article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
equal - sized hard spheres constitute probably the simplest example of a purely entropic material . in a hard - sphere system
there is no contribution to the internal energy @xmath1 from interparticle forces so that @xmath1 is a constant , at a fixed temperature .
minimising the free energy , @xmath2 , is thus simply equivalent to maximising the entropy @xmath3 .
consequently , the structure and phase behaviour of hard spheres is determined solely by entropy .
although the hard - sphere model was originally introduced as a mathematically simple model of atomic liquids@xcite recent work has demonstrated it usefulness as a basic model for complex fluids@xcite .
suspensions of submicron poly(methyl methacrylate ) or silica colloids , coated with a thin polymeric layer so that strong repulsions dominate the attractive dispersion forces between the colloidal cores , behave in many ways as hard spheres . in the last decade ,
a great deal of effort has been devoted to systematic studies of such colloidal ` hard - sphere ' systems@xcite . for sufficiently monodisperse colloids ,
crystallisation is observed at densities similar to those predicted by computer simulation for hard spheres@xcite .
measurements of the osmotic pressure and compressibility show a similar dramatic agreement with predicted hard sphere properties@xcite .
there is however one important and unavoidable difference between colloids and the classical hard sphere model which is frequently overlooked . whereas the spheres in the classical model are identically - sized ( _ i.e. _ monodisperse ) colloidal particles have an inevitable spread of sizes which is most conveniently characterised by the polydispersity , @xmath4 , defined as @xmath5 where @xmath6 with @xmath7 the density distribution and @xmath8 .
recent work has revealed that as soon as a hard sphere suspension is allowed to enjoy a significant degree of polydispersity , several interesting new phenomena arise .
experiments find that the crystallisation transition is suppressed altogether at @xmath9 while samples with @xmath10 crystallise only slowly in the coexistence region and not above the melting transition@xcite .
other examples of the effects of polydispersity are the appearance of a demixing transition in a polydisperse fluid of hard spheres@xcite and the observation of a liquid - vapour transition in polydisperse adhesive hard spheres@xcite . the effect of polydispersity on the crystallisation of hard sphere colloids has been investigated by computer simulation@xcite , density functional@xcite , and analytical theories@xcite .
the picture that emerges is remarkably consistent .
all calculations find that the fluid - solid phase transition vanishes for polydispersities above a certain critical level @xmath11 .
the phase diagram for small polydispersities ( @xmath12 ) has been rationalised @xcite in terms of the appearance of an additional high density crystal - to - fluid transition , in a polydisperse system . while , at low polydispersities hard spheres display , with increasing density , the conventional fluid - to - crystal transition , at higher polydispersities re - entrant behaviour is predicted .
the two freezing transitions converge to a single point in the @xmath13 plane which is a polydisperse analogue of the point of equal concentration found in molecular mixtures@xcite . at this singularity , the free energies of the polydisperse fluid and crystal phases are equal .
the purpose of this note is to examine the fate of a _
highly _ polydisperse ( @xmath14 ) hard sphere fluid .
previous theoretical research has not been able to identify a fluid - solid transition for @xmath14 so it is generally believed that the equilibrium phase is disordered at all densities up to close packing .
several years ago , pusey@xcite suggested that a highly polydisperse suspension might crystallise by splitting the broad overall distribution into a number of narrower distributions of polydispersity @xmath15 , each of which could be accommodated within a single crystalline phase .
each crystal would then have a correspondingly different mean size with the number of crystalline phases increasing with the overall polydispersity .
for fractionated crystallisation to occur the total free energy of the set of multiple crystals must be lower than that of the equivalent polydisperse fluid .
this can only happen if the reduction in free energy as particles are removed from a fluid and placed in a crystal is sufficiently large to exceed the loss of entropy of mixing as the distribution is partitioned .
this is a delicate balance and it is far from obvious where the result lies .
pusey , for instance , originally suggested that fractionation would generate crystals with a polydispersity of @xmath11 so as to minimise the number of crystal phases required and the subsequent loss of entropy of mixing .
however , as noted above , at @xmath11 the free energy of the polydisperse fluid and crystal phases are equal@xcite and so there is no driving force for fractionation . in earlier work@xcite the possibility of fractionated crystallisation for @xmath14
was considered but no conditions where two crystal phases could coexist could be found . here
we re - examine the stability of a polydisperse hard - sphere fluid using a much simpler approach .
rather than solving the equations of phase equilibria in a polydisperse system we restrict ourselves to the easier task of comparing the free energies , at the same density and temperature , of crystal and fluid phases .
we find , in agreement with pusey@xcite , that fractionation occurs in polydisperse hard sphere mixtures but that the polydispersity of the resulting crystals is substantially less than @xmath11 .
the rest of the paper is organised as follows : in section [ model ] we present our model for the free energies of the polydisperse fluid and crystal phases .
the stability diagram is present in section [ results ] .
finally , in section [ discussion ] we summarise and conclude .
our model consists of @xmath16 hard sphere particles in a volume @xmath17 , at an overall density of @xmath18 .
each particle has a diameter @xmath19 drawn from some overall distribution @xmath7 so that @xmath8 .
previous work has suggested@xcite that the thermodynamic properties of a polydisperse system are relatively insensitive to the detailed _ shape _ assumed for the diameter distribution , at least when the polydispersity is small ( @xmath20 ) .
indeed the phase behaviour has been found@xcite , to a rather good approximation , to be a function only of the first three moments of the diameter distribution , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and the normalised width @xmath4 . for a broad diameter distribution , higher moments will presumably also need to be considered .
consequently , the phase behaviour will become increasingly sensitive to the shape of the distribution assumed .
however we expect that the width of the distribution will still play an important if not the dominant role in determining the generic features of the phase behaviour of a polydisperse system .
since our concern here is with establishing these general features of the polydisperse phase diagram we have taken @xmath7 as a simple rectangular distribution , @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the mean diameter and the normalised width @xmath25 is related directly to the conventional polydispersity @xmath4 by @xmath26 .
it will prove convenient to choose as variables the mean diameter @xmath24 , the polydispersity @xmath4 and the volume fraction @xmath27 .
our first task is to calculate the thermodynamics of the fluid state . the free energy density ( @xmath28 )
may be conveniently split into ideal and excess portions @xmath29 the ideal part of the free energy density is given by a straightforward generalisation of the free energy of an ideal gas as @xmath30 with @xmath31 .
for the case of the rectangular distribution , the ideal free energy density is simply @xmath32 we calculate the excess free energy density , @xmath33 , of the polydisperse fluid from the general equation of state given by salacuse and stell@xcite .
this equation of state is a straightforward generalisation of the highly successful eos for an arbitrary hard sphere mixture@xcite first considered by mansoori _
the mansoori eos has been checked against simulation data by a number of authors and agreement is generally excellent .
the free energy per particle ( @xmath34 ) is then @xmath35 .
now we consider the free energy of the fractionated solid phase .
since as mentioned above , we expect the number of crystals to depend upon the overall polydispersity @xmath4 of the parent distribution , we consider the general case of @xmath36 coexisting crystals . in order to establish some relation between the parent distribution @xmath7 and the sub - distribution , @xmath37 , found in the @xmath38 crystal
we make two assumptions .
first we choose the distribution in each crystal to be rectangular and second , to keep the theory computationally manageable , we force the width ( or polydispersity ) to be equal in each of the @xmath36 coexisting phases . with these two restrictions
the housekeeping of the fractionation process is straightforward .
the @xmath38 crystal , for instance , contains all @xmath39 particles whose diameters lie between @xmath40 $ ] and @xmath41 $ ] with @xmath42 , the width of the crystal distribution , given by @xmath43 .
the mean diameter of particles in the @xmath38 crystal is then simply given as @xmath44 \label{meandiameter}\ ] ] and the polydispersity of each crystal is @xmath45 .
the diameter distribution in the @xmath38 crystal is then @xmath46 at an overall density of @xmath47 with @xmath48 the volume of the @xmath38 phase .
although the number of particles in each crystal phase is the same for all crystals and equal to @xmath49 ( since the polydispersity of each crystal is assumed equal ) the volume @xmath48 of each phase is so far undetermined . to fix the volume , or equivalently the number density @xmath50 , of each crystal we use the fact that the crystals are in equilibrium with each other
this constraint is straightforward to apply since , in our model of the partition , no particle may exist in anymore than one crystal .
consequently we do not need to consider exchange of particles .
equilibrium simply requires that the osmotic pressure of each crystal , @xmath51 , be fixed and equal to an external pressure of , say , @xmath52 @xmath53 with the density of each crystal phase determined , the total number density of the set of @xmath36 coexisting crystals is then @xmath54 and the corresponding composite packing fraction is @xmath55 .
the mean free energy per particle is @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the free energy density of the @xmath38 crystal . to complete our model for the fractionated phases we need an expression for the excess free energy of a polydisperse crystal .
for that purpose we use a scaled particle theory .
since the details have been described elsewhere@xcite we just outline the approach here .
the model exploits the picture of particles in a solid as being confined in cells or cages formed by the neighbours from which they can not escape . while , in a monodisperse crystal the cells are all identical , in a polydisperse crystal the size and shape of the cell varies .
the idea is to recognise that one can allow for the variability in the cell shape , to a first approximation , by considering just a finite number of different - sized neighbours .
the number of different - sized particles is determined by the accuracy with which the properties of the finite mixture approximate those of the polydisperse system .
if the excess free energy of the polydisperse system is a function of the first @xmath58 moments of the diameter distribution @xmath59 $ ] different - sized spheres are needed to match the diameter moments of the continuous distribution ( @xmath60 $ ] is the smallest integer not less than @xmath61 ) . for a polydisperse system of hard spheres , highly successful mean - field theories such as
the percus - yevick approximation suggest that only four diameter moments are significant@xcite . in this case , the properties of a polydisperse system should be well approximated by a binary mixture of spheres , chosen so that the first four moments of the polydisperse and binary distributions are equal .
the two diameter distributions are ` equivalent ' and all excess properties are , to a first approximation , equal . for the rectangular distribution
the equivalent binary distribution has an equal number of large and small spheres with diameters @xmath62 and @xmath63 respectively .
specifically then , we equate the excess free energy of the polydisperse crystal with that of an equivalent binary substitutional crystal .
for the evaluation of the latter we take advantage of the analytical expressions quoted by kranendonk and frenkel@xcite as fits to monte carlo simulation results . combining the excess free energy with the ideal free energy density , @xmath64 yields the free energy density @xmath57 of the @xmath38 crystal . finally , we note that our model for the polydisperse crystal implicitly assumes that all different - sized spheres are placed randomly on the sites of a common fcc lattice . at high polydispersities , the smallest particles in the distribution
could also be accommodated within the interstices of a crystal of larger particles .
the current calculations ignore this possibility and so are valid only for polydispersities of @xmath65 . putting everything together
, we now calculate the difference free energy per particle , @xmath66 , between the polydisperse fluid and the fractionated set of @xmath36 crystals as follows .
the overall particle density distribution of either the set of crystals or the polydisperse fluid is characterised by identical values for the overall volume fraction @xmath67 , the polydispersity @xmath4 and the mean diameter @xmath24 . for fixed @xmath68 , @xmath4 and @xmath24 , the free energy of the fluid @xmath69
is calculated from eqs .
[ fideal ] and the mansoori eos .
combining eqs .
[ constantp ] and [ effectiverho ] we see that the overall volume fraction @xmath67 of the solid phases ( or equivalently the mean density @xmath70 ) may be considered as a function of the osmotic pressure @xmath52 . inverting this relation yields the osmotic pressure @xmath52 and so , from eq
. [ constantp ] , the densities @xmath50 of each of the coexisting crystals which taken together have an overall volume fraction of @xmath67 . knowing the density , polydispersity @xmath71 and mean diameter @xmath72 ( from eq .
[ meandiameter ] ) of each crystal it is straightforward to calculate the corresponding free energy density @xmath57 and the mean free energy @xmath73 of the multiple crystals from eq . [ freesolid ] .
we now present in detail results for the stability of a system of polydisperse hard spheres obtained from the theory described above . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we show the free energy difference , @xmath74 , between the fractionated crystals and the fluid phase as a function of polydispersity , for the representative density of @xmath75 .
the first question to be addressed is the relative stability of the various fractionated crystals and the fluid phase . referring to fig .
[ fig1 ] , we see that for low levels of polydispersity , at this density , the crystal has a significantly lower free energy than the fluid phase . however , with increasing polydispersity , the stability of the polydisperse crystal reduces rapidly until for @xmath76 the unfractionated polydisperse crystal is unstable relative to the fluid phase .
the origin of this behaviour lies in the different ways polydispersity affects the maximum packing fraction , or equivalently the free volume , of ordered and disordered structures . in a fluid ,
smaller particles are free to pack in the cavities between larger particles and so the free volume and thus the entropy increases with polydispersity .
conversely , the periodicity of a crystal causes the free volume and entropy of a polydisperse crystal to decrease with increasing polydispersity .
consequently the free energy of a fixed - density polydisperse crystal will diverge at a critical level of polydispersity at which the fluid free energy will remain finite .
second , we note from fig . [ fig1 ] that at low polydispersities , fractionating the distribution into two or more crystals always raises the free energy of the solid state .
this is because of the loss of entropy of mixing as the diameter distribution is split up .
the contribution to the free energy difference , @xmath74 , due to the loss of entropy of mixing is simply : @xmath77 for fractionation into @xmath36 crystal phases which is very close to the differences seen in fig .
[ fig1 ] as @xmath78 .
however at finite polydispersities , eq .
[ mixing ] , does not give a reasonable estimate of the free energy differences between the various sets of crystals .
as is evident , the free energy @xmath74 reduces with increasing polydispersity . the reduction being smaller as the number of crystals considered increases
this is because the polydispersity of each fractionated crystal drops as the total number of crystals , between which the overall distribution is split , increases . for instance , fractionating a distribution with a polydispersity of 6% between two phases would result in crystals with 3% polydispersity , three phases would lead to 2% polydispersity and so on . as the polydispersity of each of the individual crystals decreases
the influence of the divergence of the free energy at the close - packing limit is reduced and so the free energy is less affected by the overall polydispersity . as a consequence the fractionated two - crystal phase takes the place of the polydisperse single - phase crystal , as the state of lowest free energy , for @xmath79 and remains the most stable phase until @xmath80 , at which point the fluid appears . by a procedure similar to that described above , we have mapped out the range of stability of the polydisperse hard sphere system for @xmath81 .
our results are shown in fig .
the regions are labelled by the number of coexisting crystals which minimise the total free energy of the polydisperse system while the boundaries indicate the specific densities and polydispersities at which competing phases have equal free energies . as is evident , there are appreciable areas of density and polydispersity where fractionation into multiple crystals is predicted . at low volume fractions , @xmath82 ,
the polydisperse fluid is the most stable phase at all polydispersities .
however with an increase in packing fraction a crystalline phase takes the place of the polydisperse fluid as the most stable phase .
the nature of the crystalline phase depends on the magnitude of the polydispersity @xmath4 .
so while for @xmath83 we have crystallisation into the usual single polydisperse crystal , with increasing polydispersity the fluid fractionates upon solidification into a rapidly increasing number of crystals .
the diagram gets more and more complicated as the polydispersity grows since , by necessity , the number of crystalline phases required to accommodate the increasing width of the diameter distribution increase .
so while for polydispersities in the range @xmath84 two fractionated crystals are first formed , three crystals are required for @xmath85 , four for @xmath86 , five for @xmath87 while at @xmath88 complete crystallisation requires six different crystal phases .
furthermore , we note that as the polydispersity increases the packing fraction at which the fluid becomes unstable increases from @xmath89 at @xmath90 to @xmath91 at @xmath88 .
the degree of fractionation predicted varies with the overall level of polydispersity . referring to fig .
[ fig3 ] , we see that the polydispersity of the crystal(s ) at the fluid - solid boundary reaches a maximum of 0.085 before on average falling with increasing fluid polydispersity , although in a far from continuous fashion . where fractionation occurs , fig
. [ fig3 ] reveals that the polydispersity of each crystal formed is considerably lower than the critical polydispersity , estimated here as @xmath92 .
in addition to the fluid - multiple crystal transitions discussed above , fig .
[ fig2 ] reveals that there is a further sequence of demixing transitions in the solid phase .
compressing a polydisperse crystal causes a solid - state phase separation in which the diameter distribution is fractionated .
for instance a polydisperse crystal with @xmath93 is stable up to a density of @xmath94 . at this point
the system separates into two crystals , each of polydispersity @xmath95 , which are stable until a total density of @xmath96 is reached .
further compression results in three crystals , followed at still high densities by a cascade of demixing transitions .
the explanation for this behaviour lies in the effect of polydispersity on the limiting packing fraction of a crystal . as mentioned previously
, the density at which the free energy of a polydisperse crystal starts to diverge reduces with increasing polydispersity . as a polydisperse crystal
is compressed there comes a point at which the reduction in the excess free energy which occurs when the polydispersity is reduced is sufficient to exceed the increase in the ideal free energy of mixing after fractionation . at this point the crystal phase separates .
finally , we emphasise that we have calculated only the stability boundaries , not the full equilibrium phase diagram of a system of polydisperse spheres .
the reason for this is that a full calculation of the phase equilibria , particularly in view of the large number of competing phases found in this work , would be a large and complicated problem .
however we expect our stability diagram ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) to be a useful guide to the form of the phase diagram . confirmation of this point of view is provided by the comparison , seen in fig .
[ fig4 ] , between the current model and the fluid - single crystal coexistence region established in earlier work@xcite .
the dashed curves indicate the positions of the polydisperse cloud - point boundaries and were calculated by a novel moment projection method using , as input , polydisperse free energies similar to those described above . referring to fig .
[ fig4 ] , we see that the stability boundary lies approximately midway between the two coexistence densities .
inspection of fig .
[ fig4 ] reveals , rather intriguingly , that the polydisperse point of equal concentration , marked by the large circle in fig .
[ fig4 ] , is practically coincident with the lowest density at which the binary system of fractionated crystals is stable .
this seems to be a chance occurrence .
however , the proximity of the two points suggests that , at equilibrium , the re - entrant melting predicted in ref .
@xcite will in fact be pre - empted by a solid state phase separation .
we have analysed the stability of a polydisperse fluid of hard spheres with respect to a process of simultaneous fractionation and crystallisation .
although the model is quite simple we find several interesting features .
in particular , we predict that for a sufficiently polydisperse system of hard spheres fractionation occurs upon solidification .
the fluid diameter distribution separates into a number of fractions of narrower polydispersity which then crystallise .
furthermore , we find that compressing a polydisperse crystal induces a sequence of demixing transitions in the crystal . to keep the theory presented here manageable we have been forced to make a number of assumptions .
we have , for instance , imposed a somewhat arbitrary model for the fractionation process .
in particular we have assumed that a rectangular diameter distribution fractionates into a number of equal - width daughter distributions , each of which is also rectangular in form . in principle
, we could relax the constraint of equal width .
however , since the densities of the coexisting crystals are similar it seems likely that this modification would have little effect .
the more critical restriction is probably the assumption made for the form of the daughter distribution .
however , in view of the relative insensitivity of polydisperse systems to the detailed form chosen for the diameter distribution , we expect that the current predictions will be in at least qualitative if not quantitative agreement with more rigorous calculations , when available .
we now speculate briefly on the feasibility of observing solid - state fractionation in experiments on hard - sphere colloids .
the first point to note is that fractionation requires colloid diffusion over distances comparable to the size of the growing crystallite .
the rate of such large scale diffusive motion reduces with increasing colloid density , as a result of caging effects , and essentially vanishes at the glass transition density , @xmath97@xcite . for uniformly - sized hard spheres
simulations@xcite find a long - lived metastable glassy state around @xmath98 which persists up to the random close packing limit at @xmath99 .
the glass transition in a system of polydisperse hard spheres has not been studied to the best of our knowledge although schaertl and silescu@xcite have estimated @xmath100 as a function of polydispersity from simulation . assuming a simple linear relationship between the two densities gives a crude estimate of the glass transition density as @xmath101 . referring to fig .
[ fig4 ] , we see that if this estimate for the glass transition is used , then fractionated crystallisation might be experimentally observable for polydispersities in the narrow range @xmath102 where diffusive motion is still possible although slow . if conversely , the dynamics of the fractionation process turn out to be appreciably slower than the experimental timeframe then experiments should follow our earlier predictions@xcite and exhibit a polydisperse point of equal concentration
. a clear resolution of this ambiguity must await experiment .
finally , our results suggest a possible explanation for the apparently anomalous simulations reported by bolhuis and kofke@xcite .
in contrast with other theoretical work , this study found that : ( i ) the particle size distributions in the fluid and crystal phases were significantly different and ( ii ) that the coexistence region although initially narrowing with increasing polydispersity finally widened .
the phase diagram was traced out by integrating along the fluid - crystal coexistence line .
implicit in this approach is the assumption that only one crystalline phase exists at the fluid - solid boundary . referring to fig .
[ fig2 ] , we envisage that at the point where two polydisperse crystals become stable the simulation will follow one of the two fluid - solid branches until it halts at the discontinuity marking the start of the three - crystal region . with this picture in mind , we may readily account for the observation that at the point , where the simulation could no longer follow the fluid - solid boundary , the crystal polydispersity was almost exactly half that of the fluid value . at the same time
, we note that their limiting polydispersity ( @xmath103 ) lies close to our estimate for the highest polydispersity ( 0.117 ) at which two polydisperse crystals remain the equilibrium phase . | we consider the nature of the fluid - solid phase transition in a polydisperse mixture of hard spheres . for a sufficiently polydisperse mixture
( @xmath0 ) crystallisation occurs with simultaneous fractionation . at the fluid - solid boundary ,
a broad fluid diameter distribution is split into a number of narrower fractions , each of which then crystallise .
the number of crystalline phases increases with the overall level of polydispersity . at high densities , freezing is followed by a sequence of demixing transitions in the polydisperse crystal . |
polyelectrolyte ( pe ) solutions are systems widely studied since they show properties that are of fundamental interest for applications in health science , food industry , water treatment , surface coatings , oil industry , among other fields .
in fact , one of the problems found in genetic engineering in the appearance of conformational changes of the adn molecule , which is a charged polyelectrolyte.@xcite .
+ here we study an infinite dilution polyelectrolyte solution , so that , the interaction among polyelectrolyte macromolecules are negligible .
we model the polyelectrolyte as having dissociable functional groups that give rise to charged sites and counter - ions in aqueous solution .
the long range interactions arising from these multiple charges are responsible for their macroscopic complex properties , which can not be explained by regular polymer theories .
the spatial structures of these materials in solution have been studied extensively , particularly with a scaling theory@xcite that are not appropriate for highly charged pe .
the first simulations carried out for a single chain predicted the formation of groups of monomers , as the fraction of charged monomers increased .
such structures are known as pearl necklaces .
the size of such pearls and the distance between then is determined by the balance between the electrostatic repulsion and steric effects .
+ these pearl necklace structures have also been found in molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations@xcite . in this paper
we are interested in the application of the much simpler cellular automata simulation to characterize the main features of a polyelectrolyte that could be responsible for such conformations .
the complete simulation of this complex system requires the description of a model in terms of potential or forces . in the md simulations of limbach and holm @xcite ,
the monomers are connected along the chain by the finite extendible nonlinear elastic ( fene ) bond represented by the potential energy .
@xmath0 where @xmath1 is the distance between two bonded monomers , @xmath2 , is the elastic bond constant , @xmath3 is the monomer diameter , @xmath4 is boltzmann s constant , @xmath5 is the absolute temperature and the parameter @xmath6 represents the maximum extension of the bond between two neighbor monomers .
two charged sites i and j , with charges @xmath7 and @xmath8 , a distance @xmath9 apart , interact with the electrostatic coulomb potential @xmath10 this potential is weighed by the bjerrum length @xmath11 $ ] , where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the solvent permitivity and the vacuum permitivity respectively , @xmath14 is the electric charge unit .
the parameter @xmath15 is a measure of the strength of the electrostatic force as compared to the kinetic energy .
the length ratio @xmath16 is a measure of the reduced temperature @xmath17 $ ] .
the short range and van der waals interaction between any two particles or monomers is represented in the md simulation by a typical truncated lennard - jones potential @xmath18 + \epsilon_{cut } & r_{ij } < r_{c},\\ 0 & r_{ij } > r_{c } \end{array}\right.\ ] ] where @xmath19 is the potential energy well depth and @xmath20 is the cut off energy .
this potential prevents the superposition of the bonding monomers .
counter - ions interact via a purely repulsive lj interaction with @xmath21 .
even though in the cellular automata simulation we do not use any form of potential energies or forces in an explicit manner , the _ rules _ for the movement of the different particles must be inspired on a model defined in terms of such potentials .
we therefore establish our rules based on the essence of the previous three potentials .
+ the polymer is constructed by placing the monomers in a three dimensional cubic network of side @xmath22 and volume @xmath23 .
each cell then has @xmath24 neighbors and represents a monomer with a monovalent charge @xmath25 , @xmath26 , or , for a neutral monomer , @xmath27 , as depicted in fig.(1 ) in two dimensions . out of a total of @xmath28 monomers in the chain
, it is assumed that a given fraction @xmath29 is charged .
the polymer is then constructed by randomly binding consecutive sites in the network .
each monomer could be charged or uncharged , with a distribution chosen randomly .
a key step on the construction of the polyion is the spatial location of the dissociated counter - ions .
we place the counter - ions also randomly in free cells in the volume around the charged monomer within a distance @xmath15 , that is , in a volume @xmath30 centered on the charged site .
the use of the bjerrum parameter , which is related to the quality of the solvent , ensures the conservation of the total electroneutrality but gives a spatial distribution of counter - ions around the charged sites .
+ so , each monomer @xmath31 of the system is represented in a @xmath32 matrix where each element @xmath33 indicates the @xmath34 polymer with charge @xmath35 , that could be @xmath36 or @xmath27 , at the positions @xmath37 given by the cell label @xmath38 $ ] . the counter - ions with opposite charge
are represented by a similar @xmath39 matrix @xmath40 .
+ for simplicity we chose monomers with dissociable groups that give a site with a positive charge .
we then set the following displacement rules for the different particles : + * _ neutral monomer particle _ * 1 .
locate the unoccupied nearest neighbor sites .
the new position where a move could be acceptable are those where it does not superimposed with any other particle in the system and where no bond is broken .
2 . count the amount of monomer particles around the current position and around every unoccupied neighbor , within a cube of volume @xmath41 centered on it .
3 . move the test neutral monomer to the position that has the higher amount of monomers around it , including the current one if it were the case .
* _ positively charged monomer particle _ * 1 . as before ,
locate the unoccupied acceptable nearest neighbor sites .
2 . count the amount of charge around the current position and around every unoccupied neighbor , within a cube of volume @xmath30 centered on it .
3 . move the test positive charged monomer to the position that has the lowest positive charge around it , including the current one if it were the case . *
_ negatively charged counter - ion _ * 1 .
move randomly to an unoccupied site within a cube of volume @xmath30 centered on the accepted new position of the corresponding positive monomer in the polymeric chain .
we denote the position of monomer i with @xmath42 and the distance between two particles i and j with @xmath43 .
the center of mass for the chain is then @xmath44 . and the center of mass coordinates are @xmath45 .
a parameter that is useful in the study of the spatial conformations of a polymer is the radius of gyration @xmath46 , defined as @xmath47 according with our construction and movement rules , we can vary the length of the chain @xmath22 , or the number of monomers @xmath28 , satisfying @xmath48 and the number of charged monomers , @xmath49 .
we also take as an independent variable the parameter @xmath15 , which determines the number of cells , of size @xmath3 , where the range of the electrostatic attraction between a charged monomer and contra - ion extends .
the charge distribution of the sequence of charged and uncharged monomers is determined randomly depending on the initial random seed .
+ in fig.(2 ) we show some of the equilibrium conformations obtained for a polyelectrolyte with @xmath50 monomers , with @xmath51 , for several charge fractions .
the line represents the polyelectrolyte , the filled black bonded circles represent the charged monomers .
the counter - ions in solution are represented by open non - bonded circles . for clarity ,
the neutral monomers are not shown .
for a low charge fraction of @xmath52 , the polyion presents an elongated string appearance . as the charge fraction
is increased the polyion contracts and some groups of monomers tend to form clusters , so that , already for @xmath53 , it shows the locally collapsed structures known as pearl necklace .
these results are very similar to those obtained by the molecular dynamics simulations of limbach and holm @xcite + it is important to notice that for a given total charge , determined by the fraction @xmath29 , different distributions of the charged monomers give different conformations . to study this behavior ,
we have carried out simulations with several initial seeds for @xmath50 monomers , with a fixed fraction @xmath53 and a range parameter of @xmath54 . in fig.(3 ) , we show the temporal evolution of the radius of gyration @xmath55 . in all cases the conformations change from the initial given @xmath55 value to a plateau value that correspond to the equilibrium structures .
fig.(3 ) clearly show that the plateau @xmath55 values , and thence , the final conformations depend on the charge distribution . in fig.(4 ) we show snapshots of final structures corresponding with the different seeds of fig.(3 ) . + as we can see from fig.(4 ) , the formation of the pearl necklace structures is independent of the charge sites distribution , for a given @xmath29 and @xmath15 .
these clusters seem to be stabilized by the counter - ions as a consequence of the electroneutrality condition that we force to be satisfied .
this is so because in our model the degree of freedom of the mobile counter - ions is much higher that that of the monomers tied to the chain .
the strong repulsions that originate by the formation of clusters of neutral and positively charged monomers is compensated by the counter - ion cloud that forms around it . in order to study the reproducibility of the configurations found , we carried out a large number of simulation runs , for fixed values of @xmath56 , @xmath53 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 and for the same initial charge distribution . in fig.(5 ) we show the histograms for the frequency with which a given value of @xmath55 appears .
we can see that the distribution of the @xmath55 is very closely a gaussian with a reasonably low dispersion of less than a @xmath59 about the mean value .
+ in fig.(5b ) we can see that similar distribution is obtained when the range parameter @xmath60 increases to a value of @xmath58 .
we have further tested the effect of the parameter @xmath15 by generating structures for different values of it . in fig.(6 ) we show some equilibrium conformations for @xmath60 equal to a ) 3,b ) 6,c ) 9 and d ) 12 .
here we use a large charge fraction @xmath53 and @xmath50 and we used the same initial charge distributions in all cases .
as we can observe as bjerrum length increases the final polyelectrolyte structures become more compact .
the number or pearls or conglomerates is higher for the lower values of @xmath15 , a result similar to that obtained by md simulations of limbach y holm @xcite-@xcite
with the simple technique described here , we were able to reproduce the complex structure of model polyelectrolytes that fare very well with those predicted by the more sophisticated molecular dynamic and monte carlo simulations@xcite .
we even predict situations with single conglomerates and with pearl necklace type conglomerates .
we thus show the potentiality of the celular automata in the simulation of the trends in the formation of the various types of spatial conformations of polyelectrolytes .
we remark on the importance of the charge distribution once the fractional charge is fixed .
this work was supported in part by the grant 04 - 005 - 01 from the decanato de investigacin of universidad nacional experimental del tchira , in part by the grant g-9700741 of fonacyt , and in part by the grant c-1279 - 0402-b from consejo de desarrollo cientco humanstico y tecnolgico of universidad de los andes .
+ numerical calculations were carried out at the computer center cecalcula .
+ 25 a.v .
dobrynin , r.h .
colby and m. rubinstein,_macromolecules _ , * 28*,1859,(1995 ) .
a. v. dobrynin ; m. rubinstein ; s. p. obukhok,_macromolecules_,*29*,2974,(1996 ) . y. yasmasaki , y. teramoto , and k. yoshikawa,_biophys .
j._,*80*,2974,(2001 ) .
h. j. limbach y c. holm,_j .
b_,*107*,8041 - 8055,(2003 ) .
u. micka ; c. holm ; k. kremer,_langmuir_,*15*,4033,(1999 ) . u. micka ; k. kremer,_europhys .
lett._,*49*,189 - 195,(2000 ) . h.
j. limbach y c. holm , _ j. chem .
phys._,*114*,9674 - 9682,(2002 ) .
h. j. limbach y c. holm,_comput .
commun._,*147*,321 - 324,(2002 ) . h.
j. limbach y c. holm ; k. kremer , _
j. phys : condens .
matter_,*15*,s205-s211,(2003 ) . h. j. limbach y c. holm ; k. kremer , _ europhys .
lett._,*60*,566 - 572,(2002 ) . | resumen + + abstract + . + |
) ( e ) 2-wasserstein distance.,width=291 ] -.5 cm comparing , summarizing and reducing the dimensionality of empirical probability measures defined on a space @xmath0 are fundamental tasks in statistics and machine learning .
such tasks are usually carried out using pairwise comparisons of measures .
classic information divergences @xcite are widely used to carry out such comparisons . unless @xmath0 is finite , these divergences can not be directly applied to empirical measures , because they are ill - defined for measures that do not have continuous densities . they also fail to incorporate prior knowledge on the geometry of @xmath0 , which might be available
if , for instance , @xmath0 is also a hilbert space .
both of these issues are usually solved using @xcite s approach @xcite to smooth empirical measures with smoothing kernels before computing divergences : the euclidean @xcite and @xmath1 distances @xcite , the kullback - leibler and pearson divergences @xcite can all be computed fairly efficiently by considering matrices of kernel evaluations .
the choice of a divergence defines implicitly the _ mean _ element , or barycenter , of a set of measures , as the particular measure that minimizes the sum of all its divergences to that set of target measures @xcite .
the goal of this paper is to compute efficiently barycenters ( possibly in a constrained subset of all probability measures on @xmath0 ) defined by the _ optimal transport distance _ between measures @xcite .
we propose to minimize directly the sum of optimal transport distances from one measure ( the variable ) to a set of fixed measures by gradient descent .
these gradients can be computed for a moderate cost by solving smoothed optimal transport problems as proposed by @xcite .
wasserstein distances have many favorable properties , documented both in theory @xcite and practice @xcite .
we argue that their versatility extends to the barycenters they define .
we illustrate this intuition in figure [ fig : nines ] , where we consider 30 images of nested ellipses on a @xmath2 grid .
each image is a discrete measure on @xmath3 ^ 2 $ ] with normalized intensities .
computing the euclidean , gaussian rkhs mean - maps or jeffrey centroid of these images results in mean measures that hardly make any sense , whereas the 2-wasserstein mean on that grid ( defined in [ subsec : defbaryc ] ) produced by algorithm [ algo : discwass ] captures perfectly the structure of these images .
note that these results were recovered without any prior knowledge on these images other than that of defining a distance in @xmath3 ^ 2 $ ] , here the euclidean distance .
note also that the gaussian kernel smoothing approach uses the same distance , in addition to a bandwidth parameter @xmath4 which needs to be tuned in practice .
this paper is organized as follows : we provide background on optimal transport in [ sec : back ] , followed by the definition of wasserstein barycenters with motivating examples in [ sec : baryc ] .
novel contributions are presented from [ sec : computing ] : we present two subgradient methods to compute wasserstein barycenters , one which applies when the support of the mean measure is known in advance and another when that support can be freely chosen in @xmath0 .
these algorithms are very costly even for measures of small support or histograms of small size .
we show in [ sec : smooth ] that the key ingredients of these approaches the computation of primal and dual optimal transport solutions can be bypassed by solving smoothed optimal transport problems .
we conclude with two applications of our algorithms in [ sec : exp ] .
let @xmath0 be an arbitrary space , @xmath5 a metric on that space and @xmath6 the set of borel probability measures on @xmath0 .
for any point @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the dirac unit mass on @xmath9 . for @xmath10 and probability measures
@xmath11 in @xmath6 , their @xmath12-wasserstein distance @xcite is @xmath13where @xmath14 is the set of all probability measures on @xmath15 that have marginals @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
we will only consider empirical measures throughout this paper , that is measures of the form @xmath18 where @xmath19 is an integer , @xmath20 and @xmath21 lives in the probability simplex @xmath22 , @xmath23 let us introduce additional notations : * measures on a set @xmath24 with constrained weights .
* let @xmath25 be a non - empty closed subset @xmath25 of @xmath22 .
we write @xmath26**measures supported on up to @xmath27 points . * * given an integer @xmath27 and a subset @xmath25 of @xmath28 , we consider the set @xmath29 of measures of @xmath0 that have discrete support of size up to @xmath27 and weights in @xmath25 , @xmath30 when no constraints on the weights are considered , namely when the weights are free to be chosen anywhere on the probability simplex , we use the shorter notations @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
consider two families @xmath33 and @xmath34 of points in @xmath0 .
when @xmath18 and @xmath35 , the wasserstein distance @xmath36 between @xmath16 and @xmath17 is the @xmath37 root of the optimum of a network flow problem known as the _ transportation problem _ @xcite .
this problem builds upon two elements : the _ * matrix * _ @xmath38 _ * of pairwise distances * _ between elements of @xmath24 and @xmath39 raised to the power @xmath12 , which acts as a cost parameter , @xmath40_{ij } \in\mathbb{r}^{n\times m},\ ] ] and the _ * transportation polytope * _ @xmath41 of @xmath42 and @xmath43 , which acts as a feasible set , defined as the set of @xmath44 nonnegative matrices such that their row and column marginals are equal to @xmath45 and @xmath46 respectively .
writing @xmath47 for the @xmath19-dimensional vector of ones , @xmath48 let @xmath49 be the frobenius dot - product of matrices .
combining eq .
& , we have that @xmath50the distance @xmath36 raised to the power @xmath12can be written as the optimum of a parametric linear program @xmath51 on @xmath44 variables , parameterized by the marginals @xmath52 and a ( cost ) matrix @xmath38 : @xmath53
we present in this section the wasserstein barycenter problem , a variational problem involving all wasserstein distances from one to many measures , and show how it encompasses known problems in clustering and approximation . a wasserstein barycenter of @xmath54 measures @xmath55 in @xmath56 is a minimizer of @xmath57 over @xmath58 , where @xmath59 @xcite consider more generally a non - negative weight @xmath60 in front of each distance @xmath61 .
the algorithms we propose extend trivially to that case but we use uniform weights in this work to keep notations simpler .
we highlight a few special cases where minimizing @xmath57 over a set @xmath58 is either trivial , relevant to data analysis and/or has been considered in the literature with different tools or under a different name . in
what follows @xmath62 and @xmath63 are arbitrary finite subsets of @xmath0 .
* @xmath64 * when only one measure @xmath17 , supported on @xmath63 is considered , its closest element @xmath16 in @xmath65if no constraints on weights @xmath45 are given can be computed by defining a weight vector @xmath45 on the elements of @xmath24 that results from assigning all of the mass @xmath66 to the closest neighbor in metric @xmath5 of @xmath67 in @xmath24 . + * centroids of histograms * : @xmath68 finite , @xmath69 .
when @xmath0 is a set of size @xmath70 and a matrix @xmath71 describes the pairwise distances between these @xmath70 points ( usually called in that case bins or features ) , the @xmath72-wasserstein distance is known as the earth mover s distance ( emd ) @xcite . in that context
, wasserstein barycenters have also been called emd prototypes by @xcite . *
euclidean @xmath0 * : @xmath73 , @xmath74 . minimizing @xmath57 on @xmath75
when @xmath76 is a euclidean metric space and @xmath77 is equivalent to the @xmath27-means problem @xcite .
* constrained @xmath27-means * : @xmath73 , @xmath78 .
consider a measure @xmath17 with support @xmath63 and weights @xmath43 .
the problem of approximating this measure by a uniform measure with @xmath27 atoms a measure in @xmath79in @xmath80-wasserstein sense was to our knowledge first considered by @xcite , who proposed a variant of @xcite s algorithm @xcite for that purpose .
more recently , @xcite remarked that such an approximation can be used in the resampling step of particle filters and proposed in that context two ensemble methods inspired by optimal transport , one of which reduces to a single iteration of @xcite s algorithm .
such approximations can also be obtained with kernel - based approaches , by minimizing an information divergence between the ( smoothed ) target measure @xmath17 and its ( smoothed ) uniform approximation as proposed recently by @xcite and @xcite .
@xcite consider conditions on the @xmath81 s for a wasserstein barycenter in @xmath6 to be unique using the multi - marginal transportation problem .
they provide solutions in the cases where either ( i ) @xmath82 ; ( ii ) @xmath83 using @xcite s interpolant @xcite ; ( iii ) all the measures @xmath81 are gaussians in @xmath84 , in which case the barycenter is a gaussian with the mean of all means and a variance matrix which is the unique positive definite root of a matrix equation ( * ? ? ?
* eq.6.2 ) .
@xcite were to our knowledge the first to consider practical approaches to compute wasserstein barycenters between point clouds in @xmath85 .
to do so , @xcite propose to approximate the wasserstein distance between two point clouds by their _ sliced _
wasserstein distance , the expectation of the wasserstein distance between the projections of these point clouds on lines sampled randomly . because the optimal transport between two point clouds on the real line can be solved with a simple sort
, the sliced wasserstein barycenter can be computed very efficiently , using gradient descent .
although their approach seems very effective in lower dimensions , it may not work for @xmath86 and does not generalize to non - euclidean metric spaces .
we propose in this section new approaches to compute wasserstein barycenters when ( i ) each of the @xmath54 measures @xmath81 is an empirical measure , described by a list of atoms @xmath87 of size @xmath88 , and a probability vector @xmath66 in the simplex @xmath89 ; ( ii ) the search for a barycenter is not considered on the whole of @xmath6 but restricted to either @xmath90 ( the set of measures supported on a predefined finite set @xmath24 of size @xmath19 with weights in a subset @xmath25 of @xmath91 ) or @xmath29 ( the set of measures supported on up to @xmath27 atoms with weights in a subset @xmath25 of @xmath28 ) .
looking for a barycenter @xmath16 with atoms @xmath24 and weights @xmath45 is equivalent to minimizing @xmath57 ( see eq .
[ eq : primal ] for a definition of @xmath51 ) , @xmath92 over relevant feasible sets for @xmath45 and @xmath24 . when @xmath24 is _ fixed _
, we show in [ subsec : dualityconvexity ] that @xmath57 is convex w.r.t @xmath45 regardless of the properties of @xmath0 .
a subgradient for @xmath57 w.r.t @xmath45 can be recovered through the _ dual optimal solutions _ of all problems @xmath93 , and @xmath57 can be minimized using a projected subgradient method outlined in
[ subsec : xrestricted ] .
if @xmath24 is _ free _ , constrained to be of cardinal @xmath27 , and @xmath0 and its metric @xmath5 are both _ euclidean _ , we show in [ subsec : xeuclidean ] that @xmath57 is not convex w.r.t @xmath24 but we can provide subgradients for @xmath57 using the _ primal optimal solutions _ of all problems @xmath93 .
this in turn suggests an algorithm to reach a local minimum for @xmath57 w.r.t .
@xmath45 and @xmath24 in @xmath29 by combining both approaches . *
dual transportation problem . * given a matrix @xmath95 , the optimum @xmath96 admits the following dual linear program ( lp ) form ( * ? ? ?
* , 7.8 ) , known as the dual optimal transport problem : @xmath97 where the polyhedron @xmath98 of dual variables is @xmath99 by lp duality , @xmath100 .
the dual optimal solutions which can be easily recovered from the primal optimal solution ( * ? ? ?
* eq.7.10)define a subgradient for @xmath51 as a function of @xmath45 : [ prop : convex ] given @xmath43 and @xmath95 , the map @xmath101 is a polyhedral convex function .
any optimal dual vector @xmath102 of @xmath103 is a subgradient of @xmath96 with respect to @xmath45 .
these results follow from sensitivity analysis in lp s @xcite .
@xmath104 is bounded and is also the maximum of a finite set of linear functions , each indexed by the set of extreme points of @xmath98 , evaluated at @xmath45 and is therefore polyhedral convex .
when the dual optimal vector is unique , @xmath102 is a gradient of @xmath51 at @xmath45 , and a subgradient otherwise .
because for any real value @xmath105 the pair @xmath106 is feasible if the pair @xmath107 is feasible , and because their objective are identical , any dual optimum @xmath107 is determined up to an additive constant . to remove this degree of freedom which arises from the fact that one among all @xmath108 row / column sum constraints of @xmath41 is redundant
we can either remove a dual variable or normalize any dual optimum @xmath102 so that it sums to zero , to enforce that it belongs to the tangent space of @xmath22 .
we follow the latter strategy in the rest of the paper .
let @xmath109 be fixed and let @xmath25 be a closed convex subset of @xmath22 .
the aim of this section is to compute weights @xmath110 such that @xmath111 is minimal .
let @xmath112 be the optimal dual variable of @xmath113 normalized to sum to 0 .
