article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
the total production rate for taus at a hadron collider is not a useful quantity .
taus must have significant transverse momentum ( @xmath0 ) in order to be observable .
leptonic decays of taus will yield isolated electrons or muons that can be detected but these can also be directly produced so discriminating their origin can be difficult .
hadronic decays of taus result in jets that must be distinguished from jets arising from qcd processes using the particle multiplicity and invariant mass .
the dominant standard model production that results in an observable sample is @xmath1 which produces @xmath2 events per @xmath3 . given this large sample it is reasonable to ask if any useful measurements of tau properties can be made .
measurement of the lifetime is difficult as it requires a determination of the decay length using the vertex tracking system and knowledge of the tau momentum . in the case of
@xmath4 the momentum can be reconstructed using a constrained fit involving the @xmath5 mass ( see section 3 ) .
the process is statistics limited to a precision of approximately 1.8 fs for @xmath6 of data ( @xcite vol
i p. 305 ) .
use of the @xmath7 decay which has a much larger rate is more difficult as there are two neutrinos @xcite .
two methods were attempted involving using the observed tau decay products and the tau mass constraint to determine the momentum of the neutrino in the tau decay and an estimator method @xcite . in this case
the statistical error could be less due to the larger event sample provided that the qcd background can be rejected .
however , the systematic uncertainties from alignment and other sources are difficult to estimate .
rate decays of the tau can provide a probe of new physics .
lepton number is known to be violated in the neutrino sector and the rare decays @xmath8 , @xmath9 or @xmath10 can be expected to occur . in many models @xcite @xcite , @xcite the first of these is expected to be the largest and a simulation will be discussed here @xcite .
the signal is an isolated @xmath11 and photon whose invariant mass reconstructs to the tau .
there are two sources of background @xmath12 and @xmath13 ; the latter dominates . after cuts to reduce the background , the signal acceptance is approximately @xmath14 and the mass resolution is 20 mev resulting in a background of approximately 17 events per @xmath3 .
the resulting limit is not competitive with what is possible at belle and babar unless the full luminosity of the lhc can be exploited .
a study in this environment where the pile - up of minimum bias events degrades resolution and increases background has not been undertaken .
the @xmath15 process is important as a tool for searching for higgs bosons at lhc . as a prelude to this and to illustrate the technique , i will first discuss @xmath4 .
missing neutrinos imply that tau energy can not be measured directly .
however the direction of tau can be obtained from observed decay products as the energy of the produced taus is large compared to the mass . if @xmath5 has signifificant transverse momentum so that tau s are not back to back in phi and the only missing @xmath16 in the event arises from tau decay , then the tau momenta and invariant mass of the @xmath17 system can be reconstructed by assuming that the neutrinos follow the direction of the observed decay products .
these events have no other features so that the selection must be based on the pair of taus .
there is a very large di - jet background from qcd events which must be overcome and the events require a trigger .
events are selected by requiring an isolated electron or muon with @xmath18 gev and @xmath19 and hadronic jet with @xmath20 , @xmath19 , and a number of associated reconstructed tracks @xmath21 , the jet is also required to be narrow , having its energy deposits in the electromagnetic calorimeter confined with a cone of radius @xmath22 in @xmath23 space .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the reconstructed @xmath5 mass with the peak at the correct value .
the figure shows the mass resolution of @xmath24 which is dominated by the missing @xmath25 resolution of the detector . the small residual qcd background is also shown .
the subset of events with @xmath26 can be used to determine the tau decay vertex for the lifetime measurement discussed above .
signal for @xmath27 .
the dashed line shows the background . from @xcite ,
figure 9.54 [ fig1],width=226 ]
the decay @xmath15 can be reconstructed using the technique described in the previous section and the mass of the higgs measured .
the production rates and branching ratios of the standard model higgs are too small for the signal to be seen above the qcd background using the dominant production process @xmath28 .
however the lower rate process @xmath29 while it may not enable a discovery to be made , will give information on the higgs couplings .
the two jets arising from the quarks in the production process are at large rapidity and can be used to reject background .
final states @xmath30 and @xmath31 are used and the @xmath17 invariant mass reconstructed as above with a resolution @xmath32 .
the table shows the expected signal and background @xcite .
it is important to emphasize that this result is based on a parametrized simulation that assumes that the tau tagging and jet tagging is not degraded in the presence of pile - up .
nevertheless it indicates a viable signal for mass range @xmath33 if the higgs mass were already known from another process .
note that signal to background ratio is such that structure would clearly be seen at the higgs mass . .
number of expected signal and background events for the @xmath34 channel , for 100 @xmath35 and two detectors .
cross sections are added for @xmath30 and @xmath36 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in extensions to the standard model more higgs bosons are expected .
the minimal supersymmetric model ( mssm ) has three neutral ( @xmath37 ) and one charged ( @xmath38 ) particles .
their properties are determined by two parameters which can be taken to be the mass of @xmath39 and @xmath40 , which controls the coupling to tau s .
@xmath39 and @xmath41 can be observed over certain regions of parameter space .
the technique adopted is the same as that used for @xmath42 .
figure [ atau ] shows three possible signals and the background which arises from qcd jets .
this signal covers a large fraction of mssm parameter space and is one of the most important probes of the mssm higgs sector .
signal for @xmath27 showing three possible masses .
the background is shown as the unfilled histogram . from @xcite .
[ atau ] , width=226 ] [ tausec ]
a charged higgs boson is expected to decay @xmath43 or @xmath44 .
the latter decay involves the reconstruction of jets and the qcd background in the di - jet mass distribution is a serious difficulty to observation of this mode .
the former decay is more promising .
production of a heavy @xmath38 via @xmath45 is too small , the production via @xmath46 has @xmath47 pb for a mass of @xmath38 of 400 gev .
the decay @xmath43 will result in either an isolated lepton or jet .
the former is not useful so the latter is exploited .
the final state @xmath48 is identified by requiring three jets one of which is tagged as containing a b - hadron from the vertex system and requiring that these three jets are consistent with @xmath49 ( @xmath50 and @xmath51 ) .
another jet with only one associated charged track and @xmath52 gev is required along with missing @xmath25 ( @xmath53 gev ) .
the signal is in transverse mass of `` @xmath54 '' and missing @xmath25 which is shown in figure [ htau ] .
the peak is displaced below the higgs mass as the missing @xmath25 has contributions from both neutrinos in the decay @xmath55 and these tend to cancel .
and the jet identified as a tau .
the signal from @xmath56 shows two possible masses . the background is also shown . from @xcite .
[ htau ] , width=226 ]
if supersymmetry ( susy ) is relevant to the problems of electroweak symmetry breaking , susy particles will be sufficiently light that the lhc will be a susy factory .
third generation sparticles are particularly interesting as they carry information about how supersymmetry is broken . in the case of the first two generations
the mixing between the supersymmetric partners of the left and right handed charged leptons is expected to be small .
however the two @xmath57 mass eigenstates are mixtures of @xmath58 and @xmath59 and we need to measure masses and mixings .
the direct production of @xmath57 via electroweak processes such as @xmath60 is small . in many cases many more
@xmath57 s are produced from decays of strongly produced squarks and gluinos via processes such as @xmath61 where @xmath62 and @xmath63 are weak gauginos and the latter is stable and exits the detector contributing to missing @xmath25 .
it is possible that taus may be the only leptons produced in gaugino decay .
leptonic tau decays are of limited use as the origin of the lepton is unknown ; one must search for hadronic tau decays that give rise to characteristic jets .
susy events are expected to be very complex and one can rely on jet and @xmath64 cuts to get rid of standard model background and obtain clean susy sample . this sample can then be studied in detail .
the background to hadronic tau decays then arises from qcd jets in the susy event and a rejection factor of order 10 ( the number of jets in a such an event ) rather than order 100 which is needed in the analysis described in section [ tausec ] .
a particular model is used in the example illustrated here .
( @xcite vol ii p. and @xcite ) .
events are selected as follows : @xmath65 jets , one of which has @xmath66 gev and the rest have @xmath67 gev , there are no isolated electrons or muons with @xmath68 gev and @xmath69 gev .
the jets are examined and `` tau '' candidates extracted by selecting jets with low track multiplicity and invariant mass @xcite using an algorithm based on a study using @xmath5 decays to generate taus in the appropriate kinematic regime .
the invariant mass of observed `` tau '' pairs is then shown in figure [ tautau ] . a clear peak can be seen above the background which is dominated by events where one of the tau jet candidates is a misidentified qcd jet . if all the tau energy had been detected , the distribution would have had a sharp cut - off at @xmath70 which evaluates to 61 gev in this example .
the peak is below this due to the energy carried of by neutrinos in the tau decays .
the situation is rather more complicated than this analysis shows .
the energy distribution of the visible tau decay products depends on the tau polarization and the dependence is largest in the @xmath71 final state and smallest in the states with large hadron multiplicity .
a separation of these states could therefore yield information on the polarization of the taus .
this in turn gives information on the @xmath57 composition .
simulation work on this difficult topic is underway .
99 atlas collaboration , `` atlas physics and detector performance technical design report , '' lhcc 99 - 14/15 .
d. cavalli and b. osculati , atlas physics note atl - phys-2000 - 014 ( 2000 ) k. kodama _ et al .
_ [ fermilab e653 collaboration ] , phys .
b * 303 * , 359 ( 1993 ) .
j. ellis , m. e. gomez , g. k. leontaris , s. lola and d. v. nanopoulos , hep - ph/9911459 .
j. l. feng , y. nir and y. shadmi , phys .
rev . * d61 * , 113005 ( 2000 ) .
j. hisano , t. moroi , k. tobe and m. yamaguchi , phys .
* d53 * , 2442 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9510309 ] . l. serin and r. stroynowski , atlas physics note , atl - phys-97 - 114 ( 1997 ) .
a. djouadi
_ et al . _ ,
arxiv : hep - ph/0002258 .
d. cavalli and s. resconi , atlas physics note , atl - phys-2000 - 005 ( 2000 ) k. a. assamagan , y. coadou and a. deandrea , eur .
j. directc * 9 * , 1 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203121 ] .
i. hinchliffe and f. e. paige , phys .
d * 61 * , 095011 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9907519 ] .
y. coadou _
et al . _ , atlas internal note atl - phys-98 - 126 . | at the lhc , new particles can be expected that decay to final states involving taus .
examples are given from simulations by the atlas experiment showing how such final states can be exploited . |
in a previous work@xcite , we introduced a new formalism where , instead of implementing a dynamical foliation by taking a spatial dependence of the fifth coordinate including its time dependence , we considered another extra dimension , the sixth dimension , making possible the implementation of two dynamical foliations in a sequential manner .
the first one was considered by choosing the fifth coordinate depending of the cosmic time , and the second one by choosing the sixth coordinate as dependent of the 3d spatial coordinates ( in our case considered as isotropic ) .
of course , all of these choices preserve the continuity of the metric .
in addition , the 6d metric must be ricci - flat .
this requirement is a natural extension of the vacuum condition used in the stm theory@xcite , in which 5d ricci - flat metrics are used@xcite and the cylinder condition has been eliminated in favor of retaining the metric s dependence on the extra coordinate . in simple words , we used the campbell - magaard theorem@xcite and its extensions for embedding a 5d ricci - flat space - time in a 6d ricci - flat space - time .
the conditions of 6d ricci - flatness and the continuity of the metric gives us the foliation of the sixth coordinate .
these conditions specify the sixth dimension as a function of the 3d spatial coordinates , in order to establish the foliation .
this function , for a particular 6d metric , can be seen in 4d as a gravitational potential related to a localized compact object that has the characteristics of a white hole . from a more general point of view , this is a mechanism for inducing localized matter onto a time - varying 4d hypersurface by establishing a spatial foliation of a sixth coordinate from a 6d ricci - flat metric .
the importance of this approach lies in that it can describe matter at both , cosmological and astrophysical scales , in an expanding universe .
the use of 6d physics is currently popular in particle physics@xcite , but with the sixth dimension as time - like , rather than space - like .
+ in this letter we aim to study some predictions of this model on astrophysical scales .
the power spectrum of matter is one of the most important statistics to describe the large - scale and astrophysical - scale structures of the universe .
the studies developed in the last years have shown that on astrophysical scales the power spectrum of galaxies and clusters of galaxies can be satisfactorily expressed by a power law with an index between @xmath0 and @xmath1@xcite . on larger scales
the spectrum turns over reaching a maximum on scales of @xmath2 .
we shall suppose that the evolution of structure in the universe is only due to gravity .
in order to describe a 6d vacuum , we consider the recently introduced 6d riemann - flat metric@xcite @xmath3 -d\psi^2 - d\sigma^2\ ] ] which defines a 6d vacuum state @xmath4 ( @xmath5 ) .
we consider the 3d spatial space in spherical coordinates : @xmath6 ; here @xmath7 .
the metric ( [ ini ] ) resembles the 5d ponce de leon one@xcite , but with one additional space - like dimension .
furthermore , the coordinate @xmath8 is dimensionless and the extra ( space - like ) coordinates @xmath9 and @xmath10 are considered as noncompact .
we define a physical vacuum state on the metric ( [ ini ] ) through the action for a scalar field @xmath11 , which is nonminimally coupled to gravity @xmath12,\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the ricci scalar and @xmath14 gives the coupling of @xmath11 with gravity . implementing the coordinate transformation @xmath15 and @xmath16 on the frame @xmath17
( considering @xmath18 as a constant ) , followed by the foliation @xmath19 on the metric ( [ ini ] ) , we obtain the effective 5d metric @xmath20 - d\sigma^2,\ ] ] which is not ricci - flat because @xmath21 .
however , it becomes riemann - flat in the limit @xmath22 i.e. @xmath23 , so that in this limit a 5d vacuum given by @xmath24 , ( @xmath25 ) .
hence , we can take the foliation @xmath26 in the metric ( [ 5d ] ) on the sixth coordinate , and we obtain the effective 4d metric @xmath27,\ ] ] where @xmath28 is the cosmic time , and @xmath29 is the hubble parameter for the scale factor @xmath30 , with @xmath31 .
the einstein equations for the effective 4d metric ( [ 4d ] ) are @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) , where @xmath34 is represented by a perfect fluid : @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 being the pressure and the energy density on the effective 4d metric ( [ 4d ] ) . in a previous work@xcite @xmath38 was found for a puntual mass @xmath39 ( @xmath40 is the planckian mass ) located at @xmath41 , in the absence of expansion ( @xmath42 ) @xmath43 here , @xmath44 is the value of @xmath45 such that @xmath46 and @xmath47 the gravitational constant .
hence , the function @xmath38 describes the geometrical deformation of the metric induced from a 5d flat metric , by a mass @xmath48 .
this function is @xmath49 ( or @xmath50 ) for @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) , respectively .
furthermore , @xmath53 , and thereby the effective 4d metric ( [ 4d ] ) is ( in their 3d ordinary spatial components ) asymptotically flat . in this analysis
we are considering the usual 4-velocities @xmath54 .
the equation of state for a given @xmath45 is@xcite @xmath55 e^{-2 h t } } { \left[h^2 - \frac{2 g m_n}{r^3 } e^{-2 h t}\right ] } , \ ] ] being @xmath56 . from the equation ( [ state ] ) we can see that at the end of inflation , when the number of e - folds is sufficiently large , the second term in ( [ state ] ) becomes negligible on cosmological scales [ on the infrared ( ir ) sector ] , and the equation of state on this sector describes an asymptotic vacuum dominated ( inflationary ) expansion : @xmath57 on the other hand , for @xmath58 , we obtain ( on arbitrary scales ) @xmath59}{\left [ h^2 - \frac{2gm_n}{r^3}\right]},\ ] ] which for a non - expanding universe ( @xmath60 ) gives us , for @xmath51 , the equation of state for primordial galaxies @xmath61 which means that primordial galaxy formation should be possible on scales smaller than @xmath44 .
the effective 4d action for the universe is @xmath62,\ ] ] where @xmath63 is the effective 4d ricci scalar for the effective 4d metric ( [ 4d ] ) , @xmath64 gives the coupling of the scalar field @xmath65 with gravity on the background induced by the foliation of the first extra dimension @xmath9 at @xmath66 and @xmath67 gives the coupling of @xmath11 with gravity , on the background induced by the foliation of the second extra dimension @xmath10 at @xmath68 .
the equation of motion for the field @xmath11 on the metric ( [ 4d ] ) is @xmath69 - \frac{1}{(1 + 2\phi_n(r))^2 } \frac{\partial\phi_n}{\partial r } \frac{\partial \varphi}{\partial r } \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left.+ \frac{1}{r^2 { \rm sin}(\theta ) } \frac{\partial}{\partial\theta } \left[{\rm sin}(\theta ) \frac{\partial\varphi}{\partial\theta}\right ] \right .
\nonumber \\ & & + \left . \frac{1}{r^2 { \rm sin}^2(\theta ) } \frac{\partial^2\varphi}{\partial\phi^2 } \right ] + \left [ \xi_1 \left.^{(4)}{\cal r}\right|_{\phi_n=0 } + \xi^{n , l}_2(r ) \left.^{(4 ) } { \cal r}\right|_{h=0 } e^{-2 h t}\right ] \varphi = 0.\label{5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that under this approach , the expansion is affected by a geometrical deformation induced by the gravitational attraction of a white hole of mass @xmath70 .
this deformation is described by the function @xmath38 , which tends to zero on cosmological scales [ see figure ( [ f1 ] ) ] . in this section
we study the weak field approximation for the equation ( [ 5 ] ) . in that limit approximation
the function @xmath38 in ( [ sphi ] ) can be written as @xmath71 @xmath48 being the mass of the compact object located at @xmath41 .
note that the function ( [ 6 ] ) , as well as the exact one ( [ sphi ] ) , goes to zero at @xmath72 . for @xmath73
there is a stable equilibrium for test particles at @xmath74 and it exhibits a gravitational repulsion ( antigravity ) for @xmath75 .
hence , this object has the properties of a white hole @xcite . in the figure ( [ f1 ] ) we have plotted @xmath38 given by the eqs .
( [ sphi ] ) [ the exact expression plotted with a continuous line ] and ( [ 6 ] ) [ the weak field approximated expression plotted with a pointed line ] , respectively , for @xmath52 .
notice that the difference between both is more important on smaller scales .
furthermore , it is evident that the exact expression of @xmath38 is more sensitive to the interaction . in order to obtain solutions of the equation ( [ 5 ] ) we propose @xmath76 . with this choice and using the fact that [ see the eq .
( 11 ) in @xcite ) ] : @xmath77 , we obtain @xmath78 & + & \left [ 3 g m_n ( 1 + 2\phi_n ) + r\phi_n\right ] \frac{\partial \varphi_r}{\partial r } \nonumber \\ & = & \varphi_r \left [ \frac{12 g m_n}{r } \xi^{n , l}_2(r ) -\alpha_t r^2 + \alpha_r\right ] ( 1 + 2\phi_n ) , \label{1b } \\ { \rm sin}(\theta ) \frac{\partial}{\partial\theta } \left [ { \rm sin}(\theta ) \frac{\partial \varphi_{\theta,\phi } } { \partial\theta}\right ] & + & \frac{1}{{\rm sin}^2(\theta ) } \frac { \partial^2\varphi_{\theta,\phi}}{\partial\phi^2 } = \alpha_r \varphi_{\theta,\phi } , \label{1c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are separation constants .
the solution of the equation ( [ 1c ] ) is given by the spherical harmonics @xmath81 [ @xmath82 @xmath83 where @xmath84 is a separation constant and @xmath85 are the legendre polynomials : @xmath86 ( 1-x^2)^{m/2 } ( d^{l+m}/ dx^{l+m } ) ( x^2 - 1)^l$ ] . in order to study astrophysical implications for the solutions of eqs .
( [ 1a ] ) , ( [ 1b ] ) and ( [ 1c ] ) , we shall concentrate on the dispersive case ( @xmath87 ) for @xmath65 . in this case @xmath88 is the wavenumber related to the coordinate @xmath45 . on the other hand , for solving the equation ( [ 1b ] ) , we propose @xmath89 such that @xmath90 $ ] . with this choice ( [ 1b ] ) can be replaced by the equations @xmath91=0 , \label{3a } \\ & & \frac{d\varphi_{k_r}}{dr } \left[6 g m_n(1 + 2\phi_n ) + 2r\phi_n\right ] + \varphi_{k_r } \left [ r^2 \left(f^2_n - \frac{df_n}{dr}\right ) - 2 r f_n + 2\phi_n \left(k^2_r r^2 - l(l+1)\right ) \right.\nonumber \\ & & - \left .
3 g m_n ( 1 + 2\phi_n ) f_n - r \phi_n f_n - \frac{12 g m_n \xi^{n , l}_2(r)}{r } \left(1 + 2\phi_n \right)\right]=0 . \label{3b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the solution for the equation ( [ 3a ] ) is @xmath92,\ ] ] where @xmath93 are the bessel functions . on the other hand , from the equation ( [ 3b ] )
we obtain the coupling @xmath67 @xmath94 - \left [ r^2\left(f^2_n - \frac{df_n}{dr}\right ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & - & \left.\left .
2 r f_n + 2\phi_n \left[k^2_r r^2 - l(l+1)\right ] -3 g m_n \left ( 1 + 2\phi_n \right ) f_n - r \phi_n f_n\right]\right\ } , \label{coup}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath95 \left[3 g m_n \left(1 + 2\phi_n(r)\right ) + r \phi_n(r)\right]$ ] . the solution of the equation ( [ 1a ] ) for the dispersive case is @xmath96,\ ] ] @xmath97 being a constant , @xmath98 and @xmath99 is the hankel function of second kind .
the complete solution for the field @xmath65 can be written as @xmath100 } { \large\int } d^3 k_r \sum^{l}_{m =- l } \sum^{n-1}_{l=0 } \left [ a_{k_r l m } y_{l , m}(\theta,\phi ) \varphi_{k_r}(r ) \xi_{k_r}(t ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & + & \left .
a^{\dagger}_{k_r l m } y^*_{l , m}(\theta,\phi ) \varphi^*_{k_r}(r ) \xi^*_{k_r}(t)\right ] , \label{var}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 and @xmath102 are given respectively by the expressions ( [ 3c ] ) and ( [ 26 ] ) .
in this section we shall study the structure formation during inflation on astrophysical scales . in the framework of cosmological scales
, we understand that these are small scales , on which one feels the presence of the compact object [ and thus we shall consider @xmath103 .
we must understand the present astrophysical scales ( @xmath104 100 mpc ) .
we shall refer to this part of the spectrum as the small - scale ( ss ) spectrum .
it is known from observation that galaxies and clusters of galaxies are correlated .
this should be responsible for differences in the clustering properties of the populations in the nearby universe .
one population is characteristic for rich superclusters , and the other for poorer ones .
the former population has a power spectrum with a sharp peak and a correlation function with zero crossing near @xmath105 .
the later population has a flatter power spectrum and a zero crossing of the correlation function near @xmath106 .
the effective small - scale squared fluctuations in presence of @xmath107 are given by[see @xcite ] @xmath108 } \int _ { \epsilon k_{h}}^{k_{h}}\frac{dk_{r}}{k_{r}}k_{r}^{3}\left.\left[\xi _ { k_r}\xi % % @ _ { k_r}^{*}\right]\right|_{ir}^{(\phi_n(r)\simeq 0)}\ ] ] where @xmath109 is a dimensionless constant parameter , and @xmath110 is the wavenumber related with the hubble radius at the time @xmath111 ( when the horizon re - enters ) , and @xmath112 is the planckian wavenumber .
the asymptotic expression for the modes on the ir sector is@xcite @xmath113 inserting ( [ modosir ] ) into ( [ sma3 ] ) we obtain @xmath114 } k_{h}^{3 - 2\nu}(1-\epsilon)^{3 - 2\nu}.\ ] ] hence , the expression ( [ sma4 ] ) becomes @xmath115 } \left<\varphi^2\right>_{ir}^{(\phi_n(r)\simeq 0)},\ ] ] where@xcite @xmath116 finally , we can write the power spectrum of @xmath117 , making @xmath118 and @xmath119 @xmath120 } k^{3 - 2\nu}_r.\ ] ] in the figure ( [ f2 ] ) we have plotted the coupling parameter @xmath67 in eq .
( [ coup ] ) on astrophysical scales [ @xmath121 , for @xmath122 , @xmath123 and @xmath124 .
notice that we have used @xmath101 given in eq .
( [ 3c ] ) and @xmath38 given in eq .
( [ 6 ] ) .
it is evident that the coupling parameter becomes more important as @xmath45 increases ( i.e. , for bigger scales ) . in the figure ( [ f3 ] )
we shows the power spectrum @xmath125 as a function of the wavenumber @xmath88 on astrophysical scales .
there are three indices that are important on the whole spectrum .
two of these dominate on astrophysical scales .
the first one for @xmath126 , the second one on the range @xmath127 . the third index @xmath128 dominates on cosmological scales ( @xmath129 ) .
we have used @xmath130 ( which corresponds to @xmath131 ) in all the graphics .
we have studied the power spectrum on astrophysical scales of the @xmath132-expectation value .
the model here studied predicts a spectrum that agrees qualitatively with experimental data@xcite .
an interesting result is that we detect two different sectors with different power indices , which dominate on different astrophysical scales .
the third index is @xmath133 , which is relevant on cosmological scales .
another interesting result is the periodicity of the coupling @xmath67 .
notice that its amplitude increases with @xmath45 .
this coupling should be responsible for the correlation of the galaxies on astrophysical scales . for simplicity , in this letter
we are considered a de sitter expansion , where the hubble parameter @xmath18 is a constant .
however , the formalism could be extended to whatever @xmath134 .
the possibility of having a dynamical foliation using only 5d ( in models without gravitational sources ) , was explored@xcite . in our model the fifth dimension
is responsible for the 4d de sitter expansion , which is physically driven by the inflaton field @xmath11 . from the physical point of view
, the sixth dimension is responsible for the spatial curvature induced by the mass of the white hole ( located at @xmath41 ) . in more general terms
, the fifth dimension is physically related to the vacuum energy density which is the source of the effective 4d global inflationary expansion whereas the sixth one induces local gravitational sources .
99 j. e. madriz aguilar and m. bellini , phys
* b648 * , 19 ( 2007 ) . j. overduin , p. s. wesson , phys .
rept . * 283 * , 303 ( 1997 ) .
p. s. wesson , gen . rel
* 16 * , 193 ( 1984 ) ; p. wesson , gen .
. grav . * 22 * , 707 ( 1990 ) ; p. s. wesson , phys .
* b276 * , 299 ( 1992 ) ; p. s. wesson and j. ponce de leon , j. math . phys .
* 33 * , 3883 ( 1992 ) ; h. liu and p. s. wesson , j. math . phys . * 33 * , 3888 ( 1992 ) ; p. wesson , h. liu and p. lim , phys . lett . *
b298 * , 69 ( 1993 ) .
n. i. katzourakis , _ bundle - theoretical globalization of campbell - magaard embedding theorem in the context of md gravity_. e - print : math - ph/0407067 .
c. romero , r. tavakol , gen .
* 28 * , 365 ( 2007 ) ; s. s. seahra , p. s. wesson , class .
20 * , 1321 ( 2003 ) .
i. bars , yueh - cheng kuo , phys .
lett . * 99 * : 041801 ( 2007 ) .
j. einasto , _ et .
al _ , astroph .
j. * 519 * , 441 ( 1999 ) .
j. ponce de leon , gen .
rel . grav . *
20 * , 539 ( 1988 ) .
r. kallosh , a. linde , phys . rev . *
d52 * , 7137 ( 1995 ) .
review of particle physics : phys .
b592 * , 207 ( 2004 ) .
madriz and m. bellini , eur .
j. * c42 * , 349 - 354 ( 2005 ) . | using a previously introduced model in which the expansion of the universe is driven by a single scalar field subject to gravitational attraction induced by a white hole during the expansion ( from a 6d vacuum state ) , we study the origin of squared inflaton fluctuations spectrum on astrophysical scales . epsf.sty |
the benchmarks for optimal performance of heat engines and refrigerators , under reversible conditions , are the carnot efficiency @xmath4 , and the carnot coefficient of performance @xmath5 respectively , where @xmath6 is the ratio of cold to hot temperatures of the reservoirs . for finite - time models such as in the endoreversible approximation @xcite and the symmetric low - dissipation carnot engines @xcite , the maximum power output is obtained at the so called curzon - ahlborn ( ca ) efficiency , @xmath7 @xcite . however , ca - value is not as universal as @xmath8 . for small temperature differences ,
its lower order terms are obtained within the framework of linear irreversible thermodynamics @xcite .
thus models with tight - coupling fluxes yield @xmath9 as the efficiency at maximum power .
further , if we have a left - right symmetry , then the second - order term @xmath10 is also universal @xcite . on the other hand , the problem of finding universal benchmarks for finite - time refrigerators is non - trivial .
for instance , the rate of refrigeration ( @xmath11 ) , which seems a natural choice for optimization , can not be optimized under the assumption of a newtonian heat flow ( @xmath12 ) between a reservoir and the working medium @xcite . in that case , the maximum rate of refrigeration is obtained as the coefficient of performance ( cop ) @xmath13 vanishes .
so instead , a useful target function @xmath14 has been used @xcite , where @xmath11 is the heat absorbed per unit time by the working substance from the cold bath , or the rate of refrigeration .
the corresponding cop is found to be @xmath15 , for both the endoreversible and the symmetric low - dissipation models .
so this value is usually regarded as the analog of ca - value , applicable to the case of refrigerators . in any case
, the usual benchmarks for optimal performance of thermal machines are decided by recourse to optimization of a chosen target function .
the method also presumes a complete knowledge of the intrinsic energy scales , so that , in principle , these scales can be tuned to achieve the optimal performance . in this letter
, we present a different perspective on this problem .
we consider a situation where we have a limited or partial information about the internal energy scales , so that we have to perform an inference analysis @xcite in order to estimate the performance of the machine .
inference implies arriving at plausible conclusions assuming the truth of the given premises .
thus the objective of inference is not to predict the `` true '' behavior of a physical model but to arrive a rational guess based on incomplete information . in this context
, the role of prior information becomes central . in the spirit of bayesian probability theory ,
we treat all uncertainty probabilistically and assign a prior probability distribution to the uncertain parameters @xcite .
we define an average or expected measure of the performance , using the assigned prior distribution .
the approach was proposed by one of the authors @xcite and has been then applied to different models of heat engines @xcite .
these works show that ca - efficiency can be reproduced as a limiting value when the prior - averaged work or power in a heat cycle is optimized .
in particular , for the problem of maximum work extraction from finite source and sink , the behavior of efficiency at maximum estimate of work shows universal features near equilibrium @xcite , e.g. @xmath16 $ ] .
similarly , other expressions for efficiency at maximum power , such as in irreversible models of stochastic engines @xcite , which obey a different universality near equilibrium , can also be reproduced from the inference based approach @xcite .
however , so far the approach has not been applied to other kinds of thermal machines such as refrigerators .
it is not obvious , beforehand , that the probabilistic approach can be useful in case of refrigerators also .
the purpose of this paper is to extend the prior probability approach by taking the paradigmatic feynman s ratchet and pawl model @xcite .
we show that the prior information infers not only the ca - efficiency @xmath17 in the engine mode , but also the @xmath18 value in the refrigerator mode of the model .
further , we point out that the expected heat flows in the averaged model behave as newtonian flows .
the present paper is organized as follows . in section 2
, we describe the model of feynman s ratchet as heat engine and discuss its optimal configuration . in section 2.1 ,
the approach based on prior information is applied to the case when the efficiency of the engine is fixed , but the internal energy scales are uncertain .
the approach is extended to the refrigerator mode , in section 3 . in section 4 ,
we discuss alternate models where also the use of jeffreys prior leads to emergence of ca efficiency .
finally , section 5 is devoted to discussion of results and conclusions .
the model of feynman s ratchet as a heat engine consists of two heat baths with temperatures @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
a vane , immersed in the hot bath , is connected through an axle with a ratchet in contact with the cold bath , see fig.[fig - ratchet ] .
the rotation of the ratchet is restricted in one direction due to a pawl which in turn is connected to a spring .
the axle passes through the center of a wheel from which hangs a weight .
so the directed motion of the ratchet rotates the wheel , thereby lifting the weight . to raise the pawl
, the system needs @xmath21 amount of energy to overcome the elastic energy of the spring .
suppose that in each step , the wheel rotate an angle @xmath22 and the torque induced by the weight be @xmath23 . then the system requires a minimum of @xmath24 energy to lift the weight .
hence the rate of forward jumps for lifting the weight is given as @xmath25 where @xmath26 is a rate constant and we have set boltzmann s constant @xmath27
. the statistical fluctuations can produce a directed motion at a finite rate , only if the ratchet - pawl system is mesoscopic .
hence the pawl can undergo a brownian motion by bouncing up and down as it is immersed in a finite temperature bath .
this turns the wheel in backward direction and lowers the position of the weight .
this is the reason that the system can not work as an engine if @xmath28 @xcite .
the rate of the backward jumps is @xmath29 thus one can regard @xmath30 and @xmath31 as the work done by and on the system , respectively . in an infinitesimally small time interval @xmath32 , the work done by the system is given as @xmath33 thus the power output of the engine is defined as @xmath34 .
similarly , the rate of heat absorbed from the hot reservoir , is given as @xmath35 or the amount of heat absorbed in the small time interval is @xmath36 .
then the efficiency of the engine is given by @xmath37 the rate at which waste heat is rejected to the cold reservoir is @xmath38 , which follows from the conservation of energy flux .
the power output , optimized with respect to energy scales @xmath39 and @xmath21 @xcite , is given by @xmath40 the corresponding efficiency at maximum power is @xmath41 further , it was discussed in ref .
@xcite that the above expression for efficiency shares some universal properties of efficiency at optimal power found in other finite - time models @xcite .
now we consider a situation where the efficiency of the engine has some pre - specified value @xmath42 , but the energy scales ( @xmath43 ) are not given to us in a priori information .
since @xmath42 is known , the problem is reduced to a single uncertain parameter , due to eq .
( [ efficiency - ratchet ] ) .
one can cast the problem either in terms of @xmath39 or @xmath21 . in terms of the latter , we can write power as @xmath44 analogous to quantification of prior information in bayesian statistics , we assign a prior probability distribution for @xmath21 in some arbitrary , but a finite range of positive values : @xmath45 $ ] .
later we consider an asymptotic range in which the analysis becomes simplified and we observe universal features .
now consider two observers @xmath46 and @xmath47 who respectively assign a prior for @xmath39 and @xmath21 .
taking the simplifying assumption that each observer is in an equivalent state of knowledge , we can write @xcite @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the prior distribution function , taken to be of the same form for each observer . at a fixed known value of efficiency
, it implies that @xmath50 , where the normalization constant , @xmath51^{-1}$ ] .
this is also known as jeffreys prior for a one - dimensional scale parameter @xcite . now the expected value of power , over this prior , is defined to be @xmath52 where @xmath53^{-1}. \label{defc}\ ] ] upon performing the integration , we get @xmath54 now this expected power depends on the extreme values defining the range of the prior .
we chose a finite range in order to define a normalized prior distribution .
otherwise , information on the finite values of these scales is not available . on the other hand , as the range is made arbitrarily large , the average power becomes increasingly small .
thus a comparison between the absolute magnitudes of optimal power ( eq . ( [ maxpower ] ) ) and
the prior - averaged power does not seem fruitful .
however , the expected power is seen to become optimal at a certain value of the given efficiency .
further , universal features are shown by this efficiency in the asymptotic limit .
it also provides a good estimate of the actual values of efficiency at maximum power .
hence , on maximizing @xmath55 with respect to @xmath42 , we get @xmath56 for given values of the limits , we obtained numerical solution for @xmath42 .
as shown in fig .
[ finite - limits - engine ] , the efficiency at maximum expected power versus @xmath57 is plotted , for a given value of the upper limit @xmath58 .
alternately , setting the lower limit @xmath57 as relatively small in magnitude , one can visualise the behaviour of the efficiency with @xmath58 .
interestingly , these solutions show convergence to the ca - value , @xmath2 .
( scaled by @xmath19 ) , while @xmath59 .
the upper and lower curves correspond to @xmath60 and @xmath61 , respectively .
the dashed lines represent corresponding ca values . the efficiency is also plotted versus @xmath58 ( inset ) , assuming @xmath62 . for larger values of @xmath58 ,
the efficiency approaches ca value .
, width=283 ] the convergence to the ca value as observed in fig .
1 , can be argued as follows .
let us assume that the temperature gradient is not very large , i.e. @xmath0 is not close to zero . or in other words , @xmath8 is small compared to unity .
this implies that @xmath42 is also small since it is bounded from above by @xmath8 .
now let us consider the limits which satisfy , @xmath63 and @xmath64 @xcite , referred to as _ asymptotic range _ in the following .
then the condition ( [ deta ] ) simplifies to the form @xmath65 this implies that the efficiency at optimal @xmath66 , approaches the ca value . _
uniform prior _ : on the other hand , maximal ignorance about the likely values of a parameter may be represented by a uniform prior density , @xmath67 .
then the expected power , is given as @xmath68 where @xmath69 .
integrating the above equation , we get @xmath70 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we are interested in the efficiency at maximum expected power ( @xmath71 ) in the asymptotic range . therefore , by putting @xmath72 and then considering the asymptotic limit , we get @xmath73 whose real solution is given by @xmath74 where @xmath75 . these efficiencies
are compared in fig .
[ fig - ratchet - engine ] .
in particular , we note that in the asymptotic range , the efficiency depends only on the ratio of the reservoir temperatures .
further , the use of jeffreys prior gives a closer approximation to the actual behavior of efficiency at optimal performance of the engine . ) ) when a uniform prior is used , also in the asymptotic range .
the dashed curve represents the efficiency at optimal power @xmath76 , eq .
( [ efopt]).,width=302 ] to compare these efficiencies near equilibrium i.e. @xmath8 close to zero , we expand these expressions as taylor series for small values of @xmath8 , @xmath77 \;\ ; ( { \rm eq . ( \ref{efopt } ) } ; \mbox { at optimal power } ) \label{seropt}\\ \eta^*&=&\frac{\eta_c}{2}+\frac{\eta_c^2}{8}+\frac{6 \eta_c^3}{96}+o[\eta_c^4]\ ; \ ; { \rm ( ca\ ; value\ ; from\ ; 1/\epsilon_2 \ ; prior ) } \label{serp } \\ \eta_u&=&\frac{\eta_c}{2}+\frac{\eta_c^2}{16}+\frac{\eta_c^3}{64}+o[\eta_c^4].\;\ ; { \rm ( with\ ; uniform\ ; prior)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the series in eqs .
( [ seropt ] ) and ( [ serp ] ) were obtained in ref .
we note that @xmath9 term in the optimal performance can be faithfully reproduced by the expected power irrespective of the chosen prior .
however , the second order term follows from the use of jeffreys prior .
in this section , we consider the function of feynman s ratchet as a refrigerator @xcite .
it is analogous to bttiker - landauer model @xcite , as discussed in @xcite . by optimizing the target function @xmath78 for feynman s ratchet
, the cop at optimal performance @xmath79 satisfies a transcendental equation @xcite .
the solution can be approximated by an interpolation formula @xmath80 similar to the case of heat engine , we now show using the prior based approach , that cop at optimal performance can be obtained for feynman s ratchet as refrigerator .
the cop for certain values of @xmath39 and @xmath21 is given by @xmath81 .
also the rate of refrigeration is given by @xmath82 in terms of @xmath13 and one of the scales say , @xmath21 , the @xmath1-criterion is given by @xmath83 now we suppose that the cop is fixed at some value @xmath13 , and @xmath21 is uncertain , within the range @xmath45 $ ] .
then jeffreys prior for @xmath21 can be argued , similar to eq .
( [ choice - of - prior ] ) . now we define the expected value of @xmath1 as @xmath84 where @xmath85 is given by eq .
( [ defc ] ) . upon integrating the above equation
, we get @xmath86 as with power output for the engine , the average @xmath87 becomes increasingly small in the asymptotic limit . in the following ,
we focus on cop at maximal @xmath87 , in the asymptotic limit .
so the maximum of @xmath87 with respect to @xmath13 , is evaluated as @xmath88 the numerical solution for @xmath13 versus one of the limits is shown in fig .
[ finite - limits - refri ] .
-criterion is plotted versus @xmath58 ( scaled by @xmath19 ) , while @xmath62 .
the upper and lower curves correspond to @xmath61 and @xmath60 , respectively .
the dashed lines represent corresponding @xmath18 values . for larger values of @xmath58 ,
cop approaches the corresponding @xmath18 . in inset
, cop is plotted versus @xmath57 , when @xmath59 .
the cop approaches @xmath18 as @xmath57 takes smaller values .
, width=302 ] finally , in the asymptotic range , the above expression reduces to @xmath89 so the permissible solution ( @xmath90 ) of the above quadratic equation , which maximizes @xmath87 , is given as @xmath91 _ uniform prior _ : on the other hand , with uniform prior , the expected @xmath1-criterion is given as @xmath92 upon integrating the above equation , we get @xmath93.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now , we want to estimate @xmath94 , the cop at maximum expected @xmath1-criterion in asymptotic range .
hence , by putting @xmath95 and imposing the asymptotic range , we obtain the following equation @xmath96 whose acceptable solution can be finally written in the following form @xmath97 - 1 .
\label{unicop}\ ] ] again , we see that in the asymptotic range , the cop is given only in terms of the ratio of the reservoir temperatures .
we show in fig .
[ fig - fridge ] , a comparison amongst the different expressions for cop at optimized performance versus this ratio . ) is plotted versus @xmath0 .
the solid curve shows the cop at optimal expected performance ( @xmath87 ) when jeffreys prior is assigned and the asymptotic range is applied .
the dashed line represents the interpolation formula for cop corresponding to the optimum @xmath1 value @xcite .
the top , dotted line is the result of uniform prior , again in the asymptotic range .
the inset shows the same three quantities for close - to - equilibrium values of @xmath0.,width=302 ] in near - equilibrium regime , the carnot cop @xmath98 , as well as @xmath18 become large in magnitude .
one can then write the series expansion for @xmath18 relative to @xmath98 as follows : @xmath99.\ ] ] in this case , @xmath94 relative to @xmath98 behaves as follows : @xmath100.\ ] ] according to refs .
@xcite close to equilibrium and upto the leading order , @xmath101 behaves as @xmath102 .
the optimal behavior is thus reproduced by the use of jeffreys prior , but uniform prior is not able to generate this dependence .
similarly , for large temperature differences , @xmath103 , we get the limiting behavior as @xmath104 while @xmath105 .
the interpolation formula at optimal performance , gives @xmath106 @xcite . before closing this section
, we point out that performing the same analysis in terms of @xmath39 as the uncertain scale , we obtain a similar behavior in the asymptotic range of values , and the same figures of merit , @xmath17 and @xmath18 , are obtained with the choice of jeffreys prior .
so far , we have focused on the performance of feynman s ratchet . in the following ,
we wish to point out that the above inference analysis can also be performed on other classes of heat engines / refrigerators @xcite .
the model which we discuss below is a four - step heat cycle performed by a few - level quantum system ( working medium ) .
further , the cycle is accomplished using infinitely slow processes .
the particular cycle is the quantum otto cycle @xcite .
consider a quantum system with hamiltonian @xmath107 , with eigenvalue spectrum of the form @xmath108 . here
@xmath109 is characterised by the energy quantum number and other parameters / constants which remain fixed during the cycle .
we assume there are @xmath110 non - degenerate levels .
the parameter @xmath111 represents an external control , equivalent to applied magnetic field for a spin system .
initially , the system is in thermal state @xmath112 at temperature @xmath19 , where @xmath113 , @xmath114 , and the partition function @xmath115 .
the quantum otto cycle involves the following steps @xcite : \(i ) the system is detached from the hot bath and made to undergo a quantum adiabatic process , in which the external control is slowly changed from the value @xmath111 to @xmath116 . thus the hamiltonian changes from @xmath117 to @xmath118 with eigenvalues @xmath119 . following quantum adiabatic theorem
, the system remains in the instantaneous eigenstate of the hamiltonian and so the occupation probabilities of the levels remain unchanged . for @xmath120 ,
this process is the analogue of an adiabatic expansion .
the work done _ by _ the system in this stage is equal to the change in mean energy @xmath121)$ ] .
the change in energy spectrum is such that the ratio of energy gaps between any two levels before and after the quantum adiabatic process is the same .
this makes it possible to assign temperature to the system along the adiabatic process .
thus after step ( i ) , this temperature is given by @xmath122 .
\(ii ) the system with changed spectrum @xmath123 is brought to thermal state @xmath124 by contact with cold bath at inverse temperature @xmath125 , where @xmath126 and @xmath127 . on average ,
the heat rejected to the bath in this step , is defined as @xmath128 h_2)$ ] .
\(iii ) the system is now detached from the cold bath and made to undergo a second quantum adiabatic process ( compression ) during which the control is reset to value @xmath111 .
work done _ on _ the system in this step is @xmath129)$ ] .
\(iv ) finally , the system is put in contact with the hot bath again .
heat is absorbed by the system in this step , whence it recovers its initial state @xmath130 .
on average , the total work done in one cycle , is calculated to be @xmath131 similarly , heat exchanged with hot bath in step ( iv ) is given by @xmath132 heat exchanged by the system with the cold bath is @xmath133 .
the efficiency of the engine @xmath134 , is given by @xmath135 clearly , this cycle has two internal energy scales and the efficiency is also similar to that of feynman s ratchet , eq .
( [ efficiency - ratchet ] ) .
one can seek an optimal engine configuration , by optimising work output per cycle over the parameters @xmath111 and @xmath116 .
however , unlike the case of feynman s ratchet as engine , a closed - form expression for the efficiency at optimal work seems difficult to obtain here @xcite .
we can formulate a problem of estimation here , for performance of the engine , assuming that the absolute magnitudes of internal scales are not known .
further , we simplify by assuming that the ratio of energy scales , or in other words , the efficiency is specified . in the following ,
we briefly outline the emergence of ca efficiency in this problem .
the following treatment generalizes the analysis of ref .
@xcite .
it is convenient to express @xmath136 , using eq .
( [ eta ] ) . due to analogy with the ratchet problem
, we may take the prior for the uncertain parameter @xmath111 to be jeffreys prior : @xmath137 , where @xmath138^{-1}$ ] . the expected work per cycle for a given @xmath42 , is then given by @xmath139 to perform the integration , we write @xmath140 and integrate by parts .
the result can be written as : @xmath141 thus the average work is evaluated to be @xmath142 , \label{wev}\ ] ] or , which is written briefly as : @xmath143,\ ] ] where @xmath144 and @xmath145 can be easily identified from eq .
( [ wev ] ) .
now we wish to find the efficiency at optimal average work , and so we apply the condition @xmath146 the resulting equation is , in general , a function of @xmath147 and @xmath148 . however , we are interested in the asymptotic limit of large @xmath147 and vanishing @xmath148 . in this limit ,
the dominant term in the sum @xmath149 is given by @xmath150 , where @xmath151 is the ground - state energy .
therefore , @xmath152 .
similarly , in the said limit @xmath153 finally , using the above limiting forms in eq .
( [ wzero ] ) , we obtain : @xmath154 = 0,\ ] ] which implies that the expected work becomes optimal at @xmath155 , or at ca - efficiency .
we observed in feynman s ratchet that for small temperature differences , the figures of merit at optimal values of @xmath66 and @xmath87 , agree with the corresponding expressions at the optimal values of @xmath156 and @xmath1 .
the important conditions which hold in this comparison are , jeffreys prior as the underlying prior and an asymptotic range of values over which the prior is defined .
in contrast , the uniform prior is not able to generate the optimal behavior in the near equilibrium regime .
further we note that for endoreversible models with a newtonian heat flow between a reservoir and the working medium , the efficiency at optimal power is exactly @xmath17 @xcite .
correspondingly , the cop at optimal @xmath1-criterion is given by @xmath18 @xcite .
in this paper , these values are obtained with an inference based approach assuming incomplete information in a mesoscopic model of heat engine .
we have also shown that our analysis applies to a broader class of idealized models of heat engines / refrigerators , driven by quasi - static processes . here
also , ca efficiency emerges from the use of jeffreys prior , under the given conditions of the model .
we conclude with an argument to support as to why our approach yields the familiar results of finite - time thermodynamics . to exemplify , in the case of feynman s ratchet , the asymptotic range has been considered _
after _ we optimized the expected power output ( in case of engine ) over the efficiency .
one may consider these two steps in the opposite order , i.e. take the asymptotic range first and then perform the optimization .
for that we rewrite eq .
( [ q1dot ] ) as follows : @xmath157 and define the expected heat flux as @xmath158 then in the asymptotic range , we obtain the approximate expression as @xmath159,\ ] ] where @xmath85 is as in eq .
( [ defc ] ) . here
we can draw a parallel with newtonian heat flow : @xmath160 $ ] where @xmath161 is an effective temperature .
similarly , the prior - averaged rate of heat rejected to the cold reservoir can be written as @xmath162.\ ] ] here also , we may identify another newtonian heat flow @xmath163 $ ] , with the same effective heat conductance @xmath85 , between an effective temperature @xmath164 and temperature @xmath165 of the cold reservoir .
then it is easily seen that the maximum of expected power @xmath166 , is obtained at ca value .
similarly , one can argue for the emergence of @xmath18 in the case of refrigerator mode , in terms of effective heat flows which are newtonian in nature .
interestingly , the above expressions seem to suggest an analogy between the expected mesoscopic model with limited information , and a finite - time thermodynamic model with newtonian heat flows . if we compare with the endoreversible models @xcite
, then we observe that the assumption of a newtonian heat flow goes together with obtaining ca efficiency at maximum power , and cop @xmath18 at optimum @xmath1-criterion .
we however note that the analogy does not hold in entirety .
the effective temperatures defined above do not have physical counterpart in the ratchet model , although in the endoreversible picture , these denote the temperatures of the working medium while in contact with hot or cold reservoirs .
secondly , the heat conductances need not be equal for the endoreversible model with newtonian heat flows .
further , the intermediate temperatures @xmath167 and @xmath168 as above , are equal in magnitude at the maximum expected power @xmath66 . however , for the endoreversible model , these temperatures are not equal at maximum power @xcite . still , the form of expressions for the rates of heat transfer do provide a certain insight into the emergence of the familiar expressions for figures of merit at optimal expected performance within the prior - averaged approach .
finally , we close with a few observations on future lines of enquiry . it was seen in fig .
1 , that for a specified finite range for the prior , the estimates of efficiency at maximum power are either above , or below the estimates in the asymptotic range . in particular , the estimates are function of the values @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
we obtain universal results , dependent on the ratio of reservoir temperatures , only in the asymptotic range .
further , the smaller values of the upper limit , overestimate the efficiency ( inset in fig .
1 ) whereas the larger values of the lower limit , underestimate the efficiency .
an opposite behavior is seen for the refrigerator mode ( fig .
moreover , this trend for a chosen mode ( engine / refrigerator ) is specific to the choice of the uncertain variable .
thus the trend is reversed , if instead of choosing @xmath21 , we perform the analysis with @xmath39 as the uncertain variable .
this behavior is seen in both the engine as well as the refrigerator mode .
investigation into the relation between inferences derived from the two choices for the uncertain variable , may yield further insight into the behavior of estimated performance and the approach in general .
the point may be appreciated by noting that by specifying a finite - range for the prior we add new information to the probabilistic model . in order that inference may provide a useful and practical guess on the actual performance of the device
, this additional prior information has to be related to some objective features of the model .
these considerations are relevant for further exploring the intriguing relation between the subjective and the objective descriptions of thermodynamic models @xcite .
the authors acknowledge financial support from the department of science and technology , india under the research project no .
sr / s2/cmp-0047/2010(g ) , titled : `` quantum heat engines : work , entropy and information at the nanoscale '' .
y. wang , m. li , z. c. tu , a. c. hernndez , j. m. m. roco , coefficient of performance at maximum figure of merit and its bounds for low - dissipation carnot - like refrigerators , phys .
e 86 ( 2012 ) 011127 .
y. hu , f. wu , y. ma , j. he , j. wang , a. c. hernndez , j. m. m. roco , coefficient of performance for a low - dissipation carnot - like refrigerator with nonadiabatic dissipation , phys .
e 88 ( 2013 ) 062115 . | we estimate the performance of feynman s ratchet at given values of the ratio of cold to hot reservoir temperatures ( @xmath0 ) and the figure of merit ( efficiency in the case of engine and coefficienct of performance in the case of refrigerator ) .
the latter implies that only the ratio of two intrinsic energy scales is known to the observer , but their exact values are completely uncertain .
the prior probability distribution for the uncertain energy parameters is argued to be jeffreys prior .
we define an average measure for performance of the model by averaging , over the prior distribution , the power output ( heat engine ) or the @xmath1-criterion ( refrigerator ) which is the product of rate of heat absorbed from the cold reservoir and the coefficient of performance .
we observe that the figure of merit , at optimal performance close to equilibrium , is reproduced by the prior - averaging procedure .
further , we obtain the well - known expressions of finite - time thermodynamics for the efficiency at optimal power and the coefficient of performance at optimal @xmath1-criterion , given by @xmath2 and @xmath3 respectively . this analogy is explored further and we point out that the expected heat flow from and to the reservoirs , behaves as an effective newtonian flow .
we also show , in a class of quasi - static models of quantum heat engines , how ca efficiency emerges in asymptotic limit with the use of jeffreys prior . |
lattice gases are arguably the simplest models for the simulation of classical physical systems .
these models provide elementary microscopic dynamics whose hydrodynamic limits are , _ inter alia _ , the diffusion equation , burgers equation and the navier stokes equations @xcite .
they also provide a simple arena for the creation of new models of physical phenomena such as multicomponent flow and dynamical geometry @xcite .
lattice gases possess deterministic , stochastic and quantum ( unitary ) formulations .
simulation of quantum systems on quantum computers remains one of the very few applications for which exponential speedup over classical computation is provable .
the quantum lattice gases defined by meyer @xcite and by boghosian and taylor @xcite may be simulated on a quantum computer in exponentially fewer steps than are required on a classical computer and with an exponential reduction in hardware .
these models , together with other approaches by lloyd @xcite and by ortiz and gubernatis @xcite , have made concrete feynman s observation that simulation of quantum systems is hard on classical computers , but easy on quantum computers @xcite .
meyer was led to the definition of the quantum lattice gas by consideration of quantum generalizations of cellular automata ( ca ) .
the simplest possible quantum ca model would be a map in which the updated state of a cell depended linearly on the state of its neighbours and the global evolution rule was unitary .
meyer showed that the only such maps are trivial , namely , the identity map and the left or right shift , possibly multiplied by a phase .
this `` no - go '' theorem proves that there are no nontrivial homogeneous scalar unitary cellular automata @xcite .
quantum cellular automata models may evade this no - go theorem @xcite by having cell values which are not scalar , or by having local update rules which are not linear ( although the global evolution in such models remains quantum mechanical , and therefore linear ) .
non - scalar models sacrifice some simplicity , while the determination of unitarity for nonlinear models is problematic @xcite .
a third possibility exists : we may _ partition _ our cellular automata , dividing our evolution into two substeps , acting on two distinct neighborhoods .
this was the approach taken by meyer @xcite and also by watrous @xcite .
if one of the substeps of the evolution is interpreted as propagation of the cell values to neighboring sites we may identify the partitioned cellular automata with a lattice gas model @xcite .
the dynamics of all lattice gases take place by propagation of particles to neighboring sites on the lattice , followed by a local collision operation . in a stochastic lattice gas which obeys semi - detailed balance ,
the collision step is a doubly - stochastic markov matrix acting on the state of a single lattice site . for a lattice gas with only a single particle moving on the lattice
, the stochastic model reduces to a classical random walk . in the collision step of a quantum lattice - gas model , the state at a site
is acted on by a unitary scattering matrix . just as in the classical case , the one - particle sector of the model possesses an interpretation as a discrete - time discrete - space quantum random walk .
quantum lattice gases are explicitly formulated as discrete models for quantum physics , and so are subject to additional physical constraints . in particular
, the unitary scattering matrix is constrained to be parity invariant .
the quantum lattice gas was shown to yield the continuum propagator for the dirac equation in one dimension @xcite , and also possesses the schroedinger equation as a nonrelativistic continuum limit @xcite .
the quantum random walk has also been studied extensively from a point of view quite different from that of physical modeling .
quantum random walks may provide an alternative route for the development of new quantum algorithms .
such walks have the property that the variance of the walk grows linearly with time , in sharp contrast to classical walks where the variance grows as the square root of time .
this echoes the computational advantage of grover s search algorithm , and indeed unstructured search can be reformulated as a quantum random walk problem .
discrete - time quantum walks have yielded exponential performance improvements in the hitting time on the hypercube , and continuous - time quantum walks have yielded an exponential improvement in the solution of a graph traversal problem . for an overview of the subject of quantum random walks we refer the reader to the review of kempe @xcite .
two things distinguish quantum lattice gases from discrete quantum walks .
firstly , the absence of scalar homogeneous models means that discrete quantum walks must also introduce an extra degree of freedom .
this degree of freedom is interpreted as a `` coin '' state which determines the motion of the walker at the next time step . in the context of the quantum lattice gas this degree of freedom
is interpreted as the spin ( or , in one dimension , helicity ) degree of freedom of the particle .
secondly , the constraint of parity invariance imposed by meyer in one dimension , and discrete rotation invariance imposed by boghosian and taylor in @xmath0-dimensions is infrequently applied to discrete time quantum random walks .
the coin state is commonly updated by the hadamard operation , which is not invariant under parity inversion .
while parity inversion symmetry is a fundamental requirement for models of physics , from the point of view of the computational properties of quantum walks parity invariance is not an obvious requirement .
unitary actions and measurements are the elementary operations allowed on closed quantum systems . however , no quantum system ( excepting , possibly , the entire universe ) is truly closed .
open quantum systems may be treated as subsystems of some larger closed quantum system .
the unitary evolution of the entire closed system induces a ( generally non - unitary ) evolution on the open quantum subsystem .
such operations , which include measurements and unitary actions in their span , are referred to as _ quantum operations _ in the context of quantum information theory @xcite .
the theory of open quantum systems has been developed from the point of view of fundamental physics in the work of feynman and vernon , caldeira and leggett and prokofev and stamp @xcite . in this seminal work
the environment degrees of freedom are included explicitly , and renormalization group arguments are adduced to model the environment as belonging to one of two universality classes : either the environment degrees of freedom are localized ( spin bath ) or delocalized ( oscillator bath ) .
`` random level '' models of the environment have also been studied @xcite . in keeping with the motivation of this issue
we shall leave the fascinating computational properties of both discrete - time and continuous - time quantum random walks aside .
we shall focus instead on the physical interpretation of the classical stochastic lattice gas as a microscopic model for diffusion and of the quantum lattice gas as a microscopic model for a single particle obeying the dirac equation in the continuum limit .
our aim in the present paper will be the construction of a single model capable of capturing both types of behavior in different parameter regimes .
we shall consider decoherence arising from an interaction with an environment coupling only to the particles internal degrees of freedom and not to the particles position degrees of freedom .
such decoherence models are referred to as `` coin '' decoherence in the context of quantum random walks . in general ,
coin decoherence produces a transition from behavior characteristic of a quantum walk in which the standard deviation of the walk grows linearly in time to behavior characteristic of a classical walk in which the standard deviation varies as the square root of time @xcite .
previous decoherence models for quantum walks considered a scattering step which is a unitary action with probability @xmath1 , and a unitary action followed by a projective measurement with probability @xmath2 @xcite .
models in which measurements on the coin yield less than total information have also been considered @xcite .
we begin by considering a decoherence model for quantum lattice gases ( or equivalently , discrete - time quantum random walks ) with an explicitly physical motivation .
we require that the system - environment interaction be fixed and that the interaction preserve the parity invariance of the original lattice gas .
we first describe the unitary lattice - gas dynamics and the extension of such dynamics to the density matrix formalism , necessary for the introduction of quantum operations into such dynamics .
we then introduce the framework of quantum operations , and discuss two types of decoherence models for quantum lattice gases .
we derive the constraints on the unitary operator coupling the system and environment arising from the requirement of parity invariance .
numerical results are presented for one parameterization of the decoherence model , which qualitatively verify the transition from quantum to classical ( _ i.e. _ , diffusive ) behavior in the model .
we close the paper with discussion and some directions for future work .
the state vector formulation of quantum mechanics is inadequate to describe situations in which we have imperfect knowledge of the quantum state .
such perfect knowledge is expressed by the system being in a _ pure state _ , that is , a vector of complex amplitudes whose moduli squared sum to one .
consider the imperfect preparation of a quantum state such that state @xmath3 is prepared with probability @xmath4 , where the ( classical ) probabilities @xmath4 sum to one .
we can not simply represent this by a real linear convex combination of states , as we already have a complex superposition over observable basis states .
we must instead consider a linear real convex combination of the dyads @xmath5 , @xmath6 such a real linear convex combination is called a _
mixed state_. the density matrix is the appropriate tool for simultaneously describing two probabilistic aspects of the theory
one arising from classical uncertainty about the state of the system , and one arising from the fundamental uncertainty arising from quantum superposition .
the time evolution of the density matrix may be obtained by linear extension of the evolution of the pure states .
the time evolution of a pure state is given by @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the unitary evolution operator of the system , and so the time evolution of the density matrix is given by conjugation : @xmath8 : @xmath9 , where dagger indicates the hermitian conjugate .
the hilbert space of a quantum system which can be divided into two subsystems @xmath10 and @xmath11 possesses a basis which can be tensor factored such that each basis vector @xmath12 can be expressed as a tensor product @xmath13 , such that @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
the reduced density matrix of subsystem @xmath10 is obtained by taking the partial trace of the full density matrix over subsystem @xmath11 .
we may now define a quantum operation on the density matrix of system @xmath10 .
we take the tensor product of the density matrix of the system @xmath10 with that of the environment @xmath11 .
a unitary operation @xmath16 acts on the resulting density matrix by conjugation .
the environmental subsystem @xmath11 is then traced over , resulting in a new density matrix for the system @xmath10 .
such quantum operations are therefore maps from density matrices to density matrices . such maps may be constructed without reference to an environment state by invoking the operator - sum representation .
the theory of such maps may also be formulated axiomatically without reference to the constructive procedure adduced here @xcite . in the present paper
we utilize the unitary representation of quantum operations given above , while noting that a formulation of the noise model we shall construct in terms of the operator - sum representation is possible , and in fact may be a more convenient representation of the model .
in the present paper we restrict attention to one dimensional lattice gases with two directions per site .
the ( classical ) particle states are specified as follows : each site on the lattice has two lattice vectors connecting it to its left and right neighbors .
there may be at most one particle per site per vector .
the dynamics of all lattice gases take place in two substeps .
first , the particles propagate along their vectors to neighboring sites , retaining their velocity as they do so .
second , the particles at each site undergo a collision changing the occupations of the vectors at each site .
the propagation step clearly conserves any quantity that is obtained by summing a function of particle mass and velocity over all particles , since those quantities are not changed as particles propagate .
the collision step is required to conserve a subset of these quantities that are of physical interest , such as mass , momentum , etc . in the following
we shall consider models which conserve particle number only ; if we regard the particles as each having unit mass , this may be thought of as conservation of mass . for a one dimensional lattice with two vectors per site , the only deterministic rules which preserve particle number are trivial .
the first nontrivial model occurs when one considers a stochastic collision in which a single particle at a site has probability @xmath1 to reverse direction .
the stochastic lattice gas with a single particle may be identified with a random walk .
generalizing to multiple particles we find the evolution of the single particle distribution function for a classical stochastic lattice gas obeys the diffusion equation .
the stochastic models include the ( trivial ) deterministic models as the special case @xmath17 .
the single timestep evolution operator @xmath8 of the quantum lattice gas without decoherence is the composition of advection and scattering steps : @xmath18 where the scattering matrix may be parameterized up to a global phase as : @xmath19 and the hilbert space is @xmath20 dimensional , where @xmath21 is the lattice size .
this quantum lattice gas was shown to yield the continuum propagator for the dirac equation for a particle with mass @xmath22 in @xcite .
the model may also be interpreted as a discrete - space discrete - time quantum random walk , subject to the constraint that the scattering rule be parity invariant .
we generalize the above model by first extending the dynamics to those of the density matrix for the lattice gas .
this allows us to handle the mixed states which will arise when we introduce decoherence into the dynamics .
we couple the particles internal degrees of freedom to a bath of arbitrary size and act on the internal degrees of freedom and the bath with a unitary matrix which is the product : @xmath23,\ ] ] where @xmath24 is the identity operator on the bath .
we then trace over the environment degrees of freedom at each timestep .
this decoherence model corresponds to a generalization of the quantum lattice gas to the case where the collision operator is neither a unitary operator , nor a classical markov matrix as in the stochastic classical lattice gas , but a quantum operation .
the set of quantum operations contains both unitary actions and markov actions as special cases .
the unitary operator is clearly included as a special case when one considers @xmath25 which do not couple the system and the environment ( _ i.e. _ , which tensor factor into @xmath26 ) .
it is clear that the markov operations of the classical stochastic lattice gas are included when one considers an initialization of the density matrix of the lattice gas in a completely classical state that is , a density matrix at each site with only diagonal entries , @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
the action of the unitary part of the collision operator on this matrix is : @xmath29 this reproduces the action of a classical markov matrix on the vector of probabilities @xmath30 , where the probability that the particle continues in its current state is @xmath31 if the interaction with the environment induces the map : @xmath32 we can construct this mapping by coupling the system to a two - dimensional environment in the completely mixed state @xmath33 using the controlled - not gate where the system is the control qubit . more generally , the map given in eq .
( [ eq : measure ] ) is the effect of a measurement on the system , and such actions are included in the set of quantum operations .
the correspondence of unitary operations combined with measurements as equivalent to markov operations is also discussed in the context of type - ii quantum computing in @xcite . in order to complete the demonstration that classical stochastic lattice gases are included as a subset of models described by a density matrix
whose collision process is a quantum operation , we must show that a classical ( _ i.e. _ , diagonal ) density matrix evolves to another classical density matrix under propagation .
the classical density matrix is non - zero only in entries @xmath34 , which evolve under propagation to @xmath35 .
diagonal density matrices evolve to diagonal density matrices under propagation and a subset of collision operations evolving diagonal density matrices to diagonal density matrices are equivalent to the markov matices implementing collisions of a classical stochastic lattice gas .
hence a single - particle quantum lattice - gas simulation in which the entire density matrix is stored and in which the collision rule is a quantum operation includes as special cases quantum lattice - gas evolution and the stochastic evolution of a classical lattice gas .
deterministic classical lattice gases are included as they are a special case of stochastic lattice gases .
such a model therefore provides a bridge between the quantum lattice gas which possesses the dirac equation as a continuum limit and classical stochastic lattice gases which possess the diffusion equation as a continuum limit .
we now define the set of quantum operations giving our new scattering rule .
specification of a set of quantum operations defines a `` quantum noise '' model .
such a model has two ingredients : a model for the environment state and a model for the system - environment interaction . before specifying the environment state
we must specify how many dimensions the environment hilbert space must have . here
we may invoke a theorem which states that for a @xmath0-dimensional system hilbert space a @xmath36-dimensional environment is sufficient to produce every possible quantum operation on the system .
this theorem states that for a quantum operation specified by a set of principal components in the operator - sum representation it is always possible to find a unitary operator coupling a @xmath36-dimensional environment to a @xmath0-dimensional system which reproduces this quantum operation @xcite .
this suggests the following noise model : we initialize the four - dimensional environment in a fiducial state ( @xmath37 for example ) .
we then sample from a distribution over the unitary group @xmath38 and apply our sampled operator to the eight - dimensional system - environment pair , and then we trace over the environment .
such a model samples from the entire set of quantum operations .
the preparation of the environment in a fiducial state does not imply a loss of generality , as the sampled operation can be considered to be first an operator acting only on the environment preparing a random environment state , followed by an operation coupling the system and environment .
the distribution over the set of quantum operations is induced in a nontrivial way by the distribution over @xmath38 .
such a model would resemble a random level , or random matrix model , of the environment @xcite . on the other hand , our aim is the construction of a noise model with physically inspired constraints on the system - environment interaction . for such physically motivated noise models we wish the system - environment coupling matrix to be a constant unitary operator , arising from a putative fixed system - environment interaction hamiltonian ( which we may or may not know ) .
if we regard our quantum lattice gas as a discrete model for the dirac equation , we note that the interaction of the helicity degree of freedom of a dirac particle with an environment is indeed fixed by fundamental physics .
we must take care about the meaning of the theorem invoked above for noise models with a constant system - environment interaction .
the theorem does not state that a fixed unitary operator coupling a @xmath36-dimensional environment to a @xmath0-dimensional system can reproduce every quantum operation on the system . in the sequel
we construct our noise model for an environment of arbitrary dimension , although we revert to a four - dimensional environment for reasons of computational tractability for simulations .
equation ( [ eq : meyercoll ] ) gives an explicit parameterization of all parity - preserving two - dimensional unitary operators , up to a global phase .
such convenient parameterizations of quantum operations do not yet exist , and so we follow the explicit constructive procedure for such operations given above .
we choose a model for the environment such that its state is a unimodular complex vector whose cartesian components are independent random variables .
the environment - system interaction is fixed , and we consider a wide class of such interactions , namely those which preserve the parity invariance of the original unitary quantum lattice gas .
the unitary update @xmath39 obeys parity invariance @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the parity exchange operator .
the parity preserving couplings @xmath42 have the property that they commute with the parity exchange operator acting on the system tensored with the identity operator acting on the environment . @xmath43=0\ ] ] eq .
( [ eq : timeevolsym ] ) expresses a discrete symmetry of a discrete - time evolution operator . in physics we are more usually concerned with continuous symmetries and continuous time evolution operators .
the usual statement of invariance of an interaction hamiltonian under a particular symmetry transformation is that the infinitesimal generators of the symmetry transformation commute with the hamiltonian . in the language of lie groups
this means that the hamiltonian lies in the commutator subalgebra of the generators of the symmetry transformation in the lie algebra of @xmath44 , where @xmath21 is the number of degrees of freedom of our system .
we may also apply these ideas to a discrete symmetry of a discrete - time discrete - space model .
let @xmath45 be the lie algebra element corresponding to @xmath46 .
let @xmath47 be the lie algebra element corresponding to @xmath8 .
a sufficient condition that eq .
( [ eq : timeevolsym ] ) holds is : @xmath48=0.\ ] ] the lie algebra of @xmath44 is the set of anti - hermitian matrices .
we use the basis arising from the root system of the lie algebra of @xmath44 @xcite : @xmath49[eq : lab ] where @xmath50 is the kronecker delta , and there is no sum on repeated indices .
we note that @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
the convention for the antisymmetric matrices is chosen so that the labelling superscripts increase from left to right , and so that the negative entry is always in the upper triangular portion of the matrix .
the commutation relations of the lie algebra follow from [ eq : lab ] : @xmath53 _ { kl}&=0\hspace{1 cm } 1\leq p\leq n\\ [ d^r , s^{qp}]_{kl}&=\delta_{pr}a^{qr}+\delta_{rq}a^{pr}\\ [ d^r , a^{qp}]_{kl}&=\delta_{rp}s^{rq}-\delta_{rq}s^{rp}\\ [ s^{rs},a^{qp}]_{kl}&=\delta_{sp}s^{rq}-\delta_{sq}s^{rp}+\delta_{rp}s^{sq}-\delta_{rq}s^{sp}\\ [ s^{rs},s^{qp}]_{kl}&=\delta_{ps}a^{qr}+\delta_{qs}a^{pr}+\delta_{pr}a^{qs}+\delta_{qr}a^{ps}\\ [ a^{rs},a^{qp}]_{kl}&=\delta_{ps}a^{qr}+\delta_{qs}a^{pr}+\delta_{pr}a^{qs}+\delta_{qr}a^{ps } \end{split}\ ] ] the block diagonal form of @xmath46 makes it straightforward to diagonalize , and it is therefore straightforward to obtain the lie algebra element @xmath45 .
@xmath54 a general element @xmath47 of the lie algebra may be written : @xmath55\ ] ] where @xmath56 and @xmath57 , and @xmath58 .
the commutator is then @xmath59&=\frac{\pi}{2}\left[\sum_{s=1}^n d^s- \sum_{s=1}^{n/2}s^{(2s-1)2s } , \sum_{r=1}^{n}\alpha_rd^r + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{p=1}^n\sum_{q=1}^n \left[\beta_{qp } s^{qp } + \gamma_{qp } a^{qp}\right]\right]\\ \end{split}\ ] ] applying the structure constants of the lie algebra and using @xmath56 and @xmath57 gives : @xmath59&=-\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s=1}^{n/2}\sum_{p=1}^n\biggl[\beta_{p(2s)}a^{p(2s-1)}+\beta_{p(2s-1)}a^{p(2s)}+\gamma_{p(2s)}s^{(2s-1)p}+\gamma_{p(2s-1)}s^{(2s)p } \biggr]\\ \end{split}\ ] ] the constraint that this be zero imposes a set of constraints on the @xmath60 coefficients and a set of constraints on the @xmath61 coefficients . because the coefficients and the matrices @xmath10 are real , while the matrices @xmath39 are pure imaginary , we may rearrange terms involving the @xmath10 s and @xmath39 s separately to obtain these constraints .
we write @xmath48 = c_\beta + c_\gamma.\ ] ] where @xmath62 and @xmath63 are necessary conditions for @xmath64=0 $ ] .
@xmath65\\ & = -\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}even}^{n}\sum_{p\phantom{=}even}^n\beta_{ps}a^{p(s-1)}-\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}even}^{n}\sum_{p\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\beta_{ps}a^{p(s-1)}\\ & -\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\sum_{p\phantom{=}even}^n\beta_{ps}a^{p(s+1)}-\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\sum_{p\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\beta_{ps}a^{p(s+1)}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] we wish to rearrange terms so that we have a unique set of @xmath10 s whose coefficients we can set to zero in order to obtain our constraints . in the first and fourth terms here
the indices on the @xmath10 s have opposite parity , whereas in the second and third terms the indices have the same parity in each term , but the indices are both odd in the second term and both even in the third term .
this means that the first and fourth terms may be combined by exchanging dummy indices and using the symmetry properties of the @xmath10 s , whereas the second and third terms must be dealt with separately .
denoting term @xmath66 in the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq : cbeta ] ) , @xmath67 , and taking the first and fourth terms : @xmath68 exchanging @xmath2 and @xmath69 in the second term on the right hand side : @xmath70\\ \end{split}\ ] ] using the antisymmetry of the @xmath10 s , we have @xmath71a^{ps}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] now consider the second and third terms in @xmath72 .
the second term is : @xmath73a^{ps}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] the third term is : @xmath74a^{ps}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] these equations give the following set of conditions on the beta coefficients : @xmath75 these constraints are redundant . in fact
a pair of constraints is sufficient to ensure @xmath62 : @xmath76 we now consider @xmath77 .
@xmath78\\ & = -\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}even}^{n}\sum_{p\phantom{=}even}^n\gamma_{p(s-1)}s^{sp}-\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}even}^{n}\sum_{p\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\gamma_{p(s-1)}s^{sp}\\ & -\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\sum_{p\phantom{=}even}^n\gamma_{p(s+1)}s^{sp}-\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\sum_{p\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\gamma_{p(s+1)}s^{sp}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] exchanging dummy indices in the third term , expanding the first and fourth terms , and utilizing the symmetry of the @xmath39 s and the antisymmetry of the @xmath61 s gives : @xmath79s^{sp}\\ & -\frac{\pi}{2}\sum_{s\phantom{=}even}^{n}\sum_{s\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\left[\gamma_{p(s-1)}-\gamma_{(p+1)s}\right]s^{sp}\\ & -\frac{\pi}{4}\sum_{s\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\sum_{p\phantom{=}odd}^{n-1}\left[\gamma_{p(s+1)}+\gamma_{s(p+1)}\right]s^{sp}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] this yields the constraints on the @xmath61 s : @xmath80
simulations were performed for a system whose internal degree of freedom is coupled to a four - dimensional bath . the coupling operator is therefore an element of @xmath38 .
the general form of an element of the lie algebra of @xmath38 obeying the constraints derived above is @xmath81 in all cases the system was initialized in a pure state corresponding to a gaussian spatial wavefunction centred at the origin with a standard deviation equal to one quarter of the lattice size , with equal amplitudes for both internal states of the particle .
the system was a periodic lattice with @xmath82 sites , and the parameter @xmath83 in the unitary part of the collision operator was set equal to @xmath84 .
three types of simulations were performed .
first , a simulation of the density matrix of the system and bath was performed in which the coupling matrix was the identity operator . in this case
the quantum lattice gas reproduces the unitary evolution expected in the case that the system - bath coupling is zero .
second , simulations were performed in which the system - bath coupling operator is the fourier transform over the cyclic group @xmath85 .
finally , simulations were performed in which all coefficients @xmath86 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 in a matrix of the form ( [ eq : sym ] ) were set equal to one and the resulting matrix numerically exponentiated to obtain a parity - preserving coupling .
the simulation with no system - bath coupling shows typical unitary evolution on a cycle , with the wave - packet dispersing until the edges of the wave - packet reach the periodic boundaries of the system , at which time interference occurs between the original packet and the reentrant components .
the reversibility and unitarity of the dynamics is apparent as the system never settles into a static equilibrium state .
the simulations in which the system - bath coupling is given by the fourier transform , which violates parity invariance , exhibit a driving of the system to the right .
additional simulations in which the coupling is given by the conjugate of the fourier transform with the parity inversion operator show the same driving effect in the opposite direction , as expected . simulations in which the system is coupled to the bath by our example parity - invariant unitary matrix show no driving effect .
the system undergoes an irreversible evolution of the initial probability distribution to the uniform distribution on the cycle .
the behavior of the model shows its intermediate quantum - classical nature in two ways .
first , the decay of the probability distribution shows some residual `` wave - like '' behavior in addition to the overall damping .
second , the final density matrix is not a completely mixed state , but retains non - zero off - diagonal components within a finite band . both these effects indicate that the coupling matrix chosen implements a coupling strong enough to cause irreversible dynamics on an observable timescale but weak enough that the dynamics retains some interesting quantum characteristics . coupling the system to the bath .
right : evolution with a parity - invariant coupling between system and bath.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] coupling the system to the bath .
right : evolution with a parity - invariant coupling between system and bath.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ] coupling the system to the bath .
right : evolution with a parity - invariant coupling between system and bath.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=30.0% ]
we have defined a new quantum lattice - gas model for a single particle ( or equivalently , a discrete - space discrete - time quantum random walk ) in which the scattering rule is given by a quantum operation , rather than a unitary , deterministic , or stochastic operation .
we showed that the model so defined includes unitary , stochastic and deterministic models as special cases , as well as interesting intermediate behavior .
preliminary simulation results confirm this by exhibiting non - unitary diffusive decay of an initial gaussian pure state . the noise model chosen here utilized a fixed unitary operator coupling a four - dimensional bath to the two - dimensional hilbert space of the internal degree of freedom of a single quantum lattice - gas particle .
this distinguishes our work from the noise model given by kendon and sanders @xcite in which a single environment qubit is coupled by an interaction with a strength tunable from the case of no coupling to the case where the environment produced a projective measurement of the coin degree of freedom of the quantum random walk .
as noted above , a two - dimensional environment with a fixed interaction is insufficient to reproduce all quantum operations .
however , the constraints of parity invariance on the coupling operator were obtained here for @xmath44 , and so this work could be extended to include an arbitrarily large environment .
if the most general noise model is desired , the sampling procedure discussed but not implemented above , in which randomly sampled unitary operators couple a four - dimensional bath to the internal degree of freedom of the particle , provably includes all quantum operations .
the parameterization of the noise model then involves a parameterization of the distribution of quantum operations induced by a given distribution on the unitary group .
the above discussion motivates several directions for future work .
first , the noise model presented here is not conveniently parameterized .
ideally we would be able to smoothly vary the degree of coupling between the system and the environment from zero ( where the time evolution would approximate the dirac equation ) to the case where the environment performs projective measurement of the particles internal degrees of freedom .
this property is possessed by the noise model of kendon and sanders @xcite , and such a parameterization of the model presented here is certainly possible , although it may be tedious in practice .
the work of kendon and sanders @xcite discusses decoherence in quantum random walks from the point of view of complementarity .
the work of the present paper was motivated instead by the principle of correspondence .
the generalization here satisfies the requirement that the results agree with classical theory in the case that the particle is strongly coupled to an environment .
the two most natural generalizations of the work described here are to quantum lattice - gas models with multiple particles , and to models defined in multiple dimensions .
the constraint of parity invariance becomes the constraint of invariance under discrete rotations in multiple dimensions , and one expects the constraints analogous to those derived here to be correspondingly more complex .
simulations of multiple particles , even in one dimension , have a classical computational cost which grows exponentially with the number of particles .
however , one expects that few - particle simulations will be tractable .
the possibility of efficient quantum simulation of classical systems is an important open problem in the field of quantum computation for physical modeling .
one of the central problems in this area is that most of the equations of classical physics of practical interest are irreversible macroscopic equations of motion .
the work presented here shows that irreversibility may be simply included by the use of quantum operations instead of unitary matrices .
the emergence of irreversible behavior in the degrees of freedom of the subsystem exhibited here is a manifestation of the `` arrow of time '' of non - equilibrium thermodynamics .
the interesting practical question , which remains open , is whether there are systems for which the time complexity of such classical and quantum simulation is different . more glibly : can time s arrow may be made to move faster on a quantum computer ?
pjl and bmb were supported by darpa quist program administered under afosr grant number f49620 - 01 - 1 - 0566 , and by aro contract number w911nf-04 - 1 - 0334 .
bmb was also supported by afosr award number fa9550 - 04 - 1 - 0176 .
both authors would like to thank afosr for their hospitality at the quantum computation for physical modeling workshop on marthas vineyard in 2004 .
the authors have great pleasure in thanking david meyer , gianluca caterina , howard brandt , and seth lloyd for helpful discussions and questions . | we describe a model for the interaction of the internal ( spin ) degree of freedom of a quantum lattice - gas particle with an environmental bath . we impose the constraints that the particle - bath interaction be fixed , while the state of the bath is random , and that the effect of the particle - bath interaction be parity invariant .
the condition of parity invariance defines a subgroup of the unitary group of actions on the spin degree of freedom and the bath .
we derive a general constraint on the lie algebra of the unitary group which defines this subgroup , and hence guarantees parity invariance of the particle - bath interaction .
we show that generalizing the quantum lattice gas in this way produces a model having both classical and quantum discrete random walks as different limits .
we present preliminary simulation results illustrating the intermediate behavior in the presence of weak quantum noise . |
it is well known that a potential difference @xmath0 is observed on a segment @xmath1 ( with a resistance @xmath2 ) of an asymmetric conventional metal loop @xmath3 ( with a resistance @xmath4 ) when a circular current @xmath5 is induced by the faraday s voltage @xmath6 in this loop . on the other hand
the magnetization measurements give evidence a circular direct current observed in semiconductor [ 1 ] normal metal [ 2 ] and normal state of superconductor [ 3 ] nano - structures in a constant magnetic field , i.e. without the faraday s voltage @xmath7 .
the observed periodical change of the magnetization with magnetic field at the period corresponding to the flux quantum for single electron @xmath8 or pair @xmath9 gives unambiguous evidence that this equilibrium quantum phenomenon , as well as flux quantization in superconductor [ 4 ] , is a consequence of the persistent current @xmath10 existing because of the quantization of the velocity circulation @xmath11 but in contrast to the flux quantization observed as far back as 1961 [ 5 ] the experimental results [ 1 - 3 ] give evidence of the persistent current along the loop with non - zero resistance @xmath12 .
the persistent current at @xmath12 was predicted as far bag as 1970 both in normal state @xmath13 of superconductor [ 6 ] and in non - superconductor mesoscopic structures [ 7 ] .
it was written in [ 7 ] and the later theoretical works [ 8,9 ] have corroborated that the persistent current can be observed at electron scattering ( at a finite mean free path @xmath14 ) , i.e. at non - zero dissipation .
thus , the persistent current can be observed at non - zero dissipation like conventional circular current .
nevertheless most experts are fully confident that a potential difference @xmath15 can not be observed on a segment @xmath1 when the persistent current @xmath10 is observed along the asymmetric mesoscopic loop with non - homogeneous dissipation @xmath16 along its circumference @xmath3 .
the observation [ 10 ] of the quantum oscillation of the dc voltage @xmath17 on a system of aluminum loops in the temperature region corresponding to the superconducting resistive transition , i.e. at @xmath12 , call this confidence in question . the superconducting resistive transition of the nano - structure containing 1050 asymmetric aluminum loops with diameter @xmath18 written at the measuring current with different values @xmath19 .
the inset shows the quantum oscillation of the dc voltage @xmath20 induced by the external as current with the frequency @xmath21 and the amplitude @xmath22 at the temperature @xmath23 corresponding to superconducting state of this nano - structure . ]
the persistent current observed in normal state of superconductor and non - superconductor ( semiconductor and normal metal ) has seminar nature and the theorists demonstrate this likeness .
kulik made the theory of the persistent current in non - superconductor nano - structure [ 7 ] just after the work [ 6 ] on this phenomenon in normal state of superconductor and in twenty years f. von oppen and e. k. riedel have calculated the flux - periodic persistent current in mesoscopic superconducting rings close to @xmath24 [ 11 ] after the calculation of the disorder - averaged persistent current for a non - superconductor mesoscopic ring [ 9 ] .
the persistent current can be observed in a loop when the wave function of electron or superconducting condensate is closed now and again in this loop .
therefore the persistent current can have an appreciable value only if the mean free path @xmath14 is not smaller than the loop length @xmath3 [ 8,9 ] . in the superconducting state
the mean free path of pairs is infinite @xmath25 and the persistent current has a value @xmath26 much large then in a non - superconductor loop @xmath27 [ 8,9 ] .
although the fermi velocity exceeds the pair velocity @xmath28 determined by the relation ( 1 ) the pair number @xmath29 in any real loop is so great at @xmath30 that @xmath31 . because of the large @xmath32 value
the quantum oscillation of the dc voltage @xmath20 with high amplitude can be observed at @xmath30 , fig.1 .
but because of zero resistance @xmath33 an external ac current with the amplitude @xmath34 exceeding the superconducting critical current @xmath35 should be applied at @xmath30 [ 12 ] .
the little - parks oscillations of the resistance @xmath36 reduced to the one in the normal state @xmath37 measured on two nano - structures containing aluminum loops with diameter @xmath18 ( the upper curve ) and @xmath38 ( the lower curve ) demonstrate the increase of the amplitude of the superconducting transition shift @xmath39 in magnetic field with the loop decrease . ]
such switching between quantum states with different connectivity of the wave function can induce a potential difference @xmath40 on segment of an asymmetric loop [ 14,15 ] .
it is expected that its value in the normal state @xmath13 may be larger than in non - superconductor loop since the @xmath32 value in the first case [ 3 ] is larger than in the second one [ 1,2 ] .
the persistent current @xmath41 increases with the loop length @xmath42 decrease .
but at a too small loop @xmath43 the switching between states with different connectivity of the wave function becomes impossible [ 14 ] because of the critical temperature shift @xmath44 [ 16 ] . here
@xmath45 is the superconductor coherence length at @xmath46 and @xmath47 is the width of the superconducting transition .
our measurements have corroborated the @xmath48 amplitude increase with the @xmath49 loop decrease , fig.2 .
we have found that @xmath50 at the diameter of our aluminum loop @xmath51 .
we intend to present results of the @xmath17 measurements on nano - structures with great number of such loops , fig.3 .
it may be these results will answer on the question on a possibility to observe the like phenomenon in semiconductor and normal metal loops .
an electron micrograph of the nano - structure containing 1080 asymmetric aluminum loops with diameter @xmath38 . ]
this work has been supported by grant of the program `` quantum nanostructures '' of the presidium of ras , grant 08 - 02 - 99042-r - ofi of the russian foundation of basic research and grant `` quantum bit on base of micro- and nano - structures with metal conductivity '' of the program `` technology basis of new computing methods '' of itcs department of ras .
d. mailly , c. chapelier , and a. benoit , _ phys.rev.lett .
_ * 70 * , 2020 ( 1993 ) ; b. reulet et al .
, _ phys . rev.lett._ * 75 * , 124 ( 1995 ) ; w. rabaud et al .
, _ phys . rev.lett._ * 86 * , 3124 ( 2001 ) ; r. deblock et al .
lett . _ * 89 * , 206803 ( 2002 ) ; r. deblock et al .
b _ * 65 * , 075301 ( 2002 ) ; n. a. j. m. kleemans et al . , _ phys
lett . _ * 99 * , 146808 ( 2007 ) . ho - fai cheung , e. k. riedel , and y. gefen _ phys . rev.lett._
* 62 * , 587 ( 1989 ) ; v. ambegaokar and u. eckern _ idid .
_ * 65 * , 381 ( 1990 ) ; ho - fai cheung , y. gefen , e. k. riedel , and wei - heng shih , _ phys . rev .
b _ * 37 * , 6050 ( 1988 ) | the observations of the dc voltage proportional to the persistent current on system of asymmetric superconductor loops at a non - zero resistance raise a question on a nature of this quantum phenomenon and its possibility in semiconductor and normal metal mesoscopic loops . |
precise stellar flux standards are required for the calibration of the james webb space telescope ( jwst ) and for the interpretation of dark energy measures with the supernova ia technique .
cohen et al .
( 1992a ) and , more recently , engelke et al .
( 2010 , epk ) recommend the use of sirius as the primary ir standard , because vega s rapid rotation and dust ring complicate the modeling of its ir flux distribution .
thus , sirius ( @xmath5 cma , hd 48915 , hr 2491 ) was observed by _
hst / stis _ on 2012 oct 7 and 2013 jan 26 .
the hot wd companion , sirius b , is 10 mag fainter at v and contributes @xmath61% of the system flux , even at 1300 ( holberg et al .
1998 , beuermann et al . 2006 ) .
the hst flux system ( bohlin & gordon 2014 ) is based on the flux distribution of nlte model atmospheres for the pure hydrogen white dwarfs ( wds ) gd153 and gd71 and on a nlte metal line - blanketed model of rauch et al .
( 2013 , rwbk ) for g191b2b .
the absolute normalization of each model flux is defined by the stis net signal in electrons / s from each wd relative to the stis net signal for vega at 5557.5 ( 5556 in air ) , where megessier ( 1995 ) found an absolute flux of @xmath7 erg @xmath3 s@xmath4 @xmath8% .
this paper reconciles the megessier visible flux with the msx mid - ir fluxes and derives @xmath2 erg @xmath3 s@xmath4 @xmath9% at 5556 for vega s monochromatic flux .
this 0.6% change to the hst fluxes also brings the extrapolated flux for sirius to within 0.6% of the average msx mid - ir absolute flux measures .
the stis sirius observations and their flux calibration are discussed in section 2 .
section 3 compares the modeled ir spectral energy distribution ( sed ) with the msx absolute flux measurements , while section 4 discusses vega , its dust rings , and the lack of any evidence for variability in the hipparcos data .
stis observations of sirius in the three ccd low dispersion modes g230 lb , g430l , and g750l ( hernandez 2012 ) heavily saturate the full well depth of the ccd detector . however , the excess charge just bleeds into adjacent pixels along the columns perpendicular to the dispersion axis and is not lost at gain = 4 .
gilliland et al .
( 1999 , ggk ) demonstrated that saturated signals on the stis ccd are linear in total charge vs. stellar flux , as long as the extraction region on the image is large enough to include all the charge .
in particular , ggk demonstrated linearity to 0.1% accuracy using 50@xmath10 overexposed images of a star in m67 compared with unsaturated exposures of the same star .
sirius data extraction and calibration proceeded as detailed for similarly saturated observations of vega ( bohlin & gilliland 2004 , bg ) , except that taller extraction heights of 206 , 182 , and 148 pixels are required for g230 lb , g430l , and g750l , respectively , for single 4s exposures with g230 lb and 0.3s for g430l and g750l . for these saturated images ,
the signal level is so high that any signal loss due to charge transfer efficiency ( cte ) effects ( goudfrooij & bohlin 2006 ) is @xmath60.1% .
table 1 is the journal of the sirius observations , while figure [ modcf ] demonstrates both the repeatability of g230 lb observations and the linearity beyond saturation .
the individual sub - exposure times from table 1 are either 0.3s or 4s .
figure [ modcf ] shows the ratio of the six g230 lb observations to their average .
the two 16s exposures with four sub - exposures of 4s repeat to 0.2% and dominate the average spectrum .
the 0.3s exposures average 0.30% higher than the 4s exposures , in agreement with bg , who also found 0.3009s for the nominal 0.3s exposure time .
however , the scatter of @xmath11 means that the 0.30% exposure time increase has less than a 2@xmath12 significance ; and 0.3000s is used for the short exposure time . after extracting the spectra from the images , adjusting the flux to a standard 7-pixel - high aperture ( bohlin 1998 ) , and correcting for sensitivity changes with time using the method of stys et al .
( 2004 ) , corrections to the wavelengths are made for sub - pixel wavelength errors that are obvious in the high s / n saturated spectra .
these shifts range up to 0.79 pixel and are found by cross - correlation of the absorption lines with a model flux distribution .
the stis absolute flux calibration is based on model atmosphere seds for the three primary wds g191b2b , gd153 , and gd71 .
gianninas et al .
( 2011 , g11 ) fit new balmer line observations of these wds with updated nlte , pure - hydrogen models that include improved theoretical calculations of the balmer lines ( tremblay & bergeron 2009 ) .
g11 found @xmath13 and @xmath14 of 60920 k and 7.55 @xmath15 for g191b2b , 40320 k and 7.93 @xmath15 for gd153 , and 33590 k and 7.93 @xmath15 for gd71 .
for g191b2b , rwbk computed line - blanketed nlte models and reported a best fit to the absorption lines in stis and fuse high dispersion spectra of @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
however , a @xmath18 model is within the uncertainty and is more consistent with the stis relative uv flux among the three stars .
in addition , rwbk found @xmath19 from the lyman lines , which corresponds to e(b - v)=0.0005 according to the galactic average @xmath20 of bohlin et al .
( 1978 ) .
new models for the three fundamental primary standards gd71 , gd153 , and g191b2b ( bohlin 2003 ) are calculated with the tbingen nlte model - atmosphere package ( werner et al .
2003 , rauch & deetjen 2003 ) , which includes metal line blanketing for g191b2b but only pure hydrogen for gd153 and gd71 at the g11 @xmath13 and @xmath21 .
the model parameters for the three primary wds appear in table 2 .
their seds are available via calspec and also from the registered virtual observatory service theossa that was created in the framework of the gavo project .
after reddening the g191b2b model by e(b - v)=0.0005 and normalizing relative to the 5556 flux of for vega , these three seds define the stis absolute flux calibration and all observed stis fluxes .
previous to november 2013 , pure hydrogen models calculated with the hubeny nlte code defined the seds of all three stars .
the switch to rauch models results in a wavelength dependent shift of the hst flux scale by @xmath221% in the stis wavelength range . at 8 ,
the worst discrepancy with the spitzer / irac fluxes ( bohlin et al .
2011 ) had been a 4@xmath12 difference of 12% for g191b2b .
the 4% lower flux at 8 for the new g191b2b sed reduces the discrepancy to 8% with less than a 3@xmath12 significance .
the final sirius fluxes adjusted to the new calibration can be found in the calspec database with the file name sirius_stis_001.fits .
included in the file are the estimated systematic uncertainty of 1% and the statistical uncertainties , which determine a s
/ n per pixel that ranges up to 15000 at 4000 - 4100 , where @xmath23 electrons per pixel are extracted from the ccd spectral images .
figure [ siriuscont ] compares the stis flux for sirius to other results , including an @xmath24 resolution , original kurucz model and an update ( kurucz private comm .
all of the illustrated seds have been divided by the same theoretical smooth continuum , as normalized to the stis flux at 68007700 , in order to display the spectral features on an expanded scale .
ratio plots of stis / model have large and distracting , spurious dips and spikes near strong absorption line features because of small mismatches in resolution and tiny wavelength errors
. the ratios of flux / continuum in figure [ siriuscont ] display the nature of the absorption lines , and the irrelevant small mismatches at line centers are often off - scale and can be easily ignored .
longward of 1 , the 2013 kurucz model , normalized to the stis flux in the 68007700 range , is chosen for the composite sirius sed .
many of the weak stis features which are @xmath61% correspond to spectral features in the kurucz model . to define the final composite sirius sed below 1675 ,
an iue spectrum is used after normalization to the stis flux by multiplying by 1.28 .
the highest speed iue trail data used for bright stars often missed the exact slit center , making the absolute flux low ; but see section 3.4 for verification of the 1.28 factor .
the blue curve in figure [ siriuscont ] is from epk , while the cohen et al .
( 1992a ) reference sed is green .
the cohen sed for sirius is part of the cww standard star network ( cohen et al . 1992b , cohen 2007 ) .
the epk curve ( blue ) is more than 10% low at places in the top two panels of figure [ siriuscont ] but differs from the kurucz extrapolation ( red ) by only a few percent in the bottom panel .
the epk fluxes are the zero - point sed from their table 4 , as scaled up by their -1.368 mag for sirius .
below 0.9 , the epk sed is based on the vintage absolute flux for 109 vir from tg et al .
( 1977 ) , as scaled to zero magnitude . between 0.9 and 9 , epk warp nicmos and iso measured flux distributions to match various photometry . from 9.435 , the upward trend of the blue curve in figure [ siriuscont ] reflects the epk smooth adjustment of the cww model to closely track the msx absolute fluxes of price et al .
( 2004 , ppem ) .
the normalized kurucz model ( red ) agrees with the observed stis flux ( black ) to better than @xmath251% over most of the wavelength range in the middle panel of figure [ siriuscont ] .
the original 1993 specially tailored kurucz model agrees with his 2013 update to @xmath61% longward of 1800 ; and at shorter wavelengths , the update fits the observed flux significantly better .
this precise agreement of stis and model suggests that the modeled flux could represent the true stellar flux with a similar accuracy of @xmath251% longward of 1 .
absolute ir flux measurements with direct reference to laboratory standards were pioneered from the ground by selby et al .
( 1983 ) , blackwell et al . (
1983 ) , mountain et al .
( 1985 ) , and booth et al .
. from space where the atmosphere does not cause complications , the spirit iii instrument on the midcourse space experiment ( msx ) provided pedigreed absolute mid - ir fluxes from emissive reference spheres ( ers ) that were ejected and observed as point sources with fluxes based on lab data and basic physics .
preliminary msx results appear in cohen et al .
( 2001 ) , while ppem present a definitive final analysis . in their table 9 , ppem compare their new ers based absolute fluxes to the ensemble average of a subset of the cww network of standards .
however , the uncertainties for each of the 4 msx bands in that table 9 seem to be the internal statistical precision to which the msx flux scale can be related to the cww average scale . for the final msx external uncertainties of the absolute flux measures , the 1.4% from the ppem abstract is most appropriate .
larger uncertainties of 34% are quoted for the calculated ers fluxes ; but those values are reduced by an analysis of the band - to - band flux ratios , which constrain the sphere temperature .
a minimum error bar arises from the two uncertainties of 2% attributed to @xmath261% in the sphere radii and @xmath261% in the distance to the ejected spheres . if each of the 5 ers ejection events are independent , eg . the 1% radius error is random and not the same for all 5 released spheres , then the error - in - the - mean floor for each band is @xmath27 , which is consistent with the adopted 1.4% in table 3 .
in addition to the systematic corrections to the global cww flux scale , the cww flux for sirius itself was found to be offset by 1% low compared to the ensemble set of cww program stars .
table 3 summarizes these results and includes the correction factors and final msx in - band , effective fluxes ( irradiance ) for sirius , where the negative corrections mean that the cww flux is low and must be increased by the tabulated factors to agree with the msx results .
the fluxes in column 5 of table 3 are the integral fluxes over the bandpass from table 2 of ppem divided by the table 1 bandwidth of cohen et al .
( 2001 ) times the correction in column 4 of table 3 . multiplying this total cww correction factor by the column 7 ratio of the green cww to the red curve adopted for the ir extension of the hst / stis fluxes in figure [ siriuscont
] produces the ratio of msx to the adopted ir flux . these ratios of msx to hst / stis are tabulated in the final column ( 8) of table 3 and are plotted with their 2@xmath12 error bars of 2.8% as the filled circles at the msx isophotal wavelengths in figure [ siriuscont ] . to normalize the kurucz model to the msx lab based absolute flux calibration , the illustrated normalization that is based on the 5556 vega flux of megessier ( 1995 ) would be multiplied by the average of the four factors in the final column of table 3 . however to properly weight the visible and mid - ir absolute fluxes , a weighted average correction of @xmath28% includes the 5556 normalization at unit value @xmath29% with a @xmath30 weight along with the four ir corrections with their @xmath31 weights .
equivalently , to establish a new hst flux scale that is based on vega at 5556 , the megessier value should be multiplied by 0.9945 .
a revised , msx weighted value of @xmath32% is adopted .
( coincidentally , this new value is the same as recommended by hayes ( 1985 ) . )
the most significant deviation among the five absolute flux measures is for the msx a band , where the 0.976 offset from table 3 is improved by the 0.9945 factor to 0.982 , i.e. a deviation from unity by 1.8/1.4 = 1.3@xmath12 .
the revised absolute normalization is within the uncertainty expectations of all five absolute flux measures from the visible to the mid - ir .
while the sirius flux is difficult to model in detail in the far - uv , where the line - blanketing is severe , other modeling efforts reproduce the visible ir shape .
figure [ lnmzcont ] compares the best efforts of linnell et al .
( 2013 and private comm . ) and of mszros et al .
( 2012 and private comm . ) to the stis fluxes by dividing by the same kurucz continuum level as in figure [ siriuscont ] .
the linnell model shown in figure [ lnmzcont ] is slightly improved over the on - line sed .
the small differences between the kurucz and mszros models are probably due to different solar abundances and different updates to the synthesis code .
mszros uses the asplund et al .
( 2005 ) abundances and the f. castelli version of the synthesis code , while linnell uses the i. hubeny line list and synspec .
the modeling of the sirius ir sed is robust with all three independent models agreeing to better than @xmath261% , which increases confidence that the adopted sirius ir flux is accurate to 1% .
figure [ solsticecont ] shows that the absolute uv flux of sirius that is defined by iue and stis is confirmed by the independent lab based calibration of snow et al .
( 2013 ) for the solstice fluxes ( green ) over their 13003000 range .
these two measured absolute flux levels agree to @xmath253% , as expected from the solstice / stis comparison for three stars in bohlin & gordon ( 2014 ) .
the structure of the spectral features in the stis data ( black ) at r@xmath25500 often matches the kurucz r=500 resolution model ( red ) longward of 1675 .
the r@xmath25250 iue data ( black ) below 1675 and the r@xmath25100 solstice seds also nicely track the flux level of the model , but the spectral structure is smoother than the r=500 model .
in general , the observed spectral structure is remarkably well reproduced by the theoretical modeling , even with the heavy uv line - blanketing .
once sirius is established as a primary flux standard , the flux of any other star is determined by just the brightness relative to sirius .
these signal ratios are free of errors in instrumental flux calibrations .
for example , the ratio of vega to sirius is available for a few ir missions ; and the total flux of vega on the hst absolute flux scale is this ratio times the well - modeled flux of the primary ir standard , sirius .
vega is a pole - on rapid rotator ( peterson et al .
2006 ) requiring a model with temperature zones in the 790010150 k range ( aufdenberg et al .
however longward of 4000 , a single temperature kurucz model at 9400 k fits the stis sed to 1% , as discussed by bohlin ( 2007 ) . after subtracting this calspec kurucz model for the vega photospheric flux ( @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35=-0.5 $ ] , bohlin 2007 ) ,
the remainder is the emission from the dust rings surrounding vega , as shown in figure [ vegadust ] .
the photospheric kurucz model that fits the stis flux for vega is the dotted line , which decreases steeply to less than the total dust emission beyond @xmath2540
. the measured ratios of vega / sirius include the four broadband msx points of ppem ( @xmath10 ) , i.e. the vega flux from their table 3 divided by the sirius flux from their table 2 .
the open circles in figure [ vegadust ] are from the irac ratios ( marengo et al .
2009 ) with their 1% error bars .
the dirbe data are from the electronic version of table 1 in smith et al .
( 2004 ) , while neugebauer et al .
( 1984 ) review the iras data .
three of the six dirbe values ( squares ) in figure [ vegadust ] are low at 3.5 , 12 , and 60 , even after correcting sirius by 0.014 mag for other stars in the 42 arcmin dirbe beam ( su et al .
2013 , hereafter su ) .
the 3.5 and 12 points are offscale in figure [ vegadust ] , while the three dirbe measures at 2.2 , 4.9 , and 25 nicely track the other experimental results .
the error bars on the dirbe points are the rms scatter divided by the square root of the number of observations ( n ) ; however , there is another quoted dirbe uncertainty @xmath36 due to background fluctuations .
what is not clear is whether or not @xmath36 should be reduced by @xmath37 to get total dirbe uncertainties .
the illustrated error bars for dirbe , irac , msx , and iras all include a 1% uncertainty for the sirius flux combined in quadrature with the instrumental rms scatter . using interferometric techniques in the k band at 2.1 , absil et al .
( 2013 ) measure a 1.26@xmath38% dust contribution with respect to the vega photosphere .
similarly , defrre et al .
( 2011 ) find a 1.23@xmath39% contribution from small grains at the h band .
these interferometric results are the filled black circles in figure [ vegadust ] and are independent of the sirius sed .
su models the dust with three rings at different temperatures : an inner hot ring of radius @xmath40 at 2400 k , a warm 170 k ring at 23 , and a cold 50 k ring peaked at 1114 .
for the data analyzed here , a 270 k blackbody fits the warm component better than the 170 k of su , while 62 k is used for the cold dust .
planck blackbody curves for the three temperatures are normalized to the observed fluxes in figure [ vegadust ] .
following su , the three blackbody curves are truncated longward of the peak with a steep @xmath41 decline , where x=2.8 , 2.5 , and 2.9 , instead of the x=2 for the rayleigh jeans slope .
the total emission from all three blackbody curves ( black curve ) falls within @xmath42 of the observational data , except for a @xmath43 deviation for the msx 14.65 point and for the two offscale and the 60 dirbe points .
the normalization of the three dust components is summarized in table 4 and includes the ratio of the peak dust emission to photosphere in the final column .
the sum of dust emission plus photosphere could be used as a standard star sed in the ir with a @xmath251% photospheric uncertainty plus the tabulated uncertainty in the dust contribution .
however , this total ir vega flux is dependent on the observational aperture size , which compromises its practical utility as a standard star longward of 1 .
the kurucz special photospheric models that do not include the dust contributions are in the calspec database as alpha_lyr_mod_001.fits ( @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35=-0.5 $ ] ) and sirius_mod_001.fits ( @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath35=+0.4 $ ] ) .
epk reported that the _ hipparcos _ photometry @xmath46 ( van leeuwen et al .
1997 ) shows that vega is a variable star .
those data are reviewed here with the conclusion that this apparent variability is most likely caused by saturation of the pulse counting electronics in the image dissector photomultiplier tube .
for the brightest stars , figure [ hiplin ] shows increasing differences between @xmath46 and the v mag ( johnson et al .
1966 ) for a and f stars . for example , @xmath46 for sirius is @xmath250.37 mag too faint , while for stars fainter than v=1 , the two magnitude measures are equal within @xmath250.02 . for vega , the _ hipparcos _
0.087 mag is 0.06 fainter than the standard johnson value of v=0.03 .
figure [ hipvari ] shows that the exact effect of the pulse pileup is sensitive to environmental conditions , eg .
temperature , as the electronics attempt to discriminate between coincident pulses .
thus , the recorded count rate fluctuates the most for the brightest star , sirius , where the rms scatter of the 160 separate measures is 0.051 mag . for vega after removing a spurious 2.29 value , the rms of the remaining 102 values is 0.014 mag , i.e. considerably above the typical 0.0040.005 mag rms of fainter stars , where the @xmath46 photometry becomes linear .
epk state that
while the discrepant magnitude for vega `` ... might be attributed to saturation effects , other , brighter stars do not show such discrepancies between v and @xmath46 .
hence , we conclude that the faintness of vega can not be attributed to non - linearity in _ hipparcos_. '' this work demonstrates just the opposite : brighter stars @xmath47 discrepant and the faint @xmath46=0.087 for vega @xmath48 caused by non - linearity .
furthermore , the apparent variability and gradual apparent brightening of the four brightest stars in figure [ hipvari ] is probably caused by slight variations in the exact level of pulse pileup in the detector .
_ photometry does not provide good evidence for the variability of vega .
constructive comments on preliminary drafts were provided by m. bessel , s. deustua , r. kurucz , sz .
mszros , t. rauch , and the referee .
primary support for this work was provided by nasa through the space telescope science institute , which is operated by aura , inc .
, under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
absil , et al .
2013 , , 555 , a104 asplund , m. , grevesse , n. , & sauval , a. j. 2005 , in asp conf .
336 , cosmic abundances as records of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis , ed .
t. g. barnes iii & f. n. bash ( san francisco , ca : asp ) , 25 aufdenberg , et al .
2006 , apj , 645 , 664 beuermann , k. , burwitz , v. , & rauch , t. 2006 , a&a , 458 , 541 blackwell , d. e. , leggett , s. k. , petford , a.d . , mountain , c. m. , & selby m. j. 1983 , , 205 , 897 bohlin , r. 1998 , instrument science report , stis 98 - 01 ( baltimore : stsci ) bohlin , r. 2003 , 2002 hst calibration workshop , eds . s. arribas , a. koekemoer , and b. whitmore ( baltimore : stsci ) , p. 115
bohlin , r. c. 2007 , in asp conf .
364 , the future of photometric , spectrophotometric , and polarimetric standardization , ed . c. sterken ( ann arbor , mi : sheridan books ) , 315 bohlin , r. c. , & gilliland , r. l. 2004 , aj , 127 , 3508 ( bg ) bohlin r. c. , gordon , k. d. , rieke , g. h. , ardila , d. , carey , s. , deustua , s. , engelbracht , c. , ferguson , h. c. , flanagan , k. , kalirai , j. , meixner , m. , noriega - crespo , a. , su , k. y. l. , and tremblay , p. e. 2011 , aj , 141 , 173 bohlin , r. c. , & gordon , k. d. 2014 , pasp , in preparation bohlin , r. c. , savage , b. d. , & drake , j. f. 1978 , , 224 , 132 booth , a. j. , selby , m.j . , blackwell , d.e . ,
petford , a.d . , & arribas s. 1989 , a&a , 218 , 167 cohen , m. 2007 , in asp conf .
364 , the future of photometric , spectrophotometric , and polarimetric standardization , ed .
c. sterken ( ann arbor , mi : sheridan books ) , 333 cohen , m. , walker , r. g. , barlow , m. j. , & deacon , j. r. 1992a , aj , 104 , 1650 cohen , m. , walker , r. g. , jayaraman , s. , & barker , e. 2001 , aj , 121 , 1180 cohen , m. , walker , r. g. , & witteborn .
f. c. 1992b , aj , 104 , 2030 defrre , d. , et al .
2011 , , 534 , a5 engelke , c. w. , price , s. d. , & kraemer , k. e. 2010 , aj , 140 , 1919 ( epk ) gianninas , a. , bergeron , p. , & ruiz , m. t. 2011 , , 743 , 138 ( g11 ) gilliland , r. l. , goudfrooij , p. , & kimble , r. a. 1999 , pasp , 111 , 1009 ( ggk ) goudfrooij , p. & bohlin , r. 2006 , instrument science report , stis 2006 - 03 , ( baltimore : stsci ) hayes , d. s. 1985 , in calibration of fundamental stellar quantities , proc . of iau symposium
111 , eds .
d. s. hayes , l. e. pasinetti , a. g. davis philip ( reidel : dordrecht ) , p. 225
hernandez , s. , et al .
2012 , `` stis instrument handbook '' , version 12.0 , ( baltimore : stsci ) holberg , j. b. , barstow , m. a. , bruhweiler , f. c. , cruise , a. m. , & penny , a. j. 1998 , , 497 , 935 johnson , h. l. , iriarte , b. , mitchell , r. i. , wisniewski , w. z. 1966 , comm . lunar plan . lab .
, 4 , 99 landolt , a. u. 1992 , 104 340 landolt , a. u. , & uomoto , a. k. 2007 , aj , 133 , 768 linnell , a. p. , destefano , p. , & hubeny , i. 2013 , aj , 146 , 68 marengo , m. , et al .
2009 , apj , 700 , 1647 megessier , c. 1995 , a&a , 296 , 771 mszros , sz . ,
2012 , aj , 144 , 120 mountain , c. m. , selby , m. j. , leggett , s. k. , blackwell , d. e. , & petford a. d. 1985 , , a&a , 151 , 399 neugebauer , g. , et al . 1984 , apjl , 278 , l1 peterson , d. m. , et al .
2006 , nature , 440 , 896 price , s. d. , paxson , g. , engelke , c. , & murdock , t. l. 2004 , aj , 128 , 889 ( ppem ) rauch , t. , & deetjen , j. l. 2003 , in asp conf .
series , vol .
288 , stellar atmosphere modeling , eds .
i. hubeny , d. mihalas , & k. werner , 103 rauch , t. , werner , k. , bohlin , r. , & kruk , j. w. 2013 , a&a , 560 , a106 selby , m. j. , mountain , c. m. , blackwell , d. e. , petford , a. d. , & leggett , s. k. 1983 , , 203 , 795 smith , b. j. , price , s. d. , & baker , r. i. 2004 , apjs , 154 , 673 snow , m. , reberac , a. , quemerais , e. , clarke , j. , mcclintock , w. e. , & woods , t. n. 2013 , in issi scientific report series , vol .
13 , cross - calibration of far uv spectra of solar system objects and the heliosphere , eds .
e. quemerais , m. snow , and r. m. bonnet ( new york : springer ) , 191 stys , d. j. , bohlin , r. c. & goudfrooij , p. 2004 , instrument science report , stis 2004 - 04 , ( baltimore : stsci ) su , k. y. l. , et al .
2013 , , 763 , 118 ( su ) tremblay , p. e. , & bergeron , p. 2009
, , 696 , 1755 tg , h. , white , n. m. , & lockwood , g. w. 1977 , a&a , 61 , 679 van leeuwen , f. , evans , d. w. , grenon , m. , grossmann , v. , mignard , f. , & perryman , m. a. c. 1997 , a&a , 323 , l61 werner , k. , deetjen , j. l. , dreizler , s. , nagel , t. , rauch , t. , & schuh , s. l. 2003 , in asp conf .
series , vol .
288 , stellar atmosphere modeling , eds .
i. hubeny , d. mihalas , & k. werner , 31 0.1% , except for the last observation of each visit , which is high by @xmath250.4% .
the exposure time of the short observations is a small fraction of the total , so that this small non - repeatability has a @xmath60.1% effect on the final average .
[ modcf],height=576 ] , @xmath45 , and @xmath35=+0.4 $ ] .
the original and 2013 kurucz models coincide , except where the dots are discernable .
the blue curve is from epk , while green represents the cww template for sirius .
the stis data cover the wavelength range below 1 @xmath0 m and are supplemented by iue data below 1675 .
the short wavelength limit of the cww sed is 1 @xmath0 m .
the black filled circles with @xmath49 error bars are the msx values of ppem .
[ siriuscont],height=672 ] .
the black filled circles are the msx values of ppem but are now shown after the 0.9945 correction to the hst / stis flux scale . the black circle at 0.556 is the @xmath7 erg @xmath3 s@xmath4 @xmath4 value of megessier ( 1995 ) , which is now 0.55% above the stis flux .
notice the expanded scale in the bottom panel , where both models are within 1% of the reference kurucz model ( red in figure [ siriuscont ] ) .
[ lnmzcont],height=672 ] .
the two observational results agree to @xmath253% , while the model tracks both observations with remarkable fidelity , considering the computational difficulty of accounting for the heavy line - blanketing at these uv wavelengths .
[ solsticecont],height=720 ] error bars are from various ir space missions : squares ( dirbe ) , open circles ( irac ) , @xmath10 ( msx ) , diamonds ( iras ) ; and the filled circles are the ground - based interferometric results .
the individual dust ring components are for 2400 k ( blue ) , 270 k ( green ) , and 62 k ( red ) , while the continuous black line is the sum of these three components .
[ vegadust],height=576 ] magnitudes for bright stars from a johnson v mag of -1.46 for sirius in the uppper left panel to v=3.73 for 109 vir at the lower right .
the brightest stars with @xmath50 in the top four panels are affected by instabilities at these highest count rates where pulse pileup is significant .
[ hipvari],height=480 ] llllcc obto11010 & g230 lb & 12 - 10 - 07 & 21:03:13 & 1.2 & 4 + obto11020 & g230 lb & 12 - 10 - 07 & 21:06:13 & 6.0 & 4 + obto11030 & g230 lb & 12 - 10 - 07 & 21:12:22 & 1.2 & 4 + obto11040 & g430l & 12 - 10 - 07 & 21:23:12 & 0.9 & 3 + obto11050 & g430l & 12 - 10 - 07 & 21:25:27 & 0.9 & 3 + obto11060 & g750l & 12 - 10 - 07 &
21:35:32 & 2.1 & 7 + obto12010 & g230 lb & 13 - 01 - 26 & 12:10:59 & 1.2 & 4 + obto12020 & g230 lb & 13 - 01 - 26 & 12:13:59 & 6.0 & 4 + obto12030 & g230 lb & 13 - 01 - 26 & 12:20:08 & 1.2 & 4 + obto12040 & g430l & 13 - 01 - 26 & 12:30:58 & 0.9 & 3 + obto12050 & g430l & 13 - 01 - 26 & 12:33:13 & 0.9 & 3 + obto12060 & g750l & 13 - 01 - 26 & 12:43:18 & 2.1 & 7 + 8.28 ( a ) & + 0.4 & -1.0 & 1.006 & 8.477e-13 & 1.4 & 0.970 & 0.976 + 12.13 ( c ) & -0.4 & -1.0 & 1.014 & 1.883e-13 & 1.4 & 0.968 & 0.982 + 14.65 ( d ) & -1.9 & -1.0 & 1.030 & 9.031e-14 & 1.4 & 0.968 & 0.996 + 21.34 ( e ) & -2.5 & -1.0 & 1.036 & 2.025e-14 & 1.4 & 0.967 & 1.002 + | the space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) has measured the flux for sirius from 0.171.01 @xmath0 m on the _ hst _ white dwarf scale .
because of the cool debris disk around vega , sirius is commonly recommended as the primary ir flux standard .
the measured stis flux agrees well with predictions of a special kurucz model atmosphere , adding confidence to the modeled ir flux predictions .
the ir flux agrees to 23% with respect to the standard template of cohen and to 2% with the msx absolute flux measurements in the mid - ir .
a weighted average of the independent visible and mid - ir absolute flux measures implies that the monochromatic flux at 5557.5 ( 5556 in air ) for sirius and vega , respectively , is @xmath1 and @xmath2 erg @xmath3 s@xmath4 @xmath4 with formal uncertainties of 0.5% .
contrary to previously published conclusions , the hipparcos photometry offers no support for the variability of vega .
pulse pileup severely affects the hp photometry for the brightest stars . |
phase transition phenomena in spontaneously broken quantum field theories have long been a subject of importance and interest due to their wide range of possible applications , going from low energy phenomena in condensed matter systems to high energy phase transitions in particle physics and cosmology ( for reviews , see for example @xcite ) .
in addition to thermal effects , phase transition phenomena are also known to be triggered by other external effects , like , for example , by external fields . in particular , those changes caused by external magnetic fields have attracted considerable attention in the past @xcite and received reinvigorated interest recently , mostly because of the physics associated with heavy - ion collision experiments . in heavy - ion collisions , it is supposed that large magnetic fields can be generated , and the study of their effects in the hadronic phase transition then became subject of intense interest ( see e.g. @xcite for a recent review ) .
magnetic fields can lead in particular to important changes in the chiral / deconfinement transition in quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) @xcite and even the possibility of generating new phases @xcite as far the influence of external magnetic fields and thermal effects on phase transformations are concerned , one well known example that comes to our mind is the physics associated with superconductivity , in particular in the context of the ginzburg - landau theory @xcite .
let us recall in that case thermal effects alone tend to produce a phase transition at a critical temperature where superconductivity is destroyed and the system goes to a normal ordered state .
the phase transition in this case is second order .
however , in the presence of an external magnetic field , but below some critical value , by increasing the temperature the system undergoes a first order phase transition instead .
this simple example already shows that magnetic fields may have influence on the phase transition other than we would expect from thermal effects alone .
there are also other examples of more complex systems where external magnetic fields may have a drastic effect on the symmetry behavior . among these effects , besides the possibility of changing the order of the phase transition , as in the ginzburg - landau superconductor , it can in some circumstances strengthen the order of the phase transition , like in the electroweak phase transition in the presence of external fields @xcite , or there can also be dynamical effects , like delaying the phase transition @xcite .
external magnetic fields alone can also lead to dynamical symmetry breaking ( magnetic catalysis ) @xcite ( for an earlier account , see ref .
@xcite ) . likewise
, nonperturbative effects may affect the symmetry properties of a system , once the external parameters are changed , in a way different than seeing through a purely perturbative calculation , or by a mean - field leading order description .
this is because perturbation theory is typically beset by problems , for example around critical points , due to infrared divergences , or at high temperatures , when powers of coupling constants can become surmounted by powers of the temperature ( see e.g. the textbooks @xcite for extensive discussions ) .
thus , high temperature field theories and the study of phase transitions in general require the use of nonperturbative methods , through which large classes of terms need to be resummed .
familiar techniques used to perform these resummations include , for example , ring diagram ( or daisy and superdaisy ) schemes @xcite , composite operator methods @xcite and field propagator dressing methods @xcite .
other methods used include also numerical lattice studies and expansions in parameters not related to a coupling constant , like the @xmath0 expansion and the @xmath1-expansion @xcite , the use of two - particle irreducible ( 2pi ) effective actions @xcite , hard - thermal - loop resummation @xcite , variational methods , like the screened perturbation theory @xcite and the optimized perturbation theory ( opt ) @xcite
. of course , any resummation technique must be implemented with care so to avoid possible overcounting of terms and lack of self - consistency .
failure in not following this basic care can lead to a variety of problems , like predicting nonexistent phenomena or producing a different order for the phase transition .
one classical example of this was the earlier implementations of daisy and superdaisy schemes , that at some point were giving wrong results , e.g. predicting a first order transition @xcite for the @xmath2 theory , an unexpected result since the model belongs to the universality class of the ising model , which is second order .
these methods have also initially predicted a stronger first order phase transition in the electroweak standard model , a result soon proved to be misleading @xcite .
these wrong results were all because of the wrong implementation of the ring - diagram summation at the level of the effective potential , as clearly explained in the first reference in @xcite in this work we will analyze the phase transition for a self - interacting complex scalar field model and determine how an external magnetic field , combined with thermal effects , affects the transition .
all calculations will be performed in the context of the opt nonperturbative method .
our reasons for revisiting here the phase transition in this model are two - fold .
first because this same model has been studied recently in the context of the ring - diagram resummation method @xcite , where it was found that the ring - diagrams render the phase transition first order and that the effect of magnetic fields was to strengthen the order of the transition and also to lower the critical temperature for the onset of the ( first order ) phase transition .
so in this work we want to reevaluate these findings in the context of the opt method .
we recall , from the discussion of the previous paragraph , that the ring diagram method requires special attention in its implementation and that previous works have already concluded erroneously about its effects on the transition .
the opt method has a long history of successful applications ( for a far from complete list of previous works and applications see e.g. refs . @xcite and references therein ) .
the opt method automatically resums large classes of terms in a self - consistent way so to avoid possible dangerous overcounting of diagrams . in our implementation of the opt here , we will see that already at the first order in the opt it is equivalent to the daisy and superdaisy schemes .
the opt then provides a safe comparison with these other nonperturbative schemes .
in particular , to our knowledge , this is the first study of the opt method when considering the inclusion of an external magnetic field .
finally , we also want to properly treat the effects of small magnetic fields ( which requires summing over very large landau - levels ) in an efficient way , particularly suitable for numerical work .
this way we can evaluate in a precise way the effects of external magnetic fields ranging from very small to very large field intensities ( in which case , in general , just a few landau - levels suffice to be considered ) . for this study we will make use of the euler - maclaurin formula and fully investigate the validity of its use as an approximation for the landau level sums for different ranges for the magnetic field .
the remaining of this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii we introduce the model and explain the application of the opt method for the problem we study in this paper .
it is shown explicitly which terms are resummed by the opt .
we also verify that the goldstone theorem is fulfilled in the opt . in sec .
iii we study the phase transition in the spontaneously broken self - interacting quartic complex scalar field in the opt method , first by incorporating only thermal effects and then by including both temperature and an external magnetic field . in sec .
iv we study the advantages of using the euler - maclaurin formula for the sum over the landau levels .
the accuracy and convergence of the method is fully examined .
we determine that the sum over the landau levels , in the regime of low magnetic fields , where typically we must sum over very large levels so to reach good accuracy , can be efficiently performed within the very few first terms in the euler - maclaurin formula . as an application , an analytical formula for the critical temperature for phase restoration , as a function of the magnetic field , @xmath3 ,
is derived .
our final conclusions are given in sec .
v. finally , an appendix is included to show some of the details of the renormalization of the model in the context of the opt .
in our study we will make use of a self - interacting quartic complex scalar field model with a global @xmath4 symmetry and spontaneously symmetry breaking at tree - level in the potential , whose lagrangian density is of the standard form , @xmath5 where @xmath6 for spontaneously symmetry breaking .
it is convenient to write the complex scalar field @xmath7 in terms of real and imaginary components , @xmath8 . in terms of a ( real ) vacuum expectation value ( vev ) for the field , @xmath9 , we can
, without loss of generality , shift the field @xmath7 around its vev in the @xmath10 direction , @xmath11 the feynman propagators for @xmath10 and @xmath12 , in terms of the vev then reads , @xmath13 using the tree - level vev for the field , @xmath14 in eqs .
( [ dphi1 ] ) and ( [ dphi2 ] ) , @xmath10 is then associated with the massive higgs mode ( with mass squared @xmath15 at the tree level ) and @xmath12 is the goldstone mode of the field , remaining massless throughout the symmetry broken phase .
the implementation of the opt in the lagrangian density is the standard one @xcite , where it is implemented through an interpolation procedure , @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 is the lagrangian density part with the renormalization counterterms needed to render the theory finite . in @xmath19 ,
the dimensionless parameter @xmath20 is a bookkeeping parameter used only to keep track of the order that the opt is implemented ( it is set to one at the end ) and @xmath21 is a ( mass ) parameter determined variationally at any given finite order of the opt .
a popular variational criterion used to determine @xmath21 is known as the principle of minimal sensitivity ( pms ) , defined by the variational relation @xcite @xmath22 which is applied to some physical quantity @xmath23 , calculated up to some order-@xmath24 in the opt . the optimum value @xmath25 , which satisfies eq .
( [ pms ] ) , is a function of the original parameters of the theory and it is in general a nontrivial function of the couplings .
it is because of the variational principle used that nonperturbative results are generated .
other variational criteria can likewise be defined differently , but they produce the same final result for the quantity @xmath23 , as shown recently @xcite . in terms of the interpolated lagrangian density , eq .
( [ interpol ] ) , the feynman rules in the opt method are as follows .
the interaction vertex is changed from @xmath26 to @xmath27 .
the quadratic terms @xmath28 in eq .
( [ interpol ] ) define new vertex insertion terms .
the propagators for @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) now become @xmath31 as in the many other previous applications @xcite , we apply the pms , eq .
( [ pms ] ) , directly on the effective potential , which is the most convenient quantity to study the phase structure of the model . to first order in the opt ,
using the previous feynman rules in the opt method given above , the effective potential @xmath32 is given by the vacuum diagrams shown in fig .
[ vacuum ] . from the diagrams shown in fig .
[ vacuum ] and by further expanding the propagators eqs .
( [ dphi1-delta ] ) and ( [ dphi2-delta ] ) in @xmath20 , the explicit expression for the renormalized effective potential at first order in the opt ( some of the details of the renormalization in the opt method are given in the appendix a ) becomes @xmath33 ^ 2\ ; , \label{veff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the momentum integrals are expressed in euclidean space and the regularization is performed in @xmath34 scheme , where , in the finite temperature only case , @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the euler - mascheroni constant , @xmath37 is an arbitrary mass regularization scale , @xmath38 is the dimension of space and @xmath39 are the matsubara frequencies for bosons at temperature @xmath40 .
the inclusion of an external magnetic field presents no additional difficulty .
for example , without loss of generality , we can consider a constant magnetic field in the @xmath41-space direction and use a gauge where the external electromagnetic field is @xmath42 .
the feynman propagator for a charged scalar field with charge @xmath43 becomes @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is the energy dispersion ( for charged scalar bosons ) in an external constant magnetic field @xcite , @xmath46 where the last term denotes the landau levels ( @xmath47 ) .
likewise , the momentum integrals , taking into account the degeneracy multiplicity of the landau levels @xcite , are now represented by @xmath48 let us now apply the pms condition ( [ pms ] ) on the effective potential eq .
( [ veff ] ) .
we obtain straightforwardly that the optimum @xmath25 satisfies the nontrivial ( renormalized ) gap equation @xmath49\bigr|_{\eta = { \bar \eta}}\;. \label{etabar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the extrema of the effective potential are defined as usual , by requiring that the first derivative of the effective potential with respect to @xmath50 vanishes .
this gives us the trivial solution @xmath51 and the solution for the minimum , @xmath52\;. \label{varphi}\ ] ] we can now verify the effective mass for the field , in particular for the @xmath12 component of the complex scalar field .
the effective mass for @xmath12 in the opt is given by @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the ( renormalized ) field s self - energy , which at first order in the opt is trivially found to be given by @xmath55\bigr|_{\eta = { \bar \eta}}\;. \label{sigma1}\ ] ] using now eqs .
( [ sigma1 ] ) , ( [ etabar ] ) and ( [ varphi ] ) in eq .
( [ m2 ] ) , we obtain immediately that @xmath56 , which is nothing but the result expected due to goldstone theorem for the symmetry broken complex scalar field model .
it can also be verified that this result carries out at higher orders in the opt method , in which case , at some order-@xmath24 in the opt , the self - energy is the one at the respective order , @xmath57 , entering in the above equations .
previous demonstrations of the goldstone theorem in the opt were for the linear sigma model @xcite and for the @xmath58 nambu jona - lasinio model @xcite .
finally , it is noticed from the pms equation given above , eq .
( [ etabar ] ) , that the opt naturally resums the leading order loop terms of the field s self - energy .
so it is quite analogous , at already in the first order in the opt approximation , to the ring - diagram resummation @xcite . and that this resummation is also performed automatically in a self - consistent way , it is clear from the interpolation procedure . while @xmath59 enters in all propagators , thus carrying the self - energy corrections , the insertions of @xmath59 ( the term @xmath60 in eq .
( [ interpol ] ) is treated as an additional interaction vertex ) subtract spurious contributions at each order , thus avoiding dangerous overcounting of diagrams ( this is also similar to the procedure used in the screened perturbation theory @xcite ) . going to higher orders in the opt resums higher order classes of diagrams . for our purposes of comparing with the ring - diagram results
, it suffices then to keep up to first order in the opt .
we are now ready to study the phase structure and the symmetry restoration in the complex scalar field model at finite temperature and in an external magnetic field .
it is convenient to first investigate the case of finite temperature only , so to later compare with the case when an external magnetic field is added .
it is convenient to write the explicit expressions for each term entering in the effective potential in eq .
( [ veff ] ) . at finite temperature and in the absence of an external magnetic field , using ( [ intt ] ) , we have that the first momentum integral in ( [ veff ] ) becomes ( recalling that @xmath61 ) @xmath62 where we have identified explicitly the divergent term and the finite term , @xmath63 , is given by @xmath64 \omega^4 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{t^4}{\pi^2 } \int_0^\infty dz \ , z^2 \ln\left[1-\exp\left(-\sqrt{z^2+\omega^2/t^2}\right)\right]\;. \label{yt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] likewise , for the remaining momentum integrals in ( [ veff ] ) we obtain @xmath65\ ; , \label{fb } \\ \delta \frac{\lambda}{3 } \varphi^2 \int_p \frac{i}{p^2 - \omega^2 } & = & \delta \frac{\lambda}{3 } \varphi^2 \left[-\frac{\omega^2}{(4\pi)^2 } \frac{1}{\epsilon } + x(t,\eta)\right]\ ; , \label{fc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath66 is given by @xmath67 + \frac{t^2}{2 \pi^2}\int_0^\infty dz \frac{z^2}{\sqrt{z^2+\frac{\omega^2}{t^2}}}\;\frac{1 } { \exp\left(\sqrt{z^2+\frac{\omega^2}{t^2}}\right)-1}\;. \label{xt}\ ] ] next , there is the term coming from the mass counterterm in eq .
( [ veff ] ) ( see appendix a ) , @xmath68 where we have also defined @xmath69 ^{2}+\frac{1}{2}+\frac{\pi ^{2}}{12}\;. \label{w0}\ ] ] finally , we have the two - loop contributions shown in fig . [ vacuum ] .
they all sum up in the opt expansion to give @xmath70 ^ 2 & = & \delta \frac{\lambda}{3 } \frac{\omega^{4}}{\left ( 4\pi\right)^{4}}\frac{1}{\epsilon ^{2 } } -\delta \lambda \frac { \omega^{2 } } { 24\pi^{2 } } x\left ( t,\eta\right ) \frac{1}{\epsilon } \nonumber \\ & + & \delta \frac{2\lambda}{3 } \frac{\omega^{4}}{\left ( 4\pi\right)^{4 } } w(\eta ) + \delta \frac{\lambda}{3 } x^{2}\left ( t,\eta\right)\;. \label{fe}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eqs .
( [ ln ] ) , ( [ fb ] ) , ( [ fc ] ) , ( [ fd ] ) and ( [ fe ] ) , we find the complete expression for the renormalized effective potential at first order in the opt : @xmath71\right\ } x\left ( t,\eta\right)\;. \label{vefft}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the phase structure at finite temperature is completely determined by eqs .
( [ vefft ] ) , ( [ etabar ] ) and ( [ varphi ] ) .
the optimum @xmath72 , determined by the pms criterion , and the vacuum expectation value ( vev ) for the scalar field , can now be both , respectively , be expressed as @xmath73 and @xmath74 in the opt we can exactly compute the critical temperature of phase transition . using that at the critical point the vev of the field vanishes , @xmath75 , then from eq .
( [ etabart ] ) we obtain that @xmath76 which upon using it in eq .
( [ varphit ] ) , we obtain @xmath77 from the definition of @xmath78 , eq . ( [ xt ] ) , we then obtain that @xmath79 and when using the above result back in eq .
( [ varphitc ] ) , we obtain the exact result for the critical temperature at this first order in the opt : @xmath80 this result for @xmath81 is the same predicted before for a scalar field model with two real components @xcite , obtained in the high temperature one - loop approximation .
the result ( [ tc ] ) is exact in our opt approximation and obtained independent of any high temperature approximation , as usually assumed in any previous calculations . from eqs .
( [ etabart ] ) and ( [ varphit ] ) , we obtain directly the behavior of the vev @xmath82 as a function of the temperature . for comparison purposes
, we use analogous parameters as adopted in ref .
@xcite , in the numerical value for @xmath83 in our notation . in the approximations used in @xcite , the terms involving the regularization scale were not included . here
we express all quantities in terms of the regularization scale @xmath37 . ]
where @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
for these parameters , the authors in ref .
@xcite find a first order phase transition . in fig .
[ fig2 ] we show the result for the minimum of the effective potential , @xmath86 as a function of the temperature .
the effective potential , for different temperatures and same parameters as in fig .
[ fig2 ] , is shown in fig .
note that the effective potential has an imaginary part for temperatures below @xmath81 , eq .
( [ tc ] ) , since there can be values of @xmath50 for which @xmath87 becomes negative .
this happens for values of @xmath50 in between the inflection points of the potential , which defines the spinodal region of instability in between the ( degenerate ) vev of the field , determined by eq .
( [ varphit ] ) . in fig .
[ fig3 ] , for the case of @xmath88 , we show the real part of the effective potential , so to be able to show all the potential , including the spinodal region .
it should be noted that the minimum of the effective potential , determined by the coupled eqs .
( [ etabart ] ) and ( [ varphit ] ) , is well defined and unique , where the only solutions for eq .
( [ varphit ] ) are the two degenerate minima for @xmath88 , while for @xmath89 , the only solution is @xmath90 .
therefore , the phase transition can readily be inferred to be second order for any set of parameters .
it is also clear from the results shown by figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] that the transition due to thermal effects only is of second order .
the effective potential does not develop local minima and the vev of the field varies continuously from @xmath91 till @xmath92 , where it vanishes .
this is the expected behavior , since the complex scalar field model belongs to the same universality class of a @xmath93 heisenberg model , for which the phase transition is second order @xcite .
thus , we see that the opt method correctly describes the phase transition in the model , capturing the correct physics .
furthermore , as an added bonus , we can exactly compute the critical temperature of transition let us now investigate the phase structure when an external magnetic field is also applied to the system .
in the presence of a constant magnetic field , the feynman rules change as shown in subsec .
[ opt+veff ] .
the momentum integrals in eq .
( [ veff ] ) are given by ( [ inttb ] ) and the dispersion relation for charged particles is given by eq .
( [ ek ] ) , which takes into account the landau energy levels of a charged particle in a magnetic field ) only applies for the fields in the complex base @xmath94 , since @xmath95 are not appropriate eigenstates of charge .
however , when re - expressing the effective potential in the complex scalar field base , the final result turns out to be the same as in eq .
( [ veff ] ) or ( [ vefft ] ) , but with the functions @xmath96 and @xmath97 depending now also on the magnetic field . ] . at finite @xmath98 , the first momentum integral term in ( [ veff ] ) becomes : @xmath99\;. \label{ln1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by performing the sum over the matsubara frequencies in ( [ ln1 ] ) , we obtain two terms .
one is independent of the temperature and the other is for @xmath100 .
the @xmath91 term is @xmath101 + \frac{(eb)^2}{4 \pi^2 } \zeta'\left(-1,\frac{\omega^2 + eb}{2 eb}\right ) , \label{ln1t0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where to write the second line in ( [ ln1t0 ] ) , we used the analytic continuation of the hurwitz zeta function @xcite , @xmath102 and @xmath103 is its @xmath104-derivative . in writing the final terms in eq .
( [ ln1t0 ] ) we have also dropped constant terms since they do not affect the phase structure . the @xmath105 part of ( [ ln1 ] ) is @xmath106 \right\}\;. \label{ln1t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can now write eq .
( [ ln1 ] ) in a form analogous to eq .
( [ ln ] ) , @xmath107 where @xmath108 is given by @xmath109 + \frac{(eb)^2}{4 \pi^2 } \zeta'\left(-1,\frac{\omega^2 + eb}{2
eb}\right ) \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{e b}{\pi } t^2 \sum_{k=0}^{+\infty } \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty } \frac{d z}{2 \pi } \ln \left\ { 1- \exp\left [ - \sqrt{z^2 + \frac{\omega^2}{t^2 } + ( 2k + 1)\frac{e b}{t^2 } } \right ] \right\}\;. \label{ytb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] analogous manipulations leading to eq .
( [ lntb ] ) allow us to write the remaining momentum integral terms in eq .
( [ veff ] ) like @xmath110 where @xmath111 -\frac{e b}{16 \pi^2 } \ln(2 \pi ) - \frac{\omega^2}{16 \pi^2 } \ln\left ( \frac{m^2}{2 e b } \right)\nonumber \\ & + & \frac{e b}{2 \pi } \sum_{k=0}^{+\infty } \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty } \frac{d z}{2 \pi } \frac{1}{\sqrt{z^2 + \frac{\omega^2}{t^2 } + ( 2k + 1)\frac{e b}{t^2}}}\ ; \frac{1}{\exp\left[\sqrt{z^2 + \frac{\omega^2}{t^2 } + ( 2k + 1)\frac{e b}{t^2}}\right ] -1}\;. \label{xtb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] actually , eq .
( [ tadloop ] ) is just the derivative of eq .
( [ lntb ] ) with respect to @xmath112 , as can be easily checked .
the final expression for the renormalized effective potential at finite temperature and in a constant external magnetic field has an analogous form as eq .
( [ vefft ] ) , where by using eqs .
( [ lntb ] ) and ( [ tadloop ] ) in ( [ veff ] ) , we obtain @xmath113\right\ } { \tilde{x}}(t , b,\eta)\;. \label{vefftb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , the pms criterion and the minimum of the effective potential are again also of the form as eqs .
( [ etabart ] ) and ( [ varphit ] ) : @xmath114 and @xmath115 with eqs .
( [ vefftb ] ) , ( [ etabartb ] ) and ( [ varphitb ] ) , we are now in position to study the effects of an external magnetic field in the phase structure of the model , in addition to the thermal effects . in fig .
[ fig4 ] we show the phase diagram for the symmetry broken complex scalar field model in the @xmath116 plane .
it shows that the magnetic field strengths the symmetry broken phase , increasing the critical temperature for phase transition .
we must note that this result for the phase diagram is very different from that seen in the superconductor or in the scalar quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) case @xcite .
in contrast to our case , where we are only studying the effects of @xmath98 and @xmath40 on the charged scalars , in the scalar qed there is also the interactions with the gauge field . in the scalar qed case with a local @xmath4 gauge symmetry , in the symmetry broken phase , because of the higgs mechanism the gauge field becomes massive and the external magnetic field gets screened ( the meissner effect ) . as the magnetic field is increased , eventually above a critical field the phase is restored through a first order phase transition . in the study made in this paper , on the other hand , we consider only the case of a broken _ global _ @xmath4 symmetry .
the effect of the magnetic field on the global @xmath4 symmetry can also be seen in the next two figures . in fig .
[ fig5 ] we have plotted the vev of the field at fixed @xmath117 , thus starting from a symmetry restored phase , @xmath90 , as a function of @xmath98 . the critical temperature , for the parameters used , is @xmath118 , which fully agrees with eq .
( [ tc ] ) , and the symmetry returns to be broken , @xmath119 , for a magnetic field above a critical value given by @xmath120 . in fig .
[ fig6 ] the effective potential is plotted for the same fixed temperature of fig .
[ fig5 ] and for values of @xmath98 below , at and above the critical value @xmath121 , above which the symmetry becomes broken again ( as before , to show the spinodal region of the potential , we have plotted only the real part of it ) .
it should be noticed from these results that the phase transition is once again second order .
the effect of the magnetic field is to enlarge the symmetry broken region by making the critical temperature larger , but it does not change the order of the transition . finally , we have again used for comparison a case with analogous parameters as considered in ref .
@xcite , and contrary to the results found in that reference , we have found again here only a second order phase transition . for the analogous parameters used in @xcite ( see observations made in previous subsection ) , @xmath84 , @xmath85 and @xmath122 , the change of the critical temperature in relation to the @xmath123 case shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] is only to produce a slight shift of the critical temperature to a value @xmath124 higher . in fig .
[ fig7 ] , we have plotted the vev of the field for the case of zero magnetic field and for a much higher value of the magnetic field , @xmath125 , so to be able to visualize the difference .
even so , the difference even for such value of magnetic field is only marginal , changing the critical temperature obtained at @xmath123 , @xmath126 , to @xmath127 for the value of @xmath98 used . in all cases
we have tested for a nonvanishing magnetic field and other different parameters of the potential , the transition is again verified to be second order , with the vev varying always continuously from its value at @xmath91 to zero at @xmath128 .
when working with quantum field theories in a magnetic field , we need to deal with the sum over the landau levels . at @xmath91
this does not present a problem in general , since we can express the expressions in terms of zeta functions .
we have seen this in the previous section , where all terms at @xmath91 were presented in analytical form .
however , at finite temperature this is not possible in general , therefore , we either need to numerically perform the sums over the landau levels , or find suitable approximations for the expressions .
this job becomes easier in the high magnetic field regime , with @xmath129 , for which most of the time suffices to use only the very first terms of the sum , or even just the leading landau level term .
higher order terms are quickly boltzmann suppressed in this case . but
this is not so in the low magnetic field regime , with @xmath130 , and @xmath131 , where most of the time requires to sum up to very large landau levels .
this has the potential to make any numerical computation to become quickly expensively , specially when there are in addition numerical integrations involved , like in our case here ( note that we have not made use of high temperature approximations , but worked with the complete expressions in terms of the temperature dependent integrals ) .
simple approximate analytical results , which are always desirable to obtain , can also become difficult to obtain without a suitable approximation that can be used .
one such approximation was discussed in ref .
@xcite , but it is valid only for very small magnetic fields . here
we discuss a more natural alternative for dealing with the cases of low magnetic fields , based on the euler - maclaurin formula .
the euler - maclaurin ( em ) formula provides a connection between integrals and sums .
it can be used to evaluate finite sums and infinite series using integrals , or vice - versa . in its most general form
it can be written as @xcite : @xmath132 + \sum_{i=1}^{n}\frac{b_{2i}}{(2i)!}\left[f^{(2i-1)}(b ) - f^{(2i-1)}(a)\right ] \nonumber \\ & + & \int_{a}^{b } \frac{b_{2n+1}(\{x\})}{(2n+1 ) ! } f^{(2n+1)}(x)\,dx\ ; , \label{em}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath133 are the bernoulli numbers , defined by the generating function @xmath134 and @xmath135 are the bernoulli polynomials , with generating function @xmath136 the notation @xmath137 in @xmath138 in eq .
( [ em ] ) means the fractional part of @xmath139 and @xmath140 means the @xmath24-th derivative of the function .
the last term in eq .
( [ em ] ) is known as the _ remainder_. next , we study the reliability of the use of the em formula as a suitable approximation for the sums over landau levels and we estimate the errors involved in doing so . in the following , we will call the 0th - order in the em formula when only the first term in the rhs of eq .
( [ em ] ) is kept , the 1st - order when also the second term is kept and so on so forth .
thus , for example , the landau sum part of @xmath108 in eq .
( [ ytb ] ) , up to second order in the em formula , becomes @xmath141 \simeq \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty } \frac{d z}{2 \pi } \left\ { \int_{0}^{\infty}\ln \left [ 1- e^{-e(z,\omega , t , b , k ) } \right]d k \right .
\nonumber\\ & + & \left . \frac{1}{2 } \ln \left [ 1- e^{-e(z,\omega , t , b , 0 ) } \right ] \right.\nonumber\\ & - & \left .
\frac{e b}{12 t^2}\ ; \frac{1}{e(z,\omega , t , b , 0 ) \left[e^{e(z,\omega , t , b , 0)}-1\right ] } \right\}\ ; , \label{emy}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath142 likewise , the landau sum part of @xmath143 in eq .
( [ xtb ] ) , up to second order in the em formula , becomes @xmath144 } \right.\nonumber\\ & + & \left .
\frac{e b}{12t^2}\ ; \frac{1}{e^2(z,\omega , t , b , 0 ) \left[e^{e(z,\omega , t , b , 0)}-1\right ] } \left[\frac{1}{e(z,\omega , t , b , 0 ) } + \frac{e^{e(z,\omega , t , b , 0)}}{e^{e(z,\omega , t , b , 0)}-1}\right]\right\}\;. \label{emx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in tab .
[ tab1 ] we assess the reliability of using the em at each order ( we have studied it up to the forth - order ) for the sums in eqs .
( [ emy ] ) and ( [ emx ] ) , for different values for the ratio @xmath145 , and we compare the results with the exact ones .
.the precision of the em formula ( without the remainder ) at each order ( up to 4th - order ) , compared with the result from the landau sum . in all cases we have considered @xmath146 in eqs .
( [ emy ] ) and ( [ emx ] ) , when extending them up to 4th - order . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] from the results shown in tab .
[ tab1 ] , we see that the em approximation produces results that already at first order have good accuracy compared to the exact values coming from the full landau sums .
it performs particularly very well for values of @xmath147 , reaching convergence within just the very first few terms in the expansion .
however , for values @xmath148 , increasing the order in the em series , it quickly looses accuracy .
this can be traced to the fact that as we go to a higher order in the derivatives appearing in the sum on the rhs of eq .
( [ em ] ) , higher powers of @xmath145 are produced , eventually spoiling the approximation ( though it oscillates around the true value ) .
this apparent runaway behavior is only cured by the introduction of the last term in eq .
( [ em ] ) , the remainder .
it should be noted that eq .
( [ em ] ) is not an approximation to the sum , but it is actually an identity .
the important term in that context is the remainder , the last term in eq .
( [ em ] ) . in all our numerical tests , within the numerical precision for the integrals ( for convenience
, we have performed all the numerical integrations in _ mathematica _
@xcite ) , we have verified that eq .
( [ em ] ) has agreed with the results from the sum over the landau levels in the lhs of eqs .
( [ emy ] ) and ( [ emx ] ) , for all values tested and at all orders ( when including the remainder ) , with a precision of less than @xmath149 .
this is quite impressed , recalling that we can in principle keep only the first few terms in eqs .
( [ emy ] ) and ( [ emx ] ) ( the first order approximation ) when including the remainder . for numerical computation
this is a tremendous advantage , since eq .
( [ em ] ) can easily be coded , compared to having to perform sums over very large landau levels ( particularly in the cases of low magnetic fields ) and the multiple integrations that may be required .
given all the advantages of using the em formula , it is quite surprising that it is not used frequently in physics , despite being well known in mathematics . in particular
, we see that it is well suitable in problems involving external magnetic fields . to our knowledge ,
one of the few works that we are aware of that have previously made use of the em formula before were for example refs .
@xcite . in ref .
@xcite the author derived the effective potential of the abelian - higgs model , including both thermal effects and an external magnetic field , in the one - loop approximation .
the em formula was used at its zeroth order ( by just transforming the sum in an integral ) to obtain analytical results for the effective potential in the high magnetic field region .
but from the results of tab .
[ tab1 ] , this is exactly the region and order in the approximation that lead to the largest errors . in @xcite
the em formula was used to obtain an expression for the effective potential for vector bosons and to study pair production in an external magnetic field , while in @xcite it was used to obtain analytical expressions for the internal energies for non - interacting bosons confined within a harmonic oscillator potential .
none of these previous works have assessed the reliability of the use of the em formula . as an application of the em formula to our problem
, we estimate from it the dependence of the critical temperature with the magnetic field .
recall from eq .
( [ varphitc ] ) the critical temperature can be obtained by setting @xmath146 and @xmath51 in the equation for the vev .
thus , from eq .
( [ varphitb ] ) , we need to solve the equation @xmath150 as we have seen from the results of tab .
[ tab1 ] , the em formula for low magnetic fields produce reliable results already at the second order , and for very small magnetic fields , good precision is reached even at first order .
thus , for example from the expansion in eq .
( [ emx ] ) , and performing the @xmath24 integral in the first term , we obtain @xmath151 where @xmath152 .
results for the integrals in eq .
( [ emxa ] ) can be found in the low magnetic field regime , where @xmath153 .
this regime is equivalent to the high temperature regime in quantum field theory , from where a series expansion in @xmath154 can be found .
in fact , the integrals in eq .
( [ emxa ] ) can be easily related to the @xmath155 bose - einstein integrals found in that context ( see for example the app .
a in ref .
@xcite ) , from where we obtain the leading order terms in the expansion in powers of @xmath154 : @xmath156 going to higher order in the em series only lead to @xmath157 ( with @xmath158 ) terms , for @xmath159 .
using the result ( [ aproclxa ] ) in eq .
( [ xtb ] ) and then back in eq .
( [ tcbeq ] ) , after some algebra , we obtain the approximate result for the critical temperature as a function of the magnetic field , @xmath160 the result ( [ tcb ] ) shows the growth of the critical temperature with the magnetic field , as seen numerically from the results obtained in the previous section .
a comparison with our previous results also shows that eq .
( [ tcb ] ) provides an excellent fit for @xmath3 , leading to results with less than @xmath161 error compared to the full numerical results for @xmath81 , for values of field such that @xmath162 .
for example , for the parameters @xmath163 and @xmath164 , the approximation ( [ tcb ] ) gives @xmath165 , while the full numerical calculation gives @xmath166 .
in this paper we have revisited the phase transition problem for the self - interacting complex scalar field model when thermal effects and an external magnetic field are present .
we have studied this problem in the context of the nonperturbative method of the optimized perturbation theory .
we have shown that the opt method preserves the goldstone theorem and that carrying out the approximation to first order is analogous to the ring diagram resummation method .
the opt carries out the resummation of self - energy diagrams in a self - consistent way , avoiding overcounting issues , which have previously plagued the ring diagram method in its very early applications . by using the opt method ,
we have demonstrated that the phase transition in the model is always second order in the presence of thermal effects and by including an external magnetic field , there is no change to the phase transition order .
the effect of the external magnetic field is to strengthen the symmetry broken phase , producing a larger vev for the field and also a larger critical temperature .
the study we made in this paper considered only the effects of the magnetic field and temperature on the charged scalar field ( the model is one with a global @xmath4 symmetry ) .
our study , in a sense , is closer to the case of studying the effects of @xmath98 and @xmath40 in the linear sigma model @xcite , where no couplings to gauge fields ( except to the external field ) are considered in general .
the inclusion of other field degrees of freedom , or when promoting the symmetry from a global one to a local symmetry , can of course change both qualitatively and quantitatively how the magnetic field affects the system .
in particular , as concerning the possibility of producing a first order phase transition , either due to thermal effects , or by a magnetic field or from both . this is what we expect in the context of the scalar qed , where due to the screening of the magnetic field in the broken phase , the phase diagram and transition are very different .
the phase structure can also be very different when adding other interactions and having other symmetries .
for example , in the context of the electroweak phase transition @xcite , it has been shown that the effect of the magnetic field is to make the first order transition stronger . by omitting vacuum energy terms from the effective potential , which may have phenomenological motivations , as in ref .
@xcite , may also lead to a first order transition , instead of a second order one . still comparing our results with those obtained in the abelian higgs model
, there is a tantalizing question of whether for very strong magnetic fields a new phase could be formed .
this could be for example a phase with global vortices condensation , thus restoring the symmetry again .
this would be in analogy to the local , nielsen - olesen vortex conndensation that can happen in type ii superconductors @xcite .
vortex condensation in that case is energetically favorable to happen for fields beyond a critical value and when the mass of the higgs field becomes larger that the mass of the gauge field .
this is an interesting possibility to investigate in the future . as an aside , but a complementary part of this work , we have verified the reliability of the use of the euler - maclaurin formula as an approximation for the sum over landau energies in a magnetic field .
we have verified that it produces results with errors of less than @xmath167 already at the first few orders in the em formula and that it leads to particularly suitable approximations in the low magnetic field region ( @xmath168 ) .
the low magnetic field region is typically the region where we have to face the problem of summing over very larger number of landau levels , which , in practice , can be overwhelming in terms of cpu time , when working numerically .
the em formula in this case can be a very valuable tool , both for numerical computations , but also for obtaining approximate analytical results , which would be otherwise very difficult through the use of the landau sums directly . as an application of the em formula , we have obtained an approximate expression for the dependence of the critical temperature with the magnetic field in our problem .
we expect that the em formula can also be used in many other applications involving the effects of magnetic fields in phase transitions , like in condensed matter problems or in the recent interest in studying the effects of magnetic fields in the qcd phase transition .
furthermore , our results ( including the use of the opt method ) can also be of interest in the study of cosmological phase transitions in general .
magnetic fields can be easily generated in the early universe @xcite .
these fields can then influence subsequent cosmological phase transitions or also be important in particle physics phenomena in the early universe .
works in those contexts are in progress and we will report on them elsewhere .
work partially supported by capes , cnpq and fapemig ( brazilian agencies ) .
r.l.s.f . would like to thank a. ayala , e. s. fraga , a. j. mizher , h. c. g. caldas and m. b. pinto for discussions on related matters .
in this appendix we briefly explain the renormalization of the effective potential eq .
( [ veff ] ) .
first , note that the interpolation procedure in the opt method , eq .
( [ interpol ] ) , introduces only new quadratic terms , thus , it does not alter the renormalizability of the original theory .
therefore , the counterterms needed to render the theory finite have the same polynomial structure of the original lagrangian @xcite . by collecting all the divergences from the vacuum loop terms in eq .
( [ veff ] ) , we have that the divergence from the contribution ( [ fc ] ) is canceled by the counterterm eq .
( [ massct ] ) .
a potential temperature and magnetic field dependent divergence , proportional to either @xmath96 in the two - loop vacuum term eq .
( [ fe ] ) , or @xmath172 in the case of a finite external magnetic field , is explicitly canceled against identical term coming from the mass counterterm diagrams , eq .
( [ fd ] ) .
the remaining divergences in the effective potential are only vacuum ones , independent of the background field , and they can be all canceled by introducing a vacuum counterterm @xmath173 , added to the effective potential . at the first order in the opt , @xmath173 is given by thus , at first order in the opt , we only require the two counterterms , eqs .
( [ massct ] ) and ( [ vacuumct ] ) .
going to second order in the opt it will also require a coupling constant renormalization counterterm , @xmath175 , from which we can built vertex counterterm vacuum diagram contributions to the effective potential @xcite ( see also the first two references in @xcite ) .
at second order in the opt we would also obtain @xmath176 contributions for eqs .
( [ massct ] ) and ( [ vacuumct ] ) .
going to higher orders in the opt only produces additional @xmath177 , @xmath178 , contributions to the mass , vertex and vacuum counterterms .
r. j. rivers , e. kavoussanaki and g. karra , cond . mat .
phys . * 3 * , 133 ( 2000 ) ; r. j. rivers , _ patterns of symmetry breaking in cosmology and the laboratory _ , proceedings of the national workshop on cosmological phase transitions and topological defects ( porto , portugal , 2003 ) , ed . t.a .
girard ( grafitese , edificio ciencia , 2004 ) , pp11 - 23 .
r. gatto and m. ruggieri phys .
d * 83 * , 034016 ( 2011 ) ; m. delia , s. mukherjee and f. sanfilippo , phys .
d * 82 * , 051501 ( 2010 ) .
a. j. mizher , m. n. chernodub and e. s. fraga , phys .
d * 82 * , 105016 ( 2010 ) ; a. ayala , a. bashir , a. raya and a. sanchez phys .
d * 80 * , 036005 ( 2009 ) ; d. p. menezes , m. benghi pinto , s. s. avancini and c. providncia , phys .
c * 80 * , 065805 ( 2009 ) .
gusynin , v. a. miransky and i. a. shovkovy , phys .
lett . * 73 * , 3499 ( 1994 ) ; v. p. gusynin , v. a. miransky and i. a. shovkovy , nucl .
. * b462 * , 249 ( 1996 ) ; k. g. klimenko and d. ebert , phys . atom .
* 68 * , 124 ( 2005 ) ; v. c. zhukovsky , k. g. klimenko , v. v. khudyakov and d. ebert , jetp lett . * 73 * , 121 ( 2001 ) .
e. j. ferrer , v. de la incera , nucl .
* b824 * , 217 ( 2010 ) e. braaten and r. d. pisarski , nucl . phys .
* b337 * , 569 ( 1990 ) ; j. frenkel and j. c. taylor , nucl . phys . * b334 * , 199 ( 1990 ) ; j. o. andersen , e. braaten , and m. strickland , phys .
rev . lett . * 83 * , 2139 ( 1999 ) ; phys .
d * 61 * , 014017 ( 1999 ) .
f. karsch , a. patks , and p. petreczky , phys .
b * 401*,69 ( 1997 ) ; j. o. andersen and m. strickland , phys . rev .
d * 64 * , 105012 ( 2001 ) ; phys .
d * 71 * , 025011 ( 2005 ) ; j. o. andersen and l. kyllingstad , phys .
d * 78 * , 076008 ( 2008 ) .
v. i. yukalov , moscow univ .
31 * , 10 ( 1976 ) ; theor .
* 28 * , 652 ( 1976 ) ; r. seznec and j. zinn - justin , j. math . phys . * 20 * , 1398 ( 1979 ) ; j. c. le guillou and j. zinn - justin , ann
* 147 * , 57 ( 1983 ) ; r. p. feynman and h. kleinert , phys .
a * 34 * , 5080 ( 1986 ) ; h. f. jones and m. moshe , phys .
b234 * , 492 ( 1990 ) ; a. neveu , nucl . phys .
( proc . suppl . )
* b18 * , 242 ( 1991 ) ; v. yukalov , j. math .
phys * 32 * , 1235 ( 1991 ) ; k. g. klimenko , z. phys .
* c60 * , 677 ( 1993 ) ; for a review , see h. kleinert and v. schulte - frohlinde , _ critical properties of @xmath179-theories _ , chap .
19 ( world scientific , singapure 2001 ) .
m. b. pinto and r. o. ramos , phys .
d * 60 * , 105005 ( 1999 ) ; phys .
d * 61 * , 125016 ( 2000 ) ; g. krein , d.p .
menezes and m.b .
pinto , phys .
b * 370 * , 5 ( 1996 ) ; m. c. b. abdalla , j. a. helayel - neto , daniel l. nedel and carlos r. senise , jr , phys . rev .
d * 77 * , 125020 ( 2008 ) .
kneur , m. b. pinto and r. o. ramos , phys .
d * 74 * , 125020 ( 2006 ) ; j .-
kneur , m. b. pinto , r. o. ramos and e. staudt , phys .
d * 76 * , 045020 ( 2007 ) ; phys .
b * 657 * , 136 ( 2007 ) ; e. s. fraga , l. f. palhares and m. b. pinto , phys .
d * 79 * , 065026 ( 2009 ) .
m. abramowitz and i. a. stegun ( eds . ) , _ handbook of mathematical functions with formulas , graphs , and mathematical tables _ , ( new york , nj , dover , 1972 ) ; t. m. apostol , amer .
monthly * 106 * , 409 ( 1999 ) ; g. arfken , `` bernoulli numbers , euler - maclaurin formula .
'' sec . 5.9 in _ mathematical methods for physicists _ , ( 3rd ed .
orlando , fl , academic press , 1985 ) . | symmetry restoration in a theory of a self - interacting charged scalar field at finite temperature and in the presence of an external magnetic field is examined .
the effective potential is evaluated nonperturbatively in the context of the optimized perturbation theory method .
it is explicitly shown that in all ranges of the magnetic field , from weak to large fields , the phase transition is second order and that the critical temperature increases with the magnetic field .
in addition , we present an efficient way to deal with the sum over the landau levels , which is of interest especially in the case of working with weak magnetic fields . |
erds noticed @xcite that any graph @xmath3 with minimum degree @xmath4 at least @xmath5 contains a spanning , bipartite subgraph @xmath6 with @xmath7 .
the proof for this fact is obtained by taking a maximal edge - cut , a partition of @xmath8 into two sets @xmath9 and @xmath10 , such that the number of edges with one endpoint in @xmath9 and one in @xmath10 , denoted @xmath11 , is maximal .
observe that if some vertex @xmath12 in @xmath9 does not have degree at least @xmath1 in @xmath13 $ ] , then by moving @xmath12 to @xmath10 , one would increase @xmath11 , contrary to maximality .
the same argument holds for vertices in @xmath10 .
in fact this proves that for each vertex @xmath14 , by taking such a subgraph @xmath6 , the degree of @xmath12 in @xmath6 , denoted @xmath15 , is at least @xmath16 .
this will be used throughout the paper .
thomassen observed that the same proof shows the following stronger statement .
given a graph @xmath3 which is at least @xmath17 _ edge - connected _ ( that is one must remove at least @xmath5 edges in order to disconnect the graph ) , then @xmath3 contains a bipartite subgraph @xmath6 for which @xmath6 is @xmath1 edge - connected .
in fact , each edge - cut keeps at least half of its edges .
this observation led thomassen to conjecture that a similar phenomena also holds for _ vertex - connectivity_. before proceeding to the statement of thomassen s conjecture , we remind the reader that a graph @xmath3 is said to be @xmath1 _ vertex - connected _ or @xmath1-_connected _ if one must remove at least @xmath1 vertices from @xmath8 in order to disconnect the graph ( or to remain with one single vertex ) .
we also let @xmath18 denote the minimum integer @xmath1 for which @xmath3 is @xmath1-connected . roughly speaking
, thomassen conjectured that any graph with high enough connectivity also should contain a @xmath1-connected spanning , bipartite subgraph .
the following appears as conjecture 7 in @xcite .
[ conj7 ] for all @xmath1 , there exists a function @xmath0 such that for all graphs @xmath3 , if @xmath19 , then there exists a spanning , bipartite @xmath20 such that @xmath21 . in this paper
we prove that conjecture [ conj7 ] holds up to a @xmath2 factor by showing the following : [ thm : graph ] for all @xmath1 and @xmath22 , and for every graph @xmath3 on @xmath22 vertices the following holds . if @xmath23 , then there exists a spanning , bipartite subgraph @xmath20 such that @xmath21 .
because of the @xmath2 factor , we did not try to optimize the dependency on @xmath1 in theorem [ thm : graph ] .
however , it looks like our proof could be modified to give slightly better bounds .
in this section , we introduce a number of preliminary results .
the first tool is the following useful theorem due to mader @xcite .
[ mader ] every graph of average degree at least @xmath24 has an @xmath25-connected subgraph .
because we are interested in finding bipartite subgraphs with high connectivity , the following corollary will be helpful .
[ cor : maderbipartite ] every graph @xmath3 with average degree at least @xmath26 contains a ( not necessarily spanning ) bipartite subgraph @xmath6 which is at least @xmath25-connected .
let @xmath3 be such a graph and let @xmath27 be a partition of @xmath8 such that @xmath11 is maximal .
observe that @xmath28 , and therefore , the bipartite graph @xmath29 with parts @xmath9 and @xmath10 has average degree at least @xmath24 .
now , by applying theorem [ mader ] to @xmath29 we obtain the desired subgraph @xmath6 .
we will also make use of the following easy expansion lemma .
[ lemma : joining two k connected graphs ] let @xmath30 and @xmath31 be two vertex - disjoint graphs , each of which is @xmath1-connected .
let @xmath6 be a graph obtained by adding @xmath1 independent edges between these two graphs .
then , @xmath32 .
note first that by construction , one can not remove all the edges between @xmath30 and @xmath31 by deleting fewer than @xmath1 vertices .
moreover , because @xmath30 and @xmath31 are both @xmath1-connected , each will remain connected after deleting less than @xmath1 vertices . from here
, the proof follows easily .
next we will show how to merge a collection of a few @xmath1-connected components and single vertices into one @xmath1-connected component . before stating the next lemma formally , we will need to introduce some notation .
let @xmath33 be @xmath34 vertex - disjoint @xmath1-connected graphs , let @xmath35 be a set consisting of @xmath36 vertices which are disjoint to @xmath37 for @xmath38 , and let @xmath39 be a @xmath1-connected graph on the vertex set @xmath40 .
also let @xmath41 be a @xmath42-tuple and @xmath43 denote the @xmath44th element of @xmath45 .
finally , let @xmath46 denote the family consisting of all graphs @xmath3 which satisfy the following : 1 .
the disjoint union of the elements of @xmath45 is a spanning subgraph of @xmath3 , and 2 . for every distinct @xmath47 if @xmath48 , then there exists an edge in @xmath3 between @xmath43 and @xmath49 , and 3 . for every @xmath50
, there is a set of @xmath1 independent edges between @xmath37 and @xmath1 distinct vertex sets @xmath51 , where @xmath52 .
[ merge few into on ] let @xmath33 be @xmath34 vertex - disjoint graphs , each of which is @xmath1-connected , and let @xmath35 be a set of @xmath36 vertices for which @xmath53 for every @xmath54 .
let @xmath39 be a @xmath1-connected graph on the vertex - set @xmath40 , and let @xmath55 .
then , any graph @xmath56 is @xmath1-connected .
let @xmath56 , and let @xmath57 be a subset of size at most @xmath58 .
we wish to show that the graph @xmath59 is still connected .
let @xmath60 be two distinct vertices in @xmath29 ; we show that there exists a path in @xmath29 connecting @xmath61 to @xmath62 . towards this end , we first note that if both @xmath61 and @xmath62 are in the same @xmath63 , then because each @xmath63 is @xmath1-connected
, there is nothing to prove .
moreover , if both @xmath61 and @xmath62 are in distinct elements of @xmath45 which are also disjoint from @xmath64 , then we are also finished , as follows . because @xmath39 is @xmath1-connected ,
if we delete all of the vertices in @xmath39 corresponding to elements of @xmath45 which intersect @xmath64 , the resulting graph is still connected .
therefore , one can easily find a path between the elements containing @xmath61 and @xmath62 which goes only through `` untouched '' elements of @xmath45 , and hence , there exists a path connecting @xmath61 and @xmath62 .
the remaining case to deal with is when @xmath61 and @xmath62 are in different elements of @xmath45 , and at least one of them is not disjoint with @xmath64 .
assume @xmath61 is in some such @xmath43 ( @xmath62 will be treated similarly ) .
using property @xmath65 of @xmath66 , there is at least one edge between @xmath43 and an untouched @xmath49 . therefore one can find a path between @xmath61 and some vertex @xmath67 in an untouched @xmath49
this takes us back to the previous case . a _ directed graph _ or
_ digraph _ is a set of vertices and a collection of directed edges ; note that bidirectional edges are allowed . for a directed graph @xmath68 and a vertex @xmath69 we let @xmath70 denote the out - degree of @xmath12 .
we let @xmath71 denote the _ underlying graph of _ @xmath68 , that is the graph obtained by ignoring the directions in @xmath68 and merging multiple edges . in order to find the desired spanning ,
bipartite @xmath1-connected subgraph in theorem [ thm : graph ] , we look at sub - digraphs in an auxiliary digraph .
the following is our main technical lemma and is the main reason why we have a @xmath2 factor .
[ lem : main ] if @xmath68 is a finite digraph on at most @xmath22 vertices with minimum out - degree @xmath72 then there exists a sub - digraph @xmath73 such that 1 . for all @xmath74 we have @xmath75 , and 2 .
@xmath76 . if @xmath77 , then there clearly is nothing to prove .
so we may assume that @xmath78 .
delete a separating set of size at most @xmath58 .
the smallest component , say @xmath79 , has size at most @xmath80 and for any @xmath81 , every out - neighbor of @xmath12 is either in @xmath82 or in the separating set that we removed , and so @xmath83 we continue by repeatedly applying this step , and note that this process must terminate .
otherwise , after at most @xmath2 steps we are left with a component which consists of one single vertex and yet contains at least one edge , a contradiction .
with the preliminaries out of the way , we are now ready to prove theorem [ thm : graph ] .
as long as @xmath63 contains a bipartite subgraph which is at least @xmath1-connected on at least @xmath86 vertices , let @xmath87 be such a subgraph of maximum size , and let @xmath88 .
note that @xmath30 must exist as @xmath89 and so by corollary [ cor : maderbipartite ] , @xmath90 must contain a @xmath1-connected bipartite subgraph of size at least @xmath91 .
let @xmath92 be the sequence obtained in this manner , and note that all the @xmath93 s are vertex disjoint with @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
observe that if @xmath30 is spanning , then there is nothing to prove . therefore , suppose for a contradiction that @xmath30 is not spanning .
let @xmath96 be the subset of @xmath8 remaining after this process ; note that it might be the case that @xmath97 . because each @xmath93 is a bipartite , @xmath1-connected subgraph of @xmath63 of maximum size and @xmath3
is @xmath98 connected , we show that the following are true : 1 . for every @xmath99
, there are less than @xmath100 independent edges between @xmath93 and @xmath101 , and 2 . for every @xmath102 and @xmath103 ,
the number of edges in @xmath3 between @xmath12 and @xmath93 , denoted by @xmath104 , is less than @xmath105 , and 3 . for every @xmath106
, there exists a set @xmath107 consisting of exactly @xmath86 independent edges , each of which has exactly one endpoint in @xmath93 . indeed , for showing @xmath108 , note that if there are at least @xmath100 independent edges between @xmath93 to @xmath101 , by pigeonhole principle , at least @xmath1 of them are between the same part of @xmath93 ( say @xmath109 ) and the same part of @xmath101 ( say @xmath110 )
therefore , the graph obtained by joining @xmath93 to @xmath101 with this set of at least @xmath1 edges is a @xmath1-connected ( by lemma [ lemma : joining two k connected graphs ] ) , bipartite graph and is larger than @xmath93 , contrary to the maximality of @xmath93 . for showing @xmath111 ,
note that if there are at least @xmath105 between @xmath12 and @xmath93 then there are at least @xmath1 edges incident with @xmath12 touch the same part of @xmath93 , and let @xmath112 be a set of @xmath1 such edges .
second , we mention that joining a vertex of degree at least @xmath1 to a @xmath1-connected graph trivially yields a @xmath1-connected graph
. next , since all the edges in @xmath112 are touching the same part , the graph obtained by adding @xmath12 to @xmath113 and @xmath112 to @xmath114 , will also be bipartite .
this contradicts the maximality of @xmath93 . for @xmath115 , note first that since @xmath30 is not spanning , using @xmath111 we conclude that in the construction of the bipartite subgraphs @xmath92 in the process above , @xmath116 therefore , using corollary [ cor : maderbipartite ] , it follows that @xmath117 contains a bipartite subgraph of size at least @xmath91 which is also @xmath1-connected .
therefore , the process does not terminate at this point , and @xmath31 exists ( that is , @xmath118 ) .
it also follows that for each @xmath106 we have @xmath119 .
next , note that @xmath3 is @xmath120 connected , and that each @xmath93 is of size at least @xmath121 . for each @xmath44 , consider the bipartite graph with parts @xmath113 and @xmath122 and with the edge - set consisting of all the edges of @xmath3 which touch both of these parts .
using knig s theorem ( see @xcite , p. 112 ) , it follows that if there is no such @xmath107 of size @xmath86 , then there exists a set of strictly fewer than @xmath86 vertices that touch all the edges in this bipartite graph ( a vertex cover ) . by deleting these vertices
, one can separate what is left from @xmath93 and its complement , contrary to the fact that @xmath3 is @xmath98 connected . in order to complete the proof
, we wish to reach a contradiction by showing that one can either merge few members of @xmath123 with vertices of @xmath124 into a @xmath1-connected component or find a @xmath1-connected component of size at least @xmath86 which is contained in @xmath124 . in order to do so
, we define an auxiliary digraph , using a special subgraph @xmath125 , and use lemmas [ lem : main ] and [ merge few into on ] to achieve the desired contradiction .
we first describe how to find @xmath29 .
first , we partition @xmath124 into two sets , say @xmath9 and @xmath10 , where @xmath126 and observe that , using @xmath111 , since @xmath127 , any vertex @xmath128 must send edges to more than @xmath129 distinct elements in @xmath130 . for each @xmath131
, let @xmath107 be a set as described in @xmath115 .
observe that , using @xmath111 , each such @xmath107 touches more than @xmath132 distinct elements of @xmath133 .
let @xmath134 be a subset of size exactly @xmath135 such that each pair of edges in @xmath136 touches two distinct elements of @xmath133 , which of course are distinct from @xmath63 .
recall that @xmath137 for every @xmath131 .
let @xmath140 be mutually independent random variables .
for each @xmath106 , if @xmath141 , then let @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
otherwise , let @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
for every @xmath146 , if @xmath147 , then let @xmath148 , and otherwise @xmath149
. now , delete all of the edges between two distinct elements of @xmath150 which receive the same label according to @xmath151 .
finally , define @xmath29 as the spanning bipartite graph of @xmath3 obtained by deleting all of the edges within @xmath9 and for distinct @xmath44 and @xmath152 , the edges between @xmath93 and @xmath101 which are not contained in @xmath153 .
recall by construction , using @xmath151 we generated labels at random ; therefore , by using chernoff bounds ( for instance see @xcite ) , one can easily check that with high probability the following hold : 1 . for every @xmath106 , each set @xmath154 touches at least ( say ) @xmath155 other elements of @xmath45 , and 2 .
for each @xmath156 , the degree of @xmath157 into @xmath158 is at least ( say ) @xmath159 , and 3 . for each vertex @xmath160
, there exist edges between @xmath161 and @xmath162 that touch at least ( say ) @xmath163 distinct members of @xmath123 .
now we are ready to define our auxiliary digraph @xmath68 . to this end
, we first orient edges ( again , bidirectional edges are allowed , and un - oriented edges are considered as bidirectional ) of @xmath29 in the following way : for every @xmath106 , we orient all of the edges in @xmath164 out of @xmath93 .
we orient all of the edges between @xmath9 and @xmath162 out of @xmath9 .
we orient edges between @xmath10 and @xmath162 arbitrarily , and we orient the remaining edges within @xmath158 in both directions .
now , we define @xmath68 to be the digraph with vertex set @xmath165 , and @xmath166 if and only if there exists an edge between @xmath61 and @xmath62 in @xmath29 which is oriented from @xmath61 to @xmath62 . in order to complete the proof
, we first note that with high probability @xmath68 is a digraph on at most @xmath22 vertices with out - degree @xmath167 .
this follows immediately from properties @xmath168-@xmath65 as well as the way we oriented the edges .
therefore , one can apply lemma [ lem : main ] to find a sub - digraph @xmath169 such that in fact , with high probability , @xmath170 note that by construction , every pair of edges which are oriented out of some @xmath93 must be independent and go to different components . using property @xmath171 above combined with the fact that @xmath172 , we may conclude that the subgraph @xmath173 induced by the union of all the components in @xmath174 satisfies @xmath175 . applying lemma
[ merge few into on ] with @xmath176 and @xmath177 , it follows that @xmath178 .
* case 1 : * @xmath179 contains @xmath113 for some @xmath44 .
we note that this case is actually impossible because it would contradict the maximality of @xmath93 for the minimal index @xmath44 such that @xmath180 .
* case 2 : * @xmath181 .
we note that in this case , there must be at least one vertex @xmath182 .
indeed , @xmath183 is @xmath1-connected , and there are no edges within @xmath9 .
now , it follows from properties @xmath171 and @xmath184 above that @xmath185 thus , it follows that @xmath186 . combining this observation with the facts that @xmath183 is @xmath1-connected and @xmath181
, we obtain a contradiction .
this case can not arise because @xmath183 should have been included as one of the bipartite subgraphs @xmath187
. * acknowledgments . *
the authors would like to thank the anonymous referees for valuable comments .
the second author would also like to thank andrzej grzesik , hong liu and cory palmer for fruitful discussions in a previous attempt to attack this problem . | in 1989 , thomassen asked whether there is an integer - valued function @xmath0 such that every @xmath0-connected graph admits a spanning , bipartite @xmath1-connected subgraph . in this paper
we take a first , humble approach , showing the conjecture is true up to a @xmath2 factor . |
the investigation of the specific heat @xmath2 is an important tool for understanding the nature of the superconductivity and anisotropy of the superconducting gap @xmath3 on the fermi surface @xmath4 .
historically the relative specific heat jump @xmath5 was used to establish the bcs picture@xcite for the conventional superconductors having nearly isotropic gap .
subsequently the thermodynamics of clean anisotropic - gap superconductors was analyzed in the weak coupling approximation by pokrovsky and ryvkin .
@xcite they have found that anisotropy suppresses the value @xmath5 in comparison to its isotropic value 1.43 .
this inequality is not satisfied in classical low - temperature superconductors partly because they are not extremely clean , but also since the weak coupling approximation has a poor precision .
geilikman and kresin @xcite have proved that the first correction due to interaction increases @xmath5 and thus disguises the anisotropy effect .
the modern superconductors display really high anisotropy .
in particular , superconductivity is highly anisotropic in mgb@xmath1 .
this fact is the main motivation of this work .
it is well known that only superconducting crystals of very high quality can reach the theoretical clean - limit asymptotics . as a rule ,
the reduced specific heat jump is sample - dependent and understanding of this disorder dependence is a challenging problem .
the latter is especially important for mgb@xmath6 a compound now being in the limelight of superconductor materials science .
the aim of the present paper is to derive the dependence of the critical temperature and the relative specific heat jump @xmath7 on the elastic scattering time of the charge carriers at the critical temperature @xmath8 for two - band superconductors having in mind application to mgb@xmath1 .
for this purpose we need corresponding formulae for a general dirty anisotropic superconductor .
such equations were derived in @xcite .
we reproduce them here for readers convenience and because there occurred several misprints in the cited work which we correct here . in the @xmath9-approximation the electrical resistivity of the normal metal @xmath10
is determined by this scattering time .
thus , our formula can be used for the investigation of correlations in the experimentally determined @xmath5 versus @xmath11 plot .
the comparison of the theoretical curve and the experimental data can reveal the gap anisotropy @xmath12 and the scattering rate @xmath13 .
the gap can depend on both the quasimomentum @xmath14 and the band index @xmath15 the applicability of the weak - coupling theory to mgb@xmath1 is contentious .
however , experimental results on the relative specific heat discontinuity@xcite indicate that the anisotropy effect is more profound than the effect of interaction . for this compound ,
the reduced specific heat @xmath5 is definitely smaller than the weak - coupling bcs value 1.43 .
moreover the temperature dependence of the specific heat of the superconducting phase is described fairly well@xcite by the two - band model@xcite and the relative specific heat jump agrees@xcite with the moskalenko s weak - coupling formula.@xcite the comparison of the latter and the _ ab initio _ strong - coupling calculations@xcite for mgb@xmath1 shows that the decrease of @xmath5 due to different values of the superconducting gap for different bands is at least 2 times bigger than the increase of this reduced specific heat jump due to the strong coupling effects .
we discuss this point in the concluding discussion .
in this section we reproduce some results for an anisotropic clean superconductors obtained by different authors many years ago and derive equation for the specific jump discontinuity in this case .
though neither of these results is new , they are necessary for understanding nest sections.it was shown in ref .
that , within the framework of the weak - coupling theory , the order parameter possesses the property of separability : @xmath16 according to eq .
( [ sep ] ) , the temperature dependence characterized by the factor @xmath17 is separated from the angular dependence described by the factor @xmath18 . the ginzburg - landau ( gl ) expansion for the free energy density@xcite can be written in terms of the temperature - dependent factor @xmath17 alone : @xmath19 the specific heat jump per unit volume is related to the gl coefficients by the following relation : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the specific heat per unit volume of the superconducting phase and @xmath22 is that of the normal phase .
our starting point are the expressions of gorkov and melik - barkhudarov@xcite for the gl coefficients in the clean limit which can be written as @xmath23 where the hurwitz and the riemann zeta functions , @xmath24 and @xmath25 , respectively , read @xmath26 and obey the relation @xmath27 a simple variational derivation of eq .
( [ eq : glclean ] ) is given in ref . .
the celebrity of @xmath28 in mathematics has been discussed in ref . .
the normalized moments of the gap anisotropy function are determined by averaging over the fermi surface , having the general form in the @xmath29-dimensional case @xmath30 where @xmath31 is an infinitesimal surface element and @xmath32 is the quasiparticle velocity . the quasi - momentum space integral is taken over the whole brillouin zone ( bz ) .
the integration over the fermi surface @xmath4 implicitly includes summation over fragments and sheets of different bands , if any .
the normalizing factor @xmath33 is the density of states ( dos ) per unit volume for fixed spin , and enters the normal - phase specific heat @xmath34 this equation together with the formulae for the gl coefficients , eq .
( [ eq : glclean ] ) , lead to the following value for the reduced jump of the specific heat @xmath35 which is exactly the result obtained in refs . ; for a methodical derivation see ref . . using eq .
( [ eq : glclean ] ) for @xmath36 slightly lower than @xmath37 we get for the equilibrium order parameter @xmath38 which is the result by gorkov and melik - barkhudarov.@xcite
in this subsection we analyze the transition temperature @xmath0 as a function of the elastic scattering rate @xmath39 and the angular dependence of the order parameter @xmath40 as it was explained before , the angular dependence is the same for any temperature at fixed @xmath9 .
the transition line has been studied in ref . .
although the equations obtained in the latter work were rather general , their treatment was focused on a specific situation a mixture of @xmath41- and @xmath42-pairing characteristic for cuprate superconductors .
therefore , it is useful to analyze the results for a less exotic case of anisotropic @xmath41-pairing . the general equation for the transition line found in ref
. reads @xmath43 where following notations are introduced : @xmath44,\label{f}\\ g(t,\tau ) & = \frac{1}{\pi}\left[\digamma\!\left(x+\frac{1}{2}\right ) -\digamma\!\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)\right ] , \label{g}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath45 ; @xmath46 is the cutoff energy ; @xmath47 is the euler digamma function ; @xmath48 are eigenvalues of the linear operator @xmath49 with kernel @xmath50 equal to the electron - electron effective interaction energy at the fermi surface multiplied by the dos @xmath51 ; @xmath52 are the corresponding eigenfunctions normalized according to the condition @xmath53 .
the transition temperature of the clean superconductor is determined by the equation @xmath54 which gives @xmath55 where @xmath56 @xmath57 is the euler constant , and @xmath58 is the maximum eigenvalue of the operator @xmath59 the angular dependence of the order parameter in this case is given by the corresponding eigenfunction @xmath60 .
as long as @xmath61 remains large the transition temperature @xmath0differs from @xmath62 by insignificant corrections of the order of @xmath63 we call the superconductor moderately dirty if the value @xmath64 becomes small , but @xmath65 is still close to @xmath66 .
more precisely , it means that @xmath67 .
then the solution of eq .
( [ t - line ] ) reads @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the anisotropy coefficient , which is equal to 1 for an isotropic superconductor , and @xmath70 in this range of the scattering rate the angular dependence of the gap @xmath18 is identical to that for the clean superconductor : @xmath71 .
thus , the transition temperature decreases in a power - like way with the increase of the scattering rate @xmath39 or the residual resistivity @xmath72 proportional to this rate .
this is a peculiarity of the anisotropic superconductor .
the exponent in eq .
( [ hohenberg ] ) is zero for the isotropic superconductor , cf .
equation ( [ hohenberg ] ) was first derived by hohenberg@xcite for weakly anisotropic superconductors .
its validity for arbitrary @xmath73 in the range of moderate dirt was proved in ref . .
we call the dirt strong if the parameter @xmath74 becomes less than @xmath66 and has the order of magnitude of @xmath75 and if the difference @xmath76 is not small in comparison to @xmath66 .
equation ( [ hohenberg ] ) remains qualitatively correct , but @xmath73 becomes a slowly varying function of @xmath9 .
the exact formula for the transition temperature in this range is given by eq .
( 37 ) of ref . .
in the extra - dirty limit @xmath77 becomes much smaller than @xmath66 , but still @xmath78 the last inequality ensures that the elastic scattering does not destroy the fermi surface . in the extra - dirty limit the angular dependence of the gap reaches its limiting value @xmath79 , where @xmath80 .
the equation for @xmath0 in the extra - dirty limit reads : @xmath81 where @xmath82 it should be noted that @xmath83 in the last equation differs from that for the clean superconductor , namely : @xmath84 the theory of dirty anisotropic superconductors @xcite was based on the green s functions method combined with the abrikosov - gorkov averaging over the random impurity field.@xcite a simplifying assumption was the isotropy of the scattering which is characterized by a constant rate @xmath39 .
in particular , the authors derived the gl equations and gl coefficients with an accuracy of a common scaling factor@xcite ( see also an earlier article @xcite for the representation accepted in this article this factor is @xmath85 , as it follows from the comparison of eq .
( [ eq : glclean ] ) and eqs . ( 48 ) , ( 60 ) , ( 78)(82 ) in ref . .
correcting a misprint in eq .
( 59 ) in ref . , further repeated in eqs .
( 61 ) , ( 82 ) therein , and slightly regrouping terms we find : @xmath86 , \label{a}\ ] ] @xmath87 & & \qquad\qquad\quad + 2\left\langle \chi^{2}\right\rangle \left\langle \chi \right\rangle^{2 } \left(x_{c}^{3}\zeta_{4,2}+x_{c}^{2}\zeta_{3,2}\right)\nonumber\\[5pt ] & & \qquad\qquad\quad\left .
+ \left\langle \chi \right\rangle^{4}x_{c}^{4}\zeta_{4,3}\right ] , \label{eq : dirty}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 is the dimensionless scattering rate extrapolated to the critical temperature .
the resistivity of the normal metal @xmath89 is determined by the drude formula : @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the effective mass tensor and @xmath92 is the density of normal charge carriers ; for clean crystals the total volume density of all charge carriers , electrons and holes , @xmath93 , can be determined by the hall constant @xmath94 in strong magnetic fields . for clean superconductors , disregarding some subtleties , the same ratio @xmath95 enters the london penetration depth @xmath96 at @xmath97 @xmath98 where in gaussian units @xmath99 @xmath100 0.11 @xmath101 m .
multiplying these equations we obtain a useful estimate @xmath102 the notation @xmath103 in eq .
( [ eq : dirty ] ) stands for the generalized zeta - functions defined in ref . and
taken at the value of the argument @xmath104 , i.e.@xcite @xmath105 for the readers convenience we recall the definition of these functions : @xmath106 they represent a natural generalization of the hurwitz zeta functions : @xmath107 below we provide the asymptotics of @xmath108 for @xmath109 necessary for the further calculations : @xmath110z^{-k-1 } , \quad & \text{for}\quad & l\ge2,{\nonumber}\\ \zeta_{k,1}(z ) \sim & z^{-k}\ln z , \quad & \text{for}\quad & k\ge1,{\nonumber}\\ \zeta_{k,0}(z ) \sim & ( k-1)^{-1}z^{-k+1 } , \quad & \text{for}\quad & k >
1 . \label{eq
: zetaasymp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] let us note that , for integer arguments @xmath111 , the hurwitz zeta functions are associated with the euler polygamma function @xmath112 : @xmath113 with these notations the reduced discontinuity of the specific heat reads : @xmath114 where @xmath115 ^ 2{\nonumber}\\[5pt ] & \quad\;\times \left [ \left\langle \chi ^{4}\right\rangle \zeta_{3,0 } -\left\langle \chi^{2}\right\rangle^{2}x_{c}\zeta_{4,0}\right . { \nonumber}\\[5pt ]
& \qquad\quad + 4\left\langle \chi^{3}\right\rangle \left\langle \chi \right\rangle x_{c}\zeta_{3,1}{\nonumber}\\[5pt ] & \qquad\quad + 2\left\langle \chi^{2}\right\rangle \left\langle \chi \right\rangle^{2 } \left(x_{c}^{3}\zeta_{4,2}+x_{c}^{2}\zeta_{3,2}\right)\nonumber\\[5pt ] & \qquad\quad \left .
+ \left\langle \chi \right\rangle^{4}x_{c}^{4}\zeta_{4,3 } \right ] ^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this general equation will be applied in the following subsections to some important special cases .
it should be stressed that for isotropic superconductors , @xmath116 , the specific heat jump is impurity independent : @xmath117 .
the proof is straightforward taking into account the identity @xmath118 likewise , using eq .
( [ eq : zetaasymp ] ) one can prove that the asymptotic form of @xmath5 for an extremely disordered superconductor with an arbitrary anisotropy is given by , to leading order in @xmath119 , @xmath120.\ ] ] keeping in mind the application to mgb@xmath1 ( for a review see ref . ) , we apply the general results of the previous sections to a simplified model of a two - band superconductor . in this model
we assume that the fermi surface consists of two disconnected sheets having different dos . the interaction amplitude @xmath121 is assumed to be a constant within each band .
thus , it can be described by a @xmath122 matrix : @xmath123 where @xmath124 are the interaction energies between any two points within the first and the second sheet of the fermi surface , respectively ; @xmath125 is the interaction between any two points of different bands .
let us first work out the transition temperature @xmath62 and the order parameter @xmath126 for a clean two - band superconductor.@xcite for our simplified model the order parameter @xmath127 is a constant within each band , i.e. it can be represented by a 2-component vector : @xmath128 the eigenvectors @xmath129 of the operator @xmath49 obey the following linear equations : @xmath130 where the coefficients @xmath131 are the statistical weights of the two bands , which reflect the integral character of the operator @xmath49 .
the two independent eigenvalues of eqs .
( [ 2b - eqs ] ) read @xmath132 where @xmath133
the corresponding eigenvectors are : @xmath134 this is apparently a kind of the bogolyubov transformation .
both vectors are normalized : @xmath135 the average values of the anisotropic eigenfunctions read : @xmath136 it is useful to write simple expressions for the squared averages : @xmath137,\\ \ { \left<}\psi_{+}{\right>}^2&+{\left<}\psi_{-}{\right>}^2=1 , \quad{\left<}\chi{\right>}^2={\left<}\psi_{+}{\right>}^2 .
\label{av - square}{\nonumber}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the gap ratio @xmath138 eq .
( [ psi+ ] ) gives @xmath139 whence the moments of the anisotropy function read @xmath140 using the general results formulated earlier , we find the transition temperature of the clean two - band superconductor : @xmath141 equation ( [ t - line ] ) for the critical curve within this model can be simplified to the form : @xmath142 { \nonumber}\\ = ( 1-\lambda_+ f)(1- \lambda_- f ) .
\label{2b - t - line}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we have denoted @xmath143 and abbreviated the functions @xmath65 and @xmath144 as @xmath145 and @xmath146 , respectively , cf .
( [ f ] ) , ( [ g ] ) .
it is convenient to introduce the dimensionless scattering rate @xmath147 and the dimensionless transition temperature @xmath148 ; @xmath149 . in terms of these variables
the functions @xmath145 and @xmath146 read : @xmath150 the equation for @xmath0 finally reads @xmath151{\nonumber}\\ = \left(1-f\lambda_{+}\right)\left(1-f\lambda_{-}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath152 to give a realization of the possible dependence @xmath153 , we have made a numerical calculation setting@xcite @xmath154 @xmath155 @xmath156 and @xmath157 ; other authors give slightly different values , cf . refs . .
the results for @xmath158 and @xmath5 vs @xmath159 are shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] . in the asymptotic regions of moderate and extreme dirt eq .
( [ hohenberg ] ) is valid with @xmath160^{-1 } = \frac{c_1\delta^2+c_2}{\left(c_1\delta+c_2\right)^2}\]]for the clean and moderate dirt cases , and @xmath161for the extreme dirt case .
the order parameter in the moderate dirt range is proportional to @xmath162 . in the range of strong disorder
it reads : @xmath163 in the limit of extreme disorder @xmath164 it tends to the limiting value : @xmath165 it is worthwhile to note that at @xmath166 the anisotropy parameter @xmath73 is equal to 1 for any value of the scattering rate independently on the values @xmath167 , and all thermodynamical values do not depend on @xmath9 similarly to the completely isotropic case . for two - band model : the reduced critical temperature @xmath148 versus dimensionless scattering rate @xmath168 .
the set of parameters corresponds to mgb@xmath1 ; for details see the text .
( b ) reduced specific heat jump @xmath5 as a function of the dimensionless scattering rate @xmath169 for the same set of parameters .
the dashed line indicates the asymptotic ( bcs ) value for @xmath170 .
the curve will be shifted up by about 20% due to the strong - coupling effects .
[ fig:1],title="fig : " ] + for two - band model : the reduced critical temperature @xmath148 versus dimensionless scattering rate @xmath168 .
the set of parameters corresponds to mgb@xmath1 ; for details see the text .
( b ) reduced specific heat jump @xmath5 as a function of the dimensionless scattering rate @xmath169 for the same set of parameters .
the dashed line indicates the asymptotic ( bcs ) value for @xmath170 .
the curve will be shifted up by about 20% due to the strong - coupling effects .
[ fig:1],title="fig : " ] we note that the normalization factors of the gap - anisotropy function and the superconducting gap cancel each other in the formulae for the experimentally measurable jump of the specific heat .
therefore , we can use the normalization @xmath171 without loss of generality .
the calculations made above can be used directly to find the averages necessary for the calculation of the specific heat .
the influence of the disorder on the relative specific heat discontinuity for a two - band superconductor is shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] ( b ) . in the extreme dirty limit
we find that the relative specific heat discontinuity tends to its isotropic value in agreement with the fact that the density of states becomes isotropic in this limit.@xcite it is straightforward to verify that in the isotropic case ( @xmath172 on the fermi surface ) the coefficients @xmath173 and @xmath174 do not depend on @xmath9 .
thus , neither the energy gap , nor the specific heat are influenced by impurities , in accordance with the anderson theorem.@xcite analyzing eq .
( [ t - line ] ) , we conclude that the transition temperature also does not depend on the scattering rate . indeed , in the isotropic case the eigenfunctions of the operator @xmath49 are spherical harmonics @xmath175 . among the latter only one
, @xmath176 has a nonzero average .
thus , eq . ( [ t - line ] ) takes the simple form : @xmath177 according to the definitions ( [ f ] ) and ( [ g ] ) , the sum @xmath178 does not depend on the scattering rate .
hence , @xmath0 also does not depend on the scattering rate .
the separable approximation @xmath179 where @xmath180 is very often used for modelling of the gap anisotropy in superconductors @xmath181 . as we demonstrated earlier , this approximation is valid in the range of clean and moderately dirty superconductors . applying this approximation to the equation for @xmath0 in two - band model eq .
( [ eq : tc2band ] ) we obtain moskalenko and palistrant,@xcite abrikosov@xcite and kogan s equation@xcite @xmath182 , \label{eq : ag}\ ] ] where@xcite @xmath183 , and @xmath184 and @xmath185 are rates of interband scattering .
the results of the numerical solution of this equation are depicted on fig .
[ fig:2 ] . for superconductors with zero
averaged gap @xmath186 which are @xmath187- and @xmath42-type superconductors , for example , this equation formally coincides with the abrikosov - gorkov result@xcite for superconductors with magnetic impurities ; superconductivity disappears at the critical value @xmath188 for weak disorder we have @xmath189 in such a way one of the most important properties of multigap and anisotropic superconductors is that the nonmagnetic impurities are pair breaking , similar to magnetic impurities in conventional superconductors.@xcite a similar influence of structural defects was discussed by abrikosov@xcite for triplet superfluids .
the reduction of the critical temperature by disorder has been observed for layered cuprates,@xcite for impurity scattering in triplet superconductor@xcite upt@xmath190 and recently for mgb@xmath1.@xcite only dimensionless ratios of the gap function moments , like @xmath191 in eq .
( [ eq : ag ] ) , or @xmath192 in eq .
( [ eq : jump ] ) are relevant for the thermodynamics of superconductors .
this explains why strongly anisotropic - gap layered cuprates were seemingly successfully analyzed as two - band superconductors@xcite ( this reference is a comprehensive review of the properties of multigap superconductors ) , and vice versa why the first prominent two - gap superconductor mgb@xmath1 could be analyzed as if it were a single - band anisotropic - gap superconductor;@xcite cf .
ref . .
vs @xmath193 for different gap anisotropies @xmath194 0 , 0.2 , 0.4 , 0.6 , 0.8 , and 1 . for an isotropic superconductor , @xmath195 ,
the critical temperature is disorder independent while for @xmath187- or @xmath42-type superconductors ( as some cuo@xmath1 superconductors are ) @xmath196 and the transition line is exactly the same as the abrikosov - gorkov@xcite curve for magnetic impurities in isotropic superconductors .
[ fig:2 ] ]
in order to investigate @xmath5 versus @xmath197 correlations it is necessary to have a good method for the determination of @xmath198 this could be far - infrared measurement of the high - frequency conductivity , or merely the static resistivity . for polycrystalline materials
one has to use compounds like mgb@xmath1 with good connections between grains .
the variation of the residual resistivity can be produced by radiation .
for mgb@xmath1 the gap ratio @xmath199 can be determined by spectroscopic measurements , and the ratio of the dos @xmath200 can be calculated from first principles . under these conditions , for high - quality clean samples we can evaluate the up - shift of the @xmath7 curve , and the influence of strong - coupling effects .
another complication is related to the variation of the electron wave functions in the two bands .
this can lead to different scattering rates in the two bands .
we consider that the scattering rate in the @xmath201-band with bigger gap is more important for the disorder reduction of the specific heat jump .
if the scattering time can not be determined by spectroscopic measurements we can use the value of the resistivity at the critical temperature @xmath202 .
thus , the dependence of @xmath0 and the relative specific heat jump on resistivity at @xmath203 will be given by our formula and fig .
[ fig:2 ] , fig .
[ fig:1 ] ( b ) , with the scale of the abscissa being a fitting parameter .
we expect that the derived weak - coupling formula can be as useful for the analysis of @xmath204 versus @xmath205 correlations as the weak - coupling theory was successful in describing the temperature dependence of the specific heat for the clean mgb@xmath1 samples.@xcite thus , we conclude that the weak - coupling theory of the impurity reduction of the specific heat jump can reveal the main trend and qualitative properties of the effect .
irradiated superconductors are also a good example for the application of the present theory . furthermore , let us note that conventional dirty superconducting alloys , for which a big enough series of samples with continuously changing resistivity can be prepared , are the best tools to investigate the influence of disorder on the thermodynamics of superconductors .
finally , let us summarize our results .
( _ i _ ) in anisotropic superconductors the transition temperature is suppressed by disorder like @xmath206 where @xmath207 is an anisotropy parameter which is a slowly varying function of @xmath9 .
( _ ii _ ) the order parameter retains its angular dependence until @xmath208 whereas the dos becomes isotropic for @xmath209 the anisotropy of the order parameter can be probed in tunneling experiments .
( _ iii _ ) the specific heat is suppressed by disorder just like @xmath0 , with an accuracy of a slowly varying factor .
( _ iv _ ) the relative jump of the specific heat @xmath210 is smaller than its isotropic value in the clean limit .
it is enhanced by disorder tending to its isotropic limit in the extreme disordered case .
( _ v _ ) in isotropic superconductors , and the two - band model with @xmath211 and arbitrary @xmath212 @xmath213 and @xmath214 do not depend on the scattering rate @xmath215 in particular this is the case for @xmath216 this work was supported by the flemish government programme goa and iuap .
vlp acknowledges support from nsf under the grant dmr0072115 and by the humboldt foundation .
he is also thankful to prof .
w. selke and rwth aachen for the hospitality . 99 j. bardeen , l. n. cooper , and j. r. schrieffer , phys .
rev . * 108 * , 1175 ( 1957 ) , eq .
v. l. pokrovskii , zh .
* 40 * , 641 ( 1961 ) [ sov .
jetp * 13 * , 447 ( 1961 ) ] . v. l. pokrovski and m. s. ryvkin , zh . exp .
. fiz . * 43 * , 92 ( 1962 ) [ sov . phys
. jetp * 16 * , 67 ( 1963 ) ] .
s. v. pokrovsky and v. l. pokrovsky , phys .
rev . b * 54 * , 13275 ( 1996 ) .
y. wang , t. plackowski , and a. junod , physica c * 355 * , 179 ( 2001 ) .
f. bouquet , y. wang , r. a. fisher , d. g. hinks , j. d. jorgensen , a. junod , and n. e. phillips , europhys .
lett . * 56 * , 856 ( 2001 ) .
v. a. moskalenko , fiz . met .
metalloved .
* 8 * , 503 ( 1959 ) [ phys . met .
( ussr ) * 8 * , 25 ( 1959 ) ] .
a. a. golubov , j. kortus , o. v. dolgov , o. jepsen , y. kong , o. k. andersen , b. j. gibson , k. ahn , and r. k. kremer , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 14 * , 1353 ( 2002 ) .
l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , _ course on theoretical physics , vol .
5 , statistical physics , part 1 _ ( pergamon press , oxford , 1980 ) , ch . xiv .
v. l. ginzburg and l. d. landau , zh .
fiz . * 20 * , 1064 ( 1950 ) .
e. m. lifshitz and l. pitaevskii , _ course on theoretical physics , vol .
9 , statistical physics , part 2 _ ( pergamon press , oxford , 1981 ) , sec . 45 , sec .
. l. p. gorkov and t. k. melik - barkhudarov , zh . exp .
* 45 * , 1493 ( 1963 ) [ sov .
jetp * 18 * , 1031 ( 1964 ) ] .
t. mishonov and e. penev , int . j. mod
b * 16 * , 3573 ( 2002 ) , cond - mat/0206118 .
j. m. borwein , d. m. braedley , and r. e. crandall , j. comp .
math . * 121 * , 247 ( 2000 ) , sec
b. t. geilikman and v. z. kresin , zh . exp .
pisma * 5 * , 271 ( 1967 ) [ sov .
jetp lett . * 5
* , 220 ( 1967 ) ] . c. buzea and t. yamashita , superconductors , science & technology * 14 * , r115 ( 2001 ) , figs
14 , 15 , and references therein ; cond - mat/0108265 ; s. v. shulga , s .- l .
drechsler , h. eschrig , h. rosner , w. e. pickett , _ the upper critical field problem in mgb@xmath1 _ , cond - mat/0103154 ; h. rosner , j. m. an , w. e. pickett , s .- l .
drechsler , _ fermi surfaces of diborides : mgb@xmath1 and zrb@xmath1 _ , cond - mat/0203030 ; g. fuchs , s .- l .
drechsler , s. v. shulga , k .- h .
mller , a. handstein , k. nenkov , and h. rosner , _ the upper critical field problem and irreversibility line of mgb@xmath1 _ ( unpublished ) .
h. choi , d. roundy , h. sun , m. l. cohen , and s. g. louie , _ first - principles calculation of the superconducting transition in mgb@xmath1 within the anisotropic eliashberg formalism _ , cond - mat/0111182 .
d. a. papaconstantopoulos and m. j. mehl , _ precise tight - binding description of the band structure of mgb@xmath1 _ , cond - math/0106408 .
p. w. anderson , j. phys .
solids * 11 * , 26 ( 1959 ) .
p. c. hohenberg , zh . exp .
* 45 * , 1208 ( 1963 ) [ sov .
jetp * 18 * , 834 ( 1964 ) ] .
a. a. abrikosov and l. p. gorkov , zh . exp .
* 39 * , 1781 ( 1960 ) [ sov .
jetp * 10 * , 593 ( 1960 ) ] ; zh .
35 * , 1558 ( 1959 ) ; zh .
* 36 * , 139 ( 1959 ) .
a. a. abrikosov , l. p. gorkov and i. e. dzyaloshinskii , _ methods of quantum field theory in statistical mechanics _
( dover , new york , 1975 ) . c. h. choi and p. muzikar , phys .
b * 39 * , 11296 ( 1989 ) .
there is a misprint in eq . ( 81 ) of ref . :
the factor @xmath159 in the second term of the expression for the coefficient @xmath217 was missed ; @xmath218 in eq .
( 78 ) was misprinted as @xmath219
. t. takabatake and m. ishikawa , solid state commun .
* 66 * , 413 ( 1988 ) .
v. a. moskalenko , m. e. palistrant , and v. m. vakalyuk , usp .
nauk * 161 * , 155 ( 1991 ) [ sov .
34 * , 717 ( 1991 ) ] ; eq .
( 2.11 ) and eq . (
4.9 ) , fig . 3 and fig . 4 .
h. srikanth , s. sridhar , d. a. gaewsky and m. b. maple , physica c * 291 * , 235 ( 1997 ) .
g. xiao , m. z. cieplak , j. q. xiao and c. l. chien , phys .
rev . b * 42 * , 8752 ( 1990 ) .
y. dalichaouch , m. c. andrade , d. a. gajewski , r. chau , p. visani , and m. b. maple , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 3938 ( 1995 ) .
v. a. moskalenko and m. e. palistrant , zh . exp .
teor . fiz .
* 49 * , 770 ( 1965 ) [ sov .
jetp * 22 * , 536 ( 1966 ) ] .
a. a. abrikosov , physica c * 214 * , 107 ( 1993 ) . v. g. kogan , _ macroscopic anisotropy in superconductors with anisotropic gaps _
, cond - mat/0204038 , eq .
( 13 ) ; phys .
b * 66 * , 020509 ( 2002 ) .
a. a. abrikosov , _ fundamentals of the theory of metals _ ( north holland , amsterdam , 1988 ) , sec . 21 , eq . ( 21.5 ) , sec . 17.1 and references therein .
a. a. abrikosov , physica c * 244 * , 243 ( 1995 ) . s. haas and k. maki , phys . rev . b * 65 * , 020502(r ) ( 2001 ) . t. m. mishonov , e. s. penev , and j. o. indekeu , phys . rev .
b * 66 * , 066501(c ) ( 2001 ) . | the ginzburg - landau coefficients , and the jump of the specific heat are calculated for a disordered two - band superconductor .
we start with the analysis of a more general case arbitrary anisotropy .
while the specific heat discontinuity at the critical temperature @xmath0 decreases with increasing disorder , its ratio to the normal state specific heat at @xmath0 increases and slowly converges to the isotropic value . for a strong disorder
the deviation from the isotropic value is proportional to the elastic electron scattering time . in the case of a two - band superconductor
we apply a simplified model of the interaction independent on momentum within a band . in the framework of this model
all thermodynamic values can be found explicitly at any value of the scattering rate .
this solution explains the sample dependence of the specific heat discontinuity in mgb@xmath1 and the influence of the disorder on the critical temperature . , |
the discovery of features in the x - ray spectra of the thermal emission spectra of the isolated neutron star 1e 1207 @xcite and three other isolated neutron stars has revived the interest in studies of medium-@xmath1 elements in strong magnetic fields .
the reason is that the observed features could be due to atomic transitions in elements that are fusion products of the progenitor star .
however , to calculate synthetic spectra for model atmospheres , and thus to be in a position to draw reliable conclusions from observed spectra to the elemental composition of the atmosphere and the distribution of elements on different ionization stages , accurate atomic data for these elements at very strong magnetic fields ( @xmath2 to @xmath3 t ) are indispensible . while the atomic properties of hydrogen and , partly , helium at such field strengths have been clarified in the literature over the last 25 years ( for a detailed list of references see , e. g. , ref . ) , for elements with nuclear charges @xmath4 only fragmentary atomic data exist with an accuracy necessary for the calculations of synthetic spectra .
we have tackled @xcite the problem by adapting the diffusion monte - carlo method ( dqmc ) @xcite to the case of neutron star magnetic fields .
this method has the advantage that ground - state energies can be determined practically free from approximations .
the basic idea of dqmc is to identify the ground state wave function @xmath5 ( @xmath6 of an @xmath7-body hamiltonian @xmath8 with a _ particle density _ whose correct distribution is found by following the random walk of many test particles ( `` walkers '' ) in imaginary time in 3@xmath7-dimensional configuration space . to reduce fluctuations
one works with a density distribution @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is a given guiding function used for importance sampling .
the density distribution @xmath11 obeys a drift - diffusion equation in imaginary time . because the importance - sampled green s function is an exponential operator
, one can expand it in terms of a euclidean path integral .
for sufficiently small time steps one can write down accurate approximations to the green s function , and sample it with diffusion monte - carlo @xcite .
the choice of the guiding function is crucial for the success of the dqmc procedure .
we take the guiding function @xmath12 as a slater determinant of single - particle orbitals each of which is a product of a landau state in the lowest level with a given magnetic quantum number and an unkown longitudinal wave function ( `` adiabatic approximation '' @xcite ) .
the different longitudinal wave functions are obtained selfconsistently by an iterative solution of the hartree - fock equations using b - splines on finite elements . to incorporate correlation effects
it is common to multiply the guiding function by a jastrow factor , @xmath13 .
we adopt the form @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the magnetic field strength in atomic units ( @xmath16 , @xmath17 t ) .
this leads to modifications of the adiabatic approximation guiding functions only at small distances , of the order of the larmor radius .
as a representative example , fig .
[ fig1 ] shows for the ground state of neutral iron ( @xmath18 ) at @xmath19 t the typical flow of a diffusion quantum monte carlo simulation .
ions can be treated without additional complication in the same way @xcite .
the figure depicts the energy offset @xmath20 , the block energy @xmath21 and the averaged block energy @xmath22 as a function of the number of blocks performed .
the complete simulation goes through three stages . during the first 100 blocks , a variational quantum monte carlo calculation ( vqmc )
is performed . since the adiabatic approximation guiding wave function is augmented by the jastrow factor ,
the vqmc calculation already lowers the energy in comparison with the initial adiabatic approximation result .
this stage is followed , in the next 300 blocks , by a fixed - phase diffusion quantum monte carlo ( fpdqmc ) simulation .
it is seen that the onset of the simulation leads to a considerable drop in the energy .
finally , in the last 300 blocks a released - phase diffusion quantum monte carlo ( rpdqmc ) simulation is carried out , which still slightly lowers the averaged block energy , by roughly 0.1 per cent .
the dashed vertical lines in fig .
[ fig1 ] indicate the blocks where dynamical equilibrium of the walkers is reached .
the relatively small difference between the fixed - phase and the released - phase results indicates that the phase of the adiabatic approximation wave function already well reproduces the phase of the ground state wave function .
the small fluctuations of the individual block energies @xmath21 evident in fig .
[ fig1 ] are characteristic of diffusion quantum monte carlo simulations .
it is also seen , however , that the averaged block energies @xmath23 quickly converge to constant values in all three stages of the simulation .
our final rpdqmc result for the energy is @xmath24 kev and lies well below the density functional ( df ) value .
the standard deviation of the block energies at the end of the simulation in this case is @xmath25 kev .
( ragged curve ) and the averaged block energy @xmath22 ( smooth curve ) in the dqmc simulation for the ground state energy of neutral iron ( @xmath18 ) at @xmath19 t as a function of the number of blocks . in each block , 200 time steps @xmath26a.u . were performed .
( hffem ( top horizontal line ) : energy value in adiabatic approximation ; df ( second horizontal line from top ) : density functional result of ref ; mcph@xmath27 ( third horizontal line from top ) : result of ref . . ) , width=432 ] @xmath28ref . .
@xmath29ref . .
[ table3 ] table [ table3 ] lists the results for all elements from helium to iron at the magnetic field strength @xmath30
t. the table contains in the first three columns the results of the three stages of the simulation and in the fourth column the energy values in adiabatic approximation calculated with our own hartree - fock finite - element method hffem .
literature values obtained by ivanov and schmelcher @xcite ( 2dhf ) , by mori and hailey @xcite ( mcph@xmath27 , multi - configurational perturbative hybrid hartree - hartree - fock ) and the results of density functional calculations @xcite ( df ) are given in the remaining columns .
the numbers in brackets attached to the hffem , 2dhf , mcph@xmath27 and df results designate the number of electrons occupying an excited hydrogen - like single - particle longitudinal state .
it can be seen that already the fixed - phase results lie slightly below the values that were obtained using the 2dhf method .
the comparison with the results of the mcph@xmath27 method shows that our rpdqmc energy values generally lie below those results , but there are also exceptions where our results lie above the mcph@xmath27 energies .
this may be due to the fact that the hybrid method is not self - consistent , since it evaluates the exchange energy in first - order perturbation theory in a basis of hartree states and it does not include the back - reaction of the excited landau states whose admixtures are taken into account perturbatively on the effective interaction potentials . therefore the method need not necessarily produce an upper bound on the energy .
the comparison with the results of the df calculations shows that these yield lower ground state energies at small nuclear charge numbers than our rpdqmc results , while for large @xmath1 the reverse is the case .
the df results listed in table [ table3 ] differ in the choice of the exchange functional .
given this restriction , it can not be ensured that the df calculations in all cases produce an upper bound on the ground state energy in magnetic fields as do the ab - initio methods used in this work or in a ref . .
we have extendend the released - phase diffusion monte carlo method to the calculation of the ground state energies of atoms and ions from helium to iron neutron star magnetic field strengths by using adiabatic approximation wave functions as guiding wave functions @xcite .
however , for matching observed thermal spectra from isolated neutron stars , wavelength information , and thus energies of excited states , are requisite .
jones et al . @xcite have shown a way how to calculate excited states of small atoms in strong magnetic fields using the correlation function monte carlo method @xcite .
the challenge remains to transfer their method to the dqmc simulations presented in this paper , and to calculate excited states of large atoms in intense fields .
this work was supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft within the sfb 382 `` methods and algorithms for simulating physical processes on high - performance computers '' at the universities of tbingen and stuttgart . | the diffusion quantum monte carlo method is extended to solve the old theoretical physics problem of many - electron atoms and ions in intense magnetic fields .
the feature of our approach is the use of adiabatic approximation wave functions augmented by a jastrow factor as guiding functions to initialize the quantum monte carlo prodecure .
we calculate the ground state energies of atoms and ions with nuclear charges from @xmath0 for magnetic field strengths relevant for neutron stars . |
much interest has been aroused in wormholes since the morris - thorne article @xcite .
these act as tunnels from one region of spacetime to another , possibly through which observers may freely traverse .
wormhole physics is a specific example of solving the einstein field equation in the reverse direction , namely , one first considers an interesting and exotic spacetime metric , then finds the matter source responsible for the respective geometry . in this manner
, it was found that these traversable wormholes possess a peculiar property , namely exotic matter , involving a stress - energy tensor that violates the null energy condition @xcite .
in fact , they violate all the known pointwise energy conditions and averaged energy conditions , which are fundamental to the singularity theorems and theorems of classical black hole thermodynamics . the weak energy condition ( wec )
assumes that the local energy density is positive and states that @xmath0 , for all timelike vectors @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the stress energy tensor . by continuity ,
the wec implies the null energy condition ( nec ) , @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is a null vector .
violations of the pointwise energy conditions led to the averaging of the energy conditions over timelike or null geodesics @xcite .
for instance , the averaged weak energy condition ( awec ) states that the integral of the energy density measured by a geodesic observer is non - negative , i.e. , @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the observer s proper time .
although classical forms of matter are believed to obey these energy conditions , it is a well - known fact that they are violated by certain quantum fields , amongst which we may refer to the casimir effect .
pioneering work by ford in the late 1970 s on a new set of energy constraints @xcite , led to constraints on negative energy fluxes in 1991 @xcite .
these eventually culminated in the form of the quantum inequality ( qi ) applied to energy densities , which was introduced by ford and roman in 1995 .
the qi was proven directly from quantum field theory , in four - dimensional minkowski spacetime , for free quantized , massless scalar fields and takes the following form @xmath7 in which , @xmath1 is the tangent to a geodesic observer s wordline ; @xmath6 is the observer s proper time and @xmath8 is a sampling time .
the expectation value @xmath9 is taken with respect to an arbitrary state @xmath10 .
contrary to the averaged energy conditions , one does not average over the entire wordline of the observer , but weights the integral with a sampling function of characteristic width , @xmath8 .
the inequality limits the magnitude of the negative energy violations and the time for which they are allowed to exist .
the basic applications to curved spacetimes is that these appear flat if restricted to a sufficiently small region .
the application of the qi to wormhole geometries is of particular interest .
a small spacetime volume around the throat of the wormhole was considered , so that all the dimensions of this volume are much smaller than the minimum proper radius of curvature in the region .
thus , the spacetime can be considered approximately flat in this region , so that the qi constraint may be applied .
the results of the analysis is that either the wormhole possesses a throat size which is only slightly larger than the planck length , or there are large discrepancies in the length scales which characterize the geometry of the wormhole .
the analysis imply that generically the exotic matter is confined to an extremely thin band , and/or that large red - shifts are involved , which present severe difficulties for traversability , such as large tidal forces .
due to these results , ford and roman concluded that the existence of macroscopic traversable wormholes is very improbable ( see @xcite for an interesting review ) .
it was also shown that , by using the qi , enormous amounts of exotic matter are needed to support the alcubierre warp drive and the superluminal krasnikov tube . however , there are a series of objections that can be applied to the qi .
firstly , the qi is only of interest if one is relying on quantum field theory to provide the exotic matter to support the wormhole throat .
but there are classical systems ( non - minimally coupled scalar fields ) that violate the null and the weak energy conditions , whilst presenting plausible results when applying the qi . secondly , even if one relies on quantum field theory to provide exotic matter , the qi does not rule out the existence of wormholes , although they do place serious constraints on the geometry .
thirdly , it may be possible to reformulate the qi in a more transparent covariant notation , and to prove it for arbitrary background geometries . more recently , visser _ et al _ @xcite , noting the fact that the energy conditions do not actually quantify the `` total amount '' of energy condition violating matter , developed a suitable measure for quantifying this notion by introducing a `` volume integral quantifier ''
. this notion amounts to calculating the definite integrals @xmath11 and @xmath12 , and the amount of violation is defined as the extent to which these integrals become negative .
although the null energy and averaged null energy conditions are always violated for wormhole spacetimes , visser _ et al _ considered specific examples of spacetime geometries containing wormholes that are supported by arbitrarily small quantities of averaged null energy condition violating matter .
it is also interesting to note that by using the `` volume integral quantifier '' , extremely stringent conditions were found on `` warp drive '' spacetimes , considering non - relativistic velocities of the bubble velocity @xcite .
as the violation of the energy conditions is a problematic issue , depending on one s point of view , it is interesting to note that an elegant class of wormhole solutions minimizing the usage of exotic matter was constructed by visser @xcite using the cut - and - paste technique , in which the exotic matter is concentrated at the wormhole throat . using these thin - shell wormholes ,
a dynamic stability was analyzed , either by choosing specific surface equations of state @xcite , or by considering a linearized stability analysis around a static solution @xcite .
one may also construct wormhole solutions by matching an interior wormhole to an exterior vacuum solution , at a junction surface .
in particular , a thin shell around a traversable wormhole , with a zero surface energy density was analyzed in @xcite , and with generic surface stresses in @xcite .
a similar analysis for the plane symmetric case , with a negative cosmological constant , is done in @xcite .
a general class of wormhole geometries with a cosmological constant and junction conditions was analyzed by debenedictis and das @xcite , and further explored in higher dimensions @xcite .
a particularly simple , yet interestingly enough , case is that of a construction of a dust shell around a traversable wormhole . the null energy condition violation at the throat is necessary to maintain the wormhole open , although the averaged null energy condition violating matter can be made arbitrarily small @xcite .
thus , in order to further minimize the usage of exotic matter , one may impose that the surface stress energy tensor obeys the energy conditions at the junction surface . for a pressureless dust shell ,
one need only find the regions in which the surface energy density is non - negative , to determine the regions in which all of the energy conditions are satisfied .
the plan of this paper is as follows : in section ii , we present a specific spacetime metric of a spherically symmetric traversable wormhole , in the presence of a generic cosmological constant , analyzing the respective mathematics of embedding .
we verify that the null energy and the averaged null energy conditions are violated , as was to be expected . using the `` volume integral quantifier '' and considering the specific example of the ellis `` drainhole ''
, we verify that the construction of this spacetime geometry can be made with arbitrarily small quantities of averaged null energy condition violating matter . in section iii
, we present the unique exterior vacuum solution . in section iv , we construct a pressureless dust shell around the interior wormhole spacetime , by matching the latter to the exterior vacuum solution .
we also deduce an expression governing the behavior of the radial pressure across the junction surface . in section
v , we find regions where the surface energy density is positive , thereby satisfying all of the energy conditions at the junction , in order to further minimize the usage of exotic matter . in section vi ,
specific dimensions of the wormhole , namely , the throat radius and the junction interface radius , and estimates of the total traversal time and maximum velocity of an observer journeying through the wormhole , are also found by imposing the traversability conditions .
finally , we conclude in section vii .
consider the following static and spherically symmetric line element ( with @xmath13 ) @xmath14 where @xmath15 and @xmath16 are arbitrary functions of the radial coordinate , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 is the cosmological constant .
@xmath15 is called the redshift function , for it is related to the gravitational redshift .
we shall see ahead that this metric corresponds to a wormhole spacetime , so that @xmath16 can be denoted as the form function , as it determines the shape of the wormhole @xcite .
the radial coordinate has a range that increases from a minimum value at @xmath19 , corresponding to the wormhole throat , to @xmath20 , where the interior spacetime will be joined to an exterior vacuum solution .
consider , without a significant loss of generality , an equatorial slice , @xmath21 , of the line element ( [ metricwormhole ] ) , at a fixed moment of time and a fixed @xmath22 .
the metric is thus reduced to @xmath23 , which can then be embedded in a two - dimensional euclidean space , @xmath24 .
the lift function , @xmath25 , is only a function of @xmath17 , i.e. , @xmath26 .
thus , identifying the radial coordinate , @xmath17 , of the embedding space with the slice considered of the wormhole geometry , we have the condition for the embedding surface , given by @xmath27 to be a solution of a wormhole , the radial coordinate has a minimum value , @xmath28 , denoted as the throat , which defined in terms of the shape function is given by @xmath29 at this value the embedded surface is vertical , i.e. , @xmath30 . as in a general wormhole solution ,
the radial coordinate @xmath17 is ill - behaved near the throat , but the proper radial distance , @xmath31 , is required to be finite throughout spacetime .
this implies that the condition @xmath32 is imposed .
furthermore , one needs to impose that the throat flares out , which mathematically entails that the inverse of the embedding function , @xmath33 , must satisfy @xmath34 at or near the throat .
this flaring - out condition is given by @xmath35 implying that at the throat , @xmath28 or @xmath36 , we have the important condition @xmath37 we will see below that this condition plays a fundamental role in the analysis of the violation of the energy conditions .
using the einstein field equation , @xmath38 , in an orthonormal reference frame with the following set of basis vectors @xmath39 the stress energy tensor components of the metric ( [ metricwormhole ] ) are given by @xmath40 \label{tau}\ , , \\
p_{t}(r)&=&\frac{1}{8\pi}\left [ \left(\frac{\lambda}{3}r^2-\frac{m}{r } \right)\left(\phi ' ' + ( \phi')^2+\frac{\phi'}{r}\right)- \frac{(1+r\phi')}{2r^3}\left(m'r - m-\frac{2\lambda}{3 } r^3\right ) + \lambda \right ] \label{p}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath41 is the energy density , @xmath42 is the radial pressure , and @xmath43 is the pressure measured in the lateral directions , orthogonal to the radial direction . one may readily verify that the null energy condition ( nec ) is violated at the wormhole throat .
the nec states that @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is a null vector . in the orthonormal frame , @xmath46
, we have @xmath47 .\ ] ] due to the flaring out condition of the throat deduced from the mathematics of embedding , i.e. , eq . ( [ flarecondition ] )
, we verify that at the throat @xmath48 , and due to the finiteness of @xmath15 , from eq .
( [ necthroat ] ) we have @xmath49 . matter that violates the nec is denoted as exotic matter .
in particular , one may consider a specific class of form functions that impose that eq .
( [ metricwormhole ] ) is asymptotically flat .
this condition is reflected in the embedding diagram as @xmath50 in the limit @xmath51 , i.e. , @xmath52 as @xmath53 . in this case
we verify that the averaged null energy condition ( anec ) , defined as @xmath54 , is also violated .
@xmath55 is an affine parameter along a radial null geodesic .
carrying out an identical computation as in @xcite , we have @xmath56 one may also consider the `` volume integral quantifier '' , as defined in @xcite , which provides information about the `` total amount '' of anec violating matter in the spacetime . taking into account eq .
( [ necthroat ] ) and performing an integration by parts , the volume integral quantifier is given by @xmath57 \;dr \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] consider , for simplicity , the ellis `` drainhole '' solution @xcite ( also considered in @xcite ) , which corresponds to choosing a zero redshift function , @xmath58 , and the following form function @xmath59 suppose now that the wormhole extends from the throat , @xmath19 , to a radius situated at @xmath20 .
evaluating the volume integral , one deduces @xmath60 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking the limit as @xmath61 , one verifies that @xmath62 .
thus , as in the examples presented in @xcite , with the form function of eq .
( [ homerform ] ) , one may construct a traversable wormhole with arbitrarily small quantities of anec violating matter .
the exotic matter threading the wormhole extends from the throat at @xmath19 to the junction boundary situated at @xmath20 , where the interior solution is matched to an exterior vacuum spacetime .
in general , the solutions of the interior and exterior spacetimes are given in different coordinate systems .
therefore , to distinguish between both spacetimes , the exterior vacuum solution , written in the coordinate system @xmath63 , is given by @xmath64 if @xmath65 , the solution is denoted by the schwarzschild - de sitter spacetime . for @xmath66
, we have the schwarzschild - anti de sitter spacetime , and of course the specific case of @xmath67 is reduced to the schwarzschild solution , with a black hole event horizon at @xmath68 .
note that the metric ( [ metricvacuum ] ) is asymptotically de sitter , if @xmath65 as @xmath69 , or asymptotically anti - de sitter , if @xmath66 , as @xmath70 . for the schwarzschild - de sitter spacetime ,
@xmath71 , if @xmath72 , then the factor @xmath73 possesses two positive real roots ( see @xcite for details ) , @xmath74 and @xmath75 , corresponding to the black hole and the cosmological event horizons of the de sitter spacetime , respectively . in this domain we have @xmath76 and @xmath77 . considering the schwarzschild - anti de sitter metric , with @xmath66 , the factor
@xmath78 has only one real positive root , @xmath74 , corresponding to a black hole event horizon , with @xmath79 ( see @xcite for details ) .
we shall match eqs .
( [ metricwormhole ] ) and ( [ metricvacuum ] ) at a junction surface , @xmath80 , situated at @xmath81 . in order for these line elements to be continuous across the junction , @xmath82
, we consider the following transformations @xmath83 @xmath84 and @xmath18 correspond to the exterior and interior cosmological constants , respectively , which we shall assume continuous across the junction surface , i.e. , @xmath85 .
we shall consider that the junction surface @xmath80 is a timelike hypersurface defined by the parametric equation of the form @xmath86 .
@xmath87 are the intrinsic coordinates on @xmath80 , and @xmath6 is the proper time as measured by a comoving observer on the hypersurface .
the intrinsic metric to @xmath80 is given by @xmath88 note that the junction surface , @xmath89 , is situated outside the event horizon , i.e. , @xmath90 , to avoid a black hole solution .
using the darmois - israel formalism @xcite , the surface stresses at the junction interface are given by @xmath91 with @xmath92 @xcite .
@xmath93 and @xmath94 are the surface energy density and the tangential surface pressure , respectively .
the surface mass of the thin shell is given by @xmath95 .
the total mass of the system , @xmath96 , is provided by the following expression @xmath97 in particular , considering a pressureless dust shell , @xmath98 , from eq .
( [ surfpressure ] ) , we have the following constraint @xmath99 which restricts the values of the redshift parameter , @xmath100 . eliminating the factor containing the form function in eq .
( [ surfenergy ] ) by using eq .
( [ zetarestriction ] ) , the surface energy density is then given by the following relationship @xmath101 \ , , \label{sigma}\ ] ] with @xmath102 .
this expression will be analyzed in the following section .
it is also of interest to obtain an equation governing the behavior of the radial pressure at the junction boundary in terms of the surface stresses at the junction boundary @xcite , given by @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath105 are the radial pressures acting on the shell from the exterior and the interior .
equation ( [ pressurebalance ] ) relates the difference of the radial pressure across the shell in terms of a combination of the surface stresses , @xmath93 and @xmath94 , and the geometrical quantities .
note that @xmath106 for the exterior vacuum solution .
thus , for the particular case of a dust shell , @xmath107 , eq .
( [ pressurebalance ] ) reduces to @xmath108}{\sqrt{1-\frac{2m}{a}-\frac{\lambda}{3}a^2 } } \,.\ ] ]
the weak energy condition ( wec ) on the junction surface implies @xmath109 and @xmath110 , and by continuity implies the null energy condition ( nec ) , @xmath111 .
the strong energy condition ( sec ) at the junction surface reduces to @xmath112 and @xmath113 , and by continuity implies the nec , but not necessarily the wec .
the dominant energy condition ( dec ) implies @xmath109 and @xmath114 . in principle , by taking the limit @xmath115 ( note ,
however , that @xmath90 ) , the `` total amount '' of the energy condition violating matter , of the interior solution , may be made arbitrarily small .
thus , in the spirit of further minimizing the usage of exotic matter , we shall find regions where the energy conditions are satisfied at the junction surface .
for the specific case of a dust shell , this amounts to finding regions where @xmath109 is satisfied .
this shall be done for the schwarzschild spacetime , @xmath116 , the schwarzschild - de sitter solution , @xmath117 , and the schwarzschild - anti de sitter spacetime , @xmath118 . in the analysis that follows we shall only be interested in positive values of @xmath96 . for the schwarzschild spacetime , @xmath116
, one needs to impose that @xmath119 , so that eq .
( [ zetarestriction ] ) reduces to @xmath120 the right hand term is positive , which implies that the redshift parameter is always positive , @xmath121 . equation ( [ sigma ] ) reduces to @xmath122 \,.\ ] ] to analyze this relationship , we shall define a new dimensionless parameter , @xmath123 .
therefore , eq . ( [ schwsigma ] ) may be rewritten in the following compact form @xmath124 with @xmath125 given by @xmath126 \,.\ ] ] equation ( [ schwarzsigma ] ) is depicted in fig .
1 . in the interval @xmath127
, we verify that @xmath128 for @xmath129 , implying a positive energy density , @xmath130 , and thus satisfying all of the energy conditions . for @xmath131 , a boundary surface , @xmath132 ,
is given at @xmath133 .
a positive surface energy density is verified in the following region @xmath134 i.e. , @xmath135 . ) .
we have considered the definition @xmath123 . for @xmath127 and @xmath129
, we verify that @xmath128 . for @xmath131 , with @xmath133 , we have @xmath128
. see text for details.,width=278 ] for the schwarzschild - de sitter spacetime , @xmath117 , consider the definitions of the dimensionless parameters @xmath136 and @xmath123 .
then eq . ( [ zetarestriction ] ) takes the form @xmath137 we verify that the redshift parameter is null , @xmath138 , if the factor @xmath139 is zero , i.e. , @xmath140 , which is represented in fig .
2 . for @xmath121 , we have @xmath141 , or @xmath142 ; for @xmath143 , we have @xmath144 , or @xmath145
. only the region below the solid curve , given by @xmath146 is of interest . the surface energy density , eq .
( [ sigma ] ) , as in the previous case , may be rewritten in the following compact form @xmath147 with @xmath148 given by @xmath149 \,,\ ] ] with @xmath102 .
to analyze eq .
( [ sigmasds ] ) consider a null surface energy density , @xmath150 , i.e. , @xmath151 , so that we deduce the relationship @xmath152 \,,\ ] ] for @xmath153 .
for the particular case of @xmath154 , depicted in fig .
( [ sigmasds ] ) reduces to @xmath155 , which is null for @xmath156 , i.e. , @xmath157 ; positive for @xmath158 , i.e. , @xmath159 ; and negative for @xmath160 , i.e. , @xmath161 .
thus the energy conditions are satisfied in the region to the right of the curve , @xmath162 , depicted in fig .
2 . in the interval , @xmath163
, we verify that @xmath164 , for @xmath165 . for @xmath166 ,
then a non - negative surface energy density is verified for @xmath167 .
the particular case of @xmath168 is depicted in fig .
2 . the energy conditions are also satisfied to the right of the respective curve and to the left of the solid line , @xmath169 . and @xmath123 .
only the region below the solid line is of interest .
the energy conditions are obeyed to the right of each respective dashed curves , @xmath138 , @xmath162 and @xmath168 .
see text for details.,width=230 ] for the schwarzschild - anti de sitter spacetime , @xmath118 , consider the parameters @xmath170 and @xmath123 .
( [ zetarestriction ] ) takes the form @xmath171 the right hand side of eq .
( [ zetarestrictionsads ] ) is always positive , so that the restriction @xmath172 is imposed . the surface energy density , eq .
( [ sigma ] ) , is given in the following compact form @xmath173 with @xmath174 given by @xmath175 \,.\ ] ] consider a null surface energy density , @xmath150 , i.e. , @xmath176 , so that from eq .
( [ sigmasads ] ) , we have the relationship @xmath177 \,,\ ] ] for @xmath153 . for the particular case of @xmath154 ,
( [ sigmasads ] ) takes the form @xmath178 , which is null for @xmath156 , i.e. , @xmath157 ; positive for @xmath158 , i.e. , @xmath159 ; and negative for @xmath160 , i.e. , @xmath179 .
only the region to the left of the solid curve , given by @xmath180 , is of interest . for @xmath127
, a non - negative surface energy density is given for @xmath181 and @xmath182 .
for @xmath183 , @xmath184 for @xmath185 . for @xmath186 , we have @xmath184 for @xmath187 . and @xmath123 .
only the region to the left of the solid curve , given by @xmath180 , is of interest . for the cases of @xmath162 and @xmath188 , the energy conditions are satisfied to the right of the respective dashed curves , and to the left of the solid line . for the specific case of @xmath189 ,
the energy conditions are obeyed above the respective curve .
see text for details.,width=230 ]
in this section we shall consider the traversability conditions required for the traversal of a human being through the wormhole , and consequently determine specific dimensions for the wormhole .
specific cases for the traversal time and velocity will also be estimated . in this section
we shall insert @xmath190 to aid us in the computations .
consider the redshift function given by @xmath191 , with @xmath192 .
thus , from the definition of @xmath92 , the redshift function , in terms of @xmath100 , takes the following form @xmath193 with @xmath194 . with this choice of @xmath15 , @xmath100
may also be defined as @xmath195 .
the case of @xmath196 corresponds to the constant redshift function , so that @xmath197 . if @xmath198 , then @xmath15 is finite throughout spacetime and in the absence of an exterior solution we have @xmath199 .
as we are considering a matching of an interior solution with an exterior solution at @xmath20 , then it is also possible to consider the @xmath200 case , imposing that @xmath15 is finite in the interval @xmath201 .
one of the traversability conditions required is that the acceleration felt by the traveller should not exceed earth s gravity @xcite . consider an orthonormal basis of the traveller s proper reference frame , @xmath202 , given in terms of the orthonormal basis vectors of eqs .
( [ basisvectors ] ) of the static observers , by a lorentz transformation , i.e. , @xmath203 where @xmath204 , and @xmath205 being the velocity of the traveller as he / she passes @xmath17 , as measured by a static observer positioned there @xcite .
thus , the traveller s four - acceleration expressed in his proper reference frame , @xmath206 , yields the following restriction @xmath207 the condition is immediately satisfied at the throat , @xmath36 . from eq .
( [ travellergravity ] ) , one may also find an estimate for the junction surface , @xmath20 .
consider that the dust shell is placed in an asymptotically flat region of spacetime , so that @xmath208 .
we also assume that the traversal velocity is constant , @xmath209 , and non - relativistic , @xmath210 .
taking into account eq .
( [ redshift ] ) , from eq .
( [ travellergravity ] ) one deduces @xmath211 . considering the equality case , one has @xmath212 providing a value for @xmath213 , one may find an estimate for @xmath20 .
for instance , considering that @xmath214 , one finds that @xmath215 .
another of the traversability conditions required is that the tidal accelerations felt by the traveller should not exceed the earth s gravitational acceleration @xcite .
the tidal acceleration felt by the traveller is given by @xmath216 , where @xmath217 is the traveller s four velocity and @xmath218 is the separation between two arbitrary parts of his body .
note that @xmath218 is purely spatial in the traveller s reference frame , as @xmath219 , so that @xmath220 . for simplicity ,
assume that @xmath221 along any spatial direction in the traveller s reference frame @xcite .
thus , the constraint @xmath222 provides the following inequalities @xmath223 - \frac{\phi'}{2r^2}\left(m'r - m-\frac{2\lambda}{3 } r^3\right ) \bigg| \ ,
\big|\eta^{\hat{1}'}\big|\,c^2 \leq g_{\oplus } \ , , \label{radialtidalconstraint } \\ & & \bigg|\frac{\gamma^2}{2r^3}\left[\left(\frac{v}{c}\right)^2 \;\left(m'r - m-\frac{2\lambda}{3}r^3 \right)+2r^2 \left(\frac{\lambda}{3}r^2-\frac{m}{r}\right)\phi ' \right ] \bigg|\ , \big|\eta^{\hat{2}'}\big|\,c^2 \leq g_{\oplus } \ , . \label{lateraltidalconstraint}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the radial tidal constraint , eq .
( [ radialtidalconstraint ] ) , constrains the redshift function , and the lateral tidal constraint , eq .
( [ lateraltidalconstraint ] ) , constrains the velocity with which observers traverse the wormhole . at the throat , @xmath28 or @xmath36 , and taking into account eq .
( [ redshift ] ) , we verify that eq .
( [ radialtidalconstraint ] ) reduces to @xmath224 or @xmath225 considering the equality case . from this relationship
, one may find estimates for the junction interface radius , @xmath20 , and the wormhole throat , @xmath19 .
( [ tidalrestriction ] ) , one deduces @xmath226 using eqs .
( [ equalitycase2 ] ) and ( [ equalitycase ] ) , one may find an estimate for the throat radius , by providing a specific value for @xmath227 .
for instance , considering @xmath228 and equating eqs .
( [ equalitycase2 ] ) and ( [ equalitycase ] ) , one finds @xmath229 ) , if @xmath230 , we verify that the embedding diagram flares out very slowly , so that from eq .
( [ r0 ] ) , @xmath19 may be made arbitrarily small .
nevertheless , using specific examples of the form function , for instance eq .
( [ homerform ] ) , we will assume the approximation @xmath231 .
using the above value of @xmath232 , from eq .
( [ r0 ] ) we find @xmath233 .
one may use the lateral tidal constraint , eq .
( [ lateraltidalconstraint ] ) , to find an upper limit of the traversal velocity , @xmath234 .
evaluated at @xmath19 , we find @xmath235 .
the traversal times as measured by the traveller and an observer situated at a space station , which we shall assume rests just outside the junction surface , are given respectively by @xcite @xmath236 where @xmath237 is the proper radial distance .
since we have chosen @xmath210 and @xmath238 , we can use the following approximations @xmath239 for instance , considering the maximum velocity , @xmath240 , with @xmath241 , the traversal through the wormhole can be made in approximately a minute .
we have presented a specific metric of a spherically symmetric traversable wormhole in the presence of a generic cosmological constant , verifying that the null energy condition and the averaged null energy condition are violated , as was to be expected .
we verified that evaluating the `` volume integral quantifier '' , the specific ellis drainhole may also be theoretically constructed with arbitrarily small quantities of averaged null energy condition violating matter .
furthermore , we constructed a pressureless dust shell around the interior wormhole solution , by matching the latter to a unique vacuum exterior spacetime , in the presence of a generic cosmological constant . in the spirit of minimizing the usage of exotic matter
, regions were determined in which the surface energy density is non - negative , thus satisfying all of the energy conditions at the junction surface .
an equation governing the behavior of the radial pressure across the shell was also determined .
taking advantage of the construction , and considering the traversability conditions , estimates of the throat radius and the junction interface radius , of the total traversal time and maximum velocity of an observer journeying through the wormhole , were also found .
f. lobo and p. crawford , weak energy condition violation and superluminal travel " , current trends in relativistic astrophysics , theoretical , numerical , observational , lecture notes in physics * 617 * , springer - verlag publishers , l. fernndez et al .
eds , pp . 277291 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0204038 ] . | firstly , we review the pointwise and averaged energy conditions , the quantum inequality and the notion of the `` volume integral quantifier '' , which provides a measure of the `` total amount '' of energy condition violating matter .
secondly , we present a specific metric of a spherically symmetric traversable wormhole in the presence of a generic cosmological constant , verifying that the null and the averaged null energy conditions are violated , as was to be expected .
thirdly , a pressureless dust shell is constructed around the interior wormhole spacetime by matching the latter geometry to a unique vacuum exterior solution . in order to further minimize the usage of exotic matter
, we then find regions where the surface energy density is positive , thereby satisfying all of the energy conditions at the junction surface .
an equation governing the behavior of the radial pressure across the junction surface is also deduced .
lastly , taking advantage of the construction , specific dimensions of the wormhole , namely , the throat radius and the junction interface radius , and estimates of the total traversal time and maximum velocity of an observer journeying through the wormhole , are also found by imposing the traversability conditions . |
a monoidal model category is a quillen model category which is also a monoidal category in a compatible way @xcite .
a monoidal model category has several additional features ; its homotopy category inherits a monoidal structure , moreover , under reasonable assumptions , monoids , modules and algebras over a given monoid have model structures with weak equivalences are the maps which are weak equivalences in the ground category @xcite , @xcite . +
a reedy category is a small category @xmath0 equipped with some additional structure making it possible to , by iterative process , construct diagrams of shape @xmath0 in a given category . given a reedy category @xmath0 and a model category @xmath1 , the category @xmath2 of @xmath0-diagrams in @xmath1 admits a model category structure for which the weak equivalences are the objectwise weak equivalences @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
if we further assume that @xmath1 is a closed symmetric monoidal model category , then the diagram category @xmath2 has a symmetric monoidal structure given by the objectwise product .
our objective in this paper is to prove that @xmath2 is a closed symmetric monoidal model category , provided that @xmath1 is cofibrantly generated with cofibrant unit . + quite recently , berger and moerdijk extended the notion of reedy model structure to a useful wider class of small categories which is invariant under equivalence @xcite , they further define a convolution product on the diagram category and prove that , under reasonable assumptions , the resulting category is a symmetric monoidal model category [ theorem 7.6 in @xcite ] , this last theorem of theirs overlaps with our main result .
+ we next describe the plan of this work . in section
[ s2 ] , we briefly review a special case of the enriched yoneda s lemma and derive two lemmas for later use . in section [ s3 ] ,
we give a criteria for a functor of @xmath1-modules from @xmath2 to another @xmath1-module to be a left adjoint and apply it to prove that the symmetric monoidal structure on @xmath2 is closed , in section [ s4 ] we prove the compatibility of the reedy model structure on @xmath2 with the monoidal product .
all categories considered in this paper are assumed to be locally small in the sense that the class of morphisms from one object to another is a set .
for any category @xmath3 and any two objects @xmath4 , @xmath5 objects in @xmath3 , the set of morphisms from @xmath4 to @xmath6 is denoted always denoted by @xmath7 +
let @xmath1 be a closed symmetric monoidal category . recall that an @xmath1-module is by definition a category @xmath3 equipped with an action @xmath8 satisfying the expected coherence diagrams , a precise definition is given in [ @xcite definition 4.1.6 ] .
observe that @xmath1 is symmetric and therefore a right or left action of @xmath1 on @xmath3 is a two sided action .
a functor @xmath9 between @xmath1-modules is called a functor of @xmath1-modules if it commutes , up to natural isomorphisms , with the action of @xmath1 and satisfies the expected coherence diagrams as described in [ @xcite definition 4.1.7 ] .
an @xmath1-module @xmath3 is said to be closed if the action of @xmath1 on @xmath3 is two sided closed , i.e. if there are two functors @xmath10 such that for every @xmath11 in @xmath1 and @xmath12 , @xmath5 in @xmath3 , there are natural isomorphisms @xmath13 throughout this section , @xmath0 is assumed to be a small category , @xmath1 is a bicomplete closed symmetric monoidal category with monoidal product @xmath14 , unit @xmath15 and internal homomorphism functor denoted exponentially so that for @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 in @xmath1 , we have @xmath19 .
let @xmath20 the category of functors from @xmath21 to @xmath22 .
for @xmath4 , @xmath5 in @xmath20 , the set of morphisms from @xmath12 to @xmath5 in @xmath20 is isomorphic to the end of the functor @xmath23 which takes @xmath24 to @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the category of sets , i.e. @xmath27 the functor @xmath28 which takes a pair @xmath29 to the object @xmath30 given by @xmath31 defines an @xmath1-module structure on @xmath32 we want to show that this action is closed . for @xmath12 , @xmath5 be in @xmath33 and @xmath11 in @xmath1 , define @xmath34 to be the object of @xmath20 given by @xmath35 and @xmath36 [ l1 ] @xmath37 so that @xmath20 is a closed @xmath1-module .
@xmath38 the functor @xmath39 preserves ends , therefore @xmath40 for @xmath41 , define a functor @xmath42 by @xmath43 the coproduct of as many copies of the unit @xmath15 as there are elements in the hom set @xmath44 , for @xmath45 , @xmath46 is understood to be induced by the induced map @xmath47 the following result is a special case of the enriched yoneda s lemma @xcite , @xcite .
[ l2 ] the functors @xmath48 and @xmath49 @xmath50 defined by @xmath51 are equivalent .
[ l3 ] the i - evaluation functor @xmath52 , @xmath53 , is right adjoint with left adjoint the functor @xmath54 given by @xmath55 .
let @xmath56 and @xmath57 @xmath58 where the last isomorphism is a consequence of yoneda s lemma [ l2 ] .
define the differential of a functor @xmath59 to be the functor @xmath60 given by @xmath61 , @xmath62 the following manifestation of yoneda lemma is a special case of proposition i.5.1 in @xcite , it justifies our terminology and may be thought of as a categorical analog of the fundamental theorem of calculus .
[ l4 ] ( yoneda reduction ) let @xmath63 , then @xmath12 is isomorphic to the coend of @xmath64 , i.e. @xmath65 for @xmath66 @xmath67 thus @xmath68 .
recall that a functor between two cocomplete categories is said to be cocontinuous if it preserves colimits . still in this section
, @xmath0 is assumed to be a small category , @xmath1 is a bicomplete closed symmetric monoidal category with monoidal product @xmath14 , unit @xmath15 and internal homomorphism functor denoted exponentially . [ t1 ] let @xmath3 be a cocomplete @xmath1-module and @xmath69 a functor of @xmath1-modules then @xmath70 is a left adjoint iff it is cocontinuous , in which case its right adjoint @xmath71 is given @xmath72 a left adjoint functor is cocontinuous .
conversely , suppose that @xmath70 is cocontinuous and suppose that it has a right adjoint @xmath71 . for @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 , we have @xmath76 therefore @xmath77 . in particular ,
when @xmath78 , by lemma [ l2 ] , one has @xmath79 so define @xmath80 to be the object in @xmath33 given by the previous formula , then @xmath81 @xmath71 is a then a right adjoint of @xmath70 . let @xmath82 be another small category and @xmath83 a functor and @xmath84 the functor be induced by @xmath85 . for @xmath86 , @xmath87 .
@xmath88 is a cocontinuous functor of @xmath1-modules , by theorem [ t1 ] one has the following [ c1]the functor @xmath89 has a right adjoint functor @xmath90 given by @xmath91 for @xmath92 , let @xmath93 be the object of @xmath94 defined by @xmath95 , then @xmath96 is a symmetric monoidal category . let @xmath97 be the diagonal functor , i.e @xmath98 , @xmath99 induces a functor @xmath100 .
[ c2 ] the functor @xmath101 has a right adjoint functor @xmath102 given by @xmath103 by corollary [ c1 ] , @xmath104 has a right adjoint functor @xmath102 given by @xmath105 or @xmath106 , thus @xmath107 . [ exam ]
let @xmath108 and @xmath109 be the categories of simplicial sets an bisimplicial sets respectively , then @xmath110 and @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the category of finite ordinal numbers with order preserving maps and @xmath113 is the category of sets .
the functor @xmath114 given by 2.1 is defined by @xmath115 the set of maps in @xmath108 from @xmath11 to @xmath116 . the diagonal map @xmath117 induces a left adjoint functor @xmath118 whose right adjoint is the functor @xmath119 given by @xmath120 ( see 5.3 in @xcite ) .
next , we show that the symmetric monoidal structure defined on @xmath33 is closed .
[ c3 ] @xmath121 is a closed symmetric monoidal category with internal homomorphism functor @xmath122 given by @xmath123 for @xmath124 define a functor @xmath125 @xmath126 @xmath127 is a cocontinuous functor of @xmath1-modules , by theorem [ t1 ] , @xmath128 has a left adjoint functor @xmath129 given by @xmath130 .
define @xmath131 , we then have @xmath132 for all @xmath133 .
let @xmath1 be a a closed symmetric monoidal category , @xmath0 a reedy category and @xmath134 , @xmath135 the direct and inverse subcategories of @xmath0 which define the reedy structure on @xmath0 .
the inclusion functor @xmath136 induces a functor @xmath137 . by corollary [ c1 ]
, @xmath138 has a right adjoint functor @xmath108 , suppose further that @xmath1 has a model category structure and let @xmath33 and @xmath139 have the corresponding reedy model category structures , then clearly , @xmath138 preserves and reflects cofibrations and weak equivalences , in particular , the pair @xmath140 is a quillen adjunction .
[ p1](lemma 4.2 in @xcite ) suppose that @xmath0 is a reedy category and @xmath1 is a closed symmetric monoidal model category with cofibrant unit @xmath15 , then the action of @xmath1 on @xmath33 is compatible with the reedy model structure on @xmath141 step1 .
@xmath0 is a direct category .
+ let @xmath142 be a fibration in @xmath33 and @xmath143 a cofibration in @xmath1 .
the maps @xmath144 are fibrations in @xmath1 which are trivial if @xmath145 is , therefore the maps @xmath146 are fibrations in @xmath1 which is are trivial if @xmath147 or @xmath145 is .
hence , @xmath148 is a fibration in @xmath33 which is trivial if @xmath149 or @xmath145 is , the result then follows from 4.2.2 in @xcite .
the general case .
+ let @xmath134 and @xmath135 be the direct and inverse subcategories of @xmath0 which define the reedy structure on @xmath0 and @xmath150 be the restriction functor . for @xmath151 in @xmath33 ( resp .
@xmath152 and @xmath153 in @xmath1 , let @xmath154 .
assume that @xmath151 is a cofibration in @xmath33 and @xmath153 is a cofibration in @xmath1 , @xmath138 preserves ( trivial ) cofibrations .
by step 1 , @xmath155 is a cofibrations which is trivial if @xmath149 or @xmath156 is , or @xmath157 and @xmath138 reflects ( trivial ) cofibrations , thus @xmath158 is a cofibration which is trivial if @xmath149 or @xmath156 is . 1 .
let @xmath1 be a cofibrantly generated model category with @xmath159 ( resp .
@xmath160 ) as a set of generating cofibrations ( resp .
trivial cofibrations ) .
if @xmath0 is a direct category , and @xmath161 , by lemma [ l3 ] , the functor @xmath162 given by @xmath163 is left adjoint to the i - evaluation @xmath164 , by remark ( 5.1.8 ) in @xcite , @xmath33 is cofibrantly generated with @xmath165 ( resp .
@xmath166 as a set of generating cofibrations ( resp .
trivial cofibrations ) 2 .
let @xmath167 be a cofibrantly generated model category which has a closed symmetric monoidal structure and an internal homomorphism functor @xmath122 .
assume further that @xmath167 satisfies the unit axiom ( axiom 2 of definition 4.2.6 in @xcite ) ; then , by lemma 4.2.4 in @xcite the following three properties are equivalent 1 .
the model category structure on @xmath167 is compatible with the monoidal structure .
2 . if @xmath168 and @xmath169 are generating ( trivial ) cofibrations in @xmath167
, then the induced map + @xmath170 is a cofibration which is trivial if @xmath149 or @xmath156 is .
if @xmath168 is a generating ( trivial ) cofibration and @xmath171 is a ( trivial ) fibrations in @xmath167 , then the induced map @xmath172 is a fibration which is trivial if @xmath149 is a trivial cofibration or @xmath156 is a trivial fibration .
[ l5 ] let @xmath0 be a direct category , @xmath1 a closed symmetric monoidal model category with cofibrant unit @xmath15 , @xmath173 and @xmath174 a ( trivial ) cofibration in @xmath1 , then , with the reedy model category structure [ t2 ] suppose that @xmath0 is a reedy category and @xmath1 is a cofibrantly generated closed symmetric monoidal model category with cofibrant unit @xmath15 , then @xmath33 is a closed symmetric monoidal model category . by corollary [ c3 ]
@xmath33 closed symmetric monoidal category .
the unit axiom for @xmath33 follows immediatly from the unit axiom for @xmath189 it remains to prove the pushout axiom .
+ step 1 : @xmath0 is direct + let @xmath168 be a cofibration @xmath1 and @xmath171 be a fibration in @xmath2 , @xmath190 be the left adjoint of the q - evaluation @xmath191 , by lemma [ l3 ] , @xmath192 and by remarks [ r1].1 and [ r1].2 , we only need to prove that @xmath193 is a fibration which is trivial if @xmath149 or @xmath156 is . by corollary [ c3 ] , the induced objectwise maps of this last map are the maps @xmath193 is a fibration which is trivial if @xmath149 or @xmath156 is .
+ step 2 : the general case + the result is immediate consequence of step 1 and the fact that the restriction functor @xmath137 is monoidal , preserves and reflects ( trivial ) cofibrations . c. berger , i. moerdijk . on an extension of the notion of reedy category .
z. 269 , 2011 .
f. borceux , handbook of categorical algebra 2 , categories and structures , encyclopedia of math- ematics and its applications , vol .
51 , cambridge university press , 1994 .
e. j. dubuc , kan extensions in enriched category theory , springer , 1970 .
w. g. dwyer , p. s. hirschhorn , d. m. kan , model categories and more general abstract homotopy theory : a work in what we like to think of as progress , preprint .
p. goerss and j. jardine simplicial homotopy theory , progress in mathematics 174 , @xmath196 1999 .
hirschhorn , model categories and their localizations , mathematical surveys and monographs , vol .
99 , american mathematical society , providence , ri , 2003 .
m. hovey , model categories , surveys and monographs of the amer .
63 , 1999 .
m. hovey , monoidal model categories , preprint , 1998 .
g. m. kelly , basic concepts of enriched category theory , repr .
theory appl .
categ , 2005 .
s. maclane , categories for the working mathematician , graduate texts in mathematics , vol . 5 , springer - verlag , 1971 .
d. quillen homotopical algebra , lecture notes in mathematics 43 , springer , berlin , 1967 .
s. schwede and b. shipley , algebras and modules in monoidal model categories proc .
london math .
80 , 2000 . | given a small category @xmath0 and a closed symmetric monoidal category @xmath1 , we show that the diagram category @xmath2 with the objectwise product is a closed symmetric monoidal category .
we then prove that if @xmath0 is a reedy category and @xmath1 has a model structure compatible with its product , then so is the reedy model structure on @xmath2 provided that @xmath1 is cofibrantly generated . |
the radio bright outer galaxy region ctb 102 ( @xmath1 ) was first cataloged by the @xcite radio survey of the galactic plane .
the source is then mentioned in subsequent galactic radio surveys including @xcite where it is identified as kr 1 . using radio recombination line ( rrl ) observations at @xmath23 cm
, @xcite ( h87@xmath3 , @xmath43@xmath5 beam ) identified the region as a region with a line brightness of @xmath6 mk , a velocity of @xmath7 km s@xmath8 and a full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of @xmath9 km s@xmath8 .
radio continuum images at 1.42 ghz and @xmath10 resolution from the canadian galactic plane survey ( cgps , * ? ? ?
* ) , show filamentary structures extending from a bright complex source . from the appearance of the structure and a kinematic distance estimate
, the region appears to be a very large region and a major feature in the perseus spiral arm .
yet this major galactic region is unstudied .
suffering heavy extinction in this direction in the galactic plane , there is no known optical counterpart to ctb 102 .
the purpose of this study is to determine the basic properties of ctb 102 , mainly how large in physical size it is , and how it influences its galactic environment . in this paper
we present new rrl observations towards ctb 102 .
rrl observations allow direct velocity measurements , and along with continuum observations will tell us the density and temperature of any gas in the beam at or near thermodynamic equilibrium .
rrl observations towards ctb 102 were performed with the 100-m nrao green bank telescope ( gbt ) during 6 nights in 2006 , july 31 , august 2 - 4 , 15 & 17 .
twelve pointings were observed around the ctb 102 complex .
these telescope pointings are illustrated in figures [ pointings ] and [ velocities ] .
positions and total integration times for the chosen observations are given in table [ obs - tbl ] , the observations themselves were divided into 600 s scans .
rrls observed were h103@xmath3 through h110@xmath3 .
a 50 mhz bandwidth receiver was used to allow the eight recombination lines to be simultaneously observed in the high end of the @xmath11-band ( @xmath12 ghz ) .
both polarizations were admitted , and the spectrum consists of 4096 channels ( @xmath13 km s@xmath8 per channel ) .
system temperatures ranged from 19 to 26 k , depending mainly on the elevation of the source .
average system temperatures for each observation are given in table [ obs - tbl ] .
as a check of the system s ability to record rrl emission , the bright `` head '' of ctb 102 at @xmath14 , hereafter ctb102p , was observed for 600 s at the beginning of each session .
none of the eight 50 mhz bands were seriously affected by radio frequency interference .
frequency - switched scans in each linear polarization ( yy , xx ) were folded individually ; since frequency - switching was done in - band ( @xmath1512.5 mhz ) , we doubled our effective integration time .
each 600 s scan contains 16 spectra . to assure that no line structure ( e.g. very extended wings from outflows ) is removed , velocities forbidden by galactic rotation ( typically @xmath16 km s@xmath17 km s@xmath8 and @xmath18 km s@xmath19 km s@xmath8 ) defines a range of baseline velocities . for each of the 16 spectra in every scan
, a baseline was determined using a fourth - order polynomial fitted to the range of baseline velocities .
this fitted baseline was then subtracted from every spectrum in each scan .
after baseline subtraction , the spectra in the individual scans are combined ( for every velocity channel , intensity values are summed up and then divided by the number of scans ) to create averaged spectra , one for each line and polarization . at this point in the reduction process , there are 16 spectra ( h103@xmath3 xx , h103@xmath3 yy , h104@xmath3 xx , etc . ) for every observation in table [ obs - tbl ] .
these averaged spectra were regridded to a common channel width ( 0.67 km s@xmath8 ) and smoothed to a common velocity resolution ( 1.5015 km s@xmath8 ) .
typically 4 - 10 of these averaged spectra do not show residual wavy baselines in regions of no rrl signal .
the only exception is h110@xmath3 ( polarization xx ) , which shows a very wide `` bump '' in the spectrum centered around @xmath20 km s@xmath8 , extending into the region of the rrl signal .
this line and polarization is completely excluded from the analysis . to reduce noise , composite spectra , one for each filament , are made by combining the averaged spectra that do not show residual wavy baselines .
the composite spectra typically have a noise level of @xmath21 mk ( antenna temperature ) . since rrls are expected to be quite wide ( 25 - 30 km s@xmath8 ; * ? ? ?
* ) , a spectral resolution of 1.5 km s@xmath8 is unnecessarily fine .
a higher s / n can be achieved without loss of information by moderate smoothing of the composite spectra , although too much will add an artificial width to spectral lines present .
we conservatively choose a resolution of 3.0 km s@xmath8 .
to our final smoothed composite spectra , gaussians are fit to obtain spectral line parameters : line amplitude ( @xmath22 ) , central velocity ( @xmath23 ) and fwhm ( @xmath24 ) . smoothed spectra and the gaussian fits
are shown in figure [ spectra ] and the obtained parameters are presented in table [ par - tbl ] . note that antenna temperature has been divided by the beam efficiency , @xmath25 for the gbt at 5 ghz , to convert to brightness temperature .
the uncertainties in table [ par - tbl ] are obtained in monte carlo fashion . to the originally obtained gaussian fit ,
randomly drawn noise from a normal distribution with the same standard deviation as the previously obtained @xmath26 is added .
a new gaussian is then fitted to the generated spectrum and its parameters stored .
after 1000 repetitions , the standard deviation of the distributions of spectral line parameters is combined with the mean fit uncertainties to produce the total uncertainties .
figure [ velocities ] displays the observed velocities of the filaments / objects , overlayed on a cgps 1.42 ghz continuum image .
this study finds that the bright radio source ctb102p has a velocity of @xmath27 km s@xmath8 , which is 1.7 km s@xmath8 less than the value in @xcite .
the difference is probably due to the difference in pointing position , as well as the difference in telescope beam size between the studies .
the velocity of ctb102p is hereafter referred to as @xmath28 .
one purpose of this study is to find out the size of ctb 102 , i.e. are the filaments and objects we see around ctb 102 at the same distance ?
the velocity gradient ( for a flat rotation curve with @xmath29 kpc and @xmath30 km s@xmath8 ) in this part of the galaxy is @xmath31 km s@xmath8 kpc@xmath8 .
looking at the last column of table [ par - tbl ] , most filaments and objects have a @xmath32 km s@xmath8 , so it seems likely that the ctb 102 complex and objects kr 4 , kr 6 and nrao 652 are in the same part of the galaxy .
in contrast , wb 43 ( @xmath33 km s@xmath8 ) is clearly a local region , and in no way connected to the ctb 102 complex ( figure [ spectra ] ) .
filament 2 is another possible unrelated object ( see sec [ disc ] ) , its velocity ( @xmath34 km s@xmath8 ) deviates the most from the velocity of ctb102p , @xmath35 km s@xmath8 , and is @xmath31 km s@xmath8 less than any other velocity observed in this study .
computing the average absolute difference for all observations ( except wb 43 ) yields a result of 6.6 km s@xmath8 , but excluding filament 2 from the average , the value drops to 4.3 km s@xmath8 .
the majority of fwhms in this study fall between 20 km s@xmath8 and 26 km s@xmath8 , which is typical for dense regions @xcite .
the line width of a rrl depends on mainly two things , thermal motion , which is described by the electron temperature ( @xmath36 ) , and microturbulence .
both of these processes produce gaussian profile shapes , so a doppler temperature ( @xmath37 ) , which provides an upper limit to the true electron temperature , can be adopted as follows @xcite : @xmath38 where @xmath24 is the observed fwhm in km s@xmath8 from table [ par - tbl ] , corrected for the spectral resolution of 3 km s@xmath8 . the lte electron temperature can be calculated using the line to continuum brightness ratio : @xmath39 where @xmath40 and @xmath41 @xcite . the continuum brightness temperature @xmath42 is obtained by convolving the cgps 1.42 ghz mosaic to the @xmath43 resolution of the gbt .
the background is estimated individually for each filament ( typical background estimate uncertainty @xmath44 k ) and the background is subtracted from the average brightness temperature within a @xmath43 circle centered on the telescope pointing . assuming temperature follows the power law @xmath45 the resulting @xmath42 is scaled using the average frequency of the observed rrls ( 5.46 ghz ) .
the parameters derived in this way for each filament / object are in table [ der - tbl ] .
the @xmath36 is quite sensitive to the estimated background temperature , especially when the peak brightness temperature is barely above the background .
note that @xmath46 within the @xmath47 uncertainty in all cases .
@xmath37 provides a useful upper limit to @xmath36 in case the uncertainty in @xmath36 is large .
these derived parameters for the ionized gas gives an average lte electron temperature of @xmath48 k. this value falls within the typical range of electron temperatures for regions .
we note the fwhm of ctb102p determined in this study , @xmath49 km s@xmath8 , is 4.6 km s@xmath8 less than the value for @xmath24 in @xcite .
again , the difference is probably due to the difference in beam size and pointing position .
with the majority of the filaments velocities found to be very similar to that of the central body , the whole ctb 102 complex subtends about one to two degrees of sky .
its distance would be able to tell us how far across its influence extends across the outer disk . here
we provide the first ever distance estimate for this region . to begin with ,
figure [ lbvhi ] shows a latitude - velocity slice in the direction @xmath50 , taken from the 26-meter telescope survey of galactic plane @xcite .
extensive intermediate velocity ( @xmath51 km s@xmath8 ) is seen extending from @xmath52 in latitude .
the beyond @xmath53 km s@xmath8 appears split into three blended concentrations .
the lower - latitude concentration at @xmath54 and @xmath55 km s@xmath8 blended together with the concentration near @xmath56 at @xmath57 km s@xmath8 are contemporarily taken together to form the perseus arm ( see * ? ? ?
* for example ) .
the outer arm is the smaller oblong feature up at @xmath58 , @xmath59 km s@xmath8 , which is also blended with the upper - latitude portion of the perseus arm .
as seen in the top panel of figure [ lbvhi ] , the contemporary perseus arm exhibits a very substantial tilt in latitude towards negative velocities .
this is known as the `` rolling '' motion in this arm .
as well , the splitting of the perseus arm into two concentrations has been explained by a spiral shock @xcite which is thought to precede the arm .
however , an alternative explanation for the @xmath60 structure in the suggests that there are actually three spiral arms beyond @xmath61 km s@xmath8 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) ; the perseus arm ( centered at @xmath62 km s@xmath8 ) , the cygnus ( = outer ) arm ( @xmath63 km s@xmath8 ) , and the `` far '' outer arm up at @xmath64 . in this 3-arm interpretation ,
the perseus and cygnus arms have more reasonable moderate rolling gradients ( @xmath65 km s@xmath8 per degree ) .
the cygnus arm appears at higher latitudes than perseus since it lies further into the upwardly - warped outer galactic disk .
the systemic velocity estimated for ctb 102 in ( @xmath66 km s@xmath8 ; see sec [ disc ] ) and its latitude ( @xmath67 ) place it somewhat in the middle of the contemporary perseus arm , in an `` wall '' that connects the two brighter concentrations . in @xmath68 plots ( figure [ lbvhi ] , top ) ,
ctb 102 is situated between the two major concentrations , and in the 3-arm picture above it is not clear in which spiral arm it resides . in @xmath69 maps ( figure [ lbvhi ] , bottom ) a `` mushroom - cap''-like feature centered on ctb 102 s coordinates ( @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 km s@xmath8 ) appears as a `` blister '' off of the top of the extensive arm at @xmath73 . as well , in an @xmath74 plot of @xmath75 ( figure [ lbvhi ] , center ) this cap is seen as a finger - like extension off of the cygnus arm , centered at @xmath76 km s@xmath8 extending down to @xmath77 km s@xmath8 .
it has the appearance of either an upper - latitude extension to the perseus arm ( up to @xmath78 ) , or a blended concentration ( possibly the wall of an expanding bubble ) extending off the cygnus arm to more positive velocities .
a distance to the perseus arm in this direction then forms a good estimate for at least a lower - limit distance to ctb 102 .
the velocity of ctb 102 ( @xmath79 km s@xmath8 ) indicates a rather large kinematic distance of 6.8 kpc , assuming a flat rotation curve with @xmath80 kpc , 28 km s@xmath8 kpc@xmath8 .
however , this assumes that the systemic @xmath23 derives only from the projection onto the line - of - sight of the object s galactic circular motion .
being near a major spiral feature of the galaxy , ctb 102 is likely influenced by gravitational forces from the stellar component of the arm , so its velocity is likely tainted with non - circular motions such as those from the `` rolling '' motions in the arms ( velocity gradients perpendicular to the plane ) , and streaming motions from the gravitational influence of density waves .
a new kinematic - based distance method that accounts for non - circular streaming motions due to a two - armed density wave has been developed by @xcite . the approach is to model the galactic distribution and rotation curve by fitting an empirical model of galactic structure and density - wave motions to the observations , rather than just assuming a purely circular model .
the model assumes only two arms are present in the second quadrant , arranged as a two - armed density wave pattern .
we model a direction near to @xmath81 to ensure that velocity gradients with latitude ( i.e. rolling motions , which are not accounted for in * ? ? ?
* ) are not included .
the `` rolling '' gradient of the perseus arm observed towards ctb 102 is @xmath65 km s@xmath8 per degree of latitude ; corrected for this latitude gradient , ctb 102 s systemic velocity is @xmath82 km s@xmath8 .
the velocity field of the best fitting model in the direction @xmath83 , @xmath84 is shown in figure [ vfield ] . in this direction
only the perseus arm is seen along the line - of - sight .
the model shows the perseus arm gaseous density peak ( associated with the spiral shock ) to be 4.3 kpc distant from the sun in this direction .
the velocity field is ambiguous between @xmath85 km s@xmath8 due to the shock , so the heliocentric distance to ctb 102 ( @xmath8652 km s@xmath8 ) is either 4.3 kpc or 5.8 kpc . a simple line of reasoning will show that @xmath87 kpc is probably not the true distance to ctb 102 .
supposing that it is , then for @xmath88 the galactocentric distance to ctb 102 is @xmath89 kpc ( for @xmath90 kpc ) , and in this direction the perseus arm shock ( which defines where the arm is ) is 9.3 kpc from the center . by assuming the arm is a logarithmic spiral with pitch angle @xmath91 , one finds the intersection of a 10.1 kpc radius circle with the shock at a current position of @xmath92 ( here @xmath93 is galactocentric azimuth , defined as zero from the galactic center to the sun and related to longitude @xmath94 by @xmath95 ; hence @xmath93 is positive in the 2@xmath96 quadrant of longitude ) .
thus the stars have since migrated some @xmath97 beyond the arm ( their formation place ) to their current position @xmath98 kpc , @xmath99 .
how long has it taken them to move this @xmath100 angular distance ?
for `` flat '' circular rotation the angular velocity of ctb 102 is @xmath101 km s@xmath8 kpc@xmath8 .
a reasonable pattern speed for the perseus arm is @xmath102 km s@xmath8 kpc@xmath8 , a mean between modern estimates near 20 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and older estimates near 11 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) for the milky way s spiral pattern . then the time it took the system to migrate @xmath103 from the arm at angular rate @xmath104 ( the relative angular velocity with respect to the arm ) is @xmath105 myr . if the massive stars in ctb 102 formed from the compression of the shock , then by now the only ones left would be those that live longer than 75 myr , or stars of @xmath106 m@xmath107 ( b5v types , for example ) .
a cluster of hundreds of such stars would be needed to power ctb 102 ( @xmath108 pc @xmath109 ; see sec .
[ central ] ) .
it is highly unlikely that ctb 102 contains stars later than b5 _ only_. it is more likely that ctb 102 lies near to the arm / shock , which is 4.3 kpc distant in this direction .
the uncertainty in this estimate is @xmath110 , from the variation of best - fitting models of the same direction and in models fitted to several immediately adjacent directions ( see * ? ? ?
this agrees with stellar distances of the nearby optically - brilliant regions sh2 - 124 ( @xmath111 , @xmath112 , @xmath113 km s@xmath8 , @xmath114 kpc ) and sh2 - 132 ( @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 km s@xmath8 , @xmath118 kpc ) , both of which are perseus arm objects ( @xmath119co/-based velocities and spectrophotometric distances to 100 sharpless objects in the second quadrant are forthcoming in * ? ? ?
we note that ctb 102 and filaments may instead be kinematically associated with the cygnus spiral arm , participating in an extensive star - formation group along with region nrao 655 ( @xmath120 km s@xmath8 ; * ? ? ?
* ) and snr 3c434.1 ( @xmath121 km s@xmath8 ; * ? ? ?
this would extend its distance estimate here by a factor of 1.6 , since the mean stellar distance to cygnus arm regions between @xmath122 ( sh2 - 121 , bfs 8 , sh2 - 128 , bfs 10 & da 568 ) is @xmath123 kpc .
radio continuum measurements of regions can provide a lower limit on the total number of ionizing photons ( @xmath124 ) and estimates of the average excitation parameter ( @xmath125 ) .
assuming an optically thin , spherical , constant - density region , the equations used are @xcite : @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the frequency in ghz , @xmath128 is the flux density measured at frequency @xmath127 in mjy , @xmath129 is the distance to the source in kpc , and @xmath36 is the electron temperature in units of @xmath130 k. parameter values used are @xmath131 ghz , @xmath132 kpc and @xmath133 k. since none of the parameters are very sensitive to @xmath36 , and the uncertainties in table [ der - tbl ] are large , a general value of @xmath130 k is used @xcite . the flux density for the considered region is obtained from the cgps continuum image by using the dominion radio astrophysical observatory ( drao ) software imview .
a polygon incorporating the region of interest is drawn by eye .
the polygon s perimeter defines the background , and a twisted plane is fitted to estimate the background . the flux density with the estimated background subtracted is then used to compute the parameters @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
the biggest contribution to the uncertainty is where to draw the polygon around the region of interest . to estimate this uncertainty , each flux measurement
is done ten times , each time with a new polygon drawn .
the average value is used to compute the estimated parameters , and the standard deviation is used to estimate the uncertainty in the flux measurement .
a representative polygon around the region of interest is shown in figure [ est - plot ] , top .
the flux density is measured ten times with results ranging between @xmath134 and @xmath135 jy .
after subtraction of the flux density from the foreground source wb 43 , the average value and @xmath47 uncertainty in the flux density is @xmath136 jy , which gives a value of @xmath137 s@xmath8 and @xmath138 pc @xmath109 .
almost all the uncertainty in these values comes from the uncertainty in the distance .
comparing the values @xmath139 to @xcite suggests an ionizing flux and excitation parameter corresponding to a o5 v class star .
comparing to @xcite suggests an o4 v star .
however , the 30 k contour in figure [ est - plot ] shows the brightest parts of ctb 102 being along an arc stretching from ctb102p towards filament 7 ( i.e. towards smaller galactic longitude and latitude ) . given this continuum flux distribution , it is more likely that the ionizing flux comes from several stars . in summary ,
the estimates together with the morphology of the 1.42 ghz continuum emission , suggest that the ctb 102 complex is powered by at least several late type o stars , maybe even an early type o star ( since @xmath124 is a lower limit ) .
filament 10 looks strikingly circular in the 1.42 ghz continuum image ( see figure [ est - plot ] , bottom ) with an angular diameter of @xmath140 , yielding a physical size of @xmath141 pc at a distance of @xmath142 kpc .
the intensity profile , with a rapid fall - off at the edge , strongly suggests the region is ionization bound .
as such this filament would not contribute ionizing photons to the larger complex .
drawing a circular polygon around filament 10 ( average background @xmath143 k ) yields @xmath144 jy for the flux density ( same method for uncertainty estimate as for the whole complex ) , giving @xmath145 s@xmath8 @xmath146 and @xmath147 pc @xmath109 .
comparisons suggest an o9.5 v @xcite or an b0.5 v @xcite star ionizing the region . for this filament , a single star or a compact cluster of early type b stars
are ionizing the probably homogeneous ism , given the circular radio continuum profile .
this study was partly motivated by the appearance of the ctb 102 region in the 1.42 ghz continuum mosaic ( figure [ pointings ] ) .
looking at figure [ velocities ] , one can make out the region looking like a cone - shaped bubble .
the radio brightness is concentrated along a ridge following an arc with a maximum at ctb102p .
the arc goes towards filaments ( in turn ) 7 , 6 , 5 , 4 and continues towards greater galactic latitude , with faint filamentary structures around @xmath148 eventually bending back towards greater galactic longitude and then down . within the arc
, there appears to be a `` cleared out '' region extending from the central region of ctb 102 towards greater galactic latitude and smaller galactic longitude .
the observed velocities for the filaments along this arc all fall within @xmath149 km s@xmath8 of the velocity of ctb102p , indicating that they at least are in the same part of the galaxy . taking the velocities and 1.42 ghz continuum image together ,
it is likely that the ctb 102 complex includes filaments 7 , 6 , 5 and 4 .
filament 2 is probably not part of the region , since its velocity deviates by @xmath150 km s@xmath8 , and no obvious association with the other filaments is seen in the radio continuum data . as will be discussed below
, our model shows that filament 2 could not be powered by ctb 102 . with the inclusion of these filaments , the angular size of the ctb 102 region
is @xmath151 , which corresponds to a physical size of @xmath152 pc at a distance of 4.3 kpc .
inclusion of filaments 8 , 9 , and 10 , all within @xmath153 km s@xmath8 of ctb102p with apparent connections to ctb 102 in the 1.42 ghz image , increases the angular size of the to @xmath154 or @xmath155 pc at 4.3 kpc .
the objects kr 4 , kr 6 and nrao 652 have no obvious connection to the region in the radio data , and are probably regions which happen to be in the same part of the galaxy as ctb 102 . if the assumption of the filaments being part of the structure is indeed correct , what sort of process would create such a big region ?
the typical sound speed in a region is on the order of @xmath156 km s@xmath8 , which is also the typical velocity associated with blister regions and champagne flows @xcite .
this velocity corresponds to @xmath157 pc/(@xmath158 yr ) .
the velocity is consistent with the observed velocities in table [ par - tbl ] .
however , to reach a radius of @xmath159 pc ( @xmath160 or @xmath155 pc ) would require a time scale of 5 to 6.5 million years ( assuming constant expansion velocity ) .
this time scale is longer than the main - sequence life time of a o5 v star , @xmath161 years @xcite , but comparing cgps 408 mhz and 1.42 ghz show no sign of a supernova in the ctb 102 region .
also , ctb 102 does not appear like a blister in the 1.42 ghz continuum image .
rather , an alternative interpretation is the whole ctb 102 complex with its filaments is a combination of an region with a bubble / chimney structure .
a stellar wind from massive a o star(s ) creates a bubble in the interstellar medium ( ism ) . towards a region of the galaxy with lower density ( higher galactic latitude )
the expanding bubble has its top `` blown off '' , creating the possible chimney . towards regions with higher densities , the expanding stellar wind bubble sweep up a shell of the ism .
the shell and left over neutral material is exposed to ultraviolet radiation from the o star(s ) , gets ionized and forms the region . what would be expected if this interpretation is correct ?
the structure would show a cavity in . in this picture , the expanding bubble sweeps up a shell of neutral material .
this shell would be ionized from the inside of the bubble and if viewed through the edge , the increased path length would cause the shell to appear as neutral and ionized filaments .
these and filaments would have observed velocities which do not deviate too much from each other and from the velocity of the central region . also , the ionized filaments would be expected to be located on the `` inside '' of the neutral filaments .
support for the idea comes from viewing the structure in the region .
figure [ h1-figure ] shows the averaged velocity slices ( of width 2.5 km s@xmath8 ) of the cgps line data , overlayed with contours ( 15 and 30 k ) indicating where the 1.42 ghz continuum flux is located in relation to the .
a cleared out region is most easily seen in the final three velocity frames ( @xmath162 to @xmath163 km s@xmath8 ) , extending from the central region of ctb 102 towards the galactic north .
this cavity in disappears beyond @xmath164 km s@xmath8 .
the galaxy contains gas out to @xmath165 km s@xmath8 in this direction ( see figure [ lbvhi ] , center ) .
the emission is mostly concentrated along an arc extending from north of ctb 102 , wrapping around the `` edges '' of the region and extending more faintly up next to filaments 7 , 6 and 4 .
these filaments ( seen in the final three velocity frames , @xmath162 to @xmath163 km s@xmath8 ) are located on the `` outside '' of the corresponding filaments and they correspond roughly in velocity to the rrl results in table [ par - tbl ] . in the first velocity frame , @xmath166 km s@xmath8 , a filament of is spatially coincident with filament 5 ( observed @xmath167 km s@xmath8 ) .
figure [ msx ] shows a msx a - band image ( 8.3 ) towards ctb 102 .
the contour corresponds to an averaged cgps brightness temperature level of 70 k from the @xmath168 km s@xmath8 velocity frame in figure [ h1-figure ] .
the msx a - band traces pah emission from neutral material being bombarded with ultraviolet photons .
figure [ msx ] clearly shows the morphological association between structures seen in the arc discussed above , neutral material in a uv radiation field and the 1.42 ghz continuum emission .
this is best demonstrated by the 8.3 emission tracing a thin filamentary structure which extends from the main arc towards ctb102p ( i.e. towards greater galactic longitude and latitude ) .
this thin filament runs parallel to the bright arc seen in the 1.42 ghz continuum image ( traced by the 30 k contour in figure [ est - plot ] ) , something which would be expected if the interpretation of a neutral shell being ionized from slightly above the bright arc is correct .
can ionizing photons reach the filaments ? to reach the inside of the proposed swept up shell at filament 6 , ionizing photons have to travel an angular distance of @xmath169 from ctb102p , corresponding to @xmath170 pc at @xmath142 kpc . in the bubble scenario ,
the inside of the bubble is filled with stellar wind , a hot , low density plasma .
absorption in such a plasma is negligible , and the purely geometrically diluted radiation field could easily maintain a high ionization fraction in the ionized inside of the swept up shell .
the same is true for the other filaments we consider part of the shell structure .
for filament 2 , at a distance of @xmath171 pc from ctb102p ( @xmath172 ) , a purely geometrically diluted radiation field could maintain a high ionization fraction if the stellar wind bubble extended all the way out to filament 2 .
the proposed bubble does not extend that far ( see below ) , and inserting any realistic ism between the proposed bubble and filament 2 causes significant absorption in the ism , thus leaving no photons from ctb 102 to ionize filament 2 .
a simple analytical model of the development of a stellar wind bubble was given by @xcite .
using the formulation in @xcite , the radius ( @xmath173 ) , shell expansion velocity ( @xmath174 ) and shell fractional thickness ( @xmath175 ) of such a region are given by : @xmath176 where @xmath177 is the energy loss rate from the star , @xmath178 is the mean molecular weight of the medium the shell is expanding into ( @xmath179 for neutral ism , @xmath180 for a fully ionized ism ) , @xmath181 is the ism density and @xmath182 is the sound speed inside the bubble .
we estimate @xmath177 using a typical mass loss rate of @xmath183 m@xmath184/yr and a stellar wind velocity of @xmath185 km s@xmath8 .
the sound speed is @xmath186 km s@xmath8 and the ism density is @xmath187 @xmath188 ( mean ism density , from * ? ? ? * ) .
if @xmath179 it would take @xmath189 years to reach the position of filament 6 from ctb102p ( 60 pc ) , by that time the expansion velocity of the shell will be @xmath190 km s@xmath8 .
the other extreme , if @xmath180 , a radius of 60 pc would be reached in @xmath191 years , with a expansion velocity at that time of @xmath192 km s@xmath8 .
the expansion velocity for both scenarios is fairly insensitive to large @xmath193 , and reaches order of magnitude @xmath31 km s@xmath8 after roughly 2.5 million years .
the estimated thickness of the proposed shell from the 1.42 ghz continuum image and the line data is @xmath194 , corresponding to a fractional thickness of @xmath195 .
the time it takes the model shell to reach such a fractional thickness is @xmath196 years ( if @xmath179 ) or @xmath197 years ( if @xmath180 ) . if instead @xmath198 @xmath188 ( the rest of the parameters remain the same ) , time to reach 60 pc increases by a factor of @xmath199 .
this suggests that if this mechanism is responsible for the observed filaments , the ism in the direction of decreasing galactic latitude can not be more than a few particles per cubic centimeter , or the timescale exceeds the main - sequence life time of the probable star(s ) . in the basic model for the expanding swept - up shell ,
the shell density would be @xcite : @xmath200 estimates of the column density test this picture where the observed filaments are due to our line of sight through the edge of the shell .
the maximum path length @xmath201 looking through the edge of a uniform density spherical shell of radius @xmath173 and thickness @xmath202 would be : @xmath203 estimating the column density towards the filaments is done by integrating the cgps line data . the single channel ( width 0.82 km s@xmath8 ) rms noise is 3.3 k , corresponding to a single channel rms noise in the column density of @xmath204 @xmath109 . for filament 6 , @xmath205 pc and @xmath206 , which gives @xmath207 pc .
this is on the order of the radius of the proposed bubble in this direction , so this is probably an upper limit in path length through the edge of any shell associated with ctb 102 .
the column density through filament 6 is @xmath208 @xmath109 ( making the rms noise negligible ) .
the uniform density needed in a shell to produce such a column density is @xmath209 @xmath188 . in the model ,
the time required to reach this shell density ( with @xmath187 @xmath188 ) is @xmath210 years .
given the large uncertainties of the parameters involved , in @xmath173 ( from the distance uncertainty ) , @xmath202 ( uncertainty in telling where the filaments start and end ) and column density ( mainly determining the background ) , the uncertainty in the shell density can be as large as @xmath211 .
within such a large uncertainty , the model can account for observed column densities within a time frame set by the main - sequence life time of a massive star .
however , it can not be ruled out that the observed filaments are higher density regions in the ism that happen to be exposed to ionizing photons from the star(s ) powering the region .
even if that is the case , the medium between the filaments and the powering source would most likely be low density material with a high ionization fraction to allow for enough photons to reach the filaments .
such a medium is consistent with the line data and the 1.42 ghz continuum image .
the @xcite model is very basic and does not take into account multiple stellar winds nor non - uniform ism , but the estimates indicate that the bubble model is a plausible explanation of the size of ctb 102 , allowing for observed size , velocities and fractional shell thickness in a time scale of @xmath212 years . that is less than the main - sequence life time of the star(s ) that is probably powering the region .
for the same reason , it is unlikely that the proposed bubble would reach all the way out to filament 2 .
the overall morphology of ctb 102 indicates that the proposed region / bubble / chimney is a major feature in the perseus galactic arm , powerful enough to disrupt the ism and clear out a @xmath213 pc region .
the appearance of ctb 102 in the with a cleared out region makes the ctb 102 complex comparable in size to the w4 superbubble in the perseus arm @xcite .
the w4 superbubble is modeled by @xcite as expanding in a stratified atmosphere .
an association of nine o - type stars ( ic 1805 ) is probably the reason for the cavity in and the ionization structure of the w4 region .
ctb 102 shares similarities with w4 in large scale distribution and ionization structure .
we have obtained new rrl observations of ctb 102 that show that the filamentary structure surrounding the central region is physically associated with the central region .
we provide the first ever distance estimate for this region , 4.3 kpc .
we argue that the best explanation for the size and appearance of the whole complex is that it is a large region combined with a wind - blown interstellar bubble / chimeny structure .
msx , and 1.42 ghz observational data are consistent with this view .
the authors thank dana balser of nrao , green bank , for his help and problem solving skills during the gbt observations .
we thank the referee for many helpful comments .
the national radio astronomy observatory is a facility of the national science foundation operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc .
the dominion radio astrophysical observatory is operated as a national facility by the national research council of canada .
the canadian galactic plane survey is a canadian project with international partners , and is supported by a grant from the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada ( nserc ) .
this work made use of data products from the midcourse space experiment .
taylor , a. r. , gibson , s. j. , peracaula , m. , martin , p. g. , landecker , t. l. , brunt , c. m. , dewdney , p. e. , dougherty , s. m. , gray , a. d. , higgs , l. a. , kerton , c. r. , knee , l. b. g. , kothes , r. , purton , c. r. , uyaniker , b. , wallace , b. j. , willis , a. g. , & durand , d. 2003 , , 125 , 3145 ccccccc ctb102p & 21 12 28.9 & 52 32 23 & 93.115 & 2.835 & 3600 & 23.7 + 2 & 21 01 32.5 & 50 51 17 & 90.725 & 2.955 & 30000 & 21.9 + 4 & 21 05 19.1 & 52 17 01 & 92.185 & 3.465 & 14400 & 21.3 + 5 & 21 05 56.4 & 51 52 53 & 91.950 & 3.125 & 15000 & 21.0 + 6 & 21 07 14.6 & 52 07 03 & 92.260 & 3.135 & 10200 & 21.1 + 7 & 21 10 48.6 & 51 55 51 & 92.495 & 2.605 & 3000 & 21.9 + 8 & 21 15 39.9 & 52 22 03 & 93.325 & 2.365 & 7200 & 22.4 + 9 & 21 13 59.6 & 52 15 09 & 93.065 & 2.470 & 2400 & 23.0 + 10 & 21 13 49.2 & 52 27 25 & 93.195 & 2.630 & 600 & 23.5 + kr 4 & 21 16 24.3 & 52 48 02 & 93.715 & 2.585 & 3000 & 22.1 + kr 6 & 21 19 01.0 & 53 22 26 & 94.400 & 2.705 & 6600 & 21.5 + nrao 652 & 21 15 20.1 & 51 52 56 & 92.940 & 2.065 & 6600 & 23.5 + wb 43 & 21 09 21.6 & 52 22 22 & 92.668 & 3.069 & 600 & 23.9 + ccccccc ctb102p & @xmath214 & @xmath215 & @xmath216 & @xmath217 & + 2 & @xmath218 & @xmath219 & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & 16 + 4 & @xmath222 & @xmath223 & @xmath224 & @xmath225 & 5 + 5 & @xmath226 & @xmath227 & @xmath228 & @xmath229 & 11 + 6 & @xmath226 & @xmath223 & @xmath230 & @xmath231 & 4 + 7 & @xmath232 & @xmath215 & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & 5 + 8 & @xmath235 & @xmath227 & @xmath236 & @xmath237 & 6 + 9 & @xmath238 & @xmath239 & @xmath240 & @xmath241 & 4 + 10 & @xmath242 & @xmath243 & @xmath244 & @xmath245 & 2 + kr 4 & @xmath246 & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & @xmath249 & 5 + kr 6 & @xmath250 & @xmath227 & @xmath251 & @xmath252 & 7 + nrao 652 & @xmath253 & @xmath227 & @xmath254 & @xmath255 & 6 + wb 43 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 & @xmath258 & @xmath259 & 62 + cccc ctb102p & @xmath260 & @xmath261 + 2 & @xmath262 & @xmath263 + 4 & @xmath264 & @xmath265 + 5 & @xmath266 & @xmath267 + 6 & @xmath268 & @xmath269 + 7 & @xmath270 & @xmath271 + 8 & @xmath272 & @xmath273 + 9 & @xmath274 & @xmath275 + 10 & @xmath276 & @xmath277 + kr 4 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 + kr 6 & @xmath280 & @xmath281 + nrao 652 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 + wb 43 & @xmath284 & @xmath285 + | we present new radio recombination line observations of the previously unstudied region ctb 102 .
line parameters are extracted and physical parameters describing the gas are calculated .
we estimate the distance to ctb 102 to be 4.3 kpc . through comparisons with and 1.42 ghz radio continuum data
, we estimate the size of ctb 102 to be @xmath0 pc , making it one of the largest regions known , comparable to the w4 complex .
a stellar wind blown bubble model is presented as the best explanation for the observed morphology , size and velocities . |
a major goal of neutron star ( ns ) research has remained unrealized despite 30 years of effort - to determine the fundamental properties of the superdense matter in a ns interior , in particular its equation of state ( eos ) and composition .
there are many approaches which can be employed in this effort ( @xcite and references therein ) , but one of the most intensively studied is to exploit the thermal radiation from isolated ns .
this radiation can be used to deduce information about the eos from neutron star cooling theory @xcite .
extracting information about the ns interior is not straightforward , however , since the observed spectrum does not represent the ns surface emission , but is modified by radiative transfer effects in the ns atmosphere .
the problem of unfolding the observed spectrum and understanding ns interiors thus depends on deducing the composition of the atmosphere .
ns atmospheres are interesting in their own right . we know
little about their nature , other than that some ns probably have hydrogen atmospheres @xcite , since they fit well to the sophisticated h - atmosphere models that have been developed @xcite .
the observations have been silent on the question of whether non - hydrogen atmospheres exist .
the ns 1e1207.4 - 5209was discovered by @xcite with the einstein observatory and is associated with the snr pks 1209 - 51 .
subsequent observations established it as a prototypical radio silent ns associated with a snr @xcite .
rosat and asca observations were fit with a black - body spectrum @xcite and a hydrogen atmosphere model @xcite .
no x - ray pulsations were detected .
_ chandra_detected x - ray pulsations with @xmath2 s @xcite . while this is perhaps not surprising in light of previous work ,
the small period derivative estimated @xcite certainly was unexpected .
the inferred surface b - field is @xmath3 g. even more remarkable , @xcite ( hereafter szpt ) have discovered features at @xmath4 kev and @xmath5 kev are required to obtain acceptable fits to the spectrum ( which was fit with a @xmath6 k underlying black - body continuum ) .
a feature of marginal significance and unclear origin was also noted at @xmath7 kev . a subsequent observation by _ xmm - newton_@xcite has provided some hint of substructure in the features , and has marginally detected the @xmath7 kev feature seen by _
chandra_. three different phenomenological fits indicative of either absorption lines or edges were used by szpt to fit the two strong features . of enormous significance
, the spectrum was shown to be inconsistent with hydrogen atmosphere models . the intense effort which has gone into the hydrogen atmosphere models and their success in explaining other ns observations
@xcite lends credence to the inevitable conclusion that the atmosphere of 1e1207.4 - 5209is something other than hydrogen .
unfortunately , as pointed out elsewhere @xcite , work on non - hydrogen atmospheres at high b - fields is much less developed .
szpt argued on various grounds that the features could not arise via cyclotron lines .
instead they tentatively suggested emission from a once ionized - helium atmosphere with a b - field of @xmath8 g. this b - field is inconsistent with that derived from the spin parameters , but szpt argue this could be due to an off - centered b - field or glitches affecting the @xmath9 measurement .
others have argued for a cyclotron line solution at lower b - field @xcite .
@xcite claimed an atmosphere of iron or other high - z elements at a b - field of @xmath1 g , although they did not actually fit their _ xmm - newton_data to a model .
in this paper we offer alternate interpretations of these spectral features .
all our interpretations involve atomic transitions , mainly in he - like ions of mid - z elements at @xmath10 g , consistent with the b - field derived from the ns spin properties .
the most likely of these interpretations is that the ns atmosphere contains oxygen or neon ; most noteworthy is that _ all _ our models , whether considering just the two strong features or including the third weak feature , demand mid - z elements for an acceptable solution .
our model , combined with the _ xmm - newton_and _ chandra_data , easily rule out the iron and high - z solutions of @xcite .
some comments are in order on our approach .
the atomic spectroscopy data used in this analysis is based on a novel approach for obtaining fast and accurate solutions to the schrdinger equation for b - fields in the landau regime ( appropriate for all cases considered here ) .
this approach , multiconfigurational , perturbative , hybrid , hartree , hartree - fock theory , allows rapid computation of transition energies and oscillator strengths for arbitrary atom , ion , excitation state and b - field ( @xcite , hereafter mh02a ) .
this permits a complete search of all possible spectroscopic transitions consistent with the given line or edge energies . while it may appear that this approach produces an uninterestingly large number of potential solutions , we demonstrate in a companion paper ( @xcite , hereafter mh02b ) that this is not the case .
we show that the presence of two or more line or edge features provides a remarkable robustness to a host of poorly - understood atomic physics effects and unambiguously restricts the atmosphere composition to mid - z elements .
we only briefly mention our data reduction here , as our approach closely follows that of szpt .
indeed , we emphasize that none of our conclusions here would be modified if we simply used the spectral line parameters derived by szpt .
our analysis is described in more detail in mh02b .
the results presented here are for phase - integrated spectra only . subsequent work will consider phase - resolved data , which can provide more information on the system geometry .
we fit the spectrum with two models : a blackbody with two absorption edges ( edge model ) and a blackbody with two absorption lines ( line model ) .
as noted by szpt , these spectral features are required to get acceptable fits .
the fit parameters for our models are given in table [ tab_fit ] .
we show the raw _ chandra_spectrum in figure [ fig_bb ] overlaid with a blackbody to clearly indicate the presence of the absorption features .
figures [ fig_lineedge ] show the results of our best fit line and edge models .
we briefly review the quantum numbers of bound electrons in b - fields in the landau regime .
states are labeled by @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the magnetic quantum number and @xmath13 is the longitudinal quantum number .
the @xmath14 states have larger binding energy than the @xmath15 states .
consistent with the terminology of mh02a , we call the former tightly - bound states and the latter loosely - bound states . generally the ground state of an ion is a tightly - bound state . in the x - ray band transitions are mostly likely to be either photo - absorption ( tightly - bound state to continuum ) or absorption lines from tightly - bound to loosely - bound state ( tight - loose transition ) .
tight - tight transitions appear in the optical band .
details of the transition selection rules are discussed elsewhere ( mh02a , mh02b ) .
we first considered the two strongest features at @xmath4 kev and @xmath5 kev and assume both features are due to atomic transitions in a single element and ionization state ( case a ) .
this effectively defines a solution for the dominant absorbing element in terms of he - like ions .
li - like ions and those in lower ionization states are not dominant absorbers under the expected atmospheric conditions ( mh02b ) .
h - like ions can not be the dominant absorbers because this is grossly incommensurate with the features relative widths and strengths even under conditions far removed from local thermodynamic equilibrium ( mh02b ) .
h - like ions can , however , be present since the relevant spectral features will be blended with the he - like features . in the he - like ions ,
the electrons are making tight - loose transitions out of the @xmath16 ground state to the @xmath17 excited states respectively , or to the continuum .
neither tightly - bound states at higher magnetic quantum number nor non - adjacent tightly - bound states are acceptable . in the former case the feature energy ratios can not be produced and in the latter case unobserved features in the _ chandra_band would be produced .
we searched for any combination of element , redshift and b - field which could give the observed positions of the spectral features .
our b - field range was @xmath18 g to @xmath19 g. in the case of edge solutions we also permitted ( small ) pressure shifts ( details in mh02b ) .
line solutions are insensitive to pressure shifts .
the properties of the solutions including derived values of the b - field and redshift are shown in table [ tab_summary ] .
the first two solutions involve atomic line transitions in he - like oxygen and neon and the third solution he - like neon absorption edges .
a similar oxygen solution was rejected because its redshift was too low , violating causality and stability conditions for the ns interior @xcite .
for the neon edge solution there is an electron cyclotron line in the _ chandra_/_xmm - newton_energy band but it was made to overlap the higher energy spectral feature by introducing a small pressure shift ( @xmath20 ev ) .
such pressure shifts slightly affect the energy ratio of the two edge features and serve to further constrain other elements and conditions of the atmosphere ( mh02b ) . the line and edge widths are all consistent with expectations for stark broadening and non - constant b - field broadening respectively ( mh02b ) .
our case b assumes that one spectral feature is an atomic transition and the second is a cyclotron line .
a 1.4 kev or 0.7 kev electron cyclotron line defines a b - field of @xmath21 g or @xmath22 g respectively . in the former case solutions can only be found for h - like ions transitioning out of the @xmath23 ground state to the @xmath24 excited state or the continuum .
these are all mid - z solutions albeit with lower b - field than those considered above . in the case of a 0.7 kev electron cyclotron line ,
the b - field is low enough that our perturbation method breaks down for higher landau levels and is therefore less accurate ; we estimate that putative solutions would involve the elements beryllium or boron and are therefore implausible .
if one of the features is a nuclear cyclotron line then the other feature must be a transition from the ground state of either helium or hydrogen .
however there is no combination of @xmath25 and @xmath26 that can reproduce the line positions .
thus nuclear cyclotron lines are ruled out .
although case b is formally allowed we consider it highly unlikely .
there are difficulties in attempting to reconcile the depth and width of the spectral features ( mh02b ) .
nevertheless it is interesting that even this scenario including cyclotron lines only admits solutions involving mid - z elements .
table [ tab_summary ] also shows proposed solutions if the feature at @xmath7 kev is confirmed ( case c solutions ) .
again it is of importance to note that only mid - z solutions are acceptable .
we had to relax one of our previous assumptions by assuming additional significant absorption from h - like ions .
an admixture of h - like ions in a given atmosphere is quite plausible for reasonable conditions of temperature and density ( mh02b ) .
the first case considered is identical to the he - like oxygen / neon case presented above but with the addition of a h - like oxygen / neon absorption edge due to the @xmath23 ground state to continuum transition . in this model
the other h - like lines overlap the he - like lines so no additional features are produced .
the second solution invokes photoabsorption edges in he - like neon for the two lower energy features and the higher energy feature is due to an electron cyclotron line .
our most important conclusion is that _ all _ viable solutions for b - fields comparable to that inferred from the ns spin parameters require mid - z atmospheres in both the two and three spectral feature case .
our solutions which most closely correspond to the inferred b - field demand he - like oxygen and neon .
in contrast to this paper , szpt proposed ultrahigh b - field solutions .
their helium atmosphere appears problematic , however . in order to get the right feature positions szpt s
h - like helium features must of necessity arise in transitions from electrons in the @xmath23 or @xmath27 quantum states to @xmath24 and @xmath28 states .
the @xmath24 state is heavily depopulated at the types of ion densities one expects and the @xmath28 state is actually autoionized due to the large nuclear cyclotron energy . in fact the motional stark shift and pressure effects in helium will likely destroy all the loosely - bound states .
consequently one is forced to assume the features are absorption edges , and this leads to severe difficulty explaining the relative edge strengths ( mh02b ) .
@xcite did not fit their _ xmm - newton_data , but proposed nevertheless that the spectral features could be attributed to iron or some other high - z element at a field @xmath1 g. our current work rules out their proposal .
there is no combination of b - field , redshift , element or ionization states , even with unphysical , arbitrary pressure shifts , that is consistent with the _ xmm - newton_and _ chandra_data .
the interpretation we present here makes an important prediction : the observed features may show substantial substructure when observed with higher spectral resolution .
transition energies from the tightly bound ground state to loosely bound final excited states differing in longitudinal quantum number are rather close to each other , and may be blended .
details of predicted energies and transition assignments are presented in mh02b .
whether detailed atmospheric models would lead to a washing out of this substructure through broadening is not clear , but its detection would certainly confirm that the features are atomic transitions since we would not expect similar substructure in cyclotron lines .
in fact , @xcite claim a marginal detection of such substructure . concerning the b - field derived from the free parameter fits to the data , we note that our neon and oxygen line solutions are all within a factor of two or three of the b - field derived from spin parameters .
the discrepancy may lie in the ns b - field geometry or line blending .
line blending will affect our b - field ( and redshift ) estimate , but will not affect our element identifications .
the analysis here , along with that of szpt , begs the question of why there is anything in the atmosphere other than hydrogen .
oxygen or neon are expected constituents near the ns mass cut in many models of supernova explosions @xcite . indeed due to turbulent mixing in such explosions oxygen
can be found throughout the core @xcite . but given that a very thin layer of hydrogen accreted from the interstellar medium is enough to produce an optically thick hydrogen atmosphere , we are left to ponder mechanisms by which such accretion can be inhibited , or at least permit simultaneous emission from a mid - z element .
one possibility is that the timescale for an optically thick layer to accrete onto the surface is shorter than that for gravitational stratification in the atmosphere @xcite . in that case , even trace amounts of mid - z elements could lead to strong emission @xcite .
optical observations of the associated snr indicate the presence of oxygen and it has been argued that the unusually high galactic latitude of this ns implies the oxygen originated in the progenitor star @xcite
. thus a rich source of oxygen is available .
alternately the mid - z atmosphere may be associated with the ns mass cut , and a propeller effect may be severely inhibiting accretion of hydrogen .
we note that several of our proposed solutions allow a hydrogen - rich environment ( mh02b ) . for more progress to be made on 1e1207.4 - 5209it
will be necessary to develop complete models of ns atmosphere for mid - z elements incorporating the more sophisticated atomic data bases we have utilized here .
this source has much to tell us in the years to come , especially when higher resolution spectroscopic observations become available . ,
d. 1996 , supernovae and nucleosynthesis .
an investigation of the history of matter , from the big bang to the present ( princeton series in astrophysics , princeton , nj : princeton university press , |c1996 ) , g. g. , shibanov , y. a. , zavlin , v. e. , & meyer , r. d. 1995 , in the lives of the neutron stars .
proceedings of the nato advanced study institute on the lives of the neutron stars , publisher , kluwer academic , dordrecht , the netherlands , boston , massachusetts , 1995 .
p.71 lrrr @xmath29 [ ev ] & @xmath30&@xmath31&@xmath31 + @xmath32 [ 10@xmath33@xmath34 & @xmath35 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 + @xmath38 [ km ] & @xmath39&@xmath40&@xmath41 + @xmath42 [ ev ] & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & @xmath44 + @xmath45 & @xmath46&@xmath47&@xmath48 + ew@xmath49 [ ev ] & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 + @xmath53 [ ev ] & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 + @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath60 + ew@xmath61 [ ev ] & @xmath62 & @xmath63 & @xmath64 + line ( edge ) ratio & @xmath65 & @xmath66&@xmath67 + @xmath68 & 1.07 & 1.01 & 1.10 + cccccc a & & two lines & 0.550.75 & 0.060.21 & no + a & & two lines & 0.801.10 & 0.620.86 & no + a & & two edges & 0.180.20 & 0.560.57 & yes + b & & one edge & cyclotron line & 0.210.22&0.70 - 0.73 & no + b & & one line & cyclotron line & 0.130.14 & 0.100.13 & no + b & & one line & cyclotron line & 0.18 - 0.19 & 0.45 - 0.49 & no + c & , & two lines & one edge & 0.550.75 & 0.060.21 & no + c & , & two lines & one edge & 0.801.10 & 0.620.86 & no + c & & two edges & cyclotron line & 0.260.28 & 0.590.60 & yes + | recently @xcite reported the first clear detection of absorption features in an isolated neutron star , 1e1207.4 - 5209 .
remarkably their spectral modeling demonstrates that the atmosphere can not be hydrogen .
they speculated that the neutron star atmosphere is indicative of ionized helium in an ultra - strong ( @xmath0 g ) magnetic field .
we have applied our recently developed atomic model @xcite for strongly - magnetized neutron star atmospheres to this problem .
we find that this model , along with some simple atomic physics arguments , severely constrains the possible composition of the atmosphere .
in particular we find that the absorption features are naturally associated with he - like oxygen or neon in a magnetic field of @xmath1 g , comparable to the magnetic field derived from the spin parameters of the neutron star .
this interpretation is consistent with the relative line strengths and widths and is robust .
our model predicts possible substructure in the spectral features , which has now been reported by _ xmm - newton_@xcite .
however we show the mereghetti et al .
claim that the atmosphere is iron or some comparable high - z element at @xmath1 g is easily ruled out by the _ chandra_and _ xmm - newton_data . |
the success of models based on the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) @xcite approximation in describing structure phenomena , not only in nuclei along the valley of @xmath1-stability , but also in exotic nuclei with extreme isospin values and close to the particle drip lines , has also renewed the interest in theoretical studies based on the relativistic random phase approximation ( rrpa ) .
although several rrpa implementations have been available since the eighties , only very recently rrpa - based calculations have reached a level on which a quantitative comparison with experimental data became possible .
two points are essential for the successful application of the rrpa in the description of dynamical properties of finite nuclei : ( i ) the use of effective lagrangians with nonlinear self - interaction terms , and ( ii ) the fully consistent treatment of the dirac sea of negative energy states .
many studies over the last decade have shown that the inclusion of nonlinear meson terms in meson - exchange rmf models , or nonlinear nucleon self - interaction terms in relativistic point - coupling models , is absolutely necessary in order to reproduce ground - state properties of spherical and deformed nuclei on a quantitative level .
techniques which enable the inclusion of nonlinear meson interaction terms in the rrpa framework , however , have been developed only recently in the calculation of the relativistic linear response @xcite , and in the solution of the rrpa - matrix equation @xcite . for a quantitative description of excited states
, the rrpa configuration space must include not only the usual particle - hole states , but also pair - configurations formed from occupied states in the fermi sea and empty negative - energy states in the dirac sea .
even though it was known for a long time that the inclusion of configurations built from occupied positive - energy states and empty negative - energy states is essential for current conservation and the decoupling of spurious states @xcite , only recently it has been shown that the fully consistent inclusion of the dirac sea of negative energy states in the rrpa is essential for a quantitative comparison with the experimental excitation energies of giant resonances @xcite .
the rrpa with nonlinear meson interaction terms , and with a configuration space that includes the dirac sea of negative - energy state , has been very successfully employed in studies of nuclear compressional modes @xcite , of multipole giant resonances and of low - lying collective states in spherical nuclei @xcite , of the evolution of the low - lying isovector dipole response in nuclei with a large neutron excess @xcite , and of toroidal dipole resonances @xcite .
an interesting alternative to the highly successful rmf models with nonlinear self - interaction terms , is an effective hadron field theory with medium dependent meson - nucleon vertices .
such an approach retains the basic structure of the relativistic mean - field framework , but could be more directly related to the underlying microscopic description of nuclear interactions . in particular , the density dependent relativistic hadron field ( ddrh ) model @xcite has been successfully applied in the calculation of nuclear matter and ground - state properties of spherical nuclei @xcite , and extended to hypernuclei @xcite , neutron star matter @xcite , and asymmetric nuclear matter and exotic nuclei @xcite . very recently , in ref .
@xcite we have extended the relativistic hartree - bogoliubov ( rhb ) model @xcite to include density dependent meson - nucleon couplings .
the effective lagrangian is characterized by a phenomenological density dependence of the @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 meson - nucleon vertex functions , adjusted to properties of nuclear matter and finite nuclei .
it has been shown that , in comparison with standard rmf effective interactions with nonlinear meson - exchange terms , the density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings significantly improve the description of symmetric and asymmetric nuclear matter , and of isovector ground - state properties of @xmath5 nuclei .
this is , of course , very important for the extension of rmf - based models to exotic nuclei far from @xmath1-stability ( description of the neutron skin , the neutron halo , pygmy isovector dipole resonances ) , and for applications in the field of nuclear astrophysics . in this work
we derive the rrpa with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings . just as in the static case
the single - nucleon dirac equation includes the additional rearrangement self - energies that result from the variation of the vertex functionals with respect to the nucleon field operators , the explicit density dependence of the meson - nucleon couplings introduces rearrangement terms in the residual interaction of the rrpa .
the rearrangement contribution is essential for a quantitative analysis of excited states in the rrpa framework . in sec .
[ secii ] we present the formalism of the relativistic rpa with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings , and derive the rrpa equations in the small amplitude limit of the time - dependent rmf .
the results of an illustrative calculation of multipole giant resonances in @xmath0pb are analyzed in sec .
[ seciii ] .
section [ seciv ] contains the summary and the conclusions .
the standard density dependent relativistic hadron field ( ddrh ) model @xcite for nuclear matter and finite nuclei is defined by the lagrangian density @xmath6 vectors in isospin space are denoted by arrows , and bold - faced symbols indicate vectors in ordinary three - dimensional space .
the dirac spinor @xmath7 denotes the nucleon with mass @xmath8 .
@xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 are the masses of the @xmath2-meson , the @xmath3-meson , and the @xmath4-meson .
@xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 are the corresponding coupling constants for the mesons to the nucleon . @xmath15 .
the coupling constants and the mass of the @xmath2-meson are treated as free parameters , adjusted to reproduce nuclear matter properties and ground - state properties of finite nuclei .
@xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 are the field tensors of the vector fields @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and of the photon : @xmath21 the meson - nucleon couplings @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 are assumed to be vertex functions of lorentz - scalar bilinear forms of the nucleon field operators . in most applications of the density - dependent hadron field theory these couplings are chosen as functions of the vector density @xmath22 , with @xmath23 .
alternatively , the couplings could be functionals of the scalar density @xmath24 .
it has been shown , however , that the vector density dependence produces better results for finite nuclei @xcite , and provides a more natural relation between the self - energies of the density - dependent hadron field theory and the dirac - brueckner microscopic self - energies @xcite . in the present work
we choose the vector density dependence for the meson - nucleon couplings .
the single - nucleon dirac equation is derived by the variation of the lagrangian ( [ lagrangian ] ) with respect to @xmath25 @xmath26+}v({\bm r},t)+ { \bm \beta } \big(m+s({\bm r},t)\big ) + \sigma_0^r({\bm r},t ) \right\ } \psi _ { i } \;.
\label{dieq}\ ] ] the dirac hamiltonian contains the scalar and vector nucleon self - energies defined by the following relations : @xmath27 @xmath28 the density dependence of the vertex functions @xmath12 , @xmath13 , and @xmath14 produces the _ rearrangement _ contribution to the vector self - energy @xmath29 the inclusion of the rearrangement self - energies is essential for the energy - momentum conservation and the thermodynamical consistency of the model @xcite . in the time - dependent rmf model
@xcite one usually neglects the retardation effects for the meson fields , and the self - energies are determined at each time by the solutions of the klein - gordon and poisson equations : @xmath30 \,\sigma ( { \bm r,}t ) & = & -g_{\sigma } ( \rho _ v)\,\rho _ { s}({\bm r,}t ) \nonumber \\ \left [ -\delta + m_{\omega } ^{2}\right ] \,\omega _ { \mu } ( { \bm r,}t ) & = & g_{\omega } ( \rho _ v)\,j_{\mu } ( { \bm r,}t)~ , \nonumber \\ \left [ -\delta + m_{\rho } ^{2}\right ] \,\vec{\rho}_{\mu } ( { \bm r,}t ) & = & g_{\rho } ( \rho _ v)\,\,\vec{j}_{\mu } ( { \bm r},t)~ , \nonumber \\ -\delta \,a_{\mu } ( { \bm r,}t ) & = & e\,j_{c\mu } ( { \bm r},t)~. \label{kgeq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this approximation is justified by the large masses in the meson propagators .
retardation effects can be neglected because of the short range of the corresponding meson exchange forces .
the explicit solutions of eqs .
( [ kgeq ] ) read , respectively , @xmath31 with the yukawa propagators @xmath32 where @xmath33 denotes the @xmath34 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 mesons , and the photon .
the sources of the fields are the nucleon densities and currents calculated in the _ no - sea _
approximation @xmath35 where the summation is over all a occupied states in the fermi sea , i.e. only occupied single - nucleon states with positive energy explicitly contribute to the nucleon self - energies . even though the stationary solutions for the negative - energy states do not contribute to the densities in the _ no - sea _ approximation , their contribution is implicitly included in the time - evolution of the nuclear system @xcite .
the relativistic random phase approximation ( rrpa ) represents the small amplitude limit of the time - dependent relativistic mean - field theory . in the remainder of this section
we will derive the rrpa equations with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings from the response of the density matrix @xmath36 to an external field @xmath37 which oscillates with a small amplitude . in the single - particle space
this field is represented by the operator @xmath38 the expression for the single - particle density matrix reads @xmath39 by writing the dirac spinor in terms of large and small components @xmath40 the density matrix takes the form @xmath41 the equation of motion for the density operator reads @xmath42 \ ; , \label{eqmot}\ ] ] and in the small amplitude limit the density matrix is expanded to linear order @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the stationary ground - state density . from the definition of the density matrix ( [ denmat ] ) , it follows that @xmath45 is a projector at all times , i.e. @xmath46 @xmath45 .
in particular , this means that the eigenvalues of @xmath44 are 0 and 1 . in the non - relativistic case particle states above the fermi level
correspond to the eigenvalue 0 , and hole states in the fermi sea correspond to the eigenvalue 1 . in the relativistic case
, one also has to take into account states from the dirac sea . in the _ no - sea _ approximation these states are not occupied ,
i.e. they correspond to the eigenvalue 0 of the density matrix .
@xmath47 @xmath46 @xmath45 also implies , in leading order , @xmath48 and this means that the only non - vanishing matrix elements of @xmath49 are : @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 .
these are determined by the solution of equation ( [ eqmot ] ) , which in the linear approximation reads @xmath54 + \left [ \frac{\partial \hat{h}}{\partial \rho } \delta \rho , \hat{\rho}^{(0)}% \right ] + \left [ \hat{f},\hat{\rho}^{(0)}\right ] \;,\ ] ] with @xmath55 under the influence of the external field ( [ ext ] ) , in the small amplitude limit @xmath56 also exhibits the harmonic time dependence e@xmath57 .
taking into account that @xmath58 is diagonal in the stationary basis , the resulting rrpa equations read @xmath59 or , in matrix form @xmath60 \left ( \begin{array}{c } x \\ y \end{array } \right ) = \left ( \begin{array}{c } f \\ \bar{f } \end{array } \right ) \;.\ ] ] the rrpa matrices @xmath61 and @xmath62 read @xmath63 and the amplitudes @xmath64 and @xmath65 are defined @xmath66 the vectors which represent the external field contain the matrix elements @xmath67 in the self - consistent rrpa the matrix elements of the residual interaction are derived from the dirac hamiltonian of eq .
( [ dieq ] ) : @xmath68 in order to calculate the contributions of each meson field to @xmath69 , we expand the meson - nucleon couplings and their derivatives around the ground - state density @xmath70 @xmath71 if for the meson fields appearing in the scalar and vector nucleon self - energies we use the explicit solutions ( [ kgsol ] ) in terms of the meson propagators and nucleon densities and currents , the individual contributions of the meson fields to @xmath69 are obtained from the particle - hole matrix element of the dirac hamiltonian : * the contribution of the isoscalar - scalar sigma field @xmath72 where @xmath73 * the contribution of the isoscalar - vector omega field @xmath74 where @xmath75 * the contribution of the isovector - vector rho field @xmath76 where @xmath77 * and finally the contribution of the coulomb field @xmath78 the subscripts 1 and 2 of the dirac matrices refer to particle 1 and 2 , respectively .
@xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 denote the vector , scalar , and isovector - vector density , respectively , and the derivatives of the meson - nucleon couplings with respect to the vector density are evaluated at ground - state density @xmath70 . the radial integrals
@xmath82 ( @xmath83 ) contain @xmath84 , which is the radial factor in the first term of the multipole expansion of the yukawa propagator ( [ kgprop ] ) : @xmath85 we notice that , in addition to the direct contribution of the meson exchange interactions ( first terms in eqs .
( [ ress])-([resr ] ) ) , the explicit density dependence of the meson - nucleon couplings introduces a number of _ rearrangement _ terms in the residual two - body interaction @xmath86 .
these rearrangement terms are essential for fully consistent rrpa calculations . only when their contribution is included in the matrix elements of the residual interaction , it becomes possible to reproduce reasonably well the excitation energies of giant multipole resonances . without rearrangement terms
, one finds discrepancies of the order of several mev between the experimental excitation energies and the rrpa peak energies , calculated with relativistic effective interactions that are adjusted to ground state properties of spherical nuclei .
a very similar effect is observed in rrpa calculations based on effective forces with non - linear meson self - interactions , when the contribution of the non - linear terms is not included in the matrix elements of the residual interaction @xcite .
in this section the rrpa with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings is applied in illustrative calculations of giant resonances in spherical nuclei . in particular , we analyze the isoscalar monopole , the isovector dipole and the isoscalar quadrupole resonances in @xmath0pb .
we will show which isoscalar and isovector properties of the effective mean - field interactions affect the multipole strength distributions , and how the results of rrpa calculations can be used to constrain the effective interaction . for the density dependence of the meson - nucleon couplings we adopt the functionals used in refs.@xcite .
the coupling of the @xmath2-meson and @xmath3-meson to the nucleon field reads @xmath87 where @xmath88 is a function of @xmath89 , and @xmath90 denotes the baryon density at saturation in symmetric nuclear matter .
the eight real parameters in ( [ func ] ) are not independent .
the five constraints @xmath91 , @xmath92 , and @xmath93 , reduce the number of independent parameters to three .
three additional parameters in the isoscalar channel are : @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and @xmath9 - the mass of the phenomenological sigma - meson . for the @xmath4-meson coupling the functional form of the density dependence
is suggested by db calculations of asymmetric nuclear matter @xcite @xmath96\;. \label{grho}\ ] ] the isovector channel is parameterized by @xmath97 and @xmath98 . for the masses of the @xmath3 and @xmath4 mesons
usually the free values are used : @xmath99 mev and @xmath100 mev . in principle
one could also consider the density dependence of the meson masses .
however , since the effective meson - nucleon coupling in nuclear matter is determined by the ratio @xmath101 , the choice of a phenomenological density dependence of the couplings makes an explicit density dependence of the masses redundant .
the eight independent parameters , seven coupling parameters and the mass of the @xmath2-meson , are adjusted to reproduce the properties of symmetric and asymmetric nuclear matter , binding energies , charge radii and neutron radii of spherical nuclei . in particular , in ref .
@xcite we have introduced the density - dependent meson - exchange effective interaction ( dd - me1 ) , whose parameters are displayed in table [ tab1 ] .
the seven coupling parameters and the @xmath2-meson mass have been simultaneously adjusted to properties of symmetric and asymmetric nuclear matter , and to ground - state properties ( binding energies , charge radii and differences between neutron and proton radii ) of twelve spherical nuclei . for the open shell nuclei
pairing correlations have been treated in the bcs approximation with empirical pairing gaps ( five - point formula ) . in ref .
@xcite the relativistic hartree - bogoliubov ( rhb ) model with the density - dependent interaction dd - me1 in the @xmath102-channel , and with the finite range gogny interaction d1s in the @xmath103-channel , has been tested in the analysis of the equations of state for symmetric and asymmetric nuclear matter , and of ground - state properties of the sn and pb isotopic chains .
it has been shown that , as compared to standard non - linear relativistic mean - field effective forces , the interaction dd - me1 has better isovector properties and therefore provides an improved description of asymmetric nuclear matter , neutron matter and nuclei far from stability . in the present analysis
we perform fully consistent rrpa calculations of isoscalar monopole , isovector dipole and isoscalar quadrupole giant resonances in @xmath0pb .
the single - particle basis and the particle - hole couplings are obtained from the same effective lagrangian , and the configuration space includes both particle - hole pairs , as well as pairs formed from hole states and negative - energy states from the dirac sea .
our starting point is the dd - me1 effective force , both in the dirac hamiltonian ( [ dieq ] ) , as well as the residual interaction .
we then proceed to construct families of density - dependent interactions with some given characteristic ( compressibility , asymmetry energy , etc . ) , and study the resulting properties of giant resonances .
the isoscalar giant monopole resonance ( isgmr ) represents the most simple mode of collective excitations in nuclei . in particular , the isgmr in heavy nuclei is the only source of experimental information on the nuclear matter compression modulus @xmath104 .
this quantity determines basic properties of nuclei , supernovae explosions , neutron stars and heavy - ion collisions .
the range of values of @xmath104 has been deduced from the measured excitation energies of the isgmr in spherical nuclei .
the presently available experimental data set , however , does not limit the range of @xmath105 to better than @xmath106 mev .
the microscopic determination of the nuclear matter compressibility is based on the construction of sets of effective interactions that differ mostly by their prediction of the excitation energies of isgmr , i.e. by the value of @xmath105 , but otherwise reproduce reasonably well experimental data on ground - state nuclear properties @xcite .
effective interactions with different values of @xmath105 are used to calculate bulk ground - state properties of heavy spherical nuclei in a self - consistent mean - field framework , and rpa or time - dependent mean - field calculations are performed for the isoscalar monopole excitations .
such a fully consistent calculation of both ground - state properties , as well as isgmr excitation energies , restricts the range of possible values for @xmath105 .
however , since there are also other effects beyond the mean - field level which influence the isoscalar monopole resonance ( anharmonicities , pairing , coupling between single - nucleon and collective motion ) , it has been argued @xcite that , rather than on the systematics over the whole periodic table , the determination of the nuclear compressibility should rely more on a good measurement and microscopic calculations of gmr in a single heavy nucleus such as @xmath0pb .
microscopic calculations have been performed both in the non - relativistic and in the relativistic mean - field framework .
modern non - relativistic hartree - fock plus rpa calculations , using both skyrme and gogny effective interactions , indicate that the value of @xmath105 should be in the range 210 - 220 mev @xcite .
in particular , in ref .
@xcite a set of effective gogny forces was generated , which on one hand allow a good description of static properties of nuclei , and on the other hand span the range @xmath107 mev .
it was shown that the rpa calculations reproduce the available experimental data on isgmr in medium - heavy and heavy nuclei only for @xmath105 in the range 210 - 220 mev . in ref .
@xcite it has been shown that even generalized skyrme forces , with both density- and momentum - dependent terms , can only reproduce the measured breathing mode energies for values of @xmath105 in the range @xmath108 mev .
in relativistic mean - field models based on non - linear meson self - interactions on the other hand , results of both rrpa and time - dependent calculations suggest that empirical gmr energies are best reproduced by an effective force with @xmath109 mev @xcite .
it has to be emphasized , however , that even though relativistic calculations have been performed using non - linear effective interactions with different values of @xmath105 , these forces were not constructed specifically with the purpose of determining @xmath105 .
rather , standard non - linear effective interactions have been used , which also exhibit other differences that could affect the microscopic determination of the nuclear matter compressibility . starting from dd - me1 , in this work we have generated a consistent set of relativistic density - dependent effective interactions with @xmath110 mev .
the same functional form for the density dependence for the meson - nucleon couplings has been used for these forces and , except for the value of @xmath105 , their parameters have been adjusted to the same set of experimental data on ground - state properties of twelve spherical nuclei @xcite .
the results of fully consistent rrpa calculations with these forces are shown in fig .
[ figa ] , where we display the calculated excitation energies of isgmr in @xmath0pb as function of the nuclear matter compressibility .
the shaded region denotes the range of presently available experimental data @xcite .
we notice that , in accordance with the results obtained with relativistic effective forces with non - linear meson self - interactions , only the density - dependent interactions with @xmath111 mev reproduce the experimental value .
we have also verified that isgmr excitation energies for lighter nuclei , calculated with these particular interactions , are closest to the empirical curve @xmath112 mev and that they reproduce the experimental excitation energies . for the density - dependent effective interaction with @xmath113 mev , in fig .
[ figb ] we display the isoscalar monopole strength distribution and transition densities in @xmath0pb .
the position of the isgmr peak is at @xmath114 mev , and we plot the proton , neutron and total isoscalar transition densities .
the present analysis , therefore , confirms that there is a pronounced difference between the values of the nuclear matter compression modulus predicted by microscopic non - relativistic ( @xmath115 mev ) and relativistic ( @xmath116 mev ) mean - field plus random phase approximation calculations .
the origin of this discrepancy is at present not understood , even though there are some indications that it might be due , at least in part , to the differences in the density dependence of the asymmetry energy predicted by non - relativistic and relativistic models @xcite .
the calculated properties of isovector dipole giant resonances ( ivgdr ) will be predominantly determined by the isovector channel of the effective interaction .
in particular , the excitation energies of ivgdr can be directly related to the nuclear matter asymmetry energy .
the energy per particle of asymmetric nuclear matter can be expanded about the equilibrium density @xmath90 in a taylor series in @xmath4 and @xmath117 @xcite @xmath118 where @xmath119 @xmath120 and @xmath121 the empirical value of the asymmetry energy at saturation density ( volume asymmetry ) @xmath122 mev .
the parameter @xmath123 defines the linear density dependence of the asymmetry energy , and @xmath124 is the correction to the incompressibility .
the contribution of the term @xmath125 in ( [ taylor ] ) is very small in ordinary nuclei and the coefficient is not constrained in the mean - field approximation .
a ground - state nuclear property which is directly determined by the asymmetry energy is the difference between the neutron and the proton radii . in a recent study of neutron radii in non - relativistic and covariant mean - field models @xcite ,
the linear correlation between the neutron skin and the symmetry energy has been analyzed .
in particular , the analysis has shown that there is a very strong linear correlation between the neutron skin thickness in @xmath0pb and the individual parameters that determine the symmetry energy @xmath126 : @xmath127 , @xmath123 and @xmath124 .
the empirical value of @xmath128 in @xmath0pb ( @xmath129 fm from proton scattering data @xcite , and @xmath130 fm from the alpha scattering excitation of the isovector giant dipole resonance @xcite ) places the following constraints on the values of the parameters of the symmetry energy : @xmath131 mev , 2 mev/@xmath132 4 mev/@xmath133 , and @xmath134 mev @xmath135 mev .
properties of isovector collective modes in finite nuclei should , in principle , provide additional constraints on the isovector channel of the effective interaction . in an analysis of skyrme forces and giant resonances in exotic nuclei @xcite , reinhard noticed a somewhat surprising property of the ivgdr : while it is true that the excitation energy of this resonance is sensitive to the volume asymmetry @xmath127 , the resonance energy decreases by increasing the asymmetry energy at saturation .
this was qualitatively explained by noticing that an increase in the volume asymmetry is always accompanied by an increase of the slope @xmath123 , i.e. of the linear density dependence of the asymmetry energy . in order to study this effect in a more quantitative way ,
we have generated , starting from dd - me1 , a set of eight density dependent effective interactions with 30 mev @xmath136 37 mev .
the parameters of the density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings have been adjusted in such a way that , while increasing @xmath127 in units of 1 mev , the resulting effective interactions still reproduce the same set of data on ground - state properties of spherical nuclei , that was used for the original interaction dd - me1 @xcite .
this means that these effective interactions essentially differ only in their description of the asymmetry energy curve as function of the baryon density .
the resulting nuclear matter asymmetry energy curves , and the calculated ivgdr excitation energies in @xmath0pb , are displayed in fig .
[ figc ] . in the upper left panel
we plot the rrpa excitation energy of the ivgdr in @xmath0pb as function of the volume asymmetry @xmath127 .
similar to what has been observed in ref .
@xcite , the resonance energy decreases with increasing @xmath127 .
the reason for this decrease is shown in the lower left panel , where we plot the corresponding values of the slope parameter @xmath123 , which defines the linear density dependence of the asymmetry energy .
we notice that , in order to reproduce the bulk properties of spherical nuclei , an increase of @xmath127 necessitates a non - linear increase of @xmath123 .
the resulting asymmetry energy curves as functions of the baryon density are shown in the right panel of fig .
the increase of @xmath123 with @xmath127 implies a transition from a parabolic to an almost linear density dependence of @xmath137 in the density region @xmath138 @xmath139 .
this means , in particular , that the increase of the asymmetry energy at saturation point will produce an effective decrease of @xmath137 below @xmath140 @xmath139 . but
this is , of course , the density region characteristic for the ivgdr .
we find , therefore , that the excitation energy of the ivgdr decreases with increasing @xmath141 , because this increase implies a decrease of @xmath137 at low densities characteristic for the surface modes . in the upper left panel of fig .
[ figc ] we also compare the calculated ivgdr peak energies for @xmath0pb , with the experimental value of @xmath142 @xcite .
it appears that the experimental ivgdr excitation energy constrains the nuclear matter asymmetry energy at saturation density to the interval 34 mev @xmath136 36 mev . for the effective interaction with @xmath143 mev , in fig .
[ figd ] we display the rrpa isovector dipole strength distribution and the corresponding proton , neutron , and total isovector transition densities for the peak at 13.3 mev in @xmath0pb .
[ fige ] illustrates what happens when the increase of the nuclear matter asymmetry energy at saturation density is not accompanied by an increase of the slope parameter @xmath123 .
starting with dd - me1 , which has @xmath144 mev , we have generated a set of effective interactions with different values of @xmath127 , but now they all have the same slope parameter @xmath123 ( lower left panel ) , i.e. the parameters are not readjusted to reproduce the data set of ground state properties of spherical nuclei .
binding energies and radii are only approximately reproduced with these effective interactions .
the resulting asymmetry energy curves as functions of the baryon density are plotted in the right panel .
since @xmath123 is constant , by increasing @xmath127 the asymmetry energy @xmath137 increases for all densities . as a result ,
the ivgdr peak energies of @xmath0pb increase linearly with @xmath127 ( upper left panel ) . in non - relativistic rpa calculations ,
the excitation energy of the isoscalar giant quadrupole resonance ( isgqr ) can be directly related to the nucleon effective mass that characterizes a given effective interaction . in the non - relativistic mean - field approximation ,
the total effective mass @xmath145 of a nucleon in a nucleus characterizes the energy dependence of an effective local potential that is equivalent to the , generally nonlocal and frequency dependent , microscopic nuclear potential @xcite .
@xmath145 is a measure of the density of single - nucleon states around the fermi surface and , therefore , it affects the giant resonances . for skyrme interactions , in particular , a linear dependence on @xmath145
is found for the rpa excitation energies of the isgqr .
the larger the effective mass , i.e. the higher the density of states around the fermi surface , the lower is the calculated isgqr excitation energy . both the calculation of ground - state properties in spherical nuclei , as well as the rpa results for isgqr excitation energies , place the following constraint on the nucleon effective mass for skyrme - type interactions : @xmath146 @xcite . in the relativistic framework
the concept of effective nucleon mass is more complicated .
in addition to the @xmath147 ( characterizes the momentum dependence of the mass operator ) and @xmath148 ( characterizes the explicit energy dependence of the mass operator ) , a third effective mass , the `` lorentz mass '' appears in the relativistic approach .
it results from different lorentz transformation properties of the scalar and vector potentials @xcite .
however , what is usually termed `` the relativistic effective mass '' that characterizes an effective interaction , is a fourth mass : the dirac mass @xcite @xmath149 where @xmath8 is the nucleon mass and @xmath150 is the scalar nucleon self - energy .
it has to be emphasized that the dirac mass should not be identified with the effective mass determined from non - relativistic shell and optical model analyses of experimental data , i.e. with the `` non - relativistic - type effective mass '' .
the dirac mass is determined , on one hand by the binding energy at saturation density in nuclear matter ( the effective single - nucleon potential is the sum of the attractive scalar and repulsive vector nucleon self - energies ) , and on the other hand by the empirical spin - orbit splittings in finite nuclei ( the effective single - nucleon spin - orbit potential is proportional to the difference between the scalar and vector self energies ) .
this is the reason why , for virtually all mean - field relativistic effective interactions , @xmath151 .
in contrast to the non - relativistic effective mass , the dirac mass can not be related to the isgqr . on the other hand
, we would like to use the isoscalar quadrupole response to constrain the isoscalar properties of our density - dependent effective interactions .
this can be done in the following way .
we first notice that a particular ratio of isoscalar parameters @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( @xmath154 ) in eq .
