03232773393392563, 0.01759195327758789, -0.05289895832538605, -0.009752116166055202, 0.010223891586065292, -0.0026413036976009607, -0.0013243318535387516, -0.028322793543338776, -0.028780214488506317, -0.03202531859278679, 0.02305041439831257, -0.04842941462993622, -0.00838751345872879, 0.05242563411593437, 0.018995266407728195, -0.017224285751581192, 0.04563269764184952, -0.027095502242445946, -0.04062088578939438, 0.008652077987790108, -0.025752494111657143, 0.0009757506777532399, 0.018193243071436882, -0.04293815419077873, 0.04823555424809456, 0.032204270362854004, -0.009657751768827438, 0.04138985648751259, -0.04962817579507828, 0.05654877424240112, 0.05606706812977791, 0.019166374579072, -0.011559661477804184, -0.03297573700547218, 0.017331255599856377, -0.00030968079227022827, -0.014341017231345177, -0.0024274871684610844, -0.05451548099517822, 0.012082121334969997, 0.003716044593602419, -0.010818622075021267, -0.06344825774431229, -0.0005376132321543992, 0.033994629979133606, 0.033651549369096756, 0.03450328856706619, 0.04032520204782486, -0.03194216266274452, -0.03873077780008316, 0.003005055943503976, 0.023033129051327705, -0.0007354620029218495, 0.052664466202259064, 0.023906460031867027, 0.052833132445812225, 0.03634633868932724, 0.033346425741910934, 0.020564494654536247, 0.04270682483911514, -0.013000569306313992, -0.0009892808739095926, 0.019954852759838104, -0.03145672008395195, 0.010754297487437725, -0.011580978520214558, -0.020962141454219818, 0.07350759208202362, 0.00311018037609756, -0.008259139023721218, 0.00516869593411684, -0.0017900295788422227, -0.016787221655249596, 0.033974479883909225, -0.033087357878685, 0.01811429299414158, 0.025406397879123688, 0.008284682407975197, 0.03500422462821007, -0.014953423291444778, -0.011146556586027145, -0.05410991981625557, -0.018493719398975372, 0.044023942202329636, 0.023682575672864914, 0.005760354921221733, 0.028211427852511406, -0.02033565565943718, -0.01611305959522724, -0.03721976652741432, 0.010238483548164368, -0.006150422617793083, -0.06017623841762543, -0.048867061734199524, -0.04318292811512947, -0.025547198951244354, 0.00624819053336978, -0.021934781223535538, -0.011180977337062359, 0.028933679684996605, 0.010847686789929867, -0.044786177575588226, 0.01945083774626255, 0.002818451961502433, 0.026636281982064247, -0.02703305520117283, -0.03659158945083618, 0.011831303127110004, 0.030168721452355385, -0.017166050150990486, 0.03709648177027702, -0.01959848403930664, -0.06619934737682343, 0.024620138108730316, 0.011203603819012642, -0.007331756874918938, 0.008809608407318592, -0.01599377579987049, 0.02408755198121071, -0.0010812175460159779, -0.011429736390709877, -0.08158589154481888, -0.04346354678273201, 0.020054861903190613, -0.012459445744752884, 0.03619549050927162, 0.016620496287941933, -0.01137029193341732, 0.035899918526411057, 0.04275504872202873, -0.009813029319047928, -0.03747294843196869, 0.023647205904126167, -0.03791674226522446, -0.03120739385485649, 0.045537661761045456, 0.027100497856736183, 0.027070410549640656, 0.013385226018726826, 0.0020893793553113937, 0.0029207186307758093, 0.026372147724032402, -0.02796347439289093, -0.015486493706703186, 0.023729784414172173, 0.0034188292920589447, -0.0263070035725832, 0.025949876755475998, 0.04168316349387169, -0.033404573798179626, 0.020655924454331398, 0.021414779126644135, 0.031155522912740707, 0.016692550852894783, 0.0005159360007382929, 0.001433816971257329, -0.017973221838474274, -0.016776615753769875, -0.021462691947817802, 0.0590084046125412, -0.0034415016416460276, -0.015140151605010033, 0.013840769417583942, 0.003916385117918253, 0.03206370770931244, -0.03886411339044571, 0.00047887524124234915, 0.0797937884926796, 0.03233437240123749, 0.019786624237895012, 0.005373241845518351, -0.007664176169782877, -0.0032629172783344984, 0.044650301337242126, -0.04125821590423584, -0.027030430734157562, 0.021803762763738632, 0.06445828825235367, 0.057784225791692734, 0.019179485738277435, -0.03950965031981468, 0.01975618675351143, -0.05313050374388695, -0.01170020829886198, -0.013631388545036316, 0.06387658417224884, -0.0028369121719151735, 0.05246163159608841, 0.0488184317946434, 0.0220012329518795, -0.021757666021585464, -0.00622985977679491, -0.022605951875448227, 0.06753719598054886, -0.01330105122178793, 0.00004887168688583188, 0.021338503807783127, -0.004137715324759483, 0.014674544334411621, -0.017939889803528786, -0.003002815879881382, 0.0074554025195539, 0.031187238171696663, -0.022774605080485344, 0.054197054356336594, -0.0067182923667132854, 0.02283327281475067, 0.007764673791825771, 0.03342572972178459, -0.020371098071336746, -0.029108960181474686, 0.016213858500123024, 0.047729507088661194, -0.05141522362828255, 0.008267172612249851, -0.04157157987356186, 0.012520376592874527, 0.01058503333479166, 0.05911974608898163, 0.016370614990592003, 0.01423773542046547, -0.021595483645796776, 0.02336241491138935, -0.017764508724212646, 0.038915615528821945, 0.054108235985040665, -0.004637277219444513, -0.019895227625966072, -0.02665763907134533, 0.009438252076506615, -0.014237204566597939, 0.02342027798295021, -0.004771722014993429, -0.0027800798416137695, 0.06552929431200027, 0.07240282744169235, -0.027262495830655098, 0.007316334638744593, 0.05445096641778946, 0.04944819584488869, -0.022129828110337257, -0.03535674884915352, -0.030048508197069168, -0.022952016443014145, -0.005687969736754894, 0.030548224225640297, 0.03590898588299751, 0.011501988396048546, -0.006201803218573332, 0.054888058453798294, -0.005116525571793318, -0.06251873821020126, -0.01018575206398964, -0.030102944001555443, 0.039131976664066315, -0.025770898908376694, -0.062041010707616806, -0.01992422342300415, 0.04794151335954666, 0.04032346233725548, 0.026632042601704597, -0.02444753609597683, -0.10053971409797668, 0.02460615523159504, 0.033835671842098236, 0.04878053069114685, -0.08113221824169159, -0.024111051112413406, 0.028309695422649384, 0.007409927435219288, 0.08897154778242111, -0.031048787757754326, 0.009579567238688469, 0.0013970759464427829, -0.025325551629066467, -0.010220617987215519, 0.01190247479826212, -0.02875855751335621, 0.009454813785851002, -0.014084875583648682, 0.029434602707624435, -0.003618246177211404, -0.05909597501158714, -0.04059354588389397, -0.0021309093572199345, 0.016916250810027122, 0.006811126135289669, -0.030177757143974304, -0.024419575929641724, -0.004624171182513237, -0.006547639612108469, -0.011581463739275932, -0.05439120903611183, 0.009426215663552284, 0.03677935153245926, -0.017360089346766472, 0.08110661804676056, -0.016304953023791313, 0.02145158126950264, 0.0190084520727396, -0.018605850636959076, -0.031285520642995834, 0.02775469236075878, -0.01278538629412651, 0.046386610716581345, 0.015228774398565292, -0.005334720481187105, 0.05880160629749298, 0.029530927538871765, -0.036070458590984344, 0.007386141922324896, -0.020194485783576965, -0.043772630393505096, -0.03843052312731743, -0.015712760388851166, -0.03026008978486061, 0.01019354909658432, -0.035012129694223404, 0.03944855183362961, -0.0053800237365067005, -0.009534464217722416, -0.011770782992243767, -0.005018281284719706, 0.007234022952616215, 0.07524830102920532, -0.018267305567860603, -0.015140702947974205, -0.006351441610604525, 0.02786722220480442, 0.009007243439555168, -0.03742998093366623, 0.016077715903520584, -0.015949109569191933, -0.01775597408413887, -0.02343210205435753, -0.02763943187892437, -0.00798332504928112, -0.06087915971875191, -0.034556612372398376, 0.010676255449652672, -0.0018941630842164159, 0.026525991037487984, -0.00566475884988904, 0.03534353896975517, 0.020337678492069244, -0.02486562728881836, -0.006705394946038723, 0.03077409230172634, 0.02422640286386013, 0.03275735676288605, -0.012812437489628792, 0.03744915500283241, 0.009557930752635002, 0.00416552321985364, -0.10325122624635696, -0.015682388097047806, 0.006658746860921383, 0.006007918156683445, -0.04860561341047287, -0.020559947937726974, -0.03405288606882095, -0.018794145435094833, -0.018917053937911987, 0.0010843477211892605, 0.035061340779066086, 0.01777942292392254, -0.022522492334246635, -0.020954031497240067, -0.017513692378997803, 0.07926545292139053, 0.03428911417722702, 0.008343109861016273, 0.0030638454481959343, -0.03360540419816971, -0.004914033226668835, 0.01802842877805233, -0.00018737799837253988, -0.06250134855508804, -0.041331272572278976, -0.02177456021308899, -0.01306389831006527, 0.04528838396072388, 0.012683716602623463, -0.026072775945067406, -0.008582163602113724, -0.009963281452655792, -0.022012218832969666, -0.04323292151093483, 0.015558387152850628, -0.028324106708168983, 0.01584186591207981, -0.01827615685760975, -0.010112127289175987, -0.0393788106739521, 0.012136985547840595, 0.01276108156889677, 0.017759518697857857, -0.05788607522845268, -0.003140432294458151, 0.05209672823548317, -0.012196858413517475, -0.0072836787439882755, -0.00196036696434021, -0.0039002313278615475, 0.030481288209557533, 0.008581770583987236, -0.0044104959815740585, -0.0042451126500964165, 0.0593147836625576, 0.00903963204473257, -0.026618974283337593, -0.024640096351504326, -0.009415514767169952, 0.035903774201869965, -0.024644162505865097, -0.0012657357146963477, 0.02613695338368416, 0.03436717391014099, -0.02315666899085045, -0.024772662669420242, -0.02601788379251957, -0.006662390194833279, 0.05919449403882027, 0.029849031940102577, 0.010745292529463768, 0.03482198715209961, 0.06174178421497345, 0.005066155921667814, 0.02967320941388607, 0.07057802379131317, 0.04242581129074097, 0.030489057302474976, 0.025957785546779633, -0.049138396978378296, -0.004774876404553652, 0.036598414182662964, -0.029797010123729706, 0.05489437282085419, -0.059898246079683304, -0.008756183087825775, 0.024485532194375992, 0.061331138014793396, -0.0017844106769189239, -0.03816674277186394, -0.03987357020378113, -0.024721823632717133, 0.012630890123546124, 0.02853843942284584, 0.005884531419724226, 0.015145518817007542, 0.0008258599555119872, 0.04092938452959061, 0.003250343492254615, 0.0043352507054805756, -0.013808377087116241, -0.09111692011356354, 0.005019837990403175, 0.028438031673431396, -0.018955985084176064, 0.030432874336838722, -0.012034326791763306, -0.04507799446582794, 0.006169121712446213, -0.04711261764168739, 0.01874125376343727, -0.025600092485547066, 0.023850996047258377, -0.010525288060307503, 0.049010422080755234, -0.012796292081475258, 0.013080170378088951, 0.02009558118879795, -0.010437649674713612, 0.094242624938488, 0.05661178007721901, 0.0147430170327425, -0.05577302724123001, 0.06579826027154922, -0.0037967737298458815, -0.039113111793994904, -0.016118573024868965, -0.008907409384846687, 0.041851457208395004, 0.014609470963478088, 0.05329441279172897, 0.06182781979441643, 0.013912825845181942, 0.018001431599259377, 0.06194663420319557, -0.015470554120838642, -0.03506894409656525, -0.0040379539132118225, 0.015238999389111996, 0.0166297797113657, -0.042822010815143585, -0.03644080087542534, -0.02146821841597557, 0.04091328755021095, -0.011113923974335194, -0.02487170137465, 0.02293567918241024, 0.023616677150130272, -0.012651452794671059, -0.03469613566994667, 0.014316597022116184, 0.01743643917143345, 0.022070985287427902, -0.0310191847383976, -0.02025238797068596, 0.016625436022877693, -0.02862311527132988, 0.021359048783779144, 0.02285248599946499, -0.0032100644893944263, -0.0032395601738244295, 0.0021584252826869488, 0.02188221737742424, -0.03625042364001274, -0.035812221467494965, -0.05297062173485756, 0.014087141491472721, -0.007900633849203587, -0.02965816669166088, 0.007376018911600113, 0.018121732398867607, 0.008006053976714611, -0.031194565817713737, 0.00199263752438128, 0.03155488893389702, 0.026427676901221275, -0.02616501785814762, -0.029410531744360924, -0.040072664618492126, 0.013524902984499931, -0.021841756999492645, 0.012599174864590168, 0.0006107378285378218, -0.016866156831383705, -0.059013061225414276, -0.022836603224277496, 0.028246106579899788, -0.010529828257858753, -0.004957431927323341, -0.02345999702811241, -0.018040234223008156, -0.015980206429958344, 0.004589463584125042, -0.008433086797595024, 0.00389154558070004, -0.003627848345786333, 0.0014843125827610493, -0.004099590238183737, -0.047592926770448685, 0.030683431774377823, 0.005251444410532713, -0.023926176130771637, 0.0009353854693472385, -0.018460800871253014, 0.007848400622606277, 0.015205043368041515, -0.0016399231972172856, 0.01874101720750332, 0.02828500233590603, -0.006031904835253954, 0.026736067607998848, -0.006756266113370657, -0.05375903844833374, -0.050861768424510956, -0.03921188414096832, -0.0658760517835617, -0.0012746923603117466, 0.0008850547601468861, 0.027870936319231987, -0.03805237263441086, 0.02325596660375595, -0.003341173753142357, -0.008438939228653908, 0.0043373568914830685, 0.011930913664400578, 0.02962653525173664, -0.04822665825486183, -0.03232424706220627, 0.0210733599960804, -0.005927050951868296, -0.05484803020954132, -0.022898977622389793, -0.05548746511340141, -0.03493256866931915, 0.01071128249168396, 0.0014361519133672118, -0.023486699908971786, 0.009093938395380974, -0.027593031525611877, 0.016590841114521027, -0.02237812802195549, 0.0005963227595202625, -0.02990192547440529, -0.03691114857792854, 0.04733444005250931, 0.013701621443033218, -0.01090332679450512, 0.0025458778254687786, -0.008746032603085041, 0.04904995486140251, 0.022960513830184937, 0.009674648754298687, 0.029776282608509064, 0.0048394110053777695, 0.014967883937060833, 0.020232034847140312, 0.07818525284528732, -0.01469490583986044, -0.025488026440143585, 0.014504635706543922, -0.06709404289722443, -0.01549771148711443, 0.035858672112226486, -0.00455413106828928, 0.03436591476202011, -0.004451517015695572, -0.02535620518028736, 0.030910642817616463, 0.023150725290179253, -0.004764809273183346, -0.037825144827365875, -0.006845655385404825, 0.0019757223781198263, 0.030575236305594444, -0.022689955309033394, -0.017428027465939522, 0.009503289125859737, 0.00676682498306036, 0.04351029545068741, 0.06468760222196579, 0.026347750797867775, -0.012109536677598953, -0.022146373987197876, 0.04794295132160187, 0.019789263606071472, -0.00343379401601851, -0.030398288741707802, 0.0043173921294510365, 0.04374559223651886, -0.05144977569580078, 0.006952551659196615, -0.005381462164223194, 0.02455711178481579, -0.06328058987855911, -0.0012405425077304244, 0.01364121213555336, -0.004453830420970917, 0.03361837565898895, -0.037268687039613724, 0.014109907671809196, 0.0038679554127156734, -0.035055555403232574, -0.008127948269248009, -0.0351242795586586, -0.00242456141859293, -0.040394265204668045, -0.0019407758954912424, -0.016264237463474274, 0.015570828691124916, 0.03230578824877739, 0.007283301558345556, 0.029727943241596222, -0.004279573913663626, 0.016108104959130287, -0.01689055562019348, 0.02297372743487358, 0.0036463383585214615, -0.00012968439841642976, -0.08902981877326965, 0.030083347111940384, -0.04445386677980423, -0.042889304459095, 0.048475440591573715, -0.009865629486739635, 0.028868617489933968, 0.01115330494940281, 0.00019886302470695227, 0.002780240960419178, 0.04135166481137276, -0.00581177556887269, 0.021215101704001427, -0.03597470745444298, 0.05109106004238129, -0.012140209786593914, 0.05011891573667526, -0.009879164397716522, -0.015596350654959679, 0.0031014252454042435, -0.053138814866542816, -0.004567740485072136, 0.01275887805968523, -0.008368697948753834, -0.000058575529692461714, -0.0319896824657917, -0.03833985701203346, 0.05067242681980133, -0.03088541142642498, 0.03742328658699989, -0.039764195680618286, -0.01643114537000656, 0.009210231713950634, 0.02295484021306038, 0.018575308844447136, 0.0018490618094801903, -0.016870111227035522, -0.05681551620364189, -0.02735733985900879, 0.022148752585053444, 0.017107805237174034, -0.07019635289907455, -0.010029463097453117, -0.03745456412434578, 0.02259696088731289, 0.0037652605678886175, -0.006324649788439274, -0.03559098020195961, 0.049666933715343475, -0.0553445890545845, 0.0013228891184553504, 0.011334736831486225, -0.020788663998246193, 0.020276321098208427, -0.08406778424978256, 0.022894082590937614, 0.024732345715165138, -0.03190748021006584, 0.003124937880784273, 0.005998742766678333, -0.05771571025252342, -0.017565108835697174, 0.0639156848192215, 0.010841443203389645, -0.028574181720614433, 0.008093290030956268, 0.003926429431885481, -0.03333190456032753, -0.02747858129441738, 0.029303692281246185, -0.006542273331433535, 0.00719703733921051, -0.022109506651759148, -0.006227793172001839, 0.04111482575535774, -0.01730765588581562, 0.03232184797525406, 0.009555704891681671, 0.007592175621539354, -0.010101868771016598, -0.03703165799379349, 0.024488482624292374, 0.007130553480237722, 0.005461792461574078, 0.02998599410057068, 0.007681055925786495, 0.0005487151793204248, 0.04540589824318886, 0.014364691451191902, -0.025615269318223, 0.0483376644551754, -0.03662799671292305, 0.010616479441523552, 0.01365748606622219, 0.04025697708129883, -0.007632272318005562, -0.08222620189189911, -0.014288639649748802, 0.03425120189785957, -0.021929124370217323, -0.00194400770124048, -0.00880416203290224, 0.046805478632450104, 0.02380369044840336, -0.010868140496313572, 0.018137075006961823, -0.003686107462272048, -0.04957558214664459, 0.015080850571393967, 0.02934929169714451, 0.028371131047606468, 0.028516989201307297, 0.012682969681918621, 0.02740420587360859, -0.021633336320519447, 0.032666873186826706, 0.03137148544192314, 0.03111928142607212, 0.02027636580169201, -0.02190583012998104, 0.024875584989786148, 0.010739575140178204, 0.0064697349444031715, 0.03553657978773117, -0.016054784879088402, 0.04227220639586449, -0.03230529651045799, -0.010057315230369568, -0.04157659783959389, -0.015408258885145187, -0.015591473318636417, 0.022983847185969353, 0.03620906546711922, 0.007506269961595535, -0.020160451531410217, 0.020141173154115677, 0.009855645708739758, -0.010267511010169983, 0.00971058290451765, -0.01593954861164093, 0.030016610398888588, -0.03334670886397362, -0.0176527202129364, -0.007151126395910978, -0.02262662537395954, -0.04360107332468033, 0.01949811913073063, 0.08464735001325607, 0.012374664656817913, 0.048308320343494415, 0.010685530491173267, 0.004473169334232807, -0.013416314497590065, 0.05869082361459732, -0.03893067687749863, -0.0770283117890358, -0.0695526972413063, 0.011995065957307816, -0.0076894499361515045, -0.02025221474468708 ]
<p>I'm trying to understand the assumptions of different parameterizations in a Markov network. In this case, I'm trying to understand the assumptions (and effects) that result from parameterizing pairwise potentials with pairwise frequencies (i.e., $\psi_{(a, b)} = p(a, b)$), which the authors use in:</p> <p>Mitrofanova, A. et al. Prediction of Protein Functions with Gene Ontology and Interspecies Protein Homology Data. IEEE/ACM Trans. Comput. Biol. and Bioinf., 8, 775–784.</p> <p>Let's say we have a 3 node network (a)-(b)-(c), where the RV are Bernoulli. By chain rule of probability (and independence), in all cases, $p(a, b, c) = p(a) p(b|a) p(c|b)$.</p> <p>First, if we define $p(a, b, c) = \psi_{a, b}(a,b) \psi_{b, c}(b,c)$, where $\psi_{a, b} = p(a, b)$ and $\psi_{b, c} = p(b, c)$, then it appears that $p(b)$ must be equal to 1 (or 0). What would happen in larger, loopy networks?</p> <p>Second, if we use the same number of free parameters, constrained so each local potential sums to one, and learned the parameters (but the potentials need not be marginals), then I calculate that $p(b) = \psi_1(b) \psi_2(b)$, where $\psi_1(b) = \Sigma_a\psi_{b,c}$. As long as I don't assume $\psi_1(b) = \psi_2(b) = p(b)$, then is it a valid, useful parameterization? Are there any assumptions?</p> <p>Third, let's now remove the constraint on the local potentials, and add in a global normalization constant instead. If I compare $p(a) p(b|a) p(c|b)$ to $\frac{1}{Z} p(a,b) p(c,b)$, I can see that $Z = p(b)$. That's good.</p> <p>If, however, I try to calculate $Z$ by summing over all combinations of $a, b, c$, then I get that Z equals $\Sigma_b{p(b)p(b)}$. What happened?</p>