@xmath57 being a sum of terms @xmath93 , we have that : the function @xmath114 is polyhedral convex , with subgradient @xmath115 assuming @xmath25 is closed and convex , we can consider a naive projected subgradient minimization of @xmath57 . alternatively ,
if there exists a bregman divergence @xmath116 for @xmath117 defined by a prox - function @xmath118 , we can define the proximal mapping @xmath119 and consider accelerated gradient approaches @xcite .
we summarize this idea in algorithm [ algo : discwass ] . * inputs * : @xmath120 . for @xmath121 .
form all @xmath122 matrices @xmath123 , see eq . .
set @xmath124 .
@xmath125 , @xmath126 .
form subgradient @xmath127 using all dual optima @xmath112 of @xmath128 .
@xmath129 . @xmath130 .
notice that when @xmath131 and @xmath132 is the kullback - leibler divergence @xcite , we can initialize @xmath133 with @xmath134 and use the multiplicative update to realize the proximal update : @xmath135 , where @xmath136 is schur s product .
alternative sets @xmath25 for which this projection can be easily carried out include , for instance , all ( convex ) level set of the entropy function @xmath137 , namely @xmath138 where @xmath139 .
we consider now the case where @xmath84 with @xmath140 , @xmath5 is the euclidean distance and @xmath77 .
when @xmath84 , a family of @xmath19 points @xmath24 and a family of @xmath141 points @xmath39 can be represented respectively as a matrix in @xmath142 and another in @xmath143 .
the pairwise squared - euclidean distances between points in these sets can be recovered by writing @xmath144 and @xmath145 , and observing that @xmath146 * transport cost as a function of @xmath24 . * due to the margin constraints that apply if a matrix @xmath147 is in the polytope @xmath41 , we have : @xmath148 discarding constant terms in @xmath149 and @xmath46 , we have that minimizing @xmath94 with respect to locations @xmath24 is equivalent to solving @xmath150 as a function of @xmath24 , that objective is the sum of a convex quadratic function of @xmath24 with a piecewise linear concave function , since @xmath151 is the minimum of linear functions indexed by the vertices of the polytope @xmath41 . as a consequence , @xmath94 is not convex with respect to @xmath24 . + * quadratic approximation . *
suppose that @xmath152 is optimal for problem @xmath94 .
updating eq .
, @xmath153 minimizing a local quadratic approximation of @xmath51 at @xmath24 yields thus the newton update @xmath154 a simple interpretation of this update is as follows : the matrix @xmath155 has @xmath19 column - vectors in the simplex @xmath156
. the suggested update for @xmath24 is to replace it by @xmath19 barycenters of points enumerated in @xmath39 with weights defined by the optimal transport @xmath152 .
note that , because the minimization problem we consider in @xmath24 is not convex to start with , one could be fairly creative when it comes to choosing @xmath5 and @xmath12 among other distances and exponents .
this substitution would only involve more complicated gradients of @xmath38 w.r.t .
@xmath24 that would appear in eq . .
we now consider , as a natural extension of [ subsec : xrestricted ] when @xmath84 , the problem of minimizing @xmath57 over a probability measure @xmath16 that is ( i ) supported by _ at most @xmath27 atoms _ described in @xmath24 , a matrix of size @xmath158 , ( ii ) with weights in @xmath159 .
* alternating optimization .
* to obtain an approximate minimizer of @xmath111 we propose in algorithm [ algo : general ] to update alternatively locations @xmath24 ( with the newton step defined in eq .
[ eq : newton ] ) and weights @xmath45 ( with algorithm [ algo : discwass ] ) . * input * : @xmath160 for @xmath161 initialize @xmath162 and @xmath110 @xmath163 using algorithm [ algo : discwass ] .
@xmath164 optimal solution of @xmath165 @xmath166 , setting @xmath167 $ ] with line - search or a preset value .
* algorithm [ algo : general ] and @xcite/@xcite algorithms . * as mentioned in
[ sec : back ] , minimizing @xmath57 defined in eq . over @xmath168 , with @xmath73 , @xmath77 and
no constraints on the weights ( @xmath169 ) , is equivalent to solving the @xmath27-means problem applied to the set of points enumerated in @xmath170 . in that particular case ,
algorithm [ algo : general ] is also equivalent to @xcite s algorithm .
indeed , the assignment of the weight of each point to its closest centroid in @xcite s algorithm ( the maximization step ) is equivalent to the computation of @xmath171 in ours , whereas the re - centering step ( the expectation step ) is equivalent to our update for @xmath24 using the optimal transport , which is in that case the trivial transport that assigns the weight ( divided by @xmath54 ) of each atom in @xmath172 to its closest neighbor in @xmath24 .
when the weight vector @xmath45 is constrained to be uniform ( @xmath173 ) , @xcite proposed a heuristic to obtain uniform @xmath27-means that is also equivalent to algorithm [ algo : general ] , and which also relies on the repeated computation of optimal transports . for more general sets @xmath25 , algorithm [ algo : discwass ]
ensures that the weights @xmath45 remain in @xmath25 at each iteration of algorithm [ algo : general ] , which can not be guaranteed by neither @xcite s nor @xcite s approach .
* algorithm [ algo : general ] and @xcite s @xcite transform .
* @xcite has recently suggested to approximate a weighted measure @xmath17 by a uniform measure supported on as many atoms .
this approximation is motivated by optimal transport theory , notably asymptotic results by @xcite , but does not attempt to minimize , as we do in algorithm [ algo : general ] , any wasserstein distance between that approximation and the original measure .
this approach results in one application of the newton update defined in eq .
, when @xmath24 is first initialized to @xmath39 and @xmath174 to compute the optimal transport @xmath152 .
* summary * we have proposed two original algorithms to compute wasserstein barycenters of probability measures : one which applies when the support of the barycenter is fixed and its weights are constrained to lie in a convex subset @xmath25 of the simplex , another which can be used when the support can be chosen freely .
these algorithms are relatively simple , yet to the best of our knowledge novel .
we suspect these approaches were not considered before because of their prohibitive computational cost : algorithm [ algo : discwass ] computes at each iteration the dual optima of @xmath54 transportation problems to form a subgradient , each with @xmath175 variables and @xmath122 inequality constraints .
algorithm [ algo : general ] incurs an even higher cost , since it involves running algorithm [ algo : discwass ] at each iteration , in addition to solving @xmath54 primal optimal transport problems to form a subgradient to update @xmath24 .
since both objectives rely on subgradient descent schemes , they are also likely to suffer from a very slow convergence .
we propose to solve these issues by following @xcite s approach @xcite to smooth the objective @xmath57 and obtain strictly convex objectives whose gradients can be computed more efficiently .
to circumvent the major computational roadblock posed by the repeated computation of primal and dual optimal transports , we extend @xcite s approach @xcite to obtain smooth and strictly convex approximations of both primal and dual problems @xmath51 and @xmath104 . the matrix scaling approach advocated by @xcite was motivated by the fact that it provided a fast approximation @xmath176 to @xmath51 .
we show here that the same approach can be used to smooth the objective @xmath57 and recover for a cheap computational price its gradients w.r.t . @xmath45 and @xmath24 .
a @xmath44 transport @xmath147 , which is by definition in the @xmath177-simplex , has entropy @xmath178 @xcite has recently proposed to consider , for @xmath179 , a regularized primal transport problem @xmath176 as @xmath180 we introduce in this work its dual problem , which is a smoothed version of the original dual transportation problem , where the positivity constraints of each term @xmath181 have been replaced by penalties @xmath182 : @xmath183 these two problems are related below in the sense that their respective optimal solutions are linked by a unique positive vector @xmath184 : [ prop : primdual]let @xmath185 be the elementwise exponential of @xmath186 , @xmath187 .
then there exists a pair of vectors @xmath188 such that the optimal solutions of @xmath176 and @xmath189 are respectively given by @xmath190 the result follows from the lagrange method of multipliers for the primal as shown by ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2 ) , and a direct application of first - order conditions for the dual , which is an unconstrained convex problem .
the term @xmath191 in the definition of @xmath192 is used to normalize @xmath192 so that it sums to zero as discussed in the end of [ subsec : dualityconvexity ] .
the positive vectors @xmath193 mentioned in proposition [ prop : primdual ] can be computed through @xcite s matrix scaling algorithm applied to @xmath185 , as outlined in algorithm [ algo : sk ] : [ theo : sk ] for any positive matrix @xmath194 in @xmath195 and positive probability vectors @xmath42 and @xmath43 , there exist positive vectors @xmath196 and @xmath197 , unique up to scalar multiplication , such that @xmath198 .
such a pair @xmath193 can be recovered as a fixed point of the sinkhorn map @xmath199 the convergence of the algorithm is linear when using hilbert s projective metric between the scaling factors @xcite .
although we use this algorithm in our experiments because of its simplicity , other algorithms exist @xcite which are known to be more reliable numerically when @xmath200 is large .
* input * @xmath201 @xmath202 ; @xmath203 % use ` bsxfun(@rdivide , k , a ) ` set @xmath204`ones(n,1)/n ` ; ` u=1./(\widetilde{k}(b./(k^tu ) ) ) ` .
@xmath205 @xmath206 . @xmath207 . % use @xmath208 ; * summary : * given a smoothing parameter @xmath179 , using sinkhorn s algorithm on matrix @xmath185 , defined as the elementwise exponential of @xmath209 ( the pairwise gaussian kernel matrix between the supports @xmath24 and @xmath39 when @xmath77 , using bandwidth @xmath210 ) we can recover smoothed optima @xmath211 and @xmath212 for _ both _ smoothed primal @xmath176 and dual @xmath189 transport problems . to take advantage of this
, we simply propose to substitute the smoothed optima @xmath211 and @xmath212 to the original optima @xmath102 and @xmath152 that appear in algorithms [ algo : discwass ] and [ algo : general ] .
we present two applications , one of algorithm [ algo : discwass ] and one of algorithm [ algo : general ] , that both rely on the smooth approximations presented in
[ sec : smooth ] .
the settings we consider involve computing respectively tens of thousands or tens of high - dimensional optimal transport [email protected] for the first application , @xmath214 for the second which can not be realistically carried out using network flow solvers . using network flow solvers ,
the resolution of a single transport problem of these dimensions could take between several minutes to several hours .
we also take advantage in the first application of the fact that algorithm [ algo : sk ] can be run efficiently on gpgpus using vectorized code ( * ? ? ?
* alg.1 ) .
we use @xmath215 images of the mnist database , with approximately @xmath216 images for each digit from 0 to 9 .
each image ( originally @xmath217 pixels ) is scaled randomly , uniformly between half - size and double - size , and translated randomly within a @xmath218 grid , with a bias towards corners .
we display intermediate barycenter solutions for each of these 10 datasets of images for @xmath219 gradient iterations .
@xmath200 is set to @xmath220 , where @xmath221 is the squared - euclidean distance matrix between all 2,500 pixels in the grid .
using a quadro k5000 gpu with close to 1500 cores , the computation of a single barycenter takes about 2 hours to reach 100 iterations . because we use warm starts to initialize @xmath222 in algorithm [ algo : sk ] at each iteration of algorithm [ algo : discwass ] , the first iterations are typically more computationally intensive than those carried out near the end .
-1.2 cm ) centroids .
the size of each of the 57.647 blue crosses is proportional to the local average of the relevant variable ( income above and population below ) at that location , normalized to sum to 1 .
each downward triangle is a centroid of the @xmath27-means clustering ( equivalent to a wasserstein barycenter with @xmath169 ) whose size is proportional to the portion of mass captured by that centroid .
red dots indicate centroids obtained with a uniform constraint on the weights , @xmath173 . since such centroids are constrained to carry a fixed portion of the total weight , one can observe that they provide a more balanced clustering than the @xmath27-means solution.,title="fig:",width=415 ] in practice , the @xmath27-means cost function applied to a given empirical measure could be minimized with a set of centroids @xmath24 and weight vector @xmath45 such that the entropy of @xmath45 is very small .
this can occur when most of the original points in the dataset are attributed to a very small subset of the @xmath27 centroids , and could be undesirable in applications of @xmath27-means where a more regular attribution is sought .
for instance , in sensor deployment , when each centroid ( sensor ) is limited in the number of data points ( users ) it can serve , we would like to ensure that the attributions agree with those limits . whereas the original @xmath27-means can not take into account such limits
, we can ensure them using algorithm [ algo : general ] .
we illustrate the difference between looking for optimal centroids with `` free '' assignments ( @xmath169 ) , and looking for optimal `` uniform '' centroids with constrained assignments ( @xmath173 ) using us census data for income and population repartitions across 57.647 spatial locations in the 48 contiguous states .
these weighted points can be interpreted as two empirical measures on @xmath223 with weights directly proportional to these respective quantities .
we initialize both `` free '' and `` uniform '' clustering with the actual 48 state capitals .
results displayed in figure [ fig : america ] show that by forcing our approximation to be uniform , we recover centroids that induce a more balanced clustering .
indeed , each cell of the voronoi diagram built with these centroids is now constrained to hold the same aggregate wealth or population .
these centroids could form the new state capitals of equally rich or equally populated states . on an algorithmic note ,
we notice in figure [ fig : graphe ] that algorithm [ algo : general ] converges to its ( local ) optimum at a speed which is directly comparable to that of the @xmath27-means in terms of iterations , with a relatively modest computational overhead .
unsurprisingly , the wasserstein distance between the clusters and the original measure is higher when adding uniform constraints on the weights . ) and its unconstrained equivalent ( @xmath27-means ) to the income empirical measure .
note that , because of the constraints on weights , the wasserstein distance of the uniform wasserstein barycenter is necessarily larger . on a single cpu core ,
these computations require 12.5 seconds for the constrained case , using sinkhorn s approximation , and 1.55 seconds for the regular @xmath27-means algorithm . using a regular transportation solver , computing
the optimal transport from the 57.647 points to the 48 centroids would require about 1 hour for a single iteration , width=283 ] we have proposed in this paper two original algorithms to compute wasserstein barycenters of empirical measures .
using these algorithms in practice for measures of large support is a daunting task for two reasons : they are inherently slow because they rely on the subgradient method ; the computation of these subgradients involves solving optimal and dual optimal transport problems .
both issues can be substantially alleviated by smoothing the primal optimal transport problem with an entropic penalty and considering its dual .
both smoothed problems admit gradients which can be computed efficiently using only matrix vector products .
our aim in proposing such algorithms is to demonstrate that wasserstein barycenters can be used for visualization , constrained clustering , and hopefully as a core component within more complex data analysis techniques in future applications .
we also believe that our smoothing approach can be directly applied to more complex variational problems that involve multiple wasserstein distances , such as wasserstein propagation @xcite . | we present new algorithms to compute the mean of a set of empirical probability measures under the optimal transport metric .
this mean , known as the wasserstein barycenter , is the measure that minimizes the sum of its wasserstein distances to each element in that set .
we propose two original algorithms to compute wasserstein barycenters that build upon the subgradient method .
a direct implementation of these algorithms is , however , too costly because it would require the repeated resolution of large primal and dual optimal transport problems to compute subgradients . extending the work of @xcite
, we propose to smooth the wasserstein distance used in the definition of wasserstein barycenters with an entropic regularizer and recover in doing so a strictly convex objective whose gradients can be computed for a considerably cheaper computational cost using matrix scaling algorithms .
we use these algorithms to visualize a large family of images and to solve a constrained clustering problem . |
moduli spaces of smooth algebraic curves have been defined and then compactified in algebraic geometry by deligne and mumford in their seminal paper @xcite .
a conceptually important extension of this notion in the case of pointed curves was introduced by knudsen @xcite .
the points in the boundary of the moduli spaces of pointed , nodal curves with finite automorphism group .
these curves are called _ stable curves _ ( or pointed stable curves ) .
the topology of one such curve is encoded in a combinatorial object , called
_ stable graph_. the boundary of the moduli space admits a topological stratification , made of loci whose points are curves with a fixed topological type and a prescribed assignment of the marked points on each irreducible component .
the combinatorics of the stable graphs have been investigated in several papers in algebraic geometry , for many different purposes ( see for instance @xcite ) .
our aim with this program is to provide a useful and effective tool to generate all the stable graphs of genus @xmath0 with @xmath1 unordered marked points up to isomorphism , for low values of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we construct an algorithm to generate all the stable graphs of genus @xmath0 with @xmath1 unordered marked points .
our program uses then the software ` nauty ` @xcite to eliminate isomorphic graphs from the list of graphs thus created . since to check that two stable graphs
are isomorphic is computationally onerous , we try to generate a low number of stable graphs , provided that we want at least one for every isomorphism class .
the algorithm generates recursively the vectors of genera , number of marked points , number of loops , and the adjacency matrix .
while it fills these data , it checks the stability condition and the condition on the total genus as early as possible , in order to minimize the time spent on the branches of the recursion that do not lead to stable graphs .
some analysis of the algorithm s performances can be seen in section [ sec : performance ] .
programs for enumerative computations on @xmath3 have been implemented in both maple and macaulay2 ( @xcite ) .
our program can be used , for example , to improve the results of ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) , or to prove combinatorial results on the moduli space of pointed stable curves with low genus ( cfr .
@xcite , for example corollary 5.3 ) .
from now on , we fix two natural numbers @xmath4 and @xmath5 such that @xmath6 . for every @xmath7 , we define @xmath8 and @xmath9 to be the symmetric group on the set @xmath10 . *
an _ undirected multigraph _
@xmath11 is a couple @xmath12 with @xmath13 a finite set of _ vertices _ and @xmath14 a finite multiset of _ edges _ with elements in @xmath15 . *
the multiplicity of the edge @xmath16 in @xmath14 is denoted by @xmath17 . * the _ total multiplicity _ of @xmath11 , or its _ number of edges _
, is @xmath18 : the cardinality of @xmath14 as a multiset . *
the _ degree _ of a vertex @xmath19 is @xmath20 . *
a _ colored undirected multigraph _ is a multigraph with some additional data attached to each vertex .
[ def : stable graph ] a _ stable graph _ of type @xmath21 is a colored undirected multigraph @xmath22 , subject to the following conditions . 1 .
the color of a vertex @xmath19 is given by a pair of natural numbers @xmath23 .
the two numbers are called respectively the _ genus _ and the _ number of marked points _ of the vertex @xmath19 .
[ it : condition connected ] @xmath11 is connected .
[ it : condition genus ] its _ total genus _ , defined as @xmath24 , equals @xmath4 .
its _ total number of marked points _ , defined as @xmath25 , equals @xmath5 .
[ it : condition stability ] stability condition : @xmath26 for every vertex @xmath19 with @xmath27 . the number @xmath28 is often called the _ number of half edges _ associated to the vertex @xmath19 .
condition [ it : condition stability ] can be rephrased in : for every vertex @xmath19 of genus @xmath29 , its number of half edges is at least @xmath30 .
two stable graphs @xmath31 and @xmath32 are _ isomorphic _ if there is a bijection @xmath33 such that : * @xmath34 for every @xmath35 ; * @xmath36 and @xmath37 for every @xmath38 .
our task is to generate one stable graph for each isomorphism class .
note that from the definition just given , we are working with an unordered set of marked points .
the output of the program are the boundary strata of the moduli space of stable , genus @xmath0 curves with @xmath1 unordered points @xmath39 .
in this section we describe the general ideas of our algorithm .
let us first introduce the notation we use in the program .
[ not : gnla ] the set of vertices @xmath13 will always be @xmath10 , so that vertices will be identified with natural numbers @xmath40 . the multiplicity of the edge between @xmath41 and @xmath42 will be denoted by @xmath43 : the symmetric matrix @xmath44 is called the _ adjacency matrix _ of the stable graph . for convenience , we will denote @xmath45 : it is the vector whose elements are the number of loops at the vertex @xmath42 . for simplicity , we will consider @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath43 to be defined also for @xmath41 or @xmath42 outside @xmath10 , in which case their value is always assumed to be @xmath29 . in the following , we assume @xmath49 in order not to deal with degenerate cases .
there are trivially @xmath50 stable graphs of type @xmath21 with one vertex . indeed ,
if there is exactly one vertex , the choice of the genus uniquely determines the number of loops on it after definition [ def : stable graph ] .
the program uses recursive functions to generate the data that constitute a stable graph . in order
, it generates the numbers @xmath46 , then the numbers @xmath47 , @xmath48 ( the diagonal part of the matrix @xmath44 ) , and finally , row by row , a symmetric matrix representing @xmath44 .
when all the data have been generated , it tests that all the conditions of definition [ def : stable graph ] hold , in particular that the graph is actually connected and satisfies the stability conditions .
then it uses the software ` nauty ` @xcite to check if this graph is isomorphic to a previously generated graph .
if this is not the case , it adds the graph to the list of graphs of genus @xmath4 with @xmath5 marked points .
a priori , for each entry of @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 , and @xmath44 the program tries to fill that position with all the integers .
this is of course not possible , indeed it is important to observe here that each datum is bounded . from below , a trivial bound is @xmath29 , that is , no datum can be negative . instead ,
a simple upper bound can be given for each entry of @xmath0 by the number @xmath4 , and for each entry of @xmath1 by the number @xmath5 .
for @xmath51 and @xmath44 , upper bounds are obtained from @xmath4 using the condition on the total genus ( condition [ def : stable graph ] ) .
these bounds are coarse : section [ sec : ranges ] will be devoted to proving sharper bounds , from above and from below .
also , we will make these bounds dynamical : for instance assigning the value @xmath52 clearly lowers the bound for @xmath53 .
the improvement of these bounds is crucial for the performance of the algorithm . in any case , once we know that there are bounds , we are sure that the recursion terminates .
the algorithm follows this principle : we want to generate the smallest possible number of couples of isomorphic stable graphs .
to do so , we generalize the idea that to generate a vector for every class of vectors of length @xmath54 modulo permutations , the simplest way is to generate vectors whose entries are increasing .
the program fills the data row by row in the matrix : @xmath55 and generates only matrices whose columns are ordered .
loosely speaking , we mean that we are ordering the columns lexicographically , but this requires a bit of care , for two reasons : * the matrix @xmath44 needs to be symmetric ; in the program we generate only the strictly upper triangular part ; * the diagonal of @xmath44 need not be considered when deciding if a column is greater than or equal to the previous one .
therefore , to be precise , we define a relation ( _ order _ ) for adjacent columns .
let us call @xmath56 and @xmath57 two adjacent columns of the matrix .
they are said to be equivalent if @xmath58 for any @xmath59 . if they are not equivalent , denote with @xmath60 the minimum index such that @xmath61 and @xmath62
. then we state the relation @xmath63 if and only if @xmath64 .
we do not define the relation for non - adjacent columns .
we say that the data are ordered when the columns are weakly increasing , that is if , for all @xmath42 , either @xmath56 is equivalent to @xmath57 or @xmath63 . to ensure that the columns are ordered ( in the sense we explained before ) , the program keeps track of _
we start filling the genus vector @xmath0 in a non decreasing way , and every time a value @xmath46 strictly greater than @xmath65 is assigned , we put a division before @xmath42 .
this means that , when assigning the value of @xmath47 , we allow the algorithm to start again from @xmath29 instead of @xmath66 , because the column @xmath57 is already bigger than the column @xmath56 . after completing @xmath0 ,
we start filling the vector @xmath1 in such a way that , within two divisions , it is non decreasing .
again we introduce a division before @xmath42 every time we assign a value @xmath47 strictly greater than @xmath66 .
we follow this procedure also for the vector @xmath51 . finally , we start filling the rows of the matrix @xmath44 . here
the procedure is a bit different . indeed even if for the purpose of filling the matrix it is enough to deal only with the upper triangular part , imposing
the conditions that the columns are ordered involves also the lower triangular part .
a small computation gives that the value of @xmath43 is assigned starting from : @xmath67 and we put a division before @xmath41 if @xmath68 and a division before @xmath42 if @xmath69 .
we can not conclude immediately that this procedure gives us all possible data up to permutations as in the case of a single vector .
this is because the transformation that the whole matrix undergoes when a permutation is applied is more complicated : for the first three rows ( the vectors @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 ) , it just permutes the columns , but for the remaining rows , it permutes both rows and columns . indeed , to prove that the procedure of generating only ordered columns does not miss any stable graph is the content of the following section .
we want to prove the following result . [ prop : main ] the algorithm described in the previous section generates at least one graph for every isomorphism class of stable graphs . from now on , besides @xmath4 and @xmath5 , we also fix the number of vertices @xmath54 , and focus on proving that the algorithm generates at least one graph for every isomorphism class of stable graphs with @xmath54 vertices .
we have decided previously to encode the data of a stable graph in a @xmath70 matrix @xmath71 ( cfr . ) .
we denote by @xmath72 the set of all such matrices , and by @xmath73 the set of all @xmath74 matrices that are generated by the algorithm described in the previous section .
we can assume that the graphs generated by the algorithm are stable , since we explicitly check connectedness and stability .
in other words , we can assume the inclusion @xmath75 .
hence , in order to prove proposition [ prop : main ] , we will show that every @xmath76 is in @xmath73 up to applying a permutation of @xmath10 .
the idea is to give a characterization ( lemma [ lemma : char ] ) of the property of being an element of @xmath73 .
recall first that the algorithm generates only matrices whose columns are ordered , as described in section [ sec : description ] . more explicitly , if @xmath77 , then @xmath78 if and only if : @xmath79 let us call a piece of data @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , or @xmath43 a _ breaking position _ if it does not satisfy the condition above .
observe that a matrix @xmath76 has a breaking position if and only if @xmath4 is not an element of @xmath73 .
we now introduce a total order on the set @xmath72 of matrices @xmath80 .
if @xmath4 is such a matrix , let @xmath81 be the vector obtained by juxtaposing the vectors @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 and the rows of the upper triangular part of @xmath44 .
for example , if @xmath82 ( with the same structure as ) , then we define @xmath83 [ def : order ] if @xmath84 , we write @xmath85 if and only if @xmath81 is smaller than @xmath86 in the lexicographic order . in this case
we say that the matrix @xmath4 is smaller than the matrix @xmath87 .
note that this total order on the set of matrices must not be confused with the partial order described in section [ sec : description ] . from now on we will always refer to the latter order on @xmath72 .
if @xmath88 is a permutation and @xmath89 is a graph , then we can apply @xmath90 to the entries of the data of @xmath4 , obtaining an isomorphic graph .
the action of @xmath90 on @xmath4 is : @xmath91 where @xmath92 , @xmath93 , @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
we denote this new matrix by @xmath96 .
we write @xmath97 for the element of @xmath9 that corresponds to the transposition of @xmath98 .
now we are able to state the characterization we need to prove proposition [ prop : main ] .
[ lemma : char ] let @xmath76 ; then @xmath99 if and only if @xmath4 is minimal in the set @xmath100 with respect to the order given in definition [ def : order ] . we will prove that @xmath4 is not minimal if and only if there is a breaking position .
assume there is at least one breaking position in @xmath4 .
if there is one in @xmath0 , @xmath1 , or @xmath51 , it is trivial to see that transposing the corresponding index with the previous one gives a smaller matrix .
if this is not the case , let @xmath43 be a breaking position such that @xmath101 is not a breaking position whenever @xmath102 ( the position @xmath103 is the first breaking position of its column ) .
we deduce that @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , and that for all @xmath102 not in @xmath107 , we have @xmath108 .
let @xmath109 ; the vectors @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath51 ( the first three rows ) coincide in @xmath4 and @xmath87 .
* if @xmath110 , the smallest breaking position is in the upper triangular part of @xmath44 ; it is then clear that @xmath111 . *
if @xmath112 , the smallest breaking position is in the lower triangular part ; by using the symmetry of the matrix @xmath44 we again obtain @xmath111 ( see the right part of figure [ fig : a ] ) . at ( -1,7.5 ) @xmath113 ; at ( 12.5,-1 ) @xmath114 ; at ( 11.5,7.5 ) @xmath115 ; at ( 12.5,7.5 ) @xmath116 ; at ( 7.5,11.5 ) @xmath115 ; at ( 7.5,12.5 ) @xmath116 ; ( 8,11 ) ( 8,13 ) ( 15,13 ) ( 15,11 ) cycle ; ( 11,8 ) ( 13,8 ) ( 13,15 ) ( 11,15 ) cycle ; ( 0,11 ) ( 0,13 ) ( 7,13 ) ( 7,11 ) cycle ; ( 11,0 ) ( 13,0 ) ( 13,7 ) ( 11,7 ) cycle ; ( 0,0 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 15,15 ) ( 0,15 ) cycle ; in 1,2, ... ,14 ( 0 , )
( 15 , ) ; ( , 0 ) ( , 15 ) ; in 0,1, ... ,14 ( , )
( , + 1 ) ( + 1,+1 ) ( + 1 , ) cycle ; at ( -1,11.5 ) @xmath113 ; at ( 7.5,-1 ) @xmath114 ; at ( 6.5,11.5 ) @xmath115 ; at ( 7.5,11.5 ) @xmath116 ; at ( 11.5,6.5 ) @xmath115 ; at ( 11.5,7.5 ) @xmath116 ; ( 12,6 ) ( 12,8 ) ( 15,8 ) ( 15,6 ) cycle ; ( 6,12 ) ( 8,12 ) ( 8,15 ) ( 6,15 ) cycle ; ( 0,6 ) ( 0,8 ) ( 11,8 ) ( 11,6 ) cycle ; ( 6,0 ) ( 8,0 ) ( 8,11 ) ( 6,11 ) cycle ; ( 0,0 ) ( 15,0 ) ( 15,15 ) ( 0,15 ) cycle ; in 1,2, ...
,14 ( 0 , ) ( 15 , ) ; ( , 0 ) ( , 15 ) ; in 0,1, ...
,14 ( , )
( , + 1 ) ( + 1,+1 ) ( + 1 , ) cycle ; conversely , let @xmath42 be such that @xmath117 .
then consider the first entry ( reading from left to right ) of the vector @xmath81 that is strictly bigger than @xmath86 .
this is a breaking position .
notice that if it occurs in the matrix @xmath44 ( equivalently , in the last @xmath54 rows ) , it is actually the first breaking position of its column .
the proof of proposition [ prop : main ] follows arguing as in this example .
let @xmath118 be the graph of the previous example : @xmath119 \hline\\[1pt ] \bullet & 1 & 1 & 1\\ 1 & \bullet & 2 & 1\\ 1 & 2 & \bullet & 0\\ 1 & 1 & 0 & \bullet \end{smallmatrix}\right)}\text{.}\ ] ] this graph is stable but not in @xmath73 because , for example , @xmath120 implies that @xmath121 is a breaking position .
thus we apply the permutation @xmath122 , obtaining the graph @xmath123 \hline\\[1pt ] \bullet & 1 & 1 & 1\\ 1 & \bullet & 1 & 2\\ 1 & 1 & \bullet & 0\\ 1 & 2 & 0 & \bullet \end{smallmatrix}\right ) } \prec g_0\text{.}\ ] ] now @xmath124 is a breaking position ; applying @xmath125 , we obtain @xmath126 \hline\\[1pt ] \bullet & 1 & 1 & 1\\ 1 & \bullet & 1 & 0\\ 1 & 1 & \bullet & 2\\ 1 & 0 & 2 & \bullet \end{smallmatrix}\right ) } \prec g_1\text{.}\ ] ] this introduces a new breaking position at @xmath127 , so we apply the transposition @xmath128 : @xmath129 \hline\\[1pt ] \bullet & 1 & 1 & 0\\ 1 & \bullet & 1 & 1\\ 1 & 1 & \bullet & 2\\ 0 & 1 & 2 & \bullet \end{smallmatrix}\right ) } \prec g_2\text{.}\ ] ] the graph @xmath130 is finally in @xmath73 and indeed no transposition can make it smaller .
recall that we have to prove that for every @xmath76 , there is a permutation @xmath88 such that @xmath131 .
so , let @xmath132 .
if @xmath99 , then we are done ; otherwise , @xmath4 does not satisfy the condition of lemma [ lemma : char ] , hence there is a transposition @xmath133 such that @xmath134 .
the iteration of this process comes to an end ( that is , we arrive to a matrix in @xmath73 ) since the set @xmath135 is finite .
in section [ sec : description ] we have introduced the algorithm , by describing the divisions . in this section
we introduce accurate ranges for the possible values of @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 and @xmath44 .
we will deduce from the conditions of definition [ def : stable graph ] some other necessary conditions that can be checked before the graph is defined in its entirety .
more precisely , every single datum is assigned trying all the possibilities within a range that depends upon the values of @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and upon the values of the data that have already been filled .
the conditions we describe in the following are not the only ones possible ; we tried other possibilities , but heuristically the others we tried did not give any improvement .
the order in which we assign the value of the data is @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 , and finally the upper triangular part of @xmath44 row after row .
suppose we are assigning the @xmath41-th value of one of the vectors @xmath0 , @xmath1 or @xmath51 , or the @xmath103-th value of @xmath44 .
we define the following derived variables @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138 that depend upon the values that have already been assigned to @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 , @xmath44 .
we let @xmath136 be the maximum number of edges that could be introduced in the subsequent iterations of the recursion , and @xmath137 be the number of couples of ( different ) vertices already connected by an edge .
we let @xmath138 be the number of vertices @xmath139 to which the algorithm has assigned @xmath140 .
note that the final value of @xmath138 is determined when the first genus greater than @xmath29 is assigned , in particular the final value of @xmath138 is determined at the end of the assignment of the values to the vector @xmath0 . on the other hand , @xmath137 starts to change its value only when the matrix @xmath44 begins to be filled . _
after _ the assignment of the @xmath41-th value , the derived values @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138
are then updated according to the assignment itself .
[ not : partial_assign ] when deciding @xmath0 , @xmath1 , or @xmath51 , we let @xmath141 be the minimum between @xmath142 and the number of half edges already assigned to the @xmath41-th vertex .
this is justified by the fact that we know that , when we will fill the matrix @xmath44 , we will increase by one the number of half edges at the vertex @xmath41 in order to connect it to the rest of the graph .
whenever @xmath143 , @xmath141 is the number of _ stabilizing _ half edges at the vertex @xmath41 : one half edge is needed to connect the vertex to the rest of the graph , and then at least two more half edges are needed to stabilize the vertex . when deciding @xmath43 , it is also useful to have defined @xmath144 , the total number of half edges that hit the @xmath41-th vertex .
finally , we define @xmath145 we are now ready to describe the ranges in which the data can vary .
we study subsequently the cases of @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 and @xmath44 , thus following the order of the recursions of our algorithm .
each range is described by presenting a first list of general constraints on the parameters and then by presenting a second list containing the actual ranges in the last line .
when the algorithm is deciding the value of @xmath146 , we have the following situation : * @xmath147 by condition [ it : condition genus ] ; * amongst the @xmath136 edges , there are necessarily @xmath148 non - loop edges ( to connect the graph ) ; these @xmath148 edges give one half edge for each vertex , whereas we can choose arbitrarily where to send the other @xmath149 half edges ; conversely , the @xmath150 half edges of the remaining edges can be associated to any vertex ; therefore , the maximum number of half edges ( not counting those that are needed to connect the graph ) is @xmath151 ; * we need @xmath152 half edges to stabilize the genus @xmath29 vertices , since one half edge comes for free from the connection of the graph .
we use the following conditions to limit the choices we have for @xmath146 : 1 .
since @xmath0 is the first vector to be generated , there is no division before @xmath41 , hence @xmath153 remember that @xmath154 whenever @xmath155 ; 2 .
we need at least @xmath148 non - loop edges , hence ( using the fact that @xmath156 ) @xmath157 3 . in order to stabilize the @xmath138 vertices of genus @xmath29 ( using the fact that one stabilizing half edge comes for free by connection ) we must have @xmath158 when deciding @xmath159 , we have the following situation : * as before , @xmath160 , and the maximum number of half edges still to be assigned is @xmath161 ; * we need @xmath162 half edges to stabilize the first @xmath138 vertices ; * if @xmath143 , we need @xmath163 more half edges to stabilize the first @xmath164 vertices .
the following conditions define then the ranges for the possible choices for @xmath159 : 1 .
if there is not a division before @xmath41 ( that is , if @xmath165 ) , then we require @xmath166 ; otherwise , just @xmath167 ; 2 .
we can not assign more than @xmath5 marked points , hence ( where we treat the case of @xmath143 in a special way ) @xmath168 3 . if @xmath143 , for the purpose of stabilizing the first @xmath164 curves we can not use marked points anymore , therefore we have @xmath169 when deciding @xmath171 , this is the situation : * @xmath172 , and the maximum number of half edges still to assign is @xmath173 ; the conditions on @xmath170 are then the following : 1 .
if there is not a division before @xmath41 , then we require @xmath174 ; otherwise , just @xmath175 ; 2 .
we need at least @xmath148 non - loop edges , hence @xmath176 3 .
let @xmath139 be the index of the genus @xmath29 vertex with the least number of stabilizing half edges such that @xmath177 ; it already has @xmath178 half edges , but we can not use loops anymore to stabilize it ; hence , @xmath179 4 . assume @xmath143 ; if @xmath180 , we are adding to the @xmath41-th vertex @xmath181 stabilizing half edges , and to stabilize the @xmath138 genus @xmath29 vertices , we need to have @xmath182 5 .
assume @xmath143 ; after deciding @xmath170 , we still have @xmath136 edges to place , and each of them can contribute with one half edge to the stabilization of the @xmath41-th vertex ; moreover , one of these half edges is already counted for the stabilization ; hence @xmath183 when deciding @xmath43 , this is the situation : * earlier in notation [ not : partial_assign ] , we observed that for the purpose of filling the vectors @xmath0,@xmath1 and @xmath51 we could consider a genus @xmath29 vertex stabilized when it had at least two half - edges ( since the graph is going to be connected eventually ) .
when assigning the values of @xmath44 , the stability condition goes back to its original meaning , i.e. each vertex has at least @xmath30 half edges .
* @xmath184 ; * we have already placed edges between @xmath137 couples of different vertices ; here are the constraints that @xmath43 must satisfy : 1 .
if there is not a division before @xmath41 , then we require @xmath185 ; otherwise , just @xmath186 ; 2 .
if there is not a division before @xmath42 , then we require @xmath187 ; 3 .
we need at least @xmath188 ( if positive ) edges to connect the graph , because if @xmath189 , @xmath137 will increase by @xmath190 ( this estimate could be very poor , but enforcing the connectedness condition in its entirety before completing the graph is too slow ) , hence : @xmath191 4 .
@xmath43 contributes with at most @xmath192 stabilizing half edges ; hence , to stabilize the @xmath138 genus @xmath29 vertices , we need @xmath193 5 .
if @xmath194 ( that is , if this is the last chance to add half edges to the @xmath41-th vertex ) , then we add enough edges from @xmath41 to @xmath148 in order to stabilize the vertex @xmath41 ; moreover , if up to now we did not place any non - loop edge on the vertex @xmath41 , we impose @xmath195 .
the complexity of the problem we are trying to solve is intrinsically higher than polynomial , because already the amount of data to generate increases ( at least ) exponentially with the genera and the number of marked points .
we also observed an exponential growth of the ratio between the time required to solve an instance of the problem and the number of graphs generated .
anyway , our program is specifically designed to attack the problem of stable graphs , and it can be expected to perform better than any general method to generate graphs applied to our situation .
we present here some of the results obtained when testing our program on an intel core2 quad processor q9450 at 2.66ghz .
the version we tested is not designed for parallel processing , hence it used only one of the four cores available .
however , when computing a specific graph , the program needs to keep in the memory only the graphs with the same values in the vectors @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 : memory usage becomes therefore negligible .
moreover this shows that we can assign the computations of stable graphs with prescribed @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath51 to different cores or cpus , thus having a highly parallelized implementation of the program . .
] .for small @xmath4 , the maximum @xmath5 such that all stable graphs of type @xmath197 can be computed in less than @xmath198 minutes . in the last column
we show the ratio of duplicated graphs among the total number of those created by our generation algorithm . [ cols=">,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] in table [ tab : number ] we list , for each genus @xmath4 , the maximum number of marked points @xmath5 for which we can compute all the stable graphs of type @xmath21 under 15 minutes . in figure [ fig : plot ] we show all the couples @xmath21 that we computed against the time needed ; the lines connect the results referring to the same genus . from this plot
it seems that , for fixed @xmath4 , the required time increases exponentially with @xmath5 .
however , we believe that in the long run the behaviour will be worse than exponential .
this is suggested also by the fact that the ratio of non - isomorphic stable graphs over those created by our generation algorithm tends to zero as @xmath4 and @xmath5 grow ( see figure [ fig : plot_duplicated ] ) .
more benchmarks and up - to - date computed results are available at ` boundary ` s webpage , http://people.sissa.it/~maggiolo/boundary/[`http://people.sissa.it/~maggiolo/boundary/ ` ] .
both the authors want to acknowledge their host institutions , sissa and kth .
the second author was partly supported by the wallenberg foundation .
both authors were partly supported by prin `` geometria delle variet algebriche e dei loro spazi di moduli '' , by istituto nazionale di alta matematica .
the authors are also very grateful to susha parameswaran for linguistic suggestions , and to the referees for suggesting further improvements of the presentation .
s. busonero , m. melo , and l. stoppino , _ on the complexity group of stable curves _ , adv . in geometry
* 11 * ( 2011 ) , no .
2 , 241272 , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/0808.1529[arxiv:0808.1529 ] ] . p.
deligne and d. mumford , _ the irreducibility of the space of curves of given genus _ , inst .
hautes tudes sci .
publ . math .
* 36 * ( 1969 ) , 75109 .
m. a. van opstall and r. veliche , _ maximally symmetric stable curves ii _ , http://arxiv.org/abs/math/0608799[arxiv:math/0608799 ] .
s. yang , _ intersection numbers on @xmath200 _ , journal of software for algebra and geometry , * 2 * ( 2010 ) , 15 . | we present and prove the correctness of the program ` boundary ` , whose sources are available at http://people.sissa.it/~maggiolo/boundary/[`http://people.sissa.it/~maggiolo/boundary/ ` ] . given two natural numbers @xmath0 and @xmath1 satisfying @xmath2 , the program generates all genus @xmath0 stable graphs with @xmath1 unordered marked points .
each such graph determines the topological type of a nodal stable curve of arithmetic genus @xmath0 with @xmath1 unordered marked points .
our motivation comes from the fact that the boundary of the moduli space of stable genus @xmath0 , @xmath1-pointed curves can be stratified by taking loci of curves of a fixed topological type . |
diffraction by an infinite wedge is a fundamental canonical problem in acoustic scattering .
exact closed - form frequency - domain solutions for point source , line source or plane wave excitation with homogeneous dirichlet ( sound soft ) or neumann ( sound hard , or rigid ) boundary conditions are available in many different forms@xcite .
for example , series expansions in terms of eigenfunctions are available for near field calculations ( e.g. for analysing edge singularities ) .
contour integral representations over so - called sommerfeld - malyuzhinets contours are better suited to far field computations ( e.g. for deriving diffraction coefficients in computational methods such as the geometrical theory of diffraction @xcite ) .
more recently it has been discovered that the ` diffracted ' component of these solutions ( precisely , that which remains after subtracting from the total field the geometrical acoustics terms ) can be expressed in a more physically intuitive form , namely as a line integral superposition of directional secondary sources located along the diffracting edge @xcite .
( in fact the frequency domain expressions derived in ref .
@xcite had appeared already in ref .
@xcite , but the interpretation in terms of secondary edge sources seems to have been first made in ref . @xcite . )
one appealing feature of the edge source interpretation is that it offers a natural way to write down approximate solutions for finite edges , simply by truncating the domain of integration .
it has also led to edge integral equation formulations of scattering problems , where the integral equation is posed on the union of all the scatterer s edges @xcite . for dirichlet and neumann boundary conditions the edge source formulations
are now well understood : efficient numerical evaluation of the line integrals has been considered in ref .
@xcite using the method of numerical steepest descent , as has the behaviour of the line integrals near shadow boundaries @xcite and edges @xcite .
note also ref .
@xcite , where the corresponding time - domain case is considered . for the more difficult case of diffraction by a wedge with impedance ( absorbing ) boundary conditions ,
some exact solutions are also known .
for example , the case of plane wave incidence on an impedance wedge can be solved using the sommerfeld - malyuzhinets technique , and converted to a series expansion using a watson - type transformation ( see ref .