( [ func ] ) , characterizes the density of single - nucleon states around the fermi surface . in fig .
[ figf ] we display the average energy gaps between the last occupied and the first unoccupied major shells @xmath155 in @xmath0pb , where @xmath156 and the sums run over occupied ( unoccupied ) states within a major shell .
the average gaps for proton and neutron states are plotted as functions of the parameter @xmath157 @xmath158 see eq .
( [ func ] ) .
starting from dd - me1 , we have generated a set of five effective interactions with @xmath159 .
for each interaction the remaining parameters were readjusted to reproduce our standard set of ground - state data for twelve spherical nuclei , as well as the nuclear matter equation of state .
the average gap between the last occupied and first unoccupied major shells , both for proton and neutron states , is approximately linearly proportional to @xmath157 .
this parameter , therefore , plays the role of the inverse of the effective mass . as functions of @xmath157 , in fig .
[ figg ] we plot the corresponding centroid energy of the isoscalar quadrupole hartree response in @xmath0pb ( upper panel ) , and the peak energies of the isgqr obtained by the full rrpa calculation with the five density - dependent interactions ( lower panel ) .
the calculated isgqr excitation energies are compared with the experimental value of @xmath160 mev @xcite ( shaded area ) .
both the centroids of the hartree response and the isgqr peak energies are linearly proportional to @xmath157 and the comparison with experimental data on isgqr , therefore , places an additional constraint on the parameters that characterize the isoscalar channel of the effective interaction . for @xmath161 , in fig .
[ figh ] we plot the rrpa isoscalar quadrupole strength distribution in @xmath0pb ( left panel ) , and for the isgqr peak at 11.2 mev the proton , neutron , and total isoscalar transition densities .
the position of the calculated peak should be compared with the empirical excitation energy @xmath160 mev , and also the @xmath162 low - lying discrete @xmath163 state at 4.62 mev is found in good agreement with the experimental value of 4.07 mev .
during the last decade the standard rmf models with nonlinear meson - exchange effective interactions have been very successfully applied in the description of a variety of nuclear structure phenomena . in the last couple of years also
the relativistic random - phase approximation ( rrpa ) , based on effective lagrangians with nonlinear meson self - interaction terms , has been used to investigate properties of low - lying collective states and of giant resonances .
the use of nonlinear effective interactions , however , presents not only a number of technical problems , but also the predictive power of models based on these type of interactions appears to be somewhat limited , especially for isovector properties of exotic nuclei far from @xmath1-stability .
an interesting alternative are models with density - dependent meson - nucleon vertex functions .
even though these two classes of models are essentially based on the same microscopic structure , i.e. on density dependent interactions , the latter can be more directly related to the underlying microscopic nuclear interactions . in a number of recent analyses it has been also shown that relativistic effective interactions , with explicit density dependence of the meson - nucleon couplings , provide an improved description of asymmetric nuclear matter , neutron matter and nuclei far from stability . among the new structure phenomena observed or predicted in nuclei far from stability ,
one of the most interesting is the evolution of the isovector dipole response in nuclei with a large neutron excess .
the multipole response of nuclei with large neutron excess has been the subject of many theoretical studies in recent years , and some predictions have been confirmed by very recent experimental data on low - lying electric dipole strength in neutron rich nuclei @xcite .
there are , however , many unknowns and this topic presents an interesting challenge for modern theoretical advances .
it is , therefore , important to develop also a relativistic framework , based on effective lagrangians with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings , in which the dynamics of exotic collective modes in nuclei far from stability can be investigated . in this work
we have derived the rrpa matrix equations in the small amplitude limit of the time - dependent relativistic mean - field theory .
the explicit density dependence of the meson - nucleon vertices introduces a number of rearrangement terms in the residual two - body interaction .
we have found that the rearrangement contribution to the matrix elements of the rrpa equations is crucial for a quantitative comparison with experimental data on giant resonances . in the present analysis
we have performed illustrative rrpa calculations of the isoscalar monopole , isovector dipole and isoscalar quadrupole response of @xmath0pb .
the calculations are fully self - consistent : the single - particle basis and the particle - hole couplings are generated from the same effective lagrangian , and the rrpa configuration space includes both the positive - energy particle - hole pairs , as well as pairs formed from hole states and negative - energy states in the dirac sea . on one hand , we have tested our approach by comparing the rrpa results for giant resonances with well known experimental data . on the other hand we have also analyzed how the rrpa results on multipole giant resonances can be used to constrain the parameters that characterize the isoscalar and isovector channel of the density - dependent effective lagrangians . starting with
the recently introduced effective interaction dd - me1 @xcite , rrpa calculations have been performed for families of density - dependent interactions with a given characteristic ( nuclear matter incompressibility , asymmetry energy etc . ) .
the analysis of the isoscalar monopole response has shown that only the density - dependent interactions with the nuclear matter compression modulus in the range @xmath111 mev , reproduce the experimental excitation energy of the isoscalar giant monopole resonance in @xmath0pb .
this confirms our previous results obtained with relativistic effective forces with non - linear meson self - interactions and points , once again , to the pronounced difference between the values of the nuclear matter compression modulus predicted by microscopic non - relativistic and relativistic mean - field plus rpa calculations .
the rrpa results for the isovector dipole response constrain the isovector channel of the effective interactions . by using interactions with different values of the volume asymmetry energy @xmath127 ,
but which otherwise reproduce the same data set of ground - state properties of spherical nuclei , we have shown that the calculated ivgdr peak energy actually decreases by increasing the asymmetry energy at saturation .
the comparison with the experimental ivgdr excitation energy constrains the volume asymmetry to the interval 34 mev @xmath136 36 mev . in the non - relativistic framework
the isoscalar quadrupole response can be related to the effective mass of the mean - field interaction .
the concept of effective mass in the relativistic mean - field models is more complicated , and the quantity which is usually termed as `` effective mass '' can not be identified with the effective mass determined from non - relativistic shell and optical model analyses of experimental data .
nevertheless , we have shown that a comparison of rrpa results with the empirical isgqr and with the low - lying @xmath162 @xmath163 state , places an additional constraint on the parameters which characterize the isoscalar channel of the density - dependent effective interactions .
the rrpa with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings presents an important step in the relativistic description of the nuclear many - body problem . in the present work we did not attempt an analysis of the multipole response in exotic nuclei far from @xmath1-stability . in order to do that
, pairing correlations must be included in the rrpa framework .
work is in progress on the fully self - consistent relativistic quasiparticle random - phase approximation ( rqrpa ) , based on effective lagrangians with density - dependent meson - nucleon couplings , and formulated in the relativistic hartree - bogoliubov canonical single - particle basis .
this work has been supported in part by the bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung under project 06 tm 979 , and by the gesellschaft f " ur schwerionenforschung ( gsi ) darmstadt .
t. n. acknowledges the support from the alexander von humboldt - stiftung . | the matrix equations of the relativistic random - phase approximation ( rrpa ) are derived for an effective lagrangian characterized by density - dependent meson - nucleon vertex functions .
the explicit density dependence of the meson - nucleon couplings introduces rearrangement terms in the residual two - body interaction , that are essential for a quantitative description of excited states .
illustrative calculations of the isoscalar monopole , isovector dipole and isoscalar quadrupole response of @xmath0pb , are performed in the fully self - consistent rrpa framework , based on effective interactions with a phenomenological density dependence adjusted to nuclear matter and ground - state properties of spherical nuclei .
the comparison of the rrpa results on multipole giant resonances with experimental data constrains the parameters that characterize the isoscalar and isovector channel of the density - dependent effective interactions . |
evolutionary games @xcite have recently received ample attention in the physics community , as it became obvious that methods of statistical physics can be used successfully to study also interactions that are more complex than just those between particles @xcite .
broadly classified as statistical physics of social dynamics @xcite , these studies aim to elevate our understanding of collective phenomena in society on a level that is akin to the understanding we have about interacting particle systems . within the theoretical framework of evolutionary games ,
the evolution of cooperation @xcite is probably the most interesting collective phenomenon to study .
several evolutionary games constitute so - called social dilemmas @xcite , the most prominent of which is the prisoner s dilemma game , and in which understanding the evolution of cooperation still a grand challenge .
regardless of game particularities , a social dilemma implies that the collective wellbeing is at odds with individual success .
an individual is therefore tempted to act so as to maximize her own profit , but at the same time neglecting negative consequences this has for the society as a whole .
a frequently quoted consequence of such selfish actions is the `` tragedy of the commons '' @xcite .
while cooperation is regarded as the strategy leading away from the threatening social decline , it is puzzling why individuals would choose to sacrifice some fraction of personal benefits for the wellbeing of society . according to nowak @xcite
, five rules promote the evolution of cooperation .
these are kin selection , direct and indirect reciprocity , network reciprocity , and group selection .
recent reviews @xcite clearly attest to the fact that physics - inspired research has helped refine many of these concepts .
in particular evolutionary games on networks , spurred on by the seminal discovery of spatial reciprocity @xcite , and subsequently by the discovery that scale - free networks strongly facilitate the evolution of cooperation @xcite , are still receiving ample attention to this day @xcite .
one of the most recent contributions to the subject concerns the assignment of cognitive skills to individuals that engage in evolutionary games on networks @xcite .
the earliest forerunners to these advances can be considered strategies such as `` tit - for - tat '' @xcite and pavlov @xcite , many of which were proposed already during the seminal experiments performed by axelrod @xcite , and which assume individuals have cognitive skills that exceed those granted to them in the framework of classical game theory .
it has recently been shown , for example , that incipient cognition solves several open question related to network reciprocity and that cognitive strategies are particularly fit to take advantage of the ability of heterogeneous networks to promote the evolution of cooperation @xcite .
here we build on our previous work @xcite , where we have presented the idea that not strategies but rather emotions could be the subject of imitation during the evolutionary process .
it is worth noting that the transmissive nature of positive and negative emotional states was already observed in @xcite , where it was concluded that humans really do adjust their emotions depending on their contacts in a social network .
moreover , the connection between intuition and willingness to cooperate was also tested in human experiments @xcite .
it therefore is of interest to determine how the topology of the interaction network affects the spreading of emotions , which may in turn determine the level of cooperation . in the context of games on lattices
, we have shown that imitating emotions such as goodwill and envy from the more successful players reinstalls imitation as a tour de force for resolving social dilemmas , even for games where the nash equilibrium is a mixed phase .
we have also argued that envy is an important inhibitor of cooperative behavior .
we now revisit the snowdrift , stag - hunt and the prisoner s dilemma game on random graphs and scale - free networks , with the aim of determining the role of interaction heterogeneity within this framework .
we focus on sympathy and envy as the two key emotions determining the emotional profile of each player , and we define them simply as the probability to cooperate with less and more successful opponents , respectively . strategies thus become link - specific rather than player - specific , whereby the level of cooperation in the population can be determined by the average number of times players choose to cooperate .
interestingly , in agreement with a recent experiment , we find that network reciprocity plays a negligible role @xcite .
the outcome on regular random graphs is the same as reported previously for the square lattice , leading to the conclusion that the ability of cooperators to aggregate into spatially compact clusters is irrelevant .
only when degree heterogeneity is introduced to interaction networks , we find that the evolution of emotional profiles changes .
as we will show , homogeneous networks lead to fixations that are characterized by high sympathy and high envy , while heterogeneous networks lead to low or modest sympathy and low envy .
network heterogeneity thus alleviates a key impediment to higher levels of cooperation on lattices and regular networks , namely envy , and by doing so opens the possibility to much more cooperative states even under extremely adverse conditions . from a different point of view
, it can be argued that some topological features of interaction networks in fact determine the emotional profiles of players , and they do so in such a way that cooperation is the most frequently chosen strategy .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows .
first , we describe the mathematical model , in particular the protocol for the imitation of emotional profiles as well as the definition of social dilemmas on networks .
next we present the main results , whereas lastly we summarize and discuss their implications .
the traditional setup of an evolutionary game assumes @xmath0 players occupying vertices of an interaction network . moreover ,
each player @xmath1 having a pure strategy , cooperates @xmath2 or defects @xmath3 with all neighbors independently of their strategy and payoff . here , instead of pure strategies
, we introduce an emotional profile @xmath4 $ ] to each player , which characterizes the willingness to cooperate towards a neighbor in dependence on the other player s success that is quantified by the payoff value .
more precisely , if the corresponding payoff values are @xmath5 and @xmath6 for players @xmath1 and @xmath7 , respectively , then @xmath8 determines the probability that player @xmath1 will cooperate with player @xmath7 in case of @xmath9 .
conversely , when @xmath10 , the parameter @xmath11 is the probability that player @xmath1 will cooperate with player @xmath7 . in the rare case of equality ( @xmath12 ) ,
the corresponding probability is the average of @xmath8 and @xmath11 . in this way
the @xmath13 pair thus determines how a given player @xmath1 will behave when facing less or a more successful opponent @xmath7 .
as described in the introduction , the pair determines each player s sympathy and envy . if @xmath14 we say the player is completely sympathetic .
alternative interpretations such as goodwill and charity are also viable , given that player @xmath1 will always cooperate with less successful opponents .
similarly , if @xmath15 we say the player is not envious .
despite the fact that the opponents are more successful , she will always cooperate with them .
as by @xmath8 , alternatives such as servility or proneness to brownnose or `` butter up '' appear fit as well .
it is important to note that a player @xmath1 may simultaneously cooperate and defect towards neighbors @xmath7 and @xmath16 if their payoffs are very different .
furthermore , player @xmath1 may adopt different strategies even if @xmath17 due to the probabilistic nature of an emotional profile .
when two players engage in a round of an evolutionary game , we assume that mutual cooperation yields the reward @xmath18 , mutual defection leads to punishment @xmath19 , and the mixed choice gives the cooperator the sucker s
payoff @xmath20 and the defector the temptation @xmath21 . within this traditional setup
we have the prisoner s dilemma ( pd ) game if @xmath22 , the snowdrift game ( sg ) if @xmath23 , and the stag - hunt ( sh ) game if @xmath24 , thus covering all three major social dilemma types where players can choose between cooperation and defection . following common practice @xcite , we set @xmath25 and @xmath26 , thus leaving the remaining two payoffs to occupy @xmath27 and @xmath28 , as depicted schematically in fig .
[ rrg](a ) . to begin , each player @xmath1
is assigned a random @xmath13 pair and a payoff from the reachable @xmath29 $ ] interval , where @xmath30 denotes the average degree of players .
subsequently , every payoff value is updated by considering the proper neighborhoods of a player and the actual emotional parameters .
importantly , after the accumulation of new payoffs , player @xmath7 can not imitate a pure strategy from player @xmath1 but only its emotional profile , i.e. , the @xmath8 and/or @xmath11 value .
imitation is decided so that a randomly selected player @xmath1 first acquires its payoff @xmath5 by playing the game with all its @xmath31 neighbors , as defined by the interaction network .
note that @xmath31 is thus the degree of player @xmath1 .
next , one randomly chosen partner of @xmath1 , denoted by @xmath7 , also acquires its payoff @xmath6 by playing the game with all its @xmath32 neighbors .
player @xmath7 then attempts to imitate the emotional profile of players @xmath1 with the probability @xmath33\}$ ] , where @xmath34 determines the level of uncertainty by strategy adoptions @xcite .
the latter can be attributed to errors in judgment due to mistakes and external influences that affect the evaluation of the opponent . without loss of generality we set @xmath35 , implying that better performing players are readily imitated , but it is not impossible to adopt the strategy of a player performing worse . importantly , since the emotional profile consist of two parameters , two random numbers are drawn to enable independent imitation of @xmath8 and @xmath11 .
this is vital to avoid potential artificial propagations of freak ( extremely successful ) @xmath13 pairs .
technically , @xmath36 @xmath13 pairs were available at the start of the evolutionary process .
finally , after each imitation the payoff of player @xmath7 is updated using its new emotional profile , whereby each full monte carlo step involves all players having a chance to adopt the emotional profile from one of their neighbors once on average .
prior to presenting the result of this model , it is important to note that there will almost always be a fixation of @xmath13 pairs , i.e. , irrespective of @xmath21 and @xmath20 only a single pair will eventually spread across the whole population .
once fixation occurs the evolutionary process stops .
the characteristic probability of encountering cooperative behavior in the population , which is equivalent to the stationary fraction of cooperators @xmath37 in the traditional version of the game , can then be determined by means of averaging over the final states that emerge from different initial conditions .
exceptions to single @xmath38 pair fixations are likely to occur for strongly heterogeneous networks , where more than one @xmath13 pair can survive around strong hubs .
this effect is more pronounced in the harmony game ( hg ) quadrant , but becomes negligible in the prisoner s dilemma parametrization of the game . in case
more than a single @xmath13 pair does survive , we present in what follows the average over several independent realizations . for the monte carlo simulations
, we have used @xmath39 players and up to @xmath40 full steps , and we have averaged over @xmath41 independent runs .
we start by presenting results obtained on a regular random graph @xcite with @xmath42 , as it is a natural extension of a simple square lattice population which we have considered before in @xcite . importantly , while the degree distribution remains uniform , other topological features , like the presence of shortcuts or the emergence of a nonzero clustering coefficient , change significantly .
previous works on games using pure strategies highlighted that these details may play a significant role by the evolution of cooperation in social dilemmas @xcite .
figure [ rrg ] depicts the color map encoding the fixation values of @xmath43 ( left ) and @xmath44 ( right ) on the @xmath45 parameter plane . from the presented results it follows
that if the governing social dilemma is of the snowdrift type , players will always ( never ) cooperate with their neighbors provided their payoff is lower ( higher ) . in the prisoner s dilemma quadrant
, we can observe either complete dominance of defection regardless of the status of the opponents , or the same situation as in the snowdrift quadrant provided @xmath20 is not too negative . for the stag - hunt and the harmony game
the outcome is practically identical as obtained by means of the traditional version of the two games . in general , however , both color profiles differ only insignificantly from the ones we have reported in @xcite ( see figs . 2 and 3 there ) for the square lattice .
this leads to the conclusion that the structure of interactions does not play a prominent role as long as the degree of all players is uniform .
this leads to suspect that the heterogeneity of interactions might play a pivotal role .
we therefore depart from the regular random graph to random graphs with different degree distributions , as depicted in fig .
we consider four different types of random graphs with gaussian distributed degree , yet with increasing variance . according to the legend of fig .
[ dist ] , the random graph with @xmath46 is thus the least heterogeneous ( only degrees @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 are possible ) , while the random graph with @xmath50 is the most heterogeneous .
increasing gradually the variance from @xmath46 to @xmath50 thus enables us to monitor directly the consequences of heterogeneity stemming from the interaction network .
color maps encoding the fixation values of @xmath43 and @xmath44 for the four different random graphs are depicted in fig .
[ randoms ] . by following the plots from left to right
, it can be observed that as the heterogeneity of the interaction network increases , the fixation of profiles of both @xmath43 and @xmath44 change . by focusing on the snowdrift and the prisoner s dilemma quadrant
, there is a gradual shift from high-@xmath43 low-@xmath44 emotional profiles to low-@xmath43 and high-@xmath44 values as heterogeneity increases .
accordingly , taking into account also results presented in fig .
[ rrg ] , we conclude that homogeneous interaction networks promote emotions like sympathy and envy ( @xmath51 and @xmath52 ) , while heterogeneous interaction network prefer indifference and servility ( @xmath53 and @xmath54 ) .
it is worth highlighting that these emotional profiles emerge completely spontaneously based on payoff - driven imitation .
the change is thus brought about exclusively by the heterogeneity of the interaction network .
it is possible to take a step further in terms of the heterogeneity of the interaction network by considering scale - free networks .
we therefore make use of the standard model proposed by barabsi and albert @xcite .
results presented in fig .
[ sf ] further support our arguments , as the region of low and moderate @xmath43 values extends further into the snowdrift quadrant , while at the same time low @xmath44 values vanish more and more from both the snowdrift and the prisoner s dilemma quadrant . as before ,
the harmony games and the stag - hunt quadrant remain relatively unaffected , which corroborates the fact that the proposed shift from the imitation of strategies to the imitation of emotional profiles affect predominantly the social dilemma games .
it is also worth reminding that on scale - free networks the fixation may not be unique because different hubs can sustain their own micro - environment independently from the other hubs .
we therefore depict an average over several independent realizations to arrive at representative results . in order to obtain an understanding of the preference for low-@xmath43 and high-@xmath44 values , as it is exerted by heterogeneous interaction networks ,
it is of interest to examine the time evolution of @xmath43 and @xmath44 values , as depicted in fig .
[ fixation ] .
the figure shows the probability of any given @xmath38 pair in the population at different times increasing from top left to bottom right .
it can be observed that high-@xmath43
high-@xmath44 combinations die out first .
these players cooperate with both their more and less successful opponents , and they do so with a high probability . in agreement with well - known results concerning the evolution of cooperation in spatial social dilemmas @xcite ,
the bulk of cooperators is always the first to die out . only after their arrangement in suitable compact domains the cooperators can take advantage of network reciprocity and prevail against defectors . in our case , however ,
this does not happen , i.e. , the `` always cooperate '' players never recover .
instead , the evolution proceeds by eliminating also all pairs which contain moderate and high @xmath43 values , until finally the only surviving low-@xmath43 profiles are left to compete .
however , preserving at least some form of cooperation may yield an evolutionary advantage , and thus ultimately the low-@xmath43
high-@xmath44 emotional profile emerges as the only remaining .
notably , the described scenario is characteristic only for heterogeneous networks . for homogeneous networks the differences between players are more subtle , and
indeed it is not at all obvious that cooperating with the more successful neighbors would confer an evolutionary advantage .
accordingly , high-@xmath44 profiles are not viable and die out .
cooperation can thrive only on the expense of high @xmath43 values , as reported already in @xcite .
importantly though , given an appropriately heterogeneous interaction network , the low-@xmath43
high-@xmath44 emotional profile can be very much beneficial for the global cooperation level . to support this statement
, we present in fig .
[ cooperate ] the average frequency of cooperation as obtained on the regular random graph ( left ) and the scale - free network ( right ) .
note that the former in general represent homogeneous graphs .
the comparison reveals that a much higher cooperation level can be sustained , especially in the snowdrift quadrant , if the dominating emotions are neither sympathy nor envy .
to confirm this further , we have manually imposed a high-@xmath43 low-@xmath44 emotional profile on the scale - free network . while this profile is optimal for homogeneous networks ( compare also fig .
[ cooperate ] ( left ) with fig .
4 in @xcite ) the outcome on heterogeneous networks is disappointing , yielding no more than a modest cooperation level of @xmath55 in the most challenging snowdrift and prisoner s dilemma regions .
this imposes another interesting conclusion , namely , if the emotional profiles of players can evolve freely as dictated by payoff - driven imitation microscopic dynamics , then the topology `` selects '' the optimal profile in order to produce the highest attainable cooperation level .
lastly , it is instructive to explore how the low-@xmath43
high-@xmath44 emotional profile actually works on scale - free networks .
a visualization is possible by measuring separately the average willingness to cooperate for players who have different degree .
since the payoff of every player is obtained from the pairwise interaction constituted by each individual link , a higher degree @xmath30 therefore in general leads to a higher payoff and also a higher `` social prestige '' . as fig .
[ degree ] illustrates , players with low degree will dominantly cooperate with their opponents that have a higher degree and thus most likely a higher payoff . in other words , they can use the `` @xmath44-part '' of their emotional profile .
this act of cooperation , however , is unilateral because the hubs rarely compensate it . due to low values of @xmath43 cooperation with the less successful players
is strongly suppressed .
what is more , while players with a higher degree also cooperate with the more successful opponents ( they have the same emotional profile and hence the same high @xmath44 ) , this action is very rare given that there are simply not many who would be superior .
it is sad but still true that the hubs with the highest degree very rarely cooperate in the stationary state . despite this rather unfriendly behavior of the `` leaders '' ,
the average cooperation level is still acceptable and in fact remarkably high even under adverse conditions ( e.g. , @xmath56 and @xmath57 ) , but this is exclusively because the inferior players do their best and virtually always cooperate towards their superiors .
we have shown that high levels of cooperation can evolve amongst self - interested individuals if instead of strategies they adopt simple emotional profiles from their neighbors .
since the imitation was governed solely by the payoffs of players , we have made no additional assumptions concerning the microscopic dynamics .
the later has been governed by the traditional `` follow the more successful '' rule , which we have implemented with some leeway due to the fermi function . starting from an initial configuration with all possible emotional profiles , we have determined the one that remains after sufficiently long relaxation ( only in the harmony game quadrant , if staged on heterogeneous networks , the fixation may not be unique ) .
we have found that the fixation depends not only on the parametrization of the game , but even more so on the topology of the interaction network .
more precisely , the topology - induced heterogeneity of players has been identified as the most important property . if players were staged on a network where their degree was equal , then independently of other topological properties of the network the fixation occurred on emotional profiles characterized by high @xmath43 and low @xmath44 values in the interesting payoff region . in agreement with the definition of @xmath43 and @xmath44 ,
these are players characterized by high sympathy but also high envy .
this profile is also in agreement with the one reported earlier in @xcite for the square lattice . on heterogeneous networks , however , the fixation is most likely to be on low or moderate values of @xmath43 and high values of @xmath44 .
accordingly , we have the prevalence of low sympathy ( charity , goodwill ) for those that are doing worse , but also little envy ( high servility , proneness to brownnose or `` suck up '' ) towards those that are doing better .
noteworthy , although we have not presented actual results , the application of payoffs normalized with the degree of players returns the same results as observed on homogeneous networks .
this observation is in agreement with our preliminary expectation because it is well established that the scale - free topology introduces a strong heterogeneity amongst players , but also that this effect is effectively diminished by applying normalized payoffs or degree - sensitive cost @xcite .
accordingly , in the latter case players become `` equal '' , which results in the selection of emotional profile we have recorded for regular graphs .
this observation strengthens further our argument that indeed solely the heterogeneity of players is crucial for the selection of the dominant emotional profile .
we thus may argue that on heterogeneous networks each `` dictators dream '' profile can evolve via a simple evolutionary rule .
the majority may not be happy about it because the combination of moderate @xmath43 and high @xmath44 values is not necessarily the most coveted personality profile .
yet as our study shows , it does have its social advantages .
namely , in the absence of envy or in the presence of servility the cooperation level in the whole population can be maintained relatively very high , even if the conditions for the evolution of cooperation are extremely adverse ( high @xmath21 , low @xmath20 ) . in this sense , we conclude that charity and envy are easily outperformed by competitiveness and proneness to please the dominant players , and that indeed this profile emerges completely spontaneous .
put differently , it can be argued that it is in fact chosen by the heterogeneity amongst players that is introduced by an appropriate interaction network .
we would also like to emphasize that the discussed `` emotional profiles '' do not necessarily cover the broader psychological interpretation of the term @xcite .
we have used this terminology to express the liberty of each individual to act differently towards different partners in dependence on the differences in social rank ( or success ) , which traditional strategies in the context of evolutionary games do not allow . as such , and in the absence of considering further details determining our personality ,
our very simple model naturally can not be held accountable for describing actual human behavior .
instead , it reveals the topology of interactions as a crucial property that determines the collective behavior of a social network . according to our observations ,
it is indeed the heterogeneity of the interaction network that is key in determining our willingness to help others .
finally , we emphasize that in the present model cooperation is maintained without reciprocity .
the mechanism at work here is very different from those discussed thoroughly in previous studies . unlike direct and indirect reciprocity , network reciprocity , or even reputation , punishment and reward , which are all deeply routed in the fact that neighboring cooperators will help each other out while at the same time neighboring defectors will craft their own demise , here
the nature of links determines the winner .
it may well happen that cooperation and defection occur along the same link , yet still the status of the population as a whole is very robust .
what players really share is the way how to behave towards each other under different circumstances , which is determined within the framework of an emotional profile .
+ + this research was supported by the hungarian national research fund ( grant k-101490 ) , china s education ministry via the humanities and social sciences research project ( 11yjc630208 ) , and the slovenian research agency ( grant j1 - 4055 ) . | we show that the resolution of social dilemmas on random graphs and scale - free networks is facilitated by imitating not the strategy of better performing players but rather their emotions .
we assume sympathy and envy as the two emotions that determine the strategy of each player by any given interaction , and we define them as probabilities to cooperate with players having a lower and higher payoff , respectively . starting with a population where all possible combinations of the two emotions are available
, the evolutionary process leads to a spontaneous fixation to a single emotional profile that is eventually adopted by all players . however , this emotional profile depends not only on the payoffs but also on the heterogeneity of the interaction network .
homogeneous networks , such as lattices and regular random graphs , lead to fixations that are characterized by high sympathy and high envy , while heterogeneous networks lead to low or modest sympathy but also low envy .
our results thus suggest that public emotions and the propensity to cooperate at large depend , and are in fact determined by the properties of the interaction network . |
the theoretical expression for the angular two - point correlation function @xmath3 can be derived from its spatial counterpart @xmath4 by projection via the relativistic limber equation ( peebles 1980 ) : @xmath5 ^ 2 } , \label{eq : limber}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath6 is the comoving radial coordinate , @xmath7 ( for a flat universe and in the small angle approximation ) , and @xmath8 is the number of objects within the shell ( @xmath9 ) . + the mass - mass correlation function @xmath10 to be inserted in eq.([eq : limber ] ) has been obtained following the work by @xcite ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) , which provides an analytical way to derive the trend of @xmath10 both in the linear and non - linear regime . note that @xmath10 _ only _ depends on the underlying cosmology , which we fix by adopting @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and a cobe - normalized value of @xmath14 .
the relevant properties of scuba galaxies are included in the redshift distribution of sources @xmath8 , and in the bias factor @xmath15 .
the effective bias factor @xmath16 of all the dark matter haloes with masses greater than some threshold @xmath17 is then obtained by integrating the quantity @xmath18 ( whose expression has been taken from @xcite ) - representing the bias of individual haloes of mass @xmath19 - opportunely weighted by the number density @xmath20 of scuba sources : @xmath21 note that , as @xmath22 can be thought as the fraction of haloes hosting a galaxy in the process of forming stars , its expression can also be written as @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the mass spectrum of haloes with masses between @xmath19 and @xmath25 ( @xcite ) , @xmath26 is the duration of the star - formation burst and @xmath27 is the life - time of the haloes in which these objects reside ( see @xcite ) . according to @xcite , sources showing up in the scuba counts can be broadly divided into three categories : low - mass ( masses in the range @xmath28 , duration of the star formation burst @xmath29 gyr , and typical fluxes @xmath30 mjy ) , intermediate - mass ( @xmath31@xmath32 and @xmath33 gyr ) and high - mass ( @xmath34 , @xmath35 gyr , dominating the counts at fluxes @xmath36 mjy ) .
note that by @xmath37 we denote the mass in stars at completion of the star formation process .
+ in order to evaluate the bias factor in eq.([eq : bias ] ) we then consider two extreme cases for the ratio between the mass in stars and the mass of the host dark halo : @xmath38 and @xmath39 . @xmath40 roughly corresponds to the ratio @xmath41 between total and baryon density , where we adopted for the latter quantity the standard value from primordial nucleosynthesis ; this corresponds to having assumed all the baryons to be locked into stars and , as a consequence , has to be considered as a conservative lower limit .
@xmath38 is instead related to @xmath42 , @xmath43 being the present mass density in visible stars : the likely value is expected to be @xmath44 % .
armed with the above results we can then evaluate the two - point correlation function in eq .
( [ eq : limber ] ) for different @xmath45 ratios and different flux cuts .
figure 1 presents our predictions for @xmath3 , respectively for a flux cut of 50 ( solid line ) , 10 ( dashed line ) and 1 ( dotted line ) mjy . higher curves of each kind correspond to the case @xmath38 , while lower curves refer to @xmath40 . +
the highest clustering amplitude is found for the brightest sources ( @xmath46 mjy ) .
this is because they are associated to the most massive dark halos and are therefore highly biased tracers of the dark matter distribution .
in addition , according to @xcite , they have a rather narrow redshift distribution so that the dilution of the clustering signal is minimum .
the very sharp drop of all the curves at @xmath47 is due to the absence of nearby objects .
this reflects the notion that the actively star - forming phase in spheroids is completed at @xmath48 .
+ note that , since the clustering amplitude strongly depends on the quantity @xmath45 , measurements of the angular correlation function @xmath3 are in principle able to discriminate amongst different models of scuba galaxies and in particular to determine both their star - formation rate , via the amount of baryonic mass actively partaking the process of star formation , and the duration of the star - formation burst . a first attempt to measure the angular correlation function of @xmath49 mjy scuba sources has been recently presented by @xcite .
although such measurements are dominated by noise due to small - number statistics , it is nevertheless interesting to note that as illustrated by the left - hand panel of figure 2 our model ( with a preference for the @xmath38 case ) shows full consistency with the data ( kindly provided by s. scott ) . another possible way to obtain some information on the nature of scuba sources via their clustering properties
is provided by the predictions of @xcite for lyman - break galaxies to be the low- to intermediate - mass tail of primeval spheroidal galaxies , with @xmath50 gyr and a star - formation rate ranging from a few to a hundred @xmath51 . in figure 2
( right - hand panel ) we then plotted the predicted @xmath3 for those sources with @xmath52 mjy ( corresponding to @xmath53 ) , expected to be found within the redshift range @xmath54 , covered by the original ( steidel et al . , 1996 ) sample . as in the former case ,
the higher curve is for @xmath38 , the lower one for @xmath40 .
the data points show the @xcite measurements . even though large errors once again affect the observational findings
, it is nevertheless clear that the predicted trend for @xmath3 can correctly reproduce the data for high ( @xmath55 ) values of the @xmath2 ratio .
this result is consistent with the predictions by @xcite and implies a well defined relationship between scuba galaxies and lbgs .
furthermore , it also confirms the expectations for a small fraction ( on the order of a few percent ) of the total mass to be confined into stars .
finally , it is also worth noticing that our predictions are in agreement with the strong clustering of eros recently detected by @xcite , since we expect ( @xcite ) these objects to be the direct descendants of scuba galaxies , and therefore to exhibit the same clustering properties .
an issue intimately connected with the analysis of galaxy clustering is the study of the contribution of unresolved sources ( i.e. sources with fluxes fainter than some detection limit @xmath56 ) to the background intensity .
its general expression is given by : @xmath57 ( see e.g. @xcite ) , where @xmath58 denotes the differential number counts , @xmath59 and @xmath60 are respectively the maximum and minimum local luminosity of the sources , @xmath61 is the k - correction , @xmath62 is the redshift when the sources begin to shine , @xmath63 is the redshift at which a source of luminosity @xmath64 is seen with a flux equal to the detection limit @xmath56 , @xmath65 is the luminosity function ( i.e. the comoving number density of sources per unit @xmath66 ) , and @xmath6 is the comoving radial coordinate .
the intensity fluctuation @xmath67 due to inhomogeneities in the space distribution of unresolved sources is then given by eq .
( [ eq : i ] ) , with the quantity @xmath65 replaced by @xmath68 .
it is easily shown that the angular correlation of such intensity fluctuations @xmath69 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 define two positions on the sky separated by an angle @xmath72 , can be expressed as the sum of two terms @xmath73 and @xmath74 , the first one due to poisson noise ( i.e. fluctuations given by randomly distributed objects ) , and the second one owing to source clustering .
it is possible to show ( @xcite ) that , in the case of highly clustered sources , the poissonian term @xmath73 is negligible with respect to the one due to clustering . in the following we therefore only concentrate on temperature fluctuations caused by the @xmath74 term ( hereafter simply called @xmath75 ) . by making use of the quantities
previously defined and of eq .
( [ eq : i ] ) , the clustering term @xmath75 takes the form : @xmath76 where the effective volume emissivity @xmath77 is expressed as : @xmath78}\!\!\!\!\ !
\phi(l , z)\ ; k(l , z)\ ; l\;d{\rm log}l \label{eq : jeff}\end{aligned}\ ] ] .
@xmath79 in eq.([eq : cth ] ) has been evaluated separately for the three cases of low- , intermediate- and high - mass objects , by plugging in eq .
( [ eq : jeff ] ) the appropriate expressions for the luminosity function . the total contribution of clustering to intensity fluctuations
has then been derived by adding up all the values of @xmath79 obtained for the different mass intervals and by also taking into account the cross - correlation terms between objects of different masses , according to the expression @xmath80 where the indexes @xmath81,@xmath82 stand for high , intermediate and low masses .
+ note that , the quantity @xmath83 in eq.([eq : cth ] ) should indeed be read as @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the maximum halo mass corresponding to the maximum visible bulge mass ( i.e. upper limit for the mass locked into stars ) , which corresponds in eq.([eq : bias ] ) to a replacement in the upper limit of the integrals of @xmath86 with @xmath85 .
the angular power spectrum of the intensity fluctuations can then be obtained via ( see @xcite ) : @xmath87 ^ 2{\rm exp}\left(- \frac{h\nu}{k_b t}\right)/\left(\frac{h\nu}{k_b t } \right)^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which relates intensity and temperature fluctuations .
figure [ fig : dt ] shows the predicted values for the quantity @xmath88 ( in units of k ) at respectively 353 ghz ( @xmath89 m left - hand panel ) and 545 ghz ( @xmath90 m right - hand panel ) the central frequencies of two of the channels of the high frequency instrument ( hfi ) of the esa s planck mission as a function of the multipole @xmath91 up to @xmath92 .
results are plotted for two different values of the source detection limit ( @xmath93 and 10 mjy for the 353 ghz case and @xmath94 and 45 mjy for the 545 ghz case ) and the usual two values of @xmath2 .
also shown , for comparison , is the power spectrum of primary ( cmb ) anisotropies ( solid line ) predicted for the cosmology specified in the caption , computed with the cmbfast code developed by @xcite . at @xmath89
m , our model predicts fluctuations of amplitude due to clustering comparable to ( and possibly even larger than ) those obtained for primary cmb anisotropies at @xmath95 .
this is because most of the clustering signal comes from massive galaxies with fluxes @xmath96 mjy , which lie at substantial redshifts and are therefore highly biased tracers of the underlying mass distribution .
also the strongly negative k - correction increases their contribution to the effective volume emissivity [ eq . ( [ eq : jeff ] ) ] and therefore to the fluctuations .
the @xmath90 m case is even more striking , since the contribution from clustering is expected to be more than an order of magnitude greater than the one originating from primordial fluctuations , regardless of the flux detection limit .
+ this implies that important information on the clustering properties of faint sub - mm galaxies ( and hence on physical properties such as their mass and/or the amount of baryons involved in the star - formation process ) will reside in the planck maps at frequencies greater than 353 ghz where , however , the dominant signal is expected to come from interstellar dust emission . in order to show this effect , in figure 3
we have also plotted the expected contribution from galactic dust emission averaged all over the sky ( upper dashed - dotted curves ) .
this was derived from the iras maps at @xmath97 m , rescaled at the frequencies under exam by assuming a grey - body spectrum with @xmath98 k. as already anticipated , this signal appears to be the dominant one in both the 353 and 545 ghz planck channels . nevertheless , it is still possible to extract information on the nature of sub - mm galaxies if one restricts the analysis to high galactic latitude regions ( i.e. @xmath99 , lower dashed - dotted curves in figure 3 ) , which are the least affected by galactic dust emission . in fact , as it can be seen from figure 3 , the dust contribution in this region becomes less important than the one due to the clustering of unresolved sources for @xmath100 .
daddi , e. , cimatti , a. , pozzetti , l. , hoekstra , h. , rttgering , h.j.a . ,
renzini , a. , zamorani , g. , mannucci , f. 2000 , a&a 361 , 535 de zotti , g. , franceschini , a. , toffolatti , l. , mazzei , p. , danese , l. , 1996 , ap . lett.comm .
35 , 289 giavalisco , m. , steidel , c.c . ,
adelberger , k.l . ,
dickinson , m.e . ,
pettini , m. , kellogg , m. 1998 , apj 503 , 543 granato , g.l .
, silva , l. , monaco , p. , panuzzo , p. , salucci , p. , de zotti , g. , danese , l. 2001 , mnras 324,757 jing , y.p .
1998 , apj 503 , l9 magliocchetti , m. , bagla , j. , maddox , s.j . ,
lahav , o. 2000 , mnras 314 , 546 magliocchetti , m. , moscardini , l. , panuzzo , p. , granato , g.l . , de zotti , g. , danese , l. 2001 , mnras , accepted , astro - ph/0102464 martini , p. & weinberg , d.h . , 2001 ,
apj 547 , 12 moscardini l. , coles p. , lucchin f. , matarrese s. , 1998 , mnras , 299 , 95 peacock , j.a .
& dodds s.j . , 1996 ,
mnras 267 , 1020 peebles , p.j.e .
1980 , the large - scale structure of the universe , princeton university press seljak , u. , zaldarriaga , m. 1996 , apj 469 , 437 .
scott , s.e .
, et al . , astro - ph/0107446 sheth , r.k . & tormen , g. 1999 , mnras 308 , 119 smail , i. , ivison , r.j . ,
blain , a.w .
1997 , apj 490 , l5 | the clustering properties of scuba - selected galaxies are investigated within the framework of a unifying scheme relating the formation of qsos and spheroids .
the theoretical angular correlation function is derived for different bias functions , corresponding to different values of the ratio @xmath0 between the mass of the dark halos hosting such galaxies and the mass in stars produced at the end of the major star - formation burst .
scuba sources are predicted to be strongly clustered , with a clustering strength increasing with mass .
comparisons with the best available measurements show better fits for @xmath1 . the model can also account for the clustering of lyman - break galaxies , seen as the optical counterpart of low- to intermediate - mass primeval spheroidal galaxies .
best agreement is once again obtained for high values of the @xmath2 ratio .
we also discuss implications for small scale fluctuations observed at different wavelengths by forthcoming experiments such as the planck mission aimed at mapping the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) . |
most of the neutron star low mass x ray binaries can be divided into two classes , z and atoll sources , based on the correlated behavior of their timing properties at low frequencies ( @xmath0 hz ) and their x ray spectral properties @xcite .
both classes show quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) with frequencies ranging from a few hundred hz to more than 1000 hz ( kilohertz qpos ) . the low
frequency part of the power spectra of both classes is usually dominated by a similar broad band limited noise component , but it is unclear if these are physically the same component @xcite .
in addition to the band limited noise both classes show several quasi - periodic oscillations below 200 hz . in the z sources these are named after the branch of the z track in the color color diagram ( see below ) where they mostly occur : horizontal ( hbos ) , normal ( nbos ) and flaring branch oscillations ( fbos ) .
the hbo shows a sub and a second harmonic at @xmath1 and @xmath2 times the frequency of the main peak , and sometimes a peak at @xmath3 times the frequency of the hbo @xcite . obviously , the most straightforward interpretation of this is that the sub hbo is the fundamental frequency , with second , third and fourth harmonics all observed @xcite .
below 200 hz the atoll sources show several lorentzian components ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
note that these components are called lorentzian and not qpo ; this is because these features are sometimes too broad ( fwhm @xmath4 centroid frequency/2 ) to be classified as a qpo . in the atoll sources all components
become broader as their characteristic frequency decreases @xcite .
it has been suggested that the hbo in the z and the low frequency lorentzian in the atoll sources are the same physical components @xcite . the energy spectrum of neutron star low mass x
ray binaries can be usefully parametrized through the use of color color or color intensity diagrams , where a color is the ratio of counts in two different energy bands . as the energy spectrum of a source changes , it moves through these diagrams .
the timing properties of both the z and the atoll sources depend on the position of the source in the color color diagram .
the z sources move fast through the color color diagram and draw up a z track within hours to days ( see e.g. gx 340 + 0 ; * ? ? ?
* ) whereas the typical atoll sources move slowly through the color color diagram and draw up a c shaped track within weeks to months ( see e.g. 4u 172834 ; * ? ? ?
* ) , although the `` banana '' part of the track , a curved branch to the bottom and right hand sides of the diagram , is traced out as fast as in the z sources .
the slow motion in the island part of the diagram , to the left hand and top sides , combined with observational windowing , tends to lead to the formation of isolated patches of data points , which is the origin of the term `` island state '' @xcite .
whereas the continuum power spectra of the banana state are dominated by a power law component at low frequencies with perhaps a weak band limited noise component ( which becomes stronger as the source approaches the island state ) , the island state power spectra are dominated by the band limited noise . as the source moves away from the banana into the island state the count rate drops , the x
ray spectrum becomes harder and the band limited noise becomes stronger while its characteristic frequency decreases . in the most extreme island states ( 4u 160852 ; @xcite ; @xcite ; 4u 0614 + 09 ; @xcite ; @xcite ; 4u 172834 ; @xcite ; @xcite ; 4u 170544 ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; aql x1 ; @xcite ; ks 1731260 ; @xcite ) the source is faint and hard and the band
limited noise is strong ; this is the state in which neutron stars are most similar to bhcs in the low hard state @xcite . because of the low count rates and slow motion through the color color diagram the precise properties of the extreme island state have been hard to ascertain , although observations of 4u 160852 with tenma @xcite indicated the existence of an extended branch in this state that was traced out over an interval of weeks .
recently , @xcite and @xcite used large data sets from the rossi x ray timing explorer ( rxte ) to study the color
color diagrams of several of the z and atoll sources , which contain interesting additional information about , in particular , the nature of the extreme island state in the transient atoll sources 4u 160852 , 4u 170544 and aql x1 .
they suggested that the atoll sources trace out similar three
branch patterns as the z sources , with the extreme island state cast in the role of z source horizontal branch .
however , these authors did not address the timing properties of the sources they studied . in this paper
, we continue our work on the correlated x ray spectral and timing behavior of z and atoll sources using rxte @xcite with an analysis of 4u 160852 . in these previous analyses ,
we have found strong correlations between the behavior of the timing features and the position of the source in the color color diagram in both z and atoll sources .
4u 160852 is a transient source that shows outbursts with a recurrence time varying between 80 days and several years @xcite .
frequency qpos were discovered in the `` island '' state of 4u 160852 with the ginga satellite @xcite and kilohertz qpos were discovered with rxte @xcite .
the source was included in the samples studied by @xcite and @xcite and was one of the sources that was reported to show z like behavior in the color color diagram . by connecting the timing with the energy spectral properties we can test whether 4u 160852 indeed behaves as a z source .
if this is true one would expect the power spectral properties to change smoothly along the z track , as is the case in the z sources .
we find that this is not the case . in
[ sec.disc ] we also perform a more general comparison of frequencies observed in the z and the atoll sources .
parallel tracks in color color and color intensity diagrams were first observed in the z sources @xcite and later also in the atoll sources 4u 163653 @xcite , 4u 1735 - 44 @xcite and 4u 0614 + 09 @xcite .
recently @xcite reported further parallel tracks in the color
intensity diagrams of several atoll sources .
the parallel track phenomenon in the plot of lower kilohertz qpo frequency versus intensity was first observed in 4u 0614 + 09 @xcite and 4u 160852 @xcite and has since been observed in several more atoll sources ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
it has been suggested that the parallel tracks in the plot of intensity versus frequency of the lower kilohertz qpo and the parallel tracks in the color intensity diagrams might be the same phenomena @xcite .
van der klis ( 2001 ) has proposed a possible explanation for this parallel track phenomenon in terms of a filtered response of part of the x ray emission to changes in the mass accretion rate through the disk .
the frequency versus intensity parallel track phenomenon is particularly clear in 4u 160852 @xcite . in [ sec.tracks ] we investigate the relation between these frequency versus intensity parallel tracks and the parallel tracks in the color intensity diagrams .
in this analysis we use all available public data from 1996 march 3 to 2000 may 24 from rxte s proportional counter array ( pca ; for more instrument information see * ? ? ?
the data are divided into observations that consist of one to several satellite orbits .
we exclude data for which the angle of the source above the earth limb is less than 10 degrees or for which the pointing offset is greater then 0.02 degrees . in our data
set we found 7 type i x ray bursts and we exclude those ( @xmath5 s before and @xmath6 s after the onset of each burst ) from our analysis .
we use the 16s time
resolution standard 2 mode to calculate the colors . for each of the five pca detectors ( pcus )
we calculate a hard color , defined as the count rate in the energy band [email protected] kev divided by the rate in the energy band [email protected] kev , and a soft color , defined as the count rate in the energy band [email protected] kev divided by the rate in the energy band [email protected] kev . per detector
we also calculate the intensity , the count rate in the energy band [email protected] kev . to obtain the count rates in these exact energy ranges we interpolate linearly between count rates in the pcu channels .
we calculate the colors and intensity for each time interval of 16 s. we subtract the background contribution in each band using the standard background model for the pca version 2.1e . in order to correct for the changes in effective area between the different gain epochs and for the gain
drifts within those epochs as well as the differences in effective area between the pcus themselves we used the method introduced by @xcite : for each pcu we calculate the colors of the crab , which can be supposed to be constant in its colors , in the same manner as for 4u 160852 .
we then average the 16 s crab colors and intensity per pcu for each day . in figure [ fig.crab ]
we can see the clear differences in the soft color trends of crab between the five pcus caused by the effects mentioned above . for each pcu we divide the 16 s color and intensity values
obtained for 4u 160852 by the corresponding crab values that are closest in time but within the same gain epoch .
we then average the colors and intensity over all pcus . if we multiply the soft color by 2.36 , the hard color by 0.56 and the intensity by 2400 c / s / pcu we approximately recover the observed , uncorrected values for 4u 160852 ( quoted values are averages of the crab colors during the observations over all five pcus ) . to improve statistics we rebin the 16 s color and intensity points to 256 s and exclude all data for which the resulting relative errors are larger than 5% .
this led to a loss of about 40 ks of data at count rates below @xmath8 crab . for most of these data
neither timing nor colors were of sufficient quality to determine the source state .
starting may 12 , 2000 , the propane layer on pcu0 , which functions as an anti coincidence shield for charged particles , was lost . however , as all our data after may 12 , 2000 ( @xmath9 ks ) was excluded because the relative color errors were larger than 5% this was not a issue in our analysis . for the fourier timing analysis we use the 122@xmath10s time
resolution event and single bit modes and the 0.95@xmath10s time resolution good xenon modes .
we only use data for which all energy channels are available . this led to a loss of about 9 ks of data in the lower banana state . in some observations there was data overflow in the timing modes due to excessive count rates from the source ; we excluded those data . this led to a loss of about 27 ks of data at the highest intensity level
( see also below ) .
the power spectra were constructed using data segments of 256 s and 1/8192 s time bins such that the lowest available frequency is 1/256 hz and the nyquist frequency 4096 hz ; the normalization of @xcite was used . to get a first impression of the timing properties at the different dates and positions in the color color diagram ,
the power spectra were combined per observation .
the resulting power spectra were then converted to squared fractional rms .
we subtracted a constant poisson noise level estimated between 2000 and 4000 hz where neither noise nor qpos are known to be present .
as fit function we use the multi lorentzian function
; a sum of lorentzian components @xcite plus a power law to fit the vlfn ( see * ? ? ?
we only include those lorentzians in the fit whose significance based on the error in the power integrated from 0 to @xmath11 is above 3.0 @xmath12 .
two to five lorentzian components were generally needed for a good fit . for the lorentzian that is used to fit the band limited noise we fixed the centroid frequency to zero .
we plot the power spectra in the power times frequency representation ( @xmath13 ; e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , where the power spectral density is multiplied by its fourier frequency . for a multi
lorentzian fit function this representation helps to visualize a characteristic frequency , @xmath14 , namely , the frequency where each lorentzian component contributes most of its variance per logarithmic frequency interval : in @xmath13 the lorentzian s maximum occurs at @xmath14 ( @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the centroid and @xmath17 the hwhm of the lorentzian ; * ? ? ?
we represent the lorentzian relative width by @xmath18 defined as @xmath19 .
in this section we try to get an idea of the timing properties of the source as it moves through the color color diagram .
we step through the data in chronological order and look at the timing properties ( per observation , see [ sec.obs ] ) and the position of the source in the color color diagram . in this way we select continuous time intervals
for which the power spectrum and the position in the color color diagram remain similar . for each continuous time interval
we construct a representative power spectrum by adding up all observations within that interval . to get a first idea of the timing properties we made initial fits to the representative power spectra of the continuous time intervals using the multi
lorentzian fit function described in [ sec.obs ] . in most cases the power spectral features present could be directly identified with known components seen in other atoll sources by comparing with the power spectral features of 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 172834 ( using figures 1 , 2 and 3 of * ? ? ?
a more thorough fitting and description of the power spectral features will be presented in
[ sec.comb_ps ] where we obtain optimal statistics by constructing representative intervals for all our data by adding up the continuous time intervals that have similar positions in the color color diagram and show similar power spectra .
the data on 4u 160852 can be usefully divided into 3 segments .
the first segment ranges from 1996 march 3 to december 28 ( the decay of the 1996 outburst , see * ? ? ?
* ) , the second segment from 1998 february 3 to september 29 ( the 1998 outburst , see * ? ? ? * ) and the third segment from 2000 march 6 to may 10 ( persistent data ) .
in practice most data were available for the second segment ( the 1998 outburst ) so we will present the results for the second segment first .
these results can then serve as a template for the rest of the data . in figure [ fig.cc_deel2 ]
we show as black points the lightcurve and color color diagram for the second segment of the data ( the 1998 outburst ) .
the grey points in the lower frame represent the overall color color diagram including all the data .
intensity and colors are normalized to the crab ( see [ sec.obs ] ) .
the numbers 917 ( 18 are reserved for the first segment of the lightcurve ) indicate the continuous time intervals for which the power spectra and the position in the color color diagram remain similar ( see [ sec.timingtour ] ) . the data for which no power spectra could be computed due to data overflow ( see also [ sec.obs ] ) are indicated by the larger crosses at the peak of the outburst and in interval 9 of the color color diagram . in table [ tbl.timingtour ] we present the duration of each interval , the time until the next interval and the 216 kev intensity during each interval .
we identify several power spectral features and classify the continuous time intervals into color intervals a j ; these will be discussed in [ sec.comb_ps ] where we put all information together . for the 1998 outburst
we find 7 different classes , i.e. , the source returns twice to similar positions in the color color diagram where it displays similar power spectral shapes .
each class is marked with a different symbol in the color color diagram of figure [ fig.cc_deel2 ] .
for the 1998 outburst we confirm the result of @xcite that the color color diagram shows the classical atoll shape ( see * ? ? ?
the characteristic frequencies of most of the power spectral components increase along the track starting at the open triangles and ending at the crosses in figure [ fig.cc_deel2 ] ( for a more detailed discussion of the power spectral behavior with respect to the position in the color color diagram , see
[ sec.move_cc ] ) . in figure [ fig.cc_deel1 ]
we show as black points the lightcurve and color color diagram for the first segment of the data ( the decay of the 1996 outburst ) .
the grey points represent the overall color color diagram including all the data .
the numbers 18 again indicate continuous time intervals for which the power spectra and the position in the color color diagram remain similar .
the symbols and entries in table [ tbl.timingtour ] are as described in [ sec.segment2 ] .
we find one class additional to those observed during intervals 917 .
this class is composed of continuous time intervals 2 , 4 and 6 , fills up the region between the open diamonds and the filled stars in the color color diagram , and is marked with open stars in figure [ fig.cc_deel1 ] .
note further that part of the open diamonds here are in a slightly different position in the color color diagram , at a higher hard color and a lower soft color , than where they were during the second segment of the lightcurve .
this is accompanied by a lower intensity .
if we sort the classes by characteristic frequency as measured in the power spectra , the characteristic frequencies change along an `` @xmath20shaped '' track in the color color diagram ( see also [ sec.move_cc ] ) . in the third segment of the data the source count rates were low and in most observations
one or more detectors were switched off .
this , together with the short durations of the observations ( only @xmath21 s per observation ) led to bad statistics . in most cases it was impossible to identify any power spectral features , therefore the classification for this segment of the data
was solely done on position in the color color diagram .
if any power spectral features were detected they were always consistent with this color based classification .
as before , in figure [ fig.cc_deel3 ] black points represent the lightcurve and color color diagram for the third segment of the data and grey points the overall color color diagram .
the numbers 1830 now indicate continuous time intervals for which the position in the color color diagram remained similar , and the symbols mark the classification , here based on the position in the color color diagram only ; entries in table [ tbl.timingtour ] are as described in
[ sec.segment2 ] .
note that the source is in the class marked with the crosses for only the second time during continuous time interval 21 , but now at much lower intensity ( 0.03 crab ) than it was the first time in continuous time interval 9 ( 0.241.30 crab ) at the peak of the 1998 outburst . to improve the statistics we average the power spectra in each of the 8 classes . in the class marked with the filled circles the lower kilohertz qpo is extremely narrow and varies in frequency over several hundreds of hz .
this leads to multiple peaks in the power spectrum .
therefore we split up this class into three parts depending on lower kilohertz qpo frequency ; the first with the lower kilohertz qpo ranging from 540 to 640 hz , the second with the lower kilohertz qpo ranging from 640 to 710 hz and the third with the lower kilohertz qpo ranging from 710 to 900 hz .
a finer division would have compromised the statistics at low frequencies .
the observations in this class where no lower ( or upper ) kilohertz qpo was detected were added based on position in the color color diagram . in figure [ fig.cc_int ]
we show the resulting 10 intervals in the color color diagram and in figure [ fig.hid_sid_int ] we show the corresponding hard color and soft color vs. intensity diagrams .
note that the data for which no power spectra could be computed due to data overflow ( see [ sec.obs ] and [ sec.segment2 ] ) are not included in figures [ fig.cc_int ] and [ fig.hid_sid_int ] .
we mark the different classes in order of increasing characteristic frequencies from a to j. we use letters here to avoid confusion with the numbered continuous time intervals of [ sec.timingtour ] .
we fit each interval with the multi
lorentzian fit function described in 2 . for the intervals where the kilohertz qpos have sufficiently high frequencies not to interfere with the low frequency features and vice
versa , we fit the kilohertz qpos between 500 and 2048 hz and then fix the kilohertz qpo parameters when we fit the whole power spectra .
this is for computational reasons only ; the results are the same as those obtained with all parameters free .
if the @xmath18 value of a lorentzian becomes negative in the fit , we fix it to zero .
no significantly negative q s occured .
the fits have a @xmath22/dof below 1.4 for intervals a
g . for interval
h the @xmath22/dof is high ( 5.43 ) ; this is caused by the motion of the lower kilohertz qpo from 710 to 900 hz ( see above ) .
for intervals i and j the @xmath22/dof are 2.5 ( dof = 100 ) and 1.8 ( dof = 97 ) .
this is caused by deviations of the vlfn from the power law used to fit it ( see appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] ) .
we now specify the terminology that we will use for the various power spectral components .
typical power spectral components observed for the atoll sources are described for the two sources 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 172834 in @xcite . as in @xcite
we call the upper kilohertz qpo l@xmath23 and its characteristic frequency @xmath24 .
the lower kilohertz qpo has been linked to a broad bump at @xmath9 to @xmath25 hz found in the low luminosity bursters 1e 17243045 , gs 182624 and slx 1735269 @xcite and in the atoll source 4u 0614 + 09 at its lowest characteristic frequencies @xcite .
although we emphasize that this identification is very tentative ( see [ comp : timing : atoll ] ) we will , as was done in @xcite , call both the lower kilohertz qpo and this 1025 hz bump ( which do not occur simultaneously ) , l@xmath26 ( characteristic frequency @xmath27 ) .
no standard terminology yet existed for the hectohertz lorentzian @xcite ; here we will call it l@xmath28 ( characteristic frequency @xmath29 ) .
the behavior of the band limited noise and qpos in the 0.150 hz range in the atoll sources 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 is complex ( see also * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we describe it as a function of @xmath24 or position in the color color diagram ( see figure [ fig.freq_freq ] ) .
first , the characteristic frequency of the band limited noise increases from @xmath30 to @xmath31 hz . in this phase
the band limited noise is broad and usually fitted with a zero centered lorentzian or a broken power law . then at @xmath31 hz this noise component appears to `` transform '' into a narrow qpo ( called very low
frequency lorentzian in * ? ? ?
* ) whose frequency smoothly continues to increase up to @xmath32 hz , while what appears to be another band limited noise component appears at lower characteristic frequencies .
it is unclear exactly how these three components are related . here , to remain true to the naming scheme of @xcite we call the band limited noise component that becomes a qpo as well as the qpo it becomes l@xmath33 ( characteristic frequency @xmath34 ) and the `` new '' broad band limited noise appearing at lower frequency l@xmath35 ( characteristic frequency @xmath36 ) , but
please note the uncertainties in the interpretation underlying this nomenclature .
finally , in the banana branch of 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 ( where usually no kilohertz qpos are detected ) a broad lorentzian is also present at @xmath37 hz for which it is unclear whether it is l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 or a new component ; here we shall list it as l@xmath35 .
the atoll sources 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 both additionally show a @xmath38 hz lorentzian at frequencies above l@xmath33 , called the low frequency lorentzian by @xcite . at high characteristic frequencies ( @xmath39 hz ) this lorentzian appears as a narrow qpo . at low characteristic frequencies ( @xmath40 hz ) this lorentzian is broad and
can be identified with the component in the low luminosity bursters which @xcite call l@xmath41 ( hump ) .
for this reason , we also call this low frequency lorentzian l@xmath41 ( characteristic frequency @xmath42 ) . in some observations
the low luminosity bursters show a narrow low
frequency qpo ( called l@xmath43 in * ? ? ?
* ) simultaneously with l@xmath41 .
the @xmath14 of l@xmath43 is slightly lower than that of l@xmath41 . for 1e 17243045
the lorentzian centroid frequencies of l@xmath43 and l@xmath41 coincided but this was not the case for gs 182624 @xcite .
l@xmath43 was not observed in 4u 172834 or 4u 0614 + 09 and we also do not detect it in 4u 160852 .
a detailed description of the behaviour of the power spectral components of 4u 160852 is given in appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] .
in figure [ fig.powspec_1608 ] we show the averaged power spectra and best fit functions of the intervals a j .
the fit parameters for the low
frequency part of the power
spectra are listed in table [ tbl.lowfitpar ] , the fit parameters for the high frequency part are listed in table [ tbl.highfitpar ] .
we obtain 95% confidence upper limits for the fractional rms amplitude of l@xmath28 in intervals b , c and e and of l@xmath41 in intervals b , c and e using @xmath44 , fixing @xmath18 to 0.2 and allowing @xmath29 to run between 100 and 200 hz . for setting upper limits to l@xmath41 we fix @xmath18 to 1.5 , 3.0 and 3.5 and let @xmath42 run between 2232 hz , 3444 hz and 4250 hz respectively ( the values expected from the results for 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 ) .
in figure [ fig.freq_freq ] we plot the characteristic frequencies of 4u 160852 versus @xmath24 , together with the results of @xcite for 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 .
the black points mark the results for 4u 160852 , the grey points the results for 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 .
the different symbols indicate different power spectral components .
the results for 4u 160852 mostly fall on the relations established for 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 .
also the @xmath18 values of the various components versus @xmath24 are similar to those for 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 . in figure [ fig.rms_all ]
we plot the rms fractional amplitude of all components versus @xmath24 .
the general trends in this plot for 4u 160852 are similar to those of 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 @xcite , but there is an offset in rms between the relations for the three sources @xcite .
for the two kilohertz qpos the rms fractional amplitudes in 4u 160852 are similar to those in 4u 0614 + 09 but larger than in 4u 172834 @xcite .
for all other features ; l@xmath28 , l@xmath41 , l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 and at low frequencies l@xmath26 the rms fractional amplitudes for 4u 0614 + 09 are the largest followed by 4u 172834 whereas the rms fractional amplitudes for 4u 160852 are the lowest . as we describe in appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] in more detail , both the relations in figures [ fig.freq_freq ] and [ fig.rms_all ] as well as a direct comparison with the power spectra of 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 ( figures 1 and 2 in * ? ? ?
* ) allow us to identify the power spectral components of 4u 160852 in the different intervals within the identification scheme described above .
now that we have described and identified all power spectral components in 4u 160852 , we can link the timing properties ( tables [ tbl.lowfitpar ] and [ tbl.highfitpar ] ) to the position in the color color diagram .
we can also link the timing properties and x ray spectral properties to the classical island and banana states described by @xcite .
intervals a d are occurrences of the island state ( strong broadband noise with low @xmath14 , no vlfn ) in which intervals a
c can be classified as the extreme island state .
the extreme island state shows l@xmath33 , l@xmath41 , l@xmath26 and l@xmath23 all at low characteristic frequencies .
the power spectral components are all broad and strong .
interval e forms a transition between the island state and the lower banana , it still has relatively strong broad band noise but also shows a pair of narrow kilohertz qpos that are typical for what @xcite called the lower left banana state .
so , intervals f h are all lower left banana state . here
the vlfn appears , the kilohertz qpos are double , l@xmath33 transforms from a band limited noise component into a qpo and l@xmath35 appears ( see also [ sec.comb_ps ] ) .
intervals i and most of interval j are also still in what @xcite called the lower banana state based on their position in the color color diagram ; only the upper right part in the color color diagram of interval j is in the upper banana state based on color color position .
the vlfn is strong and the broad band noise is weak in these intervals .
intervals i and j show l@xmath23 at the highest frequencies , l@xmath35 , and a strong vlfn component .
the characteristic frequencies increase in order a
j and form an `` @xmath20shaped '' track in the color color diagram .
recently , @xcite and @xcite studied the color color diagrams of several of the z and atoll sources , including 4u 160852 , and suggested that the atoll sources trace out similar three
branch patterns as the z sources .
we observe the same shape of the color color diagram for 4u 160852 as @xcite and @xcite did ( fig .
[ fig.cc_int ] ) .
interval c in figure [ fig.cc_int ] represents a deviation from the classical atoll shape .
according to the interpretation of @xcite and @xcite the source would have to move in the z track order d
c in figure [ fig.cc_int ] .
interval c would then correspond to the horizontal branch of the z sources .
we observe a transition from d to c and back to d with gaps of three days during the decay of the 1996 outburst ( fig .
[ fig.cc_deel1 ] ) .
we also observe a transition from e to c and back to e with gaps of only one day during the decay of the 1998 outburst ( fig .
[ fig.cc_deel2 ] ) .
the source is first in e for an interval of @xmath45 day during which the hard color increases by @xmath46 ( so @xmath47 day@xmath48 ) , then there is a gap of 0.9 day after which the source appears in c with an increase in hard color of @xmath30 ( if the source moved directly from e to c @xmath49 day@xmath48 ) .
then in c there is an interval of @xmath50 day where the hard color increases by @xmath46 ( @xmath49 day@xmath48 ) .
so this is consistent with the source moving directly from e to c at approximately constant speed ( probably through d ) and not through a or b as required if 4u 160852 behaved as a z source . in c
there is a gap of @xmath51 day after which the source appears again in c but at a slightly ( @xmath52 ) lower hard color . for an @xmath45 day interval the source stays in c while the hard color decreases by @xmath52 ( @xmath53 day@xmath48 ) . then there is a gap of @xmath54 day and after that the source has returned to e with a hard color of @xmath30 less ( @xmath55 day@xmath48 )
this is consistent with the source moving directly back from c to e , again at constant speed , and not through a or b. transitions from and to states a and b had gaps of 7 and more days , so it is impossible to draw conclusions from these .
the characteristic frequencies of the timing features decrease in the order d
b a ( appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] ) .
this is also not consistent with the idea that 4u 1608 - 52 behaves as a z source , as in z sources the characteristic frequencies of the timing features increase along the z starting at the horizontal branch ( i.e. , this would predict frequencies decreasing in the order dbac ) .
one might say that 4u 160852 draws up an approximate `` @xmath20 '' shape in the color color diagram along which the characteristic frequencies of the timing features change smoothly .
parallel tracks in the intensity versus lower kilohertz qpo frequency in 4u 160852 were discovered by @xcite , and extensively studied by @xcite and @xcite . the hard color and soft color vs. intensity diagrams of 4u 160852 ( see fig . [ fig.hid_sid_int ] ) and those of several other atoll sources also show narrow parallel tracks @xcite . based on the appearance of the diagrams , it has been suggested that there is a relation between these two types of parallel tracks @xcite .
based on our new analysis it is now possible to directly link the parallel tracks in the color intensity diagrams to those in the qpo frequency
intensity diagrams using the frequency of the lower kilohertz qpo as obtained by @xcite .
similarly to @xcite and @xcite we only include data for which both kilohertz qpos are detected simultaneously and therefore the lower kilohertz qpo is identified unambiguously .
we rebin our 16 s colors in such a way that they match the 64448 s data intervals of @xcite . in figure [ fig.mendez_rate ]
we plot the frequency of the lower kilohertz qpo and the hard and soft color versus the 2.016.0 kev intensity .
the alternating black / grey symbols represent the parallel tracks in the intensity versus the frequency diagram ; the tracks contain data that are continuous in time , with only the @xmath56 s gaps due to earth occultations .
note that the parallel track phenomenon in the lower kilohertz qpo frequency vs. intensity diagram is only observed in a small region of the color intensity diagrams ( see figure [ fig.hid_sid_int ] ) where the lower kilohertz qpo is strong and narrow enough to be accurately traced on 64448 s timescales . with this analysis
, we can investigate how the parallel tracks in the frequency vs. intensity diagram relate to those in the color intensity diagrams .
interestingly , it turns out that the frequency
intensity tracks can not , as previously thought , be identified with the narrow vertical tracks visible in the color intensity diagrams of figures [ fig.hid_sid_int ] and [ fig.mendez_rate ] .
each of these latter tracks corresponds to a single satellite orbit .
the parallel tracks in the frequency vs. intensity diagram are only identifiable as ( rather fuzzy ) tracks in the color intensity diagrams after several satellite orbits have elapsed and thus turn out to be composed of several of those narrow vertical tracks .
the parallel tracks in the frequency versus intensity diagram could also identified in the hard color intensity diagram of 4u 163653 , where two banana tracks shifted by 20 % in intensity were observed in the hard color intensity diagram @xcite , and exactly the same 20 % shift was observed between the corresponding two parallel lines in the frequency versus intensity diagram . in 4u 160852
we do not observe complete banana tracks shifted in intensity as in 4u 163653 .
the drift in x ray flux in 4u 160852 already occurs on timescales of several days @xcite , too short for a complete track to form , where in 4u 163653 the source can stay on one track for several months @xcite .
these fast changes in intensity in 4u 160852 are due to its transient character , where 4u 163653 is a persistent source for which changes in intensity occur much more gradually .
note , that within each of the two parallel lines in the frequency versus intensity diagram of 4u 163653 there is no correlation observed between frequency and intensity .
the narrow vertical tracks in the color intensity diagrams are caused by variations in color that for the most part can be explained by the scatter due to counting statistics .
the parallel tracks in the frequency versus intensity diagram , although composed of data covering several consecutive satellite orbits , already show up within individual orbits due to a short term correlation between the lower kilohertz qpo frequency and intensity in combination with small errors in these quantities but persist over several consecutive orbits .
the correlation between colors and intensity ( or kilohertz qpo frequency ) in individual orbits is veiled by the limited counting statistics , so in the color intensity diagrams the parallel qpo tracks can only be identified on the longer timescales of several satellite orbits . to further illustrate this point in figure [ fig.mendez_sc ] we plot soft color versus the frequency of the lower kilohertz qpo ; lines connect the points of individual satellite orbits , and for clarity four representative individual orbits
are highlighted in black .
on orbit time scales , the lower kilohertz qpo frequency and soft color seem uncorrelated due to the counting statistics errors on the color , whereas on a longer time scale a clear correlation emerges .
we note that for some parallel tracks in figure [ fig.hid_sid_int ] there is a correlation between color and intensity on short timescales , especially in interval j. in those cases the counting statistics are better due to the higher count rates and thus the parallel track phenomenon in the color diagrams is more similar to that in the kilohertz qpo frequency versus intensity diagram @xcite .
however , in our interval j there is no timing feature present that is trackable on short timescales . in conclusion we can now identify the parallel qpo tracks in the color intensity diagrams .
bad counting statistics that shows up in the form of the narrow nearly vertical parallel tracks in the color intensity diagrams cause the @xmath57color correlation to be veiled on short timescales ( less than hours ) so in the color intensity diagrams the parallel qpo tracks can only be found for the longer timescales of several satellite orbits .
we have studied the color diagrams and the power spectral behavior of the atoll source 4u 160852 .
we found that the timing behavior of 4u 160852 is almost identical to that of the other atoll sources 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 .
if we plot the characteristic frequencies of the timing features versus the characteristic frequency of the upper kilohertz qpo , together with the results of @xcite for 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 , the three sources follow the same relations ( see fig .
[ fig.freq_freq ] ) .
also the behavior of the @xmath18 value is the same for the three sources .
the general trends in rms fractional amplitude for 4u 160852 are also similar to those of 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 , but there is an offset between the relations for the three sources ( see fig .
[ fig.rms_all ] ) .
we connected the timing behavior with the position of the source in the color color diagram and found that the timing behavior is not consistent with the idea that 4u 1608 - 52 traces out a three - branched z shape in the color - color diagram along which the timing properties vary gradually as is the case in in z sources .
instead , the power spectral properties change along an `` @xmath20shaped '' track . finally , our measurements for the colors together with the precise measurements of lower kilohertz qpo frequency of @xcite gave us an opportunity to link the parallel tracks in the intensity versus color diagrams with the parallel tracks in the intensity versus lower kilohertz qpo frequency diagrams .
we found that the parallel tracks in the frequency versus intensity diagram can be found back in the color
intensity diagrams as fuzzy structures ; they should not be confused with the narrow vertical parallel tracks visible in the intensity versus color diagrams which are mostly due to the errors in the colors .
the power spectral properties in 4u 160852 change along an `` @xmath20shaped '' track .
the question now arises whether the `` @xmath20shaped '' track we find in the color color diagram of 4u 160852 is universal for atoll sources .
we can compare our results with those of @xcite who studied the x ray color and timing properties of a well sampled state transition of 4u 170544 where the source moves from the lower banana to the extreme island state and back .
this transition was also included in @xcite who studied a larger dataset of 4u 170544 . in the color
color diagram the source moves from the lower banana , to the left of the extreme island state as the count rate decreases .
then both the soft color and the count rate increase , whereas the hard color remains approximately constant , and the source traces out a horizontal track in the color color diagram .
then , while the count rate continues to increase , the source moves back from the right of the extreme island state to the lower banana @xcite . in the whole horizontal track
the power spectra remained the same @xcite . in this extreme island state 4u 170544
did not reach characteristic frequencies as low as those in interval a of 4u 160852 ( it is very similar to interval b ) .
if we look at the overall light and color curves of 4u 170544 presented in @xcite we see that apart from the extreme island state just described , which took place in the forty days around mjd 51230 , there is another extreme island state , with much sparser sampling , in which a higher hard color is reached . if we take a quick look at the timing of this mjd 51380 data we find that when the source reaches this higher hard color , the source shows a power spectrum very similar to that of interval a of 4u 160852 . as for the mjd 51230 extreme island state , during this mjd
51380 extreme island state the count rate and the soft color increase simultaneously and in the color color diagram another horizontal track is drawn up above the mjd 51230 one .
returning now to 4u 160852 we note that in the state transition of 4u 160852 during the 1998 outburst ( see figure [ fig.cc_deel2 ] ) we observe the same phenomenon of a horizontal track being traced out in the extreme island state .
the source is in interval c ( continuous time interval 12 in fig .
[ fig.cc_deel2 ] ) for two observations , the first of which has a count rate about a factor two higher than the second .
this higher count rate is accompanied by a 5 % higher soft color in the first observation .
the power spectrum is the same in both observations .
so , like the case of 4u 170544 , the change in count rate is accompanied by a correlated change in soft color which traces out a small almost ( the hard color changes slightly , see above ) horizontal track in the color color diagram ( continuous time interval 12 in fig .
[ fig.cc_deel2 ] ) .
a possible explanation for this behavior of atoll sources in the extreme island state is the so called `` secular motion '' in the color color diagram .
this phenomenon was first observed in z sources , in which the z shaped track in the color color and color intensity diagrams is traced out within several hours up to a day . on longer timescales the whole z track shifts both in soft color and count rate ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the timing properties remain mostly unaffected by these shifts and are primarily determined by the position along the z track ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. the same phenomenon has been observed in the banana state of the atoll source 4u 163653 @xcite .
the horizontal tracks in the extreme island state of the atoll sources may be entirely caused by a secular motion , similar to that in the z sources . because the sources remain in one particular island state ( similar timing properties and hard color ) for a long time ( weeks to months ) , the slow process of secular motion has time to draw up a horizontal branch . in this horizontal branch
the timing remains similar , as is the case for z source secular motion . as noted by @xcite ,
this aspect of the behavior can be explained by the scenario that @xcite proposed to explain the parallel track phenomenon in the intensity versus lower kilohertz qpo frequency diagram .
it seems that the z shape in the color color diagram of some of the atoll sources is caused by transitions between the banana and the extreme island states that occur at different soft color .
figure [ fig.schema ] provides a schematic of what in our interpretation occurs in these sources .
several different horizontally extended extreme island branches appear above each other in the color color diagram at different hard color values .
these are traced out at different epochs . to first order
only the hard color determines the timing properties . within each extreme island state the soft color changes in correlation with intensity . during state transitions
the extreme island state is entered or left at a soft color value depending on intensity . a possible explanation for the fact that the timing remains similar while the intensity ( and thus soft color ) changes and that the state transitions can occur at different intensities ( soft colors ) is the scenario of @xcite where the truncation radius of the disk , which determines the timing properties and therefore the state , is not set by the accretion rate through the disk but by the ratio of this accretion rate over its long term average ( c.f .
so , if a source shows a state transition to an extreme island state at a minimum intensity which increases after that ( as happened in the mjd 51230 state transition of 4u 170544 * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the source will enter the extreme island state at a lower soft color and move to a higher soft color as the intensity increases .
if a state transition to an extreme island state takes place during a decay after an outburst of a transient source , we would expect that after the extreme island state is entered at a particular soft color , the source then moves to a lower soft color as it fades ( this and the reverse state transition from an extreme island to the banana state during the outburst rise were observed in aql x1 , see * ? ? ?
* ) . in our interpretation , the shape we observe in the color color diagram of 4u 160852 is caused by observations of the source in extreme island states at different intensities and therefore at different soft colors .
extreme island states a and b are observed at higher intensities than extreme island state c , causing c to have a lower soft color .
contrary to the case in 4u 170544 and aql x1 we do not observe a large change in soft color ( or intensity ) within each extreme island state and it is unclear whether this is because the source was not observed sufficiently long or dense enough in these extreme island states , or whether this is a property of 4u 160852 .
the three atoll sources , 4u 160852 , 4u 160852 and 4u 0614 + 09 , we have studied up to now ( * ? ? ? * this paper ) show a similar and very distinct timing behaviour ( figures [ fig.freq_freq ] and [ fig.rms_all ] ) .
4u 160852 differs from 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 172834 in that 4u 160852 is a transient source whose intensity changes by about 2 orders of magnitude where this is only about 1 order of magnitude for 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 172834 .
although 4u 160852 has a much larger range in intensity ( @xmath58 crab in the 2.016.0 kev range ) than 4u 0614 + 09 ( @xmath59 crab ) , 4u 160852 and 4u 0614 + 09 show a similar range in characteristic frequencies for the different power spectral components . for 4u 160852 @xmath24 ranges from 216 to 1061 hz ( excluding intervals i and j for which the identification of @xmath24 is uncertain see appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] ) .
this range in @xmath24 is reached with a minimum intensity range of @xmath60 crab ( see fig .
[ fig.hid_sid_int ] ) . for 4u 0614 + 09 a similar @xmath24 range of 233 to 1067 hz
is reached with a minimum intensity range of @xmath61 crab .
so , both sources reach similar frequency ranges within a similar change in intensity .
4u 172834 has not yet shown a similar range in characteristic frequencies as 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 160852 ( until now @xmath62 hz ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
also no 2.016.0 kev intensities were published for the intervals used in @xcite and @xcite .
there are also some differences in the timing behaviour ; in particular in l@xmath33 when it appears as a qpo . as a function of @xmath24
, @xmath63 is slightly higher in 4u 160852 than in 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 but it covers the same range .
the @xmath18 values for l@xmath33 here are similar for the three sources .
the relation between @xmath63 and @xmath24 in figure [ fig.freq_freq ] has a turnover at 30 hz in 4u 0614 + 09 @xcite ; there might be a turnover at 45 hz in 4u 172834 , but in 4u 160852 no turnover has been observed . the plot of rms fractional amplitude of all components versus @xmath24 ( fig .
[ fig.rms_all ] ) shows an offset between the relations for the three atoll sources 4u 160852 , 4u 0614 + 09 , and 4u 172834 .
this offset is different for the low
frequency features , l@xmath28 , l@xmath41 , l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 , and at low frequencies l@xmath26 , than for the two kilohertz qpos ( see also [ sec.comb_ps ] ) .
it seems that there are two groups , one containing the high and the other the low frequency features .
the difference between the two groups might be due to geometrical effects .
the different offsets in figure [ fig.rms_all ] hint towards the lorentzian at @xmath64 hz , found in the lowest frequency states of 4u 160852 ( interval a ) and 4u 0614 + 09 , being l@xmath23 ( see appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] ) , whereas it could have been identified as either l@xmath23 or l@xmath28 based on its frequency ( see appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] ) .
the identification of the @xmath64 hz lorentzian is important because the power spectra of 4u 160852 and 4u 0614 + 09 at the lowest inferred mass accretion rate closely resemble those of the low luminosity bursters 1e 17243045 , gs 182624 , and slx 1735269 @xcite and the millisecond x ray pulsar sax j1808.4 - 3658 @xcite .
these sources all seem to be atoll sources that are only observed at low mass accretion rate . if the @xmath64 hz lorentzian is the upper kilohertz qpo then the high frequency peaks in those sources are probably also upper kilohertz qpos .
note that although in 4u 160852 l@xmath41 already becomes undetectable at @xmath65 hz whereas this happens at @xmath66 hz in 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 , this is not a significant difference as the upper limits on the fractional rms of l@xmath41 in 4u 160852 are consistent with this component still being present at those frequencies .
the broad l@xmath26 component found in intervals a and b was previously found in 4u 160852 with ginga by @xcite and has also been identified in the atoll source 4u 0614 + 09 @xcite .
this component has also been found in the low
luminosity bursters 1e 17243045 , gs 182624 , and slx 1735269 @xcite .
the lorentzian has been tentatively identified with the lower kilohertz qpo based on extrapolations of frequency frequency relations ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the rms fractional amplitude of the broad l@xmath26 is much higher than that of the lower kilohertz qpo ( see fig .
[ fig.rms_all ] ) , however , a similar increase in rms is visible in that figure for l@xmath23 .
but note that l@xmath23 is detected in all intervals where l@xmath26 is present as the lower kilohertz qpo in intervals h
e then dissapears in intervals d and c and only shows up again as the broad lorentzian in intervals b and a. interval b of 4u 160852 shows a narrow qpo with a characteristic frequency ( 2.458 hz ) between those of l@xmath33 and l@xmath67 .
this qpo is probably the same as the one discovered in the island state of 4u 160852 by @xcite : their power spectrum of the 1989 august 2526 interval is very similar to our interval b , it has l@xmath33 with a characteristic frequency of @xmath68 hz , l@xmath41 at @xmath69 hz and a narrow qpo at @xmath70 hz ( see figure 4 of * ? ? ?
luminosity bursters 1e 17243045 , gs 182624 @xcite as well as the bhcs gx 3394 @xcite and cyg x1 @xcite also show narrow qpos with a characteristic frequency between those of l@xmath33 and that of l@xmath41 . for 1e 17243045
the centroid frequency of the narrow qpo coincides with the centroid frequency of l@xmath41 , but for 4u 160852 this is not the case ; here the centroid frequency of the narrow qpo ( @xmath71 hz ) is close to half the centroid frequency of l@xmath41 ( @xmath72 hz ) .
no similar narrow lorentzians were fitted by @xcite for 4u 172834 or 4u 0614 + 09 , but 4u 172834 does show narrow residuals between the characteristic frequency of l@xmath33 and that of l@xmath41 .
in figure [ fig.narrowqpo ] we plot @xmath42 versus the @xmath14 of these narrow qpos . for cyg x1
many narrow qpos were fitted by @xcite ; we only plot those qpos that have a characteristic frequency between @xmath63 and @xmath42 .
the points of the low luminosity bursters and most of those of gx 3394 line up in figure [ fig.narrowqpo ] .
these qpos were all labeled as l@xmath43 by @xcite .
the two points of gx 3394 that deviate from the line are from two observations where gx 3394 showed two simultaneous qpos ; the highest frequency qpo falls on the relation in figure [ fig.narrowqpo ] while the lowest frequency qpo falls below it . if we fit the points of the low
luminosity bursters and gx 3394 with a power law our result as well as those of @xcite for 4u 160852 fall below this relation .
so we can not identify this narrow qpo in 4u 160852 with l@xmath43 .
in the two observations where gx 3394 showed two narrow simultaneous qpos , the characteristic frequencies of the lowest frequency qpo as well as the results for cyg x1 also fall well below the power law . it might be that these qpos and those of 4u 160852 are related .
these points fall close to a line that indicates half the low
luminosity burster relation which is also plotted in figure [ fig.narrowqpo ] .
note that if we use centroid frequency instead of @xmath14 the relations in figure [ fig.narrowqpo ] worsen .
in addition to comparing the color color diagram tracks and the associated power spectra , we can also compare the timing properties of z sources with those of atoll sources by making similar plots of @xmath14 of the different power spectral components versus @xmath24 as we did for the atoll sources 4u 160852 , 4u 0614 + 09 and , 4u 172834 in figure [ fig.freq_freq ] . in figure [ fig.atoll_z ]
we do this for the z sources gx 5 - 1 @xcite , gx 340 + 0 @xcite , gx 17 + 2 @xcite and cyg x2 @xcite .
we include the lower kilohertz qpo , the low frequency noise ( lfn ) , the horizontal branch oscillations ( hbo ) , and the harmonic and sub harmonic of the hbo , and plot these versus @xmath24 .
the grey symbols are the results of the atoll sources also displayed in figure [ fig.freq_freq ] , the black symbols represent the z sources . note that the broad band noise in these z sources was not fitted with a zero centered lorentzian but with a cutoff power law , @xmath73 , for gx 5 - 1 , gx 340 + 0 , and gx 17 + 2 and with a smooth broken power law , @xmath74^{-1}$ ] , for cyg x2 .
this leads to expressions for @xmath14 , defined as the frequency of maximum power density in @xmath13 , of @xmath75 for the cutoff power law , and @xmath76^{1/\beta } \nu_{b}$ ] for the smooth broken power law . from figure [ fig.atoll_z ]
we confirm the identification of the hbo in the z sources with l@xmath41 in the atoll sources made by @xcite .
however , the suggestions that either the lfn @xcite or the sub
hbo @xcite in the z sources might be similar to the classical broad band noise in the island state of the atoll sources seems not to be supported by the relation of the characteristic frequencies of these components with @xmath24 . at @xmath77
hz the band limited noise component in the l@xmath33l@xmath23 relation is replaced by a qpo ( see [ sec.comb_ps ] ) and the band limited noise component l@xmath35 appears and follows a new relation with @xmath24 .
the lfn points fall below the l@xmath33l@xmath23 relation but seem to line up with l@xmath35 . the sub
hbo points fall above the l@xmath33l@xmath23 relation until @xmath77 hz where the qpo takes over from the band limited noise component ( see above ) . based on this comparison of frequencies ,
the lfn might still be associated with l@xmath35 and the sub hbo might be related with l@xmath33 when it is a qpo , although for 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 172834 no harmonic relation was present between l@xmath41 and l@xmath33 when it is a qpo @xcite .
note also that the lfn in gx 17 + 2 follows a different relation compared to that in the other z sources .
other differences between gx 17 + 2 and the other z sources in figure [ fig.atoll_z ] are that the lfn in gx 17 + 2 is peaked , the harmonic of the hbo is relatively strong and it shows a flaring branch oscillation ( fbo ) whereas the other sources show a flat lfn , a relatively weak harmonic of the hbo and no fbo @xcite .
we note that none of these differences with the other z sources serve to make gx 17 + 2 more similar to the other atoll sources .
the results presented in sections [ sec.comb_ps ] , appendix [ sec.detailed_ps ] , and this section show that the low frequency part of the power spectra of both the atoll and the z sources behaves in a very complex manner . for the atoll sources many different lorentzian components appear , disappear or change from broad lorentzians into narrow qpos .
although this behavior is complex , the power spectral components of the three atoll sources for which we have performed a multi lorentzian timing study show remarkable similarities . by using frequency vs. frequency plots such as the one in figure [ fig.freq_freq ] , and by comparing the power spectra of different sources directly with each other it is possible to identify all these components within a single classification .
we do this here for 4u 160852 ( section [ sec.comb_ps ] ) .
note however , that sometimes additional narrow features become significant in the power spectra ( see [ comp : timing : atoll ] ) .
as another example , a recent rxte observation of 4u 160852 during an outburst in 2001 , shows a power spectrum ( figure [ fig.nupnu_2001 ] ) very similar to that of interval b ( fig . [ fig.powspec_1608 ] ) , except that instead of the broad peak at @xmath78 hz , a narrow ( @xmath79 ) qpo with an rms fractional amplitude of @xmath80 appears at 30 hz .
also several , marginally significant , features are visible between 2 and 5 hz . if we compare the low
frequency features of the atoll sources with those found in the z sources , in a frequency vs. frequency plot we see that only the hbo of the z sources can be unambiguously identified with the l@xmath67 of the atoll sources . the frequency vs. @xmath24 relations of the other low frequency features
partly overlap in figure [ fig.freq_freq ] but are not identical , and the relation of the characteristic frequency of the lfn with @xmath24 is not even the same for all z sources .
it appears that for some components the frequency vs. @xmath24 relations are not universal .
there might be small physical differences between the atoll sources and z sources ( and within the z sources themselves ) that affect these relations .
so , either these features are different phenomena in different types of sources , or something else ( e.g. neutron star mass , magnetic field strength ) affects the relations .
if this is so , this hidden parameter does not change much from source to source , or the relations do not depend strongly on this parameter as the relations are similar , as the relations are very similar within each source type .
three different characteristic frequencies can be used to test the frequency relations predicted by the several qpo models ; @xmath14 , @xmath16 and @xmath81 .
@xmath14 is the frequency at which a lorentzian contributes most of its variance per log frequency @xcite and is the one used in this paper .
@xmath16 is the centroid frequency of the lorentzian and can be obtained from our fit parameters @xmath14 and @xmath18 as @xmath82 . according to @xcite the @xmath16 of the lorentzian is shifted with respect to the eigenfrequency of the oscillation due to damping .
this shift depends on the damping rate which can be estimated from the width of the lorentzian @xcite .
we can calculate this eigenfrequency , @xmath81 , from @xmath14 and @xmath18 as @xmath83 . in this section
we use our fit parameter @xmath14 unless stated otherwise . the transition layer model ( tlm * ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) associates the lower kilohertz qpo with the keplerian frequency of the inner disk edge ( @xmath84 ) . between the neutron star and the keplerian disk
a transition layer is present . in the tlm
the upper kilohertz qpo is produced by radial oscillations of a blob thrown out of the transition layer into a magnetosphere .
this radial eigenmode or hybrid frequency ( @xmath85 ) relates to @xmath84 as @xmath86 , where @xmath87 is the rotational frequency of the star s magnetosphere near the equatorial plane .
this implies that @xmath85 should always exceed @xmath88 . for 4u 160852 @xcite
found that @xmath87 is always larger than 300 hz and thus @xmath89 hz should apply . for 4u 160852
we find that when there is a pair of kilohertz qpos present ( intervals e h ) the upper kilohertz qpo frequency ranges from 830 to 1062 hz .
but the 200682 hz single kilohertz qpo of intervals a d , which we identify as the upper kilohertz qpo based on frequency color @xcite , frequency frequency ( fig .
[ fig.freq_freq ] ) and rms frequency ( see * ? ? ?
* and fig .
[ fig.rms_all ] ) correlations , fall well below the 600 hz predicted by the tlm model .
note that neither the use of @xmath16 , nor @xmath81 , shifts these frequencies above the 600 hz limit .
if these single kilohertz qpos were not the upper , but the lower kilohertz qpos , this would lead to the unlikely scenario that the presence of an upper kilohertz qpo would lead to a completely different power spectrum for a similar lower kilohertz qpo frequency ( compare , e.g. , c with e or d with g in fig .
[ fig.powspec_1608 ] ) . the @xmath42 vs. @xmath27 relation for neutron stars and bhcs ( see @xcite for the relation in the @xmath16 representation , and @xcite for the relation in the @xmath14 representation )
was recently extended towards lower frequencies by including 17 white dwarf sources ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the points of 4u 0614 + 09 , 4u 172834 , and 4u 160852 fall on the @xmath42 vs. @xmath27 relation ; only the point from interval b of 4u 160852 deviates .
the @xmath42 vs. @xmath27 relation can be fitted with a power law with an index close to 1 @xcite .
the tlm explains this by assuming that @xmath27 is the keplerian frequency of the inner disk ( see above ) , and @xmath42 represents the frequency of magnetoacoustic oscillations , @xmath90 , in the disk transition layer .
the relation between @xmath42 and @xmath27 is then a result of a global relation between @xmath90 of the transition layer and @xmath84 at the adjustment radius @xcite . for each individual source
the tlm predicts an index for the @xmath90 vs. @xmath84 relation that is steeper than one and should be studied separately @xcite .
note , however , that the atoll sources cover a large range of the @xmath42 vs. @xmath27 relation , as there are points around @xmath91 hz and around @xmath92 hz . while 4u 160852 only contributes points around @xmath91 hz and 4u 172834 only around @xmath92 hz , 4u 0614 + 09 contributes both .
this suggests that the @xcite relation is not just a global relation between different sources as suggested by @xcite but can also be found within individual sources .
note also that although the tlm explains the @xcite relation as above in @xcite , the hbos of the z sources , which are part of @xcite relation , are explained differently , namely as the vertical eigenmode of a blob rotating with a keplerian frequency thrown into the magnetosphere ( see above ) in other tlm papers ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in the sonic point
beat frequency model ( spbfm ; * ? ? ?
* ) the upper kilohertz qpo represents the keplerian frequency at the inner disk edge .
the lower kilohertz qpo then arises from a beat of the keplerian frequency at the inner disk edge with the neutron star spin frequency .
this led to an early prediction that @xmath93 , the frequency difference between the upper and the lower kilohertz qpo , is equal to the spin frequency and should therefore be constant . observations of several sources , among which 4u 172834 @xcite and 4u 160852 @xcite , showed a significant decrease in @xmath93 when the upper kilohertz qpo frequency increased .
further refinements of the spbfm by @xcite could explain this decrease in @xmath93 .
neither the use of @xmath14 nor @xmath81 instead of @xmath16 makes @xmath93 constant .
note that our measurements of the high frequency kilohertz qpos ( @xmath94 hz ) are not the best to use here as the addition of a lot of data leads to an artificial broadening of the lorentzian ( see [ sec.comb_ps ] ) .
therefore here we used the precise measurements of these high frequency kilohertz qpos made by @xcite for 4u 172834 and by @xcite for 4u 160852 to calculate @xmath14 and @xmath81 .
for both sources @xmath93 increases by less than 1.5 % if @xmath14 is used instead of @xmath16 and by less than 3.1 % if @xmath81 is used instead of @xmath16 . note that , just as for the tlm , the low frequencies we find for the upper kilohertz qpo ( see above ) are a problem for the spbfm . in the spbfm
the lower bound on the upper kilohertz qpo frequency is set by the keplerian frequency at the maximal radius where the radiation coming from the neutron star surface can still remove sufficient angular momentum from the gas in the disk so that it falls supersonically to the neutron star surface @xcite .
this radius is about @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is the radius of the marginally stable orbit .
so , to reach @xmath97 hz the mass of the neutron star has to exceed @xmath98 @xmath99 . the relativistic precession model ( rpm ; * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) assumes that the upper kilohertz qpo represents the keplerian frequency of the inner disk .
the lower kilohertz qpo frequency represents the periastron precession frequency of the accretion disk , which is assumed to contain slightly elliptical orbits .
this leads to the prediction that the frequency difference ( @xmath93 ) between the two kilohertz qpos decreases both at low and high kilohertz qpo frequencies ( see figure 1 of * ? ? ?
* ) . if the broad l@xmath26 at low frequencies ( intervals a and b of 4u 160852 and interval 1 of 4u 0614 + 09 in * ? ? ?
* ) is the lower kilohertz qpo ( but see [ comp : timing : atoll ] ) , then this predicted decrease in @xmath93 at low kilohertz qpo frequencies is observed in 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 160852 .
note that the point of interval b of 4u 160852 falls above the curves of figure 1 in @xcite by @xmath100 .
more complicated modelling within the framework of the rpm as is done for sco x1 in @xcite is beyond the scopes of this paper .
the rpm also predicts a low frequency qpo at the lense thirring precession frequency of @xmath101 hz @xcite , where @xmath102 is the moment of inertia in units of @xmath103 g @xmath104 , @xmath105 is the mass of the neutron star in @xmath99 , and @xmath106 is the neutron star spin frequency .
we searched our data for a power law with an index of 2 as predicted by the rpm by fitting the frequency vs. @xmath24 relations for the low frequency features ( fig .
[ fig.freq_freq ] ) for the three sources 4u 172834 , 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 160852 with power laws .
we used @xmath14 , @xmath16 , and @xmath81 for the characteristic frequencies ( see above ) .
we find that the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 relation has an index that is the closest to the 2 predicted by the rpm .
if we use @xmath14 or @xmath81 for the frequency the relations clearly deviate from a power law .
the points fall below the fitted power law at low and high frequencies and above at intermediate frequencies , leading to very large @xmath22/dof of 4605/21 ( @xmath14 ) and 7179/21 ( @xmath81 ) .
if we use @xmath16 for the frequency we find that the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 relation can be described by a power law of the form @xmath107 ( see figure [ fig.powerlawfit ] ) .
the @xmath22/dof of this fit is still high ( 373/20 ) but this is not due to systematic deviations from a power law .
the averaged relative scatter around the fitted power law is only 6 % on the @xmath42 axis and only 3 % on the @xmath24 axis .
the high @xmath22/dof is probably a result of not including any systematic errors when determining the errors of the power spectral fit parameters ( see * ? ? ?
note , that if we use @xmath16 for the frequency we exclude those points that have @xmath108 ( from fits with a zero centered lorentzian ) .
the result that the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 relation can be described by a power law with an index close to 2 was found previously for a more limited frequency range ( @xmath62 hz ) in 4u 172834 ( index 2.11 ; * ? ? ?
* ) and 4u 0614 + 09 ( index 2.46 ; * ? ? ?
it is remarkable that now that we have extended the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 relation towards @xmath109 hz , the relation can still be described by a power law and that the power law index is found to be even closer to 2 .
we can get an indication of the spin frequency by looking at the burst oscillation frequency which is 363 hz for 4u 172834 @xcite and 620 hz for 4u 160852 @xcite .
if these two frequencies are the spin frequency of the neutron star in each case ( the most likely scenario , see * ? ? ?
* ) , then it is difficult to understand why the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 relations of these sources coincide .
if we assume that we see the spin frequency in 4u 172834 and twice the spin frequency in 4u 160852 , we find an average spin frequency of about 335 hz for these sources . for the @xmath16 representation fit , this leads to @xmath110 which is too large for proposed equations of state ( the acceptable range is @xmath111 ; * ? ? ?
if we assume that we see the spin frequency in 4u 160852 and half the spin frequency in 4u 172834 , the average spin frequency is about 670 hz for these sources .
this leads to @xmath112 which is acceptable .
recently , @xcite studied the x ray energy spectra of 4u 160852 as a function of position in the color color diagram .
they find that , similar to other atoll sources , the spectra of the island state ( our intervals a , b and c ) of 4u 160852 are dominated by a hard power law spectrum .
there is also a soft component present which in their view is probably due to the neutron star surface rather than the accretion disk .
the banana state ( our intervals e j ) spectrum is soft and it is uncertain whether the soft component is due to the neutron star surface or the disk . to explain the spectral behavior of 4u 160852 @xcite use a scenario where in the island state the disk is far from the surface of the neutron star .
the large radius of the inner disk prevents the disk from being observed directly in the pca spectra . in the island / banana state transition the inner accretion flow , which was geometrically thick and optically thin in the island state , collapses into a geometrically thin and optically thick disk .
the inner edge of the disk is now close to the neutron star , and it is observed as the soft component and increases the soft color . from the diskbb model ,
@xcite estimate an inner disk radius in the banana state of @xmath113 km .
the inner accretion flow becomes more optically thick lowering the hard color .
we can compare this scenario with the results of our timing study .
if we assume that @xmath24 represents the keplerian frequency at the inner disk edge ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) we find , assuming a neutron star mass of 1.4 m@xmath114 ( for a different neutron mass the results change by a factor ( m@xmath115 , which is 1.2 for a 2.4 m@xmath114 neutron star ) , that the inner disk terminates at @xmath116 km for the island state ( intervals a , b and c ) . for the banana state ( intervals e j ) we find an inner disk radius of @xmath117 km and decreasing towards higher soft color .
indeed we find that the inner disk radius is closer to the neutron star in the banana than in the island state , but the values in both the banana and the island state are close to the @xmath113 km estimated by @xcite for the banana state .
so , the difference in radius between island and banana state seems too small to make the disk disappear from the pca spectrum in the island state as proposed in the scenario of @xcite described above .
if we assume that instead of @xmath24 , @xmath118 represents the keplerian frequency at the inner disk edge ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , this would lead to much larger differences in inner disk radius between the island ( @xmath119 km ) and the banana state ( @xmath120 km ) , so this interpretation could be consistent with the @xcite scenario .
the identification of @xmath27 as the keplerian frequency at the inner disk edge is also suggested by the recently proposed extension of the pbk relation @xcite towards lower frequencies by including 17 white dwarf sources ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) .
for the white dwarf sources a qpo is plotted versus the dwarf nova oscillation , dno , the dnos are thought to occur at the keplerian frequency of the inner disk edge ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the behavior in the soft color vs. intensity diagram of 4u 160852 and 4u 170544 in their extreme island states can also be explained within the scenario of @xcite .
let us assume that @xmath118 represents the keplerian frequency of the inner disk edge . in the extreme island states the disk is far out at 200 km and can not be seen in the pca energy spectrum ( see above ) , the soft color should therefore only depend on the spectral properties of the neutron star .
if we look at the extreme island states a and b of 4u 160852 and 4u 170544 in the soft color versus intensity diagram , there seems to be a one to one relation between soft color and intensity ( see fig .
[ fig.hid_sid_int ] for 4u 160852 ) .
we can fit this relation with a power law with an index of about 0.1 .
we propose that in the extreme island state as the accretion rate ( intensity ) increases , the neutron star surface gets more heated and the soft color increases . outside the extreme island states the soft color
is determined by the spectral properties of both the neutron star surface and the disk and its dependence on accretion rate is therefore more complicated .
the main conclusions of this paper can be summarized as follows : * the timing behavior of 4u 160852 is almost identical to that of the atoll sources 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 , and can be described in terms of a well defined set of components ( l@xmath23 , l@xmath26 , l@xmath28 , l@xmath41 , l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 ) which all vary in characteristic frequency together ( except for l@xmath28 for which @xmath14 is constant ) , sharing the same frequency correlations . *
the timing behavior is not consistent with the idea that 4u 1608 - 52 traces out a three - branched z shape in the color - color diagram along which the timing properties vary gradually as in z sources .
instead , the power spectral properties change smoothly along an `` @xmath20shaped '' track , which is probably composed of three , partially observed , extended extreme island branches .
* 4u 160852 , at its lowest frequencies , shows a power spectrum almost identical to that of the low luminosity bursters 1e 17243045 , gs 182624 , and slx 1735269 , and the millisecond x ray pulsar sax j1808.4 - 3658 .
the low luminosity bursters and the millisecond x ray pulsar all seem to be atoll sources at low mass accretion rate .
a similar conclusion was reached previously based on 4u 0614 + 09 @xcite . *
the high frequency peak at about 200 hz in interval a of 4u 160852 is more likely to be the upper kilohertz qpo than the hectohertz lorentzian .
this means that the corresponding @xmath121 hz peaks in 4u 0614 + 09 , 1e 17243045 , gs 182624 , slx 1735269 and sax j1808.4 - 3658 also most likely represent the upper kilohertz qpo .
* the low
frequency part of the power spectra of both the atoll and the z sources behaves in a very complex manner .
nevertheless , for the atoll sources it is possible to identify all these components within a single classification .
if we compare the low frequency features of the atoll sources with those found in the z sources we find that the hbo of the z sources can be identified with l@xmath41 of the atoll sources . based upon the frequency relations with the upper kilohertz qpo neither the lfn nor the sub harmonic of the hbo of the z sources can straightforwardly be identified with the band limited noise of the atoll sources . *
the parallel tracks in the frequency versus intensity diagram can be identified in the intensity versus color diagrams .
however , the statistical spread in the colors , which shows up as the narrow nearly vertical parallel tracks in the color intensity diagrams , cause the @xmath57color correlation to be veiled on short timescales ( less than hours ) so in the color intensity diagrams parallel tracks similar to the parallel qpo tracks can only be identified on longer timescales .
* we have tested the transition layer model , the sonic point beat frequency model , and the relativistic precession model using our results for the three atoll sources 4u 0614 + 09 , 4u 172834 , and 4u 160852 . neither the transition layer model nor the sonic point beat frequency model can explain the upper kilohertz qpo frequency range we find in these sources .
the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 can be described by a power law with an index of 2 as predicted by the relativistic precession model , however it is very likely that the burst oscillation frequencies found for 4u 172834 ( 363 hz ) , and 4u 160852 ( 620 hz ) represent the spin frequency of the neutron star in each case .
then it is difficult to understand why the @xmath42 vs. @xmath24 relations of these sources coincide . *
our timing and color results are consistent with the scenario proposed by @xcite to explain the results of their x ray energy spectral study of 4u 160852 , only if @xmath118 , and not @xmath24 represents the keplerian frequency of the inner disk edge . in this scenario
the disk is close to the neutron star in the banana state , and far from the neutron star in the island state .
the large radius of the inner disk in the island state prevents the disk from being observed directly in the pca spectra .
this work was supported by nwo spinoza grant 080 to e.p.j .
van den heuvel , by the netherlands organization for scientific research ( nwo ) , and by the netherlands research school for astronomy ( nova ) .
this research has made use of data obtained through the high energy astrophysics science archive research center online service , provided by the nasa / goddard space flight center .
we would like to thank peter jonker for providing us with tables for the gx 51 and gx 340 + 0 data .
we now provide a detailed description of the components found in the combined power spectra of 4u 160852 and compare them to previous results on 4u 172834 , 4u 0614 + 09 of @xcite and the low luminosity bursters discussed by @xcite
. the combined power spectrum of * interval a * ( fig .
[ fig.powspec_1608 ] ) is very similar to interval 1 of 4u 0614 + 09 ( see figure 2 in * ? ? ?
it shows l@xmath33 and l@xmath41 at the lowest characteristic frequencies observed in atoll sources .
figure [ fig.freq_freq ] confirms the identification of these components .
as was the case in 4u 0614 + 09 , interval a shows l@xmath26 at @xmath31 hz and a broad lorentzian at @xmath64 hz . the lorentzian at @xmath64 hz found in 4u 160852 ( interval a ) and 4u 0614 + 09 can be identified as either l@xmath23 or l@xmath28 based on its frequency .
however , this lorentzian has a similar rms fractional amplitude for both 4u 160852 and 4u 0614 + 09 .
the upper kilohertz qpos of 4u 160852 and 4u 0614 + 09 always have a similar fractional rms , whereas for l@xmath28 the fractional rms is always about 5 percentage points less in 4u 160852 than in 4u 0614 + 09 ( see fig .
[ fig.rms_all ] ) .
this hints towards this component being l@xmath23 .
* interval b * is similar to interval a , it shows l@xmath33 , l@xmath41 , l@xmath26 and l@xmath23 , but all at higher characteristic frequencies .
interval b also shows a narrow qpo at 2.458 hz which will be discussed in [ comp : timing : atoll ]
. intervals a and b both show a component designated l@xmath26 , at @xmath31 and @xmath122 hz respectively .
the broad l@xmath26 at these low frequencies can be tentatively identified with the lower kilohertz qpo based on extrapolations of frequency frequency relations ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. however , this lorentzian might also be an unrelated feature ( see [ comp : timing : atoll ] ) .
* interval c * shows only three components , l@xmath33 , l@xmath41 and l@xmath23 again all at higher frequencies than in the previous interval .
* interval d * shows l@xmath33 , l@xmath28 and l@xmath23 .
compared to interval c , l@xmath41 is no longer present and l@xmath28 has appeared .
based on the similarities with 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 , l@xmath41 would be expected to be more narrow than in intervals a c ( expected @xmath18 about 12 ) and have a characteristic frequency of about 30 hz .
figure [ fig.powspec_1608 ] shows a non significant narrow peak at @xmath123 hz in interval d which can probably be attributed to l@xmath41 .
as noted above , l@xmath28 , a broad lorentzian with a constant @xmath14 of @xmath124 hz , appears in interval d for the first time . in interval
a l@xmath28 would lie on top of l@xmath23 ( see above ) and in intervals b and c l@xmath28 would lie in the flank of l@xmath23 .
therefore it is hard to detect l@xmath28 in intervals a c .
note that there is some excess power at the expected location of 150 hz in interval c. in interval d l@xmath23 has moved above this frequency range so that l@xmath28 is more easily detectable . both the frequency and the fractional rms of l@xmath33 in interval d
are above the relations in figures [ fig.freq_freq ] and [ fig.rms_all ] . including the little peak at @xmath123 hz in the fit hardly affects l@xmath33 .
these deviations from the relations in figures [ fig.freq_freq ] and [ fig.rms_all ] are most likely due to frequency shifts inside interval d , which covers a large range in the color color diagram ( see fig .
[ fig.cc_int ] ) . splitting this interval
further up would compromise the statistics .
* interval e * shows l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 and a pair of kilohertz qpos . here
the character of l@xmath33 has changed from a band limited noise component ( fitted with a zero centered lorentzian ) to a qpo .
l@xmath28 is visible in the power spectrum but is not significant ( 2.4 @xmath12 single trial ) in this interval .
because leaving it out of the fit makes l@xmath35 fit power up to hundreds of hz leading to an overestimated @xmath36 and rms fractional amplitude , we include a l@xmath28 at 150 hz ( the average value in 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 ) with @xmath125 ( see above ) in the fit . in table [ tbl.highfitpar ] and in figure [ fig.rms_all ] we only show the upper limit for this l@xmath28 .
the characteristic frequency of l@xmath35 in interval e is still high compared to the general relation between @xmath36 and @xmath24 ( see fig .
[ fig.freq_freq ] ) .
this is similar to what was observed in 4u 172834 where in this range there are also two points where @xmath36 is significantly above the relation .
these deviations all occur close to the l@xmath33 `` transformation '' and when the l@xmath33 qpo is still weak compared to the band limited noise component l@xmath35 ( see fig . [ fig.rms_all ] ) , so one possible explanation is that in these transition power spectra a narrow and a broad l@xmath33 are merged together .
the power spectra of * intervals f , g and h * all show very low frequency noise ( vlfn ) , and l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 , l@xmath28 and the pair of kilohertz qpos all increasing in frequency . * intervals i and j * both show vlfn , l@xmath28 and a broad kilohertz qpo .
it is unclear whether the kilohertz peak represents the upper , the lower or even a blend of both kilohertz peaks .
there were no other power spectral features present which could be used to identify this component with the help of the correlations of figure [ fig.freq_freq ] . if these peaks , with characteristic frequencies of about 1050 and 1250 hz , would be the lower kilohertz qpo they would be among the highest frequency lower kilohertz qpos found in any source up to date ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
so to be slightly conservative and also because it is more convenient , as in figures [ fig.freq_freq ] and [ fig.rms_all ] we use the characteristic frequency of l@xmath23 to plot against , we list these kilohertz qpos as l@xmath23 . the @xmath18 values for the kilohertz qpos in intervals
i and j are much lower than those in 4u 172834 and 4u 0614 + 09 .
this is probably an artificial broadening due to the movement of the kilohertz qpo during the intervals . a finer subdivision of intervals i and j does not lead to observing l@xmath23 and l@xmath26 separately .
note that no kilohertz qpos were found in the individual observations of these intervals @xcite .
interval j shows an additional broad bump which is also seen in 4u 172834 ( interval 18 and 19 of figure 1 in * ? ? ? * ) and 4u 0614 + 09 ( interval 9 of figure 2 in * ? ? ?
* ) ; this lorentzian can be identified as either l@xmath33 , l@xmath35 or a new type of lorentzian . here
we list it as l@xmath35 .
the vlfn in 4u 160852 shows a similar behavior to that in other atoll sources .
the power law index is about constant around 1.5 , with the exception of interval f where it is 2.5 .
the rms fractional amplitude generally increases with position in the color color diagram . in intervals
i and j the vlfn clearly deviates from just a power law .
this leads to high @xmath22/dof values of 2.5 and 1.8 . adding lorentzians in interval i and j to fit the deviations leads to significantly better @xmath22/dof of 1.3 and 1.2 .
the @xmath14 of the lorentzian in interval i is then 0.02 hz and in interval j 0.3 hz in interval i the lorentzian does not only fit the deviation but almost the entire vlfn .
the inclusion of the lorentzians lowers the rms fractional amplitude of the power law to 1.59 % for interval i and 2.27 % for interval j. + 1 & 3 & 3 & 0.160.25 & h + 2 & 1 & 3 & 0.05 & d + 3 & 1 & 3 & 0.040.05 & i + 4 & 1 & 3 & 0.020.03 & d + 5 & 1 & 4 & 0.02 & c + 6 & 1 & 16 & 0.030.04 & d + 7 & 116 & 84 & 0.030.04 & b + 8 & 64 & 402 & 0.010.02 & c + + 9 & 43 & 5 & 0.241.20 & j + 10 & 6 & 1 & 0.080.21 & fgh + 11 & 1 & 1 & 0.05 & e + 12 & 2 & 1 & 0.020.04 & c + 13 & 1 & 1 & 0.03 & e + 14 & 5 & 2 & 0.050.10 & i + 15 & 1 & 7 & 0.030.04 & fg + 16 & 7 & 38 & 0.040.05 & b + 17 & 119 & 523 & 0.030.05 & a + + 18 & 1 & 4 & 0.060.07 & i + 19 & 1 & 2 & 0.03 & d + 20 & 1 & 7 & 0.01 & c + 21 & 1 & 3 & 0.03 & j + 22 & 1 & 9 & 0.01 & c + 23 & 1 & 12 & 0.02 & i + 24 & 1 & 4 & 0.01 & c + 25 & 1 & 4 & 0.020.03 & g + 26 & 1 & 4 & 0.02 & c + 27 & 1 & 4 & 0.070.08 & f + 28 & 6 & 2 & 0.030.11 & i + 29 & 1 & 2 & 0.01 & d + 30 & 1 & & 0.01 & c + lcccccccccccccc a & & & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + b & & & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + c & & & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + d & & & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & & & & & @xmath127 + e & & & [email protected] & 3.8@xmath128 & 4.46@xmath129 & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & & @xmath130 + f & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & & @xmath131 + g & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 10.6@xmath132 & 0 ( fixed ) & 2.44@xmath133 & & & + h & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 15.4@xmath134 & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & & &
+ i & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & & & & & & + j & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & + lccccccccc a & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 216@xmath12634 & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] + b & & & @xmath135 & [email protected] & 0 ( fixed ) & [email protected] & 309@xmath12613 & [email protected] & [email protected] + c & & & @xmath136 & & & & 474@xmath12621 & [email protected] & [email protected] + d & 189@xmath12623 & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + e & & & @xmath137 & 531@xmath138 & 6.1@xmath139 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + f & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 19@xmath140 & 8.3@xmath141 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + g & 157@xmath12618 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 16.8@xmath142 & 9.91@xmath143 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + h & [email protected] & 3.0@xmath144 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + i & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 1046@xmath12645 & [email protected] & [email protected] + j & 123@xmath12625 & [email protected] & [email protected] & & & & 1252@xmath12695 & [email protected] & [email protected] + | we have studied the atoll source 4u 160852 using a large data set obtained with the rossi x - ray timing explorer .
we find that the timing properties of 4u 160852 are almost exactly identical to those of the atoll sources 4u 0614 + 09 and 4u 172834 despite the fact that contrary to these sources 4u 160852 is a transient covering two orders of magnitude in luminosity .
the frequencies of the variability components of these three sources follow a universal scheme when plotted versus the frequency of the upper kilohertz qpo , suggesting a very similar accretion flow configuration .
if we plot the z sources on this scheme only the lower kilohertz qpo and hbo follow identical relations . using the mutual relations between the frequencies of the variability components we tested several models ; the transition layer model ,
the sonic point beat frequency model , and the relativistic precession model .
none of these models described the data satisfactory .
recently , it has been suggested that the atoll sources ( among them 4u 160852 ) trace out similar three
branch patterns as the z sources in the color color diagram .
we have studied the relation between the power spectral properties and the position of 4u 160852 in the color color diagram and conclude that the timing behavior is not consistent with the idea that 4u 1608 - 52 traces out a three - branched z shape in the color - color diagram along which the timing properties vary gradually , as z sources do . |
superfluidity represents the assembly of complex phenomena such as persistent currents , quantization of circulation , nonclassical rotational inertia , and topological excitations @xcite .
gaseous bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) offer a testing ground for these phenomena because of their great flexibility to realize various experimental conditions .
for instance , the feshbach technique makes it possible to control the sign and strength of interactions .
furthermore , optical and magnetic traps offer ideal containers of becs , in which microscopic surface rugosities that give rise to dissipation are either absent or can be manipulated as tunable parameters @xcite .
these experiments have now become possible in low - dimensional systems @xcite by tightening the confinement in one- or two- direction(s ) .
low - dimensional systems are simple theoretical models for studying vortices , persistent currents , and solitons @xcite . for the case of attractive interactions ,
becs do not collapse and form solitons in one dimension @xcite .
interestingly , a bright soliton forms also in two dimensions if the strength of interaction is made to oscillate rapidly @xcite . in this paper
we study a system of attractive bosons confined in a one - dimensional torus @xcite under rotation .
when the excitation in the radial direction is negligible , such a system is described by the lieb - liniger model @xcite with attractive interaction , in which a rotating term is added to the hamiltonian and the periodic boundary condition in a finite system is explicitly taken into account .
when the rotational frequency of the container is increased , a hartree - fock theory @xcite shows that the angular momentum of the system is found to exhibit plateaus of the quantized circulation @xcite .
we investigate the stability of quantized circulation by employing the gross - pitaevskii mean - field theory ( mft ) , the bogoliubov theory , and the exact diagonalization of the many - body hamiltonian . in refs .
@xcite , it is found that quantum fluctuations become significant near the boundary between the uniform and soliton phases in a non - rotating torus , and that the boundary is singular in the bogoliubov approximation .
we will show , however , that in the rotating torus quantum fluctuations are significant only in the immediate vicinity of a critical point at which a normalized rotational frequency of the container @xmath0 is integral and the dimensionless strength of interaction @xmath1 is equal to -1/2 ; for other values of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , there are no singularities in physical quantities at the phase boundary because the soliton can be formed without passing through the singular critical point .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ derivation ] , the ground - state wave functions of the system under rotation are derived analytically within the gross - pitaevskii mft . in sec .
[ quantum fluctuation ] , effects of quantum fluctuations on the quantized circulation are examined based on the bogoliubov theory and on the exact diagonalization of the many - body hamiltonian .
the results obtained by these two methods will be shown to agree very well , demonstrating the validity of the bogoliubov theory . in sec .
[ circulation ] , the circulation is calculated as a function of @xmath0 at zero and finite temperatures based on the mft and on the exact diagonalization method . in sec .
[ stirring ] , the response of the system , which is initially at rest , to a time - dependent axisymmetry - breaking potential is examined in order to clarify the process in which the quantized circulation becomes thermodynamically stabilized .
we consider a system of @xmath2 identical bosons with mass @xmath3 which are contained in a rotating torus of radius @xmath4 and cross section @xmath5 , where the angular frequency of rotation is @xmath6 in units of @xmath7 .
the hamiltonian for the system in the rotating frame of reference is then given by @xmath8,\nonumber\\ \label{hamiltoniank}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the angular - momentum operator , @xmath10 is the azimuthal angle , and @xmath11 characterizes the strength of interaction , where @xmath12 is the @xmath13-wave scattering length . here and henceforth , the length , the energy , and the angular momentum are measured in units of @xmath4 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 , respectively . in eq .
( [ hamiltoniank ] ) we include for convenience the kinetic energy @xmath16 of the rigid body which is a constant and only shifts the zero of energy .
it is shown @xcite , by using the single - valuedness boundary condition of the many - body wave function that physical quantities of the system described by the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltoniank ] ) change periodically with respect to @xmath0 with the period of one . the phase is therefore characterized by a phase winding number @xmath17,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the symbol @xmath18 $ ] expresses the maximum integer that does not exceed @xmath19 , and by a continuous variable @xmath20 which is the angular frequency relative to @xmath21 , and the range of @xmath22 is limited to @xmath23 . in fig .
[ pd](a ) , we show @xmath21 and @xmath22 as functions of @xmath0 . we first seek the lowest - energy state of the one - dimensional gross - pitaevskii equation ( gpe ) in the rotating frame of reference , @xmath24\psi(\theta)=\mu\psi(\theta ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath25 is the chemical potential , and a dimensionless parameter @xmath26 gives the ratio of the mean - field interaction energy to the zero - point kinetic energy .
the condensate wave function @xmath27 is assumed to obey the periodic boundary condition @xmath28 , and is normalized as @xmath29 .
it is appropriate to assume the form of the solution as @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the number density and @xmath32 the phase . and
angular frequency ( relative to @xmath21 ) @xmath33 as functions of @xmath0 .
( b ) ground - state phase diagram .
the bold curve corresponds to the phase boundary determined by eq .
( [ stability condition ] ) : @xmath34 .
the upper and lower regions of the bold curve correspond to the uniform - density phase and the bright - soliton phase , respectively . the winding number @xmath21 takes on a constant integer in between the vertical solid lines in fig .
[ pd](b ) and changes by 1 when crossing them . on the solid lines ,
the ground - state wave function is described by the jacobian cn - function which has one node . on the vertical dotted lines ,
the ground state wave function is described by the jacobian dn - function . in between the horizontal dotted line and the bold curve ,
the uniform - density state is thermodynamically unstable , and below the horizontal dotted line , the uniform - density state is dynamically unstable . ]
the stationary state which circulates on the ring with a uniform density is a plane wave , @xmath35 the stability of the ground state is determined by the sign of the lowest excitation energy . diagonalizing the bogoliubov - de gennes ( bdg ) equations @xmath36u_n+2\pi\gamma\psi^2 v_n&= & \!\!\lambda_n u_n , \nonumber\\ \left[\left(i\frac{\partial}{\partial\theta}-\omega\right)^2-\mu + 4\pi\gamma|\psi|^2\right]v_n+2\pi\gamma\psi^{\ast 2 } u_n&=&\!\!-\lambda_n v_n , \nonumber\\ \label{bdg}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we obtain the excitation energies @xmath37 and the corresponding amplitudes @xmath38 with positive norms as @xmath39 where the normalization constants @xmath40 are determined from the orthonormality condition @xmath41d\theta=\delta_{n , m } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath42}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for repulsive interactions @xmath43 , the ground state of eq .
( [ gpeq ] ) always takes the form of the uniform - density solution ( [ plane wave ] ) , since the lowest excitation energy @xmath44 ( for @xmath45 ) or @xmath46 ( for @xmath47 ) from it is positive for all @xmath1 and @xmath0 .
however , for the attractive case , the first excitation energy @xmath46 or @xmath44 becomes zero at @xmath48 in fig .
[ pd](b ) , we show the phase diagram of the ground states with respect to @xmath1 and @xmath0 .
the phase boundary ( [ stability condition ] ) of the ground states is represented by the bold curve .
the uniform - density solution becomes thermodynamically unstable for @xmath49 ( in between the horizontal dotted line and the bold curve ) because the first excitation energy becomes negative , while it becomes dynamically unstable for @xmath50 ( in the lower region of the horizontal dotted line ) because the first excitation energy acquires an imaginary part .
the uniform - density state is thus stable only when @xmath51 ( i.e. , in the upper region of the bold curve ) . for @xmath52 ( in the lower region of the bold curve in fig .
[ pd](b ) ) , the uniform - density state is either thermodynamically or dynamically unstable , and a soliton state becomes stable . in this subsection ,
we derive the ground - state soliton solution of eq .
( [ gpeq ] ) .
the definitions of several kinds of elliptic integrals and elliptic functions @xcite used throughout this paper are summarized in appendix [ elliptic ] to make the present paper self - contained . substituting eq .
( [ general solution form ] ) into the gpe ( [ gpeq ] ) and taking the real and the imaginary parts , we obtain @xmath53 equation ( [ 2nd_eq ] ) is integrated to give @xmath54 substituting this into eq .
( [ 1st_eq ] ) yields @xmath55 this equation can be rewritten in the form of an elliptic integral @xmath56 which has formally the same solution as the case without rotating term @xcite and is given by @xmath57,\label{g_density}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where dn@xmath58 is the jacobian elliptic function , @xmath59 , and @xmath60 .
a constant @xmath61 is given below in eq .
( [ eta ] ) and the parameter @xmath62 will be determined later in eq .
( [ mgeneral ] ) .
we denote the complete elliptic integrals of the first and the second kinds as @xmath63 and @xmath64 , respectively .
since the soliton breaks the translational symmetry , the solution ( [ g_density ] ) contains an arbitrary parameter @xmath65 which is regarded as the center of mass of the total particles . from the normalization condition , the normalization constant @xmath66
is determined as @xmath67 $ ] .
substituting @xmath31 in eq .
( [ g_density ] ) in eq .
( [ eq of mu ] ) , we obtain @xmath68 where @xmath69 are defined as @xmath70 and sgn denotes the sign function such that @xmath71 when @xmath72 ( i.e. , @xmath73 ) , and @xmath74 when @xmath75 , ( i.e. , @xmath76 , see fig .
[ pd](a ) ) .
the cases of @xmath77 will be treated separately below . from eqs .
( [ phased ] ) and ( [ g_density ] ) , the phase part is given by @xmath78\right\}^{-1}\right],\quad\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is integrated analytically using the relations ( [ jrelations ] ) and ( [ pi1 ] ) to give @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the elliptic integral of the third kind , and the constants @xmath81 and @xmath82 are given by @xmath83 since the wave function is single - valued , the phase @xmath32 satisfies @xmath84 this condition can be used to determine the value of @xmath62 as follows . in the present case , the parameters @xmath62 and @xmath81 satisfy the relation @xmath85 , and then using the relations ( [ reductionpi])-([lambda function ] ) , the elliptic integral @xmath80 at @xmath86 reduces to @xmath87,\\ \varepsilon&=&\arcsin \sqrt{\frac{f_{\rm c}}{m_1 f}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 is heuman s lambda function defined in terms of the incomplete elliptic integrals of the first @xmath89 and the second kinds @xmath90 as @xmath91.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the phase at @xmath86 thus becomes @xmath92.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the notation @xmath93 instead of @xmath0 and @xmath21 , condition ( [ svbc ] ) then leads to @xmath94 which determines the parameter @xmath62 .
this equation has a solution only when @xmath52 and @xmath95 , i.e. , in the region delimited by adjacent vertical dotted and solid lines and by the bold curve in fig .
[ pd](a ) .
next let us consider two special cases : @xmath96 ( @xmath0 is equal to integer @xmath21 , i.e. , on the vertical dotted lines in fig .
[ pd](b ) ) and @xmath97 ( @xmath0 is equal to half - integer @xmath98 , i.e. , on the vertical solid lines ) . the ground - state wave function given by eqs .
( [ g_density ] ) and ( [ g_phase ] ) is simplified when @xmath99 and @xmath100 according to the limiting values of several parameters summarized in appendix [ limit ] . when @xmath101 , the amplitude @xmath102 reduces to the jacobian elliptic function @xmath103 , and the phase @xmath104 reduces to @xmath105 , @xmath106 substituting this solution into the gpe ( [ gpeq ] ) yields the chemical potential @xmath107 and an equation @xmath108 which determines the parameter @xmath62 only when @xmath50 .
the dn - solution includes the ground state in the rest container with @xmath109 .
when @xmath110 , the amplitude is given by the jacobian elliptic function cn@xmath58 , and @xmath104 reduces to @xmath111 , @xmath112 the chemical potential and an equation that determines the parameter @xmath62 are obtained as @xmath113 the equation ( [ mcn ] ) has a solution only when @xmath114 .
the wave function ( [ cng ] ) has a node at @xmath115 and the phase jumps by an amount of @xmath116 at the node .
with increasing @xmath0 adiabatically , the vortex enters the ring through this node .
( solid curves ) and phases @xmath117 ( dotted curves ) for several values of angular frequency @xmath22 and phase winding number @xmath118 with @xmath119 .
the density depends only on @xmath120 .
the phase difference @xmath121 is given by @xmath122 in figs .
( a ) and ( b ) , and by @xmath123 in fig .
( c ) because at @xmath124 the wave function has a node at which the phase jumps by an amount of @xmath116 . ] per atom , and ( b ) chemical potential @xmath25 .
both of them decrease monotonically with increasing @xmath125 and are periodic with respect to @xmath0 . ] to illustrate the @xmath0 dependence of the soliton solution , we present in fig .
[ wffig ] the densities and the phases for @xmath119 , where the integral constant of the phase is chosen so that @xmath126 .
the density profiles of the solitons depend only on the relative angular frequency @xmath120 . as the strength of interaction is increased , the parameter @xmath62 approaches unity ( see fig .
[ m ] in appendix [ limit ] ) for all @xmath22 . in the limit of @xmath127 , both dn@xmath58 and cn@xmath58
become sech@xmath128 which is a soliton solution in infinite space @xcite .
the ground - state energy @xmath129 per atom of the uniform - density state is @xmath130 and that of the soliton is @xmath131}{\pi^2}\nonumber\\ & \ & + \frac{2k^2\left[3e^2 - 2(1+m_1)ke+m_1k^2\right]}{3\pi^4\gamma}.\label{ge}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ ge ] ) reduces to the energy of the dn - solution in the limit @xmath132 as @xmath133}{3\pi^2 e},\label{dne}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and to that of cn - solution in the limit @xmath134 as @xmath135}{3\pi^2(e - m_1k)}.\label{cne}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the ground - state energy per atom @xmath129 and the chemical potential @xmath25 are shown in figs . [ enecp](a ) and ( b ) . for a given @xmath1 , the ground - state energy @xmath129 reaches minima for integer @xmath0 and maxima for half - integer @xmath0 , and is smooth everywhere . in the regime @xmath50 ,
the chemical potential @xmath25 becomes maximal for integer @xmath0 and minimal for half - integer @xmath0 , and has kinks at the phase boundaries given by @xmath34 .
the type of the phase transition is the same as that of the non - rotating case @xcite ; at the phase boundary , ( i ) @xmath129 is smooth , the first derivative of @xmath129 with respect to @xmath1 or @xmath0 has a kink , and the second derivative of @xmath129 has a jump , and ( ii ) @xmath25 has a kink , and the first derivative of @xmath25 has a jump .
detailed behaviors of these quantities near the phase boundary are discussed in appendix [ phase_boundary ] .
without rotation , the quantum depletion diverges at @xmath136 and the first excitation energy obtained by the bogoliubov theory becomes gapless at that point , which requires a modification of the mft @xcite .
we investigate here whether in the presence of rotation there is such a singular point at which the effects beyond the bogoliubov theory are significant .
[ b ] ( eq . ( [ depletion ] ) ) at the phase boundary calculated by the bogoliubov theory.,title="fig : " ] we evaluate the depletion of the condensate calculated by the bogoliubov theory as @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the hole amplitude in the bdg equation ( [ bdg ] ) . if @xmath139 is of the order of unity , the validity of the bogoliubov theory is not ensured . since the excitation in the uniform - density regime
is contributed mainly from the excitation with quantum number 1 , the depletion in the uniform - density regime becomes @xmath140 at the phase boundary @xmath141 , this is rewritten as @xmath142 which is shown in fig .
[ depletion figure ] .
the quantum depletion diverges at the boundary @xmath143 .
however , as @xmath120 is increased , @xmath144 at the phase boundary decreases and the depletion becomes much less pronounced as shown in fig .
[ depletion figure ] .
this result is also inferred from fig .
[ pd](b ) .
the uniform - density state becomes dynamically unstable below the horizontal dotted line @xmath136 , and this line touches the phase boundary ( the bold curve ) only at @xmath101 .
[ b ] for @xmath145 ( solid curve ) , @xmath146 ( dashed - and - dotted curves ) , and @xmath124 ( dotted curves ) .
the ( quasi ) zero - energy levels in the soliton regime correspond to the goldstone modes associated with the translation - symmetry breaking due to soliton formation .
open circles show the excitation energy @xmath147 obtained by the exact diagonalization of the hamiltonian for @xmath148 with @xmath146 , which agrees with the bogoliubov spectrum @xmath149 ( bold curve ) even at the phase boundary @xmath150 .
, title="fig : " ] we compare low - lying energy levels obtained by the bogoliubov theory with those obtained by the exact diagonalization of the many - body hamiltonian ( [ hamiltoniank ] ) . in fig .
[ spectra ] , we show the bogoliubov spectra @xmath37 obtained by the bdg equation ( [ bdg ] ) as a function of the strength of interaction for the angular frequency @xmath151 , and @xmath152 .
the curves represent the excitation energies from the uniform - density state for @xmath153 , and those from the soliton for @xmath154 .
all levels are continuous at the boundaries @xmath155 , which indicates a smooth crossover between the uniform - density state and the soliton state .
when @xmath101 ( solid curves ) , @xmath156 and @xmath44 are degenerate in the uniform - density regime , but they separate into two branches , the first excitation and a goldstone mode , in the soliton regime ( @xmath157 ) .
the goldstone mode , which is associated with the translation - symmetry breaking , boosts the soliton along the ring without increasing the energy . as @xmath120
is increased from zero ( dashed - and - dotted curves ) , the degeneracy is lifted by rotation .
next we calculate the low - lying energy levels by the exact diagonalization of the many - body hamiltonian to see how they deviate from the bogoliubov spectra near the phase boundary .
the procedure of the diagonalization is the same as that without rotation @xcite . denoting the number of atoms with angular momentum @xmath158 as @xmath159
, the plane - wave bases are prepared as @xmath160 where @xmath161 is the angular momentum of the condensate , and @xmath162 is the cutoff . within the subspace in which the particle number and the total angular momentum are conserved as @xmath163
we perform the diagonalization of the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltoniank ] ) , which is rewritten as @xmath164 we denote the ground - state angular momentum as @xmath165 that gives the lowest energy eigenvalue , and the ground - state energy as @xmath166 .
open circles in fig .
[ spectra ] show excitation energy @xmath147 obtained by the diagonalization of the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltoniand ] ) for @xmath148 and @xmath146 with cutoff @xmath167 .
the results agree very well with the bogoliubov spectrum @xmath149 ( we represent here only the excitation that conserve the total angular momentum @xmath165 ) .
we have also confirmed that the difference between the bogoliubov spectrum and the exact one becomes even smaller as @xmath120 is further away from zero , consistent with the analysis of the depletion of the condensate .
the bogoliubov theory is thus vindicated except for @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
the magnetic flux is excluded from a superconductor when the applied magnetic field is below a critical value .
the analog of this meisner effect in superfluid system is the hess - fairbank effect @xcite , in which the system is not set into rotation when the frequency @xmath0 of a rotating drive is below a critical value @xmath170 .
when @xmath0 exceeds @xmath170 , the circulation of the system , which is defined as the integral of the superfluid velocity along a closed contour , is quantized in units of @xmath171 @xcite , in analogy with the case of a type - ii superconductor in which quantized vortices enter the system when the external magnetic field exceeds the lower critical field @xmath172 .
the applied magnetic field and the magnetic flux in the superconductor correspond to the applied rotation and the angular momentum @xmath173 of the superfluid , respectively .
we calculate the angular momentum of the ground state @xmath174 , where @xmath175 is the mean - field solution ( [ plane wave ] ) with eqs .
( [ g_density ] ) and ( [ g_phase ] ) obtained in sec .
[ derivation ] , and we find the analytical expression for the expectation value of @xmath176 per atom as @xmath177 where @xmath178 is given in eq .
( [ ww ] ) [ see also fig . [ parameters](a ) ] . in the limits
@xmath179 and @xmath134 , @xmath180 reduces to @xmath21 and @xmath98 , respectively .
equation ( [ mfl ] ) is shown in fig .
[ l0 ] as a function of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , where the plateaus correspond to the uniform - density regime , and the crossover regions between plateaus correspond to the soliton regime . for @xmath50 ,
the stable uniform - density state does not exist and the plateaus disappear . since the quantum fluctuation is small , eq .
( [ mfl ] ) correctly describes the ground - state angular momentum except for @xmath181 and @xmath169 .
both hartree - fock theory @xcite and monte carlo calculation @xcite show that this system exhibits the hess - fairbank effect in a certain parameter regime , which is consistent with our results .
we briefly comment on the same problem for repulsive interaction ( @xmath182 ) .
according to the mft , the ground state with repulsive interaction has a uniform density for all parameters .
the expectation value of the angular momentum then increases stepwise like the noninteracting case with @xmath183 in fig .
the repulsive bosons do not prefer the mixing of different angular - momentum states since it costs the fock exchange energy . .
when @xmath184 , the plateaus disappear . ]
we examine the effect of thermal fluctuations on the quantized circulation at finite temperature .
the total angular momentum of the system is obtained from the derivative of free energy @xmath185 with respect to @xmath0 as @xmath186 where @xmath187 is a dimensionless temperature with @xmath188 being the boltzmann constant , @xmath189 denotes the ensemble average at temperature @xmath190 , and the second term in eq .
( [ l at t ] ) corresponds to the angular momentum of the rigid body arising from the constant term of the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltoniank ] ) . and
@xmath148 at temperatures @xmath191 and @xmath192 obtained by diagonalization of hamiltonian ( [ hamiltoniand ] ) .
dotted lines show the result of the mean - field theory at @xmath193 . ] to evaluate the free energy , we employ the exact diagonalization method of the many - body hamiltonian .
all low - lying levels @xmath194 have been obtained in sec .
[ quantum fluctuation ] , and we use them to calculate the free energy @xmath195 figure [ lt ] shows the angular momentum for several temperatures calculated from eqs .
( [ l at t ] ) and ( [ fe ] ) , where the mean - field result at @xmath193 is also presented for comparison as dotted lines . at absolute zero , the result obtained by the exact diagonalization agrees well with the mean - field result , which supports the validity of the mft consistently with the results in sec .
[ quantum fluctuation ] . as the temperature
is increased , thermal excitations wash out the edge of the step of the circulation , and the angular momentum of the system approaches that of the classical fluid , i.e. , @xmath196 . in the present paper , we have focused on the properties near @xmath193 in this calculation ; however , in principle , this method can be extended to higher temperature by increasing the cutoff angular momentum as long as the excitations of radial modes are negligible .
near @xmath197 , though the diagonalization gives less accurate results than at @xmath198 because a larger number of bases are needed in order to allow the state to have a node , the accuracy can also be improved by the increase of the cutoff angular momentum .
finally , we consider an experimental situation . to be concrete , let us consider @xmath199li ; then eq . ( [ tau ] ) leads to @xmath200)^2}\ [ { \rm nk } ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus for a torus with @xmath201 , @xmath202 in fig .
[ lt ] corresponds to @xmath203 nk which can be achieved with current experimental techniques .
a torus geometry may also be set up by the technique of microelectronic chips @xcite .
rotation of the system can actually be driven by a potential that breaks the axisymmetry of the system . as a concrete example
, we consider a time - dependent potential @xmath204 which stirs the system with angular frequency @xmath6 , and we fix the amplitude of the potential as @xmath205 .
we take as an initial state @xmath206 with a fixed strength of interaction @xmath207 , and let the system evolve in time according to the gpe , @xmath208\psi(\theta , t ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] figures [ resonance ] ( a)-(c ) show the time evolutions of the angular momentum of the condensate and the amplitude @xmath209 .
one of the phase boundaries for @xmath207 determined by eq .
( [ stability condition ] ) is @xmath210 . as @xmath0 gets close to @xmath211 , the stirring potential causes the dynamical instability , and a significant growth in density
is seen in fig .
[ resonance](c ) . figure [ resonance](d ) plots the maximum amplitude @xmath212 as a function of @xmath0 , which shows the resonance induced near the phase boundary
. however , the angular momentum of the system oscillates without damping , and the system does not reach any stationary state . at @xmath213 ( solid curves ) driven by a time - dependent stirring potential ( [ potential ] ) with @xmath207 for ( a ) @xmath214 , ( b ) @xmath215 , and ( c ) @xmath216 .
note that the oscillations of the density and angular momentum are enhanced close to @xmath210 .
( d ) maximum amplitude of the wave function as a function of @xmath0 . ] to achieve a stationary state , we must introduce energy dissipation .
we therefore study the time - evolution of the system according to a generalized gpe @xcite , @xmath217\!\!\psi(\theta , t ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath218 is a phenomenological damping constant .
figure [ vortex ] ( a ) shows the time evolutions of the angular momentum for several values of the stirring angular frequency with @xmath219 .
the system acquires a finite angular momentum , and the magnitude of the absorbed angular momentum converges to that of the thermodynamically stable state as shown in fig . [ vortex](b ) .
we note that as long as @xmath0 lies in the same plateau region , the angular momentum converges to the same integral value , demonstrating that the ground state derived in sec .
[ derivation ] can indeed be prepared by the time - dependent stirring potential in the presence of energy dissipation and that the circulations is indeed quantized in the thermodynamically stable state . from these results , it is concluded that the system reaches a thermodynamically stable state after both density fluctuations and energy dissipation .
the oscillations in the density is drastically enhanced near the resonant frequency ( dynamical instability ) .
however , the system can acquire a net angular momentum due to energy dissipation ( landau instability ) .
similar mechanisms were found in the vortex lattice formation @xcite . for @xmath207 and @xmath205 .
( b ) expectation value of angular momentum per atom obtained by the mft for @xmath207 . ]
in conclusion , we investigated the rotational properties of one - dimensional bosons with attractive interactions confined in a rotating torus trap .
we derived the ground state wave function analytically within the mft as a function of the strength of interaction @xmath1 and of the rotational frequency of the torus @xmath0 . a uniform - density solution and a bright - soliton one
are found to smoothly cross over to each other .
the density of the soliton depends on the rotational frequency @xmath22 relative to @xmath21 and has a node at @xmath220 when a vortex enters the ring . in order to investigate the validity of the bogoliubov theory , we compared the excitation spectrum obtained by the bogoliubov theory with that obtained by the exact diagonalization of the many - body hamiltonian , and found that the mft well describes the ground state except for @xmath221 , where the phase boundary and the borderline of the onset of the dynamical instability coincide , and hence quantum fluctuations are significant
. the angular momentum of the ground state is quantized with respect to @xmath0 in the uniform - density regime , but it is not in the soliton - regime .
the circulations at finite temperature are examined by the exact diagonalization method . to understand the process in which the system is set into rotation
, we considered a time - dependent stirring potential which breaks the axisymmetry of the torus .
the potential is shown to induce the dynamical instability , causing the density to oscillate resonantly and triggering the acquisition of the angular momentum by the system . with energy dissipation
, the quantized circulation is found to become thermodynamically stabilized via the landau instability .
this research was supported by a grant - in - aid for scientific research ( grant no.15340129 ) , by special coordination funds for promoting science and technology from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan and by the yamada science foundation .
we summarize definitions and interrelations of some elliptic integrals and elliptic functions @xcite that are used in the present paper .
elliptic integrals of the first kind @xmath222 , the second kind @xmath223 , and the third kind @xmath224 are defined as @xmath225 using a parameter @xmath226 , jacobian elliptic functions are defined by @xmath227 and these functions are interrelated as @xmath228.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the parameter set @xmath229 instead of @xmath230 , the elliptic integrals are also expressed as @xmath231 elliptic integrals are said to be complete when @xmath232 , and are usually denoted as @xmath233 complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds are expanded for @xmath234 as infinite series @xmath235,\label{series1}\nonumber\\ \\ e(m)\!\!\!&=&\!\!\!\frac{\pi}{2}\left[1\!-\!\!\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{\!2}\!\!m\right . \!-\!\!\left(\frac{1\!\cdot\ ! 3}{2\!\cdot\ ! 4}\right)^{\!2}\!\!\frac{m^2}{3 } \left.\!-\!\!\left(\frac{1\!\cdot\ ! 3\!\cdot\ ! 5}{2\!\cdot\ ! 4\ ! \cdot\ ! 6}\right)^{\!2}\!\!\frac{m^3}{5}\!-\!\cdots\right].\label{series2}\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] the elliptic integral of the third kind @xmath236 has other expressions depending on the relation between @xmath62 and @xmath81 .
when @xmath85 and @xmath237 , it reduces to @xmath238 where @xmath88 is heuman s lambda function defined as @xmath239.\end{aligned}\ ] ]
we consider the limits @xmath179 and @xmath240 of the soliton solution for @xmath241 given by @xmath242\label{densitya},\\ \varphi(\theta)&=&\omega\theta-{\rm sgn}(\omega)\delta_2^{-1}\pi \left(\left .
n;\frac{k\theta}{\pi}\right| m\right)\label{phasea},\\ \mu&=&\frac{1}{2\pi^2}(f_{\rm d}-f_{\rm c}-f)\label{cpa } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath243 the limiting values and behaviors of several parameters are summarized in table [ limit table ] and fig .
[ parameters ] , respectively . in the limit @xmath179 ( @xmath244 )
, the equations ( [ densitya ] ) and ( [ phasea ] ) continuously become those of the dn - solution since @xmath245 and @xmath246 from fig .
[ parameters ] and table [ limit table ] . in the limit @xmath134 ( @xmath247 ) , where the parameters behave as @xmath248 , @xmath246 , eqs .
( [ densitya ] ) and ( [ phasea ] ) reproduce the cn - solution .
it can easily be verified by setting @xmath249 or @xmath250 in eq .
( [ cpa ] ) that in these limits the chemical potential for @xmath251 continuously approaches @xmath252 the first derivative of the ground - state energy with respect to @xmath0 has a kink at the phase boundary , which is verified by the relations ( [ mfl ] ) and ( [ l at t ] ) as , @xmath253 .limiting values of various parameters of the soliton solution .
the limit @xmath179 is equivalent to the limit @xmath254 or @xmath255 , and @xmath256 is equivalent to @xmath257 or @xmath258 .
the limit @xmath259 corresponds to the uniform - density limit @xmath260 . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] ( dashed - and - dotted ) , @xmath261 ( dashed ) , @xmath262 ( solid ) , and @xmath263 ( dotted curves ) .
( d ) incomplete elliptic integral of the third kind @xmath264 for @xmath265 as a function of @xmath10 . ]
figure [ m ] shows the solution @xmath62 calculated numerically by solving @xmath266 where the line of intersection between the curves and the @xmath1-@xmath22 plane corresponds to the phase boundary @xmath267 .
calculated numerically from eq .
( [ m eqs ] ) .
the dotted curve on the @xmath22-@xmath1 plane represents the phase boundary @xmath267 , and there exists a unique solution @xmath62 in the soliton regime @xmath268 . ]
we investigate the continuity of the ground - state properties at the phase boundary . from fig .
[ m ] , we see that the parameter @xmath62 becomes zero for all soliton solutions in the limit @xmath269 .
the uniform - density limit of the soliton solution is hence mathematically obtained by taking the limit of @xmath259 .
let @xmath270 be a positive small deviation of @xmath1 from the value at the phase boundary for a fixed @xmath22 . for @xmath271 , the parameter @xmath272 , and hence the physical quantities near the phase boundary
are expanded in terms of @xmath270 as follows . for the dn - solution ( @xmath101 ) ,
the phase boundary is @xmath136 and let @xmath273 . using the equation @xmath249 , we obtain @xmath274 the expansion formulae ( [ series1 ] ) and ( [ series2 ] ) become @xmath275 using these expansions , the ground - state energy and the chemical potential are expressed as functions of @xmath270 instead of @xmath62 near the phase boundary @xmath273 .
the jump of the second derivative of the ground - state energy and the first derivative of the chemical potential are obtained as @xmath276 at @xmath136 and @xmath101 . for the cn - solution ( @xmath110 ) at @xmath277 ,
the expansions are obtained in a similar way as @xmath278 the ground - state energy and the chemical potential are expanded in terms of @xmath270 as @xmath279 which are continuously connected with those of the uniform - density solution at @xmath183 and @xmath110 . however , the first derivative of the ground - state energy and that of the chemical potential are given by @xmath280 and have discontinuous jumps at @xmath183 and @xmath110 by the following amounts : @xmath281 | we investigate rotational properties of a system of bosons with attractive interactions confined in a one - dimensional torus .
two kinds of ground states , uniform - density and bright - soliton states , are obtained analytically as functions of the strength of interaction and of the rotational frequency of the torus .
the quantization of circulation appears in the uniform - density state , but disappears upon formation of the soliton . by comparison with the results of exact diagonalization of the many - body hamiltonian
, we show that the bogoliubov theory is valid at absolute zero over a wide range of parameters . at finite temperature
we employ the exact diagonalization method to examine how thermal fluctuations smear the plateaus of the quantized circulation .
finally , by rotating the system with an axisymmetry - breaking potential , we clarify the process in which the quantized circulation becomes thermodynamically stabilized . |
the amount and the timing of appearance of the transcriptional product of a gene is mostly determined by regulatory proteins through biochemical reactions that enhance or block polymerase binding at the promoter region ( @xcite ) . considering that many genes code for regulatory proteins that can activate or repress other genes , the emerging picture is conveniently summarized as complex network where the genes are the nodes , and
a link between two genes is present if they interact .
the identification of these networks is becoming one of the most relevant task of new large - scale genomic technologies such as dna microarrays , since gene networks can provide a detailed understanding of the cell regulatory system , can help unveiling the function of previously unknown genes and developing pharmaceutical compounds .
different approaches have been proposed to describe gene networks ( see ( @xcite ) for a review ) , and different procedures have been proposed ( @xcite ) to determine the network from experimental data .
this is a computationally daunting task , which we address in the present work .
here we describe the network via deterministic evolution equations ( @xcite ) , which encode both the strenght and the direction of interaction between two genes , and we discuss a novel reverse engineering procedure to extract the network from experimental data .
this procedure , though remaining a quantitative one , realizes one of the most important goal of modern system biology , which is the integration of data of different type and of knowledge obtained by different means .
we assume that the rate of synthesis of a transcript is determined by the concentrations of every transcript in a cell and by external perturbations . the level of gene transcripts is therefore seen to form a dynamical system which in the most simple scenario is described by the following set of ordinary differential equations ( @xcite ) : @xmath0 where @xmath1 is a vector encoding the expression level of @xmath2 genes at times @xmath3 , and @xmath4 a vector encoding the strength of @xmath5 external perturbations ( for instance , every element @xmath6 could measure the density of a specific substance administered to the system ) . in this scenario the gene regulatory network is the matrix @xmath7 ( of dimension @xmath8 ) , as the element @xmath9 measures the influence of gene @xmath10 on gene @xmath11 , with a positive @xmath9 indicating activation , a negative one indicating repression , and a zero indicating no interaction .
the matrix @xmath12 ( of dimension @xmath13 ) encodes the coupling of the gene network with the @xmath5 external perturbations , as @xmath14 measures the influence of the @xmath15-th perturbation on the @xmath11-th gene .
a critical step in our construction is the choice of a linear differential system .
even if a such kind of model is based on particular assumptions on the complex dynamics of a gene network , it seem the only practical approach due to the lack of knowledge of real interaction mechanism between thousands of genes
. even a simple nonlinear approach would give rise to an intractable amount of free parameters .
however , it must also be recognized that all other approaches or models have weakness points .
for instance , boolean models ( which have been very recently applied to inference of networks from time series data , as in ( @xcite ) , strongly discretize the data and select , _ via _ the use of an arbitrary threshold , among active and inactive gene at every time - step .
dynamical bayesian models , instead , are more data demanding than linear models due to their probabilistic nature
. moreover , their space complexity grows like @xmath16 ( at least in the famous reveal algorithm by k.p .
murphy ( @xcite ) ) , which makes this tool suitable for small networks . the linear model of eq .
( [ eq - cont ] ) is suitable to describe the response of a system to small external perturbations .
it can be recovered by expanding to first order , and around the equilibrium condition @xmath17 , the dependency of @xmath18 on @xmath19 and @xmath4 , @xmath20 .
stability considerations ( @xmath21 must not diverge in time ) require the eigenvalues of @xmath7 to have a negative real part .
moreover it clarifies that if the perturbation @xmath4 is kept constant the model is not suitable to describe periodic systems , like cell cycles for example , since in this case @xmath21 asymptotically approaches a constant .
unfortunately data from a given cell type involve thousands of responsive genes @xmath2 .
this means that there are many different regulatory networks activated at the same time by the perturbations , and the number of measurements ( microarray hybridizations ) in typical experiments is much smaller than @xmath2 .
consequently , inference methods can be successful , but only if restricted to a subset of the genes ( i.e. a specific network ) ( @xcite ) , or to the dynamics of genes subsets .
these subsets could be either gene clusters , created by grouping genes sharing similar time behavior , or the modes obtained by using singular value decomposition ( svd ) . in these cases
it is still possible to use eq .
( [ eq - cont ] ) , but @xmath21 must be interpreted as a vector encoding the time variation of the clusters centroids , or the time variation of the characteristics modes obtained via svd . in this paper
we present a method for the determination of the matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 starting from time series experiments using a global optimization approach to minimize an appropriate figure of merit . with respects to previous attempts ,
our algorithm as the uses explicitly the insight provided by earlier studies on gene regulatory networks ( @xcite ) , namely , that gene networks in most biological systems are sparse . in order to code such type of features the problem itself must be formulated as mixed - integer nonlinear optimization one ( @xcite ) .
moreover our approach is intended to explicitly incorporate prior biological knowledge as , for instance , it is possible to impose that : @xmath22 @xmath23 if it is known that gene @xmath10 inhibits ( does not influence , activates , influences ) gene @xmath11 .
this means that the optimization problem is subject to inequality and/or equality constraints .
summing up the characteristics of the problem we must solve : high dimensionality , mixed integer , nonlinear programming problem for the exact solution of which no method exists .
an approximate solution can be found efficiently using a global optimization techniques ( @xcite ) based on an intelligent stochastic search of the admissible set .
as consequence of the optimization method used , there is no difficulties to integrates different time series data investigating the response of the same set of genes to different perturbations , even if different time series are sampled at different ( and not equally spaced ) time points .
the integration of different time series is a major achievement , as it allows for the joint use of data obtained by different research groups.we believe that the integration of multiple time - series dataset in unveiling a gene network is a topic of great interest as focused in recently published papers ( @xcite ) .
we illustrate and test the validity of our algorithm on computer simulated gene expression data , and we apply it to an experimental gene expression data set obtained by perturbing the sos system in bacteria _
the simplest assumption regarding the dynamical response of gene transcripts ( intially in a steady state , @xmath24 for @xmath25 ) , to the appearance of an external perturbation @xmath26 at time @xmath27 is given by eq .
( [ eq - cont ] ) . since the state of the system measured at discrete times @xmath28 , @xmath29
, it useful to consider the discrete form of eq .
[ eq - cont ] .
@xmath30 where @xmath31 is a matrix with dimension @xmath32 , and @xmath33 is a function of the perturbations , namely @xmath34 here we have assumed , for simplicity sake , @xmath35 , but the generalization to the most general case is straightforward . in particular , for constant @xmath4 one gets @xmath36 . due to the presence of noise
the measured @xmath37 do not coincide with the true values @xmath38 expected to satisfy eq .
( [ eq - cont ] ) . if we for simplicity observed samples affected by independent , zero mean additive noise @xmath39 , namely @xmath40 , the matrices ruling the dynamics of eq .
( [ eq - cont ] ) can be found by requiring the minimization of a suitably defined _
cost function_. under the simplifying assumption of a constant external perturbation , previous works have been focused on the determination of @xmath31 and @xmath41 ( from which @xmath7 and @xmath12 can be retrieved ) , as in ( @xcite ) .
the matrices @xmath31 and @xmath41 have been assumed to be those minimizing the cost function @xmath42 eq .
[ eq - cont ] can be written as standard linear least squares estimation problem for @xmath43 , whose solution can be found by computing the pseudoinverse of a suitable matrix , providing that number of observations is sufficiently high : @xmath44 . in the present analysis
we introduce a new reverse engineering approach to determine the matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 , which turns out to be more efficient and flexible than previous ones .
our approach is based on the following considerations , which have not been taken into account in previous works : * each gene expression time series could in principle be scanned according to both time versus , namely the _ time - reversibility _ of dynamics .
* there is a biological evidence suggesting that the matrix @xmath31 is sparse ( @xcite ) .
for this reason any reverse engineering algorithm has to be able to capture the proper sparsity of gene regulatory network . * in many situations there are biological prior information about bounds on numerical value of some specific entries of @xmath7 and @xmath12 .
such bounds must be taken into account in the solution procedure . as a consequence of this we use as a cost function the reduced @xmath45 defined as follows : @xmath46 where @xmath47 .
\label{eq - mcost}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath48 , and the quantities @xmath31 and @xmath49 can be obtained from @xmath7 and @xmath12 by appropriate numerical approximation algorithms for eq.s ( [ eq - discrete - matrix ] ) .
the quantity @xmath50 denotes the standard deviation of the independent , additive noise affecting the dataset .
a straightforward optimization on dynamics / input matrices of eq . ( [ eq - cont ] ) is the main improvement of the proposed approach with respect to the previous ones .
this is the only way that enable us to incorporate the sparseness requirement on @xmath51 and eventually available biological priors .
it is clear that sparseness was destroyed by exponentiation and integration involved in the continuous - discrete transformation of the problem , in the same way simple bounds on @xmath51 elements are transformed in highly complex nonlinear relations on @xmath52 .
the price paid for the flexibility of the approach is the computational effort required for any computation of the error function .
this put a very strong attention to the efficiency of the optimization algorithm . in eq .
( [ eq - mcost ] ) the two contributions in square brackets account for the forward and backward propagation , respectively , and thus implement the time reversibility of the dynamics . moreover , the sparsity of the gene network is taken into account via the number of degrees of freedom ( d.o.f . )
defined as @xmath53 with @xmath54 the number of free parameters , @xmath55 the number of equations ( constraints ) and @xmath56 the number of elements of @xmath7 and @xmath12 ( a total of @xmath56 ) fixed to zero . the generalization of the algorithm to the case in which there are different time - series , @xmath57 , corresponding to the response of the same set of genes to similar and/or different perturbations @xmath58 with @xmath59 is straightforward . in this case
the cost function to be minimized is simply @xmath60 here we have assumed the noise to depend on the time - series ( @xmath61 ) . it is clearly possible , however , to introduce a time ( @xmath62 ) and even a gene ( i ) dependence , i.e to use @xmath63 .
we detail now our procedure to find the spare matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 minimizing @xmath45 , , which is in general a formidable task .
the first difficulty is the determination of the number @xmath64 of not vanishing elements of @xmath65 ( or equivalently the number of d.o.f .
@xmath66 ) .
having determined @xmath67 the problem is still very complicated since there are @xmath68 different ways of choosing these @xmath67 elements out of the @xmath69 candidates . for typical values of the parameters , for instance
@xmath70 and @xmath71 , the number of possible combinations is of the order of @xmath72 , so big that any kind of extensive algorithmic procedure is precluded . a practical approach to ,
at least approximately solve , this formidable problem is that of resort to a global optimization techniques based on a stochastic strategy to search of the admissible set , for a comprehensive review os such type of methods one can see ( @xcite ) .
we have tackled this problem via the implementation of the more classical of such methods : a simulated annealing procedure ( @xcite ) , based on a monte carlo dynamics . for each possible value of the number of parameters @xmath67 , the algorithm search for the matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 with a total of @xmath67 non zero elements minimizing the cost function of eq .
( [ eq - mcost ] ) , as discussed below .
we then easily determine @xmath73 and the minimizing matrices @xmath74 and @xmath75 which are our best estimates of the true matrices . in order to determine the matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 with a total of @xmath67 non zero parameters which minimize the cost function , our simulated annealing procedure starts with two random matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 with a total of @xmath67 not vanishing parameters , and changes the elements of these matrices according to two possible monte carlo moves .
one move is the variation of the value of a not vanishing element of the two matrices , the other one consists in setting to zero a previously non - zero element , and to a random value a zero element .
each move , which involves a variation @xmath76 of the cost function , is accepted with a probability @xmath77 $ ] , where @xmath78 is an external parameter . as in standard
optimization by annealing procedures , we start from a high value of @xmath78 , of the order of the cost function value , and then we slowly consider the limit @xmath79 . in the limit of infinitesimally small decrease of @xmath78
the algorithm is able to retrieve the true minimum of the cost function , while for faster cooling rates estimates of the real minimum are recovered . as the monte carlo moves attempt to change the values of the elements of @xmath7 and @xmath12 , it is easy to introduce biological constraints on the values of @xmath80 and of @xmath81 , as we will shown in a following example .
the algorithm requires the evaluation of the cost function @xmath82 , which is a time consuming operation as the computation of the discrete matrix @xmath31 and of its inverse @xmath83 are required .
we have implemented this algorithm in c++ making use of the gnu scientific library , www.gsl.org .
in this section , we illustrate our reverse engineering algorithm with three examples .
the validity of our algorithm and of other known ones are evaluated by comparing the exact dynamical matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 with their best estimate @xmath74 and @xmath75 obtained via the reverse engineering procedure . to this end , we have introduced the parameter @xmath84 where @xmath85 or @xmath75 and @xmath86 is the @xmath87 norm of the matrix @xmath88 . clearly , @xmath89 , the equality being satisfied if and only if @xmath90 .
since @xmath91 is a measure of a relative error it has no upper bound , but the estimate of @xmath92 becomes unreliable when @xmath91 is above @xmath93 , i.e. @xmath94 .
this parameter allows for a faithful evaluation of the quality of the reverse engineering approach , as it summarizes the comparisons of all retrieved elements @xmath95 with their true values @xmath96 .
we discuss three applications .
first , we show how our algorithm works when applied to a single time series . in this case
one can show that the cost function @xmath97 , which takes into account both the forward and the backward propagation , is more effective in determining the structure of the gene network than the usual cost function @xmath98 of eq .
( [ eq - cost ] ) , which only considers the forward propagation .
the second example shows how we can easily take into account the presence of different time - series , while the last example shows how biological priors can be included . before discussing the examples we shortly describe the procedure used to generate the synthetic dataset . in order to generate a synthetic dataset @xmath37 one must construct the matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 , from which it is possible to generate the noiseless time - series @xmath38 .
hence , one gets @xmath99 for @xmath100 where @xmath101 are i.i.d .
random variables with standard deviation @xmath50 .
while there are no constraints on @xmath12 , @xmath7 must be a sparse random matrix whose complex eigenvalues have negative real part .
the generation of @xmath7 proceeds according the following steps .
first , we generate a @xmath32 block diagonal matrix @xmath102 , whose @xmath2 blocks are @xmath103 antisymmetric matrices with diagonal elements @xmath104 and off diagonal elements @xmath105 , or @xmath106 negative real elements @xmath107 . by direct constructions
all of the @xmath2 eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath102 have negative real part .
then we generate a series @xmath108 of random unitary matrices , with only @xmath109 off - diagonal not vanishing entries , and compute the matrices @xmath110 , all of them sharing the spectrum of @xmath111 . clearly , as @xmath15 grows , the number of vanishing entries ( the sparsity ) of @xmath112 decreases .
we fix @xmath7 as the matrix @xmath113 characterized by the desired number of vanishing elements . by choosing typical values of @xmath104 and @xmath114
it is possible to control the time scale of the relaxation process of the system following the application of the perturbation .
synthetic time - series @xmath37 with @xmath115 elements measured at @xmath116 = 20 equally spaced time - points . ]
let us consider a simulated time - series @xmath117 with @xmath115 measured at @xmath118 equally - spaced time - points , as shown in fig .
this dataset is generated by starting from a sparse gene network @xmath7 ( with only @xmath119 out of @xmath120 non - zero elements ) , a constant perturbation @xmath121 and a sparse external perturbation - coupling matrix @xmath12 with a single not vanishing entry .
the white noise is characterized by a standard deviation @xmath122 measured in units of the mean absolute value of the expression levels of all genes .
in particular the value @xmath123 has been used .
we have applied our algorithm to this dataset . to this end , we have minimized the reduced chi - square @xmath45 , defined in eq .
( [ eq - rcs ] ) , for different values of the number of parameters @xmath67 ( i.e. of the number of degrees of freedom @xmath124 ) . fig .
[ fig2 ] shows that @xmath45 has a non - monotonic dependence on the number of parameters @xmath67 .
this feature is a signature of the fact that both networks with few or with many connections are bad descriptions of the actual gene regulatory system .
accordingly , our best estimate of the number of not vanishing parameters is @xmath125 , where @xmath45 has its minimum , and the corresponding minimizing matrices @xmath74 ( with @xmath126 non zero entries ) and @xmath75 ( with @xmath127 non zero elements ) are our best estimates of the actual gene network encoding matrix @xmath7 and of the matrix @xmath12 .
the main panel ( inset ) show the dependence of @xmath45 ( of the minimum of the cost function ) on the number of not vanishing parameters @xmath67 , as determined by our algorithm when applied to the time - series shown in fig .
the fluctuations are due to the probabilistic nature of the monte carlo minimization procedure .
the quantity @xmath45 varies non - monotonically with @xmath67 , and has a minimum with @xmath128 parameters . ]
the estimators assume the values @xmath129 and @xmath130 .
these values indicate that , when applied to this small dataset , our algorithm is able to retrieve @xmath12 to a very good approximation , and @xmath7 with a comparatively larger error . for comparison , we have also obtained the matrices @xmath31 and @xmath41 which exactly minimize @xmath98 via a linear algebraic approach , and retrieved the corresponding continuous matrices via the use of the bilinear transformation , obtaining the scores @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
these numbers prove that by exploiting the time reversibility of the equation of motion , and the sparseness of the gene network , is it possible to estimate the parameters of the network with a greater accuracy , as also shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] where we plot the best estimates @xmath133 obtained by both methods versus their true values @xmath9 : in the case of perfect retrieval all of the points should lie on the @xmath134 line .
+ we plot here the values of the element of the estimated matrices @xmath135 , obtained both with the linear algebraic approach and with our algorithm , versus their true value @xmath80 .
ideally , the points should line on the @xmath134 dotted line . ]
there are two major problems encountered when trying to infer a gene network via the analysis of time - series data .
the first one is that there are usually to few time - points with respect to the large number of genes .
the second one is associated to the fact that , when the system responds to an external perturbation , only the expression of the genes directly or indirectly linked to that perturbation changes , i.e. , only a specific sub - network of the whole gene network is _ activated _ by the external perturbation .
while through the study of the time - series it is possible to learn something about the regulatory role of the responding genes , nothing can be learnt about the regulatory role of the non - responding genes .
these problems can be addressed by using gene network retrieval procedures which are able to simultaneously analyze different time - series ( @xcite ) , particularly if these measure the response of the system to different perturbations , as we expect different perturbations to activate different genes .
our reverse engineering approach naturally exploits the presence of multiple time series by requiring the minimization of eq .
( [ eq - min - molti ] ) . here
we study the network discussed in the previous example by adding to the time - series shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] , other ones generated by the application of two different perturbations . for sake of simplicity all time - series are measured at equally - spaced time - points , but with an elapsing time between two consecutive data points depending on the particular time - series .
hence that the problem can not be reduced to the one of a single average time - series by exploiting the linearity of eq .
( [ eq - cont ] ) . as the number of time - series increases , our determination of the gene network @xmath7 becomes more and more accurate .
for instance , while by means of a single perturbation we obtain @xmath129 ( @xmath136 ) , by using two time - series we obtain @xmath137 ( @xmath138 ) , and by using three time series we get @xmath139 ( @xmath140 ) .
dependence of @xmath141 on the fraction of priors , as obtained by analyzing one or two time - series .
the scoring parameter @xmath141 decreases as the number of priors increases , indicating that a better estimate of the gene network @xmath7 is recovered . ]
+ + as the traditional approach to research in molecular biology has been an inherently local one , examining and collecting data on a single gene or a few genes , there are now couples of gene which are known to interact in a specific way , or do not interact at all .
this information is nowadays easily available by consulting pubic databases such as gene ontology .
here we show that it is possible to integrate this non - analytical information in our reverse engineering approach , improving the accuracy of the retrieved network . to this end
we consider again the gene network @xmath7 but we introduce some constraints on a fraction @xmath142 of randomly selected elements of the matrices @xmath7 and @xmath12 , namely @xmath143 . as our retrieval procedure tries to exchange vanishing and not vanishing elements of @xmath7 and @xmath12 we introduce the constraints as follows :
if the element is zero in the exact matrices then we set it to zero and we never try to set it to a non - zero value ; on the contrary , if the element is different from zero , its value is free to change and we never try to set it to zero . by using this approach
we assure that our best estimates of @xmath7 and @xmath12 are consistent with the previous knowledge . in order to stress the greater improvement that can be obtained via the use of biological priors
, we consider now the same gene network @xmath7 and perturbations of examples 1 and 2 , but we corrupt the noiseless dataset by adding a noise ( see eq .
( [ eq - noise ] ) ) characterized by @xmath144 , and not by @xmath145 as before . due to the high value of the noise
the linear algebraic approach is not more able to recover the gene network matrix , as it obtains a score @xmath146 .
we show in fig . [
fig_priors ] the dependence of @xmath141 on the fraction of randomly selected elements of @xmath7 and @xmath12 fixed either to zero or to non - zero , both for the case in which only one or two perturbations have been used in the retrieval procedure .
as expected , @xmath147 decreases as the number of priors increases , showing that as more biological knowledge on the system of interest is available the reliability of our reverse engineering approach improves .
we applied our algorithm to a nine gene network , part of the sos network in _
e. coli_. the genes are @xmath148 , @xmath149 , @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath152 , @xmath153 , @xmath154 , @xmath155 , @xmath156 , and the used time - series consists of six time measurements ( in triplicate ) of the expression level of these genes following treatment with norfloxacin , a known antibiotic that acts by damaging the dna .
the time series is the same used in ref .
( @xcite ) , and experimental details can be found there .
given @xmath157 there are @xmath158 unknowns to be determined , as @xmath7 is a @xmath32 matrix , and @xmath12 is a vector of length @xmath2 . since @xmath159 ,
the experimental data allows for the writing of @xmath160 equations , and for the determination of only @xmath161 unknowns , while a literature survey ( @xcite ) suggests that there are at list @xmath162 connections between the considered genes ( including the self - feedback ) . as in previous works ,
we are therefore forced to use an interpolation technique to add new time measurements , creating a time series with @xmath163 time points . when applied to this dataset
, our algorithm found that @xmath45 is minimized by a matrix @xmath7 with @xmath164 not vanishing entries , and a vector @xmath12 with @xmath127 non - zero elements , which are given in table [ table1 ] . in the literature ,
there are @xmath162 known connections between the nine considered genes , including the self - feedback .. we are able to find @xmath165 of these connections . regarding the interaction with norfloxacin , our algorithm found that primary target is @xmath148 , as expected .
l|ccccccccc||c & reca & lexa & ssb & recf & dini & umudc & rpod & rpoh & rpos & @xmath12 + + reca & -1.68 & - & -0.36 & 1.81 & 1.05 & 0.84 & - & - & -0.59 & 0.71 + + lexa & -0.11 & -1.56 & 0.59 & 0.58 & 0.40 & - & -0.34 & - & - & 0.13 + + ssb & -0.47 & 1.82 & -2.83 & - & 0.60 & - & 0.96 & -1.71 & 1.29 & - + + recf & 0.68 & 0.42 & - & -0.93 & -0.52 & -0.40 & -0.30 & 1.13 & - & 0.38 + + dini & 1.18 & 0.72 & 0.39 & -0.96 & -1.71 & 0.42 & - & - & - & 0.34 + + umudc & 0.47 & -0.63 & -0.39 & -0.64 & 0.19 & -0.65 & 0.11 & - & 0.53 & - + + rpod & -0.06 & -0.28 & - & 0.36 & - & - & -0.22 & - & - & 0.40 + + rpoh & - & - & -1.10 & 1.60 & -0.32 & 0.92 & - & -3.46 & 1.46 & - + + rpos & -0.39 & -0.43 & - & - & 0.18 & 0.92 & 0.26 & 0.82 & -0.72 & -0.11 +
in the framework of a linear deterministic description of the time evolution of gene expression levels , we have presented a reverse engineering approach for the determination of gene networks .
this approach , based on the analysis of one or more time - series data , exploits the time - reversibility of the equation of motion of the system , the sparsity of the gene network and previous biological knowledge about the existence / absence of connections between genes . by taking into account this information
the algorithm significatively improves the level of confidence in the determination of the gene network over previous works .
the drawback of our procedure is the computational cost , which at the moment limits the applicability of the algorithm to a small number of genes / clusters .
there are two time - consuming procedures .
one is the transformation of the continuous matrix @xmath7 in the discrete matrix @xmath31 , which we have been avoided by using the bilinear transformation , but whose validity breaks down as the time interval between two consecutive measurements increases .
the second one , which at the moment is the most expensive in time , is the computation of the inverse matrix @xmath83 , which we accomplish through the so - called lu decomposition whose computational cost is @xmath166 .
alternative methods for exploiting the reversibility of the dynamics should therefore by devised for applications with a larger number of genes .
we thank d. di bernardo for rousing our interest in this subject , and for helpful discussions . | the important task of determining the connectivity of gene networks , and at a more detailed level even the kind of interaction existing between genes , can nowadays be tackled by microarraylike technologies . yet
, there is still a large amount of unknowns with respect to the amount of data provided by a single microarray experiment , and therefore reliable gene network retrieval procedures must integrate all of the available biological knowledge , even if coming from different sources and of different nature . in this paper
we present a reverse engineering algorithm able to reveal the underlying gene network by using time - series dataset on gene expressions considering the system response to different perturbations .
the approach is able to determine the sparsity of the gene network , and to take into account possible _ a priori _ biological knowledge on it .
the validity of the reverse engineering approach is highlighted through the deduction of the topology of several _ simulated _ gene networks , where we also discuss how the performance of the algorithm improves enlarging the amount of data or if any a priori knowledge is considered .
we also apply the algorithm to experimental data on a nine gene network in _ escherichia coli_. |
future device technology and quantum information processing may be based on spintronics @xcite , where one manipulates the electron s spin ( and not only its charge ) . here
we address attempts to build mesoscopic spin filters ( or spin valves ) , which generate a tunable spin - polarized current out of unpolarized electron sources .
much recent effort in this direction uses narrow - gap semiconductor heterostructures , where the spins are subject to the rashba @xcite spin - orbit interaction ( soi ) : in a two - dimensional electron gas confined by an asymmetric potential well , the strength of this soi can be varied by an electric field perpendicular to the plane in which the electrons move @xcite .
an early proposal of a spin field - effect transistor @xcite used the rashba soi to control the spin precession of electrons moving in quasi - one - dimensional wires .
some of the most striking quantum effects arise due to interference , which is best demonstrated in quantum networks containing loops . indeed ,
interference due to the rashba soi has been measured on a nanolithographically - defined square loop array @xcite .
recently , several theoretical groups proposed spin filters based on a _ single _ loop , subject to both an electric and a magnetic ( aharonov - bohm ( ab ) @xcite ) perpendicular fields ( e.g refs .
however , such devices produce a full polarization of the outgoing electrons only for _ special values _ of the two fields .
later work considered the effects of the rashba soi on the conductance of chains of loops . these included studies of chains of diamond - like loops @xcite , and studies of finite chains of circular loops @xcite .
although both studies showed some destructive interference due to the soi , they did not concentrate on the tuning of the fully polarized spins which can be obtained in certain parameter ranges .
recently @xcite , we proposed a spin filter based on a periodic chain of diamond - like square loops , connected to each other at opposite corners [ see fig . [ 1 ] ] . unlike the above earlier papers , which used a continuum description for the wires on the network , we used a simple tight - binding model , with quantum dots ( or ` atoms ' ) only at the nodes of the square diamonds .
this allowed us to obtain transparent analytical expressions for the ballistic conductance through the chain and for the outgoing spin polarization .
we found that a combination of both the rashba soi and the ab flux through each loop can result in destructive interference , which can block the transmission of all the spin components except one , which is then polarized at a tunable direction .
technically , this single spin direction is associated with a single propagating wave solution of the schrdinger equation , while all the other solutions involve evanescent modes . here
we extend our analysis of this diamond - like chain in several directions .
first , we replace the previous square loops by rhombi , with a general angle @xmath0 ( fig . [ 1 ] ) .
it turns out that the filter is more efficient for @xmath1 .
second , we generalize our previous study , by allowing different site energies ( controlled by appropriate gate voltages ) on the various sites in the unit cell ( i.e. sites @xmath2 and @xmath3 in fig .
[ 1 ] ) . different site energies at sites @xmath4 and @xmath3 turn out to have drastic effects on the ballistic conductance .
third , we propose using this filter at fixed electric and magnetic fields , controlling the outgoing polarization using a gate voltage .
( in ref . @xcite we worked at fixed energy , and varied the magnetic and electric fields . )
fourth , we replace each edge of each rhombus by a tight - binding chain of ` atoms ' ( or quantum dots ) . in this context
, we compare our tight - binding approach with the continuous quantum network approach used in earlier work on the same geometry @xcite . as we discuss elsewhere @xcite , the two approaches are not equivalent .
section 2 outlines the tight - binding model which we use for solving the schrdinger equation on the periodic chain of generalized diamonds .
section 3 presents results for the polarization of the electrons in the regions where they are fully polarized .
we compare our tight - binding approach to earlier continuum network models in sec . 4 , and summarize our results in sec . 5
the basic theory was presented in ref .
however , for the generalizations introduced here we find it easier to use the ( rotated ) coordinate axes shown in fig .
[ 1 ] . setting the opening angle of each diamond to @xmath0 , the coordinates of the sites in the @xmath5th unit cell become @xmath6 and @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the basic step along the @xmath9axis .
we start with the simplest tight - binding model , which has ` atomic ' sites only at the corners of the diamonds ( this will be extended below ) .
the hopping @xmath10 unitary matrices within the @xmath5th diamond thus become @xmath11 where @xmath12 denotes the site @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the vector of pauli matrices , @xmath15 ( @xmath16 represents the strength of the rashba term ) , @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 is the number of flux units through each diamond . for each bond , the hopping matrix
must be multiplied by the hopping energy , @xmath20 ( below we measure all energies in units of @xmath21 ) . within the @xmath5th diamond ,
the schrdinger equations for the spinors @xmath22 and @xmath23 are @xmath24 except for the special energies @xmath25 , which represent dispersionless solutions ( not shown in the figures ) , we express @xmath26 and @xmath23 in terms of @xmath27 and @xmath28 , and substitute into the equations for @xmath27 .
we end up with effective one - dimensional equations , @xmath29 with @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and with the non - unitary @xmath32 matrix @xmath33,\nonumber\\ & 2b_y=2a^{}_+ c s \cos\beta,\ \ \
2b_z =- ia^{}_-s^2\sin(2\beta),\label{db}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 assuming a propagating wave , @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is a normalized spinor , we find that this spinor must obey @xmath39 , with @xmath40 where @xmath41 , and @xmath42 .
therefore , @xmath43 is an eigenstate of @xmath44 , with the unit vector @xmath45 : @xmath46 , and we have @xmath47 .
thus , @xmath48 and @xmath49 must obey the equation @xmath50 . at fixed @xmath49 ,
this is a polynomial of degree 6 in @xmath48 , so that one expects 6 energy bands . in the special symmetric case where @xmath51 , partially treated in ref .
@xcite , two of these solutions represent dispersionless solutions at @xmath52 , and thus one is left with only four bands ( whose shape and location varies with @xmath53 ) .
the value of @xmath54 only represents a shift in energy , so we fix @xmath55 . for @xmath56
the dispersionless modes become dispersive , and in general the spectrum also becomes asymmetric with respect to @xmath57 and to @xmath58 .
an example of this phenomenon is shown in fig .
[ spec ] , for the square diamond ( @xmath59 ) . as explained in @xcite , the ballistic conductance at a given energy @xmath48 is equal to @xmath60 , where @xmath61 is the number of propagating wave solutions which move in one direction . to study @xmath61
, we now fix @xmath48 and solve the spectrum equation for @xmath49 . in the general case
, this equation turns into a quartic equation in @xmath62 .
this equation reduces to a quadratic equation for @xmath51 . out of the solutions for @xmath49
we count only the right - moving propagating modes , with real @xmath49 and with a positive velocity @xmath63 . as in @xcite
, we again find ranges of @xmath48 with @xmath64 or @xmath65 .
generally @xmath61 depends on all three parameters @xmath66 and @xmath67 . unlike ref .
@xcite , where we fixed @xmath48 and presented results as functions of @xmath68 or @xmath67 , here we fix @xmath67 and fig .
[ contour ] presents contour plots of @xmath69 at @xmath70 . as already indicated by fig .
[ spec ] , changing @xmath71 can open the large gap which existed in the symmetric case near @xmath72 .
this can be seen by comparing the top two plots in fig .
[ contour ] : the right hand side plot , for @xmath73 and @xmath74 , is asymmetric with respect to changing the sign of @xmath48 , and it exhibits non - zero ballistic conductance at small positive energy .
the gate voltage governing @xmath71 can thus be used efficiently to vary the ballistic conductance between zero and non - zero values . .
four full lines : @xmath75 .
six dashed lines : @xmath76 .
all energies are in units of @xmath21.,width=226 ]
in the regions with @xmath77 we have only one propagating mode . as explained above , each mode
is associated with a single spinor @xmath38 .
the spinor of an electron coming from the left will in principle be written as a linear combination of all the four ( or six ) solutions . however , when @xmath77 all the right moving modes except one are evanescent , i.e. they decay with distance .
therefore , the regions with @xmath77 represent full polarization of the conducting electrons . for the symmetric case , fig .
[ contour ] also compares between three values of the rhombus angle @xmath78 .
interestingly , the square diamond ( @xmath59 ) is not the optimal filter ; increasing @xmath78 broadens the regions with @xmath77 , where we have full polarization of the electrons .
therefore , we present below results for @xmath79 .
looking at each panel in fig .
[ contour ] , we can identify cuts for which there are broad regions with @xmath77 .
for each cut , the spin polarization is given by @xmath80 .
figure [ kapspin ] shows these spin components , as a function of @xmath48 at fixed @xmath81 ( the spins are fully aligned in the @xmath82direction for @xmath83 ) and as a function of @xmath68 at fixed @xmath84 . as one can see , small changes in @xmath48 ( determined by the fermi energy ) or in @xmath68 ( determined by the voltage which fixes the strength of the rashba soi ) can cause jumps in @xmath85 between large positive and negative values . and @xmath86 of the polarized propagating mode and the evanescent inverse decay length ( in units of @xmath87 ) versus @xmath48 at @xmath81 ( left ) and versus @xmath88 at @xmath84 ( right ) .
all plots have @xmath79 .
data are shown only in regions where @xmath77.,title="fig:",width=136 ] and @xmath86 of the polarized propagating mode and the evanescent inverse decay length ( in units of @xmath87 ) versus @xmath48 at @xmath81 ( left ) and versus @xmath88 at @xmath84 ( right ) .
all plots have @xmath79 .
data are shown only in regions where @xmath77.,title="fig:",width=136 ] + and @xmath86 of the polarized propagating mode and the evanescent inverse decay length ( in units of @xmath87 ) versus @xmath48 at @xmath81 ( left ) and versus @xmath88 at @xmath84 ( right ) .
all plots have @xmath79 .
data are shown only in regions where @xmath77.,title="fig:",width=136 ] and @xmath86 of the polarized propagating mode and the evanescent inverse decay length ( in units of @xmath87 ) versus @xmath48 at @xmath81 ( left ) and versus @xmath88 at @xmath84 ( right ) .
all plots have @xmath79 .
data are shown only in regions where @xmath77.,title="fig:",width=136 ] + and @xmath86 of the polarized propagating mode and the evanescent inverse decay length ( in units of @xmath87 ) versus @xmath48 at @xmath81 ( left ) and versus @xmath88 at @xmath84 ( right ) .
all plots have @xmath79 .
data are shown only in regions where @xmath77.,title="fig:",width=136 ] and @xmath86 of the polarized propagating mode and the evanescent inverse decay length ( in units of @xmath87 ) versus @xmath48 at @xmath81 ( left ) and versus @xmath88 at @xmath84 ( right ) .
all plots have @xmath79 .
data are shown only in regions where @xmath77.,title="fig:",width=136 ] + in practical situations , one will not use an infinite chain of diamonds . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , the spin polarization is maintained even for a finite chain , provided we use adiabatic contacts at the exit .
however , this finite chain must be long enough so that the evanescent modes will decay before the electrons come out . in the symmetric case , @xmath62 is found from solving the quadratic equation @xmath89 . for @xmath77 , one of the solutions has @xmath90 , and therefore a real @xmath49 , while the other solution has @xmath91 , and therefore an imaginary @xmath92 .
the bottom panels in fig .
[ kapspin ] show the imaginary part of @xmath49 for these other modes , denoted by @xmath93 .
as one can see , there are broad regions in which @xmath94 , so that a small number of diamonds suffices for the evanescent modes to decay .
interestingly , @xmath93 diverges to infinity as @xmath68 approaches special values , for which the coefficient of @xmath95 in the above quadratic equation approaches zero . writing this equation as @xmath96 , the solutions for small @xmath97
are @xmath98 and @xmath99 . clearly , @xmath93 diverges as @xmath97 approaches zero . using the specific relations which follow eq .
( [ h ] ) , we identify @xmath100 .
it is then easy to check that the condition @xmath101 is equivalent to @xmath102 .
when this condition is obeyed , @xmath103 and @xmath104 have a vanishing eigenvalue , which means that the corresponding eigenvector is completely blocked [ see eq .
( [ ren ] ) ] .
interestingly , ref .
@xcite found similar blocking for finite chains at special values of the parameters .
we now generalize our model , by replacing each edge of a diamond by @xmath105 bonds in series . consider a single ` large ' bond , e.g. the bond @xmath106 in fig .
[ 1 ] . solving the appropriate one - dimensional tight - binding model along this bond ,
we find that the spinor on the site @xmath107 , @xmath108 [ @xmath109 , with @xmath110 and @xmath111 , is given by @xmath112}{\sin(kam)}[u^{\dagger}_{ab}]^{m / m}\psi^{}_a\nonumber\\ & + \frac{\sin(kam)}{\sin(kam)}[u^{}_{ab}]^{(m - m)/m}\psi^{}_b,\label{psiab}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath113 is the same as in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) , @xmath114 is the new lattice constant , and @xmath115 is the wave vector for the one - dimensional solution , related to the energy @xmath48 and to the new elementary hopping energy @xmath21 via @xmath116 .
we next discuss a general node on the network , @xmath117 .
the tight - binding equation at this node is @xmath118^{1/m}\psi^{(uv)}(1),\label{eq7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we assumed that all the ` large ' bonds are equivalent to each other , having the same number @xmath105 of internal bonds , the same lattice constant @xmath97 and the same hopping energy @xmath21 .
substituting eq .
( [ psiab ] ) on the right hand side , it is straightforward to rewrite eq .
( [ eq7 ] ) as @xmath119 with @xcite @xmath120\bigr ) , \label{eu}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath121 is the number of bonds meeting at site @xmath117 .
the generalization to arbitrary bonds is obvious .
equations ( [ neweq ] ) look exactly like our tight - binding equations ( [ eq2 ] ) , provided we replace @xmath122 by @xmath123 .
therefore , we might expect some similarities in the solutions .
the equation for @xmath124 in ( [ eq2 ] ) now has @xmath125 on the left hand side , and therefore the dispersionless modes contain all the solutions of @xmath126 . with @xmath127 ,
this yields @xmath128 .
except for these energies , we again eliminate the side site spinors , restricting ourselves to the symmetric case , @xmath51 . in this case
, we also have @xmath129 .
it is then convenient to separate the common factor @xmath130 from eq .
( [ db ] ) , and rewrite the generalized eq .
( [ ren ] ) in the form @xmath131 with @xmath132 , and with @xmath133 , where now @xmath134 .
the symmetric cases which we described above are characterized by the same matrix @xmath135 .
since all the spin physics described above resulted only from the matrix @xmath135 , which does not depend on the energy @xmath48 , all of that discussion will remain unchanged .
the only effect of adding the internal bonds on each ` large ' bond appears in the new parameter @xmath136 , which is now given by @xmath137 as before , the spectrum is determined by @xmath138 where @xmath139 and @xmath140 . for each value of @xmath49 ,
( [ newspec ] ) determines two values for @xmath136 , which are independent of @xmath105 and of @xmath48 .
we then solve each of these equations for all possible values of @xmath141 , and obtain the energies of the various bands via @xmath116 .
bonds on each ` large ' bond , with @xmath142 .
top : @xmath143 ( left ) , @xmath144 ( right ) .
bottom : @xmath145 .
all energies are in units of @xmath21.,title="fig:",width=136 ] bonds on each ` large ' bond , with @xmath142 .
top : @xmath143 ( left ) , @xmath144 ( right ) .
bottom : @xmath145 .
all energies are in units of @xmath21.,title="fig:",width=136 ] + bonds on each ` large ' bond , with @xmath142 .
top : @xmath143 ( left ) , @xmath144 ( right ) .
bottom : @xmath145 .
all energies are in units of @xmath21.,title="fig:",width=136 ] bonds on each ` large ' bond , with @xmath142 .
top : @xmath143 ( left ) , @xmath144 ( right ) .
bottom : @xmath145 .
all energies are in units of @xmath21.,title="fig:",width=136 ] for the special case @xmath146 , eq .
( [ lam ] ) reduces to @xmath147 .
examples of the spectra for this case and for several values of @xmath105 are shown in fig .
[ newe ] . clearly , the number of bands increases with @xmath105 .
however , the basic qualitative shapes of @xmath148 for all the bands are similar to each other .
thus , we expect that within each band we would reproduce the filtering properties described in sec .
however , the energy scales for each band become narrower as @xmath105 increases .
this narrowing is most pronounced for the lowest band , which always appears below the band of the one - dimensional solutions , @xmath149 . within our tight - binding model ,
this narrow band involves an imaginary value of @xmath115 , @xmath150 , implying very small wave functions in the middle of each ` large ' bond .
this imaginary solution results from the solution of @xmath151 . at large @xmath105 , @xmath136 becomes negligible , and the two bands converge to a single band , with @xmath152 and thus @xmath153 .
the bottom panels in fig .
[ newe ] show the spectrum for @xmath145 .
the right hand side panel zooms on the two lowest bands , demonstrating that these bands maintain their qualitative features even as @xmath105 increases .
the lowest band does indeed narrow down , becoming dispersionless in the limit @xmath154 , where the equation @xmath155 yields the solution @xmath156 , with @xmath157 .
in contrast to our calculations , refs . @xcite and @xcite used a continuum wire model for each ` large ' bond on each diamond .
their solution for the spinor at distance @xmath158 from node @xmath97 on the bond @xmath106 is given by @xmath159}{\sin(kl)}[u^{\dagger}_{ab}]^{x / l}\psi^{}_a\nonumber\\ & + \frac{\sin(kx)}{\sin(kl)}[u^{}_{ab}]^{(l - x)/l}\psi^{}_b.\label{psiabb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the electron on each bond is now free , its energy is given by @xmath160 , and bercioux _ et al .
_ plot @xmath161 . as usual with tight - binding equations , this solution coincides with our tight - binding solution ( [ psiab ] ) in the limit @xmath162 , keeping @xmath163 and @xmath164 .
having found these solutions , refs . @xcite and @xcite
proceed to use the neumann boundary conditions at the nodes : @xmath165 with these conditions , they end up with equations like our ( [ neweq ] ) , but with our @xmath123 replaced by @xmath166 .
thus , they would have @xmath167 , and therefore @xmath168 . these results , with @xmath169 ,
are reproduced in the left panel of fig .
again , the qualitative shape of each band looks similar to ours .
however , this approach can not reproduce the lowest band with imaginary @xmath115 which we found for finite @xmath105 . , right ) , with @xmath142 and with energies in units of @xmath21.,title="fig:",width=136 ] , right ) , with @xmath142 and with energies in units of @xmath21.,title="fig:",width=136 ] + as discuss in ref .
@xcite , there is no way to make the tight - binding model and the continuum models identical for any finite @xmath105 .
however , in the limit @xmath162 one can modify the tight - binding model , by setting a site energy @xmath170 . with this special value , our eq .
( [ lam ] ) becomes @xmath171 , which becomes identical to the expression used in refs .
@xcite and @xcite when @xmath172 .
unfortunately , we know of no good reason to choose this particular value for the site energy in the tight - binding model . the right hand panel in fig .
[ berc ] shows results of the modified tight - binding model for @xmath145 . except for the dispersionless band below the continuum
, we expect these results to approach those in the left hand side panel as @xmath162 .
reference @xcite already compared the results of a chain of diamonds to a single diamond . as also noted in ref .
@xcite , having more loops in series broadens the parameter regions which yield full polarization .
reference @xcite also discussed the conditions for having full filtering on a chain of finite length . here
we have extended that discussion by showing that there exist broad regions with relatively short evanescent decay lengths , so that one can obtain filtering with relatively short chains .
in addition , we have shown that the filtering results are quite robust : in addition to the parameters discussed in ref .
@xcite , the filtering persists upon changing many additional parameters ( e.g. the opening angle of each diamond ) .
we also mention the asymmetry of the spectra in the non - symmetric case , which implies that a large ( positive or negative ) bias voltage between the left and right hand ends of the device can yield different currents in the two directions . | we present several new results , extending our recent proposal of a spin filter based on a tight - binding model for a periodic chain of diamond - like loops [ phys .
rev .
b * 78 * , 125328 ( 2008 ) ] . in this filter ,
the rashba spin - orbit interaction ( which can be tuned by a perpendicular gate voltage ) and the aharonov - bohm flux ( due to a perpendicular magnetic field ) combine to select only one propagating ballistic mode . for this mode ,
the electronic spins are fully polarized along a direction that can be controlled by the electric and magnetic fields and by the electron energy .
all the other modes are evanescent .
generalizing the square diamonds into rhombi with arbitrary opening angles , we find that increasing these angles widens the parameter range for efficient filtering . a different gate voltage on the two sides of each rhombus is found to delocalize the electrons for energies on one side of the band center .
we also compare our tight - binding model with models which use continuous quantum networks of one - dimensional wires , and find coincidence only when one chooses particular site energies at the nodes of the network . |
ngc3801 is a nearby e / s0 galaxy at a distance of @xmath147.9 mpc , with the body of the galaxy being crossed by two main dust features ( heckman et al .
1986 ; verdoes kleijn et al .
a warped dust lane lies along the optical minor axis while patchy dust filaments are seen on the eastern and western halves of the galaxy . at brightness levels
@xmath2@xmath123@xmath324 mag arcsec@xmath4 , the galaxy shows a hysteresis loop like structure while at even fainter levels , a boxy isophotal structure is seen ( heckman et al .
it hosts a small radio galaxy with an angular size of @xmath150 arcsec ( 11 kpc ) , whose jet axis is almost orthogonal to the rotation axis of the stellar component or orthogonal to the minor - axis dust lane ( heckman et al .
millimetre - wave observations have helped identify a radio core and clumps of co(1@xmath30 ) emission suggesting a r@xmath12 kpc circum - nuclear rotating gas disk orthogonal to stellar rotation and perpendicular to the radio jet ( das et al .
_ chandra _ observations reveal shock - heated shells of hot gas surrounding the radio lobes ( croston , kraft , & hardcastle 2007 ) .
hi observations with the arecibo telescope show gas in both emission and absorption , but higher resolution observations are required to determine its distribution and kinematics ( heckman et al . 1983 ) .
we present the first ever imaging study in hi , dust , uv and pa@xmath5 emission .
figure 1 shows the radio continuum image superimposed on an optical dss blue - band image in the left panel and the total intensity hi image superimposed on the 8.0 @xmath0 m dust / pah emission image from the _ spitzer _ on the right panel .
the dust emission shows a prominent linear feature nearly orthogonal to the jet in the central region ( r@xmath12 kpc ) .
we found that both the 8.0 @xmath0 m dust / pah emission and uv emission from _ galex _ show similar @xmath130 kpc wide s - shaped structure , representing young massive star formation in it .
our hi - emission study with the vla shows emission blobs on the eastern ( mostly red - shifted ) and western ( blue - shifted ) sides , roughly coinciding with the tails of the s - shaped structure ( figure 1 , right panel ) .
these hi results suggest a rotating gas disk ( v@xmath6@xmath1280 km s@xmath7 ) , with velocities nearly twice than that of the stars ( cf .
heckman et al . 1985 ) .
in addition , broad , faint , blue - shifted absorption wing and an hi absorption clump associated with the shocked shell around the eastern lobe are seen , possibly due to jet - driven outflow . due to its similarity with kinematically decoupled cores and other properties , we propose that a merger between a gas - rich spiral galaxy and an elliptical galaxy has triggered its agn activity and has shaped its stellar , gaseous and radio - jet structures .
detailed stellar population synthesis studies to understand its time evolution are in progress .
croston , j. h. , kraft , r. p. , & hardcastle , m. j. 2007 , apj , 660 , 191 das m. et al .
2005 , apj , 629 , 757 heckman , t. m. , balick , b. , van breugel , w. j. m. , & miley , g. k. 1983 , aj , 88 , 583 heckman , t. m. , illingworth , g. d. , miley , g. k. , & van breugel , w. j. m. 1985 , apj , 299 , 41 heckman , t. m. et al .
1986 , apj , 311 , 526 verdoes kleijn , g. a. , baum , s. a. , de zeeuw , p. t. , & odea , c. p. 1999 , aj , 118 , 2592 | we present preliminary results from a multi - wavelength study of a merger candidate , ngc3801 , hosting a young fr i radio galaxy , with a z - shaped structure .
analysing archival data from the vla , we find two hi emission blobs on either side of the host galaxy , suggesting a 30 kpc sized rotating gas disk aligned with stellar rotation , but rotating significantly faster than the stars .
broad , faint , blue - shifted absorption wing and an hi absorption clump associated with the shocked shell around the eastern lobe are also seen , possibly due to an jet - driven outflow . while 8.0 @xmath0 m dust and pah emission , from _
spitzer _ and near and far uv emission from _ galex _ is seen on a large scale in an s - shape , partially coinciding with the hi emission blobs , it reveals a @xmath12 kpc radius ring - like , dusty , starforming structure in the nuclear region , orthogonal to the radio jet axis .
its similarities with kinematically decoupled core galaxies and other evidences have been argued for a merger origin of this young , bent jet radio galaxy . |
non - photonic single electron data @xcite , which present an indirect probe of heavy quark energy loss , have significantly challenged the underlying assumptions of jet tomography theory .
a much larger suppression of electrons than predicted @xcite was observed in the @xmath2 gev region . ``
these data falsify the assumption that heavy quark quenching is dominated by [ pqcd based ] radiative energy loss when the bulk [ weakly coupled ] qcd matter parton density is constrained by the observed dn / dy @xmath3 1000 rapidity density of produced hadrons . ''
@xcite whdg @xcite revisited the assumption that pqcd collisional energy loss is negligible compared to radiative energy loss @xcite . as argued there , and references therein , `` the elastic component of the energy loss can not be neglected when considering pqcd jet quenching . '' as shown in whdg and elsewhere @xcite , the computationally expensive integrations over the geometry of the qgp can not be reduced to a simple ` average length ' prescription . indeed , this computation time is essential to produce radiative + collisional energy loss calculations consistent with the pion data .
there are large theoretical uncertainties in the whdg results @xcite . very significant to the electron prediction
is the uncertainty in the charm and bottom cross - sections .
there are also theoretical uncertainties in the energy loss mechanisms . here
, two aspects of the collisional energy loss will be examined with the aim of improving the energy loss model .
similar to radiative energy loss , the fluctuations of collisional energy loss around the mean affect the quenching of the quark spectra .
collisional fluctuations are often modelled in a fokker - planck formalism , characterized by two numbers or functions : drag and diffusion .
whdg implemented an approximation to this scheme applicable for small energy loss by giving the collisional loss a gaussian width around the mean , with @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the mean energy loss given by a leading log calculation .
the drag - diffusion method is essentially a continuum approximation to a discrete process . a high energy jet traversing
the qgp will undergo only a small number of collisions . in the gyulassy - wang model ,
the expected mean free path of a quark is @xmath6fm , so there is a very significant surface region in which the fluctuations will differ greatly from those given by the continuum approximation .
it is therefore necessary to look at the fluctuations per collision and in the number of collisions . a simple model to investigate this is to model the medium as _ initially _ static objects which will then recoil upon collision , model the interaction between jet and medium using the full htl medium modified propagator .
this gives the probability of longitudinal momentum loss : @xmath7 \nonumber \\
c_l = 2+\frac{1}{e}(\omega + \vec{v}.\vec{q})(2 - \frac{\omega}{m})\,,\ , c_t = \left ( \frac{-\omega}{m}\right)\left ( v^2 - ( \vec{v}.\hat{\vec{q}})^2 \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] this single collision distribution is then poisson convoluted to give the distribution for a finite number of expected collisions : @xmath8 the mass of the medium particle is tuned to give an average energy loss similar to that of the bt and tg leading log calculations ( @xmath9gev - although here we are not interested in the average energy loss per se ) . in fig .
[ fig : pofeps ] , the probabiliy of fractional energy loss in one collision is shown , similar to a @xmath10 bjorken collisional style model , with screening at small t - values ( shown in the right pane of fig .
[ fig : pofeps ] ) .
figure [ fig : collfluct ] illustrates the distributions in energy loss for a finite number of collisions for bottom and light quark jets .
the results for charm quarks are qualitatively similar to those for light quarks . for a large number of collisions ( eg average number of collisions @xmath11 , l@xmath12fm ) ,
the distributions are roughly symmetric and somewhat similar to the simple whdg gaussian .
this is expected from the central limit theorem .
the @xmath13 values extracted from these distributions are similar , with @xmath14 and the gaussian approximation only differing by @xmath15 .
surprisingly , a similar result for the @xmath13 values is found for @xmath16 collisions for bottom quarks .
the large change arrives for light quarks . for both @xmath17 collisions ,
the gaussian approximation gives a very different distribution for the fluctuations and a very different @xmath13 value .
the gaussian approximation overpredicts the @xmath13 suppression by @xmath18 , which is around a 30% effect for @xmath19 collisions .
this can not be neglected .
a full treatment of the finite number of collisions will reduce the quenching due to elastic energy loss compared to the treatment in whdg .
this conclusion is also applicable to other uses of fokker - planck / langevin formalisms that use a continuum description of the collisional process .
the @xmath13 predictions for bottom quarks are likely only marginally affected , those for light quarks most affected .
in @xcite , the change of the fixed qcd coupling @xmath20 from 0.3 to 0.4 was seen to significantly change the @xmath13 precitions from the whdg model .
there has been much recent work on the effect of a running coupling on the collisional energy loss @xcite ( ie @xmath21 ) . here
, we revisit the collisional energy loss in a similar manner to @xcite , looking at a simple bjorken - style estimate @xcite .
bjorken s estimate for the collisional energy loss is : @xmath22 in @xcite , the running coupling version for very high jet energies is given as : @xmath23 although this neglects the finite energy kinematic bound on the jet . adding in this bound to this calculation gives @xmath24 which is similar in structure to the original fixed coupling estimate .
a numerical comparison of equations [ eqnpesh1],[eqnpesh2],[eqnpesh3 ] is shown in fig .
[ fig : runalpha ] . for reasonable temperatures ,
@xmath25gev , all results are of a similar order of magnitude . for reasonable energies , no qualitatively new behavior is seen ( although , as found in @xcite , the @xmath26 behavior is new , but this affects much higher energies than those of interest at rhic or even lhc ) . when the kinematic bounds are taken into account ,
the result for the average energy loss including running coupling is often larger than the fixed @xmath1 result used in @xcite .
however , the numerical result is very sensitive to the input parameters used , illustrated in the middle and right panes of fig .
[ fig : runalpha ] for changing the prescription for @xmath27 from that used in @xcite to that from @xcite .
it has been argued previously `` that radiative and elastic average energy losses for heavy quarks were in fact comparable over a very wide kinematic range''@xcite , and even `` e @xmath28 10 gev light and charm quark jets have elastic energy losses smaller but of the same order of magnitude as the inelastic losses''@xcite .
hence , collisional energy loss can not be neglected when considering jet quenching of high energy jets in the qgp at either rhic or lhc .
a simple model combining collisional and radiative energy losses significantly reduces the discrepancy between the predictions and data .
two possible improvements to the whdg model have been examined here .
the inclusion of a finite number of collisions is seen to reduce the effect of the collisional energy loss on the quenching of gluons , light and charm quarks , but not to significantly affect the bottom quark @xmath13 .
opposite to this effect , including a running qcd coupling increases the energy loss by up to a factor of @xmath29 .
the combination of these two affects , along with other large uncertainties in the prediction for electron @xmath13 such as the ratio of charm to bottom total cross - sections , hints at the possibility that both the pion and electron @xmath13s may both be within range of purely perturbative calculations .
10 s. s. adler _ et al . _
[ phenix collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 032301 ( 2006 ) x. dong , aip conf .
proc . * 828 * , 24 ( 2006 ) [ nucl .
a * 774 * , 343 ( 2006 ) ] [ arxiv : nucl - ex/0509038 ] .
m. djordjevic , m. gyulassy , r. vogt and s. wicks , phys .
b * 632 * , 81 ( 2006 ) [ nucl - th/0507019 ] .
s. wicks , w. horowitz , m. djordjevic and m. gyulassy , nucl . phys .
a * 784 * , 426 ( 2007 ) .
m. gyulassy , p. levai and i. vitev , nucl .
b * 594 * , 371 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0006010 ] .
m. djordjevic and m. gyulassy , nucl .
a * 733 * , 265 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0310076 ] .
t. renk and k. j. eskola , [ hep - ph/0610059 ] .
s. wicks , w. horowitz , m. djordjevic and m. gyulassy , nucl . phys .
a * 783 * , 493 ( 2007 ) .
a. peshier , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 212301 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0605294 ] .
j. braun and h. j. pirner , arxiv : hep - ph/0610331 .
j. d. bjorken , fermilab - pub-82 - 059-thy | with the qgp opacity computed perturbatively and with the global entropy constraints imposed by the observed @xmath0 , radiative energy loss alone can not account for the observed suppression of single non - photonic electrons .
collisional energy loss is comparable in magnitude to radiative loss for both light and heavy jets .
two aspects that significantly affect the collisional energy loss are examined : the role of fluctuations , and the effect of introducing a running qcd coupling as opposed to the fixed @xmath1 used previously . |
holography is a new concept of the superstring theory based on the duality between gauge and supergravity theories , proposed by maldacena in 1997.@xcite the superstring theory with conformal and lorentz invariance has ten - dimensional space - time to avoid anomalies .
its elemental degrees of freedom are one - dimensional open or closed strings
. the fluctuation modes of these strings are expected to give the elementary particle degrees of freedom as in the standard model .
one can also find a soliton of strings as the ( @xmath2 + 1)-dimensional membrane composed by the condensed strings , called @xmath3-brane.@xcite in particular , @xmath3-brane has two important aspects as follows .
first , a ( @xmath2 + 1)-dimensional gauge theory appears _ on _ @xmath3-brane . here , an open string with the two edges on the @xmath3-brane has ten independent fluctuation modes ; scalar fields @xmath4 and the other vector - like fields @xmath5 .
@xmath5 have an index @xmath6 on @xmath3-brane extending to ( @xmath2 + 1)-dimensional space - time , and @xmath7 fields can be regarded as gauge fields on the @xmath3-brane . in this sense ,
( @xmath2 + 1)-dimensional gauge theory appears _ on _ @xmath3-brane .
second , @xmath8(@xmath2+_1_)+1@xmath9-dimensional supergravity appears _ around _ the @xmath3-brane .
in fact , @xmath3-brane is found to be a strong gravitational system in ten - dimensional space - time as a black hole or a black brane,@xcite giving nontrivial curvatures around it . due to the geometrical symmetry
, the angle coordinates around @xmath3-brane become trivial and can be integrated out in the action of @xmath3-brane . then , there eventually remains just one radial dimension with nontrivial curvature , indicating the existence of gravity . in this sense ,
@xmath8(@xmath2+_1_)+1@xmath9-dimensional supergravity appears _ around
_ @xmath3-brane .
( the italic `` _ 1 _ '' denotes the radial dimension around @xmath3-brane . )
now we discuss the holography .
holography indicates the equivalence between the ( @xmath2 + 1)-dimensional gauge theory without gravity _ on _ @xmath3-brane and the @xmath8(@xmath2+_1_)+1@xmath9-dimensional supergravity _ around _ @xmath3-brane .
dimensions are different with each other to give the concept of holography . in particular , the ( @xmath2 + 1)-dimensional gauge theory projected on the surface of @xmath3-brane is often called as the `` hologram '' of the @xmath8(@xmath2+_1_)+1@xmath9-dimensional supergravity . the most essential property of holography is the existence of strong - weak duality ( s - duality ) between the gauge theory and the supergravity : couplings are transversely related with each other . therefore , if one wants to analyze the non - perturbative ( strong - coupling ) aspects of one side , one can attack from the other dual side only with the tree - level ( weak - coupling ) calculations .
consequently , this new concept of holography is expected to be a powerful tool for both sides of the gauge theory in hadron physics and the gravitational theory in astrophysics.@xcite
if one succeeds in constructing qcd with quarks and gluons on a special configuration of @xmath1-branes , one can attack the non - perturbative aspects of qcd from the tree - level dual supergravity side .
this is the strategy of holographic qcd . in 2005 ,
sakai and sugimoto succeeded in constructing massless qcd on @xmath0 multi-@xmath1-brane system.@xcite @xmath10-brane has opposite chirality relative to @xmath11-brane to introduce the concept of chiral symmetry in this model .
then , by using the concept of holography , non - perturbative aspects of massless qcd can be analyzed by the tree - level calculation in the dual @xmath8(4+_1_)+1@xmath9-dimensional supergravity side , called holographic qcd . in fact
, this theory describes mesons as color - singlet low - energy objects , and reproduces meson mass spectra in coincidence with experimental data , and also other many traditional meson phenomenologies like vector - meson dominance , ksrf relation , gsw model and so on.@xcite in this sense , holographic qcd can be regarded as the `` unified meson theory '' based on qcd . in this construction , however , @xmath8(4+_1_)+1@xmath9-dimensional classical supergravity is dual with large-@xmath12 qcd . then , as a general property of large-@xmath12 qcd , another important color - singlet objects as _ baryons _ do not directly appear in the large-@xmath12 limit.@xcite in fact , it is non - trivial to describe baryons in the large-@xmath12 holographic qcd .
in order to describe baryons in holographic qcd , we introduce the concept of chiral solitons ( skyrmions ) in the large-@xmath12 holographic model .
the skyrme model is first proposed in 1961,@xcite describing a baryon as a topological chiral soliton of the pion field , which is the nambu - goldstone boson relating to spontaneous chiral - symmetry breaking . here
, the stability of the chiral soliton is known to be sensitive to the four - derivative terms of pion fields .
chiral and lorentz symmetries allows three candidates as four - derivative terms : @xmath13 ^ 2,\hspace{4mm}{\rm tr}\{l_\mu , l_\nu\}^2,\hspace{4 mm } { \rm tr}(\partial_\mu l_\nu)^2 , \label{deri1}\ ] ] where @xmath14 is one - form of pion fields , @xmath15 . the first term in eq.([deri1 ] )
is the skyrme term .
the other two candidates in eq.([deri1 ] ) are known to give instability of the skyrmion,@xcite but these two can not be excluded by the symmetry arguments . as a remarkable fact , in the leading order of holographic qcd ,
only the skyrme term in eq.([deri1 ] ) appears .
this can be understood from the fact that the leading order of the effective action ( dbi action ) of @xmath11-brane includes only `` two time - derivatives '' at most , which gives a severe restriction on the possible terms in the effective meson theory .
thus , the topological picture for baryons is derived from qcd and seems to be justified ingeniously in this framework with the superstring theory .
we investigate the hedgehog configuration for pion fields @xmath16 and @xmath17 meson fields @xmath18 in the meson effective action derived from holographic qcd as @xmath19 @xmath20 ( @xmath21 ) is a dimensionless function with boundary conditions @xmath22 and @xmath23 , giving topological charge equal to unity as a unit baryon number . with the hedgehog configuration ansatz ( [ wytp ] ) , we uniqeuly derive the energy density @xmath24 $ ] for the brane - induced skyrmion including interaction terms of pions and @xmath17 mesons from holographic qcd as follows : @xmath25 = \frac{f_\pi^2}{4}{\left [ } 2{\left ( } r^2 f^{'2}+2\sin^2f { \right ) } { \right ] } + \frac{1}{32e^2}{\left [ } 16 \sin^2f { \left ( } 2 f^{'2}+\frac{\sin^2f}{r^2}{\right ) } { \right ] } \nonumber\\ & + & \frac{1}{2 } { \left [ } 8{\left\ { } \newcommand{\rtk } { \right\ } } 3\tilde{g}^2 + 2 r \tilde{g}(\tilde{g}^ { ' } ) + r^2\tilde{g}^{'2}\rtk { \right ] } + m_{\rho}^2 { \left [ } 4 r^2 \tilde{g}^2 { \right ] } - g_{3\rho } { \left [ } 16 r \tilde{g}^3 { \right ] } + \frac{1}{2}g_{4\rho } { \left [ } 16 r^2 \tilde{g}^4 { \right ] } \nonumber\\ & + & g_1 { \left [ } 16 { \left\ { } \newcommand{\rtk } { \right\ } } f^{'}\sin f \cdot{\left ( } \tilde{g}+ r \tilde{g}^{'}{\right)}+\sin^2f\cdot\tilde{g}/r\rtk { \right ] } - g_2 { \left [ } 16 \sin^2f\cdot\tilde{g}^2 { \right ] } \nonumber\\ & - & g_3 { \left [ } 16 \sin^2f\cdot{\left ( } 1-\cos f{\right)}\tilde{g}/r { \right ] } - g_4 { \left [ } 16 { \left ( } 1-\cos f{\right)}\tilde{g}^2 { \right ] } + g_5 { \left [ } 16 r { \left ( } 1-\cos f { \right)}\tilde{g}^3 { \right ] } \nonumber\\ & + & g_6 { \left [ } 16 r^2 f^{'2}\tilde{g}^2 { \right ] } + g_7 { \left [ } 8 { \left ( } 1-\cos f{\right)}^2\tilde{g}^2 { \right ] } . \label{energy_dense_an}\end{aligned}\ ] ] all the coupling constants ( @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 ) in eq.([energy_dense_an ] ) are uniquely determined by just two experimental inputs as @xmath30 and @xmath31 , which is a remarkable consequence of holographic framework .
we numerically obtain the stable chiral soliton solution as a baryon in holographic qcd , which basically supports the `` skyrme soliton picture '' for baryons with corrections by @xmath17 mesons .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the total energy density of a baryon and each contribution of @xmath17 meson interaction terms derived from holographic qcd . this result indicates the active contribution of @xmath17 mesons in the deeper interior region of baryons , and such a `` @xmath17 mesonic parton '' in the soliton may lead to a new picture for baryons from holographic framework
we have performed the first study of baryons as chiral solitons in holographic qcd with @xmath0 multi-@xmath1-brane system.@xcite we have found that the holographic qcd has a stable hedgehog soliton solution as a baryon , which is basically described as the skyrme soliton of pions including @xmath17 mesons in the interior region . just after our study , similar studies of baryons were done using instantons in the five - dimensional gauge theory in holographic framework.@xcite it is also interesting to compare chiral solitonic baryons in the holographic qcd with other - type construction of stringy hadrons in a holographic framework.@xcite from more general point of view , `` holography '' is a powerful concept which links qcd - hadron physics and blackhole - astrophysics by virtue of its s - duality .
large applications of this new concept are much expected in near future .
0 j. m. maldacena , _ adv .
* 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) .
j. polchinski , _ phys .
* 75 * , 4724 ( 1995 ) .
e. witten , _ adv .
_ * 2 * , 505 ( 1998 ) .
s. mukherji and s. s. pal , _ jhep _ * 0205 * , 026 ( 2002 ) . t. sakai and s. sugimoto , _ prog .
phys . _ * 113 * , 843 ( 2005 ) ; * 114 * , 1083 ( 2005 ) .
g. t hooft , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b 72 * , 461 ( 1974 ) ; * b 75 * , 461 ( 1974 ) .
t. h. r. skyrme , _ proc .
r. soc . a _ * 260 * , 127 ( 1961 ) ; * 262 * , 273 ( 1961 ) .
i. zahed and g. e. brown , _ phys .
rep . _ * 142 * , 1 ( 1986 ) .
k. nawa , h. suganuma and t. kojo , _ phys
d _ * 75 * , 086003 ( 2007 ) .
k. nawa , h. suganuma and t. kojo , _ prog .
suppl . _ * 168 * , 231 ( 2007 ) .
d. k. hong , m. rho , h .- u .
yi , _ phys .
d _ * 76 * , 061901 ( 2007 ) .
h. hata , t. sakai , s. sugimoto and s. yamato , _ prog .
phys . _ * 117 * , 1157 ( 2007 ) . | we perform the first study of baryons in holographic qcd with @xmath0 multi-@xmath1-brane system in type iia superstring theory .
the baryon is described as a chiral soliton solution in the four - dimensional meson effective action derived from holographic qcd .
we also present a brief review of the holographic model from the viewpoints of recent hadron physics and qcd phenomenologies . |
the allen brain atlas ( aba , @xcite ) put neuroanatomy on a genetic basis by releasing voxelized , _ in situ _ hybridization data for the expression of the entire genome in the mouse brain ( ) .
these data were co - registered to the allen reference atlas of the mouse brain ( ara , @xcite ) .
about 4,000 genes of special neurobiological interest were proritized . for these genes
an entire brain was sliced coronally and processed ( giving rise to the coronal aba ) . for the rest of the genome
the brain was sliced sagitally , and only the left hemisphere was processed ( giving rise to the sagittal aba ) .
+ from a computational viewpoint , gene - expression data from the the aba can be studied collectively , thousands of genes at a time . indeed
the collective behaviour of gene - expression data is crucial for the analysis of @xcite , in which the brain - wide correlation between the aba and cell - type - specific microarray data was studied .
these microarray data characterize the transcriptome of @xmath0 different cell types , microdissected from the mouse brain , and collated in @xcite .
however , for a given cell characterized in this way , it is not known where other cells of the same type are located in the brain .
a linear model was proposed in @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , and used to estimate the region - specificity of cell types by linear regression with positivity constraint .
the model was fitted using the coronal aba only , which allowed to obtain brain - wide results . however
, this restriction implies that only one ish expression profile per gene was used to fit the model .
this poses the problem of the error bars on the results of the model .
since all the ish data in the aba were co - registered to the voxelized ara , so that data for the sagittal and coronal atlas can be treated computationally in the same way .
however , the aba does not specify from which cell type(s ) the expression of each gene comes . + * gene expression energies from the allen brain atlas .
* in the aba , the adult mouse brain is partitioned into @xmath1 cubic voxels of side 200 microns , to which ish data are registered @xcite for thousands of genes . for computational purposes , these gene - expression data can be arranged into a voxel - by - gene matrix . for a cubic labeled @xmath2 , the _ expression energy _
@xcite of the gene @xmath3 is a weighted sum of the greyscale - value intensities evaluated at the pixels intersecting the voxel : @xmath4 the analysis of @xcite is restricted to digitized image series from the coronal aba , for which the entire mouse brain was processed in the aba pipeline ( whereas only the left hemisphere was processed for the sagittal atlas ) .
+ * cell - type - specific transcriptomes and density profiles . * on the other hand , the cell - type - specific microarray reads collated in @xcite ( for @xmath5 different cell - type - specific samples studied in @xcite ) can be arranged in a type - by - gene matrix denoted by @xmath6 , such that @xmath7 and the columns are arranged in the same order as in the matrix @xmath8 of expression energies defined in eq .
[ expressionenergy ] .
+ we proposed the following linear model in @xcite for a voxel - based gene - expression atlas in terms of the transcriptome profiles of individual cell types and their spatial densities : @xmath9 where the index @xmath10 denotes labels cell type , and @xmath11 denotes its ( unknown ) density at voxel labeled @xmath2 .
the values of the cell - type - specific density profiles were computed in @xcite by minimizing the value of the residual term over all the ( positive ) density profiles , which amounts to solving a quadratic optimization problem ( with positivity constraint ) at each voxel .
these computations can be reproduced on a desktop computer using the matlab toolbox ( bgea ) @xcite . for other applications of the toolbox see @xcite ( marker genes of brain regions ) , @xcite for co - expression properties of some autism - related genes , and @xcite for computations of stereotactic coordinates ) .
the optimization procedure in our model is deterministic . on the other hand ,
decomposing the density of a cell type into the sum of its mean and gaussian noise is a difficult statistics problem ( see @xcite ) .
some error estimates on the value of @xmath11 were obained in @xcite using sub - sampling techniques ( i.e. sub - sampling the data repeatedly by keeping only a random 10% of the coronal aba ) .
this induced a ranking of the cell types based on the stability of the results against sub - sampling .
however , the 10 % fraction is arbitrary ( even though it is close to the fraction of the genome covered by our coronal data set ) .
+ , defined in eq .
[ meanfittingdef ] , for medium spiny neurons , labeled @xmath12 in our data set .
the restriction to the left hemisphere comes from the use we made of sagittal image series , which cover the left hemisphere only.,scaledwidth=99.0% ] in the present work we simulated the variability of the spatial density of cell types by integrating the digitized sagittal image series into the data set . for gene labeled @xmath3 ,
the aba provides @xmath13 expression profiles , where @xmath13 is the number of image series in the aba for this gene .
hence , instead of just one voxel - by - gene matrix , the aba gives rise to a family of @xmath14 voxel - by - gene matrices , with voxels belonging to the left hemisphere .
a quantity computed from the coronal aba can be recomputed from any of these matrices , thereby inducing a distribution for this quantity .
this is a finite but prohibitively large number of computations , so we took a monte carlo approach based on @xmath15 random choices of images series , described by the following pseudo - code : + the larger @xmath15 is , the more precise the estimates for the distribution of the spatial density of cell types will be .
the only price we have to pay for th e integration of the sagittal aba is the restriction of the results to the left hemisphere in step 2 of the pseudo - code .
the average density across random draws of image series for cell type labeled @xmath10 reads : @xmath16}(v ) .
\label{meanfittingdef}\ ] ] ) , for medium spiny neurons , labeled @xmath12 , based on @xmath17 random draws .
the right - most peak , corresponding to the striatum , is well - decoupled from the others , furthermore the other peaks are all centered close to zero ( making most of them almost invisible ) .
medium spiny neurons have @xmath18 percent of their densities supported in the striatum , without any region gathering more than 5 percent of the signal in any of the random draws.,scaledwidth=110.0% ] a heat map of this average for medium spiny neurons ( extracted from the striatum ) is presented on fig .
[ meanfittings ] .
it is optically very similar to the ( left ) striatum , which allows the model to predict that medium spiny neurons are specific to the striatum ( which confirms prior neurobiological knowledge and therefore serves as a proof of concept for the model ) .
+ to compare the results to classical neuroanatomy , we can group the voxels by region according to the ara . since the number of cells of a given type in an extensive quantity , we compute the fraction of the total density contributed by a given brain region denoted by @xmath19
( see the legend of fig .
[ fittingdistrs ] for a list of possible values of @xmath19 ) : @xmath20}(t ) = \frac{1}{\sum_{v\in\mathrm{left\;hemisphere}}\rho_{[i],t}(v ) } \sum_{v\in v_r } \rho_{t,[i]}(v ) .
\label{fittingdistrdef}\ ] ] we can plot the distribution of these @xmath15 values for a given cell type and all brain regions ( see fig . [ meanfittings ] for medium spiny neurons , which gives rise to the best - decoupled right - most peak in the distribution of simulated densities ) .
moreover , we estimated the densities of the contribution of each region in the coarsest version of the ara to the total density of each cell type in the data set .
for most cell types , this confirms the ranking of cell types by stability obtained in @xcite , but based on error bars obtained from the same set of genes in every fitting of the model ( see the accompanying preprint @xcite for exhaustive results for all cell types in the panel ) .
the most stable results against sub - sampling tend to correspond to cell types for which the anatomical distribution of results is more peaked .
the present analysis can be repeated when the panel of cell - type - specific microarray expands .
9 p. grange , j.w .
bohland , b.w .
okaty , k. sugino .
h. bokil , s.b .
nelson , l. ng , m. hawrylycz and p.p .
mitra , _ cell - type based model explaining coexpression patterns of genes in the brain _ , proceedings of the national academy of sciences 2014 111 ( 14 ) 53975402 .
p. grange , j.w .
bohland , b.w .
okaty , k. sugino .
h. bokil , s.b .
nelson , l. ng , m. hawrylycz and p.p .
mitra , _ cell - type - specific transcriptomes and the allen atlas ( ii ) : discussion of the linear model of brain - wide densities of cell types _ , .
y. ko , s.a .
ament , j.a .
eddy , j. caballero , j.c .
earls , l. hood and n.d . price ( 2013 ) ,
_ cell - type - specific genes show striking and distinct patterns of spatial expression in the mouse brain _ , proceedings of the national academy of sciences , 110 ( 8) , 30953100 .
tan , l. french and p. pavlidis ( 2013 ) , _ neuron - enriched gene expression patterns are regionally anti - correlated with oligodendrocyte - enriched patterns in the adult mouse and human brain , _ frontiers in neuroscience , 7 . p. grange , m. hawrylycz and p.p .
mitra ( 2013 ) , _ computational neuroanatomy and co - expression of genes in the adult mouse brain , analysis tools for the allen brain atlas _ , quantitative biology , 1(1 ) : 91100 .
( doi ) 10.1007/s40484 - 013 - 0011 - 5 .
p. grange and p.p .
mitra ( 2012 ) , _ computational neuroanatomy and gene expression : optimal sets of marker genes for brain regions _ , ieee , in ciss 2012 , 46th annual conference on information science and systems ( princeton ) . | the allen brain atlas ( aba ) of the adult mouse consists of digitized expression profiles of thousands of genes in the mouse brain , co - registered to a common three - dimensional template ( the allen reference atlas ) .
this brain - wide , genome - wide data set has triggered a renaissance in neuroanatomy .
its voxelized version ( with cubic voxels of side 200 microns ) can be analyzed on a desktop computer using matlab .
on the other hand , brain cells exhibit a great phenotypic diversity ( in terms of size , shape and electrophysiological activity ) , which has inspired the names of some well - studied cell types , such as granule cells and medium spiny neurons .
however , no exhaustive taxonomy of brain cells is available .
a genetic classification of brain cells is under way , and some cell types have been characterized by their transcriptome profiles .
however , given a cell type characterized by its transcriptome , it is not clear where else in the brain similar cells can be found .
the aba can been used to solve this region - specificity problem in a data - driven way : rewriting the brain - wide expression profiles of all genes in the atlas as a sum of cell - type - specific transcriptome profiles is equivalent to solving a quadratic optimization problem at each voxel in the brain .
however , the estimated brain - wide densities of 64 cell types published recently were based on one series of co - registered coronal _ in situ _ hybridization ( ish ) images per gene , whereas the online aba contains several image series per gene , including sagittal ones . in the presented work ,
we simulate the variability of cell - type densities in a monte carlo way by repeatedly drawing a random image series for each gene and solving optimization problems .
this yields error bars on the region - specificity of cell types . + _ prepared for the international conference on mathematical modeling in physical sciences , 5th-8th june 2015 , mykonos island , greece . _ |
non - magnetic spin control is among the most rapidly developing topics of modern semiconductor spin physics .
substantial progress has been achieved by application of the pump - probe technique to bulk semiconductors , quantum wells and quantum dots , where spins are created , manipulated and detected by optical pulses @xcite .
singly charged quantum dot structures are of particular interest . in these systems
discrete energy spectrum of charge carriers makes resonant optical excitation possible , which substantially enhances spin - photon coupling . at the same time , quenching the orbital motion due to size quantization suppresses significantly the spin - orbit induced spin decoherence making it possible to achieve long spin lifetimes of single electrons or holes .
in addition to robust optical initialization of electron spin by polarized light , spin polarization readout @xcite , and ultrafast spin rotation by light @xcite , in quantum dot ensembles a number of prominent effects , such as spin precession mode - locking and nuclei - induced frequency focussing have been demonstrated @xcite , see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite for review .
the spin - photon interfacing and optical spin control has also been demonstrated for single quantum dots @xcite .
the charge carrier spin state is , as a rule , detected by the faraday or kerr rotation . typically , the faraday rotation angle was on the order of @xmath0 degrees in refs .
the efficiency of spin - photon interaction can be strongly enhanced by placing the active system into a microcavity , where the electric field and , accordingly , faraday / kerr rotation are accumulated due to multiple passages of light between the mirrors @xcite .
it makes possible to reach giant spin - faraday effect in bulk semiconductor @xcite , and even to detect a host - lattice nuclei - induced faraday rotation @xcite . on a single spin level embedding a quantum dot qd into a microcavity
has enabled to achieve a resident hole spin control @xcite and detect fluctuations of a single spin @xcite .
very recently , a macroscopic rotation of photon polarization reaching several degrees has been observed in a single qd deterministically coupled to a photonic mode of a micropillar cavity demonstrating efficient spin - photon coupling @xcite . in quantum - dot / microcavity structures two regimes of light - matter interaction , namely , weak and strong coupling ,
are known @xcite . in the weak coupling regime ,
realized in above works @xcite , the dampings of cavity mode and trion exceed their coupling constant , while in the strong coupling regime the dampings are small as compared with the coupling constant , see ref .
@xcite for rigorous criterion , and the coherent energy transfer between the photon and material excitation becomes possible .
the strong coupling regime has been already achieved for neutral qds placed in various types of microcavities @xcite , see ref .
@xcite for review . the strong coupling between a two - level quantum system and a single electromagnetic mode in a zero - dimensional cavity results in a formation of the jaynescummings ladder of coupled states @xcite .
the rung splitting in this ladder is dependent on the number of photon quanta in the cavity .
the spectroscopic manifestation of this dependence carries a direct signature of the quantization of light and reveals non - semiclassical properties of the intracavity field as observed in atomic systems @xcite , superconducting circuits @xcite , and in microcavities with neutral quantum dots , where zero - dimensional exciton provides the two - level atom - like nonlinearity @xcite .
fundamental limitations on realization of the strong coupling regime for the charged qds embedded into microcavities are absent @xcite : the light - matter interaction is accompanied by generation of trions , three particle fermionic complexes with two electrons in the spin singlet state and a hole with an unpaired spin in case of the resident electron ( @xmath1 trion ) or with two holes and unpaired electron in case of the resident hole ( @xmath2 trion ) .
this brings spin degree of freedom into the jaynes - cummings ladder and calls for a theory of the optical control of a single spin in the qd cavity quantum - electrodynamics structure operating in the strong coupling regime .
such a theory is developed in the present paper .
we demonstrate a possibility to initialize the electron spin by a single circularly polarized pulse in the transverse magnetic field .
it is also shown that the train of pulses leads to a complete spin orientation .
moreover , we predict an efficient spin rotation by the circularly polarized control pulse and tens of degrees for the spin - kerr and faraday rotation angles of the probe pulse .
we consider a zero - dimensional microcavity with an embedded negatively charged qd .
we denote the growth axis as @xmath3 axis , and assume that the light is incident along @xmath3 .
the scheme of the system under study is sketched in fig .
[ fig : scheme : sys ] .
the cavity eigenfrequency @xmath4 is assumed to be close to the trion resonant frequency @xmath5 in the dot , and for simplicity we assume the two orthogonally polarized cavity modes to be degenerate . in the presence of an external magnetic field @xmath6 applied along the @xmath7-axis ,
the hamiltonian of the system @xmath8 is written as a sum of the light - matter interaction operator @xmath9 and the zeeman hamiltonian @xmath10 here @xmath11 are the creation and annihilation operators for the @xmath12 circularly - polarized cavity photons , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the creation and annihilation operators , respectively , for the electron with the spin @xmath3-component @xmath15 and the singlet trion with the heavy - hole angular - momentum projection @xmath16 , @xmath17 is the photon - trion coupling constant , @xmath18 is the larmor frequency of the electron spin precession in the magnetic field , @xmath19 is the electron @xmath20-factor describing the zeeman effect . due to a small value of the transverse lnde factor for heavy holes @xcite we neglect , hereafter , the trion spin precession .
we assume the qd size to be small compared with the exciton bohr radius which allows us to treat the trions ( three - particle complexes ) as fermions @xcite and use for @xmath14 the fermionic commutation relations .
furthermore , the hamiltonian ( [ hpm ] ) includes an external electric field of the pump , probe or control pulse with the carrier frequency @xmath21 and smooth real envelopes @xmath22 being proportional to the electric field incident on the zero - dimensional microcavity and mirror transmission coefficient @xcite . note that although the incident fields @xmath22 are treated classically we take into account the quantization of photonic states inside the cavity . the hilbert space corresponding to this model is thus constituted by the four - level spin system of the qd and by the fock states of the intracavity @xmath23 and @xmath24 photons . regarding the spin - system ,
its four basis states are denoted @xmath25 , @xmath26 ( corresponding to an electron with @xmath27 or @xmath28 , respecively ) and @xmath29 , @xmath30 ( corresponding to a trion with @xmath31 or @xmath32 ) , and the basis states for the cavity are denoted @xmath33 and @xmath34 , with @xmath35 the respective numbers of @xmath23 and @xmath24 photons . in the following we use notations such as @xmath36 to denote a state of the qd / microcavity system with spin - up electron and photon numbers @xmath37 and @xmath38 @xcite .
the hamiltonian describes the coherent energy exchange between photons and trions in the microcavity as well as the effects of external pumping and magnetic field . in order to describe incoherent processes of photon mode decay via the photon leakage through the mirrors and non - radiative decay of trions in qds
we should introduce the density matrix @xmath39 satisfying the quantum master equation @xmath40-\mathcal l\lbrace\rho(t)\rbrace\:,\ ] ] where @xmath41 denotes the time - derivative of the density matrix and the lindblad operator @xmath42 responsible for the incoherent processes can be presented as @xcite @xmath43 \right . \\ + \ \gamma \left [ a_{j \frac32}^\dag a_{j \frac32}\rho(t ) + \rho(t ) a_{j \frac32}^\dag a_{j \frac32 } \right . \\ \left . \left . -\ 2\ a_{j \frac12}^\dag a_{j\frac32}\rho(t ) a_{j \frac32}^\dag a _ { j \frac12 } \right ] \right\}\ : .
\hspace{1.8 cm } \mbox { } \end{gathered}\ ] ] here @xmath44 is the decay rate of the cavity mode , and @xmath45 is the trion decay rate unrelated with the photon emission to the cavity mode . in this paper , we assume the former to exceed , by far , the latter ( @xmath46 ) as it is typically the case @xcite , focus on a quite strong coupling regime ( @xmath47 ) and consider moderately high magnetic fields : @xmath48 in this model the initialization , control and detection of the single electron spin in the cavity is practically independent of @xmath45 , and the inclusion of this additional parameter allows us to check its low influence . as will be shown below , the condition @xmath49 allows us to neglect the magnetic - field induced mixing between the excited states and take it into account only for the ground states @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
in such a regime , the hamiltonian @xmath52 leads to coherent spin beats at the frequency @xmath53 between these two ground states , whereas all the other states remain negligibly affected and @xmath24 photons , i.e. , @xmath54 and @xmath55 . under the considered conditions these states can be realized for linearly or elliptically polarized incident light , i.e. , for the probe .
however , since the probe is weak , this mixing can be disregarded , see sec .
[ sec : det ] . ] .
furthermore , if @xmath56 the spin precession is much faster than the trion or photon decay processes , the limit in which the spin dynamics is governed only by the population and coherence of the two ground states . for reasonable values of the parameters @xmath57 @xmath58ev ,
@xmath59 @xmath58ev and @xmath60ev , the magnetic field satisfying the conditions ( [ b : field ] ) corresponds to the range of 1@xmath6110 t. additional pure dephasing processes , with a dephasing rate @xmath62 , can also be included into eq .
following , e.g. , ref .
this increases the relaxation rate of the off - diagonal elements from the rate @xmath63 to @xmath64 .
however , in the strong - coupling regime with @xmath45 and @xmath62 being much smaller than @xmath44 the results are almost insensitive to both @xmath45 and @xmath62 .
a general description of the decay and decoherence processes would require the inclusion of the relaxation and dephasing sources ( i.e. , electron - phonon interaction , coupling with other photon modes , etc . ) in the hamiltonian of a system @xcite .
however , in the present study we restrict the analysis to the simplest possible model , considering only the markovian processes that can be described by eq . .
in the following the spin relaxation processes of electron and trion ( e.g. , splin - flip and/or spin - decoherence experienced by the hole spin in the trion state , even in the absence of trion decay ) are also neglected because for the zero - dimensional carrier states they are slow as compared with the trion decay rate @xmath45 and the photon decay rate @xmath44 ( see refs .
@xcite and references therein ) .
accordingly , they play no role in the spin orientation and control .
it is worth to mention that the formalism of eqs . , and is derived under the conditions @xmath65 , i.e. when the incoherent processes are perturbative , and @xmath66 , while the relations between the decay rates @xmath67 and the photon - trion coupling constant @xmath20 can be arbitrary . hence , the formalism is applicable in both the weak and strong coupling regimes @xcite .
in this section we study the effect of a short circularly - polarized pulse on the resident electron spin in the quantum microcavity .
first we present the formalism based on the schrdinger equation to describe the action of pump and control pulses .
next we consider the spin initialization process and then address the coherent spin control by circularly polarized pulses .
we bound ourselves to short optical pulses with a duration @xmath68 satisfying the conditions @xmath69 and @xmath70 . since usually @xmath71 the condition @xmath72 is fulfilled as well .
as for the product @xmath73 , its value is left arbitrary .
the process of spin initialization or control of a resident electron by short circularly - polarized pulses can conveniently be divided into three stages corresponding , in accordance with the inequalities , to three different time scales : ( i ) on the time scale of @xmath74 where both the magnetic field and relaxation processes are unimportant and the action of a pump / control pulse can be described in the framework of the hamiltonian with @xmath75 , ( ii ) on the time scale @xmath76 one should take into account the magnetic field in eq . , and
( iii ) for @xmath77 the photon decay becomes important .
such separation of time scales strongly simplifies the calculations . to illustrate the approach
, we consider the spin dynamics under the excitation by @xmath23 polarized pulses . similarly to the pump - probe experiments on single qds and qd arrays without a cavity @xcite , the repetition period of the pump pulses is assumed to be longer than the damping times @xmath78 and @xmath79 .
hence the accumulated photons have the time to escape the cavity and the system returns to the ground state before the arrival of the next optical pulse .
therefore , it is sufficient to trace the behavior of the system following a single optical pulse .
in addition , we point out that for a circularly - polarized excitation the system evolution is simplified .
if only @xmath23 photons are injected into the cavity , i.e. , @xmath80 , the system evolution is limited to the subset of states corresponding to @xmath81 , and the states with spin @xmath82 remain unexcited . with explicit notations
, we thus use a basis formed by the states @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 , corresponding to @xmath86 @xmath23 photons and no @xmath24 photons .
let the resident electron , before the pulse arrival ( @xmath87 ) be in the state given by the spinor components @xmath88 normalized to the unity . in the above - mentioned notations , the total initial system state is thus given by @xmath89 . in the first stage , i.e. at the direct action of the pump pulse ( @xmath90 ) , the system may be described by a time - dependent wavefunction given by @xmath91 in this equation the coefficients @xmath92 and @xmath93 correspond to states @xmath94 and @xmath95 , respectively .
note that the states @xmath94 and @xmath96 are coupled through optical electron - trion transition , i.e. , via the light - matter interaction .
the coefficients @xmath97 correspond to the uncoupled states @xmath98 , for which no interaction occurs between the electron spin @xmath99 and the @xmath23 photons .
these coefficients satisfy the initial conditions : @xmath100 and all other coefficients vanishing .
the coefficients @xmath101 obey the following infinite set of coupled differential equations [ c ] @xmath102 here @xmath103 and @xmath104 are the detunings , respectively , between the cavity - mode frequency and the pulse carrier frequency , and between the quantum - dot and cavity - mode resonant frequencies , and the time variable in @xmath105 and @xmath97 is omitted for brevity .
equations of motion for @xmath106 can be obtained from by setting @xmath107 : @xmath108 the latter permits an analytical solution for the real @xmath109 as follows @xcite @xmath110 where @xmath111 and @xmath112 according to eq .
, after the pulse the system is described by a coherent superposition of the electron , trion and multiphoton states .
the dynamics under a @xmath24 polarized pulse can be described similarly .
it is worth stressing that the statistics of uncoupled ladder of states , related with @xmath113 , is described by the coherent glauber distribution inherent for the classical light @xcite .
by contrast , due to the presence of two - level system non - linearity the coefficients @xmath114 in eqs .
( [ c ] ) do not obey coherent distribution @xcite .
therefore , to describe spin initialization , control and detection the field quantization in the cavity should be explicitly taken into account . at the second stage ,
started after the short pulse has passed and lasting during the time @xmath115 , the magnetic field comes into play and the shrdinger equation reduces to the set [ b - eq ] @xmath116 a direct consequence of the above equations is that under the assumption @xmath49 , the transverse magnetic field mixes , in the first order , only the ground ( no - photon / trion ) states @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
the set ( [ b - eq ] ) is decomposed into a pair of closed equations @xmath119 describing the electron spin in the no - photon ground state with @xmath120 , and other equations @xmath121 the initial conditions for them are given by the limiting values @xmath122 found in the first stage .
the components of the electron spin @xmath123 in the ground bare states @xmath117 and @xmath118 are determined by [ sxyz ] @xmath124\:,\\ s_y & = \frac{\rm i}{2 } \left [ c^-_0d^*_0-{c^-_0}^*d_0\right]\:,\\ s_z & = \frac12 \left[|c^-_0|^2-|d_0|^2\right]\ : .
\label{s0z}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the magnetic field @xmath125 induces the larmor spin precession in the @xmath126 plane [ precession0 ] @xmath127 where the initial components @xmath128 ( @xmath129 ) are related by eqs .
( [ sxyz ] ) with the first - stage coefficients @xmath130 and @xmath131 . here
we stress that the amplitude of the larmor spin precession is governed only by the populations and coherences for the two ground states @xmath117 and @xmath118 . on the third stage , @xmath132
, irreversible relaxation processes should be included into the analysis .
the trion decay and the photon escape return the system to the ground state .
however , for high enough magnetic field , @xmath133 , the electron returning from the states @xmath134 , @xmath135 with @xmath136 and the trion states into the ground states makes no contribution to the rotating spin @xmath137 . indeed , if @xmath133 the states @xmath117 and @xmath118 experience a larmor rotation which is much faster than the typical time intervals between the successive photon or trion decay events .
these events incoherently contribute to increase the population of either @xmath117 or @xmath118 state .
thus , they leave both the direction and magnitude of the spin vector @xmath137 unchanged , as confirmed by a numerical calculation carried out within the density matrix formalism for the condition @xmath133 . qualitatively ,
this can be understood by transforming to the coordinate system rotating with the larmor frequency around the field @xmath138 : in this system the ground - state electron spin is fixed whereas the direction of the electron spin incoming from the decaying excited states is changing with the frequency @xmath53 . as a result ,
the spin dynamics is not modified during the third stage and closely follows eqs if @xmath133 ( the situation where @xmath139 is comparable to @xmath53 is described below and in appendix [ sec : reson ] ) . finally , when considering timescales @xmath140 , one also has to take into account the spin relaxation for the resident electron .
for these timescales the spin dynamics is modified , as compared to eqs .
( [ pr10 ] ) and ( [ pr20 ] ) , by [ precession ] @xmath141 where @xmath142 is the phenomenological spin relaxation time of resident electron assumed to exceed by far @xmath143 , @xmath79 , and @xmath78 .
equations together with ( [ sxyz ] ) fully describe the resident - electron spin dynamics induced by the short circularly - polarized pulse .
we also point out that , in typical experiments , periodic trains of pulses are used , with a repetition rate of the order or even much higher than the spin relaxation rate .
the effect of periodic pump pulses is discussed in appendix [ sec : train ] , showing that very efficient spin initialization can be obtained even when considering the incomplete spin initialization induced by a single pump pulse and a relaxation of the spin coherence between two consecutive pulses . using this formalism we address below the spin coherence initialization and spin control effects . of a resident electron after a single @xmath23 short pump pulse vs. the pulse area under the resonant excitation of the microcavity tuned to resonance with the trion transition , i.e. for @xmath144 .
different curves correspond to different pump pulse durations indicated at each curve .
( b ) the electron spin @xmath145 as a function of the pump - pulse detuning @xmath146 at the fixed pulse area @xmath147 calculated after eqs . , and for the following parameters : @xmath148 and @xmath149 ( solid curve ) , @xmath148 and @xmath150 ( dashed curve ) , @xmath151 and @xmath149 ( dotted curve ) .
] figure [ fig : pump ] demonstrates the electron spin polarization @xmath145 induced by a short @xmath23-polarized pump pulse as ( a ) a function of pump pulse area introduced by @xmath152 at the double resonant condition @xmath153 , and ( b ) a function of the detuning between the pump pulse carrier frequency @xmath21 and the cavity resonant frequency @xmath4 . to model the initially unpolarized electron we used the spinor components @xmath88 of equal absolute values , @xmath154 , and averaged @xmath145 over their relative phase .
the envelope function of the pump pulse is taken in the form of rosen & zener pulse @xcite @xmath155 as follows from fig .
[ fig : pump](a ) , at small values of @xmath156 ( weak pulses ) the electron spin polarization increases proportionally to @xmath157 or to the first power of the light intensity , as expected from general considerations . with the further increase in @xmath156 it reaches a maximum and
then slopes down .
the decrease in polarization is related to depopulation of the ground states @xmath158 and @xmath159 : for optical pulses of high intensity the coefficients @xmath160 and , according to eqs .
, @xmath161 .
this is because spectral wings of high intensity pulse induce non - resonant transitions , see below .
it is worth to emphasize that the @xmath156-dependence does not show any oscillations , in contrast to the rabi cycle inherent to two - level systems @xcite .
this can be understood taking into account an infinite number of strongly - coupled excited states in the system under consideration , see detailed discussion on rabi effect in appendix [ sec : rabi ] .
furthermore , a single pump pulse can not polarize electron spin by more than @xmath162 if initially the electron is unpolarized . in the optimal case , indeed , the pulse will fully transfer one of the spin components to the excited states , and leave unaffected the other spin component , i.e. @xmath163 and @xmath164 right after the pump pulse .
in such a case , the trion and photon decay processes will equally transfer the populations of the excited states towards the two ground states .
this corresponds to a maximal polarization degree @xmath165 if the spin is initially unpolarized before the pulse ; however , as shown in appendix [ sec : train ] , a train of synchronized pump pulses can result in the complete spin polarization of the resident carrier @xcite .
, @xmath82 denote heavy - hole - in - trion spin , single arrows @xmath166 , @xmath99 denote resident electron spin .
the transitions between the states after injection of single @xmath23 photon are shown by wavy arrow .
the polariton modes are split by @xmath167 and a weak external magnetic field @xmath168 acts only on the ground electron states , see main text for details . ]
we now turn to the spectral features of this spin initialization procedure , which can be understood by considering the eigenstates of the system in the absence of any external field ( i.e. when @xmath22 and @xmath75 ) .
indeed , the condition @xmath169 corresponds to a strong coupling regime with a clear spectral separation between the polaritonic states induced by the light - matter coupling . in the absence of @xmath24 photons ,
the eigenstates we have to consider in our system are the ground states @xmath170 and @xmath171 , the uncoupled states @xmath98 with @xmath172 , and the polaritonic eigenstates of the form @xmath173,\ ] ] also with @xmath172 . while the energies @xmath174 of the uncoupled eigenstates @xmath98 are simply given by @xmath175 the energies @xmath176 of the polaritonic eigenstates , eq . , are given by the jaynes - cummings formulae @xcite : @xmath177 figure [ fig : scheme : tr ] presents the energy spectrum of this system for the two ground states , and for the first three excited states , illustrating that the energy degeneracy is lifted only for the excited states .
this is the reason why , when a magnetic field is turned on in the limit @xmath178 , this leads to an efficient mixing between the ground states but not between the excited states .
figure [ fig : scheme : tr ] also demonstrates , why , in the results of fig .
[ fig : pump](a ) , efficient spin initialization is obtained when the pump pulse is longer than the inverse coupling constant @xmath179 , i.e. @xmath180 .
indeed , the wider the pulse spectrum , the weaker the rate of resonant transition and , in addition , the spectrally wide pulses give rise to transitions involving both spin - up and spin - down electron states . for @xmath181ev , the condition @xmath182 corresponds to @xmath183 ps . under the double resonance condition , @xmath184
, the right - handed circularly - polarized pump pulse orients the electron spin in the positive @xmath3 direction , as shown in fig .
[ fig : pump](a ) and in fig .
[ fig : pump](b ) for zero detuning . to explain this sign of @xmath145 we refer to the wavy arrows in fig .
[ fig : scheme : tr ] : for a large enough coupling constant @xmath20 , the carrier frequency @xmath21 is out of resonance with the split excited states ( [ polaritons ] ) and in resonance with the transitions @xmath185 as a result the @xmath23 pulse causes a reduction of the coefficient @xmath131 , exciting and therefore disordering the electron spin - down state .
it is clear that one can invert the spin polarization by detuning the pulse frequency from @xmath186 to one of the polariton transitions , thus causing @xmath187 and @xmath188 , in agreement with the behavior of the solid curve in fig .
[ fig : pump](b ) . as mentioned above , the high - intensity pulse results in the reduction of both @xmath189 and @xmath190 since the power of spectral wings increases with the pulse area .
an extra feature in the curve is related to the resonant two - photon excitation of the @xmath191 polaritonic states , at energies given by @xmath192 in eq . : for this process the resonance condition is @xmath193 or @xmath194 being a signature of the second rung in the jaynes - cummings ladder . for the larger detunings , @xmath195 , the optical transition efficiency decreases and the electron spin orientation is suppressed , similarly to the above - mentioned effect of pulse duration shortening , compare also the solid and dashed curves in fig .
[ fig : pump](b ) .
the detuning @xmath196 between the trion and cavity - mode resonances shifts leftwards the dips related to the spin - up polaritons , as seen from the dotted curve in fig .
[ fig : pump](b ) . as indicated in the panels .
the black solid curves are calculated in the density matrix formalism using eqs . and .
the red dashed curves are calculated for @xmath197 after eqs . with the amplitude determined by eqs . , and ( indicated by blue dotted lines ) .
the green dash - dotted line is calculated using the resonant approximation after eqs . .
the parameters of the calculation are @xmath198 , @xmath199 , @xmath200 , @xmath201 and @xmath202 . ]
the results obtained within the simplified three - stage model presented above are corroborated by the numerical calculations performed within the full density matrix approach .
this approach was also applied to calculate explicitly the spin beats after eqs . and .
the results are presented in fig .
[ fig : beats ] by black solid lines together with the predictions of the simplified three - stage model ( red / dashed lines ) for three different magnitudes of magnetic field .
the parameters of calculations are presented in the figure caption and , as above , the initial condition corresponds to the unpolarized electron . in the case of @xmath75 the long - living spin beats ( at @xmath203 ) are not excited , because in the absence of both magnetic field and spin flip processes , the electron spin returning from the excited states exactly compensates the spin generated by the pump pulse . accordingly , an increase of @xmath53 leads to a non - zero amplitude of the long - living spin beats . for large enough magnetic field , where @xmath133 and the inequalities are fulfilled , the spin beats calculated in the density matrix formalism and in the three - stage model expectedly
a more elaborate model of spin coherence initialization outlined in appendix [ sec : reson ] allows us to describe spin coherence excitation even for @xmath204 , corresponding results of calculations are presented by green dash - dotted lines in the fig .
[ fig : beats ] .
the dependence of the spin beats on the ratio @xmath205 is also illustrated in fig . [ fig : magnetic ] .
fitting the numerically - calculated spin beats with eqs .
, at the time scale ranging from @xmath68 to some value @xmath206 chosen in a way that @xmath207 , allows us to determine the initial spin components @xmath145 and @xmath208 in eqs . , and compare them to the prediction of eq . .
the deduced values of @xmath145 and @xmath208 are shown in fig .
[ fig : magnetic ] as functions of the magnetic field . at small magnetic fields , @xmath204 , where the three - stage model is inapplicable the density matrix calculation predicts the quadratic and linear dependencies of @xmath145 and @xmath208 on the magnetic field . at the higher fields , @xmath133 , the electron spin @xmath208 vanishes and @xmath209 saturates at a value given by eq . .
a slow decrease of @xmath209 in this region is related with the increasing ratio @xmath210 assumed to be small in the schrdinger equation approach .
these properties are similar to those in the previously - studied spin initialization in quantum wells and qds without a cavity @xcite .
hence , the comparison of the developed three - stage model and full density matrix approach demonstrates that under the condition @xmath133 one can indeed neglect the contribution of excited states to the spin beats .
and @xmath208 calculated in the density matrix formalism using eqs . and , black solid and red dashed curves respectively , with the same parameters as in fig .
[ fig : beats ] and @xmath211 . ] as a function of the detuning between the cavity resonance and carrier frequency of control pulse for @xmath212 and two control pulse durations indicated at the curves .
( b ) electron spin polarization degree after the control pulse arrival calculated for the same parameters as in ( a ) .
( c ) trajectory of spin vector @xmath213 under variation of detuning @xmath214 from @xmath215 to @xmath216 for @xmath212 and @xmath149 . ] equations , , and describe also the coherent spin manipulation by short circularly polarized pulses . to address such a situation
we assume that shortly before the control pulse arrival the resident electron spin is aligned along @xmath217-axis , yielding @xmath218 in the absence of the control pulse , this situation would simply correspond to the spin precession described by eqs . with initial conditions @xmath219 , @xmath220 , and @xmath221 .
after the control pulse , the spin orientation will still be described by eqs , but with modified values of the coefficients @xmath222 , @xmath208 , and @xmath145 .
indeed , similarly to the previously studied situation of the qd without the cavity @xcite the circularly polarized pulse induces spin rotation in the @xmath223 plane . the spin rotation angle induced by the control pulse
is defined from the phase of the spin beats in eqs . :
this rotation angle @xmath225 , calculated in the three - stage model , is presented in fig .
[ fig : rot](a ) as a function of the detuning @xmath146 between the carrier frequency and qd / cavity resonances ( here and below @xmath226 ) . here , as before , the conditions @xmath227 were assumed to be satisfied .
figure [ fig : rot](a ) shows that spectrally narrow control pulses can rotate the resident electron spin in the @xmath223 plane by an arbitrary angle .
particularly , as demonstrated with the dashed curve , calculated for @xmath228 , the spin rotation angle in the plane can reach @xmath229 . for somewhat shorter pulses @xmath230
the spin rotation angle is still significant .
we now show that besides spin rotation , the control pulse also generally induces a spin depolarization , which , however , can remain limited under proper excitation conditions . in the optical control situation , indeed , one specifically starts with a situation where @xmath231 .
because the two ground states are populated , the control pulse will populate at least one of the excited states , thus leading to a partially polarized spin right after the control pulse .
the spin will then remain partially polarized after the depopulation of the excited states , on the time scale of @xmath232 .
this depolarizing effect is similar to the one which is obtained with a qd without a microcavity , whenever a trion population is created by the control pulse : the trion decay at random times then leads to an unavoidable spin depolarization . in order to limit this depolarization , a well known technique in qds without microcavities
consists in using specific values of the pulse area @xmath233 , where @xmath234 is an integer @xcite , so that the trion state populations remain negligible after the control pulse .
a similar technique can be applied in the present case , by applying a control pulse which reduces the population of the excited states right after the pulse , see appendix [ sec : rabi ] where the conditions for the rabi cycle are analyzed . in order to illustrate the effect of the control pulse ,
the degree of spin polarization in the strong coupling regime is plotted in fig .
[ fig : rot](b ) as a function of the detuning .
the depolarization effect is present for any values of @xmath156 and @xmath146 , but can remain moderate for given values of the pulse area , as for example with @xmath228 , @xmath212 , and @xmath235 in fig .
[ fig : rot](b ) . the panel ( c ) of fig .
[ fig : rot ] visualizes the spin control and presents the possible spin polarizations of the qd after the control pulse arrival for different detunings @xmath146 provided the spin is initially oriented along @xmath217 axis .
note that this trajectory can be simpler or even more complex depending on the pulse power and duration .
the longer is the pulse the more polarization can be kept for the given rotation angle . for example , calculation shows that taking @xmath149 and @xmath212 one can rotate spin by @xmath236 with small depolarization of about 15% .
we also point out that this possible depolarization does not contradict the fact that , in the formerly described spin initialization process , perfect spin polarization can be achieved using a train of circularly polarized optical pulses . indeed , as shown in appendix
[ sec : train ] , under the double resonance condition @xmath237 , and with a proper synchronisation of the pulses , one can reach a situation where @xmath238 before and after a pulse arrival : in such a case the only state which is populated at the pulse arrival is the ground state @xmath50 .
this states remains unaffected by the circularly polarized incoming pulse , which therefore does not induce neither any spin depolarization nor spin rotation .
the spin polarization is detected by a linearly polarized probe pulse . in the strong coupling regime
the faraday and kerr effects induced by a single electron spin become giant , since one circular component of the probe pulse can be fully transmitted through the cavity , while the other one can be fully reflected @xcite .
it follows from refs .
@xcite that in the limit of small amplitude of the probe beam , @xmath239 , the reflection coefficients , @xmath240 , of the monochromatic @xmath241 polarized light from the microcavity can be presented as @xmath242 where [ r01 ] @xmath243 here we have introduced @xmath244 and @xmath245 being the photon escape rates through the mirrors ( light is incident on the mirror characterized by @xmath244 ) , in these notations @xmath246 .
the transmission coefficients through the microcavity are given by @xmath247 .
equations , can be derived from general eq . retaining only states with @xmath248 and @xmath249 excitation in the system and neglecting the magnetic field @xmath53 ;
the magnetic field effect is considered below .
these formulae are valid provided that the duration of the probe pulse , @xmath68 , exceeds by far @xmath79 , so that one can treat it to be quasi - monochromatic , but , on the other hand , @xmath68 should be short enough compared with the electron spin reorientation time , otherwise @xmath250 can not be considered as a constant during the probe pulse action and strong fluctuations of reflectivity and transmission arise . for the unpolarized electron the intensity coefficient of light reflection is polarization independent and , according to eq .
( [ rpm ] ) , given by @xmath251 accordingly , the three dips appear in the reflectivity spectrum at a zero - detuning condition @xmath226 , see inset in fig .
[ fig : probe ] .
the dip at the frequency @xmath4 corresponds to the light component experiencing no coupling with the qd , its reflectivity is given by @xmath252 , and the two dips centered at @xmath253 correspond to the polariton resonances split in the strong coupling regime and described by @xmath254 .
noteworthy , this is in contrast with the case of low - density two - dimensional electron gas in the microcavity @xcite , where for unpolarized electrons two features are present in the reflection / transmission spectra in the strong coupling regime . in the latter case
the circularly polarized components of the probe beam always interact with multitudes of electrons .
for the _ cw _ probe beam the spin - kerr / faraday angles and induced ellipticity are given by @xcite [ kfe ] @xmath255 @xmath256 @xmath257 respectively
. the ellipticity of the transmitted beam is given by eq .
with the replacement @xmath258 . in the case of a short probe pulse the reflectivity coefficient and spin signals should be convoluted with the normalized fourier transform @xmath259 of the probe pulse envelope defined by @xmath260^{-1/2 } , \ ] ] where @xmath261 .
the result reads [ averaging ] @xmath262 @xmath263 @xmath264 @xmath265\tilde{\mathcal e}^2(\omega)}{2\int_{-\infty}^\infty \mathrm d \omega [ |r_+(\omega)|^2+|r_-(\omega)|^2]\tilde{\mathcal e}^2(\omega)}}.\ ] ] note , that the frequency dependences of the kerr and faraday rotation signals are similar for the qd embedded into a microcavity operating in a strong coupling regime @xcite : both signals consist of the dispersive features centered at polariton and bare cavity mode frequencies and both can reach tens of degrees .
the ellipticity has maxima at the eigenfrequencies of the system .
when computing these kerr and faraday rotation signals , one can also take into account the effect of magnetic field , @xmath266 , similarly to ref . .
for a sufficiently weak probe pulse the relevant states involve no more than one photon and are represented by @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath267 , @xmath268 , @xmath269 , @xmath270 , @xmath271 , @xmath272 .
the important feature of the spin coherence detection in this case is that during the lifetime of the probe pulse inside the cavity the electron spin rotates substantially , hence , the reflected and transmitted light is modulated by the spin beats . for the monochromatic probe beam at a frequency @xmath21 the reflected
light contains the same - frequency component with the amplitude reduced by the factor @xmath273 and two components at the frequencies @xmath274 whose amplitudes are proportional to the incident field amplitude with the coefficients @xmath275 respectively , where @xmath276 for @xmath23/@xmath24 polarized components of the probe beam , @xmath277 and spin components in eqs .
, correspond to @xmath278 , i.e. the moment of the probe pulse arrival . here
[ r : all ] @xmath279,\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath280,\end{gathered}\ ] ] @xmath281.\ ] ] similar equations hold also for the transmitted light .
note that eqs .
describes spin - flip raman scattering of the light in the zero - dimensional microcavity operating in the strong coupling regime @xcite .
the components of electric field of reflected pulse can be found from eqs . , and .
for the pulse linearly polarized along @xmath7-axis one has [ refl : pulse : all ] @xmath282 @xmath283.\end{gathered}\ ] ] equations together with general definitions of spin signals , ref .
@xcite , allow us to calculate the spin - kerr and spin - ellipticity signals . .
parameters of the calculation : @xmath284 , @xmath285 , @xmath286 , @xmath287 , @xmath288 ( black solid curves ) , @xmath289 ( red dashed curves ) and @xmath290 ( blue dotted curves ) .
the inset shows the reflectivity spectra in case of unpolarized electron for the continuous monochromatic probe and @xmath75 . ]
figure [ fig : probe ] shows the kerr rotation angle calculated as a function of the detuning for different probe pulse durations .
the dispersive features of @xmath291 correspond to the frequencies @xmath292 and @xmath293 .
interestingly the dependence of the rotation angle on the pulse duration at a fixed detuning is nonmonotonic . on one hand ,
the shorter the pulse , the wider its frequency spectrum , hence , the spectral features become less pronounced with a decrease in the pulse duration . on the other hand , for relatively long pulses @xmath294
the spin precession during the pulse action suppresses the signal @xcite . as a result
the optimal sensitivity is reached for the moderate pulse durations @xmath295 .
these results show that giant modifications of the optical polarization , which have recently been experimentally demonstrated for _ cw _ monochromatic light @xcite , are possible even in the presence of short non - monochromatic pulses . furthermore , as envisioned in ref .
@xcite for the _ cw _ case , with these short pulses it will also be possible to use generalized polarization measurements in a properly - chosen polarization basis : this will allow approaching the ideal situation where the output polarization states corresponding to spin @xmath296 and @xmath297 are orthogonal to each other , and thus distinguishable with a single photon detection event .
such a possibility is at the heart of many theoretical proposals relying on the efficient interaction between a single spin and a single photon for a wide range of applications @xcite and can be also interesting in view of generation of photonic states with unconventional statistics @xcite .
to conclude , we have presented a theory of single electron spin coherence initialization , detection and manipulation by short optical pulses for a quantum dot / microcavity structure operating in the strong coupling regime .
thereby , the jaynes - cummings ladder model is extended to spin - polarized zero - dimensional trion polaritons .
it is shown that the spin polarization after a single pump pulse can reach 50% in a moderate transverse magnetic field .
the train of pump pulses is shown to cause the complete spin polarization of the resident electron .
the direction of the photoinduced spin depends both on the photon helicity and carrier frequency of the pump pulse .
the possibilities for the coherent control of single spin in the strong coupling regime are analyzed .
the spin rotation induced by a circular pulse is accompanied , in general , by depolarization , which can be moderate for optimal conditions .
the spin - kerr and faraday rotation angles detected by short linearly polarized pulses are calculated and shown to reach tens of degrees .
this work was partially supported by the russian foundation for basic research and dfg in the framework of icrc trr160 , rf president grants nsh-1085.2014.2 , md-5726.2015.2 , and sp-643.2015.5 , rf government grant 14.z50.31.0021 ( leading scientist m.h .
bayer ) , dynasty foundation , st .- petersburg government grant , eu project spangl4q , and also by the french anr project spiqe .
the condition @xmath133 in analytical model of spin coherence generation can be relaxed under the assumptions @xmath298 , @xmath299 , and @xmath300 . in this case
the ladder of polariton states is not excited by the pump pulse , hence , @xmath301 for @xmath302 . on the other hand
, the resonant excitation of the bare cavity mode at the first stage leads to the formation of coherent state described by eq . .
during the next stage , @xmath303 , the phase coherence between excited states is destroyed and the quantum dot in the microcavity can be described , similarly to ref .
@xcite , by the set of kinetic equations for occupancies @xmath304 of photonic states with @xmath305 photons and spin density matrix for the ground ( electron ) state .
making use of the general eq .
one finds that [ cf .
@xcite ] [ reson - pump ] @xmath306 where @xmath307 accounts for the spin polarization income from the excited states @xmath308 ( we recall that we consider the @xmath23 excitation ) .
taking into account that @xcite @xmath309 and @xmath310 we obtain from eq .
@xmath311 here @xmath312 is the number of photons in the cavity and @xmath313 is the average number of the excited states in the ladder .
it follows from eq .
that @xmath314 where the parameter @xmath315 is defined by eq . .
solving the set of eqs .
one obtains instead of eq .
@xmath316 particularly , in the limiting case of @xmath75 the integral can be analytically calculated and @xmath317 .
\label{reson0}\ ] ] we compare in fig . [
fig : beats](a ) the calculation after eq .
( green dash - dotted line ) with exact numerical solution in the density matrix formalism ( black solid line ) .
similarly the panels ( b ) and ( c ) illustrate the agreement between the calculations after eq . and
the two other approaches described above in case of @xmath318 .
the difference between black and green curves is caused only by the moderate magnitude of the parameter @xmath228 , where the ladder of polariton states is also weakly excited .
we have numerically checked that for the larger value of @xmath149 the difference becomes negligible .
in order to address the effect of the pump - pulse train with the repetition period @xmath319 we follow refs .
@xcite and introduce a linear relation between the `` long - living '' electron spin components right before the pump pulse arrival @xmath320 and right after the pulse arrival @xmath321 [ note , that in this definition , @xmath322 in eq . ] : @xmath323 where the operator @xmath324 describes spin transformation and depolarization by the pulse and @xmath325 describes the spin generation .
the matrix elements of @xmath324 and the components of @xmath325 are determined by the pump pulse parameters .
the spin precession between the pulses , @xmath326 , is described by the linear transformation @xmath327 , where the matrix of the operator @xmath328 can be presented according to eqs .
, in the form : @xmath329 correspondingly , the steady - state value of @xmath321 satisfies the equation @xmath330 under the condition of phase synchronization @xmath331 , where the electron spin makes integer number of revolutions between the pulses , @xmath332 reduces to the unit operator and we obtain @xmath333^{-1 } \bm g.\ ] ] for the sake of illustration we consider the resonant case where the pump carrier frequency equals to that of the bare cavity mode , @xmath334 .
then under conditions @xmath335 and the operator @xmath324 and vector @xmath336 are expressed only via one parameter @xmath337 as [ cf .
@xcite ] @xmath338 and @xmath339 . in this case
@xmath340 and @xmath341 @xmath342 for @xmath343 , one has @xmath344 which means that the complete spin polarization by the train of pump pulses is achievable .
in the limit of very strong coupling where @xmath345 and for very spectrally narrow circularly polarized pulse @xmath346 one can , neglecting magnetic field effect , expect rabi cycle resulting in the oscillations between the ground state @xmath166 and one of the polariton states , see eq . and fig .
[ fig : scheme : tr ] , @xmath347 , @xmath348 .
in this situation the wavefunction of the system can be presented in the form @xmath349 where coefficients @xmath350 and @xmath351 satisfy standard equations for the driven two - level system dynamics @xcite : @xmath352 } \mathcal b,\\ \mathrm
i \dot{\mathcal b } & = \omega_\pm \mathcal b + \frac{\mathcal e_+(t)}{\sqrt{2}}\exp{[-\mathrm i ( \omega - \omega_{\pm } ) ] } \mathcal a,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and time argument is omitted for brevity . unlike eqs . of the main text , here ,
we use here the basis of polariton eigenstates . the possibility to disregard other states in eq .
is justified for moderate pump pulse areas , @xmath156 , by the condition : the transition from either of @xmath353 states to the higher energy states are suppressed since corresponding transition frequencies differ strongly from @xmath354 .
an increase of the pump pulse area @xmath355 , where in two - level approximation many periods of rabi cycle would take place , invokes here the transitions to the higher energy states and results in the damping of rabi oscillations .
we also note , that for the parameters of calculations presented in figs .
[ fig : pump ] , [ fig : rot ] many excited states are involved and rabi oscillations do not take place .
it is also worths mentionning that control pulses of specific shapes , e.g. , rectangular pulses , under certain conditions , namely , @xmath356 and @xmath357 , can lead to the spin rotation without any depolarization .
indeed , the parameter @xmath358 in eq . for @xmath106 can be made zero for specific pulse duration while the phase @xmath359 is not , generally , a multiple of @xmath229 . in this cases
@xmath190 remains constant in amplitude but acquires the phase , while @xmath189 is unaffected by the control pulse .
we note that in the limit of weak coupling where the feedback of the quantum dot on the cavity mode can be neglected ( and the field inside the cavity can be treated classically ) , rabi oscillations naturally arise since photons of given circular , @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) polarizations couple @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) electron with @xmath29 ( @xmath360 ) trion states , see refs .
@xcite for more details .
a. s. bracker , e. a. stinaff , d. gammon , m. e. ware , j. g. tischler , a. shabaev , a. l. efros , d. park , d. gershoni , v. l. korenev , i. a. merkulov .
_ optical pumping of the electronic and nuclear spin of single charge - tunable quantum dots_. phys .
lett . * 94 * , 047402 ( 2005 ) .
a. greilich , r. oulton , e. a. zhukov , i. a. yugova , d. r. yakovlev , m. bayer , a. shabaev , a. l. efros , i. a. merkulov , v. stavarache , d. reuter , a. wieck .
_ optical control of spin coherence in singly charged @xmath361 quantum dots_. phys .
lett . * 96 * , 227401 ( 2006 ) .
a. greilich , s. e. economou , s. spatzek , d. r. yakovlev , d. reuter , a. d. wieck , t. l. reinecke , m. bayer .
_ ultrafast optical rotations of electron spins in quantum dots_. nature physics * 5 * , 262 ( 2009 ) .
a. greilich , d. r. yakovlev , a. shabaev , a. l. efros , i. a. yugova , r. oulton , v. stavarache , d. reuter , a. wieck , m. bayer .
_ mode locking of electron spin coherences in singly charged quantum dots_. science * 313 * , 341 ( 2006 ) . c. y. hu , a. young , j. l. obrien , w. j. munro , j. g. rarity .
_ giant optical faraday rotation induced by a single - electron spin in a quantum dot : applications to entangling remote spins via a single photon_. phys . rev .
b * 78 * , 085307 ( 2008 ) . r. giri , s. cronenberger , m. vladimirova , d. scalbert , k. v. kavokin , m. m. glazov , m. nawrocki , a. lematre , j. bloch .
_ giant photoinduced faraday rotation due to the spin - polarized electron gas in an @xmath234-gaas microcavity_. phys .
b * 85 * , 195313 ( 2012 ) .
r. giri , s. cronenberger , m. m. glazov , k. v. kavokin , a. lematre , j. bloch , m. vladimirova , d. scalbert .
_ nondestructive measurement of nuclear magnetization by off - resonant faraday rotation_. phys .
* 111 * , 087603 ( 2013 ) . k. de greve , p. l. mcmahon , d. press , t. d. ladd , d. bisping , c. schneider , m. kamp , l. worschech , s. hofling , a. forchel , y. yamamoto .
_ ultrafast coherent control and suppressed nuclear feedback of a single quantum dot hole qubit_. nat phys * 7 * , 872 ( 2011 ) . c. arnold , j. demory , v. loo , a. lematre , i. sagnes , m. glazov , o. krebs , p. voisin , p. senellart , l. lanco .
_ macroscopic rotation of photon polarization induced by a single spin_. nat commun * 6 * ( 2015 ) .
t. yoshie , a. scherer , j. heindrickson , g. khitrova , h. m. gibbs , g. rupper , c. ell , o. b. shchekin , d. g. deppe .
_ vacuum rabi splitting with a single quantum dot in a photonic crystal nanocavity_. nature * 432 * , 200 ( 2004 ) .
reithmaier , g. sek , a. lffler , c. hofmann , s. kuhn , s. reitzenstein , l. v. keldysh , v. d. kulakovskii , t. l. reinecker , a. forchel .
_ strong coupling in a single quantum dot semiconductor microcavity system_. nature * 432 * , 197 ( 2004 ) .
e. peter , p. senellart , d. martrou , a. lematre , j. hours , j. m. gerard , j. bloch .
_ exciton - photon strong - coupling regime for a single quantum dot embedded in a microcavity_. phys .
lett . * 95 * , 67401 ( 2005 ) .
j. m. fink , m. gppl , m. baur , r. bianchetti , p. j. leek , a. blais , and a. wallraff .
_ climbing the jaynes - cummings ladder and observing its @xmath363 nonlinearity in a cavity qed system_. nature * 454 * , 315 ( 2008 ) .
j. kasprzak , s. reitzenstein , e. a. muljarov , c. kistner , c. schneider , m. strauss , s. hfling , a. forchel , and w. langbein , nature mater .
* 9 * , 304 ( 2010 ) . _ up on the jaynescummings ladder of a quantum - dot / microcavity system_. nature phys . *
4 * , 382 ( 2008 ) .
i. a. yugova , m. m. glazov , d. r. yakovlev , a. a. sokolova , m. bayer .
_ coherent spin dynamics of electrons and holes in semiconductor quantum wells and quantum dots under periodical optical excitation : resonant spin amplification versus spin mode locking_. phys . rev .
b * 85 * , 125304 ( 2012 ) .
s. spatzek , s. varwig , m. m. glazov , i. a. yugova , a. schwan , d. r. yakovlev , d. reuter , a. d. wieck , m. bayer . _ generation and detection of mode - locked spin coherence in @xmath361 quantum dots by laser pulses of long duration_. phys .
b * 84 * , 115309 ( 2011 ) .
s. g. carter , a. shabaev , s. e. economou , t. a. kennedy , a. s. bracker , t. l. reinecke .
_ directing nuclear spin flips in @xmath365 quantum dots using detuned optical pulse trains_. phys .
lett . * 102 * , 167403 ( 2009 ) .
e. a. zhukov , d. r. yakovlev , m. bayer , m. m. glazov , e. l. ivchenko , g. karczewski , t. wojtowicz , j. kossut .
_ spin coherence of a two - dimensional electron gas induced by resonant excitation of trions and excitons in cdte/(cd , mg)te quantum wells_. phys .
b * 76 * , 205310 ( 2007 ) . c.y .
hu , w.j .
munro , and j.g .
_ deterministic photon entangler using a charged quantum dot inside a microcavity_. phys . rev .
b * 78 * , 125318 ( 2008 ) . c. bonato , et al . _
cnot and bell - state analysis in the weak - coupling cavity qed regime_. phys .
lett . * 104 * , 160503 ( 2010 ) .
_ fault - tolerant quantum computing with coded spins using the conditional faraday rotation in quantum dots .
b * 73 * , 075312 ( 2006 ) .
y. takahashi , et al .
_ quantum nondemolition measurement of spin via the paramagnetic faraday rotation_. phys .
a * 60 * , 49744979 ( 1999 ) .
leuenberger , m.e .
flatt , d.d .
_ teleportation of electronic many - qubit states encoded in the electron spin of quantum dots via single photons_. phys .
* 94 * , 107401 ( 2005 ) .
e. waks and j. vuckovic .
_ dipole induced transparency in drop - filter cavity- waveguide systems_. phys .
lett . * 96 * , 153601 ( 2006 ) .
s. k. y. lee and c. k. law .
_ analysis of photon - atom entanglement generated by faraday rotation in a cavity .
a * 73 * , 053808 ( 2006 ) .
hu , j.g . rarity .
_ loss - resistant state teleportation and entanglement swapping using a quantum - dot spin in an optical microcavity . _
phys . rev .
b * 83 * , 115303 ( 2011 ) .
a. b. young , c.y .
hu , j.g . rarity .
_ generating entanglement with low - q - factor microcavities . _
a * 87 * , 012332 ( 2013 ) . | we present a microscopic theory of optical initialization , control and detection for a single electron spin in a quantum dot embedded into a zero - dimensional microcavity . the strong coupling regime of the trion and the cavity mode is addressed .
we demonstrate that efficient spin orientation by a single circularly polarized pulse is possible in relatively weak transverse magnetic fields .
the possibilities for spin control by additional circularly polarized pulse are analyzed .
under optimal conditions the kerr and faraday rotation angles induced by the spin polarized electron may reach tens of degrees .
= by 60 = 255=255 by -60 by 255 |
in recent years graphene@xcite has become one of the most attractive materials due to its unique properties such as high - mobility electron transport @xcite , the presence of room - temperature quantum hall effect@xcite , the strong lattice structure@xcite and the extremely high in - plane thermal conductivity.@xcite however , its highly active surface and the lack of a band gap in the electronic structure are emerging drawbacks for graphene .
recently , interests have now also focused on other two - dimensional systems having honeycomb structures , such as graphane@xcite , halogenated graphenes@xcite , silicene@xcite , iii - v binary compounds@xcite , and transition metal dichalcogenides ( tmds)@xcite .
recent studies have revealed that among various monolayer structures especially tmds are quite promising materials for electronics and optoelectronics applications .
bulk tmds have a number of exceptional properties such as superconductivity of tas@xmath0 and nbse@xmath0 , mott transition in 1t - tas@xmath0 and the presence of charge density wave in tise@xmath0 .
@xcite it was also reported that the electrical and optical properties of tmds are dramatically altered with the number of layers@xcite .
although bulk hexagonal tmds possess an indirect band gap , mono - layer tmds exhibit a direct band gap which is crucial for optoelectronic devices , sensors and catalysts .
in addition , n - type and p - type field - effect - transistors ( fets ) based on monolayer and multilayer tmds have been investigated.@xcite it was also reported that many monolayer 2d crystals are reactive and segregation may occur easily.@xcite therefore , the investigation of bilayer structures which are chemically more stable than monolayer structures is of vital significance .
recent studies have shown that synthesis of heterostructures made of combinations of different tmd single layers , graphene , fluorographene and hexagonal - bn ( hbn ) is experimentally achievable.@xcite since tmds and other two - dimensional structures have a lot of diverse monolayer structures , when they are combined together they are expected to exhibit very different properties .
@xcite since the intercalation and migration of foreign atoms is inevitable during the formation of such lamellar materials and heterostructures , the investigation of the diffusion characteristics of various impurities is essential .
early studies revealed that alkali - metal doping of bulk tise@xmath0 and mos@xmath0 can be utilized as an efficient way to tune the fermi level.@xcite the electrical conductivity of mos@xmath0 can be altered by substitutional doping.@xcite furthermore , decoration of the surfaces of few layer tmds by metal nanoparticles like au , ag and pt may provide p- and n - type doping.@xcite the metal - atom adsorbed tmds find their application in various areas including energy storage@xcite , photonics@xcite , biosensing@xcite , and catalysis.@xcite in a recent study , it has been demonstrated that , the presence of various impurities at the interface between mos@xmath0/graphene / hbn and ws@xmath0/graphene / hbn heterostructures may modify the mobility of charge carriers.@xcite it was also reported that contamination and migration of various molecules are inevitable during the formation of graphene based heterostructures and trapped hydrocarbons segregate into isolated pockets , leaving the rest of the interface atomically clean .
@xcite in addition , it was found that , attached metal nanoparticles on tmds / graphene stacks can be suitable for enhanced optoelectronic properties.@xcite despite some recent studies on adatom adsorption on various tmds , intercalation and migration of foreign atoms in heterostructures have not been investigated . in this study , using density functional theory based electronic structure method , we investigate the diffusion characteristics of heavy metal atoms ( au and ag ) on monolayers and intercalated in such bilayer heterostructures .
the paper is organized as follows : in sec .
[ sec2 ] we give details of our computational methodology . in sec .
[ sec3 ] the energetics of the metal atoms ag and au on monolayers of graphene and tmds are presented . in sec .
[ sec4 ] diffusion characteristics of those metal atoms inside bilayer heterostructures are shown and in sec . [ sec5 ] we summarize and conclude our results .
to determine ground state atomic structures and migration characteristics of monolayers and their bilayer heterostructures , first - principles calculations were performed using density functional theory ( dft ) with a plane - wave basis set as implemented in the vienna ab initio simulation package ( vasp).@xcite for the exchange correlation function generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) of perdew , burke and ernzerhof@xcite was used together with the van der waals correction.@xcite spin - unpolarized calculations were carried out using projector - augmented - wave potentials ( paw ) . the plane - wave basis set with kinetic energy cutoff of 500 ev was used . a 4@xmath14 and 3@xmath13 hexagonal supercells of single layer and bilayer structures are employed to model diffusion paths of metal atoms , respectively .
the k - point samples were 3@xmath13@xmath11 for these supercells .
it is calculated that a 12 of vacuum space is enough to hinder long - range dispersion forces between two adjacent images in the supercell .
lattice constants and total energies were computed with the conjugate gradient method , where atomic forces and total energies were minimized .
the convergence criterion of our calculations for ionic relaxations is @xmath2 ev between two consecutive steps .
the maximum hellmann - feynman forces acting on each atom were reduced to a value of less than @xmath3 ev / .
all components of the external pressure in the unit cell was held below 1 kbar . for the electronic density of states
gaussian smearing was used with a broadening of 0.1 ev .
the non - local correlation energies were determined by employing density functional theory plus the long - range dispersion correction ( dft+d2 ) method.@xcite the values of 24.670 , 5.570 , 12.640 , 1.750 , 24.670 , 40.620 , and 40.620 are used as the c@xmath4 coefficient of mo , s , se , c , ag , au , and w atoms , respectively . on the other hand , values of 1.639 , 1.683 , 1.771 , 1.452 , 1.639 , 1.772 , and 1.772 are used for the vdw radius of mo , s , se , c , ag , au , and w atoms , respectively .
these c@xmath4 coefficients and vdw radii were determined from previous studies .
@xcite it is essential that long - range dispersion correction to the interlayer force is taken into account in order to obtain reliable layer - layer distances and electronic properties of the heterobilayers . to study the adsorption and diffusion of metal atoms in these systems , total energies of monolayer tmds ( graphene ) with adatom were calculated for 19 ( 12 ) different points which include the high symmetry points ( h , m , b , and t ) .
total energies of bilayers with adatom were calculated for only 4 high symmetry points . in these different points ,
the adatom - surface distance was fully relaxed while the position of the adatoms parallel to the surface was kept fixed . to obtain accurate diffusion characteristics of heavy atoms on monolayer tmds and graphene ,
calculations were performed using 4x4 supercells . in these calculations , first and second nearest neighbors of the adatom were fully relaxed while all the rest was kept fixed .
on the other hand , in the bilayer calculations , all atoms of bilayers were free to move in all directions .
binding energies were calculated for the most favorable adsorption sites .
these binding energies were calculated from the expression @xmath5 , where e@xmath6 is the binding energy of the metal atoms on the tmds or graphene , e@xmath7 is the energy of monolayer tmds or graphene , e@xmath8 is the energy of metal atoms , e@xmath9 is the total energy of the metal atom - monolayer system .
we have chosen the following convention to define the diffusion energy barrier .
the binding energy of an adatom was calculated at all high - symmetry points of the tmds and the graphene surface .
since adatoms follow the lowest energy path , the difference of the energies between the most favorable site and the second most favorable site was considered as the diffusion energy barrier . in order to obtain the correct value of the charge transferred between the metal atoms , the tmds and the graphene , bader charge analysis was performed . rather than electronic orbitals in bader methodology , charge partitioning
is based on electronic charge density and therefore it is highly efficient , it scales linearly with the number of grid points , and is more robust than other partitioning schemes.@xcite
so far , experiments have revealed that similar to graphene many of the tmds ( mos@xmath0 , mose@xmath0 , ws@xmath0 , wse@xmath0 , res@xmath0 ) have a lamellar crystal structure where the layers are held together by weak van der waals forces , while intra - layer metal - chalcogen bonds have strong covalent character . due to the weakly ( vdw )
bonded layered structure of graphene and tmds either diffusion of foreign atoms on their surface or easy intercalation into the layers may take place .
moreover , these foreign atoms may provide new functionalities to the tmds and to the heterostructures made of various layered materials .
therefore , understanding how foreign atoms adsorb , migrate and intercalate are of highly importance .
first we calculate the binding and migration of ag and au atoms on the surface of monolayer tmds and graphene .
for a hexagonal primitive unitcell of mos@xmath0 , mose@xmath0 , ws@xmath0 and graphene the lattice parameters are calculated to be 3.190 , 3.316 , 3.179 and 2.468 , respectively . for calculations of adsorption and migration of metal atoms
4@xmath14 supercells were used in order to limit au - au ( and ag - ag ) interaction between adjacent cells . as shown in fig .
[ structures ] for a metal atom adsorbed on tmds and graphene , there are four possible adsorption sites : top of carbon or chalcogen atom ( t ) , bridge site on c - c or m - x bond ( b ) , on top of the center of hollow site ( h ) and on top of metal atom mo or w ( m )
. diffusion and mobility of impurities on a two - dimensional crystal surface can be described by quantities such as activation energy ( @xmath10 ) and jump probability ( @xmath11 ) from the binding site over the lowest - barrier path at room temperature .
the @xmath11 value is a measure of the possibility of propagation by overcoming the energy barrier among the possible adsorption sites .
jump probability from one lattice site to another one can be calculated by using the formula @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the boltzmann constant and it increases exponentially with increasing temperature . here
@xmath10 is the activation energy which is equal to the difference of the energy of the two lowest energy states . our calculated adsorption sites , binding energies , vertical adsorption position , charge transfer , energy barrier and jump probability ( @xmath11 ) values are listed in table [ table1 ] .
we see that the bonding of an ag atom to graphene occurs at the b site and the h site is the least favorable adsorption site . in accordance with the previous dft study , we found that the binding energy of au on graphene is almost twice the binding energy of ag on graphene .
the ag atoms lose ( while the au atoms gain ) a small amount of charge when they bind to the graphene surface.@xcite on the surface of tmds , the most favorable bonding site for ag atoms is the h site and the next largest adsorption energy is found for the m site .
it is reasonable to assume that metal atoms diffuse through these two favorable adsorption sites .
therefore the energy difference between these two lowest - energy sites can be regarded as the diffusion barrier .
since the energy barrier for ag between h and m sites is high ( @xmath1450 mev ) diffusion through these symmetry points may not occur at low temperatures .
it appears from fig .
[ ag - hesap ] that ag atoms on graphene migrate through the b and t sites with almost zero ( @xmath142 mev ) energy barrier , while migration on tmds ( mos@xmath0 , mose@xmath0 and ws@xmath0 ) occurs through h and m sites .
as shown in table [ table1 ] , room temperature @xmath11 values of ag atoms are 0.129 , 0.182 , 0.072 and 0.926 for mos@xmath0 , mose@xmath0 , ws@xmath0 and graphene , respectively .
thus diffusion of the ag atoms on graphene occurs much more easily than on tmds .
binding energy of a single au atom on graphene and tmds is found to be @xmath14300 mev larger than that of ag .
interestingly , on mose@xmath0 , au atoms prefer bonding on the h site like ag atoms , while the top of a sulfur atom ( t site ) is the most preferable site on mos@xmath0 and ws@xmath0 layers .
the distinctive behavior of the au atoms can be explained by the distinctive characteristic of the s - au bond . although the chemical properties of chalcogen atoms s and se are quite similar , as shown by yee et al.@xcite , the strength of the s - au bond is slightly weaker than the se - au bond .
our calculations reveal that the binding energy of an au atom on mose@xmath0 surface is higher than the binding energy of an au atom on mos@xmath0 and ws@xmath0 surfaces .
interestingly , strong au - s bonds require bonding on t site while the au - se bond results in h - site adsorption . as shown in fig.[au - hesap ] , as in the ag adsorption case , mos@xmath0 and ws@xmath0 surfaces have almost identical characteristics for au adsorption at all high symmetry points .
in addition , the migration barrier seen by au atoms is @xmath1430 mev larger than the energy barrier of ag atoms on graphene . therefore , compared to ag on graphene ,
the smaller jump probability of au atoms on graphene implies relatively slow and smaller nucleation of au clusters on graphene which agrees with experimental results.@xcite [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] next we investigate the diffusion and energy barriers which are seen by ag and au atoms sandwiched in between single layers of tmds .
there are two possible stacking types for bilayer tmds ; aa and ab stacking . in the aa
stacking , the chalcogen atom ( s or se ) in one layer is on top of the chalcogen atom ( s or se ) of the other layer . on the other hand , in ab stacking , chalcogen atom ( s or se ) in one layer
is on top of the metal atoms ( mo or w ) of the other layer .
our calculations show that for the considered bilayer heterostructures of tmds , the ab stacking is the ground state geometry . _
mos@xmath15/mos@xmath15 bilayers : _ the lattice parameter of ab - stacked bilayer mos@xmath15/mos@xmath15 structure was found to be almost the same as of monolayer mos@xmath15 .
it is seen that the ag - mos@xmath15 distance decreases due to the presence of the upper mos@xmath15 layer .
the layer - layer distance of bilayer mos@xmath0 increases from 3.08 to 3.70 upon single ag intercalation . on the other hand ,
single au atom causes a larger layer separation ( from 3.08 to 4.12 ) than ag atoms .
our calculations revealed that the most preferable site of the ag atom remains the h - site , even after the addition of the second layer .
our charge analysis showed that metal atoms tend to donate a larger amount of charge when they are intercalated in bilayers .
the amount of charge transfer becomes 0.42@xmath16 and 0.15@xmath16 for ag and au atoms , respectively .
however , it is worthwhile to note that the preferable adsorption site for au atoms changes from t to b site .
au atoms tend to bind with two s atoms that are in two different layers . for this reason ,
the b - site is the most favorable site .
the minimum diffusion barrier of ag atom is increased by @xmath14 170 mev after the addition of the second layer .
interestingly diffusion barriers of the ag atom between bilayer mos@xmath15 from h to m and h to t sites are the same .
the minimum diffusion barrier of au atom is reduced by half when a second layer is added .
these results show that the diffusion behavior of ag and au atoms between bilayer mos@xmath0 are completely different .
ag atoms are not likely to form clusters inside the bilayer mos@xmath0 . on the other hand
, au atoms may form clusters between two mos@xmath0 layers and the clusterization weight of them is larger than that on single layer of mos@xmath0 . _
mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 bilayers : _ for the geometry optimization of the mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 bilayer structure we performed full atomic and lattice parameter relaxation and therefore internal strain due to lattice mismatch is lowered to less than 1 kb . the lattice parameter of mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 is calculated to be 3.252 . for this lattice parameter ,
the maximum lattice mismatch is @xmath142@xmath17 which is in the range of experimentally available strain values .
when au and ag atoms are intercalated between mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 , they show the same trend ; their height above the mos@xmath0 surface are fairly close ( 1.7 for ag and 1.8 for au ) and the layer - layer distance increases from 3.1 to 3.6 and 3.7 for ag and au , respectively .
h - site is the most favorable site for ag and au atoms when they are located between mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 bilayer . when ag atom is inserted in mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 , it donates 0.41@xmath16 to neighboring tmd layers .
it appears that the majority of the charges are transfered to the mos@xmath15 layer .
similarly the au atom loses 0.13@xmath16 charge when inserted between mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 .
the minimum diffusion barrier of ag atom is increased by @xmath14 150 mev when the second layer is present .
but the second favorable site does not change with the addition of the mose@xmath15 layer ( m ) .
the minimum diffusion barrier of au atom increases from 23 to 75 mev with mose@xmath15 addition .
second favorable site of au atom changes from h to b site when mose@xmath15 layer is added .
similar to mos@xmath0/mos@xmath0 , the jump probability of ag atom becomes zero with the addition of mose@xmath0 as a second layer .
the @xmath11 value of au atom decreases from 0.411 to 0.055 with the addition of mose@xmath0 layer .
therefore , the formation of ag cluster between mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 bilayer heterostructure is hindered by the presence of the second layer .
the nucleation of au clusters may happen with a slower nucleation rate in mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 as compared to monolayer mos@xmath15 . _
mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 bilayers : _ the lattice mismatch between mos@xmath15 and ws@xmath15 is negligible and the lattice parameter of the bilayer structure was calculated to be 3.182 . both au and
ag atoms prefer to be bonded on the h site 1.85 away from the surface of mos@xmath15 .
when ag and au atoms are inserted between mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 , the interlayer distances increase from 3.09 to 3.71 and 3.74 , respectively .
we found that the ag atom donates 0.41 @xmath16 to the surrounding mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 bilayer structure whereas the amount of charge transfer is 0.18 @xmath16 for au .
the minimum diffusion barrier of the ag atom increases @xmath14 190 mev with the addition of ws@xmath15 layer , but it does not change the second favorable site of ag atom ( m ) . it is seen that the addition of the ws@xmath15 layer does not have any significant effect on the minimum diffusion barrier of the au atom . in this case , the change of the @xmath11 value of the ag atom shows the same trend with bilayer mos@xmath15 and mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 . in these cases ,
the @xmath11 value of ag atom becomes zero with the addition of the second layer ( ws@xmath15 in this case ) .
on the other hand , addition of a ws@xmath15 layer does not change the @xmath11 value of the au atom between mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 , significantly . as a result ,
ag atoms are not likely to form clusters when intercalated in mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 , while the clusterization probability of au atoms does almost not change with ws@xmath15 layer addition .
we found that the binding energy of ag and au atoms is maximum when they are placed on mos@xmath0 and mose@xmath0 , respectively and the binding energy of these atoms on graphene is lower than that on tmds .
ag atoms prefer to bind at the h site on tmds , while the h and the t sites are most favorable adsorption sites for au atoms . just as for the ag atom , au atom binds to h site on mose@xmath0
. however , au atom binds to t site on mos@xmath0 and ws@xmath0 . when ag atom adsorbs on these monolayers , it tends to donate charge , whereas au atom tends to receive charge from these monolayers .
calculated @xmath11 values revealed that , clusterization tendency of ag and au are the largest on graphene and mos@xmath0 layers , respectively .
addition of a second layer has a considerable effect on the diffusion phenomena of ag and au atoms .
ag atom binds to h site of all tmds heterostructures , whereas it binds to m site of the mos@xmath15/graphene heterostructure .
when an au atom is inserted between mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 and mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 heterostructures , h site is the energetically most favorable site .
b and t sites are the most favorable sites for the au atom when it is placed between mos@xmath15/mos@xmath15 and mos@xmath15/graphene heterostructures
. the clusterization probability of ag atom becomes zero when tmds are added as a second layer .
on the other hand , the @xmath11 value of ag atom increases with the addition of a graphene layer .
addition of a graphene layer hinders diffusion of au atom .
ws@xmath0 addition as a second layer , does not make a significant effect on the cluster formation probability of au atom .
addition of mose@xmath0 as a second layer reduces the clusterization of au , whereas the addition of a second mos@xmath0 layer increases it .
our calculated intercalation energies showed that , when au and ag atoms are inserted between mos@xmath15/graphene , mos@xmath15/mos@xmath15 , mos@xmath15/mose@xmath15 or mos@xmath15/ws@xmath15 , they are energetically more stable as compared to the case where ag and au atoms are adsorbed on the monolayer substrates . the energy barrier for au atoms is lower than the one for ag atoms , when they are inserted between tmd heterostructures . on the other hand ,
the energy barrier of ag atoms is lower than the energy barrier of au atoms when they are inserted between mos@xmath0/graphene .
tunability of diffusion barriers seen by adatoms in van der waals heterostructures makes these materials potential hosts for controlled growth of nanoclusters .
this work was supported by the flemish science foundation ( fwo - vl ) and the methusalem foundation of the flemish government .
computational resources were provided by tubitak ulakbim , high performance and grid computing center ( tr - grid e - infrastructure ) , and hpc infrastructure of the university of antwerp ( calcua ) a division of the flemish supercomputer center ( vsc ) , which is funded by the hercules foundation .
is supported by a fwo pegasus marie curie fellowship .
f.i . and r.t.s .
acknowledge the support from tubitak project 111t318 .
99 k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , y. zhang , s. v. dubonos , i. v. grigorieva , and a. a. firsov , science * 306 * , 666 ( 2004 ) . k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos , and a. a. firsov , nature * 438 * , 197 ( 2005 )
. k. i. bolotin , k. j. sikes , j. hone , h. l. stormer , and p. kim , phys . rev . lett . * 101 * , 096802 ( 2008 )
. k. s. novoselov , z. jiang , y. zhang , s. v. morozov , h. l. stormer , u. zeitler , j. c. maan , g. s. boebinger , p. kim , and a. k. geim , science * 315 * , 1379 ( 2007 ) . c. lee , x. wei , j. w. kysar , and j. hone , science * 321 * , 385 ( 2008 ) . j. h. seol , i. jo , a. l. moore , l. lindsay , z. h. aitken , m. t. pettes , x. li , z. yao , r. huang , d. broido , n. mingo , r. s. ruoff , and l. shi , science * 328 * , 213 ( 2010 ) . j. o. sofo , a. s. chaudhari , and g. d. barber , phys .
b * 75 * , 153401 ( 2007 ) . m. z. s. flores , p. a. s. autreto , s. b. legoas , and d. s. galvao , nanotechnol . *
20 * , 465704 ( 2009 ) .
r. r. nair , w. ren , r. jalil , i. riaz , v. g. kravets , l. britnell , p. blake , f. schedin , a. s. mayorov , s. yuan , m. i. katsnelson , h. m. cheng , w. strupinski , l. g. bulusheva , a. v. okotrub , i. v. grigorieva , a. n. grigorenko , k. s. novoselov , and a. k. geim , small * 6 * , 2877 ( 2010 ) . h. sahin , m. topsakal , and s. ciraci , phys . rev .
b * 83 * , 115432 ( 2011 ) .
h. peelaers , a. d. hernandez - nieves , o. leenaerts , b. partoens , and f. m. peeters , appl .
lett . * 98 * ,
051914 ( 2011 ) . h. sahin , and s. ciraci , j. phys .
c * 116 * , 24075 ( 2012 ) .
a. kara , h. enriquez , a. p. seitsonen , l. c. l. y. voon , s. vizzini , b. aufray , and h. oughaddou , surf .
sci . rep . *
67 * , 1 ( 2012 ) .
h. sahin , s. cahangirov , m. topsakal , e. bekaroglu , e. akturk , r. t. senger , and s. ciraci phys .
b * 80 * , 155453 ( 2009 )
. l. f. mattheiss , phys .
b * 8 * , 3719 ( 1973 ) . m. chhowalla , h. s. shin , g. eda , l. j. li , k. p. loh , and h. zhang , nat .
chem . * 5 * , 263 ( 2013 ) .
y. ma , y. dai , m. guo , c. niu , y. zhu , and b. huang , acs nano * 6 ( 2 ) * , 1695 ( 2012 ) .
s. tongay , h. sahin , c. ko , a. luce , w. fan , k. liu , j. zhou , y. s. huang , c. h. ho , j. yan , d. f. ogletree , s. aloni , j. ji , s. li , j. li , f. m. peeters , and j. wu , nat . commun . * 5 * , 3252 ( 2014 ) .
b. sipos , a. f. kusmartseva , a. akrap , h. berger , l. forro , and e. tutis , nat . mater . * 7 * , 960 ( 2008 ) .
r. a. jishi , and h. m. alyahyaei , phys .
b * 78 * , 144516 ( 2008 ) .
a. splendiani , l. sun , y. zhang , t. li , j. kim , c. y. chim , g. galli , and f. wang , nano lett .
* 10 * , 1271 ( 2010 ) .
e. cappelluti , r. roldan , j. a. silva - guillen , p. ordejon , and f. guinea , phys . rev .
b * 88 * , 075409 ( 2013 ) .
h. sahin , s. tongay , s. horzum , w. fan , j. zhou , j. li , j. wu , and f. m. peeters , phys .
b * 87 * , 165409 ( 2013 ) .
s. das , h. y. chen , a. v. penumatcha , and j. appenzeller , nano lett . * 13 * , 100 ( 2013 ) .
b. radisavljevic , a. radenovic , j. brivio , v. giacometti , and a. kis , nat . nanotechnol .
* 6 * , 147 ( 2011 ) .
h. fang , s. chuang , t. c. chang , k. takei , t. takahashi , and a. javey , nano lett .
* 12 * , 3788 ( 2012 ) .
a. k. geim , intern .
b * 25 * , 4055 ( 2011 ) .
a. k. geim , and i. v. grigorieva , nature * 499 * , 419 ( 2013 ) .
h. terrones , f. lpez - uras , and m. terrones , sci .
rep . * 3 * , 1549 ( 2013 ) .
s. j. haigh , a. gholinia , r. jalil , s. romani , l. britnell , d. c. elias , k. s. novoselov , l. a. ponomarenko , a. k. geim , and r. gorbachev , nat . mat . * 11 * , 764 ( 2012 ) .
l. britnell , r. v. gorbachev , r. jalil , b. d. belle , f. schedin , a. mishchenko , t. georgiou , m. i. katsnelson , l. eaves , s. v. morozov , n. m. r. peres , j. leist , a. k. geim , k. s. novoselov and l. a. ponomarenko science * 335 * , 947 ( 2012 ) . c. dean , a. f. young , l. wang , i. meric , g. h. lee , k. watanabe , t. taniguchi , k. shepard , p. kim , and j. hone , solid state commun .
* 152 * , 1275 ( 2012 ) .
t. georgiou , r. jalil , b. d. belle , l. britnell , r. v. gorbachev , s. v. morozov , y. j. kim , a. gholinia , s. j. haigh , o. makarovsky , l. eaves , l. a. ponomarenko , a. k. geim , k. s. novoselov and a. mishchenko , nat . nanotechnol . * 8 * , 100 ( 2012 ) .
y. ma , y. dai , w. wei , c. niu , l. yu , and b. huang , j. phys .
c * 115 ( 41 ) * , 20237 ( 2011 ) .
x. li , y. dai , y. ma , s. han , and b. huang , phys .
* 16 * , 4230 ( 2014 ) .
p. joensen , r. f. frindt , and s. r. morrison , mat .
* 21 * , 457 ( 1986 ) .
w. jaegermann , c. h. pettenkofer , a. schellenberger , c. a. papageorgopoulos , m. kamaratos , d. vlachos , and y. tomm , chem .
. lett . * 221 * , 441 ( 1994 ) .
k. k. tiong , y. s. huang , and c. h. ho , journal of alloys and compounds * 317 * , 208 ( 2001 )
. v. v. ivanovskaya , a. zobelli , a. gloter , n. brun , v. serin , and c. colliex , phys .
b * 78 * , 134104 ( 2008 ) . c. n. r. rao , h. s. s. r. matte , r. voggu , and a. govindaraj , dalton transactions * 41
* , 5089 ( 2012 ) .
y. shi , j. k. huang , l. jin , y. t. hsu , s. f. yu , l. j. li , and h. y. yang , sci .
rep . * 3 * , 1839 ( 2013 ) .
j. kim , s. byun , a. j. smith , j. yu , and j. huang , j. phys .
lett . * 4 * , 1227 ( 2013 ) .
h. s. s. matte , u. maitra , p. kumar , b. g. rao , k. pramoda , and c.n.r .
rao , zeitschrift fr anorganische und allgemeine chemie * 638 * , 2617 ( 2012 ) .
f. huang , and j. j. baumberg , nano lett .
* 10 * , 1787 ( 2010 ) .
h. qian , y. zhu , and r. jin , proceedings of the national academy of sciences * 109 * , 696 ( 2012 ) .
s. he , k. k. liu , s. su , j. yan , x. mao , d. wang , y. he , l. j. li , s. song , and c. fan , analytical chem . * 84 * , 4622 ( 2012 ) .
y. c. lu , z. xu , h. a. gasteiger , s. chen , k. hamad - schifferli , and y. shao - horn , j. american chem .
society * 132 * , 12170 ( 2010 ) .
a. v. kretinin , y. cao , j. s. tu , g. l. yu , r. jalil , k. s. novoselov , s. j. haigh , a. gholinia , a. mishchenko , m. lozada , t. georgiou , c. r. woods , f. withers , p. blake , g. eda , a. wirsig , c. hucho , k. watanabe , t. taniguchi , a. k .
geim , and r. v. gorbachev , nano lett .
* 14 ( 6 ) * , 3270 ( 2014 ) .
s. j. haigh , a. gholinia , r. jalil , s. romani , l .britnell , d. c. elias , k. s. novoselov , l. a. ponomarenko , a. k. geim , and r. gorbachev , nat .
11 * , 764 ( 2012 ) .
l. britnell , r. m. ribeiro , a. eckmann , r. jalil , b. d. belle , a. mishchenko , y. j. kim , r. v. gorbachev , t. georgiou , s. v. morozov , a. n. grigorenko , a. k. geim , c. casiraghi , a. h. c. neto , and k. s. novoselov , science * 340 * , 1311 ( 2013 )
. b. sachs , l. britnell , t. o. wehling , a. eckmann , r. jalil , b. d. belle , a. i lichtenstein , m. i. katsnelson , and k. s. novoselov , appl .
. lett . * 103 * , 251607 ( 2013 ) .
g. kresse and j. furthmller , phys .
b * 54 * , 11169 ( 1996 ) .
j. p. perdew , k. burke , and m. ernzerhof , phys .
* 77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) .
s. grimme , j. comp . chem . * 27 * , 1787 ( 2006 ) .
m. amft , s. lebegue , o. eriksson , and n. v. skorodumova , j. phys .
* 23 * , 395001 ( 2011 ) . g. henkelman , a. arnaldsson , and h. jnsson , comp .
sci . * 36 * , 354 ( 2006 ) .
w. tang , e. sanville , and g. henkelman , j. phys .
: condensed mat . * 21 * , 084204 ( 2009 ) .
e. sanville , s. d. kenny , r. smith , and g. henkelman , j. comp . chem . * 28 * , 899 ( 2007 ) .
k. nakada and a. ishii , isbn 978 ( 2011 ) . c. k. yee , a. ulman , j. d. ruiz , a. parikh , h. white , and m. rafailovich , langmuir * 19 * , 9450 ( 1992 ) .
k. s. subrahmanyam , a. k. manna , and s. k. pati chem .
. lett . * 497 * , 70 ( 2010 ) .
b. g. rao , h. s. s. r. matte , and c. n. r. rao , j. cluster sci .
* 23.3 * , 929 ( 2012 ) .
h. p. komsa and a. v. krasheninnikov , phy .
b * 88 * , 085318 ( 2013 ) . c. gong , c. huang , j. miller , l. cheng , y. hao , d. cobden , j. kim , r. s. ruoff , r. m. wallace , k. cho , x. xu and y. j. chabal , acs nano * 7 * , 11350 ( 2013 ) . | the diffusive motion of metal nanoparticles au and ag on monolayer and between bilayer heterostructures of transition metal dichalcogenides and graphene are investigated in the framework of density functional theory .
we found that the minimum energy barriers for diffusion and the possibility of cluster formation depend strongly on both the type of nanoparticle and the type of monolayers and bilayers .
moreover , the tendency to form clusters of ag and au can be tuned by creating various bilayers .
tunability of the diffusion characteristics of adatoms in van der waals heterostructures holds promise for controllable growth of nanostructures . |
numerical relativity has made enormous progress within the last few years .
many numerical relativity groups now have sufficiently stable and accurate codes which can simulate the inspiral , merger , and ringdown phases of binary black hole coalescence .
similarly , significant progress has been made in the numerical simulation of stellar gravitational collapse and there now seems to be a much better understanding of how supernova explosions happen .
all these processes are among the most promising sources of gravitational radiation and therefore , there is significant interest in using these numerical relativity results within various data analysis pipelines used within the gravitational wave data analysis community . a dialog between numerical relativists and data analysts from the ligo scientific collaboration ( lsc ) was recently initiated in november 2006 through a meeting in boston .
it seems appropriate to continue this dialog at a more concrete level , and to start incorporating numerical relativity results within various data analysis software .
the aim of this document is to suggest formats for data exchange between numerical relativists and data analysts .
it is clear that there are still outstanding conceptual and numerical issues remaining in these numerical simulations ; the goal of this document is not to resolve them .
the goal is primarily to spell out the technical details of the waveform data so that they can be incorporated seamlessly within the data analysis software currently being developed within the lsc .
the relevant software development is being carried out as part of the lsc algorithms library which contains core routines for gravitational wave data analysis written in ansi c89 , and is distributed under the gnu general public license .
the latest version of this document is available within this library .
the remainder of this document is structured as follows : section [ sec : multipoles ] describes our conventions for decomposing the gravitational wave data in terms of spherical harmonics , section [ sec : format ] specifies the data formats for binary black hole simulations , and finally section [ sec : openissues ] enumerates some open issues in binary black hole simulations which could be topics of further discussion between data analysts and numerical relativists .
the output of a numerical relativity code is the full spacetime of a binary black hole system . on the other hand ,
what is required for gravitational wave data analysis purposes is the strain @xmath0 , as measured by a detector located far away from the source .
the quantity of interest is therefore the gravitational wave metric perturbation @xmath1 in the wave - zone , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 are space - time indices .
we always work in the transverse traceless ( tt ) gauge so that all information about the metric perturbation is contained in the tt tensor @xmath4 , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are spatial indices .
the wave falls off as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the distance from the source : @xmath9 here @xmath10 is a transverse traceless tensor and @xmath11 is the total mass of the system ; this approximation is , naturally , only valid far away from the source .
there are different methods for extracting @xmath4 from a numerical evolution .
one common method is to use the complex weyl tensor component @xmath12 which is related to the second time derivative of @xmath4 .
another method is to use the zerilli function which approximates the spacetime in the wave - zone as a perturbation of a schwarzschild spacetime . for our purposes , it is not important how the wave is extracted , and different numerical relativity groups are free to use methods they find appropriate .
the starting point of our analysis are the multipole moments of @xmath4 and it is important to describe explicitly our conventions for the multipole decomposition .
in addition to these multipole moments , we also request the corresponding values of @xmath12 or the zerilli function in the formats described later .
let @xmath13 be a cartesian coordinate system in the wave zone , sufficiently far away from the source .
let @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 denote the spatial orthonormal coordinate basis vectors . given this coordinate system ,
we define standard spherical coordinates @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the inclination angle from the @xmath19-axis and @xmath20 is the phase angle . at this point , we have not specified anything about the source .
in fact , the source could be a binary system , a star undergoing gravitational collapse or anything else that could be of interest for gravitational wave source modeling . in a later section
we will specialize to binary black hole systems and suggest possibilities for some of the various choices that have to be made . however , as far as possible , these choices are eventually to be made by the individual source modeling group .
we break up @xmath4 into modes in this coordinate system . in the wave zone , the wave will be propagating in the direction of the radial unit vector @xmath21 in the transverse traceless gauge , @xmath4 has two independent polarizations @xmath22 where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the usual basis tensors for transverse - traceless tensors in the wave frame @xmath25 it is convenient to use the combination @xmath26 , which is related to @xmath12 by two time derivatives as @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the weyl tensor and @xmath29 denote abstract spacetime indices .
if we denote the unit timelike normal to the spatial slice as @xmath30 and the promotions of @xmath31 to the full spacetime as @xmath32 , then the null tetrad adapted to the constant @xmath8 spheres is @xmath33 where @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 is the complex conjugate of @xmath38 . ]
@xmath39 it can be shown that @xmath40 can be decomposed into modes using spin weighted spherical harmonics @xmath41 of weight -2 : @xmath42 the expansion parameters @xmath43 are complex functions of the retarded time @xmath44 and , if we fix @xmath8 to be the radius of the sphere at which we extract waves , then @xmath43 are functions of @xmath45 only .
the explicit expression for the spin weighted spherical harmonics in terms of the wigner @xmath46-functions is @xmath47 where @xmath48^{1/2}}{(\ell + m -k)!(\ell - s - k)!k!(k+s - m ) ! } \times \left(\cos\left(\frac{\iota}{2}\right)\right)^{2\ell+m - s-2k}\left(\sin\left(\frac{\iota}{2}\right)\right)^{2k+s - m}\ ] ] with @xmath49 and @xmath50 . for reference ,
@xmath51 the mode expansion coefficients @xmath43 are given by @xmath52 if @xmath12 is used for wave extraction , then @xmath43 is given by two time integrals of the corresponding mode of @xmath12 . in this case , it is important that the information provided contains details about how the integration constants are chosen .
we define @xmath53 and @xmath54 as @xmath55 it is these modes @xmath56 of @xmath57 and @xmath58 that we suggest to be provided as functions of time in units of @xmath11 .
let us now specialize in simulations of binary black hole coalescence .
a numerical relativity simulation has many parameters that need to be specified , and several of them may not be directly relevant to the data analysis problem .
we need to specify which parameters of the numerical simulation will be significantly useful for the astrophysics of a binary black hole system in a circular orbit . for our purposes ,
a single numerical waveform is defined by at least seven parameters : the mass ratio @xmath59 and the three components of the individual spins @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
these parameters will be referred to as the `` metadata '' for a waveform ; more parameters can be added as necessary .
we use the convention that @xmath62 denotes the larger of the two masses so that @xmath63 . the choice of precisely how @xmath62 , @xmath64 and the spins are calculated is left up to the individual numerical relativity groups .
in addition , the start frequency @xmath65 of the waveform , in units of @xmath11 , is an important parameter relevant for data analysis . for a given value of the mass ,
this gives the physical start frequency of the waveform , and this will need to be lesser than the lower cut - off frequency relevant for a particular detector .
for example , @xmath66hz is an appropriate value appropriate for the initial ligo detectors . for the wavfeorm data itself , we suggest the data for a single mode @xmath56 to be written as a plain text file in three columns for the time @xmath45 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 respectively . for a given simulation , numerical groups may wish to decide the maximum value of @xmath69 to which they will provide the waveform . from the data analysis standpoint
, it is most useful that for every @xmath70 , waveforms are provided for all values of @xmath71 , irrespective of any symmetries that may be present in the simulation .
if there are certain modes which , due to small amplitude , can not be accurately determined , these can be set to zero .
numerical groups often extract the waveform from the simulation at several different radii and then use richardson extrapolation to determine the most accurate waveform . for data analysis purposes , we do not consider waveforms from different radii as distinct , and would prefer only the most accurate determination of the waveform from any given simulation .
it is natural to use the total mass @xmath11 of the binary as the unit for the time and strain columns .
however , there can be subtleties in the choice of @xmath11
. it could be the adm mass of the spacetime , an approximation to the adm mass measured at the wave - extraction sphere , or it could be the sum of the individual masses . again , the choice is left up to the numerical relativity group which produced the waveform , and it depends on whatever best represents the time coordinate and the scale of @xmath4 in the particular simulation . for data analysis purposes , we would prefer the sampling in time to be uniform .
if the result of a simulation , or set of simulations , yields a waveform sampled non - uniformly , we ask that the nr group performs an interpolation to give a uniformly sampled waveform .
a sampling rate of @xmath72 is usually sufficient for our purposes , but this is not a requirement .
the strain multiplied by the distance will also be in units of the total mass @xmath11 of the binary .
there can be any number of comment lines at the top of the file and it is envisioned that the details of the simulation and the mode contained in the file will be held in the comment lines .
this could be an example of a data file : .... # numerical waveform from .... # equal mass , non spinning , 5 orbits , l = m=2 # time hplus hcross 0.000000e+00 1.138725e-02 -8.319811e-04 2.000000e-01 1.138725e-02 -1.247969e-03 4.000000e-01 1.138726e-02 -1.663954e-03 6.000000e-01 1.138727e-02 -2.079936e-03 8.000000e-01 1.138728e-02 -2.495913e-03 1.000000e-00 1.138728e-02 -2.911884e-03 1.200000e+00 1.138729e-02 -3.327850e-03 1.400000e+00 1.138730e-02 -3.743807e-03 1.600000e+00 1.138731e-02 -4.159757e-03 1.800000e+00 1.138733e-02 -4.575696e-03 2.000000e+00 1.138734e-02 -4.991627e-03 2.200000e+00 1.138735e-02 -5.407545e-03 2.400000e+00 1.138737e-02 -5.823452e-03 2.600000e+00 1.138739e-02 -6.239345e-03 2.800000e+00 1.138740e-02 -6.655225e-03 3.000000e+00 1.138752e-02 -7.071059e-03 3.200000e+00 1.138754e-02 -7.486903e-03 3.400000e+00 1.138757e-02 -7.902739e-03 ...... .... the metadata information for the different datafiles will be stored in a separate file .
this metadata can contain ( at least ) two sections , one for the simulation metadata , and the other listing the filenames which correspond to the various @xmath73 modes of the waveform .
there will be a separate metadata file for each simulation .
this could be an example of a metadata file : .... [ metadata ] simulation - details = nrfile.dat nr - group = friendlynrgroup email = [email protected] mass - ratio = 1.0 spin1x = 0.0 spin1y = 0.0 spin1z = 0.5 spin2x = 0.0 spin2y = 0.8 spin2z = 0.0 freqstart22 = 0.1 [ ht - data ] 2,2 = example1_22.dat 2,1 = example1_21.dat
2,0 = example1_20.dat 2,-1 = example1_2 - 1.dat 2,-2 = example1_2 - 2.dat .... it would be desirable if the waveform data are reproducible at a later date if necessary . for this purpose , the numerical relativity groups can submit a file with the parameters of the simulation .
there is no requirement on the format of this file
. the ` simulation - details ` line will contain the name of the file describing the parameters used to describe the nr simulation .
in addition , we ask for the numerical relativity groups to provide a ` nr - group ` name and a contact ` email ` .
the remainder of the entries in the ` [ metadata ] ` section describe the physical parameters of the waveform . to begin with , for non - spinning waveforms ,
the only required parameter is the mass ratio . for waveforms with spin , the initial spins of the two black holes ( in the co - ordinates discussed in the previous section )
must also be specified .
the start frequency of the 2 - 2 mode of the waveform in units of @xmath11 is denoted by @xmath74 .
we emphasize that whenever necessary , we will add more parameters such as , for example , the eccentricity of the orbit , or start frequencies of other modes etc .
lines starting with a @xmath75 or @xmath76 will be taken to be comment lines and there can be an arbitrary number of comment lines .
the section ` [ ht - data ] ` contains one line for each @xmath73 mode .
these give the file names containing the corresponding modes .
the filenames can be specified as relative paths to the data files starting from the location of the metadata file .
thus , if the datafiles are stored in a sub - directory called ` data ` , then the metadata file would read : .... [ ht - data ] 2,2 = data / example1_22.dat 2,1 = data / example1_21.dat 2,0 = data / example1_20.dat 2,-1 = data / example1_2 - 1.dat 2,-2 = data / example1_2 - 2.dat .... if the waveforms have been calculated using @xmath12 , then for cross - checking purposes , we request that datafiles containing the real and imaginary parts of @xmath12 are also provided in the same format as for the waveforms , i.e. three columns which are respectively time , real part of @xmath12 and imaginary part of @xmath12 .
again there can be an arbitrary number of comment lines , but in this case there does not need to be a metadata file .
this data can be referenced in the metadata file in an additional section : .... [ psi4-data ] 2,2 = data / example1_psi4_22.dat 2,1 = data / example1_psi4_21.dat 2,0 = data / example1_psi4_20.dat 2,-1 = data / example1_psi4_2 - 1.dat 2,-2 = data / example1_psi4_2 - 2.dat .... similarly , if the waveforms were extracted using the zerilli formalism , a section ` [ zerilli - data ] ` would be added . to summarize , the numerical relativity groups are asked to submit a tarball containing the following information for each simulation : 1 .
: : [ required ] the data files for @xmath77 and @xmath78
one for each @xmath73 mode of the simulation .
2 . : : [ required ] the meta - data file .
3 . : : [ optional ] data files for the functions ( e.g. @xmath12 or the zerilli function ) which were used to construct @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
4 . : : [ required ] parameter file for reproducing the waveform .
we now list some open issues for binary black hole simulations which could be topics for further discussion .
we associate the coordinate system @xmath13 with the binary system as follows .
the orbital plane of the binary at @xmath81 is taken to be the @xmath82-@xmath83 plane with the @xmath19-axis in the direction of the orbital angular momentum .
* is this the best choice of the @xmath19-axis ?
would it be better to choose , say , the spin of the final black hole as the @xmath19-axis ?
the decision will be determined by requirements of simplicity and having as few modes to work with as possible . *
the orbital plane is unambiguous when the black holes are non - spinning but it can be ambiguous in many situations , especially when the spin of the black holes causes the orbital plane to precess significantly . in such cases ,
it is left to the numerical relativity group to decide what the best choice of the `` orbital plane '' is . what is the right choice for parameters such as the individual masses , the total mass and the spins ?
here are some possibilities : * @xmath62 and @xmath64 could be the parameters appearing in the initial data construction .
alternatively , for non spinning black holes , they could be the irreducible masses of the two horizons : @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the horizon area . for spinning black holes
it could be given by the christodoulou formula : @xmath86 where @xmath87 is an appropriately defined spin for the individual black holes .
the calculation of @xmath87 is again left up to the numerical relativity group .
* for the total mass @xmath11 , is it better to use the sum of individual horizon masses ( including the effect of angular momentum ) , or could it be the total adm mass or rather , an approximation to the adm mass calculated at the sphere where the waves are extracted ? this could be specified in the metadata file , for example through the additional lines + .... madm = 1.0 mchristodoulou = 0.97 .
what is the best choice for the radiation extraction sphere ? * how far away do we need to take the sphere ?
is it sufficient to take the sphere to be a coordinate sphere , or do we need some further gauge conditions ? how important is the choice of initial data ? * clearly , the initial data used in almost all current simulations do not exactly represent real astrophysical binary black hole systems .
is this deviation important for gravitational wave detection ?
how large are the error - bars on the numerical results ?
* is there a reliable way to estimate the systematic errors due to finite resolution effects , different gauge choices , wave extraction methods etc ?
numerical relativity groups are welcome to raise any other issues that might be important .
we are grateful to various numerical relativists for numerous discussions and suggestions . in particular
, we would like to thank the following people for valuable inputs to this document : peter diener , sascha husa , luis lehner , lee lindblom , carlos lousto , hiroyuki nakano , harald pfeiffer , luciano rezzolla , and erik schnetter . | this document suggests possible data formats to further the interaction between gravitational wave source modeling groups and the gravitational wave data analysis community . the aim is to have a simple format which is nevertheless sufficiently general , and is applicable to various kinds of sources including binaries of compact objects and systems undergoing gravitational collapse . .... dear colleagues , with recent advances in the fields of numerical simulations of gravitational - wave sources and gravitational wave detection , we have reached a time when closer collaborations will benefit both fields .
close interactions between these fields may enhance the chances of detecting gravitational waves , and enable us to better understand the physics and astrophysics involved .
we would like to develop a uniform interface to public waveforms produced by the source - modeling community that could be used by the ligo scientific collaboration ( lsc ) , and other detector groups . in this document
, we suggest a simple format for the waveforms .
the software tools designed around this format , by the lsc , will be released under the gpl .
we expect that data analysis groups will use the public waveforms in their analyses when appropriate .
while this interface document proposes technical standards for numerical relativity waveforms , we believe that the ability to extract the best astrophysical information from nr waveforms in gravitational wave searches will depend not just on adopting standards , but on the ability of the gravitational wave detector communities and the numerical relativity communities to interact closely and develop a sufficiently detailed understanding of each other 's technical methods and limitations . to effectively use nr waveforms , gravitational wave scientists will need to understand the physical limitations and subtleties of numerical data , and to effectively produce waveforms , numerical relativists will need to understand the instrumental limitations and subtleties of gravitational wave interferometers .
we hope that this opens the way to deeper interactions between the gw and nr communities and look forward to closer collaborations that may develop between the two communities as we explore the gravitational - wave universe together . the ligo scientific collaboration .... |
understanding how crystalline solids form from fluid phases is a problem that both poses significant intellectual challenges and is a basic input for materials science @xcite .
the standard picture implies that nanoscopic nuclei of the solid are formed due to spontaneous thermal fluctuations when the fluid density has a value exceeding the fluid density at fluid - solid coexistence . due to the cost in surface excess free energy caused by the crystal - fluid interface @xcite , a free energy barrier in phase space needs to be overcome in every event of this so - called homogeneous nucleation @xcite process . in the present paper
, we are neither concerned with the further crystal growth processes @xcite that follow after the crystal nuclei have been formed , nor shall we consider the fact that in practice heterogeneous nucleation @xcite may dominate ( since the free energy barrier may be significantly reduced for nuclei attached to the walls of the container , or to seed particles @xcite , etc . ) . due to the large value of the nucleation barrier ( which in typical cases is several ten s of the thermal energy @xmath0 @xcite ) and the nanoscopic size of these nuclei ( typically they contain only a few hundred particles @xcite )
nucleation events are rare and difficult to observe directly ( either in experiment or in simulation ) . also the detailed properties of the nuclei that are formed are non - universal and depend upon the particular system under study .
experiments often infer the nucleation rate indirectly from later stages of the process , when the phase transformation from fluid to solid reaches completion @xcite .
of course , this procedure inevitably involves questionable assumptions .
simulations of nucleation kinetics , however , often are feasible only under conditions where the barrier is only of order 10@xmath0 or less @xcite . then it is inevitable that the nuclei are extremely small and strongly fluctuating objects , for which the `` classical '' description in terms of a competition between bulk and surface free energies @xcite fails @xcite
. many of the difficulties alluded to above are already encountered when one considers nucleation of fluid droplets from a supersaturated vapor @xcite .
however , for nucleation of crystals from melts there occur three additional complications ( i ) the interface tension @xmath1 between a crystal surface and the fluid depends on the orientation of the unit vector @xmath2 normal to the surface relative to the axes of the crystal lattice @xcite .
the shape of the nucleus then is not a spherical droplet as in the case of vapor to liquid nucleation , but also exhibits anisotropy . for strong enough anisotropy , facetted nanocrystals
are expected @xcite . in general , the equilibrium crystal shape is nontrivial and can only be obtained from @xmath3 via the wulff construction @xcite .
( ii ) also kinetic processes , such as attachment of particles to the surface of a nanocrystal , may depend on the surface orientation @xcite .
if the nucleation barrier is not very high , and nucleation plus growth proceed relatively fast , crystal shapes rather different from the equilibrium shape could result @xcite .
( iii ) often , a fluid at the melting / crystallization transition is rather dense , and enhancing the density further a glass transition is encountered @xcite .
then the variation of the kinetic prefactor in the nucleation rate with density becomes an important factor @xcite .
far from the equilibrium coexistence conditions a separation of a static boltzmann factor involving the nucleation barrier and a kinetic prefactor may be impossible .
similar problems arise in other systems where the liquid to solid transition is not driven by enhancing the density , as is done in the generic case of colloids described as a hard sphere fluid @xcite , but by reducing the temperature : in fluids such as silica @xcite , triphenyl phosphite @xcite and ortho - terphenyl @xcite strong supercooling is possible and ultimately a glass transition @xcite is reached .
nucleation competing with glass formation @xcite shall not be considered here , and also the interplay of crystallization with a liquid - liquid unmixing , as it has been proposed for water and various other liquids @xcite is out of our focus .
the present paper hence is only concerned with the first problem , of predicting the nucleation barrier associated with the formation of crystalline nuclei , but avoiding the assumption that @xmath3 actually is isotropic and the nuclei are spherical . a central element of the present paper , however , is , that the nucleation barrier can be obtained directly from a careful analysis of the equilibrium conditions for the nucleus and the surrounding fluid phase @xcite . while in the thermodynamic limit this surrounding fluid phase is metastable
, we show that in finite systems there actually occurs a stable equilibrium between the small crystalline nucleus and this surrounding fluid phase .
we show , using a simple model for a suspension of colloids with short - range attractive interactions , that in this method there is no longer any need to obtain @xmath3 and to carry out the wulff construction .
while the precise shape of the crystalline nucleus is not found in this approach , nucleation barriers can be estimated with reasonable precision . in the next section
, we shall describe the model that we use , a variant of the asakura - oosawa ( ao ) model @xcite for colloid - polymer mixtures @xcite , and summarize what is known on the thermodynamic properties of this model in the bulk .
we recall here that the ao model contains the widely studied case of the hard sphere fluid as special case , but has the merit that the control parameters of the attractive part of the potential ( its depth and its range , respectively ) can easily be tuned ( experimentally this could be done by varying the concentration of polymers in the suspension , and their size via choosing different molecular weights @xcite ) .
since in this way both the density gap @xmath4 ( onset of melting of the crystal occurs at a density @xmath5 , onset of freezing of the fluid occurs at @xmath6 ) and the interfacial tension @xmath3 can be varied over a wide range , the system qualifies as a model suitable to stringently test the theory . in section 3 , the preparation of the inhomogeneous systems , where a crystalline nucleus coexists with surrounding fluid in a finite simulation box , is described in detail , since the equilibration of such systems exhibiting two - phase coexistence is notoriously difficult @xcite .
we also introduce the local bond orientational order parameters @xcite that are used to identify ( in each system configuration that needs to be further analyzed ) where the crystalline nucleus ( and its interface separating it from the surrounding fluid ) is located .
note that the identification of interfaces between coexisting phases at the single particle level involves important ambiguities @xcite ; we feel that previous work where the estimation of the nucleation barrier as function of the nucleus size was attempted , based on such methods , possibly somewhat suffered from this ambiguity . in sec .
4 the thermodynamic method utilized in the present paper , where the density @xmath7 , pressure @xmath8 , and chemical potential @xmath9 of the liquid surrounding the crystal nucleus are accurately estimated , for a wide range of total particle densities @xmath10 ( varying the simulation box volume @xmath11 for several choices of the number @xmath12 of colloidal particles ) . we explain how from an analysis of this equilibrium we can infer both the volume @xmath13 of the crystalline nucleus , and the associated free energy barrier @xmath14 . finally , in sec .
5 we give a brief summary of our results , and an outlook on further related problems .
potential @xmath15 versus distance @xmath16 between two colloidal particles , for the softeffao model , and compared to @xmath17 for the effao model . in both cases ,
@xmath18 and @xmath19 is chosen , and @xmath20 is used as unit of length.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] colloid - polymer mixtures @xcite contain three ingredients : colloidal particles , hard sphere - like in a size range from 10 nm to 1@xmath21 ; flexible polymers , which have a high enough molecular weight to form coils in solution with a radius in the range from 10@xmath22 to 100@xmath22 ; and a small molecule fluid in which the colloidal particles are suspended , and which must be chosen such that it acts as a good solvent for the polymers or a theta solvent , in which the polymers take a random walk - like structure @xcite . by suitable coating of the colloids with a surfactant layer
one can avoid polymer adsorption on the colloids , and screen out the attractive van der waals interaction between the colloids , avoiding their aggregation .
the ao model provides a simplified description of the statistical thermodynamics of such a system , representing the colloids as hard spheres of diameter @xmath23 , and the polymers as soft spheres of diameter @xmath24 .
while polymer - colloid overlap is also strictly forbidden , polymers can overlap each other with zero energy cost @xcite . as is well known the depletion effect causes an ( entropic ) effective interaction between the colloids .
note that the molecular solvent in this model is not explicitly regarded at all .
if the size ratio @xmath25 is small enough @xmath26 @xcite ) , one can derive an equivalent one - component model ( which we refer to as `` effective ao model '' in the following ) of a colloidal fluid , where the particles interact with the following effective potential : @xmath27 here @xmath16 is the radial distance between two colloidal particles , and @xmath28 the polymer fugacity ( @xmath29 is the polymer chemical potential and @xmath30 their thermal de broglie wavelength ) . in the following
we shall denote the model defined by eq .
[ eq1 ] , where the polymer degrees of freedom were integrated out and hence all information on the distribution of polymers is lost , as effective asakura - oosawa ( effao ) model . while eq .
[ eq1 ] is convenient for analytical work ( e.g. using density functional theory @xcite ) , it is cumbersome to use in simulations : the singularity of @xmath31 at @xmath32 precludes the use of the virial formula @xcite to compute the pressure in the system ( alternative methods to compute the pressure in systems containing hard particles exist @xcite but are difficult to apply and require huge numerical effort ; also the use of molecular dynamics methods @xcite would be very inconvenient ) . since real colloidal particles anyway never behave as strictly hard spheres @xcite , however ;
there is no need to stick exactly to the potential , eq .
[ eq1 ] , but one can equally well consider a model where the singular behavior at @xmath33 has been replaced by a smooth function .
thus we replace the hard core part of eq .
[ eq1 ] by the following model , called the soft effective asakura - oosawa ( softeffao ) model , while the other parts of eq .
[ eq1 ] are maintained , @xmath34\;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the constants b , @xmath35 are chosen as @xmath36 and @xmath37 ; of course , the form chosen for eq . [ eq2 ] is rather arbitrary , other functions could be used equally well .
[ fig1 ] gives a comparison of both potentials , eq .
[ eq1 ] and eq .
. for this softeffao model the application of the virial formula is straightforwardly possible , and as shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] , the equation of state of both models is very similar , for the choice @xmath18 , and @xmath38 that will be studied here .
here we have defined the packing fraction @xmath39 of the colloids and the polymer reservoir packing fraction @xmath40 as @xmath41 @xmath42 normalized pressure @xmath43 plotted vs. @xmath39 for both the effao model ( squares ) and the soft effao model ( circles ) .
full curves through the data points are guides to the eye only , and statistical errors are smaller than the size of the symbols , and hence not shown .
note that the equation of state contains two disjunct functions ; one for the liquid branch @xmath44 ) and one for the crystalline solid ( @xmath45 ) ( which has a face - centered cubic ( fcc ) structure ) , respectively .
note that the data for the liquid branch comprise also metastable states ( for @xmath46 ) and the data for the solid branch comprise metastable states as well ( for @xmath47 ) .
the coexistence pressure @xmath48 is found from the interface velocity method ( see fig .