73,623
[ -0.024983128532767296, -0.02670452371239662, -0.013158013112843037, -0.022223886102437973, -0.015586023218929768, -0.01314342487603426, -0.05637093260884285, -0.029094386845827103, 0.03056611306965351, -0.022745762020349503, 0.03988970071077347, 0.010150113143026829, 0.012586811557412148, -0.010379751212894917, 0.003919465001672506, 0.04731682315468788, -0.0038685838226228952, 0.006928951479494572, -0.020480681210756302, 0.014974834397435188, 0.03733561933040619, 0.06480642408132553, 0.061846304684877396, 0.00022768632334191352, -0.01960773579776287, 0.030899900943040848, 0.01665692776441574, -0.014729476533830166, -0.0032090989407151937, 0.09508123993873596, -0.045020055025815964, -0.012486901134252548, 0.0336885042488575, 0.04418925195932388, 0.002228831872344017, 0.012814386747777462, -0.055323634296655655, -0.049184877425432205, -0.026144759729504585, 0.05844813212752342, -0.03875816985964775, -0.009700322523713112, 0.01407033670693636, 0.04352039098739624, -0.0229587871581316, 0.04096904769539833, -0.009174688719213009, -0.032495614141225815, 0.018856264650821686, -0.04607723653316498, 0.06744158267974854, 0.003908551763743162, 0.022045839577913284, 0.03436826914548874, -0.00963812880218029, -0.03003070317208767, 0.07585223019123077, 0.05199303478002548, 0.02285279519855976, -0.09151811897754669, -0.028351588174700737, -0.011169041506946087, 0.04112628847360611, -0.015924498438835144, -0.05042925849556923, 0.045247647911310196, 0.04178907349705696, -0.00336051476188004, 0.024336490780115128, 0.005282001569867134, 0.011164776980876923, -0.022883590310811996, 0.04156308248639107, 0.0039509921334683895, 0.04454878345131874, 0.05107215419411659, -0.024010131135582924, 0.019823510199785233, 0.004051499534398317, 0.018884344026446342, -0.01721973530948162, 0.042388319969177246, -0.0057240864261984825, 0.025520246475934982, 0.011271812953054905, -0.026656195521354675, 0.06670991331338882, -0.017103342339396477, 0.000014877050489303656, -0.018718797713518143, -0.01564895361661911, 0.0102161830291152, 0.05855969339609146, -0.043427783995866776, -0.036574769765138626, 0.03625544160604477, 0.005603124853223562, -0.027669191360473633, -0.012581625021994114, -0.04807496815919876, -0.03068317286670208, -0.05197134613990784, -0.02925059013068676, 0.06214204430580139, -0.014125297777354717, 0.0004225859884172678, -0.030181879177689552, 0.0075011528097093105, -0.05395197868347168, -0.03318591043353081, -0.04565754532814026, 0.03712072968482971, -0.021396012976765633, 0.042223088443279266, -0.012230170890688896, -0.013334515504539013, -0.026756230741739273, 0.002598121529445052, 0.03799858316779137, 0.049374595284461975, 0.01484947931021452, -0.018787259235978127, 0.016606515273451805, 0.0063479277305305, -0.051477182656526566, 0.0022876278962939978, 0.028511647135019302, 0.004684630781412125, -0.059633418917655945, 0.04146318510174751, 0.04706219211220741, -0.013179965317249298, 0.03022843599319458, 0.03186910226941109, 0.007788232062011957, 0.013491388410329819, -0.07283374667167664, 0.018674606457352638, 0.041715916246175766, -0.03869100660085678, 0.006703165825456381, -0.0704055055975914, -0.010672750882804394, 0.026810165494680405, 0.09211818873882294, -0.038797080516815186, 0.05877267196774483, 0.025856919586658478, 0.041405774652957916, 0.02642139047384262, -0.01934058777987957, -0.03482981398701668, -0.0558520071208477, 0.0007391830440610647, -0.07142578065395355, -0.04763128235936165, 0.030467309057712555, 0.02918471209704876, -0.0027046159375458956, 0.03851651772856712, 0.04401249811053276, -0.0013492020079866052, -0.01003916934132576, -0.0024351344909518957, 0.004114500712603331, -0.02516627125442028, 0.041465312242507935, 0.0006372409989126027, 0.039183150976896286, 0.024254322052001953, -0.03864721208810806, 0.012637259438633919, -0.024181734770536423, 0.06318607926368713, 0.04489114508032799, -0.027261830866336823, -0.019903020933270454, -0.017600461840629578, 0.030191123485565186, 0.011906725354492664, -0.012452785857021809, -0.004789342638105154, -0.03156369552016258, 0.011303067207336426, -0.0038331497926265, 0.031705502420663834, 0.005663621239364147, 0.0031175692565739155, 0.009575629606842995, -0.03175439313054085, -0.030171457678079605, -0.06786458194255829, -0.016117973253130913, -0.005373693536967039, -0.010553119704127312, 0.06766059994697571, 0.0000593886106798891, -0.05172482505440712, 0.0056105852127075195, 0.003195070195943117, -0.05004869028925896, 0.037178944796323776, 0.037950269877910614, -0.013085977174341679, 0.036402683705091476, 0.04128582030534744, 0.03511129319667816, 0.028468942269682884, 0.0462147518992424, -0.03873082622885704, -0.06676971912384033, 0.04700282961130142, -0.02623298019170761, 0.03969988599419594, -0.012003566138446331, -0.039498768746852875, -0.013152722269296646, 0.033665526658296585, -0.015443148091435432, -0.0028430416714400053, -0.05866257846355438, 0.025298794731497765, 0.040800273418426514, 0.009916387498378754, 0.013516668230295181, 0.05351043492555618, 0.024110885336995125, 0.009667283855378628, -0.030194001272320747, -0.00024862936697900295, -0.059716567397117615, -0.04010816290974617, 0.024633802473545074, 0.06038423627614975, -0.004514457657933235, 0.0022496068850159645, 0.01763494312763214, 0.03572360426187515, 0.013428613543510437, 0.003662971779704094, -0.015448277816176414, -0.038044001907110214, 0.04082609713077545, -0.015245990827679634, -0.0035241926088929176, -0.006987989880144596, 0.03245936334133148, -0.016122151166200638, 0.05080180987715721, -0.04349261894822121, -0.017302410677075386, 0.03321127966046333, -0.011600918136537075, -0.004114164505153894, -0.03891079127788544, 0.015999987721443176, 0.03109557367861271, -0.010552103631198406, 0.027922585606575012, -0.01195885706692934, 0.005819589830935001, -0.010866355150938034, -0.039275798946619034, -0.02011146955192089, 0.0005066251615062356, 0.02348324842751026, -0.00889548659324646, -0.009703276678919792, 0.01720435544848442, -0.029987264424562454, -0.001795844524167478, -0.02727566473186016, 0.003513249335810542, 0.011945215985178947, 0.008330798707902431, 0.006368457339704037, -0.007420652080327272, 0.03226674720644951, -0.060520321130752563, -0.037673190236091614, 0.012136853300035, 0.021741574630141258, 0.02225390262901783, 0.024721480906009674, -0.03598781302571297, -0.02503829635679722, -0.028572693467140198, -0.0031839192379266024, 0.05651551112532616, -0.013566289097070694, -0.016748446971178055, 0.01661653444170952, -0.012189690954983234, -0.04795301333069801, -0.030186878517270088, -0.03668380156159401, 0.02685307338833809, -0.02033832110464573, -0.0017151932697743177, 0.03922111168503761, 0.03401552885770798, -0.03845546394586563, 0.014668638817965984, -0.026453038677573204, -0.0057632578536868095, 0.016630103811621666, -0.004110207315534353, -0.027855059131979942, -0.009447058662772179, 0.016176916658878326, 0.02547692321240902, -0.0338871143758297, -0.01698225922882557, -0.058178726583719254, -0.035038091242313385, 0.03091311827301979, 0.0009244795073755085, 0.05292185768485069, 0.011161594651639462, -0.03046325221657753, 0.08861527591943741, -0.030856583267450333, -0.03350234404206276, 0.0040568080730736256, 0.008250419050455093, -0.023104574531316757, -0.001993739977478981, 0.012632993049919605, 0.03288235142827034, 0.004215383902192116, 0.061853278428316116, -0.002476735971868038, 0.023822499439120293, 0.052345216274261475, -0.04314155876636505, -0.018711041659116745, 0.058926116675138474, 0.039886970072984695, -0.034724146127700806, 0.04671620950102806, 0.03061574697494507, 0.02802245505154133, 0.028275158256292343, 0.018774528056383133, -0.0022562032099813223, -0.016636943444609642, -0.011488169431686401, 0.02923242747783661, -0.011860182508826256, 0.018596062436699867, -0.031016500666737556, 0.05267892777919769, 0.0033437134698033333, -0.0623178705573082, 0.001117049716413021, 0.011357964016497135, 0.051552802324295044, -0.03821632266044617, 0.003159564221277833, 0.03701642528176308, 0.04293934628367424, -0.0024738144129514694, -0.036099474877119064, -0.009779563173651695, -0.028192846104502678, -0.006303632631897926, -0.03816879540681839, -0.04152573645114899, 0.0096023790538311, 0.02416284568607807, -0.025237813591957092, -0.006425029598176479, -0.02351965382695198, -0.01559900026768446, -0.02190481312572956, 0.005487085320055485, -0.02873324044048786, 0.030523905530571938, -0.03961014747619629, 0.05040293186903, -0.0537140928208828, -0.01791524700820446, -0.00030527342460118234, 0.034480899572372437, -0.03466450795531273, 0.00427718972787261, -0.0028648367151618004, -0.01942094974219799, 0.03263360261917114, -0.029200995340943336, 0.08461695164442062, -0.03410186991095543, -0.0006025058683007956, 0.005211525596678257, 0.02194278873503208, -0.03482300788164139, -0.005070212297141552, -0.043419066816568375, -0.04598451778292656, -0.038960400968790054, 0.023975510150194168, 0.015280370600521564, 0.024477533996105194, 0.027905866503715515, 0.028864268213510513, -0.030546901747584343, -0.013211340643465519, -0.0234407689422369, 0.010837637819349766, 0.016071120277047157, 0.03531121835112572, 0.03731017932295799, 0.04321420192718506, -0.006921996828168631, 0.002760369563475251, 0.024857154116034508, 0.055065106600522995, 0.07271535694599152, -0.028760788962244987, 0.03819780796766281, -0.05259361490607262, -0.004784357734024525, -0.01891925372183323, 0.04057200998067856, 0.02145419642329216, 0.014649841003119946, 0.05517284572124481, 0.006849464029073715, 0.01666032150387764, 0.015516444109380245, 0.0466654896736145, 0.008264364674687386, -0.02129991352558136, -0.013657189905643463, -0.002506247255951166, -0.027167940512299538, 0.013016055338084698, -0.0007980860536918044, -0.016197901219129562, -0.01003419328480959, 0.01670970395207405, -0.007674401625990868, 0.0037780203856527805, -0.05278267711400986, -0.00008467303268844262, 0.003856981173157692, 0.006368780508637428, -0.02745215594768524, -0.02881607599556446, 0.02583950012922287, 0.0314643532037735, 0.011241449974477291, -0.004275149665772915, -0.03322625160217285, -0.02014705166220665, -0.031070202589035034, 0.04759284108877182, 0.02259560488164425, 0.0018781368853524327, -0.03722785413265228, -0.030974537134170532, 0.0004762102907989174, 0.012419439852237701, -0.0017079662065953016, 0.02429957315325737, 0.030240001156926155, -0.0017967656021937728, -0.028622785583138466, -0.07319483906030655, -0.012794990092515945, 0.00008827720012050122, -0.04740190505981445, 0.026086220517754555, -0.049023550003767014, -0.0020049435552209616, -0.0416693277657032, -0.005123766139149666, -0.004417050164192915, 0.09255857765674591, -0.07024973630905151, -0.008322903886437416, 0.004815568216145039, 0.020675595849752426, 0.017794623970985413, -0.07326291501522064, 0.040441352874040604, -0.014292149804532528, 0.01033321674913168, 0.041866887360811234, -0.01298985444009304, -0.048695582896471024, 0.04461946710944176, -0.01749090850353241, -0.030430510640144348, 0.005654903128743172, 0.004545306321233511, 0.038496796041727066, 0.026726704090833664, -0.005197302438318729, 0.04979976266622543, 0.01604573428630829, -0.046531129628419876, -0.005057157017290592, -0.047759879380464554, 0.016054151579737663, -0.006101345177739859, 0.006480526644736528, -0.06104806065559387, -0.0011661434546113014, 0.01790216565132141, 0.0008466673316434026, 0.011597692035138607, 0.021927686408162117, -0.024832749739289284, -0.02735874056816101, -0.011769144795835018, 0.008065980859100819, -0.010992196388542652, 0.012696471065282822, 0.022415485233068466, 0.028322329744696617, 0.029038039967417717, -0.003060951828956604, -0.007792935706675053, -0.04289953410625458, 0.028787093237042427, 0.02648191526532173, -0.04184151068329811, 0.0009494104888290167, -0.05271768569946289, -0.025873245671391487, 0.018948232755064964, -0.04654281586408615, 0.047206681221723557, 0.046864788979291916, 0.0353730246424675, -0.009164629504084587, -0.052870724350214005, -0.017839089035987854, -0.028748197481036186, -0.04755452275276184, 0.006632145494222641, -0.025826986879110336, -0.004137285985052586, -0.03483129292726517, 0.014519339427351952, -0.03965304046869278, 0.016229793429374695, -0.0004954087780788541, -0.008847512304782867, -0.04620644450187683, -0.018283849582076073, 0.023789841681718826, -0.016929183155298233, -0.04617583006620407, 0.021304888650774956, 0.08596423268318176, -0.008506162092089653, -0.006815506611019373, -0.008046423085033894, 0.02484002336859703, 0.042357221245765686, 0.006310544908046722, 0.002038043923676014, 0.009251493029296398, -0.028286771848797798, 0.03518228605389595, -0.0009092415566556156, 0.021657750010490417, -0.023610500618815422, -0.001910011051222682, -0.0020449054427444935, -0.011282555758953094, 0.04292222112417221, -0.0226154625415802, -0.005038023926317692, 0.0018451532814651728, 0.00754640344530344, -0.005797345191240311, 0.0025141523219645023, -0.046536896377801895, 0.009949092753231525, 0.0376749150454998, 0.0031670485623180866, 0.011459100060164928, -0.00005208880247664638, -0.03131620213389397, 0.009759213775396347, -0.005776483565568924, -0.049531158059835434, 0.015922341495752335, 0.05986133962869644, 0.042904481291770935, -0.0023821061477065086, -0.010310903191566467, -0.04589903727173805, 0.04582598805427551, 0.011136088520288467, 0.04744919762015343, 0.01538030430674553, -0.0022436107974499464, -0.016527222469449043, -0.03168706223368645, -0.09018925577402115, 0.03964019566774368, 0.05196250230073929, 0.03435363993048668, 0.0460984893143177, 0.0010981131345033646, 0.010285924188792706, -0.019799785688519478, -0.0664389356970787, -0.008514508605003357, 0.0014244893100112677, -0.008053233847022057, 0.029127126559615135, -0.03492659702897072, -0.029183926060795784, 0.04605989530682564, -0.02706066705286503, -0.025152936577796936, 0.011832999996840954, 0.020692944526672363, 0.035826776176691055, -0.012568293139338493, -0.03718602657318115, -0.033263757824897766, 0.061441920697689056, -0.07636027038097382, 0.0049009122885763645, 0.01295703649520874, -0.039121873676776886, 0.018813660368323326, 0.08565748482942581, -0.010366027243435383, -0.05962805449962616, -0.010158006101846695, -0.03025318868458271, 0.016398226842284203, 0.02198334038257599, 0.03207363560795784, 0.04143069311976433, -0.014121669344604015, -0.003097020322456956, 0.005268946290016174, 0.0442173033952713, 0.011703095398843288, -0.08140057325363159, -0.0213620588183403, 0.0010133582400158048, -0.048165854066610336, -0.0011738953180611134, 0.04255145415663719, -0.026665005832910538, 0.020987974479794502, -0.0016618948429822922, 0.05622074007987976, 0.01850300095975399, 0.04503185674548149, -0.05240451171994209, 0.047585293650627136, 0.01259843073785305, 0.00383164850063622, -0.011854050680994987, -0.0059426878578960896, 0.1267247349023819, 0.06612338870763779, 0.03949079290032387, -0.06609431654214859, 0.02661789394915104, -0.027781512588262558, -0.003115331521257758, -0.029710033908486366, -0.005539167206734419, 0.0485357828438282, -0.009710649959743023, -0.04701419547200203, -0.0008750511333346367, 0.020866217091679573, -0.014420070685446262, 0.04050781950354576, -0.028873443603515625, -0.021307863295078278, 0.03846041113138199, -0.00782566238194704, -0.03220444545149803, -0.00426400825381279, 0.004430320113897324, -0.03390750288963318, 0.011173645034432411, -0.0008473157067783177, -0.012268171645700932, 0.0042870002798736095, 0.00796604249626398, -0.0153525210916996, 0.012061656452715397, -0.005248252302408218, -0.017907775938510895, 0.003213977674022317, 0.021398426964879036, 0.021355437114834785, 0.0161591749638319, -0.03686276450753212, 0.0012613149592652917, 0.02485867217183113, -0.011323456652462482, 0.011669293977320194, 0.039612188935279846, -0.015256502665579319, -0.04136643558740616, -0.05914127826690674, -0.0482281893491745, 0.05386858433485031, -0.03486209362745285, -0.015590299852192402, 0.024503342807292938, -0.006422822829335928, -0.0006593950092792511, -0.01568751409649849, 0.024234162643551826, -0.002612695563584566, 0.01232554018497467, -0.01875581033527851, -0.04218075051903725, -0.039774466305971146, 0.03367345407605171, -0.032818421721458435, 0.02700146660208702, -0.020567571744322777, -0.05763962119817734, -0.01164543628692627, 0.017821386456489563, 0.02784563973546028, 0.02131178230047226, 0.03937147185206413, -0.008506921119987965, -0.0067810132168233395, -0.04711281135678291, -0.0563906729221344, 0.016966283321380615, 0.0015287253772839904, 0.056444041430950165, -0.002484756987541914, 0.011961409822106361, -0.031341250985860825, -0.07753248512744904, -0.004044038243591785, -0.04632830619812012, 0.008575985208153725, -0.021997621282935143, -0.008627907373011112, 0.04020916670560837, 0.038682203739881516, -0.0008499232353642583, 0.034724898636341095, -0.01401479821652174, 0.056407779455184937, 0.02018587291240692, -0.04366956278681755, -0.03409435972571373, 0.005638561677187681, -0.0443115159869194, 0.007258643861860037, 0.009201855398714542, 0.04336695745587349, 0.005939406808465719, 0.06830661743879318, -0.026765789836645126, 0.03770257160067558, 0.006971929222345352, -0.006954653188586235, 0.0062680612318217754, -0.030153406783938408, 0.004485935438424349, 0.042019471526145935, 0.018369952216744423, -0.028221765533089638, -0.03184313699603081, 0.01637939177453518, 0.0013322933809831738, 0.033205222338438034, -0.04010137915611267, -0.07427261024713516, -0.017696036025881767, -0.011661507189273834, 0.005930203944444656, 0.0062460387125611305, -0.0015406409511342645, -0.0011099008843302727, 0.014333260245621204, -0.005481240339577198, 0.00927629042416811, -0.024721570312976837, 0.0029915105551481247, -0.02114691212773323, -0.021501662209630013, 0.021984577178955078, -0.008608452044427395, 0.00683523528277874, -0.0063656908459961414, 0.042777422815561295, 0.03253623843193054, 0.03067595139145851, -0.022180335596203804, -0.03954499959945679, 0.008312086574733257, -0.029024027287960052, -0.018735691905021667, 0.0027228209655731916, 0.001420601736754179, 0.04543691501021385, 0.03243387117981911, -0.00914718583226204, -0.007662343792617321, 0.04940877482295036, -0.013113892637193203, 0.03192581236362457, -0.025686034932732582, 0.0009604975930415094, 0.013389063067734241, -0.00036008397000841796, -0.01658868044614792, 0.0033690272830426693, 0.004706178791821003, -0.0033532849047333, 0.025747885927557945, -0.012448865920305252, -0.026762476190924644, 0.028251128271222115, -0.002936631441116333, 0.01720130816102028, -0.018164722248911858, -0.009089861996471882, -0.009608923457562923, 0.0071654412895441055, 0.009368062019348145, 0.029788846150040627, -0.020718663930892944, 0.015654856339097023, -0.07404599338769913, -0.014366759918630123, 0.007416701875627041, 0.004808902274817228, 0.060238540172576904, -0.012509321793913841, -0.008322594687342644, -0.0033676910679787397, -0.04075295850634575, -0.00019449550018180162, 0.020105017349123955, 0.017183534801006317, -0.003212712472304702, -0.00517099816352129, 0.0006002223817631602, 0.03412080556154251, 0.020848793908953667, 0.016628559678792953, 0.0016609051963314414, 0.029177773743867874, -0.017767956480383873, -0.031882185488939285, -0.0218348391354084, 0.024915480986237526, 0.003715697443112731, -0.03396955877542496, 0.023317581042647362, -0.04496099054813385, -0.0514737069606781, 0.03202264755964279, 0.008641412481665611, 0.007747620344161987, -0.007620880845934153, 0.019625363871455193, 0.009947891347110271, 0.030998580157756805, 0.02223038487136364, -0.02711308002471924, 0.028684260323643684, -0.008749914355576038, -0.0017486426513642073, 0.018311306834220886, -0.029378755018115044, 0.005132663995027542, -0.014978590421378613, -0.01602395810186863, -0.04799869656562805, 0.0006029317737556994, -0.003347305813804269, -0.02349161170423031, 0.01409280113875866, -0.021837834268808365, -0.001693515107035637, 0.016858911141753197, 0.000980823184363544, -0.051599886268377304, 0.011361849494278431, 0.027272479608654976, 0.04220037907361984, 0.01927516609430313, 0.02383323945105076, -0.006739859003573656, -0.031261879950761795, 0.010449224151670933, 0.01864553615450859, -0.029059235006570816, -0.07573970407247543, -0.002981077181175351, -0.0054088071919977665, 0.0027825941797345877, -0.028411326929926872, -0.03953493759036064, -0.025941526517271996, 0.02106357179582119, 0.008679637685418129, 0.032043080776929855, -0.012562919408082962, -0.0185697004199028, -0.0019991216249763966, -0.07965811342000961, 0.0732632726430893, 0.01889287307858467, 0.015489998273551464, -0.05676642805337906, -0.014954671263694763, -0.009626148268580437, -0.008386656641960144, 0.036025069653987885, -0.00218776473775506, 0.006190154701471329, -0.010775679722428322, 0.0692911371588707, 0.01715659350156784, -0.02566666342318058, 0.0394602045416832, -0.012708514928817749, 0.036656517535448074, -0.015458616428077221, 0.017638757824897766, 0.007360881194472313, 0.03072264976799488, -0.01755256950855255, -0.01729213260114193, 0.005447259172797203, 0.018769031390547752, -0.01694312132894993, 0.02892487496137619, 0.007153867743909359, 0.018653245642781258, 0.04840881749987602, -0.00704092625528574, 0.02675367146730423, -0.03130406141281128, 0.0036619233433157206, -0.022547388449311256, 0.028876356780529022, -0.015098929405212402, -0.036675699055194855, 0.020802311599254608, 0.0034450606908649206, 0.026083460077643394, -0.054904766380786896, 0.011137503199279308, 0.04679393768310547, 0.00939987413585186, -0.028783896937966347, 0.04263210669159889, -0.00018363152048550546, 0.0425165630877018, -0.008730506524443626, 0.0322788804769516, -0.008167924359440804, -0.007713098078966141, 0.00900354329496622, 0.005578947719186544, 0.008920567110180855, -0.0063834101893007755, 0.03873376175761223, 0.032709747552871704, -0.05247339606285095, 0.04495364427566528, 0.0031309446785598993, 0.03404545783996582, -0.054272957146167755, -0.024121958762407303, 0.014286884106695652, -0.027580715715885162, -0.026074647903442383, -0.006090240087360144, -0.002552390331402421, 0.09254096448421478, -0.01592608168721199, 0.001019874936901033, -0.04660484939813614, 0.014968659728765488, 0.01863454282283783, -0.008243378251791, -0.011141713708639145, 0.02511419542133808, -0.0043019759468734264, -0.002244941657409072, -0.0060213664546608925, -0.008693236857652664, 0.0369434617459774, -0.05790204554796219, 0.019170528277754784, 0.02486826293170452, 0.05364523082971573, -0.02072749473154545, 0.017763642594218254, -0.018633609637618065, -0.003662626026198268, 0.042159829288721085, 0.047150325030088425, 0.018375331535935402, -0.015453475527465343, 0.007357179187238216, 0.013691124506294727, 0.03972749039530754, -0.03879480063915253, 0.009511066600680351, -0.03658949211239815, 0.013996780849993229, -0.005329468287527561, -0.03421394154429436 ]