@xcite and the references therein ) .
but the solution obtained is much more cumbersome than those for the corresponding dirichlet and neumann problems , and the technique requires the solution of a certain non - trivial functional difference equation .
this increased complexity is perhaps to be expected , since the physics of the impedance problem are fundamentally more complicated than those for the dirichlet and neumann problems ; in particular , the wedge faces can under certain conditions support surface waves .
however , for the special ( yet important ) case of a right - angled wedge , the solution takes a particularly simple and explicit form@xcite . in ref .
@xcite , rawlins proves that the solution to the impedance problem for a right - angled wedge ( with possibly different impedances on each face ) can be obtained from that of the corresponding dirichlet problem , generalised to allow complex incident angles , by the application of a certain linear differential operator ( see eqs .
below for details ) .
rawlins applies this operator to the classical series and integral representations of the dirichlet solution to obtain relatively simple series and integral representations for the impedance solution .
( the solution for the case where the impedance is the same on both faces was presented previously in a similar but more complicated form in ref .
@xcite . ) in this paper it will be shown that rawlins solution for the impedance wedge can be transformed into an edge source representation of the same form as those derived for rigid ( sound - hard ) wedges in ref .
this appears to be the first edge source representation for diffraction by an impedance wedge .
while the solution obtained is valid only for a right - angled wedge , it should be remarked that this special case is ubiquitous in many acoustical applications ( e.g. , urban acoustics @xcite ) .
the edge source formulation for ideal ( dirichlet and neumann ) wedges will briefly be reviewed . for the most general setting ( illustrated in fig . 1 ) ,
consider a point source @xmath0 and point receiver @xmath1 in the presence of a wedge of exterior angle @xmath2 .
let @xmath3 denote cylindrical coordinates with the @xmath4-axis along the edge , the propagation domain occupying the region @xmath5 , and the wedge the region @xmath6 .
consider also cartesian coordinates @xmath7 with @xmath8 , @xmath9 , @xmath10 . without loss of generality
it will be assumed that the receiver is located in the plane @xmath11 , at @xmath12 .
for each point @xmath4 on the edge one can also introduce local spherical coordinates @xmath13 , with @xmath14 defined as before and @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 . for consistency with ref .
@xcite the time - dependence @xmath18 will be assumed throughout .
then the diffracted field at @xmath1 ( i.e. the total field minus the geometrical acoustics field ) due to a monopole source at @xmath19 can be written as a line integral @xmath20 over edge positions @xmath4 , where @xmath21 is the wedge index @xcite .
the integral in eq . can be interpreted as a superposition of secondary edge sources along the edge .
the factor @xmath22 can be interpreted as a directivity function , and takes the following forms for dirichlet ( @xmath23 ) and neumann ( @xmath24 ) boundary conditions : @xmath25 where @xmath26 @xmath27 and the auxiliary function @xmath28 is @xmath29 the second expression for @xmath28 in eq .
shows that @xmath22 is a function only of the local spherical angles @xmath30 ; this justifies the interpretation of @xmath22 as a directivity function .
the formula for @xmath31 above corrects that in ref .
@xcite by reversing the sign of @xmath31 . also , the first expression for @xmath28 in eq .
( [ eq : etadef ] ) corrects a sign error in the corresponding formula in ref .
@xcite . a mixed wedge with dirichlet conditions on @xmath32 and neumann conditions on @xmath33 can also be treated , by summing the dirichlet solutions for a wedge angle @xmath34 and source positions @xmath35 and @xmath36 respectively .
this gives the directivity factor @xmath37 where @xmath38 which , when inserted in eq . , agrees with the solution derived by buckingham in eqs . ( 62)-(63 ) of ref .
@xcite using a modal expansion .
the solution for a mixed wedge with neumann conditions on @xmath32 and dirichlet conditions on @xmath33 can then be obtained by replacing @xmath14 by @xmath39 and @xmath35 by @xmath40 in eq . .
for the two - dimensional case of plane wave incidence perpendicular to the edge , the source is placed at @xmath41 with @xmath42 . in this case
@xmath43 and , because of symmetry , the integration range in eq . (
[ eq : basicintegral ] ) can be halved .
furthermore , for plane wave incidence the @xmath44 spherical attenuation factor is removed , and , if one refers the phase of the diffracted sound pressure relative to the arrival time at the edge , the phase oscillation factor @xmath45 also disappears , giving @xmath46 for plane wave incidence perpendicular to a right - angled wedge , for which @xmath47 ( i.e. @xmath48 ) , further simplification is obtained . now
. is @xmath49 and using multiple angle formulas one can show that @xmath50 where @xmath51 to summarise , for plane wave incidence perpendicular to the edge of a right - angled wedge , with @xmath52 , the total field is @xmath53{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}kr\cos(\theta-\theta_0)}\notag \\ & \quad+ r_1{{\rm h}}[\pi-\theta-\theta_0]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}kr\cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag \\ & \quad+ r_2{{\rm h}}[\theta+\theta_0 - 2\pi]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}kr\cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag \\ & \quad+ p_d(r,\theta ) , \label{eqn : ptotal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the diffracted field @xmath54 is given by eq .
and the remaining three terms represent the geometrical acoustics field ( here @xmath55 $ ] is the heaviside step function : @xmath55=1 $ ] , @xmath56 ; @xmath55=1/2 $ ] , @xmath57 ; @xmath55=0 $ ] , @xmath58 ) .
the first term in eq . represents the incident field , the second the reflected wave from the face @xmath32 and the third the reflected wave from @xmath33 .
@xmath59 are reflection coefficients : for the pure dirichlet case @xmath60 ; for the pure neumann case @xmath61 ; and for the mixed dirichlet / neumann and neumann / dirichlet cases @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 , @xmath65 , respectively . in order to understand how eq .
should be generalised to the case of impedance boundary conditions , it is instructive to review its derivation from the classical sommerfeld contour integral solution .
part of this derivation was presented already in ref .
@xcite , but in this section the analysis of ref .
@xcite will be extended to allow a complex incident angle @xmath35 , corresponding physically to diffraction by an inhomogeneous plane wave . for brevity
, attention will be restricted to the dirichlet case , but the neumann and mixed problems can be analysed similarly . for the dirichlet case
the sommerfeld contour integral solution is @xcite @xmath66 where the integration contour is in two parts : @xmath67 lies above all singularities of the integrand and goes from @xmath68 to @xmath69 , and @xmath70 lies below all singularities of the integrand and goes from @xmath71 to @xmath72 ( see fig .
[ fig : gamma ] ) .
the integral converges rapidly for all complex @xmath14 and @xmath35 , and the integrand has poles at @xmath73 for @xmath74 . as is pointed out in ref .
@xcite , the formula in eq .
makes sense not just for real @xmath75 , but also for all complex @xmath35 . ]
one can obtain an expression suitable for far field ( large @xmath76 ) evaluation by deforming the contour in eq . onto the steepest descent contours @xmath77 and @xmath78 passing through the saddle points at @xmath79 ( see fig .
[ fig : gamma ] ) .
these contours are defined by @xmath80 respectively , where @xmath81 is the gudermannian function with @xmath82 , @xmath83 for @xmath84 , and @xmath85 . to achieve the deformation one draws down the contour @xmath67 onto @xmath70 , picking up residue contributions from any poles lying between @xmath77 and @xmath78 .
assuming that @xmath86 and @xmath87 , one obtains@xcite @xmath88{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta-\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \;\;-{{\rm h}}[\pi-|\theta+\re{\theta_0}+\mathrm{gd}(\im{\theta_0})|]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \;\;-{{\rm h}}[\pi-|\theta+\re{\theta_0}+\mathrm{gd}(\im{\theta_0})-3\pi|]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \;\;+ p^d_d(r,\theta ) , \label{eqn : sommtotal}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
where @xmath89 @xmath90 and the integrals over @xmath77 and @xmath78 have been combined into a single integral over the contour @xmath91 illustrated in fig .
[ fig : contoura ] by the changes of variable @xmath92 .
note that eq . corrects a sign in one of the exponents in the corresponding formula in ref .
@xcite ( eq . ( 26 ) on p. 166 ) .
note also that in ref .
@xcite rawlins uses the equivalent representation @xmath93 the first term in eq . represents the incident wave , and the second and third terms in eq .
represent the two reflected waves . note that the location of the zone boundary across which these waves are switched on / off by the heaviside function prefactors is shifted compared to the case of purely real @xmath35 .
the shift agrees exactly with that derived in ref .
@xcite for the case of an inhomogeneous plane wave incident on a half plane .
note also that at a zone boundary the argument of one of the heaviside functions in eq
. equals zero , and a pole lies on the contour of integration . in this case a principal value integral should be taken in eq .
( for consistency with the assumption that @xmath94=1/2 $ ] ) ; the same convention applies to the other decompositions in eqs . , , and .
the edge source representation can then be obtained from eq . as follows .
first deform the contour of integration from @xmath91 to the imaginary axis @xmath95 in fig .
[ fig : contoura ] ( equivalently , deform the original contours @xmath67 and @xmath70 onto the vertical contours @xmath96 and @xmath97 in fig .
[ fig : gamma ] rather than @xmath77 and @xmath78 before changing variables ) .
then write the resulting integral as an integral over the positive imaginary axis only , applying the identity@xmath98 which follows from the identity @xmath99 finally , parametrise the resulting integral by @xmath100 so that @xmath101 and @xmath102 , giving @xmath103{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta-\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad-{{\rm h}}[\pi-|\theta+\re{\theta_0}|]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad-{{\rm h}}[\pi-|\theta+\re{\theta_0}-3\pi|]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+ p^d_{d,{\rm edge}}(r,\theta ) , \label{eqn : sommtotaledgesource}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath104 is given by the edge source integral in eq . .
clearly eq .
reduces to eq . when @xmath52 . for complex @xmath35
there is a discrepancy in the arguments of the heaviside functions between eqs . and ; this is simply a consequence of the contour deformation from @xmath91 to @xmath95 .
accordingly , eq . does not represent a decomposition of the field into ` geometrical acoustics ' and ` diffracted ' components , at least not in the sense understood in ref .
such discrepancies will have implications for the physical interpretation of the edge source integral derived for the impedance problem in the following section .
the main aim of this paper is to generalise eq . to the case of impedance boundary conditions , @xmath105 where the unit normal vector @xmath106 points into the wedge , and @xmath107 is the complex admittance ( inversely proportional to the impedance ) , which is assumed to satisfy @xmath108 , so as to prohibit energy creation at the boundary .
it will be assumed that @xmath107 takes a constant value on each of the two wedge faces , but that the value of this constant may be different for the two wedge faces . following ref .
@xcite , in order to simplify later formulas @xmath107 will be written @xmath109 where @xmath110 are complex angles such that @xmath111 recalling that the wedge faces are given respectively by @xmath112 , @xmath113 ( @xmath32 ) and @xmath114 , @xmath115 ( @xmath116 ) , the boundary condition in eq .
can then be stated as @xmath117 \dfrac{\partial p}{\partial x } = { { \rm i}}k \cos{\theta_2}p , & \textrm{on } \theta=3\pi/2 .
\end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that when @xmath107 takes the same value on both faces the angles @xmath118 and @xmath119 are related by @xmath120 , since @xmath121 .
rawlins shows that the total field @xmath122 for the impedance problem can be written as @xcite @xmath123 where @xmath124 and @xmath125 where @xmath126 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 denotes the dirichlet solution for incident angle @xmath129 ( this follows from eqs .
( 28)-(31 ) in ref . @xcite combined with standard trigonometric identities ) . for completeness note that in eq .
( 29 ) on p. 167 of ref .
@xcite , @xmath130 in the numerator should be @xmath131 .
rawlins derivation of eq . in ref .
@xcite is based on a trick first introduced by williams in ref .
@xcite to solve the analogous problem for a mixed neumann / impedance wedge . to evaluate the formula in eq .
, rawlins uses the representation for @xmath128 given in eq . , but translates @xmath132 to give @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the translated version of @xmath91 passing through the saddle point at @xmath135 ( see fig .
[ fig : contourb ] .
this transformation greatly simplifies the application of the differential operator @xmath136 because the spatial variables @xmath137 and @xmath138 occur only in the exponential factor in the integrand in eq . , with @xmath139 .
hence eq . can be evaluated as@xcite @xmath140{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta-\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+r_1^i{{\rm h}}[\pi-\theta-\theta_0]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+r_2^i{{\rm h}}[\theta+\theta_0 - 2\pi]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}k
r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+t_1^i{{\rm h}}[\pi-\theta-\re{\theta_1}-\operatorname{gd}(\im{\theta_1})]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_1)}\notag\\ & \quad+t_2^i{{\rm h}}[\theta+\re{\theta_2}+\operatorname{gd}(\im{\theta_2})-2\pi]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_2)}\notag\\ & \quad+ p^i_d(r,\theta ) , \label{eqn : sommtotalimp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath141 and ( changing variable back to @xmath142 ) @xmath143 the first term in eq . represents the incident field ; the second and third terms represent reflected waves from the two wedge faces ; the fourth and fifth terms represent surface waves propagating along the two wedge faces ; and the final term @xmath144 represents the diffracted field . a surface wave associated with the face @xmath32 is excited if @xmath145 , and in this case is confined to the angular region @xmath146 .
similarly , a surface wave associated with the face @xmath116 is excited if @xmath147 , and in this case is confined to the angular region @xmath148 . in terms of the admittance parameter @xmath107 , recalling eq .
one finds that surface waves are excited if @xmath149 the surface waves ( when they exist ) decay exponentially with increasing distance both perpendicular to and along the face with which they are associated ( unless @xmath107 is pure negative imaginary , in which case they maintain a constant amplitude along the face itself , decaying in the perpendicular direction ) .
the diffracted field @xmath150 can be approximated in the far field using the method of steepest descent , giving@xcite @xmath151 as @xmath152 , where the diffraction coefficient @xmath153 note that eq .
corrects a typographical error in ref .
@xcite : in eq .
( 36 ) of ref .
@xcite , @xmath154 in the denominator should be @xmath155 .
note also that the approximation in eq
. breaks down near zone boundaries ( i.e. , at values of @xmath14 for which the argument of one of the heaviside functions in eq .
equals zero ) .
a more sophisticated far field approximation , valid uniformly across the zone boundaries , is given in ref .
@xcite . an edge source representation for @xmath144 can be derived by closely following the procedure outlined in section [ sec : dirderivation ] for the dirichlet case .
first deform the contour of integration from @xmath91 to @xmath95 ( recall fig .
[ fig : contoura ] ) . then write the resulting integral as an integral over the positive imaginary axis only . simplifying the resulting expression
requires slightly more work than in the dirichlet case because the part of the integrand in eq .
not involving @xmath156 is no longer an even function of @xmath142 as it was in the dirichlet case . to deal with this ,
first decompose @xmath157 into a sum of even and odd parts ( with respect to @xmath142 ) @xmath158 then deal with the contribution from the even part using eq . , and that from the odd part using the identity @xmath159 where @xmath160 with @xmath161 eq
. follows from the identity @xmath162 finally , parametrising the contour using eq . gives an edge source representation for the impedance solution : @xmath140{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta-\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+r_1^i{{\rm h}}[\pi-\theta-\theta_0]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+r_2^i{{\rm h}}[\theta+\theta_0 - 2\pi]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}k
r \cos(\theta+\theta_0)}\notag\\ & \quad+t_1^i{{\rm h}}[\pi-\theta-\re{\theta_1}]{{\rm e}}^{-{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_1)}\notag\\ & \quad+t_2^i{{\rm h}}[\theta+\re{\theta_2}-2\pi]{{\rm e}}^{{{\rm i}}k r \cos(\theta+\theta_2)}\notag\\ & \quad+ p^i_{d,{\rm edge}}(r,\theta ) , \label{eqn : sommtotalimpedgesource}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath163 and @xmath164 where @xmath165 and , for @xmath166 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 denote the functions @xmath31 and @xmath169 evaluated at incidence angle @xmath129 .
with regard to surface waves , note that the arguments of the heaviside functions multiplying the fourth and fifth terms on the right - hand - side of eq .
are always equal to zero except in the degenerate cases ( i ) @xmath170 and @xmath32 and ( ii ) @xmath171 and @xmath172 , respectively .
thus , recalling the discussion at the end of section [ sec : impcontint ] , one finds that if either @xmath118 or @xmath119 is such that surface waves are present , these surface waves must form part of the edge source integral in eq . .
in this case , in the region where the surface waves exist it holds that @xmath173 so that the edge source integral in eq .
can not be associated solely with the diffracted field , as is the case for ideal ( dirichlet or neumann ) boundary conditions with a real incidence angle .
nonetheless , one can check that by applying the method of stationary phase to the integral in eq .
, the far - field diffraction coefficient approximation in eq . is recovered .
this does not contradict the above remarks ( in particular eq . ) since the surface wave contributions ( when present ) are exponentially small with respect to increasing @xmath76 , and hence are not picked up by the method of stationary phase .
it should be remarked that the existence of the edge source representation in eq .
is of mainly theoretical interest ( for example in the development of approximate solutions for finite edges and of edge integral equation formulations of scattering problems - see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . for numerical computations of the infinite wedge solution at medium to high frequencies the expression in eq . should be used rather than that in eq . , because of the faster convergence of the integral in eq .
compared to that in eq . .
a secondary edge source representation has been presented ( in eq . ) for the exact solution of scattering of a plane wave at perpendicular incidence on a right - angled impedance wedge . when the impedance parameters are such that surface waves are present , the edge source integral can not be associated solely with the diffracted field , as in the case of ideal ( dirichlet or neumann ) boundary conditions , because it also incorporates the surface waves .
a similar edge source representation should also be possible for general wedge angles , starting from the contour integral solutions in refs .
@xcite and @xcite .
but the analysis , and the resulting edge integral , are expected to be significantly more complicated than in the right - angled case considered here , for which one has the particularly simple contour integral solution provided by ref .
another interesting problem would be the derivation of edge source representations for more general incident waves , for example line source or point source excitation .
however , to the present author s knowledge no convenient contour integral solution exists for these cases . certainly the expressions obtained would be significantly more complicated than those obtained here for plane wave incidence ; for a start , the green s function for a line source or point source above an impedance boundary can not be obtained by the method of images , as it can in the plane wave case .
these generalisations are left for future work . | this paper concerns the frequency domain problem of diffraction of a plane wave incident on an infinite right - angled wedge on which impedance ( absorbing ) boundary conditions are imposed .
it is demonstrated that the exact sommerfeld - malyuzhinets contour integral solution for the diffracted field can be transformed to a line integral over a physical variable along the diffracting edge .
this integral can be interpreted as a superposition of secondary point sources ( with directivity ) positioned along the edge , in the spirit of the edge source formulations for rigid ( sound - hard ) wedges derived in [ u. p. svensson , p. t. calamia and s. nakanishi , acta acustica / acustica 95 , 2009 , pp .
568 - 572 ] .
however , when surface waves are present the physical interpretation of the edge source integral must be altered : it no longer represents solely the diffracted field , but rather includes surface wave contributions . |
we thank r. liotta for stimulating discussions and his reading of the manuscript .
this work was supported by the swedish research council ( vr ) under grant nos .
621 - 2012 - 3805 , and 621 - 2013 - 4323 .
the calculations were performed on resources provided by the swedish national infrastructure for computing ( snic ) at nsc in linkping and pdc at kth , stockholm .
b. bally , b. avez , m. bender , p .- h .
heenen , phys .
113 , 162501 ( 2014 ) .
a. litvinov et al . , phys .
95 ( 2005 ) 042501 .
a. v. afanasjev , s. e. agbemava , d. ray , and p. ring , phys .
c 91 ( 2015 ) 014324
. s. changizi and c. qi , phys .
c 91 ( 2015 ) 024305 .
m. beiner , h. flocard , n. van giai , p. quentin , nucl .
a238 ( 1975 ) 29 .
p. klupfel , p .- g .
reinhard , t. j. brvenich , and j. a. maruhn , phys .
c 79 ( 2009 ) 034310 .
m. bender , j. dobaczewski , j. engel , w. nazarewicz , phys.rev .
c 65 ( 2002 ) 054322 and references therein .
w. satula , aip conf .
381 ( 1999 ) 141 .
k. j. pototzky , j. erler , p. -g .
reinhard , v. o. nesterenko , eur .
j. a 46 ( 2010 ) 299 .
j margueron , s goriely , m grasso , g colo and h sagawa , j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
36 ( 2009 ) 125103 . l. m. robledo , r. bernard , g. f. bertsch , phys . rev .
c 86 ( 2012 ) 064313 .
afanasjev , h. abusara , phys .
c 81 ( 2010 ) 014309 ; 82 ( 2010 ) 034329 .
afanasjev , s.shawaqfeh , phys .
b 706 ( 2011 ) 177 . h. d. xu , y. wang , j. li , j.b .
lu , nucl .
phys . a 929 ( 2014 ) 191 . | the empirical pairing gaps derived from four different odd - even mass staggering formulas are compared . by performing single-@xmath0 shell and multi - shell seniority model calculations as well as by using the standard hfb approach with skyrme force we show that the simplest three - point formula @xmath1 $ ] can provide a good measure of the neutron pairing gap in even-@xmath2 nuclei .
it removes to a large extent the contribution from the nuclear mean field as well as contributions from shell structure details .
it is also less contaminated by the wigner effect for nuclei around @xmath3 .
we also show that the strength of @xmath4 can serve as a good indication of the two - particle spatial correlation in the nucleus of concern and that the weakening of @xmath4 in some neutron - rich nuclei indicates that the di - neutron correlation itself is weak in these nuclei .
the occurrence of a systematic odd - even staggering ( oes ) of the nuclear binding energy has long been identified in nuclear physics , which is associated with the pairing correlation @xcite .
it plays an important role in many nuclear phenomena and is the dominant many - body correlation beyond the nuclear mean field . yet , in spite of the many efforts performed in the study of pairing correlations , there are still features which may be induced by the pairing interaction that are not well understood @xcite .
in particular , this is the case in neutron - rich nuclei , where the study of effects induced by pairing may shed light on the understanding of various exotic phenomena ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) .
the simplest expression one can use to extract the empirical pairing gap from the oes of the binding energy is the three - point formula @xcite , which for systems with even neutrons acquires the form @xcite @xmath5\\ = -\frac{1}{2}[s_n(n+1,z)-s_n(n , z)]\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath6 is the ( positive ) binding energy and @xmath7 is the one - neutron separation energy . the proton pairing gap can be defined in a similar way .
the above formula indicates that @xmath8 measures the additional binding gain by the last neutron in the even-@xmath2 system relative to the odd system with one more neutron .
however , besides pairing , a number of other mechanisms may contribute to the oes @xcite .
this includes effects induced by the mean field in deformed nuclei ( or the kramers degeneracy ) and the contribution from the diagonal interaction matrix elements of the two - body force . as discussed in detail in refs .
@xcite by satula and co - workers , the contribution from the quickly varying single - particle structure of the mean field to the empirical pairing gap is minimized in odd - mass systems . in even systems where the last neutrons occupy different orbitals
the single - particle energy contributes substantially to @xmath8@xcite .
alternatively , there is another version of the three - point formula written as @xmath9\\ = \frac{1}{2}\left[b(n , z)+b(n-2,z)-2b(n-1,z)\right ] \\ = \frac{1}{2}[s_{2n}(n , z)-2s_n(n-1,z)],\end{gathered}\ ] ] which actually corresponds to @xmath10 for the case of odd nuclei @xcite .
@xmath11 is smaller than @xmath8 in most cases .
it is often stated that @xmath11 measures the pairing effect in the odd nuclei , as illustrated in ref .
@xcite , whereas @xmath8 is impacted by single particle states ( see e.g. , recent discussion in ref . @xcite and references therein ) .
the challenging problems thus arise include : one lacks a measure of the pairing gap in the even system , which is mixed with the deformation effect , and the empirical pairing gap for the odd system is related to pairing only in an indirect manner ( i.e. , the energy loss due to the absence of pairing ) .
the physics becomes even more obscure when abrupt changes occur , e.g. , around shell closures . in practice , as a compromise , the value of @xmath11 has often been compared to the theoretical pairing gap calculated for the even systems @xcite and to the oes derived from theoretical binding energies @xcite . the direct comparison between the theoretical pairing gap and empirical oes is convenient from a computational point of view since only one single calculation is required , which avoids the complicated handling of the blocking effect in the odd nuclei . it is known that the theoretical pairing gap , e.g. , that from the bcs theory , is not an observable and can not be compared with the empirical oes in a straightforward way .
however , they can be quantitatively quite close to each other in most cases and both of them are still important quantities that deserves further attention .
in particular , within the bcs approach , the corresponding pairing gap is given by @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the pairing strength , and @xmath14 , @xmath15 are the standard occupation numbers .
this implies that the pairing gaps can serve as a signature of the change in two - particle spatial correlation / clusterization , since they are also proportional to @xmath16 .
this feature is also responsible for the clustering of the four nucleons that eventually constitute the @xmath17-particle at the nuclear surface of heavy nuclei @xcite . in this paper
we would like to argue that , among the expressions for the oes studied here , the simple three - point formula @xmath18 removes to a large extent the contribution from the varying part of the nuclear mean field as well as contributions from other shell structure details and can serve as a reliable indication for the pairing effect in even-@xmath2 systems .
in other words , @xmath18 can be compared to the theoretical pairing gap in a semi - quantitive manner and thus contains fruitful information on the pairing effects . in particular
, the abrupt changes in @xmath18 do have physical meaning .
moreover , by using @xmath18 one can make it more convenient to extract the neutron - proton interaction from binding energy differences @xcite .
we will also show that @xmath18 is free from the wigner effect for nuclei around @xmath3 and that its weakening in some neutron - rich nuclei may indicate that the di - neutron spatial correlation itself is weak in those nuclei .
there are other formulas available for the pairing gap including the so - called four - point and the five - point formulas .
the four - point formula is defined as @xcite @xmath19\\ = \frac{1}{2}[\delta^{(3)}(n)+\delta^{(3)}_c(n)].\end{gathered}\ ] ] that is , it measures the average value of @xmath10 in adjacent even and odd systems .
the five - point formula is given by @xcite @xmath20\\ = \frac{1}{4}[\delta^{(3)}_c(n+2)+2\delta^{(3)}(n)+\delta^{(3)}_c(n)].\end{gathered}\ ] ] the five - point formula is also used in refs .
@xcite . in refs . @xcite
, the experimental pairing gap is taken as the average of adjacent ones deduced through the three - point formula as @xmath21 , \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is actually also a five - point formula involving the same group of nuclei as @xmath22 but with different weights for each nucleus .
our calculations show that there is no significant difference between the results derived from @xmath23 and @xmath18 for open - shell nuclei where the pairing gap is a smooth function of @xmath2 . for the same reason , @xmath24 and @xmath25
show quite a similar behavior for most nuclei .
noticeable differences between @xmath26 and @xmath18 may be seen where abrupt changes in pairing correlations are expected to happen , e.g. , around shell closures , which is smoothed out in the former case .
[ htdp ] empirical neutron pairing gaps ( in mev ) from different oes formulas for all even - even nuclei as a function of neutron number @xmath2 . results which errors larger than @xmath27 kev are marked in red color .
the dashed curves are determined by fitting to the data .
the solid horizontal lines show the average value of @xmath28 ( [email protected] mev ) and the corresponding @xmath30 uncertainty ) . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the empirical pairing gaps obtained by various oes formulas are shown in fig .
[ fig:4gaps_errors ] for which the nuclear binding energies are extracted from refs .
@xcite .
the results are fitted by the expression @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath17 are parameters to be determined .
our calculations show that this expression performs equally well as the usual @xmath33-dependence fit , as can be seen in table [ tab : fitt ] where the results of fitting a power function to the different mass formulas as a function of neutron number , @xmath2 , and mass numbers , @xmath33 , are given .
it is also seen that the dependence of the gap upon the neutron or mass number is weakest for @xmath4 .
this is consistent with the conclusions of refs .
@xcite that the pairing gap should not show significant mass dependence . only in nine cases
one has @xmath4 larger than 2 mev .
they correspond to @xmath34be ( 4.11 ) , @xmath35be ( 2.57 ) , @xmath35c ( 3.53 ) , @xmath36c ( 2.8 ) , @xmath37o ( 3.15 ) , @xmath38ne ( 2.6 ) , @xmath39 mg ( 2.3 ) , @xmath40si ( 2.02 ) and @xmath41ti ( 2.0 ) ( within parenthesis are the corresponding pairing gaps in mev ) .
the mean values of the pairing gaps corresponding to the different expressions given above are ( in mev ) @xmath8 = 1.46 , @xmath4 = 1.08 , @xmath42 = 1.26 and @xmath22 = 1.26 .
we also evaluated the empirical pairing gaps for the proton for which one obtains @xmath43 mev , which contains a smooth contribution from the coulomb field .
in table [ tab : fitt ] we also included calculations for the even-@xmath2 odd-@xmath44 nuclei .
however , it should be mentioned that the empirical oes @xmath4 thus extracted contains a sizable negative contribution from the residual neutron - proton interaction between the odd particles in the intermediate odd - odd nuclei . as indicated in eqs .
( 1 ) , ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) , all these oes formulas contain constantly a contribution from the mean field which peaks at the shell closure and persists in open - shell nuclei @xcite .
for the same reason , the oes formula eq .
( 2 ) may not be applicable to evaluate the pairing gaps in odd-@xmath2 nuclei .
differences between the neutron gaps derived from different gap formulas in fig .
1 with respect to @xmath18 . the right bottom figure shows the neutron gaps for @xmath45 nuclei in comparison with their corresponding fitted curves from fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] same as fig .
[ fig : diff_gaps_subplot3 ] but for the difference between @xmath46 and @xmath18 in selected isotopic chains .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] the differences between the various gap formulas and @xmath47 are plotted in figs . [
fig : diff_gaps_subplot3 ] and [ fig : diff_gaps_subplot4 ] .
the dispersal of the data below @xmath48 ( @xmath49 ) as well as around shell closures can be an indication of the significant mean - field contribution to the gaps in above regions , which is expected to show a @xmath50 dependence @xcite . in this context it is worthwhile to point out that the differences between @xmath8 and @xmath28 was found to be a consequence of the gap between the single - particle energies of the corresponding neighboring orbitals @xcite .
as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : diff_gaps_subplot4 ] , the differences between @xmath47 and @xmath51 show quite small values for nuclei that can be reasonably described within a single-@xmath0 shell or nearly - degenerate systems , e.g. , for nuclei with @xmath2 between 20 and 28 ( @xmath52 ) as well as @xmath2 below ( @xmath53 ) and above ( @xmath54 ) @xmath55 . for these systems , as we will show below , the difference between @xmath47 and @xmath51 is mainly induced by the pauli and particle blocking effects .
@xmath56 show quite large values around @xmath3 nuclei with @xmath57 and 22 .
one may suspect that @xmath56 is still contaminated by the wigner effect , which refers to the additional binding gained in @xmath3 nuclei .
this is indeed the case for all the other three oes formulas where , as seen in the lower right panel of fig .
2 , the calculated gap values for @xmath3 nuclei are systematically much larger than the average values . on the other hand ,
the calculated @xmath58 values for @xmath3 nuclei follow nicely the average behavior , as it was also shown in ref .
@xcite , even though relatively large fluctuations are present .
these fluctuation may be due to dramatic changes in the mean field when going from the daughter ( @xmath59 ) system to the mother nucleus .
for instance , they may be due to quite different deformation properties .
an illustration of this is provided by the nucleus @xmath34be , which shows a deformed two-@xmath17-particle cluster structure while @xmath60be ( as well as the mirror nucleus @xmath60he ) is spherical .
this is also the case for the nuclei @xmath38ne and @xmath41ti which are expected to gain additional binding due to the strong neutron - proton quadrupole correlation .
to illustrate the origin of the oes and the difference between different formulas , we start with the simple seniority model . for a system with @xmath61 identical particles in a single @xmath0-shell
, the binding energy can be solved analytically in the seniority scheme .
the hamiltonian for such a model can be written as @xcite , @xmath62 where @xmath63 represents the quasi - spin operator , and @xmath64 and @xmath65 are creation and annihilation operators .
@xmath13 is the strength of the pairing interaction .
the energy of the state with seniority @xmath66 can be written as @xmath67 if one assumes @xmath68 for the ground state of even - even system and @xmath69 for that of the odd system , the expression above can be simplified as @xmath70(j+1)g,\\ & = & \left[\frac{n}{2}\right]\left(\left[\frac{n}{2}\right]-1\right)g + \delta_{v,1}\left[\frac{n}{2}\right ] g+\left[\frac{n}{2}\right]e_2\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath71 $ ] denotes the largest integer not exceeding n/2 and corresponds to the total number of @xmath68 pairs .
the nonlinear term in the equation above , which is proportional to @xmath72 or more exactly @xmath73\left(\left[\frac{n}{2}\right]-1\right)$ ] , is related to the energy loss due to the pauli effect .
the @xmath74 term in above equation indicates the energy loss in the @xmath69 odd system due to the the particle ( pauli ) blocking effect : the unpaired particle blocks the scattering of other pairs to its own level . in practice
, the odd system corresponds to a even system with one less particle and with a lower degeneracy . a schematic plot for the competition between the pauli blocking effect and pairing blocking effect of the unpaired odd particle .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] @xmath75 is the energy of one pair .
this term is the one that contributes to the theoretical oes and for systems with even @xmath61
we have @xmath76 it should be emphasized that a striking feature one thus finds is that the two blocking terms cancel each other in @xmath77 and they do not contribute to the pairing gap . a schematic picture is given in fig . [ sch ] to illustrate this point .
however , as implied from the figure , this is not the case for @xmath78 for which one has , @xmath79 where the term @xmath80 is due to the superfluous contribution from the blocking effects .
this unwanted term is the main origin of the differences between @xmath81 and @xmath10 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : diff_gaps_subplot4 ] , in nuclei that can be well described within a single @xmath0 shell . for non - degenerate systems the pairing collectivity manifests itself through the correlated contribution from many configurations , which is induced by the non - diagonal matrix elements of the pairing interaction in a shell - model context . for two particles in a non - degenerate system with a constant pairing
, the energy can be evaluated through the well known relation , @xmath82 the corresponding wave function amplitudes are given by @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the normalization constant .
all amplitudes @xmath85 contribute to the two - particle clustering with the same phase due to the strongly attractive nature of the pairing interaction .
the correlation energy induced by the monopole pairing corresponds to the difference @xmath86 where @xmath87 denotes the lowest orbital . as the gap @xmath88 increases the amplitude @xmath85
becomes more dispersed , resulting in stronger two - particle spatial correlation .
this difference , or more exactly @xmath89 with the self energy removed , is an important measure of the two - particle spatial correlation at the surface , reflected in a corresponding clustering of the two nucleons forming the pair ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) .
this clustering induces an increase in the strength of the corresponding pair - transfer reaction . as an example , in fig .
[ fig3 ] we consider a simple model with a set of equally spaced levels with double degeneracy .
we consider 16 levels and the single - particle energy is taken as @xmath90 .
the total energy is obtained by diagonalizing the corresponding hamiltonian matrix .
it is found that the total energy for such a system follows closely a relation similar to eq .
( [ eqs ] ) @xmath91\left(\left[\frac{n}{2}\right]-1\right)\mathcal{g } + \delta_{v,1}(\varepsilon_b+\delta)\nonumber\\ & & + \left[\frac{n}{2}\right]e_2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath92 is the single - particle energy of the unpaired orbital for a odd system , @xmath87 is the energy loss due to the related blocking effect .
it contributes significantly to the oes and determines its evolutions as a function of pair number .
@xmath93 is a parameter that is related to the pairing strength and level density .
one has @xmath94 and 1.06 for @xmath95 and 0.5 , respectively . within the simple bcs context
, the separation energy is approximately given by @xmath96 and @xmath97 , where @xmath98 is the fermi energy .
one thus gets @xmath99 but one should bear in mind , as the exact solution of the pairing hamiltonian in fig .
[ fig3 ] indicates , that there is still a sizable difference between the blocking effect and the oes especially for small systems with only few particles .
pairing gaps @xmath100 for a equally spaced douby degenerate system with 16 levels and @xmath95 ( solid circle ) and 0.5 ( open circle ) .
the triangles denote the contribution from the particle blocking effect , @xmath87.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] from a macroscopic point of view , there may be a residual contribution to @xmath47 from the symmetry energy ( expected to be negative ) and other non - linear terms of the binding energy @xcite .
our calculations with the liquid drop model show that the average residual contributions are around -60 kev and -200 kev for neutron and proton pairing gaps , respectively .
the later case is dominated by a smooth contribution from the coulomb field .
the main argument for the usage of @xmath101 instead is that the smooth non - linear terms in the binding energy can be canceled up to the fourth order @xcite .
that is , it removes the liquid - drop contribution to the oes to the largest extent .
however , as mentioned in ref .
@xcite , the disadvantage is that the odd - even effects may be diminished as a result of the averaging over nuclei further apart .
it should also be mentioned that there is an additional contribution to the binding energy from the diagonal matrix element with @xmath102 ( the so - called self - energy ) which is equal to @xmath103g$ ] . in the ideal case
, one should have this contribution removed and the pairing gap for a single-@xmath0 system will be of the form @xmath104 for heavy nuclei the bcs coupling constant roughly takes @xmath105 which gives a contribution to @xmath100 that is comparable but opposite to that of the smooth contribution from the nonlinear terms mentioned above . in the other words , one may expect that these two unwanted contributions largely cancel each other . as a result ,
if one assume that both contributions to the binding energy have been taken into account by the hf configuration , for the neutron pairing gap one is expected to have @xcite @xmath106 all the variety of oes formulas studied above have their advantages and disadvantages ( see , earlier discussions in refs .
@xcite ) . we will focus on the simple @xmath47 particular for two reasons : it is the one that may be least contaminated by the nuclear shell effect and it involves only three nuclei .
these are important for our study of unstable nuclei where the experimental data are scarce wheras the unknown shell evolution can play a decisive role . for open shell nuclei ,
the uncertainty as related to the different definiation of the oes is much smaller as compared to the uncertainty induced by our limitted understanding of the density functional and the shell structure of dripline nuclei .
our aims are to understand the pairing properties of neutron dripline nuclei and to extract reliable information from binding energies based on the gap @xmath107 .
we hope that this may shed light on our understanding of the stability mechanisms as well as probing the importance of di - neutron spatial correlations in these nuclei .
it is theoretically suggested that di - neutron correlations may be enhanced in some situations such as in a low density region of nuclear matter and in the surface of finite neutron - rich nuclei @xcite . to explore this point further
we have done systematic calculations in semi - magic neutron - rich ( dripline ) nuclei by using the hartree - fock - bogoliubov ( hfb ) formalism , which is expected to be more reliable than the simple bcs approach . in the standard hfb formalism
, the hamiltonian is reduced to the mean field in the particle - hole channel and the pairing field in the particle - particle channel .
the hfb equations are , @xmath108 where @xmath109 and @xmath110 are the two components of the single quasi - particle wave functions .
we evaluated the coordinate - space solutions by using the hfb solver hfbrad in a spherical box @xcite . in the particle - hole channel we used the skyrme functional with the sly4 parameter set @xcite . in the particle - particle channel we used the zero - range @xmath87 interaction given by @xcite @xmath111 here
@xmath112 is the pairing strength , @xmath113 is the isoscalar nucleonic density and @xmath114 .
@xmath115 and 1 correspond to the volume and surface pairings , respectively .
we have done calculations by using different pairing interactions but for simplicity only results corresponding to the mixed pairing with @xmath116 are shown .
the pairing strength is fitted to give a mean neutron gap of @xmath117mev in @xmath118sn and no @xmath33 or isospin dependence is considered .
calculations are done in a box with the size @xmath119 fm .
only quasiparticle states with energy lower than 60 mev are taken into account .
calculated @xmath120 and @xmath121 for ca ( upper ) and sn ( lower ) together with the experimental @xmath47 and calculated @xmath47 by using the hfrabd and hfbtho codes .
( explained in the text).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] calculated @xmath120 and @xmath121 for ca ( upper ) and sn ( lower ) together with the experimental @xmath47 and calculated @xmath47 by using the hfrabd and hfbtho codes .
( explained in the text).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=38.0% ] besides oes from calculated binding energies , two different theoretical gaps will be compared with the experimental pairing gap @xmath122 : the canonical gap @xmath120 , which consists of the diagonal elements of the pairing - field matrix for the lowest canonical state ( lcs ) , and the average gap @xmath121 , that is the average value of the pairing fields @xcite . as typical examples , in fig .
[ fig : tincalcium ] we plotted @xmath120 and @xmath121 calculated for calcium and tin isotopes , which have been intensively studied quite recently from different perspectives .
the results are compared with experimental @xmath47 and calculated @xmath47 which is the pairing gap calculated from the hfb binding energies by using eq .
( 2 ) . in the latter case
, the binding energies are calculated using the code hfbrad ( in the coordinate representation within the spherical symmetry ) @xcite and compared with those from the code hfbtho ( in the axial deformed harmonic oscillator basis ) @xcite as a cross - check for our calculations .
the two calculations should give very similar results if the influence of both the continuum and deformation is negligible .
indeed , as can be seen from the figure , the results from the two codes are very close to each other in most cases and come even closer if spherical symmetry constraint is applied in the latter case . in both codes calculations for odd-@xmath2 isotopes
are done within the blocking approximation using the equal filling approximation @xcite . in practice ,
we have done calculations by blocking all possible quasiparticle orbitals around the fermi surface and the one that gives the highest binding energy is chosen .
a self - consistent treatment of the blocking for the one - quasiparticle hfb state is done in ref .
@xcite by taking into account beyond mean field effects using the generator coordinate method . in general the values of calculated @xmath47
are closer to the experimental @xmath47 than the two theoretical hfb pairing gaps , which vanish at closed shell .
the results for @xmath120 and @xmath121 are practically the same in most cases in fig .
[ fig : tincalcium ] .
but it should be mentioned that both definitions of the theoretical pairing gap have their advantages and disadvantages .
the use of @xmath120 as a measure of the pairing gap is questioned in ref .
@xcite and in refs .
@xcite for dripline nuclei . in the relativistic hartree - bogoliubov calculations for selected isotopic and isotonic chains with a finite - range pairing force as presented in ref .
@xcite , it is seen that @xmath121 are systematically smaller than @xmath120 and come closer to the @xmath10 and @xmath123 indicators . in ref .
@xcite , it is also shown that the neutron @xmath120 vanishes at the drip line for nearly all semi - magic isotopic chains studied whereas the gap @xmath121 can persist in some cases .
on the other hand , @xmath121 and @xmath120 can give quite similar prediction for bound nuclei .
calculations in ref .
@xcite show that @xmath120 can be closer to the experimental average gap eq .
( [ eq : averr ] ) than @xmath121 . in the relativistic mean field calculations
@xcite , the calculated mean gaps and oes agree pretty well with each other . in ref .
@xcite , the mean gap and oes from calculated binding energies are compared with the empirical oes for even - even hafnium isotopes , where it is found that quantatively the mean gap reproduces better the trend in experimental data .
the level spacing is crucial for pairing correlation which strongly depends on the shell structure @xcite and on the deformation @xcite .
a general calculations including the deformation effects are done recently in ref .
@xcite with a separable pairing interaction of finite range .
it is shown that the differences in the underlying single - particle structure represent the major source of uncertainty in the prediction of drip line and the pairing properties in neutron rich nuclei depend substantially on the different covariant energy density functionals .
in particular , the emergence of deformation driving intruder orbitals can lower the chemical potential and make the system bound whereas extruder orbitals with high @xmath124 values can make the system unbound . a systematic calculation on the possible effect of the density dependence of the zero - range pairing force on the pairing correlation of dripline nuclei
is also shown in ref .
@xcite . calculated
@xmath120 and @xmath121 for ca ( upper ) and sn ( lower ) isotopes upto the neutron dripline with three different skyrme parameter sets in comparison with the corresponding calculated oes @xmath18.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] calculated @xmath120 and @xmath121 for ca ( upper ) and sn ( lower ) isotopes upto the neutron dripline with three different skyrme parameter sets in comparison with the corresponding calculated oes @xmath18.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] to explore the dependence of our calculations on the functionals , in fig .