3 ) , and the coexistence packing fractions then result from @xmath49 with @xmath50 being the inverse functions of @xmath51 .
the result for the liquid were obtained using @xmath52 colloidal particles and using both the npt ensemble and the nvt ensemble ( see text ) to show that finite size effects are negligible.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] note that @xmath40 is defined such that it would give the packing fraction of polymers @xmath53 if the simulation box would contain the ideal gas of polymers only . the pressure isotherm shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] contains two branches , the liquid branch ( at the left ) and the solid branch ( representing a face - centered cubic ( fcc ) crystal , at the right ) .
actually the solid branch was computed in the npt ensemble , choosing a cubic box with @xmath52 particles , arranged at the sites of a fcc lattice as initial condition .
simulations where only the total volume @xmath54 is allowed to fluctuate or where the simulation box linear dimensions @xmath55 in the three cartesian directions are allowed to fluctuate independently gave ( within statistical errors ) identical results for the function @xmath56 that is shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] . in our simulations , we have disregarded the alternative hexagonal close - packed ( hcp ) structure throughout , since it is not expected to be the stable phase @xcite .
of course , it nevertheless would be interesting to study crystal nuclei having the hcp structure surrounded by fluid , applying the technique of the present work , and to compare their nucleation barriers to those of fcc nuclei .
however , this interesting issue must be left to future work .
the liquid branch was obtained from both runs in the @xmath57 ensemble and in the nvt ensemble ( sampling then @xmath58 at given fixed @xmath39 from the virial expression @xcite ) . within statistical errors ,
the results from the npt and nvt ensembles agree precisely , indicating hence that finite size effects on the isotherms for @xmath59 are already negligible .
we also note that for the ranges of @xmath39 shown we never could observe a spontaneous crystallization of the liquid , nor a spontaneous melting of the solid .
this implies that the time span of the simulation runs was too short to observe a decay of a metastable phase via nucleation and growth .
it also is interesting to ask for the effect of choosing different parameters @xmath60 and @xmath35 in the potential , eq . [ eq2 ] .
one can show that increasing @xmath60 has the effect of displacing the liquid branch slightly ( and almost uniformly ) to the left .
the effect on the solid branch is much more pronounced , however , it is shifted to the left by much larger extent , and hence the width of the liquid - solid coexistence region decreases @xcite . in thermal equilibrium
, the liquid phase and the crystal in fig . [ fig2 ] can coexist at a single pressure only , @xmath61 , where also the chemical potentials @xmath62 of both phases are equal , @xmath63 but from fig . [ fig2 ] we see that there occurs an extended region of hysteresis , where either the liquid @xmath64 or the crystal @xmath65 is metastable in our simulation . hence the accurate estimation of @xmath48 is a nontrivial problem .
we follow the procedure of zykova - timan et al . @xcite by locating @xmath48 from studies of `` slab configurations '' ( fig . [ fig3 ] ) of liquid - solid coexistence in the npt ensemble .
we estimate the interface velocity from the time derivative of the volume @xmath66 as a function of pressure @xmath58 , identifying @xmath48 from the pressure for which @xmath66 changes sign ( figs .
[ fig4],[fig5 ] ) .
the initial system at each pressure is chosen as rectangular parallelepiped , @xmath67 , choosing @xmath68 , and a crystal slab of extension @xmath69 in the z - direction , with two ( 001 ) interfaces ( which for the length of the runs performed are still non - interacting , even if the crystal gradually melts ( and therefore the volume change @xmath70 increases with time , fig . [ fig4 ] ) . at each @xmath58 ,
the linear dimension @xmath71 is chosen as @xmath72 , @xmath73 being an integer @xmath74 and @xmath75 the equilibrium lattice constant at the pressure @xmath58 that we wish to test ; @xmath75 can be estimated from the crystal branch in the @xmath58 vs. @xmath39 isotherm ( fig . [ fig3 ] ) .
also @xmath76 was chosen commensurate with an integer number of crystal planes .
such a choice of linear dimensions commensurate with the crystal structure is essential , since we use periodic boundary conditions throughout , and one must avoid strain deformations of the crystalline slab . the remaining volume @xmath77 contains liquid with a density chosen according to the liquid branch on the isotherm @xmath78 for the pressure that is tested ( the precise value of @xmath79 for the initial configuration is chosen such that the particle number @xmath12 is an integer , of course ) . to prepare the initial configuration for the npt simulation of this slab configuration we actually carry out first a run in the nvt ensemble with v fixed through the initial values of @xmath71 and @xmath79 , to achieve that the liquid configurations in the crystal - liquid interfacial region also equilibrates ( only particles in the liquid region take part in this initial equilibration , carrying out about 10@xmath80 monte carlo moves , i.e. displacements of single particles ) .
snapshot picture of a effao configuration of a system with linear dimensions @xmath81 with @xmath82 , the crystal slab on the left side and the liquid on the right side . here
@xmath83 and @xmath59 was chosen , appropriate for @xmath84 .
particles belonging to the liquid are shown in blue color , particles belonging to the crystal are shown in red color , while particles in the center of the interface are displayed in green color . for the cutoff values for @xmath85 and @xmath86 refer to @xcite.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] in the simulations in the @xmath57 ensemble then all particles are considered for displacement moves , and in the volume moves all three linear dimensions @xmath87 and @xmath79 are allowed to fluctuate independently ( unlike @xcite where @xmath88 was held fixed , so only @xmath79 could fluctuate ) , but keeping @xmath73 fixed .
this procedure required an order of magnitude more statistical effort than used in @xcite .
the length of the runs was @xmath89 mc cycles ( one cycle consisted of @xmath12 particle displacement moves and one volume move ) , and in each case 100 independent runs were made .
volume change @xmath70 as a function of monte carlo ( mc ) cycles for different normalized pressures @xmath90 , as indicated in the figure , for the effective ao model ( a ) and for the soft effective ao model ( b ) .
the system contains @xmath91 colloids in each case , corresponding to @xmath92 lattice planes in x and y direction .
the solid straight lines are fits , from which @xmath93 is determined .
each curve is averaged over 100 independent runs . ]
volume change @xmath70 as a function of monte carlo ( mc ) cycles for different normalized pressures @xmath90 , as indicated in the figure , for the effective ao model ( a ) and for the soft effective ao model ( b ) .
the system contains @xmath91 colloids in each case , corresponding to @xmath92 lattice planes in x and y direction .
the solid straight lines are fits , from which @xmath93 is determined .
each curve is averaged over 100 independent runs . ]
[ fig4 ] shows that @xmath70 increases with time for low pressures ( as expected , due to the progressing melting of the crystalline slab the volume fraction of the liquid that requires more volume increases ) and for high pressures the opposite trend is observed . clearly , these data still are affected by statistical fluctuations , and there is also significant scatter in the variation of the interface velocities with pressure ( fig . [
these difficulties are a serious limitation for the accuracy with which @xmath48 can be determined .
taking also the trend with increasing number @xmath73 of planes ( and hence increasing linear dimension @xmath71 ) into account ( fig .
[ fig5]b ) , we conclude @xmath94 ( a ) velocities of volume changes @xmath95 , as determined in fig . 4 , plotted vs. @xmath58 , for different choices of @xmath73 , as indicated .
results for the effective ao model and for the soft effective ao model ( b ) are shown .
straight line fits of the data are shown , from which the transition point @xmath96 , highlighted by a horizontal straight line ) @xmath61 is estimated .
( c ) pressure @xmath58 where @xmath97 plotted vs. @xmath98 , where @xmath73 is the number of lattice planes in @xmath99 and @xmath100 direction in the box . disregarding the smallest size , the remaining data are fitted empirically to straight lines , yielding the result @xmath101 for the effao model and @xmath102 for the soft effao model . ] ( a ) velocities of volume changes @xmath95 , as determined in fig . 4 , plotted vs. @xmath58 , for different choices of @xmath73 , as indicated .
results for the effective ao model and for the soft effective ao model ( b ) are shown .
straight line fits of the data are shown , from which the transition point @xmath96 , highlighted by a horizontal straight line ) @xmath61 is estimated .
( c ) pressure @xmath58 where @xmath97 plotted vs. @xmath98 , where @xmath73 is the number of lattice planes in @xmath99 and @xmath100 direction in the box . disregarding the smallest size , the remaining data are fitted empirically to straight lines , yielding the result @xmath101 for the effao model and @xmath102 for the soft effao model . ] ( a ) velocities of volume changes @xmath95 , as determined in fig . 4 , plotted vs. @xmath58 , for different choices of @xmath73 , as indicated .
results for the effective ao model and for the soft effective ao model ( b ) are shown .
straight line fits of the data are shown , from which the transition point @xmath96 , highlighted by a horizontal straight line ) @xmath61 is estimated .
( c ) pressure @xmath58 where @xmath97 plotted vs. @xmath98 , where @xmath73 is the number of lattice planes in @xmath99 and @xmath100 direction in the box . disregarding the smallest size , the remaining data are fitted empirically to straight lines , yielding the result @xmath101 for the effao model and @xmath102 for the soft effao model.,scaledwidth=25.0% ] in our preliminary publication @xcite , slightly different values were quoted , @xmath103 ( effao model ) and @xmath104 ( soft eff ao ) relying on the empirical observation that an extrapolation against @xmath105 seemed to work best @xcite .
note , however , that there is no theoretical justification for an extrapolation against @xmath105 , one might rather expect an extrapolation against the inverse interface area should be used , as done in fig .
5c . as a caveat
, we note that if we would have chosen only the tree smallest choices of @xmath73 , one would have erroneously concluded that finite size effects on pcoex are very small , resulting in estimates significantly off .
as we shall see later , this error ( which is less than 1% ) is the most critical limitation to the accuracy that we can reach for the prediction of nucleation barriers ; however , it is by no means straightforward to obtain @xmath48 with significantly smaller errors .
knowing the coexistence pressures the corresponding packing fractions of the coexisting phase are readily found from fig .
[ fig2 ] . for the soft effective ao model ,
this implies @xmath106 the chemical potential @xmath107 of the colloids is a basic quantity for the study of phase coexistence , since ( unlike the pressure tensor ) @xmath107 is strictly spatially constant in a system in thermal equilibrium , even if the system is inhomogeneous due to the presence of interfaces , external walls , etc .
thus when we consider the coexistence of a crystalline nucleus of finite size with surrounding liquid in a simulation box , we have @xmath108 instead of eq .
[ eq4 ] , which applies in the thermodynamic limit .
we expect @xmath109 , due to the laplace pressure effect .
quantification of these differences @xmath110 , @xmath111 as function of nucleus size is one of the main aims of the present paper , which will allow us also to estimate the nucleation barrier , without identification of the crystal - liquid interface on the particle level ( sec .
4).therefore precise estimation of the chemical potential is a matter of concern .
now it is well known that the standard widom particle insertion method @xcite becomes inapplicable at liquid densities near the melting transitions , since the acceptance probability for virtual particle insertions becomes extremely small .
it was early recognized , however , that in principle one could circumvent this problem studying a system with a soft repulsive wall , since near this wall the density is reduced and hence the acceptance probability is higher @xcite . since the chemical potential near the wall must be the same as far away from the wall ( where the liquid density may be so high that particle insertions fail ) , we know the chemical potential also in the latter region . of course , the accuracy of this approach is a nontrivial problem ; the spatial extent of the region where the chemical potential can be `` measured '' covers only a small fraction of the system when the system is large .
when the system is rather small , as used in @xcite , the density shows pronounced oscillations throughout the simulation box ( `` layering '' ) , and then it is not at all clear to which bulk conditions the considered system would correspond . as a matter of fact , to our knowledge the simple idea of ref .
79 has never been convincingly validated with respect to its practical usefulness yet .
( a ) illustration of the method to compute the chemical potential of a dense colloidal fluid , using a @xmath81 geometry with two walls at @xmath112 and at @xmath113 , and periodic boundary conditions in x and y directions , for the case @xmath114 , @xmath115 and four choices of particle number ( @xmath116 and 1250 , respectively , at @xmath117 from bottom to top respectively ) . at z = 0 a soft repulsive potential acts ( eq .
[ eq3 ] ) while at @xmath113 a hard wall acts ( which causes significant layering ) .
the insert shows the regions where in each case the chemical potential @xmath107 is computed ( and demonstrates that @xmath107 is independent of @xmath118 in this region in each case , as it should be ) .
the bulk liquid packing fraction corresponding to @xmath107 can be read off from an average over the region where the packing fraction profile @xmath119 is constant , i.e. for @xmath120 in this example .
( b ) soft wall potential @xmath121 given in eq.[eq9 ] as function of distance @xmath118 in colloid diameter to the wall . ] ( a ) illustration of the method to compute the chemical potential of a dense colloidal fluid , using a @xmath81 geometry with two walls at @xmath112 and at @xmath113 , and periodic boundary conditions in x and y directions , for the case @xmath114 , @xmath115 and four choices of particle number ( @xmath116 and 1250 , respectively , at @xmath117 from bottom to top respectively ) . at z = 0 a soft repulsive potential acts ( eq .
[ eq3 ] ) while at @xmath113 a hard wall acts ( which causes significant layering ) .
the insert shows the regions where in each case the chemical potential @xmath107 is computed ( and demonstrates that @xmath107 is independent of @xmath118 in this region in each case , as it should be ) .
the bulk liquid packing fraction corresponding to @xmath107 can be read off from an average over the region where the packing fraction profile @xmath119 is constant , i.e. for @xmath120 in this example .
( b ) soft wall potential @xmath121 given in eq.[eq9 ] as function of distance @xmath118 in colloid diameter to the wall . ] fig .
[ fig6 ] now compellingly shows that the method indeed works well , for our model . at the strongly repulsive wall at the right side in fig .
[ fig6 ] , for @xmath113 , we use a weeks - chandler - anderson - type potential @xmath122 , \\
z'=l_z - z , \ ; 0 \leq z ' \leq \sigma_{w1}2^{1/6},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath123 and @xmath124 , and @xmath125 for @xmath126 .
at the weakly repulsive wall at the left side in fig . 6 , we choose a potential of the form @xmath127 + b(z ) \big)s(z ) \\
& \text{where } b(z)=16\big[1 - 10\left(\frac{z-\epsilon_{w2}}{z_c-\epsilon_{w2}}\right)^3 + 15\left(\frac{z-\epsilon_{w2}}{z_c-\epsilon_{w2}}\right)^4 \nonumber \\ & \qquad \ ; \qquad \qquad \qquad - 6\left(\frac{z-\epsilon_{w2}}{z_c-\epsilon_{w2}}\right)^5\big ] \\ & \text{and } s(z)=\frac{(z - z_c)^4}{(h+(z - z_c)^4 } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath128 @xmath129 @xmath130 @xmath131 and @xmath132 for @xmath133 .
note that neither @xmath134 nor @xmath135 exhibit a discontinuity at their cutoff values , also the force is continuous there .
due to the large range of @xmath136 and the rather smooth variation of @xmath134 the layering of the packing fraction @xmath137 quickly reaches a horizontal plateau . due to the depletion of particles near the soft wall ( and the excess density that occurs near the hard wall , where a pronounced layering is observed @xcite ) the packing fraction @xmath138 that is observed in the flat region of @xmath135 differs somewhat from the average packing fraction @xmath139 in the simulation box .
note that @xmath140 in the example shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] , we have chosen @xmath141 and @xmath142 ( from bottom to top ) , while the corresponding estimates for @xmath138 were @xmath143 and @xmath144 , respectively .
the chemical potential @xmath107 ( shown in the insert ) needs to be associated with @xmath138 , of course , since @xmath139 differs from @xmath138 by wall excess corrections , @xmath145 with @xmath146 the data given would allow precise estimation of these excess densities of the walls , @xmath147 and @xmath148 , as well , but this is out of the scope of the present paper .
we rather emphasize that near the left wall , where @xmath119 gradually rises to @xmath138 , we can use a significantly broad slab ( of a width @xmath149 of the order @xmath150 ) where @xmath119 is small enough that the widom particle insertion method allows an accurate sampling of the chemical potential .
although @xmath119 is rapidly varying in these intervals of @xmath118 where the sampling of @xmath107 is done , we do find that @xmath107 is nicely constant in each case , the statistical fluctuations being smaller than the thickness of the horizontal straight lines shown in the insert.although this method relies only on a small fraction @xmath151 of the volume that is simulated , nevertheless a satisfying accuracy of the function @xmath152 in the fluid phase is reached .
one could have chosen a soft wall potential at both walls , and thus improve the statistics for the estimation of the chemical potential somewhat .
such a choice would in particular be necessary in cases where complete wetting of the fluid at melting conditions at the hard walls occur , since then there would be an extended range of strong layering . in our case
, the layering extends over a few particle diameters only , and thus does not matter .
( a ) chemical potential @xmath107 ( in units of @xmath0 ) plotted vs. packing fraction @xmath39 , for different choices of @xmath71 and @xmath79 , as indicated .
the data labeled as `` widom '' ( available for not so large packing fractions ) are obtained by the standard particle insertion method for homogeneous bulk systems .
arrows on abscissa and ordinate indicate @xmath153 and @xmath154 , respectively .
( b ) chemical potential @xmath107 plotted vs. pressure @xmath58 , using the same data as in part ( a ) .
arrows at the abscissa and ordinate indicate @xmath48 and @xmath154 , respectively . ]
( a ) chemical potential @xmath107 ( in units of @xmath0 ) plotted vs. packing fraction @xmath39 , for different choices of @xmath71 and @xmath79 , as indicated .
the data labeled as `` widom '' ( available for not so large packing fractions ) are obtained by the standard particle insertion method for homogeneous bulk systems .
arrows on abscissa and ordinate indicate @xmath153 and @xmath154 , respectively .
( b ) chemical potential @xmath107 plotted vs. pressure @xmath58 , using the same data as in part ( a ) .
arrows at the abscissa and ordinate indicate @xmath48 and @xmath154 , respectively . ]
[ fig7 ] presents then a plot of @xmath107 vs. @xmath39 over a wide range @xmath155 ) of the fluid branch of the isotherm , including hence also its metastable part . for not too large values of @xmath156
also estimates recorded for bulk @xmath157 systems ( with no walls and periodic boundary conditions throughout ) are included , applying the standard particle insertion method .
these estimates are in excellent agreement with the results found from the method described above , only for the last point @xmath158 ) the result of this direct method is slightly off , due to a too small acceptance rate of the particle insertions .
we also include many different choices of both @xmath71 and @xmath79 in fig .
[ fig7 ] , and demonstrate that our results are not hampered by finite size effects . since we know the transition point @xmath159 ( [ eq1 ] ) from figs .
( [ fig2],[fig5]b ) , we can read off @xmath160 ( [ eq4 ] ) as well ( fig.[fig7]a , b ) .
note that fig .
[ fig7]b shows that the relation @xmath161 versus @xmath58 for the liquid branch near @xmath48 is very accurately represented by a straight line , hence validating a simple taylor expansion @xmath162 here we have given the pressure an index @xmath163 to emphasize that fig .
[ fig7]b and eq . [ eq13 ]
describe the pressure of the liquid phase and not the crystal ( when we consider a crystal nucleus surrounded by the liquid phase , the pressure @xmath164 in the crystal exceeds @xmath8 ) .
when we want to analyze the phase coexistence between a crystalline nucleus and surrounding liquid phase ( the associated chemical potential then can be inferred from fig .
[ fig7]b ) as a function of the nucleus volume , it is mandatory to identify where inside the simulation box the crystalline nucleus actually is located , for each configuration of the colloidal particles that is analyzed . due to statistical fluctuations fluid particles in the interfacial region may get attached to the crystal , as well as the inverse process .
while in equilibrium there should be just fluctuations of the size and shape of the crystalline nucleus around their proper average values , these fluctuations will also lead to random displacements of the center of mass of the crystalline nucleus . in a long simulation run
, we hence should have a diffusive motion of the crystalline nucleus in our system . of course ,
reliable `` measurements '' of @xmath8 can only be taken in such subboxes of the system which are not affected by the presence of the nucleus ; i.e. remote also from the region of the crystal - liquid interface in the analyzed configuration of the system .
note that also the orientations of the lattice planes at the crystal nucleus can be arbitrary , they should not be biased by the axes of the simulation box , if the simulated system is large enough . ( a ) distribution @xmath165 in the liquid ( at @xmath166 ) , hcp and fcc phases ( at @xmath167 ) ( b ) variation of @xmath168 and and @xmath169 with @xmath39 in the liquid and fcc phases , for the range from @xmath170 to @xmath171 .
( c ) distribution recorded for the coexistence of a crystal nucleus surrounded by fluid .
this case refers to an average packing fraction @xmath172 in the simulation box and @xmath173 in its liquid part . ]
( a ) distribution @xmath165 in the liquid ( at @xmath166 ) , hcp and fcc phases ( at @xmath167 ) ( b ) variation of @xmath168 and and @xmath169 with @xmath39 in the liquid and fcc phases , for the range from @xmath170 to @xmath171 .
( c ) distribution recorded for the coexistence of a crystal nucleus surrounded by fluid . this case refers to an average packing fraction @xmath172 in the simulation box and @xmath173 in its liquid part . ]
( a ) distribution @xmath165 in the liquid ( at @xmath166 ) , hcp and fcc phases ( at @xmath167 ) ( b ) variation of @xmath168 and and @xmath169 with @xmath39 in the liquid and fcc phases , for the range from @xmath170 to @xmath171 .
( c ) distribution recorded for the coexistence of a crystal nucleus surrounded by fluid .
this case refers to an average packing fraction @xmath172 in the simulation box and @xmath173 in its liquid part.,scaledwidth=25.0% ] the identification of whether particles are part of the liquid phase or part of the crystalline nucleus is based on the well - known steinhardt bond orientational order parameters @xcite .
they are defined in terms of spherical harmonics @xmath174 as @xmath175 where @xmath176 is the distance vector from the considered colloidal particle , labeled by index i , to one of its @xmath177 neighbors within a cutoff radius ( defining what the `` nearest neighbors '' are ) .
the polar angles @xmath178 and @xmath179 of this distance vector are chosen with respect to an arbitrary but fixed reference frame .
we use a cutoff radius of 1.3 @xmath180 here , determined by the first minimum of the radial distribution function @xmath181 measured in a bulk fcc crystal .
it is advantageous @xcite to average the @xmath182 over a particle and all its nearest neighbors @xmath183 where @xmath184 means that one takes @xmath185 from eq .
the order parameter that finally is used is then defined as @xmath186 in order to distinguish fcc crystals from liquids it is useful to consider the resulting distribution of @xmath187 and @xmath188 ( fig .
[ fig8]a ) .
one sees that in the pure phases the distribution are well separated from each other . since it is conceivable that in simulations of phase coexistence also hexagonal closed packed ( hcp ) regions compete with fcc regions , also data for @xmath165 for a hcp crystal
are included : however , in our study we have not encountered any evidence that this structure plays a role for our model .
it is also gratifying to note that the peak position of @xmath188 and @xmath189 are basically independent of @xmath39 , when one studies fcc crystals in the relevant region of packing fractions ( fig . [ fig8]b ) .
the situation is somewhat different when one considers phase coexistence between a crystalline nucleus and surrounding fluid ( fig .
[ fig8]c ) : now one finds a `` ridge '' connecting the sharp peak ( representing the crystalline nucleus ) with the broad peak representing the liquid .
clearly there is an ambiguity whether particles yielding a `` signal '' in this intermediate region are to be `` counted '' as part of the liquid or as part of the crystal .
we shall return to this problem in the next section .
we study systems of cubic shape ( @xmath190 boxes with periodic boundary conditions ) at constant volume and a particle number @xmath12 chosen such that the packing fraction @xmath39 is inside the two - phase coexistence region , namely @xmath191 , for a total number of colloids @xmath192 , 8000 and 10000 and start with a situation where a compact crystal nucleus ( of about the right volume @xmath193 and packing fraction @xmath194 , so that the remaining particles are compatible with a surrounding liquid of the expected density ) is initially already present . in the quoted parameter range , one finds that after a ( very long ) equilibration stage the system settles down at the stable equilibrium situation , where the crystal has somewhat grown or shrunk in size and adjusted its shape , such that the proper equilibrium is established .
schematic plot of the chemical potential @xmath107 versus density @xmath10 for a system undergoing a liquid - solid transition in a finite box volume @xmath11with periodic boundary conditions . due to interfacial effects ,
non - negligible in finite systems , the isotherm deviates from @xmath195 in the two - phase coexistence region , @xmath196 .
the sharp kinks of the curve are in reality rounded due to fluctuations as long as @xmath11 is finite ( for @xmath197 , however , all special features of this isotherm disappear and only the horizontal straight line @xmath198 remains ) . at the density @xmath199 , the system undergoes a transition from homogeneous fluid to a situation of two - phase coexistence ( crystalline nucleus ( red particles ) surrounded by fluid ( blue particles ) ,
see @xcite ) .
particles in the center of the interfacial region are shown in green , cf .
[ fig3 ] . at @xmath200 , the shape of the crystalline nucleus changes from spherical to cylindrical , while at @xmath201 a slab configuration ( with two planar interfaces ) sets in . in the density region where the slab configuration prevails , @xmath202 ( as well as @xmath203 )
hold also for finite volumes.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] when we try to do this at significantly smaller @xmath39 ( but still in the two - phase coexistence region , e.g. for @xmath204 ) , we regularly find that the crystalline nucleus melts , and the system ultimately becomes a homogeneous fluid ; when we try to do this at significantly larger @xmath39 , e.g. for @xmath205 , we find that the compact droplet undergoes ultimately always a fluctuation to an elongated , more or less cylindrical , shape , connected into itself through the periodic boundary condition . for still larger @xmath39 ( @xmath206 ) ,
even the cylinder is unstable , and the system develops towards a `` slab '' configuration , where a crystal domain extending in two directions throughout the box is separated from the liquid by two planar interfaces ( in this region one must work with @xmath207 boxes , varying @xmath39 by changing @xmath79 and choosing @xmath71 commensurate with an integer number of lattice planes , of course , to avoid that the crystal domain is strained , cf .
thus , there is only a rather small range of packing fractions where the desired equilibrium between a crystalline nucleus and surrounding fluid is actually stable . a qualitative explanation of the situation is provided in fig .
[ fig9 ] , where the chemical potential is plotted versus density : in a finite system , the region of two - phase coexistence actually is reduced in comparison with the bulk .
the homogeneous liquid in fact loses its thermodynamic stability not for @xmath208 but at the higher density @xmath199 .
this enhanced stability of the fluid for densities where in the thermodynamic limit the fluid would be metastable is due to the fact that the surface free energy cost associated with the formation of a nucleus would be too high .
the same phenomena is well know for the vapor - liquid transition @xcite , where the transition at @xmath209 is termed the droplet evaporation - condensation transition @xcite .
it has been suggested that @xcite @xmath210 in @xmath211 dimensions , while the densities @xmath212 show only insignificant dependence on box size . a plot of pressure @xmath58 versus density looks similar to fig .
[ fig9 ] when the plot refers to the majority phase , i.e. the liquid phase for @xmath213 , and the crystal for @xmath214 .
note that the interchange of what majority and minority means , at @xmath215 , happens in the regime where the slab morphology prevails , and then @xmath216 . on the other hand , in the regions where the fluid coexists with compact nuclei ( spherical droplets , in the vapor to liquid transition , respectively ) the pressure inside the nucleus is enhanced in comparison with the pressure n the surrounding phase . while in situations of phase coexistence the chemical potential is homogeneous ( as it must be in equilibrium , when the coexisting domains may exchange particles freely ) , the pressure distribution is not homogeneous . even for the slab configuration , where the pressure inside both coexisting phases is
the same , as stated above , a nontrivial variation of the pressure tensor components occurs in the interfacial regions . in this region of packing fractions @xmath39 , where a stable equilibrium between a compact nucleus and surrounding fluid is established we record after every @xmath217 monte carlo steps
the configuration of the crystalline nucleus , see fig .
[ fig10]a for an example , and take an average over the radial density distribution of the particles belonging to this nucleus around its center of mass ( fig . [ fig10]b ) . of course , we do not imply that the shape of the crystalline nucleus is on average spherical ( although this turns out to be a rather good approximation ) .
but the information shown in fig . [ fig10]a , b helps us in each configuration of the system that is analyzed , to identify the region of the fluid that is sufficiently remote from the crystal ( where @xmath218 in fig .
[ fig10]b are already flat , independent of @xmath16 , and have values typical for the liquid phase ) , where now measurements of the pressure @xmath8 and associated packing fraction @xmath219 can be performed .
gratifyingly , these data ( fig .
[ fig11 ] ) are fully compatible with the continuation of the liquid branch of the isotherm ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) for pressures exceeding @xmath48 .
this result shows that the liquid surrounding the nucleus is in thermal equilibrium , which is a basic condition for the analysis presented in the following section .
( a ) cutout of the cross section through the system , for a plane containing the center of mass of the ( compact ) crystalline nucleus for the choice @xmath220 of the total packing fraction and @xmath221 .
particles belonging to the crystal are shown in red ; their regular arrangement can be clearly recognized .
particles clearly belonging to the fluid are shown in blue , while green particles belong to the interfacial region .
the classification of solid and liquid can be found in @xcite .
( b ) radial density profiles of the order parameters @xmath189 and @xmath188 , for the case where @xmath222 and the packing fraction in the liquid could be estimated as @xmath223 at a pressure of @xmath224 . ]
( a ) cutout of the cross section through the system , for a plane containing the center of mass of the ( compact ) crystalline nucleus for the choice @xmath220 of the total packing fraction and @xmath221 .
particles belonging to the crystal are shown in red ; their regular arrangement can be clearly recognized . particles clearly belonging to the fluid are shown in blue , while green particles belong to the interfacial region .
the classification of solid and liquid can be found in @xcite .
( b ) radial density profiles of the order parameters @xmath189 and @xmath188 , for the case where @xmath222 and the packing fraction in the liquid could be estimated as @xmath223 at a pressure of @xmath224 . ]
pressure @xmath8 of the liquid surrounding a droplet plotted vs. average packing fraction @xmath39 of the colloid particles in the total simulation volume .
three choices of particle number @xmath12 are included , as indicated . for clarity , the region of interest
is shown also on a plot with strongly magnified abscissa scale . also data for @xmath225
are included , where the crystal forms a slab configuration ( cf .
9 ) , and the pressure agrees ( apart from fluctuations ) with @xmath48 as it should be.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] fig .
[ fig11 ] now shows our data for the pressure of the fluid phase surrounding the nucleus for the three choices of particle number n = 6000 , 8000 and 10 000 , in the regime @xmath226 , where stable nuclei occur .
we now use a simple extension of the lever rule for phase coexistence , adapted to account for finite size effects , to infer the volume @xmath13 of the crystalline nucleus , namely @xmath227 note that @xmath39 is the chosen control variable and when @xmath12 is chosen also @xmath11 is fixed .
we observe @xmath8 as well as @xmath228 directly , as discussed above .
since a direct estimation of @xmath229 in a small fluctuating crystal nucleus suffers from relatively large statistical errors ( and perhaps also systematic errors , if parts of the interfacial region are included ) , we use the appropriate value @xmath229 from the bulk crystal branch of the isotherm ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) . to find @xmath229 we use the fact that we know @xmath154 to carry out the thermodynamic integration .
@xmath230 to find the chemical potential of the crystal branch of the isotherm . from figs .
[ fig2],[fig11 ] we note that @xmath231 is a slightly nonlinear function of @xmath58 near @xmath48 , unlike @xmath232 , and therefore it is necessary to go beyond the simple linear expansion ( cf . eq.[eq13 ] ) @xmath233 ) ( note @xmath234 . ) the crystal pressure @xmath235 then follows from eq .
[ eq8 ] since we have determined @xmath107 and @xmath8 in the liquid region explicitly , the equality of the chemical potentials determines also @xmath164 through eq .
using then the data of fig .
[ fig2 ] , where the pressure of the crystal @xmath164 is determined as function of its packing fraction , we obtain @xmath229 once @xmath164 has been obtained .
then the crystallite volume @xmath13 is obtained from eq .
[ eq17 ] , without the need of assuming anything about the shape of this crystal nucleus .
if we would assume that the volume is strictly spherical , @xmath236 , we could try to use the radial order parameter profiles of @xmath237 and @xmath238 , fig .
[ fig10]b , to estimate @xmath239 from the inflection point of these curves .
[ fig12 ] shows effective radii obtained in this way , and compares them with an effective radius @xmath240 extracted from the general method ( using eqs .
[ eq17],[eq18 ] ) with the spherical approximation .
unexpectedly , these data indicate a rather good agreement , indicating that for the present model anisotropy effects of the interface tension can not be very important .
to elaborate the consequences of this finding for the theory of homogeneous nucleation of crystals in this system , we note that in classical nucleation theory the formation free energy of a nucleus is written in terms of volume and surface terms as @xcite @xmath241 in the description of the surface excess free energy @xmath242 of the crystal nucleus , the dependence of the crystal - liquid interface tension @xmath3 on the orientation of the interface normal @xmath2 relative to the crystal axes @xcite needs to be taken into account . only for isotropic
@xmath243 the nucleus is a sphere of radius @xmath244 and this surface excess free energy simply is @xmath245 with a geometric factor @xmath246 . for crystals , however , the term @xmath247 has to be replaced by a more complicated expression @xmath248 where @xmath249 is the surface area of a unit volume whose shape is derivable from @xmath250 with the wulff construction @xcite , and the integration in eq .
[ eq20 ] is extended over this surface .
the average interface tension @xmath251 introduced in eq .
[ eq20 ] is defined as @xmath252 the critical nucleus according to the theory of homogeneous nucleation satisfies the conditions @xmath253 , and hence eqs .
[ eq19 ] , [ eq20 ] yield @xmath254^{1/3}\ ] ] and the associated free energy barrier is @xmath255 while in the thermodynamic limit the liquid surrounding the critical nucleus is metastable , and actually the equilibrium condition @xmath256 refers to the unstable equilibrium on top of a saddle point in configuration space , we here deal with a stable equilibrium between the nucleus and the surrounding nucleus in the finite box .
the equilibrium condition is the same , however , because in both cases the nucleus can freely exchange particles with the surrounding liquid , and the chemical potential in the system is constant .
of course , the analysis presented can not be extended to arbitrary small box volumes , since working at fixed packing fraction @xmath257 the chemical potential in a small volume is not strictly constant , but exhibits statistical fluctuations which are not independent from the statistical fluctuations of @xmath13 , and hence give rise to finite size effects .
( a ) nucleus radius @xmath239 extracted from the inflection point of the order parameter profile @xmath238 [ within error it coincides with inflection point of @xmath237 ] plotted vs. average packing fraction.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] however , an attractive feature of eq . [ eq23 ]
is that actually neither a knowledge of @xmath249 nor of @xmath251 is needed to predict @xmath14 : knowing @xmath13 and the pressure difference @xmath259 yields directly @xmath14 , and hence the need to estimate @xmath3 and carry out the wulff construction is bypassed .
[ fig13 ] shows a plot of @xmath14 vs. @xmath260 , using our simulation results for the three different choices of @xmath12 .
gratifyingly , the data for different @xmath12 overlap , there do not seem to be significant finite size effects present ( at least not for the regime of @xmath261 explored here ) .
it also is interesting that the data do not indicate significant deviations from the straight line behavior , indicating that we get a meaningful estimate of the constant @xmath262 from the slope of this straight line .
unlike related work on vapor to liquid nucleation in simple fluids @xcite , curvature corrections ( of order @xmath263 in this plot ) do not seem to play any role here , thus there is also no need to consider the distinction between the equimolar dividing surface ( implicit in eq .
[ eq17 ] ) and the surface of tension which needed to be considered in the vapor to liquid case @xcite ) .
since we have already seen that the direct estimation of nuclei volume from a spherical approximation ( fig .
[ fig12 ] ) is in good agreement with the volume determined from the thermodynamic analysis , it is of course tempting to try a direct spherical approximation of @xmath14 as well , replacing @xmath249 in eq .
[ eq21 ] by @xmath246 , and using instead of @xmath251 an estimate for the smallest interface tension @xcite , which occurs for the close - packed 111 crystal surface , namely @xmath264(3 ) , yielding @xmath265 it turns out that the resulting straight line is almost indistinguishable from the straight line included in fig .
[ fig13 ] !
this good agreement can also be seen when one considers the pressure difference @xmath266 as function of @xmath39 ( fig .
[ fig14 ] ) and includes there the prediction appropriate for a spherical nucleus , @xmath267 for the individual choices of @xmath12 , using again @xmath268 as an approximation for @xmath243 .
although the other interface tensions @xmath269 for the present model are about 3% larger than @xmath268 @xcite , this weak anisotropy of the present model does not lead to significant deviations from the spherical approximation , for the present choice of model parameters .
barrier @xmath14 against homogeneous nucleation ( in units of @xmath0 ) plotted vs. @xmath260 , using the data for @xmath13 and @xmath259 from the thermodynamic analysis of the equilibrium between nucleus and surrounding liquid , for the data for 0.525 @xmath270 and @xmath271 and @xmath272 .
the straight line is a fit through the data that includes the origin @xmath273 for @xmath274 , using an independent estimate for the surface tension and assuming a spherical nucleus shape ( see text).,scaledwidth=30.0% ] pressure difference @xmath275 plotted versus the average packing fraction @xmath39 in the simulation box , for particle number n = 6000 ( topmost set of data ) , 8000 ( middle set of data ) and 10 000(lowest set ) , respectively .
data points are from the thermodynamic analysis ( green symbols represent the formula @xmath276 ) , curves show the prediction @xmath277 , using @xmath278 ( taken from @xcite ) and @xmath279 as indicated.,scaledwidth=30.0% ]
in this paper we have introduced a smooth variant of the asakura - oosawa model for colloid - polymer mixtures , in the limit of small size ratios where the polymers can be integrated out in favor of a short range colloid - colloid attraction , to study the phase transition from the fluid phase to the face - centered cubic crystal .
we have paid particular attention to phase coexistence in finite volumes , and the information on nucleation barriers that one can extract from an analysis of phase coexistence .
a key ingredient of the discussion has been the observation that the chemical potential of the system , considered as a function of packing fraction at constant volume , exhibits a loop ( fig .
[ fig9 ] ) .
the enhancement of @xmath107 relative to @xmath154 in the first descending part of this loop , and the associated enhancement of the pressure @xmath8 in the liquid over @xmath48 , contains information that can be used to estimate the surface excess free energy of the crystalline nucleus . in order to be able to study this problem with meaningful accuracy , we have first located phase coexistence between bulk phases from the standard `` interface velocity '' method , where one prepares a `` slab configuration '' of a crystal coexisting with liquid , separated from it by planar interfaces , in a simulation box of suitably elongated shape . studying the `` velocity '' with which the volume of the box changes with time ( due to interface motion ,
when the crystal shrinks for @xmath280 or grows for @xmath46 ) , one can estimate the coexistence pressure @xmath48 . unfortunately ,
this method due to large statistical fluctuations ( fig .
[ fig4 ] ) and finite size effects ( fig .
[ fig5 ] ) requires a major computational effort , and alternative more efficient methods to accurately estimate @xmath48 would be desirable . after this part of our work
was completed , a method due to pedersen et al .
@xcite came to our attention , which could be advantageous for this purpose .
we have also applied a method where the fluid in an elongated simulation box is exposed to one wall with a very soft potential , enabling the estimation of the chemical potential @xmath107 also in a situation where in the bulk the packing fraction is too high so that the standard widom particle insertion method would not work ( fig .
[ fig6],[fig7 ] ) .
we have shown that by this method @xmath107 can be estimated for the liquid branch of the isotherm , even for pressures @xmath46 .
the crystalline nuclei ( coexisting with fluid ) have been studied both by geometrical identification where the crystal - fluid interface is located ( fig .
[ fig10],[fig12 ] ) using the well - known concept of bond orientational order parameters @xmath281 , cf .
[ fig8 ] ) to locally distinguish the phases , and by thermodynamic analysis ( figs.[fig11],[fig13],[fig14 ] ) .
we show that for the present model the assumption that the anisotropy of @xmath3 can essentially be ignored , and therefore the nuclei have effectively a spherical shape , works very accurately .
we stress , however , that we do not expect that this conclusion works in general ; if the anisotropy @xmath3 is more pronounced , the spherical approximation must fail , but our thermodynamic method which only needs the information on the fluid pressure , fluid chemical potential , and nucleus volume , still should work .
such a more anisotropic case is expected for the present model at large @xmath282 in eq .
[ eq1]b , when @xmath153 is much smaller than @xmath194 .
however , an explicit study of this case must be left to future work .
an important feature of our work also is the excellent agreement with classical nucleation theory , @xmath283 ( fig . [ fig13 ] ) .
this conclusion seems to be at variance with both experimental and simulation studies on nucleation in colloidal suspensions ( see @xcite for a review ) .
however , we feel that most of this work has been done for conditions where @xmath284 is much larger than in the present work , so actually the nucleation barrier is then rather small ; our pressure range @xmath285 for the pressure of the metastable fluid ( fig . [ fig11 ] ) translates into packing fractions @xmath286 of the fluid surrounding the crystalline nucleus in our box .
these numbers are close to @xmath287 , the relative distance from the transition where freezing sets in is at most 6% .
in contrast , experiments @xcite and simulations for hard spheres @xcite typically deal with packing fractions in the range @xmath288 ( note that within the available accuracy @xmath153 in our model agrees with the corresponding value for hard spheres ) .
note that this range of the experiments corresponds to huge values of @xmath289 ( cf .
[ fig2 ] ) , and correspondingly the estimate that classical nucleation theory would imply yields droplet radii that do not exceed about two colloid diameters , and barriers that are only of the order of 5 to 10 @xmath0 .
it is clear that for such small nuclei the approximations of the classical nucleation theory are expected to fail . on the other hand , for
such dense colloidal suspensions the nucleation rate will be strongly affected by the slowing down that sets in when the colloidal glass transition @xcite is approached .
in fact , radu and schilling @xcite have pointed out a strong and nontrivial effect due to the kinetic prefactor of the nucleation rate .
since the slowing down associated with the glass transition is not a well understood problem @xcite , studies attempting to test nucleation theory should avoid this region , and focus on the region close to @xmath153 , as done here .
finally , we discuss the issue why the spherical approximation is such a good approximation to the actual crystal shape in this case .
the simple explanation is that the anisotropy pf the interfacial tension of the crystal fluid interface in this model is very weak , the difference between @xmath291 and @xmath292 is a few % only .
a similar situation also arises in the lattice gas model @xcite , at temperatures well above the roughening temperature .
recent work @xcite has studied the angular dependence of the interface tension in this model over a wide range of temperatures , showing that the dependence on interface tension on interface orientation amounts to a variation of typically a few % as well ( this anisotropy vanishes at the critical point of this model ) .
the corresponding enhancement of the nucleation barrier was found to be of the order of 10 % as well @xcite ; only at low temperatures , where facetted crystal shapes occur , large derivations from the spherical approximations were found @xcite .
thus , we expect that the present findings are generic for all systems where the anisotropy of the interfacial tension at melting conditions amounts only a few % . :
this work was supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ( dfg ) under grant no s sfb - tr6/d5 and vi237/4 - 3 .
we thank the hochleistungsrechenzentrum stuttgart ( hlrs ) and the zentrum fr datenverarbeitung mainz for generous grants of computing time at the hermit and mogon supercomputers .
99 a. c. zettlemoyer ( ed . ) _ nucleation _
( m. dekker , new york , 1969 ) w. a. tiller , _ the science of crystallization : microscopic interfacial phenomena _ ( cambridge univ . press , new york , 1991 ) i. gutzow and j. schmelzer , _ the vitreous state : thermodynamics , structure , rheology , and crystallization _ ( springer , berlin , 1995 ) d. kashchiev , _ nucleation : basic theory with applications _ ( butterworth - heinemann , oxford , 2000 ) s. balibar and f. caupin , comptes rendus physique * 7 * , 988 ( 2006 ) d. m. herlach , p. galenko , and d. holland - moritz , _ metastable solids from undercooled melts _ ( pergamon , oxford , 2007 ) k. f. kelton and a. i. greer , _ nucleation _ ( pergamon , oxford , 2009 ) h. emmerich , p. virnau , g. wilde and r. spatschek ( eds . ) _ heterogeneous nucleation and microstructure formation : steps towards a system and scale bridging understanding _ , epj * 223 * , no3 ( 2014 ) t. palberg , j. phys . : condens . matter * 26 * , 333101 ( 2014 ) h. mller - krumbhaar , w. kurz , and e. brener , in _ phase transformations in materials _ ( g. kostorz , ed . ) p. 81
( wiley - vch , weinheim , 2001 ) d. turnbull , j. appl . phys . * 21 * , 1022 ( 1950 ) j. e. burke and d. turnbull , progr . met .
phys . * 3 * 220 ( 1952 ) h. biloni , in _ physical metallurgy _
( r. w. cahn and p. haasen , eds . )
( north - holland , amsterdam , 1983 ) w. j. boettinger , s. r. correll , a. l. greer , a. karma , w. kurz , m. rappaz , and r. trivedi , acta metr .
* 48 * , 43 ( 2000 ) s. auer and d. frenkel , condens .
matter * 14 * , 7667 ( 2002 ) a. cacciuto , s. auer and d. frenkel , phys .
* 93 * , 166105 ( 2004 ) a. cacciuto , s. auer and d. frenkel , j. chem
. phys . * 119 * , 7467 ( 2003 ) d. winter , p. virnau and k. binder , phys .
* 103 * , 225703 ( 2009 ) d. winter , p. virnau and k. binder , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 21 * , 464118 ( 2009 ) d. deb , a. winkler , p. virnau , and k. binder , j. chem .
* 136 * , 134710 ( 2012 ) s. dorosz , t. schilling , j. chem .
phys . * 136 * , 044702 ( 2012 ) v. w. a de villeneuve , d. verboekend , r. p.
a. dullens , d. g. a. l. aarts , w. k. kegel , and h. n. w. lekkerkerker , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 17 * , s3371 ( 2005 ) h. j. schpe and p. wette , phys .
rev . e**83 * * , 051405 ( 2011 ) s. jungblut and c. dellago , epl * 96 * , 56006 ( 2011 ) a. engelbrecht and h. j. schpe , soft matter * 8 * , 11034 ( 2012 ) k. binder and d. stauffer , adv . phys . * 25 * , 343 ( 1976 ) m. radu and t. schilling , epl * 105 * , 26001 ( 2014 ) f. schmitz , p. virnau , and k. binder , phys . rev . e**81 * * 705330 ( 2013 ) g. wulff , z. kristallogr . mineral . * 34 * , 449 ( 1901 ) c. herring , phys .
rev . * 82 * , 87 ( 1951 ) c. herring , in _ structure and properties of solid surfaces _
( r. gomer , ed . )
( univ . of chicago press , chicago , 1952 ) j. w. cahn and d. w. hoffmann , acta metall .
* 22 * , 1205 ( 1974 ) d. w. hoffmann and j. w. cahn , surf .
sci * 31 * , 368 ( 1972 ) r. k. p. zia and j. avron , phys .
rev . b**25 * * , 2042 ( 1982 ) c. rottmann and m. wortis , phys .
rep . * 103 * , 59 ( 1984 ) m. wortis , in _ chemistry and physics of solid surfaces , vol .
( r. vanselow , ed . )
( springer , berlin , 1988 ) k. binder , pnas * 111 * , 3974 ( 2014 ) p. n. pusey and w. van megen , nature * 320 * , 340 ( 1986 ) p. n. pusey , in _ liquids , freezing , and the glass transition , _ edited by j. p. hansen , d. levesque , and j. zinn - justin ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1991 ) p. 736 .
w. c. k. poon and p. n. pusey , in _ observation , prediction and simulation of phase transitions in complex fluids _ , edited by m. baus , l. f. rull , and j. p. ryckaert ( kluwer , dordrecht , 1995 ) p. 3
h. bach and d. krause ( eds . ) _ analyses of the composition and structure of glass and glass ceramics _ ( springer , berlin , 1999 ) k. binder and w. kob , _ glassy materials and disordered solids : an introduction to their statistical mechanics _ , 2nd ed .
( world scientific , singapore , 2011 ) a. ha , i. cohen , x. zhao , m. lee , and d. kivelson , j. phys . chem . * 100 * , 1 ( 1996 ) h. tanaka , eur . phys .
j. e**35 * * , 113 ( 2012 ) r. boehmer , g. hinze , g. diezemann , b. geil , and h. sillescu , europhys . lett . * 36 * , 55 ( 1996 ) h. e. stanley ( ed . )
_ liquid polymorphism _
( j. wiley & sons , hoboken , 2014 ) a. statt , p.virnau and k. binder , phys .
lett * 114 * , 026101 ( 2015 ) s. asakura and f. oosawa , j. chem . phys .
* 22 * , 1255 ( 1954 ) s. asakura and f. oosawa , j. polym .
* 33 * , 183 ( 1998 ) k. binder , p. virnau , and a. statt , j. chem
* 14 * , 141 ( 2014 ) w. c. k. poon , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 14 * , r859 ( 2002 ) h. n. w. lekkerkerker and r. tuinier , _ colloids and the depletion interaction _ ( springer , berlin , 2011 ) l. g. mcdowell , p. virnau , m. mller , and k. binder , j. chem . phys . * 120 * , 5293 ( 2004 ) l. g. mcdowell , v. k. shen , and j. r. errington , j. chem . phys . *
125 * , 034705 ( 2006 ) m. schrader , p. virnau and k. binder , phys .
rev . e**79 * * , 061104 ( 2009 ) b. j. block , s. k. das , m. oettel , p. virnau , and k. binder , j. chem .
phys . * 135 * , 154702 ( 2010 ) a. troester , m. oettel , b. j. block , p. virnau and k .binder , j. chem . phys . * 136 * , 064709 ( 2012 ) k. binder , b. j. block , p. virnau and a. troester , am .
* 80 * , 1099 ( 2012 ) p. j. steinhardt , d. r. nelson , and m. ronchetti , phys .
rev . b**28 * * , 783 ( 1983 ) w. lechner and c. dellago , j. chem .
* 129 * , 114707 ( 2008 ) j. d. weeks , j. chem .
phys . * 67 * , 3106 ( 1977 ) j. s : rowlinson and b. widom , _ molecular theory of capillarity _
( clarendon press , oxford , 1982 ) k. binder , m. mller , f. schmid and a. werner , adv .
colloid interface sci .
, * 94 * , 237 ( 2001 ) p. tarazona and e. chacon , phys .
rev . b**70 * * , 235407 ( 2004 ) t. zykova - timan , j. horbach , and k. binder , j. chem .
phys . * 133 * , 014705 ( 2010 ) k. binder , j. phys . :
series * 510 * , 012002 ( 2014 ) p.
j. flory , _ principles of poylmer chemistry _
( cornell university press , ithaca , n. y. , 1953 ) m. dijkstra , r. van roij , and r. evans , phys . rev . e**59 * * , 5744 ( 1999 ) r. evans , in _ fundamentals of inhomogeneous fluids _ , edited by d. henderson ( dekker , new york , 1992 ) , p. 85
j. p. hansen and i. r. mcdonald , _ theory of simple liquids _
( academic press , san diego , 1980 ) e. de miguel and g. jackson , mol .
* 104 * , 3717 ( 2006 ) d. deb , d. wilms , a. winkler , p. virnau , and k. binder , int . j. mod .
phys . c**23 * * , 1240011 ( 2012 ) m. p. allen and d. j. tildesley , _ computer simulation of liquids _
( clarendon press , oxford , 1989 ) d. c. rapaport , _ the art of molecular dynamics simulation _
( cambridge univ . press ,
cambridge , 2004 ) w. c. k. poon , e. r. weeks , and c. p. royall , soft matter * 8 * , 21 ( 2012 ) c. p. royall , w. c. k. poon , and e. r. weeks , soft matter * 9 * , 17 ( 2013 ) a. statt , _ dissertation _
( johannes - gutenberg - universitt mainz , 2015 , unpublished ) b. widom , j. chem .
* 39 * , 2808 ( 1963 ) j. g. powles , b. holtz , and w. a. b. evans , j. chem
* 101 * , 7804 ( 1994 ) k. binder , physica a**319 * * , 99 ( 2003 ) f. schmitz and p.virnau ( submitted ) s. auer and d. frenkel , nature * 409 * , 1020 ( 2001 ) l. filion , m. hermes , r. ni , and m. dijkstra , j. chem
. phys . * 133 * , 244115 ( 2010 ) t. schilling , s. dorosz , h. j. schpe , and g. opletal , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 23 * , 194120 ( 2011 ) p. n. pusey and w. van megen , nature * 320 * , 340 ( 1980 ) p. n. pusey , in _ liquids , freezing and glass transition _ , edited by j. p. hansen , d. levesque and j. zinn - justin , ( elsevier , amsterdam , 1991 ) chapter 10 .
u. r. pedersetn , f. hummel , g. kresse , g. kahl , and c. dellago , phys .
rev . b**88 * * , 094101 ( 2013 ) ; u. r. pedersen , j. chem .
phys . * 139 * , 104102 ( 2013 ) b. j. block , s. kim , p.virnau , and k. binder , phys.rev e * 90 * , 062106 ( 2014 ) l. v. woodcock , nature * 385.6612 * , 141 - 143 ( 1997 ) bolhuis , peter g. , d. m. s. c. frenkel , siun - choun mau , and david a. huse , nature * 388.6639 * , 235 - 236 ( 1997 ) a. d. bruce , n. b. wilding , and g. j. ackland . phys .
lett * 79 * , 3002 ( 1997 ) a. d. bruce , bruce , a. d. , a. n. jackson , g. j. ackland , and n. b. wilding , phys .
e * 61 * , 906 ( 2000 ) | as a model for a suspension of hard - sphere like colloidal particles where small nonadsorbing dissolved polymers create a depletion attraction , we introduce an effective colloid - colloid potential closely related to the asakura - oosawa model but that does not have any discontinuities . in simulations ,
this model straightforwardly allows the calculation of the pressure from the virial formula , and the phase transition in the bulk from the liquid to crystalline solid can be accurately located from a study where a stable coexistence of a crystalline slab with a surrounding liquid phase occurs . for this model ,
crystalline nuclei surrounded by fluid are studied both by identifying the crystal - fluid interface on the particle level ( using suitable bond orientational order parameters to distinguish the phases ) and by `` thermodynamic '' means .
i.e. , the latter method amounts to compute the enhancement of chemical potential and pressure relative to their coexistence values .
we show that the chemical potential can be obtained from simulating thick films , where one wall with a rather long range repulsion is present , since near this wall the widom particle insertion method works , exploiting the fact that the chemical potential in the system is homogeneous .
finally , the surface excess free energy of the nucleus is obtained , for a wide range of nuclei volumes . from this method
, it is established that classical nucleation theory works , showing that for the present model the anisotropy of the interface excess free energy of crystals and their resulting nonspherical shape has only a very small effect on the barrier . |
gauge theory and gravity scattering amplitudes have a far richer structure than evident from their respective lagrangians .
as one such example , in this talk we will describe a recently discovered duality between color and kinematic numerators of gauge - theory scattering amplitude diagrams @xcite . remarkably , this duality appears to have important implications for gravity : when the gauge - theory numerators satisfy the duality , the numerators of corresponding gravity theories are given by a double copy of the gauge theory numerators , diagram by diagram @xcite , as demonstrated recently @xcite .
the double - copy property has the benefit of greatly clarifying the mysterious kawai , lewellen and tye ( klt ) relation between gauge and gravity tree amplitudes @xcite . in this talk
we will focus on the recent progress in extending the duality and double - copy properties to loop level @xcite .
we also summarize the structure of gauge - theory lagrangians whose feynman diagrams satisfy the duality , leading to gravity lagrangians that exhibit the double - copy property @xcite .
-1.2 cm -.3 cm many of the recent developments for scattering amplitudes rely on on - shell methods , which include on - shell recursion @xcite at tree level and the unitarity method @xcite at loop level . a particularly powerful approach to generalized unitarity cut constructions
@xcite is the method of maximal cuts @xcite , organizing the calculation starting from unitarity cuts where all propagators are cut and then systematically reducing the number of cut propagators . on -
shell methods allow one to construct new amplitudes using simpler on - shell amplitudes as input .
cuts that decompose loop amplitudes into tree amplitudes , such as the sample four - loop ones displayed in , are generally the most advantageous ones to use .
the unitarity method gives a set of rules for reconstructing complete amplitudes from cuts .
as discussed in a variety of talks at this conference @xcite , the unitarity method is by now a standard tool in loop computations . as one state - of - the - art example from collider physics , it plays a central role in progress towards the long - awaited nlo calculation of @xmath0-jet production at the lhc , described in this conference @xcite .
cm multiloop calculations are typically rather involved , yielding expressions with no easily accessible structure or pattern .
consider , _
e.g. , _ the rather lengthy results for @xmath1 scattering amplitudes in qcd , given in refs .
might there be a structure hidden in these rather opaque expressions ? to answer this question , it is easiest to begin by looking at one the simplest @xmath2 two - loop amplitudes identical helicity scattering in qcd first computed in ref .
@xcite .
the all - plus helicity amplitude is given in terms of three integrals , two of which are displayed in .
the planar and non - planar double - box contributions shown in may be expressed in terms of loop integrals as in ref .
@xcite , @xmath3 \ , , \nn \\
a^{\rm np}_{12;34 } \hskip -.2 cm & = & \hskip -.2 cm i \ , { \spb1.2\spb3.4 \over \spa1.2\spa3.4 } \ ,
s_{12 } \ , i_4^{\rm np } \bigl [ n(p , q ) \bigr]\ , , \nn \ ] ] where the @xmath4 represent numerator polynomials depending on the loop momenta @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
remarkably , the polynomials ( and the prefactors ) for both integrals are identical .
the shared numerator is given by , @xmath7 where the vectors @xmath8 represent the @xmath9-dimensional components of the loop momenta @xmath10 ; that is , @xmath11 } + \mud_i$ ] , where @xmath12}$ ] has only four - dimensional components and we take @xmath9 to be positive . the propagators of the integrals are of course different and correspond to the two diagrams in .
the prefactor depends on spinor inner products
@xmath13 and @xmath14 ; further details on spinor - helicity notation may be found in , for example , ref .
we denote the number of gluon states circulating in the loop by @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the dimension of spacetime .
( @xmath16 is the dimension of the polarization vectors which can be taken to be independent of the dimension of the loop momenta . )
the above result has a rather striking feature : the numerators of the planar and non - planar integrals are identical .
this feature is rather obscure from a feynman diagram point of view , where no discernible relationship between the planar and non - planar contributions is apparent .
this curious feature seems to be an important clue for novel structures in gauge - theory amplitudes .
but what might it be ?
we know now @xcite that this curiosity is a hint of hidden structures , including : * a new duality between color and kinematics . * all - loop relations between planar and non - planar diagrammatic integrands .
* a double - copy structure of gravity diagram kinematic numerators in terms of gauge - theory ones .
although these properties are not yet completely proven , below we discuss evidence that these properties hold to all loop orders .
any amplitude with all particles in the adjoint representation of the gauge group can be arranged into the form , @xmath17 where the sum runs over the set of @xmath18-point diagrams with only cubic vertices and we suppress factors of the coupling constant .
the product runs over all propagators ( internal lines ) @xmath19 of each diagram .
the @xmath20 are the color factors obtained by dressing every three vertex with an @xmath21 structure constant , and the @xmath22 are kinematic numerator factors depending on momenta , polarizations and spinors ( and grassmann parameters for supersymmetric amplitudes expressed in superspace ) .
the form ( [ agauge ] ) follows trivially from feynman diagrams , by representing all contact terms as inverse propagators in the kinematic numerators , which then cancel propagators . according to the duality proposal of ref .
@xcite , arrangements of the diagrammatic numerators in exist such that they satisfy equations in one - to - one correspondence with the color jacobi identities . specifically , we demand that every color jacobi identity induces a kinematic identity : @xmath23 this duality is expected to hold in a large variety of theories , including supersymmetric extensions of yang - mills theory . at four points the duality is automatically satisfied for any choice of valid numerators @xcite , but at higher points the existence of such arrangements is rather nontrivial
. indeed there is , as of yet , no complete proof that this can always be accomplished .
surprisingly , this duality implies non - trivial relations between the color - ordered partial amplitudes of gauge theory @xcite .
a proof of these amplitude relations has recently been given both in field theory and in string theory @xcite .
remarkably , once the gauge - theory amplitudes are arranged into a form satisfying the duality ( [ bcjduality ] ) , gravity tree amplitudes are given by a double copy of gauge - theory numerator factors @xcite , @xmath24 where the @xmath25 represent numerator factors of a second gauge theory amplitude , the sum runs over the same set of diagrams as in , and we suppressed the gravitational coupling constant .
this formula recently has been proven for pure gravity and for @xmath26 supergravity , under the assumption that the duality ( [ bcjduality ] ) holds in the corresponding gauge theories , by use of on - shell recursion @xcite .
if pure - yang - mills amplitudes are used , the obtained gravity amplitudes correspond to einstein gravity coupled to an antisymmetric tensor and dilaton ; the @xmath18-graviton tree - level amplitudes of this theory are those of pure einstein gravity .
if both families of kinematic factors are for the @xmath27 super - yang - mills theory , the gravity theory amplitudes are those of @xmath26 supergravity . for this double - copy relation to hold , at least one family of numerators ( @xmath22 or @xmath25 ) needs to satisfy the duality ( [ bcjduality ] ) @xcite . additionally , the @xmath28 numerator factors need not come from the same theory as the @xmath22 factors .
this allows for the construction of gravity amplitudes with varying amounts of supersymmetry .
the duality has also been studied in string theory @xcite .
we note that the heterotic string offers a natural venue for understanding these properties because of the parallel treatment of color and kinematics @xcite . if one compares the yang - mills and einstein gravity lagrangians @xmath29 it seems rather puzzling that gravity can be a double copy of gauge theory .
indeed , the perturbative expansions appear to be completely different : expanding the metric around flat space , we find that gravity is composed of an infinite sequence of increasingly complicated vertices , whereas the yang - mills lagrangian has local interactions that terminate at four points . on the other hand , the klt relations map the tree - level scattering amplitudes of gravity to those of gauge theory .
this suggests that the standard lagrangians ( [ lagrangians ] ) obscure the relation between the two .
some initial steps in understanding the relationship between gravity and gauge theory at the level of the lagrangian were carried out in ref .
in particular , that paper developed some tricks for separating the graviton lorentz indices into `` left '' and `` right '' classes , consistent with the double - copy property .
( see also ref .
@xcite . ) however , the connection to gauge theory remained rather mysterious . as realized in ref .
@xcite , the key missing ingredient was the color - kinematic duality of ref .
@xcite .
to see how to make the proper rearrangement , consider first the yang - mills lagrangian . the initial step is to rearrange the lagrangian so its feynman diagrams satisfy the color - kinematic duality . as noted earlier for four - point amplitudes ,
the duality is automatic the ordinary form of the yang - mills lagrangian generates diagrams that satisfy the duality . beyond four points , for the duality to be satisfied directly by the feynman diagrams , we must modify the lagrangian yet leave the amplitudes unchanged . for five points ,
this may be accomplished by adding the following term to the yang - mills lagrangian @xcite : @xmath30 } a^{a_2}_\rho a^{a_3\mu } \frac{1}{\box}(a^{a_4\nu } a^{a_5\rho } ) \ , .
\label{lagragian5alt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this new term leaves the amplitudes unchanged because it vanishes identically by the color - jacobi identity .
nevertheless , the canceling terms have different color structures and thus are associated with different diagrams .
these terms modify the individual diagrams so that the duality holds .
the additional term ( [ lagragian5alt ] ) is , however , nonlocal .
we can make the lagrangian local by introducing a set of auxiliary fields as explained in ref .
in fact , with a sufficient number of such fields , all higher - point interactions can be replaced by three - point interactions . once the gauge - theory lagrangian has been put into this form , a gravity lagrangian which yields the correct amplitudes
is given simply by two copies of the gauge theory lagrangian , as described in ref .
@xcite , with the identification @xmath31 , dropping the color factors .
( the color indices play essentially no role in this identification . )
if one had an all orders lagrangian , it would be possible to investigate non - perturbative implications . because of the double - copy property , one might expect that _ all _ classical solutions of gravity could be written as double copies of solutions of gauge theories . in particular , in coordinate space we can expect gravity solutions to be convolutions of gauge - theory solutions , with the schematic form , @xmath32
very recently ref .
@xcite proposed that the color - kinematic duality and gravity double - copy property extends to _ all _ loop orders .
this might seem a rather bold conjecture , yet the unitarity method provides strong motivation .
indeed the duality was first observed in the three- and four - loop four - point amplitudes of @xmath27 super - yang - mills theory , with various on - shell conditions imposed @xcite .
the success of the duality at the lagrangian level @xcite is also quite suggestive .
the loop - level expressions for gauge and gravity amplitudes would then be , @xmath33 where we again suppressed the couplings and the sums now run over all distinct @xmath18-point @xmath34-loop diagrams with cubic vertices .
these include distinct permutations of external legs , and the @xmath35 are the symmetry factors of each diagram .
as at tree level , at least one family of numerators ( @xmath36 or @xmath37 ) is constrained to satisfy the duality ( [ bcjduality ] ) .
we expect these formulas to hold in a large class of theories , including theories which are the low energy limits of string theories .
it should also hold in pure gravity , but in this case extra projectors would be required to remove the extra unwanted states arising in the direct product of two pure yang - mills theories . as at tree level , the ability to organize amplitudes around cubic graphs is trivially accomplished by inserting inverse propagators into the numerators to account for contact terms .
the non - trivial part of this conjecture is that there always exists sufficient freedom to arrange gauge - theory multiloop amplitudes in a way that satisfies the color - kinematic duality ( [ bcjduality ] ) .
the unitarity method straightforwardly ensures that the double - copy property of gravity extends to loop level when it holds at tree level , since all cuts that decompose loop amplitudes into products of tree amplitudes will have this property @xcite . since we do not yet have a proof that the color - kinematic duality holds , it is important to check some explicit examples .
the known one and two - loop four - point amplitudes of @xmath27 super - yang - mills theory and @xmath26 supergravity , as given in ref .
@xcite , satisfy the conjectures ( [ loopbcj ] ) .
another example is the previously mentioned two - loop four - point identical - helicity amplitude of pure yang - mills theory @xcite , which can also be shown to satisfy the duality @xcite .
a more sophisticated example , which we outline here , is the three - loop four - point amplitude of @xmath27 super - yang - mills theory .
this amplitude offers a rather non - trivial check of the duality given both the high loop order and the non - trivial dependence of the numerators on loop momenta .
it was originally constructed in refs .
@xcite via the unitarity method . in ref .
@xcite , the duality was made manifest by appropriate reshufflings of terms in the earlier forms of the amplitude .
super - yang - mills and @xmath26 supergravity three - loop four - point amplitudes in the arrangement of ref .
the corresponding integrals are obtained by combining their propagators with numerator factors given in .
the ( internal ) symmetry factor for diagram ( d ) is @xmath38 , the rest are unity .
all distinct external permutations of each diagram appear in the amplitude . ]
cm -.5 cm -1 .
cm the duality requires that the numerator identities in must be imposed for every propagator in every diagram . in
we display one such numerator relation . for any diagram
, we can describe any internal line , carrying some momentum @xmath39 , in terms of formal graph vertices @xmath40 , and @xmath41 where the @xmath42 are the momenta of the other legs attached to @xmath39 , as illustrated on the left side of .
the duality ( [ bcjduality ] ) requires that , @xmath43 where @xmath18 represents the numerator associated with the diagram specified by the set of vertices , the omitted vertices are identical in all three diagrams , and @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 in the numerator expressions .
there is one such equation for every propagator in every diagram .
solving the system of distinct equations enforces the duality conditions ( [ bcjduality ] ) .
it turns out@xcite that a solution to the duality relations is found in terms of the 12 diagrams displayed in .
.4 cm [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] of course the amplitude must be the correct one for the theory under consideration , and thus must satisfy all cut conditions as well . the explicit solution found in ref .
@xcite , satisfying both the cut conditions and the duality , is displayed in .
interestingly , after imposing the duality , the maximal cut of diagram ( e ) in is sufficient for finding the unique solution , when the numerators are local and no diagram has a worse power counting than the known amplitude . in this table ,
an overall factor of @xmath47 has been removed from the entries , @xmath48 are mandelstam invariants corresponding to @xmath49 and @xmath50 , where @xmath51 and @xmath52 are external and internal momenta as labeled in .
the reader may check that all duality relations hold .
@xcite also verified that the double - copy property holds for @xmath26 supergravity , confirming it on a complete set of cuts using the known amplitude @xcite .
in this talk we summarized a recently proposed gauge - theory duality between color and kinematics , leading to a double - copy property for gravity theories @xcite .
although the duality remains a conjecture , we can even now exploit it to guide loop computations , simply by enforcing the duality and verifying the consistency with the unitarity cuts .
this is helpful both for organizing gauge - theory amplitudes and for obtaining the corresponding double - copy gravity amplitudes .
there are a number of interesting open problems related to the color - kinematic duality .
in particular , it would be helpful to carry out further checks of the duality for multiloop processes .
more generally an all - orders proof would be important , especially if it leads to new insight into the origins of the duality .
the duality suggests the existence of a group theoretical construction of the kinematic numerators , which would , of course , be very interesting to develop .
we would also like to have lagrangians whose diagrams satisfy the duality to all orders , and which give gravity lagrangians as double copies , along the lines described in ref .
we expect this to have non - trivial implications at strong coupling .
it seems likely that the duality should hold as well in higher - genus perturbative string theory .
the duality and double - copy property may also shed new light on the issue of ultraviolet divergences in @xmath26 supergravity . for four - point amplitudes through four loops , explicit computations show that ultraviolet cancellations exist beyond those needed for finiteness @xcite . beyond this
, the situation is less clear .
a consensus has formed that supersymmetry alone can not prevent divergences in four dimensions starting at seven loops @xcite .
supergravity until nine loops @xcite has been retracted @xcite .
] although nontrivial cancellations are known to exist to all loop orders @xcite , we do not know if these cancellations are sufficient to render the theory finite .
recent reviews discussing the ultraviolet properties of @xmath26 supergravity may be found in refs .
@xcite .
the color - kinematic duality and gravity double - copy structure likely have important non - perturbative implications .
in particular , these properties suggest that classical solutions in gravity theories may be expressible as double copies of classical solutions in gauge theories .
we thank t. dennen , l. dixon , y. t. huang , h. ita , m. kiermaier and r. roiban for discussions and collaboration on topics described in this presentation .
this research was supported by the us department of energy under contract de fg0391er40662 .
j.j.m.c . gratefully acknowledges the financial support of a guy weyl physics and astronomy alumni grant .
h.j.s research is supported by the european research council under advanced investigator grant erc - adg-228301 .
z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco and h. johansson , phys .
d * 78 * , 085011 ( 2008 ) [ 0805.3993 [ hep - ph ] ] .
z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco and h. johansson , 1004.0476 [ hep - th ] .
z. bern , t. dennen , y. t. huang and m. kiermaier , 1004.0693 [ hep - th ] . h. kawai , d. c. lewellen and s .- h .
h. tye , nucl .
b * 269 * , 1 ( 1986 ) ; z. bern , a. de freitas and h. l. wong , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 3531 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/9912033 ] .
z. bern , living rev .
rel . * 5 * , 5 ( 2002 ) [ gr - qc/0206071 ] ; n. e. j. bjerrum - bohr , p. h. damgaard , b. feng and t. sondergaard , 1005.4367 [ hep - th ] .
r. britto , f. cachazo , b. feng and e. witten , phys . rev
. lett . *
94 * , 181602 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0501052 ] .
z. bern , l. j. dixon , d. c. dunbar and d. a. kosower , nucl .
b * 425 * , 217 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9403226 ] ; nucl .
b * 435 * , 59 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9409265 ] .
z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , nucl .
b * 513 * , 3 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9708239 ] ; z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , jhep * 0408 * , 012 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0404293 ] ; r. britto , f. cachazo and b. feng , nucl .
b * 725 * , 275 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0412103 ] .
z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco , h. johansson and d. a. kosower , phys .
d * 76 * , 125020 ( 2007 ) [ 0705.1864 [ hep - th ] ] .
z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco , l. j. dixon , h. johansson and r. roiban , phys .
d * 78 * , 105019 ( 2008 ) [ 0808.4112 [ hep - th ] ] . s. badger , r. sattler and v. yundin , 1006.5011 [ hep - ph ] ; j. m. henn , 1005.2902 [ hep - ph ] ; c. papadopoulos , in these proceedings ; w. perkins , in these proceedings . c. f. berger _
et al . _ , in these proceedings , 1005.3728 [ hep - ph ] .
e. w. n. glover , c. oleari and m. e. tejeda - yeomans , nucl .
b * 605 * , 467 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0102201 ] ; z. bern , a. de freitas and l. j. dixon , jhep * 0203 * , 018 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0201161 ] ; z. bern , l. j. dixon and d. a. kosower , jhep * 0001 * , 027 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0001001 ] . l. j. dixon , arxiv : hep - ph/9601359 .
d. zhu , phys .
d * 22 * , 2266 ( 1980 ) ; c. j. goebel , f. halzen and j. p. leveille , phys .
d * 23 * , 2682 ( 1981 ) .
n. e. j. bjerrum - bohr , p. h. damgaard and p. vanhove , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 161602 ( 2009 ) [ 0907.1425 [ hep - th ] ] ; s. stieberger , 0907.2211 [ hep - th ] ; b. feng , r. huang and y. jia , 1004.3417 [ hep - th ] . c. r. mafra , jhep * 1001 * , 007 ( 2010 ) [ 0909.5206 [ hep - th ] ] ; n. e. j. bjerrum - bohr , p. h. damgaard , t. sondergaard and p. vanhove , 1003.2403 [ hep - th ]
. h. tye and y. zhang , 1003.1732 [ hep - th ] .
z. bern and a. k. grant , phys .
b * 457 * , 23 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9904026 ] .
w. siegel , phys .
d * 48 * , 2826 ( 1993 ) [ hep - th/9305073 ] .
z. bern , l. j. dixon , d. c. dunbar , m. perelstein and j. s. rozowsky , nucl .
b * 530 * , 401 ( 1998 ) [ hep - th/9802162 ] .
z. bern , j. j. carrasco , l. j. dixon , h. johansson , d. a. kosower and r. roiban , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 161303 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0702112 ] .
z. bern , j. j. carrasco , l. j. dixon , h. johansson and r. roiban , phys .
lett . *
103 * , 081301 ( 2009 ) [ 0905.2326 [ hep - th ] ] .
g. bossard , p. s. howe and k. s. stelle , phys .
b * 682 * , 137 ( 2009 ) [ 0908.3883 [ hep - th ] ] . h. elvang , d. z. freedman and m. kiermaier , 1003.5018 [ hep - th ] ; r. kallosh and p. ramond , 1006.4684 [ hep - th ] . j. bjornsson and m. b. green , 1004.2692 [ hep - th ] ; p. vanhove , 1004.1392 [ hep - th ]
. m. b. green , j. g. russo and p. vanhove , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 131602 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0611273 ] ; n. berkovits , m. b. green , j. g. russo and p. vanhove , jhep * 0911 * , 063 ( 2009 ) [ 0908.1923 [ hep - th ] ] .
z. bern , l. j. dixon and r. roiban , phys .
b * 644 * , 265 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0611086 ] ; z. bern , j. j. carrasco , d. forde , h. ita and h. johansson , phys .
d * 77 * , 025010 ( 2008 ) [ 0707.1035 [ hep - th ] ] .
z. bern , j. j. m. carrasco and h. johansson , 0902.3765 [ hep - th ] ; h. nicolai , physics , * 2 * , 70 , ( 2009 ) ; r. p. woodard , rept .
phys . *
72 * , 126002 ( 2009 ) 0907.4238 [ gr - qc ] ; l. j. dixon , 1005.2703 [ hep - th ] . | we review the recently discovered duality between color and kinematics in gauge theories .
this duality leads to a remarkably simple double - copy relation between diagrammatic numerators of gravity scattering amplitudes and gauge - theory ones .
we summarize nontrivial evidence that the duality and double - copy property holds to all loop orders .
we also comment on other developments , including a proof that the gauge - theory duality leads to the gravity double - copy property , and the identification of gauge - theory lagrangians whose double copies yield gravity lagrangians . |
based upon the second law of thermodynamics carnot proposed that every cyclic engines should consist of at least two reservoirs with two distinct temperatures , namely high and low temperature reservoirs .
the former supplies entropy accompanying heat into the engine , while the latter absorbs the supplied entropy to eliminate it from the engine .
it has been shown , however , that the engine proposed by szilard @xcite , referred to as the szilard engine ( sze ) , can be operated by using only a single reservoir , so that it was regarded as the so - called maxwell s demon @xcite which is believed to violate the second law of thermodynamics .
the thermodynamic cycle of the sze consists of three steps as shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] ; ( a ) to insert a wall so as to divide a box into two parts , ( b ) to perform measurement to obtain information on which side the atom is in , and ( c ) to attach a weight to the wall to extract work via isothermal expansion with a thermal reservoir of temperature @xmath0 contacted .
now it is widely accepted that the sze does not contradict the second law since the _ information _ entropy of the sze is transferred to the reservoir via measurement and erasure mediated by the demon @xcite .
the second law thus forces us to directly relate information to physical entropy , which reveals a profound role of information in nature .
the sze has been exploited to understand many physical problems in various contexts @xcite and realized in experiment @xcite . .
[ fig1],width=453 ] the third law of thermodynamics , proposed by nernst in @xmath1 @xcite , asserts that the entropy of a substance approaches zero as temperature approaches absolute zero .
this statement is true only if the ground state of the substance is unique . otherwise , the entropy approaches non - zero finite value called as the residual entropy .
many quantum statistical behavior in low temperature , e.g. the specific heat of solids , is governed by the third law .
however , it is now found that the third law is a derived law rather than a fundamental law .
interestingly there is no study on the relation between the information and the third law .
moreover , it has never even been asked what the role of the third law is in the context of the information heat engine , especially the sze . in the classical sze , the entropy production defined as
the work extracted from the engine divided by temperature is independent of temperature . in this paper
we show that the third law of thermodynamics manifests itself in the sze , particularly in the low temperature .
the entropy production is limited by the third law ; the entropy production vanishes as temperature approaches zero .
exception occurs when the ground state exhibits degeneracies either by accidence or due to symmetry .
the entropy production then approaches a non - zero finite value completely determined by the number of the degeneracies .
moreover , various non - trivial temperature dependence of the entropy production of the quantum sze containing bosons or fermions with or without interaction can be understood by considering the third law and such degeneracies . through this paper
we assume that all the measurement is performed in a perfect manner .
how the imperfect measurement modifies the results of the classical sze has been investigated in ref .
the non - equilibrium effect in the classical sze has also been considered in ref .
@xcite .
the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we introduce the work formula of the quantum sze and discuss one tricky point of when and how the measurement has been done during the thermodynamic process .
section iii is the main part of this paper .
we show the role of the third law in the sze and present the simplest model , one particle sze . in sec .
iv , we investigate various physical situations of two particle sze , which shows rich behaviors of a simple information heat engine in the low temperature .
finally , we conclude this paper .
to correctly address the behavior of the sze in low temperature , we should deal with it in a quantum mechanical way .
recently it has been found by one of us that the work of the quantum sze is expressed as @xcite @xmath2 where @xmath3 and @xmath4 represent the probability to find @xmath5 atoms in the left side of the box among total @xmath6 atoms right after a wall is inserted for the time - forward protocol , and that for the time - reversed protocol , respectively .
here @xmath7 , @xmath0 and @xmath8 denote the boltzmann constant , the temperature of a heat reservoir and the entropy production , respectively .
recently we reported , however , that eq .
( [ eq : work ] ) itself can be derived from fully classical consideration .
the partition functions , required to calculate @xmath9 and @xmath10 , differ in whether the classical or the quantum mechanics are taken into account @xcite .
all the calculations performed in this paper are based upon eq .
( [ eq : work ] ) .
now we would like to address one frequently asked question on the sze : when and how the measurement process has been done during the thermodynamic process .
the answer is that the measurement is automatically done by the reservoir when the box is completely separated into two parts by inserting a wall .
it is noted that the process of inserting a wall should be performed in an isothermal way in the quantum sze , which inevitably introduces the reservoir into the problem @xcite . in order to make the engine have a well - defined temperature at every moment the reservoir has to observe the eigenenergy of the engine so that each energy eigenstate is properly occupied following the canonical distribution .
below we show that such a measurement of the energy corresponds to that of the information on which part of box the particle is located in when the wall is inserted .
the engine and the wall can be modeled as an one - dimensional box and a potential barrier , respectively ; that is , @xmath11 and @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the hight of the wall . for simplicity
assume that temperature is negligibly small so that only the ground state is dominantly occupied .
when @xmath13 is large enough , the ground and the first excited state , denoted as @xmath14 and @xmath15 , respectively , are nearly degenerate so as to be almost equally occupied . thus the density operator is written as @xmath16 now we introduce @xmath17 ( @xmath18 ) , which describes a localized state in the left ( right ) side of the box , as follows latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } explicitly @xmath17 is written as @xmath20 @xmath18 can be given in a similar way with the probability localized in the right side .
one can then show that eq .
( [ eq : density matrix 1,2 ] ) is mathematically equivalent to @xmath21 it means that the state is now represented as the probability mixture of the left and the right side .
it is thus no need to perform any additional measurement on which side the particle is in since it has already been done by the reservoir .
when the wall is completely inserted the state of the engine is not a coherent superposition of two states @xmath17 and @xmath18 but rather their probability mixture .
the similar argument can be found in ref .
@xcite , where once the wall is completely inserted the reservoir is contacted with the engine in order to perform the isothermal expansion . in our case , however , the reservoir should be contacted during the whole process of inserting a wall .
here we prove that the entropy production , @xmath8 , is bounded by the entropy of a system , @xmath22 , which guarantees that @xmath8 vanishes as @xmath22 vanishes .
when the wall is inserted , the entropy of the system is expressed as @xmath23 where @xmath24 represents the probability that the system has a discrete energy @xmath25 when @xmath5 atoms reside in the left side of the box , and @xmath26 in the right .
according to @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the conditional probability that the system has an energy @xmath25 , once @xmath5 atoms are found in the left side , one finds @xmath29 where @xmath30 . here
@xmath31 and @xmath32 are exploited . as temperature approaches zero , the entropy of system @xmath22 and accordingly @xmath8 approach zero due to the third law .
now we consider the sze containing a single atom with the wall inserted at @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 denote the distance between the wall and the left end of the box , and the size of the box , respectively . here
the box is modeled as an infinite potential well .
it is shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] that the entropy productions of the quantum sze for various @xmath36 vanish as @xmath37 except @xmath38 .
note that the entropy production of the classical sze remains constant , i.e. a binary entropy @xmath39 , independent of temperature .
the deviation of the entropy production between the quantum and the classical sze becomes prominent around @xmath40 , where @xmath41 denotes the @xmath42th eigenenergy of the left ( right ) side of the box ( @xmath43 ) , namely @xmath44 and @xmath45 , where @xmath46 and @xmath5 are the planck constant and a mass of the atom , respectively .
the reason is that if @xmath47 is larger ( smaller ) than @xmath48 the left ( right ) side of the box is predominantly occupied once @xmath49 is satisfied .
this is confirmed in the inset of fig .
[ fig2 ] , where @xmath8 scaled by @xmath50 as a function of @xmath0 scaled by @xmath51 coalesce with each other for all @xmath36 , and all the curves start to bend at @xmath52 .
it should be noted that it was reported in ref .
@xcite that the work of the quantum sze is exactly equivalent to that of the classical one as far as a single atom is concerned .
this statement is true only if the wall is inserted precisely at @xmath38 , at which the ground state exhibits the degeneracy due to the reflection symmetry .
the entropy production associated with this degeneracy exactly corresponds to the classical one , namely @xmath53 . in a generic case ,
i.e. @xmath54 , however , the quantum result should deviate from the classical due to the third law . of the quantum sze with a single atom as a function of @xmath55 for @xmath38 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 and @xmath59 from top to bottom , where @xmath60 .
( inset ) the same data scaled by @xmath50 for @xmath61-aix and @xmath51 for @xmath34-axis .
[ fig2],width=321 ] let us discuss the meaning of the vanishing entropy production due to the third law in the context of information entropy .
as temperature goes to zero , only the ground state becomes dominantly occupied . for @xmath62 , the ground state is located in the right side due to @xmath63 .
thus it is no doubt that the atom occupies the ground state of the right side at zero temperature so that the atom should be found in the right without any uncertainty . in the viewpoint of information
the entropy is zero since there is no uncertainty for the location of the atom .
it also means one can not transfer any information or entropy to the reservoir by performing measurement and erasure .
therefore , the work can not be extracted from the engine .
if more than one atom is considered , the quantum statistical nature such as bosons and fermions comes into play .
however , the third law still governs the low temperature behavior of the entropy production .
when the ground state of the system is unique , the entropy production of two atoms vanishes at zero temperature no matter what they are bosons or fermions . in the case of bosons ,
the degeneracy of the ground state occurs when the reflection symmetry takes place , that is , @xmath64 .
the vanishing entropy production then becomes prominent for @xmath65 , which is clearly shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig3 ] presenting the entropy production of two non - interacting spin-@xmath66 bosons .
note here that there exists another energy scale @xmath67 , at which the entropy production starts to increases as @xmath0 decreases although it is not so dramatic in the inset of fig . [ fig3 ] .
this rather peculiar behavior is associated with the residual entropy @xmath68 appearing at @xmath38 at @xmath69 @xcite , which is larger than the entropy production in the high temperature limit , namely @xmath53 . as temperature decreases @xmath8 first increases around @xmath70 and then decreases around @xmath71 ( see the dashed curve in the inset of fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
such behavior becomes obscure when @xmath72 ( see the dashed dotted curve in the inset of fig . [ fig3 ] ) . of the quantum sze with two non - interacting spinless fermions as a function of @xmath73 for @xmath74 ( the solid curve ) , @xmath75 ( the dashed curve ) , @xmath76 ( the dotted curve ) , and @xmath77 ( the dashed dotted curve ) and ( inset ) two non - interacting spin-@xmath66 bosons for @xmath78 and @xmath76 from top to bottom .
( a ) the schematic diagram of energy levels at @xmath79 . the filled circle represents the ground state
is occupied by one fermion while two dotted circles denote two possible ways the second fermion can occupy the next state .
[ fig3],width=321 ] two fermions exhibit completely different behavior .
it is shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] that the entropy production of two non - interacting _ spinless _ fermions approaches zero even for @xmath74 .
the reason is that the ground state of two fermions is non - degenerate due to the pauli s exclusion principle @xcite .
however , at @xmath79 as temperature decreases the entropy production first decreases but finally approaches @xmath53 ( see the dashed curve in fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
this unexpected behavior is ascribed to the accidental degeneracy between the ground state of the left side and the first excited state of the right as shown in fig .
[ fig3](a ) .
one fermion then occupies the ground state of the right while the second fermion is allowed to occupy either the left or the right , which contributes to entropy by @xmath53 .
let us now consider more realistic situations , namely two spin - zero bosons with either attractive or repulsive interaction and two spin-@xmath80 fermions with either ferromagnetic or anti - ferromagnetic interaction .
it is not surprising that the results will become more complicated .
however , the basic principle is the same as before : how the entropy production behaves in the low temperature limit is completely determined by the third law .
now we have one more energy scale , i.e. the interaction energy .
make sure that the work can still be expressed as eq .
( [ eq : work ] ) even if the interaction between atoms takes place . of the classical sze of two distinguishable particles with the attractive ( the solid curve ) and the repulsive interaction ( the dashed curve ) and of the quantum sze of two spin-@xmath66 bosons with the attractive ( the dotted curve ) and the repulsive interaction ( the dashed - dotted curve ) as a function of @xmath73 for @xmath74 .
( inset ) @xmath8 as a function of @xmath36 at @xmath81 .
the schematic diagram represents the energy levels of several configurations depending on @xmath36 ( see the text for the detail ) .
[ fig4],width=321 ] here two interacting bosons are taken into account .
for simplicity the interaction potential @xmath82 for two bosons is modeled as follows : @xmath83 , where @xmath13 is negative ( positive ) for the attractive ( repulsive ) interaction , if two bosons are at the same side , otherwise @xmath84 . for the attractive interaction there exist two degenerate ground states for @xmath74 at zero temperature giving rise to @xmath85 since two atoms behave like a molecular pair by residing in the same side .
this is indeed equivalent to the single atom case studied above , and becomes pronounced when @xmath86 .
the slight increase of @xmath8 larger than @xmath53 ( the dotted curve of fig .
[ fig4 ] ) is a classical effect ( see the solid curve of fig .
[ fig4 ] ) . even in the classical case
it is more likely for two atoms to reside at the same side when the attractive interaction exists , from which configuration one can extract more entropy production than a non - interacting case . for the repulsive interaction ,
the residual entropy at zero temperature is zero since for @xmath87 two bosons considerably repel each other like two spinless fermions discussed above ( see the dashed - dotted curve of fig . [ fig4 ] ) .
the similar behavior can also be observed in classical case ( the dashed curve of fig .
[ fig4 ] ) . note that these correspondences between the quantum and the classical sze are available only at @xmath74 . as @xmath36 decreases from @xmath80 , the entropy production at @xmath81 rapidly vanishes for the attractive potential as shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig4 ] . for the repulsive potential ,
however , the maximum occurs at @xmath88 since the accidental degeneracy between two configurations shown schematically in the inset of fig .
[ fig4 ] can occur at @xmath89 .
now let us consider two spin-@xmath80 fermions with spin - spin interaction modeled as @xmath90 where @xmath91 and @xmath92 represent the spin of each fermion , and @xmath13 is a positive ( negative ) constant for anti - ferromagnetic ( ferromagnetic ) interaction .
the interaction potential can be rewritten as @xmath93 with @xmath94 .
if no interaction is considered , there exist six degenerate ground states for @xmath74 at zero temperature ; namely @xmath95 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath100 , where @xmath101 and @xmath102 denote the wavefunctions of the coordinate space in the left ( right ) side and those of the total spin states , respectively , and @xmath103 represents @xmath104 $ ] .
it is noted that the work can be extracted only from two of them , that is , @xmath95 and @xmath96 , since the others have one fermion per each side giving rise to no pressure difference between two sides .
this explains the entropy production approaches @xmath105 rather than @xmath106 at zero temperature as shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] . of the quantum sze with two spin-@xmath80 fermions with no interaction ( the solid curve ) ,
the ferromagnetic ( the dashed curve ) and the anti - ferromagnetic ( the dotted curve ) interaction as a function of @xmath73 for @xmath74 . ( a ) the schematic diagram represents the energy levels of the spin singlets ( @xmath107 ) and the triplets ( @xmath108 ) .
( inset ) @xmath8 as a function of @xmath36 at @xmath81 .
[ fig5],width=321 ] as far as the anti - ferromagnetic interaction is concerned , six degenerate levels are split into two groups so that the energy of the spin singlets ( @xmath107 ) , namely @xmath109 , becomes smaller than that of the triplets ( @xmath108 ) , namely @xmath110 , as shown in fig .
[ fig5](a ) . for @xmath87 , there exist three degenerate ground states instead of six .
it gives rise to @xmath111 , where @xmath112 reflects that the work is extractable from two cases among three [ see the lower row of fig .
[ fig5](a ) ] . for the ferromagnetic interaction , on the other hand ,
the opposite occurs ; that is , the energy of the singlets become larger than that of the triplets .
although again the degeneracy of the ground states at zero temperature is still three , the extractable work vanishes since there exists one fermion per one side in every configuration [ see the upper row of fig .
[ fig5](a ) ] . when the reflection symmetry is broken
, i.e. @xmath113 , the entropy production @xmath81 rapidly vanishes for both the non - interacting and the anti - ferromagnetic cases as shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig5 ] . for the ferromagnetic case , however , the maximum occurs at @xmath88 .
this might be associated with the accidental degeneracy similar to that shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig4 ] . however , the story is not that simple .
the accidental degeneracy between two configurations , namely @xmath107 and @xmath108 , presented schematically in the inset of fig .
[ fig5 ] , indeed occurs at @xmath88 .
since @xmath108 is triple - degenerate while @xmath107 non - degenerate , the entropy production of such configuration is given as @xmath114 however , this is smaller than @xmath115 , the maximum value of @xmath116 .
figure [ figs1 ] schematically shows the configurations of energy levels with @xmath36 varied .
the degeneracy between @xmath107 and @xmath108 takes place at @xmath117 which satisfies @xmath118 . by using eq
( 1 ) the entropy production can be written as @xmath119 where @xmath120 and @xmath121 in zero temperature limit are exploited . here
we can safely assume @xmath122 , implying @xmath123 due to @xmath124 as @xmath37 , in which @xmath125 denotes the energy difference between the configurations of two fermions and @xmath5 fermions in the left side ( @xmath126 ) . thus @xmath127 and @xmath128
are given as @xmath129 and @xmath130 where @xmath131 represents triple - degeneracy of @xmath108 state .
once we have @xmath132 , eq . ( [ eq : entropy_r_deg ] ) is recovered . as a matter of fact , eq .
( [ eq : entropy production ] ) is maximized by @xmath53 when @xmath133 or equivalently @xmath134 is satisfied .
it looks strange that the entropy production of the non - degenerate ground state is not equal to zero , and moreover exhibits the maximum possible value .
this is ascribed to finite temperature effect . for a non - zero temperature ,
no matter how small it is , there exist @xmath135 maximizing @xmath8 by @xmath53 once @xmath134 is fulfilled . as @xmath37 ,
@xmath135 approaches @xmath136 as shown in fig .
[ figs2 ] .
therefore , the maximum value of @xmath8 , @xmath53 , in the inset of fig .
[ fig5 ] is correct , and it occurs not at @xmath117 but at @xmath137 . as a function of r for @xmath138 ( the solid curve ) , @xmath139 ( the dashed curve ) and @xmath140 ( the dotted curve ) .
[ figs2],width=321 ]
in summary , we have shown that the third law of thermodynamics plays an important role in understanding the low temperature behavior of the sze . when there is no degeneracy in the ground state the entropy production vanishes in the zero temperature limit .
various degeneracies generated from quantum statistical nature , symmetries , interaction , and accidence determine the entropy production in the low temperature , which limits the work extractable from the sze .
we would like to thank takahiro sagawa , simone de liberato , and masahito ueda for useful discussions .
this was supported by the nrf grant funded by the korea government ( mest ) ( no.2009 - 0084606 , no.2009 - 0087261 and no.2010 - 0024644 ) . | the role of the third law of thermodynamics in the szilard engine has been addressed .
if the ground state is non - degenerate , the entropy production defined as the work extractable from the engine divided by temperature vanishes as temperature approaches zero due to the third law .
the degenerate ground state induced by the symmetry or by accidence gives rise to non - zero entropy production at zero temperature associated with the residual entropy .
various physical situations such as the sze consisting of bosons or fermions either with or without interaction have been investigated . |
this manuscript is dedicated to the memory of gerald e. brown who was my ph .
d. thesis advisor , a mentor in my professional career and a lifelong friend .
i first met gerry in the fall of 1972 when i was a graduate student in stony brook .
he just returned from nordita .
he summoned me to his office one day and asked me if i could do some calculation for him .
the problem is calculating the spectrum of two nucleons in the orbital @xmath0 with a delta function interaction.the next day , i went to show him my results .
he had a look and said `` the gap between the @xmath1 and @xmath2 states is a factor of 2 of that between @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
ok , you can work for me now . ''
i did not know it was a test to help him decide whether he wanted to take me on as his research assistant .
gerry is well known for many insightful quotations about physics .
let me relate one which is attributed to him and it may not have been recorded in a written form before . during the opening
talk at one few body conference , gerry was quoted to have said `` in classical physics , you can not solve three - body problem . with quantum mechanics , you can not solve two - body problem and with relativistic quantum mechanics , you can not solve one - body problem . in quantum field theory , you do nt know how to solve the vacuum . ''
following gerry s logic , we can now append his quote by `` with the advent of string theory , you no longer know where the vacuum is . ''
i have learned many - body theory and laudau s fermi - liguid theory under gerry and my ph .
d. thesis was on a self - consistent rpa calculation of nuclear giant resonances on hatree - fock ground states . in the later years , i have followed gerry to work on chiral soliton model of the nucleon , particularly the skyrmion .
the many intriguing properties of the nucleon both theoretically and experimentally have led me to work on lattice quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) calculation since the late eighties . from 1995 to 2009
, we have been meeting in caltech every january as part of a contingent of theory guests , courtesy of bob kckeown and of the kellogg lab . during these visits
, gerry would explain to me his work in black holes and heavy ion collisions and i would update him on the progress in lattice qcd . over the years , i would like to think that i have inherited part of his extraordinary enthusiasm and love for physics through osmosis and i have been influenced greatly by his way of dissecting and tackling a complex problem through intuition , backed by estimation .
it is natural to extend the study from nuclear structure to nucleon structure , especially when there is an excellent tool in lattice qcd .
i am indebted to gerry for introducing me to the fascinating world of nuclear and nucleon structures .
i would like take this opportunity to thank him for his encouragement and support over the years .
historically , the study of nuclear structure started out from models like the liquid - drop model , the collective models and the shell model .
the modern approaches include many - body theory , green s function monte carlo and lattice effective theory calculation . similarly , the study of nucleon structure progressed from quark model , mit bag model , chiral soliton model , qcd sum rules , instanton liquid model to the more recent lattice qcd calculation .
the latter is an _ ab initio _
euclidean path - integral calculation of qcd with controllable statistical and systematic errors .
i will make a comparison between the many - body theory approach to nuclear structure and the lattice qcd approach to nucleon structure .
i will draw some parallels of the two approaches and point out some differences .
many - body theory is a non - relativistic quantum field theory , while qcd is a relativistic quantum field theory . as such , concepts like valence and sea degrees of freedom , collective phenomenon , and vacuum polarization are common , albeit in different contexts . in the case of nucleus
, the first order of approximation is the mean - field description of the ground state of fermi sea , such as the shell model or the hartree - fock approximation as depicted in fig .
[ hf ] and the nucleon quasi- particle and -hole states around the fermi sea interact via an effective interaction .
this is analogous to the quenched approximation of lattice qcd where the partition function is approximated by the gauge action only without the fermion determinant as depicted in fig .
nucleon properties are calculated with the multi - point correlation functions with the 3-quark interpolation field for the source and sink of the nucleon at distant time slices in the pure gauge background .
more refined approaches to nuclear structure to take into account the particle - hole excitation include single particle renormalization with particle - phonon coupling @xcite and kuo - brown interaction of the valence nucleons via core excitation of phonons @xcite .
these are illustrated in fig .
[ kb_core ] . on the nucleon structure side
, the analogy would be the incorporation of the dynamical fermions in the gauge background field with quark loops in the vacuum which represent the fermion determinant in the partition function .
this is drawn schematically in fig .
[ lattice_df ] .
we shall show that there are parallel developments of the same concepts in dynamics as well as classification of degrees of freedom in many - body theory and qcd , since both are quantum field theories .
in section [ collectivity ] , we shall discuss collectivity in these two theories .
the z - graph in nuclear structure and the corresponding connected sea partons will be compared in section [ z - cs ] .
the core polarization will be contrasted with disconnected sea contribution in section [ core - polarization ] .
finally , we will present the latest lattice calculation to reveal the quark and glue components of the proton spin in section [ spin ] .
giant resonances in nuclei with large electric and magnetic transition rates can be qualitatively understood as a collective excitation of many particle - hole states in gerry s schematic model @xcite .
they have been successfully described in the random phase approximation ( rpa ) on hatree - fock ground states @xcite .
the rpa diagrams are illustrated in fig .
[ rpa ] . in qcd
, the fact that the experimental mass of @xmath4 is much larger than all the other nambu - goldstone bosons is known as the @xmath5 problem and is believed to be related to the @xmath5 anomaly of the divergence of the flavor - singlet axial current .
the resolution in the context of large @xmath6 has been given by witten @xcite and veneziano @xcite .
in fact , the veneziano s diagrammatic formulation as illustrated in fig .
[ veneziano ] is the same as gerry s schematic model for the degenerate particle - hole states . in the @xmath5 case , the collective upward lift from the @xmath7 and @xmath8
` would - be ' nambu - goldstone bosons is due to the constant coupling related to the topological susceptibility of the pure gauge theory .
we see that even though the physics contents of the giant resonance and the @xmath5 problem are different , both are the results of collectivity as is the case of bcs superconductivity .
therefore , it is natural to employ similar formulations to tackle them .
problem in veneziano s diagramatic approach . ]
in many - body theory with time - ordered bethe - goldstone diagrams , one inevitably encounters z - graphs as demonstrated in fig .
this refers to the part of the diagram where the a hole line is still connected to the valence particle lines when the interaction lines are cut .
this is in contrast to the particle - hole bubble in the left diagram where the hole line is disconnected from the valence particle lines when the interaction lines are cut .
this distinction of the ` connected hole ' and ` disconnected hole ' diagrams had not been introduced in the classification of the parton degrees of freedom until the surprisingly large gottfired sum rule violation was discovered in the deep inelastic scattering ( dis ) experiment by the nmc collaboration @xcite .
the gottfried sum rule @xcite , @xmath9/x = 1/3 $ ] , was obtained under the assumption of a symmetric @xmath10 and @xmath11 sea @xcite .
the nmc measurement of @xmath12 implies that the assumption of a symmetric @xmath10 and @xmath11 sea was invalid and the @xmath13-integrated difference of the @xmath10 and @xmath11 sea is @xmath14 dx = 0.148 \pm 0.039 $ ] .
this striking result from the nmc was subsequently checked using an independent experimental technique . from measurements of the drell - yan cross section ratios of @xmath15 , the na51 @xcite and the fermilab e866
@xcite experiments clearly observed the @xmath10 and @xmath11 difference in the proton sea over the kinematic range of @xmath16 .
[ hadonic_tensor ] in order to understand the origin of this large difference between @xmath17 and @xmath18 , an euclidean path - integral description of the hadronic tensor @xmath19 for deep inelastic scattering was formulated @xcite . in the bjorken limit
, there are three gauge invariant and topologically distinct diagrams , as shown in fig .
1 . the various lines in fig . 1 represent the quark propagators from the source of the nucleon interpolation field at time @xmath20 to the sink time at @xmath21 and the currents are inserted at @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
we first note that fig .
[ cs ] , where the quarks propagate backward in time between @xmath22 and @xmath23 , corresponds to contributions from the anti - partons which we refer as ` connected - sea ' ( cs ) @xmath24 and @xmath25 .
in contrast , the time - forward propagating quarks in fig . [ val+cs ] correspond to valence and cs partons @xmath26 and @xmath27 , where the valence is defined as @xmath28 and @xmath29 . finally , fig .
[ ds ] gives the the disconnected sea ( ds ) @xmath30 and @xmath31 for since it contains both forward and backward propagating quarks .
the nomenclature of connected and disconnected seas follows from those in the time - ordered perturbation theory
cs is the higher fock - state component in the z - graphs where the quark lines associated with the current insertions are connected to the valence quark lines ; whereas , the ds corresponds to vacuum polarization . we should point out a fine difference between the cs from fig .
[ cs ] and the connected hole in the z - graphs as illustrated in fig .
[ z ] . in the path - integral diagram in fig .
[ cs ] , the anti - quarks between the currents at @xmath22 and @xmath23 are pre - existing , i.e. they are in the nucleon wavefunction and exist before @xmath22 and after @xmath23 just as the case in fig .
[ ds ] so that dis is measuring the parton density .
they are not pair - produced by the hard photon from the lepton - nucleon scattering . the existence of the cs is easily revealed in the path - integral approach owing to the fact that it is a time - ordered formulation as are the bethe - goldstone diagrams . in this sense ,
[ cs ] can be considered a generalized z - graph . similarly , fig .
[ ds ] can be considered a ` direct diagram ' in the bethe - goldstone sense ; while fig .
[ cs ] , by the same token , can be considered the ` exchange diagram ' to reflect the fact that quarks are fermions . in the isospin limit
where @xmath32 , it is proved @xcite that the ds do not contribute to the gottfried sum rule violation .
the isospin symmetry breaking is small and can not explain the large observed violation .
rather , the majority of the violation could only come from the cs .
we see from figs .
[ val+cs ] and [ cs ] that the cs and the valence are tangled together in one flavor trace .
hence , there is no isospin symmetry between @xmath24 and @xmath25 since the state of the proton , being made up of two valence @xmath33 and one valence @xmath34 , is not an isospin singlet state .
furthermore , we see that while @xmath33 and @xmath34 have both cs and ds , strange and charm have only the ds .
as far as the small-@xmath13 behavior is concerned , there is only reggeon exchange for the flavor non - singlet valence and cs , so the small-@xmath13 behavior for the valence and cs partons is @xmath35 on the other hand , there is flavor - singlet pomeron exchange in addition to the reggeon exchange for the ds partons , thus their small @xmath13 behaviors are @xmath36 since the cs is in the same connected insertions as the valence , it evolves like the valence ; whereas , the ds evolves differently in that it has an additional pair - creation kernel from the gluon @xcite .
while the difference of @xmath37 and @xmath38 can be obtained from @xmath39 , there is not yet a well - established way to directly obtain @xmath40 and , for that matter , separately @xmath37 and @xmath38 from experiments .
we have shown a way to achieve this separation with a combination of experiments , the global fit of pdf , and a lattice calculation of the momentum fraction @xmath41 in the di in fig .
the recent hermes semi - inclusive dis experiment of kaon production on deuteron @xcite has produced the strangeness parton distribution function @xmath42 at @xmath43 .
we have used this data , combined with the ratio of the lattice calculation of the strange and @xmath44 momentum fractions in the disconnected insertion , and @xmath45 from the globally fitted parton distribution function ( pdf ) , to extract @xmath40 in the following formula @xmath46 at @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is from the ct10 pdf @xcite which contains both the cs and ds .
the strange parton distribution @xmath42 is from the hermes data and @xmath49 is the ratio of the strange momentum fraction to that of the @xmath44 in the disconnected insertion in a lattice calculation with dynamical fermions @xcite @xmath50 in extracting the cs in eq .
( [ udcs ] ) , we have assumed that the strange parton distribution is proportion to that of @xmath51 so that the proportional constant is @xmath49 . in this way , the cs @xmath52
is obtained in eq .
( [ udcs ] ) by subtracting the ds from the total @xmath48 from ct10 pdf .
obtained from is plotted together with @xmath53 from e866 drell - yan experiment and from sidis hermes experiment .,title="fig : " ] we plot the distribution function evaluated with eq .
( [ udcs ] ) , multiplied by the momentum fraction , i.e. @xmath54 in fig .
[ csupmd ] together with @xmath55 from e866 drell - yan measurement @xcite at @xmath56 and from semi - inclusive dis hermes measurement @xcite at @xmath57 .
we see that @xmath58 from eq .
( [ udcs ] ) is peaked at medium @xmath59 , the same way as @xmath53 from e866 and .
this is consistent with the expectation that the small-@xmath13 of cs , like the valence , behaves as @xmath60 as we alluded to earlier ; so that , when cs is multiplied with @xmath13 , it would be peaked at medium @xmath13 , in contrast to that of the ds , e.g. @xmath61 from the hermes experiment .
furthermore , we note that @xmath58 is generally larger than @xmath53 in this @xmath13-range as it should and is larger by a factor @xmath62 4 at the peak .
we also plot @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 from ct10 in fig .
[ csu+d ] to show that the cs and ds have very different @xmath13-dependence .
the different shapes of cs and ds are in good agreement with the expectation discussed earlier .
this agreement lends support to the approach we have adopted .
it is interesting to note that should a very different value of @xmath49 be used , the @xmath13-dependence of cs and ds would no longer agree with expectation .
obtained from is plotted together with @xmath66 from ct10 and @xmath67 which is taken to be @xmath68.,title="fig : " ] besides having different small @xmath13 behavior , the cs and ds evolve differently in the evolution equation @xcite .
the cs evolves the same way as the valence , while the the ds evolution has an additional contribution from the gluon splitting .
the global analyes of pdfs have not yet incorporated the separate evolutions for cs and ds .
in improving the magnetic moment calculation of one particle outside the closed shell , the core - polarization has been considered which involves the particle - hole excitation as depicted in fig .
this is referred to as the arima - horie effect @xcite in the nuclear physics literature , as shown in fig .
[ core ] . in the case of lattice qcd
, the nucleon form facts are calculated through the 3-point functions in fig .
[ 3pt ] . the connected insertion in fig .
[ ci ] contains the valence and the cs , while fig .
[ di ] contains the ds .
it is the latter that corresponds to the core polarization in the nuclear structure . for deep inelastic scattering , the valence and cs contributions from fig .
[ val+cs ] and fig .
[ cs ] have merged into the moment calculation of fig .
[ ci ] under the operator product expansion ( it is the short - distance taylor expansion in euclidean path - integral formulation ) . on the other hand , the ds parton and anti - parton contributions in fig .
[ ds ] has become the sum of di moments in fig . [ di ] .
we have done a complete calculation of the quark and glue momenta and angular momenta in the proton @xcite .
these include the quark contributions from both the connected and disconnected insertions .
the quark disconnected insertion loops are computed with @xmath69 noise , and the signal - to - noise is improved with unbiased subtractions .
the glue operator is comprised of gauge - field tensors constructed from the overlap operator .
the calculation is carried out on a @xmath70 quenched lattice at @xmath71 for wilson fermions with @xmath72 , and @xmath73 which correspond to pion masses at @xmath74 , and @xmath75 mev , respectively .
the chirally extrapolated @xmath33 and @xmath34 quark momentum / angular momentum fraction is found to be @xmath76 , the strange momentum / angular momentum fraction is @xmath77 , and that of the glue is @xmath78 . the previous study of quark spin on the same lattice revealed that it carries a fraction of @xmath79 of proton spin .
the orbital angular momenta of the quarks are then obtained from subtracting the spin from their corresponding angular momentum components .
we find that the quark orbital angular momentum constitutes @xmath80 of the proton spin with almost all of it coming from the disconnected insertions . in table
[ tab : chiral ] , we list the quark momentum fractions @xmath81 for the connected insertion ( ci ) ( @xmath33 and @xmath34 ) and disconnected insertion ( di ) ( @xmath44 and @xmath82 ) as well as that of the glue .
we also list the corresponding @xmath83 and total angular momenta fraction @xmath84 for each quark flavor and glue .
these values are obtained at @xmath85 gev in @xmath86 scheme after perturbative renormalization and mixing between the quark and glue operators @xcite .
.renormalized values in @xmath86 scheme at @xmath87 gev .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] and @xmath82 quarks.,title="fig : " ] we illustrate the composition of proton spin in a pie chart in fig . [ pie ] .
the total quark spin constitutes 25(12)% and the glue also gives 28(8)% .
the rest ( 47(13)% ) comes from the quark orbital angular momentum .
since the @xmath33 and @xmath34 quark orbital angular momenta in the connected insertion ( i.e. valence ) almost cancel , almost all of the quark orbital angular momentum comes from the disconnected insertion ( i.e. vacuum polarization ) .
we have used the momentum and angular momentum sum rules to obtain the renormalization constants for the lattice quark and glue energy - momentum tensor operators and used perturbative renormalization and mixing between the quark and glue operators to quote our final numbers in the @xmath86 scheme at @xmath87 gev .
this is the first time that a complete calculation on the decomposition of the proton momentum and spin is carried out .
now that we have gone through the complete calculation in the quenched approximation , the next step in to carry out the same calculations with valence overlap fermion on @xmath88-flavor dynamical domain - wall fermion gauge configurations on several lattices with different lattice spacings and sea quark masses so that we can obtain definitive results of the proton spin components at the physical pion mass and the continuum limit with realistic dynamical quarks in the vacuum in order to compare with experiments and make predictions .
one of the quantities to calculate is the quark spin and the most challenging part is the disconnected insertion .
we first calculated the quark loop for the axial - vector current and found that , contrary to the pseudoscalar and scalar cases , it is not dominated by the low modes . as a result , one needs a large number of noises to control the statistical error of the high modes . instead of increasing the number of noises ,
we take another approach .
we shall calculate the axial - vector matrix element from the anomalous ward identity @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the local topological charge operator . for the overlap fermion
, the topological charge is given by the overlap dirac operator , i.e. + we see from the r.h.s of eq .
( [ awi2 ] ) that the renormalization of the pseudoscalar density is canceled by the renormalization of the quark mass for overlap fermion and there is no renormalization for the topological term due the index theorem as obeyed by the @xmath90 defined by the overlap operator .
therefore , calculating the r.h.s .
( [ awi2 ] ) gives the non - perturbatively renormalized axial - vector matrix element which is the quark spin .
we show our preliminary results on the topological charge contribution whose signal is coded in the slope of the figure .
.,title="fig : " ] the slope is @xmath91 .
this is done on the @xmath92 lattice with 100 configurations and both the valence and sea quarks are at pion mass of 330 mev .
this is the contribution of the anomaly to the quark spin for each flavor and at @xmath93 .
when the @xmath94 extrapolation to @xmath95 and chiral extrapolation to the physical pion are carried out , we expect the number to be larger .
the pseudoscalar density contribution turns out to the very small .
we are analyzing them with more configurations and with more nucleon sources .
a statistical error of 15% is targeted .
production is ongoing for the two @xmath96 lattices with lattice spacings of @xmath97 and @xmath98 fm .
when the continuum and physical pion mass limits are taken , we should have a better picture on the quark spin in the proton .
we see that nuclear structure in many - body theory and lattice qcd calculation of nucleon structure share many conceptual similarities in the classification of fermion degrees of freedom and collective phenomena .
however , there is a significant difference in that the nucleon structure involves explicit glue contributions which are absent in the study of nuclear structure .
furthermore , there are triangle anomaly and trace anomaly in qcd which have significant consequences in quark spin and nucleon mass .
these are novel and challenging features in the study of nucleon structure both theoretically and experimentally .
i thank my colleagues in the @xmath99 collaboration for the lattice results .
the research is supported partially by the u.s .
department of energy grant de - fg05 - 84er40154 and the center for computational sciences of university of kentucky . | similarities between nuclear structure study with many - body theory approach and nucleon structure calculations with lattice qcd are pointed out .
we will give an example of how to obtain the connected sea partons from a combination of the experimental data , a global fit of parton distribution functions and a lattice calculation .
we also present a complete calculation of the quark and glue decomposition of the proton momentum and angular momentum in the quenched approximation .
it is found that the quark orbital angular momentum constitutes about 50% of the proton spin . nuclear structure , nucleon structure , quantum chromodynamics , quark and glue momentum and angular momentum 21.60.jz , 24.10.cn , 24.30 .
cz , 12.38 .
gc , 12.38.-t |
very recently the scientific community has paid a lot of attention in understanding the supercondictivity of the non - centrosymmetric superconductors , since the superconducting properties of such materials are expected to be unconventional @xcite . in a lattice with inversion symmetry , the orbital wave function of the cooper pair has a certain symmetry and the spin paring will be simply in either the singlet or triplet state .
the noncentrosymmetry in the lattice may bring a complexity to the symmetry of orbital wave function .
this effect with the antisymmetric spin - orbital coupling gives rise to the broken of the spin degeneracy , thus the existence of the mixture of spin singlet and triplet may become possible@xcite .
so there might be something unconventional , such as spin triplet pairing component , existing in the non - centrosymmetric superconductors .
recently , a spin - triplet pairing component was demonstrated in li@xmath6pt@xmath7b both by penetration depth measurement@xcite and nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr)@xcite , as was ascribed to the large atomic number of pt which enhances the spin - orbit coupling .
re@xmath0w is one of the rhenium and tungsten alloys family . up to now , two superconducting phases of re@xmath0w were reported with @xmath8k@xcite and @xmath97k@xcite .
both phases belong to the @xmath1-mn phase ( a12 , space group i43m)@xcite , which has a non - centrosymmetric structure .
moreover , atomic numbers of re and w are 75 and 74 , respectively , being close to that of pt .
therefore , similar spin - triplet pairing component as that in li@xmath6pt@xmath7b are expected in re@xmath0w .
most recently , it was found that the superconducting phase of re@xmath0w with @xmath10k is a weak - coupling s - wave bcs superconductor by both penetration depth @xcite and andreev reflection measurements @xcite . in this paper , we report the measurements of the ac susceptibility and low - temperature specific heat of re@xmath0w alloys .
both the measurements imply that our samples have two superconducting phases with critical temperatures near @xmath11k and @xmath12k , respectively , and the high temperature phase near @xmath11k accounts for nearly 78%-87% in total volume .
the specific heat data can be fitted very well by the simple two - component model , which is based on the isotropic s - wave bsc theory .
furthermore , a linear relationship is found between the zero - temperature electronic specific heat coefficient and the applied magnetic field .
these results suggest that the absence of the inversion symmetry does not result in novel pairing symmetry in re@xmath0w .
the re@xmath0w alloys are prepared by arc melting the re and w powders ( purity of 99.9% for both ) with nominal component @xmath13 in a ti - gettered argon atmosphere . normally , the obtained alloy is a hemisphere in shape with a dimension of @xmath14 mm ( radius ) @xmath15 @xmath14 mm ( height ) .
some pieces of the alloy had been cut from the original bulk ( e.g. sample @xmath16 and sample @xmath17 ) .
the ac susceptibility of these samples has been measured at zero dc magnetic field to identify their superconducting phases , whereas , all of them have two superconducting transitions at about @xmath11k and @xmath12k , as shown in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] .
the specific heat was measured by a physical property measurement system ( ppms , quantum design ) .
the data at a magnetic field were obtained with increasing temperature after being cooled in field from a temperature well above @xmath18 , namely , field cooling process .
under different dc magnetic fields , with ac field @xmath19oe and frequency @xmath20hz.,width=302 ] the temperature dependence of ac susceptibility ( @xmath21 ) at different dc magnetic fields from @xmath22 t to @xmath12 t is shown in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] .
one can see that two distinct superconducting transitions occur at @xmath23 and @xmath24 k in @xmath25 curve at @xmath26 [ fig .
[ fig : fig1](b ) ] , and double peaks in @xmath27 show up at the corresponding temperatures .
these two phases are consistent with the previous reports in which they are proofed to be non - centrosymmetric@xcite .
the peaks of @xmath28 shift to lower temperatures as the magnetic field increases , showing the continuous suppression of superconductivity by the magnetic field .
the low-@xmath29 peak shifts to lower temperatures more slowly than the high-@xmath29 one , indicating distinct behaviors of the upper critical fields in these two superconducting phases .
as @xmath30 increases to @xmath31 7 t , the @xmath32 curves are completely flat , showing no sign of superconducting transition .
similar results were obtained on sample @xmath33 and other samples . plotted as @xmath34 versus @xmath35 at various fields.,width=302 ] we thus measured the specific heat of sample @xmath33 and in fig . [
fig : fig3 ] we present the data of @xmath34 versus @xmath35 at various magnetic fields . on each curve , there are two jumps related to the superconducting transitions consistent with the measurements of ac susceptibility . from the zero field data in low temperature region , one can see that the residual specific heat coefficient @xmath36 is close to zero , implying the absence of non - superconducting phase .
the superconducting anomaly is suppressed gradually with increasing magnetic field , and from the curve at @xmath12 t there is no sign of superconductivity above @xmath37k , consistent with the observation in @xmath32 curve . the low temperature part of the normal state specific heat at @xmath38 t in fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] is not a straight line , implying that the specific heat of phonon does not satisfy the debye s @xmath39 law .
we may need a @xmath40 term to fit the normal state specific heat well : @xmath41 the first term is the electronic specific heat in the normal state , and the others are the contributions of the phonons . fitting the data of @xmath12 t to eq .
( [ eq : eq1 ] ) , the coefficients @xmath42mj / mol@xmath43k@xmath44 , @xmath45mj / mol@xmath43k@xmath46 , @xmath47mj / mol@xmath43k@xmath48 , and @xmath49mj / mol@xmath43k@xmath50 are determined . from the relation : @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the avogadro constant , and @xmath53 the number of atoms in one unit cell , we obtained the debye temperature of our alloys @xmath54k . these coefficients and debye temperature
are all very close to the results of other works on re - w alloys@xcite .
versus t. the solid lines are the calculating results which separate the electronic specific heat into two components with different @xmath18 by using specific heat formula based on the bcs theory.,width=302 ] by subtracting the phonon contribution , the electronic specific heat @xmath55 is obtained , which is shown in fig .
[ fig : fig4 ] as @xmath56 versus @xmath29 . before a quantitative analysis ,
the low temperature specific heat at low fields has presented a strong evidence that re@xmath0w has a nodeless gap function . for a nodal superconductor ( expected by the strong mixing of spin - singlet and spin - triplet pairing components in a heavily non - centrosymmetric superconductor such as li@xmath57pt@xmath0b ) , the low temperature @xmath34 vs. @xmath29 relation should be a power law like .
however , as denoted by the dashed lines in fig .
[ fig : fig4 ] , if a linear relationship is assumed , the specific heat at zero field would be negative when the temperature approaches to zero .
in the following section , by using a quantitative analysis , we will demonstrate that both phases of re@xmath0w have an isotropic gap function , which is in good agreement with the expectation of an @xmath5-wave superconductor .
on which the specific heat have been measured .
( b ) shows the zero field specific heat data , and the black line is the calculating result based on the bcs theory.,width=302 ] figure [ fig : fig5 ] shows the ac susceptibility and specific heat data at zero dc field measured on the same sample(@xmath17 ) .
the ac susceptibility data have been normalized .
the high temperature phase occupies nearly @xmath58% in the whole superconducting volume . in order to fit the zero field electronic specific heat
, we attempt to use the formula derived from thermodynamic relations based on the bcs theory@xcite @xmath59 where @xmath60 , and @xmath61 is an isotropic @xmath5-wave gap which depends on temperature in the same way as expected by bcs theory . since there are two coexistent phases in our samples , we use two separate terms of @xmath62 and @xmath63 to take into account the contributions of the high @xmath18 and low @xmath18 phases , respectively .
thus the total specific heat can be expressed as follows : @xmath64 in which @xmath65 and @xmath66 indicate the weight of the contributions for the two phases . according to eq .
( [ eq : eq3 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : eq5 ] ) we can nicely simulate the experimental data very well as presented in fig .
[ fig : fig5](b ) by a solid line .
the parameters for the best fit are @xmath67mev , @xmath68 for @xmath69k and @xmath70mev , @xmath71 for @xmath72k and @xmath73 is the gap value at zero temperature .
interestingly , @xmath68 found here is very close to the relative weight 85% of the high temperature phase which was obtained from the ac susceptibility data in fig . [
fig : fig5](a ) .
furthermore , @xmath74mev is in good agreement with that from the penetration depth and andreev reflection experiments@xcite .
these results give a strong evidence that there is no novel pairing symmetry in our alloys . to get further evidence for this argument
, we did similar calculations for the specific heat in the mixed state using the same weights of the two phases obtained from the zero field calculation . in the mixed state
, there are two different regions , namely the core region and the outside core region .
therefore we adopted a simple two - component model@xcite which separates the electronic specific heat into two components .
the electronic specific heat is thus written as @xmath75 here @xmath1 is an adjustable parameter .
the first part on the right hand side is the quasi - particle density of states ( dos ) coming from the normal vortex core regions , and the second part comes from the superconducting regions outside the cores .
the results of the quantitative calculations are plotted as solid lines in fig .
[ fig : fig4 ] , and they are in good agreement with the experimental data for all magnetic fields . at zero temperature obtained from the calculation based on bcs theory.,width=302 ] in the superconducting state , @xmath76 , where @xmath77 is the electronic specific heat coefficient that is dependent on temperature and field . according to eq .
( [ eq : eq4 ] ) , the zero temperature electronic specific heat coefficient @xmath78 is equal to @xmath79 , which is shown in fig .
[ fig : fig7 ] as solid squares , and the solid line is a linear fit to the data .
the obvious linear relationship of @xmath77 vs. @xmath30 presents further evidence that re@xmath0w is a conventional superconductor in which @xmath78 is proportional to the number of vortex cores and hence to the applied field . for a nodal superconductor with novel pairing symmetry , on the other hand , a nonlinear @xmath78 relation
should be expected , which is obviously not the case in our present samples@xcite .
in summary , we have synthesized re@xmath0w alloys by arc melting . from the measurements of ac susceptibility and specific heat on the alloys
two distinct superconducting phases were found .
both the qualitative and quantitative analysis were done on the specific heat data in zero field and the mixed state .
we found that the simple two - component model based on the bcs theory with an isotropic @xmath5-wave gap can fit our experimental data very well , and we obtained a linear @xmath78 relationship .
all these results indicate that the absence of the inversion symmetry does not result in any novel pairing symmetry in re@xmath0w for both @xmath10k and @xmath8k phases .
this work was supported by the national science foundation of china , the ministry of science and technology of china ( 973 project : no .
2006cb601000 , no .
2006cb921802 , no .
2006cb921300 ) , the knowledge innovation project of chinese academy of sciences ( itsnem ) . | the alloys of non - centrosymmetric superconductor , re@xmath0w , which were reported to have an @xmath1-mn structure [ p. greenfield and p. a. beck , j. metals , n. y. * 8 * , 265 ( 1959 ) ] with @xmath2k were prepared by arc melting . the ac susceptibility and low - temperature specific heat were measured on these alloys .
it is found that there are two superconducting phases coexisting in the samples with @xmath3k and @xmath4k , both of which have a non - centrosymmetric structure as reported previously . by analyzing the specific heat data
measured in various magnetic fields , we found that the absence of the inversion symmetry does not lead to the deviation from a @xmath5-wave pairing symmetry in re@xmath0w . ,
lei shan , qiang luo , weihua wang , re@xmath0w , non - centrosymmetric , superconductivity , specific heat |
simulations of the ism in a shearing box domain have shown that turbulence driven by sne leads to an amplification of the mean magnetic field . using the test - field method ( schrinner et al .
@xcite ) , we derived transport coefficients relating the mean electromotive force to the mean magnetic field ( gressel @xcite ) . with these we were able to reproduce the time behaviour seen in the simulations . under conditions found in our own galaxy , and assuming a constant circular velocity , a rotation rate @xmath0 was required for the dynamo to work .
in order to further define the turbulence properties as a function of the star formation rate , rotation and gas density , we analysed a comprehensive set of direct simulations . taking these as an input , we here compute global mean - field maps for a set of different model galaxies .
measuring test - field coefficients for a wide set of direct simulations ( gressel et al .
@xcite , @xcite ) led to the following scaling relations for the relevant diagonal term in the @xmath1 tensor , @xmath2 for the ( downward ) turbulent pumping described by the antisymmetric part of the @xmath1 tensor @xmath3 for the turbulent diffusivity @xmath4 and for the mean vertical outflow velocity @xmath5 the relations were derived for sf rates , @xmath6 , varying from one tenth up to the galactic value @xmath7 , angular velocities between @xmath8 and @xmath9 and midplane densities from @xmath10 up to @xmath11 . from the simulations , we moreover found a vertical gradient of the turbulent velocity @xmath12 independent of the star formation rate , density and angular velocity .
we approximate the vertical profiles for the @xmath1 tensor by a @xmath13 curve with a scale height of @xmath14 .
the value of @xmath15 is chosen to be constant for @xmath16 and linearly growing with a slope of one third outside this range . for simplicity , we assume a constant scale height within our models . we also neglect the anisotropic part of the turbulent diffusivity , which seems to be of minor importance for the current models .
the rotation curve is modelled with a brandt law @xmath17 further we modify the vertical wind above @xmath18 by adding a radial outward velocity of the same size as @xmath19 .
the wind velocities reach values of 100 - 200 km / s at z=4kpc , which is an order of magnitude higher than in the models of moss et al . @xcite . with these input parameters ,
we solve the induction equation @xmath20 in a cylindrical domain with @xmath21 , and of vertical extent @xmath22 . defining @xmath23 and @xmath24
, we obtain a dynamo number @xmath25 .
the pitch angle , @xmath26 , can be estimated by @xmath27 , scaling as @xmath28 .
these estimates show that stronger sf reduces the dynamo number and increases the pitch angle .
it is known that the stationary quadrupole solution of the @xmath29 dynamo exists only in a finite range of the dynamo number . because the final strength of the regular field also depends on the saturation process ,
this estimate does , however , not provide a prediction for the final field strength in dependence of the star formation .
nevertheless , this behaviour still opens the possibility for radially extended regular magnetic fields .
this is because , in an exponential disc , sf decays much faster with radius than the angular velocity , and hence the dynamo number may be nearly constant over a large radial range .
+ applying a kenicutt schmidt - type law , @xmath30 , we can specify our galaxy model by a radial density profile , which we leave constant up to @xmath31 and then exponentially decay with a scale length of @xmath32 , as seen in fig .
[ fig : models ] . for the nonlinear back - reaction
, we use a classical , however anisotropic , @xmath1 quenching . while the usual quenching of only the diagonal terms in the @xmath1 tensor
would lead to solutions with a small pitch angle , independently quenching the pumping term can also saturate the dynamo by the increasing field advection from the wind . in this case , the pitch angle of the kinematic mode can be preserved ( elstner et al .
the models rely on a crude approximation of the vertical profiles for the turbulent transport coefficients , which still leave some uncertainty in the absolute numbers given in table 1 .
nevertheless , the general trend agrees well with the predictions form the local dynamo number analysis .
the pitch angle , measured from the magnetic vectors ( see fig . [
fig : polmap ] ) of the polarisation map at @xmath31 , increases slightly with the star formation rate as predicted by the ratio @xmath33 above .
the growth times of the order of @xmath34 tend to increase with the star formation rate , but there are exceptions ( cf . a1 and a2 of table 1 ) .
no large - scale magnetic field amplification was observed for @xmath35 in model b3 , and in the weakly differentialy rotating model a5 . yet , strong starbursts are usually not long - lasting events and therefore the dynamo may still operate on longer time scales .
the final field strength is not strongly dependent on the sf rate , and only the toroidal field is influenced by the difference in turbulent diffusivity .
the inverse dependence of the dynamo action on the sf activity is mainly due to an enhanced turbulent diffusion .
this does not necessarily increase the turbulent velocity but may equally change the correlation time .
in fact , the preference of magnetic arms _ between _ the optical arms may be based on this very property of ism turbulence ( cf .
rohde et al .
@xcite ) .
* sf rate and rotation determine the dynamo calling for adequate galaxy evolution models .
* low star formation rates favour the dynamo , explaining coherent inter - arm fields .
* strong sf may suppress large - scale dynamo action ( no vertical fields in the centre ) .
* explaining the radio - fir relation will require a different type of amplification mechanism at least for the small - scale field .
elstner d. , gressel o. , rdiger g. , 2009 , iaus 259 , 467 gressel o. , elstner d. , ziegler u. , rdiger g. , 2008 , a&a 486 , l35 gressel o. , 2009 , phd thesis , university of potsdam ( astro - ph:1001.5187 ) gressel o. , elstner d. , rdiger g. , 2011 , iaus 274 , 348 moss d. , sokoloff d. , beck r. , krause m. , 2010 , a&a 512 , a61 rohde r. , elstner d. , beck r. , 1999 , a&a 350 , 423 schrinner m. , rdler k .- h . , schmitt d. et al . , 2005 , an 326 , 245 | magnetic field amplification by a fast dynamo is seen in local box simulations of sn - driven ism turbulence , where the self - consistent emergence of large - scale fields agrees very well with its mean - field description .
we accordingly derive scaling laws of the turbulent transport coefficients in dependence of the sn rate , density and rotation .
these provide the input for global simulations of regular magnetic fields in galaxies within a mean - field mhd framework . using a kennicutt - schmidt relation between the star formation ( sf ) rate and midplane density
, we can reduce the number of free parameters in our global models .
we consequently present dynamo models for different rotation curves and radial density distributions . |
in recent decades , relaying transmission as well as network coding have attracted increasing attention as these two techniques can well exploit cooperative diversity / network coding gain to improve network performance in terms of metrics of interest @xcite-@xcite .
two - way relay channel , a typical application which jointly utilizes relays and network coding , has been extensively studied in @xcite-@xcite , where the throughput of dnc are studied in @xcite and the rate region of pnc are studied in @xcite .
further , green communication has received increasing attention , as it introduces novel solutions to greatly reduce energy consumptions in communication systems designs . in the literature ,
numerous works studied reducing energy usage while still satisfying the qos requirement for various types of communication networks , e.g. , @xcite investigated an energy - aware transmission strategy in a multi - user multi - relay cellular network and @xcite discussed various energy - aware scheduling algorithms in wireless sensor networks . in this work , we are motivated to analytically analyze the energy usage of pnc and the superposition - coding based dnc ( spc - dnc ) .
we then find the decision criterion in selecting pnc or spc - dnc in terms of minimizing energy usage for each channel realization .
further , a pnc / spc - dnc switching strategy is designed to smartly select the energy - efficient strategy under fading channel realizations , with the qos requirement still being satisfied .
to better compare the two strategies , we focus on the end - to - end symmetric throughput scenario . however , our analysis can be naturally extended to asymmetric throughput case , and is omitted here due to the limited scope of this work .
in this work , a three - node , two - way relaying network over fading channels is studied . in this twrn , the two source nodes , @xmath0 and @xmath1 want to exchange data through the aid of the relay node , @xmath2 .
all nodes work in half - duplex mode and can not transmit and receive simultaneously . the direct link between the two sources
is assumed to be unavailable .
the channel power gains of the @xmath3-@xmath2 ( @xmath4 ) link is denoted as @xmath5 and that of the @xmath2-@xmath3 is @xmath6 .
the noise at each node is assumed to be additive white gaussian noise with zero mean and unit variance . in this work ,
we aim to minimize average energy usage for a twrn subject to a symmetric end - to - end rate requirement from both sources , which might be required by video / audio applications .
the two considered strategies are pnc and spc - dnc , which consist of two phases , including the multi - access uplink phase and the network - coded broadcasting downlink phase , as shown in fig .
[ fig : system ] . and @xmath7 is decoded at relay and forwarded to both users . in spc - dnc , both @xmath8 and @xmath7 are decoded at relay and then combined together before broadcasting on the downlink
. it is assumed that @xmath8 and @xmath7 are of the same length.,width=453 ] to minimize energy usage , we shall firstly review the energy usage of the two strategies , followed by the determination of the criterion rule in selection .
finally , the pnc / spc - dnc switching scheme is presented with the designed iterative algorithm .
in this section , we shall firstly discuss the energy usage of the pnc and spc - dnc schemes separately .
we then move on to find the rule in scheme selection for energy usage minimizing .
pnc is consisted of two phases . in the uplink phase , the two source nodes transmit @xmath9 and @xmath10 simultaneously to the relay node and the relay node decodes a function message @xmath11 and then forward it to both sources on the downlink .
as each source has complete prior knowledge of its own transmitted message , it can subtract this message and then decodes the message from the other source . in @xcite , it is found that the achievable pnc uplink rate @xmath12 is given by , @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the receive @xmath14 at each source node .
the required power at @xmath3 to support transmit rate @xmath15 on the uplink is therefore given by , @xmath16 and the total required power on the uplink then is @xmath17 on the downlink , the relay node broadcasts the decoded function message to both source nodes and the minimal power required to support broadcast rate @xmath15 is given by , @xmath18 where @xmath19 follows from that the broadcast rate is determined by the minimum channel gain of all source nodes .
the spc - dnc scheme time shares the traditional multi - access uplink phase and the network coded broadcasting over the downlink . on the uplink , assuming that @xmath20 , from @xcite , the messages from @xmath1 should be decoded first to minimize sum power consumption and the power of each source node is given by , @xmath21 and the minimal sum power required is given by @xmath22 where we define @xmath23 and @xmath24 to simplify notation .
on the downlink , the relay node also transmits the combined messages from the uplink and the transmit power required is identical to that given in ( [ eq : pnc_3 ] ) and is omitted here .
given both the power consumption for pnc and spc - dnc , we are interested in comparing them in terms of energy usage , given the same transmit rate requirement , the rule on selection of pnc and spc - dnc are hence presented in theorem [ the ] .
[ the ] given the channel realization and the uplink rate , pnc consumes less energy than spc - dnc iff the following inequality holds , @xmath25 it is observed that on the downlink both pnc and spc - dnc consumes the same energy given the same broadcast rate .
hence we only need to compare the energy consumed by pnc or spc - dnc on the uplink .
suppose the transmit rate over the uplink from both sources are @xmath15 , we have @xmath26 hence if ( [ eq : con_switch ] ) holds , we have @xmath27 and concludes that pnc is more energy - efficient than spc - dnc and should be selected for the given channel realization and transmit rate .
otherwise , spc - dnc uses less energy and is preferred .
further , from theorem [ the ] we can readily arrive at lemma [ lem ] as follows , [ lem ] if all the channel gains are equal , pnc is more energy - efficient than spc - dnc if the following inequality holds true and less energy - efficient otherwise .
@xmath28 the proof is omitted here as ( [ eq : lem2 ] ) can be readily obtained by solving a quadratic equation from ( [ eq : the ] ) . based on the observations above , it is therefore concluded that , pnc is beneficial under relatively high data requirements in terms of energy usage . on the other hand ,
spc - dnc is preferred for energy usage reduction in low - snr regime .
it is noted that both spc - dnc and pnc consumes the same amount of energy on the downlink with the same broadcast rate .
however , as observed , on the uplink , both strategies may consume different amounts of energy under channel variations .
therefore , it is promising to further reduce energy usage by smartly switching among the multi - access uplink transmission of spc - dnc and the uplink of pnc under different channel realizations to minimize total power consumption , given the qos requirement is met . in this sense , we define @xmath29 , i.e. , pnc or spc - dnc are selected based on their power usage to reduce energy usage .
in addition , we denote @xmath30 and @xmath31 as the time fraction assigned to the uplink and downlink transmission , respectively , the associated optimization problem , termed as * p1 * , is therefore formulated as follows , @xmath32 subject to the following constraints , @xmath33 where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the averaged minimal sum power usage on the uplink and that on the downlink over the distribution of the associated channel gain distributions .
( [ eq : opt_con_up ] ) and ( [ eq : opt_con_down ] ) are the rate requirements for the uplink and downlink .
( [ eq : opt_con_timesplit ] ) is the physical time resource splitting constraint .
note that * p1 * is not a convex optimization problem , due to the quadratic terms as well as the term @xmath36 , which is not convex as the minimal of two convex functions may not be convex functions .
instead , we can solve * p1 * by firstly assuming that only pnc / dnc is used and then iteratively updating the transmit scheme in terms of energy usage for each channel gain realization . in each iterative step ,
given the transmit rate allocated to each channel realization from last step , the more energy efficient strategy ( pnc or spc - dnc ) is adopted and hence the energy usage is reduced at each step .
the iteration ends until no additional energy reduction is attainable . in this sense ,
the switching scheme must uses less energy than employing only pnc or spc - dnc . to be specific , in each step , the transmission strategy for each realized channel gain is determined and the associated optimization is referred to as * sub - p1*. giving the analysis above , the steps of the algorithm is hence presented as follows
input : all possible @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath37 ( a predefined threshold ) 2 .
initialization : solve * sub - p1 * by assuming that only spc - dnc / pnc is employed in transmission and obtain the total energy usage @xmath38 in the initialized step .
iteration : compare the energy used in pnc and spc - dnc given the rate allocated in the last iteration under all possible channel realizations , and use the strategy with the minimal energy usage to replace the strategy employed in the last iteration and rerun * sub - p1 * and obtain the associated total energy usage @xmath39 .
4 . go to step 3 ) if @xmath40 and go to step 5 ) otherwise .
output : @xmath39 , the optimal time splitting , the best strategy for each channel realization , the associated allocated rate as well as the transmit power level in solving * sub - p1 * in the @xmath41th iteration . for clarity , a flowchart of the iterative algorithm
is also plotted , as shown in fig .
[ fig : flowchart ] note that in each iteration step , the energy usage is reduced .
in addition , the total energy usage is lower bounded by zero in nature . combining these two facts into account , the convergence of the iterative algorithm is guaranteed and at least some local - optimal point is achieved .
further , it is worth noting that , in our implementation , the algorithm converges within tens of iterations and is hence promising in practice .
it is also noted that at each iteration of the iterative algorithm , * p1 * reduces to * sub - p1 * where spc - dnc / pnc is selected and specified for each channel realization . it will be shown that * sub - p1 * is an equivalent convex optimization problem , followed by the analysis based on the karush - kuhn - tucker ( kkt ) conditions , which solves * sub - p1 * efficiently . to be specific , @xmath42 in * p1 *
is replaced by @xmath43 in * sub - p1*. in addition , to circumvent the difficulty of the quadratic terms , we define @xmath44 ( @xmath45 ) and @xmath46 ( @xmath45 ) .
hence , * sub - p1 * can be formulated as follows , @xmath47 subject to the following constraints , @xmath48 where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the the linear transformations of the perspectives of the corresponding convex functions @xmath51 and hence preserve convexity . the lagrangian function associated with * sub p1 *
is hence given by , @xmath52 the associated kkt conditions are then derived as follows , @xmath53 after some arithmetic operations , the optimal power allocations for the uplink is then derived as follows , @xmath54 where @xmath55 the downlink optimal power allocations with respect to the channel gains can be similarly derived from ( [ eq : downlink_opt ] ) and is presented below .
@xmath56 for the optimal time splitting , it is noted that the closed - form solutions are not tractable as the associated kkt conditions are transcendental equations . however
, numerical algorithms can be applied to find the optimal @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
henceforth , * sub - p1 * can be solved efficiently by kkt conditions and in each iteration of the presented algorithm the global optimal solution is obtained and hence we argue that the proposed algorithm in sec .
v above leads to a sub - optimal solution .
in this section , numerical results are presented to verify our findings . in the considered setting , noise at each node is assumed to be gaussian with zero mean and unit variance and all links are assumed to be rayleigh fading channels with unity link gain on average .
the reciprocity of the associated uplink and downlink channels is assumed .
the average total energy usage of each scheme is obtained by averaging over @xmath57 independent realizations of link gains and the average symmetric end - to - end rate requirement on both sides is in the unit of bit / s / hz . as observed in fig .
[ fig : all ] , pnc performs better than spc - dnc with relatively high data rate requirement and worse with low data rate requirement . in addition
, it is observed that the optimal switching scheme outperforms solely pnc and spc - dnc schemes for all data rate requirements and the performance gain achieved is hence demonstrated , validating the superiority of our designed switching scheme .
in this work , we studied a three - node , two - way relaying system .
our aim was to minimize average total energy usage for a twrn by switching between pnc and spc - dnc , while satisfying the qos requirement .
to this end , we analytically derived the optimal selection criterion for spc - dnc and pnc for each channel gain realization and the associated optimal problem to minimize energy usage by switching between spc - dnc and pnc was formulated and solved .
the performance gain of the designed adaptable pnc / dnc switching scheme , over the schemes by only employing spc - dnc or pnc , was validated by numerical results . c. fragouli , d. katabi , a. markopoulou , m. medard , and h. rahul , `` wireless network coding : opportunities & challenges , '' in _ proc .
ieee military communi .
( milcom07)_. 1em plus 0.5em minus 0.4emieee , 2007 , pp .
18 .
r. devarajan , c. s. jha , u. phuyal , and v. k. bhargava .
energy - aware resource allocation for cooperative cellular network using multi - objective optimization approach " .
_ ieee trans .
wireless communi .
5 , pp . 17971807 , 2012 . | in this work , we consider an energy minimization problem with network coding over a typical three - node , two - way relaying network ( twrn ) in the wireless fading environment , where two end nodes requires the same average exchange rates no lower than a predefined quality - of - service ( qos ) constraint . to simplify the discussion ,
the selected network coding modes only include physical - layer network coding ( pnc ) and the superposition coding based digital network coding ( spc - dnc ) .
we first analyze their energy usages and then propose a optimal strategy , which can be implemented by switching between pnc and spc - dnc for each channel realization . an iterative algorithm is hence presented to find the optimal power allocations as well as optimal time splitting for both uplink and downlink transmissions .
the conducted numerical study validates the performance improvement of the new developed strategy .
network coding , two - way , resource allocation , switching . |
the similar age of the stars in open clusters make them vital objects for the study of stellar evolution
. however , for such studies , it is essential to separate the field stars from the cluster members . proper motions ( pms ) of the stars in the region of open clusters provide a unique possibility of getting membership information of the stars .
proper motions in combination with radial velocities also provide valuable information on the kinematic parameters of the galactic rotation curve and the distance to the galactic center .
they are also useful to study the formation and evolution of the open cluster system .
the open cluster ngc 3766 ( @xmath11 ; @xmath12 ; @xmath13 ; @xmath14 ) is located in the carina complex of the milky way .
the cluster has been the target of many photometric studies ( ahmed ( 1962 ) ; yilmaz ( 1976 ) ; shobbrook ( 1985 ) , ( 1987 ) ; moitinho et al .
( 1997 ) ; tadross ( 2001 ) ; mcswain & gies ( 2005 ) ) with the aim to determine the various physical parameters of the cluster .
the most remarkable attribute of ngc 3766 is the presence of largest number of be stars yet known in any galactic cluster . among the 37 brightest stars , 12 show emission lines ( sher ( 1965 ) ;
schild ( 1970 ) ; lloyd evans ( 1980 ) ) .
fundamental parameters of b stars in ngc 3766 was studied by aidelman et al .
( 2012 ) using spectroscopic data .
a proper motion study of ngc 3766 was made by baumgardt et al .
( 2000 ) using eight stars taken from hipparcos catalogue and derived the mean absolute proper motion @xmath15 mas yr@xmath5 and @xmath16 mas yr@xmath5 . in spite of extensive photometric studies of this cluster ,
there is a lack of study providing proper motions and membership probabilities ( @xmath0 ) of the stars in the wide - field region of open cluster ngc 3766 . with the photometric data ,
membership information is desirable to minimize field star contamination .
the archival wide - field multi - epoch ccd observations taken with the wfi@*2.2*m telescope provide an opportunity to derive precise pms with a time - span of only a few years , and is deeper by several magnitudes than previous photographic surveys ( anderson et al .
2006 ; yadav et al .
2008 ; bellini et al . 2009 ; sariya , yadav & bellini 2012 ) .
the main purpose of the present study is to estimate the fundamental parameters of the cluster using stars chosen according to their derived membership probabilities ( @xmath0 ) .
the @xmath0 of different sources in ngc 3766 is also discussed .
we also derived luminosity function ( lf ) , mass function ( mf ) and mass segregation of the cluster using stars of @xmath17 70% .
the pms , @xmath0 and photometric @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes are provided to the astronomical community for the follow - up studies .
observational data alongwith reduction procedures and determination of proper motions are described in the next section .
colour - magnitude diagrams using proper motions are described in sec .
[ cmd ] . in sect .
[ mp ] we present cluster membership analysis .
[ par ] is devoted to derivation of fundamental parameters of the cluster .
luminosity and mass function are described in sec .
[ sec : lf ] while sec . [ sec : ms ] is devoted to the mass segregation study . in sect . [ cat ]
we describe our catalogue and finally , in sect .
[ con ] we present the conclusions of present study .
ccd data for ngc 3766 were collected with the wide - field imager camera ( wfi ) mounted on * 2.2*m eso / mpi telescope at la silla chile . using these archival data of two epochs ,
proper motions were computed .
the first epoch consists of four images in @xmath2 filter and three images in @xmath3 filter taken on 27@xmath18 feb 2000 , while second epoch have four images in @xmath3 filter taken on 9@xmath18 april 2006 .
the observational log is listed in table [ log ] .
the wfi@*2.2*m consists of eight 2048@xmath194096 eev ccds with @xmath20 pixel@xmath5 resulting in a total field - of - view 34@xmath21 .
images used in the analysis were taken between @xmath22 seeing condition and between 1.25 - 1.35 airmass .
long and short exposures were acquired to map the brighter as well as fainter stars of the cluster .
ccccc filters & exposure time & seeing & airmass&limiting mag .
+ & ( in seconds ) & & & + + @xmath2&2@xmath1930 ; 2@xmath19240&[email protected]&1.25&@xmath121 + @xmath24 & 1@xmath1930 ; 2@xmath19240&[email protected]&1.33&@xmath120 + + @xmath24 & 4@xmath1950&[email protected]&1.35&@xmath120 + for the reduction of mosaic ccd images , we adopted the procedure described in anderson et al .
( 2006 , paper i ) .
the procedure include de - biasing , flat - fielding and correction for cosmic rays .
to get the position and flux of the stars in the image , we made an array of empirical point spread functions ( psfs ) for each image .
an array of 15 psfs in each 2048@xmath194096 pixels chip ( 3 across and 5 high ) as shown in fig . 3 of paper
i was considered because psfs changes significantly with position on the detector . in total , 120 psfs have been considered for entire field of view ( 8192@xmath198192 pixels ) .
these psfs are saved in a look - up table on a very fine grid . to select suitable stars for the psfs , an automatic code was developed ( see paper i ) .
an iterative process is designed to work from the brightest down to the faintest stars and find their precise position and instrumental flux for @xmath2 and @xmath3 exposures . and @xmath3 and as a function of @xmath3 magnitudes.,width=321 ] in paper i
, it is shown that wfi@*2.2*m has a large geometric distortion , i.e. pixel scale is changing across the field of view ( see paper i ) . to derive the correction for geometric distortion
, we parametrized the distortion solution by a look - up table of corrections for each chip that covered each 2048@xmath194096 pixel chip , sampling every 256 pixels .
this resulted in a 9@xmath1917 element array of corrections for each chip . at
any given location on the detector , a bi - linear interpolation between the four closest grid points of the look - up table provided the corrections for the target point . the derived look - up table may have a lower accuracy on the edges of a field because of the way the self - calibration frames were dithered ( see paper i ) . an additional source of uncertainty is related to a possible instability of distortions for the @xmath25 m reported earlier .
this prompted us to use the local - transformation method to derive pms .
detailed descriptions about the distortion solution is given in paper i. in the local transformation approach a small set of local reference stars is selected around each target object .
it is advantageous to use pre - selected cluster members to form a local reference frame because of a much lower intrinsic velocity dispersion among the cluster members .
then , six - parameter linear transformations are used to transform the coordinates from one frame into another , taken at different epochs .
a general linear transformation from one frame @xmath26 into another @xmath27 has 6 parameters , and can be put into the following form : + @xmath28= \left [ \begin{array}{cc } a~~ b\\c~~ d \end{array } \right ] \left [ \begin{array}{c } x - x_0\\y - y_0 \end{array } \right ] + \left [ \begin{array}{c } u_0\\v_0 \end{array } \right]$ ] + the parameters @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the linear terms , and @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the constant terms .
the equation look like there are 8 free parameters in the equations , but we can choose the zero - point in one frame arbitrarily , so only one of the two offsets is actually solved for . the easiest way to solve for the offsets is to adopt the centroid of the star list in the first frame as the offset for that frame , @xmath35 .
then , the centroid in the other frame will be the least - squares solution for the other offset , ( @xmath36 .
the residuals of this transformation are characterizing relative pms convolved with measurement errors .
in essence , this is a classical `` plate pair '' method but extended to all possible combinations of the first and second epoch frames .
relative pm of a target object is the average of all displacement measurements in its local reference frame .
the last step is to estimate the measurement errors from intra - epoch observations where pms have a zero contribution .
a complete description of all steps leading to pms is given in paper i. in order to transform instrumental @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes into the standard johnson - cousin system , we used the data published by moitinho et al .
total 92 stars were used to calibrate @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes .
we derived photometric zero - points and colour terms using the following transformation equations : + @xmath37 @xmath38 + where the subscript `` ins '' means instrumental magnitudes and `` std '' stands for secondary standard magnitudes . @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the colour terms while @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the global zero - points .
the quadratic colour terms are negligible .
the values of colour terms are 0.29 and 0.16 , while the zero - points are 24.39 and 23.79 for @xmath2 and @xmath3 filters respectively . versus visual magnitude.,width=321 ] in fig .
[ error_mag ] we show the rms of the residuals around the mean magnitude for each filter as a function of the @xmath3 magnitude .
the photometric standard deviations have been computed from multiple observations , all reduced to the common photometric reference frame in the chosen bandpass .
the stars brighter than @xmath1 12.0 mag in @xmath3 have higher dispersion because of saturation . on average , photometric
rms are better than @xmath10.02 mag for stars between 12 - 18 mag and @xmath1 0.04 mag between 18 - 20 mag in @xmath3 filter .
the @xmath43 raw coordinates of each star in each frame were corrected for geometric distortion using the look - up table provided in paper i , brought into a common reference frames by means of six - parameter linear transformations , and averaged . to transform the averaged @xmath44 and @xmath45
coordinate into ra and dec of j2000 , we used the online digitized sky eso catalogue in skycat software , as an absolute astrometric reference frame . thanks to our accurate geometric - distortion solution and a reasonable stability of the intra - chip positions , that it was possible to apply a single plate model involving linear and quadratic terms and a small but significant cubic term in each coordinate .
this solution also absorbs effects caused by differential refraction .
the standard error of equatorial solution is @xmath1 30 mas in each coordinate .
proper motions were computed using @xmath3-filter images to minimize colour - dependent terms in our analysis .
moreover , our geometric - distortion solution provides the smallest residuals with @xmath3 images ( paper i ) .
a total of three images for first epoch and four images for the second epoch were used in proper motion determination .
first , we selected a sample of probable cluster members using the @xmath3 vs. @xmath46 cmd .
selected stars are located on the main - sequence in the magnitude range 8.0@xmath47 mag .
these stars define a local reference frame to transform the positions of a given first - epoch image into positions of a second - epoch image . by adopting only stars on cluster sequence having proper motion errors @xmath483.0 mas yr@xmath5
, we assure that pms are measured relative to the bulk motion of the cluster . to minimize the effect of uncorrected distortion residuals we used the local transformation approach based on the closest 25 reference stars on the same ccd chip .
no systematics larger than random errors are visible close to the corners or edges of chips .
we iteratively removed some stars from the preliminary photometric member list that had proper motions clearly inconsistent with cluster membership , even though their colours placed them near the fiducial cluster sequence .
the distribution of proper motions rms error is presented in fig .
[ error_pm ] .
the precision of the proper motion measurement is better than 3 mas yr@xmath5 upto 14 mag in @xmath3 .
they are gradually increasing upto 4 mas yr@xmath5 for @xmath49 mag . and @xmath50 as a function of @xmath44 and @xmath45 in @xmath51 pixels .
gaps in @xmath44 and @xmath45 axis are the inter - chip space present in the mosaic ccd.,width=340,height=340 ] ucac3 catalogue ( zacharias et al .
( 2010 ) ) provides the absolute proper motions of the stars in the region of ngc 3766 .
there are 94 common stars found to be brighter than @xmath52 mag .
to compare our proper motions with ucac3 , we changed the ucac3 proper motions to relative proper motions .
for this , we subtracted the mean absolute proper motion of the cluster ( @xmath53 mas yr@xmath5 , @xmath54 mas yr@xmath5 ) from individual proper motion of stars .
[ ucac3 ] shows the comparison of our pms with those of the ucac3 catalogue .
top - left panel shows the vector - point diagrams ( vpds ) of ucac3 stars while top - right panel shows the vpd of our measurements .
a concentration of stars around ( 0 , 0 ) mas yr@xmath5 is seen in both vpds .
our proper motions distribution is tighter than the ucac3 distribution .
this is because our data is more precise than ucac3 data . in the lower panels of fig .
[ ucac3 ] we show the proper motions in @xmath55 and @xmath50 as a function of @xmath44 and @xmath45 coordinates .
there is no clear systematic trend seen in this diagram .
pms @xmath55 and @xmath50 are plotted as vpd in the top panels of fig .
[ cmd_inst ] .
bottom panels show the corresponding @xmath3 vs. @xmath46 cmd .
left panels show all stars while middle and right panels show the probable cluster members and field stars .
a circle of 4 mas yr@xmath5 around the cluster centroid in vpd of proper motions defines our membership criterion .
the chosen radius is a compromise between losing cluster members with poor proper motions and including field stars sharing the cluster mean proper motion .
the shape of cluster members pm dispersion is circular , providing that our pm measurements are not affected by any systematics .
the cmd of most probable cluster members is shown in the lower middle panel .
main - sequence of the cluster is clearly separate out , which demonstrates the power of pms derived in this study .
the lower right panel represents the cmd for field stars .
few cluster members are also visible in this cmd because of their poorly determined proper motions . fig .
[ cmd_ii ] shows @xmath56 cmd with vpd in various magnitude bins .
we divided the cmd into five magnitude bins and in each bin , we adopted different selection criteria to identify cluster members , which were more stringent for stars with more reliable measurements from data of high signal - to - noise ratio , and less restrictive for stars with less precise measurements .
these stars have a proper - motion error of @xmath57 3.0 mas yr@xmath5 . for each magnitude bin
, we considered as cluster members those stars with a proper motion within the circle shown in the middle column of fig .
[ cmd_ii ] . the right side of fig .
[ cmd_ii ] shows the color - magnitude diagram for stars assumed to be cluster members .
this figure shows that the separation of brighter cluster members from the field stars is clearly visible while fainter members are not clearly separated out .
the reason may be that proper motions for fainter stars are not determined accurately .
the available archive images are again not sufficiently deep to derive reliable proper motions of fainter stars .
the proper motions derived in this paper are also not sufficiently accurate to study the internal motion of the cluster .
the vpd for the proper motions derived in this study is shown in fig.[cmd_inst ] .
present proper motion leads to the compact appearance of the cluster stars in vpd .
membership determination based on proper motions is useful for further astrophysical studies in the region of cluster .
the fundamental mathematical model set up by vasilevskis et al . ( 1958 ) and the technique based upon the maximum likelihood principle developed by sanders ( 1971 ) for membership determination have been continuously used and refined . an improved method for membership determination of stars in clusters based on proper motions with different observed precisions
was developed by stetson ( 1980 ) and zhao & he ( 1990 ) .
zhao & shao ( 1994 ) then added the correlation coefficient of the field star distribution to the set of parameters describing their distribution on the sky .
a tight clump at @xmath58cos@xmath59=@xmath50=0.0 mas yr@xmath5 in fig . [ cmd_inst ] is representing the cluster stars and a broad distribution is seen for the field stars .
[ cmd_ii ] indicates that the field stars centroid for panel 3 ( middle column ) is at a different location than for the last panel .
therefore , we consider two groups ( @xmath60 mag and @xmath61 mag ) for membership determination . to determine the membership probability
, we adopted the method described in balaguer - nunez et al .
this method has already been used for @xmath62 centauri ( bellini et al .
( 2009 ) ) and by us for ngc 6809 ( sariya et al .
( 2012 ) ) . in this method
first we construct the frequency distribution of cluster stars ( @xmath63 ) and field stars ( @xmath64 ) .
the frequency function for the @xmath65 star of a cluster can be written as follows : + @xmath66 } \}$ ] + where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are the proper motions of the @xmath65 star while @xmath69 and @xmath70 are the cluster s proper motion center .
@xmath71 is the intrinsic proper motion dispersion of cluster member stars and ( @xmath72 ) are the observed errors in the proper motion components of @xmath73 star .
the frequency distribution for @xmath65 field star is as follows : + @xmath74 @xmath75\}$ ] where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are the proper motions of @xmath73 star while @xmath76 and @xmath77 are the field proper motion center . @xmath78 and @xmath79 are the observed errors in proper motions component and @xmath80 and @xmath81 are the field intrinsic proper motion dispersions and @xmath82 is the correlation coefficient .
it is calculated by @xmath83 we did not consider the spatial distribution of the stars due to small observed field . to define the distribution function @xmath84 and @xmath85 we used stars having proper motion error better than 3 mas yr@xmath5 .
as expected , in the vpd , the center of cluster stars is found to be at @xmath86 = 0.0 mas yr@xmath5 and @xmath87 = 0.0 mas yr@xmath5 .
our proper motion data set could not determine intrinsic proper motion dispersion ( @xmath71 ) for cluster stars . assuming a distance of 2.5 kpc ( present estimate ) and radial velocity dispersion 1 kms@xmath5 for open clusters ( girard et al .
( 1989 ) ) , the expected dispersion in proper motions would be @xmath1 0.08 mas yr@xmath5 .
therefore , we adopted @xmath71 = 0.08 mas yr@xmath5 . for field stars
@xmath88 mag , we have : @xmath89 = @xmath904.9 mas yr@xmath5 , @xmath91 = 2.7 mas yr@xmath5 , @xmath80 = 5.7 mas yr@xmath5 and @xmath81 = 4.0 mas yr@xmath5 , while for @xmath92 mag : @xmath89 = @xmath905.4 mas yr@xmath5 , @xmath91 = 0.5 mas yr@xmath5 @xmath80 = 6.6 mas yr@xmath5 and @xmath81 = 5.3 mas yr@xmath5 . + the distribution of all the stars can be calculated as + @xmath93 + where @xmath94 and @xmath95 are the normalized number of stars for cluster and field ( @xmath96 ) . for the first group ( @xmath60 mag ) , @xmath97 and @xmath98 while for the second group ( @xmath92 mag ) , @xmath99 and @xmath100
therefore , the membership probability for @xmath73 star is + @xmath101 + a good indicator of cluster and field separation is the membership probability .
it is plotted as a function of magnitude in fig .
[ vvsmp ] .
as seen in this plot , high membership probability ( @xmath102 ) extend down to @xmath103 mag . at fainter magnitudes the maximum probability gradually decreases .
[ mp_hist ] shows the histogram of membership probabilities for 2468 stars in the cluster region .
it shows a clear separation between cluster members and field stars .
this also indicates that the proper motion membership determination made using the method mentioned above is effective for the cluster ngc 3766 .
we find 818 stars with membership probabilities higher than 70% .
as function of the @xmath3 magnitude , for all the stars in our catalogue . at @xmath104 mag and fainter ,
@xmath105 diminishes as a result of increasing errors in the pms.,width=321 ] during the observations of the cluster we can not avoid the contamination by background and foreground objects . the effectiveness of our membership determination can be estimated using membership probabilities as described in shao & zhao ( 1996 ) .
the effectiveness of membership determination is estimated as : + @xmath106}{\sum_{i=1}^n p(i)\sum_{i=1}^n ( 1-p(i))}$ ] , + where the bigger e is , the more effective the membership determination is .
so we determine the effectiveness of membership determination as 0.65 for ngc 3766 .
it is shown in fig .
3 of shao & zhao ( 1996 ) that the effectiveness of membership determination of 43 open clusters are from 0.20 to 0.90 with peak value 0.55 . compared with the work by shao & zhao ( 1996 )
, we can see that the effectiveness of membership determination for ngc 3766 is significantly high .
70% in ngc 3766 region.,width=321 ] present catalogue can be used to assign membership probability of various types of stars in this cluster .
we found three be stars and one ap star in our catalogue according to the categorization in webda .
membership probabilities of these stars are listed in table [ vari ] .
the value of @xmath107 for the listed stars indicate that they are member of the cluster .
.membership probabilities of be and ap stars in the region of ngc 3766 . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
the purpose of this study is to provide a catalogue of precise proper motions and membership probability of stars in the field of open cluster ngc 3766 .
we have obtained proper motions and astrometric membership probabilities down to @xmath6 mag in 15@xmath1930 arcmin@xmath108 area around the open cluster ngc 3766 .
the fundamental parameters , lf , mf and mass segregation are derived using the stars of @xmath9 .
the linear radius of the cluster derived in the present study is 3.6 pc .
the interstellar reddening @xmath109 is found to be [email protected] mag . a distance of [email protected] kpc and an age of @xmath1 20 myr
have been derived for the cluster .
the mf slope @xmath10 is estimated using the stars brighter than 16.0 mag in @xmath3 .
present analysis indicates that ngc 3766 is dynamically relaxed and one possible reason of this relaxation may be the dynamical evolution of the cluster .
finally , we provide the membership probability for different types of stars , already found in the literature . here
, we also demonstrate that the ccd observations taken just 6 years apart can provide accurate proper motions and it can be used to separate the cluster members from field stars down to @xmath6 mag . + * acknowledgments * + this work was based on observations with the mpg / eso 2.2-m telescope located at la silla and paranal observatory , chile , under ddt programs 164.o-0561(e ) and 077.c-0188(b ) .
we thank the anonymous referee for a careful reading of the manuscript and for many useful comments .
this research has made use of the vizier catalogue access tool , cds , strasbourg , france and of the webda open cluster database .
schmidt - kaler th . , 1982 , in : landolt / bornstein , numerical data and functional relationship in science and technology , new series , group vi , vol . 2b , scaifers k. & voigt h. h. ( eds . )
springer - verlog , berlin , p. 14 | relative proper motions and cluster membership probabilities ( @xmath0 ) have been derived for @xmath1 2500 stars in the field of the open star cluster ngc 3766 . the cluster has been observed in @xmath2 and @xmath3 broadband filters at two epochs separated by @xmath1 6 years using a wide - field imager mounted on the wfi@eso*2.2*m telescope .
all ccd frames were reduced using the astrometric techniques described in anderson et al .
( 2006 ) .
the proper motion r.m.s .
error for stars brighter than @xmath4 mag is 2.0 mas yr@xmath5 but it gradually increases up to @xmath14 mas yr@xmath5 at @xmath6 mag . using proper motion data ,
membership probabilities have been derived for the stars in the region of the cluster .
they indicate that three be and one ap stars are member of the cluster .
the reddening @xmath7 mag , a distance [email protected] kpc and an age of @xmath1 20 myr are derived using stars of @xmath9 .
mass function slope @xmath10 is derived for the cluster and cluster was found to be dynamically relaxed .
finally , we provide positions , calibrated @xmath2 and @xmath3 magnitudes , relative proper motions and membership probabilities for the stars in the field of ngc 3766 .
we have produced a catalog that is electronically available to the astronomical community .
[ firstpage ] galaxy : open cluster : individual : ngc 3766 - astrometry - catalogs |
one of the outstanding questions in contemporary astronomy is the origin of hecrs ranging from below the knee of the cosmic - ray spectrum at @xmath4 ev to the highest energies exceeding @xmath5 ev .
ultra - high energy cosmic rays ( uhecrs ) , defined here as cosmic rays ( crs ) with energies greater than the ankle energy at @xmath6 ev , are probably extragalactic protons in view of their large gyroradii , lack of enhancements of arrival directions toward the galactic plane , the observed flattening of the cosmic - ray spectrum at the ankle ( which could result from photopair energy - loss processes on cosmic - ray protons @xcite ) , and suggestions of a composition change from heavy to light nuclear composition above @xmath7 ev @xcite ( see @xcite for a review ) .
because high - energy protons will radiate @xmath1-ray photons from hadronic and leptonic processes at the site where they are produced , the most likely candidate sources of uhecrs are extragalactic nonthermal @xmath1-ray emitters , specifically grbs and blazar agns .
models for these sources involve jets of relativistic plasma that are ejected by accreting black holes .
the paucity of blazar sources within tens of mpc that could account for the near isotropy of cosmic rays at energies @xmath8 ev suggest that grbs are the sources of uhecrs .
grbs in the galaxy will also accelerate hecrs , and could form most of the cosmic rays with energies between @xmath9 ev and @xmath10 ev . several types of observations can test this hypothesis .
detection of high - energy neutrinos from a grb , which would requires an ultra - relativistic hadronic component that is much more powerful than the nonthermal electron component that produces the hard x - ray and soft @xmath1-ray emissions from grbs @xcite , is predicted by this model .
another prediction is the detection of hadronic emission components in the spectra of grbs .
the unusual @xmath1-ray emission component observed @xcite in grb 941017 , which could be caused by ultra - relativistic hadron acceleration and photopion processes in the inner jets of grbs @xcite , could be the first example of such a signature .
a third observation that would implicate grbs as the sources of hecrs is the detection of high - energy neutron @xmath2-decay halos around star - forming galaxies @xcite , including @xmath2-decay emission from grbs in the milky way @xcite .
a fourth observation is the absence of @xmath11 ev cosmic - ray _ point - source _ excesses , such as the source claimed to be detected with the sugar array .
this is opposite to the conclusion arrived by @xcite , as explained below , and will soon be tested with the auger experiment , which is now taking data .
we have recently proposed a model for hecrs from galactic and extragalactic grbs @xcite , building on previous suggestions that uhecrs are accelerated by extragalactic grbs @xcite . in our model , relativistic outflows in grbs are assumed to inject power - law distributions of cosmic rays to the highest ( @xmath12 ev ) energies . a diffusive propagation model for hecrs from a single recent grb within @xmath13 kpc from earth that took place within the last 0.5 million years can explain the kascade data for the cr ion spectra near and above the knee . the cr spectrum at energies @xmath11 ev is fit with crs from extragalactic grbs .
uhecrs produced by extragalactic grbs lose energy from momentum redshifting and photo - pair and photo - pion production on the cmbr during propagation through a flat @xmath14cdm universe ( we take @xmath15 and @xmath16 in our calculations ) .
attenuation produces features in the uhecr flux at characteristic energies @xmath17 ev and @xmath18 ev due to photo - pair and photo - pion energy - loss processes , respectively , from distant sources at @xmath19 .
the grb rate - density evolution is assumed to follow the sfr history derived from the blue and uv luminosity density of distant galaxies . to accommodate uncertainty in the sfr evolution ,
we take two models , one based on optical / uv measurements without extinction corrections ( lower sfr ) , and the other with extinction corrections ( upper sfr ) .
the upper sfr is roughly a factor of 3(10 ) greater than the lower sfr at red - shift @xmath20 for @xmath21 ev crs , both evolution models give the same flux , but the upper sfr contributes a factor @xmath22 more cr flux over the lower sfr at energies @xmath23 ev .
ev and using the upper limit to the sfr evolution .
we also show the agasa data ( triangles ) , but do not include these in our fits ( see @xcite for references to the data ) .
the cutoff energy for the galactic - halo component is @xmath24 ev and @xmath25 the fit implies that the transition from galactic to extragalactic crs occurs near the second knee and that the ankle is associated with photo - pair production . ]
the combined kascade , hires - i and hires - ii monocular data between @xmath26 ev to @xmath27 ev are fit in fig.1 which shows our best case , with cosmic - ray number injection index @xmath28 , @xmath29 ev , and the upper sfr .
a @xmath30 spectrum provides a worse fit than the @xmath31 case , although the cr energy demand is less in this case because crs are injected equally per unit decade in particle energy .
the transition between galactic and extragalactic crs is found in the vicinity of the second knee at @xmath32 ev , consistent with a heavy - to - light composition change @xcite .
the ankle , at @xmath33 ev , is interpreted as a suppression from photo - pair losses , analogous to the gzk suppression .
by normalizing the energy injection rate to that required to produce the cr flux from extragalactic sources observed locally , we determine the amount of energy a typical grb must release in the form of nonthermal hadrons .
our results imply that grb blast waves are baryon - loaded by a factor @xmath34 compared to the primary electron energy that is inferred from the fluxes of hard x - rays and soft @xmath1 rays measured from grbs . in fig .
2 we show the neutrino fluences expected in the collapsar grb scenario from a burst with photon fluence @xmath35 . the neutrino fluences are calculated for 3 values of the doppler factor @xmath36 from a grb at redshift @xmath37 ( we take a hubble constant of 65 km s@xmath38 mpc@xmath38 in the calcuations ) . in order to demonstrate the dependence of the neutrino fluxes on @xmath36 , we consider 3 values of @xmath36 and set @xmath39 in this calculation .
we assume that the prompt emission is contributed by @xmath40 spikes with characteristic timescales @xmath41 each , which defines the characteristic size ( in the proper frame ) of the emitting region associated with each individual spike through the relation @xmath42 .
the numbers of muon neutrinos that would be detected from a single grb with these parameters with icecube for @xmath43 and 300 are @xmath44 and 0.016 , respectively .
we should note , however , that for the assumed value of @xmath45 , the calculated total fluence of neutrinos ( both @xmath46 and @xmath47 ) produced when @xmath48 is @xmath49 erg @xmath50 , i.e. , by a factor @xmath51 _ larger _ than the assumed radiation fluence .
this means that the maximum value of the baryon loading that could be allowed if the high - energy radiation fluence is less than the x/@xmath1 fluence for this particular case should be about 8 10 , instead of 20 , in order that the hadronic cascade @xmath1-ray flux is guaranteed not to exceed the measured photon flux .
consequently , the expected number of neutrinos for @xmath52 should be reduced to @xmath53 . on the other hand ,
the neutrino fluence for the case @xmath54 is equal to @xmath55 , so this accommodates an increased baryon - loading from @xmath56 up to @xmath57 , with the expected number of neutrinos observed by icecube being @xmath58 .
if the radiation fluence at mev
gev energies is allowed to exceed the x/@xmath1 fluence by an order of magnitude , a possibility that glast will resolve , then the expected number of detected neutrinos could be increased correspondingly . with x - ray /
mev @xmath1-ray fluence of @xmath59 ergs @xmath50 and doppler factors @xmath48 , 200 and 300 , and a nonthermal baryon - loading factor @xmath60 . ] for the large baryon load required for the proposed model of hecrs , calculations show that 100 tev
100 pev neutrinos could be detected several times per year from all grbs with kilometer - scale neutrino detectors such as icecube @xcite .
detection of even 1 or 2 neutrinos from grbs with icecube or a northern hemisphere neutrino detector will provide compelling support for this scenario for the origin of high - energy and uhe cosmic rays .
based on joint analysis of batse large area detector and the egret total absorption shower counter data , gonzlez et al.@xcite reported the detection of an anomalous mev emission component in the spectrum of grb 941017 that decays more slowly than the prompt emission detected with the lad in the @xmath61 kev 1 mev range .
the multi - mev component lasts for @xmath62 seconds ( the @xmath63 duration of the lower - energy prompt component is 77 sec ) , and is detected with the batse lad near 1 mev and with the egret tasc between @xmath13 and 200 mev .
the spectrum is very hard , with a photon number flux @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the observed photon energy .
this component is not predicted or easily explained within the standard leptonic model for grb blast waves , though it possibly could be related to comptonization of reverse - shock emission by the forward shock electrons @xcite , including self - absorbed reverse - shock optical synchrotron radiation @xcite .
another possibility is that hadronic acceleration in grb blast waves could be responsible for this component .
we have argued @xcite that this component could be a consequence of the acceleration of hadrons at the relativistic shocks of grbs . a pair - photon cascade initiated by photohadronic processes between high - energy hadrons accelerated in the grb blast wave and the internal synchrotron radiation field produces an emission component that appears during the prompt phase , as shown in fig . 3 .
photomeson interactions in the relativistic blast wave also produce a beam of uhe neutrons , as proposed for blazar jets @xcite .
subsequent photopion production of these neutrons with photons outside the blast wave will produce a directed hyper - relativistic electron - positron beam in the process of charged pion decay and the conversion of high - energy photons formed in @xmath66 decay .
these energetic leptons produce a synchrotron spectrum in the radiation reaction - limited regime extending to @xmath67 gev energies , with properties in the 1 200 mev range similar to that measured from grb 941017 .
grbs displaying these anomalous @xmath1-ray components are most likely to be detected as sources of high - energy neutrinos @xcite .
if grbs are the sources of hecrs , then high - energy neutrons will be formed at the burst site through photo - pion processes and , being neutral , can escape to intergalactic space .
indeed , it is possible that charged ultra - high energy protons and ions are trapped by ambient magnetic field and lose energy adiabatically near the acceleration site , so that uhecrs are made primarily of neutron - decay protons . the decay of the neutrons far from the grb through the process @xmath68 leads to @xmath2-decay electrons that make synchrotron and compton radiation .
the best prospect for discovering neutron - decay halos is to search for diffuse optical synchrotron halos surrounding field galaxies that display active star formation @xcite .
grbs that have recently taken place in our galaxy will produce compton radiation at tev energies that could be detected by the _ hess _ and _ veritas _ imaging air cherenkov telescopes @xcite .
the emission of nonthermal synchrotron and compton radiation from photopion processes by uhecrs traveling through intergalactic space will also produce a nonthermal component of the diffuse radiation background , which can be used to determine the magnetic field of intergalactic space .
because the milky way is actively making young high - mass stars , grbs will also occur in our galaxy .
the rate of grbs in the milky way is very uncertain because of lack of precise knowledge about the opening angle of grb jets , but could be as frequent as once every 10,000 years . over the age of the galaxy , there is a good chance that a nearby powerful grb with a jet oriented towards earth could have lethal consequences for life . it has recently been argued @xcite that such an event contributed to the ordovician extinction event 440 myrs ago .
to assess cosmic ray transport from a grb , we @xcite developed a 3d propagation model to simulate the sequence of irradiation events that occurs when a grb jet is pointed towards earth .
the cosmic rays move in response to a large - scale magnetic field that traces the spiral arm structure of the galaxy , and they diffuse through pitch - angle scattering with magnetic turbulence . the magnetic field of the galaxy is modeled as a bi - symmetric spiral for the galaxy s disk , and a dipole magnetic field for the galaxy s halo @xcite .
the evolution of the particle momentum is found by solving the lorentz force equation .
a monte carlo simulation of pitch - angle scattering and diffusion was developed that takes into account the energy dependence of the cosmic - ray mean free path .
4 displays the cosmic - ray halo that surrounds a grb source 14,000 years after the grb event .
the geometry of the system is modeled by twin radial jets of cosmic rays with a jet - opening half - angle of 0.1 radian . a conical shell forms as a result of protons and neutron - decay protons with energies @xmath11 ev .
@xmath69 ev . ] the hypothesis @xcite that the @xmath11 ev cosmic - ray excesses detected with the agasa ( akeno giant air shower array ) and sugar arrays @xcite are cosmic - ray neutrons from a grb is not , however , supported by our simulations . the relativistic blast waves in a grb
accelerate the highest energy cosmic rays over timescales of weeks or less @xcite , and the high - energy neutrons therefore arrive on this same timescale .
cosmic ray protons with energies @xmath70 ev are delayed over a timescale @xmath71 years from a source at the distance of the galactic center . for the sugar excess , which is coincident on the sub - degree angular scale with a point source
, a grb would have to take place within weeks of the observation for cosmic - ray protons to maintain their direction to the source . including the requirement that the grb jet was also pointed towards earth means that an impulsive grb origin is excluded because such an event is so improbable .
the greater ( @xmath72 ) extent of the agasa excess does not conclusively exclude a grb origin , but here the diffuse excess could simply reflect the greater pathlength for cosmic - ray proton collisions with spiral arm gas along the cygnus arm . because the sugar point source does not admit an impulsive grb solution , only cosmic rays from a persistent source , such as a microquasar , could make such an excess .
the hypothesis @xcite that grbs are sources of @xmath0 ev cosmic rays is therefore incompatible with such a source .
our cosmic - ray origin hypothesis will soon be tested by results from the auger observatory to confirm or refute the existence of the sugar source .
if the source is real , then our grb / cosmic - ray model is incomplete .
we have summarized a complete model @xcite for hecrs from galactic and extragalactic grbs .
our interpretation of the hecr spectrum requires that grbs are hadronically dominated , which is necessary @xcite for neutrinos from grbs to be detectable with a km - scale neutrino telescope .
detection of high - energy neutrinos from grbs will provide strong support for this model .
searches for anomalous @xmath1-ray emission components with _ glast _ ,
as already observed form grb 941017 with batse and egret , will give additional support for cosmic - ray acceleration in grbs , provided that these components can be attributed to hadronic cascade radiation @xcite .
observations of neutron @xmath2-decay radiation from recent grbs in the galaxy @xcite and around galaxies that host grbs @xcite provide further tests of the hypothesis that high - energy cosmic rays are accelerated by grbs .
the ground - based auger experiment , which will measure air showers and nitrogen fluorescence from the uhecr interactions in the atmosphere , is now taking data .
this experiment will greatly expand our knowledge of high - energy cosmic rays , for example , by measuring with high quality statistics and checks on calibration the spectrum of @xmath12 ev cosmic rays which produce high - energy neutrinos at their source and as they propagate through intergalactic space .
detection of @xmath73 ev cosmic - ray point sources is incompatible with an origin from impulsive grbs , so that if the sugar source is confirmed , this cosmic - ray origin model is incomplete .
i am pleased to acknowledge my collaboration with armen atoyan , jeremy holmes , and stuart wick .
this work was supported by the office of naval research and a nasa _ gamma ray large area space telescope _ grant . | a complete model for the origin of high - energy ( @xmath0 ev ) cosmic rays from gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) and implications of this hypothesis are described .
detection of high - energy neutrinos from grbs provide an unambiguous test of the model .
evidence for cosmic - ray acceleration in grbs is suggested by the detection of anomalous @xmath1-ray components such as that observed from grb 941017 .
neutron @xmath2-decay halos around star - forming galaxies such as the milky way are formed as a consequence of this model .
cosmic rays from grbs in the galaxy are unlikely to account for the @xmath3 ev cosmic - ray excess reported by the sydney university giant air shower recorder ( sugar ) , but could contribute to past extinction events .
[ 1999/12/01 v1.4c il nuovo cimento ] |
electroexcitation of nucleon resonances has long been recognized as a sensitive tool in exploring the complex nucleon structure at varying distances scales .
mapping out the transition helicity amplitudes will tell us a great deal about the underlying quark or hadronic structure .
most of the recent data have been taken with the clas detector @xcite using the 6 gev polarized electron beam at jefferson lab .
this allows to measure simultaneously the entire resonance mass region and a wide range in the photon virtuality @xmath0 .
several final states are measured simultaneously @xcite . in this
talk i discuss recent results on the extraction of transition amplitudes for several well - known states from pion electroproduction .
an interesting aspect of nucleon structure at low energies is a possible quadrupole deformation of the lowest excited state , the @xmath2 .
such a deformation would be evident in finite values of the quadrupole transition amplitude @xmath3 and @xmath4 , which otherwise would be equal to zero @xcite .
quadrupole ratios @xmath5 and @xmath6 are shown in fig.[remrsm ] .
the development of sophisticated phenomenological analysis methods @xcite over the past decade resulted in a consistent picture for these quantities .
@xmath7 remains negative , small and nearly constant in the entire range @xmath8
there are no indications that leading pqcd contributions are important , which would require @xmath10 @xcite .
the longitudinal quadrupole ratio @xmath11 also remains negative , but its magnitude rises strongly with increasing @xmath0 .
simultaneous description of both @xmath7 and @xmath11 is achieved with dynamical models that include pion - nucleon interactions explicitly , supporting the idea that most of the quadrupole strength in the @xmath1 transition is due to meson effect @xcite . and @xmath11 from @xmath12 electroproduction . @xmath13 .
data from @xcite .
, width=264 ]
the standard constituent quark model which describes this state as a radial excitation of the nucleon , has difficulties to describe basic features such as the mass , photocouplings , and @xmath0 evolution .
this has prompted the development of alternative models involving gluon fields @xcite , or meson - baryon degrees of freedom @xcite .
( left panel ) .
the full circles are the new clas results .
the squares are previously published results of fits to clas data at low @xmath0 .
the right panel shows the longitudinal amplitude .
the bold curves are all relativistic light front quark model calculations @xcite .
the thin dashed line is for a gluonic excitation@xcite .
, width=453,height=226 ] given these different theoretical concept for the structure of the state , the question `` what is the nature of the roper state ? '' has been a focus of the @xmath14 program with clas .
the state is very wide , and pion electroproduction data covering a large range in the invariant mass w with full center - of - mass angular coverage are key in extracting the transition form factors . as an isospin @xmath15 state , the @xmath16 couples more strongly to n@xmath17 than to p@xmath18 .
also contributions of the high energy tail of the @xmath2 are much reduced in that channel due to the @xmath19 nature of the @xmath2 .
previous studies @xcite have mostly used the @xmath20 final state often resulting from measurements that focussed on the @xmath2 mass region .
this analysis included new high statistics @xmath21 data that covered the entire mass region up to @xmath22 gev .
a large sample of differential cross sections and polarization asymmetry data @xcite from clas have been analyzed using the fixed - t dispersion relations approach and the unitary isobar model .
the transverse and longitudinal electrocoupling amplitudes @xmath23 and @xmath24 of the transition to the @xmath25 resonance are extracted from fits @xcite to these data , and are shown in fig .
[ roper ] . at the real photon point
@xmath23 is negative , rises quickly with @xmath0 , and changes sign near @xmath26 gev@xmath9 . at @xmath27gev@xmath9
the amplitude has about the same magnitude but opposite sign as at @xmath28 .
it slowly falls off at high @xmath0 .
this remarkable behavior of a sign change with @xmath0 has not been observed before for any nucleon form factor or transition amplitude .
the longitudinal coupling @xmath24 is smaller than the transverse one . at high @xmath0
both amplitudes are qualitatively described by the light front quark models , which strongly suggests that at short distances the roper behaves indeed as expected from a radial excitation of the nucleon .
the low @xmath0 behavior is not well described by the lf quark models and all fall short of describing the amplitude at the photon point .
this suggests that important contributions , e.g. meson - baryon interactions describing the large distances behavior , are missing .
( left ) for the @xmath29 .
the full circles are from the analysis of the clas @xmath21 and @xmath12 data@xcite .
the other data are from the analysis of @xmath30 data @xcite .
the curves represent constituent quark model calculations of @xcite ( dashed ) , @xcite ( dashed - dotted ) , and @xcite ( solid).,width=453,height=188 ]
this state has been studied extensively in the @xmath30 channel , where it appears as an isolated resonance near the @xmath32 threshold .
phenomenological analyses of data from clas @xcite and hall c @xcite have resulted in the @xmath0 evolution of the transverse transition amplitude @xmath23 from @xmath33 electroproduction data . however , there are two remaining important uncertainties that need to be examined .
the first uncertainty is due to the branching ratio of the coupling @xmath34 .
the pdg @xcite gives ranges of @xmath35 and @xmath36 , which adds a large uncertainty to the resulting helicity amplitudes .
since this state has very small coupling to channels other than @xmath32 and @xmath37 , a measurement of the reaction @xmath38 can reduce this uncertainty .
adjusting @xmath39 and @xmath40 brings the two data sets into excellent agreement , as shown in fig .
the second uncertainty comes from the lack of precise information on the longitudinal coupling .
this contribution is usually neglected when analyzing the @xmath30 channel .
an important advantage of the @xmath37 channel is that it is also sensitive to the longitudinal transition amplitude @xmath24 resulting from a significant @xmath41 wave interference with the nearby @xmath42-wave amplitude of the @xmath16 .
since the @xmath16 does not couple to @xmath30 , this channel has very little sensitivity to the @xmath24 amplitude .
a longstanding prediction @xcite of the dynamical constituent quark model is the helicity switch from the dominance of the @xmath44 amplitude at the photon point to @xmath23 dominance at @xmath45 gev@xmath9 .
indications of such behavior have been observed in previous analysis @xcite , but analyses have been hampered by incomplete kinematical coverage of data , and the scarceness of @xmath21 data , which are most sensitive to the excitation of the state .
the new clas data have largely eliminated this shortcoming .
( left ) and @xmath44 ( middle ) and @xmath24 ( right ) for the @xmath43 .
model curves as in fig.2.,width=529,height=207 ] figure [ d13 ] shows the clas results for the electrocouplings .
the @xmath44 amplitude is large at the real photon point and decreasing rapidly in strength with increasing @xmath0 .
@xmath23 is small at the photon point and increases rapidly in magnitude with increasing @xmath0 . at high @xmath0 @xmath23
becomes the dominant amplitude , which confirms the early prediction of the constituent quark model .
the past decade of experimental research on the electroproduction of pseudoscalar mesons , has led to consistent set of data on transition amplitudes for several of the lower mass excited states of the nucleon .
this set of the most precise amplitudes to date allows us to put to test models of the nucleon structure in terms of the effective degrees of freedom .
b. mecking et al .
instrum . meth .
a503 , 513 - 553 , 2003 .
v. burkert and t .- s .
h. lee , int .
e13 , 1035 , 2004 .
a. buchmann and e. henley , phys .
d65 , 073017 , 2002 .
d. drechsel , o. hanstein , s. kamalov , l. tiator , nucl .
phys . a 645 , 145 , 1999 .
i. aznauryan , phys .
rev.c67,015209 , 2003 .
g. a. warren , c.e .
carlson , phys .
d42 , 3020 , 1990 . t. sato and t.s .
lee , phys.rev.c63 , 055201 , 2001 .
kamalov and s.n .
yang , phys .
83 , 4494 , 1999 . s. stave et al .
, arxiv:0803.2496 [ hep - ex ] , n.f .
sparveris et al . , phys .
b561 , 102 , 2007 .
sparveris et al . , phys .
94 , 022003 , 2005 .
d. drechsel , et al .
, eur . phys .
j.a34 , 69 , 2007 .
frolov et al . ,
phys.rev.lett.82:45-48 , 1999 .
li , v. burkert , zh .
li ; phys .rev .
d46 , 70 , 1992 .
f. cano and p. gonzales , phys .
b431 , 270 , 1998 .
o. krehl , et al . , phys.rev.c62,025207 , 2000 .
k. joo , et al , phys .
88 , 122001 , 2002 .
k. joo et al . , phys .
c68 , 032201 , 2003 . m. ungaro et al .
lett.97 , 112003 , 2006 .
kelly et al .
lett.95 , 102001 , 2005 . h. egiyan at al .
, phys.rev.c73,025204 , 2006 . k. joo et al . , phys .
c70 , 042201 , 2004 . k. joo et al .
c72 , 058202 , 2005 .
a. biselli et al .
c78 , 045204 , 2008 .
k. park et al . ,
phys.rev.c77,015208 , 2008 . i. aznauryan et al .
c71 , 015201 ; phys .
c72 , 045201 , 2005 . i. aznauryan et al .
( clas ) , phys .
c78 , 045209 , 2008 . for an overview ,
see : i. aznauryan , phys .
c76 , 025212 , 2007 .
r. thompson et al . , phys .
86 , 1702 , 2001 , h. denizli , phys .
c76 , 015204 , 2007 .
armstrong et al . , phys .
d60 , 052004 , 1999 .
dalton et al . , arxiv:0804.3509 [ hep - ex ] f.e .
close and f.j .
gilman , phys .
b 38 , 541 , 1972 s. capstick and b.d .
keister , phys .
d51 , 3598 , 1995 .
e. pace , g. salm , and s. simula , few body syst .
10 , 407 , 1999 .
braun , et al . , arxiv:0902.3087 ( hep - ph ) m. warns , et al .
, z. phys .
c45 , 627 , 1990 .
review of particle physics , c. amsler et al .
b 667 , 2008 . | recent measurements with clas at jefferson lab of nucleon resonance transition form factors for several lower mass states are discussed .
address = jefferson lab , 12000 jefferson avenue , newport news , virginia |
high power in a narrow frequency band ( spectral lines ) are common features of an interferometric gravitational wave ( gw ) detector s output .
although continuous gravitational waves could show up as lines in the frequency domain , given the current sensitivity of gw detectors it is most likely that large spectral features are noise of terrestrial origin or statistical fluctuations .
monochromatic signals of extraterrestrial origin are subject to a doppler modulation due to the detector s relative motion with respect to the extraterrestrial gw source , while those of terrestrial origin are not .
matched filtering techniques to search for a monochromatic signal from a given direction in the sky demodulate the data based on the expected frequency modulation from a source in that particular direction .
in general this demodulation procedure decreases the significance of a noise line and enhances that of a real signal .
however , if the noise artifact is large enough , even after the demodulation it might still present itself as a statistically significant outlier , thus a candidate event .
our idea to discriminate between an extraterrestrial signal and a noise line is based on the different effect that the demodulation procedure has on a real signal and on a spurious one .
if the data actually contains a signal , the detection statistic presents a very particular pattern around the signal frequency which , in general , a random noise artifact does not .
we propose here a chi - square test based on the shape of the detection statistic as a function of the signal frequency and demonstrate its safety and its efficiency .
we use the @xmath0 detection statistic described in @xcite and adopt the same notation as @xcite . for applications of the @xmath0 statistic search on real data , see for example @xcite .
we consider in this paper a continuous gw signal such as we would expect from an isolated non - axisymmetric rotating neutron star . following the notation of @xcite ,
the parameters that describe such signal are its emission frequency @xmath3 , the position in the sky of the source @xmath4 , the amplitude of the signal @xmath5 , the inclination angle @xmath6 , the polarization angle @xmath7 and the initial phase of the signal @xmath8 . in the absence of a signal @xmath9
follows a @xmath10 distribution with four degrees of freedom ( which will be denoted by @xmath11 ) . in the presence of a signal @xmath12 follows a non - central @xmath11 distribution . given a set of template parameters @xmath13 ,
the detection statistic @xmath0 is the likelihood function maximized with respect to the parameters @xmath14 .
@xmath0 is constructed by combining appropriately the complex amplitudes @xmath15 and @xmath16 representing the complex matched filters for the two gw polarizations . and given the template parameters and the values of @xmath15 and @xmath16 it is possible to derive the maximum likelihood values of @xmath17 let us refer to these as @xmath18 .
it is thus possible for every value of the detection statistic to estimate the parameters of the signal that have most likely generated it .
so , if we detect a large outlier in @xmath0 we can estimate the associated signal parameters : @xmath19 .
let us indicate with @xmath20 the corresponding signal estimate .
let @xmath21 be the original data set , and define a second data set @xmath22 if the outlier were actually due to a signal @xmath23 and if @xmath20 were a good approximation to @xmath23 , then @xmath24 constructed from @xmath25 would be @xmath11 distributed .
since filters for different values of @xmath26 are not orthogonal , in the presence of a signal the detection statistic @xmath0 presents some structure also for values of search frequency that are not the actual signal frequency . for these other frequencies
@xmath24 is also @xmath11 distributed if @xmath20 is a good approximation to @xmath23 .
we thus construct the veto statistic @xmath27 by summing the values of @xmath28 over more frequencies .
in particular we sum over all the neighbouring frequency bins that , within a certain frequency interval , are above a fixed significance threshold .
we regard each such collection of frequencies as a single `` candidate event '' and assign to it the frequency of the bin that has the highest value of the detection statistic .
the veto statistic is then : @xmath29 in reality , since our templates lie on a discrete grid , the parameters of a putative signal will not exactly match any templates parameters and the signal estimate @xmath20 will not be exactly correct . as a consequence @xmath25 will still contain a residual signal and @xmath30 will not exactly be @xmath11 distributed
. the larger the signal , the larger the residual signal and the larger the expected value of @xmath27 .
therefore , our veto threshold @xmath31 will not be fixed but will depend on the value of @xmath0 .
we will find such @xmath0-dependent threshold for @xmath27 based on monte carlo simulations .
the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) for any given value of the detection statistic can be expressed in terms of the detection statistic as @xmath32 , as per eq .
( 79 ) of @xcite
. therefore we will talk equivalently of an snr - dependent or @xmath0-dependent veto threshold .
let us first examine the ideal case where the detector output consists of stationary random gaussian noise plus a systematic time series ( a noise line or a pulsar signal ) that produces a candidate in the detection statistic @xmath33 for some template sky position @xmath34 and at frequency @xmath26 .
the question that we want to answer is : is the shape of @xmath33 around the frequency of the candidate consistent with what we would expect from a signal ?
our basic observables are the four real inner products @xmath35 between the observed time series @xmath21 and the four filters @xmath36 : @xmath37 where @xmath38 runs from @xmath39 to @xmath40 .
the inner product is defined by eq.(42 ) of @xcite .
the four filters @xmath36 depend on the target frequency @xmath26 and the target sky location @xmath41 .
the hypothesis @xmath42 that we would like to examine is @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the detector noise and @xmath45 is the template , which in this case perfectly matches the signal . the parameters @xmath18 are the maximum likelihood estimators of @xmath46 derived from the data and the template parameters @xmath34 and @xmath26 .
the definitions of the four coefficients @xmath47 are given in @xcite .
given that the template parameters @xmath48 exactly match the parameters of the actual signal , then the waveform @xmath49 exactly matches the actual signal @xmath23 . in this case the four variables @xmath50 : @xmath51 are four correlated random gaussian variables .
the paper @xcite constructs the detection statistic @xmath0 from the data @xmath52 .
similarly , we construct @xmath53 from the data @xmath54 .
@xmath55 is also centrally @xmath11 distributed in the presence of a signal and perfect signal - template match .
we obtain the veto statistic by summing @xmath56 over the different frequencies of the event @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the number of the frequency bins in the event .
if the value of @xmath27 is not consistent with a @xmath59 distribution , we reject the hypothesis @xmath42 .
note that the degrees of freedom of the veto statistic is @xmath60 , as we use four data points to infer the four parameters @xmath61 .
in the real analysis the signal parameters @xmath62 will not exactly match the values of one of our templates @xmath34 . as a consequence
, @xmath18 will not match exactly the actual @xmath61 parameters and the frequency where the maximum of the detection statistic occurs , @xmath63 , will _ not _ be the actual frequency of the signal @xmath3 .
however we can still set up a procedure to answer the question : is the shape of the @xmath0 statistic event consistent with what we would expect from a signal with parameters _ close to _ @xmath34 ?
suppose that an event has been identified for a position template @xmath34 and for a value of the signal frequency @xmath63 .
this is how the veto analysis would proceed : 1 .
we determine @xmath18 and @xmath64 for each @xmath65 of the event .
we generate a veto signal @xmath66 and compute the four variables @xmath67 3 .
we construct the variables : + @xmath68 4 .
( [ eq : nu ] ) we compute @xmath69 and then @xmath27 .
if @xmath70 is a good approximation to @xmath71 , then @xmath27 follows the @xmath59 distribution .
as already outlined at the end of section [ s : summary ] , the veto statistic does not in general follow a @xmath59 distribution because in general the signal parameters do not exactly match the template parameters . due to this mismatch when step 3 is performed in the procedure described in the previous section ,
not all the signal is removed from @xmath72 .
consequently @xmath73 acquires a non - zero centrality parameter .
since this scales as @xmath74 in the presence of a signal , the veto statistic threshold has to change with the snr of the candidate event in order to keep the false dismissal rate constant for a range of different signal strengths .
we will thus adopt a snr - dependent veto threshold on our veto statistic @xmath27 .
we will determine the threshold @xmath75 via monte - carlo simulations .
an snr - dependent threshold in a similar context was first used by the tama group @xcite who performed snr-@xmath76 studies to veto out candidate events in their inspiral waves searches . see also @xcite for a detailed description of a @xmath10 time - frequency test . in a context of a resonant bar detector
burst search , see @xcite .
to determine the false dismissal rate , the false alarm rate and the threshold equation for the veto statistic , we have performed a set of monte carlo simulations on artificial and real noise .
we have used 10 hours of fake gaussian stationary noise and of real science data from the ligo hanford 4 km interferometer .
the results presented here are thus valid for a 10 hour observation time , which is the observation time of the all - sky , wide - band search that we plan to conduct on data from the second science run of the ligo detectors .
we do not take into account spin down of pulsars .
this may be justified for the short time length of the data . as it will be explained below
we have injected both signals and spurious noise artifacts of the type that we observe in the detector output .
the parameters of the gravitational waves signals which are injected into the noise are uniformly chosen at random in the following ranges : @xmath77 $ ] hz , @xmath78,\sin\delta_s\in [ -1,1]$ ] , @xmath79 $ ] , @xmath80 $ ] , @xmath81 $ ] . the strain @xmath82 or
the amplitude of the model noise line is also randomly chosen in such a way that the resulting detection statistics value lie in the range : @xmath83 .
below @xmath84 the efficiency of the test quickly degrades .
we will thus not apply this veto technique to candidate events with @xmath85 . in this sense ,
our method is designed to only discard large outliers .
we have performed @xmath86 monte carlo simulations .
the following steps were executed iteratively 200 times : * we randomly choose a signal frequency @xmath3 of a simulated gravitational wave and then follow the steps below 100 times : * * we randomly choose a signal sky position @xmath87 and perform the steps below 100 times : 1 .
we randomly choose a set of @xmath61 signal parameters and generate the 10 hour long data set described above consisting of random gaussian noise and the fake signal .
we randomly displace the sky position template from the signal values by adding a random number uniformly distributed between @xmath88 half the sky positions grid spacing : @xmath89 and @xmath90 ( both in radians ) .
the grid spacing was estimated numerically and ensures that the loss in @xmath0 due to the signal - template mismatch is less than 5 @xmath91 for @xmath92 of the simulations , for a 10 hour observation .
3 . we search for the signal with template values @xmath34 in a small frequency range around @xmath3 .
this results in the identification of an event , defined by a value of @xmath0 ( the highest value of all the @xmath0 values in the event , denoted by @xmath93 ) occurring at a frequency @xmath63 . based on this
we determine the maximum likelihood estimators @xmath18 . also , we compute @xmath94 for all the frequencies of the event .
we generate a veto signal @xmath95 .
we compute @xmath96 for all the frequencies of the event .
we construct @xmath27 from @xmath97 . by considering only values of @xmath98
we obtain 1426915 sets of @xmath0 and @xmath27 values .
[ fig : safetygauss ] is the scatter plot of these .
it is convenient to normalize each @xmath27 by the corresponding number of degrees of freedom , @xmath99 , since @xmath99 could differ from one injection to another since the number of frequency bins in a candidate varies from event to event .
if @xmath27 follows the @xmath100 distribution , then the mean of @xmath27 is just @xmath99 . fig .
[ fig : safetygausspdf ] shows the estimated probability distributions of @xmath101 for four selected ranges of @xmath0 .
these four graphs show that the probability distributions are well - defined and the monte carlo simulations give a good estimate of the probability distribution of @xmath102 .
since a variable mismatch exists between the signals and the templates , the distribution of @xmath27 is actually not strictly a central @xmath100 and the expected value of @xmath102 is thus not strictly 1 . and
, as expected , the peak of the distributions of fig .
[ fig : safetygausspdf ] deviates from 1 more as the signal becomes larger . from fig .
[ fig : safetygauss ] one can now define the threshold on the veto statistic , based on the false dismissal rate that one is willing to accept .
the solid line in the figure , with equation @xmath103 is the line with the lowest false alarm rate for which , with our sample size , we have not falsely dismissed any of the injected signals . in the rest of this paper
, we will adopt this line , eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) , as the nominal threshold line . , and snr @xmath104 .
the straight line represents eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) .
the detector is assumed to be lho detector .
the number of the data points with @xmath105 is 1426915 .
, height=302 ] with snr in the four selected ranges .
this figure is for the 10 hours simulated data .
the detector is assumed to be lho detector .
, height=302 ] we have performed @xmath86 monte carlo simulations by injecting a simulated pulsar signal into real data .
all the steps are similar to those described in [ s : injections_noise ] .
we have avoided injections in bands contaminated by spectral disturbances . from this set of simulations ,
we obtain a similar scatter plot as fig [ fig : safetygauss ] .
and indeed , the threshold line eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) still does not dismiss any injected signals . to study how efficient the test is in vetoing noise artifacts that resemble the signals that we are trying to detect ,
we have performed an additional set of simulations . for each simulation
, we have injected sets of time - domain exponentially - damped sinusoids ( as a model of a line noise ) into both fake gaussian noise and in real data . in the frequency domain these damped sinusoids
have a cauchy distribution , components of which are often observed in the real data .
we hence follow similar steps as for the safety tests described above and produce the corresponding scatter plots of snr versus @xmath102 .
the efficiency test here is ill - defined in the sense that it is possible to generate infinite numbers of line noises that have completely different shapes from pulsar signals .
nonetheless , we think these tests provide `` a feel '' for the efficiency of our veto method .
the following steps are iteratively performed 200 times : * we randomly choose the frequency of a noise line and follow the steps below 100 times : * * we randomly choose a target sky position , with uniform distribution in @xmath106,\sin\delta\in [ -1,1]$ ] and then perform the steps below 50 times : 1 .
we randomly choose the noise line parameters .
the e - fold decay rate varies between @xmath107 and @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the total observation time
we generate a 10 hour long data set consisting of random gaussian noise with standard deviation 1 and the noise line defined by the parameters above .
we perform a search in a frequency band around the frequency of the noise line and identify an event , i.e. a value of @xmath0 and @xmath63 . from the values of the complex component of the detection statistic at @xmath63 we determine @xmath18 and @xmath94 for every frequency of the event .
we generate a veto signal @xmath110 5 .
we compute @xmath96 for the veto signal for all the frequencies of the event .
we obtain @xmath102 .
[ fig : efficiencygauss ] shows the snr-@xmath102 plot .
it may seem that the data points are densely distributed in the left upper region with large snrs and small @xmath102 .
this deceptive appearance is due to the coarse graphical resolution of the figure .
this can be clearly seen in the estimated probability distributions , shown in fig .
[ fig : efficiencygausspdf ] .
in fact , if we take our nominal threshold line , eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) , shown as the solid line in fig .
[ fig : efficiencygauss ] , the false alarm rate is estimated to be 8.4 @xmath91 . , and snr @xmath104 .
the straight line represents eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) .
the detector is assumed to be lho detector .
the number of the data points with @xmath105 is 954063 .
, height=302 ] with snr in the four selected ranges corresponding to fig .
[ fig : efficiencygauss ] .
, height=302 ] we have performed @xmath111 monte - carlo simulations injecting noise lines as described above into real data , avoiding frequency bands with large noise artifacts .
the resulting scatter plot is similar to that obtained for the gaussian random noise case .
indeed , we obtain @xmath112 false alarm rate for the nominal threshold eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) .
having observed safety and efficiency of our veto method , we now show an application of the method to real data ( no signal nor noise lines injected ) .
we take the following steps iteratively 1200 times : * we randomly choose a template sky direction @xmath34 over the whole sky 1 .
we perform a wide - band search over the interval [ 100,500 ] hz in the 10 hour real data set .
we identify events in the detection statistic and to each of these events we apply our veto test .
this procedure yields a value of @xmath0 and @xmath102 for each candidate event .
the scatter plot snr-@xmath102 is shown in fig .
[ fig : realveto ] .
two distinct branches along the solid line at higher snrs are evident .
both branches are due to spectral features in the data : the highest snr branch to a line at 465.7 hz , the lower branch to a line at 128.0 hz .
these spectral features `` trigger - off '' a whole set of templates giving rise to the observed structure in the scatter plot . , and snr @xmath104 .
the straight line represents eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) .
the number of the data points is 68388 .
the maximum @xmath113 is 66.6 .
, height=302 ] if we adopt the threshold line eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) , 70 @xmath91 of the events are rejected .
we have defined a veto statistic to reject or accept candidate cw events based on a consistency shape test of the measured detection statistic .
we have shown how to derive the snr - dependent threshold for the veto test , through monte carlo simulations on a playground data set similar to the one that one intends to analyze .
the veto method demonstrated in this paper does not require any a - priori information on the source of noise lines .
however , we expect that the effectiveness of this veto technique can greatly benefit from data characterization studies aimed at identifying spectral contamination of instrumental origin .
we are now further investigating methods to veto out family of outliers identified in the scatter plots above the solid line in fig .
[ fig : realveto ] . natural candidates are those noise lines whose properties are known experimentally , for example the 16 hz harmonics in the lho data due to the data acquisition system .
it is precisely these harmonics that give rise to one of the major branches above the solid line in fig .
[ fig : realveto ] , as shown in fig .
[ fig : realvetomike ] . in this paper
, we have used a 10 hour long data set . for a longer observational time , the difference between an extraterrestrial line and a terrestrial one becomes larger because the doppler modulation patterns of a putative signal carry a more specific signature , that of the motion of the earth around the sun .
we have not included spin down of pulsars in our current study , as we have used short enough time length data .
spin down effects of pulsars become more important for a longer observation time , and spin down effects generate characteristic feature in the @xmath0 statistic shape .
we thus expect that our veto method will become more efficient and safer for longer observation times .
finally , we note that a veto threshold line varies depending on observational data time length and noise behavior
. the threshold line eq .
( [ eq : thresholdline ] ) is specifically for 10 hours lho data , of particular band , and we recommend that any other search that uses quite different data set from our play ground data should determine a threshold line based on a play ground data in each analysis . , but after removing the 16 hz harmonics .
the number of the data points is 60375 .
the maximum @xmath113 is 66.6 . ,
height=302 ] we would like to thank m. landry , who has provided us with the tables of the experimentally - measured noise lines of the data sets that we have analyzed .
the work of xs was supported by national science foundation grants phy 0071028 and phy 0079683 .
999 jaranowski p , krlak a and schutz b. f 1998 phys .
rev . d*58 * 063001 astone p _
et al . _ 2003 class . quantum grav . * 20 * , s665 abbott b _ et al .
( ligo scientific collaboration ) _
2004 phys .
d * 69 * , 082004 allen b _ et al .
_ 2004 class .
quantum grav .
* 21 * , s671 tagoshi h _
( tama collaboration ) _
2001 phys .
d * 63 * 062001 allen b 2004 _ preprint _
gr - qc/0405045 baggio l _
2000 phys .
d * 61 * 102001 | in a blind search for continuous gravitational wave signals scanning a wide frequency band one looks for _ candidate events _ with significantly large values of the detection statistic .
unfortunately , a noise line in the data may also produce a moderately large detection statistic . in this paper , we describe how we can distinguish between noise line events and actual continuous wave ( cw ) signals , based on the shape of the detection statistic as a function of the signal s frequency .
we will analyze the case of a particular detection statistic , the @xmath0 statistic , proposed by jaranowski , krlak , and schutz .
we will show that for a broad - band 10 hour search , with a false dismissal rate smaller than @xmath1 , our method rejects about @xmath2 of the large candidate events found in a typical data set from the second science run of the hanford ligo interferometer . |
recently , tiocl was proposed to be a quasi - one - dimensional ( 1d ) @xmath2 quantum spin system , that develops a spin - peierls state at low temperatures.@xcite the spin - peierls state is now well established by the temperature dependence of the magnetic susceptibility ( @xmath3 ) , that is zero below the phase transition at @xmath4 k , the observation by nmr of two independent ti atoms below @xmath5 , the two - fold crystallographic superstructure below @xmath5 and electronic band - structure calculations.@xcite the atomic displacements in the superstructure as well as the calculated band structure , with the single valence electron of ti@xmath6 occupying the @xmath7 orbital , indicate that the spin - peierls state is formed on the chains of ti atoms parallel to @xmath8 via direct exchange interactions .
@xcite although the properties of the low - temperature phase of tiocl are those of a true spin - peierls system , tiocl is not a conventional spin - peierls compound , because the phase transition at @xmath5 is first - order .
the temperature dependencies of @xmath3 , electron spin resonance ( esr ) , nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) , specific heat ( @xmath9 ) and x - ray diffraction have shown that a second - order phase transition occurs at @xmath10 k. @xcite the 1d character of the magnetic interactions was also supported by the temperature dependencies of optical reflectivity and angle - resolved photoelectron spectroscopy ( arpes ) , @xcite although it was suggested that on cooling from room temperature , a crossover from two - dimensional ( 2d ) towards 1d interactions occurs.@xcite the nature of the state above @xmath5 is not understood yet .
orbital , spin and structural fluctuations have been proposed to be responsible for the properties of tiocl .
@xcite however , rckamp _ _ et al.__@xcite suggested that orbital fluctuations can be ruled out .
tiobr and tiocl crystallize in the feocl structure type.@xcite physical properties of both compounds are similar , with the two transition temperatures scaled down towards @xmath11 k and @xmath12 k in tiobr . @xcite
the two - fold superstructures below @xmath5 are similar in tiocl and tiobr , suggesting a spin - peierls state for tiobr too.@xcite in the present contribution we report the discovery of incommensurate satellite reflections in x - ray diffraction of tiobr at temperatures @xmath13 with @xmath14 .
complete crystal structures are presented , but the data do not allow to distinguish between a one - dimensional and a two - dimensional incommensurate modulation wave .
these two models provide two possible interpretations for the understanding of the interatomic interactions in tiobr and tiocl .
single crystals of tiobr were prepared by gas transport reaction.@xcite a single crystal of dimensions @xmath15 mm@xmath16 was glued on a carbon fiber that was attached to a closed - cycle helium cryostat mounted on a four - circle huber diffractometer .
single - crystal x - ray diffraction with synchrotron radiation was measured at beam - line d3 of hasylab ( desy , hamburg ) , employing monochromatized radiation of wavelength @xmath17 and a point detector .
diffraction at room - temperature confirmed the feocl structure type.@xcite the temperature dependence of the component @xmath18 of the modulation wavevector @xmath19 was determined from @xmath20-scans along @xmath21 centered on the positions @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
up to @xmath11 k a single peak was found at @xmath24 , while for @xmath25 k two peaks appeared in each scan , at positions @xmath26 ( fig . [ f - qscans]a ) . above @xmath27
any diffraction at these positions had disappeared .
these results show that below @xmath5 tiobr has a two - fold superstructure , while in the intermediate phase tiobr is incommensurately modulated .
the component @xmath18 of the modulation wavevector was found to continuously decrease on decreasing temperature , and it jumps to zero at @xmath5 ( fig . [ f - sats_int+pos]a ) .
this result corroborates the incommensurate character of the modulation in the intermediate phase , and it shows the first - order character of the transition at @xmath5 .
the transition temperature was determined from fig .
[ f - sats_int+pos]a as @xmath28 k. ( a ) q - scans along @xmath21 centered on @xmath22 at @xmath29 k ( open circles ) and @xmath30 k ( full circles ) .
( b ) q - scans along @xmath31 centered on @xmath32 at @xmath33 k. lines are a guide for the eye .
step - widths of the scans were @xmath34 .
intensities in ( a ) are higher than those in ( b ) .
, title="fig:",width=147 ] ( a ) q - scans along @xmath21 centered on @xmath22 at @xmath29 k ( open circles ) and @xmath30 k ( full circles ) .
( b ) q - scans along @xmath31 centered on @xmath32 at @xmath33 k. lines are a guide for the eye .
step - widths of the scans were @xmath34 .
intensities in ( a ) are higher than those in ( b ) . , title="fig:",width=147 ] ( a ) temperature dependence of @xmath18 in @xmath19 .
@xmath18 was obtained as half the distance between the two maxima in @xmath20-scans , like those given in fig .
[ f - qscans]a .
( b ) temperature dependencies of the intensities of the satellite reflections @xmath22 ( squares ) and @xmath35 ( circles ) .
the line represents a fit with the function @xmath36 with @xmath37 k. similar plots lead to @xmath38 k for @xmath39 , @xmath40 k for @xmath41 and @xmath42 k for @xmath43 . , title="fig:",width=147 ] ( a ) temperature dependence of @xmath18 in @xmath19 .
@xmath18 was obtained as half the distance between the two maxima in @xmath20-scans , like those given in fig .
[ f - qscans]a .
( b ) temperature dependencies of the intensities of the satellite reflections @xmath22 ( squares ) and @xmath35 ( circles ) .
the line represents a fit with the function @xmath36 with @xmath37 k. similar plots lead to @xmath38 k for @xmath39 , @xmath40 k for @xmath41 and @xmath42 k for @xmath43 .
, title="fig:",width=147 ] the integrated intensities of reflections were measured by @xmath44-scans centered at the expected reflection positions . in this way
, the temperature dependencies were measured of the intensities of two commensurate satellites ( below 27 k ) and of four incommensurate satellites ( fig .
[ f - sats_int+pos]b ) . due to an experimental error
, reliable intensities were not obtained for temperatures @xmath45 k @xmath46 k. the intensities @xmath47 above @xmath5 could be fitted by a function @xmath36 , that provided consistent estimates for the transition temperature from all four reflections , with an average value of @xmath48 k. the gradual loss of intensity of the incommensurate satellites on approaching @xmath27 is an indication for the second - order character of the phase transition at this temperature
. incited by the observation , that some reflections were broader than others in the @xmath44-scans of the data collection ( see below ) , the possibility of a second incommensurate component of the modulation was investigated , then resulting in a modulation wavevector @xmath49 .
evidence for a splitting along @xmath31 was obtained from @xmath20-scans along @xmath31 with narrow slits ( fig .
[ f - qscans]b ) .
these results show that each incommensurate satellite @xmath50 actually is the superposition of two satellites @xmath51 with @xmath52 at @xmath33 k. in @xmath44-scans they are not resolved , because of the relatively large width of the reflections due to the less than optimal crystal quality .
the two - fold superstructure below @xmath5 of tiobr was determined from the integrated intensities of the bragg reflections measured at @xmath53 k.@xcite the result was in complete accordance with the two - fold superstructure of tiocl,@xcite and it thus shows that the low temperature phase of tiobr is a spin - peierls state like that in tiocl.@xcite at @xmath33 k the integrated intensities of the bragg reflections up to @xmath54 @xmath55 were measured by @xmath44-scans . as noticed above , each measured satellite intensity corresponds to the superposition of two reflections at @xmath56 , or at @xmath57 , while the two groups are separated from each other .
structure refinements were performed within the superspace approach for incommensurate structures , @xcite employing the computer program jana2000.@xcite the diffraction data have orthorhombic @xmath58 symmetry .
refinements of the average structure against the intensities of the main reflections showed that the room - temperature structure in @xmath59 is also valid as the average structure at 35 k. cooling had negatively affected crystal quality , resulting in full widths at half maximum ( fwhms ) of the reflections up to 0.06 degrees at 50 k. a systematic variation of reflection widths could not be observed between 50 k and 35 k. however , the splitting of reflections due to a possible lowering of symmetry is expected to be small , probably less than the observed fwhm above the transition . as a consequence , information on a possible lowering of the symmetry towards monoclinic could not be derived from the reflection profiles . without direct information on the symmetry ,
two possibilities exist for the superspace group .
if the orthorhombic symmetry is preserved , the modulation is two - dimensional with modulation wavevectors @xmath60 at @xmath61 k. the @xmath62-dimensional superspace group is @xmath63 .
the incommensurate modulation is described by one harmonic for each of the two waves ( eq . [ e - ortho_qvectors ] ) . because all atoms are in the mirror plane @xmath64 , the two harmonics are equivalent by symmetry and three of the six independent components are zero .
this leads to modulation functions for each of the three atoms ti , o and br given by three parameters only , @xmath65
\nonumber\\ u_y(\bar{x}_{s4},\bar{x}_{s5 } ) & = & u_y^1 [ \sin(2\,\pi \bar{x}_{s4 } ) + \sin(2\,\pi \bar{x}_{s5 } ) ] \\
u_z(\bar{x}_{s4},\bar{x}_{s5 } ) & = & u_z^1 [ \cos(2\,\pi \bar{x}_{s4 } ) + \cos(2\,\pi \bar{x}_{s5 } ) ] \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
@xmath68 is the average position of the atom in the unit cell , and @xmath69 enumerates the unit cells .
a reduction of the symmetry to monoclinic with unique axis @xmath70 gives the same model for the modulation functions as was obtained in orthorhombic symmetry .
therefore this possibility was not considered any further .
alternatively , monoclinic symmetry with unique axis @xmath71 corresponds to a one - dimensional modulation with wavevector @xmath72 , and with the @xmath73-dimensional superspace group @xmath74 .
the modulation now is a single wave , that can be obtained from eq .
[ e - mod_function ] by removing all terms containing @xmath75 .
the diffraction symmetry @xmath58 implies that the crystal is twinned , if the symmetry is monoclinic , with the first domain modulated by @xmath76 and the second domain modulated by @xmath77 .
structure refinements , employing the nine independent modulation parameters , gave excellent fits to the diffraction data with equal @xmath78-factors for both monoclinic symmetry ( assuming twinning ) and orthorhombic symmetry .
with @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
] furthermore , both models give rise to equal values for the structure factors , so that they can not be distinguished on the basis of the diffraction data .
both structure models have equal values for the parameters , except for a scale factor of @xmath81 between the modulation amplitudes , that is explained by the different assumptions on twinning ( table [ t - tiobr_modulation_displacements ] ) .
the two models share several features , that allow for conclusions on the state of the intermediate phase .
the major amplitude is the displacement of ti along @xmath8 .
this is similar to the displacements in the low - temperature phase , and it suggests that antiferromagnetic interactions between ti atoms along @xmath8 are important in the incommensurate phase .
displacements along @xmath70 are small , in accordance with the lt phase , where symmetry requires them to be zero .
thus , the intermediate phase appears to be an incommensurate version of the low - temperature two - fold superstructure .
the incommensurability determines that the modulation amplitudes as well as ti
ti distances assume all values between a maximum and minimum .
alternatively , it can not be excluded that the modulation is a block - wave , that would correspond to domains with a two - fold superstructure separated by domain walls where the spin pairs would be broken .
both the continuous modulation as well as the domain model are in accordance with incomplete spin - pairing and with the observed finite value of @xmath3 in the intermediate phase .
l c c c c atom & @xmath82 & @xmath83 ( ) & @xmath84 ( ) & @xmath85 ( ) + + ti & 0.11096 ( 6 ) & -0.0043 ( 7 ) & 0.0262 ( 6 ) & -0.0116 ( 6 ) + o & -0.05127 ( 23 ) & 0.0031 ( 33 ) & 0.0150 ( 20 ) & 0.0160 ( 18 ) + br & 0.32947 ( 3 ) & -0.0033 ( 6 ) & -0.0062 ( 4 ) & -0.0148 ( 3 ) + + + ti & 0.11096 ( 6 ) & -0.0057 ( 11 ) & 0.0369 ( 9 ) & -0.0165 ( 8) + o & -0.05126 ( 23 ) & 0.0050 ( 46 ) & 0.0213 ( 29 ) & 0.0225 ( 26 ) + br & 0.32947 ( 3 ) & -0.0049 ( 8) & -0.0088 ( 5 ) & -0.0210 ( 4 ) + rckamp _ _ et al.__@xcite have proposed that the incommensurate phase is the result of frustration between intra- and interchain interactions , for which a finite amplitude of the modulation along @xmath70 is required .
the monoclinic model with a @xmath86 modulation is in accordance with this interpretation .
this model features displacements along @xmath70 that are small but vary in phase with the major displacement along @xmath8 ( eq . [ e - mod_function ] and fig .
[ f - displacements_supercell]a ) .
interference of the two waves in the orthorhombic model implies that the displacements along @xmath70 and @xmath8 are out of phase ( eq . [ e - mod_function ] and fig .
[ f - displacements_supercell]b ) , _
i.e _ a large displacement along @xmath8 corresponds to zero displacement along @xmath70 .
this is exactly as can be expected for a competition between intra- and interchain interactions , the former dominating in regions with large @xmath87 displacements and the latter being important in regions with small @xmath87 .
the model of frustrated spin - peierls interactions could also be supported by this interpretation of the crystal structure.@xcite alternatively , the @xmath88 nature of the modulation wave in orthorhombic symmetry suggests that the incommensurability might be the result of a competition between spin - peierls interactions on the chains and @xmath88 magnetic interactions between neighboring ti atoms along @xmath89 $ ] , resulting in a helical magnetic structure coupled to the lattice distortion .
@xcite the latter interpretation is in accordance with the observed increase of the two - dimensional character on increasing temperature,@xcite and with the proposed contributions of @xmath90 and @xmath91 symmetries to the orbital of lowest energy and the increased admixture of these orbitals at higher temperatures due to phonons .
@xcite the two symmetries lead to completely different properties of the phase transition at @xmath5 .
structurally , the orthorhombic model can be considered a precursor to the spin - peierls state , and the phase transition is a lock - in transition .
on the other hand , the monoclinic model requires that the unique axis switches from @xmath71 to @xmath70 at @xmath5 .
accordingly , the domain structure of the material must change , and a much more sluggish behavior of the transition , _
e.g. _ hysteresis , would be expected .
previously , we have failed to observe incommensurate satellites in the intermediate - temperature phase of tiocl .
this is easily explained by the experimental method , that involved scans along reciprocal lattice directions , and thus might have missed possible satellites , especially if the incommensurate components in tiocl will be larger than in tiobr .
we have found that tiobr exhibits a second - order phase transition at @xmath48 k towards an incommensurately modulated structure .
available experimental data indicate that this structure is either orthorhombic with a two - dimensional modulation or monoclinic with a one - dimensional modulation .
both structure models give rise to similar local structures .
arguments have been given that favor or disfavor mechanisms for the existence of the incommensurate phase , that involve either frustrations between dimerized chains @xcite or two - dimensional magnetic interactions @xcite in competition with one - dimensional spin - peierls interactions .
the equivalence of the low - temperature structures of tiobr and tiocl shows that tiobr is in a spin - peierls state below @xmath92
k. @xcite one double layer of ti atoms parallel to the @xmath93 plane .
( a ) for the 1d modulation in monoclinic symmetry .
( b ) for the 2d modulation in orthorhombic symmetry .
atoms are depicted at their basic positions , with shifts towards their true position indicated by arrows with a length of 20 times the true displacements .
dark and light circles represent ti atoms at @xmath94 and @xmath95 , respectively .
the modulation was computed in a @xmath96 supercell approximation .
, title="fig:",width=151 ] single crystals were grown by a. suttner .
we thank w. morgenroth for assistance with the synchrotron experiment at beam - line d3 of hasylab at desy ( hamburg , germany ) .
financial support by the german science foundation ( dfg ) is gratefully acknowledged . | temperature - dependent x - ray diffraction of the low - dimensional spin 1/2 quantum magnet tiobr shows that the phase transition at @xmath0 k corresponds to the development of an incommensurate superstructure . below @xmath1
k the incommensurate modulation locks in into a two - fold superstructure similar to the low - temperature spin - peierls state of tiocl .
frustration between intra- and interchain interations within the spin - peierls scenario , and competition between two - dimensional magnetic order and one - dimensional spin - peierls order are discussed as possible sources of the incommensurability . |
silicon is mostly locked in sis , sio and sic@xmath1 in the circumstellar envelope ( cse ) of the carbon - rich star irc+10216 , as evidenced observationally and predicted by models @xcite .
these molecules are efficiently formed in the gas phase , close to the stellar photosphere as a consequence of chemical processes enabled under thermodynamical equilibrium @xcite . in the dust formation region ( @xmath2520 ) , the si - bearing molecules are likely to condense onto the dust grains due to their highly refractory nature .
the silicon contained in the dust grains can form molecules through grain - surface reactions . also , the interaction of shocks produced by the pulsation of the star with the dust grains can extract certain amounts of silicon from the grains and incorporate that silicon into the gas - phase to react and form other species ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . beyond this region , the abundances of si - bearing molecules
are expected to decrease up to the outermost shells of the envelope , where the interstellar ultraviolet ( uv ) radiation field dissociates all the remaining molecules .
previous interferometer observations showed the spatial distribution of these molecules in irc+10216 .
the sis @xmath3=5 4 , @xmath3=6 5 , @xmath3=8 7 , @xmath3=9 8 and @xmath3=12 11 brightness distributions display a quasi - circular shape with a diameter of @xmath220 elongated along the nebular axis ( p.a.@xmath220@xmath4 , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
recent observations with the combined array for research in millimeter - wave astronomy ( carma ) of the sis @xmath3=14 13 v=0 and v=1 lines have been reported by @xcite , where the v=0 line shows a circular and compact brightness distribution of @xmath22 and displays maser emission .
the v=1 brightness distribution shows a compact source centered at the star position .
sio @xmath3=5 4 v=0 brightness distribution maps carried out with the submillimeter array ( sma ) were reported in @xcite .
they show circular symmetry with a diameter of @xmath26 at the systemic velocity of the source , which is -26.5 ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the @xmath3=6
5 v=0 brightness distribution reported in @xcite displays a quasi - circular symmetry centered at the position of the star , with a diameter of @xmath23 elongated along the nebular direction ( ne sw ) .
sic@xmath0 observations carried out with the plateau de bure interferometer ( pdbi ) and carma , show a brightness distribution composed of : ( @xmath5 ) an elongated compact component located at the innermost regions of the cse @xcite and , ( @xmath6 ) a hollow shell structure located at @xmath215 from the star @xcite . the formation mechanism for this outer component
was suggested in @xcite , where the reaction between si and c@xmath0h@xmath0 yielding sic@xmath0 , could be responsible for the sic@xmath0 enhancement in the outer envelope . in this work we present the cycle0 observations carried out with the atacama large millimeter array ( alma ) toward irc+10216 .
we detected emission of sis @xmath3=15 14 lines of vibrationally excited states , from v=0 up to v=7 , and tentatively of v=8 , 9 and 10 .
@xmath3=15 14 lines of different isotopologues
are also detected : @xmath7sis ( v=05 ) , @xmath8sis ( v=04 ) , si@xmath9s ( v=03 ) , si@xmath10s ( v=04 ) , @xmath7si@xmath9s ( v=0 ) and @xmath7si@xmath10s ( v=0 ) .
we also detected emission of sio @xmath3=6 5 ( v=02 ) , @xmath7sio @xmath3=6 5 ( v=0 ) and several lines of sic@xmath0 in the ground vibrational state .
the observations were carried out with alma[multiblock footnote omitted ] between 2012 april 8 and 23 during cycle0 .
irc+10216 was observed in the frequency range 255.3 to 274.8ghz ( band 6 ) covered by four different setups with a bandwidth of @xmath25ghz , a channel spacing of 0.49mhz and an effective resolution of 0.98mhz .
detailed information of each setup is summarized in table[tab : obs ] .
the observations were performed using sixteen antennas covering baselines up to 402 m that allowed us to obtain an angular resolution of @xmath20.6 .
the shortest baselines used were @xmath220 m which allow us to recover structures with a size up to @xmath1112 .
two runs of 72 minutes each were performed , of which 26 minutes correspond to correlations on source .
further details about calibration and imaging restoration can be found in @xcite .
the coverage of the uv plane achieved with the setup 6 provides low contributions of the sidelobes ( @xmath1210% of the primary beam ) to the dirty beam . for the rest of the setups the uv coverage is worse and large contributions of the sidelobes ( up to 2030% of the primary beam ) appear in the dirty beam .
the continuum comes from a point - like source located at @xmath13=9@xmath1447@xmath1557446 and @xmath16=13@xmath416@xmath174386(j2000 ) , which is in good agreement with the position of irc+10216 measured with the very large array ( vla ) with 40 mas resolution @xcite .
we measured an intensity peak of 650 mjybeam@xmath18 with an uncertainty of @xmath28% .
the calibration of the data was performed using casa[multiblock footnote omitted ] and data analysis with gildas[multiblock footnote omitted ] .
.observational parameters.[tab : obs ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
in figs.[fig : si - bear ] and [ fig:29sio ] , we show maps of the emission of the lines sic@xmath0 @xmath19=11@xmath20 10@xmath21 , @xmath7sio @xmath3=6 5 and @xmath7sis @xmath3=15 14 in their ground vibrational state at different offset velocities with respect to the systemic velocity of the source .
sic@xmath0 ( fig.[fig : si - bear ] ) displays a central component elongated in the ne
sw direction with a size of @xmath245 along the nebular axis and @xmath234 in the perpendicular direction .
the elongation is also observed in the @xmath7sio emission ( see below ) and in the sio and sic@xmath0 maps by @xcite where the authors invoke a possible bipolar outflow to explain it . at the systemic velocity of the source and at + 6 offset , a ringlike , clumpy and weak component is seen at @xmath21011 from the central star .
the angular distance between the position of the star and the ring structure , considering a distance of @xmath2130pc to the star from us @xcite , corresponds to a linear distance of @xmath22@xmath2210@xmath23 cm .
this ringlike component is consistent with the peak abundance of sic@xmath0 in the outer envelope of irc+10216 reported in @xcite and the chemical model of @xcite .
although , this ringlike structure is probably filtered in our data given the shortest baselines used . between the central and the ringlike structure , emission of sic@xmath1 is either very low or absent @xcite .
finally , the redshifted emission ( + 12 ) displays a quasi - circular distribution with a diameter of @xmath256 .
these brightness distributions could be interpreted as the sic@xmath1 is formed in regions close to the star , then it condenses onto the dust grains , and eventually it reappears at the outer shells of the cse , perhaps as a hollow shell , as the consequence of the interaction between the uv galactic radiation field and the cse @xcite . for @xmath7sio ( figs.[fig : si - bear ] and [ fig:29sio ] ) , the bulk of the emission arises from a compact central component with a size of 2 .
this line also displays an extended and clumpy distribution , elongated in the ne sw and with a size of @xmath267 . at velocities close to the terminal expansion velocity , @xmath214.5@xcite ,
the brightness distribution is elongated in the ne
sw direction with a size of @xmath234 .
the blueshifted emission at -13 displays a decrease just in front of the star , which can be interpreted as self - absorption and probably absorption of the continuum emission mostly coming from the star .
there is no conclusive explanation for the elongation ; nevertheless , some authors pointed out that it could evidence the presence of a bipolar outflow in the cse @xcite .
the possible presence of a binary companion to cwleo could also play a decisive role in this scenario @xcite .
the observed brightness distributions of the vibrationally excited sis lines are expected to be compact and centered on the star since the involved levels are excited at the high temperatures prevailing close to the star . the sis @xmath3=15 14 v=0 line , which displays maser emission @xcite , shows a circular brightness distribution with a diameter of @xmath22 at the systemic velocity of the source . for the sis @xmath3=15 14 v@xmath241 lines , the observed distributions are not spatially resolved .
fig.[fig : si - bear ] shows the emission of the @xmath7sis @xmath3=15
14 v=0 line , which displays a brightness distribution of a compact source surrounding the central star with a diameter of @xmath22 .
a large - scale artificial modulation can be seen below the 25@xmath25 level .
since it is related to the visibilities at short baselines , we do not expect it to modify the shape and flux of the compact central component of the brightness distribution . also , the quality of the several sis and @xmath7sis maps is affected owing to the low uv coverage and non - neglible contribution of the sidelobes for the setups 35 ( see table[tab : obs ] ) . the lines that lie in the range covered by the setup 6 , are those of high vibrationally excited states ( e.g. sis @xmath3=15
14 v@xmath2410 , @xmath7sis @xmath3=15 14 v@xmath246 ) which are tentative and spatially unresolved .
[ a ] [ b ] [ c ] the cycle0 observations with alma allowed us to detect several @xmath3=15 14 lines of high vibrationally excited states of sis isotopologues , in particular , up to v=7 for the main isotopologue ( see fig.[fig : sis_all ] ) .
the sis @xmath3=15 14 v=8 and v=10 lines are probably blended with unidentified lines , so we consider them to be tentative .
additionally , the sis @xmath3=15 14 v=9 line is considered tentatively detected because even though its fwhm measured seems to follow the trend shown in fig.[fig : sis_all ] , its measured integrated intensity is underestimated considering the population diagram of fig.[fig : sis_all ] .
all these lines display a compact unresolved emission peaking at the central star .
the fwhm of the lines measured from the spectra at the stellar position decreases with increasing upper level energy ( see fig.[fig : sis_all ] ) .
we verified this behavior for sis , @xmath7sis , @xmath8sis , si@xmath9s and si@xmath10s . in the dust formation region ,
the gas displays a velocity gradient as a function of the radial distance to the star , i.e. , the closer to the star the lower the expansion velocity ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein )
. hence , those lines involving higher vibrational states , which are excited in inner and warmer regions , are narrower .
thermal broadening for the sis lines excited in the dust formation region is @xmath21 , and thus this mechanism could only account partially for the fwhm variation of the lines .
we analyzed the excitation conditions of sis with the rotational diagram technique @xcite using the spectra at the stellar position ( see fig.[fig : sis_all ] ) .
we considered two different linear trends for the observational data : one for the transitions with e@xmath26@xmath112500k ( i.e. v=0 , 1 and 2 ) , and a different trend for the rest ( i.e. v=37 ) .
the v@xmath248 lines are excluded from the fit .
the values derived from the v=0 to v=2 fit are uncertain owing to the maser nature of the sis @xmath3=15 14 v=0 line and also due to possible optically thick emission .
both data series show a linear behavior consistent with a single vibrational ( excitation ) temperature for each of the fits .
the vibrational temperature derived from the fit involving the transitions in high - energy vibrational states is higher than the temperature derived for the low vibrational levels .
therefore , the emission produced by sis transitions in high - energy vibrational states can only arise from regions close to the photosphere .
this result is similar to the one obtained by @xcite for hcn .
we used a large velocity gradient ( lvg ) code to model the sis emission @xcite .
further details about the spectroscopic data used in the calculations are given in
[ sec : vibmom ] .
the sis collisional data were taken from @xcite and extrapolated to high rovibrational levels .
we adopted a distance to the star of @xmath2130pc , an effective temperature of @xmath22330k and a stellar radius of @xmath24@xmath2210@xmath27 cm as input for our model @xcite .
we used two different models : ( @xmath5 ) the model of @xcite , which was used to reproduce the molecular abundances in the inner layers of irc+10216 , that we call the `` 2012 model '' , and , ( @xmath6 ) this work , which is a modification of the model ( @xmath5 ) .
we modified the h@xmath0 density , decreasing it by a factor @xmath22 , as described in @xcite ( this was used to reproduce the dust nucleation zone , 110 , of irc+10216 ) .
additionally , the sis abundance in the dust nucleation zone needs to be balanced with a similar increase ( factor of @xmath22 ) to avoid an underestimation of the sis emission . from these models ( see fig.[fig : sis_all ] ) we obtain a good agreement with the vibrational temperature derived from the vibrational diagram and moderate discrepancies with the total column density within a factor of @xmath22 .
these discrepancies in the column density may be explained by the dilution due to the size of the emitting region compared to the half power beam width of the synthetic beam , which would increase the optical depth of the lines .
the size of the emitting region should decrease with the vibrational state owing to the energies needed to excite those lines . with our models , we found moderate to high optical depths @xmath28(v=1)@xmath210 to @xmath28(v=4)@xmath20.8 for the abundance profile ( @xmath5 ) and @xmath28(v=1)@xmath247 to @xmath28(v=8)@xmath21.0 for the abundance profile ( @xmath6 ) .
the potential energy function used to describe the internuclear motions of the sis isotopologues is a born oppenheimer ( bo ) potential properly extended to accommodate born
oppenheimer breakdown ( bob ) corrections .
the effective potential has the form @xcite
@xmath29\frac{j(j+1)}{r^{2 } } \label{pefdmm1}\ ] ] where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the silicon and sulfur atomic masses and @xmath32 is the reduced mass .
the bo potential is given by @xmath33^{2 } \label{pefdmm2}\ ] ] where @xmath34 @xmath35 and @xmath36 and the bob potential and centrifugal correction terms are represented by the power expansions @xmath37
@xmath38 @xmath39 the potential parameters were obtained by nonlinear least squares fitting to the observed infrared and microwave line positions of the sis isotopologues up to v=12 .
the final data set included a total of 2863 lines , 414 rotational transitions @xcite and 2449 rovibrational transitions @xcite .
mass - independent dunham coefficients , u@xmath40 , have been derived by @xcite .
the fit to the potential energy function was performed using the levenberg
marquardt algorithm @xcite to minimize the @xmath41 function , with the line positions weighted by the square of the experimental uncertainties .
the rovibrational energy levels of the isotopologues needed to calculate the line positions were computed by solving the radial schrdinger equation using the variational method of @xcite along with harmonic - type basis functions .
the potential parameters obtained in the fit are given in the comments of the table[vdip ] .
the final @xmath41 value was 1.767 .
the unweighted standard deviations for the rotational and , vibrational - rotational line positions were 0.0229mhz and 0.000657cm@xmath18 , respectively .
the dipole moment function used for sis was determined semiempirically by @xcite , and the dipole moment matrix elements were computed up to v=4 . in table[vdip ] we provide them up to v=12 .
the agreement between our calculations and those of @xcite for v@xmath434 is excellent .
sic was detected in irc+10216 by @xcite with line profiles indicating that the molecule was produced in an external shell , probably as a product of the photodissociation of sic@xmath0 .
our observations did not cover any frequency range where sic lines could arise ; however , lines of @xmath7sic and sic v=1 lie in this range , but they were not detected .
for a temperature in the photosphere of 2300k a significant number of sic molecules could be in the v=1 state ( e@xmath44@xmath21400k ) and higher vibrational levels .
we derived an upper limit to the sic column density of 4.4@xmath2210@xmath45@xmath46 from the @xmath7sic upper limit , where we used an isotopic @xmath47si/@xmath7si ratio of 20 @xcite .
hence , sic@xmath0 is the main carrier of sic bonds in the gas phase in the dust formation zone of irc+10216 .
alma has proved to be an outstanding tool to study the molecular emission from cses of evolved stars , even at the early stages of its development . in particular
, alma allowed us to detect sis rotational lines in high - energy vibrational states that have been analyzed to constrain the physical conditions of the innermost shells of irc+10216 .
we found that these lines should be excited in regions close to the photosphere of irc+10216 .
it also has served to unveil the different brightness distributions of si - bearing molecules .
we expect that future alma science , with its full suite of capabilities ready for the next observation cycle , would give us the chance to map the brightness distributions of these si - bearing molecules in greater detail , allowing us to understand their formation mechanisms .
we thank the spanish mineco / micinn for funding support through grants aya2009 - 07304 , aya2012 - 32032 , the astromol consolider project csd2009 - 00038 and the european research council ( erc grant 610256 : nanocosmos ) . | we report the detection of sis rotational lines in high - vibrational states as well as sio and sic@xmath0 lines in their ground vibrational state toward irc+10216 during the atacama large millimeter array cycle0 .
the spatial distribution of these molecules shows compact emission for sis and a more extended emission for sio and sic@xmath0 , and also proves the existence of an increase in the sic@xmath0 emission at the outer shells of the circumstellar envelope .
we analyze the excitation conditions of the vibrationally excited sis using the population diagram technique , and we use a large velocity gradient model to compare with the observations .
we found moderate discrepancies between the observations and the models that could be explained if sis lines detected are optically thick .
additionally , the line profiles of the detected rotational lines in the high energy vibrational states show a decreasing linewidth with increasing energy levels
. this may be evidence that these lines could be excited only in the inner shells , i.e. , the densest and hottest , of the circumstellar envelope of irc+10216 . |
phase transitions are amongst the most remarkable and ubiquitous phenomena in nature .
they involve sudden changes in measurable macroscopic properties of systems and are brought about by varying external parameters such as temperature or pressure .
familiar examples include the transitions from ice to water , water to steam , and the demagnetization of certain metals at high temperature .
these dramatic phenomena are described mathematically by non - analytic behaviour of thermodynamic functions , which reflect the drastic changes taking place in the system at a microscopic level . besides materials science
, phase transitions play vital roles in cosmology , particle physics , chemistry , biology , sociology and beyond ; the universe began in a symmetric manner and went through a series of phase transitions through which the particles of matter with which we are familiar ( electrons , protons , the higgs boson , etc . ) materialised .
more mundane examples include traffic flow ( where there is a transition between jammed and free - flowing states ) , growth phenomena and wealth accumulation ( where there may be a transition to a condensation phase , for example ) .
while the latter examples refer to non - equilibrium systems , the emphasis in this article is on a famous transition which exists in equilbrium systems . the mathematical physics which describes such phenomena belongs to the realm of equilibrium statistical mechanics , one of the most beautiful , sophisticated and successful theories in physics .
equilibrium statistical physics is based on the following premise : the probability that a system is in a state @xmath1 with energy @xmath2 at a temperature @xmath3 is @xmath4 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 is a universal constant , and @xmath7 is a normalising factor known as the partition function , @xmath8 here , the subscript @xmath9 indicates the linear extent of the system .
a related fundamental quantity is the free energy , @xmath10 , given by @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the dimensionality of the system .
phase transitions can only occur when the system under consideration has an infinite number of states in which it can exist for example , in the thermodynamic limit @xmath13 . in the modern classification scheme
, such phase transitions are categorised as first- , second- ( or higher- ) order if the lowest derivative of the free energy that displays non - analytic behaviour is the first , second ( or higher ) one .
transitions of infinite order brake no system symmetries .
the most famous of these is the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) transition in the two - dimensional @xmath0 model @xcite .
the model is defined on a two - dimensional regular lattice , whose sites are labeled by the index @xmath14 , each of which is occupied by a spin or rotator @xmath15 .
these two - dimensional unit vectors have @xmath16 or @xmath17 symmetry .
the energy of a given configuration is @xmath18 where the summation runs over nearest neighbouring sites or links .
this model is used to study systems such as films of superfluid helium , superconducting materials , fluctuating surfaces , josephson - junctions as well as certain magnetic , gaseous and liquid - crystal systems . the scenario proposed in seminal papers by and kosterlitz and thouless
@xcite is that at a temperature above the critical one ( @xmath19 or @xmath20 ) positively and negatively charged vortices ( i.e. , vortices and antivortices ) which are present ( see fig . 1 )
are unbound ( dissociated from each other ) and disorder the system . below the critical temperature ( @xmath21 or @xmath22 ) they are bound together and are relevant as dynamical degrees of freedom . there
, long - range correlations between spins at sites @xmath14 and @xmath23 ( separated by a distance @xmath24 , say ) exist and are described by the correlation function whose leading behaviour in the thermodynamic infinite - volume limit is @xmath25 the correlation length ( which measures to what extent spins at different sites are correlated ) diverges and this massless low - temperature phase persists , with the system remaining critical with varying @xmath26 , up to @xmath27 at which @xmath28 . above this point ,
correlations decay exponentially fast with leading behaviour @xmath29 here @xmath30 is the correlation length , and @xmath31 measures the distance from the critical point . as this critical point
is approached , the leading scaling behaviour of the correlation length , the specific heat and the susceptibility ( which respectively measure the response of the system to variations in the temperature and application of an external magnetic field ) are @xmath32 in which and @xmath33 is a non - universal constant .
this exponential behavour is known as essential scaling , to distinguish it from more conventional power - law scaling behaviour ( in which , for example , @xmath34 ) . in summary ,
the bkt scenario means a transition which ( i ) is mediated by vortex unbinding and ( ii ) exhibits essential scaling .
besides the two - dimensional @xmath0 model , transitions of the bkt type exist in certain models with long - range interactions @xcite , antiferromagnetic models @xcite , the ice - type @xmath35 model @xcite and in string theory @xcite amongst others .
thus a thorough and quantitative understanding of the paradigmatic @xmath0 model is crucial to a wide breadth of theoretical physics .
for many years monte carlo and high - temperature analyses of the @xmath0 model sought to verify the analytical bkt renormalisation - group ( rg ) prediction that @xmath36 and @xmath37 and to determine the value of @xmath38 .
typically @xmath38 was determined by firstly fixing @xmath39 .
subsequent measurements of @xmath40 yielded a value incompatible with the the bkt prediction .
because of the elusiveness of its non - perturbative corroboration , the essential nature of the transition was questioned @xcite .
see table 1 of @xcite for an extensive overview of the status of the model up to that point .
the fundamental realization of @xcite was that the thermal scaling forms ( [ b ] ) and ( [ c ] ) ( and similar formulae for related thermodynamic functions ) are inconsistent as they stand .
instead , they must be modified to include logarithmic corrections : @xmath41 with @xmath42 and @xmath43 where rg indications implicit in @xcite are that @xmath44 .
eq.([cc ] ) is an analytic prediction , which , since it is based on perturbation theory , requires confirmation through non - perturbative approaches .
however , infinite lattices are not attainable using finite numerical resources .
instead , one simulates finite systems , where , at criticality ( @xmath45 ) , the lattice size @xmath9 plays the role of @xmath46 in this model .
the finite - size scaling ( fss ) prediction for the susceptibility is then @xmath47 to verify the bkt scaling scenario then , the thermal formula ( [ cc ] ) and/or the fss formula ( [ ccfss ] ) needs to be confirmed numerically .
sophisticated fss techniques ( involving partition function zeros ) were used in @xcite to resolve , for the first time , the hitherto conflicting results for @xmath48 , @xmath38 and @xmath40 . however , the analysis resulted in an estimate of @xmath49 for @xmath24 , a value in conflict with the rg prediction of @xmath44 from @xcite .
thus , in recent years , the focus of numerical studies of the @xmath0 model shifted to the determination of the logarithm exponent @xmath24 .
indeed , the fss analyses of @xcite , using ( [ ccfss ] ) , yielded values compatible with that of @xcite but incompatible with @xcite ( see table 1 ) .
nonetheless , it was clear that taking the logarithmic corrections into account leads to the resolution of the @xmath48-@xmath38-@xmath40 controversy .
the most precise estimate for the critical temperature in the literature for the @xmath0 model with the standard action of ( [ xy ] ) is contained in @xcite and is @xmath50 .
this value was obtained by mapping the @xmath0 model onto the exactly solvable body centered solid - on - solid model , and thereby circumventing the issue of logarithmic corrections . as demonstrated in table 1 ,
recent analyses which have inluded the logarithmic corrections have resulted in estimates for @xmath38 compatible with this value ( while keeping @xmath51 ) . in @xcite and @xcite respectively , phase transitions in a lattice grain boundary model and a lattice gauge theory are studied . because these are in the same universality class as the @xmath0 model in two dimensions , they have the same scaling behaviour ( [ ccfss ] ) . however , the critical temperatures in these models bear no relationship to that of the @xmath0 counterpart .
although @xcite contains a study of the @xmath0 model , it employs the villain formulation , which is different to ( [ xy ] ) , and leads to a different value for the nonuniversal quantity @xmath38 .
.estimates for @xmath38 and @xmath24 for the @xmath0 model from a selection of recent papers with indications of the method used to obtain them ( rg related , fss or thermal scaling ) .
[ cols= " < , < , < , < , < " , ] it was suggested in @xcite that just as taking the logarithmic corrections into account leads to the resolution of the leading scaling behaviour , in the same spirit it is conceivable that numerical measurements for @xmath24 may become compatible with the rg prediction if sub - leading corrections are taken into account . in this case ,
( [ ccfss ] ) is more fully expressed as @xmath52 this was tested in @xcite to determine if the discrepancies between the numerical and theoretical estimates for @xmath24 can be ascribed to sub - leading corrections .
however , the lattice sizes available ( up to @xmath53 ) were too small to resolve the issue .
recently this issue was again addressed in a very high precision numerical simulation ( using lattices as big as @xmath54 ) in @xcite .
using the ansatz @xmath55 and fitting to @xmath24 gives @xmath56 if large enough lattices are used .
this value is compatible with the analytic prediction , @xmath57 . notwithstanding this result ,
which is fss based , it is rather surprising that all of the analyses of the thermal scaling formula ( [ cc ] ) in table 1 yield positive values of @xmath24 far from the rg prediction that @xmath58 .
it appears , therefore , that the fss approach is more powerful than that based on thermal scaling , although more extensive analyses would be required to test how this approach compares with that of @xcite .
while large scale simulations were required to resolve these puzzles , a different technique , not requiring extensive simulations was used in @xcite . a conformal mapping
was used to switch from a confined @xmath59 lattice to the semi - infinite half plane . in this way
, @xmath26 could be deduced from the correlation function at any value of @xmath60 . in particular
, @xmath61 is accurately recovered at the transition temperature and clear evidence for existence of logarithmic corrections in the correlation function @xmath62 is presented .
the vortex - binding scenario is crucial to the bkt phase transition in the two - dimensional @xmath0 model .
because the energy of a single vortex increases with the system size as @xmath63 , at low temperature they can only occur in vortex - antivortex pairs .
mutual cancelation of their individual ordering effects means that such a pair can only affect nearby spins and can not significantly disorder the whole system .
topological long - range order exists in the system at low temperature .
however at high temperature , the number of vortices proliferates and the distance between erstwhile partners becomes so large that they are effectively free and render the system disordered .
it was for a long time believed that altering the energetics of the @xmath0 model to disable the vortex - binding scenario may lead to a transition different to the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless one @xcite .
the step model is obtained from the @xmath0 model by replacing the hamiltonian ( [ xy ] ) by @xmath64 the energy associated with a single vortex for this system is expected to be independent of the lattice size .
therefore , on the basis of this argument , vortices could exist at all temperatures , disordering the system .
i.e. , there was expected to be no vortex - driven phase transition in the step model if there is a phase transition , it was expected not to be of the bkt type .
indeed , early studies supported this assertion @xcite .
however , in @xcite , very strong numerical evidence was presented that ( i ) there is a phase transition in the step model and ( ii ) it is of the bkt type ( with even the corrections to scaling being the same as those for the @xmath0 model ) .
given the very different vortex energetics for the two models , this came as a surprise .
the issue was further addressed in @xcite , where evidence for the existence of a bkt transition in the step model was again proffered .
the approach of @xcite focused on numerical analyses of the helicity modulus , which experiences a jump at the transition . a similar approach to the @xmath0 model is contained in @xcite .
the main idea of @xcite , which explains the occurence of the bkt transition in the step model , is that while the energy associated with a single fixed vortex in the system remains finite , the _ free energy _ grows as @xmath63 .
this fact inhibits proliferation of free vortices in the low - temperature phase .
it further implies that the harmonic properties of the interaction ( [ xy ] ) do not form a necessary condition for a bkt transition .
consequently , and as pointed out in @xcite , the bkt phase transition may be an even more general phenomenon than hitherto recognised .
* asymptotic freedom of @xmath65 @xmath66 models : * it is generally believed that there are differences of a fundamental nature between abelian and nonabelian models .
the @xmath0 model has an @xmath16 symmetry group and is abelian , while all @xmath66 models with @xmath67 are nonabelian .
the mermin - wagner theorem states that a continuous symmetry of the @xmath66 type can not be broken in two dimensions @xcite .
thus there can not be a transition to a phase with long - range order in either of the @xmath68 or @xmath69 scenarios there .
however , in a two - dimensional theory , topological defects of dimension @xmath70 can exist if the @xmath71 homotopy group , @xmath72 , of the order parameter space is non - trivial . for @xmath66 models , this space is the hypersphere @xmath73 .
the only non - trivial group is @xmath74 which is isomorphic to the set of integers under addition .
this is the condition that gives rise to point defects ( vortices ) with integer charge in the @xmath68 case ( the @xmath0 model ) .
the binding of these vortices at low temperature is the mechanism giving rise to the bkt phase transition @xcite . for @xmath69
, conditions are not supportive of the existence of topological defects of this type and the widely held belief is that there is no phase transition , there being no distinct low - temperature phase .
perturbation theory predicts that the @xmath69 models are asymptotically free .
there is , however , no rigorous proof to this effect .
this belief has been questioned and @xcite have given numerical evidence for the existence of phase transitions of the bkt type in these models as well as heuristic explanations of why such transition could occur and a rigorous proof that this would be incompatible with asymptotic freedom .
perturbative and monte carlo calculations for the @xmath75 and @xmath76 models have been performed in @xcite , which do not support the existence of such a bkt - like phase transition there and instead are in agreement with perturbation theory and the asymptotic freedom scenario .
nonetheless , the controversy has not entirely gone away @xcite , and one may argue that inclusion of logarithmic considerations could help for a precise unambiguous resolution . + * the diluted @xmath0 model : * an interesting current topic of research has been the question of the role of impurities in the @xmath0 model @xcite .
the presence of impurities brings the model closer to real systems , where such physical defects are present .
impurities are modeled by randomly diluting the number of sites ( or bonds ) on the lattice .
clearly , if the dilution is so strong as to inhibit the percolation of spin - spin interactions across the lattice ( such that it is effectively broken into finite disconnected sets ) no phase transition can occur for any model .
thus moderate dilution generally is expected to decrease the location of the transition temperature . however , the special additional feature of the @xmath0 model is the presence of vortices and the fact that they drive the transition .
vortices are attracted to and , to some extent , anchored by impurities and the vortex energy is reduced at such a vacancy . therefore with increasing dilution , more
vortices can be formed and the amount of disorder in the system is increased .
this effect may enhance the lowering of the critical temperature to such an extent that it vanishes before the percolation threshold is reached .
this is the issue addressed in @xcite .
the percolation threshold occurs when the density of site vacancies is @xmath77 .
the critical vacancy density is identified by the vanishing of the critical temperature , which in turn is identified as being the location at which @xmath78 . in @xcite
the critical temperature was reported to vanish above the percolation threshold at vacancy density @xmath79 . however , in it was suggested that the critical density is , in fact , closer to the percolation threshold .
support for the latter result recently appeared in @xcite .
if this is true , it means that the vortices do not , in fact , strongly enhance the lowering of the critical temperature . from the collective experience with the pure @xmath0 model as reported above , it is clear that a more precise identification of the critical temperature through @xmath78 would require taking account of the logarithmic corrections , although ignoring them may suffice as first approximation . indeed
, ignoring these corrections in the pure model also leads to an estimate for the critical temperature which is higher than accurate values @xcite .
besides the value of the critical temperature in a diluted model , one is also interested in the scaling behaviour of the thermodynamic functions at the phase transition there .
the harris criterion predicts that disorder does not change the leading scaling behaviour of a model if the critical exponent @xmath80 associated with the specific heat of the pure model is negative @xcite .
this is the case for the @xmath0 model in two dimensions .
however , it is unclear what effect dilution can have on the quantitative nature of the exponents of the logarithmic corrections in such a case .
this would be an interesting avenue for future research , and the @xmath0 model ( which has negative @xmath80 ) offers an ideal platform upon which to base such pursuits .
+ * other models with logarithmic corrections : * logarithmic corrections to scaling also exist in other important models .
while their existence has been unambiguously verified in @xmath81 @xmath66 models @xcite , this is not so in most cases @xcite . in particular , kim and landau applied fss techniques to the four - state @xmath65 potts model @xcite .
again , fss behaviour could only be described if the logarithmic corrections are included .
however , here inclusion of the leading multiplicative logarithmic corrections is insufficient and sub - leading additive corrections are required .
the puzzle of why unusually large numbers of correction terms are necessary ( despite the availability of the exact value of @xmath38 in this model ) could , perhaps , now be resolved by an analysis on the scale of @xcite and this would be another interesting avenue to pursue .
similar problems concerning logarithmic corrections and their detection exist in other two - dimensional models such as the diluted ising model @xcite .
theoretical progress on the general issue of logarithmic corrections will be reported elsewhere @xcite .
the issue of topologically driven phase transitions characterized by the two - dimensional @xmath0 model has been revisited and a timely review of the status of scaling at the famous berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless transition given .
after two decades of work , the perturbative renormalization group precictions of @xcite for the leading scaling behaviour were confirmed in @xcite and there is now little or no doubt about the correctness of the analytic predictions , @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the recent controversy over the value of the leading logarithmic correction exponent @xmath24 ( summarized in table 1 ) has been re - examined and claims as to its resolution ( at least in the context of finite - size scaling ) and state - of - the - art calculations summarized @xcite . besides the @xmath0 model , such multiplicative logarithmic corrections are manifest in a variety of other models , and their resolution in these contexts is now at the forefront current modern numerical investigations in statistical and lattice physics .
a summary of some recent work on such models , as well as likely future directions has been given .
finally , recent work @xcite confirming the vortex - binding scenario as the phase transition mechanism in the @xmath0 model has also been reviewed to complete a full account of the current status of one of the most remarkable and beautiful models in theoretical physics .
this work was supported by eu marie curie research grants chbict941125 and fmbict961757 .
b. berche , a.i .
farias sanchez and r. paredes v. , europhys .
( 2002 ) 539 ; b. berche , phys . lett . a 302 ( 2002 )
336 ; b. berche , j. phys . a 36 ( 2003 ) 585 ; b. berche and l. shchur , jetp lett .
79 ( 2004 ) 213 . | in statistical physics , the @xmath0 model in two dimensions provides the paradigmatic example of phase transitions mediated by topological defects ( vortices ) . over the years
, a variety of analytical and numerical methods have been deployed in an attempt to fully understand the nature of its transition , which is of the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless type .
these met with only limited success until it was realized that subtle effects ( logarithmic corrections ) that modify leading behaviour must be taken into account .
this realization prompted renewed activity in the field and significant progress has been made .
this paper contains a review of the importance of such subtleties , the role played by vortices and of recent and current research in this area .
directions for desirable future research endeavours are outlined . |
tunneling in a magnetic field is a matter of investigation for many years .
the magnetic field can influence tunneling across a potential barrier in two different ways .
first , the magnetic field can modify an underbarrier motion related to a classically forbidden region .
studies of this phenomenon are presented in the literature . in refs . @xcite it was pointed out that an underbarrier fall of the wave function can be less rapid in an inhomogeneous sample .
see also refs .
@xcite . in ref .
@xcite a transmission coefficient through a quadratic barrier was found .
a decay of a metastable state was considered in ref .
the certain peculiarities of an underbarrier wave function were discussed in refs .
@xcite .
second , the magnetic field can influence a state of an electron at a classically allowed region after an exits from under the barrier .
a typical example is the wigner resonance when the electron tunnels into a potential well with a level aligned to its energy @xcite .
see experimental measurements , for instance , in refs .
another example relates to a specific density of states in the classical region after the tunneling barrier .
a state of an electron , influenced by the magnetic field , may fit better that density of states and this results in increase of tunneling rate @xcite .
the goal of the paper is to study tunneling decay rate of a metastable state in a magnetic field ( the electron after tunneling goes to infinity ) .
the question to be answered : can a magnetic field increase the decay rate ? it is clear that the above effect of density of states at the region after the barrier can , in principle , increase the rate . but this effect , related to a prefactor , can not be very large . according to ref .
@xcite , there is approximately @xmath0 enhamcement of the effect
. it would be much more amazing to increase the main exponential part of the decay rate by the magnetic field .
the references @xcite say that it is impossible . indeed , when an electron enters under the barrier its velocity deviates , due to the cyclotron effect , from a tunneling path with no magnetic field .
this leads to a reduction of the tunneling probability by the magnetic field .
the reduction can be also explained in terms of increasing of the total barrier .
the additional barrier is proportional to a squared velocity of the electron in the magnetic field @xcite .
but there is a situation when the electron tunnels from a quantum wire or another object extended in the direction perpendicular to tunneling . in this case a state prior to tunneling can have a finite velocity perpendicular to the tunneling direction . according to the cyclotron effect ,
this velocity rotates under the barrier and becomes more aligned with the tunneling direction .
this leads to enhancement of the tunneling rate by the magnetic field ( cyclotron enhancement ) . formally , cyclotron enhancement of tunneling results from a reduction of the main tunneling exponent which reminds one of wentzel , kramers , and brillouin ( wkb ) .
the exponent can be reduced in a few times .
suppose that at zero magnetic field the tunneling rate is proportional to @xmath1 .
the magnetic field can turn it into , say , @xmath2 .
we consider in the paper tunneling from a straight quantum wire , directed in the @xmath3 axis , embedded into a two - dimensional electron system in the @xmath4 plane .
the potential barrier is created by the electric field @xmath5 directed along the @xmath6 axis ( the direction of tunneling ) .
the magnetic field @xmath7 is aligned along @xmath8 . according to electrodynamics , after tunneling a motion of the electron in perpendicular magnetic and electric fields is restricted by a finite interval in the @xmath6 direction @xcite . to get the electron passed to the infinite @xmath6 one should put some potential wall(s ) along the @xmath6 direction restricting the @xmath3 motion .
due to multiple reflections from the restricting wall in the magnetic field the electron goes to the infinite @xmath6 .
we model the walls by the potential proportional to @xmath9 .
the theory presented relates also to tunneling from a flat @xmath10 film with quantized electron motion in the @xmath6 direction . the electron tunnels into a three - dimensional reservoir .
restricting walls should be placed parallel to the @xmath11 plane . without the restricting walls
a solution can be obtained analytically on the bases of the modified wkb approach as shown in sec .
[ sec : wkb ] .
an approximation of classical complex trajectories is formulated in sec .
[ sec : traj ] . in secs .
[ sec : masha ] and [ sec : vania ] two different methods of numerical calculations are applied to the problem with restricting walls .
we consider an electron localized in the @xmath4 plane .
the static magnetic field @xmath7 is directed along the @xmath8 axis .
suppose a motion of the electron in the @xmath4 plane to occur in the potential @xmath12 .
then the schrdinger equation , with the vector potential @xmath13 , has the form @xcite @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the cyclotron frequency .
the potential @xmath16 describes the quantum wire placed in the @xmath3 direction ( the first term ) , the constant electric field @xmath5 ( the second term ) , and the restricting walls in the @xmath3 direction are modeled by the third term . at @xmath17 and @xmath18 the discrete energy level in the @xmath19 well ( @xmath20 ) is a ground state in the wkb approximation . let us introduce the dimensionless electric field @xmath21 and the magnetic field @xmath22 by the equations @xmath23 below we measure @xmath6 and @xmath3 in the units of @xmath24 and time in the units of @xmath25 the energy is @xmath26 where the dimensionless energy @xmath27 is negative in our problem .
we also introduce a large semiclassical parameter @xmath28 at zero magnetic field @xmath29 the wkb probability of tunneling @xcite @xmath30 is small . in the new variables schrdinger equation ( [ 1 ] ) has the form @xmath31\psi=\lambda\psi.\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can exclude the point @xmath32 , if to impose the boundary condition @xmath33 with the semiclassical accuracy , the lowest level at the @xmath19 well is @xmath34 . at a finite electric field that level is metastable and
we should find a decay rate due to tunneling in the magnetic field . when the potential barrier is hardly transparent ( a large @xmath35 ) one can use the semiclassical approximation for the wave function @xcite @xmath36,\ ] ] where @xmath37 is the classical action satisfying the equation of hamilton - jacobi at @xmath38 @xmath39 the function @xmath37 is continuous .
as follows from eq .
( [ 4 ] ) , @xmath40 is also continuous . according to that
, one can consider the action at positive @xmath6 with the boundary condition @xmath41 which follows from eq .
( [ 2a ] ) . in the approximation of a large @xmath35 the condition ( [ 2a ] )
is reduced to @xmath42 if to consider the problem at positive @xmath6 only .
first , we consider tunneling from the quantum wire , when there are no restriction of the motion in the @xmath3 direction . in other words , we drop down the term @xmath9 in the potential @xmath12 ( [ 2 ] ) . in this case
the solution of the schrdinger equation ( [ 1 ] ) @xmath43 is determined by the effective schrdinger equation @xmath44 with the effective potential energy the effective potential energy ( [ 36c ] ) is plotted for a positive @xmath45 in eq .
( [ 36d ] ) .
an electron tunnels between @xmath32 and @xmath46 .
the two dots mark terminal points between which a classical motion occurs . the potential barrier with no magnetic field is shown by the straight line.,width=207 ] @xmath47 the first term in eq .
( [ 36c ] ) is proportional to squared velocity of the electron .
solutions with positive and negative wave vector @xmath45 are possible according to different directions of motion in the wire . in the wkb approximation for the state , localized in the @xmath19 well , @xmath48 in the physical units ,
the velocity along the quantum wire is @xmath49 ( color online ) the decay rate ( [ 41 ] ) of the metastable state of the quantum wire versus magnetic field @xmath22 at @xmath50 .
left curve : the state in the wire has zero velocity parallel to the wire , @xmath34 .
right curve : the same when the velocity is finite , @xmath51.,width=264 ] below we consider a positive @xmath45 related to the motion from @xmath52 to @xmath53 in @xmath3 . for this case
the potential energy @xmath54 is shown schematically in fig .
[ fig1 ] and the wkb wave function under the barrier , @xmath55 , has the form @xmath56.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the classical terminal point , determined by the condition @xmath57 , is @xmath58 where @xmath59 the terminal point @xmath46 plays a role of the exit point from under the barrier and is marked in fig .
the classically allowed region , @xmath60 , is between two terminal points displayed in fig .
our consideration has a meaning , when the classically allowed region is of a finite width .
this occurs under the condition @xmath61 when the two terminal points in fig .
[ fig1 ] are separated . for the @xmath3-independent potential considered
the classically allowed motion occurs between the two terminal points in fig .
it means that after an exit from under the barrier the electron motion will remain restricted in the @xmath6 direction . a penetration through the barrier , @xmath55 , in fig .
[ fig1 ] can be enhanced , when the level @xmath27 in the @xmath19 well coincides with one of the discrete levels in the well at @xmath62 .
the wigner resonant tunneling occurs in this case @xcite .
a scenario becomes different , if we return to the full potential energy ( [ 2 ] ) . after coming from under the barrier
the electron participates in cyclotron motion and the lorentz drift similar to a classical particle .
the lorentz drift in the potential @xmath63 brings the electron to the infinite @xmath6 .
this happens , according to electrodynamics , as a result of multiple reflections from the `` wall '' @xmath64 @xcite . in that case wigner tunneling
does not occur since there are no discrete levels to the right of the barrier .
this situation corresponds to a decay of the metastable state in the @xmath19 well since after tunneling the electron goes to the infinite @xmath6 . whereas the potential @xmath9 strongly disturbs the motion at the classical region , the underbarrier motion along the direction @xmath65 is hardly violated since reflections from that potential under the barrier are less important .
it is shown in sec .
[ sec : masha ] .
for this reason , for an underbarrier motion in the full potential ( [ 2 ] ) one can use the approach , when the potential @xmath9 is dropped down .
accordingly , in the semiclassical approximation the tunneling rate is given by the wkb formula @xmath66,\ ] ] which follows from eq .
( [ 37 ] ) as @xmath67 . for zero magnetic field , @xmath68 , the tunneling rate ( [ 41 ] ) does not depend on @xmath27 and coincides with the conventional wkb expression ( [ 26b ] ) . for @xmath50 and @xmath34 the tunneling rate in fig .
[ fig2 ] drops down with the magnetic field , as usually , since the metastable state in the quantum wire has zero momentum ( [ 36d ] ) perpendicular to tunneling . for @xmath50 and @xmath69
such a momentum is finite resulting in cyclotron enhancement of tunneling . in fig .
[ fig2 ] we plot the tunneling rate for @xmath51 .
this value is chosen to have a link to numerical data discussed below .
for the potential ( [ 2 ] ) analytical solutions of the schrdinger equation ( [ 26a ] ) and the hamilton - jacobi equation ( [ 4 ] ) do not exist . nevertheless , to calculate a tunneling rate with the exponential accuracy it is not necessary to solve the hamilton - jacobi equation ( [ 4 ] ) in the full @xmath4 plane .
it is sufficient to track @xmath37 along a classical trajectory @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is imaginary time since an underbarrier classical motion is impossible .
the method of classical trajectories in imaginary time is well developed for static potential barrier with no magnetic field @xcite . in this case
the main contribution to a tunneling rate comes from the extreme path linking two classically allowed regions .
the real underbarrier path @xmath70 can be parametrized as a classical trajectory in imaginary time .
a situation with a magnetic field is substantially different .
for the potential ( [ 2 ] ) in a magnetic field the coordinate @xmath72 remains real in the underbarrier motion but @xmath73 becomes imaginary .
this means that the trajectory does not track the entire underbarrier path as for zero magnetic field .
it just provides a `` bypass '' through the plane of complex @xmath3 .
so the method of classical trajectories for tunneling in a magnetic field is nontrivial .
one should note that the same situation takes place for tunneling across nonstationary barriers where imaginary time stands instead of imaginary @xmath3 .
validity of the nontrivial trajectory method for the nonstationary barrier was numerically proved in ref .
the numerical results of the present paper support the trajectory method also for a static magnetic field .
we consider tunneling from the @xmath19 well ( @xmath74 ) to the classically allowed region ( @xmath75 ) .
the ratio of the densities @xmath76 can be identified with a tunneling rate . with the semiclassical accuracy , @xmath77 , where @xmath78\right)\ ] ] is the tunneling exponent .
the trajectory method allows to calculate the part @xmath79\ ] ] of the total action ( [ 14 ] ) only .
this part is expressed through the classical trajectory @xmath80.\end{aligned}\ ] ] see , for example , @xcite .
the expression in the square brackets is the lagrangian in terms of imaginary time .
the coordinates @xmath72 and @xmath81 in eq .
( [ 27 ] ) are solutions of the classical equations of motion @xmath82 with the conditions @xmath83 since the trajectory terminates at the @xmath19 well , this leads to the first condition ( [ 29 ] ) . the second condition ( [ 29 ] )
results from eq .
( [ 4a ] ) . the third condition ( [ 29 ] ) corresponds to the physical exit point @xmath65 .
the fourth condition ( [ 29 ] ) is a property of an exit point where the electrons stops to move in the tunneling direction .
note , that the physical velocity perpendicular to the tunneling direction at the exit point from under the barrier is not zero . in the dimensionless units
used it is @xmath84 a solution of eqs .
( [ 28 ] ) corresponds to the total energy @xmath85 the relation ( [ 19 ] ) is the fifth condition to the equations ( [ 28 ] ) which can be satisfied by a proper choice of @xmath86 .
the trajectory terminates at the unphysical ( complex ) point @xmath32 , @xmath87 .
one should connect this point with a physical one , for example , @xmath32 , @xmath65 .
in other words , one should add to @xmath88 the action @xmath89.\ ] ] to complete the tunneling exponent ( [ 14 ] ) .
one can find the action ( [ 20 ] ) by a direct solution of the hamilton - jacobi equation ( [ 4 ] ) .
since the condition ( [ 4a ] ) holds at all @xmath3 , it follows from ( [ 4 ] ) that @xmath90 the integration results in @xmath91 { \rm sgn}\left(\frac{\partial\eta}{\partial\tau}\bigg|_{\tau_{0}}\right),\ ] ] where @xmath92 the modified potential with the infinite wall at @xmath93 .
the discrete energy levels @xmath94 are associated with the @xmath19 well .
the levels @xmath95 are connected with the triangular well.,width=170 ] the sign term in eq .
( [ 35 ] ) accounts for a correct sign of the square root just to match the solution at the point @xmath32 , @xmath87 .
so the tunneling rate is given by @xmath96 where the parts of the total action are determined by eqs .
( [ 27 ] ) and ( [ 35 ] ) .
it is not difficult to check that , if to formally drop down the part @xmath9 in the potential ( [ 2 ] ) , the trajectory formalism ( [ 23 ] ) gives the same result ( [ 41 ] ) . for this purpose
one has to write down the explicit expression for the classical trajectory @xmath97 which follows from eqs .
( [ 28 ] ) , if to drop down the nonlinear part in @xmath98 .
the total underbarrier time is determined by the relation @xmath99 one should also put @xmath100 in eq .
( [ 35 ] ) . at the terminal time @xmath86 , as follows from eqs .
( [ 42 ] ) and ( [ 43 ] ) , @xmath101
for numerical studies of the problem we consider the schrdinger equation ( [ 26a ] ) at positive @xmath6 with the boundary condition ( [ 4b ] ) . since in numerical calculations
an infinite @xmath6 is impossible we modify the potential @xmath12 ( [ 2 ] ) adding the infinite potential wall at @xmath93 .
the wall is accounted for by the condition @xmath103 . in fig .
[ fig3 ] the modified potential @xmath104 is shown , where the electron is completely localized resulting in discrete eigenvalues of energy @xmath27 . in the @xmath19 well , due to the potential @xmath105 , there are discrete levels @xmath94 . with no @xmath9 potential
the set @xmath94 becomes continuous .
the levels associated with the triangular well are @xmath95 .
for the potential @xmath12 ( [ 2 ] ) an electron , initially localized at the @xmath19 well , can go to the infinite @xmath6 providing a decay of this metastable state during the typical time @xmath106 , where @xmath107 is the tunneling exponent ( [ 14 ] ) .
( color online ) decimal logarithm of the electron density at @xmath50 calculated by the method of sec .
[ sec : masha ] .
the dashed curve : zero magnetic field , @xmath68 .
the solid curve : the finite magnetic field , @xmath108 , and the eigenvalue at the wire @xmath109 .
the two dots mark the classical exit points calculated from eqs .
( [ 37 ] ) and ( [ 38]).,width=340 ] for a state , initially localized at the @xmath19 well of the potential @xmath110 , the same type of time @xmath106 is required to spread out to the triangular well when @xmath94 is not equal to @xmath95 , that is we are away from wigner resonances .
the ratio of steady wave functions at the triangular well and at the @xmath19 well is exponentially small .
if to avoid wigner resonances , it is determined by the same exponent as the tunneling decay rate for the case of an infinite @xmath111 .
this justifies the use of @xmath110 . when an energy level , occupied by the electron at the @xmath19 well , coincides with one at the triangular well the wigner resonant tunneling occurs .
in this situation the ratio ( [ 5 ] ) of steady wave functions at the triangular well and at the @xmath19 well is not exponentially small . nevertheless , the time to fill out the initially empty triangular
well still remains exponentially long , @xmath112 .
we numerically calculated @xmath113 for the potential @xmath110 using the discrete two - dimensional net in @xmath4 space .
a step was chosen from a condition of a better convergence .
the method used works well for hyperbolic system and does not result in unphysical exponents .
we started with the asymptotic @xmath114 at @xmath115 and chosen eigenvalues of @xmath27 from the condition of @xmath116 at @xmath65 .
in the calculations we put @xmath50 , @xmath117 , and @xmath118 .
the calculations are performed at the interval @xmath119 with the boundary condition ( [ 4b ] ) at @xmath32 . a distance between energy levels in fig .
[ fig3 ] can be estimated from the semiclassical approach @xcite as @xmath120 .
this is confirmed by the numerical calculations .
the results are figured out in fig .
[ fig4 ] .
( color online ) the three - dimensional plot of the decimal logarithm of the electron density for @xmath108 , @xmath51 , and @xmath50.,width=340 ] at zero magnetic field , @xmath68 , the variables are separated and @xmath121 is a solution of the effective schrdinger equation ( [ 36b ] ) with the potential ( [ 36c ] ) , where one has to add the wall at @xmath122 and formally put @xmath123 and @xmath124 . the wave function is shown in fig .
[ fig4 ] by the dashed curve . due to reflections from the wall at @xmath122 the wave function
oscillates at the interval @xmath125 . at the classical exit point
@xmath126 the wave function , calculated by eq .
( [ 37 ] ) , is marked by the dot on the dashed curve in fig .
[ fig4 ] where @xmath127 . at the finite magnetic field ,
@xmath108 , the numerically calculated wave function is plotted by the solid curve in fig .
the chosen eigenvalue @xmath51 is one of the discrete levels @xmath94 in fig .
the wave function is extended over the whole interval @xmath119 due to reflections from the potential @xmath9 and the wall at @xmath122 in the magnetic field .
a classical exit point @xmath128 and @xmath129 can be calculated on the basis of the trajectory method of sec .
[ sec : traj ] .
the results hardly differ from the case of sec .
[ sec : wkb ] when the potential @xmath9 was dropped down .
according to eq .
( [ 44 ] ) , @xmath130 which leads to the very small potential @xmath131 .
it is obvious and also can be shown that an influence of this potential on the classical trajectory is small .
we emphasize that in our case the potential @xmath9 hardly influences the underbarrier motion only .
after an exit from under the barrier the electron is strongly reflected by that potential .
( color online ) decimal logarithm of the maximal value of the wave function after an exit from under the barrier versus magnetic field @xmath22 .
the maxima relate to wigner resonances , @xmath132 .
a level in the wire from the interval @xmath133 is adjusted to the variable @xmath22 .
the dashed curve is @xmath134 from fig .
[ fig2 ] with @xmath51 for comparison .
it corresponds to the electron density after the barrier when @xmath135 ( no wigner resonances).,width=302 ] neglecting the part @xmath9 , one can easily perform trajectory calculations .
this results in the exit point ( [ 38 ] ) , @xmath136 , and the electron density @xmath137 marked as the dot on the solid curve in fig .
we see that the analytical and numerical results are close to each other for both zero and the finite magnetic fields .
the three - dimensional plot of @xmath138 is shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] . due to reflections from the potential @xmath9 and the wall at @xmath122 ,
the motion covers the whole region apart the barrier .
we also performed numerical calculations for the potential @xmath139 instead of @xmath9 just to be closer to a situation of an infinite restricting wall .
qualitatively , the wave function looks the same filling out the whole @xmath4 space to the right of the barrier . to get tunneling to the triangular well more adequate to tunneling to an infinite region
, we should avoid wigner resonances , as pointed out above . in fig .
[ fig6 ] the maximal value of @xmath140 after the exit point is plotted versus @xmath22 .
as one can see , the structure of wigner resonances is very pronounced .
a shape of the wave functions in the triangular well close to wigner peaks was checked .
we found no deviation from eigenfunctions at the triangular well , when the @xmath19 well at @xmath32 was absent .
this proves the wigner nature of the peaks in fig .
we choose @xmath108 to get away of the wigner resonances as clear from fig .
in sec . [ sec : masha ] we performed the numerical calculations at the interval @xmath119 using the boundary condition ( [ 4b ] ) at @xmath32 . in this section
we demonstrate the numerical formalism , which does not explore the boundary condition ( [ 4b ] ) .
the calculations are performed at the interval @xmath141 , where the potential @xmath110 is symmetrically continued from the region @xmath142 for negative @xmath6 .
the @xmath19 function is approximated by a narrow well of the width of one computational step . the same method to model a @xmath19 well was used in ref .
@xcite . for positive @xmath6 in the semiclassical approach ( a large @xmath35 ) the results for the symmetric potential chosen and for
the potential @xmath110 should be close to each other .
this is confirmed by the numerical calculations . in this section
we use a matrix formalism .
we start up with the schrdinger equation @xmath143\psi=\lambda\psi\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the conditions @xmath144 .
( [ 46 ] ) differs from the form ( [ 26a ] ) by the gauge .
the wave function can be written as the expansion @xmath145 where @xmath146 is a normalized eigenfunction of a harmonic oscillator , @xmath147 one can easily show that the functions @xmath148 satisfy the equations @xmath149f_{n}=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the matrices @xmath150 , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 are symmetric and @xmath153 the matrix @xmath151 ( @xmath152 ) is determined by the relation analogous to ( [ 50 ] ) but with the substitution @xmath154 ( @xmath155 ) .
the non - zero elements are @xmath156 @xmath157 @xmath158 and also @xmath159 , @xmath160 , @xmath161 , and @xmath162 obtained as symmetric combinations from ( [ 53 ] ) with the shifts of @xmath163 .
( color online ) decimal logarithm of the electron density at @xmath50 calculated by the method of sec .
[ sec : vania ] .
the dashed curve : zero magnetic field , @xmath68 .
the solid curve : the finite magnetic field , @xmath108 , and the eigenvalue of the wire state @xmath164 .
the two dots mark the classical exit points @xmath127 for @xmath68 and @xmath165 for @xmath108 calculated from eqs .
( [ 37 ] ) and ( [ 38]).,width=272 ] the above matrix formalism is used to numerically calculate the wave function ( [ 47 ] ) by a solution of the eigenvalue problem ( [ 49 ] ) .
the calculations were performed by means of the discretization of the interval @xmath141 using 513 points . to check the scheme we made additional runs for the interval @xmath166 with the equal number of discrete points .
the both methods resulted in the same eigenvalues and eigenfunctions .
in all the calculations we considered nine terms in the expansion ( [ 47 ] ) of the wave function .
the results are displayed in fig .
[ fig7 ] showing the states generic with ones in fig .
the difference in @xmath94 for the both figures is 0.008 which is substantially less than @xmath167 . comparing figs .
[ fig7 ] and [ fig4 ] , one can conclude that two different numerical methods lead to very similar results .
the numerical data of the both methods are also in a good agreement with the trajectory results shown by the dots in figs .
[ fig4 ] and [ fig7 ] .
a common point of view is that due to intrinsic underbarrier mechanisms a magnetic field always reduces a probability of tunneling decay of a metastable state . in other words
, it never chances to get tunneling rate enhanced by a magnetic field for many orders of magnitude .
this point of view is supported by a general arguments that in the classical electrodynamics a motion ahead is prevented by cyclotron rotation and the same happens in quantum mechanics .
the famous example is landau states .
the increased localization of a wave function in a magnetic field can also be explained by an additional potential , proportional to squared velocity , created by the magnetic field .
any hand waving explanation leads to a conclusion of tunneling reduction .
we propose a mechanism which contrasts to that point of view .
cyclotron enhancement of tunneling is clear for understanding .
it occurs due to a rotation under the barrier of a velocity vector of the electron . under the cyclotron rotation
it becomes more aligned with the tunneling direction , which increases the tunneling rate .
a necessary condition for the phenomenon is a finite velocity ( [ 36e ] ) in the decayed state of the quantum wire .
the velocity should be directed along the vector @xmath168 , which is parallel to the wire . in the case of the opposite direction the magnetic field
reduces the tunneling rate . for cyclotron enhancement of tunneling
it is important that a sample , from where tunneling occurs , should be extended in the direction perpendicular to tunneling .
the effect is absent in tunneling from a small quantum dot .
the scenario of decay of the metastable state in the magnetic field consists of two parts .
first , the electron moves under the barrier rotating its velocity . on this step ,
a role of reflections from the restricting walls is minor .
second , after exit from under the barrier the electron goes to infinity performing multiple reflections from the restricting walls .
the semiclassical approach used is confirmed by two different numerical methods .
a domain of parameters for the phenomenon can be roughly estimated from the condition that the lorentz force , caused by the velocity in the wire , is of the order of the potential force @xmath5 .
the parameter @xmath22 is @xmath169 since we are interested in @xmath170 and the semiclassical parameter @xmath35 is large , the landau splitting @xmath171 is always less then @xmath172 which defines a scale of the energy levels in the quantum wire . to be specific ,
let us consider different regimes of tunneling .
_ strong effect on tunneling _ ( @xmath173 ) .
we take @xmath174 and @xmath175 . then at zero magnetic field
the tunneling rate ( [ 41 ] ) is @xmath176 . at @xmath177 the tunneling rate ( [ 41 ] )
becomes @xmath178 .
the enhancement occurs under the condition @xmath179 . for reasonable values of the magnetic field , @xmath180 tesla ,
the quantum wire or the thing film should be `` soft '' in the sense of a not large @xmath181 ev . see refs .
@xcite . the exit point from under the barrier
is estimated as @xmath182 and the electric field is @xmath183 ev / cm .
_ weak effect on tunneling _ ( @xmath184 ) .
we take @xmath185 and @xmath175 . then at zero magnetic field
the tunneling rate ( [ 41 ] ) is @xmath186 . at @xmath184 the tunneling rate ( [ 41 ] )
becomes @xmath187 .
the enhancement occurs under the condition @xmath188 . for reasonable values of the magnetic field , @xmath180 tesla
, one can choose @xmath189 ev . the exit point from under the barrier is estimated as @xmath190 and the electric field is @xmath191 ev / cm .
one can conclude that an experimental observation of cyclotron enhancement of tunneling is possible .
an experimental arrangement can be a quantum wire embedded into a two - dimensional electron system .
the electric field is parallel to the two dimensional system and is perpendicular to the wire .
the magnetic field is perpendicular to the wire and to the electric field .
one can use a dielectric wall parallel to the tunneling direction just to get electrons moved away after tunneling along the wall due to multiple reflections from it in the magnetic field .
another way of an experimental observation is to use a thin film , with a quantized motion inside , perpendicular to the electric field .
a magnetic field can enhance a tunneling decay rate of a metastable state for many orders of magnitude .
this happens due to intrinsic underbarrier mechanisms of a cyclotron rotation of an electron velocity .
it becomes more aligned with the tunneling direction resulting in the enhancement of the tunneling rate .
the effect can be observed experimentally for tunneling from a quantum wire or a thing film across a barrier created by an applied electric field .
we thank s. v. iordanski for valuable discussions .
this work was partially supported by russian foundation for basic research and `` financiadora de estudos e projetos - finep '' and brazilian `` ministrio da cincia e tecnologia - mct '' . | a state of an electron in a quantum wire or a thin film becomes metastable , when a static electric field is applied perpendicular to the wire direction or the film surface .
the state decays via tunneling through the created potential barrier .
an additionally applied magnetic field , perpendicular to the electric field , can increase the tunneling decay rate for many orders of magnitude .
this happens , when the state in the wire or the film has a velocity perpendicular to the magnetic field .
according to the cyclotron effect , the velocity rotates under the barrier and becomes more aligned with the direction of tunneling .
this mechanism can be called cyclotron enhancement of tunneling . 1.0 cm |
measurements of @xmath4 in semileptonic decays , @xmath5 in @xmath0@xmath1 mixing , and @xmath6 from cp violation in @xmath2@xmath3 and @xmath0@xmath1 mixing have firmly established the existence of a cp - violating phase in the ckm matrix .
the present situation , often referred to as the `` standard analysis '' of the unitarity triangle , is summarized in figure [ fig : utfit ] .
three comments are in order concerning this analysis : 1 .
the measurements of cp asymmetries in kaon physics ( @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) and @xmath0@xmath1 mixing ( @xmath9 ) probe the imaginary part of @xmath10 and so establish cp violation in the top sector of the ckm matrix .
the standard model predicts that the imaginary part of @xmath10 is related , by three - generation unitarity , to the imaginary part of @xmath11 , and that those two elements are ( to an excellent approximation ) the only sources of cp violation in flavor - changing processes . in order to test this prediction
one must explore the phase @xmath12 in the bottom sector of the ckm matrix .
2 . with the exception of the @xmath9 measurement the standard analysis
is limited by large theoretical uncertainties , which dominate the widths of the various bands in the figure .
these uncertainties enter via the calculation of hadronic matrix elements . below i will discuss some novel methods to constrain the unitarity triangle using charmless hadronic @xmath0 decays , which are afflicted by smaller hadronic uncertainties and hence provide powerful new tests of the standard model , which can complement the standard analysis .
3 . with the exception of the measurement of @xmath4 the standard constraints are sensitive to meson antimeson mixing . mixing amplitudes are of second order in weak interactions and hence might be most susceptible to effects from physics beyond the standard model .
the new constraints on @xmath13 discussed below allow a construction of the unitarity triangle that is over - constrained and independent of @xmath0@xmath1 and @xmath2@xmath3 mixing .
it is in this sense complementary to the standard analysis .
the phase @xmath14 can be probed via tree
penguin interference in decays such as @xmath15 .
experiment shows that amplitude interference is sizable in these decays .
information about @xmath14 can be obtained from measurements of direct cp asymmetries ( @xmath16 ) , but also from the study of cp - averaged branching fractions ( @xmath17 ) .
the challenge is , of course , to gain theoretical control over the hadronic physics entering the tree - to - penguin ratios in the various decays .
recently , much progress has been made toward achieving that goal .
hadronic weak decays simplify greatly in the heavy - quark limit @xmath18 .
the underlying physics is that a fast - moving light meson produced by a point - like source ( the effective weak hamiltonian ) decouples from soft qcd interactions @xcite .
a systematic implementation of this color transparency argument is provided by the qcd factorization approach @xcite , which makes rigorous predictions for hadronic @xmath0-decay amplitudes in the heavy - quark limit .
one can hardly overemphasize the importance of controlling nonleptonic decay amplitudes in the heavy - quark limit . while a few years ago reliable calculations of such amplitudes appeared to be out of reach , we are now in a situation where hadronic uncertainties enter only at the level of power corrections suppressed by the heavy @xmath19-quark mass . in recent work , qcd factorization has been applied to the entire set of the 96 decays of @xmath0 and @xmath20 mesons into @xmath21 or @xmath22 final states ( @xmath23pseudoscalar meson , @xmath24vector meson ) @xcite . it has been demonstrated that the approach correctly reproduces the main features seen in the data , such as the magnitudes of the various tree and penguin amplitudes , and the fact that they have small relative strong - interaction phases . in the future , when more data become available , this will allow us to extract much useful information about the flavor sector of the standard model either from global fits or from analysis of certain classes of decay modes such as @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 .
detailed comparison with the data may also reveal limitations of the heavy - quark expansion in certain modes , perhaps hinting at the significance of some power corrections in @xmath28 .
despite of the success of qcd factorization in describing the data , there is an interest in analyzing ckm parameters using methods that rely as little as possible on an underlying theoretical framework . in this talk
i discuss a method for constructing the unitarity triangle from @xmath0 physics using measurements whose theoretical interpretation is `` clean '' in the sense that it only relies on assumptions that can be tested using experimental data .
i call this construction the cp-@xmath19 triangle , because it probes the existence of a cp - violating phase in the @xmath19 sector of the ckm matrix .
the cp-@xmath19 triangle is over - determined and can be constructed using already existing data .
most importantly , this construction is insensitive to potential new physics effects in @xmath0@xmath1 or @xmath2@xmath3 mixing .
the present analysis is an update of @xcite using the most recent data as of summer 2003 .
the first ingredient is the ratio @xmath29 extracted from semileptonic @xmath0 decays , whose current value is @xmath30 .
several strategies have been proposed to determine @xmath4 with an accuracy of about 10% @xcite , which would be a significant improvement .
the first plot in figure [ fig : cpt ] shows the corresponding constraint in the @xmath13 plane . here and below the narrow
, dark - colored band shows the theoretical uncertainty , while the lighter band gives the current experimental value .
the second ingredient is a constraint derived from the ratio of the cp - averaged branching fractions for the decays @xmath31 and @xmath32 , using a generalization of the method suggested in @xcite .
the experimental inputs to this analysis are a certain tree - to - penguin ratio @xmath33 and the ratio @xmath34 } = 0.804\pm 0.085\ ] ] of two cp - averaged @xmath25 branching fractions @xcite . without any recourse to qcd factorization
this method provides a bound on @xmath35 , which can be turned into a determination of @xmath35 ( for fixed value of @xmath36 ) when information on the relevant strong - interaction phase @xmath37 is available . the phase @xmath37 is bound by experimental data ( and very general theoretical arguments ) to be small , of order @xmath38 @xcite .
( in the future , this phase can be determined directly from the direct cp asymmetry in @xmath32 decays . )
it is thus conservative to assume that @xmath39 , corresponding to @xmath40 . with this assumption the corresponding allowed region in the @xmath13 plane
was analyzed in @xcite .
the resulting constraint is shown in the second plot in figure [ fig : cpt ] .
the third constraint comes from a measurement of the time - dependent cp asymmetry @xmath41 in @xmath42 decays .
the present experimental situation is still unclear , since the measurements by babar ( @xmath43 ) and belle ( @xmath44 ) are not in good agreement with each other @xcite .
the naive average of these results gives @xmath45 .
( inflating the error according to the pdg prescription would yield @xmath46 , but for some reason the experimenters usually use the naive error without rescaling , and i will follow their example . )
the theoretical expression for the asymmetry is @xmath47 here @xmath48 is the cp - violating phase of the @xmath49@xmath50 mixing amplitude , which in the standard model equals @xmath51 .
usually it is argued that for small @xmath52 ratio the quantity @xmath53 is approximately given by @xmath54 , and so apart from a `` penguin pollution '' the asymmetry @xmath55 . in order to become insensitive to possible new physics contributions to the mixing amplitude
i adopt a different strategy @xcite .
i use the measurement @xmath56 @xcite and write @xmath57 , with a sign ambiguity in the real part .
( the plus sign is suggested by the standard fit of the unitarity triangle . ) a measurement of @xmath58 can then be translated into a constraint on @xmath14 ( or @xmath59 and @xmath60 ) , which remains valid even if the @xmath61 measurement is affected by new physics .
the result obtained with the current experimental values and assuming @xmath62 is shown in the third plot in figure [ fig : cpt ] .
the resulting bands for @xmath63 are obtained by a reflection about the @xmath59 axis .
this follows because the expression for @xmath58 is invariant under the simultaneous replacements @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
each of the three constraints in figure [ fig : cpt ] are , at present , limited by rather large experimental errors , while comparison with figure [ fig : utfit ] shows that the theoretical limitations are smaller than for the standard analysis . yet , even at the present level of accuracy it is interesting to combine the three constraints and construct the resulting allowed regions for the apex of the unitarity triangle . the result is shown in the left - hand plot in figure [ fig : summary ] .
note that the lines corresponding to the new constraints intersect the circles representing the @xmath4 constraint at large angles , indicating that the three measurements used in the construction of the cp-@xmath19 triangle provide highly complementary information on @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
there are six ( partially overlapping ) allowed regions , three corresponding to @xmath62 ( dark shading ) and three to @xmath63 ( light shading ) .
if we use the information that the measured value of @xmath7 requires a positive value of @xmath60 , then only the solutions in the upper half - plane remain .
comparison with figure [ fig : utfit ] shows that one of these regions ( corresponding to @xmath62 ) is in perfect agreement with the standard fit .
this is highly nontrivial , since with the exception of @xmath4 none of the standard constraints are used in this construction .
interestingly , there is a second allowed region ( corresponding to @xmath63 ) which would be consistent with the constraint from @xmath7 but inconsistent with the constraints derived from @xmath9 and @xmath66 .
such a solution would require a significant new physics contribution to @xmath0@xmath1 mixing .
j. d. bjorken , nucl .
suppl . *
11 * , 325 ( 1989 ) .
h. d. politzer and m. b. wise , phys .
b * 257 * , 399 ( 1991 ) .
m. beneke , g. buchalla , m. neubert and c. t. sachrajda , phys .
rev . lett .
* 83 * , 1914 ( 1999 ) ; nucl .
b * 591 * , 313 ( 2000 ) .
m. beneke , g. buchalla , m. neubert and c. t. sachrajda , nucl .
b * 606 * , 245 ( 2001 ) .
m. beneke and m. neubert , nucl . phys .
b * 651 * , 225 ( 2003 ) ; preprint hep - ph/0308039 .
m. neubert , preprint hep - ph/0207327 .
m. neubert , phys . rev .
d * 49 * , 4623 ( 1994 ) ; phys .
b * 543 * , 269 ( 2002 ) .
r. d. dikeman and n. g. uraltsev , nucl .
b * 509 * , 378 ( 1998 ) ; + i. i. bigi , r. d. dikeman and n. uraltsev , eur .
j. c * 4 * , 453 ( 1998 ) .
a. f. falk , z. ligeti and m. b. wise , phys .
b * 406 * , 225 ( 1997 ) . c. w. bauer , z. ligeti and m. e. luke , phys .
b * 479 * , 395 ( 2000 ) ; phys .
d * 64 * , 113004 ( 2001 ) .
m. neubert , jhep * 0007 * , 022 ( 2000 ) ; + m. neubert and t. becher , phys .
b * 535 * , 127 ( 2002 ) .
m. neubert and j. l. rosner , phys .
b * 441 * , 403 ( 1998 ) ; phys .
lett . * 81 * , 5076 ( 1998 ) ; m. neubert , jhep * 9902 * , 014 ( 1999 ) .
i use the average of babar , belle , and cleo data as compiled in the second paper in @xcite . | the study of charmless hadronic two - body decays of @xmath0 mesons is one of the most fascinating topics in @xmath0 physics .
a construction of the unitarity triangle based on such decays is presented , which is independent of @xmath0@xmath1 and @xmath2@xmath3 mixing .
it provides stringent tests of the standard model with small theoretical uncertainties .
clns 03/1841 address = f.r .
newman laboratory for elementary - particle physics + cornell university , ithaca , ny 14853 , usa |
zebrafish ( danio rerio ) of the ab and ab / tl genetic background were maintained , raised and staged as previously described @xcite . for protein over - expression in germ cells ,
the mrna was injected into the yolk at one - cell stage .
capped sense rna was synthesized with the mmessage mmachine kit ( ambion , + http://www.ambion.com/index.html ) . to direct protein expression to pgcs , the corresponding open reading frames ( orfs )
were fused upstream to the 3utr of the nanos1 ( nos1 - 3utr ) gene , facilitating translation and stabilization of the rna in these cells @xcite . for global protein expression ,
the respective orfs were cloned into the psp64ts ector that contains the 5 and 3 utrs of the xenopus globin gene .
the injected rna amounts are as provided below .
the following constructs were used : * ypet - ypet - rascaax - nos-1 ( 240 pg . )
was used to label membrane in germ cells . * lifeact - pruby - nos-1 ( 240 pg . )
was used to label actin in germ cells . *
dn - rok - nos-1 ( 300 pg . ) was used to interfere with rok function in pgcs * aqp1a - nos-1 ( 300 pg . ) was used to over - express aquaporin-1a in pgcs * aqp3a - nos-1 ( 300 pg . ) was used to over - express aquaporin-3a in pgcs * aqp1a egfp - nos-1 ( 360 pg . ) was used to visualize the subcellular localization of aquaporin1a in pgcs * aqp3a egfp - nos-1 ( 300pg . ) was used to visualize the subcellular localization of aquaporin3a in pgcs the morpholinos for knocking down protein translation were obtained from genetools , llc http://www.gene - tools.com/. the following sequences were used : aquapoin1a : 5 aagccttgctcttcagctcgttcat3 ( injected at 400@xmath50 m ) ; aquaporin 3a : 5 acgcttttctgccaacccatctttc 3 ( injected at 400@xmath50m);. for the control , standard morpholino 5cctcttacctcagttacaatttata 3 was used .
time - lapse movies of blebbing cells in live zebrafish embryos were acquired with the zeiss lsm710 bi - photon microscope using one - photon mode . the 20x water - dipping objective with the numerical aperture 1.0 was used .
the bit depth used was 16 and the scanning speed ranged between 150 to 250 ms / frame for fast imaging of bleb formation .
images were preprocessed with fiji software to eliminate the background . the bleach correction tool ( embl )
was used to correct for the reduction in fluorescence intensity during prolonged time - lapse movies .
sequences of of image stacks were then processed using the 3d active meshes algorithm @xcite implemented in the icy software http://icy.bioimageanalysis.org/. the algorithm performs three - dimensional segmentation and tracking using a triangular mesh that is optimized using the original signal as a target . from the resulting three dimensional mesh one can then measure the cell volume its surface area .
three dimensional rendering of the meshes was done using paraview ( http://www.paraview.org/ ) .
statistical significance was evaluated using kolmogorov - smirnov tests implemented in custom made python codes . to confirm that the volume fluctuations observed in the zebrafish cells in vivo are real
, we have to exclude possible systematic errors induced by the three dimensional mesh reconstruction algorithm @xcite .
our experimental analysis shows smaller volume fluctuations for cells where the bleb formation has been suppressed ( dn - rok and aqp- mutants ) , with respect to wild type cells ( wt ) or those for which blebbing has been enhanced ( aqp+ ) .
in particular , as shown in fig .
1(a ) , wt and aqp+ cells display a more complex morphology when compared to dn - rok or aqp- , which appear instead to have a rounded shape .
hence , the first question to be answered is whether in presence of complex morphological shapes , the algorithm introduces a systematic bias in the measured cell volume .
in other words the question is : does the algorithm produce a larger error while calculating the volume of blebbing cells , with respect to those where blebs are absent ? to answer to this question we generate a set of synthetic ellipsoidal cells whose volume is in the range of the zebrafish cells analyzed in our experiments ( @xmath90 ) , as shown in fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs ] .
synthetic cells are generated through the imagej software ( http://imagej.nih.gov/ij/ ) by creating 3d stacks having the shape of ellipsoids with semi - axes @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
initially , we set the voxel size to @xmath93 along the three directions ( see fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs](a ) ) . the volume is then calculated both according to the formula @xmath94 and by counting the number of voxels belonging to the synthetic cell , @xmath95 . the relative error between the two estimates
is @xmath96 , so that we can safely consider the estimate @xmath95 as the real volume of the synthetic stacks generated .
the main sources of error in analyzing confocal image stacks stems from the anisotropic voxel . in our experiments
the resolution along the @xmath97 direction is @xmath98 , while it is @xmath93 in the xy plane . to reproduce the voxel anisotropy in the synthetic stacks , we select just one single xy plane every 6 composing the original z - stack .
a resulting typical cell is shown in fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs](b ) .
we then extract the mesh of this newly obtained stack ( see fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs](c ) ) and calculate the ensuing volume @xmath99 .
our set of synthetic cells consists of 35 ellipsoids of different semi - axes , for which we calculate the true volume @xmath95 reported in fig.[fig : volume_ellipsoids_comparison ] .
then , each ellipsoid is first processed by the anysotropic voxelization in the z direction , and subsequently analyzed by the 3d active mesh algorithm .
the volumes of the extracted meshes are reported in fig.[fig : volume_ellipsoids_comparison ] ( @xmath99 ) .
it is apparent that the algorithm systematically underestimates the volume by roughly @xmath100 .
we checked that is error is greatly reduced for isotropic voxels .
a constant systematic error is not worrying , since we are only interested in changes in volume and all the images have the same voxel anisotropy and therefore the same error . before addressing the fluctuations of this error , we focus on possible spurious changes in the measured volume induced by a change in shape .
for each of the synthetic ellipsoidal cells , we create a synthetic cell with the same volume but presenting 1 , 2 , or 3 blebs on the surface .
blebs are generated as spherical caps of different radii with centers placed randomly on the ellipsoid surface ( see fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs](d ) ) .
we then perform the same anysotropic voxelization of the original z - stack done for the plane ellipsoids ( see fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs](e ) ) . from this image
we extract the active mesh ( fig.[fig : synthetic_blebs](f ) ) and calculate its volume .
the volumes of the meshes of synthetic cells with blebs , @xmath101 , are displayed in fig.[fig : volume_ellipsoids_comparison ] .
one can only see a very small difference between the values of @xmath101 and @xmath99 , but they both appear underestimate the true value @xmath95 by about @xmath102 .
what is surprising , however , is that cells with blebs appear to approximate the real volume slightly better than cells without blebs . to confirm this
, we report in fig.[fig : volume - error - vss ] the relative volume fluctuations @xmath103 as a function of the measured mesh surface fluctuations @xmath104 .
if no errors were made by the algorithm in estimating the synthetic volumes one would expect @xmath105 since pair of cells were constructed with the same volume but different shapes .
if complex shape with blebs would lead to an overestimation of the volume with respect an ellipsoidal cell with no blebs , one would expect @xmath103 and @xmath104 to be positively correlated . to the contrary
, the linear regression of the data in fig.[fig : volume - error - vss ] shows a small but clear anti - correlation between volume and surface fluctuations .
this is in contrast with experimental results showing that changes in shape are positively correlated with changes in volume ( fig .
[ fig : vs_correlations ] ) .
hence , this result can not be considered an artefact of the measurement but a real feature of the cells .
the previous analysis clearly demonstrates that the volume fluctuations observed in our experiments do not depend on the shape of the cells , but the algorithm systematically underestimates the volume of both of about @xmath102 .
the next question is whether these systematic fluctuations are of the same order of magnitude as the observed ones .
are the fluctuations reported in fig .
1(b ) real or just an artefact introduced by the mesh reconstruction algorithm ?
this question is particularly compelling in the case of wt and aqp+ cells , since for dn - rok and aqp- cells we can accept that the volume might remain constant . to answer to this question
generate a set of 120 synthetic cells , 60 with blebs randomly placed and of different sizes , and 60 without blebs , each cell having its own real volume @xmath95 calculated with imagej .
we then process each synthetic cell according to the protocol previously outlined : anysotropic voxelization in the z direction and subsequent mesh analysis .
finally we calculate the fluctuations @xmath106 and its cumulative distribution @xmath107 . in fig.[fig : cumulative_fluctuation_ellipsoids_comparison_cell ] we compare @xmath107 with the corresponding cumulative distributions of wt , aqp+ , dn - rok and aqp- cells , once it has been shifted by the average systematic volume bias @xmath108 .
this figure shows that systematic errors made by icy in the estimation of the cell volume , are compatible with the observed volume fluctuations of dn - rok and aqp- cells , but not with those aqp+ and wt cells , which instead appear to be significantly larger .
we thus conclude that the difference in volume fluctuation between aqp+/wt cells and dn - rok / aqp- is not an artefact of the analysis . by performing numerical simulations
, we notice that a straightforward formulation of the method suffers from poor volume conservation .
this general drawback of the immersed boundary method has been already pointed out by many other authors in different contexts @xcite . to overcome this problem
we implement the method proposed in ref .
@xcite and enforce the incompressibility constraint on the discrete lagrangian grid in the weak sense : @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the outward unit normal to the membrane at the position @xmath54 and @xmath111 is a discrete measure of the arclength in the actual configuration at the position @xmath112 .
the above constraint is satisfied by adding a corrective term to the equation of motion @xmath113 , where @xmath114 satisfies the incompressibility constraint and @xmath115 is given by @xmath116 with this correction , we observe that the incompressibility constraint is satisfied and the cell volume is perfectly conserved .
aqp3 is expressed by pgcs . a pgc expressing egfp fusion of aquaporin-3a and an rfp - tagged membrane marker .
scale bar is 10@xmath50 m . ]
aquaporin knockdown and overexpression does not induce significant changes in the average cellular volume .
a similar result holds for the dn - rok mutant .
the results show the dispersion of the data , the average and the standard error .
statistical significance ( @xmath48 values ) is evaluated according to the kolmogorov - smirnov test . ]
two example of synthetic image stacks representing cells without ( a - c ) and with ( d - f ) blebs .
the original stacks of equal volume ( a and d ) , are first transformed removing a set of planes ( 1 every 6 ) to obtain an anisotropic voxel corresponding to the experimental resolution ( b and e ) , i.e. @xmath117 m in the x , y directions and @xmath118 m along z. the resulting stacks ( b and e ) are analyzed to obtain a three - dimensional mesh ( shown in c and f ) ] volume comparison of synthetic cells .
we compare the measured volumes of cells without blebs ( @xmath99 ) with those corresponding to cells with blebs ( @xmath101 ) and with the true volumes ( @xmath95 ) , which is the same for each pair of cells .
the results show a large constant systematic error @xmath102 , and small fluctuations for cells with and without blebs . ]
the relative difference in the measured volume for pairs of cells of the same true volume but different surface due to the presence or absence of blebs .
the data show fluctuations of @xmath119 and a small negative correlation between volume and surface changes . ]
the cumulative distribution of relative error fluctuations for the volume of a large number of synthetic cells with and without blebs compared with experimental measurements .
the cumulative distribution of synthetic cells is shifted by @xmath120 to allow a visual comparison with the experimental quantities .
@xmath121 corresponds the time averaged volume for aqp+ , aqp- , dn - rok and wt cells , whilst it is @xmath122 for synthetic cells .
volume fluctuations for wt and aqp+ cells are significantly larger than those observed in synthetic cells , whereas dn - rok and aqp- mutant cells volume fluctuations seem to be compatible with the systematic errors induced by the mesh algorithm . ]
volume and surface fluctuations are correlated .
principal component analysis of volume and surface relative values .
scatter plots for a ) wt , b ) dn - rok , c ) aqp+ and d ) aqp- are reported together with an ellipse with axis given by the two eigenvectors of the cross - correlation matrix , whose amplitude is reported in panel e ) and f ) for the largest and smaller axis .
the dashed line represents the expected result for the ideal case of the isotropic deformation of a sphere . ]
time evolution of the pressure drop across the membrane from numerical simulations.a representative example of the evolution of the pressure drop in numerical simulations shows that the average is very different from the maximum ( top ) .
furthermore , the standard deviation of the distribution fluctuates intermittently in time in correspondence to the blebbing activity ( bottom ) .
results are obtained for a permeability @xmath84 . ] a schematic representation of the bleb formation process .
a ) the cortex contracts squeezing water outside of the cell .
b ) the membrane buckles and the cortex - membrane interface fractures .
c ) the bleb expands as the interface fails and water flows inside the cell as the internal fluid pressure is relieved . ]
.results of statistical significance tests for validity of gaussian statistics for volume and surface fluctuations .
we report the p - values obtained from the kolmogorov - smirnov test .
a small p - value ( e.g. @xmath17 ) would imply that we can reject the hypothesis that the distribution is described by gaussian statistics . in the present case , the p - value is large indicating that a guassian distribution provides a good fit to the data . [
table : pvalue ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
* a representative example of the time evolution of a pgc in wt conditions .
the movie is obtained using an average intensity 3d projection in imagej . * a representative example of the time evolution of a pgc in dnrok conditions .
the movie is obtained using an average intensity 3d projection in imagej . * a representative example of the time evolution of a pgc in aqp- conditions .
the movie is obtained using an average intensity 3d projection in imagej . * a simulation of the computational model using a porous membrane .
the color represents fluid pressure ( see fig .
3a ) . * a simulation of the computational model using an impermeable .
the color represents fluid pressure ( see fig . | cells modify their volume in response to changes in osmotic pressure but it is usually assumed that other active shape variations do not involve significant volume fluctuations . here
we report experiments demonstrating that water transport in and out of the cell is needed for the formation of blebs , commonly observed protrusions in the plasma membrane driven by cortex contraction .
we develop and simulate a model of fluid mediated membrane - cortex deformations and show that a permeable membrane is necessary for bleb formation which is otherwise impaired . taken together
our experimental and theoretical results emphasize the subtle balance between hydrodynamics and elasticity in actively driven cell morphological changes .
cells can change their shape to explore their environment , communicate with other cells and self - propel .
these macroscopic changes are driven by the coordinated action of localized motors transforming chemical energy into motion .
active processes in biological systems can be linked to a large variety of collective non - equilibrium phenomena such as phase - transitions , unconventional fluctuations , oscillations and pattern formation @xcite .
a vivid example of actively driven non - equilibrium shape fluctuations is provided by cellular blebs , the rounded membrane protrusions formed by the separation of the plasma membrane from the cortex as a result of acto - myosin contraction @xcite .
blebs occur in various physiological conditions @xcite , as for instance during zebrafish embryogenesis @xcite , or cancer invasion @xcite .
while some questions concerning the mechanisms governing bleb formation and its relation to migration have been resolved @xcite , key aspects of bleb mechanics remain unclear .
geometrical constraints dictate that active shape changes associated with blebs should necessarily involve either fluctuations in the membrane surface or in cellular volume , and possibly both .
it is generally believed , however , that the cellular volume is not significantly altered during bleb formation , so that the cell is usually considered incompressible @xcite . yet ,
experimental evidence in vitro suggests that aquaporins ( aqps ) , a family of transmembrane water channel proteins @xcite , are involved in cell migration @xcite and blebbing @xcite .
the implied significance of fluid transport through the membrane suggests that an interplay between hydrodynamic flow and active mechanics has an important but still unclear role in blebbing . in this letter
, we reveal the role of the membrane permeability in the formation , expansion and retraction of cellular blebs .
we show by direct experiments in vivo and numerical simulations that bleb formation involves volume fluctuations , considerable water flow through the membrane , and relatively smaller surface fluctuations . _
experiment : _ one of the limitations impeding the experimental studies of the bleb dynamics is the lack of proper tools to generate high - resolution spatial - temporal data of bleb dynamics .
this is due to the fact that the time scale of bleb formation is relatively short ( about 1 minute starting from initiation of the bleb to its retraction ) , which requires fast imaging and photostable markers . here
, we create an improved membrane marker @xcite which we inject in one - cell stage zebrafish embryos ( see supplemental material for experimental methods @xcite ) .
together with wild type ( wt ) zebrafish pgcs , a well studied biological model to investigate blebbing in vivo @xcite , we also consider cells expressing dominant - negative rho kinase mutant ( dn - rok ) which inhibits acto - myosin contractility suppressing blebbing activity @xcite .
zebrafish expresses a large number aqps contributing to the water permeability of the membrane @xcite .
here we focus on aqp1 and aqp3 , the most ubiquitously expressed aquaporins @xcite . to asses their role in volume change and blebbing , we consider pgcs with aqp1 and aqp3 overexpression ( aqp+ ) and knockdown ( aqp- ) .
the imaging of blebbing is done during 12 - 16 hours post fertilization , when we record time - series of confocal images for a large number of cells .
sequences of image stacks are then processed using the 3d active meshes algorithm implemented in the icy software @xcite .
the algorithm performs three - dimensional segmentation and tracking using a triangular mesh that is optimized using the original signal as a target . from the resulting three dimensional mesh one
can then measure the cell volume and its surface area ( see also @xcite ) . in fig .
[ fig : volume - surface]a , we illustrate representative phenotypes of pgcs under different conditions ( see also the corresponding movies @xcite ) .
these observation show that wt cells display a marked blebbing activity that , as expected , is strongly suppressed when active contraction is hindered , as in dn - rok cells @xcite .
remarkably , we also observe a strong reduction in bleb activity in aqp- cells , where water flow is hindered .
in contrast , water flow enhances blebbing as manifested by the presence of larger blebs in the aqp+ condition . to quantify these qualitative observations , we measure the cell volume @xmath0 and its surface @xmath1 sampling the results over a large number of time - frames taken on different cells . to account for cell - to - cell variability
, we consider relative volumes @xmath2 and surfaces @xmath3 changes , where @xmath4 ( @xmath5 ) is the time - averaged volume ( surface ) of each cell .
the average value of the volume @xmath0 does not change significantly for the four cases @xcite .
( color online ) volume and surface fluctuations during blebbing are controlled by aqps .
a ) representative phenotypes for bleb formation in pgcs under different conditions : wild type ( wt ) , cells expressing dn - rok mutant which impairs contractility by interfering with acto - myosin contraction ( dn - rok ) , cells where aqp1a and 3a is suppressed ( aqp- ) , cells with over - expression of aqp1a/3a ( aqp+ ) .
the scale bar corresponds to @xmath6 .
the cumulative distribution of relative volume ( b ) and surface ( c ) fluctuations for the four conditions illustrated in a ) together with a gaussian fit ( dashed lines ) .
the distributions are sampled over @xmath7 different time - frames corresponding to @xmath8 different cells .
( wt : @xmath9 cells and @xmath10 time - frames ; dn - rok : @xmath11 and @xmath12 , aqp- : @xmath13 and @xmath14 ; aqp+ : @xmath15 and @xmath16 ) . ] in fig .
[ fig : volume - surface]b , we report the cumulative distribution of relative volume changes which indicates significant fluctuations , reaching up to 10% , in the wt case .
volume fluctuations are strongly reduced for the dn - rok and aqp- cases , while they are enhanced in the aqp+ case .
the relative volume and surface distributions themselves are well described by gaussian statistics , as also confirmed by a kolmogorov - smirnov test @xcite .
a statistical test also indicates that the differences between wt and both aqp- and dn - rok are significant ( @xmath17 ) , but the differences between wt and aqp+ and between aqp- and dn - rok are not @xcite .
relative surface fluctuations are small that volume fluctuations in the wt case and are further reduced for dn - rok and aqp- and slightly increased for aqp+ ( see fig .
[ fig : volume - surface]c ) .
we also checked that relative surface and volume fluctuations are correlated @xcite , suggesting a direct link between blebbing activity and volume fluctuations induced by water transport . suppressing water flow
has the same effect as suppressing active contraction , in both cases blebs are hindered .
furthermore , the volume fluctuations we observe follow closely bleb expansion and retraction as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : volume - bleb - time ] .
expansion of a bleb correspond to a visible volume increase while when a bleb retracts the volume decreases .
here we concentrate on aqp+ pgc since the blebs are distinctly visible and the analysis clearer , but the same result holds for wt cells where , however , several blebs may form and retract simultaneously .
( color online ) bleb formation is directly related to volume changes .
a ) time lapse of a single aqp+ cell .
two dimensional sections are shown in the upper panels and the corresponding reconstructed three - dimensional meshes in the lower ones .
arrows indicate blebs .
the scale bar corresponds to @xmath6 .
b ) evolution of the volume for the same cell .
time points corresponding to the panels in a ) are denoted in yellow .
an increase in volume is observed in correspondence with each newly formed bleb . ]
_ model : _ in order to better understand the physical role of water flow in bleb formation , we resort to numerical simulations of a two - dimensional model of the biomechanics of cortex - membrane deformations including fluid transport through the plasma membrane .
several existing computational models for cellular blebs simulate the detachment and expansion of the membrane due to the active contraction of the cortex , assuming cell volume conservation @xcite . here , we relax this assumption by introducing and varying the membrane permeability @xmath18 @xcite in a model based on the immersed boundary method @xcite in the stokes approximation @xcite , considering a contracting discretized elastic cortex coupled to an elastic membrane .
we describe both the membrane and the cortex by a set of discrete nodes connected by springs on one dimensional closed curves parametrized by their initial arc length @xmath19 with @xmath20 $ ] . using lagrangian coordinates , the position of node @xmath21
is denoted by @xmath22 ( for the membrane ) and @xmath23 ( for the cortex ) .
initial positions are chosen to be @xmath24 and @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the membrane and cortex radii , respectively .
the interactions between the nodes on their respective curves include nearest - neighbor ( nn ) and three - body interaction terms to account for stretching and bending energies .
we also model the cortex - membrane interface by a set of springs with random stiffness @xmath28 @xmath29 , drawn from a uniform distribution .
disorder in the stiffness represents at a coarse - grained scale the random arrangement of cortex - membrane linker proteins .
the energy of the system can be decomposed as @xmath30 .
the first two terms are given by @xmath31 \\
\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where x corresponds to either membrane ( m ) or cortex ( c ) , @xmath32 is the distance between node @xmath21 and @xmath33 , @xmath34 is the equilibrium distance between nn nodes , @xmath35 ( n / m ) is the stiffness coefficient , @xmath36 ( j ) is the bending coefficient , @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the angles between the triplets @xmath39 in deformed and equilibrium configurations , respectively .
the interaction energy is given by @xmath40 , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the distances between the membrane and cortex node with the same index @xmath21 in the deformed and equilibrium configurations .
a non - vanishing rest length @xmath43 for the cortex element is needed to prevent that the cortex collapses under hydrostatic forces and represents a convenient method @xcite to account for osmotic regulation present in cells @xcite .
cortex elements are assumed to follow over - damped dynamics @xmath44 , where @xmath45 @xmath46 is the cortical drag coefficient .
we first consider an impermeable elastic membrane that moves with the fluid velocity satisfying a no - slip boundary condition .
the fluid velocity @xmath47 and the pressure @xmath48 satisfy stokes equation with the incompressibility constraint @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the fluid viscosity and @xmath51 is the body force per unit volume @xmath52 that can be calculated by spreading the force density @xmath53 from solid ( lagrangian @xmath54 ) to fluid ( euler @xmath55 ) coordinates as @xmath56 , where @xmath57 and @xmath58 is the two dimensional discretized delta function .
eq .
( [ eq : velocity ] ) is solved using the regularized stokeslet method @xcite as in ref .
@xcite . after the velocity has been calculated in euler
coordinates , we evolve the membrane nodes as @xmath59 .
we take special care to correct @xmath60 to enforce volume conservation , a common problem of the immersed boundary method @xcite .
cortex contraction and healing are the main driving forces of the blebbing activity . in our model ,
we assume that the cortex is pre - stretched which we impose by choosing a value for the equilibrium distance between the nodes @xmath43 that is smaller than their initial distances .
bleb nucleation in our model occurs stochastically due to the randomness of the stiffness of the bonds representing the membrane - cortex interface .
local detachment is then implemented by setting to zero the bond stiffness @xmath28 if its stretching @xmath41 is above a threshold that we set at @xmath61 .
finally , to implement interface healing , we assume that each cortex node @xmath21 , associated to a removed interface bond , moves towards the membrane with velocity @xmath62 until it attaches again when @xmath63 @xcite .
when disconnected nodes become connected again , we assign new random values to the stiffness @xmath28 of the bond .
we observe that the strength of disorder ( i.e. the wideness of its distribution ) controls bleb nucleation which in turn may cause the presence of a large number of blebs , occurring simultaneously . as in previous models
@xcite , we neglect additional time - dependent effects due to viscoelasticity and actin turnover in the cortex @xcite .
we introduce permeability into the model by following ref .
@xcite .
we assume darcy law and impose a porous slip velocity normal to the membrane given by @xmath64}{a},\ ] ] where @xmath65 is permeability , @xmath50 is the viscosity , @xmath66 is membrane thickness and @xmath67 $ ] is the pressure jump . using the normal stress jump condition @xmath67= \nicefrac{\mathbf { \mathbf f}\cdot \mathbf n } { \delta s(\mathbf r_{\mathrm{m}_{k}})}$ ]
, the porous velocity @xmath68 reads @xmath69 where @xmath70 @xmath71 and @xmath72 is the force on the node .
finally , we reach the equation used in the simulations @xmath73 . _
simulations : _ to simulate the model , we assume a square fluid domain that we discretize using a square grid with a discretization step @xmath74 and @xmath75 , where @xmath76 is the length of the domain in each direction and @xmath77 is the number of eulerian coordinates .
the fluid domain covers both the inside and outside of the membrane and has an area of @xmath78 @xmath79 .
the discretization steps @xmath80 and @xmath81 are of size @xmath82 @xmath83 .
( color online ) numerical simulations show that membrane porosity is needed for blebbing .
a ) a series of snapshots of the numerical simulations of bleb formation and retraction .
the color represents the local fluid pressure : red for positive and blue for negative pressures while the cell membrane is green .
a ) results obtained with physiological permeability : @xmath84 .
b ) for @xmath85 , bleb formation is impaired .
c ) the cumulative distribution of relative area fluctuations for different permeabilities .
d ) the standard deviation of the distribution of relative cell areas as a function of permeability . the physiological range is depicted in grey . ]
the membrane permeability in zebrafish embryos has been measured experimentally and is reported to be in the range @xmath86 depending on the developmental stage @xcite . here , we perform numerical simulations under different values of @xmath18 , ranging from @xmath85 to @xmath87 , to account for aqp overexpression and knockdown ( see table s1 for a complete list of parameters ) . when @xmath18 is in the physiological range , we observe realistic bleb formation and retraction ( fig . [
fig : simulations]a and movie s5 ) .
when we delete membrane permeability , setting @xmath85 and enforcing strict cell volume conservation , bleb activity is suppressed ( fig .
[ fig : simulations]b and movie s6 ) .
we can relate the simulations to the experimental results by noticing that the cell area @xmath88 , the two dimensional analogue of the three dimensional cell volume @xmath0 , fluctuates more or less when the permeability is increased or reduced ( fig .
[ fig : simulations]cd ) , in correspondence with aqps over - expression or knock - down , respectively @xcite .
both experiments and simulations suggest that blebs occur as long as the fluid is able to flow sufficiently fast through the membrane .
( color online ) a ) spatio - temporal evolution of the pressure jump across the membrane computed from the normal stress jump condition in numerical simulations with @xmath84 .
the pressure drop is strongly enhanced in localized regions corresponding to blebs .
b ) the corresponding distribution of pressure jumps displays long tails . ]
_ discussion : _ our model allows us to better understand why volume fluctuations are crucial for blebbing .
acto - myosin driven cortex contraction leads to a shrinkage of the cell by squeezing some water outside .
indeed the fluid pressure inside the cell is initially larger than the one outside ( see fig . [
fig : simulations]a ) .
the contraction of the cortex induces stretching in the membrane - cortex linkers leading the membrane to buckle @xcite .
buckling provides an effective way for membranes to avoid considerable elastic compression and is associated with a structural softening of the system @xcite .
furthermore , it allows to generate large membrane deflections needed to form a bleb . in differentiated cells
additional membrane surface can be obtained by disassembling caveolae @xcite , but this can not happen in pgcs where caveolin is not expressed . when the interface fractures , the mechanical stress on the detached part of the membrane decreases , but it increases on the interface that is still attached , inducing crack propagation . as the bleb expands , the fluid pressure inside the cell is reduced ( see fig .
[ fig : simulations]a ) leading to an inflow of water . in fig .
[ fig : drop]a , we display the spatio - temporal evolution of the pressure jump across the membrane , showing large fluctuations in correspondence to bleb formation @xcite .
these pressure spikes , whose distribution is long - tailed ( fig .
[ fig : drop]b ) , are a manifestation of the stress concentrations around cracks and are needed to account for the observed volume fluctuations , because otherwise the average pressure jump generated by a uniform cortex contraction ( around @xmath89 pa ) would not displace sufficient amount of fluid during the short lifetime of a bleb @xcite .
healing of the membrane - cortex interface eventually leads to bleb retraction and to an increased fluid pressure inside the cell .
the mechanism described above does not work for an impermeable membrane : isochoric buckling is possible in principle but , in addition to bending , it necessarily causes considerable stretching which is energetically expensive @xcite .
thus , when the interface fractures the bleb does not form and interface delamination takes place without localized membrane expansion .
our numerical results show that volume fluctuations during blebbing are due to mechanically induced highly non - uniform pressure drops across the membrane .
the same mechanism could also explain the experimental observation that blebs are nucleated preferentially in regions of negative membrane curvature @xcite .
changes in osmotic pressure gradients could also contribute to the process , as suggested previously @xcite , but are not explicitly included in our model .
future experimental work will clarify if this and other assumptions present in our model are correct , but our results should stimulate both new experiments and the development of more elaborate theories and models .
this would also allow to better understand the role of transmembrane water transport for other cellular protrusions , given that past experimental results relate the presence of aquaporins to the formation of lamellipodia @xcite and filopodia @xcite .
the present methodology provides the basis for a physical explanation of this broad class of phenomena .
we thank a. dufour , a. l. sellerio and d. vilone for useful discussions .
a. t. , o. u. s. , and s. z. are supported by the european research council through the advanced grant no .
291002 sizeffects
. s. z. acknowledges support from the academy of finland fidipro progam , project no .
13282993 .
c. a. m. l. p. acknowledges financial support from miur through prin 2010 .
e. k. acknowledges the support of a febs long - term postdoctoral fellowship while writing this manuscript .
a. taloni , e. kardash and o. u. salman contributed equally to this paper .
43 natexlab#1#1bibnamefont # 1#1bibfnamefont # 1#1citenamefont # 1#1url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2]#2 [ 2][]#2 , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , ,
* * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) .
see supplemental material for detailed experimental methods , image processing methodology , supplemental figures with experimental and numerical data , animations of experiments and simulations .
, , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , ,
, * * , ( ) . , ph.d .
thesis , ( ) .
, , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , _ _ ( , , ) .
, , , , , * * , ( ) . , , , ,
* * , ( ) . |
plasma - carbon interaction yields small hydrocarbon molecules on divertor region of a nuclear fusion device@xcite . diffusing from divertor region to core plasma region of fusion device ,
generated hydrocarbon takes energy from the core plasma .
reduction of hydrocarbon diffusing from divertor is the main aim of studies in plasma - carbon research . to achieve the aim ,
researches with computer simulation have been being done@xcite .
however , the creation mechanism of the hydrocarbons has not been elucidated yet .
we , therefore , as the first step to clarify the creation mechanism , investigated , by computer simulation , collision process of hydrogen atoms and one graphene sheet , which is regarded as one of basic processes of complex plasma - carbon interaction in the previous works@xcite . from the previous works in which an incident hydrogen kinetic energy @xmath2 is less than 100 ev to compare with experiments , it was found that an hydrogen - absorption ratio of one graphene sheet depends on the incident hydrogen energy , and that the collision mechanism between a graphene and a hydrogen can be classified into three types of processes : absorption process , reflection process , and penetration process ( see fig . [ fig:2](a ) ) .
moreover , it was also found that when hydrogen atom is absorbed by graphene , the nearest carbon atom overhangs from the graphene which we called overhang structure " .
based on the above results , as the second step , simulation model were extended@xcite from a single graphene sheet to multilayer graphene sheets , which is a more realistic sputtering process of graphene sheets and hydrogen atoms than the previous work@xcite . from the second work@xcite , we found the following fact : breaking the covalent bonds between carbon atoms by hydrogen does not play an important role during destruction process of graphene structure , but momentum transfer from incident hydrogen to graphene causes to destroy graphene structure .
moreover , it was found@xcite , that almost all fragments of graphene sheets form chain - shaped molecules , and that yielded hydrocarbon molecules are composed of carbon chain and single hydrogen - atom .
in the present paper , we investigate hydrogen isotope effect for collision process of a single hydrogen isotope and one graphene sheet .
information of dependence of the chemical reaction on a type of isotope is necessary to realize plasma confinement nuclear fusion system . in the present simulation ,
we change only the mass of the injected isotope , without changing the interaction potential .
we used ` classical ' molecular dynamics ( cmd ) algorithm with modified brenner s reactive empirical bond order ( rebo ) potential which we proposed to deal with chemical reaction between hydrogen and graphene in the previous simulations@xcite .
a ) b ) + c )
we adapt cmd simulation with the _ nve _ condition , in which the number of particles , volume and total energy are conserved .
the second order symplectic integration@xcite is used to solve the time evolution of the equation of motion .
the time step is @xmath3 .
the modified brenner s reactive empirical bond order ( rebo ) potential@xcite has the following form : @xmath4}^\mathrm{r } ( r_{ij } ) - \bar{b}_{ij}(\{r\},\{\theta^\mathrm{b}\},\{\theta^\mathrm{dh}\ } ) v_{[ij]}^\mathrm{a}(r_{ij } ) \right ] } , \nonumber \\
\label{eq : model_rebo}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath5 is the distance between the @xmath6-th and the @xmath7-th atoms .
the functions @xmath8}^{\mathrm{r}}$ ] and @xmath8}^{\mathrm{a}}$ ] represent repulsion and attraction , respectively .
the function @xmath9 generates multi body force .
( see details of the modified brenner s rebo potential in ref.@xcite . ) in order to investigate the difference of the isotopes , i.e. , hydrogen ( h ) , deuterium ( d ) or tritium ( t ) , we clarify the mass dependence of the injected isotope .
the value of the mass for h , d , or t is shown in table [ tab:4 ] .
the potential function is not changed for each isotope .
simulation model is shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] .
we inject the hydrogen isotope into the graphene composed of 160 carbon atoms .
the center of mass of the graphene is set to the origin of coordinates .
the surface of the graphene is parallel to the @xmath10@xmath11 plane .
the size of the graphene is 2.13 nm @xmath12 1.97 nm .
the graphene has no lattice defects and no crystal edges due to periodic boundary condition toward @xmath10 and @xmath11 directions .
the structure of the graphene is used to the ideal lattice of graphene .
each velocity of carbon atoms of the graphene is zero in the initial state , that is , the initial temperature of the graphene is set to zero kelvin .
the hydrogen isotope is injected parallel to the @xmath1 axis from @xmath13 .
we repeat 200 simulations where the @xmath10 and @xmath11 coordinates of injection points are set at random . as a result ,
we obtain three chemical reaction ratios for h , d , or t by counting each a reaction .
we observed three kinds of reactions between the single hydrogen isotope atom and the graphene by cmd simulation , which are absorption reaction , reflection reaction and penetration reaction ( see fig . [ fig:2 ] ) .
we found the following differences of the reflection and the absorption ratios among three isotopes . on the other hand ,
the penetration ratio has almost the same @xmath14 dependence . from the previous work@xcite
, it was found that two kinds of repulsive force work between the incident atom and the graphene .
one is derived by the @xmath0electron over the graphene and the other is done by nuclear of carbon . as the result of the present simulation , the @xmath14 dependence has the following properties . in the case of @xmath15 ,
the reflection ratio is almost one for all isotopes .
this behavior is explained by the fact that the reflection in this energy region is derived by the repulsive force of @xmath0electrons over graphene surface@xcite , which does not depend on the mass of the incident isotope .
as @xmath14 is getting larger than 0.5 ev , the reflection ratios are decreasing , and then it is increasing by the nuclear repulsive force of the carbon atom .
around @xmath16 ev , they have the peak ( see figs . [ fig:2 ] and
[ fig : ref ] ) .
then , without the mass dependence , they decrease again and approach to zero ( fig .
[ fig : ref ] ) , because the penetration reaction appears in the energy region that @xmath17 the details of the penetration reaction will appear in [ sec.pene ] . by comparison with three isotopes , it is found that the peak energy of the reflection ratio becomes larger as the mass is getting larger , but the peak height becomes smaller ( see fig .
[ fig : ref ] ) .
this behavior can be explained by the reflection mechanism in the previous work@xcite , where the incident energy @xmath14 has the following necessary condition for the reflection reaction by the nuclear of carbon : @xmath18 } , \label{eq.ref}\ ] ] where the isotope mass @xmath19 dependence is modified from the previous equation@xcite in order to cover three isotopes .
the hydrogen mass @xmath20 is 1.00794 u , and the carbon mass @xmath21 is 12.00000 u. the value of @xmath22 is given in table [ tab:4 ] and fig .
[ fig : ref ] for all isotopes . from eq .
( [ eq.ref ] ) or table [ tab:4 ] , it is found that , as the mass of the incident atom becomes larger , it needs higher incident energy for the isotope to be reflected by the graphene .
the reflection reaction by the nuclear repulsion occurs at @xmath23 , and then it increases monotonically until the penetration reaction becomes dominant among three reactions , as shown in fig .
[ fig : ref ] therefore , in the case that the starting energy of the reflection reaction by the nuclear @xmath24 is smaller , the reflection ratio can reach a higher value at the peak energy . according to the above mechanism
, the peak energy of the reflection ratio becomes larger and the peak height becomes smaller , as the mass of the isotopes is getting heavier , as shown in fig .
[ fig : ref ] .
the absorption ratio has two peaks at @xmath25ev and 24 ev .
one peak denotes the overhang state in the positive @xmath1 side of the graphite , and the other peak is the overhang state in the negative @xmath1 side@xcite . from fig .
[ fig:2 ] , the height of the second peak , which is near 24 ev , becomes smaller , as the mass of the incident isotope is increasing . on the other hand
, the first peak of the absorption ratio , which is around 5 ev , becomes large .
the origin of the mass dependence of the absorption ratio is the same one as that of the reflection ratio in [ sec.ref ] . the velocity becomes slower as the mass becomes large .
therefore , it becomes easier for the graphene to trap the isotope in the positive @xmath1 side . from fig .