<p>I am a little new to neural network. I have two questions: 1. Can we use neural network in the small $n$ large $p$ situation? 2. Any regularization methods designed for parameter elimination? (Shrink some $\omega$ to 0). For example to add $L_1$ regularizer as Lasso? I know some methods for avoiding over-fitting, (weight decay, early stopping, ect.) but none of them shrink parameters to 0. </p>
73,624
[ 0.0008478345698677003, -0.015152583830058575, -0.04418868571519852, -0.02391095645725727, 0.009757831692695618, -0.014616109430789948, -0.04929371178150177, -0.0394093282520771, 0.024849211797118187, -0.07288241386413574, 0.01777275651693344, 0.013234822079539299, 0.03409280627965927, -0.015157251618802547, -0.00858735479414463, 0.010772484354674816, -0.03892626240849495, -0.00534915691241622, 0.000604164379183203, -0.00028522932552732527, 0.03400063514709473, 0.040947578847408295, 0.017189249396324158, -0.010253945365548134, -0.024165447801351547, 0.038017235696315765, -0.012617174535989761, 0.021427150815725327, -0.006388020236045122, 0.05986212193965912, -0.022688623517751694, -0.006762790493667126, 0.010751839727163315, 0.03251097723841667, -0.019268928095698357, 0.026600347831845284, -0.030087437480688095, -0.03947702422738075, 0.005821193102747202, 0.01604137383401394, -0.00003441719672991894, -0.031131474301218987, 0.016000857576727867, 0.010546337813138962, -0.006835067644715309, 0.016208339482545853, 0.010197754018008709, -0.042127810418605804, 0.00209847092628479, -0.04984201118350029, 0.04587900638580322, 0.0036684053484350443, 0.015337865799665451, 0.030413173139095306, 0.0058830855414271355, -0.004024259280413389, 0.05622480437159538, 0.08177844434976578, 0.001154559082351625, -0.06725192815065384, -0.02270505204796791, -0.010576663538813591, 0.04321683570742607, -0.03379267081618309, -0.03905971348285675, 0.037749309092760086, -0.005836384370923042, -0.016345465555787086, -0.019016144797205925, -0.015404473058879375, 0.0035336611326783895, -0.0061085643246769905, 0.025716915726661682, 0.03664495423436165, 0.004308932926505804, 0.027069678530097008, -0.00010368586663389578, 0.002949824556708336, 0.05426318570971489, 0.016397910192608833, 0.0028938292525708675, 0.02705802395939827, 0.024576565250754356, 0.01432003267109394, 0.009310273453593254, 0.00864771194756031, 0.06148746237158775, -0.026845883578062057, 0.037407953292131424, 0.0006913536344654858, -0.03160637617111206, 0.01637827418744564, 0.05034376308321953, -0.026649661362171173, -0.021014781668782234, 0.03229348734021187, 0.021154187619686127, 0.05031909421086311, 0.037168458104133606, -0.007857723161578178, 0.0021214892622083426, -0.040143970400094986, -0.028107039630413055, 0.05236765369772911, -0.023373998701572418, -0.0042638350278139114, -0.006942092441022396, 0.0010404748609289527, -0.018758639693260193, -0.007297678384929895, -0.04564889892935753, 0.02426592819392681, -0.03545437380671501, -0.023046912625432014, 0.05052170902490616, -0.021969420835375786, -0.01219247281551361, -0.054242733865976334, 0.01872936822474003, 0.11758412420749664, 0.004694985691457987, -0.004977211821824312, 0.05896799638867378, -0.026913564652204514, -0.0580645352602005, -0.02223554626107216, 0.050386086106300354, -0.01194219570606947, -0.03763450309634209, 0.04566517472267151, -0.008796467445790768, -0.04660056158900261, 0.03430121764540672, -0.004230459686368704, 0.06691636890172958, 0.024016374722123146, -0.06623078882694244, -0.035543475300073624, 0.020766232162714005, -0.05836379900574684, 0.007979539223015308, -0.05315961688756943, 0.008214577101171017, 0.027525946497917175, 0.06260490417480469, 0.02152683027088642, 0.011776639148592949, 0.028234733268618584, 0.029444390907883644, -0.0044762310571968555, -0.029995078220963478, -0.007043634541332722, -0.012080909684300423, 0.02489153854548931, -0.022199727594852448, -0.08291267603635788, 0.057888999581336975, 0.024859141558408737, -0.0104390112683177, -0.006995249539613724, 0.06682542711496353, -0.017428280785679817, 0.01676243171095848, -0.022091228514909744, -0.006351409014314413, -0.013716132380068302, 0.07450379431247711, 0.017146553844213486, 0.01970287412405014, 0.009383409284055233, -0.013018150813877583, 0.005802356172353029, 0.036562446504831314, 0.023322610184550285, 0.045294590294361115, -0.0021332751493901014, -0.04091912508010864, -0.02374126948416233, 0.044209014624357224, 0.03296332061290741, -0.036428388208150864, -0.004468219354748726, 0.008797936141490936, -0.004197537433356047, -0.008387759327888489, 0.04905778914690018, 0.010430697351694107, -0.03746499866247177, 0.0048052542842924595, -0.015393770299851894, -0.013233894482254982, -0.02480284869670868, 0.014535670168697834, 0.01160402037203312, 0.02353549934923649, 0.03378292918205261, 0.027215059846639633, -0.012225421145558357, -0.006641721818596125, -0.01375837717205286, -0.017485717311501503, 0.036060880869627, -0.0009797947714105248, -0.004938809666782618, 0.0004492721927817911, 0.03883367404341698, -0.01471217256039381, -0.039039552211761475, 0.06756430119276047, -0.028677985072135925, -0.0440686009824276, 0.02090998739004135, 0.008035706356167793, 0.0015495306579396129, -0.00643717497587204, -0.028530104085803032, 0.011774225160479546, -0.012912389822304249, -0.01720772683620453, 0.021459829062223434, -0.07162953913211823, 0.08064635097980499, 0.05264051631093025, 0.022424759343266487, 0.030841613188385963, 0.005191293079406023, 0.02621161937713623, 0.00014497135998681188, -0.020450929179787636, 0.010263602249324322, -0.05251157283782959, -0.03676280006766319, 0.033720921725034714, 0.03893526270985603, -0.05311477556824684, 0.0464218333363533, 0.06251890957355499, 0.03473370149731636, 0.03786138817667961, -0.00657512154430151, -0.014042539522051811, -0.017897959798574448, 0.0031750209163874388, 0.017726199701428413, 0.005493505857884884, -0.0013237843522801995, -0.0050795613788068295, -0.006877023261040449, 0.0288250669836998, 0.0067976005375385284, -0.014840315096080303, 0.028644617646932602, 0.019298311322927475, -0.031677763909101486, -0.015183674171566963, -0.018563374876976013, 0.008893958292901516, -0.011757120490074158, 0.02561255171895027, -0.018810341134667397, 0.019827187061309814, 0.016040287911891937, -0.01730150356888771, -0.03468328341841698, 0.034353725612163544, 0.0163256973028183, -0.020700233057141304, 0.02652698941528797, 0.03438062593340874, -0.06693095713853836, 0.024347228929400444, -0.031036414206027985, -0.0004835337749682367, -0.059878043830394745, 0.03246729448437691, 0.046469397842884064, -0.01615649275481701, 0.02729264833033085, -0.021877476945519447, -0.02176283672451973, 0.02787587232887745, -0.023850442841649055, 0.03959759324789047, 0.02463902160525322, -0.05802028626203537, 0.011427661404013634, -0.03940792754292488, 0.003941317088901997, 0.02261042408645153, -0.003102820599451661, 0.02936440147459507, 0.004100389778614044, -0.04042869061231613, -0.06611312180757523, -0.051777184009552, -0.06014198064804077, 0.021487394347786903, -0.003743887646123767, -0.029416915029287338, 0.048229947686195374, 0.02425988018512726, -0.013803289271891117, 0.008611025288701057, -0.013417961075901985, -0.00520568061619997, -0.04537896066904068, -0.010704861022531986, -0.02110588736832142, 0.02735988236963749, -0.01813161000609398, 0.044647421687841415, -0.03442820906639099, 0.023599844425916672, -0.05390230938792229, -0.05276893079280853, 0.023377487435936928, -0.007837477140128613, -0.003675946732982993, 0.005244492087513208, -0.0027597821317613125, 0.09638801217079163, 0.016753457486629486, -0.04281723126769066, -0.03192742168903351, 0.025879524648189545, -0.036983150988817215, -0.06216886267066002, 0.008338137529790401, -0.00009079768642550334, 0.03179623931646347, 0.020284567028284073, -0.022525068372488022, 0.014893581159412861, 0.0413384884595871, 0.008123784326016903, 0.013249942101538181, 0.041432637721300125, -0.0029525405261665583, 0.00890626385807991, 0.008703346364200115, 0.024442875757813454, -0.002750371815636754, 0.04127891734242439, -0.014417698606848717, 0.0179726704955101, -0.02596431039273739, -0.0054910737089812756, 0.006900070700794458, -0.004852862097322941, -0.011463752016425133, -0.017527131363749504, 0.01166650652885437, 0.0075540621764957905, -0.001050202758051455, -0.01812167279422283, 0.03099118173122406, 0.06569773703813553, -0.01785283349454403, 0.02216448076069355, 0.024482684209942818, 0.007451043464243412, -0.02961915172636509, -0.004435217939317226, 0.00221554609015584, -0.030955426394939423, 0.023695144802331924, -0.01527674775570631, 0.0193496011197567, 0.02830078825354576, 0.033296093344688416, 0.030026301741600037, 0.00365955731831491, -0.03492783382534981, 0.02768781967461109, -0.03817752003669739, 0.002167472383007407, -0.010881093330681324, 0.08573849499225616, -0.0046923281624913216, 0.03540017083287239, 0.010359511710703373, -0.006399356760084629, 0.012944776564836502, 0.026335150003433228, -0.09328798204660416, 0.015223640948534012, -0.023809226229786873, -0.036462727934122086, 0.013281739316880703, 0.002293193945661187, 0.047161344438791275, -0.02041369490325451, 0.030870618298649788, -0.02256191335618496, 0.024412674829363823, -0.038460418581962585, 0.0020131270866841078, -0.04123356565833092, 0.004932256881147623, -0.01398562639951706, 0.01667347550392151, 0.012480874545872211, -0.005205473862588406, -0.020139653235673904, 0.057216253131628036, -0.01250629685819149, -0.013917336240410805, -0.019712837412953377, 0.019991841167211533, 0.008367727510631084, 0.04810290038585663, 0.05965418368577957, 0.05307670310139656, -0.04018501937389374, 0.0032182512804865837, 0.022117963060736656, 0.07096059620380402, 0.04648255929350853, 0.031938400119543076, 0.010549345053732395, -0.06730394065380096, -0.03828870505094528, 0.0005294159636832774, 0.05632689222693443, 0.00970729161053896, -0.005329265259206295, 0.04314010590314865, 0.005636880174279213, -0.06241769716143608, -0.00861865933984518, 0.06672220677137375, -0.01073042768985033, -0.010181521996855736, -0.026267122477293015, 0.0007517203921452165, 0.00839656125754118, 0.04062267020344734, 0.022093655541539192, -0.008645264431834221, -0.02400398626923561, -0.007019365206360817, 0.028073662891983986, -0.03028285875916481, -0.008210732601583004, -0.0447632297873497, 0.06277266144752502, 0.04697504639625549, -0.020009979605674744, -0.013573984615504742, -0.0011406404664739966, 0.04507559537887573, 0.0593610480427742, 0.009495572187006474, 0.030466793105006218, -0.060348037630319595, 0.002480653114616871, 0.021452419459819794, 0.05461413413286209, -0.01855812594294548, -0.02559022419154644, -0.047669876366853714, -0.04380602762103081, 0.05163392797112465, 0.012451614253222942, 0.008428772911429405, 0.008059997111558914, -0.012584760785102844, -0.003948901314288378, -0.01996888779103756, -0.02860271744430065, 0.00799480825662613, -0.03559602051973343, 0.02300005406141281, -0.047714728862047195, -0.029274120926856995, -0.02215523086488247, 0.015192782506346703, -0.009037170559167862, 0.08190008252859116, -0.012517920695245266, 0.002528001321479678, 0.0028025552164763212, 0.035356827080249786, 0.004562322981655598, -0.07134360820055008, -0.01272044237703085, 0.004354782868176699, -0.05844015255570412, 0.045165836811065674, 0.02746109664440155, -0.06552032381296158, 0.04534013196825981, 0.0026985902804881334, -0.04190145432949066, -0.007508011069148779, -0.03712562844157219, 0.0441412553191185, 0.028541607782244682, 0.002925524953752756, 0.0698750913143158, 0.00315057672560215, 0.0018799301469698548, 0.023735683411359787, -0.0369148850440979, 0.007729078643023968, -0.02238091081380844, 0.001865495927631855, -0.023736121132969856, -0.016859738156199455, 0.012520636431872845, 0.043753013014793396, 0.02479984425008297, 0.04122514650225639, -0.012379735708236694, -0.011182407848536968, -0.0011238597799092531, 0.03888075053691864, 0.02773607335984707, -0.03591400384902954, 0.04100817069411278, 0.01881377212703228, 0.035790689289569855, -0.025613754987716675, -0.02378244698047638, -0.006978231016546488, 0.045930586755275726, 0.032218631356954575, -0.022773340344429016, 0.0029776759911328554, -0.02822965756058693, -0.03245783597230911, 0.04004247486591339, -0.010476162657141685, 0.05572517588734627, 0.03218614682555199, 0.017091412097215652, -0.013990410603582859, -0.044840242713689804, -0.0021274297032505274, -0.012924076989293098, -0.03162413462996483, 0.006876763887703419, -0.08232282847166061, 0.01743323728442192, 0.0029867077246308327, -0.016097746789455414, -0.05590697005391121, -0.0297634769231081, 0.0480378083884716, -0.00584312854334712, -0.029152585193514824, -0.03687318414449692, -0.016985325142741203, -0.0181317999958992, -0.03044865094125271, -0.01812567748129368, 0.05335133895277977, -0.02960626408457756, 0.01885630562901497, 0.0026848819106817245, 0.0040800911374390125, 0.06885768473148346, 0.013065000995993614, -0.014911497011780739, -0.0070317331701517105, -0.0254854504019022, 0.00012771009642165154, 0.006735394708812237, 0.03743739426136017, -0.0205596424639225, 0.002367613138630986, -0.03909739851951599, -0.01758616417646408, 0.043842919170856476, -0.00842809397727251, 0.002085372107103467, 0.045463960617780685, -0.008313501253724098, -0.011739499866962433, -0.002974170260131359, -0.003657964989542961, -0.0018569101812317967, 0.021779870614409447, -0.0024307523854076862, 0.013174907304346561, 0.00918758288025856, -0.053901124745607376, 0.016883118078112602, 0.010340547189116478, -0.016080321744084358, -0.004641700070351362, 0.059201449155807495, 0.0018976913997903466, -0.012210015207529068, -0.01738657057285309, -0.02098153904080391, 0.06704343855381012, 0.006570152472704649, 0.010997583158314228, -0.0073343007825315, 0.03511388227343559, -0.06804724782705307, -0.06678717583417892, -0.04808143898844719, -0.0077980393543839455, 0.02898830734193325, 0.012024989351630211, 0.050425443798303604, 0.007565728854387999, 0.01681198552250862, -0.014684446156024933, -0.019993407651782036, 0.008064638823270798, 0.009908128529787064, -0.02453518845140934, 0.043052371591329575, 0.020937975496053696, 0.005259339697659016, 0.00904859323054552, 0.007708035409450531, 0.013589311391115189, 0.02812303975224495, -0.030250025913119316, 0.018436932936310768, 0.004717248026281595, -0.04762016981840134, -0.0369948148727417, 0.021647023037075996, -0.04852377623319626, 0.022991865873336792, -0.0032783537171781063, -0.03204118087887764, 0.06206119433045387, 0.02712891437113285, 0.049834515899419785, -0.03681418299674988, -0.05614849552512169, -0.045123372226953506, 0.014477609656751156, 0.03753635287284851, -0.008607227355241776, 0.036479610949754715, -0.01493952888995409, -0.0036952344235032797, 0.019557688385248184, 0.04007852077484131, -0.0006888107163831592, -0.07192448526620865, -0.06500647962093353, -0.026787491515278816, -0.034565411508083344, 0.02576327882707119, 0.029140228405594826, -0.03665810078382492, 0.0421721413731575, -0.02161550149321556, 0.04601138457655907, 0.024066483601927757, 0.0314154252409935, -0.01690387912094593, 0.04341032728552818, 0.00727633573114872, 0.018963240087032318, 0.0033966496121138334, 0.007778622210025787, 0.12203953415155411, 0.10873466730117798, 0.0027943351306021214, -0.0666230097413063, -0.0063278465531766415, -0.04023751616477966, -0.010333657264709473, -0.035964250564575195, 0.02188851498067379, 0.0006317677907645702, 0.002595284953713417, 0.0010834434069693089, 0.03302506357431412, -0.00892274733632803, -0.015978479757905006, 0.04576718062162399, -0.03156323358416557, -0.03763963282108307, 0.01972946524620056, 0.007002894300967455, 0.004609641153365374, -0.009540281258523464, -0.028273846954107285, 0.013889237307012081, -0.01202054601162672, -0.023504357784986496, -0.019236987456679344, -0.018589451909065247, 0.03925245627760887, -0.04231267794966698, -0.014877558685839176, -0.02309555374085903, -0.012303108349442482, 0.02535463497042656, 0.010096046142280102, 0.028273554518818855, -0.011126055382192135, -0.014582358300685883, -0.0005246892105787992, 0.023954514414072037, 0.02894325740635395, -0.007873727940022945, 0.008370609022676945, -0.022111397236585617, -0.03519958257675171, -0.03897776082158089, -0.021377846598625183, 0.055735040456056595, -0.015065062791109085, 0.03597569838166237, 0.03379712253808975, 0.017454585060477257, 0.03114018402993679, -0.025354143232107162, -0.018730567768216133, 0.05177854001522064, -0.00022610981250181794, -0.02530599758028984, 0.004021822940558195, -0.0027290056459605694, 0.0076173897832632065, 0.01606232486665249, 0.009615595452487469, 0.024701308459043503, -0.02151651307940483, 0.005500756204128265, -0.005720909684896469, 0.018399670720100403, 0.003949024248868227, 0.03286149352788925, -0.020893407985568047, -0.0007042823708616197, -0.01602746918797493, -0.022372346371412277, 0.05143464356660843, 0.007182709872722626, 0.002417805837467313, -0.02513253502547741, -0.013323920778930187, -0.020703546702861786, -0.05826078727841377, 0.01180094201117754, -0.037030477076768875, -0.01918814331293106, -0.04575293883681297, -0.03771330043673515, 0.017380710691213608, 0.03912040591239929, 0.007436336018145084, -0.014273076318204403, -0.014775912277400494, 0.05241623893380165, 