[ fig : tincalcium2 ] we extended our calculations for ca and sn isotopes shown in fig .
[ fig : tincalcium ] to the neutron dripline .
calculations are done with the siii @xcite , sly4 @xcite as well as the recently proposed sv - bas @xcite skyrme functionals .
the two - neutron dripline occurs around @xmath125 and @xmath126 for those two isotopic chains .
it is thus found that the calculated oes agrees well with the two pairing gaps for known nuclei but noticable differences are seen as the neutorn number increases . in particular , big differences among different calculations
are seen for ca isotopes around @xmath127 in relation to the different predictions of the emergence of the @xmath127 , 34 and 40 subshells .
significant deviations between @xmath121 and @xmath120 are seen in sv - bas calculations for nuclei beyond the dripline .
in fact , ref .
@xcite has shown that there is a distinct difference between the mean gap and the lowest canonical gap beyond drip - line for calculations with surface - peaked pairing interaction .
a similar deviation may happen in calculations with the mixed pairing interaction , as in the case shown in fig .
[ fig : tincalcium2 ] . however , this is usually not the case for volume interactions .
it should be mentioned that the time - odd field is not considered in the hfbtho and hfbrad calculations shown in the figure , which may affect the binding energy of the odd-@xmath33 nucleus and the corresponding oes .
the time - odd field can contribute to the ground state mean fields of odd-@xmath33 and odd - odd nuclei ( breaking the kramer s degeneracy ) as well as in nuclear rotation and other dynamic processes @xcite .
the time - odd field , which is still relatively poorly understood and functional dependent , is neglected in most relativistic and non - relativistic mean field calculations .
the possible influence of the time - odd field in light @xmath128 nuclei is discussed in ref .
@xcite .
systematic skyrme hartree - fock plus bcs calculations with the time - odd field for odd-@xmath33 nuclei between@xmath129 are presented recently in ref .
@xcite .
it was shown that the influence of the time - odd field is generally small and decrease rapidly with increasing mass number .
in particular , there is no indication that the deviation between experimental and theoretical oes can be improved by the inclusion of the time - odd field @xcite , from which the fluctuation induced is much smaller than that from the different functional .
skyrme hfb calculations with the time - odd field are also done for the whole mass table in ref .
@xcite and for rare earth nuclei with @xmath130 and @xmath131 in ref .
@xcite .
it is found that the average energy shift as induced by the time - odd field is only 50 kev but with a large deviation of 42 kev and hence the equal filling approximation is precise for most practical calculations .
a similar conclusion may be draw from gogny hfb calculations where full calculations with the time - odd field give very similar results to those from the filling approximation and the inclusion of the time - odd field hardly improves the gap description @xcite .
recent systemtic calculations on the effect of the time - odd field in the relativistic mean field approach can be found in refs . @xcite and references therein .
ref .
@xcite found that the time - odd field in the relativisitic mean field approach always induces an additional binding but weakly affects the relative energies of different quasiparticle states in medium and heavy mass nuclei .
the influence of that attractive contribution from the time - odd mean field to the odd nuclei into oes can be of up to 10% in light nuclei and of around 5 - 6% in heavy nuclei .
however , even in that case , the required modification of the strength of pairing force is modest @xcite , which is significantly smaller than earlier expectations . in ref .
@xcite , it is suggested that the @xmath18 can be a measure of the sole pairing gap if the contribution from the time - odd reversal symmetry breaking field cancels out the contribution from the smooth part of the total energy .
upper : the two - neutron spatial correlation plots for @xmath132ca ( left ) and @xmath133ca ( right ) .
lower : same as upper but for @xmath134sn ( left , 4 holes ) and @xmath135sn ( right , 4 particles ) .
calculations are done with the sly4 force .
notice that the scale is different.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] in ref .
@xcite it is mentioned that for spherical nuclei where the drip line occurs around neutron closed shells the pairing gap is expected to be reduced .
our calculations show that this is indeed the case for neutron - rich ca and sn isotopes .
our understanding of the shell structure in ca isotopes have been significantly extended recently ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) . @xmath127 and 34 have been shown to be new magic numbers in ca isotopes , a conclusion which is supported by hfb calculations @xcite .
the @xmath18 values for @xmath136ca are much smaller than those for nuclei in the @xmath137 shell . the pairing gap for @xmath133ca is expected to be even smaller . in the upper panel of fig . [ fig : twopar_subplot ] , following the same procedure as in ref .
@xcite , we evaluated in the canonical basis the two - neutron spatial correlations in @xmath133ca and compared it with that in @xmath132ca .
the results are plotted as a function of the angle @xmath138 between the two neutrons and the radius @xmath139 where @xmath140 is the radius of the single - particle wave function .
for strongly correlated wave functions , the two - neutron spatial correlation is expected to peak at @xmath141 at the surface . as can be seen from the figure ,
the peak in @xmath132ca is much stronger than that in @xmath142ca .
the pairing tensor as a function of radius @xmath140 for neutron - rich nuclei @xmath143ca ( solid line ) and @xmath144sn ( dashed line ) as calculated from different skyrme parameterizations.,scaledwidth=45.0% ] the spatial correlation of the neutron pair can also be inferred from the pairing / abnormal density @xmath145 . in fig .
[ fignnn ] , we plotted the calculated pairing tensor which is defined as @xmath146 and is related to the pair transfer form factor , for two nuclei @xmath143ca ( solid line ) and @xmath144sn .
@xmath143ca is at the neutron dripline for which the calculated pairing tensors and pairing gaps from difference functionals can be quite different .
the nucleus @xmath144sn is within the dripline .
the pairing tensors calculated from the three functional are quite close to each other . but as can be seen from fig .
[ fig : tincalcium2 ] , there is a significant difference between the theoretial mean gap @xmath121 and the oes from the theoretical binding energies .
a similar deviation is also seen in ref .
@xcite .
the origin for such a large deviation is not exactly known yet .
it may be related to the fact that , for sn isotopes in this region , the chemical potential @xmath98 is pretty close to zero and the quasiparticle orbitals involved in the blocking calculations are all unbound . for such cases ,
the theoretical oes and gaps have to be carefully interpreted .
there is a noticeable kink at @xmath147 for tin isotopes which may be related to the occupancy of the low degeneracy orbital @xmath148 .
a sudden drop occurs in the experimental pairing gaps in the sn isotopes when going from @xmath149 to @xmath150 .
this can be reproduced by the hfb calculations with the volume and mixed pairing interactions @xcite .
that drop is related to the reduced level density above n=82 .
that is , there is a noticeable gap between the @xmath151 orbital and the higher- lying ones . which may result in a @xmath152 sub shell closure @xcite .
the reduced pairing collectivity in these nuclei can be clearly seen in the two - neutron spatial correlation plots given in the lower part of fig .
[ fig : twopar_subplot ] , where we compared @xmath134sn , which have four holes in the core @xmath153sn , and @xmath135sn , with four particles above the core .
as can be seen from the figure , the peak in @xmath134sn is around one order of magnitude stronger than that in @xmath135sn .
hfb describes very well the pairing gap as well as the two - particle spatial correlation in open - shell nuclei .
a known problem is that both the bcs and the hfb condensates collapse at closed shell , since in this case all orbitals are fully occupied ( c.f . , eq .
( 13 ) ) .
in fact , as the systematic calculations in ref .
@xcite shows , roughly 20 - 30% of the known nuclei contain collapsed bcs or hfb condensates .
it is therefore fair to affirm that the failure of these two approaches to reproduce the oes does not necessary mean that there is no pairing correlation in these nuclei .
two typical examples are @xmath154ca and @xmath153sn shown in fig .
[ fig : twopar_subplot ] .
these two nuclei show @xmath47 values similar to neighboring nuclei below the closed shell .
indeed our calculations with the seniority model @xcite show that the two - neutron spatial correlations in these two nuclei are as strong as those in neighboring ones .
again , @xmath47 is a good indication of the two - neutron correlation in these cases . anyway , as mentioned above , comparisons between the theoretical gaps from even - even nuclei can only be compared with the empirical pairing gap in a semi - quantitative manner . in summary
, in this paper we compared the pairing gaps derived from four different oes formulas .
we showed that @xmath100 gauge very well the nuclear pairing correlation since it removes to a large extent the contribution from the single - particle structure of the nuclear mean field and the shell effect .
it can serve as a reliable filter if one is primarily interested in evaluating the pairing effect in structure model calculations .
this is particularly interesting for the study of dripline nuclei since experimental data on those nuclei are usually scarce and show large fluctuations of shell structure .
in addition , @xmath100 is expected to be less contaminated by the wigner effect for nuclei around @xmath3 .
we have also shown that the strength of @xmath100 can be a good semi - quantative indication for the two - particle spatial correlation .
this is supported by our calculations with the hfb model with skyrme force as well as with the multi - shell seniority model .
moreover , we found that the weakening of @xmath4 in some neutron - rich nuclei indicates that the di - neutron correlation is weak in those nuclei .
as examples , the pairing gaps and di - neutron spatial correlations in neutron - rich calcium and tin isotopes are evaluated in detail .
calculations for the different pairing gaps and oes with different functional quantatively agree well with each other as well as with experimental data
. however , these results need to be carefully examined when one approaches the dripline , where large deviations between different functionals and different definations of the pairing gaps may be seen . |
type ia supernovae ( snia ) are deeply connected with many important frontiers of astrophysics and cosmology .
they occur in all galaxy types and are major contributors to galactic chemical evolution , in particular of iron .
they are very bright and , as high redshift distance indicators , play a critical role in establishing the modern cosmology paradigm @xcite . however , there are major uncertainties regarding the nature of the snia progenitors and explosions . while it is established that most snia result from the thermonuclear explosion of carbon - oxygen white dwarfs ( wd ) near the chandrasekhar mass , the mechanism of mass gain remains debated . in the single - degenerate ( sd ) scenario
the wd accretes mass from a companion star @xcite , while in the double - degenerate ( dd ) scenario the wd merges with another wd @xcite .
in addition , although the main products are known , the basic mechanism of nuclear burning remains under debate .
in deflagration the ignited flame propagates subsonically , while in detonation it propagates supersonically as a shock wave .
there are combined models , as well as the possibility of detonation in the he layer of a sub - chandrasekhar wd .
the difference between star formation and snia rates depends on what the snia progenitors are .
the rate of snia following an episode of star formation depends on ( i ) the delay time , which describes the time required for a newly - formed snia progenitor to develop into a snia , and ( ii ) the production efficiency , which is the number of snia produced per @xmath9 of star formed .
the sd and dd scenarios involve different progenitors and have different predictions for these quantities .
although current predictions are comparable within uncertainties , improved information on the global delay - time distribution ( dtd ) and snia efficiency will discriminate between snia progenitor scenarios @xcite .
it is well known from nuclear fusion modeling and optical light curve observations that each snia yields as much as 0.50.7 @xmath10 of radioactive @xmath11ni .
the decay of @xmath11ni , via @xmath11co to stable @xmath11fe , provides the primary source of energy in the form of nuclear gamma rays and energetic positrons that deposit much of their energy in the ejecta that powers the snia optical display .
initially , the gamma - rays are trapped , but as the snia ejecta expands and the matter density drops they start to escape , while the positrons remain largely trapped until much later times .
the decline rates of the optical light curve show the timescales set by the decay of @xmath12 ( half life of 6 days ) and @xmath13 ( half life of 77 days ) .
the detection of gamma rays that escape the ejecta is the key to resolving the central mysteries of snia @xcite .
since gamma rays are more penetrating and their opacities are much simpler than those for optical photons , they offer a more straightforward and direct probe of the inner mechanisms of snia @xcite .
the gamma ray flux allows the identification of radioactive material yield , and its time evolution allows tomography of the surrounding ejecta ; both quantities can be compared with model predictions . in a few cases of fortuitously nearby snia ,
limits just above theoretical expectations have been set .
no snia features have been seen in the cosmic gamma - ray background ( cgb ; e.g. , * ? ? ?
reliable knowledge of snia rates is essential to defining realistic prospects for gamma - ray detection , and new data make this possible . in the first part of this paper
, we investigate the cosmic snia rate and determine the delay of snia relative to their progenitor formation and the efficiency of forming snia ( section [ sec : progenitor ] ) .
we use a large selection of star formation indicators with recent updates ( section [ sec : rate ] ) , as well as a comprehensive compilation of snia rate data ( section [ sec : ratedata ] ) .
we study the effects of delay and efficiency using data over a substantial redshift range , and we discuss what our results reveal about the snia progenitors , i.e. , for sd and dd scenarios ( section [ sec : ratesynthesis ] ) . in the second part of this paper , we bring in gamma rays as a probe of snia explosions and progenitors ( section [ sec : gamma ] ) .
our analysis of the cosmic snia rate plays a critical role in determining the gamma - ray detection prospects .
we first review the gamma - ray emission for several benchmark snia models ( section [ sec : gammaemission ] ) .
we determine the snia contribution to the cgb using our updated cosmic snia rate inputs ( section [ sec : cgb ] ) .
we derive snia rates from supernova catalogs , and joining them with cosmic snia rates , we investigate the local snia rate with a higher accuracy than previously possible ( section [ sec : catalog ] ) .
we revisit the status of gamma - ray observations in light of our updated local snia rate ( section [ sec : localpast ] ) .
finally , we give new results on the excellent gamma - ray detection prospects for nearby snia and the physics that this will probe ( section [ sec : local ] ) .
we close with a summary of our findings ( section [ sec : summary ] ) . throughout , we adopt the standard @xmath14cdm cosmology with @xmath15 , @xmath16 , and @xmath17 km s@xmath18 mpc@xmath18 .
comparing the cosmic star formation rate and the high redshift snia rate of the _ goods _ fields suggests a dtd tightly distributed around 34 gyr @xcite . however , small snia statistics , uncertain dust corrections , and the uncertain star formation rate at high redshift complicate studies of the dtd in this range @xcite .
we perform a new investigation of the snia rate by adopting both greatly updated star formation rate data ( section [ sec : rate ] ) and snia rate data ( section [ sec : ratedata ] ) . in particular , we focus on the low redshift range , which provides a complementary test to previous studies . by comparing the calculation to observations , we determine the global dtd and snia efficiency , and discuss implications for snia progenitors ( section [ sec : ratesynthesis ] ) .
the snia rate at a given time corresponds to the stellar birthrate at earlier epochs , convolved with the dtd , normalized by the efficiency of forming snia progenitor systems .
the normalization is @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the snia formation efficiency , @xmath21 is the initial mass function , and the integration is performed over the mass range for snia progenitors . unless otherwise stated , we present all results for the salpeter initial mass function ; our results on the snia rate do not strongly depend on this choice because the snia progenitor mass range is sufficiently high .
assuming @xmath22 and @xmath23 do not vary with space and time , @xmath24 is a constant representing the number of snia produced per @xmath9 of stars formed , so that @xmath25 = \eta \int_{t_{10}}^{t_c } \phi(t_c - t'_c ) \dot{\rho}_\star[z(t'_c ) ] \ , dt'_c,\ ] ] where @xmath26 is the dtd , its argument is the time difference between progenitor star formation and snia explosion , @xmath27 is the star formation rate , and the integration is performed over cosmic time from @xmath28 , the age of the universe when the first stars were being formed , @xmath29 .
@xmath26 is normalized such that its integral over the entire delay time range is unity .
we do not consider the effect of metallicity on the rates . on a logarithmic axis .
data as labeled ( see text for details ) , agree to within @xmath30% for @xmath31 .
the uncertainty increases with redshift , but the overall shape is well constrained .
the fitted curve is shown by a solid line @xcite .
[ fig : sfr ] ] in the limit that @xmath26 is large only for small @xmath32 , we recover a prompt population of supernovae , i.e. , similar to core - collapse supernovae , for which the cosmic rate evolution is the same as for the star formation rate . for snia ,
the observation that they occur in both young star - forming galaxies and old elliptical galaxies with little star formation demonstrates the need for a wide range of delay times .
recently , two populations of snia , a `` prompt '' population with delay times @xmath33 gyr and a `` delayed '' population with delay times @xmath34 gyr , have been reported . whether this represents a truly bimodal distribution , or whether it is the result of two coarsely sampled bins of what is in reality a continuous dtd , remains uncertain .
we adopt a power - law dtd , @xmath35 .
power - laws have been reported from snia observations : for example , with @xmath36 from the snls data @xcite , with @xmath37 from observations of transients in passively evolving galaxies @xcite , with @xmath38 from local snia in the lick observatory supernova search ( loss ) @xcite , and most recently @xmath39 from cluster snia @xcite .
in fact , the number of wds following an instantaneous star formation burst is also a simple power - law in @xmath32 : for an initial mass function @xmath40 ( @xmath41 for salpeter ) and a power - law approximation to the evolutionary time - scale of 38 @xmath9 stars @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) , the index is @xmath44 .
however , this distribution extends only over the lifetimes of progenitors , 30400 myr , which is much smaller than the observed range of delay times . the extra time needed for mass transfer before triggering a snia would shift the delay time distribution towards longer delays , but the final dtd is largely dependent on the properties of the binary and its evolution .
we apply our dtd over times 0.113 gyr and adopt @xmath45 as a parameter .
the lower time limit could be as short as the lifetime of a 8 @xmath9 star , @xmath46 0.03 gyr , but recent studies of the spatial distribution of snia in their host galaxies indicate a lower limit of 0.2 gyr @xcite .
we adopt 0.1 gyr ; at the precision of the current snia rate measurements , our results are not very sensitive to small delays .
we fix our upper limit to the look - back time to @xmath47 , which is sufficiently long to accommodate snia observed in the oldest elliptical galaxies . allowing a larger value would not change the redshift evolution , and would simply scale the efficiency .
the cosmic star formation rate density is shown in figure [ fig : sfr ] .
the compilation of @xcite , which includes data from multiple star formation indicators , is shown together with recent data from mid - infrared - emitting galaxies @xcite , lyman break galaxies ( lbg ) @xcite , and gamma - ray burst ( grb ) host galaxies @xcite .
note that @xcite report results integrated down to a chosen luminosity limit ; we show instead complete integrations ( see @xcite for details ) .
we also show hubble ultra deep field ( udf ) measurements from @xcite , similarly integrated to low galaxy luminosities .
new udf results from @xcite have just appeared . as these indicate a steeper rise at low galaxy luminosities , the integration for the full star formation rate would need to be carefully regulated , and we do not perform this here .
the star formation rate has been checked by independently measured quantities , such as the extragalactic background light @xcite , stellar mass density @xcite , and upper limits on the diffuse supernova neutrino background @xcite . on the top axis
we label cosmic time .
it highlights that delay times of gyrs will result in noticeable differences in the slope between the star formation and snia rate rates .
the star formation rate rapidly increases by one order of magnitude between redshift 0 and 1 , which has been very well measured by a variety of indicators .
this serves as an important feature to be compared to the snia rate . at higher redshift ,
the star formation rate eventually declines , at first slowly after @xmath48 , and then more rapidly after @xmath49 .
the exact slope above @xmath49 remains uncertain , although this does not affect our conclusions , as we discuss in section [ sec : ratesynthesis ] .
since the first measurement of snia at cosmological distances @xcite , many surveys have collected homogenous samples of ccd - discovered snia .
these surveys periodically observe the same patch of sky , or the same sample of galaxies , to find transients .
cuts are applied to select the most confidently - identified supernovae , and corrections for dust and incompleteness are applied .
we summarize the present snia rate measurements in table [ table : data ] .
the high redshift ( @xmath50 ) rates are the hardest to measure .
dust corrections are non - trivial and uncertain , e.g. , the dust corrected data of @xcite are a factor @xmath51 higher than their uncorrected data .
even this has been argued to be insufficient and the rates could be treated as lower limits @xcite . on the other hand ,
snia surveys are likely contaminated by core - collapse supernovae , for which the rate increases from @xmath52 at @xmath53 to @xmath54 by @xmath48 , i.e. , @xmath34 times the snia rate by @xmath48 .
it is therefore important that only the most confidently - identified snia those that are spectroscopically confirmed are selected for rate measurements .
indeed , rates derived using photometric classification @xcite are generally higher than those based on a higher fraction of spectroscopically confirmed snia @xcite .
this is usually reflected in the large systematic errors .
finally , the sample sizes rapidly become small at high redshift , where typically @xmath55 23 .
these issues make it difficult to use the high redshift rate measurements @xcite , even though they would be very sensitive to delays due to the small cosmic time difference since the first stars were being formed . at intermediate redshift ( @xmath56 ) , many of the measurements are based solely on spectroscopic confirmed snia .
multi - band photometric identification is also now reliable : @xcite show that in the sdss - ii supernova survey only @xmath462% of the photometric snia in @xmath57 may be misidentified .
furthermore , the effects of dust become less important than at high redshifts .
however , many surveys target a pre - selected sample of galaxies and , while a large sample is adopted , there would be a bias towards bright galaxies , and supernovae that explode in faint galaxies would be missed .
lastly , we note that sample sizes vary largely from survey to survey . finally , in the local ( @xmath58 mpc ) volume , the rate has been calculated from compilations of carefully selected snia , as well as the local loss measurement @xcite .
note that the rate calculated from @xcite probably reflects a local enhancement ( section [ sec : catalog ] ) . ) .
the best - fit @xmath59 power - law dtd ( solid ) is shown , with a shaded band reflecting the uncertainty .
other dtd shown are as labeled in figure [ fig : cosmicrate ] ; they do not fit the data as well .
[ fig : localrate ] ] compared to the star formation rate , the snia rate is further away from a consensus .
although the number of rate measurements has increased , the scatter is large , and at times , measurements in comparable redshifts are in direct disagreement .
bearing in mind the strengths and weaknesses of the data , we group the rate measurements into two categories : * _ filled points _ : those based on dedicated surveys using only spectroscopically identified snia .
we also include select surveys with less than 100% spectroscopic identification , including the survey by sdss which includes an order of magnitude more snia than any other survey @xcite , and measurements by @xcite which are the most reliable measurements in the high redshift regime . * _ empty points _ : those based largely on photometrically identified snia .
we caution that even within each category , the sample size , observation schedule , limiting magnitude , and other conditions vary , and our description is simply an attempt to appreciate some of the important differences between measurements @xcite .
now , we can make better sense of the calculated and measured snia rates despite their uncertainties .
when we restrict ourselves to the filled points , we find that the snia rate increases by only a factor @xmath513 from redshift 0 to 0.8 or so . on the other hand , the cosmic star formation rate increases by a factor 10 from redshift 0 to 1 .
_ this implies that a large fraction of snia have cosmologically - large time delays_. we show in figures [ fig : localrate ] and [ fig : cosmicrate ] the calculated and measured snia rates .
we fit the calculated cosmic snia rate form to the selection of rate data consisting of filled points and local measurements ( excluding that by @xcite ) . for the power - law dtd
we fit for the normalization at redshift zero , @xmath60 , and the dtd exponent , @xmath45 .
we find best - fit values @xmath61 with @xmath62 for 17 degrees of freedom .
the projections of the @xmath63 elliptical contour give @xmath64 and @xmath1 ; these parameters are strongly anti - correlated .
the uncertainty is shown as grey shading in the figures . the best - fit efficiency and uncertainty of making snia
is @xmath65 , or , assuming a snia progenitor mass range of 38 @xmath10 , a snia fraction ( which we define as the number of snia divided by the number of 38 @xmath9 stars formed ; the fraction of stars in snia - producing binaries is twice this ) of @xmath66% . , but over the entire redshift range where data are available .
in addition to the best - fit @xmath59 power - law dtd ( solid ) , we show the no delay ( dotted ) , the two - component dtd of @xcite ( dot - dashed ) , and the 3.4 gyr narrow dtd of @xcite ( dot - dot - dashed ) , as labeled . [
fig : cosmicrate ] ] in addition to the power - law dtd we show the bimodal dtd of @xcite ( dot - dashed ) , the 3.4 gyr narrow dtd of @xcite ( dot - dot - dashed ) , and the no - delay case ( dotted ) , for comparison .
these dtds do not fit the data as well , with @xmath67 values of 10 , 17 , and 21 , respectively .
all rise too fast compared to the reliable data ( filled points ) .
this also means they underpredict the @xmath53 rate .
the different results in @xcite are due to the choice of data .
the narrow dtd is driven by a declining snia rate at @xmath68 ( see green left - pointing triangles in figure [ fig : cosmicrate ] ) , while our result is driven by the slow rise at low redshift . at present
, the dtd does not clearly identify the snia progenitor scenario , because both the sd and dd scenarios can lead to power - law dtds with @xmath69 . in the dd scenario ,
the delay is approximately dictated by the time taken by a binary to merge by angular momentum loss , which from general relativity scales as the fourth power of the binary separation .
for a logarithmically - flat distribution of binary separations , one obtains @xmath38 . although binary evolution synthesis studies of the sd scenario typically show that the dtd peaks at characteristic scales related to stable mass transfer ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , power - law dtds have also been predicted : for example , @xcite report power - law dtds with @xmath69 .
both progenitor scenarios are acceptable fits , but as predictions of snia progenitor scenarios improve and snia rate data accumulates , better testing would become possible .
we have assumed for simplicity a power - law dtd ; in order to generally test the progenitor scenario , a generic form for the dtd should be statistically tested ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
. the choice of the initial mass function does not affect the shape of the snia rate , but changes the number of snia progenitor stars .
this introduces a small tens of percent difference in the efficiency . for a modern baldry - glazebrook initial mass function with a low - mass suppression @xcite ,
the snia fraction required is @xmath70% .
since the comparison of cosmic rates is not sensitive to small delays , there could be more short - lived progenitors than indicated by our simple dtd form .
uncertainty in the cosmic star formation rate beyond @xmath49 affects the low redshift snia slope , albeit weakly , through the long tail of the dtd .
there is a degeneracy in the high - redshift star formation slope and the value of @xmath45 , where a higher star formation rate can be compensated by a larger @xmath45 .
however , at the precision of the current snia rate measurements , this uncertainty does not affect our conclusions .
our snia efficiency is comparable to those from recent studies of volumetric snia rates @xcite , and somewhat lower than those derived by other methods @xcite .
note that comparisons must be done with a common assumption for the initial mass function .
as described above , a more modern initial mass function would increase our efficiency , although a difference remains .
the true value of the efficiency remains to be determined ; see @xcite for a detailed discussion and implications of the snia efficiency . for example , our snia fraction contrasts with the @xmath71% advocated in some dd scenarios , where conservative conditions on the mass ratios are applied @xcite .
the higher required efficiency that we found suggests the need to relax some assumptions , or to include contributions from snia of lower mass progenitors .
we should note here that our definition for efficiency implicitly assumes binaries that would become a snia within @xmath72 gyr .
it is revealing to discuss the snia rate jointly with the core - collapse supernova rate .
the ratio of snia to core - collapse supernova ( ia / ii ) at @xmath53 is @xmath730.3 .
here we use the @xmath53 cosmic snia rate instead of the local 10 mpc data , as the latter rate is @xmath33 per year ; the recent decade , for example , had no snia @xcite .
since snia are delayed , the snia rate should increase less strongly than the star formation rate and the core - collapse rate from @xmath53 to @xmath48 .
the ia / ii ratio should therefore decrease with redshift in this range .
however , the data do not clearly show such a trend , being consistent with no evolution ( @xcite ; this is true even with updates on the core - collapse rate , e.g. , ) .
a likely possibility is that fainter core - collapse supernovae are being missed compared to the brighter snia ( see * ? ? ?
the importance of the missing core - collapse supernovae spans topics such as the formation of black holes in massive stellar collapse , supernova neutrinos , and metal enrichment .
gamma rays reveal information of the snia interior that can be effectively used to study snia physics .
we first review the gamma - ray emission per snia , focusing on a range of snia models that accommodate normal , superluminous , and subluminous snia ( section [ sec : gammaemission ] ) . using the cosmic snia rate analyzed in section [ sec : progenitor ] ,
we discuss prospects for using the cgb to detect snia gamma rays ( section [ sec : cgb ] ) .
we then discuss the local snia rate with higher precision than previously possible , by combining our cosmic snia rate analysis with snia rates from supernova catalogs of nearby supernovae ( section [ sec : catalog ] ) .
after reviewing the current status of gamma - ray observations ( section [ sec : localpast ] ) , we give new results detailing the prospects for snia gamma - ray detection and studying snia physics .
llccccc & & & & + & ref . &
@xmath74 [ @xmath10 ] & 812 kev & 847 kev & 1238 kev + normal : delayed - detonation & _ dd202c _ & 1 & 0.72 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + normal : deflagration & _ w7 _ & 2 & 0.58 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 + normal : he - detonation & _ hed8 _ & 3 & 0.51 & 1.6 & 4.4 & + superluminous : late - detonation & _ w7dt _ & 4 & 0.76 & 2.2 & 5.9 & + superluminous : he - detonation & _ hecd _ & 5 & 0.72 & 2.5 & 5.5 & + subluminous : he - detonation & _ hed6 _ & 3 & 0.26 & 0.6 & 2.2 & + subluminous : pulsed delayed - detonation & _ pdd54 _ & 6 & 0.14 & 0.05 & 1.2 & + in all snia models , the decay chain @xmath82 provides the primary source of energy that powers the snia optical display .
the @xmath11ni decays by electron capture and the daughter @xmath13 emits gamma rays by the nuclear de - excitation process @xmath83 where percentages express photons per decay and the sum can be larger than 100% . only the dominant lines are noted here .
the daughter @xmath11co decays by electron capture ( 81% ) as well as positron emission ( 19% ) , and the daughter @xmath84 de - excites by emitting gamma rays @xmath85 where the percentages include the effects of the 19% branching ratio for positron production by beta decay . initially , most of the gamma rays compton scatter on the snia ejecta and deposit their energy . as the ejecta expands and the matter density decreases , more gamma rays escape .
the observed 847 kev line luminosity is @xmath86 \left [ \frac{e^{-t/\tau_{\rm co } } - e^{-t/\tau_{\rm ni } } } { \tau_{\rm co } - \tau_{\rm ni } } \right ] \ , { \rm \gamma \ , s^{-1 } } , \ ] ] where @xmath87 is the model - dependent probability of escape through the snia ejecta , the quantity in the first square brackets defines the model - dependent nucleosynthesis yield , and the second square brackets reflect the nuclear decay rate . here , @xmath74 is the nickel mass
, @xmath88 is the avogadro number , and @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the half life : @xmath91 days for @xmath11ni and 77.2 days for @xmath11co . _
the distribution of @xmath74 ( over many snia ) and especially the time - evolution of @xmath87 ( per snia ) can be used to probe snia physics . _ in deflagration , nuclear burning ignites near the center and burning moves subsonically across the progenitor . in pure detonation ,
the flame front propagates supersonically as a shock front , but we do not consider this further since the resulting elemental abundances disagree with data @xcite . in delayed - detonation ,
an initial deflagration becomes a detonation at some critical density that is an unknown parameter .
all these models are usually assumed to be initiated from a wd near the chandrasekhar mass , accreting mass from a non - degenerate star . in he - detonation , burning commences in the degenerate helium layer near the surface of a sub - chandrasekhar mass wd . in dd scenario models
, ignition occurs at low densities as mass from the disrupted binary accretes .
it is expected that a large material envelope covers the burning sites , so that the escape probability for gamma rays is lower than in sd scenarios , thus probing the progenitors .
@xcite compared the gamma - ray emission from seven transport codes for a selection of snia models .
they conclude that differences due to transport codes are 1020% , much less than the differences that result from models .
the continuum emission is more model dependent than the line emission since it depends on multiple scatterings and the time - integrated continuum differs by up to a factor @xmath46 2 between codes . from @xcite
we adopt a selection of snia models representative of normal , superluminous , and subluminous snia , and spanning the deflagration , delayed - detonation , and he - detonation models . the average peak line emission , over a @xmath92 s period ,
are summarized in table [ table : gamma ] .
the light curves for super - luminous snia ( solid ) and normal snia ( dashed ) are shown in figure [ fig : lightcurve ] .
we comment on dd snia models in section [ sec : discussion ] .
we adopt two time - integrated gamma - ray spectra : a deflagration model _ w7 _ of @xcite , which yields which yields @xmath93 of @xmath11ni , and a delayed - detonation model _ 5p0z22.23 _ of @xcite , which yields @xmath94 of @xmath11ni .
both models are representative of normal snia , the most common kind . ] the snia contribution to the cgb depends on the cosmic snia rate and the time - integrated gamma - ray number spectrum per snia , @xmath95 , as @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the measured photon energy , and @xmath98^{1/2}$ ] .
the left - hand side is equivalent to @xmath99 , and the redshift factor in eq .
( [ eq : cgb ] ) comes from the energy scaling . in figure
[ fig : cgb ] we show the resulting snia contribution to the cgb , for the deflagration model _ w7 _ ( solid ) and the delayed - detonation model _
5p0z22.23 _ ( dot - dashed ) . for _
w7 _ , the shading show the uncertainty due to snia rate .
we see that the snia contributions are at least a factor @xmath100 smaller than current cgb measurements , and up to @xmath4620 depending on the snia rate and snia model .
although the spectrum per snia has line features , these are washed out due to redshift .
our results are comparable to those of previous studies .
although early studies showed large contributions from snia @xcite , later studies report contributions to be @xmath4610 @xcite and @xmath10110 @xcite less than the measured intensity . if the dominant fraction of the cgb could be subtracted by future detectors , the snia contribution could be detected .
the feasibility depends on the true nature of the currently measured cgb .
proposed sources include various populations of agns ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , hot coronae of agns @xcite , and exotic dark matter models @xcite .
the measured cgb may also be dominated by detector backgrounds .
the true nature is unknown , and remains an important quest for future experiments to elucidate .
angular - correlation techniques may help differentiate the various possibilities @xcite .
s@xmath18 at peak .
the dashed lines represent @xmath102 detector line sensitivities ( @xmath92 s ) , labeled with years of operation ; the sensitivity is dependent on exposure ( see text ) .
[ fig : catalog ] ] knowing the local snia rate is a critical prerequisite for assessing the prospects for detecting gamma rays from individual snia .
many studies have discussed the snia rate , most notably in the 1980s by @xcite and in the 1990s by @xcite , which provided much needed guidance on gamma - ray detection prospects .
now we have the advantage of systematic supernova surveys and greatly improved snia statistics .
in addition to supernova catalogs , we use our cosmic snia rate to arrive at a consistent picture for the local snia rate .
more than 5000 supernovae discovered up to the end of 2009 are listed in the sternberg astronomical institute supernova catalog ( sai ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the asiago supernova catalog , and the catalog maintained by the central bureau for astronomical telegrams . in some cases , the catalogs disagree on details , but these discrepancies are increasingly rare for more recent supernovae . in the presence of a disagreement , we chose the classification in sai ; only small quantitative , and no qualitative , differences appear if preference is given to the other catalogs .
we have used the reported recession velocities in the sai catalog for their distances , with cross checks for the nearest snia with catalogs of galaxies @xcite .
s@xmath18 per snia ) .
the extrapolation of the cosmic snia rate , as well as the rates derived from supernova catalogs , are shown and labeled accordingly .
the dashed lines are @xmath102 detector line sensitivities ( @xmath92 s ) as labeled .
the inset shows part of the figure magnified for clarity .
[ fig : prospects ] ] snia discovered over the most recent 40 years ( 1970 - 2009 ) are shown in figure [ fig : catalog ] as a function of distance .
we see that while rare , there have nonetheless been a number of snia within 10 mpc , at approximately 1 per decade ( unfortunately , none in the recent decade ) .
it is clear that one needs to go only a small factor in distance to observe @xmath103 snia per decade . at larger distance
, we see that the commencement of dedicated snia searches in the 1990s dramatically increased the number of snia discovered .
yet these are still underestimates , due to missing coverage at large distances .
furthermore the @xmath104 sky is not evenly sampled ; the northern hemisphere is more closely observed than the south , resulting in a snia discovery ratio of approximately @xmath105 ( 2000 - 2009 , within 100 mpc ) . the comparison to the cosmic snia rate is also revealing .
the red lines show the extrapolated cosmic snia rate , and the incompleteness of the catalog is apparent by @xmath106 mpc . with next - generation surveys such as the palomar transient factory @xcite
, snia measurements are becoming more complete .
many more snia are also being discovered pre - maximum , offering more targets for future gamma - ray detectors .
around 20 mpc the catalog shows more snia than the cosmic extrapolation .
the excess is as high as a factor @xmath107 for the 2022 mpc bin , although this is not statistically strong . even considering the uncertainty in the cosmic snia rate this excess persists .
there is also some excess from the virgo galaxy cluster , located at @xmath108 mpc in the northern hemisphere and containing in excess of 1000 galaxies .
the snia sample of @xcite , which contains snia within 28 mpc , similarly shows a high snia rate .
there are strong upper limits on the gamma - ray emission from individual snia . among
the earliest was sn 1986 g , observed by the solar maximum mission ( _ smm _ ) instrument @xcite , followed by sn 1991 t and sn 1998bu @xcite both observed by the compton gamma ray observatory ( _ cgro _ ) .
the derived limits depend on the fact that sn 1986 g was subluminous , sn 1991 t was superluminous , and sn 1998bu was normal . furthermore , distance uncertainties weaken the limits . in all cases , limits are compatible with theoretical predictions within uncertainties , though very close @xcite . on the top x - axis of figure [ fig : catalog ]
, the distance scale is converted to a 847 kev number flux , assuming that all snia yield @xmath109 s@xmath18 during the peak @xmath92 s. this is a conservative estimate for a normal snia ; subluminous and superluminous snia would have different axis scalings ( table [ table : gamma ] ) .
the in - flight 3@xmath110 narrow - line sensitivity of _ spi _ onboard the _ integral _ satellite is @xmath111 @xmath112 s@xmath18 at @xmath3 mev for a @xmath92 s exposure .
the equivalent for _ comptel _ onboard the _ cgro _ satellite is @xmath113 @xmath112 s@xmath18 @xcite .
the nuclear compton telescope ( _ nct _ ) balloon experiment has a narrow - line sensitivity comparable to _ integral _
@xcite , the dual gamma - ray mission is 30 times more sensitive @xcite , and the proposed advanced compton telescope ( _ act _ ) satellite is 60 times better @xcite .
nearby snia are labeled in figure [ fig : catalog ] , from which we see that those observed by _
cgro _ were just out of range .
note that sn 1991 t was a superluminous snia , for which the _ cgro _ horizon is larger than shown in figure [ fig : catalog ] , but still insufficient .
sn 2003gs was briefly observed by the _ integral _ satellite , with no line detection @xcite .
the _ integral _ sensitivity horizon to 847 kev gamma rays is @xmath114 mpc , corresponding to 0.16 snia per year ( figure [ fig : prospects ] ) .
the 812 kev flux is smaller , and is visible out to a maximum of 46 mpc , corresponding to 0.0060.03 snia per year .
the 847 kev horizon for superluminous and subluminous snia are @xmath4613 mpc and @xmath467 mpc , respectively . in practice ,
the energy resolution of _ spi _ is better than the doppler broadened width of the lines , so that the signal is spread over multiple energy bands .
this reduces the effectiveness of detector background rejection with _
, and the sensitivity horizon decreases by a factor of at most @xmath51 @xcite .
this issue similarly applies to next - generation detectors which we discuss in the next section .
the rates are summarized in table [ table : number ] , neglecting the reduced detector background rejection due to line width .
these are also labeled in figure [ fig : prospects ] , where the cumulative number of catalog snia are shown as functions of the 847 kev flux ( bottom x - axis ) and distance ( top x - axis ) lccc search mode & + & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 + 847 kev detection [ yr@xmath18 ] & 0.10.2 & 1.01.4 & 60100 + 847 kev light curve [ yr@xmath18 ] & 0.10.2 & 1.01.3 & 6080 + 812 kev detection [ yr@xmath18 ] & 0.0060.03 & 0.030.2 & 220 + 812 kev light curve [ yr@xmath18 ] & 0.0010.006 & 0.0050.03 & 0.54 + the initial goal of snia gamma - ray studies would be a single long - exposure detection of the 847 kev line from a nearby snia , which , together with the optical data , would provide a robust handle on the amount of @xmath11ni synthesized in the explosion . the prospects for detecting the 847 kev emission from @xmath3 snia per year is not too far from current _ integral _ sensitivity ( table [ table : number ] ) . ) at a distance of 20 mpc .
the @xmath7 detector sensitivities ( @xmath92 s ) are labeled by arrows . on the right axis
the statistical significance for _ act _ , over a 1 day viewing period , is shown ( see text for how significance accumulates with the square - root of the viewing period ) .
_ act _ will produce detailed 812 kev and 847 kev light curves of all snia at 20 mpc ( subluminous snia have not been plotted for clarity , but remain above the _ act _ sensitivity at 20 mpc ) .
bottom : the _ difference _ between models , taking _
w7 _ as the reference , shown as the difference in signal count rate per day by _ act_. the horizontal shading indicates the square root of the background rate .
[ fig : lightcurve ] ] however , more important in the future is improving beyond a single 847 kev detection and measuring the gamma - ray light curve , as this ultimately holds the power to distinguish between snia models .
in particular , the period during which the system transitions from an optically thick to a thin one gives the @xmath119 in eq . [ eq : emission ] and provides the best opportunity for model discrimination .
for example , he - detonation produces @xmath11ni nearer to the wd surface compared to other models , resulting in an earlier transition and hence an earlier rise of gamma - ray lines .
deflagration is the other extreme , with ignition occurring in the central regions of the wd , resulting in slower rise of the gamma - ray emission .
these points are clear in figure [ fig : lightcurve ] , where the he - detonation models _ hecd _ and _ hed8 _ are shown together with delayed - detonation ( _ w7dt _ and _ dd202c _ ) and deflagration ( _ w7 _ ) models .
in addition , detection of the 812 kev line from @xmath11ni is important , given its strong emission during the transition period .
in figure [ fig : lightcurve ] , both super - luminous snia ( solid ) and normal snia ( dashed ) are shown together , but optical observations would distinguish between these two classes so we focus on model testing within each class .
first , we show on the right y - axis of figure [ fig : lightcurve ] the significance that can be achieved by _ act _ observing a snia at 20 mpc in 1-day ( @xmath120 s ) viewing periods . since mev gamma - ray satellites are dominated by detector backgrounds , the significance of the snia signal scales as @xmath121 , where @xmath122 is the signal counts , @xmath123 is the background counts , and @xmath124 is the viewing period .
the targeted @xmath102 sensitivity of _ act _ is @xmath125 ( for @xmath92 s ) , and we scale it to a viewing period of 1 day .
we see that _ act _ will allow detailed reconstruction of the 812 kev and 847 kev light curves with very large significance at this distance .
second , provided that the snia is close enough for sufficient photon statistics , studying the shape of the light curve does not depend on knowing the exact distance to the snia .
the shape is distinctly different between models , as we illustrate more clearly in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : lightcurve ] , where we show the difference counts at _ act _ , for a viewing period of 1 day , all relative to the @xmath126 model .
an uncertain distance would scale the fluxes accordingly , but retain the shape differences between models . for illustration ,
the square root of the background counts is shown as the horizontal shading .
_ act _ would easily distinguish between normal snia models with high significance at this distance .
the difference between superluminous snia is smaller than the square root of the background counts ; better testing would be possible with a coarser time binning .
the physics potential can be scaled to a detector with generic properties .
the significance shown in figure [ fig : lightcurve ] ( top right y - axis ) scales as @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the signal flux , @xmath124 is the viewing period , and @xmath129 is the @xmath102 line sensitivity in a @xmath130 s viewing period . note significance accumulates with the square - root of the time period , i.e. , 2 consecutive @xmath131 detection implies an overall @xmath132 detection . the square root of the background counts ( bottom of figure [ fig : lightcurve ] ) scales as @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the effective area of the detector .
the rate of snia within 20 mpc is @xmath3 per year , and therefore , _ act _
will strongly constrain snia models at a rate of at least 1 per year .
snia further away also yield information , with statistical significance gained by coarser time binning . at 220 times per year , _ act _ would detect the 812 kev emission and build a detailed 847 kev light curve . at 60 - 80 times per year ,
_ act _ would detect the 847 kev light curve near peak , and at almost 100 times per year , it would detect the 847 kev emission and measure the variation in the @xmath11ni yield of snia .
we summarize these gamma - ray detection prospects in table [ table : number ] .
the wide - field all - sky nature of _ act _ could in principle detect snia independently of optical discoveries , although in practice next - generation optical surveys would bring out the full potential of _ act _ by providing more targets for joint analysis .