[ fig:2 ] , it is found that the penetration ratio does not depend on the mass of the incident isotope , i.e. , h , d and t. the incident atom must overcome the graphene potential to penetrate the graphene sheet . the graphene potential does not depend on the mass of the incident atom .
therefore , the penetration ratio does not depend on the mass of the isotope .
we reveal the hydrogen isotope effect of three chemical reactions , i.e , the reflection , the absorption and the penetration reactions , by cmd simulation with the modified brenner s rebo potential . from the previous work@xcite ,
the reflection process is divided into two processes , that is , reflection by @xmath0electron and by nuclear . in the present work
, we find that the reflection by @xmath0electron does not depend on the mass of the incident isotope , but the peak of the reflection by nuclear moves to higher side of @xmath14 .
in addition to the reflection , we also find that the absorption ratio in the positive @xmath1 side of the graphene becomes larger , as the mass of the incident isotope becomes larger . on the other hand ,
the absorption ratio in the negative @xmath1 side of the graphene becomes smaller .
last , it is found that the penetration ratio does not depend on the mass of the incident isotope because the graphene potential is not affected by the mass .
dependence of the reflection ratio by the nuclear repulsion .
filled circles , filled squares , and filled triangles denote the reflection ratios for hydrogen , deuterium and tritium , respectively .
these plotted data are picked up from fig .
[ fig:2 ] .
the estimated minimum nuclear - reflection - energies @xmath26 and @xmath27 are given in table [ tab:4 ] .
dashed line , solid line and dash - dotted line are drawn as the guide for eyes . ]
dependence of the reflection ratio by the nuclear repulsion .
filled circles , filled squares , and filled triangles denote the reflection ratios for hydrogen , deuterium and tritium , respectively .
these plotted data are picked up from fig .
[ fig:2 ] .
the estimated minimum nuclear - reflection - energies @xmath26 and @xmath27 are given in table [ tab:4 ] .
dashed line , solid line and dash - dotted line are drawn as the guide for eyes . ]
.the mass and the reflection threshold energy by nulcear repulsive force @xmath28 for hydrogen , deuterium and tritium .
the reflection threshold energy @xmath28 depends on the mass of the isotope as eq .
( [ eq.ref ] ) .
we use the unified atomic mass u as the unit of mass . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the authors acknowledge dr .
noriyasu ohno for helpful comments .
numerical simulations are carried out by use of the plasma simulator at national institute for fusion science .
the work is supported partly by grand - in aid for exploratory research ( c ) , 2006 , no .
17540384 from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology and partly by the national institutes of natural sciences undertaking for forming bases for interdisciplinary and international research through cooperation across fields of study , and collaborative research programs ( no .
nifs06kdat012 , no .
nifs06ktat029 , no .
nifs07usnn002 and no .
nifs07kein0091 ) . 10 t. nakano , h. kubo , s. higashijima , n. asakura , h. takenaga , t. sugie , and k. itami , nucl .
fusion * 42 * , 689 ( 2002 ) .
j. roth , j. nucl .
mater . * 51 * , 266269 ( 1999 ) .
j. roth et al .
fusion * 44 * , l21 ( 2004 ) .
b. v. mech , a. a. haasz , and j. w. davis , j. nucl . mater .
* 1147 * , 241243(1997 ) .
a. sagara et al .
( lhd experimental group ) , j. nucl .
* 1 * , 313316(2003 ) .
d.a . alman and d.n .
ruzic , j. nucl . mater . *
313316 * , 182186 ( 2002 ) . a. ito and h. nakamura , j. plasma phys . * 72 * , 805808 ( 2006 ) .
a. ito and h. nakamura , submitted to j. nucl .
mater . ; e - print cond - mat/0703377 .
h. nakamura and a. ito , mol .
* 33 * , 121126 ( 2007 ) .
d. w. brenner , o. a. shenderova , j. a. harrison , s. j. stuart , b. ni , and s. b. sinnott , j. phys .
matter * 14 * , 783 ( 2002 ) .
m. suzuki , j. math . phys . * 26 * , 601 ( 1985 ) . | we reveal the hydrogen isotope effect of three chemical reactions , i.e , the reflection , the absorption and the penetration ratios , by classical molecular dynamics simulation with a modified brenner s reactive empirical bond order ( rebo ) potential potential .
we find that the reflection by @xmath0electron does not depend on the mass of the incident isotope , but the peak of the reflection by nuclear moves to higher side of incident energy .
in addition to the reflection , we also find that the absorption ratio in the positive @xmath1 side of the graphene becomes larger , as the mass of the incident isotope becomes larger . on the other hand ,
the absorption ratio in the negative @xmath1 side of the graphene becomes smaller .
last , it is found that the penetration ratio does not depend on the mass of the incident isotope because the graphene potential is not affected by the mass . [ 1 ] \ { ll # 1 . |
the main aim of the series ` paris cosmology colloquia ' , in the framework of the international school of astrophysics * ` daniel chalonge ' * , is to put together real cosmological and astrophysical data and hard theory approach connected to them .
the chalonge paris cosmology colloquia bring together physicists , astrophysicists and astronomers from the world over .
each year these colloquia are more attended and appreciated both by phd students , post - docs and lecturers .
the format of the colloquia is intended to allow easy and fruitful mutual contacts and communication .
the subject of the 14th paris cosmology colloquium 2010 was ` the standard model of the universe : theory and observations ' .
the colloquium took place during three full days ( thursday july 22 , friday 23 and saturday july 24 ) at the parisian campus of paris observatory ( hq ) , in the historic perrault building .
the * 14th paris cosmology colloquium 2010 * was within the astrofundamental physics spirit of the chalonge school , focalized on recent observational and theoretical progress on the cmb and inflation with predictive power , dark matter , dark energy , dark ages and lss in the context of the standard model of the universe .
never as in this period , the golden age of cosmology , the major subjects of the daniel chalonge school were so timely and in full development : the wmap mission released in 2010 the new survey ( 7 years of observations ) and the planck mission launched in may 2009 is performing its first survey .
the * main topics * were : observational and theoretical progress in deciphering the nature of dark matter , large and small scale structure , warm ( kev ) dark matter and sterile neutrinos .
inflation after wmap ( in connection with the cmb and lss data ) , slow roll and fast roll inflation , quadrupole suppression and initial conditions .
cmb polarization .
cmb measurements by the planck mission and its science perspectives .
all lectures were plenary and followed by a discussion .
enough time was provided to the discussions .
informations of the colloquium are available on * http://www.chalonge.obspm.fr/colloque2010.html * informations on the previous paris cosmology colloquia and on the chalonge school events are available at * http://chalonge.obspm.fr * ( lecturers , lists of participants , lecture files and photos during the colloquia ) .
this paris colloquia series started in 1994 at the observatoire de paris .
the series cover selected topics of high current interest in the interplay between cosmology and fundamental physics .
the paris cosmology colloquia are informal meetings .
their purpose is an updated understanding , from a fundamental point of view , of the progress and current problems in the early universe , cosmic microwave background radiation , large scale structure and neutrinos in astrophysics and the interplay between them .
emphasis is given to the mutual impact of fundamental physics and cosmology , both at theoretical and experimental -or observational- levels .
deep understanding , clarification , synthesis , a careful interdisciplinarity within a fundamental physics approach , are goals of this series of colloquia .
sessions last for three full days and leave enough time for private discussions and to enjoy the beautiful parisian campus of observatoire de paris ( built on orders from colbert and to plans by claude perrault from 1667 to 1672 ) .
sessions took place in the cassini hall , on the meridean of paris , in salle du conseil ( council room ) in the historic perrault building ( btiment perrault " ) of observatoire de paris hq , under the portraits of laplace , le verrier , lalande , arago , delambre and louis xiv and in the grande galerie ( the great gallery ) .
an * exhibition * retraced the 19 years of activity of the chalonge school and of george smoot participation to the school . the books and proceedings of the school since its creation , as well as historic daniel chalonge material , instruments and the daniel chalonge medal were on exhibition at the grande galerie .
after the colloquium , a visit of the perrault building took place guided by professor suzanne debarbat more information on the colloquia of this series can be found in the proceedings ( h.j . de vega and n. sanchez , editors ) published by world scientific co. since 1994 and by observatoire de paris , and the chalonge school courses published by world scientific co and by kluwer publ co. since 1991 .
we want to express our grateful thanks to all the sponsors of the colloquium , to all the lecturers for their excellent and polished presentations , to all the lecturers and participants for their active participation and their contribution to the outstanding discussions and lively atmosphere , to the assistants , secretaries and all collaborators of the chalonge school , who made this event so harmonious , wonderful and successful . with compliments and kind
regards , * hector j de vega , maria cristina falvella , norma g sanchez *
* * peter biermann * ( mpi - bonn , germany & univ of alabama , tuscaloosa , usa ) + astrophysical dark matter * * daniel boyanovsky * ( univ . of pittsburgh , dept of physics and astronomy , usa ) + kev dark matter particle candidates : sterile neutrinos * * asantha cooray * ( university of california , irvine , usa ) + first large - scale structure and cosmological results from atlas and hermes surveys with herschel observatory * * claudio destri * ( infn univ . milano - bicocca dpt
. di fisica g. occhialini , italy ) + fast - roll eras in the effective theory of inflation , low cmb multipoles and mcmc analysis of the cmb+lss data . * * hector j. de vega * ( cnrs lpthe univ de paris vi , p & m curie , paris , france ) + the effective theory of inflation , and kev dark matter in the standard model of the universe * * carlos s. frenk * ( institute for computational cosmology , durham , uk ) + small and large scale structure in the standard model of the universe * * gerard f. gilmore * ( nstitute of astronomy , cambridge university , uk ) + dark matter on small astrophysical scales * * stefan gottlber * ( astrophysikalisches institut potsdam , potsdam , germany ) + constrained local universe simulations ( clues ) * * eiichiro komatsu * ( univ of texas , dept of astronomy , austin , usa ) + the wmap 7-years results : cosmological interpretation * * anthony n. lasenby * ( cavendish laboratory , cambridge university , uk ) + the cmb in the standard model of the universe : a status report * * stacy s. mcgaugh * ( astronomy dept , univ of maryland , college park , md , usa ) + the baryon content of cosmic structures and its relation to dark matter * * reno mandolesi ( inaf - iasf , bologna , italy ) & paolo natoli * ( univ .
roma due tor vergata and asi science data center , frascati , italy ) + measurements of the cmb by the planck satellite and their implications * * flix mirabel * ( cea - saclay , france & iafe - buenos aires , argentina ) + cosmic evolution of stellar black holes and the end of the dark ages * * rafael rebolo * ( instituto astrofisico de canarias , tenerife , spain ) + cmb polarization : the quijote cmb experiment * * bernard sadoulet * ( particle cosmology group , univ of california , berkeley , usa ) + status report on dark matter searches * * paolo salucci * ( sissa - astrophysics , trieste , italy ) + universality properties in galaxies and cored density profiles * * norma g. sanchez * ( cnrs lerma observatoire de paris , paris , france ) + predictions of the effective theory of inflation and kev dark matter in the standard model of the universe * * anton tikhonov * ( saint - petersburg state univ , russia ) + sizes of minivoids and tully - fisher relation in the local volume : another @xmath0cdm - overabundance problem and its possible solutions
more informations on the colloquium lectures are at : * http://www.chalonge.obspm.fr/colloque2010.html * * the nature of dark matter * + p.l .
biermann 1,2,3,4,5 with help from j.k .
becker@xmath3 , l. caramete@xmath4 , l. clavelli@xmath5 , j. dreyer@xmath3 , b. harms@xmath5 , a. meli@xmath6 , e .- s .
seo@xmath7 , & t. stanev@xmath8 + 0.5 cm @xmath9 mpi for radioastronomy , bonn , germany ; @xmath10 dept . of phys . , karlsruher institut fr technologie kit , germany , @xmath5 dept . of phys . & astr .
, univ . of alabama ,
tuscaloosa , al , usa ; @xmath11 dept . of phys .
, univ . of alabama at huntsville , al , usa ; @xmath12
dept . of phys . & astron . ,
univ . of bonn ,
germany ; @xmath3 dept . of phys .
bochum , bochum , germany ; @xmath13 institute for space sciences , bucharest , romania ; @xmath6 ecap , physik .
erlangen - nrnberg , germany ; @xmath7 dept . of physics ,
univ . of maryland ,
college park , md , usa ; @xmath8 bartol research inst .
, univ . of delaware ,
newark , de , usa + dark matter has been detected since 1933 ( zwicky ) and basically behaves like a non - em - interacting gravitational gas of particles . from particle physics supersymmetry
suggests with an elegant argument that there should be a lightest supersymmetric particle , which is a dark matter candidate , possibly visible via decay in odd properties of energetic particles and photons : observations have discovered : ( i ) an upturn in the cr - positron fraction ( pamela : adriani et al .
2009 nature ) , ( ii ) an upturn in the cr - electron spectrum ( atic : chang et al .
2008 nature ; fermi : aharonian et al .
2009 aa ) , ( iii ) a flat radio emission component near the galactic center ( wmap haze : dobler & finkbeiner 2008 apj ) , ( iv ) a corresponding ic component in gamma rays ( fermi haze : dobler et al .
2010 apj , su et al .
2010 arxiv ) , ( v ) the 511 kev annihilation line also near the galactic center ( integral : weidenspointner et al .
2008 newar ) , and most recently , ( vi ) an upturn in the cr - spectra of all elements from helium ( cream : ahn et al .
2009 apj , 2010 apjl ; for h and he the upturn has been confirmed by pamela , shown at the cospar meeting july 2010 ) .
all these features can be quantitatively explained with the action of cosmic rays accelerated in the magnetic winds of very massive stars , when they explode ( biermann et al .
2009 prl , 2010 apjl ) , based on well - defined predictions from 1993 ( biermann 1993 aa , biermann & cassinelli 1993 aa , biermann & strom 1993 aa , stanev et al 1993 aa ) .
while the leptonic part of these observations may be explainable with pulsars and their winds , the hadronic part clearly needs very massive stars , such as wolf - rayet stars , their winds and their explosions . what the cosmic ray work ( biermann et al
. , from 1993 through 2010 ) shows , that allowing for the magnetic field topology of wolf rayet star winds ( see , e.g. parker 1958 apj ) , both the leptonic and the hadronic part get readily and quantitatively explained , close to what had been predicted , without any significant free parameter , so by occam s razor the wolf - rayet star wind proposal is much simpler .
this allows to go back to galaxy data to derive the key properties of the dark matter particle : work by hogan & dalcanton ( 2000 prd , 2001 apj ) , gilmore et al .
( from 2006 mnras , 2007 apj , etc . ) , strigari et al . ( 2008 nature ) , gentile et al . (
2009 nature ) ; work by boyanovsky et al .
( 2008 prd ) , de vega & sanchez ( 2010 mnras ) clearly points to a kev particle . a right - handed neutrino is a candidate to be this particle ( e.g. kusenko & segre 1997 plb ; fuller et al .
2003 prd ; kusenko 2004 ijmp ; for a review see kusenko 2009 physrep ; biermann & kusenko 2006 prl ; stasielak et al .
2007 apj ; loewenstein et al .
2009 apj ; loewenstein & kusenko 2010 apjl ) : this particle has the advantage to allow star formation very early , near redshift 80 , and so also allows the formation of supermassive black holes , possibly formed out of agglomerating massive stars in the gravitational potential of a dark matter clump ; the stellar wind limit derived by yungelson et al .
2008 aa does not apply for stars at near zero heavy elements , since such stars have weak winds .
black holes in turn also merge , but in this manner start their mergers at masses of a few million solar masses ; the mass is given by the instability of stars at such a mass due to general relativity and radiation effects .
this readily explains the supermassive black hole mass function as the result of mergers between black holes .
the corresponding gravitational waves are not constrained by any existing limit , and could have given a substantial energy contribution at high redshift .
our conclusion is that a right - handed neutrino of a mass of a few kev is the most interesting candidate to constitute dark matter
. a consequence should be lyman alpha emission and absorption at around a few microns ; corresponding emission and absorption lines might be visible from molecular hydrogen h@xmath14 ( tegmark et al .
1997 apj ) and h@xmath15 ( goto et al .
2008 apj ) and their ions , in the far infrared and sub - mm wavelength range .
the detection at very high redshift of massive star formation , stellar evolution and the formation of the first super - massive black holes would constitute the most striking and testable prediction of this specific dark matter particle proposal .
-0.4 cm physics & astronomy , university of pittsburgh , pittsburgh , pa 15260 . *
the case for sterile neutrinos as warm dark matter candidates .
* sterile neutrinos with mass in the @xmath16 kev range are suitable warm dark matter candidates that may help solve some possible small scale problems of the @xmath0 cdm concordance model .
i review some of the non - resonant production mechanisms and analyze their transfer function and power spectra at small scales . .....................................................................................................................................................................
in the _ concordance _
@xmath0cdm standard cosmological model dark matter ( dm ) is composed of primordial particles which are cold and collisionless . in this cold dark matter ( cdm )
scenario particles feature negligible small velocity dispersion leading to a power spectrum that favors small scales .
structure formation proceeds in a hierarchical `` bottom up '' approach : small scales become non - linear and collapse first and their merger and accretion leads to structure on larger scales , dense clumps that survive the merger process form satellite galaxies .
large scale simulations seemingly yield an over - prediction of satellite galaxies [ 1 ]
. simulations within the @xmath0cdm paradigm also yield a density profile in virialized ( dm ) halos that increases monotonically towards the center and features a cusp , such as the navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) profile [ 2 ] .
these density profiles accurately describe clusters of galaxies but there is an accumulating body of observational evidence [ 3,4 ] that suggest that the central regions of ( dm)-dominated dwarf spheroidal satellite ( dsphs ) galaxies feature smooth cores instead of cusps as predicted by ( cdm ) .
salucci et .
al . [ 5 ] reported that the mass distribution of spiral disk galaxies can be best fit by a cored burkert - type profile .
warm dark matter ( wdm ) particles were invoked [ 6 ] as possible solutions to these discrepancies .
a model independent analysis suggests that dark matter particles with a mass in the kev range is a suitable ( wdm ) candidate [ 7,8 ] , and sterile neutrinos with masses in the @xmath16 kev range are compelling ( wdm ) candidates [ 9,10 ] .
these neutrinos can decay into an active - like neutrino and an x - ray photon , and recent astrophysical evidence in favor of a @xmath17 kev line has been presented in ref . [ 11 ] .
abundance and phase space density of dwarf spheroidal galaxies constrain the mass to be in the @xmath16 kev range [ 8 ] . in ref .
[ 13 ] we analyze the small scale aspects of sterile neutrinos with mass in the kev range produced by two different non - resonant mechanisms : sterile - active mixing or dodelson - widrow [ 9 ] ( dw ) and by the decay of vector or scalar bosons at the ew scale ( bd ) [ 12 ] the transfer function and power spectra are obtained by solving the collisionless boltzmann equation during radiation and matter domination .
there are three stages in the evolution : ( i ) ( rd ) when the wdm particle is relativistic , ( ii ) ( rd ) when the particle is non - relativistic and ( iii ) ( md ) . during stages ( i ) and
( ii ) the gravitational potential is dominated by the acoustic oscillations in the radiation fluid .
the evolution throughout these two stages determine the initial condition to stage ( iii ) during which wdm density perturbations dominate the gravitational potential and the boltzmann - poisson equation can be related to a fluid like equation .
the power spectra features wdm acoustic oscillations on mass scales @xmath18 .
details are available in ref .
[ 13 ] .
there are two relevant scales : @xmath19 which is the wavevector of modes that enter the hubble radius at matter - radiation equality , and the free streaming scale @xmath20 $ ] where @xmath21 is the mean square root velocity dispersion of the wdm particle at _ matter - radiation equality_. for a wdm candidate with @xmath22 kev produced non - resonantly and decoupling either at the electroweak or qcd scale @xmath23 .
the free streaming length scale @xmath24 is proportional to the distance traveled by a non - relativistic particle with average velocity @xmath21 from matter - radiation equality until today , _ and _ it also determines the size of the ( comoving ) horizon ( conformal time ) when the wdm particle transitions from relativistic to non - relativistic : @xmath25 $ ] .
this means that perturbations with @xmath26 enter the horizon when the wdm particle is still relativistic and undergo suppression by relativistic free streaming between the time of horizon entry until @xmath27 . for @xmath28 ( a is the normalization amplitude ) for cdm , dw and bd for @xmath29 .
note the quasi degeneracy for dw with @xmath30 ( d ) and bd with @xmath31 ( c ) in a large range of @xmath32 . , width=491,height=264 ] during the rd era acoustic oscillations in the radiation fluid determine the gravitational potential @xmath33 .
the time dependence of @xmath34 induces an early isw that results in an _ enhancement _ of the amplitude of wdm density perturbations for wavelengths larger than the sound horizon of the radiation fluid at @xmath27 , namely @xmath35 , but those with @xmath36 are suppressed by relativistic free streaming . in stage
( iii ) the boltzmann - poisson equation is related to a fluid - like equation , whose solutions yield wdm acoustic oscillations .
we obtain a semi - analytic expression for the transfer function and power spectrum valid for arbitrary distribution functions , mass and decoupling temperature .
these are computed for two different scenarios of sterile neutrinos produced non - resonantly ( dw ) and ( bd ) .
the transfer functions are very different _ even for the same mass_. [ 1 ] b. moore _ et .
. j. lett . *
524 * , l19 ( 1999 ) ; s. ghigna _ et.al .
_ astrophys.j .
* 544*,616 ( 2000 ) ; a. klypin _ et .
j. * 523 * , 32 ( 1999 ) ; astrophys .
j. * 522 * , 82 ( 1999 ) .
[ 2 ] j. f. navarro , c. s. frenk , s. white , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . * 462 * , 563 ( 1996 ) ; j. diemand _ et.al .
_ mon . not .
soc . * 364 * , 665 ( 2005 ) .
[ 3 ] r. f.g .
wyse and g. gilmore , arxiv:0708.1492 ; g. gilmore _ et .
arxiv : astro - ph/0703308 ; g. gilmore _ et.al .
_ arxiv:0804.1919 ( astro - ph ) ; g. gilmore , arxiv : astro - ph/0703370 . [ 4 ] g.gentile _ et.al _ astrophys .
* 634 * , l145 ( 2005 ) ; g. gentile _ et.al._ , mon . not .
. soc . * 351 * , 903 ( 2004 ) ; v.g .
j. de blok _ et.al .
_ mon . not .
. soc . * 340 * , 657 ( 2003 ) , g. gentile _ et.al._,arxiv:astro-ph/0701550 ; p. salucci , a. sinibaldi , astron . astrophys . * 323 * , 1 ( 1997 ) .
[ 5 ] p. salucci et al .
mnras * 378 * , 41 ( 2007 ) ; p. salucci , arxiv:0707.4370 . [ 6 ] b. moore , _ et.al .
_ mon . not .
. soc . * 310 * , 1147 ( 1999 ) ; p. bode , j. p. ostriker , n. turok , astrophys .
j * 556 * , 93 ( 2001 ) ; v. avila - reese _ et.al . _
j. * 559 * , 516 ( 2001 ) .
[ 7 ] h. j. de vega , n. sanchez , mon . not .
. soc . * 404 * , 885 ( 2010 ) ; arxiv:0907.0006 ; h. j. de vega , p. salucci , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:1004.1908 .
[ 8 ] d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , phys .
d 78 , 063546 ( 2008 ) ; d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:0710.5180 , phys .
d 77 , 043518 ( 2008 ) .
[ 9 ] s. dodelson , l. m. widrow , phys .
lett . * 72 * , 17 ( 1994 ) .
[ 10 ] a. kusenko , arxiv : hep - ph/0703116 ; int.j.mod.phys.*d16*,2325 ( 2008 ) ; t. asaka , m. shaposhnikov , a. kusenko ; phys.lett . * b638 * , 401 ( 2006 ) ; p. l. biermann , a. kusenko , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 091301 ( 2006 ) ; a. kusenko , phys . rev . lett . * 97 * , 241301 ( 2006 ) ; k. petraki , a. kusenko , phys . rev .
* d 77 * , 065014 ( 2008 ) ; k. petraki , phys . rev . * d 77 * , 105004 ( 2008 ) ; a. kusenko , phys.rept.*481 * , 1 ( 2009 ) ; a. boyarsky , o. ruchayskiy , m. shaposhnikov , ann.rev.nucl.part.sci.*59 * , 191 ( 2009 ) .
[ 11 ] m. lowenstein , a. kusenko , astrophys.j.*714*,652 ( 2010 ) ; astrophys.j * 714 * , 652 ( 2010 ) ; m. loewenstein , a. kusenko , p. l. biermann ; astrophys.j.*700 * , 426 ( 2009 ) .
[ 12 ] d. boyanovsky , phys.rev.*d78 * , 103505 ( 2008 ) ; j. wu , c .- m.ho , d. boyanovsky , phys
* d80 * , 103511 ( 2009 ) .
[ 13 ] d. boyanovsky , j. wu , arxiv : 1008.0992 -0.3 cm university of california , department of physics and astronomy , irvine , ca usa * first results from herschel extragalactic surveys : hermes and h - atlas *
i presented a summary talk focusing on several key results obtained by two consortia that are primarily using spire instrument for extragalactic observations with the herschel space observatory .
i focused on the results that appear in the special issue of astronomy and astrophysics journal ( volume 518 ) that contains first results from the science demonstration phase ( sdp ) data from herschel .
the results i presented include : \(1 ) number counts of sub - mm galaxies at 250 , 350 and 500 microns from hermes ( oliver et al .
2010 ) and atlas + ( clements et al .
2010 ) .
\(2 ) the clustering of the resolved sources ( cooray et al .
2010 for hermes and maddox et al .
2010 for atlas ) , \(3 ) the surface density of lensed sub - mm galaxies ( from negrello et al .
submitted for atlas ) . in terms of clustering
i showed that we have a marginal detection of the 2-halo to 1-halo transition in the correlation function of bright smgs ; this sets a mass scale of few times 10@xmath37 m@xmath38 for sub - mm sources assuming that the 350 micron bright sources are mostly at z of 2 .
these bright sources , however , only account for 15% of the extragalatic background light . to understand the nature of faint sources ( those responsible for the confusion noise and fainter than the confusion noise )
, i showed that one can treat the map as a map of fluctuating field similar to maps of the cmb anisotropies and one can directly study the angular power spectrum of the map .
a measurement of the unresolved fluctuation power spectrum is described in amblard et al .
( 2010 ; submitted ) and i summarized some of the results related to this work .
finally , i outline the science goals of the herschel - spire legacy survey ( hsls ) , a recently proposed open - time program to esa with spire on herschel to cover 4000 square degrees on the sky with spire scanning the sky in fast mode with maps made of single scans .
the survey is aimed at finding 2.5 to 3 million individual sources down to the 50% completeness level of the catalogs at 25 , 26 , and 30 mjy at 250 , 350 and 500 microns respectively .
the hsls maps will be used for a wide variety of cosmological studies including cross - correlation with the cmb maps to look for isw and cmb lensing signal traced by dusty , starbursts at redshifts of 1 to 3 . among the 2.5 to
3 million detected sources will be at least 2000 bright lensed galaxies and more than 10,000 dusty galaxies at redshifts greater than 5 .
* references * a&a special issue on herschel first science results vol 518 ( july 2010 ) . s.j .
oliver et al , arxiv:1005.2184 , hermes : spire galaxy number counts at 250 , 350 and 500 microns , a&a special issue on herschel first science results , vol 518 ( july 2010 ) .
l. clements et al , arxiv:1005.2184 , the herschel - atlas : extragalactic number counts from 250 to 500 microns , a&a special issue on herschel first science results , vol 518 ( july 2010 ) . a. cooray et al , arxiv:1005.3303 , hermes : halo occupation number and bias properties of dusty galaxies from angular clustering measurements , a&a special issue on herschel first science results , vol 518 ( july 2010 ) . s. j. maddox , arxiv:1005.2406 , herschel atlas : the angular correlation function of submillimetre galaxies at high and low redshift a&a special issue on herschel first science results , vol 518 ( july 2010 ) .
a. cooray et al.arxiv:1007.3519 , the herschel - spire legacy survey ( hsls ) : the scientific goals of a shallow and wide submillimeter imaging survey with spire .
-0.3 cm dipartimento di fisica g. occhialini , universit milano - bicocca and infn , sezione di milano - bicocca , piazza della scienza 3 , 20126 milano , italia .
[email protected] *
fast roll eras , primordial fluctuations + and the lowest cmb multipoles : theory and observations * + cosmic inflation is by now the standard paradigm for the description of the evolution of the universe before the hot big bang .
inflation solves the horizon and flatness problems , provides an explanation for the large entropy of the observed universe and naturally generates the scalar fluctuations that seed cmb anisotropies .
single - field inflation is based on a scalar field ( the inflaton ) whose fairly flat potential determines a slow - roll evolution with a sufficiently large number @xmath39 of efolds ( to solve the horizon and flatness problems ) as well as a nearly scale - invariant power spectrum of scalar fluctuations . in particular , the simplest double - well inflaton potential , the so - called binomial new inflation ( bni ) , provides a stable ( in the ginsburg - landau sense ) realization of the inflaton paradigm in very good agreement with present cmb observations of the spectral index @xmath40 and upper limits on the tensor to scalar ratio @xmath41 .
[ d. boyanovsky , c. destri , h.j .
de vega , n. sanchez , ijmp 24 , no .
20 - 21 , 3669 ( 2009 ) ] .
it must be stressed that the model also provides a lower bound on @xmath41 , namely @xmath42 to 95% c.l . quite close to the detetectability limits of planck .
in this talk the main focus is on the inflaton evolution before the slow - roll stage . indeed
this attractor stage is generically preceeded by a fast - roll stage which in turn follows a period of decelerating expansion .
the corresponding evolution of the scale factor , the inflaton and the scalar quantum fluctuations are studied in detail both semi - analytically and numerically with the bni potential .
particular attention is placed on the effect that bunch - davies initial conditions at finite time have on the observable cmb spectrum .
this effect is embodied in the transfer function @xmath43 which relates the power spectrum @xmath44 as @xmath45\ ] ] to the standard pure slow - roll spectrum @xmath46 obtained when the bunch - davies conditions are imposed in the infinite past .
several results for @xmath43 are presented from accurate numerical calculations as well as from semi - analytic approximations .
in particular , it is shown quite generally how @xmath47 vanishes as @xmath48 when @xmath49 while @xmath43 vanishes as @xmath50 times oscillating terms with zero average when @xmath51 .
the latter property is crucial for a negligible back - reaction on the metric , ensuring the applicability of semi - classical gravity . also the important , in principle observable effect of a nonzero @xmath43 on the angular multipoles @xmath52 is exhibited .
when finite - time bunch - davies conditions are imposed at the transition from fast - roll to slow - roll the lowest cmb multipoles are depressed .
comparison with current data through standard monte carlo markov chains analysis shows a small likelihood improvement over the assumption that the low quadrupole is simply a manifestation of cosmic variance .
the core idea put forward is that the large scale cmb anisotropies may provide information on the beginning of inflation .
indeed the early fast - roll inflation is generic and provides a simple mechanism for quadrupole depression , setting around @xmath53 the total number of inflation efolds .
the near saturation of the entropy bound may suggest a deep connection between the duration of inflation and the entropy production at reheating .
references : + d. boyanovsky , c. destri , h. j. de vega , n. sanchez , `` the effective theory of inflation in the standard model of the universe and the cmp + lss data analysis '' , int . j. mod
. phys . * a 24 * , 3669 - 3864 ( 2009 ) and author s references therein .
+ c. destri , h. j. de vega and n. g. sanchez , `` preinflationary and inflationary fast - roll eras and their signatures in the low cmb multipoles '' , phys . rev .
d 81 , 063520 ( 2010 ) .
-0.3 cm h.j.dv : lpthe , cnrs / universit paris vi - p . & m. curie & observatoire de paris , paris , france + n.g.s : lerma , cnrs / observatoire de paris , paris , france * predictions of the effective theory of inflation in the standard model of the universe and the cmb+lss data analysis * inflation is today a part of the standard model of the universe supported by the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) and large scale structure ( lss ) datasets .
inflation solves the horizon and flatness problems and naturally generates density fluctuations that seed lss and cmb anisotropies , and tensor perturbations ( primordial gravitational waves ) .
inflation theory is based on a scalar field @xmath54 ( the inflaton ) whose potential is fairly flat leading to a slow - roll evolution .
we focuse here on the following new aspects of inflation .
we present the effective theory of inflation la * ginsburg - landau * in which the inflaton potential is a polynomial in the field @xmath54 and has the universal form @xmath55 ) $ ] , where @xmath56 is the scale of inflation and @xmath57 is the number of efolds since the cosmologically relevant modes exit the horizon till inflation ends .
the slow - roll expansion becomes a systematic @xmath58 expansion and the inflaton couplings become * naturally small * as powers of the ratio @xmath59 .
the spectral index and the ratio of tensor / scalar fluctuations are @xmath60 while the running index turns to be @xmath61 and therefore can be neglected .
the * energy scale of inflation * @xmath62 gev turns to be completely determined by the amplitude of the scalar adiabatic fluctuations [ 1 - 2 ] . a complete analytic study plus the monte carlo
markov chains ( mcmc ) analysis of the available cmb+lss data ( including wmap5 ) with fourth degree trinomial potentials showed [ 1 - 3 ] : * * ( a ) * the * spontaneous breaking * of the @xmath63 symmetry of the inflaton potential . * * ( b ) * a * lower bound * for @xmath41 in new inflation : @xmath64 and @xmath65 . * * ( c ) * the preferred inflation potential is a * double well * , even function of the field with a moderate quartic coupling yielding as most probable values : @xmath66 .
this value for @xmath41 is within reach of forthcoming cmb observations . * * ( d ) * the present data in the effective theory of inflation clearly * prefer new inflation*. * * ( e ) * study of higher degree inflaton potentials show that terms of degree higher than four do not affect the fit in a significant way .
in addition , horizon exit happens for @xmath67 \sim 0.9 $ ] making higher order terms in the potential @xmath68 negligible [ 4 ] .
* * ( f ) * within the ginsburg - landau potentials in new inflation , @xmath69 and @xmath70 in the @xmath71 plane are within the universal banana region fig .
[ banana ] and @xmath41 is in the range @xmath72 [ 4 ] .
we summarize the physical effects of * generic * initial conditions ( different from bunch - davies ) on the scalar and tensor perturbations during slow - roll and introduce the transfer function @xmath43 which encodes the observable initial conditions effects on the power spectra .
these effects are more prominent in the _ low _ cmb multipoles : a change in the initial conditions during slow roll can account for the observed cmb * quadrupole suppression * [ 1 ] .
slow - roll inflation is generically preceded by a short * fast - roll * stage .
bunch - davies initial conditions are the natural initial conditions for the fast - roll perturbations . during fast - roll ,
the potential in the wave equations of curvature and tensor perturbations is purely attractive and leads to a suppression of the curvature and tensor cmb quadrupoles [ 1 ] . a mcmc analysis of the wmap+sdss data * including fast - roll * shows that the quadrupole mode exits the horizon about 0.2 efold before fast - roll ends and its amplitude gets suppressed . in addition , fast - roll fixes the * initial inflation redshift * to be @xmath73 and the * total number * of efolds of inflation to be @xmath74 [ 1,3 ] .
fast - roll fits the tt , the te and the ee modes well reproducing the quadrupole supression .
a thorough study of the * quantum loop corrections * reveals that they are very small and controlled by powers of @xmath75 , * a conclusion that validates the reliability of the effective theory of inflation [ 1 ] . *
this work [ 1 - 4 ] shows how powerful is the ginsburg - landau effective theory of inflation in predicting observables that are being or will soon be contrasted to observations .
the planck satellite is right now measuring with unprecedented accuracy the primary cmb anisotropies .
the standard model of the universe ( including inflation ) provides the context to analyze the cmb and other data .
the planck performance for @xmath41 related to the primordial @xmath76 mode polarization , will depend on the quality of the data analysis .
the ginsburg landau approach to inflation allows to take high benefit of the cmb data .
we evaluate the planck precision to the recovery of cosmological parameters within a reasonable toy model for residuals of systematic effects of instrumental and astrophysical origin based on publicly available information .
we use and test two relevant models : the @xmath0cdm@xmath70 model , i. e. the standard @xmath0cdm model augmented by @xmath41 , and the @xmath0cdm@xmath70 t model , where the scalar spectral index , @xmath40 , and @xmath41 are related through the theoretical ` banana - shaped ' curve @xmath77 coming from the double - well inflaton potential ( upper boundary of the banana region fig . [ banana ] . in the latter case , @xmath77 is imposed as a hard constraint in the mcmc data analysis .
we take into account the white noise sensitivity of planck in the 70 , 100 and 143 ghz channels as well as the residuals from systematics errors and foregrounds .
foreground residuals turn to affect only the cosmological parameters sensitive to the b modes [ 5 ] . in the ginsburg - landau inflation approach ,
better measurements on @xmath40 , as well as on te and ee modes will improve the prediction on @xmath41 even if a detection of b modes is still lacking [ 5 ] .
forecasted b mode detection probability by the most sensitive hfi-143 channel : at the level of foreground residual equal to 30% of our toy model , only a 68% cl detectiof @xmath41 is very likely . for a 95% cl detection the level of foreground residual
should be reduced to 10% or lower of the adopted toy model .
the possibility to detect @xmath41 is borderline [ 5 ] . in the @xmath78-plane setting @xmath79 .
the upper border of the region @xmath80 corresponds to the fourth order double well potential ( new inflation ) .
the lower border is described by the potential @xmath81 for @xmath82 and @xmath83 for @xmath84 [ 4 ] .
we display in the vertical full line the observed value @xmath85 using the wmap+bao+sn data set .
the broken vertical lines delimit the @xmath86 region.,width=377,height=226 ] .
upper panel : cumulative @xmath87channel marginalized likelihood distributions , including @xmath76 modes and foreground residuals , of the cosmological parameters for the @xmath0cdm@xmath70 model .
the fiducial ratio is @xmath88 .
lower panel : cumulative marginalized likelihoods from the three channels for the cosmological parameters for the @xmath0cdm@xmath70 t model including @xmath76 modes and fiducial ratio @xmath88 and the foreground residuals .
we plot the distributions in four cases : ( a ) without residuals , ( b ) best case smooth : with 30% of the toy model residuals in the @xmath89 and @xmath90 modes .
( c ) worst case smooth : with the toy model residuals in the @xmath89 and @xmath90 modes .
( d ) with 65% of the toy model residuals in the @xmath89 and @xmath90 modes and @xmath91 in the @xmath92 modes rugged by gaussian fluctuations of @xmath93 relative strength . , title="fig:",height=264 ] + .
upper panel : cumulative @xmath87channel marginalized likelihood distributions , including @xmath76 modes and foreground residuals , of the cosmological parameters for the @xmath0cdm@xmath70 model .
the fiducial ratio is @xmath88 .
lower panel : cumulative marginalized likelihoods from the three channels for the cosmological parameters for the @xmath0cdm@xmath70 t model including @xmath76 modes and fiducial ratio @xmath88 and the foreground residuals .
we plot the distributions in four cases : ( a ) without residuals , ( b ) best case smooth : with 30% of the toy model residuals in the @xmath89 and @xmath90 modes .
( c ) worst case smooth : with the toy model residuals in the @xmath89 and @xmath90 modes .
( d ) with 65% of the toy model residuals in the @xmath89 and @xmath90 modes and @xmath91 in the @xmath92 modes rugged by gaussian fluctuations of @xmath93 relative strength . , title="fig:",height=264 ] * references * [ 1 ] review article : d. boyanovsky , c. destri , h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez int . j. mod
a24 , 3669 - 3864 ( 2009 ) and author s references therein . [ 2 ] c. destri , h. j. de vega , n. sanchez , phys .
d77 , 043509 ( 2008 ) , astro - ph/0703417 .
[ 3 ] c. destri , h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:0804.2387 .
phys . rev .
d 78 , 023013 ( 2008 ) .
[ 4 ] c. destri , h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:0906.4102 .
+ d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega , c. m. ho et n. g. sanchez , phys .
d75 , 123504 ( 2007 ) .
[ 5 ] c. burigana , c. destri , h. j. de vega , a. gruppuso , n. mandolesi , p. natoli , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:1003.6108 , to apear in apj .
@xmath94 -0.2 cm institute of astronomy , cambridge * dark matter , feedback , and the lowest luminosity galaxies * the lowest luminosity dwarf galaxies are extremely valuable probes of dark matter on small scales , formation of the first bound systems , and the reality of feedback processes .
dwarf galaxies are extremely dark - matter dominated , so that detailed stellar dynamics analyses are our only viable method to quantify the actual spatial distribution of matter on small scales .
it has long been of interest that dense cusps are predicted by the simplest versions of lcdm , while observers find only cores in nature .
is a more sophisticated lcdm model required , or is astrophysical feedback confusing everything ? in either case current lcdm models need substantial improvement , so what information can we find to guide those improvements ? how cuspy is cdm ? we have been developing for some time the first full robust distribution function analysis of stellar kinematics in dsph , in order to determine the true dark matter distribution .
the methodology is a development of that used in the only dynamical determination of dark matter near the sun ( kuijken & gilmore 1989,1991 ) .
it is based on our new studies of several thousand precision velocities in dsph galaxies , with sophisticated mcmc - based comparison of models and data . after some years of effort , the method is in place , and data are being analysed
. how massive are the first halos ?
a popular approach to understanding the ` satellite problem ' , which is a 3 orders of magnitude discrepancy between the predicted number of bound satellites and the numbers observed , is that all galaxies below some threshold fail to form satrs , while all above it are almost entirely disrupted by ` feedback ' , and so are invisible . while this concept ( due to joe silk long ago ) must be true , what is the mass and mass range ?
some recent analyses assert that al dsph have a common mass , over many magnitudes in luminosity .
is this some ` threshold ' mass ?
we are making progress in two ways here .
first , the claimed masses are not based on observations , but are model extrapolations from central dispersions .
data show a correlation between velocity dispersion and radius of measurement , which is the information to explain .
such a relation applies in any common mass profile .
second , we have developed improved observational methods which show almost all kinematic data for the very faint dsph are of inadequate accuracy to resolve teh true kinematics .
new studies are in preparation which are quite inconsistent with current popular models .
mass ranges are broader than supposed , feedback does not operate as has been suggested . how violent is feedback
? one of the longest - known challenges in galaxy formation models is the very considerable difference between the shape of the galaxy luminosity function and the featureless power - law mass function predicted by the simplest lcdm models . among predictions
are that milky way - like galay halos are debris from the previously very common dsph parents .
a second critical process is feedback - many low - mass galaxies are severely affected by astrophysical feedback early . what that feedback is remains to be discovered .
however , the stellar populations in dsph galaxies are now well - established to be quite different than stellar populations in the milky way halo . the milky way is not formed from dsph - like systems .
so what is wrong with feedback models ? and what is the feedback ?
very substantial progress is being made in quantifying feedback , from detailed analysis of the chemical distributions and star formation histories of the dsph .
we have established ( norris , wyse , gilmore etal 2010 arxiv1008.0137 ) that the lowest luminosity galaxies host very broad chemical abundace dispersions , requiring that they continued star formation from near zero abundance through several enrichment generations .
that is , feedback was extremely mild . in at least these systems
, feedback does not substantially modify initial conditions .
there is room for very considerable improvement in the models to agree with observations
. the next generation of galaxy formation models at low masses will be able to be based on data
. it will be interesting to see what they predict .
* references : * kuijken & gilmore 1989,1991 norris , wyse , gilmore et al .
2010 arxiv1008.0137 -0.2 cm astrophysikalisches institut potsdam , germany onstrained * l*ocal * u*nivers*e * * s*imulations the clues - project during the last decade cosmological parameters have been determined to a precision of just a few percent giving rise to the standard model of cosmology : a flat friedmann universe whose mass - energy content is dominated by a cosmological constant , a cold dark matter component and baryons .
the basic paradigm of structure formation suggests that dark matter forms halos , within which galaxy formation takes place via complex baryonic physics .
the dark matter halos grow via the process of accretion and mergers and galaxy formation proceeds by the combined action of clumpy and anisotropic gas accretion and mergers with dwarf galaxies . on small scales galaxy formation
can be observed and analysed best in the local universe , resulting in the so - called near - field cosmology .
this motivated cosmologists to turn their attention and study the archaeology of the local group in their quest for understanding galaxy formation .
this also motivated us to simulate the formation of the local group in the most realistic possible way . within the clues project ( http://clues-project.org constrained local universe simulations ) we perform numerical simulations of the evolution of the local universe .
the simulations reproduce the local cosmic web and its key players , such as the local supercluster , the virgo cluster , the coma cluster , the great attractor and the perseus - pisces supercluster .
for these simulations we construct initial conditions based on observational data of the galaxy distribution in the local universe .
the implementation of the algorithm of constraining gaussian random fields [ 2 ] to observational data , the used observational data and the constrained simulations have been described in [ 1 ] .
in total we have run 5 big collisionless ( n - body only ) simulations with 1 billion particles each ( i.e. @xmath95 ) .
two of these simulations correspond to one realisation with wmap3 cosmological parameters , that was done both assuming cold and warm dark matter and the other three are cdm realisation with wmap5 cosmological parameters .
the second set of simulations we performed corresponds to high resolution re - simulations of the local group .
these simulations were performed with dark matter only as well as with dark matter , gas dynamics , cooling , star formation and supernovae feedback ( both in the cdm and wdm scenario ) .
all the simulations are described on the web page of the clues project . in order to test the effects of different dark matter candidates on the formation of the local group , we have performed constrained simulations assuming that the dark matter is made of a warm candidate with @xmath96 kev . due to the large thermal velocities of the wdm particles power
is removed from short scales of the fluctuation spectrum : the free - streaming length is @xmath97 kpc . we have chosen this extreme case to study the maximal possible effect of the warm dark matter on the local structure of the universe . to this end
we have compared our predicted galaxy distribution in the local universe with the observed one in the alfalfa survey .
we found that our predictions agree well for the @xmath0wdm cosmogony . on the contrary ,
the @xmath0cdm model predicts a steep rise in the velocity function towards low velocities and thus forecasts much more sources both in virgo - direction as well as in anti - virgo - direction than the ones observed by the alfalfa survey .
these results indicate a potential problem for the cold dark matter paradigm [ 4 ] .
also the spectrum of mini - voids points to a potential problem of the @xmath0cdm model .
the @xmath0wdm model provides a natural solution to this problem , however , the late formation of halos in the @xmath0wdm model might be a problem for galaxy formation [ 3 ] .
constrained simulations are a very useful tool to study the formation and evolution of our local group in the right cosmological environment and the best possible way to make a direct comparison between numerical results and observations , minimising the effects of the cosmic variance .
[ 1 ] s. gottlber , y. hoffman , g. yepes , 2010 , proceedings of `` high performance computing in science and engineering , garching / munich 2009 '' , springer - verlag , ( astro - ph/1005.2687 ) [ 2 ] y. hoffman , e. ribak , 1991 , apjl , 380 , l5 [ 3 ] a.v .
tikhonov , s. gottlber , g. yepes , y. hoffman , 2009 , mnras , 399 , 1611 [ 4 ] j. zavala , y. p. jing , a. faltenbacher , g. yepes , y. hoffman , s. gottlber and b. catinella , 2009 , apj , 700 , 1779 -0.2 cm university of texas at austin , dept of astronomy , austin usa * wmap 7-year results * we have announced the results from 7 years of observations of the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) on january 26 . in this talk , we presented the cosmological interpretation of the wmap 7-year data , including the detection of primordial helium , images of polarization of microwave background around temperature peaks ( see figure 6 ) , and new limits on inflation and properties of neutrinos .
we also reported a significant detection of the sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) effect , showed that we found , for the first time in the sz effect , a significant difference between the relaxed and non - relaxed clusters . in more detail ,
our latest determination of the primordial spectral tilt is @xmath98 ( 68% cl ) , a measurement which excludes @xmath99 by 99.5% cl .
the latest 95% upper limit on the tensor - to - scalar ratio is @xmath100 ( which is from wmap+bao+@xmath101 ) .
the 95% upper limit on the total mass of neutrinos is @xmath102 ev , whereas the effective number of relativistic species is @xmath103 ( 68% cl ) .
whether @xmath104 is favored will be tested by the planck satellite , which is expected to reduce the error bar by a factor of four . as for the sz effect
, we find that our sz measurements agree with the predictions from the x - ray data very well on a cluster - by - cluster basis .
however , the current _ theoretical _ predictions overestimate the amount of the gas pressure ( hence sz ) in clusters of galaxies .
this will become important when using clusters of galaxies as a cosmological probe .
reference : e. komatsu , et al .
, ` seven - year wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) observations : cosmological interpretation , ' to appear in the astrophysical journal supplement series , arxiv:1001.4538 . from the spot center and the radial polarization pattern at @xmath105 from the spot center ( the right panel ) .
we also analyzed the hot spots in the same way , finding the opposite polarization patterns , consistent with the prediction.,width=264 ] -0.2 cm addresses : _ astrophysics group , cavendish laboratory , j.j .
thomson avenue , cambridge cb3 0he , u.k . and kavli institute for cosmology , c / o institute of astronomy , madingley road , cambridge , cb3 0 ha , u.k . _ + email : ` [email protected] ` * cmb observations : current status and implications for theory * + the aim of this talk was to give an overview of the current state of cosmic microwave background observations and scientific implications .
it is still very much the case that the cmb is one of the most powerful tools of modern cosmology , and that a significant fraction of all information in cosmology over the past 10 to 15 years has come from it . as regards primordial cmb observations and results , we are effectively in an ` interregnum ' period at the moment ,
although of course some wonderful data is currently being taken by the planck satellite , with the first results for primordial cmb expected during 2012 .
compared to a year ago , there is no great change as regards results from ground - based experiments measuring primordial anisotropies bicep [ 3 ] and quad [ 2 ] are still the leading experiments as regards polarization . in space
we have do have an increment of knowledge , from wmap7 [ 9 ] details of which are discussed by prof .
for the first time this has given us the opportunity to look at the temperature and polarization patterns around hot and cold spots in the cmb .
these follow what would be expected for simple adiabatic density perturbations at recombination , and are an important test of the standard model .
this has been carried out in a statistical way by stacking the images of many thousands of hot / cold spots .
it will interesting with future data to look at individual features , e.g. the ` cold spot ' first drawn attention to by cruz , and which has been advocated as due to late time effects from a topological defect remnant known as a ` texture ' [ 4 ] . in the latter case a quite different pattern of cmb polarization around it would be expected , as opposed to that expected for a standard primordial cmb perturbation . although the explanation in terms of a texture is speculative , detection of such an object would certainly be very important for cosmology and high energy physics theory . a further area in which the cmb can contribute to fundamental physics lies in the areas of testing inflation theory , and also assumptions underlying the nature of the universe on large scales during inflation itself .
ref.[5 ] puts forward a model in which the early universe is slightly oblate ( specifically a bianchi ix model ) during the period at which inflationary perturbations are being laid down on the largest scales .
this has obvious links with questions about whether there is a north / south asymmetry in the statistics of the cmb sky distribution , and possible links to issues such as a ` dark flow ' [ 8 ] . in a further paper , [ 8 ]
have demonstrated the links between their early universe model , which replaces the ` big bang ' with a non - singular pancaking event , and the taub - nut anisotropic universe model .
it is shown how the latter , when viewed in a more physically appropriate coordinate system , is actually the vacuum limit of the scalar field bianchi model introduced by [ 5 ] , and instead of having two alternations between open , closed and open , it in fact remains always closed , but oscillating indefinitely through episodes of ( non - singular ) pancaking .
it is perhaps remarkable that the vacuum can go through an infinite succession of exactly repeating oscillations in this way . as regards secondary anisotropies ( those imposed e.g. by clusters of galaxies or other features of large scale structure at late times )
there has been big progress over the past year , with the first results from ` blank field ' sunyaev - zeldovich samples appearing , and new constraints on the high-@xmath106 cmb power spectrum .
the telescopes contributing to these developments include the south pole telescope ( spt ) , the arcminute microkelvin imager ( ami ) in cambridge , and the atacama cosmology telescope ( act ) in chile . for ami
, the first results on a blank field candidate cluster detected via its sz effect are about to be published , and results on pointed observations of 7 known clusters have appeared in [ 14 ] .
a particularly intriguing recent ami observation is of the ` northern hemisphere bullet cluster ' , a2146 , drawn attention to by [ 12 ] .
this demonstrates an offset between the peaks of x - ray and sz emission , consistent with the idea of complex bulk motions . for the spt
, a description of a sample of clusters selected via their sz effect in blank field observations has been given in [ 13 ] , and an analysis of their x - ray properties in [ 1 ] .
the equivalent in terms of x - ray properties for blank field clusters detected using the act is contained in [ 11 ] and both telescopes have produced their first estimates of the high-@xmath106 cmb power spectrum , in [ 10 ] for the spt and [ 7 ] for act .
taken together , these results are extremely interesting , in that they all show how the amplitude of the sz effect , whether as determined in individual clusters , or in terms of the statistical contribution to the high-@xmath106 power spectrum , is _ significantly smaller _ than expected from current x - ray observations , and models for cluster evolution and scaling .
this in fact ties in with results from wmap 7 year data [ 9 ] , where the statistical level of sz cluster effects ( got by stacking at the positions of known clusters ) are systematically smaller than expected from the x - ray observations , by factors up to 2 in amplitude ( similar to the factors involved in the ground - based observations ) .
this hints strongly at a gap of our understanding of processes in clusters , and will probably require us to treat clusters on a more individual basis ( taking account of properties such as whether they are relaxed , and/or contain cooling flows ) in comparing x - ray and sz data , as well as improving the models of scaling and evolution with cosmic epoch . for both of these areas , observations from planck can be expected to play a pivotal role .
* references : * * [ 1 ] andersson et al.(2010 ) k. andersson x - ray properties of the first sze - selected galaxy cluster sample from the south pole telescope , arxiv 1006.3068 . * [ 2 ] brown et al.(2009 ) m. l. brown improved measurements of the temperature and polarization of the cosmic microwave background from quad . _
_ , 705:0 978999 . *
[ 3 ] chiang et al.(2010 ) h. c. chiang measurement of cosmic microwave background polarization power spectra from two years of bicep data , _ _ , 711:0 11231140 . *
[ 4 ] cruz et al.(2007 ) a cosmic microwave background feature consistent with a cosmic texture .
_ science _ , 318:0 1612 , december 2007 . *
[ 5 ] dechant et al.(2009 )
dechant , a. n. lasenby , and m. p. hobson . .
_ _ , 790 ( 4):0 043524 , february 2009 . *
[ 6 ] dechant et al.(2010)dechant , lasenby , and hobson , cracking the taub - nut , _ classical and quantum gravity _ , 270 ( 18):0 185010 , september 2010 . * [ 7 ] fowler et al.(2010 ) j. w. fowler the atacama cosmology telescope : a measurement of the @xmath107 cosmic microwave background power spectrum at 148 ghz , arxiv:1001.2934 .
* [ 8 ] kashlinsky et al.(2010 ) a. kashlinsky , f. atrio - barandela , h. ebeling , a. edge , and d. kocevski .
a new measurement of the bulk flow of x - ray luminous clusters of galaxies . _ _ , 712:0 l81l85 , march 2010 . * [ 9 ] komatsu et al.(2010 ) e. komatsu seven - year wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) observations : cosmological interpretation , arxiv:1001.4538 . *
[ 10 ] lueker et al.(2010 ) m. lueker measurements of secondary cosmic microwave background anisotropies with the south pole telescope , _ _ , 719:0 10451066 . *
[ 11 ] menanteau et al.(2010 ) f. menanteau the atacama cosmology telescope : physical properties and purity of a galaxy cluster sample selected via the sunyaev - zeldovich effect
. arxiv:1006.5126 . *
[ 12 ] russell et al.(2010 ) h. r. russell . _
_ , 406:0 17211733 . *
[ 13 ] vanderlinde et al.(2010 ) k. vanderlinde galaxy clusters selected with the sunyaev - zeldovich effect from 2008 south pole telescope observations , arxiv:1003.0003 . * [ 14 ] zwart et al.(2010 ) j. t. l. zwart sunyaev - zeldovich observations of galaxy clusters out to the virial radius with the arcminute microkelvin imager , arxiv:1008.0443 .
-0.2 cm department of astronomy , university of maryland , college park , md 20742 - 2421 , usa * the baryon content of cosmic structures * cosmic parameters like as the mass density @xmath108 and expansion rate @xmath109 are now known with great precision .
the majority of mass in the universe appears to be composed of non - baryonic dark matter , whilst the normal baryonic material composing the stars and gas that we can actually observe constitutes a distinct minority .
this cosmic baryon fraction is well quantified : @xmath110 .
an inventory of the detected baryons in individual cosmic structures like galaxies and clusters of galaxies falls short of this universal value . on the largest scales of clusters ,
most but not all of the expected baryons are detected .
the fraction of detected baryons decreases monotonically from the cosmic baryon fraction as a function of mass . in the smallest dwarf galaxies ,
fewer than 1% of the expected baryons are detected .
it is an observational challenge to identify the missing baryons , and a theoretical one to understand the observed variation with mass . + the fraction of the expected baryons that are detected as a function of mass or circular velocity ( left ) and the corresponding fraction that have been converted to stars ( right ) .
purple squares are galaxy clusters .
dark blue circles are star dominated spirals galaxies .
light blue circles are gas dominated disks .
red squares are local group dwarf satellites .
giant elliptical galaxies appear to deviate from the trend whether measured by velocity dispersion ( open squares ) or gravitational lensing ( pink square ) . however , large systematic uncertainties for these objects are possible .
+ this work is published in + mcgaugh , s. s. , schombert , j. m. , de blok , w. j. g. , & zagursky , m. j. 2010 , apj , 708 , l14
-0.2 cm sissa , astrophysics section , trieste , italy * universal properties in galaxies and cored dm profiles * the presence of large amounts of unseen matter in galaxies , distributed differently from stars and gas , is well established from rotation curves which do not show the expected keplerian fall - off at large radii , but increase , remain flat or start to gently decrease according to a well organized pattern that involves an invisible mass component becoming progressively more more abundant at outer radii and in the less luminous galaxies ( persic , salucci and stel , 1996 ) . in spirals we have the best opportunity to study the mass distribution : the gravitational potentials of a spherical stellar bulge ,
a dark halo , a stellar disk and a gaseous disc give rise to an observed equilibrium circular velocity @xmath111 the poisson equation relates the surface ( spatial ) densities of these components to the corresponding gravitational potentials .
the investigation is not difficult : e.g. @xmath112 , the surface stellar density is proportional ( by the mass - to - light ratio ) to the observed surface brightness : @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the disk mass and @xmath115 is the disk scale length and @xmath116 a combination of bessel functions .
dark and luminous matter in spirals are coupled : at any galactocentric radii @xmath117 measured in terms of disk length - scale @xmath118 , @xmath119 there is a _
radial _ tully - fisher relation ( yegorova and salucci 2007 ) , i.e. a relation between the local rotation velocity @xmath120 and the total galaxy luminosity : @xmath121 . spirals present universal features in their kinematics that correlate with their global galactic properties ( pss and by salucci et al , 2007 ) .
this led to the discovery , from 3200 individual rotation curves ( rcs ) , of the ` universal rotation curve ' of spirals @xmath122 ( see pss , and fig ( 1 ) ) , i.e. of a function of galactocentric radius @xmath70 , that , tuned by a global galaxy property ( e.g. the luminosity ) , well reproduces , out to the virial radius , the rc of any spiral ( salucci _ et al .
@xmath123 is the observational counterpart to which the circular velocity profile emerging in cosmological simulations must comply . in the same way of individual rcs
, it underlies a mass model that includes a freeman disk and a dm halo with a burkert profile @xmath124 @xmath125 is the core radius and @xmath126 the central density , see salucci and burkert ( 2000 ) for details .
we obtain the structural parameters @xmath127 , @xmath128 , @xmath114 by @xmath129 fitting the urc and a number of individual rcs .
as result a set of scaling laws among local and global galaxy quantities emerges ( see fig 2 ) .
0.3truecm and out to @xmath130 ) and luminosity ( halo mass ) .
see salucci et al ( 2007 ) for details and for the urc out to the virial radius.,title="fig : " ] -0.1truecm these scaling laws indicate ( salucci et al , 2007 ) that spirals have an inner baryon dominance region where the stellar disk dominates the total gravitational potential , while the dm halo emerges farther out . at any radii ,
objects with lower luminosities have a larger dark - to - stellar mass ratio .
the baryonic fraction in spirals is always much smaller than the cosmological value @xmath131 , and it ranges between @xmath132 to @xmath133 , suggesting that processes such as sn explosions must have removed a very large fraction of the original hydrogen .
smaller spirals are denser , with their central density spanning 2 order of magnitudes over the mass sequence of spirals .
-0.3 cm -0.6truecm -0.5truecm to assume a cored halo profile is obligatory .
it is well known that @xmath134 scenario provides a successful picture of the cosmological structure formation and that large n - body numerical simulations performed in this scenario lead to the commonly used nfw halo cuspy spatial density profile . however , a careful analysis of about 100 high quality , extended and free from deviations from axial symmetry rcs has now ruled out the disk + nfw halo mass model , in favor of cored profiles ( e.g. gentile _ et al .
_ 2004 , 2005 , spano _ et al .
_ 2007 , de blok 2008 and de naray _
2008 ) .
the mass modelling in dsph , lsb and ellipticals is instead still in its infancy .
however , data seem to confirm the pattern shown by in spirals ( gilmore , 2005 , walker , 2010,nagino and matsushita , 2009 ) .
regarding the structural properties of the dm distribution a most important finding is that the central surface density @xmath135 , where @xmath128 and @xmath127 are the halo core radius and central spatial density , is nearly constant and independent of galaxy luminosity .
based on the co - added rotation curves of @xmath136 spiral galaxies , mass models of individual dwarf irregular and spiral galaxies of late and early types with high - quality rotation curves and on galaxy - galaxy weak lensing signals from a sample of spiral and elliptical galaxies , we find that @xmath137 in units of @xmath138(m@xmath139 pc@xmath140 ) .
this constancy transpasses the family of disk systems and reaches spherical systems .
the internal kinematics of local group dwarf spheroidal galaxies are consistent with this picture .
our results are obtained for galactic systems spanning over 14 magnitudes , belonging to different hubble types , and whose mass profiles have been determined by several independent methods . very significantly , in the same objects , the approximate constancy of @xmath141 is in sharp contrast to the systematical variations , by several orders of magnitude , of galaxy properties , including @xmath127 and central stellar surface density see figure ( 3 ) . the evidence that the dm halo central surface density @xmath142 remains constant to within less than a factor of two over fourteen galaxy magnitudes , and across several hubble types , does indicates that this quantity is perhaps hiding the physical nature of the dm . considering that dm haloes are ( almost ) spherical systems
it is surprising that their central surface density plays a role in galaxy structure .
moreover , this evidence , is difficult to understand in an evolutionary scenario as the product of the process that has turned the primordial cosmological gas in the stellar galactic structures we observe today . such constancy , in fact , must be achieved in very different galaxies of different morphology and mass , ranging from dark - matter - dominated to baryon - dominated objects . in addition , these galaxies have experienced significantly different evolutionary histories ( e.g. numbers of mergers , significance of baryon cooling , stellar feedback , etc . ) .
the best explanation for our findings stems from the dm nature : the dm particle mass and decoupling temperature .
recent theoretical work ( de vega , sanchez 09 ; de vega , salucci , sanchez 10 ) points towards a dm particle mass in the kev scale leading to the formation of cored dm virialized structures .
the results obtained so far indicate the distribution of matter galaxies is a benchmark for understanding dark matter nature and the galaxy formation process .
in particular , the universality of certain structural quantities and the dark - luminous coupling of the mass distributions , seem to bear the direct imprint of the nature of the dm ( donato _ et al .
_ 2009 , gentile _ et al .
_ 2009 ) . -.0truecm
-0.8truecm * de blok , w.j.g _ et al .
_ 2008 , arxiv:0810.2100 . * donato , f. gentile , g. , salucci , p. 2004
, mon . not .
soc . , 353 , l17 .
* donato f. , _ et al .
_ 2009 , mon . not .
soc . , 397 , 1169 .
* gentile , g. _ et al .
_ 2004 , mon . not .
soc . , 351 , 903 .
* gentile , g. _ et al .
_ 2005 , astrophys .
j. , 634 , l145 . * gentile g. , _ et al .
_ 2009 , nature , 461 , 627 . * kuzio de naray , r. _ et al .
_ 2008 , astrophys .
j. , 676 , 920 . * navarro , j. f. , frenk , c. s. , white , s. d. m. 1996 , astrophys .
j. , 462 , 563 ( nfw ) . * persic , m. , salucci , p. , stel , f. 1996 , mon . not .
r. astron .
281 , 27 ( pss ) .
* salucci , p. _ et al .
_ 2007 , mon . not .
soc . , 378 , 41 .
* shankar , f. _ et al .
_ 2006 , astrophys .
j. , 643 , 14 . * spano , m. , marcelin , m. , amram , p. _ et al .
_ 2008 , mon . not .
383 , 297 .
* nagino , r. and matsushita k , a & a , 2009 , 501 , 157 * yegorova , i.a . , salucci , p. 2007 , mon . not .
r. astron .
soc . , 377 , 507 . *
walker , m. et al , 2010 , apj 717 , 87 * gilmore , g. et al 2007 apj , 663 , 948 * de vega10 de vega , h j , salucci p. , sanchez n. , arxiv:1004.1908 * de vega , h j , sanchez n. g. , arxiv0901.0922 -0.3 cm hjdv : lpthe , cnrs / universit paris vi - p . & m. curie & observatoire de paris .
+ ngs : observatoire de paris , lerma & cnrs * kev scale dark matter from theory and observations and galaxy properties from linear primordial fluctuations * in the context of the standard cosmological model the nature of dm is unknown
. only the dm gravitational effects are noticed and they are necessary to explain the present structure of the universe .
dm ( dark matter ) particles must be neutral and so weakly interacting such that no effects are detectable .
dm candidates are beyond the standard model of particle physics.theoretical analysis combined with astrophysical data from galaxy observations points towards a dm particle mass in the * kev scale * ( kev = 1/511 electron mass ) [ 1 - 4 ] .
dm particles can decouple being ultrarelativistic ( ur ) at @xmath143 or non - relativistic @xmath144 .
they may decouple at or out of local thermal equilibrium ( lte ) .
the dm distribution function : @xmath145 $ ] freezes out at decoupling becoming a function of the comoving momentum @xmath146 .
@xmath147 is the physical momentum .
basic physical quantities can be expressed in terms of the distribution function as the velocity fluctuations , @xmath148 and the dm energy density @xmath149 where @xmath150 is the integration variable and @xmath151 is the number of internal degrees of freedom of the dm particle ; typically @xmath152 . *
two * basic quantities characterize dm : its particle mass @xmath153 and the temperature @xmath154 at which dm decouples .
@xmath154 is related by entropy conservation to the number of ultrarelativistic degrees of freedom @xmath155 at decoupling by @xmath156 ev .
one therefore needs * two * constraints to determine the values of @xmath153 and @xmath154 ( or @xmath155 ) .
one constraint is to reproduce the known cosmological dm density today . @xmath157 .
two independent further constraints are considered in refs .
[ 1 - 4 ] .
first , the phase - space density @xmath158 [ 1 - 2 ] and second the surface acceleration of gravity in dm dominated galaxies [ 3 - 4 ] .
we therefore provide * two * quantitative ways to derive the value @xmath153 and @xmath155 in refs .
[ 1 - 4 ] .
the phase - space density @xmath159 is invariant under the cosmological expansion and can * only decrease * under self - gravity interactions ( gravitational clustering ) .
the value of @xmath159 today follows observing dwarf spheroidal satellite galaxies of the milky way ( dsphs ) : @xmath160 ( gilmore et al .
07 and 08 ) .
we compute explicitly @xmath161 ( in the primordial universe ) and it turns to be proportional to @xmath162 [ 1 - 4 ] . during structure formation
@xmath159 * decreases * by a factor that we call @xmath163 .
namely , @xmath164 .
the value of @xmath163 is galaxy - dependent .
the spherical model gives @xmath165 and @xmath166-body simulations indicate : @xmath167 ( see [ 1 ] ) . combining the value of @xmath168 and @xmath169 with the theoretical analysis yields that @xmath153 must be in the kev scale and @xmath154 can be larger than 100 gev .
more explicitly , we get general formulas for @xmath153 and @xmath155 [ 1 ] : @xmath170^{\frac38}\ ] ] where @xmath171 and @xmath172 kev using the dsphs data , @xmath173 and @xmath174 .
these formulas yield for relics decoupling ur at lte : @xmath175 since @xmath176 , we see that @xmath177 gev .
moreover , @xmath178 for @xmath179 .
for example for dm majorana fermions @xmath180 kev .
we get results for @xmath153 and @xmath155 on the same scales for dm particles decoupling ur out of thermal equilibrium [ 1 ] . for a specific model of sterile neutrinos where decoupling is out of thermal equilibrium : @xmath181 for relics decoupling non - relativistic we obtain similar results for the dm particle mass : kev @xmath182 mev [ 1 ] .
notice that the dark matter particle mass @xmath153 and decoupling temperature @xmath154 are * mildly * affected by the uncertainty in the factor @xmath163 through a power factor @xmath183 of this uncertainty , namely , by a factor @xmath184 the comoving free - streaming ) wavelength , ( fig .
1 ) , and the jeans mass are obtained in the range @xmath185 these values at @xmath186 are consistent with the @xmath166-body simulations and are of the order of the small dark matter structures observed today . by the beginning of the matter dominated era @xmath187 , the masses are of the order of galactic masses @xmath188 and the comoving free - streaming wavelength scale turns to be of the order of the galaxy sizes today @xmath189 .
lower and upper bounds for the dark matter annihilation cross - section @xmath190 are derived : @xmath191 and @xmath192 there is at least five orders of magnitude between them , the dark matter non - gravitational self - interaction is therefore negligible ( consistent with structure formation and observations , as well as by comparing x - ray , optical and lensing observations of the merging of galaxy clusters with @xmath166-body simulations ) .
typical `` wimps '' ( weakly interacting massive particles ) with mass @xmath193 gev and @xmath194 gev would require a huge @xmath195 , well above the upper bounds obtained and can not reproduce the observed galaxy properties .
they produce an extremely short free - streaming or jeans length @xmath196 today @xmath197 that would correspond to unobserved structures much smaller than the galaxy structure .
wimps result strongly disfavoured .
galaxies are described by a variety of physical quantities : \(a ) * non - universal * quantities : mass , size , luminosity , fraction of dm , dm core radius @xmath125 , central dm density @xmath126 .
\(b ) * universal * quantities : surface density @xmath198 and dm density profiles . @xmath199
( or halo binding energy ) .
the galaxy variables are related by * universal * empirical relations .
only one variable remains free .
that is , the galaxies are a one parameter family of objects .
the existence of such universal quantities may be explained by the presence of attractors in the dynamical evolution .
the quantities linked to the attractor always reach the same value for a large variety of initial conditions .
this is analogous to the universal quantities linked to fixed points in critical phenomena of phase transitions.the universal dm density profile in galaxies has the scaling property : @xmath200 where @xmath125 is the dm core radius . as empirical form of cored profiles
one can take burkert s form for @xmath201 .
cored profiles * do reproduce * the astronomical observations ( see the contribution here by salucci and the review by de blok 2010 ) .
the surface density for dark matter ( dm ) halos and for luminous matter galaxies is defined as : @xmath202 @xmath203 halo core radius , @xmath204 central density for dm galaxies . for luminous galaxies @xmath205 ( donato et al .
09 , gentile et al .
observations show an universal value for @xmath206 : independent of the galaxy luminosity for a large number of galactic systems ( spirals , dwarf irregular and spheroidals , elliptics ) spanning over @xmath207 magnitudes in luminosity and of different hubble types . observed values : @xmath208 similar values @xmath209
are observed in interstellar molecular clouds of size @xmath125 of different type and composition over scales @xmath210 pc ( larson laws , 1981 ) .
notice that the surface gravity acceleration is given by @xmath211 times newton s constant .
0.2 cm the scaling form eq.(1 ) of the density profiles implies scaling properties for the energy and entropy .
the total energy becomes using the virial theorem and the profile @xmath212 : @xmath213 therefore , the energy scales as the volume .
0.1 cm the boltzmann - vlasov distribution function @xmath214 for consistency with the profile form eq.(1 ) , must scale as @xmath215 where @xmath153 is the dm particle mass .
hence , the entropy scales as @xmath216 the * entropy * scales as the * surface * as it is the case for black - holes .
however , for black - holes of mass @xmath217 and area @xmath218 , the entropy @xmath219 .
that is , the proportionality coefficients @xmath220 between entropy and area are very different : @xmath221 showing that the entropy per unit area of the galaxy is much smaller than the entropy of a black - hole .
in other words the bekenstein bound for the entropy of physical is well satisfied here . in order to compute the surface density and the density profiles from first principles
we have evolved the linearized boltzmann - vlasov equation since the end of inflation till today [ 2 - 3 ] .
we depict in fig .
10 the density profiles vs. @xmath222 for fermions ( green ) and bosons ( red ) decoupling ultrarelativistic and for particles decoupling non - relativistically ( blue ) .
these profiles turn to be universal with the same shape as , for example , the burkert profile .
@xmath223 depends on the galaxy and is entirely determined theoretically in terms of cosmological parameters and @xmath153 [ 2 - 3 ] .
-90 we obtain in refs .
[ 3,4 ] for the galaxy surface density in the linear approximation @xmath224^{0.161 } \left[1 + 0.0489 \ ; \ln \frac{q_{prim}}{({\rm kev})^4 } \right ] { \rm mev}^3\ ] ] where @xmath225 is the primordial spectral index and fermions decoupling ur were considered .
matching the * observed values * from spiral galaxies @xmath226 with this @xmath227 gives the primordial phase - space density @xmath228 and from it the mass of the dm particle .
we obtain @xmath229 kev for the dark matter particle mass [ 4 ] .
we obtain the linear density profiles for any dm particle mass @xmath230 [ 3 - 4 ] . at intermediate scales
@xmath231 we obtain [ 4 ] , @xmath232 \ ; 10^{-26 } \ ; \frac{\rm g}{{\rm cm}^3 } \quad , \quad 1+n_s/2 = 1.482\ ] ] the theoretical linear results * agree * with the universal empirical behaviour @xmath233 : m. g. walker et al .
( 2009 ) ( observations ) , i. m. vass et al .
( 2009 ) ( simulations ) .
at small scales @xmath234 kpc ) the linear density profiles turns to be * cored * for kev scale dm particles , and * cusped * for wimps [ 3 - 4 ] .
we summarize in the table the values for non - universal galaxy quantities from the observations and from the linear theory results .
the larger and less denser are the galaxies , the better are the results from the linear theory for non - universal quantities .
the linear approximation turns to improve for larger galaxies ( i. e. more diluted ) [ 4 ] .
therefore , universal quantities as profiles and surface density are reproduced by the linear approximation .
the agreement between the linear theory and the observations is * remarkable*. the last column of the table corresponds to 100 gev mass wimps .
the wimps values strongly disagree by several orders of magnitude with the observations . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] * references * 1 : : h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:0901.0922 , mon . not .
r. astron .
404 , 885 ( 2010 ) .
2 : : d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:0710.5180 , phys . rev . *
d 77 * , 043518 ( 2008 ) .
3 : : h. j. de vega , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:0907.0006 .
4 : : h. j. de vega , p. salucci , n. g. sanchez , arxiv:1004.1908 . -0.2 cm saint petersburg state university , astrophysics inst . , saint petersburg , russia + e - mail : [email protected] * voids and dwarf galaxies in the local volume : another @xmath0cdm - overabundance and possible solutions * at present , the reference cosmological model is a flat friedmann universe whose mass - energy content is dominated by a cosmological constant , a cold dark matter ( cdm ) component and baryons .
this @xmath0cdm model describes structure formation at large scales very well , however it fails on small scales : the standard model predicts much more small scale structure than observed .
the problem of @xmath0cdm overabundance on small mass scales has its origin in the mismatch between the faint end of the observational luminosity function and the mass function of the dm halos predicted by the @xmath0cdm model .
numerically , the problem initially showed up as the `` missing satellites problem '' - strong excess of substructures in simulated milky way sized dm halos with respect to the observed number of dwarf galaxies in the local group ( lg ) ( klypin et al . , 2009 ) .
more than 10 years of `` solving '' the problem has led to the statement that there should be many truly `` dark '' halos without stellar or gas components .
but still none of the solutions became `` essential '' or `` concordant '' .
for instance , in some recipes procedure of construction of lg satellites lf when accounting for sdss incompleteness assumes uniformity of missed dwarf galaxies population ( tollerud et al .
2009 ) which is a very poor approximation for known and newly discovered dwarf lg population .
tikhonov & klypin ( 2009 ) have found that the @xmath0cdm model exhibits the same problem concerning the problem of void dwarf galaxies .
they found that in the @xmath0cdm model the minivoids are too small when compared to observations .
our analysis led to the conclusion that the @xmath0cdm model fits the observational spectrum of minivoids defined by galaxies with @xmath235 assuming that these galaxies can contain only dm halos with circular velocities @xmath236 km / s ( which roughly corresponds to @xmath237 ) .
this is a quite interesting result from the theoretical side - according to some estimates , halos with @xmath238km / s had essentially no gas infall and star formation inside them .
the extrapolation of a ` common mass scale ' ( strigari et al . , 2008 ) for lg s dsphs points to a similar total mass of the smallest observable gravitationally bound systems in the universe containing dark matter .
the problem ( for the @xmath0cdm model , not for nature ) is that about 100 of nearby dwarf galaxies with @xmath235 rotate slower than 35 km / s .
there are some things special about dwarf isolated galaxies most of them are old , they rotationally support thin disks and they produce stars right now .
we have a small but nonnegligible collection of galaxies such as camelopardalisb , cgcg269 - 049 , ddo125 exhibiting regular rotation with maximum rotational velocities as low as 10 - 15km / s with clear indications of modern star formation .
@xmath0cdm - overabundance is quite spectacular when comparing the local tully - fisher relation for dwarf galaxies with model one in tikhonov & klypin ( 2009 ) ( assuming the simplest semi - analytical approach - abundance matching ) . )
( red circles ) is compared with the mean vff obtained from the 14 lvs in the @xmath0wdm simulation with haloes with circular velocity @xmath239 ( open blue triangles ) and @xmath240 ( filled black circles ) , for which the @xmath241 scatter is also shown . ] .
galaxy @xmath242 in lv sample is nearly complete down to 20 km / s .
error bar in vf on 20 km / s because of galaxies with unknown @xmath243 is smaller than symbol size .
vf of @xmath0cdm cr clues simulation ( black filled circles ) and @xmath0wdm 1kev simulation ( blue triangles ) are corrected for adiabatic compression .
arrows indicate @xmath0cdm - overabundance factors obtained with void - analysis.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] thus , with the reasonable assumption that halos with at least @xmath244km / s should contain galaxies we do have strong ( about factor of 10 ) @xmath0cdm - overabundance .
the problem is more severe than in the case of missing satellites since much less physics may be involved to explain the discrepancy for isolated galaxies .
@xmath0cdm - overabundance is much more prominent in terms of observational local volume ( lv karachentsev et al . , 2001 ) and model ( high resolution wmap5 and wmap3 clues http://www.clues-project.org/simulations ) cumulative circular velocity functions
vfs ( with corrections of dm halo peak circular velocity for adiabatic compression ) .
@xmath0cdm demonstrates evident discrepancy with observations which starts from rotational ( circular ) velocities @xmath245km / s and steeply increases towards smaller @xmath246 ( @xmath243 ) .
a factor of 3 @xmath0cdm overabundance is obtained with voids statistics on volume - limited ( vl ) local supercluster sample ( @xmath247mpc , @xmath248 , `` virgo '' hemisphere ) and it points in the direction of our previous results .
a factor of 10 @xmath0cdm overabundance on @xmath249 lv galaxy sample ( 8 mpc around mw ) is obtained by a comparison of the observed spectrum of mini - voids in the local volume with the spectrum of mini - voids determined from the @xmath0cdm simulations .
these two overabundance factors are nearly exact numerical points on real and model velocity function divergence if we use the lv tully - fisher dependence to correspond @xmath243 with @xmath250 .
different things coincide .
the @xmath0cdm model predicts much more dwarf objects than we do see as dwarf galaxies in our very local neighbourhood .
still possibilities of quenching of star formation in small halos such as different kinds of feedback or ( and ) uv photoheating during the epoch of reionization are proposed .
observational possibility to solve the discrepancy relies on the large amount of lsb galaxies to discover .
the population of dsphs in the field is rather limited .
there is only one confirmed nearby dsph in the field
kkr25 ( karachentsev et al . , 2001 ) and there are indications that we can not expect significant increase of new dsphs in the field
. other possible population should be of very low sb and thus such galaxies they should be quite extended .
this possibility meets some difficulties .
it is known that blind hi surveys did not find hi clouds with masses larger than @xmath251 which do not have optical counterpart . another possibility dwarf galaxies locate in dm halos which are significantly more massive than we may reasonably expect from galaxy dynamics i.e. by halo with circular velocity @xmath252 .
preliminary results indicate that they do not .
non - baryonic solution of the @xmath0cdm - overabundance with dm particles of kev mass scale ( @xmath0wdm - warm dark matter model ) is considered to be able to solve @xmath0cdm problems on small scales . wdm physics effectively acts as a truncation of @xmath0wdm power spectrum .
@xmath0wdm clues simulation with 1 kev particle gives much better answer than @xmath0cdm reproducing sizes of local minivoids .
the velocity function of 1 kev wdm lv - counterpart reproduce observational velocity function remarkably well . wdm model has its own difficulties such as uncertainties with star formation in dwarf wdm halos because of their late formation , problem of dwarf fake - halos appeared in wdm - like simulations by spurious fragmentation of filaments . by the way , it is still not clear how reliable are @xmath253-forest constraints which put a lower bound on probable mass of wdm particle ( boyanovsky , 2010 ) . * overall
we may conclude that kev dm particles deserve experimental attempts of their detection . * ) ( red circles ) is compared with the mean vff obtained from the 14 lvs in the @xmath0cdm simulation with haloes with circular velocity @xmath239 ( open triangles ) , @xmath254 ( open diamonds ) , and @xmath255 ( filled black circles ) , for which the @xmath241 scatter is also shown.,scaledwidth=50.0% ]
about one hundred participants ( from europe , north and south america , africa , armenia , china , india , israel , japan , korea , new zealand , russia , south africa , taiwan , ukraine ) attended the colloquium .
journalists , science editors and representatives of the directorates of several agencies were present in the colloquium .
discussions and lectures were outstanding .
inflection points in several current research lines emerged .
new important issues and conclusions arised and between them , it worths to highlight : results and the current state of missions and ongoing projects were reported by their teams : wmap7 , bicep , quad , spt , ami , act , planck , quijote , herschel , spire , atlas and hermes surveys . *
the wmap 7-year data and their cosmological interpretation were presented including the detection of primordial helium , significant improvements in the high multipole temperature data and of polarization data at all multipoles , new limits on inflation and properties of neutrinos .
the primordial spectral tilt is @xmath256 ( 68% cl ) , @xmath28 is excluded by 99.5% cl .
the latest 95% upper limit on the tensor - to - scalar ratio is @xmath257 ( from wmap+bao+@xmath101 ) .
* progress with cmb secondary anisotropies continue rapidly : first ` blank field ' sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) samples appearing and new constraints on high-@xmath2 cmb power spectrum .
they were recently providing some ` puzzles ' as sz amplitudes look sistematically smaller than theoretically expected .
the wmap-7 sz and the x - ray data are fine and agree but the existing _ theoretical _ models of the intracluster medium need revision since they overestimate the amount of the gas pressure ( and hence sz ) in clusters of galaxies .
distinction between relaxed and non - relaxed clusters becomes a crucial issue here , wmap-7 sz analysis showed this distinction is significant .
* the quijote - cmb experiment will provide unique information on the polarization emission ( synchrotron and anomalous ) from our galaxy at low frequencies , which will be of value for future b - mode experiments .
it will reach the sensitivity level to detect the b - mode signal due to primordial gravity waves if @xmath258 .
quijote will complement planck at low frequencies , the combined two experiments will allow improvement on @xmath41 information , galactic magnetic field determination , primordial magnetic fields . *
large scale cmb anisotropies provide information on the initial conditions of inflation .
early fast - roll inflation is generic , it mergers smoothly to slow roll and its inclusion provides a mechanism for lowest multipoles depression in the standard cosmological model .
fast - roll depression of the quadrupole sets to about @xmath53 the total number of inflation e - folds . *
the primordial cmb fluctuations are almost gaussian .
the effective theory of inflation la ginsburg - landau predicts negligible primordial non - gaussianity , negligible running scalar index and the tensor to scalar ratio @xmath41 in the range @xmath259 , with the best value @xmath260 at reach of the next cmb observations .
forecasted @xmath70-detection probability for planck with 4 sky coverages is border line .
improved measurements on @xmath261 as well as on te and ee modes will improve these constraints on @xmath70 even if a detection will be lacking .
results from planck are eagerly expected . * first results from herschel atlas and hermes surveys
were reported : number counts and surface density of sub - mm galaxies , clustering of the resolved sources , and the herschel - spire legacy survey ( hsls ) programme : 2.5 to 3 million sources ( at least 2000 bright lensed galaxies and 10,000 dusty galaxies at z larger than 5 ) , cross - correlation with cmb maps for the isw and cmb lensing signal traced by dusty , starbursts at z of 1 - 3 . *
most of the baryons that we expect to be associated with galaxies are missing .
the cosmic baryon fraction is well quantified : @xmath110 .
an inventory of the detected baryons in individual cosmic structures like galaxies and clusters of galaxies falls short of this universal value . on the largest scales of clusters ,
most but not all of the expected baryons are detected .
the fraction of detected baryons decreases monotonically from the cosmic baryon fraction as a function of mass . in the smallest dwarf galaxies ,
fewer than 1% of the expected baryons are detected .
it is an observational challenge to identify the missing baryons , and a theoretical one to understand the observed variation with the mass . * a robust analysis of stellar kinematics in dsph galaxies in order to determine the true dark matter distribution
have been presented : it is based on new studies of several thousand precision velocities in dsph galaxies , with sophisticated mcmc - based comparison of models and data .
the stellar populations in dsph galaxies and in the milky way halo are now well - established to be quite different . the milky way is not formed from dsph - like systems .
very substantial progress is being made in quantifying feedback from the chemical distributions and star formation histories of the dsph : feedback does not operate as has been suggested , feedback was extremely mild in the lowest luminosity galaxies and does not substantially modify initial conditions . * an ` universal rotation curve ' ( urc ) of spiral galaxies was discovered from 3200 individual observed rotation curves ( rcs ) well reproduces out to the virial radius the rotation curve of any spiral galaxy .
this urc is the observational counterpart to which the circular velocity profile emerging in cosmological simulations must comply .
large n - body numerical simulations performed in the @xmath0cdm scenario lead to the well known nfw halo cuspy density profile .
however , a careful analysis from about 100 observed high quality rotation curves has now * ruled out * the disk + nfw halo mass model , in favor of * cored profiles*. + the observed galaxy surface density appears to be universal within @xmath262 with values around @xmath263 for galactic systems spanning over 14 magnitudes , different hubble types , morphologies and mass profiles determined by several independent methods . * the features observed in the cosmic - ray spectrum by auger , pamela , fermi , hess , cream and others can be all quantitatively explained with the action of cosmic rays accelerated in the magnetic winds of very massive star explosions such as wolf - rayet stars , without any significant free parameter .
all these observations of cosmic ray positrons and electrons and the like are due to normal astrophysical sources and processes , and do not require hypothetical decay or annihilation of heavy dm particles .
the models of annihilation or decay of heavy dark matter become more and more tailored to explain these normal astrophysical processes and their ability to survive observations is more and more reduced .
* sterile neutrinos with mass in the @xmath264 range are suitable warm dark matter candidates that may help solve the small scale problems of the @xmath0cdm concordance model .
these neutrinos can decay into an active - like neutrino and an x - ray photon .
abundance and phase space density of dwarf spheroidal galaxies constrain the mass to be in the @xmath16 kev range .
small scale aspects of sterile neutrinos and different mechanisms of their production were presented : the transfer function and power spectra are obtained by solving the collisionless boltzmann equation during the radiation and matter dominated eras : as a consequence , the power spectra features new wdm acoustic oscillations on mass scales @xmath265 . * a right - handed neutrino of a mass of a few kev appears as the most interesting candidate to constitute dark matter .
a consequence should be lyman alpha emission and absorption at around a few microns ; corresponding emission and absorption lines might be visible from molecular hydrogen h@xmath14 and h@xmath15 and their ions , in the far infrared and sub - mm wavelength range .
the detection at very high redshift of massive star formation , stellar evolution and the formation of the first super - massive black holes would constitute the most striking and testable prediction of this specific dark matter particle proposal .
* clues numerical simulations with warm dark matter of mass of @xmath96 kev have been presented and its predicted galaxy distribution in the local universe for the @xmath0wdm cosmogony agrees well with the observed one in the alfalfa survey . on the contrary ,
the @xmath0cdm model predicts a steep rise in the velocity function towards low velocities and thus forecasts much more sources both in virgo - direction as well as in anti - virgo - direction than the ones observed by the alfalfa survey .
these results indicate problems for the cold dark matter paradigm , also the spectrum of mini - voids points to a problem of the @xmath0cdm model .
the @xmath0wdm model provides a natural solution to this problem . * the non - baryonic solution of the @xmath0cdm - overabundance with dm particles of kev mass scale ( @xmath0wdm - warm dark matter ) is considered to be able to solve @xmath0cdm problems on small scales .
wdm physics effectively acts as a truncation of the @xmath0cdm power spectrum .
@xmath0wdm clues simulation with 1 kev particles gives much better answer than @xmath0cdm when reproducing sizes of local minivoids .
the velocity function of 1 kev wdm local volume - counterpart reproduces the observational velocity function remarkably well .
overall , kev dm particles deserve dedicated experimental efforts of their detection .
* facts and status of dm : astrophysical observations points the existence of dm . despite of that , proposals to replace dm by modifing the laws of physics did appeared .
notice that modifying gravity spoils the standard model of cosmology and particle physics supported by cmb and lss observations not providing an alternative .
* after more than twenty active years the subject of dm is mature and it appears divided in three sets : ( a ) particle physics dm model building beyond the standard model of particle physics , dedicated laboratory experiments , annhilating dm , all concentrated on wimps .
( b ) astrophysical dm : astronomical observations , astrophysical models .
( c ) numerical cdm ( wimps ) simulations . :
the results of ( a ) and ( b ) do not agree and ( b ) and ( c ) do not agree neither at small scales . none of the small scale predictions of cdm wimps simulations have been observed : cusps , over abundance of substructures by a huge factor .
in addition , all direct dedicated searchs of wimps from more than twenty years gave null results .
something is going wrong in the dm research .
what is going wrong and why ? * astronomical observations strongly indicate that * dark matter halos are cored till scales below 1 kpc*. more precisely , the measured cores * are not * hidden cusps .
numerical simulations with wimps ( particles heavier than @xmath266 gev ) without * and * with baryons yield cusped dark matter halos .
adding baryons do not alleviate the problems of wimps simulations , on the contrary adiabatic contraction increases the central density of cups worsening the discrepancies with astronomical observations . * the results of numerical simulations
must be confronted to observations .
the discrepancies of cdm wimps simulations with the astronomical observations at small scales @xmath267 kpc * keep growing and growing * : satellite problem ( for example , only 1/3 of satellites predicted by wimps simulations around our galaxy are observed ) , voids problem , peculiar velocities problem ( the observations show larger velocities than wimp simulations ) , size problem ( wimp simulations produce too small galaxies ) .
* the use of kev scale dm particles in the simulations alleviate all the above problems .
for the core - cusp problem , setting the velocity dispersion of kev scale dm particles seems beyond the present resolution of computer simulations
. analytic work in the linear approximation produces cored profiles for kev scale dm particles and cusped profiles for wimps .
model - independent analysis of dm from phase - space density and surface density observational data plus theoretical analysis points to a dm particle mass in the kev scale .
the dark matter particle candidates with high mass ( 100 gev , `` wimps '' ) became strongly disfavored , while cored ( non cusped ) dark matter halos and light ( kev scale mass ) dark matter are being increasingly favoured from theory and astrophysical observations .
* as a conclusion , the dark matter particle candidates with large mass ( @xmath268 gev , the so called ` wimps ' ) became strongly disfavored , while light ( kev scale mass ) dark matter are being increasingly favoured both from theory , numerical simulations and a wide set of astrophysical observations .
* many researchers continue to work with @xmath0cdm at small scales and to perform simulations with heavy dm candidates ( mass @xmath269 gev ) despite the * growing * evidence that these dm particles do not reproduce the small scale astronomical observations ( @xmath267 kpc ) .
[ the kev scale dm particles naturally produce the observed small scale structure ] .
the answer to this strategic question is certainly not strictly scientific .
it should be recalled that the connection between small scale structure features and the mass of the dm particle directly follows from the value of the free - streaming length @xmath270 and is well known .
structures smaller than @xmath270 are erased by free - streaming .
dm particles with mass in the kev scale give @xmath271 kpc while 100 gev dm particles produce an extremely small @xmath272 pc . while @xmath271 kpc is in nice agreement with the astronomical observations , a @xmath270 a million times smaller requires the existence of a host of dm smaller scale structures till a distance of the size of the oort s cloud in the solar system . no structures of this type
have ever been observed .
* _ ` examine the objects as they are and you will see their true nature ; look at them from your own ego and you will see only your feelings ; because nature is neutral , while your feelings are only prejudice and obscurity ' _ * shao yong , 1011 - 1077 [ quoted by gerry gilmore in his lecture ] .
all the colloquium lectures can be found at : * http://www.chalonge.obspm.fr/colloque2010.html * best congratulations and acknowledgements to all lectures and participants which made the 14th paris cosmology colloquium 2010 so fruitful and interesting , the ecole dastrophysique daniel chalonge looks forward for you for the next colloquium of this series .
we thank anton tikhonov for having kindly provided to us the three figures reproduced in the following pages ( nearby galaxy data by igor d. karachentsev fig .
[ obs ] ; clues simulations with 1 kev dm particles fig .
[ kev ] and clues simulations with wimps dm particles fig .
[ wimp ] ) .
the readers can compare the galaxy observations in fig .
[ obs ] with the results of wdm 1 kev simulations in fig .
[ kev ] and with the wimps cdm simulations fig .
[ wimp ] and see which simulations better agree with the observations .
we recall that the highlights and conclusions of the chalonge 13th paris cosmology colloquium 2010 @xcite and the chalonge cias dark matter meudon workshop 2010 are available in the arxiv @xcite . * galaxy observations * * simulations with 1 kev dm particles * wdm 1 kev clues wmap3 simulation with halos of circular velocity @xmath273 km / s from anton tikhonov .
more distant objects are dimer . ] * simulations with heavy wimps as dm particles * cdm wmap5 simulation with @xmath273 km / s from anton tikhonov .
more distant objects are dimer . ]
* the nature of dark matter * + 0.5 cm p.l . biermann@xmath274 + 0.5 cm @xmath9 mpi for radioastronomy , bonn , germany ; @xmath10 dept . of phys . , karlsruher institut fr technologie kit , germany , @xmath5 dept . of phys .
, univ . of alabama ,
tuscaloosa , al , usa ; @xmath11 dept . of phys .
, univ . of alabama at huntsville ,
al , usa ; @xmath12 dept . of phys . & astron . , univ . of bonn ,
germany ; + anthony ( tony ) n. * lasenby * ( cambridge ) : the cmb in the standard model of the universe , a status report . big progress with secondary anisotropy experiments , new results on sz samples and high - l cmb power spectrum ; sz amplitudes look systematically smaller than expected ; modern frontiers are polarization and high - wavenumber power spectrum ; photon diffusion around recombination , thomson scattering generates linear polarization with rms order 5 microk ; need to measure nanok ; gravity waves allow to approach physics at gut scale ; various experiments measure wavenumber around a few tens to a few thousands - many balloon uld ( ultra - long - duration ) flights 2010 and future ; premier european experiment is called quijote , 10 - 36 ghz , angular resolution about 1 degree ; shows planck one - year sky map ; bicep gives the best direct limit on polarization , tensor - to - scalar ratio ; bicep2 test map shows dust polarization in galactic plane at 1 - 3 percent level ; polarization patterns of stacked hot and cold spots in wmap7 03100273 , 0405341 and 0710.5737 give special cold spot suggesting 3d texture ; talks about biaxially symmetric bianchi ix models for the universe , a generalized frw model ; dechant et al .
prd 79 , 043524 ( 2009 ) ; structure on the largest scale could stem from an epoch , when the universe was oblate ? ? ? ; see lasenby & doran 2005 ; efstathiou ( 2003 ) ; dark flows kashlinsky et al . 2008 , 2009 , 2010 ;
feldman , hudson , watkins 2008 , 2009 ; dechant , lasenby & hobson 1007.1662 ; see taub ( 1951 ann.math.phys .
53 , 472 ) ; ami : eight 13 m telescopes for sz measurements in cambridge ; for large clusters the sz detection is independent of redshift of the cluster , a 32h observations should give 20 sigma detection ; candidate cluster detection in one of heir blank fields ; another bullet type cluster , a2146 , russell et al .
1004.1559 ; 13sigma detection in 9h with ami ; complex bulk flow motions ; cbi and bima see excess emission at wave - numbers larger than 2000 ; friedman et al .
0901.4334 ; quad disagrees with cbi ; luecker et al . 0912.4317 ; vanderline et al .
1003.0003 ; andersson et a. 1006.3068 ; fowler et al .
1001.2934 ; menateau et al .
1006.5126 ; conflict with sz expectations ; cmb power spectrum goes flat and slowly increases with very high wavenumber ; upon questioning he states that indeed weak radio sources make up a large part of the signal ; it does require modelling ... 0.5 cm eiichiro * komatsu * ( austin ) : wmap7 results : cosmological interpretation ; 9 years of data by august 2010 ; first detection of primordial helium ; tilt less than unity ; improved neutrino limits ; confirmed polarization patterns around cold / hot spots ; measurement of sz : missing pressure ?
series of papers in 2010 , all on arxiv ; power - spectrum slightly better after 7 years than 5 years ; @xmath275 ; more helium implies fewer electrons , and so enhances damping ; ratio of first cmb power - spectrum peak to second gives baryon density , first to third gives matter density , including dm ; sum mass of various neutrinos @xmath276 ev , using @xmath101 ; cmb polarization is generated by local temperature quadrupole anisotropy ; on large angular scales @xmath277 newton s grav pot/3 ; discusses temperature signal from potential disturbances , from velocity disturbances , gravitational waves .. ; here are 12387 hot spots , and 12628 cold spots - stack them ; discusses e - mode and b - mode : e - mode detected , b - mode next holy grail " ; wmap data consistent with simple single - field inflation models ; sz effect ( 1969 + 1972 ) decrement @xmath278 217 ghz , increment @xmath279 217 ghz ; significant difference between relaxed and non - relaxed clusters ; sz effect and cmb fluctuations can now be separated , example coma cluster ; using arnaud et al profile outer part gives good convergence between many clusters : discrepancy komatsu et al .
2010 ; key point is that cooling flow clusters are relaxed , all non - cooling flow clusters are non - relaxed clusters ; arnaud et al profile ruled out , reason arnaud et al did not distinguish relaxed and non - relaxed clusters ; cosmic ray and magnetic field pressure might be important , details highly uncertain ; fermi satellite detects no gamma rays , so cr pressure in a certain energy range of the particles low ; my comment that ism already very complicated , determining for instance b and b@xmath280 gives very discrepant results , so sz discrepancies almost certainly imply that we learn physics of intra - cluster medium ... 0.5 cm rafael * rebolo * ( tenerife ) : cmb polarization : the quijote experiment : dodelson 2003 etc ; scattering generates polarization ; two orthogonal components , e - mode : tangential around any hot spot ; b - mode gives vortex like pattern around a spot : kamionkowske et al .
1997 ; seljak & zaldarriga 1997 ; scalar perturbations give e - mode , no b - mode ; gravitational waves gives e and b - mode - i wonder about vortices in the gas given by tidal forces ( a. lasenby answered this : non - linear effect ) ; kovac et al .
2002 nature ; jarosik et al .
2010(wmap7 ) ; komatsu et al . 2010
( wmap7 ) ; chiang et al .
2010 ( wmap7 ) ; quijote science goals cosmological parameters from e - mode polarization measurements ; built at teide observatory ; teide obs .
is run by iac ( tenerife ) ; first step goal five polarization maps in 10 - 30 ghz to correct the 30 ghz from foreground emission and then determine the b - mode polarization ; tucci , m. et al . give the contribution of extragalactic radio sources ( mn 386 , 1729 , 2008 ) ; discusses the contribution from spinning and magnetic dust ( ? ) ; lazarian & draine 2000 apj ; status of experiment ; i expressed a bit of skepticism on our understanding of foreground emission , and its characteristics , such as spottiness and spectral index ; i also asked about the influence of rotation of density perturbations and its effect on scattering - rotation is due to tidal forces most people think ;
... 0.5 cm hector j. * de vega * ( paris ) : inflation and kev dm in the standard model of the universe ; out of equilibrium evolution of fast expansion , explosive particle production , see 0901.0549 ; inflation ends after finite number of e - folds , about 60 ; wmap7 gives scale of inflation ; it turns out that the scale of inflation is the gut scale , @xmath281gev , nice coincidence or key ?
; see 0703417 , 1003.6108 ; double well potential favored ; our present universe was built from the quantum fluctuations at the end of inflation ; dm distribution fct freezes out at decoupling ; phase space density q argument using gilmore et al .
2007 and later , @xmath282 ; @xmath283 ; @xmath284 between 1 and a few @xmath285 ; dm mass of particle @xmath286 , order kev ; 0710.5180 , 0901.0922 ; shows graph of @xmath287 for wimps , kev dm particles , and 10 ev dm particles , p(k ) cut for kev dm particles at @xmath288 kpc ; for all larger scales irrelevant , no difference to wimps ; argues for universal quantities , like @xmath199 , surface density of dm , and dm density profiles ; universal quantities may be attractors in the poincare sense ; energy scales as volume , but entropy scales as surface ; satisfies bekenstein bound ( probably 1973 prd paper ) ; using then the surface densities gives about 2.6 kev ( marginally higher for fermions ) ; see m.g .
walker et al . 2009 ( observations ) , i.m .
vass et al . 2009
( simulations ) ; his conclusion dm particle between 1.6 and 2 kev ; my comment : how about the argument on sub - thermal behaviour by mikhail shaposhnikov ( 2006/2007 ) ? ; in terms of scale @xmath128 , central density , and halo velocity dispersion wimps contradict data by many orders of magnitude ; argues that right - handed neutrinos most natural ; see galeazzi et al 2001 prl 86 , 1978 ; argues the empty slot of right - handed neutrinos can be filled with kev scale right - handed neutrinos ; results : a ) reproduces the phase space density , b ) universal galaxy profiles hdv + nosa 2009 ) ; c ) universal surface density ( hoffman et al .
2007 ; hdv + nosa 2010 ) ; d ) alleviates satellite problem ; e ) alleviates the void problem ; also mentions our work , blasi & serpico 2009 , kashlinsky et al .
2008 , watkins et al .
2009 , lee & komatsu 2010 ; hdv et al .
1004.1908 , 0907.0006 , 0901.0922 ; mentions a discrepancy in helioseismology ( asplund et al .
2009 ) ; in discussion nosa and hdv state that @xmath284 larger for spirals than for dsphs ; big debate with komatsu , incomprehensible ; tikhonov asks about lyman alpha constraints on dm kev particles : salucci answers that there are problems to give quantitative bounds from lyman alpha since the data are not very reliable ; hdv says that these lyman alpha constraints only concern the dodelson - widrow model of sterile neutrinos .
i remember from another discussion that there is no serious problem here ; ...
0.5 cm daniel * boyanovsky * ( pittsburgh ) : kev dm particle candidates , sterile neutrinos ; mentions strigari et al .
; he mentions that rh neutrinos couple only to left - handed neutrinos via a seesaw mass matrix ; rh neutrinos may also solve the other problems of voids , and massive halos ; mentions kusenko & loewenstein claim of the discovery of an emission line possibly from the decay of a rh neutrino , 0912.0552 now in apjl ; mixing angles @xmath289 to @xmath290 are necessary ( see recent kusenko review ) ; phase space density is conserved , so @xmath291 : phase space density diminished in violent relaxation mergers ! ; uses then boltzmann - einstein equation for dm , radiation , and baryonic density ; distinguishes three stages , i ) relativistic free streaming , radiation dominated , ii ) non - relativistic free streaming , but still radiation dominated , and iii ) matter dominated , and non - relativistic free streaming ; decaying ( q ) and growing ( p ) modes ; production models : a ) non - resonant dodelson - widrow production via sterile - active mixing , b ) boson decay : scalar and vector boson decay , all with thermal distribution fct at 100 gev ; wdm acoustic oscillations at very small scales , in wavenumber @xmath292 one example ; program from micro to macro ... 0.5 cm stefan * gottloeber * ( potsdam ) : constrained local universe simulations ( clues ) ; nice pictures of simulations ; bolshoi simulations gives good integral mass fcts for galaxies , looks like @xmath293 ; require both very large scale and also very good mass resolution - impossible of present day computers , so use nested simulations ; so constrained " local universe simulations , try to simulate the local environment of our galaxy ; shows lots of nice 3d movies ; mass accretion histories of the dm halos ; @xmath294 solar masses at redshift 4 , and about @xmath295 today ; satellites tend to enter our galaxy froma preferred directions ; the matter stripped from these subhalos retains a memory of that direction ; cosmology with wdm : shows parallel simulations , with cdm and wdm ; he concludes , that @xmath296 kev is a lower limit ; hi arecibo survey gives lf , and cdm does not fit , wdm fits - lower lf , zavals et al .
2009 ; spectrum of mini - voids ( tikhonov 2009 ; later talk ) ; also suggests wdm models ; critical mass @xmath297 of star formation : for halos with less mass no star formation : runs from @xmath298 solar masses at redshift 6 to @xmath299 solar masses today ; make dm decay sky models , antonio cuesta et al . ; some questions about this simulated sky map , contributions from galactic halo , local universe ; there must be an olbers paradox for such models ; ... 0.5 cm claudio * destri * ( milano ) : fast - roll eras in the effective theory of inflation , low cmb multipoles and a mcmc analysis of the cmb + lss data : [email protected] ; many eqs ; horizon problem ; entropy of the universe dominated by photons and neutrinos ; tensor - scalar ratio in generic single - field inflation ; paper with claudio d. : boyanovsky et al .
2009 ijmpa 24 ; using wmap + other data tensor to scalar ratio @xmath3000.025 , best fit 0.05 ; destri - de vega - sanchez 0906.4102 ; pre - inflation stage @xmath301 .. , slow - roll inflation stage @xmath302 .. , radiation dominated stage @xmath303 .. , matter dominated stage @xmath304 .. ; destri - de vega - sanchez phys .
rev . d81 ( 2010 ) .
komatsu et al .
apj 2010 cmb polarization ; ayaita et al .
prd 2010 on too few hot spots ; bennett et al .
1001.4758 ; destri + hdv + nosa prd 78 , 023013 ( 2008 ) ; fast roll depression sets to about 64 the number of e - folds in inflation ; 1003.6108 ; additional explanations by nosa ; 0.5 cm carlos s. * frenk * ( durham ) : cosmology in our backyard : first detection possibilities for detecting of supersymmetric cold dark matter particles ; a ) at lhc , b ) underground las , c ) indirectly via decay emission ; peebles 1982 , davis et al .
1985 , bardeen et al . 19
.. ; sanchez et al .
2006 ; at really small scales the nature of dm really plays a role ; non - baryonic dm candidates , a ) hot , neutrino , b ) warm , sterile neutrino , c ) cold , axion , neutralino ; free - streaming cutoff , @xmath305 for 100 gev wimp ; vie et al .
2008 , boyarsky et al .
2009;@xmath306 ... ; davis et al .
1985 again ; 30 ev neutrinos give too much clumping in simulations ; warm dm gives less small structure , same large scale structure in simulations as cdm , gao et al .
; test cdm on a ) structure of dark matter halos , b ) number of satellites , c ) remnants of merging , streams ; shows movies ; more massive halos and halos that form earlier have higher density , navarro , frenk , white 1997 ; there is no obvious density plateau at the center in these simulations ; springel et al . 2008 ; 6 different galaxy size halos simulated at varying resolution , with the highest at 15 pc softening scale , and @xmath307 particles ; density profile of nfw goes down to very small radii ; slight but significant deviations from similarity : simulations give cuspy profiles : spike at center ; but how about nature ? ; halo likely to be modified by the galaxy forming in it ; vikhlinin in et al . 2006 ; central profiles of clusters are very well fitted by nfw ; data from 2 to 0.01 of @xmath308 ; carlos frenk clearly says : cdm predicts cusps ; bradac et al .
2008 ; to study dwarf spheroidal galaxies with jeans eq , terms stellar density profile , radial velocity dispersion and anisotropy ; assumes anisotropy zero ; milky way dwarfs test @xmath309 in the limit of small radius @xmath310 , all galaxies have either a = 0.5 or a = 1 ( nfw ) ; strigari , frenk , white 2010 ; conclusion : photometric and kinematic data for milky way satellites consistent with cuspy nfw profiles ; he emphasizes that he is testing for cuspy profiles , he is not testing core - profiles ; he is only testing data versus prediction , and his prediction was cusps , and finds that the data are fully consistent ; nosa contradicts him , and says cdm is more than his fits , of course also true ; she emphasizes that a more complete theory fails for cdm ; carlos frenk in turn emphasizes that he is not testing such things , he is just testing his cdm version via nfw - updates , and only to its limits , as done in the aquarius runs ; some arguments on the assumption of an - isotropy in phase space , which he does not use ; next step in his argument sub - halos : simulations produce @xmath311 sub - halos , observations detect only a few tens ; argues about strigari et al .
2008 : wdm or astrophysics inside cdm halos ?
normal conclusion is that there is a special scale in cosmology ; he argues about astrophysics , see gao & lovell 2011 ; questions : how many sub - halos make a visible galaxy ; millenium run compared with 2df .. observations ; benson et al . 2003 ; sn feedback and photoionization ; at high mass agn feedback ; with these two / three effects predicted mass factor comes down ; kauffmann et al .
1993 , bullock et al . 2001 , benson et al . 2002 ; reports about big argument with scott tremaine ; koposov et al . 2008 ; cooper et al .
2009 ; okamooto & frenk 2009 ; okamoto et al . ;
irwin ; compares visible satellites and dark satellites ; he has reionization at redshift 9 ; finds a critical velocity from reionization , and that defines the critical mass which is visible , not sterile neutrino ; states strongly , if cdm is right , the dark sub - halos must be there ; dandan hu + aq 2009 , 2010 ; cooper et al .
2010 ; bernard sadoulet asks about the cornell hi arecibo project and what carlos frenk predicts ; life is complicated is the answer ; his main point is that cdm can not so easily be ruled out ; 0.5 cm gerard ( gerry ) f. * gilmore * ( cambridge ) : dm on small astrophysical scales : where are we with dwarf spheroidal galaxies ?
a ) sizes , b ) ages / chemical abundances / first stars , c ) kinematics , d ) masses ; sgr dsph ( ibata et al . 1995 ) proves that late minor merging occurs in mw , but not dominant in evolution of mw except ion outer halo @xmath279 25 kpc ; oh et al . , de blok et al .
2008 ; states cusped dm is very hard to find " ; kuijken & gilmore 1989 , 1991 remains the only experimental determination of dm density ; satellite number problem , moore et al 1999 ; one can limit feedback from chemical enrichment data ; belokurov et al . 2006a ; governato et al .
2010 ; updated field of streams ; update from gilmore et al .
2007 ; absolute magnitude versus half - light - radius show globular clusters versus small galaxies : show clear gap ; belokurov et al .
2009 , 2010 ; chemistry ?
big scatter from single sne ?
metallicity depletion and energy feedback connects clearly to gas loss ; wyse & gilmore 1993 ; shows diagram of o / fe versus fe / h to distinguish the various imfs and sne ; kobashi et al .
2006 ; ruchti et all 2010 ; dsphs vs mw abundances , halo / thick disk is not dsph graveyard ; koch et al . 2008 ; shetrone et al . 2008 ; frebel et al . 2009 ; aoki et al .
2009 ; ... ; metallicity luminosity relation : norris , gilmore et al .
2010a , b , .. ; dispersion in metallicity increases as luminosity decreases- consistent with stochastic inhomogeneous enrichment , gentle feedback ; significant stripping ruled out ; wyse & gilmore 1995 ; edvardsson et al . 1993 ; g - dwarf problem ?
nomoto , komatsu et al stellar evolution of zero heavy element stars ; finds carbon rich extremely metal - poor stars ! stars in dsphs are younger , and have different chemistry than the halo and thick disk stars ; strigari et al .
2008 nature diagram extended to @xmath312 ; shows fe / h , m / l and mass within 300 pc across @xmath313 to @xmath314 ; determines the true velocity dispersion of some systems to be of order 3 km / s ; many velocity dispersions of order 5 km / s : clear implication , that this can not be due to temperature effects , too cold ; stellar density increases ; walker et al . 2006 , 2009 , gilmore et al . ; koch , gg et al .
2007 ; cored and cusped halo profiles fit almost equally well ! cores slightly favored , but not conclusive ; playing on anisotropy of phase space ; reminds that the use of the jeans equation assumes a given velocity dispersion profile - hat is the key mistake in using this eq ( essentially hydrostatic equilibrium for a stellar distribution ) ; now they use velocity distribution fcts ; wu & tremaine 2006 , wu 2007 , lukas 2002 + 2005 , wilkinson et al .
2002 ; dispersion profile as test - positive ; conclusions : a ) minimum physical scale for galaxies , half light radius @xmath279 100 pc , b ) cored ( ? ) profiles , with similar low mean mass densities @xmath315 phase space density fairly constant , maximum for galaxies , are the the first halos ?
c ) pre - galactic abundances ; ... long discussion between carlos frenk and gerry gilmore ; ... at tea / coffee had a discussion with gg : he confirmed that his key work was on the reionization and feedback argument for small galaxies , and his work demonstrates that a ) the velocity dispersion for many is smaller than a temperature effect can reproduce , and b ) that the required star formation history for the feedback argument fails ; these small galaxies do show a special mass scale ; ... they show a mass distribution , and this distribution peaks around @xmath316 ; .. 0.5 cm paolo * salucci * ( trieste ) : universality properties in galaxies and cored density profiles ( cores -@xmath279 no spike ) ; 1996 mn , 2007 mn , 2009 mn ; shows diagram central surface brightness vs magnitude ; fraction of luminosity versus fraction of radial scale universal profile for spirals ; no dm in the innermost regions of galaxies ; giant ellipticals : no dm at center , velocity dispersion not controlled by dm ; the slope of @xmath317 is crucial : the slope measures the presence of dm ; introduces the details of his universal rotation curve ( urc ) " ; burkert profile provides excellent fit , better than nfw ; halo mass fct @xmath318 ; tries out his parametrization on galaxy eso 116- ... and burkert fits best ; 50 objects investigates , nfw inconsistent ; ddo47 also does not work with nfw ; length scale of galaxy correlates with core radius , donato et al . 2004 ; central baryonic surface density constant among galaxies ( gentile et al . 2009
nature ) ; shows some amazing colorful movies to illustrate things ; carlos frenk defends the nfw work ; paolo s. points out that some of his work was done and published before nfw ( 1997 ) ; long debate on core vs cusp ( density spike ) , between carkos frenk and nosa + hdv ; ... before start discussion with paolo salucci on the history of the arguments about rotation curves ; suggested that many early papers misleading in the sense , that there was an argument only on invisible matter , not on any cosmological contribution .
even zwicky ( 1933 ) talked about baryonic missing matter , like oort 1932 .
0.5 cm stacy s. * mcgaugh * ( maryland ) : baryon content of cosmic structures and its relation to dm ; @xmath319 , and @xmath320 , but structure ?
average ratio 0.17 ; mcgaugh et al .
2010 : clusters dominant baryons gas @xmath321 , groups stars ?
@xmath322 , ellipticals stars @xmath322 , spirals , gas rich late spirals , dsph satellites ; clusters may have less than the global average in baryonic fraction @xmath323 ; giodini et al .
2009 ; @xmath323 for stars increase with lower mass clusters , while the dominant gas @xmath323 decreases with lower mass towards groups , where the two fractions overlap ; spirals stars , atomic gas , molecular gas , young & knezek 1989 , mcgaugh & blok 1997 ; molecular gas tricky , he uses scaling relation ( if co , bad ) ; ngc2403 fraternali et al . ;
lund et al . 2006 ; xue et al .
2008 ; sellwood & mcgaugh 2005 ; total mass of galaxy @xmath324 ; mcgaugh 2004 , 2005 ; baryonic tully - fisher relation ; ellipticals faber - jackson relation ; he ignores gas in groups , says too little known ( my comment : we detected hot gas in groups almost 30 years ago , and published in apjl ; in one case it was a lot of gas , ngc5846 ) ; stark et al .
2009 , trachternach et al . 2009 ; kuzio de naray et al . 2006 . 2007 ,
etc ) ; local dwarf data walker et al .
2009 , mateo et al .
1998 , martin et al . 2008 ; @xmath325 ; various models 2010 , trujilo - gomez et al . ,
de rossi , unreadable ; detected baron fraction declines with decreasing total mass ; stellar mass fraction peaks between @xmath295 and @xmath322 ; galaxies suffer a baryon deficit problem ; could be molecular , see pfenniger & combes ; pfenniger & revaz 2005 ; hoekstra et al .
2001 ; pederson et al ; anderson & bregman 2010 ; mcgaugh & wolf 2010 ; reionization does not seem to work ; best bet ? ?
maybe gas ( just as jerry ostriker says ) ; 0.5 cm asantha * cooray * ( irvine , he ) : first large scale structure and cosmologiocal results from atlas and hermes surveys with the herschel observatory ( came out a few days ago ) : shows many maps with very high angular resolution in multiple - color , three long wavelength fir ; @xmath326 ; achieved instrument noise in repeated 30 arcsec beam about 10 mjy / beam ( nguyen et al .
2010 ) ; spire instrument noise = confusion noise in 2 repeat scans ; at 2 micron and at 200 micron the same w m@xmath140 sr@xmath327 , so same energy density ; spire source counts at 250 micron oliver et al .
2010 ; xu et al .
2003 , lagache et al .
2004 , negrello et al .
2007 , le borgne et al .
2009 , pearson et al .
2009 , rowan - rowinson 2009 , valiante et al .
2009 , ... , number counts of bright galaxies ( ulirgs+ ) over - predicted by models ; source counts reach 80 percent of bg at 250 micron , 80 percent at 350 percent , and 85 percent of 500 micron , using counts , @xmath328 analysis , and stacking ; colors generally spread redder than models predict , so colder dust or higher redshift ( as we argued ) ; the most likely explanation , he says , is actually high redshift ; gruppioni et al . 2010
; eales et al . 2010
; starbursts dominate at high @xmath329 and high @xmath330 ; elbaz et al .
2010 ; l. shao 2010 ; argument that starburst and agn luminosities coupled by mergers ( sure .. ) ; amblard et al .
2010 ; dowell et al . 2010 ; zemcov et al . 2010 ; cooray et al . 2010 ; bulk of far - ir bg produced by milky - way like halos at redshifts 1 to 3 ; special a&a issue on herschel out ; esa first results symposium talks online ; cooray et al . 2010 ; 0.5 cm anton * tikhonov * ( st . petersburg ) : sizes of mini - voids and the tully - fisher relation in the local volume ; another cdm overabundance problem and its possible solution ; compares spectrum of void sizes in local volume sample with simulations ; karachentsev et al .
2007 , 2004 ; tikhonov & klypin 2009 ; tully et al .
2008 apj ; defines cumulative void fct ; tikhonv & kararentsev 2007 as a fct of void size , about 1 at 1 mpc , and about 0.2 at 4 mpc , all in local volume ( maybe volume fraction of voids above a certain size ) ; the observed void fct disagrees strongly with lcdm simulations , theory a factor of 10 more than observed ; makarov & karantentsev 2010 ; afanasiev & moiseev 2005 ; begun et al .
2006 ; possible solutions : a ) hundreds of dsphs or lsbs still to find , b ) dwarf galaxies are hosted by significantly more massive halos , c ) dwarf formation was suppressed , d ) lwdm , truncation of scales , @xmath331 kev ; ... chengalur & begum ( gmrt ) ; 0.5 cm * plb * ( bonn , tuscaloosa ) : dark matter has been detected since 1933 ( zwicky ) and basically behaves like a non - em - interacting gravitational gas of particles . from particle physics supersymmetry
suggests with an elegant argument that there should be a lightest supersymmetric particle , which is a dark matter candidate , possibly visible via decay in odd properties of energetic particles and photons : observations have discovered i ) an upturn in the cr - positron fraction ( pamela : adriani et al .
2009 nature ) , ii ) an upturn in the cr - electron spectrum ( atic : chang et al .
2008 nature ; fermi : aharonian et al
. 2009 aa ) , iii ) a flat radio emission component near the galactic center ( wmap haze : dobler & finkbeiner 2008 apj ) , iv ) a corresponding ic component in gamma rays ( fermi haze : dobler et al .
2010 , su et al .
2010 arxiv ) , v ) the 511 kev annihilation line also near the galactic center ( integral : weidenspointner et al .
2008 newar ) , and most recently , vi ) an upturn in the cr - spectra of all elements from helium ( cream : ahn et al .
2009 apj , 2010 apjl ; for h and he the upturn has been confirmed by pamela , shown at the cospar meeting july 2010 ) .
all these features can be quantitatively explained with the action of cosmic rays accelerated in the magnetic winds of very massive stars , when they explode ( biermann et al .
2009 prl , 2010 apjl ) , based on well - defined predictions from 1993 ( biermann 1993 aa , biermann & cassinelli 1993 aa , biermann & strom 1993 aa , stanev et al 1993 aa ) . while the leptonic part of these observations may be explainable with pulsars and their winds , the hadronic part clearly needs very massive stars , such as wolf - rayet stars , their winds and their explosions . what the cosmic ray work ( biermann et al . , from 1993 through 2010 ) shows , that allowing for the magnetic field topology of wolf rayet star winds ( see , e.g. parker 1958 apj ) , both the leptonic and the hadronic part get readily and quantitatively explained , close to the predictions , without any significant free parameter , so by occam s razor the wolf - rayet star wind proposal is much simpler
this allows to go back to galaxy data to derive the key properties of the dark matter particle : work by hogan & dalcanton ( 2000 prd , 2001 apj ) , gilmore et al .
( from 2006 mnras , 2007 apj , etc . ) , strigari et al . ( 2008 nature ) , gentile et al . (
2009 nature ) ; work by boyanovsky et al .
( 2008 prd ) , de vega & sanchez ( 2010 mnras ) clearly points to a kev particle .
a right - handed neutrino is a candidate to be this particle ( e.g. kusenko & segre 1997 plb ; fuller et al .
2003 prd ; kusenko 2004 ijmp ; for a review see kusenko 2009 physrep ; biermann & kusenko 2006 prl ; stasielak et al .
2007 apj ; loewenstein et al .
2009 apj ; loewenstein & kusenko 2010 apjl ) : this particle has the advantage to allow star formation very early , near redshift 80 , and so also allows the formation of supermassive black holes , possibly formed out of agglomerating massive stars in the gravitational potential of a dark matter clump ; the stellar wind limit derived by yungelson et al .
2008 aa does not apply for stars at near zero heavy elements , since such stars have weak winds .
black holes in turn also merge , but in this manner start their mergers at masses of a few million solar masses ; the mass is given by the instability of stars at such a mass due to general relativity and radiation effects .
this readily explains the supermassive black hole mass function as the result of mergers between black holes .
the corresponding gravitational waves are not constrained by any existing limit , and could have given a substantial energy contribution at high redshift .
our conclusion is that a right - handed neutrino of a mass of a few kev is the most interesting candidate to constitute dark matter
. a consequence should be lyman alpha emission and absorption at around a few microns ; corresponding emission and absorption lines might be visible from molecular hydrogen h@xmath14 ( tegmark et al .
1997 apj ) and h@xmath15 ( goto et al .
2008 apj ) and their ions , in the far infrared and sub - mm wavelength range .
the detection at very high redshift of massive star formation , stellar evolution and the formation of the first super - massive black holes would constitute the most striking and testable prediction of this specific dark matter particle proposal .
questions about massive stars , and about the other right - handed neutrinos ; i emphasized i ) the arguments from cr physics , so debunking dm decay arguments , and ii ) the very early star formation , which should be testable by observation , and would be a phantastic discovery .
0.5 cm bernard * sadoulet * ( berkeley ) : direct detection of dark matter : why wimps ?
future of direct detection ?
dark matter could be due to new physics at the tev scale ; @xmath332 points to wz scale at point , when going non - relativistic ; wimps ; @xmath333 cdm is still alive ; halo wimp scattering , annihilation products ; lhc detection ; elastic scattering in halo , energy deposition a few kev ; signal nuclear recoil ; bg electron recoil ; estimated rate 1 event per kg per month ; should show annual modulation ( but would several thousand events ) ; typical plot cross - section versus mass of wimp in log - log ; various experiments give exclusion regions , january 2009 compilation by jeff filippini , savage et al . ;
dama claim april 2008 still stands : if wimps exist , we expect a modulation in event rate - dama claims to have seen it ; dama claims 3 kev peak can not be fully explained by @xmath334k escape peak ; bernard sa states : not a wimp , incompatible with other experiments `` ; 0907.1438 ; dama modulation is proportional to bg , very disturbing ; other criticism ' ' not blind analysis " ; nobody finds the result plausible enough to repeat the experiment ; conclusion : a different team has to repeat the experiment at the south pole ( e.g. ) ; cdms ii dec 2009 : ionization + a - thermal photons ; cdms bind analysis : timing discrimination to find two events ; result in science feb 12 , 2010 ; cdms vs. edelweiss ; edelweiss presented results july 18 , last sunday : one event of interest in nuclear recoil region ; new results from xenon 100 " may 2010 : exclusion limit similar to cdms ; savage et al .
1006.0972 ; hooper et al .
1007.1005 ; new system using metastable detectors , so energy deposit creates bubble , or else ; many various detection techniques , like liquid argon ; there approaches : a ) lhc , b ) laboratory , c ) cosmos ; 0.5 cm felix * mirabel * ( saclay - buenos aires ) : cosmic evolution of stellar bhs and the end of the dark ages ; dark ages count from 400,000 years @xmath335 years ; asking about reionization of the universe ( madau , rees , volonteri et al .
2004 ; loeb et al . and many others )
; he proposes as a working hypothesis that bh high mass x - ray binaries may have played a complementary role , to that of their massive stellar progenitors in the process of the reionization of the universe ( fits my ideas , only i use an even higher redshift perhaps ) ; talks about stellar forensics , wonders about the implosion of massive stars without sne ; heger et al .
2003 , georgy et al .
a&a 502 , 611 - 622 ( 08/2009 ) , mapelli et al .
2010 , fryer 1999 ; the bhs in low mass galaxies have larger mass than those in our galaxy ; zampieri & roberts 2009 , pakull et al .
2020 , king et al . 2001 ; the occurrence rate of ulxs with @xmath336 per unit galaxy mass in starburst galaxies is a decreasing fct of the metallicity of the host galaxy ; example ulxs in the cartwheel galaxy ( gao et al .
2007 ) ; rappaport et al .
2010 on arp147 ; massive stars of high metallicity end as neutron stars rather than bhs ; mirabel et al . 1999 ,
vrba et al .
2000 , davies et al .
2009 , muno et al .
2006 , davies et al . 2009 ; progenitors of core - collapse sne have masses @xmath337 , smartt et al araa 2009 , smith et al . 2010 ; mirabel & irapuan rodrigues 2001 - 2009 ; assumption : if bh binaries have no anomalous motion they must have been formed without energetic sn kick ; for such an exercise it is necessary to determine the space motion of such systems : mirabel et al .
1992 , mirabel & rodriguez 1994 , dhawan et al . 2007 ; shows the galactic trip of sco x-1 ( mirabel & rodrigues 2003 ) ; two run - away bhs mirabel et al .
2001 nature , israelian et al .
1999 nature ; suggests that the @xmath338 bh in cyg x-1 was born in the dark ( mirabel & rodrigues 2003 science ) ; gives the number of about @xmath339 stellar bhs in the galaxy ; grs1915 + 105 and v404 cyg have bhs with @xmath340 and have small velocities , especially small vertical velocity components ; hosts of llgrbs are small irr galaxies , fruchter et al .
2006 nature , and mirabel et al .
2003 , levesque et al . 2010 ; suggests that the fraction of bhs should increase with redshift ; turk et al .
2009 science , krumholz et al .
2009 science , stacy et al .
2010 apj ; pop ii stars were multiple systems dominated by binaries with @xmath341 ; a grb at z = 8.2 has similar properties to grbs at lower redshift , salvaterra et al .
2009 nature ; hst galaxies at z = 8 - 9 are photon starved to reionize the universe ; unless there are small galaxies below detection , top heavy imf ( lorenzoni et al . , bouwens et al .
2010 ( my comment : that fits our ideas , expressed in caramete & biermann 2010 ) ; estimates the number of ionizing photons from the microquasar to be about 3 times that of the progenitor star ( mirabel et al .
work in progress ) ; microquasars ionize multiple times due to the energetic photons ( similar to our argument in biermann & kusenko 2006 prl , then for dm rh neutrino decay ) ; conclusion : a large proportion of stellar bhs important for reionization ; .. i comment with our bh paper ( 2010 arxiv ) , and suggest to go even further ( agglomerating massive stars in a group inside a dm halo clump all the way to make bhs of a million @xmath342 ) ; 0.5 cm paolo * natoli * ( rome ) , report for reno mandolesi ( bologna ) : the planck satellite : first fluctuation and gw generator , later fluctuation amplifier , but gw dissipator ; 436 days since launch , 100 percent of sky covered ; about half the sky has been covered twice ; the currently approved mission operation will cover @xmath279 four sky surveys , until the end of the cold phase ( nov 2011 ) ; now end of cryo - lifetime expected to end of jan 2012 ; lots of technical details ; he suddenly mentions that pks 1222 + 21 = 4c21.35 jumped up by a huge factor at tev ; they see every single flat spectrum radio source ; ... one wonders how many there are ... (my comment : down to 0.25 jy one every two degrees at 5 ghz even ; s51803 + 78 is flat from 5 ghz to 60 microns ) ; ... 0.5 cm norma g. * sanchez * ( paris ) : predictions of the effective theory of inflation and kev dark matter in the standard model of the universe : baryonic matter 4.6 percent , dm 23.4 percent , 72 percent de ; matter - de equality at @xmath343 ; end of inflation @xmath344 ; ew phase transition @xmath345 ; qcd phase ransitioon @xmath346 ; bbn @xmath347 ; dm outside standard model of particle physics ; de described by cosmological constant @xmath0 ; during inflation the universe expands by @xmath348 ; inflation lasts @xmath349 s and ends by @xmath350 ; energy scale , when inflation starts is about @xmath351 gev , about gut scale ; planck time @xmath352 s ; fast roll inflation @xmath353 to @xmath354 s , slow roll inflation @xmath354 s to @xmath349 s ; fast roll inflation suppresses the cmb quadrupole ; boyanovsky et al .
2006 prd 74 , 123006 ; @xmath355 at beginning of inflation ; compares inflation with semi - classical quantum gravity a la hawking ; compares also bh evaporation with cosmic inflation , inverse ; suggests that string temperature is a quantum gravity concept ; destri et al .
2008 prd 77 , 043509 ; r is tensor to scalar perturbation ratio , so a measurement of the primordial gravitons , lower bound @xmath279 0.016 at 98 % c.l . , @xmath279 0.049 at % c.l .
, 0.055 most probable level ; mcmc stands for monte - carlo - markoff - chain = mcmc , and is a method of analysis ; basically predictions for wmap9 and planck : burigana et al .
nosa + hdv ) 1003.6108 ; @xmath356 at 95 % c.l . , best value at 0.04 , tilt @xmath357 . for dark matter distinguishes ( a ) particle physics , ( b ) astrophysics , ( c ) numerical simulations : and b as well as b and c do not agree ; answers in their papers : 2008 to 2010 , prd , mnras and astro - ph ; her expression : @xmath358 : based on biermann & kusenko 2006 i conclude for z = 100 this gives @xmath359 ; interesting for massive star clumps ; if i take the geometric average , i get @xmath360 , then @xmath361 for baryonic matter , so @xmath362 , so just what you need to make a massive star clump ; good to make the first sms bhs , necessary near @xmath363 ; ... 0.5 cm my conclusion : things are beginning to hang together , and we can now make quite specific predictions as a consequence of the kev dm model . if the right - handed neutrino were this particle , star formation and the first super - massive black holes could be formed quite early , possibly earlier than redshift 50
. a confirmation would be spectacular .
* acknowledgements * plb would like to thank g. bisnovatyi - kogan , j. blmer , r. engel , t.k .
gaisser , l. gergely , g. gilmore , a. heger , g.p .
isar , p. joshi , k.h .
kampert , gopal - krishna , a. kusenko , n. langer , m. loewenstein , i.c .
mari , s. moiseenko , b. nath , g. pavalas , e. salpeter , n. sanchez , r. sina , j. stasielak , v. de souza , h. de vega , p. wiita , and many others for discussion of these topics .
* adriani , o. , et al .
( pamela coll . ) , , 607 - 609 ( 2009 ) ; arxiv 0810.4995 * aharonian , f. , et al . , ( h.e.s.s .- coll . ) , *508 * , 561 - 564 ( 2009 ) ; arxiv:0905.0105 * ahn , h.s .
et al . ( cream - coll . ) , , 593 - 603 ( 2009 ) ; arxiv:0911.1889 * ahn , h.s .
et al . ( cream - coll . ) , , l89 - l93 ( 2010 ) ; arxiv:1004.1123 * biermann , p.l . , *271 * , 649 ( 1993 ) - paper cr - i ; astro - ph/9301008 * biermann , p.l . , & cassinelli , j.p . ,
*277 * , 691 ( 1993 ) - paper cr - ii ; astro - ph/9305003 * biermann , p.l . , & strom , r.g . , *275 * , 659 ( 1993 ) - paper cr - iii ; astro - ph/9303013 * biermann , p.l . , 23rd icrc , in proc .
invited , rapporteur and highlight papers " ; eds .
d. a. leahy et al . , world scientific , singapore , p. 45
( 1994 ) * biermann , p. l. , becker , j. k. , meli , a. , rhode , w. , seo , e .- s . , & stanev , t. , , 061101 ( 2009 ) ; arxiv:0903.4048 * biermann , p.l . ,
becker , j.k . ,
caceres , g. , meli , a. , seo , e .- s .
, & stanev , t. , , l53 - l57 ( 2010 ) ; arxiv:0910.1197 * bisnovatyi - kogan , g. s. , _ astron .
* 47 * , 813 ( 1970 ) * bisnovatyi - kogan , g. s. , moiseenko , s. g. ,
_ chinese j. of astron . & astroph . suppl . _ * 8 * , 330 - 340 ( 2008 ) * chang , j. , et al . , 362 ( 2008 ) * dobler , g. , finkbeiner , d.p . , , 1222 - 1234 ( 2008 ) ; arxiv:0712.1038 * dobler , g. , finkbeiner , d. p. , cholis , i. , slatyer , t. r. , weiner , n. , eprint arxiv:0910.4583 ( 2009 ) * gopal - krishna , peter l. biermann , vitor de souza , paul j. wiita , in press ( 2010 ) ; arxiv : * schlickeiser , r. , ruppel , j. , , 033044 ( 2010 ) ; arxiv:0908.2183 * stanev , t. , biermann , p.l . & gaisser , t.k . , *274 * , 902 ( 1993 ) - paper cr - iv ; astro - ph/9303006 * stawarz , l. , petrosian , v. , & blandford , r.d . , , 236 - 247 ( 2010 ) ; arxiv:0908.1094 * weidenspointner , g. , et al . , 454 - 456 ( 2008 )
photos of the colloquium are available at : http://www.chalonge.obspm.fr/colloque2010.html
arkhipova natalia , astro space center of lebedev physical institute , moscow russia + aslanyan petros , joint institute for nuclear research , lhep dubna russia + bhadra arunava , university of north bengal siliguri india + biermann peter l. , mpifr bonn germany and ua tuscaloosa , al , usa + biesiada marek , institute of physics , university of silesia , katowice poland + blau steve , american institute of physics , college park , maryland usa + bluhm robert , colby college , waterville usa + bonifacio paolo , university of aberdeen , aberdeen uk + boyanovsky daniel , university of pittsburgh , dept of physics & astronomy , pittsburgh , pa usa + bradu pascal , ecole polytechnique , palaiseau france + buchard albert , ibens ( ens ) , paris france + burde georgy , ben - gurion university of the negev , sede - boker camp israel + calabrese erminia , university of rome `` la sapienza '' , rome italy + cea paolo , dipartimento di fisica di bari & infn di bari , bari italy + chargui yassine , faculty of sciences of tunis , tunis tunisia + chauvineau bertrand , observatoire de la cte dazur , grasse france + chen xuelei , national astronomical observatories , chinese academy of sciences , beijing china + cho inyong , seoul national university of technology , seoul south korea + ciobanu nellu institute of applied physics , academy of sciences , chisinau moldova + cnudde sylvain , observatoire de paris lesia meudon , france + collins hael , niels bohr international academy , copenhagen denmark + comis barbara , `` sapienza '' , university of rome , roma italy + cooray asantha , university of california , irvine irvine usa + cosmai leonardo , universit di bari & infn sezione di bari , bari italy + de vega hector j. , upmc paris vi lpthe jussieu & cnrs , paris france + dechelette typhaine , iap , paris france + destri claudio , univ milano - bicocca - infn dipt di fisica g occhialini , milano italy + dokuchaev vyacheslav , institute for nuclear research of the russian acad , moscow russia + dumin yurii izmiran , russian academy of sciences troitsk , moscow russia + easson damien , arizona state u. and ipmu , u. of tokyo , tokyo japan + echaurren juan , codelco chile , north division , calama chile + fabretti alexandre , university paris vi , paris france + falvella maria cristina , italian space agency & miur - direzione generale ricerca , rome italy + flin piotr jan kochanowski , university , institute of physics , kielce poland + freitas diniz edgard , national institute for space research - inpe , so jos brazil + frenk carlos s. , center for computational cosmology- univ of durham , durham united kingdom + ghodsi hoda , university of glasgow , glasgow united kingdom + ghosh shubhrangshu , iia academia sinica , taipei taiwan + gilmore gerard f. , institute of astronomy , university of cambridge , cambridge united kingdom + giocoli carlo zah / ita university of heidelberg , heidelberg germany + goldman itzhak , afeka college , department of exact sciences , tel aviv israel + gottlber stefan , astrophysikalisches institut potsdam , potsdam , germany + hanzevack emil , college of william & mary , williamsburg usa + hashim norsiah , university of malaya , kuala lumpur malaysia + ivanov mikhail , sternberg astronomical institute , m.v.lomonosov , moscow russia + journeau philippe , discinnet labs , puteaux france + kahniashvili tina , carnegie mellon university , pittsburgh , pa usa + kamiya noriaki , university of aizuwakamatsu , aizuwakamatsu japan + karczewska danuta , university of silesia , katowice poland + khadekar goverdhan , rtm ngapur university , nagpur nagpur , india + komatsu eiichiro , university of texas at austin , dept of astronomy , austin usa + kostro ludwik , university of gdansk , gdansk poland + krawiec adam , jagiellonian university , krakow poland + lasenby anthony , cavendish laboratory , astrophysics group , univ .
cambridge , united kingdom + letourneur nicole , observatoire de paris lesia meudon , meudon france + li nan , national astronomical observatories , chinese acad .
sciences , beijing china + lima neto gastao , iag - universidade de so paulo , so paulo brazil + lin hai , university of santiago de compostela , santiago de compostela spain + mc gaugh stacy , university of maryland , college park maryland usa + mehta kushal , university of arizona , steward observatory , tucson usa + mirabel flix , cea - saclay , france & iafe - buenos aires , argentina and gif - sur - yvette france + moskaliuk stepan , bogoliubov institute for theoretical physics of na , kiev ukraine + musakhanyan viktor , gavar and haybusak universities , yerevan armenia + mussa atifah , university college london ucl , london uk + natoli paolo , universit roma 2 tor vergata and asi science data center ,
frascati italy + noh hyerim , korea astrronomy and space science institute , taejon korea + orani stefano , imperial college london , london uk + pagano luca , university of rome `` sapienza '' , roma italy + pandolfi stefania , university of rome `` la sapienza '' , rome italy + pandya aalok , department of physics , university of rajasthan , jaipur india + pankaj kumar , igidr , mumbai mumbai india + parisi maria florencia , facultad de matematica , astronomia y fisica , univ crdoba argentina + pea suarez vladimir jearim , universidad industrial de santander , bucaramanga
colombia + pilo luigi , university of laquila and infn , laquila italy + ramon medrano marina , universidad complutense dept fisica teorica , madrid spain + realdi matteo , department of physics , university of padua , padua italy + rebolo rafael , instituto astrofisico de canarias , tenerife tenerife spain + ricotti massimo , university of maryland , college park usa + robles sandra , universidad autonoma de madrid , madrid spain + rochus pierre , universit de lige , centre spatial de lige , lige , belgium + rodriguez ivan , cinvestav mexico , d.f .
mexico + romano antonio enea , yukawa institute theoretical physics , kyoto japan + ruiz andres nicolas , instituo de astronomia teorica y experimental ( iate ) , cordoba argentina + sabbatini lucia , university of roma tre , dept . of physics , roma italy + sadoulet bernard , particle cosmology group , university of california , berkeley usa + salucci paolo , sissa - trieste- astrophysics group , trieste italy + sanchez norma g. , observatoire de paris lerma and cnrs , paris france + sevellec aurelie , observatoire de paris lesia meudon , meudon france + smoot george , lnbl - univ california and univ paris denis diderot , berkeley and paris usa + soares ivano damiao , centro brasileiro de pesquisas fisicas - cbpf / mct , rio de janeiro brazil + sorensen peter , llnl , livermore usa + starikova svetlana , department of astronomy , university of padova , padua italy + stivoli federico , inria , paris france + suciu oana elena , faculty pf physics and faculty of mathematics , bab cluj - napoca romania + szydlowski marek , jagiellonian university , krakow poland + tabatabaei seyed , alireza queen mary , university of london , london uk + tartaglia angelo , politecnico di torino , torino italy + tedesco luigi , dipartimento di fisica di bari and infn di bari , bari italy + thomas daniel , imperial college , london uk + tikhonov anton , saint - petersburg state university , astronomical institute , saint - petersburg russia + ting yuan sen , ecole polytechnique paris , palaiseau france + trinidad rodrigo , universiad de san carlos de guatemala , guatemala guatemala + turzynski krzysztof , institute of theoretical physics , university of warsaw , warsaw poland + ungku ferwani salwa , university of malaya , kuala lumpur malaysia + urtado olivier , orsay m1 , astrophysique , versailles france + vazquez - mata jose antonio , university of sussex , brighton uk + verma murli manohar , department of physics , lucknow university , lucknow india + van elewyck veronique , apc - universit paris 7 , paris france + vishwakarma ram gopal , university of zacatecas , zacatecas mexico + von knop jan heinrich heine , university dsseldorf , dsseldorf germany + wagstaff jacques , lancaster university , lancaster england + wandelt benjamin , institut dastrophysique de paris , paris france + wang xiang - yu , department of astronomy , nanjing university , nanjing china + xu xiaoying , steward observatory , university of arizona , tucson usa + zanini alba , infn sezione di torino , turin italy + ziaeepour houri , max - plank institute fur extraterrestrisch physik , garching b. munchen , germany + zidani djilali , observatoire de paris - cnrs , paris france + zolotkhin ivan , observatoire de paris and sternberg astr .
, paris france + | the chalonge 14th paris cosmology colloquium 2010 was held on 22 - 24 july in the historic paris observatory s perrault building , in the chalonge school spirit combining real cosmological / astrophysical data and hard theory predictive approach connected to them in the standard model of the universe : news and reviews from wmap7 , bicep , quad , spt , ami , act , planck , quijote , herschel , spire , atlas and hermes surveys ; astrophysics and particle physics dark matter ( dm ) searches and galactic observations ; related theory and simulations , with the aim of synthesis , progress and clarification .
peter biermann , daniel boyanovsky , asantha cooray , claudio destri , hector de vega , gerry gilmore , stefan gottlber , eiichiro komatsu , stacy mcgaugh , anthony lasenby , rafael rebolo , paolo salucci , norma sanchez and anton tikhonov present here their highlights of the colloquium .
inflection points in several current research lines emerged , particularly on dark matter ( dm ) where @xmath0wdm ( warm dark matter ) emerges impressively over @xmath0cdm whose ever - increasing galactic scale problems are staggering . the summary and conclusions by h. j. de vega , m. c. falvella and n. g. sanchez stress among other points : ( i ) data confirm primordial cmb gaussianity .
inflation effective theory predicts negligible primordial non - gaussianity , negligible scalar index running and a tensor to scalar ratio @xmath1 at reach / border line of next cmb observations ; the present data with this theory clearly prefer new inflation ; early fast - roll inflation is generic and provides lowest multipoles depression .
cmb secondary anisotropies progress rapidly with new cmb high-@xmath2 constraints and sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) amplitudes smaller than expected : cmb and x - ray data agree but intracluster medium models need revision ( they overestimate sz ) , relaxed and non - relaxed clusters need distinction as wmap7 shows.(ii ) the milky way is not formed from dsph - like systems .
feedback does not operate as already suggested : it was extremely mild in the lowest luminosity galaxies , it does not substantially modify initial conditions .
( iii ) the cosmic ray positron and electron excess recently observed is explained by natural astrophysical processes , while annihilating / decaying dark matter models face growing tailoring to explain observations .
( iv ) cored ( non cusped ) dm halos and warm ( kev scale mass ) dm are increasingly favored from theory and astrophysical observations , they naturally produce the observed small scale structures ; sterile neutrinos are suitable candidates .
wimps ( heavier than 1 gev ) are strongly disfavoured combining theory with galaxy observations . putting all together ,
evidence that @xmath0cdm does not work at small scales is staggering .
@xmath0wdm simulations with 1 kev particles reproduce observations , sizes of local minivoids and velocity functions . overall
, kev scale dm particles deserve dedicated searchs and simulations .
peter biermann presents his live minutes of the colloquium and concludes that a right - handed sterile neutrino of mass of a few kev is the most interesting dm candidate .
photos of the colloquium are included .
_astron . &
astroph .
_ @jnl#1#1 |
galaxy scaling relations , such as the fundamental plane , and its various projections , and the colour - magnitude relation have been used to enhance our understanding of galaxy structure and evolution .
early - type galaxies , in particular , form a relatively homogeneous population and hence rather well - defined scaling relations .
most large samples of early - type galaxies come from the rich environments of galaxies clusters .
studies of these high density regions benefit from the large numbers of galaxies in a small angular region of the sky ( hence making observations more efficient ) and from the morphology - density relation , which tells us that such environments are dominated by early - type galaxies .
thus our current knowledge gained from galaxy scaling relations applies mostly to clusters .
the field and group environments are less well studied in this respect , and provide a means to study environmentally - dependent processes .
for example , galaxy mergers ( which can be about hundred times more efficient in today s groups than clusters , cf .
@xcite ) may result in merger - remnant ellipticals that deviate strongly from the scaling relations ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . on the other hand many of the well studied elliptical galaxies are brightest group galaxies .
recent x - ray observations of groups and their constituent galaxies have provided a new insight into the study of the evolution of galaxies in small ensembles and in intermediate - density environments @xcite .
@xcite find that the shape of the luminosity function of galaxies in groups with low x - ray luminosity is significantly bimodal , in comparison with that of x - ray bright groups or rich clusters , showing a strong environmental effect on the morphological mix in a system , and on the evolution of galaxies in general .
it is likely that the dip in the luminosity function at intermediate magnitudes arises from increased merging in low velocity dispersion systems . of particular interest in this context are early - type galaxies , which are more abundant in clusters and groups than in the field . several well - known scaling relations ( such as the faber - jackson relation or the fundamental plane of elliptical galaxies )
utilise galaxy velocity dispersions and hence require spectroscopic data .
however , scaling relations like the kormendy relation @xcite and the photometric plane of galaxies @xcite can be constructed from photometric observations alone .
there have been many studies aimed at understanding the differences in the structure of ellipticals ( e ) and dwarf ellipticals ( de ) , with mixed results . while some ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) argue in favour of the similarities between the two populations , others ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) find evidence otherwise ( see @xcite for more details ) .
traditionally , the surface brightness distribution of ellipticals and bulges of disk galaxies have been modelled by the de vaucouleursprofile .
however , during the last decade , better photometry and advanced analysis have shown that their surface brightness distribution is , in general , better represented by the sersic profile ( @xmath0 , @xcite ) , of which the de vaucouleurs profile ( @xmath4 ) is a special case @xcite .
the sersic model is also widely used to describe the brightness distribution of bulges of disk galaxies @xcite .
the disk component of galaxies is usually characterised by an exponential distribution . in this paper
we examine the surface brightness distribution of ellipticals belonging to galaxy groups , where most galaxies in the universe reside . the relatively small number of galaxies in individual groups , compared to clusters , requires any analysis to be carried out on a large sample .
this can be done in several ways . here ,
the galaxies are classified based on the x - ray luminosity ( @xmath5 ) of their parent groups , which , being correlated with the velocity dispersion of the group ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , can be an index of the dynamical state and the mass of the group @xcite
. the principal properties of the groups , and a detailed description of the sample can be found in section 2 .
the analysis techniques and morphology of galaxies is discussed in section 3 .
correlations among various parameters and the scaling relations is studied in section 4 .
section 5 contains a discussion and a summary of results .
our sample is drawn from the group evolution multi - wavelength study ( gems , * ? ? ? * ) of sixty groups , compiled by cross - correlating a list of over 4000 known groups from various studies with the list of archival rosat pspc x - ray observations with integration @xmath6 ks .
this includes several hickson groups , as well as loose groups from the cfa survey .
a large fraction of these were detected in the x - ray , and for the others we have upper limits for their x - ray luminosity . of the gems sample ,
16 groups were observed at the 2.5 m isaac newton telescope at the roque de los muchachos observatory , la palma , between 2000 february 410 .
this is a random and representative subsample of the original sample of 60 groups , where all groups accessible for the allocated observing run were observed .
the detector used was the wide field camera ( wfc ) , which is an array of four thinned eev ccds situated at the f/3.29 prime focus of the int , each with an area of @xmath7 pixels , each pixel being 0.33 arcsec across .
each ccd thus can image an area of @xmath8 arcmin of sky , together covering 1017 sq.arcmin .
photometry was performed with broadband bri filters , of which we analyse only the @xmath9-band images here .
our analysis is limited to galaxies brighter than @xmath10 .
the median seeing achieved was about 1.1 arcsec in @xmath9 .
further details can be found in @xcite .
the identification of the group galaxies is based on a colour selection .
source extraction was performed using the sextractor software @xcite , which uses a routine based on neural network generated weights for star - galaxy separation .
detections were checked visually and objects with the _ stellaricity _ parameter greater then 0.9 were deemed to be definitely stellar and therefore discarded . to obtain colours , a fixed aperture , set to be slightly greater than the seeing , was used to evaluate fluxes with different filters .
all objects with fwhm less than the mean seeing were not processed further .
galaxies were selected as being likely group members on the basis of their @xmath11 colour .
a conservative cut of @xmath12 was found to remove the majority of background galaxies for all groups in our sample ( see @xcite for further details ) .
those galaxies found in the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) within the virial radius @xmath13 ( see * ? ? ?
.the sample of 16 groups used in this study [ table1 ] [ cols="<,>,>,>,^ , > " , ] @xmath14number of member galaxies within our imaging field identified by the colour selection outlined in [ colourselection ] .
+ @xmath15distance measured from the mean redshift of group ( assuming @xmath16 km s@xmath17mpc@xmath17 ; @xmath18 ) , corrected for local bulk flows .
+ @xmath19bolometric x - ray luminosity from @xcite the core of our data analysis is the two - dimensional decomposition of galaxies , by fitting a sersic profile to the bulge and an exponential profile to the disk component , for obtaining the structural photometric parameters , and morphological classification . this analysis was carried out on all galaxies identified as group members using the selection method described in the previous section .
the bulge - disk decomposition procedure used here involves fitting two - dimensional image models to the observed galaxy images , assumed to consist of a bulge and a disk component .
the model image is convolved with a gaussian psf , with the fwhm measured from the galaxy frame .
details of the accuracy and reliability of the decomposition procedure , and the associated galaxy simulation code , can be found in @xcite .
the sersic profile for the bulge is given by @xmath20 ; \\
r_{\rm bulge } & = & \sqrt{x^2 + y^2/(1 - \epsilon_b)^2}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath21 and @xmath22 are the distances from the centre of the galaxy along the major and minor axis respectively .
the quantity @xmath23 is a function of @xmath1 , and is evaluated as a root of an equation involving the incomplete gamma function @xcite .
it is well approximated by @xmath24 for @xmath25 , which corresponds to the de vaucouleurs law , @xmath26 .
we model the disk intensity by the @xcite exponential distribution , @xmath27 the disk is assumed to be intrinsically circular , with the observed ellipticity @xmath28 of the disk in the observed image being due to projection effects alone .
the free parameters of the fit are : 1 .
the central bulge intensity @xmath29 , 2 . the half - light radius of the bulge @xmath2 , 3 .
the ellipticity of the bulge @xmath30 , 4 .
the bulge shape parameter @xmath1 ( sersic profile ) , 5 .
the central intensity of the disk @xmath31 , 6 .
the scale length of the disk @xmath32 , and 7 .
the ellipticity of the disk @xmath28 .
additional parameters such as sky background and position angle are estimated in a preliminary fit and are then held fixed during the final fitting process .
[ sec : results ] we were able to obtain satisfactory fits with a reduced @xmath33 for 471 galaxies from our initial sample of 764 galaxies .
any fit with a reduced @xmath34 is considered to be unacceptable and the galaxy excluded from the sample . such unacceptable fits
result mainly from irregularities in the brightness distribution , or from the presence of multiple nuclei or close companions .
such features can not be represented by the simple and smooth models used in this study .
the galaxies with satisfactory fits to the surface brightness model are assigned morphological types based on their bulge - to - total luminosity ratio , @xmath35 .
an ideal elliptical galaxy has @xmath36 and a late - type disk galaxy has a value of @xmath35 close to zero .
we classify a galaxy as early - type when it has @xmath37 .
this criterion was chosen to be @xmath38 by @xcite , but the conclusions of this study are not sensitive to such a difference in selection .
an `` elliptical galaxy '' is one with @xmath39 .
a galaxy with @xmath40 is considered as a pure disk galaxy with an exponential luminosity profile , since the bulge in this case is too small to be modelled by the sersic profile .
the x - ray luminosities of the parent groups in our sample are taken from @xcite , who measured them by fitting two - dimensional @xmath41-profiles to rosat pspc observations in the 0.52 kev range , extrapolated to estimate the bolometric x - ray luminosity .
point sources were removed from the data before luminosity calculations and the values have then been corrected for flux lost in this process using the surface brightness models .
since the number of galaxies in each group is small , we obtain statistical results by grouping galaxies according to x - ray brightness of their parent groups .
we have divided the groups to be x - ray bright or dim according to their bolometric x - ray luminosity being more or less than the median of the sample , @xmath42 erg / s .
this luminosity refers to the x - ray luminosity of the group plus any central galaxy that might exist .
in addition , we have a third category of group ( called x - ray undetected ) where there is no discernible `` group emission '' , and all the diffuse emission , if any , can be accounted for as due to individual non - central galaxies in the group .
there are 189 , 174 and 108 galaxies ( out of 316 , 298 and 150 ) with acceptable profile fits in the categories of x - ray bright , dim and undetected groups respectively .
since the sample covers a wide range of x - ray luminosity , here we seek possible differences in the properties of galaxies that depend on their local environment characterised by @xmath5 .
figure [ fig : nhist ] shows the distribution of the sersic parameter for early type galaxies ( @xmath37 ) in x - ray bright , dim and undetected groups .
there is no significant difference in the distribution of values of the sersic parameter @xmath1 among x - ray bright , dim and undetected groups , corroborated by the k - s statistics .
the difference , in the distribution of the half - light radius @xmath2 of bulges of early - type disk galaxies , between the various categories of parent groups , is substantial .
[ fig : rehist ] and [ fig : absmaghist ] show the distribution of @xmath2 and @xmath43 in the three sub - samples in this study , indicating that x - ray bright groups contain a larger fraction of galaxies that are bigger and more luminous than their counterparts in x - ray dim groups .
this is confirmed by the k - s test performed on the distributions of @xmath2 and @xmath43 .
the underdensity of early - types implied by the gap in the histograms for x - ray dim and undetected groups in fig .
[ fig : absmaghist ] around @xmath44 is due to the dip in the lf of these groups , discussed in further detail by @xcite .
the sersic parameter @xmath1 is often found to be correlated with the absolute magnitude of the elliptical galaxies @xcite , which would indicate that the sersic parameter is an intrinsic property of a galaxy . here
, we find a highly scattered correlation between @xmath1 and @xmath43 for elliptical galaxies ( both e and de ) in groups , with a scatter of about 1.5 mag in @xmath43 , which is much larger than the scatter ( about 0.45 mag in @xmath45 ) found by @xcite . in order to understand the origin of this scatter in the @xmath46 relation , we plot the galaxies as a function of their normalised projected distance from the centre of their parent group ( fig . [ fig : nradial ] ) . since the distribution of the sersic parameter does not show a significant variation with x - ray properties of the group , we use galaxies belonging to all three sub - samples together to improve statistics .
galaxies in the core of the groups ( @xmath47 ) have higher values for the sersic parameter ( mean value and 95% confidence level of @xmath48 ) , while in the outer regions ( @xmath49 ) , galaxies have lower values of @xmath1 and hence are less cuspy ( mean value and 95% confidence level of @xmath50 ) . the systematic variation in values of @xmath1 with the distance from the centre of the parent group appears to be independent of how bright the galaxies are .
@xcite recently found a triangular distribution between the concentration index of galaxies ( related to @xmath1 ) and the projected two - dimensional local density of galaxies in clusters , which is expected even if @xmath1 ( and concentration parameter ) and @xmath43 were tightly correlated . at higher
projected densities , galaxies with both low and high values of concentration index will be binned together due to projection . on the other hand ,
since galaxies in low - density environments have low @xmath1 , at lower projected densities only galaxies with lower values of concentration index will be seen .
[ fig : ndistance ] shows a similar triangular distribution between the sersic parameter @xmath1 and normalised projected distance for the galaxies in our sample . if @xmath1 and @xmath43 of elliptical galaxies were correlated for normal and dwarf ellipticals , fig .
[ fig : ndistance ] would seem to indicate that the dwarf ellipticals are preferentially removed from the core of each group , but enhanced in the outer regions .
however , from fig [ fig : nradial ] it appears that the situation is more complicated .
we find faint des ( @xmath51 ) , with relatively higher values of @xmath1 , at smaller normalised projected distances from the centre of the groups .
this might suggest that these high-@xmath1 des are at the core of their groups .
this strongly suggests that environmental effects can play a key role in the shape of the light profile ( characterised by values of @xmath1 ) , in galaxies and that this parameter is not an intrinsic property of a galaxy .
this also shows that des , traditionally known to have near - exponential brightness profiles , can have cuspy cores , and can exist in the central regions of groups .
these `` nucleated '' des have been found to be more centrally concentrated in their distribution in detailed studies of nearby clusters , e.g. virgo and fornax @xcite .
it is interesting to note that such cusps are also known to exist in starburst des ( e.g. * ? ? ?
one of the essential observational ingredients of the study of galaxy evolution is the family of scaling relations such as the fundamental plane , characteristic of dynamically relaxed elliptical galaxies @xcite .
although the fundamental plane for bright elliptical galaxies is found to be scarcely affected by environmental factors , it may not be so for low mass ellipticals . while @xcite showed that dwarf ellipticals as dwarfs ( des ) and those brighter as normal ellipticals ( es ) .
] follow the same trend defined by the fundamental plane of bright elliptical galaxies , albeit with a larger scatter due to structural variation , the dwarf ellipticals in virgo cluster studied by @xcite belong to a different fundamental plane . in the absence of spectroscopic measures of velocity dispersion , which is a key parameter in constructing the fundamental plane , one can study those projections of the fundamental plane which are purely photometric .
in this section , we will study the photometric characteristics of the elliptical galaxies in our sample ( those with @xmath52 , as defined in 3.1 ) , a subset of our sample of `` early - type galaxies '' ( @xmath53 ) elliptical galaxies are known to show a strong correlation between the mean surface brightness @xmath54 , and the half - light radius @xmath2 , known as the kormendy relation ( kr ) @xmath55 , with the slope @xmath56 lying in the range 2.03.0 @xcite .
the kormendy relation for cluster ellipticals shows a r.m.s .
scatter of about 0.1 dex , which would result in a 25% error in @xmath2 and hence in measuring distance to the galaxies .
[ fig : kormendy ] shows the kormendy relation for elliptical galaxies in our sample , where galaxies belonging to parent groups which are x - ray bright ( @xmath57 erg / s ) , x - ray dim and x - ray undetected are plotted with different symbols .
the plot shows two distinct populations : the `` normal '' ellipticals ( @xmath58 , mean kr slope @xmath59 ) and the dwarf ellipticals ( @xmath60 , mean kr slope @xmath61 ) .
however , from fig . [
fig : kormendy ] , it is apparent that instead of a linear kr , we may interpret the distribution of des as one of high scatter , truncated by our magnitude limit ( @xmath62 ) .
we also note that there are very few galaxies in the zone between the two populations , which results from the significant dip in the luminosity function of groups in the range @xmath63 , as seen in @xcite . comparing with the kr for galaxies in rich clusters , we find that the slope of the kr for our brightest galaxies ( @xmath64 ) [email protected] , compared to [email protected] for a similar sample in the coma cluster ( @xcite , plotted as the solid line in fig . [
fig : kormendy ] ) . extending the kr plot of the coma cluster to fainter galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , ellipticals in the magnitude range @xmath66 are found to follow a trend , at almost constant @xmath2 , quite distinct from that of the brighter galaxies , the latter having a slope similar to that found in our sample .
our sample of dwarfs extends to fainter @xmath67 smaller ( @xmath68 pc ) galaxies , and shows the presence of substantial scatter in both axes .
some contribution to this large scatter may also arise from dependencies on local environment , since we are merging galaxies from 16 groups in a single plot .
our conclusion ( in agreement with @xcite ) is that the kormendy relation in itself does _ not _ provide strong evidence for any fundamental difference in structure between normal and dwarf ellipticals .
recent developments in the study of the structure of galaxies and the modelling of brightness profiles , in particular with the use of the more general sersic model , provides a unified description of the photometric properties of normal ( e ) and dwarf ellipticals ( de ) , traditionally seen as two distinct families ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the discontinuity between these two extreme exponential ( @xmath69 , des ) and de vaucouleurs profiles ( @xmath70 , es ) is now filled by both populations possessing a large range of values @xmath71 .
the bulges of disk galaxies share the same photometric plane with ellipticals .
the photometric plane ( pp , * ? ? ?
* ) is a bivariate relation that links only photometric parameters , obtained by fitting a sersic model to a galaxy image , @xmath72 .
our simulations show that fitting galaxy brightness distributions with unsuitable models ( e.g. the de vaucouleurs model to a galaxy where @xmath73 ) , can result in a significant variation in the values of structural parameters .
for example , assuming @xmath25 in the case of a @xmath74 galaxy can result in a change in the value of half - light radius by a factor of three .
thus it is important to allow for a free parameter @xmath1 to account for the cusp and core in ellipticals or bulges of disk galaxies .
most scaling relations , e.g. the kormendy relation or the fundamental plane , are insensitive to these variations , since the three parameters of the sersic model ( @xmath3 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) are correlated and their combinations used in these scaling relations are robust @xcite .
the photometric plane , on the other hand , allows us to explore the entire range of these parameters for elliptical galaxies , and thus can be used more effectively as a tool to examine the connection between structural parameters and the evolutionary history of galaxies .
the photometric plane for all ellipticals in our sample is given by @xmath75 this equation is similar to that found for the bright elliptical galaxies in the @xmath76-band study of 42 coma galaxies @xcite .
however , the scatter in @xmath1 here is 0.13 @xmath77 , much larger than the scatter found for the coma cluster sample , which is 0.05 @xmath77 , which can be attributed to the fact that our sample is dominated by des . to verify this
, we examine the ellipticals with @xmath78 in x - ray bright groups ( comparable to the coma sample ) , to find that the scatter about the photometric plane for es is only 0.06 @xmath77 in @xmath79 , compared to 0.10 @xmath77 for des .
the fact that the scatter around the the photometric plane of normal es is lower than that of des indicates that es and des are structurally different systems even though their @xmath1 values might be similar .
we plot the principal axes ( @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath82 ) of the photometric plane against each other in fig .
[ fig : photplane ] , where @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 ( directly comparable to the similar plot for coma ellipticals in @xcite ) . since this sample has a fainter magnitude limit , it probes the pp for dwarfs more extensively , and demonstrates that the pp for the des has a is strikingly low scatter ( in contrast , for example , to their scatter in the kormendy plot ) .
this strongly suggests that des might be a more homogeneous class than is normally thought , and follow well - defined structural trends . to explore a more direct connection with the underlying physical changes in galaxy structure between es and des
, we turn to a slightly different version of these correlations in the next section .
@xcite , in their study of cluster ellipticals , showed that the photometric plane is close to a plane of constant specific entropy of galaxies , originally introduced by @xcite .
although self - gravitating systems like galaxies do not posess stable states of absolute maximum entropy , the evolution of entropy via two - body relaxation will be a slow process , and @xcite argue that the violent relaxation process which occurs during galaxy formation may establish a quasi - equilibrium state of constant specific entropy , and they find evidence that both simulated and observed galaxies do indeed show approximately constant entropy per unit mass . in the case of observed galaxies , the properties of the photometric plane result from this approximate constancy of specific entropy . on examination of the surfaces of constant entropy in detail
, it is found that they actually exhibit some curvature when represented in the coordinate system of the pp .
it can be seen , from the two edge - on views of our plane in fig .
[ fig : photplane ] , that there are clear indications of curvature in the distribution of the dwarfs .
this curvature , rather than stochastic scatter , accounts for much of the larger variance about the plane for des ( compared to nornal es ) discussed in section 4.2 .
could this curvature be indicating that dwarfs really follow a surface of constant specific entropy ? in fig .
[ fig : entropy ] we plot a representation of the photometric plane in terms of @xmath86 , for our sample , using eq .
( [ eq : ppeq ] ) above , and overlay a line of constant specific entropy .
the latter has been calculated using eqs .
( 23 ) & ( 24 ) of @xcite , in conjunction with the relevant relations from their appendix a. here , we have only adjusted the value of the specific entropy parameter ( @xmath87 ) to find the curve which best matches our data .
the curvature seen in the distribution of dwarfs in fig .
[ fig : entropy ] is similar to that the constant @xmath87 surface , although the shape does not match in detail .
it is also apparent that the normal es fall above the dwarfs in the figure , which corresponds to the direction of increasing @xmath87 .
the dashed line corresponds to a specific entropy plane with @xmath88 for our sample of elliptical galaxies dominated by des .
this study confirms earlier results that massive ellipticals show higher values of the sersic parameter @xmath1 , _
i.e. _ a cuspier surface brightness profile at their centre @xcite . from the large scatter in the plot of absolute r magnitude and @xmath1 ( fig .
[ fig : nradial ] ) , we conclude that the shape of the radial profile , represented by the value of @xmath1 , is not uniquely related to the intrinsic luminosity of the galaxy .
furthermore , the dependence of @xmath1 on the location of galaxies within their groups ( fig .
[ fig : nradial ] ) shows that environmental dependence is responsible for part of this scatter .
although we find no significant difference between the values of @xmath1 in groups of different x - ray luminosity , we do find that for both des and es ( though not the most luminous es ) , surface brightness profiles tend to be cuspier ( higher @xmath1 ) for galaxies located in the cores of groups .
one explanation for this correlation could be the effects of interaction - induced star formation in triggering nuclear starbursts within more centrally located galaxies . normal ellipticals in groups are found to yield similar photometric plane and kormendy relation parameters to those in rich clusters .
there is no difference in the kormendy relation or photometric plane between ellipticals belonging to the the different classes of x - ray bright , faint or undetected groups .
furthermore , the kormendy relation is found to be of little value in distinguishing structural differences between des and es , since the kr slope found for dwarfs is dominated by selection effects , most notably the magnitude limit of the sample .
the sparse region in the kr plot , separating des and es , is easily interpereted as resulting from the dip seen in the galaxy luminosity function at @xmath89 , and discussed in more detail in @xcite .
dwarf and normal ellipticals are distinguished much more effectively in terms of their location in the photometric plane in the space of @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the dwarfs inhabit a non - flat surface in this space , with a curvature somewhat akin to a surface of constant specific entropy , as defined by the equations of @xcite , though the match is only approximate .
even if galaxies do have constant specific entropy , a degree of mismatch between observation and the analytical expressions of @xcite is not surprising , given the numerous assumptions ( e.g. mass - traces - light , and isotropic velocities ) which have been made in deriving the equations of the isentropic surfaces .
the well - defined nature of the locus followed by these dwarfs is a strong indicator of their structural coherence , and the larger scatter that they exhibit about their photometric plane is largely due to the curvature of the surface they inhabit , rather than to a large random scatter in their properties .
normal galaxies , on the other hand , are offset relative to the dwarf locus , in a direction corresponding to higher specific entropy . in this context , it is interesting that @xcite find , from their simulations , that merging tends to increase specific entropy .
hence the offset may indicate that normal ellipticals , which fall above the dip seen in the galaxy luminosity function , have undergone mergers , whilst dwarfs have not .
this supports the idea @xcite that merging may have played a role in generating the dip in the luminosity function , by converting middle - ranking galaxies into larger ones , whilst dwarfs are largely unaffected due to their smaller merger cross - sections .
we would like to thank ale terlevich for help in observation and basic data reduction , john osmond for making the results of his analysis available for us and yogesh wadadekar for the use of his 2d decomposition code .
99 andredakis , y.c . ,
peletier , r.f . , & balcells , m. 1995 , mnras , 275 , 874 balogh m.l . , smail i. , bower r.g . , ziegler b.l . , smith g.p
, davies r.l . , gaztelu a. , kneib j .- p . and ebeling h. , 2002 , apj , 566 , 123 bertin g. & arnouts , s. , 1996 , a&as , 117 , 393 bertin g. , ciotti l. and del principe m. 2002 , a&a , 386 , 149 binggeli b. and jerjen h. , 1998 , a&a , 333 , 17 burstein , d. 1979 , apjs , 41 , 435 caon , n. , capaccioli , m. & donofrio , m. 1993 , mnras , 163,1013 de jong , r. s. 1996 , a&as , 118 , 557 dellantonio i.p .
geller m.j . and fabricant d.g . , 1994 ,
aj , 107 , 427 de vaucouleurs , g. 1948 , ann . dastrophys . , 11
, 247 djorgovski , s.g . &
davis , m. 1987 , apj , 313 , 59 dressler a. et al.1987 , apj , 313 , 42 faber , s. m. , and jackson , r. e. 1976 , apj , 204 , 668 ferguson , h. c. & binggeli , b. 1994 , a&a rev . , 6 , 67 forbes , d. a. , ponman , t. j. , & brown , r. j. n. 1998 , apj , 508 , l43 freeman , k. 1970 , apj , 160 , 811 graham a. w. & guzmn r. , 2003 , aj , 125 , 2936 graham a. w. , 2001 , aj , 121 , 820 graham a. w. , trujillo i. and caon n. , 2001 , aj , 122 , 1707 guzmn r. , graham a.w . , matkovic a. , vass i. , gorgas j. and cradiel n , 2003 , astro - ph/0303390 helsdon s. f. & ponman t. j. 2000 , mnras , 315 , 356 jorgensen i. , franx m. and kjaergaard p. , 1995 ,
mnras , 276 , 1341 jorgensen i. , franx m. and kjaergaard p. , 1996 ,
mnras , 280 , 167 khosroshahi h. g. , wadadekar y. , kembhavi a. and mobasher b. 2000a , apj , 531 , l103 khosroshahi h. g. , wadadekar y. and kembhavi a. 2000b , apj , 533 , 162 kormendy , j. 1977 , apj , 217 , 406 kormendy , j. 1985 , apj , 295 , 73 lima neto g. b. , gerbal d. and marquez i. 1999 , mnras , 309 , 481 mamon , g. a. 1986 , apj , 307 , 426 mrquez i. , lima neto g. b. , capelato h. , durret f. , gerbal d. , 2000 , a&a , 353 , 873 mrquez i. , lima neto g. b. , capelato h. , durret f. , lanzoni b. , gerbal d. , 2001 , a&a , 379 , 767 miles t. a. , raychaudhury s. , forbes , d. , goudfrooij , p. , ponman , t.j .
, 2003 , submitted to mnras mulchaey j. s. 2000 , araa , 38 , 289 nieto j .- l . , bender r. , davoust e. and prugniel p. 1990 , a&a , 230 , l17 osmond , j.p.f .
& ponman t.j . , 2003 ,
submitted to mnras peterson r.c . and caldwell n. , 1993 , aj , 105 , 1411 sersic , j.l . 1968 , atlas de galaxias australes .
observatorio astronomica , cordoba summers , l. k. , stevens , i. r. , & strickland , d. k. 2001 , mnras , 327 , 385 terlevich , a. i. , caldwell , n. , & bower , r. g. 2001 , mnras , 326 , 1547 trujillo i. , aguerri j.a.l . , gutierrez c.m . and cepa j. , 2001 , aj , 122 , 38 trujillo i. , aguerri j.a.l .
, gutierrez c.m . , caon n. and cepa j. , 2002 , apj , 573l , 9 wadadekar y. , robbason r. , & kembhavi a. 1999 , aj , 117 , 1219 young c.k . and currie m.j .
1994 , mnras , 268 , l11 ziegler b.l .
, saglia r.p . , bender r. , belloni p. , greggio l. and seitz s. , 1999 , a&a , 346 , 13 | we present a photometric analysis of a large sample of early - type galaxies in 16 nearby groups , imaged with the wide - field camera on the isaac newton telescope . using a two - dimensional surface brightness decomposition routine
, we fit sersic ( @xmath0 ) and exponential models to their bulge and disk components respectively . dividing the galaxies into three subsamples according to the x - ray luminosities of their parent groups , we compare their photometric properties .
galaxies in x - ray luminous groups tend to be larger and more luminous than those in groups with undetected or low x - ray luminosities , but no significant differences in @xmath1 are seen .
both normal and dwarf elliptical galaxies in the central regions of groups are found to have cuspier profiles than their counterparts in group outskirts .
structural differences between dwarf and normal elliptical galaxies are apparent in terms of an offset between their `` photometric planes '' in the space of @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
dwarf ellipticals are found to populate a surface , with remarkably low scatter , in this space with significant curvature , somewhat similar to the surfaces of constant entropy proposed by @xcite .
normal ellipticals are offset from this distribution in a direction of higher specific entropy .
this may indicate that the two populations are distinguished by the action of galaxy merging on larger galaxies .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : fundamental parameters galaxies : evolution galaxies : dwarf galaxies : elliptical and lenticular , cd galaxies : structure galaxies : groups x - ray : galaxies : clusters |
compact diode - pumped sources of the femtosecond pulses tunable within the wavelength range between 2 and 3 @xmath0 m are of interest for various applications , such as laser surgery , remote sensing and monitoring , spectroscopy of semiconductors etc . to date
only cryogenically operated pb - salt diode lasers , optical parametrical oscillators and difference - frequency convertors were available for the operation in this spectral range .
therefore the possibility of the direct mid - ir lasing from the new class of the transition - metal doped chalcogenides @xcite has attracted much attention .
the impressive advantages of these media are room - temperature operation between 2 and 3 @xmath0 m , possibility of direct diode pumping , high emission and absorption cross - sections , negligibly low excited - state absorption and , as consequence , low thermal load ( the basic laser material characteristics will be described in the next section ) . the most remarkable examples of such lasers are cr@xmath1-doped znse , zns and znte . to date
the following achievements for these media have been demonstrated : 1 ) for cr : znse cw operation with over 1.7 w power @xcite , over 1100 nm tunability @xcite , over 350 nm tunable diode - pumped cw operation @xcite , active mode locking @xcite and active modulator assisted passive mode locking @xcite were achieved ; 2 ) for cr : zns pulsed @xcite and tunable cw operation @xcite were obtained .
cr : znte , which is a member of the considered media class , remains unexplored . in spite of the numerous advantages ,
there exist some obstacles for femtosecond pulse generation from these lasers . as they are the semiconductors , i.e. possess a comparatively narrow band - gap , the nonlinear refraction in the active crystal is large ( see below ) .
hence the self - focusing has a comparatively low threshold which in the combination with the self - phase modulation produce a tendency to the multiple pulse operation in the kerr - lens mode locking ( klm ) regime @xcite .
thus , there is a need in the study of the klm stability limits and methods of the stability enhancement in the considered lasers .
moreover , the large absorption and emission cross sections tend to the stabilization of the cw operation , which prevents the klm self - start .
in this paper we present an analysis of the nonlinear refraction in the zinc - chalcogenides ( by the example of znse ) . in the combination with the lasing properties this defines the main requirements to the klm optimization .
then , the results of the numerical optimization of the klm aimed at the multipulsing suppression and taking into account a strong saturation of the kerr - lens induced fast absorber are presented .
we demonstrate the possibility of the few optical cycle pulse generation from the cr - doped zinc - chalcogenodes .
the problem of the self - starting klm is analyzed on the basis of the generalized momentum method taking into account real - world laser configurations , gain guiding , soft - aperture , thermo - lensing and other properties of the considered laser materials .
the presented models are quite general and can be applied to the overall optimization of the different klm lasers .
simulation of the klm can be based on the two quite different approaches .
first one supposes the full - dimensional modelling taking into account the details of the field propagation in the laser cavity @xcite .
the minimal dimension of such models is 2 + 1 and they allow the description of the spatio - temporal dynamics of the ultrashort pulses and their mode pattern .
its main disadvantages are a large number of the parameters resulting in ambiguity of the optimization procedure and complexity of the interpretation of the obtained results .
second approach is based on 1 + 1 dimensional model in the framework of the so - called nonlinear ginzburg - landau equation @xcite , which describes the klm as an action of the fast saturable absorber governed by the few physically meaningful parameters , viz . , its modulation depth @xmath2 and the inverse saturation intensity @xmath3 .
this method allows the analytical realization in the week - nonlinear limit @xcite , however in the general case the numerical simulations are necessary .
we shall base our analysis on the both approaches . in the beginning
let us consider the master equation describing the ultrashort pulse generation in the klm solid - state laser : @xmath4a(z , t),\ ] ] where @xmath5 is the field amplitude ( so that @xmath6 has a dimension of the intensity ) , @xmath7 is the longitudinal coordinate normalized to the cavity length ( thus , as a matter of fact , this is the cavity round - trip number ) , @xmath8 is the local time , @xmath9 is the saturated gain coefficient , @xmath10 is the linear net - loss coefficient taking into account the intracavity and output losses , @xmath11 is the group delay caused by the spectral filtering within the cavity , @xmath12 are the @xmath13-order group - delay dispersion ( gdd ) coefficients , @xmath14 = @xmath15 = @xmath16 is the self - phase modulation ( spm ) coefficient , @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the frequency and wavelength corresponding to the gain band maximum , @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the linear and nonlinear refraction indexes , respectively , @xmath21 is the double length of the gain medium ( we suppose that the gain medium gives a main contribution to the spm ) .
the last term in eq . describes the self - steepening effect and for the simplification will be not taken into account in the simulations . as an additional simplification we neglect the stimulated raman scattering in the active medium @xcite .
these two factors will be considered hereafter .
the gain coefficient obeys the following equation : @xmath22 here @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the absorption and emission cross - sections of the active medium , respectively , @xmath25 is the gain relaxation time , @xmath26 is the absorbed pump intensity , @xmath27 is the pump frequency , @xmath28 = @xmath29 is the maximum gain coefficient , @xmath30 is the concentration of the active centers .
the assumption @xmath31 ( @xmath32 is the pulse duration , @xmath33 is the cavity period ) allows the integration of eq . .
then for the steady - state gain coefficient we have : @xmath34 where @xmath35 = @xmath36 is the gain saturation energy flux , @xmath37 = @xmath38 is the pulse energy . for the numerical simulations in the framework of the distributed model it is convenient to normalize the time and the intensity to @xmath11 = @xmath39 and @xmath40 , respectively ( @xmath41 is the gain bandwidth ) .
the simulation were performed on the @xmath42 mesh .
only steady - state pulses were considered . as the criterion of the steady - state operation we chose the peak intensity change less than 1% over last 1000 cavity transits .
the klm in the considered model ( [ lg ] , [ alpha ] ) is governed by the only four basic parameters : @xmath43 , @xmath44 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 .
this allows unambiguous multiparametric optimization . in the presence of the higher - order dispersions ,
the additional @xmath12 parameters appear .
this complicates the optimization procedure , but keeps its physical clarity .
now let us consider the basic active media parameters .
.[params - exp ] material parameters of the cr - doped zinc - chalcogenides . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
in the previous section we considered the ultrashort pulse stability on the basis of the distributed 1 + 1-dimensional model . however , this model can not provide answers to the basic questions : what is the self - start ability of the kerr - lens mode locking and what has the real - world laser configuration to be ?
these questions require an analysis on the basis of the time - spatial model .
the simplest way is the assumption of the gaussian spatial distribution for the laser beam reducing problem to the 1 + 2-dimensions .
the free - space propagation of the gaussian beam can be considered on the basis of the usual abcd - matrix formalism , while the propagation inside the nonlinear active medium is described by the following equation : @xmath45a\left ( { z , r , t } \right ) + i\chi \left| { a\left ( { z , r , t } \right ) } \right|^2 a\left ( { z , r , t } \right ) = \\ \alpha \exp \left ( { - \frac{{2r^2 } } { { w_p^2 } } } \right)a\left ( { z , r , t } \right ) + t_f ' ^2 \frac{{\partial ^2 a\left ( { z , r , t } \right ) } } { { \partial t^2 } }
. \nonumber\end{gathered}\ ] ] here @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the group - velocity dispersion and the inverse group - velocity delay coefficients ( for znse we used @xmath48=2054 fs@xmath49/cm and @xmath47=13 fs / cm ) . the left - hand side of eq .
( [ self ] ) describes the non - dissipative factors : thermo - lensing @xcite ( @xmath50=@xmath51/ @xmath52 , @xmath53 is the wave number , @xmath54 is the coefficient of the refractive index thermo - dependence ( 5.35@xmath55 for znse ) , @xmath56 is the loss coefficient at the pump wavelength , @xmath57 is the pump power , @xmath58 is the thermo - conductivity coefficient ( 0.172 @xmath59 for znse ) ) ; diffraction ( in the cylindrically symmetrical case ) ; group - velocity dispersion and self - phase modulation ( providing self - focusing for radially varying beam , @xmath60=@xmath61 ) . the right - hand side of eq .
( [ self ] ) describes the dissipative factors inside the gain medium : radially varying gain ( providing gain guiding and soft aperture action , @xmath9 and @xmath62 are the saturated gain coefficient and the pump beam size , respectively ) ; spectral filtering caused by the gain band profile .
it is convenient to rewrite eq .
( [ gain ] ) in the following way : @xmath63 where @xmath64=@xmath65 ( @xmath66 is the generation power ) , @xmath67 is the generation mode beam size .
@xmath64=@xmath68 for the pulse with the gaussian time - profile , 2 for the @xmath69-shaped pulse and 1 for the cw ( in the latter case @xmath32=@xmath33 ) . the crucial simplification in the analysis of eq . ( [ self ] )
is based on the so - called aberrationless approximation : the propagating field has the invariable spatial - time profile , which is described by the set of the @xmath7-dependent parameters . in the non - dissipative case
this approximation allows the variational approach providing rigorous description of the gaussian beam propagation outside the parabolical approximation @xcite . in the dissipative case we have to use the momentum method @xcite
however , in contrast to refs . @xcite we shall consider the momentums resulting from the symmetries of eq .
( [ self ] ) .
the @xmath70 invariance , the transverse and time translating invariance suggest the following momentums @xcite : @xmath71 like the variational approach we can substitute to eqs .
( [ momentum ] ) the trial solution describing the ultrashort pulse . if we take the gaussian time - spatial profile @xmath72 ( @xmath73 is the complex amplitude , @xmath74=@xmath75 , @xmath76 is the pulse amplification parameter excepting the geometrical magnification for the gaussian beam ) , the equations describing the evolution of the pulse and beam parameters are @xcite : @xmath77 t_f^2 + 2 \beta_2 ' ^2 \tau \left ( z \right)\psi \left ( z \right),\\ \label{iter } \frac{{dg\left ( z \right)}}{{dz } } = \frac{\alpha } { { 1 + \frac{{2w'\left ( z \right)^2 } } { { w_p^2 } } } } - \frac{{2t_f^2 } } { { \tau \left ( z \right)^2 } } - \beta_2 ' ^2 \psi \left ( z \right),\\ \nonumber \frac{{db\left ( z \right)}}{{dz } } = \frac{{2\vartheta } } { { w_p^2 } } + \frac{{2b\left ( z \right)^2 } } { k } + \frac{{\sqrt 2 p_0 e^{2g\left ( z \right ) } } } { { \pi p_{cr } k w\left ( z \right ) ' ^4 } } - \frac{1}{{2kw'\left ( z \right)^4 } } , \\ \nonumber \frac{{d\psi \left ( z \right)}}{{dz } } = 2 \beta_2 ' ^2 \left ( { \frac{1}{{\tau \left ( z \right)^4 } } - \psi \left ( z \right)^2 } \right ) - \frac{{8t_f^2 \psi \left ( z \right)}}{{\tau \left ( z \right)^2 } } + \frac{{2 p_0 e^{2g\left ( z \right ) } } } { { \pi p_{cr } w\left ( z \right ) ' ^2 \tau \left ( z \right)^2 } } , \\ \nonumber p_g = p_0 e^{2g\left ( z \right)},\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath78 and @xmath79 are the power and the beam size before the active medium , respectively .
eq . ( [ iter ] ) in the combination with the abcd - formalism allows defining the stability regions for cw , single- and multiple pulsing ( the latter requires the trivial generalization of the trial function ) .
such regions can predict the real - world laser configurations providing the self - starting kerr - lens mode locking . as it is seen from table 2 the main features of the considered
active media are the comparatively low @xmath80 ( e.g. @xmath80=2.6 mw for ti : sapphire ) and the extremely low @xmath81 ( 300 kw for ti : sapphire ) .
this causes the stabilization of the cw against the mode locking due to the strong gain saturation .
however , as it is seen from eqs .
( [ gain2 ] , [ iter ] ) ( note that the gain saturation is intensity - dependent , but the self - focusing is power - dependent ) , we can enhance the tendency to the mode locking due to the suppression of the gain saturation .
this can be achieved by the growth of the generation mode within the active medium owing to , for example , the cavity shortening or the decrease of the folding mirrors curvature ( fig .
[ zones ] ) . at the same time we have to keep the moderate level of the absorbed pump power and to use the asymmetrical cavity in order to separate the stability zones .
the preferable configurations correspond to the pulse operation without the cw .
this occurs between the cw stability zones ( see fig . [ zones ] ) .
in conclusion , we presented the models , which can be usable for the numerical optimization of the klm lasers . on the basis of these models ,
the klm abilities of the cr - doped zinc - chalcogenides were estimated .
it was shown , that the strong spm inherent to these media and destabilizing the single pulse operation can be overcomed by the choice of the appropriate gdd , pump , modulation depth and saturation parameter of the kerr - lensing induced fast saturable absorber . as a result ,
the cr : znte possesses the lowest klm threshold , however strong spm constrains the achievable pulse power for this laser .
the best stability for the highest energy flux and the shortest pulse duration ( 19 fs ) are achievable in cr : zns .
cr : znse .
the presence of the third - order dispersion increases the minimum achievable pulse durations up to 34 - 40 fs and causes the strong ( up to 140 nm ) stokes shift of the generation wavelength .
however , the latter effect does not reduce noticeably the pulse energy .
the kerr - lens mode locking self - start ability of the considered active media is reduced by the strong gain saturation so that the cavity tuning providing the ultrashort pulsing differs essentially from that for the ti : sapphire .
we have to avoid over - pumping and over - shortening of the generation mode . as a result , the short and asymmetrical cavities with the comparatively large curvature of the folding mirrors are preferable . on the whole , the cr - doped zinc - chalcogenides have the prospects for the sub-50 fs generation that amounts to only few optical cycles around 2.5 @xmath0 m .
this work was supported by austrian national science fund project m688 .
l.d.deloach , r.h.page , g.d.wilke , s.a.payne , and w.f.krupke .
`` transition metal - doped zinc chalcogenides : spectroscopy and laser demonstration of a new class of gain media , '' _ ieee j. quantum electron . _
* 32 * , pp . 885895 , 1996 .
r.h.page , k.i.schaffers , l.d.deloach , g.d.wilke , f.d.patel , j.b.tassano , s.a.payne , w.f.krupke , k .-
t.chen , a.burger .
`` cr@xmath1:doped zinc chalcogenides as efficient widely tunable mid - infrared lasers , '' _ ieee j. quantum electron . _ * 33 * , pp . 609619 , 1997 .
u.hmmerich , x.wu , v.d.davis , s.b.trivedi , k.grasze , r.j.chen , s.w.kutcher .
`` demonstration of room - temperature laser action at 2.5 @xmath0 m from cr@xmath1:cd@xmath82mn@xmath83te , '' _ optics lett . _ * 22 * , pp . 11801182 , 1997 .
g.j.wagner , t.j.carrig .
`` power scaling of cr@xmath84:znse lasers , '' in _ osa trends in optics and photonics _ , vol .
50 , _ advanced solid - state lasers _
marshall , ed .
( osa , washington dc 2001 ) , pp . 506510 .
i.t.sorokina , e.sorokin , a.dilieto , m.tonelli , r.h.page . `` tunable diode - pumped continuous - wave operation and passive mode - locking of cr@xmath1:znse laser , '' in _ conference on lasers and electro - optics / europe 2001 _ , conference digest , mnich , p. 151
, 2001 .
e.sorokin , i.t.sorokina , r.h.page .
room - temperature cw diode - pumped cr@xmath85:znse laser , in _ osa trends in optics and photonics _ , vol .
50 , _ advanced solid - state lasers _ , cr .
marshall , ed .
( osa , washington dc 2001 ) , pp . 101105 .
k.graham , s.mirov , v.fedorov , m.e.zvanut , a.avanesov , v.badikov , b.ignatev , v.panutin , g.shevirdyaeva .
`` spectroscopic characteristics and laser performance of diffusion doped cr@xmath1:zns , '' in _ osa trends in optics and photonics _ , vol .
50 , _ advanced solid - state lasers _ , cr .
marshall , ed .
( osa , washington dc 2001 ) , pp . 561567 .
v.l.kalashnikov , e.sorokin , i.t.sorokina .
`` multipulse operation and limits of the kerr - lens mode locking stability for cr@xmath1:znse laser , '' in _ osa trends in optics and photonics _ , vol .
65 , _ advanced solid - state lasers _ , m.e .
fermann , l.r .
marshall , eds .
( osa , washington dc 2002 ) , pp . 374378 .
detailed investigations show some interesting modification of the single pulse stability and its spectral characteristics , see v.l .
kalashnikov , s. naumov , e. sorokin , i. sorokina , `` spectral broadening and shift of the few optical cycle pulses in cr@xmath86:yag laser , '' in program of assp2003 , san antonio , usa , february 2 - 5 , tub1 , 2003 . | the kerr - lens mode locking ability and the ultrashort pulse characteristics are analyzed numerically for the cr - doped znte , znse , zns active media .
the advantages of these materials for the femtosecond lasing within 2 - 3 @xmath0 m spectral range are demonstrated . |
the superconductivity is the intrinsic capacity of certain materials that allows to conduct electric currents without resistance and losses of energy in specific conditions . in 1911
it was discovery by heike kamerlingh onnes@xcite when observed the electric resistance of the mercury disappear abrupt at 4.2k . in the next years
several materials were discovered showing the occurrence of this phenomenon below certain critical temperature value @xmath5 .
a microscopic explanation was not arrived until 1960 , when bardeen , schriefer and cooper proposed a successful theory , today known as the bcs theory . with the discovery of the @xmath1 superconductor in 1986 at @xmath6 , was open a new stage , up to now devoted to the obtaining and investigation of such kind of high @xmath5 superconductors . in this case , up to nowadays it had not been possible to develop a full explanation for high temperature superconductivity .
the essential characteristic of the first discovered htc superconductor @xmath1 , and various others in its class , is that it has a crystalline structure containing cuo2 layers , inside a perovskite structure separated by block layers , who play a main role as charge reservoirs .
usually , the block layers are insulators and do not have any contribution to the low energy electronics states .
on another hand in the layers , the minimum energy of the electronics state are around the fermi level . at half filling ( hole concentration p=0 ) , the cuprates are antiferromagnetic insulators ( afi ) , with a neel temperature near 300 @xmath7 . when the number of holes grow , the antiferromagnetic phase is rapidly destroyed and the cuprates show a pseudogap phase .
if you continue doping with hole , the metallic phase turns up . in 1930
bloch and wilson @xcite developed the band theory , that explain why several materials are metals and another are insulators . however the band theory failed in trying to explain the electronic structure of a large number of insulators . in this group were the , and , which were predicted as having metallic behavior .
this result opened the doors for the profound study of the strongly correlated materials , which are characterized by showing strong correlation properties among the electrons .
two of the founding fathers of these studies mott and hubbard , attributed the insulator behavior to the electron - electron correlation .
nowadays , a generalized criterion exists : for getting behaviors like the ones of insulators of mott , it is necessary to take into account the short range correlations between electrons of opposite spin which are included in the phenomenological hubbard models @xcite .
it is also clear that the hf approximation , when is considered from first principles in a elemental electronic system , should not be able to predict the correlation between opposite spin electrons . in the recent works @xcite by using a one band model , solved in the hf approximation , it was obtained a gap at @xmath8 for the , then predicting its insulator behavior .
this reflect that some of the important properties of these materials , that are products of the strong electronic correlations , can be predicted by the model in the hf approximation .
this outcome does not result strange , after taking in mind that , by example the antiferromagnetism , that is a strong correlation property , can be derived form a hf solution of the hubbard model .
the main point to note in this , is that the considered model is not the original first principle electronic system .
in fact the model only differs from a hubbard one in that the near neighbor approximation was not taken .
since the hamiltonian adopted in the model does not includes the spin , the hf solution do not determine a direction for the antiferromagnetism .
this fact define the basic motivation of this work .
it consists in including the spin - orbit interaction in the starting hamiltonian and then study the effect of the spin - orbit interaction in the solutions .
the expectation was to study the magnetic anisotropy of the model .
therefore , he specific objectives of our work are the following ones : 1 .
obtain the form of the spin - orbit operator in the frame of the mentioned model for the superconductor material @xcite .
2 . afterwards , to evaluate the anisotropy energy of the antiferromagnetic hf states of the model , in the no doping limit of the . for this purpose the mean value of the spin - orbit operator of the electrons with the crystalline field @xcite
is evaluated in the hf states . since the hf solution is degenerated with respect to spin rotations , to evaluate the mean value , the hf states were arbitrarily rotated in the spin structure of their many particles @xcite , by unitary transformations .
these spin rotations are the ones representing corresponding space rotations around an arbitrary spatial axis .
in general , the htscs presents a tetragonal structure , and have one or more planes in its structure separated by layers of another atoms ( ba , o , la , ... ) . in the planes , each cooper ion is coupled to four oxygen ions separated an approximate distance of 1.9 . the critical temperature depended of the maximum number of adjoint layers ( figure [ fig_noplanos_sc ] ) .
the electronic behavior of the cuprates is very strongly determined by the electronic density in the two dimensional layers .
the basic behavior of the layers , is common for all the cuprate superconductors .
+ the family of monolayer compounds , , where x indicates the magnitude of strontium ( ) doping , crystallize to the tetragonal structure centered in body ( bct ) , usually named t structure , showed in the figure [ fig_htc_ec ] . in the the planes
are separated by @xmath9 6.6 , separated by 2 planes of , that act like charge reservoirs , absorbing electrons of the conductor planes under the doping of the material with holes .
+ exist consensus in consider the electronic structure of the , as quasi two dimensional .
this low dimensionality of this electronic system allows to be treated from another viewpoint .
for example collective phenomena , such as fluctuations in spin density waves ( s.d.w ) and charge density waves ( c.d.w ) , could be the origin of the superconducting mechanism @xcite . in the figure [ fig_tran_fase1 ]
, it is illustrated the phase diagrams in the ( x , t ) plane for the compound , where is the temperature .
even when the absolute antiferromagnetic order and the insulator mott state persist for a wide range of temperatures , it is very sensible at doping .
for example , in the @xmath8 limit , it is lost at @xmath10 doping , but in the pseudogap ( sg ) phases and superconductor ( sc ) ones , exist experimental evidence of a less extended afm order @xcite .
all the ideas mentioned before support the possibility that the afi state ( x=0 ) play a crucial role in guaranteeing first : a correlation between pairs of holes ( sg ) , second : a condensation of these holes toward the sc state @xcite . in this compound
a structural phase transition occurs . at high temperatures the structure is tetragonal , but for low temperature the cu atoms and the six oxygens around them , stray slowly of their positions , forming an orthorhombic structure . in the majority of the theoretical studies about this compound
, this little distortion is usually ignored .
the crystalline structure of the lsco have simple planes , while the systems and ( ybco ) has double planes .
the intermediate layers of lsco do not have the chains that affects considerably the planes , in contrast with ybco , and the complicate structure that present the intermediate layers of the .
the band diagram shown in the figure [ fig_banda_matheiss ] associated to the was obtained by means of techniques of lapw@xcite .
the last occupied band is half filled , predicting a metallic behavior , and its form suggests a tight - binding nature for the electron gas that occupied it within the effective environment of the rest of the bands .
the less bound electrons to the compound , are the ones of the atoms , that do not have closed their last shells ( 3d ) , at difference with the situation with the ions .
these electrons are the ones that form the last band in the corresponding solid .
predict a tight - binding behavior in the reciprocal plane , title="fig : " ] + the model proposed in the references @xcite is described in this section .
one of the most used pictures to describe the movement of the valence electrons in a solid with a periodic potential is the tight - binding model .
this model is applicable when the overlapping of the atomic orbitals of the neighbors can be considered small and it can be supposed that is not necessary to carry out significant corrections to the atomic wave functions , created by the interaction with the neighboring orbitals .
the tight - binding approximation provides a reconciliation among the seemingly contradictory representations of the very localized atomic levels and on another hand the free electron model @xcite , in which the wave functions are lineal combination of planes waves . from the previous comments we can suppose that these electrons are strongly correlated to the base cells , preferably toward the corresponding centers of @xcite
. then , the lattice will be supposed as the square lattice of @xmath11 atoms located at the @xmath4 planes ( see figure [ fig_sub_redes ] ) .
the electrons not belonging to the last band and the nuclear charge that neutralizes them , play a double role .
they act in one hand , as an effective polarizable medium that screens the field produced by a point charge external to them , and in second place , due to their spatial distribution and magnitude , they guarantee with their action the periodic order of the solid , that is modeled with a periodic potential in the lattice of points .
the hamiltonian of the model introduced in the references take the form : @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the kinetic energy term , @xmath14 is the periodic potential that exercise the electrons in the partially filled single band , and @xmath15 runs over the points of the lattice of ( see figure [ fig_sub_redes ] ) , @xmath16 is the potential of the jellium background correspondingly only to the surplus of charges which neutralize the electrons that partially filled the band , @xmath17 screened coulomb potential , @xmath18 is the effective potential that feel the electrons that partially filling the last band , @xmath19 is the spin - orbit interaction term .
+ + one of the most useful techniques to find approximate solutions to the schrodinger 's equation is the molecular orbitals approximation . in this approach
it is considered that the electrons occupy spin - orbital functions of a given energy .
this technique is based in the _ variational theorem _ , which state that the expected value of @xmath20 for an arbitrary wave function is not smaller that the lowest eigenvalue @xmath21 corresponding to the exact solution of the equation@xcite .
then , the best wave function is obtained when the energy calculated by the equation ( [ variachf ] ) has a minimum .
@xmath22 then , the problem is reduced to find the solution by finding it form in all the allowed many electronic states , under the condition of making minimal the energy of the system . in the hf formalism one keeps each electron in a spin - orbital , in the field of the nucleus and the other electrons that are in their respective spin - orbitals ( fixed ) , subject to the constraint that the spin - orbitals are orthonormal .
after this minimization process , the hf equations for individual spin - orbitals result : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the fock operator and @xmath25 are the eigenvalues that represent the energies of the spin - orbitals ( @xmath26 ) . the fock operator for an arbitrary electron @xmath27 ( equation [ operfock ] ) can be separated in three terms like it is shown next : @xmath28,\ ] ] where the hamiltonian operator @xmath29 is defined by : @xmath30 here and in what follows , the arguments of the wave functions @xmath27 and @xmath31 , indicate the collection formed by the spacial coordinates and the spin . in absence of interelectronic interactions ( [ corefock ] )
will be the only operator corresponding to the movement of a single electron in the field of the nucleus and the other electrons , that do not pertain to the partially filled band crossing the fermi level .
the direct interaction operator is @xmath32 where @xmath33 represents the integral for the space coordinates and the sum for the spin coordinates .
this operator correspond to the average potential of an electron in the state @xmath34 . on the other hand the exchange operator is expressed as : @xmath35
the equation ( [ fock ] ) is known as the canonical hf equation and the fact that it corresponds to a non linear eigenvalue and eigenfunctions problem , implies that to find the solutions becomes necessary an iterative procedures .
this fact leads to propose a group of test spin - orbitals that allow to obtain a new group of such orbitals , from which a new fock operator is generated .
the process is repeated until the energy and the functions converges , such a procedure is named the self - consistent field process . in a general way the spin - orbitals ( @xmath26 )
are expanded by means of a well - known group of basis functions associated with the geometric positions of the nuclei .
this basis should satisfy two practical conditions 1 .
should reasonably describe the physics of the problem .
2 . the integrals that appears in the mathematical treatment should be evaluates with relative easiness .
the spatial components of the spin - orbitals is expanded in terms of the basis functions generally centered in atoms , according to ( [ basedes ] ) .
the expansion which must be infinite in principle , is truncated using a number of functions * m * , being @xmath36 the coefficients determining each atomic orbital contribution @xmath37 in the linear expansion @xcite
@xmath38 substituting the orbitals expanded according to ( [ basedes ] ) in the hf equation @xcite , a set of matrix equations is obtained which can be : @xmath39 where * f * is the fock matrix for the @xmath40 ; * s * is the superposition matrix among the elements of the base @xmath41 and * c * is the coefficients matrix @xmath36 . in the beginnings
, the developing of hf techniques for systems of many particles , like bands and polyatomic complex calculations , was limited by the memory and speed of the machine calculators of that times .
it was necessary to devise , on the basis of arguments and credible approaches , for example like the hole 's fermi model @xcite , mean field approximation , etc , a reduction of the functional space for searching and of the complications of the calculations .
an useful assumption is to consider that the solution states of the system of equations([scf ] ) have quantized spin in the same direction in all the space , that is to say : @xmath42 if the spatial functions @xmath43 and @xmath44 are identical , the hf calculations is named as restrictive , otherwise unrestricted @xcite .
however , due to their definitions , both cases are restrictive .
it can be said that the hf system of equations ( [ scf ] ) is written in a form being invariant under rotation , because it is not considered the spin quantization in one absolute direction .
that is , the states to be found are not @xmath45 type neither @xmath46 one .
the first in derive the hf equations in this fully unrestricted form was p. a. m. dirac in the 1930 @xcite .
work in this rotation invariant way wide the functional space being investigated . in consequence
it allows to extend the hf scheme towards the search of ground states showing magnetic character .
this possibility is suggested in references @xcite . these works considered a base that allowed to find hf solutions for the spin - orbitals showing spin quantization depending of the spatial position . the tight - binding basis in the one band approximation , that was used in these works consists of 4 sets of basis functions : @xmath47 where @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 .
the equation ( [ scf ] ) projected in the tight binding basis ( [ base de bloch ] ) was written in the form : @xmath51\textbf{.}\textrm{b}^{\textbf{k},l}= \widetilde{\varepsilon}_{l}(\textbf{k } ) \
\textrm{s}_{\textbf{k}}\textbf{.}\textrm{b}^{\textbf{k},l},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 is hamiltonian part that corresponds to the kinetic energy and the total effective potential , @xmath53 is the direct interaction term , + @xmath54 is the exchange term , + @xmath55 it is the neutralizing bottom potential , + @xmath56 is the overlapping matrix . + also @xmath57 and @xmath58 are the dimensionless parameters in those that @xmath59 is the characteristic radius of the functions @xmath60 , @xmath61 is the separation between two @xmath11 near neighbors in the absolute red , @xmath62 is planck constant , @xmath63 and @xmath64 are the mass and the charge of the electron respectively . in the low overlapping approximation among nearest neighbors ( that is to say among different sublattices ) the functions of the base that correspond to different sublattices with the same spin quantization are the only one , not being orthogonal .
however , the orthogonalization of different elements of the same sublattice , as well as the unit norm of all elements , are valid .
the @xmath65 orbitals will be called as wannier orbitals and represent the probability amplitude to find an electron in the surroundings of a point of the lattice .
magnetism arises on the sub - atomic level from localized polarization of the electron clouds of certain atoms arising from unpaired electrons .
this causes the charge on the atom to have a lattice angular momentum .
any flow of charge causes additional physical effects on the surroundings , usually referred to as a @xmath66 effect . in the case of atoms
the lattice angular momentum of the charge cloud causes a magnetic field perpendicular to the rotation plane of the charge .
the magnitude of this magnetic or spin moment is dependent on the species of atoms @xcite . how these spin moments interact with each other
is critical to how different materials are characterized magnetically .
when atoms are brought in proximity to each other there is a probability of an electron jumping from one atom to another , known as the heisenberg exchange [ 4 ] .
this interaction probability can indirectly couple the spin moments of the atoms , causing the spin moments to align parallel or anti - parallel . in most materials the spin moments are small and aligned randomly , leading to paramagnetism as shown in figure .
in some materials however , specifically transition metals such as nickel , cobalt , and iron , the spin moments are large , and align in parallel .
this causes a lattice spontaneous magnetic moment in the material . in case ,
the use of scattering of neutrons techniques @xcite , has contributed important information about the magnetic structure of these materials . in the figure [ fig_spin_plan3d ]
the afm profile of the in the copper - oxygen is shown .
the places contains the magnetic moment , whose address rests approximately to 45 grades on the link .
it happens that the ions and complete their more external layers , while the lacks an electron for it .
then the ion presents an electron without matching up .
it is also the less bound one to the arrangement .
( a ) [ [ section ] ]
one of the most basic parameters in a magnetic system is the magneto - crystalline anisotropy , that is , the preference of the spin moments to align with some fixed crystallographic axes .
this is a consequence of the interaction of the local environment though its spin - orbit interaction with the electrons .
the simplest form of anisotropy is the uniaxial one that consists in that the magnetic moment prefers to align throughout a simple axis @xmath67 , usually called the easy axis . considering the operator @xmath68 as an perturbation of the initial hamiltonian [ eqn_hamtotal ]
, the anisotropy energy will be evaluated in this subsection , in the first correction to the hf energy of the system , according to the corresponding formula of perturbation theory .
@xmath69 where the @xmath70 orbitals are obtained of rotating the orbital solution @xmath71 around the axis defined by the unitary vector @xmath72 in an angle @xmath73 . to rotate the orbital one should interpret the following procedure : let us suppose that we have an orbital that is eigenfunctions of the operator @xmath74 and we make a rotation around the axis defined by the unitary vector @xmath75 in an angle @xmath73
. then , the @xmath76 axis will become an @xmath77 axis , and the orbital will be transformed in an orbital that is eigenfunction of @xmath78 according to ( [ eqn_orbrot ] ) .
@xmath79 a rotation of the orbital leads to a rotation of the antiferromagnetic structure of the material at @xmath8 .
this can be expressed in the following way @xcite : @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the magnetization vector rotated around an @xmath75 axis , in an angle @xmath73 starting from the initial direction of the magnetization vector @xmath82 and @xmath83 is the tensor that rotates the magnetization vector in the three - dimensional space .
.,title="fig : " ] + the quantity @xmath84 can be interpreted in the following way : let us suppose that the system has its antiferromagnetic structure in certain direction and that this structure is rotated around the axis @xmath75 in an angle @xmath73 .
then @xmath85 is the correction to the hf energy of the system produced by the spin - orbit interaction , when the magnetic structure has that direction ( see figure [ fig_anti_rotada ] ) .
the anisotropy energy was studied in the initial model . that is , considering as the basis functions , the bloch functions constructed in the sublattices by means of defined by wannier gaussian orbitals .
it was already seen that in this two - dimensional model the spin - orbit operator reduces to the following form : @xmath86 in the following developments , it will be considered that @xmath87 , where @xmath63 is the electron mass .
the expression for the energy to evaluate is given for : @xmath88 where @xmath89 are the constants for the expansion of the hf solutions of the original problemin terms of the basis functions @xcite .
+ the formula ( [ eqn_energanis4 ] ) can be wrote as follows : @xmath91 @xmath92 @xmath93\varphi_{0}(\vec{x}-\vec{r^{r}}).\ ] ] in the nearest neighbor approximation , the term @xmath94 take the following form : @xmath95\varphi_{0}(\vec{x } ) & \text{if r = t } \\
\sum^{1}_{n=-1}e^{ik_{x}np}\int_{v^{n}_{2 } } d^{2}\vec{x}\varphi_{0}(\vec{x}+\vec{e_{x}}np)[e_{x}\hat{p}_{y}-e_{y}\hat{p}_{x}]\varphi_{0}(\vec{x})+ \\
\exp^{ik_{y}np}\int_{v^{n}_{3 } } d^{2}\vec{x}\varphi_{0}(\vec{x}+\vec{e_{y}}np)[e_{x}\hat{p}_{y}-e_{y}\hat{p}_{x}]\varphi_{0}(\vec{x } ) & \text{if $ r\neq t$ } \end{cases}\ ] ] that can be expressed in more explicit form according to : @xmath96e^{-\frac{\vec{x}^2}{2\ a^2 } } & \text{if r = t } \\
\sum^{1}_{n=-1}e^{ik_{x}np}\int_{v^{n}_{2 } } d^{2}\vec{x}e^{-\frac{|\vec{x}+\vec{e_{x}}np|^2}{2\ a^2}}[e_{y}x - e_{x}y]e^{-\frac{\vec{x}^2}{2\ a^2}}+ \\
e^{ik_{y}np}\int_{v^{n}_{3 } } d^{2}\vec{x}e^{-\frac{|\vec{x}+\vec{e_{y}}np|^2}{2\ a^2}}[e_{y}x - e_{x}y]e^{-\frac{\vec{x}^2}{2\ a^2 } } & \text{if $ r\neq t$ } \end{cases}\ ] ] where @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
the integration regions are taken in what follows of fixed dimensions because the wannier orbitals are very much localized in the lattice centers .
@xmath99 @xmath100 , @xmath101 @xmath102 : + @xmath103 , + @xmath104 , + @xmath105 , + @xmath106 , + @xmath107 . + as the wannier orbitals are two - dimensional gaussian functions , they coincide with the wavefunctions of the harmonic two - dimensional oscillator .
therefore , from the analysis already done , we can easily derive the effective potential in the vicinity of the as a parabolic potential ( figure [ fig_potencialefectivo1 ] ) .
@xmath108 and the length unit @xmath101 @xmath109.,title="fig : " ] + the components @xmath110 , @xmath111 of the electric field are derived form the effective potential , see figure [ fig_potencialefectivo ] .
they are odd functions in the @xmath112 coordinates , a property that makes that the integral factor @xmath113 is an odd function .
as the integration regions are symmetrical regarding , at least one of the coordinates , it follows that @xmath114 .
@xmath108 and the length unit @xmath101 @xmath109.,title="fig : " ] + this result evidences that the gaussian wannier orbitals in our small overlapping approximation , predict a vanishing anisotropy energy .
this means that the first correction to the hf energy for the system , determined by the spin - orbit interaction does nt determine an easy magnetization axis . this result is not coinciding with the observations , which indicates the existence an easy axis at zero doping and @xmath115
however , this difference can be attributed to various factors .
one of them is the known absence of long range order in the pure 2d systems .
another cause , can be the fact that the model slightly simplifies the microscopic structure of the electron system by assuming it as pure two dimensional and moreover , by considering wannier orbitals not resembling open the shell properties of the @xmath11 atoms .
the reduced form of @xmath94 ( [ eqn_orbrot3 ] ) indicates that their value only depends on the properties of symmetry of the electric field and the orbitals in a vicinity of the , and not in the whole lattice .
it points that out is fundamental to more deeply formulate the starting basis of states for the model to predict the magnetic properties .
in this section , it is considered a modification of the orbitals of the model in reference @xcite .
it is supposed that the wannier orbitals are three - dimensional .
their symmetry is assumed with the same properties as the original problem .
the wannier obitals in general sense will be denoted by @xmath116 .
it is supposed that they are even or odd functions regarding the inversion of anyone of their coordinates , referred to the atoms in that they are centered . in this case
the spin - orbit operator should have the usual form in three dimensions : @xmath117.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition of the anisotropy energy ( [ eqn_energanis ] ) and ( [ eqn_soexp1 ] ) , it follows that it is a lineal combination of terms of the form : @xmath118 where the @xmath119 are of the following form : @xmath120 , + @xmath121 , + @xmath122 , + where the regions of integration @xmath123 can have in general sense three possible spatial symmetries , when are defined by : + @xmath124 , + @xmath125 , + @xmath126 , + @xmath127 + , @xmath128 .
+ next it follows that : @xmath129 @xmath130 @xmath131 it can be underlined that the two functions @xmath132 and @xmath133 have the same parity regarding @xmath134 if both are even or odd . it is considered in our analysis that the effective potential near the atoms of our model is even .
hence it follows that the fields @xmath135 are odd functions regarding @xmath134 and once fixed @xmath134 , is even regarding the others coordinates @xmath136 .
let us show the ( [ eqn_demostrado]-[eqn_demostrado2 ] ) properties now .
proof of [ eqn_demostrado ] . 1 . the functions @xmath116 and @xmath137 has the same parity regarding @xmath134 and using the initial premise about the fields , the integrand is an odd function concerning the @xmath134 coordinate .
2 . let us use the result : if the integral of a function converges absolutely , in an integration region in @xmath138 that has parallelepiped form , then the iterate integrals can commute the integration order ( theorem of fubini ) .
3 . using the previous result we concluded that @xmath139 proof of [ eqn_demostrado1 ] . 1 .
if @xmath140 , then @xmath116 and @xmath141 have different parity regarding @xmath142 and @xmath143 and continues being even regarding @xmath142 , of the initial premise , for what ( [ eqn_demostrado1 ] ) is kept .
if @xmath144 , @xmath116 and @xmath145 have identical parity regarding @xmath134 and using the initial premise of the fields , then the integrand is odd regard the @xmath134 coordinate , for that ( [ eqn_demostrado1 ] ) is kept .
3 . in both cases the before cited fubini property was employed .
proof of [ eqn_demostrado2 ] 1 .
if @xmath146 , it follows that @xmath116 and @xmath147 have different parity regard @xmath148 and @xmath143 continues been even regard @xmath142 , of the initial premise , for what it vanishes .
if @xmath149 , @xmath116 and @xmath150 have identical parity regard @xmath134 and using the initial premise of the fields , then has an odd integrand regard the @xmath134 coordinate , and ( [ eqn_demostrado2 ] ) is kept .
3 . in both cases
the result of fubini also was used .
the results are summarized in the following form : if the wannier orbitals that we propose are even or odd functions regard the space coordinates and the effective potential that it is assumed in the vecinity of the atoms , is an even function regards the space coordinates , the anisotropy energy in the model also vanishes and therefore an axis easy magnetization is not predicted .
notice that the condition , that wannier orbitals that we propose are even or odd functions , is enough but not necessary condition for the vanishing of the energy .
this fits the possibility that using orbitals that neither be even or odd , a non vanishing anisotropy energy could follows .
as it is known that the less bound electrons of the occupy the @xmath2 orbitals , and the electrons considered into our model , are representing the one partially filling the most energetic band in @xmath151 we can expect that the wannier orbitals of our problem should more closely resemble the @xmath152orbitals of @xmath11 .
these @xmath152 orbitals are solutions of the hydrogen atom , .
then , we could assume as the potential in the vicinities of the a coulomb potential alternatively as it was considered in the initial model .
the wannier orbitals of the @xmath152 type are even functions regarding the space coordinates .
the components of the electric field @xmath143 are odd functions because derived of the coulomb potential .
then we uses the previous result to conclude that , if we suppose orbitals of the @xmath152 type then the model again will predicts anisotropy energy null and non easy axis of magnetization
. however , the possibility of employing a general linear combination of the @xmath2 orbitals of @xmath11 in addition to a more realistic @xmath3 character of the model by including multiple @xmath4 planes , opens the the opportunity to describe the observed antiferromagnetic anisotropy at low doping and temperatures .
to study the influence of the spin - orbit operator in the hartree - fock approximation the operator is projected in the basis of the orbitals proposed in the model : @xmath153\textbf{.}\textrm{b}^{\textbf{k},l}= \widetilde{\varepsilon}_{l}(\textbf{k } ) \ \textrm{s}_{\textbf{k}}\textbf{.}\textrm{b}^{\textbf{k},l}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can include the spin operator to obtain the next matrix equation @xmath154\textbf{.}\textrm{b}^{\textbf{k},l}= \widetilde{\varepsilon}_{l}(\textbf{k } ) \
\textrm{s}_{\textbf{k}}\textbf{.}\textrm{b}^{\textbf{k},l},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the derivation of the term @xmath155 in the model is presented next : @xmath156 where @xmath157 + @xmath158 @xmath159 in the near neighbor approximation the term @xmath160 take the following form : + @xmath161,\ ] ] + @xmath162 , + @xmath163 , + @xmath164 . + for the same reasons that in section ( anisotropy energy with orbitals of wannier gaussian ) the five integrals are null .
+ @xmath165 .
+ we can conclude that the spin - orbit operator is null in the matrix hartree fock representation , that implies no change in the hartree fock solution .
the same analysis could be done with the three dimensional wannier orbitals and the result using the section(anisotropy energy with orbitals of wannier that are odd or even functions ) would be the same as for bidimensional gaussian wannier orbitals .
we have studied the magnetic anisotropy properties of at zero temperature , in the context of a two - dimensional model of the layers , which hartree fock solutions were obtained in references@xcite . for this purpose the spin - orbit interaction was considered as a perturbation to the initial hamiltonian of the system and the energy was evaluated as a function of the direction of the antiferromagnetic structure of the material , when it is rotated .
the basic conclusions of the work are : \2 ) for the gaussian wannier orbitals and their parabolic corresponding effective potential employed in the model , it was obtained that the magnetic anisotropy energy vanishes .
then , an easy axis of magnetization does nt appears and the antiferromagnetic structure does nt align in any direction .
\3 ) the use of more general wannier orbitals , as can be gaussian atomic three - dimensional or orbital @xmath2 type , assuming that they are even or odd , all produce vanishing vanishing anisotropy energy .
this follows mainly because the orbitals and the potentials are even or odd functions with regard the coordinates . | we study the anisotropy energy in a planar model for the @xmath0 layers of the investigated in previous works .
the tight - binding ( tb ) potential of the model was extended out of the validity region with the purpose of incorporate it in the potential .
next , the spin - orbit operator was considered in the hartree fock solution of the full hf problem .
it follows that in spite of the fact that the extended potential possesses the square symmetry of the crystalline structure , the anisotropy energy vanishes in its purely 2d formulation .
the result indicates that for the prediction by the model of the observed non vanishing magnetic anisotropy at zero doping and temperature in @xmath1 , its formulation requires of a 3d representation of its wannier orbitals and the use of @xmath2 like orbitals .
the consideration of more realistic @xmath3 character of the model , by including multiple @xmath4 planes , also could be important due to the argued absence of long range order in 2d . |
the transport of biologically or chemically active substances by a fluid flow is a problem of great geophysical relevance .
important examples arise in the study of atmospheric advection of reactive pollutants or chemicals , such as ozone , n@xmath0o @xcite , or in the dynamics of plankton populations in ocean currents @xcite .
the inhomogeneous nature of the resulting spatial distributions was recognized some time ago ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
more recently , satellite remote sensing and detailed numerical simulations identify filaments , irregular patches , sharp gradients , and other complex structures involving a wide range of spatial scales in the concentration patterns . in the case of atmospheric chemistry , the presence of strong concentration gradients has been shown to have profound impact on global chemical time - scales @xcite .
on - site measurements and data analysis of the chemical or biological fields have confirmed their fractal or multifractal character @xcite . in the case of plankton communities , _ patchiness _ has been variously attributed to the interplay of diffusion and biological growth , oceanic turbulence , diffusive instabilities , and nutrient or biological inhomogeneities @xcite .
advection by unsteady fluid flow and predator - prey interactions ( formally equivalent to chemical reaction ) are emerging as two key ingredients able to reproduce the main qualitative features of plankton patchiness @xcite .
the ` chaotic advection ' paradigm has been shown to be a useful approach to understand geophysical transport processes at large scales @xcite . briefly
, chaotic advection ( or lagrangian chaos)@xcite refers to the lagrangian complex motion of fluid parcels arising from a flow which is not turbulent in the eulerian description .
lagrangian chaotic flows are much simpler than turbulent ones , being thus more accessible to analytical characterization and understanding .
they retain however many of the qualitative features relevant to transport and mixing processes in complex geophysical flows .
though the properties of inert passive tracer fields under chaotic advection have been widely studied @xcite much less is known about biologically or chemically evolving reactant distributions .
nonetheless , some results have been recently obtained , as for example in reactions of the type @xmath1 in closed chaotic flows @xcite and in open chaotic flows @xcite .
recently , some of us @xcite considered the general case of stable chemical dynamics in closed chaotic flows in the limit of small diffusion and in the presence of an external spatially non - homogeneous source of one of the chemical components .
the main result was that the relationship between the rate at which the chemical dynamics approaches local equilibrium with the chemical source and the characteristic time scale of the stirring by the chaotic flow determines the fractal or non - fractal character of the long - time distribution .
the faster the stirring is , the more irregular is the pattern .
the purpose of this paper is to apply and verify the general results above in a concrete model of plankton dynamics in flows of geophysical relevance .
in addition we compare structures appearing in closed and open flows , stressing the intermittent character of irregularities in the open flow case .
we expect this result to apply also to other situations in atmospheric or oceanic chemistry .
the paper is organized as follows : next section summarizes the general theoretical results obtained by @xcite .
the particular plankton dynamics and the two different flows subject of our study are presented in sect .
[ sec : models ] .
they are variations of a kinematic model for a two - dimensional meandering jet , leading to a closed and an open flow model .
section [ sec : closed ] describes numerical results for the closed flow case , whereas sect .
[ sec : open ] considers the open flow .
finally , sect .
[ sec : conclusions ] contains our conclusions .
the temporal evolution of reacting fields is determined by advection - reaction - diffusion equations .
advection because they are under the influence of a flow , reaction because we consider species interacting with themselves and/or with the carrying medium .
diffusion because turbulent or molecular random motion smoothes out the smallest scales . for the case of an incompressible velocity field @xmath2 ,
the standard form of these equations is @xmath3 where @xmath4 , @xmath5 , are interacting chemical or biological fields advected by the flow @xmath2 , @xmath6 are the functions accounting for the interaction of the fields ( e.g. chemical reactions or predator - prey interactions ) .
diffusion effects are only important at small scales and we will neglect them in the following . in this limit of zero diffusion @xmath7 the above description can be recast in lagrangian form : @xmath8 @xmath9 where the second set of equations describes the chemical or population dynamics inside a fluid parcel that is being advected by the flow according to the first equation . in the absence of diffusion
, a coupling between the flow and the chemical / biological evolution can only appear as a consequence of the spatial dependence of the @xmath10 functions .
this spatial dependence describes non - homogeneous sources or sinks for the chemical reactants or spatially non - homogeneous reaction or reproduction rates .
such inhomogeneities may arise naturally from a variety of processes such as localized upwelling , inhomogeneous solar irradiation , or river run - off , to name a few . from now on ,
the incompressible flow @xmath2 will be assumed to be two - dimensional and time dependent .
this situation generally leads to chaotic advection . for simplicity
, our general arguments will be stated for the case in which @xmath2 satisfies the technical requirement of _ hyperbolicity _ , but in the examples less restrictive flows will be used .
the most salient feature of advection by a chaotic flow is sensibility to initial conditions , that is , fluid particles initially close typically diverge in time at a rate given by the maximum lyapunov exponent of the flow @xmath11 : @xmath12 equation ( [ lyapunov ] ) is valid for nearly all the initial orientations of the initial particle separation @xmath13 .
however , the incompressibility condition implies that there is a particular orientation of the initial separations @xmath14 for which the two trajectories approach each other : @xmath15 , with @xmath16 .
the general class of chemical reactions studied by @xcite was the one leading to stable local equilibrium in the absence of flow or , in terms of the chemical dynamical subsystem ( [ chemical ] ) , the dynamics approaching a unique fixed point for each constant position @xmath17 .
this means that there are not chemical instabilities nor chemical chaos , and that the concentrations tend to approach a value determined at each point by the sources in @xmath18 . in the presence of advection by the flow @xmath19 ,
the relaxation process is altered , but can be characterized by the value of the maximum lyapunov exponent @xmath20 of the chemical subsystem ( [ chemical ] ) , which we assume to remain negative . for characterizing the spatial structure of the @xmath21 fields we calculate the difference @xmath22 inserting this expression , for @xmath23 small enough , into the equation for the chemical dynamics ( details can be found in * ? ? ?
* ) we can obtain the evolution of the gradients of the chemical field at long times : @xmath24 where the vectors @xmath25 are combinations of the vectors @xmath26 pointing at each point along the most contracting direction of the flow and of the vector @xmath27 associated to the contracting direction in the chemical subspace .
@xmath28 is the trajectory ending at @xmath17 at time @xmath29 .
it is important to realize that eq .
( [ monster ] ) gives the long time behavior of @xmath30 correctly in all but in one direction .
the directional derivative of @xmath31 in the most expanding direction should be obtained with ( [ monster ] ) but replacing @xmath32 by @xmath33 , and the vectors @xmath34 by the ones associated to the expanding direction .
the convergence of the gradients for @xmath35 depends on the sign of the exponent @xmath36 .
there are two possibilities : * if @xmath37 then the convergence of the chemical dynamics towards local equilibrium is stronger than the effect of the chaotic flow on the fluid particles .
gradients are finite so that a smooth asymptotic distribution is attained by the chemical fields . *
if @xmath38 then in the @xmath35 limit the chemical pattern becomes _ nowhere differentiable_. an irregular structure with fractal properties is developed .
remember however that at each point there is a direction for which @xmath36 should be substituted by @xmath39 , always negative , in ( [ monster ] ) . in this
direction derivatives are finite and the field is smooth .
+ thus the resulting structure is _ filamental _ ,
i.e. , irregular in all directions except in one along which it is smooth .
this one corresponds to the direction of the filaments lying along the unstable foliation of the chaotic advection .
the fractal characteristics of the filamental structure in the closed flow case were investigated by @xcite .
we will see however that there are differences between the closed and the open case , which will be discussed in sects .
[ sec : closed ] and [ sec : open ] .
in the numerical investigations below we will consider a simple model of plankton dynamics immersed in a meandering jet flow .
this plankton model , used by @xcite and related to the one used by @xcite , considers explicitly three trophic levels : the nutrient content of a water parcel , described in terms of its carrying capacity @xmath40 ( defined as the maximum phytoplankton content it can support in the absence of grazing ) , the phytoplankton biomass @xmath41 , and the zooplankton @xmath42 .
the lagrangian ` chemical ' subsystem ( [ chemical ] ) reads : @xmath43 all terms have been adimensionalized to keep a minimal number of parameters .
equation ( [ ct ] ) describes the relaxation of the carrying capacity , at a rate @xmath44 , towards an inhomogeneous shape @xmath45
. this will be the only explicitly inhomogeneous term in the model , and describes a spatially dependent nutrient input , arising from some topography - determined upwelling distribution or latitude dependent illumination , for example .
the first terms in eq .
( [ pt ] ) describe phytoplankton logistic growth , whereas the last one models predation by zooplankton .
this effect gives also rise to the first term in ( [ zt ] ) .
the term containing @xmath46 , the zooplankton mortality , describes zooplankton death produced by higher trophic levels .
the only stable fixed point of model ( [ ct])-([zt ] ) is given by @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and @xmath49 .
the model flow will be given by the following streamfunction @xcite : @xmath50}{\left ( 1+k^2 b(t)^2 \sin^2 \left[k(x - ct)\right ] \right)^{\frac{1}{2 } } } \right ) \label{jetstreamfunction}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it describes a jet flowing eastwards , with meanders in the north - south direction which are themselves advected by the jet at a phase velocity @xmath51 . @xmath52 and @xmath53 are the ( properly adimensionalized ) amplitude and wavenumber of the undulation in the streamfunction . the motion of the tracer particles ( the dynamical system ( [ flow ] ) ) is given by @xmath54 if the amplitude @xmath55 of the meanders is time - independent , a simple change in the frame of reference renders the flow time - independent and eq .
( [ streamfunction ] ) defines a non - chaotic integrable dynamical system .
chaotic advection appears in this model if @xmath55 is made to vary in time , for example periodically : @xmath56 following @xcite , we use the parameter values @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
these values guarantee the existence of ` large scale chaos ' , i.e , the possibility that a test particle crosses the jet passing from north to south or viceversa .
this is weaker than the requirement of hyperbolicity , but is enough to illustrate the general aspects of our theory .
the natural interpretation of the jet - flow just introduced is as an open flow : it advects most of the fluid particles from @xmath59 towards @xmath60 .
we will localize the source term near the origin of coordinates : @xmath61 in this way , there is inhomogeneous nutrient input just near the origin , and capacity and plankton concentration in the fluid particles will decay as they are advected downstream . a quite different class of natural flows
are closed ones , e.g. recirculating flows in closed basins .
our jet model flow can be made closed simply by imposing periodic boundary conditions at the ends of the interval @xmath62 .
particles leaving the region through the right boundary are reinjected from the left . in this way nutrients
are injected and extracted continuously from fluid elements as they traverse the different regions of the source @xmath63 this was the situation considered by @xcite .
we will see that different structures develop in the open and in the closed situation .
numerically we proceed by integrating backwards in time eq .
( [ flow ] ) with initial coordinates on a rectangular grid ( @xmath64 ) and then the chemical field for each point is obtained by integrating ( [ chemical ] ) forward in time along the fluid trajectories so generated .
figure [ figure1 ] shows a snapshot of the long - time phytoplankton distribution in the closed flow case for parameter values @xmath65 and @xmath66 . in this case
@xmath67 , therefore the distribution is smooth . a transect along the line @xmath68 is also shown .
taking @xmath69 , so that now @xmath70 we obtain the distribution in fig .
[ figure2 ] .
a complex filamental structure is clearly seen , in agreement with our theoretical arguments .
the fractal nature of the pattern is also seen in the horizontal cut presented also in fig .
[ figure2 ] .
a hlder exponent of @xmath71 was predicted for these kind of transects in @xcite .
this implies plankton - variance power spectrum decaying as @xmath72 , with @xmath731,3]$ ] which agrees with field observations of plankton distributions @xcite .
contrarily to closed flows , open flows are characterized by unbounded trajectories of fluid particles .
typical fluid particles enter and , after some time , leave the region of the nutrient source ( @xmath74 ) .
thus , most fluid elements have only spent the most recent part of their trajectories inside the active region , with the rest of their evolution spent in regions with no spatial dependence of the nutrient input . for this part of the trajectory the gradient @xmath75 in eq .
( [ monster ] ) vanishes , implying that there would not be divergence of the gradients in the long - time limit .
it is well known from the study of chaotic advection in open flows @xcite , that while most of the particles spend only a finite amount of time in selected bounded regions of the flow , typically these regions contain also bounded orbits in which some of the particles can stay forever .
although the chaotic set formed by the bounded orbits is a fractal set of measure zero , particles visiting the vicinity of the stable manifold of this set can still spend arbitrarily long time in the selected bounded region .
this leads to the formation of characteristic fractal patterns in the advection dynamics even in the case of passive particles , as it was shown in numerical studies @xcite and laboratory experiments of open flows @xcite . for the particles that have spent infinitely long time in the source region , their chemical / biological evolution is equivalent to the one in a closed flow with the possibility of diverging gradients .
the only difference is that now the values of @xmath32 and @xmath20 are those corresponding to the chaotic set of bounded orbits that never leave the biologically active region .
the smooth - filamental transition observed in the previous section for the closed flow will occur here only on this fractal set , which will always be surrounded by a smooth distribution .
this results in a strongly intermittent character of the filamental field .
figure [ figure3 ] shows a phytoplankton pattern for parameter values @xmath76 and @xmath66 , and a transect crossing it , in the open - flow case .
the inhomogeneity in the filamental structure is obvious , with singularities in a set recognized as the unstable manifold of the chaotic set formed by bounded orbits in the source region .
smooth structures are also obtained when @xmath67 .
the proper description of the resulting structures should use the concept of multifractality , that is , inhomogeneous distribution of fractal properties .
in fact , even in the closed flow case , at finite times the flow lyapunov exponent @xmath32 would have space - dependent finite - time corrections , that will need to be taken into account in a proper generalization of ( [ monster ] ) .
a quantitative description of these multifractal filamental structures will be presented elsewhere @xcite .
the spatial patterns formed by interacting populations under the influence of chaotic flows have been studied . in particular , we have considered a coupled model of ` nutrient ' , phytoplankton and zooplankton concentrations advected by two ( open and closed ) jet - like flows .
general results have been reported for arbitrary chaotic flows , stressing the existence of a smooth - filamental transition depending on the relative strength of the maximum lyapunov exponent of the flow and the one corresponding to the planktonic dynamical system .
patterns obtained for open and closed chaotic flows are different because of the transient or permanent character of the biological activity .
comparison of the structures for the different fields ( capacity , phytoplankton and zooplankton ) , and quantitative description of their multifractal properties will be presented elsewhere @xcite .
the models considered here are extreme simplifications of real biological and geophysical situations .
we expect however that the main qualitative features found here , namely the possibility of finding smooth or filamental patterns depending on stirring and relaxation rates , and the increased inhomogeneities in open flows , to be present in more realistic chemical or biological transport situations .
helpful discussions with tams tl are acknowledged .
this work was supported by cicyt project mar98 - 0840 .
z.n . was supported by an european science foundation / tao ( _ transport processes in the atmosphere and the oceans _ ) exchange grant .
bacmeister , s.d .
eckermann , l. sparling , k. roland , m. loewenstein and m.h .
profitt , _ analysis of intermittency in aircraft measurements of velocity , temperature and atmospheric tracers using wavelet transforms _ , in : gravity wave processes : their parameterization in global climate models , ed . k.
hamilton ; heidelberg , springer - verlag , 85 , ( 1997 ) .
mahlman , d.g .
andrews , d.l .
hartmann , t. matsuno and r.g .
murgatroyd , _ transport of trace constituents in the stratosphere_. in dynamics of the middle atmosphere , ed .
j. holton and t. matsuno ; tokyo , terrapub , dordrecht , reidel , 387 ( 1984 ) . ; j.d .
mahlman , h. levy ii and w.j .
moxim , _ three - dimensional simulations of stratospheric @xmath77 : predictions for other trace constituents _ , j. geophys .
res . , * 91 * , 2687 ( 1986 ) .
e. ott and t.m .
antonsen , _ fractal measures of passively convected vector fields and scalar gradients in chaotic fluid flows _ , phys . rev . * a 39 * , 3660 ( 1989 ) ; _ chaotic fluid convection and the fractal nature of passive scalar gradients _ , phys
lett . * 61 * , 2839 ( 1988 ) . | we study the spatial patterns formed by interacting populations or reacting chemicals under the influence of chaotic flows .
in particular , we have considered a three - component model of plankton dynamics advected by a meandering jet .
we report general results , stressing the existence of a smooth - filamental transition in the concentration patterns depending on the relative strength of the stirring by the chaotic flow and the relaxation properties of planktonic dynamical system .
patterns obtained in open and closed flows are compared . |
studying the finite temperature phase transition of lattice qcd and the equation of state near this transition requires an understanding of the zero quark mass limit , where molecular dynamics methods fail completely @xcite . even at realistic values of the @xmath4 and @xmath5 quark masses
, the dirac operator is nearly singular , and iterative methods for its inversion become extremely costly in computer time .
for this reason , we modify the lattice qcd action by the addition of an irrelevant , chirally invariant 4-fermion interaction which renders the dirac operator non - singular , even when the quark mass is zero . because the extra interaction is irrelevant
, such an action should lie in the same universality class as the standard action , and thus have the same continuum limit .
the 4-fermion interaction we choose is of the gross - neveu , nambu - jona - lasinio form @xcite .
ideally , such an interaction should be chosen to have the @xmath6 flavour symmetry of the original qcd action
. however , we note that when one introduces auxiliary scalar and pseudoscalar fields to render this action quadratic in the fermion fields which is necessary for lattice simulations , the fermion determinant is no longer real , even in the continuum limit .
thus for 2 flavour qcd ( @xmath7 ) , we make a simpler choice and choose a 4-fermion term with the symmetry @xmath8 , where @xmath0 is generated by @xmath9 .
the euclidean lagrangian density for this theory is then @xmath10 .
\label{eqn : lagrangian}\ ] ] lattice field theories incorporating fermions interacting both through gauge fields and through quartic self - interactions have been studied before see for example @xcite .
brower et al .
@xcite have suggested the addition of such chiral 4-fermion interactions to lattice qcd to control the singular nature of the zero mass dirac operator .
in addition , 4-fermion terms arise in systematic attempts to improve the fermion lattice action to make it better approximate the continuum action @xcite .
our work was suggested by earlier work by one of us on lattice field theories with quartic 4-fermion actions @xcite and by studies of the role such terms play in lattice qed .
we have simulated this theory using 2 flavours of staggered quarks on @xmath11 and @xmath12 lattices , at an intermediate value of @xmath13 and zero quark mass , in order to determine the position and nature of the finite temperature transition .
we also present some zero temperature results on an @xmath14 lattice , where we demonstrate that the theory with massless quarks does indeed have a massless goldstone pion .
in addition to measuring the standard order parameters we have measured the pion , @xmath2(@xmath3 ) , and @xmath15 screening masses to probe the nature of chiral symmetry restoration at this transition .
we also simulated the corresponding theory with 4-fermion couplings but no gauge interactions on relatively small lattices ( @xmath16 and @xmath17 ) to aid us in deciding what values of 4-fermion coupling constant to choose . in section 2
we discuss the lattice formulation of qcd with chiral 4-fermion interactions .
we present our zero gauge - coupling results in section 3 .
the zero temperature results are given in section 4 , while the finite temperature simulations and results are described in section 5 .
section 6 gives discussions and conclusions , and outlines directions for future research .
equation [ eqn : lagrangian ] can be rendered quadratic in the fermion fields by the standard trick of introducing ( non - dynamical ) auxiliary fields @xmath2 and @xmath18 in terms of which this lagrangian density becomes @xmath19 the molecular dynamics lagrangian for a particular staggered fermion lattice transcription of this theory in which @xmath20 is identified with @xmath21 , the flavour equivalent of @xmath22 is @xmath23 + { n_f \over 8}\sum_s \dot{\psi}^{\dag } a^{\dag } a\dot{\psi } -\sum_{\tilde{s}}\frac{1}{8}n_f\gamma(\sigma^2+\pi^2 ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{2}\sum_l(\dot{\theta}_7 ^ 2+\dot{\theta}_8 ^ 2 + \dot{\theta}_1^{\ast}\dot{\theta}_1 + \dot{\theta}_2^{\ast}\dot{\theta}_2 + \dot{\theta}_3^{\ast}\dot{\theta}_3 ) + \frac{1}{2}\sum_{\tilde{s}}(\dot{\sigma}^2+\dot{\pi}^2)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath24 with @xmath25 running over the 16 sites on the dual lattice neighbouring the site on the normal lattice , @xmath26 and @xmath27 the usual gauge - covariant `` d - slash '' for the staggered quarks .
the factor @xmath28 in front of the pseudo - fermion kinetic term is appropriate for the hybrid molecular dynamics algorithm with `` noisy '' fermions , where @xmath29 are chosen from a complex gaussian distribution with width 1 .
the `` dots '' represent derivatives with respect to molecular dynamics `` time '' as distinct from normal time . for the presentation of all our simulation results
we use a time definition which is twice this , in order to be consistent with the convention used in the works of the hemcgc and htmcgc collaborations .
we note that @xmath30 .
although the determinant of @xmath31 does not appear to be real , it becomes so in the continuum limit . without the gauge fields , this theory reverts to the one studied in @xcite , with @xmath32 flavours .
the advantage of this choice of the chiral 4-fermion interaction is that it preserves the axial @xmath33 chiral symmetry of the normal staggered quark lattice qcd action generated by @xmath34 at @xmath35 .
this means that , when chiral symmetry is spontaneously broken , the pion associated with @xmath36 will be a true goldstone boson and will be massless at @xmath35 , even for finite lattice spacing . under this exact chiral symmetry
the fields transform as @xmath37 \label{eqn : chiral}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which we find that @xmath38,\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath35 . hence , for massless
quarks the above lagrangian has an exact @xmath33 flavour axial symmetry .
in order to ascertain which ranges of values of @xmath39 represent strong coupling and which represent weak coupling , we simulated the above lattice theory without the gluon fields where it becomes the lattice version of the nambu - jona - lasinio - gross - neveu model with @xmath40 flavours @xcite .
we have simulated this theory with @xmath35 on @xmath16 and @xmath11 lattices .
for these simulations , we ran for 5000 molecular - dynamics time units at each @xmath39 value with step size @xmath41 .
this theory is known to have a phase transition , even at zero temperature , as a function of @xmath39 @xcite . for strong coupling ( small @xmath39 )
chiral symmetry is spontaneously broken , while at weak coupling ( large @xmath39 ) chiral symmetry remains unbroken .
since the theory is strictly massless , the direction this axial symmetry is broken is arbitrary , and the chiral condensate is a linear combination of @xmath42 and @xmath43 ( or @xmath2 and @xmath18 ) . because we work on finite lattices , the direction of this symmetry breaking does not remain constant , but rotates over the course of the run .
for this reason , the order parameter we will denote by @xmath42 is actually the molecular - dynamics time average of @xmath44 , which differs from the true chiral condensate by terms @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the space - time volume of the lattice .
this quantity is given in figure [ fig : njlgn ] as a function of @xmath39 for both lattice sizes . from the @xmath16 lattice
we conclude that the zero temperature phase transition from the strong coupling phase to the weak coupling phase occurs somewhere in the range @xmath47 , while the finite temperature transition on the @xmath48 lattice occurs at a somewhat smaller value of @xmath39 .
thus we would conclude that since , for lattice qcd with chiral 4-fermion interactions , we wish to work in the weak 4-fermion coupling regime , we should restrict ourselves to values of @xmath39 which are greater than 2 .
moreover , since the introduction of this 4-fermion term produces chiral phase transitions where none previously existed , we could expect that chiral symmetry might be restored at a temperature higher than the deconfinement temperature . since this is not the case for normal lattice
qcd , we should try to work at a large enough @xmath39 value that the 2 transitions are close , if not coincident .
we describe studies to determine the appropriate range of @xmath39 values in section 5 .
we have undertaken a preliminary investigation of the hadron spectrum of qcd with chiral 4-fermion interactions of the type discussed in section 2 on an @xmath14 lattice with 2 flavours of massless quarks at @xmath49 and @xmath50 .
@xmath51 was chosen since it lies just below the phase transition for lattice qcd without the 4-fermion term on an @xmath52 lattice .
thus we were assured of being in the confined phase .
we used the hybrid molecular dynamics method with time increment @xmath41 for updating .
we ran for a total of 5000 time units , discarding the first 1000 time units for equilibration .
250 configurations spaced by 20 time units were saved for further analysis .
the first 50 of these were discarded for equilibration .
the pion and @xmath2 propagators were calculated from the correlations of the @xmath18 and @xmath2 fields , sampled every 2 time units . because , as was the case in the previous section , the direction of chiral symmetry breaking rotates during a run on a finite lattice , we chirally rotated each @xmath53 configuration ( see equation [ eqn : chiral ] ) so that @xmath54 .
the propagators are then given by @xmath55 where @xmath46 is the space - time and @xmath56 is the spatial volume of the lattice .
correlated fits are made to these propagators , binning over 10 measurements ( 20 time units ) to account for correlations , and using jackknife to remove the vacuum expectation values in the @xmath2 propagator .
the @xmath18 propagator was fitted to the form @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the lattice propagator for a massless scalar boson @xmath59 with the @xmath60 mode excluded .
we found @xmath61 and @xmath62 for the fit from @xmath63 to @xmath64 .
this fit has a 78% confidence level .
figure [ fig : pi ] shows the measured propagator with this fit superimposed . as indicated by the high confidence level , our measured pion propagator is very well fit by a massless scalar propagator , except at @xmath65 where we see the remnant of the original @xmath66-function interaction .
thus the sum of fermion `` bubble '' diagrams has converted the auxilliary @xmath18 field to a true goldstone pion .
for large @xmath67 the sigma propagator should behave as @xmath68 + b [ e^{-m_{\pi_2 } t } + e^{-m_{\pi_2 } ( n_t - t)}]\ ] ] we have attempted such fits , but are unable to find a stable value for the @xmath69 mass . for this reason we resorted to the single particle fit obtained by setting @xmath70 to zero . here , our best fit yielded @xmath71 with a 51% confidence level .
this mass was consistent with those obtained from the 2 particle fits .
we have plotted our @xmath2 propagator and this fit in figure [ fig : sigma ] .
here it is clear why our fits were so poor the propagator disolves into noise after only a few time - slices , which is the usual problem encountered when trying to calculate high mass propagators as in equation [ eqn : sigma ] .
( here the error in the propagator is expected to be independent of t , whereas for meson propagators calculated directly from the quark propagator , the error falls with increasing t ) .
it is interesting to speculate as to whether the `` tail '' of this propagator is due to the 2-pion cut in the @xmath2 propagator .
we have performed simulations on @xmath1 lattices and with 2 flavours of zero mass quarks , in order to study the transition from hadronic matter to a quark gluon plasma at finite temperature .
our initial runs were performed on @xmath11 lattices with @xmath72 , @xmath73 , and @xmath74 the time step @xmath41 for these runs .
we experimented with values of @xmath75 from @xmath76 to @xmath77 , and found @xmath41 to be small enough that finite @xmath75 errors were smaller than statistical errors .
we measured the wilson / polyakov line and the chiral condensate , @xmath42 , enabling us to determine the phase structure of the theory .
since , as we have seen in section 3 , the presence of the 4-fermion coupling can break chiral symmetry , even at zero gauge coupling where there is no confinement , we expect that the chiral symmetry restoration and deconfinement will in general occur at different values of @xmath78 .
in fact for values of @xmath39 less than that for the transition at zero gauge coupling , chiral symmetry will always be broken . in figure
[ fig : wil - psi ] we show the values of the 2 order parameters for each of @xmath72 , @xmath73 , and @xmath74 .
it is clear at @xmath72 that the deconfinement transition , marked by the rapid increase in the wilson / polyakov line ( around @xmath79 ) , occurs at a much lower value of @xmath78 than the chiral symmetry restoration , marked by a drop in @xmath42 ( which does not reach zero for the reasons given in section 3 ) between @xmath80 and @xmath74 . at @xmath81
the 2 transitions still appear to be distinct , although we can not rule out this being a finite volume effect , while at @xmath50 the 2 transitions appear to be coincident .
since we are interested in obtaining results which are relevant to the continuum limit where the 4-fermion coupling vanishes and the 2 transitions _ are _ believed to be coincident , we chose to work at @xmath50 .
\(a ) ( b ) \(c ) ( d ) at @xmath50 , we observed signs of a two state signal in the time evolution of both order parameters at @xmath82 , indicating the possibility of a first order transition . figure [ fig:533_8 ] shows the time evolution of the wilson / polyakov line at this @xmath78 value .
thus we conclude that the transition occurs at @xmath83 on this size lattice . since the standard action shows a false first order transition on small lattices , we repeated our runs on a @xmath12 lattice .
having @xmath84 enabled us to measure hadronic screening lengths in the @xmath85 direction . on this larger lattice , we find evidence for 2-state signals at @xmath86 and @xmath82 . in figure
[ fig : wilson ] we show the time evolution of the wilson / polyakov line for these 2 @xmath78 values . at @xmath86
the wilson line measured from a cold start remains small for the total length of the run while that from a hot start , remains large for over 3000 time units before it tunnels rapidly to a low value and stays there . at @xmath82
the wilson line from a hot start remains high for the entire run , while that from a cold start remains low for over 1500 time units before it tunnels rapidly to a high value and stays there .
there is no sign of metastability for higher or lower @xmath78 values .
we thus conclude that the transition occurs in the range @xmath87 , and probably closer to @xmath86 .
the values of these quantities , @xmath88 and the average plaquette , @xmath89 are given in tables [ tab : wilpsiapq8],[tab : wilpsiapq12 ] .
we note that the required relationship @xmath90 is approximately true in the chirally broken phase , but that in the chirally symmetric phase it is somewhat less well obeyed .
since the continuum values of both these quantities are zero in this symmetric phase , this suggests that the difference is in the @xmath91 departures of our estimators for these quantities from their true values , which do not have to obey this relationship .
\(a ) ( b ) lldddd @xmath78 & time & wilson line & @xmath42 & @xmath88 & plaquette + 5.0 & 2000 & 0.025(2 ) & 1.217(3 ) & 0.1235(5 ) & 0.5825(3 ) + 5.1 & 2000 & 0.031(2 ) & 1.147(2 ) & 0.1170(5 ) & 0.5636(3 ) + 5.2 & 1000 & 0.031(4 ) & 1.065(4 ) & 0.1080(7 ) & 0.5430(8 ) + 5.3 & 1000 & 0.073(7 ) & 0.910(5 ) & 0.0923(8 ) & 0.5149(7 ) + 5.32 & 6000 & 0.113(6 ) & 0.838(6 ) & 0.0857(8 ) & 0.5064(6 ) + 5.33 & 10000 & 0.325(38 ) & 0.526(55 ) & 0.0575(48 ) & 0.4900(24 ) + 5.34 & 4000 & 0.519(11 ) & 0.236(19 ) & 0.0290(17 ) & 0.4746(5 ) + 5.35 & 2000 & 0.544(5 ) & 0.197(7 ) & 0.0260(8 ) & 0.4717(4 ) + 5.36 & 2000 & 0.546(6 ) & 0.191(8 ) & 0.0254(9 ) & 0.4699(4 ) + 5.4 & 1000 & 0.595(7 ) & 0.131(5 ) & 0.0203(8 ) & 0.4619(4 ) + 5.5 & 1000 & 0.679(5 ) & 0.093(3 ) & 0.0173(6 ) & 0.4469(3 ) lrdddd @xmath78 & time & wilson line & @xmath42 & @xmath88 & plaquette + 5.2 & 2140 & 0.040(1 ) & 1.045(2 ) & 0.1056(3 ) & 0.5427(2 ) + 5.3 & 2040 & 0.089(20 & 0.873(2 ) & 0.0887(3 ) & 0.5136(3 ) + 5.31 & 2080 & 0.103(4 ) & 0.838(4 ) & 0.0849(5 ) & 0.5096(3 ) + 5.32 & 4020 & 0.130(5 ) & 0.801(6 ) & 0.0809(5 ) & 0.5055(4 ) + 5.325c & 4100 & 0.138(6 ) & 0.782(6 ) & 0.0794(6 ) & 0.5034(4 ) + 5.325h & 5080 & 0.483(5 ) & 0.172(11 ) & 0.0184(12 ) & 0.4790(3 ) + 5.33c & 3200 & 0.181(9 ) & 0.730(10 ) & 0.0742(9 ) & 0.4994(6 ) + 5.33h & 4100 & 0.496(3 ) & 0.147(9 ) & 0.0163(9 ) & 0.4775(2 ) + 5.34 & 2080 & 0.525(4 ) & 0.098(6 ) & 0.0116(6 ) & 0.4743(2 ) + 5.35 & 2080 & 0.544(3 ) & 0.076(2 ) & 0.0096(3 ) & 0.4716(1 ) + 5.4 & 2020 & 0.601(2 ) & 0.052(2 ) & 0.0079(3 ) & 0.4621(1 ) we now turn to a consideration of the hadronic screening lengths which measure the propagation of exitations with hadronic quantum numbers in hadronic matter and the quark - gluon plasma . in particular
these measure the manner in which chiral symmetry is restored as we pass through the transition from hadronic matter to a quark - gluon plasma . here
we concentrate on the @xmath18 and @xmath92 propagators which can be calculated from the @xmath18 and @xmath2 auxiliary fields , as in section 2 , i.e. from @xmath93 in the hadronic phase we fit the pion propagator to @xmath94 where @xmath95 is the lattice propagator for a massless scalar boson @xmath96 with the @xmath60 mode excluded .
the @xmath2 propagator was fitted to @xmath97 + b [ e^{-m_{\pi_2 } z } + e^{-m_{\pi_2 } ( n_z - z)}]\ ] ] and to the special case where @xmath98 , which was often adequate in this range of @xmath78 values . above the transition , in the quark - gluon plasma phase , since @xmath99 , one can not distinguish @xmath2 and @xmath18 and it makes most sense to consider @xmath100 which we fit to @xmath101\ ] ] since choosing to fit our pion to a massless scalar boson propagator below the transition , and to a massive propagator above might seem to be forcing the result we want , we have looked at fits to the pion propagator obtained as in section 2 by chirally rotating our propagators so that @xmath102 , and then fitting to [ eqn : pi ] .
the results obtained from our best fits are given in table [ tab : pifits ] .
as in the zero temperature case we bin our data in bins of 10 , i.e. 20 time units .
note that , for all our mass fits we have selected our runs from a cold start for @xmath86 and from a hot start for @xmath82 , which folds in our knowledge that the transition occurs in the range @xmath103 lcddd @xmath78 & range & a & b & confidence + 5.2 & 1 11 & 0.0051(2 ) & 0.0069(2 ) & 0.832 + 5.3 & 2 12 & 0.0044(3 ) & 0.0079(4 ) & 0.639 + 5.31 & 1 12 & 0.0045(2 ) & 0.0072(2 ) & 0.739 + 5.32 & 1 11 & 0.0042(1 ) & 0.0075(1 ) & 0.248 + 5.325 & 1 11 & 0.0047(2 ) & 0.0069(1 ) & 0.858 + 5.33 & 2 5 & 0.0028(1 ) & 0.0133(18 ) & 0.739 + 5.34 & 2 12 & 0.0020(1 ) & 0.0101(4 ) & 0.475 + 5.35 & 4 10 & 0.0010(1 ) & 0.0164(12 ) & 0.642 + 5.4 & 3 8 & 0.0006(1 ) & 0.0155(8 ) & 0.567 + 5.5 & 3 12 & 0.00009(6 ) & -0.0035(12 ) &
0.528 we note that the coefficient @xmath31 which measures the amount of massless scalar propagator in this fit drops abruptly as we increase @xmath78 through the phase transition , and continues to drop as @xmath78 is increased .
in addition , the parameters of the fits become more sensitive to the fitting range as @xmath78 is increased beyond this transition .
thus we feel justified in taking the pion screening mass to be zero below the transition , as required by goldstone s theorem , while fitting it to a massive propagator above the transition . above the transition ,
our definition of @xmath42 should not vanish , but rather should scale as @xmath104 , and so vanish in the in the infinite ( spatial ) volume limit . in table
[ tab : pbp ] we compare @xmath42 measured on the @xmath12 with @xmath105 , measured on the @xmath17 lattice , and the corresponding values of @xmath88 for values of @xmath78 above the transition , ldddd @xmath78 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 + 5.33 & 0.147(9 ) & 0.202(21 ) & 0.0163(9 ) & 0.0221(18 ) + 5.34 & 0.098(6 ) & 0.091(7 ) & 0.0116(6 ) & 0.0111(7 ) + 5.35 & 0.076(2 ) & 0.076(3 ) & 0.0096(3 ) & 0.0100(3 ) + 5.4 & 0.052(2 ) & 0.050(2 ) & 0.0079(3 ) & 0.0078(3 ) except for @xmath82 which really should not have been included , since the @xmath17 data really represents a mixture of high and low temperature phases , scaling is true within our statistical errors .
this helps justify our conclusion that chiral symmetry is indeed restored in the high temperature phase , and our choice of screening propagator fits based on this assumption .
the fact that this scaling is true for both quantities is an indication that the departures from the relationship between them is an artifact of the @xmath110 difference between these quantities and the vacuum condensates they represent , as suggested above .
our @xmath2 and @xmath18 screening mass fits are shown in figure [ fig : sigma - pi ] .
below the transition the @xmath2 mass falls steeply as the transition is approached .
what is unclear is whether it actually falls to zero at the transition .
the pion is massless in this regime . above the transition
the @xmath2/@xmath18 mass rises rapidly from a small and possibly zero value at the transition , and is expected to approach @xmath111 as @xmath112 .
thus the restoration of the @xmath113 chiral symmetry is manifest in the spectrum of screening masses / screening lengths .
in addition to the @xmath18 and @xmath2 , figure [ fig : sigma - pi ] shows the screening masses in the flavor triplet scalar channel , @xmath66(@xmath15 ) .
these are obtained from measurements of the `` connected '' part of the @xmath2 propagator ( i.e. one quark `` bubble '' instead of the complete `` chain of bubbles '' ) .
in contrast with the @xmath2 and @xmath18 , the @xmath66 always remains heavy .
we therefore have a situation where the @xmath114 axial symmetry only becomes effectively restored at temperatures well above the chiral phase transition , in agreement with @xcite .
the splitting between @xmath66 and @xmath2 or @xmath18 is very clear in this study because we work at zero quark mass and @xmath39 . ]
the screening mass of the @xmath66 also exhibits a jump ( or rapid crossover ) which is consistent with our determination of a first order transition .
finally we have measured observables associated with the entropy density , energy density and pressure .
we present these as is , since tree level extractions of entropy density , energy density and pressure are unphysical ( they require @xmath115 , the ideal gas relation , which can not hold through a first order transition where pressure is continuous and energy density is discontinuous ) , and the one loop calculations have yet to be calculated . in addition , for the energy density and pressure , we need zero temperature measurements of observables at the same @xmath78 values .
the 3 observables given in table [ tab : entropies ] are related to the contributions of the gauge fields , the quark fields and the chiral 4-fermion interactions respectively , to the entropy density .
dddd @xmath78 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 + 5.2 & 0.0001(13 ) & -0.0298(5 ) & 1.0362(4 ) + 5.3 & 0.0067(10 ) & -0.0145(6 ) & 1.0282(4 ) + 5.31 & 0.0081(11 ) & -0.0125(8 ) & 1.0264(4 ) + 5.32 & 0.0105(8 ) & -0.0070(10 ) & 1.0259(3 ) + 5.325 & 0.0116(8 ) & -0.0049(11 ) & 1.0250(3 ) + 5.33 & 0.0563(7 ) & 0.0632(6 ) & 1.0118(2 ) + 5.34 & 0.0587(6 ) & 0.0672(6 ) & 1.0109(4 ) + 5.35 & 0.0599(7 ) & 0.0692(5 ) & 1.0104(4 ) + 5.4 & 0.0605(9 ) & 0.0716(4 ) & 1.0094(3 ) + 5.5 & 0.0588(9 ) & 0.0738(3 ) & 1.0087(3 ) what is most noticable is that each of these quantities shows a sizable jump at the transition indicating that there will indeed be a significant increase in entropy across this transition .
this helps substantiate our conclusion that the transition is first order . on the other hand ,
the variation of each of these quantities on either side of this transition is modest .
the action for lattice qcd with 2 flavours of staggered quarks is modified by the addition of a chiral 4-fermion interaction .
the chosen 4-fermion interaction has a @xmath113 symmetry , where @xmath119 is the normal @xmath6 chiral flavour symmetry of qcd with massless quarks .
this irrelevant interaction alows us to simulate at zero quark mass by rendering the dirac operator non - singular .
we have performed simulations at @xmath120 , a relatively weak value for the 4-fermion coupling , and zero quark mass at both zero and finite temperatures .
the zero temperature calculation was performed on an @xmath14 lattice at @xmath49 , and was meant as a precurser to performing serious hadron spectroscopy with this action .
our major result was clear evidence of a massless goldstone pion , the other hadrons having relatively large masses ( in lattice units ) for gauge couplings and hence lattice spacings this large .
the effectiveness of the 4-fermion term in rendering the dirac operator non - singular is reflected in that the average number of conjugate gradient iterations required to invert the dirac operator was @xmath121 . the finite temperature simulations were performed on @xmath12 and @xmath17 lattices .
the finite temperature transition occured at @xmath122 , which is to be compared with @xmath123 , estimated for the massless quark extrapolation with the standard action @xcite .
we have seen clear evidence that the transition is a strong first order transition . since we believe that the actual continuum transition should be second order ( or possibly weakly first order ) @xcite which is what simulations with the standard action suggest @xcite , we believe this to be due to the size of the 4-fermion interaction , enhanced by the strength of the gauge coupling . again
the condition of the dirac operator was well under control , it requiring @xmath124 conjugate gradient iterations , on average , to invert this operator throughout the range of @xmath78 s considered .
we are now running at @xmath1 with @xmath125 , and @xmath126 with @xmath50 and @xmath125 .
preliminary results at @xmath126 suggest a second order transition at @xmath50 , which is even clearer at @xmath125 .
it is still too early to draw any conclusions from the ongoing runs at @xmath1 , @xmath125 .
the @xmath18 and @xmath2 screening masses showed the appropriate behaviour .
the goldstone pion mass remained zero below the transition , and increased from zero after the transition .
the @xmath2 mass dipped as the transition was approached from below ( it is not clear whether it actually approached zero on the cold side of the transition ) , and rose , apparently from zero , above the transition where it was degenerate with the pion mass .
the other screening masses remained large across the transition .
in particular the connected part of the @xmath2 propagator , the @xmath127 ramained large over this region . however , flavour symmetry violation is large enough at these @xmath78 and @xmath39 values that it is not clear whether this is further evidence that the flavour singlet @xmath128 symmetry remains broken across the transition from hadronic matter to a quark - gluon plasma @xcite .
if our thermodynamics simulations at larger @xmath129 and/or @xmath39 do indicate a second order transition , we should be able to determine the universality class of this transition and the critical indices , enabling us to determine the equation of state of hadronic matter .
with still larger @xmath129 we should be able to measure asymptotic scaling and determine the position , as well as nature of the phase transition . at zero temperature
we should be able to obtain the hadronic spectrum , first at zero mass and then at the physical quark masses _ without _ having to perform an extrapolation in quark mass .
we are investigating how one might overcome the difficulties with simulating with a 4-fermion term having the more physical @xmath119 chiral symmetry , and perhaps @xmath130 chiral symmetry .
in addition we will investigate combining this improvement to the standard lattice qcd action with the improvements of lepage _ et al . _
@xcite , or of the `` perfect action '' methods @xcite .
preliminary results of these simulations were reported at lattice97 @xcite .
these computations were performed on the cray c-90 at nersc .
this work was supported by the u. s. department of energy under contract w-31 - 109-eng-38 , and the national science foundation under grant nsf - phy92 - 00148 .
we would like to thank john sloan and misha stephanov for informative conversations .
999999 f. karsch and e. laermann , phys .
d * 50 * , 6954 ( 1994 ) .
t. blum _ et al .
d * 51 * , 5153 ( 1995 ) ; c. bernard _ et al .
d * 55 * , 6861 ( 1997 ) . c. bernard
_ et al . _ ,
d * 54 * , 4585 ( 1996 ) .
s. gottlieb et al . , phys .
d * 55 * , 6852 ( 1997 ) .
a. ukawa , nucl .
phys . b(proc .
suppl . ) * 53 * , 106 ( 1997 ) .
k. kanaya , nucl .
b(proc . suppl . ) * 47 * , 144 ( 1996 ) .
f. karsch , nucl .
b(proc . suppl . )
* 34 * , 63 ( 1994 ) .
d. j. gross and a. neveu , phys .
d * 20 * , 3235 ( 1974 ) .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys . rev . *
122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) .
k. i. kondo , h. mino and k. yamawaki , phys .
d * 39*,2430 ( 1989 ) .
r. c. brower , y. shen and c .- i .
tan , boston university preprint buhep-94 - 3 ( 1994 ) ; r. c. brower , k. orginos and c .- i .
tan , nucl .
b(proc . suppl . )
* 42 * ( 1995 ) .
b. sheikholeslami and r. wohlert , nucl . phys . *
b259 * , 572 ( 1985 ) .
t. blum _ et al .
d * 55 * , r1133 ( 1997 ) .
s. hands , a. kocic and j. b. kogut , ann .
* 224 * ( 1993 ) .
s. kim , a. kocic and j. b. kogut , nucl .
b429 * , 407 ( 1994 ) .
s. hands and j. b. kogut , e - print hep - lat/9705038 ( 1997 ) .
s. hands , s. kim and j. b. kogut , nucl .
b442 * , 364 ( 1995 ) .
r. pisarski and f. wilczek , phys .
d * 29 * , 338 ( 1984 ) .
j. b. kogut , j .- f .
lagae and d. k. sinclair , nucl .
b(proc . suppl . )
* 53 * , 269 ( 1997 ) . c. bernard
_ et al . _ ,
suppl . ) * 53 * , 442 ( 1997 ) .
m. alford _
et al . _ ,
b361 * , 87 ( 1995 ) . | we have studied lattice qcd with an additional , irrelevant 4-fermion interaction having a @xmath0 chiral symmetry , at finite temperatures . adding this 4-fermion term allowed us to work at zero quark mass , which would have otherwise been impossible .
the theory with 2 massless staggered quark flavours appears to have a first order finite temperature phase transition at @xmath1 for the value of 4-fermion coupling we have chosen , in contrast to what is expected for 2-flavour qcd .
the pion screening mass is seen to vanish below this transition , only to become massive and degenerate with the @xmath2 ( @xmath3 ) above this transition where the chiral symmetry is restored , as is seen by the vanishing of the chiral condensate . 0.5 in |
it is useful to begin by recalling the basic assumptions and observations that lead us to the concept of the extragalactic cosmic background radiation , as opposed to radiation surface brightness that may be some highly variable function of position and direction .
deep counts of objects detected at a broad range of wavelengths , from gamma ray sources to radio galaxies , are close to isotropic across the sky .
it is an excellent bet therefore that the integrated radiation from observed sources plus those too faint to be detectable as individual objects also is quite to isotropic .
this allows us to think of the local extragalactic radiation background as a function of one variable , the radiation energy density @xmath0 per interval of frequency @xmath1 .
the fluctuations around the mean as a function of position in the sky are important too , as a measure of large - scale structure , but @xmath0 is the center of attention in these proceedings . the argument for large - scale homogeneity against a universe with a radial density gradient and us at the center is less direct but i think persuasive ; my review of the considerations is in peebles ( 1993 ) . if we are persuaded then we conclude that within our hubble length space is filled with a near uniform sea of radiation with spectral energy density @xmath0 : the cosmic extragalactic background radiation .
if the propagation of the radiation is described by a metric theory then it satisfies the liouville or brightness theorem . if the metric describes a homogeneous isotropic spacetime then the geometry is fixed by the expansion factor @xmath2 , a function of the proper world time @xmath3 alone , together with the radius of curvature @xmath4 of sections of constant time , where the comoving radius @xmath5 is a constant . in this spacetime
the radiation energy density @xmath6 integrated over frequency at time @xmath3 is an integral over the history of production and absorption of radiation , @xmath7 at tine @xmath8 the net rate of production of radiation ( emitted minus absorbed ) per unit proper volume is @xmath9 , and @xmath10 is the rate of production of energy per comoving volume normalized to the time @xmath3 of observation .
the remaining factor in the integrand , @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the redshift at the epoch @xmath8 observed at time @xmath3 , represents energy lost due to the cosmological redshift . if spacetime were static , @xmath13 independent of time , equation ( 1 ) says @xmath14 could not have been constant : there would have to have been a characteristic time at which star formation commenced .
the point , associated with the name olbers , is not often mentioned now ; an edifying discussion is to be found in bondi ( 1960 ) . in the classical steady state cosmology ( which also is well described by bondi )
the universe is expanding , @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is hubble s constant .
this makes the integral converge even when @xmath14 is constant , stars forming at a fixed mean rate per physical volume back to the indefinitely remote past .
but we know now this is not a viable picture : cowie and lilly describe in these proceedings observations of galaxies and an intergalactic medium at high redshift that are distinctly different from what is observed nearby ; the more youthful appearance of objects at high redshift agrees with the interpretation that they are seen closer to the time when the structure we see started forming . in the general relativistic friedmann - lematre model with a classical stress - energy tensor that satisfies @xmath17 the integral in equation ( 1 ) has to have a lower limit , at the singular start of expansion at @xmath18 . in the eternal inflation scenario ( linde 1990 ) this unsatisfactory situation
is relieved by the return to a steady state philosophy : the lower limit to the integral extends back along our world line to the remote past .
let us consider now the interpretation of the radiation background under the standard relativistic cosmology .
evolution after inflation or whatever produced the initial conditions for the present state of our expanding universe was accompanied by exchanges of energy among different forms .
an accounting of the integrated results of the transactions at the present epoch offers a measure of cosmic evolution , and in particular it informs our interpretation of the infrared background .
the estimates in table 1 are expressed in units of the einstein - de sitter value , @xmath19 , at hubble constant @xmath20 km s@xmath21 mpc@xmath21 .
that is , these numbers are contributions to the cosmological density parameter .
the first set of numbers , labeled primeval , are thought to have been fixed by physical processes operating in the early universe , well before stars and galaxies started forming ; the second set are estimates of the effects of the formation and evolution of structure on scales ranging from clusters of galaxies down to star remnants .
the accounting in this table accepts the evidence for a friedmann - lematre model that is close to cosmologically flat , the stress - energy tensor being dominated by a term that acts like einstein s cosmological constant , @xmath22 .
the next most important term appears to be some form of nonbaryonic dark matter .
the baryon density in the third line agrees with the theory of the origin of the light elements in the early universe , with the fluctuation spectrum of the 3 k thermal background radiation within reasonable - looking uncertainties ( eg .
hu et al . 2000 ) and with the observational constraints on the baryon budget ( fukugita , hogan , & peebles 1998 ) .
the baryon entry seems secure to 30% or so , a truly remarkable advance .
it is a measure of the state of our subject that the two largest entries are conjectural .
the evidence for low pressure dark matter at about the density indicated in the table is compelling if we accept general relativity theory ( and hence the inverse square law for gravity ) ; the evidence for @xmath22 or its near operational equivalent is strong if we accept the adiabatic cdm model for structure formation .
work in progress promises to establish more tests of general relativity theory applied on the scale of the hubble length , of the cosmology , and of the theory of structure formation .
the results certainly will be searched for potential insights into the enigmatic leading entries in the table .
lc + + + & @xmath23 + + + + + + @xmath22/quintessence / dark energy & @xmath24 + + low pressure nonbaryonic matter & @xmath25 + baryons & @xmath26 + relict neutrinos & @xmath27 + thermal radiation & @xmath28 + gravitational binding energy & @xmath29 + + + + + + gravitational binding energy : + relativistic & @xmath30 + stars & @xmath31 + galaxies & @xmath32 + nuclear binding energy : + helium & @xmath33 + heavy elements & @xmath34 + x - gamma radiation & @xmath35 + optical / near ir radiation & @xmath36 + far ir / sub mm radiation & @xmath36 + + the entry for relict neutrinos that broke thermal equilibrium with the background radiation at @xmath37 assumes the tau neutrino mass is no smaller than 0.03 ev , from atmospheric neutrinos ( super - kamiokande collaboration 2000 ) , and no larger than about 1 ev , to avoid undue effect on structure formation ( klypin et al .
the accepted provenance of the 3 k thermal radiation and its related neutrinos entropy originating near the end of inflation is conjectural .
the observed peak in the angular fluctuation spectrum of this radiation , at the length scale set by decoupling at @xmath38 , is good evidence this radiation is primeval , present well before the observed stars and galaxies could have started forming .
the meaning of the last of the primeval entries is illustrated by the comparison of two friedmann - lematre models , both containing only cold dark matter particles with the same particle mass , and with the same comoving radius of curvature measured relative to the mean distance between particles . in one model
the mass distribution is close to homogeneous ; in the other model primeval curvature fluctuations have placed most of the dark matter in gravitationally bound nonrelativistic halos . at a given mean particle number density
the mean mass density is smaller in the latter model by the amount of the mean halo gravitational binding energy : the sum of the kinetic energy of proper motion of the particles relative to the general expansion and the gravitational potential energy relative to a homogeneous mass distribution .
thus when the particle number densities are the same the physical radii of curvature are the same in the two models , and the expansion rate , from the relativistic expression @xmath39 , is lower in the model with halos .
this gravitational binding energy in the model with halos is primeval in the sense that it is a consequence of the gravitational growth of structure out of given initial conditions ; there is no energy transaction when the halos collapse to form bound systems .
we have good evidence that this gravitational growth of structure is responsible for the large - scale structure of our universe ; most dramatic is the consistency of the angular fluctuation spectrum of the 3 k background with the simple adiabatic cdm model for the gravitational instability picture ( eg .
hu et al . 2000 and references therein ) .
in this cdm model radiation pressure suppresses the growth of density fluctuations on scales less than the matter - radiation jeans length at decoupling , @xmath40 mpc , lowering the binding energy , and the dissipation of the small - scale pressure waves adds a little entropy .
the number in the table for the primeval gravitational binding energy assumes the rms peculiar velocity is comparable to that of the local group relative to the 3 k background , @xmath41 km s@xmath21 , in matter at the sum of the mass densities in the second and third entries .
many have commented on the small differences of values of successive entries in this first group , which may in part reflect the anthropic consideration that these parameters can be adjusted so we could not have been here to measure them , may in part result from physical relations to be discovered , and may in part be pure coincidence .
similar remarks apply to the second group of entries , of course . the first entry in this second group is based on the contribution to the density parameter by the mass bound in compact nuclei of galaxies ( from the review by fabian 2000 ) .
if these objects are relativistic black holes , mass may flow into them without the emission of energy in radiation or jets .
for our purpose this accretion without emission represents an exchange of small particles for large ones , both gravitationally bound to the massive halos of galaxies , and it has no effect on the accounting in table 1 .
the same applies to the kinetic energy of a jet that is dissipated within the galaxy .
the factor @xmath42 in the table is the mean fraction of energy in radiation and jets that has left the gravitationally bound halos within which these compact objects live .
most of the baryons are thought to be in intragroup and intracluster plasma , distributed in about the same way as the dark matter .
the gravitational binding energy per unit mass consequently is about the same , and , as we have noted , in the adiabatic cdm model this primeval binding energy appeared without transfer of energy to some other form
. the dominant energy exchange in this component of the baryons may be the thermal bremsstrahlung and emission line x - ray radiation from intracluster plasma ; less important transactions include the energy exchanges due to galactic winds and the energy exchanges between baryons and dark matter via fluctuations in the gravitational potential .
the formation of baryon - rich spheroids and disks of galaxies requires about the same dissipative production of binding energy per unit mass as does star formation . here
too one can think of subdominant energy transactions : magnetic fields produced by galaxy dynamos and then blown out with the galactic winds , and escaping cosmic rays .
the largest transaction likely was the contribution to the cosmic background radiation .
the entry for the binding energy in atomic nuclei heavier than helium is from fukugita ( 2000 ) ; it uses the baryon budget of fukugita , hogan , & peebles ( 1998 ) at @xmath43 km s@xmath21 mpc@xmath21 , and assumes the heavy element abundance is @xmath44 times solar in the intracluster plasma and @xmath45 times solar in the intragroup plasma .
the production of helium in stars assumes the ratio of production of helium and heavier elements is @xmath46 .
the energies in the optical / near ir and far ir / sub - mm extragalactic radiation backgrounds are taken from pei , fall , & hauser ( 1999 ) .
these measurements , and their interpretations , are the subject of these proceedings ; a few comments suggested by the entries table 1 will be noted here .
the optical extragalactic background at @xmath475000 likely is dominated by starlight from low redshift , because the spectra of most galaxies decrease toward the ultraviolet . if so this background is not sensitive to the parameters of the cosmological model , but it is of considerable importance to cosmology as a test for stars in the extreme outer halos of galaxies or in objects with effective radii or surface brightnesses too small to be included in galaxy counts ( arp 1965 ; peebles 1971 ) .
the measurement of the extragalactic contribution to the light of the night sky has a long history ( eg .
dube , wickes , & wilkinson 1979 ; bernstein 2000 ) .
it shows we have not grossly underestimated the density of starlight , but further advances in the measurements will be followed with interest .
the estimate of the energy released by star formation is less than the upper bound on the background radiation between the optical / near ir and far ir / sub - mm peaks , not an observationally promising situation .
the energy released during dissipative contraction to the central baryon - dominated parts of the galaxies could make an interesting contribution to the x - ray background .
the contribution by spheroids depends on the mode of formation , whether by dissipative contraction of plasma followed by star formation or by near dissipationless merging of dense star clusters .
wyse ( 1999 ) reviews the observational considerations on which might be closer to what happened . if the latter , and if the star cluster building blocks had small individual escape velocities , the radiation accompanying the dissipative assembly of the star clusters could be lost in the uv / optical background .
disks likely formed by dissipative settling , and might be a significant source for the soft x - ray background .
the energy density in the x - ray background is three orders of magnitude down from the estimate of the energy density in black holes in galactic nuclei .
fabian ( 2000 ) , hasinger ( 2000 ) and others note that even with the @xmath48 redshift dimming ( eq . [ 1 ] ) , and a low radiation efficiency , @xmath42 , there is an ample budget for significant contributions by agns to the optical and sub - mm backgrounds .
about half the extragalactic b - band background radiation comes from the disks of spiral galaxies .
the dust in disks absorbs a substantial fraction of the starlight , so the contribution to the energy density in the sub - mm radiation background from starlight absorbed and reradiated by dust would be expected to be comparable to the contribution to the optical / near infrared radiation by unabsorbed starlight .
this is in line with the background measurements discussed by hauser and others at this meeting .
the entry for the binding energy in atomic nuclei is comparable to the measured energy in the infrared background .
and with pettini s ( 1999 ) calibration the time integral of the observed star formation history agrees with the present mass density in stars .
these three results could be taken to suggest we are getting close to a reconciliation of our accounts .
there are some complications to consider , however , as discussed next .
michael fall and piero madau discuss in these proceedings an important observational and conceptual advance , the establishment of a global star formation history .
this history can be compared to the record of the evolution of heavy element abundances , and to the resulting extragalactic infrared background .
i will present reasons for thinking complications in the history may require a generalization of the star formation history to a function of two variables , world time and environment .
the latter might have just three values : normal @xmath49 galaxy bulges , galaxy disks , and everywhere else .
even with this simple second parameter the assembly of useful observational constraints would be a messy project , but it may be necessary for concordance in the interpretation of a more sophisticated version of table 1 . to begin ,
suppose we choose cosmological parameters ( and the range of values now under popular discussion is not that broad ) so as to fix the world time @xmath3 as a function of redshift . then the madau plot ( pei & fall 1995 ; madau et al . 1996 )
the observed star formation rate @xmath50 per unit comoving volume as a function of redshift could be replotted as the product @xmath51 as a function of @xmath52 ( or , what is equivalent , @xmath53 against @xmath54 ) .
the motivation is the same as for the representation of the energy density of the extragalactic background as @xmath55 : in a semi - logarithmic plot the area under the curve is the contribution to the integral over the independent variable per logarithmic interval of the variable .
that is , this way to represent the star formation history gives us a picture of when there were significant contributions to the net mass in stars .
one would see that about half the observed star formation was relatively recent , at redshift @xmath56 .
where are these young stars ?
the answer may well be complicated ; i will mention two simple possibilities .
first , the star formation observed at @xmath56 might be concentrated somewhere other than in the normal textbook galaxies .
maybe this has something to do with the enigmatic fading faint blue galaxy population ; we do nt know where they ended up either . in this scenario
most stars may have formed at @xmath56 and produced most of the metals and most of the extragalactic infrared radiation .
but by assumption the extragalactic infrared background would have no direct relation to the origin and evolution of the populations of normal galaxies .
a second scenario is that most of the stars that formed at @xmath56 end up in normal @xmath49 galaxies .
then the evidence as i understand it is that these stars would have to be subdominant additions to the predominantly older star populations . we might recall that this evidence includes these four points .
a. about two thirds of the star mass in the high surface density @xmath57 galaxies is in spheroids .
the evidence i have been hearing is that most of these spheroid star populations are a good deal older than @xmath58 .
b. galaxy counts as a function of redshift at @xmath59 are consistent with near passive evolution of the star populations already present at @xmath60 . c. it seems to be agreed that the present population of normal @xmath57 galaxies by and large were in place , with near familiar morphologies , and close to the present - day comoving number densities , at @xmath60 .
d. the normal - looking @xmath49 spirals and ellipticals observed at @xmath58 are close to the tully - fisher and fundamental plane dynamical relations , after correction for passive evolution , consistent with the idea that these are full - grown textbook galaxies .
i think we must conclude that in this scenario the observed star formation history does not include the main event : the bulk of the star formation would have to be off scale to larger redshift , or maybe present at the redshift range of the madau plot but heavily obscured by dust and in concentrations small enough to have avoided too many scuba detections .
we have a constraint on this hypothetical `` main event '' from the production of heavy elements .
pei , fall , & hauser ( 1999 ) estimate that the observed star formation rate integrated from high redshift to @xmath61 is about enough to account for the observed accumulation of mass in heavy elements at this redshift , while pettini ( 1999 ) and pagel ( 1999 ) argue that the observed mass in heavy elements at @xmath61 may actually be significantly less than what might have been expected from the seen amount of star formation up to this epoch . under the former estimate
the `` main event '' requires a special conjecture : we have to suppose the heavy elements associated with the substantial early star formation are hidden , perhaps in dense clouds . under the latter estimate heavy elements have
to be hidden at @xmath61 , so it would not be such a great stretch to imagine the heavy elements associated with the `` mail event '' are hidden too .
advances in the subtle analysis of the constraints on the star formation history , including the relation between star formation and heavy element production , will be fascinating to follow .
it has been widely and properly noted that we have significant observational evidence galaxies as we know them formed recently , at @xmath59 : the energy in the infrared extragalactic background , without large redshift dimming , is comparable to the binding energy of the heavy elements in normal @xmath57 galaxies , and the time integral of the seen star formation rate , which implies most stars are young , agrees with the seen mass in stars .
but i have argued other lines of evidence indicate the cohort of stars and their heavy elements that formed at @xmath56 had to have ended up somewhere other than the high surface brightness parts of normal galaxies , or else are subdominant additions to the normal galaxies .
true coincidences happen , of course : we have a sensible case for similar contributions to the sub - mm background by two quite different sources the radiation from stars and from agns with quite different fractions processed through dust .
the lesson is that untangling the relations among the extragalactic radiation background , the histories of star formation in different environments , and the accumulations of stars and heavy elements , is likely to be a complicated operation .
this is hardly surprising , considering that we live in a complicated universe .
but the suite of observational evidence in hand is rich , rapidly growing , and fascinating to see sorted out .
i am grateful to masataka fukugita for his help in constructing table 1 , to david hogg for his help with the astronomy , and to michael fall and piero madau for their helpful comments on the paper .
this work was supported in part by the us national science foundation . | i review the assumptions and observations that motivate the concept of the extragalactic cosmic background radiation , and the issues of energy accounts and star formation history as a function of galaxy morphological type that figure in the interpretation of the measurements of the extragalactic infrared background .
# 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
strongly correlated electron systems in low dimensions are of fundamental interest due to their fascinating properties resulting from strong quantum fluctuations @xcite . especially in the case of the high - t@xmath20 cuprate superconductors , the role of quantum fluctuations is heavily debated .
two - magnon raman scattering has been proven to be a powerful tool to study quantum fluctuations in the magnetic sector@xcite .
in contrast to the well understood magnon dispersion as measured by inelastic neutron scattering@xcite , the quantitative understanding of the two - magnon line - shape in the raman response@xcite and in the optical conductivity@xcite remains an issue open to debate .
interestingly , in the so - called cuprate ladder systems like sr123 or the telephone - number compounds ( sr , ca , la)@xmath2cu@xmath3o@xmath4 a prominent peak in the magnetic raman response is observed at the same energy of about @xmath21 @xmath13 as in the two - dimensional compounds@xcite .
in contrast to the gapless long - range ordered two - dimensional compound , the quasi one - dimensional two - leg ladders are known to be realizations of a gapped spin liquid@xcite .
because the elementary excitations above this groundstate are triplons@xcite , we call the corresponding raman response as two - triplon raman scattering . on the one hand , one may expect that the raman response is dominated by short - range , high - energy excitations , suggesting a certain similarity between ladders and planes , both being built from edge - sharing cu@xmath18 plaquettes .
the peak frequencies are in fact at @xmath21 @xmath13 . on the other hand , the line shape and
in particular the peak width strongly varies between different compounds . in 2d ,
the peak width is of the order of @xmath22 @xmath13 , in la6ca8 about @xmath23 @xmath13 , in sr123 and sr14 only @xmath24 @xmath13 . due to the observation of a very sharp two - triplon raman line in the spin liquid sr14 , gozar _ et al . _
have questioned whether the large line width in 2d and the related , heavily discussed spectral weight above the two - magnon peak can be attributed to quantum fluctuations@xcite . in the last years theoretical developments in the field of quasi one - dimensional systems , namely the quantitative calculation of spectral densities@xcite , has led to a deeper understanding of magnetic contributions to the raman response of undoped cuprate ladders .
besides the usual heisenberg exchange terms the minimal magnetic model includes four - spin interactions which are 4 - 5 times smaller than the leading heisenberg couplings@xcite .
the existence and the size of the four - spin interactions are consistent with theoretical derivations of generalized @xmath25-@xmath26 models from one - band or three - band hubbard models@xcite . in the present paper
we show that the strong variation of the line width can be traced back to changes of the spatial anisotropy of the exchange constants .
the sharp raman line in sr14 and sr123 results from @xmath27 , the increased line width in la6ca8 reflects @xmath15 , and the isotropic couping @xmath28 for the square lattice yields the much larger width observed in 2d .
in fact , we obtain a quantitative description of the dominant raman peak in 2d using a toy model which mimics the 2d square lattice by the superposition of a vertical and a horizontal ladder .
we thus conclude that the dominant raman peak is well described by short - range excitations .
besides the dominant two - triplon peak , the large spectral weight measured at high energies remains an open problem for the cuprate ladders and planes .
we review possible sources of the high - energy spectral weight which were suggested in the past , e.g. quantum fluctuations@xcite , the role of spin - phonon interaction@xcite and the triple resonance@xcite . in case of the cuprate planes
no final conclusion concerning the origin of the high - energy weight can be drawn , but in the case of the cuprate ladders the spin - phonon coupling and the triple resonance can be ruled out .
in raman scattering multi - particle excitations with zero change of the total spin can be measured .
starting at @xmath29 from an @xmath30 ground state the singlet excitations with combined zero momentum are probed .
the raman response in spin ladders has been calculated by first order perturbation theory@xcite and by exact diagonalization@xcite . in this work ,
raman line - shapes are presented obtained from continuous unitary transformations ( cut ) using rung triplons as elementary excitations@xcite .
the results are not resolution limited because neither finite size effects occur nor an artificial broadening is necessary
. for zero hole doping , the minimum model for the magnetic properties of the @xmath31 two - leg ladders is an antiferromagnetic heisenberg hamiltonian plus a cyclic four - spin exchange term @xmath32 @xcite [ eq : hamiltonian ] @xmath33 where @xmath34 denotes the rungs and @xmath35 the legs .
the exchange couplings along the rungs and along the legs are denoted by @xmath8 and @xmath7 , respectively .
the relevant couplings modeling sr123 and sr14@xcite are illustrated in fig .
[ fig_sketch ] .
there is also another way to include the leading four - spin exchange term by cyclic permutations @xcite which differs in certain two - spin terms from eq .
( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) @xcite .
both hamiltonians are identical except for couplings along the diagonals if @xmath8 and @xmath7 are suitably redefined @xcite . ) ) .
the circles denote the positions of cu@xmath36 ions carrying a spin 1/2 each .
the crystallographic axes are such that @xmath37 and @xmath38 for sr123 and @xmath39 and @xmath40 for sr14 . ] at @xmath29 the raman response @xmath41 is given by the retarded resolvent @xmath42 the observables @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) for magnetic light scattering in rung - rung ( leg - leg ) polarization read in leading order @xcite [ observables ] @xmath45 the factors @xmath46 and @xmath47 depend on the underlying microscopic electronic model .
it is beyond the scope of the present work to compute them .
the results will be given in units of these factors squared .
in this article we will only consider non - resonant raman excitation processes .
we discuss which laser energy should be used in order to investigate the non - resonant regime .
technically , we employ a cut to map the hamiltonian @xmath48 to an effective hamiltonian @xmath49 which conserves the number of rung - triplons , i.e. @xmath50=0 $ ] where @xmath51 @xcite . the ground state of @xmath49 is the rung - triplon vacuum .
for the response function @xmath41 the observable @xmath52 is mapped to an effective observable @xmath53 by the same cut .
the cut is implemented in a perturbative fashion in @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
the effective hamiltonian is calculated up to high orders ( 1-triplon terms : 11@xmath56 , 2-triplon terms : 10@xmath56 order ) .
the effective observable @xmath57 is computed to order @xmath58 in the 2-triplon sector .
the resulting plain series are represented in terms of the variable @xmath59 @xcite where @xmath60 is the one - triplon gap
. then standard pad extrapolants @xcite yield reliable results up to @xmath61 depending on the value of @xmath62 .
consistency checks were carried out by extrapolating the involved quantities before and after fourier transforms . in case of inconclusive extrapolants
the bare truncated series are used .
we will estimate the overall accuracy below by comparing with dmrg results@xcite .
the raman line shape is finally calculated as continued fraction by tridiagonalization of the effective two - triplon hamiltonian .
sectors with odd number of triplons are inaccessible by raman scattering due to the invariance of the two observables @xmath63 and @xmath64 with respect to reflections about the centerline of the ladder@xcite .
thus only excitations with even number of triplons matter .
therefore the leading contributions to the raman response come from the 2-triplon sector .
it was shown earlier that the two - triplon contribution is the dominant part of the raman response at low and intermediate energies@xcite .
the role of the four - triplon contribution for the high - energy spectral weight will be discussed at the end of this work .
in this part we will compare the theoretically obtained two - triplon contributions to the experimental line - shapes of the cuprate ladders sr123 and sr14 .
the crystals of sr123 have been grown and measured under the same conditions as described in refs . and , while the data of sr14 have been provided by gozar _
et al._@xcite .
the experimental raman line - shape depends strongly on the laser energy because resonant contributions are present .
this becomes apparent in a strong anisotropy between the width of the two - triplon peak in leg and rung polarization for laser energies @xmath65 ev . the width of the two - triplon peak in leg polarization is much sharper . for laser energies @xmath66 ev , the strong anisotropy between both polarizations vanishes@xcite .
it is therefore important to figure out which laser energy has to be used for the comparison between the non - resonant theory and the experiment in order to study the magnetic excitations only .
the first criterion can be gained from the optical conductivity as for example given in ref . :
the intensity of the two - triplon peak develops in the same way as the optical conductivity . for the non - resonant regime both , energy of the incident and
scattered light , should be smaller than the charge transfer gap ( sr14 : @xmath67 ev ) .
thus , we have chosen spectra with laser energies @xmath68 ev in the case of sr14 and @xmath69 ev for sr123 .
luckily , the value of the optical conductivity is about 100 @xmath70@xmath13 in the sub gap regime at @xmath71 ev@xcite ( which is 1 - 2 orders of magnitude larger than for the 2d cuprates @xcite ) yielding a non vanishing intensity of the two - triplon peak . here
@xmath72 denotes the energy of the two - triplon peak .
the second criterion arises from the polarization dependence of the two - triplon peak .
depending on the laser energy used one can observe a drastic difference in the line shape between the two polarizations@xcite . while the difference in the line shapes
is large for @xmath73 ev , it does almost vanish in the case of @xmath74 ev @xcite .
this fits very well to the weak polarization dependence of the purely magnetic response as described by eqs .
( [ observables ] ) : for @xmath75 the raman line - shape is identical in the rung and the leg polarization .
small deviations @xmath76 as relevant for the description of sr123 and sr14 produce small deviations with respect to the symmetry between the rung and leg polarization of the ladder .
these deviations can not account for the drastic change between the two polarizations as observed for @xmath73 ev @xcite .
we therefore conclude that the spectra @xmath74 ev are the best choice in order to compare to a purely magnetic , non - resonant theory .
now we discuss the dependence of the width of the two - triplon peak on the parameters @xmath77 and @xmath78 . in fig .
[ fig : fwhm ] , the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the two - triplon peak is shown . the overall uncertainty shown as error bars in fig . [
fig : fwhm ] of the extrapolated two - triplon fwhm was determined by comparing to dmrg data@xcite .
let us first consider the case @xmath79 . here
the two - triplon width should be identical in both polarizations .
it can be clearly seen that the numerically obtained results reflect this property rather well indicating that the uncertainties in the extrapolation are small concerning the matrix elements .
there is a strong dependence of the fwhm of the two - triplon peak on the parameter @xmath77 .
the peak sharpens significantly when the ratio @xmath77 of the magnetic heisenberg exchanges increases ( 4 times from @xmath28 to @xmath27 ) . in the case of @xmath80 ,
the width depends on the polarization . in general , the width in ( xx)-polarization is larger than in ( yy)-polarization . for fixed @xmath77 the fwhm changes at maximum by a factor of two when varying @xmath81 from @xmath82 to @xmath83 .
( squares ) , @xmath84 ( triangles ) and @xmath27 ( diamonds ) as a function of the strength of the four - spin interactions @xmath85 .
the orange ( grey ) symbols denote ( xx)-polarization and the blue ( black ) symbols ( yy)-polarization .
the solid lines are a guide to the eye obtained by spline interpolation.,width=309 ] in figs .
[ fig : comp](a - d ) , the experimental raman response of sr123 and sr14 is shown for ( xx)- and ( yy)-polarization ( red / black and cyan / grey curves ) .
the spectra of sr123 were taken in the same way as described in ref . .
the data of sr14 has been made available by gozar _
et al._@xcite .
in addition , theoretically obtained two - triplon contributions are displayed ( orange / grey and blue / black ) . experimentally , the width of the two - triplon peak of both materials is almost identical ( @xmath86 150 @xmath13 ) .
only the position of the two - triplon peak is different ( @xmath86 3140 @xmath13 for sr123 and @xmath86 3000 @xmath13 for sr14 ) which is a result of the slightly different madelung potentials of both compounds . for modeling the raman response we assume @xmath16 for both compounds .
this order of magnitude was previously obtained for cuprate ladders by inelastic neutron scattering@xcite , by infrared absoption@xcite , raman response@xcite and theoretical works deriving extended low - energy heisenberg models@xcite . in order to account for the fwhm and the two - triplon peak position we determine @xmath27 and global energy scales @xmath87 @xmath13 for sr123 and @xmath88 @xmath13 for sr14 .
it was previously argued that in sr14 a charge order of the chain subsystem modulates the magnetic exchange in the ladders@xcite .
this opens a gap in the raman response which has a large effect on the two - triplon peak for the parameters @xmath15 and @xmath76 which are appropriate for la6ca8 .
however , the effect is small for larger @xmath77-values because the induced gap opens well above the two - triplon peak at @xmath89 @xmath13 .
the set of parameters used above for sr123 and sr14 describes quantitatively well the raman response as shown in tab .
[ tab_plane ] and figs .
[ fig : comp](a - d ) .
especially both polarizations for each material can be modeled using only one set of parameters @xmath8 , @xmath77 and @xmath81 .
the smaller fwhm of sr123 and sr14 compared to la6ca8@xcite can be directly explained by their larger @xmath77-values ( see fig .
[ fig : fwhm ] ) .
the coupling constants of sr14 are in good agreement with those obtained by ir absorption measurements@xcite .
additionally , our set of parameters yields a spin gap of @xmath90 @xmath13 for sr123 and @xmath91 @xmath13for sr14 using the underlying one - triplon dispersion .
the latter value is consistent with the spin gap measured by inelastic neutron scattering@xcite .
k ) and sr14 ( @xmath92 k ) with the theoretically obtained two - triplon contribution .
the data of sr14 have been provided by gozar _
et al._@xcite .
( a ) the red ( black ) curve denotes the ( xx)-polarization ( @xmath37 ) of sr123 with a laser excitation energy @xmath931.95 ev .
the orange ( grey ) curve displays the theoretical two - triplon contribution with @xmath27 , @xmath16 and @xmath94 @xmath13 .
( b ) the red ( black ) curve denotes the ( xx)-polarization ( @xmath39 ) of sr14 with a laser excitation energy @xmath68 ev .
the orange ( grey ) curve displays the theoretical two - triplon contribution with @xmath27 , @xmath95 and @xmath88 @xmath13 .
( c ) ( yy)-polarization ( @xmath38 ) for sr123 .
identical parameters as in ( a ) . the cyan ( grey ) curve displays the experimental data and the blue ( black ) curve the theoretical two - triplon contribution .
( d ) ( yy)-polarization ( @xmath40 ) for sr14 .
identical parameters as in ( b ) and the same colors as in ( c).,width=309 ]
in this section we calculate the raman response for the undoped two - dimensional cuprate compounds using a toy model consisting of two uncoupled two - leg ladders ( see fig .
[ fig_sketch_plane ] ) .
this is motivated by the fact that the building blocks of ladders and planes are edge - sharing cu@xmath18 plaquettes .
we expect that the raman response is dominated by short - range and high - energy excitations yielding a certain similarity between ladders and planes .
indeed , the positions of the two - magnon peak in the 2d cuprates and the two - triplon peak in the cuprate ladders are found at almost the same frequency @xmath96 @xmath13 , but the fwhm of the two - dimensional compounds is a factor of 2 - 6 larger .
we have shown in the last section that the fwhm of the two - triplon peak in the cuprate ladder compounds strongly varies with @xmath77 .
we therefore conjecture that the larger fwhm of the two - dimensional cuprates originates from the isotropic coupling @xmath28 .
there will be of course deviations at small energies resulting from the differences between a gapped two - leg ladder and the gapless excitations in the two - dimensional compounds .
clearly , a magnon description would be the proper starting point to treat the long - ranged ordered antiferromagnetic state .
we think , however , that a triplon picture which includes the interactions on the quantitative level can give a good description of the raman response .
a similar treatment in terms of gapped quasi - particles already led to an improved agreement between theory and experiments@xcite .
-direction and the other in @xmath77-direction .
we approximate the two - dimensional square lattice by the sum of these two uncoupled orthogonal ladders . ] in the following we will show how to deduce the a@xmath97 and b@xmath98 raman spectra of the square lattice from those of the two - leg ladder .
clearly , one should use @xmath28 because the square lattice is isotropic ( @xmath99 ) .
starting from the fleury - loudon operator the observables @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) for magnetic light scattering in b@xmath98 ( a@xmath98 ) polarization read in leading order for the two - dimensional square lattice@xcite [ observables_2d ] @xmath102 here @xmath103 ( @xmath104 ) denotes a summation over nearest - neighbors in @xmath77-direction ( @xmath105-direction ) .
the parameters @xmath106 and @xmath107 depend on the underlying microscopic model and are in general not equal@xcite .
we approximate the two - dimensional square lattice by a sum of two uncoupled two - leg ladders , one oriented in @xmath77-direction , the other in @xmath105-direction
. the situation is sketched in fig .
[ fig_sketch_plane ] .
the summation over both ladder orientations will restore the square lattice symmetries . comparing eq .
( [ observables_2d ] ) with eq.([observables ] ) one readily deduces the following relations [ observables_rel ] @xmath108 between the relevant observables in the two - leg ladder and the two - dimensional square lattice . note that for @xmath109 , the raman response in the a@xmath98 polarization vanishes due to the property @xmath110@xcite .
the latter point is consistent with earlier treatments of the two - dimensional raman response .
but for a finite strength of the four - spin interactions @xmath81 , also the a@xmath98 polarization is finite@xcite . .
( a ) b@xmath98-polarization for @xmath79 ( cyan / grey ) , @xmath111 ( dashed ) and @xmath16 ( blue / black ) .
( b ) a@xmath98-polarization for @xmath79 ( orange / grey ) , @xmath111 ( dashed ) and @xmath16 ( red / black ) .
note the different scales for the raman response in @xmath112 and @xmath113 spectra.,width=309 ] the theoretical two - triplon contribution of the b@xmath98 ( panel a ) and the a@xmath114 ( panel b ) polarization is shown in fig .
[ fig:2d_a1g_b1 g ] .
the parameters used are an isotropic coupling @xmath28 and a strength of the four - spin interactions @xmath79 , @xmath111 , and @xmath16 .
the b@xmath98 polarization displays a symmetric two - triplon peak which is dominating the raman response .
the four - spin interactions shift the whole spectrum to lower energies and decrease the total intensity .
the fwhm of the two - triplon peak is approximately given by the average width of the two - triplon peaks of an isolated two - leg ladder in rung and in leg polarization .
thus , the width is nearly independent of the value of @xmath81 .
the a@xmath98 polarization is almost zero for vanishing @xmath81 .
this again reflects the accurate extrapolation of the matrix elements . for non - zero @xmath81 , a finite a@xmath97 contribution is realized .
the differences in the line - shape between a@xmath98 and b@xmath98 are a pure effect of different matrix elements . compared to the two - triplon peak in the b@xmath98 polarization
the a@xmath98 polarization displays a two peak structure where the second peak is sharper and at higher energies . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in the following we will compare the theoretical two - triplon contribution to the raman response with low temperature experimental data on r@xmath0cuo@xmath18 ( @xmath115 ev)@xcite , sr@xmath0cuo@xmath0cl@xmath0 ( @xmath116 ev)@xcite , and yba@xmath0cu@xmath1o@xmath19 ( @xmath115 ev)@xcite taken from the literature . as discussed in section [ cl ] the laser energy used for
the experiment is a crucial issue .
analogous to the ladders one should use spectra of cuprate planes measured with laser energies below the charge gap for comparing to the purely magnetic theoretical response . but it turns out that the optical conductivity is rather low ( @xmath117 @xmath70@xmath13 ) below the charge gap @xmath118 which results in a vanishing intensity of the two - magnon peak @xcite .
an analogous choice of the laser energies below the charge gap as discussed for the cuprate ladders is not possible .
therefore , we used data measured with laser energies @xmath119 ev@xmath120 . at the energy @xmath119 ev
the optical conductivity is quite smooth and @xmath121 ev@xcite .
simultaneously @xmath119 ev coincides with the triple resonance at @xmath122 . the triple resonance theory predicts two peaks in the raman response at about @xmath123 and @xmath124 .
the relative intensity of both peaks depends on the laser energy .
the second peak is strongly suppressed at @xmath125 . in that sense
this laser energy can be assigned to be closest to the non - resonant regime @xcite . in fig .
[ fig:2d_comp ] experimental data and theoretical contributions using @xmath28 and @xmath16 are shown for both polarizations .
frequencies are measured in units of @xmath26 .
we first discuss the b@xmath98 polarization in fig .
[ fig:2d_comp](a ) .
we have chosen the global energy scale @xmath26 for all experimental curves such that the positions of the experimental two - magnon and the theoretical two - triplon peaks match .
this yields quantitatively reasonable values for these compounds .
in addition , we find quantitative agreement between the experimental fwhm and the theoretical fwhm of the two - triplon peak .
the values of @xmath26 and the fwhm are listed in tab .
[ tab_plane ] for all compounds .
note that the fwhm for @xmath28 is larger than for the anisotropic case @xmath126 as discussed for the ladder compounds . clearly , there are also deviations between theory and experiment .
as expected , the low - energy spectral weight in the theoretical line - shape is larger compared to the experimental curves .
this is definitely a consequence of approximating the two - dimensional square lattice with quasi one - dimensional models .
there is also spectral weight missing at higher energies above the two - triplon peak .
possible explanations will be described below .
the results for the a@xmath98 polarization ( shown in fig . [ fig:2d_comp](b ) ) are explained next .
we used the _ same _ global energy scales @xmath26 for the experimental curves as determined from the b@xmath98 polarization above . in order to reproduce the maximum intensity of the experiment , we multiplied the theoretical curve from fig .
[ fig:2d_a1g_b1g](b ) by a factor 5 .
this implies that the microscopic parameters @xmath127 and @xmath107 are anisotropic . a possible reason for this anisotropy could be the restriction to the fleury - loudon observable .
an extension of this observable to higher orders in @xmath128 ( four - spin and next - nearest neighbor two - spin terms ) gives additional contributions to @xmath129 and @xmath101@xcite .
the relevance of these contributions has not been analyzed . in the experiment a broad hump
is measured .
we find it very promising that the theoretical contribution displays the dominant spectral weight just for these energies .
however , the line - shape can not be resolved completely because the dip in the theoretical curve is not observed in the experiment .
it originates from neglecting the finite life - time effects which are already present in the description of the isolated two - leg ladder@xcite being the building block of our square - lattice toy model .
we conclude that at least a part of the experimental a@xmath98 polarization originates from the finite four - spin interactions . for @xmath109
, there is no purely magnetic contribution to the raman response for this polarization .
a finite a@xmath98 raman response can be regarded as an evidence for the presence of sizable four - spin interactions .
this follows entirely from symmetry arguments and holds true for the full two - dimensional model . at higher energies , spectral weight is missing in the theoretical contribution in an analogous fashion as in the b@xmath98 polarization .
cuo@xmath18 ( @xmath115 ev , @xmath130 k ) and sr@xmath0cuo@xmath0cl@xmath0 ( @xmath116 ev , @xmath92 k ) . the raman data of nd@xmath0cuo@xmath18 and sr@xmath0cuo@xmath0cl@xmath0 are reproduced from refs . and .
the experimental curves are smoothed and their zero position is shifted horizontally as indicated by the black horizontal lines . ( a )
b@xmath98-polarization : the blue ( black ) curve denotes the two - triplon contribution with @xmath28 and @xmath16 . the global energy scale @xmath26 is chosen such that experimental two - magnon and the theoretical two - triplon peak merge .
this yields @xmath131 @xmath13 for nd@xmath0cuo@xmath18 ( cyan / grey ) and sr@xmath0cuo@xmath0cl@xmath0 ( dashed ) .
( b ) a@xmath98-polarization ( theory : red / black ; experiment : organge / grey ) : same notations as in ( a ) .
note that the _ same _ magnetic exchange couplings @xmath26 are used .
the a@xmath98-cut is multiplied by a factor 5 in comparison to the curve in fig .
[ fig:2d_a1g_b1g].,width=309 ]
as shown in sect . [ cl ] and in sect .
[ cp ] the cut can not account for the missing high - energy spectral weight when comparing to the raman experiments . also other theories proposed previously like calculations based on spin - waves@xcite , paramagnons@xcite , jordan - wigner fermions@xcite and numerical studies@xcite were faced with the same problem . extended theories including _ ( i ) multi - particle contributions _ , _
( ii ) spin - phonon coupling _ , _ ( iii ) two - magnon / triplon plus phonon absorption _ and _ ( iv ) triple resonance _ are necessary in order to describe the high - energy spectral weight .
most of the publications deal with the two - dimensional compounds . here
we will try to review these ideas and reexamine them in the light of our new results .
especially the quantitative results for the cuprate ladders can give new insights in this discussion . _ ( i ) multi - particle contributions _ one open problem is the role of multi - particle contributions to the raman response , i.e. the four - magnon contribution in the case of the square lattice and the four - triplon contribution in the case of the two - leg ladder . at this stage
no quantitative calculations are available .
but it is known that the multi - triplon spectral weights are sizable for the two - leg ladder@xcite .
the main effect of the four - spin interaction on the high - energy spectral weight is a small shift from the two - triplon to the multi - triplon channels@xcite .
but this shift is not sufficient to account for the high - energy spectral weight as observed in experiments .
this was also found in treatments for the two - dimensional square lattice@xcite .
however , the complete magnetic infrared absorption spectrum ( including the high - energy part ) of la6ca8 can be described quantitatively by including multi - particle contributions@xcite . here
@xmath81 does not play the dominant role for the high - energy spectral weight@xcite .
it is therefore plausible that these contributions give a noticeable effect also on the high - energy raman response .
there are also indications that the spectral weight can not be fully explained in this way .
for example , the four - magnon spectral weight was shown to be negligible for the 2d square lattice@xcite .
but the magnon - magnon interaction which was not treated in this calculation could enhance the high - energy spectral weight . also quantum monte carlo calculations which include all magnon contributions for the two - dimensional heisenberg model seem to explain only a part of the high - energy spectral weight@xcite . but finite size effects and inaccuracies of the analytical continuation can lead to uncertainties in determining the high - energy spectral weight . _
( ii ) spin - phonon coupling _ the latter observations suggest that additional degrees of freedom are important .
it was argued by several authors that the coupling to phonons produces a large amount of spectral weight above the two - triplon peak@xcite . in one approach the spin - phonon coupling modulates the magnetic exchange couplings with a gaussian distribution .
another approach introduces a finite spin wave damping induced by the spin - phonon coupling .
both scenarios produce a significantly broadened and asymmetric two - magnon peak as observed in experiments@xcite . nevertheless , the consistency of a spin - phonon coupling as suggested above with experiments is not clear .
the magnitude of this coupling has to be unrealistically large in order to describe infrared absorption data@xcite .
additionally , it was pointed out by freitas and singh@xcite that the temperature - dependent correlation length and the spin dynamics which agree well with purely magnetic models does not leave room for such a coupling@xcite
. there are no investigations of the role of spin - phonon couplings for the case of the cuprate ladder systems .
but the fwhm of the two - triplon peak can be quantitatively understood within a purely magnetic model as shown in sect .
thus , we conclude that the spin - phonon coupling is not strong in the case of the cuprate ladder compounds .
such a coupling leads to a broad two - triplon peak in the same way as for the two - dimensional case .
this is a contradiction when considering the raman response and the infrared absorption of cuprate ladders simultaneously : on the one hand one needs a larger anisotropy between leg and rung coupling ( larger @xmath77 ) in order to sharpen the two - triplon peak in the raman response again ( see fig . [
fig : fwhm ] ) but on the other hand one can not explain the infrared absorption with an substantially increased @xmath77@xcite .
a strong spin - phonon coupling is therefore in contradiction with the results obtained for cuprate ladders .
this can be also seen as an indication that the same holds true for the two - dimensional compounds@xcite . _
( iii ) two - magnon / triplon plus phonon absorption _ a third alternative explaining the high - energy spectral weight uses phonons as possible momentum sinks . here
a strong spin - phonon coupling is not necessary .
the idea is based on the work of lorenzana and sawatzky for infrared absorption@xcite .
it is well accepted in the case of infrared absorption measurements on cuprate ladders@xcite and planes@xcite that the dominant processes are magnetic excitations which are assisted by phonons .
it was realized by freitas and singh that similar processes could be important also for the raman response in cuprate planes@xcite . in an analogous fashion a two - triplon plus ( raman active ) phonon process for the raman response in cuprate ladders could be important .
it can be used to transfer spectral weight above the two - triplon peak leading to an asymmetric line - shape .
it is a difficult task to determine the relative strength of this process compared to the usual two - triplon scattering . _
( iv ) triple resonance _ additionally , the triple resonance was proposed to account for the high - energy spectral weight in the two - dimensional compounds@xcite . as already stated in sec .
[ cp ] , the experimental spectra of the planes are taken in the resonant regime .
it is known that the triple resonance scenario yields an additional peak above the two - magnon peak .
its intensity depends significantly on the energy of the incident light in accordance with experiments@xcite . in principle , the same effect is also present in ladder compounds .
but for the laser energy @xmath132=1.92 ev@xmath133 considered for sr123 and sr14 the triple resonance condition is not fulfilled . due to the simplified model used for the 2d system no conclusion about the high - energy weight can be drawn from our results .
because a large spin - phonon coupling and the triple resonance can be ruled out for the cuprate ladder systems , the observed high - energy spectral weight in the cuprate ladder compounds has to be explained most probably by the multi - triplon or two - triplon plus phonon contributions .
the first part of this work deals with the theoretical understanding of non - resonant magnetic raman scattering on cuprate two - leg ladder compounds , namely sr123 , sr14 , and la6ca8 .
therefore we applied a triplon - conserving cut on a microscopic spin - model which includes heisenberg couplings and additional four - spin interactions .
we studied the two - triplon contribution to the non - resonant magnetic raman response .
the dominating feature of the two - triplon contribution is the two - triplon peak which has a characteristic fwhm depending on the model parameters @xmath77 and @xmath81 .
we carefully chose the experimental data closest to the non - resonant regime and compared them with our theory .
the key observation we found is that the sharpness of the two - triplon peak in sr123 and sr14 in comparison to la6ca8 can be explained by the stronger anisotropy of the magnetic exchange along the rungs and legs of the ladder .
indeed , the two - triplon peak width depends strongly on the parameter @xmath77 .
both materials can be modeled with the parameters @xmath134 and @xmath135 but different global energy scales @xmath136 @xmath13 for sr123 and @xmath137 @xmath13 for sr14 .
the parameters for sr14 are in good agreement with infrared absorption @xcite and inelastic neutron scattering@xcite experiments .
we conclude that the dominating two - triplon peak of the magnetic raman response in cuprate ladders can be consistently explained within the microscopic model .
the presence of a four - spin interaction of the order of @xmath138 can be viewed as a settled issue . in the second part of this article we used the results found for the two - leg ladder to describe the magnetic raman response of the undoped two - dimensional cuprate compounds in b@xmath98 and a@xmath98 polarization .
the contribution to the a@xmath98 polarization is only allowed for finite four - spin interactions due to symmetry reasons .
we use an isotropic coupling @xmath28 and @xmath16 for the comparison with the experimental data .
convincingly , we find quantitative agreement for the two - triplon peak position _ and _ the two - triplon peak width for several compounds . additionally , a sizable spectral weight is found in the a@xmath98 polarization consistent with experiments .
we conclude that the processes dominating the magnetic raman response are short - ranged .
the last part deals with the missing high - energy spectral weight above the dominating two - triplon peak for the case of cuprate ladders and planes .
we review possible sources of this spectral weight like multi - particle contributions , the role of spin - phonon coupling , a two - triplon plus phonon process and the triple resonance to the magnetic raman response .
we deduced from our results that the high - energy spectral weight can not be explained with realistic values for the spin - phonon coupling .
in summary , our calculations lead to an unified understanding of the magnetic raman response in cuprate ladder compounds within a purely magnetic model .
a strong spin - phonon coupling can be excluded for these materials .
additionally , we obtained a convincing quantitative description of the dominating two - magnon peak in the raman response of cuprate planes using a toy model consisting of two uncoupled two - leg ladders .
this suggests that the short - ranged triplon excitations might be an alternative starting point for the description of the two - dimensional cuprate compounds .
we gratefully acknowledge g.s . uhrig , m. grninger , a. gozar , a. reischl , and s. jandl for very helpful discussions .
we thank a. gozar for the kind provision of experimental data on sr14 .
this work is supported by the dfg in sfb 608 .
j. orenstein and a.j .
millis , science * 288 * , 468 ( 2000 ) .
s. sachdev , science * 288 * , 475 ( 2000 ) .
anderson , science * 288 * , 480 ( 2000 ) .
p. knoll , c. thomsen , m. cardona , and p. murugaraj , phys .
b * 42 * , r4842 ( 1990 ) . g. blumberg , p. abbamonte , m.v .
klein , w.c .
lee , , d.m .
ginsberg , l.l .
miller , a. zibold , phys .
b * 53 * , r11930 ( 1996 ) .
s. sugai , m. sato , t. kobayashi , j. akimitsu , t. ito , h. takagi , s. uchida , s. hosoya , t. kajitani , and t. fukuda , phys .
b * 42 * , r1045 ( 1990 ) . p.e .
sulewski , p.a .
fleury , k.b .
lyons , s - w .
cheong , and z. fisk , phys .
b * 41 * , 225 ( 1990 ) .
sulewski , p.a .
fleury , k.b .
lyons , and s - w .
cheong , phys . rev
. lett . * 67 * , 3864 ( 1991 ) .
m. yoshida , s. tajima , n. koshizuka , s. tanaka , s. uchida , and t. itoh , phys .
b * 46 * , 6505 ( 1992 ) .
e. manousakis , rev .
mod . phys . *
63 * , 1 ( 1991 ) .
kastner , r.j .
birgeneau , g. shirane , and y. endoh , rev .
* 70 * , 897 ( 1998 ) .
clarke , a. harrison , t.e .
mason , and d. visser , solid state commun . *
112 * , 561 ( 1999 ) .
hayden , g. aeppli , r. osborn , a. d. taylor , t. g. perring , s .- w .
cheong , and z. fisk , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 3622 ( 1991 ) .
r. coldea , s.m .
hayden , g. aeppli , t. g. perring , c.d .
frost , t.e .
mason , s .- w .
cheong , and z. fisk , phys .
* 86 * , 5377 ( 2001 ) .
perkins , j.m .
graybeal , m.a .
kastner , r.j .
birgeneau , j.p .
falck , and m. greven phys .
lett * 71 * , 1621 ( 1993 ) .
perkins , r.j .
birgeneau , j.m .
graybeal , m.a .
kastner and d.s .
kleinberg , phys .
b * 58 * , 9390 ( 1998 ) .
m. grninger , d. van der marel , a. damascelli , a. erb , t. nunner , and t. kopp , phys .
b * 62 * , 12422 ( 2000 ) .
j. lorenzana , j. eroles , and s. sorella , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 5122 ( 1999 ) .
a. gling , u. kuhlmann , c. thomsen , a. lffert , c. gross and w. assmus , phys .
b * 67 * , 052403 ( 2003 ) .
a. gozar , g. blumberg , b.s .
dennis , b.s .
shastry , n. motoyama , h. eisaki , and s. uchida , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 197202 ( 2001 ) .
e. dagotto and t.m .
rice , science * 271 * , 618 ( 1996 ) . z.v .
popovi , m.j .
konstantinovi , v.a .
ivanov , o.p .
khuong , r. gaji , a. vietkin , and v.v .
moshchalkov , phys .
b * 62 * , 4963 ( 2000 ) .
s. sugai and m. suzuki , phys .
stat . sol .
( b ) * 215 * , 653 ( 1999 ) .
schmidt and g.s .
uhrig , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 227204 ( 2003 ) . c. knetter , k.p .
schmidt , m. grninger , and g.s .
uhrig , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 167204 ( 2001 ) .
schmidt , c. knetter , and g.s .
uhrig , europhys . lett . *
56 * , 877 ( 2001 ) .
nunner , p. brune , t. kopp , m. windt , and m. grninger , phys .
b * 66 * , 180404(r ) ( 2002 ) .
m. grueninger , m. windt , e. benckiser , t.s.nunner , k.p .
schmidt , g.s .
uhrig und t. kopp , adv.sol.stat.phys .
* 43 * , 95 ( 2003 ) .
w. zheng , c.j .
hamer , and r.r.p .
singh , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 037206 ( 2003 ) .
schmidt , c. knetter and g.s .
uhrig , phys .
b * 69 * , 104417 ( 2004 ) .
s. trebst , h. monien , c.j .
hamer , z. weihong , and r.r.p .
singh , phys .
lett . * 85 * , 4373 ( 2000 ) .
schmidt , c. knetter , m. grninger , and g.s .
uhrig , phys .
rev . lett . * 90 * , 167201 ( 2003 ) .
s. brehmer , h .- j .
mikeska , m. mller , n. nagaosa , and s. uchida , phys .
b * 60 * , 329 ( 1999 ) .
e. mller - hartmann and a. reischl , eur .
j. b * 28 * , 173 ( 2002 ) .
y. mizuno , t. tohyama and s. maekawa , j. phys .
jpn * 66 * , 397 ( 1997 ) .
schmidt and y. kuramoto , physica c * 167 * , 263 ( 1990 ) .
m. takahashi , j. phys .
state phys .
* 10 * , 1289 ( 1977 ) .
a. h. macdonald , s. m. girvin , d. yoshioka , phys .
b * 41 * , 2565 ( 1990 ) .
m. roger and j.m .
delrieu , phys . rev .
b * 39 * , 2299 ( 1989 ) .
a. reischl , e. mller - hartmann , g.s .
uhrig , phys .
b * 70 * , 245124 ( 2004 )
singh , p.a .
fleury , k.b .
lyons , and p.e .
sulewski , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 2736 ( 1989 ) .
canali and s.m .
girvin , phys .
b * 45 * , 7127 ( 1992 ) .
y. honda , y. kuramoto , and t. watanabe , phys .
b * 47 * , 11329 ( 1993 ) .
sandvik , s. capponi , d. poilblanc , and e. dagotto , phys .
b * 57 * , 8478 ( 1998 ) .
katanin , and a.p .
kampf , phys .
b * 67 * , 100404(r ) ( 2003 ) .
j. erole , c.d .
batista , s.b .
bacci , and e.r .
gagliano , phys .
b * 59 * , 1468 ( 1999 ) . m.j .
reilly and a.g .
rojo , phys .
b * 53 * , 6429 ( 1996 ) .
saenger , phys .
b * 52 * , 1025 ( 1995 ) .
w.h . weber and g.w .
ford , phys .
b * 40 * , 6890 ( 1989 ) .
s. haas , e. dagotto , j. riera , r. merlin , and f. nori , j. appl .
* 75 * , 6340 ( 1994 ) .
f. nori , r. merlin , s. haas , a.w .
sandvik , and e. dagotto , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 553 ( 1995 ) .
chubukov , and d.m .
frenkel , phys .
. lett . * 74 * , 3057 ( 1995 ) .
f. schnfeld , a.p .
kampf , and e. mller - hartmann , z. phys .
b * 102 * , 25 ( 1997 ) .
d.k . morr and a.v .
chubukov , phys .
b * 56 * , 9134 ( 1997 ) . c. jurecka , v. grtzun , a. friedrich , and w. brenig , eur .
j. b * 21 * , 469 ( 2001 ) .
y. natsuma , y. watabe and t. suzuki , phys .
japan * 67 * , 3314 ( 1998 ) .
m. matsuda , k. katsumata , r.s .
eccleston , s. brehmer , and h.j .
mikeska , j. appl .
87 * , 6271 ( 2000 ) .
m. matsuda , k. katsumata , r.s .
eccleston , s. brehmer , and h .- j .
mikeska , phys .
b * 62 * , 8903 ( 2000 ) .
sr14 has intrinsically six holes per unit cell , but it is believed that the majority of the holes are located in the chain subsystem ( see ref . ) .
n. ncker , m. merz , c. a. kuntscher , s. gerhold , s. schuppler , r. neudert , m.s .
golden , j. fink , d. schild , s. stadler , v. chakarian , j. freeland , y.u .
idzerda , k. conder , m. uehara , t. nagata , j. goto , j. akimitsu , n. motoyama , h. eisaki , s. uchida , u. ammerahl , and a. revcolevschi , phys .
b * 62 * , 14384 ( 2000 ) . neglecting the two - spin exchange terms along the diagonals ,
our notation @xmath139 is given in terms of the other notation @xmath140 using cyclic permutations by @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath143 ( see ref . ) .
p.a . fleury and r. loudon ,
* 166 * , 514 ( 1968 ) .
shastry and b.i .
shraiman , phys .
lett . * 65 * , 1068 ( 1990 ) . c. knetter and g.s .
uhrig , eur .
j. b * 13 * , 209 ( 2000 ) . c. knetter , k.p .
schmidt , and g.s .
uhrig , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 36 * , 7889 ( 2003 ) . c. knetter , k.p .
schmidt , and g.s .
uhrig , eur .
j. b * 36 * , 525 ( 2004 ) .
schmidt , c. knetter , and g.s .
uhrig , acta physica polonica b * 34 * , 1481 ( 2003 ) .
schmidt , h. monien , and g.s .
uhrig , phys .
b * 67 * , 184413 ( 2003 ) . c. domb and j.l
lebowitz , _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , academic press , new york , vol . 13 ( 1989 ) .
schmidt , phd thesis , university of cologne ( 2004 ) .
a. lffert , c. gross , and w. assmus , j. cryst .
growth 237 , 796 ( 2002 ) .
choi , y.s .
lee , t.w .
noh , e.j .
choi , y. bang , and y.j .
kim phys .
b * 60 * , 4646 ( 1999 ) .
the extrapolation of the matrix elements are relatively accurate .
the maximum deviation between the two - triplon widths in both polarizations is @xmath144 for @xmath145 .
the one - triplon hopping elements yield a quantitative one - triplon dispersion when compared to dmrg data ( see ref . ) .
so we conclude that the largest extrapolation error is due to the extrapolation of the two - triplon interaction amplitudes . to get an estimate of this error we compared the energy of the @xmath30 two - triplon bound state at finite momentum for @xmath109 obtained by dmrg with the results of the cut .
then we changed the two - triplon interaction for the raman case by the maximum deviation of the bound state energies and calculated the effect on the fwhm of the two - triplon peak . in the end
we added @xmath144 to account for the uncertainty of the matrix elements .
the resulting uncertainties are shown as error bars in fig .
[ fig : fwhm ] .
calzado , c. de graaf , e. bordas , r. caballol , and j - p .
malrieu , phys .
b * 67 * , 132409 ( 2003 ) .
m. windt , phd thesis , university of cologne ( 2003 ) .
eccleston , m. uehara , j. akimitsu , h. eisaki , n. motoyama , and s .-
uchida , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 1702 ( 1998 ) .
d. salamon , ran liu , m.v .
klein , m.a .
karlow , s.l .
cooper , s - w .
cheong , w.c .
lee and d.m .
ginsberg , phys .
b * 51 * , 6617 ( 1995 )
hsu , phys .
b * 41 * , 11379 ( 1990 ) .
wang , phys .
* , r13774 ( 1991 ) .
m. windt , m. grninger , t. nunner , c. knetter , k.p .
schmidt , g.s .
uhrig , t. kopp , a. freimuth , u. ammerahl , b. bchner , and a. revcolevschi , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 127002 ( 2001 ) .
freitas and r.r.p .
singh , phys .
b * 62 * , 5525 ( 2000 ) .
y. endoh , k. yamada , r.j .
birgeneau , d.r .
gabbe , h.p .
jenssen , m.a .
kastner , c.j .
peters , p.j .
picone , t.r .
thurston , j.m .
tranquada , g. shirane , y. hidaka , m. oda , y. enomoto , m. suzuki , and t. murakami , phys .
b * 37 * , 7443 ( 1988 ) .
s. chakravarty , b.i .
halperin , and d.r .
nelson , phys .
b * 39 * , 2344 ( 1989 ) . and
b. dabrowski , phys . rev .
b * 49 * , r13295 ( 1994 ) .
j. lorenzana and g.a .
sawatzky , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 1867 ( 1995 ) .
j. lorenzana and g.a .
sawatzky , phys .
b * 52 * , 9576 ( 1995 ) . | an unified picture for the raman response of magnetic excitations in cuprate spin - ladder compounds is obtained by comparing calculated two - triplon raman line - shapes with those of the prototypical compounds srcu@xmath0o@xmath1 ( sr123 ) , sr@xmath2cu@xmath3o@xmath4 ( sr14 ) , and la@xmath5ca@xmath6cu@xmath3o@xmath4 ( la6ca8 ) .
the theoretical model for the two - leg ladder contains heisenberg exchange couplings @xmath7 and @xmath8 plus an additional four - spin interaction @xmath9 . within this model sr123 and sr14
can be described by @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 @xmath13 and @xmath14 @xmath13 .
the couplings found for la6ca8 are @xmath15 , @xmath16 , and @xmath17 @xmath13 .
the unexpected sharp two - triplon peak in the ladder materials compared to the undoped two - dimensional cuprates can be traced back to the anisotropy of the magnetic exchange in rung and leg direction . with the results obtained for the isotropic ladder we calculate the raman line - shape of a two - dimensional square lattice using a toy model consisting of a vertical and a horizontal ladder .
a direct comparison of these results with raman experiments for the two - dimensional cuprates r@xmath0cuo@xmath18 ( r = la , nd ) , sr@xmath0cuo@xmath0cl@xmath0 , and yba@xmath0cu@xmath1o@xmath19 yields a good agreement for the dominating two - triplon peak .
we conclude that short range quantum fluctuations are dominating the magnetic raman response in both , ladders and planes .
we discuss possible scenarios responsible for the high - energy spectral weight of the raman line - shape , i.e. phonons , the triple - resonance and multi - particle contributions . |
since its discovery , spin glass has been considered as a third distinct type of low - temperature magnetic arrangement in solids , in addition to ferromagnetic and anti - ferromagnetic @xcite . in spin glass , spins are disordered , prompting the term `` glass '' , and give zero net magnetic moment .
great theoretical effort went into understanding the nature of the spin glass transition .
the collection of new ideas and theories has formed a new large research field in condensed matter physics , with connections proposed to other disciplines such as economics and biology @xcite .
a couple of decades ago , it was remarked that `` as fame and topicality diminish , the problem remains an interesting , yet pass , research topic '' @xcite .
one of the reasons for continued interest in this area is the presence of fundamental theoretical problems that are not resolved .
there is also current interest in new systems such as magnetic nanoparticles , ferrofluids , relaxor ferroelectrics and so on , where spin glass behavior is observed .
the main signature of the spin glass transition is the susceptibility cusp , which is considered to mark the transition from the paramagnetic to the spin glass phase @xcite .
the temperature at which the cusp develops is called spin glass transition temperature , @xmath3 ( or @xmath4 )
. the susceptibility cusp has stimulated approaches to spin glass transition based on the existence of a phase transition at @xmath3 , between the high - temperature paramagnetic phase and a novel low - temperature `` spin glass '' phase .
this was primarily inspired by the phase transition theory , centered at the changes of system properties at the phase transition temperature @xcite .
the traditional phase transition theory requires the presence of two distinct phases on both sides of the phase transition @xcite . on the other hand , as detailed studies revealed
, there is no obvious distinct second phase in the spin glass transition : the structure of the low - temperature spin - glass phase is not different from the high - temperature paramagnetic phase , and is equally disordered .
the absence of a second phase presents a problem with viewing spin glass transition as a phase transition , resulting in persisting difficulties and controversies @xcite . to circumvent the problem , popular theories introduced and discussed novel non - conventional order parameters @xcite while retaining the view that a phase transition of some sort takes place .
an advantage of this approach is that well - established methods of statistical mechanics can be used to calculate system equilibrium properties and their derivatives such as susceptibility .
such was the edwards - anderson ( ea ) theory @xcite which introduced the new order parameter for spin glass : @xmath5 , where superscripts @xmath6 and @xmath7 denote two different moments of time for spin @xmath8 .
as introduced , @xmath9 serves to quantify the difference between the mobile spins in the paramagnetic phase and the frozen spins in the glass phase at @xmath3 .
notably , @xmath9 describes the change in dynamic behaviour but not the difference between two distinct equilibrium phases as in the conventional phase transition theory .
the important next step in the ea theory is the substitution of the time average by the ensemble average , by making an assumption that the system is in equilibrium and is ergodic .
subsequently , statistical mechanics is used to calculate system s equilibrium thermodynamic functions .
the ea theory was followed by numerous theoretical studies that introduced new ideas , concepts and novel mathematical frameworks aimed at clarifying and understanding the unconventional nature of the spin - glass phase transition , the low - temperature phase and the ea order parameter @xcite .
importantly , similar to the ea theory , current approaches are based on the existence of a second distinct spin glass phase and a phase transition of some sort , and discuss the associated order parameters .
consequently , the predominant current view is that spin glass transition is a thermodynamic phase transition , even though unconventional @xcite .
several outstanding problems remain with the phase transition approach .
an essential problem rests with identifying the nature of the spin glass phase .
this begs the important question of whether experimental data can be understood without making the assumption that a distinct spin glass phase exists .
another important issue is the conflict between theory and experiments @xcite .
experiments widely show strong dynamic effects . @xmath3
significantly increases with field frequency , or as observation time decreases @xcite .
this is inconsistent with a transition between two equilibrium phases @xcite .
we note at this point that the same effect is seen in the liquid - glass ( structural ) transition @xcite .
in addition to the susceptibility cusp , other properties of spin glass systems have been studied , but have not lead to a conclusive evidence for a phase transition @xcite .
for example , magnetic heat capacity shows no anomaly at @xmath3 , unlike in a phase transition @xcite . on the other hand ,
the behavior of non - linear susceptibility , @xmath10 , above @xmath3 is interpreted to be consistent with critical scaling and is taken as evidence for the static phase transition at @xmath3 @xcite .
this conclusion is shared by most authors @xcite , although others are more cautious @xcite .
it is noted that scaling exists away from @xmath3 only , but fails close to @xmath3 where @xmath10 flattens off , inconsistent with a phase transition picture @xcite .
there are other problems with analyzing this and other similar scaling data : first , the choice of @xmath3 is arbitrary because @xmath3 is not fixed but depends on observation time , introducing arbitrariness in the scaling analysis .
this applies not only to the interpretation of experiments , but also to extensive simulations of spin glasses @xcite .
in particular , as larger times are accessed in the simulations , @xmath3 decreases as expected from the experiments , altering critical exponents , lower critical dimension and so on @xcite , and thus suggesting that no firm values of these quantities can be asserted .
second , a phase transition is accompanied by the scaling behavior , but the opposite does not generally need to be the case .
consequently , the scaling behavior is seen in spin glass simulations where the phase transition is known to be absent @xcite , weakening the evidence for a phase transition from the scaling data . finally , the system is not in equilibrium at and below @xmath3 , so it is not known that the scaling data are related to a new phase @xcite .
we note that slow non - equilibrium relaxation effects could precede a true phase transition as well ( eg paramagnetic to ferromagnetic ) , however in this case the presence of the distinct low - temperature phase is known experimentally .
the non - equilibrium state of the spin glass system generally complicates the approach based on a phase transition . in both experiments and simulations , relaxation time @xmath2 continuously increases on lowering the temperature @xcite , as is the case in the structural glass transition . at a certain temperature ,
@xmath2 exceeds observation time , at which point the system falls out of equilibrium .
this presents a problem for understanding experimental systems using statistical mechanics @xcite .
this problem and other issues discussed above , including the increase of @xmath3 with field frequency , remain unresolved at present @xcite .
notably , profound non - equilibrium dynamic effects as well as thermodynamic anomalies are observed in both spin and structural glass transitions .
interestingly , the current view of the two phenomena is markedly different .
the predominant opinion is that the structural glass transition is not a phase transition , and is a purely dynamic effect despite the heat capacity jump at @xmath3 @xcite .
the current view also holds that the spin glass transition is a phase transition , the unconventionality of which comes from the dynamic effects @xcite . for example
, mydosh asks : `` how can we get rid of the dynamical processes to determine the basic properties of the underlying phase transition ? at present an answer has not yet appeared '' @xcite . in this paper , we propose that instead of attempting to get rid of universal and profound dynamic effects in order to discuss the underlying phase transition , a more fruitful approach is to consider that the dynamic effects are at the heart of the spin glass transition . in this approach , we explore whether the main experimental results can be understood in an entirely dynamic picture .
contrary to the assumption currently held @xcite , we propose that paramagnetic and spin glass states are qualitatively the same .
consequently , we do not discuss a phase transition of some sort , and therefore do not face complications and controversies surrounding the nature of the spin glass phase and a phase transition @xcite .
we propose that the central experimental result , the susceptibility cusp , necessarily originates when a system stops relaxing at the experimental time scale . in this picture
, the observed cusp marks the _ crossover _ that separates two time regimes , high - temperature relaxational regime @xmath11 and low - temperature spin wave regime @xmath12 , where @xmath1 is the observation time and @xmath2 is system relaxation time .
time - dependent effects , inconsistent with the phase transition approach , and the logarithmic increase of @xmath3 with field frequency in particular , originate as the immediate consequence of the proposed picture .
our proposal thus represents a new outlook at the problem in which the experimental data can be interpreted in a way that is simpler and more physically transparent , an attractive possibility in view of persisting difficulties and controversies in the field . in our discussion , we explore close parallels between the spin glass transition and the structural glass transition .
importantly , we do so opposite to the historical trend when the insights from the existing spin glass theories were used to understand the structural glass transition ( see , e.g. , refs .
these previous approaches invoked the concepts from the spin glass transition theories based on phase transitions and subsequently applied them to the structural glass transition .
consequently , the structural glass transition was related to a phase transition of some sort . on the other hand ,
we start from a recent picture which explains the structural glass transition as a purely dynamic phenomenon , without any reference to a distinct solid glass phase or a phase transition @xcite .
we subsequently propose that the spin glass transition can equally be understood as a purely dynamic phenomenon .
the next section outlines the recent dynamic approach to structural glass transition , followed by our proposal that the same general idea can be used to understand the spin glass transition .
in the field of spin glass transition , the most commonly discussed effect is the cusp of susceptibility at @xmath3 . in the area of structural glass transition @xcite , the response of a system
is measured to the heat flow , and is quantified by heat capacity .
if a liquid avoids crystallization on cooling , the heat capacity changes with a jump at the glass transition temperature @xmath3 . for various liquids , @xmath13 @xcite , where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are constant - pressure liquid and glass heat capacities , respectively .
the jump of @xmath16 provides one definition of @xmath3 at which the glass is said to form .
because above and below @xmath3 the system structure is equally disordered , the jump of @xmath16 immediately presents a problem that is at the heart of glass transition @xcite : how can the jump be understood if there is no distinct second phase ?
this problem remains unresolved , resulting in several important and interesting controversies @xcite .
one set of theories rationalize the jump of heat capacity by relating it to the existence of a phase transition and using the concepts from the phase transitions theory .
this approach has been convincingly criticized for a number of reasons ( see , e.g. , ref .
perhaps the most important reason is that it has not been possible to identify a distinct low - temperature phase , the glass phase . to get round this problem ,
several theories have put forward the proposals about the non - conventional mechanisms of the phase transition and non - trivial descriptions of the second phase , while retaining the idea of a phase transition in general @xcite .
another set of glass transition theories maintain that glass transition phenomena at @xmath3 have purely dynamic origin , corresponding to the freezing of atomic jumps in a liquid at the experimental time scale @xcite .
the assumed absence of a phase transition and thermodynamic anomalies is supported by the wide experimental observation that the liquid and the glass structures at @xmath3 are nearly identical @xcite . however , the challenge for these theories is to explain the origin of the heat capacity jump at @xmath3 as well as its large magnitude , which can be of the order of @xmath17 per atom .
we have recently proposed @xcite how to explain the jump of heat capacity in a purely dynamic picture , without asserting the existence of a distinct phase and a phase transition of some sort and , therefore , showed how to reconcile the above contradiction .
we recall that glass transition temperature @xmath3 has two experimental definitions which give similar values of @xmath3 . in the calorimetry experiments , @xmath3 is the temperature at which the jump of @xmath16 is measured . in the experiments that measure liquid relaxation time @xmath2 ( e.g. dielectric relaxation experiments ) , @xmath3 is the temperature at which @xmath2 exceeds the experimental time @xmath1 of typically @xmath18 s @xcite .
we proposed that when @xmath2 exceeds @xmath1 , the jump of heat capacity at @xmath3 follows as a necessary consequence due to the change of liquid elastic , vibrational and thermal properties including the bulk modulus and thermal expansion .
therefore , the jump of @xmath16 at @xmath3 is the result of the dynamic crossover rather than a phase transition .
consequently , there is no need to invoke a second glass phase , a phase transition of some sort and face associated problems .
we first discuss why and how liquid thermal expansion coefficient @xmath19 and bulk modulus @xmath20 change at @xmath3 . unlike in a solid , atoms in a liquid are not fixed , but rearrange in space .
this gives the liquid its ability to flow .
each flow event is a jump of an atom from its surrounding atomic `` cage '' , accompanied by large - scale rearrangement of the cage atoms .
we call this process a local relaxation event ( lre ) .
a lre lasts on the order of elementary ( debye ) vibration period @xmath21 ps .
frenkel introduced liquid relaxation time @xmath2 as the time between lres in a liquid at one point in space @xcite .
smaller and larger @xmath2 correspond to smaller and larger liquid viscosities , respectively . basing on this property only , frenkel concluded that at short times @xmath12 , liquid response is the same as that of a solid , i.e. is purely elastic . on the other hand , for @xmath11 , viscous liquid flow takes place , during which each lre gives the additional , viscous , displacement .
hence , for @xmath11 , liquid response to external perturbation ( e.g. pressure ) consists of both elastic and viscous response @xcite .
this picture provided the microscopic basis for the earlier phenomenological model of maxwell @xcite , who proposed to separate elastic and viscous response in his viscoelastic approach to liquids .
lets consider that a liquid is subject to pressure @xmath22 .
pressure induces a certain number of lres , which bring the liquid to equilibrium at new external conditions ( @xmath22 , @xmath23 ) after time @xmath2 .
as follows from the maxwell - frenkel approach , the change of liquid volume , @xmath24 , is @xmath25 , where @xmath26 and @xmath27 correspond to solid - like elastic deformation and viscous relaxation process due to lres , respectively .
lets define @xmath3 as the temperature at which @xmath2 exceeds the observation time @xmath1 .
this implies that lres do not operate at @xmath3 during the time of observation .
therefore , @xmath24 at @xmath3 is given by purely elastic displacement as in elastic solid .
then , @xmath28 and @xmath29 above and below @xmath3 , respectively , where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are bulk moduli of the liquid and the glass , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are initial volumes of the liquid and the glass , and @xmath34 is the elastic deformation of the glass .
let @xmath35 be a narrow temperature interval that separates the liquid from the glass so that @xmath2 in the liquid , @xmath36 , is @xmath37 and @xmath38 . then , @xmath39 and @xmath40 . combining the expressions for @xmath30 and @xmath31
, we find : @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the ratio of relaxational and elastic response to pressure .
the relationship between @xmath43 and @xmath44 can be calculated in a similar way , giving @xcite : @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the ratio of relaxational and elastic response to temperature .