0.04317615553736687, -0.060833536088466644, -0.03716049715876579, -0.03950556740164757, -0.03733828663825989, 0.03541451320052147, 0.006124839186668396, 0.05751481279730797, -0.0015125885838642716, -0.00023846380645409226, -0.009761611931025982, 0.023935576900839806, -0.016288630664348602, -0.004612535238265991, 0.010120093822479248, -0.07778184860944748, 0.03578058257699013, -0.011599874123930931, 0.026077507063746452, -0.03685150295495987, -0.020130297169089317, -0.02750508300960064, -0.006439360789954662, 0.004367724061012268, 0.015370259992778301, -0.04964363947510719, 0.014317724853754044, 0.0000024964720068965107, 0.009240863844752312, -0.027439134195446968, 0.013097216375172138, -0.013267670758068562, 0.011177510023117065, -0.03228059783577919, -0.06741735339164734, -0.007587043568491936, 0.021756837144494057, -0.010917610488831997, -0.04180637374520302, 0.0014724524226039648, -0.0027904952876269817, -0.0031369575299322605, -0.018500443547964096, 0.010039170272648335, 0.013796872459352016, 0.06543835997581482, -0.034569546580314636, -0.03488094359636307, 0.031206926330924034, -0.05437673255801201, -0.06658907979726791, 0.012475945986807346, -0.008868959732353687, 0.05000772327184677, 0.04169442504644394, -0.00949761364609003, -0.0509050190448761, 0.025726698338985443, -0.025775553658604622, -0.007782096043229103, -0.0007482203072868288, -0.006398411467671394, -0.027146847918629646, 0.004025386180728674, 0.013555635698139668, -0.021704725921154022, -0.0009810973424464464, -0.012889713980257511, 0.025577478110790253, 0.00792316161096096, -0.025407804176211357, 0.018274910748004913, -0.0028000299353152514, 0.04961911961436272, 0.006957318168133497, 0.018638063222169876, 0.00287860375829041, 0.04152834415435791, -0.02346254326403141, 0.026992516592144966, 0.011855890043079853, 0.021594714373350143, -0.1112913191318512, -0.028296666219830513, -0.01227963250130415, 0.012492970563471317, 0.05916926637291908, -0.06401271373033524, 0.02351679466664791, 0.011016069911420345, -0.07567425072193146, 0.030448712408542633, -0.03033716231584549, 0.015453164465725422, -0.003938000183552504, -0.026878781616687775, -0.0025807716883718967, 0.001238710363395512, 0.03150535747408867, 0.03904028981924057, 0.024133656173944473, -0.02002635784447193, 0.008145488798618317, 0.012388397008180618, -0.03240025416016579, 0.0369441919028759, 0.021101752296090126, -0.04996080696582794, 0.02039024420082569, -0.05540480464696884, -0.020697500556707382, 0.005465272814035416, -0.014267701655626297, 0.004663325846195221, 0.016669457778334618, 0.010363604873418808, -0.010424408130347729, 0.03340708464384079, 0.03604547679424286, 0.012519593350589275, 0.017291806638240814, -0.0036915980745106936, -0.01934943161904812, -0.008926980197429657, -0.0017273600678890944, 0.03253457695245743, 0.00992802157998085, -0.01783384196460247, -0.023790130391716957, -0.00769604928791523, 0.002098213881254196, -0.0030973628163337708, 0.020769692957401276, -0.015452305786311626, -0.018998997285962105, -0.02333480678498745, 0.020758993923664093, -0.014055313542485237, -0.008542155846953392, -0.008099796250462532, 0.053009334951639175, -0.007334831636399031, 0.015701742842793465, -0.0012042090529575944, -0.05912662670016289, 0.009587140753865242, -0.002072442788630724, -0.03480735793709755, -0.05813424289226532, 0.020729990676045418, 0.013603146187961102, 0.00014202826423570514, -0.03335285931825638, -0.043564241379499435, -0.03723091632127762, 0.039083149284124374, -0.031809259206056595, 0.03535791486501694, 0.014335094951093197, -0.057463135570287704, -0.011785232461988926, -0.08422250300645828, 0.03743273392319679, -0.029916860163211823, 0.01733586937189102, 0.0018773191841319203, 0.03425111621618271, -0.02635287679731846, -0.011155245825648308, 0.05101505294442177, -0.019814394414424896, 0.02235892415046692, -0.004855225328356028, -0.012485832907259464, 0.027078034356236458, -0.014994514174759388, 0.01224533375352621, -0.005621360614895821, -0.008010828867554665, -0.03939278423786163, -0.005829761736094952, 0.008854672312736511, 0.02496105432510376, 0.008921419270336628, 0.040272295475006104, -0.010827658697962761, 0.008187035098671913, -0.016341563314199448, 0.03944797441363335, -0.02425525337457657, 0.030253944918513298, 0.03212482109665871, 0.002997824689373374, 0.004137021955102682, 0.006685103755444288, 0.013795546256005764, -0.06722568720579147, 0.008929474279284477, -0.04558297246694565, -0.04229474812746048, -0.03142340108752251, 0.046042345464229584, 0.018441595137119293, -0.07329133152961731, -0.012332838959991932, 0.033175092190504074, -0.012903631664812565, -0.008303765207529068, 0.01976805366575718, -0.0009799603139981627, 0.010521076619625092, -0.03015119396150112, 0.016457179561257362, 0.025701278820633888, 0.041284069418907166, 0.008240903727710247, 0.021009718999266624, 0.016039011999964714, -0.04238741844892502, 0.07910134643316269, 0.01105425599962473, -0.023445971310138702, 0.03520495817065239, -0.0004964748513884842, 0.0585329607129097, -0.050434306263923645, -0.0300345029681921, 0.03238150104880333, -0.004748791456222534, 0.014243105426430702, -0.025546234101057053, -0.008844972588121891, 0.04973154515028, -0.01997334323823452, 0.00006928130460437387, -0.023421676829457283, -0.033685050904750824, -0.008427540771663189, 0.012943550944328308, -0.027602795511484146, 0.0271320678293705, 0.00006877152191009372, -0.0012283292599022388, -0.014381841756403446, 0.017341788858175278, 0.004598755389451981, -0.06893280148506165, -0.0026901240926235914, -0.008372925221920013, 0.006462814752012491, -0.018128830939531326, -0.02465824782848358, -0.013560845516622066, -0.01935761049389839, 0.010296618565917015, 0.03632691502571106, 0.062042541801929474, -0.029954854398965836, -0.0017188801430165768, 0.009762794710695744, 0.03614918142557144, -0.035115744918584824, 0.022686833515763283, 0.012713730335235596, -0.0033359334338456392, -0.010399124585092068, -0.009834657423198223 ]
<p>I have two columns of data, and would like to show their differences through the visualization approach. The current issue is that these two columns are in-fact very close to each other. In other words, I would like to zoom in the minor differences that are existed using a graphical way. Are there any suggestions? Thanks.</p> <p>Here is part of the data set. The third column is the difference between the first column and second column.</p> <pre><code>0.999998295 0.999998331 -3.56E-08 0.99999381 0.999986678 7.13E-06 0.999997682 0.999998494 -8.12E-07 0.999989429 0.999989062 3.67E-07 0.999998877 0.999998505 3.72E-07 0.999995327 0.999996709 -1.38E-06 0.999995779 0.999995146 6.33E-07 0.999997484 0.999996701 7.83E-07 0.999998829 0.999998076 7.53E-07 0.999997523 0.999998836 -1.31E-06 0.999998287 0.999996964 1.32E-06 0.999983543 0.999989135 -5.59E-06 0.999992705 0.999994249 -1.54E-06 0.999995663 0.999998168 -2.50E-06 0.999997263 0.999999195 -1.93E-06 0.999994474 0.999996713 -2.24E-06 0.999993058 0.999994063 -1.00E-06 0.999998295 0.999996262 2.03E-06 0.99999736 0.999998185 -8.25E-07 0.999983507 0.996875105 0.003108402 0.999996339 0.999996597 -2.58E-07 </code></pre>
36,029
[ -0.020968575030565262, 0.059006333351135254, -0.01666969433426857, 0.002231297781690955, -0.01247851550579071, 0.06072114035487175, -0.009040267206728458, -0.028401033952832222, -0.019790876656770706, -0.02562204748392105, 0.04891053959727287, 0.059021543711423874, 0.04442906379699707, 0.02636585384607315, 0.01168018952012062, -0.012713798321783543, -0.015059088356792927, 0.000710094056557864, -0.0019274377264082432, -0.053399428725242615, -0.0001760364102665335, -0.022103695198893547, 0.02797577530145645, -0.004746049176901579, -0.003450168762356043, 0.02204076200723648, 0.042249877005815506, -0.002678121440112591, -0.036455750465393066, 0.05230110138654709, -0.0011002820683643222, -0.0416080579161644, 0.026219449937343597, 0.02740572579205036, -0.006069154478609562, 0.016894999891519547, 0.004436969757080078, -0.01017141342163086, -0.04076983034610748, 0.04109713435173035, -0.004956020973622799, 0.0192481130361557, 0.0008445529383607209, 0.056331973522901535, 0.007005937397480011, -0.007265429012477398, 0.009886685758829117, 0.004138012882322073, 0.022199781611561775, -0.009882038459181786, 0.06642264127731323, -0.009103266522288322, 0.04151478409767151, -0.005283953156322241, -0.052266743034124374, 0.001961873611435294, 0.015831416472792625, 0.08738870918750763, 0.005209110677242279, -0.060867469757795334, 0.011149863712489605, -0.02001579850912094, 0.00033727858681231737, -0.017043864354491234, 0.0054948157630860806, 0.05255746841430664, -0.03641213849186897, -0.013712666928768158, 0.022732967510819435, -0.056332334876060486, -0.008478829637169838, 0.04857020452618599, 0.049749381840229034, -0.036533646285533905, 0.021825125440955162, -0.03687006235122681, 0.0019979760982096195, 0.0031601886730641127, 0.04246237501502037, 0.043793532997369766, -0.010586357675492764, 0.013262318447232246, 0.01937139593064785, 0.017789119854569435, 0.032530318945646286, 0.009778972715139389, 0.05835707485675812, -0.05452838912606239, 0.011354047805070877, 0.0626738965511322, -0.02821025252342224, 0.022809946909546852, 0.03031838871538639, 0.01976091042160988, -0.00354293012060225, 0.031649116426706314, 0.01061938051134348, -0.0008771272259764373, -0.025308024138212204, -0.034942351281642914, -0.016539523378014565, -0.03072812594473362, 0.012364083901047707, -0.0019820183515548706, 0.011759121902287006, -0.01074086781591177, 0.0009673201711848378, 0.009559153579175472, -0.026254253461956978, -0.020165393128991127, 0.01959635689854622, 0.013960817828774452, 0.03778105229139328, 0.020524289458990097, 0.0075559127144515514, -0.042207591235637665, 0.00012113880802644417, -0.008158082142472267, 0.03340321406722069, 0.0662994459271431, 0.038564905524253845, -0.015868760645389557, -0.007374293636530638, -0.00773367565125227, -0.0592663437128067, 0.03382307291030884, 0.004140307195484638, -0.006776071153581142, -0.026593085378408432, 0.029669877141714096, -0.04469200596213341, -0.004550824407488108, 0.060541264712810516, -0.012210225686430931, 0.04091130942106247, 0.04201105982065201, -0.07681698352098465, -0.040614306926727295, 0.055779535323381424, -0.021151993423700333, 0.00019724231970030814, -0.02239273674786091, 0.005146608222275972, 0.013705341145396233, 0.02512379363179207, 0.06484132260084152, -0.01391871739178896, -0.008645422756671906, 0.020442798733711243, 0.04187512770295143, -0.007241168059408665, 0.03422354534268379, -0.018945060670375824, -0.025824636220932007, 0.023585032671689987, -0.03981870040297508, -0.021906841546297073, 0.040876634418964386, -0.056811701506376266, 0.003432429628446698, 0.03350711241364479, 0.010855321772396564, -0.00001546317434986122, -0.032893095165491104, -0.050648290663957596, -0.02336696721613407, 0.05724530294537544, -0.0025586106348782778, 0.009985299780964851, 0.022836022078990936, -0.03564556688070297, 0.042259640991687775, -0.04377952590584755, 0.010491959750652313, 0.06585459411144257, -0.004353399854153395, 0.005031197797507048, -0.029353486374020576, -0.00037255219649523497, 0.0593336783349514, -0.03571606054902077, -0.023795345798134804, -0.0306247491389513, -0.02084091678261757, 0.029902469366788864, 0.040361978113651276, 0.004811435006558895, -0.05708114057779312, 0.07257039844989777, -0.08904536813497543, -0.02870846912264824, -0.07019112259149551, 0.015297678299248219, 0.008957304060459137, -0.03613920882344246, 0.029137110337615013, 0.005002640653401613, -0.00961796659976244, 0.021319638937711716, -0.021346477791666985, -0.00915231741964817, 0.019321909174323082, 0.02032601460814476, -0.04008611664175987, -0.003524688770994544, 0.043363381177186966, 0.07200493663549423, 0.0028344234451651573, 0.030224157497286797, -0.008082816377282143, 0.014614547602832317, 0.021237514913082123, -0.03831452131271362, 0.012177582830190659, 0.012463225983083248, 0.01311450731009245, -0.00578813161700964, 0.0460270531475544, -0.029208051040768623, -0.005898061208426952, -0.045519325882196426, 0.01759190671145916, 0.05782632529735565, 0.0044343057088553905, -0.022090626880526543, -0.04740032181143761, -0.00017616145487409085, 0.06116554141044617, 0.015719695016741753, -0.01300122495740652, -0.015665842220187187, 0.023572713136672974, 0.029471468180418015, 0.04730448126792908, -0.05342703312635422, -0.013604430481791496, 0.05065204203128815, -0.012424404732882977, 0.025703202933073044, 0.04303208366036415, -0.029796265065670013, -0.03477102518081665, -0.011004311963915825, -0.016210120171308517, 0.00045902925194241107, -0.012984134256839752, 0.04260736331343651, 0.033543672412633896, 0.03751145303249359, -0.030718518421053886, 0.007554116193205118, -0.011531265452504158, -0.01686614565551281, -0.008068135008215904, -0.012556063011288643, 0.01490449532866478, 0.05720240995287895, 0.014883077703416348, -0.028109876438975334, 0.03424254059791565, -0.028489328920841217, 0.003604461904615164, 0.012279143556952477, -0.019284427165985107, -0.00008987270120996982, 0.06781266629695892, -0.04037304222583771, 0.012496800161898136, -0.0031591588631272316, -0.05124243348836899, 0.04088461399078369, -0.06560547649860382, -0.013303210958838463, -0.07125397026538849, 0.025309141725301743, 0.07027921080589294, 0.022298242896795273, 0.004855640698224306, -0.014006480574607849, -0.04010976478457451, 0.023057937622070312, 0.01290091685950756, 0.038645189255476, 0.010062625631690025, -0.0031224892009049654, 0.016819721087813377, -0.01388615183532238, -0.0029421676881611347, 0.03128485754132271, 0.023273084312677383, -0.012766990810632706, -0.006244772579520941, 0.03285594657063484, -0.022467708215117455, -0.003816879354417324, -0.029363181442022324, 0.01593727618455887, -0.020038099959492683, 0.019208421930670738, 0.04035492241382599, -0.014586039818823338, -0.03613503649830818, 0.005540597252547741, -0.02189953252673149, 0.009409883059561253, -0.02521037869155407, 0.004026889801025391, -0.0012287143617868423, 0.013473697938024998, -0.033559344708919525, 0.004704560153186321, -0.00962663535028696, 0.001980446046218276, -0.04690942168235779, -0.025106314569711685, -0.013165159150958061, 0.020910024642944336, 0.04074268788099289, -0.023303575813770294, -0.040201544761657715, 0.036112330853939056, 0.015871362760663033, -0.03095538169145584, -0.0810069665312767, 0.02603609301149845, -0.07594774663448334, 0.014540456235408783, -0.02166854962706566, 0.014925578609108925, 0.03925479203462601, -0.005344208795577288, -0.010601231828331947, 0.05377718806266785, 0.0643921047449112, 0.0028592669405043125, 0.02080901525914669, 0.02050977572798729, -0.029165351763367653, -0.0011862971587106586, 0.009301502257585526, -0.008378859609365463, -0.04451493173837662, 0.03281974792480469, -0.00885877013206482, 0.01797030307352543, 0.01365713682025671, -0.027613047510385513, 0.013799634762108326, 0.03240703418850899, 0.012807002291083336, -0.02019827626645565, -0.01307675801217556, 0.012909287586808205, 0.0011125733144581318, 0.0099188182502985, 0.034068621695041656, 0.0431295707821846, -0.019133981317281723, -0.01711183227598667, 0.08713049441576004, 0.056757085025310516, -0.011396440677344799, 0.03581276908516884, -0.0039420779794454575, 0.009627383202314377, 0.02160164900124073, -0.08655950427055359, -0.06921371072530746, 0.025806687772274017, 0.02479780651628971, 0.016332175582647324, 0.026448804885149002, -0.03628204017877579, -0.0029512220062315464, -0.017269082367420197, -0.029331356287002563, -0.011692559346556664, 0.04764574393630028, 0.0004781745665241033, 0.054031744599342346, 0.015544254332780838, -0.005288011394441128, -0.014286786317825317, -0.03397127613425255, -0.056506864726543427, 0.03874881565570831, -0.0064642406068742275, -0.00829110387712717, -0.006004077382385731, 0.016871172934770584, -0.006800756324082613, -0.03984147310256958, 0.015209376811981201, 0.004449021071195602, 0.010201322846114635, -0.0401577427983284, 0.0191110298037529, 0.017050782218575478, 0.018289314582943916, -0.05023316293954849, 0.029629092663526535, 0.03950710594654083, -0.006364497356116772, 0.03838195279240608, 0.009827528148889542, -0.03328491374850273, 0.007022177800536156, -0.0021281999070197344, 0.008416305296123028, 0.010298875160515308, 0.04736161604523659, 0.006557107903063297, 0.023600278422236443, -0.03266139701008797, -0.014873201958835125, 0.00607606815174222, 0.03126160055398941, 0.04109843075275421, -0.03306702896952629, -0.01377745158970356, -0.011849209666252136, -0.011809928342700005, -0.04747660085558891, 0.04999031499028206, -0.006750354077666998, 0.04798787087202072, -0.0016003168420866132, 0.014809466898441315, -0.03595561906695366, 0.006063585169613361, 0.060945115983486176, 0.03963979706168175, -0.03958837315440178, -0.05335870757699013, -0.02675475738942623, -0.013188260607421398, -0.0012358485255390406, 0.013407047837972641, 0.03229493275284767, 0.03502815589308739, 0.006281078327447176, 0.0035390553530305624, 0.007087701931595802, -0.028858544304966927, -0.009944215416908264, 0.020933616906404495, -0.0044820550829172134, 0.01926136203110218, 0.023080209270119667, 0.0396275594830513, 0.002801791299134493, 0.033361148089170456, -0.01452162116765976, 0.00801780354231596, -0.10469023138284683, -0.008728137239813805, 0.030960533767938614, 0.022447926923632622, 0.005011053755879402, -0.02856403775513172, -0.04260183870792389, -0.015021898783743382, 0.0615866482257843, -0.04944387078285217, 0.045561738312244415, -0.02198019251227379, 0.0298443790525198, -0.06793578714132309, -0.008121680468320847, -0.030240479856729507, 0.01839378848671913, -0.029352299869060516, -0.007406236603856087, -0.041246507316827774, -0.03830920159816742, -0.015754833817481995, 0.011663343757390976, -0.022904396057128906, 0.051503680646419525, -0.0034858251456171274, -0.02498629502952099, 0.016350895166397095, -0.02270563505589962, -0.019329022616147995, -0.017198633402585983, 0.04322915896773338, 0.02735588140785694, -0.009810445830225945, 0.03728673234581947, -0.03196614980697632, -0.0025312635116279125, 0.016920549795031548, 0.0035668588243424892, 0.014312668703496456, 0.02429896593093872, -0.005915365181863308, 0.071079321205616, 0.06503623723983765, -0.03396060690283775, 0.02085447497665882, 0.020312612876296043, 0.0015665715327486396, 0.02265104278922081, -0.057787034660577774, 0.02005390077829361, 0.0006798504618927836, -0.029501808807253838, -0.035404764115810394, 0.020206527784466743, -0.012175051495432854, 0.02396416664123535, -0.041340067982673645, 0.0587848499417305, -0.017106693238019943, 0.0033774429466575384, 0.022103821858763695, 0.048474736511707306, -0.030654137954115868, -0.0027987549547106028, 0.02722540870308876, -0.013988015241920948, -0.015372027643024921, -0.007987868040800095, 0.02071499451994896, -0.022609775885939598, -0.021503904834389687, 0.022197717800736427, -0.06923949718475342, -0.03467407450079918, -0.014826962724328041, 0.014058967120945454, -0.002504761330783367, -0.027442358434200287, -0.02248186431825161, -0.005669365171343088, 0.025319073349237442, 0.04565785825252533, -0.022242547944188118, -0.008095383644104004, 0.05553651228547096, -0.0007147789001464844, 0.015392656438052654, -0.019457129761576653, 0.02994750626385212, 0.007359556388109922, -0.01559014618396759, -0.06230010837316513, -0.00493707787245512, 0.02370525151491165, 0.014227883890271187, -0.07007116079330444, -0.044200871139764786, -0.0755409374833107, 0.027431311085820198, 0.00811487715691328, -0.03483731672167778, 0.015152102336287498, -0.025009294971823692, 0.00978135783225298, -0.023946627974510193, -0.009799455292522907, 0.08572722971439362, -0.020981861278414726, 0.02452624775469303, 0.019956395030021667, -0.006854028906673193, -0.020867835730314255, 0.04509567841887474, -0.007440142799168825, -0.029168685898184776, -0.017003197222948074, -0.021963395178318024, 0.006691626738756895, 0.021440301090478897, -0.023811975494027138, -0.017399193719029427, -0.010583797469735146, 0.00007527528214268386, 0.05060615390539169, -0.02027249149978161, -0.008015059866011143, -0.045905373990535736, 