_ dual _ s focusing capabilities would rely on knowledge of the snia location from an optical trigger .
for all the above estimates we have assumed the narrow - line sensitivities of detectors as documented .
since snia gamma - ray lines are expected to be doppler - broadened by up to 3% , this treatment is optimistic , although it does allow us to compare the maximum performance of detectors . in practice , the broad - line sensitivities are only marginally worse than the narrow - line sensitivities .
for example , the @xmath135% broadened line sensitivity of _ act _ is @xmath136 ( @xmath7 in @xmath92 s ; @xcite ) , a factor 2 different from the narrow - line sensitivity .
the gamma - ray horizon therefore decrease by @xmath137 , and the numbers in the final column of table [ table : number ] decrease to 2030 , 16 - 21 , 15 , and 0.11 , respectively .
although smaller , these rates would still allow rapid progress in the understanding of snia .
similarly , the significance and @xmath138 for the broad - line case can be calculated to be @xmath139 and @xmath140 in a 1-day bin , respectively .
the significance remains high , and @xmath138 remains smaller than the model differences , demonstrating the physics potential .
we focused on the 812 kev and 847 kev lines because they are expected to have the highest fluxes .
there are other lines for which there are interesting prospects , for example the 158 kev line from @xmath11ni and the 1238 kev line from @xmath11co .
the detectability of these lines is only marginally less than that of the 812 kev and 847 kev lines ( eqs .
[ eq : ni][eq : co ] ) .
additionally , the 511 kev line from annihilation of positrons produced in @xmath11co decay ( eq . [ eq : co ] ) is particularly important for understanding the positron escape fraction , thought to be @xmath3% , but quite uncertain @xcite .
it has important implications for the origin of the galactic 511 kev emission ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
it should also be mentioned that other radioactive nuclei such as @xmath141ti and @xmath142ni are expected in snia .
the half life of @xmath143 is 68 years , implying historical snia as prime targets rather than the snia discussed in this paper .
the @xmath144 decay chain , with half lives of 52 hours and 391 days , would be a more suitable target .
however , as the production of @xmath142ni is not as abundant as @xmath11ni in most cases , it would be a useful line only for exceptionally close snia .
other model - distinguishing features that we have not mentioned include line shift and line width evolutions . during the first few weeks
, the high optical depth means that much of the gamma - ray emission originates from the approaching ejecta , with photons escaping essentially radially , so that the lines are blue - shifted .
together with the line width , these are measures of the expansion velocity , and their time evolution tests snia models .
the caveat with the former is that shifts occur mostly during the optically thick regime , so model testing is difficult except for exceptional cases ( e.g. , the dd scenario we mention next ) .
the line width offers a more promising test , in particular with detectors with spectral resolution of order @xmath145300 ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* for detailed predictions ) . the gamma - ray emission for the dd scenario experiences significant suppression due to the envelope resulting from the merging wds . in the
det2env4 _ model of @xcite , the enveloping matter means that the line shifts remain high for a long period of time , up to @xmath6 days , whereas sd scenario models all fall in a few weeks @xcite .
in addition , the envelope strongly suppresses the 812 kev from @xmath11ni decay , so that the flux is weaker than even the deflagration model _ w7_. the 847
kev emission also peaks at a later stage . recently ,
several authors have explored the collision of two wds in dense stellar systems as an alternate pathway to snia within the family of dd scenarios @xcite .
shock - triggered thermonuclear explosions in such events are predicted to yield @xmath11ni masses that are sufficient to power subluminous snia .
although detailed gamma - ray light curves have not yet been published , they could be targets for next - generation gamma - ray detectors if their gamma - ray emissions are comparable to those of subluminous snia .
growth of the snia sample has led to variants of snia being discovered .
deep searches have revealed peculiar faint explosions : sn 2002bj , observed by the loss survey , was a faint snia showing unusually rapid evolution on time scales of days @xcite .
the low luminosity and short rise time ( @xmath146 7 days ) translate to 0.150.25@xmath10 of @xmath11ni .
another supernova , sn 2005e , has an estimated rise time of 79 days , very small estimated @xmath11ni yield , and spectra showing abundance of helium burning products @xcite .
its location in an isolated galaxy with little star formation activity suggests an old progenitor , e.g. , wd binaries , instead of the core collapse of a massive star .
these resemble so - called `` .ia '' explosions , which has been proposed to occur in binary wds undergoing helium mass transfer @xcite .
as the binary evolves , the mass required for unstable helium burning increases , until a final flash that leads to a faint thermonuclear explosion that is one - tenth as bright for one - tenth the time of a normal snia @xcite .
the predicted rates match those observed , both being in the range of a few percent of snia .
although the @xmath11ni yield is lower than in a normal snia , this is compensated by a larger escape probability for gamma rays .
indeed , the rapidly falling light curves of snia variants suggest that of order unity of the @xmath11co decay gamma rays are escaping already by @xmath147 days .
this contrasts with normal snia , where up to 90% of the gamma rays at 20 days are down - scattered in the ejecta .
it turns out the low @xmath11ni yield and high escape fraction almost compensate each other .
the time - integrated escape fraction of gamma - ray photons in normal snia is about 50% , so that snia variants , with half as much @xmath11ni and up to twice the total escape fraction , provide a comparable gamma - ray output to normal snia .
the low rate of snia variants therefore make them subdominant contributors to gamma - ray observations .
the situation is potentially more interesting for positrons . adopting the canonical escape fraction 1% for normal snia @xcite
, snia variants could contribute up to @xmath51 times more than normal snia towards the positron budget , depending on their rate .
this would help narrow the gap between the supernovae positron yield and that required from observations of the galactic 511 kev line .
again , line detection will prove important : late - time detection of the 511 kev line would provide a direct constraint of the fraction of positrons escaping through the ejecta .
another snia variant is the extremely luminous super - chandrasekhar mass snia .
they exhibit higher magnitudes and slower ejecta velocities compared to normal snia , with predicted progenitor masses that exceed the chandrasekhar mass .
for example , sn 2003fg was a @xmath148 snia with a predicted ni yield of @xmath149 and progenitor mass of @xmath150 @xcite .
the recent super - chandrasekhar mass sn 2009dc has a ni yield of @xmath151 @xcite , and spectropolarimetry observations suggest the explosion was near spherical , supporting a truly super - chandrasekhar progenitor @xcite . rapid rotation may support such a massive wd .
binary wds could also produce super - chandrasekhar mass snia .
if the light curves of candidate super - chandrasekhar mass supernovae are indeed powered by a larger - than - normal amount of produced nickel , this will give a large gamma - ray signal ; if they are instead powered by circumstellar interactions , this will not give such a large gamma - ray signal .
gamma rays provide unique clues to the currently debated progenitor properties and explosion mechanisms of type ia supernovae ( snia ) .
they directly probe the power source of snia and provide tomography of the snia ejecta . as the importance of snia in astrophysics and cosmology continues to grow ,
the detection of gamma rays become increasingly essential .
the detectability relies on there being sufficient optical snia discoveries within the `` sensitivity horizon '' of gamma - ray telescopes . in this paper
we investigate the prospects for studying snia physics using current and future gamma - ray detectors .
below we summarize our results .
we first investigate the snia rate , which is a prerequisite for snia gamma ray detection prospects .
it is also interesting since the snia rate with respect to its progenitor formation rate depends on what the snia progenitors are .
we jointly analyze the cosmic star formation rate , cosmic snia rate , and the snia rate derived from snia catalogs .
we deduce a delay time distribution ( dtd ) and snia fraction that fit the data , and discuss the local ( @xmath152 mpc volume ) snia rate . * _ delay - times _ : when snia rate measurements are categorized according to sample size and fraction of spectroscopically - identified snia , we find that the more reliable measurements collectively show significantly slower evolution with redshift than the star formation rate .
the difference is due to the delay between progenitor formation and snia : we find that a dtd of the form @xmath153 with @xmath154 provides a good fit .
the substantially - prompt bimodal dtd of @xcite and the narrow gaussian dtd around 3.4 gyr of @xcite do not fit the global data as well . *
_ snia efficiency _
: for our dtd , we find an efficiency of making snia of @xmath155 .
assuming that the snia progenitor mass range is 38 @xmath10 , this equates to a snia fraction of @xmath156% ( for the salpeter initial mass function ; the dependence on this choice is weak ) .
* _ implication for local snia rate _ : the local snia rate is much higher than previously thought .
supernova catalog entries between 2000 to 2009 reveal on average 40 snia per year within 100 mpc , a significant increase from the @xmath51 in the 1980s @xcite and 5.5 in the 1990s @xcite .
even so , discoveries are still severely incomplete outside about 30 mpc . the expected true rate within 100 mpc is about @xmath157 snia per year .
the snia rate within @xmath158 mpc is @xmath3 per year .
the detection of gamma rays from snia directly tests the @xmath11ni mass inferred from optical observations , and also provides tomography of the snia interior by measuring the time - dependent escape probability . in the previous section
we quantitatively discussed how snia discoveries are becoming more complete , and highlighted 20 mpc as the distance for annual snia discovery .
our main results on snia gamma - ray detection prospects and the physics potential of gamma - ray detectors are as follows .
* _ cgb contribution _ : the snia contribution to the cosmic gamma - ray background ( cgb ) is at most 1020% of the cgb flux published by _
smm _ and _ comptel _ , confirming previous results .
the origin of the @xmath46 mev cgb , and whether the snia contribution can be identified , therefore remain an important task to be clarified by future gamma - ray observations . * _ current local snia prospects _ : local snia gamma - ray detection prospects are better than thought a decade ago , principally driven by the vastly increased rate of snia discoveries .
current gamma - ray satellites probe snia in the rare regime : _ integral _ probes snia within @xmath34 mpc , occurring at a rate of @xmath159 snia per year .
this is only somewhat larger than previous estimates of @xmath160 per year @xcite , but we are more confident about the normalization . * _ future local snia prospects _ : the distance for annual snia discovery ( 20 mpc ) is only a factor 2 further than current horizons ( figures [ fig : catalog ] and [ fig : prospects ] ) .
future detectors with a line sensitivity of @xmath161only a factor 3 better than that of _ integral_will cross this threshold . the proposed _
act _ satellite , with a 60 times better line sensitivity than that of _ integral _ , will probe snia out to @xmath162 mpc , translating to a rate of 100 snia per year . improved supernova surveys are discovering more snia and at earlier times , making this possible .
* _ implication for explosions _ : nearby snia will be targets for detecting gamma ray lines from both @xmath11ni and @xmath11co decays , and for their light curve reconstruction .
the _ act _ satellite will give a hugely significant @xmath163 detection of gamma - ray light curves every year from snia within 20 mpc .
these snia will allow detailed analysis of snia explosion physics , providing unprecedented understanding of the snia explosion mechanism .
a more modest detector with a line sensitivity of @xmath161 would measure the 847 kev light curve for tomography once a year , and detect the 812 kev line @xmath33 per year ( table [ table : number ] ) .
given the importance of snia from cosmology to nucleosynthesis , the need to understand the mechanisms of snia will only increase with time .
detecting their gamma ray emission is the only way to probe their inner physics .
judging from the snia rates , even a modest improvement in gamma - ray line sensitivity would reach the distance range with annual detections .
proposed next - generation gamma - ray satellites are in an excellent position to rapidly offer revolutionary results .
we are grateful to louie strigari for collaboration on an early stage of this project , and to steven boggs , tomas dahlen , alex filippenko , neil gehrels , laura greggio , matt kistler , dan maoz , kenichi nomoto , evan scannapieco , stephen smartt , kris stanek , louie strigari , mark sullivan , frank timmes , and haojing yan for sharing their expertise and advice .
sh and jfb were supported by nsf career grant phy-0547102 ( to jfb ) .
lcccrl ( 28 mpc ) & - & @xmath164 & 37 & 100 & @xcite + ( 40 mpc ) & @xmath165 & - & 70 & 100 & cappellaro et al .
( 1999 ) + 0 & - & @xmath166 & 274 & - & @xcite + 0.09 & - & @xmath167 & 17 & 100 & @xcite + 0.1 & @xmath168 & - & 19 & 100 & @xcite + 0.13 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 & 14 & 100 & blanc et al .
( 2004 ) + 0.14 & @xmath171 & @xmath172 & 4 & 100 & hardin et al .
( 2000 ) + 0.46 & - & @xmath173 & 8 & 100 & @xcite + 0.47 & @xmath174 & @xmath175 & 73 & 100 & @xcite + 0.55 & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & 38 & 100 & @xcite + [ 0.2 , 0.6 ] & - & @xmath178 & 8 & 54 & @xcite + [ 0.6 , 1.0 ] & - & @xmath179 & 25 & 54 & @xcite + [ 1.0 , 1.4 ] & - & @xmath180 & 20 & 54 & @xcite + [ 1.4 , 1.8 ] & - & @xmath181 & 3 & 54 & @xcite + [ 0.2 , 0.6 ] & - & @xmath182 & 3 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.6 , 1.0 ] & - & @xmath183 & 14 & 52 & @xcite + [ 1.0 , 1.4 ] & - & @xmath184 & 6 & 52 & @xcite + [ 1.4 , 1.8 ] & - & @xmath185 & 2 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.025 , 0.050 ] & - & @xmath186 & 516 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.075 , 0.125 ] & - & @xmath187 & 516 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.125 , 0.175 ] & - & @xmath188 & 516 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.175 , 0.225 ] & - & @xmath189 & 516 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.225 , 0.275 ] & - & @xmath190 & 516 & 52 & @xcite + [ 0.275 , 0.325 ] & - & @xmath191 & 516 & 52 & @xcite + 0.3 & @xmath192 & @xmath193 & 26 & 35 & botticella et al .
( 2008 ) + 0.25 & - & @xmath194 & 1 & 24 & @xcite + 0.35 & - & @xmath195 & 5 & 24 & @xcite + 0.45 & - & @xmath196 & 9 & 24 & @xcite + 0.55 & - & @xmath197 & 29 & 24 & @xcite + 0.65 & - & @xmath198 & 23 & 24 & @xcite + 0.75 & - & @xmath199 & 28 & 24 & @xcite + 0.2 & @xmath200 & @xmath201 & 17 & 0 & @xcite + [ 0.0 , 0.5 ] & - & @xmath202 & 0.0 & 0 & @xcite + [ 0.5 , 1.0 ] & - & @xmath203 & 5.5 & 0 & @xcite + [ 1.0 , 1.5 ] & - & @xmath204 & 10.0 & 0 & @xcite + [ 1.5 , 2.0 ] & - & @xmath205 & 3.0 & 0 & @xcite + [ 0.2 , 0.6 ] & - & @xmath206 & 5.44 & 0 & @xcite + [ 0.6 , 1.0 ] & - & @xmath207 & 18.33 & 0 & @xcite + [ 1.0 , 1.4 ] & - & @xmath208 & 8.87 & 0 & @xcite + [ 1.4 , 1.7 ] & - & @xmath209 & 0.35 & 0 & @xcite + | type ia supernovae ( snia ) remain mysterious despite their central importance in cosmology and their rapidly increasing discovery rate .
the progenitors of snia can be probed by the delay time between progenitor birth and explosion as snia .
the explosions and progenitors of snia can be probed by mev nuclear gamma rays emitted in the decays of radioactive nickel and cobalt into iron .
we compare the cosmic star formation and snia rates , finding that their different redshift evolution requires a large fraction of snia to have large delay times .
a delay time distribution of the form @xmath0 with @xmath1 provides a good fit , implying @xmath2 of snia explode more than @xmath3 gyr after progenitor birth .
the extrapolation of the cosmic snia rate to @xmath4 agrees with the rate we deduce from catalogs of local snia .
we investigate prospects for gamma - ray telescopes to exploit the facts that escaping gamma rays directly reveal the power source of snia and uniquely provide tomography of the expanding ejecta .
we find large improvements relative to earlier studies by gehrels et al . in 1987 and timmes & woosley in 1997 due to larger and more certain snia rates and advances in gamma - ray detectors .
the proposed advanced compton telescope , with a narrow - line sensitivity @xmath5 times better than that of current satellites , would , on an annual basis , detect up to @xmath6 snia ( @xmath7 ) and provide revolutionary model discrimination for snia within 20 mpc , with gamma - ray light curves measured with @xmath8 significance daily for @xmath6 days .
even more modest improvements in detector sensitivity would open a new and invaluable astronomy with frequent snia gamma - ray detections . |
the inference of couplings between dynamical subsystems , from data , is a topic of general interest .
transfer entropy @xcite , which is related to the concept of granger causality @xcite , has been proposed to distinguish effectively driving and responding elements and to detect asymmetry in the interaction of subsystems . by appropriate conditioning of transition
probabilities this quantity has been shown to be superior to the standard time delayed mutual information , which fails to distinguish information that is actually exchanged from shared information due to common history and input signals @xcite . on the other hand , granger formalized the notion that , if the prediction of one time series could be improved by incorporating the knowledge of past values of a second one , then the latter is said to have a _ causal _ influence on the former . initially developed for econometric applications ,
granger causality has gained popularity also in neuroscience ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
a discussion about the practical estimation of information theoretic indexes for signals of limited length can be found in @xcite .
transfer entropy and granger causality are equivalent in the case of gaussian stochastic variables @xcite : they measure the information flow between variables @xcite .
recently it has been shown that the presence of redundant variables influences the estimate of the information flow from data , and that maximization of the total causality is connected to the detection of groups of redundant variables @xcite . in recent years ,
information theoretic treatment of groups of correlated degrees of freedom have been used to reveal their functional roles as memory structures or those capable of processing information @xcite .
information theory suggests quantities that reveal if a group of variables is mutually redundant or synergetic @xcite .
most approaches for the identification of functional relations among nodes of a complex networks rely on the statistics of motifs , subgraphs of _ k _ nodes that appear more abundantly than expected in randomized networks with the same number of nodes and degree of connectivity @xcite .
an interesting approach to identify functional subgraphs in complex networks , relying on an exact expansion of the mutual information with a group of variables , has been presented in @xcite . in this work
we generalize these results to show a formal expansion of the transfer entropy which puts in evidence irreducible sets of variables which provide information for the future state of the target .
multiplets of variables characterized by an high value , unjustifiable by chance , will be associated to informational circuits present in the system .
additionally , in applications where linear models are sufficient to explain the phenomenology , we propose to use the exact formula for the conditioned mutual information among gaussian variables so as to get a computationally efficient approach .
an approximate procedure is also developed , to find informational circuits of variables starting from few variables of the multiplet by means of a greedy search .
we illustrate the application of the proposed expansion to a toy model and two real eeg data sets . the paper is organized as follows . in the next section
we describe the expansion and motivate our approach . in section iii
we report the applications of the approach and describe our greedy search algorithm . in section iv we draw our conclusions .
we start describing the work in @xcite . given a stochastic variable @xmath0 and a family of stochastic variables @xmath1 , the following expansion for the mutual information , analogous to a taylor series , has been derived there : @xmath2 where the variational operators are defined as @xmath3 @xmath4 @xmath5 and so on .
now , let us consider @xmath6 time series @xmath7 .
the lagged state vectors are denoted @xmath8 @xmath9 being the window length .
firstly we may use the expansion ( [ mi ] ) to model the statistical dependencies among the @xmath10 variables at equal times .
we take @xmath11 as the target time series , and the first terms of the expansion are @xmath12 for the first order ; @xmath13 for the second order ; and so on .
we note that @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the _ interaction information _ , a well known information measure for sets of three variables @xcite ; it expresses the amount of information ( redundancy or synergy ) bound up in a set of variables , beyond that which is present in any subset of those variables . unlike the mutual information
, the interaction information can be either positive or negative .
common - cause structures lead to negative interaction information . as a typical example of positive interaction information
one may consider the three variables of the following system : the output of an xor gate with two independent random inputs ( however some difficulties may arise in the interpretation of the interaction information , see @xcite ) .
it follows that positive ( negative ) @xmath16 corresponds to redundancy ( synergy ) among the three variables @xmath11 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 . in order to go beyond equal time correlations , here we propose to consider the flow of information from multiplets of variables to a given target .
accordingly , we consider @xmath19 which measures to what extent all the remaining variables contribute to specifying the future state of @xmath11 .
this quantity can be expanded according to ( [ mi ] ) : @xmath20
a drawback of the expansion ( [ mi2 ] ) is that it does not remove shared information due to common history and input signals ; therefore we choose to condition it on the past of @xmath11 , i.e. @xmath21 . to this aim
we introduce the conditioning operator @xmath22 : @xmath23 and observe that @xmath24 and the variational operators ( [ diff1 ] ) commute .
it follows that we can condition the expansion ( [ mi3 ] ) term by term , thus obtaining @xmath25 the first order terms in the expansion are given by : @xmath26 and coincide with the bivariate transfer entropies @xmath27 ( times -1 ) .
the second order terms are @xmath28 and may be seen as a generalization of the interaction information @xmath29 ; hence a positive ( negative ) @xmath30 corresponds to a redundant ( synergetic ) flow of information @xmath31 .
the typical examples of synergy and redundancy , in the present framework of network analysis , are the same as in the static case , plus a delay for the flow of information towards the target .
the third order terms are @xmath32 and so on . the generic term in the expansion ( [ mi4 ] ) , @xmath33 is symmetrical under permutations of the @xmath34 and , remarkably , statistical independence among any of the @xmath34 results in vanishing contribution to that order .
therefore each nonvanishing accounts for an irreducible set of variables providing information for the specification of the target : the search for for informational multiplets is thus equivalent to search for terms ( [ term ] ) which are significantly different from zero .
another property of ( [ mi4 ] ) is that the sign of each term is connected to the informational character of the corresponding set of variables , see @xcite ) . for practical applications ,
a reliable estimate of conditional mutual information from data should be used .
non parametric methods are recommendable when nonlinear effects are relevant .
however , a conspicuous amount of phenomenology in brain can be explained by linear models : therefore , for the sake of computational load , in this work we adopt the assumption of gaussianity and use the exact expression that holds in this case @xcite , which reads as follows .
given multivariate gaussian random variables @xmath0 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 , the conditioned mutual information is @xmath37 where @xmath38 denotes the determinant , and the partial covariance matrix is defined @xmath39 in terms of the covariance matrix @xmath40 and the cross covariance matrix @xmath41 ; the definition of @xmath42 is analogous . the statistical significance of ( [ term ] ) can be assessed by observing that it is the sum of terms like ( [ bar ] ) which , under the null hypothesis @xmath43 , have a @xmath44 distribution .
alternatively , statistical testing may be done using surrogate data obtained by random temporal shuffling of the target vector @xmath11 ; the latter strategy is the one we use in this work .
in this subsection we show the application of the proposed expansion , truncated at the second order . to this aim
we turn to real electroencephalogram ( eeg ) data , the window length @xmath9 being fixed by cross validation .
firstly we consider recordings obtained at rest from 10 healthy subjects . during the experiment , which lasted for 15 min ,
the subjects were instructed to relax and keep their eyes closed . to avoid drowsiness ,
every minute the subjects were asked to open their eyes for 5 s. eeg was measured with a standard 10 - 20 system consisting of 19 channels @xcite .
data were analyzed using the linked mastoids reference , and are available from @xcite .
for each subject we consider several epochs of 4 seconds in which the subjects kept their eyes closed . for each epoch
we compute the second order terms at equal times @xmath45 and the lagged ones @xmath46 ; then we average the results over epochs . in order to visualize these results ,
for each target electrode we plot a on a topographic scalp map the pairs of electrodes which are redundant or synergetic with respect to it .
both quantities are distributed with a clear pattern across the scalp .
interactions at equal times are one order of magnitude higher than the lagged interactions , and are dominated by the effect of spatial proximity , see fig . 1 .
on the other hand , @xmath46 show a richer dynamics , such as interhemispheric communications and predominance redundancy to and from the occipital channels , see fig .
2 , reflecting the prominence of the occipital rhythms when the subjects rest with their eyes closed .
as another example we consider intracranial eeg recordings from a patient with drug - resistant epilepsy and which has thus been implanted with an array of @xmath47 cortical electrodes and two depth electrodes with six contacts .
the data are available at @xcite and described in @xcite . for each seizure data
are recorded from the preictal period , the 10 seconds preceding the clinical onset of the seizure , and the ictal period , 10 seconds from the clinical onset of the seizure .
we analyze data corresponding to eight seizures and average the corresponding results . for each electrode
we compute the lagged influences @xmath46 , obtaining for each electrode the pair of other electrodes with redundant or synergetic contribution to its future .
the patient has a putative epileptic focus in a deep hippocampal region , with the seizure that then spreads to the cortical areas . in fig .
3 we report the values of coefficients @xmath48 taking as the target a cortical electrode located on the putative cortical focus : we report the values of @xmath46 corresponding to all the couple of the electrodes , as well as their sum over electrode @xmath49 .
it is clear how the redundancy increases during the seizure . on the other hand , for sensors from 70 to 76 , corresponding to a depth electrode , the redundancy is higher in the preictal period , reflecting the fact that the seizure is already active in its primary focus even if not yet clinically observable .
the values of @xmath48 corresponding to this electrode are reported in fig .
4 . given a target variable ,
the time required for the exhaustive search of all the subsets of variables , with a statistically significant information flow ( [ term ] ) , is exponential in the size of the system .
it follows that the exact search for large multiplets is computationally unfeasible , hence we adopt the following approximate strategy .
we start from a pair of variables with non - vanishing second order term @xmath48 w.r.t . the given target .
we consider these two variables as a _ seed _ , and aggregate other variables to them so as to construct a multiplet .
the third variable of the subset is selected among the remaining ones as those that , jointly with the previously chosen variable , maximize the modulus @xmath50 of the corresponding third order term .
then , one keeps adding the rest of the variables by iterating this procedure . calling @xmath51 the selected set of k - 1 variables , the set
@xmath52 is obtained adding , to @xmath51 , the variable , among the remaining ones , with the greatest modulus of @xmath53 .
these iterations stop when @xmath53 , corresponding to @xmath52 , is not significantly different from zero ( the bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons is to be applied at each iteration ) ; @xmath51 is then recognized as the multiplet originated by the initial pair of variables chosen as the seed .
we apply this strategy to the following toy model @xmath54 where @xmath55 and @xmath56 are i.i.d .
unit variance gaussian variables . in this model
the target @xmath11 is influenced by the process @xmath56 ; variables @xmath57 , @xmath58 , are a mixture of @xmath56 and noise @xmath55 , whilst the remaining @xmath59 variables are pure noise .
estimates of @xmath53 are based on time series , generated from ( [ map ] ) and 1000 samples long . the results are displayed in figure ( [ figmodels ] ) .
firstly we consider the case @xmath60 and @xmath61 , with all the twenty variables driving the target with equal couplings @xmath62 ; in figure ( [ figmodels])-a we depict the term @xmath53 corresponding to the @xmath63-th iteration of the greedy search .
we note that @xmath53 has alternating sign and its modulus decreases with @xmath63 . in figure ( [ figmodels])-b
we consider another situation , with @xmath64 and @xmath65 , the ten non - zero couplings @xmath62 being non - uniform .
@xmath53 still shows alternating sign , and @xmath53 vanishes for @xmath66 ; hence the multiplet of ten variables is correctly identified .
the order of selection is related to the strength of the coupling : variables with stronger coupling are selected first . in figure ( [ figc3 ] )
we consider again the eeg data from healthy subjects with closed eyes @xcite , and apply the greedy search taking c3 as the target and @xmath67 as the seed .
we find a subset of 9 variables influencing the target .
the fact that the sign of @xmath53 is alternating , as in the previous model , suggests that the channels in this set correspond to a single source which is responsible for the inter - hemispheric communication towards the target electrode c3 . in figure ( [ figo1 ] )
we take o1 as the target and @xmath68 as the seed .
a subset of 11 variables is found which describes the information flow from the frontal to the occipital cortex . for two target electrodes , c3 on the left and o1 on the right .
the target electrode is in white , and for each of the other electrodes @xmath69 on the map , the value of @xmath45 is displayed for the other electrodes .
[ figeegz],width=321 ] for two target electrodes , c3 on the left and o1 on the right .
the target electrode is in white , and for each of the other electrodes @xmath69 on the map , the value of @xmath46 is displayed for the other electrodes .
[ figeegz2],width=321 ] for a cortical electrode ( in white ) right before and during the clinical onset of a seizure , and the sum over the second electrode of the pair in the lower right panel .
[ figcort],width=321 ] for a depth electrode ( in white ) right before and during the clinical onset of a seizure , and the sum over the second electrode of the pair in the lower right panel .
[ figdepth],width=321 ] as a function of the multiplet size @xmath63 for a model in which one variable is influenced by all the other variables or by part of them . in ( a )
@xmath60 and @xmath61 : all the 20 variables influence the target with unitary weight . in (
b ) @xmath64 and @xmath65 ; the weights @xmath62 are [ 1.75 1.75 1 1 1 1 .5 .5 .5 .5 ] . the insets show the logarithm of the absolute value of @xmath53 .
the first point @xmath70 , in both plots , represents the initial pair of variables chosen as the seed , i.e. @xmath71
. the other parameters are , in both cases , @xmath72 .
[ figmodels],width=321 ] leads to a @xmath53 which is not significantly different from zero .
right : the absolute value of this contributions plotted on a scalp map .
[ figc3],width=321 ] is not significantly different from zero .
right : the absolute value of this contributions plotted on a scalp map .
[ figo1],width=321 ]
summarizing , we have proposed to describe the flow of information , in a system , by means of multiplets of variables which send information to each assigned target node .
we used a recently proposed expansion of the mutual information , between a stochastic variable and a set of other variables , to measure the character and the strength of multiplets of variables .
indeed , terms of the proposed expansion put in evidence irreducible sets of variables which provide information for the future state of the target channel .
the sign of the contributions are related to their informational character ; for the second order terms , synergy and redundancy correspond to negative and positive sign , respectively . for higher orders
, we have shown that groups of variables , related to the same source of information , lead to contributions with alternating signs as the number of variables is increased . a decomposition with similarities to the present work
have been reported in @xcite , where for multiple sources the distinction between unique , redundant , and synergistic transfer has been proposed ; in @xcite the inference of an effective network structure , given a multivariate time series , using incrementally conditioned transfer entropy measurements , has been discussed .
the main purpose of this paper is to introduce an information based decomposition , and we did that in a framework unifying granger causality and transfer entropy , thus using a formula which is exact for linear models . in cases in which a nonlinear model is required , the entropy has to be computed , requiring a high enough number of time points for statistical validation ; nonetheless the expansion that we proposed remains valid and exact in both cases .
we have reported the results of the applications to two eeg examples .
the first data set is from _ resting brains _ and we found signatures of inter - hemispherical communications and frontal to occipital flow of information . concerning a data set from an epileptic subject , our analysis puts in evidence that the seizure is already active , close to the primary lesion , before it is clinically observable .
99 t. schreiber,_phys .
lett . _ * 85 * , pp .
461 - 464 , 2000 .
granger , _ econometrica _ * 37 * , pp .
424 - 438 , 1969 .
m. staniek , k. lehnertz , phys .
* 100 * , 158101 ( 2008 ) .
m. lindner , r. vicente , v. priesemann , and m. wibral , bmc neuroscience * 12 * , 119 ( 2011 ) .
blinowska , r. kus , m. kaminski , _ phys .
e _ * 70 * , pp . 50902 - 50905(r ) , 2004 .
smirnov , b.p .
bezruchko , _ phys rev . _
* e 79 * , pp .
46204 - 46212 , 2009 .
m. dhamala , g. rangarajan , m. ding,_phys .
_ * 100 * , pp .
18701 - 18704 , 2008 .
d. marinazzo , m. pellicoro , s. stramaglia , _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 * , pp .
144103 - 144107 , 2008 .
l. faes , a. porta , g. nollo , _ phys .
* e 78 * , 26201 ( 2008 ) .
a. porta et al , _ methods of information in medicine _ 49 , pp .
506 - 510 , 2010 .
l. barnett , a.b .
barrett , and a.k .
seth , _ phys . rev
* 103 * , pp . 238701 - 23704 , 2009 .
k. hlavackova - schindler , m. palus , m. vejmelka , j. bhattacharya , physics reports * 441 * , 1 ( 2007 ) .
l. angelini , m. de tommaso , d. marinazzo , l. nitti , m. pellicoro , and s. stramaglia , _ phys .
_ * e 81 * , 37201 ( 2010 ) .
a. borst , f.e .
theunissen , _ nat .
neurosci . _
* 2 * , pp .
947 - 957 , 1999 .
e. schneidman , w. bialek , m.j .
berry ii , _
j. neuroscience _ * 23 * , pp . 11539 - 11553 , 2003 .
bettencourt et al . , _ phys .
rev . _ * e 75 * , pp .
21915 - 21924 , 2007 .
r. milo et al . , _ science _ 298 , pp .
824 - 827 , 2002 .
e. yeger - lotem et al . , _ proc .
natl.acad . sci .
_ 101 , pp .
5934 - 5939 , 2004 .
bettencourt , v. gintautas , m.i .
ham , _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 * , pp .
238701 - 238704 , 2008 .
z. shehzad et al . , _ cerebral cortex _ * 19 * , pp .
2209 - 2229 , 2009 .
n. tzourio - mazoyer et al . , it neuroimage * 15 * , pp .
273 - 289 , 2002 .
fox et al .
, _ proc natl acad sci u s a. _ * 102 * , pp .
9673 - 9678 , 2005 .
r. salvador et al . , _ cereb .
cortex _ * 15 * , 1332 - 1342 , 2005 .
r. leech , r. braga , and d. j. sharp , _ the journal of neuroscience _ 32 , pp .
215 - 222 , 2012 .
g. nolte et al . , _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 * , pp .
234101 - 234104 , 2008 .
g. nolte , a. ziehe , v. nikulin , a. schlgl , n. krmer , t. brismar , k.r .
mller , phys .
* 100 * , 234101 , 2008 | we propose a formal expansion of the transfer entropy to put in evidence irreducible sets of variables which provide information for the future state of each assigned target .
multiplets characterized by a large contribution to the expansion are associated to informational circuits present in the system , with an informational character which can be associated to the sign of the contribution . for the sake of computational complexity
, we adopt the assumption of gaussianity and use the corresponding exact formula for the conditional mutual information .
we report the application of the proposed methodology on two eeg data sets . |
weak gravitational lensing due to large scale structure ( cosmic shear ) has become a promising source of cosmological information . a new generation of ground- and space - based surveys suited for precision weak lensing measurements have been developed with the importance of this new probe in mind .
these ongoing , future , and proposed surveys ( e.g. cfhtls , des , euclid , hsc , hst , jwst , lsst , pan - starrs , and wfirst ) promise to provide greatly improved measurements of cosmic shear using the shapes of up to billions of galaxies . there has been much work done to explore the potential of these cosmic shear measurements , which we review in @xcite , for both the 2- and 3-point cosmic shear correlations . beyond the constraints obtained on cosmological parameters from the 2-point cosmic shear correlation and the corresponding shear power spectrum , the 3-point cosmic shear correlation and shear bispectrum are able to break degeneracies between the cosmological parameters that the power spectrum alone does not @xcite .
the results of @xcite , for example , showed that the constraints on the dark energy parameters and the matter fluctuation amplitude should be able to be improved by a further factor of 2 - 3 using the bispectrum measured in a deep lensing survey .
most recently , parameter constraints were derived by @xcite using weak lensing data from the hst cosmos survey , measuring the third order moment of the aperture mass measure .
their independent results were consistent with wmap7 best - fit cosmology and provided an improved constraint when combined with the 2-point correlation .
the bispectrum also allows us to explore information about non - gaussianity in the universe that is inaccessible at the 2-point level , providing constraints on the degree of non - gaussianity in addition to the information on other cosmological parameters ( see for example @xcite and references therein . ) however , several systematic effects limit the precision of cosmic shear measurements , which must be accounted for in order to make full use of the potential of future weak lensing surveys ( see for a summary @xcite and references therein ) , and one of the serious systematic effects of weak lensing is this correlated intrinsic alignment of galaxy ellipticities , which act as a nuisance factor ( see for example @xcite and references therein ) . the dark energy equation of state can be biased by as much as @xmath1 , for example , if intrinsic alignment is ignored @xcite .
@xcite found that the matter power spectrum amplitude can be affected by up to @xmath2 due to the intrinsic alignment , demonstrating the importance of developing methods to isolate and remove the intrinsic alignment from the cosmic shear signal . .
] there are two 2-point intrinsic alignment correlations .
the first is a correlation between the intrinsic ellipticity of two galaxies , known as the intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity ( ii ) correlation , between two intrinsically aligned galaxies .
the second , known as the gravitational shear - intrinsic ellipticity ( gi ) correlation , was identified by @xcite and is due to a matter structure both causing the alignment of a nearby galaxy and contributing to the lensing signal of a background galaxy .
the large - scale gi correlation was first reported by @xcite in the sdss , with @xcite finding an even stronger gi correlation for luminous red galaxies ( lrgs ) .
the authors showed that this contamination can affect the lensing measurement and cosmology by up to @xmath3 , while affecting the matter fluctuation amplitude by up to @xmath2 .
@xcite confirmed this through numerical simulations , where a level of contamination of @xmath3 was found .
the gi correlation was also measured in the sdss dataset by @xcite and @xcite , and most recently , @xcite measured strong 2-point intrinsic alignment correlations in various sdss and megaz - lrg samples .
similarly , when we consider the 3-point correlation , the gravitational shear - gravitational shear - gravitational shear ( ggg ) bispectrum suffers from contamination by the 3-point intrinsic alignment correlations .
the first correlation is between the intrinsic ellipticities of three spatially close galaxies which are intrinsically aligned by a nearby matter structure , known as the intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity ( iii ) correlation .
the second is the gravitational shear - intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity ( gii ) correlation , where a matter structure which contributes to the lensing of a galaxy in the background also intrinsically aligns two spatially nearby galaxies .
finally , there is the gravitational shear - gravitational shear - intrinsic ellipticity ( ggi ) correlation , where a matter structure which intrinsically aligns a galaxy in the foreground also lenses two galaxies in the background .
the sign of the ggi and gii correlations can depend both on triangle shape and scale .
the 3-point intrinsic alignment correlations are represented diagrammatically in fig .
[ giifig:3ptia ] .
it was shown by @xcite that compared to the lensing spectrum , the lensing bispectrum is typically more strongly contaminated by galaxy intrinsic alignment , up to @xmath4 compared to the ggg lensing signal .
@xcite demonstrated that the iii and gii intrinsic alignment correlations can be greatly reduced with photo - z s by using cross - spectra of galaxies in two different redshift bins so that the galaxies are separated by large enough distances to assure that the tidal effect is weak .
however , as shown in fig . 4 of @xcite , while the iii bispectrum is supressed almost totally for adjacent , large redshift bins , the gii bispectrum is not .
thus we propose an extension to the ggi self - calibration technique @xcite for the gii bispectrum below .
there has been significant work in recent years toward measuring and removing the effect of galaxy intrinsic alignment on cosmological measurements , and we review these briefly .
the 2-point intrinsic alignment correlations and methods for their removal have been well studied in recent literature ( see for example @xcite ) . using a geometrical approach , @xcite generalized the nulling technique to the 3-point ggi correlation by exploiting its redshift dependence , but it was found that the technique throws out some of the valuable lensing signal . finally , we have recently generalized the approaches of @xcite and @xcite to develop a set of 3-point self - calibration techniques .
we proposed using additional galaxy density ( cross-)correlations which are already present in weak lensing survey measurements to self - calibrate the ggi cross - correlation in @xcite , while the unique redshift dependencies of the intrinsic alignment bispectra allowed us to self - calibrate the intrinsic alignment auto - correlations in @xcite .
we propose here an extension to the ggi self - calibration technique of @xcite , developing a technique to self - calibrate the gii cross - correlation bispectrum . while the impact of the gii cross - correlation on cosmological information is significantly less than the impact of the ggi cross - correlation , especially for widely separated redshift bin combinations
, it still has a contribution for adjacent redshift bin combinations , which must be measured and removed if one hopes to achieve precision , systematic free bispectrum measurements . to do this ,
we develop a relationship between the gii and galaxy density - intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity ( gii ) bispectrum .
we also devise an estimator to measure the gii bispectrum from the observed galaxy density - ellipticity - ellipticity bispectrum .
we then discuss the performance of such a self - calibration technique , describing both measurement and systematic errors due to the self - calibration .
we organize the paper as follows . in sec .
[ giiback ] , we briefly discuss the necessary survey parameters and lensing calculations . in sec .
[ giisc ] , we develop the 3-point gii self - calibration .
we first develop a relation between the gii and gii bispectra , which allows for the estimation and removal of the gii intrinsic alignment cross - correlation from the cosmic shear signal .
we then establish an estimator to extract the galaxy density - density - intrinsic ellipticity correlation ( ggi ) from the observed galaxy ellipticity - density - density measurement for a photo - z galaxy sample .
section [ giierror ] describes the residual sources of error to the gii self - calibration technique , and we present the necessary relations to quantify these errors .
finally , we summarise the effectiveness and impact of the gii self - calibration in sec .
[ giiconc ] .
we expand in the appendix upon the detailed calculation of the coefficients in the error calculation found in sec .
[ giiciggerror ] and provide a list of expected values .
the self - calibration technique proposed by @xcite for the 2-point intrinsic alignment correlations and generalized by @xcite for the 3-point correlations makes use of the information already found in a lensing survey , including galaxy shape , angular position and photometric redshift , in order to calculate and remove the dominant intrinsic alignment contaminations . in evaluating the performance of the self - calibration technique
, we will consider as an example survey parameters to match an lsst - like weak lensing survey @xcite , but of course the calculations are applicable to all current and planned weak lensing surveys ( e.g. cfhtls , des , euclid , hsc , hst , jwst , lsst , pan - starrs , and wfirst ) .
we divide galaxies into photo - z bins according to photo - z @xmath5 , where the _
i_-th photo - z bin has a range @xmath6 for mean photo - z @xmath7 . in this notation
, @xmath8 implies that @xmath9 .
the galaxy redshift distribution over the _ i_-th redshift bin is @xmath10 and @xmath11 as a function of photo - z and true redshift , respectively .
these are then related by a photo - z probability distribution function ( pdf ) @xmath12 .
our calculations assume that the survey will acheive a half sky coverage ( @xmath13 ) and a galaxy surface density of 40 arcminute@xmath14 with redshift density distribution of @xmath15 with @xmath16 .
the ellipticity shape noise is described by @xmath17 @xcite and the photo - z error by a gaussian pdf of the form @xmath18 with @xmath19 .
we construct photo - z redshift bins with width @xmath20 , centred at @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) .
redshifts below @xmath23 are excluded , not because of poor performance in the gii self - calibration technique , but rather due to the weaker lensing signal at low redshifts , which artificially inflates the fractional errors we evaluate in sec .
[ giierror ] .
these errors are measured with respect to the lensing signal , and thus lower photo - z bins are not useful in evaluating the true performance of the gii self - calibration . the intrinsic alignment self - calibration techniques ( gii and ggi ) both rely upon two basic observables measured in a weak lensing survey : galaxy surface density and galaxy shape . the galaxy surface density , @xmath24 , is a function of the 3d galaxy distribution @xmath25 in a given photo - z bin . the galaxy shape is expressed in terms of ellipticity , which measures the cosmic shear @xmath26 . however , the intrinsic ellipticities of galaxies contaminate the cosmic shear .
this intrinsic ellipticity has a random component , which is simple to correct for and which we include as part of the shot noise in the error estimations of sec .
[ giierror ] .
a second component to this intrinsic ellipticity is due to the correlated intrinsic alignment of galaxies and was introduced in sec .
[ giiintro ] .
the measured shear can be labelled as @xmath27 , where @xmath28 denotes the correlated intrinsic ellipticity due to intrinsic galaxy alignment .
we are concerned only with the weak limit of gravitational lensing , so we can work with the lensing convergence @xmath29 instead .
thus from the measured @xmath30 , we can obtain the convergence @xmath31 .
we assume a standard , flat @xmath32cdm universe in our calculations .
the convergence @xmath29 of a source galaxy at comoving distance @xmath33 and direction @xmath34 is then related in the born approximation to the matter density @xmath35 by the lensing kernel @xmath36 @xmath37 the 3d matter bispectrum is defined from @xmath29 as @xmath38 where the ensemble average is denoted by @xmath39 and @xmath40 is the dirac delta function .