( [ 2],[3 ] ) describe the relationships between @xmath20 and @xmath19 in the liquid and the glass due to the presence of lres in the liquid above @xmath3 and their absence in the glass at and below @xmath3 , as long as @xmath3 is the temperature at which @xmath12 .
we note that @xmath31 and @xmath44 can be called unrelaxed , or non - equilibrium values , of bulk modulus and thermal expansion , respectively , because relaxational response @xmath27 in the glass decays during time @xmath2 .
we now relate the jump of constant - pressure heat capacity , @xmath16 , to the corresponding changes of @xmath19 and @xmath20 at @xmath3 .
we write @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the constant - volume heat capacity .
we note that @xmath48 around @xmath3 , or at any temperature where @xmath49 , is essentially due to the vibrational motion because the relative number of diffusing atoms is proportional to @xmath50 , and is therefore negligibly small @xcite . using the grneisen approximation ,
we have shown that @xmath51 @xcite . as discussed above ,
@xmath19 and @xmath20 are different above @xmath3 when @xmath11 and below @xmath3 when @xmath12 ( see eqs .
( [ 2]-[3 ] ) ) .
therefore , the two different time regimes give different values of @xmath16 : @xmath52 @xmath53 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 refer to liquid and glass , respectively .
( [ 31]-[32 ] ) relate the change of heat capacity to the changes of @xmath19 and @xmath20 due to the presence of relaxational response in the liquid and its absence in the glass . using the experimental values of @xmath44 , @xmath43 , @xmath31 and @xmath30
, we have shown that the calculated values of the liquid and glass @xmath54 according to eqs .
( [ 31],[32 ] ) are in reasonable agreement with the experimental @xmath54 @xcite .
importantly , the jump of heat capacity at @xmath3 in our theory takes place within the same single thermodynamic liquid phase , but below and above @xmath3 the liquid is characterized by different values of @xmath19 and @xmath20 due to the freezing of lres at @xmath3 where the liquid falls out of equilibrium . therefore , our theory is purely dynamic .
in contrast to previous theories of glass transition @xcite , we do not discuss transitions between distinct thermodynamic phases , even though it may be tempting to invoke phase transitions , conventional or unconventional , in order to explain the origin of heat capacity jump . instead , the jump of heat capacity in this picture is due to the _ crossover _ between two different regimes , relaxational regime above @xmath3 and elastic regime below @xmath3 . as we have shown earlier
, the crossover may be sharp enough if small variations of temperature around @xmath3 give large changes of @xmath2 , leading to the freezing of lres in a narrow temperature range and giving the appearance of a phase transition @xcite . as discussed in ref .
@xcite in detail , our theory predicts no difference of @xmath16 between the liquid and the glass at long times when both systems are in equilibrium . in this case ,
@xmath55 and @xmath56 , giving @xmath57 .
we note that reaching such an equilibrium state for common glasses can take astronomical times and longer .
for example , lets consider sio@xmath58 glass at room temperature @xmath59=300 k. the activation energy barrier @xmath60 can be assumed constant , because sio@xmath58 is a `` strong '' liquid @xcite .
then , combining @xmath61 and @xmath62 , we write @xmath63 . taking @xmath640.1 ps , @xmath65 k and @xmath66 s , we find @xmath67 s , approximately the fourth power of the age of the universe .
although solid for any practical purpose , sio@xmath58 at room temperature is an equilibrium liquid during times @xmath68 .
consequently , it shows no jump of heat capacity on cooling from high temperature if @xmath68 .
the dynamic origin of the jump of @xmath16 at @xmath3 in our theory explains a well - known effect that @xmath3 logarithmically increases with the quench rate @xmath69 , where @xmath35 is the temperature interval above @xmath3 ( see , e.g. , refs .
according to our theory , the jump of heat capacity at @xmath3 takes place when the observation time @xmath1 crosses relaxation time @xmath2 .
this implies that @xmath2 at which the jump of heat capacity takes place is @xmath70 .
combining this with @xmath71 ( here @xmath60 is nearly constant because @xmath2 is approximately arrhenius around @xmath3 @xcite ) gives @xmath72 according to eq .
( [ log ] ) , @xmath3 increases with the logarithm of @xmath9 , as widely observed in the experiments .
furthermore , the dependence of @xmath3 on @xmath9 is consistent with the experimental results @xcite ) .
this is the immediate and important result of our theory .
we note that eq .
( [ log ] ) predicts no divergence of @xmath3 because the maximal physically possible quench rate is set by the minimal elementary time @xmath73 ( debye vibration period ) so that @xmath74 is always larger than @xmath9 in eq .
( [ log ] ) .
our main proposal is that , similar to the jump of @xmath20 , @xmath19 and @xmath16 in the structural glass transition , the susceptibility cusp in the spin glass transition is not related to the existence of a distinct spin glass phase and a phase transition of any sort .
instead , we propose that the cusp is the result of the _ crossover _ between the two regimes , the high - temperature relaxational regime and low - temperature spin wave elastic - like regime , when observation time @xmath1 exceeds system relaxation time @xmath2 . in this picture , the crossover is a purely dynamic effect that takes place within the same single phase .
similar to liquids , we define @xmath2 as the time between two consecutive spin jumps ( large - scale spin rearrangements in classical picture or transitions between states with different spin quantum numbers ) that play the role of lres in a liquid . when @xmath11 at high temperature , spin lres are operative , governing the dynamics of the system . in this regime ,
the system is in equilibrium that is equivalent to the equilibrium relaxational state in a liquid at @xmath75 .
consequently , the equilibrium statistical mechanics can be applied to spin lres . in a two - level system of non - interacting spins ,
the free energy is @xcite : @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the spin magnetic moment , @xmath78 is the applied field and @xmath79 .
the magnetic moment @xmath80 , which at high temperature becomes @xmath81 , giving curie law for susceptibility @xmath82 : @xmath83 curie behaviour of @xmath84 is observed in spin glass systems at high temperature @xcite . on temperature decrease
, a spin - glass system can not find an ordered state due to frustration related to disorder of various types @xcite . if @xmath60 is the activation barrier for a spin rearrangement , @xmath85 , where @xmath73 is the elementary vibration period .
@xmath60 can be temperature - dependent , as discussed in the next section .
hence , @xmath2 continuously increases on lowering the temperature until condition @xmath11 is violated at a certain temperature , @xmath3 .
when @xmath0 at @xmath3 , spin lres become frozen at the experimental time scale .
at this point , the system falls out of equilibrium and becomes non - ergodic .
consequently , eqs .
( [ fcurie ] ) and ( [ claw ] ) do not apply at and below @xmath3 .
the remaining excitations in the system are spin waves . associated , in classical representation , with small - amplitude spin displacements @xcite , spin waves carry thermal energy in an interacting system , ordered or disordered . in spin glasses , spin waves
are analogues of elastic waves propagating in glasses or liquids @xcite , and can be similarly localized and damped at short wavelengths @xcite . at large wavelengths , spin waves in spin glasses have been predicted theoretically , with the linear dispersion @xmath86 , where @xmath87 is the speed of magnons @xcite .
this has subsequently been confirmed in theoretical studies @xcite , simulations @xcite and experiments @xcite .
we note that spin waves are present above @xmath3 as well @xcite but this does not alter our main results because spin waves become increasingly damped at high temperature @xcite .
unlike magnetic lres that fall out of equilibrium at @xmath3 , the gas of magnons is in thermal equilibrium .
similar to the free energy of phonons @xcite , the free energy of non - interacting magnons is : @xmath88 where @xmath89 are magnon frequencies and @xmath90 is the zero - point energy . magnetic moment and susceptibility due to spin waves , @xmath91 , have been calculated for ordered magnetic structures .
for example , using the dependence of magnon frequencies in a ferromagnet on external field @xmath78 , @xmath92 , where @xmath93 is the exchange parameter , @xmath94 is spin and @xmath95 is lattice constant in eq .
( [ free ] ) , gives bloch law : @xmath96 @xcite . on the other hand ,
@xmath91 has not been calculated for spin glasses . from eq .
( [ free ] ) , @xmath91 is @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the susceptibility due to zero - point vibrations . for spin glasses , field dependencies of @xmath89
can be taken as @xmath99 and @xmath100 , where @xmath101 and @xmath102 are longitudinal and transverse waves , respectively @xcite .
this gives @xmath103 and @xmath104 for small fields ( @xmath105 ) at which @xmath84 is measured in spin glasses @xcite .
next , the linear @xmath106 relationship for small fields implies the quadratic density of states , @xmath107 , as for phonons .
@xmath108 , where @xmath109 is debye frequency and the normalization coefficient takes into account that @xmath110 transverse waves contribute to the sums in eq .
( [ free1 ] ) because field derivatives of the longitudinal frequency are zero and hence do not contribute to @xmath91 . using the above field derivatives , substituting the sums in eq .
( [ free1 ] ) with integrals with @xmath107 and noting that integration can be extended to @xmath111 at low temperature due to the fast convergence of the integrals , we find : @xmath112 where @xmath113 is debye temperature of spin waves .
we find , therefore , that @xmath91 is quadratic with temperature and approaches constant value @xmath98 at @xmath114 , consistent with experimental results ( see , e.g. , refs @xcite ) .
interestingly , the same behaviour ( quadratic at low temperature and temperature - independent at @xmath114 ) was found in the ea theory based on the description of the spin glass transition in terms of a phase transition and order parameters @xcite .
we note that the approximations used above , including the limit of zero @xmath78 and the dependence of @xmath115 on @xmath116 and @xmath78 , may affect the low - temperature behavior of @xmath84 .
however , it is clear that the behavior of @xmath91 below @xmath3 is qualitatively different from @xmath117 above @xmath3 due to a different mechanism of magnetic response .
as long as spin lres are operative and in equilibrium when @xmath11 , eqs .
( [ fcurie ] ) and ( [ claw ] ) apply .
this gives @xmath118 in the long - time relaxational regime above @xmath3 : @xmath119 regime ( [ curie ] ) is equivalent to the high - temperature regime in the structural glass transition where lres in a liquid are in equilibrium when @xmath11 . on the other hand , when @xmath12 in the short - time spin - wave regime , magnetic response is governed by eqs .
( [ free ] ) and ( [ waves ] ) .
this gives @xmath120 at and below @xmath3 : @xmath121 therefore , we find that temperature decrease results in the dynamic _ crossover _ between the two regimes , relaxational ( [ curie ] ) and spin - wave regime ( [ sw ] ) .
this crossover is analogous to the crossover between relaxational and elastic regime in liquids , see eqs .
( [ 31 ] ) and ( [ 32 ] ) .
we propose that the experimental susceptibility cusp is due to this crossover .
we make two further observations supporting this proposal .
first , we show that the crossover at @xmath3 can be fairly sharp , giving the appearance of a `` cusp '' characteristic of true phase transitions .
we identified spin glass systems for which the temperature dependence of @xmath2 has been measured , and selected several representative systems in a wide range of @xmath3 between about 3 k and 300 k ( see table 1 ) . in refs .
@xcite , @xmath2 has been fitted to the vogel - fulcher - tammann ( vft ) law : @xmath122 . using the dependence @xmath123
, we calculate what temperature increase above @xmath3 , @xmath124 , is needed in order to reduce @xmath2 by an order of magnitude : @xmath125 .
@xmath124 gives an estimation of the temperature range in which the predicted crossover between the high - temperature relaxational regime above @xmath3 and low - temperature spin - wave regime at @xmath3 operates .
the values of both @xmath4 and @xmath126 are given in table 1 .
we also list parameters @xmath127 , @xmath128 and @xmath3 used in the calculation . .@xmath3 ,
@xmath124 and @xmath129 for several spin - glass systems .
[ cols= " < , < , < , < , < , < , < " , ]
as in structural glass transition , two main effects that set in above @xmath3 in spin glass systems are the vft law mentioned above and stretched - exponential relaxation ( ser ) . in liquids , slow relaxation sets in at high temperature @xmath130 where @xmath2 is on the order of picoseconds @xcite . above @xmath130 ,
relaxation is exponential .
it was assumed or postulated that ser is due to some sort of cooperativity of molecular relaxation in a liquid that sets in on temperature decrease , but the physical origin of cooperativity has remained unknown . we have recently proposed @xcite that the physical origin of the vft law and ser in a liquid is the elastic _ interaction _ between lres .
large atomic displacements due to the lre distort the surrounding liquid and induce elastic waves .
the wave frequency , @xmath115 , is on the order of debye frequency because the wavelength is on the order of interatomic separations , implying that @xmath131 in the range of @xmath2 relevant for glass transition .
as discussed by frenkel @xcite , waves with frequency @xmath131 propagate in a liquid as in a solid .
the waves distort cages around other lre centres in the liquid , and therefore affect their relaxation .
hence , we identified elastic waves as the physical mechanism of mediating interaction , and proposed @xcite that this interaction sets the cooperativity of relaxation whose origin was discussed @xcite but not understood from the physical point of view . the key question is the range of this interaction .
as discussed in detail @xcite , this range is given by @xmath132 : @xmath133 where @xmath87 is the speed of sound .
the non - trivial point is that @xmath134 _ increases _ with @xmath2 .
this is directly opposite to the commonly discussed decay of hydrodynamic waves , whose propagation range varies as @xmath135 .
the difference is due to the solid - like regime of wave propagation , @xmath136 , which is qualitatively different from the hydrodynamic regime , @xmath137 .
we called @xmath132 liquid elasticity length because it defines the range over which two lres interact with each other via induced elastic waves .
importantly , @xmath134 _ increases _ on lowering the temperature because @xmath2 increases .
we proposed that this is the key to the origin of slow relaxation , the vft law @xcite as well as ser @xcite .
as such , the above mechanism is general enough to describe relaxation in any dynamic system where local entities relax and induce mediating waves ( elastic , spin or other ) that affect relaxation of other entities in the system .
hence , we propose that the same mechanism operates in spin glass systems . here , a localized spin rearrangement induces a spin wave that affects relaxation of other spins in the system .
when @xmath138 , where @xmath139 is the characteristic distance between the neighbouring spins , spin lres do not interact , resulting in exponential and arrhenius relaxation as expected .
however , when @xmath140 on lowering the temperature , interaction between spin lres sets in .
similar to liquids , we propose that this interaction is responsible for the vft law and ser seen in spin glass systems @xcite .
( [ del ] ) predicts that , similarly to liquids @xcite , two dynamic crossovers in spin glass systems operate at @xmath141 and @xmath142 , where @xmath87 is the speed of spin wave and @xmath143 is system size .
the first crossover is from exponential ( non - cooperative ) to non - exponential ( cooperative ) relaxation .
the second crossover is from the vft to a more arrhenius relaxation when @xmath132 reaches system size @xmath143 @xcite .
in contrast to structural glass transition , the dynamic crossovers in spin glass systems have not been experimentally studied in detail .
therefore , our prediction can be investigated in future high - temperature experiments in spin glass systems .
we note that this picture predicts that @xmath2 and @xmath3 increase with @xmath143 when @xmath144 , provided that the thermalization length of the spin wave is larger than @xmath132 .
seen in supercooled liquids @xcite , this effect is also seen in spin glass systems @xcite .
consistent with the proposed picture , it also supports the possibility of the second crossover at @xmath142 .
in this paper , we have proposed to take a new outlook at the spin glass transition problem , in view of persisting difficulties and controversies in the field .
we proposed to interpret existing and future experimental data in a way that is simpler and more physically transparent .
there is certainly more work to be done to clarify how the proposed ideas apply to the wealth of spin glass systems and phenomena .
we have argued that the structural and spin glass transition are similar , but in a different way than previously thought . instead of asserting that the spin glass transition is related to a phase transition and order parameters and rolling out this approach to the structural glass transition @xcite , we proposed that the structural glass transition can be understood as an entirely dynamic phenomenon , and subsequently suggested that equally can the spin glass transition .
we generally remark that a phase transition between two distinct equilibrium phases results in the change of system properties , a well - studied and understood topic in physics @xcite .
however , there are many examples , including in structural and spin glass transition , where the system equally changes many of its important properties at a certain temperature , yet the second phase and the order parameter are not apparent , the nature of the phase transition is not clear and the system shows profound dynamic effects .
we have proposed that in this case , the change of system properties can be understood as an entirely dynamic phenomenon with no reference to a phase transition of some sort and order parameters . in this simple picture ,
system properties change at the dynamic crossover when the system stops relaxing at the experimental time scale when @xmath0 . finally , we have explored closed similarities between relaxation properties of liquids and spin glass systems above @xmath3 and proposed that slow relaxation effects are due to interactions between spin lres via induced spin waves .
this can stimulate future experiments to study high - temperature relaxation effects in spin glass systems . | existing theories explain spin glass transition in terms of a phase transition and order parameters , and assume the existence of a distinct spin glass phase .
in addition to problems related to clarifying the nature of this phase , the common challenge is to explain profound dynamic effects . here , we propose that the main experimental results of spin glass transition can be understood in an entirely dynamic picture , without a reference to a distinct spin glass phase , phase transition and order parameters . in this theory , the susceptibility cusp at the glass transition temperature is due to the dynamic crossover between the high - temperature relaxational and low - temperature spin wave regime .
the crossover takes place when @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is observation time and @xmath2 is relaxation time .
time - dependent effects , inconsistent with the phase transition approach , and the logarithmic increase of @xmath3 with field frequency in particular , originate as the immediate consequence of the proposed picture . in our discussion , we explore similarities between the spin and structural glass transitions . |
mesonic lagrangians are often used to describe the decays and the spectral functions of resonances listed in the pdg @xcite .
such lagrangians make use of some symmetries of the underlying qcd ( such as flavor or chiral symmetry ) , e.g. chiral perturbation theory @xcite and ( extended ) sigma models @xcite . in particular , in the case of some enigmatic resonances , such as the light @xmath2 meson addressed in this work , the role of mesonic loops turns out to be extremely important , see e.g. refs .
@xcite and refs . therein .
yet , mesons are not elementary particles but are extended objects with a radius of about @xmath4 fm .
some type of form factor is needed . already in the @xmath5 model , e.g. ref .
@xcite , a form factor reducing the decay for increasing phase space is present .
this form factor is also useful when calculating quantum fluctuations ( loops ) , since all contributions become finite ( see sec .
it is possible to include a form factor directly in the lagrangian by using nonlocal interaction terms , e.g. refs .
in many studies of mesons , a 3d form factor is employed for simplicity .
this is usually regarded as a breaking of covariance . here
we discuss how to introduce nonlocal terms which deliver the desired 3d cutoff ( sec . 3 ) .
interestingly , an extension which preserves covariance is possible @xcite .
implications for the scalar kaonic sector and conclusions are discussed in sec .
in general , effective lagrangians contain both derivative and nonderivative interaction terms @xcite .
a prototype of such a lagrangian in which a ( scalar ) state @xmath6 interacts with two ( pseudoscalar ) particles @xmath7 and @xmath8 reads : @xmath9 the scalar kaonic sector is obtained upon identifying @xmath10 ( in first approximation corresponding to @xmath1 ) and @xmath11 and @xmath12 ( other isospin combinations are here neglected ) .
the tree - level decay width @xmath13 as function of the ` running ' mass @xmath14 of @xmath6 reads:@xmath15 ^{2}\text { , } % \ ] ] where @xmath16 is the mass of @xmath7 and @xmath17 the mass of @xmath8 .
the quantity @xmath18 is the modulus of the three - momentum of ( one of the ) outgoing particle(s):@xmath19 the actual value of the tree - level decay width is obtained by setting @xmath14 to the tree - level ( nominal ) mass @xmath20 of the field @xmath6 , @xmath21 the lagrangian ( [ laglocal ] ) as it stands is not suitable for loop calculations .
one can regularize the theory by considering an ` ad hoc ' modification of both vertices via a form factor:@xmath22 the quantity @xmath23 is often called ` cutoff ' ( a smooth cutoff here ) .
the choice of a gaussian is part of the modelling and is obviously not unique .
anyway , there is clear physical motivation behind @xmath23 : it is the energy scale which takes into account that mesons are extended objects .
the dimension of the system is roughly given by @xmath24 numerically @xmath23 lies between @xmath4 and @xmath25 gev @xcite .
the ` local ' limit is recovered for @xmath26 as a consequence of eq .
( [ abmod ] ) , the decay width changes as @xmath27 and is similar to the form factor implemented in the @xmath5 model ( see e.g. @xcite and the ` quark model ' review in ref .
@xcite ) .
the contribution of the loop @xmath28 in which the particles @xmath7 and @xmath8 circulate as calculated from the original local lagrangian ( [ laglocal ] ) reads@xmath29 ^{2}}{\left [ k_{1}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}% + i\varepsilon\right ] \left [ k_{2}^{2}-m_{2}^{2}+i\varepsilon\right ] } \text { , } % \ ] ] where the constraint @xmath30 is understood and @xmath31 is the momentum of the unstable particle @xmath32 in its reference frame @xmath33 as mentioned above , this loop contribution is divergent ( with @xmath34 ) .
the substitution ( [ abmod ] ) makes it convergent thanks to the form - factor:@xmath35 ^{2}f_{\lambda } ^{2}(\vec{k}_{1}^{2})}{\left [ k_{1}^{2}-m_{1}^{2}+i\varepsilon\right ] \left [ k_{2}^{2}-m_{2}^{2}+i\varepsilon\right ] } \text { . }
\label{looplambda}%\ ] ] at this point , one may object that the form factor breaks covariance , since it depends on the three - momentum only .
we will show in the next section that this is not necessarily the case .
once the form factor is introduced , the full propagator of the particle @xmath6 is calculated as @xmath36 ^{-1}$ ] where @xmath37 is the bare mass of @xmath6 and @xmath38 at the one - loop level , the breit - wigner mass of @xmath6 is defined as @xmath39 while the pole mass is obtained by solving the equation @xmath40 in the complex @xmath41-plane , see e.g. ref .
@xcite for the scalar @xmath42 and @xmath43 sectors .
the real part of the loop can be also obtained as @xmath44 where @xmath45 is an additional constant due to a subtlety of qft containing derivatives , see ref .
@xcite for details . for @xmath46 , @xmath47 scale as @xmath48 then a three - time subtracted dispersion relation would be needed .
this is quite cumbersome and reinforces the viewpoint that -for the particular case of hadronic physics- a physical cutoff is a meaningful procedure .
the modification of eq . ( [ abmod ] ) and , consequently , the form factor in eqs . ( [ gammalambda ] ) and ( [ looplambda ] )
have been introduced as an ` ad hoc ' change of the feynman rules .
yet , it is possible to modify the lagrangian in order that the modified equations automatically follows from it . * nonlocal extension 1 * : the easiest way ( see refs .
@xcite ) is to consider the following nonlocal lagrangian ( for simplicity we discuss here only the @xmath49-term in eq .
( [ laglocal ] ) , but the @xmath50-term is very similar):@xmath51 the feynman rule at the @xmath49-vertex is modified ( upon defining @xmath52 @xmath53 , hence : @xmath54 ) : @xmath55 for @xmath56 one reobtains the local limit .
a covariant form factor requires a dependence @xmath57 , hence @xmath58 follows . quite interestingly , if the masses of @xmath7 and @xmath8 are equal and on - shell , @xmath59 , in agreement with eq .
( [ gammalambda ] ) upon setting @xmath60 . however , the loop is different from eq .
( [ looplambda ] ) , since it involve @xmath61 into the integral [ and not simply @xmath62 . a generalization in case of unequal masses
is discussed in refs .
@xcite .
the choice @xmath63 leads to the desired result @xmath64 of eq .
( [ abmod ] ) and also of eqs .
( [ gammalambda ] ) and ( [ looplambda ] ) , but it explicitly breaks covariance .
this result is anyway valuable since it shows that it is possible to get the desired 3d cutoff form , but should be used only in the reference frame of the decaying particle .
* nonlocal extension 2 * : we aim to determine the lagrangian which generates the vertex function ( [ abmod ] ) in a covariant manner @xcite .
we start from the general nonlocal expression:@xmath65 where the vertex - function @xmath66 in position space has been introduced .
the case @xmath66 @xmath67 delivers the local limit ( [ laglocal ] ) .
the vertex function in momentum space is given by:@xmath68 here we _ assume _ that @xmath66 is such that @xmath69 it respects covariance because the final form factor is a function of lorentz - products .
nevertheless , in the rest frame of @xmath6 one recovers the desired dependence : @xmath70 note , in order to get the desired expression , @xmath71 out of which @xmath72 with @xmath73 and @xmath74 this line of reasoning shows that it is -at least in principle- possible to reconcile covariance with a 3d form factor in the rest frame of the decaying particle .
in this work we have discussed form factors entering in mesonic interaction terms .
we have started from a local lagrangian and we have modified the interaction vertex ` ad hoc ' by introducing a function of the three - momentum of one outgoing particle .
then , we have presented two nonlocal extensions of the lagrangian that deliver the desired expressions without the need of modifying by hand the feynman rules .
the first nonlocal extension is relatively simple but delivers the desired form factor at the price of breaking covariance .
the second extension is more involved but delivers a 3d cutoff in the rest frame of the decaying particle by respecting covariance .
recently , the expressions of the propagator described in sec . 2 ( which are then justified by our study of sec .
3 ) were used to study the positions of the poles in the complex plane in both the isodoublet- and isovector - scalar sectors . in both cases ,
the lagrangians contains only one seed state , corresponding to the quark - antiquark resonances @xmath75 and @xmath76 respectively . yet , the loops ( with the necessary presence of a form factor ) are strong enough to generate two additional resonances : @xmath77 and @xmath78 these are companion poles , and hence dynamically generated states .
moreover , these states disappear in the large-@xmath3 limit , confirming their non - conventional nature . in particular , @xmath2 is not yet confirmed in the pdg @xcite .
the study based on the formalism described in these proceedings unequivocally finds a pole : @xmath79 gev @xcite .
this is in agreement with other works , e.g. ref .
@xcite and refs . therein , and reinforces the need of accepting this state in the pdg . in both refs .
@xcite one obtains a similar values of the cutoff : @xmath80 gev .
moreover , in ref .
@xcite different form factors have been tested .
it is found that they can not fit the pion - kaon scattering data so well as the gaussian form factor .
thus , even if there is in principle no fundamental reason behind a gaussian function , it nevertheless seems to be the best choice in order to describe hadronic phenomenology .
d. parganlija , p. kovacs , g. wolf , f. giacosa and d. h. rischke , phys . rev . *
d87 * , 014011 ( 2012 ) arxiv:1208.0585 [ hep - ph ] ; s. janowski , f. giacosa and d. h. rischke , phys .
d * 90 * ( 2014 ) 11 , 114005 [ arxiv:1408.4921 [ hep - ph ] ] . y. v. burdanov , g. v. efimov , s. n. nedelko and s. a. solunin , phys .
d * 54 * ( 1996 ) 4483 [ hep - ph/9601344 ] ; f. giacosa , t. gutsche and a. faessler , phys .
c * 71 * ( 2005 ) 025202 [ hep - ph/0408085 ] ; r. d. bowler and m. c. birse , nucl .
a * 582 * ( 1995 ) 655 [ hep - ph/9407336 ] ; f. giacosa , glueball phenomenology within a nonlocal approach , phd thesis , tuebingen ( 2105 ) .
a. faessler , t. gutsche , v. e. lyubovitskij and y. l. ma , phys . rev .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 014005 [ arxiv:0705.0254 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. faessler , t. gutsche , v. e. lyubovitskij and y. l. ma , phys .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 114008 [ arxiv:0709.3946 [ hep - ph ] ] . | mesons are extended objects , hence their interaction can be described by utilizing form factors . at the lagrangian level
, one can use nonlocal interaction terms . here
we describe two possible nonlocal lagrangians leading to a 3d form factor : the first one is simple but does not fulfill covariance ( if one insists on a 3d cutoff ) , the second extension is more involved but guarantees covariance .
such form factors are useful when calculating mesonic loops . as an important example
, we discuss the scalar kaonic sector , @xmath0 .
the lagrangian contains a single scalar kaon ( the well - establish state @xmath1 ) , but through loops @xmath2 emerges as a dynamically generated companion pole ( which disappears in the large-@xmath3 limit ) . |
this work deals with a one dimensional inelastic kinetic model , introduced in @xcite , that can be thought of as a generalization of the boltzmann - like equation due to kac ( @xcite ) .
motivations for research into equations for inelastic interactions can be found in many papers , generally devoted to maxwellian molecules . among them , in addition to the already mentioned pulvirenti and toscani s paper , it is worth quoting : @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
see , in particular , the short but useful review in @xcite .
returning to the main subject of this paper , the one - dimensional inelastic model we want to study reduces to the equation @xmath3 where @xmath4 stands for the probability density function of the velocity of a molecule at time @xmath5 and @xmath6 @xmath7 being a nonnegative parameter . when @xmath8 , ( [ eq1 ] ) becomes the kac equation .
it is easy to check that the fourier transform @xmath9 of @xmath4 satisfies equation @xmath10 where @xmath11 stands for the fourier transform of @xmath12 . equation ( [ eq2 ] ) can be considered independently of ( [ eq1 ] ) , thinking of @xmath9 , for @xmath13 , as fourier
stieltjes transform of a probability measure @xmath14 , with @xmath15 . in this case , differently from ( [ eq1 ] ) , @xmath16 need nt be absolutely continuous , i.e. it need nt have a density function with respect to the lebesgue measure .
following @xcite , @xmath17 can be expressed as @xmath18 where @xmath19 and @xmath20 is the so called _ wild product_. the wild representation ( [ eq3 ] ) can be used to prove that the kac equations ( [ eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq2 ] ) have a unique solution in the class of all absolutely continuous probability measures and , respectively , in the class of the fourier
stieltjes transforms of _ all _ probability measures on @xmath21 . moreover , this very same representation , as pointed out by @xcite , can be reformulated in such a way to show that @xmath9 is the characteristic function of a completely specified sum of real valued random variables .
this represents an important point for the methodological side of the present work , consisting in studying significant asymptotic properties of @xmath9 , as @xmath22 .
indeed , thanks to the mckean interpretation , our study will take advantage of methods and results pertaining to the _ central limit theorem _ of probability theory . as to the organization of the paper , in the second part of the present section we provide the reader with preliminary information
mainly of a probabilistic nature that is necessary to understand the rest of the paper . in section [ s2 ]
we present the new results , together with a few hints to the strategies used to prove them .
the most significant steps of the proofs are contained in section [ s3 ] , devoted to asymptotics for weighted sums of independent random variables .
the methods used in this section are essentially inspired to previous work of harald cramr and to its developments due to peter hall .
see @xcite , @xcite .
completion of the proofs is deferred to the appendix .
it is worth lingering over the mckean reformulation of ( [ eq4 ] ) , following @xcite .
consider the product spaces @xmath23 with @xmath24 , @xmath25 being a set of certain _ binary trees _ with @xmath26 leaves .
these trees are defined so that each node has either zero or two `` children '' , a `` left child '' and a `` right child '' .
see figure [ figure1 ] .
now , equip @xmath27 with the @xmath28algebra @xmath29 where , given any set @xmath30 , @xmath31 denotes the power set of @xmath30 and , if @xmath30 is a topological space , @xmath32 indicates the borel @xmath28algebra on @xmath30 .
define @xmath33 , with @xmath34 and @xmath35 , to be the coordinate random variables of @xmath27 . at this stage , for each tree in @xmath25 fix an order on the set of all the @xmath36 nodes and , accordingly , associate the random variable @xmath37 with the @xmath38th node .
see ( a ) in figure [ figure1 ] .
moreover , call @xmath39 the @xmath26 leaves following a left to right order . see ( b ) in figure [ figure1 ] .
define the depth of leaf @xmath40 in symbols , @xmath41 to be the number of generations which separate @xmath40 from the `` root '' node , and for each leaf @xmath40 of a tree , form the product @xmath42 where : @xmath43 equals @xmath44 if @xmath40 is a `` left child '' or @xmath45 if @xmath40 is a `` right child '' , and @xmath37 is the element of @xmath46 associated to the parent node of @xmath40 ; @xmath47 equals @xmath48 or @xmath49 depending on the parent of @xmath40 is , in its turn , a `` left child '' or a `` right child '' , @xmath50 being the element of @xmath51 associated with the grandparent of @xmath40 ; and so on . for the unique tree in @xmath52 it is assumed that @xmath53 . for instance , as to leaf 1 in ( a ) of figure [ figure1 ] , @xmath54 and , for leaf 6 , @xmath55 . from the definition of the random variables
@xmath56 it is plain to deduce that @xmath57 holds true for any tree in @xmath58 , with @xmath59 for further information on this construction , see @xcite .
it is easy to verify that there is one and only one probability measure @xmath60 on @xmath61 such that @xmath62 where , for each @xmath5 , * @xmath63 is a well specified probability on @xmath25 , for every @xmath26 .
* @xmath64 is the probability distribution that makes the @xmath65 independent and identically distributed with continuous uniform law on @xmath66 .
* @xmath67 is the probability distribution according to which the random variables @xmath68 turn out to be independent and identically distributed with common law @xmath69 .
expectation with respect to @xmath60 will be denoted by @xmath70 and integrals over a measurable set @xmath71 will be often indicated by @xmath72 . in this framework one
gets the following proposition , a proof of which can be obtained from obvious modifications of the proofs of theorem 3 and lemma 1 in @xcite .
( @xmath73 ) _ the solution @xmath4 [ @xmath9 , respectively ] of ( [ eq1 ] ) [ ( [ eq2 ] ) , respectively ] can be viewed as a probability density function [ the characteristic function , respectively ] of @xmath74 for any @xmath75 .
moreover , @xmath76 converges in distribution to zero as @xmath22 . _ as a first application of this proposition , one easily gets @xmath77\\ & = e^{-t}\phi_0(\xi)+e^{-t}\sum_{n \geq 2 } ( 1-e^{-t})^{n-1 } { \hat{q}_n}(\xi;\phi_0 ) .
\end{split}\ ] ] then , since @xmath78 for any @xmath79 with @xmath80real part of @xmath81 the conditional characteristic function of @xmath82 , given @xmath83 , coincides with the characteristic function of @xmath82 when @xmath11 is replaced by its real part .
whence , @xmath84 with @xmath85imaginary part of @xmath81 .
the distribution corresponding to @xmath86 is symmetric and is called _ even part _ of @xmath69 .
in fact , @xmath86 turns out to be an even real valued characteristic function , and this fact generally makes easier certain computations . it should be pointed out that if the initial datum @xmath69 is a symmetric probability distribution , then the distribution of @xmath82 is the same as the distribution of @xmath87 .
it can be proved that the possible limits ( in distribution ) of @xmath82 , as @xmath22 , have characteristic functions @xmath17 which are solutions of @xmath88 this result has been communicated to us by filippo riccardi , who proved it by resorting to a suitable modification of the skorokhod representation used in the appendix of the present paper .
it is interesting to note that also the stationary solutions of ( [ eq2 ] ) must satisfy ( [ eq6 ] ) .
we did nt succeed in finding all the solutions of ( [ eq6 ] ) , but it is easy to check that @xmath89 is a solution of ( [ eq6 ] ) , for any @xmath90 .
it is well known that ( [ eq7 ] ) is strictly connected with certain sums of random variables .
indeed , it is a stable real valued characteristic function with characteristic exponent @xmath91 and , in view of a classical lvy s theorem , ( @xmath92 ) _ if @xmath93 are independent and identically distributed real valued random variables , with symmetric common distribution function @xmath94 , then in order that the random variable @xmath95 be the limit in distribution of the normed sum @xmath96 it is necessary and sufficient that @xmath95 has characteristic function ( [ eq7 ] ) for some @xmath97 .
_ one could guess that ( @xmath92 ) may be used to get a direct proof of the fact that @xmath82 converges in distribution to a stable random variable with characteristic function ( [ eq7 ] ) .
this way , one would obtain that these characteristic functions are all possible pointwise limits , as @xmath22 , of solutions @xmath9 of ( [ eq2 ] ) .
in point of fact , direct application of results like ( @xmath92 ) is inadmissible since @xmath82 is a weighted sum of a random number of summands , affected by random weights which are not stochastically independent . in spite of this , by resorting to suitable forms of conditioning for @xmath82 , one can take advantage of classical propositions pertaining to the central limit theorem .
in addition to the problem of determining the class of all possible limit distributions for @xmath82 , an obvious question which arises is that of singling out necessary and sufficient conditions on @xmath69 , in order that @xmath82 converges in distribution to some specific random variable . as to the classical setting mentioned in ( @xmath92 ) , it is worth recalling ( @xmath98 ) _ if @xmath93 are independent and identically distributed real valued random variables , with ( not necessarily symmetric ) common distribution function @xmath94 , then in order that @xmath99 converge in law to a random variable with characteristic function ( [ eq7 ] ) with some specific value for @xmath100 or , in other words , that @xmath94 belong to the domain of normal attraction of ( [ eq7 ] ) it is necessary and sufficient that @xmath94 satisfies @xmath101 as @xmath102 and @xmath103 as @xmath104 , i.e. _
@xmath105 for more information on stable laws and central limit theorem see , for example , chapter 2 of @xcite and chapter 6 of @xcite . to complete the description of certain facts that will be mentioned throughout the paper , it is worth enunciating ( @xmath106 ) _ if @xmath11 stands for the fourier
stieltjes transform of a probability distribution function @xmath94 satisfying ( [ nda - f ] ) , then @xmath107 where @xmath108 is bounded and @xmath109 as @xmath110 . _ ( @xmath106 ) , which is a paraphrase of thorme 1.3 of @xcite , can be proved by mimicking the argument used for theorem 2.6.5 of @xcite .
in the present paper our aims are : firstly , to find initial distribution functions @xmath94 ( or initial characteristic functions @xmath11 ) so that the respective solutions of ( [ eq2 ] ) may converge pointwise to ( [ eq7 ] ) .
secondly , to determine the rate of convergence of the probability distribution function @xmath111 , corresponding to @xmath9 , to a stable distribution function @xmath112 with characteristic exponent @xmath2 , with respect both to specific weighted @xmath1metrics and to kolmogorov s distance .
it is well known from the lvy continuity theorem that pointwise convergence of sequences of characteristic functions is equivalent to _ weak convergence _ of the corresponding distribution functions . in particular , in our present case , since the limiting distribution function @xmath112 is ( absolutely ) continuous , weak convergence is equivalent to uniform convergence , i.e. @xmath113 left hand side of ( [ eq9 ] ) is just the _ kolmogorov distance _ ( @xmath114 , in symbols ) between @xmath111 and @xmath112 . as to the above mentioned first aim , besides sufficient conditions for convergence reducing to the fact that @xmath94 belongs to the domain of normal attraction of ( [ eq7 ] ) a necessary condition for convergence is given . as far as rates of convergence
are concerned , results can be found in the paper of pulvirenti and toscani , with respect to a specific _ weighted @xmath1metric _ , used to study convergence to equilibrium of boltzmann like equations starting from @xcite .
see also @xcite . denoting this distance by @xmath115 , @xmath116 being some positive number
, one has @xmath117 with reference to ( [ eq1 ] ) , after writing @xmath118 for a density of @xmath112 , theorem 6.2 in @xcite reads : ( @xmath119 ) _ let @xmath120 with @xmath12 such that @xmath121 is finite for some @xmath122 in @xmath123 .
then @xmath124 holds true for every @xmath13 , with @xmath125 moreover , ( [ eq11 ] ) is still valid if @xmath126 and @xmath127 if finite for some @xmath122 in @xmath128 $ ] .
_ it should be pointed out that the proof of ( @xmath119 ) provided in @xcite rests on a hypothesis that is weaker than the one evoked in ( @xmath119 ) , i.e. @xmath129 for some @xmath130 . in the present paper
we prove weak convergence of @xmath111 to @xmath112 under much more general hypotheses than those adopted in ( @xmath119 ) . for reader
s convenience , it is worth noticing that the probability distribution function @xmath131 corresponding to @xmath86 ( see the final part of subsection [ subec_2.1 ] ) coincides with @xmath132 at each point @xmath133 of continuity for @xmath94 . in view of ( @xmath98)(@xmath106 ) , if @xmath94 belongs to the domain of normal attraction of ( [ eq7 ] ) , then there is a nonnegative @xmath134 for which @xmath135 and the characteristic function associated to @xmath131 , i.e. @xmath86 , satisfies @xmath136 for some bounded , real - valued @xmath137 such that @xmath138 as @xmath139 .
moreover , @xmath134 is related to @xmath100 by @xmath140 the precise statement of the aforementioned convergence reads [ thm1 ] given @xmath0 , let the initial data for problems ( [ eq1])([eq2 ] ) satisfy @xmath141 then @xmath142 in particular , if @xmath143 , then for every @xmath144 one has @xmath145 i.e. the weak limit of @xmath14 is the point mass @xmath146 . on the other hand , if @xmath0 and there is a strictly positive and increasing sequence @xmath147 , divergent to @xmath148 , such that @xmath149 converges weakly to any probability distribution function , then @xmath150 proof of theorem [ thm1 ] is deferred to the appendix .
after presenting the most general statement we achieved about the weak convergence of @xmath111 , let us proceed to investigate how convergence is fast .
pulvirenti and toscani s argument to prove ( @xmath119 ) lies in studying equation ( [ eq4 ] ) directly via suitable inequalities and from an analytical viewpoint .
differently , in our approach one starts from inequality @xmath151 is defined by ( [ eq7 ] ) and , according to ( @xmath73 ) , @xmath152 represents the conditional characteristic function of @xmath82 given @xmath153 .
hence , from the beginning , we try to obtain bounds for @xmath154 .
this is tantamount to investigating bounds for @xmath155 when @xmath156 is the characteristic function of @xmath157 with @xmath93 independent and identically distributed random numbers , with common distribution function @xmath94 , and @xmath158 think of @xmath26 and @xmath159 as realizations of @xmath160 and @xmath161 , respectively .
according to ( @xmath73 ) one can assume @xmath162 we study this problem preliminary to the investigation of rates of convergence for @xmath82 under the additional conditions that @xmath94 is _ symmetric _ ( and , consequently , the corresponding characteristic function @xmath11 is even ) and that it belongs to the domain of normal attraction of @xmath163 .
see ( @xmath98)(@xmath106 ) and ( [ eq12bis])([eq12ter ] ) .
this way we also get bounds for convergence in law of weighted sums @xmath164 to stable random variables , which are of interest in themselves and , as far as we know , seem to be new .
they are explained and precisely formulated in section 3 .
resuming now the main issue of the speed of convergence of @xmath82 to equilibrium , some further notation is needed .
we set @xmath165 and , given @xmath166 , define @xmath167 to be some element of @xmath168 such that @xmath169 comes true whenever @xmath170 .
next , we put @xmath171 , @xmath172 , @xmath173 .
now we are in a position to present our first results which concern convergence of @xmath111 to @xmath112 with respect to @xmath1metrics .
[ thm2 ] let @xmath94 belong to the domain of normal attraction of @xmath112 with @xmath2 , for some @xmath0 .
define @xmath108 and @xmath137 to be the same as in ( @xmath106 ) and ( [ eq12ter ] ) , respectively .
set @xmath174 then @xmath175 is valid for any @xmath176 in @xmath168 .
the upper bound provided in theorem [ thm2 ] goes to zero as @xmath22 thanks to ( @xmath73 ) , ( @xmath106 ) and the definition of @xmath177 .
then , it can be used to yield further bounds , either via the statement of specific upper bounds for the expectations which appear in the right hand side , or through the adoption of suitable extra
conditions on @xmath108 . as to the former way of arguing , it is worth recalling that proposition 8 in @xcite gives @xmath178 with @xmath179 defined as in ( [ eq12 ] ) .
moreover , from lemma 1 in @xcite , @xmath180 which , in turn , yields @xmath181 for any positive @xmath28 and @xmath182 .
now , define @xmath183 as @xmath184 and set @xmath185 next , observe that the upper bound provided by theorem [ thm2 ] can be written as @xmath186 with @xmath187 and @xmath28 satisfying @xmath188 to obtain @xmath189 then , since @xmath190 can be re - written thanks to ( [ eq17])([eq18 ] ) as a sum of exponential functions , ( [ eq19 ] ) provides a bound entirely expressed , through @xmath177 , in terms of exponential functions of @xmath5 .
exponential rates of relaxation to equilibrium hold true under some extra condition concerning the local behavior of @xmath108 near the origin .
[ thm3 ] assume that , in addition to the assumptions made in theorem [ thm2 ] , ( [ eq:13bis ] ) holds for some @xmath191 . moreover , let @xmath167 be chosen in such a way that @xmath192 entails @xmath193 for some @xmath194 .
then , @xmath195 holds true for @xmath196 in @xmath197 $ ] , while @xmath198 is verified for @xmath196 in @xmath199 $ ] . in short
, this proposition can be condensed into the following statement : _ under the hypotheses of theorem [ thm3 ] , there are constants @xmath200 and @xmath201 such that : @xmath202,\\ \chi_{2\a } ( f(\cdot , t),g_\a ) \leq & a_2 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{4 } ) } \qquad \text{if } \quad \d \in ( \a , 2\a].\\ \end{split}\ ] ] _ statements of the same type as theorems [ thm2 ] and [ thm3 ] are proved in section 5 in @xcite for @xmath203 @xmath204 , i.e. when @xmath112 is a gaussian distribution function with zero mean .
notice that the rate of convergence given in the former part of the last theorem coincides with that of toscani and pulvirenti previously quoted in ( @xmath119 ) .
the latter part of theorem [ thm3 ] and , mainly , theorem [ thm2 ] seem to be new .
see subsection [ subsec2.4 ] for further comments .
rates of convergence of @xmath111 to @xmath112 , in kolmogorov s metric , can be deduced from the representation of @xmath82 as weighted sum , via the well - known berry - esseen inequality in its form given , for example , in theorem 3.18 of @xcite .
it is worth recalling that application of this inequality is allowed thanks to the fact that @xmath112 has derivatives of all orders at every point .
henceforth , given any strictly positive @xmath205 and @xmath182 , we put @xmath206 and @xmath207 with @xmath208 as in ( [ eq12ter ] ) .
[ thm4 ] if @xmath94 belongs to the domain of normal attraction of @xmath112 with @xmath2 for some @xmath0 , then @xmath209\\ + & \frac{{{{\bf c}}}||h_{\a}||}{\tilde{d}}e_t(\betamax)+ \frac{8}{5\pi}m^2n_{2\a}e^{-t(1 - 2a_{4 } ) } + \frac{64}{25\pi}m^4n_{4\a}e^{-t(1 - 2a_{6})}\\ + & \frac{e^{-t}}{2}\sup_{x \in \re}|f_0(x)+f_0(-x-0)-1| \end{split}\ ] ] @xmath210 being the constant which appears in the above - mentioned version of the berry - esseen inequality and @xmath211
. a further bound for @xmath212 can be obtained by replacing the summand @xmath213\ ] ] with @xmath214.\ ] ] finally , it is worth presenting a bound of the same style as ( [ eq19 ] ) , entirely depending on exponential functions : @xmath215 notice that the above two bounds go to zero as @xmath216 .
indeed , the latter goes to zero since , on the one hand , @xmath217 and , on the other hand , @xmath218 and @xmath182 can be chosen in such a way that @xmath219 turns out to be strictly positive .
exponential bounds can be given under the usual condition on the behavior of @xmath108 near the origin .
if , besides the assumptions considered in theorem [ thm4 ] , @xmath208 is such that @xmath220 as @xmath221 for some @xmath222 , and @xmath167 is chosen to assure that @xmath223 entails @xmath224 , then @xmath225 in view of ( [ eq18 ] ) , the thesis of theorem [ thm5 ] can be formulated as : _ there are positive constants @xmath226 and @xmath227 such that @xmath228 for every @xmath229 .
a characteristic feature of the results presented until now is that all the assumptions adopted to obtain bounds in particular , extra - conditions to achieve exponentially fast convergence are formulated in terms of conditions on the initial characteristic function . in general , with respect to actual choice of initial data , it is easier and more natural to assign conditions on @xmath94 than on @xmath11 .
apropos of this remark , see the role played by lemma 6.1 in @xcite and section [ subsec2.4 ] below .
with reference to the classical case of independent and identically distributed summands , see , for example , @xcite , @xcite . accordingly
, the main objective of the rest of the section is to determine bounds for @xmath212 , expressed in terms of quantities whose computation is generally easier than the computation of characteristic functions , once either @xmath94 or some approximate form of @xmath94 has been assigned . to pave the way for presentation ,
let us complement previous notation given , in particular , in subsection [ subec_2.1 ] : @xmath230 where @xmath231 is some strictly positive number and the integral has to be meant as improper riemann integral .
moreover , @xmath232 with @xmath233 and @xmath234 [ thm6 ] if @xmath94 belongs to the domain of normal attraction of @xmath112 with @xmath2 in @xmath235 , and @xmath236 if @xmath237 , then @xmath238\\ + & \frac{{{{\bf c}}}||h_{\a}||}{\tilde{d}}e_t(\betamax)+ \frac{2}{\pi } \big \ { b_1 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{4/\a } ) } + b_2 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{(8 - 2\a)/\a } ) } \\ & b_5 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{4 } ) } + b_6e^{-t(1 - 2a_{6 } ) } \big \ } + \frac{e^{-t}}{2}\sup_{x \in \re}|f_0(x)+f_0(-x-0)-1| .
\\ \end{split}\ ] ] then , setting @xmath239 for @xmath240 , and recalling ( [ eq18 ] ) , we obtain a bound completely expressed in terms of exponential functions , that is @xmath241 in order to obtain exponential bounds , we reinforce the assumptions made in theorem [ thm6 ] , in the sense that @xmath242 besides the assumptions made in theorem [ thm6 ] , suppose ( [ eq20 ] ) holds true .
then , @xmath243 which is tantamount to saying that there are positive constants @xmath244 and @xmath245 such that @xmath246 holds for every @xmath13 .
it remains to consider the case with @xmath91 in @xmath168 . in point of fact , the next theorem is valid for any @xmath91 in @xmath247 , but it requires further notation .
firstly , @xmath248 is assumed to be _ monotonic _ on @xmath249 .
then , one sets @xmath250 with @xmath251 where @xmath252 [ thm8 ] let @xmath91 belong to @xmath247 and let @xmath253 be monotonic on @xmath249 .
then , @xmath254\\ + & \frac{{{{\bf c}}}||h_{\a}||}{\tilde{d}}e_t(\betamax)+ \frac{2}{\pi } \big \ { \bar b_1 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{4/\a } ) } + \bar b_2 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{(8 - 2\a)/\a } ) } \\ & b_5 e^{-t(1 - 2a_{4 } ) } + b_6e^{-t(1 - 2a_{6 } ) } \big \ } + \frac{e^{-t}}{2}\sup_{x \in \re}|f_0(x)+f_0(-x-0)-1| .
\\ \end{split}\ ] ] as done elsewhere in this section , it should be noted that the inequality @xmath255 \\ & \leq \left ( \frac{{{{\bf c}}}||h_{\a}||}{\tilde{d } } + \frac{2}{\pi } \bar b_3(k_3+k_5 ) \right ) e^{-t(1-q\s \a/2 - 2a_q ) } \\ & + \frac{{{{\bf c}}}||h_{\a}||}{\tilde{d } } e^{-\s t } + \frac{2}{\pi } \bar b_3 \{\bar h_1^ * ( e^{-\s t})+ \bar h_3^ * ( e^{-\s t } ) \}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] is useful to yield a bound for @xmath256 depending only on exponential functions , while an exponential bound can be derived from the next theorem .
[ thm9 ] besides the assumptions made in theorem [ thm8 ] , suppose ( [ eq20 ] ) holds true .
then , @xmath257 in view of the greater expressiveness of assumptions given for @xmath94 , if compared to conditions on @xmath11 , already stressed at the beginning of subsection [ subsec2.3 ] , we conclude the section with a brief comparative analysis .
this analysis deals , on the one hand , with the two kinds of conditions actually used in the present paper and , on the other hand , with our conditions on @xmath94 compared with those introduced in @xcite .
recall that in subsections 2.1 and 2.2 we have used an extra condition which , in the symmetric case , reduces to @xmath258 for some @xmath259 in @xmath260 when @xmath91 belongs to @xmath235 , and for some @xmath259 in @xmath260 when @xmath91 belongs to @xmath168 provided that @xmath261 is monotonic for @xmath262 . as to the former point under discussion , notice that for @xmath91 in @xmath235 one can resort to easy inequalities , to be explained and used in the proof of proposition [ prop5 ] , to obtain @xmath263 where , in view of ( [ eq22a ] ) , @xmath264 .
an analogous conclusion holds true when @xmath265 with @xmath266 and @xmath267 in the place of @xmath268 and @xmath269 , respectively .
see formal developments in the proof of proposition [ prop6 ] .
hence : _ if @xmath259 belongs to @xmath260 with @xmath270 , and @xmath253 is monotonic on @xmath271 for some @xmath272 when @xmath265 , then ( [ eq22a ] ) entails ( [ eq21a ] ) .
_ moving on to the latter kind of comparisons , it should be recalled that @xcite , in order that initial data can satisfy ( [ eq22a ] ) , assume @xmath273 in section 4 of @xcite it is proved that ( [ eq23a ] ) _ entails _ ( [ eq21a ] ) and now we prove that ( [ eq23a ] ) _ yields _ ( [ eq22a ] ) _ when @xmath274_. indeed , from the markov inequality , @xmath275 this , combined with a well known asymptotic expression for @xmath112 ( see , for example , sections 2.4 and 2.5 of @xcite ) , gives @xmath276 then , ( [ eq22a ] ) _ follows form _ ( [ eq23a ] ) _ when @xmath274_. this last restriction is consistent with theorem 6.2 in @xcite , mentioned in @xmath277 , and with the first part of theorem [ thm3 ] .
moreover , it should be noted that classical asymptotic formulae for @xmath118 ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) can be applied to exhibit simple examples of initial data which meet ( [ eq22a ] ) but do not meet ( [ eq23a ] ) . in other words ,
the criterion evoked by @xcite to get ( [ eq21a ] ) together with exponential bounds for @xmath278 with @xmath274 could be usefully replaced by the weaker condition ( [ eq22a ] ) , as we have done for convergence with respect to the kolmogorov metric .
as mentioned in the introductory paragraph of section [ s2 ] see , in particular , explanation for ( [ eq14 ] ) , ( [ eq15_1 ] ) and ( [ eq15_2 ] ) the present section focuses on the study of the convergence in distribution of weighted sums of independent random variables .
this study , besides the interest it could hold in itself , is essential for proving the theorems already stated in section [ s2 ] . in point of fact , the main steps of the arguments used to prove these theorems are set out in the propositions we get ready to enunciate and prove in the present section .
specific indications of how they are used will be given in the appendix .
for the present , it should be recalled that we are interested in convergence in distribution of sums @xmath279 with @xmath280 _ independent and identically distributed real valued random variables with common distribution function @xmath94_. moreover , the numbers @xmath281 _ are assumed to satisfy _ ( [ eq15_1 ] ) - ( [ eq15_2 ] ) , and @xmath94 is supposed to be a _ symmetric element of the domain of normal attraction of _ ( [ eq7 ] ) . then according to ( @xmath98 ) and ( @xmath106 ) , there is @xmath282 satisfying @xmath283 for which @xmath284 and @xmath285 where @xmath108 is a bounded real - valued function satisfying @xmath109 as @xmath221 .
see ( [ eq12bis ] ) - ( [ eq12ter ] ) .
the above conditions , printed in italic type , are assumed to be in force throughout the present section , and will be not repeated in the following statements .
it is worth recalling that these statements are inspired by previous work published in @xcite and @xcite .
accordingly , the present line of reasoning is based on certain inequalities contained in the following lemma where , as in the rest of the section , for the sake of typographic convenience , @xmath286 is used instead of @xmath287 .
[ lemma1 ] let @xmath288 be the characteristic function of ( [ eq21 ] ) . then
, @xmath289\\ \end{split}\ ] ] holds for any @xmath290 in @xmath291 , @xmath292 , @xmath176 in @xmath293 , @xmath167 , @xmath294 , @xmath295 and @xmath296 being the same as in theorem [ thm2 ] with @xmath108 in the place of @xmath137 , @xmath297 and @xmath298 .
moreover , for @xmath299 , @xmath176 in @xmath168 and @xmath290 in @xmath291 , @xmath300 \end{split}\ ] ] with @xmath301 _ proof .
_ according to previous notation , set @xmath302 and @xmath303 .
now , in view of @xmath304 , @xmath305 and the last term turns out to be bounded from above by @xmath306 when @xmath307 . since @xmath308 for @xmath309 and some @xmath310 satisfying @xmath311 ( see , for example , lemma 3 in section 9.1 of @xcite ) , then @xmath312 yields @xmath313 with @xmath314 .
moreover , if @xmath315 and @xmath316 , @xmath317 and , via @xmath304 , @xmath318 with @xmath319 and @xmath320 writing @xmath321 with @xmath322 equalities ( [ 3322 ] ) give @xmath323 as to @xmath324 , for @xmath325 and any sufficiently small @xmath167 , one gets @xmath326 by the definition of @xmath167 given immediately before the beginning of subsection [ subsec2.1 ] .
this entails @xmath327 for any @xmath328 in @xmath329 and @xmath330 .
next , an application of jensen s inequality yields @xmath331 which , in turn , combined with ( [ eq24 ] ) , gives @xmath332 now , from ( [ eq25 ] ) with @xmath333 , @xmath334 at this stage it remains to consider @xmath335 . in this case , one gets @xmath336 and , to complete the proof for ( [ eq22 ] ) , it is enough to take account of the obvious inequality @xmath337 . now , as far as ( [ eq23 ] ) is concerned , take @xmath299 and @xmath176 in @xmath168 .
then , ( [ eq22 ] ) becomes @xmath338 now , for @xmath339 and @xmath340 , @xmath341 and ( [ eq23 ] ) follows from ( [ eq26 ] ) with @xmath342 replaced by @xmath295 on @xmath343 .
@xmath344 lemma [ lemma1 ] can be used to obtain bounds for the @xmath345distance between @xmath112 and the probability distribution function @xmath346 of @xmath164 .
[ prop1 ] the @xmath345distance between @xmath346 and @xmath112 satisfies @xmath347 for any @xmath176 in @xmath168 , with @xmath348 ( @xmath349 being any positive number ) . _
_ consider ( [ eq23 ] ) and observe that @xmath350 holds true on the set @xmath351 since @xmath352 on this set .
@xmath353 it is easy to check that the upper bound stated in proposition [ prop1 ] is @xmath354 for @xmath355 .
lemma [ lemma1 ] can also be exploited to determine analogous bounds for @xmath278 and @xmath356 , under the extra condition ( [ eq:13bis ] ) .
[ prop2 ] suppose ( [ eq:13bis ] ) is valid for some @xmath130 and take @xmath167 in such a way that @xmath357 @xmath358 if @xmath359 entails @xmath360 for some @xmath361 .
then , @xmath362 for any @xmath274 , and @xmath363 for any @xmath259 in @xmath364 $ ] .
_ from ( [ eq22 ] ) with @xmath365 and @xmath366 , @xmath367 then , if @xmath259 belongs to @xmath368 $ ] , one easily obtains the former of the inequalities to be proved .
the latter follows similarly from ( [ eq22 ] ) with @xmath365 and @xmath369 .
@xmath353 as mentioned at the beginning of subsection [ subsec2.2 ] , here we pass from weighted @xmath1metrics to kolmogorov s metric via the classical berry esseen inequality @xmath370 @xmath210 being the constant which appears in theorem 3.18 in @xcite .
take ( [ eq22 ] ) , with @xmath365 and @xmath371 , and sobstitute it in the right hand side of the above berry esseen inequality to obtain [ prop3 ] one has @xmath372 with @xmath373 and @xmath374 .
this upper bound is @xmath354 as @xmath355 .
more informative bounds can be obtained under extra condition ( [ eq:13bis ] ) .
[ prop4 ] if ( [ eq:13bis ] ) is valid for some @xmath130 and @xmath167 is fixed in such a way that @xmath357 @xmath358 if @xmath359 entails @xmath375 for some @xmath361 , then @xmath376 + \frac{{{\bf c}}}{\tilde{d } } \|\galpha \|q_{(n)}=o(1 ) \quad \text{as $ n \to + \infty$.}\\ \end{split}\ ] ] _ proof .
_ under the present extra
condition , inequality in the previous proposition combined with inequality @xmath377 , valid for every @xmath40 and @xmath378 , yields the desired bound .
@xmath344 now , we proceed to present bounds for @xmath379 under restrictions on the initial distribution function , rather than on @xmath11 .
notation is the same as in subsection [ subsec2.3 ] with the proviso that @xmath131 is replaced by ( symmetric ) @xmath94 and , consequently , symbols with @xmath380 , like @xmath253 , @xmath381 , @xmath382 , etc .
must be changed to symbols without @xmath380 , i.e. , @xmath30 , @xmath383 , @xmath134 , etc .
, respectively . [ prop5 ]
let @xmath91 be in @xmath235 and let the additional restriction that @xmath384 if @xmath237 be valid . then , @xmath385 in particular , if @xmath383 is such that @xmath386 for any @xmath387 , @xmath259 in @xmath260 and some constant @xmath388 , then @xmath389 are valid for any @xmath182 in @xmath390 $ ] . _
_ we start from the definitions of @xmath30 and @xmath11 to obtain , via ( [ eq21_bis ] ) , @xmath391 which , in view of @xmath304 , yields @xmath392 where @xmath393 for these quantities one can write @xmath394 with @xmath395 , and @xmath396 combination of these inequalities with the definition of @xmath397 ( see proposition [ prop3 ] ) gives us @xmath398 using this inequality , we obtain @xmath399 it remains to study integrals like @xmath400 for @xmath401 . following the argument used in @xcite to prove lemma 7 , one can state the inequality @xmath402 with @xmath403 . to complete the proof of the main part of the proposition it is enough to use ( [ eq36bis ] ) to obtain a bound for the right - hand side of ( [ eq28 ] ) and , then , to replace this bound for the first sum in the right hand side of ( [ eq27_bis ] ) . as to the latter claim , recall that @xmath404 , @xmath405 and use the additional condition .
@xmath353 [ prop6 ]
let @xmath91 be in @xmath247 and let the additional hypothesis that @xmath30 is monotonic on @xmath249 be valid for some @xmath272 .
then , @xmath406 moreover , if @xmath383 is such that @xmath407 for any @xmath387 , @xmath259 in @xmath260 and some constant @xmath388 , one gets @xmath408 for every @xmath182 in @xmath390 $ ] .
_ one starts from proposition [ prop3 ] once again , noticing that equality @xmath409 holds with @xmath410 observe that @xmath411 with @xmath412 moreover , @xmath413 then , @xmath414 hence , @xmath415|b_2(\xi q_j)|d\xi \\ & + ( 2 \bar{k}_1 n_2 + 8 \bar{k}_1 \bar{k}_2 n_{\a+2})q_j^2 + 8 \bar{k}_1 ^ 2n_4q_j^{4-\a } + \frac{4}{5}m^2 n_{2\a } q_j^{2\a}+ \frac{32}{25}m^2n_{4\a } q_j^{3\a}\big\}\\ & + \frac{{{\bf c}}\|\galpha\|}{\tilde{d } } q_{(n)}. \end{split}\ ] ] applying the fubini theorem and the formula for integration by parts , we can write @xmath416 where @xmath417 then , @xmath418 and @xmath419 to complete the proof it suffices to replace the quantities @xmath420 with their upper bounds and , next , to recall the definition of the constants @xmath421.@xmath353
in this part of the paper we present the proofs of the theorems stated in section [ s2 ] . for the sake of expository clarity , let us recall the common inspiring principles for all of these proofs .
first of all , we refer to representation ( [ eq5bis ] ) which , combined with ( [ eq13 ] ) , gives @xmath422 where @xmath423 is equal to @xmath424 when @xmath425 , @xmath426 @xmath427 and , in the definition of @xmath428 , @xmath11 is replaced by @xmath429 .
analogously , @xmath430 where @xmath431 is obtained from @xmath432 by replacing @xmath26 , @xmath286 and @xmath94 with @xmath160 , @xmath433 and @xmath434 , respectively .
* proof of theorem [ thm3 ] . *
argue as in the previous proof by using the upper bounds obtained in proposition [ prop2 ] , instead of the upper bound of proposition [ prop1 ] .
moreover , to evaluate expectations , make use of the obvious inequality @xmath437 $ ] and , then , of ( [ eq16 ] ) and ( [ eq17]).@xmath353 the remaining theorems from [ thm5 ] to [ thm9 ] can be proved following the same line of reasoning , according to the scheme : resort to proposition [ prop4 ] and to ( [ eq16 ] ) for theorem [ thm5 ] . apply proposition [ prop5 ] and ( [ eq16])-([eq17 ] ) to prove theorems [ thm6 ] and [ thm7 ] .
finally , use proposition [ prop6 ] and ( [ eq16])-([eq17 ] ) to prove theorems [ thm8 ] and [ thm9 ] .
it remains to prove theorem [ thm1 ] .
its former part is a straightforward consequence of theorem [ thm4 ] . as to the latter
, we use the same argument as in the proof of theorem 1 in @xcite , based on @xcite . accordingly , for every @xmath440 we define @xmath441 where : @xmath442 stands for a conditional distribution of @xmath443 , given @xmath444 ; @xmath445 is the @xmath160-fold convolution of @xmath446 ; @xmath447 indicates unit mass at @xmath133 ; @xmath448^c)$ ] .
moreover , the @xmath449 are conditionally i.i.d . with common distribution @xmath131 . to grasp the importance of @xmath450 , notice that its components represent the essential ingredients of central limit problems
as to this fundamental theorem , we refer to section 16.8 of @xcite .
the range of @xmath450 can be seen as a subset of @xmath451 , where : @xmath452 $ ] ; @xmath453 indicates the set of all probability measures on the borel class @xmath454 on some metric space @xmath296 ; @xmath455 is a distinguished metrizable compactification of @xmath456 .
these spaces are endowed with topologies specified in subsection 3.2 of @xcite , which make @xmath30 a separable compact metric space .
now recall that , under the assumption of the latter part of theorem [ thm1 ] , @xmath457 must converge in distribution .
next , from lemma 3 in @xcite , with slight changes , the sequence of the laws of the vectors @xmath458 contains a subsequence @xmath459 which is weakly convergent to a probability measure @xmath460 supported by @xmath461 . at this stage ,
an application of the skorokhod representation theorem ( see , e.g. , @xcite , @xcite ) , combined both with the properties of the support of @xmath460 and with @xmath462 , entails the existence of random vectors @xmath463 defined on a suitable space @xmath464 , in such a way that @xmath465 and @xmath466 have the same law ( for every @xmath467 ) .
moreover , @xmath468 where the convergence must be understood as pointwise convergence on @xmath469 and @xmath470 designates weak convergence of probability measures . from ( [ a3 ] ) and
theorem 16.24 of @xcite , there is a random lvy measure @xmath16 , symmetric about zero , such that @xmath471 holds pointwise on @xmath469 for every @xmath387 . to complete the proof
, we assume that @xmath472 and show that this assumption contradicts ( [ a4 ] ) .
indeed , the assumption implies that for any @xmath473 there is @xmath474 such that @xmath475 for every @xmath476 and , therefore , @xmath477 since ( [ a3 ] ) yields @xmath478 , then @xmath479 , which contradicts ( [ a4 ] ) in view of the arbitrariness of @xmath38 .
kac , m. ( 1956 ) .
foundations of kinetic theory . in _ proceedings of the third berkeley symposium on mathematical statistics and probability , 19541955 _ * 3 * 171197 .
university of california press , berkeley and los angeles . | this paper deals with a one dimensional model for granular materials , which boils down to an inelastic version of the kac kinetic equation , with inelasticity parameter @xmath0 . in particular
, the paper provides bounds for certain distances such as specific weighted @xmath1distances and the kolmogorov distance between the solution of that equation and the limit .
it is assumed that the even part of the initial datum ( which determines the asymptotic properties of the solution ) belongs to the domain of normal attraction of a symmetric stable distribution with characteristic exponent @xmath2 . with such initial data
, it turns out that the limit exists and is just the aforementioned stable distribution . a necessary condition for the relaxation to equilibrium
is also proved .
some bounds are obtained without introducing any extra condition .
sharper bounds , of an exponential type , are exhibited in the presence of additional assumptions concerning either the behaviour , near to the origin , of the initial characteristic function , or the behaviour , at infinity , of the initial probability distribution function . |
wormholes are hypothetical handles or tunnels in spacetime linking widely separated regions of our universe or entirely different universes .
morris and thorne @xcite proposed the following line element for the wormhole spacetime : @xmath0 using units in which @xmath1 . here
@xmath2 is called the _ redshift function _ , which must be everywhere finite to prevent an event horizon .
the function @xmath3 is called the _ shape function _ , which has the property that @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the _ throat _ of the wormhole .
a key requirement is the _ flare - out condition _ at the throat : @xmath6 , while @xmath7 near the throat .
the flare - out condition can only be satisfied by violating the null energy condition ( nec ) , which states that @xmath8 for all null vectors and where @xmath9 is the energy - momentum tensor .
so given the null vector @xmath10 , the nec is violated if @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the energy density and @xmath13 the radial pressure . the possible existence of wormholes in the outer region of the halo has already been discussed in refs .
@xcite using the navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) density profile @xcite : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the characteristic scale radius and @xmath16 is the corresponding density .
this model yields a shape function whose basic properties , such as the throat size , remain the same in the region considered @xcite .
it is well known that the nfw model predicts velocities in the central parts that are too low @xcite , but these discrepancies do not exist in the outer regions of the halo where the wormholes discussed in refs .
@xcite are located @xcite . in this study
we are going to be primarily concerned with the region closer to the center where the universal rotation curve ( urc ) dark matter profile is valid @xcite : @xmath17 here @xmath18 is the core radius and @xmath19 the effective core density . while the urc model is valid throughout the halo region , we assume that the outer region has already been dealt with in refs
. @xcite using the nfw model , thereby leaving only the central region , which is the subject of this paper . in this connection
we would like to add here that the urc represents any single rotation curve in spirals of any mass and hubble type , and it is an obvious step forward with respect to assuming a constant value . at some time , a cored burkert profile is a step forward with respect to nfw profile that , it is now common fact that the latter fails to reproduce the dark matter distribution . both the urc and the cored profile are born empirically and find some explanation later on @xcite .
therefore , our plan of the present work is as follows : in sec .
2 we provide the basic equations and their solutions under the urc dark matter profile whereas sec . 3 is devoted for some specific comments regarding the results obtained in the study .
even though we now have the density profile , other properties of dark matter remain unknown .
so we are going to assume that dark matter is characterized by the general anisotropic energy - momentum tensor @xcite @xmath20 with @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath13 being the transverse and radial pressures , respectively .
the line element for the galactic halo region is given in eq .
( [ e : line1 ] ) . the flat rotation curve for the circular stable geodesic motion in the equatorial plane yields the tangential velocity @xcite @xmath23 the radius @xmath24 in kpc and velocity @xmath25 in km / s of the rotation curve of objects with total virial mass @xmath26 solar masses is given below ( table - 1 ) @xcite .
we find the best fitting curve which is given in fig . 1 . by applying intuition , we propose that the observed rotation curve profile in the dark matter region is of the form @xmath27.\ ] ] for a typical galaxy the tangential velocity @xmath25 is shown in fig .
moreover , for sufficiently large @xmath24 , @xmath28 250 km / s @xmath29 @xcite .
one can note that our proposed curve and observed curve profile for tangential velocity are almost similar to each other for the specific values of the parameters i.e. the proposed and observed rotational velocities are both fittable with our empirical formula .
therefore , our assumption is more or less justified .
[ cols= " > , < " , ] the einstein field equations for the above metric are @xmath30\label{e : ein3}&=&8\pi p_{t}(r).\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eqs .
( [ e : v1 ] ) and ( [ e : v2 ] ) and using some typical values , we obtain the redshift function @xmath31 here @xmath32 is the exponential integral and @xmath33 is an integration constant . the graph of @xmath34 in fig .
2 shows the behavior in the central part of the halo , which is the region that we are primarily concerned with .
( for large @xmath24 , @xmath34 is such that @xmath35 where @xmath36 @xcite ) .
the determination of the shape function @xmath3 requires a little more care .
first of all , we assume that @xmath37 , @xmath34 , and the halo have a common origin in order to use eqs .
( [ e : v1 ] ) and ( [ e : ein1 ] ) in the calculations . to see if the shape function meets the basic requirements , we start with eq .
( [ e : ein1 ] ) , @xmath38 and integrate from 0 to @xmath24 to obtain @xmath39 where @xmath40 is an integration constant .
to get an overview of the shape function , we assign some arbitrary values to the parameters and obtain the plots in fig.2 shows that the throat is located at some @xmath41 , where @xmath42 intersects the @xmath24-axis . also , for @xmath43 , @xmath44 , which implies that @xmath45 .
furthermore , @xmath42 is decreasing for @xmath46 , implying that @xmath6 .
hence the flare - out condition is satisfied .
so based on the urc model , the qualitative features meet all the requirements for the existence of a wormhole . at this point
it would be desirable to examine the effect of using more specific parameters .
for example , if the throat of the wormhole coincides with the core radius @xmath47 , then we get for the shape function @xmath48 where @xmath49 as before , @xmath50 .
having determined the throat radius allows a closer look at the flare - out condition , which again depends on @xmath51 . by eqs .
( [ e : ein1 ] ) and ( [ e : rho ] ) , @xmath52 in the specific case of the milky way galaxy , @xmath53 kpc @xcite and @xmath54 kpc)@xmath55 g cm @xmath56 @xcite . substituting in eq .
( [ e : bprime ] ) , we get @xmath57 the flare - out condition is easily satisfied . notice that this result does not change if we adopt the milky way values for @xmath58 and @xmath18 found by the accurate analysis of @xcite to complete our discussion , we will use eqs .
( [ e : ein2 ] ) and ( [ e : ein3 ] ) to obtain the radial and lateral pressures : @xmath59 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath60 $ ] . @xmath61 where @xmath62 @xmath63\nonumber.\end{aligned}\ ] ] according to fig .
3 , @xmath11 , so that the null energy condition is indeed violated . for values of the parameters
the possible existence of wormholes in the outer regions of the halo was discussed in ref .
@xcite , based on the nfw density profile . possible detection by means of gravitational lensing , discussed in ref .
@xcite , has shown that the basic features , such as the throat size , are independent of the position within the halo . because of certain discrepancies discovered near the center , this paper uses the observationally motivated urc dark matter density profile instead in order to accommodate the region closer to the center of the halo .
this center is also the center of the wormhole .
it is subsequently shown that the solution obtained satisfies all the criteria for the existence of a wormhole , particularly the violation of the null energy condition . in the special case of the milky way galaxy , if the throat radius @xmath47 coincides with the radius of the core , then @xmath65 , thereby meeting the flare - out condition .
a similar result can be expected for most spiral galaxies .
thus our result is very important because it confirms the possible existence of wormholes in most of the spiral galaxies .
scientists remain silent on whether it is possible to manufacture or create of the exotic matter violating null energy condition in laboratory . as a result
the construction of a wormhole geometry in our real world is extremely difficult .
however in the galactic halo region , dark matter may supply the fuel for constructing and sustaining a wormhole .
hence , wormholes could be found in nature and our study may encourage scientists to seek observational evidence for wormholes in the galactic halo region .
fr and sr are thankful to the inter - university centre for astronomy and astrophysics ( iucaa ) , india for providing associateship programme where a part of the work has been done .
fr is also grateful to jadavpur university , india for financial support .
f. rahaman , p.k.f .
kuhfittig , s. ray , n. islam , eur .
j. c * 74 * , 2750 ( 2014 ) p.k.f .
kuhfittig , eur .
j. c * 74 * , 2818 ( 2014 ) m.s .
morris , k.s .
thorne , am .
* 56 * , 395 ( 1988 ) j.f .
navarro , c.s .
frenk , s.d.m .
white , astrophys .
j. * 462 * , 563 ( 1996 ) g. gentile , p. salucci , u. klein , d. vergani , p. kalberla , mnras * 351 * , 903 ( 2004 ) c. tonini , a. lapi , p. salucci , astrophys . j. * 649 * , 591 ( 2006 ) .
maccio , et al . , apj lett .
* 744 * , l9 ( 2012 ) g. castignani , n. frusciante , d. vernieri , p. salucci , nat .
* 4 * , 265 ( 2012 ) p. salucci , a. lapi , c. tonini , g. gentile , i. yegorova , u. klein , mnras * 378 * , 41 ( 2007 ) ; persic , m. salucci , p. stel , f. 1996 , mnras , 281 , 27 n. bozorgnia et al , jcap _ 1312 _ , 050 ( 2013 ) s. chandrasekhar , mathematical theory of black holes ( oxford classic texts , 1983 ) l.d .
landau and e.m .
lifshitz , the classical theory of fields ( oxford , pergamon press , 1975 ) f. rahaman , m. kalam , a. de benedictis , a.a .
usmani , s. ray , mnras * 27 * 389 ( 2008 ) k.k .
nandi , a.i .
filippov , f. rahaman , s. ray , a.a .
usmani , m. kalam , a. de benedictis , mnras * 399 * , 2079 ( 2009 ) j. ponce de len , gen .
* 25 * , 1123 ( 1993 ) | an earlier study @xcite has demonstrated the possible existence of wormholes in the outer regions of the galactic halo , based on the navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) density profile .
this paper uses the universal rotation curve ( urc ) dark matter model to obtain analogous results for the central parts of the halo .
this result is an important compliment to the earlier result , thereby confirming the possible existence of wormholes in most of the spiral galaxies .
general relativity ; universal rotation curves ; wormholes |
the proton magnetic form factor at large momentum transfer has been extensively analyzed within perturbative quantum chromodynamics ( pqcd ) over the last decade @xcite .
the theoretical basis of these calculations is the hard scattering formula @xcite in which the proton form factor is generically expressed as a convolution of a hard - scattering amplitude @xmath5 and proton distribution amplitudes ( da ) @xmath6 which represent valence quark fock state wave functions integrated over quark transverse momenta ( defined with respect to the momentum of their parent proton ) : @xmath7 \int_{0}^{1}[dx^{\prime } ] |f_{n}(\mu _ { f})|^{2}\ , \phi ^{\star}(x^{\prime},\mu _ { f } ) t_{h}(x , x^{\prime},q,\mu ) \phi ( x,\mu _ { f } ) , \label{eq : gm}\ ] ] where @xmath1 is the invariant momentum transfer squared and @xmath8=dx_{1}dx_{2}dx_{3}\delta ( 1-\sum_{}^{}x_{i})$ ] , @xmath9 being the momentum fractions carried by the valence quarks . the renormalization scale is denoted by @xmath10 and the factorization scale by @xmath11 .
the latter scale defines the interface between soft physics absorbed in the wave function and hard physics , treated explicitly within pqcd .
the dimensionful constant @xmath12 represents the value of the proton wave function at the origin of the configuration space and has to be determined nonperturbatively @xcite .
the residual ( mainly perturbative ) scale dependence of @xmath12 and that of the proton da is controlled by the evolution equation @xcite .
to lowest order the hard scattering amplitude is calculated as the sum of all feynman diagrams for which the three quark lines are connected pairwise by two gluon propagators .
this allows the quarks in the initial and final proton to be viewed as moving collinearly up to transverse momenta of order @xmath11 .
it is then easy to show that @xmath13 , wherein @xmath0 is the running strong coupling constant in the one - loop approximation .
the pauli form factor @xmath14 and hence the electric form factor @xmath15 can not be calculated within the hard scattering picture ( hsp ) , since they require helicity - flip transitions which are not possible for ( almost ) massless quarks .
these form factors are dominated by sizeable higher twist contributions as we know from experiment @xcite .
( [ eq : gm ] ) is obtained by taking the + component of the electromagnetic vertex and represents the helicity - conserving part of the form factor .
the choice of the renormalization scale in the calculation of the proton form factor is a crucial point .
most authors @xcite use a constant @xmath0 outside the integrals over fractional momenta , with an argument rescaled by the characteristic virtualities for each particular model da .
choosing @xmath10 that way and using das calculated by means of qcd sum rules distributions whose essential characteristic is a strong asymmetry in phase space
results for @xmath16 have been obtained @xcite that compare fairly well with the data @xcite . on the other hand , the so - called `` asymptotic '' da @xcite @xmath17 into which any da should evolve with @xmath18yields a vanishing result for @xmath19 . however , for a renormalization scale independent of x , large contributions from higher orders are expected in the endpoint region , @xmath20 . indeed , for the pion form factor this has been shown explicitly , at least for the next - to - leading order @xcite .
such large higher - order contributions would render the leading - order calculation useless .
a more appropriate choice of the renormalization scale would be , e.g. , @xmath21 , since such a scale would eliminate the large logarithms arising from the higher - order contributions .
unfortunately , this is achieved at the expense that @xmath0 becomes singular in the endpoint regions .
it has been conjectured @xcite that gluonic radiative corrections ( sudakov factors ) will suppress that @xmath0-singularity and , therefore , in practical applications of the hsp one may handle this difficulty by cutting off @xmath0 at a certain value , typically chosen in the range 0.5 to 0.7 .
another , semi - phenomenological recipe to avoid the singularity of @xmath0 is to introduce an effective gluon mass @xcite which cut - offs the interaction at low @xmath1 values .
besides the extreme sensitivity of the form factors on the utilized da and besides the problem with higher - order contributions and/or the singularity of @xmath22 , there is still another perhaps more fundamental
difficulty with such calculations .
indeed , the applicability of ( [ eq : gm ] ) at experimentally accessible momentum transfer , typically a few gev , is not _ a priori _ justified .
it was argued by isgur and llewellyn - smith @xcite and also by radyushkin @xcite that the hsp receives its main contributions from the soft endpoint regions , rendering the perturbative calculation inconsistent .
recently , this criticism has been challenged by sterman and collaborators @xcite .
based on previous works by collins , soper , and sterman @xcite , they have calculated sudakov corrections to the hard - scattering process taking into account the conventionally neglected transverse momentum , @xmath23 , of the quarks .
the sudakov corrections damp those contributions from the endpoint regions in which transverse momenta of the quarks are not large enough to keep the exchanged gluons hard .
moreover , as presumed , the sudakov corrections cancel the @xmath22-singularity without introducing additional _ ad hoc _ cut - off parameters as for instance a gluon mass . thus the modified hsp provides a well - defined expression for the form factor which takes into account the perturbative contributions in a self - consistent way , even for momentum transfers as low as a few gev
however , an important element has not been considered in the analyses of refs .
this concerns the inclusion of the intrinsic transverse momentum of the hadronic wave function .
as it was recently shown by two of us @xcite for the case of the pion form factor , the inclusion of the transverse size of the pion extends considerably the self - consistency region of the perturbative contribution down to values of momentum transfer unreachable by the sudakov corrections alone . on the other hand
, the incorporation of the @xmath23-dependence leads to a substantial decrease of the magnitude of the ( leading - order ) pion form factor .
unfortunately , a clear - cut comparison with the available data is not possible because of their low quality and the uncertainty in the determination of the pion - nucleon coupling constant @xcite .
nevertheless , it seems reasonable to expect that the pion form factor receives considerable soft contributions in the presently accessible gev region .
the aim of the present paper is to perform an analysis for the proton form factor within the modified hsp .
one of our objectives is to critically examine li s approach @xcite and to enlarge the theoretical framework by including the intrinsic @xmath23-dependence of the proton wave function . at the same time
we want to clarify several technical points , which are absent in the pion case and are first encountered in the more complicated calculation of the proton form factor .
the purpose of our analysis is to investigate how reliably the perturbative contribution to the proton form factor can be calculated and to answer the question whether there is a proton wave function
modeled on the basis of qcd sum rules @xcite which is capable of providing , in a theoretically self - consistent way , a good agreement with the data within the modified hsp .
it is clear that being able to identify the leading - order perturbative contribution reliably allows us to estimate the size of soft contributions to the proton form factor , contributions which are not accounted for in the modified hsp formalism .
[ note that the @xmath23-dependent effects taken into account in the modified hsp represent also soft contributions of higher - twist type . ] sudakov suppression ( which can be viewed as the perturbative part of the transverse wave function ) and intrinsic @xmath23-dependence of the wave function may also have a lot of interesting consequences in other exclusive reactions .
thus , for instance , sotiropoulos and sterman @xcite have applied these elements to near - forward proton - proton elastic scattering claiming that their interplay drives the transition of the fixed @xmath24 differential cross section from the @xmath25 behavior at moderate @xmath26 to the @xmath27 behavior at larger @xmath26 , as predicted by dimensional counting rules @xcite .
the outline of the paper is as follows . in sec .
ii we discuss the proton wave function .
the modified hsp is treated in sec .
the discussion of the infrared ( ir ) cut - off prescription in the sudakov factor and its effect on the @xmath0-singularities is given in sec .
the numerical results are presented in sec .
v and our conclusions are contained in sec .
similarly to sotiropoulos and sterman @xcite , we write the valence quark component of the proton state with positive helicity in the form @xmath28 \int_{}^ { } [ d^{2}k_{\perp } ] \bigl\ { & \phantom { } & \!\!\!\!\!\ ! \psi _ { 123}\,{\cal m}_{+-+}^{a_{1}a_{2}a_{3 } } + \psi _ { 213}\,{\cal m}_{-++}^{a_{1}a_{2}a_{3 } } \nonumber \\ & - & \bigl(\psi _ { 132}\ , + \ , \psi _ { 231}\bigr){\cal m}_{++-}^{a_{1}a_{2}a_{3 } } \bigr\ } \epsilon _ { a_{1}a_{2}a_{3 } } , \label{eq:|p,+>}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have assumed the proton to be moving rapidly in the @xmath29-direction .
hence , the ratio of transverse to longitudinal momenta of the quarks is small .
the measure over the transverse momentum integration is defined by @xmath30 = \frac{1}{\left(16\pi ^{3}\right)^{2 } } \ , \delta ^{(2 ) } \left ( \sum_{i=1}^{3}\vec{k}_{\perp i } \right ) d^{2}k_{\perp 1 } d^{2}k_{\perp 2 } d^{2}k_{\perp 3}.\ ] ] in the zero binding energy limit , which is characteristic for the parton picture , one has @xmath31 the three quark state with helicities @xmath32 and colors @xmath33 is given by @xmath34 since the orbital angular momentum is assumed to be zero , the proton helicity is the sum of the quark helicities .
the quark states are normalized as follows : @xmath35 from the permutation symmetry between the two u quarks and from the requirement that the three quarks have to be coupled to give an isospin @xmath36 state it follows that eq .
( [ eq:|p,+ > ] ) can be expressed in terms of only one independent scalar function @xcite . in the sequel
, @xmath37 denotes the momentum space wave function .
the subscripts on @xmath37 refer to the order of momentum arguments , for example @xmath38 .
note that , in general , the wave function depends on the factorization scale @xmath11 .
we make the following convenient ansatz for the wave function : @xmath39 the distribution amplitude @xmath40 ( in the notation of @xcite ) is defined in such a way that @xmath41\ , \phi _ { 123}(x,\mu _ { f } ) = 1 , \label{eq : danorm}\ ] ] where an obvious abbreviated notation has been introduced .
the da can be expressed in terms of the eigenfunctions of the evolution equation @xcite , @xmath42 , which are linear combinations of appell polynomials
. then the proton da can be cast into the form @xmath43 where the notations of @xcite are adopted .
@xmath44 is the asymptotic da mentioned in the introduction .
the exponents @xmath45 , driving the evolution behavior of the da , are related to the anomalous dimensions of trilinear quark operators with isospin @xmath36 ( see @xcite ) and resemble the @xmath46 in the brodsky - lepage notation @xcite . because they are positive fractional numbers increasing with n , higher - order terms in ( [ eq : phi ] ) are gradually suppressed .
the constants @xmath45 are given in table 1 ; @xmath47 for three flavors .
constraints on the da are obtained implicitly by restricting their few first moments within intervals determined from qcd sum rules @xcite , which are evaluated at some self - consistently determined normalization point @xmath11 of order 1 gev ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) : @xmath48x_{1}^{n_{1}}x_{2}^{n_{2}}x_{3}^{n_{3 } } \phi _ { 123}(x,\mu _ { 0})\ ] ] [ eq : moments ] in most model calculations , mentioned above , the moment constraints provided by qcd sum rules are used to determine the first five expansion coefficients @xmath49 , where @xmath50 due to normalization ( 2.7 ) . however , since the moments are burdened by errors , these expansion coefficients although mathematically uniquely determined by the moments of corresponding order @xcite in practice their numerical values can not be fixed precisely giving rise to different options for the proton da . in our calculation of form factors
we employ amplitudes complying with the chernyak - ogloblin - zhitnitsky ( coz ) sum - rule moment constraints .
it was shown in @xcite that such amplitudes constitute a finite orbit in the @xmath51 plane ranging from coz - like amplitudes @xcite with @xmath52 to the recently proposed @xcite heterotic one with @xmath53 .
for the convenience of the reader , the qcd sum - rules constraints and the expansion coefficients @xmath49 of selected model amplitudes are compiled in table 1 .
the @xmath23-dependence of the wave function is contained in the function @xmath54 which is normalized according to @xmath55 \omega _ { 123}(x,\vec{k}_{\perp } ) = 1 .
\label{eq : omeganorm}\ ] ] due to ( [ eq : danorm ] ) and ( [ eq : omeganorm ] ) , @xmath12 is the value of the da at the origin of the configuration space .
its evolution behavior is given by @xmath56 and its value has been determined to be @xmath57 @xcite . in eq .
( [ eq : ansatz ] ) @xmath58 represents the soft part of the proton wave function , which results by removing the perturbative part and absorbing it into the hard - scattering amplitude @xmath5 .
the perturbative tail of the full wave function behaves as @xmath59 for large @xmath23 , whereas the soft part vanishes as @xmath60 or faster .
the nonperturbative or intrinsic @xmath23-dependence of the soft wave function , being related to confinement , is parametrized as a simple gaussian according to @xmath61 .
\label{eq : blhm - omega}\ ] ] this parametrization of the intrinsic @xmath23-dependence of the wave function , which is due to brodsky , huang , lepage , and mackenzie @xcite , seems to be more favorable than the standard form of factorizing @xmath62- and @xmath23-dependencies .
at least for the case of the pion wave function , this has recently been effected by zhitnitsky @xcite on the basis of qcd sum rules .
he finds that a factorizing wave function is in conflict with some general theoretical constraints which any reasonable wave function should comply .
zhitnitsky s qcd sum - rule analysis of the pion wave function seems to indicate that the @xmath23-distribution may also show a double - hump structure , which means that small and large values of @xmath23 are favored relative to intermediate values .
it is likely that the proton wave function may exhibit a similar behavior , though this kind of analysis has yet to be done . for the purposes of the present work we ignore this possibility
in ( [ eq : blhm - omega ] ) the parameter @xmath63 controls the root mean square transverse momentum ( r.m.s . ) , @xmath64 , and the r.m.s .
transverse radius of the proton valence fock state . from the known charge radius of the proton
, we expect the r.m.s .
transverse momentum to be larger than about @xmath65 mev .
the actual value of @xmath64 may be much larger than @xmath65 mev , e.g. , 600 mev or so .
indeed , sotiropoulos and sterman @xcite show that application of the modified hsp to proton - proton elastic scattering leads to an approximate @xmath25-behavior of the differential cross section at moderate @xmath66 .
the behavior @xmath67 , predicted by dimensional counting , appears only at very large @xmath66 . at precisely which value of @xmath66
the transition from the @xmath25 to the @xmath27 behavior occurs , depends on the transverse size of the valence fock state of the proton . since the isr @xcite and
the fnal @xcite data are rather compatible with a @xmath25-behavior of the differential cross section , sotiropoulos and sterman conclude that the transverse size of the proton is small , perhaps @xmath68 fm .
correspondingly , the r.m.s .
transverse momentum is larger than 600 mev . it is worth noting that such a value is supported by the findings of the emc group @xcite in a study of the transverse momentum distribution in semi - inclusive deep inelastic @xmath69 scattering .
a phenomenologically successful approach to the hsp , in which baryons are viewed as bound states of a quark and an effective diquark , also uses a value of this size for @xmath64 @xcite .
there is a second constraint on the wave function , _ viz . _ the probability for finding three valence quarks in the proton : @xmath70 \frac{2\left(\phi _ { 123}(x)\right)^{2 } + \phi _ { 132}(x ) \phi
_ { 231}(x)}{x_{1}x_{2}x_{3 } } \leq 1.\ ] ] in our numerical analysis to be presented in sec . 5 ,
we make use of two different values of the r.m.s . transverse momentum , namely , one which is obtained by the requirement @xmath71 for a given wave function .
[ this corresponds to the minimum value of the r.m.s . transverse momentum . ] the other option for the r.m.s .
transverse momentum we consider is the rather large value of 600 mev . in the latter case
, the probability for the valence quark fock state depends on the wave function .
following li @xcite , we write the proton form factor in the form @xmath72[dx ' ] \int_{}^{}[d{}^{2}k_{\perp}][d{}^{2}k_{\perp}^{\prime } ] \sum_{j=1}^{2 } t_{h_{j}}(x , x',\vec{k}_{\perp},\vec{k}'_{\perp},q,\mu ) y_{j}(x , x',\vec{k}_{\perp},\vec{k}'_{\perp},\mu _ { f } ) .
\label{eq : g_m}\ ] ] note , however , that our notation is slightly different compared to that of li .
making use of the symmetry properties of the proton wave function under permutation , the contributions from the 42 diagrams involved in the calculation of the proton form factor in lowest order can be arranged into two reduced hard scattering amplitudes of the form @xmath73
\left [ x_{2}x_{2}'q^{2 } + ( \vec{k}_{\perp 2 } - \vec{k}_{\perp 2}')^{2 } \right ] } , \label{eq : t_h_1}\ ] ] @xmath74 \left [ x_{2}x_{2}'q^{2 } + ( \vec{k}_{\perp 2 } - \vec{k}_{\perp 2 } ' ) \right ] } , \label{eq : t_h_2}\ ] ] where @xmath75 is the casimir operator of the fundamental representation of @xmath76 . in the hard scattering amplitudes only the @xmath23-dependence of the gluon propagators is included , whereas that of the quark propagators has been neglected .
it is expected that this technical simplification introduces only a minor error of about @xmath77 in the final result . for the case of the pion form factor
this has been explicitly demonstrated by li @xcite . the functions @xmath78 in ( [ eq : g_m ] )
are short - hand notations for linear combinations of products of the initial and final state wave functions @xmath79 , weighted by @xmath9-dependent factors arising from the fermion propagators , namely : @xmath80 @xmath81 ignoring the transverse momenta in the hard scattering amplitudes ( [ eq : t_h_1 ] ) and ( [ eq : t_h_2 ] ) , and inserting ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) and ( [ eq : omeganorm ] ) , one arrives at the standard hsp result for the magnetic form factor .
although this expression is correct in the asymptotic momentum domain , the transverse degrees of freedom are an essential ingredient of the formalism and neglecting them leads to inconsistencies in the endpoint regions , where one of the fractional momenta @xmath9 or @xmath82 tends to zero .
after all , it is precisely this approximation that is responsible for the inconsistencies mentioned in the introduction .
the power of combining the transverse momentum dependence of the hard scattering amplitude and radiative corrections in the form of sudakov form factors was realized by sterman and collaborators @xcite .
ultimately , it leads to a suppression of contributions from the dangerous soft regions , where both the longitudinal and transverse momenta of the quarks are small . in order to include the sudakov corrections , it is advantageous to reexpress eq .
( [ eq : g_m ] ) in terms of the variables @xmath83 , which are canonically conjugate to @xmath84 and span the transverse configuration space
. then @xmath72[dx ' ] \int_{}^{}\frac{d{}^{2}b_{1}}{(4\pi ) ^{2 } } \frac{d{}^{2}b_{2}}{(4\pi ) ^{2 } } \sum_{j}^{}\ , \hat{t}_{j}(x , x',\vec{b},q,\mu ) \hat{y}_{j}(x , x',\vec{b},\mu _ { f } ) \ , { \rm e}^{-s_{j } } , \label{eq : g_m(b)}\ ] ] where the fourier transform of a function @xmath85 is defined by @xmath86 since the hard scattering amplitudes depend only on the differences of initial and final state transverse momenta , there are only two independent fourier - conjugate vectors @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
they are , respectively , the transverse separation vectors between quarks 1 and 3 and between quarks 2 and 3 .
accordingly , the transverse separation of quark 1 and quark 2 is given by @xmath89 [ note that sotiropoulos and sterman @xcite define the transverse separations in a cyclic way which results in the interchange @xmath90 , as compared to our definition . ]
the fact that there are only two independent transverse separation vectors is a consequence of the approximation made in the treatment of the hard scattering amplitudes ( [ eq : t_h_1 ] ) and ( [ eq : t_h_2 ] ) which disregards the @xmath23-dependence of the quark propagators .
this approximation is justified by the enormous technical simplification it entails , given that the thereby introduced errors are very small . then by virtue of rotational invariance of the system with respect to the longitudinal axis , the form factor ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] )
can be expressed in terms of a seven - dimensional integral instead of an eleven - dimensional one .
physically , the relations @xmath91 , @xmath92 mean that the physical probe ( i.e. , the photon ) mediates only such transitions from the initial to the final proton state , which have the same transverse configurations of the quarks . the fourier - transformed hard scattering amplitudes appearing in eq .
( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) read @xmath93 @xmath94 where @xmath95 is the modified bessel function of order 0 and @xmath96 denotes the length of the corresponding vector .
we have now chosen the renormalization scale in such a way that each hard gluon carries its own individual momentum scale @xmath97 as the argument of the corresponding @xmath0 .
the @xmath97 are defined as the maximum scale of either the longitudinal momentum or the inverse transverse separation , associated with each of the gluons : @xmath98 , \nonumber \\ & t_{21 } & = { \rm max } \left [ \sqrt{x_{1}x_{1}^{\prime}q } , 1/b_{1 } \right ] , \nonumber \\ & t_{12 } & = t_{22 } = { \rm max } \left [ \sqrt{x_{2}x_{2}^{\prime}q } , 1/b_{2 } \right ] , \label{eq : t_ij}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one may think of other choices . however , they are not expected to lead to very different predictions for the form factor @xcite .
the quantities @xmath99 contain the same combinations of initial and final state wave functions as those in ( [ eq : y_1 ] ) and ( [ eq : y_2 ] ) , the only difference being that now the products @xmath100 are replaced by corresponding products of fourier - transformed wave functions : @xmath101 . using ( [ eq : ansatz ] ) and ( [ eq : blhm - omega ] ) , the fourier transform of the wave function reads @xmath102 where the fourier - transform of the @xmath23-dependent part is given by @xmath103 \right\}. \label{eq : fourieromega}\ ] ] the exponentials @xmath104 in ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) are the sudakov factors , which incorporate the effects of gluonic radiative corrections . because of this , ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) is not simply the fourier transform of ( [ eq : g_m ] ) but an expression comprising an additional physical input .
thus ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) may be termed the `` modified hard - scattering formula '' . on the ground of previous works by collins and soper @xcite , botts and sterman @xcite have calculated a sudakov factor using resummation techniques and having recourse to the renormalization group .
they find sudakov exponents of the form @xmath105 \nonumber \\ & + & \sum_{l=1}^{3 } \left [ s(x_{l}^{\prime},\tilde{b}_{l},q ) + \int_{1/\tilde{b}_{l}}^{t_{j2 } } \frac{d\bar{\mu}}{\bar{\mu } } \gamma _ { q}(g(\bar{\mu } ^{2 } ) ) \right ] , \label{eq : s}\end{aligned}\ ] ] wherein the sudakov functions @xmath106 are given by @xmath107 \nonumber \\ & - & \left [ \frac{a^{(2)}}{4\beta _ { 1}^{2 } } - \frac{a^{(1)}}{4\beta _ { 1 } } { \rm ln}\bigl({\rm e}^{2\gamma -1}/2\bigr ) \right ] { \rm ln}\left ( \frac{\hat{q}_{l}}{\hat{b}_{l } } \right ) \nonumber \\ & - & \frac{a^{(1)}\beta _ { 2}}{32\beta _ { 1}^{3 } } \left [ { \rm ln}^{2}(2\hat{q}_{l } ) - { \rm ln}^{2}(2\hat{b}_{l } ) \right ] .
\label{eq : s}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath108 or @xmath109 ( @xmath110 ) and the variables @xmath111 and @xmath112 are defined as follows : @xmath113\ ] ] @xmath114.\ ] ] the coefficients @xmath115 and @xmath116 are @xmath117 @xmath118 where @xmath119 is the number of quark flavors and @xmath120 is the euler - mascheroni constant . in the sequel @xmath121
@xmath122 is the anomalous quark dimension in the axial gauge @xcite . the sudakov function , @xmath106 , in ( [ eq : s ] ) takes into account leading and next - to - leading gluonic radiative corrections of the form shown in fig .
[ fig : gluonlines ] .
the quantities @xmath123 ( @xmath110 ) are infrared cut - off parameters , naturally related to , but not uniquely determined by the mutual separations of the three quarks @xcite .
a physical perspective on the choice of the ir cut - off is provided by the following analogy to ordinary qed .
one expects that because of the color neutrality of a hadron , its quark distribution can not be resolved by gluons with a wave length much larger than a characteristic quark separation scale ; meaning that long wave length gluons probe the color singlet proton and hence radiation is damped .
radiative corrections with wave lengths between the ir cut - off and an upper limit ( related to the physical momentum q ) yield to suppression ; it is understood that still softer gluonic corrections are already taken care of in the hadron wave function , whereas harder gluons are considered as part of @xmath5 .
different choices of the ir cut - off have been used in the literature : thus , li @xcite chooses @xmath124 ( this choice hereafter is termed the `` l '' prescription ) , whereas hyer @xcite in his analysis of the proton - antiproton annihilation into two photons and of the time - like proton form factor as well as sotiropoulos and sterman @xcite take @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 ( this choice is denoted the `` h - ss '' prescription ) . still another possibility , and
the one proposed in the present work for reasons that will be explained below is to use as ir cut - off the maximum of the three interquark separations , i.e. , to set @xmath128 this choice , designated by `` max '' , is analogous to that in the meson case , wherein the quark - antiquark distance naturally provides a secure ir cut - off .
the specific features of each particular cut - off choice will be discussed in detail in sec .
[ sec : singularities ] .
the integrals in ( [ eq : s ] ) arise from the application of the renormalization group equation ( rge ) .
the evolution from one scale value to another is governed by the anomalous dimensions of the involved operators .
the integrals combine the effects of the application of the rge on the wave functions and on the hard scattering amplitude .
the range of validity of ( [ eq : s ] ) for the sudakov functions is limited to not too small @xmath129 values . whenever @xmath130 is large relative to the hard ( gluon ) scale @xmath131 , the gluonic corrections are to be considered as higher - order corrections to @xmath5 and hence are not contained in the sudakov factor but are absorbed in @xmath5 . for that reason ,
li @xcite sets any sudakov function @xmath106 equal to zero whenever @xmath132 .
moreover , li holds the sudakov factor @xmath104 equal to unity whenever it exceeds this value , which is the case in the small @xmath123-region .
actually , the full expression ( [ eq : s ] ) shows in this region a small enhancement resulting from the interplay of the next - to - leading logarithmic contributions to the sudakov exponents and the integrals over the anomalous dimensions .
we follow the same lines of argument in our analysis .
the ir cut - offs @xmath130 in the sudakov exponents mark the interface between the nonperturbatively soft momenta , which are implicitly accounted for in the proton wave function , and the contributions from soft gluons , incorporated in a perturbative way in the sudakov factors .
obviously , the ir cut - off serves at the same time as the gliding factorization scale @xmath11 to be used in the evolution of the wave function .
for that reason , li @xcite as well as sotiropoulos and sterman @xcite take @xmath133 .
the `` max '' prescription ( [ eq : max ] ) , adopted in the present work , naturally complies with the choice of the evolution scale proposed in @xcite .
it is well known that the inclusion of an @xmath62-dependent renormalization scale in the argument of @xmath0 within the standard hsp of brodsky - lepage @xcite presents the difficulty that the value of @xmath0 becomes singular in the endpoint regions . to render the form factors ( eq . ( [ eq : gm ] ) ) finite , additional external parameters , like an effective gluon mass @xcite or a cut - off prescription have to be introduced .
technically , such parameters play the rle of ir regulators serving to regularize one of the gluon propagators , which may become soft along the boundaries of phase space ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
one of the crucial advantages of the modified hsp , proposed by sterman and collaborators @xcite , is that there is no need for external regulators because the sudakov factor may suppress the singularities of the `` bare '' ( one - loop ) @xmath135 inherently . indeed in the pion case
, it was shown @xcite that the transverse quark - antiquark separation is tantamount to an ir regulator which suffices to cancel all singularities from the soft region .
concerning the proton form factor , the situation is much more complicated because more scales are involved and hence the choice of the appropriate ir cut - off parameters @xmath123 is not obvious , as discussed in sec .
iii . as we shall effect in the following
, the cancellation of the @xmath0-singularities by the sudakov factor depends sensitively on that particular choice . in fig .
[ fig : sudakov ] we display the exponential of the sudakov function @xmath136 $ ] for @xmath137 by imposing li s requirement @xcite : @xmath138 whenever @xmath139 .
ultimately , the cancellation of the @xmath0-singularities relies on the fact that whenever one of the @xmath0 tends to infinity ( owing to the limit @xmath140 ) , the sudakov factor @xmath104 rapidly decreases to zero . as it can be observed from fig .
[ fig : sudakov ] this is not the case in the region determined by @xmath141 and simultaneously @xmath142 , where @xmath136 $ ] is fixed to unity . in the pion case
this does not matter , since the other @xmath143\to 0 $ ] faster than any power of @xmath144 $ ] and , consequently , the sudakov factor drops to zero .
in contrast , the treatment of the proton form factor is more subtle . in that case
, @xmath104 does not necessarily vanish fast enough to guarantee the cancellation of the @xmath0-singularities .
this can be illustrated by the following configuration : if , say , @xmath145 and @xmath146 then @xmath147 and @xmath148 can have any value between 0 and @xmath149 .
since @xmath150 is unrestricted within the limits @xmath151 and @xmath152 , the corresponding exponentials of the sudakov functions @xmath153 $ ] and @xmath154 $ ] do not automatically fall off to zero in order to yield sufficient suppression of the @xmath0-singularities , unless all three @xmath123 are coerced to be equal .
if the three @xmath123 are allowed to be different , then the sudakov factor provides suppression only through the contributions of the anomalous dimensions . according to the `` l '' and `` h - ss '' prescriptions , which , in general , allow for different @xmath123 in the sudakov functions , the integrand in ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) has singularities behaving as @xmath155 for @xmath156 and @xmath157 hold fixed .
the maximum degree of divergence is given by @xmath158 where the first term @xmath159 comes from the evolution of @xmath12 , ( [ eq : f_n ] ) and the constant @xmath160 is related to the anomalous dimension driving the evolution behavior of the proton da , see ( [ eq : phi ] ) and table 1 : @xmath160 is the maximum value of the @xmath161 within a given polynomial order of the expansion of the da . we reiterate that the @xmath45 are positive fractional numbers increasing with @xmath162 .
thus the singular behavior of the integrand becomes worse as the expansion in terms of appell polynomials extends to higher and higher orders .
the term @xmath163 in ( [ eq : kappa ] ) stems from the integrations over the anomalous dimensions in the sudakov factor @xmath104 ( see ( [ eq : s ] ) ) .
finally , the term @xmath152 originates from that @xmath164 which becomes singular in ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) , c.f .
, ( [ eq : t_ij ] ) .
which one of the @xmath0 couplings becomes actually singular , depends on the prescription imposed on the ir cut - off parameters @xmath123 .
the integral ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) does not exist if @xmath165 .
as table 1 reveals , this happens already for proton das which include appell polynomials of order 1 , i.e. , for all das except for the asymptotic one : @xmath17 .
thus application of the `` l '' and `` h - ss '' prescriptions on the choice of the ir cut - off parameters @xmath123 to the proton form factor entails the modified hsp to be invalid .
in view of these results , li s analysis of the proton form factor @xcite seems to be seriously flawed .
a simple recipe to bypass the singular behavior of the integrand is to ignore completely the evolution of the da or to `` freeze '' it at any ( arbitrary ) value larger than @xmath166 .
hyer @xcite suggested to take for the factorization scale @xmath167 . in this case
, the @xmath160 appears in ( [ eq : kappa ] ) only if all three @xmath123 tend to @xmath168 at once .
but then at least one of the @xmath136 $ ] drops to @xmath151 faster than any power of @xmath169 .
apparently , hyer s choice of the factorization scale avoids singularities of the form ( [ eq : sing ] ) , but seems to us physically implausible .
since he only presents numerical results for the proton form factor in the time - like region , we can not compare with his results directly .
another option , and actually the one proposed in this work , is to use a common ir cut - off not only for the evolution of the wave function but also in the sudakov exponent . for a common cut - off @xmath170
, the sudakov factors always cancel the @xmath0-singularities ; if , for a given @xmath171 , we are in the dangerous region , @xmath172 , @xmath173 , at least one of the other two sudakov functions lies in the region @xmath174 , @xmath173 ( @xmath175 ) and therefore provides sufficient suppression , as outlined above . in particular , we favor @xmath176 as the optimum choice ( `` max '' prescription ) , since it does not only lead to a regular integral but also to a non - singular integrand .
the sudakov factor @xmath177 subject to the `` l '' and `` max '' prescriptions is plotted for a specific quark configuration in fig . [
fig : bcplots ] .
this figure makes it apparent that the sudakov factor in connection with the `` max '' prescription is unencumbered by singularities in the dangerous soft regions . as a consequence of the regularizing power of the `` max '' prescription , the perturbative contribution to the proton form factor ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) saturates in the sense that the results become insensitive to the inclusion of the soft regions .
a saturation as strong as possible is a prerequisite for the self - consistency of the modified hsp , as will be discussed in sec . v. to demonstrate the amount of saturation
, we calculate the proton form factor through ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) , employing a cut - off procedure to the @xmath96-integrations at a maximum value @xmath178 . in fig .
[ fig : g_m(b_c ) ] the dependence of @xmath16 on @xmath178 for the three choices , labeled : `` l '' , `` h - ss '' , and `` max '' is shown using , for reasons of comparison with previous works , the coz da and ignoring evolution .
[ evolution has been dispensed with to avoid the concomitant singularity in @xmath179 as @xmath180 when imposing the `` l '' and `` h - ss '' prescriptions . ]
as one sees from the figure , the `` max '' prescription leads indeed to saturation ; the soft region @xmath181 does not contribute to the form factor substantially .
in fact , already @xmath182 of the result are obtained from the regions with @xmath183 .
note that @xmath0 increases to a value of @xmath184 at @xmath185 .
this indicates that a sizeable fraction of the contributions to the form factor is accumulated in the perturbative region .
unfortunately , this saturation is achieved at the expense of a rather strong damping of the perturbative contribution to the proton form factor . using the two other prescriptions ( `` l '' and `` h - ss '' ) and ignoring evolution , we have found larger results for @xmath16 , but no indication for saturation : the additional contributions to the form factor gained this way are accumulated exclusively in the soft regions , i.e. , for values of @xmath186 near @xmath152 .
these findings are in evident contradiction to li s results ( figure 5 in @xcite ) for which an acceptable saturation has been claimed . on the other hand
, we can qualitatively confirm the saturation behavior of the proton form factor calculated by hyer @xcite in the time - like region .
since we regard a saturation behavior as a stringent test for the self - consistent applicability of pqcd , calculations which accumulate large contributions from soft regions ( large @xmath178 ) can not be considered as theoretically legitimate .
the rle of the evolution effect subject to the `` max '' prescription is also exhibited in fig .
[ fig : g_m(b_c ) ] .
it shows that the effect of evolution is large , although finite , owing to the strong suppression provided by the sudakov factor .
note that according to our discussion in sec .
iii , the factorization scale is @xmath187 .
the significant feature of the evolution effect is that it tends to neutralize the influence of the ir cut - off .
thus one obtains larger values of the proton form factor at the expense of a slightly worse saturation .
in this section we give numerical results for the proton form factor . in these calculations
we throughout employ the `` max '' prescription with evolution included , using @xmath188180 mev and @xmath189 gev . before proceeding with the presentation of our final results ,
let us investigate the effect of including the intrinsic transverse momentum in our calculations .
the @xmath23-dependence of the proton wave function effectively introduces a confinement scale in the formalism , the importance of which may be appreciated by looking at fig .
[ fig : g_m(q^2 ) ] .
this figure shows results , obtained for the coz da without @xmath23-dependence and for two different values of @xmath190 . to describe the intrinsic @xmath23-dependence , one can use ( [ eq : blhm - omega ] ) or , after transforming to the transverse configuration space , ( [ eq : fourieromega ] ) .
notice that in li s approach the gaussian in ( [ eq : fourieromega ] ) has been replaced by unity .
the oscillator parameter @xmath63 is determined in such a way that either the normalization of the wave function @xmath191 is unity ( resulting into @xmath192 mev for the coz da ) , or by inputing the value of the r.m.s . transverse momentum . in the second case ,
we use a value of @xmath193 mev ( see the discussion in sec .
ii ) , which implies @xmath194 . as can be seen from this figure , the predictions for the form factor are quite different for the three cases .
the intrinsic @xmath23-dependence of the wave function leads to further suppression of the perturbative contribution , which becomes substantial if the r.m.s .
transverse momentum is large . on the other hand ,
this suppression is accompanied by an increasing amount of saturation , since also the gaussian ( [ eq : fourieromega ] ) suppresses predominantly contributions from the soft regions , viz .
, the large @xmath195-regions .
in contrast to the sudakov factor , however , this suppression is @xmath196-independent .
the interplay of the two effects , sudakov suppression and intrinsic transverse momentum , leads to a different @xmath196-behavior of the form factor depending on the value of the r.m.s transverse momentum , as can be seen from fig .
[ fig : g_m(q^2 ) ] .
the @xmath196-dependence beyond @xmath4 gev@xmath3 is rather weak , being approximately compatible with dimensional counting ( modulo logarithmic corrections ) .
for very large values of @xmath196 beyond @xmath197 gev@xmath3 the three curves have approached each other within @xmath77 accuracy .
this happens when the sudakov factor dominates the gaussian ( [ eq : fourieromega ] ) and selects those configurations with small interquark separations . in this region , which one may consider as the pure perturbative region , the results for the form factor are independent of the confinement scale introduced by the r.m.s
. transverse momentum .
the penalty of the additional suppression of the perturbative contribution caused by the gaussian ( [ eq : fourieromega ] ) is mitigated by the advantage that the perturbative contribution becomes more self - consistent than by the sudakov factor alone .
this is indicated in the enhanced amount of saturation with increasing r.m.s .
transverse momentum . adapting the criterion of self - consistency , originally suggested by li and sterman @xcite for the pion case , namely that @xmath198 of the results are accumulated at moderate values of the coupling constant , say , @xmath199 , we find self - consistency for @xmath200 gev@xmath3 ( for the coz da ) . finally , in fig .
[ fig : strip ] , we demonstrate the effect of different proton das on the form factor . to this end
, we investigate a set of @xmath201 das @xcite , which all respect the qcd sum - rule constraints @xcite .
the results for the various das or more precisely wave functions , since we include their intrinsic transverse momentum dependence obtained under the `` max '' prescription with evolution included , form the shaded area shown in the figure .
all wave functions are normalized to unity and the corresponding r.m.s . transverse momenta vary between @xmath202 mev and @xmath203 mev ( see table 1 ) .
the theoretical form - factor predictions span a `` band '' congruent to the `` orbit '' of solutions found in @xcite .
the upper bound of the `` band '' corresponds to the da coz@xmath204 , which yields the maximum value of the form - factor ratio @xmath205 in the standard hsp .
the lower limit of the `` band '' is obtained using the da `` low '' ( sample 8 in @xcite ) with @xmath206 .
explicitly shown are the results for the coz da @xcite , its optimized version ( with respect to the sum - rule constraints ) and the `` heterotic '' da , recently proposed by two of us in @xcite .
we note that the differences among these curves practically disappear already at about @xmath207 gev@xmath3 , despite the fact that these amplitudes have distinct geometrical characteristics @xcite . since the true valence fock state probability is likely much smaller , or invariably the r.m.s .
transverse momentum larger than of order of @xmath208 mev , the `` band '' describes rather _ maximal _
expectations for the ( leading - order ) perturbative contributions to the form factor ; at least for proton wave functions of the type we utilize .
comparison with the experimental data reveals that the theoretical predictions amount , at best , to approximately @xmath198 of the measured values . this is the benchmark against which we have to discern novelties and aberrations . closing this discussion
we note that , since we are calculating only the helicity - conserving part of the current matrix element it is not obvious whether we should compare the theoretical predictions with the data for the sachs form factor @xmath16 or the dirac form factor @xmath209 .
therefore we have exhibited in fig .
[ fig : strip ] both sets of data @xcite for comparison .
since the two sets of data differ by only @xmath77 , our conclusions concerning the smallness of the theoretical results remain unaffected .
the various model wave functions led to self - consistency of the perturbative contribution , i.e. , @xmath198 of the results are accumulated in regions where @xmath199 , in the range of @xmath1 between @xmath2 and @xmath4 gev@xmath3 .
the objective of the present work has been to derive the proton magnetic form factor within the modified version ( sec .
iii ) of the standard brodsky - lepage hsp @xcite , a scheme which takes into account gluonic radiative corrections @xcite in terms of transverse separations .
this is done by incorporating in the formalism the sudakov factor , calculated by botts and sterman @xcite .
there are already some interesting applications of the modified hsp @xcite .
the significant element of this type of analyses is that the @xmath0-singularities , arising from hard - gluon exchange and evolution , can be cancelled without introducing free external parameters .
we emphasize that in contrast to pure phenomenological recipies ( e.g. , the introduction of a gluon mass ) , the modified hsp provides an explicit scheme how the ir protection of the `` bare '' @xmath0 proceeds through gluonic radiation accumulated in the sudakov factor .
thus , in the modified hsp , one may conceive of the ( finite ) ir - protected @xmath0 as being the effective coupling . by this procedure the potentially dangerous soft regions of momenta are suppressed entailing also a reduction of the perturbative contribution to the form factor . while in the pion case @xcite
, it is fortunate that the cancellation of the @xmath0-singularities comes out naturally , li s approach to the proton form factor @xcite leads to a lack of complete cancellation of the @xmath0-singularities ( see sec .
iv ) . without evolution of the proton wave function the emerging singularities in ( [ eq :
g_m(b ) ] ) are still integrable , but logarithmic corrections due to evolution yield ultimately to uncompensated singularities . on the grounds of our discussion , we are reasonably confident that li s treatment can be cured within the modified hsp .
we suggest to use a a common ir cut - off in the sudakov exponents ( [ eq : s ] ) and sudakov functions ( [ eq : s ] ) : viz . , the maximum transverse separation .
this `` max '' prescription provides sufficient ir protection , since even with evolution , the integrand in ( [ eq : g_m(b ) ] ) remains finite .
a significant feature of this treatment is that the proton form factor saturates , i.e. , it becomes insensitive to the contributions from large transverse separations .
the other choices of the ir cut - off ( `` l '' , `` h - ss '' ) , we have discussed , do not lead to saturation . however , this reliable saturation and ir protection of the form factor is achieved at the expense of a strong reduction of the perturbative contribution to the form factor .
the damping of the proton form factor becomes even stronger if one takes into account the intrinsic transverse momentum dependence of the proton wave function ( see fig .
[ fig : g_m(b_c ) ] and fig .
[ fig : g_m(q^2 ) ] ) .
this has been done by assuming a non - factorizing @xmath62 and @xmath23-dependence of the wave function of the brodsky - lepage - huang - mackenzie @xcite type and fixing the value of @xmath190 either via the valence quark probability @xmath191 or by inputing the value @xmath193 mev by hand @xcite .
a remarkable finding is that the form factor calculated within the modified hsp , appropriately extended to include the intrinsic transverse momentum of the proton wave function , shows only a mild dependence on the particular model da .
the perturbative contribution to the form factor becomes self - consistent in all cases for momentum transfers larger than @xmath2 to @xmath4 gev@xmath3 .
the actual value of the onset of self - consistency depends on the particular wave function and the r.m.s .
transverse momentum chosen .
self - consistency is defined such that @xmath198 of the result are accumulated in regions where @xmath210 is smaller than @xmath211 ( sec .
v ) . comparing our theoretical results with the data
, it turns out that they fall short by at least @xmath198 .
this is true not only for the coz da , ( which we have exemplarily used to facilitate comparison with previous works ) but actually for the whole spectrum of amplitudes determined in @xcite and found to comply with the coz sum - rule requirements .
depending on the actual value of the r.m.s .
transverse momentum , the reduction of the perturbative contribution may be even stronger than @xmath198 .
the fact that in all considered cases the self - consistently calculated perturbative contribution to the proton form factor fails to reproduce the existing data , is perhaps a signal that soft contributions ( higher twists ) not accounted for so far by the modified hsp should be included .
such contributions comprise , e.g. , improved and/or more complicated wave functions , orbital angular momentum , higher fock components , quark - quark correlations ( diquarks ) , radiative corrections to the quark and gluon condensates , quark masses , etc .
also remainders of genuine soft contributions , like vector - meson - dominance terms or the overlap of the soft parts of the wave functions ( feynman contributions ) , may still be large at accessible momentum transfers .
the rather large value of the pauli form factor @xmath14 around @xmath4 gev@xmath3 , as found experimentally @xcite , indicates that sizeable higher - twist contributions still exist in that region of momentum transfer @xcite .
one may suspect similar or even larger higher - twist contributions to the helicity non - flip current matrix element controlling @xmath209 and @xmath16 .
large ( perturbative ) higher - order corrections to the hard - scattering amplitude can not be excluded as well , since their size has not yet been estimated . in analogy to the drell - yan process , these corrections may be condensed in a k - factor multiplying the leading - order perturbative result . however , with our choice of the renormalization scale , the k - factor is expected to be close to unity .
at least for the case of the pion form factor , calculations of the k - factor to one - loop order exist @xcite , which indicate that choosing the renormalization scale analogously to ours , the value of the k - factor is indeed close to unity .
in conclusion we note that it was not our primary aim to use the modified hsp to obtain best agreement with the data , although from our point of view this scheme represents a decisive step towards a deeper understanding of the electromagnetic form factors . in the present work
the focus has been placed on theoretical problems , overlooked previously .
lepage , s.j .
brodsky : phys .
d22 ( 1980 ) 2157 v.l .
chernyak , i.r .
zhitnitsky : nucl .
b246 ( 1984 ) 52 m. gari , n.g .
stefanis : phys .
b175 ( 1986 ) 462 ; phys .
d35 ( 1987 ) 1074 i.d .
king , c.t .
sachrajda : nucl .
b279 ( 1987 ) 785 c.e .
carlson , m. gari , n.g .
stefanis : phys .
58 ( 1987 ) 1308 c .- r .
sill , r.m .
lombard - nelsen : phys .
d36 ( 1987 ) 165 n.g .
stefanis : phys .
d40 ( 1989 ) 2305 ; d44 ( 1991 ) 1616(e ) v.l .
chernyak , a.a .
ogloblin , i.r .
zhitnitsky : z. phys .
c42 ( 1989 ) 569 a. schfer : phys .
b217 ( 1989 ) 545 n.g .
stefanis , m. bergmann : phys .
d47 ( 1993 ) r3685 s.j .
brodsky , g.r .
farrar : phys .
d1 ( 1975 )
1309 p. bosted _ et al .
68 ( 1992 ) 3841 p. kroll : proceedings of workshop on hadron structure 93 , s. dubnika , a. z. dubniov ( eds . ) , bansk tiavnica , slovakia , sept . 5 - 10 , 1993 n.g .
stefanis , m. bergmann : proceedings of workshop on exclusive reactions at high momentum transfer , c.e .
carlson , p. stoler , m. taiuti ( eds . ) , elba , italy , 24 - 26 june , 1993 , world scientific , singapore , 1994 ; proceedings of workshop on quantum field theoretical aspects of high energy physics , b. geyer , e .-
ilgenfritz ( eds . ) , kyffhuser , germany , september 20 - 24 , 1993 s. rock _ et al . _ : phys .
49 ( 1982 ) 1139 ; r.g .
et al . _ : phys .
57 ( 1986 ) 174 ; s. platchkov _
et al . _ : nucl .
a510 ( 1990 ) 740 ; s. rock _
et al . _ : phys .
d46 ( 1992 ) 24 ; a. lung _
et al . _ : phys .
70 ( 1993 ) 718 ; a.f .
d48 ( 1993 ) 29 r.d .
b186 ( 1981 ) 429 f.m .
dittes , a.v .
radyushkin : yad .
34 ( 1981 )
529 [ sov . j. nucl .
34 ( 1981 ) 293 ] j.m .
cornwall : phys .
d26 ( 1982 ) 1453 n. isgur , c.h .
llewellyn - smith : phys .
52 ( 1984 ) 1080 ; nucl .
phys . b317 ( 1989 ) 526 a.v .
radyushkin : nucl .
a527 ( 1991 ) 153c ; _ ibid . _ a532 ( 1991 ) 141c ; j. botts , g. sterman : nucl .
phys . b325 ( 1989 ) 62 h .-
li , g. sterman : nucl .
b381 ( 1992 ) 129 h .-
li : phys .
d48 ( 1993 ) 4243 j.c .
collins , d.e .
soper : nucl .
b193 ( 1981 ) 381 ; _ ibid .
_ b194 ( 1982 ) 445 ; j.c .
collins , d.e .
soper , g. sterman : nucl .
b261 ( 1985 ) 104 r. jakob , p. kroll : phys .
b315 ( 1993 ) 463 c.e .
carlson , j. milana : phys .
14 ( 1990 ) 1717 m.g .
sotiropoulos , g. sterman : stony brook report itp - sb-93 - 83 ( january 1994 ) s.j .
brodsky , g. farrar : phys .
( 1973 ) 1153 m. peskin : phys . lett . 88b ( 1979 )
128 m. bergmann , n.g .
stefanis : phys .
d48 ( 1993 ) r2990 m. bergmann , n.g .
stefanis : phys .
b325 ( 1994 ) 183 g.p .
lepage , s.j .
brodsky , t. huang , p.b .
mackenzie : banff summer institute , particles and fields 2 , a.z .
capri , a.n .
kamal ( eds . ) ( 1983 ) a.r .
zhitnitsky : dallas preprint ( smu - hep-93 - 25 ) ( december 1993 ) e. nagy _
et al . _ : nucl .
b150 ( 1979 ) 221 j.l .
et al . _ : phys .
39 ( 1977 ) 979 ; w. feissler _ et al .
d23 ( 1981 ) 33 j.j .
: phys.lett .
95b ( 1980 ) 306 ; a. schlagbhmer : ph.d thesis , freiburg ( 1981 ) p. kroll : proceedings of the adriatico research conference on _ spin and polarization dynamics in nuclear and particle physics _
, trieste , italy , 1988 ; p. kroll , m. schrmann , w. schweiger : z. phys .
a338 ( 1991 ) 339 ; _ ibid .
_ a342 ( 1992 ) 429 ; p. kroll , m. schrmann , w. schweiger : int .
phys . a6 ( 1991 ) 4107 p. kroll _
et al . _ : phys .
b316 ( 1993 ) 546 r. jakob _ et al . _
: z. phys .
a347 ( 1993 ) 109 d.e .
soper : nucl .
b163 ( 1980 ) 93 t. hyer : phys .
d47 ( 1993 ) 3875 t. gousset , b. pire : saclay report dapnia / sphn-94 - 09 ( 03/1994 ) c. corian , h .-
li : phys .
b 309 ( 1993 ) 409 lrrrrrr @xmath212 & @xmath213 & @xmath214(coz@xmath215 ) & @xmath214(coz ) & @xmath214(coz@xmath216 ) & @xmath214(het ) & @xmath214(low ) @xmath217 @xmath218 & 20/9 & 3.2185 & 3.6750 & 3.5268 & 3.4437 & 4.1547 @xmath217 @xmath219 & 24/9 & 1.4562 & 1.4840 & 1.4000 & 1.5710 & 1.4000 @xmath217 @xmath220 & 32/9 & 2.8300 & 2.8980 & 2.8736 & 4.5937 & 3.3756 @xmath217 @xmath221 & 40/9 & -17.3400 & -6.6150 & -4.5227 & 29.3125 & 26.1305 @xmath217 @xmath222 & 42/9 & 0.4700 & 1.0260 & 0.8002 & -0.1250 & -0.5855 @xmath217 & 271 & 271 & 267 & 317 & 299 @xmath217 & 0.9893 & 0.9939 & 1.0069 & 0.8537 & 0.9217 @xmath217 | the behavior of the proton magnetic form factor is studied within the modified hard scattering picture , which takes into account gluonic radiative corrections in terms of transverse separations .
we parallel the analysis given previously by li and make apparent a number of serious objections .
the appropriate cut - off needed to render the form - factor calculation finite is both detailed and analyzed by considering different cut - off prescriptions .
the use of the maximum interquark separation as a common infrared cut - off in the sudakov suppression factor is proposed , since it avoids difficulties with the @xmath0-singularities and yields a proton form factor insensitive to the inclusion of the soft region which therefore can be confidently attributed to perturbative qcd .
results are presented for a variety of proton wave functions including also their intrinsic transverse momentum .
it turns out that the perturbative contribution , although theoretically self - consistent for @xmath1 larger than about @xmath2 gev@xmath3 to @xmath4 gev@xmath3 , is too small compared to the data .
= 0 |
lattice calculations of quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) give firm evidence that nuclear matter undergoes a phase transition to a plasma state at a certain temperature @xmath0 of about 170 to 180 mev .
calculations have been performed at a chemical potential @xmath1 .
recent results are for staggered fermions @xcite and renormalization group improved wilson fermions @xcite .
the low density region reflects , e.g. , the scenario during the evolution of the early universe . to achieve information from lattice calculations at small @xmath2 several methods
have recently been developed , i.e. , multiparameter reweighting @xcite , taylor expansion at @xmath3 @xcite , imaginary @xmath2 @xcite .
the region of validity is approximately @xmath4 @xcite .
effective approaches to qcd indicate an extremely rich phase diagram also for @xmath5 @xcite .
experimentally the qcd phase diagram is accessible to heavy ion collisions . in particular relativistic heavy ion collision at sps / cern and
rhic / bnl explore the region where hadronic degrees of freedom are expected to be dissolved .
some results of rhic are now available that give hints of a non - hadronic state of matter @xcite . on the other hand light - front quantization of qcd
can provide a rigorous alternative to lattice qcd @xcite .
although the calculational challenge in real qcd of 3 + 1 dimension seems large ( as does lattice qcd ) it starts also from the fundamental qcd .
the light - front quantization of qcd has the particular advantage that it is completely formulated in physical degrees of freedom .
it has emerged as a promising method for solving problems in the strong coupling regime .
light front quantization makes it possible to investigate quantum field theory in a hamiltonian formulation @xcite .
this makes it well suited for its application to systems of finite temperature ( and density ) .
the relevant field theory has to be quantized on the light front as well , which is presently being developed @xcite .
i present the light - front field theory at finite temperatures and densities in the next section . for the time
being it is applied to the nambu - jona - lasinio model ( njl ) model @xcite that is a powerful tool to investigate the non - perturbative region of qcd as it exhibits spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry and the appearance of goldstone bosons in a transparent way .
finally , going a step further i shall give the general in - medium light cone time ordered green functions that allow us to treat quark correlations that lead to hadronization .
the four - momentum operator @xmath6 on the light - front is given by ( notation of ref .
@xcite ) @xmath7 where @xmath8 denotes the energy momentum tensor defined through the lagrangian of the system and @xmath9 is the quantization surface .
the hamiltonian is given by @xmath10 . to investigate a grand canonical ensemble
we need the number operator , @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the conserved current .
these are the necessary ingredients to generalize the covariant partition operator at finite temperature @xcite to the light - front .
the grand canonical partition operator on the light - front is given by @xmath13\right\},\ ] ] where @xmath14 , with the lorentz scalars temperature @xmath15 and chemical potential @xmath2 .
the velocity of the medium is given by the time - like vector @xmath16 @xcite , and @xmath17 .
we choose the medium to be at rest , @xmath18 .
the grand partition operator then becomes @xmath19 with @xmath20 and @xmath21 defined in ( [ eqn : p ] ) and ( [ eqn : n ] ) .
the density operator for a grand canonical ensemble @xcite in equilibrium follows @xmath22 the corresponding fermi distribution functions of particles @xmath23 and antiparticles @xmath24 are given by @xmath25^{-1 } \label{eqn : fermipm}\ ] ] and @xmath26 .
this fermionic distribution function ( for particles ) on the light - front has first been given in @xcite .
the fermi function for the canonical ensemble can be achieved by simply setting @xmath1 .
this then coincides with the distribution function given recently in ref .
@xcite ( up to different metric conventions ) .
the light - front time - ordered green function for fermions is @xmath27 we note here that the light - cone time - ordered green function differs from the feynman propagator @xmath28 in the front form by a contact term @xmath29 and therefore coincides with the light - front propagator given previously in ref .
@xcite . to evaluate the ensemble average @xmath30 of ( [ eqn : defcrono ] )
, we utilize the imaginary time formalism @xcite .
we rotate the light - front time of the green function to imaginary value .
hence the @xmath31-integral is replaced by a sum of light - front matsubara frequencies @xmath32 according to @xcite , @xmath33 where @xmath34 , @xmath35 for fermions [ @xmath36 for bosons ] . in the last step
we have performed an analytic continuation to the complex plane . for noninteracting dirac fields the ( analytically continued ) imaginary time green function
becomes @xmath37 where @xmath38 . for equilibrium the imaginary time formalism and the real time formalism
are linked by the spectral function @xcite . for @xmath1
this propagator coincides with that of @xcite , but differs from that of @xcite .
the nambu - jona - lasinio ( njl ) originally suggested in @xcite has been reviewed in ref .
@xcite as a model of quantum chromo dynamics ( qcd ) , where also a generalization to finite temperature and finite chemical potential has been discussed .
its generalization to the light - front including a proper description of spontaneous symmetry breaking , which is not trivial , has been done in ref .
@xcite , which we use here .
the lagrangian is given by @xmath39 in mean field approximation the gap equation is @xmath40 where @xmath41 in hartree and @xmath42 in hartree - fock approximation , @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) is the number of colors ( flavors ) . for the isolated case
@xmath45 is the feynman propagator . taking only the lowest order in @xmath46 expansion of the 1-body or 2-body operators
the light front gap equation can be achieved by a @xmath31 integration , where in addition @xmath47 and @xmath48 have to be renormalized to accommodate the expansion .
for details see @xcite .
the propagator to be used in ( [ eqn : gap ] ) is given in ( [ eqn : lfmed ] ) .
the gap equation becomes @xmath49 to regularize ( [ eqn : gapmed ] ) we require @xmath50 . as a consequence @xmath51 and @xmath52 for the isolated case
this regularization is fully equivalent to the lepage - brodsky one and the three - momentum cut - off . for the in medium case
this @xmath53 regularization leads to analytically the same expressions as given in @xcite for the instantaneous case @xcite .
the calculation of the pion mass @xmath54 , the pion decay constant @xmath55 , and the condensate value are also available on the light - front @xcite .
the model parameters are adjusted to the isolated system .
we use the hartree approximation , i.e. @xmath56 .
parameter values are chosen to reproduce the pion mass @xmath57 mev , the decay constant @xmath58 mev , and to give a constituent quark mass of @xmath59 mev , i.e. @xmath60 mev , @xmath61 mev , and @xmath62 mev .
the parameters are reasonably close to the cases used in the review ref .
the difference between the bare mass @xmath63 and the constituent mass is due to the finite condensate , which is @xmath64 mev .
in hot and dense quark matter the surrounding medium leads to a change of the constituent quark mass due to the quasiparticle nature of the quark .
the constituent mass as solution of ( [ eqn : gapmed ] ) is plotted in fig .
[ fig : mass ] as a function of temperature and chemical potential .
the fall - off is related to chiral symmetry restoration , which would be complete for @xmath65 .
it is related to the qcd phase transition . for @xmath66
mev the phase transition is first order , which is reflected by the steep change of the constituent mass . to keep close contact with the 3 m results we have chosen for the @xmath53 in - medium regulator mass @xmath67 with @xmath68 mev fixed for all @xmath15 and @xmath2
we define the phase transition to occur at a temperature at which @xmath69 is half of the isolated constituent quark mass @xcite . the phase diagram is shown in fig .
[ fig : phase ] .
the line indicates the phase boundary separating the hadronic phase from the quark gluon plasma phase .
results presented in this section are based on an effective interaction in the @xmath70 channel .
they have to be supplemented by the medium dependence of @xmath55 and @xmath54 that are currently underway .
we are now interested in the @xmath71 channel .
since we are going up to the three - particle system , we presently approximate the spin structure .
to solve the full three - fermion problem on the light front even for the isolated case is quite a challenge .
the spin structure is already rather complex , see e.g. @xcite .
therefore the elementary spins are averaged tr@xmath72 ( in the medium ) and hence , for the time being , we are only dealing with bose type particles however subject to fermi - dirac statistics .
our main focus here is to see how such a three - particle system is dynamically influenced by a medium of finite temperature and density ; ultimately , how nucleons are formed in the hot and dense environment of a plasma of quarks and gluons as the temperature and the density becomes smaller and how the relevant degrees of freedom in the fermi function change as the many - particle system undergoes a change to hadronic degrees of freedom . to this end
we need to formulate suitable few - body equations that describe clusters of quarks in a medium .
in addition , because of the drastic mass change , see fig . [
fig : mass ] , these equations have to be relativistic ones .
the equations derived here are based on a systematic quantum statistical framework formulated on the light front using a cluster expansion for the green functions .
the formalism has been given elsewhere @xcite .
we repeat here the basics to make a connection to the previous sections . the light - front time ordered cluster green function
is defined by @xmath73 where all particles @xmath74 are all taken at the same light front time @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
the upper ( lower ) sign stands for fermion ( boson ) type clusters . because of the global light - cone time introduced , the dynamical equation for a cluster is equivalent to a dyson equation with a complicated mass operator that contains an instantaneous part and a memory ( or retardation ) part . for the time
being we neglect the memory term .
this is equivalent to a mean field approximation for clusters leading to faddeev - type three - body equations . for a simple zero range interaction the @xmath77 matrix , fig .
[ fig : t2 ] , separates and is given by the propagator @xmath78 , i.e. @xmath79 the expression for @xmath80 is represented by the loop diagram of fig .
[ fig : loop ] and , in the rest system of the two - body system @xmath81 , given by @xmath82 where @xmath83 and @xmath84 given in ( [ eqn : fermipm ] ) with @xmath85 where @xmath86 . for a fermi system
there are two important effects occurring due to the blocking factors of ( [ eqn : b ] ) .
one is the dissociation limit ( mott effect ) where @xmath87 . above a certain temperature and density no bound states
can be formed .
the second effect is related to the appearance of a bose pole in the @xmath77 matrix .
this happens for @xmath88 and defines the critical temperature below which the system becomes unstable and forms a new vacuum consisting of cooper pairs or a condensate .
this is related to superconductivity or superfluidity . in this case for @xmath89
, we get @xmath90 i.e. both nominator and denominator of ( [ eqn : b ] ) are zero .
the three - particle case is driven by the fadeev - type in medium equation @xmath91 where we have introduced vertex functions @xmath92 and @xmath78 given before , and an invariant cut - off @xmath93 . here
the mass of the virtual three - particle state ( in the rest system @xmath94 is @xmath95 which is the sum of the on - shell minus - components of the three particles .
the nucleon scale is introduced by setting @xmath96 mev .
the isolated quark mass used in these calculations is @xmath97 mev .
[ fig : mott ] shows a shaded area that reflect the region where the transition from baryons to quarks ( or quark diquarks ) occur .
the area is defined by use of different regularization masses . the chiral phase transition given before
is indicated by the solid line .
[ fig : csc ] shows the possible transition of quark matter to a superconducting phase .
we have given a relativistic formulation of field theory at finite temperatures and densities utilizing the light front form .
the proper partition operator ( and the statistical operator ) have been given for the grand canonical ensemble .
the special case of a canonical ensemble is given for @xmath1 .
the resulting fermi function depends on transverse and also on the @xmath98 momentum components .
the @xmath98 components emerge in a natural way in a covariant approach . as an application we have revisited the njl low energy model of qcd .
we reproduce the phenomenology of the njl model , in particular the gap - equation and the chiral phase transition .
we have further given consistent relativistic three - quark equations valid in a dense medium of finite temperature .
we find that the dissociation transition and the critical temperature for the color superconductivity agree qualitatively with results expected from other sources .
however , the latter results are by no means final .
we have shown that it is possible to write down meaningful consistent equations to solve the relativistic in - medium problem on the light front .
the next steps would be to use the njl model all through to give a consistent picture for the @xmath70 and the @xmath71 channel .
further insight into this just emerging possibilities of treating relativistic many - particle systems on the light front might be provided by other theories , like 1 + 1 qcd , the yukawa model , and finally real qcd .
i gratefully acknowledge the fruitful collaboration with s. mattiello , t. frederico , and h.j .
weber , who have substantially contributed to the work i had the pleasure to present in this talk .
i also thank s. brodsky for his interest and discussion on this new approach . in particular , i would like to thank the organizers of the workshop for a fruitful and well organized meeting .
work supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft , grant be 1092/10 .
99 c. bernard _ et al . _
[ milc collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - lat/0309118 and refs .
therein f. karsch , e. laermann and a. peikert , nucl .
b * 605 * ( 2001 ) 579 .
a. ali khan _ et al . _
[ cp - pacs collaboration ] , phys .
d * 64 * ( 2001 ) 074510 .
z. fodor and s. d. katz , phys . lett .
b * 534 * , 87 ( 2002 ) ] .
z. fodor , s. d. katz and k. k. szabo , phys .
b * 568 * , 73 ( 2003 ) . c. r. allton
_ , phys .
d * 66 * , 074507 ( 2002 ) .
m. beyer , s. mattiello , t. frederico and h. j. weber , phys .
b * 521 * , 33 ( 2001 ) .
s. mattiello , m. beyer , t. frederico and h. j. weber , few body syst .
* 31 * , 159 ( 2002 ) .
s. j. brodsky , acta phys .
b * 32 * , 4013 ( 2001 ) .
s. j. brodsky , fortsch .
phys . *
50 * , 503 ( 2002 ) .
brodsky , nucl .
proc . suppl . *
108 * , 327 ( 2002 ) . v. s. alves , a. das and s. perez , phys
. rev .
d * 66 * , 125008 ( 2002 ) .
s. mattiello , m. beyer , t. frederico and h. j. weber , few body syst .
* 14 * , 379 ( 2003 ) h. a. weldon , phys .
d * 67 * , 085027 ( 2003 ) .
h. a. weldon , phys .
d * 67 * , 128701 ( 2003 ) .
a. das and x. x. zhou , arxiv : hep - th/0305097 .
a. n. kvinikhidze and b. blankleider , arxiv : hep - th/0305115 . m. beyer , s. mattiello , t. frederico and h. j. weber , arxiv : hep - ph/0310222 .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys .
rev . * 122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , phys .
124 * , 246 ( 1961 ) .
w. israel , annals phys .
* 100 * , 310 ( 1976 ) .
w. israel , physics * 106a * , 204 ( 1981 ) .
h. a. weldon , phys .
d * 26 * , 1394 ( 1982 ) . l.p.kadanov and g. baym , _ quantum statistical mechanics _
( mc graw - hill , new york 1962 ) .
fetter , j.d .
walecka , _ quantum theory of many - particle systems _ ( mcgraw - hill , new york 1971 ) and dover reprints 2003 . | a light front field theory for finite temperature and density is currently being developed .
it will be used here to describe the transition region from quark matter to nuclear matter relevant in heavy ion collisions and in the early universe .
the energy regime addressed is extremely challenging , both theoretically and experimentally .
this is because of the confinement of quarks , the appearance of bound states and correlations , special relativity , and nonlinear phenomena that lead to a change of the vacuum structure of quantum chromodynamics . in the region of the phase transition it eventually leads to a change of the relevant degrees of freedom .
we aim at describing this transition from quarks to hadronic degrees of freedom in a unified microscopic approach . |
semiclassical general relativity predicts violations of the point - wise energy conditions associated with negative energy phenomena such as warp drives , traversable wormholes@xcite , and even _ _ time machines__@xcite .
however , the same theory can be used to constrain the magnitude and duration of negative energy pulses .
two of these restrictions are given by the quantum inequalities ( qis ) and the quantum interest conjecture ( qic ) .
the qis@xcite impose a lower bound on the expectation value ( in a quantum state @xmath0 ) of the renormalized stress - energy tensor along a timelike geodesic , @xmath1 weighted by a non - negative and normalized test function @xmath2 .
the initial bounds on @xmath3 depended on the modified bessel functions , and were obtained using a lorentzian test function@xcite . eventually flanagan found a more general bound in ( 1 + 1)-dimensional minkowski space for a massless scalar field@xcite , which does not depend on the specific choice of the test function , @xmath4 similarly , fewster and eveson obtained bounds in ( 1 + 1 ) and ( 3 + 1 ) dimensional flat space@xcite .
although their two dimensional inequality is slightly weaker than ( [ flanagan ] ) , their result for ( 3 + 1 ) dimensions is the most general and optimum bound for a massless scalar field , @xmath5''(t)\right)^2\,dt.\ ] ] both inequalities , ( [ flanagan ] ) and ( [ few&eve ] ) , can be written as a more general statement for @xmath6-dimensional spacetime@xcite , @xmath7 with @xmath8 . here
@xmath9 is the derivative operator , and the set of constants @xmath10 are given by @xmath11 the test function is now normalized such that @xmath12 .
it is easy to check that we recover equations ( [ flanagan ] ) and ( [ few&eve ] ) from ( [ qi ] ) , by setting @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively .
furthermore , by integrating by parts , the qis become a statement regarding the lack of negative eigenvalues for a one - dimensional pseudo - hamiltonian , @xmath15 where @xmath16 here @xmath17 is effectively a _ potential _ for a quantum mechanical system .
therefore it is possible to use the point of view of one - dimensional quantum mechanics ( after some technical considerations@xcite ) to reduce the qis to a much _ simpler _ framework .
once the quantum mechanical viewpoint is adopted , it is more convenient to also use its notation
. then the _ operator _
@xmath18 can be written as @xmath19 , where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are operators in the usual hilbert space of square - integrable functions .
this technical construction allows us to rewrite the eigenvalue problem in coordinates , as an ordinary differential equation for the eigenfunctions @xmath22 ( the test functions @xmath23 used before ) ; the _ multiharmonic _ time - independent schrdinger equation ( sde ) , @xmath24 where we have set @xmath25 to simplify the algebra . again ,
if @xmath13 we recover the ( 1 + 1)-dimensional case in the form of the time - independent sde , @xmath26 fortunately in this case , there is a theorem by simon@xcite , which guarantees the existence of a negative eigenvalue for the sde , if @xmath27 with this theorem , the qic can be related to the qis in ( 1 + 1 ) dimensions .
it is also possible to reformulate the qic for a more general set of energy pulses@xcite , unlike the original formulation , which is restricted to @xmath28-function pulses@xcite . to see this clearly ,
let us split the potential as @xmath29 its positive part minus its negative part .
then in order to guarantee positive eigenvalues , the potential must violate ( [ simon ] ) .
that is , @xmath30 since here the potential @xmath21 represents the expectation value of the renormalized stress - energy tensor , it is clear that to fulfill the qis the net energy density must always be positive , i.e. , its positive part must always overcompensate the negative one .
this is a simplified version of the original formulation of the qic@xcite .
the ( 3 + 1)-dimensional case can be recovered from the multiharmonic sde by choosing @xmath14 .
this yields the _ biharmonic _ sde , @xmath31 however , we now need to generalize simon s theorem for ( [ bsde ] ) .
first , via a variational argument , the lowest eigenvalue @xmath32 of ( [ bsde ] ) satisfies @xmath33 \d x,\ ] ] assuming all the test functions are normalized .
secondly , let us choose the following test function @xmath34 we then enforce the normalization @xmath35 to obtain @xmath36 and @xmath37 note that the kinetic term of ( [ eigenval ] ) , @xmath38'')^2\d x}{\sigma^4},\ ] ] diverges .
it contains a term proportional to @xmath28-function square , which arises from differentiating twice the absolute value . nevertheless , by expanding the normalized functions @xmath39 into a power series , @xmath40 we can get rid of the troublesome term by properly setting the expansion coefficient @xmath41 to zero . moreover , to make ( [ kinetic ] ) converge at zero , we also need @xmath42 . the rest of the coefficients can be freely chosen .
then we have , from ( [ eigenval ] ) , ( [ test ] ) and ( [ gexpan ] ) @xmath43 with @xmath44'')^2\d x$ ] . now choosing a sufficiently large @xmath45 , it is clear that @xmath46 implies a negative eigenvalue for the differential equation .
lastly , it is possible to collect more information from ( [ expand ] ) if we set @xmath47 .
then the next two terms become relevant . and
since the sign and magnitude of @xmath48 and @xmath49 are arbitrary , either @xmath50 or @xmath51 is a sufficient condition to guarantee the absence of a bound state .
differentiating twice the last expression with respect to @xmath52 , we have @xmath53 and finally @xmath54 .
that is , if @xmath47 , a necessary condition for the lack of a bound state is that @xmath54 .
this proves the extension of simon s theorem for the biharmonic sde , and it also proves the qic in ( 3 + 1)-dimensional minkowski space . to clarify the proof of the qic , we must recover the notation of semiclassical general relativity .
then the version of the qic we just proved states that the qis imply , either @xmath55 everywhere along the world line , _ or _
@xmath56 which is slightly stronger than the awec . once again , splitting the energy density into its positive part minus its negative part , @xmath57 the positive energy density must overcompensate the negative part elsewhere along the world line .
by proving the variant of simon s theorem for the biharmonic sde , we were able to reformulate the qic in ( 3 + 1)-dimensional flat spacetime similarly to the ( 1 + 1)-dimensional case studied in references and .
in flat spacetime , an energy pulse which satisfies the qis ( and the qic proved above ) must also fulfill an awec - like inequality .
although several technical aspects have not been mentioned here , a more detailed proof of the qic in flat spacetime can be found in reference .
this research was supported by the marsden fund administered by the royal society of new zealand . + ga was additionally supported by victoria university of wellington .
h. epstein , v. glaser and a. jaffe , nuovo cim .
* 36 * ( 1965 ) 1016 ; t. a. roman , phys .
d * 33 * , 3526 ( 1986 ) .
m. alcubierre , class .
* 11 * ( 1994 ) l73 [ arxiv : gr - qc/0009013 ] ; m. j. pfenning and l. h. ford , class .
* 14 * ( 1997 ) 1743 [ arxiv : gr - qc/9702026 ] ; f. s. n. lobo and m. visser , class .
* 21 * , 5871 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0406083 ] ; f. s. n. lobo and m. visser , arxiv : gr - qc/0412065 .
m. s. morris and k. s. thorne , am .
j. phys .
* 56 * , 395 ( 1988 ) ; m. s. morris , k. s. thorne and u. yurtsever , phys .
lett . * 61 * , 1446 ( 1988 ) ; m. visser , nucl .
b * 328 * , 203 ( 1989 ) [ arxiv:0809.0927 [ gr - qc ] ] ; m. visser , phys . rev .
d * 39 * , 3182 ( 1989 ) [ arxiv:0809.0907 [ gr - qc ] ] : m. visser , s. kar and n. dadhich , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 201102 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0301003 ] .
j. friedman , m. s. morris , i. d. novikov , f. echeverria , g. klinkhammer , k. s. thorne and u. yurtsever , phys .
d * 42 * , 1915 ( 1990 ) ; s. w. hawking , phys .
d * 46 * , 603 ( 1992 ) ; m. visser , arxiv : gr - qc/0204022 .
l. h. ford , phys .
3972 ( 1991 ) . l. h. ford and t. a. roman , phys .
d * 55 * , 2082 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9607003 ] .
e. e. flanagan , phys .
d * 56 * , 4922 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9706006 ] .
c. j. fewster and s. p. eveson , phys .
d * 58 * , 084010 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9805024 ] .
c. j. fewster and e. teo , phys .
d * 61 * , 084012 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9908073 ]
. b. simon , annals phys . *
97 * , 279 ( 1976 ) .
e. teo and k. f. wong , phys .
d * 66 * , 064007 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0206066 ] .
l. h. ford and t. a. roman , phys .
d * 60 * , 104018 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/9901074 ] .
g. abreu and m. visser , phys .
d * 79 * , 065004 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0808.1931 [ gr - qc ] ] . | the _ quantum inequalities _ , and the closely related _ quantum interest conjecture _ , impose restrictions on the distribution of the energy density measured by any time - like observer , potentially preventing the existence of exotic phenomena such as _ alcubierre warp - drives _ or _ traversable wormholes_. it has already been proved that both assertions can be reduced to statements concerning the existence or non - existence of bound states of a certain 1-dimensional quantum mechanical hamiltonian . using this approach
, we will informally review a simple variational proof of one version of the quantum interest conjecture in ( 3 + 1)-dimensional minkowski space . 2 |
more than half of the disk galaxies in the universe have central bars @xcite .
n - body simulations show that bars form naturally in disk galaxies , and play a crucial role in their formation and evolution @xcite .
there is now abundant evidence that our own galaxy is barred ( see review by * ? ? ?
one of the earliest indications came from the large non - circular motions of gas in the inner galaxy measured by @xcite and subsequently by @xcite .
but it was not until the 1990s that the presence of a bar in the milky way ( mw ) was firmly established by the observations of a distinct peanut - shaped bulge in the cobe nir light distribution @xcite , a non - axisymmetric signature in the gas kinematics @xcite , ogle photometry showing a magnitude offset of the bulge red clump giants at positive and negative longitudes @xcite , and a large optical depth of the bulge to microlensing @xcite .
all these observations agree that the bar is inclined at some orientation angle with respect to the sun - galactic center line with its the near end in the first galactic quadrant ( @xmath7 ) .
nonaxisymmetric models of the inner galaxy have been produced in the last decade . @xcite and @xcite used cobe data to model the density distribution in the galactic bar .
@xcite measured the properties of the bar using gas kinematics .
@xcite used red clump giants to trace the mass distribution of the bar . @xcite and
@xcite have taken initial steps towards building fully self - consistent stellar dynamical models based on the available density and kinematic data .
existing stellar kinematic observation are insufficient to fully constrain the models , and there is significant variation in the estimates of the bar parameters such as orientation ( @xmath8 ) , co - rotation radius ( 3.5 5 kpc ) and pattern speed ( @xmath9 km s@xmath3 kpc@xmath3 ) .
there is not yet a unified quantitative dynamical model of the galactic bar that explains all the observations in a consistent manner and the properties of the galactic bar are still poorly determined .
+ the signature of the galactic bar should also be seen in the kinematic distortions of the stellar velocity field , since the orbits are no longer circular , but rather are elongated streams along the bar .
the stellar kinematic evidence of bulge triaxiality is still ambiguous .
there has been significant work done in the past on the line - of - sight velocities of m and k giants @xcite and proper motions @xcite in the bulge .
but most of these radial velocity observations were limited to the low extinction baade s window ( @xmath10 ) .
@xcite show that measurements in baade s window ( bw ) alone are insensitive to the effects of triaxiality , and a stronger kinematic signature of the bar will be apparent away from @xmath11 .
the ideal observation would be to measure stellar velocity distributions with high s / n for several lines - of - sight ( los ) in the bar .
a sample size of @xmath12 stars per los would enable the measurements of the higher moments of the velocity distribution and of the average radial velocity shift between the stellar streams in the bar @xcite .
in addition , combining accurate proper motions with these los velocities would provide even stronger constraints on the current dynamical models of the galactic bar .
further , the ratio of organized stellar streaming motion around the bar to random motion constrains the bar s angular rotation speed ( also called pattern speed ) @xcite .
since bars can interact strongly with dark matter halos , transferring angular momentum into the halo and slowing the bar rotation dramatically @xcite , constraining the current pattern speed of the mw bar will provide a bound on the disk to halo mass ratio for the inner galaxy .
the most recent bulge radial velocity survey by @xcite ( also see * ? ? ? * ) measured radial velocities at many positions along the major and minor axes of the bar , obtaining the rotation and velocity dispersion curves .
these observations have addressed the crucial problem of measuring kinematics of the bar away from bw .
however , their sample size along each los is limited to about 100 stars , insufficient to measure the higher moments of the individual velocity distributions or the kinematics of the stellar streams .
our goal in the current investigation is to obtain a large radial velocity sample along several los , in order to measure these important quantities . the basic procedure in fabry - prot ( fp ) imaging spectroscopy is to obtain a series of narrow - band images , tuning the interferometer over a range of wavelengths covering a spectral feature of interest .
the data cube thus produced is analyzed to extract a short portion of the spectrum of each object in the field of view .
this spectrum is fit to determine the strength , width and central wavelength of the spectral feature , and the level of the adjacent continuum .
if there are many objects of interest within the field of view , the technique can be extremely efficient .
fp spectroscopy has traditionally been used to measure emission features in extended objects , and has been highly successful for studying the velocity fields in disk galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) star forming regions @xcite , planetary nebula @xcite , and supernova remnants @xcite .
it is less common to employ fp techniques to measure absorption spectra , but they have been used to determine the kinematics of stars in a large number of globular clusters @xcite , and the pattern speed of the bar in the early type galaxy ngc 7079 @xcite .
and the central wavelength is 8543 .
the increasing stellar density towards the southwest edge of the field is caused by the bulge globular cluster ngc 6522 .
[ stellarfield ] ] in the present paper we use fp absorption line spectroscopy to obtain radial velocities using the @xmath0 line for 2488 red clump giants ( rcgs ) , 339 red giants ( m / k type ) and 318 disk main sequence stars , towards three los in the mw bar : bw and two symmetric offset positions at @xmath13 ( see figure [ cobe ] ) .
this sample is an order of magnitude larger than any previous sample for a given los .
we also measure equivalent widths of the @xmath0 absorption lines that can be used to infer metallicities ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) for the late type stars
. this will be the subject of a subsequent paper ( paper ii ) and is discussed only briefly here . in paper iii we will use our measurements for new , more detailed dynamical models of the mw bar .
llccccc field & date obs . &
@xmath14 & @xmath15 & @xmath16 & @xmath17 & @xmath18 + mm5b - a & 1996 & 17:47:24.05 & -35:00:21.07 & -5.00 & -3.47 & 472 + mm5b - b & 1997 & 17:47:40.03 & -35:00:34.0 & -4.97 & -3.52 & 378 + mm5b - c & 1999 & 17:47:20.71 & -35:56:52.84 & -4.95 & -3.43 & 608 + mm5b - d & 1997/99 & 17:47:39.80 & -35:56:47.85 & -4.92 & -3.49 & 525 + bwc - a & 1999 & 18:03:39.70 & -29:59:51.2 & 1.06 & -3.93 & 718 + bw1-a & 1999 & 18:02:29.41 & -29:49:27.4 & 1.09 & -3.62 & 359 + mm7b - a & 1996 & 18:11:29.61 & -25:54:06.6 & 5.50 & -3.46 & 353 + mm7b - b & 1997 & 18:11:44.23 & -25:54:26.0 & 5.52 & -3.51 & 322 + mm7b - c & 1997/99 & 18:11:30.32 & -25:50:38.5 & 5.55 & -3.44 & 288 + mm7b - d & 1999 & 18:11:44.72 & -25:50:33.4 & 5.58 & -3.48 & 396 + [ obs ]
observations were made between 1996 and 1999 using the rutgers fabry - prot ( rfp ) system at the f/13.5 cassegrain focus of the cerro tololo inter - american observatory ( ctio ) 1.5 m telescope .
the field of view of the rfp was circular with a diameter of @xmath19 .
the detector was a tek 1024 x 1024 pixel ccd , giving an image scale of @xmath20 per pixel .
typical seeing was in the range of @xmath21 .
each narrow - band exposure was of 900 s duration .
a typical image is shown in figure [ stellarfield ] .
we observed three los : the mm5b field at l = -5 , the mm7b field at l = + 5 , and bw .
there are four overlapping subfields in each of the mm5b and mm7b fields , as shown in figure [ cobe ] , and two sub - fields in bw .
table [ obs ] lists the location of each sub - field and the total number of stars obtained per field .
the choice and nomenclature of the fields was motivated by the ogle survey @xcite , which provides us with excellent i and v band stellar photometry .
in total we obtained @xmath22 stellar spectra .
we chose to observe the @xmath0 spectral line .
the calcium triplet ( 8498.02 , 8542.09 and 8662.14 ) is one of the strongest near - infrared spectral features in late - type stars like the rcgs .
the triplet arises from the transition between the two levels of @xmath23 and the two levels of @xmath24 in .
the temperature of the bulk of the ism is not high enough to excite to the @xmath23 state , and therefore no contamination from the foreground ism is expected .
the 8542 line is the strongest of the triplet and falls in a wavelength region where the night sky is relatively free of strong terrestrial emission lines .
we used a medium - resolution etalon with a spectral response function that is well fit by a voigt function with a fwhm of 4 , equivalent to approximately 140 km s@xmath3 at 8500 .
we typically scanned a range of @xmath25 with wavelength steps of 1 .
the fp images are not monochromatic , because the rays from off - axis points pass through the collimated beam at an angle , making the passband shift to the blue towards the edge of the field .
the scanning range was sufficient to compensate for the 4 center - to - edge gradient by including extra images at the red end of the scan .
the resulting spectra allowed measurement of the central wavelength of the line with high precision ( 5 10 km s@xmath3 ) .
this project was plagued by bad weather and technical difficulties with the instrument and telescope , requiring a significantly longer period of time to acquire the data than expected . during two of the nights in the 1997
run the instrument shutter malfunctioned , affecting the data for sub - fields mm5b - b and mm7b - b , which upon reduction showed large deviations in kinematics compared to the neighboring fields that overlap with them .
for this reason we excluded these two fields from our analysis .
because of time constraints only 18 images were obtained for the bw1-a field with heavy obscuration from clouds for half of them , and hence we also excluded this field .
these exclusions brought the total sample size down to 3360 stars from seven sub - fields , of which 3144 are used in our kinematic analysis .
we calibrated the wavelength response of the system with several lines around 8542 from a neon spectral lamp .
the complete calibration sequence was done once per observing run , and was stable over the duration of the run ( and indeed from year to year ) .
the precision of the wavelength calibration was typically better than @xmath26 , corresponding to 1.8 km s@xmath3at 8500 .
the zero - point of the wavelength scale was affected by changes in the environmental conditions such as temperature and atmospheric pressure , and was monitored by taking a single neon calibration image once each hour during the observations . the wavelength zero - point for each observation image
was determined by interpolation from these hourly calibrations . on images that have night sky lines within their spectral range , we can also use these sky lines to check the zero point .
there were two weak oh lines ( at 8548.71 & 8538.67 ; @xcite ) that fall within our scanning range .
although these lines had very low s / n , the zero - point we measured from them for a few frames was consistent with the interpolated calibration ring measurement .
+ the images in each data cube are overscan corrected , trimmed and bias subtracted using iraf . to perform photometry on the individual images we use the daophot stand - alone package by @xcite that was specially developed to perform crowded field stellar photometry .
the task find gives the initial centroids of all the stars in the field .
after performing the initial aperture photometry using the phot task , psf - based photometry is performed using a quadratically variable psf , which we found to be especially useful at the edges of the field .
we used about 50 100 stars per image to determine the psf .
the allstar task then simultaneously fits all of the stars in the image using the measured psf to give a star subtracted image , and fluxes and positions for all stars . because daophot performs local sky subtraction , the fluxes are not affected by the presence of the weak oh sky lines .
daophot includes the allframe @xcite program that is particularly useful for reducing a data cube .
it simultaneously performs the psf fitting for all stars in all the images of the cube to derive positions and magnitudes in a self - consistent manner , making use of the geometric transformations between the individual images and photometry information for all images .
because our fields are much less crowded than , for example , a globular cluster , daophot is able to resolve the stars easily .
the final output of daophot are the centroids , fluxes ( in arbitrary units ) and flux uncertainty for each star . in fp absorption line work
, it is critically important to account for changes in flux due to variations in atmospheric transmission
. this can be significant if the images of a spectral scan were taken over several nights or even in different years , or in non - photometric weather conditions . to measure the image - to - image normalization , we select about 30 high s / n stars uniformly covering the fov , so that there is a range in velocity and wavelength coverage .
we assume that all of these stars have a single dominant absorption line that is well represented by a voigt function .
we fit a voigt profile to the spectrum of each star , and at each point calculate the ratio of the fit to the observed flux . for each image in the scan , we then calculate the mean and standard deviation of these ratios , using all of the normalization stars for that image .
this ratio is the normalization factor for that image .
if an image was taken in average transparency conditions , then its normalization factor should be 1.0 , within the photometric uncertainty ; if the image had lower transparency , the normalization will be greater than unity .
we correct the fluxes for each image in the scan using the individual normalization factors . in order to determine the final normalization factors
, we re - fit the profile to the normalized data , and iterate the entire process until it converges .
this procedure introduces an additional uncertainty in the flux measurement , which we call the ` normalization uncertainty ' .
we combine this in quadrature with the daophot flux uncertainties . for the highest s / n ( @xmath27 ) stars the flux normalization error dominates , while for the majority of stars the daophot flux error is more important . since the different normalization stars have a range of velocities , and also because of the center - to - edge wavelength gradient in a fp image , an individual image samples the stars at several different points on the line profile ; this avoids building in " a particular profile shape through the normalization factors . under photometric conditions ,
the normalization factors were typically @xmath28 , with uncertainties of @xmath29 . in bad conditions ,
the worst normalizations were @xmath30 , with uncertainties of @xmath31 .
we often re - observed at some of the wavelengths taken under poor conditions , and found excellent agreement between stellar fluxes after normalization .
the @xmath0 absorption line profiles with the combined uncertainties are fit with a voigt function using the levenberg - marquardt method of least - squares fitting .
the fit gives the central wavelength , continuum level , line strength , and the gaussian and lorentzian widths along with their measurement uncertainties .
we find that the gaussian contribution to the shape of the absorption line is negligible for the majority of stars and the line could be fit equally well by fixing the gaussian width at @xmath32 , using essentially a lorentzian profile .
this is because the instrumental profile itself is essentially lorentzian with a negligible gaussian core , and the @xmath0 line in these stars is strongly saturated with damping wings from collisional broadening .
figure [ spec ] shows a sub - sample of absorption lines covering almost the entire brightness range for our sample from i - band magnitude of 10.0 to 16.5 .
the voigt fit is represented by the solid line . for the brightest stars the velocity uncertainties can be as low as 2 km s@xmath3 and even for the very faint stars we can measure the absorption line adequately well with velocity uncertainties of 20 30 km s@xmath3 .
+ table [ data ] lists the heliocentric radial velocities and their uncertainties that we measured for our complete sample of 3360 stars with 1605 and 1037 stars at @xmath4 , respectively , and 718 in bw .
the median velocity error for our sample is @xmath33 km s@xmath3 .
the uncertainties are higher for fainter stars and also in cases where a star has a close or unresolved neighbor . in figure
[ verr ] we show the distribution of velocity errors and the error as a function of s / n for the mm5b - c subfield .
the major source of error in the radial velocity measurements comes from the uncertainties in the flux measurements , which include contributions from daophot and normalization errors . in the case of very high
s / n stars in the best seeing sub - fields like mm5b - c and bwc - a ( with lower normalization errors ) the velocity errors can be as small as 2 5 km s@xmath3 . to check
if the velocity errors obtained from our voigt fitter are reasonable , we carried out monte carlo simulations of the data .
for each star in our sample , we generated 1000 random realizations of its spectrum by perturbing the fluxes of each point of the voigt profile fit by the corresponding @xmath34 individual flux uncertainty .
we then fit a voigt function to each of these generated spectra and find that the mean ratio of the error estimate from a single fit to the standard deviation of the velocities from the monte carlo fits is about 0.97 for all the fields , indicating that the single fit errors from our voigt fitter code are reliable . for the bw los , there are nine bulge m / k - giant stars in our work that are also present in the radial velocity samples of @xcite and @xcite .
the velocity comparison is shown in figure [ common ] .
our error bars on the horizontal axis are equal to or smaller than the size of the data points .
our velocities agree very well with the previous measurements , with a reduced chi - square of 1.02 .
we also have two measurements ( repeated over 1 3 years ) of the radial velocities for some stars in the region where the fields at a given los overlap with each other .
the comparison between the velocities of stars in these overlapping regions is shown in figure [ comm ] where the vertical axis shows the velocity difference divided by the @xmath35 error bars ( @xmath36 ) .
the dashed , dotted and dot - dashed lines show the @xmath35 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 limits respectively .
the stars at the very edge of the field in the overlapping regions may not show up in every image taken in the scan of that field , so they are not included in this comparison .
there is also a 10% chance for a foreground disk main sequence star to be a spectroscopic binary which may result in velocity variations of @xmath39 km s@xmath3@xcite .
we find three such examples of foreground stars with large velocity differences in the overlapping regions , and these three stars are omitted from figure [ comm ] .
the comparison for the mm5b overlapping regions has a reduced chi - square of @xmath40 .
there is one additional star ( not foreground ) in each of the two overlapping regions of the mm7b fields that has a deviation of more than @xmath41 , inflating the reduced chi - square for these fields .
we do nt have a clear explanation for the deviations in these two cases except that they could be spectroscopic binaries in the bulge .
the reduced chi - square for all the stars in the mm7b fields is 1.6 ; excluding the two outliers reduces chi - square to 1.06 . for most of the stars in the overlapping region we list the weighted mean velocity and errors in table [ data ] . for the faintest stars from the overlapping regions , we use the velocity from only the field with the best image quality , where the fit to the absorption line was significantly better than the other field .
the comparison with previous work , and in the overlapping regions , indicates that our velocity measurements are repeatable and reliable .
the velocity uncertainty of less than 30 km s@xmath3 is small compared to the velocity dispersion of the stars in the bar , and will have no effect on our conclusions .
, title="fig : " ] +
we use photometric information to distinguish between the foreground disk stars , bulge red giants and bulge rcgs . since our observed fields are coincident with the ogle survey , we have precision ( 1 2% ) v and i band photometry and astrometryogle / photdb/ ] @xcite .
unfortunately , the fields mm7b - d and a quarter of mm7b - c fell outside the ogle field .
photometric observations for these fields were obtained with the 1-m telescope at the south african astronomical observatory ( saao ) .
reduction of these data using the iraf photometry package gives v and i band magnitudes with an accuracy of 5% 10% .
there are some stars in our sample that have no ogle or saao photometry . for these stars we use the fp measurement of the continuum level of the @xmath0 absorption line to estimate i - band magnitudes . to check the accuracy of these fp i - band magnitudes we use all the stars in the mm7bc field where we have both ogle and saao photometry .
we determine the zero point of the fp i - band magnitudes from the ogle photometry for these stars .
we compare them to the ogle and the saao magnitudes to find that they are surprisingly consistent with differences @xmath42 .
these fp i - band magnitudes are used to exclude foreground stars as discussed in section 6 .
comparison with the much deeper ogle survey shows that our sample of rcgs in the bar is essentially complete . table [ data ]
lists the astrometry and photometry .
the photometry source ( ogle , saao or fp ) is indicated in the last column .
the astrometry for all fields comes from ogle except for the field mm7b - d where the source is the digitized sky survey .
the color - magnitude diagram ( cmd ) is shown in figure [ mm5bselectfun ] for the mm5b field with 1605 stars .
we chose to show the cmd for this particular los since it has the largest number of stars and also has ogle photometry for all them .
the cmds for the other two los look almost identical . @xcite
discuss various parts and features of the bw cmd using the photometry of about @xmath43 stars from the ogle project .
we discuss in brief these features and their selection limits in the @xmath44 plane to be used in our analysis .
+ the first feature is a distinct red clump , marked by the red points .
these rcgs are very useful candidates for studying the kinematics of the bar .
they are basically metal - rich counterparts of the horizontal branch stars burning helium in their cores and hydrogen in their envelopes .
their intrinsic luminosity distribution is very narrow and has a weak dependence on metallicity and age , making them excellent distance indicators @xcite .
they are bright and numerous in the inner galaxy and are located in the region of cmd that is least contaminated by disk stars @xcite .
our selection limits for rcgs towards all three los are @xmath45 , corrected for the extinction ( @xmath46 ) and reddening ( @xmath47 ) values from @xcite .
this i - band limit corresponds to a distance range of about 5.5 13 kpc for intrinsic red clump magnitude @xmath48 @xcite .
@xcite used a slightly different selection criteria for ogle rcgs where they define extinction independent i - band magnitudes .
the effect of these two different selection methods on the overall kinematics of the rcgs is negligible , with changes in the mean radial velocity and dispersion of about 0.75 km s@xmath3 and 1.15 km s@xmath3 respectively .
the latter selection also gives 2% fewer stars at @xmath4and 10% fewer stars in bw .
we have also investigated the effect of varying the brighter end of the i - band selection limit from 13.0 13.6 magnitudes , which produced negligible changes to the mean velocity and dispersion ( @xmath49 km s@xmath3 ) .
the effects of different selection criteria for rcgs will be more significant when modeling the data ( subject of paper iii ) , where it will be investigated in greater detail .
about 210 stars at @xmath50and 39 in bw have only i - band photometry . without color information
it is not possible to distinguish them from the foreground disk stars ( blue points in figure [ mm5bselectfun ] ) .
if we apply only i - band cuts then the maximum difference in the kinematics between including or excluding these stars without color information is about 1.3 km s@xmath3 in mean velocity and 0.6 km s@xmath3 in dispersion .
the 2mass point source catalogue has j , h and k band photometry for our lines of sight .
we found j - k colors for 60% of these stars with no v - i color information .
the j - k colors confirmed that after applying the i - band or distance cut about 96% of these stars were rcgs . by analyzing the field mm7b - c , where 99% of the sample has complete v and i band photometry , we find that the contamination due to lack of color information is @xmath51 , after applying the i - band or distance cut .
this amounts to contamination by only 11 stars at @xmath4and 2 stars in bw .
these numbers are negligible compared to the overall sample size and will have little effect on the kinematics
. thus we include these stars ( with just the i - band limits ) in our final sample that will be used to measure bar kinematics , which now has a total of 1193 rcgs at @xmath52 , 738 at @xmath53and 557 in bw .
the region marked by the green points at roughly @xmath54 contains the bulge m / k - giants @xcite .
this is the same m - giant population used in the recent radial velocity survey by @xcite . in section 7.2
we use them to make a direct comparison with that study .
this sample , measured simultaneously from the same data cube , allows us to compare the kinematics of two different stellar populations in the bar / bulge region .
the feature marked by the blue points at @xmath55 is formed by the disk main sequence ( dms ) stars .
the stars in this feature are thought to be associated with the sagittarius spiral arm located at @xmath56 kpc from the sun @xcite .
we have radial velocities of about 350 stars in this region over three los .
this feature and its possible association with the sagittarius arm is discussed in section 7.3 . + finally , the feature at @xmath57 on the cmd marked by the magenta points consists of the disk red clump giants spread over a distance of about 1.0 4.0 kpc .
we had just enough stars in our sample along this los to detect this feature and measure its kinematics .
the fp imaging spectroscopy has allowed us to measure simultaneously the kinematics of all these features , providing a powerful and reliable way to look for differences between the various stellar populations in a consistent manner .
the large size of our sample allows us to measure , for the first time , the higher moments of the velocity distribution along our three los .
we fit a gauss - hermite series to the velocity distribution @xcite of rcgs to extract the four velocity moments mean line of sight velocity ( @xmath60 ) , line - of - sight velocity dispersion ( @xmath61 ) , asymmetry of the distribution ( @xmath58 ) , and flatness of the distribution ( @xmath59 ) using a maximum likelihood estimator ( mle ) .
an advantage of using the mle is that it corrects for the individual velocity errors that can broaden the width of the distribution .
we use the mle code developed by glenn van de ven ( private communication ; see @xcite for more details ) to fit a gauss - hermite series to our velocity distributions and to determine the velocity moments .
the code gives a robust measurement of the uncertainties of each moment in two ways .
the bootstrap method randomly draws from the observed velocity distribution with replacement ( see sect
. 15.6 of * ? ? ?
* ) ; this gives the maximum possible errors of the parameters .
the gaussian randomization ( gr ) method randomly draws velocities from an intrinsic gaussian distribution with a given mean and dispersion that is broadened by velocity errors randomly drawn from the observed velocity error distribution ( see appendix b of * ? ? ?
gr gives reliable estimates if the individual errors are not underestimated , which we believe is the case with our analysis .
finally , the code uses the biweight statistic to measure just the first two velocity moments ( @xmath60 and @xmath61 ) and their uncertainties ; these are the appropriate measures to compare with previous investigations that had too few stars to reliably determine the higher moments .
mm5b - a and mm5b - c have identical kinematics and can be combined into a single field mm5b-(a+c ) .
mm5b - d is at the same los and overlaps with the mm5b - c sub - field but has a mean velocity that is offset by 13 km s@xmath3 ( i.e. about a @xmath37 deviation ) .
the dispersions in all three sub - fields however agree within the @xmath35 errors .
for this reason we measure the velocity moments at @xmath62 using both mm5b-(a+c ) as well as the three sub - fields combined mm5b-(a+c+d ) .
there are no significant differences in the kinematics of sub - fields mm7b - a , mm7b - c and mm7b - d , so they are combined into a single field mm7b-(a+c+d ) .
the velocity distributions for mm5b-(a+c ) and mm7b-(a+c+d ) are shown in the left and right panel of figure [ vhist ] .
the dotted line is the gauss - hermite fit with the @xmath58 and @xmath59 moments represented by the dashed and dot - dashed lines respectively .
table [ kine ] lists the velocity moments along with their uncertainties .
our large sample size allows us to measure @xmath60 and @xmath61 with high accuracy .
as expected , in galactocentric coordinates @xmath60 has equal amplitude of about @xmath63 km s@xmath3 at @xmath4 , respectively .
the @xmath59 moment is significantly non - zero while the @xmath58 is consistent with zero .
our high s / n velocity distributions show no sign of cold kinematic features that could be related to disrupted satellites , as suggested by @xcite .
+ the analysis of the bw velocity distribution ( middle panel ) is slightly complicated by the presence of stars from the bulge globular cluster ngc 6522 , the outskirts of which extend into the southwest edge of our field ( see figure [ stellarfield ] ) .
the spike at the center of the bw velocity distribution ( shown in figure [ vhist ] middle panel ) is caused by the stars that are part of this cluster . to extract kinematics
we fit a double gaussian ( broad for the bulge and narrow for ngc 6522 ) to this distribution .
the narrow gaussian has a mean velocity of @xmath64 km s@xmath3 and dispersion of @xmath65 km s@xmath3 ; consistent with previous measurements for ngc 6522 of @xmath66 km s@xmath3 and @xmath67 km s@xmath3 respectively @xcite .
the dotted line in figure [ vhist ] shows the double gaussian fit to the distribution and the solid line is the broad component representing the bulge velocity distribution .
we also fit a gauss - hermite series to this distribution and list the values in table [ kine ] , although this measurement is most probably affected by the presence of the spike at the center .
since this is the most heavily studied los , there are several measurements of the kinematics in bw for comparison .
our values of the mean line - of - sight velocity and dispersion are in excellent agreement with all previous measurements of the kinematics in bw such as @xcite ( @xmath68 km s@xmath3 , @xmath69 km s@xmath3 ) , @xcite ( @xmath70 km s@xmath3 , @xmath71 km s@xmath3 ) , @xcite ( @xmath72 km s@xmath3 , @xmath73 km s@xmath3 ) , @xcite ( @xmath74 km s@xmath3 , @xmath75 km s@xmath3 ) and @xcite ( @xmath76 km s@xmath3 , @xmath77 km s@xmath3 ) .
our measurements of the kinematics of m - giants ( in the heliocentric coordinate system ) are listed in table [ kine2 ] .
we do not tabulate the measurements for bw since the globular cluster m - giants dominate the already small sample , and are difficult to separate from the bulge population , making the measurement unreliable . in figure [ comp ]
we compare the kinematics of the bulge rcgs and m - giants from our sample with that of @xcite m - giants and @xcite ( zhao hereafter ) model .
we find that the radial velocities of the rcgs and m - giants stars agree well with each other and with the @xcite measurements .
however the los dispersion for our m - giant sample ( green diamonds ) is systematically lower than the rcgs ( red triangles ) , and is consistent with the velocity dispersion of @xcite m - giants ( black circles ) .
note that the higher dispersion of the rcgs in our sample is not because they are fainter and thus have somewhat larger velocity uncertainties .
the mle method we use removes the effects of the uncertainties from the estimate of the dispersion . in any event , to produce the difference between
the m - giant and the rcg dispersion would require addition in quadrature of 40 50 km s@xmath3 compared to the uncertainties of 10 25 km s@xmath3 .
the blue dashed line in figure [ comp ] is the prediction from zhao s model .
the bar in this model rotates faster than the observed rotation curve at greater longitudes . according to zhao and @xcite this rapid rotation is due to a lack of retrograde orbits in the model . but adding retrograde orbits will increase the @xmath61 of the model , which may then agree with the dispersion of rcgs rather than that of the m - giants .
cccc los & @xmath78 & @xmath61 & n + & ( @xmath79 ) & ( @xmath80 & + + ( -5.0 , -3.5 ) & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & 171 + ( 5.5 , -3.5 ) & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & 98 + + ( -5.0 , -3.5 ) & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & 134 + ( 1.06 , -3.9 ) & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & 75 + ( 5.5 , -3.5 ) & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & 109 + [ kine2 ] is there really a difference in dispersion between the m - giants and rcgs ?
one possibility is that the m - giant sample may have more foreground contamination , which could cause the observed decrement in the dispersion .
our m - giant selection criteria are virtually the same as those of @xcite , who argue that contamination is negligible .
if the difference is real , then perhaps there is an age difference between the rcgs and the m - giants , with rcg s being older .
another possibility is that the m - giants represent multiple dynamical populations .
but at this point we have no means to distinguish between these or other hypotheses .
we plan to obtain more lines - of - sight in the bar using the fp system @xcite on the 10-m southern african large telescope ( salt ) @xcite to explore this discrepancy further .
our measurements of the kinematics of the dms stars ( blue dots in figure [ mm5bselectfun ] ) are listed in table [ kine2 ] .
earlier studies of the baade s window cmd @xcite found an excess of stars within 2.5 kpc of the sun .
they associated this increased stellar density ( by a factor @xmath56 ) of dms stars with the location of the sagittarius spiral arm at a distance of @xmath56 kpc .
the simulations performed by @xcite showed this density enhanced feature to consist of some very young stars ( 0.1 2.0 gyr ) that are identified with the recent spiral arm population superimposed on a larger population of young and intermediate age ( 2.0 7.0 gyr ) stars identified with some past spiral arm population .
we find the @xmath61 to be the same ( @xmath91 45 km s@xmath3 ) towards all three los .
according to the relationship between velocity dispersion and distance from the galactic center @xcite , our dispersion corresponds to a position within 3.5 kpc of the sun .
this suggests that the majority of the stars in this feature may belong to the sagittarius spiral arm population . ]
the dispersion of the disk red clump feature ( magenta points on the cmd ) is about 53 km s@xmath3 , consistent with the disk kinematics .
previous observations have established that the near end of the galactic bar is in the first galactic quadrant , i.e. , at positive longitudes . since the stars forming the bar stream in the same sense as the galactic rotation , for this bar orientation the stars on the near and far side of the bar will have radial velocity components towards and away from us , respectively .
the radial velocity difference between these approaching and receding stellar streams depends on the orientation of the bar , among other things .
since rcgs are good distance indicators with a small dispersion in intrinsic luminosity , they can be localized in space and used to measure precisely the velocity shift between the two streams ( @xcite ; mp02 hereafter ) .
this measurement will provide an additional strong constraint on the dynamical models of the galactic bar , especially its orientation angle .
+ mp02 discuss the optimal selection of the bright and faint samples to isolate these stellar streams .
we adapt their criteria for the characteristics of our data set , selecting rcgs 0.2 to 0.6 magnitudes brighter and fainter than the peak in the observed luminosity distribution for each field to define the bright ( front side ) and faint ( back side ) , respectively .
figure [ idist ] illustrates the two samples for the l = -5.0 field , and the details of these bright and faint samples for the three los are listed in table [ streamdata ] .
figure [ stream ] shows the velocity distribution of the near and far side samples .
we detect a clear velocity shift of @xmath92 km s@xmath3 in each of @xmath93 los . the velocity shift in bw
is much smaller and is consistent with zero .
this may be because in bw we are seeing an older spheroidal bulge population superimposed on the bar population , masking this signal .
the higher velocity dispersion in bw also indicates that there are higher random motions compared to the streaming motions .
our observed shifts of 35 km s@xmath3 are much greater than any possible projection effects arising from the galactic rotation and the location of the near and far samples ( 1 2 km s@xmath3 ) .
this suggests that there are strong non - circular streaming motions associated with the bar .
mp02 predicted the difference of the los component of the streaming motions between the bright and faint sample to be @xmath94 km s@xmath3 based on the e2 model of @xcite .
this predicted shift is consistent with our measurements in the @xmath4 fields but not in bw .
mp02 also discussed the effects of red giant contamination on these shifts and concluded that their presence in the rcg sample could significantly dilute the magnitude of the velocity shifts , so that the actual shifts could be larger than those that we measure .
@xcite ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) used sio masers in the bar to measure the velocity shifts .
they find an average radial velocity difference of @xmath95 km s@xmath3 for sources with distances less than 7 kpc compared to those at distances greater than 7 kpc , essentially independent of longitude .
while their results agree with our measurements , they suffer from a large ( 50% ) uncertainty in distance and large statistical errors in kinematics ( due to a smaller sample size ) . as pointed out by @xcite most of the dynamical models of the inner galaxy
do not predict or even discuss the change in average radial velocity with distance .
the dynamical model of @xcite was one of the first to discuss this in some detail . in their figures
9 and 10 they plot line - of - sight and proper motion kinematics as a function of distance for four windows , one of which is bw .
we have a large enough sample of rcgs to plot los average velocity and dispersion as a function of distance in the inner galaxy , which we show in figure [ vimag ] .
although we can not make an exact comparison with hafner s predictions for bw since they use a generic selection function for k giants , our data are nonetheless in excellent agreement with their model ( open diamonds in figure [ vimag ] ) .
table [ data ] lists the equivalent widths and their uncertainties for our complete sample of 3360 stars .
we measured the equivalent widths of @xmath0 lines in our sample by integrating the voigt fit over all wavelengths .
our measurements of mean equivalent width and dispersion for the bulge rcgs are listed in table [ ew ] .
the mean equivalent width ( @xmath96 ) and its dispersion decrease on either side of bw similar to the los velocity dispersion .
because the @xmath0line is a good proxy for metallicity @xcite , the gradient in the mean equivalent width may imply a gradient in metallicity @xcite along the galactic bar .
we also find that the mean ew of the dms stars is about 25% lower than the bulge rcgs , which is consistent with a bulge that is more metal rich than the solar neighborhood .
this has been the consensus of many previous studies in bw , for example @xcite .
the factors affecting the measurement of fp equivalent widths and inferring [ fe / h ] using the calcium infrared triplet method is addressed in detail in paper ii . for recent work on the metallicity of the galactic bulge
see @xcite .
cccc los & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & n + & & & + ( -5.0,-3.5 ) & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & 804 + ( 1.1,-3.9 ) & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & 557 + ( 5.5,-3.5 ) & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & 738 + in this paper we have presented measurements of the @xmath0 absorption line using fabry - prot imaging spectroscopy .
this work shows the strength and reliability of this technique in measuring radial velocities for a large sample of stars with i - band magnitudes ranging from 10.0 16.5 .
past investigations have mostly used red giants to study the bar s stellar kinematics .
our work is the first to measure the kinematics of red clump giants , which are more numerous in the inner galaxy than the m and k giants .
the main focus of this paper is to present the data and preliminary interpretations , but full interpretation will only be possible with extensive modeling that we will present in paper iii .
we obtained radial velocities for three los in the mw bar that include two offset positions at @xmath104and the central field of bw .
the large sample size enabled high precision measurements of the first four moments of the velocity distributions for the first time .
the symmetric moment @xmath59 is significantly non - zero , and its negative value indicates that the distributions are flat - topped rather than peaked .
this seems consistent with a model of the bar with stars in elongated orbits forming two streams at different mean radial velocities , broadening and flattening the total distribution .
because our sample of bar rcgs is essentially complete , the continuity equation suggests that the number of stars in the two streams should be the same .
table [ streamdata ] shows that this is the case within the poisson noise .
we then expect no asymmetry in the velocity distribution function , and our measures of @xmath58 are indeed consistent with zero . when we divide our sample into bright and faint samples we detect a clear kinematic signature of streaming motions about the bar .
the stellar streams have velocity difference of about 35 km s@xmath3 at @xmath4 .
there is no indication of these streams in bw , perhaps because they are masked by a spheroidal bulge component .
the larger velocity dispersion in bw is consistent with this interpretation .
our large sample size allows us to take the first step towards measuring the los kinematics as a function of apparent magnitude ( or distance ) using the rcgs . as @xcite points out
, these measurements can provide powerful constraints on dynamical models of the inner galaxy . with larger data sets it will be possible to detect the transition from disk to bar , and measure the bar s thickness .
the technique of fp imaging spectroscopy has allowed us to measure the radial velocities samples that are an order of magnitude larger ( at individual los ) than previous studies .
this large sample allows us to determine the kinematics of various stellar populations : bar rcgs , bar m - giants and the disk main sequence stars .
our measurements show that the rcg and m - giant populations have the same @xmath60 but their dispersions differ by about 10 km s@xmath3 .
the kinematics of the dms population suggests that most of these stars belong to the sagittarius spiral arm .
in addition to the kinematic measurement , we have used the fp spectra to measure the @xmath0 line strengths .
we can use these results to measure the metallicities of the individual stars .
metallicity distributions for several los in the bar / bulge can provide strong constraints on the chemical evolution models that can determine the star formation rate , initial mass function , and formation time scale ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) for the inner galaxy .
our measurements indicate a gradient in mean and dispersion of equivalent width as a function of galactic longitude , and a clear difference in the mean line strengths between the disk and bulge / bar .
the metallicity measurements will be the subject of paper ii .
motivated by the success of this project , we plan to use the fp system on the 10-m class salt to obtain a much more extensive determination of the kinematics and metallicity of stars in the inner galaxy .
salt s much greater aperture and larger fov will enable us to measure @xmath105 stars along a single los in an hour of observing time .
we will investigate at least 10 los along the major axis of the bar , obtaining 15000 20000 stellar spectra .
this data set will provide the basis for models of the structure and chemical evolution of the galactic bar and bulge .
we can also investigate the long bar suggested by recent spitzer observations @xcite and search for hypervelocity stars .
this planned increase by another order of magnitude in the size of the data sample will revolutionize the studies of the inner galaxy .
bohdan paczynski was an early and enthusiastic collaborator on this project , and provided insight and inspiration that contributed greatly to its success .
jerry sellwood has provided the theoretical foundation for the program and cheerfully tutored our understanding of bar dynamics .
tad pryor was our daophot expert and statistical guru .
rutgers undergraduates robert polocz and brian schnitzer assisted with data reduction .
the director and staff of ctio provided their usual outstanding level of support for the observations , especially when amazingly bad weather and recalcitrant equipment threatened to scuttle the project .
we thank the director of saao for allocating observing time and dr .
john menzies for obtaining the additional photometry observations .
victor debattista has provided invaluable help in developing dynamical models using these data .
this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france .
this project has been supported by the national science foundation through grant ast0507323 . , c. , allsman , r. a. , alves , d. r. , axelrod , t. s. , becker , a. c. , bennett , d. p. , cook , k. h. , drake , a. j. , freeman , k. c. , geha , m. , griest , k. , lehner , m. j. , marshall , s. l. , minniti , d. , nelson , c. a. , peterson , b. a. , popowski , p. , pratt , m. r. , quinn , p. j. , stubbs , c. w. , sutherland , w. , tomaney , a. b. , vandehei , t. , & welch , d. l. 2000 , , 541 , 734 , r. a. , churchwell , e. , babler , b. l. , indebetouw , r. , meade , m. r. , whitney , b. a. , watson , c. , wolfire , m. g. , wolff , m. j. , ignace , r. , bania , t. m. , bracker , s. , clemens , d. p. , chomiuk , l. , cohen , m. , dickey , j. m. , jackson , j. m. , kobulnicky , h. a. , mercer , e. p. , mathis , j. s. , stolovy , s. r. , & uzpen , b. 2005 , , 630 , l149 , d. a. h. , hearnshaw , j. b. , nordsieck , k. h. , & odonoghue , d. 2003 , in presented at the society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference , vol .
4834 , discoveries and research prospects from 6- to 10-meter - class telescopes ii . edited by guhathakurta , puragra .
proceedings of the spie , volume 4834 , pp .
264 - 275 ( 2003 ) . ,
p. guhathakurta , 264275 bwca-1 & 256217 & 18:03:35.16 & -29:58:12.3 & -4.49 & 1.60 & 4.64 & 0.17 & 11.560 & 2.117 & o + bwca-2 & 256200 & 18:03:31.91 & -30:00:28.3 & -27.71 & 2.55 & 2.12 & 0.12 & 11.523 & 3.960 & o + bwca-3 & 256193 & 18:03:31.67 & -30:00:43.4 & -44.86 & 1.91 & 4.55 & 0.19 & 11.730 & 2.522 & o + bwca-4 & 402256 & 18:03:43.52 & -30:01:46.1 & -17.77 & 1.70 & 4.34 & 0.15 & 11.733 & 1.358 & o + bwca-5 & 256201 & 18:03:30.78 & -30:00:27.9 & 92.33 & 2.41 & 3.79 & 0.18 & 12.241 & 2.702 & o + bwca-6 & 256199 & 18:03:32.87 & -30:00:31.4 & 9.84 & 3.60 & 2.42 & 0.20 & 12.098 & 0.710 & o + bwca-8 & 402258 & 18:03:45.27 & -30:01:32.5 & -74.90 & 3.48 & 2.94 & 0.22 & 12.214 & 3.876 & o + bwca-9 &
& 18:03:36.34 & -30:01:50.2 & -20.10 & 3.03 & 3.80 & 0.23 & 12.020 & & f + bwca-11 & 244433 & 18:03:34.54 & -30:01:37.6 & 32.20 & 3.41 & 1.20 & 0.11 & 12.229 & 4.566 & o + bwca-12 & 412692 & 18:03:38.98 & -29:58:25.9 & -38.04 & 2.72 & 5.65 & 0.31 & 12.215 & 2.595 & o + bwca-13 & 423223 & 18:03:41.96 & -29:57:49.1 & -70.86 & 2.80 & 4.07 & 0.25 & 12.289 & 2.120 & o + bwca-15 & 412682 & 18:03:38.18 & -30:00:51.2 & -16.60 & 2.91 & 4.07 & 0.23 & 12.467 & 1.912 & o + bwca-16 & 412681 & 18:03:38.24 & -30:00:59.7 & 67.05 & 2.41 & 4.64 & 0.23 & 12.476 & 2.346 & o + bwca-19 & 412690 & 18:03:36.96 & -29:58:47.1 & -58.58 & 2.45 & 6.04 & 0.31 & 12.483 & 2.094 & o + bwca-20 & 256196 & 18:03:33.66 & -30:00:36.1 & -24.73 & 2.47 & 3.46 & 0.20 & 12.579 & 1.894 & o + bwca-21 & 412685 & 18:03:42.64 & -30:00:06.5 & 131.70 & 3.01 & 4.69 & 0.32 & 12.493 & 2.927 & o + bwca-22 & 402257 & 18:03:37.71 & -30:01:34.0 & -15.85 & 2.90 & 3.79 & 0.22 & 12.637 & 2.040 & o + bwca-23 & 412683 & 18:03:47.96 & -30:00:38.1 & -17.18 & 3.30 & 4.40 & 0.32 & 12.627 & 2.948 & o + bwca-27 & 412719 & 18:03:39.69 & -29:58:47.5 & -108.48 & 3.33 & 6.48 & 0.35 & 12.787 & 2.576 & o + bwca-28 & 412708 & 18:03:49.05 & -29:59:35.0 & -7.34 & 2.95 & 5.23 & 0.35 & 12.905 & 2.475 & o + bwca-29 & 256222 & 18:03:34.70 & -30:01:15.7 & -18.07 & 3.08 & 3.48 & 0.23 & 12.923 & 1.883 & o + bwca-30 & 412702 & 18:03:37.64 & -30:00:26.0 & -45.72 & 6.02 & 3.66 & 0.41 & 12.877 & 0.925 &
o + bwca-32 & 256236 & 18:03:34.96 & -29:59:48.6 & -76.35 & 5.27 & 4.78 & 0.45 & 12.982 & 3.493 & o + bwca-33 & 412727 & 18:03:45.61 & -29:58:12.0 & -132.32 & 3.95 & 4.81 & 0.40 & 13.174 & 2.579 & o + bwca-34 & 412711 & 18:03:41.51 & -29:59:20.3 & -134.86 & 3.59 & 4.75 & 0.26 & 13.081 & 2.852 & o + bwca-35 & 256235 & 18:03:30.56 & -29:59:51.0 & 44.72 & 3.22 & 4.07 & 0.29 & 13.173 & 2.307 & o + bwca-36 & 256238 & 18:03:32.78 & -29:59:39.1 & 143.70 & 2.71 & 4.15 & 0.27 & 13.132 & 2.736 & o + bwca-38 & 412728 & 18:03:42.44 & -29:58:10.6 & -168.91 & 3.82 & 5.29 & 0.34 & 13.205 & 2.625 & o + bwca-39 & 412712 & 18:03:47.60 & -29:59:15.4 & -65.47 & 3.57 & 5.50 & 0.38 & 13.223 & 2.865 & o + bwca-40 & 412718 & 18:03:38.12 & -29:58:58.3 & 3.29 & 3.78 & 5.35 & 0.39 & 13.150 & 2.474 & o + bwca-42 & 412732 & 18:03:37.09 & -29:57:56.3 & 4.77 & 3.54 & 2.35 & 0.22 & 13.133 & 1.571 & o + bwca-43 & 412724 & 18:03:39.04 & -29:58:28.0 & -153.07 & 4.33 & 5.49 & 0.39 & 13.173 & 1.917 & o + bwca-44 & 412704 & 18:03:38.05 & -30:00:10.2 & -61.60 & 4.52 & 3.80 & 0.27 & 13.141 & 1.419 & o + bwca-45 & 412716 & 18:03:47.48 & -29:59:06.4 & 110.99 & 2.89 & 4.14 & 0.28 & 13.309 & 2.530 & o + bwca-46 & 412699 & 18:03:46.37 & -30:00:47.9 & -130.64 & 3.93 & 4.99 & 0.36 & 13.333 & 2.210 & o + bwca-47 & 412720 & 18:03:45.08 & -29:58:46.3 & 89.38 & 3.35 & 4.34 & 0.31 & 13.284 & 2.242 & o + bwca-48 & 402288 & 18:03:40.62 & -30:01:46.0 & -10.80 & 4.33 & 3.03 & 0.30 & 13.377 & 1.751 & o + bwca-49 & 412729 & 18:03:39.95 & -29:58:07.8 & -102.93 & 4.34 & 4.77 & 0.37 & 13.295 & 1.956 & o + bwca-50 & 256226 & 18:03:36.45 & -30:00:39.8 & -13.72 & 3.74 & 5.04 & 0.39 & 13.311 & 2.713 & o + lcccc likelihood & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 + biweight & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & & + likelihood & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 + biweight & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & & + likelihood & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 + biweight & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & & + likelihood & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 + bw ( b ) & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & & + ngc 6522 ( n ) & @xmath130 & @xmath65 & & + ccrcccr @xmath131 & 15.4 & @xmath132 & 186 & @xmath133 & 140 & @xmath134 + @xmath135 & 15.2 & @xmath136 & 94 & @xmath137 & 109 & @xmath138 + @xmath139 & 15.6 & @xmath140 & 174 & @xmath141 & 167 & @xmath142 + | we use fabry - prot absorption line imaging spectroscopy to measure radial velocities using the @xmath0 line in 3360 stars towards three lines of sight in the milky way s bar : baade s window and offset position at @xmath1 .
this sample includes 2488 bar red clump giants , 339 bar m / k - giants , and 318 disk main sequence stars .
we measure the first four moments of the stellar velocity distribution of the red clump giants , and find it to be symmetric and flat - topped .
we also measure the line - of - sight average velocity and dispersion of the red clump giants as a function of distance in the bar .
we detect stellar streams at the near and far side of the bar with velocity difference @xmath2 30 km s@xmath3at @xmath4 , but we do not detect two separate streams in baade s window .
our m - giants kinematics agree well with previous studies , but have dispersions systematically lower than those of the red clump giants by @xmath5 km s@xmath3 . for the disk main sequence stars we measure a velocity dispersion of @xmath6 km s@xmath3 for all three lines - of - sight , placing a majority of them in the thin disk within 3.5 kpc of the sun , associated with the sagittarius spiral arm .
we measure the equivalent widths of the @xmath0 line that can be used to infer metallicities .
we find indications of a metallicity gradient with galactic longitude , with greater metallicity in baade s window .
we find the bulge to be metal - rich , consistent with some previous studies . |
the objective of the work described here has been to develop a general purpose parallel lattice - boltzmann code ( lb ) , called _
ludwig _ , capable of simulating the hydrodynamics of complex fluids in 3-d .
such a simulation program should eventually be able to handle multicomponent fluids , amphiphilic systems , and flow in porous media as well as colloidal particles and polymers .
in due course we would like to address a wide variety of these problems including detergency , binary fluids in porous media , mesophase formation in amphiphiles , colloidal suspensions , and liquid crystal flows .
so far , however , we have restricted our attention to simple binary fluids , and it is this version of the code that will be described below in more detail . nonetheless , the generic elements related to the structure of the code are valid for any multicomponent fluid mixture , as defined through an appropriate free energy , expressed as a functional of fluid density and one or more composition variables ( scalar order parameters ) .
we discuss in some detail also how to include solid objects , such as static and moving walls and/or freely suspended colloids , in contact with a binary fluid .
more generally , the modular structure of _ ludwig _ facilitates its extension to many other of the above problems without extensive redesign . but note that , with several of these problems ( such as liquid crystal flows which require tensor order parameters ) , it is not yet clear how to proceed even at the serial level , and only first attempts have begun to appear in the literature @xcite .
the lattice - boltzmann model ( lb ) simulates the boltzmann equation with linearized collisions on a lattice @xcite .
both the changes in position and velocity are discretized .
it can be shown that , at sufficiently large length and time scales , lb simulates the dynamics of nearly incompressible viscous flows @xcite .
for the simplest case of a one - component fluid , it describes the evolution of a discrete set of particle densities on the sites ( or _ nodes _ ) of a lattice : @xmath0 the quantity @xmath1 is the density of particles with velocity @xmath2 resident at node @xmath3 at time @xmath4 .
this particle density will , in unit time increment , be convected ( or _ propagate _ ) to a neighboring site @xmath5 . here
@xmath2 is a lattice vector , or _ link _ vector , and the model
is characterized by a finite set of velocities @xmath6 .
the quantity @xmath7 is the equilibrium distribution of @xmath1 , and is one of the key ingredients of the model .
it characterizes the type of fluid that _ ludwig _ will simulate , and determines the equilibrium properties of such a fluid ( see section [ ssec : binaries ] below ) .
the right hand side of equation [ eqn : lb ] describes a mixing of the different particle densities , or _ collision _ : the @xmath8 distribution relaxes towards @xmath9 at a rate determined by @xmath10 , the relaxation parameter .
the relaxation parameter is related ( through @xmath11 ) to the viscosity @xmath12 of the fluid , and gives us control of its dynamics . to specify a particular model , besides the equilibrium properties given through @xmath13 , one has to choose the geometry of the lattice in which the density of particles move .
such a geometry should specify both the arrangement of nodes and the set of allowed velocities .
the only restrictions in such a choice lie on the fact that they should have sufficient symmetry to ensure that at the hydrodynamic level the behavior is isotropic and independent of the underlying lattice @xcite .
the hydrodynamic quantities , such as the local density , @xmath14 , momentum , @xmath15 and stress , @xmath16 are given as moments of the densities of particles @xmath1 @xcite , namely @xmath17 , @xmath18 , and @xmath19 .
the dynamics of lb , as expressed in equation [ eqn : lb ] , provides immediate insight into the implementation and underlying optimization issues .
it is characterized by two basic dynamic stages : * the propagation stage ( left - hand side of equation [ eqn : lb ] ) , consisting of a set of nested loops performing memory - to - memory copies ; * the collision stage ( right hand side ) , which has a strong degree of spatial locality and relies on basic add / multiply operations : its implementation is straightforward and can be highly optimized .
the lb model described so far can be extended to describe a binary mixture of fluids , of tunable miscibility , by adding a second distribution function , @xmath20@xcite .
( further distribution functions would allow still more complicated mixtures to be described . ) as in single - fluid lb , the relevant hydrodynamic variables related to the order parameter are also moments of the additional distribution function @xmath20 , namely the composition ( order parameter ) @xmath21 , and the flux @xmath22 .
for each site ( including solid sites ) , the distributions @xmath8 and @xmath20 are stored in a structure element of type * site * : xxx = xxx = typedef struct\ { + float f[nvel ] , + g[nvel ] ; + } site ; where * nvel * is the number of velocity vectors used by the model . for example , for the cubic lattices described later on , where _ ludwig _ has been implemented so far , the number of velocity vectors has been 15 and 19 .
figure [ fig : d3qx ] shows the sets of velocities for the two 3-d models developed .
( to nearest neighbors ) , and eight with @xmath23 ( to next next nearest neighbors ) .
the d3q19 model has nineteen velocities : one with speed zero ( a rest particle ) , six with @xmath24 ( to nearest neighbors ) , and 12 with @xmath25 ( to next nearest neighbors).,title="fig : " ] ( to nearest neighbors ) , and eight with @xmath23 ( to next next nearest neighbors ) .
the d3q19 model has nineteen velocities : one with speed zero ( a rest particle ) , six with @xmath24 ( to nearest neighbors ) , and 12 with @xmath25 ( to next nearest neighbors).,title="fig : " ] we follow the procedure of swift et al .
@xcite ( see also @xcite for a schematic description ) in which @xmath8 describes the density field @xmath14 , whilst @xmath20 describes the order parameter field , @xmath26 .
both distribution functions have relaxational dynamics of the type of equation [ eqn : lb ] but are characterized by different relaxation parameters @xmath27 .
the second relaxation parameter , associated with the order parameter field , will determine its diffusivity . by studying appropriate moments of the distribution functions
, one can construct a relaxational dynamics that will describe , in the continuum limit , the dynamics of a near - incompressible , isothermal binary fluid with an arbitrary local free energy functional @xmath28 $ ] .
the model chosen is a symmetric @xmath29 or cahn - hilliard type free energy : @xmath30 where @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are model parameters . for the density @xmath14 ,
lb dynamics ensures an ideal gas equation of state , with a speed of sound equal to @xmath34 . in practice @xmath14 remains almost constant at a value which we choose to be unity .
this can be done by ensuring that under all conditions the fluid velocity remains small compared to unity in lattice units .
( more generally one requires velocities small compared to the sound speed . ) for negative @xmath31 , the above model has two coexisting fluid phases with order parameter values @xmath35 ; for many problems it is convenient to set @xmath36 so that @xmath37 .
note also that , although there is a long history of studying @xmath29 theory on the lattice , one needs to be aware of possible lattice artifacts in the thermodynamic , as well as the hydrodynamic , sectors of the model @xcite .
for example , the coefficient @xmath33 , determines the thickness @xmath38 and the interfacial tension @xmath39 of the interface between two fluids @xcite .
but the thickness must be kept large enough to avoid a strong anisotropy of the interfacial tension caused by the underlying lattice . moreover ,
the values of the different parameters should be carefully selected to give the required compromise between numerical stability and accuracy , and computational speed @xcite . however , since the same physical parameters ( in a binary fluid , viscosity , density , interfacial tension ) can be achieved with more than one set of simulation parameters , it is normally possible to steer around any problems , though they do present traps for the unwary .
the specific role played by order parameter mobility in the simulations of binary fluids is discussed in @xcite .
we emphasize that _ ludwig _ is structured so that the free energy functional can be chosen at will .
this is a desirable feature of lb over , for example , the dissipative particle dynamics algorithm ( dpd ) , where the free energy being modeled has to be deduced _ a posteriori _ from the simulation results @xcite , although first attempts are being carried out to allow for free energy _ a priori _
determination @xcite .
the user of the code has to evaluate , from the free energy and according to a well - established procedure @xcite , the equilibrium distribution functions @xmath9 , @xmath40 for use in the relaxation equation [ eqn : lb ] and the corresponding one for @xmath20 .
this data is entered into the subroutine for the collision step .
for example , in the case of the binary fluid mixture in the d3q15 geometry one has @xcite @xmath41 here , @xmath42 is an index that denotes the speed , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are constants given by @xmath47 @xmath48 @xmath49 here @xmath50 is the thermodynamic contribution to the pressure tensor which can be evaluated directly from the chosen form of the free energy functional @xcite , and for equation [ eqn : fe ] it reads @xmath51 the equilibrium distribution for the order parameter , @xmath40 , is the same as for @xmath9 , with @xmath52 replaced by @xmath53 in the above equations ; here @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is the order parameter mobility @xcite . for evaluation of @xmath50 and other quantities ,
we need to compute spatial gradients of @xmath26 . to minimize thermodynamic lattice anisotropies ,
this is done using a larger set of links than used for the propagation step ; for example on the d3q15 lattice we use all 26 ( first , second and third ) nearest neighbors so that numerically @xmath56 @xmath57\ ] ] with an enlarged set @xmath58 . note that these are not the only possible choices
. there may be considerable scope for further improvement by optimizing the choices made for gradient discretization , but we leave this for future work .
one drawback of lb is that , unlike dpd and some other competing mesoscale techniques , it is not unconditionally stable .
however , our experience suggests that even if the model becomes eventually unstable for any given set of parameter values , the problem arises so suddenly that such an instability does not impede collection of robust and reliable data over long periods beforehand @xcite .
nonetheless , it would be very desirable to have a fully stable version of the algorithm and this might considerably reduce the time spent in parameter steering exercises that are currently needed prior to allocating resources for production runs .
the scientific objectives presented in section [ sec : objectives ] are ambitious and imply the availability of a variety of different features , consistent with a development time stretching across a few years . because none of the lb codes available at the start of the project had the required features , _
s creators decided to design a new package from scratch whose main characteristic would be its versatility : _ ludwig _ had to be capable of producing data of scientific interest at an early stage of its development , include built - in support for multiple models and free energies , and be sufficiently user - friendly to be customisable and usable by non - programmers . great care has thus been taken to use a design which would fulfill all of the above requirements .
the best approach would thus maximize code re - use to cut down development time , and be portable and extendible to increase the package s overall lifetime .
the portability issues led us to choose ansi - c and mpi-1.1 .
this combination provided the required features without sacrificing too much in the area of performance .
in addition to portability , mpi also provided valuable features such as support for user - defined operators ( e.g. to perform global operations on distributed sets of vectors and tensors ) and a high level of abstraction through the use of derived datatypes .
the latter is particularly valuable to make all the i / o and communication routines non model - specific . due to the magnitude of the system size required to study the phenomena described in section [ sec : objectives ] , it became obvious from the early stage of the design that _ ludwig _ would have to be parallelized in order to provide the required scalability .
fortunately , the symmetry of the underlying cubic lattice guarantees a uniform data distribution and hence an equal amount of computations per lattice site .
indeed , the collision and propagation stages will take place over all lattice sites , which restricts possible causes of load imbalance to the introduction of solids objects non - uniformly distributed across the simulation box .
this pseudo - uniform distribution of the computations added to the intrinsic locality of the lb algorithm made _ regular domain decomposition _
the most suitable decomposition strategy @xcite . in this approach ,
the data is geometrically decomposed in equal volumes , which are then distributed to each processing element ( pe ) .
obviously the ` ideal ' load - balancing can only be achieved for a restricted class of studies such as simulations of spinodal decomposition .
as soon as lees - edwards walls or solid objects are introduced whether these are truly moving or freely suspended particles such as colloids , pseudo - moving plates to shear the system , or static structures such as a porous network , the behavior of the code will be affected as its overall performance becomes restricted by that of the slowest process . however , most applications described in section [ sec : objectives ] exhibit sufficient symmetry to circumvent the load imbalance induced by the solid objects .
should the solid objects be distributed inhomogeneously across the system , it will be necessary to specify a more adequate processor topology to ensure an efficient parallelization .
_ ludwig _ has been developed with a modular and hierarchical structure in mind .
the current version of the package is composed of 258 functions ( over 25,000 lines of code ) split in three main components , as illustrated in figure [ fig : structure ] : 1 .
model subdirectories : contain all the model - specific functions as well as main.c .
these model - specific options contain three main ingredients of the code : the geometry of the lattice , the free energy that defines the type of fluid to be modeled , and the type of boundary conditions which determines the interaction with solid objects .
users can plug - in their own routines in misc.c .
once the model is defined , the _ only _ modification required to run simulations is to edit main.c to call the relevant measuring functions . at this time
, the models available include the lattice geometries d3q15 , and d3q19 ( see figure [ fig : d3qx ] and reference @xcite for their definitions ) , although this package has been designed to support models with subset of velocities beyond the third nearest neighbors .
common subdirectory : contains all the low - level calls such as the communication layer and the parallel i / o , as well as a set of routines to provide real - time graphics during simulations .
this functionality proves invaluable to gain a better understanding of the dynamics and for debugging purposes .
these generic functions can be called by all models .
utilities subdirectory : contains stand - alone pre- and post - processors for setting - up initial configurations and analyzing the simulation data . the non - specificity of the common routines has been made possible by mpi s high - level features such as derived datatypes , communicators , and user - defined operators . indeed , these routines can be used to define series of generic and opaque objects and operators which can be accessed and manipulated without the need to know their model - specific characteristics . in effect , these routines implement a generic , generalized model , which in some ways is reminiscent of the concept of objects and methods as implemented in the object - oriented paradigm . since the use of object - oriented programming language such as c++ or java had to be discounted on the ground of their lack of bindings for mpi-1.1 and their poor performance on hpc systems , the approach described above is in the authors opinion the best alternative .
the main advantage of this modular approach is the fact that the computational complexity is hidden , which allows the users to concentrate on the physical analysis of a given system rather than on implementation issues .
other advantages include code re - use , package extendibility , portability and efficiency .
_ ludwig _ achieves a high level of portability : indeed , it has been successfully installed on a variety of serial and parallel platforms ( cray t3e , t3d and j90 , sgi origin 2000 , hitachi sr-2201 , sun e-3000/hpc-3500 , dec and sun workstations as well as a linux pc ) with no modification required .
three different types of solid objects may be defined in _
ludwig _ : 1 .
static solid objects , e.g. static walls and porous networks ; 2 .
( pseudo-)moving walls , e.g. to shear the system ; 3 . ( truly-)moving particles , e.g. freely suspended colloids .
all solid objects are implemented applying stick boundary conditions , following the bounce - back on the links ( bbl ) scheme proposed by ladd @xcite . during propagation ,
the component of the distribution function that would propagate into the solid node is _ bounced back _ and ends up back at the fluid node , pointing in the opposite direction .
this produces stick boundary conditions at roughly one half the distance along the link vector joining the solid and fluid nodes , ensuring that the velocity of the fluid in contact with the solid equals the velocity of the latter ( see figure [ fig : bbl ] ) .
let us assume that a solid - fluid boundary exists between a node at @xmath3 and one at @xmath5 , where @xmath59 labels the relevant lattice vector .
let @xmath60 be the opposite lattice vector , so that @xmath61 .
then , at the link , there are two incoming velocity distributions after the collision ; denote this time @xmath62 .
the post - collision distributions are : @xmath63 and @xmath64 .
these distributions are reflected so that : @xmath65 if the solid is moving with a velocity @xmath66 , the previous boundary conditions have to be modified . if the densities @xmath8 and order parameters @xmath20 are allowed to leak across the boundary links , then the velocity at the link can be matched to the velocity of the wall @xcite . in the case of a binary mixture , generalizing the results of ladd @xcite , the basic bbl scheme is modified as follows : @xmath67 where the quantities @xmath68 are geometric factors related to the weights of the different subsets of velocities @xmath2 , and are fixed when imposing the appropriate equilibrium distribution functions for @xmath8 and @xmath20 .
note that the bbl rules given above require careful implementation if they are properly to account for the effect on the composition variable @xmath26 of motion in a direction normal to the solid - fluid boundary .
this boundary condition allows us to have a solid wall moving in any direction in contact with the fluid @xcite .
the velocity of the solid particles can be fixed beforehand . in this case
, one can use such moving objects e.g. to apply a shear flow through parallel plates at the boundaries of a sample , or to study aspects of colloid hydrodynamics such as the steady - state sedimentation of an ordered array of colloidal spheres with a prescribed distribution .
alternatively , if the velocities of the solid particles are updated , one can for example simulate the dynamics of colloidal suspensions @xcite .
although periodic boundary conditions are applied to the model by default , these can be modified by explicitly adding solid surfaces at the boundaries . in the previous subsection
we have shown how to add them ensuring stick boundary conditions .
this is enough for a mono - component simple fluid .
however , for complex fluids it is also in general necessary to specify the behavior of additional fields at solid boundaries , whether these are at the edges of the system or internal boundaries between fluid and solid phases .
for example , in the case of a binary mixture it may be desirable to specify the wetting properties of a solid surface , i.e. its preference for one of the two components . in order to deal with these situations ,
we have developed in _
ludwig _ a more generic way of characterizing a solid interface .
we have considered three different kinds of sites on the lattice : solid , fluid and boundary sites ( the latter are fluid sites with at least one neighboring solid site ) .
accordingly , the links are then classified as _ wet _ or _
dry links _ depending on whether they join fluid sites or solid to fluid sites , respectively .
then , in order to implement the appropriate thermodynamic boundary conditions at the solid - fluid interfaces ( which we discuss in detail in the next section ) , the values of @xmath8 and @xmath20 corresponding to the boundary sites and dry links are stored in two separate lists , different from the basic vectors which store @xmath8 and @xmath20 for _ all _ sites .
note that additional information also needs to be stored for the boundary links and boundary sites .
the structure defined to store this information is called * bc_link*. in addition to the location and orientation of the links , it also contains the force applied on the node and its velocity , in case it is needed . xxx = xxx= xxxxxxxxxx = typedef struct bc_link bc_link ; + struct bc_link\ { + int i , j , / * i and j are the indices of the two nodes + by convention , i is the ( local ) solid node , + j is the fluid node * / + index , / * index is the velocity that links the two nodes * / + dup ; / * true when a duplicate link * / + float frc , / * force on the node at ( r+0.5*c , t+0.5 ) in direction c * / + v ; / * velocity component of link * / + bs_site * site ; / * only relevant to wetting : pointer to the site with the + value of the concentration at the middle of the link * / + bc_link * next ; / * store these in a singly linked list * / + } ; + note that all members of this list have a pointer * site * to the corresponding element of the boundary site list .
links that have their ends on different pe domains ( i.e. partly in the halo region ) need to be duplicated on both pes .
the structure member * dup * is therefore required to avoid multiple counting when carrying out summations over all links .
this structure is enough to implement the bbl described in the previous subsection .
similarly , boundary sites are stored in a structure of type * bs_site * , which includes information mostly required for the implementation of the thermodynamic boundary conditions ( wetting effects ) .
these include the free energy parameters of the neighboring wall , the fluid or solid nature of the * ngrad * neighboring sites ( i.e. a binary map of dry or wet links to these sites ) , as well as the actual gradient on the link which value is required by the bbl algorithm described in section [ ssec : solidobj ] . the extended set defined by *
ngrad * includes all vectors to nearest neighbors , next nearest neighbors , next - but - one nearest neighbors , and the null vector ( thus for a 3-d cubic lattice ( d3q15 ) , * ngrad * = 27 ) .
this extended set of neighbors has been introduced to improve the representation of the order - parameter gradients close to the wall .
xxx = xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx = typedef struct bs_site bs_site ; + struct bs_site\ { + int ind ; / * ( global ) index of site * / + uint wet ; / * binary number specifying ` wet ' and ` dry ' links * / + float c , h ; / * value of c and h in surface free energy * / + float phi[ngrad ] ; / * gradients on the link ( along ngrad vectors ) * / + bs_site * next ; / * store these in a singly linked list * / + } ; + note that the actual implementation of the bbl is undertaken by applying equation [ eqn : mod_bbl ] to all the ( dry ) links in the linked list * bc_link*. whilst the @xmath8 and @xmath20 can be accessed directly using their array index , the link velocities @xmath66 and composition variable @xmath26 need to be retrieved from the structure itself as * bc_link@xmath69v * and * bc_link@xmath69site@xmath69phi [ ] * respectively .
another aspect worth pointing out is that both structures are defined in different directories ( see figure [ fig : structure ] ) . indeed , although the _ boundary_sites _ functions are intrinsically model - specific because they depend on the velocity sets and free energy parameters , the _ boundary_links _ routines on the other hand are completely independent from the model used .
the implementation of static solid objects and moving walls in parallel is simple . indeed , since these objects do not move across pe domains during the course of a simulation , one needs only to build the two linked lists * bc_link * and * bs_site * once , and independently for each node .
the case of moving solid particles is more complicated and deserves further discussion .
although non - spherical objects can be described @xcite , we restrict the discussion to spherical ones for simplicity s sake . in this case
they are defined by four parameter ; their radius @xmath70 , the position of their center of mass @xmath71 and their linear and angular velocities , @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
note that although @xmath71 moves continuously , the surface of the particle is discretized since it is defined by the lattice links which would cross the surface .
each particle can therefore be defined as follows : xxx = xxx= xxxxxxxxxxx = typedef struct colloid colloid ; + struct colloid\ { + int index ; / * global index of colloid ( 0 .. n_colloid-1 ) * / + fvector r , / * position of the center of mass * / + v , w , / * linear and angular velocity of the center of mass * / + t , f ; / * torque and force * / + float r ; / * radius * / + int * pe ; / * list of pe domains span by this colloid * / + int local ; / * true for local pe , false otherwise * / + coll_link * lnk ; / * pointer to list of links ( surface ) * / + colloid * next ; / * store these in a singly linked list * / + } ; + where the list of links required to describe the surface of each colloid is stored in a separate linked list of type * coll_link * : xxx = xxx= xxxxxxxxxxxx = typedef struct coll_link coll_link ; + struct coll_link\ { + int i , j , / * i and j are the indices of the two nodes + by convention , i is the inner node , + j is the outer node * / + index , / * index is the velocity that links the two nodes * / + dup , / * true when a duplicate link + ( set when crossing different pe domains ) * / + local ; / * true for local pe , false otherwise * / + float dist ; / * distance from middle of link to center of mass * / + coll_link * next ; / * store these in a singly linked list * / + } ; + in order to update the velocities of the particle at each time step it is necessary to know the force and torque exerted by the fluid on the particle .
these are computed from the change in momentum of the fluid at each link after it has bounced back .
the motion of the colloid evolves as in a molecular dynamics step .
the discretization of the particle surface onto the lattice links implies its radius is not strictly constant .
it is therefore necessary to keep the actual distance between the center of the link and the center of mass of the particle for _ each _ link as a separate variable * dist * to compute the torque .
the complete information about any given colloid is replicated on all the pes which have their local domain intersected by it ( list stored in * colloid.pe * ) .
the variable * coll_link.local * tells which ( non - local ) links must be skipped during the bbl , which is implemented by applying equation [ eqn : mod_bbl ] just like for any other solid objects .
contributions to the torque from each link will be summed locally and then across pes .
the radius of the colloids must be larger than the lattice spacing , and its actual value will depend on the volume fractions of solid particles considered . up to around @xmath74 in volume fraction , a small value of the radius , e.g. 2.5 lattice spacings , is sufficient to get accurate results @xcite .
at higher volume fractions , larger radii should be considered . this will eventually , at very high packing fractions , limit the performance of the lb code , as progressively larger system sizes will be needed .
similar limitations will apply when dealing with polydisperse suspensions , or motion of non - spherical objects .
a more complete discussion of the implementation , optimization , and application of moving solid particles will be published elsewhere .
as pointed out already , for a two component fluid , the interaction with a solid wall should allow a difference in interaction between the two components and the wall even when the fluids are symmetric in all other respects .
it can be energetically favorable for one of the two components to be in contact with the solid surface , in which case , in static equilibrium the fluid - fluid interface is not perpendicular to the wall .
the equilibrium angle @xmath75 is called the contact angle and is determined , via the young equation @xcite @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the solid / fluid surface tension for the bulk phase with positive ( negative ) order parameter , and @xmath78 is the fluid - fluid surface tension .
the resulting wetting phenomena are known to play a major part in the behavior of complex fluids next to ( or including ) solid objects , but their implementation in simulations still remains in its infancy @xcite .
in particular , it is important to make sure that the observed wetting behavior is consistent with the thermodynamic requirement of young s equation in equilibrium .
we have therefore devised a novel predictor - corrector scheme to ensure an accurate implementation of controlled wetting effects at the solid - fluids interface in three dimensions .
recalling that _ ludwig _ uses a symmetric @xmath29 model free energy ( see equation [ eqn : fe ] ) , a simple way to account for wetting properties is to associate with the solid surfaces an additional surface free energy density @xmath79 , where @xmath80 is the value of the compositional order parameter in contact with the wall . according to cahn theory @xcite
, the equilibrium order parameter profile corresponds to that which minimizes the free energy functional @xmath81 + \int f_s(\phi_s ) ds$ ] where @xmath82 obeys equation [ eqn : fe ] and the integral is over the solid surface .
the two solid - fluid interfacial tensions are found by minimizing this expression near a flat solid - fluid interface to find the equilibrium free energy @xmath83 , subtracting the contribution @xmath84\ , d\mathbf{r}$ ] of the same volume of bulk fluid , and dividing by the interfacial area . the functional minimization also gives the composition profile near the wall , and the boundary condition satisfied at the solid surface , which is @xmath85 where @xmath86 is normal to the wall . in general , @xmath87 is a function of the local order parameter .
the classical work on wetting has shown that a functional relation of the form @xmath88 is enough to reproduce the various different wetting scenarios @xcite . by tuning the parameters @xmath89 and @xmath90 , we modify the properties of the surface in a thermodynamically controlled manner @xcite , so that the fluid - solid interfacial tensions can be tuned at will . since we are dealing with a symmetric mixture ,
if @xmath91 the two phases will have neutral wetting and show a local variation in composition near the wall ( @xmath92 ) of the same magnitude .
nonzero @xmath90 allows then for an asymmetry in the surface value of the order parameter for the two coexisting phases and a contact angle different from @xmath93 degrees .
the main difficulty to implement the general boundary condition , equation [ eqn : sfe ] , is that it depends on the value of the order parameter at the surface , @xmath80 , which is itself a dynamical variable .
moreover , due to bbl , the solid surface lies between the sites thus making the calculation of @xmath94 and @xmath95 by finite difference from neighboring sites using equations [ eq : grad_def ] and [ eq : lap_def ] impossible . to circumvent this
, we use a predictor - corrector scheme to estimate the gradient at the solid wall as follows ( see figure [ fig : wetting ] ) : 1 . determine which sites are next to a wall ( boundary sites ) , and hence which links cross the wall ( i.e. dry links ) ; 2 .
estimate @xmath94 using finite differences on all wet links ; 3 . from this estimate of @xmath94 ,
extrapolate to halfway along the dry links , and calculate @xmath80 ; using @xmath80 on the dry links , calculate @xmath96 on these links ; 4 .
calculate @xmath94 and @xmath95 for the boundary sites using _ all _ the gradients estimated on the links .
this scheme gives good quantitative results of the wetting angles in accordance with thermodynamic predictions .
results from case studies , both for a droplet and for planar interfaces are discussed in section [ sec : results ] .
production runs on the phase separation kinetics of binary fluid mixtures have been carried out on the cray t3d and the hitachi sr-2201 at epcc , and on the cray t3e-1200 at csar @xcite .
in addition to these distributed memory systems , we also investigated the performance of the code on shared - memory platforms such as the sun hpc-3500 at epcc .
distributed on 8 pes for 12,000 steps .
the shear has been applied through fixed walls at constant velocity , thus requiring a total of @xmath97 bbls per step .
the order parameter and velocity fields were saved 60 times and the full configuration only once , thus representing a combined output of 17 gb for the simulation . the darkest color at the top of the bar chart represents the remaining stages of the simulation ( i.e.initialization , bbl , measurements , and i / o ) . ] the profile information reproduced in figure [ fig : benchmark ] provides us with an interesting insight on the critical sections of the code .
firstly , one notices that over 90% of the simulation time is spent in the collision and propagation stages which are both intrinsically serial and well load - balanced for most problems .
the raw performance ( excluding all i / o and measurements ) varies from @xmath98 to @xmath99 gridpoint - updates per second for the cray t3e and sun hpc-3500 respectively .
details of the timing information for the various stages of the simulation of spinodal decomposition under shear is given in figure [ fig : benchmark ] .
note that the halo swap and bbl only account for 4 - 7% .
a comparison of the profiles obtained on the sun hpc-3500 and cray t3e-1200 also shows up that the critical parts of the code are highly system dependent .
as expected , the increased clock speed of the t3e-1200 ( 600mhz compared to only 400mhz on the hpc-3500 ) benefits the collision stage which is a highly - localized algorithm with basic arithmetic operators ( add / multiply ) .
this routine has been highly optimized and makes a good use of the t3e memory hierarchy . on the other hand ,
the memory - to - memory copies performed in the propagation stage do not benefit from this increase in clock speed as much .
indeed , the hpc-3500 significantly outperforms its rival by over 23% even though the algorithm for the propagation had been tuned for the t3e by rearranging loops to make an efficient use of its streams ( see @xcite for further information about stream optimization ) .
particular attention should also be paid to finding the optimal ordering for the velocity set @xmath100 .
it is important to order the velocity set such that they correspond , as much as possible , to sequential positions in memory for the distribution functions .
the first production platform for this package was the cray t3d which , due to its lack of second - level cache , was particularly sensitive to data locality .
the arrangement reproduced in table [ tab : velset ] proved to be the most effective to preserve data locality with a performance increase of over 20% on the t3d ( compared to an unoptimized sequence ) for the combined collision and propagation stages .
note that some orderings can speed - up one of these stages alone and be detrimental to the second one .
the gain in performance resulting from data locality is not as significant on systems with second - level cache though .
the best ordering of the velocity vectors is therefore often system - specific .
.optimal velocity set for the cray t3d [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] as shown in figure [ fig : scaleup ] , _ ludwig _ also demonstrates near - linear scaling from 16 up to 512 processors . however , the overall cost of the i / o can become a major bottleneck for the unwary ( e.g. a @xmath101 system will generate in excess of 31 gb per configuration dump ) .
the i / o has been optimized by performing parallel i / o . the pool of pes is split into @xmath102 groups of @xmath103 processors , thus providing @xmath102 concurrent i / o streams ( typically , @xmath104 ) .
each group has a root pe which will perform all i / o operations .
the remaining @xmath105 pes send their data in turn to the i / o pes which pack these data and write them to disk .
this approach usually offers high bandwidth without having to use platform specific calls such as disk striping . .
details of the simulation are similar to that given in figure [ fig : benchmark ] with the exception of the system size which has been increased to @xmath106 .
the only quantity measured during this benchmark is the order parameter field , @xmath107 which was measured and saved to disk every 50 iterations .
speed - up data have been included for simulations with and without the i / o ( note that in both cases , the time taken for dumping full re - start configurations was not included ) .
the i / o consists in 240 data dumps of 191 mb written to disks through eight parallel output streams . ]
note that mpi2-io had initially to be discounted on the ground of portability and performance .
we conclude this discussion by deploring the lack of a full support for mpi-2 single - sided communications on some platforms .
indeed , this functionality proves invaluable for the implementation of the lees - edwards boundary conditions and moving particles .
_ ludwig _ has already been used to study a number of problems for binary fluid mixtures of current interest : 1 .
establishment of the role of inertia in late - stage coarsening @xcite ; 2 .
study of the effect of an applied shear flow on the coarsening process @xcite ; 3 .
persistence exponents in a symmetric binary fluid mixture @xcite .
these results have been published elsewhere and will not be discussed further here . a number of validation exercises relating to binary mixtures are also described in @xcite . here
we focus on discussing new validation results obtained using the novel predictor - corrector scheme for the thermodynamically consistent simulation of wetting phenomena , as presented earlier .
we present results for two types of tests for the properties of binary fluids near a solid wall .
first , we verify that the modified bounce - back procedure , equation [ eqn : mod_bbl ] , gives the expected balance both for the momentum and for the order parameter .
second , we check the numerical accuracy of the modified boundary condition that accounts for the wetting properties of the wall , equation [ eqn : sfe ] , as implemented through the predictor - corrector step . to test the validity of the modified bounce - back rule for the order parameter field , we have looked at the motion of a pair of planar interfaces perpendicular to two parallel planar solid walls when the whole system is moving at a constant velocity parallel to the walls .
the initial condition corresponds to a stripe of one equilibrium fluid ( @xmath108 ) , oriented perpendicular to the walls , surrounded by a region of the other fluid ( @xmath109 ) , with periodic boundary conditions . due to galilean invariance , the profile should remain undistorted and move at the same velocity as it is moving with initially , but with lb this is not guaranteed _ a priori _ and has to be validated .
we have considered both the case of neutral wetting and the asymmetric case where @xmath90 is nonzero .
( open circles ) , and also for a bounce - back of the order parameter field in which the advection induced by the moving walls is neglected ( filled diamonds ) . ] for neutral surfaces , we show in figure [ fig : interface1 ] the leading interfacial profiles at different times , both for the bounce - back rules described in equation [ eqn : bbl ] , and for an improperly formulated bounce - back of the order parameter that does not take into account the motion of the wall .
( the latter is equivalent to assuming @xmath110 only in the equations describing the bounce - back of the order parameter distribution function . )
as can be seen , although the profile is advected due to the existence of a net momentum at the wall , if the bounce - back is not done in the frame of reference of the moving wall ( leading to equation [ eqn : mod_bbl ] ) the fluid - fluid interface has a spurious curvature and it moves more slowly than it should . from the rectilinear shape of both the leading ( shown in figure [ fig : interface1 ] ) and trailing interfaces of the rectangular strip , we have found that galilean invariance is in fact well satisfied with equation [ eqn : mod_bbl ] .
figure [ fig : interface1 ] corresponds to a situation of high viscosity and low diffusion ( @xmath111 ) but the same features have been observed for a number of different physical parameters .
the magnitudes of the errors made by using the inappropriate bounce - back , in this geometry , are found to decrease upon increasing the mobility , probably because a large mobility allows a faster relaxation to the imposed velocity profile in the interfacial region ( especially near the contact with the walls ) . .
the walls wet partially , and therefore the stripe relaxes from its initial configuration to a bent interface .
we show the interfaces for the bounce - back described in equation [ eqn : bbl ] ( open circles ) , and also for a bounce - back of the order parameter field in which the advection induced by the moving walls is neglected ( filled diamonds ) . in open squares
we show the trailing interface at time 4000 to show the magnitude of the deviations with respect to galilean invariance ( see text ) . ] in figure [ fig : interface2 ] we show the same configuration as described in the previous paragraph , but for the case in which the solid surface partially wets one of the two phases , so that @xmath90 is nonzero and @xmath112 rather than 90 degrees . in this case
the profile should relax from the initial perpendicular stripe to a curved interface .
again , the use of inappropriate bounce - back for the order parameter leads to a slower motion of the interface , and a significant distortion away from the equilibrium interfacial shape . in order to test galilean invariance here , for the final interface ( @xmath113 timesteps )
we have compared the leading and trailing edge of the stripe .
there is a slight deviation in this case , implying that the asymmetry entering via @xmath90 couples through to the overall fluid motion relative to the underlying lattice , which ( by galilean invariance ) it should not .
however , the resulting violation is very small , and the interfacial deviations do not grow beyond one lattice spacing . we have also verified that if the velocity of the walls is perpendicular to their own plane , then an order parameter profile , initially in equilibrium , remains stationary .
this confirms that the chosen boundary conditions can account for generically moving interfaces for the case of a binary mixture .
finally , for stationary walls , we have computed the contact angles for the simplest asymmetric case in which @xmath114 ( see equation [ eqn : sfe ] ) . in this situation
the order parameter at the wall will deviate by the same magnitude , but with opposite sign , in the two bulk phases .
for this choice ( with @xmath115 ) the contact angle , @xmath75 , is predicted to depend on the parameter @xmath116 according to @xmath117\ ] ] we have considered a geometry in which the two solid walls have the same wetting properties .
we start , as in the previous case , with an initial stripe perpendicular to the walls , defining two regions with opposite equilibrium values for the order parameter .
the equilibrium profile for the interface then corresponds to a cylindrical cap . by fitting the cylindrical cap it is possible to get a numerical value for the contact angle . in figure
[ fig : angle ] we show the measured contact angles as a function of @xmath118 for different interfacial widths @xmath119 , and compare these with the above theoretical prediction .
( note that , by maintaining fixed @xmath120 have kept constant the values @xmath35 of the equilibrium order parameters in the two coexisting phases . ) as can be seen , the agreement between the theoretical prediction and the measured contact angle is quantitative .
is the liquid / liquid interfacial width expressed in lattice units . ]
the parameters that characterize the binary mixture have been chosen to ensure fairly wide fluid - fluid interfaces .
( in fact , the smallest interfacial width , @xmath121 , is at least twice as large as that used previously in production runs for binary fluid demixing @xcite . ) for narrower interfaces than this , the contact angles can differ significantly from the predictions due to anisotropies induced by the lattice , whose effects were studied ( for fluid - fluid interfaces only ) in @xcite .
this effect should be more relevant for small contact angles .
indeed , when a narrow fluid - fluid interface has a glancing incidence with the solid wall , the discrete separation of lattice planes will lead to significant errors in the estimation of the order parameter gradients ; the direction of these not only determines the surface normal of the fluid - fluid interface , and hence the contact angle , but is crucial to an accurate estimate of the free energies near the contact line . however , except perhaps for small contact angles , there is not much accuracy gained from choosing @xmath122 larger than @xmath123 .
because of the finite width of the interfaces , one has to be careful to measure the contact angle by extrapolation from regions of fluid - fluid interface that are more than about @xmath122 from the wall . to check that we did this correctly , we have also numerically and analytically computed the three interfacial tensions directly by the method outlined in section [ ssec : wetting ] . from the values of the surface tensions obtained ,
it is the possible to get values for the contact angles , through young s law , equation [ eqn : young ] .
as expected , the values agree with the theoretical predictions and the contact angles measured from the profiles ( figure [ fig : angle ] ) .
we have described a versatile parallel lattice boltzmann code for the simulation of complex fluids .
the objective has been to develop a piece of code that allows to study the hydrodynamics of a broad class of multicomponent and complex fluids , focusing initially on binary fluid mixtures with or without solid surfaces present .
it combines a parallelization strategy , making it suitable to exploit the capabilities of supercomputers , with a modular structure , which allows its use without the need to know its computational details , and with the possibility of focusing on the physical analysis of the results .
this strategy has led to a code that is in principle adaptable to several different uses within the academic collaboration involved @xcite .
we have discussed how to introduce generic fluid - solid boundary conditions , and discussed which structures were developed to combine the requirements of specific physical features with the generic structure of the code .
the performance of the code in different computers shows its portability , and it scales up efficiently on parallel computers .
we have implemented generic boundary conditions for a binary mixture in contact with moving solid interfaces .
we have shown how one recovers appropriate behavior of the momentum and the fluid order parameter so long as the bounce - back rule , in the moving frame of the wall , is performed with the distribution function that characterizes the order parameter as well as that for momentum ( equation [ eqn : mod_bbl ] ) . a mesoscopic boundary condition that accounts for the wetting properties of a binary mixture near a solid surface has been described .
it has been shown how to deal appropriately with the gradients of the order parameter at the wall , and with the role of the finite interfacial width when analyzing the results .
the values obtained for the contact angle agree with the predictions of the model simulated , showing the absence of lattice artifacts , at least for contact angles larger than about 20 degrees .
these results are , however , for planar solid interfaces oriented along a lattice direction .
we have not checked in detail the dependence of the contact angle on the orientation of the solid surface , and it may require further work on the discretization of order parameter derivatives before this isotropy can be relied upon .
analogously to the problem of small wetting angles mentioned above , the problem may prove most acute for low - angle inclination of the solid surface , where the naive discretization of the solid phase leads to a series of well - separated steps in the wall position .
current and planned work with _
ludwig _ includes the hydrodynamic simulation of multicomponent fluid flow in a porous networks with controlled wetting ; implementation of lees - edwards ( sliding periodic ) boundary conditions ; large - scale simulations of binary fluids under shear , and the improvement of the gradients to make the thermodynamics of this model more fully independent of the underlying symmetries of the lattice .
longer term plans include studying colloid hydrodynamics and extending _ ludwig _ to study amphiphilic systems under shear ( see @xcite for an example of this studied by dpd ) .
the authors would like to acknowledge michael cates , simon jury , alexander wagner , patrick warren , and julia yeomans for valuable discussions .
they thank michael cates for assistance with the manuscript .
this work has been funded in part under the maxwell institute s project on fluid flow in soft and porous matter and the epsrc e7 grand challenge and gr / m56234 . c.p .
lowe , d. frenkel and a.j .
masters , j. chem.phys . *
103 * , 1582 ( 1995 ) .
hagen , d. frenkel and c.p .
lowe , physica a * 272 * , 376 ( 1999 ) . j. rowlinson and b. widom , _ molecular theory of capilarity _ , clarendon press , oxford 1982 . | this paper describes _ ludwig _ , a versatile code for the simulation of lattice - boltzmann ( lb ) models in 3-d on cubic lattices .
in fact _
ludwig _ is not a single code , but a set of codes that share certain common routines , such as i / o and communications . if _
ludwig _ is used as intended , a variety of complex fluid models with different equilibrium free energies are simple to code , so that the user may concentrate on the physics of the problem , rather than on parallel computing issues . thus far , _
ludwig _
s main application has been to symmetric binary fluid mixtures .
we first explain the philosophy and structure of _ ludwig _ which is argued to be a very effective way of developing large codes for academic consortia .
next we elaborate on some parallel implementation issues such as parallel i / o , and the use of mpi to achieve full portability and good efficiency on both mpp and smp systems .
finally , we describe how to implement generic solid boundaries , and look in detail at the particular case of a symmetric binary fluid mixture near a solid wall .
we present a novel scheme for the thermodynamically consistent simulation of wetting phenomena , in the presence of static and moving solid boundaries , and check its performance .
lattice - boltzmann .
wetting . computer simulations .
parallel computing .
binary fluid mixtures . |
astronomical observation of emission from the @xmath9 transition at 4.83 ghz ( 6 cm ) of the formaldehyde ( h@xmath0co ) molecule is exceedingly rare .
only four galactic sources have been observed to emit : three of these sources have been shown to be masers . the h@xmath0co 6 cm emission in the compact region ngc 7538 b was first observed by downes & wilson ( 1974 ) and was shown to be a compact , non - thermal maser by forster et al .
most recently , an h@xmath0co maser was discovered in g29.96 - 0.02 by pratap , menten & snyder ( 1994 , hereafter pms94 ) .
masers are also observed in sgr b2 ( whiteoak & gardner 1983 ) .
the fourth h@xmath0co emission source , orion - kl , is known to have extended thermal emission ( _ e.g_. johnston et al .
though detection of h@xmath0co masers is expected to require interferometric observations which are not sensitive to the broad angular scale @xmath9 absorption that dominates single dish measurements of the 4.83 ghz line ( _ e.g_. bieging et al .
1980 ) , dedicated interferometric surveys ( _ e.g_. forster et al . 1985 ; pms94 ; mehringer , goss , & palmer 1995 ) have been rather unsuccessful in discovering new masers .
there is currently no working theoretical model of the galactic formaldehyde maser process , despite a history of relatively rapid understanding of astrophysical formaldehyde phenomena . almost immediately after the discovery of interstellar formaldehyde in 6 cm absorption by snyder , buhl , zuckerman , & palmer ( 1969 ) , observations were made of `` anomalous '' 6 cm absorption ( palmer , zuckerman , buhl , & snyder 1969 ) , 2 cm absorption ( evans , cheung , & sloanaker 1970 ) , and emission in the @xmath10 ( kutner , thaddeus , et al .
1971 ) and @xmath11 ( thaddeus et al . 1971 ) millimeter lines ( see fig . 1 ) . improved laboratory measurements ( tucker , tomasevich , & thaddeus 1971 , 1972 ; nerf 1972 ) and excitation calculations ( townes & cheung 1969 ; thaddeus 1972 ; evans 1975 ; garrison et al .
1975 ) explained these phenomena shortly thereafter , but can not explain the observed maser emission .
boland & de jong ( 1981 ) proposed a continuum radiation pump mechanism to explain the ngc 7538 maser . though the radiative pump has been successfully applied to the several ( @xmath12 ) extragalactic h@xmath0co ( mega)masers which have been observed ( _
e.g_. baan et al .
1986 , 1993 ) , the model is not applicable to the continuum morphology discovered in ngc 7538 more recently ( _ e.g_. pratap et al .
1992 ) , nor can the model explain the sgr b2 and g29.96 - 0.02 masers discovered subsequently .
thus , the galactic 6 cm formaldehyde maser phenomenon remains unexplained nearly 30 years after its discovery . in a search for new empirical constraints on these mysterious objects
, this paper presents an observational study of the galactic h@xmath0co masers in ngc 7538 and g29.96 - 0.02 .
ngc 7538 ( s158 ) is a well - studied region complex at a distance of @xmath13 kpc ( campbell & thompson 1984 ) . at the southern edge of the optical nebula
lie three radio and infrared sources .
the radio sources were designated a , b , & c by martin ( 1973 ) from 2@xmath14-resolution 5 ghz observations .
wynn - williams et al . (
1974 ) detected infrared counterparts at 20 @xmath15 m for the radio sources ; a : irs2 , b : irs1 , and c : irs3 .
the masers are located in front of irs1 ( iras 23116 + 6111 ) which is partially optically thick at 6 cm .
the irs1 region is thought to have a central star of type o6 v or b0.5 ii ( _ e.g_. israel et al .
1973 ; willner 1976 ) and there is a relatively large mass of cold dust associated with irs1 ( but not irs2 or 3 ) resulting in a relatively low region gas - to - dust mass ratio of 75 ( willner 1976 ) .
ngc 7538-irs1 is also associated with a remarkable number of maser species besides h@xmath0co ( see 4.4 ) .
g29.96 - 0.02 ( hereafter g29.96 ) is a cometary region at a distance of @xmath16 kpc ( morisset et al .
the h@xmath0co masers lie in a `` hot core '' about two arcseconds west of the cometary head . the hot core ( @xmath17 k ; @xmath18 ) is thought to be powered by an embedded star , not by the cometary region ( _ e.g_. de buizer et al .
2002 ; pratap et al .
1999 ; cesaroni et al .
the hot core also shows maser emission from h@xmath0o and ch@xmath19oh ( hofner & churchwell 1996 ; walsh et al .
1998 ) .
all previous observational studies of h@xmath0co masers have utilized either single dish antennas or @xmath2 km baseline interferometers ( _ e.g_. forster et al .
1980 , 1985 ; rots et al . 1981 ; pms94 ) .
past observations were unable to spatially resolve the maser emission . a lower limit of @xmath20 k brightness temperature has been determined for the ngc 7538 and g29.96 masers ( rots et al .
1981 ; pms94 ) .
the ngc 7538 h@xmath0co source has two velocity components at @xmath21 km s@xmath22 ( component i ) and @xmath23 km s@xmath22 ( component ii ) , separated by @xmath24 ( rots et al . 1981 ) .
forster et al . ( 1985 ) noted a factor of two intensity increase in component i over 3 years .
no polarization was detected in the ngc 7538 maser components to a 3-@xmath6 upper limit of 5% of the total intensity in the stokes @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 parameters ( forster et al .
the g29.96 masers exhibit several blended spectral features including velocity components at @xmath28 km s@xmath22 ( component i ) and @xmath29 km s@xmath22 ( component ii ) that appear coincident on the sky ( pms94 ) .
no polarization observations have been made of the g29.96 masers .
sensitive milliarcsecond - resolution observations of h@xmath0co masers are needed . placing more stringent empirical constraints on galactic h@xmath0co 6
cm maser emission requires the following observational results : ( 1 ) a determination of the angular extent of the maser emission @xmath30 , allowing a determination of the intrinsic sizes and brightness temperatures , ( 2 ) a detection of the radiatively coupled @xmath31 ( 2 cm ) line , yielding limits on inversion and level populations , ( 3 ) sensitive limits on polarized intensity , and ( 4 ) a characterization of the observed maser intensity increase in ngc 7538 .
furthermore , accurate relative positions of the h@xmath0co masers with respect to other maser species could constrain the poorly - understood physical conditions of the maser environment .
compared to the rots et al .
( 1981 ) vla observations of the ngc 7538 h@xmath0co masers which used 12 antennas recording a single polarization , the vla is now more sensitive , using all 27 antennas and recording dual polarizations .
furthermore , using the sensitivity of the vlba with the phased vla , observations of the relatively weak ( @xmath32 mjy ) h@xmath0co masers at milliarcsecond angular resolution are possible .
we have conducted new observations of the ngc 7538 and g29.96 h@xmath0co masers at 6 cm and 2 cm using the very large array ( vla ) of the nrao and at 6 cm using very long baseline array ( vlba ) of the nrao and the multi - element radio linked interferometry network ( merlin ) .
we have summarized the observational parameters in tables 1 , 2 , and 3 .
tables 1 and 2 list the logistical parameters of the observations including bandwidth , spectral configuration , and calibrator information .
all antennas in all observations use dual - circular polarization feeds .
table 3 lists the resulting sensitivities of the images .
we assume throughout that the observed 6 cm formaldehyde line is the dominant @xmath33 hyperfine component which is separated from the @xmath34 component by 1.13 km s@xmath22 ( tucker et al . 1971 ; downes et al . 1976 ) .
the maser line widths , velocities , and velocity gradients were determined using the the groningen image processing system ( gipsy ) software packagegipsy/ ] .
all other reduction and imaging was done with the astronomical image processing system ( aips ) software package .
the ngc 7538 and g29.96 masers were observed on 13 february 1996 at 4.83 ghz ( 6 cm ) using the 27 antennas of the vla for 20 minutes each .
the ngc 7538 and g29.96 maser positions were also observed on 13 february 1996 at 14.49 ghz ( 2 cm ) with the vla for 40 minutes each . in `
cnb ' configuration the vla baseline lengths range from 0.065 km to 7.7 km .
all of the vla ` cnb ' observations were sensitive to the continuum radiation from the regions .
the continuum contribution was subtracted from the maser channels using the aips task uvlsf .
the 2 cm continuum radiation from g29.96 was averaged and imaged from 40 line - free channels over about 1 mhz of bandwidth .
the rms noise of the line - free 2 cm continuum image of g29.96 is 3.0 mjy beam@xmath22 . the ngc 7538 masers were observed on 24 july 2002 at 4.83 ghz with the vla for 40 minutes . in `
b ' configuration the array baseline lengths range from 0.21 km to 11.4 km .
the vla ` b ' observations were sensitive to the continuum radiation from the regions .
the continuum contribution was subtracted from the maser channels using the aips task uvlsf .
the continuum radiation was averaged and imaged from 28 line - free channels over 84 khz of bandwidth .
the rms noise of the line - free continuum image is 1.6 mjy beam@xmath22 .
the ngc 7538 masers were observed on 1 - 3 october 2001 using the merlin radio telescope of jodrell bank observatory for a total of @xmath35 hours .
six antennas were used ; the mark ii at jodrell bank , the 32 m antenna at cambridge , and the 25 m dishes at knockin , darnhall , tabley , and defford .
the baseline lengths of merlin range from 11 km to 217 km .
the phases were calibrated by frequent observations at 14 mhz bandwidth of 2300 + 638 .
3c84 was observed at both 14 mhz and 500 khz bandwidth allowing bandwidth - dependent calibration to be transferred . due to a pointing error
, the merlin observations were centered 1.6 arcminutes from the maser position .
though a @xmath36 displacement is within the primary receiving beam of the merlin antennas ( @xmath37 ) , decoherent averaging during on - line integration ( ` time smearing ' ) made necessary a factor of 2.8 amplitude correction ( see thompson 1999 ) .
the measured positions of the masers were not affected by the error .
using the ten antennas of the vlba and the 27-element phased vla as an 11-station vlbi array , we observed the ngc 7538 and g29.96 h@xmath0co masers on 22 september 2000 for @xmath38 hours each .
the amplitude scale was set by online system temperature monitoring and _ a priori _ gain measurements .
the vlba observations of the masers were phase - referenced to their respective phase calibrators .
the phase referencing technique allows the maser visibility phases ( which correspond to sky position ) to be determined from those of the brighter phase - reference source ( see walker 1999 ) .
the maser targets and the phase - reference sources were alternately observed in a 2.5:1.5 minute cycle .
data from the hancock , north liberty , mauna kea , and st .
croix vlba stations were not part of the final data set because the station - based visibility phases could not be adequately tracked and transferred due to poor signal to noise .
the baseline lengths contributing to the final images range from 52 to 1806 km .
the vla images of the continuum radiation from the regions are shown in figures 2 and 3 .
the vla ` b ' array image ( 2.2 ) of the 6 cm continuum radiation from ngc 7538 is shown in figure 2 with the position of the h@xmath0co masers indicated . the vla ` cnb ' array image ( 2.1 ) of the 2 cm continuum radiation from g29.96 is shown in figure 3 with the position of the h@xmath0co masers indicated .
we have detected h@xmath0co masers with vlbi observations for the first time .
the vlba images of the ngc 7538 h@xmath0co component i masers are shown in figure 4 .
component i splits into two peaks , ia and ib , in the vlba image .
the absolute position uncertainty of the strongest peak in the vlba images of component i is 2 mas , phase - referenced to the calibrator j2302 + 6405 .
the positions of the emission peaks in the brightest vlba channel image at @xmath39 km s@xmath22 are summarized in table 4 .
the vlba position for component i is consistent with rots et al .
( 1981 ) within their 100-mas - uncertainty .
the ia and ib feature peaks are separated by @xmath40 mas ( 42 au ) in the @xmath39 km s@xmath22 channel image .
the total extent of the velocity structure of component i in the vlba images is @xmath41 mas ( @xmath42 au ) .
the merlin images show both components i and ii .
figure 5 shows the channel images of the brightest emission from the two components .
the components are separated by @xmath43 mas ( 240 au ) , in agreement with the previous determination of @xmath44 mas by rots et al .
( 1981 ) .
component i shows a very compact structure from which merlin observations recover all of the emission and from which the vlba recovers about 60% of the emission . in the vlba images ( fig
. 4 ) , features ia and ib have resolved angular diameters @xmath45 mas corresponding to brightness temperatures @xmath46 k. in contrast , component ii does not show any compact structure on long baselines : merlin detects only @xmath47% of the emission and only the two shortest vlba baselines detect component ii .
the deconvolved size of component ii in the merlin image ( fig .
5 ) is 64 mas .
the component sizes are consistent with the previous upper limits of 150 mas measured by rots et al . ( 1981 ) .
the angular size of component ii corresponds to a brightness temperature of @xmath48 k. the measurement of the maser brightness temperature and of the background continuum radiation which the maser amplifies allows a determination of the gain of the maser .
the measurements are related by @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the brightness temperature of the maser , @xmath51 is the brightness temperature of the background continuum radiation , and @xmath52 is the gain of the maser . using a brightness temperature @xmath53 k measured from the vla ` b ' observations , the masers have gains @xmath54 .
the maser lines are resolved in velocity in all of the observations except those from the vla ` cnb ' array .
all of the lines are fit well by single gaussians .
table 5 summarizes the fitted and deconvolved peak intensity , velocity width at half - maximum , and line center for the different observations .
the merlin and vlba observations show , for the first time , a velocity gradient in the masing gas . in the vlba images ,
the dashed arrow in figure 4 traces the direction of a velocity field which extends through the ia peak at a position angle of @xmath55 for several tens of milliarcseconds ( several beamwidths ) .
figure 6 shows a position - velocity plot of the slice indicated in figure 4 .
the plot shows a linear velocity dependence along the slice of magnitude 28 @xmath7 ( 1900 @xmath8 ) .
the merlin observations show a velocity gradient in both components that is consistent with that shown in figure 6 .
we note that a linear velocity gradient is consistent with the maser emission arising from a rigid rotating disk ( or cylinder ) .
however , the position of component ii is not consistent with a linear extension of the component i gradient shown figure 6 .
that is , component ii does not lie on the disk which models figure 6 . emission from a maser component at @xmath56 km s@xmath22 consistent with the 28 @xmath7 velocity gradient would lie @xmath57 mas away from component i at @xmath58 position angle , as marked by the ` @xmath59 ' symbol in figure 5 .
however , component ii is observed to lie @xmath60 mas from component i at @xmath61 position angle ( fig .
therefore we conclude that the two maser components are not simply related and do not lie in a single , uniform gas cloud . the vla ` b ' array spectrum of the h@xmath0co masers is shown in figure 7 . in july 2002 , we observed component i to have an intensity of @xmath62 mjy beam@xmath22 .
the intensity on july 2002 is a factor of three larger than the @xmath63 mjy beam@xmath22 observed in april 1983 by forster et al . ( 1985 ) when variability was first noted using the westerbork synthesis radio telescope with 0.36 km s@xmath22 velocity resolution .
we note an intensity increase in component ii for the first time . in july 2002
, we observe an intensity for component ii of @xmath64 mjy beam@xmath22 with the vla ` b ' array compared to @xmath65 mjy beam@xmath22 observed by forster et al .
a light curve of the maser component intensities is shown in figure 8 . at the 3-@xmath6 level
, we detect no polarization in any of the observations .
our vla data place a more sensitive upper limit of 1% ( 3-@xmath6 ) on circularly polarized intensity than the previous limit of 5% set by forster et al .
the merlin and vlba data show no detectable linearly polarized intensity , corresponding to a 10% ( 3-@xmath6 ) upper limit in stokes @xmath25 & @xmath26 , consistent with the previous limit of 5% set by forster et al .
( 1985 ) .
table 6 summarizes the vlba image properties of the g29.96 masers
. the vlba+y27 @xmath66 km s@xmath22 image of g29.96 h@xmath0co maser component i is shown in figure 9 .
the absolute position uncertainty of the vlba image peak is 10 mas , phase - referenced to the calibrator j1851 + 0035 .
the image of component ii in the @xmath67 km s@xmath22 channel appears coincident on the sky .
the two components are separated by @xmath68 mas ( @xmath69 au ) .
the resolved sizes of the masers in the vlba images are @xmath70 mas , corresponding to brightness temperatures @xmath71 k. using a brightness temperature @xmath72 k for the background 6 cm continuum radiation measured from the vla ` cnb ' observations after a beam dilution correction using the 2 cm continuum image , the g29.96 maser gains are @xmath73 .
figure 10 shows the g29.96 h@xmath0co maser spectra .
the figure includes both the vlba+y27 spectrum from the current paper and the vla ` a ' array spectrum observed by pratap et al .
( pms94 ) .
pratap et al . , with a spectral resolution of 0.38 km s@xmath22 , detected `` several blended features '' whose emission is spread over @xmath74 km s@xmath22 . remarkably , we detect two _ spectrally unresolved _ velocity features in the vlba data despite a more favorable spectral resolution of 0.30 km s@xmath22 .
our vla ` cnb ' spectra are consistent with pratap et al . after correction for absorption , which is discussed below in
the properties of the g29.96 line emission are summarized in table 7 . at the 3-@xmath6 level
, we detect no polarization in any of the observations .
the vla and vlba observations were sensitive only to stokes @xmath75 and @xmath27 parameters .
the vla data place an upper limit of 15% ( 3-@xmath6 ) circularly polarized intensity on component i. the vlba data are also consistent with zero polarized intensity .
we have detected the 2 cm transition in the direction of galactic h@xmath0co maser sources for the first time . using the vla ` cnb ' array
, we observe the 2 cm line in absorption in both ngc 7538 and g29.96 .
all of the 2 cm line detections have a corresponding 6 cm feature that is coincident in velocity .
the optical depths @xmath52 of all of the absorption features are noted in figures 11 - 14 .
the optical depths are calculated using @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the ( negative ) temperature of the line ( after continuum subtraction ) and @xmath78 k is the excitation temperature of the line ( palmer et al . 1969 ; thaddeus 1972 ) .
the derived h@xmath0co column densities are discussed in 4 .
figure 11 shows the 2 cm absorption at the position of the ngc 7538 masers .
the 2 cm minimum in the ngc 7538 observations corresponds to the position and velocity ( @xmath79 km s@xmath22 ) of ( the weaker ) maser component ii ( fig .
the position of the 2 cm minimum at the component i velocity ( @xmath21 km s@xmath22 , fig .
11d ) lies less than two arcseconds away .
figure 12 shows the 6 cm and 2 cm spectra at the position of the g29.96 maser .
no 2 cm line is detected at the velocity of the maser but an absorption feature is seen at @xmath80 km s@xmath22 .
the 6 cm absorption evident in figure 12a at @xmath80 km s@xmath22 and @xmath81 km s@xmath22 is discussed below . no 2 cm line emission is detected from either ngc 7538 or g29.96 with a 3-@xmath6 brightness temperature sensitivity limit of 43 k. a low gain ( @xmath82 ) maser amplification of the 2 cm doublet in either ngc 7538 or g29.96 would produce an emission line of brightness temperature @xmath83 k. we conclude that there is no inversion of the 2 cm line . using the vla ` cnb ' array
we detect 6 cm absorption in both ngc 7538 and g29.96 .
we detect 6 cm absorption in g29.96 at the position of the masers in the hot core ( fig .
12a ) as well as against the cometary region . figure 13a shows the fit to the hot core absorption features which are summarized in table 8 .
the maser spectrum after subtraction of the absorption ( fig .
13b ) is consistent with the pratap et al .
( pms94 ) observations .
figure 14a shows the spectrum at the 6 cm minimum in the vla ` cnb ' observations which corresponds to absorption against the cometary region .
figure 14b shows the 2 cm absorption spectrum at this position .
we detect no 6 cm absorption at the position of the masers in ngc 7538-irs1 .
figure 14c shows the spectrum at the 6 cm minimum of the vla ` cnb ' observations which corresponds to absorption against irs2 .
no 2 cm absorption is detected at this position ( fig .
14d ) which is consistent with the 2 cm observations of martn - pintado et al .
( 1985 ) and evans et al .
( 1975 ) ( though compare our fig .
11a , b with fig . 9 of martn - pintado et al . ) .
the formaldehyde column densities can be calculated from the absorption spectra .
column densities @xmath84 calculated from 6 cm spectra are denoted @xmath85 while those calculated from 2 cm spectra are denoted @xmath86 .
the following relations were used to determine column densities from the spectra ( _ e.g_. wilson 1972 ; wadiak et al .
1988 ; osterbrock 1989 ) @xmath87 @xmath88 where @xmath84 has units @xmath89 , @xmath90 has units k , @xmath91 has units km s@xmath22 , and where the summation is over the spectral channels with line radiation .
the column densities are summarized in table 9 grouped by cloud velocity and background continuum object .
we have detected the formaldehyde distributions in ngc 7538 and g29.96 though observations of the 2 cm and 6 cm lines in absorption against the regions continuum radiation .
the absorbing systems offer information about the ambient formaldehyde environment .
appendix a describes the calculations which permit comparisons between the 6 cm and 2 cm lines relating to table 9 .
section 4.2 discusses the formaldehyde calculations permitted by the masers lines .
the detection of both 6 cm and 2 cm absorption lines toward the g29.96 hot core at @xmath80 km s@xmath22 ( fig .
12a , b ) permits a calculation of the excitation temperatures as described in appendix a. the ratio of optical depths is 2.35 for which @xmath92 .
if we choose excitation temperatures in this ratio for the @xmath93 values listed for the hot core in table 9 , we find comparable column densities for the 6 cm and 2 cm lines , indicating that the absorbing cloud is smaller than the 6 cm beam .
the ngc 7538 masers two velocity components show 2 cm absorption at both velocities ( fig . 11b , d ) . though the masers only exist in a region of diameter @xmath94 au ( fig . 4 ) , the clouds responsible for the 2 cm absorption lines have larger sizes comparable to the beam ( @xmath95 au ) .
the two maser velocity components appear to come from two separate cloud environments .
in addition to ( 1 ) the detection of the of the distinct absorbing velocities , evidence for two separate ngc 7538 masers includes : ( 2 ) the components have disparate brightness temperatures ( @xmath96 k compared to @xmath97 k ) and maser gains ( @xmath98 compared to @xmath99 ) , ( 3 ) the components are not connected by the velocity gradient observed in the maser gas ( fig . 5 ) , and ( 4 ) the masers appear to increase intensity independently ( fig
we conclude that the masers occur in separate clouds .
the maser amplification process depends on the column density of the maser species . in this section
we calculate the formaldehyde column densities from the observed maser gains .
we use the level notation from appendix a for our calculation .
we find that a comparison between the column densities derived from absorption lines and maser lines indicates a relatively strong maser inversion .
the gain of the maser amplification of background radiation can be expressed as ( _ e.g_. elitzur 1992 ) @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the einstein @xmath102-coefficient for stimulated emission and @xmath103 is the amplification path or gain length . here
we express @xmath52 in the form of equation 21 from boland & de jong ( 1981 ) , @xmath104 where @xmath105 such that a more negative number is a stronger inversion , @xmath106 , @xmath107 is the fractional abundance of ortho - formaldehyde with respect to the total density of hydrogen , and @xmath108 is the density of hydrogen .
the values of the parameters used in our calculations are listed in table 10 . for the values obtained from vlba observations ( @xmath73 and @xmath109 km s@xmath22 ,
see table 5 ) , we find @xmath110 .
we derive limiting values of @xmath111 from the following arguments : ( 1 ) we consider @xmath112 to be geometrically constrained to be comparable to the radius of the region , @xmath113 . for @xmath114 , @xmath115 .
( 2 ) for ngc 7538-irs1 , van der tak et al . ( 2000 ) have determined @xmath116 . adopting this value
, we obtain @xmath117 . (
3 ) any non - thermal h@xmath0co level populations must occur in the density range @xmath118 ( green et al .
1978 ) or else the level populations ` thermalize ' and any pumping is quenched .
for instance , the orion - kl emission lines originate in gas of density @xmath119 which could not support non - thermal excitation ( kunter & thaddues 1971 ; johnston et al .
for @xmath118 we obtain @xmath120 .
the maser population inversion is defined not to exceed unity such that @xmath121 which implies @xmath122 .
the limits @xmath123 may be compared with the typical inversion strength of the boland & de jong radiative pump model @xmath124 .
alternately , we may assume that the column density @xmath125 in the maser gas is the same as that independently found from our absorption observations ( 3.3.3 ) . from table 9 , a typical value is @xmath126 . for @xmath127
k we find that @xmath128 .
using @xmath129 from above we obtain @xmath130 which is consistent with the @xmath111 value reasoned from the maser gain . a continuum radiation excitation mechanism capable of producing the high gains observed in the 6 cm masers
would also be expected to affect the 2 cm doublet level populations : the relatively flat bremsstrahlung spectrum of region plasmas should excite the 6 cm and 2 cm doublets comparably ( to within an order of magnitude , see also wadiak et al .
for example , the boland & de jong ( 1981 ) radiative inversion model predicts a 2 cm maser for region spectra which turnover at wavelength @xmath131 cm .
however , no 2 cm maser is present ( 3.3.1 ) though the spectrum of ngc 7538-irs1 is observed to turnover in the favorable @xmath131 cm range ( _ e.g_. pratap et al . 1992 ; gaume et al . 1995 ; bloomer et al . 1998 ;
momose et al .
2001 ; akabane et al .
2001 ) . furthermore , since formaldehyde occurs in typical column densities around most regions ( including the maser objects , _
e.g_. van der tak et al .
2000 ; schier et al . 2002 ) , there is no reason on the grounds of either continuum morphology or formaldehyde abundance to expect that only the few maser - bearing regions should support a formaldehyde inversion .
therefore , we suggest that the 6 cm maser inversion is due to a rare collisional excitation , not to the readily available centimeter wavelength continuum radiation which has been discussed by other authors ( _ e.g_. pratap et al . 1992 ; pms94 ; mehringer , goss , & palmer 1994 ) .
the remarkable paucity of formaldehyde masers is likely a result of selective inversion conditions such as resonant interactions with species exclusive to only a few regions . in an attempt to find unusual conditions which can explain the presence of collisionally - pumped formaldehyde masers , we discuss the shock morphology of regions .
hill & hollenbach ( 1978 ) have modelled the dissociation wave and shock wave evolution of expanding regions .
our maser environments most resemble their `` model 3 '' in which the density is @xmath132 and the region radius is @xmath133 cm and the ambient magnetic field @xmath134 of the model is closest to that of ngc 7538-irs1 ( hoare , private communication ; momose et al .
2001 ) . for ngc 7538-irs1
the model correctly predicts the observed h@xmath0 line emissivity ( @xmath135 , bloomer et al .
1998 ; hoban et al . 1991 ) , shock velocity ( @xmath2 km s@xmath22 , _
e.g_. deharveng et al .
1979 ) , and age ( @xmath136 yr , _
e.g_. martin 1973 ) for the region .
the relevant aspect of the hill & hollenbach model is that the initially faster dissociation wave is eventually overtaken by the shock wave .
the epoch at which the shock passage occurs is @xmath137 yr , in good agreement with the age of the irs1 region . during the passage there exists a transition region about half - molecular in composition .
also , the region contains transient phenomena such as non - equilibrium populations of various species such as cool molecular gas and hot excited atoms .
evidence that these transition - shock collision regions are sufficiently rare to explain the observed paucity of formaldehyde masers is discussed by bertoldi & draine ( 1996 ) .
they find that for `` a broad range of parameters of interest '' ( density , shock velocity , etc . )
the dissociation and shock waves are merged and there is _ no _ relative evolution of the hill & hollenbach type .
however , they suggest that clumps in the ambient molecular cloud are sites where the dissociation and shock waves _ are _ separate and where time - dependent effects may become important . therefore , we suggest that formaldehyde masers occur in the small number of regions which possess ( 1 ) separately evolving dissociation and shock waves , ( 2 ) an age equal to the epoch of dissociation and shock wave passage , and ( 3 ) a neighboring molecular cloud with ambient clumps of sufficient number density and formaldehyde column density to cause time - dependent wave effects .
we consider it possible that the formaldehyde maser inversion is a result of collisions between formaldehyde and a rare transient species within the relatively exotic conditions in the shock / dissociation - transition region .
however , since h@xmath0co collisions with relatively rare species , such as hot h atoms or excited h@xmath0 ( _ e.g_. green et al .
1978 ) have not been fully explored , the collision cross - sections required to formulate a quantitative model are not yet available .
ngc 7538 is the closest of the three sources known to have h@xmath0co masers ( @xmath138 kpc compared with g29.96 - 0.02 ( @xmath139 kpc ) and sgr b2 ( @xmath140 kpc ) ) .
also , the ngc 7538-irs1 region contains a large number of maser species .
ngc 7538 is then best suited for studies targeted at understanding the h@xmath0co relationship to other maser species in close linear and angular proximity .
for example , empirical correlations among the h@xmath0co , oh , and h@xmath0o maser species have prompted searches for new h@xmath0co masers ( _ e.g_. forster et al .
1985 ) . in the search for a working h@xmath0co pump ,
an understanding of the physical conditions of irs1 through the observation of other masers is valuable .
studying the nearby masers that have relatively well - understood excitation mechanisms could considerably illuminate the h@xmath0co inversion environment .
figure 15 shows the 22 ghz continuum image of irs1 from gaume et al .
( 1995 ) overlaid with the positions of other known masers in the region .
a protostellar outflow is thought to power the maser environment . based on 15 ghz continuum observations , campbell ( 1984 )
suggests an edge - on protostellar disk and bipolar outflow .
a disk / outflow scenario is also supported by 22 ghz continuum and h66@xmath141 recombination line observations ( gaume et al .
1995 ) which show a @xmath32 km s@xmath22 stellar wind and apparent disk ( cf .
jaffe & martn - pintado 1999 ) .
furthermore , based on ch@xmath19oh maser observations , minier et al .
( 1998 ) suggest a protostellar disk and a blueshifted southern outflow . alternately , a shell model has been proposed to explain the various maser positions ( dickel et al .
1982 ) . a cartoon summary of these models , including the molecular clumps that we suggest are important for the formaldehyde maser process ,
are included with the observational data in figure 15 .
table 11 summarizes the observational uncertainties and physical conditions of the masers .
the @xmath142 ( 3,3 ) masers are the only irs1 masers that could arise at the same density , temperature , and position as the h@xmath0co masers ( fig .
15 ; table 11 ) . furthermore , the velocity gradient observed in the @xmath142 ( 3,3 ) masers is consistent with the h@xmath0co maser velocity gradient shown in figure 5 .
the position of the non - metastable @xmath143 ( 9,6 ) maser in the irs1 region ( madden et al .
1986 ) is also consistent with the @xmath142 and h@xmath0co masers positions and velocity gradient . the @xmath143 ( 9,6 )
maser species , like h@xmath0co , is quite rare and poorly - understood ( elitzur 1992 ) .
though the current position uncertainty of the nh@xmath19 ( 9,6 ) maser is too large to positively associate it with the h@xmath0co , the two may be related . the ngc 7538 nh@xmath19 ( 9,6 )
maser has only been observed at a single epoch ; however , the nh@xmath19 ( 9,6 ) maser in w49 is known to be variable ( wilson & henkel 1988 ; huettemeister et al .
future observations of nh@xmath19 in ngc 7538 could indicate ( 1 ) an accurate absolute position for the ngc 7538 @xmath143 ( 9,6 ) maser near the ngc 7538 h@xmath0co masers and/or ( 2 ) @xmath143 ( 9,6 ) maser intensity increase similar to the ngc 7538 h@xmath0co masers ( fig .
8) . either ( 1 ) or ( 2 ) would suggest that the h@xmath0co and nh@xmath19 masers arise in the same volume .
the h@xmath0o masers in the region have the most disparate physical conditions from the h@xmath0co ( table 11 ) .
however , recent observations ( hoare , private communication ) show that the irs1 h@xmath0o masers appear related to the h@xmath0co masers .
merlin observations show 9 h@xmath0o masers within 200 mas of the h@xmath0co positions .
furthermore , the two h@xmath0o masers closest in position and velocity to h@xmath0co maser component ii ( @xmath144 km s@xmath22 ) have tripled in intensity in 10 years .
it is interesting to note that the h@xmath0co masers have also tripled in intensity over 10 years . since it is unlikely that the h@xmath0o and h@xmath0co masers exist in the same volume , perhaps the two species are related by a shock interaction with a clump at @xmath144 km s@xmath22
indeed , the shock - driven pumping scheme for h@xmath0o masers ( elitzur , hollenbach , & mckee 1989 ) includes molecular clumps and may be compatible with the h@xmath0co pumping mechanism we suggest using the hill & hollenbach ( 1978 ) and bertoldi & draine ( 1996 ) models .
we have detected and imaged the unusual h@xmath0co masers with vlbi baselines for the first time showing milliarcsecond structure ( tens of aus in linear scale ) and brightness temperatures in excess of @xmath96 k. merlin images of the ngc 7538 h@xmath0co masers show the separation between the two velocity components to be @xmath43 mas and the components appear to arise in separate clouds .
we also measure a @xmath145 velocity gradient in the ngc 7538 maser gas . both ngc 7538 maser components
have been shown to increase intensity on 5 - 10 year timescales despite remaining constant in intensity for the first 10 years after discovery .
we do not detect variability in the g29.96 masers on a two year timescale .
we detect the 2 cm formaldehyde line in absorption in both ngc 7538 and g29.96 .
we detect no 2 cm line emission from any of the maser regions from which we conlcude that there is no inversion of the 2 cm levels . from the good agreement between the column densities derived from the maser lines and the absorption lines , we find that the inversion of the masers is @xmath146 .
we suggest that the strong but rare formaldehyde inversion process involves a collisional pumping interaction .
we posit that the environment which generates these pump conditions results from unusual shock dynamics around the regions .
is supported by the nrao pre - doctoral researcher program .
we thank d. s. shepherd for helpful comments on an earlier draft .
we thank m. hoare for communicating the merlin observations of the ngc 7538 h@xmath0o masers .
the optical depth @xmath52 for thermal absorption is proportional to @xmath147 where @xmath15 is the permanent dipole moment of the molecule , @xmath148 is the transition frequency , @xmath149 is the thermal doppler line width , @xmath150 is the line strength , and @xmath151 and @xmath152 are , respectively , the number of absorbers and the statistical weights of the upper and lower levels of the transition . for the 6 cm and 2 cm transitions of formaldehyde @xmath153 , @xmath154 , @xmath155 for both levels in the 6 cm doublet , and @xmath156 for both levels in the 2 cm doublet ( see townes & schawlow , 1955 )
. we may analyze our data using a four level system for which we use the following notation : @xmath157 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 , and @xmath160 .
we shall present our results as constraints on three excitation temperatures ; @xmath161 between the 6 cm doublet levels , @xmath162 between the 2 cm doublet levels , and @xmath163 between the @xmath164 and @xmath165 doublets .
we examine only those absorbing systems for which we have detected both 6 cm and 2 cm absorption .
also , we assume that the absorbing clouds are smaller than the telescope beam while the extent of the continuum radiation is not .
when both the 6 cm and 2 cm line have been observed we may compare the optical depths of the lines @xmath166 where it is assumed that @xmath167 , where @xmath168 is the solid angle of the telescope beam over which the absorption measurement is averaged , and where @xmath169 can be substituted since the total populations between the 6 cm and 2 cm doublets are approximately thermally distributed . substituting @xmath170 , we have the relation @xmath171 for calculations we will use @xmath172 , @xmath173 k , and @xmath174 ghz .
akabane , kenji , matsuo , hiroshi , kuno , nario , & sugitani , koji 2001 , , 53 , 821 baan , w. a. , gsten , r. , & haschick , a. d. 1986 , , 305 , 830 baan , w. a. , haschick , a. d. , & uglesich , r. 1993 , , 415 , 140 baudry , a. , desmurs , j. f. , wilson , t. l. , & cohen , r. j. 1997 , , 325 , 255 bertoldi , f. & draine , b. t. 1996 , , 458 , 222 bieging , j. , downes , d. , wilson , t. l. , martin , a. h. m. , & guesten , r. 1980 , , 42 , 163 bloomer , j. d. , watson , d. m. , pipher , j. l. , forrest , w. j. , ali , b. , greenhouse , m. a. , satyapal , s. , smith , h. a. , fischer , j. , & woodward , c. e. 1998 , , 506 , 727 boland , w. & de jong , t. 1981 , , 98 , 149 campbell , b. 1984 , , 282 , l27 campbell , b. & thompson , r. i. 1984 , , 279 , 650 cesaroni , r. , hofner , p. , walmsley , c. m. , & churchwell , e. 1998 , , 331 , 709 de buizer , james m. , watson , alan m. , radomski , james t. , pia , robert k. , & telesco , charles m. 2002 , , 564 , l101 deharveng , l. , lortet , m. c. , & testor , g. 1979 , , 71 , 151 dickel , h. r. , rots , a. h. , goss , w. m. , & forster , j. r. 1982 , , 198 , 265 downes , d. & wilson , t. l. 1974 , , 191 , l77 downes , d. , wilson , t. l. , & bieging , j. 1976 , , 52 , 321 eliztur , moshe 1976 , , 203 , 124 elitzur , moshe , hollenbach , david j. , & mckee , christopher f. 1989 , , 346 , 983 elitzur , moshe 1992 , astronomical masers ( astrophys . & space sci .
library 170 ; dordrecht : kluwer ) evans , n. j. , ii , cheung , a. c. , & sloanaker , r. m. 1970 , , 159 , l9 evans , n. j. , ii , morris , g. , sato , t. , & zuckerman , b. 1975 , , 196 , 433 evans , n. j. , ii , 1975 , , 201 , 112 flower , d. r. , offer , a. , & schilke , p. 1990
, , 244 , 4p forster , j. r. , goss , w. m. , wilson , t. l. , downes , d. , & dickel , h. r. 1980 , , 84 , l1 forster , j. r. , graham , d. , goss , w. m. , & booth , r. s. 1982 , , 201 , 7p forster , j. r. , goss , w. m. , gardner , f. f. , & stewart , r. t. 1985 , , 216 , 35p garrison , b. j. , lester , w. a. , jr . , miller , w. h. , & green , s. 1975 , , 200 , l175 gaume , r. a. , johnston , k. j. , nguyen , h. a. , wilson , t. l. , dickel , h. r. , goss , w. m. , & wright , m. c. h. 1991 , , 376 , 608 gaume , r. a. , goss , w. m. , dickel , h. r. , wilson , t. l. , & johnston , k. j. 1995 , , 438 , 776 green , s. , garrison , b. j. , lester , w. a. , jr . , & miller , w. h. 1978 , , 37 , 321 guibert , j. , elitzur , m. , & nguyen - q - rieu 1978 , , 66 , 395 hill , j. k. & hollenbach d. j. 1978 , , 225 390 hoban , s. , reuter , d. c. , mumma , m. j. , & storrs , a. d. 1991 , , 370 , 228 hofner , p. & churchwell , e. 1996 , , 120 , 283 huettemeister , s. , wilson , t. l. , mauersberger , r. , lemme , c. , dahmen , g. , & henkel , c. 1995 , , 294 , 667 israel , f. p. , habing , h. j. , & de jong , t. 1973 , , 27 , 143 jaffe , d. t. & martn - pintado , j. 1999 , , 520 , 162 johnston , k. j. , palmer , patrick , wilson , t. l. , & bieging , j. h. 1983 , , 271 , l89 kameya , o. , morita , k .-
i . , kawabe , r. & ishiguro , m. 1990 , , 355 , 562 kutner , m. , thaddeus , p. , jefferts , k. b. , penzias , a. a. , & wilson , r. w. 1971 , , 164 , l49 kutner , m. & thaddeus , p. 1971
, , 168 , l67 madden , s. c. , irvine , w. m. , matthews , h. e. , brown , r. d. , & godfrey , p. d. 1986 , , 300 , l79 martin , a. h. m. 1973 , , 163 , 141 martn - pintado , j. , wilson , t. l. , henkel , c. , & gardner , f. f. 1985 , , 142 , 131 mauersberger , r. , henkel , c. , & wilson , t. l. 1987 , , 173 , 352 mehringer , david m. , goss , w. m. , & palmer , patrick 1994 , , 434 , 237 mehringer , david m. , goss , w. m. , & palmer , patrick 1995 , , 452 , 304 minier , v. , booth , r. s. , & conway , j. e. 1998 , , 336 , l5 minier , v. , booth , r. s. , & conway , j. e. 2000 , , 362 , 1093 momose , m. , tamura , m. , kameya , o. , greaves , j. s. , chrysostomou , a. , hough , j. h. , & morino , j .- i . 2001 , , 555 , 855 morisset , c. , schaerer , d. , martn - hernndez , n. l. , peeters , e. , damour , f. , baluteau , j .-
, cox , p. , & roelfsema , p. 2002
, , 386 , 558 nerf , r. b. , jr .
1972 , , 174 , 467 osterbrock , d. e. 1989 , astrophysics of gaseous nebulae and active galactic nuclei ( university science books : mill valley ) palmer , patrick , zuckerman , b. , buhl , david , & snyder , lewis e. 1969 , , 156 , l147 palmer , p. , gardner , f. f. , & whiteoak , j. b. 1984 , , 211 , 41p pavlakis , k. g. & kylafis , n. d. 2000 , , 534 , 770 pratap , p. , snyder , l. e. , & batrla , w. 1992 , , 387 , 241 pratap , p. , menten , k. m. , & snyder , l. e. 1994 , , 430 , l129 ( pms94 ) pratap , preethi , megeath , s. t. , & bergin , edwin a. 1999 , , 517 , 799 rots , a. h. , dickel , h. r. , forster , j. r. , & goss , w. m. 1981 , , 245 , l15 schier , f. l. , jrgensen , j. k. , van dishoeck , e. f. , & blake , g. a. 2002 , , 390 , 1001 snyder , l. e. , buhl , d. , zuckerman , b. , & palmer , p. 1969
, , 22 , 679 sutton , e. c. , sobolev , a. m. , ellingsen , s. p. , cragg , d. m. , mehringer , d. m. , ostrovskii , a. b. , & godfrey , p. d. 2001 , , 554 , 173 thaddeus , p. , wilson , r. w. , kutner , m. , penzias , a. a. , & jefferts , k. b. 1971 , , 168 , l59 thaddeus , p. 1972
, , 173 , 317 thompson , a. r. 1999 , in synthesis imaging in radio astronomy ii . edited by g.
b. taylor , c. l. carilli , and r. a. perley . asp conference series , 180 , 11 townes , c. h. & cheung , a. c. 1969 , , 157 , l103 townes , c. h. & schawlow , a. l. 1955 , microwave spectroscopy ; new york : mcgraw - hill tucker , k. d. , tomasevich , g. r. , & thaddeus , p. 1971
, , 169 , 429 tucker , k. d. , tomasevich , g. r. , & thaddeus , p. 1972
, , 174 , 463 van der tak , f. f. s. , van dishoeck , e. f. , & caselli , p. 2000 , , 361 , 327 wadiak , e. j. , rood , r. t. , & wilson , t. l. 1988 , , 324 , 931 walker , r. c. 1999 , in synthesis imaging in radio astronomy ii . edited by g. b. taylor , c. l. carilli , and r. a. perley . asp conference series , 180 , 433 walmsley , c. m. & ungerechts , h. 1983 , , 122 , 164 walsh , a. j. , burton , m. g. , hyland , a. r. , & robinson , g. 1998 , , 301 , 640 whiteoak , j. b. & gardner , f. f. 1983 , , 205 , 27p willner , s. p. 1976
, , 206 , 728 wison , t. l. 1972 , , 19 , 354 wilson , t. l. & henkel , c. 1988 , , 206 , l26 wynn - williams , c. , becklin , e. , & neugebauer , g. 1974 , , 187 , 473 l c c c c c c c c c c vla ` cnb ' & 2 cm & -58.0 & 32.0 & 1562.5 & 63 & 3c286 & 3.40 & b2229 + 695 & 1.1 & @xmath1752 + vla ` cnb ' & 6 cm & -58.0 & 95.0 & 1562.5 & 127 & 3c286 & 7.47 & b2229 + 695 & 1.1 & @xmath1752 + vla ` b ' & 6 cm & -59.0 & 7.0 & 98.0 & 63 & 3c48 & 5.48 & b2229 + 695 & 1.1 & @xmath1752 + merlin & 6 cm & -59.0 & 30.0 & 500.0 & 256 & 3c286 & 7.47 & b2300 + 638 & 1.0 & 100 + vlba+y27 & 6 cm & -59.0 & 30.0 & 500.0 & 128 & b1749 + 096 & 2.2 & j2302 + 6405 & 0.25 & @xmath1752 + vla ` cnb ' & 2 cm & 100.0 & 32.0 & 1562.5 & 63 & 3c286 & 3.40 & b1749 + 096 & 2.1 & @xmath1752 + vla ` cnb ' & 6 cm & 100.0 & 95.0 & 1562.5 & 127 & 3c286 & 7.47 & b1821 + 107 & 1.3 & @xmath1752 + vlba+y27 & 6 cm & 100.3 & 30.0 & 500.0 & 128 & b1749 + 096 & 2.2 & j1851 + 0035 & 0.4 & 10 + l c c c c c c r vla ` cnb ' & 2 cm & 13 feb 1996 & 0.60 & 6 & [email protected] & 53 & 90 + vla ` cnb ' & 6 cm & 13 feb 1996 & 0.80 & 6 & [email protected] & 38 & 120 + vla ` b ' & 6 cm & 24 jul 2002 & 0.20 & 5 & [email protected] & -11 & 36 + merlin & 6 cm & 02 oct 2001 & 0.14 & 9 & [email protected] & 38 & 1.2 + vlba+y27 & 6 cm & 23 sep 2000 & 0.30 & 13 & [email protected] & 37 & 0.25 + vla ` cnb ' & 2 cm & 13 feb 1996 & 0.60 & 6 & [email protected] & 22 & 90 + vla ` cnb ' & 6 cm & 13 feb 1996 & 0.80 & 6 & [email protected] & 11 & 120 + vlba+y27 & 6 cm & 23 sep 2000 & 0.30 & 7 & [email protected] & -17 & 0.25 + r r r r i & 1268(20 ) & -58.05(1 ) & 0.99(6 ) + ii & 372(20 ) & -60.22(8 ) & 0.88(8 ) + i & 1310(35 ) & -57.90(4 ) & 0.82(5 ) + ii & 270(35 ) & -60.19(6 ) & 0.64(8 ) + ia & 216(13 ) & -57.90(2 ) & 0.37(9 ) + ib & 153(13 ) & -57.82(2 ) & 0.41(9 ) + ii & & & + r c c c -57.6 & & 0.27 & 11b + -58.1 & & 2.42 & 11d + -60.1 & & 3.36 & 11b + -57.3 & 3.60 & & 14c + 107.1 & 2.17 & 7.79 & 13a , 12b + 98.2 & 18.99 & & 13a + 100.8 & 0.71 & & 14a + 98.5 & 0.61 & 0.78 & 14a , b + l r r c r c h@xmath0co & @xmath180 & @xmath181 & 1 & 2 & 3.1.1 + @xmath182nh@xmath19 ( 3,3 ) & @xmath183 & @xmath184 & 2,3 & 100 & 10 + oh ( 1720 mhz ) & @xmath185 & @xmath186 & 4 & 100 & 11 + oh ( 4765 mhz ) & @xmath187 & @xmath188 & 5,12 & 500 & 12 + oh ( 6035 mhz ) & @xmath189 & @xmath190 & 6 & 1800 & 13 + ch@xmath19oh & @xmath183 & @xmath191 & 7 & 30 & 14 + h@xmath0o & @xmath192 & @xmath193 & 8 & 15 & 15,16 + @xmath194nh@xmath19 ( 9,6 ) & @xmath195 & @xmath196 & 9,17 & 3000 & 17 + | the 6 cm formaldehyde ( h@xmath0co ) maser sources in the compact regions ngc 7538-irs1 and g29.96 - 0.02 have been imaged at high resolution ( @xmath1 mas ) . using the vlba and merlin , we find the angular sizes of the ngc 7538 masers to be @xmath2 mas ( 30 au ) corresponding to brightness temperatures @xmath3 k. the angular sizes of the g29.96 - 0.02 masers are @xmath4 mas ( 130 au ) corresponding to brightness temperatures @xmath5 k. using the vla , we detect 2 cm formaldehyde absorption from the maser regions .
we detect no emission in the 2 cm line , indicating the lack of a 2 cm maser and placing limits on the 6 cm excitation process .
we find that both ngc 7538 maser components show an increase in intensity on 5 - 10 year timescales while the g29.96 - 0.02 masers show no variability over 2 years .
a search for polarization provides 3-@xmath6 upper limits of 1% circularly polarized and 10% linearly polarized emission in ngc 7538 and of 15% circularly polarized emission in g29.96 - 0.02 .
a pronounced velocity gradient of 28 @xmath7 ( 1900 @xmath8 ) is detected in the ngc 7538 maser gas . |
the existence of complete non flat minimal surfaces with bounded coordinate functions , has been the instigator of many interesting articles on the theory of minimal surfaces in @xmath4 and @xmath3 over the last few decades .
the question of whether there exists a complete bounded complex submanifold in @xmath6 was proposed by p. yang in @xcite and answered by p. jones in @xcite where this author present a short and elegant method to construct bounded ( embedded ) complex curves @xmath7 , where @xmath8 means the open unit disc of the complex plane .
although these curves are minimal in @xmath3 ( they are holomorphic ) , their respective projections @xmath9 and @xmath10 are not minimal in @xmath4 .
if we pursue this , we need to impose that the complex curve @xmath7 also satisfies @xmath11 where @xmath12 denotes the derivative with respect to the complex coordinate on @xmath8 . from now on , curves of this kind
will be called _ holomorphic null curves .
_ the previous question is closely related to an earlier question by e. calabi , who asked in 1965 @xcite whether or not it is possible for a complete minimal surface in @xmath4 to be contained in a ball in @xmath4 .
two articles , in particular , have made very important , if not fundamental , contributions to this problem .
the first one was by l. p. jorge and f. xavier @xcite , who constructed examples of complete minimal surfaces in a slab .
the second one was by n. nadirashvili @xcite , who more recently produced examples contained in a ball . in both cases ,
the key step was the ingenious use of runge s classical theorem . in respect
to complete bounded minimal null curves in @xmath6 , the existence of such curves has been an open problem for @xmath13 . for the case
@xmath14 , j. bourgain @xcite proves that these curves can not exist .
moreover , jones in @xcite proved that for @xmath15 it is possible to construct complete bounded null curves in @xmath6 . in this paper
we give a positive solution to the existence of complete bounded null curves in @xmath3 and obtain some interesting consequences .
to be more precise , we prove the following theorem : [ thm : a ] there is a complete holomorphic null immersion @xmath16 whose image is bounded . in particular , there is a complete bounded ( immersed ) minimal surface in @xmath4 such that its conjugate minimal surface is also bounded . here
, we denote by @xmath17 ( resp .
@xmath18 ) the open ( resp
. closed ) ball in @xmath19 of radius @xmath20 centered at @xmath21 .
since the projection of @xmath22 into @xmath5 gives a holomorphic immersion , we also get the following result , see section [ subsec : proof2dim ] : [ cor : b ] there is a complete holomorphic immersion @xmath23 whose image is bounded .
we remark that the existence of complete bounded complex submanifolds in @xmath3 has been shown in @xcite .
theorem [ thm : a ] is equivalent to the existence of complete bounded null curves in @xmath2 , and also equivalent to complete bounded mean curvature @xmath24 surfaces ( i.e. cmc-1 surface ) in the hyperbolic @xmath0-space @xmath1 . here
a holomorphic map @xmath25 from a riemann surface @xmath26 to the complex lie group @xmath2 is called _ null _ if the determinant @xmath27 of @xmath28 vanishes , that is @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is a complex coordinate of @xmath26 .
a projection @xmath31 of a null holomorphic curve is a cmc-1 surface in @xmath1 , where @xmath32 is the projection , see in section [ subsec : sl2c ] .
then theorem [ thm : a ] is a corollary to the existence of complete bounded null curve in @xmath2 as in theorem [ thm : c ] , see section [ subsec : c3sl2c ] . to state the theorem
, we define the matrix norm @xmath33 as @xmath34 for @xmath35-matrix @xmath36 ( see appendix [ app : norm ] ) . note that if @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and the equality holds if and only if @xmath36 is the identity matrix .
[ thm : c ] for each real number @xmath39 , there is a complete holomorphic null immersion @xmath40 such that @xmath41 . in particular
, there is a complete cmc-1 surface in @xmath42 of genus zero with one end contained in a given geodesic ball ( of radius @xmath43 , see lemma [ lem : dist - norm ] in appendix [ app : norm ] ) . a projection of immersed null holomorphic curves in @xmath3 ( resp .
@xmath2 ) onto lorentz - minkowski 3-space @xmath44 ( resp
. de sitter 3-space @xmath45 ) gives maximal surfaces ( resp .
cmc-@xmath24 surfaces ) , which may admit singular points .
recently , alarcon @xcite constructed a space - like maximal surface bounded by a hyperboloid in @xmath44 , which is weakly complete in the sense of @xcite but may not be bounded .
it should be remarked that our bounded null curve in @xmath3 in theorem [ thm : a ] induces a bounded maximal surface in @xmath44 as a refinement of alarcon s result : [ cor : maxface ] there are a weakly complete space - like maximal surface in @xmath44 and a weakly complete space - like @xmath46-@xmath24 surface in @xmath45 whose image are bounded .
the definition of weak completeness for maximal surfaces and for cmc-@xmath24 surfaces ( with singularities ) are mentioned in the proof in section [ subsec : proofmaxface ] .
our procedure to prove theorem [ thm : c ] is similar in style to that used by nadirashvili in @xcite ( see also @xcite for a more general construction ) .
however , we have to improve the techniques because nadirashvili s method does not allow us to control the imaginary part of the resulting minimal immersion . in order to do this
, we work on a cmc-1 surface in hyperbolic 3-space @xmath1 instead of a minimal surface in euclidean 3-space . on each step of construction
, we will apply runge approximation for very small region of the surface , and so we can treat such a small part of the cmc-1 surface like as minimal surface in the euclidean 3-space , which is the first crucial point
. we shall give an error estimation between minimal surface and the cmc-1 surface by using the well - known ode - technique ( see [ subsec : est - ode ] in appendix [ app : norm ] ) .
next , we will lift the resulting bounded cmc-1 surface into a null curve @xmath2 . since @xmath1 is a quotient of @xmath2 by @xmath47 , the compactness of @xmath47 yields the boundedness of the lifted null curve associated with the bounded cmc-1 surface .
finally , using a transformation between null curves in @xmath3 and null curves in @xmath2 , we can get a complete bounded null immersed curve in @xmath3 from the one in @xmath2 .
section [ subsec : proof2dim ] is devoted to explain this equivalence . to prove theorem [ thm : c ] , the following lemma plays a crucial role ( see section [ subsec : proofsl2c ] ) : [ main ] let @xmath48 and @xmath49 be positive real numbers and @xmath50 a holomorphic null immersion such that 1 .
[ lem : main : ass-1 ] @xmath51 , 2 .
[ lem : main : ass-2 ] @xmath52 contains the geodesic disc of radius @xmath48 with center @xmath21 , where @xmath53 is the induced metric by @xmath22 defined in .
[ lem : main : ass-3 ] @xmath54 for @xmath55 . then for arbitrary positive numbers
@xmath56 and @xmath57 , there exists a holomorphic null immersion @xmath58 such that 1 .
[ lem : main : concl-1 ] @xmath59 , 2 .
[ lem : main : concl-2 ] @xmath60 contains the geodesic disc of radius @xmath61 with center @xmath21 , 3 .
[ lem : main : concl-3 ] @xmath62 for @xmath55 , 4 .
[ lem : main : concl-4 ] @xmath63 and @xmath64 on the open disc @xmath65 , where @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 for the complex coordinate @xmath30 in @xmath8 .
a crucial difference between our main lemma and the main lemma in @xcite is the estimation of extrinsic radius . in @xcite ,
the extrinsic radius is estimated as @xmath69 and the boundedness of the extrinsic radius of the resulting surface reduces to the fact that @xmath70 converges .
however , our estimation of the extrinsic radius is multiplicative and reduces to the fact that @xmath71 converges . as an application of theorem [ thm : a ] , the existence of higher genus examples corresponding to corollary [ cor : b ] and corollary [ cor : maxface ] is recently shown in @xcite .
we would like to finish this introduction by mentioning a relating result .
f. x. mller in @xcite introduced a remarkable relationship between complete bounded minimal surfaces in @xmath4 and martingales .
let @xmath26 be a riemann surface and @xmath72 a null holomorphic _ immersion _ , and set @xmath73 where @xmath30 is a local complex coordinate on @xmath26 .
then @xmath74 is a locally defined @xmath3-valued holomorphic function such that @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the inner product of @xmath3 defined by @xmath77 and @xmath78 is the hermitian norm of @xmath3 .
conversely , if a @xmath3-valued 1-form @xmath79 on a simply connected riemann surface @xmath26 satisfies , @xmath80 is a holomorphic null immersion , where @xmath81 is a base point .
we define the _ induced metric _ @xmath82 of @xmath83 as @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the canonical hermitian metric of @xmath3 .
note that @xmath82 is a _ half _ of the pull - back @xmath86 , and coincides with the induced metric of the minimal immersion @xmath87 since @xmath83 is a null curve , we can write @xmath88 where @xmath89 and @xmath90 are a meromorphic function and a holomorphic @xmath24-form , respectively .
we call @xmath91 the _ weierstrass data _ of @xmath83 . using these weierstrass data ,
we can write @xmath92 here , @xmath93 can be identified with the gauss map by the stereographic projection .
a holomorphic map @xmath94 from a riemann surface @xmath26 into the complex lie group @xmath2 is called _ null _ if @xmath95 holds on @xmath26 , where @xmath12 denotes the derivative with respect to a complex coordinate @xmath30 .
take a null holomorphic _ immersion _ @xmath96 and let @xmath97 since @xmath94 is a null immersion , @xmath98 is a holomorphic @xmath99-valued @xmath24-form with @xmath100 where @xmath101 denotes the matrix norm defined in in the appendix .
conversely , if an @xmath99-valued holomorphic @xmath24-form @xmath102 on a simply connected riemann surface @xmath26 satisfies , the solution @xmath94 of an ordinary differential equation @xmath103 is a null holomorphic immersion into @xmath2 .
we define the _ induced metric _
@xmath104 of @xmath94 as @xmath105 where @xmath85 is the canonical hermitian metric of @xmath2 induced from the matrix norm ( a.1 ) in the appendix . identifying the hyperbolic @xmath0-space @xmath1 with the set @xmath106 as in in appendix [ app : norm ]
, @xmath107 gives a conformal mean curvature one immersion ( a cmc-1 surface @xcite ) , where @xmath32 is the projection .
the induced metric of @xmath108 coincides with @xmath104 , which is the reason why we add the coefficient @xmath109 in . since @xmath94 is null , we can write @xmath110 where @xmath89 and @xmath90 are a meromorphic function and a holomorphic @xmath24-form , respectively .
we call @xmath91 the _ weierstrass data _ of @xmath94
. then we can write @xmath111 the meromorphic function @xmath89 is called the _ secondary gauss map _ of @xmath94 ( @xcite ) .
if a null curve @xmath83 in @xmath3 and a null curve @xmath94 in @xmath2 are obtained by the same weierstrass data @xmath112 , their induced metrics coincide , and then they have the same intrinsic behavior . in this case
, we call @xmath94 the _ cousin _ of @xmath83 . the forms @xmath113 and @xmath98 in and are related as @xmath114 in which @xmath115 holds . remark that the weierstrass data @xmath116 in @xcite coincides with @xmath117 here .
we call a @xmath3-valued holomorphic @xmath24-form @xmath79 on @xmath26 a _ w - data _ if holds .
if @xmath26 is simply connected , it provides a null curve in @xmath3 by , while a null curve in @xmath2 by and .
firstly , we give a proof of theorem [ thm : a ] in the introduction using theorem [ thm : c ] . it should be remarked that even when a null curve in @xmath3 is complete and bounded , its cousin in @xmath2 may not be bounded in general .
so we consider another transformation to prove theorem [ thm : a ] .
let @xmath118 which is birational , and it can be easily checked that @xmath119 maps null curves in @xmath120 to null curves in @xmath2 .
the map @xmath119 is essentially the same as bryant s transformation of null curves between @xmath3 and the complex quadric @xmath121 @xcite .
let @xmath25 be a complete bounded null immersion defined on a riemann surface @xmath26 . by replacing @xmath94 by @xmath122 ( @xmath123 )
, we may assume @xmath124 without loss of generality , where @xmath125 .
then @xmath126 is a bounded holomorphic null immersion of @xmath26 into @xmath3 . on any bounded set in @xmath3 ,
the pull - back of canonical hermitian metric of @xmath2 by @xmath119 is equivalent to the canonical hermitian metric of @xmath3 by the following well - known lemma [ lem : metric ] .
hence the induced metric @xmath127 of @xmath128 is complete because so is the induced metric @xmath104 of @xmath94 .
[ lem : metric ] let @xmath129 and @xmath130 be two riemannian metrics on a manifold @xmath131 . for each compact subset @xmath132 of @xmath131 , there exist constants @xmath133 such that @xmath134 on @xmath132 .
[ rem : imbound ] boundedness of the real part of a null immersion in @xmath3 ( a minimal surface ) does not imply the boundedness of its imaginary part ( the conjugate surface ) in general .
in contrast to this fact , _ a cmc-1 surface @xmath108 is bounded if and only if so is its holomorphic lift @xmath94 _ , because @xmath135 and @xmath136 , where @xmath33 denotes the matrix norm as in appendix [ app : norm ] . or the _ compact _ lie group @xmath47 is considered as the `` imaginary part '' in @xmath42 .
next , we give a proof of corollary [ cor : b ] in the introduction .
let @xmath137 be a null holomorphic immersion obtained by theorem [ thm : a ] , and @xmath112 the weierstrass data as in .
then the projection @xmath138 of @xmath83 is a bounded holomorphic map .
moreover , it is a complete immersion .
in fact , @xmath139 hence @xmath140 never vanishes and @xmath141 is complete . let @xmath142 be a bounded null immersion as in theorem [ thm : a ]
. then @xmath143 provides a maximal surface ( i.e. with zero mean curvature ) with singularities .
since @xmath22 is an immersion , @xmath144 is considered as a _
maxface _ in the sense of @xcite .
moreover , the _ lift metric _ as in ( * ? ? ?
* definition 2.7 ) coincides with @xmath53 given in , which is complete .
then in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* definition 4.4 ) , @xmath144 is weakly complete . similarly , take a null immersion @xmath145 as in theorem [ thm : c ] , and let @xmath146 where @xmath45 is the de sitter @xmath0-space . then @xmath147 gives a cmc-1 ( i.e. , mean curvature one ) surface with singularities . since @xmath148 is an immersion , @xmath147 is a _ cmc-1 face _ in the sense of @xcite and @xcite .
moreover , since the induced metric of @xmath149 is complete , @xmath147 is _ weakly complete _ in the sense of @xcite .
the proof of theorem [ thm : c ] via main lemma follows an standard inductive argument .
we construct a suitable sequence @xmath150 of null immersions of @xmath151 into @xmath2 as follows : take an initial null immersion @xmath152 such that @xmath153 is the geodesic disc of radius @xmath154 with center @xmath21 , and fix a positive integer @xmath155 . for each integer @xmath156
, we apply our main lemma inductively supposing that @xmath157 has been already constructed .
let @xmath158 since @xmath159 , we can construct @xmath160 such that 1 .
@xmath161 contains a geodesic disc centered at the origin and of radius @xmath162 2 . the inequality @xmath163 holds on @xmath164 , where @xmath165 is a positive constant depending only on the initial choice of the null curve @xmath166 , 3 .
and @xmath167 converges to a complete null immersion @xmath168 uniformly on any compact set of @xmath8 . as a consequence
, @xmath22 satisfies @xmath169 on @xmath170 .
we can choose the initial data of the initial curve @xmath166 such that @xmath165 is arbitrarily close to @xmath171 .
since @xmath172 is also arbitrary , we can let @xmath173 for an arbitrary @xmath39 .
to prove the main lemma , we will work on nadirashvili s labyrinth ( @xcite ) .
we fix the definitions and notations on the labyrinth : let @xmath131 be a ( sufficiently large ) positive number . for @xmath174 , we set @xmath175 and let @xmath176 we define an annular domain @xmath177 as @xmath178 and @xmath179 where @xmath180 is the ray @xmath181 .
let @xmath182 be a compact set defined as @xmath183 and define a compact set @xmath184 by @xmath185 where @xmath186 denotes the @xmath56-neighborhood ( of the euclidean plane @xmath187 ) of @xmath182 .
each connected component of @xmath184 has width @xmath188 . for each number @xmath189
, we set @xmath190 then @xmath191 s are compact sets .
the construction of complete bounded minimal surfaces in @xmath4 provides the following assertion ( see @xcite ) : [ lem : transf ] let @xmath192 be an integer , and @xmath193 a w - data on @xmath151 ( in the sense of the end of section [ sec : prelim ] ) . then for each @xmath194 and each integer @xmath195 satisfying @xmath196 , there exists a new w - data @xmath197 on @xmath151 satisfying the following properties : 1 . [
item : trans:1 ] on @xmath198 , it holds that @xmath199 2 .
[ item : trans:2 ] there exists a constant @xmath200 depending only on @xmath113 such that @xmath201 3 .
[ item : trans:3 ] there exists a real unit vector @xmath202 in @xmath4 such that @xmath203 and @xmath204 holds , where @xmath76 is the inner product as in .
let @xmath205 be the real part of null immersion @xmath206 as in for @xmath207 .
we think in @xmath205 as the minimal immersion @xmath208 in @xcite .
then we can construct a new minimal immersion @xmath209 imitating the corresponding procedure as in @xcite .
however , our construction of @xmath209 is much easier .
actually , we do not need to adjust that @xmath210 to be contained in a certain cone with small cone - angle centered at @xmath211-axis in @xmath4 .
the conditions [ item : trans:1 ] and [ item : trans:2 ] follow from ( * ? ? ?
* , items ( a.1@xmath212 ) , ( a.2@xmath212 ) , and ( a.3@xmath212 ) ) .
the condition [ item : trans:3 ] follows from ( * ? ? ?
* ( 11 ) ) .
however , to get the estimate @xmath213 on @xmath214 , we need the property that @xmath215 as in ( * ? ? ?
* ( b.3 ) or p. 293 ) , where @xmath89 is the meromorphic function in . for this purpose , the axis for the lopez - ros deformation corresponding to the deformation of weierstrass data @xmath216 with respect to a certain holomorphic function as in ( * ?
* ( 4 ) ) and in @xcite might be slightly moved from the @xmath211-axis with the angle @xmath217 , that is @xmath218 finally , we let @xmath219 to be the weierstrass data of our @xmath209 . then it satisfies the desired properties . in this subsection
, we shall reduce our main lemma to the following let @xmath220 be a null holomorphic immersion satisfying @xmath221 such that @xmath222 contains a geodesic disc of radius @xmath48 with center @xmath21 . for each positive numbers @xmath56 and s with @xmath223 , there exist a sufficiently large integer @xmath131 and a sequence of null immersions @xmath224 satisfying the following properties : 1 . [ item : key:1 ] @xmath225 , 2 . [ item : key:2 ] @xmath226 holds on @xmath198 , where @xmath227 3 .
[ item : key:3 ] there exists a constant @xmath228 depending only on @xmath229 such that @xmath230 4 .
[ item : key:4 ] @xmath8 contains a closed geodesic disc @xmath231 centered at @xmath21 with radius @xmath61 with respect to @xmath232 .
moreover , it holds that @xmath233 where @xmath234 is the boundary of @xmath235 , and @xmath236 is a constant depending only on @xmath229 .
we construct the sequence of null immersions @xmath237 in @xmath2 inductively .
assume that @xmath238 ( @xmath239 ) constructed already .
then @xmath240 is constructed as follows : we set @xmath241 then @xmath242 , and @xmath243 attains the euclidean distance between the origin @xmath244 and @xmath214 , see figure [ fig : figure-1 ] . and
the curve @xmath245 let @xmath246 be a cmc-1 surface associated with @xmath238 , and we set @xmath247 here @xmath248 is chosen so that the geodesic line passing through @xmath249 and @xmath250 lies in @xmath251-plane in @xmath252 .
( here , we consider @xmath1 a hyperboloid in the minkowski space @xmath253 , see in appendix [ app : norm ] ) .
we set @xmath254 then one can easily check that @xmath255 applying lemma [ lem : transf ] to the w - data @xmath256 , we get new a w - data @xmath257 satisfying [ item : trans:1][item : trans:3 ] . then we define a new null immersion @xmath258 such that @xmath259 after that , we set @xmath260 then @xmath225 , which proves [ item : key:1 ] , and if we set @xmath261 , it holds that @xmath262 by [ item : trans:1 ] , [ item : trans:2 ] in lemma [ lem : transf ] and and , we get the assertions [ item : key:2 ] and [ item : key:3 ] .
in this way , we can get @xmath263 inductively .
note that , by [ item : key:2 ] and corollary [ cor : comparison - hyp ] , it holds that @xmath264 where @xmath265 , @xmath266 and @xmath267 stands for the canonical distance function of @xmath1 , see [ subsec : matrixnorm ] in appendix [ app : norm ] . here , the constant @xmath268 depends only on @xmath229 .
_ throughout this proof , we shall denote by @xmath269 constants which depend only on @xmath229 . _
the properties [ item : key:2 ] and [ item : key:3 ] yield that @xmath8 contains a closed geodesic disc @xmath270 of radius @xmath61 centered at @xmath21 with respect to the induced metric @xmath232 by @xmath263 ( see @xcite ) .
let @xmath271 and we will show [ item : key:4 ] in the statement of the lemma . if @xmath272 for all @xmath189 , the inequality is easy to show using and lemma [ lem : dist - norm ] in appendix [ app : norm ] , see @xcite . otherwise , we assume @xmath273 for some @xmath195 .
let @xmath274 be the @xmath232-geodesic joining @xmath21 and @xmath275 , and take @xmath276 such that the geodesic joining @xmath277 and @xmath275 lies in @xmath214 , see figure [ fig : figure-1 ] .
then the @xmath232-distance of @xmath275 and @xmath277 satisfies @xmath278 where @xmath279 is a constant depending only on @xmath229 ( see @xcite ) .
thus , by taking a suitable path @xmath280 ( as in figure [ fig : figure-1 ] ) joining @xmath281 and @xmath277 in the complement of @xmath214 , we have @xmath282 since @xmath283 is of order @xmath284 . ] let @xmath285 be the totally geodesic plane in @xmath1 passing through @xmath286 which is perpendicular to the geodesic joining @xmath287 and @xmath288 , where @xmath289 is the point corresponding to the identity matrix @xmath290 ( as in in appendix [ app : norm ] ) .
let @xmath291 ( @xmath292 ) be the foot of perpendicular from @xmath293 to the plane @xmath285 , see figure [ fig : figure-2 ] .
then @xmath294 gives the distance of @xmath293 and the plane @xmath285 , and [ item : key:4 ] is obtained as a conclusion of the following lemma : [ lem : plane - dist ] under the situations above , namely , for @xmath295 and for @xmath296 satisfying @xmath297 it holds that @xmath298 where @xmath299 is a constant depending only on @xmath229 .
we shall prove this lemma later , and now finish the proof of key lemma : assume lemma [ lem : plane - dist ] is true . by and lemma [ lem : dist - norm ] ,
we have @xmath300 see in appendix [ app : norm ] . on the other hand , by and the fact that the three points @xmath288 , @xmath293 , @xmath291 form a right triangle ( figure [ fig : figure-2 ] ) .
@xmath301 thus , applying the hyperbolic pythagorean theorem for the hyperbolic right triangle @xmath302 ( see figure [ fig : figure-2 ] ) , we have @xmath303 for a sufficiently large @xmath131 .
the last inequality is obtained by the inequality @xmath304 for @xmath305 $ ] , and @xmath306 for a sufficiently large number @xmath131 . hence by lemma [ lem : plane - dist ] , @xmath307\\ & = \cosh\bigl ( { \operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}(o , q)\bigr ) \cosh\bigl ( { \operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}(q,\beta_j(p))\bigr)\\ & \hphantom{\cosh({\operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}(o , q))}+ \sinh\bigl ( { \operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}(o , q)\bigr ) \sinh\bigl ( { \operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}(q,\beta_j(p))\bigr)\\ & \leq \exp \left({\operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}(q,\beta_j(p))\right ) \cosh { \operatorname{dist}^{}}_{{\mathcal{h}}^3}\bigl(o , q\bigr)\\ & \leq \exp\left(14s^2+\frac{c_4}{\sqrt{n}}\right ) \frac{1}{2 } \bigl(\max_{z \in \overline{{\mathbb{d}}}_1}|{\mathcal{b}}_0(z)|\bigr)^2 \left(1+s^2 + \frac{c_6}{\sqrt{n}}\right)\\ & \leq \frac{1}{2 } \bigl(\max_{z \in \overline{{\mathbb{d}}}_1}|{\mathcal{b}}_0(z)|\bigr)^2 \left(1 + 2\left(14s^2+\frac{c_4}{\sqrt{n}}\right)\right ) \left(1+s^2 + \frac{c_6}{\sqrt{n}}\right)\\ & \leq \frac{1}{2 } \bigl(\max_{z \in \overline{{\mathbb{d}}}_1}|{\mathcal{b}}_0(z)|\bigr)^2 \left \{1+s^2 + 2\left(14s^2+\frac{c_4}{\sqrt{n}}\right)s^2 + \frac{c_7}{\sqrt{n } } \right\ } \\ & \leq \frac{1}{2 } \bigl(\max_{z \in \overline{{\mathbb{d}}}_1}|{\mathcal{b}}_0(z)|\bigr)^2 \left(1 + 2 s^2 + \frac{c_7}{\sqrt{n}}\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] here we used the inequality @xmath308 for @xmath309 $ ] , and @xmath310 for @xmath223 and a sufficiently large @xmath131 .
thus , using , we have [ item : key:4 ] . and @xmath311 let @xmath312
. note that @xmath313 and @xmath314 are congruent to @xmath315 and @xmath316 respectively , and @xmath317 because of and .
let @xmath318 be the totally geodesic plane through @xmath287 which is perpendicular to the geodesic joining @xmath287 and @xmath319 , see figure [ fig : figure-3 ] .
let @xmath320 be the isometry of @xmath1 such that @xmath321 .
then it holds that @xmath322 and it is sufficient to estimate the distance between @xmath318 and @xmath323 .
however , our estimation is not direct .
firstly , we consider the plane @xmath324 passing through @xmath287 which is perpendicular to the geodesic ray @xmath325 , which is expressed as @xmath326 because of the definition of @xmath327 in .
then it can be expected that @xmath249 must be sufficiently close to @xmath319 because @xmath328 is very close to @xmath286 , and that the distance of @xmath323 and @xmath324 might be close to that of @xmath323 and @xmath329 . according to this observation
, we shall firstly estimate the distance between @xmath323 and @xmath324 , next give the estimation of the angle of @xmath324 and @xmath329 , and will get the conclusion : [ [ step-1-the - estimation - of - the - distance - of - tilde - hp - and - pi . ] ] step 1 : _ the estimation of the distance of @xmath323 and @xmath324 . _
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we set @xmath330 where the integration is done in the path @xmath280 through the boundary of @xmath214 as in figure [ fig : figure-1 ] .
then by theorem [ thm : int - estimate-2 ] in appendix [ app : norm ] , we have @xmath331 where @xmath332 ^ 2,\quad |\widetilde\delta|\leq \left[\left(\max_{\gamma}|\widetilde h|\right)\int_{\zeta_j}^p |\tilde\psi|\,|dz|\right]^2.\ ] ] here , since the euclidean length of @xmath280 is estimated by @xmath333 , we have @xmath334 on the other hand yields @xmath335 moreover , by , it holds that @xmath336 , and we have @xmath337 on the other hand , by , we have @xmath338 and then , @xmath339 because @xmath340 . we let @xmath341 we can choose @xmath131 sufficiently large so that @xmath342 because of @xmath223 .
so we have @xmath343 then by , and and the assumption @xmath340 , we have @xmath344 @xmath345 we set @xmath346 the minkowski 4-space @xmath253 can be identified with the space of @xmath347-hermitian matrices @xmath348 , as in in appendix [ app : norm ] .
the euclidean 3-space @xmath4 is isometrically embedded in @xmath348 by @xmath349 then @xmath350 and @xmath351 can be considered as minimal immersions in @xmath352 induced by @xmath353 and @xmath354 respectively ( see and ) . then , [ item : trans:3 ] of lemma [ lem : transf ] implies that the angle @xmath355 between @xmath356-plane in @xmath4 and the vector @xmath357 is less than @xmath358 , see figure [ fig : figure-4 ] . ]
applying this fact , we shall now estimate the distance between @xmath324 in and @xmath359 : since the distance between @xmath360 and its foot of perpendicular to the plane @xmath324 is equal to @xmath361 , yields that @xmath362 where we used the inequality @xmath363 [ [ step-2-the - estimation - of - the - angle - between - of - pi - and - widetilde - pi . ] ] step 2 : _ the estimation of the angle between of @xmath324 and @xmath329 . _
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + by , we have @xmath364 next , applying , we have that @xmath365 that is , there exists a positive constant @xmath366 such that @xmath367 if @xmath131 is sufficiently large
. and @xmath329 ] now , let @xmath369 be the foot of perpendicular from @xmath249 to the geodesic @xmath370 .
then we have @xmath371 since the triangle @xmath372 is a right triangle ( see figure[fig : figure-5 ] ) .
let @xmath373 be the angle between the geodesics @xmath325 and @xmath374 at @xmath287 , which coincides with the angle between @xmath324 and @xmath318 , see figure [ fig : figure-5 ] . applying the sine law in hyperbolic geometry , we have @xmath375 by , and , we get @xmath376 where we use the fact @xmath377 .
this yields that @xmath378 .
let @xmath379 be the closest point from @xmath323 to @xmath324 . then @xmath380 because of .
thus , by step 1 , we have @xmath381 since @xmath382 depends only on @xmath229 , we have the conclusion .
we would like to finish this section with four open questions .
are there complete null curves properly immersed in the unit ball of @xmath3 ?
this problem is equivalent to ask for the existence complete cmc-1 surfaces properly immersed in a suitable domain of @xmath1 .
next problem seems to be intrinsically related with the previous one .
is it possible to construct complete embedded null curves in a ball of @xmath3 ? as we mentioned in the introduction ,
jones @xcite constructed examples of complete bounded holomorphic curves @xmath7 , but these examples do not satisfy the nullity condition . recently
, t. colding and w. p. minicozzi ii in @xcite have proved that the answer to this question in the case of @xmath4 is `` no '' .
hence , it would be interesting to know whether the situation is similar in the complex case or not .
the next two problems belong to hyperbolic geometry . are there complete bounded minimal surface in @xmath1 ? are there complete bounded surface with gaussian curvature less than @xmath383 in @xmath1 ?
like as in @xcite , our construction of cmc-1 surface in @xmath1 can be taken to be of negative gaussian curvature if we begin to prove our main theorem via an umbilic point free initial cmc-1 surface .
however , we can expect @xmath383 since it is equal to the curvature of @xmath1 .
we define the hermitian norm @xmath33 of @xmath384 , the set of @xmath35 matrices of complex coefficients by @xmath385 where @xmath386 . by definition , @xmath387 holds for any unitary matrix @xmath388 .
moreover , one can easily verify the following properties : on the other hand , we identify the set @xmath348 of @xmath35-hermitian matrices with the minkowski @xmath395-space @xmath253 as @xmath396 the hyperbolic @xmath0-space @xmath1 is considered as the hyperboloid in @xmath253 , which is identified as @xmath397 we denote by @xmath267 the distance function of @xmath1
. then @xmath398 holds .
[ thm : int - estimate-2 ] if @xmath410\to m_2({\mathbb{c}})$ ] satisfies , it holds that @xmath415}|{\mathcal{b}}(t)|\bigr)\int_0^t|\alpha(t)|\,dt \right)^2 , \qquad
\left(z(t):={\mathcal{b}}(t)-{\operatorname{id}}-\int_{0}^t \alpha(t ) dt\right).\ ] ] we now let @xmath422 and @xmath423 be smooth functions into @xmath99 defined on @xmath424 $ ] , and consider initial value problems @xmath425 for any continuous function @xmath426\to m_2({\mathbb{c}})$ ] , we define the supremum norm of @xmath280 by @xmath427}|\gamma(t)|.\ ] ] take @xmath36 as @xmath432 . differentiating it , we have @xmath433 , which implies the first conclusion . since @xmath434 , we have @xmath435}|x|\right ) \left(\max_{t\in[0,a]}|y|\right)^2.\ ] ] by theorem [ thm : int - estimate ] we have @xmath436 , which yields the conclusion .
fruyy a. alarcon , _ on the calabi - yau problem for maximal surfaces in @xmath44 _ , differ .
* 26 * ( 2008 ) , 625634 .
j. bourgain , _ on the radial variation of bounded analytic functions on the disc _ , duke math . j. , * 69 * ( 1993 ) , 671682 .
r. bryant , _ surfaces of mean curvature one in hyperbolic space _ ,
astrisque * 154155 * ( 1987 ) , 321347 .
r. bryant , _ surfaces in conformal geometry _ , proc . of symposia in pure math .
, * 48 * ( 1988 ) , 227240 .
e. calabi , _ problems in differential geometry _ , ed .
s. kobayashi and j. eells , jr . , in proceedings of the united states - japan seminar in differential geometry , kyoto , japan , 1965 , nippon hyoronsha co. , ltd . , tokyo ( 1966 ) p. 170
. t. h. colding and w. p. minicozzi ii , _ the calabi - yau conjectures for embedded surfaces .
_ preprint , 2004 ; math.dg/0404197 .
s. fujimori , w. rossman , m. umehara , k. yamada and s .- d .
yang , _ spacelike mean curvature one surfaces in de sitter @xmath0-space _ , preprint , 2007 ; arxiv:0706.0973 , to appear in communications in analysis and geometry .
m. umehara and k.yamada , _ complete surfaces of constant mean curvature-@xmath24 in the hyperbolic @xmath0-space _ , ann . of math .
* 137 * ( 1993 ) , 611638 .
m. umehara and k. yamada , _ surfaces of constant mean curvature @xmath444 in @xmath445 with prescribed hyperbolic gauss map _ , math .
* 304 * ( 1996 ) , 203224 .
m. umehara and k. yamada , _ maximal surfaces with singularities in mikowski space _ , hokkaido math . j.
* 35 * ( 2006 ) , 1340 .
p. yang , _ curvature of complex submanifolds in @xmath6 _ , proc .
symp . pure math .