0.006029867101460695, -0.053482696413993835, 0.005825463216751814, 0.014339977875351906, -0.0035509613808244467, 0.028116371482610703, 0.02380802109837532, -0.059787288308143616, -0.004765370860695839, 0.041286468505859375, -0.03133619949221611, -0.00197868375107646, 0.028222067281603813, -0.012419837526977062, 0.01640859618782997, -0.014628356322646141, 0.02990628033876419, 0.005547008942812681, 0.05237208679318428, -0.03688220679759979, -0.025016825646162033, -0.036937400698661804, -0.035213906317949295, 0.06604861468076706, 0.00968522671610117, 0.04197613522410393, 0.04463981091976166, -0.01874593086540699, -0.03751693293452263, -0.03240285441279411, -0.045240771025419235, -0.015504539012908936, -0.002222450915724039, 0.02159816399216652, -0.015160712413489819, -0.0011913481866940856, 0.01045280322432518, 0.03553856164216995, 0.004570166580379009, 0.05260690674185753, -0.037097979336977005, -0.014915755949914455, 0.00508227339014411, -0.011448521167039871, -0.014686721377074718, 0.02654286101460457, -0.024594688788056374, 0.04588876664638519, -0.0038310550153255463, -0.030473586171865463, 0.014054437167942524, 0.01543152704834938, -0.02132435515522957, -0.03078850731253624, -0.03749547898769379, -0.07722499966621399, 0.008915770798921585, 0.013612053357064724, -0.02587372623383999, 0.008596351370215416, 0.0053586820140480995, 0.0338597372174263, -0.03190888836979866, 0.02758537046611309, -0.05302131921052933, -0.022332102060317993, -0.003574459347873926, -0.025218050926923752, 0.0019313499797135592, 0.055906858295202255, -0.002001855755224824, -0.056801553815603256, 0.011518255807459354, -0.008311495184898376, -0.006721047218888998, 0.011003986932337284, -0.01647624932229519, 0.021080223843455315, 0.05597284063696861, -0.007640506606549025, 0.017724983394145966, 0.02046353369951248, -0.031985387206077576, 0.14202538132667542, 0.033601365983486176, 0.007729699369519949, -0.02085656113922596, 0.038010373711586, 0.029214678332209587, -0.027585960924625397, -0.006026912946254015, 0.007436787709593773, 0.02726690098643303, -0.011938335373997688, 0.03324688971042633, 0.05765581503510475, 0.03826044872403145, 0.017957469448447227, 0.04544523358345032, 0.01045288611203432, 0.005310766398906708, -0.028024954721331596, 0.026232313364744186, -0.010941166430711746, 0.014312640763819218, -0.08329694718122482, -0.020543813705444336, 0.00455835834145546, 0.023860590532422066, -0.05625354126095772, -0.008882975205779076, 0.026487797498703003, 0.02386748045682907, -0.06553230434656143, 0.023403743281960487, 0.0049325767904520035, 0.0048292106948792934, 0.0030955348629504442, -0.009604686871170998, 0.02909918501973152, -0.013110712170600891, 0.004317028447985649, 0.009613542817533016, 0.0064694080501794815, -0.0028529094997793436, -0.03770880773663521, 0.014391325414180756, -0.033074989914894104, -0.026897266507148743, -0.04071326553821564, 0.03296167030930519, 0.021196085959672928, -0.021088777109980583, 0.012346047908067703, 0.005373712629079819, -0.012466252781450748, -0.033075425773859024, -0.012412992306053638, -0.007697572931647301, -0.0005496630910784006, 0.035296473652124405, 0.006153095979243517, 0.03386061266064644, 0.043933723121881485, -0.01412170473486185, -0.009383129887282848, 0.013573485426604748, -0.015250438824295998, -0.027799557894468307, -0.010373243130743504, 0.05184528976678848, -0.014716139063239098, 0.005429601296782494, -0.018988044932484627, -0.007581023965030909, 0.022490233182907104, -0.013316569849848747, -0.0175862368196249, 0.011427834630012512, 0.021491752937436104, 0.04145309701561928, -0.018688345327973366, -0.016821937635540962, 0.006786757614463568, 0.04598909243941307, -0.00633684266358614, -0.010634345933794975, -0.032373033463954926, 0.002706976141780615, 0.06992238014936447, 0.030109725892543793, 0.0283624567091465, -0.007397477049380541, -0.027631273493170738, 0.08334890753030777, 0.006169441156089306, -0.06614619493484497, -0.01584763266146183, 0.009437350556254387, -0.002457771450281143, -0.002761680632829666, -0.03852417320013046, 0.037836551666259766, 0.02013443596661091, -0.021724747493863106, 0.020302871242165565, 0.023002078756690025, -0.02202734164893627, -0.019580161198973656, -0.004726308397948742, -0.006003246642649174, -0.005746189970523119, 0.016434689983725548, -0.05470478907227516, -0.01913617178797722, 0.04531211033463478, -0.04854578152298927, -0.053490154445171356, -0.03142565116286278, 0.015060384757816792, -0.00209646113216877, 0.006959494203329086, 0.01788005232810974, -0.005081943701952696, -0.017092257738113403, -0.05092740058898926, -0.03647845983505249, -0.024015959352254868, -0.061704155057668686, 0.00010996355558745563, 0.009068956598639488, -0.013197964988648891, -0.00012527935905382037, 0.028147561475634575, 0.008562403731048107, 0.027424994856119156, 0.0352867916226387, 0.015771755948662758, 0.010208786465227604, -0.00868081022053957, 0.021167077124118805, 0.0035198030527681112, -0.016673818230628967, 0.014559177681803703, -0.026904311031103134, -0.09311895072460175, 0.03818642720580101, -0.02511206455528736, 0.039498068392276764, -0.008401702158153057, 0.011884333565831184, -0.025705760344862938, 0.07285132259130478, 0.014840124174952507, -0.021125884726643562, -0.01466202549636364, 0.0007603780250065029, -0.01695462316274643, -0.027468018233776093, -0.0054658567532896996, -0.048108555376529694, 0.0013594190822914243, 0.03232336789369583, 0.046818990260362625, -0.0047001768834888935, -0.02199891209602356, -0.018794409930706024, -0.0013482412323355675, 0.01684330590069294, 0.004054639488458633, -0.024796564131975174, 0.10208795219659805, -0.0058721150271594524, -0.01901148445904255, 0.010437439195811749, 0.012009317055344582, 0.0021408405154943466, -0.07635369151830673, -0.024158522486686707, 0.011281541548669338, 0.006947631016373634, 0.06367529183626175, -0.04600038379430771, 0.017554497346282005, 0.022356484085321426, -0.05291019380092621, 0.0030248069670051336, -0.01366354338824749, 0.013437764719128609, 0.022934312000870705, 0.01131339929997921, -0.01679052598774433, 0.03398663178086281, 0.03219114989042282, 0.06569816172122955, 0.0673120841383934, 0.026816047728061676, -0.011152834631502628, -0.0254200492054224, -0.030960654839873314, 0.023315105587244034, 0.02468254417181015, -0.03589849919080734, 0.01425935234874487, -0.023605020716786385, -0.007962475530803204, 0.003949083387851715, -0.024612825363874435, 0.010361076332628727, 0.0020940788090229034, 0.00010920307249762118, 0.032269611954689026, 0.06046118214726448, 0.02727567031979561, 0.011385479010641575, -0.05562577769160271, -0.027484897524118423, 0.009021200239658356, 0.008777241222560406, -0.028209414333105087, 0.04820866882801056, 0.04331217706203461, 0.0032854904420673847, -0.009286075830459595, 0.014047998934984207, 0.009012527763843536, -0.021456222981214523, -0.043924860656261444, 0.003948420751839876, 0.034470085054636, -0.03562561795115471, -0.013749961741268635, -0.02304656431078911, -0.0031946811359375715, 0.018881728872656822, 0.029362570494413376, -0.021549290046095848, 0.037884414196014404, -0.018074143677949905, -0.06580471247434616, -0.027480870485305786, 0.01743216998875141, 0.03755528852343559, -0.055504318326711655, -0.02079271897673607, 0.004440536722540855, -0.022177595645189285, 0.005727552808821201, -0.007427857723087072, -0.026105904951691628, 0.040618181228637695, -0.03194168582558632, -0.017786238342523575, 0.023843254894018173, 0.024549968540668488, 0.008848072960972786, -0.0978066623210907, -0.013338472694158554, 0.0031992816366255283, -0.03307008370757103, 0.005651841871440411, 0.007984130643308163, -0.04213837906718254, 0.09414784610271454, 0.06343605369329453, 0.032929930835962296, -0.01579151675105095, -0.017097093164920807, 0.016048546880483627, 0.025967953726649284, -0.07984599471092224, 0.020157840102910995, -0.006356849335134029, -0.025349799543619156, 0.03862164542078972, -0.01649518869817257, -0.021861841902136803, 0.01639951579272747, 0.0074254232458770275, 0.03432229533791542, -0.01215388160198927, 0.02262509986758232, -0.04633280634880066, 0.022150525823235512, 0.00336839840747416, -0.0910763368010521, -0.006111836992204189, -0.0018951939418911934, -0.023510541766881943, 0.01718403398990631, 0.017192749306559563, -0.019291147589683533, 0.009986309334635735, -0.03858747333288193, -0.027382101863622665, 0.020858582109212875, -0.037384483963251114, 0.030806489288806915, -0.07586702704429626, 0.011015625670552254, 0.00831225048750639, -0.01894969679415226, 0.004890542011708021, 0.024556389078497887, 0.030336622148752213, 0.011555826291441917, -0.006701930426061153, 0.01606215164065361, -0.024465767666697502, -0.007127281744033098, 0.041404206305742264, -0.04579060897231102, 0.005825551692396402, -0.007004525512456894, -0.004120766185224056, -0.004365031141787767, -0.039877455681562424, 0.010899900458753109, -0.017681408673524857, 0.014365780167281628, 0.012011132203042507, -0.018324684351682663, 0.03648025542497635, -0.022314872592687607, -0.011436328291893005, 0.007961869239807129, 0.011404666118323803, 0.023942284286022186, -0.04778219014406204, 0.01938733644783497, -0.017492741346359253, 0.023314006626605988, -0.011487915180623531, 0.01002869475632906, -0.006027031224220991, 0.004150477237999439, -0.010582683607935905, 0.02777811512351036, 0.02003359980881214, -0.004126644693315029, -0.013524430803954601, 0.00334386364556849, 0.02180456928908825, -0.009697762317955494, -0.006611323915421963, 0.011604842729866505, 0.002820192603394389, -0.052235715091228485, -0.018236897885799408, 0.04658512398600578, 0.022624623030424118, 0.002244750503450632, -0.009995370171964169, -0.04417775198817253, 0.008569928817451, 0.016696015372872353, -0.05434468761086464, -0.0642680898308754, 0.005474938545376062, 0.010387366637587547, 0.011548558250069618, -0.03663906455039978 ]
<p>How can I fit a copula for a bivariate vector of negative binomial and Bernoulli margins?</p> <p>I would prefer a Frank or Clayton copula.</p>
39,251
[ -0.017964908853173256, -0.027434511110186577, -0.029177654534578323, 0.01053928304463625, 0.04300687089562416, 0.010729863308370113, 0.008030802011489868, 0.00894777849316597, 0.03901484236121178, -0.05086797848343849, 0.04238437861204147, 0.06325492262840271, 0.03302236646413803, 0.008967475034296513, 0.050329141318798065, -0.008871873840689659, -0.015217887237668037, -0.009156673215329647, -0.01334454771131277, 0.002458495320752263, 0.05562436953186989, 0.011465289629995823, 0.0644773468375206, 0.025168217718601227, 0.004232005216181278, -0.004973225295543671, 0.04900737479329109, -0.01627558097243309, 0.008214088156819344, 0.07747765630483627, -0.05716726556420326, -0.06519690155982971, 0.029712766408920288, 0.061219293624162674, 0.00006613109144382179, 0.0031974895391613245, -0.017554879188537598, -0.017325468361377716, -0.008872161619365215, 0.034309271723032, -0.021895308047533035, -0.02034759521484375, 0.01275698933750391, 0.028020741418004036, 0.017854824662208557, 0.006755166221410036, 0.00592286279425025, -0.054642584174871445, 0.0345735028386116, -0.07817332446575165, 0.04897202178835869, 0.008041709661483765, 0.046816326677799225, 0.04814302176237106, -0.027944475412368774, -0.014606906101107597, 0.07393129914999008, 0.08283837139606476, 0.013640950433909893, -0.07377693802118301, 0.004667841363698244, -0.037717580795288086, 0.03556758910417557, -0.015718596056103706, -0.028702588751912117, 0.043457575142383575, 0.007798288948833942, -0.03402317315340042, -0.0021256394684314728, -0.018114956095814705, 0.018340066075325012, 0.02847423031926155, 0.05172152817249298, -0.03648141026496887, 0.03921521455049515, -0.02690301090478897, 0.022029414772987366, 0.03801965340971947, 0.0305788554251194, 0.01335611566901207, 0.013835722580552101, 0.017695581540465355, 0.017781730741262436, 0.00955581571906805, -0.00746511435136199, -0.02318730019032955, 0.07435443997383118, -0.013462099246680737, 0.012546829879283905, 0.020450662821531296, -0.024176815524697304, 0.0013854566495865583, 0.04586145654320717, -0.01252615638077259, -0.030702635645866394, 0.03735615313053131, -0.02999643050134182, 0.007493921089917421, 0.0046187699772417545, -0.04188418388366699, -0.02185220457613468, -0.03721827641129494, -0.0021254639141261578, 0.06944891810417175, 0.01054298970848322, 0.013239708729088306, -0.02464698627591133, -0.000019774281099671498, -0.0034087705425918102, -0.03370213508605957, -0.031494539231061935, 0.046831462532281876, 0.011602372862398624, -0.010329969227313995, 0.01759299449622631, -0.01742686703801155, -0.01876043900847435, -0.020848413929343224, 0.02524145320057869, 0.05946147441864014, 0.02161606028676033, -0.0014378189807757735, 0.03290913626551628, -0.013387106359004974, -0.07285813242197037, 0.030708443373441696, 0.0059143416583538055, -0.003944546449929476, -0.05059380084276199, 0.013568973168730736, -0.007201937958598137, -0.03743032366037369, 0.01790359802544117, 0.005845046602189541, -0.0072473022155463696, -0.008597815409302711, -0.09650912135839462, -0.014863427728414536, 0.026859579607844353, -0.0298630241304636, -0.008374536409974098, -0.06827537715435028, 0.02223893627524376, 0.017590302973985672, 0.05766855180263519, 0.01652277261018753, 0.05710260570049286, 0.012174242176115513, 0.044029876589775085, 0.005137970671057701, 0.0007394428830593824, 0.022182350978255272, -0.0321548655629158, 0.009527704678475857, -0.04494001343846321, -0.05186579003930092, 0.010022670961916447, 0.004392941016703844, -0.023667089641094208, -0.017711326479911804, 0.05017520487308502, 0.032574888318777084, -0.02934105135500431, -0.043296992778778076, -0.00654047355055809, -0.041871894150972366, 0.052745696157217026, -0.013798415660858154, 0.012782405130565166, 0.03850585222244263, -0.012083386071026325, 0.009156680665910244, -0.005780033767223358, 0.020072484388947487, 0.05953075736761093, -0.025440992787480354, 0.004905118606984615, -0.012593114748597145, 0.034859031438827515, 0.03631420060992241, -0.0456550270318985, -0.005144401453435421, -0.03048757277429104, 0.01284297090023756, 0.022948132827878, 0.02565707638859749, -0.004536428023129702, 0.0004408956738188863, 0.03758327290415764, -0.047560449689626694, -0.04826666787266731, -0.04257291927933693, 0.005547268316149712, 0.013908165507018566, -0.01683403179049492, 0.06276615709066391, -0.005548643879592419, 0.015769582241773605, -0.00966690480709076, 0.011915656737983227, -0.038808673620224, 0.00408577173948288, 0.04990578070282936, -0.04019388183951378, 0.006009853444993496, 0.06624257564544678, 0.0827440395951271, -0.0067302631214261055, 0.05139927938580513, -0.01614837534725666, -0.05925847217440605, -0.01822424866259098, -0.0174623541533947, 0.023567473515868187, -0.006724672857671976, -0.017895540222525597, 0.007629404775798321, -0.002681592246517539, 0.025520535185933113, 0.004561781417578459, -0.05917705222964287, 0.023316817358136177, 0.09345715492963791, 0.01740184798836708, 0.013879201374948025, -0.010807763785123825, 0.0048017241060733795, 0.006676151417195797, -0.009227967821061611, -0.02532436139881611, -0.0420670285820961, 0.031204238533973694, 0.027234237641096115, 0.018953733146190643, -0.016580581665039062, -0.004683246370404959, 0.0512307845056057, -0.002394590061157942, -0.010661238804459572, -0.005752814933657646, 0.01681620068848133, -0.023781893774867058, -0.004321346525102854, -0.004658916499465704, 0.013111663050949574, 0.006893746554851532, 0.034558843821287155, -0.015332609415054321, 0.04553057998418808, -0.032206401228904724, -0.06160331517457962, 0.061927925795316696, 0.011832956224679947, -0.001158400671556592, -0.017919639125466347, -0.03850739821791649, 0.057352859526872635, -0.006755505688488483, 0.01494587492197752, 0.05386309698224068, 0.013637914322316647, 0.02119120955467224, 0.023885995149612427, -0.026026161387562752, 0.04051581025123596, 0.041426945477724075, -0.021833576261997223, -0.01104598119854927, 0.013324649073183537, -0.041994523257017136, 0.02270449511706829, -0.021802600473165512, -0.049451835453510284, -0.014476096257567406, -0.02271842770278454, 0.011122320778667927, 0.01445002295076847, 0.0015508966753259301, -0.018070673570036888, -0.04384554177522659, 0.021447043865919113, 0.007842261344194412, -0.006847684737294912, 0.0037705199792981148, -0.010404395870864391, -0.010584756731987, -0.02828132174909115, 0.008201954886317253, 0.017519215121865273, -0.009215548634529114, 0.007758076302707195, 0.023787224665284157, 0.0114499656483531, -0.014618807472288609, -0.015546487644314766, 0.003687935182824731, -0.031177382916212082, -0.05783875659108162, -0.05311824753880501, 0.05184903368353844, 0.01694464311003685, -0.06699632853269577, -0.012688820250332355, -0.012136613018810749, 0.0008480482501909137, -0.06118547171354294, -0.010367653332650661, 0.04316578805446625, 0.003048913087695837, 0.03243809565901756, 0.012926210649311543, -0.02879318594932556, -0.006396319717168808, -0.05512430891394615, -0.04472852870821953, 0.009611597284674644, -0.0009531747782602906, 0.0002872395853046328, 0.009688567370176315, -0.029739392921328545, 0.02691826783120632, 0.018416276201605797, 0.018232056871056557, -0.05756730958819389, 0.0007099913782440126, -0.029939725995063782, 0.002428379375487566, 0.03341751918196678, 0.010811170563101768, 0.013308342546224594, 0.04083199426531792, -0.0024270256981253624, 0.0030282435473054647, 0.02520841732621193, 0.034739911556243896, -0.023758796975016594, 0.017656074836850166, -0.008227167651057243, 0.0018113881815224886, 0.005173348821699619, -0.036109987646341324, 0.010110635310411453, 0.026602476835250854, 0.03926459327340126, 0.01029474101960659, 0.014035798609256744, -0.03358140587806702, -0.003173892153427005, -0.01790911890566349, -0.010853207670152187, -0.013970197178423405, 0.026809336617588997, 0.024500492960214615, -0.02476959489285946, 0.003251593792811036, -0.006863364949822426, 0.05342233180999756, -0.03538726270198822, 0.032531820237636566, 0.056740302592515945, 0.017683997750282288, -0.005499308463186026, -0.0012821173295378685, -0.023823445662856102, -0.005024268291890621, -0.006457782816141844, -0.03567623347043991, 0.0113978311419487, 0.01465546153485775, 0.056575022637844086, 0.036913592368364334, -0.028143830597400665, -0.02107161097228527, -0.017100492492318153, -0.065139539539814, 0.0209638848900795, -0.023470472544431686, 0.006808485370129347, -0.016871687024831772, 0.023127606138586998, -0.0016199651872739196, 0.01287283655256033, 0.017022056505084038, 0.022115744650363922, -0.04399598389863968, 0.018799401819705963, -0.02495904639363289, 0.019781315699219704, -0.032497767359018326, 0.0009789791656658053, 0.03202399984002113, -0.016769487410783768, -0.012559500522911549, -0.0347273088991642, 0.013998998329043388, -0.011919351294636726, -0.006700432859361172, -0.001692989026196301, -0.012906862422823906, 0.03589298576116562, -0.025613345205783844, 0.02842920646071434, 0.00040134714799933136, 0.0292129497975111, 0.05031644180417061, 0.024785494431853294, -0.014208474196493626, -0.0014162303414195776, 0.01949707418680191, 0.004171616397798061, 0.042420703917741776, 0.00009558552119415253, 0.06051505357027054, -0.0014839043142274022, 0.020703302696347237, -0.017305748537182808, 0.029197517782449722, 0.04702797532081604, 0.008843733929097652, -0.01720220036804676, -0.06596072763204575, -0.024779975414276123, -0.018123028799891472, -0.003923055715858936, 0.03472809121012688, 0.019075660035014153, 0.1220879778265953, 0.02160332165658474, -0.038701899349689484, 0.01577872410416603, 0.03598848357796669, 0.02843143604695797, 0.02271963469684124, -0.0016747218323871493, -0.008392120711505413, -0.009003021754324436, -0.008725615218281746, -0.00009523825428914279, 0.014613966457545757, -0.048941731452941895, 0.010132437571883202, 0.0623779296875, -0.039299290627241135, -0.025090288370847702, 0.013009908609092236, 0.024538759142160416, 0.032627835869789124, -0.009964167140424252, -0.03794584050774574, 0.008236958645284176, 0.038528405129909515, 0.02034572698175907, 0.03153053671121597, 