@xmath41 enforces the condition that the three vectors form a triangle in fourier space . under the limber approximation
, we express the 2d angular cross - correlation bispectrum as @xmath42 where when @xmath43 , for example , @xmath44 is the 3d matter bispectrum shown in eq .
[ giieq : corr ] .
however , more generally @xmath45 , and the intrinsic alignment ( i ) and galaxy ( g ) bispectra are calculated as described below .
the redshift is simply related through the hubble parameter , @xmath46 , to @xmath47 , and we can write the weighting function in terms of redshift as @xmath48 @xmath49 is simply the weighted lensing kernel for redshift bin @xmath50 , while @xmath51 is the normalized galaxy photo - z distribution .
the required lensing , intrinsic alignment , and galaxy bispectra are calculated following @xcite and @xcite .
a deterministic galaxy bias is assumed for the galaxy bispectra , and the galaxy intrinsic alignment signal is calculated using the fiducial parameterized model of @xcite ( sb10 ) , which is based on the halo model prescription .
the sb10 model reduces by design to the linear alignment model @xcite at large scale , but aims for a more motivated modelling of intrinsic alignment at small scales .
the flat - sky bispectrum is related to the all - sky bispectrum through the wigner-3j symbol , where @xmath52 following the fitting formula of @xcite with coefficients @xmath53 described in section 2.4.3 of @xcite , we compute the 3d bispectrum due to nonlinear gravitational clustering @xmath54 we make a direct expansion of this method to approximate the 3d intrinsic alignment bispectra , using the intrinsic alignment power spectra instead of the nonlinear matter power spectrum , where @xmath55 this treatment provides reasonable results for the intrinsic alignment bispectra .
a lensing survey will capture the information necessary for several sets of correlations between the @xmath25 and @xmath56 which can be constructed for galaxy triplets .
like the ggi self - calibration technique , the gii self - calibration requires only three of these observed correlations .
the first is the angular cross - correlation bispectrum between galaxy ellipticities ( @xmath56 ) in the _ i_-th , _ j_-th and _ k_-th redshift bins @xmath57 unless catastrophic photo - z errors overwhelm the data , we can safely neglect the iii cross - correlation , which is negligible for thick photo - z bins , by selecting galaxy triplets where @xmath58 .
though the impact of the gii correlation under these conditions was neglected in @xcite , it can still impact the bispectrum for adjacent bins and should be taken into account if the goal is to make a precise measurement of the total intrinsic alignment contamination .
for bin combinations which are not adjacent , this gii term can again be safely neglected and the ggi self - calibration is sufficient . under this requirement , we still find that @xmath59 due to the lensing geometry .
we then have for @xmath58 , @xmath60 the contribution from the gii bispectrum @xmath61 ( @xmath58 ) is typically very small and in some cases effectively zero . the gii self - calibration technique , which seeks to calculate and remove the gii cross - correlation which survives in adjacent photo - z bins , then acts as a correction to the ggi self - calibration , which is the only intrinsic alignment contamination that survives for non - adjacent photo - z bin combinations .
we will denote the gii bispectrum @xmath62 in order to preserve the association of each quantity _ g _ or _
i _ to its redshift bin .
the second observable is the angular cross - correlation bispectrum between convergence ( @xmath56 ) in the _ i_-th redshift bin and the galaxy density ( @xmath24 ) in the _ j_-th and _ k_-th redshift bins .
the self - calibration requires the case where @xmath63 @xmath64 this correlation contributes further information about the intrinsic alignment of galaxies .
the final observable is measured in the angular cross - correlation bispectrum between galaxy density ( @xmath24 ) in the _ i_-th , _ j_-th and _ k_-th redshift bins for @xmath63 , giving @xmath65 we also require for the gii self - calibration results from both the gi cross - correlation and intrinsic alignment auto - correlation self - calibration techniques @xcite .
we have neglected thus far the contribution of magnification bias to these measurements .
this was discussed and justified for the 3-point measurements in sec .
4.3 of @xcite and was shown to be negligible .
there is also a non - gaussian contribution to the observed bispectra , which is also neglected as discussed in sec .
4.4 of @xcite .
our gii self - calibration technique calculates and removes the gii contamination in eq .
[ giieq : one ] through the measurements from eqs .
[ giieq : two ] & [ giieq : three ] , which are both available in the same lensing survey . the fractional contamination of the correlated intrinsic alignment to the lensing signal is expressed as @xmath66 for the self - calibration to work , the contamination @xmath67 must be sufficiently large as to contribute a detectable @xmath68 at the corresponding @xmath69 bins in @xmath70 .
we denote this threshold @xmath71 . when @xmath72 , the gii self - calibration can be applied to reduce the gii contamination . the residual error after the gii self - calibration will be expressed as a residual fractional error on the lensing measurement .
we differentiate @xmath73 as statistical error and @xmath74 as systematic error , as in the discussion of the ggi self - calibration . the performance of the gii self - calibration
will then be quantified by the parameters @xmath71 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 , which are discussed and calculated in sec .
[ giierror ] . for parallelism , we preserve the notation from @xcite , though it is essential to note that the quantities are often not the same in each technique . in order to self - calibrate the gii bispectrum , we must first determine the relationship between @xmath62 and @xmath75 .
we follow the same general approach as for the ggi bispectrum , relating the two by use of a deterministic galaxy bias @xmath76 @xcite such that the smoothed galaxy density is a function of matter density expressed as @xmath77 the linear galaxy bias ( @xmath78 ) was used by @xcite for the 2-point correlations . in addition
, @xmath79 represents the first order non - linear contribution .
@xmath79 is typically expected to be negative and @xmath80 @xcite , and it is insufficient to model the bias as simply scale dependent as in the 2-point case @xcite .
following @xcite , we use this expression for the galaxy density to relate @xmath81 to @xmath82 .
we neglect the portion of the bispectrum due to primordial non - gaussianity and the trispectrum term , which contains further information about the non - gaussianity .
this was justified and discussed further in sec .
4.4 of @xcite , and results in the relationship @xmath83.\label{giieq : bg}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the galaxy bias changes slowly over the _ i_-th redshift bin with median comoving distance @xmath84 , we can write to a good approximation @xmath85 . we can further approximate @xmath86 and @xmath87 in the limit where the comoving distance distribution of galaxies in the _ i_-th redshift bin is narrow , and substituting eq .
[ giieq : bg ] into limber s approximation for @xmath75 and comparing to @xmath88 , we have the approximations @xmath89\big),\label{giieq : scale2b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath90 where @xmath91 and @xmath92 . from eqs .
[ giieq : scale1b ] & [ giieq : scale2b ] , we can now write @xmath93.\label{giieq : scale3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to express the 3d power spectra in eq .
[ giieq : scale3 ] as 2d spectra , we will use the approximations @xmath94 and @xmath95 , where @xmath96 .
equation [ giieq : scale3 ] is then @xmath97.\label{giieq : scale4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression now relates @xmath62 to @xmath75 , allowing us to identify the gii bispectrum in the observable @xmath98 .
like the similar expression for the ggi self - calibration , it is necessary to have information about the gi and ii power spectra obtained from the 2-point self - calibration techniques @xcite
. we can measure @xmath75 through the information contained within the observable @xmath99 . to measure it directly ,
we must first remove the contamination of the geometry dependent @xmath100 , which is not useful for the gii self - calibration .
lensing geometry simply requires eliminating those triplets of galaxies where the redshift of the galaxy used to measure the ellipticity is lower than those used to measure galaxy number density in the case of a spectroscopic galaxy sample . in this way
, those triplets remaining have no contamination from lensing and measure only @xmath75 .
however , for a photo - z galaxy sample , the typically large photo - z error prevents us from directly employing this method .
photo - z error causes a true redshift distribution of width @xmath101 even for a photo - z bin with width @xmath102 . in practice ,
photo - z bin widths are typically @xmath103 .
it is possible with such photo - z errors for galaxy triplets in the _ i_-th redshift bin to provide a measureable lensing contribution even when @xmath104 , except for the special cases where the redshift or both the photo - z error and bin size are limited to sufficiently low values .
a general photo - z galaxy sample then requires a more careful approach when separating @xmath75 from @xmath100 . in order to construct such an estimator
, we first consider the orientation dependence of the two components .
we define a redshift for each galaxy in the triplet : @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 , or @xmath108 for the galaxies used in the lensing / intrinsic alignment measurement and @xmath109 for the galaxy used in the number density measurement .
the gii correlation is independent of the relative position of the three galaxies .
for example , the correlations with @xmath110 , @xmath111 or @xmath112 are statistically identical when the sides of the triangle are fixed . however , the ggg and gig correlations do depend on the relative position of the three galaxies . due to the lensing geometry dependence
, the correlation with @xmath113 is statistically smaller than other orientations . the behavior of @xmath114 for equilateral triangles ( @xmath115 ) over three redshift bins spanning the survey range .
the expected values of @xmath116 are similar to those found for the ggi self - calibration , though with more @xmath69-dependence .
this is primarily due to the greater complexity found in @xmath116 , as the sum of two components instead of one .
the suppression is dependent on the redshift bin chosen , increasing with redshift due to increased photo - z error at higher redshift .
generally , @xmath117 , and the significant deviation from unity ensures that the estimator @xmath118 is valid for lensing surveys of interest . ] this dependence provides two observables from @xmath119 .
the first is @xmath119 , where all triplets are weighted equally .
the second is @xmath120 , which counts only those triplets with @xmath121 .
this weighting is denoted by the subscript s. this ordering is necessarily different from that employed in the ggi self - calibration . from our previous discussion
, we then have @xmath122 and @xmath123|_s = b^{ggg}_{iii}|_s + b^{gig}_{iii}|_s$ ] .
we now define the suppression ratio @xmath124 where we have explicitly included the @xmath69-dependence which had been previously neglected .
this ratio describes the suppression of the signal due to the weighting of triplets described for subscript s. by definition @xmath125 , with @xmath126 if the photo - z is perfectly accurate and @xmath127 if the photo - z has no correlation to the true redshift .
@xmath116 is calculated using the galaxy redshift distribution , which is discussed in sec .
[ giiqfact ] .
the definition of @xmath128 possesses an explicit dependency on the intrinsic alignment , which in principle would make the estimator dependent on intrinsic alignment model .
however , as we discuss in sec .
[ giiqfact ] , we find that for an lsst - like survey , @xmath129 is large enough compared to @xmath130 that we can approximate @xmath131 to very high accuracy .
we can thus treat @xmath128 as independent of intrinsic alignment model for sufficiently deep surveys .
we now define the estimator for @xmath75 , which we denote @xmath118 , in terms of @xmath128 and the two observables @xmath132 this estimator is @xmath133 as expected , when @xmath126 this gives @xmath134 as for a spectroscopic galaxy sample with no photo - z error . however , @xmath116 must not approach unity , where @xmath118 is singular . for the lsst - like survey described in sec .
[ giiback ] , we calculate @xmath116 for various redshift bins following the procedure described in sec .
[ giiqfact ] .
this result is given in fig .
[ giifig : q ] for equilateral triangles , where we find @xmath135 and in general that @xmath116 should deviate significantly from unity .
the estimator @xmath118 is thus expected to be applicable in any typical lensing survey .
the ratio @xmath116 in eq .
[ giieq : qfact ] must first be evaluated in order to employ the estimator @xmath118 .
this mirrors the derivation in sec .
3.3 of @xcite , which we will summarize here as it applies to @xmath116 .
we begin from the real space angular correlation functions @xmath136 and @xmath137 . taking the average correlation
, we express this in terms of the ensemble average and calculate the associated bispectra .
for the correlations with galaxy triplets weighted by the subscript s , we define the statistical weighting functions @xmath138 where @xmath139 and @xmath140 ( @xmath141 ) if @xmath142 ( @xmath143 ) and is zero otherwise .
since @xmath144 allow only @xmath145 of the integral to survive , @xmath146 , @xmath147 are normalised by a factor 3 in order to remove the suppression due to the selection function and measure only that due to the lensing geometry .
we can now express directly the bispectra necessary to compute @xmath116 @xmath148 and @xmath149 the ratio @xmath116 is now defined through eqs .
[ giieq : q4 ] & [ giieq : q5 ] . for the deep survey we are considering , we find that we can approximate to very high accuracy @xmath150 , where @xmath151 is the mean value of @xmath147 across the _ i_-th redshift bin .
this is because for a deep survey , @xmath129 is much larger than @xmath130 , making the contribution from @xmath146 negligible . in the limit where photo - z error dominates , @xmath152 , and so @xmath153 . in this limit ,
the estimator @xmath118 becomes singular and @xmath75 can no longer be differentiated from @xmath154 . in the opposite limit , where @xmath155 , @xmath156 , where our estimator mirrors the extraction method for @xmath75 in spectroscopic galaxy samples .
we will quantify the performance of the gii self - calibration technique using the survey parameters described in sec .
[ giiback ] .
this includes both a statistical measurement error introduced through the estimator @xmath118 , which propagates into the final measurement of @xmath62 and thus of @xmath157 , and a systematic error due to inaccuracy in the scaling relation between @xmath62 and @xmath75
. we will also summarize other possible sources of error which might impact the performance of the self - calibration , though a more detailed account can be found in @xcite .
the estimator @xmath118 introduces a statistical error into the measurement of @xmath75 and thus @xmath157 . in order to quantify the accuracy of the estimator @xmath158
, we consider the contribution of measurement errors such as shot and shape noise in @xmath159 which propagate into our measurement of @xmath68 through the estimator . for a given redshift bin
we calculate the rms error , working in a pixel space with @xmath160 sufficiently fine and uniform pixels of photo - z @xmath161 and angular position @xmath162 .
the measured overdensity is given by @xmath163 , and the measured ` shear ' is given by @xmath164 , where ` n ' represents the measurement noise . from eq .
[ giieq : b2s ] , we construct the pixel space angular bispectra @xmath165[\kappa_{\beta}+\kappa^i_{\beta}+\kappa^n_{\beta}][\kappa_{\gamma}+\kappa^i_{\gamma}+\kappa^n_{\gamma}]\exp[i(\bm{\ell_1}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\alpha}}+\bm{\ell_2}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\beta}}+\bm{\ell_3}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\gamma}})],\nonumber\\ b^{(2)}|_s(\ell_1,\ell_2,\ell_3)&=&n_p^{-3}\sum_{\alpha\beta\gamma}[\delta_{\alpha}+\delta^n_{\alpha}][\kappa_{\beta}+\kappa^i_{\beta}+\kappa^n_{\beta}][\kappa_{\gamma}+\kappa^i_{\gamma}+\kappa^n_{\gamma}]\exp[i(\bm{\ell_1}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\alpha}}+\bm{\ell_2}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\beta}}+\bm{\ell_3}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\gamma}})]s_{\alpha\beta\gamma}.\label{giieq : ester1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath166 when @xmath167 and is zero otherwise .
thus in the limit @xmath168 , @xmath169 and the average @xmath170 . from our definition of the estimator in eq .
[ giieq : cig ] , we can construct the difference @xmath171[(3s_{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_{gii})\nonumber\\ & & \times(\delta_{\alpha}+\delta^n_{\alpha})(\kappa_{\beta}+\kappa^i_{\beta}+\kappa^n_{\beta})(\kappa_{\gamma}+\kappa^i_{\gamma}+\kappa^n_{\gamma})-(1-q_{gii})\delta_{\alpha}\kappa^i_{\beta}\kappa^i_{\gamma}]\nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{(1-q_{gii})}n_p^{-3}\sum_{\alpha\beta\gamma}\exp[i(\bm{\ell_1}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\alpha}}+\bm{\ell_2}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\beta}}+\bm{\ell_3}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\gamma}})](3s_{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_3)\nonumber\\ & & \times[(\delta_{\alpha}+\delta_{\alpha}^n)((\kappa_{\beta}+\kappa^i_{\beta}+\kappa^n_{\beta})(\kappa_{\gamma}+\kappa^n_{\gamma})+(\kappa_{\beta}+\kappa^n_{\beta})\kappa_{\gamma}^i)].\label{giieq : products}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we have used here that @xmath170 and that the gii correlation does nt depend on the relative position of the galaxy triplets .
we can now write the rms error in a similar way to eq .
41 of @xcite and simplify the resulting 256 6-point correlations which arise from expanding eq .
[ giieq : products ] .
we apply wick s theorem , which allows us to express each 6-point correlation as 15 products of three 2-point correlations .
this results in 3840 products , most of which are zero .
for example , any correlation between signal and noise or dissimilar noise terms vanish .
further , due to the angular dependence of the correlations ( @xmath172 ) , only those correlations with @xmath173 where _ a _
@xmath174 and _ b _ @xmath175 are non - vanishing .
this leaves 124 surviving products in the rms error expression @xmath176\exp\left[i(\bm{\ell_1}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\lambda}}+\bm{\ell_2}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\mu}}+\bm{\ell_3}\cdot\bm{\theta_{\nu}})\right]\left(3s_{\alpha\beta\gamma}-q_3\right)\nonumber\\ & & \times\left(3s_{\lambda\mu\nu}-q_3\right)\big\{\big(\langle\kappa_{\beta}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\beta}^n\kappa_{\mu}^n\rangle\big)\big[\big(\langle\delta_{\alpha}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}^n\delta_{\lambda}^n\rangle\big)\big(\langle(\kappa_{\gamma}+i_{\gamma})(\kappa_{\nu}+i_{\nu})\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\gamma}^n\kappa_{\nu}^n\rangle\big)\nonumber\\ & & + \langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\nu}+i_{\nu})\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\gamma}+i_{\gamma})\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big ] + \big(\langle\kappa_{\beta}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\beta}^n\kappa_{\nu}^n\rangle\big)\big[\big(\langle\delta_{\alpha}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}^n\delta_{\lambda}^n\rangle\big)\big(\langle(\kappa_{\gamma}+i_{\gamma})(\kappa_{\mu}+i_{\mu})\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\gamma}^n\kappa_{\mu}^n\rangle\big)\nonumber\\ & & + \langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\mu}+i_{\mu})\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\gamma}+i_{\gamma})\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big ] + \big(\langle\kappa_{\gamma}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\gamma}^n\kappa_{\mu}^n\rangle\big)\big[\big(\langle\delta_{\alpha}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}^n\delta_{\lambda}^n\rangle\big)\big(\langle(\kappa_{\beta}+i_{\beta})i_{\nu}\rangle+\langle i_{\beta}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\big)\nonumber\\ & & + \langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\nu}+i_{\nu})\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\beta}+i_{\beta})\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big ] + \big(\langle\kappa_{\gamma}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\gamma}^n\kappa_{\nu}^n\rangle\big)\big[\big(\langle\delta_{\alpha}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}^n\delta_{\lambda}^n\rangle\big)\big(\langle(\kappa_{\beta}+i_{\beta})i_{\mu}\rangle+\langle i_{\beta}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\big)\\ & & + \langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\mu}+i_{\mu})\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\beta}+i_{\beta})\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big ] + \big(\langle\delta_{\alpha}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}^n\delta_{\lambda}^n\rangle\big)\big[\langle\kappa_{\beta}i_{\mu}\rangle\langle i_{\gamma}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\beta}i_{\nu}\rangle\langle i_{\gamma}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle+\langle\kappa_{\gamma}i_{\mu}\rangle\langle i_{\beta}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\nonumber\\ & & + \langle\kappa_{\gamma}i_{\nu}\rangle\langle i_{\beta}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\big ] + \langle\kappa_{\beta}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big[\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\gamma}+i_{\gamma})i_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\mu}+i_{\mu})\rangle\langle i_{\gamma}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\gamma}+i_{\gamma})i_{\mu}\rangle\nonumber\\ & & + \langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\nu}+i_{\nu})\rangle\langle i_{\gamma}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\big ] + \langle\kappa_{\gamma}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big[\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\beta}+i_{\beta})i_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\langle(\kappa_{\beta}+i_{\beta})i_{\mu}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\nu}+i_{\nu})\rangle\langle i_{\beta}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\nonumber\\ & & + \langle\delta_{\alpha}(\kappa_{\mu}+i_{\mu})\rangle\langle i_{\beta}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\big]+\langle i_{\beta}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big[\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\langle\kappa_{\gamma}i_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\langle\kappa_{\gamma}i_{\mu}\rangle\big]+\langle i_{\gamma}\delta_{\lambda}\rangle\big[\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\mu}\rangle\langle\kappa_{\beta}i_{\nu}\rangle+\langle\delta_{\alpha}\kappa_{\nu}\rangle\langle\kappa_{\beta}i_{\mu}\rangle\big]\big\}.\nonumber\label{giieq : ester2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] noises only correlate at zero lag ( @xmath177 , @xmath178 ) , and the correlations not involving @xmath29 depend only on separation , not on relative orientation of the galaxy pairs along the line - of - sight .
however , correlations like @xmath179 and @xmath180 are dependent on the relative orientation and must be treated with care when evaluating eq .
[ giieq : ester2 ] . in order to quantify this orientation dependence
, we apply @xmath181 @xcite and @xmath182 such that @xmath183 the residual statistical uncertainty @xmath184 for equilateral triangles ( @xmath115 ) in the @xmath62 measurement and threshold of intrinsic alignment contamination @xmath71 at which the gii self - calibration technique can calculate and remove the intrinsic alignment contamination at s / n=1 are plotted for a variety of redshift bin combinations . at large @xmath69
, we see the effects of shot noise beginning to take over . generally , @xmath184 is less than the minimum survey error expected for such a survey , and is thus negligible .
we expect this result to hold for non - equilateral triangles as well , but the use of the gii self - calibration is limited by our understanding of non - gaussian effects for very elongated triangle shapes , as discussed in @xcite , and we leave discussion of its applicability for these very elongated triangle shapes to a future work . ] the suppression ratio @xmath185 is defined in an identical way to @xmath186 , but for the @xmath187 power spectrum .
we can now evaluate eq .
[ giieq : ester2 ] analytically , converting to its fourier representation @xmath188 \nonumber\\ & & + c^{\text{ig } } \big[c^{\text{ig } } \left(c^{\text{gg}}k_7+c^{\text{ggn } } k_8\right)+c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{gg } } k_9 + c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{ig}}k_{10}\\ & & + c^{\text{ggn } } \left(c^{\text{gg } } k_{11}+c^{\text{ggn } } k_{12}\right)\big]\nonumber\\ & & + c^{\text{ggn } } \big[c^{\text{ggn } } \left(c^{\text{gg } } c_1 + c^{\text{ggn } } e_1\right)+ c^{\text{ig}}c^{\text{ig } } k_5+c^{\text{ii } } \left(c^{\text{gg } } k_5+c^{\text{ggn } } k_6\right)\nonumber\\ & & + c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{gg}}k_{13}+ c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{ig } } k_{14}\big]\big\ } \nonumber\label{giieq : ester3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the details of this calculation and the coefficients @xmath189 and @xmath190 are included in the appendix .
the final rms error @xmath191 evaluated for a given triangle with bin width @xmath192 is then given by @xmath193 \nonumber\\ & & + c^{\text{ig } } \big[c^{\text{ig } } \left(c^{\text{gg}}k_7+c^{\text{ggn } } k_8\right)+c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{gg } } k_9 + c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{ig}}k_{10}\\ & & + c^{\text{ggn } } \left(c^{\text{gg } } k_{11}+c^{\text{ggn } } k_{12}\right)\big]\nonumber\\ & & + c^{\text{ggn } } \big[c^{\text{ggn } } \left(c^{\text{gg } } c_1 + c^{\text{ggn } } e_1\right)+ c^{\text{ig}}c^{\text{ig } } k_5+c^{\text{ii } } \left(c^{\text{gg } } k_5+c^{\text{ggn } } k_6\right)\nonumber\\ & & + c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{gg}}k_{13}+ c^{\text{gg}}c^{\text{ig } } k_{14}\big]\big\}\nonumber\label{giieq : ester4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath194 and @xmath195 , where @xmath196 is the average number density of galaxies in the _ i_-th redshift bin .
the statistical error @xmath191 differs in several key ways from the statistical error @xmath191 in the ggi self - calibration , both in the complexity of its calculation due to the additional @xmath29 term and the resulting components , which include terms like @xmath187 .
it is more sensitive to the intrinsic alignment contamination in the limit than in the igg and 2-point cases , but is still safe from strong dependence in the limit where @xmath197 is dominant .
the errors @xmath191 and @xmath198 @xcite propagate into the measurement of @xmath88 through eq .
[ giieq : scale4 ] . to find the fractional error @xmath184 this induces in the lensing bispectrum , we simply scale @xmath199 by the factor @xmath200 such that @xmath201 . this error is equal to @xmath71 , the minimum intrinsic alignment @xmath200 which can be detected through the self - calibration with s / n=1 or @xmath202 .
thus both the residual statistical error in the measurement of @xmath203 and the lower limit at which the intrinsic alignment can be calculated and removed with the self - calibration is represented by @xmath204 .
thus the gii self - calibration technique can turn a systematic contamination @xmath200 of the lensing signal into a statistical error @xmath205 , which is insensitive to the original intrinsic alignment contamination .
we show in fig .
[ giifig : merror ] @xmath184 for the survey parameters described in sec .
[ giiback ] . compared to the minimum survey error as found in @xcite , @xmath184 is negligible for most scales , only becoming comparable for some photo - z bin combinations at very large scale .
the inaccuracy of the relationship between @xmath62 and the observable @xmath75 is quantified in eq .
[ giieq : sys1 ] by @xmath206 .
the dominant systematic error in the measurement of @xmath157 through the gii self - calibration technique is due to this inaccuracy . for equilateral triangles ( @xmath115 )
, @xmath206 is plotted for several sets of adjacent redshift bins , where the stronger dependence of the lensing kernel on redshift causes a significantly higher inaccuracy .
we neglect totally non - adjacent photo - z bin combinations , as the gii signal is truly negligible in such cases .
equation [ giieq : scale4 ] is accurate to within @xmath207 for all scales and photo - z bin combinations .
however , for most scales and photo - z bin choices , it is accurate to within @xmath3 .
this is comparable to the accuracy found in the ggi self - calibration , and we expect the gii self - calibration to be capable of reducing the gii intrinsic alignment contamination by a factor of 10 or so in general .
these results are insensitive to the original intrinsic alignment contamination , such that for any @xmath208 , the ggi self - calibration will reduce the ggi contamination down to survey limits or by a factor of 10 or so , whichever is less , for all but a few photo - z bin choices at large scale . ] in addition to the statistical error introduced through the estimator @xmath118 , there is a systematic error which is introduced by eq .
[ giieq : scale4 ] , which relates the intrinsic alignment contamination @xmath62 in the lensing bispectrum to other survey observables . the accuracy of eq .
[ giieq : scale4 ] is quantified by @xmath209\bigg)^{-1}-1.\label{giieq : sys1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this induces a residual systematic error in the lensing measurement of @xmath210 @xmath206 is evaluated numerically and shown in fig .
[ giifig : serror ] for equilateral triangles and a variety of neighboring photo - z bin choices .
we neglect totally non - adjacent photo - z bin combinations , as the gii signal is truly negligible in such cases .
the accuracy of eq .
[ giieq : scale4 ] reflects the differences between @xmath62 and @xmath211 .
the accuracy of eq .
[ giieq : scale4 ] depends primarily on mean redshift of the photo - z bins chosen , becoming more accurate at higher redshift where the intrinsic alignment is less strong . by comparison ,
the accuracy of the equivalent scaling relation for the ggi self - calibration shows strong tendencies toward the effects of the lensing kernel , since the lensing contribution to the signal is much stronger .
equation [ giieq : scale4 ] is accurate to within @xmath207 for all scales and photo - z bin combinations .
however , for most scales and photo - z bin choices , it is accurate to within @xmath3 .
this is comparable to the accuracy found in the ggi self - calibration , and we expect the gii self - calibration to be capable of reducing the gii intrinsic alignment contamination by a factor of 10 or so in general .
these results are insensitive to the original intrinsic alignment contamination , such that for any @xmath208 , the ggi self - calibration will reduce the ggi contamination down to survey limits or by a factor of 10 or so , whichever is less , for all but a few photo - z bin choices at large scale .
the actual impact of the systematic on the measurement of @xmath212 is significantly less , however , as it is scaled by @xmath200 , which is typically expected to be on the order of 10 - 20% .
this would lead to an actual systematic error on the percent level .
the gii self - calibration suffers from many additional potential sources of uncertainty , including uncertainties in galaxy bias modelling , limitations in the models used for the intrinsic alignment and bispectrum calculations , magnification bias effects , and the effects of non - gaussianity in the bispectrum .
@xcite provides detailed calculations which compare the order at which magnification and non - gaussian effects , as well as uncertainties in the galaxy bias model , might impact the self - calibration for the ggi bispectrum . while not all of these calculations apply directly to the gii self - calibration , it is trivial to replicate them following @xcite .
they also address a range of other possible factors which might influence the self - calibration , including for example cosmological uncertainties and catastrophic photo - z errors . in all cases ,
they find that the dominant impact on the performance of the self - calibration comes from the statistical and systematic errors described in secs .
[ giiciggerror ] and [ giiscalingerror ] .
we find that this holds for the gii self - calibration as well , with the exception of uncertainty in the galaxy bias parameters , which becomes comparable to the statistical measurement error in @xmath213 at large scale .
the performance of the gii self - calibration can be summarised under three regimes , which are defined by the magnitude of the gii contamination as represented by @xmath200 .
the first is where the gii correlation is too small to detect in @xmath98 , with @xmath214 .
if the intrinsic alignment can not be detected in @xmath98 , the gii self - calibration is not applicable .
this generally means that the gii contamination is also negligible when compared to @xmath215 , the minimum statistical error in the lensing bispectrum , and there is no need to correct for it .
this is likely true for all totally non - adjacent photo - z bin choices , where the gii signal is naturally negligible as discussed in @xcite .
however , the gii contamination to the lensing bispectrum is likely not negligible if @xmath216 and it must be corrected for .
the gii self - calibration is now able to detect and calculate the gii cross - correlation . in the second regime , where @xmath217 , the statistical error @xmath184 induced by measurement error in the estimator
@xmath118 is dominant .
this error is generally negligible when compared to @xmath215 , and so in this regime , the gii self - calibration should perform at the statistical limit of the lensing survey . where @xmath218 , the systematic error @xmath219 due to the relationship between @xmath62 and @xmath75 in eq .
[ giieq : scale4 ] is dominant . in the case where @xmath220 , @xmath215 is still dominant .
otherwise the gii self - calibration can suppress the gii contamination by a factor of 10 or so for all but a few photo - z bin choices at the largest scales . in this case
, other complementary techniques could be employed to further reduce the gii contamination down to the statistical limit for the lensing survey .
for example , one such case has been explored by @xcite for the 2-point correlations , but such studies of the 3-point intrinsic alignment are left to be done .
@xcite combines the gi self - calibration with a photo - z self - calibration to better protect the gi self - calibration against catastrophic photo - z effects .
both methods are possible because the gi and ggi self - calibration uses primarily those correlations in one redshift bin to estimate the intrinsic alignment , while @xcite use those correlations between redshift bins .
others have also used information between redshift bins to calibrate the intrinsic alignment contamination in the 2- and 3-point correlations @xcite .
such techniques for the 3-point intrinsic alignment correlations should eventually complement the gii and ggi self - calibration techniques for improved reductions in the contamination by the intrinsic alignment in the cosmic shear signal , but further exploration is necessary in order to jointly apply these complementary techniques to realistic survey conditions .
the 3-point intrinsic alignment correlations ( ggi , gii , iii ) are expected to strongly contaminate the galaxy lensing bispectrum at up to the 20% level .
@xcite showed that while the iii correlation can be safely neglected by considering only the cross - correlation bispectrum between three different photo - z bins , the gii cross - correlation remains a contaminant for adjacent bins in addition to the ggi cross - correlation and thus must be considered in any self - calibration of adjacent photo - z bin combinations .
@xcite first generalized the self - calibration technique to the bispectrum in order to calculate and remove the 3-point ggi contamination from the ggg bispectrum . in this work
we extend the self - calibration to the 3-point gii cross - correlation in order to measure and remove its remaining contamination from adjacent bin triplets . in order to do this ,
we establish the estimator @xmath118 to extract the gii correlation from the galaxy ellipticity - ellipticity - density measurement for a photo - z galaxy sample .
this estimator is expected to be generally applicable to weak lensing surveys and reduces to the simple extraction method for spectroscopic galaxy samples at low photo - z error .
we then develop a scaling relation between the gii and gii bispectra using the linear and non - linear galaxy bias to relate the galaxy density and cosmic shear measurements .
we can then calculate and remove the gii correlation from the ggg bispectrum . while this method is in principle applicable to all @xmath69 and triangle shapes
, we maintain the modest restrictions of @xcite on very elongated triangles due to the effects of non - gaussianity and at very non - linear scales due to limitations in the understanding of the galaxy bias model used .
combining the gii and ggi self - calibration techniques will then allow a complete removal of the 3-point intrinsic alignment contamination from the cosmic shear signal .
the performance of the gii self - calibration technique is also quantified for a typical weak - lensing survey . the residual statistical error due to measurement uncertainty in the estimator @xmath118
is shown to be generally negligible when compared to the minimum measurement error in the lensing bispectrum .
we consider the systematic error introduced by the relationship between @xmath62 and @xmath75 , showing that @xmath221 for all photo - z bin choices and all scales , while except for the very largest scales , @xmath222 .
the intrinsic alignment contamination can then be reduce the gii contamination by a factor of 10 or more for all adjacent photo - z bin combinations at @xmath0 . for larger scales ,
we find that the gii contamination can be reduced by a factor of 3 - 5 or more .
this will potentially allow the gii self - calibration to reduce the gii correlation to the statistical limit of the lensing survey , as discussed in sec .
[ giibehavior ] .
these results are not strongly sensitive to the original intrinsic alignment contamination , such that for any @xmath208 , the gii self - calibration can reduce the gii contamination down to survey limits or by a factor of 10 or so , whichever is less , for all but the largest scales .
this is comparable to the ggi self - calibration , where for any @xmath223 , it can reduces the ggi contamination down to survey limits or by a factor of 10 or greater for most photo - z bin choices , whichever is less .
we thus expect the gii self - calibration to perform well with the ggi self - calibration , and together they promise to be an efficient technique to isolate the total 3-point intrinsic alignment signal from the cosmic shear measurement .
the authors would like to thank p. zhang for valuable comments .
mi acknowledges that this material is based upon work supported in part by national science foundation under grant ast-1109667 and nasa under grant nnx09aj55 g , and that part of the calculations for this work have been performed on the cosmology computer cluster funded by the hoblitzelle foundation .
when evaluating the sum and converting eq .
[ giieq : ester2 ] to fourier space , the products of the correlations each have a numerical coefficient due to the restrictions on redshift ordering .
many , however , are identical due to symmetries , and others are numerically equivalent when specific suppression ratios are chosen .
the calculation of the unique coefficients @xmath225 and @xmath190 in eqs .
[ giieq : ester3 ] & [ giieq : ester4 ] are summarised here .
the coefficients @xmath225 are simply collections of other coefficients , as shown @xmath226 from these , we group the coefficients by the number of orientation dependent correlations , for example @xmath227 , are involved in their calculation .
the first coefficient is trivial , due to products with no noise correlations or orientation dependent correlations .
we then calculate @xmath228 for the following terms , each is calculated as in the case of eq .
[ giieq : appendix ] , but limited by some ordering restriction due to a noise or orientation dependent correlation . for those terms with no orientation dependent correlations , there exist five unique coefficients : @xmath229 the coefficient @xmath230 is achieved through the restrictions @xmath231 , @xmath232 , and @xmath233 ; @xmath234 is achieved through @xmath235 and @xmath236 ; @xmath237 through @xmath238 , @xmath239 , @xmath240 , and @xmath241 ; @xmath242 through @xmath243 and @xmath244 ; and finally @xmath245 through @xmath246 and @xmath247 . using the shorthand @xmath252 for eq .
[ giieq : sub ] , we can express the coefficient conditions as follows .
the coefficient @xmath253 is achieved through the restriction @xmath254 ; @xmath255 is achieved through @xmath256 ; @xmath257 through @xmath258 and @xmath259 ; @xmath260 through @xmath261 and @xmath262 ; @xmath263 through @xmath264 and @xmath265 ; @xmath266 through @xmath267 and @xmath268 ; @xmath269 through @xmath270 and @xmath271 ; @xmath272 through @xmath273 , @xmath274 , @xmath275 , and @xmath276 ; @xmath277 through @xmath278 and @xmath279 ; @xmath280 through @xmath281 and @xmath282 , and @xmath283 ; @xmath284 through @xmath285 and @xmath286 ; @xmath287 through @xmath288 and @xmath289 ; @xmath290 through @xmath291 and @xmath292 ; @xmath293 through @xmath294 and @xmath295 ; @xmath296 through @xmath297 and @xmath298 ; @xmath299 through @xmath300 and @xmath301 ; @xmath302 through @xmath303 , @xmath304 , and @xmath305 ; @xmath306 through @xmath307 and @xmath308 ; @xmath309 through @xmath310 and @xmath311 ; @xmath312 through @xmath313 and @xmath314 ; and finally @xmath315 through @xmath316 and @xmath317 . for those with two orientation dependent correlations
, there exist 12 unique coefficients : @xmath318 the coefficient @xmath319 is achieved through the restrictions @xmath320 and @xmath321 ; @xmath322 is achieved through @xmath323 and @xmath324 ; @xmath325 through @xmath326 and @xmath327 ; @xmath328 through @xmath329 and @xmath330 ; @xmath331 through @xmath332 and @xmath333 ; @xmath334 through @xmath335 and @xmath336 ; @xmath337 through @xmath338 and @xmath339 ; @xmath340 through @xmath341 and @xmath342 ; @xmath343 through @xmath338 and @xmath339 ; @xmath344 through @xmath345 and @xmath346 ; @xmath347 through @xmath348 and @xmath349 ; and finally @xmath350 through @xmath351 and @xmath352
. finally , for those with three orientation dependent correlations , there exist 4 unique coefficients : @xmath353 the coefficient @xmath354 is achieved through the restrictions @xmath355 and @xmath356 ; @xmath357 is achieved through @xmath358 and @xmath359 ; @xmath360 through @xmath361 and @xmath362 ; and finally @xmath363 through @xmath364 and @xmath365 . 108 baldauf t. , smith r. , seljak u. , mandelbaum r. , 2010 , prd , 81 , 063531 blazek j. , mcquinn m. , seljak u. , 2011 , jcap , 05 , 010 bridle s. , king l. , 2007 , new j. phys . ,
9 , 444 brown m.l .
, taylor a.n . , hambly n.c .
, dye s. , 2002 , mnras , 333 , 501 brown m.l . ,
taylor a.n . ,
bacon d.j . , gray m.e .
, dye s. , meisenheimer k. , wolf c. , 2003 , mnras , 341 , 100 catelan p. , kamionkowski m. , blandford r.d .
, 2001 , mnras , 320 , l7 cooray a. , sheth r. , 2002 , phys .
372 , 1 crittenden r.g .
, natarajan p. , pen u .-
theuns t. , 2001 , apj , 559 , 552 croft r. , metzler c. , 2000 , apj , 545 , 561 faltenbacher a. , li c. , white s.d.m .
, jing y.p . , mao s. , wang j. , 2009 , res .
astron . & astrophys . , 9 , 41 fry j.n . , gaztanaga e. , 1993 , apj , 413 , 447 heymans c. , heavens a. , 2003 , mnras , 339 , 711 heymans c. , white m. , heavens a. , vale c. , van waerbeke l. , 2006 , mnras , 371 , 750 hirata c.m . , seljak u. , 2003 , prd , 67 , 43001 hirata c.m . , seljak u. , 2004 , prd , 70 , 063526 hirata c.m . , mandelbaum r. , ishak m. , seljak u. , nichol r. , pimbblet k.a . , ross n.p . ,
wake d. , 2007 , mnras , 381 , 1197 hu w. , 2000 , prd , 62 , 043007 hu w. , 2002 , prd , 65 , 023003 huterer d. , komatsu e. , shandera s. , 2010 , advances in astronomy , vol .
2010 , i d .
697147 ishak m. , 2005 , mnras , 363 , 469 ishak m. , foundation of physics journal , 2007 , 37 , 1470 jeong d. , komatsu e. , 2009 , apj , 703 , 1230 jing y.p .
, 2002 , mnras , 335 , 89 joachimi b. , bridle s. , 2010 , a&a , 523 , a1 joachimi b. , schneider p. , 2008
, a&a , 488 , 829 joachimi b. , schneider p. , 2009
, a&a , 507 , 105 joachimi b. , schneider p. , 2010
, a&a , 517 , a4 joachimi b. , mandelbaum r. , abdalla f. , bridle s. , 2010 , a&a , 527 , a26 king l. , 2005 , a&a , 441 , 47 king l. , schneider p. , 2002
, a&a , 396 , 411 king l. , schneider p. , 2003
, a&a , 398 , 23 kirk d. , bridle s. , schneider m. , 2010 , mnras , 408 , 1502 krause e. , hirata c.m . , 2011 , mnras , 410 , 2730 lsst science collaborations and lsst project , 2009 , lsst science book , version 2.0 , arxiv : astro - ph/0912.0201 , http://www.lsst.org/lsst/scibook/ mandelbaum r. , hirata c.m . , ishak m. , seljak u. , brinkmann j. , 2006 , mnras , 367 , 611 matarrese s. , verde l. , jimenez r. , 2000 , apj , 541 , 10 munshi d. , van waerbeke l. , smidt j. , coles p. , 2012 ,
mnras , 419 , 536 okumura t. , jing y.p .
, 2009 , apjl , 694 , l83 refregier a. , 2003 , ann . rev .
a&a , 41 , 645 schmidt f. , 2008 , prd , 78 , 043002 scoccimarro r. , couchman h. , 2001 , mnras , 325 , 1312 semboloni e. , heymans c. , van waerbeke l. , schneider p. , 2008
, mnras , 388 , 991 semboloni e. , schrabback t. , van waerbeke l. , vafaei s. , hartlap j. , hilbert s. , 2010 , mnras , 410 , 143 schneider m.d . , bridle s. , 2010 , mnras , 402 , 2127 shi x. , joachimi b. , schneider p. , 2010
, a&a , 523 , a60 song y.s . , 2005 , prd , 71 , 024026 takada m. , jain b. , 2003 , mnras , 340 , 580 takada m. , jain b. , 2004 , mnras , 348 , 897 troxel m.a . ,
ishak m. , 2012 , mnras , 419 , 1804 troxel m.a . , ishak m. , 2012 , submitted mnras troxel m.a . , ishak m. , 2012 , accepted mnras vafaei s. , lu t. , van waerbeke l. , semboloni e. , heymans c. , pen u .-
l . , 2010 ,
32 , 340 verde l. , jimenez r. , kamionkowski m. , matarrese s. , 2001 , mnras , 325 , 412 zhang p. , 2010 ,
apj , 720 , 1090 zhang p. , 2010
, mnras , 406 , l95 zhang p. , pen u .-
bernstein g. , 2010 , mnras , 405 , 359 | we extend the 3-point intrinsic alignment self - calibration technique to the gravitational shear - intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity ( gii ) bispectrum . the proposed technique will allow the measurement and removal of the gii intrinsic alignment contamination from the cross - correlation weak lensing signal .
while significantly decreased from using cross - correlations instead of auto - correlation in a single photo - z bin , the gii contamination persists in adjacent photo - z bins and must be accounted for and removed from the lensing signal .
we relate the gii and galaxy density - intrinsic ellipticity - intrinsic ellipticity ( gii ) bispectra through use of the galaxy bias , and develop the estimator necessary to isolate the gii bispectrum from observations .
we find that the gii self - calibration technique performs at a level comparable to that of the gravitational shear - gravitational shear - intrinsic ellipticity correlation ( ggi ) self - calibration technique , with measurement error introduced through the gii estimator generally negligible when compared to minimum survey error .
the accuracy of the relationship between the gii and gii bispectra typically allows the gii self - calibration to reduce the gii contamination by a factor of 10 or more for all adjacent photo - z bin combinations at @xmath0 . for larger scales , we find that the gii contamination can be reduced by a factor of 3 - 5 or more .
the gii self - calibration technique is complementary to the existing ggi self - calibration technique , which together will allow the total intrinsic alignment cross - correlation signal in 3-point weak lensing to be measured and removed .