30 , part 2 , american mathematical society , providence , r. i. , 1977 , pp . | we construct a simply connected complete bounded mean curvature one surface in the hyperbolic @xmath0-space @xmath1 . such a surface in @xmath1 can be lifted as a complete bounded null curve in @xmath2 . using a transformation between null curves in @xmath3 and null curves in @xmath2 , we are able to produce the first examples of complete bounded null curves in @xmath3 . as an application
, we can show the existence of a complete bounded minimal surface in @xmath4 whose conjugate minimal surface is also bounded .
moreover , we can show the existence of a complete bounded immersed complex submanifold in @xmath5 . |
according to the geometric invariant theory introduced by mumford @xcite , the _ git quotient _ @xmath0 of an action of a complex reductive group @xmath1 on a projective variety @xmath2 equipped with a polarization ( ample equivariant line bundle ) has coordinate ring equal to the @xmath1-invariant part of the coordinate ring on @xmath2 .
geometrically @xmath0 is the quotient of an open _ semistable locus
_ @xmath3 by an equivalence relation , where a point @xmath4 is semistable if there is a non - constant invariant section of a tensor power of the polarization that is non - zero at the point .
if the action of @xmath1 on the semistable locus has only finite stabilizers , then @xmath0 is the quotient of @xmath5 by the action of @xmath1 , by which we mean here the _ stack - theoretic _ quotient , see for example @xcite .
if @xmath2 is in addition smooth , then @xmath0 is a smooth proper deligne - mumford stack with projective coarse moduli space . in kempf - ness @xcite , see also mumford et al @xcite , the coarse moduli space of the git quotient is identified with the symplectic quotient of @xmath2 by a maximal compact subgroup of @xmath1 .
the question of how the git quotient depends on the polarization , or equivalently , choice of moment map is studied in a series of papers by guillemin - sternberg @xcite , brion - procesi @xcite , dolgachev - hu @xcite , and thaddeus @xcite . under suitable stable = semistable conditions ,
the git quotient @xmath0 undergoes a sequence of weighted blow - ups and blow - downs .
the class of birational equivalences which appear via variation of git is reasonably large .
in fact , for a class of so - called _ mori dream spaces _ , any birational equivalence can be written as a composition of birational equivalences induced by variation of git @xcite .
the question of how the cohomology of the quotient depends on the polarization is studied in kalkman @xcite , which proves a wall - crossing formula for the intersection pairings under variation of symplectic quotient .
similar results , in the context of donaldson theory , are given in ellingsrud - gttsche @xcite . to state
kalkman s wall - crossing formula , recall that any lie group @xmath1 has a homotopically - trivial _ universal bundle _
@xmath6 , uniquely defined up to homotopy equivalence . if @xmath2 is a @xmath1-space with a reasonable homotopy type then the equivariant cohomology @xmath7 is the cohomology @xmath8 of @xmath9 . in this paper
we work with rational coefficients ; if @xmath1 acts with only finite stabilizers then the map @xmath10 has cohomologically trivial fibers and so @xmath11 by the serre spectral sequence .
if @xmath2 is a smooth projective @xmath1-variety as above such that @xmath1 acts locally freely on the semistable locus ( that is , with finite stabilizers ) then there is a natural map @xmath12 studied in kirwan s thesis @xcite , given by restriction to the semistable locus @xmath13 and then descent under the quotient @xmath14 . consider the simplest case @xmath15 .
let @xmath16 denote the git quotients corresponding to polarizations @xmath17 .
let @xmath18 be the kirwan maps and let @xmath19 } \alpha\ ] ] denote integration over @xmath16 .
formula expresses the difference between the integrals @xmath20 as a sum of fixed point contributions from components @xmath21 that are semistable for @xmath22 for some @xmath23 .
each such fixed point has a contribution to the localization formula for the integral of a class @xmath24 over @xmath2 given as follows .
let @xmath25 denote the normal bundle of the inclusion @xmath26 , and @xmath27 its @xmath1-equivariant euler class , or equivalently , equivariant chern class of degree equal to the real rank .
we identify @xmath28 with the polynomial ring @xmath29 $ ] in a single element @xmath30 of degree @xmath31 , representing the hyperplane class in the cohomology of @xmath32 .
if @xmath33 and @xmath34 is a decomposition into line bundles with weights @xmath35 then @xmath36 since @xmath1 acts with no non - trivial fixed vectors on @xmath37 , the euler class has an inverse @xmath38\ ] ] after inverting the equivariant parameter @xmath30 .
if one has a splitting as in then the inverted class admits an expansion @xmath39 the contribution from a fixed point component @xmath21 is the integral of the restriction @xmath40 times the inverted euler class , denoted @xmath41 , \quad \alpha \mapsto \int_{[x^{g , t } ] } \iota_{x^{g , t}}^ * \alpha \cup { { \operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_{x^{g , t}})^{-1 } .\ ] ] let @xmath42 denote the residue , that is , the coefficient of @xmath43 : @xmath44 \to { \mathbb{q } } , \quad \sum_{n \in { \mathbb{z } } } a_n \xi^n \mapsto a_{-1 } .\ ] ] [ kalk1 ] let @xmath15 and let @xmath2 be a smooth projective @xmath1-variety equipped with polarizations @xmath45 .
suppose that stable = semistable for both polarizations @xmath46 .
then @xmath47 in other words , failure of the following square to commute is measured by an explicit sum of wall - crossing terms : @xmath48 the formula also holds for certain quasi - projective varieties , such as vector spaces whose weights are contained in an open half - space , see the more general theorem [ kalk2 ] below .
( integration over projective space ) [ projspace ] the following simple example illustrates the notation involved .
let @xmath15 act on @xmath49 by scalar multiplication , so that @xmath50 $ ] .
suppose that polarizations @xmath51 correspond to the characters @xmath52 , so that the git quotients @xmath53 and @xmath54 with a unique singular value @xmath55 corresponding to the point @xmath56 .
the kirwan map @xmath57 sends the generator @xmath58 to the hyperplane class @xmath59 .
we compute the integrals @xmath60 for @xmath61 via wall - crossing . on one side ,
the integral is zero , since the quotient is empty . by the kalkman formula @xmath62 } \xi^a \cup { { \operatorname}{eul}}_g({\mathbb{c}}^k)^{-1 } \\ & = & { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \xi^a / \xi^{k } = \begin{cases } 1 & a = k- 1 \\ 0 & \text{otherwise } \end{cases } \end{aligned}\ ] ] confirming that @xmath63 is the dual of the fundamental class .
this ends the example .
the main result of this paper is a generalization of theorem [ kalk1 ] to the setting of gromov - witten theory , that is , quantum cohomology .
the formula is the same , but the kirwan map , trace , and fixed point contributions are _ quantized _ in the sense that each is replaced by a formal map depending on a formal variable @xmath64 whose restriction to @xmath65 gives the classical version above .
first we recall the definition of quantum cohomology of a smooth polarized projective @xmath1-variety @xmath2 . the _ equivariant novikov field _
@xmath66 associated to a @xmath67-variety @xmath2 with polarization @xmath68 consists of linear combinations of formal symbols @xmath69 for @xmath70 : @xmath71 we write @xmath72 if we wish to emphasize the dependence on @xmath73 .
the _ equivariant quantum cohomology _ is the tensor product @xmath74 or @xmath75 if we wish to emphasize the dependence on @xmath73 .
a more standard definition in algebraic geometry would use the cone of effective curve classes , but the definition give here has better invariance properties , for example , under hamiltonian perturbation .
below we will need several variations on this definition .
let @xmath76 denote the space of finite linear combinations of the symbols @xmath69 .
we denote by @xmath77 the subspace @xmath78 .
let @xmath79 be the space consisting of expressions involving only powers @xmath69 with @xmath80 .
we denote by @xmath81 the subspace @xmath82 . the quantum cohomology @xmath83 has the structure of a frobenius manifold , in particular , a family of products @xmath84 defined by equivariant virtual enumeration of genus zero _ stable maps _ , that is , maps @xmath85 from projective nodal curves @xmath86 of arithmetic genus zero to @xmath2 with no infinitesimal automorphisms .
the moduli stack @xmath87 of such maps of homology class @xmath88 and arithmetic genus @xmath89 is a proper deligne - mumford stack equipped with a perfect relative obstruction theory and evaluation map @xmath90 the action of @xmath1 on @xmath2 induces an action of @xmath1 on @xmath87 by translation ; then the evaluation maps induce a map @xmath91 the quantum product at @xmath92 is defined by restricting to @xmath93 and defining for @xmath94 @xmath95 where the push - forwards are defined using the behrend - fantechi virtual fundamental classes @xmath96_g$ ] , and the definition is extended to @xmath97 by linearity over @xmath98 , see @xcite .
note that we take the virtual fundamental classes to lie in the homology @xmath99 of the coarse moduli space , rather than in the chow ring as in @xcite .
the quantum cohomology @xmath83 can also be defined using the smaller ring @xmath100 but not @xmath101 , because of the infinite sum .
the orbifold quantum cohomology @xmath102 of the quotient @xmath0 is defined by virtual enumeration of stable maps from orbifold curves , as follows . for
any element @xmath103 let @xmath104 be the centralizer of @xmath103 , @xmath105 $ ] its conjugacy class , and @xmath106 the subgroup generated by @xmath89 .
we denote by @xmath107 the _ rigidified inertia stack _ from abramovich - graber - vistoli @xcite , given by @xmath108 } x^{g,{{\operatorname}{ss } } } / ( z_g/ { \langle}g { \rangle}).\ ] ] denote by @xmath109 the quantum cohomology of the git quotient @xmath0 defined using the same novikov field @xmath98 ; this larger ring contains @xmath110 by virtue of kirwan s injection @xmath111 .
virtual enumeration of representable morphisms from orbifold curves satisfying certain conditions to @xmath0 defines a family of products @xmath112 a quantum version of the kirwan map @xmath113 ( we keep the same notation as in the classical case ) was constructed in @xcite .
the map @xmath114 is a formal , non - linear map with the property that each linearization @xmath115 is a @xmath116-homomorphism , defined by virtual enumeration of _ affine gauged maps_. such a map is by definition a representable morphism @xmath117 from a weighted projective line @xmath118 to the quotient stack @xmath119 mapping the stacky point at infinity @xmath120 to the semistable locus @xmath121 .
( more precisely , the domain is a smooth deligne - mumford stack of dimension one with a single stacky point with automorphism group of order @xmath122 . )
these are the algebro - geometric analogs of the _ vortex bubbles _ considered in gaio - salamon @xcite .
the compactified moduli stack @xmath123 of affine gauged maps of homology class @xmath70 is , if stable = semistable for @xmath2 , a proper smooth deligne - mumford stack with a perfect relative obstruction theory over the complexification of stasheff s multiplihedron , and evaluation maps @xmath124 the quantum kirwan map is defined for @xmath125 by @xmath126 it is defined over the smaller equivariant novikov ring @xmath100 , but one obtains good surjectivity properties only using the novikov field @xmath98 , see @xcite .
the map @xmath114 is a quantization of kirwan s in the sense that @xmath127 is the map studied in @xcite .
a quantization of the classical integration map over @xmath0 is given by the _ graph potential _ in givental @xcite @xmath128 defined by virtual enumeration of genus zero orbifold stable maps to @xmath129 of homology class @xmath130 for some @xmath131 .
let @xmath132 denote the stack of such maps of class @xmath133 , which we view as an element of @xmath134 via the inclusion of the semistable locus .
the graph potential is defined for @xmath135 by @xmath136 } { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * ( \alpha , \ldots , \alpha ) .\ ] ] again @xmath137 is defined over the equivariant novikov ring @xmath138 .
the graph potential @xmath137 is related via the quantum kirwan map to a _ gauged gromov - witten potential _
@xmath139 defined by virtual enumeration of _ gauged maps _ , by which we mean morphisms from @xmath86 to the quotient stack @xmath119 , satisfying a mundet stability condition @xcite generalizing semistability for vector bundles on curves : ( mundet semistability ) [ mundetsemistable ] a _ gauged map _ from a smooth projective curve @xmath86 to the quotient stack @xmath119 is a morphism @xmath140 , consisting of a pair @xmath141 , see @xcite .
we suppose that @xmath142 is the complexification of @xmath143 , and @xmath143 is equipped with an inner product invariant under the action of @xmath144 , inducing an identification @xmath145 . 1 .
( associated graded morphism ) given a reduction of @xmath146 to a parabolic subgroup @xmath147 given by a section @xmath148 and an antidominant , central element @xmath149 in the lie algebra @xmath150 of @xmath151 , there is an _ associated graded _ morphism given by a bundle @xmath152 whose structure group reduces to the levi subgroup of @xmath146 and stable section @xmath153 with domain a nodal curve @xmath154 .
the bundle @xmath155 is the limit of the bundles @xmath156 associated to the homomorphisms @xmath157 for @xmath158 , while the section @xmath159 is the gromov limit of the family of sections @xmath160 of @xmath161 induced by @xmath149 .
( hilbert - mumford weight ) the principal component @xmath162 of @xmath154 is the irreducible component such that the restriction @xmath163 of @xmath164 to @xmath162 maps isomorphically to @xmath86 .
the principal component @xmath165 of the associated graded section @xmath159 takes values in the fixed point set of the automorphism induced by @xmath149 .
the _ hilbert - mumford weight @xmath166 _ determined by the polarization @xmath73 , is the usual hilbert - mumford weight , that is , the weight of the @xmath167-action on @xmath73 over a generic value of @xmath165 .
3 . ( ramanathan weight ) assume that @xmath168 is a weight of @xmath151 .
the ramanathan weight of @xmath169 of @xmath170 with respect to @xmath171 is given by the first chern number of the line bundle determined by @xmath149 via the associated bundle construction : if @xmath172 is the one - dimensional representation of @xmath151 with weight @xmath149 then the line bundle is @xmath173 and the _ ramanathan weight _ is @xmath174 } c_1 ( \sigma^*p \times_r { \mathbb{c}}_\lambda ) .\ ] ] 4 .
( mundet weight ) the _ mundet weight _ is the sum of the hilbert - mumford and ramanathan weights : @xmath175 5 .
( mundet semistability ) the morphism @xmath170 is _ mundet semistable _
if @xmath176 for all such pairs @xmath171 @xcite , and _ mundet stable _ if the above inequalities are satisfied strictly . more generally , a _ nodal @xmath177-marked gauged map _ consists of an @xmath177-marked nodal projective curve @xmath178 and a morphism @xmath179 of class @xmath180 , consisting of a principal component @xmath181 which maps under @xmath164 and projection to the first factor isomorphically to @xmath86 , and a collection of _ bubble components _ @xmath182 .
the datum @xmath183 is _ mundet semistable _ if the restriction @xmath184 is mundet semistable , and each bubble component @xmath185 on which @xmath164 is given by a trivial @xmath1-bundle with constant section has at least three special ( marked or nodal ) points .
let @xmath186 denote the stack of mundet semistable @xmath177-marked gauged maps .
taking @xmath2 and @xmath1 to be points , and @xmath187 to be trivial , one obtains the _ fulton - macpherson space _ associated to @xmath86 , that is , the moduli space @xmath188)\ ] ] of stable maps to @xmath86 of class @xmath189 \in h_2(c,{\mathbb{z}})$ ] .
we denote by @xmath190 the stack of pre - stable maps of class @xmath189 $ ] , that is , without the stability condition .
the category of mundet - semistable gauged maps from @xmath86 to @xmath119 of homology class @xmath187 and @xmath177 markings forms an artin stack @xmath186 @xcite , which if stable = semistable is a proper smooth deligne - mumford stack with perfect relative obstruction theory over @xmath190 , evaluation map @xmath191 and forgetful morphism @xmath192 . [ toric ] ( toric case ) suppose that @xmath1 is a torus acting on a vector space @xmath2 with weight decomposition @xmath193 so that @xmath1 acts on the one - dimensional representation @xmath194 with weights @xmath195 .
suppose that @xmath2 is equipped with a polarization given by a trivial line bundle with character @xmath196 .
let @xmath86 be a curve of genus @xmath197 .
then @xmath198 where the polarization on @xmath199 is the trivial line bundle with character @xmath200 , see @xcite . for example , if @xmath15 acts on @xmath49 by scalar multiplication then @xmath201 for @xmath202 and positive character @xmath200 .
( gauged gromov - witten potential ) suppose that stable = semistable for all gauged maps .
the gauged potential @xmath203 is the formal map defined by @xmath204 } { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * ( \alpha,\ldots , \alpha ) \ ] ] for @xmath24 , and extended to @xmath83 by linearity . ( graph potential and gauged potential as quantizations of integration ) both @xmath137 and @xmath203 are quantizations of integration over the quotient in the following sense : given @xmath205 and a fulton - macpherson class @xmath206 , consider the integral @xmath207 } { { \operatorname}{ev}}_n^ * \alpha \cup f^ * \beta .\ ] ] if @xmath208 is the point class then @xmath209 } \alpha .\ ] ] indeed any map from the curve @xmath86 to @xmath0 of homology class @xmath197 is constant .
it follows that @xmath210 in particular , for @xmath211 we obtain @xmath212 which implies the claim .
a similar discussion holds for @xmath203 , that is , @xmath209 } ( d_0 \kappa_x^g |_{q = 0 } ) \alpha .\ ] ] the reader who is confused by the appearance of the fulton - macpherson class should keep in mind that a similar phenomenon appears in the fukaya category setting : ( co)units are defined by integrals over the moduli space of holomorphic disks with a single marking where the _ position of the marking is fixed_. this ends the remark . the gauged potential and the graph potential of the quotient
are related by the _
adiabatic limit theorem _ of @xcite ( which is a generalization of an earlier result of gaio - salamon @xcite ) : let @xmath213 be a real _ stability parameter _ ; we consider mundet stability with respect to the polarization @xmath214 with @xmath215 .
[ adiabatic limit theorem ] [ largerel ] if @xmath0 is a locally free quotient then stable = semistable for @xmath213 sufficiently large ( more precisely , for any class @xmath216 there exists an @xmath217 such that @xmath218 implies stable = semistable ) and @xmath219 in other words , the diagram @xmath220{e , t}{{\kappa}_x^g } \node { } \node{qh ( x { /\kern-.7ex/}g ) } \arrow{sw , b}{\tau_{x { /\kern-.7ex/}g } } \\
\node { } \node{\lambda_x^g } \node { } \end{diagram}\ ] ] commutes in the limit @xmath215 .
there is more general version of the adiabatic limit theorem for _ euler class twistings _ : the universal curve @xmath221 admits a universal gauged map @xmath222 for any @xmath1-equivariant bundle @xmath223 we denote by @xmath224 the index of the bundle @xmath225 ; this is an object in the bounded derived category of @xmath226 , since @xmath227 is proper .
the euler class @xmath228 is well - defined after passing to the equivariant cohomology of @xmath226 for the trivial @xmath167-action corresponding to scalar multiplication on the fibers and inverting the equivariant parameter . in order to study the dependence of the graph gromov - witten potential of the quotient on the choice of polarization , suppose that @xmath229 are two polarizations of @xmath2 and @xmath230 is the family of rational polarizations given by interpolation .
let @xmath16 denote the git quotients , @xmath231 the _ quantum _ kirwan maps ( note that we do not introduce new notation for the quantum version ; the classical kirwan map is obtained by setting @xmath65 ) and @xmath232 the graph potentials . the main result of this note is a formula for the difference @xmath233 as a sum of fixed point contributions given by gauged gromov - witten invariants with smaller structure group .
namely , for any @xmath234 such that @xmath235 is non - empty , there exists a stack @xmath236 of _
@xmath1-fixed @xmath177-marked gauged maps _ from @xmath86 to @xmath119 consisting of a principal component mapping to @xmath237 and bubbles mapping to @xmath119 .
we denote by @xmath238 the moving part of the normal complex @xmath239 defined in , with euler class @xmath240 .\ ] ] the mundet stability condition in general depends on a choice of equivariant khler class ; here we are interested in the _ large area limit _ in which the gauged gromov - witten invariants are related to the git quotient .
we denote by @xmath241 the space of @xmath242-valued functions on @xmath243 .
note that @xmath244 has no ring structure extending that on @xmath98 .
the space @xmath244 can be viewed as the space of distributions in the quantum parameter @xmath64 .
[ fixed point potential ] let @xmath245 be as above , and @xmath23 such that @xmath235 is non - empty .
the _ fixed point potential _ associated to this data is the map @xmath246 \\ \quad
\alpha \mapsto \sum_{d \in h_2^g(x,{\mathbb{z } } ) } \sum_{n \ge 0 } \int_{[{\overline}{{\mathcal{m}}}_n^{g}(c , x , l_t , d)^g ] } ( q^d / n ! ) { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * ( \alpha , \ldots , \alpha ) \cup { \epsilon}_+(t(x / g))^{-1}\end{gathered}\ ] ] for @xmath24 , extended to @xmath247 by linearity .
we may now state the main result of the paper , in the case of circle actions .
[ quantum kalkman formula , circle group case ] [ qkalkcirc ] suppose that @xmath15 and @xmath2 is a smooth projective @xmath1-variety equipped with polarizations @xmath45 , and stable = semistable for @xmath51 .
then @xmath248 in other words , failure of the following square to commute is measured by an explicit sum of wall - crossing terms given by certain gauged gromov - witten invariants : @xmath249 the diagram is somewhat more complicated than in the classical case in , because the maps @xmath250 are defined using different the novikov rings @xmath251 .
if a symbol @xmath69 appears in one novikov ring @xmath252 but not the other then the corresponding contribution to @xmath253 must be equal to the @xmath69-term in the wall - crossing contribution on the right .
see example [ threepoint ] . the wall - crossing formula for gromov - witten invariants theorem [ qkalkcirc ] should be considered mirror to various results in on the behavior of the derived category of bounded complexes of coherent sheaves under variation of git quotient appearing recently in segal @xcite , halpern - leistner @xcite and ballard - favero - katzarkov @xcite , and more generally for crepant birational transformations , earlier in @xcite .
more precisely , one would hope that these results have extensions to open - closed gromov - witten theory , in particular , semi - orthogonal decompositions of fukaya categories similar to those for the derived categories of matrix factorizations in the works above .
we have stated the formula in its simplest form ; there are various extensions which include : 1 .
( insertions from fulton - macpherson spaces ) the moduli stacks @xmath226 resp . @xmath254
admit _ forgetful morphisms _
@xmath255 to the moduli stack @xmath256 of homology class @xmath189 $ ] stable maps to @xmath86 . for any class @xmath257 ,
one may insert @xmath258 in the integral defining the potentials as in .
the wall - crossing formula then holds in the sense of _ homotopy compositions of traces and morphisms of cohft algebras _ discussed in @xcite .
in fact , without the fulton - macpherson insertions the potentials @xmath259 will often vanish , unless one interprets them equivariantly in the case of a curve @xmath86 of genus zero with a circle action , in which case they are closely related to givental s _ @xmath260 and @xmath261 functions _
( fixed point potential as a quantization of kalkman s ) the fixed point potential @xmath262 quantizes the fixed point contributions in kalkman s formula , in the following sense : let @xmath86 be a genus zero curve and consider the @xmath177-th taylor coefficient derivative @xmath263 .
consider the integral with insertion of the fulton - macpherson class @xmath264 given by @xmath265 } { { \operatorname}{ev}}_n^ * \alpha \cup f^ * \beta \cup { \epsilon}_+(t(x / g))^{-1}.\ ] ] if @xmath266 is the point class then @xmath267 } \alpha \cup { { \operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_{x^{g , t}})^{-1}\ ] ] which appears in kalkman s wall - crossing formula .
indeed any map from the genus zero curve @xmath86 to @xmath119 of homology class @xmath197 consists of a trivial bundle and constant section .
it follows that @xmath268 in particular , for @xmath211 we obtain @xmath269 which implies the claim .
furthermore , the euler class @xmath270 is the euler class of the normal bundle to @xmath235 .
( twistings by euler classes ) one can introduce _ twisted gromov - witten invariants _ as follows . for any equivariant bundle @xmath271 on @xmath2 , inserting the euler class @xmath272 of gives twisted gauged gromov - witten invariants . introducing similar twistings in the definition of @xmath114 ,
the wall - crossing formula extends to this case as well .
4 . ( wall - crossing for individual gromov - witten invariants )
although we have written the formula as a difference of potentials , after unraveling the definitions one obtains wall - crossing formulas for individual gromov - witten invariants , or at least finite combinations of them . in fano cases , one can often obtain wall - crossing formulas for individual gromov - witten invariants .
( wall - crossing for non - convex actions ) in same cases , even though the action of @xmath1 on @xmath2 is not convex at infinity ( e.g. @xmath1 is a torus acting on a vector space @xmath2 with weights not contained in any half - space ) the moduli spaces @xmath226 are non - compact , but the moduli spaces admit an auxiliary group action with proper fixed point loci , and the maps @xmath273 etc .
can be defined via localization .
the wall - crossing formula holds in this case as well , as long as the auxiliary group action extends to the various master spaces involved and the fixed point loci on these master spaces is proper ( after fixing the homology class of the gauged map . ) see example [ simpleflop ] below .
( three - point gromov - witten invariants of projective space ) [ threepoint ] the following simple example illustrates the notation involved in theorem [ qkalkcirc ] . as in example
[ projspace ] , let @xmath274 acting on @xmath49 by scalar multiplication , so that @xmath50 $ ] .
suppose that polarizations @xmath51 correspond to the characters @xmath52 , quotients @xmath275 and @xmath276 , and a unique singular value @xmath277 corresponding to the point @xmath56 .
let @xmath278 denote the hyperplane class . for integers
@xmath279 we compute genus @xmath197 @xmath280 @xmath281 invariants @xmath282 of @xmath283 via wall - crossing ; this was already covered in cieliebak - salamon @xcite . since @xmath284 ,
the minimal chern number of @xmath2 is @xmath285 . for dimensional reasons , there are no quantum corrections in @xmath286 and so @xmath287 the adiabatic limit theorem [ largerel ] with fulton - macpherson insertions implies that the genus zero , three - point invariants @xmath288 of class @xmath289 in the quotient @xmath0 equal gauged gromov - witten invariants : @xmath290 } { { \operatorname}{ev}}_1^ * \xi^a \cup { { \operatorname}{ev}}_2^ * \xi^b \cup { { \operatorname}{ev}}_3^ * \xi^c \cup f^ * \beta\ ] ] where @xmath291 is the projective line and @xmath292 is the point class , that is , the class fixing the location of the three marked points .
consider the wall - crossing formula theorem [ qkalkcirc ] , applied to the third order derivatives of the potential in the directions @xmath293 with the fulton - macpherson insertion described above .
there are no holomorphic spheres in @xmath2 , so the moduli stack @xmath294 is a point , consisting of the bundle @xmath146 with first chern class @xmath295 with constant section equal to zero .
thus the fixed point stack is @xmath296 the index bundle of @xmath297 at the fixed point is @xmath298 it has euler class @xmath299 by the wall - crossing formula [ qkalkcirc ] @xmath300 } \frac { { { \operatorname}{ev}}_1^ * \xi^a \cup { { \operatorname}{ev}}_2^ * \xi^b \cup { { \operatorname}{ev}}_3^ * \xi^c \cup f^ * \beta}{{\epsilon}_+(t(x / g ) ) } \\ & = & { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \xi^{a + b + c } / \xi^{2k } \\ & = & \begin{cases } 1 & a + b + c = 2k- 1 \\ 0 & \text{otherwise } .\end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus @xmath301 as is well - known .
for example , taking @xmath302 we obtain that there is a unique line in projective space passing through two generic points and a generic hyperplane .
we give another fano example in example [ c1 ] , where we compute the change in a coefficient in the fifth quantum power of the first chern class for a blow - up of the projective plane .
this ends the example .
the most interesting case of the wall - crossing formula theorem [ qkalkcirc ] is the _ crepant case _ by which we mean that the sum of the weights at any fixed point vanishes ( definition [ crepant ] ) ; the term _ crepant _ was introduced by reid @xcite as the opposite of discrepant in the context of the minimal model program . in the last section
we give a proof of a version of the crepant transformation conjecture of li - ruan @xcite , bryan - graber @xcite , coates - corti - iritani - tseng @xcite , coates - ruan @xcite on equivalence of gromov - witten theories in this case : [ wall - crossing for crepant birational transformations of git type ] [ cytype ] suppose that @xmath303 are as in theorem [ qkalkcirc ] , and @xmath86 has genus zero . if all the wall - crossings are crepant then @xmath304 almost everywhere ( a.e . ) in the quantum parameter @xmath64 . 1 .
theorem [ cytype ] implies many of the special cases already known in the literature , although actually computing the transformations @xmath305 relating the graph potentials @xmath306 can be a difficult task .
note that iwao - lee - lin - wang @xcite , lee - lin - wang @xcite extend the invariance to cases not necessarily related by variation of git , while the results here are more general than that of @xcite , @xcite since we allow `` weighted flops '' .
2 . almost everywhere equality in the formal parameter @xmath64 means the following : considering both sides as elements in @xmath307 , the space of distributions on @xmath308 , the difference is a tempered distribution in at least one direction and its fourier transform in that direction has support of measure zero , see section [ cy ] .
the proof of theorem [ cytype ] uses an action of the picard stack of the curve on the fixed point stacks . in the crepant case
the ( almost ) invariance under this action implies that , after summing over degrees , the wall - crossing term is a sum of derivatives of delta - functions in the quantum parameter @xmath64 .
[ simpleflop ] ( simple three - fold flop , cf .
li - ruan @xcite , iwao - lee - lin - wang @xcite , lee - lin - wang @xcite ) the following simple example may help to explain the notion of `` almost everywhere vanishing '' of the wall - crossing contributions in the quantum parameter .
let @xmath309 acting on @xmath310 with weights @xmath52 each of multiplicity @xmath31 .
then @xmath311 where @xmath291 is the projective line and we abuse notation by denoting by @xmath312 the total space of two copies of the tautological line bundle @xmath313 . then @xmath314 and @xmath315 are isomorphic but the birational transformation relating them , induced by the variation of git quotient , is a simple flop .
we consider the wall - crossing formula corresponding to the three - point invariants with each insertion given by @xmath316 ; that is , the third derivative of @xmath306 with a fulton - macpherson class @xmath258 fixing the positions of the three marked points . in order to make sense of the non - compact integration in the @xmath317 case one
must take an equivariant extension of with respect to the action of @xmath167 acting by scalar multiplication , and use localization for the residual @xmath167-action . thus if @xmath318 is the equivariant parameter for the auxiliary @xmath167 then @xmath319 where @xmath320 is the symplectic class integrating to @xmath321 on the zero - section @xmath322 .
the fixed point set of the residual @xmath167 action is the zero section of @xmath323 , which acts with weights @xmath324 ( with multiplicity two ) on the normal bundle .
the degree zero moduli space is @xmath16 itself , and integration over this non - compact space can be defined via localization as @xmath325 the auxiliary circle action extends to the various master spaces involved , and the wall - crossing formula holds in this case as well , defining each contribution via localization .
there is a unique fixed point @xmath56 , with normal bundle isomorphic to @xmath2 .
thus the wall - crossing term is @xmath326 thus kalkman s wall - crossing formula reduces to @xmath327 moving on to non - zero classes @xmath328 , there is a unique gauged map of class @xmath187 mapping to the fixed point @xmath56 , with normal complex having weight @xmath321 with multiplicity @xmath329 and weight @xmath330 with multiplicity @xmath331 , by riemann - roch .
thus the wall - crossing term class @xmath187 is @xmath332 the class @xmath187 occurs in the expression @xmath333 iff @xmath334 resp
. @xmath335 . indeed , the contribution of @xmath69 is the contribution of @xmath69 to the gauged gromov - witten potential in theorem [ largerel ] , which by definition is an integral over mundet stable maps which in this case is the git quotient of @xmath336 by the @xmath167 action corresponding to the polarization @xmath51 , where @xmath337 denote the one - dimensional representations with weight @xmath52 . for @xmath338 ,
only one factor @xmath339 is non - vanishing and the git quotient is empty for the polarization @xmath340 corresponding to the character @xmath341 . since each @xmath342 appears in only one of the novikov rings @xmath343 we must have , after composing with the quantum kirwan map , that the higher degree integrals for @xmath344 are @xmath321 for @xmath345 and @xmath197 for @xmath346 resp . for @xmath347 are @xmath348 for @xmath349 and @xmath197 for @xmath345 , each corresponding to an integral over multiple covers of the zero section .
summing over classes @xmath187 the wall - crossing formula in theorem [ qkalkcirc ] becomes @xmath350 the reader may compare with the treatment of simple flops in @xcite , ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 3.2 ) which contains essentially the same computation .
note that here we have not given an explicit description of the maps @xmath305 which relate the two graph potentials .
this ends the example .
in this section we give a proof of kalkman s formula [ kalk1 ] and give a generalization to non - abelian quotients .
the wall - crossing formula is somewhat simpler for the case of a circle group , so we begin with that case .
let @xmath15 and @xmath2 a smooth projective @xmath1-variety as above , equipped with polarizations @xmath45 .
the proof of the wall - crossing formula is by localization on a proper deligne - mumford stack @xmath351 whose fixed points include @xmath16 and the fixed point components @xmath235 with @xmath23 . from the point of view of symplectic geometry
, this is the _ symplectic cut _ construction in lerman @xcite , but we need the algebraic approach here given in thaddeus ( * ? ? ?
* section 3 ) .
first recall from the introduction that @xmath352 denotes the family of rational polarizations interpolating between @xmath51 .
we denote by @xmath353 the corresponding git quotients , by which we mean the stack - theoretic quotient of the semistable locus for @xmath354 by the action of @xmath1 .
this means that if @xmath355 are moment maps for action of a maximal compact of @xmath1 on @xmath51 with respect to a unitary connection then @xmath356 is a moment map for the action of @xmath1 on @xmath354 . even more concretely ,
if @xmath355 are equal up to a constant @xmath357 then @xmath358 are all equal up to a constant depending on @xmath359 . for the following see thaddeus ( * ? ? ?
* section 3 ) .
[ existence of a master space ] [ master ] suppose that stable = semistable for @xmath51 and for any @xmath23 and any @xmath359-semistable point @xmath360 , @xmath361 acts with finite stabilizer on the fiber @xmath362 .
then there exists a smooth proper deligne - mumford @xmath1-stack @xmath351 equipped with a line bundle ample for the coarse moduli space whose git quotients @xmath363 are isomorphic to those @xmath364 of @xmath2 by the action of @xmath1 with respect to the polarization @xmath354 and whose fixed point set @xmath365 is given by the union @xmath366 where @xmath235 is the component of @xmath367 that is semistable for parameter @xmath359 .
the projectivization @xmath368 of the direct sum @xmath369 of the polarizations @xmath45 has a natural polarization given by the relative hyperplane bundle @xmath370 of the fibers , with stalks @xmath371 } = { \operatorname}{span}(l_- + l_+)^{\vee}.\ ] ] let @xmath372 denote the projection .
( a word of warning : the notation @xmath373 will be used for a number of different projections in this paper . ) the space of sections of @xmath374 has a decomposition under the natural @xmath167-action with eigenspaces given by the sections of @xmath375 with @xmath376 .
it follows that the semistable locus in @xmath377 is the union of @xmath378 where @xmath379 is the semistable locus for @xmath380 $ ] .
let @xmath381 denote the geometric invariant theory quotient , by which we mean the stack - theoretic quotient of the semistable locus .
the assumption on the action of the stabilizers implies that the action of @xmath1 on the semistable locus in @xmath368 is locally free , so that stable = semistable for @xmath368 .
it follows that @xmath351 is a proper smooth deligne - mumford stack .
the quotient @xmath351 contains the quotients of @xmath382 with respect to the polarizations @xmath51 , that is , @xmath16 .
the @xmath1-action with weights @xmath52 on @xmath383 induces a @xmath1-action on @xmath351 with fixed point set as described above .
indeed , the fixed points are pairs @xmath384 $ ] such that either @xmath385 , or @xmath386 are both non - zero but the projection to @xmath2 is @xmath1-fixed . [ cond ]
( condition for stable = semistable ) the proof shows that the @xmath1-action on @xmath377 has stable = semistable iff the condition of the lemma holds , that is , stable = semistable for @xmath51 and for any @xmath23 and @xmath359-semistable point @xmath360 , @xmath361 acts with finite stabilizer on the fiber @xmath362 .
indeed , this is the condition for @xmath1 to act locally freely on the semistable locus in @xmath377 . the projection @xmath387 induces a @xmath1-invariant map @xmath388 .
composing with the kirwan map one obtains a canonical map @xmath389 .
its composition with @xmath390 is equal to @xmath391 .
taking the residue of the localization formula for the @xmath1-action on @xmath351 gives theorem [ kalk1 ] , see lerman @xcite .
indeed for any equivariant class @xmath24 of top degree , its pullback to @xmath377 descends to a class @xmath392 whose restriction to @xmath323 is @xmath393 , and whose restriction to @xmath394 is @xmath395 . since @xmath396 the integral of @xmath397 over @xmath351 vanishes . on the other hand , by localization the integral is @xmath398 } \alpha = \int_{[x { /\kern-.7ex/}_- g ] } \frac{\kappa_{x,-}^g(\alpha)}{{{\operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_- ) } + \int_{[x { /\kern-.7ex/}_+ g ] } \frac{\kappa_{x,+}^g(\alpha)}{{{\operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_+ ) } + \sum_{t \in ( -1,1 ) } \int_{[x^{g , t } ] } \frac{\iota^*_{x^{g , t } } \alpha}{{{\operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_{x^{g , t}})}\ ] ] where @xmath399 are the normal bundles to @xmath400 in @xmath351 .
the inverted euler classes are @xmath401 hence taking residues one obtains @xmath402 } \frac{\iota^*_{x^{g , t } } \alpha } { { { \operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_{x^{g , t}})}\ ] ] as claimed .
kalkman s wall - crossing formula can be used to study the intersection pairings for variation of git for the action of an arbitrary connected complex reductive group @xmath1 on a smooth polarized projective variety @xmath2 as follows .
let us examine the structure of the fixed point set of @xmath167 on @xmath351 .
for any @xmath403 , we denote by @xmath404 the stabilizer of @xmath405 under the adjoint action of @xmath1 .
let @xmath406 be a maximal torus and @xmath407 the corresponding cartan algebra .
let @xmath408 denote the weyl group .
for any @xmath409 , we denote by @xmath410 resp . @xmath411 the group of @xmath412 that fix the element @xmath403 resp .
line @xmath413 .
thus the quotient @xmath414 is either isomorphic to @xmath415 or to @xmath416 , depending on whether or not there is a weyl group element acting as @xmath330 on @xmath417 .
[ fplem ] suppose that stable = semistable for the @xmath1-action on @xmath418 , so that @xmath351 is a smooth proper deligne - mumford stack with @xmath167 action , constructed in the proof of lemma [ master ] .
. any fixed point @xmath419 with @xmath420 $ ] for some @xmath421 has the property that for all @xmath158 , @xmath422 for some unique @xmath423 .
2 . for each @xmath409
there is a morphism @xmath424 with fiber @xmath425 .
the images of @xmath426 cover @xmath427 , disjointly after passing to equivalence classes of one - parameter subgroups .
3 . for any @xmath24
, the pull - back of @xmath428 under @xmath426 is equal to image of @xmath429 under the restriction map @xmath430 4 .
the pull - back of the normal bundle @xmath431 of @xmath427 under @xmath426 is canonically isomorphic to the image of @xmath432 under the quotient map @xmath433 , by an isomorphism that intertwines the action of @xmath434 on @xmath435 with the action of @xmath167 on @xmath431 . if @xmath436 \in { \tilde}{x}^{{\mathbb{c}}^\times}$ ] , with @xmath421 then @xmath436 \in { \tilde}{x}^\xi$ ] , where @xmath30 is a generator of the lie algebra of @xmath167 and @xmath437 is the zero set of the vector field @xmath438 generated by @xmath30 . since @xmath351 is the quotient of @xmath377 by @xmath1 , if @xmath439 denotes the vector field on @xmath377 generated by @xmath30 then @xmath440 for some @xmath403 .
since @xmath1 acts locally freely @xmath405 must be unique .
integrating gives @xmath441 for all @xmath442 . by uniqueness of @xmath405 ,
this holds for every point in the component of @xmath437 containing @xmath436 $ ] .
the fiber of the morphism @xmath443 is the set of @xmath444 fixing both @xmath445 and @xmath446 under the adjoint action .
the set of @xmath447 fixing @xmath445 is @xmath448 , while the set of @xmath444 fixing @xmath434 and @xmath445 is isomorphic to @xmath425 .
hence the fiber is @xmath425 .
the remaining claims are left to the reader .
the group @xmath449 acts trivially on @xmath450 , which is therefore a @xmath451-space .
this is the `` smaller structure group '' referred to in the abstract . for any fixed point component @xmath452 that is @xmath359-semistable , we denote by @xmath453 the normal bundle of @xmath454 modulo @xmath455 , quotiented by @xmath451
let @xmath456 , \quad \alpha \mapsto \int_{[x^{\zeta , t } { /\kern-.7ex/}(g_\zeta/{\mathbb{c}}^\times_\zeta ) ] } \alpha \cup { { \operatorname}{eul}}_{{\mathbb{c}}^\times_\zeta}(\nu_{x^{\zeta , t}})^{-1}\ ] ] where we have omitted the map @xmath457 to simplify notation , and @xmath30 is the equivariant parameter for @xmath434 .
[ kalkman wall - crossing ] [ kalk2 ] let @xmath2 be a smooth projective @xmath1-variety and @xmath45 polarizations with stable = semistable for the @xmath1 action on @xmath377 .
then @xmath458 } \frac{|w_\zeta|}{|w_{{\mathbb{c}}\zeta}| } { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \tau_{x,\zeta , t}^{g_\zeta}\ ] ] where the sum over @xmath459 $ ] represents a sum over one - parameter subgroups of @xmath1 , up to conjugacy . [ classexamples ] 1
. [ blowupp2 ] [ eight ] ( blow - up of the projective plane as a quotient of a product of projective lines by a circle action ) let @xmath460 with polarization @xmath461 with @xmath462 .
let @xmath463 .
since @xmath297 is the same as @xmath464 plus a trivial line bundle , we have @xmath465 furthermore , since all weights are @xmath321 , we have @xmath466 .
consider the wall - crossing from the chamber @xmath467 to the first non - empty chamber @xmath468 .
there is a unique fixed point with weights @xmath469 on the normal bundle ; hence @xmath470 indeed , @xmath471 is three times the generator of @xmath472 , so @xmath473 } c_1({\mathbb{p}}^2)^2 = 9 .\ ] ] consider next the wall - crossing from the chamber with quotient @xmath474 to the chamber with quotient @xmath475 , where @xmath476 is the blow - up of @xmath477 at a point . letting @xmath478 denote the blow - down map we have @xmath479 where @xmath480 are the hyperplane class and class of the exceptional divisor respectively .
hence @xmath481 to compare this result with the wall - crossing formula , note that the fixed point set @xmath235 consists of a unique point @xmath482,[1,0],[1,0])$ ] which is semistable exactly for @xmath483 , with tangent weights @xmath484 .
it follows that the first chern class squared and euler classes are @xmath485 hence the wall - crossing term is @xmath486 } \iota_{x^{g , t}}^ * \alpha \cup { { \operatorname}{eul}}_g(\nu_{x^{g , t}})^{-1 } \right ) = { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \frac{\xi^2}{-\xi^3 } = -1 .\ ] ] the wall - crossing formula reduces to @xmath487 in fact each blow - up of @xmath477 lowers @xmath488 by @xmath321 , leading to the 9 del pezzo surfaces , each of which contains a simple simply - laced root system corresponding to classes of self - intersection @xmath489 etc . @xcite .
2 . ( blow - up of the projective plane as a quotient of affine four - space by a two - torus )
let us do the same example in a different way , namely as a quotient of an affine space .
@xmath310 with @xmath490 acting with weights @xmath491 .
consider the path of polarizations in @xmath492 from @xmath493 to @xmath494 so that @xmath495 is isomorphic to @xmath477 via the map @xmath496 = [ ( a , b , cd^{-1},1 ) ] \mapsto [ a , b , cd^{-1 } ] .\ ] ] on the other hand @xmath314 is isomorphic to the blow - up of @xmath477 with the map to @xmath477 blowing down the exceptional divisor given by @xmath497 \mapsto [ a , b , cd^{-1 } ] .\ ] ] as one moves in a line from say @xmath498 to @xmath499 the symplectic quotients are in order @xmath500 where the initial and final contractions are projective bundles over the fixed point sets @xmath501 resp . @xmath291 for the residual action of @xmath167 on the quotient of @xmath2 by the diagonal action .
see figure [ twochamber ] , where the two chambers for the possible quotients are shown together with the moment polytopes of the quotients in each chamber .
+ action on @xmath502,height=192 ] + consider first the wall - crossing from the empty chamber to the non - empty chamber with quotient @xmath477 in figure [ twochamber ] .
we have @xmath503 .
hence the wall - crossing term is @xmath504 } c_1({\mathbb{p}}^2)^2 = 9 $ ] as expected .
+ the wall - crossing term for passing from the chamber with quotient @xmath477 to that with quotient @xmath476 is @xmath505 this implies that @xmath506 } c_1({\mathbb{p}}^2)^2 = 8 $ ] as we already computed in item above .
+ passing from the chamber with quotient @xmath476 to the adjacent chamber with empty quotient , note that the symplectic quotient at the wall - crossing point @xmath507 equal to @xmath291 and a wall - crossing term of @xmath508 } \kappa_{x}^{{\mathbb{c}}^\times } \frac { ( 3\xi_1 + 2\xi_2)^2 } { \xi_2 ( \xi_1 + \xi_2)}\ ] ] where @xmath509 is the kirwan map for the quotient by the first factor of @xmath167 , so that @xmath510 has @xmath167-quotients @xmath323 . under @xmath511
we have that @xmath512 maps to the generator @xmath513 of @xmath514 while @xmath515 maps to the parameter @xmath30 for the residual @xmath167-action .
the wall - crossing term is @xmath516 } \frac { ( 3\omega + 2\xi)^2 } { \xi ( \omega + \xi ) } & = & { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \int_{[{\mathbb{p } } ] } \frac { ( 3\omega + 2\xi)^2 } { \xi^2 } ( 1 - \omega/ \xi + \omega^2/\xi^2 - \ldots ) \\&= & { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \int_{[{\mathbb{p } } ] } 12 \omega/\xi - 4 \omega/\xi = -8 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] thus as expected the wall - crossing formula reduces to @xmath517 3 . ( resolution of a crepant singularity )
the following example illustrates the application of the wall - crossing to orbifolds , in which the integrals become rational , and also the non - compact case , in which the integrals must be defined via localization .
suppose that @xmath518 and @xmath15 acts with weights @xmath321 with multiplicity @xmath285 and @xmath519 with multiplicity @xmath321 , so that @xmath520 ( by our conventions , a stack with trivial canonical bundle ) while @xmath495 is isomorphic to the total space of @xmath521 .
let @xmath522 ( the next - to - highest chern class of @xmath523 ) so that @xmath393 is the top chern class of @xmath16 .
then @xmath524 } { { \operatorname}{eul}}({\mathbb{c}}^k/{\mathbb{z}}_k ) = 1/k .\ ] ] indeed , interpreting this integral via localization using the @xmath167-action given by scalar multiplication , there is a unique fixed point with stabilizer of order @xmath285 which contributes @xmath525 to the integral . on the other side of the wall , @xmath526 } { { \operatorname}{eul}}({\mathbb{p}}^{k-1 } ) = k .\ ] ]
the wall - crossing term is @xmath527 as expected .
( a del pezzo surface as a quotient of a product of projective lines by a non - abelian group ) let @xmath528 with the diagonal action of @xmath529 , equipped with the polarization @xmath530 corresponding to varying the symplectic class on the first factor . from the symplectic point of view
, this is the symplectic quotient of @xmath531 by the @xmath532-action with radii of the spheres @xmath533 .
the moment map for the action is @xmath534 the quotient @xmath0 is homeomorphic to the _ moduli space of polygons _ @xmath535 a point in the zero level set of the moment map is fixed by a one - parameter subgroup iff the points @xmath536 are colinear , in which case the subgroup fixing them is rotation around the corresponding line .
one sees easily from this ( or the algebraic description ) that the singular values of @xmath359 are @xmath537 corresponding to a single orbit of colinear configurations @xmath538 when @xmath539 and four orbits of colinear configurations @xmath540 when @xmath541 .
thus the chamber structure for @xmath359 is @xmath542 . since the quotient in the last chamber is empty , and all the weights are one , the quotient @xmath353 for the last chamber must be @xmath477 , while passing from the second to first chamber the quotient undergoes a blow - up at @xmath543 points . consider the wall - crossing given by passing between chambers so that @xmath544 and @xmath545 we compute the square of the first chern class by wall - crossing : let @xmath463 , so that @xmath546
. the fixed points of @xmath167 action for the given singular value are the @xmath547 configurations with @xmath540 with all colinear .
consider the case that @xmath548 is fixed by the maximal torus action ; the tangent bundle of this point has weights @xmath549 hence @xmath550 at @xmath551 , while the normal bundle modulo @xmath455 has weights @xmath552 .
taking into account the factor @xmath553 ( corresponding to the fact that the configurations related by multiplication by @xmath330 have the same image in @xmath365 ) we have @xmath554 } c_1(x { /\kern-.7ex/}_+ g)^2 & = & \int_{[x { /\kern-.7ex/}_- g ] } c_1(x { /\kern-.7ex/}_- g)^2 + 4 { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \frac{\xi^2}{-\xi^3 } \\ & = & 9 -4 = 5 \end{aligned}\ ] ] which matches the fact that each blow - up of @xmath477 lowers @xmath488 by @xmath321 . our main result will be derived from a virtual extension of wall - crossing formulas , carried out by kiem - li @xcite using the virtual localization formula of graber - pandharipande @xcite ; we assume that the reader is familiar with the concepts of equivariant perfect obstruction theories etc . from those papers . in this section
we explain the virtual extension and give an application to a simple complete intersection .
let @xmath555 be a deligne - mumford @xmath1-stack equipped with a @xmath1-equivariant perfect obstruction theory which admits an embedding in a smooth deligne - mumford @xmath1-stack .
this means that @xmath555 is equipped with an object @xmath271 of the bounded derived category of @xmath1-equivariant coherent sheaves , together with a morphism from @xmath271 to the cotangent complex , satisfying certain axioms , see @xcite , @xcite ; a typical example is an invariant complete intersection as in example [ nodal ] below
. if @xmath403 is any element then the fixed point stacks @xmath556 also have equivariant perfect obstruction theories compatible with that on @xmath555 ; we denote by @xmath557 the virtual normal complex for the embedding @xmath558 .
the euler class @xmath559 is well - defined in the equivariant cohomology @xmath560 , after inverting the equivariant parameter @xmath30 . from the virtual localization formula one
obtains the following virtual version of the wall - crossing theorem [ kalk2 ] , which can be considered a corollary of kiem - li @xcite : [ virtual kalkman wall - crossing ] [ virkalk ] let @xmath555 be a proper deligne - mumford @xmath1-stack equipped with a @xmath1-equivariant perfect obstruction theory which admits an embedding in a smooth deligne - mumford @xmath1-stack .
let @xmath561 be a @xmath1-line bundles that are ample for the coarse moduli spaces , so that the stable = semistable for @xmath377 .
let @xmath562 resp .
@xmath563 denote integration resp .
equivariant integration over @xmath564 resp .
@xmath565 times @xmath566 . then @xmath567 } \frac{|w_{\zeta}|}{|w_{{\mathbb{c}}\zeta}| } { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \tau_{{\mathcal{x}},\zeta , t}^{g_\zeta}\ ] ] where the sum over @xmath459 $ ] represents a sum over unparametrized one - parameter subgroups of @xmath1 , up to conjugacy .
[ nodal ] ( wall - crossing over a nodal fixed point ) the following simple example may help illustrate the notation .
suppose that @xmath2 is a nodal projective line with a single node , equipped with the standard @xmath167-action on each component , so that the weights of the action on the tangent spaces the node are @xmath568 .
we equip @xmath2 with a polarization so that the weights are @xmath52 at the smooth fixed points , and @xmath197 at the nodal point .
then @xmath569 is a point for @xmath23 , and is singular for @xmath570 .
since @xmath2 is complete intersection , @xmath2 is virtually smooth and the virtual wall - crossing formula of theorem [ virkalka ] applies .
we examine the wall - crossing for the trivial class @xmath571 at the singular value @xmath572 .
the virtual normal complex at the nodal point is the quotient of @xmath573 , the sum of one - dimensional representations with weights @xmath574 , modulo their tensor product @xmath575 , which has weight zero .
hence the normal complex has inverted euler class @xmath576 the integrals on the left and right hand sides are @xmath321 ( being the integrals over points ) while the wall - crossing term is @xmath577 } { { \operatorname}{eul}}_g ( \nu_{x , g , t})^{-1 } = { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi 0 = 0 \end{aligned}\ ] ] as desired .
in this section , we prove a quantum generalization of kalkman s wall - crossing formula theorem [ kalk2 ] . in the first two subsections , we define the wall - crossing terms as integrals over moduli spaces of gauged maps fixed by a central subgroup .
the last two subsections contain a construction of a master space for moduli spaces of gauged maps , and a proof of the wall - crossing formula via virtual localization on the master space .
the construction of the master space is obtained from one for a different compactification of gauged maps introduced by schmitt @xcite , pulled back under a relative version of givental s morphism from stable maps to the quot scheme .
schmitt s compactification has the advantage that it is constructed by git methods so the classical techniques apply .
let @xmath1 be a complex connected reductive group and @xmath578 a central subgroup .
for any principal @xmath1-bundle @xmath579 , the right action of @xmath580 induces an action on the associated bundle @xmath581 , and so on the space of sections . the fixed point set of @xmath580 on @xmath581 is @xmath582 , the associated bundle with fiber the fixed point set @xmath583 .
let @xmath584 be as above .
the action of @xmath580 on the space of sections of @xmath581 preserves mundet semistability and so induces an action of @xmath580 on @xmath585 .
the action of @xmath580 on @xmath146 induces an action on parabolic reductions , preserving the associated graded bundles and morphisms and so the mundet weight of definition [ mundetsemistable ] .
the following is straight - forward , and similar to the case of stable maps in kontsevich @xcite : let @xmath584 be as above .
the fixed point locus for the action of @xmath580 on @xmath226 is the substack whose objects are pairs @xmath586 such that 1 .
@xmath164 takes values in @xmath587 on the principal component @xmath162 ; 2 . for any bubble component @xmath588 mapping to a point in @xmath86 , @xmath164 maps @xmath589 to a one - dimensional orbit of @xmath580 on @xmath581 ; and 3 .
any node of @xmath154 maps to the fixed point set @xmath587 . in this subsection
we explain the wall - crossing terms in the main result theorem [ qkalkcirc ] and state the generalization to arbitrary group actions theorem [ kalk3 ] below .
let @xmath2 be a smooth projective @xmath1-variety equipped with polarizations @xmath229 .
[ fixed gauged maps ] [ fixedef ] for each @xmath403 , let @xmath590 denote the stack of mundet - semistable morphisms from @xmath86 to @xmath591 that are @xmath434-fixed and take values in @xmath592 on the principal component . via the inclusion @xmath593 the universal curve over @xmath590 admits a morphism to @xmath119 , and the tangent complex @xmath239 defines an object @xmath594 in the bounded derived category of @xmath590 with an action of @xmath434 .
we denote by @xmath595 the moving part of @xmath594 with respect to the action of @xmath434 and @xmath596 its euler class , as in , but in the more general setting considered here .
[ fixedlargearea ] ( large - area limit of fixed gauged maps ) the mundet semistability condition for fixed gauged maps simplifies somewhat in the limit @xmath597 .
suppose that @xmath454 is the component of @xmath450 that is @xmath354-semistable .
for any class @xmath187 there exists a @xmath598 such that for @xmath599 , any mundet - semistable fixed map for polarization @xmath354 must consist of a principal component mapping to @xmath600 and bubbles mapping to @xmath591 .
indeed , mundet semistability for @xmath214 implies that the hilbert weight @xmath166 is at most @xmath601 times minus the ramanathan weight @xmath602 , for any @xmath603 .
in particular , this holds @xmath604 for @xmath405 antidominant and @xmath605 the trivial parabolic reduction , in which case the ramanathan weight for a pair @xmath170 with respect to @xmath171 is simply @xmath606 .
the latter is bounded by a constant @xmath607 depending on @xmath608 , since @xmath609 is the projection of @xmath187 onto @xmath610 .
so the hilbert weight @xmath611 is less than @xmath612 .
it follows for any @xmath599 where @xmath613 and any @xmath354-semistable pair @xmath170 , the section @xmath164 takes values in @xmath614 .
( in algebraic language , this is @xmath607 times the inverse of the smallest difference in hilbert - mumford weights for @xmath405 for different fixed point components . ) to summarize , in the large - area limit @xmath215 , the set of values of @xmath359 for which @xmath615 is non - empty coincides with the set of values of @xmath359 for which @xmath454 is non - empty , and the principal component of any object @xmath170 of @xmath615 takes values in @xmath614 .
conversely , suppose that stable = semistable for the @xmath1-action on @xmath377 .
suppose that @xmath170 is @xmath451-semistable and @xmath164 takes values in @xmath614 on the principal component
. then @xmath170 is @xmath616-semistable for @xmath445 for sufficiently large @xmath213 for a unique @xmath617 in a small neighborhood of @xmath359 .
indeed , the stable = semistable assumption implies that hilbert - mumford weight for the action of @xmath434 on @xmath454 is non - constant ( that is , @xmath454 is semistable for a single value of @xmath359 , see remark [ cond ] ) .
it follows that @xmath618-semistability of @xmath170 for the holds for @xmath619 close to @xmath359 and @xmath213 sufficiently large so that @xmath620 , while @xmath451-semistability holds by assumption .
in general , semistability for a product of groups is not equivalent to semistability for the factors but this is true if one of the factors acts trivially , as in the present case .
we will construct in the proof below a perfect relative obstruction theory on @xmath621 .
this construction allows the following definition : [ fixed point contributions to wall - crossing for gromov - witten invariants ] [ contrib ] virtual integration over the stacks @xmath622 defines a `` fixed point contribution '' @xmath623 , \\
\quad \alpha \mapsto \sum_{d \in h_{g}^2(x,{\mathbb{z } } ) } \sum_{n \ge 0 } \int_{[{\overline}{{\mathcal{m}}}_n^{g_\zeta}(c , x , l_t,\zeta , d ) ] } ( q^d / n ! ) { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * ( \alpha , \ldots , \alpha ) \cup { \epsilon}_+(t(x / g))^{-1 } \end{gathered}\ ] ] for @xmath24 , extended by linearity over @xmath624 , where we omit the restriction map @xmath625 to simplify notation .
[ quantum kalkman formula , arbitrary group case ] [ kalk3 ] suppose that @xmath2 is equipped with polarizations @xmath51 so stable = semistable for the action of @xmath1 on @xmath377 .
then the gromov - witten invariants of @xmath16 are related by a sum of twisted gauged gromov - witten invariants for subgroups @xmath626 @xmath627,t \in ( -1,1 ) } \frac{|w_{\zeta}|}{|w_{{\mathbb{c}}\zeta}| } { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \tau^{g_\zeta}_{x,\zeta , t } , \ ] ] where the sum over @xmath459 $ ] is over equivalence classes of unparameterized one - parameter subgroups generated by @xmath403 .
we already gave a simple example [ threepoint ] of this formula in the introduction .
we give another fano example : [ c1 ] ( quantum powers of the first chern class for the blow - up of the projective plane ) suppose that @xmath628 acts on @xmath310 with weights @xmath629 .
consider the path from @xmath498 to @xmath499 in @xmath630 crossing through the chambers with git quotients @xmath500 .
we denote by @xmath315 resp . @xmath314 the second resp .
third quotient .
the quantum kirwan morphism for @xmath631 has no quantum corrections , since these varieties are fano , and so @xmath632 we consider the wall - crossing formula for invariants with @xmath633 fixed markings , corresponding to the small quantum product @xmath634 . by example
[ toric ] , the moduli space of gauged maps is , after fixing the locations of the markings , the quotient of the space of sections @xmath635 by @xmath1 , with stability condition corresponding to the stability condition for @xmath2 , see @xcite . we take @xmath636 , so that @xmath637 ( or @xmath638 for short ) where for any weight @xmath639 , @xmath640 denotes the one - dimensional representation with weight @xmath639 .
the moduli spaces of gauged maps corresponding to the various chambers are therefore the empty set , @xmath641 , its blow - up along a @xmath291 , and the empty set again .
we consider the sequence of polarizations corresponding to the vectors @xmath498 , @xmath493 , @xmath494 , @xmath499 .
the first wall - crossing term for degree @xmath642 invariants corresponds to the direction @xmath643 , for which there is a unique @xmath405-fixed stable map with normal weights @xmath642 with multiplicity 4 and @xmath644 with multiplicity @xmath31 . the wall - crossing term is @xmath645 using this implies that @xmath646 $ ] which is shorthand for saying that the coefficient of @xmath647 $ ] is @xmath648 ; here @xmath116 is the small quantum product , as expected since @xmath649 .\ ] ] the second wall - crossing term corresponds to the change of quotient from @xmath477 to @xmath476 with @xmath650 is ( after fixing the five points on @xmath291 ) an integration over @xmath651 , the quotient of the @xmath405-fixed summand @xmath652 by @xmath167 , @xmath653 } \kappa_{{\mathbb{c}}^7}^{{\mathbb{c}}^\times } \frac { ( 3 \xi_1 + 2\xi_2)^5 } { \xi_1 ^ 4 \xi_2}\ ] ] where @xmath654 is the descent map in equivariant cohomology from @xmath638 . using that @xmath655 is the generator @xmath513 of @xmath514 this gives @xmath656 } \frac { ( 5 \omega + \xi)^5 } { ( \omega + \xi)^4 ( \omega - \xi ) } & = & { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \int_{[{\mathbb{p } } ] } - \xi^{-5 } ( 25 \omega \xi^4 + \xi^5)(1 - 4 \omega/\xi ) ( 1 + \omega/\xi ) \\ & = & 11 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] it follows that @xmath657 .$ ] the last wall - crossing term for the degree @xmath642 invariant is @xmath658 } \kappa_{{\mathbb{c}}^7}^{{\mathbb{c}}^\times } \frac { ( 3\xi_1 + 2\xi_2)^5 } { \xi_2(\xi_1 + \xi_2)^2 } = 232 .\ ] ] this is as expected since the quotient is empty in the last chamber .
one can verify that the expansion of @xmath659 contains @xmath660 $ ] using the known quantum multiplication table for @xmath476 from crauder - miranda @xcite : @xmath661 where @xmath662 are the exceptional resp .
fiber resp .
point resp .
fundamental classes respectively , @xmath663 , and using a little help from mathematica .
( we thank eric malm for teaching us how to get mathematica to compute these coefficients . ) by the adiabatic limit theorem [ largerel ] , to prove the wall - crossing formula [ kalk3 ] it suffices to prove a formula for the difference of gauged potentials .
the following result is a algebro - geometric generalization of a wall - crossing formula of cieliebak - salamon @xcite for gauged gromov - witten invariants of quotients of vector spaces defined using symplectic geometry .
we will deduce our main result theorem [ kalk3 ] by taking the large area limit @xmath664 of the following theorem : [ gwall ] let @xmath2 be a smooth projective @xmath1-variety .
suppose that @xmath229 are polarizations such that semistable = stable for the stack @xmath665 of [ masterprop ]
. then the gauged gromov - witten potentials are related by @xmath666,t \in ( -1,1 ) } \frac{|w_{\zeta}|}{|w_{{\mathbb{c}}\zeta}| } { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \tau^{g_\zeta}_{x,\zeta , t}\ ] ] where the sum is over equivalence classes @xmath459 $ ] of unparametrized one - parameter subgroups generated by @xmath403 , and the same mundet semistability parameter should be used to define the potentials on both sides of the equation .
the proof of the wall - crossing formula [ gwall ] depends on the construction of _ master space _ in the sense of [ master ] whose quotients are the moduli spaces of mundet stable gauged maps .
[ existence of a master space ] [ masterprop ] under suitable stable = semistable conditions , there exists a proper deligne - mumford @xmath167-stack with perfect relative obstruction theory @xmath667 whose @xmath167-fixed substack is the union of @xmath668 and the images of the stacks @xmath615 for @xmath669 of definition [ contrib ] .
furthermore , @xmath667 admits an embedding in a non - singular deligne - mumford stack .
the proof will be given after several constructions . first recall the quot - scheme compactification of mundet semistable morphisms from @xmath86 to @xmath119 constructed by schmitt @xcite : [ quot - scheme compactification of gauged maps ] in the case @xmath670 and @xmath671 , a _ projective bump _ over a smooth projective curve @xmath86 is a datum consisting of a vector bundle @xmath672 ; a line bundle @xmath673 ; and a surjective morphism @xmath674 .
more generally , if @xmath1 is an arbitrary group embedded in @xmath675 , and @xmath2 is a smooth projective @xmath1-variety embedded in @xmath676 then a projective bump is a projective @xmath675-bump and a reduction of the frame bundle @xmath677 to @xmath1 such that the corresponding injection @xmath678 takes values in the associated @xmath2-bundle @xmath679 .
a bump is _ mundet semistable _ if it satisfies the inequality of definition [ mundetsemistable ] for every pair @xmath171 consisting of a parabolic reduction @xmath605 and antidominant coweight @xmath149 .
let @xmath680 denote the stack of mundet semistable projective bumps of class @xmath608 over @xmath86 with target @xmath2 .
in the toric case discussed in example [ toric ] there are no non - constant holomorphic maps from curves to @xmath2 and so @xmath681 that is , the moduli space of maps from irreducible domain is already compact and does not require compactification .
the following summarizes results of schmitt @xcite : [ git construction of projective bumps ] [ schmittgit ] @xcite @xmath680 admits a presentation as a git quotient of a _ framed moduli space _ @xmath682 ( consisting of bundles that can be written as quotients of a given trivial bundle on @xmath86 , which we omit from the notation ) by the action of a group @xmath683 acting on the space of framings , with respect to a polarization @xmath684 on @xmath685 depending on the choice of polarization @xmath68 . if stable = semistable , then @xmath680 is a proper deligne - mumford stack with a projective coarse moduli space .
the stack @xmath680 seems not to be virtually smooth in general and so , it seems , can not be expected to admit a good virtual fundamental class .
we denote by @xmath686 the stack - theoretic quotient , @xmath687 which contains @xmath680 as an open substack . in order to study the dependence on polarization ,
suppose we are given two polarizations @xmath45 and denote by @xmath688 the relative hyperplane bundle as in .
consider the git quotient @xmath689 we call an object of @xmath690 a _ polarized bump _
, since generically an object of it is equivalent to a bump together with a point in the line bundle over it . from the geometric invariant theory construction ,
it follows : [ stack of polarized bumps ] if stable = semistable then the stack @xmath690 is a smooth proper deligne - mumford stack with a projective coarse moduli space .
we denote by @xmath691 the stable locus of the bundle @xmath692 for @xmath693 depending on @xmath694 $ ] , and by @xmath695 the artin quotient stack . by lemma [ master ] [ master space for bumps ]
the residual action of @xmath167 on the stack @xmath690 has git quotient with respect to the polarization @xmath692 isomorphic to @xmath696 .
we wish to obtain similar results for the kontsevich - style compactification , which is the one having a virtual fundamental class with the expected properties .
the projection @xmath697 is a @xmath291-bundle over @xmath698
. let @xmath699 ) \subset { \overline}{{\mathfrak{m}}}_n^g(c , x ) $ ] denote the artin stack of gauged maps that are semistable with respect to the stability condition defined by @xmath354 for some @xmath700 $ ] : @xmath701 ) : = \bigcup_{t \in [ -1,1 ] } { \overline}{{\mathcal{m}}}_n^g(c , x , l_t ) .\ ] ] there is a _ relative givental morphism _ from @xmath699)$ ] to @xmath702 extending the forgetful morphism on the open stratum ( if non - empty ) .
the morphism , roughly speaking , replaces each bubble tree which maps to a point in @xmath86 with a base point for the linear system corresponding to the quotient .
the relative givental morphism is constructed more generally in popa - roth @xcite .
each object in @xmath703 ) $ ] is a pair of a bundle @xmath704 with stable section @xmath705 , where @xmath706 is a nodal curve ; the givental morphism replaces @xmath164 with the corresponding quotient .
there is no morphism from @xmath707 to @xmath708 since the domain has objects with infinitely many isomorphism classes of bundles , while the isomorphism classes of bundles in the target form a finite set .
[ polarized gauged maps ] a _ mundet semi - stable polarized gauged map _ is an object in the fiber product of the relative givental morphism with the projection from the master space for projective bumps : @xmath709 ) \times_{{\overline}{{\mathfrak{m}}}^{g,{{\operatorname}{quot}}}(c , x ) } { \overline}{{\mathcal{m}}}^{g,{{\operatorname}{quot}}}(c , x , l_+,l_-)\ ] ] that is , a polarized gauged bump together with a lift of the underlying bump to the moduli stack of stable gauged maps that are mundet - semistable for some @xmath700 $ ] . if stable = semistable for polarized gauged maps , then for any @xmath608
, @xmath667 is a smooth proper deligne - mumford stack .
since @xmath710 is proper and deligne - mumford , and the codomain is proper deligne - mumford under the stable = semistable assumption .
smoothness is immediate from the fiber product description , since the second morphism is an open embedding . in this subsection
, we deduce the quantum wall - crossing formula by applying virtual localization to the master space @xmath667 constructed in the previous subsection . under the given hypotheses the stack @xmath667 is a proper deligne - mumford stack and an open substack of artin stack @xmath711 defined by dropping the semistability condition .
[ obstruction theory for polarized gauged maps ] for any @xmath608 , the artin stack @xmath712 has a relative obstruction theory over the moduli stack @xmath190 of parametrized prestable curves . if stable = semistable then the restriction of this obstruction theory to @xmath667 is perfect .
the complex in the relative obstruction theory is denoted @xmath713 in the diagram below , constructed from the following commutative diagram of complexes of coherent sheaves .
we use @xmath714 resp .
@xmath715 for the cotangent complex resp .
relative cotangent complex for the morphism to avoid conflict with previous notation .
@xmath716 } \arrow{w } \arrow{s } \\ \node{t^{\vee}_\pi } \node{t^{\vee}_{{\overline}{{\mathfrak{m}}}_n^{g}(c , x , l_-,l_+ ) } } \arrow{w } \node { \pi^ * t^{\vee}_{{\overline}{{\mathfrak{m}}}_n^g({c},x,[-1,1 ] ) } } \arrow{w } \node{t^{\vee}_\pi[1]}\arrow{w } \end{diagram}\ ] ] where the horizontal lines are exact triangles and the second vertical arrow @xmath717 exists by the axioms of a triangulated category .
the map @xmath717 satisfies the axioms of an obstruction theory by the five lemma applied to the cohomology of the above diagram .
if the automorphisms are finite then the relative obstruction theory is perfect .
indeed for the base @xmath718 is identified with the dual of the lie algebra of the group of automorphisms ( * ? ? ?
* example 6.7(c ) ) , and this carries over to the total space by the long exact sequence . for any @xmath608 , @xmath667 admits an embedding in a non - singular deligne - mumford stack .
consider an embedding @xmath719 and @xmath1-equivariant embedding @xmath720 for some @xmath285 .
let @xmath721 denote the universal bundle over the moduli space of framed bumps @xmath722 , equipped with the action of @xmath683 by changing the framings as in proposition [ schmittgit ] .
then @xmath723 embeds in the projectivization @xmath724 .
the latter is projective by schmitt s construction ( it is the pull - back of the universal bundle on quot scheme ) and so embeds @xmath683-equivariantly in some @xmath725 .
then @xmath667 is an embedded substack of @xmath726 , with objects given by stable maps that are compositions of stable sections of @xmath727 with the inclusion into @xmath728 .
since @xmath729 is a non - singular deligne - mumford stack , the quotient @xmath726 is a non - singular artin stack .
the group @xmath683 acts locally freely on an open subset @xmath730 by the stable = semistable assumption and the quotient @xmath731 is deligne - mumford .
[ wall - crossing for gauged gromov - witten invariants , preliminary version ] [ prewall ] let @xmath2 be a smooth projective @xmath1-variety equipped with polarizations @xmath45 .
suppose that stable = semistable for the master space @xmath667 . then for any @xmath205 , @xmath732 } { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * \alpha - \int _ { [ { \overline}{{\mathcal{m}}}_n^g(c , x , l_-,d ) ] } { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * \alpha \\ = { { \operatorname}{resid}}_\xi \left ( \sum_{f } \int_{[f ] } \iota_f^ * { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * \alpha \cup { { \operatorname}{eul}}_{{\mathbb{c}}^\times}(\nu_f)^{-1 } \right)\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath733 ranges over the fixed point components of @xmath167 on @xmath734 not equal to @xmath735 with normal complex @xmath736 . by virtual localization applied to the @xmath167-action on @xmath737 , as in the kiem - li fixed point formula theorem [ virkalk ] .
next we describe the moduli spaces of @xmath167-fixed gauged maps in terms of gauged maps with smaller structure group .
let @xmath738 denote the category of @xmath405-fixed gauged maps whose principal component is semistable for the polarization given by @xmath354 for some @xmath23 , as in definition [ fixedef ] .
[ fixed points as reducible gauged maps ] [ red ] any @xmath167-fixed component of @xmath739 is in the image of @xmath738 in @xmath740 for some @xmath23 where @xmath741 is a non - zero element , @xmath445 is stabilizer , and @xmath449 the unparametrized one - parameter subgroup generated by @xmath405 , consisting of maps @xmath742 taking values in @xmath743 on the principal component , and @xmath591 on the bubbles .
furthermore , for @xmath744 the map @xmath745 has fiber isomorphic to @xmath746 .
any fixed point of @xmath167 on @xmath747 is necessarily in the fiber over a gauged map @xmath748 with infinite automorphism group .
the infinitesimal automorphism generated by the action of @xmath167 is a section of the adjoint bundle @xmath749 , given by an element @xmath750 at a base point @xmath751 .
the structure group of @xmath146 reduces to the centralizer @xmath445 , and being fixed by the automorphism the section @xmath164 takes values in the fixed point set @xmath752 of @xmath405 on the principal component .
the fiber of the morphism is @xmath753 for @xmath409 , corresponding to pairs @xmath170 related by @xmath1-isomorphisms that are not @xmath445-isomorphisms .
[ bubbles ] we may describe the fixed point locus as a stack of `` bubble trees '' as follows : there is an isomorphism @xmath754 } \left ( { \mathcal{m}}^{g_\zeta,{{{\operatorname}{fr}}}}_r(c , x^{\zeta , t } ) \times_{(x^\zeta)^r } \prod_{j=1}^r { \overline}{{\mathcal{m}}}_{|i_j|+1}(x ) \right)^\zeta / ( g_\zeta)^r\ ] ] where the right - hand - side denotes the fixed point set of the action @xmath434 on the moduli stack of gauged maps to @xmath454 with bubbles in @xmath2 .
indeed , by definition each object of @xmath755 consists of a principal component mapping to @xmath600 and a collection of bubble trees in @xmath2 fixed ( up to reparametrization ) by the action of @xmath434 .
[ obstheory ] ( obstruction theory for the fixed point components ) @xmath756 is an artin stack , and if every automorphism group is finite modulo @xmath434 , each substack with fixed homology class @xmath757 is a proper deligne - mumford stack with a relatively perfect obstruction theory over @xmath758 whose complex is @xmath759 .
the relatively perfect obstruction theory @xmath756 is pulled back from that on the @xmath167-fixed point set in @xmath665 in proposition [ red ] , which exists by the construction of relatively perfect obstruction theories on fixed point loci in @xcite .
let @xmath760 $ ] denote the virtual fundamental class in the homology of the coarse moduli space resulting from corollary [ obstheory ] .
integration with respect to these classes yields _ @xmath405-fixed gauged gromov - witten invariants _ of definition [ contrib ] .
these gauged gromov - witten invariants satisfy splitting properties similar to the gauged gromov - witten invariants defined by integration over @xmath226 constructed in @xcite , @xcite , that we will not discuss here .
the @xmath405-fixed gauged gromov - witten invariants that appear in the wall - crossing formula involve further twists by euler classes of index bundles @xmath761 , that is , the moving part of @xmath762 .
this completes the construction of the fixed point potential in definition [ contrib ] .
we remark that the resulting fixed point potential @xmath763 takes values in @xmath764 rather than in @xmath765 because gromov compactness fails for gauged maps in the case that a central subgroup @xmath434 acts trivially . indeed , in this case , the energy @xmath766 of a gauged map of class @xmath187 does not determine the isomorphism class of the bundle , since twisting by a character of @xmath434 does not change the energy .
theorem [ kalk3 ] now follows from theorem [ prewall ] and proposition [ red ] , and the observation that stable = semistable for @xmath2 implies stable = semistable for gauged maps in the limit @xmath664 , discussed in @xcite and , for fixed gauged maps , in remark [ fixedlargearea ] .
the right - hand - side of theorem [ kalk3 ] can also be re - written using the quantum kirwan map for @xmath767 , using the adiabatic limit theorem for @xmath768-gauged maps . however , in our examples the gauged gromov - witten invariants are always easier to compute than the gromov - witten invariants of the git quotients , so we have left the formula as written .
ruan and others , see @xcite , conjectured that _ crepant resolutions _ induce equivalences in gromov - witten theory .
more generally , suppose that @xmath769 are smooth proper deligne - mumford stacks with projective coarse moduli spaces related by a birational equivalence @xmath770 .
such a birational equivalence is called _ crepant _ ( or a _ @xmath771-equivalence _ ) if @xmath770 factors into morphisms @xmath772 from a smooth stack @xmath580 with projective coarse moduli space such that the pullbacks of the canonical divisors to @xmath580 are equal , as in kawamata @xcite
. it is conjectured by li - ruan @xcite , bryan - graber @xcite and others ( perhaps motivated by physics papers such as witten @xcite ) that in such a situation ( not necessarily arising from geometric invariant theory ) the gromov - witten theories of @xmath773 and @xmath774 are equivalent , in a sense to be made precise .
many special cases have been proved , see for example iwao - lee - lin - wang @xcite , lee - lin - wang @xcite , boissire - mann - perroni @xcite , bryan - gholampour @xcite , @xcite , bryan - graber - pandharipande @xcite , coates - corti - iritani - tseng @xcite and coates - iritani - tseng @xcite .
we prove a version theorem [ cytype ] of ruan s conjecture for crepant birational equivalences induced by variation of git .
suppose that @xmath2 is a smooth projective @xmath1-variety , and @xmath16 are git quotients obtained from polarizations @xmath45 .
suppose that stable = semistable for @xmath377 so that the master space @xmath775 is a smooth proper deligne - mumford stack .
[ crepant ] a birational transformation of git type @xmath776 will be called _ crepant _ if the sum of the weights of @xmath167 on @xmath777 , counted with multiplicity , vanishes . more generally ,
in the case of twisted gromov - witten theory associated to a @xmath1-vector bundle @xmath223 , we say that @xmath778 is crepant resp .
weakly crepant if the same holds for @xmath779 where @xmath780 is the index of @xmath271 as in .
it is easy to check that the definition of crepant transformation of git type is a special cases of the definition of crepant transformation ( @xmath771-equivalence ) in kawamata @xcite etc .
indeed , kempf s descent lemma ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.3 ) and the crepant condition together imply that the canonical bundle ( possibly twisted by the top exterior power of @xmath780 ) descends to each singular quotient , from which the canonical bundles on @xmath16 are pulled back .
the proof of invariance follows from a symmetry of the fixed point contributions under an action of the picard stack @xmath781 of line bundles on @xmath86 defined as follows .
the lie algebra @xmath782 has a distinguished factor generated by @xmath405 , and using an invariant metric the weight lattice of @xmath782 has a distinguished factor @xmath783 given by its intersection with the lie algebra of @xmath434 . after passing to a finite cover
, we may assume that @xmath784 .
[ pic ] ( action of the picard stack on fixed loci ) in the limit @xmath215 there is a canonical action of @xmath785 on the moduli stack @xmath621 for any @xmath23 .
the isomorphism preserves the relative obstruction theories and so the behrend - fantechi virtual fundamental classes .
furthermore , the isomorphism preserves the class @xmath786 for any @xmath787 .
an object of @xmath621 consists of a tuple @xmath788 where @xmath579 is a @xmath1-bundle and @xmath705 is @xmath405-fixed , in particular , the restriction of @xmath164 to the principal component of @xmath86 maps into the fixed point locus @xmath450 .
let @xmath449 denote the subgroup of @xmath445 generated by @xmath789 .
then @xmath785 acts on @xmath621 by @xmath790 where we use that @xmath791 since the action of @xmath434 on @xmath450 is trivial . because the mundet weights @xmath792 approach @xmath166 as @xmath215 , the limiting mundet is unchanged by the shift by @xmath793 in the limit @xmath215 and so mundet semistability is preserved , see remark [ fixedlargearea ] .
the action of an object @xmath793 of @xmath785 induces an isomorphism @xmath794 where @xmath795 .
the action of @xmath785 lifts to the universal curves , denoted by the same notation . since the obstruction theory on @xmath615 is the @xmath405-invariant part of @xmath594 , the isomorphism preserves the relative obstruction theories and so the behrend - fantechi virtual fundamental classes .
since the evaluation map is unchanged by pull - back by @xmath796 ( up to isomorphism given by twisting by @xmath793 ) , the class @xmath797 is preserved .
[ distrib ] in preparation for the proof of theorem [ cytype ] we briefly recall a few items from the schwartz theory of _ distributions _ for which the standard reference is hrmander @xcite .
recall that if @xmath798 is the circle then we denote by @xmath799 the space of continuous linear functionals on the smooth functions on @xmath798 , and by @xmath800 the space of _ tempered distributions_. fourier transform defines an isomorphism of @xmath801 with the space of functions on @xmath783 with polynomial growth .
we view @xmath64 as a coordinate on the punctured plane @xmath167 .
any formal power series in @xmath802 defines a distribution on @xmath798 , which is tempered if the coefficient of @xmath69 has polynomial growth in @xmath187 .
in particular @xmath803 is the delta function at @xmath804 , and has fourier transform the constant function with value @xmath321 .
any distribution of the form @xmath805 , for @xmath806 polynomial , is a sum of derivatives of the delta function ( since fourier transform takes multiplication to differentiation ) and so is almost everywhere zero .
we study the dependence of the fixed point contributions @xmath807 with respect to the picard action defined in lemma [ pic ] .
suppose that @xmath793 is a @xmath434-bundle of first chern class the generator of @xmath808 , after the identification @xmath809 .
we denote the corresponding class in @xmath810 by @xmath811 .
consider the action of @xmath783-subgroup of @xmath785 generated by @xmath793 .
the contribution of any component @xmath615 of class @xmath812 differs from that from the component induced by acting by @xmath813 , of class @xmath814 , by the ratio of euler classes @xmath815 which we now compute .
let @xmath454 be the component of the fixed point set @xmath450 which is semistable for @xmath23 .
for simplicity , we assume that @xmath454 is connected ; in general , one should repeat the following argument for each connected component .
consider the decomposition into @xmath167-bundles @xmath816 where @xmath167 acts on @xmath817 with non - zero weight @xmath35 .
then @xmath818 is canonically isomorphic to @xmath819 on the bubble components , since the @xmath1-bundles are trivial on those components .
because the pull - back complexes are isomorphic on the bubble components , the difference @xmath820 is the pullback of the difference of the restrictions to the principal part of the universal curve , that is , the projection on the second factor @xmath821 these restrictions are given by @xmath822 where @xmath823 is the map from the universal curve to @xmath86 .
the projection @xmath824 is a representable morphism of stacks given as global quotients @xcite in which case by grothendieck - riemann - roch @xcite , @xcite @xmath825 where @xmath826 is a constant section of @xmath824 .
the equality of chern characters above implies an isomorphism in rational @xmath771-theory ; by the splitting principle we may assume that the @xmath817 are line bundles .
the difference in euler classes is therefore given by the euler class of the last summand in @xmath827 let @xmath828 be the sum of weights of the action at the fixed point component @xmath454 . expanding out the product we obtain @xmath829 and @xmath830 indicates further terms with the property that he coefficient of @xmath831 is polynomial in @xmath122 . by the crepant assumption in definition [ crepant ] , the sum of the weights is @xmath832 summing the terms from @xmath833 we obtain a distribution almost everywhere vanishing : for any singular value @xmath234 , @xmath834 } \\
\left ( 1 + \xi^{-1 } \sum_{i=1}^k r c_1(\nu_{x^{\zeta , t},i } ) + \ldots \right ) { { \operatorname}{ev}}^ * ( \alpha , \ldots , \alpha ) \end{gathered}\ ] ] where as before the terms @xmath830 are polynomial in the @xmath122 .
now for any polynomial @xmath835 in @xmath122 , @xmath836 vanishes almost everywhere in @xmath64 , being a function times a sum of derivatives of delta functions in @xmath64 , see remark [ distrib ] .
since @xmath837 is a sum of such wall - crossing terms , this completes the proof of theorem [ cytype ] . 1 .
the proof shows that if in fact the action of @xmath1 on @xmath2 is calabi - yau in the sense that @xmath838 , then the wall - crossing term is not only almost everywhere vanishing but also a sum of _ at least second _ derivatives of delta functions . 2 . the standard formulation of the crepant transformation conjecture in coates - ruan @xcite etc .
uses analytic continuation .
the above results say nothing about convergence of the gauged gromov - witten potentials , so it is rather difficult to put the version above in this language .
however , if the potentials have expressions as analytic functions with overlapping regions of definition on the torus @xmath839 with coordinate @xmath64 , then they are equal on that region .
( crepant resolution of @xmath840 ) let @xmath15 act on @xmath518 with weights @xmath841 , and let @xmath51 denote the trivial line bundles with characters @xmath52
. then @xmath495 is isomorphic to the quotient stack @xmath840 and @xmath314 is the crepant resolution of its coarse moduli space .
theorem [ cytype ] implies that the gromov - witten theories of @xmath16 are equivalent . even in the case of an @xmath842-singularity ( @xmath843 )
the transformation relating the two equivalent gromov - witten theories is non - trivial ; see coates - corti - iritani - tseng @xcite and bryan - gholampour @xcite for more on quantum cohomology of resolutions of ade singularities .
( flop ) let @xmath15 act on @xmath844 with weights @xmath574 each with multiplicity @xmath285 , and let @xmath51 denote the trivial line bundles with characters @xmath52 .
then @xmath353 undergoes a simple flop as @xmath359 passes through zero ( blow - down of a @xmath283 followed by a blow - up ) and theorem [ cytype ] implies that the gromov - witten theories of @xmath323 are equivalent .
see iwao - lee - lin - wang @xcite for the invariance under simple flops in general and example [ simpleflop ] .
( quantum mckay correspondences for abelian three - fold singularities ) let @xmath151 be the regular representation of @xmath845 and consider the affine scheme of representations of the mckay quiver with relations , @xmath846 we denote by @xmath847 the set of isomorphism classes of irreducible representations of @xmath845 , for any @xmath848 let @xmath849 denote the corresponding irreducible representation , and @xmath850 the representation ring .
the group of equivariant automorphisms of the regular representation @xmath851 acts on @xmath852 by conjugation and induces a faithful action of @xmath853 . any _ stability parameter
_ @xmath854 induces a character @xmath855 \mapsto
\prod_{\rho \in { \operatorname}{irr(\gamma ) } } \det(g_\rho)^{\theta(\rho)}\ ] ] and so a linearization of the trivial bundle . denote @xmath856 the stack - theoretic quotient of the semistable locus in @xmath852 with respect to @xmath318 . a result of bridgeland , king , and reid @xcite shows that @xmath857 is a crepant resolution of the coarse moduli space of @xmath858 .
craw - ishii @xcite show further that any two projective crepant resolutions of ( the coarse moduli space of ) @xmath858 are related by variation of git .
by theorem [ cytype ] and the results of craw - ishii @xcite , any two quotients @xmath859 for which stable = semistable have equivalent gromov - witten theories in the sense of theorem [ cytype ] assuming that the git quotient at the wall being crossed is a smooth stack .
this already follows from the results of iwa - lee - lin - wang @xcite , since as craw - ishii @xcite shows , the transitions are all simple flops
. it would be interesting to understand , given a quiver with relations , for which stability parameters the git quotients are smooth stacks .
for example , ishii - ueda @xcite have given a non - degeneracy condition for smoothness of the moduli spaces associated to dimer models for generic stability parameters .
for any codimension one wall whose associated git quotient is smooth ( that is the semistable locus associated to the polarization lying in a wall is smooth ) one obtains an equivalence of gromov - witten theories .
however , we do not know for which walls this condition holds .
m. brion and c. procesi .
action dun tore dans une varit projective .
in a. connes et al . , editors , _ operator algebras , unitary representations , enveloping algebras , and invariant theory _ ,
volume 62 of _ progress in mathematics _ , pages 509539 , paris , 1989 , 1990 .
birkhuser , boston . g. kempf and l. ness .
the length of vectors in representation spaces . in k.
lnsted , editor , _ algebraic geometry _ ,
volume 732 of _ lecture notes in mathematics _ , pages 233244 , copenhagen , 1978 , 1979 .
springer - verlag , berlin - heidelberg - new york .
i. manin . , volume 4 of _ north - holland mathematical library_. north - holland publishing co. , amsterdam , second edition , 1986 .
algebra , geometry , arithmetic , translated from the russian by m. hazewinkel . | we prove a quantum version of kalkman s wall - crossing formula @xcite , @xcite comparing intersection pairings on geometric invariant theory ( git ) quotients related by a change in polarization , under certain stable = semistable assumptions .
the formula is the same , but each expression in the formula is quantized in the sense that it is replaced by an integral over moduli spaces of certain stable maps ; in particular , the wall - crossing terms are gauged gromov - witten invariants with smaller structure group . as an application ,
we show that the graph gromov - witten potentials of quotients related by wall - crossings of crepant type are equivalent up to a distribution in the quantum parameter that is almost everywhere zero .
this is a version of the crepant transformation conjecture of li - ruan @xcite , bryan - graber @xcite , coates - ruan @xcite etc . in cases where the crepant transformation is obtained by variation of git .
= 8.5 in |
we represent the residues of the membrane protein as single beads centered in their @xmath0 positions .
adjacent beads are tethered together into a polymer chain by a harmonic potential with the average @xmath62 distance along the chain equal to @xmath63 .
the membrane is described simply by a slab of width @xmath64 .
two non - bonded residues @xmath65 form a contact if their distance is less then @xmath66 . in the study of globular proteins ,
the topology of the native state is encoded in the contact map giving the pairs @xmath65 of non - bonded residues that are in contact .
here , in addition , the locations of such pairs with respect to the membrane becomes crucial .
the contacts are divided into three classes : _ membrane contacts _ where both @xmath67 and @xmath68 residues are inside the membrane , _ interface contacts _ with @xmath67 and @xmath68 in the interface region @xcite outside the membrane and _ surface contacts _ with one residue inside the membrane and the other outside .
thus a given protein conformation can have a native contact but improperly placed with respect to the membrane ( _ misplaced native contact _ ) .
the crucial interaction potential between non - bonded residues @xmath65 is taken to be a modified lennard - jones 12 - 10 potential : @xmath69 + 5\ \gamma_1(i , j)\left ( \frac{% d_{ij}}{r_{ij}}\right)^{12}.\ ] ] the matrices @xmath70 and @xmath71 encode the topology of the tmp in the following way : if @xmath65 is not a contact in the native state @xmath72 ; if @xmath65 is a contact in the native state but not at the proper location ( i.e. a misplaced contact ) @xmath73 ; if @xmath65 is a native state contact in the proper region @xmath74 .
this model is intended to describe the folding process in the interface and in the membrane region .
our interaction potential ( similar in spirit to a well known model@xcite for globular proteins ( see also other approaches that model helix formation @xcite ) ) assigns two values to the energy associated with the formation of a native contact , @xmath61 and @xmath75 .
the model captures the tendency to form native contacts .
in addition , in order to account for the effective interactions between the membrane and the protein , the model assigns a lower energy , @xmath76 , to the contact which occurs in the same region as in the native state structure compared to @xmath77 when the contact is formed but in the wrong region of space .
this feature proves to be crucial in determining the mechanism of insertion of the protein across the membrane in order to place all native contacts in the same regions as in the native state .
even though the interaction potential is simple and intuitively appealing , it is not possible to simply guess ( without detailed calculations ) the folding mechanism and quantitatively determine the probability of occurrence of the various folding pathways@xcite .
when @xmath78 , the protein does not recognize the presence of the interface - membrane region and the full rotational symmetry is restored ( the system behaves like a globular protein ) .
the difference in the parameters ( @xmath79 ) controls the amount of tertiary structure formation outside the membrane .
when the difference is small , the protein assembles almost completely outside the membrane and the insertion process would be diffusion limited .
our results are independent of the precise values of the energy parameters @xmath61 and @xmath80 ( @xmath81 ) as long as they are not too close to each other .
we report here the results of simulations with @xmath82 and @xmath83 .
@xmath84 and @xmath85 are the distance between the two residues @xmath65 and their distance in the native configuration , respectively . in order to account for the chirality of the tmp , a potential for the pseudodihedral angle @xmath86 between the @xmath87 atoms in a helix corresponding to four successive locations
is added which biases the helices to be in their native state structure .
the thermodynamics and the kinetics of the model were studied by a monte carlo method for polymer chains allowing for local deformations .
the efficiency of the program ( usually low for continuum calculations ) has been increased by full use of the link cell technique @xcite and by the multiple markov chain method , a new sampling scheme , which has been proven to be particulary efficient in exploring the low temperature phase diagram for polymers @xcite . in our simulation @xmath88 different temperatures ranging from @xmath89 to @xmath90 have been studied .
the free energy is calculated by reweighting the different temperatures with the ferrenberg - swendsen @xcite algorithm .
the free energy difference @xmath91 between two states a and b has been estimated as the reversible work that has to be done in order to go from a to b. hence , denoting by @xmath92 a reaction coordinate connecting a and b ( for @xmath93 and @xmath94 the system is in a and b respectively ) , and by @xmath95 , the canonical average at fixed reaction coordinate , @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the force and @xmath98 is a suitably dense partition of the interval @xmath99 .
the average value @xmath100 at each @xmath101 is computed by a long ( more than 5000 steps ) monte carlo run performed with dynamics satisfying the constraint @xmath102 .
the free energy differences obtained with this method are accurate to within @xmath44 0.1@xmath103 for the various states whereas the free energy barriers are accurate within @xmath39 0.5@xmath103 .
this error takes into account possible hysteresis effects due to the finite simulation time . , 1 - 2 ( 1999 ) .
fersht , a. r. , w. h. freeman , new york ( 1999 ) .
karplus , m. & sali , a. _ curr .
_ * 5 * , 58 - 73 ( 1995 ) .
white , s. h. & wimley , w. c. _ ann .
_ * 28 * , 319 - 365 ( 1999 ) .
ostermeier , c. & michel , h. _ curr .
biol . _ * 7 * , 697 - 701 , ( 1997 ) .
von heijne , g. _ prog .
biol . _ * 66 * , 2 , 113 - 139 ( 1996 ) . booth , p.j .
_ folding & design _ , r85-r92 ( 1997 ) .
biggin , p. c. & sansom , m. s. p. _ biophysical chemistry _ * 76 * , 161 - 183 ( 1999 ) .
deber , c. m. & goto , n. k. _ nature structural biology _ * 3 * , 815 - 818 ( 1996 ) .
popot , j. l. & engelman , d. m. _ biochemistry _ * 29 * , 4031 - 4036 ( 1990 ) .
pappu , r. v. , marshall , g. r. & ponder , j. w. _ nature structural biology _ * 6 * , 50 - 55 ( 1999 ) .
milik , m. and skolnick , j. _ proc .
usa _ * 89 * , 9391 - 9395 , ( 1992 ) milik , m. and j. skolnick .
_ proteins : funct .
_ * 15*,10 - 25 , ( 1993 ) jacobs , r .
e. & ite , s. h. , biochemistry 26 , 6127 - 6134 ( 1987 ) roseman , m. a. , j. mol .
200 , 513 - 522 ( 1988 ) .
wimley , s.c . & white , s.h _ designing transmebrane @xmath4-helices that insert spontaneously _ preprint .
university of california , irvine ( 2000 ) engelman , d.m . & steitz , t.a .
_ cell _ , * 23 * , 411 - 422 ( 1981 )
. jacobs , r.e .
& white , s.h . _
biochemistry _ , * 28 * , 3421 - 3427 ( 1989 )
. jacobs , r.e .
& white , s.h .
_ biochemistry _ , * 25 * , 2605 - 2612 ( 1986 ) .
pinheiro , t. j. t. , elve , g.a . ,
watts , a. and roder , h .. _ biochemistry _ * 36*,13122 - 13132 ( 1997 ) rankin , s. e. , watts , a. and pinheiro , t.j.t .
_ biochemistry _ * 37 * , 12588 - 12595 ( 1998 ) bryson , e. a. , rankin , s.e . , carey , m .
watts , a. and pinheiro , t.j.t .
_ biochemistry _ * 38 * : 9758 - 9767 ( 1999 ) fersht , a. r. _ current opinion in struct .
biology _ * 5 * , 79 - 84 ( 1995 ) fersht , a. r. _ current opinion in struct . biology _ * 7 * , 3 - 9 ( 1997 ) micheletti , c. , banavar , j. r. , maritan , a. & seno , f. _ phys .
lett . _ * 82 * , 3372 - 3375 ( 1999 ) .
munoz , v. & eaton , w. a. _ proc .
sci . _ * 96 * , 11311 - 11316 ( 1999 ) .
galzitskaya , o. v. & finkelstein , a. v. _ proc .
sci . _ * 96 * , 11299 - 11304 ( 1999 ) .
alm , e. & baker , d. _ proc .
sci . _ * 96 * , 11305 - 11310 ( 1999 ) .
chiti , f. , taddei , n. , white , p. m. , bucciantini , m. , magherini , f. , stefani , m. and dobson , c. m. _ nature structural biology _ * 6 * , 1005 , ( 1999 ) .
martinez , j. c. and serrano , l. _ nature structural biology _ * 6 * , 1010 , ( 1999 ) .
riddle , d. s. , grantcharova , v. p. , santiago , j. v. , alm , e. , ruczinski , i. and baker , d. _ nature structural biology _ * 6 * , 1016 , ( 1999 ) . bryngelson , j. d. and wolynes , p. g. _ proc .
usa _ * 84 * , 7524 , ( 1987 ) .
kahn , t. w. , sturtevant , j.m . and
engelman , d.m .
_ biochemistry _ * 31*,8829 - 8839 ( 1992 ) kahn , t. w. & engelman , d.m .. _ biochemistry _ * 31 * , 6144 - 6151 ( 1992 ) garel , t. , huse , d.a . ,
leibler , l. & orland , h. _ europhys .
* 8 * , 9 - 12 ( 1989 ) maritan , a. , riva , m.p .
& trovato , a. _ j. phys .
gen . _ * 32 * , l275-l280 ( 1999 ) taketomi , h. , ueda , y. & go , n. _ int . j. pept .
protein res . _ * 7 * , 445 - 459 ( 1975 ) .
guo , z. & thirumalai , d. _ journal of molecular biology _ * 263 * , 323 - 343 ( 1996 ) takada , s. , luthey - schulten , z. & wolynes , p.g .
_ jour . of chem .
phys . _ * 110 * , 11616 - 11629 ( 1999 ) geroff , i. , milchev , a. , binder , k. & paul , w. _ j. chem .
phys . _ * 98 * , 6256 - 6539 ( 1993 ) .
m. c. tesi , van rensburg , e.j . ,
orlandini , e. & whittington , s. g. _ j. stat .
* 29 * , 2451 - 2463 ( 1996 ) .
ferrenberg , a. m. & swendsen , r. h. _ phys .
* 63 * , 1195 - 1198 ( 1989 ) .
1truecm acknowldgements we thank cristian micheletti for fruitful discussions and steve white for a critical reading of the manuscript and for many enlightening suggestions .
this work was supported by infm ( pais project ) , murst - cofin99 , nasa and the donors of the petroleum research fund administered by the american physical society .
* figure 1 : * structure and thermodynamics of the helical transmembrane protein . + * a ) * ribbon representation of the two - helix fragment of bacteriorhodopsin formed by the first @xmath1 amino - acids . the part inside the membrane ( determined by using the neural network learning algorithm available at http://www.embl-heidelberg.de/services/sander/predictprotein/ ) is shown in red , the part above ( below ) the membrane in blue ( green ) . *
b ) * average equilibrium fraction of native contacts outside , @xmath11 ( @xmath104 ) , inside , @xmath10 ( @xmath105 ) , and across , @xmath12 ( @xmath106 ) , the membrane as a function of the temperature @xmath8 .
all these quantities are expressed in energy unit of @xmath61 ( see methods ) .
the folding transition temperature @xmath107 when all the curves cross the value @xmath108 is around 0.6 .
this value is in accord with the temperature of the heat capacity maxima .
* figure 2 : * schematic representation of states encountered by non - constitutive proteins during the folding process . + in * a ) * the red cylinders denote @xmath4-helices that reside within the membrane in the native state .
the region inside the membrane is in turquoise whereas the rest represents the interface region @xcite in which the folding process starts .
state @xmath19 denotes the denatured state of the protein , @xmath109 is a state in which the helices have been formed but are not yet inside the membrane whereas @xmath28 corresponds to a similar state but with the helices completely embedded in the membrane without any inter - helical contacts .
usually the helices form and enter into the membrane separately .
@xmath35 denotes an obligatory intermediate and @xmath110 depicts the native state .
the state @xmath53 represents an ensemble of long lived conformations in which helices are formed inside the membrane with several inter - helical contacts , but with the two @xmath4-helices still incorrectly positioned .
this conformations differ in term of packing efficiency of the helices .
the state @xmath111 is not obligatory for the folding kinetics . in * b ) *
the schematic pathways to the native state are shown . in the most directed path ,
the entropy decreases on going from @xmath19 to @xmath110 . from @xmath28
to @xmath35 the entropy loss of one helix is not compensated by a corresponding energy gain until both helices become vertical .
this is the principal origin of the high free energy barrier between the state @xmath28 and the native state .
* figure 3 : * typical time dependence of different parameters as a function of the monte - carlo steps for the pathway @xmath112 .
fraction of native contacts inside the membrane ( * a * ) , normalized z - coordinate of the center of mass of the protein ( with respect to that of the native state conformation ) ( * b * ) and overall fraction of native helical contacts ( * c * ) .
each monte - carlo step corresponds to 50000 attempted local deformations .
the transition from state @xmath28 to state @xmath35 is signalled by a sharp jump of the position of the center of mass .
note that there is no perceptible sign of this transition in terms of newly formed native contacts .
most of the helical contacts are formed in the early stages of the folding .
this fraction does not significantly increase until helices correctly assemble and the inter - helical contacts are formed .
the @xmath113 transition is reached by a progressive zippering of the horizontal and vertical helices .
this zippering is usually very quick ( few mc steps ) and is only slightly slowed down ( see the plateau corresponding to @xmath114 in * a * ) when the trajectory passes through somewhat deformed conformations .
( * d * ) protein conformations at different times during the folding .
the colours red , green and blue have the same significance as in figure 1a with the grey bonds being ones crossing the membrane .
* figure 4 : * distribution of the fraction of native contacts inside the membrane + ( * a * ) and of the normalized @xmath50-coordinate of the center of mass ( @xmath115 ) ( * b * ) .
the data were obtained using 40 independent kinetic simulations with pathway @xmath112 .
the grey scale distribution indicates the probabilities at given times : darker points denote higher probability .
* figure 5 : * free energy profiles along three reaction coordinates at t=0.85 t@xmath25 .
the continuous lines are spline fits to the free energy data ( crosses ) . to obtain free energy differences between two states
we estimate the reversible work that has be done to go from one state to the other . for this purpose
, we fix the z coordinate of a specific residue in order to compute the canonical average of the force and then apply eq .
( 2 ) ( see methods ) .
the free energy of the native state is defined to be equal to 0 .
( * a * ) free energy as a function of the @xmath50-coordinate of the 58-th residue ( @xmath116 corresponds to the middle of the membrane ) starting from hv ; this forces the second helix to cross the membrane as the protein goes from hv to n ; the local minimum at z@xmath11720 corresponds to a state topologically equivalent to hv , with the helix containing the 58-th residue fully formed on the membrane interface but without any contact with the first helix ( in hv some of the inter - helices contacts are already formed ) ; ( * b * ) the 5-th residue is translocated across the membrane with the protein starting from state hi and proceeding to hv ; ( * c * ) the same as in ( * b * ) , but the initial state is i ( see fig . | nearly a quarter of genomic sequences and almost half of all receptors that are likely to be targets for drug design @xcite are integral membrane proteins .
understanding the detailed mechanisms of the folding of membrane proteins is a largely unsolved , key problem in structural biology . here
, we introduce a general model and use computer simulations to study the equilibrium properties and the folding kinetics of a @xmath0-based two helix bundle fragment ( comprised of @xmath1 amino - acids ) of bacteriorhodopsin .
various intermediates are identified and their free energy are calculated toghether with the free energy barrier between them . in @xmath2 of folding trajectories ,
the folding rate is considerably increased by the presence of non - obligatory intermediates acting as traps . in all cases , a substantial portion of the helices
is rapidly formed .
this initial stage is followed by a long period of consolidation of the helices accompanied by their correct packing within the membrane .
our results provide the framework for understanding the variety of folding pathways of helical transmembrane proteins . #
1#2 # # 1##2#2##1 0.3 cm -1truecm considerable effort has been expended to understand the dynamics of the folding and biological functionality of proteins . whereas the behavior of small water soluble globular proteins is reasonably well understood
both experimentally and theoretically @xcite , much less is known about membrane proteins ( mp ) @xcite that cross biological membranes .
transmembrane proteins ( tmp ) are the most important and best studied class of mp @xcite .
they are characterized by the presence in their primary structure of long segments ( @xmath3 ) of amino acids with a high degree of hydrophobicity . in the native structure , these correspond to the transmembrane segments which are inserted in the lipidic interior of the membrane @xcite .
these segments are predominantly made up of @xmath4-helices and @xmath5-sheets .
the stability of @xmath4-helices and @xmath5-sheets inside the membrane follow from the formation of hydrogen bonds between the backbone atoms other possibilities are excluded within the apolar enviroment @xcite .
phenomenological models have proved to be powerful for interpreting experimental data .
the most common of these is the _ two - stage model _ based on experimental evidence that the folding of tmp occurs in two stages . in the first stage ,
@xmath4-helices and @xmath5-sheets are formed with the full native state structure being formed in a distinct second stage @xcite .
a more refined model@xcite takes into account four main steps : partitioning , folding , insertion and association .
recently , pappu et al .
@xcite have used a potential smoothing algorithm to predict transmembrane helix packing in good accord with experimental data .
milik and skolnick @xcite have carried out careful monte carlo studies of the insertion of peptide chains into lipid membranes and have proposed a new hydropathy scale based on experimental data obtained by studying the interactions of tripeptides with phospholipid membranes@xcite and the self - solvation effect in protein systems@xcite .
recently wimley and white@xcite have designed transmembrane peptides that spontaneously insert across bilayers but yet have measurable monomeric water stability , opening the way for the determination of the thermodynamic cost of partitioning hydrogen bonded peptide bonds into the membrane hydrocarbon core .
the monte - carlo results of milik and skolnick@xcite are in good accord with engelman and steitz s helical hairpin hypothesis@xcite further extended by jacobs and white@xcite .
the unfolded chain is first adsorbed onto the membrane interface , driven mostly by the hydrophobic effect and electrostatic lipid - protein interactions @xcite .
a polypeptide chain has a greater possibility , while anchored to the interface , of saturating its internal hydrogen bonds and forming helices .
such helical fragments have a greater propensity to subsequently diffuse into the lipid phase .
a detailed study of tmp has not yet been possible because little is known about the interactions between amino acids inside the membrane or between them and the lipid molecules . here
, we adopt a simple , yet powerful , strategy for attacking the folding properties of tmp that circumvents this shortcoming .
our novel approach is based on extensive studies of the folding of globular proteins which have underscored the important role played by the topology of the native state in controlling both the functionality and the main features of the folding process .
nature uses a rich repertory of twenty kinds of amino acids with sometimes major and at other times subtle differences in their interactions with the solvent and with each other in order to design sequences that fit the putative native state with minimal frustration @xcite .
thus a fruitful and general strategy for the study of protein folding would be to extract information on the folding process directly from the topology of the native state . our study here focuses on the folding process by using a tractable approach ( described in the methods section ) that by - passes the details of the complex interactions of the protein in the lipid enviroment by introducing effective potentials , induced by the presence of the membrane and the associated interface region , that stabilize the native state structure .
the validity of the approach based on the native state topology , in the case of globular proteins , has been confirmed a posteriori from the agreement between theory and experimental findings @xcite .
the approach proposed here is similar in spirit and ought to be a tool and a guide for the difficult experimental situation of tmp@xcite .
our model allows a complete characterization of the thermodynamics and the dynamics of the full folding process . due to the small number of degrees of freedom involved
, the dynamics of the system can be simulated for the full folding process .
moreover , the free energies of the most relevant intermediate states and free energy profiles along the reaction paths connecting them can be explicitly calculated by thermodynamic integration ( see methods ) .
thus the model is able to quantitatively discriminate between the possible reaction paths envisaged for the insertion process of tmp across the membrane@xcite , a feature that is not an obvious consequence of the structure of the model .
where there is overlap , our model captures the qualitative features of the earlier simulations of milik and skolnick@xcite .
the tmp we considered is made up of the first 66 amino acids of bacteriorhodopsin consisting of two @xmath6-helices ( fig .
@xmath7 ) .
it has been shown that the first two helices of bacteriorhodopsin can be considered as independent folding domains@xcite .
furthermore , the side - by - side interactions between transmembrane helices play a key role in the stabilization of the protein structure@xcite .
our studies were carried out using a monte carlo algorithm that has been proven to be extremely efficient for interacting hetero - polymers ( methods ) .
the behaviour of the structural similarity between the system equilibrated at temperature @xmath8 ( measured in dimensionless units ) and the native state is shown in figure @xmath9 in terms of the average fraction of native state contacts as a function of @xmath8 and partitioned depending on their positions with respect to the membrane .
the three curves correspond respectively to the average fraction of native contacts inside ( @xmath10 ) , outside ( @xmath11 ) and across ( @xmath12 ) the membrane ( see methods ) .
all these curves , well separated at high t , collapse for @xmath8 below the transition temperature @xmath13 , indicating a cooperative effect in the folding . on monitoring the free energy as a function of the energy around @xmath14 , one observes additional local minima ( besides those corresponding to the unfolded and folded states ) suggesting the presence of an intermediate .
the intermediate is characterized by having the two helices almost completely formed but not yet correctly inserted across the membrane . a metastable state in which the protein exists at the membrane interface ought to be expected on general grounds .
indeed a generic heteropolymer with hydrophobic and hydrophilic aminoacids , of which a tmp is a particular case , has a favorable conformation which is localized near surfaces between two selective media ( the outside and the inside part of the membrane in the present case)@xcite . at not too high temperatures , the gain in energy to place hydrophobic / hydrophilic protein segments in their preferred enviroment compensates the entropy loss for being localized at the interface with respect to remain in the bulk phase .
thus , even though our model does not explicitly contain information on the character of the amino acids , it is able to predict this feature .
the presence of these extra minima suggests that non - constitutive membrane proteins would fold with multi - state kinetics corresponding to on - pathway intermediates . to establish their nature of and their influence on the dominant folding pathways
, we have performed a detailed analysis of the folding kinetics .
each independent kinetic folding simulation was started with the equilibrated denaturated state at @xmath15 .
the protein is placed initially outside the membrane in the interface region @xcite , at a distance comparable to the average size of the denatured protein and then suddenly quenched to a temperature ( @xmath16 ) well below the transition temperature .
this case simulates the folding kinetics of non - constitutive membrane proteins , i.e. proteins that do not need a translocon providing a tunnel through which the protein is injected into the lipid bilayer .
folding to the native state occurs mainly through the states depicted in figure @xmath17 with the dominant pathways shown in figure @xmath18 . in all the pathways
, the system goes from the unfolded state , @xmath19 to state @xmath20 in which @xmath21 of the secondary structure is formed ( see @xmath22 in figure @xmath23 ) and disposed horizontally along the interface .
the free energy of this state ( measured with respect to the free energy of the fully folded state ) is @xmath24 t@xmath25 .
this state corresponds to the formation of around @xmath26 of the membrane contacts .
the average time @xmath27 to reach state @xmath28 is of the order of @xmath29 monte carlo steps ( see figures @xmath30 and @xmath31 ; each monte - carlo step corresponds to 50000 attempted local deformations . ) .
state hi turns out to be an obligatory on - pathway intermediate of the folding kinetics for non - constitutive mp in agreement with the general argument mentioned above .
once the protein reaches state @xmath28 , it undergoes a relatively slow process of self - arrangement in order to insert and assemble the secondary structures across the membrane .
this process is the rate - limiting step of the folding process , since it involves the translocation , through the lipidic layer , of a substantial number of hydrophilic residues . among the possible pathways , starting from @xmath28 , the most frequent ( @xmath32 of the cases ) and the fastest turn out to be @xmath33 .
a quantitative characterization of this dominant pathway is presented in figures 3 ( for a single folding process ) and 4 ( as an average over @xmath34 folding processes ) .
the intermediate @xmath35 is characterized by having one @xmath6 helix inserted across the membrane and is reached in an average period corresponding to a significant fraction of the total folding time ( see figure @xmath30 ) .
the free energy in this state is @xmath36 @xmath37 the free energy barrier between @xmath38 and @xmath35 is at @xmath39 @xmath40 @xmath14 ( hence , the rate constant of the transition @xmath41 is proportional to @xmath42 ) . the full free energy profile versus a reaction coordinate is shown in fig .
5 .
the last part of the folding process corresponds to the insertion of the second helix and the assembly of the two secondary structures into the native state structure .
this process lasts approximately one third of the folding time along the pathway @xmath43 .
the quasistatic free energy barrier between @xmath35 and the folded state is @xmath44 @xmath45 @xmath14 .
the rate costant of the transition @xmath46 is , therefore , proportional to @xmath47 .
these results are consistent with the time scales observed in the unconstrained folding dynamics . at the end , the protein is completely packed , ( @xmath10 saturates to 1 ( figures @xmath48 and @xmath49 ) ) and the helices are correctly positioned across the membrane ( note the second jump in the @xmath50 coordinate of the center of mass in figures @xmath51 and @xmath52 ) .
much slower dynamics can occur when non - obligatory intermediates are visited by the system .
these long lived states ( @xmath53 in figure @xmath17 ) involve a distribution of misfolded regions that trap the system and are characterized by having most of the inter - helical contacts formed ( assembly of the secondary structures ) but with the two @xmath54-helices still incorrectly positioned .
note , for example , that in states @xmath53 , only transmembrane contacts and some contacts outside the membrane are misplaced and they account for only a small fraction of the native state energy . for this reason , in the states @xmath55 , the free energy is @xmath39
@xmath56 @xmath14 , only slightly higher than the free energy of @xmath35 .
the folding can proceed from @xmath57 either by disentangling the two helices and passing through the obligatory intermediate @xmath35 , or by the simultaneous translocation through the membrane of the two helices .
these processes , however , entail the crossing of a big free energy barrier ( @xmath39 @xmath58 @xmath14 for the first process and @xmath59 for the second ) and happen with low probability .
indeed , at sufficiently low temperatures , the loss in energy of the interhelical contacts is not compensated by the gain in the configurational entropy due to the uncoupling of the @xmath60helices .
thus below the folding temperature , i - states act as trapping regions for the system and when trapped , the protein spends most of the time during folding in this state . in summary , we have presented detailed calculations of helical transmembrane proteins leading to a vivid picture of the folding process .
our strategy relies on the dominant role played by the topology of the native state structure and by the effective geometry imposed by the membrane and provides a picture which would be expected to be quite accurate for well - designed sequences that are a good fit to the target native state conformation .
it is interesting to note that , with our choice of the parameters , the pathway in which the helices assemble outside the membrane and are inserted later is unlikely to occur .
models based on the topology of the native state structure have been remarkably successful @xcite in correctly describing the main features of the folding process determined in experiments @xcite for various globular proteins .
a similar approach has been generalized here to the almost virgin field of transmembrane proteins where experiments are rather difficult@xcite .
our findings do not depend on the precise values of the @xmath61 parameters introduced in the model underscoring the robustness of the results .
our approach predicts a folding process involving multiple pathways with a dominant folding channel .
the simpliciy of our model allows for a quantitative description of all the pathways since we can monitor the correct / uncorrect formation of native contacts and compute free energy profiles .
further details not captured by the present approach arising from amino - acid specific interactions among themselves , with the solvent and in particular with the interior of the membrane may of course change the quantitative nature of the results .
however , our model , which captures the bare essentials of a membrane protein , ought to provide a zeroth order picture of the folding process .
also , as experimental data becomes available , the results could be benchmarked with models of this type to glean the other factors that matter . |
luc moreau is a postdoctoral fellow of the fund for scientific research - flanders . work done while a recipient of an honorary fellowship of the belgian american educational foundation , while visiting the princeton university mechanical and aerospace engineering department .
this paper presents research results of the belgian programme on inter - university poles of attraction , initiated by the belgian state , prime minister s office for science , technology and culture .
the scientific responsibility rests with its authors . | some biological systems operate at the critical point between stability and instability and this requires a fine - tuning of parameters .
we bring together two examples from the literature that illustrate this : neural integration in the nervous system and hair cell oscillations in the auditory system . in both examples
the question arises as to how the required fine - tuning may be achieved and maintained in a robust and reliable way .
we study this question using tools from nonlinear and adaptive control theory .
we illustrate our approach on a simple model which captures some of the essential features of neural integration . as a result
, we propose a large class of feedback adaptation rules that may be responsible for the experimentally observed robustness of neural integration .
we mention extensions of our approach to the case of hair cell oscillations in the ear .
persistent neural activity is prevalent throughout the nervous system .
numerous experiments have demonstrated that persistent neural activity is correlated with short - term memory .
a prominent example concerns the oculomotor system
see @xcite for a review and experimental facts .
the brain moves the eyes with quick saccadic movements . between saccades , it keeps the eyes still by generating a continuous and constant contraction of the eye muscles ; thus requiring a constant level of neural activity in the motor neurons controlling the eye muscles .
this constant neural activity level serves as a short - term memory for the desired eye position . during a saccade
, a brief burst of neural activity in premotor command neurons induces a persistent change in the neural activity of the motor neurons , via a mechanism equivalent to integration in the sense of calculus .
neural activity of an individual neuron , however , has a natural tendency to decay with a relaxation time of the order of milliseconds .
therefore the question arises as to how a transient stimulus can cause persistent changes in neural activity . according to a long - standing hypothesis , persistent neural activity
is maintained by synaptic feedback loops .
positive feedback can oppose the tendency of a pattern of neural activity to decay .
if the feedback is weak , then the natural tendency to decay dominates and neural activity decays . as the feedback strength is increased , the neural dynamics undergo a bifurcation and become unstable .
when the feedback is tuned to exactly balance the decay , then neural activity neither increases nor decreases but persists without change .
this , however , requires a fine - tuning of the synaptic feedback strength and the question arises as to how a biological system can achieve and maintain this fine - tuning @xcite . some gradient descent and function approximation algorithms performing this fine - tuning
have been proposed @xcite and a feedback learning mechanism based on differential anti - hebbian synaptic plasticity has been studied in @xcite .
nevertheless , it is still unclear how the required fine - tuning is physiologically feasible . for this reason , a different model for neural integration based upon bistability
has recently been proposed in @xcite . in the present paper
, we do not follow the line of research based upon bistability .
instead , we pursue the hypothesis of precisely tuned synaptic feedback .
the present paper proposes an adaptation mechanism that may be responsible for the fine - tuning of neural integrators and that may explain the experimentally observed robustness of neural integrators with respect to perturbations .
before we present this adaptation mechanism in detail , we first discuss a similar phenomenon in the auditory system . in order to detect the sounds of the outside world , hair cells in the cochlea operate as nanosensors which transform acoustic stimuli into electric signals .
in @xcite these hair cells are described as active systems capable of generating spontaneous oscillations .
ions such as @xmath0 are believed to contribute to the hair cell s tendency to self - oscillate . for low concentrations of the ions ,
damping forces dominate and the hair cell oscillations are damped .
as the concentration increases the system undergoes a hopf bifurcation , the dynamics become unstable , and the hair cells exhibit spontaneous oscillations . in @xcite
the hair cells are postulated to operate near the critical point , where the activity of the ions exactly compensates for the damping effects . as before , this requires a fine - tuning of parameters ( the ion concentrations ) and again the question arises as to how this fine - tuning can be achieved and maintained . in @xcite
a feedback mechanism has been proposed which could be responsible for maintaining this fine - tuning .
it thus seems that operating in the vicinity of a bifurcation is a recurrent theme in biology . and
the question as to how proximity to the bifurcation point may be achieved and maintained in a noisy environment may be of considerable , general interest .
we view the two presented examples as special instances of the following general problem .
consider a forced dynamical system , described by a differential equation @xmath1 .
the right - hand side of this equation depends on a parameter @xmath2 and the unforced dynamics @xmath3 are assumed to exhibit a bifurcation when @xmath2 equals a critical value @xmath4 .
the problem consists of finding a feedback adaptation rule for the parameter @xmath2 which guarantees proximity to the bifurcation point ; that is , which steers @xmath2 toward its critical value @xmath4 .
this adaptation law may depend on @xmath2 and @xmath5 but should be independent of @xmath4 , since this critical value is not known precisely .
this abstract formulation captures common features of both biological examples and suggests some unexpected links with the literature .
questions very similar to the present one have been studied extensively in the literature on adaptive control @xcite and stabilization @xcite ; and the general problem is closely related to extremum seeking @xcite , and to instability detection @xcite , where an operating parameter is adapted on - line in order to experimentally locate bifurcations .
although the above general formulation is convenient , there is little hope that a complete and satisfactory theory can be developed that applies to all possible instances of the problem . simplifying assumptions
make it more tractable . in this letter
, we study in detail what is probably the most simple but nontrivial instance of the general problem .
we consider the one - dimensional system @xmath6 which captures some of the essential features of neural integration and is in fact closely related to the autapse model from @xcite . with this interpretation
, @xmath5 is a strictly positive variable representing neural activity in the integrator network and @xmath7 represents the signal generated by the premotor command neurons .
the term @xmath8 corresponds to the natural decay of neural activity and @xmath9 represents a positive , synaptic feedback loop .
of course , when studying neural integration , questions can be investigated at varying levels of detail .
it is clear that a simple model as ( [ e : ni ] ) has several limitations .
because of its one - dimensional nature , the present model is , for example , unable of reproducing the distributed nature of persistent activity patterns observed in the brain .
nevertheless , eq . ( [ e : ni ] ) captures a key feature of neural integration : when the feedback is tuned to exactly balance the decay , eq .
( [ e : ni ] ) behaves as an integrator and produces persistent neural activity .
eq .
( [ e : ni ] ) is therefore a valuable model when studying fine - tuning of neural integrator networks @xcite .
we are interested in the fine - tuning of eq .
( [ e : ni ] ) and study this question using tools from nonlinear and adaptive control theory .
first , we ignore the presence of the input @xmath7 and consider the simpler equation @xmath10 we present a large class of feedback adaptation laws for ( [ e : pa ] ) which steer @xmath2 to its critical value @xmath4 ; thus enabling the automatic self - tuning of parameters and the spontaneous generation of persistent neural activity .
we consider adaptation laws could come from synaptic plasticity . in particular , the term @xmath11 might be related to types of synaptic plasticity that depend on the temporal ordering of presynaptic and postsynaptic spiking , as in @xcite .
] of the form @xmath12 we show that , under three very mild conditions , this adaptation rule guarantees convergence to the bifurcation point for ( [ e : pa ] ) .
the first condition requires that @xmath13 is a strictly increasing function .
this means that the term @xmath14 in ( [ e : adaptation ] ) acts as a negative feedback . as a consequence , if the neural activity @xmath5 were constant in ( [ e : adaptation ] ) , then the synaptic feedback gain @xmath2 would naturally relax to a rest value depending on @xmath5 via the equation @xmath15 .
the second condition states that there exists @xmath16 such that @xmath17 .
this condition implies that , if the neural activity would be constant and equal to @xmath16 in ( [ e : adaptation ] ) , then the synaptic feedback gain @xmath2 would naturally relax to its critical , desired value @xmath4 .
of course there is no guarantee that the neural activity would be equal to , or even converge to , this special value @xmath16 . instead
, the level of neural activity is governed by eq .
( [ e : pa ] ) . therefore , in order for the adaptation law ( [ e : adaptation ] ) to work , we need to impose a last condition , that @xmath18 is a decreasing function .
this means that the level of neural activity negatively regulates the synaptic feedback strength .
we now show that , under these three conditions , the feedback adaptation law ( [ e : adaptation ] ) indeed tunes the synaptic feedback gain @xmath2 to exactly balance the natural decay rate @xmath4 .
we begin with noticing that the combined system of equations ( [ e : pa])([e : adaptation ] ) has a unique rest point .
this equilibrium is determined by setting the right - hand sides of ( [ e : pa])([e : adaptation ] ) equal to zero , yielding @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
although the precise value of @xmath4 is unknown , if we are able to prove that all trajectories of ( [ e : pa])([e : adaptation ] ) converge to this ( unknown ) fixed point , then it follows that @xmath2 indeed converges to its desired , critical value @xmath4 . in order to prove this
, we introduce a coordinate transformation @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
this transforms ( [ e : pa])([e : adaptation ] ) into @xmath23 and @xmath24 . in these new coordinates ,
the dynamics take the form of a nonlinear mass - spring - damper system ( with unit mass , nonlinear spring characteristic @xmath25 and nonlinear damping function @xmath26 ) .
it follows from physical energy considerations that this system exhibits damped oscillations @xcite .
this shows that all trajectories of ( [ e : pa])([e : adaptation ] ) indeed converge to the unique fixed point , where @xmath20 .
the above coordinate transformation reveals a subtle relationship between self - tuning of bifurcations and the internal model principle ( `` imp '' ) from robust control theory ( see @xcite for a discussion of the imp from a systems biology perspective ) .
this relation is made explicit by the equation @xmath23 , which represents an integrator and corresponds to integral action studied in robust control theory .
one regards the constant @xmath4 as an unknown perturbation acting on the system .
the imp implies that , in order to track this constant perturbation , the system dynamics should contain integral action .
the integral action is generated by the biological system itself , and not by the feedback adaptation law .
we have so far ignored the presence of the signal @xmath7 .
we showed that the adaptation law ( [ e : adaptation ] ) tunes the synaptic feedback gain to exactly compensate for the natural decay rate , resulting in the spontaneous generation of persistent neural activity . at these equilibrium conditions ,
the action potential firing rate equals @xmath16 , which is related to @xmath4 by @xmath17 . in the next paragraphs
, we take into account the effect of the input @xmath7 . in this case
, the value @xmath16 will play the role of a parameter that influences the accuracy with which the feedback adaptation law guarantees proximity to the bifurcation point .
the signal @xmath7 will in general result in a time - varying action potential firing rate @xmath27 .
the mechanism with which this happens , is determined by the neural integrator equation ( [ e : ni ] ) and the adaptation law ( [ e : adaptation ] ) . for the purpose of analysis ,
we make two simplifying assumptions , both of which seem to be natural and physically relevant for neural integration .
first , we assume that , over any sufficiently large time interval @xmath28 $ ] , the time spent by @xmath27 in any interval @xmath29 $ ] is approximately independent of @xmath30 . in more mathematical terms , we assume the existence of a function @xmath31 such that for every test function @xmath32 , the time average @xmath33 converges to @xmath34 as @xmath35 , uniformly with respect to @xmath30 .
secondly , we assume that the adaptation law acts on a much slower time scale than the time variations in @xmath27 . under these assumptions ,
the effect of the action potential firing rate @xmath27 on the adaptation law ( [ e : adaptation ] ) may be approximated by the average effect @xmath36 .
it is now clear when the adaptation law guarantees proximity to the bifurcation point : if the compatibility condition @xmath37 is satisfied , then time scale separation arguments suggest that @xmath2 will converge approximately to @xmath4 and the neural integrator will approximately behave as a perfect integrator .
the compatibility condition may by interpreted as follows @xcite . when the premotor command signal @xmath7 has zero time - average and the adaptation law acts on a slow time scale , then eq .
( [ e : ni ] ) behaves as a good integrator and the firing rate @xmath27 equals the time - integral of @xmath7 plus an integration constant .
the compatibility condition ensures that this integration constant is compatible with the desired range for the firing rate @xmath27 .
we illustrate this result on a particular example representative for saccadic eye movements .
we consider the case of periodic saccadic eye movements asking for an action potential firing rate in the motor neurons alternating between @xmath38 and @xmath39 every second . at each saccade
, a brief burst of neural activity in premotor command neurons changes the actual firing rate .
we assume that this change is such that immediately after each saccade , the actual firing rate equals the desired firing rate . between saccades
, we assume that no input is applied . at its desired level between saccades ,
which is consistent with experimental observations . ]
if the neural integrator is perfectly tuned , then the actual firing rate will remain constant between saccades and equal to the desired firing rate ( eyes are fixed ) .
if the neural integrator is not perfectly tuned , then the actual firing rate will deviate from the desired firing rate ( eyes drift ) until a new saccade occurs which brings the actual firing rate to its new desired value .
fig .
[ f2 ] shows the results of a simulation where the adaptation law satisfies the compatibility condition of the previous paragraph . in the beginning of the simulation
, we have mis - tuned the neural integrator .
clearly , after a short transient , the adaptation law achieves excellent tuning and the drift between two successive saccades becomes negligible .
we have thus shown that an adaptation law can tune a neural integrator with great accuracy to its bifurcation point . in order to achieve perfect tuning
, however , the adaptation law itself needs to satisfy a compatibility condition .
it seems that we have merely moved the problem of fine - tuning from the neural integrator to the adaptation law . the crucial observation and one of the main contributions of the present paper , however , is that this results in a significant decrease in sensitivity . _
the adaptation law is robust with respect to perturbations in its parameters . _ in order to illustrate this significant increase in robustness , let us first summarize the well - known @xcite sensitivity properties of neural integration .
experiments suggest that the actual time constant obtained in a tuned neural integrator circuit is typically greater than @xmath40 ; that is , @xmath41 .
this requires for the fine - tuning of @xmath2 a relative precision @xmath42 ranging from @xmath43 to @xmath44 , depending on whether the intrinsic time constant @xmath45 equals @xmath46 or @xmath47 ( typical values suggested in the literature ) . the required precision for @xmath2
should be contrasted with the required precision for the parameters of the adaptation law proposed in the present paper .
the simulations of fig .
[ f3 ] show that , in order to have @xmath41 as observed in experiments , the parameters of the adaptation law need to be tuned with a precision of @xmath48 , independent of the intrinsic time constant @xmath45 . comparing this with the originally required precision for the synaptic feedback strength @xmath2
, we conclude that _ the proposed adaptation mechanism could improve the robustness of neural integration with a factor ranging from @xmath49 to @xmath50_. we have studied a simple model for neural integration and proposed a class of feedback adaptation rules that could explain the experimentally observed robustness of neural integration with respect to perturbations . the analysis tools that we have introduced extend to the study of fine - tuning involved in other systems such as hair cell oscillations in the ear @xcite .
consider the nonlinear oscillator equation @xmath51 , which captures some of the essential features of hair cell oscillations @xcite .
inspired by our previous analysis , we consider a feedback adaptation law for the parameter @xmath2 of the form @xmath52 , with @xmath53 a positive variable characterizing the magnitude of oscillations and related to @xmath5 and @xmath54 via the expression @xmath55 .
fig .
[ f4 ] shows that , in the absence of the stimulus @xmath7 , this type of adaptation law is indeed able to bring and keep the bifurcation parameter close to its critical value , resulting in the spontaneous generation of oscillations . |
in this paper , we present a formal analysis of electromagnetic ( em ) radiative corrections to @xmath0 transitions .. see however ref .
@xcite ] only em corrections to the dominant octet nonleptonic hamiltonian are considered .
such corrections modify not only the original @xmath3 amplitude but also induce @xmath4 contributions as well . by the standards of particle physics ,
this subject is very old @xcite . yet
, there exists in the literature no satisfactory theoretical treatment .
this is due largely to complications of the strong interactions at low energy .
fortunately , the modern machinary of the standard model , especially the method of chiral lagrangians , provides the means to perform an analysis which is both correct and structurally complete .
that doing so requires no fewer than _ eight _ distinct chiral langrangians is an indication of the complexity of the undertaking .
there is , however , a problem with the usual chiral lagrangian methodology . the cost of implementing its calculational scheme is the introduction of many unknown constants , the finite counterterms associated with the regularization of divergent contributions .
as regards em corrections to nonleptonic kaon decay , it is impractical to presume that these many unknowns will be inferred phenomenologically in the reasonably near future , or perhaps ever . as a consequence , in order to obtain an acceptable phenomenological description , it will be necessary to proceed beyond the confines of strict chiral perturbation theory . in a previous publication @xcite
, we succeeded in accomplishing this task in a limited context , @xmath5 decay in the chiral limit .
we shall extend this work to a full phenomenological treatment of the @xmath0 decays in the next paper @xcite of this series .
the proper formal analysis , which is the subject of this paper , begins in sect . 2 where we briefly describe the construction of @xmath6 decay amplitudes in the presence of electromagnetic corrections .
in section 3 , we begin to implement the chiral program by specifying the collection of strong and electroweak chiral lagrangians which bear on our analysis .
the calculation of @xmath6 decay amplitudes is covered in section 4 and our concluding remarks appear in section 5
. .1 cm 0.2 cm
there are three physical @xmath6 decay amplitudes , is defined via @xmath7 . ]
_ k^0 ^+ ^- _ + - , _ k^0 ^0 ^0 _ 00 , _
k^+ ^+ ^0 _ + 0 .
[ a0 ] we consider first these amplitudes in the limit of exact isospin symmetry and then identify which modifications must occur in the presence of electromagnetism . in the @xmath8 two - pion isospin basis
, it follows from the unitarity constraint that _ + - & = & a_0 e^i _ 0 + a_2 e^i _ 2 , + a_00 & = & a_0 e^i _ 0 - a_2 e^i _ 2 , [ a1 ] + a_+0 & = & 3 2 a_2 e^i _ 2 .
the phases @xmath9 and @xmath10 are just the @xmath8 pion - pion scattering phase shifts ( watson s theorem ) , and in a cp - invariant world the moduli @xmath11 and @xmath12 are real - valued . the large ratio @xmath13 is associated with the @xmath3 rule . when electromagnetism is turned on ,
several new features appear : 1 .
charged external legs experience mass shifts ( _ cf _ fig .
[ fig : f1](a ) ) .
photon emission ( _ cf _ fig . [ fig : f1](b ) ) occurs off charged external legs .
this effect is crucial to the cancelation of infrared singularities .
final state coulomb rescattering ( _ cf _ fig .
[ fig : f1](c ) ) occurs in @xmath14 .
4 . there are structure - dependent hadronic effects , hidden in fig . 1 within the large dark vertices .
in this paper , we consider the leading contributions ( see fig .
[ fig : f2 ] ) which arise from corrections to the @xmath3 hamiltonian .
there will be modifications of the isospin symmetric unitarity relations and thus extensions of watson s theorem .
any successful explanation of em corrections to @xmath6 decays must account for all these items .
an analysis @xcite of the unitarity constraint which allows for the presence of electromagnetism yields _ + - & = & ( a_0 + a_0^em ) e^i(_0 + _ 0 ) + 1 ( a_2 + a_2^em ) e^i(_2 + _ 2 ) , + a_00 & = & ( a_0 + a_0^em ) e^i(_0 + _ 0 ) - ( a_2 + a_2^em ) e^i(_2 + _ 2 ) , [ a6 ] + a_+0 & = & 3 2 ( a_2 + a_2^+em ) e^i ( _ 2 + _
2 ) , to be compared with the isospin invariant expressions in eq . ( [ a1 ] ) .
this parameterization holds for the ir - finite amplitudes , whose proper definition is discussed later in sect . 4.3 .
observe that the shifts @xmath15 and @xmath16 in @xmath17 are distinct from the corresponding shifts in @xmath18 and @xmath19 .
this is a consequence of a @xmath20 component induced by electromagnetism . in particular
, the @xmath20 signal can be recovered via _
5/2 = 5 .
[ a6f ] .1 cm 2.8 cm
the preceding section has dealt with aspects of the @xmath6 decays which are free of hadronic complexities . in this section and
the next , we use chiral methods to address these structure - dependent contributions .
the implementation of chiral symmetry via the use of chiral lagrangians provides a logically consistent framework for carrying out a perturbative analysis . in chiral perturbation theory ,
the perturbative quantities of smallness are the momentum scale @xmath21 and the mass scale @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is the quark mass matrix .
in addition , we work to first order in the electromagnetic fine structure constant @xmath24 , _
i = a_i^(0 ) + _ i^(1 ) + .
[ c1 ] our goal is to determine the @xmath25 components @xmath26 .
the fine structure constant thus represents a second perturbative parameter , and we consider contributions of chiral orders @xmath27 and @xmath28 , _
i^(1 ) a_i^(e^2 p^0 ) + a_i^(e^2 p^2 ) .
[ c1a ] we shall restrict our attention to just the leading electromagnetic corrections to the @xmath6 amplitudes . since the weak @xmath29 amplitude is very much larger than the @xmath30 amplitude , our approach is to consider only electromagnetic corrections to @xmath29 amplitudes . as a class
these arise via processes contained in fig .
[ fig : f2 ] , where @xmath31 is the octet weak coupling defined below in eq .
( [ c6 ] ) .
we adopt standard usage in our chiral analysis , taking the matrix @xmath32 of light pseudoscalar fields and its covariant derivative @xmath33 as u ( i _ k _ k /f _ )
( k = 1, ,8 ) , d_u _ u + i e [ q , u ] a _ , [ c2 ] where @xmath34 is the quark charge matrix and @xmath35 is the photon field .
the remainder of this section summarizes the eight distinct effective lagrangians ( strong , electromagnetic , weak and electroweak ) needed in the analysis . in the @xmath36 sector
, we shall employ the strong / electromagnetic lagrangian ^(2)_str = f^2_04 ( d_u d^u^ ) + f^2_04 ( u^+ u^ ) , [ c3 ] where @xmath37 is the pseudoscalar meson decay constant in lowest order .
@xmath38 will be used to produce @xmath39 and @xmath40 vertices in our calculation .
the lagrangian @xmath38 will generate ( via tadpole diagrams ) strong self - energy effects on the external legs in the @xmath0 transitions . in order to regularize these divergent contributions ,
one employs the lagrangian @xcite @xmath41 .
it is not necessary to write out this well - known set of operators , but simply to point out that the resulting wave function renormalization factors @xmath42 and @xmath43 obey = z _
f^3 , [ c3a ] up to logarithms .
this explains the presence of @xmath44 in formulae such as eqs .
( [ d7]),([d8 ] ) in section 4 .
two other nonweak effective lagrangians enter the calculation .
the first is associated with electromagnetic effects at chiral order @xmath27 , _
ems^(0 ) = g_ems ( q u q u^ ) , [ c4 ] where the coupling @xmath45 is fixed ( in lowest chiral order ) from the pion electromagnetic mass splitting , g_ems = f_^2 2 m_^2 .
[ c5 ] the second extends the description to chiral order @xmath28 .
we need only the following subset of the lagrangian given in ref .
@xcite , & & l_ems^(2 ) = f^2 e^2 .
although the finite parts of the coefficients @xmath46 remain unconstrained , see however refs .
@xcite for model determinations .
the @xmath47 octet lagrangian begins at chiral order @xmath21 , _
8^(2 ) = g_8 ( _ 6 d_u d^u^ ) , [ c6 ] with @xmath48 fit @xcite from @xmath0 decay rates .
we use this to generate @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath27 vertices .
two chiral lagrangians will serve to provide counterterms for removing divergent contributions .
the first @xcite is the octet @xmath47 lagrangian at chiral order @xmath49 , _
8^(4 ) & = & n_5 _ 6 + & + & n_6 _ 6 u _
u^ ( ^^u - ^u^ ) + & + & n_7 _ 6 ( u ^+ u^ ) _ u ^u^ + & + & n_8 _ 6 _ u ^u^ ( u^+ ^u ) + & + & n_9 _ 6 + & + & n_10 _ 6 ( u ^u ^ + u^u^+ u ^u^ ) + & + & n_11 _ 6 ( u ^+ u^ ) ( u^+ ^u ) + & + & n_12 _ 6 ( u ^u ^ + u^u^- u ^u^ ) + & + & n_13 _ 6 ( u ^- u^ ) ( u ^- u^ ) .
[ c7 ] at present , little is known of the finite parts of the couplings @xmath50 .
the @xmath47 lagrangian at chiral order @xmath27 is _
emw^(0 ) = g_emw ( _ 6 u q u^ ) , [ c8 ] where @xmath51 is an _ a priori _ unknown coupling constant .
it has been calculated recently in ref .
@xcite , g_emw = ( -0.62 0.19 ) g_8 m_^2 .
[ c9 ] we note in passing that despite the presence of just one charge matrix @xmath52 the lagrangian of eq .
( [ c8 ] ) indeed describes @xmath53 effects .
a second factor of @xmath52 could be decomposed into a combination of the unit matrix and the @xmath54 matrix @xmath55 .
the contribution from @xmath56 would vanish , leaving the form of eq .
( [ c8 ] ) .
the second operator that we use to provide counterterm contributions is the @xmath47 lagrangian at chiral order @xmath28 . in terms of the notation @xmath57
, we have & & l_emw^(2 ) = e^2 g_8 . the first six operators in the above list appear in ref . @xcite .
the remaining three are also required for our analysis . to our knowledge
, none of the divergent or finite parts of the @xmath58 are yet known .
the leading em corrections arise from the processes of fig . [
fig : f1 ] and fig .
[ fig : f2 ] . contributions to fig .
[ fig : f2 ] occur in two distinct classes , those explicitly containing virtual photons ( fig .
[ fig : f3 ] ) and those with no explicit virtual photons ( fig .
[ fig : f4 ] ) .
the latter are induced by em mass corrections and by insertions of @xmath51 . in figs .
[ fig : f3],[fig : f4 ] , the larger bold - face vertices are where the weak interaction occurs . the integrals which occur in our chiral analysis are standard and already appear in the literature ( _ e.g. _ see ref .
@xcite or ref .
it suffices here to point out that all divergent parts of the one - loop integrals are ultimately expressible in terms of the @xmath59-dimensional integral a ( m^2 ) dk 1 k^2 - m^2 = ^d-4 , [ bpp1 ] where @xmath60 is the integration measure , @xmath61 is the scale associated with dimensional regularization and @xmath62 is the singular quantity .
[ bpp2 ] each amplitude in the discussion to follow will be expressed as a sum of a finite contribution and a singular term containing @xmath62 .
.1 cm 0.2 cm we begin with the @xmath27 amplitudes , _ + -^(e^2 p^0 ) = - f_k f_^2 ( g_8 m_^2 + g_emw ) , _ 00^(e^2 p^0 ) = 0 , _ + 0^(e^2 p^0 ) = a_+-^(e^2 p^0 ) .
[ d1 ] although these have already been determined in ref .
@xcite , we include them here for the sake of completeness .
they are finite - valued and require no regularization procedure .
next come the amplitudes of order @xmath63 , expressed as _
p^2 ) = a_i^(expl ) + a_i^(impl ) + a_i^(ct ) .
[ d2 ] the superscript ` expl ' refers to figs .
[ fig : f1](a),(c ) and fig .
[ fig : f3 ] where virtual photons are _ explicitly _ present , whereas superscript ` impl ' refers to fig .
[ fig : f4 ] where em effects are _ implicitly _ present via em mass splittings and @xmath51 insertions . the final term
@xmath64 is the counterterm amplitude .
we turn first to the class @xmath65 of explicit photonic diagrams . for these contributions ,
it is consistent to take meson masses in the isospin limit .
we find & & f_k f_^2 g_8 a_+-^(expl ) = ( m_k^2 - m_^2 ) _ + - ( m _ ) + & & + 4 - 6 ^d-4 e^2 m_k^2 , + & & f_k f_^2 g_8 a_00^(expl ) = 0 , [ d7 ] + & & f_k f_^2 g_8 a_+0^(expl ) = 4 m_^2 - 6 ^d-4 e^2 m_^2 .
the quantity @xmath66 , which appears in the above expression for @xmath67 , is associated with the processes of figs . [
fig : f1](a),(c ) . due to
such processes , the weak decay amplitudes @xmath68 will develop infrared ( ir ) singularities in the presence of electromagnetism .
to tame such behavior , an ir regulator is introduced and appears as a parameter in the amplitudes . for our work , this takes the form of a photon squared - mass @xmath69 .
@xmath66 is given by _ + - ( m_^2 ) & = & 1 4 , [ a50 ] where = ( 1 - 4 m_^2 /m_k^2 ) ^1/2 [ a50a ] and a ( ) & = & 1 + 1 + ^2 2 , + h ( ) & = & ^2 + + 2 f ( 1 + 2 ) - 2 f ( - 1 2 ) , [ a51 ] + f(x ) & = & - _ 0^x dt 1 t |1 - t| . notice that the function @xmath66 is complex , and both its real and imaginary parts have a logarithmic singularity as @xmath70 .
the solution to this problem is well known ; in order to get an infrared - finite decay rate , one has to consider the process with emission of soft _ real _ photons , whose singularity will cancel the one coming from soft _ virtual _ photons .
we shall be more explicit on this point in sect .
.1 cm 0.5 cm the amplitudes @xmath67 and @xmath71 each contain an additive divergent term ( proportional to @xmath62 ) and also depend on the arbitrary scale @xmath61 introduced in dimensional regularization of loop integrals .
both these features will require the introduction of counterterms .
next comes the class @xmath72 of diagrams in fig .
[ fig : f4 ] not containing explicit photons . for such contributions
, one must be sure to include all possible effects of chiral order @xmath27 and @xmath28 and treat the various terms in a consistent manner .
thus for the contributions to fig .
[ fig : f4 ] , isospin - invariant meson masses are used in amplitudes involving @xmath73 and @xmath74 , whereas electromagnetic mass splittings appear in amplitudes involving @xmath75 .
we write the results as sums of complex - valued finite amplitudes @xmath76 and divergent parts , essentially the amplitudes @xmath77 , _
i^(impl ) = re f_i ( ) + i i m f_i ( ) + ^d-4 d_i , ( i = + - , 00 , + 0 ) .
[ d8 ] the scale - dependence in @xmath76 comes entirely from its real part @xmath78 .
we express the @xmath79 in terms of dimensionless amplitudes @xmath80 , e f_i ( ) = _ i g_8 m_k^2 f_^2 f_k a_i^(impl ) ( ) , [ d8p ] with @xmath81 , @xmath82 .
since the @xmath83 coefficients have rather cumbersome analytic forms , we find it most convenient to express them in the compact form a_i^(impl ) ( ) = b_i^(m ) m_^2 f^2 + b_i^(g ) g f^2 + , [ d8q ] where g g_emw / g_8 .
[ d8r ] the coefficients appearing in eq .
( [ d8q ] ) are given in table 1 .
l|cccc + & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 + @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 + @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 + @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 + the finite functions also have imaginary parts @xmath103 which arise entirely from the processes in fig . [ fig : f4](c ) . from direct calculation
we find & & f_k f_^2 f^2 g_8 i m f_+- = - 16 , + & & f_k f_^2 f^2 g_8 i m f_00 = - 16 ( m_k^2 - m_^2 ) , [ d8s ] + & & f_k f_^2 f^2 g_8 i m f_+0 = 32 ( m_k^2 - 2 m_^2 ) ( m_^2 + g ) , where @xmath104 is defined in eq .
( [ a50a ] ) . as a check on our calculation
, we have verified that the above results are identical to those obtained from unitarity .
the singular parts of @xmath105 are embodied by the @xmath106-functions , & & f^2 f_k f_^2 g_8 d_+-
= m_k^2 + m_^2 , + & & f^2 f_k f_^2 g_8 d_00 = ( m_k^2 - m_^2 ) , [ d8a ] + & & f^2 f_k f_^2 g_8 d_+0 = m_k^2 + m_^2 .
to arrive at the above , we have used both the correspondence between @xmath107 and @xmath45 given in eq .
( [ c5 ] ) and also the relation m_^^2 - m_^0 ^ 2 = m_k^+^2 - m_k^0 ^ 2 , [ d8b ] in the evaluation of loop integrals .
the latter follows from dashen s theorem @xcite and is justified since terms violating dashen s theorem would begin to contribute at the higher chiral order @xmath108 .
.1 cm 0.2 cm in order to cancel the singular @xmath62-dependence in the @xmath0 amplitudes , it is necessary to calculate all possible counterterm amplitudes which can contribute .
these enter in a variety of ways , as shown in fig .
[ fig : f5 ] where the small bold - face square denotes the counterterm vertex . for figs .
[ fig : f5](a),(b ) the counterterm vertex has @xmath47 whereas in fig .
[ fig : f5](c ) it has @xmath36 . using the lagrangians @xmath109 , @xmath110 and @xmath111
we determine the counterterm amplitudes to be & & f^2 f_k f_^2 g_8 a_+-^(ct ) = + & & m_k^2 ( e^2 f^2 ( x_1 - 4 u_1 - 83 u_2 ) + m_^2 ( 8 n_7 - 4 n_8 - 4 n_9 ) ) + & & + m_^2 ( e^2 f^2 ( x_2 + 4 u_1 + 83 u_2 ) - m_^2 ( 4 n_5 + 8 n_7 + 2 n_8 ) ) , + & & f^2 f_k f_^2 g_8 a_00^(ct ) = ( m_k^2 - m_^2 ) e^2 f^2 , [ d5 ] + & & f^2 f_k f_^2 g_8 a_+0^(ct ) = m_k^2 ( e^2 f^2 x_3 - m_^2 ( 4 n_5 + 4 n_8 ) ) + & & + m_^2 ( e^2 f^2 x_4 - m_^2 ( 2 n_8 + 4 n_9 ) ) , where the @xmath112 are coefficients in the @xmath113 lagrangian @xmath109 of eq .
( [ c7 ] ) , the @xmath114 are combinations of coefficients in the @xmath115 lagrangian @xmath111 of eq .
( [ c5a ] ) , u_1 = _ 1 + _ 2 , u_2 = _ 5 + _ 6 , u_3 = -2 _ 3 + _ 4 , [ d6 ] and the @xmath116 are combinations of coefficients in the @xmath113 lagrangian @xmath110 of eq .
( [ c5a ] ) , x_1 & = & - 4 9 s_1 - 1 9 s_2 + 2 9 s_3 + 2 3 s_5 - 4 s_6 + 2 3 s_7 + s_8 + s_9 , + x_2 & = & 4 9 s_1 - 2 9 s_2 + 4 9 s_3 + 4 3 s_5 + 4 s_6 - 2 3 s_7 - s_8 - s_9 , + x_3 & = & - 2 3 s_1 - 1 3 s_2 + 4 3 s_4 + 2 3 s_5 + 2 3 s_7 , [ d6a ] + x_4 & = & 2 3 s_1 + 2 3 s_3 - 4 3 s_4 + 4 3 s_5 - 2 3 s_7 , + x_00 & = & 2 9 ( s_1 + s_2 + s_3 ) + 2 3 s_4 + s_8 + s_9 , the counterterms themselves have finite and singular parts , n_i & = & n_i ^d-4 + n_i^(r ) ( ) , + u_i & = & u_i ^d-4 + u_i^(r ) ( ) , [ d6b ] + x_i & = & x_i ^d-4 + x_i^(r ) ( ) .
the coefficients @xmath117 of the divergent parts of @xmath118 have already been specified in the literature @xcite and hence the @xmath61-dependences of @xmath119 , @xmath120 are known from the renormalization group equations .
we infer the @xmath121 coefficients in this paper by canceling divergences in the @xmath122 amplitudes . upon combining results
obtained thus far , we find the new results x_00 & = & - 13 m_^2 e^2 f^2 - 3 g e^2 f^2 , + x_1 & = & 3 + 272 m_^2 e^2 f^2 - 13 2 g e^2 f^2 , + x_2 & = & 3 - 18 m_^2 e^2 f^2 - 7 g e^2 f^2 , [ d9c ] + x_3 & = & - 73 m_^2 e^2 f^2 - 89 18 g e^2 f^2 , + x_4 & = & 6 - 2 m_^2 e^2 f^2 - 86 9 g e^2 f^2 , where we recall @xmath123 .
removal of the infrared divergence from the expression for the decay rate is achieved by taking into account the process @xmath124 . for soft photons
, whose energy is below the detector resolution @xmath125 , this process can not be experimentally distinguished from @xmath126 , so the observable quantity involves the inclusive sum over the @xmath127 and @xmath128 final states . at the order we are working ,
it is sufficient to consider just the emission of a single photon .
the amplitude for the radiative decay is given in lowest order by @xmath129 where @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the polarization and momentum of the emitted photon .
+ the infrared - finite observable decay rate is @xmath132 where @xmath133 and @xmath134 is the differential phase space factor for each process .
the infrared divergent ( ird ) part of @xmath135 is seen to be @xmath136^{2 } \int \ , d \phi_{+ - } \ \ 2 \alpha
\ , { \cal r}e { b}_{+ - } ( m_{\gamma } ) \right . \ \ . \label{v3}\ ] ] equation ( [ v3 ] ) displays explicitly the singularity and shows that the imaginary part of @xmath137 has no observable effect at this order .
this result has been shown to be true to all orders in @xmath24 @xcite .
for @xmath138 we get the following expression , up to terms of order @xmath139 , _ + - ( ) = ^2 d _ + - i_+-(m _ , ) , [ x1 ] where _ + - ( m _ , ) = , [ x2 ] with & & f ( ) = 1 + 1 + ^2 2 .
[ x3 ] from these explicit expressions of @xmath140 and @xmath141 it is easy to see that the combination @xmath142 does not depend on the infrared regulator @xmath143 . however , this combination has a dependence on the experimental resolution @xmath125 . to obtain a meaningful prediction therefore requires knowledge of the experimental treatment of soft photons
. a careful discussion of this point will appear in ref .
@xcite .
a generalization of the above considerations beyond the order @xmath144 in chpt leads to the following parameterization , _ + - ( ) = d _ + - g_+- ( ) | a_+ -^(0 ) + a_+ -^(1 ) |^2 , [ v4 ] where to first order in @xmath24 , g_+- ( ) = 1 + 2 re b_+ - ( m _ ) + i_+- ( m _ , ) .
[ v4a ] with the prescription of dropping the term proportional to @xmath145 in the photonic loop contribution , the electromagnetic amplitude @xmath146 can be read from eqs .
( [ d1]),([d7]),([d8]),([d5 ] )
. the physical amplitudes will be complex - valued functions , as dictated by unitarity .
the real parts are obtained by combining the finite loop amplitudes ( eq . ( [ d7 ] ) for @xmath147 and eqs . ( [ d8p]),([d8q ] ) along with table 1 for @xmath105 ) with the counterterm amplitudes of eq .
( [ d5 ] ) , e a_i^(e^2 p^2 ) = _ i g_8 m_k^2 f_^2 f_k .
[ d15 ] in order to make the scale - dependence of @xmath148 explicit , we write e
a_i^(loop ) = b_i + c_i .
[ d16 ] numerical determination of the above quantities will depend on @xmath31 ( obtained from ref .
@xcite ) , @xmath107 and @xmath51 ( given in eq . ( [ c9 ] ) ) .
we obtain the central values l b_+- = 11.8 10 ^ -3 , + b_00 = - 0.5 10 ^ -3 , + b_+0 = - 1.3 10 ^ -3 , l c_+- = 7.1 10 ^ -3 , + c_00 = -3.9 10 ^ -3 , + c_+0 = -2.7 10 ^ -3 . [ d17 ] the imaginary parts of the physical amplitudes can be either determined from unitarity or read off from eqs .
( [ d8]),([d8s ] ) . of most interest is the em shift in @xmath149 , as only it receives the @xmath150 ( @xmath3 ) enhancement , ( i m a_2^em ) & = & 32 , [ d17a ] where @xmath151 and @xmath152 are pion - pion t - matrix elements in the isospin basis .
the above three contributions have physically distinct origins ; the first involves the direct effect of electromagnetism on the @xmath153 decay amplitude , the second arises from final state scattering in which electromagnetism induces leakage from @xmath154 to @xmath155 , and the third is due to the shift in two - pion phase space produced by the electromagnetic mass shift @xcite .
despite the presence of many unknown finite counterterms , it is possible to apply the numerical results of eq .
( [ d17 ] ) and obtain rough estimates of the em corrections .
the reasoning is that since the physical amplitudes are independent of the scale @xmath61 , there must be compensating @xmath61-dependence between the chiral logarithms of eq .
( [ d16 ] ) and the counterterms
. therefore the counterterms must be at least of the same order - of - magnitude as the chiral logs or even larger .
we have adopted the operational procedure of assuming the counterterm contribution @xmath156 vanishes at the scale @xmath157 , and we assign an uncertainty given by @xmath158 .
this leads to the numerical values ( a_0^em ) & = & ( 0.024 0.026 ) 10 ^ -7 m_k^0 , + ( a_2^em ) & = & ( 0.015 0.022 ) 10 ^ -7 m_k^0 , + ( a_2^+em ) & = & ( - 0.005 0.005 ) 10 ^ -7 m_k^0 , [ e1 ] + a_5/2 & = & ( 0.012 0.016 ) 10 ^ -7 m_k^0 , with @xmath159 and @xmath160 .
specifically , for the em shift @xmath161 calculated in ref .
@xcite , we now have the extended result = - ( 2.0 2.2 ) % .
[ e2 ] if one allows for the uncertainty in @xmath51 in addition to those in the counterterm values , we find = - ( 2.0^+4.0_-2.2 ) % .
[ e3 ] in the numerical findings of eqs .
( [ e1])-([e3 ] ) , the error bars are seen to be almost as large or larger than the signal . in our opinion , this is the best that one can do within a strict chiral perturbation theory approach . 1 .
since the central values of the amplitudes have @xmath162 , the electromagnetic loop corrections are seen to produce @xmath20 effects , although the uncertainties of the counterterm values overwhelms the numerical result .
a phenomenological analysis @xcite based on @xmath163-wave pion - pion scattering lengths and forward dispersion relations gives @xmath164 .
yet an isospin analysis of @xmath6 decays yields @xmath165 .
presumably this difference of nearly @xmath166 can be reconciled by subtracting em effects from the @xmath6 decays .
the main em shift should be in @xmath10 as only this angle experiences a @xmath3 enhancement .
using eq .
( [ d17a ] ) to calculate the angle @xmath167 of eq .
( [ a6 ] ) , we find _ 2 = a_0^(e^0p^2 ) _
2^(e^0p^2 ) 4.5^o .
[ e4 ] this evaluation , valid at order @xmath168 , is seen to worsen the discrepancy between the two determinations . to reveal the explanation behind this puzzle requires more work .
@xcite 3 . finally , the most important implication of these estimates is that the electromagnetic shifts in @xmath12 are not large , being only a few percent .
naive estimates allow the possibility that this shift could be much larger , perhaps even being a major portion of @xmath12 .
our previous work at the leading order in the chiral expansion yielded a small effect .
one motivation of the present calculation was to see if the next order effects upset this conclusion .
our estimates show that the natural size of the shift in @xmath12 remains at the few percent level .
this has been a complicated calculation with many different lagrangians , describing different aspects of electromagnetic physics , required to obtain the full effect .
these include explicit photon loops , mass shifts in the mesons propagating in loops and the short - distance electroweak interaction .
the chiral power counting was crucial in sorting out which effects must be included for a consistent calculation .
the resulting structure is universal and model independent .
however , it is a prelude to more fully predictive applications , as there remain unknown low energy constants which are not predicted by chiral symmetry alone .
different models can be used to estimate the renormalized constants which appear in the chiral lagrangians , and these model predictions can then be readily translated into the physical amplitudes through the use of our calculation . in a following publication ,
we attempt to describe the extent that this may be accomplished using dispersive techniques to match long and short distance physics @xcite
. 99 # 1 # 2 # 3 nucl .
# 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 phys .
# 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 phys .
* # 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 phys . rev . * # 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 phys . rev .
* # 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 rev .
# 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 z. phys .
* # 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 , c. wolfe , ph.d.thesis , univ . of toronto ( 1999 )
unpublished .
for example , see f. abbud , b.w .
lee and c.n .
yang , phys . rev .
lett . * 18 * ( 1967 ) 980 ; a.a .
belavin and i.m .
narodetskii , sov .
* 8 * ( 1968 ) 568 ; a. neveu and j. scherk , phys
b27 * ( 1968 ) 384 ; a.a . belkov and v.v .
kostyuhkin , sov .
* 51 * ( 1989 ) 326 . v. cirigliano , j.f .
donoghue and e. golowich , phys .
b450 * ( 1999 ) 241 . , v. cirigliano , j.f .
donoghue and e. golowich , hep - ph/9909374 .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , nucl .
* b250 * ( 1985 ) 465 .
r. urech , nucl . phys .
* b433 * ( 1995 ) 234 .
j. bijnens and j. prades , nucl .
b490 * ( 1997 ) 239 .
r. baur and r. urech , nucl .
b499 * ( 1997 ) 319 .
b. moussallam , nucl . phys . * b504 * ( 1997 ) 381 .
g. ecker , j. kambor , and d. wyler , nucl .
b394 * ( 1993 ) 101 .
e. de rafael , nucl . phys . *
7a * ( proc
. suppl . )
( 1989 ) 1 .
j. gasser and h. leutwyler , ann .
* 158 * ( 1984 ) 142 .
e. golowich and j. kambor , nucl .
b447 * , ( 1995 ) 373 .
r. dashen , phys . rev . * 183 * , ( 1969 ) 1245 .
j. kambor , j. missimer and d. wyler , phys . lett .
* b261 * ( 1991 ) 496 .
s. weinberg , phys .
* b140 * ( 1965 ) 516 .
yennie , s.c .
frautschi and h. suura , ann .
* 13 * ( 1961 ) 379 .
e. chell and m.g .
olsson , phys .
* d48 * ( 1993 ) 4076 . | an analysis of electromagnetic corrections to the ( dominant ) octet @xmath0 hamiltonian using chiral perturbation theory is carried out .
relative shifts in amplitudes at the several per cent level are found .
+ 2.0 cm 1.5 cm vincenzo cirigliano@xmath1 , john f. donoghue@xmath2 and eugene golowich@xmath2 + .15 cm @xmath1 dipartimento di fisica delluniversit and i.n.f.n .
+ via buonarroti,2 56100 pisa ( italy ) + [email protected] + .15 cm @xmath2 department of physics and astronomy + university of massachusetts + amherst ma 01003 usa + [email protected] + [email protected] + .3 cm 1.5 cm |
the recent progress of radioactive nuclear beam facilities has provided us with marvelous findings in nuclear physics .
exotic structures such as neutron halos @xcite and neutron skins @xcite have been found in experimental studies of light unstable nuclei in the neutron - rich region .
much new information on the shapes and structures of nuclei far from stability is being revealed by the systematic measurement of radii and moments of unstable nuclei @xcite . planned facilities in the world
will access a large number of unstable nuclei in the whole region of the nuclear chart and enable us to explore where and how exotic phenomena of nuclear structure appear in the region far from the stability line @xcite .
one of the great interests is to know where the deformation of unstable nuclei appears and how the shape of these nuclei changes along the isotopic and isotonic chains . at the same time
, the relativistic many - body framework has been extensively applied to study nuclei and nuclear matter @xcite .
this has been motivated by the recent success of the relativistic brueckner - hartree - fock ( rbhf ) theory , in which the strong density - dependent repulsion arises automatically from the relativistic many - body treatment , in reproducing the saturation property of nuclear matter @xcite . among other properties , the relativistic mean field ( rmf )
theory , which is the phenomenological framework of the rbhf theory , has been shown to be excellent at describing the properties of unstable nuclei as well as stable ones @xcite .
the rmf theory has also been successfully applied to the study of the deformation of nuclei , as well as other properties of the stable and unstable nuclei @xcite .
furthermore , the rmf theory has been used to calculate the equation of state(eos ) of nuclear matter in the wide density and temperature regions tabulated for the application to supernova simulations @xcite .
recently , a systematic study of all even - even nuclei up to the drip lines in the nuclear chart has been performed in the rmf theory with axial deformation @xcite .
the ground state properties of about 2000 even - even nuclei from @xmath11 to @xmath12 have been studied and all possible deformations of each nuclide have been surveyed using a constrained , axially deformed rmf model . through
the systematic analysis of the ground state deformations thus found , the pattern of the appearance of prolate and oblate deformations has been obtained . in the same study
, it was also found that the coexistence of prolate and oblate shapes with similar binding energies occurs in many nuclei in the nuclear chart .
this coexistence suggests the possible appearance of deformation beyond the axial kind , such as triaxial or even higher order multipole deformations .
the appearance of triaxial deformation in this context has been studied in the case of the neutron - rich sulfur isotopes @xcite . in the axial rmf calculation for neutron - rich sulfur isotopes ,
the energy curves as a function of the @xmath13 deformation have two minima , at both prolate and oblate deformations , with energies very close to each other .
judging solely from the energy curve , one can not conclude which ground state deformation is realized or whether yet another type of deformation appears .
the rmf calculations with triaxial deformation of the same isotopes have been performed to clarify this point and a smooth shape transition from prolate to oblate shapes through triaxial shape has been found along the sulfur isotopic chain @xcite .
this example motivates us to study further the appearance of triaxial deformation in other regions of the nuclear chart .
it is interesting to explore where triaxial deformation appears in the nuclear chart , especially in relation with the behavior of the appearance of axial deformation . in the present study ,
we have chosen to explore the proton - rich xe region for the appearance of triaxial deformation .
we have made a systematic study of 25 even - even nuclei covering @xmath0 and @xmath1 , using the rmf theory with triaxial deformation , in order to clarify how their shapes change as a function of @xmath14 and @xmath15 in this region .
we have calculated the energy surface of those nuclei as a function of the deformation parameters , @xmath13 and @xmath16 , to explore the ground state deformation .
the previous study of @xmath17xe , @xmath18cs and @xmath19ba isotopes using the rmf theory with axial deformation @xcite was successful in reproducing the general features of the ground state properties . however , disagreement with the measured isotope shift for the proton - rich region , which might be due to triaxial deformation , was observed . in the systematic rmf calculation with axial deformation @xcite , which we will discuss in sect
3 , the shape change from oblate to prolate shape occurs as @xmath15 increases , in a region in which the two shapes coexist .
thus , the axially symmetric rmf calculations strongly suggest that this region could contain triaxial deformed nuclei .
this region has been discussed as a possible region for triaxial deformation in studies using conventional frameworks @xcite .
there have also been experimental efforts to measure excitation energies in order to study the collective nature of the nuclei in this region @xcite .
studies of triaxial deformation within the mean field approach have also been performed in other regions of the nuclear chart @xcite . in sect .
2 , we describe the framework of the rmf theory with deformation .
we discuss the behavior of the shape within the rmf theory under the assumption of axial symmetry in sect .
we present the results of the calculations in the rmf theory with triaxial deformation in sect .
results of the calculations are discussed in sect .
we summarize the paper in sect .
we briefly describe the framework of the rmf theory and the procedure of the calculation .
all details can be found in @xcite . in the rmf theory ,
the system of nucleons is described by fields of mesons and nucleons under the mean field approximation .
we start with the effective lagrangian , which is relativistically covariant , composed of meson and nucleon fields .
we adopt a lagrangian with non - linear @xmath20 and @xmath21 terms @xcite , @xmath22\psi \\
\nonumber & & + \frac{1}{2}\partial_{\mu}\sigma\partial^{\mu}\sigma -\frac{1}{2}m^2_{\sigma}\sigma^2-\frac{1}{3}g_{2}\sigma^{3 } -\frac{1}{4}g_{3}\sigma^{4 } \\
\nonumber & & -\frac{1}{4}w_{\mu\nu}w^{\mu\nu } + \frac{1}{2}m^2_{\omega}\omega_{\mu}\omega^{\mu } + \frac{1}{4}c_{3}\left(\omega_{\mu}\omega^{\mu}\right)^2 \\
\nonumber & & -\frac{1}{4}r^a_{\mu\nu}r^{a\mu\nu } + \frac{1}{2}m^2_{\rho}\rho^a_{\mu}\rho^{a\mu } -\frac{1}{4}f_{\mu\nu}f^{\mu\nu } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the notation follows the standard one .
on top of the walecka @xmath20 - @xmath21 model with photons and isovector - vector @xmath23 mesons , non - linear @xmath20 meson terms are introduced to reproduce the properties of nuclei quantitatively and give a reasonable value for the incompressibility @xcite .
the inclusion of the non - linear term of @xmath21 meson @xcite is motivated by the recent success of the relativistic brueckner - hartree - fock theory @xcite .
deriving the euler - lagrange equations from the lagrangian under the mean field approximation , we obtain the dirac equation for the nucleons and klein - gordon equations for the mesons .
the self - consistent dirac equation and klein - gordon equations are solved by expanding the fields in terms of harmonic - oscillator wave functions @xcite .
the rmf model contains the meson masses , the meson - nucleon coupling constants and the meson self - coupling constants as free parameters .
we adopt the parameter set tma , which was determined by fitting the experimental data of masses and charge radii of nuclei in a wide mass range @xcite .
the parameters are listed in table 1 .
we remark that this parameter set has a mass dependence so as to reproduce nuclear properties quantitatively from the light mass region to the superheavy region . with the tma parameter set ,
the symmetry energy is 30.68 mev and the incompressibility is 318 mev .
note that the bulk properties of nuclear matter at saturation with the parameter set tma is calculated for uniform matter in the limit of infinite mass number .
the tma parameter set has been used for the systematic study of all even - even nuclei up to the drip lines in the nuclear chart within the rmf framework under the assumption of axial symmetry @xcite .
it has been shown that the overall agreement of the calculated results using tma with the experimental data of masses and charge radii is excellent and is found to be much better than the results of spherical rmf calculations with tma . in the present study , we extend the rmf calculation with the tma parameter set from the axially symmetric to the triaxially symmetric one , in order to explore the appearance of triaxial deformation in the region in which axial deformations with similar binding energies coexist .
we discuss the correspondence between the axial and triaxial rmf calculations in the subsequent section . in order to take into account triaxial deformation ,
the fields are expanded in terms of the eigenfunctions of a triaxially deformed harmonic oscillator potential @xcite .
we perform calculations that constrain the quadrupole moments of the nucleon distribution , in order to survey the coexistence of multiple shapes and to identify the ground state deformation .
we use a quadratic constraint to calculate a complete map of the energy surface as a function of the deformation @xcite .
we take a basis of up to @xmath24 major shells of the harmonic oscillator wave functions .
this is normally enough for the constrained calculations in this mass range @xcite .
we have performed calculations with @xmath25 major shells in the case of no - pairing and found that the energy surface does not change significantly for moderate deformation .
we have also performed non - constrained calculations with pairing up to @xmath26 and the convergence was generally good with @xmath24 .
we take the pairing window as given by gambhir et al .
@xcite as @xmath27mev .
as for the pairing correlations , we perform the rmf calculations with triaxial symmetry using a bcs formalism @xcite .
since we calculate the energy surface in the full @xmath28 range , we take the pairing interaction strength for a given nucleus as @xmath29[mev ] for both protons and neutrons @xcite .
although the bcs - type treatment has often been used in the rmf calculations , it would be preferable to incorporate the pairing correlations in the relativistic many body framework in a consistent manner .
a study with the relativistic hartree - bogoliubov theory has been performed under the assumption of spherical symmetry @xcite . a systematic study of nuclear deformation within such a relativistic many - body framework
is currently being made @xcite .
before we present the results of the rmf calculation with triaxial symmetry , we discuss the corresponding results of the rmf calculation with axial symmetry @xcite .
we examine the behavior of the calculated ground state properties of even - even nuclei in the proton - rich xe region .
we note here that the calculated properties of deformations as well as masses and radii in this region agree very well with the experimental data . in the region of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , roughly speaking , the deformation changes according to the proton number , with a few exceptions .
the sn isotopes ( @xmath30 ) are dominated by a spherical shape and the te isotopes ( @xmath31 ) have , for the most part , an oblate shape .
the xe , ba and ce isotopes ( @xmath32 ) all have a prolate shape .
we show the energy surfaces for te and xe isotopes as functions of @xmath13 deformation ( fig .
1 ) . the general trend shows a transition in shape from spherical , through oblate , to prolate as the proton number increases .
furthermore , there is always more than one energy minimum and shape coexistence is generally observed @xcite in this region of nuclides , as can be seen in fig .
1 . for each nucleus
there is a corresponding second minimum which has the deformation parameter , @xmath13 , of opposite sign to that of the absolute minimum .
the energy difference between the absolute minimum and the second minimum is generally small in this region .
we next present the rmf calculations with triaxial deformation for 25 nuclei covering the range @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we present the energy surfaces of these nuclei in the @xmath13 and @xmath16 deformation parameter space , calculated using constraints on the two deformation parameters .
figure 2 displays the energy surfaces of the sn , te , xe , ba , ce ( @xmath0 ) isotopes with @xmath1 , arranged in the form of the nuclear chart .
the spacing of contours is 1 mev in total energy in all figures .
the energy minimum is marked by the black region , in which the energy difference is less than 1 mev from its absolute minimum energy . as for the sn isotopes , the minima appear consistently at the spherical shape ( @xmath33 ) .
the te isotopes show a @xmath16-soft character , having similar energies along the @xmath16 direction .
most of the xe , ba and ce isotopes have minima at prolate deformation . in some cases ( @xmath34ba , @xmath35ba , @xmath36ce , @xmath35ce and @xmath37ce ) , the region of the shallow minimum extends to quite large @xmath16 deformation .
these results indicate that the triaxial shape is not stable in those nuclei , but the energy surfaces are very @xmath16 soft .
we discuss here the influence of the pairing correlations and the effective interaction on the triaxial rmf calculations .
since the consistent calculation of pairing correlations with deformation within the relativistic many - body framework is still under development , we have performed the rmf calculations with pairing correlations in the bcs formalism , as a first study of the appearance of axial and triaxial deformation .
we see here the effect of pairing correlations on the magnitude of the binding energy and the deformation by comparing the results of calculations with and without pairing .
we show in fig .
3 the energy surfaces in the @xmath28 plane of @xmath38te , @xmath39xe and @xmath34ba without and with pairing correlations .
the qualitative behavior of the two cases is very similar . generally speaking
, the magnitude of the @xmath13 deformation is reduced by the pairing correlations .
the energy minimum seen at finite @xmath16 deformation in @xmath34ba is washed out by the inclusion of the pairing correlations . in fig .
4 we show the proton deformation parameters @xmath13 extracted from the rmf calculation with axial deformation . in the same figure we also show the experimental data obtained from the b(e2 ) values@xcite . in this figure
we see that our results compare well with experimental data .
we also calculate the energy surface of @xmath34ba with alternative nl1 parameter set @xcite of the rmf theory in order to test the dependence of triaxial deformation on the choice of the rmf parameter . in fig . 5
, we compare the energy surfaces obtained by using the tma and nl1 parameter sets .
a well - distinguished minimum is seen at prolate deformation for the case of the nl1 parameter set .
this feature is slightly stronger than in the tma case .
we mention that triaxial deformation is not found in calculations within the skyrme - hartree - fock(shf ) theory@xcite
. it would be interesting to compare the energy surfaces of rmf and shf theories in a wide mass range . in fig .
6 we show the total binding energy of the nuclei studied .
the theoretical values are taken from the axially symmetric calculations , since no distinguished triaxial shapes were found in the triaxial calculations .
we see slightly over binding for the sn isotopes , which may be due to the use of the constant pairing correlations and will be studied further .
we show in fig . 7 the charge radius as a function of the neutron number . the general tendency is found to be quite satisfactory .
we have studied systematically the triaxial deformation of 25 even - even nuclei in the proton - rich xe region .
we have calculated their ground state structures in the rmf theory with triaxial deformation and with pairing correlations and obtained their energy surfaces in the plane of the deformation parameters , @xmath13 and @xmath16 , by constraining the quadrupole moments .
we have explored the appearance of triaxial deformation in the region covering @xmath0 and @xmath1 , by looking for the minima of the derived energy surfaces in the triaxial deformation parameter space . through comparisons with the results obtained in the rmf calculations with axial symmetry
, we have discussed the correspondence between the coexistence of axial shapes and the appearance of triaxial shapes .
we have found no distinguished energy minima at triaxial deformations . however , the energy surfaces are often very @xmath16 soft .
this feature is caused by the pairing correlations since , when we remove the pairing correlations in the rmf calculations , we find well distinguished triaxial deformation in this mass region . we have compared the energy surfaces of two parameter sets , the tma and nl1 ones .
the tma parameter set provides more softness in the @xmath16 direction than the nl1 one provides .
comparisons of the binding energies and deformations with experimental data are , in general , quite satisfactory .
we note here that we have not worked out the angular momentum and particle number projection , which have already been developed in the non - relativistic approach .
the restorations of these symmetries may change somewhat the results on the deformation , as has been discussed in the non - relativistic description of deformed nuclei .
the relativistic approach to triaxial deformation is not yet at such a level of systematic study and these refinements have not been considered here .
this is certainly a direction for future work .
we would like to thank j. meng for fruitful discussions .
the entire calculation was performed on the fujitsu vpp500/30 and vpp700e/128 supercomputer at riken , japan .
k. s. would like to express special thanks to the computing facility of riken for a special allocation of vpp500/30 computing time for the first stage of this study .
999 i. tanihata , h. hamagaki , o. hashimoto , y. shida , n. yoshikawa , k. sugimoto , o. yamakawa , t. kobayashi and n. takahashi , phys .
lett . * 55 * ( 1985 ) 2676 .
i. tanihata , d. hirata , t. kobayashi , s. shimoura , k. sugimoto and h. toki , phys . lett .
* b289 * ( 1992 ) 261 .
t. suzuki , h. geissel , o. bochkarev , l. chulkov , m. golovkov , d. hirata , h. irnich , z. janas , h. keller , t. kobayashi , g. kraus , g. mnzenberg , s. neumaier , f. nickel , a. ozawa , a. piechaczeck , e. roeckl , w. schwab , k. smmerer , k. yoshida , i. tanihata , phys .
* 75 * ( 1995 ) 3241 .
j. h. hamilton , treatise on heavy ion science , ed .
d. a. bromley ( plenum , new york ) , * 8 * ( 1989 ) 3 .
e. w. otten , treatise on heavy ion science , ed .
d. a. bromley ( plenum , new york ) , * 8 * ( 1989 ) 517 .
i.tanihata , progress in particle and nuclear physics * 35 * ( 1995 ) 505 see for example , proceedings of the fourth international conference on radioactive nuclear beams , ohmiya , japan , 1996 , nucl . phys . * a616 * ( 1997 ) .
b. d. serot and j. d. walecka , adv .
* 16 * ( 1986 ) 1 .
b. d. serot , rep .
* 55 * ( 1992 ) 1855 .
r. brockmann and r. machleidt , phys . rev .
* c42 * ( 1990 ) 1965 .
l. engvik , m. hjorth - jensen , e. osnes , g. bao and e. ostgaard , phys .
lett . * 73 * ( 1994 ) 2650 .
r. brockmann and h. toki , phys .
lett.*b68 * ( 1992 ) 3408 .
reinhard , m. rufa , j. maruhn , w. greiner and j. friedrich , z. phys .
* a323 * ( 1986 ) 13 .
y. k. gambhir , p. ring and a. thimet , ann . of phys .
* 198 * ( 1990 ) 132 .
d. hirata , h. toki , t. watabe , i. tanihata and b. v. carlson , phys . rev . * c44 * ( 1991 ) 1467 .
k. sumiyoshi , d. hirata , h. toki and h. sagawa , nucl . phys .
* a552 * ( 1993 ) 437 .
k. pomorski , p. ring , g.a .
lalazissis , a. baran , z. lojewski , b.nerlopomorska and m. warda , nucl . phys .
* a624 * ( 1997 ) 349 . m. m. sharma and p. ring , phys
* c46 * ( 1992 ) 1715 .
d. hirata , h. toki , i. tanihata and p. ring , phys . lett .
* b314 * ( 1993 ) 168 .
g. a. lalazissis and m. m. sharma , nucl .
a586 * ( 1995 ) 201 .
h. shen , h. toki , k. oyamatsu and k. sumiyoshi , prog .
* 100 * ( 1998 ) 1013 .
d. hirata , k. sumiyoshi , i. tanihata , y. sugahara , t. tachibana , and h. toki , nucl . phys .
* a616 * ( 1997 ) 438 ; riken preprint no
. riken - af - nf-268 d. hirata , k. sumiyoshi , b. v. carlson , h. toki and i. tanihata , nucl . phys .
* a609 * ( 1996 ) 131 .
d. hirata , h. toki and i. tanihata , nucl . phys .
* a589 * ( 1995 ) 239 .
r. f. casten , p. von brentano , k. heyde , p. van isacker and j. jolie , nucl . phys .
* a439 * ( 1985 ) 289 .
r. wyss , a. granderath , w. lieberz , r. bengtsson , p. von brentano , a. dewald , a. gelberg , a. gizon , j. gizon , s. harrisopulos , a. johnson , w. nazarewicz , j. nyberg and k. schiffer , nucl .
* a505 * ( 1989 ) 337 .
a. gelberg , d. lieberz , p. von brentano , i. ragnarsson , p. b. semmes and i. wiedenhver , nucl .
a557 * ( 1993 ) 439c .
u. meyer , a. faessler and s. b. khadkikar , nucl .
a624 * ( 1997 ) 391 .
a. dewald , p. sala , r. wrzal , g. bhm , d. liebrez , g. siems , r. wirowski , k. o. zell , a. gelberg , p. von brentano , p. nolan , a. j. kirwan , p. j. bishop , r. julin , a. lampinen and j. hattula , nucl . phys .
* a545 * ( 1992 ) 822 .
p. petkov , r. krcken , a. dewald , p. sala , g. bhm , j. altmann , a. gelberg , p. von brentano , r.v .
jolos and w. andrejtscheff , nucl . phys . *
a568 * ( 1994 ) 572 .
p. bonche , h. flocard , p. h. heenen , s. j. krieger and m. s. weiss , nucl . phys .
* a443 * ( 1985 ) 39 .
w. koepf and p. ring , phys . lett . *
b212 * ( 1988 ) 397 .
s. aberg , h. flocard and w. nazarewicz , annu .
nucl . part .
* 40 * ( 1990 ) 439 and references therein .
t. r. werner , j. a. sheikh , w. nazarewicz , m. r. strayer , a. s. umar and m. misu , phys . lett . * b333 * ( 1994 ) 303 . y. sugahara and h. toki , nucl . phys .
* a579 * ( 1994 ) 557 .
j. boguta and a. r. bodmer , nucl . phys .
* a292 * ( 1977 ) 413 .
a. r. bodmer , nucl . phys .
* a526 * ( 1991 ) 703 .
y. sugahara , doctor thesis , tokyo metropolitan university ( 1995 ) .
h. toki , d. hirata , y. sugahara , k. sumiyoshi and i. tanihata , nucl . phys .
* a588 * ( 1995 ) 357c .
h. flocard , p. quentin , a. k. kerman and d. vautherin , nucl . phys .
* a203 * ( 1973 ) 433 .
n. tajima , s. takahara and n. onishi , nucl .
a603 * ( 1996 ) 23 . l. s. kisslinger and r. a. sorensen , mat .
vid . selsk . *
32 * no . 9 ( 1960 )
j. meng and p. ring , phys .
lett . * 77 * ( 1996 ) 3963 .
d. hirata and b. v. carlson , enam98 , ed .
b. m. sherrill , d. j. morrissey and c. n. davids ( the american institue of physics ) ( 1998 ) 527 .
s. raman , c. h. malarkey , w. t. milner , c. w. nestor , jr . , and p. h. stelson , at .
data nucl .
data tables * 36 * ( 1987 ) 1 .
g. audi and a.h .
wapstra , nucl . phys .
* a595 * ( 1995 ) 409 .
h. de vries , c. w. de jager and c. de vries , at .
data nucl .
data tables * 36 * ( 1987 ) 495 .
* table 1 * @xmath40 & 938.900 \\ \hline $ m_{\sigma}$ [ mev ] & 519.151 \\ \hline $ m_{\omega}$ [ mev ] & 781.950 \\ \hline $ m_{\rho}$ [ mev ] & 768.100 \\ \hline $ g_{\sigma}$ & 10.055 $ + $ 3.050/$a^{0.4}$ \\
\hline $ g_{\omega}$ & 12.842 $ + $ 3.191/$a^{0.4}$ \\ \hline $ g_{\rho}$ & 3.800 $ + $ 4.644/$a^{0.4}$ \\ \hline $ g_{2}$ & $ -$0.328 $ -$ 27.879/$a^{0.4}$ \\ \hline $ g_{3}$ & 38.862 $ -$ 184.191/$a^{0.4}$ \\ \hline $ c_{3}$ & 151.590 $ -$ 378.004/$a^{0.4}$ \\
\hline \end{tabular}\ ] ]
fig.1 : : the energy curve obtained in axial rmf calculations as a function of the deformation parameter , @xmath13 , for the @xmath41te and @xmath17xe isotopes . calculated points are connected by dashed curves to guide the eye .
note that the curves for @xmath39te and @xmath34te are shifted downward by 0.02 mev to distinguish them from the other curves .
fig.2 : : the energy surface in the plane of deformation parameters , @xmath13 and @xmath16 , calculated in the rmf theory with triaxial deformation for nuclei in the range of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , arranged in the form of the nuclear chart .
the energy difference between the contours is 1 mev in total binding energy .
the energy minimum is marked by the black region , in which the energy difference is less than 1 mev .
fig.3 : : the energy surfaces obtained in the triaxial rmf calculation without and with pairing are shown for @xmath38te , @xmath39xe and @xmath34ba . the energy difference between the contours is 1 mev in total binding energy .
the energy minimum is marked by the black region .
fig.4 : : the proton deformation parameter @xmath13 , obtained from the rmf calculation with axial deformation , is shown as a function of the neutron number .
the experimental data are extracted from ref .
fig.5 : : the energy surfaces obtained in the triaxial rmf calculation with the nl1 and tma parameter sets are shown for @xmath34ba . the energy difference between the contours is 1 mev in total binding energy .
the energy minimum is marked by the black region .
fig.6 : : the total binding energy calculated using the rmf theory with axial deformation is shown as a function of the neutron number .
the experimental data are extracted from ref .
fig.7 : : the charge radius calculated using the rmf theory with axial deformation is shown as a function of the neutron number .
the experimental data are extracted from ref . | we use the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) theory to systematically study the change of deformation of even - even nuclei in the proton - rich xe region .
we investigate the appearance of triaxial deformation in 25 nuclei in the region covering @xmath0 and @xmath1 by performing constrained , triaxially symmetric rmf calculations of their energy surfaces .
we include pairing correlations using the bcs formalism .
we find that the sn isotopes are spherical and the te isotopes are very gamma unstable with shallow minima around @xmath2 .
adding more protons , the xe , ba and ce isotopes have prolate deformations with their sizes increasing with proton number .
the neutron number dependence is found to be small .
we compare the calculated results with the available experimented data on the binding energy and the radii .
s. sugimoto@xmath3 , k. sumiyoshi@xmath4 , d. hirata@xmath5 , b.v .
carlson@xmath6 , + i. tanihata@xmath4 , and h. toki@xmath3 + @xmath7the institute of physical and chemical research ( riken ) , + hirosawa , wako , saitama 351 - 0198 , japan + @xmath8research center for nuclear physics(rcnp ) , osaka university , + mihogaoka , ibaraki , osaka 567 - 0047 , japan + @xmath9japan synchrotron radiation research institute ( jasri ) - spring-8 , + sayo , hyogo , 679 - 5198 , japan + @xmath10departamento de fsica , instituto tecnolgico da aeronutica - cta , + so jos dos campos , so paulo , brazil |
in the local universe , the star formation surface density is determined by the molecular gas surface density ( e.g. larson 1992 ) .
recent studies have shown that this relation probably holds at higher redshift ( @xmath15 ) as well ( e.g. tacconi et al .
2013 ; genzel et al . 2015 ) , suggesting that the gas reservoir is the key factor controlling the growth rate of galaxies . in the broader context of galaxy evolution
, this has been interpreted as evidence for the equilibrium growth framework in which star formation is regulated by a balance between inflows and outflows ( bouch et al .
2010 ; dav , finlator , & oppenheimer 2012 ; lilly et al . 2013 ; peng & maiolino 2014 ) . in this model ,
galaxy growth in an integrated sense is driven by the cycle of baryons between galaxies and the halo gas ( dav et al .
2012 ) with the star formation efficiency set by stellar feedback ( hopkins et al . 2014 ) .
however , in a resolved sense , exactly how different physical processes couple in different parts of galaxies to regulate star formation and drive structural assembly remains unknown ( dav et al .
observationally , significant progress is being made in mapping the molecular gas reservoir and the spatial distribution of star formation of galaxies .
molecular gas can now be mapped based on the spatial distribution of co thanks to millimeter arrays such as pdb and alma ( e.g. genzel et al .
2013 ; rybak et al .
star formation can be mapped out to @xmath16 using the spatial distribution of the emission line owing to integral field units on ground - based telescopes ( sinfoni , osiris , kmos frster schreiber et al .
2009 ; law et al . 2009
; wisnioski et al . 2015 ) and the wfc3 grism on hst ( nelson et al . 2012 ; nelson et al .
2013 ) .
however , studies of spatially resolved star formation using the emission line suffer from an important systematic uncertainty as they only trace the photons that are not absorbed by dust . the dust attenuation toward star - forming regions
is most directly probed using balmer recombination line flux ratios , the balmer decrement : as dust attenuation is wavelength dependent , its effects can be measured by comparing the observed and intrinsic balmer decrements ( e.g. calzetti 1997 ) . on a galaxy - integrated basis , the quantity of dust attenuation toward hii regions ( ) measured using balmer decrements has been shown to increase with increasing stellar mass ( ) , star formation rate ( sfr ) , and attenuation toward the stars ( ) ( calzetti et al .
2000 ; wild et al .
2011 ; momcheva et al .
2013 ; domnguez et al . 2013 ; price et al . 2014 ; reddy et al . 2015 ) .
as the stellar mass surface density and the star formation surface density are typically highest in the centers of galaxies , we expect the attenuation to vary within galaxies , such that the dust attenuation is highest in the centers .
this is also expected from the fact that both the metallicity and , most importantly , the gas column density increase with decreasing distance from the center ( e.g. bohlin , savage , & drake 1978 ; gilli et al .
2014 ; nelson et al .
therefore , in order to tie the global gas reservoir to galactic structural assembly we need to correct the spatially - resolved measurements for the attenuation toward star - forming regions .
measuring spatially - resolved balmer decrements is now possible with the wide field camera 3 ( wfc3 ) grism capability on the hubble space telescope , which we employed for the 3d - hst survey ( brammer et al .
2012 ; momcheva et al . 2015 ) .
the grism data enable us to create emission line maps for every object in the survey ( see nelson et al .
2012 ; nelson et al .
2013 ; wuyts et al .
2013 ; nelson et al .
2015 ) . in a narrow redshift window
( @xmath17 ) we can map the spatial distribution of both the and emission lines , as they both fall within the g141 wavelength coverage .
galaxy - integrated balmer decrements were analyzed in price et al .
( 2014 ) . here
we present spatially resolved balmer decrements for galaxies at @xmath0 and derive radial dust gradients .
the gradients are measured from deep stacks , using the full 3d - hst dataset .
we study radial dust gradients as a function of , and apply these gradients to the observed distributions to obtain spatially - resolved dust - corrected star formation surface density profiles .
we use data from the 3d - hst survey , a 248 orbit nir slitless spectroscopic survey over the candels fields with the g141 grism ( brammer et al .
2012 ; skelton et al .
2014 ; momcheva et al . 2015 ) .
these slitless grism observations have high spatial resolution and low spectral resolution , and therefore provide images of galaxies in the light of their emission lines for every object in the field of view .
we focus on the redshift range @xmath17 , for which both and fall in the wavelength coverage of the g141 grism .
the absence of sky emission lines in the spectra implies that no further restrictions on the redshifts are required ; in ground - based observations it is rare that both and are unaffected by oh lines .
the galaxies are divided in three mass bins : [ @xmath18 , [ @xmath19 , [ @xmath20 , the median stellar mass in these bins is 9.17 , 9.53 , and 10.23 respectively .
a detailed description of how emission line maps are made from grism data is provided in nelson et al .
briefly , the and emission line maps are made by subtracting the continuum from the two - dimensional spectra and masking contaminating flux from nearby objects .
we stack the and emission line maps as a function of .
these properties were determined from the combination of the grism spectra and deep uv - ir photometric catalogs ( brammer et al .
2012 ; skelton et al . 2014
; whitaker et al .
we select all galaxies with @xmath21 , applying no emission line flux limit for or so as not to introduce systematics into the line ratio measurements .
galaxies which have or emission line maps with more than half of their central 3kpc masked due to contamination are removed ; this is roughly half of the sample . in the stacking procedure the broadband emission
is used to center and normalize the emission line maps .
we masked the nearby @xmath22 and @xmath23 lines with an asymmetric double pacman mask ( see nelson et al .
we correct the image stacks for the effects of the point spread function ( psf ) , using the method described in szomoru et al .
( 2013 ) and nelson et al .
( 2015 ) : after fitting the stacks with galfit ( peng et al . 2010 ) , the residuals of the fit are added to the unconvolved galfit srsic model . this method has been shown to reconstruct the true flux distribution even if the srsic model is a poor fit ( szomoru et al .
the averaged maps are shown in fig .
[ fig : maps ] .
radial profiles of the and emission are computed in circular apertures , again following nelson et al .
( 2015 ) . from the 3d - hst survey .
[ fig : maps ] , scaledwidth=50.0% ] we correct these measured profiles for emission . as a result of the low spectral resolution of the g141 grism , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are blended in our spectra . to account for the contamination of by , the blended observed line
must be scaled by a factor @xmath26@xmath27/ ) .
we can not measure / directly , and we make use of previous measurements in the literature .
the galaxy - integrated / increases as a function of ( e.g. erb et al .
2006 ; zahid et al . 2014
; steidel et al . 2014 ; wuyts et al .
2014 ) , which is probably a reflection of the mass - metallicity relation .
we use the zahid et al .
( 2014 ) relation and scale the overall normalization of the radial profiles down accordingly .
the adopted / ratios are [ 0.03,0.07,0.24 ] for the low through high mass stacks respectively .
we also consider the effects of gradients in / within the galaxies , as abundance gradients have been widely observed in the local universe ( e.g. snchez et al . 2014 ) .
however , trends at higher redshift are much less certain with observed / gradients ranging from flat or negative to positive ( swinbank et al .
2012 ; jones et al . 2013
; stott et al .
2014,leethochawalit et al .
2015 , wuyts et al . in prep ) .
given these uncertainties we do not apply a radially - varying correction , but we note that adopting a radial gradient of /@xmath28 , as inferred from radial o / h measurements in the local universe ( snchez et al .
2014 ) , does not change our results . typically , balmer emission lines also need to be corrected for underlying absorption .
the atmospheres of stars ( particularly a stars ) produce balmer absorption lines and the emission line flux must first fill in the absorption . in our analysis ,
the absorption was corrected for in the subtraction of the two - dimensional continuum model .
this model is a linear combination of eazy templates with emission lines removed ( see brammer , van dokkum , & coppi 2008 ; momcheva et al . 2015 ) which is then convolved with the @xmath29 detection image .
therefore , the continuum model has , to very good approximation , both the same spectrum and morphology as the true continuum emission that underlies our emission line maps .
we are essentially subtracting a negative image of the galaxy in absorption .
for reference , the integrated absorption line strength is @xmath30 in the stacks , consistent with , e.g. , domnguez et al .
( 2013 ) ; momcheva et al .
this is , in general , a small fraction of the emission line equivalent width , although it becomes more significant for at the highest masses ( up to @xmath31 ) .
the fully corrected and profiles , in units of @xmath32 , are shown in fig.[fig : habprofs ] .
we can reliably trace out to @xmath33 , and the @xmath34 fainter out to @xmath35 ; at larger radii the error in the measurement is more than half of the measured flux . at low masses ,
the and surface brightness profiles are nearly exponential . as mass increases
, the emission grows more centrally concentrated while the becomes _ less _ centrally concentrated than exponential .
this is the central result of this letter : with increasing stellar mass , galaxies become increasingly more dust obscured toward their centers . fig .
[ fig : habprofs ] also shows the effect of assuming different quantities of stellar absorption ( shaded regions ) .
these profiles were derived by artificially changing the absorption line equivalent width in the best - fitting 2d eazy model , increasing and decreasing it by half .
the increase in the slope and normalization of the balmer decrement with implies a corresponding increase in the slope and normalization of the dust attenuation .
we derive the dust attenuation toward as follows .
the increase of the balmer decrement over the intrinsic value can be expressed in terms of a balmer color excess : @xmath36 here ( /)@xmath37 is the expected ratio produced by the recombination and subsequent cascade of electrons in photoionized hydrogen atoms : ( /)@xmath38 for case b recombination and @xmath39 ( osterbrock & ferland 2006 ) . if dust is present , it will preferentially attenuate the shorter wavelength @xmath40 more than the longer wavelength @xmath25 , increasing the observed value of the balmer decrement ( ( /)@xmath41 ) .
the balmer color excess can therefore be used to derive the attenuation toward : @xmath42 + deriving requires the adoption of a reddening curve @xmath43 to compute the values at ( ) and ( ) . in fig .
[ fig : ahaprofs ] we show the radial trend of the absorption toward , using different parameterizations of the reddening and attenuation . as expected from the trends in the balmer decrement profiles , shows a stronger dependence on radius and a higher overall normalization for higher masses .
the attenuation in low mass galaxies is essentially zero at all radii . as mass increases , attenuation increases toward the center . in the highest mass bin ,
the attenuation in the central regions reaches values in excess of two magnitudes . while the qualitative trends remain unchanged with different dust laws , the profiles do have quantitative differences .
in particular , is higher if the slope of the attenuation curve is flatter between the wavelengths of and or if @xmath44 is larger ( see e.g. cardelli , clayton , & mathis 1989 ; calzetti et al .
2000 ; gordon et al .
2003 ; reddy et al .
2015 ) . with the exception of the centers of the highest mass galaxies , these differences
are small compared to the systematic and random errors in the measurements of the balmer decrement .
we quantify the radial dust profiles as follows : @xmath45 with @xmath9 in kpc .
we fit the dust profiles derived using the calzetti et al .
( 2000 ) attenuation curve , for consistency with previous work ( e.g. momcheva et al .
2013 ; domnguez et al .
2013 ; price et al . 2014 ) and because this curve gives the best agreement with the total uv+ir star formation rates ( see sect . 4 ) . for the three mass bins we find @xmath46 $ ] and @xmath47 $ ] .
we set @xmath48 and @xmath49 to zero in the lowest mass bin as the formal best fit is ( slightly ) negative .
these fits are shown by the thick dashed lines in fig.[fig : ahaprofs ] .
while the observed profiles show hints of more complex structure , perhaps even separate bulge and disk components , higher order fits are not justified given the low signal - to - noise ratio and the spatial resolution of the data .
we parameterize the change of the slope and normalization with by fitting linear functions to the coefficients @xmath50 and @xmath51 . to good approximation ( @xmath52 mag ) , we find @xmath53 and @xmath54 , with @xmath10 the stellar mass in units of @xmath11m@xmath3 . over a decade in mass , the attenuation at 2 kpc increases by @xmath55 magnitudes , and the attenuation at 0.5 kpc increases by @xmath56 magnitudes .
the gradients are consistent with the galaxy - integrated measurements of price et al .
with the radial profiles of and , we derive radial profiles of star formation corrected for dust .
star formation rates are computed from emission using kennicutt ( 1998 ) and a chabrier ( 2003 ) initial mass function : @xmath57 star formation rates are corrected for the dust attenuation toward hii regions ( ) using : @xmath58 with @xmath59 given by eq .
[ fit.eq ] .
figure[fig : dustcorrprofs ] shows the radial sfr profiles corrected for dust . as a test of our procedure
, we integrate these dust - corrected sfr profiles out to @xmath60 ( with @xmath61 the half light radius of the emission ) , and compare them to the average uv+ir star formation rates of the same galaxies ( see whitaker et al .
2014 ; momcheva et al .
2015 ) . in the three mass bins , we find that the total h@xmath62-derived star formation rates are 2.4 , 3.3 , and 8.6 respectively
. the ratios of the h@xmath62 star formation rates to the uv+ir star formation rates are 1.3 , 1.2 , and 0.7 respectively .
these ratios are similar when using the whitaker et al .
( 2014 ) uv+ir sfr measurements for the median masses in the bins .
we conclude that the dust corrections are reasonable to within the systematic uncertainty of our uv+ir star formation rates ( see e.g. utomo et al .
2014 ) . particularly in our highest mass bin
the implied central sfrs are much higher than prior to the dust correction : the total star formation in the central @xmath12kpc is @xmath63 in the highest mass bin , whereas it was @xmath64 before correction .
approximately half of the total star formation rate takes place inside 1kpc in the highest mass bin .
using the wfc3 grism to map the distribution of and emission , we constructed the first spatially - resolved maps of the balmer decrement at @xmath65 .
these measurements provide stringent constraints on the radial gradients in the dust attenuation toward star forming regions of galaxies , allowing us to derive dust - corrected radial distributions of star formation .
we find that the dust attenuation is small ( @xmath66mag ) at all radii in galaxies with @xmath67m@xmath3 .
galaxies with higher masses have significant dust attenuation toward their centers .
the immediate implication is that the central ( @xmath68kpc ) observed emission of high mass galaxies should not be directly converted to star formation , and the central surface brightness should not be directly converted to stellar mass density .
a potential concern in this analysis is that by stacking small galaxies with high attenuation and large galaxies with low attenuation , we could infer a radial dust gradient where on an individual galaxy basis , there is none . to test this
, we remove all compact galaxies with sizes more than 0.1 and 0.3dex below the size - mass relation from the stack . in both cases ,
the qualitative trends remain unchanged meaning the gradients are real , not a byproduct of stacking a heterogeneous sample .
another concern is that weighting galaxies by their flux biases the stacks toward galaxies with high and equivalent widths .
if galaxies with high equivalent widths have preferentially low dust attenuation , this analysis could underestimate the true dust attenuation at the median mass of the stacks .
a straightforward interpretation of our results is that we see the in - situ building of bulges in massive galaxies at @xmath69 .
however , a key question is whether this central star formation accounts for a significant fraction of the stars in the central kpc of present - day galaxies .
the total amount of stars that are formed in the central kpc can be approximated by @xmath70 with @xmath71 a correction for mass loss due to stellar winds ( see e.g. bruzual & charlot 2003 ) and @xmath72 the duration of the star formation . for @xmath73gyr ( that is , assuming that the current star formation rate is maintained until @xmath74 ) , we find that the total mass that is added is @xmath75 , or @xmath76 of the total mass of the galaxy . if @xmath77gyr the added mass is much less significant .
we note that this does not necessarily imply that galaxies are growing outside - in " : this depends on the radial @xmath78 profiles ( szomoru et al .
2013 ) which are driven by gradients in dust and age .
this could be tested by deriving mass profiles from the high spatial resolution candels multi - color imaging . in summary
, we infer that it is possible that a central mass concentration is built up through in - situ star formation in the highest mass galaxies , but only if the radial distribution of star formation observed at @xmath0 is sustained over several gyr .
this can be tested with spatially - resolved absorption maps at lower redshift , which can be created using adaptive optics or the g102 grism on the wfc3 camera .
furthermore , high resolution imaging of the molecular gas and of the continuum dust emission with alma can provide direct information on the presence of large amounts of dust in the centers of massive galaxies at these redshifts .
finally , with future facilities such as jwst our initial study of averaged spatially - resolved balmer decrements at moderate redshifts can be expanded to higher redshifts and individual galaxies . | we derive average radial gradients in the dust attenuation towards hii regions in 609 galaxies at @xmath0 , using measurements of the balmer decrement out to @xmath1kpc .
the balmer decrements are derived from spatially resolved maps of and emission from the 3d - hst survey .
we find that with increasing stellar mass both the normalization and strength of the gradient in dust attenuation increases .
galaxies with a mean mass of @xmath2m@xmath3 have little dust attenuation at all radii , whereas galaxies with @xmath4m@xmath3 have @xmath5mag in their central regions .
we parameterize this as @xmath6 , with @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 in kpc , and @xmath10 the stellar mass in units of @xmath11m@xmath3 .
this expression can be used to correct spatially resolved measurements of to radial distributions of star formation . when applied to our data ,
we find that the star formation rates in the central @xmath12kpc of galaxies in the highest mass bin are @xmath13m@xmath3yr@xmath14 , six times higher than before correction and approximately half of the total star formation rate of these galaxies . if this high central star formation rate is maintained for several gyr , a large fraction of the stars in present - day bulges likely formed in - situ . . |
recent advances in wireless communications and microelectronic devices are leading the trend of research toward cognitive radios ( crs ) @xcite .
the main feature of crs is the opportunistic usage of spectrum .
cr systems try to improve the spectrum efficiency by using the spectrum holes in frequency , time , and space domains @xcite .
this means that secondary users ( sus ) are allowed to utilize the spectrum , provided that their transmissions do not interfere with the communication of primary users ( pus ) @xcite .
the fundamental components of cr systems that allow them to avoid interference are spectrum sensing and resource allocation .
however , in a practical cr network , spectrum occupancy measurements for all the frequency channels at all times are not available .
this is partially because of energy limitations and network failures .
another highly important and very common reason for occurrence of missing entries in the data set is the hardware limitation .
each su may want to use different frequency channels , but it may not be capable of sensing all the channels simultaneously @xcite . on the other hand , a complete and reliable spectrum sensing data set is needed for a reliable resource allocation .
therefore , we need to develop a method to estimate the missing spectrum sensing measurements . this task is especially more challenging in dynamic environments .
there are different approaches toward the problem of data analysis in the cr networks . in @xcite ,
a learning approach is introduced based on support vector machine ( svm ) for spectrum sensing in multi - antenna cognitive radios .
svm classification techniques are applied to detect the presence of pus .
several algorithms have been been proposed using dictionary learning framework @xcite .
these approaches try to find the principal components of data using dictionary learning and exploit the components to extract information .
the goal of this paper is to estimate the missing spectrum sensing data as accurate as possible in the time varying environments .
an approach is introduced based on nonnegative matrix factorization ( nmf ) @xcite to represent the spectrum measurements as additive , not subtractive , combination of several components .
each component reflects signature of one pu , therefore the data can be factorized as the product of signatures matrix times an activation matrix .
dimension reduction is an inevitable pre - processing step for high dimensional data analysis @xcite .
nmf is a dimension reduction technique that has been employed in diverse fields @xcite .
the most important feature of nmf , which makes it distinguished from other component analysis methods , is the non - negativity constraint .
thus the original data can be represented as additive combination of its parts . in our proposed method ,
a new framework is introduced to decompose the spectrum measurements in cr networks using a piecewise constant nmf algorithm in presence of missing data .
piecewise constant nmf and its application in video structuring is introduced in @xcite . in the proposed method
, we try to handle the missing entries in the data and also take a different approach to solve the corresponding optimization problem using an iterative reweighed technique . in the context of cr networks
, nmf is utilized in @xcite to estimate the power spectra of the sources in a cr network by factorizing the fourier transform of the correlation matrix of the received signals .
our proposed method estimates the missing entries in power spectral density measurements by enforcing a temporal structure on the activity of the pus and can be used in scenarios when the number of the pus is not known .
the introduced method takes advantage of a prior information about the activity of the pus and exploits piecewise constant constraint to improve the performance of the factorization .
moreover , a solution for the introduced minimization problem is suggested using the majorization - minimization ( mm ) framework .
the rest of the paper is organized in the following order . in section [ model ] , the system model and the problem statement are introduced .
section [ pcnmf ] describes the proposed new nmf problem . in section [ mm ]
, a method is presented to solve the piecewise constant nmf problem in mm framework with missing data .
section [ results ] presents the simulation results and finally section [ conclusions ] draws conclusions .
due to the nature of wireless environments , trustworthy information can not be extracted from measurements of a single su . to find the spectrum holes in frequency , time , and space , there exists a fusion center that collects and combines the measurements from all the sus @xcite .
cooperative spectrum sensing makes the missing data estimation algorithm more robust .
fusion center predicts the missing entries by using the collected measurements.however , since each su is not able to sense the whole spectrum all the time , the data set collected from the sus contains missing entries .
network failures , energy limitations , and shadowing can also cause loss of data . without loss of generality ,
we want to reconstruct the power map in a single frequency band .
the network consists of @xmath0 primary transmitters and @xmath1 spectrum sensors that are randomly spread over the entire area of interest .
figure [ powermap ] illustrates an example of a network with @xmath2 pus and @xmath3 sus in a @xmath4 area .
the received power of the @xmath5 sensor at time @xmath6 can be written as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the transmit - power of the @xmath9 pu at time @xmath6 , @xmath10 is the channel gain from the @xmath9 pu to the @xmath5 su , and @xmath11 is the zero - mean gaussian measurement noise at the @xmath5 sensor with variance @xmath12 . considering a rayleigh fading model ,
the channel gain coefficient can be modeled as : @xmath13 where the channel constant @xmath14 , @xmath15 is the carrier frequency , @xmath16 is the speed of light , and @xmath17 and @xmath18 are the transmitter and receiver antenna gains .
@xmath19 is the path loss exponent which determines the rate at which power decays with the separation distance @xmath20 between the @xmath5 su and the @xmath9 pu and @xmath21 models the fading effect . at time
slot @xmath6 , measurements from sus can be stacked in a vector @xmath22 , given as @xmath23 where @xmath24^t}$ ] , @xmath25^t}$ ] , and @xmath26^t}$ ] . at each time slot ,
only a few sus observe the power levels and report them to the fusion center .
therefore the vector @xmath22 contains some _ missing _ entries .
furthermore , each pu can be active or inactive in each time slot .
some of the characteristics of the environment can be exploited to simplify the problem .
it is assumed that channel gains are slowly time varying such that they can be considered as constant in a time window .
therefore , matrix representation of ( [ multiple_su ] ) can be written as : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is an @xmath29 matrix , which includes measurements from sensors in @xmath30 time slots , @xmath31 $ ] is a @xmath32 matrix , which consists of @xmath0 channel gain vectors in the @xmath1-dimensional space of data , and @xmath33 is an @xmath34 matrix that indicates the power levels of pus in each time slot ( @xmath35 if the @xmath9 pu is inactive at time @xmath6 ) . here , the goal is to estimate the missing data using the partial observations . to achieve this goal ,
the data is decomposed using piecewise constant nmf .
then the components of data and the activation matrix are used to estimate the missing data .
promoted by ( [ compact_form ] ) , it is easy to see that the measurements of each time slot can be represented as an additive , not subtractive , combination of few vectors .
this algebraic representation has a geometric interpretation .
figure [ pyramid ] helps us to visualize the structure of data in a @xmath36-dimensional space of data . in this figure
, @xmath36 sus are measuring power levels in an area with @xmath36 pus .
it is easy to notice that measurement vectors lie within a pyramid in the positive orthant with @xmath37 edges proportional to @xmath38 .
this is due to fact that all the points in the pyramid can be written as an additive combination of the edges .
although it is assumed that the channel gains are stationary for a time window of length @xmath30 , pus can become activated / deactivated in this time window any number of times and can change their transmission power in each activation .
hence , the power levels of pus tend to be piecewise constant .
nmf is a widely - used technique to decompose data to its nonnegative components . here
, the structure of the power level matrix @xmath33 is exploited while handling the missing entries . as a result ,
the general objective function is presented as follows : @xmath39 where @xmath40 is a weighted measure of fit and @xmath41 is a penalty , which favors piecewise constant solutions .
@xmath42 is a nonnegative scalar weighting the penalty .
the constraints denote that all the entries of @xmath43 and @xmath44 are nonnegative .
@xmath45 is an @xmath29 weight matrix that is used to estimate the weighted distance between @xmath28 and @xmath46 .
the coefficients of the weight matrix denote the presence of data ( @xmath47 if the measurement of the @xmath5 su at time slot @xmath6 is unavailable / available ) .
nmf algorithms utilize different measures of fit such as euclidean distance , generalized kullback - leibler ( kl ) divergence , and the itakura - saito divergence . in all the cases ,
the distance can be calculated as the sum of the distances between different coefficients @xcite .
@xmath48 in our case , euclidean distance is used as the measure of fit .
this objective function is commonly used for problems with gaussian noise model , a common noise model in communication systems , hence : @xmath49 since there exist sharp transitions in power level of pus and power level of each pu is constant in each transmission period , rows of @xmath50 tend to be piecewise constant . in order to favor the piecewise constant solutions ,
the penalty function is defined as : @xmath51 when @xmath52 tends to @xmath53 , this penalty function represents the sum of @xmath54 norm of the transition vectors , i.e. @xmath55 , where @xmath56 is an @xmath57 vector containing power levels of pus in time @xmath6 .
this penalty favors the solutions with a lower number of transitions .
however , since it is not differentiable , it can be replaced with a differentiable approximation : @xmath58 where @xmath59 is a small positive constant and is much less than all the non - zero elements of @xmath60 @xmath61 to avoid division by zero . in section [ mm ] , an algorithm is derived to find the minimizer of the following problem : @xmath62 after estimating @xmath33 and @xmath43 , the missing entries of @xmath28 can be approximated using the equation @xmath63 .
in this section , an iterative algorithm is described to find the solution of the optimization problem proposed in ( [ scale_objective ] ) .
for that , majorization - minimization ( mm ) framework is employed @xcite .
mm algorithm and its variants have been used in various applications such as parameter learning and image processing @xcite .
the update rules are derived to calculate the entries of @xmath33 given the entries of @xmath43 and then the entries of @xmath43 given the entries of @xmath33 , using an iterative reweighed algorithm .
first , the update rules for @xmath33 given @xmath43 are derived .
then , the update rules for @xmath43 will be derived in a similar manner . as it is clear in ( [ seperable_measure ] ) , we can write the distance measure as a sum of different time slots : @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the weighted euclidean distance between @xmath66 and @xmath67 , given @xmath66 and @xmath43 . in mm framework , the update rules are derived by minimizing an auxiliary function @xcite . by definition
, @xmath68 is an auxiliary function of @xmath65 if and only if @xmath69 and @xmath70 for @xmath71 .
if @xmath68 is chosen such that it is easier to minimize , the optimization of @xmath65 can be replaced with iterative minimization of @xmath68 over @xmath72 .
thus , in the literature , convex functions are frequently used as the auxiliary functions @xcite .
it is shown in @xcite that @xmath65 is non - increasing under the update @xmath73 this is due to the fact that in the @xmath74 iteration we have @xmath75 . following a similar approach as @xcite ,
the auxiliary function for the weighted euclidean distance can be formulated as : @xmath76 where @xmath77 is an @xmath78 diagonal matrix with @xmath79 and @xmath80 is the @xmath9 diagonal entry of @xmath81 and @xmath82 is element - wise multiplication . to solve the problem presented in ( [ scale_objective ] )
, the contribution of @xmath83 should be considered in the auxiliary function .
for that , a convex version of @xmath83 is employed : @xmath84 now the update rules can be obtained using the iterative version of ( [ reweighted_penalty ] ) .
this means that @xmath85 is updated in each iteration using the values of @xmath33 in the previous iteration . to form the penalized auxiliary function , @xmath86 , we add up @xmath87 with the contribution of @xmath72 to @xmath41 .
thus , @xmath86 can be written as : @xmath88.\end{gathered}\ ] ] it is worthwhile to mention that @xmath89 @xmath90 . since @xmath86 is convex , it can be easily minimized over @xmath72 by setting the gradient to zero .
hence the update rule is attained as : @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the @xmath9 element of the gradient @xmath93 . finding the update rule for @xmath43 is simple .
this is due to the fact that @xmath41 is not a function of @xmath43 .
hence , the update rule for @xmath43 is similar to the update rule for standard nmf , except the missing entries must be taken into account @xcite .
the update rules can be written in matrix form as : @xmath94 where @xmath82 is the element - wise multiplication and the division is also performed in an element - wise manner .
the obtained update rules in ( [ p_update_rule ] ) and ( [ gamma_update_rule ] ) are exploited alternatively to estimate @xmath43 and @xmath33 . then the missing entries of @xmath28 are predicted by @xmath95 .
however , by using the objective function in ( [ scale_objective ] ) , the optimization problem results in solutions with entries of @xmath33 tend toward @xmath53 and @xmath96 tends toward @xmath97 .
we take advantage of the scale ambiguity between @xmath43 and @xmath33 to avoid this issue .
let @xmath98 be a diagonal @xmath78 matrix with its @xmath9 diagonal entry equal to @xmath99 . in each iteration
, the rescaled matrix pair @xmath100 is used instead of the original matrix pair @xmath101 . as a practical scenario
, we should also consider the case when the secondary network has no information about the number of the pus , i.e. @xmath0 . in this case , the common dimension of matrices @xmath43 and @xmath33 is not known .
there have been some efforts in model order selection in nmf @xcite . in the numerical experiments ,
@xmath102 is used as the common dimension to factorize the data in such conditions .
this is only possible if the secondary network has some information about the upper bound of @xmath0 .
for the numerical experiments , one frequency channel is considered with @xmath103 active pus in the area .
figure [ topol ] illustrates the topology of the network .
incomplete measurements are collected from @xmath104 sus .
we use the same simulation environment and the same network topology as in @xcite .
the simulation parameters are set as follows , unless otherwise is stated .
the path loss is computed as @xmath105 , where @xmath106 is the distance , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 .
@xmath10 is computed by multiplying the pathloss by the fading coefficient @xmath109 where @xmath110 @xmath111 , and @xmath112 is circulary symmetric zero mean complex gaussian noise with variance @xmath113 @xcite .
pus activity is modeled by a first order markov model .
all the pus utilize the spectrum @xmath114 of the time slots .
transition matrix of the @xmath9 pu is @xmath115 and @xmath116 .
@xmath117 is the probability that the @xmath9 pu stops transmitting from time @xmath118 to @xmath6 and @xmath119 is the probability that the pu activates transmitting .
the parameter @xmath117 is uniformly distributed over @xmath120 $ ] . each time a pu becomes activated , it chooses the transmission power from a uniform distribution with support @xmath121 $ ] .
each su makes a measurement with @xmath122 of chance .
the measurements are contaminated by additive white gaussian noise .
the noise variance is @xmath123 for all the sus .
partial measurements are generated for @xmath124 time slots .
to reduce the computational burden , the first @xmath125 time slots are used to estimate @xmath43 .
next , by using the obtained @xmath43 and the update rule ( [ p_update_rule ] ) , @xmath33 is estimated for all @xmath126 time slots .
the regularization factor @xmath42 is set to @xmath127 and @xmath128 factors are used to factorize the data . figure [ truevspredicted ] shows the true power levels and the reconstructed one at a randomly selected su versus time for the time window of @xmath129 samples .
it can be seen that the missing entries are accurately recovered through the proposed method , and it is evident that the proposed algorithm can easily track abrupt changes in power level .
figure [ nmf_dl ] compares the rmse , averaged over sus , of the proposed method with two similar methods .
the method introduced in @xcite exploits the spatial correlation between adjacent sus measurements and semi - supervised dictionary learning ( ss - dl ) to estimate the missing entries . for the numerical results ,
the batch version of ss - dl is employed and the parameters are set to their optimal values .
furthermore , to emphasize the effect of the piecewise constant penalty , the results are also compared with the weighted nmf , i.e. wnmf @xcite .
wnmf employs binary weight matrix to deal with the missing entries .
this figure shows that the proposed method outperforms its competitors in different noise levels ( figure [ nmf_dl].(a ) ) and different probabilities of miss ( figure [ nmf_dl].(b ) ) .
@xmath130 denotes the ratio of the missing entries among the spectrum data . 1 monte carlo trials . , title="fig:",width=326 ] [ vsnoise ] 1 monte carlo trials .
, title="fig:",width=326 ] [ vspmiss ] this figure shows that wnmf and ss - dl almost perform the same for low noise variance and low @xmath130 .
however , for harsh environments with high noise variance or high @xmath130 , ss - dl produces more accurate results .
the pc - nmf method outperforms both methods in different noise levels and different probabilities of miss .
for instance , pc - nmf has @xmath131 less rmse compared to the ss - dl method for @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
this improvement in the performance does not increase the computational burden of the algorithm .
table [ time ] shows the running times for different methods averaged over @xmath134 monte carlo trials for @xmath132 , @xmath133 , and @xmath128 . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] [ time ] it is known that the nmf methods converge much faster than methods based on gradient descent @xcite
. however , table [ time ] also illustrates that the proposed method does not require more computational resources compared with wnmf .
to study the effect of the piecewise constant penalty on the output of the algorithm , figure [ pupowerlevel ] depicts the power level of two pus and the estimated activation levels using the introduced method and wnmf .
both methods can estimate the power levels up to a scale factor .
the number of factors is set to @xmath36 , i.e. @xmath135 .
this figure illustrates the fact that the proposed method produces a more accurate factorization by taking advantage of piecewise constant constraint as a prior information .
as it was expected , power levels estimated by pc - nmf are piecewise constant , while the results generated by wnmf are noisy .
in fact , the piecewise constant penalty decreases the effect of noise and fading .
moreover , the sharp transitions are preserved in the factors returned by pc - nmf .
by exploiting inherent structural feature of cognitive radio networks , we proposed a piecewise constant nmf approach that can decompose the data set into its components .
majorization - minimization framework is utilized to solve the optimization problem of the piecewise constant nmf .
numerical simulations suggest that this method is able to predict the missing entries in the spectrum sensing database accurately . | in this paper , we propose a missing spectrum data recovery technique for cognitive radio ( cr ) networks using nonnegative matrix factorization ( nmf ) .
it is shown that the spectrum measurements collected from secondary users ( sus ) can be factorized as product of a channel gain matrix times an activation matrix .
then , an nmf method with piecewise constant activation coefficients is introduced to analyze the measurements and estimate the missing spectrum data .
the proposed optimization problem is solved by a majorization - minimization technique .
the numerical simulation verifies that the proposed technique is able to accurately estimate the missing spectrum data in the presence of noise and fading .
nonnegative matrix factorization , cognitive radio network , spectrum sensing , missing data estimation |
quantum key distribution ( qkd ) involves the generation of a shared secret key between two parties via quantum signal transmission [ 1 ] , [ 2 ] .
( among other possible terms , we will often use the more appropriate generation " in lieu of distribution , " ignoring their fine distinction in conventional cryptography [ 3 ] . ) qkd is widely perceived to have been proved secure in various protocols [ 1 ] , [ 2 ] , in contrast to the lack of security proofs for conventional methods of encryption for privacy or key distribution. security proofs in qkd are highly technical and are also multi - disciplinary in nature , as is the case with the subject area of quantum cryptography itself .
theoretical qkd involves in its description and treatment various areas in quantum physics , information theory , and cryptography at an abstract and conceptual level .
it is difficult for non - experts in qkd security to make sense of the literature ; moreover , even experts are often not aware of certain basics in some of the relevant fields .
many who perform assessments on qkd security follow the vague community consensus on qkd security being guaranteed by rigorous proofs .
a common perception is that qkd gives perfect secrecy , " as asserted for example in a useful recent monograph on conventional cryptography [ 3 , p. 589 ] .
it is interesting to note that qkd is commonly taught to physics students as being an important application of quantum optics because qkd is provably secure . to our knowledge
, the provable security property is often taught as being self evident and is not questioned on any level ( recent advances in quantum hacking may be an exception ; however , such attacks are based on discrepancies between the model and real systems as opposed to the security of the model itself ) .
the commonly cited reason for no - cloning or quantum entanglement is very far from sufficient . even in the technical literature
, a qkd - generated key is often regarded as perfect whenever it is used in an application .
one main purpose of this paper is to correct such a misconception and to demonstrate how the imperfect generated key affects the security proofs themselves .
security proofs by their nature are conceptual , logical and mathematical yet indispensable for guaranteeing security .
cryptographic security can not be guaranteed by experiment , if only because possible attack scenarios can not be exhausted via experiment .
however , security is a most serious issue in cryptography and must be thoroughly and carefully analyzed [ 4 , two prefaces and ch . 1 ; see also quotes in appendix i ] .
_ the burden of proof _ is on one who makes the security claim , not on others to produce specific successful general attacks . in this paper
, we will describe the actual security theory situation of qkd with just enough technical materials for accurate statements on the results .
we will be able to describe some main security issues without going into the physics , and we can treat everything at a _ classical _ probability level , to which a _ quantum _ description invariably reduces .
we will discuss in what ways these security issues have been handled inadequately . some major work in the qkd security literature will be mentioned and also discussed in appendix i , which may help clarify the issues and illuminate the development that led to the current security situation . in appendix ii , we compare qkd to conventional cryptography and provide a preliminary assessment on the usefulness of qkd when conventional cryptography appears adequate .
( note that cryptography is a small and relatively minor subarea of computer security [ 4 ] .
it is the latter that results in news headlines . ) in appendix iii , some possible objections to certain points of this paper from the viewpoint of the current qkd literature are answered .
table 1 in section viii.b gives a summary comparison of various numerical values .
generally , perfect security can not be obtained in any key distribution scheme with security dependent on physical characteristics due to system imperfections mixed with the attacker s disturbance , which must be considered in the security model .
this is especially the case with qkd , which involves small signal levels .
we use the term qkd " in this paper to _ refer _ to protocols with security depending on information - disturbance tradeoffs [ 1 ] , [ 2 ] , excluding those based on other principles such as the kcq " approach in [ 5 ] , which permits stronger signals and for which no general security proof has yet been claimed . in qkd , one can at best generate a key that is close to perfect in some sense. this immediately raises the issue of a security criterion , its operational significance and its quantitative level .
security is very much a quantitative issue .
quantitative security is quite hard to properly define and to rigorously evaluate ; thus , there are few such results in the literature on conventional mathematics - based cryptography .
it is at least as hard in physics - based cryptography , and there is yet no true valid quantification of qkd security under all possible attacks . that there are problems and gaps in qkd security proofs has been discussed since 2003 in [ 6 , app . a ] , [ 7 ] , [ 5 , app .
a and b ] , [ 8 ] , culminating in the numerical adequacy issue in [ 9 ] in 2012 , which provides the trace distance criterion level for a so - called near - perfect " key .
this last numerical adequacy point is emphasized in [ 10 ] , and a reply is given in [ 11 ] , which in turn is replied to in [ 12 ] ; no further exchange on this topic has resulted . the basic point of [ 11 ] is that a trace distance level of @xmath0 is sufficient for security .
there have since been several arxiv papers that elaborate upon the several qkd security issues that have yet to be resolved .
this paper summarizes and supersedes those papers in a coherent framework for analyzing qkd security .
this paper shows in what ways , even at a value of @xmath0 , which is ten orders of magnitude beyond what is currently achievable , such a trace distance level does not provide adequate security guarantees in a cryptosystem that involves the use of a vast number of keys at such a level ; see section viii . before proceeding to a detailed treatment , we list the major problems of currently available qkd security proofs as follows : 1 . the chosen security criterion ,
namely , a quantum trace distance @xmath1 , has been misinterpreted .
the operational security guarantee that it yields does not cover some important security concerns .
the numerical security level that has been obtained is far from adequate .
the very strong level of guarantee asserted recently is derived from erroneous reasoning .
3 . the known security proofs are not complete nor justified at various stages in a valid manner , especially in connection with the major necessary step of error correction , which has not been treated in a rigorous manner .
a trace distance level guarantee of a key @xmath2 limits the information - theoretic security level that can be obtained when @xmath2 is used for message authentication , taking away an otherwise available security parameter that allows arbitrarily high levels of message authentication security .
there are many other serious issues facing qkd security proofs , many of which relating to physics and implementation .
these issues will not be discussed in this paper , which concentrates on a careful exposition of the above four points .
much of the technical content in this paper is conceptual analysis , especially on the use of probability in real - world applications .
the applications are not essentially mathematical or physical in nature , which is partly why they are easy to miss and result in various confusions .
sections iii.a , iv , v.c , viii.b , and appendix iii contain relevant clarifications on the subtle meaning of probability in real - world applications .
note that knowledge of physics , classical or quantum , is _ not _ required to understand the content of this paper .
furthermore , the relevant basic cryptography concepts will be explained when being introduced .
we briefly review the different representations of conventional and quantum cryptography in regard to the cryptographic goals of privacy and key distribution [ 3 ] .
may or may not be uniformly distributed.,width=288 ] in fig .
1 , the conventional stream cipher encryption of a data sequence @xmath3 for privacy is depicted .
a user alice transmits @xmath4 , which is the xor of the data bits @xmath5 and running key bits @xmath6 for each @xmath7 : @xmath8 we use uppercase to denote random variables and lower case to denote the values they take on .
thus , from ( 1 ) , alice transmits @xmath9 for given @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
a prior shared key bit sequence @xmath10 unknown to the attacker eve is known to alice and the other user bob , who can decrypt @xmath11 from @xmath12 by knowing @xmath6 .
the attacker eve would then learn nothing about @xmath13 from @xmath14 without knowing something about @xmath2 .
she knows nothing about @xmath2 when the @xmath15 are ( statistically ) independent bits with equal probability of being 0 or 1 .
this so - called one - time pad " encryption , her probability of obtaining the sequence @xmath13 correctly given that she knows @xmath14 through interception is equal to her _ a priori _ probability on @xmath13 .
for uniformly distributed @xmath13 , @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the bit length of the sequences .
( the vertical bar @xmath18 is always used in this paper to denote the bit length of the sequence within it . lower case @xmath19 are discrete probability distributions , and no continuous distributions will be used . )
we may represent this by @xmath20 , namely , the uniform random variable to eve .
thus , in addition to @xmath21 , which is the _ a priori _ probability of each @xmath22 , there is also no correlation of any type between the @xmath22s that eve can find .
this is perfect secrecy . "
the security under discussion is the _ information - theoretic security _ of the intrinsic uncertainty to eve .
( see section iii and appendix ii . )
the correlation among bits in @xmath2 is a most important feature often missed in cryptography , especially in connection with the trace distance ( statistical distance ) criterion , which is presented in section iv.a and also in section iv.b in the context of distinguishability .
the goal of qkd is to generate a key @xmath2 , which ideally is @xmath23 , by transmitting bits @xmath24 from alice to bob via quantum signals with no use of shared secret keys . in reality
, a prior shared secret key is needed to start executing the qkd protocol , at least for message authentication against man - in - the - middle attacks .
.,width=288 ] the qkd key generation process is depicted in fig .
2 . for definiteness ,
the original bb84 protocol [ 1 ] is schematically described in the following , which contains the key idea of qkd .
a sequence of quantum optical signals is modulated by the data @xmath24 and sent from alice to bob , with each bit @xmath25 modulating a separate quantum signal .
( we use @xmath24 to distinguish these key generation data from the data @xmath13 on which the qkd key @xmath2 is used to encrypt , as in fig . 1 . ) in bb84 , each quantum signal is a single photon in a so - called
qubit" , a two - dimensional quantum state space
. eve could intercept and set her probe on the qubits during signal transmission .
bob measures on one of the two bb84 bases randomly upon receiving each qubit signal and obtains a bit value of 0 or 1 .
after the entire sequence is measured , bob publicly announces which basis he measured on each @xmath7 , and the ones mismatched " to alice s transmitted signal are discarded .
then , a portion of the remaining matched ones is used to check the frequency of bit error , which is called the _ quantum bit error rate _ ( qber ) .
the other portion is called the _ sifted key _ @xmath26
from which the final key @xmath2 is to be generated . for our purposes
, there is __no need _ _ to understand the exact physics and underlying rationale of the above procedure. the only thing that matters for the purposes of this paper is the representation of eve s knowledge on the generated @xmath2 via her final classical observed value @xmath14 by the joint distribution @xmath27 .
eve s probe inevitably disturbs the quantum signals if she learns anything from the probe , a characteristic quantum effect of the information - disturbance tradeoff , which has no classical analog .
it is usually assumed that the users would regard all disturbance as indicated by the qber level to be from eve s interception .
they would estimate how much information " eve can learn about @xmath24 with such a disturbance. ( the vague word
information " would be specified precisely in context . )
the users have to correct the errors in @xmath26 to obtain a useful key @xmath2 .
such errors would always be present from system imperfections due to the low signal level .
error correction is typically accomplished by an ordinary error correcting code ( ecc ) on @xmath26 , as indicated in fig .
2 . the users then transfer the estimate of eve s information on @xmath26 to the error - free @xmath28 .
if eve s information is below a certain threshold level , the users may employ privacy amplification" [ 1 ] on @xmath28 to eliminate it .
the privacy amplification code ( pac ) usually involves linear hashing compression [ 3 ] on @xmath28 to a final generated key @xmath2 with bit length @xmath29 , which is a small fraction of @xmath30 . what is the security desired and claimed for the qkd - generated key @xmath2 ?
because this is a physical and in particular a quantum cryptosystem , there are many mutually exclusive different observed values @xmath14 that eve could obtain from her choice of quantum probe and based on the quantum measurement on the probe .
she could estimate various properties of @xmath2 from the @xmath14 that she obtains , each with a certain probability of success .
she also would gather side information relevant to improving her estimates before she measures her probe and makes estimates .
such side information would include the bb84 bases open announcement and the specific pac employed in the qkd round .
it may also involve the specific ecc used .
the users goal is to make eve s probability of success in obtaining any characteristic of @xmath2 close to the level whereby @xmath2 is perfect , i.e. , when @xmath23 .
an especially significant attack on privacy encryption is the _ known - plaintext attack _ ( kpa ) , which is the main vulnerability of conventional mathematics - based encryption . the _ ciphertext - only attack _ , for which @xmath31 to eve , that qkd security analyses focus upon is usually not considered as a serious risk for symmetric - key ciphers [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] , [ 8 ] , which can be further substantiated in an information - theoretic manner .
a brief summary is given in appendix ii , which compares qkd with conventional cryptography .
a kpa runs as follows .
eve may know a portion of the data @xmath13 that is encrypted with @xmath2 and hence knows part of @xmath2 because @xmath14 is open .
she may then learn something about the remainder of @xmath2 through correlations among the bits in an imperfect @xmath2 and hence something about the unknown portion of @xmath13 .
it is such a kpa when a qkd key is being used that must be protected against .
this implies that correlations between bits in @xmath2 must be addressed in qkd security .
perfect secrecy _ against all attack possibilities would require that @xmath2 is uniformly distributed to eve for any @xmath14 that she may possibly obtain that is allowed by the laws of quantum physics together with all her side information .
thus far , a security criterion is chosen to measure the difference between an imperfect key and a perfect key with a quantitative security level .
the term __unconditional security _ _ was coined [ 13 ] and widely used to include the following two conditions : + _ unconditional security : _ 1 .
complete generality on possible attacks ; 2 .
quantitative security level can be made as close to perfect as desired .
the data bit length @xmath32 or @xmath29 in a qkd round is often taken to be a
_ security parameter _
@xmath33 , namely , the quantitative security level improves with increasing @xmath33 and becomes perfect as @xmath34 [ 13 ] .
such unconditional security for qkd is often claimed because it distinguishes qkd from conventional cryptography ; moreover , it is the only advantage of qkd ( see appendix ii ) .
security against only some attacks means that the qkd approach may not lead to good security in the future when other attacks become practical .
the latter is often taken to be the situation with conventional cryptography .
unconditional security in qkd remains asserted on occasion , both theoretically for a given protocol and physical models and experimentally as potential or even actualized possibility .
however , _ no _ security parameter has ever been found for any qkd protocol at any key generation rate , and certainly , @xmath32 and @xmath29 are not such parameters , as will be shown in section iii.b .
to explain the process and requirements of a security proof , we proceed to quantitatively describe the information - theoretic security of a cryptosystem.
it is sometimes asserted that a cryptographic security criterion is a matter of definition " and interpretation , " although this is highly misleading and can be considered incorrect .
there are definite specific characteristics in a cryptographic goal on which users want to protect against successful attacks
. a security criterion would be inadequate for a security task it is supposed to serve if it does not lead to a guarantee at an adequate quantitative level .
the range of adequate levels may depend on the specific application ; however , one can not sensibly define " a protocol to be secure if its security criterion and level do not cover such possible attacks .
interpretation " of a mathematical statement , on security or any other matter , may be correct or incorrect when it is applied to a real - world situation .
moreover , there have been many erroneous interpretations in qkd security analysis .
these errors are mainly conceptual errors , not mathematical nor mainly mathematical mistakes .
these errors often involve reading ordinary meanings into a word that in context is a technical term that carries only a precise technical meaning .
we will see many examples of these errors in sections iii to viii of this paper .
the operationally or empirically meaningful security criteria on the secrecy of any shared key string @xmath2 for privacy or key distribution , whether it is generated by qkd or any method , are the attacker eve s probabilities or rates of success in correctly obtaining various parts or characteristics of @xmath2 , including @xmath2 itself in its entirety .
this is the case even in complexity - based security , as we will see .
the quantitative information - theoretic security of a key @xmath2 is often described by a single - number security criterion , such as eve s shannon mutual information @xmath35 on @xmath2 [ 14 ] through her observation @xmath14 , which she may obtain by intercepting the signal transmission .
this @xmath35 is defined [ 14 ] from the joint distribution @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the distribution of the generated @xmath2 obtained by the users under a given quantum probe from eve .
the conditional probability @xmath38 is specified through the cryptosystem representation and eve s measurement result , from which she derives her estimate of a characteristic @xmath39 , denoted by @xmath40 , which is a function of @xmath41 . for example , from @xmath41 , she could estimate @xmath42 as @xmath43 . because she takes @xmath44 to be @xmath2 , we can simplify our notation by simply writing @xmath2 itself instead of @xmath44 , i.e. , @xmath2 is being observed from eve s viewpoint .
thus , @xmath38 gives the conditional probability that the @xmath41 observed by eve given @xmath45 is the actual key generated .
eve can now derive @xmath46 for all possible @xmath45 through @xmath38 and bayes rule .
the criterion @xmath35 gives the number of shannon bits @xmath35 concerning @xmath2 known to eve because , in this case , one can write @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the conditional entropy of @xmath2 given @xmath14 [ 14 ] . note that , as we just indicated , eve has a _ full distribution _ on her knowledge of @xmath2 given any observation @xmath41 with the conditional distribution @xmath46 .
we may assume that all the side information that eve may possess has been considered in her final @xmath46 .
we order the @xmath49 possible values of @xmath2 entering @xmath46 and suppress its @xmath41 dependence so that , in various abbreviated notations , eve has @xmath50 with @xmath51 this probability profile is the complete information " eve has on @xmath2 given her observation @xmath41 .
any single number criterion , such as @xmath35 , _ merely _ expresses a constraint on @xmath52 . when @xmath53 , we have @xmath54 , and eve knows nothing about @xmath13 . for a given level @xmath55 ,
what does this imply for the security of @xmath2? this question arises for any criterion that is used as a theoretic quantity . a single - number information - theoretic measure on the uncertainty or
information " is a theoretical quantity whose operational or empirical meaning needs to be independently explained [ 15 , preface ] . in the context of ordinary communications , the two theoretic quantities entropy and mutual information are related to the empirical data rate and error rate through the shannon source and channel coding theorems
. what would be the operational meaning of these quantities in the context of cryptography ?
one __cannot _ _ simply assume the word information " for a technical concept would carry its ordinary meaning in any application , especially not quantitatively .
shannon himself emphasized such a danger early on [ 16 ] . in shannon s cryptography paper [ 17 ] ,
he used such information measures ; however , except for the ideal case of @xmath56 for a one - time pad , he did not explain their operational cryptographic significance . in cryptography , one
is concerned that eve should not be able to correctly estimate various quantities associated with a key @xmath2 from her observation and side information .
such success is generally obtained only probabilistically. therefore , this operational security requirement translates to eve _ not _ being able to estimate such quantities well , i.e. , not with appreciable probability . in the case of perfect secrecy ,
eve s @xmath52 above equals the uniform @xmath57 . therefore ,
in the general imperfect case , her estimate probabilities as derived from @xmath52 should be close to that derived from @xmath57 . in particular , the exact level needs to be quantitatively compared to that from @xmath57 and its numerical adequacy to ensure security for a given application .
thus , given a security criterion level that sets a constraint on @xmath52 above , we would need to ascertain what success probabilities eve may possibly obtain .
specifically , we would compare the @xmath58 from any @xmath46 not ruled out by the security criterion constraint to the @xmath23 level : @xmath59 we use the notation @xmath60 to explicitly demonstrate that the @xmath58 level refers to the @xmath2 with a distribution @xmath46 .
clearly , @xmath60 , eve s maximum probability of correctly obtaining @xmath2 , needs to be sufficiently small for any meaningful claim to security even if it may be far larger than the @xmath61 level. we would address such a general security probability guarantee based on security measures in sections iv and v. their connections to the numerical security levels of concrete protocols are discussed in section viii .
when @xmath2 is used to encrypt data @xmath13 , part of @xmath62 may be known to eve in a kpa , as discussed in section ii .
let @xmath63 be the subsequence of @xmath2 known to eve , say , when @xmath2 is used as a one - time pad , and let @xmath64 be a subsequence of @xmath65 , @xmath65 being the remainder of @xmath2 excluding @xmath63 . then , eve s optimal success probabilities from such an attack should be compared to the perfect security level when @xmath23 , @xmath66 where @xmath67 , @xmath68 , and @xmath69 are the sequences obtained from @xmath57 with the same bit positions as @xmath63 , @xmath65 , and @xmath64 , respectively . in general , eve may possess only statistical information on @xmath13 without knowing part of it exactly .
we will not address this more complicated situation in this paper .
it is important to note that we may write 1 .
operational guarantee for an event = + rule out its possible occurrence with a high probability an average number of occurrences ( sample mean ) is _ not _ an operational guarantee because the number of occurrence is itself a random quantity from a finite number of trials , each of which has the same probability distribution .
this does not mean that an average can not be used as a measure of security .
it means that an average is a less accurate measure compared to a probability statement on individual occurrences or on a multiple - use sample mean .
if the variance is known in addition to the average ( mean ) , the probability statement on the sample mean can be made , and operational guarantees can be restored .
if only the average is known , the markov inequality can be used to provide an accurate individual probability statement , as shown in section v.c .
complexity - based security is operationally equivalent to the following success probability characterization .
let @xmath70 be the total number of possibilities that eve can attempt computationally among the @xmath71 possible @xmath2 values to determine if a particular value is the correct value , as in opening a safe .
it is easy to show that , with a uniform chance of success for each trial , her overall probability of success is , for a uniform probability distribution on the @xmath72 possible cases , @xmath73 eq .
( 7 ) can be readily generalized when eve s success probability for each trial is not uniform but known [ 5 ] .
indeed , it can be observed that there is no difference between complexity - based security and information - theoretic ( probabilistic ) security if eve is given a sufficient number of attempts to determine the correctness of a given @xmath45 , as in the case of cracking a safe .
she would need at most @xmath72 trials and on average @xmath74 trials .
the problem of complexity - based security is that it is very hard to prove a lower bound on the number of trials eve needs for a given problem , and no such proof exists for any common problem .
it will be observed that it is also very hard to prove qkd security , and no such proof yet exists as well. in the literature on classical noise - based key generation within information - theoretic security [ 18 ] , [ 19 ] , [ 20], both before and after the emergence of qkd in 1984 [ 21 ] , the security criterion used is the mutual information @xmath75 between the generated key @xmath2 and eve s observation @xmath14 .
no relation of this information - theoretic quantity to eve s operational success probability was given until [ 5]. the issue will be discussed further in the next section in connection with the statistical distance criterion .
here , we would like to remove a major misconception about security proofs that use the mutual information criterion , first discussed in appendix a of ref [ 5 ] and which directly carries over to the qkd case for the @xmath1 criterion as well [ 5 ] , [ 22 ] .
apart from the problem of bounding @xmath60 from @xmath35 , the latter we will abbreviate as @xmath76 , the asymptotic security proofs that show , with @xmath77 , @xmath78 were erroneously supposed as proofs that @xmath2 is asymptotically perfect .
that is confusing the meaning of a limit because @xmath79 is not a number .
what occurs here is that the convergence rate of @xmath76 to @xmath80 determines the asymptotic security level as follows . from lemma 2 in [ 5 ] , for any @xmath81 , it is possible that @xmath82 eq .
( 9 ) states that , under the constraint of a given level of @xmath35 , there are possible @xmath37 with @xmath58 at the same quantitative level as @xmath83 .
thus , a very insecure @xmath2 , compared to @xmath57 , can satisfy ( 8) , even when @xmath76 converges exponentially in @xmath84 : @xmath85 for a constant @xmath86 .
it is possible given eq .
( 10 ) that @xmath87 , as compared to @xmath61 for a uniform key .
apart from condition ( i ) of unconditional security in section ii , such an asymptotic proof of ( 8) does not imply condition ( ii ) for unconditional security . indeed , it does not even imply @xmath2 is in any sense near perfect , as the above case ( 10 ) shows .
we may mention that the current quantum criterion @xmath1 suffers from the same exponential problem as will be discussed in the following section . although @xmath1 can be directly used in a finite @xmath84 protocol, this exponential problem is why relatively large and insecure levels of @xmath1 are obtained in a real protocol with sizable key rates .
the quantum generalization of @xmath76 is called accessible information " , which is the maximum mutual information @xmath35 that eve can obtain from any quantum measurement on her probe. such an additional issue of measurement optimization is characteristic of quantum detection [ 23 ] , [ 24 ] .
this issue plays no role in our context after we take @xmath76 to be eve s accessible information so that the quantum security situation reduces to a classical one under such @xmath76 .
the early proofs of qkd security up until 2004 are based on the use of such an accessible information criterion as well as the current proof on the so - called measurement - device - independent approach [ 25 ] .
thus , the proofs all suffer directly from the problems explained above and remain in error even after the proof is converted to one with the trace distance criterion . a particularly influential early security proof is given in [ 26 ] , which is the basis of the heuristic generalizations used to include various system imperfections in [ 27 ] .
the side information that eve has from the open announcement of ecc and pac of fig .
2 are considered in the proofs of [ 13 ] , [ 26 ] , [ 27 ] . in section vii
, we will discuss how they considered in more recent proofs and what problems are yet to be resolved.
the mutual information criterion does not directly guarantee security against known - plaintext attacks ( kpa ) .
we require bounds on the conditional probability ( 6 ) when part of @xmath2 , namely , @xmath63 , is known to eve so that correlation between the bits in @xmath2 will not leak much information about @xmath65 , namely , the remainder of @xmath2 . in qkd , this kpa problem is considered as one of universal composition " [ 28 ] , [ 29 ] , [ 30 ] in which the security when @xmath2 is being used in an application is taken to be a composition " security issue .
although kpa security is crucial and is the usual concern of privacy in conventional ciphers , as noted above , it was not addressed or discussed in the qkd literature until ref [ 28 ] twenty years after ref [ 21 ] appeared .
this topic was addressed in [ 28 ] as a composition security issue , with the conclusion that security is ensured when the accessible information goes to @xmath80 exponentially in @xmath29 .
that is directly contradicted by ( 10 ) above even simply for ciphertext - only attack security .
then , in ref [ 31 ] , it was noted in a specific counter - example that a single - bit kpa leak is possible under the accessible information criterion due to the phenomenon of quantum information locking " , and the trace distance criterion @xmath1 was proposed as an improved criterion ( the @xmath1 criterion was also discussed in [ 28 ] ) with the claim that , under @xmath88 , the probability that @xmath2 is not perfect is at most @xmath89 .
specifically , @xmath1 is claimed to be the maximum probability that the generated @xmath2 is not perfect , such probability being called the _ failure probability .
_ apparently , the accessible information criterion is much worse .
under such a criterion , knowing @xmath90 number of bits in @xmath2 may fully reveal the remainder of @xmath2 [ 32 ] .
such a maximum failure probability interpretation of @xmath1 , as originally given in [ 29 ] , [ 30 ] and continuously maintained in many subsequent papers and in the general review [ 2 ] , is _ incorrect _ ; however , it has been maintained publicly in the qkd community to date , despite its flaw having been revealed and explained in early 2009 [ 33 ] , [ 34 ] , in [ 5 ] and [ 8 ] , and in several arxiv papers until the fall of 2014 in [ 22 ] . only in ref
[ 35 ] is such an interpretation vaguely combined with a correct security consequence of @xmath1 ( eq . ( 14 ) below ) but with no acknowledgment of previous errors .
part of the reason is likely that the indistinguishability advantage " interpretation of @xmath1 is employed instead for validation of this incorrect interpretation , which serves to justify qkd security that can not be otherwise obtained . in sections
iv and v , we will treat this issue in detail to identify the major security issues involved and those that have not been resolved with the @xmath1 criterion .
there are _ two _ different derivations of the failure probability interpretation of @xmath1 in the qkd literature , which we will treat in sections iv.a and iv.b .
this incorrect failure probability interpretation of the qkd security criterion @xmath1 is prevalent , and the distinguishability advantage " derivation in section iv.b remains widely quoted and discussed as validation of the interpretation .
the issue is of major importance because the criterion issue and its ramifications lie at the foundation of information theoretically secure key generation , both classically and in the quantum case .
thus , the full treatment of this issue in this section is very much warranted .
we proceed by first explaining how a security criterion functions in a physical cryptosystem where signal transmission can be intercepted . as described in section iii.a , based on her attack and the physical system representation , eve could derive a conditional probability distribution @xmath46 on the various possible values of @xmath2 given her observation @xmath14 .
she also has side information from the execution of the protocol , namely , the public announcements in the qkd case , which we can label as @xmath91 .
we use the following notational abbreviations by suppressing the @xmath41 and @xmath91 dependences @xmath92 specifically , the distribution @xmath37 applies to a given @xmath91 and @xmath41 . the @xmath93 are ordered as in ( 4 ) so that a @xmath45 value that leads to the value @xmath60 is a most likely estimate of @xmath2 from eve s given @xmath91 and @xmath41 .
note that it is this whole probability profile @xmath94 that represents the general results of eve s attack , which _ are not _ simply an estimate of @xmath2 , and as we will see , the results can not be replaced by a single numerical criterion . in a classical situation , @xmath94 is obtained from the channel " transition probability @xmath95 and the side information @xmath91 . in the quantum case , there would be infinitely many such transition probabilities , depending on what quantum probe and what quantum measurement eve chooses to make .
a security proof has to address all such possible @xmath37 under a specific class of attacks or all possible attacks allowed by the law of physics , as in condition ( i ) of unconditional security .
it has been explicitly shown in section iii that an information - theoretic single - number security criterion merely puts a constraint on what possible @xmath37 eve may obtain , and it must satisfy the criterion constraint . for mutual information , the constraint states that @xmath94 must not give a higher @xmath76 value that is ruled out by the security proof . under the @xmath76 criterion , @xmath60 given by eqs .
( 9 ) and ( 10 ) shows that @xmath96 exponentially in @xmath29 does not imply that @xmath2 provides good security asymptotically . here
, we ignore the random variations in all parameters except @xmath45 by focusing on @xmath37 .
security will be weakened when these random variations are considered in sections v and viii .
classically , it is already more convenient theoretically to measure the imperfection of @xmath2 by its statistical distance ( variational distance [ 14 ] , kolmogorov distance ) @xmath97 from the uniform distribution @xmath57 than by @xmath76 as follows
. for two probability distributions @xmath52 and @xmath98 on the same sample space , the @xmath99 is defined to be @xmath100 thus , @xmath101 . from the well - known inequality in
[ 14 , eq .
( 11.137 ) ] , it immediately follows that , for any subsequence or segment " @xmath102 of @xmath2 and denoting @xmath97 by @xmath103 similar to @xmath76 , @xmath104 the result in [ 14 , eq .
( 11.137 ) ] applies to any probability value @xmath105 and hence to the maximum @xmath106 in particular . under the constraint @xmath107 , it is easy to show by explicit construction [ 5 ] that the bound ( 13 ) can be achieved by many permissible @xmath37 .
( we will often omit the unnecessary @xmath108 or @xmath107 in the following and simply set a @xmath1 or @xmath103 level . ) in particular , for any @xmath102 , one can achieve the bound ( 13 ) with equality .
the case of the entire key @xmath109 for the total compromise probability @xmath110 is of special importance .
these classical results directly apply to the quantum case in which a quantum trace distance @xmath111 is defined between eve s probe and an ideal quantum state to the users . after eve measures on her probe ,
a trace distance bound on eve s attack simply translates to a bound on @xmath97. such a bound constrains the @xmath37 that eve could obtain from any probe and quantum measurement .
thus , in this paper , one can _ regard _ @xmath112 as @xmath113 in the context of a quantum protocol . note that ( 14 ) shows the _
exponential problem _ in numerical security guarantee through @xmath103 similar to ( 10 ) above .
an exponentially small @xmath114 only gives security on @xmath60 corresponding to an @xmath115-bit uniform key after dropping the small @xmath116 factor in ( 14 ) . in particular , achieving ( 14 ) with equality already _ shows _ that the failure probability interpretation of @xmath103 is logically incorrect because it does not include the @xmath117 factor .
the original interpretation of the quantum trace distance @xmath113 , which may be abbreviated as @xmath1 , is based on a failure probability " interpretation on the classical @xmath103 , which @xmath118 would reduce to upon eves measurement on her probe .
a key @xmath2 is called @xmath89-secure " when @xmath108 .
it is stated in [ 30 , p.414 ] that an @xmath89-secure key can be considered _
identical _ to an _ ideal _ ( perfect ) key- except with probability @xmath89 " ( emphasis in original statement ) .
in addition , in [ 29 , p.414 ] , it is stated that
the real and the ideal setting can be considered identical with probability at least @xmath119 " .
therefore , the failure " in the failure probability " refers to @xmath2 being not perfect , and a _ failure probability _ @xmath120
guarantee means that it is rigorously proved that there is a maximum probability @xmath89 that @xmath2 fails to be perfect .
this unambiguous and incorrect interpretation is repeated in many papers ; see note [ 25 ] of ref [ 8 ] for a collection of cases .
this is also explicitly asserted in the review [ 2 ] and in the most complete qkd security proof available to date [ 36 ] . this error has never been acknowledged , and the failure probability interpretation is widely perceived to be correct . the valid consequence , eq .
( 14 ) , of a @xmath1 guarantee is stated explicitly in [ 35 ] ; however , the incorrect interpretation is maintained as a vague paraphrasing without noting the difference , and an indistinguishability argument is offered for such an interpretation .
the security consequences of an incorrect interpretation will be presented in sections v to viii .
removing such a misinterpretation is important to obtaining true and proven security . in section iv.a , we will analyze the errors committed in drawing the failure probability interpretation . in section iv.b , we will do the same for the indistinguishability " argument , which is often taken to imply the same incorrect interpretation . in sections iv - viii
, we will see in many places how the wrong interpretation misrepresents the security situation , attributing a security guarantee to @xmath1 that it does not provide .
the above failure probability claim was drawn from prop .
2.1.1 in [ 29 ] , which is the same as lemma 1 in [ 30 ] .
it is re - stated as theorem a.6 in [ 35 ] .
the claim states that , for two random variables @xmath13 and @xmath14 in the same space with probability distributions @xmath121 and @xmath122 that are marginals of a joint distribution @xmath123 , one may obtain @xmath124 generally , for arbitrary @xmath123 , one obtains the following coupling inequality " [ 37 , sections i.2 and i.5 ] , @xmath125 thus , ( 15 ) amounts to the assertion that the bound ( 16 ) can be achieved by some @xmath123 . applying ( 15 ) with @xmath126 and @xmath127
, the probability @xmath128 is taken to be a probability that @xmath2 is not @xmath57 , and the failure probability interpretation of @xmath103 was thus drawn .
this is an example of interpreting mathematical symbols incorrectly when addressing real - world applications .
there are several other such examples of incorrectly connecting mathematics and the real world in qkd security analysis , say , in connection with indistinguishability " and universal composition " , as we will see later .
the symbol @xmath129 merely abbreviates the probability of an event in which the outcome of @xmath13 equals the outcome of @xmath14 from an applicable joint distribution @xmath123 , namely , @xmath130 this does not say anything about the whole @xmath13 and @xmath14 themselves , as the failure probability interpretation claims .
more importantly , there is no joint distribution at play in this qkd situation other than the independent product distribution @xmath131 , much less one that achieves the bound ( 16 ) .
the incorrect failure probability interpretation reads into ( 15 ) meaning which is not warranted . that it is wrong
can be observed directly [ 5 ] from a @xmath37 that achieves the bound ( 14 ) , which has the additional factor @xmath116 exceeding what is given by the failure probability interpretation .
when @xmath132 , the two distributions are necessarily different because @xmath133 if and only if @xmath134 . in what sense
then can @xmath23 hold with a probability when @xmath135 ?
such a probabilistic interpretation for given @xmath121 and @xmath122 may be represented mathematically by the existence of a distribution @xmath136 such that , from the theorem of total probability , @xmath137 for a probability @xmath86 , in this case , @xmath138 . because @xmath136 is a probability distribution , eq . ( 18 ) is easily shown [ 38 ] to hold if and only if , for @xmath139 and @xmath127 , @xmath140 for large @xmath72 , up to which @xmath7 varies , eq .
( 19 ) implies all @xmath93 take essentially the same value of approximately @xmath86 , and hence , @xmath52 must be nearly uniform .
this condition ( 19 ) can not be satisfied for @xmath141 [ 8 ] . for any @xmath86 ,
( 19 ) implies a uniformity on @xmath142 that does not follow from simply a guarantee on @xmath103 .
specific counter examples can be easily constructed .
thus , several errors are committed in the original derivation of the incorrect failure probability interpretation , any of which would invalidate the derivation .
we omit a detailed discussion on the first two points , which are rather self evident . 1 .
there is no reason to expect that maximizing @xmath123 is in effect so that eq .
( 15 ) holds despite ( 16 ) .
the mathematical representation of the failure probability interpretation of @xmath103 is not given via a joint distribution @xmath143 , which is irrelevant to such an interpretation .
the correct representation of the failure probability interpretation is given by eq .
( 18 ) , which can not hold for @xmath144 and which is also not warranted for any @xmath86 because of ( 19 ) .
note that @xmath113 from ( 14 ) gives the _ total compromise probability " _
@xmath60 of the whole @xmath2 associated with @xmath113 , which is _ not _ the probability @xmath145 that @xmath2 turns out to be non - uniform , apart from the @xmath117 factor .
this is because @xmath120 implies @xmath146 but not the other way around , as we have shown .
a quantum trace distance measure @xmath147 obtained by dividing @xmath1 by @xmath29 and called the _ failure probability per bit _ is introduced in [ 35 ] , which clearly gives a substantially lower failure rate than does @xmath1 itself .
it is a misleading terminology because it suggests that the bits in @xmath2 are statistically independent .
with such an interpretation , the total compromise probability @xmath60 becomes not ( 14 ) but the following @xmath145 : @xmath148 two errors are committed in @xmath145 above obtained from a given @xmath113 . instead of applying @xmath149 to @xmath2 as a whole , it is arbitrarily reduced by @xmath150 to give a per bit " level @xmath151 _ and _ is then applied to each bit of @xmath2 independently regardless of the length @xmath29 . as a result , the @xmath60 level is greatly underestimated as the @xmath145 in ( 20 ) . generally , dividing a quantity such as @xmath76 and @xmath103 by the size @xmath29 does not produce a bit - independent quantity , as a matter of course .
this incorrect interpretation of failure probability per bit " is used in [ 35 , p.14 ] : 1 . for example , if an implementation of a qkd protocol produces a key at a rate of 1 mbit / s with a failure per bit of @xmath152 , then this protocol can be run for the age of the universe and still have an accumulated failure strictly less than 1 . "
the failure probability per bit here is @xmath153 with the @xmath145 of ( 20 ) .
the numerical security situation of ( f ) is given in section viii.b .
the failure probability per bit interpretation misses the crucial point that the significance of a given @xmath154 level depends strongly on @xmath29
. a level of @xmath155 may be good for @xmath156 but is poor for @xmath157 .
on the other hand , the guaranteed level ( 13 ) gives the same bound @xmath113 on the difference from a uniform distribution value @xmath158 independently of the length @xmath159 .
thus , a @xmath113 value that appears to be small may actually be relatively large for a long @xmath2 or subsequence @xmath102 .
this confusion occurs in the same manner in the following distinguishability advantage interpretation of @xmath1 .
the indistinguishability argument was originally used in [ 28 ] and previously to argue that the trace distance @xmath1 in the quantum case or the statistical distance @xmath103 in the classical case is a good measure of how close @xmath2 is to an ideal situation for the users .
it is precisely formulated as a distinguishability advantage statement for the binary decision problem of discriminating between the two distributions for @xmath2 and @xmath57 .
we will simply consider the @xmath103 case because the quantum detection problem reduces to a classical one once the ( optimal ) quantum measurement is fixed .
for the distinguishability advantage interpretation to serve as a functional security criterion , say , on kpa , one must first write down what the interpretation asserts quantitatively for a given problem .
it appears , as this section will describe in detail , that the incorrect failure probability interpretation of section iv.a is being asserted .
specifically , distinguishability is supposed to provide a justification of the interpretation .
in addition to the counter examples of sections iv.a and v.a to the failure probability interpretation of @xmath1 , we show in this section how such a justification is conceptually invalid .
consider the well - known classical binary decision problem of deciding between two hypotheses h~0~ and h~1~ from an observed random variable with conditional distribution @xmath160 and @xmath161 for the two hypotheses . the maximum probability of a correct decision @xmath162 is given by @xmath163 where @xmath164 and @xmath58 are the _ a priori _ probabilities of h~0~ and h~1~. in ( 21 ) , the @xmath165 is defined exactly as in ( 12 ) , with @xmath166 and @xmath167 taking the place of @xmath168 and @xmath169 .
when @xmath170 , the second term on the right - hand side of ( 21 ) becomes @xmath171 in terms of an usual statistical distance .
for this equal _ a priori _ probability case , @xmath103 becomes the distinguishability advantage " of knowing @xmath37 compared to the no observation case with the a posteriori probabilities of h~0~ and h~1~ equal to the _ a priori _ probability @xmath172 .
thus , it is thought that if @xmath103 is small , @xmath2 is hardly distinguishable " from @xmath57 .
it is easily observed from ( 21 ) that @xmath162 is biased toward hypothesis h~0~ when @xmath173 and similarly for h~1~. when @xmath164 goes to 1 , @xmath162 for h~0~ also goes to 1 , as it should intuitively .
it is not known how ( 21 ) is related to the distinguishability advantage @xmath174 when @xmath175 .
thus , as it can already been observed from simply the problem formulation , the criterion @xmath103 can only admit a distinguishability advantage interpretation in cryptography , if at all , for @xmath176 , with @xmath177 being the _ a priori _ probability @xmath164 of the hypothesis h~0~ that the situation is perfect for the users and @xmath178 for the actual situation where eve has made an observation described by her @xmath37 .
it is our contention that this requirement of @xmath179 is not realistically meaningful , and furthermore , _ no _ quantitative security conclusion on eve s success probabilities can be drawn from such interpretation ; in particular , the bound ( 13 ) or ( 14 ) must be derived mathematically from the mathematical expression of @xmath103 with _ no _ extraneous interpretation .
the following already presents that the conclusion of the real situation being indistinguishable " from an ideal one or having distinguishability advantage @xmath103 " can not be validly drawn .
the conditional probability whereby the situation is ideal for the @xmath180 case from binary discrimination is given by@xmath181 why would the ideal situation have such a high probability close to @xmath172 for any @xmath182 ?
this is because the _ a priori _
probability @xmath177 is taken to be 1/2 to begin with even though it should be 0 .
indeed , if it makes sense to assign an _ a priori _ probability to the real and ideal situations in a binary discrimination problem , the _ a priori _ probability of the real situation should be @xmath183 , and the ideal situation should be @xmath80 .
this is also the conclusion drawn from ( 18)-(19 ) above .
however , what if one simply ponders the decision problem with @xmath184 ? then , the conclusion of such a problem can not be applied to any real - world problem .
this is because such a discrimination problem has no empirical meaning because we all know we are in the real situation where eve s presence is assured .
if this may not be the case , the problem should be formulated as one with all possible unknown probabilities of eve s absence or false alarms " [ 39 ] and not one with a fixed _ a priori _ probability .
furthermore , eve never cares to make such a discrimination ; her objective is to learn about @xmath2 .
this is another case of reading into mathematics an unwarranted assertion about the real world .
we will elaborate this point further in the remainder of this section because there is a similar use of @xmath103 in conventional cryptography that we can not go into in this paper and that lends unwarranted security significance to indistinguishability " .
( in particular , correlations between the future bits are not accounted for in the single - bit distinguisher " prediction , similar to what we indicated above at the end of subsection iv.a . )
the problem of a metaphysical " distinguishability interpretation can be observed from the fact that there are _ many _ hypothetical situations , say , one with any @xmath103 level , in addition to the @xmath185 ideal case .
should we conduct multiple - hypothesis decision making ?
why not a binary one with one situation less secure than the real one ? why would such a decision allow one to conclude all the features of the decided upon hypothesis , which are simply given by fiat ?
one major problem of using such an distinguishability advantage argument is that it _ becomes _ in one s mind an _ indistinguishability _ statement when the distinguishability advantage @xmath103 is small .
indeed , the real situation and the ideal situation are then taken to be distinguishable and hence different only with probability @xmath103 .
thus , @xmath103 becomes the failure probability interpretation of the previous section !
such an explicit interpretation of quantitative indistinguishability as failure probability is common ; see for example [ 40 , p.3 ] .
moreover , it appears to be used by many as a valid derivation of the failure probability interpretation of @xmath103 despite the errors in the original derivation discussed in section iv.a and the abundance of counter - examples to such a claim , the reasons for its invalidity notwithstanding .
the following may help further clarify what went wrong .
there is a common - sense meaning of two items being indistinguishable , " with
the leibniz metaphysical principle concerning the identity of indiscernibles " implicitly used .
that such an indistinguishability conclusion can not be drawn from a binary decision problem can be directly observed from the common problem of radar detection as to whether there is an incoming flying object . in a militaristic situation
, the object of concern could be an enemy airplane , say , with or without a warhead .
the yes - no target detection problem of whether an enemy airplane is present _ can not _ alone determine whether a warhead is on board . in the absence of further information
, one can not infer that the airplane has a warhead because that is hypothesis h~1~ in the binary decision problem formulation , which one simply applies _ by hand_.
there are many possibilities on the details of the incoming target ; it is not valid to pick one and exclude others and then use binary discrimination to affirm the picked possibility .
similarly , the occurrence of an ideal situation is an unwarranted conclusion that one can not make use of in other problems .
one has to _ mathematically derive _ a result for a problem from the given mathematical statement @xmath107 .
indistinguishability arguments in terms of @xmath103 are supposed to be universally composable " in that they justify the use of @xmath2 in any application to which it would be applied [ 28 ] , [ 29 ] .
we would later run into such issues in connection with known - plaintext attacks and error correction . here
, we may simply emphasize that there is no such automatic universal composability from @xmath103 or @xmath1 , with or without a distinguishability advantage . even in the case
whereby it is composable , the proof from @xmath1 may be far from trivial , as we will also observe .
the main point is that an intuitive interpretation may only serve as a guide to the general situation .
valid logical and mathematical deduction from premise to conclusion is required to establish proof .
this is especially clear when a quantitative level is desired .
summarizing , the distinguishability advantage " justification of operational guarantees from @xmath103 or @xmath1 is incorrect in several ways : 1 .
the indistinguishable probability is for a specific binary decision problem , which does not imply that the two situations are indistinguishable in other physical senses .
2 . in the real world , the _ a priori _ probability for the ideal situation can not be @xmath172 ; instead , it should be @xmath80 .
the ideal situation can not be inferred to be the real situation from the binary decision because it includes other features not included in the binary hypothesis testing formulation .
the key question to ask concerning the distinguishability advantage " argument is what is the quantitative security assertion ?
it seems that the answer so far is the failure probability interpretation , to which we have given various counter - examples in section iv.a and will give another in section v.
the bound ( 13 ) provides a security guarantee on the security of @xmath2 and its subsequences @xmath102 when eve attacks @xmath2 during its generation process before it is used . as mentioned before , when @xmath2 is used for privacy ,
it is more important to protect against known - plaintext attacks to maintain the secrecy of @xmath65 when @xmath63 , namely , the remainder of @xmath2 , is known to eve . how does such security follow from the incorrect failure probability interpretation of @xmath1 ?
it seems that this issue is addressed explicitly only in [ 35 , section 5.1 ] , with the conclusion that the security is the same as that originally obtained from @xmath1 .
indeed , the failure probability interpretation alone without the indistinguishability and other considerations in [ 35 ] would appear to give such a conclusion already .
thus , regardless of the @xmath63 known to eve , @xmath65 remains uniform to her except for a probability @xmath1 .
note that the distinguishability interpretation gives exactly the same quantitative security conclusion as the failure probability interpretation , as noted in section iv.b .
such a conclusion is __incorrect _ _ , as the following counter - example shows .
let @xmath186 be a specific sequence of @xmath45 with probability @xmath187 .
we denote the first @xmath188 bits of @xmath186 by @xmath189 and the remaining @xmath190 bits by @xmath191 .
let all the other sequences @xmath45 with the first @xmath188 bits @xmath189 have @xmath192 .
the other sequences @xmath45 with the first @xmath188 bits different from @xmath189 are assigned a probability @xmath61 as in @xmath57 .
then , @xmath193 .
when the known @xmath194 in a kpa turns out to be @xmath189 , eve knows that the remainder @xmath195 is @xmath191 with certainty , _ not _ with probability @xmath1 .
the underlying reason that the failure probability can not be used to obtain correct results in kpa is that there is no way to account for _ conditioning _ with just such an interpretation , and universal composition " is a vague argument and not universal .
its validity needs to be established for each composition situation . in kpa , there is apparently no composition , and thus , the original @xmath1 result is inferred in [ 35 ] as noted above , which is numerically very incorrect .
apparently , kpa security on @xmath196 of ( 6 ) can be obtained directly from ( 13 ) by writing its left - hand side as an average , with @xmath197 being the remainder of @xmath65 apart from @xmath64 : @xmath198 for @xmath199 it is observed from ( 23 ) that the probability guarantee for kpa now is an average over @xmath63 .
this is fully in accord with the above counter - example . when we remove the @xmath63 average to obtain an individual guarantee , we need to apply a markov inequality for @xmath63 .
the drawing of a specific @xmath1 from possible pacs and a specific @xmath41 from an observation @xmath14 also requires a markov inequality .
this will be discussed in section v.c. in section v.d , we will make clear that all these classical results are what quantum results reduce to .
the following security question arises : how many bits will eve correctly obtain even though her estimate of @xmath2 or @xmath64 is incorrect as a sequence under a @xmath1 guarantee through ( 13 ) or ( 23 ) ?
for example , eve guessing a 4-bit @xmath2 to be @xmath200 when it is actually @xmath201 makes a sequence estimate error but only a one - bit error out of four , not the uniformly random result of two errors .
however , an error rate leak in security that differs from the uniformly random level of @xmath202 is equivalent to a non - uniform _ a priori _
distribution @xmath203 , which is known to eve .
for instance , eve knowing that six out of ten bits of a @xmath102 are correct but not knowing which are the correct bits is equivalent to having an _ a priori _ @xmath204 with a biased probability @xmath205 on each single bit in the case that the bits are independent .
hence , the issue must be addressed in assessing ultimate security . in ordinary communications , this is called the _ bit error rate _ ( ber ) issue in coded systems , in contrast to the sequence error rate addressed in most performance analyses .
this does not represent a serious issue there because , typically , a sequence error rate itself can already be driven to zero and because ber is in any case an improvement over the sequence error rate .
the main information - theoretic problem to cryptography users concerns eve s performance from the users viewpoint , which is _ opposite _ to the performance concern of the users themselves .
it turns out that the relative importance of the different issues may be different in cryptography in addition to the fact that the required performance analysis is often more difficult , say , in lower bounding instead of upper bounding eve s error probability .
the ber is @xmath172 when @xmath23 under any attack. from the failure probability interpretation of @xmath1 , one would obtain , for any subset @xmath102 of @xmath2 in the absence of known - plaintext attacks , the following bound on such a bit error rate .
@xmath206 counter - examples to ( 25 ) can be readily constructed for small @xmath84. the actual ber needs to be validly bounded from a given @xmath103 .
eve s ber , which is less than @xmath202 , gives her information that is not available for a perfect @xmath23 , and its quantitative security consequence needs to be obtained .
it is important to observe that the ber is a very important security criterion in addition to those of ( 6 ) ; however , it alone is not sufficient as a security guarantee .
all these different probability criteria arise naturally for different security concerns for a given @xmath37 , and all have direct operational meaning .
they are perfectly protected against eve when @xmath20 .
an approximate bound for the whole @xmath2 can be derived [ 41 ] from standard information theory results through the entropy @xmath207 of @xmath2 .
let the bit error probability be @xmath208 where @xmath209 is the probability that the @xmath7th bit in @xmath2 is incorrectly obtained from her regardless of the estimate of @xmath2 . with @xmath210 being the binary entropy function , we have from the fano inequality [ 8] that @xmath211 the right - hand side of ( 27 ) can be bounded via @xmath103 for @xmath107 by neglecting @xmath76 compared to @xmath207 and using the theorem in [ 14 , p.664], @xmath212 a bound on @xmath213 follows from combining eqs .
( 27)-(28 ) ; see [ 41 ] for a discussion on the relatively weak bound on such @xmath213 in comparison to sequence errors .
note that the bound ( 13 ) for a single - bit @xmath102 does not concern the ber , which is obtained from a sequence estimate of a long @xmath102 with some bits being correct even though the sequence is wrong . for a general subsequence @xmath102
, there is no known result on the ber guarantee from @xmath103 or @xmath76 and none for @xmath64 under kpa with known @xmath194. the bound ( 25 ) from the failure probability interpretation on the ber for kpa is contradicted by the same counter - example in section v.a. summarizing , it is uncertain as to what ber guarantee for eve one can have under @xmath108. useful bounds on eve s ber for these cases are _ open _ problems with basic security significance , as we will see in connection with error correction in section vi . in the industrial control of product manufacturing ,
the criterion employed is usually the probability an item fails to meet a pre - set standard , not the average number of failures .
the former is a more stringent and operationally meaningful criterion , as we will see .
if we have a zero - one random variable , then the probability of one variable is the same as the average .
otherwise , from the average @xmath214 $ ] of a positive - valued random variable @xmath215 , we can bound the probability that @xmath215 exceeds a given level @xmath216 by the markov inequality [ 14 ] @xmath217 \leq e[z]/\gamma\ ] ] the markov inequality is needed because , often , only @xmath214 $ ] may be evaluated or bounded and because @xmath218 $ ] can not be obtained via another route .
this is the situation in the qkd security proofs .
there are at least three reasons why probability guarantees should be used instead of average guarantees .
first of all , consider the ( artificial ) example of a cryptosystem that has a 50/50 chance of being secure for 100 years or totally insecure .
its average security duration is 50 years ; however , no one would find such security meaningful .
second , the average has no direct operational meaning when the trial sample size is small relative to the size of the probability ( sample ) space for a single trial .
this is evident in the case of one sample trial , the meaning of probability for which has been extensively discussed ; see , for example , [ 42 ] .
there are insufficient samples for the average effect to kick in with a small variance in the sample mean ( average ) , and we should use probability to assess the trial sample property .
this is found to always be the case in qkd protocols .
a third reason is that an empirical average ( sample mean ) is not a deterministic quantity .
an empirical average lacks operational significance without some guarantee that the spread around the mean is sufficiently small . in qkd protocols
, there are many random parameters with a probability distribution .
the final trace distance @xmath1 obtained is itself an average over the possible pac codes , only one of which is used in a single round ( see section vi.a ) .
such an average result is common in information theory work with the so - called random coding " argument .
the possible number of pac codes is substantially larger than @xmath219 even if a toeplitz matrix is used as the pac , as is commonly the case .
therefore , the averaged @xmath1 has to be first converted into an individual @xmath1 from ( 29 ) . then
, a measurement of some @xmath14 is involved in eve s attack , which is the suppressed @xmath41 dependence of eve s @xmath37 that we focused on previously .
either classically or quantum mechanically , the guarantee is on the average over @xmath14 , and it also needs to be converted into a probability for a specific @xmath41. the number of possible @xmath41s again far exceeds @xmath219 .
these two averages are both on @xmath1 and can be combined .
there is another average over the known @xmath63 in kpa that we need to address in the case of protection against known - plaintext attacks discussed in section v.a .
therefore , in total , we would need to apply ( 29 ) one or two times .
the inequality ( 29 ) allows one to exchange the level of the failure threshold @xmath220 with another failure probability " level @xmath221 $ ] that exceeds the desired threshold level . in qkd security proofs ,
the @xmath215 itself is a probability , as observed in sections iv and v , and is a random quantity depending on the values of several other random system parameters .
if we did not use these two probabilities , we would not know quantitatively what individual probability guarantee we may obtain .
we could address such uses of ( 29 ) in the final security guarantee by adjusting the exchange to minimize any failure probability " of the protocol as follows .
consider the @xmath222 of ( 13 ) when @xmath158 is negligible compared to @xmath103 .
then , with @xmath223 denoting the conditional probability of @xmath222 given @xmath224 , etc . , we have , under @xmath225 = \epsilon$ ] and @xmath226 , @xmath227 we have used ( 29 ) and minimization over @xmath228 to arrive at the guarantee ( 30 ) .
similarly , abbreviating @xmath229 by @xmath58 with @xmath230 for @xmath231 = f$ ] , we have @xmath232 @xmath233 thus , from ( 29 ) and minimization over ( f , g ) , @xmath234 the bounds ( 30 ) and ( 33 ) are loose ; however , it appears that there is no way to tighten them without further knowledge of the random system parameters .
because the ber is a very nonlinear function of the security criterion @xmath103 , it is not known how the average @xmath103 can be converted into an individual guarantee , in contrast to the @xmath222 or @xmath235 case above . of course
, we do not even have a ber bound without such an average , except for the whole @xmath2 from ( 27)-(28 ) .
the numerical security guarantee from ( 30 ) and ( 33 ) is devastatingly worse than the original @xmath89-level guarantee . indeed , even with the incorrect failure probability interpretation of @xmath1 discussed in section iv.a , one application of ( 29 ) is required to obtain an individual guarantee on eve s probability of successfully estimating the whole @xmath2 even without any side information on @xmath63 during its use , as discussed above ; see section viii for numerical examples . at this point
, it is appropriate to emphasize that the classical analysis of @xmath103 and @xmath76 that we presented in this paper applies directly to the quantum case .
this is because , regardless of the utilized quantum criterion , @xmath1 or otherwise , the criterion would reduce to a classical quantity once eve makes her quantum measurement on her quantum probe .
the trace distance @xmath1 would reduce to a classical statistical distance @xmath103 , and the accessible information would reduce to classical mutual information . however , different quantum quantities may lead to the same classical quantity but are essentially different quantum mechanically .
this turns out to be the case for quantum accessible information and the holevo quantity ; a guarantee from the former allows quantum information locking leaks , which is not the case for the latter [ 43 ] .
the holevo quantity guarantee is essentially equivalent to the trace distance @xmath1 guarantee . from this quantum equivalence
[ 28 ] , [ 43 ] , one immediately has the following bounds , which establish the essential equivalence of @xmath103 and @xmath76 in a classical protocol and which provide a general security guarantee to classical protocol security proofs via @xmath76 similar to that provided by @xmath103 given in this paper : @xmath236 the @xmath103 in ( 31 ) is an average over the observation @xmath14 in classical protocols , which is automatically included in the quantum trace distance .
this is exactly as in the @xmath35 case.
in this section , we consider the problem of quantifying the security of the ecc output @xmath28 and the pac output @xmath2 , the generated key in fig .
2 , as well as how ecc and pac affect the final key generation rate .
the information leaks from error correction and privacy amplification were not considered in the earlier security proofs [ 7 ] , [ 26 ] , [ 27 ] .
this is sometimes justified by the invalid reason that the open exchange in these two steps is performed after eve sets her quantum probe .
however , eve may make her quantum measurement and key estimate after the open exchange .
apparently , the pac step can be rigorously quantified if the ecc step has also been quantified ; however , the ecc step can not be quantified , and there is no hint as to how a rigorous quantification of error correction may be performed in a qkd protocol . before discussing the error correction problem ,
we first discuss privacy amplification and its effect on the key rate .
the basic idea of privacy amplification is to increase the security level by compressing the input bit sequence into a shorter output bit sequence . intuitively , this is well known to be possible when the input bits are statistically independent to eve .
for example , given two bits @xmath237 and @xmath238 , each known to eve with error probability @xmath239 , the bit @xmath240 is known to her with error probability @xmath241 , which is larger than @xmath242 . when the input bits are correlated , if simply from eve s possible attack , the situation is far less simple .
useful results can be obtained using linear hashing compression represented by a @xmath243 matrix via the so - called leftover hash lemma [ 44 ] , which has a direct quantum generalization [ 45 ] .
the leftover hash lemma for universal hashing , " which covers all pac in use , provides the tradeoff between the @xmath1-level @xmath113 of @xmath2 and its length @xmath29 by the following formula , with @xmath244 , @xmath245 because it is not known whether @xmath29 greater than the minimum @xmath246 on the right - hand side of ( 2 ) could be obtained , the guaranteed key rate is given by the quantity @xmath246 .
note that @xmath247 and @xmath248 .
furthermore , the minimum @xmath113 one can obtain is , from @xmath249 , @xmath250 we can simply take the quantum @xmath113 in this paper to be the largest statistical distance @xmath97 that eve may obtain .
this leftover hash lemma guarantee is an average over the family of possible hash functions from which the pac is drawn .
the specific pac used is openly announced , and the performance is an average over possible codes , which is common in random coding "- type arguments .
a specific @xmath112 or @xmath113 level has to be first guaranteed in the security analysis to remove the pac averaging .
there are evidently some pacs with poor security , say , whenever the pac matrix is degenerate ( rank less than @xmath29 ) , for which a degeneracy of @xmath251 would leak @xmath188 shannon bits with certainty . if such degeneracy is first tested , a daunting practical task given that @xmath29 is tens of thousands and given that @xmath30 is a multiple of @xmath29 , the resulting family is not known to obey the
universal family " condition required for the proof of the leftover hash lemma . a high - probability guarantee on an adequate specific @xmath1-level is therefore essential .
the following inequality evidently holds for the @xmath2 s in fig . 2 :
@xmath252 the first inequality in ( 37 ) follows from eve possibly possessing more knowledge from the error correction in estimating @xmath28 .
the second inequality follows from privacy amplification being an open many - to - one transformation . as will be discussed in section vi.b , the users could and indeed may have to cover the chosen ecc via shared secret bits ; therefore
, one would obtain @xmath253 assuming that _ correctness _
( alice and bob agree on the same @xmath2 ) is obtained with a sufficiently high probability . in such a case ,
@xmath254 when the ecc is covered by an imperfect key , there is no known bound on @xmath255 , as will be observed in section vi.b .
hence , there is also _ no _ guarantee on the @xmath1-level of the final @xmath2 from ( 35 ) , and the pac step justification from ( 35 ) and ( 38 ) is lost because ( 38 ) is no longer valid .
the rigorous validity of the final @xmath113 level is correspondingly _ lost _ from simply this problem .
note that it is not possible to cover a pac using shared secret bits because this would require a bit cost substantially greater than the number of key bits @xmath29 generated because @xmath30 is typically many times @xmath29 .
the open announcement of pac is fully considered in the leftover hash lemma .
there is no similar result that would yield the pac information leak automatically from another known approach [ 46 ] .
privacy amplification exemplifies the exchange of key rate and privacy level inherent in qkd protocols . for pacs
to which the leftover hash lemma is applicable , there is the limit ( 35 ) on how small @xmath113 can be made whereby @xmath29 remains positive . in general , from ( 35 ) , @xmath256 sets a limit , via @xmath257 , on the number of uniform key bits that can be generated , and @xmath256 is constrained by ( 3 ) in a @xmath76 guarantee and by ( 14 ) in a @xmath103 or @xmath1 guarantee on @xmath26 .
such an exchange is fundamental .
it has not been shown how , and it appears impossible , one obtains a key at a given rate of @xmath29 per round with @xmath2 made arbitrarily close to perfect by increasing a security parameter in either a finite or an asymptotic protocol .
in particular , it is not possible to obtain @xmath60 arbitrarily close to @xmath258 from repeated use of linear pac , which is a direct consequence of ( 35)-(36 ) .
it is not known whether a pac may exist that leads to a better exchange than ( 35 ) . on the other hand ,
substantially more secure keys than those reported in the literature can be obtained from ( 35 ) at the expense of a decreased key rate [ 9 ] . in particular , a near - perfect " key @xmath2 with @xmath259 may be obtained , although that alone does not address the unsolved security issues concerning the ber and ecc .
the error correction step is called reconciliation " in the early qkd literature and is to be achieved by an open exchange cascade protocol [ 47 ] .
there is no valid quantitative result on cascade [ 48 ] because complicated nonlinearly random problems are involved .
furthermore , the difficulty of bounding the resulting @xmath255 means that the subsequent pac step can not be quantified if one uses cascade .
the same situation is obtained when the error correction step is performed openly , as further discussed later in this subsection .
currently , ecc is universally employed for error correction in qkd protocols . in particular ,
large ldpc codes are used , the performance of which is difficult to analyze [ 44 ] .
the problem of ecc information leaking to eve was not mentioned in earlier security proofs [ 13 ] , [ 26 ] , [ 27 ] , in [ 35 ] or in the recent review [ 2 ] ; however , the added side information of an ecc on @xmath26 would help eve in her estimate @xmath260 of @xmath28 if the ecc is openly known .
in particular , if the ecc is too powerful , it may even correct all of eve s errors in @xmath26 . as discussed in section iv.a , for security quantification
, one would need to bound @xmath255 , which is an impossible task even classically for any given long ecc .
there is a further quantum issue [ 9 ] similar to quantum information locking concerning the accessible information criterion .
thus , the _ only _ viable security approach is to cover the ecc using shared secret bits between uses and subtract its cost from @xmath29 to obtain the final generated key rate @xmath261 .
indeed , the following formula is currently used : @xmath262 with @xmath263 the factor @xmath264 is arbitrarily taken to be @xmath265 , the case @xmath266 being the asymptotic @xmath267 limit . the justification of ( 39 )
is given in [ 36 ] by citing the whole book [ 14 ] , which does not address such reconciliation issues or even eccs .
we give the following argument for the case @xmath268 , which appears to be what is intended in the earlier paper [ 49 ] .
consider a linear @xmath269 ecc with @xmath45 information digits and @xmath188 code digits [ 50 ] such that the number of parity check digits is @xmath270 .
if one assumes that the @xmath26 from the @xmath24 transformation in fig .
2 can be represented by a binary symmetric channel [ 8 ] with crossover probability given by the qber , then for @xmath45 given by the channel capacity @xmath271(qber ) , there exists a linear code that would correct the errors from the @xmath272 received bits for large @xmath272 by shannon s channel coding theorem , which is applicable to random coding over linear codes only . hence , the number of parity - check bits that are to be covered by a one - time pad , with @xmath188 of the @xmath269 code being @xmath272 , is @xmath273=|k''|\cdot h_2{\rm ( qber)}\ ] ] thus , ( 36 ) for @xmath268 is obtained .
we would first remark that the accounting in ( 39 ) regards the @xmath26 sequence as a codeword of an ecc , which is sometimes explicitly stated in qkd security analysis . in such a situation , covering the parity check bits is not sufficient to uphold ( 38 ) needed for the pac step .
this is because the structural information on the specific ecc used , which is open because it would take an excessive number of shared secret bits to cover it , would induce correlations among the bits in @xmath28 such that it becomes impossible to estimate the increase in @xmath256 to @xmath255 .
even the effective @xmath26 itself has been changed when it is taken as a code word . on the other hand , by regarding @xmath26 as the information digits of a linear ecc in a systematic form , alice may simply add further parity check digits and cover them by a one - time pad , hence preserving ( 38 ) . if the covered parity - check digits are assumed to be error free , then ( 39 ) continues to hold . in reality
, the digits have to be error protected for the classical channel used for their transmission .
if that channel is taken to have the same error rate give by qber , a different @xmath274 is obtained because the @xmath45 of the @xmath269 code is now @xmath26 : @xmath275\ ] ] which is larger than @xmath276 .
the resulting @xmath277 will be correspondingly smaller .
the combined key rate reduction effect of the pac and only ( 39 ) is quite pronounced .
in addition to the intrinsic physical inefficiency of qkd , they further severely limit the obtainable key rate in a full protocol .
there are several basic problems with such an approach to quantifying ecc security [ 9 ] , [ 51 ] .
the assumption of a binary symmetric channel is not valid under general attack by eve ; otherwise , there would have been no problem in quantifying the @xmath26 security since qkd day one .
the pulling back of the asymptotic @xmath267 limit to a finite @xmath272 with an ad hoc factor @xmath265 is completely unjustified . although the parity - check covering bit cost in a concrete protocol may be smaller than ( 40 ) when the protocol continues to function correctly ( from other issues , such as correctness , that we do not discuss in this paper
; however , see section vi.c ) , the hand waiving assignment of @xmath278 or @xmath279 in the literature shows that qkd security has _ not _ been rigorously quantified in principle .
this is because no correctness is guaranteed if an empirically measured quantity is used for the bit cost in lieu of ( 39 ) .
some formal results on information leakage in open eccs are presented in [ 52 ] ; however , ( 39 ) is employed in actual evaluations [ 53 ] .
substantially more serious is the following basic security issue .
the importance of qkd derives from the fact that key bits can be continuously generated between two users ; in particular , such bits can be used to execute a future qkd protocol .
otherwise , one does not obtain effective key generation .
we can perform the analysis above for ecc security only by assuming that the shared key bit used to cover the parity - check digits are the perfect one - time pad bits .
when @xmath2 is not perfect , what would the information leak be ?
this problem is _ never _ explicitly addressed in the literature . in the following
, we will ascertain whether universal composition " may be of assistance .
universal composition has been based on two different arguments .
the standard one [ 28 ] , [ 29 ] is the metric property of @xmath99 or of the quantum trace distance . for application to the present ecc problem
, we have @xmath280 where @xmath281 , @xmath282 , and @xmath283 refer to eve s distribution on @xmath2 for the ideal case @xmath23 , the case when a specific ecc is used and the case when no ecc is used . in the quantum situation , the classical @xmath99 would be replaced by the trace distance between corresponding density operators , i.e. , the quantum counterpart of classical distributions . from ( 43 ) , we need to bound @xmath284 to obtain a @xmath103 level with eccs , which appears to be an impossible task , and no result has ever been reported for carrying through this universal composition argument .
there is no valid proof if @xmath284 is taken to be the @xmath103 level of the key @xmath285 used to cover the ecc . in particular , the ber leaks of @xmath285 discussed in section
v.b would alone give eve significant side information to improve her estimate of @xmath285 and hence of @xmath26 .
there is a complicated nonlinearity involved in these @xmath228 levels .
the other argument [ 54 ] uses an incorrect and thus invalid failure probability interpretation of @xmath103 or @xmath1 .
if the argument were to be valid , then one would add the @xmath1-level of the ecc covering key to the overall @xmath1-level .
as we have observed in sections iv and v , some details concerning @xmath2 are not protected by @xmath113 ; however , they are protected under the incorrect failure probability interpretation .
in particular , the interactions of the different parts of a protocol indicates that one may not need an entire portion to be correctly estimated to improve an overall estimate on another portion .
how a ber leak of @xmath286 would affect eve s success probabilities through the ecc appears to be a complicated function of the given ecc .
there is no reason why @xmath287 would equal @xmath288 in the absence of an explicit proof .
moreover , such a level can not be generally correct because when the ecc is sufficiently powerful to correct all errors , the @xmath270 parity check digits would reveal all @xmath45 bits of @xmath28 .
however , the failure probability derivation of universal composition [ 54 ] needs such further proof .
using extraneous interpretation is not an alternative to a valid mathematical deduction . the severity of the @xmath1-level limit on a qkd key in applications will be described in the following sections on message authentication . in the present ecc case
, it appears extremely difficult to derive reliable estimates .
one may thereby conclude that the security of the ecc step in a qkd protocol has not been , and appears that it can not be , analyzed quantitatively in a valid manner . as a consequence
, the pac step is not justified due to the lack of a rigorous bound on @xmath255 , as discussed in section vii.a .
hence , the security of the entire qkd protocol has not been reliably , and certainly not rigorously , quantified .
this defect is not one of complexity in numerical evaluation but one of fundamental validity of reasoning . in this section
, we will summarize and explain the important basic and practical limits on the exchange between @xmath29 and @xmath113 , including the possible adjustments of what @xmath29 is in a qkd round for such an exchange .
indeed , what constitutes a qkd round ?
let us first ignore the practical limits on processing long eccs and pacs and simply attempt to determine what is a good choice of @xmath272 .
because @xmath26 has to be error corrected , we need to introduce a measure of correctness , namely , the probability that the users agree on the same @xmath28 . in a realistic protocol , there are various system imperfections that would compromise correctness ; however , the necessity of error correction alone implies that long eccs need to be used .
this arises from the fact that @xmath26 being broken into small pieces for error correction is equivalent to using a shorter ecc in sequence as a longer ecc , which has never been found to be an efficient method of correcting errors .
we simply have to use a sufficiently long ecc , or equivalently a sufficiently long @xmath26 , to achieve an adequate level of correctness , i.e. , of correcting all the errors in @xmath26 with a sufficiently high probability .
let us simply consider a pac from using the leftover hash lemma ( 35 ) because it is the only known way of quantifying actual security levels .
even more generally , from the nature of privacy amplification as bit sequence compression , we can see that a long @xmath26 prior to compression is needed to obtain a good security level using a sufficiently high compression bit ratio .
in contrast to ecc , one can break up @xmath28 into shorter pieces and compress each piece .
there is no correctness constraint ; the only fundamental limit is whether the @xmath60 of the smaller pieces is sufficiently small to ensure security from ( 35 ) , assuming that ( 38 ) holds . as discussed in sections vi.a - vi.b
, this assumption does not hold when the ecc is covered by an imperfect key , as in the qkd case .
apart from this crucial issue , ( 35 ) provides the fundamental exchange between the key rate and the security level , other than the need to use the markov inequality multiple times , as discussed in section v.a .
the key point of this connection is that it is not possible to have a key that can be made arbitrarily close to perfect by a security parameter , namely , condition ( ii ) of unconditional security in section ii , from only the asymptotic vanishing of mutual information or statistical distance , as explained in sections iii.a and iv.a . with ( 35 ) , the limit on the exchange is explicit .
this limit can be relaxed in one direction by sacrificing security to obtain a better key rate with the @xmath89-smooth entropy formulation commented on in [ 43 ] . however , relaxing security is not satisfactory given the current inadequate values to be discussed in section viii .
furthermore , relaxing security for longer keys is what conventional cryptography is apt to do . in practice ,
the use of long eccs and pacs is limited by the complexity of the processing involved .
both ecc processing and large matrix multiplication have been studied for decades , and it appears that it will be impossible in practice to address eccs on @xmath26 broken into pieces , whereby each of which is significantly longer than @xmath289 , in the foreseeable future . in the absence of a full protocol including message authentication , a qkd _ round _ may thus be defined by the stages of the protocol that check qber and generate a sifted key @xmath26 with subsequent ecc and pac applied , as in fig .
2 , the length @xmath272 being limited by current technology . a more important concept of a qkd _ block _ @xmath290 may be defined by the pac through ( 35 ) , with security level @xmath291 determined from @xmath292 for input blocks of length @xmath293 to the pac .
thus , @xmath293 has a maximum value of @xmath30 for a round but may be considerably shorter . under the assumption of @xmath28 correctness
, the discussion on @xmath28 being broken down into many @xmath294 is based on practical considerations . however
, this impacts on security because the blocks @xmath290 within a round may be correlated , and we also need to bound @xmath292 instead of @xmath255 .
message authentication , in which a data message is checked to determine whether it has been altered , is often considered as a cryptographic task more important than privacy [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] .
a qkd protocol necessarily involves message authentication on the open exchange between the users for basis matching , qber checking , and concerning the choice of ecc and pac after eve sets her probe . at the very least
, message authentication is required to thwart a man - in - the - middle attack eve may launch by pretending to be alice to bob and bob to alice .
the security of a message authentication code ( mac ) , which is a hash function for bit compression , is sometimes based purely on complexity . in qkd protocols ,
mac has to have information - theoretic security ; otherwise , it would contradict the qkd claim of being information theoretically secure .
a review of information theoretically secure message authentication can be found in [ 55 , ch . 4 ] and [ 56 ] .
a brief summary for our purpose is given as follows .
for a data message @xmath188 of a given bit length , a data tag of much shorter bit length @xmath295 is obtained by applying a hash function " @xmath296 to @xmath188 , say , by a compression matrix , as in a pac , which is chosen from a given family of hash functions . in a substitution attack in the open tag case , given @xmath297 and @xmath298
, eve finds @xmath299 with @xmath300 .
if the @xmath296 is chosen with a uniform secret key @xmath301 , eve s success probability @xmath302 is bounded by @xmath89 when the family of the hash function is an @xmath89-asu family .
concerning both substitution and impersonation attacks , in the latter , eve finds @xmath303 for a given @xmath188 such that @xmath295 for the correct @xmath296 with success probability @xmath304 : @xmath305 there is a general lower bound on the achievable @xmath89 for a given tap bit length @xmath306 that may be achieved : @xmath307 when the key @xmath301 is a qkd key with @xmath308 , it can be shown that [ 57 ] @xmath309 which may go to 1 and be achieved with equality for some @xmath303 .
the average of @xmath302 over possible @xmath303s , @xmath310 , is bounded by @xmath311 , as is @xmath312 [ 57 ] : @xmath313 it follows from ( 47 ) that @xmath310 and @xmath312 , not to say @xmath302 for individual @xmath303s , can not be decreased with longer @xmath306 or longer @xmath314 so long as the level of @xmath315 is given .
in particular , the authentication security parameter @xmath306 , which allows security to be arbitrarily close to perfect from ( 44 ) , is _ lost _ due to the use of an imperfect @xmath301 .
we do not yet know how to rigorously remove the average @xmath1 and average @xmath303 guarantee in ( 47 ) via the markov inequality to obtain an individual guarantee because the problem is nonlinear .
if we apply ( 33 ) as a guess , numerically , after averaging is removed via ( 24 ) for obtaining an individual @xmath316 and an individual @xmath303 guarantee , one would need @xmath317 to achieve the same security as a 32-bit @xmath306 from ( 45 ) and ( 47 ) or @xmath318 on a 64-bit @xmath306 .
these @xmath1 values are completely unrealistic , as observed in section viii .
note , however , that that is simply the @xmath60 level and does not cover ber leaks that provide information on @xmath301 to eve .
similar results are available for multiple uses of a hash function with tags covered by an imperfect key @xmath319 with @xmath320 , say , for @xmath188 uses of @xmath296 [ 58 ] : @xmath321 a large number of uses of @xmath296 are needed in one qkd round because many uses are needed for authenticating a long sequence of bits .
thus , the security guarantee is further lowered with ( 48 ) .
its quantitative effect on the final security of @xmath2 is unknown because the universal composition argument is not valid due to the problem nonlinearity alone .
equally significantly , the authentication steps in a qkd protocol have not been specified within the context of the other steps , with its imperfect levels considered .
as we have seen , one can not obtain a valid derivation of the final @xmath2 security level by declaring universal composition without explicitly detailing the justification of the argument in context .
the execution of a qkd round requires a significant number of shared secret key bits for message authentication and error correction .
it is yet unclear how quantitative security would emerge if the key used for such purposes is imperfect , as it must be for most qkd rounds .
as emphasized in section iv.a , the criterion @xmath1 applies to a key @xmath2 generated in a single qkd round .
it would _ not _ be meaningful to cite a @xmath1 level without stating the length of @xmath2 to which it applies , in effect making it a @xmath29-dependent @xmath113 .
eve s maximum possible probability of obtaining the entire @xmath84-bit @xmath2 is , from ( 14 ) , @xmath322 for security quantification , it is important to make the following two distinctions .
first , as discussed in section vi.d , the key length @xmath29 in @xmath113 may refer to that of a qkd round or to that of a qkd block .
second , within a block , we can have many different mutually disjoint segments @xmath102 of consecutive bits under attack by eve with bit gaps between them .
security is prescribed by @xmath291 whether @xmath323 or not .
the maximum probability of leaking @xmath188 different @xmath324 , @xmath325 , within a block is given , from ( 13 ) , by @xmath326 with kpa conditioning , eq .
( 50 ) is replaced by an average over @xmath63 on the left - hand side similar to ( 23 ) with respect to ( 13 ) .
note the nature of eq .
( 50 ) in contrast to the failure probability per bit @xmath327 of [ 35],[36 ] , with such bit failure probability taken to be independent among bits of a block @xmath323 , as in ( 20 ) .
the latter vastly underestimates the @xmath328 of ( 50 ) .
in particular , it is not the case that a single bit would be leaked with probability @xmath329 , as the failure probability per bit interpretation implies .
rather , a number of bits equal to the block length @xmath330 is leaked with probability @xmath291 ( apart from the @xmath331 factor ) .
generally , it is misleading to evaluate key rate or security level on a per - bit basis .
the actual data rate per unit time should be employed for practical assessment , as is the compromise probability per unit time . to bound eve
s success probabilities , one may not assume that the blocks @xmath290 within a round are independent ; however , one may make such an assumption for the @xmath332 from different rounds . certainly , the segments @xmath324 within a round are not independent , as shown by ( 50 ) . even when assuming that the blocks @xmath290 are independent , the segment s total compromise probability ( 50 ) is far larger than that given by the failure probability per bit interpretation .
the division of @xmath291 by @xmath330 is fortuitous and misleading .
the numerical solution is illustrated in the next subsection .
we consider here the use of many keys @xmath2 generated in different protocol rounds of a qkd system to guarantee that the worst - case parameter @xmath60 from @xmath333 from each round is used , considering that there is no average on @xmath60 itself , because there is no distribution for the complete @xmath37 .
( see also objection b in appendix iii . )
when there is a distribution on a random system parameter , we do not employ an average as a security measure for reasons discussed in section v.c .
( see also objection c in appendix iii . ) in particular , according to the operational guarantee statement ( og ) of section iii.a , a finite sample average in an experiment is a random quantity on which probability statements can be made instead of approximating it using the nonrandom average .
although the maximum @xmath58 of @xmath37 is an unknown nonrandom parameter without a distribution rather than a random parameter [ 39 ] , it is the probability of an event , and we can talk about averages or expectation values [ 41 ] . we can not estimate its spread as in the random parameter case and will simply consider the probability as a fractional average .
this is in contrast to the situation wherein a distribution exists and a markov inequality ( 29 ) can be used to produce an operational probability statement from the average ( mean ) . in the present case , the collection of @xmath58 in different rounds can be given instead .
the following average values cited are to be understood as having the same import as a probability strictly speaking . here
, we can not disentangle the possible conceptual subtleties of probabilities in real - world applications .
( however , see [ 41 ] . )
the theoretical numerical values of [ 29 ] for single - photon bb84 provide a tradeoff between key rate and security .
@xmath334 is obtained for @xmath335 .
if the key rate is @xmath336 bps , a segment leak of a block or a total of @xmath337 bits within a block may be leaked on average every 100 days if the @xmath1 level is individual .
the leak becomes 300 blocks per day after one use of the markov inequality from ( 30 ) . against a kpa ,
the average leakage becomes one block every 10 seconds from ( 33 ) .
the experimental results in [ 59 ] give a key rate of @xmath338 bps and @xmath339 for @xmath340 , which are approximately equal to the values given in [ 36 ] .
this amounts to an average maximum of 6 blocks or @xmath341 bits per day leaked against ciphertext - only attacks . against a kpa ,
the rate is 100 blocks or @xmath336 bits per day .
note that , as shown in ( 50 ) , these leak levels could apply to many different segment leak combinations distributed across a single block .
if the segments spread across more than one block , one should compute the leak probability of those within a block from @xmath291 and then multiply them from independence to obtain the total joint leak probability . only observing the block - leak probability
, it appears that the above numerical guarantee is far from adequate for almost all applications and is certainly not adequate for commercial banking .
it is often argued that @xmath342 is the practical " probability level for guaranteeing impossibility . with realistic numerical values of @xmath336 blocks per day with @xmath343 , a @xmath1-level guarantee of a practically perfect key ( but only from the viewpoint of @xmath344 ,
i.e. , not failure probability " ) in one day of operation would require a @xmath1-level of @xmath345 for ciphertext - only attacks alone .
such a level is 35 orders of magnitude above the available values of @xmath1 from theory alone .
there is no indication of how the numerical gap can be closed in any significant manner , again only in theory and even assuming that the security analysis in the literature is completely valid , which is not the case . on the other hand
, security can be increased to a near - uniform level by further sacrificing key rate , as presented in [ 9 ] , although that would require a larger @xmath29 than the literature value , which is limited by eccs and other processing complexities ; see section vi.c . according to the failure probability per bit interpretation discussed in section iv.a under statement ( f ) ,
a failure probability per bit @xmath147 of @xmath152 for all generated bits means that the qkd protocol can be run for the age of the universe and still have an accumulated failure strictly less than 1 " .
this conclusion is obtained from the incorrect @xmath145 of ( 20 ) .
the block value @xmath330 is not specified .
we take @xmath346 for 1 second of operation , which is a sensible value .
these numbers imply a possible average leak of @xmath347 bits per day for ciphertext - only attacks and 100 bps for kpas .
this strongly contradicts the quote ( f ) that the accumulated failure " is strictly less than 1 over the age of the universe .
table 1 compares the numerical guarantees for a @xmath348-bit block at @xmath349 and the current theoretical [ 36 ] as well as experimental [ 59 ] values at mbps key rates .
there are five cases that can be compared : the incorrect failure probability per bit interpretation [ 35 ] , the correct average guarantee from eqs .
( 13 ) and ( 50 ) , the individual operational guarantee eqs .
( 30 ) and ( 33 ) , the case where @xmath2 is uniform , and the symmetric cipher results ( see app .
ii ) from expanding a @xmath350-bit seed key to @xmath337 bits . for this nearly @xmath351-fold symmetric key expansion
, the seed key cost of @xmath352 bits per @xmath337 bits is needed in qkd for message authentication within the qkd key generation round of @xmath2 .
these results show that , even simply as an average guarantee , there are only @xmath353 bits of security in the qkd system for the @xmath337 bits compared to the @xmath350 bits of security for conventional ciphers under ciphertext - only attacks . further discussion is given in appendix ii .
the relevance of known - plaintext attacks is discussed in appendices ii.b and ii.c .
in this paper , we do not address the problems of the very low efficiency of qkd , some of which are discussed in [ 60 ] and many of which are intrinsic due to the small signal level and resulting sensitivity to disturbance .
more significantly , we do not address the physics - based security issues that have not been addressed in the qkd literature but which are fundamental to a valid security claim [ 61 ] .
in addition , especially important are the detector hacking attacks [ 62 ] that break most current qkd implementations , including the checking of the bell inequality in establishing epr pairs [ 63 ] .
this demonstrates that cryptosystem representation is a tricky and difficult issue in physics - based cryptography , especially in qkd , where many physical details may affect a single photon or a small signal that would not matter for stronger signals .
it is not yet clear what would be a reliable justification to ensure that a particular qkd system representation has incorporated all the essential features of simply the cryptosystem operation in a mathematical model that would address hacking , in addition to other extraneous loopholes .
this is a point first emphasized in [ 64 ] and is found to be prescient in several ways . in this paper , we have analyzed the fundamental information - theoretic security guarantees in cryptosystems and shown in what ways current qkd security analysis falls short .
a brief history of some security works in the literature is given in appendix i , which also contains a summary of the contents of the different sections in the body of the paper . in appendix ii
, a brief comparison of qkd with conventional cryptography is given to put the significance of qkd into perspective . in appendix iii , some possible points of objection or confusion are addressed .
a most important point of our foundational analysis is that security must involve eve s success probabilities in various problems .
the incorrect failure probability interpretation dissected in section iv implicitly recognizes such importance , and it has the following faulty security consequences : 1 .
known - plaintext attack security is incorrectly quantified , as shown in section v.a .
the important criterion concerning eve s bit error rate is incorrectly bounded , as described in section v.b .
universal composition is obtained when it is not valid , as in known - plaintext attacks , or when it requires a further justification that appears impossible to provide due to nonlinearity , as in error correction treated in section vi.b .
the security situation in message authentication is misrepresented as an individual guarantee , as discussed in section vii .
the failure probability per bit interpretation is seriously incorrect , as discussed in section iv.a with numerical security levels illustrated in section iii.b .
generally , the failure probability interpretation ascribes substantially improved quantitative security to what can be validly deduced both qualitatively for problems in which the trace distance criterion is yet to provide a guarantee and quantitatively to problems the interpretation does give a guarantee to by neglecting the difference between average and individual guarantees .
it appears that current qkd security is fundamentally no different than the uncertain security of conventional mathematics - based cryptography .
one may offer plausibility arguments for security and quantify security under some restrictive assumptions ; however , there is no proof against all possible attacks
. it may be useful to conduct research to develop new features for a qkd system that would permit a general security proof that is both transparent and valid .
it would also be useful to utilize quantum effects on larger signals to obtain information - theoretic security .
some such attempts have been undertaken in [ 5 ] and [ 65 ] in the kcq and dbm approaches .
it remains to be observed the extent to which qkd can be so broadened usefully .
i would like to begin this appendix with the following quotations : + the variety in this field is what makes cryptography such a fascinating area to work on .
it is really a mixture of widely different fields .
there is always something new to learn , and new ideas come from all directions .
it is impossible to understand it all .
there is nobody in the world who knows everything about cryptography .
there is nt even anybody who knows most of it .
we certainly do nt know everything there is to know about the subject of this book .
so here is your first lesson in cryptography : keep a critical mind .
do nt blindly trust anything , even if it is in print .
you ll soon see that this critical mind is an essential ingredient of what we call professional paranoia . "
] + it is very easy for people to take criticism of their work as a personal attack , with all the resulting problems . "
[ 4 , p. 10 ] these words were written on conventional cryptography .
they are even more appropriate for qkd . in this appendix
, we briefly outline the history of security proofs on bb84-type qkd protocols .
there are a very large number of papers on security proofs in qkd , many of which are referenced in [ 2 ] .
we will touch upon mainly those that have been mentioned in the body of the paper , including the more influential proofs on the security quantification of concrete qkd systems .
we will also take the opportunity to mention some relations between security analysis and qkd experiments thus far and to discuss some major physics security issues not addressed in the body of the paper .
security proofs for bb84 are the most well developed in the field .
other security proofs share almost all the difficulties bb84 proofs face and more .
we will summarize at the end a list of problems that no proof in qkd has yet overcome , with the exception of the kcq - dbm approach ; however , the details of why and how that is possible are yet to appear . it may be noted that security proofs , in qkd or any cryptosystem concerning privacy and key distribution , are a very complicated matter .
errors and incompleteness are to be expected during the early stages of their development .
these theoretical defects can not be glossed over in cryptography , although such defects are often justifiably neglected in physics and engineering when a final working experimental system is what decides success or failure .
security can not be proved experimentally , if only because there are an infinite variety of possible attacks , which can not all be described. there were many surprises in the history of cryptography ; thus, whether there is a valid proof in an important issue , especially in qkd , where provable security appears to be the only real advantage compared to conventional cryptography . as in the case of many mathematical propositions ,
it is not always possible to produce counter - examples to the main conclusion .
sometimes , the statement is actually true , such as the poincare conjecture and fermat s last theorem , yet a valid proof is a separate matter from assuming the truth . in the body of this paper
, we could only produce counter - examples to specific spots of reasoning in a purported proof .
we did not give a specific attack that would always succeed .
the burden is on those who claim that there is a proof to produce a valid one .
one can always change the proof claim to a plausibility claim , and we need to draw sharp boundaries in cryptography .
the discussions of this appendix should be read with this in mind . the earliest general bb84 security proofs in [ 13 ] and [ 26 ] are mainly on the security of the sifted key , namely , @xmath26 in fig .
earlier versions of [ 13 ] appeared a few years before it did , and [ 66 ] provided an important direction for [ 26 ] .
there are several noteworthy problems in these proofs , some of which are misinterpretations from others and not by the authors ; however , such errors have perpetuated .
_ first _ , these proofs are asymptotic existence proofs asserting the existence of a protocol that would yield a purportedly perfect key in the limit of long bit length @xmath272 .
they use the mutual information criterion , which we have shown in section iii.b cannot lead to such a conclusion by its mere vanishing asymptotically. this conclusion could not be drawn with the trace distance @xmath1 going to @xmath80 either ( section iv ) . however , the prevailing impression is that it could , and the issue is not addressed in the recent review [ 2 ] . _
second _ , there is no treatment of known - plaintext attacks when the generated key is used for encryption .
apparently , the quantum accessible mutual information criterion is not sufficient for proving security against kpas , as discussed in section iv .
a weakened protection against kpas is provided by @xmath1 , as presented in section v.b . _
third _ , eve s side information from error correction and privacy amplification are not considered and were later addressed in different approaches , as discussed in section vi .
the ecc problem remains to be rigorously treated for any type of qkd protocol , of which we call qkd or otherwise .
_ fourth _ , these proofs are on qubits ( two - dimensional quantum state spaces ) and lossless systems . in all implementations , we have infinite - dimensional photon state spaces with loss .
for example , coherent detection by eve is ruled out by the qubit model .
loss is ubiquitous in optical systems .
no reason has been offered as to why it would only affect throughput but not security in bb84 , although it is known that it does affect security in b92 [ 1]. see [ 61 ] for further discussions of these and other physics - related security issues . _
fifth _ , although [ 26 ] is an existence proof among the class of what is called css eccs with associated privacy amplification , it has been widely taken to have proved the ( asymptotic ) security of any specific ecc and any pac .
this error is found later in both experimental and theoretical studies .
there are various spots of uncertain validity in the reasoning of these papers .
although they are relevant to security , for the sake of this paper , we can assume that they are valid .
the main concern in this regard is that the issues involved are not purely mathematical but concern the relation of a mathematical statement to its real - world implication .
we have observed some such examples in section iv for cryptographic relations .
it is a special problem for qkd in which quantum physics at the small scale is tied to various classical physical or engineering phenomena .
an important sequel to [ 26 ] is the widely quoted [ 27 ] , which extends [ 26 ] to include various system imperfections by adjusting the final result in [ 20 ] using the attainable key rate with purported asymptotic perfect key generation .
the derivations of these adjustments are brief and heuristic and are based on ad hoc estimates .
there is no general formulation of the problem including an imperfect feature that would demonstrate how the original proof would address all possible attacks with such imperfection .
the pac in [ 26 ] is a nonlinear hash function ; however , is treated as if it is linear .
this [ 27 ] is used as the basis of the security claim on the use of decoy states for laser instead of single - photon sources ; some problems with such a connection are discussed in [ 61 ] . in particular , it is not realized that a weak laser pulse is itself coherent and not a mere multi - photon qubit [ 61 ] .
ref [ 27 ] is also used in the security claim of the so - called measurement - device - independent approach [ 25 ] .
security proofs for a finite and more specific protocol were developed and culminated in [ 36 ] for lossless bb84 with various imperfections .
many approaches to bounding eve s information on the sifted key @xmath26 have been attempted , therein settling on the smoothed " minimum entropy , which is used in numerical evaluations in [ 36 ] .
such smooth entropy is equivalently eve s maximum probability of obtaining @xmath26 but with greater flexibility in terms of giving up some level of security for a higher key rate .
(the use of these smooth entropies can not increase security by lowering the key rate . )
the trace distance criterion @xmath1 is used because the small kpa leak in the example of [ 31 ] was already considered unacceptable , and the incorrect failure probability claim from a @xmath1 guarantee was maintained .
we have discussed in sections v.d that @xmath1 and accessible information are indeed very different guarantees in the quantum domain but are essentially equivalent classically from ( 34 ) .
the errors in misinterpreting @xmath1 are analyzed in sections iv - v .
quantitatively , the numerical values of @xmath1 that were obtained are far from adequate simply on the probability of compromising the entire generated key @xmath2 in a block , as discussed in section viii .
the actual security guarantee from @xmath1 is detailed in section v. it is not given by the incorrect failure probability interpretation , and it is not known whether it can cover ber leaks , which for example eve could use to attack the qkd - key - covered parity check digits of a linear ecc discussed in section vi.b. the pac information leak is fully considered in [ 36 ] , although the ecc leak is not , as discussed in section vi .
there is the serious problem of using an imperfect key for the purpose of covering the ecc parity check digits mentioned above and for message authentication in future rounds , the latter being discussed in section vii .
the approach of [ 26 ] is generalized in [ 45 ] , [ 51 ] , [ 52 ] for a finite protocol .
it is difficult to assess the formal results in these papers. in [ 52 ] , the same ad hoc formula for ecc information leaks is used in an actual evaluation , as in [ 36]. in a concrete protocol , there is are advantages , only disadvantages , to these css - code - based approaches in addressing the ecc and pac information leak problems as compared to the approach of [ 36 ] .
we will simply provide some general remarks to indicate certain problems in the qkd experimental literature and will not dwell on specific analysis of the errors in specific papers .
that is a separate subject matter , i.e. , not that of basic security analysis . given the complexity of qkd security analysis , it is a highly nontrivial task to integrate all the components of a protocol for an experimental system . to begin with , no complete qkd protocol that includes
message authentication and error correction with an imperfect qkd key has been analyzed .
in particular , the message authentication steps are not interlaced with exactly how the bulk of the protocol runs or with what is being authenticated at what time , and the ecc information leak is only considered by an ad hoc formula without considering the relatively large @xmath1 level of the key used to cover its parity check digits .
qkd experiments do not usually concern the entire cryptosystem , the necessary message authentication , or error correction and privacy amplification .
often , a key rate is cited with no security level attached , which is nonsensical for a concrete protocol , as we observed in sections ii - iii .
part of the cause is apparently the use of [ 26 ] , as discussed in the first point of appendix i.a , with the belief that security can be made arbitrarily close to perfect for a given key rate below the threshold formula of [ 26 ] or [ 27 ] . such key rate results from [ 26 ] , [ 27 ] , with or without system imperfections and assuming that they are completely valid , have yet to consider ecc and pac leaks .
more significantly , they are often quoted for a system that employs error correction and privacy amplification methods , which is not a css code .
thus , those formulas so quoted are not relevant because they have never been shown in any way to hold outside of css codes , and even then , such proofs are merely existence proofs and do not pin down the working codes .
the situation is evidently better for the approach of [ 30 ] , the problems of which we have analyzed in the bulk of this paper and briefly mentioned in appendix i.b . even if we assume that everything is valid , the obtainable security level is insufficient , i.e. , @xmath1 is too large for many applications , as discussed in section viii .
although a @xmath1 level guarantee is not complete , it appears to be a useful criterion and needs to be ascertained for any concrete protocol analyzed without giving eve s full success probability profile ( 4 ) .
however , dbm [ 65 ] promises a new direct security approach yet to be made public .
there are three major security analysis problems that have not yet been solved for any qkd protocol , with exceptions noted below . 1 . in the presence of inevitable losses
, it has not been proved that only throughput is affected but not security .
when using an imperfect key in executing a qkd protocol , it is not known what the error correction information leak would be .
no analysis has ever been given on a full protocol involving message authentication with an imperfect key , therein demonstrating the effects of key imperfection on the security level of the final generated key .
note that point ( 1 ) does not apply to cv - qkd ( continuous variable ) , which is also immune to detector blinding attacks [ 62 ] .
( we do not discuss such very serious hacking problems in this paper .
) however , cv - qkd suffers from other major problems [ 61 ] not found in bb84 .
the recent approach [ 67 ] , which allegedly dispenses with the information - disturbance tradeoff without considering even intercept - resend attacks , is subject to all three points .
the coherent - state kcq approach in [ 5 ] is not subject to points ( 1)-(2 ) and may not require error correction due to its substantially larger signal level . with error correction , the new dbm technique [ 56 ] may be required .
by conventional ciphers " , we mean mathematics - based ciphers , which cover essentially all practical ciphers in commercial use [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] .
these are different from classical ciphers " , which rely on simply classical physics and include physical - noise - based cryptography such as that described in [ 18 ] , [ 19 ] and [ 20 ] .
quantum - physics - based cryptography is yet another gene ; however , by qkd , we mean the smaller subset defined in section i with bb84 as representative .
qkd covers key generation and direct encryption with the generated key .
we will compare both to some typical conventional ciphers in current use .
such a comparison is important for assessing the potential , progress , and future of qkd .
qkd has often been contrasted with asymmetric or public key cryptography , which only includes complexity - based security and no information - theoretic security other than that in the sense of ( 7 ) in section iii.a .
however , it is substantially more appropriate to compare qkd with symmetric key ciphers [ 8 ] because a pre - shared secret key is needed to execute a qkd protocol other than for the purpose of agent identification .
message authentication is needed to prevent man - in - the - middle attacks . for this purpose alone
, one would need information theoretically secure message authentication to preserve the overall information - theoretic security of the qkd protocol , which requires a shared secret key .
as shown in section vi , the error correction step of a qkd protocol also requires a pre - shared secret key .
of course , the qkd - generated key represents a pre - shared key for future protocols .
we have shown in section vi how the imperfect security level of such a key prevents a valid security proof and its quantitative level from being obtained . in this subsection , we will simply make some comments on the contrast between public key cryptography and qkd .
asymmetric key protocols can be used for both key generation and direct encryption for privacy .
they are not used for the latter in practice due to their relative inefficiency compared to symmetric key ciphers .
qkd in practice is more inefficient and more complex to operate compared to asymmetric key ciphers due to a number of fundamental reasons such as low signal levels and inevitable large losses .
they have the advantage of being provably information theoretically secure , which is however not yet realized , as we show in this paper .
the advantage is often claimed that qkd encryption is resistant to future compromise of the secret key in conventional ciphers .
that is surely the case in comparison to asymmetric key ciphers because decryption of the public ciphertext may be obtained in the future based on mere computational power .
however , qkd has no real advantage in this regard compared to symmetric key ciphers because the shared secret key can simply be deleted permanently .
furthermore , when the generated key from qkd is used on a conventional cipher , such a key shares the same problem , if any , as in the case of symmetric key ciphers .
symmetric key ciphers can be used for key expansion " , effectively generating new session keys " from a master key , or for privacy encryption . when used for key expansion , they are very similar to qkd generation schematically .
they have information - theoretic security because they are similar in their security as the plaintext security under ciphertext - only attacks when the cipher is used for encryption .
specifically , the generated ( running ) key sequence @xmath354 from the cipher with a uniform seed key @xmath355 , which can be regarded as a pseudo random number sequence , would have the following probability of leaking the whole @xmath354 to eve : @xmath356 this is obtained because each possible @xmath355 value leads to a different @xmath354 sequence ( non - degenerate cipher ) , which may be used in eq .
( 1 ) as the @xmath2 .
it is important to realize that this _ is _ information - theoretic security for @xmath354 , and it is very favorable for typical values of @xmath357 from @xmath358 to @xmath351 , as compared to that obtained from the qkd value ( 50 ) with the @xmath1 values in the literature . for comparison to qkd
, a block cipher can be run in stream cipher mode for the generation of a running key , as in fig
subset leaks @xmath359 depend on the specific conventional cipher . for ( non - degenerate ) linear feedback shift registers [ 3 ]
, the level is perfect for a single @xmath360 sequence of @xmath361 consecutive bits [ 6 ] . in general , the correlations between bits in @xmath354 are difficult to quantify , whereas a qkd key obtains a security guarantee under ( 13 ) . in any case ,
key expansion symmetric key ciphers do not have perfect forward secrecy"[3 ] due to the correlations between bits in @xmath354 .
moreover , a qkd - generated key does _ not _ have such secrecy either , especially not at the large @xmath113 level given in the literature , because it is imperfect .
the following numerical comparison of the qkd system of [ 59 ] with only a linear feedback shift register ( lfsr ) cipher against ciphertext - only attacks is revealing . with a seed key of only 128 bits ,
the @xmath362 level of an lfsr is @xmath363 from ( ii.51 ) for any @xmath364 , which compares quite favorably to @xmath365 for @xmath366 bits in [ 59 ] even before the markov inequality is applied for an individual guarantee .
the lsfr protects a segment @xmath102 of up to 128 consecutive bits with perfect security , whereas the system of [ 59 ] only does so at the same @xmath367 level from ( 13 ) .
it is not known what the lsfr information - theoretic security is for many scattered segments @xmath102 , and [ 59 ] gives the same @xmath367 probability for segments within a block from ( 50 ) .
there are many other uncertain securities in both systems .
it is also not clear if one is superior to another security wise .
however , it is clear that the lfsr is substantially faster and cheaper to operate .
the numerical comparison of qkd and symmetric - key ciphers is included in table 1 of section viii.b . note that there is no kpa in key expansion until the expanded key is used in an application because the plaintext is chosen to be @xmath57 , at least in principle , by the encrypter .
this is why there is information - theoretic security in conventional key expansion before the key is used , given the possibility of kpa .
non - degenerate symmetric key ciphers in current use do not have any kpa information - theoretic security because only a length of @xmath357 known input bits together with the corresponding ciphertext would uniquely fix @xmath355 in principle .
security relies on the complexity of locating @xmath355 . on the other hand ,
the qkd key remains secure for sufficiently small @xmath1 from ( 23 ) .
note that it may be possible to obtain information - theoretic security against kpa with a conventional cipher .
the theoretical possibility is presented in [ 68 , app . ]
, especially when the known plaintext is not too long .
it has been proposed that the qkd generated key can be used as the seed key in a conventional cipher . in that case , the plaintext so encrypted only obtains the protection of the conventional cipher but worse considering that @xmath355 is no longer perfect .
how the imperfection affects the conventional symmetric key cipher security is _
unknown_. in any case , as a pure conventional cipher , there is no more information - theoretic security against kpa .
we believe the following remarks are important when comparing qkd with conventional cipher security . in many specialized applications ,
it does _ not _ seem possible to launch a kpa , in contrast to most commercial applications .
examples include military applications with encryption on board an aircraft , a ship , a satellite , or a protected ground station . in such cases ,
it is not clear what advantage of significance qkd provides compared to conventional encryption , as discussed in the above subsection with a numerical example .
this is especially true given that the qkd security advantage has yet to be rigorously established ; in addition , it is inefficient and is vulnerable to hacking . more broadly , for such specialized applications , it is not clear why kirchhoff s principle [ 4 ] should be assumed . that principle states that the only security-relevant feature of the cryptosystem that an attacker does not know and that the users do is the shared secret key between the users
the cipher structure and the encryption algorithm are assumed to be openly known .
this does _ not _ appear to be a reasonable assumption in military situations .
if the encryption structure or algorithm is unknown to the attacker , it appears next to impossible for her to obtain substantial amounts of information for any reasonable cipher the users choose because the possibilities between structures and algorithms are endless and equivalent to a huge number of shared secret bits. they can be readily and often changed under software implementations .
even under kpa and kirchoff s principle , there is no known vulnerability of conventional strong ciphers such as aes . in specialized applications , a huge number of seed key bits can be pre - stored .
weaker ciphers are commonly employed due to their efficiency .
the notable security risks are not from the known strong ciphers .
is there a serious problem that awaits qkd as its solution ?
it appears that efficient bulk encryption of large ( elephant ) data flows in optical links is the one clear area that would benefit from efficient qkd .
this appendix addresses some possible objections or concerns on various points of this paper .
+ objection a : security is a matter of definition .
why is your definition better than other ones ?
answer : security is not a matter of definition .
the cryptosystem designer must decide on an acceptable probability of a successful attack by eve on any characteristic of the generated key @xmath2 from a qkd round .
consider for example @xmath2 of length @xmath337 bits .
if eve has a total compromise probability @xmath368 ( for @xmath369 ) of correctly identifying the entire @xmath2 , which is substantially larger than the uniform level of @xmath370 , is this acceptable ?
suppose that it is not ; then , regardless of the security definition used at any quantitative level , security is not guaranteed if the total compromise probability above is not ruled out .
this is formalized by the operational guarantee statement ( og ) in section iii.a .
a theoretic security criterion has to yield operational probability guarantees , which must be the concern of cryptographic security .
such an operational guarantee is difficult to obtain and has been ignored in qkd , except through the incorrect failure probability interpretation discussed in detail in section iv .
it is also neglected in some but not all information - theoretic security studies in conventional cryptography . in this paper , we detailed some basic operational guarantees for the trace distance ( statistical distance ) criterion @xmath1 ; however , not all important operational guarantees have been covered by @xmath1 .
in particular , eve s ber , discussed in section v.b , is not covered .
when eve identifies @xmath2 incorrectly as a sequence , she may still correctly obtain , say , 60% of the bits , similar to the case whereby the distribution @xmath333 is known to eve with a per bit error probability of 0.6 , which would not be considered a secure key by most designers .
most designers would want a proof against such a possibility at any designed ber level .
there are questions concerning the average versus worst - case guarantee , average versus individual guarantee , and security of multiple uses of different keys at given d levels .
these questions are discussed in section iii.a , v.c , and viii.b as well as in the following objections b and c. note that eq .
( 50 ) with @xmath369 implies that many bits and bit segments may be leaked for operation in one , say , at a key rate of 1 mbps ; see section viii .
+ objection b : the average instead of the worst case should be employed in quantifying security leaks .
answer : for a rigorous assessment of a problem on performance depending on a parameter @xmath371 , usually , only a relevant upper or lower bound can be obtained over the range of values that @xmath371 may take .
the worst - case performance , say , concerning the time complexity of an algorithm or the security level of a cryptosystem provides a guaranteed level of performance that may or may not result from an attack but that can not be exceeded . if the parameter @xmath371 has a probability distribution , one can also discuss the average performance ; see objection c. however , it may not be meaningful , in the sense of being applicable to reality , to assign a probability distribution to what is called a _ nonrandom parameter _ " [ 39 ] , which is not described by a probability distribution .
this may occur when the parameter appears in only one sample instance with no repeated trials ( although there remains meaning to assign probability to such a situation in various theories of probability [ 41 ] , such as the probability that president john kennedy was shot by more than one gunman .
the warren commission addressed such question .
see also objection c. ) in decision theory , an unknown nonrandom parameter [39 ] is then used .
this often happens , for example , when the parameter takes on a continuum of possibility . in this paper ,
the unknown parameter is @xmath37 , namely , eve s distribution on the generated key @xmath2 from her attack , as presented in section iii.a as well as in the beginning of section iv .
the function is the parameter @xmath371 under consideration , the range of which has a cardinality of the continuum .
more significantly, eve can pick any attack for which there is no distribution , and in any event , the users do not know the distribution or if one exists .
thus , we can not average over @xmath37 or @xmath58 , the maximum value of @xmath37 from eq .
we also can not average over the @xmath45 of a specific @xmath37 even though that may make sense if only because we do not know the value of that specific @xmath37 .
thus , we have to bound @xmath58 as the worst case to provide a valid guarantee .
+ objection c : an average can be used for the guarantee instead of a probability . in particular , there is no need to apply a markov inequality to convert an average guarantee into an individual guarantee .
answer : some parameters in qkd do have reasonable probability distributions , although only for a given attack in a given round .
thus , the choice of pac is taken to be uniform . the known part @xmath63 to eve of @xmath2 in a kpa
is specified by the marginal distribution of @xmath2 from the joint distribution @xmath372 with eve s observation @xmath14 . in section v.c , we detailed the main reasons why a probabilistic guarantee is more accurate than an average guarantee .
one reason is that the average has no operational meaning when the total number of trials ( pertaining to that underlying distribution ) is small , similar to the single - trial case .
( think of the above kennedy assassination example in objection b. ) this is codified in the statement ( og ) in section iii.a on operational guarantees .
equally significantly , a finite sample average remains a random quantity with its own probability distribution .
a probability statement can be made on it to satisfy ( og ) .
for example , an estimate from variance information could lead to such an estimate , not further information on the distribution .
the markov inequality estimates ( 30 ) and ( 33 ) from the average alone are weak because no other statistical information is available .
one may be stuck with a weaker guarantee , such as the average without a probability statement , and even simply relying on a single theoretic criterion without analyzing its proper operational meaning , as has been the case in qkd until now , if that is all one can obtain . however , comparing quantitative security on various characteristics of @xmath2 to the uniform @xmath57 is the concern of rigorous security .
a uniform @xmath23 gives far better and far more detailed security guarantees than does a trace distance guarantee , especially at the relatively large level that can be obtained . at the very least
, it can not be claimed that the qkd - generated key is perfect " , can be made as close to perfect as desired , or is perfect except for a small probability .
the many problems presented in this paper should make clear the dangers of such an exaggeration .
+ objection d : distinguishability advantage is a great criterion in cryptography .
is there a definite counter - example on why it is not satisfactory ?
answer : distinguishability advantage is a vague and very misleadingly phrased security guarantee . as detailed in section iv.b , it leads to the an incorrect failure probability interpretation of a statistical distance guarantee ( which the trace distance criterion reduces to upon eve s measurement on her probe ) as a definite and general quantitative consequence .
alone , it serves no purpose other than what is given mathematically , namely , a bound on the statistical distance .
in particular , there can be no counter - example until one gives the quantitative guarantee that derives from distinguishability advantage . using the failure probability interpretation as its consequence , all the counter - examples to the failure probability interpretation are counter - examples to the distinguishability advantage interpretation .
these include the examples in section iv.a and the kpa counter - example in section v.a .
distinguishability advantage as a statistical distance bound on @xmath103 is a useful criterion , as demonstrated by this paper .
it simply does not have the operational significance that has been ascribed to it .
in particular , the @xmath222 bound of eq .
( 13 ) that results is the same for a one - bit subsequence @xmath102 of @xmath2 as it is for the whole @xmath373 .
this may give the impression that the cryptosystem is substantially more secure than it actually is and apparently led to the incorrect failure probability per bit interpretation discussed in section iv.a , which grossly overestimates security .
+ objection e : is nt your kpa counter - example of section v.a not one of known - plaintext attack but one of chosen - plaintext attack ?
answer : there is no difference between kpas and chosen - plaintext attacks for the symmetric key additive stream ciphers of fig . 1 , and the counter - example concerns such a cipher .
this is because the additive key stream in symmetric key ciphers is blind to the data .
a kpa reveals part of the running key @xmath194 that happens to be uncovered from the known data @xmath237 , with the following @xmath195 depending on @xmath194 and @xmath37 .
of course , the @xmath103 level provides an average guarantee over @xmath63 , as given in eq .
thus , a bad @xmath194 can only occur with a small probability for small @xmath103 ( which @xmath1 reduces to ) .
however , such an average needs to be removed for an individual guarantee .
the incorrect failure probability interpretation produces an incorrect answer for a given @xmath194 ; see section v.a .
+ objection f : the trace distance guarantee may be sufficient in practice .
what is the evidence to the contrary ?
answer : this paper is concerned with information - theoretic security foundation and rigorous proofs of security , the latter being proclaimed for qkd for almost twenty years .
it is not clear what is meant by sufficient in practice " , which would vary from application to application .
many problems , including the lack of a real proof on qkd security , are noted in this paper .
they constitute evidence of possible practical security problems .
there is no such thing as proof by no counter - example yet " .
the burden is on those who claim qkd has been proved secure to produce a valid proof for a given model. it is the task of cryptanalysis , a major component of cryptology , to scrutinize security , which is rarely performed in the qkd literature apart from implementation issues .
+ objection g : why can not security be brought arbitrarily close to perfect by privacy amplification ?
answer : the trace distance level @xmath113 is bounded by ( 36 ) in terms of the total compromise probability @xmath255 of the shift key @xmath28 .
it can not be made arbitrarily small from the leftover hash lemma .
it is not known whether there is any way to make only @xmath60 arbitrarily close to the uniform level @xmath258 ; see section vi.a .
in addition , note from sections iii.b and iv before iv.a that asymptotic vanishing of eve s accessible information or the trace distance not only does _ not _ imply that the key is arbitrarily close to perfect but also may even imply that the key suffers from a serious weakness of having a very relatively large @xmath60 .