0.015954384580254555, -0.10232590138912201, -0.010846049524843693, 0.031004993245005608, 0.03083985298871994, -0.009848160669207573, -0.03247601538896561, -0.027572959661483765, -0.015795966610312462, 0.009126861579716206, -0.020855695009231567, 0.003946028184145689, 0.010712648741900921, 0.03177506476640701, -0.0278822872787714, -0.058103810995817184, -0.039063528180122375, 0.02730257622897625, -0.013305576518177986, 0.02225048840045929, -0.016100045293569565, -0.017115755006670952, -0.04163750261068344, 0.03508370369672775, 0.043564312160015106, 0.08155465871095657, 0.012313056737184525, -0.01633622869849205, 0.0017428949940949678, 0.013751630671322346, -0.012200973927974701, -0.07051409035921097, 0.0009450361831113696, -0.001771424780599773, -0.010074133984744549, 0.042695578187704086, -0.005161412991583347, -0.027207612991333008, 0.0012487489730119705, -0.011780034750699997, -0.01290066447108984, 0.04099534824490547, -0.05297284200787544, 0.028371749445796013, 0.007041978184133768, 0.02611052431166172, 0.03597971424460411, 0.021122585982084274, -0.01890796422958374, -0.03828825429081917, -0.031325601041316986, 0.004631785675883293, -0.0034284223802387714, -0.015412873588502407, -0.02755177579820156, -0.00880957767367363, 0.002752746921032667, 0.01731172576546669, -0.028352877125144005, 0.005610478110611439, -0.05420776456594467, -0.020984861999750137, -0.018475763499736786, 0.01864161156117916, -0.008855681866407394, 0.00875480379909277, 0.019222527742385864, -0.0173334963619709, 0.022214042022824287, -0.045068662613630295, 0.013835428282618523, -0.0002863051777239889, 0.002749354112893343, 0.0018851285567507148, -0.056451693177223206, -0.007140908855944872, -0.050299111753702164, -0.017868993803858757, -0.001759217819198966, -0.027906324714422226, 0.045239418745040894, 0.0010692584328353405, 0.008396805264055729, -0.013302614912390709, -0.03349831700325012, -0.014897225424647331, 0.03774408996105194, -0.00908899400383234, 0.027036508545279503, -0.015804603695869446, 0.03186975419521332, -0.003217630321159959, -0.02555229142308235, -0.05994444712996483, -0.03063628077507019, 0.013885132037103176, 0.0005461998516693711, -0.016152221709489822, -0.0345848873257637, 0.024702904745936394, -0.021474426612257957, -0.029556335881352425, -0.042532067745923996, 0.06632868945598602, -0.05054415762424469, -0.007628274615854025, -0.017680861055850983, -0.044058866798877716, 0.06267493218183517, -0.029965737834572792, 0.0010757724521681666, 0.02923150546848774, -0.0323573499917984, -0.017496373504400253, 0.016050364822149277, -0.027084680274128914, -0.016095571219921112, 0.02633177489042282, 0.0018746814457699656, 0.009207560680806637, 0.030250363051891327, -0.03524501249194145, 0.0015278690261766315, -0.009927884675562382, 0.0008573965751565993, 0.009869268164038658, -0.018478751182556152, -0.0074668163433671, 0.020033417269587517, 0.021832451224327087, -0.03376629948616028, -0.037503473460674286, -0.00844970066100359, -0.01058927271515131, 0.020520731806755066, 0.022769419476389885, -0.017688943073153496, 0.0065253544598817825, 0.07496733963489532, -0.01655251532793045, -0.008283649571239948, -0.0002237473236164078, -0.003723911475390196, 0.03633332997560501, 0.0069363415241241455, -0.00817182194441557, 0.055672865360975266, 0.025760632008314133, -0.04212183132767677, -0.0469210259616375, -0.054178107529878616, 0.018536340445280075, 0.028508150950074196, 0.008016085252165794, 0.004402808379381895, 0.0302305705845356, -0.006993180140852928, 0.006389958318322897, -0.052693385630846024, 0.008476769551634789, -0.0066361622884869576, -0.0029904143884778023, 0.02937917970120907, -0.03031531348824501, 0.011347024701535702, 0.009929816238582134, 0.03028968721628189, -0.024576282128691673, 0.02844570018351078, -0.025169653818011284, 0.03066650591790676, 0.022493058815598488, 0.0031823914032429457, -0.019823666661977768, 0.062269341200590134, -0.05213021859526634, -0.018090534955263138, -0.036843348294496536, -0.06725392490625381, 0.04087227210402489, 0.020553087815642357, 0.027656175196170807, -0.016231119632720947, -0.01840563304722309, -0.037681419402360916, 0.018702561035752296, -0.02012033760547638, -0.019905736669898033, 0.08170942962169647, 0.016719883307814598, 0.052388835698366165, 0.024521050974726677, 0.03759421035647392, -0.01698855124413967, -0.06066063046455383, -0.014913619495928288, -0.007623974233865738, -0.03160367161035538, 0.001452241325750947, -0.0007094345637597144, 0.004725320264697075, 0.025943590328097343, -0.04549248889088631, -0.02119947038590908, -0.016955416649580002, 0.023515397682785988, 0.0030240449123084545, 0.048019811511039734, 0.011556404642760754, 0.005430581979453564, 0.007199578918516636, 0.007163232192397118, 0.13583099842071533, 0.09762171655893326, 0.011206308379769325, -0.11419376730918884, 0.018581736832857132, -0.024189816787838936, -0.01783834397792816, -0.016544487327337265, 0.02521587163209915, 0.003381179179996252, -0.05904006212949753, 0.058085743337869644, 0.032427381724119186, -0.008629858493804932, -0.014318171888589859, 0.04926188662648201, -0.04191288352012634, -0.021558456122875214, -0.018462974578142166, 0.0035171527415513992, -0.02059256099164486, -0.018943404778838158, -0.020573418587446213, -0.004454159643501043, 0.001737130805850029, -0.060534462332725525, -0.03162767365574837, -0.0215549748390913, 0.008014230988919735, 0.02028762362897396, 0.013125517405569553, -0.010741720907390118, 0.04487764462828636, 0.019964659586548805, -0.0055922409519553185, -0.01149437390267849, 0.007006532978266478, -0.014400641433894634, -0.003633511485531926, -0.013959591276943684, -0.03002312034368515, 0.003503914223983884, 0.035977553576231, -0.019037684425711632, -0.07087187469005585, -0.041018761694431305, -0.05983386188745499, 0.02849833481013775, 0.0015030299546197057, -0.0019676275551319122, -0.022352786734700203, -0.02026028372347355, 0.0439603365957737, -0.02554781548678875, -0.01712508127093315, 0.016981342807412148, 0.016669051721692085, -0.0349874347448349, -0.04219236969947815, -0.007683882489800453, 0.01810499280691147, 0.002376766875386238, 0.070755235850811, 0.004045065958052874, -0.03865136578679085, -0.010640691965818405, -0.011601576581597328, 0.08023711293935776, 0.004783520940691233, -0.017606588080525398, 0.025058118626475334, -0.02039814367890358, -0.05093131586909294, -0.012783394195139408, 0.02641003020107746, -0.028705283999443054, 0.027974875643849373, 0.025320596992969513, -0.0033788427244871855, 0.010620425455272198, -0.05285181850194931, 0.016892392188310623, -0.036895252764225006, -0.0015384196303784847, -0.03075362928211689, -0.01291851419955492, 0.03244117647409439, 0.04748857393860817, -0.002543644281104207, 0.027231408283114433, -0.03567183017730713, 0.07484810799360275, 0.0320492684841156, -0.03349873796105385, -0.015206693671643734, -0.03931659087538719, -0.0251174159348011, -0.03665635734796524, -0.04527986794710159, 0.050025638192892075, 0.0029312586411833763, 0.026035787537693977, 0.03127382695674896, -0.0037710322067141533, -0.04833809658885002, 0.026220403611660004, 0.0042119636200368404, -0.04464033618569374, 0.018381379544734955, 0.023318002000451088, 0.0034477729350328445, -0.023906836286187172, -0.011619298718869686, -0.030183857306838036, -0.021411892026662827, 0.03578013554215431, -0.006406636442989111, -0.040699247270822525, 0.021128937602043152, -0.009083681739866734, 0.006377419922500849, -0.011999417096376419, -0.02770324982702732, -0.02385258488357067, 0.0006881137378513813, -0.00950276292860508, 0.001343390322290361, 0.016238603740930557, -0.02470128983259201, -0.005030702333897352, -0.0012417011894285679, 0.05233938992023468, 0.04797959327697754, 0.04423471912741661, 0.0008551024366170168, 0.020964747294783592, 0.011663923040032387, 0.03465839847922325, -0.03824297711253166, -0.007855747826397419, 0.03696710243821144, -0.043075449764728546, -0.0163873378187418, 0.013973403722047806, 0.0234786719083786, 0.029134465381503105, -0.0023926396388560534, -0.008421136997640133, -0.029694905504584312, 0.04911461099982262, -0.021402793005108833, -0.01740340143442154, 0.00713226618245244, -0.0009763808338902891, -0.0005629847291857004, -0.0038383984938263893, 0.003181679407134652, 0.024824250489473343, -0.03616645559668541, 0.01840951479971409, 0.05472434312105179, 0.011073575355112553, 0.007532868068665266, 0.024308424443006516, 0.00029127162997610867, 0.023181725293397903, 0.029895232990384102, 0.0006956977886147797, 0.011954224668443203, 0.032610997557640076, -0.018385285511612892, 0.03290881961584091, -0.03285187855362892, 0.03816753998398781, -0.11051442474126816, -0.018802635371685028, 0.02350393682718277, 0.008004956878721714, 0.04966531693935394, -0.0509745255112648, -0.004240448586642742, 0.0016751306829974055, -0.010908400639891624, 0.014123986475169659, 0.020209303125739098, -0.005793585442006588, -0.03457093983888626, 0.019704794511198997, -0.023009205237030983, 0.031232327222824097, -0.00037094077561050653, 0.038679078221321106, 0.04567559435963631, 0.0258514154702425, -0.0604860782623291, -0.06785526126623154, -0.005532452836632729, -0.007126659620553255, -0.010757338255643845, -0.05677052587270737, 0.04103973135352135, 0.0010895526502281427, -0.05380828306078911, 0.03569270670413971, 0.023142756894230843, 0.0258179921656847, 0.015211212448775768, 0.040261588990688324, 0.021286074072122574, 0.053414344787597656, 0.06340586394071579, -0.0022677562665194273, 0.038775231689214706, -0.01565280184149742, 0.00009310003952123225, 0.004511062055826187, -0.042202431708574295, 0.04017174616456032, 0.04477126896381378, 0.012234831228852272, -0.021233385428786278, 0.034969452768564224, -0.014157227240502834, -0.034217074513435364, -0.016642119735479355, -0.0029633953236043453, 0.005692701321095228, -0.03028835728764534, 0.03950696811079979, -0.039443112909793854, -0.028483057394623756, 0.06820826232433319, 0.013778233900666237, -0.008800161071121693, 0.016241006553173065, -0.014066499657928944, -0.05403786525130272, 0.013296308927237988, -0.013488990254700184, -0.016362793743610382, -0.03826982527971268, -0.021016571670770645, 0.00016327570483554155, 0.03755934536457062, -0.03676822409033775, 0.0004665600135922432, -0.03396062180399895, 0.004537427797913551, -0.013292194344103336, 0.0086264843121171, 0.03504529222846031, 0.014600305818021297, 0.0038705470506101847, -0.06179659068584442, 0.02424771338701248, 0.00022758933482691646, -0.004573633894324303, -0.03276427090167999, -0.02993639186024666, -0.005794962402433157, -0.019539907574653625, 0.09130246192216873, -0.012104726396501064, -0.0072861830703914165, -0.02403962053358555, 0.04144837334752083, 0.02144194021821022, -0.0020506849978119135, 0.03335297480225563, -0.02528550662100315, -0.036462217569351196, 0.0032148673199117184, -0.02748972177505493, 0.01113330852240324, 0.006218937691301107, -0.005628557410091162, -0.012437769211828709, 0.02361193671822548, 0.00954864826053381, -0.04137128219008446, 0.040744848549366, 0.004847590811550617, -0.025499766692519188, 0.06237311661243439, 0.010903065092861652, 0.015843089669942856, -0.0008169157663360238, 0.0023551497142761946, -0.07612162083387375, 0.02735060080885887, -0.03889241814613342, -0.02620840072631836, -0.010133743286132812, 0.031284868717193604, -0.014880413189530373, -0.05636280030012131, 0.016794847324490547, 0.021675925701856613, -0.045464806258678436, 0.005534196272492409, 0.02860589697957039, -0.002843383001163602, 0.04260832071304321, -0.0021769709419459105, -0.004654550459235907, 0.042916521430015564, 0.030641358345746994, 0.03894220292568207, 0.02902049943804741, 0.052127692848443985, -0.03571106493473053, 0.0016499225748702884, 0.023429840803146362, -0.05008735507726669, 0.041067272424697876, 0.013732042163610458, 0.013972514308989048, -0.023581890389323235, -0.01867578737437725, 0.03286057710647583, -0.00622625183314085, 0.020062247291207314, 0.03160736709833145, -0.019043389707803726, 0.051629211753606796, -0.015226530842483044, 0.0015933560207486153, -0.03349657356739044, -0.004858456086367369, -0.011021899059414864, -0.008308649063110352, -0.017805056646466255, 0.02249028906226158, 0.004687882028520107, -0.005457201972603798, -0.00265908264555037, -0.0264356080442667, 0.01146682444959879, -0.03425796702504158, -0.0002557635016273707, -0.03251864016056061, 0.03590278699994087, -0.037963397800922394, -0.027518756687641144, -0.009564507752656937, -0.0034221792593598366, 0.0029290628153830767, 0.049347247928380966, 0.011676197871565819, 0.008704367093741894, -0.01687883585691452, -0.015962159261107445, 0.051755212247371674, -0.08727678656578064, -0.007587228436022997, -0.028708983212709427, -0.02078363299369812, -0.028166143223643303, 0.0050415643490850925 ]
<p>I have a HLM model with significant variance in the level 1 intercepts across groups but no significant variance in the level 1 slopes across groups and find significant cross-level moderation effects. Does it make sense to interpret these or are random slopes a necessary condition for probing cross-level interaction effects? </p>
73,625
[ -0.02594287320971489, 0.010341821238398552, -0.01905728690326214, -0.008820232935249805, 0.056325141340494156, 0.03167126327753067, -0.01529548317193985, -0.04554082453250885, 0.003870719810947776, -0.02183537371456623, -0.000031448042136617005, 0.018411314114928246, 0.06213247776031494, 0.008296068757772446, 0.029364023357629776, 0.02068939059972763, -0.0023469438310712576, 0.011289230547845364, 0.010099397972226143, 0.0043328688479959965, -0.03389215096831322, 0.01809208281338215, -0.02375461719930172, -0.03584512695670128, -0.055191703140735626, 0.04589887708425522, 0.014226309955120087, -0.006981833837926388, -0.004611776676028967, 0.03702334687113762, 0.017310889437794685, 0.017698004841804504, -0.013831407763063908, 0.018463214859366417, -0.008698091842234135, -0.01647903211414814, -0.02755027450621128, -0.02498267963528633, 0.011435329914093018, 0.05312227085232735, -0.014762778766453266, -0.023959554731845856, 0.011159698478877544, 0.04789905995130539, -0.021400779485702515, -0.005319764371961355, -0.03118846006691456, 0.02249746210873127, 0.07114666700363159, -0.03499123081564903, 0.04510708898305893, 0.03353520855307579, 0.038762181997299194, 0.03429289907217026, -0.026134002953767776, -0.0037772648502141237, 0.05751069635152817, 0.06357971578836441, 0.013336118310689926, -0.019809847697615623, -0.03252923861145973, -0.0235896036028862, 0.0010477597825229168, 0.009244787506759167, -0.036645881831645966, 0.01755707338452339, 0.01170381996780634, -0.00945450458675623, 0.04561571404337883, 0.007583771366626024, -0.029474571347236633, 0.0017352898139506578, 0.03877529129385948, 0.003429315984249115, 0.04481817036867142, -0.014295760542154312, 0.024138569831848145, 0.03564554080367088, 0.017715731635689735, 0.048294223845005035, -0.02051473595201969, -0.008069684728980064, 0.014133836142718792, 0.013432159088551998, -0.02545173279941082, 0.021579992026090622, 0.05191655829548836, -0.0046648988500237465, 0.03873614966869354, 0.028300456702709198, -0.020692944526672363, 0.04194101691246033, 0.027029290795326233, 0.026119818910956383, -0.07051073014736176, 0.0080099580809474, -0.013050456531345844, -0.004197591450065374, 0.0460297092795372, 0.0328860767185688, -0.01897609233856201, -0.03785230591893196, 0.018893586471676826, 0.026193760335445404, -0.0017020853701978922, -0.014778236858546734, -0.03099442459642887, 0.007853665389120579, -0.0282411091029644, -0.03580811247229576, 0.0017917744116857648, 0.006292182486504316, 0.005729720927774906, -0.038589537143707275, 0.05954030901193619, -0.00631693797186017, -0.013428711332380772, -0.026610849425196648, 0.09126315265893936, 0.05175621435046196, 0.05472666397690773, -0.015489349141716957, 0.015048803761601448, -0.016756681725382805, -0.0583837665617466, 0.029846331104636192, -0.0010190964676439762, -0.008304750546813011, -0.015772853046655655, 0.023249847814440727, 0.036091070622205734, -0.006607523653656244, 0.032135117799043655, -0.021617000922560692, 0.02702176570892334, 0.008016987703740597, -0.07684843987226486, -0.04972316324710846, 0.03275030851364136, -0.02291293255984783, 0.049618519842624664, -0.01694955676794052, -0.0689207911491394, 0.0170738585293293, 0.049281686544418335, -0.022843869403004646, 0.04518970102071762, 0.0018586782971397042, 0.03131568804383278, -0.004769241902977228, -0.04208396375179291, -0.02639647200703621, -0.02114078402519226, -0.009684199467301369, -0.017777349799871445, -0.0942155197262764, 0.033351149410009384, 0.05697515979409218, -0.0388779416680336, 0.021276528015732765, 0.03387179598212242, -0.013643789105117321, 0.00669883331283927, 0.01635134406387806, 0.006283320486545563, -0.011968551203608513, 0.03218445926904678, -0.030479423701763153, 0.057253148406744, 0.0543845072388649, 0.013422890566289425, -0.008013264276087284, -0.016506655141711235, 0.06517520546913147, 0.0190347321331501, -0.023624476045370102, 0.016281716525554657, -0.021076926961541176, -0.010131764225661755, 0.00822138786315918, -0.05785687640309334, -0.011463221162557602, -0.027933325618505478, -0.007637603674083948, -0.019332895055413246, 0.055431611835956573, -0.04281824454665184, -0.00772532494738698, 0.06007521227002144, -0.023884853348135948, -0.07152830809354782, -0.04808055981993675, 0.03057803213596344, 0.008051492273807526, -0.05727217718958855, 0.022883428260684013, -0.023154349997639656, 0.03339817747473717, -0.03484655171632767, -0.014421142637729645, -0.015756983309984207, 0.011415068991482258, 0.008422222919762135, -0.023602550849318504, 0.041453197598457336, 0.021593643352389336, 0.011912313289940357, -0.014809267595410347, 0.04021375626325607, -0.03912654146552086, -0.06531184166669846, 0.03069930337369442, -0.05344301834702492, 0.02729153446853161, -0.04112018644809723, -0.020415449514985085, -0.02362808585166931, -0.03338504955172539, -0.017530422657728195, 0.04201072081923485, -0.06474881619215012, 0.05921650305390358, 0.07881820201873779, 0.021050654351711273, -0.013885530643165112, 0.05513250082731247, 0.05010666325688362, -0.00614548334851861, -0.053902287036180496, -0.006962822750210762, -0.053047239780426025, -0.029677290469408035, 0.015581857413053513, 0.005994248669594526, -0.02145996317267418, 0.04739144816994667, 0.07032483071088791, 0.006638419348746538, 0.020318010821938515, 0.03257561847567558, -0.0017956006340682507, -0.01377227995544672, 0.011309325695037842, 0.04224357753992081, -0.006757305935025215, -0.0014148206682875752, 0.022871222347021103, 0.016435718163847923, 0.0216917023062706, -0.0010863629868254066, 0.01586250215768814, -0.004082778934389353, 0.02581764943897724, 0.01682175137102604, -0.024148084223270416, -0.0031182921957224607, 0.03974396362900734, -0.0021620176266878843, 0.01734263449907303, 0.032864123582839966, 0.022365223616361618, -0.04796741530299187, 0.007300074212253094, -0.03852348029613495, 0.05128858610987663, 0.015359300188720226, -0.04716694355010986, -0.030425338074564934, 0.021918965503573418, -0.015094157308340073, 0.0075830421410501, -0.020373931154608727, -0.038259107619524, -0.02978353388607502, -0.013980205170810223, 0.01637255772948265, -0.02295500971376896, 0.02853851392865181, -0.048727910965681076, 0.01188658270984888, -0.007492111995816231, 0.020609337836503983, -0.014087466523051262, -0.0462983176112175, -0.023557748645544052, -0.020480433478951454, -0.01603850908577442, -0.018192175775766373, 0.02051643095910549, 0.0036703511141240597, -0.010600950568914413, 0.022485952824354172, -0.005829296074807644, -0.04724323749542236, -0.05058589205145836, -0.018020525574684143, 0.011112198233604431, -0.007310349959880114, -0.019032824784517288, 0.027857450768351555, 0.015592331998050213, -0.03393588587641716, 0.009411781094968319, 0.0006778230890631676, -0.013536318205296993, -0.021025290712714195, 0.013106919825077057, 0.0063626463524997234, 0.007309353910386562, 0.002254168502986431, 0.007603710517287254, -0.0593314990401268, 0.02580789290368557, -0.0762932226061821, -0.06939169764518738, 0.05977552384138107, -0.0016850510146468878, 