[ firstpage ] gravitational lensing cosmology |
stimulated raman adiabatic passage ( stirap ) is a well established and widely used technique for coherent population transfer in atoms and molecules @xcite .
stirap uses two delayed but partially overlapping laser pulses , pump and stokes , which drive a three - state @xmath0-system @xmath1 .
the stirap technique transfers the population adiabatically from the initially populated state @xmath2 to the target state @xmath3 .
if the pulses are ordered counterintuitively , i.e. the stokes pulse precedes the pump pulse , two - photon resonance is maintained , and adiabatic evolution is enforced , then complete population transfer from @xmath2 to @xmath3 occurs . throughout this process
, no population is placed in the ( possibly lossy ) intermediate state @xmath4 .
various aspects of stirap have been subjects of intense research , both theoretically and experimentally @xcite . because stirap is an adiabatic technique it is insensitive to small to moderate variations in most of the experimental parameters , such as pulse amplitudes , widths , delay , and single - photon detuning .
a particularly remarkable and very useful feature of stirap is its insensitivity to the properties of the intermediate state @xmath4 .
for instance , stirap has been demonstrated with high efficiency even for interaction durations exceeding the lifetime of @xmath4 by a factor of 100 @xcite .
for these reasons stirap is a very attractive technique for quantum information processing ( qip ) @xcite .
however , it is widely recognized that qip requires very high fidelities , with the admissible error of gate operations being below @xmath5 for a reliable quantum processor @xcite .
such an extreme accuracy has not yet been demonstrated for stirap , as an accuracy of 90 - 95% was sufficient for most traditional applications .
when trying to increase the fidelity beyond this number one faces various obstacles related mainly to nonadiabatic transitions .
being an adiabatic technique , stirap reaches an efficiency of unity only in the adiabatic limit ; however , the latter is approached only asymptotically as the pulse areas increase . for qip ,
the pulse areas needed are so large that they may violate various restrictions of a real experiment . in this paper
we propose how to achieve an ultrahigh fidelity in stirap , and thus make it fully suitable for qip by suitably shaped pulses .
we utilize a recent idea of guerin _ et al . _
@xcite who applied the well - known dykhne - davis - pechukas ( ddp ) method @xcite to optimize adiabatic passage in a two - state system . in order to adapt this approach to stirap , we reduce the three - level raman system to effective two - state systems in two limits : on exact resonance and for large single - photon detuning .
the optimization , which minimizes the nonadiabatic transitions and maximizes the fidelity , leads to a particular relation between the pulse shapes of the driving pump and stokes fields .
it should be noted that a fidelity of unity can also be achieved by a resonant @xmath6-pulse in a two - state transition .
however , resonant techniques suffer from their sensitivity to parameter fluctuations .
the optimized version of stirap presented here features both a very high fidelity and a robustness against variations in the intensities and the single - photon detuning .
this paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec - background ] we review the ddp method and the optimization of two - state adiabatic passage .
then we extend this idea to stirap in section [ sec - stirap ] and discuss examples in section [ sec - implementation ] . in section [ sec - f - stirap ]
we extend these ideas to fractional stirap ( f - stirap ) , which creates a coherent superposition of @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
we summarize the results in the concluding section .
the probability amplitudes in a two - state system @xmath7^{t}$ ] satisfy the schrdinger equation , ( t)=(t)(t ) , [ schrodinger-2ss ] where the hamiltonian in the rotating - wave approximation ( rwa ) reads @xcite ( t ) = 12 .
[ h2 ] the detuning @xmath8 is the difference between the transition frequency @xmath9 and the carrier laser frequency @xmath10 .
the time - varying rabi frequency @xmath11 describes the laser - atom interaction , where @xmath12 is the electric dipole moment for the @xmath13 transition and @xmath14 is the laser electric field envelope .
a very accurate technique for deriving the transition probability in the near - adiabatic regime is the dykhne - davis - pechukas ( ddp ) approximation @xcite .
the ddp formula gives the following expression for the probability for nonadiabatic transitions
pe^-2d(t_0 ) , [ dp-1 ] where d(t_0)=_0^t_0(t)dt [ d(tc ) ] is an integral over the splitting @xmath15 of the eigenenergies of the hamiltonian ( [ h2 ] ) .
the point @xmath16 ( the transition point ) is defined as the ( complex ) zero of the quasienergy splitting , @xmath17 , which lies in the upper half of the complex @xmath18-plane ( i.e. , with im@xmath19 ) .
equation ( [ dp-1 ] ) gives the correct asymptotic probability for nonadiabatic transitions provided :
( i ) the quasienergy splitting @xmath20 does not vanish for real @xmath18 , including @xmath21 ; ( ii ) @xmath20 is analytic and single - valued at least throughout a region of the complex @xmath18-plane that includes the region from the real axis to the transition point @xmath16 ; ( iii ) the transition point @xmath16 is well separated from the other quasienergy zero points ( if any ) , and from possible singularities ; ( iv ) there exists a level ( or stokes ) line defined by @xmath22 , which extends from @xmath23 to @xmath24 and passes through @xmath16 . for the case of multiple zero points in the upper @xmath18-plane , eq .
( [ dp-1 ] ) can be generalized to include the contributions from all these @xmath25 zero points @xmath26 as p_k=1^n_k e^ d(t_k)^2 , [ dp - n ] where @xmath27i@xmath28 ; usually @xmath29 or @xmath30 . here
@xmath31 accounts for the nonadiabatic coupling between the adiabatic states , with @xmath32 .
gurin _ et al .
_ @xcite have used the ddp method to optimize the adiabatic passage between two states in a very simple manner . assuming that the probability for nonadiabatic losses is solely due to the transition points @xmath26 , they have proposed to suppress these altogether by choosing the rabi frequency @xmath33 and the detuning @xmath34 such that there are _ no transition points_. this condition is obviously fulfilled if the quasienergy splitting is _ constant _ , ( t)== [ trajectory ] for example , this condition is fulfilled for a detuning and rabi frequency defined as @xmath35 , \qquad \omega ( t)=\varepsilon_0\sin \left [ \pi f(t)\right ] , \label{omega - delta } \\ 0=f(-\infty ) \leqq f(t)\leqq f(\infty ) = 1 , \label{f(t)}\end{gathered}\ ] ] with @xmath36 being an arbitrary monotonically increasing function with the above property .
condition ( [ trajectory ] ) is not the only possible condition for adiabatic optimization , but it is the simplest one @xcite .
the probability amplitudes of the three states in stirap @xmath37^{t}$ ] satisfy the schrdinger equation , [ sch - eq ] ( t ) = ( t)(t ) , where the stirap hamiltonian within the rotating - wave approximation ( rwa ) reads @xcite ( t)=12 .
[ h ] the time - varying rabi frequencies @xmath38 and @xmath39 describe the couplings between the intermediate state @xmath4 and , respectively , the initial state @xmath2 and the target final state @xmath3 . stirap is easily explained with the so - called _ dark state _
@xmath40 , which is a zero - eigenvalue eigenstate of @xmath41 , [ dark - state ] _
d(t)=_1(t)-_3(t ) , where the time - dependent mixing angle @xmath42 is defined as ( t)=^-1 [ theta ] the pulses in stirap are ordered counterintuitively , i.e. , the stokes pulse precedes the pump pulse , = 0,=0 .
[ pulse - sequence ] then @xmath43 , and therefore the dark state @xmath44 connects adiabatically states @xmath2 and @xmath3 , _ 1_d(t)-_3 .
thus , if the evolution is adiabatic then the population passes from state @xmath2 to state @xmath3 .
moreover , because the dark state does not contain a contribution from the ( possibly lossy ) intermediate state @xmath4 , the properties of the latter are less important
. when the evolution is not completely adiabatic , the population transfer @xmath45 might be incomplete .
moreover , the intermediate state receives some transient population , which may either be lost if state @xmath4 decays to other states , or lead to decoherence if it decays back into @xmath2 or @xmath3 . for stirap to be a viable tool for quantum computing , nonadiabatic transitions have to be reduced below the fault - tolerance limit of @xmath46 @xcite .
we can estimate the required resources for stirap to reach such a fidelity as follows .
the adiabatic condition for stirap ( for @xmath47 ) demands large pulse areas @xmath48d@xmath49 .
this global condition is derived from the local adiabatic condition , which reads @xmath50 .
the probability for nonadiabatic transitions in the perturbative limit is @xmath51 ; it measures the population that escapes to other adiabatic states and reduces the fidelity .
the infidelity is therefore @xmath52 .
the fault - tolerance qip limit therefore requires @xmath53 .
in fact , this very rough estimate neglects various details , such as the peculiarities of the nonadiabatic coupling @xmath54 , and in reality the condition for the pulse areas is more restrictive . in the following ,
we show that an optimized version of stirap can reach the fault - tolerance qip limit by using much smaller pulse areas . in order
to optimize stirap we use the same ideas as in the two - state adiabatic passage optimization by gurin _
_ @xcite . to this end
we make use of the reduction of stirap to effective two - state problems . on single - photon resonance ( @xmath47 )
the three - state system is reduced to an effective two - state system , with a detuning @xmath39 and a coupling @xmath38 @xcite , = 12 , [ 2-st . ] where the probability amplitudes @xmath55 are related to @xmath56 as follows @xcite c_1(t ) & = & 2 ( t ) + & & + ( |b_1(t)|^2 - |b_2(t)|^2 ) ( t ) , [ diabatic-2st - vect ] + c_2(t ) & = & 2i , + c_3(t ) & = & 2 ( t ) + & & - ( |b_1(t)|^2 - |b_2(t)|^2 ) ( t ) . because we have for stirap @xmath57 and @xmath58 , the initial condition @xmath59 demands the condition @xmath60 in the effective two - state system .
the final - state population in stirap is [ c3-prob ] |c_3(+)|^2 = ^2 .
consequently , an optimized adiabatic evolution in the two - state system implies optimized stirap .
hence applied to stirap , the two - state optimum condition simply yields [ optimal resonance ] _
p(t)^2 + _ s(t)^2 = ^2 = . in other words ,
the rms rabi frequency should be constant . again , as in the two - state optimization , this is not the only possible optimization condition but it is the simplest one . for large single - photon detuning @xmath61 , the intermediate state can be eliminated adiabatically by setting @xmath62 in eq .
( [ sch - eq ] ) .
we thus obtain @xcite i = 12 , [ two - state - eff - large - d ] where the effective rabi frequency @xmath63 and detuning @xmath64 are defined as _ ( t ) & = & - , [ rabi - eff ] + _ ( t ) & = & [ detun - eff ] the two - state condition for optimal adiabatic passage now reads [ optimal far off resonance ] _ ( t)^2+_(t)^2 = ^2 = . for constant @xmath65 this condition is identical to the one we found on resonance , eq .
( [ optimal resonance ] ) , that is it requires a constant rms rabi frequency @xmath66 .
we point out that , due to the identical conditions , on and off single - photon resonance , optimization is ensured over a very wide range of single - photon detunings .
conditions ( [ optimal resonance ] ) and ( [ optimal far off resonance ] ) suggest the following parameterization of the pump and stokes fields _
p(t ) & = & , + _
s(t ) & = & , where @xmath36 is an arbitrary monotonically increasing function , @xmath67 . viewed mathematically , @xmath68 and @xmath69 define an adiabatic path , for which the nonadiabatic correction given by the ddp formula vanishes , which leads to an optimal adiabatic following of the dark state .
the exact fulfillment of condition ( [ optimal resonance ] ) requires a constant @xmath66 and hence , infinite pulse areas .
this unphysical condition can be overcome by using a `` mask '' function @xmath70 , _
p(t ) & = & _ 0f(t ) , + _
s(t ) & = & _ 0f(t ) .
then the rms rabi frequency becomes _ time - dependent _ , @xmath71 .
this replacement does not necessarily violate the optimization condition ( [ optimal resonance ] ) because ddp transition points may still be absent , e.g. if the mask function has a suitable shape , such as gaussian .
still , a pulse - shaped mask @xmath70 violates the ddp conditions because the eigenenergy splitting @xmath72 becomes degenerate as @xmath73 .
the implication is that the probability for nonadiabatic transitions as a function of the pulse area is no longer expressed as a simple exponential , eq . , but rather by a sum of an exponential and an oscillatory term with an amplitude that vanishes only polynomially with the pulse area @xcite .
the exponential term dominates for moderate pulse areas , whereas the oscillatory polynomial term dominates for large areas @xcite .
the border value of the area @xmath74 , where the exponential decline breaks down into slowly damped oscillations , is proportional to the ratio r between the rms pulse area @xmath75 and the overlap area @xmath76 ( the area of overlap of the pump and stokes pulses ) @xmath77 .
the exponential decline of nonadiabatic transitions is favorable for high - fidelity stirap because it allows one to achieve high fidelity with moderate pulse areas .
this is turn implies a large value of the breakdown area @xmath74 , so that the ( slowly damped ) oscillations emerge only when the infidelity is very low .
hence high - fidelity stirap is facilitated by asymmetric pulses , with longer outer tails , so that the ratio @xmath78 ( and hence the breakdown area @xmath74 ) is large .
these observations are further illustrated with the figures below .
the above arguments suggest the following recipe for choosing @xmath70 : * @xmath70 should be a _ flat
_ function during the time of overlap of the pump and stokes pulses , during which the population transition takes place ; * @xmath70 should have a sufficiently _ large width _ so that the rms - to - overlap ratio @xmath78 is sufficiently large . in the examples below , as a mask @xmath70 we use the hypergaussian function , f(t)=^- ( t / t_0)^2n , [ f - pulse ] where @xmath79 corresponds to the gaussian shape . for larger ( positive integer )
@xmath80 the condition @xmath81 is fulfilled increasingly better in the overlap region .
there is a some leeway in the choice of the function @xmath36 as long as the adiabatic condition is fulfilled in the overlap region .
we use f(t ) = 11+^-t / t .
[ f(t ) example ] ) for all times @xmath18 ; 2 : pulse shapes with a hypergaussian mask ( [ f - pulse ] ) , with @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 ; 3 : gaussian pulses ( [ gaussian - pulses ] ) , with pulse delay @xmath85.,width=283 ] we point out that other choices of the function @xmath36 are also possible
. however , with the chosen method of optimization being based on the ddp approximation , which is valid only in the near - adiabatic regime , the function @xmath36 has to fulfill the adiabaticity criterion [ 2st .
ad . condition ] |(t)| | ( t ) | , where @xmath54 is the nonadiabatic coupling . using eq .
ad . condition ] ) we obtain the following condition for the function @xmath36 |(t)| _ 0 | f(t ) | ; hence @xmath36 should have a smooth time dependence in order to facilitate adiabaticity . once in the adiabatic regime , however , the function @xmath36 does not affect the ddp optimization because it does not appear in the condition . three different pulse shapes are shown in fig .
[ fig - epspulses ] : pulse shapes that obey the optimization condition for all times @xmath18 , along with the more realistic example with a hypergaussian mask , that obey the optimization condition only in the region of overlap of the pump and stokes pulses , and gaussian pulses .
[ gaussian - pulses]_p = _ 0 ^ -(t- /2)/t^2,_s = _ 0 ^-(t+/2)/t^2 , where @xmath86 is the pulse delay .
we note that the pulse area @xmath87 for the gaussian pulses is almost identical with the ddp optimized pulses . in the following
we demonstrate that the optimally shaped pulses are superior to the gaussian pulses , even with optimized delay for the latter , in achieving a very high fidelity . ) and ddp - optimized pulses ( @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath79 , @xmath88 , @xmath84).,width=283 ] in figure [ fig - epsopt_exp1 ] we plot the stirap infidelity , i.e. the deviation @xmath89 from perfect transfer for the optimized pulses , described above , and compare these to the results for the traditional implementation of stirap with a pair of gaussian pulses .
the infidelity is shown as a function of the peak rabi frequency .
for gaussian pulses , the pulse delay is chosen such that a nearly maximum fidelity is obtained . despite the optimum delay
, the gaussian shapes do not allow us to reduce the infidelity below the limit @xmath5 in the shown range of pulse areas ( eventually , at very high pulse areas the infidelity drops below this limit ) . on the contrary , ddp - optimized pulse shapes ( with @xmath79 , @xmath88 , @xmath84 ) break this limit even for small pulse areas . of the hypergaussian ( @xmath82 )
mask @xmath70 , eq .
( [ f - pulse]).,width=283 ] we note that the ddp pulses are not fully optimized due to the mask function @xmath70 vanishing at large times .
therefore the respective fidelity curve starts to oscillate , which signals the occurence of nonadiabatic transitions .
however , the magnitude of these nonadiabatic transitions can be controlled by the width of the mask function @xmath70 : a larger width pushes these oscillations further down .
hence even for small pulse areas , the optimally shaped pulses are far superior to the gaussian pulses , as shown in fig .
[ fig - epsopt_exp1 ] .
this tendency is also visible in fig .
[ fig - epsopt ] where the infidelity is plotted as a function of the pulse area for two different widths @xmath90 of the mask function @xmath70 , eq .
( [ f - pulse ] ) . by increasing the mask width
@xmath90 , the validity range of the adiabatic optimization condition ( [ optimal resonance ] ) widens , and the optimized pulses approach the ideal ddp - optimized pulse shapes in fig .
[ fig - epspulses ] . from the intermediate level for ddp - optimized ( @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 ) and gaussian pulses ( delay @xmath91 ) for a peak rabi frequency @xmath92.,width=283 ] in fig .
[ fig - epsdetuning ] we compare the line profile as a function of the common detuning @xmath65 from the intermediate level ( see eq .
( [ h ] ) ) for the optimized and gaussian pulse shapes .
the time delay for the gaussian pulses is numerically chosen for nearly maximum fidelity .
it is known that a single - photon detuning does not affect the dark state ( as long as two - photon resonance is maintained ) @xcite .
nonetheless , adiabaticity deteriorates and the transfer efficiency decreases with increasing single - photon detuning .
the robustness of the high fidelity stirap ( i.e. stirap where the infidelity is below the limit @xmath5 ) against the single - photon detuning is much more pronounced for the optimized pulses .
this feature is readily explained by the fact that the same pulse shapes optimize stirap both for @xmath47 and for large @xmath93 , as discussed above . , @xmath83 @xmath84 ) and gaussian pulses ( delay @xmath94 ) for a peak rabi frequency @xmath92.,width=283 ] it
is known that the transfer efficiency for stirap is much more sensitive to a detuning from raman resonance than to the single - photon detuning @xcite .
figure [ fig - eps2pdet ] shows the raman line profile for ddp - optimized and gaussian pulses .
as before , the time delay for the gaussian pulses is numerically chosen such that a nearly maximum transition probability @xmath95 is obtained .
the optimized pulse shapes are far superior to the gaussian pulses and allow one to maintain a high fidelity over a wide range of two - photon detunings .
the rotating wave approximation ( rwa ) is widely used whenever laser - induced excitations with optical frequencies @xmath10 much larger than the rabi frequency @xmath96 are considered .
typical optical ( carrier ) frequencies are @xmath97 $ ] , while the typical rabi frequencies are within the range @xmath98 $ ] @xcite . for two - level systems ,
perturbative inclusion of the counter - rotating terms results in the bloch - siegert shift of the eigenenergies by @xmath99 @xcite . within a typical pulse duration @xmath100 $ ]
, this accumulates maximum deviation from the calculated probabilities of @xmath101 it should be also noted that the results in rwa are exact in case of circular polarization @xcite .
fractional stirap ( f - stirap ) is a variation of stirap , which creates an arbitrary preselected coherent superposition of states @xmath2 and @xmath3 , [ hadamard ] = _ 1-_3 . as in stirap , the stokes pulse precedes the pump pulse , but unlike stirap , where the stokes pulse vanishes first , in f - stirap the two pulses vanish simultaneously , while maintaining a constant ratio of their amplitudes @xcite , [ pulse - sequence - fstirap ] 0 .
a convenient realization of f - stirap reads @xcite [ f - stirap ] _
p(t ) & = & _ 0 ^ - ( t-/2)^2/t^2 , [ fstirap - pump ] + _ s(t ) & = & _ 0\ { ^- ( t+/2)^2/t^2+^- ( t-/2)^2/t^2 } .
[ fstirap - stokes ] the ddp - optimized pulses , in analogy with the full stirap , read [ optimal f - stirap ] _
p(t ) & = & _ 0f(t ) , + _
s(t ) & = & _ 0f(t ) , where @xmath36 is again an arbitrary function that satisfies condition .
it is easy to verify that these pulse shapes satisfy the f - stirap condition ( [ pulse - sequence - fstirap ] ) . for half - stirap , when an equal coherent superposition of states @xmath2 and @xmath3 is created , we should have @xmath102 .
this superposition corresponds to the hadamard gate , which is one of the fundamental gates in quantum information processing . ,
@xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath79 , @xmath88 , @xmath84 ) and gaussian pulses ( with @xmath103).,width=283 ] figure [ fig - fstirap ] compares the transfer efficiency of f - stirap for ddp - optimized pulses and for pulses given by eqs .
( [ f - stirap ] ) . the pulse delay for the pulses ( [ f - stirap ] )
is chosen numerically for nearly maximum fidelity . in fig .
[ fig - fstirap ] the infidelity is defined as [ infidelity ] 1-|<_final|_desired>|^2 , where @xmath104 is given by eq .
( [ hadamard ] ) at @xmath102 and @xmath105 is numerically calculated for both ddp - optimized and gaussian pulses .
it is important to note that despite the delay optimization , the pulses ( [ f - stirap ] ) do not allow reduction of the infidelity below a certain limit . due to the mask function @xmath70
, the ddp - optimized pulses led to an oscillatory behaviour of the infidelity .
however , the oscillatory regime and hence the fidelity depend on the width @xmath90 and can be controlled .
in particular in the regime of small pulse areas , the ddp - optimized version of f - stirap ( with @xmath79 , @xmath88 , @xmath84 ) is far superior to the traditional gaussian pulses as shown in fig .
[ fig - fstirap ] .
we have proposed an optimization of the fidelity of the stirap technique , which uses the ddp approach to minimize nonadiabatic losses .
the rationale for this is the reduction of stirap from three to two states either : on exact single - photon resonance or for large single - photon detuning .
interestingly , the optimized pulse shapes are the same in both regimes , which makes ddp - optimized stirap very robust against variations in the detuning .
we have demonstrated with numerical simulations that the fidelity of this optimized stirap can reach very high values , with an error well below the fault - tolerant qip limit of @xmath5 , which is very difficult to reach by optimizing the pulse delay with the usual gaussian pulse shapes ( or other symmetric pulse shapes , such as hyperbolic - secant ) .
the proposed optimization is of potential importance for qip because it supplements the robustness of stirap against parameter variations with an ultrahigh fidelity of gate operations .
we furthermore emphasize that a similar optimization method could also have a significant impact on the vacuum - stimulated raman scattering in cavity qed @xcite .
this work has been supported by the projects emali , fastquast and scala of the european union , the epsrc grant(ep
/ e023568/1 ) , the research unit 635 of the german research foundation and the bulgarian nsf grants nos . 205/06 , 301/07 , and d002 - 90/08 .
n. v. vitanov , m. fleischhauer , b. w. shore and k. bergmann , adv . at .
. opt . phys . * 46 * , 55 ( 2001 ) ; n. v. vitanov , t. halfmann , b. w. shore and k. bergmann , ann .
phys . chem . *
52 * , 763 ( 2001 ) ; j. klein , f. beil , and t. halfmann , phys .
a * 78 * , 033416 ( 2008 ) . z.
kis and f. renzoni , phys .
a * 65 * , 032318 ( 2002 ) ; x. lacour , s. gurin , n. v. vitanov , l. p. yatsenko and h. r. jauslin , opt . commun . * 264 * , 362 ( 2006 ) ; c. wunderlich , t. hannemann , t. krber , h. hffner , c. roos , w. hnsel , r. blatt and f. schmidt- kaler , j. mod
. opt . * 54 * , 1541 ( 2007 ) .
p. w. shor , 37th symposium on foundations of computing 5665 ( ieee computer society press , washington dc , 1996 ) ; a. steane , rep .
. phys . * 61 * , 117 ( 1998 ) ; e. knill , nature * 434 * , 39 ( 2005 ) ; j. benhelm , g. kirchmair , c. f. roos and r. blatt , nature phys .
* 4 * , 463 ( 2008 ) . | stimulated raman adiabatic passage ( stirap ) , driven with pulses of optimum shape and delay has the potential of reaching fidelities high enough to make it suitable for fault - tolerant quantum information processing .
the optimum pulse shapes are obtained upon reduction of stirap to effective two - state systems .
we use the dykhne - davis - pechukas ( ddp ) method to minimize nonadiabatic transitions and to maximize the fidelity of stirap .
this results in a particular relation between the pulse shapes of the two fields driving the raman process .
the ddp - optimized version of stirap maintains its robustness against variations in the pulse intensities and durations , the single - photon detuning and possible losses from the intermediate state . |
the recovery problem of sparse vectors from a linear underdetermined set of equations has recently attracted attention in various fields of science and technology due to its many applications , for example , in linear regression @xcite , communication @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , multimedia @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and compressive sampling ( cs ) @xcite , @xcite .
in such a sparse representation problem , we have the following underdetermined set of linear equations @xmath12 where @xmath13 is @xmath14 is the dictionary @xmath15 is and @xmath16.[multiblock footnote omitted ] another way of writing is that a large dimensional sparse vector @xmath1 is coded / compressed into a small dimensional vector @xmath17 and the task will be to find the @xmath1 from @xmath17 with the full knowledge of @xmath7 . for this problem , the optimum solution is the sparsest vector satisfying . finding the sparsest vector is however np - hard ; thus , a variety of practical algorithms have been developed . among the most prominent
is the convex relaxation approach in which the objective is to find the minimum @xmath4-norm solution to . for the @xmath4-norm minimization , if @xmath1 is @xmath18-sparse , which indicates that the number of non - zero entries of @xmath1 is at most @xmath18 , the minimum @xmath18 that satisfies gives the limit up to which the signal can be compressed for a given dictionary @xmath7 .
an interesting question then arises : how does the choice of the dictionary @xmath7 affect the typical compression ratio that can be achieved using the @xmath4-recovery ?
recent results in the parallel problem of cs , where @xmath7 acts as a sensing matrix , reveal that the typical conditions for perfect @xmath4-recovery are universal for all random sensing matrices that belong to the rotationally invariant matrix ensembles @xcite .
the standard setup , where the entries of the sensing matrix are independent standard gaussian , is an example that belongs to this ensemble .
it is also known that the conditions required for perfect recovery do not in general depend on the details of the marginal distribution related to the non - zero elements . on the other hand , we know that correlations in the sensing matrix can degrade the performance of @xmath4-recovery @xcite .
this suggests intuitively that using a sample matrix of the rotationally invariant ensembles as @xmath7 is preferred in the recovery problem when we expect to encounter a variety of dense signals @xmath17 .
however , the set of matrix ensembles whose @xmath6-recovery performance are known is still limited , and further investigation is needed to assess whether the choice of @xmath7 is indeed so straightforward . the purpose of the present study is to fulfill this demand .
specifically , we examine the typical @xmath6-recovery performance of the matrices constructed by concatenating several randomly chosen orthonormal bases .
such construction has attracted considerable attention due to ease of implementation and theoretical elegance @xcite , @xcite , @xcite for designing sparsity inducing over - complete dictionaries for natural signals @xcite . for a practical engineering scheme , audio coding ( music source coding )
@xcite uses a dictionary formed by concatenating several modified discrete cosine transforms with different parameters . by using the replica method in conjunction with the development of an integral formula for handling random orthogonal matrices
, we show that the dictionary consisting of concatenated orthogonal matrices is also preferred in terms of the performance of @xmath6-recovery .
more precisely , the matrices can result in better @xmath6-recovery performance than that of the rotationally invariant matrices when the density of non - zero entries of @xmath1 is not uniform among the orthogonal matrix modules , while the performance is the same between the two types of matrices for the uniform densities .
this surprising result further promotes the use of the concatenated orthogonal matrices in practical applications .
this paper is organized as follows . in the next section ,
we explain the problem setting that we investigated . in section 3 , which is the main part of this paper
, we discuss the development of a methodology for evaluating the recovery performance of the concatenated orthogonal matrices on the basis of the replica method and an integral formula concerning the random orthogonal matrices . in section 4 , we explain the significance of the methodology through application to two distinctive examples , the validity of which is also justified by extensive numerical experiments .
the final section is devoted to a summary .
we assume that @xmath0 is a multiple number of @xmath19 ; namely , @xmath20 .
suppose a situation in which an @xmath21 dictionary matrix @xmath7 is constructed by concatenating @xmath22 module matrices @xmath23 , which are drawn uniformly and independently from the haar measure on @xmath10 orthogonal matrices , as @xmath24 .
\label{lorth}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using this , we compress a sparse vector @xmath25 to @xmath26 following the manner of ( [ eq : sparse_representation_without_noise ] ) . we denote @xmath27 for the concatenation of @xmath22 sub - vectors of @xmath19 dimensions as @xmath28 yielding the expression @xmath29 with full knowledge of @xmath30 @xmath31 and @xmath17 , the @xmath6-recovery is performed by solving the constrained minimization problem @xmath32 where @xmath33 for @xmath34 and @xmath35 generally denotes the minimization of @xmath36 with respect to @xmath37 and @xmath38 @xmath31 . at the minimum condition , @xmath39 constitutes the recovered vector @xmath40 in the manner of ( [ vector_union ] ) . for theoretically evaluating the @xmath6-recovery performance , we assume that the entries of @xmath41 , @xmath42 are distributed independently according to a block - dependent sparse distribution @xmath43 where @xmath44 means the density of the non - zero entries of the @xmath45-th block of the same size @xmath19 in @xmath27 and @xmath46 is a distribution whose second moment about the origin is finite , which is assumed as unity for simplicity .
intuitively , as the compression rate @xmath47 decreases , the overall density @xmath48 up to which ( [ l1_recovery ] ) can successfully recover a typical sample of the original vector @xmath27 becomes smaller .
however , precise performance may depend on the profile of @xmath49 .
the above setting allows us to quantitatively examine how such block dependence of the non - zero density affects the critical relation between @xmath50 and @xmath51 for typically successful @xmath6-recovery of @xmath27 .
expressing the solution of ( [ l1_recovery ] ) as @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 , constitutes the basis of our analysis .
equations ( [ posterior_mean ] ) and ( [ posterior ] ) mean that @xmath40 can be identified with the average of the state variable @xmath1 for the gibbs - boltzmann distribution ( [ posterior ] ) in the vanishing temperature limit @xmath55 .
however , as ( [ posterior ] ) depends on @xmath56 and @xmath57 , further averaging with respect to the generation of these external random variables is necessary for evaluating the typical properties of the @xmath6-recovery .
evaluation of such `` double averages '' can be carried out systematically using the replica method @xcite . in the replica method , we need to evaluate the average of @xmath58 for @xmath59 with respect to @xmath60 over the uniform distributions of @xmath10 orthogonal matrices . however , this is rather laborious and is easy to yield notational confusions . for reducing such technical obstacles ,
we introduce a formula convenient for accomplishing this task before going into detailed manipulations .
similar formulae have been introduced for handling random eigenbases of symmetric matrices @xcite and random left and right eigenbases of rectangular matrices @xcite .
let us assume that @xmath19-dimensional vectors @xmath61 @xmath31 are characterized by their norms as @xmath62 , where @xmath63 denotes the standard euclidean norm of the vector @xmath64 .
for these vectors , we define the function @xmath65_{\{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\ } } \right ) \cr & = & \lim_{m \to \infty } \frac{1}{m}\ln \left ( \frac{\int \left ( \prod_{t=1}^{t}{\cal d}{\boldsymbol{o}}_t \right ) \delta \left ( \sum_{t=1}^{t}{\boldsymbol{o}}_t { \boldsymbol{u}}_t \right ) } { \int \left ( \prod_{t=1}^{t}{\cal d}{\boldsymbol{o}}_t \right ) } \right ) , \label{formula_def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath66_x$ ] generally denotes the average of @xmath36 with respect to @xmath37 , and @xmath67 denotes the haar measure of the @xmath10 orthogonal matrices .
our claim is that by explicitly using @xmath68 , can be expressed as @xmath69 where @xmath70 generally denotes the extremization of function @xmath36 with respect to @xmath37 .
expression ( [ formula_concrete ] ) is derived from the fact that for fixed @xmath71 , @xmath72 moves uniformly on the surface of the @xmath19-dimensional hypersphere of radius @xmath73 when @xmath30 varies according to the uniform distribution of the orthogonal matrices ; therefore , @xmath74 in ( [ formula_def ] ) can be replaced with a spherical measure of @xmath19-dimensional vector @xmath75 . for details ,
see [ appendix1 ] .
function @xmath76 physically represents a characteristic exponent of the probability that @xmath19-dimensional vectors @xmath71 @xmath31 form a closed loop satisfying @xmath77 when they are independently and isotropically sampled under the norm constraints of @xmath78 . for small @xmath22 , the loop condition strongly restricts the region of @xmath79 to which @xmath76 is well defined . in concrete terms
, @xmath76 diverges to minus infinity unless an equality @xmath80 and the triangular inequalities @xmath81 are satisfied for @xmath82 and @xmath83 , respectively .
in particular , the constraint of ( [ t2 ] ) requires us to deal with the system of @xmath82 in a manner different from that of @xmath84 except for the case of @xmath85 , as discussed in the analysis of section 3.4 .
now , we are ready to apply the replica method for analyzing the typical property of the @xmath6-recovery ( [ posterior_mean ] ) . for this , we evaluate the @xmath86-th moment of the partition function using the identity @xmath87 which is valid for only @xmath88 . in the large system limit
@xmath89 , the rescaled logarithm of the moment , @xmath90_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0\ } , \{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\}}$ ] , can be accurately evaluated for all @xmath88 by using the saddle point method with respect to macroscopic variables @xmath91 , @xmath92 , and @xmath93 , where @xmath94 and @xmath95 .
intrinsic permutation symmetry concerning the replica indices @xmath96 in ( [ power_partition ] ) guarantees that there exists a saddle point of the form @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 , which is often termed the replica symmetric ( rs ) solution . as a simple and plausible candidate
, we adopt this solution as the relevant saddle point for describing the typical property of the @xmath6-recovery , the validity of which will be checked in section 3.5 .
the detailed computation is carried out as follows .
let us consider averaging ( [ power_partition ] ) with respect to @xmath57 and define for each fixed set of @xmath100 : @xmath101_{\{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\ } } , \label{average_o}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath102 .
when @xmath100 is placed in the configuration of the rs solution , the expression @xmath103^{\rm t } \times \left [ { \boldsymbol{u}}_t^1 \ { \boldsymbol{u}}_t^2 \ \ldots \ { \boldsymbol{u}}_t^n \right ] = \left ( \begin{array}{cccc } mr_t & mr_t & \cdots & mr_t \cr mr_t & mr_t & \cdots & mr_t \cr \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots \cr mr_t & mr_t & \cdots & m r_t \end{array } \right ) \cr & & = { \boldsymbol{e } } \times \left ( \begin{array}{cccc } m(r_t - r_t+nr_t ) & 0 & \cdots & 0 \cr 0 & m(r_t - r_t ) & \cdots & 0 \cr \vdots & \vdots & \ddots & \vdots \cr 0 & 0 & \cdots & m(r_t - r_t ) \end{array } \right ) \times { \boldsymbol{e}}^{\rm t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] holds for each @xmath45 , where @xmath104 stands for matrix transpose , @xmath105 , and @xmath106 .
@xmath107 $ ] denotes an @xmath108 orthogonal matrix composed of the vector @xmath109 and an orthonormal set of @xmath110 vectors @xmath111 that are orthogonal to @xmath112 .
this indicates that @xmath113 $ ] may be expressed as @xmath114= \left [ \tilde{{\boldsymbol{u}}}_t^1\ \tilde{{\boldsymbol{u}}}_t^2 \ \ldots \ \tilde{{\boldsymbol{u}}}_t^n \right ] \times { \boldsymbol{e}}^{\rm t } , \label{cordinate_conversion}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by using a set of @xmath86 orthogonal vectors @xmath115 ,
whose norms are given as @xmath116 and @xmath117 for @xmath118 , along with an @xmath119 orthogonal matrix @xmath120 that does not depend on @xmath45 .
this guarantees the equality @xmath121 .
furthermore , condition @xmath122 and the orthogonality of @xmath115 among the replica indexes @xmath96 allows us to evaluate the average concerning @xmath57 independently for each index @xmath123 when computing @xmath124 .
this , in conjunction with ( [ formula_def ] ) , provides each set @xmath100 of the rs configuration with an expression of ( [ average_o ] ) as @xmath125 the right hand side of ( [ energy ] ) is likely to hold for @xmath126 as well , although ( [ average_o ] ) is defined originally for only @xmath88 . on the other hand , inserting identities @xmath127 , @xmath128 and @xmath129 @xmath130 into ( [ power_partition ] ) and taking an average concerning @xmath56 , in conjunction with integration with respect to dynamical variables @xmath100 , result in the expression @xmath131_{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0}\right ) \cr & & = \int d \hat{{\boldsymbol{q } } } \exp \left ( m ( a(\{q_t , q_t , m_t\ } , \{\hat{q}_t^a,\hat{q}_t^{ab},\hat{m}_t^a\ } ) + b(\{\hat{q}_t^a,\hat{q}_t^{ab},\hat{m}_t^a\ } ) \right ) , \label{volume}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for a fixed set of @xmath132 .
the conjugate variable @xmath133 is introduced for expressing a delta function as @xmath134 , and similarly for @xmath135 and @xmath136 .
notation @xmath137 stands for an integral measure @xmath138 , and the functions on the right hand side are defined as @xmath139 and @xmath140_{x_t^0 } \right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the average for @xmath141 is taken according to ( [ sparse_dist ] ) .
the expression of ( [ volume ] ) indicates that its rescaled logarithm is accurately evaluated using the saddle point method with respect to the conjugate variables in the large system limit @xmath89 .
in addition , the replica symmetry guarantees that the relevant saddle point is of the rs form as @xmath142 , @xmath143 , and @xmath144 . as a consequence ,
the evaluation yields @xmath145_{x_t^0 } \!\right ) \!\right \ } , \label{entropy}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath146 denotes the gaussian measure .
this is also likely to hold for @xmath126 , although ( [ volume ] ) is originally defined for only @xmath88 .
the replica method uses the identity @xmath147_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0\ } , \{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\ } } = -\lim_{n\to 0 } ( \partial /\partial n)(\beta m)^{-1 } \ln \left ( \left [ z^n(\beta;\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0\ } , \{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\}\right .
$ ] @xmath148_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0\ } , \{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\ } } \right ) $ ] for evaluating the typical free energy density .
the above argument indicates that @xmath149_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0\ } , \{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\ } } \right ) $ ] can be computed by extremizing the sum of ( [ energy ] ) and ( [ entropy ] ) with respect to @xmath132 .
furthermore , the obtained expression is likely to hold for @xmath126 , although the calculations are based on ( [ power_partition ] ) that is valid for only @xmath88 .
we , therefore , take the limit of @xmath150 utilizing the expressions of ( [ energy ] ) and ( [ entropy ] ) for @xmath151 $ ] as well .
in particular , in the limit of @xmath55 , which is relevant in the current problem , the expression of the free energy of the vanishing temperature is expressed as @xmath152_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_t^0\ } , \{{\boldsymbol{o}}_t\ } } \cr & & = -\mathop{\rm extr}_{}\left \{\sum_{t=1}^{t}\left ( \frac{\partial f(\{\chi_k\})}{\partial \chi_t } ( q_t-2 m_t+\rho_t ) + \frac{\hat{q}_tq_t}{2}-\frac{\hat{\chi}_t\chi_t}{2}+\hat{m}_tm_t \right . \right .\cr & & \left .
. \hspace*{6 cm } -\int dz \left [ \phi \left ( \sqrt{\hat{\chi}_t } z+ { \hat{m}_t } x^0 ; \hat{q}_t \right ) \right ] _ { x^0 } \right ) \right \ } , \label{free_energy}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath153 and rescaled variables are introduced as @xmath154 , @xmath155 , @xmath156 , and @xmath157 to properly describe the relevant solution in the limit of @xmath55 .
extremization is to be performed with respect to @xmath158 .
similar to earlier studies , at the extremum characterized by a set of the saddle point equations @xmath159 @xmath160_{x_t^0 } , \label{sp1}\\ & & \chi_t=\int dz \left [ \frac{\partial x^2(\sqrt{\hat{\chi}_t}z+\hat{m}_t x_t^0;\hat{q}_t)}{\partial ( \sqrt{\hat{\chi}_t}z ) } \right ] _
{ x_t^0 } , \label{sp2}\\ & & m_t=\int dz \left [ x_t^0x(\sqrt{\hat{\chi}_t}z+\hat{m}_t x_t^0;\hat{q}_t ) \right ] _ { x_t^0 } , \label{sp3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath161 and @xmath162 @xmath31 physically denote the macroscopic averages of the recovered vector @xmath163 as @xmath164_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_k^0\},\{{\boldsymbol{o}}_k\}}$ ] and @xmath165_{\{{\boldsymbol{x}}_k^0\},\{{\boldsymbol{o}}_k\}}$ ] , respectively . here
, @xmath166 is provided by the extremum solution of ( [ formula_concrete ] ) for @xmath167 , and @xmath168 for @xmath169 , a lagrange multiplier should be exceptionally introduced in ( [ sph2 ] ) for enforcing @xmath170 .
the success of the @xmath6-recovery is characterized by the condition in which @xmath171 is satisfied at the extremum for @xmath172 .
therefore , one can evaluate the critical relation between @xmath173 and @xmath174 by examining the thermodynamic stability of the success solution @xmath171 @xmath31 for the saddle point equations ( [ sph1])([sp3 ] ) .
we assume @xmath175 for a while , since an exceptional treatment is required for @xmath169 . for obtaining the success solution , it is necessary that @xmath176 and @xmath177 hold . expanding ( [ sp1])([sp3 ] ) under the assumption of @xmath178 yields @xmath179 where @xmath180 , @xmath181 and we used @xmath182_{x_t^0}=\rho_t$ ] , which is derived from the assumption ( [ sparse_dist ] ) .
these result in the expression @xmath183 in addition , ( [ formula_concrete ] ) indicates that @xmath184 holds , where @xmath185 is the solution of @xmath22 coupled equations @xmath186 differentiating this yields @xmath187 where we denote @xmath188 and @xmath189 this expression makes it possible to evaluate @xmath190 as @xmath191 where @xmath192 , @xmath193 and @xmath194 .
inserting ( [ mse ] ) , ( [ hessian ] ) , and ( [ hessian_inverse ] ) into ( [ sph2 ] ) yields a set of equations to determine @xmath195 for a given set of non - zero densities @xmath196 @xmath197 where we set @xmath198 and used the relation @xmath199 , which is obtained from ( [ sph1 ] ) and ( [ chi_lambda ] ) .
equations ( [ sph2 ] ) and ( [ chiasympt ] ) indicate that the critical condition for making @xmath200 stable is expressed as @xmath201 furthermore , the condition @xmath202 must hold by the definition of @xmath203 . for characterizing the critical condition for the success of the @xmath6-recovery ,
let us suppose that the set of non - zero densities @xmath196 is provided as a function of a single parameter @xmath204 as @xmath205 .
for @xmath206 , the critical situation is specified by an appropriate set of @xmath207 variables of @xmath204 , @xmath195 , and @xmath208 .
these are provided by @xmath207 conditions of ( [ critical1])([critical3 ] ) . on the other hand ,
the critical condition for @xmath169 is provided differently from ( [ critical1])([critical3 ] ) because the constraint of @xmath170 for keeping @xmath209 well defined requires @xmath210 for any pair of @xmath211 and @xmath212 .
explicitly , the condition is provided by the following four coupled equations : @xmath213 where @xmath214 is a lagrange parameter for enforcing @xmath170 . these determine four variables of @xmath215 at the critical condition .
equations ( [ critical1])([critical3 ] ) for @xmath175 and ( [ t2critical1])([t2critical4 ] ) for @xmath169 constitute the main result of this paper . for @xmath169 , an equivalent result
can also be obtained in a slightly different manner @xcite .
the above calculation can be generalized to arbitrary levels of replica symmetry breaking ( rsb ) .
for example , under one - step rsb ( 1rsb ) ansatz , where @xmath86 replicas of each block @xmath45 are classified into @xmath216 groups of an identical size @xmath217 and their overlaps are assumed to be @xmath218 if @xmath123 and @xmath219 belong to the same group and @xmath220 otherwise , ( [ energy ] ) and ( [ entropy ] ) are modified as @xmath221 and @xmath222_{x_t^0 } \!\right \ } , \label{entropy1rsb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where @xmath223 . in the 1rsb framework ,
the rs solution is regarded as a special solution of @xmath224 and @xmath225 ( @xmath95 ) . in the limit of @xmath226 and @xmath55 keeping @xmath227 , the critical condition that a solution of @xmath228 and @xmath229 bifurcates from the rs solution , which corresponds to the de almeida - thouless ( at ) condition @xcite of the current system , is expressed as @xmath230 where @xmath231 and @xmath232_{x_t^0 } ) $ ] . for @xmath206
, @xmath233 holds for the success solution at the critical condition of the @xmath6-recovery .
equation ( [ hhath ] ) yields an eigenvalue of unity whose eigenvector is given as @xmath234 , which makes ( [ at ] ) hold .
similarly , ( [ at ] ) is also satisfied at the critical condition of the @xmath6-recovery of @xmath169 .
these validate our rs evaluation in terms of the local stability analysis , although further justification with other schemes , such as comparison with numerical experiments , is necessary for examining possibilities that the rs solution becomes thermodynamically irrelevant due to discontinuous phase transitions .
let us examine the significance of the developed methodology by applying it to two representative examples .
we consider the uniform density case of @xmath235 ( @xmath95 ) as the first example , where the uniformity allows us to solve ( [ sph1])([sp3 ] ) setting all variables to be independent of @xmath45 as @xmath236 .
in particular , setting @xmath237 simplifies the expressions of ( [ sph1])([sph3 ] ) providing @xmath238 and @xmath239 .
this makes it unnecessary to deal with the saddle point problems of @xmath169 in an exceptional manner . as a consequence
, the critical condition of the @xmath6-recovery is expressed compactly by using a pair of equations as @xmath240 for both @xmath241 and @xmath169 . by setting @xmath242 ,
these provide a critical condition identical to that obtained for the rotationally invariance matrix ensembles in earlier studies @xcite .
this indicates that for vectors of the uniform non - zero density , the @xmath6-recovery performance of the concatenated orthogonal matrices is identical to that of the standard setup provided by the matrix of independent standard gaussian entries .
however , this is not the case when the non - zero density is not uniform . as a distinctive example
, we examined the case of localized density , which is characterized by setting @xmath243 and @xmath244 for @xmath245 .
table [ table ] and figure [ figure1 ] show critical values of the total non - zero density @xmath48 given the compression rate @xmath242 for the uniform and localized density cases .
these show that the concatenated matrices always result in better @xmath6-recovery performance for vectors of the localized densities , and the significance increases as @xmath22 becomes smaller while matrices of rotationally invariant ensembles result in identical performance as long as @xmath51 is unchanged .
this indicates that , in addition to their ease of implementation and theoretical elegance , the concatenated orthogonal matrices are preferred for practical use in terms of their high recovery performance for vectors of non - uniform non - zero densities .
c|cccccccc @xmath22&2&3&4&5&6&7&8 uniform & 0.1928 & 0.1021 & 0.0668 & 0.0487 & 0.0378 & 0.0308 & 0.0257 localized & 0.2267 & 0.1190 & 0.0780 & 0.0566 & 0.0438 & 0.0354 & 0.0294 ( color online ) critical values @xmath246 of total non - zero density versus compression rate @xmath50 .
circles and crosses correspond to the localized and uniform densities , respectively , for @xmath247 .
the curve represents the relation between @xmath246 and @xmath50 for the rotationally invariance matrix ensembles .
crosses coincide with values of the curve for @xmath242 ( @xmath248 ) . ] to justify our theoretical results , we conducted extensive numerical experiments of the @xmath6-reconstruction .
figures [ figure2 ] ( a ) and ( b ) depict the experimental assessment of the critical threshold for @xmath169 and @xmath249 , respectively . the case of an i.i.d .
standard gaussian dictionary is also plotted for comparison . given fixed values of @xmath22 and @xmath0 ,
a trial was started with an empty vector @xmath27 and a concatenated orthogonal dictionary generated from a set of @xmath22 standard i.i.d .