+ objection h : there is no problem in assigning a numerical value to @xmath264 in the error correction cost ( 39 ) .
this can be taken from the actual ecc used in the protocol. answer : in that case , there is then no need to present formula ( 39 ) , which is irrelevant to the actual bit cost .
this conveys the misleading impression that there is a general justification . as outlined in section vi.b
, there is a rationale for ( 39 ) when @xmath268 because of the asymptotic number of bits needed to cover a linear ecc for guaranteed error correction , although only for a binary symmetric channel , which is not obtained under a general attack .
the point is that correctness of the round ( the users agree on the same key ) is then guaranteed .
when a finite code is used with usually a bit cost of even less than ( 39 ) for @xmath268 , correctness from an ecc can not be theoretically guaranteed and must be established with high probability by other means not given in the security proof of the protocol .
this is acceptable in practice whenever it works but can not be confused with a security proof on the model .
the assumption must at least be made clear that it is not logically incorporated in the security proof .
the more serious problem with error correction is what is focused on in section vi.b ; it has not been quantitatively shown how an imperfect key covering the ecc would degrade security or why the imperfect key bit cost of any quantitative level can be used to account for any bit leaks in any reconciliation procedure .
many unstated and strictly invalid assumptions are used in qkd security proofs , as outlined in this paper and in [ 61 ] , any of which would invalidate any claim to proven security .
the security of qkd protocols requires a substantial amount of further careful study .
objection i : it has not been explained how an imperfect key would affect qkd security when used for error correction and what the overall complexity security becomes when used in a conventional symmetric - key cipher .
answer : the first question is a major open problem in qkd security theory .
the second occurs when a qkd key is used in ciphers such as aes ; however , it is not very relevant because an imperfect key can only weaken the complexity security compared to a uniform key .
the substantive question is what the complexity security becomes if the imperfect seed key is changed more often compared to a uniform key .
both problems appear to be very difficult and seemingly not amenable to analysis .
this paper never claims to address , let alone solve , all security problems associated with qkd - generated keys .
the paper provides some fundamental results on the security of any key generation scheme , quantum as well as classical , and notes some serious unsolved problems .
whoever claims security has the burden of providing a valid proof .
i would like to thank greg kanter for his discussions that helped clarify some of the issues treated in this paper .
my cryptography research has been supported by the defense advanced research project agency and the united states air force .
h. p. yuen , mathematical modeling of physical and engineering systems in quantum information " , in _ proceedings of the qcmc _ , o. hirota , j. h. shapiro , and m. sasaki , eds , nict press , p.163 - 168 ( 2007 ) .
h. p. yuen , on the foundations of quantum key distribution- reply to renner and beyond " , arxiv;1210.2804 , 2012 ; also in the tamagawa university quantum ict research institute bulletin , vol.3 , no.1 , p.1 - 8 , 2013 .
m. ben - or , m. horodecki , d.w .
leung , d. mayers , and j. oppenheim , universally composable security of quantum key distribution , " second theory of cryptography conference ( tcc ) , lecture notes in comnputer science , vol . 3378 , springer , new york , p. 386406
, 2005 ; also quant - ph 0409078 . r. renner and r. konig , universally composable privacy amplification against quantum adversaries , " second theory of cryptography conference ( tcc ) , lecture notes in computer science , vol .
3378 , springer , new york , p. 407425
, 2005 .
h. p. yuen , essential lack of security proof in quantum key distribution " , arxiv:1310.0842v2 , 2013 ; also in _ proceedings of the spie conference on quantum - physics - based information security _ , sep 1013 .
k. yamazaki , r. nair , and h. p. yuen , problem of cascade protocol and its application to classical and quantum key generation " in _ proc .
8th international conference on quantum communication , measurement , and computing _ , ed .
o. hirota , j. h. shapiro , and m. sasaki , nict press , p. 201204
( 2007 ) .
j. jogenfors , a. m. elhassan , j. abrens , m. bourennane , and j. larsson .
hacking the bell test using classical light in energy time entanglement based quantum key distribution " , sci . adv . 1 , : e1500793 , 2015 . | the security issues facing quantum key distribution (qkd ) are explained , herein focusing on those issues that are cryptographic and information theoretic in nature and not those based on physics. the problem of security criteria is addressed .
it is demonstrated that an attacker s success probabilities are the fundamental criteria of security that any theoretic security criterion must relate to in order to have operational significance .
the errors committed in the prevalent interpretation of the trace distance criterion are analyzed .
the security proofs of qkd protocols are discussed and assessed in regard to three main features : their validity , completeness , and adequacy of the achieved numerical security level .
problems are identified in all these features .
it appears that the qkd security situation is quite different from the common perception that a qkd - generated key is nearly perfectly secure .
built into our discussion is a simple but complete quantitative description of the information theoretic security of classical key distribution that is also applicable to the quantum situation . in the appendices ,
we provide a brief outline of the history of some major qkd security proofs , a rather unfavorable comparison of current qkd proven security with that of conventional symmetric key ciphers , and a list of objections and answers concerning some major points of the paper .
pacs # : 03.67dd |
the study of front propagation of a stable phase into an unstable one encompasses several issues of great interest @xcite as flame propagation in gases @xcite , population dynamics of biological communities ( plankton in oceans ) @xcite and chemical reactions in liquids @xcite .
a common feature of all these phenomena is that they take place in a strongly deformable medium such as a fluid .
the interplay among transport , diffusion and reaction is therefore a crucial problem with several open issues ( e.g. for questions concerning combustion see ref .
@xcite ) . in the most compact model of front propagation the state of the system is described by a single scalar field @xmath4 , that represents the concentration of products .
the field @xmath5 vanishes in the regions filled with fresh material ( the unstable phase ) , equals unity where only inert products are left ( the stable phase ) and takes intermediate values wherever reactants and products coexist , i.e. , in the region where production takes place .
here we assume that the concentration of chemicals does not modify the underlying flow .
therefore , in the following , we consider the velocity field as given .
this approximation , hardly tenable in the context of flame propagation in gases , is rather appropriate for chemical front propagation in some liquid solutions @xcite . under these simplifying assumptions ,
the evolution of @xmath5 is described by @xmath6 where the second term on the l.h.s .
accounts for the transport by an incompressible velocity field . on the r.h.s
the first term describes molecular diffusion and the second one describes the production process with time scale @xmath7 .
we will first consider a production term of fischer - kolmogorov - petrovski - piskunov @xcite ( fkpp ) type , i.e. , a function @xmath8 convex ( @xmath9 ) and positive in the interval @xmath10 , vanishing at its extremes , and @xmath11 .
here we take @xmath12 .
it is also of interest to consider a production term in the form of the arrhenius law , @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the activation concentration .
the latter choice is more pertinent to the study of flames and/or chemical reactions @xcite . until now we did not specify any details of the velocity field . in many engineering applications
@xmath15 is turbulent . in this paper
we investigate front propagation in laminar flows , which , albeit simpler than turbulent ones , show remarkable qualitative similarities with more complex flows @xcite .
specifically , we consider a two dimensional stationary incompressible flow with cellular structure ( see also @xcite ) @xmath16 with the streamfunction @xcite @xmath17 we considered @xmath18-periodic boundary conditions in @xmath19 and an infinite extent along the @xmath20-axis .
this kind of flow is interesting because , in contrast to shear flows , all the streamlines are closed and , therefore , the front propagation is determined by the mechanisms of contamination of one cell to the other @xcite . since we are interested in the propagation in the @xmath20-direction , the boundary conditions are set to @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
the maximum principle ensures that at later times the field still takes values in the range @xmath23 @xcite .
the instantaneous front speed is defined as @xmath24 this expression defines the so - called bulk burning rate @xcite which coincides with the front speed when the latter exists , but it is also a well defined quantity even when the front itself is not well defined .
the asymptotic ( average ) front speed , @xmath25 , is determined by @xmath26 . in a medium at rest , it is known that eq .
( [ eq : rad ] ) , for fkpp nonlinearity , generates a front propagating , e.g. , from left to right with an asymptotic speed @xmath27 and a reaction region of thickness @xmath28 @xcite . in the more interesting case of a moving medium
, the front will propagate with an average speed @xmath29 greater than @xmath30 @xcite .
the front velocity @xmath29 is the result of the interplay among the flow characteristics ( i.e. intensity @xmath0 and length - scale @xmath18 ) , the diffusivity @xmath31 and the production time scale @xmath7 .
the goal of our analysis is to determine the dependence of @xmath29 on such quantities .
in particular , introducing the damkhler number @xmath32 ( the ratio of advective to reactive time scales ) and the pclet number @xmath33 ( the ratio of diffusive to advective time scales ) , we seek for an expression of the front speed as an adimensional function @xmath34 .
we will see that a crucial role in determining such a function is played by the renormalization of the diffusion constant and chemical time scale induced by the advection @xcite .
moreover , we consider an important limit case , i.e. , the so called geometrical optics limit , which is realized for @xmath35 maintaining @xmath36 constant @xcite . in this limit
one has a non zero bare front speed , @xmath30 , while the front thickness @xmath37 goes to zero , i.e. , the front is sharp . in this regime
the front dynamics is well described by the so - called @xmath38-equation @xcite @xmath39 the front is defined by a constant level surface of the scalar function @xmath40 . physically speaking
, this limit corresponds to situations in which @xmath37 is very small compared with the other length scales of the problem .
also in this case we provide a simple prediction for the front speed , which turns out to be expressible as an adimensional function @xmath41 .
the paper is organized as follows . in sect .
[ sec:2 ] we discuss a theoretical upper bound for the front speed which becomes an equality in the limit of ( very ) slow reaction . in sect .
[ sec:3 ] we present a numerical study for slow and fast reaction , comparing the results with a phenomenological model . in sect .
[ sec:4 ] we consider the geometrical optics limit .
[ sec:5 ] is devoted to some concluding remarks .
the appendix contains the details of the numerical method used in the simulations .
for a generic incompressible flow and a generic production term which has a bounded growth rate , @xmath42 , i.e. , @xmath43 it is possible to establish an upper bound for the speed of front propagation .
explicitly , we have @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the effective diffusion coefficient in the @xmath20-direction , which can be derived from eq .
( [ eq : rad ] ) by switching off the production term .
this bound is the consequence of the deeply rooted link existing between front propagation and advective transport .
we start the derivation of eq .
( [ eq : upb ] ) by recalling the fundamental relation among the solution of the pde ( [ eq : rad ] ) and the trajectories of particles advected by a velocity field @xmath46 and subject to molecular diffusion @xcite @xmath47 the average is performed over the trajectories evolving according to the langevin equation @xmath48 with ending point @xmath49 .
the white noise term @xmath50 accounts for molecular diffusion .
+ since the growth rate is bounded , ( [ eq : feykacext ] ) yields the inequality @xmath51 in the previous inequality , the term in angular brackets denotes the probability that the trajectory ending at @xmath52 was initially located at the left of the front interface . for fkpp production term the maximum occurs for @xmath53 , i.e. , @xmath54 . under very broad conditions , i.e. , nonzero molecular diffusivity and finite variance of the velocity vector potential @xcite , it is possible to show that asymptotically the particles undergo a standard diffusion process with an effective diffusion coefficient @xmath55 , always larger than the molecular value @xmath31 .
the issue of single particle diffusion , and the problem of finding the effective diffusivity has been the subject matter of a huge amount of work ( see e.g. @xcite for a recent review ) . in the presence of an asymptotic standard diffusion , we can substitute the term @xmath56 , with the gaussian result @xmath57 /\sqrt{2 \pi d_{\mbox{\scriptsize eff}}\ , t}$ ] with exponential accuracy .
we thus obtain @xmath58 /\sqrt{2 \pi d_{\mbox{\scriptsize eff}}\ , t}$ ] .
it is thus clear that at the point @xmath52 the field @xmath5 is exponentially small until a time @xmath59 of the order of @xmath60 .
we finally obtain the upper bound for the front velocity @xmath61 , which is eq .
( [ eq : upb ] ) .
the bound ( [ eq : upb ] ) becomes an equality in the limit of very slow reaction . if @xmath7 is the slowest time scale under consideration , advection and molecular diffusion act jointly to build an effective diffusion process , essentially unaffected by the reaction . in this case
the front width is large enough and the reaction takes place in a region of effective diffusivity .
therefore , it is allowed to substitute eq .
( [ eq : rad ] ) with an effective reaction - diffusion equation @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the eddy - diffusivity tensor @xcite . for the fkpp nonlinearity ,
this last equation gives rise to @xmath64 , where @xmath65 @xcite .
one can find a detailed derivation of this formula in ref .
@xcite . for cellular flows
, it is known that @xmath66 @xcite . inserting this expression in eq .
( [ eq : upb ] ) one obtains @xmath67 @xcite , remarkably close to the observed ones for @xmath68 ( see next section ) .
the bound ( [ eq : upb ] ) is very general and holds for generic incompressible flows and production terms . here , by means of numerical simulations ,
we consider the front propagation problem arising in the reaction advection diffusion equation ( [ eq : rad ] ) for the particular case of the cellular flow ( [ eq : stream ] ) of stirring intensity @xmath0 and fkpp nonlinearity ( with characteristic time , @xmath7 ) . in our discussion
, we always suppose that the diffusion time scale is the slowest occurring one , i.e. , @xmath69 and thus @xmath70 and @xmath71 . now before presenting the numerical results it is helpful to introduce a macroscopic description of the problem which will reduce it to an effective reaction - diffusion process with renormalized coefficients .
the basic observation is that the dynamics of @xmath5 in cellular flows is characterized by the the cell - size @xmath18 , so that we can perform a space discretization that reduces each cell , @xmath72 , to a point , @xmath73 , mapping the domain a two - dimensional infinite strip onto a one - dimensional lattice .
the field @xmath5 becomes a function defined on the lattice @xmath74 .
integrating eq .
( [ eq : rad ] ) over the cell @xmath72 , we obtain @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the flux of matter through the left boundary of the @xmath73-th cell , and @xmath77 is the rate of change of @xmath78 due to reaction taking place within the cell . on the basis of the numerical results ( see below ) , we will show that the space - discretized macroscopic reaction - diffusion equation @xmath79 is a pretty good model for the front dynamics .
the effect of the advective field is to _ renormalize _ the values of the diffusivity , @xmath80 , and the reaction time scale , @xmath81 .
this is why the velocity does not appear any more in the effective dynamics , described by eq .
( [ eq:3 ] ) @xcite .
the renormalized diffusivity @xmath45 accounts for the process of diffusion from cell to cell as a result of the nontrivial interaction of advection and molecular diffusion @xcite .
the renormalized reaction time @xmath82 amounts to the time that it takes for a single cell to be filled by inert material , and depends on the interaction of advection and production .
of course , also the production term will be affected , i.e. @xmath83 , but , as we will see , such a modification is not dramatic . indeed
, the modified production term turns always to be in the fkpp universality class .
the limiting speed of the front in the moving medium turns out to be @xmath84 , similar to eq.([eq : upb ] ) @xcite .
the problem is now reduced to derive the expressions for the renormalized parameters by means of physical considerations . in the following sections , using as an interpretative framework the above described macroscopic model
, we will present the results of detailed numerical simulations for slow ( @xmath85 ) and fast ( @xmath86 ) reaction . at small @xmath87 ,
the reaction is significantly slower than the advection , and consequently the region where the reaction takes place extends over several cells , i.e. , the front is distributed . to obtain the expression of @xmath45
we neglect the reaction term in eq .
( [ eq : rad ] ) , which reduces to the equation for a passive scalar in a cellular flow .
this is a well studied problem , the solution of which is @xcite : @xmath88 for large @xmath89 ( @xmath31 small ) the cell - to - cell diffusion mechanism can be qualitatively understood in the following way . the probability , @xmath90 , for a particle to jump across the boundary of the cell , within a circulation time @xmath91 , by virtue of molecular diffusion can be estimated as the ratio of the diffusive motion across streamlines , @xmath92 , to advective motion along streamlines , @xmath93 . as a result @xmath94 , hence the effective diffusivity @xmath95 . to obtain the expression of the typical time it takes for a whole cell to react ,
let us concentrate on the reaction in a single cell : it is first invaded by a mixture of reactants and products ( with a low content of products , @xmath96 ) on the fast advective time scale ; subsequently complete reaction ( @xmath97 ) is achieved on the slower time scale @xmath98 ( see fig .
[ fig:1 ] ) . in this regime ,
the front speed is well approximated the homogenization result @xmath99 , discussed in the previous section . within the same cell , at six successive times with a delay @xmath100 ( from left to right , top to bottom ) , as a result of the numerical integration of equation ( [ eq : rad ] ) . here
black stands for @xmath102 , white for @xmath53 . ] to check these ideas , we performed numerical simulations of eq .
( [ eq : rad ] ) , with a fkpp production term ( see appendix for details on the numerical technique ) . in fig
. [ fig:2 ] , we show the result of the calculations for the front speed @xmath25 in dependence on @xmath87 , the slow reaction corresponds to the plateau at @xmath103 .
, to the maximal one , @xmath104 , as a function of the damkhler number , @xmath87 . for @xmath103 the front propagates with the maximal velocity whereas for @xmath86 the speed slows down with increasing @xmath87 .
the behavior @xmath105 is drawn for reference . ] we have now to repeat the estimation of @xmath45 and @xmath82 for the fast reaction regime , i.e. , for large @xmath87 .
since we work always in the regime of large peclet numbers , all the above arguments for the effective diffusion still hold , while the effective time scale is different . at large @xmath87 ,
the ratio of time scales reverses , and in a ( now short ) time @xmath7 two sharply separated phases emerge inside the cell . in this regime indeed , the interface is thin compared to the cell size .
the cell filling process is characterized by an inward spiral motion of the outer , stable phase ( see fig .
[ fig:3 ] ) , at a speed proportional to @xmath0 , as it usually happens for a front in a shear flow at large @xmath87 .
therefore , the @xmath102 phase fills the whole cell on the advective time scale , giving @xmath106 . within the same cell , at six successive times with a delay @xmath107 ( left to right , top to bottom ) . here
a spiral wave invades the interior of the cell , with a speed comparable to @xmath0 . ] with respect to the upper bound ( [ eq : upb ] ) we observe for fast reaction a significative slowing - down of the front speed signaled by a different scaling dependence on the parameters @xmath109 ( see fig . [ fig:2 ] ) . for three different parameter : @xmath110 ( @xmath111 ) , @xmath112 ( @xmath113 ) and @xmath114 ( @xmath115 ) .
the continuous line shows @xmath8 .
the dotted and dash - dotted lines are the slopes ( @xmath116 and @xmath117 ) proportional to @xmath118 in the region of slow advection . ]
we have now to look at the shape of the effective reaction term @xmath119 appearing in the renormalized equation ( [ eq:3 ] ) . as shown in fig .
[ fig:5 ] , for small @xmath87 , the effective production term is indistinguishable from the `` bare '' one . increasing @xmath87 , the reaction rate tends to reduce , inducing the slowing - down of the front speed .
for @xmath120 , the effective production term essentially coincides with the microscopic one .
however , there is an intermediate regime characterized by a linear dependence on the cell - averaged concentration , with a slope proportional to @xmath118 .
this is in agreement with a typical effective reaction time @xmath121 ( see below eq .
( [ eq:5 ] ) ) . to measure the macroscopic quantities @xmath122 and @xmath123 ,
one simply integrates numerically both @xmath5 and @xmath8 at a fixed time over a cell volume .
it is worth to remark that , notwithstanding the change of shape of the effective chemical potential , the production term remains in the fkpp universality class .
let us stress that what we call fast reaction regime is still not in the geometrical optics limit . indeed , to obtain this limit it is not sufficient to take @xmath7 small , but one has to take also @xmath31 small in such a way that @xmath124 is constant
when @xmath125 goes to zero and the front thickness @xmath126 is negligible with respect to the cell size . in the fast reaction regime
studied here the condition on the front thickness holds .
+ collecting the information about fast and slow reaction @xmath127 and @xmath128 , we can derive the scaling of the effective speed of front propagation for a cellular flow .
indeed , recalling that @xmath129 , we have the final result @xmath130 the case of @xmath131 is less interesting because the dynamics is dominated by diffusion . at small @xmath87 the front propagates with an effective velocity scaling as the upper bound derived above , that is as @xmath132 . at large @xmath87 ,
the front speed enhanced is less effective than at small @xmath87 : according to eq .
( [ eq:6 ] ) , we have @xmath133 for @xmath134 . in terms of the typical velocity of the cellular flow
, we have @xmath135 for slow reaction ( @xmath136 , or equivalently @xmath103 ) whereas @xmath137 for fast reaction ( @xmath138 , or @xmath139 ) .
the scaling @xmath135 for slow reaction ( i.e. fast advection ) is a consequence of the well known result @xmath140 @xcite in the homogenization limit @xcite , it has been obtained in @xcite .
the numerical results are summarized in fig .
[ fig:4 ] . as a remark we mention that , for the class of boundary conditions investigated here , where the region of initially burnt material extends to infinity , no quenching @xcite takes place no matter of the used production term .
indeed , arrhenius - type nonlinearity substantially gives the same results as those of fkpp - type reaction presented above , i.e. , one has the two scaling laws @xmath135 and @xmath137 at fast and slow advection respectively ( see @xcite ) . as a function of @xmath0 , the typical flow velocity .
the lower curve shows data at @xmath141 ( fast advection ) .
the upper curve shows data at @xmath142 ( slow advection ) . for comparison , the scalings @xmath1 and @xmath2 are shown as dotted and dashed lines , respectively .
the horizontal line indicates @xmath30 , the front velocity without advection , for @xmath142 . ]
when the front thickness and the reaction time are much smaller than the length and time scales of the velocity field fluctuations one has the geometrical optics regime @xcite . in this case the front is a sharp interface separating the reactants from the products , and can be modeled in the framework of the @xmath38-equation ( [ eq : optics ] ) @xcite . physically speaking ,
one uses the @xmath38-equation when the front thickness is very thin and it is hard to resolve the diffusive scale .
as far as the cellular flow is concerned , the front border is wrinkled by the velocity field during propagation and its length increases until pockets of fresh material develop @xcite .
after this , the front propagates periodically in space and time with an average speed @xmath29 , which is enhanced with respect to the propagation speed @xmath30 of the fluid at rest @xcite ( see ref .
@xcite for some pictorial views ) .
the problem addressed here is the dependence of the effective speed @xmath29 on the flow intensity , @xmath0 , and the bare velocity , @xmath30 , that is expected of the form @xcite : @xmath143 where @xmath144 ) is a function which depends on the flow details . as far as we know ,
apart from very simple shear flows ( for which @xmath145 @xcite ) , there are no methods to compute @xmath146 from first principles .
mainly one has to resort to numerical simulations and phenomenological arguments . for turbulent flows , by means of dynamical renormalization group techniques , yakhot @xcite proposed @xmath147 with @xmath148 .
now @xmath0 indicates the root mean squared average velocity ( see also @xcite ) .
therefore , from ( [ eq : yakhot ] ) one has that @xmath149 for @xmath150 . for the cellular flow under investigation , albeit the exact form of the function @xmath146
is not known , a simple argument can be given for an upper and a lower bound by mapping the front dynamics onto a one - dimensional problem .
the starting point is the following observation . in the optical regime , since the interface is sharp , i.e. , @xmath151 is a two - valued function ( @xmath102 and @xmath53 ) , we can track the farther edge of the interface between product and material ( @xmath152 ) , which is defined as the rightmost point ( in the @xmath20-direction ) for which @xmath153 .
then we can define a velocity @xmath154 which gives an equivalent value of the standard definition within less than @xmath155 ( see fig . [
fig : ot2 ] ) . measured in the standard way ( [ eq : velocity ] ) ( @xmath111 ) , and as in eq . ( [ eq : defvel2 ] ) ( o ) .
the straight lines represents the average ( over a period ) of the measured value , and the lower and upper bounds .
the simulation parameters are @xmath156 , @xmath157 and @xmath158 . ] in fig .
[ fig : ot2 ] we show the time evolution of the point @xmath159 . after a transient , in the unit cell @xmath160 $ ] ( we describe the case @xmath158 , i.e.
, the one adopted here ) the point @xmath159 moves to the right along the separatrices of the streamfunction ( [ eq : stream ] ) , so that @xmath161 is essentially close to the values @xmath162 or @xmath163 . along this path
one can reduce the edge dynamics to the @xmath164-problem @xmath165 where the second term of the r.h.s .
is the horizontal component of the velocity field .
we have neglected the @xmath19-dependence , replacing it with a constant @xmath166 which takes into account the average effect of the vertical component of the velocity field along the path followed by ( @xmath167 ) . by solving ( [ eq : simplemodel ] ) in the interval @xmath168 one obtains the time , @xmath169 , needed for @xmath170 to reach the end of the cell . the front speed , as the speed of the edge particle , is then given by @xmath171 .
the final result is @xmath172 note that ( [ eq : func ] ) is valid only for @xmath173 .
( solid line ) and @xmath161 ( dashed line ) . the simulation parameters are the ones of fig .
[ fig : ot2 ] ] we have taken @xmath174 for the upper bound and @xmath175 ( which is the average of @xmath176 between @xmath162 and @xmath163 ) for the lower bound .
we have also computed the average of @xmath177 in a period of its evolution ( see fig.[fig : ot2 ] ) obtaining @xmath178 which gives indeed a very good approximation of the measured curve ( see fig .
[ fig : ot3 ] ) .
we stress that the theoretical curve is not a fit , but it just involves the measured parameter @xmath166 .
this agreement is an indication that the average of @xmath177 depends on @xmath0 and @xmath30 very weakly ( as we checked numerically ) .
previous studies @xcite reported an essentially linear dependence of the front speed on the flow intensity , i.e. , @xmath179 for large @xmath0 which is not too far but different from our result .
a rigorous bound has been obtained in ref @xcite by using the @xmath38-equation : @xmath180 as one can see from fig .
[ fig : ot3 ] , the lower bound ( [ eq : oberman ] ) seems to be closer to the numerical data than the one obtained with @xmath181 in ( [ eq : func ] ) . from eq .
( [ eq : func ] ) , asymptotically ( i.e. for @xmath182 ) one has : @xmath183 which corresponds to ( [ eq : yakhot ] ) for @xmath184 . as a function of @xmath185 ( @xmath111 ) , the yakhot formula ( [ eq : yakhot ] ) with @xmath148 ( o ) , the function @xmath186 for @xmath187 ( dashed and dotted lines ) and for @xmath188 ( solid line ) .
the dashed - dotted line is the bound ( [ eq : oberman ] ) . ]
expressions as ( [ eq : yakhot ] ) have been proposed for flows with many scales as , e.g. , turbulent flows , and in the literature different values of @xmath189 have been reported @xcite .
the fact that also the simple one - scale vortical flow investigated here displays such a behavior may be incidental .
however , we believe that it can be due to physical reasons . indeed ,
the large scale features of the flow , e.g. the absence of open channels ( like for the shear flow ) can be more important than the detailed multi - scale properties of the flow @xcite . a definite answer to this question is beyond the scope of this paper , however it could be an interesting point for future investigations .
we addressed the problem of front speed enhancement induced by stirring due to a cellular flow in different regimes . in the slow reaction case
a rather general result ( based on homogenization techniques ) gives @xmath190 ; for the fast reaction case , physical arguments give @xmath191 . in the geometrical optics
limit one finds that @xmath29 is a linear function of @xmath0 , apart from logarithmic corrections .
all these results has been confirmed by numerical simulations . the steady cellular flow treated here , albeit its simplicity , provides a paradigm that can be insightful for the study of front propagation in more general flows .
for instance , in the geometrical optics limit the asymptotical behavior @xmath183 is rather similar to the one found by yakhot ( @xmath192 ) @xcite for turbulent velocity fields .
+ one could conjecture that there are nontrivial reasons for this similarity : the front propagation principally involves the largest scales . in this context , it is not surprising that a multiscale process ( as turbulence ) or a single scale process can yield similar results .
we gratefully thank a. celani and a. torcini , who recently collaborated with us on the issue here discussed .
we also acknowledge stimulating discussions with r. m. mclaughlin and m. vergassola . this work has been partially supported by the infm _ parallel computing initiative _ and murst ( cofinanziamento _ fisica statistica e teoria della materia condensata _ ) .
m.a . has been partially supported by the european network _ intermittency in turbulent systems _ ( fmrx - ct98 - 0175 ) .
, d.v . and a.v .
acknowledge support from the infm _
center for statistical mechanics and complexity _ ( smc ) .
we introduce a lattice of mesh size @xmath193 and @xmath194 ( for the sake of simplicity we assume @xmath195 ) so that the scalar field is defined on the points @xmath196 : @xmath197 .
+ giving the field at time @xmath59 , the algorithm computes the field at time @xmath198 , and the integration method depends on which kind of physical regime we are interest in : reaction - advection - diffusion equation ( [ eq : rad ] ) or optical limit ( [ eq : optics ] ) . in numerical approaches one is forced to discretize the dynamics , so let us consider the case of a velocity field which is always zero apart from @xmath199-impulses at times @xmath200 @xmath201 in such a case the lagrangian evolution is given by a conservative map ( in 2d the map is symplectic due to incompressibility ) @xmath202 if also the production term is zero apart from @xmath199-impulses @xmath203 one can introduce a reaction map @xmath204 let us remark that choosing a @xmath199-impulsed production term can be particularly relevant in some experimental settings , i.e. , when one considers periodic illumination in light - sensitive chemical reactions as in ref .
the concentration field @xmath205 is obtained from @xmath206 solving the bare diffusion equation @xmath207 : @xmath208 or , in other terms : @xmath209 which is equivalent to eq .
( [ eq : feykacext ] ) .
let us remark that eq .
( [ eq : feykacmap ] ) is exact if both the velocity field and the reaction are @xmath199-impulsed processes .
however one can also use the formula ( [ eq : feykacmap ] ) as a practical method for the numerical integration of eq.([eq : rad ] ) if one assumes small enough @xmath210 , so that the lagrangian and reaction maps are given at the lowest order by @xmath211 from an algorithmic point of view the whole process between @xmath59 and @xmath212 , eq .
( [ eq : feykacmap ] ) , can be divided into three steps : ( 1 ) diffusive , ( 2 ) advective and ( 3 ) reactive .
the first two steps determine the origin of the lagrangian trajectory evolving with a given noise realization @xmath213 and ending in @xmath214 . in the third step , the reaction at point @xmath52 for the advected / diffused passive scalar @xmath5 is computed : this three steps can be numerically implemented as follow . for each grid point
@xmath218 , one uses @xmath219 independent gaussian processes @xmath220 , @xmath221 , @xmath222 , and computes @xmath223 . then , using the lagrangian backward propagator , @xmath224 . for @xmath225 one
needs the values of @xmath5 at time @xmath59 in the positions @xmath226 .
typically the @xmath226 are not on the grid points @xmath227 , nevertheless we can compute the value @xmath228 using simple linear interpolation from @xmath229 . therefore we have @xmath230.\ ] ] to correctly simulate the diffusion process we have to impose a relation between @xmath31 , @xmath193 and @xmath210 to assure that diffusion transports a particle over distances @xmath231 much larger than the grid size @xmath232 ( see fig [ fig : nummet ] ) . *
using the lagrangian propagator one evolves the interface between burned and unburned region ; * at each point of the evolved interface one constructs a circle of radius @xmath234 , burning the points within the circles . to numerically implement such
an algorithm one can proceed as follows : starting in a grid point , @xmath235 , of the scalar field at time @xmath236 one applies the backward evolution arriving at the point @xmath237 at the time @xmath59 . in this point
we construct the circle of radius @xmath234 . if in this circle there is at least one burned point of the scalar field at time @xmath59 , we fix @xmath238 otherwise @xmath239
. e. r. abraham , `` the generation of plankton patchiness by turbulent stirring '' , nature * 391 * , 577 ( 1998 ) ; e. r. abraham , c. s law , p. w. boyd pw , s.j lavender , m. t maldonado and a. r. bowie , `` importance of stirring in the development of an iron - fertilized phytoplankton bloom '' , nature * 407 * , 727 ( 2000 ) . j. ross , s. c. mller , and c. vidal , `` chemical waves '' , science * 240 * , 460 ( 1988 ) ; i. r. epstein , `` the consequences of imperfect mixing in autocatalytic chemical and biological systems '' , nature * 374 * , 231 ( 1995 ) .
a. n. kolmogorov , i. g. petrovskii , and n. s. piskunov , `` study of the diffusion equation with growth of the quantity of matter and its application to a biology problem '' , moscow univ .
bull . math . * 1 * , 1 ( 1937 ) ; + r. a. fischer , `` the wave of advance of advantageous genes '' , ann .
eugenics * 7 * , 355 ( 1937 ) . j.m .
ottino , _ the kinematics of mixing : stretching , chaos and transport _ ( cambridge university press , 1989 ) ; + a. crisanti , m. falcioni , g. paladin and a. vulpiani , `` lagrangian chaos : transport , mixing and diffusion in fluids '' , la rivista del nuovo cimento * 14 * , 1 ( 1991 ) .
solomon and j.p .
gollub , `` chaotic particle transport in time - dependent rayleigh - bnard convection '' , phys .
a * 38 * , 6280 ( 1988 ) ; `` passive transport in steady raleigh - bnard convection '' , phys .
fluids * 31 * , 1372 ( 1988 ) .
m. avellaneda and a. majda , `` stieltjes integral representation and effective diffusivity bounds for turbulent transport '' , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 753 ( 1989 ) ; + m. avellaneda and m. vergassola , `` stieltjes integral representation of effective diffusivities in time - dependent flows '' , phys .
e * 52 * , 3249 ( 1995 ) .
r. h. kraichnan , `` turbulent diffusion : evaluation of primitive and renormalized perturbation series by pad approximations and by expansion of stieltjes transforms into contributions from continuous orthogonal function '' , in _ the pad approximants in theoretical physics _ , p. 129
press inc .
, new york 1970 ) .
r. c. aldredge , `` the scalar - field front propagation equation and its applications '' , in _ modeling in combustion science _ , pp .
23 - 35 , eds .
, j. buckmaster and t. takeno ( springer - verlag lecture notes in physics , 1994 ) .
v. petrov , q. ouyang and h. l. swinney , `` resonant pattern formation in a chemical system '' , nature * 388 * , 655 ( 1997 ) ; m. dolnik , a. m. zhabotinsky , i. r. epstein , `` resonant suppression of turing patterns by periodic illumination '' , phys . rev .
e * 63 * , 6101 ( 2001 ) . | the problem of front propagation in a stirred medium is addressed in the case of cellular flows in three different regimes : slow reaction , fast reaction and geometrical optics limit .
it is well known that a consequence of stirring is the enhancement of front speed with respect to the non - stirred case . by means of numerical simulations and theoretical arguments
we describe the behavior of front speed as a function of the stirring intensity , @xmath0 . for slow reaction , the front propagates with a speed proportional to @xmath1 , conversely for fast reaction the front speed is proportional to @xmath2 . in the geometrical optics limit
, the front speed asymptotically behaves as @xmath3 .
pacs : 2 * front propagation in a stirred medium is an important problem in a number of fields ranging from combustion to plankton dynamics . for a realistic study of such a class of problems
one has to take into account the modification of the advecting flow induced by the reaction , e.g. in combustion .
however , many features can be understood by neglecting the back - reaction on the velocity field .
the problem addressed here is the enhancement of the front speed induced by a certain class of flows .
in particular , we consider front propagation in a two dimensional laminar flow with a stationary vortical structure in different regimes , namely slow reaction , fast reaction and geometrical optics limit .
this last limit corresponds to a very sharp front propagating as an optical front , i.e. , according to the huygens principle .
we provide predictions on the dependence of the front speed on the flow intensity , which are confirmed by numerical simulations . * |
all core collapse events with adequate spectropolarimetric observations have proven to be polarized and hence to depart from spherical symmetry in some substantial way ( wang et al .
2001 , 2003 ; leonard et al . 2001a , b , 2006 ) .
much of the spectropolarimetry shows a tendency for the data to be distributed along a single locus in the plane defined by the stokes parameters q and u. we are coming to understand , however , that departures from a single locus are rather common , and possibly systematic .
this implies a breakdown in axisymmetry that must be understood .
although this is becoming generally recognized with recent detailed spectropolarimetric studies of distant supernovae , sn 1987a provided the first evidence ( cropper et al .
1988 ; jeffery 1991 ) . on the theoretical side ,
core collapse generically produces a structure in the proto - neutron star that has a strongly negative angular velocity gradient and hence is unstable to the magnetorotational instability ( velikov 1959 ; chandrasekhar 1960 ; acheson & gibson 1978 ; balbus & hawley 1991 , 1998 ) .
the mri will exponentially grow the magnetic field on the rotational timescale by a self - induced turbulent dynamo process and produce strong , primarily toroidal magnetic fields in the proto - neutron star ( akiyama et al .
it is not truely self - consistent to consider rotating core collapse without the concomitant growth , saturation , and subsequent evolution of this magnetic field .
the ultimate problem is complex , involving rotation , magnetic fields , and neutrino transport , but it involves very interesting , and still underexplored , physics .
the first supernova for which good photometric and spectropolarimetric data were obtained was sn 1987a .
this data has still not been adequately explored and we can view it now in the context of the growing data base of more distant , but ever better studied supernovae .
jeffery ( 1991 ) summarized the photometric polarimetry obtained on sn 1987a ( fig .
both b band and v band data showed a slow growth to a polarization of 0.4 - 0.7% by day 30 - 40 .
the polarization then declined to a value near 0.2 - 0.3% by day 100 . around day 110 ,
when the major maximum gave way to the exponential radioactive tail , the polarization jumped to 1.3 to 1.5% and then slowly dropped back to around 0.2 to 0.4% by day 200 .
this jump is clearly associated with the photosphere receding through the outer hydrogen envelope and revealing the inner core .
this behavior was caught again for the type iip sn 2005dj by leonard et al .
sn 1987a gave clear evidence that the inner machine of the explosion was strongly asymmetric , evidence that has proven ubiquitous with current , systematic observations .
another remarkable fact is that the polarization angle did not waver through this whole evolution , including the large spike in polarization .
sn 1987a pointed " in a certain direction and maintained that orientation througout its development ( wang et al .
this can not be due to rayleigh - tayler nor richtmyer - meshkov instability .
other , large scale , systematic , directed asymmetries must be at work .
bochum event , " with velocity components displaced symmetrically about the principle h@xmath0 line , strongly suggests that sn 1987a was a bi - polar explosion ( hanuschik et al .
1989 ; wang et al .
2002 ) . on the other hand , the excellent spectropolarimetry of cropper et al .
( 1988 ; fig .
2 ) showed that as data is tracked as a function of wavelength over spectral features , the polarization angle does sometimes change with wavelength , giving rise to loops " in the plane of the stokes parameters , q and u. this means that there must be some substantial departure from axisymmetry imposed on the overall pointed " behavior revealed by the photometric polarimetry .
the loops are a locus with respect to wavelength , which itself is a probe of velocity slices in the homologously expanding matter .
this polarimetric behavior thus gives a rich phenomenology that is ripe in sn 1987a and other events for progress in physical understanding .
these loops will give greater insight into the composition - dependent three - dimensional structure of the ejecta .
, on the @xmath2 plane , of sn 1987a on may 5 1987 from cropper et al .
the filled grey circle is the isp , effectively the origin of polarization intrinsic to sn 1987a , on the @xmath2 plane from mendez ( private communication ) . ]
two other examples of non - axisymmetric loop structures in polarization data are given in maund et al .
( 2007a , b ) .
maund et al . ( 2007a ) discuss data on the type iib event sn 2001ig .
four days after discovery , when the supernova was still in the h - rich phase , the blended h@xmath0/he i 6678 p - cygni feature shows a distinct loop in the q / u plane , again signifying a systematic departure from axisymmetry ( fig .
3 ; left panel ) . in this case
, the blending of the two lines plays a special role .
maund et al . ( 2007b ) present data on the weird type ib / c sn 2005bf that resembled a helium - poor type ic in early data , but developed distinct helium - rich type ib features later ( wang & baade 2005 ; folatelli et al . 2006 ) . our observations on may 1 , 2005 , 34 days after the explosion , 18 days after the first peak in the light curve , and 6 days before the second peak ,
show a distinct loop in the he i 5876 line ( fig .
3 ; right panel ) .
related complex structures were revealed by the high - velocity type ic sn 2002ap ( wang et al .
thus although the sample is still small , evidence for non - axisymmetry may be ubiquitous .
a full understanding of the spectropolarimetry requires allowance for the background polarization of the interstellar medium of our galaxy , the host galaxy and , perhaps , the circumstellar environment of the supernova .
cropper et al .
( 1988 ) presented their data with no reference to this background .
jeffery ( 1991 ) quotes mendez ( private communication ) as determining the isp to be about q = + 0.36% and u = + 0.89% .
this component stayed constant for about 6 months and seemed serkowski - like . "
care must be taken since any ground - based point - spread function would include data from all the background stars , some of which are be stars that could be intrinsically , and variably polarized themselves , a problem for all extragalactic data . taking the mendez results at face value
gives a somewhat different perspective on the cropper et al .
for instance , as originally plotted , the cropper et al .
data give the impression that on june 3 , after the transition to the radioactive tail and during the spike of maximum photometric polarization , the h@xmath0 and ca ii ir features appear to show large loops " that are co - aligned , but in some sense mirror images of one another with h@xmath0 extending to positive q and u and ca ii extending to negative q and u. with the mendez isp point ( fig .
2 ) , the june 3 h@xmath0 loop is roughly symmetric in its major extent around the isp point , but ca ii only extends to negative values . both loops " appear to have a net displacement to the positive q side of a line parallel to the major axis of the loop and passing through the isp point .
the similarities and differences between these polarization structures are worth study in considerable more depth .
departure from axisymmetry and specifically the formation of loops " has been discussed by kasen et al .
( 2003 ) in the context of type ia supernovae and by hoffman ( 2007 ) in the context of type iin supernovae .
these structures could be caused by clumps of high - opacity material partially obscuring a polarized photosphere or by coherent , non - axisymmetric , composition - dependent , structures in the ejecta .
core collapse supernove , including sn 1987a , thus show strong evidence for axisymmetry , but also significant departures from axisymmetry .
the issue thus arises as to what physical processes drive the breakdown in spherical symmetry .
blondin , mezzacappa & demarino ( 2003 ) showed that the standing shock that forms after core collapse will be unstable .
there is still controversy as to whether this is a purely acoustically - driven instability that propagates primarily azimuthally ( blondin & mezzacappa 2006 ) or whether there is some radially - coupled vortical / acoustic feedback loop ( foglizzo et al .
burrows et al .
( 2006 ) have argued that the sasi may lead to , but be different from , a large scale instability in which g - modes are excited on the proto - neutron star surface that drive a large acoustic flux that could play a role in the explosion , perhaps making a substantially axisymmetric , but uni - polar explosion . as remarked above , sn 1987a
, at least , appears to have been truely bi - polar .
there is , in any case , no doubt that the basic sasi instability exists .
it must be taken into account in the physics of core collapse , and it will tend to introduce substantial asymmetries .
most of the simulations to date are 2d , non - rotating , and have no magnetic fields . some omit neutrino transport .
an important step was taken by blondin & mezzacappa ( 2007 ) to investigate the sasi in 3d .
remarkably , they found that a model with an initially non - rotating iron core , and hence no net angular momentum , produced a proto - neutron star rotating at with a 50 msec period .
this comes about because the sasi in 3d produces substantial lateral flows in the outer portions . to maintain conservation of angular momentum , an equivalent , but oppositely directed
, angular momentum must be accreted onto the core .
young & fryer ( 2007 ) find a similar behavior in 3d sph calculations .
this sort of behavior is extremely interesting since it relaxes the coupling between the rotational state of the original iron core and the spin rate of the neutron star that subsequently forms ( see also akiyama & wheeler 2005 ) .
rotation with ratio of rotational to binding energy t/|w| > 0.01 ( p @xmath3 20 - 30 msec ) may be subject to non - axisymmetric instability ( andersson 1998 ; shibata et al . 2003
; ott et al .
the thresholds , growth rates , and saturation , depend on the degree of differential rotation ( tohline & hachisu 1990 ; rampp et al .
1998 ; centrella et al .
2001 ; imamura & durisen 2004 ; ou et al . 2004 ) and will be affected by magnetic fields ( rezzolla , lamb & shapiro 2000 , 2001a , b ) .
a dynamic instability to a bar - like mode can occur for t/|w| as low as @xmath3 0.2 .
the criterion t/|w| > 0.27 is neither necessary nor sufficient for dynamical instability ( shibata & sekiguchi 2005 ) .
most work on non - axisymmetric instabilities considers the neutron star to be in complete isolation and ignores the magnetic field ; both are potentially significant . in the current context , it is important to realize that for sufficiently rapidly rotating proto - neutron stars , these naxi can occur deep inside the supernova material , before it has time to expand and dissipate .
the mri will grow magnetic field faster than all but dynamical bar - modes .
this means that the non - axisymmetric instabilities will usually occur in a magnetized medium .
ou & tohline ( 2006 ) examined the naxi due to the presence of a co - rotation point within a resonant cavity " formed by an extremum in vorticity density in a differentially rotating structure that serves to reflect acoustic waves .
note that while one - armed m = 1 spiral modes can be generated by this mechanism and by the sasi , the azimuthal acoustic modes due to the sasi are not the same as those of the naxi in a differentially - rotating proto - neutron star .
it is important to note that the density distribution near the region of peak shear and magnetic field in a proto - neutron star ( the boundary of the homologous core ) is approximately independent of whether a supernova has been successful or not in the interval 100 msec to 1 s after bounce .
this means that the naxi will interact with surrounding , magnetized matter .
the result is likely to be the generation of significant magnetoacoustic flux that will propagate out into the ambient matter , whether or not an explosion has been initiated by some other mechanism ( wheeler & akiyama 2007 ) . note also that according to the results of blondin & mezzacappa ( 2007 ) and of young & fryer ( 2007 ) , non - rotating iron cores can potentially generate rotating neutron stars subject to naxi , and hence to magnetoacoustic flux .
wheeler & akiyama ( 2007 ) estimate that for parameters appropriate to the proto - neutron star , a luminosity @xmath4 erg s@xmath5 could be radiated in magnetoacoustic flux on a time scale somewhat shorter than the de - leptonization time . at the larger end of this range , corresponding to t/|w| near the upper limit of 0.14 ,
the luminosity is quite competitive with neutrino heating rates .
the proto - neutron star formed at core bounce will radiate binding energy in neutrinos , contract , and spin up .
the time for de - leptonization is @xmath6 s to radiate most of the neutrino energy .
the time is shorter for the contraction of the radius , the key factor in spinning up the neutron star .
the former is comparable to the time for the blast wave to propagate out of the c / o or he core .
this means that de - leptonization also does not occur in the vacuum of space , but takes place within the matter - filled environment in the center of the supernova , whether it is in the process of exploding or not .
the tendency for the de - leptonizing pns to spin up will render it broadly susceptible to non - axisymmetric instabilities , the production of magnetoacoustic luminosity , and dissipation of rotation .
the evolution depends on the strength of that dissipation , but in general the time for dissipation of the rotational energy by magnetoacoustic flux will be less than the time for de - leptonization , @xmath3 10 s. constraints on the energetics of the de - leptonization phase are given by wheeler & akiyama ( 2007 ) .
the tendency for core collapse supernovae to follow a fixed axis has motivated interest in jet - induced explosions ( khokhlov et al .
rotation and magnetic fields are important ingredients in core collapse and those factors commonly lead to jets in many astrophysical environments . it still remains a significant challenge to understand how rotation and concomitant magnetic fields will lead to jets in the context of core collapse .
many groups are beginning to do rotating , magnetic simulations , but it is very challenging numerically to achieve the kind of numerical resolution needed to resolve the mri ( obergaulinger et al .
2006 and references therein ) . given that practical limitation , many groups have elected to do simulations with exaggerated initial magnetic fields and/or fields with exaggerated poloidal structure .
poloidal fields coupled with shear will naturally amplify the field strength by field - line wrapping .
this is a generically slow process since it depends linearly on the winding . to get useful " results it is necessary to have the poloidal configuration
be significantly strong .
neither a weak poloidal configuration nor a strong toroidal initial configuration are likely to produce interesting jet - like behavior in the absence of a numerical capability to follow the growth of the non - axisymmetric mri that can and will grow from a modest initial toroidal magnetic field .
calculations assuming an initially strong poloidal field can produce spectacular numerical results ( for a recent example , see burrows et al . 2007 ) , but it is not clear that these simulations reflect what nature is doing .
the initial field is likely to be modest and substantially toroidal , not poloidal , since it is likely to have been generated by shear in the progenitor star .
the same is true , of course , for the field generated by the mri or other dynamo processes in the proto - neutron star .
the challenge is to understand whether and how a jet is formed from an initially modest toroidal magnetic field .
note again that the initial iron core rotation might be modest .
if sasi - like processes spin up the neutron star independent of the initial core rotation and the rotation is enhanced during de - leptonization , there is still plenty of time and opportunity to affect the explosion dynamics with mhd jet and magnetoacoustic phenomena .
core collapse supernovae , including sn 1987a , show departures from both spherical and axial symmetry .
there is substantial evidence that the explosion of sn 1987a itself was truly bi - polar , but with important and interesting departures from axisymmetry .
the proto - neutron star that forms after core collapse will be rotating and will have a concomitantly strong , predominantly toroidal magnetic field .
these conditions might form a jet , but they are also conditions that could give rise to a strong , magnetoacoustic wave - generating engine .
supernovae make a loud noise ! the role of non - axisymmetric instabilities may help to explain the spectropolarimetry of core collapse supernovae and may also have major implications for supernova physics as well as for pulsar magnetic fields and spins .
jcw and jrm are exceedingly grateful for the fruitful collaboration with the members of our vlt spectropolarimetry team , dietrich baade , lifan wang , peter hflich , fernando patat and alejandro clocchiatti and to the wonderful facilities and crew at the vlt who make the observations possible .
jcw and jrm are supported in part by nsf grant ast0406740 .
wang , l. , wheeler , j. c. , hflich , p. , khokhlov , a. , baade , d. , branch , d. , challis , p. , filippenko , a. v. , fransson , c. , garnavich , p. , kirshner , r. p. , lundqvist , p. , mccray , r. , panagia , n. , pun , c. s. j. , phillips , m. m. , sonneborn , g. , & suntzeff , n. b. 2002 , apj , 579 , 671 | all core collapse supernovae are strongly aspherical .
the bochum event , " with velocity components displaced symmetrically about the principal h@xmath0 line , strongly suggests that sn 1987a was a bi - polar rather than a uni - polar explosion . while there is a general tendency to display a single prominant axis in images and spectropolarimetry , there is also growing evidence for frequent departures from axisymmetry .
there are various mechanisms that might contribute to large scale departures from spherical symmetry : jet - induced processes , the spherical shock accretion instability ( sasi ) and associated phenomena , and non - axisymmetric instabilities ( naxi ) .
the mri gives inevitable production of large toroidal magnetic fields . in sum : no @xmath1 without b. the role of magnetic fields , non - axisymmetric instabilities , and of the de - leptonization phase are discussed .
address = department of astronomy , university of texas at austin address = department of astronomy , university of texas at austin address = lawrence livermore national laboratory |
successful models for describing energy spectra , transition strengths and other nuclear phenomena usually work well in one region of a shell but not in others .
for example , the random phase approximation ( rpa ) @xcite is a reasonable theory for describing properties of nuclei near closed shells but fails in mid - shell regions where deformation is the most characteristic feature due to the importance of the quadruple - quadrupole ( @xmath9 ) interaction @xcite in this domain . for near mid - shell nuclei , algebraic models based on @xmath0 @xcite work best since the basis states are then eigenstates of @xmath9 .
applications of a nuclear shell - model theory always involve three considerations @xcite : * _ step 1 : _ selection of a model space based on a simplified hamiltonian . frequently used approximations include the simple harmonic oscillator hamiltonian for near closed - shell nuclei and a nilsson hamiltonian for deformed systems . *
_ step 2 : _ diagonalization of a realistic hamiltonian in the model space to obtain the energy spectrum and eigenstates of the system under consideration .
important components of a realistic hamiltonian include the @xmath10 and pairing ( @xmath11 ) interactions as well as single - particle @xmath12 and @xmath13 terms . *
_ step 3 : _ evaluation of electromagnetic transition strengths ( e2 , m1 , etc . ) between calculated eigenstates and a comparison with the available experimental data .
if the model hamiltonian includes free parameters , for example , single - particle energies and/or the strength of the @xmath9 and @xmath11 interactions , the procedure is repeated to obtain a best overall fit to the experiment data .
the easiest to use of modern shell - model codes are based on the so - called m - scheme logic , namely , model spaces spanned by many - particle configurations ( slater determinants ) with good projection of the total angular momentum @xcite .
good total angular momentum , which is a conserved symmetry due to the isotropy of space , is obtained by angular momentum projection
. codes of this type normally yield a good description of the single - particle nuclear phenomena ; unfortunately , an equally good description of collective phenomena within the framework of such a theory is very difficult to achieve . on other hand ,
an @xmath0 based shell - model scheme is designed to give a simple interpretation of collective phenomena .
an ideal scenario would incorporate both , allowing the hamiltonian of the system to `` choose '' which one of the two ( or an admixture ) is most appropriate . a project , code named red stick for baton rouge , is now under development at louisiana state university .
principal authors are jerry draayer , erich ormand , calvin johnson , and vesselin gueorguiev .
the goal of the project is to develop a new m - scheme shell - model code that allows the user to include @xmath0 symmetry - adapted basis states in addition to ( the usual ) single - particle based configurations . in this paper
we discuss the first stage of the red stick project a basis generator for @xmath14-scheme @xmath0 shell - model configurations .
we begin with a review of @xmath0 shell - model basics @xcite .
then we introduce an appropriate single - particle level scheme and give matrix elements of the generators of @xmath0 in that representation .
next we consider the structure of the highest weight state ( hws ) of an @xmath0 irrep , and especially the hws of so - called leading @xmath0 irreps .
once a hws is known , we then go on to show how all states of that irrep can be constructed using @xmath0 step operators @xcite .
states with good projection of the total angular momentum @xmath7 are obtained by considering the direct product @xmath15 .
some information about the fortran code that uses these techniques will also be presented . in this section
we review group theoretical concepts that are important to the development of the theory and introduce @xmath0 conventions adopted in our discussion .
we also consider the physical reduction @xmath16 and the canonical reduction @xmath17 with their respective labels .
first consider the so - called physical reduction @xmath18 , which yields a convenient labeling scheme for the generators of @xmath0 in terms of @xmath19 tensor operators .
the commutation relations for these @xmath20 tensor operators are given in terms of ordinary @xmath19 clebsch - gordan coefficients ( cgc ) @xcite : @xmath21 & = & -\sqrt{2}(1m,1m^{\prime } |1m+m^{\prime } ) l_{m+m^{\prime } } \nonumber \\
\lbrack q_{m},l_{m^{\prime } } ] & = & -\sqrt{6}(2m,1m^{\prime } |2m+m^{\prime } ) q_{m+m^{\prime } } \label{lq - elliott i } \\
\lbrack q_{m},q_{m^{\prime } } ] & = & 3\sqrt{10}(2m,2m^{\prime } |1m+m^{\prime } ) l_{m+m^{\prime } } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] within this reduction scheme , states of an @xmath0 irrep @xmath22 have the following labels : * @xmath23 @xmath0 irrep labels ; * @xmath24 total orbital angular momentum , which corresponds to the second order casimir operator of @xmath19 ; * @xmath25 projection of the angular momentum along the laboratory @xmath26-axis ; * @xmath27 projection of the angular momentum in a body - fixed frame , which is related to multiple occurrences of @xmath19 irreps with angular momentum @xmath24 in the @xmath23 irrep .
unfortunately , this scheme has only one additive label , namely @xmath25 , and in addition , there are technical difficulties associated with handling the @xmath27 label .
the labeling scheme for this project is the canonical reduction @xmath28 where @xmath6 is the @xmath29 generator and the @xmath30 generators are proportional to @xmath31 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 @xcite . under the action of the generators of these @xmath29 and @xmath30 groups , the remaining four generators of @xmath0 transform as two conjugate spin @xmath34 $ ] @xmath30 tensors with @xmath35 values for @xmath6 . for this scheme ,
states of a given @xmath0 irrep @xmath22 have the following labels : * @xmath23 @xmath0 irrep labels , * @xmath36 quadruple moment ( @xmath6 ) , * @xmath25 projection of the orbital angular momentum ( @xmath31 ) , * @xmath37 related to the second order casimir operator of @xmath38 , which for symmetric @xmath39 irreps is simply the number of oscillator quanta in the @xmath40 plane .
this canonical reduction , @xmath17 , has two additive labels , @xmath36 ( @xmath6 ) and @xmath25 ( @xmath31 ) and the allowed values of these labels for fixed @xmath0 irrep @xmath23 are given by @xcite : @xmath41 where @xmath42 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44
the algorithm we use to generate @xmath0 symmetry adapted states with good projection of the total angular momentum is described in this section .
it consists of four basic components : 1 ) definition of the single - particle levels and matrix elements of the @xmath0 generators for a given shell ; 2 ) generation of the hws of @xmath45 for given number of fermions @xmath1 and spin @xmath4 ; 3 ) generation of the other @xmath0 states by applying step operators to the hws ; and 4 ) generation of states of good total angular momentum projection , @xmath7 .
this will be followed by a short discussion of a fortran code that uses the algorithm .
single - particle levels of the @xmath46 @xmath47 harmonic oscillator shell belong to the symmetric @xmath48 irrep of @xmath0 . because @xmath49 , a typical three - dimensional representation of @xmath0 basis states , fig.[3d - view of su(3 ) irrep ] , reduces to a special two - dimensional triangular shape ( @xmath50 and @xmath51 become linearly dependent ) , fig.[single particle levels ] .
also , because @xmath0 is a compact group its irreps are finite dimensional and many - particle ( fermion ) configurations can be conveniently represented as binary strings with a @xmath52 or @xmath53 representing the presence or absence of a particle in the corresponding single - particle level .
( the latter , together with a `` sign rule '' to accommodate fermion statistics , is a convenient computer native implementation of a slater determinant representation of the basis states . )
a convenient ordering scheme ( which tracks the arrows in fig.[single particle levels ] ) is set by requiring a simple representation of many - particle configurations with maximum quadruple deformation .
this objective can be achieved if the states are ordered by @xmath50 ( quadruple moment ) first and then by @xmath25 ( projection of the total angular momentum ) . to be able to apply the @xmath0 generators on many - particle configurations it suffices to know the action of these generators on the single - particle states .
the eight generators of @xmath0 belong to the self - adjoint @xmath54 irrep of @xmath0 .
the operator structure should be chosen in the most convenient form for the application under consideration .
for the present application , this choice is the same as used for the basis states , namely , the @xmath55 reduction .
the matrix elements of the @xmath0 generators can be obtained either by using an application of the appropriate wigner - eckert theorem or by using explicit expressions @xcite for determining the action of the operators on the basis states . for computational purposes
it is better to adopt a direct solution , one that exploits the fact that the action is on a product of single - particle levels each of which belongs to a symmetric @xmath56 irrep of @xmath0 .
this allows the matrix elements of the @xmath0 generators to be calculated using properties of the @xmath30 only ( fig.[su(3 ) matrix elements ] ) .
a key feature is the fact that the six non - diagonal generators of @xmath0 ( recall that @xmath31 and @xmath6 are diagonal ) are rising or lowering generators of @xmath30 subgroups of @xmath0 .
the three @xmath30 subgroups and their respective actions are shown in fig . [
su(3 ) matrix elements ] .
states that are collinear with one of the sides of the triangular shape shown on the right in the figure form an irrep of the corresponding @xmath30 subgroup .
so far we have constructed single - particle states and evaluated matrix elements of the generators of @xmath0 when they act on these states .
the next step is to construct many - particle hws of @xmath57 . in the chosen scheme
there are seven extreme states which correspond to the vertexes of the three - dimensional diagram ( fig.[3d - view of su(3 ) irrep ] ) of a general @xmath58 irrep .
we are particularly interested in the vertex that has the maximum value for the quadruple moment of the system ( fig.[3d - view of su(3 ) irrep ] ) .
our hws is the state with @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 .
this hws ( maximum value of @xmath25 for maximum @xmath50 ) can be easily constructed by ensuring that the action of the @xmath0 rising generators annihilate it .
indeed , for such a hws the values of @xmath62 and @xmath63 can be determined from its @xmath50 and @xmath25 labels .
selecting the leading @xmath58 irrep ( hws with maximum overall value of @xmath36 ) out of all possible irreps of an @xmath1 fermion system with total system spin @xmath4 is very simple within the chosen scheme .
this is because the number of particles with spin up @xmath64 and spin down @xmath65 is uniquely determined by the solution of two linear equations : @xmath66 where the second equation expresses the fact that we also require the state to be highest weight with respect to @xmath67 .
further , maximizing the value of @xmath6 is achieved by filling the single - particle states of the @xmath56 irrep ( fig.[single particle levels ] ) from bottom to top .
the chosen scheme ensures that this simple procedure gives maximum values for @xmath50 and @xmath25 .
the @xmath0 irrep labels @xmath58 are obtained by evaluating the quadruple moment @xmath6 and projection of the angular momentum @xmath31 , as these are additive quantum numbers .
for example , in the @xmath68shell , there are six single - particle levels corresponding to the @xmath69 irrep of @xmath0 .
the hws of the leading irrep for @xmath70 particles and total system spin @xmath71 is @xmath72 ( fig.[n=6&s=1 ] ) , whereas for @xmath73 the leading @xmath0 irrep is @xmath74 ( fig.[n=6&s=0 ] ) .
these many - particle configurations are hws with respect to @xmath0 as well as @xmath67 .
once we have the hws of @xmath0 @xmath75 @xmath67 , we can generate any other state of the @xmath0 irrep @xmath23 by applying step operators similar to those given by hecht . by using the parameterization ( [ pqm - parametriztion ] ) @xcite
, we can identify the corresponding step operators , fig .
[ su(3 ) step operators ] .
it is important to note that applying @xmath76move or @xmath77move step operators to states on the top surface yields other states ( or zero ) on that same surface .
since the states on the top surface are hws with respect to @xmath30 in the @xmath0 @xmath78 @xmath79 reduction , the @xmath80move step operator is an @xmath30 lowering operator which changes the projection of the angular momentum , @xmath25 .
the @xmath76move and @xmath77move step operators can be obtained by imposing the restriction that they generate only transformations within the @xmath30 hws space . from an algebraic perspective , the @xmath76move and the @xmath80move operators are linear in @xmath0 generators while the @xmath77move operator is quadratic .
nevertheless , the state generation process can be written in such a way that the @xmath77move operator effectively reduces to a linear action .
these step operators can also be obtained by a projection operator technique @xcite . since the action of @xmath0 commutes with that of the spin , @xmath67 , it is not difficult to achieve the final goal of states with good total angular momentum projection , @xmath7
. recall that we started with the hws of @xmath0 @xmath75 @xmath67 .
we then introduced a procedure to generate other states of the @xmath0 irrep by applying step operators .
each of these states remains a hws of @xmath67 . by applying spin lowering operators to @xmath0 states with @xmath81
, we can generate states with labels : @xmath1 , @xmath4 , @xmath58 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath25 , and @xmath7 .
a fortran code that uses the above algorithm was run on three platforms : macintosh iici , power macintosh 8500 , and sun workstation . here
we give some of the run - time characteristics of the code for shells below the @xmath82shell : * on a @xmath83 mhz macintosh iici with math co - processor , @xmath84 mb of memory suffices and the longest run time for generating all states of any leading @xmath0 irrep was less than @xmath85 min . * on a @xmath86 mhz power macintosh @xmath87 , @xmath88 mb of memory was sufficient and the longest run time for generating all states of any leading @xmath0 irrep was less than @xmath89 sec .
* on a @xmath86 mhz sun workstation the longest run time for generating all states of any leading @xmath0 irrep was less than @xmath90 sec .
all states with good @xmath7 for any leading irrep of @xmath0 @xmath75 @xmath67 for the @xmath91 and @xmath92 shells can be generated in less than @xmath93 min . beyond the @xmath92shell ( @xmath94 )
, the number of configurations in a single @xmath0 state may exceed @xmath95 .
the storage requirement must be pushed up accordingly .
more storage is also needed because beyond the @xmath82shell the number of single - particle states exceed @xmath96 ( @xmath97 with the spin degree of freedom ) which means more than a single word is required to represent many - particle configurations .
an @xmath0 basis state generator for producing states with good projection of the total angular momentum , @xmath98 , and therefore one that is suitable for integration into modern @xmath14-scheme shell - model codes , is suggested as a possible way to obtain simultaneously a description of collective and single - particle nuclear phenomena .
indeed , a basis state generator that uses the algorithm described above and generates @xmath0 states as a sum of slater determinants ( many - particle configurations ) with good @xmath7 is available .
the basis state generation procedure consists of four main components as follows : * symmetric irreps of @xmath0 are chosen as single - particle shell - model states , * many - particle state is constructed as hws of @xmath0 @xmath75 @xmath67 , * @xmath0 step operators are applied to obtain other states within an @xmath0 irrep , * and finally , states with good @xmath7 are then obtained by @xmath67 lowering operators .
there are additional things that need to be done , especially the generation of other then leading irreps of @xmath0 .
this can be achieved by employing an algorithm for generating non - leading hws that is part of an @xmath0 reduced matrix element package @xcite or perhaps by using another more direct approach tailored to the present application .
the generation of other hws is important if one wishes to include states that are not maximally deformed in their intrinsic configuration in a calculation .
for example , these will be important if the non-@xmath9 parts of the interaction play a significant role .
the generation of good proton - neutron @xmath0 and @xmath7 states can be achieved in a variety of ways .
one scheme , the so - called strong coupling limit uses standard @xmath0 coupling procedures to couple the proton and neutron irreps to final irreps : proton states , @xmath99 @xmath100 @xmath101 @xmath102 , are coupled with neutron states , @xmath103 @xmath104 @xmath105 @xmath106 , to final states @xmath107 @xmath4 @xmath23 @xmath108 .
another procedure would be to extend what was done here for @xmath109 to @xmath110 reduced with respect to @xmath109 @xmath111 @xmath112 , the supermultiplet scheme .
the latter is not simple because the @xmath110 hws is not the one of primary interest in nuclear physics and therefore it must be reduced , which requires procedures like those developed here for a non - canonical reduction of @xmath110 .
the underlying goal is to be able to carry out shell - model calculations using @xmath14-scheme techniques with @xmath0 symmetry adapted basis states included in the basis .
the @xmath0 basis state generator described here provides good start in that direction , and therefore the beginning of an symmetry adapted @xmath14-scheme code that is an integral part of our red stick shell - model project . | a fortran code for generating the leading @xmath0 irreducible representation ( irrep ) of @xmath1 identical spin @xmath2 fermions in a harmonic oscillator mean field is introduced .
the basis states are labeled by @xmath1 the total number of particles , the @xmath0 irrep labels ( @xmath3 ) , and @xmath4 the total spin of the system .
the orthonormalized basis states have two additional good quantum numbers : @xmath5 the eigenvalue of the quadruple operator , @xmath6 ; and @xmath7 the eigenvalues of the projection of the total angular momentum operator , @xmath8 .
the approach that is developed can be used for a description of nuclei in a proton - neutron representation and is part of a larger program aimed at integrating @xmath0 symmetry into the best of the currently available exact shell - model technologies . |
the transport properties of a mesoscopic system are manifested in the evolution of its locally conserved quantities , such as particle and energy densities , following a quench from a non - uniform state . in its simplest form ,
one prepares an isolated system in an initial state at time @xmath13 with different density or temperature profiles to the left and right of the system , and then lets it evolve according to its internal translation invariant hamiltonian .
the state of the system at a time @xmath14 will then depend on the initial state and on the nature of the hamiltonian .
after a long time , a system with `` good '' ergodic properties will forget the details of its initial state and come to _ thermal equilibrium _ depending only on the total energy and on the number of particles of the initial state .
this is what is expected to be true for typical quantum systems .
the exceptions are integrable systems , in which there are many conserved quantities , and systems with many - body localization ; see , e.g. , @xcite . for such systems
there will still be an approach to some form of steady state , and this is sometimes called _ equilibration _ or _ stabilization_. ( while we would prefer the latter terminology to distinguish from _ thermal equilibration _ , also known as _ thermalization _ , the former is used for reasons of convention . )
the time of approach to a steady state will depend on the size of the system .
moreover , if one considers the entire system , there can never be a full loss of memory of the initial state .
after all , the evolution of an isolated quantum system is reversible , and for a finite quantum system the evolution is even quasi - periodic .
the approach to a steady state is therefore to be taken in a weak sense , i.e. , one has to look at local ( coarse - grained ) quantities and wait a long time but not too long
. this should be equivalent to start with a finite system , say a one - dimensional system on the interval @xmath15 $ ] for @xmath16 prepared in an initial state which is different to the left and right of the origin , evolve the system for a time @xmath17 , and consider its state projected on a subsystem taken as the interval @xmath18 $ ] for @xmath19 , followed by first letting @xmath20 and then @xmath21 while keeping @xmath22 fixed but arbitrary . in this way we can expect to obtain a steady state , described by a density matrix on the interval @xmath18 $ ] , and then ask for the density profile and the current in this final steady state @xcite . to anticipate the properties of a final steady state in this
set - up we consider first a system of length @xmath16 in contact with infinite reservoirs at its left and right boundaries with different fixed chemical potentials or temperatures @xmath23 and @xmath24 , respectively .
the coupling between system and reservoirs is done stochastically for classical systems @xcite , and for quantum systems one uses lindblad - type operators @xcite .
such a system will in general approach a steady state for fixed @xmath25 . we can then define the _ electrical conductivity _
@xmath26 as the ratio of the steady particle current @xmath4 to the average gradient @xmath27 : = .
[ df ] in the same way the _ thermal conductivity _ is defined as the ratio of the steady heat current to @xmath28 . in general , @xmath29 as @xmath20 , with @xmath30 depending on the type of system @xcite .
several cases can be distinguished : 1 .
@xmath31 ( normal conductivity ) . in this case
the system obeys _
fourier s law_. this has been shown , so far , only for classical systems with non - momentum conserving stochasticity in the bulk dynamics @xcite .
[ case_normal_conductivity ] 2 .
@xmath32 ( perfect conductivity ) .
this is the case , e.g. , for fully integrable systems such as the harmonic crystal @xcite or free fermions @xcite .
these systems have freely moving particles that carry the current .
[ case_perfect_conductivity ] 3 .
@xmath33 ( enhanced conductivity ) .
this is expected to be the case for anharmonic one - dimensional systems with momentum conserving interactions as , e.g. , in the fermi - pasta - ulam system .
the only case where this has been proven rigorously , with @xmath34 , is for a classical harmonic chain with momentum conserving stochastic interactions @xcite .
[ case_enhanced_conductivity ] 4 .
@xmath35 ( zero conductivity ) .
more precisely , @xmath36 exponentially in @xmath25 .
this is the case when one has localization as in a harmonic chain with random pinnings @xcite . here
too the result is for a classical system coupled to the reservoirs via langevin terms .
we expect , however , this to be the same for quantum systems .
[ case_zero_conductivity ] we note that in cases [ case_normal_conductivity ] and [ case_enhanced_conductivity ] it is not clear a priori how to model the stochastic interactions for a quantum system .
this is an important open problem .
going back to the isolated system of interest here , we expect the behavior of the subsystem on @xmath18 $ ] in the limit @xmath20 followed by the limit @xmath21 to be as follows . in case
[ case_normal_conductivity ] , the subsystem will be in a thermal equilibrium state with vanishing current . in case [ case_perfect_conductivity ] , it will be in a steady state that is translation invariant and has a non - vanishing current . in case [ case_enhanced_conductivity ] , it will again be in a translation invariant steady state but without any current . in case [ case_zero_conductivity ] , it will be in a steady state that maintains the initial profile , or something close to this , and thus will not be translation invariant or have a current .
case [ case_perfect_conductivity ] in the above general classification can be checked in concrete quantum models , simple enough to be accessible by analytical or numerical methods .
examples include quantum xx spin chains @xcite describing free fermions ; see also @xcite for closely related work . in this case
, the absence of interaction makes the system solvable , and , starting from a domain wall density profile , one gets a final steady state carrying a non - vanishing current .
the xxz model is an extension of the xx model describing interacting fermions , which is exactly solvable by bethe ansatz .
however , despite interesting recent progress @xcite , it still seems unclear if this solution can be used to acquire full information on the evolution of domain walls .
indeed , existing results on the evolution of quantum xxz spins chains from a domain wall state are mostly numerical or based on approximations @xcite . here
we shall consider a model for interacting ( spinless ) fermions that is more accessible to an analytical investigation , namely the luttinger model @xcite with a non - local interaction .
the first correct solution of this model and its ground state two - point correlation function were obtained in @xcite , and the evolution after a quench from a homogenous state was studied in @xcite for a local interaction and in @xcite for a non - local interaction .
we also note that , concerning its equilibrium properties , the luttinger model is a prototype for a larger equivalence class of one - dimensional systems called luttinger liquids @xcite .
the luttinger hamiltonian @xmath37 describes right- and left - moving fermions on a line for @xmath38 and @xmath39 , respectively , given by fields @xmath40 and @xmath41 satisfying antiperiodic boundary conditions and the canonical anticommutation relations \
{ ^-_r(x ) , ^+_r(x ) } = _ r , r ( x - x ) , \ { ^_r(x ) , ^_r(x ) } = 0 , [ psi_tilde_car ] with @xmath42 indicating _ wick _ ( _ normal _ ) _ ordering _ , _ fermi velocity _ @xmath43 , _ chemical potential _
@xmath44 , _ coupling constant _ @xmath45 , and a short range non - local _ interaction potential
_ @xmath46 ; see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein .
the chemical potential @xmath44 corresponds to the filled dirac sea , and we adopt the description where this is taken as the ground state .
this , however , means that there can be both positive and negative densities , which should be interpreted as relative densities to a large constant ground state density .
we consider an initial state with different density profiles to the left and right of the system , modeled as the ground state @xmath47 of the hamiltonian h_ , = h_ - _ r= _ -l/2^l/2
dx ( _ l ( -x ) + _ r ( x ) - _ 0 ) ( . : ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(x ) : .
- ) [ hamiltonian_with_mul_and_mur ] with different chemical potentials to the left , @xmath48 , and right , @xmath49 , assuming for definiteness @xmath50 , i.e. , @xmath51 as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : external_field ] .
we consider the evolution of this state under a luttinger hamiltonian @xmath52 with a new coupling constant @xmath53 , i.e. , we consider the state @xmath54 . in the case @xmath55 this corresponds to an experiment in which one switches off an external field producing an excess of density on one side of the system compared to the other at time @xmath13 and considers the evolution of the system under the translation invariant hamiltonian @xmath56 for time @xmath14 . on the other hand , if @xmath57 , there is in addition an interaction quench , i.e. , at @xmath58 there is also a change from @xmath45 to @xmath53 .
let us first consider the non - interacting case @xmath59 . by taking the limit @xmath20 followed by the limit @xmath21 , the system reaches a final steady state that is translation invariant and has a non - vanishing current that is linear in @xmath60 .
the steady state has the same two - point correlation function as the ground state of a system of non - interacting fermions with different chemical potentials @xmath61 for right- ( @xmath6 ) and left- ( @xmath7 ) moving fermions , as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : fermi_sea ] .
thus , at @xmath58 there is an excess of density on the left side compared to the right , and , asymptotically in time , there is a steady current corresponding to more right - moving fermions ( coming from the left ) than left - moving fermions ( coming from the right ) .
the current satisfies the following relation in the non - interacting case : i = ( _ l - _ r ) = ( _ + - _ - ) , where @xmath12 is the conductance quantum for the spinless case .
the conductivity defined in is therefore diverging linearly with @xmath25 ( corresponding to case [ case_perfect_conductivity ] in our general classification ) .
for right- ( @xmath6 ) and left- ( @xmath7 ) moving fermions starting from a domain wall state , @xmath51 ( solid lines ) , and from a uniform state , @xmath62 ( dashed lines ) . ] for right- ( @xmath6 ) and left- ( @xmath7 ) moving fermions starting from a domain wall state , @xmath51 ( solid lines ) , and from a uniform state , @xmath62 ( dashed lines ) . ] in this paper we address the question of how the interaction modifies the above picture .
the results are presented in detail in sec .
[ sec : results ] .
as before , the system reaches a steady state that is translation invariant and has a non - vanishing current that is still linear in @xmath60 but depends on the hamiltonian driving the evolution and on the initial state .
however , the final steady state obtained as @xmath21 has different chemical potentials @xmath63 and @xmath64 for right- and left - moving fermions , respectively , obtained from the two - point correlation function . while @xmath65 without interaction , this is not true in the interacting case : i = g_ , ( _ l - _ r ) = ( _ + - _ - ) , [ i_gll_mlmr_g_mpmm ] where @xmath66 is independent of @xmath60 but is a non - trivial function of the microscopic parameters @xmath45 and @xmath53 . the approach to this steady state is somewhat similar to the non - interacting case
: we will show that the system evolves _ ballistically _ but that the non - local interaction produces _ dispersion _ effects , similar to what is observed in numerical simulations for quantum xxz spin chains in @xcite .
when @xmath67 , the ratio @xmath66 between @xmath4 and @xmath60 reduces to the value computed at equilibrium in _ linear response theory _ , @xmath68 @xcite , where @xmath69 is the so - called luttinger parameter ; this was also found by numerical simulations in @xcite .
we find the relation in remarkable for the following reasons .
it says that the ratio of the steady current to the difference between left and right chemical potentials is highly _ non - universal _
( since it depends on the details of the initial state and the hamiltonian driving the evolution ) . on the other hand , the ratio of the steady current to the difference between chemical potentials of right- and left - moving fermions for the final state is perfectly _ universal_. the reason is that both @xmath4 and @xmath70 are renormalized a quantum many - body effect due to the interaction between the particles but with the property that the renormalizations precisely cancel if one takes their ratio .
this means that the landauer conductance @xcite for the final state is universal , which confirms previous results obtained in near - to - equilibrium approaches ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
however , we stress that we show this universality in a dynamical model of interacting fermions by a fully non - equilibrium approach
. further understanding of the final steady state can be gained by studying the correlation functions .
when @xmath67 this state has the same two - point correlation function as the ground state of a luttinger hamiltonian similar to @xmath56 but with different chemical potentials @xmath71 for right- and left - moving fermions .
this suggests that it corresponds to a generalized canonical ensemble @xcite .
however , this is very different if @xmath72 , where a different steady state is reached which can not be described as the ground state of some luttinger hamiltonian ( this can be seen by , e.g. , studying non - equal - time correlation functions ; cf .
also @xcite ) . this steady state , which has to be a function of the constants of motion of @xmath52 , has peculiar properties : its two - point correlation function has exponents which are non - trivial functions of @xmath45 and @xmath53 and thus different from the equilibrium exponents .
these non - equilibrium exponents reduce to the equilibrium ones computed in @xcite when @xmath67 and to the ones in @xcite when @xmath73 or @xmath74 , but the general expressions are to our knowledge new .
whether this state also corresponds to a generalized canonical ensemble is left open .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec : results ] we formulate the model and state the results . in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] we review the solution of the luttinger model in @xcite . in secs .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_an_external_field][sec : approach_to_steady_state ] we prove our results by , first , solving the luttinger model with an external field , second , quenching the system , and third , studying the approach to a steady state ; for the latter we use a mathematical result stated and proved in appendix [ app : asymptotics ] . in sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] we prove that , for @xmath55 , the two - point correlation function for the final steady state is the same as that of a luttinger model at equilibrium with different constant chemical potentials for right- and left - moving fermions ; this is extended in appendix [ app : general_interactions ] to more general interactions .
[ sec : concluding_remarks ] contains concluding remarks , including a discussion of the conductance in the luttinger model .
we study the evolution and approach to steady state of a system of right- and left - moving interacting ( spinless ) fermions on a line with length @xmath16 described by the luttinger model with a short range non - local interaction potential @xmath75 . the system is put out of equilibrium by switching off an external field producing an excess of density on one side compared to the other .
the time evolution is given by the hamiltonian in with fields @xmath76 , which is equivalent to @xmath77 with fields @xmath78 for @xmath79 and @xmath80 with @xmath81 ( corresponding to antiperiodic boundary conditions ) describing right- ( @xmath38 ) and left- ( @xmath39 ) moving fermions , where @xmath82 are fermion creation and annihilation operators ; this follows from the identities ^_r(x ) = e^ir^-1 _ 0 x ^_r(x ) , .
: ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(x ) : .
^+_r(x ) ^-_r(x ) : .
+ [ psi_tilde_to_psi ] ( the proof is given at the end of sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] ) .
important ( local ) observables we consider are the densities @xmath83 , which satisfy periodic boundary conditions if @xmath25 is finite .
we define the total density as @xmath84 and the current as @xmath85 . in appendix
[ app : general_interactions ] we show that these definitions are consistent with the continuity equation @xmath86 where @xmath87 and similarly for @xmath88 .
we note that the second identity in makes clear how the densities should be interpreted , namely as relative densities around the large ground state density of the filled dirac sea determined by the fermi momentum @xmath89 .
this explains why both positive and negative densities are allowed .
we require the following conditions on the fourier transform @xmath90 of the interaction potential to be satisfied : & 1 .
( p ) = ( -p ) p , + & 2 .
(p ) > - /2 p , + & 3 .
( p ) |p|^1 + 0 as p for some > 0 .
[ v_conditions_1 ] we will show that the second condition ( cf .
@xcite ) ensures that the system is stable and that the third is needed for the interacting and non - interacting fermion fock spaces to be unitarily equivalent . in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] we make the luttinger model mathematically precise by defining it in fourier space ( cf . remark [ remark : thermodynamic_limit ] ) . in particular , as is well - known , there is a unique hilbert space , the _ fermion fock space _ @xmath91 , defined by the canonical anticommutation relations and with _ vacuum _ @xmath92 given by the ground state of @xmath93 ( the relations determining @xmath91 are given in and ) .
moreover , the luttinger hamiltonian @xmath56 is a well - defined self - adjoint operator on @xmath91 bounded from below , with pure point spectrum , and with a non - degenerate ground state ; see , e.g. , @xcite for a recent review of the pertinent mathematical results .
the equilibrium properties of the luttinger model are well known and the ground state correlation functions can be exactly computed @xcite . if we let @xmath94 denote the ground state of @xmath56 , then , in the _ thermodynamic limit _
@xmath95 , the two - point correlation function is _ |
^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_= ( _ 0^dp ( p(x - y ) - 1 ) ) [ ss ] with @xmath96 ^ 2)^{-1/2 } - 1 $ ] .
as emphasized , this result ( derived in @xcite for a different interaction ) is in the thermodynamic limit ; this is motivated by our interest in length scales much smaller than the system size as discussed in sec .
[ sec : introduction ] . for later reference
we also note that implies _
| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_= e^-ir^-1 _ 0
( x - y ) _
| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) long distance decay of the correlation functions , with the appearance of an _ anomalous _ exponent @xmath97 , where , for large @xmath98 , the two - point correlation function decays as @xmath99 .
we investigate the non - equilibrium properties of this system when the initial state has an excess of density on one side compared to the other .
we choose as initial state the ground state of the hamiltonian in , which , using , is equivalent to h_ , = h_ - _ -l/2^l/2 dx ( x)(x ) , [ hamiltonian_with_ext_field ] where @xmath100 is an external field taken as a regularized version of @xmath101 ( with the heaviside function @xmath102 for @xmath103 and @xmath104 for @xmath105 ) as depicted in fig . [ fig : external_field ] .
for finite @xmath25 , we need to take the periodic boundary conditions into account , and for this we use ( x ) = - ( ( x/ ) - ( ( 2x+l)/2 ) - ( ( 2x - l)/2 ) ) [ wxl ] for some small @xmath106 . in sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_an_external_field ] we make this model well - defined by again working in fourier space .
by explicitly constructing all eigenstates and the corresponding eigenvalues of @xmath107 we show the following : [ thm : h_lambda_mu ] for finite @xmath25 , the hamiltonian @xmath107 in , with @xmath108 satisfying the conditions in and @xmath100 in , defines a self - adjoint operator on the fermion fock space @xmath91 .
this operator is bounded from below , has pure point spectrum , and a non - degenerate ground state . from sec .
[ sec : introduction ] we recall that the ground state of @xmath107 is denoted by @xmath109 , and we consider the evolution of this state under a different hamiltonian @xmath110 with coupling constant @xmath53 and no external field , i.e. , we quench the system and consider |_,^(t)= e^-ih_t|_ , . [ psi_lp_l_m ] we show that this state tends to a steady state as @xmath21 by analytically computing the expectation values of certain observables .
it is at the level of these expectation values that we pass to the thermodynamic limit ( cf .
remark [ remark : thermodynamic_limit ] ) , and in this limit we use the regularized external field @xmath111 .
this external field has the fourier transform ( p ) = , [ reg_wint_fourier ] and letting @xmath112 yields @xmath113 which is the fourier transform of @xmath101 ( interpreted in a distributional sense as a cauchy principal value ) .
we also impose the following conditions on the interaction potential in order to derive exact results for the asymptotical behavior of the system : & 1 .
( p ) c^2 ( ) ( a.e . ) , + & 2 .
( p ) , d(p)/dp , d^2(p)/dp^2 l^1 ( ) , + & 3 .
p d(p)/dp > -- 2(p ) p. [ v_conditions_2 ] as will be shown , the third condition means that the system evolves with a positive group velocity ( cf . ) .
[ remark : thermodynamic_limit ] following the approach described in sec .
[ sec : introduction ] , we only define the luttinger model for finite @xmath25 .
this allows for a simple rigorous construction of the model in fourier space ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
it is only for expectation values of observables , after we have computed them for finite @xmath25 , that we pass to the thermodynamic limit @xmath20 . to make this clear
, we use @xmath114 to denote expectation values for finite @xmath25 and write @xmath115 , and similarly for other quantities .
we first consider the case without interaction between the fermions , i.e. , @xmath116 .
the results follow as special cases from the proofs in sec .
[ sec : evolution_following_a_quench ] . for the total density and the current
we show that @xmath117 if @xmath118 , or our regularized version thereof , this means that there is a central region @xmath119 around @xmath120 with zero total density ( relative to the large constant ground state density ) bounded by two fronts moving with constant velocity .
the shape of the fronts does not change with time , and , as @xmath121 , the system reaches a state with vanishing total density everywhere .
similarly , the current is non - zero in the same region , and , as @xmath121 , it tends to the non - vanishing value @xmath122 everywhere .
we also show that the two - point correlation function without interaction is given by _
0,^0(t)| ^+_r(x)^-_r(y ) |_0,^0(t)= ( -ir^-1 _ y - rt^x - rt dz ( z ) ) . for finite @xmath17 ,
the two - point correlation function is not translation invariant .
however , asymptotically in time , _ t _ y - rt^x - rt dz ( z ) = r , meaning that translation invariance is recovered : _ t _ 0,^0(t)| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_0,^0(t)= .
[ acc0 ] since is similar to with @xmath73 , this suggests that the final steady state is similar to the ground state of free fermions with different chemical potentials @xmath123 for right- and left - moving fermions , obtained from the two - point correlation function ( cf . ) .
we can make this precise by comparing with the two - point correlation function obtained from a hamiltonian describing such a system ; this we will do below for the case with interaction .
therefore , in absence of interaction , a very clear picture emerges : the ground state of free fermions , with an external field producing a domain wall , evolves as @xmath121 to a steady state which has the same two - point correlation function as that of a ground state of free fermions with different chemical potentials for right- and left - moving fermions .
let us now consider the evolution of the domain wall initial state in the presence of interaction , i.e. , with non - zero @xmath45 and @xmath53 .
the question we try to answer is the following : how does the interaction modify the evolution of the domain wall state ?
below we present the exact results for general @xmath45 and @xmath53 .
the proofs are given in sec .
[ sec : evolution_following_a_quench ] .
we show that the total density and the current are given by the following exact expressions in the thermodynamic limit : @xmath124 with the _ renormalized fermi velocity _
v_(p ) = [ vl ] and the _ luttinger parameter _
k_(p ) = . [ luttinger_parameter ] for our particular interaction @xmath125 and @xmath126
satisfy @xmath127 , but we note that this is not true in general ; see , e.g. , @xcite or appendix [ app : general_interactions ] .
for a special case , similar to a case considered in @xcite , we plot the total density in fig . [
fig : total_density ] and the current in fig .
[ fig : current ] for the subsystem on the interval @xmath18 $ ] with @xmath19 . in this case , the initial state is the non - interacting ground state @xmath128 , which is evolved under @xmath52 with the non - local interaction potential @xmath129 with interaction range @xmath130 . we show that the two - point correlation function is given by the following exact expression in the thermodynamic limit : _ ,^(t)|
^+_r(x)^-_r(y ) |_,^(t)= e^-ir^-1 a_r(x , y , t)(x - y ) s_r(x , y , t ) [ psi_psi_factoring_infinite_l ] with a_r(x , y , t ) = _ -^ ( p ) ( ( pv_(p)t ) - ir v_(p ) ( pv_(p)t ) ) [ arxyt ] and s_r(x , y , t ) = _
,0^(t)| ^+_r(x)^-_r(y ) |_,0^(t ) .
[ srxyt ] the latter is the two - point correlation function in the absence of external field , i.e. , @xmath62 , in which case the initial state is the ground state @xmath131 of @xmath56 but the hamiltonian driving the evolution is @xmath52 as before .
we show that s_r(x , y , t ) = ( _ 0^dp ( p(x - y ) - 1 ) ) [ l_lp_two_point_func ] with exponents _ , (p ) & = - 1 , + _ , (p ) & = .
[ eta_gamma_k_kp ] in general , these differ from the equilibrium exponents in .
the latter are obtained only when @xmath55 , in which case @xmath132 and @xmath133 , where @xmath134 can be expressed in terms of @xmath135 using .
note also the identity _ , (p ) = _ (p ) + _ , (p ) .
[ eta_l_lp_equal_eta_l_gamma_l_lp ] this shows that the correlation function in is , indeed , recovered at time @xmath13 .
using the results above we study the asymptotic behavior of the total density , the current , and the two - point correlation function .
one important quantity describing the evolution is the group velocity v^g_(p ) = d(pv_(p))/dp , [ vg ] which we require to be positive ( cf .
lemma [ lemma : asymptotics ] in appendix [ app : asymptotics ] where the positivity of @xmath136 is needed ) .
this can be shown to correspond to the third condition in . in sec .
[ sec : approach_to_steady_state ] we prove the following result ( see for a stronger version of ): [ thm : asymptotics ] if @xmath108 satisfies the conditions in and , then _
t r(x , t ) = 0 , _ t i(x , t ) = , _
t a_(x , y , t ) = x , y [ rxt_ixt_arxyt_asymptotics ] and @xmath137 where @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
one consequence of is that , while the two - point correlation function in is not translation invariant for finite @xmath17 , translation invariance is recovered asymptotically in time .
this is a generalization of the corresponding result derived in @xcite . as in the non - interacting case , by comparing with , it follows that describes fermions with different chemical potentials for right- and left - moving particles , _ - _ 0 = , [ mr_m0_equal_ar ] obtained from the phase factor in the correlation function ( cf . ) .
however , since @xmath140 when @xmath72 , the correlation function in is not , in general , a ground state two - point correlation function as in .
the only case where this could be true is if @xmath55 , and in sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] we prove the following result allowing us to compare with the corresponding ( equal - time ) two - point correlation function : [ thm : hamiltonian_2 ] for finite @xmath25 , the hamiltonian h = h_ - _ r= ( _ r - _ 0 ) q_r , q_r = _ -l/2^l/2 dx _ r(x ) , [ hamiltonian2 ] with @xmath108 satisfying the conditions in and @xmath71 being constant chemical potentials satisfying @xmath141 , defines a self - adjoint operator on the fermion fock space @xmath91 . this operator is bounded from below , has pure point spectrum , and a non - degenerate ground state . denoting the ground state of @xmath142 by @xmath143 , the two - point correlation function in the thermodynamic limit is | ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |= ( _ 0^dp ( p(x - y ) - 1 ) ) [ psi_psi_correl_2 ] with @xmath144 in .
thus , for @xmath55 and are the same , and this justifies the identification in . moreover , while we do not give the details , this result can also be extended to non - equal - time two - point correlation functions , as explained at the end of sec .
[ sec : approach_to_steady_state ] . in conclusion , as @xmath121 ,
the system reaches a translation invariant steady state with a vanishing density and a non - vanishing current .
the region of vanishing density increases with time and lies between two fronts which evolve ballistically . however , for a non - local interaction , as in figs .
[ fig : total_density ] and [ fig : current ] , the system is _
dispersive_. to see this , note that , contrary to the non - interacting case , the renormalized fermi velocity in and therefore also the group velocity in , which determines the propagation of the fronts , depend on the momentum .
this means that the shape of the fronts changes over time .
these dispersion effects appear , e.g. , as oscillations traveling ahead of the fronts in figs .
[ fig : total_density ] and [ fig : current ] .
similar behavior was found in numerical simulations for quantum xxz spin chains in @xcite . only in the case
@xmath67 , i.e. , if the quench consists simply of switching off the external field , does one find that the steady state has the same two - point correlation function as the ground state of the hamiltonian in with different chemical potentials @xmath71 for right- and left - moving fermions .
when @xmath72 the final steady state is inherently different from a ground state of such a hamiltonian since the non - equilibrium exponents in are different from the equilibrium ones in .
this implies that memory of the initial state is conserved for infinite times ; cf . also @xcite .
it follows from theorems [ thm : asymptotics ] and [ thm : hamiltonian_2 ] that the final steady state carries a current @xmath145 and has an effective chemical potential difference @xmath146 depending on the coupling constants @xmath45 and @xmath53 .
however , even though the final state depends on the details of the time evolution and the initial state , the landauer conductance @xcite is universal : g = = = , [ landauer_conductance_cancelation ] which is equal to the conductance quantum @xmath147 ( in units where @xmath148 ) for the spinless case .
since , in general , the final steady state is not the ground state of a luttinger hamiltonian , this universality is a true non - equilibrium phenomenon .
finally , we note that the formulas given above for the evolution following a quench can be shown to remain valid for more general interactions in the luttinger model ; cf . the final remark in appendix [ app : general_interactions ] .
we first solve the model in the absence of external field .
what follows essentially reviews the solution of the luttinger model in @xcite but for a different interaction ( cf .
the appendix in @xcite ) than the usual luttinger interaction @xcite ( cf . also appendix [ app : general_interactions ] ) .
note that here and in the reminder of the paper we use the convention that sums over variables range over all allowed values , unless specified otherwise .
the ground state of the non - interacting hamiltonian @xmath93 is the filled dirac sea @xmath92 defined by the condition a^-_r , rk |_0= a^+_r ,- rk |_0= 0 k > 0 [ a1 ] using fermion creation and annihilation operators @xmath149 , @xmath79 and @xmath150 with @xmath81 , satisfying \ { a^-_r , k^ , a^+_r,k } = _ r , r _ k , k , \ { a^_r , k^ , a^_r,k } = 0 .
[ a2 ] the conditions in and fully determine the fermion fock space @xmath91 , and the @xmath149 can be used to construct fields @xmath151 describing right- ( @xmath38 ) and left- ( @xmath39 ) moving fermions .
we define the densities as @xmath152 for @xmath153 with @xmath81 , where wick ( normal ) ordering @xmath42 can be defined as . :
= a - _ 0| a |_0[wick_ordering ] for operators @xmath154 .
the densities satisfy = r_r , r _ p , p , + _
+ ( p)|_0= _ -(-p)|_0= 0 p 0 , [ fg ] and expressing the non - interacting hamiltonian in fourier space in its bosonized form , h_0 = ( _ + ( 0)^2 + _ -(0)^2 ) + _ p>0 ( _ + ( -p)_+(p ) + _ -(p)_-(-p ) ) , one can see that = - rp _
[ h0_rsp ] these results are well - known in both the condensed matter and mathematical physics literature ; see , e.g. , @xcite for self - contained proofs .
( we note that our conventions differ from @xcite in that @xmath155 and @xmath156 in @xcite correspond to our densities @xmath157 and @xmath158 , respectively , and our conventions for the fourier transform are such that @xmath159 for the densities , while in @xcite the corresponding transform has a minus sign in the exponent . )
we now consider the interacting hamiltonian h_ & = h_0 + , + & = ( 0 ) ( 0)^2 + _ p 0 ( p ) ( p ) ( -p ) with @xmath160 and @xmath161 satisfying the conditions in .
as explained in @xcite , @xmath56 can be diagonalized by a bogoliubov transformation implemented by a unitary operator @xmath162 ( defined in ):
s_ h_ e^-i s_ = h_0 - t_ + d_ + w_ [ diagonalized_hamiltonain ] with t_ & = - (0 ) ( 0)^2 + _ p>0 ( _ + ( -p)_+(p ) + _ -(p)_-(-p ) ) , + d_ & = _
p>0 v_(p ) ( _ + ( -p)_+(p ) + _ -(p)_-(-p ) ) , + w_ & = - _ p>0 ( - v_(p ) ) p , [ diagonalized_hamiltonain_ops ] where @xmath126 is the renormalized fermi velocity in .
since @xmath163 contains only zero modes and @xmath164 is a c - number , both commute with the densities @xmath165 .
the unitary operator @xmath162 is given by s_ = i _ p 0 _ + ( -p)_-(p ) , 2_(p ) = - p 0 .
[ s_operator ] it follows that @xmath166 = -i\ph_{\l}(p ) \r_{-r}(p)$ ] for @xmath167 , which means that e^i s_ _ r(p ) e^-i s_ = _
r(p)_(p ) + _ -r(p)_(p ) [ epis_rsp_emis ] ( to see this , define @xmath168 , differentiate , and solve the resulting differential equation @xmath169 with @xmath170 ) . the interacting ground state is @xmath171 with ground state energy @xmath164 .
since the latter has to be a finite number , this imposes the condition in that @xmath161 must decay faster than @xmath172 for large @xmath173 .
we also note that , when deriving , @xmath126 is found as v_(p ) = e^-2_(p ) , [ vl_ph ] which , using , gives precisely .
( the relation in does _ not _ hold for the general interactions considered in appendix [ app : general_interactions ] ; cf .
the comment below . ) from this we see that , since @xmath126 has to be real , we must impose the stability condition @xmath174 in .
moreover , similar to , = - r v_(p ) p _
r(p ) , [ d_rsp ] which makes clear that @xmath126 is , indeed , to be interpreted as the renormalized fermi velocity .
finally , we demonstrate how to construct the eigenstates of @xmath56 from the eigenstates of @xmath93 . to construct the latter we need the operators @xmath175 in , which are hermitian , and also to introduce new operators @xmath176 called _ klein factors _ , which are unitary , satisfying = r_r , rr_r , r_r_= -r_r _ , _ 0| r_+^q_+ r_-^-q_- |_0= _
q_-,0 q_+,q_- [ qs_and_rs ] and commuting with all @xmath165 for @xmath167 ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
for the latter , i.e. , densities with non - zero momenta , we find it convenient to introduce boson creation and annihilation operators b^+_p = ( b^-_p ) ^ , b^-_p = -i _ + ( p ) & if p > 0 , + + i _
-(p ) & if p < 0 , + [ bpm ] respectively , satisfying = _ p , p , = 0 , b^-_p|_0= 0 p 0 .
it follows that the exact eigenstates of @xmath93 ( the eigenvalues are given by for @xmath177 ) are |_0 , = ( _ p 0 ) r_+^q_+ r_-^-q_- @xmath178 with @xmath179 and @xmath180 , where at most finitely many of the @xmath181 are non - zero .
the ground state of @xmath93 is identified as @xmath182 .
these states form an orthonormal basis for the fermion fock space @xmath91 , and we denote by @xmath183 the set of all finite linear combinations of these eigenstates , from which @xmath91 can be obtained by norm - completion ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
the integer pair @xmath184 can be interpreted as the chiral charges of a given state , and @xmath185 and @xmath186 as charge and charge - changing operators , respectively .
it follows that |_ , = e^-is_ @xmath56 with eigenvalues _
, = ( q_+^2 + q_-^2 + ( q_+ + q_-)^2 ) + _ p 0 v_(p ) |p| m(p ) + w_ .
[ interacting_eigenvalue ] as for the case without interaction , the ground state of @xmath56 is identified as @xmath187 .
we note that , even though many identities stated involve unbounded operators , they are well - defined on @xmath183 ; see , e.g. , @xcite for mathematical details .
we extend the exact solution of the luttinger model to include the case with an external field @xmath100 satisfying the condition @xmath188 as well as periodic boundary conditions ( which we recall are needed if @xmath25 is finite ) . in other words , we consider the hamiltonian h_ , = h_0 + - [ hamiltonian_with_ext_field_in_fourier_space ] with = _ r _ p ( -p ) _
r(p ) , where @xmath189 is the fourier transform of @xmath100 satisfying @xmath190 due to the condition that the integral of @xmath100 over the entire space is zero .
to diagonalize @xmath107 we introduce an operator @xmath191 defined as a_ , = _ r _ p 0 ( -p ) r _
r(p ) for some suitable function @xmath192 with fourier transform @xmath193 , chosen so that it removes all terms linear in the densities ; we note that , without loss of generality , we may set @xmath194 .
it follows that @xmath195 = - p \hat{\h}(p)/2\pi$ ] , which implies e^ia_ , _
r(p ) e^-ia_ , = _
r(p ) - ip ( p ) [ f1 ] ( to see this , define @xmath196 , differentiate , and solve the resulting differential equation @xmath197 with @xmath170 ) .
this operator applied to each term in the hamiltonian yields : e^ia_ , h_0 e^-ia_ , & = h_0 - _ r _ p ( -ip ) ( -p ) _
r(p ) + _ p p^2 | ( p ) e^ia_ , e^-ia_ , & = - _ r _ p ( -ip)(-p)_r(p ) + _ p p^2 | ( p ) |^2 , + e^ia_ , e^-ia_ , & = - _ p ( -p ) ip ( p ) , where @xmath198 . therefore , by choosing @xmath193 such that ( 1 + 2(p)/ ) ip ( p ) + ( p ) = 0 [ iph1 ] is satisfied , we find that the hamiltonian can be diagonalized using @xmath162 in : e^is_e^ia_ , h_ , e^-ia_ , e^-is_ = h_0 - t_ + d_ + w_ , [ hamiltonian_with_ext_field_diagonalized ] with w_ , = w_- _ p | ( p ) |^2 using @xmath126 in , @xmath125 in , and @xmath164 in , where @xmath199 .
we note that the luttinger parameter @xmath125 can be expressed as k_(p ) = e^2_(p ) , [ luttinger_parameter_ph ] which , using , gives precisely .
( the relation in can be shown to hold for the general interactions considered in appendix [ app : general_interactions ] . )
the ground state of @xmath107 is thus @xmath200 with ground state energy @xmath201 . since the latter must be finite , this implies that the external field must satisfy _
p | ( p ) @xmath202 in .
we also note that can be written as ip ( p ) = - ( p ) [ iph2 ] using @xmath126 in and @xmath125 in .
this together with yields the identity e^ia_ , _
r(p ) e^-ia_ , = _
r(p ) + ( p ) p , [ epia_rsp_emia ] which shows that the external field appears as a c - number added to @xmath165 after the transformation under @xmath203 .
moreover , it follows from , , and that the exact eigenstates of @xmath107 are @xmath178 with @xmath179 and @xmath180 , where at most finitely many of the @xmath181 are non - zero .
the corresponding eigenvalues are _ , , = ( q_+^2 + q_-^2 + ( q_+ + q_-)^2 ) + _ p 0 v_(p ) |p| m(p ) + w_ , .
[ h_lm_eigenvalues ] it is clear that the eigenstates of @xmath204 in form a complete orthonormal basis for the fermion fock space @xmath91 defined in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] .
this implies that @xmath107 is self - adjoint on @xmath91 and has a pure point spectrum .
moreover , it follows from that all eigenvalues of @xmath204 are @xmath205 and that its ground state can be identified as @xmath206 which is clearly non - degenerate .
this also implies that @xmath204 is bounded from below .
this proves theorem [ thm : h_lambda_mu ] .
assuming the system is in the ground state @xmath109 of @xmath107 in , we study its evolution under @xmath52 and compute the expectation values of certain local observables .
first , we consider the total density @xmath207 and the current @xmath208 .
second , we compute the fermion two - point correlation function . as we will see , the results in and are the workhorse in these computations .
we recall that the expectation values are first computed for finite @xmath25 and then we pass to the thermodynamic limit ( cf .
remark [ remark : thermodynamic_limit ] ) . to compute the expectation values of @xmath209 and @xmath210 with respect to @xmath211 in , where we recall that @xmath212 , we first derive the time evolution of @xmath165 under @xmath52 , do a similarity transformation under @xmath213 , take the inverse fourier transform , and then compute the expectation value with respect to @xmath214 . through repeated use of and
we find the following transformation rule for the densities : @xmath215 with the coefficients u^++_ , (p ) & = _
(p ) ( _ (p)-_(p ) ) , & u^_ , (p ) & = _
(p ) ( _ (p)-_(p ) ) , + u^+-_ , (p ) & = _
(p ) ( _ (p)-_(p ) ) , & u^-+_ , (p ) & = _
(p ) ( _ (p)-_(p ) ) .
[ u_coefficients ] it thus follows , using the inverse fourier transform @xmath159 and computing the expectation value of with respect to @xmath214 , that the time evolution of the total density is _
,^(t)| ( x ) the time evolution of the current is _ ,^(t)|
j(x ) |_,^(t)_l = _ p ( p ) v_(p ) ( -2i ( pv_(p)t ) ) e^ipx .
[ ixt_l ] the results in and are obtained from and in the thermodynamic limit . to compute the two - point correlation function we use the following lemma which allows us to obtain the fermion fields @xmath216 as limits of regularized fields ( for proof see , e.g. , @xcite or proposition 3.7 in @xcite ) : [ lemma : psi_reg ] let @xmath217 and consider ^_r(x ; ) = l^-1/2 e^irx q_r / l r^r_r e^irx
q_r / l ( _ p > 0 e^- p ) ( r_p 0 _ r(p ) e^ipx - defined in sec . [ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] .
then @xmath218 converge to @xmath216 as @xmath219 in the following distributional sense : _ -l/2^l/2
dx ^_r(x ) e^ikx = _ 0^+ _ -l/2^l/2 dx ^_r(x ; ) e^ikx [ reg_psi_to_psi ] for all @xmath220 with @xmath221 , where the limit on the right - hand side is in the strong sense @xcite on the domain @xmath183 defined in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] . with these fields , and by again repeatedly using and
, we find , similar to , @xmath222 with e^ih_t r_r^r e^-ih_t = e^iv_t _ s= ( k_^-1+sk_^)q_sr/2l r_r^r e^iv_t _ s= ( k_^-1+sk_^)q_sr/2l and the coefficients in .
it follows that the two - point correlation function is _ ,^(t)|
^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_,^(t)_l = e^-ir^-1 a_r , l(x , y , t ) ( x - y ) s_r , l(x , y , t ) [ psi_psi_factoring_finite_l ] with a_r , l(x , y , t ) = _ p 0 ( p ) ( ( pv_(p)t ) - ir v_(p ) ( pv_(p)t ) ) [ arxyt_l ] and s_r , l(x , y , t ) = _
,0^(t)| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_,0^(t)_l .
[ srxyt_l ] the results in are obtained from in the thermodynamic limit . for the proof we use the regularized operators @xmath223 in lemma [ lemma : psi_reg ] for @xmath224 and @xmath217 .
it follows by setting @xmath62 in that @xmath225 with the time - dependent factor z_a,,l(t ) = ( -_p>0 e^-p ) [ z_factor ] ( the dependence on the interaction range @xmath130 is commented on further below ) and so - called _ vertex operators _ , w_1,r^q ( x , t ; ) & = .
( -qr _ p 0 _ r(p ) ( u^++_ , (p ) e^ip(x - r v_(p)t ) - u^_ , (p ) e^ip(x+r v_(p)t ) ) e^-|p|/2 ) .
, + w_2,-r^q ( x , t ; ) & = .
( qr _ p 0 _ -r(p ) ( u^+-_ , (p ) e^ip(x - r v_(p)t ) - u^-+_ , (p ) e^ip(x+r v_(p)t ) ) e^-|p|/2 ) . , where @xmath226 denotes _ boson normal ordering _ , i.e.
, all boson creation operators are placed to the left of all boson annihilation operators ; see , e.g. , @xcite for precise definitions
. using the coefficients in one finds that @xmath227 and @xmath228 are given by _ , (p ) & = 2 ( u^++_ , (p)^2 + u^_ , (p)^2 - 1 ) + & = 2 ( u^+-_ , (p)^2 + u^-+_ , (p)^2 ) + & = 2_(p ) 2(_(p)-_(p ) ) - 1 [ eta_ph_php ] and _ , (p ) & = 4 u^++_ , (p ) u^_ , (p ) + & = 4 u^+-_ , (p ) u^-+_ , (p ) + & = 2_(p ) 2(_(p)-_(p ) ) , [ gamma_ph_php ] respectively .
note that the dependence in on the interaction range @xmath130 is indicated to emphasize that @xmath229 vanishes in the local limit @xmath230 ; see , e.g. , @xcite for details .
the technical parts of the computations are omitted here since they are identical to those in @xcite , where they are explained in detail .
we mention only that it follows from and proposition 3.4 in @xcite that @xmath231 where the only factor which does not depend on @xmath45 or @xmath53 corresponds to _ 0,0 ^ 0(t)| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_0,0 ^ 0(t)= _ 0^+ _ l ( _ p>0 e^-p ) = .
[ psi_p_psi_m_non - interacting ] the latter is precisely the two - point correlation function in the thermodynamic limit when there is no interaction ( and no domain wall ) .
moreover , the operators @xmath232 and @xmath176 in do not contribute if we take @xmath20 other than that the last identity in puts constraints on which two - point correlation functions are non - zero : the ground state expectation value of @xmath233 for @xmath234 and @xmath235 can be non - zero only if @xmath236 and @xmath237 . therefore , after taking the limit @xmath219 , the only non - zero two - point correlation function in the thermodynamic limit is the one given in with @xmath227 and @xmath228 in ; this follows from and . finally , we note that the identity in follows from and using @xmath238 .
the asymptotic behaviors of @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath241 can be studied by considering the integrals in , , and , respectively . in appendix
[ app : asymptotics ] we show that |r(x , t ) - r| , |i(x , t ) - i| , |a_(x , y , t ) - a_| x , y [ r_i_a_asymptotics ] for certain finite constants @xmath242 with r = 0 , i = , a _ = , [ r0_i0_ar0 ] which are manifestly translation invariant . from this the result in follows .
similarly , the asymptotic behavior of @xmath243 can be studied by considering the integral in . in appendix
[ app : asymptotics ] we prove that _ t s_r(x , y , t ) = ( _ 0^dp ( p(x - y ) - 1 ) ) , [ l_lp_two_point_func_t_to_io ] where the contribution containing @xmath228 , which is non - zero if @xmath72 , has disappeared in the limit @xmath21 .
the result in follows from using and .
this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : asymptotics ] .
a result similar to can be derived for the non - equal - time two - point correlation function @xmath244 for fields @xmath245 with @xmath246 using the methods in sec . [
sec : evolution_following_a_quench ] .
although we omit the explicit expression we note that it shares the property with that contributions containing @xmath228 disappear as @xmath21 .
moreover , these particular contributions are the only ones which are not time - translation invariant , one example is a dependence on @xmath247 , and , since they disappear , time - translation invariance is recovered asymptotically in time .
one could naively try to reproduce this by treating the final state as a ground state of some luttinger hamiltonian ( cf .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] ) .
however , for @xmath72 , the same non - equal - time two - point correlation function for such a ground state of a luttinger hamiltonian , which can not be @xmath52 since @xmath248 , depends , in general , on @xmath247 . therefore , since such a state is not time - translation invariant , it can not correspond to the final steady state when @xmath72 ; cf .
also @xcite . on the other hand , we show in sec . [
sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] that for @xmath55 the two - point correlation function supports such a description , but with different chemical potentials for right- and left - moving fermions if @xmath249 .
moreover , since @xmath250 if @xmath55 , this is also true for the non - equal - time correlation function .
we now show that , for @xmath55 , the steady state , obtained asymptotically in time , has the same equal - time two - point correlation function in the thermodynamic limit as the ground state of the hamiltonian in with constant chemical potentials @xmath71 satisfying @xmath141 .
we again recall that the model is defined for finite @xmath25 ( cf .
remark [ remark : thermodynamic_limit ] ) . to diagonalize the hamiltonian @xmath142 in we use so - called _ large gauge transformations _
, which are implemented by the unitary operators @xmath176 defined in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] : r_r^-r w_r ^_r(x ) r_r^r w_r & = e^ir _ r , r w_r 2x / l ^_r(x ) , + r_r^-r w_r _
r(x ) r_r^r w_r & = _
r(x ) + _ r , r w_r / l [ large_gauge_transf ] for @xmath251 ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
we note that the requirement that the @xmath252 are integers constrain the possible values of @xmath253 for which the following arguments apply , but this will be of no consequence in the thermodynamic limit and can thus be ignored . for the densities ,
the transformation in implies that there is a shift in the zero - mode contribution , which we will see corresponds to a shift in the ground state .
it follows from sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] that e^is_ h e^-is_ = h_0 - t_ + d_ + w_ - _ r ( _ r - _ 0 ) q_r for @xmath142 in , and therefore @xmath254 to make this diagonal we must choose @xmath255 , which yields r_+^-w_+ r_-^w_- ^_r(x ) r_+^w_+ r_-^-w_- & = e^ir^-1 ( _ r - _ 0 ) x ^_r(x ) , + r_+^-w_+ r_-^w_- _
r(x ) r_+^w_+ r_-^-w_- & = _
r(x ) + , [ large_gauge_transf_w_fixed ] and r_+^-w_+ r_-^w_- e^is_ h e^-is_ r_+^w_+ r_-^-w_- = h_0 - t_ + d_ + w_ - _ r ( _ r - _ 0)^2 [ large_gauge_transf_w_fixed_hamiltonian ] ( where we have used the condition @xmath141 ) .
this means that the ground state of @xmath142 is @xmath256 with ground state energy @xmath257 .
we note that @xmath143 can also be interpreted as an excited eigenstate of @xmath56 since it has chiral charges @xmath258 if @xmath259 ( cf . ) . using the results in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] we can construct all eigenstates and eigenvalues of @xmath142 for finite @xmath25 , but we omit the details since they are similar to . this proves the statements about @xmath142 in theorem [ thm : hamiltonian_2 ] ; cf . the end of sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_an_external_field ] .
moreover , as explained in sec .
[ sec : evolution_following_a_quench ] , we can compute the two - point correlation function @xmath260 using the first identity in , which in the thermodynamic limit gives the result in , but again we omit the details since they are similar to . this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : hamiltonian_2 ] .
lastly , we note that the identities in relating the fields @xmath216 and @xmath76 can be proven in the same way as .
the only difference is in the transformation of the corresponding hamiltonians : it follows from and that there must be counterterms in , not present in , for the hamiltonians expressed using @xmath76 and @xmath216 to be the same ; cf . also @xcite .
we studied properties of the luttinger model with a non - local interaction following a quench from a domain wall initial state . the evolution of the local observables we consider is ballistic , but , at the same time , dispersive if @xmath261 .
the dispersion effects appear as oscillations traveling ahead of the wave fronts as in figs .
[ fig : total_density ] and [ fig : current ] .
this is in agreement with analytical and numerical results in @xcite for quantum xxz spin chains .
however , it should be noted that , since the model in @xcite is mapped to the luttinger model with a delta - function interaction , the evolution in that case is non - dispersive , similar to our non - interacting case , and there are divergences which are absent in our results .
asymptotically in time , the system reaches a steady state that retains memory of the initial state , meaning there is equilibration ( stabilization ) .
this was previously found in @xcite for quantum xxz spin chains and in @xcite for non - interacting bosons .
we also showed that , if @xmath72 , the final steady state has exponents which are different from those in equilibrium .
this generalizes previous results in @xcite to more general interaction quenches .
the final state is clearly different from the ground state of @xmath52 in general ( i.e. , if @xmath72 or @xmath262 ) and thus can not be described as a thermal state obtained from the usual canonical ensemble .
since the system is integrable this is not surprising : thermalization in the usual sense is not expected but rather in the sense of a generalized canonical ensemble ; see , e.g. , @xcite . for @xmath55 we showed that the ( equal - time ) two - point correlation function for the final state is equal to that for the ground state of the hamiltonian @xmath142 in with different chemical potentials for right- and left - moving fermions ( this can also be verified for the non - equal - time correlation function ) . if true for all @xmath263-point correlation functions , this would suggest that the gibbs measure of the final state is @xmath264 with @xmath142 in in the zero - temperature limit @xmath265 . therefore , when @xmath55 , the suggested generalized canonical ensemble needed to describe the final state consists of the conserved quantities @xmath52 and @xmath185 .
however , for @xmath72 we showed that this particular generalized canonical ensemble is too simple . to test whether a generalized canonical ensemble can describe the final steady state , when @xmath72 , additional conserved quantities ( which are higher - order polynomials in the commuting operators @xmath266 with @xmath267 in ) would have to be included .
this problem is left open .
we stress that universality of conductance is found via a fully non - equilibrium approach .
previous explanations of this universality were in a near - to - equilibrium setting ; see , e.g. , @xcite . whether the conductance in the luttinger model is renormalized or not has been debated .
earlier works found that it should be renormalized by the interaction @xcite , but later experimental and theoretical results found it to be universal ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
we found that these different results can be reconciled in a dynamical approach , which we believe sheds new light on this issue .
the key observation is that the current and the chemical potential difference are renormalized by the interaction , but that the renormalizations cancel when computing the landauer conductance @xcite . on the other hand ,
if one uses a non - renormalized chemical potential difference when defining the conductance , the renormalizations do not cancel .
this is summarized by the relation in , which , in particular , shows that @xmath268 ( in units where @xmath148 ) is always universal .
this relation also makes clear that our results for the luttinger model are not in conflict with the non - universal results in @xcite for quantum xxz spin chains . indeed , setting @xmath55 in yields the non - universal value @xmath269 in @xcite , which is in agreement with the result in @xcite if one takes spin degrees of freedom into account .
it is natural to conjecture that universality of conductance persists even when no exact solution is available . in equilibrium
, renormalization group techniques can explain universality also in cases without exact solutions
. it would be interesting to extend such an approach to a non - equilibrium setting .
we also note a connection between the landauer conductance and the thouless conductance for reflectionless transport of free fermions studied in @xcite
. it would be interesting to investigate if the mechanism explored in @xcite is related to our universality result .
finally , we mention that we expect our method to be applicable to more general states , such as , e.g. , thermal states .
[ [ acknowledgements ] ] acknowledgements : + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we would like to thank natan andrei , jrg frhlich , giovanni gallavotti , krzysztof gawdski , and pivi trm for helpful and inspiring discussions .
e. l. acknowledges financial support by the gran gustafsson foundation ( ggs 1221 ) . the research by j. l. l. was supported by nsf grant no .
dmr 1104500 and by afosr grant no .
fa9550 - 16 .
v. m. acknowledges support from the prin - miur national grant `` geometric and analytic theory of hamiltonian systems in finite and infinite dimensions . ''
m. is thankful for financial support from the olle eriksson foundation for materials engineering ( no .
vt-2015 - 0001 ) .
to study the asymptotic behavior of @xmath240 , @xmath239 , @xmath241 , and @xmath243 in sec .
[ sec : approach_to_steady_state ] we use the following lemma ( the proof is given at the end of this appendix ) : [ lemma : asymptotics ] let f(t ) = _
-^ e^ip u(p)t , f_0(t ) = _
-^ e^ip u(0)t [ ff0 ] ( interpreted as cauchy principal values ) with real - valued functions @xmath270 and @xmath271 ( for @xmath272 ) satisfying the following conditions : & 1 . ( f(p ) - f(0 ) ) p^-1 c^1 ( ) ( a.e . ) , + & 2 .
( f(p ) - f(0 ) ) p^-1 , d((f(p ) - f(0 ) ) p^-1)/dp l^1 ( ) , + & 3 .
( f(p ) - f(0))p^-1 0 as p , [ f_conditions ] and & 1 .
u(p ) c^2 ( ) ( a.e . ) , + & 2 .
u(p ) , du(p)/dp , d^2u(p)/dp^2 l^1 ( ) , + & 3 .
u^g(p ) = d(u(p)p)/dp > 0 p. [ u_conditions ] then |f(t ) - f_0(t)| [ ff0ct ] for some finite constant @xmath273 . if @xmath274 , or our regularized version thereof , the fourier transform of the external field is @xmath275 or tends to this as @xmath276 .
letting @xmath277 and choosing @xmath270 as the function corresponding to @xmath240 in , @xmath239 in , and @xmath241 in , respectively , the conditions in imply that the conditions in and are satisfied ; this follows using and .
we now note that _ -^ ( p u(0)t ) = 0 , _ -^ ( p u(0)t ) = t > 0 .
[ asymptotics_lemma_helper ] the identities in and then follow from lemma [ lemma : asymptotics ] and by splitting @xmath278 into real and imaginary parts .
we set @xmath279 and @xmath280 in lemma [ lemma : asymptotics ] and note that the conditions in imply that the conditions in and are satisfied ; this follows using , , and @xmath228 in .
it then follows from lemma [ lemma : asymptotics ] and , by splitting @xmath281 into real and imaginary parts , that the time - dependence in the integral in disappears as @xmath21 .
define @xmath282 by the change of variables u(0)= u(p)p , u(0 ) d= u^g(p ) dp . also , define @xmath283 by = , which implies ( ) = f(p ) , ( 0 ) = f(0 ) . by relabeling @xmath284 by @xmath282 in @xmath285
, we find f(t ) - f_0(t ) = _
-^ e^iu(0)t , and using integration by parts , f(t ) - f_0(t ) = _
-^ + _ -^ ( ) .
this implies that holds with c = _
-^ | ( ) | < since the conditions on @xmath270 in and @xmath271 in imply that the integrand is @xmath286 : this follows from a straightforward computation showing that = ( - f(0 ) ( ) ) and @xmath287 with @xmath288 and @xmath289 .
( the latter contains the second derivative of @xmath271 , which explains why the condition on @xmath290 in is needed . )
we consider an equilibrium model of the same form as the one in sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] but for general @xmath291- and @xmath292-interactions in _ g - ology _ ; see , e.g. , @xcite .
this model has different chemical potentials for right- and left - moving fermions and @xmath293 is decomposed into @xmath294 ( interaction between fermions moving in opposite directions ) and @xmath295 ( interaction between fermions moving in the same direction ) : [ general_hamiltonian ] with @xmath71 constant chemical potentials satisfying @xmath141 ; the conditions on the @xmath291- and @xmath292-interactions can be shown to be @xmath296 for @xmath297 , @xmath298 for all @xmath284 , and _
we also find it convenient to introduce the following shorthand notation : _
2(p ) = g_2 _ 2(p)/ , _
4(p ) = g_4 _ 4(p)/ , _ r = ( _ r - _ 0)/. the renormalized fermi velocity and luttinger parameter can then be written [ vl_and_luttinger_parameter_for_g2_g4 ] respectively , for general @xmath291- and @xmath292-interactions @xcite . moreover ,
similar to sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] , the possible values of @xmath299 must be integer multiples of an interaction dependent constant ( see ) , but as before this will be of no consequence in the thermodynamic limit .
we define a current which is consistent with the continuity equation implied by @xmath142 . using @xmath300
we have @xmath301 e^{-ih t}$ ] , where @xmath302 $ ] is given in , @xmath303 = - r\vf p ( \hat{\vint}_2(p)/\pi\vf ) \r_{-r}(p)$ ] , and @xmath304 = - r\vf p ( \hat{\vint}_4(p)/\pi\vf ) \r_{r}(p)$ ] .
it follows that _ t ( _ + ( p , t ) + _ -(p , t ) ) + ip ( 1 + _
4(p ) - _ 2(p ) ) ( _ + ( p , t ) - _ -(p , t ) ) = 0 .
this is the continuity equation in fourier space if we define the total density and the current as @xmath160 and j(p ) = ( 1 + _
4(p ) - _ 2(p ) ) ( _ + ( p ) - _ -(p ) ) = k_g_2,g_4(p ) v_g_2,g_4(p ) ( _ + ( p ) - _ -(p ) ) , [ general_current ] respectively . setting @xmath305 and @xmath306 , we recover @xmath307 and @xmath208 since @xmath126 in and @xmath125 in satisfy @xmath127 .
this proves that the total density and the current in the main text are consistent with the corresponding continuity equation .
let @xmath143 denote the ground state of @xmath142 and consider the average current i = l^-1 _ -l/2^l/2 dx | j(x ) |= l^-1 |
j(p = 0 ) | , which corresponds to the steady current in the main text .
only the zero modes contribute to this current since i = @xmath308 and @xmath309 , using @xmath310 in .
similar to sec .
[ sec : luttinger_model_with_constant_chemical_potentials ] , the hamiltonian @xmath142 can be diagonalized using a unitary operator @xmath311 , given by s_g_2,g_4 = i _ p 0 _ + ( -p)_-(p ) , 2_g_2,g_4(p ) = - p 0 , [ s_g2_g4 ] and large gauge transformations implemented by the unitary operators @xmath186 defined in sec .
[ sec : exact_solution_of_the_luttinger_model ] .
it follows that the ground state of @xmath142 can be written as @xmath312 with @xmath313 .
since we are interested in computing @xmath314 , it suffices to consider the zero - mode part of @xmath143 .
we therefore consider only the zero - mode part of @xmath142 , h_q = _ r ( ( 1 + _ 4(0 ) ) q_r^2 + _
2(0 ) q_rq_-r - l_r q_r ) .
the large gauge transformations are defined so that they remove all terms which are linear in the charge operators @xmath185 , @xmath315 which , using @xmath141 , implies that @xmath316 must be chosen as w_= = .
[ general_w ] from this and , using @xmath314 , we find that @xmath317 cancels : i = = .
this corresponds to a universal conductance @xmath318 , i.e. , the conductance quantum found in the main text ; the computation given here is essentially an alternative derivation of the result in @xcite , but for a less general family of hamiltonians .
we also show that it is possible to read the chemical potential difference from the two - point correlation function , as done in the main text . indeed , from
, it follows that | ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |= e^ir w_r 2(x - y)/l _
g_2,g_4| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) |_g_2,g_4 , which , using , implies that the two - point correlation function is | ^+_r(x )
^-_r(y ) |= e^-ir(k_g_2,g_4v_g_2,g_4)^-1 ( _ r-_0 ) ( x - y ) _
g_2,g_4| ^+_r(x ) ^-_r(y ) @xmath319 replacing @xmath320 in the phase on the right - hand side .
in particular , setting @xmath305 and @xmath306 we recall that @xmath321 , while , in general , the new factor cancels the factor @xmath317 in the current ( given by for @xmath322 ) .
this shows that universality of conductance holds for general @xmath291- and @xmath292-interactions and not only for the particular interaction in the main text . as a final remark
, we mention that the formulas given in the main text for the evolution of the luttinger model following a quench can be shown to remain valid for general @xmath291- and @xmath292-interactions if one replaces @xmath126 and @xmath125 with @xmath323 and @xmath324 defined in ( the other necessary changes are explained above ) .
in particular , we note that the relation in holds replacing @xmath325 with @xmath326 in but that the relation in does _ not _ generalize .
m. rigol , v. dunjko , v. yurovsky , and m. olshanii , `` relaxation in a completely integrable many - body quantum system : an ab initio study of the dynamics of the highly excited states of 1d lattice hard - core bosons , '' phys .
lett . * 98 * , 050405 ( 2007 ) .
f. d. m. haldane , `` ` luttinger liquid theory ' of one - dimensional quantum fluids .
i. properties of the luttinger model and their extension to the general 1d interacting spinless fermi gas , '' j. phys .
c : solid state phys .
* 14 * , 2585 ( 1981 ) . | we obtain exact analytical results for the evolution of a 1 + 1-dimensional luttinger model prepared in a domain wall initial state , i.e. , a state with different densities on its left and right sides .
such an initial state is modeled as the ground state of a translation invariant luttinger hamiltonian @xmath0 with short range non - local interaction and different chemical potentials to the left and right of the origin .
the system evolves for time @xmath1 via a hamiltonian @xmath2 which differs from @xmath0 by the strength of the interaction .
asymptotically in time , as @xmath3 , after taking the thermodynamic limit , the system approaches a translation invariant steady state .
this final steady state carries a current @xmath4 and has an effective chemical potential difference @xmath5 between right- ( @xmath6 ) and left- ( @xmath7 ) moving fermions obtained from the two - point correlation function .
both @xmath4 and @xmath5 depend on @xmath8 and @xmath9 . only for the case
@xmath10 does @xmath5 equal the difference in the initial left and right chemical potentials .
nevertheless , the landauer conductance for the final state , @xmath11 , has a universal value equal to the conductance quantum @xmath12 for the spinless case . |
it is inherent to the lattice approach to quantum field theory , that one has to extrapolate from finite lattices , finite statistics and non - critical coupling parameters to infinite lattices , infinite statistics and critical points . since the result supposedly is a non - trivial , non - perturbatively defined quantum field theory , this process is plagued by uncertainties .
a typical example of such a situation , where all these aspects combine , is the study of the thermal transition in qcd for small quark masses .
one is interested in the continuum limit ( gauge coupling @xmath1 ) , small or vanishing fermion masses ( @xmath2 ) , close to critical temperature ( @xmath3 ) in the thermodynamic limit ( @xmath4 ) a formidable problem .
the extrapolations are always based on assumptions on the asymptotic behavior .
well known examples are scaling functions based on renormalization group and chiral perturbation theory an expansion around a ground state with goldstone bosons . here
we will examine another such approach , which should allow the extrapolation to infinite volume and vanishing fermion mass : chiral random matrix theory ( chrmt ) .
rmt attempts to identify universal features of ensembles of ( random ) matrices with common symmetry properties . its chiral version , if successful , allows to separate two aspects of a theory like qcd : the general universal properties shared with other theories from the model - specific `` dynamical '' content of the theory .
microscopic eigenvalue distribution shapes are an example for the first aspect , expectation values of the fermion condensate for the second .
the limitations for validity of the chrmtconsiderations ( for a given @xmath5 in the phase of broken chiral symmetry ) are set by @xcite @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the linear size of the system and @xmath8 is the mass of the lightest ( pseudo-)goldstone boson .
the second restriction imposes that the pion does not fit into the space - time volume and it therefore appears to be unphysical .
however , various correlators in the dirac operator spectrum can be computed precisely in this limit . chrmthas been proven to give exact analytical predictions for the spectrum of the dirac operator in the microscopic limit @xcite .
the microscopic scaling region is simply a blowup of the origin in the spectrum . to be specific
, one considers eigenvalues @xmath9 on the scale @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the chiral condensate , related to the spectral density per unit volume @xmath12 via the banks - casher @xcite relation , @xmath13 .
this regime is , by definition , only well defined in the spontaneously broken phase where @xmath14 . in the phase with restored symmetry the scale of interest is set by the density of states in the vicinity of the onset of @xmath12 . here
we present a study of the microscopic correlators in the spectrum of the staggered dirac operator in su(3 ) gauge theory with dynamical fermions at finite temperature .
specifically we examine the low lying eigenvalue statistics at temperatures below , near , and above the critical temperature of the chiral phase transition .
our analysis is based on the evaluation of the milc collaboration s gauge configurations @xcite .
we therefore concentrate on the new aspects connected to rmt ideas for the spectral correlators of the dirac operator .
in particular for @xmath15 we study the singularity at the inner endpoint of the spectral density .
strictly speaking , in the continuum limit @xmath16 , non - zero temperature is realized for lattices @xmath17 with @xmath18 and @xmath19 . in that limit , for vanishing quark mass @xmath20
, one expects a phase transition at @xmath0 . in @xcite
the critical temperature was estimated to lie between 143 and 154 mev .
for @xmath21 chiral symmetry is broken spontaneously , with massless pseudoscalars and @xmath22 ; above @xmath0 we expect restoration of this symmetry .
whereas for pure yang - mills theory the deconfinement transition is associated with a breaking of the center - symmetry with the polyakov loop as order parameter , this symmetry is explicitly broken by the fermion action .
nevertheless , remnants of the original breaking feature of the polyakov loop persist even for small fermion masses .
the nature of the chiral phase transition depends on the number of flavors @xmath23 .
an argument based on a 3d @xmath24-models analysis @xcite predicts a first order phase transition for @xmath25 . for @xmath26
one expects a second order phase transition with @xmath27 scaling behavior . however , even first order behavior may be arguable @xcite . for staggered fermions at non - vanishing lattice spacing the correct counting of flavors
is unclear since flavor symmetry is restored only in the continuum limit .
staggered fermions ( as simulated by milc with the hybrid r - algorithm @xcite ) correspond to the case @xmath26 in the continuum limit . on coarse lattices
the so defined fermions should show at least @xmath28 scaling behavior . for a discussion of the various scenarios cf .
@xcite . it is unclear whether the phase transition at @xmath0 extends towards @xmath29 or whether , when moving from lower to higher temperature , one just observes crossover - like behavior .
some evidence points towards this second scenario @xcite . in the following ,
we denote the crossover ( phase transition ) position by @xmath30 or simply @xmath0 .
according to the nature of the elements in the random matrix , chrmtappears in three universality classes . in this paper
we consider the su(3 ) gauge theory with quarks in the fundamental representation , which belongs to the universality class of the chiral unitary ensemble ( chue ) .
the partition function under study is @xcite @xmath31 where @xmath32 is a @xmath33 block hermitian matrix ( the elements of @xmath34 being random complex numbers ) , and @xmath5 is a deterministic , i.e. not - random , off - diagonal block matrix @xmath35 here d@xmath32 denotes the haar measure , @xmath36 is an analytic function . the predictions from chrmtconcern the correlations between the eigenvalues @xmath9 of @xmath37 on the scale of individual eigenvalues in the thermodynamic limit @xmath38 .
the matrix @xmath39 is the analogue of the massless dirac operator in qcd .
the chiral phase transition within chrmtis identified through the value of the spectral density of the eigenvalues of @xmath39 near zero , i.e. using the banks - casher relation .
modeling the chiral phase transition in chrmtamounts to driving a depletion of eigenvalues of @xmath39 near the origin by means of some temperature parameter .
two separate approaches have been examined in the literature .
first , the unitary invariant chrmt@xcite , corresponding to ( [ z ] ) with @xmath40 , in which the chiral phase transition is driven by tuning @xmath41 .
second , the non - unitary invariant chrmt@xcite , corresponding to ( [ z ] ) with @xmath42 , where the deterministic block matrix @xmath5 mimics the effect of the temperature . in this paper
we do not need to distinguish between the two approaches as they are consistent for the quantities measured here .
below @xmath0 , i.e. when @xmath14 , chrmtpredicts @xcite the probability distribution for the smallest eigenvalue ( for the trivial topological sector ) @xmath43 with @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the spectral density at the origin for the _ massless _ situation ( i.e. when @xmath46 in ( [ z ] ) ) .
@xmath47 denotes the @xmath48th modified bessel function .
this result is universal in the chrmtcontext , that is , the analytic form of @xmath49 does not change under deformations of @xmath41 provided that @xmath14 . after the identification @xmath50 ( @xmath51 is the physical volume in lattice units ) , ( [ pmin ] ) allows to extract @xmath52 ( the fermion condensate in the chiral limit ) from finite - volume dirac spectra
of course , in this the mild condition ( [ qcdrange ] ) must be satisfied . above @xmath0 , when there is a finite gap in the spectral density , the repulsion between the eigenvalue pair @xmath53 becomes negligible ; chrmthence predicts a _ soft _ inner edge , known as the airy - solution @xcite . at @xmath0
signaled in chrmtby a power - like behavior of the spectral density at small @xmath9 @xmath54 , the prediction from chrmtis not unique .
it turns out that the spectral correlators depend on the value of @xmath55 @xcite .
the distribution of the smallest eigenvalue is a spectral one - point correlation function and is quite sensitive to statistical fluctuations ( see below ) . as an additional measure we also study a two - point correlator : the level spacing distribution @xmath56 .
note that the level spacings , @xmath57 , are determined in the unfolded spectrum @xmath58 .
unfolding separates the fluctuation properties of the spectrum from the supposedly smooth background behavior .
the unfolded variable is defined in terms of the eigenvalue spectrum and the local average spectral density by @xmath59 the rmt prediction for the level spacing distribution is well approximated by the unitary wigner surmise @xmath60 the level spacing distribution is not expected to be affected by temperature and masses in chrmt , see e.g. @xcite .
chrmtmakes predictions for average spectral correlators in sectors with definite topological charge @xmath61 , i.e. derived assuming exact zero modes ( these are not included in the predicted distributions ; cf .
@xcite for the result of the weighted summation of all topological sectors ) . for ginsparg - wilson fermions @xcite , which realize chiral symmetry on the lattice , one may identify exact zero modes as resulting from topological excitations according to the atiyah - singer index theorem ( for wilson fermions one can hypothesize that zero modes are replaced by real modes ) .
this is not the case for staggered fermions , where exact zero modes are absent away from the continuum limit @xcite and even gauge configurations with non - vanishing topological charge do not give zero eigenvalues .
exact zero modes are here replaced by `` almost '' zero modes which accumulate to the origin in the continuum limit . in the strong coupling region
the microscopic staggered dirac spectra summed over all topological sectors show @xcite good agreement with the analytical prediction for the topologically neutral , @xmath62 , sector from chrmt .
however , approaching weaker coupling observations contradicting this scenario have been found in a two - dimensional context @xcite . before turning to the numerical studies ,
let us comment on the validity of the chrmtpredictions .
the condition for application of chrmtin lattice analyses is well established when @xmath63 : the range in the unfolded spectrum over which the chrmtcorrelations dominate is @xmath64 @xcite , where @xmath65 is the pion decay constant .
an equivalent statement for @xmath66 is not known and no stringent tests of the low - lying eigenvalue statistics have been carried out so far .
let us emphasize that even though the larger part of the studies of chrmthave been focused on the situation where @xmath14 , there is nothing wrong from first principles in using chrmtwhen @xmath67 .
by courtesy of the milc collaboration @xcite there are sets of gauge configurations @xcite available to the lattice community .
these were generated with two species of dynamical staggered fermions , at various lattice sizes , temperatures , values of the gauge coupling and small values of the bare fermion mass . in table
[ tabconf ] the samples used in the present study are listed . for further details on the method of determination of the gauge configurations and the physical parameters
we refer to @xcite . .
summary of the milc configurations used in our analysis ( for ft01 we only considered a subset of the total of 149 configurations available ) .
the suggestions in the rightmost column are based on milc s results .
the transition is near @xmath68=5.26 for @xmath69 and @xmath68=5.725 for @xmath70 .
[ cols= " < , > , < , > , < , < , < " , ] [ tab : fit ] in order to further investigate this feature , we studied ( for the set with @xmath71 ) the influence of the configurations where the eigenvectors @xmath72 of the lowest eigenvalues exhibit a large contribution to the total chirality , i.e. @xmath73 . according to the index theorem , these configurations with large chirality , which make up roughly one half of the ensemble , tend to carry non - vanishing topological charge and therefore zero modes .
indeed we find that a substantial part ( 75% ) of the first peak may be explained from these contributions .
these findings suggest that indeed topological modes are responsible for a low - lying peak in the distributions .
below @xmath0 all topological sectors are present and the low - lying eigenvalues have comparable magnitudes ( their average position being roughly proportional to @xmath61 ) .
when the temperature approaches @xmath0 the theoretical expectation is that the topological fluctuations begin to be suppressed , although still present in the ensemble , quasi superimposed on the background distribution , which starts to broaden significantly with increasing temperature . sufficiently far above @xmath0 only the topologically trivial sector survives and there may be no small eigenvalues at all .
this is indeed what we actually observe for the lattice @xmath74 . in a recent study of quenched configurations @xcite
there have been indications for a dilute gas of instanton anti - instanton pairs producing a poissonian distribution of small eigenvalues above @xmath0 .
these may be suppressed or absent when considering dynamical fermions . in our context
this seems to be the case for the finest lattices ( @xmath75 with @xmath76 ) at our disposal .
[ secondevs ] gives the histograms for the 2nd smallest eigenvalues .
again we notice a dramatic change of the distribution shape around @xmath30 .
we interpret the sudden flatness of the distribution of the smallest eigenvalues as being ( i ) due to the vanishing spectral density and ( ii ) due to increasing statistical fluctuations near the chiral phase transition .
the latter effect is not reproduced in chrmtsince this is a zero dimensional and non - dynamical theory .
furthermore , the mutual overlap of @xmath77 and @xmath78 increases for @xmath79 .
this is also inconsistent with chrmt . in order to study this effect
further we now turn to the level spacing distributions .
another observable with definite predictions from rmt ( cf .
[ secrmt ] ) is the distribution of level spacings .
the advantage here is , that the level spacing should not be influenced by possible distortions of the smallest eigenvalues due to the unknown topological charge of the configurations ( if the smallest eigenvalues are removed from the data ) .
the studies of the level spacing statistics in lattice data so far have shown a uniform picture consistent with the rmt prediction ( [ wue ] ) .
the agreement extends on both sides of the confinement - deconfinement phase transition @xcite .
however , to the authors knowledge there is no analytical prediction from chrmtfor the level spacing distribution when focusing on the soft edge or at @xmath0 .
so one might worry that the standard prediction , eq .
( [ wue ] ) , is not appropriate when @xmath67 . within the t - model of @xcite for @xmath80 and @xmath81 ,
we have performed a numerical high statistics simulation to eliminate such doubt , and we there confirmed the distribution ( [ wue ] ) .
( the t - model is defined by ( [ z ] ) with @xmath42 and @xmath82 in ( [ tmodel ] ) chosen proportional to the unit matrix . )
usually it is possible to get high statistics on the level spacing distributions since each configuration provides a large number of eigenvalue spacings .
however , already the lowest 10 ( or 8) eigenvalues allow for a crude estimate of the distribution shape .
recall that the level spacing distribution is measured in the unfolded spectrum , see ( [ defunf ] ) .
here we use the average spacings @xmath83 between contiguous eigenvalues to define the unfolded level spacings @xmath84 in fig .
[ levelspc ] we compare the data with the parameter - free theoretical expectation .
whereas below and above @xmath0 we find reasonable agreement with the theoretical expectation , there are clear discrepancies near @xmath0 .
we observe unexpected high histogram entries .
since the average value by definition is 1 this then leads to a shift of the central peak to the left . in order to further check our unfolding procedure ,
we also considered other approaches , e.g. using a average density as in ( [ defunf ] ) by smoothing our distribution in various ways .
we furthermore tried to discard the higher lying eigenvalues , e.g. using only the lowest 5 level spacings or introducing a cutoff near the peak of the distributions in fig .
[ firstevs ] . in all those checks we found essentially the same behavior with discrepancies near @xmath0 . in conclusion of this section
, we observe at @xmath85 a breakdown of the otherwise universal microscopic spectral correlations .
the dynamics of qcd plays an essential rle in the phase transition . a rmt model where such dynamics is not there fails to account for the increased fluctuations in the eigenvalue level spacings .
we now turn to the results for @xmath15 . in our results for @xmath75 at @xmath76 ( fig .
[ all - dist](c ) ) a gap in the spectral distributions is obvious .
however even at @xmath86 we may speculate , that a clear signal of a gap is only prevented by the ( topological ) quasi - zero modes responsible for the small bump at small eigenvalues .
recall , that chrmt@xcite predicts the presence of a gap in the spectral density @xmath12 of the dirac operator centered around @xmath87 .
furthermore , the inner edge of this gap is predicted to show a singularity , at a point @xmath88 , in the macroscopic spectral density @xcite @xmath89 where @xmath90 is a known constant .
the constant @xmath91 takes the value @xmath92 in the generic chrmt , i. e. without fine - tuning the matrix potential in ( [ z ] ) ( which would be necessary in order to obtain higher values of @xmath91 ) .
this corresponds to a square - root - like eigenvalue density near @xmath88 .
one concern here is to measure @xmath91 . with the limited amount of data available
it is not possible to do this based on the spectral density only .
instead we propose to study the average distance between the smallest and the sequel eigenvalues @xmath93 ; the extraction of @xmath91 is carried out by noting the following scaling relation in the index @xmath94 , ordering by size the eigenvalues which follow the smallest , @xmath95 this proportionality follows by integration in ( [ aisingularity ] ) . in fig .
[ and ] we display the seven average distances , @xmath96 , from the ensemble of 146 configurations on a @xmath97 lattice for @xmath98 .
we also exhibit the best fit to ( [ qi ] ) with respect to @xmath91 , giving @xmath99 . also shown
are the corresponding curves for @xmath92 and @xmath100 .
the value @xmath92 is clearly favored .
since the two - point correlations behave as expected from rmt , we now turn to the one - point distribution .
the microscopic behavior of the spectral density in the vicinity of this singularity is universal in the chrmtsense , but depends on the value of @xmath91 @xcite . for @xmath92
the exact analytical prediction for the microscopic spectral density in the vicinity of the inner edge is @xcite @xmath101 here the origin has been moved to the inner spectral endpoint @xmath88 by means of the rescaled eigenvalue @xmath102 , which is defined through @xmath103 \ .\ ] ] the consistency with the prediction ( [ qi ] ) for @xmath92 and the approximate validity of chrmtcorrelations in the level spacing statistics above @xmath0 suggest that the airy - density ( [ aidens ] ) corresponding to the value @xmath92 should fit the spectral density .
if it does , then we can extract the inner - endpoint @xmath88 of the spectrum in the thermodynamic limit , by fitting @xmath104 with respect to @xmath88 to the lowest part of the spectral density , see fig .
[ airyfig ] .
this fit does not convincingly confirm airy density .
however , the statistical fluctuations at this @xmath68-value affect the _ one - point distribution _ substantially and prevent a decisive comparison .
we have examined the manifestations of the chiral phase transition in the microscopic spectral correlators for the dirac operator . for the level spacing distribution
, we find agreement with rmtbelow and above @xmath0 . below @xmath0
the chrmtdistributions allow us to determine condensate values with implicit consideration of lattice volume and quark mass dependence .
this could in principle serve to improve the scaling analysis of the condensate near the chiral transition . near @xmath0 , however , the microscopic spectral statistics differs from the chrmtprediction . by measuring the monte carlo time evolution of the chiral condensate , aoki et al .
@xcite have shown , that there are mixed phase signals , which , however , vanish towards larger volumes .
the existence of a mixed phase would offer an explanation for the observed deviations from chrmtnear @xmath0 . in that case
the level spacing distribution near @xmath0 would be a mixture of those from the two phases .
such a mixture would lead to large spacings : the spacings are unfolded according to the average spacings of the total ensemble and not according to that of the separate phases .
the observed discrepancy from the rmt level spacing statistics may also be interpreted as an inclination towards poissonian statistics ; distribution shapes interpolating between wigner and poissonian statistics have been suggested by brody @xcite . as may be seen from the @xmath75 ensembles at @xmath86 and @xmath105
, a gap develops the spectral density for @xmath15 .
this is consistent with the observed suppression of topological fluctuations in the latter ensemble @xcite . for the @xmath76 ensemble
we have measured the critical exponent characterizing the steepness of the density at the inner edge .
the value is found to be compatible with 1/2 .
this is exactly as predicted by chrmtwhere the chiral phase transition is manifested by the crossover from the bessel hard edge to the airy soft edge .
the indications of the bessel to airy scenario are suggestive but simulations with extended statistics are needed in order to quantify the observation .
however , even with low statistics the @xmath68-dependence of the distance between e.g. 8th and 1st eigenvalue provides an excellent means to identify the change of the phase . at low @xmath68 , on coarse lattices ,
staggered fermions appear to be blind with regard to the topological charge of the gauge configurations , and the smallest eigenvalue distribution agrees with the chrmtdistribution for the @xmath62 sector . as the lattice becomes finer , topology becomes more relevant .
although this is maybe `` good '' for the continuum limit of staggered fermions , it affects unfavorably the agreement with chrmtsince the want - to - be - zero modes and the non - zero modes have similar eigenvalues , and begin to separate only when the non - zero modes are pushed to larger values when increasing the temperature .
we want to thank the milc collaboration for making available the gauge configurations , that we used in our analysis .
special thanks go to jim hetrick and doug toussaint for their help in accessing those and for the support in making additional ensembles public .
. de f. thanks jim hetrick and jean - franois laga for their contribution at a preliminary stage of this project .
k. s. would like to thank andrew jackson for discussions . | we re - analyze data from available finite - temperature qcd simulations near the chiral transition , with the help of chiral random matrix theory ( chrmt ) .
statistical properties of the lowest - lying eigenvalues of the staggered dirac operator for su(3 ) lattice gauge theory with dynamical fermions are examined .
we consider temperatures below , near , and above the critical temperature @xmath0 for the chiral phase transition . below and above @xmath0
the statistics are in agreement with the exact analytical predictions in the microscopic scaling regime . above @xmath0
we observe a gap in the spectral density and a distribution compatible with the airy distribution . near @xmath0
the eigenvalue correlations appear inconsistent with chrmt . 2 |
the embedding of supersymmetric gauge theories in a string framework using systems of d - branes has been very fruitful and inspiring for many developments . for example , the famous ads / cft correspondence @xcite is rooted in the realization of the @xmath7 super yang - mills ( sym ) theory by means of d3-branes in flat space and in the profile of the supergravity bulk fields they induce in space - time . in less supersymmetric and/or in non - conformal cases ( like the @xmath8 gauge theories in four dimensions we will be interested in ) the corresponding gravitational profile depends on some transverse directions representing the energy scale thus accounting for the running of the gauge theory . this fact was explicitly checked long ago @xcite -@xcite at the perturbative level in @xmath8 sym theories realized by fractional d3 branes of type iib at non - isolated singularities , like for instance the @xmath9 orbifold . by studying the emission of closed string fields from such branes ,
the corresponding `` perturbative '' supergravity solutions were constructed and it was found that a scalar field from the twisted sector , which we will call @xmath10 , varies logarithmically in the internal complex direction @xmath11 transverse to the orbifold , matching precisely the perturbative logarithmic running of the gauge coupling with the energy scale .
however , such perturbative solutions suffer from singularities at small values of @xmath11 , _
i.e. _ in the ir region of the gauge theory , and have to be modified by non - perturbative corrections .
it is well - known that in @xmath8 gauge theories there is a whole series of non - perturbative contributions to the low - energy effective action that are due to instantons . in the last two decades tremendous advances
have been made in the study of instanton effects within field theory ( for reviews , see for instance @xcite ) , and more recently also within string theory by means of d - instantons , _ i.e. _ d - branes with dirichlet boundary conditions in all directions @xcite-@xcite . in the seminal papers
@xcite the exact solutions for the low - energy effective @xmath8 theories in the coulomb branch , including all instanton corrections , were found using symmetry and duality arguments . in particular it was shown that the effective sym dynamics in the limit of low energy and momenta can be exactly encoded in the so - called seiberg - witten ( sw ) curve which describes the geometry of the moduli space of the sym vacua .
later these results were rederived from a microscopic point of view with the help of localization techniques @xcite that permit an explicit evaluation of the integrals over the multi - instanton moduli space .
these techniques fit naturally in the string / d - brane context and indeed have been exploited for interesting generalizations of the sw results in many different directions .
it is then natural to ask how the infinite tower of instanton effects is encoded in the dual holographic description of the gauge theory in terms of gravity . to answer this question one possibility is to exploit symmetry and duality arguments and determine the background geometry that incorporates the exact sw solution , like in the m - theory constructions based on configurations of d4 and ns5 branes @xcite .
another possibility is to compute directly the multi - instanton corrections to the profiles of the gravitational bulk fields .
this is what we will discuss in this contribution , which heavily relies on the content of @xcite and especially of @xcite .
in particular we will briefly review how to derive the exact supergravity profile of the twisted field @xmath10 emitted by a system of fractional d3-branes at a @xmath12-orbifold singularity supporting a @xmath8 quiver gauge theory with unitary groups and bi - fundamental matter , and show how to obtain from it the exact running of the gauge coupling constant , including the non - perturbative contributions , in perfect agreement with the sw solution .
we study the prototypical case of @xmath13 sym theories that are realized with fractional d3-branes at the non - isolated orbifold singularity @xmath14 . in this orbifold
there are two types of fractional d3-branes , which we call types 0 and 1 , corresponding to the two different irreducible representations of @xmath12 .
the most general brane configuration therefore consists of @xmath15 branes of type 0 and @xmath16 branes of type 1 , and corresponds to an @xmath17 quiver theory in four dimensions with gauge group u(@xmath15)@xmath18u(@xmath16 ) and with a matter content given by one hypermultiplet in the bi - fundamental representation @xmath19 and one hypermultiplet in the @xmath20 representation .
the corresponding quiver diagram is represented in fig .
[ fig : quiver ] .
the branes of type 0 are represented by the blue circle while the branes of type 1 are represented by the red circle .
the oriented lines connecting the two types of branes represent the hypermultiplets in the bifundamental representations.,title="fig : " ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 4706,1844)(1203,-3953 ) ( 1441,-3121)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5176,-3121)(0,0)[lb ] ignoring the gauge degrees of freedom on the @xmath16 branes , one obtains an @xmath17 u(@xmath15 ) sym theory with @xmath21 fundamental flavors and u(@xmath16 ) as global symmetry group .
furthermore , we will decouple the u(1 ) factors and concentrate on the su(@xmath15)@xmath18 su(@xmath16 ) part of the symmetry group . in this contribution
we focus on the case @xmath22 , representing an @xmath8 su(2 ) sym theory with @xmath3 flavors , but our results and methods apply to the general case as well @xcite .
the su(2 ) @xmath3 sym theory has a vanishing @xmath23-function but , when the flavors are massive , the gauge coupling gets renormalized at 1-loop by terms proportional to the mass parameters of the hypermultiplets .
this situation corresponds to placing the fractional d3-branes at different positions in the transverse plane , _
i.e. _ to giving non - vanishing vacuum expectation values to the adjoint scalars @xmath24 and @xmath25 of the vector multiplets on the two types of branes according to @xmath26 note that this brane configuration implies that the masses of the four flavors are given by @xmath27 in this case one finds that the perturbative part of gauge coupling constant @xmath28 is given by @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the bare coupling .
besides these perturbative terms , there are also non - perturbative corrections due to instantons which can be explicitly computed using localization techniques ( see for instance @xcite for details ) .
the first two instanton contributions turn out to be given by @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the instanton counting parameter .
the complete effective coupling is therefore the sum of ( [ taupert ] ) and ( [ tauinst ] ) . for our future considerations
it is convenient to rewrite it in terms of the gauge invariant quantity @xmath33 which parametrizes the moduli space of the effective theory at the quantum level .
using the multi - instanton calculus and localization techniques , one can show that @xmath34 is related to the classical vacuum expectation value @xmath35 in the following way @xcite @xmath36 inverting this relation and substituting it into ( [ taupert ] ) and ( [ tauinst ] ) , after some simple algebra we find @xmath37 for simplicity , and also for later convenience , we have introduced a notation that explicitly exhibits only the dependence of @xmath38 on the gauge invariant parameter @xmath34 . when the flavors are massless , the effective coupling , which we denote by @xmath39 , is related to @xmath40 as follows @xmath41 it is interesting to observe that the inverse relation can be expressed in terms of modular functions .
indeed , inverting ( [ tau0 m ] ) we obtain @xmath42 where the @xmath43 s are the jacobi @xmath43-functions in terms of the dedekind @xmath44-functions .
this expression is amenable of interesting generalizations for superconformal field theories with gauge groups su(@xmath45 ) with @xmath46 @xcite .
we also observe that our coupling is related by a t - duality transformation , @xmath47 , to the one usually considered in the literature @xcite for which the relation ( [ q0tau0 ] ) takes the form @xmath48 . ] .
notice that even in this simple case , @xmath30 and @xmath39 are different and represent two different choices of effective couplings for the massless theory ( see also @xcite ) .
let us now consider the same modular function appearing in ( [ q0tau0 ] ) , but instead of the massless coupling @xmath39 let us use as argument the massive coupling @xmath49 : @xmath50 taking the logarithm of @xmath51 , we then get @xmath52 this expression has a very nice interpretation .
indeed , let us consider the sw curve for the su(2 ) @xmath3 sym which , when the flavor masses are as in ( [ masses ] ) , can be written as @xcite @xmath53 where @xmath54 with @xmath55 the curve ( [ curve ] ) describes a torus whose complex structure parameter is @xmath56 where @xmath35 and @xmath57 are the periods of the sw 1-form differential @xmath58 @xmath59 computed around a basis of dual cycles @xmath60 normalized in such a way that @xmath61 .
the sw differential @xmath58 can be written as @xmath62 with @xmath63 using this information , one can compute @xmath38 and check that , when it is expanded in powers of @xmath40 , it coincides precisely with the effective gauge coupling ( [ taumv ] ) .
other interesting quantities that characterize the curve ( [ curve ] ) are the anharmonic ratios of the four roots of the equation @xmath64 .
it is quite easy to see that these roots are @xmath65 and that a corresponding anharmonic ratio is @xmath66 it is easy to see that the expansion of @xmath67 in powers of @xmath40 perfectly matches the expression found in ( [ tmv ] ) and thus we are led to the identification @xmath68 this is not surprising since the relation between the anharmonic ratio @xmath69 and the complex structure parameter @xmath38 of a curve like ( [ curve ] ) is precisely @xmath70 , namely the same relation between @xmath71 and @xmath72 implied by ( [ qtheta ] ) and ( [ tmv ] ) .
we observe observe that the right hand side of ( [ ratio1 ] ) can be nicely written in terms of the polynomials @xmath73 and @xmath74 of the sw curve describing the theory at the so - called `` enhanon vacuum '' @xcite .
this is the specific point of the quantum moduli space corresponding to @xmath75 which describes a classical extended brane configuration resembling that of the enhanon ring @xcite . in the enhanon vacuum
we therefore have @xmath76 , and the polynomials @xmath73 and @xmath74 become @xmath77 then , from ( [ ratio1 ] ) and ( [ tlogz ] ) it is easy to realize that @xmath78 using the information encoded in the sw curve it is also possible to compute the exact quantum correlators @xmath79 forming the chiral ring elements of the gauge theory .
these correlators are in fact given by the integral @xmath80 or alternatively , they can be obtained by expanding the generating functional @xcite @xmath81 integrating ( [ genphij ] ) with respect to @xmath11 , it is easy to find @xmath82 where the integration constant has been fixed in order to match the @xmath83 terms in the expansion for large @xmath11 in both sides . with some further straightforward algebra ,
we can rewrite the right hand side of ( [ trphi ] ) in the following form @xmath84 this expression will be essential in the next section to write the exact ( _ i.e. _ all order in the instanton expansion ) gravitational profile of the twisted scalar field @xmath10 emitted by the system of fractional d3 branes , and to relate it with the dual gauge theory coupling .
the fractional d3-branes in the @xmath12 orbifold are gravitational sources for a non - trivial metric and a 4-form r - r potential from the untwisted sectors , and for two scalars , @xmath85 and @xmath86 , from the twisted ns - ns and r - r sectors respectively ( see for instance @xcite ) . while the emitted untwisted fields can propagate in all six directions transverse to the d3-branes , the twisted scalars only propagate in the complex plane transverse to the d3-brane world - volume which is not affected by the orbifold projection and which we parametrize with a complex coordinate @xmath87 .
a system of fractional d3-branes distributed on this plane therefore generate a non - trivial dependence of the fields @xmath85 and @xmath86 on @xmath87 .
the twisted scalars are conveniently combined in a complex field @xmath88 where here @xmath38 stands for the axio - dilaton of the type iib string theory .
for simplicity we assume that the axion is trivial and that there are no branes other than the fractional d3 branes so that the dilaton does not run .
thus , in this case we simply have @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the string coupling constant .
the field @xmath10 is actually part of a chiral bulk superfield @xmath91 whose structure is schematically given by @xmath92 with dots denoting the supersymmetric descendants of @xmath10 and @xmath93 being the complex conjugate of @xmath10 .
the profile of the twisted scalar @xmath10 emitted by a system of fractional d3-branes can be derived by solving the classical field equations that follow from the bulk action containing the kinetic terms and the source action describing the emission from the fractional d3-branes . at the perturbative level this profile
was obtained long ago in ref.s @xcite -@xcite and for a system of @xmath15 branes of type 0 and @xmath16 branes of type 1 located at the origin is @xmath94 where @xmath95 and @xmath96 is an arbitrary length scale .
it is convenient to introduce the quantities @xmath97 with mass dimension 1 , and rewrite the solution ( [ proft ] ) as follows @xmath98 note that in the conformal cases ( @xmath99 ) , we simply have @xmath100 let us now consider a more general configuration in which the d3-branes are not all at the origin .
this amounts to giving the adjoint scalars non - vanishing vacuum expectation values as in ( [ am ] ) ( from now on we focus again only on the case @xmath22 ) .
then , one can show that the @xmath10 profile corresponding to such a configuration is @xmath101 it is not difficult to realize that this @xmath10 field satisfies the following differential equation @xmath102 with @xmath103 where in the second step we introduced the momentum operator conjugate to @xmath11 , that is @xmath104 .
the current @xmath105 has a nice interpretation in terms of disk diagrams describing the couplings among the closed string twisted fields and the massless open string excitations of the fractional d3-branes .
indeed , by considering the interactions of the ns - ns scalar @xmath85 ( whose vertex operator we denote by @xmath106 ) with the scalar @xmath24 ( whose vertex we denote by @xmath107 ) , we find @xmath108 this result follows by computing the correlation functions of the vertex operators using standard cft techniques as discussed for example in @xcite and by frozing the scalars to their vacuum expectation values .
a completely similar calculation can be performed with the scalar @xmath25 of the type 1 branes leading to @xmath109 where the extra sign comes from the fact that branes of type 1 have opposite @xmath85-charge with respect of those of type 0 .
adding an analogous term describing the interactions of the r - r twisted scalar @xmath86 , we can write the total contribution to the effective action as @xmath110 supersymmetry requires that this interaction must be accompanied by other structures ( that could also be computed from string diagrams with extra fermionic insertions ) in such a way that the effective action follows from a holomorphic prepotential . as discussed in @xcite-@xcite such a prepotential
is obtained simply by promoting the bulk and boundary scalars to the corresponding chiral superfields . denoting by @xmath111 the fluctuation part of @xmath91 , one finds in particular the following term @xmath112 where the dots represent interactions of higher orders in @xmath111 .
the effective action follows upon integrating the prepotential over @xmath113 ; when all four @xmath43 s are taken from @xmath111 and the superfields @xmath114 and @xmath115 are frozen to their vacuum expectation values , we recover precisely the interaction ( [ intert ] ) .
the classical current ( [ tcl0 ] ) therefore is associated to a source term for @xmath10 and is related to the prepotential ( [ f ] ) in the following way @xmath116 let us now investigate how the classical profile ( [ proftam ] ) changes when non - perturbative effects due to gauge instantons are taken into account . in our brane set - up ,
instantons are introduced by adding fractional d(1)-branes .
since we neglect the dynamics on the branes of type 1 , we only consider the effects produced by adding @xmath117 d - instantons of type 0 .
the physical excitations of the open strings with at least one end - point on the d(1)-branes account for the instanton moduli which we collectively denote as @xmath118 .
they consist of the neutral sector , corresponding to d(1)/d(1 ) open strings that do not transform under the gauge group , and of the charged and flavored sectors arising respectively from the d(1)/d3@xmath119 and d(1)/d3@xmath120 open strings .
the complete list of instanton moduli and their transformation properties can be found in @xcite .
here we just recall that among the neutral moduli we have the bosonic and fermionic goldstone modes of the supertranslations of the d3-brane world - volume which are broken by the d - instantons and which are identified with the superspace coordinates @xmath121 and @xmath43 , and a complex scalar @xmath122 transforming in the adjoint representation of the instanton symmetry group u(@xmath117 ) , whose eigenvalues describe the position of the d - instantons in the un - orbifolded directions transverse to the fractional d3-branes . in order to find the non - perturbative @xmath10 profile we first compute the instanton induced prepotential @xmath123 from which the non - perturbative source current @xmath124 can be derived following a procedure similar to the one outlined for the classical current @xmath105 .
the non - perturbative prepotential is defined as @xmath125 where the integral is performed over the centered moduli @xmath126 , which include all moduli except the superspace coordinates @xmath121 and @xmath43 . here
@xmath127 is the instanton action , describing the interactions of the instanton moduli with the boundary and bulk superfields .
as explained in @xcite , such an action is @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the part accounting for the interactions of the moduli among themselves and with the fields in the vector multiplet , and @xmath130 means trace over the u(@xmath117 ) indices . inserting ( [ sinst1 ] ) in ( [ fnp ] ) , to linear order in @xmath111 we find @xmath131 the integration over the moduli space can be explicitly performed using localization techniques and nekrasov s approach to the multi - instanton calculus @xcite .
this amounts to first define the deformed instanton partition function @xmath132 where @xmath133 and @xmath134 are deformation parameters which in our string set - up can be introduced by putting the brane system in a graviphoton background @xcite , and then to compute the prepotential according to @xmath135 the integral appearing in ( [ fnp2 ] ) is related to the instanton part of the chiral ring elements @xmath79 of the gauge theory on the d3-branes , which can be computed as @xmath136 notice that the integrals in ( [ zinst ] ) and ( [ trphi0 ] ) are over all moduli including @xmath121 and @xmath43 , and that in the limit @xmath137 the factor @xmath138 in ( [ trphi0 ] ) compensates for the volume @xmath139 of the regularized four dimensional superspace . plugging ( [ trphi0 ] ) into ( [ fnp2 ] ) one gets @xmath140 which is nothing but the instanton completion of ( [ f ] ) . adding the classical and the instanton contributions we obtain the full source current for @xmath10 : @xmath141 where @xmath142 .
the field equation satisfied by @xmath10 is therefore @xmath143\,\frac{\partial^{\ell}}{\partial z^{\ell}}\,\delta^2(z ) \label{fecom}\ ] ] which is solved by @xmath144 this explicit solution shows that all non - trivial information about the @xmath10 profile is contained in the ring of chiral correlators of the gauge theory defined on the d3-branes .
this chiral ring accounts therefore for the full tower of d - instanton corrections to the gravity solution . the chiral correlators @xmath79 can be computed from ( [ trphi0 ] ) using nekrasov s approach to the multi - instanton calculus .
equivalently ( and more efficiently ) , as we have explained in the previous section , they can be obtained from the sw curve describing the sym theory .
in fact , inserting ( [ trphi1 ] ) in ( [ tauz ] ) and taking into account the explicit definition of @xmath74 given in ( [ pq ] ) , we can obtain the exact expression for the twisted scalar field emitted by the brane system , namely @xmath145 our result generalizes the one derived in @xcite for the pure su(@xmath45 ) sym theories using supergravity and m - theory considerations , and is also perfectly consistent with the findings of @xcite where the su(@xmath146 sym theory is realized in type iia using d4 branes stretched between two ns branes .
we can therefore say that the methods we have developed provide a microscopic derivation of the supergravity profile for @xmath10 in which a direct relation with the chiral ring elements of the gauge theory on the source branes is clearly established and the non - perturbative effects are explicitly explained in terms of fractional d - instantons .
we have considered a fractional d3-brane system in a @xmath0 orbifold supporting an @xmath147 sym theory with su@xmath2 gauge group and @xmath3 flavors . we have considered the scalar field @xmath10 from the twisted closed string sector emitted by such a configuration , which , at the tree level , plays the rle of the gauge coupling on the d3-branes .
as it is well known , the fractional d3-branes act as sources for @xmath10 , so that @xmath10 has a logarithmic profile in the complex direction @xmath11 transverse to the orbifold ; this profile matches the perturbative running of the gauge coupling if the transverse space is identified with the coulomb branch of the gauge theory .
we have taken into account the non - perturbative effects corresponding to the inclusion of ( fractional ) d - instantons and explicitly shown how they modify the source for @xmath10 and hence its profile .
the moduli space integrals that determine the non - perturbative source terms are related to the ones appearing in the computation of the chiral ring operators of the gauge theory . through this relation
, we can then express the profile of the twisted scalar as the quantum expectation value of its perturbative expression ( see ( [ tauz ] ) ) .
this , in turn , can be written in terms of the sw curve that describes the effective dynamics of the gauge theory on the coulomb moduli space ( see ( [ tsugra ] ) ) . at the non - perturbative level , the gauge / gravity relation is deeply modified with respect to its perturbative standing .
the twisted scalar @xmath10 can no longer be simply identified with the effective gauge coupling . however , if we consider the situation in which the source d3-branes sit at the `` enhanon '' vacuum , @xmath75 , the scalar @xmath148 is still directly , albeit non - trivially , related to the effective coupling @xmath49 when @xmath149 is identified with the quantum coulomb space variable @xmath34 .
indeed , in this case @xmath148 is given by ( [ texact ] ) ; this expression corresponds , according to ( [ tlogz ] ) , to the logarithm of the anharmonic ratio @xmath69 which parametrizes the sw torus .
the anharmonic ratio is related to the complex structure @xmath38 , namely to the effective gauge coupling , through the modular function appearing in ( [ qtheta ] ) . in these proceedings we focused on the conformal su(2 ) case , but in @xcite we showed that a similar pattern occurs for higher rank conformal gauge theories , and also , after decoupling some flavors , for asymptotically free cases : the twisted scalar emitted by the branes at the enhanon vacuum
is related in the gauge / gravity correspondence to the low energy effective couplings via non - trivial modular functions which are generalizations of that appearing in ( [ qtheta ] ) .
0.8 cm 0.2 cm we warmly thank our coauthors of @xcite , francesco fucito , francisco morales and daniel ricci - pacifici , for the fruitful and pleasant collaboration .
this work is partially supported by the miur - prin contract 2009-khzkrx and by infn through the projects mi12 and tv12 .
99 j. m. maldacena , _ the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/a:1026654312961[adv.theor.math.phys . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 231252 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9711200[arxiv:hep-th/9711200 [ hep - th ] ] .
i. r. klebanov and n. a. nekrasov , _ gravity duals of fractional branes and logarithmic rg flow
_ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(00)00016-x[nucl.phys .
* b574 * ( 2000 ) 263274 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9911096 [ arxiv : hep - th/9911096 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. bertolini , p. di vecchia , m. frau , i. pesando , a. lerda , and r. marotta , _ fractional d - branes and their gauge duals _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2001/02/014[jhep * 0102 * ( 2001 ) 014 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0011077[arxiv:hep-th/0011077 ] .
j. polchinski , _ n=2 gauge / gravity duals _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1142/s0217751x01003834[int.j.mod.phys .
* a16 * ( 2001 ) 707718 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0011193[arxiv:hep-th/0011193 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. petrini , r. russo , and a. zaffaroni , _
n=2 gauge theories and systems with fractional branes _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(01)00270-x[nucl.phys .
* b608 * ( 2001 ) 145161 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0104026 [ arxiv : hep - th/0104026 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. bertolini , p. di vecchia , m. frau , a. lerda , and r. marotta , _
n = 2 gauge theories on systems of fractional d3/d7 branes _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(01)00568-5[nucl .
* b621 * ( 2002 ) 157178 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0107057[arxiv:hep-th/0107057 ] .
m. billo , l. gallot , and a. liccardo , _ classical geometry and gauge duals for fractional branes on ale orbifolds _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(01)00399-6[nucl
b614 * ( 2001 ) 254278 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0105258[arxiv:hep-th/0105258 ] .
n. dorey , t. j. hollowood , v. v. khoze , and m. p. mattis , _ the calculus of many instantons _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0370-1573(02)00301-0[phys
* 371 * ( 2002 ) 231459 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0206063[arxiv:hep-th/0206063 ] .
m. bianchi , s. kovacs , and g. rossi , _ instantons and supersymmetry _ , lect .
notes phys .
* 737 * ( 2008 ) 303470 , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0703142[arxiv:hep-th/0703142 [ hep - th ] ] .
e. witten , _ small instantons in string theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(95)00625-7[nucl .
* b460 * ( 1996 ) 541559 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9511030[arxiv:hep-th/9511030 ] .
m. r. douglas , _ branes within branes _ , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9512077[arxiv:hep-th/9512077 ] .
m. b. green and m. gutperle , _ d - instanton induced interactions on a d3-brane _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2000/02/014[jhep * 0002 * ( 2000 ) 014 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0002011[arxiv:hep-th/0002011 ] .
m. billo , m. frau , i. pesando , f. fucito , a. lerda , and a. liccardo , _ classical gauge instantons from open strings _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2003/02/045[jhep * 0302 * ( 2003 ) 045 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0211250[arxiv:hep-th/0211250 ] .
n. seiberg and e. witten , _ monopole condensation , and confinement in n=2 supersymmetric yang - mills theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(94)90124-4[nucl .
* b426 * ( 1994 ) 1952 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9407087[arxiv:hep-th/9407087 ] .
n. seiberg and e. witten , _
monopoles , duality and chiral symmetry breaking in n=2 supersymmetric qcd _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(94)90214-3[nucl .
b431 * ( 1994 ) 484550 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9408099[arxiv:hep-th/9408099 ] .
n. nekrasov , _ seiberg - witten prepotential from instanton counting _ , http://intlpress.com/site/pub/pages/journals/items/atmp/content/vols/0007/0005/00024829/index.html[adv .
theor . math .
* 7 * ( 2004 ) 831864 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0206161[arxiv:hep-th/0206161 ] .
n. nekrasov and a. okounkov , _ seiberg - witten theory and random partitions _ , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0306238[arxiv:hep-th/0306238 ] . e. witten , _ solutions of four - dimensional field theories via m theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(97)00416-1[nucl.phys . *
b500 * ( 1997 ) 342 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9703166[arxiv:hep-th/9703166 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. ferrari , _ emergent space and the example of @xmath150 _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2012.12.004[nucl .
b * 869 * ( 2013 ) 31 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1207.0886[arxiv:1207.0886 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. ferrari , _ on matrix geometry and effective actions _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2013.02.005[nucl .
b * 871 * ( 2013 ) 181 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1301.3722[arxiv:1301.3722 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. ferrari , m. moskovic and a. rovai , _ examples of emergent type iib backgrounds from matrices _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2013.03.010[nucl .
b * 872 * ( 2013 ) 184 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1301.3738[arxiv:1301.3738 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. ferrari and m. moskovic , _
emergent d4-brane background from d - particles _ , http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1301.7062[arxiv:1301.7062 [ hep - th ] ] f. ferrari and a. rovai , _
emergent d5-brane background from d - strings _ , http://arxiv.org/abs/arxiv:1303.7254[arxiv:1303.7254 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. billo , m. frau , l. giacone , and a. lerda , _ holographic non - perturbative corrections to gauge couplings _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep08(2011)007[jhep * 1108 * ( 2011 ) 007 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.1869[arxiv:1105.1869 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. fucito , j. morales , and d. pacifici , _ multi instanton tests of holography _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep09(2011)120[jhep * 1109 * ( 2011 ) 120 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1106.3526[arxiv:1106.3526 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. billo , m. frau , l. giacone , and a. lerda , _ non - perturbative gauge couplings from holography _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/prop.201200007[fortsch.phys .
* 60 * ( 2012 ) 907913 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1201.4231[arxiv:1201.4231 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. billo , m. frau , f. fucito , l. giacone , a. lerda , j. f. morales , and d. ricci - pacifici , _ non - perturbative gauge / gravity correspondence in n=2 theories _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep08(2012)166[jhep * 1208 * ( 2012 ) 166 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1206.3914[arxiv:1206.3914 [ hep - th ] ] . m. billo , m. frau , l. gallot , a. lerda , and i. pesando , _ deformed n=2 theories , generalized recursion relations and s - duality _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep04(2013)039[jhep * 1304 * ( 2013 ) 039 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1302.0686[arxiv:1302.0686 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. flume , f. fucito , j. f. morales , and r. poghossian , _
matone s relation in the presence of gravitational couplings _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2004/04/008[jhep * 0404 * ( 2004 ) 008 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0403057[arxiv:hep-th/0403057 ] .
t. w. grimm , a. klemm , m. marino , and m. weiss , _ direct integration of the topological string _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2007/08/058[jhep * 0708 * ( 2007 ) 058 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0702187[arxiv:hep-th/0702187 [ hep - th ] ] .
l. f. alday , d. gaiotto , and y. tachikawa , _ liouville correlation functions from four - dimensional gauge theories _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11005-010-0369-5[lett .
* 91 * ( 2010 ) 167197 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0906.3219[arxiv:0906.3219 [ hep - th ] ] .
m. billo , l. gallot , a. lerda , and i. pesando , _ f - theoretic vs microscopic description of a conformal n=2 sym theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep11(2010)041[jhep * 1011 * ( 2010 ) 041 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1008.5240[arxiv:1008.5240 [ hep - th ] ] .
p. c. argyres and s. pelland , _ comparing instanton contributions with exact results in n=2 supersymmetric scale invariant theories _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2000/03/014[jhep * 0003 * ( 2000 ) 014 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9911255[arxiv:hep-th/9911255 [ hep - th ] ] .
f. benini , m. bertolini , c. closset , and s. cremonesi , _ the n=2 cascade revisited and the enhancon bearings _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.79.066012[phys.rev .
* d79 * ( 2009 ) 066012 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0811.2207[arxiv:0811.2207 [ hep - th ] ] . m. billo , m. frau , f. fucito , and a. lerda , _ instanton calculus in r - r background and the topological string _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1126-6708/2006/11/012[jhep * 0611 * ( 2006 ) 012 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0606013[arxiv:hep-th/0606013 ] . k. ito , h. nakajima , t. saka , and s. sasaki , _
n=2 instanton effective action in @xmath151-background and d3/d(-1)-brane system in r - r background _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/jhep11(2010)093[jhep * 1011 * ( 2010 ) 093 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1009.1212[arxiv:1009.1212 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. cremonesi , _ transmutation of n=2 fractional d3 branes into twisted sector fluxes _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/42/32/325401[j.phys .
* a42 * ( 2009 ) ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0904.2277[arxiv:0904.2277 [ hep - th ] ] . | recently we provided a microscopic derivation of the exact supergravity profile for the twisted scalar field emitted by systems of fractional d3-branes at a @xmath0 orbifold singularity . in this contribution
we focus on a set - up supporting an @xmath1 sym theory with su@xmath2 gauge group and @xmath3 .
we take into account the tower of d - instanton corrections to the source terms for the twisted scalar and find that its profile can be expressed in terms of the chiral ring elements of the gauge theory .
we show how the twisted scalar , which at the perturbative level represents the gravity counterpart of the gauge coupling , at the non - perturbative level is related to the effective gauge coupling in an interestingly modified way .
* non - perturbative aspects of gauge / gravity duality * 0.5 cm marco bill@xmath4 , marialuisa frau@xmath4 , luca giacone@xmath5 and alberto lerda@xmath6 0.4 cm _ @xmath4 universit di torino , dipartimento di fisica and _ _ i.n.f.n . - sezione di torino _ _ via p.giuria 1 , i-10125 torino , italy _ 0.3 cm _ @xmath6 universit del piemonte orientale , _ _ dipartimento di scienze e innovazione tecnologica and _ _ i.n.f.n .
- gruppo collegato di alessandria - sezione di torino _ _ viale t. michel 11 , i-15121 alessandria , italy
. _ 0.3 cm _ e mail : billo , frau , giacone , [email protected]_ 0.5 cm |
compounds of the @xmath1 family ( @xmath2 rb , cs ; @xmath3 mn , fe , co , ni , cu , v ; @xmath4 cl , br , i ) figure prominently in the study of phase transitions in low dimensional systems . much of the interest in the magnetic field behavior of compounds like cscucl@xmath0 arises because they are physical realizations of models related to the triangular antiferromagnet ( tafm ) .
the tafm ground state is both continuously and discretely ( two fold ) degenerate , even in the presence of a magnetic field * h * ( with magnitude @xmath5 less than the saturation field @xmath6 ) , unlike that of the square lattice afm . in a field ,
thermal fluctuations@xcite in classical tafm models and quantum fluctuations@xcite break the continuous degeneracy ( which is nontrivial because it is not due to a symmetry of the hamiltonian ) in the same way , both selecting for example the colinear structure at @xmath7 .
the magnetic properties of cscucl@xmath0 ( with a nel temperature@xcite @xmath8k ) arise from the cu@xmath9 ions ; to a good approximation , these form a triangular lattice of parallel chains , the other ions serving to define the structure . the major interactions , all nearest neighbor , are a ferromagnetic exchange interaction in the chain or @xmath10 direction , a weaker antiferromagnetic exchange interaction between chains ( within the @xmath11@xmath12 planes ) , and a dzyaloshinskii moriya@xcite ( dm ) interaction also in the @xmath10 direction .
both exchange interactions are nearly isotropic ; the latter is frustrated .
recent studies@xcite of the structure and of the phase transition giving rise to the dm term cite earlier literature on these topics . in the simplified structural model , the classical
, zero temperature , zero field structure is a three sublattice , @xmath13 tafm structure in each @xmath11@xmath12 plane ; the spins lie in the planes and rotate from plane to plane , forming an incommensurate ( ic ) helical structure@xcite .
fluctuation effects are likely large in cscucl@xmath0 for several reasons : the cu spin is small ( @xmath14 ) , the system is almost one dimensional ( the intrachain interaction is much larger than the interchain interaction ) , the interchain interaction is frustrated , the exchange interactions are nearly isotropic , and the structure is incommensurate
. experiments in magnetic field ( difficult because @xmath15 t ) indeed find major effects due to quantum fluctuations .
cscucl@xmath0 in a longitudinal field ( @xmath16 ) appears to be well understood at low temperatures @xmath17 , but the transition at @xmath18 has puzzling features@xcite .
the discontinuity@xcite in the low@xmath17 magnetization at @xmath19 was shown by nikuni and shiba@xcite to be a novel , fluctuation induced phase transition from the umbrella structure ( optimal at small @xmath5 due to a small , easy
plane anisotropy@xcite in the intrachain exchange ) to a coplanar structure ( optimal at larger @xmath5 due to quantum fluctuations ) .
further experiments@xcite , including neutron
diffraction@xcite and specific
heat measurements@xcite near @xmath18 , confirmed their analysis .
properties for a transverse field ( @xmath20 ) are not well established .
small fields deform the helix , increasing its period ; in agreement with experiment@xcite , classical ( mean field ) theory@xcite predicts that the ic wavenumber @xmath21 decreases quadratically as @xmath5 increases and that the curvature increases with @xmath17 .
the structure remains incommensurate@xcite up to @xmath22 ; it is unknown at larger fields , where classical theory@xcite predicts an intermediate commensurate ( c ) phase in which each plane has the same three sublattice structure .
classical theory fails at intermediate fields : near @xmath23 , plateaus are observed in the magnetization@xcite @xmath24 , the @xmath25cs nmr shift@xcite and the wavenumber@xcite ; the esr measurements@xcite are not easily interpreted . the plateau in @xmath24 , as for the tafm@xcite , is due to quantum fluctuations@xcite ( the analysis was done for the c state , but the result for the ic state should not differ much )
. quantum fluctuations are surely responsible also for the plateau in @xmath21 , but this remains to be demonstrated .
recent specific heat , magnetization and neutron
diffraction measurements@xcite near @xmath26 suggest major effects due to thermal fluctuations : @xmath26 increases with field ( as in the tafm@xcite ) and a new phase appears .
the following examines quantum fluctuations in the incommensurate phase of cscucl@xmath27 .
section ii.a describes the hamiltonian .
section ii.b describes classical results ( from solution of the euler lagrange equations ) ; surprisingly , the spins do not remain in the @xmath11@xmath12 planes at intermediate fields ( as found also by jensen@xcite ) .
section ii.c describes a linear spin wave ( lsw ) analysis based on the classical results ; this fails because lsw theory does not find the c state and ic state energies to equivalent accuracy .
section iii introduces a phenomenological treatment of quantum fluctuations and shows that it works well for the c state ; the same approach applied to the ic state yields a plateau in the wavenumber at approximately the observed value and at approximately the observed fields .
although results are rather sensitive to an anisotropy parameter , we conclude that a commensurate phase should appear at a field well below the saturation field , likely below @xmath28 .
the hamiltonian corresponding to the simplified structure is @xmath29 @xmath30\ , \eqno(1)\ ] ] where @xmath31 is the spin operator at the @xmath32th site in the @xmath33th @xmath11@xmath12 plane , @xmath34 and @xmath35 are unit vectors in the @xmath10 and @xmath11 directions , and the @xmath36 sum is over the six , in plane , nearest neighbors of the site @xmath37 .
the first term ( @xmath38 ) is the isotropic , ferromagnetic exchange interaction between spins in nearest neighbor planes , the second is an anisotropic correction ( of easy plane type ) to the first , the third ( @xmath39 ) is the interplane dm interaction , the fourth ( @xmath40 ) is the isotropic , antiferromagnetic exchange interaction between nearest - neighbor spins in the @xmath11@xmath12 planes , and the fifth is the zeeman energy in a transverse field @xmath41 .
the values of the coefficients have been estimated in several articles@xcite ; we use @xmath42k , @xmath43k , @xmath44k and @xmath45k .
we omit the dipole dipole interaction ( which can induce an ic state modulated in the planes@xcite ) , the anisotropy of the interchain interaction , and several small , related effects ( namely the displacement of the cu ions from the @xmath10 axis , the component of the dm vector perpendicular to the @xmath10 axis , and the @xmath46 component of the magnetizations@xcite ) . the saturation field @xmath15 t , above which each spin is aligned with the field
, is @xmath47 in terms of the model ; the reduced field is @xmath48 . a longitudinal field @xmath49 maintains the axial symmetry of zero field , and the dm term can be eliminated@xcite .
a transverse field @xmath50 breaks the symmetry , and the dm term comes into full play . the intrachain exchange term @xmath51 ) favors a state with spins parallel in adjacent layers while the smaller dm term favors a rotation by @xmath52 per layer ; the result at low fields is a helical structure , incommensurate in the @xmath10 direction .
the ic wavenumber @xmath21 is small ( @xmath53 ) at @xmath54 where the continuous degeneracy of the classical tafm ground state corresponds to a mere shift in the origin of the coordinate system ; the classical degeneracies remain for a transverse field @xmath55 , even if the spins are confined to the planes . both the dm term ( inactive for the possible c state in transverse field ) and the much smaller anisotropy term@xcite ( responsible for the phase transition in longitudinal field@xcite ) favor spins in the @xmath11@xmath12 planes . for the ic state in transverse field , it is natural to assume that the dm term confines the spins to the planes at all fields ( as it does at small @xmath5 ) , and to ignore the @xmath56 term .
surprisingly , in
plane spins are unstable at intermediate fields for isotropic exchange ( as found also by jensen@xcite ) ; the instability persists , but is much reduced , for the experimental anisotropy .
we assume that the three
sublattice structure is maintained@xcite at all fields @xmath55 .
a continuum approximation@xcite for the @xmath10direction dependence is valid , but we require the discrete model because we approximate ic states as high order commensurate states ; in principle , we miss some features of ic states , but on the other hand we find that the states are not pinned .
we use periodic boundary conditions @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the sublattice index and @xmath59 is the layer index . in the classical approximation , the spin operators @xmath31 become classical vectors of length 1/2 , and the hamiltonian of eq.(1 ) becomes the energy function @xmath60 . with lagrange multipliers @xmath61 for the constraints @xmath62 , the euler
lagrange equations are @xmath63 @xmath64 the solutions are not pinned and so a condition such as @xmath65 is necessary .
ref . studied the continuum version of eq.(2 ) ( without the anisotropy term ) for in
plane spins .
the euler
lagrange equations have many solutions .
the one optimal at a given field is too often neither simple nor obvious , and so it was necessary to generate scores of solutions and follow them as functions of the field ( in steps @xmath66 ) , minimizing the energy of each with respect to @xmath67 ; composite solutions ( with increased winding number ) gave greater accuracy when such was desired .
random starting configurations were generated at various values of @xmath68 and @xmath69 , relaxed by conjugate
gradient minimization of the energy , and then used to start solution of the euler
lagrange equations .
classical theory can not explain the plateau in @xmath70 , but it is a necessary preliminary to the lsw analysis and it sheds light on two questions : ( 1 ) does a commensurate state intervene between the incommensurate and aligned states , and ( 2 ) do the spins lie in the @xmath11@xmath12 planes at all fields ?
the answers depend crucially on the size of the anisotropy parameter @xmath56 . for isotropic exchange ( @xmath71 ) ,
the optimal structure is incommensurate up to @xmath72 . for @xmath73 , there are many solutions ( as in the continuum approximation@xcite ) , but they are well separated in energy , and the spins remain in the planes for the optimal solution ( the 111 solution of ref . ) , which evolves continuously from the solution at @xmath74 . for @xmath75 ,
the spins break out of the planes ( in the optimal solution ) ; this is surprising , for each intrachain term in the energy is optimized or neutral if the spins lie in the planes , and so is the sum of the interchain and field terms .
in contrast , we verified that the spins remain in the planes for all fields in the case of a model@xcite with a ferromagnetic chain chain interaction .
the ic phase for @xmath76 is , however , very complicated : the solutions are far more numerous , they differ only slightly in energy for the most part , and the low energy solutions are not the simplest ; ground state energy crossings make it impossible to identify with confidence the optimal solution in most of this range . in short ,
the ic phase is glassy for fields in much of the range @xmath77 , the ground state changing often and unpredictably with field , from one complicated configuration to another .
the weak , easy
plane anisotropy@xcite @xmath78 changes the phase diagram substantially , opening a large window for the c phase and destroying the glassy phase . for @xmath79 , the in
plane ic solution of the previous paragraph is optimal ; it extends to larger @xmath68 because of the anisotropy . for @xmath80 , a simple , out of plane
, ic solution is optimal ( but other ic solutions are close in energy ) ; that is , both the dm and anisotropy terms acting in concert fail to confine the spins to the planes at all fields . for @xmath81
, the commensurate ( c ) state is optimal .
all transitions are second order . if @xmath56 were only slightly larger ( say a few % ) , then likely the spins would remain in the planes at all fields , and the ic phase make a second order transition to the c phase@xcite at @xmath82 .
the following describes a linear spin wave ( lsw ) analysis of quantum fluctuations in incommensurate ( ic ) states . to our knowledge
, fluctuations have previously been studied only in ic states which are sinusoidal or nearly so .
the analysis was restricted to in
plane spins and isotropic exchange ( @xmath71 ) , and so results were obtained only for @xmath73 . a holstein
primakoff transformation@xcite to boson operators ( using a local coordinate system@xcite ) and an expansion about the classical solutions give the hamiltonian as @xmath83 the classical spins are not colinear , and so the expansion parameter is @xmath84 ( rather than @xmath85 ) , as in refs . and .
the classical angles @xmath86 between the spins and the field are determined by minimizing the classical energy @xmath87 ( of order @xmath88 ) of the @xmath89 spins : @xmath90 @xmath91\ .\eqno(4)\ ] ] the term @xmath92 ( of order @xmath93 ) is linear in the boson operators ; it vanishes for the classical angles @xmath86 and so is omitted .
the lsw hamiltonian @xmath94 ( of order @xmath95 ) has the standard form ( quadratic in the boson operators ) : @xmath96\ ] ] @xmath97 \bigr\}\ .\eqno(5)\ ] ] the @xmath98 sum runs over the @xmath99 points in the first brillouin zone ; the @xmath100 hermitian matrices @xmath101 , @xmath102 and @xmath103 , the last diagonal ( @xmath104 and independent of @xmath98 , are @xmath105_{jl , j^\prime l^\prime}= -2j_0\cos(\phi_{jl^\prime}\!-\!\phi_{jl})\,\delta_{j^\prime j } \left(e^ { ik_z}\,\delta_{l^\prime , l+1 } + e^{-ik_z}\,\delta_{l^\prime , l-1}\right)\ ] ] @xmath106 @xmath107 @xmath108_{jl , j^\prime l^\prime}= -2j_0\delta_{j^\prime j}\left(e^ { ik_z}\delta_{l^\prime , l+1 } + e^{-ik_z}\delta_{l^\prime , l-1}\right ) + 6j_1\delta_{l^\prime l } \left(\nu_{\bf k}^{\phantom\ast}\delta_{j^\prime , j+1 } + \nu_{\bf k}^\ast \delta_{j^\prime , j-1}\right ) \ , \eqno(7)\ ] ] @xmath109 + d\,\left[\sin(\phi_{j , l+1}\!-\!\phi_{jl } ) + \sin(\phi_{jl } \!-\!\phi_{j , l-1})\right]\ ] ] @xmath110 + \,18\,j_1\,h\cos\phi_{jl } \ , \eqno(8)\ ] ] where @xmath111 is the in plane structure factor @xmath112 + \exp\left[{\textstyle{1\over2}}\,i\left(-k_x\!-\!\sqrt{3}k_y\right)\right ] \right\}\ .\eqno(9)\ ] ] after a standard transformation@xcite to creation and annihilation operators @xmath113 and @xmath114 for the spin wave excitations , @xmath94 takes the form @xmath115\ .\eqno(10)\ ] ] the ground
state value is @xmath116 ; the excitation energies @xmath117 ( @xmath118 ) are found from @xmath119=0\ .\eqno(11)\ ] ] the eigenvalue problem for @xmath120 is hermitian , but the result for @xmath121 can be imaginary ( as when the classical , in plane solutions become unstable at intermediate fields ) .
the lsw analysis of quantum fluctuations in the c state is straightforward@xcite ; of course the antisymmetric dm term does not appear , and so quantum selection occurs just as in the tafm@xcite .
for the ic state ( the 111 state of ref . ) , the total energy @xmath122 was found as a function of the period @xmath69 and minimized with respect to @xmath69 to give the optimal wavenumber @xmath123 . in the relevant field region ,
the optimal @xmath69 ranged from @xmath124 @xmath11@xmath12 plane spacings to @xmath125 , large enough to justify our treatment of the ic state as a high order commensurate state and small enough that the diagonalization was practicable .
the ic wavenumber ( figure 1 ) may flatten out with field , but the assumption of in
plane spins fails for @xmath75 .
more seriously , lsw theory gives a transition to the c state at lower field , @xmath126 .
the result for @xmath78 would not be qualitatively different .
lsw theory fails because it finds the c state energy more accurately than the ic
state energy .
the c state energy is found by choosing the classical configuration ( for example , the colinear state at @xmath127 ) which minimizes the total energy @xmath122 . such a choice is not possible for the ic state and so lsw theory does not take into account sufficiently the breaking of the continuous degeneracy in determining the spin structure ; moreover , the classical ic state is a poor approximation to the quantum ic state , as we now discuss .
much of the classical ic structure@xcite can be described as a sequence of degenerate commensurate states ( a `` spatially varying commensurate state '' ) ; domain walls ( where the spins assume orientations classically forbidden in the tafm ) are well defined only very close to the ic
c transition .
but quantum fluctuations destroy the continuous degeneracy and so the ic state at even small fields will have the conventional structure , namely distinct regions where the order parameter is nearly constant at a commensurate value , separated by walls where it varies rapidly .
this structure is very different from the classical structure , and thus is difficult to obtain by the perturbative approach of the @xmath85 expansion .
extension of the analysis to higher order ( including spin rearrangement due to quantum fluctuations ) would also not find the two energies to the same accuracy ; and it is computationally out of reach , entirely without appeal , and even not possible if @xmath71 ( the classical ground state can not be found for @xmath76 ) .
a very different approach is required .
the most important effect of quantum fluctuations in this problem is the breaking of the tafm classical degeneracy .
the following describes an innovative phenomenological method to treat quantum fluctuations in the tafm part of the hamiltonian .
we represent the quantum part of the tafm energy ( terms proportional to @xmath128 , @xmath129 , _ etc . _ ) by the term @xmath130 with @xmath131 ; for in
plane spins , @xmath132 the motivation for this form of @xmath133 is partly that it favors the colinear state .
a biquadratic coupling term is important in the classical theory@xcite of the plateau@xcite in the magnetization of the @xmath134 system c@xmath135eu@xmath136 , and ref .
pointed out that such a term in the hamiltonian ( with @xmath137 ) may have the same consequences as quantum fluctuations .
our treatment is phenomenological because a biquadratic coupling term is not allowed in the hamiltonian for cscucl@xmath0 ( because @xmath14 ) , and therefore the term appears here in a fundamentally different way than previously . to test
whether the phenomenological term describes qualitatively the effects of quantum fluctuations , we applied the formalism to the tafm , minimizing the total energy @xmath138\eqno(13)\ ] ] ( this is just @xmath139 ) for the five tafm states shown in figure 2 ; the direction of * h * is irrelevant and all states have the same classical energy .
state ( b ) is optimal at low fields , @xmath154 , the region over which it exists .
the colinear state ( c ) is optimal at intermediate fields , @xmath155 ; the magnetization in this region is one third the saturation value .
state ( d ) is optimal at higher fields , @xmath156 , the region over which it exists .
the aligned state @xmath157 is optimal for @xmath158 .
except for the definitions of the fields @xmath159 , @xmath160 and @xmath72 , these are just the @xmath85 results@xcite for quantum fluctuations : the colinear state is stable in a region about @xmath161 , states ( a ) and ( e ) are optimal at no field @xmath5 @xmath162 and @xmath55 , _
etc_. however , quantum fluctuations do not renormalize@xcite @xmath72 , and the expressions for the fields @xmath163 and @xmath160 differ qualitatively .
having established that the term @xmath133 provides a reasonable description of quantum fluctuations in the tafm , we next compare it quantitatively with the lsw energy @xmath164 for the five commensurate states of cscucl@xmath0 derived from the tafm states of figure 2 .
the energies @xmath164 were found by standard methods@xcite with parameter values @xmath42k , @xmath71 , @xmath44k and @xmath165 .
the energies @xmath166 , on the other hand , are the same as for the tafm and are independent of @xmath167 . to make a fair comparison ( @xmath164 is only the leading quantum correction )
, we found @xmath133 to only first order in @xmath168 ; this means , for example , that @xmath169 for the umbrella state .
figure 3 plots the two energies for the first four states relative to state ( e ) ( which exists over the entire field range @xmath170 and so is a convenient reference state ) .
good agreement is obtained for @xmath171k and so we expect that the phenomenological term @xmath133 captures well enough the breaking of the classical degeneracy by quantum fluctuations . because @xmath164 is only the first
order correction , a moderate adjustment of @xmath172 is acceptable ; an effective @xmath172 smaller than @xmath173k is suggested by the next correction@xcite at fields just below @xmath72 .
a separate comparison should really be made for @xmath78 but this seems unwarranted .
the phenomenological approach was then applied to the ic phase of cscucl@xmath0 in transverse field .
the total energy is @xmath174 .
the euler
lagrange equations are @xmath175 @xmath176 = 0\ ; \eqno(18{\rm a})\ ] ] for in plane spins , these simplify to @xmath177 -d \,s\left[\cos(\phi_{jl}\!-\!\phi_{j , l+1 } ) -\cos(\phi_{jl}\!-\!\phi_{j , l-1})\right]\ ] ] @xmath178 -g\,\mu_{\rm b}\,h\sin\phi_{jl}\ ] ] @xmath179=0\
. \eqno(18{\rm b})\ ] ] as described in section ii.b , scores of solutions of these equations were generated and followed in field , in steps @xmath66 [ with @xmath180 . in the following ,
we use the value @xmath181k which gives a plateau in @xmath70 ; there is no plateau for significantly smaller values , and @xmath21 is nonmonotonic for significantly larger values ( @xmath182k for example)@xcite .
the phenomenological term does not change the zero field spin configuration , a simple helical structure with wavenumber @xmath183 ; the result for weak fields is almost the same as for @xmath184 . but quantum fluctuations , represented phenomenologically , make major differences for @xmath185 . for isotropic exchange ( @xmath71 )
, the ground state is incommensurate up to @xmath72 .
the spins lie in the planes until @xmath186 ; above this field , two out of plane solutions compete , their energies crossing several times ; quantum fluctuations destroy the glassy phase . for @xmath78 , the low
field , in
plane solution is optimal for @xmath187 ; as for the classical analysis ( section ii.b ) , the weak , easy plane anisotropy opens a large window for the commensurate state , which is optimal for @xmath188 up to @xmath189 ; an out of plane ic solution is optimal over such a small field range ( @xmath190 about @xmath191 ) that we ignore it .
figure 4 compares the experimental results ( available only to @xmath192 t or @xmath191 ) for the ic wavenumber with the theoretical values .
the agreement with experiment is moderately good .
the plateau occurs at about the observed value of @xmath193 and over about the correct field range ; of course the value @xmath181k was selected to give a plateau , but the position of the plateau is not adjustable .
the major difference is that the theoretical value drops prematurely .
the magnetization is moderately rounded for @xmath194 , but does not have the plateau seen in experiment@xcite .
we are grateful to prof .
shiba , dr . u. schotte and prof .
a. v. chubukov for discussions and correspondence .
this research was supported by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada .
a. e. jacobs , t. nikuni and h. shiba , j. phys .
* 62 * , @xmath211 ( 1993 ) .
equation ( 3.7 ) for the off diagonal matrix elements should be @xmath212\nu_k$ ] ; the correct definition was used in the calculations . | in low magnetic field , the stacked , triangular antiferromagnet cscucl@xmath0 has a helical structure incommensurate ( ic ) in the chain direction . the ic wavenumber ( from neutron diffraction experiments )
decreases with increasing field transverse to the chains , as predicted by classical theory , but then it has a plateau almost certainly caused by quantum fluctuations .
linear spin wave theory fails because fluctuations have particularly large effects in the ic phase .
an innovative phenomenological treatment of quantum fluctuations yields a plateau at approximately the observed value and the observed fields ; it predicts a transition to the commensurate phase so far not observed .
results depend sensitively on a weak anisotropy . |
line driven winds ( ldws ) occur in various astronomical objects , like ob and wolf - rayet stars , in accretion disks in cataclysmic variables and , probably , in active galactic nuclei and luminous young stellar objects .
these winds are powered by absorption and re - emission of photospheric continuum flux in numerous spectral transitions of c , n , o , fe , etc .
castor , abbott , & klein ( 1975 ; hereafter cak ) have analyzed the steady state euler equation for ldws .
they found an infinite family of mathematical solutions , but only one , hereafter ` critical solution ' , which extends from the photosphere to arbitrary large radii .
other solutions either do not reach infinity or the photosphere . the former solutions are called shallow and the latter ones steep .
the unique , critical wind starts as the fastest shallow solution and switches smoothly to the slowest steep solution at the critical point .
observational support that ldws adopt the critical solution comes from measured terminal speeds ( abbott 1982 ) .
furthermore , mass loss rates of supergiant winds are in general agreement with modified cak theory ( lamers & leitherer 1993 ; puls et al .
these measurements were recently extended to include galactic and extragalactic ob and a stars and central stars of planetary nebula ( kudritzki et al .
1999 ) .
abbott ( 1980 ) put cak theory in a complete analogy to the solar wind and nozzle flows .
the existence of a sonic point defines the unique , transsonic solutions for these flows , whereas the existence of a critical point for abbott waves defines the unique , cak solution for ldws . only from below this critical point
, abbott waves can propagate upstream towards the photosphere . above the critical point , they are advected outwards . because abbott waves generally propagate highly supersonically , the critical point of ldws lies at much higher speeds than the sonic point .
abbott s ( 1980 ) analysis was challenged by owocki & rybicki ( 1986 ) , who derived the green s function for a pure absorption ldw .
the green s function gives correct signal speeds in presence of hydrodynamic instabilities .
the inward signal speed in a pure absorption line wind is the sound speed , and not the much larger abbott speed , because photons propagate outwards only .
owocki & rybicki ( 1986 ) showed that a fiducial upstream signal , which still propagates inward at abbott speed , must be interpreted as _ purely local _
taylor series reconstruction . for a flow driven by scattering lines ,
however , owocki & puls ( 1999 ) find _ physically relevant _
abbott waves for a numerical green s function . in the present paper ,
we further analyze the properties of abbott waves .
we show that they are crucial for our understanding of stability of ldws and must be included in the courant time step .
so far , time - dependent numerical simulations of ldws from stars and accretion disks have ignored the ability of abbott waves to communicate in the supersonic regime , which results in a numerical runaway . in particular
, this runaway can lift the wind to the critical solution .
the critical solution is also enforced by applying pure outflow boundary conditions .
it is often argued that outflow boundary conditions are appropriate since ldws are highly supersonic .
instead , they have to be _ super - abbottic_. we show that shallow wind solutions , which correspond to solar wind breezes , are everywhere sub - abbottic . hence , these solutions are numerically destabilized by applying outflow boundary conditions .
we formulate boundary conditions which render shallow solutions numerically stable . those include non - reflecting riemann conditions for abbott waves . by allowing for kinks in the velocity law
, shallow solutions can be made globally admissible .
in the cak model for ldws , both gravity and line force scale with @xmath0 . if the sound speed and hence the pressure forces are set to zero , this leads to a degeneracy of the critical point condition , which is satisfied formally at every radius ( poe , owocki , & castor 1990 ) .
thus , for this case , abbott waves can not propagate inwards from any location in the wind . for finite sound speed , they creep inwards at small speed . inclusion of the finite disk correction factor is much more relevant for ldws than inclusion of pressure forces . with
the finite disk included , the inward speed of abbott waves below the critical point is significantly larger than the wind speed .
unfortunately , the finite disk correction factor depends on the ( unknown ) velocity law of the wind , which prevents a simple analysis of the wind dynamics .
we consider , therefore , a wind model which is analytically feasible and yet prevents the ( near-)degeneracy of the cak point - star wind .
( especially , the latter leads to poor convergence of time - dependent numerical schemes . ) as a prototype , a vertical ldw from an isothermal , geometrically thin , non - self - gravitating accretion disk is assumed .
the sound speed is set to zero .
keplerian rotation is assumed within the disk and angular momentum conservation above the disk .
this reduces the flow problem to a 1-d , planar one .
the radiative flux above an isothermal disk is roughly constant at small heights . on the other hand ,
the vertical gravity component along the wind cylinder is zero in the disk midplane , grows linearly with @xmath1 if @xmath2 ( with @xmath3 the footpoint radius in the disk ) , reaches a maximum , and drops off at large @xmath1 . to model the launch region of the wind and the gravity maximum , we choose @xmath4 , with normalization @xmath5 and @xmath6 , @xmath7 being gravitational constant , and @xmath8 is the mass of the central object .
the different spatial dependence of flux and gravity results in a well - defined critical point in the flow . for constant radiative flux ,
the cak line force becomes @xmath9 , where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are the density and velocity , and @xmath12 and @xmath13 are constants .
we choose @xmath14 .
typical values of @xmath12 from nlte calculations ( pauldrach 1987 ) and kramers law ( puls , springmann , & lennon 2000 ) are @xmath15 to 0.7
. the constant @xmath13 can be expressed in terms of the unique , critical cak mass loss rate .
this is the maximum allowed mass loss rate for a stationary wind .
we introduce new fluid variables @xmath16 and @xmath17 , @xmath18 where a subsript ` c ' refers to the critical cak solution . for stationary ,
plane parallel winds , the continuity equation becomes @xmath19 , and @xmath16 is a constant . in the following
, the quantity @xmath20 will play a central role .
the velocity law , @xmath21 , is obtained by quadrature of the wind ` solution ' @xmath22 . for @xmath14 ,
the stationary euler equation becomes , @xmath23 where we multiplied the nominator and denominator in the line force by @xmath11 , and introduced @xmath24 , the gravity at the location of the cak critical point .
the dependence of @xmath25 on @xmath1 is supressed in the equation .
the constant @xmath13 was determined as follows .
equation ( [ euler ] ) is a quadratic equation in @xmath26 .
consider the @xmath27 plane . for arbitrary @xmath1 and sufficiently small @xmath16 , the crossings
@xmath28 of the parabola @xmath29 with the abscissa determine two wind solutions @xmath22 , termed shallow and steep .
when @xmath16 increases , the crossings approach each other , and merge at some maximum @xmath30 , beyond which no further solutions exist .
hence , the _ singularity condition _
@xmath31 holds when two solutions merge , as is the case at the critical point .
together with @xmath28 , this gives @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
we add a comment which is important for the following . at every location @xmath34 , @xmath35 for the parabola which meets the abscissa in just one point .
the minimum , @xmath36 , is reached at the unique critical point , @xmath37 , which is the flow _ nozzle _ and determines the maximum mass loss which can be driven from the photosphere to infinity .
solutions ( actually , pairs of shallow and steep solutions ) with @xmath35 are called _
overloaded_. they correspond to a _ choked _ laval nozzle flow .
these solutions become imaginary in a neigborhood of the critical point .
we have shown elsewhere ( feldmeier & shlosman 2000 ) how overloaded ldw solutions can be made globally defined , by letting them decelerate , @xmath38 , around the critical point .
the _ position _ of the critical point is determined by the _ regularity _
condition , which is derived next . since @xmath28 everywhere
, @xmath39 holds too . since @xmath40
, it follows that @xmath41 , if @xmath42 .
this latter condition singles out the unique critical point , since overloaded winds have kinks at the merging point of two solutions , @xmath43 .
hence , the critical point lies at the gravity maximum , @xmath44 . for @xmath4 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 . the line force in ( [ euler ] ) becomes @xmath47 .
this holds for any solution , whether shallow or steep . solving ( [ euler ] ) for @xmath26 , @xmath48 where we introduced a new variable @xmath49 .
the signs refer to steep ( @xmath50 ) and shallow ( @xmath51 ) solutions . for @xmath36 , the square root in ( [ eulersol ] )
vanishes at the critical point . for @xmath35 ,
the root becomes imaginary in a neighborhood of the critical point .
the solutions @xmath22 of ( [ eulersol ] ) have a saddle topology in the @xmath52 plane when @xmath16 is varied from @xmath53 to @xmath35 .
the critical point @xmath54 is the saddle point .
a variable radiative flux above a non - isothermal accretion disk leads instead to two different @xmath37 , above and below the gravity maximum ( feldmeier & shlosman 1999 ) .
the lower is a saddle , the upper an extremum .
note that the cak critical point of ldws is a saddle in the @xmath55 plane , whereas the sonic point of the solar wind is a saddle in the @xmath56 plane . in all other respects ,
we find a deep analogy between ldws and the solar wind .
only the notion of a critical speed is replaced by a critical acceleration .
shallow solutions are the analogs to solar wind breezes . according to ( [ eulersol ] ) , shallow and steep solutions with @xmath57
extend from @xmath58 to @xmath59 for the present model with zero sound speed .
cak found that steep solutions start supersonically at the wind base @xmath58 , which seems unphysical . in a spherically symmetric wind
, shallow solutions do not extend to arbitrarily large @xmath1 , because they can not provide the required expansion work .
these two results and the requirement for a continuous and differentiable solution implies that the wind has to pass through the critical point .
it starts on the fastest shallow , and ends on the slowest steep solution .
figure 1 ( which is adapted from fig . 4 in abbott 1980 or fig .
8.13 in lamers & cassinelli 1999 ) shows the ldw solution topology in the @xmath60 plane , for a finite sound speed . in region ( ii ) , which is spatially the most extended in real ldws , shallow and steep solutions exist at each point @xmath61 . if @xmath34 , these solution pairs may be overloaded . in the subsonic region ( i ) , only shallow solutions ( possibly overloaded ) exist ; steep solutions are necessarily supersonic
. correspondingly , only steep solutions ( possibly overloaded ) exist in region ( iii ) .
no solutions exist in regions ( iv ) and ( v ) .
note that the gap in overloaded solutions around @xmath37 can be bridged by an extended decelerating region , @xmath62 .
= 8.4 cm the argument by cak ruling out global , steep solutions is stringent , but the exclusion of shallow solutions seems too restrictive .
the pressure force due to spherical expansion becomes important only at very large distances from the wind base . according to cak ,
shallow solutions break down around 300 stellar radii for realistic o star wind parameters .
most shallow solutions have by then overcome the local escape speed .
shallow solutions can be globally defined by a slight generalization of the cak approach , allowing for negative @xmath63 in the line force @xmath64 .
this can be done by replacing @xmath65 by @xmath66 or by @xmath67 .
the former expresses the ` blindness ' of purely local line driving to flow acceleration or deceleration .
the latter accounts for the nonlocal effect of shadowing in non - monotonic velocity laws , creating a resonance coupling .
all radiation is assumed to be absorbed at the first resonance location .
realistically , the value of the line force lies between these extremes .
the decelerating wind solution , @xmath68 , is unique , and does not split into shallow and steep branches .
hyperbolic differential equations allow for weak discontinuities , which are represented in the @xmath52 plane by jumps between different solution branches .
hence , a shallow solution may jump onto the decelerating branch .
even an overloaded solution can avoid becoming imaginary by jumping onto the decelerating branch in the vicinity of the critical point .
this opens the possibility that global solutions can be composed in a piecewise manner .
jumps in @xmath25 introduce _ kinks _ in @xmath21 .
such kinks have been found on various occasions in time - dependent ldw simulations .
they may play a central role in the observed _ discrete absorption components _ in non - saturated p cygni line profiles ( cranmer & owocki 1996 ) . in ldws from accretion disks in cataclysmic variables , a jump onto the decelerating branch even occurs for the critical solution , which would elsewhere not extend to infinity ( feldmeier & shlosman 1999 ) .
hence , the smoothness argument of cak can not be used to disqualify shallow solutions .
the time - dependent continuity and euler equation for the present wind model are , @xmath69 in the euler equation , @xmath70 is assumed .
the case @xmath71 will be discussed later .
to derive abbott waves , small perturbations are applied , @xmath72 $ ] and @xmath73 $ ] .
the subscript 0 refers to a stationary solution , subscript 1 to the perturbation .
linearizing gives @xmath74 { \rho_1 \over \rho_0 } + ( i\chi -1 ) \ ; { v_1 \over v_0 } = 0,\\ \label{eulerper } { 1\over q_0 } { \rho_1 \over \rho_0 } + \left[-i { \omega \over v_0 ' } + 1 + i\chi \left(1-{1\over q_0}\right ) \right ] { v_1 \over v_0 } = 0 , \end{gathered}\ ] ] with non - dimensional @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
setting the determinant of the system to zero gives the dispersion relation @xmath77 .
in wkb approximation , @xmath78 , one finds for the phase speed , @xmath79 , and growth rate of the inward ( @xmath51 ) mode , @xmath80 in the observers frame , and for the outward ( @xmath50 ) mode , @xmath81 with @xmath82 a small damping term of no further consequence . along a shallow solution , @xmath83 , and along a steep solution , @xmath84 . for shallow solutions with small @xmath85 and @xmath86 ,
@xmath87 is small , and the inward mode can propagate at arbitrarily large phase speed , from _ every _ location @xmath1 .
this result is new , since so far abbott waves along shallow solutions were not considered ( `` a ldw has no analog to a solar breeze , '' abbott 1980 ) . since for the cak point star model
every point is critical , @xmath88 , and the inward mode is stagnating everywhere
. stability of _
non_-wkb waves , @xmath89 , is found from a numerical solution . integrating ( [ eulersol ] ) , the velocity of the critical solution at @xmath45 ( the ` critical speed ' ) is @xmath90 . on the other hand ,
a shallow solution with @xmath91 has @xmath92 for @xmath93 .
this is no contradiction to the fact that the shallow solution is sub - abbottic .
the above analysis holds for linear waves , and the wave speed is determined by the underlying stationary solution .
general , non - linear waves can be derived from a characteristic analysis .
the characteristic form of the above equations is , without further approximations ( feldmeier & shlosman 2000 ) , @xmath94 \rho = -\rho { { \partial}v\over { \partial}z},\\ \label{chareul } & \left[{{\partial}\over { \partial}t } + a \ , { { \partial}\over { \partial}z}\right ] \left ( { 1\over\rho } { { \partial}v\over{\partial}z}\right ) = - { 1\over\rho } { { \partial}g\over{\partial}z } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the abbott speed , @xmath95 , in the observers frame is @xmath96 .
the interpretation of ( [ chareul ] ) is unconventional , in that @xmath65 should now be considered as fundamental hydrodynamic field , instead of @xmath11 .
this happens because of the nonlinear dependence of @xmath97 on @xmath65 ( courant & hilbert 1968 ) .
hence , @xmath98 in the continuity equation and @xmath99 in the euler equation are inhomogenous terms , since they do not contain derivatives of the hydrodynamic fields @xmath10 and @xmath65 . the advection operators are @xmath100 and @xmath101 , with characteristic speeds @xmath11 and @xmath95 .
the former should be read as @xmath102 in zero sound speed approximation .
the riemann invariants @xmath10 and @xmath103 correspond to wave amplitudes . in a frame moving at @xmath11 , the amplitude @xmath10 is constant , except for sources and sinks @xmath104 . in an isothermal gas , @xmath105 , and
the wave amplitude is indeed that of a pressure wave . in a frame moving at @xmath95 , the amplitude @xmath103 is constant , except for sources and sinks @xmath99 .
the sobolev optical depth is @xmath106 , indicating that the ( @xmath51 ) mode is a radiative wave . even for waves of infinitesimal amplitude
, @xmath65 may deviate strongly from @xmath107 , if the wavelength @xmath108 is short .
since @xmath109 , short - scale abbott waves are highly dispersive . for sufficiently small @xmath108
, @xmath65 becomes negative at certain wave phases .
the characteristic equations ( [ charcon ] , [ chareul ] ) hold also for @xmath71 , but @xmath95 has different meaning then . for a line force @xmath110 ,
the general @xmath95 is @xmath111 where the lower sign applies for @xmath71 , and in @xmath112 one has to use @xmath113 .
trivially , abbott waves are advected _ outwards _ in super - abbottic flow . but
that abbott waves propagate _ downstream _ as a @xmath114 mode in regions where @xmath71 is probably their single , most unique property . for a line force @xmath115 then , @xmath116 if @xmath71 .
this is because the line force drops out of the euler equation , and both wave modes become ordinary sound .
( actually @xmath117 then , for upstream propagating sound . ) in this case one has along a characteristic with coordinate @xmath118 , @xmath119 as wkb wave solution of ( [ charcon ] , [ chareul ] ) .
this describes gas dynamical _ simple _ waves . since @xmath120 , they steepen and break ( @xmath121 ) .
the derivation of simple _ abbott _ waves is beyond the scope of this paper .
we discuss now the outer boundary conditions for shallow solutions .
abbott waves can enter through the outer boundary , hence , pure outflow boundary conditions are not appropriate for shallow solutions . as hydrocode
we use a standard eulerian scheme on a staggered mesh .
advection is solved in the conservative control volume approach , using monotonic van leer ( 1977 ) interpolation .
the sound speed is set exactly to zero , and a small amount of artificial viscosity is added to handle occasional shock fronts .
details on the scheme can be found in reile & gehren ( 1991 ) and feldmeier ( 1995 ) . in a first step ,
we consider simple boundary conditions for @xmath10 and @xmath11 which still preserve essential features of abbott waves .
these boundary conditions render shallow solutions stable , and allow small perturbations to leave the grid .
they are , @xmath122 where 0 and @xmath123 are the mesh indices of the inner and outer boundary , respectively .
the conditions ( [ simpleboundary ] ) are motivated as follows .
( the reader may jump to the end of this paragraph . ) on a characteristic curve @xmath124 $ ] which leaves the mesh through a boundary , the characteristic equation is solved on the boundary via _ extrapolation _ , using one - sided , interior differentials . such an _ upwinded _ scheme is stable ( steger & warming 1981 ) . for shallow winds
, the @xmath10 wave leaves through the outer boundary if @xmath125 , hence @xmath10 is extrapolated from the interior in ( [ simpleboundary ] ) .
zeroth order extrapolation is used for stability reasons .
abbott waves enter the mesh through the outer boundary , hence a boundary condition must be applied .
we choose @xmath126 .
( to prevent standing waves , @xmath127 is often more appropriate ; but is also more susceptible to runaway than @xmath126 . ) at the _ inner _ boundary , the argument proceeds correspondingly , with interchanged roles of the waves .
we find that using @xmath128 and @xmath129 instead destabilizes shallow solutions . in time - dependent hydrodynamic simulations published so far , it is customary to insert the _ sound _ speed in the courant time step , @xmath130 with courant number @xmath131 , and the minimum has to be taken over the mesh .
we see now that abbott waves , as characteristic inward wave mode , have to be included in the courant time step , @xmath132 where @xmath95 is in the fluid frame now .
note that @xmath95 changes sign with @xmath65 .
for sufficiently small @xmath70 and for arbitrary @xmath71 , abbott waves determine the time step . at velocity plateaus where the wind velocity is more or less constant , @xmath133 from ( [ chareul ] ) , and the courant time step @xmath134 .
this is an artifact of sobolev approximation in which the line radiation force tends to zero in the absence of velocity gradients . in practice ,
in calculating the courant time step we do not allow @xmath49 to drop below a certain minimum value , usually @xmath135 .
this corresponds to @xmath136 for an ordinary courant time step not including abbott waves .
our results are not sensitive to the value of this minimum @xmath49 , if the latter is sufficiently small .
furthermore , velocity plateaus quickly acquire a tilt and propagate at finite speed .
we can then formulate _ non - reflecting _ boundary conditions for the riemann invariants @xmath10 and @xmath103 , which annihilate incoming waves .
this prevents boundary reflection of waves which originate on the interior mesh . to annihilate a wave , its amplitude ( the riemann invariant )
is kept constant in time at the boundary , @xmath137 and @xmath138 for abbott and sound waves , respectively ( hedstrom 1979 ; thompson 1987 ) .
one may say that non - reflecting boundary conditions drive the numerical solution towards a neighboring , stationary solution without waves .
the technical details of implementing these boundary conditions are discussed in appendix a.
we discuss here the numerical stability of shallow and steep solutions , depending on the appropriate courant time step and boundary conditions .
we start with steep solutions , and show that they are unconditionally stable , even when simplified boundary conditions analogous to ( [ simpleboundary ] ) are used . according to ( [ eulersol ] ) , @xmath139 everywhere for steep solutions , and abbott waves can propagate only towards larger @xmath1 . at the outer boundary ,
extrapolation @xmath140 and @xmath141 is therefore appropriate . at the inner boundary
, two conditions have to be specified .
the obvious choices are either @xmath142 , @xmath143 or @xmath144 , @xmath145 .
the first set fixes the mass loss rate , the second establishes non - reflecting boundary conditions : the wave amplitudes are @xmath10 and @xmath103 , and the latter boundary conditions keep them constant in time , meaning there are no waves .
we find that steep solutions are stable for both types of boundary conditions .
even when the initial conditions differ profoundly from a steep wind , the numerical code converges to the latter .
furthermore , we performed tests with an explicit , harmonic perturbation at fixed eulerian position in the wind .
even if the perturbation amplitude reached 100% , the wind remained on average on a steep solution , which can , therefore , be considered as unconditionally stable .
a physically more relevant question is for the stability of shallow solutions . in a first step ,
we use an analytic , shallow wind as initial conditions .
table [ table1 ] shows the _ runaway _ of this shallow to the critical velocity law .
abbott waves are _ not _ accounted for in the courant time step , and pure outflow boundary conditions @xmath140 and @xmath141 are applied .
this corresponds to the typical procedure adopted in the literature .
the runaway starts at the outer boundary and generates inward propagating abbott waves .
the velocity law evolves towards larger speeds , until the critical solution is reached .
c|rrrrrr @xmath146&0&3&6&9&20&@xmath59 0.1&*0.0*&*0.0*&*0.0*&*0.0*&*0.0*&*0.0 * 0.5&*0.2*&*0.2*&*0.2*&*0.2*&*0.2*&*0.2 * 1.0 & 0.5 & 0.4&*0.6*&*0.6*&*0.6*&*0.6 * 1.5 & 0.6 & 0.6 & 0.9&*1.0*&*1.0*&*1.0 * 2.0&_0.7 _ & 0.8&_1.2 _ & 1.4&*1.4*&*1.4 * 2.5&_0.8 _ & 0.9&_1.3_&_1.5_&*1.8*&*1.8 * 3.0&_0.8_&_1.1_&_1.3_&_1.5_&*2.1*&*2.1 * 3.5&_0.8_&_1.1_&_1.4_&_1.6_&_2.2_&*2.4 * 4.0&_0.8_&_1.2_&_1.4_&_1.6_&_2.3_&*2.7 * the mechanism of the runaway seems as follows .
the courant condition for abbott waves is violated in the outer wind , where the velocity law is flat and the abbott speed is large .
this causes numerical runaway .
opposed to standard gas dynamics , the ldw runaway does not crash the simulation .
we speculate that exponential growth in @xmath11 creates large @xmath66 , which imply small abbott speeds .
the courant condition is no longer violated , and runaway stops .
abbott waves are also excited at the outer boundary , by switching from the interior to the boundary scheme .
upstream propagating abbott waves are inconsistent with the assumed outflow boundary conditions .
the waves propagate to the wind base and drive the inner wind towards the critical solution , which is indeed consistent with outflow boundary conditions .
note in table [ table1 ] that abbott waves can propagate inwards from the outer boundary , @xmath147 , until the critical velocity law is reached ( indicated by bold numbers in the table ) .
this is no contradiction to the critical point being located at @xmath45 : the outer , shallow portion of the velocity law ( the numbers in italics ) is sub - abbottic , even when the inner , steep velocity law is already super - abbottic . to _ prevent numerical runaway _ of shallow solutions , we apply non - reflecting riemann boundary conditions and include abbott waves in the courant time step . as initial conditions , an arbitrary ( for example , linear ) velocity law is used .
abbott waves are again exited at the outer boundary and propagate inwards . however , the simulation relaxes quickly to a shallow solution .
the @xmath16-value depends on the initial data . even for an initial model with height - dependent mass flux
, we find quick convergence to a shallow solution .
further details on the stability of shallow solutions are given in appendix b. to summarize this section , both improper outer boundary conditions and courant conditions which do not account for abbott waves are responsible for numerical runaway .
we present a simplified model for line driven winds from stars and accretion disks which avoids the @xmath0 degeneracy of the cak model . radiative or abbott waves are derived , both from a dispersion and a characteristic analysis , and for all possible solutions to the euler equation , i.e. , shallow , critical , steep and overloaded ones .
we find that abbott waves can propagate upstream , towards the photosphere , from any position along a shallow wind solution .
hence , for the latter , they can enter the calculational grid through the outer boundary .
the wave propagation speed depends on the velocity slope of the wind .
abbott s ( 1980 ) result that these waves are creeping , i.e. , have only slighly negative inward speeds , holds globally only for the almost degenerate cak point - star model . in more realistic wind models ,
abbott waves can limit the courant time step .
both the neglect of abbott waves in the courant time step and in the boundary conditions leads to numerical runaway , towards the critical wind solution of maximum mass loss rate or to accretion flow .
if , instead , incoming waves are annihilated at the outer boundary and the correct courant timestep is used , shallow solutions are stable .
it is a pleasure to thank janet drew , leon lucy , stan owocki , and joachim puls for frequent discussions .
this work was supported in part by nasa grants nag 5 - 10823 , nag5 - 3841 , wku-522762 - 98 - 6 and hst go-08123.01 - 97a to i.s . , which are gratefully acknowledged .
we adopt the following procedure to calculate @xmath10 and @xmath11 on a boundary .
( i ) if the @xmath10 wave leaves the grid , @xmath148 is calculated using one - sided , interior differentials .
( ii ) if the @xmath10 wave enters the grid , @xmath149 is set ( wave annihilation ; see the main text ) .
( iii ) if the @xmath103 wave leaves the grid , @xmath150 is calculated from the euler equation ( [ chareul ] ) in characteristic form , using one - sided , interior differentials . note that @xmath151 appears here .
( iv ) if @xmath103 enters the grid , @xmath152 is set , assuming wkb waves .
( v ) the new values for @xmath10 and @xmath11 on the boundary are found by integrating @xmath153 and @xmath154 using a time - explicit scheme . in the latter step ( v ) ,
one actually needs @xmath155 , not @xmath154 . to integrate from time step @xmath156 to @xmath157 at the outer boundary ,
using @xmath154 , we write @xmath158 using @xmath159 , and similarly for @xmath160 , this becomes , @xmath161 whence @xmath162 depends on @xmath163 . due to frequent variable updating in an operator splitting scheme during the time step
, @xmath163 would have to be stored as an extra variable .
this seems not desirable , and causes indeed numerical runaway of shallow solutions .
fortunately , a simple approximation to ( [ memory ] ) gives satisfactory results , namely setting @xmath164 , or @xmath165
for numerical stability tests , we assume the following parameters , if not otherwise stated : 200 equidistant grid points from @xmath166 to @xmath167 .
below @xmath166 , the stationary wind speed is very small . since @xmath168 , one has @xmath169 for an inner boundary @xmath170 .
even small perturbations @xmath171 cause then negative speeds at @xmath172 .
this alters the direction of the @xmath10 characteristic , and often causes numerical problems .
a shallow solution with @xmath173 serves as start model .
the sound speed is set to zero .
the flow time from @xmath166 to @xmath167 is 12.4 for a shallow solution with @xmath173 , and 9.1 for the critical solution ( in the units specified in the main text ) . for @xmath173 ,
linear abbott waves propagate from @xmath167 to @xmath166 in a time 6.0 .
all simulations are evolved to time 50 .
table [ tableapp ] lists results from simulations using different outer boundary conditions and courant time steps . on the inner boundary , conditions ( [ simpleboundary ] ) were used .
cccccccc 1 & 4 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & no & 0.5 & outflow & runaway 2 & 4 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & no & 0.1 & outflow & @xmath175 ; oscill . 3 & 4 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & no & 0.5 & shallow & runaway 4 & 4 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & no & 0.1 & shallow & runaway 5 & 10 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & no & 0.1 & outflow & runaway 6 & 4 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & @xmath176 ; oscill . 7 & 10 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & slow runaway 8 & 10 & 500 & abs@xmath174 & yes & 0.5 & outflow &
slow runaway 9 & 4 & 80 & abs@xmath174 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & @xmath176 ; oscill.10 & 4 & 200 & abs@xmath174 & yes & 0.5 & shallow & stable 11 & 4 & 200 & max@xmath177 & no & 0.5 & outflow & accretion 12 & 4 & 200 & max@xmath177 & no & 0.1 & outflow & accretion 13 & 4 & 200 & max@xmath177 & no & 0.5 & shallow & stable , oscill .
14 & 4 & 200 & max@xmath177 & no & 0.1 & shallow & stable , oscill .
15 & 10 & 200 & max@xmath177 & no & 0.1 & outflow & accretion 16 & 4 & 200 & max@xmath177 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & accretion 17 & 10 & 200 & max@xmath177 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & accretion 18 & 10 & 500 & max@xmath177 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & accretion 19 & 4 & 80 & max@xmath177 & yes & 0.5 & outflow & accretion 20 & 4 & 200 & max@xmath177 & yes & 0.5 & shallow & stable consider first the line force @xmath110 .
the table shows that inclusion of abbott waves in the courant time is mandatory to prevent runaway ( runs 1 - 5 ; ` shallow ' in the column for the outer boundary conditions refers to ( [ simpleboundary ] ) . for small courant numbers , abbott waves are , to a degree , already accounted for by an ordinary time step .
runaway may then be prevented , as in run 2 , though the solution does oscillate at all times . shifting the outer boundary outwards ,
the runaway occurs again ( run 5 ) .
if abbott waves are accounted for in the time step , outflow boundary conditions ( extrapolation of @xmath10 and @xmath11 ) do not necessarily lead to runaway . instead , a stable , shallow solution may be maintained ( runs 6 , 9 ; also 2 ) .
however , the solution oscillates at all times .
shallow solutions become more unstable when the outer boundary is shifted outwards , into the shallow part of the velocity curve where abbott waves are easily excited . finally , the control run 10 shows that the initial shallow solution is numerically stable if abbott waves are included in the time step and boundary conditions ( [ simpleboundary ] ) are used . for a line force @xmath115 ,
the scheme is even more susceptible to numerical runaway .
all cases with outflow boundary conditions undergo runaway .
however , for the boundary condition @xmath141 , the solution no longer tends towards the critical solution .
instead @xmath178 drops to zero , and with it the interior wind velocity .
the outcome of the simulation is not clear , as we have not formulated appropriate line driven _ accretion _ boundary conditions .
the reason for the drop in @xmath178 is that an accidental @xmath71 at the outer boundary implies zero line force .
this causes further velocity drop and @xmath65 becomes more negative .
abbott waves carry this wind breakdown to the interior mesh .
it is not clear whether this type of line force should actually be applied in the proximity of the outer boundary .
abbott , d. c. 1980 , apj , 242 , 1183 abbott , d. c. 1982 , apj , 259 , 282 castor , j. i. , abbott , d. c. , & klein , r. i. 1975 , apj , 195 , 157 courant , r. , & hilbert , d. 1968 , methoden der mathematischen physik , springer , berlin cranmer , s. r. , & owocki , s. p. 1996
, apj , 462 , 469 feldmeier , a. 1995 , a&a , 299 , 523 feldmeier , a. , & shlosman , i. 1999 , apj , 526 , 344 feldmeier , a. , & shlosman , i. 2000 , apj , 532 , l125 hedstrom , g. w. 1979 , j. comp .
phys . , 30 , 222 kudritzki , r. p. , puls , j. , lennon , d. j. , et al . 1999 ,
a&a , 350 , 970 lamers , h. j. g. l. m. , & leitherer , c. 1993 , apj , 412 , 771 lamers , h. j. g. l. m. , & cassinelli , j. p. 1999
, introduction to stellar winds ( cambridge : cambridge univ .
press ) owocki , s. p. , & puls , j. 1999 , apj , 510 , 355 owocki , s. p. , & rybicki , g. b. 1986 , apj , 309 , 127 pauldrach , a. 1987 , a&a , 183 , 295 poe , c. h. , owocki , s. p. , & castor , j. i. 1990 , apj , 358 , 199 puls , j. , kudritzki , r. p. , herrero , a. , et al .
1996 , a&a , 305 , 171 puls , j. , springmann , u. , & lennon , m. 2000 , a&as , 141 , 23 reile , c. , & gehren , t. 1991 , a&a , 242 , 142 steger j. l. , & warming r. f. 1981 , j. comp .
, 40 , 263 thompson , k. w. 1987 , j. comp .
phys . , 68
, 1 van leer , b. 1977 , j. comp .
phys . , 23 , 276 | observations and theory suggest that line driven winds from hot stars and luminous accretion disks adopt a unique , critical solution which corresponds to maximum mass loss rate .
we analyze the numerical stability of the infinite family of shallow wind solutions , which resemble solar wind breezes , and their transition to the critical wind .
shallow solutions are sub - critical with respect to radiative ( or abbott ) waves
. these waves can propagate upstream through shallow winds at high speeds . if the waves are not accounted for in the courant time step , numerical runaway results .
the outer boundary condition is equally important for wind stability . assuming pure outflow conditions , as is done in the literature , triggers runaway of shallow winds to the critical solution or to accretion flow .
-1truecm = -0.5 in |
when quantum particles interact by a short - range potential with a scattering length much larger than the potential range , they may form universal bound states whose properties are independent of microscopic physics @xcite . besides universal @xmath2-boson bound states in one dimension @xcite and in two dimensions @xcite , the most remarkable example is the efimov effect in three dimensions , which predicts the emergence of an infinite tower of three - boson bound states with orbital angular momentum @xmath3 whose binding energies obey the universal exponential scaling @xcite .
we also solved the two coupled integral equations ( [ eq : residue ] ) numerically with @xmath1 at mass ratios of @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 and observed that the obtained binding energies asymptotically approach the predicted doubly exponential scaling for each mass ratio .
see table [ tab : binding ] for the obtained binding energies at @xmath7 for two identical bosons corresponding to the upper sign in eq .
( [ eq : residue ] ) .
y. nishida , s. moroz , and d. t. son , phys .
* 110 * , 235301 ( 2013 ) .
t. mizuno , m. takayasu , and h. takayasu , physica a * 308 * , 411 ( 2002 ) .
a. g. volosniev , d. v. fedorov , a. s. jensen , and n. t. zinner , j. phys .
* 47 * , 185302 ( 2014 ) . c. gao and z. yu , arxiv:1401.0965 [ cond-mat.quant-gas ] .
r. pires , j. ulmanis , s. hfner , m. repp , a. arias , e. d. kuhnle , and m. weidemller , phys .
lett . * 112 * , 250404 ( 2014 ) . s
tung , k. jimnez - garca , j. johansen , c. v. parker , and c. chin , phys .
lett . * 113 * , 240402 ( 2014 ) .
h .- w . hammer and d.
lee , phys .
b * 681 * , 500 ( 2009 ) ; ann .
phys . * 325 * , 2212 ( 2010 ) .
the form of the effective - range expansion up to the second order in @xmath8 is not affected as long as the underlying potential @xmath9 vanishes faster than @xmath10 at @xmath11 . for the van der waals potential @xmath12 , the denominator of eq .
( [ eq : t - matrix ] ) suffers a logarithmic correction of @xmath13\,k^2\ln|k|$ ] , which , however , disappears right at the @xmath0-wave resonance @xmath14 and thus does not affect the conclusion of this article .
z. nussinov and s. nussinov , phys .
a * 74 * , 053622 ( 2006 ) .
y. nishida and d. t. son , phys . rev . lett . * 97 * , 050403 ( 2006 ) ; phys .
a * 75 * , 063617 ( 2007 ) .
y. nishida , phys .
d * 77 * , 061703(r ) ( 2008 ) .
a. c. fonseca , e. f. redish , and p. e. shanley , nucl .
a * 320 * , 273 ( 1979 ) .
m. repp , r. pires , j. ulmanis , r. heck , e. d. kuhnle , m. weidemller , and e. tiemann , phys .
a * 87 * , 010701(r ) ( 2013 ) .
d. t. son , phys . rev .
d * 59 * , 094019 ( 1999 ) .
j. levinsen , n. r. cooper , and v. gurarie , phys .
a * 78 * , 063616 ( 2008 ) . | we study two species of particles in two dimensions interacting by isotropic short - range potentials with the interspecies potential fine - tuned to a @xmath0-wave resonance .
their universal low - energy physics can be extracted by analyzing a properly constructed low - energy effective field theory with the renormalization group method .
consequently , a three - body system consisting of two particles of one species and one of the other is shown to exhibit the super efimov effect , the emergence of an infinite tower of three - body bound states with orbital angular momentum @xmath1 whose binding energies obey a doubly exponential scaling , when the two particles are heavier than the other by a mass ratio greater than 4.03404 for identical bosons and 2.41421 for identical fermions . with increasing the mass ratio
, the super efimov spectrum becomes denser which would make its experimental observation easier .
we also point out that the born - oppenheimer approximation is incapable of reproducing the super efimov effect , the universal low - energy asymptotic scaling of the spectrum . |
according to thomson s theorem @xcite , given a certain number of conductors , each one with a given charge , the charges distribute themselves on the conductor surfaces in order to minimize the electrostatic energy .
thomson s result has been applied several times in the literature . in particular , in papers of this journal it was used ` to find the density of the induced surface charge in the classical case of a point charge in front of an infinite planar conductor ' @xcite and how ` the use of the minimum energy principle to explain static distributions of electric charge provides interesting physical insights ' @xcite .
other interesting applications of the thomson s theorem are also found in @xcite . even though the proof of the theorem may be found with great detail in @xcite , a different approach not found in the literature , based on the variational principle ,
is presented in this paper .
moreover , the analogue situation for the magnetic field is also introduced : _ the magnetic field energy is minimal for superficial currents distributions so that the magnetic vector potential points in the same direction as the surface current .
_ however , since energy conservation is assumed , this result can not be applied to ohmic conductors in which a steady current can only exist if there is an electric field .
thus , it can only be used in classical perfect conductors and superconductors .
furthermore , it must be stressed that this theorem is not incompatible with greiner s and essn s result on the magnetic field energy maximization @xcite .
their work concerns currents in wires that can move in space while this study regards fixed currents .
we shall prove this statement and thomson s theorem by using a variational principle for the electromagnetic field energy functional .
in equilibrium , the static energy functional for the electric field in a system composed of a conducting region surrounded by vacuum , may be written as : @xmath0 \right \ } \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & -\int_{v_{\rm{out } } } { \epsilon_0 \over 2 } \left \ { \vec{\nabla } \cdot \left ( \phi \vec{\nabla } \phi \right ) -
\phi \vec{\nabla}^2 \phi \right \ } \textrm{d}v+\int_{s } \sigma \phi \textrm{d}s \label{energia}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the volume of the conductor is represented by @xmath1 , the outside volume is @xmath2 and @xmath3 is the conductor boundary surface . inside the conductor , we consider the volume charge distribution @xmath4 and on the conductor s surface , the sufarce charge distribution @xmath5 . after applying green s theorem ,
the energy functional becomes : @xmath6 where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the gradient operators at the surface in the upper and lower limits , respectively . since the total charge in the conductor is limited and constrained to the conductor volume and surface
, one must include this restriction by introducing a lagrange multiplier .
therefore , the infinitesimal variation of the energy reads : @xmath9 + \delta
\sigma \left ( \phi - \lambda \right ) \right \ } \textrm{d}s\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the energy minimization , the euler - lagrange equations are : @xmath10 @xmath11 @xmath12 from these equations , in the minimum energy state , the potential is constant inside the conductor which means the electric charge distribution is superficial in an equipotential configuration proving thomson s theorem .
the same procedure will be applied to the magnetic field .
the energy functional for the magnetic field with no time dependencies is written as : @xmath13 + \vec{a } \cdot \left [ \vec{\nabla } \times \left(\vec{\nabla } \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] \right ) \right \ } \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & -\int_{v_{\rm{out } } } { 1 \over 2 \mu_0 } \left \ { \vec{\nabla } \cdot \left [ \vec{a } \times \left(\vec{\nabla } \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] + \vec{a } \cdot \left [ \vec{\nabla } \times \left(\vec{\nabla } \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] \right \ } \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & + \int_{s } \vec{k } \cdot \vec{a } \textrm{d}s\end{aligned}\ ] ] again , the volume of the conductor portion is represented by @xmath1 , the outside volume is @xmath2 and @xmath3 is the conductor boundary surface . inside the conductor , we consider the volume current distribution @xmath14 and on the conductor s surface , the sufarce current distribution @xmath15 .
using green s theorem , the energy functional becomes : @xmath16 \right ) \right \ } \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & -\int_{v_{\rm{out } } } { 1 \over 2 \mu_0 } \left \ { \vec{a } \cdot \left [ \vec{\nabla } \times \left(\vec{\nabla } \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] \right \ } \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & + \int_{s } \left \ { \vec{k } \cdot \vec{a } - { 1 \over 2 \mu_0 } \vec{a } \cdot \left [ \hat{n } \times \left ( \vec{\nabla}^+ \times \vec{a } - \vec{\nabla}^- \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] \right \ } \textrm{d}s \label{variational}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as in the electric field case , some constraints should be imposed . in particular ,
due to charge conservation , the electric current must obey the continuity equation both in volume and at the surface @xcite : @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the surface gradient operator .
notice that constraints are local , not global ones .
in other words , the lagrange multipliers are not constant but space functions .
therefore , the infinitesimal variation of the magnetic energy reads : @xmath19 \right ) + \delta \vec{j } \cdot \left ( \vec{a}-\vec{\nabla}\lambda \right ) \right \ } \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & -\int_{v_{\rm{out } } } \delta \vec{a } \cdot \frac{1}{\mu_0}\left [ \vec{\nabla } \times \left(\vec{\nabla } \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] \textrm{d}v \nonumber \\ & & + \int_{s } \left\ { \delta \vec{a } \cdot \left [ \vec{k } + \frac{1}{\mu_0 } \hat{n } \times \left ( \vec{\nabla}^+ \times \vec{a } - \vec{\nabla}^- \times \vec{a } \right ) \right ] + \delta \vec{k } \cdot \left ( \vec{a } - \vec{\nabla}_s \lambda \right ) \right \ } \textrm{d}s\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , the euler - lagrange equations for this energy functional are : @xmath20 @xmath21 @xmath22 from eq .
( [ potencial2 ] ) , the magnetic field must be zero inside the conductor , discarding any currents in volume ( @xmath23 ) in the minimum energy state .
on the other hand , from eq .
( [ surface2 ] ) , one concludes that the potential vector @xmath24 is tangent to the conducting surface . since the magnetic field is zero in the inner volume , considering a cartesian coordinate system for a given surface element ,
if one of the axis is orthogonal to the surface element , the surface current becomes : @xmath25 = \frac{1}{\mu_0 } \hat{n } \times \left [ \vec{\nabla}_{\hat{n } } \times \vec{\nabla}_s \lambda \right ] \\
\label{current}\ ] ] where @xmath26 points in the same direction of @xmath27 by definition and @xmath28 is orthogonal . from this result
, it is clear that the surface current @xmath15 will point in the same direction of @xmath24 .
notice that no restriction was imposed on the vector potential .
therefore this result is independent of the chosen gauge .
even though the proof of the theorem does not include the presence of an external magnetic field , the result can be easily generalized .
the presence of an external magnetic field demands another surface integral in eq ( [ variational ] ) for currents at infinity . it does not affect the final result , however
the minimal magnetic energy theorem can be illustrated in a simple system such as the coaxial cable .
a coaxial cable can be modeled by an outer cylindrical conducting surface with radius @xmath29 , carrying an electric current @xmath30 , and a massive cylindrical conductor with radius @xmath31 , carrying the same electric current in the opposite direction .
furthermore , for this case study , the inner current is divided into a superficial current @xmath32 at @xmath33 and a current @xmath34 in the inner volume , so that @xmath35 .
the magnetic field is readily obtained using ampre s law : @xmath36 thus , the magnetic field energy on a length @xmath37 of the cable is given by : @xmath38 the magnetic energy reaches the minimum for @xmath39 and therefore , for @xmath40 .
in other words , the magnetic energy attains its minimum value when the current only flows at the surface .
furthermore , the current density was considered to be homogeneous in the azimuthal coordinate , which is intuitively the minimum energy configuration , leading to a tangent magnetic vector potential .
a similar analysis for an electrostatic distribution can be found in @xcite .
the minimal magnetic energy theorem can also be useful to determine the configuration of the magnetic field and surface current distribution of a superconductor in equilibrium , for example , a cylindrical perfect conductor / superconductor with radius @xmath41 immersed in a external constant magnetic field ( see figure 1 ) . in order to achieve the magnetic vector potential solution
, one must solve the following differential equations : @xmath42 however , instead of starting solving immideatly , one should look into the symmetries of the system .
for instance , if the external constant magnetic field points in the same direction of the y - axis and if the cylinder is considered to be infinite , there wo nt be any dependencies on the z coordinate ( cylinder axis ) .
therefore , the magnetic field simplifies to : @xmath43 moreover , due to the symmetry of the system , the z - component of the magnetic field must be zero : @xmath44 these assumptions and constraints transform eq .
( [ curl ] ) into : @xmath45 which is the well known laplace equation . before writing down the general solution ,
let s analyze the boundary conditions . at @xmath46
, the magnetic field must be equal to the external one : @xmath47 .
furthermore , since the magnetic field is zero inside the perfect conductor , from eq .
( [ magnetic_2 ] ) one concludes the magnetic potential vector must be constant inside the perfect conductor / superconductor .
therefore , the solution for this case study is then : @xmath48 even though this is only the solution for the z - component of @xmath24 , the other components are not relevant to compute the magnetic field .
however , the two remaining solutions can always be determined assuming the coulomb gauge and using eq .
( [ equacao ] ) while the boundary condition comes from eq .
( [ current ] ) since the surface current must point in the same direction of the potential vector .
now everything is ready to calculate the magnetic field outside the cylinder : @xmath49 which implies that , @xmath50 the knowledge of the magnetic field on the cylinder s surface allows determination of the surface current : @xmath51 the total current obtained through integration of the surface current is zero as expected , otherwise the energy would diverge .
a more detailed analysis on this problem can be found in @xcite .
the same calculations can be performed for a superconducting sphere with radius @xmath41 in a constant magnetic field pointing in the z - axis direction ( see figure 2 ) .
similarly to the cylinder case , eq .
( [ curl ] ) is simplified a lot by implementing the symmetries of the system . since the external constant magnetic field points in the same direction of the z - axis
, there wo nt be any dependencies in the @xmath52 coordinate and the magnetic field along this coordinate must be zero .
therefore , the magnetic field simplifies to : @xmath53 again , these assumptions and constraints transform eq .
( [ curl ] ) into : @xmath54 = 0 \label{curl_2}\ ] ] since the magnetic field is zero inside the sphere , from eq ( [ magnetic_3 ] ) , the magnetic vector potential must have the following form : @xmath55 where c is a constant . in order to prevent the magnetic vector potential from diverging at @xmath56 and @xmath57 ,
the constant c must be zero .
furthermore , at @xmath58 , the magnetic field must be equal to the external one : @xmath59 .
therefore , the solution of eq ( [ curl_2 ] ) for this case is : @xmath60 which leads to the following magnetic field outside the sphere , @xmath61 from this result , the magnetic field at the sphere surface becomes : @xmath62 using eq ( [ surface2 ] ) , the surface current density is therefore : @xmath63 unlike the infinite superconducting cylinder in a constant magnetic field , the superconducting sphere has a total non - zero electric current , @xmath64 .
this current is essential in order to keep the magnetic field from entering inside the spherical superconductor .
a similar approach to this problem can also be found in @xcite .
in conclusion , the energy approach to the nature of magnetic fields has provided several interesting physical results such as @xcite . in particular our theorem , analogously to thomson s theorem in electrostatics , allows the prediction of surface current distributions in superconductors at equilibrium .
furthermore , it may change the distinction between superconductors and perfect conductors . in the pedagogical literature on superconductivity a distinction between superconductors and hypothetical perfect conductors is sometimes made .
both have zero resistivity below some critical temperature but when cooled below this temperature , while penetrated by constant external magnetic fields , the superconductor expels the field ( the experimentally observed meissner effect ) but , in the corresponding thought experiment , the perfect conductor does not ( see e.g. poole et al . [ 19 ] ) . from the minimal magnetic energy theorem ,
one concludes that energy minimization and expelling external fields are the same thing .
therefore , the perfect conductors would in fact behave like superconductors in their approach to thermodynamic equilibrium .
10 jackson j d 1975 _ classical electrodynamics _ ( new york : wiley ) sancho m , sebastin j l , muoz s and miranda j m 2001 _ ieee proc .- sci .
technol . _ * 148 * 121 brito l and fiolhais m 2002 _ eur .
j. phys . _
* 23 * 427 ezzat g bakhoum 2008 _ journal of electrostatics _ * 66 * 561 coulson c a 1958 _ electricity _ ( edinburgh : oliver and boyd ) panofsky w k h and phillips m 1963 _ classical electricity and magnetism _ ( reading , ma : addison - wesley ) landau l d and lifshitz e m 1960 _ electrodynamics of continuous media _ ( oxford : pergamon ) walter greiner 1998 _ classical electrodynamics _ ( new york : springer ) hanno essn 2009 _ eur .
_ * 30 * 515 donolato c 2003 _ eur
. j. phys . _
* 24 * l1 mcallister i w 1991 _ ieee transactions on electrical insulation _ * 26 * 3 yuriy n. zhilichev 1997 _ ieee transactions on applied superconductivity _ * 7 * 4 ernesto a. matute 1999 _ american journal of physics _ * 67 * 786 hanno essn 2008 _ europhysics letters _ * 84 * 20011 hanno essn 1999 _ j. phys . a : math .
gen . _ * 32 * 2297 hanno essn 1997 _ phys .
e _ * 56 * 5858 hanno essn 1996 _ phys .
* 53 * 5228 hanno essn 2005 _ eur .
_ * 26 * 279 charles p. poole jr . , horatio a. farach , richard j. creswick and ruslan prozorov 2007 _ superconductivity _ ( amsterdam : academic press ) | thomson s theorem states that static charge distributions in conductors only exist at the conducting surfaces in an equipotential configuration , yielding a minimal electrostatic energy . in this work we present a proof for this theorem based on the variational principle .
furthermore , an analogue statement for magnetic systems is also introduced and proven : the stored magnetic field energy reaches the minimum value for superficial current distributions so that the magnetic vector potential points in the same direction as the surface current .
this is the counterpart of thomson s theorem for the magnetic field .
the result agrees with the fact that currents in superconductors are confined near the surface and indicates that the distinction between superconductors and hypothetical perfect conductors is fictitious . |
the @xmath6 interaction near threshold is strongly attractive , in agreement with the existence of the unstable bound state @xmath7 below the @xmath8 threshold .
the @xmath0-nucleus interaction is also strongly attractive , as derived from the strong - interaction shifts and widths in kaonic - atom levels across the periodic table @xcite .
it is not established yet how strong the @xmath0-nucleus potential is : ` deep ' ( 150 - 200 mev @xcite ) or relatively ` shallow ' ( 50 - 60 mev @xcite ) ? is it possible to bind _ strongly _ @xmath0 mesons in nuclei and are such potentially deep bound states sufficiently narrow to allow observation and identification ? these issues have received considerable phenomenological and theoretical attention recently @xcite , and some experimental evidence for candidate states in the @xmath9 and @xmath10 reactions on @xmath11he ( kek - ps e471 , @xcite respectively ) and in the @xmath12 in - flight reaction on @xmath4o ( bnl - ags , parasite e930 @xcite ) has been presented very recently .
new experiments have been approved at kek , using @xmath13 reactions to search for @xmath0 nuclear bound states @xcite .
@xmath14 reactions @xcite were also suggested in this context .
a prime concern in searching for @xmath0 nuclear bound states is the anticipated large width due to pionic conversion modes on a single nucleon : @xmath15 with thresholds about 100 mev and 180 mev , respectively , below the @xmath16 total mass , and also due to non - pionic multi - nucleon absorption modes , say @xmath17 with thresholds about @xmath18 mev lower than the single - nucleon thresholds .
the branching ratios in parentheses are known from bubble - chamber experiments @xcite .
the aim of the present work is to study _ dynamical _ effects for @xmath0 nuclear states in the range of binding energy @xmath19 mev @xcite and in particular the width anticipated for such deeply bound states .
the relatively shallow chirally - motivated @xmath0-nucleus potentials @xcite which followed the microscopic construction by ramos and oset @xcite are of no use in this context , since they can not yield binding energy greater than the potential depth of about 50 mev .
one must therefore depart from the microscopic approach in favor of a more phenomenologically inclined model which is constrained by data other than two - body @xmath6 observables .
the theoretical framework here adopted is the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) model for a system of nucleons and one @xmath0 meson interacting through the exchange of scalar ( @xmath20 ) and vector ( @xmath21 ) boson fields which are treated in the mean - field approximation . by allowing the @xmath0 to polarize the nucleons , and vice versa , this dynamical calculation is made self consistent .
@xmath0 absorption modes are included within a @xmath22 optical - model approach , where the density @xmath23 plays a dynamical role , and the constant @xmath24 which is constrained near threshold by @xmath2-atom data follows the phase - space reduction in reactions eqs .
( [ eq : conv1],[eq : conv2 ] ) for a deeply bound @xmath0 . a wide range of binding energies may be explored in the rmf calculation simply by scanning over the coupling constants of the @xmath0 meson to the @xmath20 and @xmath21 boson fields .
detailed calculations were done by us across the periodic table . in this letter
we demonstrate the essential points and conclusions for @xmath3c and @xmath4o where the dynamical polarization effects are extremely important for the energies of the @xmath0 bound states as well as for their widths .
akaishi et al .
@xcite too have found large polarization effects in lighter nuclei using few - body variational techniques . the rmf is a systematic approach used across the periodic table beyond the very light elements explored by other techniques , and it can be used also to study multi-@xmath0 configurations and to explore the @xmath0 condensation limit @xcite .
similar rmf calculations have been recently reported for @xmath25 states in nuclei @xcite .
in the calculations described below , the standard rmf lagrangian @xmath26 with the linear ( l ) parameterization of horowitz and serot @xcite as well as the nonlinear ( nl ) parameterization due to sharma et al .
@xcite are used for the description of the nucleonic sector .
the ( anti)kaon interaction with the nuclear medium is incorporated by adding to @xmath26 the lagrangian density @xmath27 @xcite : @xmath28 the covariant derivative @xmath29 describes the coupling of the ( anti)kaon to the vector meson @xmath21 .
the vector field @xmath21 is then associated with a conserved current .
the coupling of the ( anti)kaon to the isovector @xmath23 meson is here excluded due to considering @xmath30 nuclear cores in this initial report . whereas adding @xmath31 to the original lagrangian @xmath26 does not affect the form of the corresponding dirac equation for nucleons , the presence of @xmath0 leads to additional source terms in the equations of motion for the meson fields @xmath20 and @xmath32 to which the @xmath0 couples : @xmath33 @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the @xmath0 energy in the nuclear medium : @xmath36 and @xmath37 and @xmath38 denote the nuclear scalar and vector densities , respectively . adding @xmath0 to the nuclear system
affects the scalar and vector potentials which enter the dirac equation for nucleons .
this leads to the rearrangement , or polarization of the nuclear core in the presence of @xmath0 . in order to preserve the connection to previous studies of kaonic atoms , the klein gordon ( kg ) equation of motion for the @xmath0
is written in the form @xcite : @xmath39{\bar k } = 0~~ ~~ ( \hbar = c = 1).\ ] ] here , @xmath40 denotes the static coulomb potential for the @xmath2 , @xmath41 is the @xmath0-nucleus reduced mass and @xmath42 is the complex binding energy .
the real part of the @xmath0 optical potential @xmath43 is then given by @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the scalar and vector potentials due to the @xmath20 and @xmath21 mean fields , respectively .
since the rmf approach does not address the imaginary part of the potential , @xmath47 was taken in a phenomenological @xmath22 form , where its depth was fitted to the @xmath2 atomic data @xcite .
note that @xmath23 in the present calculations is no longer a static nuclear density , but is a _ dynamical _ entity affected by the @xmath0 interacting with the nucleons via boson fields .
the resulting compressed nuclear density leads to increased widths , particularly for deeply bound states . on the other hand , the phase space available for the decay products
is reduced for deeply bound states , which will act to decrease the calculated widths .
thus , suppression factors multiplying @xmath47 were introduced from phase - space considerations , taking into account the binding energy of the kaon for the initial decaying state , and assuming two - body final - state kinematics for the decay products .
two absorption channels were considered . in the first , eq . ( [ eq : conv1 ] )
, a @xmath1 initial state decays into a @xmath48 final state .
the corresponding density - independent suppression factor is given by @xmath49 [ m_1 ^ 2-(m_y - m_\pi)^2 ] } { [ m_{01}^2-(m_\pi + m_y)^2][m_{01}^2-(m_y - m_\pi)^2]}}~ \theta ( m_1-m_{\pi}-m_y ) \;\;\ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath50 .
in the second absorption channel , eq .
( [ eq : conv2 ] ) , a @xmath51 initial state decays into a @xmath52 final state .
the corresponding suppression factor is given by @xmath53 [ m_2 ^ 2-(m_y - m_n)^2 ] } { [ m_{02}^2-(m_n + m_y)^2][m_{02}^2-(m_y - m_n)^2]}}~ \theta ( m_2-m_y - m_n ) \;\;\ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath54 .
although multi - nucleon absorption modes are often modeled to have a power - law @xmath55 ( @xmath56 @xmath57 1 ) density dependence , our comprehensive @xmath2-atom fits @xcite are satisfied with @xmath58 . we therefore assume @xmath59 in this exploratory work also for this second absorption channel , , is due to koltun @xcite ] which means that @xmath60 too is independent of density .
we comment below on the effect of a possible density dependence of @xmath60 , reflecting perhaps a @xmath61 dependence of the non - pionic decay mode ( [ eq : conv2 ] ) at high densities .
since @xmath62 final states dominate these channels @xcite the hyperon @xmath63 was here taken as @xmath64 . allowing @xmath65 hyperons would foremost _ add _ conversion width to @xmath0 states bound in the region @xmath66 mev .
for the combined suppression factor we assumed a mixture of 80% mesonic decay and 20% nonmesonic decay @xcite , i.e. @xmath67 this suppression factor is plotted as function of @xmath68 in the upper part of fig .
[ fig : gamma ] , where a residual value of @xmath69 , when both @xmath70 and @xmath60 vanish , was assumed . the coupled system of equations for nucleons and for the electromagnetic vector field @xmath71 , and for the mean fields @xmath20 and @xmath32 , eqs .
( [ eq : sigma],[eq : omega ] ) above , as well as the kg equation ( [ eq : kg1 ] ) for @xmath2 were solved self - consistently using an iterative procedure . obviously , the requirement of self - consistency is crucial for the proper evaluation of the dynamical effects of the @xmath0 on the nuclear core and vice versa .
we note that self - consistency is not imposed here on the final - state hadrons which only enter through their _ on - shell _
masses used in the phase - space suppression factors given above . for the main @xmath72 decay channel it is likely that the attraction provided by the pion within a dynamical calculation @xcite is largely cancelled by the nuclear repulsion deduced phenomenologically for @xmath62 hyperons @xcite .
the main objective of the present calculations of @xmath0-nucleus bound states was to establish correlations between various observables such as the @xmath0 binding energy , width and macroscopic nuclear properties .
in particular we aimed at covering a wide range of binding energies in order to evaluate widths of possible strongly bound @xmath0 states .
furthermore , in order to study effects of the nuclear polarization , we calculated rms radii and average densities of the nuclei involved and , in some cases , also single particle energies .
extensive calculations were made for @xmath3c and @xmath4o , nuclei that had been discussed earlier in the context of strongly bound @xmath0 states @xcite .
additionally , more restricted calculations were made for @xmath73ca and @xmath74pb . in a preliminary test we performed dynamical calculations for @xmath2 _ atomic _ @xmath75 states , which produced only negligibly small polarization effects , thus validating previous analyses of kaonic atom data .
the empirical values @xmath76 and @xmath77 , as found from a fit to kaonic atom data @xcite , were therefore used as a starting point for calculations .
a full dynamical calculation was then made for @xmath2 _ nuclear _ states starting from the @xmath22 imaginary potential obtained from the atomic fit , while entering dynamically in the iteration cycles the resulting nuclear density and the suppression factor @xmath78 as defined by eq.([eq : spf ] ) .
dynamical _ calculation nearly doubled , for the light nuclei here considered , the depth of the real part of the phenomenological _ static _
@xmath2-nucleus potential of ref .
@xcite which is of the ` deep ' variety , typically 150 - 200 mev deep in the static calculation . since there is no preferred way of varying the depth of the real @xmath2-nucleus potential in order to produce different values of binding energies , we used two methods for scanning over binding energies .
the first one , referred to below as the ` rmf ' method , was to scale down successively @xmath79 from its initial value @xmath76 and , once it reached zero , to scale down @xmath80 too from its initial value @xmath77 until the @xmath2 @xmath75 state became unbound .
as an alternative method we chose as a starting point values @xmath81 and @xmath82 obtained from fits to kaonic atom data where the rmf - based real potential was joined at large radii by a @xmath83 expression , using for @xmath24 the chiral @xmath1 amplitudes of ramos and oset @xcite .
this starting potential was of the ` shallow ' variety @xcite , about 55 mev deep in the static calculation .
it is gratifying that the replacement of the chiral @xmath83 expression within the nucleus by the rmf model did not change the resulting @xmath0-nuclear potential depth .
we then increased the potential depth by scaling up @xmath79 from its initial value @xmath81 , in order to achieve as deep binding as in the first set of calculations , while keeping @xmath80 constant at its initial value @xmath82 .
this second method will be referred to below as the ` chiral tail ' method .
note that in both methods ( @xmath84 ) the starting values ( @xmath85 ) correspond to potentials that produce in the dynamical calculation good fits to the @xmath2 atomic data , although re @xmath86 have vastly different depths .
the good fits to the atomic data are inevitably lost once the coupling constants ( @xmath79 in the procedure outlined above ) are allowed to vary in order to scan over a wide range of binding energies and the associated widths .
figure [ fig : gamma ] shows , in its middle and lower parts , calculated widths @xmath87 as function of the binding energy @xmath88 for @xmath75 states in @xmath89o and @xmath90c , respectively .
open squares and solid circles are for the l and nl versions of the rmf model , respectively , both calculated using the ` rmf ' method for scanning the binding energies .
the crosses are for rmf - l , using the ` chiral tail ' method for scanning the binding energies .
it is clearly seen that the widths of the @xmath2 nuclear state follow closely the dependence of the suppression factor on the binding energy and that , except for binding energies smaller than 50 mev , the dependence of the width on the binding energy follows , for a given nucleus , almost a universal curve .
we note that the widths calculated in the range @xmath91 mev assume values @xmath92 mev , which are considerably larger than what the suppression factor of the upper part of the figure would suggest .
this is largely related to the dynamical nature of the rmf calculation whereby the nuclear density is increased by the polarization effect of the @xmath2 , as shown in the next figures .
furthermore , replacing @xmath23 by @xmath61 for the density dependence of the non - pionic decay modes ( [ eq : conv2 ] ) is estimated to increase the above values of the width by 10 - 15 mev .
this estimate follows , again , from the increase of nuclear density with @xmath68 noticed above .
switching on the @xmath93 decay mode would increase further this estimate by 5 - 10 mev in the range @xmath94 mev .
we assert that the estimate @xmath95 mev in the range @xmath91 mev provides a reasonable lower bound on the width expected in any realistic calculation .
a more detailed systematics is defered to a subsequent regular report .
figures [ fig : nuclc ] and [ fig : nuclo ] exhibit various nuclear properties for @xmath75 states in @xmath90c and @xmath89o , respectively . the top and middle parts show the calculated average nuclear density @xmath96 and the nuclear rms radius , respectively , and the lower parts show the @xmath75 and @xmath97 neutron single - particle energies @xmath98 .
the differences between the linear and non - linear models reflect the different nuclear compressibility and the somewhat different nuclear sizes obtained in the two models .
again , for @xmath2 binding energy greater than 50 mev the results are independent of the way the binding energy is being scanned .
it is interesting to note that the increase in the nuclear rms radius of @xmath89o for large values of @xmath88 is the result of the reduced binding energy of the @xmath99 state , due to the increased spin - orbit term .
note also that as @xmath88 approaches zero we do _ not _ recover the values inherent in static calculations for the various nuclear entities because the coupling constants @xmath79 and @xmath80 , and the imaginary part of the potential , still assume nonzero values .
the substantial increase of @xmath100 , the decrease of the nuclear rms radius , and the decrease of the @xmath75 neutron single - particle energy , all point out to a significant polarization of the nuclear core by the @xmath75 @xmath2 .
finally , we note that in similar calculations for @xmath73ca and @xmath74pb the widths of the @xmath2 nuclear state _ vs. _ its binding energy turned out to be similar in shape to the corresponding results for @xmath3c and @xmath4o , but the effects on the average density and the rms radius are negligibly small , as expected for heavier nuclei .
table [ tab : tabl1 ] shows several examples of the excited - state spectrum of @xmath2-nuclear states in the core of @xmath4o .
the calculated widths of the excited states appear to follow the general trend of widths for @xmath75 states as shown in fig .
[ fig : gamma ] .
the polarization of the nucleus as judged by the value of its average density @xmath101 appears to diminish , the higher the @xmath2 state is , in agreement with fig .
[ fig : nuclo ] .
we note the fairly large spacing between neighboring states : the effective @xmath102 is of order 100 mev for the first spectrum , decreasing to 80 mev and to 70 mev in the second and third spectra , respectively , as the @xmath75 binding is made lower .
static calculations give smaller spacings .
kishimoto et al .
@xcite have very recently suggested evidence from the measured neutron spectrum in the @xmath103 reaction for a peak at @xmath104 mev which they interpreted as the @xmath97 @xmath0 state , probably since a hint for a peak at @xmath105 mev is also suggested by the same spectrum .
the results shown in table [ tab : tabl1 ] rule out such interpretation which would require @xmath106 mev , considerably less than our _ dynamical _ calculations produce . if the peak at @xmath104 mev were a @xmath97 state , one should have expected the @xmath75 state to be deeply bound , at @xmath107 mev where no signal has been observed . on the other hand , if this peak is a @xmath75 state , then the relatively shallow @xmath97 state would be expected too broad to be distinguished in the data .
binding energies and widths of deeply bound @xmath2 nuclear states in @xmath3c and @xmath4o were calculated with the aim of establishing values of widths that could be expected for binding energies in the range of 100 - 200 mev .
the method chosen was to couple the @xmath2 dynamically to the nucleus within the rmf approach , which is applicable throughout the periodic table , but which is disconnected from near - threshold @xmath1 phenomenology .
negligible polarization effects were found for _ atomic _ states , which confirms the optical - potential phenomenology of kaonic atoms as a valid starting point for the present study .
substantial polarization of the core nucleus was found in these light nuclei for deeply bound @xmath0 nuclear states .
almost universal dependence of antikaon widths on its binding energy was found , for a given nucleus , suggesting that the details of how the calculated binding energy is varied over the desired range of values is largely immaterial .
the widths are mostly determined by the phase - space suppression factors on top of the increase provided by the density of the compressed nuclei .
the present results already provide useful guidance for the interpretation of recent experimental results @xcite by placing a lower limit @xmath108 mev on @xmath0 states in @xmath4o bound in the range @xmath91 mev . for lighter nuclear targets such as @xmath11he , where the rmf approach becomes unreliable but where nuclear polarization effects are found larger using few - body calculational methods @xcite , we anticipate larger widths for @xmath0 deeply bound states , if such states do exist @xcite . this work was supported in part by the ga avcr grant iaa1048305 and by the israel science foundation grant 131/01 . .@xmath109 bound - state spectra in @xmath110 calculated for several rmf ( nl ) lagrangians specified by different coupling - constant ratios @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
the static average density for @xmath113 is @xmath114 @xmath115 . [
cols="<,<,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] | the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) model is applied to a system of nucleons and a @xmath0 meson , interacting via scalar and vector boson fields .
the model incorporates the standard rmf phenomenology for bound nucleons and , for the @xmath0 meson , it relates to low - energy @xmath1 and @xmath2 atom phenomenology .
deeply bound @xmath0 nuclear states are generated dynamically across the periodic table and are exhibited for @xmath3c and @xmath4o over a wide range of binding energies .
substantial polarization of the core nucleus is found for these light nuclei .
absorption modes are also included dynamically , considering explicitly both the resulting compressed nuclear density and the reduced phase space for @xmath0 absorption from deeply bound states .
the behavior of the calculated width as function of the @xmath0 binding energy is studied in order to explore limits on the possible existence of narrow @xmath0 nuclear states .
@xmath5 : 13.75.jz , 25.80.nv , 36.10.gv : @xmath0 nuclear interaction , @xmath0 nuclear deeply bound states corresponding author : avraham gal , [email protected] tel : + 972 2 658 4930 , fax : + 972 2 561 1519 |
recent nlo chiral model calculations of near - threshold @xmath7 dynamics , reproducing the siddharta measurement of atomic @xmath1 hydrogen @xmath8 level shift and width @xcite , have been discussed by hyodo @xcite .
the @xmath5-induced strong energy dependence of the scattering amplitudes @xmath9 arising in these calculations introduces a new feature into the analysis of @xmath1 atomic and nuclear systems as realized for @xmath1 atoms in the early 1970s @xcite .
thus , in nuclear matter , approximated for @xmath10 by the lab system , @xmath11 where @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 are binding energies , and where additional downward energy shift is generated by the momentum dependent term . unlike in the free - space @xmath0 cm system where @xmath15 , this term is found to contribute substantially in the lab system in realistic applications .
therefore , a reliable model extrapolation of @xmath0 amplitudes into subthreshold energies is mandatory in @xmath1 atom and nuclear applications . below
i give a brief overview of works on kaonic quasibound systems and kaonic atoms where subthreshold @xmath7 amplitudes were used in a physically correct way during the last two years .
it is shown how the energy dependence of these amplitudes , when translated into density dependence , leads to special patterns in kaonic systems .
finally , i focus attention to the recently proposed @xmath16 , @xmath17 @xmath18 dibaryon around the @xmath19 threshold @xcite and suggest how to search for it in experiments that look for the @xmath20 , @xmath21 @xmath22 dibaryon , better known as @xmath23 . in lieu of a concluding section , conclusions are marked in boldface throughout this review .
a prototype of such states is @xmath23 which stands for @xmath24 with isospin @xmath20 and spin - parity @xmath21 , dominated by @xmath25 and @xmath4 waves .
a summary of few - body calculations of this system is given in table [ tab : kpp ] updating older versions in recent international conferences @xcite .
.calculated @xmath23 binding energies @xmath26 & widths @xmath27 ( in mev ) . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ tab : dd ] several other fitted kaonic atom potentials are compared to the ihw - based ( 1@xmath28 + 2@xmath28 ) potential in table [ tab : dd ] .
the dd potential is a purely phenomenological potential of a form similar to eq .
( [ eq : phen ] ) and offers a benchmark , with @xmath29=103 , for what may be viewed as the ultimate density dependent fit to 65 data points across the periodic table ( it was denoted _
nominal _ in ref .
the entry for the nlo30 model is typical of results obtained in refs .
all three displayed fits produce deeply attractive real potentials , with depth in the range 180200 mev at the center of ni , and sizable absorptivities measured by imaginary potential depths in the range 7080 mev .
the r.m.s radii of @xmath30 are all smaller significantly than the point - proton distribution r.m.s .
radius @xmath31=3.69 fm in ni , reflecting the sizable contribution of the more compact re @xmath32 , whereas the r.m.s radii of @xmath33 are all slightly larger than @xmath31 , reflecting the compensating effect of i m @xmath32 on the rapidly decreasing with density i m @xmath34 .
the very significant improvement of 30 units in @xmath35 values by going from nlo30 to ihw is due to species where strong interaction observables were measured for more than a single kaonic atom level .
the width ( or equivalently ` yield ' ) of the upper level is normally dominated by i m @xmath34 , whereas the width of the lower level is dominated by i m @xmath32 . *
thus , more accurate determination of two level widths in the same kaonic atom are likely to pin down the density dependence of i m @xmath32 as it evolves with density and overtakes i m @xmath34 . *
the range of nuclear densities which prove to be effective for absorption from the lower level is exhibited on the l.h.s . of fig .
[ fig : gal4 ] for ni by plotting overlaps of the 4@xmath36 atomic radial wavefunction squared with the ni matter density @xmath37 for two choices of @xmath38 @xcite ; see also refs .
the figure demonstrates that , whereas this overlap for the relatively shallow , density - independent @xmath39 potential peaks at nuclear density of order 10% of @xmath40 , it peaks at about 60% of @xmath40 for the deeper , density - dependent dd potential and has a secondary peak well inside the nucleus ( indicating that a @xmath1 nuclear @xmath41 quasibound state exists ) .
the dd potential , clearly , exhibits sensitivity to the interior of the nucleus whereas the @xmath39 potential exhibits none . *
the superiority of deep to shallow @xmath38 can be checked by devising new measurements in a few carefully selected kaonic atoms @xcite . *
-ni atomic 4@xmath36 radial wavefunction @xmath42 squared with ni matter density @xmath37 in two models @xcite .
right : @xmath43 formation rates per @xmath44 from @xmath1 capture at rest spectra taken by finuda @xcite and as calculated @xcite normalized to the @xmath45li datum using in - medium density dependent @xmath46 branching rates that relate subthreshold energies to densities similarly to eq .
( [ eq : sc]).,title="fig : " ] -ni atomic 4@xmath36 radial wavefunction @xmath42 squared with ni matter density @xmath37 in two models @xcite .
right : @xmath43 formation rates per @xmath44 from @xmath1 capture at rest spectra taken by finuda @xcite and as calculated @xcite normalized to the @xmath45li datum using in - medium density dependent @xmath46 branching rates that relate subthreshold energies to densities similarly to eq .
( [ eq : sc]).,title="fig : " ] a reaction that could discriminate between deep and shallow @xmath1 nuclear potentials is the @xmath1 capture at rest formation of @xmath47 hypernuclear states localized in the nuclear interior .
the formation rates are expected to be sensitive to the extent to which the relevant @xmath1 atomic wavefunctions penetrate into the nucleus .
spectra and formation rates of several @xmath2-shell hypernuclei were reported recently by the finuda experiment @xcite and analyzed by ciepl et al . in ref .
a comparison between experiment and calculation is shown on the r.h.s .
[ fig : gal4 ] .
the calculations use in - medium subthreshold @xmath46 branching rates where the density dependence is related to the subthreshold energy according to eq .
( [ eq : sc ] ) . *
this comparison favors deep potentials to shallow ones . *
( left ) and i m @xmath48 ( right ) evaluated in nuclear matter within a chiral unitary approach @xcite for several values of the @xmath1 momentum @xmath49 .
the filled squares denote the density @xmath50 corresponding to @xmath49 , see text.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and i m @xmath48 ( right ) evaluated in nuclear matter within a chiral unitary approach @xcite for several values of the @xmath1 momentum @xmath49 .
the filled squares denote the density @xmath50 corresponding to @xmath49 , see text.,title="fig : " ] attempts to evaluate the absorptivity i m @xmath32 in addition to i m @xmath34 within a chiral unitary approach have been reported by sekihara et al .
their calculated nuclear - matter potentials , as a function of nuclear density @xmath50 , are shown in fig .
[ fig : gal5 ] for several values of the @xmath1 momentum @xmath49 between 0 to 250 mev / c .
the higher @xmath49 is , the deeper the @xmath51 related amplitudes bite into the subthreshold region , which weakens both 1@xmath28 and 2@xmath28 absorptivities , in agreement with the lessons gained in refs .
@xcite . to establish correspondence with finite nuclei
, these authors determined the local densities probed for the chosen values of @xmath49 by offsetting the @xmath1 kinetic energy @xmath52 against a prescribed potential @xmath53=@xmath5470 mev @xmath55 , resulting in values of density @xmath50 marked by filled squares in the figure .
the finite - nucleus absorptivities are then obtained by connecting smoothly these filled squares . comparing these calculated absorptivities at nuclear central density @xmath56 with the ihw - based absorptivities shown for ni in the lower r.h.s . of fig .
[ fig : gal3 ] , one observes that i m @xmath34 is overestimated by over a factor of two whereas i m @xmath32 is underestimated by over a factor of three . as a consequence ,
the ratio of i m @xmath32/im @xmath34 plotted in fig .
17 of sekihara et al .
@xcite underestimates significantly the relative strength of @xmath1 multinucleon absorption ( occurring at @xmath57 ) as compared to indications from old emulsion and bubble - chamber work @xcite .
( left ) and widths @xmath58 ( right ) of @xmath1 quasibound states in selected nuclei calculated self consistently by gazda and mare @xcite using static rmf densities and nlo30 in - medium @xmath51 subthreshold amplitudes , but without any @xmath32 contribution.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and widths @xmath58 ( right ) of @xmath1 quasibound states in selected nuclei calculated self consistently by gazda and mare @xcite using static rmf densities and nlo30 in - medium @xmath51 subthreshold amplitudes , but without any @xmath32 contribution.,title="fig : " ] the state of the art in @xmath1 quasibound states calculations in nuclear systems beyond four - body systems has been reviewed recently , and also in these proceedings , by ji mare @xcite .
for the sake of completeness , i show in fig .
[ fig : gal6 ] results borrowed from his presentation summarizing self consistent calculations of @xmath1 quasibound states in nuclei ranging from @xmath59he to @xmath60pb .
a prominent feature resulting from the imposition of self consistency on these calculations is the hierarchy of widths calculated within a given nucleus . with energy independent potentials
one expects the width to be maximal for the lowest , most localized @xmath61 states , and to monotonically decrease for excited states which are less localized within the core nucleus .
the reverse is observed on the r.h.s . of the figure .
this arises by requiring self consistency : the more excited a @xmath1 quasibound state is , the lower nuclear density it feels , and a smaller downward shift into subthreshold energies is implied by the @xmath62 dependence .
since i m @xmath34 decreases strongly below threshold , this means that its contribution gets larger , the higher in energy the excited quasibound state is . as stressed by gazda and mare @xcite ,
* the large widths coupled with smaller excitation energy spacings should make it difficult to identify experimentally such @xmath1 quasibound states in a unique way .
additional width contributions from i m @xmath32 will only compound this difficulty . *
the @xmath20 , @xmath21 @xmath23 quasibound state discussed in sect .
[ sec : few ] represents a close realization of a @xmath65 quasibound @xmath66 dibaryon @xcite . similarly , one could ask whether @xmath67 dibaryon quasibound states are realized and , if so , for which quantum numbers .
a close realization of a @xmath67 quasibound @xmath68 dibaryon in terms of @xmath16 , @xmath17 @xmath69 quasibound state @xmath70 was proposed a few years ago and established more solidly in the recent work of ref .
@xcite within a relativistic three - body faddeev calculation some 1020 mev below the @xmath71 threshold .
the leading two - body attractive channels in this three - body system are the @xmath2-wave @xmath72 and @xmath73 channels dominated by the @xmath74 and @xmath3 resonances , respectively , and to a lesser extent the @xmath75 @xmath76 @xmath4-wave channel .
it was found that admixing a @xmath77 channel to the @xmath69 three - body channels affects little this dibaryon quasibound state since for a @xmath2-wave @xmath78 meson it requires a pauli forbidden @xmath25 , @xmath79 combination for the leading @xmath80 @xmath4-wave configuration .
* this dibaryon candidate @xmath70 may be looked for in experiments similar to those being run at gsi @xcite and j - parc @xcite which aim at observing the associated production of @xmath23 and its subsequent decay to a @xmath81 pair . * thus , at gsi one could look for @xmath82 where the decay @xmath83 offers a unique decay channel , and at j - parc look for @xmath84 where again these decay channels offer unique channels distinctly from those looked for in @xmath23 searches .
special thanks are due to nir barnea , ale ciepl , eli friedman , humberto garcilazo , daniel gazda and ji mare , with whom i have collaborated on topics surveyed here , and to wolfram weise for many ongoing stimulating discussions and kind hospitality at tum in recent years . a. gal , int . j. mod
e19 * ( 2010 ) 2301 [ snp2008 ] ; a. gal , chin . phys . *
c34 * ( 2010 ) 1169 [ qnp2009 ] ; w. weise , nucl
. phys . * a835 * ( 2010 ) 51 [ hyp2009 ] ; t. hyodo , few - body systems * 54 * ( 2013 ) 931 [ fb2012 ] . | recent studies of kaonic atoms , few - body kaonic quasibound states and kaonic nuclei are reviewed , with emphasis on implementing the subthreshold energy dependence of the @xmath0 interaction in chiral interaction models that are consistent with the siddharta @xmath1 hydrogen data .
remarks are made on the possible role of the @xmath2-wave @xmath3 resonance with respect to that of the @xmath4-wave @xmath5 resonance in searches for strangeness @xmath6 dibaryons .
kaon - baryon interactions , few - body systems , mesic nuclei , mesonic atoms |
the problem of the transcritical flow of a bec through the penetrable barriers has been under recent active investigations @xcite .
the damping processes for the superfluid flow moving through the barrier are of a fundamental interest . in multidimensional case above some critical velocity of the obstacle motion the damping accompanied by the radiation emission @xcite is observed .
thus in the region when the motion is still superfluid , the velocity is bounded above .
the damping is associated with the landau type damping and related to the emission of the elementary excitations .
landau damping can be described in the framework of the mean field theory and is not associated with thermalization processes @xcite .
the critical velocity value at which the damping is observed , differs essentially from the values predicted by the landau theory .
as it was shown firstly by feynman @xcite , the reason is in the nonlinearity of the system . in the case of a quasi 1d bose - einstein condensate flow ,
when passing through a penetrable barrier , some interval of velocities @xmath2 exists , where trains of dark solitons are generated , that leads to deviation from predictions based on the matching with the spectrum of elementary linear excitations @xcite.in addition in this range of velocities , generation of dispersive shock waves occurs .
experimental proof of the existence of the velocities interval was given in the work @xcite .
hakim @xcite has indicated that for supersonic velocities ( including ones above supercritical velocity @xmath3 ) some radiation is still nonzero and its amplitude rapidly decreases at the ratio of the potential variation length to the gpe coherence length .
the amplitude of the wake can be characterized by the fourier transform of the obstacle potential @xcite .
thus , wide and smooth potentials can be considered as radiationless at velocities above _
supercritical_. seemingly in one dimensional case only stable dark solitons can exist .
peculiarity of the one dimension is in the fact that generation of the solitons is possible till some _ supercritical _ velocity , @xmath3 . above this velocity
the emission is strongly damped and the quasi - superfuidity is restored .
the radiation exists , but exponentially small - decay rate is proportional to @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the healing length of the order of the dark soliton width . in this work
we consider the phenomena occurring in the flow of a quasi 1d bec past _ a nonlinear _ barrier which is a localized space inhomogeneity of the the nonlinearity coefficient in the gross - pitaevskii equation .
such a type of barriers can be formed by some area of bec where the effective value of the atomic scattering length is varied in _
the space_. it can be achieved both by the feshbach resonance techniques @xcite , and by the local variation of the transverse frequency of the trap potential . in the former case , varying external magnetic field in space near the resonance , one can vary the value of the atomic scattering length @xmath6 .
another way is to use optically induced feshbach resonances @xcite . in this case
the variation can be achieved by local change in the intensity of a laser field .
variation of @xmath6 in a half space recently has been suggested to generate vortices in bec as a nonlinear piston method @xcite .
the present paper is motivated by the works @xcite where flow of a bec past an obstacle in one dimension was investigated .
we consider two cases , wide obstacle potential and short range one .
let us consider a nonlinear penetrable barrier moving through the elongated bec .
a quasi one dimensional bec can be described by the gross - pitaevsky ( gp ) equation with standard dimensionless variables @xmath7 where @xmath8 @xmath6 is the atomic scattering length , @xmath9 is the transverse frequency of the trap , @xmath10 , @xmath11 is the background value of the scattering length @xmath6 . for the further study of the flow problem it is useful to pass to the reference frame moving with the barrier @xmath12 .
so we come to the equation @xmath13 the scattering length can be manipulated with a laser field tuned near a photo association transition , e.g. , close to the resonance of one of the bound @xmath14 levels of the excited molecules .
virtual radiative transitions of a pair of interacting atoms to this level can change the value and even reverse the sign of the scattering length @xcite .
recently spatial modulations of the atomic scattering length by the optical feshbach resonance method was realized experimentally in bec @xcite .
such approach implies some spontaneous emission loss which is inherent in the optical feshbach resonance technique .
here we assume that such dissipative effects can be ignored , since they become possible if one uses laser fields of sufficiently high intensity detuned from the resonance .
thus the repulsive nonlinear barrier can be formed by an focused external laser beam with the parameters lying near the optically induced feshbach resonance .
we analyze this case following the method developed in @xcite for the linear barrier case .
let us pass to the hydrodynamical form for the gp equation ( [ eq1 ] ) .
it can be obtained by the following transformation @xmath15 substituting it into ( [ eq1 ] ) and introducing @xmath16 we obtain the system @xmath17 for a wide smooth obstacle potential we can neglect the terms in the bracket in the second equation that corresponds to the hydrodynamical approximation . omitting also primes , for stationary solutions we can put @xmath18 and @xmath19 , and obtain the following system of equations @xmath20 @xmath21 with the boundary conditions @xmath22 integrating over @xmath23 we find @xmath24 @xmath25 eliminating the function @xmath26 from these equations , we get @xmath27\equiv f(u ) .
\label{fu}\ ] ] since we consider repulsive obstacle potential @xmath28 we have the condition @xmath29 .
maximum of @xmath30 is realized at @xmath31 .
thus the maximum of the function @xmath30 is @xmath32 = \mu(v ) = \frac{1}{v}\sqrt{\left(\frac{v^2 + 2}{3}\right)^{3 } } - 1 .
\label{eqmaxfu}\ ] ] stationary solution @xmath33 is obtained by solving the equation ( [ fu ] ) with respect to @xmath34 .
this equation has a real solution defined for all @xmath23 provided that @xmath35 \leq \max[f(u ) ] , \label{maxvmaxfu}\ ] ] i.e. the range of values of @xmath36 , which is @xmath37 $ ] , lies within the range of values of the function @xmath30 @xcite .
( see eq.([eqmaxfu ] ) ) versus @xmath23 . for given obstacle potential maximum @xmath38 , critical values of the velocity @xmath39 , @xmath40,width=302 ] .
[ maxfu ] maximum of the function @xmath30 versus the obstacle velocity @xmath41 of bec is presented in fig .
[ maxfu ] . as seen for any value of @xmath42 two critical values of the velocity exist , @xmath43 , determined by equation @xmath44 . in transcritical regime , in the interval @xmath45 , the condition of the stationary flow ( [ maxvmaxfu ] ) does not hold . out of this region , in subcritical ( @xmath46 ) and supercritical ( @xmath47 )
regimes the radiation phenomena are negligible and the motion of the system can be considered as superfluid . analyzing expression ( [ eqmaxfu ] ) and
[ maxfu ] it should be noted that unlike the case of a wide linear barrier , considered in @xcite , the velocity @xmath48 is not vanish and there always exists an interval @xmath49 where the flow is superfluid .
eq.([fu ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath50 which is a cubic equation with respect to @xmath33 . solving it we obtain the following solutions for @xmath33 satisfying the boundary conditions @xmath51 where @xmath52 .
the barrier velocities are equal to @xmath53 and @xmath54 for lower and upper lines respectively.,width=302 ] spatial profiles of the local velocity @xmath34 for subcritical @xmath55 ( @xmath46 ) and supercritical @xmath56 ( @xmath47 ) regimes are depicted in fig . [ ux ] .
the nl obstacle potential is taken in the form @xmath57 with its maximum value @xmath38 . and ( b ) supercritical regime , @xmath56 through a nonlinear repulsive potential barrier @xmath58 with @xmath59 .
the initial wave packet and distribution of the bec local velocities @xmath33 are taken in the form determined by formulas ( [ sol_u- ] ) , ( [ sol_u+ ] ) and eq .
( [ pu1]).,width=302 ] and ( b ) supercritical regime , @xmath56 through a nonlinear repulsive potential barrier @xmath58 with @xmath59 .
the initial wave packet and distribution of the bec local velocities @xmath33 are taken in the form determined by formulas ( [ sol_u- ] ) , ( [ sol_u+ ] ) and eq .
( [ pu1]).,width=302 ] fig .
[ repdef ] depicts time evolution of a bec flow through a repulsive non - linear potential @xmath60 with @xmath59 in ( a ) subcritical @xmath61 and ( b ) supercritical @xmath62 regimes , respectively .
initial form of the condensate density @xmath63 is determined by eq.([pu1 ] ) as @xmath64 , where initial distribution of local velocities @xmath33 is given by eqs .
( [ sol_u- ] ) , ( [ sol_u+ ] ) .
one can see that in these regimes the flow through the barrier is steady .
existence of small amplitude waves , spreading from the hump in the beginning is a result of neglecting small terms in the course of derivation of eqs.([difpu1 ] ) and ( [ difpu2 ] ) . in fig .
[ repdef]b one can see that in supercritical regime the solution at the center has the hump form .
the numerical simulations show stability of this kind of steady flows .
( @xmath2 ) .
the nl barrier is taken in the form of @xmath58 with @xmath59 . during the time period from @xmath65 to @xmath66 (
that is not presented in the figure ) the value of @xmath67 is adiabatically being increased from @xmath68 to @xmath69 .
further evolution is given at @xmath59.,width=302 ] in order to carry out numerical simulations of the behavior of a bec at transcritical velocities ( @xmath70 ) , we can not use eqs .
( [ sol_u- ] ) , ( [ sol_u+ ] ) as an initial wave packets , because they have been derived for a steady flow . in numerical simulations
it is more convenient to increase adiabatically the strength of nl potential @xmath67 . in fig .
[ movrepdef ] we show time evolution of bec flow through a nl potential barrier in the transcritical regime with @xmath71 @xmath72 .
the nl potential is taken in the form @xmath60 .
@xmath67 is increasing from @xmath68 to @xmath69 in the time interval @xmath73 and then is kept constant .
one can see that in the transcritical regime the flow becomes unsteady and a train of dark solitons emerges from the nl barrier at the barrier potential strength @xmath59 . in this section
we follow the approach used in the work @xcite .
let us suppose the condensate to have a chemical potential @xmath74 . then in the frame of the moving obstacle with the velocity @xmath41 equation ( [ eq1 ] ) takes the form @xmath75 with uniform boundary conditions @xmath76 at @xmath77 .
looking for time independent solution in the form @xmath78 we get equations for amplitude @xmath79 and phase @xmath80 @xmath81 in the case of the @xmath1 function barrier potential ( a sharp jump in the nonlinearity ) @xmath82 the solution @xmath79 has the form @xmath83 } \
\mbox{at } \ x \lessgtr 0 , \label{r2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting obtained r(x ) into eq .
( [ eqphi ] ) and solving it we obtain phase @xmath80 as @xmath84 where unknown parameter @xmath85 depending on the potential strength @xmath86 is determined from the relation @xmath87 obtained from matching condition for derivatives @xmath88 at @xmath89 @xmath90 fig .
[ gamma ] depicts a typical relation between the potential strength @xmath86 and parameter @xmath85 at @xmath91 . as seen for given strength @xmath86
there are two values of the parameter @xmath85 ( or not a single ) corresponding to a pair of steady solutions .
one of the solutions ( @xmath92 ) is unstable and another ( @xmath93 ) is stable @xcite .
time evolution of stable and unstable steady solutions corresponding to @xmath94 and @xmath95 are shown in fig .
[ twosol ] .
and @xmath96 corresponding relatively to ( a ) stable and ( b ) unstable bec flows past a nonlinear repulsive delta potential barrier in subcritical regime .
the other parameters @xmath91 and @xmath97 . for this case @xmath98.,width=302 ] and @xmath96 corresponding relatively to ( a ) stable and ( b ) unstable bec flows past a nonlinear repulsive delta potential barrier in subcritical regime . the other parameters @xmath91 and @xmath97 . for this case @xmath98.,width=302 ] as seen the unstable solution decays into a gray soliton moving upstream with the velocity less than @xmath41 and a stable solution localized at the barrier position .
the decay is accompanied by the radiation emitted downstream in front of the barrier . unlike the case of a wide barrier , in the case of the @xmath1 function nonlinear barrier potential ,
localized steady states exist only at @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the sound velocity . in our case @xmath101 .
critical velocity @xmath102 is determined by the potential strength @xmath86 @xmath103 where @xmath104 . in order to cover a wide range of velocities
we have carried out numerical simulations of the flow of a bec through the delta potential nonlinear barrier moving with small acceleration beginning from zero velocity .
[ movenl ] depicts the time evolution of a bec flow when the acceleration @xmath105 .
the barrier potential strength @xmath97 .
the initial wave packet is taken in the form of eq .
( [ r2 ] ) . . the barrier potential strength @xmath97 , initial velocity of the flow @xmath106 . the initial wave packet is taken in the form eq .
( [ r2]).,width=302 ] time interval @xmath107 ( @xmath108 ) corresponds to a superfluid flow . at tmes
@xmath109 ( @xmath110 ) one can observe generation of grey solitons chain . in time
interval @xmath111 ( @xmath112 ) corresponding to transcritical flow of a bec at supersonic velocity one can observe qualitatively the same wave pattern obtained in the work @xcite where a dispersive shock propagates upstream with generation of soliton - like waves propagating downstream .
in conclusion , we studied steady flow in a defocusing quasi 1d bec moving through a nonlinear _ repulsive _ barrier .
such a kind of barriers can be formed by variation of the atomic scattering length of bec in _
space_. for the case of a wide nonlinear barrier we have found critical velocities of steady flows . within the interval of velocities @xmath2 , in the transcritical regime we observed generation of a slow moving train of dark solitons . at velocities above supercritical the train disappears . at the same time in this regime
one can observe formation of a hump localized at the place of _ the barrier_. for the case of a @xmath1 function nonlinear barrier potential the dependence of the steady solution parameters and a critical velocity on the potential strength @xmath86 was found in analytical form . as numerical simulations show , in subcritical regime @xmath113 an unstable solution decays into a gray soliton moving upstream and a stable solution localized at the barrier position .
the decay is accompanied by a dispersive shock wavepropagating downstream in front of the barrier .
the dynamics of flows past through a linear and nonlinear barriers are qualitatively similar except the following . in the case of a wide _ linear _
barrier , the superfluidity is broken at any small velocities if the barrier potential strength greater than some threshold value ( see fig . 2 in @xcite ) .
for a wide _ nonlinear _ barrier an interval of velocities @xmath49 _ always _ exists , where the flow is superfluid regardless of the barrier potential strength .
when using the optically induced feshbach resonance technique to generate a repulsive nonlinear barrier by focused laser beam , one should in general take into account the losses , induced by spontaneous emission of atoms .
phenomenologically it can be described by adding a nonlinear loss term @xmath114 in the gp equation.atom feeding can be described by linear gain term @xmath115 .
this case requires a separate investigation .
it should be noted that this problem relates to one considered in the recent work @xcite , where the flow of polariton condensate @xcite past a linear barrier was studied taking into account linear amplification and nonlinear damping . | the problem of a quasi 1d _ repulsive _ bec flow past through a nonlinear barrier is investigated .
two types of nonlinear barriers are considered , wide and short range ones .
steady state solutions for the bec moving through a wide repulsive barrier and critical velocities have been found using hydrodynamical approach to the 1d gross - pitaevskii equation .
it is shown that in contrast to the linear barrier case , for a wide _ nonlinear _ barrier an interval of velocities @xmath0 _ always _ exists , where the flow is superfluid regardless of the barrier potential strength .
for the case of the @xmath1 function - like barrier , below a critical velocity two steady solutions exist , stable and unstable one .
an unstable solution is shown to decay into a gray soliton moving upstream and a stable solution .
the decay is accompanied by a dispersive shock wave propagating downstream in front of the barrier . |
young planets can experience strong gravitational interactions with surrounding gas residing in a protoplanetary disk @xcite .
these interactions can lead to structural changes in a disk through the launching of waves that can result in shocks and gap formation .
they can also lead to changes in the orbital properties of the planet , resulting in their radial migration .
such phenomena are caused by the resonant forcing of the gas by the planet .
the two types of resonances that describe this interaction , the lindblad and corotational , have been extensively explored .
both of these resonances involve planar motions and will occur in a two - dimensional disk in which the vertical dynamical effects ( perpendicular to the disk orbital plane ) are ignored . for planets on circular orbits ,
the corotation resonance lies at the orbit of the planet .
the gas response at the corotation resonance is of the form of a trapped radially evanescent wave with a radial drop - off on a scale of order the disk thickness @xmath1 .
the other form of resonance , the lindblad resonance , occurs where a forcing frequency component due to the planet matches the epicyclic frequency of the gas .
there are infinitely many of these resonances . in the absence of disk self - gravity
, these resonances result in the launching of acoustic waves that transport energy and angular momentum away from the planet .
the strongest lindblad resonances lie close to the planet , but can not occur closer than @xmath2 radially from the orbit of the planet due to pressure effects .
when the disk vertical structure is taken into account , a richer set of waves can be excited at lindblad resonances @xcite .
these waves are of the form of r modes ( rotation - dominated ) , g modes ( vertical buoyancy - dominated ) , p modes ( pressure - dominated ) , and f modes ( fundamental ) . for small or moderate azimuthal wavenumbers ( @xmath3 ) ,
the lindblad response is dominated by an f mode , while the r - modes and g - modes are less strongly excited . in a vertically isothermal disk that undergoes adiabatic perturbations , as will be considered in this paper , the fundamental mode consists of two - dimensional planar motions . by means of 3d shearing box simulations , zhu et al ( 2012 ) have recently shown that a new form of planet - disk interaction can occur due to buoyancy resonances . for
this type of resonance , the disk vertical motions play a critical role .
at such a resonance , a planet forcing frequency component matches the free oscillation frequency of a vertically displaced fluid element that behaves adiabatically . like the lindblad case , there are infinitely many such resonances , one for each azimuthal wavenumber @xmath4 .
but since the free vertical oscillation frequency varies with height above the disk midplane , these resonances do not occur at particular radii as in the lindblad case . instead they lie along tilted planes .
these resonances radially extend much closer to the planet than lindblad resonances .
the one - sided ( inside or outside corotation ) torque that results from the buoyancy resonances was found to be comparable to , but smaller than , the usual lindblad torque .
the goal of this paper is to explore the analytic properties of buoyancy resonances .
the analytic approach provides a verification of the existence of this resonance and insight into its structure .
we consider the linear response of an isothermal disk that undergoes adiabatic perturbations to a simplified form of forcing . as in zhu et al ( 2012 ) , we consider the gas to reside in a shearing box , as described in section [ beq ] .
we consider waves for which the azimuthal wavenumber is of order or greater than @xmath5 .
these waves play an important role in determining the total torque caused by a planet . to make analytic progress , we consider forcing that is purely azimuthal and is independent of radius and height in the disk . in section [ saf ]
, we analyze a disk with constant vertical gravity and find separable solutions for the linear disk response .
we obtain analytic expressions for the structure of the resonance and the torque distribution .
we then consider in section [ safvg ] the case of variable vertical gravity and determine the linear response numerically by means of a fourier method in radius .
we then show that the torque density in this case agrees well with the torque density obtained by an obvious extension of the torque density expression in the constant gravity case .
section [ disc ] contains a discussion and section [ sum ] contains the summary .
we consider gas in a 3d shearing box described by cartesian coordinates @xmath6 in a frame that corotates with the disk at some radius @xmath7 from the central star and generalize the 2d shearing sheet model ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the radial coordinate @xmath8 is defined such that @xmath9 occurs at radius @xmath7 , and vertical coordinate @xmath10 is defined such that @xmath11 lies at the disk midplane .
the disk has a characteristic thickness @xmath12 .
the unperturbed disk is taken to be isothermal with equation of state @xmath13 with isothermal sound speed @xmath14 . the local angular speed of the disk is @xmath15 and the unperturbed disk velocity in the corotating frame is @xmath16 , with constant shear rate @xmath17 .
we consider the effects of a single azimuthal fourier component with azimuthal wavenumber @xmath18 of the gravitational potential @xmath19 we take @xmath20 to be real and thereby determine the phasing of @xmath21 .
we determine the @xmath22 fourier components of velocity @xmath23 , density perturbation @xmath24 , and pressure perturbation @xmath25 as functions of @xmath8 and @xmath10 that describe the response to this potential .
the linearized steady state shearing box equations for the @xmath26 and @xmath10 motion , mass conservation , and heat for an adiabatic gas are respectively @xmath27 where @xmath28 is an oort constant , @xmath29 is the vertical disk gravity that can generally be a function of @xmath10 , and @xmath30 is the vertical buoyancy frequency for gas that can also generally be a function of @xmath10 @xmath31 with adiabatic index @xmath32 .
combining equation ( [ eq : w ] ) for vertical motion with the heat equation ( [ eq : s ] ) , we have that the density perturbation is given by @xmath33 the denominator on the right - hand side of equation ( [ rho ] ) vanishes at a buoyancy resonance where the buoyancy frequency matches the forcing frequency @xmath34 the upper ( lower ) sign is appropriate for an inner ( outer ) buoyancy resonance , since @xmath35 is negative .
equation ( [ rho ] ) then contains possible singularities at buoyancy resonances .
we describe here the boundary conditions that we generally apply .
they are similar to those used in @xcite . for an inner ( outer ) buoyancy resonance , we take the outer ( inner ) @xmath8 boundary to be located at the corotation radius defined by @xmath36 near the @xmath9 boundary , quantities are assumed to be point symmetric with respect to @xmath37 .
this condition means that @xmath38 = re[p(-x , z ) \exp{(-i k_y y ) } ] \label{bcx}\ ] ] near @xmath9 . in its application to the boundary at @xmath9 , this relation implies @xmath39 a further application of equation ( [ bcx ] ) implies that @xmath40 .
these conditions can be compactly written as @xmath41 for an inner ( outer ) buoyancy resonance , following zhu et al ( 2012 ) we take the inner ( outer ) @xmath8 boundary condition to be that the radial velocity perturbations vanish , @xmath42 . by combining equations ( [ eq : u ] ) and ( [ eq : v ] )
, we obtain a condition on the pressure perturbation at this boundary that @xmath43 periodic boundary conditions are applied in the @xmath22 direction .
this condition is automatically handled by our use of fourier components in @xmath22 . in the @xmath10 direction , we apply reflection boundary conditions at the disk midplane .
that is , @xmath44 this boundary condition implies that there is no mass flux through the disk midplane from above or below .
far from the disk midplane ( large @xmath45 ) , the disk pressure perturbations are assumed to vanish , @xmath46 . to determine the torque due to a buoyancy resonance , we determine @xmath24 near @xmath47 .
we assume , as we later show , that the numerator on the right - hand side of equation ( [ rho ] ) does not vanish at a buoyancy resonance .
we expand that equation about @xmath48 and obtain to lowest order that @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the @xmath8 position relative to the resonance . to treat the singular behavior of @xmath24 at @xmath51
, we follow the standard procedure of extending @xmath52 to the complex plane and replacing @xmath52 by @xmath53 with small damping length @xmath54 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
we then have that @xmath55 . \label{rhoc}\ ] ] the second term in the brackets represents the `` resonant '' term that behaves as a dirac delta function , since @xmath56 for small @xmath54 .
the torque density in @xmath10 inside / outside corotation on the gas due to a particular @xmath22 fourier component of the perturbing potential @xmath57 is defined by @xmath58 \
, re[\partial_y \psi(x , y , z ) ] \ , dx\ , dy\\ & = & -\pi r^2 k_y \int_{x_{\rm i}}^{x_{\rm o } } im(\rho ) \phi \ , dx , \label{t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used the fact that @xmath59 is a real quantity in equation ( [ eq : phi ] ) .
the @xmath8 integration limits apply either inside or outside corotation where @xmath60 is the @xmath8 inner boundary location and @xmath61 is the @xmath8 outer boundary location . for the case inside ( outside ) corotation , @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) .
we then obtain @xmath64 where all @xmath8-dependent quantities are evaluated at the resonance where @xmath48 . to evaluate the torque , we determine the pressure perturbation @xmath65 near the resonance .
in a standard thin disk , the buoyancy frequency @xmath30 varies nearly linearly with @xmath10 , due to the change in vertical gravity with @xmath10 ( see equation ( [ eq : n ] ) ) . the resonance condition ( [ xres ] )
is then satisfied along tilted planes .
we simplify the geometry of the resonances by applying an approximate model for the vertical gravity . above ( below ) the disk midplane
, the vertical gravity is taken to be constant and downward ( upward ) . in the analysis
below , we consider the dynamics above the disk midplane where the downward vertical gravity is denoted by the constant @xmath66 .
the resonance location simplifies to a vertical plane described by a particular value of @xmath8 for each @xmath4 .
the constant vertical gravity model permits the dynamical equations to be separable in space and facilitates the development of an analytic model .
vertical hydrostatic balance for constant gravity implies that the unperturbed disk satisfies @xmath67 where @xmath68 with constants @xmath29 , @xmath1 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 we also take @xmath71 to make analytic progress , we adopt a simple potential of the form ( [ eq : phi ] ) .
we take the perturbing potential to be of the form @xmath72 where @xmath59 on the right - hand side is a real constant .
this potential gives rise to forcing that is purely azimuthal and is constant in @xmath8 and @xmath10 . to investigate the nature of this simplification
, we carried out some nonlinear numerical simulations using the athena code .
the simulations were of isothermal disks which are subject to various vertical gravities and undergo adiabatic perturbations caused by various potentials .
we define dimensionless wavenumber and coordinates as @xmath73 , @xmath74 ( a different @xmath75 than defined in section [ ns ] ) , @xmath76 , and @xmath77 .
we express the perturbing potential in terms of the modified bessel function @xmath78 .
these simulations covered cases with + ( a ) constant vertical gravity @xmath29 and potential given by equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) , so that @xmath79 , + ( b ) variable vertical gravity and potential given by @xmath80 so that @xmath81 , and + ( c ) variable vertical gravity and potential given by @xmath82 so that @xmath83 ) . + the disk structure and the potential perturbation become more realistic in going from case ( a ) to ( c ) .
constant @xmath84 is chosen as 5.8@xmath8510@xmath86 . for case ( c ) , this is equivalent to the @xmath87 fourier component of the potential of a planet with mass @xmath88 or 0.76 @xmath89 with @xmath90 and @xmath91 .
this value is sufficiently small that there is no gap opening . in cases ( b ) and
( c ) , a small smoothing length 5@xmath8510@xmath92 has been used .
a small isotropic viscosity has been used to resolve the resonance .
the viscosity is @xmath93 ( or equivalently @xmath94 ) for case ( a ) , while @xmath95 ( or equivalently @xmath96 ) for cases ( b ) and ( c ) , respectively .
the simulated gas lies above the disk midplane @xmath97 and outside corotation @xmath98 .
the simulation setup was similar to that described in zhu et al ( 2012 ) .
for case ( a ) , we used 32 vertical grid points per scale height that gives a total torque that is nearly independent of the resolution ( the error is within 5% ) .
however , the simulation does not resolve the vertical torque structure to very high accuracy .
the peak of the torque density as a function of height @xmath10 for the @xmath99 mode is at @xmath100 . for constant vertical gravity , we find that this resolution corresponds to about 6 vertical grid points near the peak of the torque density .
the boundary conditions follow those described in section [ bc ] .
the simulation domain and resolution ( in @xmath101 order ) for these three simulations are respectively : ( a ) @xmath102 with the resolution of @xmath103 , ( b ) @xmath102 with the resolution of @xmath104 , and ( c ) @xmath105 with the resolution of @xmath106 . in these simulations , we take @xmath107 and @xmath108 . the simulations were conducted in dimensionless units with the dimensionless gas density @xmath109 expressed in units of the unperturbed midplane density @xmath110 , the dimensionless coordinates expressed in units of length @xmath1 , and dimensionless time in units of @xmath111 . accordingly , the dimensionless potential used in the simulations is @xmath112 . from the simulation results , we determine the torque per length in the @xmath22 direction that we multiply by @xmath113 to obtain the torque density @xmath114 .
we expect the torque to scale with @xmath115 , since both the density perturbation and @xmath22 gravitational force depend linearly on @xmath59 . in fig .
[ fig : tdens ] , we plot the dimensionless torque density that is scaled by @xmath116 and is given by @xmath117 where @xmath118 are the dimensionless locations of the @xmath22-boundaries of the simulations and @xmath119 is the simulated disk density with both expressed in dimensionless units .
this torque density is converted to the dimensional torque density @xmath114 by multiplying by @xmath120 .
[ fig : tdens ] provides some motivation for the gravity and potential simplifications . in all three cases ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) , plotted in the respective panels after 7 orbits , the torque is confined to a narrow region centered on the buoyancy resonance .
when scaled by @xmath121 , the torque densities have somewhat similar structures .
the vertical orientation of the resonance in the case of constant gravity permits an analysis through separation of variables .
we concentrate on the case that @xmath4 is large , @xmath122 .
we are interested in this regime because the total torque is dominated by contributions that occur at large @xmath4 .
the gas at resonance has sonic or subsonic unperturbed gas speeds at the resonance . under such conditions ,
we expect the gas to respond approximately hydrostatically in the @xmath22 direction , in order to prevent the development of rapid horizontal velocities @xmath123 and @xmath124 at large @xmath4 ( see equation ( [ eq : v ] ) ) . that is
, @xmath125 and @xmath25 is a real function ( in phase with real quantity @xmath59 ) .
we show that @xmath126hydrostatic equation ( [ ph ] ) is well satisfied for @xmath127 in appendix a. the torque density integral in equation ( [ ti ] ) can then be readily evaluated .
we use equation ( [ ph ] ) to determine that @xmath128 or @xmath129 notice that the torque density is independent of the resonance width @xmath54 and azimuthal wavenumber @xmath4 , provided that @xmath4 is large .
the torque density derivation assumed that the gas behaves hydrostatically in the azimuthal direction , equation ( [ ph ] ) .
as discussed in appendix b , this assumption breaks down in a region whose thickness is of order @xmath130 about the disk midplane , where the effects of the disk midplane boundary condition , equation ( [ zbc ] ) , are important .
this boundary condition requires the torque density @xmath131 to vanish at the disk midplane .
the resulting torque is given by equation ( [ dtdz2 ] ) of appendix b. in appendix a , we obtain a separable equation for the dimensionless pressure perturbation @xmath132 off the midplane ( @xmath133 , away from the influence of the @xmath11 boundary ) , with @xmath134 ( a different @xmath75 than defined in section [ tdcg ] ) and @xmath77 .
we solve for pressure @xmath135 given by equation ( [ peq1 ] ) numerically as a two point boundary value problem with the @xmath8 boundary conditions that are described in section [ bc ] . to determine this solution
, we need to specify how to treat the singular @xmath136 term in the numerical integration across the resonance . following the procedure described in section [ beq ]
, we resolve the singularity by replacing @xmath136 by @xmath137 where @xmath138 is a dimensionless length scale defined as @xmath139 that we choose to be @xmath140 .
we adopt values for the adiabatic index @xmath108 and @xmath141 .
[ fig : px ] plots the results for @xmath135 .
notice that the pressure perturbation @xmath135 varies smoothly near the resonance , and its value there agrees well with the value of -1 predicted by the @xmath22-hydrostatic approximation ( [ ph ] ) , and as expected by the series solution ( [ c0 ] ) for large @xmath142 . in appendix a we determine the analytic properties of the buoyancy resonance . we verify them with the numerical solutions for the separable equations .
[ fig : dpx ] shows the behavior of the numerical solution for @xmath143 near the buoyancy resonance at @xmath144 . in agreement with the analytic calculation , equation ( [ psing2 ] ) of appendix
a , we see that there is a jump in the imaginary part of @xmath145 and a logarithmic singularity in the real part of @xmath145 .
the dashed lines in fig .
[ fig : dpx ] plot the analytic approximation to @xmath143 near the resonance and show good agreement .
[ fig : d2px ] shows the behavior of the numerical solution for @xmath146 near the buoyancy resonance at @xmath144 . from equation
( [ psing1 ] ) of appendix a , we expect @xmath147 to be of the form of @xmath148 , for dirac delta function @xmath149 , as is consistent with the plotted function .
as discussed in appendix a , this out of phase delta function contributes to the out of phase density response that in turn contributes to the localized torque at the resonance @xmath144 .
the leading variations in @xmath75 for @xmath150 and weak damping ( @xmath151 ) of the various physical quantities at the buoyancy resonance for @xmath152 and @xmath153 are given by @xmath154 where @xmath155 is the heaviside step function , @xmath156 are real constants , and coefficients have been omitted in the @xmath157 relations . the third column in equations ( [ simi ] ) - ( [ simf ] )
contains the functional forms in the limit of @xmath158 at fixed @xmath75 . unlike the case of lindlbad resonances , there are no radially or vertically propagating waves launched . unlike the case of the previously studied disk resonances ,
the resonance width in @xmath8 is @xmath54 that is unrelated to the gas sound speed .
the width is due to the effects of damping forces and radiative diffusion .
based on athena simulation results , we determined the torque density @xmath159 for case ( a ) that has constant @xmath59 , as described in section [ tdcg ] .
along the lines of equation ( [ dtdxdz ] ) , we calculated the dimensionless torque density @xmath160 for an outer resonance from the results of simulations by integrating the torque density in both the @xmath8 and @xmath22 directions at various heights @xmath161 above the disk midplane @xmath162 where again @xmath109 is the dimensionless gas density in units of the unperturbed midplane disk density @xmath110 , @xmath112 is a dimensionless real constant , and @xmath163 and @xmath118 are the dimensionless locations of the outer @xmath8 boundary and both @xmath22 boundaries of the simulations , respectively . the dimensional torque density @xmath159 is obtained by multiplying @xmath160 by @xmath164 . as seen in the panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig : tdens ] , the torque density was confined to a region of small radial extent centered on the buoyancy resonance .
[ fig : dtdz2 ] compares the nonlinear simulation results for @xmath160 with predictions based on the analytic expression ( [ dtdz2 ] ) and shows good agreement .
we extend the constant gravity and simple potential model of section [ saf ] to the more realistic case in which the vertical gravity varies linearly in @xmath10 , as expected in a thin disk .
we apply the simple potential given by equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) .
vertical hydrostatic balance implies that the unperturbed disk satisfies @xmath165 where @xmath166 with constants @xmath14 , @xmath1 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 we also have @xmath169 and @xmath170 based on the torque density expression ( [ t1 ] ) , we postulate that the torque in the variable gravity case is given by @xmath171 this torque density expression follows from the application hydrostatic condition ( [ ph ] ) to the torque equation ( [ ti ] ) with variable gravity . for small @xmath10 ,
the torque density varies linearly with @xmath10 . the integrated buoyancy torque for each @xmath172 is then given by @xmath173 independent of @xmath4 .
the lindblad torque has a much different dependence on wavenumber @xmath4 .
we compare the buoyancy torque @xmath174 to the lindblad torque @xmath175 subject to the same potential given by equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) .
we consider wavenumbers near the torque cutoff , @xmath176 and have that @xmath177 which follows from equation ( 13 ) of @xcite for a keplerian disk .
the ratio of the torques in a keplerian disk with @xmath178 is given by @xmath179 since we are considering wavenumbers with @xmath180 , we see that the lindblad torque is much stronger .
zhu et al ( 2012 ) reported that the one - sided ( inside or outside corotation ) total buoyancy torque in the case of the planet potential was tens of percent of the one - sided total lindblad torque and was then much stronger in a relative sense than suggest by equation ( [ tlt ] ) .
this difference is likely due to the use here of a potential that is independent of @xmath8 and @xmath10 .
the buoyancy torque in the point mass case may be getting stronger potential contributions that lie closer to the planet than the lindblad torque .
in addition , the lindblad torque declines above its torque cutoff , for @xmath181 . in the point mass case ,
the lindblad and buoyancy torques likely vary differently with @xmath4 for wavenumbers above the lindblad torque cutoff .
such differences may explain why the buoyancy torque ( integrated over @xmath4 ) is relatively stronger in the point mass case than the estimate here suggests .
in section [ sim ] we showed that the torque obtained by linear theory agrees well with that determined by nonlinear simulations . unlike the constant vertical gravity case described in section [ ns ] , we can not obtain separable solutions to the linearized equations .
instead , we determine the torque in the variable gravity case through a numerical solution to the linearized equations by means of a fourier method in @xmath8 .
this method is a 3d extension of the sheared coordinate approach taken by @xcite .
we describe the method in appendix c. equations ( [ eq : u2v ] ) - ( [ eq : s2v ] ) describe the dynamics in terms of the @xmath8 fourier transforms of physical quantities @xmath182 to quantities @xmath183 .
the equations are expressed in terms of a time - like coordinate @xmath184 and vertical coordinate @xmath10 .
these equations were nondimensionalized by setting @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 and following the dimensionless variable notation of section [ tdcg ] .
we integrated these equations by means of the method of lines in mathematica with the implicit runge - kutta option for various values of @xmath142 using @xmath188 , @xmath189 ( see explanation above equation ( [ eq : ubc ] ) ) .
the integration extended from @xmath190 to @xmath191 and @xmath161 from 0 to 4 .
boundary conditions ( [ eq : ubc ] ) - ( [ eq : pbc ] ) were applied with @xmath192 .
the results were transformed back to @xmath193 and the torque density , normalized by @xmath194 , was determined from the integral @xmath195 in dimensionless units .
the width of the peak in the density profile in @xmath75 in the numerical calculation is determined mainly by the length of the @xmath184 integration , @xmath196 .
the upper limit of the torque integral @xmath197 was typically chosen to be @xmath198 that is far enough away from the resonance that the resonant density perturbation is small . in fig . [
fig : dtdzv ] we compare the results of this calculation with the torque density equation ( [ tv1 ] ) for cases with @xmath199 and 10 and @xmath178 . as expected , the torque distribution is independent of @xmath142 for this potential .
the agreement is very good .
buoyancy resonances have been previously analyzed in the context of high mass stars that are tidally perturbed by a companion @xcite .
a buoyancy resonance occurs near the outer parts of the stellar convective core where the buoyancy frequency changes from low values in the core to high values in the radiative envelope . within this region ,
the buoyancy frequency matches that of the tidal forcing .
the response of the star is to launch buoyancy waves ( g mode waves ) that propagate towards the stellar surface where the waves damp and act to bring about spin synchronization with the binary orbit .
as we see in this paper , the adiabatic response of a disk to tidal forcing is evidently quite different . in the axisymmetric case of an isothermal disk , buoyancy waves ( g modes )
can be excited at a lindblad resonance @xcite .
they propagate on the same side of the lindblad resonance as the fundamental mode propagates which is not the region where the buoyancy resonance discussed here is found . for a vertically truncated isothermal disk ,
they accumulate near the disk upper boundary .
we do not find evidence for these waves in the numerical results presented here at small @xmath200 .
low frequency axisymmetric waves in the form of r ( rotation - dominated ) modes exist and are affected by buoyancy that confines them near the disk midplane ( see fig . 11 of @xcite ) .
these modes can also be excited at a lindblad resonance and propagate toward corotation ( @xmath9 ) , although they are only weakly excited there @xcite . to understand the star - disk difference , consider low frequency modes of given @xmath4 in the region where wave frequency @xmath201 is smaller than epicyclic frequency @xmath202 , which is the region where the buoyancy resonances described in this paper reside . in a region
such that @xmath203 , the wkb dispersion relation for the disk pressure perturbation is @xmath204 where @xmath205 is the wave frequency and @xmath206 @xcite .
this relation can be easily derived from equation ( [ peq ] ) .
we see then from equation ( [ dr ] ) that vertical propagation is possible ( @xmath207 ) only for low values of the buoyancy frequency , @xmath208 . for a disk with @xmath209 ,
such a wave can propagate vertically only in the region near the disk midplane as an r mode .
consider the stellar case . to see how waves can be launched towards a stellar surface
, we adapt equation ( [ dr ] ) to the case of a star by noticing that @xmath210 in a disk describes phase variations along the direction of the buoyancy gradient . in the case of a star ,
the buoyancy gradient is in the ( spherical ) radial direction , and so we identify @xmath210 with @xmath211 .
we identify the square of the wavenumber perpendicular to the buoyancy gradient with @xmath212 for the spherical harmonic of order @xmath213 that is associated with the tidal field .
we disregard the stellar rotation and set @xmath214 . the tidal forcing frequency due to the companion star is @xmath205 .
we then have that @xmath215 radial wave propagation is possible ( i.e. , @xmath216 ) in the radiative outer layers of a star outside the buoyancy resonance where @xmath217 ( cf . equation ( 15 ) of @xcite with @xmath218 ) .
waves can be launched at the resonance where @xmath219 because the long wavelength of the wave @xmath220 can match the spatial scale of the slowly varying tidal field .
the effects of rotation modify the dispersion relation by changing @xmath221 in the denominator on the right - hand side of equation ( [ drs ] ) to @xmath222 .
therefore , one major difference between the disk case investigated here and stellar case is due to the effects of rapid rotation , @xmath202 , in the low frequency disk case .
consider possibility that r modes are launched at buoyancy resonances in disks .
waves are launched at resonances if there is a strong overlap between the spatial form of the wave with that of the forcing .
typically that occurs at wave turning points where the long wavelength form of the wave matches the form of the relatively slowly varying potential .
for example , from equation ( [ dr ] ) , @xmath223 is small near a lindblad resonance where @xmath224 .
this locally long wavelength permits a strong coupling with the tidal potential that results in the excitation of a wave .
although vertical wave turning points for r modes lie on the buoyancy resonance plane ( @xmath225 at @xmath226 in equation ( [ dr ] ) ) , the radial wavenumbers @xmath223 are large , as follows from equation ( 58 ) of @xcite with dimensionless frequency @xmath227 for @xmath228 .
( note : @xcite used the term g modes for what are r modes , see also @xcite . )
the r mode becomes more confined vertically as it approaches corotation .
its vertical wavenumber @xmath210 at the midplane and radial wavenumber @xmath223 both grow to very large values near corotation ( @xmath9 ) .
therefore , the r mode structure may not generally match the spatial form of the potential along the buoyancy resonance .
this lack of matching may explain why r modes are not excited at buoyancy resonances .
differential equation ( [ peq1 ] ) , which we obtained for the pressure perturbation near a buoyancy resonance in the constant gravity case , is consistent with dispersion relation ( [ dr ] ) . in that case
, @xmath30 is constant , @xmath229 ( see equation ( [ psf ] ) ) , and near the buoyancy resonance @xmath230 .
we then have that @xmath231 which covers the leading order terms on the left - hand side of equation ( [ peq1 ] ) , identifying @xmath146 with @xmath232 .
however , the wkb approximation does not provide much insight into the properties of a buoyancy resonance because it does not involve waves .
@xcite determined the structure of the disk modes by using what could be called the `` waveguide '' model . in that model ,
the amplitude variations in the @xmath8 direction are assumed to occur slowly compared to phase variations . for perturbations induced by the buoyancy resonance , that assumption does not apply .
for the case of vertically varying gravity , amplitude variations along both the @xmath8 and @xmath10 directions are rapid and comparable .
the interaction between a planet and a disk that responds adiabatically can be understood qualitatively in terms of a 3d impulse delivered to the gas as it passes by the vicinity of the planet @xcite .
the impulse generates a wake whose density is affected by the buoyancy of the gas .
the wake in turn causes a planet - disk torque . to understand the physical nature of the response of the gas
, we have examined its nonaxisymmetric response to a potential that has a single azimuthal wavenumber @xmath4 .
we analyzed the role of buoyancy resonances in a disk whose unperturbed vertical structure is isothermal and is subject to adiabatic perturbations .
a vertically displaced fluid element undergoes vertical free oscillations at the buoyancy frequency @xmath30 .
although the gravitational forcing we have adopted was simplified to be purely azimuthal , this forcing induces nonaxisymmetric vertical pressure and buoyancy forces with azimuthal wavenumber @xmath4 that are stationary in the frame of the potential .
fluid elements move azimuthally through this vertical force field at velocity @xmath233 due to the disk shear .
the vertical forcing frequency on the fluid elements is then @xmath234 a buoyancy resonance occurs where the absolute values of the free ( @xmath30 ) and forcing frequencies ( @xmath235 ) match , as given by equation ( [ xres ] ) .
the resonance leads to a nonaxisymmetric density response that contains a contribution that is out of phase with respect to the potential and results in a torque . to carry out the analysis , we first considered the case of a disk with constant vertical gravity that is subject to a simple perturbing potential given by equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) .
the resonance in this case lies along a plane that is perpendicular to the disk plane , at some @xmath47 ( independent of @xmath10 ) given by equation ( [ xres ] ) .
we obtained an analytic linear description of the structure of the resonance .
the effects on the gas are highly localized to the plane of the resonance .
the results show that the localized induced motions cause localized density perturbations and a torque ( see fig . [
fig : dtdz2 ] ) .
this result confirms the existence of the buoyancy torque found in simulations by zhu et al ( 2012 ) .
the pressure perturbation is everywhere smooth , but singular behavior occurs in its second radial derivative that leads to a contribution to the torque ( figs .
[ fig : px ] - [ fig : d2px ] ) from the radial derivative of the radial velocity .
the width of the torque region is controlled by damping processes and not gas pressure .
the resonance does not result in radially or vertically propagating waves .
we then considered the case of variable vertical gravity with the same simple perturbing potential .
unlike the case of disk resonances previously studied , the buoyancy resonances in this case lie on tilted planes @xmath236 .
we obtained an analytic formula for the torque density , equation ( [ t1 ] ) that agrees well with numerical calculations ( see fig .
[ fig : dtdzv ] ) .
the buoyancy resonance exerts a torque over a region that lies radially closer to the corotation radius than the lindblad resonance .
bouyancy resonances have then very different properties from lindblad resonances .
they do not result in vertically or horizontally propagating waves .
their width is not determined by the gas sound speed , but instead by damping .
the current analysis has several limitations that could be overcome in future studies .
the potential was taken to be of a very simple form in order to investigate the existence and basic analytic properties of a buoyancy resonance . but a more realistic potential would provide a more accurate description in a linearized model .
the analysis presented here assumed that the gas behaves adiabatically .
the radiative transfer of heat between the resonant region and its surroundings can reduce the buoyancy force on perturbed gas and so weaken the resonance for sufficiently low values of the disk optical depth .
in addition , this heat exchange plays a role in determining the resonance width .
since the torque is confined to a thin layer , the resonance may saturate ( weaken ) by feedback effects that may act to change the local disk structure .
such effects can not be studied by linear theory .
the analysis thus far has been limited to shearing boxes .
the shearing box does not describe the corotation resonance and its possible interaction with the buoyancy resonance .
the effects of the buoyancy torque on the net migration rate and in particular its direction ( inwards or outwards ) depend on a competition between the inner and outer buoyancy torques that in turn depends on gradients of disk parameters .
the determination of the outcome requires going beyond the shearing box approximation .
we benefitted from useful discussions with gordon ogilvie , roman rafikov , and jim stone .
shl acknowledges support from nasa origins grant nnx11ak61 g .
zz acknowledges support by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-51333.01-a awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 .
all simulations were carried out using computers supported by the princeton institute of computational science and engineering and kraken at national institute for computational sciences through xsede grant tg - ast130002 .
we examine the behavior of pressure near the buoyancy resonance and verify the @xmath22-hydrostatic approximation of equation ( [ ph ] ) for the perturbing potential of the form given by equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) in the limit of @xmath127 . above the disk midplane , for a given @xmath4 , the gas dynamical equations ( [ eq : u ] )
- ( [ eq : s ] ) , together with equations ( [ p0 ] ) and ( [ rho0 ] ) , can be combined to provide a single equation for the pressure perturbation @xmath25 that is given by @xmath237 for the case of constant vertical gravity above the disk midplane and the simple potential given by equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) , equation ( [ peq ] ) is separable in @xmath8 and @xmath10 .
the pressure perturbation is of the form @xmath238 we apply a change to dimensionless variables @xmath239 and obtain an ordinary differential equation of the form @xmath240 where @xmath241 are real polynomials in @xmath75 that are nonzero at the resonance , that is @xmath242 close to the buoyancy resonance ( small @xmath243 ) , there is a @xmath136 singularity multiplying @xmath135 .
we expect this term to balance the term involving the highest order derivative in @xmath75 , that is @xmath146 .
the reason is that this highest derivative term is most sensitive to the structure of @xmath135 .
if we assume that @xmath244 , then @xmath245 for @xmath246 .
we then consider the following series for @xmath135 for small @xmath246 , @xmath247 where @xmath248 and @xmath249 are coefficients to be determined .
we neglect higher order terms in @xmath75 .
notice that @xmath25 is smooth in @xmath75 and @xmath250 .
the first derivative of @xmath251 contains a logarithmic singularity and its second derivative contains a @xmath136 singularity at @xmath144 .
substituting expansion ( [ psing ] ) into equation ( [ peq1 ] ) for @xmath251 , we obtain in lowest order ( order @xmath136 ) an equation of the form @xmath252 where @xmath253 used here and below are constant terms that depend on @xmath35 , @xmath202 , @xmath30 , and @xmath15 . in next order
, we obtain an equation of the form @xmath254 where @xmath255 arises from the inhomogeneous term .
we then require the coefficient of @xmath256 to vanish and the sum of the other terms to vanish .
namely , @xmath257 and @xmath258 we then solve the three equations ( [ c0c1 ] ) , ( [ c0c1phic2 ] ) , and ( [ c1c2 ] ) for three unknowns @xmath259 , @xmath260 , and @xmath261 in terms of @xmath262 and @xmath263 .
these two @xmath249 parameters are due to the two boundary conditions in @xmath75 for this second order equation in @xmath75 . in the limit of large @xmath142 or equivalently small @xmath264 ,
we find @xmath265 where @xmath266 are dimensionless order unity coefficients that depend on @xmath35 , @xmath202 , @xmath30 , and @xmath15 .
in the large @xmath142 limit , we expect the terms on the right - hand side of equation ( [ c0 ] ) involving @xmath142 to vanish . in this limit ,
equation ( [ c0 ] ) then implies equation ( [ ph ] ) that in turn implies the torque given by equation ( [ t1 ] ) . in practice , we find that the coefficient of the @xmath267 is typically small .
notice that we are assuming that the @xmath249 terms do not increase substantially with @xmath142 . to do so
would imply that the pressure perturbation varies by substantial amounts over the distance between resonance and corotation that varies inversely with @xmath142 . for smooth solutions , the terms in equation ( [ c0 ] ) involving @xmath249
can be ignored in for large @xmath142 .
the smoothness condition on @xmath268 that determines the torque ( see equation ( [ ti ] ) ) is expected hold as a consequence of the @xmath8 boundary condition ( [ xbc ] ) .
the series solution for @xmath269 follows similarly , however , there is a jump in @xmath145 across the resonance .
the imaginary part of @xmath145 undergoes a jump in value , as can be seen by integrating equation ( [ peq1 ] ) in a small region about @xmath144 @xmath270 where we have taken the integral along a counterclockwise contour @xmath84 that is a small half circle in the upper half - plane about the @xmath136 pole @xcite .
the expansion for @xmath251 that is valid for small positive and negative @xmath75 values can then be written as @xmath271 where @xmath272 is the heaviside step function and @xmath273 where we have used the fact that @xmath274 for large @xmath142 , as seen in equation ( [ c0 ] ) , in obtaining the last equation .
it can be shown that @xmath248 are real for large @xmath142 .
having determined the form of the pressure near the resonance , we can determine leading singular behavior of the velocities from equations ( [ eq : u ] ) - ( [ eq : s ] ) .
as follows from equation ( [ psing1 ] ) , near the buoyancy resonance @xmath144 , @xmath275 to lowest order in @xmath267 for a keplerian disk , quantity @xmath260 is given by @xmath276 we find that @xmath277 , @xmath278 , @xmath279 near @xmath144 for real constants @xmath280 and dirac delta function @xmath148 .
consequently , @xmath123 and @xmath124 are logarithmically singular near the resonance .
the equation of mass conservation ( [ eq : rho ] ) implies that @xmath281 .
this out of phase mass density contribution then leads to the local resonant torque density .
the torque derivation that led to equation ( [ t1 ] ) ignored the effects of the boundary conditions at the disk midplane discussed in section [ bc ] .
we consider here the effects of the midplane boundary condition that we take as @xmath282 , equation ( [ zbc ] ) . for @xmath246 , we determine homogenous solutions for the pressure perturbation of the form @xmath283 \exp{(-\lambda z ) } , \label{phom}\ ] ] where @xmath284 is a dimensionless constant that is to be determined .
solutions to the linearized pressure perturbation equation can be obtained as in the inhomogeneous case of appendix a. in the homogeneous case , @xmath259 does not appear because the solution has an arbitrary scale factor . instead , the expanded pressure equations are solved for @xmath284 , @xmath260 , and @xmath261 . in the limit of large @xmath142 , these equations imply that @xmath285 where @xmath286.\ ] ] for a keplerian disk with @xmath178 , the above evaluates to @xmath287 . near the resonance ,
the vertical velocity and density perturbation are simply related by @xmath288 consequently , the requirement that @xmath289 at the disk midplane implies that @xmath24 and therefore the torque density @xmath290 also vanish there .
the equation for the density perturbation variation in @xmath161 and thus @xmath131 are modified by an additional term that is a homogeneous solution with @xmath161 variation @xmath291 to account for this boundary condition . the resonant torque distribution in @xmath10 is then given by @xmath292 \label{dtdz2}\ ] ] with @xmath284 given by equation ( [ lam ] ) .
equations ( [ eq : u ] ) - ( [ eq : s ] ) can be solved by applying a fourier method to the @xmath8 coordinate through the use of sheared coordinates as described in @xcite .
we added a viscous term @xmath293 to the right - hand side of equation ( [ eq : w ] ) to provide greater stability for the numerical scheme .
the @xmath10 coordinate is not transformed .
the fourier transformations are @xmath294 where @xmath295 is @xmath59 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 , @xmath296 , @xmath24 , or @xmath25 and @xmath297 the inverse transformations are given by @xmath298 the limits of integration should ideally extend to @xmath299 , and @xmath300 . in the numerical scheme , they are of course limited .
these are partial differential equations with a time - like coordinate @xmath184 and a spatial coordinate @xmath10 .
guided by section [ bc ] , we apply the following boundary conditions at the disk midplane and upper boundary @xmath303 @xmath304 we consider the simple potential in which @xmath20 is real constant ( equation ( [ eq : phic ] ) ) . @xmath305
since the potential turns on at @xmath306 , we assume that for @xmath307 , all perturbed quantities are zero , e.g. , @xmath308 we integrate the above equations over a very short interval centered at @xmath306 and obtain @xmath309 we need to obtain the density perturbation @xmath311 in order to determine the torque distribution .
the inverse fourier transform ( [ qi ] ) contains artificial , small amplitude , rapid oscillations of density in @xmath8 , due to the finite duration of @xmath312 to @xmath313 and the lack of its periodicity over this interval . to remove these unwanted oscillations ,
we multiply @xmath314 by a window ( or tapering ) function that drops to nearly zero at @xmath196 ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the window function was taken to be a gaussian that is then applied to the density as @xmath315 this procedure eliminated the unwanted oscillations .
it gives similar results to those obtained by applying sufficiently strong viscous damping in the radial and azimuthal dynamical equations ( [ eq : u2v ] ) and ( [ eq : v2v ] ) , respectively .
fast fourier transforms were applied in mathematica to evaluate the integral in equation ( [ qi1 ] ) . in fourier space ,
the outer buoyancy torque produces low frequency oscillations in @xmath184 corresponding to a density disturbance at small @xmath316 .
since an outer lindblad resonance wave occurs further out in @xmath8 , it produces higher frequency disturbances in @xmath184 . determining the properties of the buoyancy resonance
then involves separating the low from high frequency signals . | zhu , stone , and rafikov ( 2012 ) found in 3d shearing box simulations a new form of planet - disk interaction that they attributed to a vertical buoyancy resonance in the disk .
we describe an analytic linear model for this interaction .
we adopt a simplified model involving azimuthal forcing that produces the resonance and permits an analytic description of its structure .
we derive an analytic expression for the buoyancy torque and show that the vertical torque distribution agrees well with results of athena simulations and a fourier method for linear numerical calculations carried out with the same forcing .
the buoyancy resonance differs from the classic lindblad and corotation resonances in that the resonance lies along tilted planes .
its width depends on damping effects and is independent of the gas sound speed .
the resonance does not excite propagating waves . at a given large azimuthal wavenumber @xmath0 ( for disk thickness @xmath1 )
, the buoyancy resonance exerts a torque over a region that lies radially closer to the corotation radius than the lindblad resonance . because the torque is localized to the region of excitation , it is potentially subject to the effects of nonlinear saturation .
in addition , the torque can be reduced by the effects of radiative heat transfer between the resonant region and its surroundings . for each azimuthal wavenumber
, the resonance establishes a large scale density wave pattern in a plane within the disk . |
young s experiment , originally the definitive proof of the wave nature of light , commands an essential role in the discussion of the foundations of quantum mechanics .
for example , in the bohr - einstein - dialogue @xcite , the double - slit experiment was used as a gedanken experiment with individual quanta . in that discussion ,
einstein wanted to argue that quantum mechanics is inconsistent in the sense that one can have path information and observe the interference pattern at the same time , while bohr was always able to demonstrate that einstein s point of view was not correct . indeed , if one carefully analyzes any situation where it is possible to fully know the path the particle took , the interference pattern can not be observed .
likewise , if one observes the full interference pattern , no path information is available .
young s experiment today is considered the most beautiful demonstration of the concept of quantum superposition [ fig . 1 ] .
whenever we do not know , not even in principle , which of the two paths the particle takes , the quantum state can be written as @xmath0 in that case , no information whatsoever is available about the slit the particle passes through .
indeed , if one asked which path the particle takes in an experiment for a specific run , one would find the particle in either slit with equal probability .
yet , obviously , this requires the use of detectors .
if one places one detector each into each slit and if one describes the detector states by quantum mechanics , then , clearly , the quantum state of the whole system becomes @xmath1 ) only has the meaning that the property of the particle to take a definite path is related to a property of the detectors .
the two detector states @xmath2 and @xmath3 describe the detector having registered the particle passing through the left and right slit , respectively
. these can even be states of an internal degree of freedom of the interfering particle ( e.g. spin or polarization states or internal atomic states ) .
a proposal for such an experiment has been made by scully _
@xcite performed a neutron interference experiment and drr _ et al . _
@xcite performed an atomic interference experiment where the disappearance of the interference pattern has to be attributed to the correlations between the internal neutron or atomic states , which serve as which - path detectors , and the paths taken inside the interferometer . in these experiments
the loss of interference is due to the fact that path information is available , in principle , independent of the fact whether the experimentalist cares to read it out or not .
if the two detector states are orthogonal , then the two particle states can not interfere , as eq .