0.023792745545506477, -0.0062231938354671, -0.005588398315012455, 0.058301910758018494, 0.027546465396881104, 0.000029028620701865293, -0.07597131282091141, -0.030063701793551445, -0.026084130629897118, -0.045521099120378494, 0.04033346846699715, 0.04181765392422676, 0.050382100045681, 0.06285410374403, -0.017579739913344383, 0.051412973552942276, 0.020382162183523178, 0.007502962835133076, -0.01244658324867487, -0.005662653129547834, 0.0028411834500730038, 0.001226067659445107, 0.017487362027168274, -0.003658018307760358, 0.019306860864162445, -0.014629633165895939, 0.03219452127814293, 0.045123789459466934, -0.013027225621044636, -0.024196842685341835, 0.03810258209705353, -0.034242384135723114, 0.03239487484097481, -0.023621102795004845, 0.037279292941093445, 0.04511226713657379, -0.004526873119175434, -0.007997666485607624, 0.0010901534697040915, 0.043821532279253006, -0.007545321714133024, 0.04337146505713463, 0.04929884523153305, 0.01632320135831833, 0.007498512044548988, -0.013587850145995617, -0.002597665414214134, 0.03063008561730385, 0.0185046698898077, -0.002809331752359867, -0.024670587852597237, 0.044781528413295746, 0.04585391655564308, -0.020922569558024406, -0.012928880751132965, -0.03284502774477005, -0.014170978218317032, -0.06211037188768387, 0.03628840297460556, -0.019001126289367676, 0.030738653615117073, -0.012025553733110428, 0.04352288693189621, -0.008846309967339039, -0.030365897342562675, -0.010747206397354603, -0.01576298661530018, -0.007697659078985453, 0.021944085136055946, -0.04281949996948242, -0.001607551472261548, 0.03609589487314224, -0.000021050076611572877, 0.03139077126979828, -0.03904479369521141, -0.008133898489177227, 0.010224795900285244, 0.028715694323182106, -0.00198578555136919, 0.007479857187718153, -0.03064763732254505, -0.04048982262611389, 0.015538626350462437, -0.0036120268050581217, 0.004822796676307917, -0.010192258283495903, 0.012447783723473549, 0.03618886321783066, -0.023978862911462784, 0.011670788750052452, -0.049492161720991135, 0.014688440598547459, 0.02741340920329094, 0.04654461890459061, 0.029808076098561287, -0.03741075471043587, -0.06862103939056396, 0.046742431819438934, -0.004489402752369642, 0.03895285353064537, 0.07036394625902176, 0.016558531671762466, -0.009002160280942917, -0.027793938294053078, -0.01641828380525112, 0.04434243589639664, -0.012622063048183918, -0.044303614646196365, -0.003975050989538431, 0.050446297973394394, 0.03209882974624634, -0.041190702468156815, 0.0399571917951107, 0.03766263648867607, 0.04188889265060425, -0.0035027696285396814, -0.05189376696944237, -0.025797341018915176, 0.032415661960840225, -0.004622757434844971, 0.04445770010352135, -0.013013285584747791, 0.026225455105304718, -0.009246955625712872, 0.04564926028251648, 0.03283226117491722, -0.03741002455353737, 0.025051746517419815, 0.002369019202888012, 0.04000645875930786, 0.004612331744283438, -0.04236069321632385, -0.002295031677931547, 0.028193185105919838, 0.039145633578300476, 0.01925591006875038, 0.007769611198455095, -0.07507556676864624, -0.005976242013275623, 0.03452463820576668, 0.03687012195587158, -0.06497961282730103, -0.01229370292276144, -0.030062850564718246, 0.008452645502984524, 0.03514509275555611, -0.0027841106057167053, 0.007092510815709829, -0.033902596682310104, 0.0037176785990595818, -0.0372806154191494, -0.024963293224573135, -0.05582037195563316, 0.04235640913248062, 0.011475742794573307, 0.02618841454386711, -0.043111953884363174, -0.026059355586767197, -0.020180389285087585, 0.04546847194433212, 0.03411722183227539, 0.03672999143600464, 0.008984683081507683, 0.003175288438796997, -0.008030758239328861, 0.04062238335609436, 0.008134379051625729, -0.08816370368003845, 0.02273477427661419, -0.00965417642146349, 0.005600192118436098, 0.05279146879911423, 0.007915668189525604, -0.03213344141840935, -0.009938757866621017, 0.035778455436229706, 0.012005306780338287, -0.02033553272485733, 0.023181620985269547, 0.06773743033409119, 0.018351823091506958, 0.034194596111774445, 0.03966505452990532, 0.034224946051836014, -0.018637660890817642, -0.02877964824438095, 0.004090561531484127, 0.02487703412771225, -0.05944424122571945, -0.053737822920084, -0.040895361453294754, -0.03950566053390503, -0.008098054677248001, 0.016185175627470016, -0.012370718643069267, 0.03088436834514141, -0.02965371124446392, -0.05025883764028549, -0.017319753766059875, 0.04586302116513252, -0.029030194506049156, -0.010687865316867828, -0.01123835239559412, 0.012946611270308495, -0.011857897974550724, -0.001030124258249998, 0.015524672344326973, -0.042332593351602554, 0.026881234720349312, 0.004495534580200911, -0.011035630479454994, -0.02940800040960312, -0.018618915230035782, -0.03160925954580307, -0.041045915335416794, -0.04770948365330696, 0.010890833102166653, -0.014131907373666763, 0.03470548242330551, -0.03935810551047325, -0.03709346801042557, 0.03819071128964424, 0.043639156967401505, 0.0011300490004941821, 0.018776196986436844, 0.027100080624222755, 0.0015242899535223842, -0.03488831967115402, -0.029376525431871414, -0.04930140823125839, -0.04600520431995392, -0.022067394107580185, -0.0024148491211235523, 0.02400103770196438, 0.008824203163385391, -0.030480539426207542, -0.033353108912706375, 0.004101605620235205, 0.01463936734944582, 0.058508239686489105, -0.03379976749420166, 0.021244702860713005, -0.008201329037547112, 0.04132534936070442, 0.07282668352127075, 0.007310269400477409, -0.03401835635304451, 0.04113110154867172, -0.014073156751692295, -0.000022909584004082717, -0.010151240974664688, -0.0016759904101490974, -0.008312816731631756, 0.000663907325360924, -0.04551703482866287, -0.01439082995057106, 0.0686168223619461, -0.012446735054254532, -0.02947162836790085, 0.004412828013300896, -0.00785801000893116, -0.0013709916966035962, -0.015818534418940544, -0.005662062205374241, -0.016245393082499504, 0.005672793835401535, 0.01811601035296917, 0.030347442254424095, -0.030049527063965797, -0.02014799416065216, 0.05336714908480644, -0.006084744818508625, -0.011119614355266094, 0.031380217522382736, 0.07720277458429337, 0.014679664745926857, -0.0009422214352525771, -0.011675627902150154, -0.02358645759522915, 0.059057824313640594, -0.005875562783330679, 0.02053642086684704, 0.034065209329128265, 0.04160941392183304, -0.007703397423028946, -0.07121127843856812, -0.005655201151967049, 0.0023747372906655073, 0.040457833558321, -0.0016429004026576877, 0.015221224166452885, 0.040309563279151917, -0.01497906818985939, -0.03786831349134445, -0.03322475403547287, 0.015414634719491005, -0.009804844856262207, 0.008419279009103775, 0.07153476029634476, -0.05708299204707146, -0.006528717465698719, 0.02866249531507492, 0.014134078286588192, 0.03846482187509537, -0.005833316594362259, 0.02929658256471157, 0.026873748749494553, 0.039640847593545914, -0.002532182028517127, -0.061873260885477066, 0.03890812024474144, -0.05750035494565964, -0.014614619314670563, -0.048420995473861694, -0.022616548463702202, 0.020695270970463753, 0.0786348357796669, 0.006391820032149553, -0.04067201167345047, -0.013265532441437244, -0.018164556473493576, 0.017948001623153687, 0.006564838346093893, -0.01121212262660265, 0.005444130394607782, 0.00131708150729537, 0.02936588041484356, -0.00818527489900589, -0.012021118775010109, -0.022946394979953766, -0.09820155799388885, -0.021931178867816925, 0.016156582161784172, -0.010171810165047646, -0.010235088877379894, -0.0015035601099953055, -0.04470512270927429, 0.005893074441701174, -0.06155254319310188, -0.014051828533411026, -0.023270800709724426, 0.003708051983267069, -0.017310477793216705, 0.026763977482914925, -0.0039679850451648235, 0.009228643029928207, 0.024189522489905357, -0.0014141894644126296, 0.11090187728404999, 0.054194193333387375, 0.017077986150979996, -0.07715180516242981, 0.028800340369343758, -0.003751294454559684, 0.010676142759621143, -0.04045909643173218, -0.024091515690088272, -0.003247543703764677, -0.021134167909622192, 0.023375989869236946, 0.04983893781900406, 0.0404367558658123, -0.0021022215951234102, 0.08730592578649521, -0.03281952440738678, -0.004644460044801235, 0.005452281329780817, -0.018885575234889984, -0.0031716814264655113, -0.012264584191143513, -0.04951491951942444, -0.0017134826630353928, 0.005667765624821186, -0.03901804983615875, 0.001293286681175232, 0.015026544220745564, 0.005459212232381105, 0.0309186652302742, -0.03156642988324165, 0.004606995265930891, -0.002120652934536338, -0.0016158361686393619, -0.001428369083441794, -0.028164099901914597, -0.01304466649889946, -0.002387498738244176, 0.030279887840151787, 0.013942673802375793, -0.018642203882336617, -0.02488051727414131, 0.023091858252882957, -0.011492733843624592, -0.041307125240564346, -0.017546141520142555, -0.007292448543012142, 0.016184039413928986, -0.03396478295326233, -0.04262470081448555, -0.0032204175367951393, 0.0023339746985584497, 0.005198081489652395, -0.018488967791199684, -0.018612785264849663, 0.017466893419623375, 0.03453376144170761, -0.04896219074726105, -0.002845504553988576, -0.03198317438364029, 0.014296279288828373, -0.02268906868994236, 0.0035483152605593204, -0.0014344790251925588, -0.05135348439216614, -0.030304642394185066, -0.047069650143384933, 0.048826828598976135, 0.011068733409047127, -0.033138226717710495, 0.013217581436038017, -0.00644672941416502, -0.04453146085143089, -0.03341475874185562, 0.012864233925938606, 0.01627935655415058, 0.024666763842105865, 0.01985483057796955, -0.01107675489038229, -0.047420307993888855, -0.012212386354804039, 0.005591574590653181, 0.000018543030819273554, -0.003572829533368349, -0.036387424916028976, -0.0415903739631176, -0.010664870962500572, 0.010611511766910553, 0.030237209051847458, 0.018960796296596527, -0.010378045029938221, 0.05609607696533203, -0.04736550152301788, -0.04040589928627014, -0.011741111986339092, 0.003415935207158327, -0.03900568187236786, -0.025373276323080063, 0.024418991059064865, 0.028997337445616722, -0.0256043728441, -0.0009402899304404855, -0.04385785758495331, 0.035975463688373566, -0.0005612417007796466, -0.010541155003011227, 0.052478302270174026, -0.07585274428129196, 0.03155480697751045, 0.05193682387471199, 0.00004789048034581356, 0.007823577150702477, -0.004752109292894602, -0.036674581468105316, -0.03074684925377369, -0.0013041435740888119, -0.010638458654284477, -0.009681067429482937, -0.02950155921280384, -0.01377877127379179, 0.0733276978135109, -0.030000625178217888, -0.030429109930992126, -0.037558723241090775, -0.009665731340646744, 0.0414515882730484, -0.0006065276102162898, 0.02437085658311844, 0.013343431055545807, 0.014165704138576984, 0.026973895728588104, 0.03342856839299202, 0.021990293636918068, -0.02445608377456665, -0.008216812275350094, 0.0048900991678237915, 0.01688174530863762, 0.052488453686237335, -0.03204790875315666, -0.05963080748915672, 0.03734580799937248, -0.025843745097517967, -0.02867758460342884, 0.02464035339653492, 0.004412032198160887, 0.04606127366423607, 0.04748045653104782, -0.02912062779068947, -0.01853083074092865, 0.03616829216480255, -0.02884514257311821, 0.0020641086157411337, -0.005697250831872225, 0.01970233954489231, 0.0206433292478323, -0.018717464059591293, -0.009795980527997017, 0.010546578094363213, 0.006628761999309063, 0.05557781457901001, 0.06355246901512146, -0.018942980095744133, 0.003378578694537282, 0.0004483272787183523, -0.02159031853079796, 0.01456909067928791, 0.0006496639107353985, -0.023303108289837837, 0.02840522862970829, 0.0246046781539917, -0.01860426738858223, 0.020162971690297127, 0.02619808539748192, 0.033372923731803894, -0.06691060215234756, -0.04324764758348465, 0.03264905884861946, 0.026372984051704407, 0.024392250925302505, -0.027340950444340706, 0.009725797921419144, 0.01699431799352169, -0.039559975266456604, -0.023907538503408432, 0.010624834336340427, -0.012414681725203991, -0.06459666788578033, 0.006475707981735468, -0.0042292894795536995, 0.012116856873035431, -0.0034468809608370066, 0.007269747089594603, 0.010522267781198025, 0.006165447179228067, 0.01363411359488964, -0.010999931953847408, -0.005865374114364386, -0.01567750982940197, 0.020890668034553528, -0.04943089559674263, 0.004361626226454973, -0.033207330852746964, -0.01515763159841299, -0.00452454062178731, -0.019992906600236893, 0.021797489374876022, 0.021735364571213722, 0.03762266784906387, 0.04060818627476692, 0.052017584443092346, 0.009127653203904629, 0.012651062570512295, 0.0014970207121223211, -0.023480409756302834, -0.0004547817225102335, 0.06842394173145294, -0.010143226943910122, -0.0028382830787450075, -0.020085951313376427, -0.007369789760559797, 0.00378625956363976, -0.0010612758342176676, -0.03561693802475929, -0.041824404150247574, -0.015956616029143333, -0.019611896947026253, -0.0157490074634552, -0.028524670749902725, 0.029621299356222153, -0.020433537662029266, -0.03422251343727112, 0.035988014191389084, 0.03163071721792221, -0.059101175516843796, 0.00853156577795744, -0.002147647552192211, -0.03249473497271538, 0.00620681419968605, 0.013001612387597561, -0.011154670268297195, -0.035448767244815826, -0.006408254150301218, -0.03253697603940964, 0.02338746376335621, -0.025080420076847076, 0.002114315517246723, -0.02872873842716217, 0.02470576949417591, -0.04006345197558403, 0.03389676287770271, -0.002466899808496237, -0.03496556729078293, 0.019935136660933495, -0.0580555722117424, 0.09482444077730179, -0.011196012608706951, -0.010724150575697422, -0.03712005168199539, 0.0025352949742227793, -0.07531007379293442, -0.010085991583764553, 0.05390167981386185, 0.013628248125314713, 0.035443078726530075, 0.033002618700265884, 0.04261051490902901, -0.019721273332834244, -0.02813146635890007, 0.07099918276071548, -0.002584784757345915, 0.024511286988854408, -0.020030172541737556, -0.01632293500006199, 0.015744928270578384, 0.028126154094934464, 0.019284117966890335, -0.0030519580468535423, 0.01271821465343237, 0.006166817154735327, -0.0008950312039814889, 0.021356312558054924, 0.0037866150960326195, -0.035439763218164444, 0.023083601146936417, -0.006119361612945795, 0.016017740592360497, 0.041128773242235184, -0.01389441080391407, -0.030888287350535393, 0.029695408418774605, -0.016311150044202805, -0.011598799377679825, 0.01824081316590309, 0.0362342894077301, -0.020720483735203743, -0.048486754298210144, 0.021668054163455963, 0.04034692049026489, -0.04786011204123497, 0.0002628140209708363, 0.03916520997881889, 0.027605658397078514, 0.02074456214904785, 0.010355171747505665, 0.029004646465182304, 0.012094071134924889, -0.014444508589804173, 0.02919601835310459, 0.04098799452185631, 0.024659745395183563, -0.0015238680643960834, 0.0030099181458353996, 0.002451482927426696, -0.003961718175560236, 0.022832108661532402, -0.010374770499765873, 0.053069114685058594, -0.027934374287724495, -0.024166667833924294, 0.05800282955169678, 0.010314627550542355, -0.000328617577906698, -0.03779232129454613, 0.007263214327394962, 0.058840133249759674, -0.03944600373506546, -0.011694973334670067, -0.06854759901762009, -0.025994684547185898, 0.021503161638975143, 0.0036847165320068598, 0.04013459011912346, 0.00639386149123311, 0.01842738501727581, -0.026356568560004234, -0.009119291789829731, -0.03049708716571331, 0.005732566583901644, -0.019090501591563225, 0.04122034087777138, -0.0035193897783756256, 0.01519625261425972, -0.030840149149298668, -0.045082129538059235, -0.022462721914052963, -0.04356617480516434, 0.04606687277555466, 0.030380694195628166, 0.00919819064438343, -0.022048141807317734, -0.03357524797320366, 0.014826145023107529, 0.05161908268928528, -0.04277186840772629, -0.014807111583650112, -0.018385840579867363, 0.004726736806333065, 0.0019755535759031773, 0.026288775727152824 ]
<p>Suppose I have to estimate 3 models:</p> <p>$y_1 = y_2\beta_1 + y_3\beta_2 + X\beta_3 + u_1$</p> <p>$y_2 = y_1\alpha_1 + y_3\alpha_2 + X\alpha_3 + u_2$</p> <p>$y_3 = y_1\gamma_1 + y_2\gamma_2 + X\gamma_3 + u_3$</p> <p>I account for the endogeneity of $y_1, y_2$ and $y_3$ with a approach which creates a additional variable which allows me to not exlude any other regressors.</p> <p>Suppose these additional regressors are $c_1$ for $y_1$, $c_2$ for $y_2$ and $c_3$ for $y_3$. Now the models will be:</p> <p>$y_1 = y_2\beta_1 + y_3\beta_2 + X\beta_3 + c_2\beta_4 + c_3\beta_5 + u_1$</p> <p>$y_2 = y_1\alpha_1 + y_3\alpha_2 + X\alpha_3 + c_1\alpha_4 + c_3\alpha_5 + u_2$</p> <p>$y_3 = y_1\gamma_1 + y_2\gamma_2 + X\gamma_3 + c_1\gamma_4 + c_2\gamma_5 + u_2$</p> <p>Given that the influence of the $c_i$ in each equation is significant, identification is achieved. The reason is that in each equation one $c_i$ is missing (for example $c_1$ in the $y_1$ equation).</p> <p>It turns out that I cannot leave $c_1$ out of the equation regarding $y_1$ (same for all the other equations). If I would, the model would be seriously biased. </p> <p>My questions are: When I estimate the full model, i.e., all $c_i$ are included in every equation and some of the regressors contained in $X$ are not signficant and these regressors are all different for each equation, is identification achieved?</p> <p>I would say yes. But this approach does only achieve identification through the insignificance of a regressor. I'm not quite sure if this is the right angle to it.</p>
36,030