( [ detectors ] ) describes then a maximally entangled state and thus one could determine the path of the particle by observing the detector state .
only if the two detector states are not orthogonal @xcite or if they are projected by a measurement onto a state that is orthogonal to neither one of them @xcite then path interference of a certain contrast may reappear , as then the complete knowledge about the path is not available .
technological progress in the times since the bohr - einstein - dialogue made it possible to realize quantum interference with many different particles all the way to massive molecules , like the fullerenes @xcite c-60 and c-70 .
it is interesting to note that in the latter experiment , the fullerene molecules are at temperatures as high as 900 k. this implies that they are not completely decoupled from the environment . on the contrary , they typically emit a few photons on their path from the source to the detector @xcite .
so why do interference fringes still appear [ fig .
2 ] ? could one not use the emitted photons to trace the path of the fullerene ?
the reason can easily be understood by referring to eq .
( [ detectors ] ) .
the wavelength of the emitted photons is typically of the order of a few micrometers , which has to be compared to the path separation , which is much lower .
therefore , the states of the two photons emitted by a fullerene on either of the interfering paths are nearly identical , implying that the photons carry virtually no information into the environment . the modulus of the scalar product between the two states of the photons corresponding to the emission by a fullerene on either of the interfering paths can be used to quantify the information about the path of the fullerene , which can in principle be extracted if the photons were observed . only if the scalar product is non - zero , then an interference pattern of a certain contrast may appear , as then the path is not completely known .
in general , the contrast ( visibility @xmath4 ) of the interference pattern is equal to the modulus of the scalar product between the two detectors states , @xmath5 .
we now calculate the scalar product between the two photon states which serve as detector states in the fullerene experiment . for the reason of simplicity we consider the fullerene experiment as a double - slit experiment .
suppose that the interfering fullerene emits @xmath6 photons at the moment it reaches the screen with the two slits .
that is , the photons are emitted by the fullerene either at the left slit or at the right slit .
then the visibility @xmath4 of the fullerene interference pattern at the observation screen is equal to the modulus of the following scalar product @xmath7 because the two possible states are the same for every of the n photons , one can transform eq .
( [ vuk ] ) into @xmath8 where @xmath9 are the two amplitudes ( spherical waves ) of a photon at observation point @xmath10 , which are emitted from the point source localized at the position @xmath11 of the left slit and @xmath12 of the right slit , respectively . here
@xmath13 is the wave - number of the photon . to calculate the integral in eq .
( [ srce ] ) we use the substitution @xmath14 and @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
the integration volume is @xmath18 .
using straightforward algebra one obtains @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 is the separation between two slits .
such dependence of the visibility on the number @xmath6 of emitted photons and their wave - number @xmath13 is in agreement with decoherence observed in an atom interferometry @xcite .
it is now clear from eq .
( [ mrmor ] ) that in the extreme case of the wave length much smaller then the slit separation and/or sufficiently large number of emitted photons the visibility @xmath4 vanishes . yet , in the fullerene experiment another extreme case is reached . there
the slit separation @xmath22 , the photons wave length is of the order of @xmath23 , and the estimated number of photons emitted during the entire time of flight of the fullerene are 1 - 2 .
therefore @xmath24 and the high visibility remains preserved .
the possible choice between path information and the observability of interference patterns is one of the most basic manifestations of quantum complementarity , as introduced by niels bohr . following our discussion ,
it is clear that it is the experimentalist who decides which observable to measure .
he can decide , for example , whether to put a detector into the interfering paths or not .
this role of the observer has led to numerous misunderstandings about the copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics . very often , and erroneously , a strong subjective element is brought into the discussion , implying that even the consciousness of the observer has a role in the quantum measurement process .
one has to be very careful at this point .
just to follow our example , the observer can decide whether or not to put detectors into the interfering path .
that way , by deciding whether or not to determine the path through the two - slit experiment , he can decide which property can become reality .
if he chooses not to put the detectors there , then the interference pattern will become reality ; if he does put the detectors there , then the beam path will become reality . yet , most importantly , the observer has no influence on the specific element of the world which becomes reality . specifically ,
if he chooses to determine the path , he has no influence whatsoever which of the two paths , the left one or the right one , nature will tell him is the one where the particle is found .
likewise , if he chooses to observe the interference pattern he has no influence whatsoever where in the observation plane he will observe a specific particle .
both outcomes are completely random .
we therefore argue that the observer has a qualitative influence on nature by deciding via his choice of apparatus which quality can manifest itself as reality , but he has no quantitative influence in the sense of which specific result will be the outcome .
it therefore appears that the objective randomness of quantum measurement provides a limit to the control any experimentalist has .
bohr @xcite writes succinctly : ... a subsequent measurement to a certain degree deprives the information given by a previous measurement of its significance for predicting the future course of phenomena .
obviously , these facts not only set a limit to the extent of the information obtainable by measurement , but they also set a limit to the meaning which we may attribute to such information .
we meet here in a new light the old truth that in our description of nature the purpose is not to disclose the real essence of the phenomena but only to track down , so far as it is possible , relations between the manifold aspects of our experience .
we will now argue that the impossibility of joint perfect observation of both path and the interference pattern is a natural consequence of the finiteness of the information content of a quantum system . on the basis of a specific measure of information
we will define information content of a quantum system .
that information can fully be contained either in the path or in the interference pattern . in both of them only partially to the extent defined by the fundamental limit on the information content
. therefore we will give a quantitative information - theoretic formulation of quantum complementarity in young s experiment .
in a double - slit experiment the path information is a dichotomic , i.e. a two - valued observable while the position in the interference pattern is a continuous one , which makes the consideration more complicated . for that reason we will modify our set - up to that of an interferometer [ fig .
3 ] where both path information and interference observation are dichotomic . afterwards we will extend our analysis to a double - slit experiment . if in fig .
3 the incoming state @xmath25 has amplitude @xmath26 and the incoming state @xmath27 has amplitude @xmath28 ( @xmath29 , then by the usual rules of a symmetric beam splitter @xcite , the outgoing states @xmath30 and @xmath31 become @xmath32 where we allow for an arbitrary , but constant , phase difference @xmath33 between amplitudes @xmath26 and @xmath28 .
it now follows that the probabilities @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 to find an individual particle in any of the four beams are : @xmath38 evidently , because of unitarity , @xmath39 and @xmath40 .
how can we see now the complementarity between the path information and the interference phenomenon ?
it is suggestive to assume that our ability to determine which path the particle takes is related to the modulus @xmath41 of the difference between the probabilities in path 1 and path 2 .
this difference results in the minimal value of 0 if both probabilities are equal and in the maximal value of unity if one of the probabilities is 1 . in the same way
as we assume the information available about the path to be proportional to the modulus of the difference @xmath41 , we may also assume the information in the interference pattern to be proportional to the modulus of the difference @xmath42 .
there is some complementarity between @xmath41 and @xmath42 , and we will now express it quantitatively such that the total information is a constant .
indeed , we find , if we introduce our new measure of information @xcite we are led to a quantitative statement of the complementarity principle .
our new measure of information , which is suitable to define the information gain in a quantum experiment , takes probability squares as a quantitative statement of our knowledge .
in @xcite it was shown that this particular measure of information is related to the estimation of the future number of occurrence of a specific outcome in a repetition of a binary experiment with two probabilistic outcomes .
we now introduce the following quantitative amounts of information @xmath43 where we have introduced the probabilities @xmath44 and @xmath45 as those probabilities where we use an additional phase shifter of phase @xmath46 in , say , beam 2 , resulting in the probabilities @xmath47 the reason that we consider also the probabilities @xmath44 and @xmath45 is that for any specific phase shifts @xmath33 between the two incoming amplitudes , even without path information , our knowledge whether the particle will be found in beam 3 or 4 might not be maximal ( fig . [ fig2 ] ) .
this knowledge however can then be re - established if an additional phase shift of @xmath46 is introduced between the two amplitudes .
now , for the sum of the three individual measures of information , we obtain @xmath48 such a complementarity relation resulting in a constant is possible only if our new measure ( [ measures ] ) is used and could not be obtained if , for example , shannon s measure of information were used @xcite .
an important property of the information content of a quantum system as defined by eq .
( [ content ] ) is that it neither depends on the incoming amplitudes @xmath26 and @xmath28 , nor on the phase factor @xmath33 between them .
this means that the total information is invariant under unitary transformations and thus equal for all possible pure incoming states .
therefore different pure incoming states might have different individual measures of information @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 but their sum is always 1 bit of information . here
@xmath49 describes the path information and @xmath50 and @xmath51 together describe the visibility of the interference effect .
we may therefore introduce the new variables @xmath52 and @xmath53 , and we obtain the final result ( see also @xcite . ) @xmath54 which is a quantitative statement of the principle of complementarity in young s experiment .
one may reinterpret eq .
( [ central ] ) such that a single particle in young s experiment is just the representative of one bit of information and the experimentalist has the choice by deciding whether to determine the path or not , whether this information resides in the path or in interference or in both of them partially to the extend defined by eq .
( [ central ] ) .
we will now extend our consideration to the situation of a double - slit experiment [ fig .
we assume that the amplitude of the interfering particle is @xmath26 in the left slit and @xmath28 in the right slit @xmath55 , where again we allow for an arbitrary phase difference @xmath33 between the two amplitudes .
a typical interference pattern in the fraunhofer limit has a sinusoidal form with a periodicity of @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the de - broglie wave - number , @xmath21 is the separation between the two slits and @xmath58 is the distance between the plane with slits and the observation plane .
consider now two pairs of points @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 in the observation plane , as shown in fig . 1 . on the basis of our new measure of information
we now introduce the amount of information @xmath62 for the pairs of points @xmath63 and @xmath64 , and similarly @xmath65 for @xmath66 and @xmath67 . here , for example , @xmath68 is the conditional probability to detect particle at @xmath63 given that the particle is to be found either in @xmath63 or @xmath64 .
therefore @xmath69 is the measure of the information that the particle will be found in the specific point @xmath63 or in the specific point @xmath64 given that we know it will be found at @xmath63 or @xmath64 anyway .
the probability density to detect the particle at point @xmath70 in the observation plane in the fraunhofer limit is given by @xmath71.\ ] ] here the probability distribution is normalized such that the total probability to find the particle somewhere within the interval @xmath72 $ ] of one period is unity .
if we now use @xmath49 for the amount of information contained in the path and @xmath69 in the pair of observation points @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath73 in the pair @xmath66 , @xmath67 , then we obtain again that @xmath74 .
we notice that the four selected points @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 for which the probability is calculated are just separated by @xmath75 and can be selected for any choice of @xmath70 . like in the case of the interferometer , we will now summarize all individual measures of information @xmath69 and @xmath73 for all @xmath70 and thus obtain the information contained in the full interference pattern .
we still use @xmath76 as given above for the measure of information contained in the path . yet
now we suggest the information contained in the interfering path to be defined by the integral @xmath77 ^ 2 dy \label{integral}\ ] ] note that the integrand in eq .
( [ integral ] ) contains the combinations @xmath78 ^ 2 + [ p(y+y/4)-p(y+3y/4)]^2\ ] ] for every @xmath70 within the interval @xmath79 , which correspond exactly to the sum @xmath80 introduced above .
one can easily calculate that @xmath81 .
therefore we have again @xmath82 for the sum of the measures of information contained in the path and in the interference pattern .
the discussion presented above obviously is just one specific example of quantum complementarity at work .
it is obvious that this can be extended to much more complicated situations , as for example to the notion of quantum entanglement @xcite . from a fundamental perspective
, this approach suggests that the most basic notion of quantum mechanics is information @xcite .
n. bohr , atomic physics and human knowledge ( wiley , new york , 1958 ) .
m. o. scully , b. g. englert and h. walther , nature * 351 * , 111 ( 1991 ) .
j. summhammer , g. badurek , h. rauch , u. kischko , and a. zeilinger , phys .
a * 27 * , 2523 ( 1983 ) .
s. drr , t. nonn and g. rempe , nature * 395 * , 33 ( 1998 ) .
w. k. wootters and w. h. zurek , phys . rev .
d * 19 * , 473 ( 1979 ) .
m. o. scully , and k. drhl , phys . rev . a * 25 * ( 1982 ) 2208 .
m. arndt , o. nairz , j. voss - andreae , c. keller , g. van der zouw , and a. zeilinger , nature * 401 * , 680 ( 1999 ) .
o. nairz , b. brezger , m. arndt , and a. zeilinger , phys .
. lett . * 87 * , 160401 ( 2001 ) m. arndt , o. nairz , and a. zeilinger , in : `` quantum [ un]speakables '' , r. bertlmann , a. zeilinger eds .
springer verlag ( spring 2002 ) .
d. a. kokorowski , a. d. cronin , t. d. roberts , and d. e. pritchard , phys .
* 86 * , 2191 ( 2001 ) .
n. bohr , atomic theory and the description of nature ( cambridge university press , new york , 1934 ) .
a. zeilinger , am .
* 49 * , 882 ( 1981 ) .
. brukner and a. zeilinger , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 354 ( 1999 ) .
. brukner and a. zeilinger , phys .
a * 63 * , 022113 ( 2001 ) .
b. g. englert , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 2154 ( 1996 ) .
brukner , m. zukowski , and a. zeilinger , lanl preprint ( 2001 ) quant - ph/0106119 .
a. zeilinger , found .
* 29 * , 631 - 643 ( 1999 ) . | young s experiment is the quintessential quantum experiment .
it is argued here that quantum interference is a consequence of the finiteness of information .
the observer has the choice whether that information manifests itself as path information or in the interference pattern or in both partially to the extent defined by the finiteness of information . |
since the theory of nucleation phenomena was introduced a long time ago @xcite , the question under which conditions the `` conventional theory '' of nucleation is accurate has been debated ( see e.g. @xcite ) and this debate continues until today . for the simplest case of homogeneous nucleation ( by statistical fluctuations in the bulk ) of a one - component liquid droplet from the vapor , the basic statement of the theory
is that under typical conditions nucleation processes are rare events , where a free energy barrier @xmath0 very much larger than the thermal energy @xmath4 is overcome , and hence the nucleation rate is given by an arrhenius law , @xmath5 here @xmath6 is the number of nuclei , i.e. droplets that have much larger radii @xmath7 than the critical radius @xmath1 associated with the free energy barrier @xmath0 of the saddle point in configuration space , that are formed per unit volume and unit time ; @xmath8 is a kinetic prefactor .
now @xmath0 is estimated from the standard assumption that the formation free energy of a droplet of radius @xmath7 can be written as a sum of a volume term @xmath9 , and a surface term @xmath10 , i.e. @xmath11 since the liquid droplet can freely exchange particles with the surrounding vapor , it is natural to describe its thermodynamic potential choosing the chemical potential @xmath12 and temperature @xmath13 as variables , and expand the difference in thermodynamic potentials of liquid and vapor at the coexistence curve , @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 denoting the densities of the coexisting vapor ( @xmath17 ) and liquid ( @xmath18 ) phases . according to the capillarity approximation ,
the curvature dependence of the interfacial tension @xmath19 is neglected , @xmath19 is taken for a macroscopic and flat vapor - liquid interface . then the critical radius @xmath1 follows from @xmath20 and the associated free energy barrier is @xmath21 however , since typically @xmath22 is less than 100 @xmath4 , the critical droplet is a nanoscale object , and thus the treatment eqs . - is questionable .
experiments ( e.g. @xcite ) were not able to yield clear - cut results on the validity of eqs . - , and
how to improve this simple approach : critical droplets are rare phenomena , typically one observes only the combined effect of nucleation and growth ; also the results are often `` contaminated '' by heterogeneous nucleation events due to ions , dust , etc .
@xcite , and since @xmath6 varies rapidly with the supersaturation , only a small window of parameters is suitable for investigation .
therefore this problem has been very attractive , in principle , for the study via computer simulation .
however , despite numerous attempts ( e.g. @xcite ) , this approach is also hampered by two principal difficulties : * computer simulations can often only study a small number of decades in time , @xcite , which in typical cases correspond to small barriers @xmath23 rather than the larger ones which are of more interest in the context of experiments .
* on the atomistic scale , it is a difficult and not generally solved problem to decide which particles belong to a droplet and which particles belong to its environment ; the vapor - liquid interface is diffuse and fluctuating @xcite . for these reasons , many of the available simulation studies have addressed nucleation in the simplistic ising ( lattice gas ) model , @xcite , first of all since it can be very efficiently simulated , and secondly because one can define more precisely what is meant by a `` cluster '' .
associating ising spins @xmath24 at a lattice site @xmath25 with a particle , @xmath26 with a hole , originally `` clusters '' were defined as groups of up - spins such that each up - spin in a cluster has at least one up - spin as nearest neighbor belonging to the same cluster @xcite .
however , now it is well understood that these `` geometrical clusters '' in general do not have much physical significance @xcite : e.g. , it is known that there exists a line of percolation transitions , where a geometrical cluster of infinite size appears , in the phase diagram @xcite .
this percolation transition is irrelevant for statistical thermodynamics of the model @xcite .
based on the work of fortuin and kasteleyn @xcite on a correlated bond - percolation model , it is now understood that physically relevant clusters in the ising model should not simply be defined in terms of spins having the same orientation and are connected by nearest neighbor bonds , as is the case in the `` geometrical clusters '' , but in addition one has to require the bonds to be `` active '' : bonds are `` active '' with probability @xmath27 @xmath28 @xmath29 being the ising model exchange constant .
due to eq .
, the `` physical clusters '' defined in this way are typically smaller than the geometrical clusters , and their percolation point can be shown to coincide with the critical point @xcite .
a geometrical cluster hence can contain several physical clusters .
note that to apply eq . , random numbers are used , and hence physical clusters are not deterministically defined from the spin configuration , but rather have some stochastic character .
this presents a slight difficulty in using physical clusters in the study of cluster dynamics .
while eq . has been used in the context of simulations of critical phenomena in the ising model , applying very efficient swendsen - wang @xcite and wolff @xcite simulation algorithms , this result has almost always been ignored in the context of simulations of nucleation phenomena @xcite . while it is allright to ignore the difference between geometrical and physical clusters in the limit @xmath30 ( obviously @xmath31 then , all bonds becoming active ) , this is completely inappropriate at higher temperatures .
the present work hence reconsiders this problem , studying both dynamical aspects of nucleation in the framework of the kinetic ising model @xcite ( without conservation laws ) , and the static properties of large droplets , applying the definition of `` physical clusters '' based on eq . throughout . for comparison
, we shall also occasionally use the `` geometrical '' cluster definition , to demonstrate that misleading conclusions would actually result in practice , for the temperatures that are commonly studied .
the study will be generalized to ising systems with free surfaces , where a boundary field @xmath32 acts @xcite .
first of all , in this way also a systematic investigation of heterogeneous nucleation at planar walls becomes feasible ; secondly , due to the reduction of the barrier @xmath33 in comparison to @xmath34 ; nucleation for reasonably large values of @xmath1 becomes accessible to study . in sec .
[ sec2 ] , we consider the equilibrium of the lattice gas model for @xmath35 in systems in a @xmath36 geometry with periodic boundary conditions , to show that physical clusters do occupy precisely the volume predicted by the lever rule analysis , @xcite as they should when the thermodynamic limit is approached .
we present evidence that physical clusters are correctly identified by both the lever rule method and the approach based on the `` atomistic '' identification of clusters based on eq . at all temperatures , from zero temperature up to the critical temperature @xmath37 .
in contrast , eq . , which implies a spherical droplet shape , is found to work only at temperatures distinctly above the interface roughening transition temperature @xmath38 @xcite , even for very large radii @xmath7 .
we attribute these discrepancies to the fact that due to the anisotropy of the interface tension for our lattice model pronounced deviations of the average droplet shape from a sphere occur @xcite , presenting data on the shape of large droplets . in sec .
[ sec3 ] , we describe our results on the dynamics of the droplet size distribution and on the attempt to find @xmath1 from the size where growth and shrinking processes of clusters are balanced .
this study is also carried out for systems with a free surface , for which the contact angles for various values of the surface field have been estimated previously @xcite , since in this case much lower barriers ( for large clusters ) result , which is crucial for making this study feasible with manageable effort . however , the radii @xmath1 predicted from this analysis of kinetics show slight deviations from the radii @xmath1 predicted from @xmath33 .
possible reasons for this discrepancy will be discussed .
finally , sec .
[ sec4 ] summarizes our conclusions .
as is obvious from eq . and the reasoning behind it , this approach is adequate when one deals with the description of macroscopically large domains in equilibrium with a surrounding bulk phase .
however , one needs to find an extension of the concept that can be applied also to nanoscopically small droplets , `` clusters '' in the lattice gas model that contain perhaps only of the order of 100 fluid particles . in this section , we want to confirm the idea that one must use the concept of `` physical clusters '' based on eq . for this purpose , rather than the `` geometrical clusters '' that are so widely used when the lattice gas model is used to test nucleation theory concepts . while the geometrical clusters are appropriate if one works at extremely low temperatures where the clusters basically have the shape of small cubes @xcite
, this region clearly is inappropriate when one has the application for vapor - to - liquid nucleation in mind , where droplets are spherical , and their interfaces are rough and fluctuating rather than smooth planar facets . in fact , many studies of nucleation in the lattice gas model have been made in @xmath39 dimensions at temperatures near @xmath40 or thereabout ; given the fact that the interfacial roughening transition of the ising model on the simple cubic lattice is known to occur at about @xcite @xmath41 , i.e. ( note @xmath42 @xcite ) @xmath43 , it is clear that temperatures much closer to @xmath37 must be studied to render the assumption of a spherical droplet shape accurate .
in fact , this assumption of a spherical droplet shape is accurate when the difference between the interfacial stiffness @xcite and the interfacial free energy becomes negligibly small .
numerical studies of hasenbusch and pinn @xcite indicate that this is only the case for @xmath44 . as a consequence ,
it is clear that most of the existing studies of nucleation phenomena in the ising model , that were based on geometrically defined clusters , and had to be done at much lower temperatures , are inconclusive : the deviation of the average droplet shape from a sphere enhances the surface term in eq . ; but the fluctuation corrections discovered for small droplets by the `` lever rule method '' @xcite show that @xmath45 for small @xmath7 and hence the surface term in eq .
is decreased .
thus , it hardly can be a surprise that some of the studies concluded that the nucleation barriers predicted by classical nucleation theory and the capillarity approximation ( that ignores the @xmath7-dependence of @xmath46 are too high , and others concluded they are too low , or even reported good agreement .
we take the latter finding as indication that the two opposing effects have accidentally more or less canceled each other .
this problem is the motivation for the present section , which attempts to show that `` physical clusters '' based on eq .
are appropriate to identify clusters in the lattice gas model , irrespective of temperature and cluster size , and are equivalent to the droplets of the `` lever rule method '' , for large enough droplets .
[ fig1 ] recalls this approach : one samples for a system of volume @xmath47 the effective thermodynamic potential @xmath48 per lattice site as a function of density @xmath49 , @xmath50/v\,,\ ] ] where @xmath51 is the number of occupied lattice sites ( @xmath52 with @xmath53 the spin variable at lattice site @xmath25 ) .
since phase coexistence between bulk liquid ( at density @xmath16 ) and vapor ( at density @xmath15 ) occurs at a chemical potential @xmath54 that corresponds to the `` field '' ( in magnetic notation ) @xmath55 , @xmath16 and @xmath15 are simply related to the spontaneous magnetization of the ising ferromagnet as @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 translates into @xmath12 via @xmath59 .
the accurate sampling of @xmath48 for large @xmath60 is a nontrivial task , it requires the use of advanced methods such as `` multicanonical monte carlo '' @xcite or `` wang landau sampling '' @xcite or `` successive umbrella sampling '' @xcite , see @xcite for background on such techniques . from eq .
, one defines a chemical potential function as a derivative , @xmath61 one recognizes that the isotherms @xmath62 vs. @xmath49 exhibit a loop : the homogeneous vapor remains stable also for some region where @xmath63 , until a peak occurs , which indicates the `` droplet evaporation / condensation transition '' @xcite : in the first regime where @xmath64 decreases with @xmath49 , a ( more or less spherical or cubical ) droplet coexists with surrounding vapor .
here , we are not interested in the further transitions that one can recognize from this curve , where the droplet changes shape from spherical to cylindrical , or to a slab configuration , etc . @xcite .
instead , we emphasize the key idea of the `` lever rule method '' : one can identify a range of choices for the chemical potential @xmath12 where three states of the finite system can exist in equilibrium with the same chemical potential , namely a homogeneous vapor at density @xmath65 , a homogeneous liquid at density @xmath66 , and a state where two - phase coexistence between the droplet and surrounding vapor occurs .
since the vapor in this case exists at the same chemical potential as the pure vapor , it must be of the same physical nature as the state with density @xmath67 , and similarly , the liquid in the droplet can be identified with the liquid at @xmath68 .
making now use of the fact that for large enough systems a system can be suitably decomposed into independent subsystems , we write for the free energy , with @xmath69 the volume taken by the droplet , @xmath70 , @xmath71 where the free energy densities @xmath72 and @xmath73 are explicitly known , and also @xmath48 is known : thus , when the droplet volume @xmath69 is known , the surface free energy @xmath74 of the droplet , which is defined via eq . , is determined .
a similar decomposition can readily be written down for the particle number , @xmath75 where we have allowed for an excess number @xmath76 of particles , to be associated with the interface .
if we consider the definition of an `` equimolar dividing surface '' @xcite , @xmath77 , and then reading off @xmath67 and @xmath68 from the construction in fig .
[ fig1 ] we see that eq . readily yields @xmath78 and @xmath69 for the considered density @xmath49 , and via eq .
we can immediately extract @xmath74 from the data .
note that these arguments do not invoke the assumption that the dividing surface needs to be a sphere .
if one makes the assumption , @xmath79 , and then one can write also @xmath80 .
thus , it is assumed that all interactions of particles inside the droplet ( volume region @xmath69 ) with particles inside the vapor ( volume region @xmath78 ) are restricted to the interfacial region , and hence can be accounted for by their contribution to the surface free energy @xmath74 .
\(a ) ( b ) however , the method defined via eqs . , , and illustrated in fig . [ fig1 ] becomes difficult to apply for very large droplets , because the sampling of @xmath48 then becomes unreliable or would require an unaffordable effort .
the method is also difficult to apply for small droplets , because then one must use relatively small simulation boxes to ensure the stability of the inhomogeneous state where a droplet coexists with surrounding vapor @xcite .
thus , it is very desirable to complement the approach by a more `` microscopic '' identification of droplets , and this is possible via eq . .
in particular , it has been shown that apart from finite size effects ( see e.g. @xcite ) that for @xmath81 the spontaneous magnetization of the ising ferromagnet @xmath82 coincides with the percolation probability @xmath83 , which is defined @xcite as the fraction of sites belonging to the largest `` physical cluster '' in the system .
when we hence analyze a configuration at a density @xmath49 , where ( cf . fig .
[ fig1 ] ) a large cluster is present in the system , using eq . to define clusters
the largest cluster will include @xmath18 sites , which we hence can associate with its ( total ) magnetization @xmath84 where @xmath85 is then the magnetization per site ( note that the ising magnet / lattice gas isomorphism implies that @xmath86 ) . as a consequence ,
we can obtain the droplet volume @xmath69 from a `` measurement '' of the average size @xmath87 of the largest cluster in the system via @xmath88 note that this volume in general differs from the volume of a geometrical cluster : if @xmath89 counts all occupied sites belonging to the geometrical cluster , and noting that the density in a large geometrical cluster is just the bulk density , namely @xmath90 , the volume taken by the geometrical cluster is given by @xmath91 in the limit @xmath92 , where also @xmath87 and @xmath69 get macroscopically large , @xmath85 tends to @xmath82 , while for finite @xmath60 it is clear that @xmath85 slightly exceeds @xmath82 ( and @xmath68 exceeds @xmath16 , see fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
however , recording the relation @xmath93 [ or the equivalent relation @xmath94 of the ising ferromagnet ] very precisely is an easy task , see fig .
[ fig2 ] , since both states at densities @xmath95 ( fig . [ fig1 ] ) are homogeneous , not affected by heterophase fluctuations , and since the temperatures studied are still well below @xmath37 , statistical fluctuations are small , and finite size effects are negligible . fig .
[ fig2 ] presents representative results for both @xmath96 and @xmath97 versus @xmath98 .
note we also have used the lattice version of the widom particle insertion method @xcite to record the inverse function @xmath99 from simulations in the canonical ensemble , where @xmath49 was chosen as the independent control variable .
the perfect agreement between both approaches not only serves as a test of the accuracy and correctness of our numerical procedures , but also shows that for the chosen temperatures and linear dimensions finite size effects on states in `` pure '' phases are completely negligible , since finite size effects are known to differ in the two ensembles @xcite , but are not detected here at all .
\(a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) to record @xmath69 as defined in eq . from the simulations , we performed simulations in the canonical ensemble , choosing various values of @xmath49 , and equilibrate a large droplet coexisting with surrounding vapor .
the initial state is then chosen putting a droplet with the size predicted by the lever rule ( and density @xmath100 ) into the simulation box , which then is carefully equilibrated .
the standard method to simulate the ising model with conserved magnetization ( which corresponds to the lattice gas model in the canonical @xmath101 ensemble ) is the `` spin exchange algorithm '' @xcite .
however , the standard nearest neighbor exchange method implies that any local excess of magnetization ( or density , respectively ) can only relax diffusively , and the resulting `` hydrodynamic slowing down ''
@xcite hampers the fast approach towards thermal equilibrium .
we thus used instead a single spin - flip algorithm in which the total magnetization is restricted to two neighboring values @xmath102 : so if the system has magnetization @xmath103 , flipping a down - spin ( which would mean a transition @xmath104 ) is automatically rejected , and if the system is in the state @xmath105 , flipping of up - spins is forbidden . for large systems ( @xmath106 )
any corrections to a strictly canonical simulation at a magnetization per spin @xmath107 are of order @xmath108 and hence negligible .
choosing very large systems ( up to @xmath109 , rather than @xmath110 as used in fig .
[ fig1 ] ) the ratio of @xmath69 as found from eq . and
@xmath111 from the lever rule ( with the assumption @xmath112 , i.e. @xmath113 is plotted vs. @xmath114 in fig .
[ fig3 ] for several temperatures and various densities @xmath49 .
these data show that @xmath115 as @xmath81 , irrespective of temperature and density ( in the density region where a droplet not affected by the periodic boundary conditions is present , as explained in fig .
[ fig1 ] ) .
the fact that @xmath116 extrapolates to unity for @xmath106 not precisely , but only within some error , is due to the fact that statistical errors affect both the estimation of @xmath87 and of @xmath111 ( via errors in the estimation of @xmath98 and hence @xmath67 ) . as expected , using the proper definition of physical clusters , one can work at arbitrary temperatures , both at @xmath117 ( a ) , @xmath13 slightly above @xmath38 ( b ) or @xmath13 rather close to @xmath37 ( d ) . while in cases ( a ) the simple geometrical cluster definition would also work ,
since essentially all bonds are `` active '' ( @xmath118 is almost unity \{eq . } ) , and the non - spherical shape of the clusters does not matter in this context .
but the geometrical cluster definition would clearly break down in case ( d ) due to the proximity of the percolation transition that occurs for geometrical clusters at a density not much larger than those included in fig .
[ fig3](d ) @xcite .
on the other hand , we note from the fact that there always occurs asymptotically in the relation @xmath119 a correction of order @xmath114 , that for physical clusters the assumption @xmath77 , that is often ( but not always @xcite ) made in the lever rule method , does not hold : i.e. , when we assume that @xmath76 is proportional to the surface area of the droplet , we can write @xmath120 where @xmath121 is a geometrical factor @xmath122 for a spherical droplet , @xmath123 for a cube ) , and @xmath124 is an excess density of the particles due to the interface of the droplet . using @xmath111 from eq . as a first - order estimate in eq .
, one readily finds that the term @xmath125 in eq . yields a @xmath114 correction , @xmath126 and hence eq . would yield instead of eq .
@xmath127 which is qualitatively in accord with fig .
[ fig3 ] . in order to test eq . and
obtain estimates for the temperature dependence of @xmath124 , fig .
[ fig4 ] plots our numerical results for the ratios @xmath116 versus @xmath128 .
we see a very good data collapse at straight lines going through unity at the ordinate within numerical error at all studied temperatures .
\(a ) ( b ) \(a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) since the data in fig .
[ fig3 ] suggest that for `` physical droplets '' in the lattice gas model an appreciable `` interfacial adsorption '' ( as expressed in @xmath129 in eq . )
occurs , it is of interest to not only study the average volume of the droplets @xmath87 but also their radial density profile ( fig .
[ fig5 ] ) .
it is seen that for radii @xmath7 which are in the range from 10 to 20 lattice constants ( corresponding to droplet volumes in the range from about 4500 to 36000 , so these are already clusters of a mesoscopic size , with a huge nucleation barrier far beyond observation in a simulation of nucleation events or in experiments ) the profiles are very broad , and their width increases slightly with increasing droplet size . for comparison , the prediction for the cluster radius resulting from the widely used standard geometrical definition of clusters
is also included : it happens that this geometrical radius is still fairly close to the correct radius at @xmath130 .
of course , closer to @xmath37 the geometrical cluster definition yields completely unreasonable results , due to the onset of percolation phenomena , and for @xmath131 and @xmath132 , the geometrical radii are indeed unreasonably large .
it is interesting to note ( fig .
[ fig5]d ) that the width of the interfacial profile increases with increasing @xmath7 .
this phenomenon is well - known for planar interfaces and attributed to capillary waves . since for a large droplet
the surface is locally planar , most of the capillary wave spectrum is not affected by the interface curvature .
thus we may , as a first approximation , take over the result for the broadening of a planar interface of linear dimension @xmath60 , replacing @xmath60 by the droplet radius @xmath7 @xcite @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the `` intrinsic width '' of the interfacial profile , @xmath135 the `` interfacial stiffness '' ( note that a factor @xmath136 is absorbed in its definition ) and @xmath137 a short wavelength cutoff , whose precise value is not known . near @xmath37 the interfacial stiffness coincides with the interfacial free energy , while @xmath138 at @xmath139 , and then the capillary wave broadening disappears . if one accepts the above formula , and uses the data of hasenbusch and pinn @xcite , one predicts for the slope @xmath140^{-1 } \approx 2.5 $ ] ( @xmath131 ) or @xmath141 ( @xmath142 ) , respectively .
the actually observed slopes of the @xmath143 term are actually somewhat smaller , namely about 2.13 at @xmath131 and @xmath144 at @xmath142 , but of the same order of magnitude .
we deliberately do not discuss the radial droplet density profiles for @xmath145 and @xmath146 , however , since at these temperatures the droplet shape shows distinct deviations from the spherical shape .
this can be checked directly by recording contours of constant density in slices of width @xmath147 ( taking into account 3 lattice planes through the droplet s center of mass , parallel to the @xmath148 plane , the @xmath149 plane and the @xmath150 plane , respectively ) . averaging these density contours over several hundred statistically independent observations the plots shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] are obtained .
they are all taken at the same fixed density @xmath151 .
note that for this density , the stable state would be a cylindrical droplet ( stabilized by the periodic boundary conditions ) but for such large systems ( @xmath152 ) the compact droplet shapes shown here ( chosen by an appropriate initial condition ) are always perfectly metastable . at @xmath145 the cubic symmetry of these cross sections through the droplet
is evident ( although the presence of facets parallel to the planes @xmath153 or @xmath154 is not evident , due to finite - size effects at the points where the facets join the round sections , which replace the sharp edges of the cubes at nonzero temperature ) . at @xmath146 , where we exceed the roughening temperature slightly ,
there clearly occur no longer any facets , but the density contours in fig .
[ fig6 ] are still distinctly non - circular : the diameter in diagonal direction clearly is about 7% larger than in the lattice directions .
even at @xmath130 , we find an enhancement of the diameter in diagonal direction of about 3% . at @xmath131 to 4.3 , however , no longer any statistically significant deviation from spherical droplet shapes ( and hence circular shape of the density contours in the cross sections ) can be detected .
note that for @xmath142 ( case ( f ) ) the geometrical cluster definition would not be applicable due to the proximity of the percolation transition of geometrical clusters .
\(a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) ( e ) ( f ) \(a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) as a final part of our analysis of static properties of physical droplets in the ising model , we exploit the fact that the chemical potential @xmath12 can be `` measured '' by the lattice version of the widom particle insertion method @xcite also in the state when the system is inhomogeneous , e.g. for the case of interest when a droplet coexists with surrounding vapor .
actually , already in @xcite it was shown that @xmath12 actually stays spatially constant in such a situation . however , while the estimation of @xmath12 from eq .
requires a very accurate estimation of the free energy density @xmath155 \{eq . , fig .
[ fig1 ] } , and in practice this works only for not so large linear dimension @xmath60 ( such as @xmath110 in fig .
[ fig1 ] ) , the estimation of @xmath12 from the particle insertion method still works for volumes that are orders of magnitude larger . as a consequence
, we can use eq . to test whether or not the actual droplet volumes @xmath156 are compatible with conventional nucleation theory for large droplets ( assuming that the droplets are spherical )
so @xmath157 holds for a critical droplet .
[ fig7 ] presents a plot of the cluster volume @xmath69 versus inverse linear dimension for several densities , at the temperatures @xmath146 , @xmath158 , @xmath159 and @xmath132 , using the classical nucleation theory prediction @xmath160 with @xmath1 given by eq . for comparison .
for this purposes @xmath161 is taken from the work of hasenbusch and pinn @xcite , and so there occur no unknown parameters whatsoever .
the geometrical cluster volume @xmath162 \{eq . } is close to the estimate based on the coniglio - klein - swendsen - wang `` physical cluster''-definition , eq . , at @xmath146 and @xmath130 , while at @xmath131 ( and higher ) the deviations become appreciable : @xmath163 then is systematically too high ( in comparison with all other estimates , including @xmath111 \{eq . } , which is used as a convenient normalization ) .
it is interesting to observe that the classical nucleation theory estimates based on eq .
are systematically too low for @xmath164 and @xmath165 , while for @xmath166 eqs . , are found to be in very good agreement .
this discrepancy at the relatively low temperatures comes from the fact that using eq . for the estimation of @xmath69
we imply that the cluster volume is spherical and hence we underestimate the surface area : the geometrical factor @xmath167 introduced in eq
. increases from about 4.836 for the spherical shape near @xmath37 up to 6.0 for the cube , as the temperature is lowered .
since the non - spherical droplet shapes at @xmath146 and 3.0 have regions of rather large curvature near the parts of the droplet where at low temperature the edges of the cube will appear , the estimation of @xmath12 then yields a too low radius @xmath1 .
the observation that the anisotropy of surface tension in the lattice gas model becomes noticeable for @xmath168 is consistent with the findings of hasenbusch and pinn @xcite .
if all the methods to define clusters were correct , in the thermodynamic limit all data should extrapolate to @xmath169 for @xmath106 , since in this limit the lever rule \{eq . }
is trivially true with @xmath170 and @xmath171 . the method based on the definition of physical clusters , eq .
, indeed is nicely compatible with this expectation at all temperatures ; although it is somewhat unsatisfactory ( and unexpected ) that at finite @xmath60 there occurs a surface correction due to the surface excess @xmath76 noted in eq .
( and discussed above )
. however , it is clear that the two other methods do not give results that are correct for @xmath106 in general : while the method based on the geometric cluster definition still gives essentially correct results at @xmath145 ( not shown here ) , where the distinction between `` geometrical '' and `` physical '' clusters is irrelevant , for temperatures @xmath172 , the volume of geometrical clusters is systematically too large . at @xmath142 ,
the error is as large as 60 to 80% even asymptotically , and for the cluster sizes that were actually studied the overestimation actually is by a factor two to five ( fig .
[ fig7]d ) ! in view of the fact that the geometric cluster definition must break down due to the percolation transition @xcite , this failure is not unexpected , but we are not aware that it ever has been quantified previously . in the regime from @xmath146 to @xmath159 , the error of the geometric cluster volume raises from a few percent to 15 to 40% .
the results obtained from the classical nucleation theory via the `` measurement '' of the supersaturation @xmath98 , on the other hand , yield essentially the correct result at high temperatures ( @xmath173 ) , for all linear dimensions studied , since the data are essentially independent of @xmath60 , and hence @xmath1 , in the considered range .
but it is remarkable that for @xmath130 we find @xmath174 ( fig . [ fig7]b ) and
for @xmath146 we find @xmath175 ( fig . [ fig7]a ) . this discrepancy becomes worse at lower temperatures ( e.g. @xmath176 at @xmath145 [ not shown ] ) , and obviously this discrepancy must be attributed to the orientation dependence of the interfacial free energy and the resulting non - spherical droplet shapes ( fig .
[ fig6 ] ) . at first sight
, the result that @xmath177 is independent of @xmath1 seems to be at variance with the finding of a curvature - dependent surface tension @xmath178 due to winter et al .
in fact , evidence was provided that @xmath179 where @xmath180 is a length proportional to the correlation length in the bulk @xcite .
note that due to the spin reversal symmetry of the ising model one can show @xcite that a tolman correction ( @xmath181 ) must be absent for @xmath182 .
however , from eqs . and , it is straightforward to show that @xmath183 \;.% has been checked \end{split}\ ] ] hence for @xmath184 it is clear that the result for @xmath1 is still given by eq . , and for @xmath185 we are safely in this regime , since the correlation length then does not yet exceed the lattice spacing .
so the deviations of the ratio @xmath177 that are seen in fig . [ fig7 ] can be attributed fully to the deviation of the droplet shape from a perfect sphere , caused by the anisotropy of the interfacial free energy . in fig .
[ fig : vcntvsvlr ] , we now present the ratio of the intercepts @xmath186 for @xmath187 as a function of temperature , since we know that \{eq . }
@xmath188 ^ 3 $ ] , while eq .
yielded @xmath189 for a spherical droplet . at @xmath190 , however , the droplet is a perfect cube , and for intermediate temperatures , its shape ( for @xmath191 ) is given by the wulff construction @xcite ( and hence not explicitly known ) .
however , for large droplet volume @xmath192 we can write in general @xmath193 when we have assumed that the droplets of different linear dimension @xmath7 ( for @xmath194 ) have the same shape at fixed temperature , so we can write @xmath195 for the droplet volume ( @xmath196 is then formally the volume for @xmath197 ) and the surface area is @xmath198 .
for instance , for a sphere we have @xmath199 and @xmath200 , and for the cube @xmath201 and @xmath202 . minimizing @xmath203 with respect to @xmath192 yields @xmath204 for a general shape , which is in between sphere and cube .
the barrier then can be written as @xmath205 using now the fact that by choosing a particular large droplet volume in our simulation , @xmath58 is automatically fixed for any volume @xmath206 due to the thermal equilibrium situation constructed in our simulation .
so it makes sense to estimate the ratio of barriers as @xmath207 for @xmath190 , we know that @xmath208 is again the interface tension of the planar surface , also used in the classical nucleation theory for the spherical surface .
hence when we write the ratio of @xmath209 , using eq . , the term @xmath210 cancels , @xmath211 this asymptotic value of @xmath212 should be reached for @xmath213 , while @xmath214 as @xmath215 .
our numerical results ( fig .
[ fig : vcntvsvlr ] ) are compatible with this expectation .
we now consider time - dependence of the system where we start the system at time @xmath216 in an equilibrated state in the vapor at @xmath217 , but switch on at time @xmath216 a chemical potential @xmath218 ( or equivalently , a positive magnetic field @xmath58 in the notation of ising ferromagnet ) at which the liquid is the stable phase . as mentioned in the introduction , we consider heterogeneous in addition to homogeneous nucleation , choosing a @xmath219 geometry with two walls at @xmath220 and @xmath221 , choosing surface fields @xmath222 such that @xmath223 favors the vapor but @xmath32 ( acting at the wall at @xmath220 ) favors the liquid .
the reason for this choice is , that by proper choice of @xmath32 one can adjust the contact angle @xmath224 at which sessile wall - attached macroscopic droplets can occur . the barrier against heterogeneous nucleation @xmath225 is predicted to be very much reduced , in comparison to the barrier @xmath34 against homogeneous nucleation ,
if the contact angle is small , since @xcite @xmath226 as shown with the `` lever rule '' method @xcite indeed rather large wall attached droplets can be simulated in equilibrium with supersaturated vapor which have barriers of order @xmath227 or so only , for suitable choices of @xmath32 and @xmath58 , and so a comparison with kinetic studies then seems reachable , and varying @xmath32 over some range provides an additional variable to test the theory .
\(a ) ( b ) as a first step , preliminary runs were performed with the single spin flip metropolis algorithm @xcite monitoring the average lifetime of the metastable vapor .
this was done using a large sample @xmath228 ) of equilibrated initial states at @xmath55 , where the considered field @xmath58 ( or chemical potential @xmath229 , respectively ) was then switched on and the time recorded when the ( initially negative ) magnetization reaches the value @xmath230 for the first time .
[ fig8 ] shows estimates for the resulting mean first passage times for a range of choices of @xmath32 as a function of the field .
when this `` lifetime '' of the state with @xmath231 ( i.e. , vapor ) does not exceed @xmath232 , the system is rather unstable , nucleation occurs fast and is followed by fast domain growth as well ; such fast decays of unstable systems are not suitable for tests of nucleation theory .
it is seen , that in a rather narrow interval of fields @xmath58 ( for each value of @xmath32 ) the lifetime increases from @xmath232 to @xmath233 .
such parameter combinations @xmath234 will be studied in the following only ; if we would study cases where the lifetime is significantly larger than @xmath233 , no critical droplet would be formed during affordable simulation times .
\(a ) ( b ) fig .
[ fig9 ] then shows typical time evolutions of the size distribution of @xmath235 of physical clusters of size @xmath18 , normalizing them by the equilibrium cluster concentration @xmath236 for @xmath55 . here
@xmath236 is defined as the average number of physical clusters per lattice site , and we have the sum rule @xmath237 since every site occupied by a particle must be part of some cluster .
of course , here we are only interested in not too small clusters , and hence fig .
[ fig9 ] focuses on clusters with @xmath238 . in the time evolution of @xmath239
we recognize three regimes : for times of order @xmath240 is rapidly rising : this period of time corresponds to the relaxation from the initial state ( where @xmath55 ) towards the metastable state . in the latter ,
@xmath235 is almost constant for at least one , or even several decades of time
. then a decay of these plateau values sets in , which is due to the fact that too many much larger clusters have grown , the volume fraction of the system that is still in the metastable phase shrinks , and so less clusters of intermediate size ( as studied in fig . [ fig9 ] ) are observed .
this behavior is qualitatively similar to previous studies ( e.g. @xcite ) which were based on the geometrical cluster definition , however .
we also remark that in the case of fig .
[ fig9]b the lifetime of the plateau extends up to @xmath241 , one decade only , as expected from fig .
[ fig8]a , since this case corresponds to a `` lifetime '' of the metastable state of only @xmath242 , and it is clear that only times @xmath243 distinctly less than @xmath244 should be analyzed . while some of the previous work on the studies of the kinetics of cluster growth in metastable ising models ( e.g. @xcite ) tried to use directly @xmath235 to extract information on the validity of nucleation theory concepts , we here try to implement a different concept .
namely , we follow the trajectories of individual ( large ) clusters with respect to their size in time , @xmath245 , where @xmath25 is an index to label individual clusters . to ensure that the @xmath25th cluster at time @xmath246 is actually a descendent of the @xmath25th cluster at the time @xmath243
, we have to choose @xmath247 small enough , and also record the location ( center of gravity @xmath248 and the components of the gyration radius @xmath249 where @xmath250 is the @xmath251th cartesian coordinate for the @xmath252th lattice site belonging to the cluster with label @xmath25 , consisting of @xmath253 lattice sites . in each time step in which an analysis of the clusters is performed ,
the set of coordinates @xmath254 is recorded .
note that there occurs the difficulty that the number of large clusters is not constant during the simulation : clusters form and decay or split into parts , and since we know that @xmath255 exceeds @xmath18 for each cluster , and the assignment of the `` active bonds '' according to eq . to identify from the geometrical cluster the associate physical clusters is a random process , some random shift of @xmath256 would occur even if we carry out two successive cluster identifications from the same spin configuration @xmath257 ) . of course , such shifts should be small in comparison with @xmath258 , but as @xmath247 is chosen nonzero it is clear that useful results are only obtained if @xmath247 is small enough , and @xmath18 is large in comparison to clusters that correspond to typical thermal fluctuations @xcite .
hence only clusters for which @xmath259 are considered ( for the temperature @xmath130 we chose arbitrarily @xmath260 ) .
so if by such criteria ( for details see @xcite ) it is ensured that the @xmath25th cluster with size @xmath261 is a descendent of the @xmath25th cluster with size @xmath253 at time @xmath243 , we can define a reaction rate @xmath262 as @xmath263}{\delta t } \right\rangle _ { \ell_i(t)}\ ] ] here the index @xmath253 stands for an average over a sampling of all cluster trajectories recorded in the simulation , and a smoothing procedure of the ( otherwise too noisy ) data with a triangular smoothing function @xcite was applied .
of course , in order to collect statistically significant data on @xmath264 , it is necessary to perform many runs for each parameter combination @xmath265 that is studied .
we observe that the lifetime of the metastable stale in such runs is fluctuating dramatically , and so it is necessary to choose the run time of each run individually , rather than the same for all runs .
it was decided to stop each run automatically when the largest cluster size @xmath266 was reached .
of course , then only clusters with @xmath267 could be studied , to avoid artifacts caused by this cutoff .
\(a ) ( b ) while eq .
is based on using all clusters @xmath268 at each time @xmath243 , one can simplify matters by restricting the analysis only to the trajectory of the biggest cluster in the system @xcite .
when one does this , one ignores possible problems from the fact that from time to time the identity of the largest cluster changes .
[ fig10 ] shows now typical results for @xmath264 , using both this latter approximation and the method based on eq . .
both methods yield similar trends , although they differ somewhat in detail ( particularly in the case of homogeneous nucleation in the bulk ) .
\(a ) + ( b ) what one expects theoretically for @xmath264 is a monotonous increase of @xmath264 with @xmath18 , where @xmath264 is negative for clusters smaller than the critical cluster size @xmath3 while @xmath264 is positive for @xmath269 .
the method yields a second positive part for @xmath18 slightly larger than @xmath270 .
this is an artifact of ignoring clusters smaller than @xmath270 , which vanishes for @xmath271 @xcite . if we identify the critical cluster size with the zero crossing of @xmath264 at the right hand side , and convert to the cluster volume @xmath272 according to eq .
, we obtain the data shown in fig .
[ fig11 ] .
it is seen that for a given value of the field @xmath58 ( or @xmath229 , respectively ) classical nucleation theory underestimates the volume of the critical cluster : in other words , a given volume @xmath272 leads to a larger value of @xmath58 . since ( according to classical nucleation theory and eq . )
the barriers scale as @xmath273 , this means when one studies nucleation barriers as function of cluster volume @xmath272 or cluster radius @xmath1 , one finds lower barriers in the simulation rather than predicted .
qualitatively , the data from the present analysis of cluster kinetics confirm the findings from the lever rule method of winter et al .
@xcite , as far as homogeneous nucleation is concerned ( fig .
[ fig11]a ) , although some questions on systematic errors in both methods have not been fully settled .
nevertheless , the qualitative agreement between these quite different approaches is satisfactory . for the case of heterogeneous nucleation , however , for a given supersaturation the critical cluster volume predicted from cluster kinetics ( fig .
[ fig10 ] ) is distinctly larger than the corresponding results from the static methods .
we have no explanation for this discrepancy .
in the present work , we have studied aspects of nucleation theory by simulation of clusters and their dynamics , using the ising ( lattice gas ) model on the simple cubic lattice . both homogeneous nucleation and heterogeneous nucleation at planar walls ( where a `` surface field '' acts ) have been considered . although many aspects of this problem have been studied before in works of various groups extending over several decades ,
most of the previous work is inconclusive since it relied on the use of the `` geometric '' cluster definition .
we have given evidence that this geometric cluster definition does not yield correct results for large clusters at the temperatures far above the roughening transition temperature where the clusters have spherical shape ; at temperatures below the roughening transition temperature the geometric clusters and the `` physical clusters '' are basically indistinguishable , but due to the pronounced anisotropy effects a simple analysis of nucleation phenomena is not possible .
however , in the limit of large droplet volumes @xmath274 , where one can neglect any corrections to the decomposition of the droplet formation free energy into the bulk term plus a surface correction , one can compute the nucleation free energy barrier @xmath0 from measuring the excess chemical potential @xmath98 that is in equilibrium with a given @xmath192 . fig .
[ fig : vcntvsvlr ] shows the enhancement of @xmath0 with respect to the standard result for spherical droplets ( using eqs . , ) .
we thus show that in the ising ( lattice gas ) model this enhancement gradually rises from unity as the temperature is lowered from the critical temperature , reaches almost 10% at @xmath275 , and rises steeply below the roughening temperature towards the low temperature limit @xmath276 ( fig .
[ fig : vcntvsvlr ] ) .
this enhancement reflects the consequences of the anisotropy of the interfacial free energy , such as the gradual crossover of the droplet shape from a sphere to a cube ( fig .
[ fig6 ] ) . on the other hand , we demonstrate that physical clusters do give consistent results , at least in the bulk when one is concerned with homogeneous nucleation .
we show that in the limit where the droplets get macroscopically large , they converge against the simple lever rule predictions .
however , we do find an ( unexpected ) surface excess in the particle number of such clusters also in this case .
we also demonstrate the validity of the relation between chemical potential ( of the supersaturated vapor ) and the droplet radius that classical nucleation theory predicts for large droplets near the critical temperature . we also give evidence that the droplet - vapor interface is broadened due to capillary waves ; we remind the reader that mean - field type theories and density functional theories @xcite can not include such capillary wave effects ( which also should give rise to a correction term on the droplet formation free energy ,
not yet included in eq . ) .
we would also like to stress that many of our considerations can be carried over to a study of clusters in @xmath277 dimensions , where a construction as in fig .
[ fig1 ] also holds . however , we expect two distinctions : ( i ) the roughening transition temperature @xmath38 is zero , so the crossover of droplet shape from the circle to the square occurs without any singularity even for arbitrarily large droplets .
( ii ) percolation coincides with the critical point , but geometrical clusters still are too large , and to describe nucleation , physical clusters defined via eq .
should also be used . of course
, it would be very desirable to carry these considerations over to nucleation in off - lattice models of fluids .
however , a precise analogue of eq . is still not known , and hence other concepts to define physical clusters @xcite need to be used , if one wishes to study nucleation near the critical point . in the second part we present a first study of the time evolution of the cluster population based on the `` physical cluster '' definition .
however , due to the large computer resources needed for this study , only data at a single temperature ( @xmath130 ) are presented . in order to allow a comparison of this part of the study with our results on static properties of critical droplets ,
as studied in the first part of the paper , we use a criterion to estimate the critical droplet size from the balance between droplet growth and shrinking processes . in the case of homogeneous nucleation ,
the results obtained in this way are roughly compatible with the results obtained from the static lever rule method . studying droplet volumes in the range from 100 to 200 , clear deviations from the classical nucleation theory are seen , which can be attributed to a decrease of the nucleation barrier due to fluctuation effects . however , in the case of heterogeneous nucleation , a rather large discrepancy between the results of the statics and dynamics of droplets is found .
this discrepancy is not understood yet , and must be left as a challenging problem for the future . * acknowledgements * : we thank d. winter for providing us with the data from ref .
@xcite that were included in fig . [ fig11 ] for comparison .
one of us ( f. s. ) thanks the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft for partial support under grant no vi 237/4 - 3 ( spp 1296 ) .
999 m. volmer and a. weber , z. phys .
chem . * 119 * , 277 ( 1926 ) r. becker and w. dring , ann .
* 416 * , 719 ( 1935 ) yu . b. zeldovich , acta physicochim .
urss * 18 * , 1 ( 1943 ) j. feder , k. c. russell , j. lothe , and g. m. pound , adv . phys . *
15 * , 111 ( 1966 ) h. reiss , j. l. katz , and e. r. cohen , j. stat
. phys . * 2 * , 83 ( 1968 ) j. s. langer , ann .
* 41 * , 108 ( 1967 ) ; ann .
phys . * 54 * , 258 ( 1969 ) _ nucleation _ , edited a. c. zettlemoyer ( m. dekker , new york , 1969 ) f. f. abraham , _ homogeneous nucleation theory _
( academic , new york , 1974 ) k. binder and d. stauffer , adv .
phys . * 25 * , 343 ( 1976 ) k. binder , rep .
* 50 * , 783 ( 1987 ) d. w. oxtoby and r. evans , j. chem .
phys . * 89 * , 7521 ( 1988 ) a. dillmann and g. e. a. meier , chem .
89 * , 71 ( 1989 ) h. reis , a. tabazadeh , and j. talbot , j. chem
. phys . * 92 * , 1266 ( 1990 ) d. w. oxtoby , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 4 * , 7627 ( 1992 ) a. laaksonen , v. talanquer , and d. w. oxtoby , annu .
phys . chem . *
46 * , 489 ( 1995 ) p.
r. ten wolde and d. frenkel , j. chem .
phys . * 109 * , 9901 ( 1998 ) d. kashchiev , _ nucleation , basic theory with applications _
( butterworth - heinemann , oxford , 2000 ) a. c. pan and d. chandler , j. phys .
b * 108 * , 19681 ( 2004 ) nucleation , _ comptes rendus physique _ , vol . 7
( 2006 ) , special issue , edited by s. balibar and j. villain .
k. binder , in _ kinetics of phase transitions _ , edited by s. puri and v. wadhavan ( crc press , boca raton , 2009 ) , chap .
2 m. schrader , p. virnau , and k. binder , phys .
e * 79 * , 061104 ( 2009 ) s. ryu and w. cai , phys .
e * 81 * , 030601(r ) ( 2010 ) b. j. block , s. k. das , m. oettel , p. virnau and k. binder , j. chem .
phys . * 133 * , 154702 ( 2010 ) a. troester , m. oettel , b. block , p. virnau and k. binder , j. chem . phys . * 136 * , 064709 ( 2012 ) y. vilsanen , r. strey , and h. reiss , j. chem
. phys . * 99 * , 4680 ( 1993 ) a. fladerer and r. strey , j. chem . phys .
* 124 * , 164710 ( 2006 ) k. iland , j. wlk , r. strey and d. kashchiev , j. chem . phys . * 127 * , 154506 ( 2007 ) d. turnbull , j. appl . phys . * 21 * , 1022 ( 1950 ) d. turnbull , j. chem .
* 18 * , 198 ( 1950 ) a. w. castleman , adv .
colloid interface sci .
* 10 * , 73 ( 1979 h. biloni , in _ physical metallurgy _
( r. w. cahn and p. haaasen , eds ) amsterdam , north - holland , 1983 ) p. 477
j. curtius , comptes rendus phys . * 7 * , 1027 ( 2006 ) k. binder and h. mller - krumbhaar , phys .
rev . b**9 * * , 2328 ( 1974 ) j. s. rowlinson and b. widom , _ molecular theory of capillarity _
( oxford univ . press , oxford , 1982 )
k. binder and d. stauffer , j. stat .
* 6 * , 49 ( 1972 ) k. binder and e. stoll , phys .
lett . * 31 * , 47 ( 1973 ) k. binder and m. h. kalos , j. stat . phys . * 22 * , 363 ( 1980 ) d. stauffer , a. coniglio , and d. w. heermann , phys .
* 49 * , 1299 ( 1982 ) d. stauffer , int . j. mod .
phys . c**3 * * , 1071 ( 1992 ) h. furukawa and k. binder , phys . rev .
a * 26 * , 556 ( 1982 ) j. marro and r. toral , physica * 122a * , 563 ( 1983 ) o. penrose , j. lebowitz , j. marro , m. kalos , and j. tobochnik , j. stat . phys . * 34 * , 399 ( 1984 ) d. w. heermann , a. coniglio , w. klein , and d. stauffer , j. stat . phys . * 36 * , 447 ( 1984 ) h. tomita and s. miyashita , phys .
b * 46 * , 8886 ( 1992 ) p. a. rikvold , h. tomita , s. miyashita , and s. w. sides , phys .
e * 49 * , 5080 ( 1994 ) p. a. rikvold , and b. m. gorman , in _ annual reviews of computational physics , vol . 1 _
( d. stauffer , ed . )
( world scientific , singapore , 1994 ) m. acharyya and d. stauffer , eur .
j. b * 5 * , 571 ( 1998 ) h. vehkamaki and i. j. ford , phys .
e * 59 * , 6483 ( 1999 ) v. a. shneidman , k. a. jackson , and k. m. beatty , phys .
rev . b**59 * * , 3579 ( 1999 ) v. a. shneidman , k. a. jackson , and k. m. beatty , j. chem .
* 11 * , 6932 ( 1999 ) r. a. ramos , p. a. rikvold , and m. a. novotny , phys .
b * 59 * , 9053 ( 1999 ) s. wonczak , r. strey , and d. stauffer , j. chem . phys . *
113 * , 1976 ( 2000 ) a. t. bustillos , d. w. heermann and c. e. cordeiro , j. chem . phys . * 121 * , 4864 ( 2004 ) k. brendel , g. t. barkema , and h. van beijeren , phys . rev .
e * 71 * , 031601 ( 2005 ) d. winter , p. virnau and k. binder , j. phys .
: condens .
matter * 21 * , 464118 ( 2009 ) d. winter , p. virnau and k. binder , phys .
* 103 * , 225703 ( 2009 ) h. mller - krumbhaar , phys
50a * , 27 ( 1974 ) k. binder , ann . phys .
* 98 * , 390 ( 1976 ) a. coniglio and w. klein , j. phys . a**13 * * , 2775 ( 1980 ) r. h. swendsen and j. s. wang , phys . rev
. lett . * 58 * , 86 ( 1987 ) m. donorio de meo , d. w. heermann , and k. binder , j. stat . phys . *
60 * , 585 ( 1990 ) a. coniglio , j. phys . * a8 * , 1773 ( 1975 ) a. coniglio , f. peruggi , c. nappi and l. russo , j. phys .
a**10 * * , 205 ( 1977 ) k. binder , solid state commun . * 34 * , 191 ( 1980 ) s. hayward , d. w. heermann , and k. binder , j. stat . phys . *
49 * , 1053 ( 1987 ) p. w. kasteleyn and c. m. fortuin , j. phys .
japan * 26 * ( suppl ) 11 ( 1969 ) c. m. fortuin and p. w. kasteleyn , physica * 57 * , 536 ( 1972 ) u. wolff , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 361 ( 1989 ) k. kawasaki , in _ phase transitions and critical phenomena , vol . 2 _ ( c. domb and m. s. green , eds . ) ( academic press , london , 1972 ) h. mller - krumbhaar and k. binder , j. stat . phys . * 8 * , 1 ( 1973 ) j. d. weeks , in _ ordering in strongly fluctuating condensed matter systems _ ( t. riste , ed . ) p. 293
( plenum press , new york , 1980 ) h. van beijeren and i. nolden , in _ structure and dynamics of surfaces ii _ ( w. schommers and p. blanckenhagen , eds . ) p. 259
( springer , berlin 1987 ) g. wulff , z. kristallogr . mineral . * 34 * , 449 ( 1901 ) c. herring , phys .
82 * , 87 ( 1951 ) c. rottman and m. wortis , phys .
b * 24 * , 6274 ( 1981 ) m. holzer , phys . rev .
b * 42 * , 10570 ( 1990 ) k. k. mon , s. wansleben , d. p. landau and k. binder , phys . rev .
b * 39 * , 7089 ( 1989 ) m. hasenbusch and k. pinn , j. phys . a * 30 * , 63 ( 1997 )
a. m. ferrenberg and d. p. landau , phys .
b * 44 * , 5081 ( 1991 ) v. privman , phys . rev . lett . *
61 * , 183 ( 1988 ) m. hasenbusch and k. pinn , physica a * 192 * , 342 ( 1993 ) m. hasenbusch and k. pinn , physica a * 203 * , 189 ( 1994 ) d. p. landau and k. binder , _ a guide to monte carlo simulation in statistical physics , 3rd ed _
( cambridge univ . press ,
cambridge 2009 ) k. binder and d. w. heermann , _ monte carlo simulation in statistical physics : an introduction_. 5th ed .
( springer , berlin 2010 ) k. binder , physica a * 319 * , 99 ( 2003 ) d. stauffer and a. aharony , _ introduction to percolation theory _ ( taylor and francis , london , 1994 ) b. widom , j. chem .
phys . * 39 * , 2808 ( 1963 ) b. widom , j. phys . chem . * 86 * , 869 ( 1982 ) f. schmitz , _ diploma thesis _
( johannes gutenberg - universitt mainz , 2011 , unpublished . ) p. virnau , m. mller , j. chem . phys . * 120 * , 10925 ( 2004 ) p. virnau , m. mller , l. g. macdowell , k. binder , j. chem . phys . * 121 * , 2169 ( 2004 ) l. g. macdowell , p. virnau , m. mller , and k. binder , j. chem .
phys . , 5293 ( 2004 ) b. a. berg , t. neuhaus , phys .
lett . * 68 * , 9 ( 1992 ) f. wang and d. p. landau , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 2050 ( 2001 ) f. wang and d. p. landau , phys .
e * 64 * , 056101 ( 2001 ) s. k. das and k. binder , phys .
lett . * 107 * , 235702 ( 2011 ) m. p. a. fisher and m. wortis , phys .
b * 29 * , 6252 ( 1984 ) d. jasnov , rep .
* 47 * , 1059 ( 1984 ) k. binder , m. mller , f. schmid , and a. werner , adv .
colloid and interface science * 94 * , 237 ( 2001 ) k. binder and m. mller , int .
c * 11 * , 1093 ( 2000 ) g. v. wulff , z. kristallogr
. mineral . * 34 * , 449 ( 1901 ) | the conventional theory of homogeneous and heterogeneous nucleation in a supersaturated vapor is tested by monte carlo simulations of the lattice gas ( ising ) model with nearest - neighbor attractive interactions on the simple cubic lattice .
the theory considers the nucleation process as a slow ( quasi - static ) cluster ( droplet ) growth over a free energy barrier @xmath0 , constructed in terms of a balance of surface and bulk term of a `` critical droplet '' of radius @xmath1 , implying that the rates of droplet growth and shrinking essentially balance each other for droplet radius @xmath2 . for heterogeneous nucleation at surfaces ,
the barrier is reduced by a factor depending on the contact angle . using the definition of `` physical '' clusters based on the fortuin - kasteleyn mapping ,
the time - dependence of the cluster size distribution is studied for `` quenching experiments '' in the kinetic ising model , and the cluster size @xmath3 where the cluster growth rate changes sign is estimated .
these studies of nucleation kinetics are compared to studies where the relation between cluster size and supersaturation is estimated from equilibrium simulations of phase coexistence between droplet and vapor in the canonical ensemble .
the chemical potential is estimated from a lattice version of the widom particle insertion method . for large droplets
it is shown that the `` physical clusters '' have a volume consistent with the estimates from the lever rule .
`` geometrical clusters '' ( defined such that each site belonging to the cluster is occupied and has at least one occupied neighbor site ) yield valid results only for temperatures less than 60% of the critical temperature , where the cluster shape is non - spherical .
we show how the chemical potential can be used to numerically estimate @xmath0 also for non - spherical cluster shapes . |
while general relativity and quantum mechanics are successful in their applicability domains , it seems that there is a fundamental incompatibility between them in order to find the so - called quantum theory of gravity .
such a theory , not completely formulated so far , would reasonably describe the structure of spacetime at the planck scale where both of the gravitational and quantum mechanical effects become important . despite the fact that there is no unique approach to quantum gravity , existence of a universal minimum measurable length , preferably of the order of the planck length @xmath3 , is a common feature of quantum gravity candidates such as string theory and loop quantum gravity @xcite .
it is then widely believed that a non - gravitational theory which includes a universal minimal length scale would appear at the flat limit of quantum gravity .
therefore , many attempts have been done in order to take into account a minimal length scale in the well - known non - gravitational theories such as quantum mechanics and special relativity .
the generalized uncertainty principle is investigated in the context of the string theory that supports the existence of a minimal length as a nonzero uncertainty in position measurement @xcite .
quantum field theories turn out to be naturally ultraviolet - regularized in this setup @xcite .
inspired by the seminal work of snyder in 1947 who was formulated a lorentz - invariant noncommutative spacetime @xcite , a phase space with noncanonical symplectic structure is formulated in the non - relativistic limit @xcite . at the quantum level
, this deformed phase space leads to the modified uncertainty relation which is very similar to one arises from the string theory motivations @xcite .
furthermore , recently , polymer quantum mechanics is suggested in the symmetric sector of loop quantum gravity which supports the existence of a minimal length scale known as the polymer length scale @xcite .
also , the doubly special relativity theories are investigated in order to take into account a minimal observer - independent length scale in special relativity @xcite .
appearance of curved energy - momentum space is the direct consequence of the doubly special relativity theories @xcite and , interestingly , the snyder noncommutative spacetime could be also realized in this setup by a relevant gauge fixing process @xcite .
apart from the details of the above mentioned phenomenological models as a flat limit for quantum gravity , all of them suggest the deformation to the density of states at the high energy regime which in turn leads to the nonuniform measure over the set of microstates .
indeed , in these setups , the number of accessible microstates will be reduced at the high energy regime due to the existence of a minimal length as an ultraviolet cutoff for the system under consideration .
reduction of the number of degrees of freedom , however , immediately suggests an effective dimensional reduction of the space .
this consequence seems to be a general feature of quantum gravity which may also open new window for the statistical origin of black holes thermodynamics @xcite .
thermodynamics of black holes are widely studied in the frameworks of phenomenological quantum gravity models such as noncommutative space @xcite , generalized uncertainty principle @xcite and polymer quantization scenario @xcite .
the reduction of the number of accessible microstates due to the universal quantum gravitational effects would also significantly change the thermodynamical properties of any physical system at the high temperature regime .
therefore , quantum gravity effects on the thermodynamics of various statistical systems are widely studied in different contexts @xcite . for the special case of the ideal gas ,
it is natural to expect that the quantum gravity effects would become important at the high temperature regime , when the corresponding thermal de broglie wavelength @xmath4 becomes of the order of the planck length @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the particles mass and @xmath7 denotes the temperature , where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the boltzmann constant and speed of light in vacuum respectively . ] .
the associated thermodynamical properties then will be significantly modified in this regime .
thermodynamics of the ideal quantum gases in noncommutative space are studied in refs .
@xcite and for the case of the effects that arise from the generalized uncertainty principle see ref .
thermodynamical properties of the ideal gas in polymerized phase space , as a classical limit of a polymer quantum mechanics , is also studied in refs .
@xcite . for the case of the relativistic ideal gases in doubly special relativity framework
@xcite . motivated by the above stated issues , in this paper we study the thermodynamical properties of the ideal gas in snyder space .
the structure of the paper is as follows : in section 2 , the statistical mechanics in the snyder space is formulated and the corresponding partition function is found . using the partition function , thermodynamics of the ideal gas
is studied in section 3 .
section 4 is devoted to the summary and conclusions .
the kinematics and dynamics of a classical system on the phase space provide a suitable framework for formulating the statistical mechanics in the semiclassical regime .
the key quantity is the liouville volume that determines the density of states from which all the thermodynamical properties of a system could be achieved . in this section , using the symplectic geometry , we formulate the statistical mechanics in snyder space .
inspired by the seminal work of snyder on noncommutative spacetime @xcite , the associated deformed phase space is formulated which also supports the existence of a minimal length @xcite .
a phase space naturally admits symplectic structure and therefore is a symplectic manifold .
suppose that @xmath10 to be a snyder - deformed phase space with @xmath11 as the associated symplectic structure which is a closed nondegenerate @xmath12-form on @xmath13 .
the local form of the symplectic structure in snyder model is given by @xcite @xmath14\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the position and momentum coordinates of a particle with @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
@xmath19 is the deformation parameter with dimension of length which is usually taken to be of the order of the planck length as @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the dimensionless numerical constant that should be fixed only with experiment @xcite . taking the low energy limit @xmath22 in the relation ( [ snyder - symplectic ] ) , the standard well - known canonical form of the symplectic structure could be recovered .
since the symplectic structure is nondegenerate by definition , one can assign a unique vector field @xmath23 to any function @xmath24 on @xmath13 as @xmath25 .
the poisson bracket for two real - valued functions is defined as @xmath26 from the above definition , it is straightforward to show that the symplectic structure ( [ snyder - symplectic ] ) generates the following noncanonical poisson algebra @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the generator of the rotation group in three dimensions with @xmath29 .
the symplectic structure ( [ snyder - symplectic ] ) or equivalently the poisson algebra ( [ snyder a ] ) properly defines the kinematics of the phase space @xmath13 in snyder model .
the dynamics of the system will be determined by specifying a hamiltonian function @xmath30 as the generator of time evolution of the system . the hamiltonian system on the phase space is then defined by the triplet @xmath31 and the dynamical evolution of the system is governed by the equation @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the hamiltonian vector field and it s integral curves are nothing but the hamilton s equations in this setup ( see ref .
@xcite for more details ) .
furthermore , the natural volume on the phase space is the liouville volume which for a @xmath34-dimensional phase space is defined as @xmath35 the liouville volume for a particle in snyder - deformed phase space then could be easily obtained by substituting the symplectic structure ( [ snyder - symplectic ] ) into the definition ( [ vol ] ) which gives @xmath36 the phase space ( liouville ) volume determines the density of states and then the number of accessible microstates for a statistical system .
it is important to check the verification of the liouville theorem for the snyder measure ( [ snyder - measure ] ) in order to formulate the statistical mechanics in snyder - deformed phase space .
the liouville theorem states that the liouville volume is invariant under the time evolution of the system @xmath37 where @xmath38 denotes the lie derivative with respect to @xmath39 .
the relation ( [ liouvillee ] ) can be traced back to the facts that @xmath40 is not explicitly time - dependent , @xmath41 and @xmath42 , where we have used the equation ( [ dynamic ] ) as @xmath43 and the closure of the symplectic structure @xmath44 . the result ( [ liouvillee ] ) for the snyder measure ( [ snyder - measure ] ) is essential for us to formulate the statistical mechanics in snyder space . before obtaining the partition function , from which all the thermodynamical properties of a system can be obtained ,
we first make a qualitative discussion about the number of microstates in snyder - deformed phase space regardless of the ensemble density and the hamiltonian function .
the number of microstates for a single - particle phase space is given by @xmath45 where we have considered a region of phase space in which the condition @xmath46 , with @xmath47 is satisfied in order to have a finite number of microstates . the quantity ( [ nm ] ) for a system with non - deformed phase space is @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is the spatial volume of the system under consideration .
for the case of the snyder - deformed phase space , substituting the liouville volume ( [ snyder - measure ] ) into the relation ( [ nm ] ) , it works out as @xmath50\big)\,.\ ] ] for the low energy regime with @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) , the relation ( [ snyder - nm ] ) for the number of microstates behaves as @xmath53 which shows that it correctly coincides with the standard result of the non - deformed case in this regime . for the high energy regime @xmath54 ( @xmath55 ) , however , the number of microstates ( [ snyder - nm ] ) behaves linearly with @xmath56 as @xmath57 ( see also figure [ fig:0 ] , where the number of microstates ( [ snyder - nm ] ) versus @xmath56 is plotted and also it is compared with the standard non - deformed case ) .
this result shows that , at the high energy regime when the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects dominate , the number of microstates will be drastically decreased .
since the number of microstates for a standard one - dimensional particle ( with two dimensional phase space ) behaves linearly with the momentum , one could conclude that two degrees of freedom will be frozen at the high energy regime and therefore a particle has only one degree of freedom in this regime .
this result suggests an effective dimensional reduction of the space from @xmath1 to @xmath2 dimension at the high energy regime in snyder model .
although this result is qualitatively obtained here for a general system ( without specifying a hamiltonian function and ensemble density ) , we will explicitly justify this result in the next section for the particular case of an ideal gas in canonical ensemble in the light of the well - known equipartition theorem of energy .
+ 15em the number of microstates versus the momentum @xmath56 for a single - particle phase space .
the blue solid and red dot - dashed lines represent the number of microstates in the snyder - deformed and non - deformed phase spaces respectively .
clearly , these two curves coincide at the low energy regime @xmath51 ( @xmath58 ) and the deviation arises at the high energy regime @xmath54 ( @xmath59 ) .
the number of microstates in the snyder - deformed case effectively behaves like a one - dimensional single - particle phase space ( the black dashed line ) which shows that two degrees of freedom freeze at the high energy regime due to the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects .
this result suggests an effective dimensional reduction of the space from @xmath1 to @xmath2 dimension at the high energy regime .
the figure is plotted for @xmath60 with @xmath61 and @xmath62.,title="fig:",width=288 ] in order to study statistical mechanics in this framework , we generalize this setup to a many - particle system .
consider a statistical system consisting of @xmath63 particles .
the corresponding kinematical phase space can be obtained by the direct coupling of the single - particle phase spaces as @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the symplectic structure on the phase space of the @xmath66-th particle , @xmath67 .
substituting the symplectic structure ( [ gamma - tot ] ) into the definition ( [ vol ] ) , the corresponding @xmath68-dimensional liouville volume will be @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the six - dimensional liouville volume corresponding to the @xmath66-th particle phase space and we have also used the fact that @xmath71 for @xmath72 , with @xmath73 being the @xmath74-th component of the @xmath66-th particle s liouville volume .
the quantum gravity parameter @xmath19 is universal and it will be the same for all the particles . therefore , the symplectic structure for all of the particles in snyder - deformed phase space is given by ( [ snyder - symplectic ] ) and the liouville volume is then given by ( [ snyder - measure ] ) . substituting the liouville volume ( [ snyder - measure ] ) for all of the particles in the relation ( [ vol - tot ] )
gives @xmath75 where clearly the standard volume @xmath76 for the non - deformed @xmath68-dimensional phase space could be recovered in the low energy limit @xmath22 . while the non - deformed phase space volume assigns a uniform probability distribution over the set of microstates , the snyder - deformed phase space volume ( [ snyder - vol ] ) assigns a nonuniform probability distribution at the high energy regime such that the microstates with higher energy are less probable .
more precisely , in the absence of any extra information for the system , the laplace principle of indifference states that all the microstates are equally likely @xcite .
however , in the presence of a minimal length , as an extra information for the system , the sufficient condition for the laplace s indifference principle is no longer satisfied in the snyder model .
the liouville volume ( [ snyder - vol ] ) is invariant under the time evolution of the system on @xmath77 which can be easily deduced from the relation ( [ liouvillee ] ) .
thus the liouville theorem is satisfied on the phase space of the @xmath63-particle system @xmath78 which allows us to study the statistical mechanics in this setup . the canonical partition function for a system at the temperature @xmath7 in snyder model
then will be @xmath79\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the gibbs factor @xmath80 is also considered . for a system in which the particles do not interact
, the total hamiltonian function could be decomposed as @xmath81 and the partition function ( [ pf - tot ] ) simplifies to @xmath82 where we have defined the single - particle partition function as @xmath83\,=\frac{1}{h^3}\int{d^3q}\int\frac{d^3p}{\big(1 + \beta^2p^2\big)}\,\exp\big[-h(q , p)/t\big].\ ] ] having the partition function ( [ snyder - pf - tot ] ) in hand , one could easily study the thermodynamical properties of the statistical systems in snyder space .
in this section we study the thermodynamical properties of the ideal gas by means of the results obtained in pervious section . by considering an ideal gas consisting of @xmath63 noninteracting particles confined in volume @xmath49 at the temperature @xmath7
, the corresponding single - particle partition function can be easily obtained from the relation ( [ snyder - pf ] ) as @xmath84=\frac{4\pi{v}}{h^3}\int_{0}^{\infty } \frac{\exp\big[-\frac{p^2}{2mt}\big]p^2dp}{\big(1+\beta^2 p^2\big)}=\frac{v\pi^{\frac{3}{2}}}{h^3\beta^3 } \bigg(\sqrt{2mt}\beta-\sqrt{\pi}\,\mbox{erfc}\bigg[\frac { 1}{\sqrt{2mt}\beta}\bigg]\exp\bigg[\frac{1}{2mt\beta^2 } \bigg]\bigg)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath85=(2/\sqrt{\pi})\int_{x}^{\infty}e^ { -t^2}dt$ ] is the complementary error function and also we have substituted @xmath86 for the hamiltonian function . to understand the qualitative behavior of the partition function ( [ pf0 ] ) , it is useful to rewrite the partition function in terms of the thermal wave length @xmath87 as @xmath88=\frac{v}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^3 } \bigg(\frac{\lambda_{_{pl}}}{\lambda}-\sqrt{\pi}\ , \mbox{erfc}\bigg[\frac{\lambda}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}}\bigg ] \exp\bigg[\frac{\lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\bigg ] \bigg)\,,\ ] ] where we have substituted @xmath89 and
also we have defined _ planck scale thermal de broglie wavelength _
@xmath90 where as we have mentioned before @xmath91 should be fixed by experiment @xcite .
expanding partition function ( [ pf ] ) for both the low and high temperature regimes gives @xmath92= \left\ { \begin{array}{ll } \frac{v}{\lambda^3 } & \hspace{.5cm}\lambda \gg\lambda_{_{\rm pl}},\\\\ \frac{v}{\lambda\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2 } & \hspace{.5cm}\lambda\sim\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}. \end{array } \right.\ ] ] as it is clear from the above relation , quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects are negligible at the low temperature limit @xmath93 and the standard result for the partition function of the ideal gas is recovered .
interestingly , the high - temperature behavior of the partition function ( [ pf0-exp ] ) shows that two degrees of freedom will be frozen at the planck scale @xmath94 and there is only one degree of freedom for a particle in this regime .
this feature , as we will show , leads to the effective reduction of the dimension of space at the high temperature regime . from the relation ( [ snyder - pf - tot ] ) , the total partition function for the ideal gas in snyder space will be @xmath95=\frac{\big(v/\lambda _ { _ { \rm pl}}^3\big)^n}{n!}\bigg(\frac{\lambda_{_{\rm pl } } } { \lambda}-\sqrt{\pi}\,\mbox{erfc}\bigg[\frac { \lambda}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}}\bigg]\exp\bigg[\frac { \lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\bigg]\bigg)^n\,,\ ] ] from which all of the thermodynamical quantities could be derived through the standard definitions .
the helmholtz free energy @xmath96 is defined as @xmath97\big]=-nt \left\{1+\ln\bigg[\frac{v}{n\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^3 } \bigg(\frac{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}}{\lambda}-\sqrt { \pi}\,\mbox{erfc}\bigg[\frac{\lambda}{\lambda _ { _ { \rm pl}}}\bigg]\exp\bigg[\frac{\lambda^2 } { \lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\bigg]\bigg)\bigg]\right\}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the stirling s formula @xmath98 \approx n\ln[n]-n$ ] for large @xmath63 . from the modified helmholtz free energy ( [ helmholtz ] ) ,
the internal energy for the ideal gas gets modified as @xmath99\exp\bigg[\frac { \lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\bigg]\bigg)^ { -1}-\frac{\lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2 } \right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the internal energy versus the temperature is plotted in figure [ fig:1 ] . as it is clear from the figure , while the internal energy of the standard ideal gas increases linearly with the temperature as @xmath100 , which is shown by the red dot - dashed line in the figure , the internal energy increases with a decreasing rate at the high temperature regime ( the blue solid line in the figure ) where the associated thermal de broglie wavelength approaches to the planck length @xmath101 .
+ 15em internal energy versus temperature .
the blue solid and red dot - dashed lines represent the internal energy in snyder - deformed and non - deformed phase spaces respectively .
as the temperature increases , the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects become more and more appreciable.,title="fig:",width=288 ] expanding the relation ( [ energy ] ) for both low and high temperature regimes gives @xmath102 the high temperature behavior of the internal energy in snyder model could be also more precisely understood from the specific heat that is defined as @xmath103 \exp\big[\frac{\lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl } } ^2}\big]}{\bigg(2-\sqrt{\pi}\,\big(\frac { \lambda}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}}\big)\mbox { erfc}\big[\frac{\lambda}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl } } } \big]\exp\big[\frac{\lambda^2 } { \lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\big]\bigg)^2}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the temperature - dependent behavior of this quantity is plotted in figure [ fig:2 ] . expanding the specific heat ( [ s - heat ] ) for low and high temperature regimes gives @xmath104 which shows that the specific heat approaches to @xmath105 at the high temperature limit ( see also figure [ fig:2 ] ) . as it is clear from figure [ fig:2 ] , the specific heat is bounded as @xmath106 in this setup .
+ 15em specific heat versus the temperature .
the blue solid and red dot - dashed lines represent the specific heat in snyder - deformed and non - deformed phase spaces respectively .
while the specific heat is independent of the temperature as @xmath107 for the case of standard ideal gas , it becomes temperature - dependent at the high energy regime in snyder model .
it asymptotically leads to the value @xmath108 at the very high temperature regime which signals the effective dimensional reduction of space from @xmath1 to @xmath2 dimension in this setup .
it is also clear from the figure that the specific heat is bounded as @xmath109 in snyder model.,title="fig:",width=288 ] in order to understand the reduction of the number of degrees of freedom in a more precise manner , we invoke the well - known theorem of _ equipartition of energy _ which states that each number of degree of freedom makes a contribution of @xmath110 towards the internal energy and @xmath111 towards the specific heat . from the relations ( [ energy - exp ] ) and ( [ s - heat - exp ] ) , it is clear that the number of degrees of freedom for the ideal gas consisting of @xmath63 noninteracting particles which move on three - dimensional euclidean space @xmath112 ( with @xmath113 configuration space ) , will be reduced from @xmath114 to @xmath63 at the high temperature regime when the thermal de broglie wavelength of the system becomes of the order of the planck length @xmath115 . in other words , there is one degree of freedom for a particle at such a high temperature regime and two degrees of freedom will be frozen due to the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects .
see also figure [ fig:3 ] which shows the temperature - dependent behavior of the number of degrees freedom @xmath116 for a particle in snyder model .
therefore , according to the equipartition theorem , the number of degrees of freedom for a particle is reduced from @xmath1 to @xmath2 at the high temperature regime in the snyder space .
this result suggests an effective high temperature dimensional reduction of space from @xmath1 to @xmath2 dimension in the snyder model .
similar results have been obtained in the context of the other phenomenological approaches to minimal length scenario .
for instance , in the context of the doubly special relativity theories , it is shown that the total number of degrees of freedom will be finite at the high temperature regime which shows that all of the degrees of freedom will be frozen in this setup @xcite .
the associated phase space then will be compact ( with finite liouville volume ) @xcite and the corresponding hilbert space is also finite dimensional @xcite ( see ref .
@xcite for some cosmological consequences of such a framework ) . furthermore , in the context of polymer quantization
, it is shown that the energy density of the photon gas will be proportional to @xmath117 rather than the standard stephan - boltzmann law that states the energy density will be proportional to @xmath118 @xcite .
this result also suggests an effective reduction to @xmath119 dimensional space at the planck scale .
thus , the dimensional reduction at the planck scale seems to be a common feature of quantum gravity proposal @xcite .
+ 15em number of degrees of freedom versus the temperature .
the classical equipartition theorem of energy states that the number of degrees of freedom for a particle is given by @xmath116 .
thus , as it is clear from the figure , the number of degrees of freedom will be reduced from @xmath1 to @xmath2 at the high temperature regime in snyder space .
this result suggests an effective dimensional reduction of space from @xmath1 to @xmath2 dimension.,title="fig:",width=288 ] the thermal pressure could be obtained from the helmholtz energy ( [ helmholtz ] ) as @xmath120 which shows that the equation of state relation preserves its standard form @xmath121 in this setup . from the relations ( [ energy ] ) and ( [ pressure ] ) , the equation of state parameter @xmath122 works out to be @xmath123\exp \bigg[\frac{\lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2 } \bigg]\bigg)^{-1}-\frac{\lambda^2}{\lambda _ { _ { \rm pl}}^2}\right\}^{-1}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the temperature behavior of the equation of state parameter ( [ w ] ) is plotted in figure [ fig:4 ] .
the equation of state parameter is constant as @xmath124 for the standard ideal gas . but , as it is clear from figure [ fig:4 ] , it becomes temperature - dependent in snyder model at the high temperature regime .
the standard result @xmath124 can be recovered at the low temperature regime @xmath125 and also @xmath126 at the high temperature regime @xmath127 .
thus , generally we have @xmath128 which could be seen from figure [ fig:4 ] ( see also refs . @xcite and @xcite where the same results are obtained in the contexts of polymer quantization and holography respectively . )
+ 15em equation of state parameter versus the temperature .
while the equation of state parameter is constant as @xmath129 for the standard ideal gas , it turns out to be temperature - dependent quantity in snyder space .
as it is clear from the figure , it approaches to @xmath130 at the very high temperature regime when the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects dominate .
the figure shows also that @xmath128.,title="fig:",width=288 ] as the final thermodynamical quantity , one could obtain the modification to the entropy from the minimal length effects .
the entropy , however , is directly related to the number of accessible microstates and it is then natural to expect that the entropy increases with a rate smaller than the standard non - deformed case at the high temperature regime since we have shown that the number of accessible microstates will be decreased at the high temperature regime in snyder space .
the direct calculation of the entropy justifies this claim . from the helmholtz free energy ( [ helmholtz ] )
, the entropy of the ideal gas will be @xmath131\exp\bigg [ \frac{\lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\bigg ] \bigg)\bigg]\nonumber\\+\bigg(2 - 2\sqrt{\pi } \bigg(\frac{\lambda}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}}\bigg ) \mbox{erfc}\bigg[\frac{\lambda}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}}\bigg]\exp\bigg[\frac{\lambda^2 } { \lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}\bigg]\bigg)^{-1}-\frac { \lambda^2}{\lambda_{_{\rm pl}}^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in figure [ fig:5 ] , the temperature - dependent behavior of the ideal gas entropy ( [ entropy ] ) is plotted . as it is clear from the figure , in contrast to the non - deformed case , the entropy increases with smaller rate in the snyder model .
this result is also a direct consequence of the effective dimensional reduction of space from three to one dimension for a particle in the snyder space .
+ 15em entropy versus the temperature .
it is clear that , in the snyder model the entropy increases with a rate smaller than the standard non - deformed case .
this is because of the fact that the number of accessible microstates is decreased at the high temperature regime due to the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects.,title="fig:",width=288 ] although , as we have shown , the minimal length effects will become important only at the very high temperature regime when the thermal de broglie wavelength of the system becomes of the order of the planck length , it is also useful to consider the low temperature behavior in order to estimate the order of the magnitude of the quantum gravity effects on the thermodynamical quantities of the ideal gas .
it is straightforward to show that the first order quantum gravity corrections to all of the thermodynamical quantities such as the internal energy ( [ energy ] ) , specific heat ( [ s - heat ] ) , and entropy ( [ entropy ] ) are proportional to @xmath132 .
therefore , the thermal de broglie wavelength @xmath133 is an appropriate parameter to determine when quantum gravitational effects will become significant , much similar in the same way as pure quantum mechanical effects become important in the standard statistical mechanics .
indeed , the pure quantum mechanical effects will become important when the thermal de broglie wavelength becomes of the order of the mean interparticle distance @xmath134 .
similarly and much in the same way , quantum gravitational ( minimal length ) effects will become important when the thermal de broglie wavelength of the system becomes of the order of the planck length .
existence of a universal minimal length , preferably of the order of the planck length , is a common address of quantum gravity candidates such as string theory and loop quantum gravity . beside
, this issue could be achieved from the spaces with deformed structures . in this paper
, we formulated the statistical mechanics in snyder space in the semiclassical regime .
existence of a minimal length , as an extra information for the system under consideration , significantly changes the probability distribution over the set of microstates in this setup .
we obtained the corresponding deformed invariant liouville volume which determines the number of accessible microstates for a statistical system and we have found that @xmath0 of the degrees of freedom will be frozen at the high energy regime . generalizing the setup into a many - particle system
, we then obtained the modified partition function for the ideal gas in the maxwell - boltzmann statistics by means of the deformed liouville volume and we have calculated the associated thermodynamical quantities such as the internal energy , specific heat , equation of state parameter , and entropy in the snyder space .
the results show that at the high temperature regime , when the thermal de broglie wavelength becomes of the order of the planck length , the quantum gravity ( minimal length ) effects dominate which significantly change the thermodynamical properties of the ideal gas . invoking the equipartition theorem of energy
, we explicitly showed that @xmath0 of the number of degrees of freedom will be frozen at the high temperature regime for the special case of the ideal gas which also confirms our pervious claim .
this result suggests an effective dimensional reduction of the space from three to one dimension at the high temperature regime which is also a common feature in alternative approaches to quantum gravity proposal .
also , our analysis shows that @xmath135 and @xmath128 for the specific heat and the equation of state parameter respectively which are the direct consequences of the effective dimensional reduction of the space at the planck scale .
although the quantum gravity effects would become important only at the high temperature regime , considering the low temperature limit is useful to estimate the order of the magnitude of the quantum gravity corrections to the thermodynamical quantities . evidently , the first order corrections to the internal energy , specific heat , and entropy are of the order of @xmath132 , where @xmath136 is the planck scale thermal de broglie wavelength ( [ lambda - p ] ) and @xmath133 is the standard thermal de broglie wavelength .
d. j. gross and p. f. mende , nucl .
b * 303 * ( 1988 ) 407 + d. amati , m. ciafaloni and g. veneziano , phys .
b * 216 * ( 1989 ) 41 + m. kato , phys .
b * 245 * ( 1990 ) 43 + l. garay , int .
a * 10 * ( 1995 ) 145 . c. rovelli and l. smolin , nucl .
b * 331 * ( 1990 ) 80 + c. rovelli and l. smolin , nucl .
b * 442 * ( 1995 ) 593 + a. ashtekar and j. lewandowski , class .
quantum grav .
* 14 * ( 1997 ) a55 + a. ashtekar and j. lewandowski , class .
quantum grav .
* 21 * ( 2004 ) r53 .
m. maggiore , phys .
b * 319 * ( 1993 ) 83 + m. maggiore , phys .
d * 49 * ( 1994 ) 5182 + a. kempf , g. mangano and r. b. mann , phys .
d * 52 * ( 1995 ) 1108 + k. nozari and a. etemadi , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 104029 .
a. ashtekar , s. fairhurst and j. willis , class . quantum grav . * 20 * ( 2003 ) 1031 + k. fredenhagen and f. reszewski , class .
quantum grav .
* 23 * ( 2006 ) 6577 + a. corichi , t. vukainac and j. a. zapata , phys
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 044016 .
g. amelino - camelia , int . j. mod .
d * 11 * ( 2000 ) 35 + g. amelino - camelia , nature * 418 * ( 2002 ) 34 + j. magueijo and l. smolin , phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 190403 + j. kowalski - glikman , lect . notes phys .
* 669 * ( 2005 ) 131 + g. amelino - camelia , l. freidel , j. kowalski - glikman and l. smolin , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 084010 .
j. kowalski - glikman , phys .
b * 547 * ( 2002 ) 291 + j. kowalski - glikman and s. nowak , class .
quantum grav .
* 20 * ( 2003 ) 4799 + f. girelli , e. r. livine and d. oriti , nucl .
b * 708 * ( 2005 ) 411 + j. kowalski - glikman , int .
a * 28 * ( 2013 ) 1330014 .
p. nicolini , a. smailagic and e. spallucci , phys .
b * 632 * ( 2006 ) 547 + s. ansoldi , p. nicolini , a. smailagic and e. spallucci , phys .
b * 645 * ( 2007 ) 261 + y. s. myung , y .- w . kim and y. -j .
park , jhep * 0702 * ( 2007 ) 012 + k. nozari and s. h. mehdipour , class .
quantum grav .
* 25 * ( 2008 ) 175015 + r. banerjee , b. r. majhi and s. samanta , phys . rev .
d * 77 * ( 2008 ) 124035 + r. banerjee , b. r. majhi and s. k. modak , class .
quantum grav .
* 26 * ( 2009 ) 085010 + c. bastos , o. bertolami , n. c. dias and j. n. prata , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 124038 .
f. scardigli , phys .
b * 452 * ( 1999 ) 39 + a. j. m. medved and e. c. vagenas , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 124021 + g. amelino - camelia , m. arzano , y. ling and g. mandanici , class .
quantum grav .
* 23 * ( 2006 ) 2585 + y. s. myung , y. -w .
kim and y. -j .
park , phys .
b * 645 * ( 2007 ) 393 + k. nozari and a. s. sefiedgar , phys .
b * 635 * ( 2006 ) 156 + a. bina , s. jalalzadeh and a. moslehi , phys .
d * 81 * ( 2010 ) 023528 + l. xiang and x. q. wen , jhep * 0910 * ( 2009 ) 046 .
s. k. rama , phys .
b * 519 * ( 2001 ) 103 + l. n. chang , d. minic , n. okamura and t. takeuchi , phys .
d , * 65 * ( 2002 ) 125028 + t. fityo , phys . lett .
a * 372 * ( 2008 ) 5872 + p.
wang , h. yang and x. zhang , phys . lett .
b * 718 * ( 2012 ) 265 + g. amelino - camelia , n. loret , g. mandanici and f. mercati , int .
d * 21 * ( 2012 ) 1250052 .
m. lubo , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 125004 + k. nozari and b. fazlpour , gen .
reltiv . grav .
* 38 * ( 2006 ) 1661 + p.
wang , h. yang and x. zhang , jhep * 08 * ( 2010 ) 043 + d. mania and m. maziashvili , phys .
b * 705 * ( 2011 ) 521 + r. collier , [ arxiv : 1110.5268 ] + b. vakili and m. a. gorji , j. stat . mech .
( 2012 ) p10013 + r. collier , [ arxiv : 1503.04354 ] .
g. m. hossain , v. husain and s. s. seahra , class .
quantum grav .
* 27 * ( 2010 ) 165013 + g. chacn - acosta , e. manrique , l. dagdug and h. a. morales - tcotl , _ sigma _ * 7 * ( 2011 ) 110 + e. castellanos and g. chacn - acosta , phys .
b * 722 * ( 2013 ) 119 + g. chacn - acosta and h. hernandez - hernandez , arxiv : 1408.1306 [ astro-ph.sr ] .
x. zhang , l. shao and b. -q .
ma , astropart .
* 34 * ( 2011 ) 840 + s. das , s. ghosh and d. roychowdhury , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 125036 + s. das and d. roychowdhury , phys .
d * 81 * ( 2010 ) 085039 + n. chandra and s. chatterjee , phys . rev .
d * 85 * ( 2011 ) 045012 .
m. chaichian , m. m. sheikh - jabbari and a. tureanu , phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 2716 + s. das and e. c. vagenas , phys
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 221301 + p.
pedram , k. nozari and s. h. taheri , jhep * 1103 * ( 2011 ) 093 + s. jalalzadeh , m. a. gorji and k. nozari , gen .
* 46 * ( 2014 ) 1632 + s. ghosh , class .
quantum grav .
* 31 * ( 2014 ) 025025 .
g. amelino - camelia , m. arzano , g. gubitosi and j. magueijo , phys .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 103524 + g. amelino - camelia , m. arzano , g. gubitosi and j. magueijo , phys .
b * 736 * ( 2014 ) 317 + m. arzano and t. trzesniewski , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 124024 . | in this paper , we formulate the statistical mechanics in snyder space that supports the existence of a minimal length scale .
we obtain the corresponding invariant liouville volume which properly determines the number of microstates in the semiclassical regime .
the results show that the number of accessible microstates drastically reduces at the high energy regime such that there is only one degree of freedom for a particle . using the liouville volume
, we obtain the deformed partition function and we then study the thermodynamical properties of the ideal gas in this setup . invoking the equipartition theorem ,
we show that @xmath0 of the degrees of freedom freeze at the high temperature regime when the thermal de broglie wavelength becomes of the order of the planck length .
this reduction of the number of degrees of freedom suggests an effective dimensional reduction of the space from @xmath1 to @xmath2 at the planck scale .
pacs numbers : : 04.60.bc key words : : quantum gravity phenomenology , thermodynamics |
entanglement is a genuine quantum correlation between two or more parties , with no analogue in classical physics . during last decades
it has been recognized as a fundamental tool in several quantum information protocols , such as quantum teleportation @xcite , quantum cryptography @xcite and quantum key distribution @xcite , and distributed quantum computing @xcite . nowadays , spontaneous parametric down - conversion ( spdc ) , a process where the interaction of a strong pump beam with a nonlinear crystal mediates the emission of two lower - frequency photons ( signal and idler ) , is a very convenient way to generate photonic entanglement @xcite .
photons generated in spdc can exhibit entanglement in the polarization degree of freedom @xcite , frequency @xcite and spatial shape @xcite .
one can also make use of a combination of several degrees of freedom @xcite .
two - photon entanglement in the polarization degree of freedom is undoubtedly the most common type of generated entanglement , due both to its simplicity , and that it suffices to demonstrate a myriad of important quantum information applications .
but the amount of entanglement is restricted to @xmath0 ebit of entropy of entanglement @xcite , since each photon of the pair can be generally described by the superposition of two orthogonal polarizations ( two - dimensional hilbert space ) . on the other hand , frequency and spatial entanglement
occurs in an infinite dimensional hilbert space , offering thus the possibility to implement entanglement that inherently lives in a higher dimensional hilbert space ( qudits ) .
entangling systems in higher dimensional systems ( frequency and spatial degrees of freedom ) is important both for fundamental and applied reasons .
for example , noise and decoherence tend to degrade quickly quantum correlations . however , theoretical investigations predict that physical systems with increasing dimensions can maintain non - classical correlations in the presence of more hostile noise @xcite .
higher dimensional states can also exhibit unique outstanding features .
the potential of higher - dimensional quantum systems for practical applications is clearly illustrated in the demonstration of the so - called _ quantum coin tossing _
, where the power of higher dimensional spaces is clearly visible @xcite .
the amount of spatial entanglement generated depends of the spdc geometry used ( collinear vs non - collinear ) , the length of the nonlinear crystal ( @xmath1 ) and the size of the pump beam ( @xmath2 ) . to obtain an initial estimate ,
let us consider a collinear spdc geometry . under certain approximations @xcite ,
the entropy of entanglement can be calculated analytically .
its value can be shown to depend on the ratio @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is the rayleigh range of the pump beam and @xmath5 is its longitudinal wavenumber .
therefore , large values of the pump beam waist @xmath2 and short crystals are ingredients for generating high entanglement @xcite .
however , the use of shorter crystals also reduce the total flux - rate of generated entangled photon pairs .
moreover , certain applications might benefit from the use of focused pump beams .
for instance , for a @xmath6 mm long stoichiometric lithium tantalate ( slt ) crystal , with pump beam waist @xmath7 @xmath8 m , pump wavelength @xmath9 nm and extraordinary refractive index @xmath10 @xcite , one obtains @xmath11 @xcite . for a longer crystal of @xmath12 mm , the amount of entanglement
is severely reduced to @xmath13 ebits .
we put forward here a scheme to generate massive spatial entanglement , i. e. , an staggering large value of the entropy of entanglement , independently of some relevant experimental parameters such as the crystal length or the pump beam waist .
this would allow to reach even larger amounts of entanglement that possible nowadays with the usual configurations used , or to attain the same amount of entanglement but with other values of the nonlinear crystal length or the pump beam waist better suited for specific experiments .
our approach is based on a scheme originally used to increase the bandwidth of parametric down - conversion @xcite . a schematic view of the spdc configuration is shown in fig.[fig1 ] .
it makes use of chirped quasi - phase - matching ( qpm ) gratings with a linearly varying spatial frequency given by @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the grating s spatial frequency at its entrance face ( @xmath16 ) , and @xmath17 is a parameter that represents the degree of linear chirp .
the period of the grating at distance @xmath18 is @xmath19 , so that the parameter @xmath17 writes @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the period at the entrance face of the crystal , and @xmath22 at its output face . and
@xmath23 designate the transverse wave numbers of the signal and idler photons , respectively .
@xmath15 is the grating wave - vector at the input face of the nonlinear crystal , and @xmath24 at its output face .
the signal and idler photons can have different polarizations or frequencies .
the different colors ( or different direction of arrows ) represent domains with different sign of the nonlinear coefficient.,width=245 ] the key idea is that at different points along the nonlinear crystal , signal and idler photons with different frequencies and transverse wavenumbers can be generated , since the continuous change of the period of the qpm gratings allows the fulfillment of the phase - matching conditions for different frequencies and transverse wavenumbers .
if appropriately designed narrow - band interference filters allow to neglect the frequency degree of freedom of the two - photon state , the linearly chirped qpm grating enhance only the number of spatial modes generated , leading to a corresponding enhancement of the amount of generated spatial entanglement . for ( a ) @xmath25 and ( b ) @xmath26 .
the nonlinear crystal length is @xmath12 mm and the pump beam waist is @xmath27 .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] + for ( a ) @xmath25 and ( b ) @xmath26 .
the nonlinear crystal length is @xmath12 mm and the pump beam waist is @xmath27 .
, title="fig:",width=264 ]
in order to determine how much spatial entanglement can be generated in spdc with the use of chirped qpm , let us consider a nonlinear optical crystal illuminated by a quasi - monochromatic laser gaussian pump beam of waist @xmath2 . under conditions of collinear propagation of the pump , signal and idler photons with no poynting vector walk - off , which would be the case of a noncritical type - ii quasi - phase matched configuration , the amplitude of the quantum state of the generated two - photon pair generated in spdc reads in transverse wavenumber space @xmath28 where @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) is the transverse wavenumber of the signal ( idler ) photon .
@xmath31 is the joint amplitude of the two - photon state , so that @xmath32 is the probability to detect a signal photon with transverse wave - number @xmath29 in coincidence with an idler photons with @xmath23 . the joint amplitude that describes the quantum state of the paired photons generated in a linearly chirped qpm crystal , using the paraxial approximation , is equal to @xmath33,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath34 is a normalization constant ensuring @xmath35 .
notice that the value of @xmath36 does now show up in eq .
( [ state2 ] ) , since we make use of the fact that there is phase matching for @xmath37 at certain location inside the nonlinear crystal , which in our case it turns out to be the input face ( @xmath16 ) .
after integration along the z - axis one obtains @xmath38\nonumber \\ & & \times\left [ \mathrm{erf}\left(\frac{3\sqrt{\alpha}l}{4\sqrt{i}}+\frac{|\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{q}|^{2}}{4k_{p}\sqrt{i\alpha}}\right)-\mathrm{erf}\left(-\frac{\sqrt{\alpha}l}{4\sqrt{i}}+\frac{|\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{q}|^{2}}{4k_{p}\sqrt{i\alpha}}\right)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 refers to the error function . notice that eq .
( [ state3 ] ) is similar to the one describing the joint spectrum of photon pairs in the frequency domain , when the spatial degree of freedom is omitted @xcite .
the reason is that both equations originate in phase matching conditions along the propagation direction ( @xmath40 axis ) . since all the configuration parameters that define the down conversion process show rotational symmetry along the propagation direction @xmath18 , the joint amplitude given by eq .
( [ state3 ] ) can be written as @xmath41 here , we have made use of polar coordinates in the transverse wave - vector domain for the signal , @xmath42 , and idler photons @xmath43 , where @xmath44 are the corresponding azimuthal angles , and @xmath45 are the radial coordinates .
the specific dependence of the schmidt decomposition on the azimuthal variables @xmath46 and @xmath46 reflects the conservation of orbital angular momentum in this spdc configuration @xcite , so that a signal photon with oam winding number @xmath47 is always accompanied by a corresponding idler photon with oam winding number @xmath48 .
the probability of such coincidence detection for each value of @xmath49 is the spiral spectrum @xcite of the two - photon state , i.e. , the set of values @xmath50 .
recently , the spiral spectrum of some selected spdc configuration have been measured @xcite .
the schmidt decomposition @xcite of the spiral function , i.e. , @xmath51 , is the tool to quantify the amount of entanglement present .
@xmath52 are the schmidt coefficients ( eigenvalues ) , and the modes @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the schmidt modes ( eigenvectors ) . here
we obtain the schmidt decomposition by means of a singular - value decomposition method .
once the schmidt coefficients are obtained , one can obtain the entropy of entanglement as @xmath55 .
an estimation of the overall number of spatial modes generated is obtained via the schmidt number @xmath56 , which can be interpreted as a measure of the effective dimensionality of the system .
finally , the spiral spectrum is obtained as @xmath57 .
for the sake of comparison , let us consider first the usual case of a qpm slt crystal with no chirp , i.e. , @xmath58 , and length @xmath12 mm , pumped by a gaussian beam with beam waist @xmath59 and wavelength @xmath9 nm . in this case , the integration of eq .
( [ state2 ] ) leads to @xcite @xmath60 the schmidt coefficients are plotted in fig .
[ fig2](a ) , and the corresponding spiral spectrum is shown in fig . [
fig3](a ) .
the main contribution to the spiral spectrum comes from the spatial modes with @xmath61 .
the entropy of entanglement for this case is @xmath62 ebits and the schmidt number is @xmath63 .
nonzero values of the chirp parameter @xmath17 lead to an increase of number of generated modes , as it can be readily seen in fig .
[ fig2](b ) for @xmath64 @xmath65 and @xmath66 @xmath8 m .
this broadening effect is also reflected in the corresponding broadening of spiral spectrum , as shown in fig . [ fig3](b ) . indeed , fig .
[ fig4](a ) shows that the entropy of entanglement increases with increasingly larger values of the chirping parameter , even though for a given value of @xmath2 , its increase saturates for large values of @xmath17 . for @xmath67 and @xmath68 ,
we reach a value of @xmath69 ebits . on the contrary ,
the schmidt number @xmath70 rises linearly with @xmath17 , as can be observed in fig .
[ fig4](b ) , for all values of @xmath2 . for sufficiently large values of @xmath2 and @xmath17 , @xmath70 reaches values of several thousands of spatial modes , i.e. @xmath71 for the same @xmath2 and @xmath17 . for large values of @xmath72 , a further increase of @xmath72 requires an even much larger increase of the number of spatial modes involved , which explain why an increase of the number of modes involved only produces a modest increase of the entropy of entanglement .
notice that the spiral spectrum presented in fig .
[ fig3](b ) is discrete .
notwithstanding , it might look continuous since it is the result from the presence of several hundreds of oam modes with slightly decreasing weights . for ( a ) @xmath25 and ( b ) @xmath73 .
the nonlinear crystal length is @xmath12 mm and the pump beam waist is @xmath27 .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] + for ( a ) @xmath25 and ( b ) @xmath73 .
the nonlinear crystal length is @xmath12 mm and the pump beam waist is @xmath27 .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] and ( b ) the schmidt number @xmath70 as a function of the chirp parameter @xmath17 for @xmath74 ( solid black line ) , @xmath75 ( dashed blue line ) and @xmath76 ( dotted - and - dashed red line ) . ,
title="fig:",width=245 ] + and ( b ) the schmidt number @xmath70 as a function of the chirp parameter @xmath17 for @xmath74 ( solid black line ) , @xmath75 ( dashed blue line ) and @xmath76 ( dotted - and - dashed red line ) .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] we have discussed entanglement in terms of transverse modes which arise from the schmidt decomposition of the two - photon amplitude and , as such , they attain appreciable values in the whole transverse plane .
alternatively , the existing spatial correlations between the signal and idler photons can also be discussed using second - order intensity correlation functions @xcite . in this approach ,
correlations are quantified by the size of the correlated area ( @xmath77 ) where it is highly probable to detect a signal photon provided that its idler twin has been detected with a fixed transverse wave vector @xmath23 .
we note that the azimuthal width of correlated area decreases with the increasing width of the distribution of schmidt eigenvalues along the oam winding number @xmath49 . on the other hand , the increasing width of the distribution of schmidt eigenvalues along the remaining number @xmath78 results in a narrower radial extension of the correlated area .
an increase in the number of modes @xmath70 results in a diminishing correlation area , both in the radial and azimuthal directions .
the correlated area drops to zero in the limit of plane - wave pumping , where attains the form of a @xmath79 function .
the use of such correlations in parallel processing of information represents the easiest way for the exploitation of massively multi - mode character of the generated beams . for the sake of comparison , when considering frequency entanglement , the entropy of entanglement depends on the ratio between the bandwidth of the pump beam ( typically @xmath80 mhz ) and the bandwidth of the down - converted two - photon state ( @xmath81 ) @xcite . for type ii spdc
, one has typically values of @xmath82 @xcite . increasing the bandwidth of the two - photon state
, one can reach values of @xmath83 thz , therefore allowing typical ratios greater than @xmath84 , with @xmath85 @xcite .
in conclusion , we have presented a new way to increase significantly the amount of two - photon spatial entanglement generated in spdc by means of the use of chirped quasi - phase - matching nonlinear crystals .
this opens the door to the generation of high entanglement under various experimental conditions , such as different crystal lengths and sizes of the pump beam .
qpm engineering can also be an enabling tool to generate truly massive spatial entanglement , with state of the art qpm technologies @xcite potentially allowing to reach entropies of entanglement of tens of ebits .
therefore , the promise of reaching extremely high degrees of entanglement , offered by the use of the spatial degree of freedom , can be fulfilled with the scheme put forward here .
the experimental tools required are available nowadays .
the use of extremely high degrees of spatial entanglement , as consider here , would demand the implementation of high aperture optical systems .
for instance , for a spatial bandwidth of @xmath86 , the aperture required for @xmath9 nm is @xmath87 .
the shaping of qpm gratings are commonly used in the area of non - linear optics for multiple applications such as beam and pulse shaping , harmonic generation and all - optical processing @xcite . in the realm of quantum optics ,
its uses are not so widespread , even though qpm engineering has been considered , and experimentally demonstrated , as a tool for spatial @xcite and frequency @xcite control of entangled photons . in view of the results obtained here concerning the enhancement of the degree of spatial entanglement
, it could be possible to devise new types of gratings that turn out to be beneficial for other applications in the area of quantum optics .
this work was supported by the government of spain ( project fis2010 - 14831 ) and the european union ( project phorbitech , fet - open 255914 ) .
j. s. thanks the project fi - dgr 2011 of the catalan government .
this work has also supported in part by projects cost oc 09026 , cz.1.05/2.1.00/03.0058 of the ministry of education , youth and sports of the czech republic and by project prf-2012 - 003 of palack university . c. h. bennett , g. brassard , c. crpeau , r. jozsa , a. peres , and w. k. wootters , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 1895 ( 1993 ) .
a. k. ekert , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 661 ( 1991 ) .
g. ribordy , j. brendel , j. d. gautier , n. gisin , and h. zbinden , phys .
a * 63 * , 012309 ( 2000 ) .
a. serafini , s. mancini , and s. bose , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 010503 ( 2006 ) .
j. p. torres , k. banaszek and i. a. walmsley , progress in optics * 56 * ( chapter v ) , 227 ( 2011 ) .
p. g. kwiat , k. mattle , h. weinfurter , a. zeilinger , a. v. sergienko , and y. shih , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 4337 ( 1995 ) . c. k. law , i. a. walmsley , and j. h. eberly , phys .
84 * , 5304 ( 2000 ) .
h. h. arnaut and g. a. barbosa , phys .
* 85 * * , 286 ( 2000 ) .
a. mair , a. vaziri , g. weihs and a. zeilinger , nature * 412 * , 313 ( 2001 ) .
j. t. barreiro , n. k. langford , n. a. peters , and p. g. kwiat , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 260501 ( 2005 ) .
e. nagali , f. sciarrino , f. de martini , l. marrucci , b. piccirillo , e. karimi and e. santamato , phys .
103 * , 013601 ( 2009 ) . for a two - photon state with density matrix @xmath88 ,
the entropy of entanglement is defined as @xmath89 , where @xmath90 is the partial trace over the variables describing subsystem @xmath91 of the global density matrix .
the entropy of entanglement of a maximally entangled quantum state , whose two parties live in a @xmath92-dimensional system , is @xmath93 .
since the state of polarization of a single photon is a two - dimensional system , the maximum entropy of entanglement is @xmath0 .
d. kaszlikowski , p. gnacinski , m. zukowski , w. miklaszewski , and a. zeilinger , phys .
* 85 * * , 4418 ( 2000 ) .
d. collins , n. gisin , n. linden , s. massar , and s. popescu , phys .
* 88 * * , 040404 ( 2002 ) .
g. molina - terriza , a. vaziri , r. ursin and a. zeilinger , phys . rev . lett . *
* 94 * * , 040501 ( 2005 ) .
the approximation consist of substituting the sinc function appearing later on in eq .
( [ state4 ] ) by a gaussian function , i.e. @xmath94}$ ] with @xmath95 , so that both functions coincide at the @xmath96-intensity . for a detailed calculation ,
see k. w. chan , j. p. torres , and j. h. eberly , phys .
a * 75 * , 050101(r ) ( 2007 ) .
s. s. r. oemrawsingh , x. ma , d. voigt , a. aiello , e. r. eliel , g. w. t hooft , and j. p. woerdman , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 240501 ( 2005 ) .
a. bruner , d. eger , m. b. oron , p. blau , m. katz , and s. ruschin , opt . lett . * 28 * , 194 ( 2003 ) .
s. carrasco , j. p. torres , l. torner , a. sergienko , b. e. a. saleh , and m. c. teich , opt . lett . * 29 * , 2429 ( 2004 ) .
m. b. nasr , s. carrasco , b. e. a. saleh , a. v. sergienko , m. c. teich , j. p. torres , l. torner , d. s. hum , and m. m. fejer , phys .
* 100 * , 183601 ( 2008 ) .
j. svozilk , and j. peina jr . , phys .
a * 80 * , 023819 ( 2009 ) . c. i. osorio , g. molina - terriza , and j. p. torres , phys .
a * 77 * , 015810 ( 2008 ) .
j. p. torres , a. alexandrescu , and l. torner , phys . rev . a * 68 * , 050301 ( 2003 ) . h. di lorenzo pires , h. c. b. florijn , and m. p. van exter , phys . rev
104 * , 020505 ( 2010 ) .
a. ekert and p. l. knight , am .
* 63 * , 415 ( 1995 ) .
walborn , a.n .
de oliveira , s. padua , and c.h .
monken , phys .
lett * 90 * , 143601 ( 2003 ) s. parker , s. bose , and m. b. plenio , phys .
a * 61 * , 032305 ( 2000 ) .
m. hamar , j. peina jr . , o. haderka , and v. michlek , phys .
a * 81 * , 043827 ( 2010 ) .
j. p. torres , a. alexandrescu , s. carrasco , and l. torner , opt .
* 29 * , 376 ( 2004 ) .
x. q. yu , p. xu , z. d. xie , j. f. wang , h.y .
leng , j. s. zhao , s. n. zhu , and n. b. ming , phys . rev
* 101 * , 233601 ( 2008 ) . | by making use of the spatial shape of paired photons , parametric down - conversion allows the generation of two - photon entanglement in a multidimensional hilbert space .
how much entanglement can be generated in this way ? in principle , the infinite - dimensional nature of the spatial degree of freedom renders unbounded the amount of entanglement available .
however , in practice , the specific configuration used , namely its geometry , the length of the nonlinear crystal and the size of the pump beam , can severely limit the value that could be achieved . here
we show that the use of quasi - phase - matching engineering allows to increase the amount of entanglement generated , reaching values of tens of ebits of entropy of entanglement under different conditions .
our work thus opens a way to fulfill the promise of generating massive spatial entanglement under a diverse variety of circumstances , some more favorable for its experimental implementation . |
despite the eternal doubts whether social phenomena can be described quantitatively @xcite , mathematical modeling of interpersonal relations has long tradition @xcite .
the idea is tempting : a bottom - up path from understanding to control and predict our own behaviour seems to promise a higher level of human existence . on the other hand ,
any progress on this path is absorbed by the society in a kind of self - transformation , what makes the object of research even more complex .
as scholars belong to the society , an observer can not be separated from what is observed ; this precludes the idea of an objective observation . yet , for scientists , the latter idea is paradigmatic ; their strategy is to conduct research as usual . as a consequence ,
the hermeneutically oriented multi - branched mainstream is accompanied by a number of works based on agent - based simulations , statistical physics and traditional , positivist sociology .
theory of the heider balance @xcite is one of such mathematical strongholds in the body of social science .
based on the concept of the removal of cognitive dissonance ( rcd ) @xcite , it has got a combinatorial formulation in terms of graph theory @xcite . in a nutshell ,
the concept is as follows : interpersonal relations in a social network are either friendly or hostile .
the relations evolve over time as to implement four rules : friend of my friend is my friend , friend of my enemy is my enemy , enemy of my friend is my enemy , enemy of my enemy is my friend . in a final balanced state ,
the cognitive dissonance is absent @xcite .
there , the network is divided into two parts , both internally friendly and mutually hostile . a special case when all relations are friendly ( so - called paradise )
is also allowed .
more recently , monte - carlo based discrete algorithms have been worked out to simulate the dynamics of the process of rcd on a social network @xcite . in parallel , a set of deterministic differential equations has been proposed as a model of rcd @xcite .
this approach has been generalized to include asymmetric relations @xcite as well as the mechanism of direct reciprocity @xcite , which was supposed to remove the asymmetry .
our aim here is to add yet another mechanism , i.e. an influence of the rate of the change of relations to the relations themselves .
this mechanism has been described years ago by elliot aronson and termed as the gain and loss of esteem @xcite ; see also the description and literature in @xcite .
briefly , an increase of sympathy @xmath0 of an actor @xmath1 about another actor @xmath2 appears to be an independent cause of sympathy @xmath3 of the actor @xmath2 about the actor @xmath1 .
by independent we mean : not coming from @xmath0 , but from the time derivative @xmath4 . in summary , both the relation @xmath5 itself and its time derivative influence the relation @xmath3 .
the efficiencies of these impacts and the rate of rcd play the roles of parameters in our model .
we note that the concept of gain and loss of esteem has triggered a scientific discussion which is not finished until now @xcite . among implications ,
let us mention two : for man - machine cooperation @xcite and for evaluations of leaders as dependent on the time evolution of their behaviour ( the so - called st .
augustine effect ) @xcite . in our opinion , it is worthwhile to try to include the effect in the existing theory of rcd
. here we are interested in three phases of the system of interpersonal relations : the jammed phase , the balanced phase with two mutually hostile groups , and the phase of so - called paradise , where all relations are friendly .
the two latter phases are known from early considerations of the heider balance in a social network @xcite .
the jammed phase is the stationary state of relations , where the heider balance is not attained .
jammed states have been discussed for the first time for the case of symmetric relations ( i.e. @xmath6 ) by tibor antal and coworkers @xcite .
the authors have shown , that this kind of states appear rather rarely , and the probability of reaching such a state decreases with the system size .
a similar conclusion has been drawn also for the evolution ruled by the differential equations @xcite .
our goal here is twofold .
first , we provide a proof that with asymmetric relations , the number of jammed states is at least @xmath7 times larger than the number of balanced states , where @xmath7 is the number of nodes .
the conclusion of this proof is that if the jammed phase is possible , it is generic .
second , we construct a phase diagram , with the model parameters as coordinates , where ranges of parameters are identified where the three above states appear . in the next section
we give a proof that for asymmetric relations the majority of stationary states are jammed states .
third section is devoted to the generalized form of the model differential equations which govern rcd , with all discussed mechanisms included .
numerical results on the phase diagram are shown in section 4 .
final remarks close the text .
in @xcite , a discrete algorithm ( the so - called constrained triad dynamics ) has been proposed to model rcd . for each pair of nodes @xmath8 of a fully connected graph , an initial sign @xmath9 ( friendly or hostile )
is assigned to the link between nodes @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
for this initial configuration , the number of imbalanced triads @xmath10 ( such that @xmath11 ) is calculated . this number can be seen as an analogue to energy ; let us denote it as @xmath12 .
the evolution goes as follows .
a link is selected randomly .
if the change of its sign lowers @xmath12 , the sign is changed ; if @xmath12 increases , the change is withdrawn ; if @xmath12 remains constant , the sign is changed with probability 1/2 .
next , another link is selected , and so on . as a consequence , in a local minimum of @xmath12
the system can not evolve ; the state is either balanced or jammed .
according to @xcite , the minimal network size where jammed states are possible is @xmath13 nodes .
an example of jammed states for @xmath14 is the case of three separate triads , where each link within each triad is positive ( friendly ) and each link between nodes of different triad is negative ( hostile ) .
as shown in @xcite , each modification of a link leads to an increase of the number of unbalanced triads above the minimal value @xmath15 .
this can be seen easily when we notice that for each unbalanced triangle , each its vertex is in different triad ; hence the number of these triangles is @xmath16 .
a simple inspection tells us that a change of any friendly link to hostile state enhances energy to @xmath17 , while any opposite change gives @xmath18 ; hence the configuration is stable .
the same can be shown for the differential equations ; for the purpose of this check we can limit the equations to the simplest form @xmath19 the condition of stability of a saturated state where for all links @xmath20 is that @xmath21 ; either @xmath0 is positive and increases , or it is negative and decreases . for the above jammed state , all positive links are within a triad , and each negative link is between different triads .
provided that the product of the @xmath22 functions is equal to one , the r.h.s .
( [ simple ] ) is equal to @xmath23 for positive links , and to @xmath24 for negative links ; hence this configuration is stable again .
this equivalence of the results for two different frames of calculation , discrete and continuous , comes from the fact that in both frames the state of one link can be changed independently on other links .
this is not so , if we modify a whole triangle , as in the local triad dynamics @xcite ; there , jammed states do not appear .
now let us consider jammed states in asymetric matrix of relations , where the condition @xmath6 does not hold . in @xcite ,
a series of such states has been identified by a numerical check . here
we show that all of them can be captured in the following scheme .
take one node ( say @xmath1-th one ) , and set all links @xmath25 , and @xmath26 ( or the opposite ) . as the @xmath1-th node can be selected in @xmath7 ways ,
there are @xmath27 such states
. now pick up one node again and divide the remaining network of @xmath28 nodes into two non - empty , internally friendly and mutually hostile sets , with nodes marked by @xmath2 and @xmath29 , respectively . without the preselected @xmath1-th node , the system is balanced . the division can be performed in @xmath30 ways .
the relations of the @xmath1-th node with the others are as follows : either @xmath25 , @xmath31 , @xmath26 , @xmath32 , or @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 .
these two options mean that we have @xmath37 jammed states . in summary , we get @xmath38 jammed states .
to @xmath2 means that @xmath0 is positive ( friendly ) .
a broken arrow means that the relation is negative ( hostile ) . ]
the stability of these jammed states can be verified analytically .
consider a configuration of @xmath39 nodes in part i of network , @xmath40 nodes in part ii , and one pre - selected node @xmath41 ; then , @xmath42 .
as above , the system is balanced ( @xmath39 against @xmath40 ) except node @xmath43 .
suppose that for @xmath44 i and @xmath45 ii we have @xmath46 and @xmath47 , as in fig .
again , the stability can be verified by inspection of the r.h.s .
( [ simple ] ) for all links .
first , each internal links within i is positive .
its time derivative is @xmath48 ( through other nodes in i ) , plus @xmath40 ( through nodes in ii ) , minus one ( through 1 ) ; the sum is positive .
( writing through node @xmath1 , we mean the contribution @xmath49 to the time derivative of @xmath50 . )
the same applies to links within ii . for @xmath51 ( positive ) ,
its time derivative is @xmath52 ( through nodes in i ) , plus @xmath40 ( through nodes in ii ) , what is positive . for @xmath53 ( positive ) ,
its time derivative is @xmath54 ( through other nodes of ii ) , plus @xmath39 ( through nodes in i , the product of two negative links in each time ) , what is positive . in the same way , for @xmath55 and @xmath56 (
both negative ) we get @xmath57 , what is negative . on the other hand , there is only @xmath58 balanced states , including the paradise state of all relations friendly .
therefore , the number of jammed states is at least @xmath7 times larger , than the number of balanced states .
we write at least because the numerical identification of jammed states has been done for @xmath59 ; it is likely , than for larger systems we would observe even more complex configurations . yet
, the numerical time increases with the number of configurations , which is @xmath60 .
with all three mechanisms built into the equation , the time derivative of the relation @xmath0 is @xmath61 \label{main}\ ] ] here the coefficient @xmath62 is a measure of intensity of the process of evening the relations between @xmath1 and @xmath2 out because of direct reciprocity .
accordingly , the coefficient @xmath63 is a measure of intensity of rcd .
the former mechanism has been introduced in @xcite ; for initially asymmetric relations , its appearance is a necessary condition for the heider balance .
varying @xmath62 , we control the mutual rate of the two processes .
however , in stationary states the time derivatives of the relations @xmath0 are equal to zero ; therefore the third coefficient @xmath64 , which is a measure of importance of the dynamics , is kept independent on @xmath62 .
the prefactor @xmath65 plays the same role as the product of @xmath22 functions in eq .
[ simple ] , i.e. to keep the relations in the prescribed range @xmath66 . for numerical calculations ,
this prefactor is more feasible .
it is not convenient to have time derivatives on the r.h.s . of an equation .
then , after a short algebra , we get @xmath67 \right ] \end{multlined } \label{main2}\ ] ] it is easy to notice that close to the stationary state , where ( @xmath20 ) , the equation reduces to the case where @xmath68 . yet , as we have found already in @xcite , the action of the mechanism of direct reciprocity is to reduce the asymmetry of the relations before the system is trapped in a jammed state .
if the coefficient @xmath62 is too small , the process is too slow and the heider balance is not attained .
therefore what is meaningful for the final state is the mutual rate of the processes .
below we present the results of the numerical solution of the system of equations which display the time evolution of @xmath0 .
how the mechanism of the gain and loss of esteem modifies the action of the direct reciprocity ?
to solve this issue , a series of numerical solutions of eqs .
( [ main2 ] ) have been performed , for different values of the parameters @xmath62 and @xmath64 and different probability distributions of the initial values of the relations @xmath0 . as a rule ,
the distributions are uniform and different from zero in the range @xmath69 ; then , @xmath70 is yet another parameter .
the width of the distribution is chosen to be @xmath71 for all calculations .
if the width is too small , the effect of asymmetry is reduced , and too large values do not allow to modify @xmath70 because the values of @xmath0 are limited to the range @xmath72 . for each set of trajectories
@xmath73 , @xmath74 , we intend to qualify the final state as one of three phases : the paradise state , the balanced state and the jammed state . as a rule ,
after a predictable number of time steps the system attained the saturated state where all relations @xmath0 were close to @xmath75 .
exceptions from this rule have been found to be very rare and almost all of them happened for @xmath76 .
numerical inspection allowed to classify these exceptions as examples of states which varied periodically in time , as identified in @xcite .
these cases have been eliminated from the statistics .
the state of paradise has been identified from the condition that all relations @xmath0 are @xmath77 .
similarly , the criterion of the balanced state is that the number of unbalanced triads ( @xmath78 ) is zero .
if neither of these conditions is fulfilled , the state is classified as a jammed state . in all but one cases ,
the jammed character of the state was equivalent to a clear asymmetry of the relations , i.e. @xmath79 . the very rare exception was that the symmetric relations happened to appear simultaneously with the non - zero number of the unbalanced triads ; such states have been discussed in @xcite .
the case of three separated triads , found in @xcite , is thoroughly discussed in our section 2 .
most of our simulations have been performed for @xmath80 nodes , what is equivalent to 380 equations of motion .
this choice is motivated by our observation , that the accuracy of numerical solution ( limited by the length of the time steps ) should be high enough to prevent a jump from one final state of all links to another .
this condition in turn makes the time of calculation quite long , if the number of nodes @xmath7 is about 30 . below @xmath80 ,
the above jumps have not been observed .
our aim here is the phase diagram , i.e. the ranges of parameters where each of the three phases appear .
here we work with three parameters : @xmath70 , @xmath62 and @xmath64 .
we proceed as follows : for a fixed value of all parameters , we perform a series of @xmath81 simulations and we count , how many times each of three phases appear .
the boundary between two phases is set for the set of parameters where each of the two phases appears with the same frequency .
the values of @xmath82 are identified from a linear fit between 30 and 70 percent of appearance of a given phase . , with the phases j , hb , p ( jammed , balanced , paradise ) ( upper plot ) , and an inset ( lower plot ) .
the lines are for @xmath83 0.0 , 0.1 and 0.2.,title="fig : " ] , with the phases j , hb , p ( jammed , balanced , paradise ) ( upper plot ) , and an inset ( lower plot ) .
the lines are for @xmath83 0.0 , 0.1 and 0.2.,title="fig : " ] numerical results of these investigations are shown in fig .
( [ f2 ] ) .
there are three plots of @xmath84 for three different values of @xmath64 .
the value @xmath85 is the critical value ; for @xmath86 , the jammed phase is more rare than the alternative balanced state or the paradise state .
we see that for @xmath70 larger than about 0.06 , the paradise phase appears for all values of @xmath62 ; this means that the evolution drives all relations to be friendly ( equal @xmath77 ) .
of course , asymmetry vanishes there , even if the symmetrizing mechanism of the direct reciprocity is not present for @xmath76 .
below @xmath70 close to @xmath71 , the obtained line @xmath87 is the boundary between the jammed phase ( @xmath88 ) and the balanced phase ( @xmath86 ) .
an important result is that when the coefficient @xmath64 increases , @xmath85 decreases .
a less distinct effect is that the transition to the paradise phase is slightly shifted towards smaller @xmath70 , when @xmath64 increases .
the proof that the majority of stationary states are unbalanced ( jammed ) , given in section 2 , highlights the role of asymmetry of the relations . recall that in the case of symmetric relations , jammed states are not generic ; this is so both for discrete @xcite and continuous @xcite dynamics .
basically however , experimentally collected data on relations are not symmetric , as discussed in @xcite ; a recent example has been reported in @xcite .
exceptions from this rule can be induced by an experimental method , as when the intensity of communication in pairs is measured @xcite .
a jammed state means that the heider balance is not attained ; we conclude that this is so in most stationary states of network of social relations .
as discussed in @xcite , in some circumstances lack of the balance can prevent conflicts .
there are two aspects of the phase diagram , described above : the mathematical and the sociological one .
let us start from mathematics .
below the critical value of @xmath62 , the mechanism driven by direct reciprocity is not efficient and the system is stuck in a jammed state . what matters is the ratio of efficiencies of both mechanisms , the one proportional to @xmath62 ( direct reciprocity ) and the one proportional to @xmath63 ( rcd ) . in eq .
( [ main ] ) , the term proportional to @xmath64 produces another mechanism of evening the asymmetric relations out , because an increase of @xmath3 is correlated with an increase of @xmath3 . in the presence of this term ,
the asymmetry is removed by two mechanisms and not only by one .
therefore , to gain the balance , a smaller value of @xmath62 is necessary ; hence , the critical value of @xmath62 decreases with @xmath64 , as we see in fig .
( [ f2 ] ) . on the sociological side ,
the results become part of current discussions on the role of cognitive processes in shaping interpersonal relations ( @xcite and references therein ) . expressed opinions allow to evaluate the level of friendliness toward us @xcite .
results of experimental research show that a positive evaluation of a person triggers a reverse sympathy stronger than similarity of attitudes @xcite . in @xcite , the roles of attitude similarity and attitude alignment have been found to act separately and interact ; similarity predicted attraction only if attitude alignment was absent . in our formulation rcd ( term proportional to @xmath63 ) , positive evaluation ( term proportional to @xmath62 ) and attitude alignment ( term proportional to @xmath64 ) act separately .
our phase diagram indicates that they also interact ; the decrease of @xmath85 with @xmath64 means , that if the attitude alignment is strong enough , the positive evaluation is not needed to restore the balanced state .
one of the authors ( k.k . ) is grateful to katarzyna krawczyk - szczepanek for kind and helpful comments .
the work of p.g . was partially supported by the pl - grid infrastructure .
28 m. weber , _ the methodology of the social sciences _ , the free press of glencoe , illinois 1949 .
n. elias , _ what is sociology ? _ , columbia up , ny 1978 .
m. burawoy , _ the extended case method _ ,
university of california press , berkeley 2009 .
l. festinger , _ a theory of cognitive dissonance _ , stanford up , 1957 .
f. heider , _ the psychology of interpersonal relations _ , lawrence erlbaum assoc . ,
. j. s. coleman , _ an introduction to mathematical sociology _ , free press , 1964 .
r. r. vallacher , a. nowak ( eds . ) , _ dynamical systems in social psychology _ , academic press , san diego 1994 .
d. helbing , _ quantitative sociodynamics _ , springer - verlag , berlin heidelberg 2010 .
n. e. friedkin and e. c. johnsen , _ social influence network theory . a sociological examination of small group dynamics _ ,
cambridge up , cambridge 2011 .
p. bonacich and p. lu , _ introduction to mathematical sociology _ , princeton up , princeton , 2012 .
d. cartwright and f. harary , _ structural balance : a generalization of heider s theory _ , the psychological review 63 , 277 ( 1956 ) .
e. aronson and v. cope , _ my enemy s enemy is my friend _
, j. of personality and social psychology 8/1 ( 1968 ) 8 - 12 .
t. antal , p. l. krapivsky and s. redner , _ dynamics of social balance on networks _ , phys .
e 72 , 036121 ( 2005 ) .
k. kuakowski , p. gawroski and p. gronek , _ the heider balance - a continuous approach _ , int .
j. modern phys .
c 16 , 707 ( 2005 ) .
p. gawroski and k. kuakowski , _ heider balance in human networks _ , aip conf .
779 , 9395 ( 2005 ) .
p. gawroski , m. j. krawczyk and k. kuakowski , _ emerging communities in networks a flow of ties _ , acta phys .
b 46 , 911 ( 2015 ) . p. gawroski and k. kuakowski , _ a numerical trip to social psychology : long - living states of cognitive dissonance _ , lecture notes in computer science 4490 , 43 ( 2007 ) .
m. j. krawczyk , m. del castillo - mussot , e. hernandez - ramirez , g. g. naumis and k. kuakowski , _ heider balance , asymmetric ties , and gender segregation _ ,
physica a 439 , 66 ( 2015 ) .
e. aronson and d. linder , _ gain and loss of esteem as determinants of interpersonal attractiveness _
, j. of experimental social psychology 1 , 156 ( 1965 ) .
e. aronson , _ the social animal _ , w. h. freeman and co. , ny 1992 . j. tognoli and r. keisner , _ gain and loss of esteem as determinants of interpersonal attraction : a replication and extension _ , j. of personality and social psychology 23 , 201 ( 1972 )
. j. w. lawrence , c. s. carver and m. f. scheier , _ velocity toward goal attainment in immediate experience as a determinant of affect _ , j. of applied social psychology 32 , 788 ( 2002 ) .
a. t. lehr and g. geller , _ differential effects of reciprocity and attitude - similarity across long- versus short - term mating context _ , j. of social psychology 146 , 423 ( 2006 ) .
a. filipowicz , s. barsade and s. melwani , _ understanding emotional transitions : the interpersonal consequences of changing emotions in negotiations _ , j. of personality and social psychology 101 , 541 ( 2011 ) . c. reid , j. l. davis and j. d. green , _ the power of change : interpersonal attraction as a function of attitude similarity and attitude alignment _ , j. of social psychology 153 , 700 ( 2013 ) . t. komatsu , h. kaneko and t. komeda , _ investigating the effects of gain and loss of esteem _ , lecture notes in computer science 5744 , 87 ( 2009 )
. s. t. allison , d. eylon , j. k. beggan and j. bachelder , _ the demise of leadership : positivity and negativity biases in evaluation of dead leaders _ ,
leadership quarterly 20 , 115 ( 2009 ) .
s. a. marvel , j. kleinberg , r. d. kleinberg and s. h. strogatz , _ continuous - time model of structural balance _ , pnas 108/5 ( 2011 ) 1771 - 1776 .
r. m. montoya and c. a. insko , _ toward a more complete understanding of the reciprocity of liking effect _
, european j. of social psychology 38 , 477 ( 2008 ) .
r. singh , r. ng , e. l. ong and p.
k. f. lin , _ differente mediators for the age , sex , and attitude similarity effects in interpersonal attraction _ , basic and applied social psychology 30 , 1 ( 2008 ) .
k. m. carley and d. krackhart , _ cognitive inconsistencies and non - symmetric friendship _ , social networks 18 , 1 ( 1996 ) .
w. w. zachary , _ an information flow model for conflict and fission in small groups _ , j. of anthropological res .
33 , 452 ( 1977 ) .
t. antal , p. l. krapivsky and s. redner , _ social balance on networks : the dynamics of friendship and enmity _ , physica d 224 , 130 ( 2006 ) . | the effect of gain and loss of esteem is introduced into the equations of time evolution of social relations , hostile or friendly , in a group of actors .
the equations allow for asymmetric relations .
we prove that in the presence of this asymmetry , the majority of stable solutions are jammed states , i.e. the heider balance is not attained there .
a phase diagram is constructed with three phases : the jammed phase , the balanced phase with two mutually hostile groups , and the phase of so - called paradise , where all relations are friendly .
social systems , heider dynamics , asymmetric relations , jammed states 05.45.-a , 89.65.ef , 89.75.fb |
let @xmath6 be a banach space , @xmath7 be a compact set , and @xmath8 be a mapping of @xmath7 onto a finite - dimensional space @xmath9 @xcite .
let @xmath10 be @xmath11-dimensional subspaces of the linear space @xmath12 the kolmogorov width @xmath13 is defined by @xmath14 where the outer infimum is calculated over all @xmath15dimensional subspaces of @xmath16 [ definition 1.1 ] @xcite .
the babenko width @xmath17 is defined by [ definition 1.2 ] @xmath18 where the infimum is calculated over all continuous mappings @xmath19 if the infimum in ( [ ( 1.1 ) ] ) is attained for some @xmath20 this subspace is called an extremal subspace .
the widths evaluation for various spaces of functions play an important role in numerical analysis and approximation theory since this problem is closely related to many optimality problems such as @xmath21 complexity of integration and approximation , optimal differentiation , and optimal approximation of solutions of operator equations .
for a detailed study of these problems in view of the general theory of optimal algorithms we refer to @xcite .
@xcite formulated the problem of evaluating the widths @xmath22 the discovery of extremal subspaces of @xmath10 .
@xcite also evaluated @xmath13 for certain compact sets @xmath23 .
kolmogorov asserted to determine the exact value of @xmath13 because it might lead to the discovery of extremal subspaces , and therefore to new and better methods of approximation . @xcite
promoted using extremal subspaces of compacts @xmath23 in constructing numerical methods in physics and mechanics .
the most general results were obtained in estimating the kolmogorov widths in sobolev spaces @xmath24 on unit balls @xmath25 .
@xcite estimated the widths @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
@xcite obtained the exact values of @xmath28 .
the widths @xmath29 for various @xmath30 and @xmath31 were studied by several authors , e.g. @xcite , @xcite , @xcite,@xcite,@xcite .
@xcite and @xcite obtained the final estimates of @xmath29 for @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
the widths of various classes of multivariable functions were analyzed by several scientists , e.g.,@xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , where the books @xcite , @xcite , @xcite,@xcite , @xcite , and the articles @xcite may serve as reviews .
solutions of numerous problems of analysis , mechanics , electrodynamics , and geophysics lead to the necessity to develop optimal methods for approximating special classes of functions .
the classes @xmath34 consist of functions having bounded derivatives up to order @xmath35 in a closed domain @xmath36 and higher order derivatives in @xmath37 whose modulus increases unboundedly in a neighbourhood of the boundary @xmath38 ( see definitions [ definition 1.3 ] [ definition 1.7 ] ) . the classes @xmath34 describe solutions of elliptic equations @xcite , weakly singular , singular , and hypersingular integral equations @xcite .
the functions representable by singular and hypersingular integrals with moving singularities @xmath39 , p=2,3,\cdots ; $ ] + @xmath40 , p=3,4,\cdots $ ] also belong to @xmath34 ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
apparently @xcite defined the class of functions @xmath41 to emphasize its role in construction approximation in numerous important problems in mathematical physics .
the relationship between the functional class @xmath41 ( as well as @xmath34 ) and compacts in the weighted sobolev space @xmath42 follows from the definition of the classes .
let @xmath43^l , l=1,2,\ldots,$ ] @xmath44 @xmath45 be integers .
let @xmath46 be the @xmath47-distance between a point @xmath48 and the boundary @xmath49 the class @xmath50 consists of functions @xmath51 which have bounded partial derivatives of orders @xmath52 in @xmath36 and partial derivatives of orders @xmath53 in @xmath54 with the norm @xmath55 where @xmath56 are nonnegative integers , @xmath57 similarly one can define the classes of functions @xmath58 @xmath59 and @xmath60 which are counterparts of the classes @xmath61 @xmath62 and @xmath63 the results of this paper can be extended to the classes @xmath64 @xmath58 @xmath59 and @xmath65 the widths estimates for the sets of functions @xmath66
@xmath67 @xmath68 and @xmath69 are of interest since they play an important role in various applied problems , for example , problems of hydrodynamics .
the author intends to use the obtained results in his further works in constructing optimal numerical methods for solving some problems of mathematical physics .
@xcite defined the class @xmath41 ( definition [ definition 1.3 ] ) and declared the problem of estimating the kolmogorov and babenko widths of @xmath41 to be one of the most important problems in the numerical analysis . later on this problem
was solved by the author ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . the classes @xmath61 @xmath70 and @xmath71 generalize the class + @xmath72 @xcite estimated the kolmogorov and babenko widths and constructed local splines for approximation of functions from @xmath61 @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
the error of approximation obtained by local splines has the same order as that of the corresponding values of the kolmogorov and babenko widths .
below we list the definitions of the functional classes @xmath61 @xmath70 @xmath73 and @xmath74 let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath76 @xmath77 be the boundary of @xmath78 and @xmath79 be positive integers .
let @xmath80 @xmath81 @xmath82 @xmath83 and @xmath84 be nonnegative integers , @xmath85 @xcite .
[ definition 1.3 ] let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath86 the class @xmath41 consists of functions @xmath87 satisfying @xmath88 @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the @xmath47-distance between a point @xmath48 and @xmath91 @xcite .
[ definition 1.4 ] let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath86 the class @xmath34 consists of functions @xmath92 satisfying @xmath93 @xmath94 note , @xmath95 @xmath96 @xcite . [ definition 1.5 ]
let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath86 the class @xmath97 consists of functions @xmath92 satisfying @xmath98 @xmath99 where @xmath100 @xmath101 @xmath102 @xmath103 @xmath104 , @xmath105 [ definition 1.6 ] let @xmath43^l , l=1,2,\ldots.$ ] let @xmath106 and @xmath107 be positive integers .
the class @xmath108 consists of functions @xmath109 satisfying + @xmath110 + @xmath111 + @xmath112 where @xmath113 [ definition 1.7 ] let @xmath3^l , l=1,2,\ldots.$ ] let @xmath107 be a positive integer , and @xmath114 be a non - integer .
the class @xmath115 consists of functions @xmath92 satisfying @xmath116 @xmath117 where @xmath118 [ definition 1.8 ] let @xmath119.$ ] the class @xmath120 @xmath121 consists of functions @xmath122 $ ] which have absolutely continuous derivatives of orders @xmath123 and a piecewise continuous derivative @xmath124 satisfying @xmath125 [ definition 1.9 ] let @xmath126=[a_1,b_1]\times\cdots\times[a_l , b_l],$ ] @xmath127 the class @xmath128 @xmath129 consists of functions @xmath130 $ ] which have absolutely continuous partial derivatives of orders @xmath123 and a piecewise continuous partial derivative of order @xmath35 satisfying @xmath131 now we briefly describe the notations we use throughout this paper .
let @xmath132 @xmath133,$ ] @xmath134.$ ] we denote by @xmath135,c)$ ] the taylor polynomial of @xmath136 of order @xmath137 with respect to the point @xmath138
i.e. @xmath139,c)= \sum^{r-1}_{j=0}(f^{(j)}(c ) / j ! ) ( t - c)^j.$ ] for @xmath140 @xmath141,$ ] @xmath142 we can re - write its taylor polynomial of order @xmath137 as @xmath143 where @xmath144 is a polynomial of order @xmath145 given by @xmath146 + @xmath147 the taylor polynomials for functions of @xmath148 variables can be re - written similarly . many types of differential and integral equations such as elliptic equations @xcite ,
weakly singular integral equations @xcite , singular , and hypersingular integral equations @xcite have solutions that belong to the functional sets similar to @xmath149 and @xmath5 therefore evaluating the widhts of @xmath150 and @xmath151 and finding the extremal subspaces are important problems in numerical analysis .
the author @xcite developed optimal with respect to order to accuracy methods for approximating the classes @xmath152 and @xmath153 .
afterwards , these methods were used in developing ( optimal with respect to order to accuracy and complexity ) approximate methods for solving fredholm and volterra weakly singular integral equations @xcite , in estimating an accuracy of elliptic equations solutions @xcite , and in developing optimal with respect to accuracy cubature rules for evaluating many - dimensional integrals @xcite .
solutions of some classes of weakly singular , singular , and hypersingular integral equations belong to the classes @xmath0 and @xmath5 in this paper we obtain the weak asymptotic estimates of the kolmogorov and babenko widths of the classes @xmath154 and @xmath155 we also construct local splines , which yield the optimal order of approximation ( in the sense of the widths @xmath156 and @xmath157 ) for functions in @xmath154 , @xmath155 the author intends to use the optimal methods for approximating the functional classes @xmath0 and @xmath1 proposed in this paper for developing optimal methods of solving weakly singular , singular , and hypersingular integral equations .
we start with recalling the following well - known assertions .
[ lemma 1.1 ] let @xmath158 be a hausdorff space , @xmath159 there exist @xmath160 points @xmath161 @xmath162 and a number @xmath163 with the following property : for each distribution of signs @xmath164 @xmath165 there is a function @xmath166 such that @xmath167 @xmath168 @xmath169 then @xmath170 in the space @xmath171 .
[ lemma 1.2 ] let @xmath6 be a banach space , @xmath7 be a compact set .
the inequality @xmath172 is true .
let @xmath173 @xmath174 be the zeros of the chebyshev polynomial of the first kind of degree @xmath175 moreover , let @xmath136 be a continuous function on @xmath176,$ ] i.e. @xmath177).$ ] finally , denote by @xmath178)$ ] the interpolating polynomial with respect to the chebyshev nodes @xmath179 @xcite .
[ lemma 1.3 ] if @xmath180 @xmath121 then + @xmath181)\|_{c[-1,1 ] } \leq \|f^{(r)}\|_{c[-1,1]}1/(r ! 2^{r-1 } ) .
$ ] now we briefly recall the estimates of the babenko and kolmogorov widths of the classes @xmath61 and @xmath97 with respect to @xmath182 and @xmath183 .
if in the following theorems no restrictions on one or several of the parameters are given , then the full range as described in the respective definitions is admissible
. @xcite .
[ theorem 1.1 ] let @xmath75.$ ] then @xmath184 @xcite . [ theorem 1.2 ] let @xmath75.$ ] if @xmath114 is integer , then @xmath185 @xcite . [ theorem 1.3 ] let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath186 then @xmath187 where @xmath188 @xcite .
[ theorem 1.4 ] let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath189 @xmath190 if @xmath114 is integer , then @xmath191 where @xmath188 @xcite . [ theorem 1.5 ] let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath189 @xmath192 if @xmath114 is integer , then @xmath193 where @xmath194 @xcite . [ theorem 1.6 ] let @xmath75^l,$ ] @xmath189 @xmath195 if @xmath114 is integer , then @xmath196 where @xmath194 the articles @xcite also contain explicit constructions of local splines which yield the optimal order of approximation error in theorems [ theorem 1.1][theorem 1.6 ]
. hence these splines can be regarded as optimal methods of approximation in the sense of the kolmogorov and babenko widths . in this paper
we extend some of these results to the classes @xmath197^l,1)$ ] and @xmath198^l,1),$ ] @xmath199
in this section we estimate the kolmogorov and babenko widths for each of the functional classes @xmath0 and @xmath200 @xmath201.$ ] [ theorem 2.1 ] let @xmath75.$ ] let @xmath202 be positive integers , @xmath203 then @xmath204 first we estimate the infimum for @xmath205 note @xmath206 by theorem [ theorem 1.1 ] we know @xmath207 therefore @xmath208 to construct a continuous local spline with @xmath11 parameters that approximates the functions of @xmath0 with the accuracy @xmath209 , we study two cases : i ) @xmath210 and ii ) @xmath211 i ) .
let @xmath212 we divide the interval @xmath176 $ ] into @xmath213 subintervals by the points @xmath214 and @xmath215 @xmath216 @xmath217 then divide the obtained interval @xmath218 $ ] into @xmath219 subintervals by the points @xmath220 @xmath221 continuing the partition procedure we subdivide @xmath222 $ ] into @xmath223 subintervals by @xmath224 @xmath225 for each interval @xmath226 $ ] we now choose a polynomial @xmath227)$ ] interpolating @xmath228 at the endpoints @xmath229 and @xmath230 in the following way .
denote the zeros of the chebyshev polynomial of the first kind of degree @xmath231 by @xmath173 @xmath232 map @xmath233 \subset [ -1,1]$ ] with an affine - linear transformation onto @xmath226 $ ] so that the points @xmath234 and @xmath235 are mapped onto @xmath229 and @xmath230 respectively .
denote the images of the points @xmath236 under this mapping by @xmath237 @xmath238 we then denote by @xmath227)$ ] the interpolation polynomial of degree @xmath239 with respect to the nodes @xmath237 @xmath238 now define the function @xmath240 on @xmath176 $ ] to piecewise consist of the polynomials @xmath241),$ ] @xmath242),$ ] @xmath243),$ ] @xmath244),$ ] @xmath245 @xmath246 with these definitions in hand , we can now estimate the pointwise approximation error @xmath247 on the intervals @xmath248,$ ] @xmath249 we obtain @xmath250 where @xmath251 is the lebesgue constant with respect to the nodes used for @xmath252 @xmath253)$ ] is the best approximation of the function @xmath136 by polynomials of degree at most @xmath231 in the norm of @xmath254,$ ] similar estimates are true in @xmath255,$ ] @xmath246 throughout this paper , we denote the constants that do not depend on @xmath256 by @xmath257 .
now let @xmath258 it is well - known that it holds @xmath259 + where @xmath260.$ ] here @xmath251 is the lebesgue constant with respect to the nodes used for @xmath261 using taylor s expansion @xmath262 with the remainder in integral form we find @xmath263 @xmath264 where @xmath265 @xmath266 therefore , @xmath267 since the lebesgue constant @xmath251 is independent of @xmath256 due to its invariance under rescaling we finally obtain @xmath268 one can obtain a similar estimate in @xmath269.$ ] with similar arguments we obtain on @xmath270 , \ 1 \leq j \leq m-1 $ ] @xmath271 similar estimates are true in @xmath272,$ ] @xmath273 the total number @xmath11 of nodes used in constructing the local spline equals @xmath274 - 1)(s-1)+(n-1)(s-1))+1.$ ] therefore @xmath275 it follows from ( [ ( 2.2 ) ] ) ( [ ( 2.4 ) ] ) that we have constructed a continuous local spline @xmath240 which approximates @xmath276 with the accuracy @xmath277 from definition [ definition 1.1 ] , it follows that @xmath278 using lemma [ lemma 1.2 ] and the inequalities ( [ ( 2.1 ) ] ) , ( [ ( 2.5 ) ] ) we complete the proof of the theorem for @xmath212 we now consider \ii ) @xmath279 we use the same points @xmath280 and @xmath281 and intervals @xmath282 and @xmath283 as before .
additionally put @xmath284 and @xmath285 @xmath286 divide each @xmath282 and @xmath283 into @xmath287 @xmath288 equal subintervals and denote the latter ones by @xmath289 @xmath290 @xmath291 @xmath292 we shall approximate @xmath293 within each @xmath294 by the interpolating polynomial @xmath295 @xmath290 @xmath291 @xmath292 let @xmath240 be the spline composed of the polynomials @xmath296 starting with approximating the error in @xmath297 we have in @xmath298 @xmath299 using taylor s expansion @xmath300 we find @xmath301 @xmath302 @xmath303 where @xmath304 @xmath305 finally , @xmath306 in @xmath307 our next step is to obtain the estimate of @xmath308 @xmath291 @xmath290 @xmath246 it is obvious that @xmath309 @xmath310 @xmath311 @xmath312 where @xmath313 the errors @xmath314 can be estimated similarly . combining the estimates obtained above we have @xmath315 ) } \leq c n^{-s}. $ ] next we need to estimate the number of nodes used to construct the local spline @xmath316 for this purpose , we first estimate the number @xmath317 of subintervals
@xmath289 @xmath290 @xmath291 @xmath292 let @xmath318 then @xmath319 @xmath320 therefore the total number of nodes used in constructing @xmath240 equals to @xmath321 hence , @xmath315 ) } \leq
c n^{-s } \leq c n^{-s}. $ ] thus , @xmath322 comparing the preceding inequality to the estimate ( [ ( 2.1 ) ] ) we complete the proof of the theorem for @xmath279 [ theorem 2.2 ] let @xmath3 $ ] .
let @xmath323 be positive integers , and @xmath114 be a positive non - integer .
the estimate @xmath324 holds , where as usual @xmath325 first , we estimate the infimum for @xmath326 note @xmath327 by theorem [ theorem 1.1 ] , the inequality @xmath328 holds .
therefore @xmath329 next , we construct a local spline @xmath240 with at most @xmath330 nodes approximating the given function @xmath331 with error at most @xmath332 we use the same subdivision procedure into intervals @xmath333 $ ] and @xmath334 $ ] as in the proof of theorem [ theorem 2.1 ] . here @xmath335 we approximate a function @xmath136 on @xmath176 $ ] by the spline @xmath240 which piecewise consists of the polynomials @xmath336 @xmath290 @xmath337 @xmath292 estimating the error @xmath338 we obtain for @xmath339 @xmath340 @xmath341 one can derive similarly @xmath342
@xmath343 for @xmath344 , the following estimate is true : @xmath345 using the taylor expansion @xmath346 we have @xmath347 @xmath348 recall @xmath349 hence , @xmath350 one can estimate the norms @xmath351 and @xmath352 @xmath353 in a similar way .
thus , we have obtained @xmath354 it remains to estimate the number @xmath11 of nodes of the local spline @xmath316 repeating the arguments used in the proof of the preceding theorem we derive @xmath355 since the specific value of @xmath31 did not enter in this calculation .
thus , we have @xmath356 and @xmath357 comparing the last inequality with the estimate @xmath358 we complete the proof of theorem .
in this section we estimate the kolmogorov and babenko widths for each of the functional classes @xmath0 and @xmath200 @xmath201^l,$ ] @xmath127 we start to estimate the kolmogorov widths .
first , we construct a local spline not necessarily continuous which approximates the functions of the classes @xmath0 for @xmath366 and has the error given in the right - hand side of ( [ ( 3.1 ) ] ) @xmath367 ( [ ( 3.3 ) ] ) .
afterwards we construct a continuous local spline having the same error of approximation .
this requires some modifications which we indicate below .
we now partition the domains @xmath370 @xmath371 in the following way .
decompose each @xmath368 into cubes and parallelepipeds @xmath372 with their edges parallel to the axes .
the lengths of edges are not less than the value @xmath373 and less than @xmath374 @xmath375 ( see fig [ fig:1 ] ) let estimate the number of @xmath377 @xmath292 clearly , @xmath378^{l-1 } = 1+m \sum\limits_{k=0}^{n-1 } \left[\frac{n^v-(k+1)^v}{(k+1)^v - k^v}\right]^{l-1 } \ge\ ] ] @xmath379 where @xmath317 is the number of faces in @xmath380 let @xmath383 dividing each edge of @xmath372 into @xmath384 equal subintervals and passing the planes parallel to the coordinate planes throught the points of division we partition @xmath385 into @xmath386 in section [ sec;sec2 ] we used the interpolating polynomial @xmath227)$ ] for functions @xmath136 of one variable .
as a next step we consider a possible multivariate counterpart .
more precisely , for a function @xmath387 of @xmath388 variables on @xmath389 $ ] we define the interpolating polynomial @xmath390)$ ] iteratively : @xmath391)= p^{t_1}_s(p^{t_2}_s(\cdots p^{t_l}_s(f;[a_l , b_l]);[a_{l-1},b_{l-1 } ] ) ; \cdots ; [ a_1,b_1 ] ) .
$ ] this polynomial then is of degree @xmath239 in each of the variables @xmath392 in other words , @xmath393)$ ] interpolates @xmath394 with respect to @xmath395;$ ] @xmath396 ) ; [ a_{l-1},b_{l-1}])$ ] interpolates @xmath397)$ ] in @xmath398 $ ] etc .
the polynomial @xmath399 interpolates @xmath387 in each @xmath386 we piece together the interpolating polynomials @xmath399 and construct a local spline @xmath316 next we estimate the approximation of @xmath400 by @xmath316 with @xmath408 in the domain @xmath409 , which has a nonempty intersection with the boundary @xmath410 we trivially have @xmath411 and thus @xmath412 which immediately yields @xmath413 @xmath414 where @xmath415 now we describe the necessary modifications to the computations above in order to construct a continuous local spline approximating @xmath0 for @xmath366 and having the estimate given in ( [ ( 3.1 ) ] ) - ( [ ( 3.3 ) ] ) .
let @xmath368 be defined as above and @xmath436 @xmath437 @xmath292 we then shall use the following modified partitioning of @xmath380 as before decompose @xmath438 into cubes or parallelepipeds @xmath439 with edges parallel to the axes , and whose lengths is not less then @xmath440 and does not exceed then @xmath441 but now choose the partition in such a way that the vertices of @xmath442 are contained in the set consisting of all vertices of the subdomains @xmath443 next , partition each @xmath439 into cubes or parallelepipeds @xmath444 with edges parallel to the axes .
we divide each edge of the subdomain @xmath439 into @xmath445 equal subintervals and pass the planes parallel to the coordinate planes through the points of division .
finally we decomposed @xmath438 into @xmath446 to decompose @xmath447 into cubes and parallelepipeds @xmath448 we pass the planes parallel to the coordinate planes through the vertices of @xmath449 which are located on a common face of the hyperplane @xmath450 denote the obtained subdomains by @xmath451 let @xmath452 consider @xmath453.$ ] if the length of the edge @xmath454 exceeds @xmath455 we divide @xmath454 into @xmath456 $ ] equal subintervals and pass the planes parallel to the coordinate planes through the points of division .
we shall refer to the result of this procedure as @xmath448 . this way we have @xmath447 decomposed into @xmath457
continuing this process we partition the domain @xmath36 into subdomains @xmath458 now we construct the continuous spline @xmath240 approximating a function @xmath136 of @xmath388 variables .
the polynomial @xmath460 interpolates @xmath136 in @xmath461 @xmath462 interpolates @xmath463 in @xmath446 we say that the function @xmath463 equals to @xmath136 at all points of interpolation except for those located on the hypersurface @xmath464 . at those points
, @xmath463 equals to @xmath465 continuing this process , we construct the interpolating polynomials @xmath466 we decompose the domain @xmath36 into subdomains @xmath485 @xmath486 following the procedure which was described above in the proof of theorem ( see the part of constructing a not necessarily continuous local spline ) .
we divide each edge of @xmath485 @xmath486 into @xmath384 equal subintervals and pass the planes parallel to coordinate planes through the points of division .
this way we have @xmath485 @xmath486 decomposed into @xmath471 @xmath292 let @xmath368 be the set @xmath516 where @xmath517 is defined by @xmath518 and @xmath519 @xmath520 here @xmath317 is the largest integer value when @xmath521 if @xmath522 then @xmath36 is decomposed into @xmath370 @xmath523 if @xmath524 then @xmath525 is the set @xmath526 hence the number @xmath317 of @xmath370 @xmath541 is less than @xmath542 we decompose each @xmath368 into cubes or parallelepipeds @xmath372 in a way described above in the proof of the theorem [ theorem 3.1](see the part of constructing a not necessarily continuous local spline ) .
clearly , the total number of @xmath485 @xmath541 is equal to @xmath543 where @xmath544 is the number of @xmath545 let @xmath546,$ ] @xmath523 introduce the functions @xmath547
@xmath548 @xmath520 constants @xmath498 @xmath549 are chosen such that @xmath550 @xmath550 obviously , such constants exist and do not depend on @xmath551 let @xmath560 first , we construct a local spline not necessary continuous which approximates the functions of @xmath0 for @xmath561 and has the error not exceeding @xmath562 afterwards we construct a continuous local spline having the same error of approximation .
when constructing a local spline we employ the same process as used in the proof of theorem [ theorem 3.1 ] ( see the part of constructing a not necessarily continuous local spline ) .
we define the domains @xmath368 and partition them into @xmath563 @xmath564 in a similar way we did for @xmath565 to construct the continuous local spline @xmath580 approximating @xmath108 for @xmath561 and having the error @xmath581 , we employ all above constructions for the continuous local spline @xmath580 approximating @xmath108 when @xmath582 cf .
the proof of [ theorem 3.1 ] .
the proof of the theorem is similar to the proof of theorem [ theorem 3.1 ] .
first , we construct a local not necessarily continuous spline which approximates the functions of the class @xmath602 and has the error given in the right - hand sides of ( [ ( 3.22 ) ] ) ( [ ( 3.24 ) ] ) .
afterwards we construct a continuous local spline having the same error of approximation .
we decompose the domain @xmath36 into subdomains @xmath471 @xmath486 following the procedure which was described more than once in this section .
( for instance , see the proof of theorem [ theorem 3.1]).in doing so , we divide each edge of @xmath485 into @xmath384 equal subintervals , @xmath603 and pass the planes parallel to the coordinate planes throught the points of division .
to interpolate @xmath136 in each of the obtained cubes or parallelepipedes @xmath604 we use the polynomial @xmath399 described in this section .
hence the local spline @xmath240 is composed of the polynomials @xmath605 @xmath292 to obtain the upper estimate of the kolmogorov widths of the functional class @xmath640 we construct a continuous local spline which has the error given in the right - hand sides of ( [ ( 3.29 ) ] ) , ( [ ( 3.30 ) ] ) . for this purpose ,
we repeart the construction of the continuous local spline provided in the proof of theorem [ theorem 3.1 ] .
one can show that the continuous local spline that approximates the functions of @xmath1 has the error given in the right - hand sides of ( [ ( 3.29 ) ] ) , ( [ ( 3.30 ) ] ) .
we decompose the domain @xmath36 into subdomains @xmath488 @xmath486 following the procedure which was described in the proof of the theorem [ theorem 3.1 ] ( see the part of babenko widths estimates for @xmath620 ) . to construct the continuous local spline @xmath580 approximating @xmath683 for @xmath561 with the error @xmath581
, we employ all above constructions for the continuous local spline @xmath580 approximating @xmath108 when @xmath684 cf .
the proof of [ theorem 3.3 ] .
anuchina , k.i .
babenko , s.k .
godunov , et al .
, theoretical foundations and constructions of numerical algorithms for problems of mathematical physics , nauka , moscow , 1979 . mr83e:65006 .
( in russian ) .
boykov ( 1989 ) , optimal cubature formulae for computing many - dimensional integrals in the class @xmath688 , zh .
vychisl . mat . mat .
, 30(8 ) , pp.1123 - 1132 .
phys . , 30(4 ) , pp.110 - 117 .
boykov , j.f zakharova , s.p .
alatkin ( 2010 ) , approximate solutions of hypersingular integral equations by spline - collocation methods based on zero degree splines , izvestiya vuz .
povolgski region .
fiziko - matematicheskie nauki . , 3
, pp.28 - 42 .
r.s ismagilov ( 1974 ) , diameters of sets in normed linear spaces and the approximation of functions by trigonometric polynomials , uspehi mat .
nauk . , 29(3 ) , pp.161 - 178 .
surv . , 29 , pp.169 - 186 . | solutions of numerous equations of mathematical physics such as elliptic , weakly singular , singular , hypersingular integral equations belong to functional classes @xmath0 and @xmath1 defined over @xmath2dimensional hypercube @xmath3^l , l=1,2,\dots.$ ] the derivatives of classes representatives grow indefinitely when the argument approaches the boundary @xmath4 . in this paper
we estimate the kolmogorov and babenko widths of two functional classes @xmath0 and
@xmath5 we construct local splines belonging to those classes , such that the errors of approximation are of the same order as that of the estimated widths .
thus we construct optimal with respect to order methods for approximating the functional classes @xmath0 and @xmath5 one can use these results for constructing methods optimal with respect to order for approximating a unit ball of the sobolev spaces with logarithmic and polynomial weights .
kolmogorov widths ; babenko widths ; optimal approximation ; splines . |
physicists have long speculated that the fundamental constants might not , in fact , be constant , but instead might vary with time .
dirac was the first to suggest this possibility @xcite , and time variation of the fundamental constants has been investigated numerous times since then . among the various possibilities , the fine structure constant and the gravitational constant have received the greatest attention , but work has also been done , for example , on constants related to the weak and strong interactions , the electron - proton mass ratio , and several others .
it is well - known that only time variation of dimensionless fundamental constants has any physical meaning .
here we consider the time variation of a dimensionless constant not previously discussed in the literature : @xmath0 .
it is impossible to overstate the significance of this constant .
indeed , nearly every paper in astrophysics makes use of it .
( for a randomly - selected collection of such papers , see refs .
@xcite ) .
.the value of @xmath0 measured at the indicated location at the indicated time . [ cols=">,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] in the next section , we discuss the observational evidence for the time variation of @xmath0 . in sec .
iii , we present a theoretical model , based on string theory , which produces such a time variation , and we show that this model leads naturally to an accelerated expansion for the universe . the oklo reactor is discussed in sec .
iv , and directions for future research are presented in sec . v.
the value of @xmath0 has been measured in various locations over the past 4000 years . in table 1
, we compile a list of representative historical measurements @xcite .
we see evidence for both spatial and time variation of @xmath0 .
we will leave the former for a later investigation , and concentrate on the latter . in fig . 1
, we provide a graph illustrating the time variation more clearly .
= 3.8truein = 3.8truein the values of @xmath1 show a systematic trend , varying monotonically with time and converging to the present - day measured value .
the evidence for time variation of @xmath0 is overwhelming .
inspired by string theory @xcite , we propose the following model for the time variation of @xmath0 .
consider the possibility that our observable universe is actually a 4-dimensional brane embedded in a 5-dimensional bulk . in this case , slices " of @xmath0 can leak into the higher dimension , resulting in a value of @xmath0 that decreases with time .
this leakage into a higher dimension results in a characteristic geometric distortion , illustrated in fig .
such leakage " has been observed previously in both automobile and bicycle tires .
however , it is clear that more controlled experiments are necessary to verify this effect .
it might appear that the observational data quoted in the previous section suggest a value of @xmath0 that increases with time , rather than decreasing as our model indicates .
since our theoretical model is clearly correct , this must be attributed to 4000 years of systematic errors .
now consider the cosmological consequences of this time variation in @xmath0 .
the friedmann equation gives @xcite @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the scale factor and @xmath4 is the total density . at late times
@xmath4 is dominated by matter , so that @xmath5 .
hence , if @xmath0 increases faster than @xmath3 , the result will be an accelerated expansion .
of course , our model gives the opposite sign for the time - variation of @xmath0 , but this is a minor glitch which is probably easy to fix .
this model for the time variation of @xmath0 has several other consequences .
it provides a model for the dark matter @xcite , and it can be used to derive a solution to the cosmological constant coincidence problem @xcite .
further , it can be developed into a quantum theory of gravity @xcite .
no discussion of the time - variation of fundamental constants would be complete without a mention of the oklo natural fission reactor .
this investigation clearly opens up an entirely new direction in the study of the time variation of fundamental constants . the next obvious possibility is the investigation of the time variation of @xmath6 . following this
, there is a plethora of other constants that could be examined : the euler - mascheroni constant @xmath7 , the golden ratio @xmath8 , soldner s constant , and catelan s constant .
more speculatively , one might consider the possibility that the values of the integers could vary with time , a result suggested by several early fortran simulations .
this possibility would have obvious implications for finance and accounting .
a number of colleagues were kind enough to comment on the manuscript .
for some reason they did not want me to use their names , so i will identify them by their initials : s. dodelson , a.l .
melott , d.n .
spergel , and t. j. weiler . | we examine the time variation of a previously - uninvestigated fundamental dimensionless constant .
constraints are placed on this time variation using historical measurements .
a model is presented for the time variation , and it is shown to lead to an accelerated expansion for the universe .
directions for future research are discussed . |
the inflationary paradigm was originally motivated by its ability to solve the `` initial conditions '' problems associated with the standard model of the big bang @xcite .
however it was quickly realised that an inflationary epoch would also produce primordial density perturbations and may be able to explain both the observed clustering of galaxies and the ( then unobserved ) anisotropies in the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) . insisting that inflation produces the observed spectrum of primordial perturbations is a more demanding requirement than merely providing the approximately 60 e - foldings of inflation needed to solve the various initial conditions problems
consequently , the focus of much present work is on the density perturbation spectra produced by different inflationary models .
this is particularly true of slow - rolling inflation , in which the scalar field evolves continuously .
the consistency of slow - rolling inflation can be directly tested through cmb observations @xcite , and in principle the potential can be reconstructed @xcite , opening a window into a gut - scale particle physics . in order to do this , accurate calculations of the perturbation spectra produced during inflation are required .
stewart and lyth @xcite give a second order calculation of the perturbation spectra for a general potential .
exact scalar field cosmologies have been widely studied , in for instance , @xcite , but power - law inflation @xcite remains the only only inflationary model for which the perturbation spectrum has been obtained exactly @xcite .
the purpose of this paper is to present a new scalar field cosmology for which the spectrum of scalar perturbations can be obtained analytically .
this solution therefore provides a second example of a slow - rolling inflationary cosmology with an exact perturbation spectrum . while the perturbations produced are not within the parameter range permitted by observation , this model extends our understanding of the problem and can be used to probe the validity of the approximation schemes used to tackle the more general problem .
for a scalar field , @xmath0 with potential @xmath1 in a spatially flat robertson - walker metric we have @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the scale factor and @xmath4 , is the hubble parameter . from these equations
we obtain the equation of motion for the scalar field , @xmath5 as is often the case when dealing with exact scalar field cosmologies it will be useful to parametrise the motion in terms of the field , @xmath0 @xcite . from equations ( [ hsqrd ] ) and ( [ adda ] )
we deduce that @xmath6 , leading to @xmath7 where a dash denotes differentiation with respect to @xmath0 .
if we specify @xmath8 we can immediately obtain the corresponding potential and evolution .
the equation governing the evolution of scalar perturbations with wavenumber @xmath9 is @xcite @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the conformal time and @xmath12 .
furthermore , we have the boundary conditions @xmath13 which guarantees that the perturbation behaves like a free field well inside the horizon and is fixed at superhorizon scales . in practice , however , we are interested in the spectrum @xmath14 and index , @xmath15 which are given by @xmath16 the form of equation ( [ mode1 ] ) can be simplified by defining @xmath17 , and @xmath18 \frac{d u_k}{d \eta } + k^2 u_k = 0 .
\label{mode2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now turn our attention to the particular case where @xmath19 is a constant , which is equivalent to demanding that the term in square brackets in equation ( [ mode2 ] ) vanishes .
in order to construct a model with an exact perturbation spectrum we demand that @xmath19 is constant . this is equivalent to requiring that @xmath20 satisfy the differential equation @xmath21 which has the solution @xmath22 the values of the integration constants @xmath23 and @xmath24 are arbitrary , but we can set @xmath25 without loss of generality , as it can be recovered by making a linear shift of the field . from equations ( [ vflatphi ] )
to ( [ tflatphi ] ) we derive the corresponding exact scalar field cosmology , @xmath26 , \label{texact}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 is the exponential integral function .
the conformal time is @xmath28 .
\label{etaexact}\ ] ] at late times , or as @xmath0 goes to zero , the conformal time tends to a constant value .
the cosmological properties of this solution are quickly derived .
the potential , shown in figure 1 , is not bounded below . however , for this solution the total energy density is always positive as the kinetic energy is very large in the region where @xmath29 is large .
the motion is not inflationary at all times . by definition
, inflation occurs when @xmath30 , or when @xmath31 , where @xmath32 thus inflation occurs only when @xmath33 .
if this model was to produce _ all _ the 60 e - foldings of inflation needed to solve the initial conditions problems in the standard model of cosmology , @xmath0 must evolve to be unreasonably close to zero in view of the typical size of the perturbations in the field .
this exact inflationary model is similar to one previously discussed by barrow @xcite , and can clearly be generalised in a number of ways . in particular , taking the hubble parameter to be of the form @xmath34 gives a similar potential .
however , in this paper we will focus on the case where @xmath19 is constant , which requires @xmath20 to have the form of equation ( [ hsoln ] ) .
we now turn our attention to the spectrum of scalar perturbations produced by this model .
the solution to equation ( [ mode2 ] ) is simple , as the first derivative term drops out and we find @xmath35 for the growing mode , after we have imposed the boundary conditions . in terms of the conformal time
, this solution has the special property that the perturbations always evolve according to the equation of motion for a free field .
however , since @xmath36 tends to a constant value @xmath37 is essentially fixed at super - horizon scales , as we would expect .
we can immediately calculate the spectral index for these perturbations , giving @xmath38 note that this value is both exact and independent of @xmath0 .
a flat , or scale - free , spectrum has an index of unity .
hence this spectrum is `` blue '' as it possesses more power at large values of @xmath9 , or small scales .
astrophysical constraints , both from the cmb data @xcite and bounds on the density of small primordial black holes @xcite rule out such a large value of @xmath39 in the physical universe . the spectrum of the tensor , or gravitational , perturbations has not been obtained exactly .
however when @xmath40 , the expansion is roughly exponential and we therefore expect the tensor perturbation spectrum to be flat .
this model can be used to probe the accuracy of the first and second order expressions for the scalar perturbation spectra . since
this exact result pertains to a particular potential it does not provide a definitive test , but the results are reassuring . written in terms of derivatives of @xmath8
the perturbation spectrum is @xcite @xmath41 the subscripts 1 and 2 denote the first and second order values , respectively , and @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the euler - mascheroni constant . in figure
2 the first and second order results are plotted for the values of @xmath0 during which this solution is inflationary .
we can immediately see that the second order result gives a much more accurate estimate of the index than the first order value , remaining within approximately 10% of the exact value when @xmath44 .
the departures from slow roll for this potential are large , even though the expansion of the scale factor is approximately exponential .
the exact scalar field cosmology developed in this paper adds another specimen to the collection of analytic inflationary models that have been discovered over the last decade .
unusually , however , the mode equation for the scalar perturbations can also be solved , making this only the second model ( after power - law inflation ) for which the exact value of the spectral index of the scalar perturbations is known .
the spectrum has an index of 3 , which is significantly different from the scale free value of unity , and is too large to satisfy the observational bounds on the primordial spectrum .
however , this solution is useful as it can be used to test approximate calculations of the spectral indices for slow - rolling inflation .
since the slow - rolling conditions are badly violated by this model the test is a comparatively stringent one , and the first order expression does not give good agreement with the exact result .
however , the second order expression for the scalar index is able to match the exact result to within 10% over most of the inflationary epoch , a result which will add confidence to its use in more realistic situations .
the author thanks ed copeland for a valuable discussion and is supported by a jsps post - doctoral fellowship and the grant - in - aid for jsps fellows ( 0694194 ) .
10 a. h. guth , phys .
d * 23 * , 347 ( 1981 ) .
s. dodelson , l. knox , and e. w. kolb , phys .
lett . * 72 * , 3444 ( 1994 ) .
e. j. copeland , e. w. kolb , a. r. liddle , and j. e. lidsey , phys .
d * 48 * , 2529 ( 1993 ) .
e. j. copeland , e. w. kolb , a. r. liddle , and j. e. lidsey , phys .
d * 49 * , 1840 ( 1994 ) .
e. d. stewart and d. h. lyth , phys .
b * 302 * , 171 ( 1993 ) .
m. madsen , gen .
grav * 18 * , 879 ( 1986 ) .
a. g. muslimov , class .
quantum grav .
* 7 * , 231 ( 1990 ) .
g. f. r. ellis and m. s. madsen , class .
quantum grav .
* 8 * , 667 ( 1991 ) .
j. e. lidsey , class .
quantum grav .
* 8 * , 923 ( 1991 ) .
r. easther , class .
quantum grav . * 10 * , 2203 ( 1993 ) .
j. d. barrow , phys .
d * 48 * , 1585 ( 1993 ) .
j. d. barrow , phys .
d * 49 * , 3055 ( 1994 ) .
f. lucchin and s. matarrese , phys .
d * 32 * , 1316 ( 1985 ) .
f. lucchin and s. matarrese , phys.lett .
b * 164 * , 282 ( 1985 ) .
d. s. salopek and j. r. bond , phys .
d * 42 * , 3936 ( 1990 ) .
l. f. abbott and m. b. wise , nuc .
b * 244 * , 541 ( 1984 ) .
d. h. lyth and e. d. stewart , phys .
b * 274 * , 168 ( 1992 ) .
j. lidsey , phys .
b * 273 * , 42 ( 1991 ) .
v. f. mukhanov , phys .
b * 218 * , 17 ( 1989 ) .
n. makino and m. sasaki , prog .
. phys . * 86 * , 103 ( 1991 ) .
v. mukhanov , h. feldman , and r. h. brandenberger , phys . rep . * 215 * , 203 ( 1992 ) .
c. l. bennett _ et al .
j ( to appear ) .
b. j. carr , j. h. gilbert , and j. e. lidsey , phys .
d * 50 * , 4853 ( 1994 ) .
* figure 1 * the potential , equation ( [ vexact ] ) , is plotted for @xmath45 . the solution is only inflationary when @xmath0 is near the origin .
* figure 2 * the first order ( short dashes ) and second order ( long dashes ) results for the perturbation spectrum are plotted , with the exact value of 3 shown for reference , against the values of @xmath0 for which the exact solution is inflationary . | we present a new , exact scalar field cosmology for which the spectrum of scalar ( density ) perturbations can be calculated exactly .
we use this exact result to the probe the accuracy of approximate calculations of the perturbation spectrum .
pacs : 04.20.jb 98.80.c |
in cosmology , the standard cosmological model ( @xmath0cdm model ) is an effective theory which well describes the current universe in the accelerating phase of the expansion .
all the astronomical observations of supernovae snia and measurements of cmb favor this model over the alternatives but we are still looking for theoretical models to dethrone the @xmath0cdm model . on the other hand the @xmath0cdm model has serious problems like the cosmological constant problem or the coincidence problem which are open and waiting for a solution . among different propositions ,
it is an idea of introducing the running cosmological term @xcite . the most popular way of introducing a dynamical form of the cosmological term is a parametrization by the scalar field , i.e. @xmath15 or the ricci scalar , i.e. @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the ricci scalar . in the both mentioned cases ,
the covariance of field equation is not violated and @xmath18 relation emerges from covariant theories i.e. @xmath19 .
for example in paper @xcite , the relation @xmath20 is emerging from the theory of the scalar field with the self - interacting potential @xmath3 .
it is interesting that this type of a @xmath1 relation is supported by the non - critical string theory consideration @xcite .
two elements appear in the @xmath0cdm model , namely dark matter and dark energy .
the main aim of observational cosmology is to constrain the density parameters for dark energy as well as dark matter . in the testing of the @xmath0cdm model ,
the idea of dark energy is usually separated from the dark matter problem , the latter is considered as the explanation of flat galactic curves .
of course the conception of dark matter is also needed for the consistency of the model of cosmological structures but the hypothesis of dark energy and dark matter should be tested not as a isolated hypothesis . in this paper
, we explore the @xmath1cdm model with @xmath4 , where @xmath21 is the cosmological time for which we know an exact solution @xcite .
this enables us to show the nontrivial interactions between the sectors of dark matter and dark energy .
it would be demonstrated that the model , which is under consideration , constitutes the special case of models with the interaction @xcite term @xmath22 .
we will be demonstrated that the time dependence of the @xmath0 term is responsible for the modification of the standard scaling law of dark matter @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the scale factor @xcite .
wang and meng @xcite developed a phenomenological approach which is based on the modified matter scaling relation @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the parameter which measures a deviation from the standard case of cold dark matter ( cdm ) .
the both effect of the decaying @xmath0 term and the modification of the scaling relation are strictly related in our model .
one can obtain that cdm particles dilute more slowly in comparison to the standard relation @xmath27 in this model . in this context , the interesting approach was developed by alcaniz and lima @xcite .
the coupling parameter @xmath26 is also a subject of testing using astronomical data @xcite . in this paper , due to
it is known the exact solutions of our model it is possible to check how it works the model and one can strictly constrain the model parameters @xcite .
we estimate the value of @xmath28 where @xmath29 is energy density of dark matter . in our methodology
we consider the astronomical data as two separate data sets with respect to redshift @xmath7 .
the first group of low redshift consists of snia , bao , @xmath8 and the ap test , and the second group is composed of planck , wp and lensing data .
the case of decaying dark matter effect is only relevant for high redshift data .
this process takes place in the early universe .
we also analyze the model under considerations in details . in this analysis the model with @xmath4
is our case study . for this model
we show the terms @xmath30 , @xmath31 are slow - changing with respect to the cosmological time and it justified to treat them as constants .
the organization of the text is following .
in section [ sec:2 ] , we present the model with @xmath4 and its interpretation in scalar field cosmology with @xmath32 and with the potential @xmath3 . in section [ sec:3 ] , it is demonstrated how @xmath1cdm cosmologies can be interpolated as interacting cosmologies with the interacting term @xmath22 and how they solve the coincidence problem @xcite . in section [ sec:4 ] , we present some results of the statistical estimations of the model parameters obtained from some astronomical data .
finally the conclusion are presented in section [ sec:5 ] .
let us consider about the flat cosmological model with homogeneity and isotropy ( the robertson - walker symmetry ) .
the source of gravity is in the time dependent cosmological term and matter is in the form of a perfect fluid with energy density @xmath33 , where @xmath21 is the cosmological time .
the cosmic evolution is determined by the einstein equations which admit the friedmann first integral in the form @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the hubble function and @xmath36 is the scale factor and @xmath37 is a real dimensionless parameter .
the sign of @xmath38 depends of the type of particle and the distribution of their energy . in the generic case
the breit - wigner distribution gives rise the negative sign of @xmath38 @xcite .
note that this parametrization is distinguished by a dimensional analysis because a dimension of @xmath39 should coincide with a dimension of a time dependent part of @xmath1 .
it is assumed that the energy - momentum tensor for all fluids in the form of perfect fluid satisfies the conservation condition @xmath40 where @xmath41 .
the consequence of this relation is that @xmath42 the cosmic evolution is governed by the second order acceleration equation @xmath43 where @xmath44 and @xmath45 are effective energy density of all fluids and pressure respectively . in the model under the consideration we have @xmath46 @xmath47 where @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath38 is a real number . for this case
the exact solution of ( [ friedmann ] ) and ( [ con ] ) for the hubble parameter @xmath50 can be obtained in terms of bessel functions @xmath51 where @xmath12 is the present value of the hubble constant , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath54 is the present age of the universe @xmath55 and @xmath56 is the index of the bessel function . from ( [ hubble ] ) , the expression for the scale factor can be obtained in the simple form @xmath57^\frac{2}{3}.\ ] ] the inverse formula for @xmath58 is given by @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the riccati - bessel function @xmath61 .
finally the exact formula for total mass @xmath62 is given in the form @xmath63 the diagram of @xmath29 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 as a function of @xmath66 obtained for low @xmath7 data is presented in fig .
[ fig:4 ] , [ fig:5 ] and [ fig:6 ] .
note that at the present epoch ( @xmath67 ) both energy densities of dark matter and dark energy are of the same order ( fig .
[ fig:5 ] ) . .
the top thick line represents the evolution of @xmath68 for @xmath69 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
the bottom thick line represents the evolution of @xmath68 for @xmath72 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
the medium line represents the best fit ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
the gray region is the @xmath75 uncertainties .
we assumed @xmath76 and we choose @xmath77 as a unit of @xmath68 . ] .
the bottom thick line represents the evolution of @xmath78 for @xmath69 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
the top thick line represents the evolution of @xmath78 for @xmath72 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
the medium line represents the best fit ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
the gray region is the @xmath75 uncertainties .
we assumed @xmath76 and we choose @xmath77 as a unit of @xmath78 . ] .
the top thick line represents the evolution of @xmath65 for @xmath69 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
the bottom thick line represents the evolution of @xmath65 for @xmath72 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
the medium line represents the best fit ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
the gray region is the @xmath75 uncertainties . ]
while the relation @xmath79 violates the covariance of the general relativity lagrangian , it can be simply demonstrated that such a relation can emerge from the covariant theory of scalar fields .
this relation reveals as a time - dependent first integral of equation of motion .
the action of general relativity for a perfect fluid has the following form @xmath80 where @xmath17 is the ricci scalar , @xmath81 @xcite and @xmath82 is the metric tensor . the signature of @xmath82 is chosen as @xmath83 . for the friedmann - lemaitre - robertson - walker ( flrw ) metric without the curvature
the ricci scalar is expressed by @xmath84 .
the einstein equations are consequence of the variation of the langragian @xmath85 .
the einstein equations for dust and a minimal coupling scalar field are the following @xmath86 and @xmath87 we assume that @xmath88 and an interaction @xmath89 between @xmath90 and @xmath64 and we assume the state equation for @xmath90 as @xmath48 and for @xmath64 as @xmath91 .
now we choice a new parametrization of @xmath64 as @xmath92 , where @xmath93 .
then ( [ eqf ] ) and ( [ eqd ] ) have the following form @xmath94 and @xmath95 the conservation equation is in the form @xmath96 because there is an interaction @xmath89 between @xmath90 and @xmath64 then the conservation equation gives two equations @xmath97 and @xmath98 the first integral of ( [ conphi ] ) is @xmath99 .
the potential @xmath3 can be of any form .
so if we want to find an exact solution for @xmath32 we should first assume the form of the potential @xmath3 .
the existence of dark matter in the universe is motivated by modern astrophysical observations as well as cosmological observations . from observations of rotation curves of spiral galaxies , masses of infracluster gas , gravitational lensing of clusters of galaxies to cosmological observations of the cosmic microwave background anisotropy and large scale structures we obtain strong evidences of dark matter .
because models of nucleosynthesis of the early universe are strongly restricted the fraction of baryons , we conclude that the nature of dark matter can not be baryonic matter .
on the other hand we imagine that particles of dark matter form a part of standard model ( sm ) of particles physics .
there are many candidates for particles of dark matter e.g. wimps .
lately sterile neutrinos have been also postulated in this context @xcite .
the interesting approach is a search of photon emission from the decay or the annihilation of dark matter particles through the astrophysical observations of x - ray regions @xcite .
for example the radiatively decaying dark matter particles as sterile neutrinos have been searched using x - ray observations @xcite .
let us consider the @xmath0cdm model which describes a homogeneous and isotropic universe which consists of baryonic and dark matter and dark energy .
let us assume an interaction in the dark sectors .
then the conservation equations have the following form @xmath100 where @xmath101 is baryonic matter density , @xmath29 is dark matter density and @xmath64 is dark energy density @xcite . @xmath102 describes the interaction in the dark sector .
let @xmath103 then ( [ con1 ] ) and ( [ con2 ] ) give @xmath104 for model with @xmath4 the conservation equation has the form @xmath105 .
so this model can be interpreted as the special case of model with the interacting in the dark sectors . in this model @xmath106 .
equation ( [ con4 ] ) for @xmath89 can be rewritten as @xmath107 or @xmath108 the solution of equation ( [ con5 ] ) is @xmath109 where @xmath110 , where @xmath111 .
@xmath102 can be written as @xmath112 .
the evolution of @xmath113 and @xmath114 is presented in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , and [ fig:2 ] .
one can observe that @xmath115 and @xmath31 is constant since the initial singularity to the present epoch . .
the top thick line represents the evolution of @xmath113 for @xmath116 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
the bottom thick line represents the evolution of @xmath113 for @xmath119 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
the medium line represents the best fit ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
the gray region is the @xmath75 uncertainties . ] .
the top thick line represents the evolution of @xmath114 for @xmath116 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath117 and @xmath122 .
the bottom thick line represents the evolution of @xmath114 for @xmath119 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath120 and @xmath123 .
the medium line represents the best fit ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
the gray region is the @xmath75 uncertainties .
note that if @xmath124 for @xmath125 , i.e. whole dark matter decays then we have the @xmath0cdm model with baryonic matter . ]
if @xmath31 is a slowly changing function than @xmath126 and ( [ solrho ] ) has the following form @xmath127 in this case @xmath128 .
the early time approximation for @xmath31 is @xmath129 if @xmath130 we can easily find that @xmath131 let us note that during the regime @xmath132 both the time dependent parametrization and quadratic parametrization @xmath133 coincide in alcaniz and lima approach @xcite .
we can rewrite @xmath29 as @xmath134 where @xmath135 . for the present epoch we can approximate @xmath30 as @xmath136 .
so in the present epoch @xmath137 . in the consequence , the friedmann equation can be written as @xmath138 .
the evolution of @xmath139 is presented in fig . [ fig:3 ] .
one can observe that @xmath30 is constant since the initial singularity to the present epoch . .
the top thick line represents the evolution of @xmath139 for @xmath116 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath117 and @xmath122 .
the bottom thick line represents the evolution of @xmath139 for @xmath119 km/(s mpc ) , @xmath120 and @xmath123 .
the medium line represents the best fit ( see table [ table:1 ] ) .
the gray region is the @xmath75 uncertainties . ]
following amendola and others @xcite the mass of dark particles can be parametrized by the scale factor as @xmath140 where @xmath141 is representing of mass of dark matter , @xmath142 .
we consider the mass @xmath143 as an effective mass of particles in a comoving volume . in amendola et al .
@xcite the parameter @xmath144 is assumed as a constant .
this simplifying assumption has physical justification as it will be demonstrated in the further dynamical analysis of the model with decaying dark matter .
equation ( [ m ] ) can be simply obtained from ( [ rhodm ] ) because @xmath145 and @xmath146 . then @xmath147 . for illustration the rate of dark matter decaying process it would be useful to define the parameter @xmath148
@xmath149 if @xmath150 then equation ( [ m ] ) has the equivalent form @xmath151 , where @xmath152 .
let consider the number of dark matter particles @xmath153 where @xmath21 is the cosmological time .
than a half of the number of these particle @xmath154 is reached at the moment of time @xmath155 . for small value of @xmath156
the parameter @xmath148 can be approximated by @xmath157 .
for example if we put @xmath158 than the number of dark matter particles decreases to half after about @xmath159 starting at the time @xmath160 . .
the bottom left line represents @xmath38 for the first fraction of particles and the top left line represents @xmath38 for the second fraction of particles before switching .
the medium left line represents effective @xmath38 . after switching the bottom line represents @xmath38 of the first fraction which is equal zero . ] in fig .
[ fig:6 ] one can see that a quotient @xmath161 decreases with the scale factor and remains of the same order for today ( @xmath162 ) .
therefore the coincidence problem is solved .
if the dark matter sector consists of two fractions of particles than @xmath163 , where @xmath164 is a value of @xmath38 for the first fraction of particles and @xmath164 is value of @xmath38 for the second fraction of particles .
if particles of the first fraction is decayed than @xmath38 for this fraction should be equal zero and the value of @xmath165 is switched .
than @xmath166 .
this phenomenon is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig:7 ] .
in this section , we present a statistical analysis of the model parameters such as @xmath12 , @xmath167 and @xmath9 .
we are using the snia , bao , cmb observations , measurements of @xmath8 for galaxies and the alcock - paczyski test .
we use the data from union 2.1 which is the sample of 580 supernovae @xcite .
the likelihood function for snia is @xmath168,\ ] ] where @xmath169 , @xmath170 , @xmath171 and @xmath172 is a covariance matrix for snia .
the distance modulus is @xmath173 ( where @xmath174 is the apparent magnitude and @xmath175 is the absolute magnitude of snia ) and @xmath176 ( where the luminosity distance is @xmath177 ) .
we use sloan digital sky survey release 7 ( sdss dr7 ) dataset at @xmath178 @xcite , 6df galaxy redshift survey measurements at redshift @xmath179 @xcite , the boss dr 9 measurements at @xmath180 @xcite , and wigglez measurements at redshift @xmath181 @xcite .
the likelihood function is given by @xmath182 where @xmath183 is the sound horizon at the drag epoch @xcite .
the likelihood function for the planck observations of cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) radiation @xcite , lensing from the planck and low-@xmath184 polarization from the wmap ( wp ) has the form @xmath185 where @xmath172 is the covariance matrix with the errors , @xmath186 is a vector of the acoustic scale @xmath187 , the shift parameter @xmath17 and @xmath188 where @xmath189 where @xmath190 is the redshift of the photon - decoupling surface . the likelihood function for the alcock - paczynski test @xcite has the following form @xmath191 where @xmath192 and @xmath193 are observational data @xcite .
we are using some data of @xmath8 of different galaxies from @xcite and the likelihood function is @xmath194 we consider two cases . in the first case we estimate our model for low @xmath7 astronomical observations such as snia , bao , @xmath8 and the alcock - paczynski test . the final likelihood function for the first case
is @xmath195 the second case is for high @xmath7 and than we use planck observations , lensing and wp .
the value of @xmath12 is chosen as @xmath196 km/(s mpc ) .
we use our own code cosmodarkbox in estimation of the model parameters .
the code uses the metropolis - hastings algorithm @xcite and the dynamical system to obtain the likelihood function @xcite .
the results of statistical analysis for the first case are represented in table [ table:1 ] .
figures [ fig:8 ] , [ fig:9 ] and [ fig:10 ] where it is shown the likelihood function with @xmath197 and @xmath198 confidence level projection on the ( @xmath167 , @xmath9 ) plane and the ( @xmath12 , @xmath9 ) plane , respectively . for the second case the results of statistical analysis is shown in table [ table:2 ] . for the high @xmath7 data we obtain that @xmath9 is negative , which means that dark matter particles decay .
, @xmath199 ) with the marked @xmath197 and @xmath198 confidence levels for snia+bao+@xmath8+ap test .
the value of hubble constant is estimated from the data as the best fit of value @xmath200 and then the diagram of likelihood function is obtained for this value . ] , @xmath199 ) with the marked @xmath197 and @xmath198 confidence levels for snia+bao+@xmath8+ap test .
the value of the hubble constant is estimated from the data as the best fit of value @xmath201 km/(s mpc ) and then the diagram of likelihood function is obtained for this value . ] , @xmath199 ) with the marked @xmath197 and @xmath198 confidence levels for planck+lensing+wp . the value of the hubble constant is equal 65.62 km/(s mpc ) and then the diagram of likelihood function is obtained for this value . ]
.the best fit and errors for the estimated model for snia+bao+@xmath8+ap test with @xmath12 from the interval ( 65.0 , 71.0 ) , @xmath167 from the interval @xmath202 and @xmath199 from the interval @xmath203 .
@xmath204 is assumed as 0.048468 .
the value of @xmath205 for the best fit is equal 108.740 and the value of aic is equal 114.74 . in comparison with this model ,
the @xmath205 of the best fit of @xmath0cdm is equal 108.761 and aic is equal 112.761 . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] we can use some information criteria in scientific practice to choose the best model .
one of information criteria is the akaike information criterion ( aic ) , which is given by @xmath206 where @xmath207 is the maximum of the likelihood function and @xmath208 is the number of model parameters .
model which is the best approximation to the truth from the set under consideration has the smallest value of the aic quantity .
it is convenient to evaluate the differences between the aic quantities computed for the rest of models from our set and the aic for the best one .
those differences @xmath209 @xmath210 are easy to interpret and allow a quick `` strength of evidence '' for the model considered with respect to the best one .
the main goal of the paper was to investigate in details the dynamic of the model with matter and the running cosmological constant term with respect to the cosmological time .
it was assumed that baryonic matter satisfies the equation of the state for dust ( i.e. is nonrelativistic ) .
we were interested how the running @xmath1 influences on the scaling relation for energy density @xmath29 .
we have found the deviation from standard scaling @xmath211 for this relation .
we explained the source of this deviation showing that @xmath29 decreases more rapidly or slowly like @xmath212 due to the energy transfer from dark matter to dark energy sector or in the opposite direction .
the direction of the energy transfer crucially depends on the sign of @xmath38 constant in the model under consideration .
the value of @xmath38 can be theoretically calculated in the quantum formalism developed by urbanowski and raczynska @xcite . in their paper
it was proposed a quantum mechanical effect which can be responsible for instability of charge particles which emit x or @xmath213 rays .
the sign of @xmath38 constant is obtained from the analysis of the decay law of unstable states of particles or its survival probability . in these calculations ,
the crucial role plays the breit - wigner distribution function which gives rise to a negative sign of the @xmath38 constant . for typical particles
, decaying processes are describing through this distribution function . from the cosmological point of view
it is interesting that fluctuations of energy of instantaneous states of particles of dark matter can be manifested as fluctuations of the velocity of particles @xcite . in order
this effect gives rise to the emission of the electromagnetic radiation from radio up to ultra - high frequencies . in the context of astrophysics important stays information can be obtained from the observation of x rays or @xmath213 rays . from x ray ccd instruments ,
dark matter is searched in kev energy for looking for the non - baryonic x ray signature @xcite .
on the other hand the @xmath38 constant is a dimensionless model parameter which value can be estimated from some astronomical data .
our estimations favor the negative @xmath38 constant for high @xmath7 , i.e. it is favored the decaying vacuum of dark matter particles and the radiative nature of the energy transfer to dark energy sector .
sterile neutrinos give rise to a negative sign of the @xmath38 constant because they can be described in terms of the breit - wigner distribution function @xcite .
the negative sign of the @xmath38 constant offers a new insight into the cosmological constant problem because the running @xmath0 is the growing function of the cosmological time with asymptotic @xmath214 at @xmath215 .
therefore this problem disappears in a natural way . in our model
the parameter @xmath38 can not change a sign . on
the other hand estimations showed the positive @xmath38 for low redshift data and the negative one for high redshift data .
one way of explanation of this discrepancy is to treat the parameter @xmath38 as some effective parameter describing two - component dark matter . for one component
the contribution to @xmath38 is negative and for second one is positive . during the cosmic evolution
the former decays entirely and the latter survives and there is the switch of the effective @xmath38 sign . in our paper
we have also found the physical background of the approach developed by alcaniz and lima @xcite in which the relation @xmath216 , where @xmath217 , plays an important role .
our observational analysis of the evolution this parameter during the cosmic evolution indicates that such an ansatz has a strongly physical justification .
we showed using astronomical data that the model with decaying dark matter is favored on a 2@xmath218 level over the @xmath0cdm standard cosmological model .
the good news are also coming from our consideration . in interacting cosmology the interacting term which is postulated in different physical forms
is interpreted as a kind of nongravitional interactions in the dark sector .
we suggest that this interaction has the radiation nature and can be rather interpreted following the urbanowski and raczynska idea as a possible emission of cosmic x and @xmath213 rays by unstable particles @xcite .
it is still an open discussion about the nature of dark matter : cold or warm dark matter @xcite .
our results showed that in the model of dark matter decay dark matter particle being lighter than cdm particles .
therefore particles of warm dark matter remain relativistic longer during the cosmic evolution at the early universe . in the investigating dynamics of the interacting cosmology
the corresponding dynamical systems , which are determining the evolutional paths , are not closed until one specify the form of the interacting term @xmath102 .
usually this form is postulated as a specific function of the hubble parameter , energy density of matter or scalar field or their time derivatives @xcite .
the case study of our model with decaying dark matter favor the choice of the interacting term in the form @xmath219 .
zilioti et al .
has recently demonstrated that the coincidence problem can be naturally solved in a large class of running @xmath6 vacuum cosmologies @xcite .
the case study of our model fully confirms this idea .
49ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1142/s0217732396000023 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0264 - 9381/22/2/003 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.72.063516 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2013.12.027 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.88.083530 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.91.123538 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.91.123539 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2014.02.043 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.86.087502 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev.nucl.010909.083654 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.121302 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1086/323867 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.113.251301 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0927 - 6505(01)00115 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.75.083506 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physletb.2005.08.049 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0004 - 637x/746/1/85 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2009.15812.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2011.19250.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2012.22066.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2012.21473.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1086/305424 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201321591 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1038/281358a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0004 - 637x/781/2/96 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0004 - 637x/761/2/187 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2011.19606.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2007.12289.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1038/nature09577 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2005.09212.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1111/j.1365 - 2966.2004.07348.x [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1051/0004 - 6361/201220142 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0004 - 6256/139/6/2360 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.71.123001 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2010/02/008 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1475 - 7516/2012/08/006 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1699114 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1093/biomet/57.1.97 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1086/177989 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.62.043511 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0370 - 2693(01)01174 - 1 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.81.043525 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.73.063516 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , | we investigate the dynamics of the generalized @xmath0cdm model , which the @xmath0 term is running with the cosmological time .
the @xmath1 term emerges from the covariant theory of the scalar field @xmath2 with the self - interacting potential @xmath3 . on the example of the model @xmath4 we show the existence of a mechanism of the modification of the scaling law for energy density of dark matter : @xmath5 .
we discuss the evolution of @xmath1 term and pointed out that during the cosmic evolution there is a long phase in which this term is approximately constant .
this effect justifies alcaniz and lima s approach to @xmath6 cosmologies .
we also present the statistical analysis of both the @xmath1cdm model with dark energy and decaying dark matter and the @xmath0cdm standard cosmological model .
we divide the observational data into two groups : low @xmath7 data ( snia , bao , @xmath8 and ap test ) and high @xmath7 data ( planck , wp and lensing ) .
while for the former we find the best fit value of the parameter @xmath9 is positive ( @xmath10 , energy transfer is from the dark energy to dark matter sector ) , for the latter we find that @xmath9 is @xmath11 which is an evidence that the energy transfer is from decaying dark matter .
this disagreement correlates with estimated values of @xmath12 ( @xmath13 km/(s mpc ) and @xmath14 km/(s mpc ) respectively ) .
the decaying dark matter causes to lowering a mass of dark matter particles which are lighter than cdm particles and remain relativistic .
the rate of the process of decaying matter is estimated .
we show that in the models of decaying dark matter , the cosmological constant problem disappears naturally .
the model with decaying dark matter possesses one parameter more but in light of the aic it is better than the @xmath0cdm standard cosmological model . |
understanding how information is stored in a quantum system and how it can be extracted is one of the main goals of quantum information science .
because quantum mechanics is often counter - intuitive , this goal is as challenging as it is promising .
historically , the existence of quantum superpositions and the interference they imply were the first aspects of quantum mechanics that confronted our intuition . when we considered measurements of an individual spin @xmath0 in the vertical direction , the states @xmath1 and @xmath2 were easy to interpret classically
however , superposition of states like @xmath3 were puzzling and the statistical interpretation on a lot of copies was the only resort . nowadays , this superposition is seen just as classical as the _ up _ and _ down _ states .
we just rename it @xmath4 and consider that it only makes sense to measure it in the horizontal @xmath5 direction .
performing the measurement in the vertical direction is possible , but it will not give any information at all .
it will disturb the system so much that it will be brought in as one of the vertical " states with perfect probability .
then quantum entanglement came into the play @xcite and challenged our intuition even more .
the essence of entanglement is well summarized by considering the so - called _
bipartite entanglement_. such kinds of entanglement states that the information about a quantum system is not only encoded exclusively in its parts , but it is also encoded in the correlations between the parts .
remarkably , when a bipartite quantum system is maximally entangled , the information appears to be fully encoded in these correlations and no longer in the system s constituents . because the different parts of a whole system are located at different spatial positions , bipartite entanglement contradicts local realism .
bipartite entanglement is well understood nowadays .
next comes the question of entanglement when the number of parties is bigger than two , the so called _ multipartite entanglement _ . without any surprises ,
multipartite entanglement is much richer than bipartite entanglement , and thus more difficult to understand @xcite .
it leads to stronger contradictions with local realism than bipartite entanglement @xcite and several inequivalent classes of entangled states exist as soon as three qubits are considered @xcite .
multipartite entanglement is also central in several applications like one - way quantum computing @xcite .
its dynamics has revealed a surprisingly large variety of flavors when exposed to a dissipative environment @xcite .
recently , a lot of work has focused on particular kinds of qubit states , totally invariant under permutation of their qubits .
this kind of state is really interesting because they are analytically tractable and easy to work with numerically .
they exhibit high entanglement content , especially in terms of their geometric entanglement @xcite , non - local behavior @xcite , convenient representation @xcite and involvement in experimental setups @xcite .
however , in some aspects , the power of the permutational symmetry is also a weakness .
it is a strongly constraining symmetry that a lot of interesting quantum states do not satisfy for more than three qubits , particularly the states that are known for their high entanglement content relative to different kinds of measures @xcite . in @xcite
, it is also demonstrated that a symmetric state of qubits can not have its reduced states all maximally mixed , except in the case where those reduced states are the smallest possible , i.e. , with only one qubit each . for symmetric states , reduced states formed with a pair , triplet , and etc .
will never be all maximally mixed . that is surprising because in a given hilbert space it is always possible to find states with all their reductions that keep about 18% of the total number of qubits maximally mixed @xcite . in the context of quantum error correction , such states are therefore robust to the loss of about 18% of their qubits because they do not encode information . for these reasons , it is then quite natural to explore beyond the perfect permutational symmetry by still capturing some of its aspects that make it so convenient .
to get some intuition on how to do such a thing , let us consider two qubits seen as two spins @xmath0 .
it is well known that arbitrary states of such a system are linear combinations of the symmetric components ( formed with the three triplets ) and an antisymmetric component ( formed with the singlet ) . for more than two qubits ,
the situation becomes richer because a given qubit can have a symmetric relationship with some qubits and an antisymmetric relationship with some others .
a 3-qubit state will decompose in different parts : one part will be indeed a totally symmetric part completely invariant by any permutation of its quits . then
, another part will have symmetry between qubits 1 and 2 but antisymmetry between 1 and 3 and 2 and 3 .
in the same vein , an other part will have antisymmetry between 1 and 2 but symmetry between 1 and 3 and 2 and 3 .
obviously , there will be four other parts corresponding to the four other ways to fix the symmetries between the qubits .
note that , however , it will not contain a completely antisymmetric part because it is impossible to antisymmetrize more than two qubits .
the goal of this paper is to study quantum states that have these kinds of intermediate symmetries that lie in between the perfect symmetric and antisymmetric ones .
those symmetries will be described thanks to the formalism of the representations of the symmetric group .
the layout of this paper is the following : sec .
ii introduces important notions about the symmetric group and its representations and rigorously defines the intermediate symmetries . in sec .
iii , a measure of the amount of intermediate symmetries contained in a quantum state is introduced .
then , all the moments and the probability distribution of that measure are calculated analytically for random states of qubits and confronted with numerical simulation .
this statistical analysis shows that the maximal antisymmetry is a generic feature of random quantum states . in sec .
iv , some relationships between quantum states with intermediate symmetries and entanglement are considered .
a natural extension of the majorana representation @xcite is introduced and some numerical calculations are presented . at the end of the section ,
a theorem is derived showing that the most antisymmetric states are a special kind of maximally entangled states in the sense that no information is contained in their individual qubits . in other words ,
those states are quantum error correcting codes robust against any 1-qubit errors .
finally , some conclusions are drawn in sec . v.
in this part , we will introduce the mathematical background that is going to be used throughout this article .
the minimum amount of required concepts and notations will be described briefly and relevant formulas will be written without demonstration .
a more rigorous approach with more details can be found in many reference books concerning the symmetric group and its representations @xcite .
the symmetric group of @xmath6 elements , noted @xmath7 , is the set of permutations of those elements where the composition of permutations plays the role of the group multiplication .
there are @xmath8 such permutations .
some of these permutations are called _ cycles _ because they exchange the elements of a subset in a circular fashion .
the number of elements that are permuted in a given cycle is called the _ length _ of the cycle . for instance , the permutation that transforms the string @xmath9 to the string @xmath10 can be seen as a cycle on the subset @xmath11 in the sense that 1 goes to position 2 , 2 goes to position 3 and 3 goes to position 1 . at the same time ,
4 and 5 keep their position .
therefore , it is a cycle of length 3 or similarly a 3-cycle .
cycles can be written in _ cycle notation _ where the elements are written in between parentheses such that the first element in the parentheses goes to the position of the second , the second goes to the position of the third one , and so on until the last element takes the position of the first one . like this
, the previous permutation is written @xmath12 .
what makes cycles interesting is that any permutation can be constructed as a combination of disjoint cycles .
the permutation that transforms the string @xmath9 to the string @xmath13 can be seen as two cycles , one on the subset @xmath11 and one on the subset @xmath14 , written @xmath15 .
note that , in the cycle notation , elements that do not change position , i.e. , cycles of size one , are omitted .
that is why the permutation considered above that could be written @xmath16 is simply written to @xmath12 .
two permutations are said to have the same cycle structure if they are constructed thanks to cycles with identical lengths .
for instance , the permutation @xmath17 and @xmath18 are a combination of a 3-cycle and a 2-cycle .
there is an interesting fact concerning the symmetric group .
its irreducible representations are in direct correspondence with its conjugacy classes .
moreover , it is possible to show that permutations that belong to the same conjugacy class have the same cycle structure .
therefore , each irreducible representation can be labeled by a quantity which reminds the cycle structure , that is to say a partition @xmath19 of the number of elements @xmath6 , noted @xmath20 .
a partition @xmath19 can be written thanks to a _
partition vector _ , which is a vector with monotonic decreasing entries that sums to @xmath6 , @xmath21 another way to represent a partition @xmath19 can be done thanks to a _ young diagram _ , a diagram that is constructed by gluing together rows of @xmath22 square boxes from top to bottom , for @xmath23 in @xmath24 $ ] . as an example for @xmath25 , all the partition vectors and their corresponding young diagrams
are given by @xmath26 partitions are listed here in the _ inverse lexicographical order _ , which means that @xmath27 , if and only if the first non - zero difference @xmath28 for @xmath23 in @xmath24 $ ] .
the position of a partition with respect to this ordering will be used in some formulas by simply writing it @xmath19 , the context preventing any risk for confusion . like this , @xmath29 and @xmath30 . from partitions and young diagrams ,
several relevant quantities need to be defined . the multiplicity of @xmath23 of a partition @xmath19 shorthanded with an exponent index as @xmath31 counts the number of times the value @xmath23 appears in a partition .
for instance , if @xmath32 , then @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
the _ hooks _ of a box in a given young diagram is defined as the set of boxes that are below and to the right of the box , including the considered box itself .
the _ hook - length _ of a given box is simply the total number of boxes in its hook . as an example , here are all the young diagrams for @xmath25 with the values of the hook - length of each box : @xmath35 note that we will denote partitions relative to the irreducible representations of the symmetric group with greek indices starting at the letter @xmath19 .
greek indices starting at the letter @xmath36 will be used to represent a given conjugacy class . by extension , any permutations that belong to the same conjugacy class will also be written @xmath36 .
it is then useful to evaluate the number of permutation in the class @xmath36 as @xmath37 the character of the permutation @xmath38 in the representation @xmath19 noted @xmath39 is a number defined as the trace of the matrix of the permutation @xmath38 in the representation @xmath19 .
it forms a _ class function _ in the sense that it has the same value for all the permutations that belong to the same conjugacy class .
for that reason , it is common to only consider the values of the character written @xmath40 associated with the conjugacy class @xmath36 and arrange them together in the matrix with element @xmath41 , called the _
character table_. in the appendix , the so - called frobenius formula is presented , which allows us to calculate all those characters .
characters satisfy the two following orthogonality relations : @xmath42 the central concept of this article is called the schur - weyl duality .
it states that the finite dimension hilbert space of @xmath6 qudits @xmath43 decomposes as a direct sum of orthogonal subspaces @xmath44 , @xmath45 each @xmath44 is constructed as the tensor product of the irreducible representation of the special unitary group su@xmath46 and the irreducible representation of the symmetric group @xmath7 , both labeled by the partition @xmath19 .
the dimension @xmath47 of the irreducible representations of su@xmath46 happens to be inversely proportional to the product of all the hook - lengths of @xmath19 noted @xmath48 , @xmath49 the dimension @xmath50 of the irreducible representation of the symmetric group @xmath7 can be obtained thanks to the following formula applied to the partition vector @xmath19 : @xmath51 the dimension @xmath52 of each @xmath44 is therefore given by the product @xmath53 and it clearly satisfies @xmath54 .
to get some intuition about the structure of the subspaces @xmath55 , it is necessary to understand how the states they contain are constructed .
basically , the states of a possible basis for @xmath55 are built by symmetrizing and antisymmetrizing the states of the computational basis following the pattern given by the young diagram @xmath19 : each row will correspond to a symmetrization and each column will correspond to an antisymmetrization . to visualize the states that spanned @xmath55 ,
it is helpful to take each state of the computational basis state , write their arguments as binary indices in the young diagram , and rearrange the indices according to all the possible permutations . because of the antisymmetrization , the only states that are going to contribute are the ones leading to permutations of the filled young diagram with each column containing distinct values .
for instance , the subspace labeled by the diagram @xmath56 will not be spanned by the state @xmath57 .
clearly there is no permutation of @xmath58 that satisfies the column constrain .
on the other hand , the states @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 will span the subspace because they can be rearranged in the form @xmath62 compatible with the antisymmetrization . as a consequence of such a construction ,
it is impossible to antisymmetrize more than @xmath63 qudits . therefore , the subspaces labeled by the young tables that contains columns with more than @xmath63 boxes are zero dimensional .
to make such a construction more systematic , it is convenient to introduce the set of projectors @xmath64 on each @xmath44 .
they can be constructed as @xmath65 @xmath66 is the unitary operator that maps the permutation @xmath38 in the hilbert space .
its matrix elements are given by @xmath67 where @xmath23 and @xmath68 are @xmath6 entries @xmath63-valued vectors that index the computational basis . by definition , @xmath69 and from eq .
( [ chi1 ] ) , it is straightforward to verify that the projectors @xmath70 form a set of orthogonal projectors such that @xmath71 from each @xmath64 , an orthonormal basis for each @xmath44 can be built by applying a gram schmidt process to the set of linear independent columns @xmath72 . such a basis will be noted @xmath73 with vectors @xmath74 , for @xmath75 $ ] .
note that the basis @xmath76 of the complete symmetric situation are nothing other that the dicke states @xcite and the other basis vector can be seen as their generalization . to see how the previous formalism works , let us consider the 2-qubit case .
the parameters are thus @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
the integer @xmath79 can be decomposed as @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
therefore , the hilbert space decomposes in two subspaces as @xmath82 to construct the projectors @xmath83 and @xmath84 , we first need to express all the relevant quantities concerning @xmath85 .
this group contains only two elements : the identity element written @xmath86 and the transposition @xmath87 .
the corresponding unitary operators can be calculated from eq .
( [ p2u ] ) as @xmath88 simply being the identity operator and @xmath89 being nothing other than the swap operator . in matrix form @xmath90 the character table of @xmath85 can be calculated for instance thanks to the frobenius formula ( see the appendix ) @xmath91 and from the definition of the hook - length , one can calculate that @xmath92 .
equation ( [ proj ] ) gives the projectors @xmath93 taking the traces of the operators gives the dimension of the subspaces @xmath94 the three linear independent columns of @xmath83 and the only distinct columns of @xmath84 already form an orthogonal basis .
after normalization we obtain the basis @xmath95 such a decomposition is quite natural in the context of 1/2 spins . @xmath96 corresponds to the _ symmetric subspace _ and its basis states are the triplet states .
@xmath97 corresponds to the _ antisymmetric subspace _ that contains the unique singlet states .
it is interesting to notice that this subspace is maximally entangled because the singlet states is a bell state .
when the number of qudits is bigger , arbitrary partitions lead to _ intermediate symmetry_. those intermediate symmetries mean that a given qudit will be symmetrized with respect to a group of qubits and antisymmetrized with another group . to be more precise , a given intermediate symmetry
will be called @xmath98-symmetry and states that will belong to an individual subspace @xmath55 will be called @xmath98-symmetric states . studying those states in the context of quantum information
is the point of the next two parts .
from now on , we will only focus on the qubits case ( @xmath78 ) and write the size of the whole hilbert space @xmath99 .
it simplifies a lot of the formulas presented in the previous part .
one simplification comes from the fact that it is impossible to antisymmetrize more than two qubits . in terms of young diagrams , it means that only diagrams with no more than two rows will lead to non - zero dimensional subspaces .
starting from the diagram @xmath100 & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \ , \\
\end{ytableau } } } ^{n}$ ] , the most antisymmetric " partition will be represented by the diagram @xmath100 & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \ , \\ \ , & \ , & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \ , \\
\end{ytableau } } } ^{n/2}$ ] if @xmath6 is even , and @xmath100 & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \ , & \ , \\ \ , & \ , & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \none[\cdot ] & \ , \\ \end{ytableau } } } ^{n/2 + 1}$ ] if @xmath6 is odd . in total
there are @xmath101 such diagrams . to calculate the dimension @xmath102 , the hook - lengths of those diagrams need to be calculated . in terms of the index of the partition with respect to the inverse lexicographical order @xmath98
, the number of boxes in the first row is given by @xmath103 .
the number of boxes in the second row is given by @xmath104 .
the hook - lengths are thus all given according to the pattern @xmath105\\ \scriptstyle { \lambda}-1 & \scriptstyle { \lambda}-2 & \none[\hspace{-0.5cm}\dots]\\ \end{ytableau } \hspace{-0.5 cm } \begin{ytableau } \underset{+1}{\scriptstyle n - 2{\lambda}+ 3 } & \scriptstyle n - 2{\lambda}+ 2 & \none[\hspace{-0.5cm}\dots]\\ \scriptstyle 1 \\
\end{ytableau } \hspace{-0.5 cm } \begin{ytableau } \scriptstyle 2 & \scriptstyle 1 \\
\end{ytableau } .\nonumber \ytableausetup{boxsize=0.6em}\ ] ] the product of all those hook - lengths is @xmath106 and eq .
( [ dimsn ] ) that contains only one factor gives @xmath107 finally the dimensions of each @xmath55 is given by @xmath108 any quantum state can be seen as a linear combination of the states @xmath109 . in other words ,
any quantum state is a superposition of the different @xmath98 symmetries .
for instance , the separable state @xmath110 is the superposition of the two bell states @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
therefore , this state contains the same amount of symmetry and antisymmetry . to quantify this ,
the following quantity is defined : @xmath113 we will call this quantity the _ weight _ of @xmath98 symmetry .
it is just the square of the norm of the components in the subspaces @xmath55 .
the more a state is @xmath98 symmetric , the bigger the weight is . note that by definition @xmath114 . calculating this quantity for
arbitrary states would not give more insight .
that is why we will evaluate it for random states and consider related statistical quantities .
the first of this quantity will be the mean values @xmath115 , where @xmath116 stands for the average over the uniform measure @xmath117 on the units sphere @xmath118 in the whole hilbert space . from eq .
( [ w ] ) , we get @xmath119 where the indices @xmath23 and @xmath68 label computational basis states and @xmath120 are the matrix element of @xmath121 of in that basis . terms of the form @xmath122 can be calculated by different ways like the diagrammatic method described in @xcite .
product of component of quantum states averaged over @xmath117 @xmath123 are nonzero if and only if each @xmath23 index has a corresponding @xmath68 index with the same value . in other words , when the string @xmath124 is a permutation of the string @xmath125 , those strings are the binary form of the indices @xmath23 and @xmath68 , respectively .
it is important to notice that such permutation acts on the set of @xmath68 indices and have nothing to do with the previously considered permutations that act on the qubits .
after the indices condition is fulfilled , the average value from eq .
( [ average ] ) takes the simplified form @xmath126 its value is now dependent on the possible degeneracy of the indices @xmath23 . when those degeneracies are taken into account , eq .
( [ average2 ] ) takes the form @xmath127 with a value that does not depend on the indices @xmath23 , but only on the powers @xmath128 .
it will be written @xmath129 . in @xcite ,
a similar expression is considered for unitary matrices drawn uniformly with respect to the haar measure of the unitary group . however , a given column of such a matrix happens to be random states uniformly distributed over @xmath117 . by consequence , results that appears in @xcite for random unitary matrix can be directly used for random states giving @xmath130 for instance , @xmath122 will only be non - zero if @xmath131 , which then leads to the term @xmath132 it is then straightforward to continue the calculation of @xmath133 . from eq .
( [ wsuite ] ) we get @xmath134 therefore , for uniform states , the average weight of @xmath98-symmetry is just the ratio between the dimensions of the subspace and the whole hilbert space , as it could have been intuitively expected .
the second moment @xmath135 can also be calculated analytically as @xmath136 the sum decomposes into three non - zero parts .
first , the part where @xmath137 and @xmath138 but @xmath139 .
second , the part where @xmath140 and @xmath141 but @xmath139 . finally , the part where @xmath142 .
it reads @xmath143 from eq .
( [ f ] ) we have @xmath144 and then @xmath145 by induction , it is possible to show that the @xmath146th - moment @xmath147 writes @xmath148 where @xmath149 are the pochhammer symbols @xcite .
the demonstration is detailed in the appendix .
the fact that all the moments can be calculated is quite interesting .
it gives a hope in the possibility to calculate the distribution of probability of the weights @xmath150 itself .
in general , the collection of all the moments does not uniquely determine the distribution .
however , if the moments satisfy some particular properties , such a uniqueness relationship exists . in @xcite
, it is shown that if @xmath151 is finite , then the moments uniquely determine the probability distribution . from eq .
( [ wk ] ) we see that @xmath152 which is clearly finite . therefore , the moment @xmath153 uniquely characterizes the probability distribution @xmath150 and it is worth trying to calculate it analytically from them .
to do so , we need to introduce the characteristic function @xmath154 note that , for simplicity , the index @xmath98 is removed from the variable @xmath155 .
the characteristic function can be seen both as a series in the moments and as the inverse fourier transform of the probability distribution .
the strategy is the following : we first try to calculate the series , and then by taking its fourier transform , we obtain the probability distribution . knowing all the moments ( [ wk ] ) , the characteristic function written as a series @xmath156 happens to be the confluent hypergeometric function @xmath157 with parameter @xmath158 and @xmath159 .
the fourier transform of such a function can be found in @xcite and finally we found the simple expression @xmath160 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the normalization factor @xmath161 is the beta function defined for integer variables as @xmath162 .
the calculated probability distribution is thus a _ beta distribution_. fig .
[ fig1 ] compares this analytic distribution to the one calculated numerically by sampling @xmath163 random states .
it is also interesting to consider such a distribution asymptotically .
when the number of qubits goes to infinity , this distribution will be well approximated by a dirac distribution centered in the mean value @xmath133 .
that is why @xmath133 is the moment that captures the most of the distribution and also deserves to be considered in the asymptotic limit . from ( [ qubitdim ] ) and ( [ w ] ) , @xmath133
as a function of @xmath6 and @xmath98 reads @xmath164 in the asymptotic limit @xmath165 the binomial coefficient can be approximated by a gaussian function @xcite and then @xmath166 the quality of such an approximation can be observed in fig .
[ fig2 ] and the limit @xmath165 is reached rapidly as @xmath6 increases . especially on the figure corresponding to @xmath167 , the dashed curve represents 100 times the absolute value of the difference between the exact and the approximate value .
we see that even in the worst case , the error is less than @xmath168 of the exact value of @xmath133 .
we also notice that the profile of @xmath133 becomes more and more peaked around a given value of @xmath98 that we can note @xmath169 . by using the approximation eq .
( [ mu1approx ] ) , we can obtain the value of @xmath169 .
the first derivative of @xmath170 with respect to @xmath98 can be calculated and can be written in the form @xmath171 where @xmath172 is a function that never vanishes on the range of @xmath98 and @xmath173 solving such a cubic equation is straightforward on a computer even if the exact result is quite complicated to write as a function of @xmath6 .
when @xmath165 , the value of @xmath169 behaves like @xmath174 which means that it is really close to the biggest value of @xmath98 as @xmath6 increases .
all this statistical study shows is that in the asymptotic limit uniform random states are almost as antisymmetric as they could be , which is really close to the possible maximal value @xmath101 .
this result is similar to those studying the amount of entanglement in random quantum states @xcite .
recently , a lot of articles studied symmetric states , especially focusing on their multipartite entanglement and their non - locality @xcite . in our context , those states are the ones contained in the subspace @xmath175 .
they are really convenient to work with both analytically and numerically .
this is mainly due to the fact that the dimension of @xmath175 scales linearly with the number of qubits as it can be checked easily from eq .
( [ qubitdim ] ) . for qubits
, we found @xmath176 .
unfortunately , the power of such states is also their weakness .
the complete permutational symmetry is quite constraining and a lot of known maximal entangled states do not satisfy it .
another inconvenience of this class of states is that they are locally equivalent to states that are not contained in the symmetric subspace .
that is why considering the other subspace @xmath55 makes sense to study .
when dealing with symmetric states , it is common to use the majorana representation @xcite .
this representation has been used intensively in recent papers @xcite . with our notations , this representation simply consists of the association of a product state @xmath177 to a ( in general entangled ) state @xmath178 .
it is natural to extend the construction to the other @xmath98-subspaces . starting with a product state @xmath179
, we construct all the states of the form @xmath180 .
note that , in such constructions involving projections , normalization of the projected state is implicit .
as we have already noticed , the product state @xmath181 will lead to two bell states when projected in the symmetric and anti - symmetric subspaces . for three qubits
, the projection of the state @xmath182 in the symmetric subspace gives the @xmath183 state that maximizes the geometric entanglement @xcite .
the four qubits case is quite interesting .
let us consider the product state @xmath184 with @xmath185 , @xmath186 , and @xmath187 .
it is straightforward to check that the projection of this state on @xmath188 and @xmath189 gives , respectively , @xmath190 those two states are known to be the states that maximize different measures of entanglement in the whole hilbert space @xcite . note that , in @xcite , a state locally equivalent to @xmath191 is actually considered .
@xmath191 is also known to maximize the geometric entanglement in the symmetric subspace @xcite .
it is interesting to observe that there exists such a product state @xmath192 being the superposition of states with high entanglement content . for bigger sizes , it is not easy to pick relevant product states that lead to high entanglement projections .
investigating the extension of the majorana representation would deserved an entire study .
however , it is not the focus of this article . instead , a numerical approach to observe what is happening for bigger size will be considered in the next part . in this part , we will again to calculate numerically relevant entanglement measures over random ensembles of quantum states
. we have to keep in mind that such numerical calculations are limited because constructing projectors according to eq .
( [ proj ] ) involves a factorial number of operations .
such calculations can be performed on a laptop computer for a decent amount of times for up to eight qubits . as a measure of multipartite entanglement
, we will use the generalization of the meyer - wallach measure @xcite defined according to @xcite as @xmath193 where @xmath194 is the reduced density matrix of subsystem @xmath195 of size @xmath196 and where the sum is performed over all the subsystems of a given size @xmath197 . for any @xmath197 ,
this measure is zero for product states and maximal ( @xmath198 ) for perfect maximally multipartite entangled states , even if reaching this maximum is known to be impossible for @xmath199 @xcite .
.average and maximum value of @xmath200 , represented as the vectors @xmath201 and @xmath202 , are calculated using a sample of @xmath203 random states .
random states " indicates that the states are uniformly picked in the whole hilbert space .
each young diagram indicates that the states are uniformly picked in the subspace labeled by the corresponding diagram .
note that the left column is also filled with the analytical value for some states known as maximum of entanglement as @xmath204 , @xmath205 and @xmath206 @xcite .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] as a function of @xmath197 in the different @xmath98-subspaces represented in the inverse lexicographical order by the markers @xmath207 , @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 , respectively.,width=321 ] in table i , the average and maximum values of @xmath200 ( represented as a vector with @xmath211 components ) are listed for quantum states of different sizes . for each size
, we can compare those quantities for known maximally entangled states , random states picked uniformly in the whole hilbert space ( referred as random state " ) , and random states picked uniformly in the subspace @xmath55 ( referred by their corresponding young diagrams ) .
we notice that basically adding some antisymmetry to the states increase the multipartite entanglement on average and in maximum .
the completely symmetric states appear to be the states with the lowest entanglement .
we also notice that typical random states also contained a big amount of multipartite entanglement .
it is due to the fact that on average random states are essentially antisymmetric ( as @xmath6 goes to infinity ) as observed in the previous part .
note that , in @xcite , an expression for the average of @xmath200 for random states uniformly distributed over a given subspace is derived as a function of the projector in the subspace . in our context , such an average value for states picked in the subspaces @xmath55 is given by @xmath212\label{qmean}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath213 .
such an expression can be evaluated on a computer the only limitation being the calculation of the projectors @xmath121 . for six qubits ,
the calculation of those average values can be calculated and are represented on the fig .
as observed with the statistical calculation , the symmetric subspace contains _ on average _ less entanglement than the subspaces that are more anti - symmetric .
the more interesting fact concerns the states contained in the most antisymmetric subspace @xmath214 when @xmath6 is even .
for those states up to the numerical precision , @xmath215 seems to always reach its maximum .
it means that those states are such that their 1-qubit reduced states are all maximally mixed .
note that states following such a property are called _
1-uniform _ in @xcite or _
1-mm _ in @xcite .
it is an interesting fact because it is known that all entanglement monotones reach their maximum on the family of states that are 1-uniform @xcite . by definition ,
those states are also quantum error correcting code robust to any 1-qubit error .
it is possible to create the projector @xmath216 in about 7 hours on a laptop computer and to check that all states in @xmath217 also satisfy @xmath218 as observed in the most antisymmetric subspaces for @xmath219 and @xmath220 .
therefore , it is worth trying to demonstrate analytically that this fact is general for any even @xmath6 . in this part
, we will be interested in the connection between multipartite entanglement and antisymmetry of a quantum state .
it is illustrated by the following theorem : for an even number of qubits , all pure states contained in the most antisymmetric subspace are 1-uniform .
let us first write the most antisymmetric partition @xmath221 as @xmath222 . by definition the basis states @xmath223 of @xmath224 are linear combinations of computational states @xmath225 with @xmath23 having a binary form that contains as much 0 than 1 .
it is related to the fact that , in this situation , it always exists permutations that lead to the young diagram filling @xmath226 & \none[\cdots ] & \none[\ , ] & 0 \\ 1 & 1 & \none[\ , ] & \none[\cdots ] & \none[\ , ] & 1 \\ \end{ytableau } } $ ] that correspond to non zero - antisymmetrization . those states can be written in a compact form as @xmath227 where the bar on the indices indicates binary complement , i.e. , @xmath228 and @xmath229 and for some coefficients @xmath230 . with
the barred " notation the action of the pauli matrix are given by @xmath231 let us now consider the rotated " states @xmath232 , where @xmath233 indicates that a pauli-@xmath5 matrix is applied on the @xmath128th qubits . without lost of generality , by fixing @xmath234
the rotated states take the form @xmath235 it is a linear combination of computational states with a binary form that contains one extra 0 or 1 making the young diagram filling unbalanced . in other words
, @xmath232 is rotated in a subspace orthogonal to @xmath224 .
a similar argument can be applied to a rotation performs by a @xmath236-pauli matrix @xmath237 .
the argument is similar for the rotation performed by the @xmath238-pauli matrix @xmath237 excepted that in this case the rotated states read @xmath239 which is also orthogonal to all the state @xmath223 . as a consequence , all the scalar products
are always zero ( @xmath241 or @xmath242 ) implying that all average values @xmath243 vanish for any state @xmath244 .
finally , in @xcite , it is explained that an @xmath6-qubit state @xmath245 is 1-uniform if and only if it satisfies @xmath246 for all @xmath247 $ ] and @xmath248.$ ] it is interesting to notice that this result looks like the opposite of theorem 1 in @xcite that says that _ all pure states of qubits contained in the most symmetric subspace are as best 1-uniform_.
we investigated the @xmath98-symmetries of a system of qubits in the context of quantum information .
we proved that , on average , pure states of qubits picked at random with respect to the uniform measure on the unit sphere of the hilbert space are almost as much antisymmetric as they are allowed to be .
we then observed that multipartite entanglement , which is measured by the generalized meyer - wallach measure , tends to be larger in subspaces that are more antisymmetric than the complete symmetric one .
eventually , we proved that all states contained in the most antisymmetric subspace are relevant multipartite entangled states in the sense that their 1-qubit reduced states are all maximally mixed . following this present study ,
several research directions are possible .
for instance , it would be interesting to find a more efficient way to construct projector eq .
( [ proj ] ) and perform numerical calculations for bigger @xmath6 .
similarly , one could try to analytically calculate the average value of the measure @xmath200 according to eq .
( [ qmean ] ) .
one could also try to observe both analytically and numerically how the quantities @xmath249 evolve when a quantum state is transformed by local unitaries .
i would like to thank daniel braun and alicia hartgrove for having read carefully the manuscript and for their useful comments .
i would also like to thank laure benhamou and ghyslain protoy for their support .
the frobenius formula @xcite allows us to calculate @xmath40 , the character in the representation @xmath19 of each permutation that belongs to the conjugacy class @xmath36 . to do so , the following quantities need to be introduced : * the independent variables @xmath250 , @xmath251 , @xmath252 where @xmath146 is at least as large as the last non - zero entry in the partition @xmath19 . *
the power sums @xmath253 with @xmath254 . * the discriminant @xmath255 . * the indices @xmath256 . * the polynomial @xmath257 $ ] .
the @xmath146th moment @xmath153 of the distribution @xmath150 is given by @xmath260 our goal is to express @xmath153 as a function of @xmath261 .
to do so , we will explicitly perform one of the sums , the one on the index @xmath262 . note that this choice is arbitrary . in the same vein
, we will reduce the order of the mean value of the @xmath263 .
it is possible because those mean values do not depend on the indices @xmath23 . from the expression in eq .
( [ f ] ) , such a reduction gives @xmath264 to perform the sum on @xmath262 , it is judicious to split the symmetric group @xmath265 that acts on the indices @xmath23 in @xmath146 disjoined sets @xmath266 @xmath267.\ ] ] by definition @xmath268 and @xmath269 .
therefore , @xmath153 goes as @xmath270\big.\nonumber\\ & + & \big.\sum_{\pi \in s^{(k)}}\sum_{i_1 \cdots i_{k-1}}\langle|\psi_{i_1}|^2\cdots|\psi_{i_{k-1}}|^2\rangle ( p_{\lambda})_{i_1i_{\pi(1)}}\cdots[\sum_{i_k}(p_{\lambda})_{i_ki_k}]\big\}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition of the projectors @xmath121 , the sum over @xmath262 gives @xmath271 the reduction from the sum over @xmath262 also implies that each set @xmath266 becomes a group @xmath272 acting on the symbols @xmath273 to @xmath274 .
it can be seen by just considering the cycle structure of the elements contained in a set @xmath266 . by definition ,
those elements are built with cycles of the form @xmath275 multiplied by all the possible other cycles built with the remaining symbols .
after removing the symbol @xmath146 in the cycle because of the summation , the previous set becomes simply the combination of all cycles built from @xmath274 symbols i.e. the group @xmath272 .
then , realizing that the @xmath276 terms in the sum over @xmath68 are all equal , it follows @xmath277 we can then identify the expression of @xmath261 @xmath278 by induction , using eq .
( [ w ] ) @xmath279 , it proves the result of eq .
( [ wk ] ) @xmath280 | we investigate the intermediate permutational symmetries of a system of qubits , that lie in between the perfect symmetric and antisymmetric cases . we prove that , on average , pure states of qubits picked at random with respect to the uniform measure on the unit sphere of the hilbert space are almost as antisymmetric as they are allowed to be .
we then observe that multipartite entanglement , measured by the generalized meyer - wallach measure , tends to be larger in subspaces that are more antisymmetric than the complete symmetric one .
eventually , we prove that all states contained in the most antisymmetric subspace are relevant multipartite entangled states in the sense that their 1-qubit reduced states are all maximally mixed . |
after the lhc s run 1 and beginning of run 2 , we are now more confident that the observed @xmath10 gev scalar boson is the long sought higgs boson of the standard model ( sm ) @xcite . however , although its brilliant success in describing particle physics , still many pressing questions are awaiting convincing solutions that can not be answered within sm .
the hierarchy problem and the neutrinos oscillations are the most illustrative ones . in this context , many theoretical frameworks have been proposed and the most popular one is supersymmetry .
the search for supersymmetry at run i of lhc gave a negative result .
therefore the original motivation of susy to solve hierarchy problem by suppressing quadratic divergencies ( qd ) is questionnable . in this case , it is legitimate to propose other perspective to interpret and control the qd . it is known that one has to call upon new physics to deal with such problem . more specifically , the new degrees of freedom in a particular model conspire with those of the standard model to modify the veltman condition and to soften the divergencies @xcite . in this paper , we aim to investigate the naturalness problem in the context of type ii seesaw model , dubbed htm , with emphasis on its effect of the htm parameter space .
more precisely , we will study how to soften the divergencies and how to gain some insight on the allowed masses of the heavy scalars in the higgs sector .
a more recent work of kundu et al.@xcite has partially discussed this issue . however , unlike the analysis in @xcite , our study use the most general renormalisable higgs potential of htm @xcite and is essentially based on dimensional regularisation approach which complies with unitarity and lorentz invariance @xcite . more importantly , the phenomenological analysis takes into account the full set of theoretical constraints , including unitarity @xcite and the consistent conditions of boundedness from below @xcite .
this work is organised as follows . in section @xmath11
, we briefly review the main features of higgs triplet model and present the full set of constraints on the parameters of the higgs potential .
section @xmath12 is devoted to the derivation of the modified veltman condition ( mvc ) in htm .
the analysis and discussion of the results are performed in section @xmath13 , with emphasis on the effects of mvc on the heavy higgs bosons , particularly on charged higgs .
conclusion with summary of our results will be drawn in section @xmath14 .
type ii seesaw mechanism can be implemented in the standard model via a scalar field @xmath15 transforming as a triplet under the @xmath16 gauge group with hypercharge @xmath17 . in this case
the most general @xmath18 gauge invariant lagrangian of the htm scalar sector is given by @xcite : @xmath19 the covariant derivatives are defined by , @xmath20+ig ' \frac{y_\delta}{2 } b_\mu{\delta } \label{eq : covd2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath21 is the higgs doublet while ( @xmath22 , @xmath23 ) , and ( @xmath24 , @xmath25 ) represent the @xmath16 and @xmath26 gauge fields and couplings respectively .
@xmath27 , with @xmath28 ( @xmath29 ) are the pauli matrices .
the potential @xmath30 reads as , @xmath31 \nonumber\\ & & + \lambda_1(h^\dagger{h})tr(\delta^{\dagger}{\delta})+\lambda_2(tr\delta^{\dagger}{\delta})^2 + \lambda_3tr(\delta^{\dagger}{\delta})^2 + \lambda_4{h^\dagger\delta\delta^{\dagger}h } \label{eq : vpot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath32 denotes the trace over @xmath33 matrices .
the triplet @xmath15 and doublet higgs @xmath21 are represented by : @xmath34 with @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
+ after the spontaneous electroweak symmetry breaking , the higgs doublet and triplet fields acquire their vacuum expectation values @xmath37 and @xmath38 respectively , and seven physical higgs bosons appear , consisting of : two @xmath39 neutral scalars ( @xmath40 , @xmath1 ) , one neutral pseudo - scalar @xmath2 and a pair of simply and doubly charged higgs bosons @xmath3 and @xmath4 .. , @xmath41 and the charged sectors , dubbed @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 see @xcite ] the masse of these higgs bosons are given by @xcite , @xmath45}{4\upsilon_t}\label{eq : mhpm}\\ & & m_{a^0}^2 = \frac{\mu(\upsilon_d^2 + 4\upsilon_t^2)}{\sqrt{2}\upsilon_t}\label{eq : ma0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the coefficients @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the entries of the @xmath39 mass matrix defined by , @xmath48 in the remainder of this paper , we assume the light @xmath39
scalar @xmath40 as the observed higgs with mass about @xmath49 gev .
the htm higgs potential parameters are not free but have to obey several constraints originating from theoretical requirements and experimental data .
thus any phenomenological studies are only reliable in the allowed region of htm parameter space . + _ : _ + first , recall that the @xmath50 parameter in htm at the tree level is given by the formula , @xmath51 which indicates a deviation from unity .
consistency with the current limit on @xmath50 from precision measurements @xcite requires that the limit @xmath52 resulting in an upper limit on @xmath38 about @xmath53 gev .
+ _ : _ + many experimental mass limits have been found for the heavy higgs bosons . from the lep direct search results , the lower bounds on @xmath54 gev for models with more than one doublet in the case of the neutral scalars . as to the singly charged higgs mass we use the lep ii latest bounds , @xmath55 gev from direct search results , whereas the indirect limit is slightly higher @xmath56 gev @xcite .
furthermore , the present lower bound from lhc is @xmath5 @xmath57 gev , where the excluded mass ranges established by atlas @xcite and cms @xcite are taken into account . in the case of the doubly charged higgs masses ,
the most recent experimental upper limits reported by atlas and cms are respectively @xmath58 gev @xcite and @xmath59 gev @xcite .
these bounds originate from analysis assuming 100% branching ratio for @xmath60 decay .
however , note that one can find realistic scenarios where this decay channel is suppressed with respect to @xmath61 @xcite invalidating partially the lhc limits .
for example , in htm with moderate triplet vev , @xmath62 gev , the analysis of @xmath63 decay channel can easily overpasses the two - sign same lepton channel for @xmath6 where the limit decreases up to @xmath64 gev @xcite . + as to the theoretical constraints on the parameter space , we should take into account the perturbativity constraints on the @xmath65 as well as the stability of the electroweak vacuum that ensure that the potential is bounded from below ( bfb ) .
let us first recall all the constraints obtained in @xcite _ : _ @xmath66 _ : _
@xmath67 we stress here that all values presented in the plots and in our subsequent analysis ( section @xmath14 ) are consistent with all theoretical and experimental bounds described in this section .
the method to collect the quadratic divergencies in a framework of dimensional regularisation is due to veltman @xcite and needs a dimensional gymnastics since the space - time dimension to pick up the quadratic divergencies depends on the number of loops .
but the idea to use the quadratic divergencies to get physical insights is much older , and goes back to the pioneering work of stuckelberg in 1939 @xcite . in the context of a renormalisable theory ( which is our case ) , it is not clear that the deductions coming from such a concept are pertinent .
indeed it provides for relations between the masses or / and the couplings constants of the theory , which could give some credit to an underlying and hypothetical symmetry . from a more basic level
, one can imagine that the relations found by this method are indicative and could provide orders of magnitude , bounds or constraints and we will follow this line in this work . this is more or less the point of view of chakraborty - kundu @xcite where they apply the cancellation of quadratic divergencies to the htm , the standard model extended by a scalar triplet .
but we differ from this work in the way to pick up the quadratic divergencies .
they use the cut - off method to regularise the divergent integrals although we will use the veltman method that we will sketch later on .
both methods have advantages and back - draws that we will not discuss here , since they provide for similar relations .
we just mention that the cut - off method is intuitive but neither lorentz nor gauge invariant .
a contrario , the dimensional regularisation method is both lorentz and gauge invariant , although less intuitive .
we refer to previous works such as @xcite and references therein for more details and discussions . to check the veltman conditions one needs to calculate the quadratic divergencies which show up in the tadpoles of the two cp - even neutral higgs of our model , namely @xmath40 and @xmath1 .
since vacuum is supposed to be cp - even , the tadpole associated with the neutral pseudoscalar field @xmath2 vanishes .
also , it is noticeable that no qcd contribution appears at one loop level , hence only the electro - weak part of the htm model is concerned in this procedure . since there is no derivative couplings , it is easy to figure out how to calculate each diagram ( see the appendix for all relevant vertices required for such calculation ) . aside the coupling constant , we just need to consider the propagator of the field in the loop , where the contribution of each loop can be written in a simple form in terms of the passarino - veltman function @xmath68 @xcite . in a 4 dimensional space - time , @xmath69 , up to some pure numerical factor , where @xmath70 is the pole term .
in a 2 dimensional space - time , @xmath71 is no longer mass dimensioned and it is a pure u.v .
divergent number ; this property is fundamental because it guarantees a gauge invariant result . this pure number will be forgotten everywhere in this section since irrelevant in the equations , together with other common factors like the dimensional dependence of the coupling constants . for the propagator of a scalar particle in htm higgs sector , ( @xmath72 ) ,
we have @xmath73 leading to a @xmath71 contribution . for a vectorial particle ( @xmath74
, we have @xmath75 leading to a @xmath76 contribution , where @xmath77 and @xmath78 are the transverse and the longitudinal projectors and @xmath79 is the space - time dimension . for a true fermionic particle ( massive leptons and quarks )
, we have @xmath80 leading to a @xmath81 contribution . to get the final results , one just has to sum up all the possible diagrams , taking into account the @xmath82 for the fermionic loops ( including faddeev - popov ghosts ) , the symmetry factor @xmath83 of the diagram @xmath84 and possibly the color factor for the quarks that we forget for conciseness . as a matter of fact , for the higgs particle @xmath85 one gets : @xmath86 where the couplings @xmath87 , the symmetry factors @xmath83 and the propagator loops @xmath88 are given in the appendix .
this formula leads , in a 2 dimensional space time , to a quite large formula depending on many parameters of the model as well as the mixing angles .
similarly , for the other cp - even higgs particle @xmath1 , one only has to change @xmath89 into @xmath90 as indicated in the appendix where these coefficients are listed .
to summarise , the veltman condition implies that the quadratic divergencies of the two possible tadpoles @xmath91 and @xmath92 of the @xmath40 and @xmath1
cp - even neutral scalar fields vanish .
both results are not very tractable , so we do not write them . the linear combination of the fermionic coupling constants @xmath93 is zero ; further it turns out that the combination @xmath94 induces simplification and one ends up with the short and nice expression : @xmath95 where @xmath96 and @xmath97 is the square of the standard model vacuum expectation value ( @xmath98 gev ) .
of course , it is very tempting to calculate the orthogonal combination , @xmath99 , which also leads to a simple result , where the quarks contributions must be multiplied by the color factor : @xmath100 + here , we do comment both results .
the two linear combinations @xmath101 and @xmath102 reproduce the real neutral components of the triplet and the doublet of the htm , after their vev shifts .
so @xmath103 and @xmath104 represent the quadratic divergencies of the fields @xmath105 and @xmath106 , as can be shown from eq .
( 2.26 ) of @xcite .
hence , its is straightforward to understand that all mixing angles disappear in @xmath103 and @xmath104 .
the absence of the @xmath107 parameter in @xmath103 is obvious since @xmath107 is the coupling constant of the pure doublet quartic interaction . in the same way ,
the absences of @xmath108 and @xmath109 are also natural in @xmath104 since these two couplings only concern the triplet .
we are also faced up to two intriguing questions : why the fermionic part is missing in the first equation ?
why the @xmath110 parameter is missing in both equations ?
the answer to the first question , on one hand , we have already noticed that the cancellation originates from the combination @xmath111 , that is on the form of the trilinear couplings higgs - fermion - antifermion . on the other hand ,
the absence of fermionic part lies in the form of the yukawa coupling with the triplet @xmath15 , given by eq .
( 2.5 ) in @xcite ) .
indeed , a close look shows that the fermionic doublet @xmath112 is no longer associated with @xmath113 but with @xmath114 , that forbids any @xmath115 coupling , insuring the absence of fermionic contribution at one loop order .
about the second question , it is bizarre because @xmath110 is the strength of a trilinear coupling between doublets and triplet , so a priori able to give contribution , but the interaction is linear in the triplet and a _ doublet - triplet - triplet _ vertex is excluded , that explains the lack of @xmath110 in @xmath104 . as to @xmath103 ,
the solution is again in the form of the interaction where we have the doublet @xmath21 and the transposed doublet @xmath116 but not @xmath117 : before breaking of the symmetries and the vev shifts , a coupling such as @xmath118 is forbidden . then after breaking and shifting the fields , we end up with two vertices , @xmath119 and @xmath120 , with opposite values @xmath121 , where @xmath106 and @xmath122 are the real and imaginary parts of the shifted field @xmath123 .
this feature suffices to cancel these two contributions in a 2 dimensional space - time , when the loop does not depend on the propagator mass as explained before . in some sense ,
the quadratic divergencies record the physics before breaking and shifting , and this is probably not a pure one - loop effect .
+ finally , it is worth to notice that veltman condition in standard model @xcite is recovered when , we remove the couplings @xmath124 and @xmath125 in the doublet formula @xmath104 , so discarding any mixing between doublet and triplet .
in this section we will focus our analysis on the modified veltman condition ( mvc ) given in @xmath126 .
our aim is twofold : first we will show that one loop quadratic divergencies are softened and go to zero within htm space parameter .
the latter is consistent with theoretical constraints given in eqs .
( @xmath127 ) , namely unitarity , bfb as well as absence of tachyon in the potential ( inducing a constraint on @xmath110 parameter )
. it also complies with the observed higgs at @xmath10 gev and with lhc measurements for higgs decay to several channels ( @xmath128 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 ) @xcite .
here we only show results with the photon mode that has the best mass resolution .
the second aim of our analysis is to gain more insight on the masses of the heavy higgs bosons and the effect of naturalness on their allowed range of variations .
+ we plot in fig.[fig : fig1 ] , the scatter plot in the ( @xmath133 ) .
the figure shows the excluded regions of space parameter by unitarity ( red ) , by combined set of bfb and unitarity ( green ) .
if in addition , we impose consistency withe atlas and cms combined data within @xmath134 on the diphoton decay mode , ( with a signal strength @xmath135 @xcite ) , the blue area is also discarded . furthermore , when the veltman condition for the doublet and triplet field enters into the game , we see a drastic reduction of the space parameter to a relatively small allowed region marked in brown .
+ fig.[fig : fig2 ] illustrates the doubly charged higgs mass @xmath6 as a function of @xmath124 resulting from a scan over different values of @xmath125 and for @xmath136 .
we find the only relevant parameter region where all of the constraints are imposed , is the area marked in grey which encodes cancellation of quadratic divergencies .
this area is delineated by @xmath124 in the range[@xmath137 corresponding to @xmath138 varying from @xmath139 to @xmath8 gev . for these mass values , @xmath125 is limited to lie in a reduced interval between @xmath140 and @xmath141 .
+ the remarkable feature of effects of the modified veltman condition on the doubly charged higgs masse is clearly indicated in fig.[fig : fig3 ] showing the @xmath142 ratio ( signal strength ) as a function of the doubly charged higgs mass @xmath6 for different values of @xmath124 .
first we consider the case when when mvc are absent ( red plot ) .
we see that , small values of @xmath124 less than @xmath143 favour low @xmath6 varying between @xmath139 and @xmath144 gev , while for larger @xmath124 , its range of variation is significantly enlarged with an upper limit about @xmath145 gev . when mvc is turned on ( green plot ) , we show that the @xmath6 intervals get smaller and smaller for @xmath124 getting larger .
we also note that unlike the lower limit which is unaffected by mvc , the upper bound is very sensitive to mvc and experiment a drastic reduction to @xmath8 gev .
similar analysis is seen in fig.[fig : fig4 ] for the simply charged higgs mass . here
, the same behaviour is reproduced : the lower mass , @xmath146 gev , is almost insensitive to the constraints including mvc , while the upper limit shows a substantial reduction from @xmath147 gev to @xmath7 gev when the conditions mvc are considered .
these overall resulting ranges of @xmath5 and @xmath6 are compatible with the lhc exclusion limits on the charged higgs bosons ( @xmath148 ) .
we have studied the naturalness problem in the type ii seesaw model .
we have shown that the veltman condition is modified by virtue of the additional scalar charged states and that quadratic divergencies at one loop can be driven to zero within at the allowed parameter space of the model .
furthermore , when a set of constraints , including unitarity , consistent boundedness from below , is combined with requirement of compatibility with the diphoton higgs decay data of lhc for the observed higgs at @xmath10 gev , the resulting parameter region is severely constrained .
if in addition , the modified veltman condition is also imposed , the effects on the masses of heavy higgs bosons @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 are analysed .
the analysis has shown a drastic reduction of the mass spectrum of @xmath5 and @xmath6 with an upper bounds at @xmath7 and @xmath8 gev respectively .
these limits are still consistent with lhc measurements . besides
, we have found an almost mass degeneracy of cp odd higgs and heavy cp even higgs , with @xmath149 .
gev has been reported by atlas and cms with a local significance of @xmath150 and @xmath151 while the global significances are @xmath134 and @xmath152 respectively @xcite .
although several interpretations of this intriguing signal in terms of higgs - like resonances have been proposed , this excess could be just another statistical fluctuation which will be washed away with more data . ]
m. chabab acknowledges support from the grant @xmath153 . this work is supported in part by the moroccan ministry of higher education and scientific research under contract @xmath154 .
m. c. peyranere would like to thank gilbert moultaka for friendly and helpful discussions .
in this appendix , we give the couplings used to calculate the tadpoles of the two neutral cp - even higgs @xmath40 and @xmath1
. since we are interested in the one - loop contributions , only three - leg couplings are useful .
further , within this restricted class , we look for vertices such as @xmath155 or @xmath156 , where @xmath157 stands for any quantum field of our model : scalar and vectorial bosons , fermions , goldstone fields @xmath158 and faddeev - popov ghost fields @xmath159 . to be precise , we have used the well - known linear @xmath160 gauge where the gauge fixing lagrangians are @xmath161 for the neutral sector and @xmath162 for the charged sector .
+ we note @xmath163 ( @xmath164 ) the couplings to the higgs @xmath40 ( @xmath1 ) . since the field @xmath157 fixes the propagator , we also give the values @xmath88 ( @xmath165 ) of the loop due to the propagator of the @xmath157 particle which gain a factor @xmath11 in case of charged fields , and the symmetry factor @xmath83 .
@xmath166 @xmath167 @xmath168 @xmath169 @xmath170 @xmath171 @xmath172 @xmath173 @xmath174 @xmath175 @xmath176 @xmath177 | in this paper we consider a minimal extension to the standard model by a scalar triplet field with hypercharge @xmath0 .
this model relies on the seesaw mechanism which provides a consistent explication of neutrino mass generation .
we show from naturalness considerations that the veltman condition is modified by virtue of the additional scalar charged states and that quadratic divergencies at one loop can be driven to zero within the allowed space parameter of the model , the latter is severely constrained by unitarity , boundedness from below and is consistent with the di - photon higgs decay data of lhc .
furthermore , we analyse the naturalness condition effects to the masses of heavy higgs bosons @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 , providing a drastic reduction of the ranges of variation of @xmath5 and @xmath6 with an upper bounds at @xmath7 and @xmath8 gev respectively , while predicting an almost degeneracy for the other neutral higgs bosons @xmath1 , @xmath2 at about @xmath9 gev . |
although interstellar extinction has been discussed in many papers and quantitatively determined by dedicated missions ( iue , 2mass and others ) , there is a lack of proper handling in the field of eclipsing binaries .
the usually adopted approach is to calculate the amount of reddening from the observed object s coordinates and its inferred distance and to subtract it uniformly , regardless of phase , from photometric observations .
this paper shows why this approach may be inadequate , especially for objects where interstellar extinction and the color difference between both components are significant .
atmospheric extinction is a better - posed problem : similarly as interstellar extinction depends on @xmath4 , atmospheric extinction depends on air - mass , which is a measurable quantity , whereas @xmath4 has to be estimated .
to estimate the effect of reddening on eclipsing binaries , we built a synthetic binary star model , consisting of two main sequence g9
f5 v stars with @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , @xmath8 and 1 day orbital period .
the simulation logic is as follows : for the given phase , we calculate the effective spectrum of the binary by convolving doppler - shifted individual spectra of the visible surfaces of both components . to this intrinsic spectrum
we rigorously apply interstellar and atmospheric extinctions ( both as functions of wavelength ) .
we then convolve this reddened spectrum with instrumental response function ( composed of the filter transmittivity and detector response functions ) and integrate over the bandpass wavelength range to obtain the flux .
in contrast , we use the same intrinsic spectrum without rigorously applying the reddening . to simulate the subtraction of a reddening
_ constant _ from photometric observations , we simply divide the intrinsic spectrum by the flux that corresponds to this constant .
finally , we calculate the flux in the same manner as before and compare it to the flux obtained by applying rigorous reddening . for building synthetic light curves we use phoebe ( pra & zwitter , 2004 ; in preparation ) .
each light curve consists of 300 points uniformly distributed over the whole orbital phase range . to be able to evaluate the impact of reddening on photometric light curves exclusively ,
all second - order effects ( limb darkening , gravity brightening , reflection effect ) have been turned off .
color index on the g9 v
v ( 5500 k6500 k ) temperature interval , calculated by integrating the spectrum over both filter bandpasses.,title="fig:",width=226,height=113 ] color index on the g9 v
f5 v ( 5500 k6500 k ) temperature interval , calculated by integrating the spectrum over both filter bandpasses.,title="fig:",width=226,height=113 ] + we take kurucz s synthetic spectra ( @xmath9 ) from precalculated tables by munari et al . (
2004 ; in preparation ) .
the used @xmath10 response data ( filter @xmath11 detector ) are taken from adps @xcite , where we apply a cubic spline fit to obtain the instrumental response function . for interstellar extinction
, we use the empirical formula ( fig .
[ redlaw ] ) , where @xmath12 was assumed throughout this study .
interstellar dust catalog was used to obtain the maximum color excess @xmath13 values for different lines of sight .
for atmospheric extinction we use the equation triplet for rayleigh - ozone - aerosol extrinction sources given by and summarized by .
the observatory altitude @xmath14 km and the zenith air - mass are assumed throughout the study . to rigorously deredden the observations for the given @xmath15 and @xmath13
, it is necessary to determine the reddening for each wavelength of the spectrum . correcting differentially and integrating over the filter bandpass then yields the dereddened flux of the given filter .
however , without spectral observations , it is difficult to calculate properly the flux correction .
since formula depends on the wavelength , the usually adopted approach found in literature is to use the effective wavelength @xmath16 of the filter transmittivity curve to calculate the reddening correction .
we demonstrate the implications in the following section .
) of the johnson b transmittivity curve .
right : overplotted light curves with the subtraction constant calculated so that the magnitudes in quarter phase are aligned .
there is still a _
measurable _ difference in eclipse depth of both light curves .
@xmath17 is assumed.,title="fig:",width=226,height=113 ] ) of the johnson b transmittivity curve .
right : overplotted light curves with the subtraction constant calculated so that the magnitudes in quarter phase are aligned .
there is still a _
measurable _ difference in eclipse depth of both light curves .
@xmath17 is assumed.,title="fig:",width=226,height=113 ] + is assumed.,title="fig:",width=226,height=113 ] is assumed.,title="fig:",width=226,height=113 ] + by comparing the rigorously calculated fluxes against intrinsic fluxes with a simple constant subtracted , we come to the following conclusions : * 1 ) * taking the effective wavelength of the filter bandpass should be avoided .
since the flux is the integral over the filter bandpass , @xmath16 has a _ conceptually _ different meaning .
furthermore , @xmath16 of the given filter depends heavily on the effective temperature of the observed object and on the color excess @xmath13 ( fig .
[ weff ] ) . to determine the subtraction constant
, one has to make sure that _ the integral _ ( rather than any particular wavelength ) of the both curves is the same .
[ discrepancy ] shows the discrepancy between the properly calculated light curve and the one obtained by subtracting a @xmath16-calculated constant .
table [ analysis ] summarizes the differences between the proper treatment and other approaches . *
2 ) * even if the subtraction constant is properly calculated , the light curves still exhibit measurable differences in both minima ( figs .
[ discrepancy ] , [ minima ] ) .
this is due to the effective temperature change of the binary system during eclipses . for the analysed case , the difference in b magnitude is @xmath2mag , which is generally observable .
* 3 ) * if light curves in three or more photometric filters are available , it is possible to _ uniquely _ determine the color excess value @xmath13 by comparing different color indices in - and - out of eclipse .
the reddening may thus be properly introduced to the fitting scheme of the eclipsing binary analysis program .
this was done in phoebe .
.the summary of different approaches to calculate the wavelength to be used for the dereddening constant .
@xmath16 is determined by requiring that the area under the spectrum on both sides is equal .
@xmath18 is the value of extinction in b filter and @xmath19 is the deviation from the rigorously calculated value .
all values are calculated for @xmath17 at quarter phase .
note that @xmath18 is smaller than @xmath20 , since our simulated binary is cooler than 10000k .
[ cols="<,^,^,>",options="header " , ] atmospheric extinction is comprised of three different sources : the rayleigh scattering , the aerosol scattering and ozone absorption @xcite .
it depends on the wavelength of the observed light and on the air - mass of obsevations , which is of course the same for both binary components ; we are thus left only with wavelength dependence at some inferred air - mass . to assess the impact on the photometric data , we compare the flux change imposed on the intrinsic spectrum by reddening and by atmospheric extinction ( fig .
[ atmosphere ] ) .
we conclude that for weakly and moderately reddened eclipsing binaries the atmospheric extinction dominates the blue parts of the spectrum due to rayleigh scattering , but for larger color excesses ( @xmath21 ) the reddening is dominant throughout the spectrum .
by not properly taking reddening into account , we introduce systematics of @xmath2mag into the solution for our simulated binary .
one may ask : is this difference worth bothering with ? to demonstrate that it is , let us simulate a bit more exotic eclipsing binary with blue b8 main - sequence ( @xmath22k , @xmath23 ) and red k4 type iii giant ( @xmath24k , @xmath25 ) components with orbital period of 15 days . fig .
[ minima ] ( right ) shows that the discrepancy between the rigorously calculated light curve and the constant - subtracted one is as large as @xmath3mag , which means @xmath26% error in the determined distance to the observed object . on the other hand ,
the reddening effect may be reduced by using narrower filter - sets , e.g. strmgren _ ubvy _ set .
furthermore , typical observed color excesses rarely exceed few tenths of the magnitude , which additionally diminishes this effect
. however , future space scanning missions such as gaia @xcite will acquire measurements of eclipsing binaries without spatial bias .
thus interstellar extinction should be carefully and rigorously introduced into the reduction pipeline for eclipsing binaries . | interstellar and atmospheric extinctions redden the observational photometric data and they should be handled rigorously .
this paper simulates the effect of reddening for the modest case of two main sequence @xmath0k and @xmath1k components of a detached eclipsing binary system .
it is shown that simply subtracting a constant from measured magnitudes ( the approach often used in the field of eclipsing binaries ) to account for reddening should be avoided .
simplified treatment of the reddening introduces systematics that reaches @xmath2mag for the simulated case , but can be as high as @xmath3mag for e.g. b8 v k4 iii systems . with rigorous treatment ,
it is possible to _ uniquely _ determine the color excess value @xmath4 from multi - color photometric light curves of eclipsing binaries
. [email protected] |
the two - way relay network shown in figure [ fig : relay ] .
user @xmath0 requires an approximate copy @xmath1 of the data @xmath2 from user @xmath3 , and user @xmath3 requires an approximate copy @xmath4 of the data @xmath5 from user @xmath0 .
the users are physically separated and direct communication is not possible . instead , indirect communication is achieved via a relay and a two - phase communication protocol . in phase @xmath0 ( uplink transmission )
, each user encodes its data to a codeword that is transmitted over a multiple access channel to the relay . in phase @xmath3 ( downlink transmission )
, the relay completely or partly decodes the noise - corrupted codewords it receives from the multiple access channel , and it transmits a new codeword over a broadcast channel to both users . from this broadcast transmission , user @xmath0 decodes @xmath1 and user @xmath3 decodes @xmath4 . in this paper , we study the downlink for the case where @xmath2 and @xmath5 have been perfectly decoded by the relay after the uplink transmission ( figure [ fig : lossy - broadcast ] ) .
we are interested in the lossy setting where @xmath1 and @xmath4 need to satisfy average distortion constraints .
we have a source coding problem ( figure [ fig : lossy - broadcast-1a ] ) when the broadcast channel is noiseless , and we have a joint source - channel coding problem when the broadcast channel is noisy ( figure [ fig : lossy - broadcast-1b ] ) . in figure
[ fig : lossy - broadcast ] we have relabelled the relay as the transmitter , user @xmath0 as receiver @xmath0 and user @xmath3 as receiver @xmath3 .
we note that the source coding problem is a special case of the joint source - channel coding problem ; however , we will present each problem separately for clarity .
it is worthwhile to briefly discuss some of the implicit assumptions in the two - way relay network setup .
the no direct communication assumption has been adopted by many authors including oechtering , _ et al . _
@xcite , gndz , tuncel and nayak @xcite as well as wyner , wolf and willems @xcite .
it is appropriate when the users are separated by a vast physical distance and communication is via a satellite .
it is also appropriate when direct communication is prevented by practical system considerations . in cellular networks , for example , two mobile phones located within the same cell
will communicate with each other via their local base - station .
we note that this assumption differs from shannon s classic formulation of the two - way communication problem @xcite .
specifically , those works assume that the users exchange data directly over a discrete memoryless channel without using a relay . the two - phase communication protocol assumption ( uplink and downlink ) is appropriate when the users and relay can not transmit and receive at the same time on the same channel @xcite .
this again contrasts to shannon s two - way communication problem @xcite as well as gndz , tuncel and nayak s separated relay @xcite , where simultaneous transmission and reception is permitted . finally , this relay network is restricted in the sense that it does not permit feedback @xcite ; that is , each user can not use previously decoded data when encoding new data . _
notation : _ the non - negative real numbers are written @xmath6 . random variables and random vectors are identified by uppercase and bolded uppercase letters , respectively .
the alphabet of a random variable is identified by matching calligraphic typeface , and a generic element of an alphabet is identified by a matching lowercase letter .
for example , @xmath7 represent a random variable that takes values @xmath8 from a finite alphabet @xmath9 , and @xmath10 denotes a vector of random variables with each taking values from @xmath9
. the length of a random vector will be clear from context .
the @xmath11-fold cartesian product of a single set is identified by a superscript @xmath11 .
for example , @xmath12 is the @xmath11-fold product of @xmath9 .
_ paper outline : _ in section [ sec:2 ] , we formally state the problem and review some basic rd functions .
we present our main results in section [ sec:3 ] , and we prove these results in sections [ sec:4 ] and [ sec:5 ] . the paper is concluded in section [ sec:6 ] .
let @xmath9 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 be finite alphabets , and let @xmath17 $ ] be a generic probability mass function ( pmf ) on @xmath18 .
the source coding and joint source - channel coding problems are defined next .
assume that @xmath19 is drawn independent and identically distributed ( iid ) according to @xmath20 .
a rate - distortion ( rd ) blockcode is a triple of mappings @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , where [ eqn : enc - dec ] @xmath24 here @xmath25 denotes the encoder at the transmitter and @xmath26 denotes the decoder at receiver @xmath27 , see figure [ fig : sc - code ] .
the compression rate @xmath28 of an rd code @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 is defined by @xmath29 where @xmath30 denotes the cardinality of @xmath31 .
we use the braced superscript @xmath32 to emphasize that a blockcode of length @xmath11 is under consideration .
the reconstruction quality of the decoded data is quantified in the usual way via average per - letter distortions . to this end , we let @xmath33\quad \text { and}\\ \delta_2&:\ { \mathscr{y } } \hspace{.8 mm } \times \hat{{\mathscr{y}}}\hspace{.8 mm } \rightarrow [ 0,d_{2,\text{max}}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] be bounded per - letter distortion measures . to simplify our presentation , we assume that @xmath34 and @xmath35 are normal @xcite . that is , for all @xmath36 we have @xmath37 for some @xmath38 .
similarly , for all @xmath39 we have @xmath40 for some @xmath41 .
this assumption is not too restrictive , and our results can be extended to more general distortion measures @xcite .
we call @xmath34 a hamming distortion measure if @xmath42 , @xmath37 for @xmath43 and @xmath44 for @xmath45 .
we call @xmath34 a difference distortion measure @xcite if it can be written in the form @xmath46 , where @xmath47 and the subtraction is performed modulo-@xmath48 .
the same naming convention applies to @xmath35 .
the average average distortions @xmath49 of an rd code @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 are defined by [ eqn : sc - dist ] @xmath50\\ \label{eqn : sc - dist-2 } \delta_2^{(n ) } & \triangleq \mathbb{e}\left[\frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^n \delta_2(y_i\hspace{.8mm},\hat{y}_i\hspace{.8 mm } ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 $ ] denotes the expectation operator .
[ def : source - coding ] let @xmath55 .
a rate @xmath56 is said to be @xmath57-achievable if for arbitrary @xmath58 there exists an rd code @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 for some sufficiently large @xmath11 with [ eqn : rd - def - ach ] @xmath59 let @xmath60 denote the set of all @xmath57-admissible rates , and let @xmath61 definition [ def : source - coding ] does not require that the two receivers agree on the exact realizations of @xmath1 and @xmath4 .
for example , receiver @xmath0 need not know the exact realization of @xmath4 . in some scenarios ,
it is appropriate that the receivers exactly agree on @xmath1 and @xmath4 .
the notion of common reconstructions is useful for such scenarios . a common - reconstructions rate - distortion ( cr - rd ) code is a tuple of mappings @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are given by and [ eqn : cr - enc - dec ] @xmath65 here @xmath66 denotes the `` common - reconstruction '' decoder at receiver @xmath27 , see figure [ fig : cr - sc - code ] . the rate @xmath28 and average distortion @xmath67 of a cr - rd code are defined in the same manner as and .
additionally , we define the average probability of common - reconstruction decoding error by @xmath68,\pr[\tilde{{\mathbf{y } } } \neq \hat{{\mathbf{y}}}]\big\}\ , \ ] ] where @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
[ def : cr - source - coding ] let @xmath71 .
a rate @xmath56 is said to be @xmath57-achievable with common reconstructions if for arbitrary @xmath58 there exists a cr - rd code @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 with @xmath72 , @xmath73 @xmath74 satisfying and @xmath75 .
let @xmath76 denote the set of all @xmath57-admissible rates with common reconstructions , and let @xmath77 the next proposition follows directly from definitions [ def : source - coding ] and [ def : cr - source - coding ] .
[ pro : rc - cr - convex ] the rd function @xmath78 and the cr - rd function @xmath79 are continuous , non - increasing and convex on @xmath80 .
moreover , for @xmath71 we have that @xmath81 _ general remark : _ the common - reconstruction condition used in this paper was inspired by steinberg s study @xcite of common reconstructions for the wyner - ziv problem .
consider the joint source - channel coding problem .
suppose that the source @xmath82 emits symbols at the rate @xmath83 , and that the channel accepts and emits symbols at the rate @xmath84 .
let @xmath85 denote the channel input alphabet , let @xmath86 denote the product of the channel output alphabets , and let the transitions from @xmath85 to @xmath86 be governed by the conditional pmf @xmath87 $ ] .
the ratio of channel symbols to source symbols , @xmath88 is called the bandwidth expansion . in the sequel , @xmath83 and @xmath84
are arbitrary fixed constants .
a joint source - channel ( jsc ) blockcode of length @xmath89 , with @xmath90 and @xmath91 being integers , is a triple of mappings @xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 . here
[ eqn : enc - dec - jsc ] @xmath95 denotes the encoder at the transmitter , and @xmath96 denotes the decoder at receiver @xmath27 .
a common - reconstruction joint source - channel ( cr - jsc ) blockcode is a tuple of mappings @xmath92 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , where @xmath101 and @xmath102 are defined in and [ eqn : cr - enc - dec - jsc ] @xmath103 here @xmath104 denotes the `` common - reconstruction '' decoder at receiver @xmath27 .
the average distortions @xmath105 of jsc and cr - jsc codes are defined by and , where @xmath90 replaces @xmath11 in the sum , and we set @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
the probability law of @xmath109 and @xmath110 is defined by the discrete memoryless broadcast channel @xmath111 for the cr - jsc code , the probability of common - reconstruction decoding error @xmath112 is defined by , where @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
[ def : jscc ] a distortion pair @xmath71 is said to be achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if for every @xmath58 there exists a joint source - channel code @xmath92 , @xmath97 , @xmath116 for some sufficiently large @xmath89 with @xmath117 [ def : jscc - cr ] a distortion pair @xmath118 @xmath119 @xmath120 @xmath121 is said to be achievable with cr and bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if for every @xmath58 there exists a cr - jsc code @xmath92 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 for some sufficiently large @xmath89 with @xmath105 satisfying and @xmath75 . in this section
, we briefly review some rate - distortion functions that will be used frequently throughout the paper .
let @xmath122 denote the @xmath7-marginal of @xmath82 .
( this notation will be extended to all marginal pmfs . )
let @xmath123 denote the set of channels @xmath124 mapping @xmath9 to @xmath14 such that @xmath125 for @xmath126 , the rd function of @xmath7 is defined by ( * ? ? ?
10 ) @xmath127
let @xmath128 denote the set of channels @xmath129 mapping @xmath18 to @xmath130 such that @xmath131 [ def : jrd ] for @xmath71 , the joint rd function of @xmath7 and @xmath132 is defined by @xcite @xmath133 let @xmath134 denote the set of all channels @xmath135 mapping @xmath18 to @xmath14 such that @xmath136 [ def : crd ] for @xmath126 , the conditional rd function of @xmath7 given @xmath132 is defined by @xmath137 let @xmath138 be finite set of cardinality @xmath139 .
let @xmath140 denote the set of pmfs @xmath141 on @xmath142 such that : @xmath143 @xmath144 forms a markov chain , and there exists a function @xmath145 such that @xmath146 [ def : wyner - ziv ] for @xmath126 , the wyner - ziv rd function for @xmath7 given @xmath132 is defined by @xcite @xmath147 the final function that we will need to define is the minimax ( or , worst noise ) capacity @xmath148 .
this function was used by zamir in @xcite to bound the rate loss in the wyner - ziv problem .
we shall use it in a similar manner to approximate @xmath78 . before defining @xmath148
, we first need to define the capacity of an additive channel with an input distortion constraint .
let @xmath149 be a random variable that takes values from @xmath150 , and let @xmath151 denote its pmf .
consider the additive - noise channel that randomly maps @xmath9 to @xmath9 via @xmath152 .
i.e. , consider @xmath149 to be modulo-@xmath48 additive noise .
the capacity of this channel ( with an input distortion constraint @xmath153 ) is defined by @xmath154 where the supremum is taken over all choices of a random variable @xmath155 ( defined on @xmath9 with pmf @xmath156 and independent of @xmath149 ) for which @xmath157 the minimax ( worst noise ) capacity under distortion constraint @xmath153 is defined by @xcite @xmath158 where the infimum is taken over all choices of a `` noise '' random variable @xmath149 such that @xmath159
our first result is a single - letter characterisation of @xmath79 for arbitrary sources and distortion measures . for @xmath71 , define @xmath160 where @xmath128 is defined in section [ sec:2:basicrdfuncts ] .
the next result is proved in section [ sec:3:proof : thm : cr - rd ] .
[ thm : cr - rd ] for @xmath71 , the cr - rd function is given by @xmath161 theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] is best understood in the context of the joint rd function of @xmath7 and @xmath132 . specifically , @xmath162 can be rewritten as @xmath163\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which can be interpreted as joint vector quantization coding followed by slepian - wolf coding .
the encoder jointly maps @xmath164 to @xmath165 .
the common - reconstruction condition requires that @xmath1 and @xmath4 satisfy the average distortion constraints @xmath153 and @xmath166 , respectively .
the rate needed to simultaneously satisfy these constraints is captured by the @xmath167 term .
the @xmath168 term captures the fact that the rate @xmath167 can be reduced by exploiting the side - information at each receiver with a slepian - wolf code .
this joint vector quantization and slepian - wolf coding structure implicitly allows the encoder to know @xmath1 and @xmath4 with high probability . we can therefore impose a third common - reconstruction constraint at the transmitter without suffering a rate - loss
that is , the rd function with common reconstructions at the transmitter and both receivers is equal to @xmath79 .
this result is to be expected because the transmitter has @xmath2 and @xmath5 from which it can always compute @xmath1 and @xmath4 .
what is less obvious , however , is that this result will also hold in the joint source - channel setting .
specifically , it will be optimal for the encoder to know @xmath1 and @xmath4 with high probability .
this result is not obvious because it is sometimes necessary to exploit randomness in the channel to efficiently induce distortions @xcite .
theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] gives a relatively straightforward single - letter characterisation of @xmath79 .
in contrast , giving a single - letter characterisation of @xmath78 is much more difficult .
a simple lower bound for @xmath78 stems from the following cut - set argument : @xmath78 must be at least as large as the smallest rate that is needed to compress @xmath2 at the transmitter for decoding by receiver @xmath0 , while ignoring the distortion constraint on @xmath5 for receiver @xmath3 .
the smallest such rate is given by the conditional rd function @xmath169 .
more formally , we have the following . [
prop : cut - set ] for @xmath71 , we have that @xmath170 where @xmath171 surprisingly , @xmath172 is the tightest lower bound in the literature .
it equals @xmath78 in the high - distortion regime where @xmath173 or @xmath174 , but it is an open problem as to whether @xmath172 always equals have been given in @xcite and @xcite .
we discuss these bounds in section [ sec:4 ] . ]
the next example describes a simple binary source where @xmath172 is equal to @xmath78 .
this example was also given in @xcite .
we review it here because it is relevant to the following discussion .
[ def : dsbs ] the source @xmath82 is said to be a doubly symmetric binary source ( dsbs ) with cross - over probability @xmath175 if @xmath9 @xmath176 @xmath14 @xmath176 @xmath15 @xmath176 @xmath16 @xmath176 @xmath177 , @xmath178 $ ] and @xmath179 where @xmath180 we can view @xmath82 as resulting from the equation @xmath181 . here
@xmath7 is uniform on @xmath9 , @xmath182 denotes modulo - two addition , and @xmath183 is independent of @xmath7 and takes values from @xmath177 with probability @xmath184 and @xmath185 .
[ exa : dsbs ] if @xmath82 is the dsbs with cross - over probability @xmath175 and @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming measures , then for all @xmath186 $ ] we have that @xcite @xmath187 where @xmath188 is the binary entropy function ( take @xmath189 ) .
let @xmath190 .
clearly , we have that @xmath191 for @xmath192 because each receiver can estimate its reconstruction directly from its side - information . for @xmath193 ,
the transmitter computes @xmath194 and sends a distorted version @xmath195 of @xmath196 to both receivers with an average ( hamming ) distortion of @xmath197 .
this can be done with a binary rd code of rate @xmath198 ; for example , see ( * ? ? ?
receiver @xmath0 decodes @xmath1 by setting @xmath199 for @xmath200 .
similarly , receiver @xmath3 decodes @xmath4 by setting @xmath201 .
it can be verified that both reconstructions , @xmath1 and @xmath4 , achieve an average distortion @xmath197 .
the rd function is therefore given by @xmath202 it is worth noting that the above code achieves an average distortion @xmath197 for both receivers ; that is , it operates at the point @xmath203 .
note also that this code does not satisfy definition [ def : cr - source - coding ] ( e.g. , receiver @xmath0 can not compute @xmath201 ) , so it can not be used as a cr - rd code .
the rd function is plotted for @xmath204 in figure [ fig : rldsbs ] . for the doubly symmetric binary source ( dsbs ) with cross over probability @xmath204 and hamming distortions .
this function is developed in example [ exa : dsbs].,title="fig:",width=245 ] + consider the three functions : the cr - rd function @xmath79 , the rd function @xmath78 and the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 .
it is clear that @xmath205 for all sources and distortion measures .
inequality @xmath206 can be strict .
for example , in example [ exa : dsbs ] there is zero common information ( in the gcs - krner @xcite sense ) between @xmath7 and @xmath132 when @xmath207 .
this means that the receivers can not agree on any non - trivial @xmath1 and @xmath4 without additional information from the transmitter .
therefore , one would expect that @xmath208 can not reach @xmath209 until @xmath210 .
in contrast , note that @xmath211 for all @xmath212 because each receiver can estimate its reconstruction directly from its side - information ; see , for example , @xmath213 in figure [ fig : rldsbs ] .
the next result shows that both @xmath206 and @xmath214 are equalities for vanishing hamming distortions .
the proof involves a minor modification of a result by sgarro @xcite ( see also wyner _
et al . _
1 ) ) and is omitted for brevity .
[ prop : losslesssc ] if @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming distortion measures , then @xmath215 our next result shows that inequalities @xmath206 and @xmath214 are in fact equalities for a non - trivial range of small distortions .
a surface @xmath216 in @xmath121 is said to be strictly positive if for all @xmath217 we have @xmath218 and @xmath219 ; see , for example , gray @xcite .
the next result is proved in section [ sec:3:small - distortions ] .
[ thm : small - distortions ] if @xmath82 has support @xmath18 and @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming distortion measures , then there exists a strictly positive surface @xmath216 in @xmath121 such that @xmath220 whenever @xmath57 lies on or below @xmath216 ; that is , there exists some @xmath221 with @xmath222 and @xmath223 .
this result is not just interesting because @xmath78 and @xmath79 both meet the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 for small distortions .
it also gives an explicit characterisation of @xmath78 for a class of sources and distortions for which @xmath78 would be otherwise unknown .
we prove theorem [ thm : small - distortions ] by matching the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 to the single - letter characterisation of the cr - rd function @xmath79 given in theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] .
an important step in this proof requires that gray s extended shannon lower bounds for joint , conditional and marginal rd functions @xcite are tight .
this tightness is only achieved in the small distortion regime .
the notion of `` small distortions '' is not vacuous ; our next result shows that the set of distortions for which theorem [ thm : small - distortions ] holds for the dsbs is in fact quite large .
moreover , the boundary of this set has a close connection to common information ( in wyner s sense @xcite ) .
let @xmath85 be a finite set of cardinality @xmath224 and let @xcite @xmath225 where @xmath226 is the set of channels @xmath227 mapping @xmath228 to @xmath85 such that the resulting joint pmf for @xmath229 forms the markov chain @xmath230 .
the next result is proved in section [ sec:3:dsbs ] .
[ thm : dsbs - cr ] if @xmath82 is the dsbs with cross - over probability @xmath178 $ ] , @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming distortion measures , and @xmath231 then the cr - rd function @xmath208 satisfies the following : 1 . for all @xmath232 $ ] @xmath233 2 .
[ thm : dsbs - cr : part2 ] @xmath234 3 . for all @xmath235 $ ] + [ thm : dsbs - cr : part3 ] @xmath236 in figure [ fig : dsbs-1 ] we plot @xmath237 , @xmath238 , and the upper bound for @xmath208 that is given in .
it can be seen from these plots that the threshold @xmath238 is reasonably large , and most interesting distortion pairs can be achieved by a cr - rd code .
our next result characterises joint source - channel coding rates with common reconstructions .
it is the joint source - channel coding extension of the theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] .
[ thm : jscc - cr ] a distortion pair @xmath71 is achievable with common reconstructions and bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if and only if there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 and @xmath129 @xmath120 @xmath128 such that [ eqn : thm : jscc - cr-1 ] @xmath239 as was the case for source coding , characterising joint source - channel coding rates without common - reconstructions ( i.e. definition [ def : jscc ] ) is difficult , and we have succeeded only in giving complete results for a few special cases .
the next proposition reviews a special case that is known in the literature .
this proposition follows from tuncel ( * ? ? ?
6 ) , and it can be thought of as the joint source - channel coding extension of sgarro s result ( proposition [ prop : losslesssc ] ) . [ prop : losslessjscc ] suppose @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming distortion measures .
zero distortion is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if and only if there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 such that [ eqn : tuncel ] @xmath240 tuncel s result is ideal because it characterises achievability simply and explicitly ; it does not require auxiliary random variables and difficult optimization problems to be solved .
the following consequences of this result are worth noting : @xmath241 the physical separation of source and channel codes is suboptimal the side - information takes a particular `` complimentary '' form , and in some circumstances it may be appropriate to use this side - information in the channel code ; for example , see @xcite . ]
; @xmath242 an optimal joint source - channel code exhibits a `` partial '' separation of source and channel coding at the transmitter , which results in the separation of source and channel random variables in ; @xmath243 an optimal joint source - channel code exploits randomness in the broadcast channel to perform a `` virtual binning , '' which is analogous to the random binning used in the proof of proposition [ prop : losslesssc ] ; @xmath244 if the broadcast channel is such that the same @xmath156 maximises @xmath245 and @xmath246 , then all channels can be used to full capacity .
this last property is not shared by broadcast channels in general . like sgarro s result for lossless source coding ( proposition [ prop : losslesssc ] )
, tuncel s result does not easily extend to more general distortion measures and distortions .
this difficulty is evidenced by the growing body of work @xcite concerning the lossy extension of @xcite .
our next result gives necessary conditions for a distortion pair to be achievable .
it is the joint source - channel coding extension of the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 for @xmath78 , see proposition [ prop : cut - set ] . a proof of this result is given in section [ sec:4 ] .
[ thm : jscc - cut - set ] if @xmath71 is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 , then there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 such that [ eqn : thmjscc - cut - set ] [ eqn : jscc - cut - set ] @xmath247 in the hamming distortion setting , we have that @xmath248 and @xmath249 .
therefore , theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] gives the necessary ( `` only if '' ) condition of proposition [ prop : losslessjscc ] .
similarly , in the high - distortion regime @xmath174 we have that @xmath250 and is satisfied by any @xmath156 .
we are left with , which is the necessary condition of shannon s joint source - channel coding theorem ( * ? ? ?
it is an open problem as to whether the conditions of theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] are both necessary and sufficient .
the next result shows that these conditions are necessary and sufficient for small distortions .
[ thm : jscc - small - distortions ] suppose @xmath82 has support @xmath18 and @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming distortion measures .
there exists a strictly positive surface @xmath216 in @xmath121 such that every @xmath57 on or below @xmath216 is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if and only if there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 such that holds .
the proof of theorem [ thm : jscc - small - distortions ] follows in a similar manner to the proof of theorem [ thm : small - distortions ] .
specifically , we match the single - letter characterisation of theorem [ thm : jscc - cr ] with the necessary conditions in theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] .
we have already reviewed the cut - set lower bound @xmath251 in the introduction .
we now review an upper bound for @xmath78 that , together with @xmath172 , gives a good approximation of @xmath78 .
let @xmath252 su and el .
gamal @xcite called this bound the compress - linear upper bound @xcite the reason will become clear shortly .
if @xmath34 and @xmath35 are difference distortion measures , let @xmath253 the next result bounds @xmath78 from above and below , and it approximates @xmath78 when @xmath153 and @xmath166 are difference distortion measures .
[ thm : rd - bounds ] for @xmath71 , we have that ( * ? ? ?
2 ) @xmath254 if @xmath34 and @xmath35 are difference distortion measures , then @xmath255 the minimax capacity bound shows that the gap between @xmath172 and @xmath256 can not be arbitrarily large @xcite .
the inequalities in were obtained independently and contemporaneously by su and el . gamal in @xcite .
this proof of theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] is relevant to the following discussion , so it is worthwhile to give a brief outline .
the fact that @xmath257 follows from the cut - set argument given in the introduction . to show @xmath258 we combine two wyner - ziv codes with a simple linear - network code . at the transmitter , @xmath2 is mapped to a binary vector using an optimal wyner - ziv code @xcite .
this code treats @xmath5 as side - information at receiver @xmath0 , but it ignores @xmath5 at the transmitter .
similarly , @xmath5 is mapped to a binary vector using a wyner - ziv code that treats @xmath2 as side - information at receiver @xmath3 , but it ignores @xmath2 at the transmitter .
the transmitter sends the modulo - two sum of these codewords ( in the same way as example [ exa : dsbs ] ) over the noiseless bc , and each receiver recovers their desired codeword by eliminating ( subtracting ) the codeword destined for the other receiver .
it is possible to perform this elimination because each receiver can calculate ( from its side - information ) the wyner - ziv codeword intended for the other receiver .
note , if conditional rd codes were used in place of wyner - ziv codes , then each receiver can not calculate the codeword intended for the other user and this elimination is not possible .
the second result follows directly from zamir s work on rate - loss in the wyner - ziv problem @xcite .
@xmath256 is called the compress - linear upper bound because it is obtained by combining two wyner - ziv compression codes with a linear - network code
. the gap between @xmath259 and @xmath260 can be no larger than the `` rate loss '' of the wyner - ziv rd function over the conditional rd function .
if @xmath82 and @xmath34 and @xmath35 are such that there is no rate loss , then theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] characterises @xmath78 .
the following examples outline a number of such scenarios .
[ thm : rd - bounds : cor : cond - ind ] if @xmath261 and @xmath262 where @xmath263 forms a markov chain , then for all distortion pairs @xmath71 we have that @xmath264 in particular , if @xmath7 and @xmath132 are independent , then we have @xmath265 if @xmath261 and @xmath262 where @xmath263 forms a markov chain , then @xmath266 also forms a markov chain .
moreover , we have @xmath267 where @xmath206 follows from the markov chain @xmath266 , @xmath214 follows because is a component of the source ; therefore , @xmath268 and @xmath269 are equal .
] @xmath261 , and @xmath270 follows because @xmath271 . on combining with the fact that @xmath272 , it follows that @xmath273 . a similar argument yields @xmath274 .
substituting these equalities into the definitions of @xmath172 and @xmath256 , and applying theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] completes the proof .
[ thm : rd - bounds : cor:2deterministic ] if @xmath275 and @xmath276 are finite sets , @xmath277 and @xmath278 are mappings , @xmath279 , @xmath280 , @xmath281 , @xmath282 , @xmath283 then we have that @xmath284 the conditional rd function @xmath169 and the wyner - ziv rd function @xmath285 are both continuous by willems in @xcite .
the continuity of the conditional rate distortion function @xmath169 at @xmath286 follows from willems result because @xmath169 is a special case of the wyner - ziv rate distortion function when the source and distortion measure are chosen appropriately . ] at @xmath286 .
we have that @xmath287 where the minimum is taken over all channels @xmath288 with @xmath289 suppose that @xmath288 achieves the above minimum .
since @xmath290 when @xmath291 and @xmath292 when @xmath293 , implies that when @xmath294 we have that @xmath288 must satisfy @xmath295 that is , @xmath296 almost surely .
therefore @xmath297 and @xmath298 .
we also have that @xmath299 where the minimization is taken over all choices of an auxiliary random variable @xmath300 with a joint pmf @xmath141 satisfying the markov chain @xmath144 and the distortion constraint @xmath301 where @xmath302 .
setting @xmath303 gives @xmath304 and therefore @xmath305 .
a similar argument gives @xmath306 .
the proof is completed by applying theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] . using standard techniques , theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] can be extended from discrete finite alphabets to real - valued alphabets @xcite .
this extension yields the following example for jointly gaussian sources .
[ exa : rd - bounds : exa:1gaussian ] if @xmath307 , @xmath308 and @xmath309\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and [ eqn : squared - error ] @xmath310 then for all distortion pairs @xmath55 we have @xmath311 where @xcite @xmath312 and [ eqn : crd - gaussian ] @xmath313 corollaries [ thm : rd - bounds : cor : cond - ind ] and [ thm : rd - bounds : cor:2deterministic ] include the results of ( * ? ? ?
iii.b ) as special cases . example [ exa : rd - bounds : exa:1gaussian ] was independently given in @xcite .
the next result characterises @xmath78 for one large distortion and shows that the upper bound @xmath256 can be loose .
its proof follows directly from the lower bound @xmath172 in theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] and the coding theorem for the conditional rd function @xcite .
this proof is omitted .
[ thm : rd - bounds : cor : max - distortion ] for @xmath71 , we have that @xmath314 in summary , the compress - linear upper bound @xmath259 and the cut - set lower bound @xmath260 well approximate @xmath78 when @xmath34 and @xmath35 are difference distortion measures .
specifically , the ideas of zamir @xcite can be used to show that the gap between @xmath172 and @xmath256 is no larger than the maximum of two minimax capacities .
the bounds yield an exact characterisation of @xmath78 for sources with zero rate - loss in the wyner - ziv problem @xcite ; however , it is well known that this condition is very restrictive ( * ? ? ?
* remark 5 ) .
two sources that satisfy this condition are the jointly gaussian source with a squared - error distortion measure ( see ( * ? ? ? * remark 6 ) and example [ exa : rd - bounds : exa:1gaussian ] ) and the erasure side - information source with a hamming distortion measure @xcite .
corollary [ thm : rd - bounds : cor : max - distortion ] and example [ exa : dsbs ] demonstrated that the compress - linear upper bound @xmath256 can be loose . we conjecture that @xmath172 is also loose in general , but no counterexample has been found to date .
we give a different lower bound for @xmath78 in appendix [ app : newlowerbound ] . in this section ,
we review an upper bound for @xmath78 that was proposed by kimura and uyematsu in ( * ? ? ?
1 ) , and we compare this bound to the compress - linear upper bound @xmath256 .
we then formulate a new upper bound for @xmath78 using a result of heegard and berger @xcite .
the main purpose of this section is to unify the achievability results of @xcite .
let @xmath315 be a finite set of cardinality @xmath316 let @xmath317 denote the set channels @xmath318 randomly mapping @xmath228 to @xmath315 such that there exist functions @xmath319 and @xmath320 with @xmath321 define @xmath322 [ lem : one - description - upper ] for @xmath71 , we have that @xmath323 lemma [ lem : one - description - upper ] is called the one - description upper bound because its proof follows from a random coding argument that describes both @xmath2 and @xmath5 with one description . the one - description bound @xmath324 and the compress - linear bound @xmath256 both involve difficult minimizations ,
so it is not immediately clear when one bound outperforms the other .
the next result resolves this question and shows that @xmath324 is always better than @xmath256 .
[ lem : one - des - v - com - lin ] for @xmath71 , we have that @xmath325 we have that @xmath326 where the auxiliary random variables @xmath300 and @xmath327 satisfy the markov chains @xmath144 and @xmath328 . note that @xmath300 and @xmath327 do not appear together in any of the mutual information or distortion conditions , so we can combine these minima into a minimum where @xmath329 forms a markov chain . to this end ,
let @xmath330 denote the set of channels @xmath331 mapping @xmath9 @xmath332 @xmath15 to @xmath138 @xmath332 @xmath333 such that the following properties hold : 1 . the joint distribution , @xmath334 , factors to form the long markov chain @xmath335 .
there exist functions @xmath336 and @xmath337 such that + @xmath338 note that the long markov chain @xmath335 in condition @xmath0 is implied by the markov chains @xmath339 , @xmath144 and @xmath328 .
we now have that @xmath340 the constraint @xmath335 implies @xmath341 which , in turn , implies @xmath342 .
therefore , we have @xmath343 similarly , we have @xmath344 combining with and completes the proof @xmath345 where follows because @xmath346 .
the results of heegard and berger ( * ? ? ?
2 ) ( see also @xcite ) can be modified to further strengthen the one - description upper bound .
let @xmath347 denote the set of _ all _ channels @xmath318 mapping @xmath9 @xmath332 @xmath15 to @xmath315 . for @xmath71 , define @xmath348\ , \ ] ] where @xmath349 and @xmath350 are the conditional rd functions of @xmath7 given @xmath351 and @xmath132 given @xmath352 , respectively .
the proof of the next result follows directly from ( * ? ? ?
2 ) and lemma [ lem : one - des - v - com - lin ] and is omitted .
[ thm : rd*-upper - bound ] for @xmath71 , we have that @xmath353 in summary , the compress - linear upper bound @xmath256 and the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 well approximate @xmath78 for difference distortion measures .
the compress - linear bound is weaker than the one - description bound , i.e. @xmath354 , and this inequality is strict for the dsbs with hamming distortion measures ( example [ exa : dsbs ] ) .
finally , the one - description bound is potentially weaker than heegard and berger s bound , i.e. @xmath355 ; however , we have not found an example where this inequality is strict . in theorem
[ thm : cr - rd ] , we claimed that the cr - rd function @xmath79 is equal to @xmath356 .
we now prove this result .
the coding theorem is a special case of the one - description bound , where @xmath357 is chosen to be @xmath358 .
we omit the proof .
it remains to prove the converse theorem .
if @xmath359 is @xmath57-admissible , then by definition there exists the following : 1 . a monotonically decreasing sequence @xmath360 with @xmath361 , and a monotonically increasing sequence @xmath362 ; 2 . a sequence of common reconstruction rd codes @xmath363 @xmath364 , where @xmath365 , @xmath366 , @xmath367 , @xmath368 \leq \epsilon_i$ ] , and @xmath369 \leq \epsilon_i$ ] .
we now show that @xmath370 for all @xmath371 , where @xmath372 . to this end
, the following inequalities will be useful : [ eqn : thm : cr - rd : fano1 ] @xmath373 where @xmath374 this inequality is a consequence of fano s inequality @xcite , the common - reconstruction property @xmath375 & \leq \epsilon_i\ \text { and}\\ \pr[\phi_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x } } ) \neq g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y } } ) ] & \leq \epsilon_i\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the fact that the cardinality of the range of @xmath66 , @xmath27 , can be no more than @xmath376 . note that @xmath377 . by definition , we also have @xmath378\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd:1:8 } & \geq \frac{1}{n_i}h\big(g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),\phi_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}}\big ) -
\varepsilon(n_i,\epsilon_i)\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd:1:9 } & \geq \frac{1}{n_i } h\big(g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}}\big ) -
\varepsilon(n_i,\epsilon_i)\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd:1:10 } & \geq \frac{1}{n_i } i\big({\mathbf{x}};g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}}\big ) -
\varepsilon(n_i,\epsilon_i)\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd:1:11 } & = \frac{1}{n_i } \sum_{j=1}^{n_i } i\big(x_j;g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}},x_1^{j-1}\big ) -
\varepsilon(n_i,\epsilon_i)\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd:1:12 } & = \frac{1}{n_i } \sum_{j=1}^{n_i } i\big(x_j;g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x}}),x_1^{j-1},y_1^{j-1},y_{j+1}^n\big|y_i\big ) -
\varepsilon(n_i,\epsilon_i)\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd : rate-1 } & \geq \frac{1}{n_i } \sum_{j=1}^{n_i } i\big(x_j;g_1^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(n_i)}(m,{\mathbf{x}})\big|y_j\big ) - \varepsilon(n_i,\epsilon_i)\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where through follow from standard identities , follows from , through follow from standard identities , and follows because the source is iid .
a similar procedure yields @xmath379 let @xmath380 and @xmath381 denote the @xmath382 elements of @xmath383 and @xmath384 , respectively .
i.e. @xmath380 and @xmath381 are the @xmath382 symbols reconstructed by the receivers .
expanding the conditions @xmath385 and @xmath386 gives @xmath387 & \leq d_1 + \epsilon_i\\ \label{eqn : thm : cr - rd : dist-2 } \mathbb{e}\left[\frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j=1}^{n_i } \delta_2(y_j,\hspace{0.8mm}\hat{y}_j)\hspace{0.8mm}\right ] & \leq d_2 + \epsilon_i\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall , @xmath388 is drawn i.i.d . according to @xmath20 . for each @xmath389 , let @xmath390 denote the conditional probability of @xmath391 given @xmath392 ; that is , combining @xmath390 with @xmath393 characterises the joint pmf of @xmath394 .
define the `` time - shared '' channel @xmath395 from and , we have @xmath396 consequently , @xmath397 .
we have that @xmath398 where we have used jensen s inequality together with the convexity of @xmath399 and @xmath400 in @xmath129 when the joint pmf of @xmath401 ( here @xmath82 ) is fixed ( see lemma [ lem : cmi - convex ] below ) . finally , combining and with the definition of @xmath356 we have @xmath402 which is the desired result . the converse is completed by noting that @xmath361 , @xmath372 , and @xmath356 is a continuous function of @xmath153 and @xmath166 .
[ lem : cmi - convex ] suppose the random vector @xmath403 on @xmath404 is characterised by the joint pmf @xmath405 .
the condition mutual information @xmath406 is convex in @xmath407 for fixed @xmath408 .
fix @xmath409 . from the convexity of mutual information ( * ? ? ?
2.7.4 ) , we have that @xmath410 is convex in @xmath411 for each @xmath412 .
the lemma follows by noting that @xmath406 is a convex combination of @xmath410 .
further details can be found in appendix [ app : lemma - convexity ] .
the next result shows that if one source is required to be reconstructed with vanishing hamming distortion , then the rd function @xmath78 and the cr - rd function @xmath79 both collapse to the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 .
[ thm : cr - rd : cor : onelossless ] if @xmath34 is a hamming distortion measure , then for all @xmath413 we have that @xmath414 from proposition [ pro : rc - cr - convex ] and theorems [ thm : cr - rd ] and [ thm : rd - bounds ] we have that @xmath415 let @xmath416 be a channel that achieves the minimum for the conditional rd function @xmath417 .
this channel and @xmath82 together define a joint pmf for @xmath418 .
in addition , set @xmath419 to obtain a joint pmf for @xmath420 .
this joint pmf belongs to the set @xmath421 .
note , we have the markov chain @xmath422 and therefore the chain @xmath423 . on substituting this joint pmf into
we obtain the following upper bound for @xmath424 : @xmath425 where follows because @xmath419 and @xmath423 forms a markov chain , and follows because @xmath426 was chosen to achieve the minimum in the definition of @xmath417 . the proof is completed by noting that @xmath427 the next result covers the one large distortion setting .
the proof follows directly from theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] and is omitted .
note that it may differ from corollary [ thm : rd - bounds : cor : max - distortion ] the large distortion result for @xmath78 .
[ thm : cr - rd : cor : max - distortion ] for @xmath126 we have that @xmath428 where @xmath429 denotes the set of all test channels @xmath135 mapping @xmath18 to @xmath14 such that @xmath430 the following result gives a useful upper bound for @xmath79 .
we will use this bound to prove the small distortion result theorem [ thm : small - distortions ] .
[ cor : thm : cr - rd ] for @xmath71 we have that @xmath431 let @xmath129 achieve the minimum for the joint rate distortion function @xmath432 . then ,
@xmath433 where the remaining mutual information terms are evaluated using @xmath434 .
note that @xmath435 where the last inequality follows from the definition of @xmath436 .
similarly , we also have that @xmath437 , and thus @xmath438 on combining this result with proposition [ pro : rc - cr - convex ] and theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] , we have @xmath439 from this chain of inequalities , it is clear that if [ eqn : imtired1 ] @xmath440 then we have that the rd function @xmath78 and the cr - rd function @xmath79 both meet the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 .
the next two examples give situations where holds . if @xmath7 and @xmath132 are independent ( @xmath441 ) , then @xmath442 and @xmath443 therefore , @xmath444 if @xmath34 and @xmath35 are hamming measures , then @xmath445 and @xmath446 therefore , @xmath447 this idea of matching the lower and upper bounds in is not just useful for these simple examples . our main result , theorem [ thm : small - distortions ] , showed that it is also useful for sources with hamming distortions with small distortions .
the proof of this result is a simple consequence of corollary [ cor : thm : cr - rd ] .
let us recall gray s results for the extended shannon lower bounds of joint , conditional and marginal rd functions . specifically , from ( * ? ? ?
3.2 @xmath13 cor .
3.2 ) there exists a strictly positive surface @xmath216 in @xmath80 such that @xmath448 for all @xmath55 that lies on or below @xmath216 . combining this result with
proves the theorem .
the joint pmf @xmath82 of the dsbs can be thought of as resulting from using @xmath7 as a uniform input to a binary symmetric channel ( bsc ) with cross over probability @xmath175 , see figure [ fig : dsbs - pmf ] . by symmetry
, we can also think of @xmath82 resulting from using @xmath132 as a uniform input to a bsc with cross over probability @xmath175 .
.,title="fig:",width=321 ] + in example [ exa : dsbs ] , it was shown that the rd function without common reconstructions @xmath78 equals the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 .
since @xmath449 for all @xmath450 $ ] , we have that @xmath451 let @xmath452 and note that @xmath453 .
for any @xmath232 $ ] , we now construct a test channel @xmath129 that belongs to @xmath454 and @xmath455 .
.,title="fig:",width=453 ] + fix @xmath232 $ ] , and let @xmath456 note that @xmath457 , where @xmath458 is the binary convolution .
let @xmath459 .
we now define a joint pmf @xmath460 on @xmath461 by assuming a uniform input to the cascade of the four bscs shown in figure [ fig : dsbs - test - channel ] .
specifically , we set @xmath462 where @xmath463 for @xmath464 and @xmath465 and @xmath466 note that since @xmath467 is uniform we may equivalently view @xmath460 as resulting from using @xmath468 as a uniform input to the ( reverse ) cascade of four bscs shown in figure [ fig : dsbs - test - channel ] . by construction , the expected distortions @xmath469 $ ] and @xmath470 $ ] for this joint pmf are both equal to @xmath471 .
moreover , since @xmath457 and @xmath472 we have that @xmath473 and the joint pmf @xmath460 defines a valid channel in @xmath454 .
combining this channel with theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] yields @xmath474 where follows because @xmath475 and @xmath476 form a markov chains , and follows by construction . at @xmath477
, we have that @xmath478 the marginal rd functions of @xmath7 and @xmath132 are given by @xmath479 wyner showed that the common information of @xmath7 and @xmath132 is given by ( * ? ? ?
* eqn . 1.19 )
@xmath480 therefore , @xmath481 .
the @xmath155 that achieves the minimum for @xmath482 is the same as the @xmath155 in figure [ fig : dsbs - test - channel ] .
specifically , for @xmath477 we use @xmath483 .
suppose that @xmath484 .
if @xmath485 , then it is clear that @xmath486 .
moreover , it is optimal to choose @xmath487 with this choice of test channel , we have that @xmath488 forms a markov chain .
the next lemma shows that this chain is necessary for @xmath489 .
[ lem : dsbs - contradiction ] if @xmath489 , then the minimum @xmath490 is achieved by a test - channel @xmath491 for which the resultant joint pmf for @xmath420 factors to form the markov chain @xmath488 and @xmath492 .
suppose @xmath491 achieves the minimum in .
from the definition of conditional rate - distortion function , @xmath493 , the following is apparent @xmath494 similarly , @xmath495 if @xmath496 then from and and @xmath497 , we have @xmath498 then , we further have @xmath499 the non - negativity of conditional mutual information gives @xmath500 and therefore @xmath488 . the proof is completed by combining this chain with to get @xmath492 . the proof of will follow via a contradiction .
suppose there exists @xmath501 such that @xmath502 .
from theorem [ thm : dsbs - cr ] we have that @xmath503\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath129 be the test channel that achieves the indicated minimum , and consider the term @xmath167 in . from lemma [ lem : dsbs - contradiction ] , the joint pmf induced by @xmath129 and @xmath82 factors to form the markov chain @xmath488 ;
therefore , @xmath167 can be lower bounded by wyner s common information ( * ? ? ?
3 ) via @xmath504 we have @xmath505 , and from lemma [ lem : dsbs - contradiction ] we have @xmath492 . since @xmath506 is strictly decreasing on @xmath507 it follows that @xmath508 , which is equivalent to @xmath509 and by the above discussion @xmath510\ , \ ] ] which implies @xmath511 , which is a contradiction since @xmath512 is strictly increasing on @xmath513 $ ] .
we choose a channel @xmath129 that achieves the bound given in .
let @xmath514 , and define @xmath515 where @xmath516 and @xmath517 and @xmath518 are indicator functions ( equal one if the subscripts are equal and zero otherwise ) .
the channel @xmath519 is depicted in figure [ fig : fourinputchannel ] . .
the transitions represented by dotted lines each have probability @xmath520.,title="fig:",width=340 ] + set @xmath521 and @xmath522 .
note that @xmath523 are both bscs with a crossover probability @xmath471 .
therefore , @xmath469 = d$ ] and @xmath470=d$ ] .
finally , the rate of the channel is given by @xmath524\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] by symmetry , we also have @xmath525 , which completes the proof . the channel @xmath519 can be view as the natural continuation of the channel , which was used to prove . specifically , @xmath519 is formed by passing @xmath155 through a bsc with crossover probability @xmath526 .
this latter quantity is chosen because @xmath527
we now extend the source coding results of section [ sec:4 ] to the joint source - channel coding setting ( definitions [ def : jscc ] and [ def : jscc - cr ] ) .
we begin by proving theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] .
if @xmath55 is admissible with bandwidth expansion factor @xmath115 , then by definition there exists for every @xmath58 a joint source - channel code @xmath528 with @xmath529 , @xmath27 .
let @xmath530 denote the codeword that is produced by the encoder .
let @xmath531 denote the marginal pmf for the @xmath532 symbol @xmath533 .
define a new `` time - shared '' random variable @xmath534 on @xmath85 with pmf @xmath535 since @xmath536 is a concave function for fixed @xmath537 , we have from jensen s inequality @xmath538 we further have @xmath539\\ \label{eqn : bc : gerhard-1 } & \leq \sum_{i=1}^{\kappa_c t } \big [ h(u_i ) - h(u_i|w_i ) \big]\\ \label{eqn : bc : gerhard-2 } & = \sum_{i=1}^{\kappa_c t } i(w_i;u_i)\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where follows because @xmath540 forms a markov chain
. then we have @xmath541 where follows from the data - processing inequality , follows because @xmath164 is iid , follows from the data - processing inequality and the fact that @xmath542 is a function of @xmath543 , follows from the definition of the conditional rate - distortion function where @xmath544 , and combines jensen s inequality and the convexity of @xmath169 in @xmath153 , and follows because @xmath545 non - increasing in @xmath153 .
similarly , it can be shown that @xmath546 the theorem follows from the continuity of @xmath169 and @xmath417 on @xmath547 and the fact that @xmath58 is arbitrary .
we now adapt an achievability result of nayak , tuncel and g@xmath548nd@xmath548z @xcite to give a sufficient condition for joint source - channel coding . when combined with theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] , this condition will give necessary and sufficient conditions for joint source - channel coding of jointly gaussian random variables with squared - error distortion measures .
[ lem : nayak ] let @xmath315 be a finite set .
a distortion pair @xmath55 is admissible with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if the following conditions are satisfied : 1 .
there exist random variables @xmath155 on @xmath85 and @xmath357 on @xmath315 ; 2 .
there exist functions @xmath549 and @xmath550 with + [ eqn : nayak - distortion ] @xmath551 & \leq d_1\\ \mathbb{e}\big[\delta_2(y,\pi_2(c , x))\big ] & \leq d_2\ ; \end{aligned}\ ] ] 3 .
the following inequalities hold + @xmath552 lemma [ lem : nayak ] is the joint source - channel coding extension of the one - description upper bound given in lemma [ lem : one - description - upper ] .
the lemma is actually a special case of a stronger result ( * ? ? ?
1 ) ; however , this weaker result will suffice for the following discussion .
note also the markov constraints in ( * ? ? ?
* cor.1 ) do not play a role here as the side - information is available to the transmitter .
the next two corollaries combine theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] and lemma [ lem : nayak ] to give necessary and sufficient conditions for the following two special cases : @xmath241 the source @xmath82 has zero - rate loss in the wyner - ziv problem , and @xmath242 one source has to be reconstructed vanishing hamming distortion .
[ cor : jscc : zero - wz - rate - loss ] if @xmath82 has zero rate - loss in the wyner - ziv problem ( i.e. , @xmath553 and @xmath554 ) , then @xmath71 is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if and only if there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 such that holds .
as discussed before , the zero wyner - ziv rate - loss condition is very restrictive and few sources are known to satisfy it .
however , an interesting example that does satisfy this condition is given next .
if @xmath401 are jointly gaussian random variables @xmath34 and @xmath35 are squared error distortion measures ( see example [ exa : rd - bounds : exa:1gaussian ] ) , then @xmath71 is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if and only if there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 such that holds .
the conditional rd functions @xmath169 and @xmath417 are given in .
[ cor : jscc : one - lossless - reconstruction ] if @xmath34 is a hamming distortion measure , then @xmath555 is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath115 if and only if there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 such that @xmath556 the necessary condition ( `` only if '' ) is given by theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] . the sufficient condition ( ``
if '' ) is proved by constructing an auxiliary random variable @xmath357 that meets the conditions of lemma [ lem : nayak ] with @xmath557 and @xmath558 . recall that @xmath559 let @xmath560 and @xmath561 be joint pmfs on @xmath142 and @xmath562 that achieve the aforementioned minima .
let @xmath563 be the joint pmf on @xmath564 defined by @xmath565 by construction , the @xmath566 and @xmath567 marginals of @xmath563 are @xmath560 and @xmath561 , and @xmath563 satisfies the chain @xmath339 . recall that @xmath560 satisfies the chain @xmath144 , and @xmath561 satisfies the chain @xmath328 .
combining these chains yields the long chain @xmath335 .
set @xmath568 and @xmath569 .
note that @xmath357 is a valid auxiliary random variable for lemma [ lem : nayak ] .
moreover , we have @xmath570 where follows because @xmath335 implies @xmath342 , follows because @xmath560 is an optimal test channel for the wyner - ziv rd function , and follows by assumption .
similarly , we have @xmath558 .
the necessary condition ( `` only if '' ) is follows from theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] and @xmath248 .
the sufficient condition ( `` if '' ) is proved by constructing an auxiliary random variable @xmath357 that meets the conditions of lemma [ lem : nayak ] as well as @xmath571 and @xmath558 . recall the joint pmf of @xmath420 used to prove corollary [ thm : cr - rd : cor : onelossless ] . choose @xmath572 and note this choice of @xmath357 meets the conditions of lemma [ lem : nayak ] .
as before , we also have that @xmath573 and @xmath574 .
the sufficient condition is a special case of lemma [ lem : nayak ] .
we now give the necessary condition .
if a distortion pair @xmath71 is achievable with bandwidth expansion @xmath575 , then by definition there exists for every @xmath58 a cr - jsc code @xmath576 with @xmath577 as well as @xmath578 & \leq \epsilon_t \text { and}\\ \label{eqn : app - g : cr - error - prob-2 } \pr\big[\phi_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y } } ) \neq g_2^{(t)}({\mathbf{v}},{\mathbf{x}})\big ] & \leq \epsilon\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] as in the proof of theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] , let @xmath108 , let @xmath531 denote the pmf for the @xmath532 symbol @xmath533 , and define the time shared random variable @xmath534 on @xmath85 via @xmath535 we will show that @xmath579 for some test channel @xmath580 . the next inequality , which will be useful later , follows from fano s inequality @xcite and : @xmath581 where @xmath582 we first invoke the techniques used in the converse proof of theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] ; specifically , we have @xmath583 we now invoke the techniques used in the converse proof of theorem [ thm : cr - rd ] .
specifically , we have @xmath584\\ \label{eqn : app - g : s-2 } & \geq \frac{1}{t } i\big({\mathbf{x}};{\mathbf{u}},g_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y}}),\phi_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(t)}({\mathbf{v}},{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}}\big ) - \varepsilon(\kappa_s , t,\epsilon)\\
\label{eqn : app - g : s-3 } & \geq \frac{1}{t } i\big({\mathbf{x}};g_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(t)}({\mathbf{v}},{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}}\big ) - \varepsilon(\kappa_s , t,\epsilon)\\ & = \frac{1}{t } \sum_{j = 1}^{\kappa_s t } i\big(x_j;g_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(t)}({\mathbf{v}},{\mathbf{x}})\big|{\mathbf{y}},x_1^{j-1}\big ) - \varepsilon(\kappa_s , t,\epsilon)\\ & = \frac{1}{t } \sum_{j = 1}^{\kappa_s t } i\big(x_j;g_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(t)}({\mathbf{v}},{\mathbf{x}}),x_1^{j-1},y_1^{j-1},y_{j+1}^{\kappa_s t}\big|y_j\big ) - \varepsilon(\kappa_s , t,\epsilon)\\
\label{eqn : app - g : s-4 } & \geq \frac{1}{t } \sum_{j = 1}^{\kappa_s t } i\big(x_j;g_1^{(t)}({\mathbf{u}},{\mathbf{y}}),g_2^{(t)}({\mathbf{v}},{\mathbf{x}})\big|y_j\big ) - \varepsilon(\kappa_s , t,\epsilon)\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where follows because @xmath585 forms a markov chain , and follows from and @xmath586 a similar procedure yields @xmath587 for @xmath588 , let @xmath542 and @xmath589 denote the @xmath532 symbols of @xmath590 and @xmath591 , respectively .
let @xmath592 denote the conditional probability of @xmath391 given @xmath392 , and define @xmath593 the average distortion requirement on the code guarantees @xmath594 we further have @xmath595 where we have used jensen s inequality together with the convexity of @xmath399 and @xmath400 in @xmath129 .
thus , we have shown that there exists a condition pmf @xmath596 and a pmf @xmath597 such that @xmath598 the necessary condition follows from theorem [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] .
we now show that this necessary condition is also sufficient for small distortions . from theorem [ thm : jscc - cr ]
, a sufficient condition for @xmath71 to be achievable is that there exists a pmf @xmath156 on @xmath85 and @xmath580 such that holds .
choose @xmath580 to achieve the minimum in the definition of the joint rd function @xmath432 .
in a similar manner to the proof of corollary [ cor : thm : cr - rd ] , we have that @xmath599 from gray ( * ? ? ?
3.2 ) , there exists a strictly positive surface @xmath216 in @xmath121 such that @xmath600 and @xmath601 whenever @xmath57 lies on or below @xmath216 . for these small distortions
, we have that @xmath602 and @xmath603 .
the downlink broadcast channel of the two - way relay network was studied in the source coding and joint source - channel coding settings .
single - letter necessary and sufficient conditions for reliable communication were given for the following special cases : common - reconstructions ( theorems [ thm : cr - rd ] and [ thm : jscc - cr ] ) , small distortions ( theorems [ thm : small - distortions ] and [ thm : jscc - small - distortions ] ) , conditionally independent sources ( corollary [ thm : rd - bounds : cor : cond - ind ] ) , deterministic distortion measures ( corollary [ thm : rd - bounds : cor:2deterministic ] ) , and sources with zero rate - loss for the wyner - ziv problem @xcite .
additionally , the notion of small distortions was explicitly characterised for the doubly symmetric binary source with hamming distortion measures in theorem [ thm : dsbs - cr ] .
each of the aforementioned results followed , in part , from the necessary conditions presented in theorems [ thm : jscc - cut - set ] and [ thm : rd - bounds ] .
it remains to be verified that these necessary conditions are , or are not , sufficient .
more generally , the source coding problem is a special case of the wyner - ziv problem with two receivers @xcite , and the joint source - channel coding problem is a special case of the wyner - ziv coding over broadcast channels problem @xcite .
it would be interesting to see if the small distortion results in this paper carry over to these problems .
the authors are grateful to gottfried lechner , badri n. vellambi , terence chan and tobias oechtering for many interesting discussions on the contents of this paper .
in this section , we present an alternative to the cut - set lower bound @xmath172 given in theorem [ thm : rd - bounds ] ( see the end of section [ sec:4a ] ) . for this purpose ,
let @xmath138 , @xmath333 and @xmath315 be finite alphabets of cardinality @xmath604 denote the set of pmfs @xmath563 on @xmath138 @xmath332 @xmath333 @xmath332 @xmath315 @xmath332 @xmath9 @xmath332 @xmath15 where 1 .
@xmath605 forms a markov chain , i.e. , @xmath606 2 .
@xmath607 is independent of @xmath401 , i.e. , @xmath608 3 .
there exist functions + @xmath609 + such that + @xmath610 & \leq d_1 , \text { and}\\ \mathbb{e}_p\big[\delta_2\big(y,\pi_2(b , c , x)\big)\big ] & \leq d_2\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] define @xmath611\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the next theorem gives a lower bound for @xmath78 .
[ thm : rd*-lower - bound ] for @xmath71 we have that @xmath612 if @xmath359 is @xmath57-admissible , then there exists a monotonically decreasing sequence @xmath360 with limit zero ; a monotonically increasing sequence @xmath362 ; and a sequence of rd codes @xmath614 such that @xmath365 , @xmath366 and @xmath367 .
then we have @xmath615\\ \label{rd - converse-13 } & = \frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j=1}^{n_i}\big [ i(x_j;m|x_1^{j-1},{\mathbf{y } } ) + i(y_j;m|y_1^{j-1})\big]\\ \label{rd - converse-14 } & = \frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j=1}^{n_i}\big [ i(x_j;m , x_1^{j-1},y_1^{j-1},y_{j+1}^{n_i}|y_j ) + i(y_j;m , y_1^{j-1})\big]\\ \label{rd - converse-15 } & \geq \frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j=1}^{n_i}\big [ i(x_j;m , y_1^{j-1},y_{j+1}^{n_i}|y_j ) + i(y_j;m)\big]\\ \label{rd - converse-16 } & = \frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j=1}^{n_i}\big [ i(x_j;m|y_j ) + i(x_j;y_1^{j-1},y_{j+1}^{n_i}|m , y_j ) + i(y_j;m)\big]\\ \label{rd - converse-17 } & = \frac{1}{n_i}\sum_{j=1}^{n_i}\big [ i(x_j , y_j;m ) + i(x_j;y_1^{j-1},y_{j+1}^{n_i}|m , y_j ) \big]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where follows from the definition of a @xmath57-admissible rate , through follow from standard identities , follows because @xmath164 is i.i.d .
, through follows from standard identities . in a similar manner
, it can also be shown that @xmath616\ .\ ] ] for @xmath617 , define @xmath618 , @xmath619 , and @xmath620 .
we consider @xmath621 , @xmath622 , to be a class of disjoint sets .
similarly , we consider @xmath623 and @xmath624 to be disjoint sets . now define @xmath625 let @xmath626 denote the resultant joint pmf on @xmath627 @xmath332 @xmath628 @xmath332 @xmath629 @xmath332 @xmath9 @xmath332 @xmath15 that characterises the random variables @xmath630 , @xmath631 , @xmath632 , @xmath633 and @xmath634 . by construction
, we have 1 .
@xmath392 is independent of @xmath635 , i.e. @xmath636 2 .
there exists a function @xmath637 such that @xmath638 , 3 .
there exists a function @xmath639 such that @xmath640 .
now define @xmath641 , @xmath642 and @xmath643 , and the `` time - shared '' pmf @xmath644 on @xmath645 . using this definition
, it can be verified that @xmath646 furthermore , by definition , we have @xmath647\\ & = \mathbb{e}_{p^*}\big[\delta_1(x,\pi_1(a , c , y)\big]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last expectation is taken with respect to @xmath648 , and @xmath649 is defined by @xmath650 where @xmath651 is arbitrary .
similarly , @xmath652\ .\ ] ] at this point we have that @xmath653\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the infimum is taken over all @xmath648 satisfying @xmath654 as well as @xmath655\ \text { and}\\ d_2 + \epsilon_i & \geq \mathbb{e}_{p^*}\big[\delta_2(y,\pi_2(b , c , x))\big]\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] note the this infimum is not altered if we impose the markov chain @xmath605 .
finally , we apply the support lemma @xcite to bound the cardinality of @xmath315 by @xmath656 , and @xmath138 and @xmath333 by @xmath657 .
( @xmath658 and @xmath659 can be bounded simultaneously since @xmath605 forms a markov chain . )
enlarge the set @xmath661 by removing the constraints @xmath662 and @xmath605 @xmath663 $ ] .
denote this new set by @xmath664 .
then , @xmath665\\ \label{eqn : rd*-converse - b-1 } & \geq \min_{p \in { \mathscr{p}}_{l}^\dag(d_1,d_2 ) } \bigg [ i(x , y;c ) + \max \big\{i(x;a|c , y),\ i(y;b|c , x ) \big\ } \bigg]\\ & = \min_{p \in { \mathscr{p}}_{l}^\dag(d_1,d_2 ) } \max \big\{i(x , y;c ) + i(x;a|c , y),\ i(x , y;c ) + i(y;b|c , x ) \big\ } \bigg]\\ \label{eqn : rd*-converse - b-2 } & \geq \min_{p \in { \mathscr{p}}_{l}^\dag(d_1,d_2 ) } \max \big\{i(x;a , c|y),\ i(y;b , c|x ) \big\ } \bigg]\\ \label{eqn : rd*-converse - b-3 } & = \min_{p \in { \mathscr{p}}_{l}^\dag(d_1,d_2 ) } \max \big\{i(x;a , c , y|y),\ i(y;b , c , x|x ) \big\ } \bigg]\\ \label{eqn : rd*-converse - b-4 } & \geq \min_{p \in { \mathscr{p}}_{l}^\dag(d_1,d_2 ) } \max \big\{i(x;\pi_x(a , c , y)|y),\ i(y;\pi_y(b , c , x)|x ) \big\ } \bigg]\\ \label{eqn : rd*-converse - b-5 } & \geq \max \big\{r_{x|y}(d_1),\ r_{y|x}(d_2 ) \big\ } \\ \label{eqn : rd*-converse - b-6 } & \equiv r_{l}(d_1,d_2)\ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] where follows because @xmath666 , and follow from the chain rule for mutual information , follows the data processing inequality , follows from the definition of the conditional rate - distortion function , and follows from the definition of @xmath260 .
suppose @xmath607 is defined by a ( fixed ) joint pmf @xmath409 .
let @xmath667 and @xmath668 be two conditional pmfs for @xmath357 given @xmath607 .
for @xmath27 , let @xmath669 denote the resulting joint pmfs .
we identify the marginals of these pmfs with subscripts in the usual way ; for example , @xmath670 we wish to evaluate the conditional mutual information @xmath406 with respect the three conditional probabilities ] : @xmath667 , @xmath668 and @xmath678 .
in particular , the lemma will be proved if it can be shown that @xmath679 \geq i(a;c|b)[p^{*}_{c|ab}]\ , \ ] ] where @xmath680 $ ] should be understood as the conditional mutual information @xmath406 when the joint probability of @xmath403 is defined by @xmath409 and @xmath681 . for this purpose ,
we write @xmath406 explicitly as a function of @xmath681 : @xmath682 where the conditional probability @xmath683 is a function of the other arguments @xmath684 then we have @xmath685 & = \sum_{i=1}^2 \sum_{a , b , c } \alpha_i p_b(b ) p_{a|b}(a|b ) p^{(i)}_{c|ab}(c|a , b ) \log \frac{p^{(i)}_{c|ab}(c|a , b)}{p^{(i)}_{c|b}(c|b ) } \\ & = \sum_b p_b(b ) \sum_{i=1}^2 \alpha_i \sum_{a , c } p_{a|b}(a|b ) p^{(i)}_{c|ab}(c|a , b ) \log \frac{p^{(i)}_{c|ab}(c|a , b)}{p^{(i)}_{c|b}(c|b)}\\ & \geq \sum_b p_b(b ) \sum_{a , c } p_{a|b}(a|b ) p^{*}_{c|ab}(c|a , b ) \log \frac{p^{*}_{c|ab}(c|a , b)}{p^{*}_{c|b}(c|b ) } \\ & = i(a;c|b)\ [ p^*_{c|ab}]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the inequality follows from the convexity of mutual information in the channel for a fixed input distribution @xcite .
y. wu , p. a. chou , and s. y. kung , `` information exchange in wireless networks with network coding and physical - layer broadcast , '' in _ proceedings conference on information sciences and systems _ , the john hopkins university , baltimore , 2005 .
r. timo , l. ong , and g. lechner , `` the two - way relay network with arbitrarily correlated sources and an orthogonal mac , '' institute for telecommunications research , the university of south australia , tech .
november 2010 .
d. gndz , j. nayak , and e. tuncel , `` wyner - ziv coding over broadcast channels using hybrid digital / analog transmission , '' in _ proceedings ieee international symposium on information theory _ , toronoto , canada , 2008 , pp
. 15431547 . | the broadcast phase ( downlink transmission ) of the two - way relay network is studied in the source coding and joint source - channel coding settings .
the rates needed for reliable communication are characterised for a number of special cases including : small distortions , deterministic distortion measures , and jointly gaussian sources with quadratic distortion measures .
the broadcast problem is also studied with common - reconstruction decoding constraints , and the rates needed for reliable communication are characterised for all discrete memoryless sources and per - letter distortion measures .
rate distortion theory , joint source - channel coding , two - way relay network . |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.