[ -0.02957294136285782, 0.00927005149424076, 0.00923946499824524, 0.02908698283135891, 0.03574686497449875, 0.04348369315266609, -0.01690256968140602, -0.02440369501709938, 0.03022906742990017, -0.03366999328136444, 0.010138357989490032, 0.0049443780444562435, 0.05449492856860161, 0.004405234474688768, 0.025240497663617134, 0.0358903706073761, 0.002422410761937499, 0.014446490444242954, 0.011667834594845772, -0.03434009477496147, -0.016379348933696747, 0.04038090258836746, -0.025576956570148468, 0.0069685024209320545, -0.031929854303598404, 0.05100492760539055, 0.05047858878970146, -0.02852996252477169, 0.004419964738190174, 0.028311265632510185, -0.023016976192593575, 0.010760907083749771, -0.028887154534459114, 0.04809437319636345, 0.013046003878116608, 0.021223150193691254, 0.009738240391016006, -0.02755187638103962, 0.04873250052332878, 0.03442242369055748, -0.060193948447704315, -0.011855012737214565, -0.007207137066870928, -0.02084328792989254, 0.005382510833442211, -0.0011602445738390088, 0.0041582295671105385, -0.014549311250448227, 0.0021220939233899117, -0.008418180979788303, 0.10280926525592804, -0.03240145742893219, 0.029190635308623314, 0.023572007194161415, -0.044567305594682693, -0.013443349860608578, 0.04806974530220032, 0.07938290387392044, -0.00431556161493063, -0.052054326981306076, -0.01425312552601099, 0.02318000979721546, 0.008103645406663418, -0.012847471050918102, -0.04190738871693611, 0.03357166796922684, 0.02362458035349846, -0.005238696932792664, 0.02749517932534218, -0.03163344785571098, 0.004027294926345348, -0.03346087411046028, 0.0299784317612648, 0.006458599586039782, 0.011518784798681736, 0.009324083104729652, -0.003245073137804866, 0.04711557552218437, 0.015565440058708191, 0.0274732057005167, -0.003917603753507137, -0.002822005422785878, 0.03469141572713852, 0.040643949061632156, 0.01796274445950985, 0.013734719716012478, 0.057634610682725906, -0.03300013393163681, 0.03026431053876877, 0.04100698605179787, -0.04929144307971001, -0.0013167742872610688, 0.044278353452682495, -0.01678931899368763, -0.027501028031110764, 0.02971925586462021, -0.006744006648659706, 0.022361936047673225, -0.00845150463283062, 0.017634933814406395, -0.020750299096107483, -0.03436700254678726, -0.02193048968911171, 0.06196817755699158, -0.00864593405276537, -0.004248606041073799, -0.009977808222174644, 0.028366249054670334, -0.007398546207696199, -0.043170392513275146, 0.019170217216014862, 0.0577600821852684, -0.019882522523403168, -0.027914149686694145, 0.02597854658961296, 0.002921903971582651, -0.017606256529688835, -0.008891191333532333, 0.062174271792173386, 0.06770455092191696, 0.04551608860492706, -0.06319551169872284, -0.01615951396524906, -0.0012826358433812857, -0.0536363311111927, -0.003212972544133663, 0.033258240669965744, -0.033322665840387344, -0.037489697337150574, 0.02582642249763012, 0.02650335431098938, -0.029985900968313217, 0.022047391161322594, 0.022428415715694427, 0.037760403007268906, 0.0038931183516979218, -0.09586396813392639, -0.04742277413606644, 0.026739951223134995, -0.02596132829785347, 0.011054414324462414, -0.05071592703461647, 0.01675594225525856, 0.031187884509563446, 0.07593196630477905, -0.0149738360196352, 0.0029322293121367693, 0.047792743891477585, 0.005015394650399685, 0.02609441988170147, 0.006321139633655548, -0.017229221761226654, -0.03667822107672691, -0.00023357471218332648, -0.03951526805758476, -0.07592198252677917, 0.019989144057035446, 0.028898091986775398, -0.024653390049934387, 0.04315318912267685, 0.011906035244464874, 0.03241255506873131, -0.012382050044834614, 0.01059113908559084, 0.012273231521248817, -0.029173284769058228, 0.030564112588763237, -0.010734840296208858, 0.009476696141064167, 0.019129028543829918, -0.0058686095289886, 0.029789110645651817, -0.012834812514483929, 0.051653310656547546, 0.021899284794926643, -0.029067637398838997, -0.029944419860839844, -0.009334005415439606, -0.03619405999779701, 0.031062528491020203, -0.06912853568792343, -0.06067362055182457, -0.0018625574884936213, 0.011562284082174301, 0.025630977004766464, 0.028130827471613884, 0.0025296115782111883, -0.01738700084388256, 0.04693436622619629, -0.028429733589291573, -0.023423975333571434, -0.04223090037703514, -0.015292923897504807, -0.01763654686510563, -0.030705533921718597, 0.0447772778570652, -0.01601511240005493, -0.010275126434862614, 0.014839224517345428, -0.0077691408805549145, -0.024328041821718216, 0.026730814948678017, 0.044360652565956116, -0.04319602996110916, 0.021701399236917496, 0.03599575161933899, 0.06063035503029823, -0.02237846329808235, 0.06898892670869827, -0.00967283546924591, -0.0030479012057185173, 0.0309278704226017, -0.023267967626452446, 0.005920332856476307, -0.03542282059788704, -0.008777938783168793, 0.008808097802102566, -0.03288091719150543, -0.02261294238269329, 0.04977897182106972, -0.07067257910966873, 0.036773085594177246, 0.04943425580859184, -0.002477060304954648, 0.004109393339604139, 0.010018753819167614, 0.023128295317292213, 0.07252445816993713, -0.026328371837735176, 0.012630276381969452, -0.04905703291296959, -0.03136212378740311, -0.004178785718977451, 0.03540188819169998, -0.06616907566785812, 0.02177182212471962, 0.049476999789476395, 0.04903360456228256, 0.008053689263761044, 0.04782614856958389, 0.030232949182391167, 0.00010067455150419846, 0.030011938884854317, -0.0011750805424526334, 0.011053718626499176, 0.009072232991456985, 0.028301790356636047, -0.01952190510928631, 0.03072235733270645, -0.0018140479223802686, 0.030229046940803528, 0.03129880875349045, 0.03837336599826813, 0.011937419883906841, 0.018456025049090385, 0.0031878422014415264, 0.05090103670954704, 0.007583397440612316, 0.04426010325551033, 0.04112676903605461, -0.0018086964264512062, -0.010115650482475758, 0.04255787283182144, 0.006285809446126223, -0.004780760034918785, 0.02479071542620659, -0.05341006815433502, 0.01923348940908909, 0.0032043755054473877, -0.025452828034758568, -0.006334955804049969, -0.04331224039196968, -0.028796566650271416, -0.03506023436784744, -0.027722248807549477, 0.03161895275115967, 0.004745821934193373, 0.027738723903894424, -0.024731654673814774, 0.0013748274650424719, 0.00772848492488265, -0.015110835433006287, 0.037119023501873016, 0.013181725516915321, -0.052731145173311234, 0.00641208840534091, -0.046057023108005524, 0.008025657385587692, 0.016965148970484734, -0.018618442118167877, -0.0017231982201337814, 0.037820637226104736, -0.00752977654337883, -0.04762871190905571, -0.058401305228471756, -0.03320574387907982, 0.03671560809016228, -0.060458458960056305, -0.048526231199502945, 0.04228861629962921, 0.05895282328128815, -0.06652183830738068, 0.0037852455861866474, -0.06447816640138626, -0.028858914971351624, 0.005925897974520922, -0.007272758521139622, -0.001952564693056047, 0.0012506676139310002, 0.029419003054499626, 0.007521004881709814, -0.014555870555341244, -0.036314669996500015, -0.06197081878781319, -0.07724478095769882, 0.025517627596855164, 0.0059074461460113525, 0.01628638617694378, -0.005730168428272009, -0.007233408745378256, 0.07656491547822952, 0.03064166195690632, 0.008278889581561089, -0.030559975653886795, 0.00039985368493944407, 0.011161467991769314, -0.023770533502101898, -0.010760689154267311, 0.01610180176794529, 0.013636116869747639, 0.03203301131725311, 0.005383775569498539, 0.04926316440105438, 0.012326367199420929, -0.004732809029519558, 0.03515717014670372, 0.010922049172222614, -0.003462463617324829, -0.00032274314435198903, 0.0077364034950733185, 0.023926204070448875, 0.012171194888651371, -0.008165014907717705, 0.02103583514690399, 0.04579059034585953, 0.04062136635184288, -0.024262158200144768, -0.008797324262559414, -0.029312919825315475, 0.009306236170232296, -0.04485389590263367, 0.024387208744883537, 0.04027963802218437, -0.027823643758893013, -0.05858387053012848, 0.010290649719536304, 0.0508287139236927, -0.009240164421498775, 0.0070779589004814625, 0.041861362755298615, 0.01889762654900551, -0.008210605941712856, 0.0006544910720549524, -0.03227012977004051, -0.020762842148542404, 0.0303970780223608, -0.005009242333471775, -0.033437009900808334, 0.03854828700423241, 0.060241490602493286, -0.020030120387673378, -0.030100176110863686, -0.03866167739033699, -0.02531641349196434, -0.08203693479299545, 0.027694273740053177, -0.05855235084891319, 0.059213705360889435, 0.019535768777132034, 0.019873779267072678, -0.026316236704587936, -0.0434737354516983, -0.012467015534639359, -0.02435847744345665, -0.07034449279308319, 0.018473800271749496, 0.0005074518849141896, 0.014103132300078869, 0.02409968711435795, -0.015723951160907745, 0.06121223047375679, -0.05029783025383949, -0.013587918132543564, -0.013961082324385643, 0.0011533101787790656, -0.027282696217298508, 0.013495859690010548, -0.028397800400853157, -0.03364431485533714, 0.03403716906905174, 0.02700977213680744, 0.047775350511074066, -0.03401623293757439, -0.003660517744719982, 0.0008320158231072128, 0.003135445760563016, 0.002837513806298375, -0.05025101080536842, 0.005378656089305878, 0.03188028931617737, 0.05728338286280632, 0.039298828691244125, 0.023718655109405518, -0.0005555212264880538, -0.004093971103429794, 0.002981139812618494, 0.010460232384502888, 0.04445840045809746, 0.0067430115304887295, -0.0433121919631958, -0.04126351326704025, 0.004202601499855518, 0.004179337527602911, 0.04318641498684883, 0.002283318666741252, 0.002732096239924431, 0.056276049464941025, 0.03618714585900307, -0.042381878942251205, 0.012272974476218224, -0.02027660235762596, 0.04316669702529907, 0.0015742355026304722, -0.04544352740049362, -0.0072236028499901295, -0.013670707121491432, -0.0004909051349386573, -0.005473978351801634, -0.017008937895298004, -0.007798067294061184, -0.01681160368025303, 0.017341090366244316, -0.007632771972566843, -0.005633336491882801, 0.006400377489626408, 0.03619110956788063, 0.024374227970838547, 0.008796703070402145, -0.037244006991386414, 0.05064280331134796, 0.01930800825357437, -0.003762851469218731, 0.035248614847660065, 0.022968042641878128, -0.070147804915905, 0.008887053467333317, 0.04675758630037308, 0.016237545758485794, -0.0362265408039093, -0.009472029283642769, -0.0024371054023504257, -0.0007146933348849416, 0.019139206036925316, -0.0018151290714740753, 0.04421926662325859, -0.008989041671156883, 0.0024668823461979628, 0.027386406436562538, -0.04484911262989044, -0.0806213989853859, 0.009007837623357773, -0.03149176388978958, 0.02510734647512436, -0.012106878682971, -0.029562916606664658, -0.022617332637310028, 0.011318635195493698, 0.010395433753728867, 0.039649881422519684, -0.018829582259058952, -0.011999335139989853, 0.0390891470015049, 0.06477534770965576, -0.001279104151763022, -0.06783217936754227, 0.013287055306136608, 0.002217703964561224, -0.02270693890750408, 0.0295626912266016, -0.03454918786883354, -0.047043200582265854, 0.015099119395017624, 0.021961426362395287, 0.0033564690966159105, -0.017537148669362068, -0.03177276998758316, 0.04378405213356018, 0.03317529335618019, 0.003639768110588193, 0.057652588933706284, 0.037185776978731155, -0.005652290768921375, -0.021328844130039215, -0.04740890860557556, -0.038777317851781845, -0.048764538019895554, -0.03513319417834282, -0.04291810095310211, -0.030706027522683144, 0.004716977477073669, 0.012311349622905254, -0.014911452308297157, 0.018205853179097176, -0.0025962209329009056, 0.0063816276378929615, -0.011969400569796562, 0.00807728711515665, -0.039661724120378494, -0.019690239802002907, -0.03928085416555405, 0.01657850109040737, 0.00007398195884888992, -0.025700975209474564, -0.006589021533727646, -0.02195197157561779, -0.016472892835736275, -0.005264312960207462, 0.013903356157243252, -0.01958821713924408, -0.0045059239491820335, -0.012576732784509659, -0.023120081052184105, 0.017084063962101936, 0.026659665629267693, -0.0004938245401717722, 0.06077059730887413, -0.017339449375867844, -0.0008228262886404991, -0.029458951205015182, 0.036894649267196655, -0.013687481172382832, 0.015665259212255478, -0.003066183300688863, 0.02203294262290001, -0.005984374321997166, -0.001863504177890718, -0.07470877468585968, -0.022516069933772087, 0.030692368745803833, 0.0009298221557401121, 0.014673808589577675, -0.003923774231225252, -0.008858458139002323, -0.011942826211452484, -0.06251289695501328, -0.031251780688762665, 0.047905027866363525, -0.02752482146024704, -0.0213873740285635, -0.019214380532503128, 0.03245801851153374, 0.06080784648656845, -0.014867066405713558, -0.02445683255791664, 0.024801425635814667, -0.04825296252965927, -0.038875967264175415, -0.012084947898983955, -0.010879959911108017, -0.015586252324283123, -0.008284881711006165, -0.0224837027490139, -0.0028792168013751507, 0.007582854013890028, -0.020833579823374748, -0.03434682637453079, 0.025458643212914467, 0.0042433119378983974, -0.01014199759811163, -0.03827040642499924, -0.013358823955059052, 0.012542168609797955, 0.01700728014111519, 0.009236053563654423, 0.011964300647377968, 0.0034104364458471537, -0.006107630208134651, 0.07641612738370895, -0.01917695440351963, -0.052459921687841415, -0.008957084268331528, 0.06840566545724869, 0.00280481087975204, 0.008954128250479698, -0.012212207540869713, 0.0024347668513655663, 0.08177732676267624, -0.005172619130462408, -0.0018723775865510106, -0.0203702375292778, 0.026843857020139694, -0.051160842180252075, -0.030579881742596626, -0.05607958510518074, 0.03357923775911331, 0.06638581305742264, -0.026965346187353134, 0.030301131308078766, 0.05933587998151779, 0.007413359358906746, -0.029641134664416313, -0.0325222983956337, -0.005765844136476517, -0.0045340657234191895, -0.024517783895134926, 0.041942935436964035, -0.014246276579797268, -0.016017865389585495, 0.05269178748130798, 0.015127775259315968, 0.03857680782675743, 0.027135781943798065, -0.030352920293807983, 0.004892777651548386, -0.024058224633336067, -0.02970060147345066, -0.05531681329011917, 0.03664589673280716, -0.052405696362257004, -0.005724191665649414, -0.004800655413419008, -0.033138174563646317, 0.0436834879219532, 0.041203975677490234, 0.011740579269826412, -0.06168803945183754, -0.03425370156764984, -0.05107320100069046, 0.038834813982248306, 0.019939804449677467, 0.0021936160046607256, 0.03410099446773529, -0.007132781203836203, 0.029853716492652893, -0.022579971700906754, 0.029611801728606224, -0.045383092015981674, -0.10495119541883469, -0.017641812562942505, -0.0215158648788929, 0.01172633282840252, 0.03963860496878624, -0.012232164852321148, -0.032946519553661346, 0.018190421164035797, -0.03034568391740322, 0.006818876601755619, 0.013379166834056377, 0.04612979292869568, -0.014223923906683922, 0.023370176553726196, -0.006041066255420446, -0.0035884531680494547, -0.0116746099665761, -0.03628034517168999, 0.13228386640548706, 0.06593278050422668, 0.0189348291605711, -0.052652399986982346, 0.004467122256755829, -0.0034646715503185987, -0.006368464790284634, -0.020093010738492012, 0.018422331660985947, -0.0038713004905730486, -0.02030572108924389, 0.0002050660114036873, 0.049641042947769165, -0.0029500192031264305, 0.00289270281791687, 0.043903715908527374, -0.04762587696313858, -0.0017854952020570636, -0.00005088793477625586, -0.0013648364692926407, -0.005122278351336718, 0.005562622100114822, -0.01698996312916279, -0.011880600824952126, -0.003354807384312153, -0.02606380730867386, -0.025515085086226463, 0.002929459325969219, -0.007304398342967033, 0.0012447073822841048, -0.01257800031453371, 0.006792914588004351, -0.01427096500992775, 0.005997917614877224, -0.0211724191904068, 0.030466025695204735, -0.015924522653222084, -0.0680476725101471, 0.014695527032017708, 0.015828602015972137, 0.0019460704643279314, 0.0343349352478981, 0.005685023032128811, 0.03411689028143883, -0.02634328044950962, -0.017655521631240845, -0.024642454460263252, 0.06411644071340561, -0.016054118052124977, -0.03355180099606514, -0.03628278523683548, 0.015477288514375687, 0.014306722208857536, -0.019980523735284805, -0.05396673455834389, 0.040222276002168655, 0.0029618816915899515, -0.057698704302310944, 0.014244142919778824, 0.011019691824913025, 0.03249493986368179, 0.021357053890824318, 0.03953094035387039, 0.023040976375341415, -0.059318579733371735, -0.040662262588739395, -0.011281395331025124, 0.05346805229783058, 0.024415982887148857, -0.005006964318454266, 0.02091585285961628, -0.01630360260605812, -0.0068367403000593185, -0.02096514031291008, 0.02608039416372776, 0.005234348122030497, 0.01889357529580593, -0.008609379641711712, 0.010837352834641933, -0.041165854781866074, -0.027971966192126274, 0.02193225361406803, -0.010838420130312443, 0.0036948893684893847, -0.045998599380254745, -0.012702278792858124, -0.002640028949826956, 0.05976949259638786, 0.04714059457182884, -0.048344142735004425, 0.022090913727879524, 0.07539860904216766, 0.021761270239949226, -0.035622455179691315, -0.02081378921866417, -0.025534961372613907, -0.046171531081199646, 0.004201453644782305, 0.02311716042459011, 0.07145395129919052, 0.024783020839095116, -0.0027281814254820347, 0.015132682397961617, 0.042079802602529526, -0.026858529075980186, -0.005675815045833588, 0.03069174848496914, -0.03208773583173752, 0.010826198384165764, 0.01884801872074604, 0.04154980555176735, -0.0035072937607765198, 0.020872969180345535, -0.0007145682466216385, -0.025920433923602104, 0.018307458609342575, -0.06894096732139587, -0.046389129012823105, 0.03170222043991089, 0.0004920248175039887, 0.05339474603533745, -0.027522986754775047, -0.018171120434999466, -0.05354234576225281, -0.018526257947087288, 0.0000498403278470505, -0.03517834469676018, 0.016193414106965065, -0.0078059774823486805, -0.010145270265638828, 0.020321829244494438, 0.02707885578274727, -0.006132107228040695, 0.00479935435578227, -0.030323609709739685, 0.020584892481565475, -0.0076920147985219955, 0.022849708795547485, -0.009125876240432262, -0.017303673550486565, 0.03491997346282005, -0.0037041304167360067, -0.023168539628386497, 0.001538842567242682, -0.018679063767194748, 0.05709042027592659, -0.00411714892834425, -0.000445797253632918, -0.055551350116729736, 0.02063114382326603, -0.026271237060427666, -0.006559798493981361, -0.02875722199678421, 0.04759158194065094, 0.03739240765571594, -0.036564480513334274, 0.017766844481229782, 0.01017930917441845, -0.002691076137125492, 0.025032490491867065, 0.035738635808229446, 0.01609433814883232, -0.0501176156103611, 0.030054647475481033, 0.03426208719611168, 0.01770348846912384, -0.02287020906805992, 0.007525412365794182, -0.0017503343988209963, 0.006564825773239136, -0.014899060130119324, 0.016324831172823906, 0.0249637458473444, 0.029837852343916893, -0.09967340528964996, -0.051542334258556366, 0.004504180513322353, 0.05554718151688576, 0.012809117324650288, -0.041042085736989975, 0.06329796463251114, 0.05310172587633133, -0.055949144065380096, 0.028162652626633644, -0.010814260691404343, 0.022957954555749893, -0.027452630922198296, 0.013378825969994068, -0.019198182970285416, 0.01873309537768364, 0.03909970447421074, 0.0024575532879680395, 0.006051701493561268, 0.008326961658895016, 0.015341836027801037, -0.06038167327642441, -0.020922662690281868, -0.01706199161708355, -0.002940873149782419, -0.06307052075862885, 0.03340967372059822, -0.016008786857128143, -0.003150814911350608, 0.04536004737019539, 0.02174418419599533, 0.0291778314858675, 0.0046765669248998165, 0.03420494869351387, 0.007570027839392424, 0.05182522535324097, 0.023235313594341278, 0.02513148821890354, 0.0031375535763800144, -0.04772689566016197, 0.014392810873687267, 0.016010401770472527, -0.019713224843144417, -0.02857978269457817, 0.003231796668842435, 0.010927429422736168, -0.020450327545404434, -0.01672491431236267, 0.020148245617747307, -0.0044695110991597176, 0.004437738563865423, -0.007519724313169718, -0.04168739542365074, -0.014822214841842651, 0.025870321318507195, -0.03137168288230896, 0.004441854078322649, 0.037072643637657166, 0.03452785313129425, -0.051437217742204666, -0.03018280304968357, -0.011753030121326447, -0.027150746434926987, 0.004502617288380861, 0.00545870466157794, 0.00226007797755301, -0.05935202166438103, -0.007895789109170437, 0.0046593137085437775, -0.030080556869506836, -0.05232736095786095, -0.004746568389236927, -0.06640347093343735, 0.0385964959859848, -0.003559637814760208, 0.01100294291973114, 0.00032258089049719274, -0.021817728877067566, 0.01222052052617073, -0.09250709414482117, 0.0706314668059349, 0.023241624236106873, 0.0008199545554816723, -0.026100099086761475, -0.00350589444860816, -0.038767751306295395, 0.028027398511767387, 0.0696147158741951, -0.025229930877685547, -0.022267334163188934, -0.008224322460591793, 0.027001945301890373, -0.025081587955355644, -0.024925271049141884, 0.03692236170172691, 0.03023531474173069, 0.020101195201277733, -0.007717562839388847, 0.0004148534208070487, 0.039313215762376785, 0.02834416925907135, -0.004175232257694006, -0.009187707677483559, 0.01573013700544834, 0.020527664572000504, 0.0023887823335826397, -0.009046529419720173, 0.0020844386890530586, -0.0065222992561757565, 0.032289862632751465, 0.016294321045279503, 0.028913721442222595, 0.018315041437745094, -0.007978814654052258, -0.07298047095537186, 0.022468818351626396, -0.02359403483569622, -0.027371080592274666, -0.026623765006661415, -0.00819152407348156, 0.004389213398098946, -0.025897255167365074, 0.019299717620015144, 0.021253349259495735, -0.0528264120221138, -0.007121634669601917, 0.02406259998679161, -0.001221192767843604, 0.05538877099752426, 0.00026889514992944896, 0.03480561450123787, 0.0026373579166829586, -0.040459271520376205, 0.054696377366781235, 0.010936932638287544, 0.004224774427711964, 0.04945852980017662, 0.0030474429950118065, 0.03873176872730255, -0.0067358966916799545, 0.0009492185199633241, -0.03356790170073509, 0.015085634775459766, -0.0235506109893322, 0.005199626088142395, 0.011246022768318653, -0.006906228605657816, 0.020307481288909912, -0.014499553479254246, -0.00820980966091156, 0.03145444020628929, -0.012946889735758305, -0.030048029497265816, -0.014505591243505478, 0.013216960243880749, 0.02140621654689312, -0.012163780629634857, -0.009158636443316936, 0.0238298699259758, 0.015005762688815594, 0.0067262062802910805, -0.010940601117908955, -0.017159417271614075, -0.01843434013426304, 0.0010423744097352028, 0.0077112275175750256, 0.013276571407914162, -0.0025727853644639254, 0.00486126309260726, -0.012927099131047726, -0.050300877541303635, -0.03258368745446205, 0.05222548544406891, 0.05920787155628204, 0.04001733288168907, -0.03363560885190964, -0.03777933493256569, -0.0069639417342841625, 0.048307377845048904, -0.037883210927248, -0.007084558717906475, -0.013370885513722897, 0.011185324750840664, 0.004604688845574856, -0.007018527947366238 ]