@xmath10 gaussian matrices using qr - decomposition . based on the relative densities @xmath250 , one sub - vector @xmath41
was then randomly chosen and assigned a non - zero component drawn from the standard gaussian ensemble .
matlab algorithm `` linprog '' from optimization toolbox was used to solve the @xmath6-minimization problem and obtain the reconstruction @xmath40 .
the reconstruction was deemed to be a success if @xmath251 and a failure otherwise . given a successful reconstruction , we again randomly chose one sub - vector @xmath41 based on the densities @xmath250 and inserted a non - zero component drawn independently from the standard gaussian ensemble into it .
the process was continued until the original vectors @xmath252 had @xmath253 non - zero components and the reconstruction was deemed a failure , that is , @xmath254 . the critical value @xmath255 was recorded and the experiment was started again using a new independent dictionary and an empty vector @xmath27 . for each value of @xmath22 and @xmath0 , we carried out @xmath256 independent trials .
the experimental critical density was defined as @xmath257 , where @xmath258 denotes the arithmetic average over the trials . for all system sizes
, we also computed the experimental per - block densities @xmath259 and checked that they were close to the desired densities @xmath250 after the @xmath256 trials . for fixed @xmath22 ,
the experimental data points @xmath260 were fitted with a quadratic function of @xmath261 .
extrapolation for @xmath262 provided the experimental estimates of the critical densities , as listed in table [ table2 ] in which the theoretical estimates in table [ table ] are also listed for comparison .
( color online ) experimental assessment of critical densities for @xmath6-reconstruction . experimental data ( see the main text ) were fitted with a quadratic function of @xmath261 and plotted with solid lines .
concatenated orthogonal `` o '' and i.i.d .
standard gaussian `` g '' basis under uniform and localized densities .
filled markers represent the predictions obtained through the replica analysis .
extrapolation for @xmath263 provides the estimates for the critical values @xmath246 .
( a ) @xmath264 , where the markers correspond to simulated values @xmath265 , and ( b ) @xmath266 , where the markers correspond to simulated values @xmath267 . , title="fig : " ] ( color online ) experimental assessment of critical densities for @xmath6-reconstruction . experimental data ( see the main text ) were fitted with a quadratic function of @xmath261 and plotted with solid lines . concatenated orthogonal `` o '' and i.i.d .
standard gaussian `` g '' basis under uniform and localized densities .
filled markers represent the predictions obtained through the replica analysis .
extrapolation for @xmath263 provides the estimates for the critical values @xmath246 .
( a ) @xmath264 , where the markers correspond to simulated values @xmath265 , and ( b ) @xmath266 , where the markers correspond to simulated values @xmath267 . , title="fig : " ] c|ccccc @xmath22&2&3&4&5 uniform ( experiment ) & 0.1927 & 0.1019 & 0.0670 & 0.0487 uniform ( theory ) & 0.1928 & 0.1021 & 0.0668 & 0.0487
localized ( experiment ) & 0.2264 & 0.1196 & 0.0779 & 0.0567 localized ( theory ) & 0.2267 & 0.1190 & 0.0780 & 0.0566 comparing the theoretical and experimental results confirms the accuracy of the replica analysis . from figure [ figure2 ]
, we observe that for the finite - sized systems , the @xmath22 orthogonal dictionaries seem to always provide higher thresholds @xmath268 than the gaussian one , even for uniform densities .
in summary , we investigated the performance of recovering a sparse vector @xmath269 from a linear underdetermined equation @xmath270 when @xmath7 is provided as a concatenation of @xmath271 independent samples of @xmath10 random orthogonal matrices and the @xmath6-recovery scheme is used .
performance was measured using a threshold value of the density @xmath51 of non - zero entries in the original vector @xmath27 , below which the @xmath6-recovery is typically successful for given compression rate @xmath272 .
for evaluating this , we used the replica method in conjunction with the development of an integral formula for handling the random orthogonal matrices .
our analysis indicated that the threshold is identical to that of the standard setup for which matrix entries are sampled independently from identical gaussian distribution when the non - zero entries in @xmath27 are distributed uniformly among @xmath22 blocks of the concatenation .
however , it was also shown that the concatenated orthogonal matrices generally provide higher threshold values than the standard setup when the non - zero entries are localized in a certain block . results of extensive numerical experiments exhibited excellent agreement with the theoretical predictions .
these mean that , in addition to their ease of implementation and theoretical elegance , the concatenated orthogonal matrices are preferred for practical use in terms of their high recovery performance for vectors of non - uniform non - zero densities .
promising future studies include performance evaluation in the case of noisy situations and development of approximate recovery algorithms suitable for the concatenated orthogonal matrices the authors would like to thank erik aurell , mikael skoglund , and lars rasmussen for their useful comments .
we also thank csc it center for science ltd . for the allocation of computational resources .
this work was partially supported by grants from the japan society for the promotion of science ( kakenhi nos .
22300003 and 22300098 ) ( yk ) and swedish research council under vr grant 621 - 2011 - 1024 ( mv ) .
when @xmath30 are sampled independently and uniformly from the haar measure of the @xmath273 orthogonal matrices , @xmath274 @xmath275 are distributed independently and uniformly on the surfaces of the @xmath19-dimensional hyperspheres of radius @xmath73 for a fixed set of @xmath19-dimensional vectors @xmath71 satisfying @xmath276 .
this means that the integral of ( [ formula_def ] ) can be expressed as @xmath277 we insert the fourier expressions of @xmath278-function @xmath279 and @xmath280 into the numerator of ( [ spherical_integration ] ) , and carry out the integration with respect to @xmath281 , where @xmath282 .
this yields the expression @xmath283 evaluating this by means of the saddle point method with respect to @xmath284 @xmath285 results in @xmath286 similarly , the denominator of ( [ spherical_integration ] ) is evaluated as @xmath287 substituting ( [ spherical_integration ] ) , ( [ numer ] ) , and ( [ denomi ] ) into ( [ formula_def ] ) leads to the expression of ( [ formula_concrete ] ) .
10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 miller a 2002 _ subset selection in regression ( second edition ) _ ( chapman and hall / crc ) | we consider the problem of recovering an @xmath0-dimensional sparse vector @xmath1 from its linear transformation @xmath2 of @xmath3 dimension . minimizing
the @xmath4-norm of @xmath1 under the constraint @xmath5 is a standard approach for the recovery problem , and earlier studies report that the critical condition for typically successful @xmath6-recovery is universal over a variety of randomly constructed matrices @xmath7 . for examining the extent of the universality
, we focus on the case in which @xmath7 is provided by concatenating @xmath8 matrices @xmath9 drawn uniformly according to the haar measure on the @xmath10 orthogonal matrices . by using the replica method in conjunction with the development of an integral formula for handling the random orthogonal matrices ,
we show that the concatenated matrices can result in better recovery performance than what the universality predicts when the density of non - zero signals is not uniform among the @xmath11 matrix modules .
the universal condition is reproduced for the special case of uniform non - zero signal densities .
extensive numerical experiments support the theoretical predictions . |
the top quark is the heaviest available fundamental particle in the standard model ( sm ) . because of the large mass of the top quark , it s interactions are an excellent probe of the electroweak symmetry - breaking mechanism , and they should therefore play an important role in the search of physics beyond the sm . for this purpose ,
particularly , the anomalous interactions of the top quark can be examined by flavor changing neutral currents ( fcnc ) . in the sm
, fcnc decays @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) can not be observed at tree level , but these decays can only make loop contributions . as a result , such processes are anticipated to be enormously rare within the sm with branching ratios of an order of @xmath9 @xcite . however , various models beyond the sm such as the minimal supersymmetric model @xcite , two - higgs doublet model @xcite , the quark - singlet model @xcite , extra dimension models @xcite , the littlest higgs model @xcite , the topcolor - assisted technicolor model @xcite or supersymmetry @xcite could lead to a very large increase of fcnc processes involving the top quark .
present experimental constraints at @xmath5 confidence level ( c. l. ) on the anomalous @xmath0 couplings are obtained from two limits : @xmath10 supplied by zeus collaboration @xcite and @xmath11 presented by cdf collaboration @xcite .
the fcnc anomalous interactions among the top quark , two quarks @xmath12 , @xmath13 and the photon can be written in a model independent way with dimension five effective lagrangian as follows @xcite @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the electromagnetic coupling constant , @xmath16 is the top quark electric charge , @xmath6 denotes the strength of the anomalous couplings of top quark with photon , @xmath17 is an effective cut - off scale which is conventionally set to the mass of the top quark @xcite , @xmath18 with @xmath19 which stands for the dirac matrix , and @xmath20 is the momentum of photon . also , using the interaction lagrangian in eq.(@xmath21 ) , the anomalous decay width of the top quark can be easily obtained as follows @xmath22 where the masses of @xmath12 and @xmath13 quarks are omitted in the above equation . since the dominant decay mode of the top quark is @xmath23 , the branching ratio of anomalous @xmath7 decay generally is given by the following formula : @xmath24 therefore , using the equations ( @xmath25 ) and ( @xmath26 ) , we can obtain the magnitude of the upper limits of anomalous coupling provided by cdf collaboration as follows @xmath27 in the literature , the interactions of the top quark via fcnc have been experimentally and theoretically examined @xcite .
the lhc might allow us to observe the top quark s fcnc couplings with its high center - of - mass energy and high luminosity .
however , the signal which may occur from the new physics beyond the sm is difficult to determine due to jets coming from proton remnants at the lhc . on the other hand , a linear lepton collider , which has extremely high luminosity and a clean experimental environment , can provide complementary information for these properties while carrying out high precision measurements that would complete the lhc results .
one of the proposed high luminosity and high energy lepton colliders is the compact linear collider ( clic ) @xcite , which is designed to be constructed in three main stages as given in table i @xcite .
the clic provides a suitable platform to examine the @xmath28 and @xmath29 processes by converting the incoming leptons into an intense beam of high - energy photons . on the other hand ,
@xmath30 and @xmath4 processes at the clic occur instinctively by the virtual photon emitted from the original @xmath31 or @xmath32 beam
. therefore , @xmath30 and @xmath33 processes are more realistic than @xmath28 and @xmath29 processes occurring through the compton backscattering mechanism .
@xmath4 processes have been described by the weizsacker - williams approximation @xcite . in this approximation , the emitted photons are scattered at very small angles from the beam pipe . since the emitted photons have a low virtuality , they are almost real .
@xmath34 processes can isolate the @xmath0 couplings from @xmath35 couplings .
jets which originate from light quarks ( @xmath12 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 quarks ) differ from heavy quarks ( @xmath13 and @xmath38 quarks ) in the final state @xcite .
therefore , the anomalous @xmath39 coupling could be distinguished from @xmath40 coupling via the process @xmath1 , if the anomalous coupling @xmath39 is not equal to @xmath40 . so far
, new physics research through @xmath41 processes at the lep @xcite , tevatron @xcite and lhc @xcite have been experimentally studied in the literature . as a result , the clic as a @xmath4 collider provides us with an important opportunity to investigate the anomalous couplings of the top quark . a schematic diagram describing this process
is represented in fig.@xmath25 .
in the case of the effective lagrangian in eq.@xmath42 , the subprocess @xmath43 is described by four tree - level diagrams ( fig.@xmath21 ) . in our calculations , we perform the simulation program comphep-4.5.1 by including the new interaction vertices @xcite . in addition , the acceptance cuts were used as the following @xmath44 @xmath45 where @xmath46 are the transverse momentum cuts of the @xmath38 and @xmath47 quarks , @xmath48 denotes pseudorapidity , and @xmath49 is the separation of the @xmath38 and @xmath47 quarks .
the integrated total cross - sections of the process @xmath50 as a function of the anomalous couplings @xmath51 for @xmath52 and @xmath53 tev are plotted in fig.@xmath53 for @xmath54 gev@xmath55 .
anomalous @xmath56 couplings are defined by effective lagrangian in eq.@xmath42 , and it has an energy dimension of @xmath57 . however , the total cross section including the sm and new physics has a higher energy dependence than the sm cross section .
therefore , we can see from this figure that the total cross section increases with increasing the center - of - mass energy .
on the other hand , there may occur an uncertainty arising from the virtuality of @xmath2 used in the weizsacker - williams approximation .
we have obtained sm cross sections for various photon virtualities as follows : @xmath58 pb at @xmath59 tev and @xmath54 gev@xmath60 , @xmath61 pb at @xmath59 tev and @xmath62 gev@xmath60 , @xmath63 pb at @xmath64 tev and @xmath54 gev@xmath60 , @xmath65 pb at @xmath64 tev and @xmath62 gev@xmath60 , @xmath66 pb at @xmath67 tev and @xmath54 gev@xmath60 , @xmath68 pb at @xmath67 tev and @xmath62 gev@xmath60 for the process @xmath50 . in fig .
@xmath26 , in detail , the integrated cross sections are given for different @xmath69 values as a function of @xmath70 .
we can see from these figures the total cross section changes slightly with the variation of the @xmath69 value . as shown in fig .
@xmath57 , we plot the invariant mass distributions for the @xmath71 system in the final state , the signal has a peak over the sm background . in the sm
, there is no single top quark production at tree level via the subprocess @xmath72 .
hence , the differential cross section depending on the invariant mass distribution of the @xmath71 system is a good observable for the top quark s fcnc couplings . in fig.@xmath73 ,
the rapidity distributions of the final state @xmath38 quark at the @xmath52 and @xmath53 tev .
it can be understood that the rapidity distributions of the final state @xmath38 quark from the new physics signal and sm background are located generally in the range of @xmath74 . in fig.@xmath75 , the transverse momentum distributions of the final state @xmath38 quark at the @xmath52 and @xmath53 tev .
we can see from fig.@xmath76 that the transverse momentum of the final state @xmath38 quark from the new physics signal and sm background can be discerned at especially large transverse momentum values .
a comprehensive examination of the anomalous coupling @xmath6 requires a statistical analysis . in this work , we calculate sensitivity of the @xmath50 process to anomalous coupling @xmath6 using two different statistical analysis methods . first , we employ a one - parameter @xmath77 test when the number of sm events is greater than @xmath78 .
the @xmath77 test without a systematic error is given by @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the total cross section including sm and new physics , @xmath81 : @xmath82 is the number of sm events calculated as @xmath83 . here
@xmath84 is the integrated luminosity , @xmath85 is the efficiency for @xmath38-tagging .
we take into account the leptonic decay of the @xmath86 boson with the branching through @xmath87 , where @xmath88 . in the second analysis , we use a poisson distribution , which is the appropriate sensitivity analysis for the number of sm events smaller than or equal to @xmath78 . in poisson analysis , the sensitivity limits are obtained assuming the number of observed events are equal to the sm prediction , i.e. , @xmath89 upper limits of the number of events @xmath90 at @xmath5 c.l .
can be obtained as follows @xcite @xmath91 the sensitivity limits on the anomalous coupling @xmath70 for different values of photon virtuality , center - of - mass energy and luminosity have been given in tables ii - iv .
it has shown that the bounds on the anomalous coupling are slightly improved when @xmath69 increases .
we can also understand that the large values of @xmath69 do not bring an important contribution to obtain sensitivity limits on the anomalous coupling at large energy and luminosity values . as shown in the tables
, this process can develop the sensitivity limits of the anomalous coupling @xmath70 with respect to the current experimental limits .
even though the lhc has high luminosity and high energy , it does not have clean environment due to the strong interactions
. therefore linear colliders , which have less background than the lhc , provide an opportunity for precise measurements of the top quark anomalous couplings .
photon - photon collisions at the linear colliders enable us to investigate fcnc top quark interactions without a contribution coming from the anomalous @xmath35 coupling .
these processes may also be more efficient to distinguish @xmath39 and @xmath40 in comparison to hadron colliders due to the @xmath12 and @xmath13 quarks appearing in the final state . in this paper
we have analyzed the @xmath50 process with the anomalous @xmath56 couplings in a model independent effective lagrangian approach at the clic .
so far , zeus and cdf collaborations have the most stringent limits on anomalous fcnc couplings of the photon with top quark . in our study
, we present more restrictive limits with respect to the obtained anomalous couplings @xmath6 than the current experimental limits and these anomalous couplings depend strictly on the center - of - mass energy and integrated luminosity . consequently , the clic make an important contribution to the search for the anomalous @xmath56 couplings through the @xmath50 process .
.parameters of the clic in three different stages . here
@xmath94 is the center - of - mass energy , @xmath95 is the total luminosity , @xmath96 is the number of particles in bunch , @xmath97 and @xmath98 are the beam sizes and @xmath99 is the bunch length @xcite .
[ tab1 ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] | photon - photon reactions provide an excellent opportunity to isolate the @xmath0 vertex . for this purpose ,
we have examined the potential of the @xmath1 ( @xmath2 is the weizsacker - williams photon and @xmath3 ) process to investigate the anomalous @xmath0 couplings in @xmath4 collisions at the clic .
we have obtained @xmath5 confidence level limits on the anomalous couplings for various values of the center - of - mass energy and integrated luminosity .
we have shown that the limit on anomalous @xmath6 coupling is more restricted with respect to current experimental limits . |
compressive sensing , or compressive sampling ( cs ) @xcite , is a novel signal processing technique proposed to effectively sample and compress sparse signals , i.e. , signals that can be represented by few significant coefficients in some basis .
assume that the signal of interest @xmath0 can be represented by @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the basis matrix and @xmath3 is @xmath4-sparse , which means only @xmath4 out of its @xmath5 entries are nonzero .
one of the essential issues of cs theory lies in recovering @xmath6 ( or equivalently , @xmath7 ) from its linear observations , @xmath8 where @xmath9 is a sensing matrix with more columns than rows and @xmath10 is the measurement vector .
unfortunately , directly finding the sparsest solution to ( [ y = ax ] ) is np - hard , which is not practical for sparse recovery .
this leads to one of the major aspects of cs theory designing effective recovery algorithms with low computational complexity and fine recovery performance .
a family of convex relaxation algorithms for sparse recovery @xcite had been introduced before the theory of cs was established .
based on linear programming ( lp ) techniques , it is shown that @xmath11 norm optimization , also known as basis pursuit ( bp ) , @xmath12 yields the sparse solution as long as @xmath13 satisfies the restricted isometry property ( rip ) with a constant parameter @xcite .
recovery algorithms based on convex optimization include interior - point methods @xcite and homotopy methods @xcite .
in contrast with convex relaxation algorithms , non - convex optimization algorithms solve ( [ y = ax ] ) by minimizing @xmath14 norm with respect to @xmath15 , which is not convex .
typical algorithms include focal underdetermined system solver ( focuss ) @xcite , iteratively reweighted least squares ( irls ) @xcite , smoothed @xmath16 ( sl0 ) @xcite , and zero - point attracting projection ( zap ) @xcite . compared with convex relaxation algorithms , theoretical analysis based on rip shows that fewer measurements are required for exact recovery by non - convex optimization methods @xcite .
a family of iterative greedy algorithms has received much attention due to their simple implementation and low computational complexity .
the basic idea underlying these algorithms is to iteratively estimate the support set of the unknown sparse signal , i.e. , the set of locations of its nonzero entries . in each iteration
, one or more indices are added to the support estimation by correlating the columns of @xmath17 with the regularized measurement vector .
typical examples include orthogonal matching pursuit ( omp ) @xcite , regularized omp ( romp ) @xcite , and stage - wise omp ( stomp ) @xcite .
compared with convex relaxation algorithms , greedy pursuits need more measurements , but they tend to be more computationally efficient . recently , several greedy algorithms including compressive sampling matching pursuit ( cosamp ) @xcite and subspace pursuit ( sp ) @xcite have been proposed by incorporating the idea of backtracking . in each iteration
, sp algorithm refines the @xmath4 columns of matrix @xmath17 that span the subspace where the measurement vector @xmath18 lies .
specifically , sp adds @xmath4 more indices to the @xmath4 candidates of support estimate , and discards the most unreliable @xmath4 ones .
similarly , cosamp adds @xmath19 more indices in each iteration , while computes the regularized measurement vector in a different way . by evaluating the reliability of all candidates in each iteration
, these algorithms can provide comparable performance to convex relaxation algorithms , and exhibit low computational complexity as matching pursuit algorithms .
another kind of greedy pursuits , including iterative hard thresholding ( iht ) @xcite and its normalized variation @xcite , is proposed with the advantages of low computational complexity and theoretical performance guarantee . in each iteration ,
the entries of the iterative solution except for the most @xmath4 reliable ones are set to zero .
together with cosamp and sp , these algorithms can be considered as greedy pursuits with replacement involved in each iteration .
to apply the theory of cs in practice , the effect of noise and perturbation must be taken into consideration .
the common analysis is the additive noise to the measurements , i.e. , @xmath20 where @xmath21 is termed measurement noise .
most existing algorithms have been proved to be stable in this scenario , including theoretical analysis of bp @xcite , romp @xcite , cosamp @xcite , sp @xcite , and iht @xcite .
it is shown that the error bounds of the recovered solutions are proportional to the @xmath22 norm of @xmath21 .
a certain distribution of the measurement noise can be introduced to achieve better results , such as gaussian @xcite or others @xcite .
until recently , only a few researches involve the perturbation to the sensing matrix @xmath23 , which is also termed system perturbation .
existing works include analysis of bp @xcite , cosamp @xcite , sp @xcite , @xmath14 norm minimization with @xmath24 $ ] @xcite , and omp @xcite . in these works , ( [ meapur ] )
is extended by introducing a perturbed sensing matrix , i.e. , @xmath25 .
it is of great significance to analyze the stability of recovery algorithms against both perturbations when the theory of cs is applied in practice .
other related works include mismatch of sparsity basis @xcite and sparsity - cognizant total least - squares @xcite .
two practical scenarios are usually considered in cs applications .
first , when @xmath23 represents a system model , @xmath26 denotes the precision error when the system is physically implemented .
thus the whole sensing process is @xmath27 and only the nominal sensing matrix and contaminated measurement vector are available for recovery , i.e. , @xmath28 where @xmath29 denotes a certain recovery algorithm . in countless other problems ,
@xmath26 is involved due to mis - modeling of the actual system @xmath23 .
thus @xmath25 and the sensing process is @xmath30 both the sensing matrix and measurement vector are contaminated , and the recovered solution is @xmath31 .
existing works @xcite are all based on the latter scenario , thus it is well considered and fully analyzed in this paper . the first scenario ( [ sysper1 ] ) is briefly discussed after that as a remark .
this paper mainly considers the recovery performance of greedy pursuits with replacement against general perturbations .
specifically , when both measurement noise and system perturbation exist , the error bounds of the solutions of cosamp , sp , and iht are derived and discussed in detail for not strictly sparse signals , i.e. , compressible signals .
it is shown that these relative error bounds are linear in the relative perturbations of the measurement vector and the sensing matrix , which indicates that the recovery performance is stable against general perturbations .
these error bounds are also compared with that of oracle recovery , and it reveals that the results in this paper are optimal up to the coefficients .
numerical simulations are performed to verify the conclusions in this paper .
previous related works including @xcite are compared with this work in section vi .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows .
section ii gives a brief review of rip and three greedy pursuits with replacement .
section iii presents the main theorems about the recovery performance of greedy pursuits with replacement against general perturbations , and the results are shown to be of the same order as oracle recovery by comparing them in section iv .
numerical simulations are performed in section v. several related works are discussed in section vi , and the paper is concluded in section vii . some detailed descriptions and discussions of greedy pursuits with replacement and proofs are postponed to appendix .
in this section , the definition of rip and descriptions of several greedy pursuits , including cosamp , sp , and iht , as well as their recovery performance against measurement noise , are introduced .
the restricted isometry property ( rip ) for any matrix @xmath17 describes the degree of orthogonality among its different columns .
@xcite for positive integer @xmath4 , define the restricted isometry constant ( ric ) @xmath32 of a matrix @xmath17 as the smallest non - negative number such that @xmath33 holds for any @xmath4-sparse vector @xmath7 .
according to definition 1 , @xmath34 implies that every @xmath4 columns of @xmath17 are linearly independent , and @xmath35 implies that @xmath17 almost maintains the @xmath22 distance between any pair of @xmath4-sparse signals .
it is also easy to check that if @xmath17 satisfies the rip with @xmath36 and @xmath37 , and @xmath38 , then @xmath39 .
calculating the exact value of ric is intractable because it involves all submatrices comprised of @xmath4 columns of @xmath17 .
fortunately , random matrices possess small rics for overwhelming probability .
for example , if the entries of @xmath40 are independently and identically distributed gaussian random variables with zero mean and variance @xmath41 , and @xmath42 satisfies @xmath43 then @xmath44 with at least probability @xmath45 , where @xmath46 and @xmath47 are two constants @xcite .
recent theoretical results about the bounds of ric can be found in @xcite . though rip
is usually used to show the impact of matrix on sparse signals , the following lemma permits us to generalize the result from sparse signals to general signals .
[ ripgeneral ] ( proposition 3.5 in @xcite ) suppose that the matrix @xmath17 satisfies rip of level @xmath4 with @xmath48 , then for any signal @xmath49 , it holds that @xmath50 lemma [ ripgeneral ] is used in the theoretical analysis of this paper for compressible signals .
greedy pursuits with replacement include cosamp , sp , and iht algorithms , and they are briefly introduced as follows .
the pseudo codes for these algorithms and some discussions are postponed to appendix a. the cosamp algorithm iteratively refines the support of @xmath4-sparse vector @xmath7 . in each iteration , @xmath19 more indices are selected by correlating @xmath17 with the residue vector @xmath51 , then the best @xmath4 candidates out of at most @xmath52 ones are kept and the residue vector is updated .
the details of cosamp can be found in @xcite . the sp algorithm is firstly proposed in @xcite and further developed in @xcite . unlike cosamp , sp adds @xmath4 more indices in each iteration , and keeps the best @xmath4 candidates .
in addition , the residue vector of sp is orthogonal to the subspace spanned by the columns of @xmath17 indexed by the @xmath4 candidates , making the new @xmath4 indices added in each iteration totally different from the previously identified @xmath4 ones
. please refer to @xcite for more details .
the iht algorithm is firstly proposed in @xcite , and later developed and analyzed in @xcite . to improve the convergence performance of the method , a normalized variation niht is proposed in @xcite which retains theoretical performance guarantee similar to iht . without loss of generality ,
only iht algorithm is discussed in the following analysis .
the following theorem [ gpra ] reveals the error bounds of the solutions of greedy pursuits with replacement when only measurement noise exists . for two sets @xmath53 and @xmath54
, @xmath55 denotes the set comprised of all elements @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
@xmath58 denotes the subvector composed of entries of @xmath7 indexed by set @xmath59 .
[ gpra ] given a noisy measurement vector @xmath60 where @xmath3 is @xmath4-sparse , the estimated solution @xmath61}$ ] in the @xmath62-th iteration of cosamp and iht algorithms satisfies @xmath63}\big\|_2\leq c\big\|{\bf s}-{\bf s}^{[l-1]}\big\|_2 + c_1\left\|{\bf e}\right\|_2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the estimated support set @xmath64 in the @xmath62-th iteration of sp algorithm satisfies @xmath65 where @xmath66 denotes the support of @xmath7 . furthermore , if the matrix @xmath17 satisfies @xmath67 , then @xmath68 , and it can be derived that @xmath69}\big\|_2\le ac^l\left\|{\bf s}\right\|_2 + d\left\|{\bf e}\right\|_2\end{aligned}\ ] ] holds for greedy pursuits with replacement .
the specific values of the constants @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath47 , @xmath46 , @xmath72 , and @xmath73 are illustrated in table [ tableconstant1 ] .
[ tableconstant1 ] .the specification of the constants [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] based on theorem [ gpra ] , two remarks are derived as follows .
* remark 4 * in the noiseless scenario , after finite iterations , the recovered solutions of cosamp and sp are guaranteed to be identical to the sparse signal @xmath3 .
the result can be verified through the following statement .
suppose @xmath74 is the smallest magnitude of the nonzero entries of @xmath3
. then after @xmath75 iterations , the recovered solution @xmath61}$ ] obeys @xmath76}\big\|_2 < s_{\min}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the support of @xmath7 is perfectly recovered , then for cosamp and sp , the solution is already identical to @xmath7 .
otherwise , at least one nonzero entry is not detected , thus the recovery error is no less than @xmath74 , which contradicts ( [ remarkequ1 ] ) .
notice that the solution of iht does not possess the above property , since exact support recovery for iht does not imply exact signal recovery .
* remark 5 * according to ( [ gprerror2 ] ) , after @xmath77 iterations , the error bound of the recovered solution satisfies @xmath78}\big\|_2\le ( d+1)\left\|{\bf e}\right\|_2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which means that the error bound is proportional to the @xmath22 norm of the noise , and the recovery performance of greedy pursuits with replacement is stable in this scenario .
for cosamp algorithm , the inequality ( [ gprerror1 ] ) can be obtained by following the steps of the proof of theorem 4.1 in @xcite , while preserving rics during the derivation . as for the second part of the theorem , it is easy to derive that if @xmath79 , then @xmath68 . by recursion
, it can be proved from ( [ gprerror1 ] ) that @xmath78}\big\|_2\le c^l\big\|{\bf s}-{\bf s}^{[0]}\big\|_2 + \frac{c_1}{1-c}\left\|{\bf e}\right\|_2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which arrives ( [ gprerror2 ] ) . [ splemma1 ] ( lemma 3 in @xcite ) let @xmath49 be a @xmath4-sparse vector , and @xmath80 is a noisy measurement vector where @xmath81 satisfies the rip with parameter @xmath82 . for an arbitrary set @xmath83 such that @xmath84 , define @xmath85 as @xmath86 then @xmath87 lemma [ splemma2 ] directly implies inequality ( [ sperror1 ] ) .
it s easy to check that if @xmath90 , then @xmath68 , and @xmath91 applying lemma [ splemma1 ] to ( [ spapp1 ] ) and with the fact that @xmath90 , inequality ( [ gprerror2 ] ) can be derived .
e. cands , j. romberg , and t. tao , `` robust uncertainty principles : exact signal reconstruction from highly incomplete frequency information , '' _ ieee trans .
information theory _ ,
52 , no . 2 , pp . 489 - 509 , feb .
2006 .
s. kim , k. koh , m. lusig , s. boyd , and d. gorinevsky , `` an interior - point method for large - scale @xmath11-regularized least squares , '' _ ieee journal of selected topics in signal process .
_ , vol . 1 , no . 4 , pp . 606 - 617 , dec . 2007 .
h. mohimani , m. babaie - zadeh , and c. jutten , `` a fast approach for overcomplete sparse decomposition based on smoothed @xmath16 norm , '' _ ieee trans .
signal process .
_ , vol .
57 , no . 1 ,
pp . 289 - 301 , jan .
j. jin , y. gu , and s. mei , `` a stochastic gradient approach on compressive sensing signal reconstruction based on adaptive filtering framework , '' _ ieee journal of selected topics in signal process .
_ , vol . 4 , no . 2 , pp .
409 - 420 , apr . 2010 .
x. wang , y. gu , and l. chen , `` proof of convergence and performance analysis for sparse recovery via zero - point attracting projection , '' _ ieee trans .
signal processing _ , vol .
60 , no . 8 ,
4081 - 4093 , aug .
2012 .
d. needell and r. vershynin , `` uniform uncertainty principle and signal recovery via regularized orthogonal matching pursuit , '' _ foundations of computational mathematics _ , vol . 9 , no . 3 , pp .
317 - 334 , june 2009 .
d. donoho , y. tsaig , i. drori , and j. starck , `` sparse solution of underdetermined systems of linear equations by stagewise orthogonal matching pursuit , '' _ ieee trans .
information theory _ ,
58 , no . 2 , pp .
1094 - 1121 , feb .
2012 .
t. blumensath and m. davies , `` normalized iterative hard thresholding : guaranteed stability and performance , '' _ ieee journal of selected topics in signal process . _ , vol . 4 , no . 2 , pp . 298 - 309 , apr .
d. needell and r. vershynin , `` signal recovery from incomplete and inaccurate measurements via regularized orthogonal matching pursuit , '' _ ieee journal of selected topics in signal process .
_ , vol . 4 , no . 2 , pp .
310 - 316 , apr . 2010 .
z. ben - haim , y. eldar , and m. elad , `` coherence - based performance guarantees for estimating a sparse vector under random noise , '' _ ieee trans .
signal process .
_ , vol . 58 , no . 10 , pp . 5030 - 5043 , oct
. 2010 .
w. dai and o. milenkovic , `` subspace pursuit for compressive sensing : closing the gap between performance and complexity , '' available online : http://citeseer.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.154.8384 . | applying the theory of compressive sensing in practice always takes different kinds of perturbations into consideration . in this paper ,
the recovery performance of greedy pursuits with replacement for sparse recovery is analyzed when both the measurement vector and the sensing matrix are contaminated with additive perturbations .
specifically , greedy pursuits with replacement include three algorithms , compressive sampling matching pursuit ( cosamp ) , subspace pursuit ( sp ) , and iterative hard thresholding ( iht ) , where the support estimation is evaluated and updated in each iteration .
based on restricted isometry property , a unified form of the error bounds of these recovery algorithms is derived under general perturbations for compressible signals .
the results reveal that the recovery performance is stable against both perturbations .
in addition , these bounds are compared with that of oracle recovery least squares solution with the locations of some largest entries in magnitude known a priori .
the comparison shows that the error bounds of these algorithms only differ in coefficients from the lower bound of oracle recovery for some certain signal and perturbations , as reveals that oracle - order recovery performance of greedy pursuits with replacement is guaranteed .
numerical simulations are performed to verify the conclusions .
* keywords : * compressive sensing , sparse recovery , general perturbations , performance analysis , restricted isometry property , greedy pursuits , compressive sampling matching pursuit , subspace pursuit , iterative hard thresholding , oracle recovery . |
galaxies and clusters of galaxies are believed to form within the potential wells of virialized dark matter ( dm ) halos .
understanding the clustering of dm halos can provide important clues to understanding the large scale structures in the universe .
a number of studies have therefore been carried out to obtain the two - point correlation function @xmath8 of dm halos .
two distinctive approaches are widely adopted .
one is analytical and is based on the press - schechter ( ps ) theories ( e.g. kashlinsky @xcite , @xcite ; cole & kaiser @xcite ; mann , heavens , & peacock @xcite ; mo & white @xcite , hereafter mw96 ; catelan et al .
@xcite ; porciani et al .
the other is numerical and is based on n - body simulations ( e.g. white et al .
@xcite ; bahcall & cen @xcite ; jing et al .
@xcite ; watanabe , matsubara , & suto @xcite ; gelb & bertschinger @xcite ; jing , brner , & valdarnini @xcite ; mw96 ; mo , jing , & white @xcite ; jing @xcite ; ma @xcite ) . the up to date version of the analytical studies is given by mw96 , which states that @xmath9 of halos with a mass @xmath10 is proportional to the dm correlation function @xmath11 on the linear clustering scale ( @xmath12 ) , i.e. @xmath13 , with the bias factor [ mw96b ] b_mw(m ) = 1+^2 - 1_c , where @xmath14 , @xmath15 , and @xmath16 is the linearly evolved rms density fluctuation of top - hat spheres containing on average a mass @xmath10 ( see mw96 and references therein for more details about these quantities ) . the subscript @xmath17 for @xmath18 in eq.([mw96b ] ) denotes the result
is analytically derived by mw96 . on the other hand ,
the most accurate simulation result was recently presented by our recent work ( jing @xcite ) , where we studied @xmath8 for halos in four scale - free models and three cdm models with the help of a large set of high - resolution n - body simulations of @xmath0 particles .
our result unambiguously showed that while the bias is linear on the linear clustering scale , the bias factor given by mw96 significantly underestimates the clustering for small halos with @xmath19 .
our simulation results both for the cdm models and the scale - free models can be accurately fitted by [ fitting ] b_fit(m)=(0.5 ^ 4 + 1)^(0.06 - 0.02n ) ( 1+^2 - 1 _ c ) , where @xmath20 is the index of the linear power spectrum @xmath21 at the halo mass @xmath10 [ neff ] n = d p_m(k ) d k|_k=2r ; 1.5 cm r=(3m4|)^1/3 . in the above equation @xmath22 is the mean density of the universe .
mw96 derived their formula in two steps .
first they obtained the bias factor @xmath23 in the lagrangian space using the ps theories .
the lagrangian bias reads , [ mw96bl ] b^l_mw(m ) = ^2 - 1_c .
but the bias that is observable is in the eulerian space .
mw96 obtained the eulerian bias ( eq.[mw96b ] ) with a _ linear mapping _ from the lagrangian clustering pattern , @xmath24 ( cf .
catelan et al .
@xcite ) . from their derivation , we conjectured in jing ( @xcite ) that two possibilities could have failed the mw96 formula for small halos .
the first possibility is that the ps theories are not adequate for describing the formation of small halos .
the halo formation in the ps theories is uniquely determined by the local peak height through the spherical collapse model , while in reality , especially the formation of small halos , can be significantly influenced by the non - local tidal force ( e.g. katz , quinn , & gelb @xcite ; katz et al .
a recent analysis by sheth & lemson ( @xcite ) for simulations of @xmath25 particles also gave some evidence that the lagrangian bias of small halos has already deviated from the mw96 prediction ( eq.[mw96bl ] ) .
possible invalidity of the linear mapping , the second possibility that fails the mw96 formula , was recently discussed by catelan et al .
( @xcite ) .
they pointed out that the linear mapping might not be valid for small halos because of large scale non - linear tidal force .
all these evidences are important but very preliminary and qualitative
. it would be important to find out if one or a combination of the two possibilities can _ quantitatively _ explain the failure of the mw96 formula . in this letter , we report our new determination for the lagrangian bias factor @xmath26 using the simulations of jing ( @xcite ) .
we use a novel method , which we call the cross - power spectrum between the linear density field and the halo number density field , to measure the bias factor .
the method has several important advantages over the conventional correlation function ( cf ) estimator . applying this method to our high - resolution simulations
yields a very accurate determination of @xmath26 for halo mass over four magnitudes both in scale - free models and in cdm models .
our result of @xmath26 can be accurately represented by @xmath27 , which quantitatively indicates that it is the failure of the ps theories for describing the formation of small halos that results in the failure of the mw96 formula .
this result has important implications for the ps theories .
an independent , highly related work by porciani et al .
( @xcite ) appeared when the present work had been nearly finished .
they measured the lagrangian bias for two scale - free simulations ( @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) of @xmath30 particles by fitting the halo two - point correlation function with the linear and second - order terms ( corresponding to the coefficients @xmath31 and @xmath32 in eq .
[ dhdm ] ) .
they concluded that the failure of the mw96 formula essentially exists in the lagrangian space and that their result can be reasonably described by @xmath27 .
while our present study ( @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) confirms their result in these aspects , our simulations have significantly higher resolution ( a factor 8 in mass ) that is essential for a robust accurate measurement of clustering for small halos .
moreover , we explore a much larger model space and use a superior measurement method .
in addition , there is some quantitative difference between their measured bias and ours which will be discussed in sect .
we will describe and discuss the cross - power spectrum method in sect . 2 , where we will also briefly describe our halo catalogs .
our measurement results will be presented and compared , in sect . 3 , to the analytical formula eq.([mw96bl ] ) and the fitting formula eq.([fitting ] ) for the eulerian bias . in sect . 4
, we will summarize our results and discuss their implications for the ps theories and for galaxy formation .
we use the fluctuation field @xmath33 to denote the density field @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is the mean density . smoothing both the halo number density field and the linear density field over scales much larger than the halo lagrangian size
, we assume that the smoothed halo field of @xmath36 can be expanded in the smoothed linear density field @xmath37 ( mo et al .
@xcite ) , [ dhdm ] _ h ( ) = b_1^l _ m ( ) + 12 b_2^l ^2_m ( ) + .... this general assumption , especially to the first order , has been verified by previous simulation analysis ( e.g. mw96 ; mo , jing , & white @xcite ; jing @xcite ) . this expansion is however naturally expected in the ps theories , with the first coefficient @xmath38 given by eq.([mw96bl ] ) and the higher order coefficients by mw96 , mo et al .
( @xcite ) , and catelan et al .
( @xcite ) . by fourier transforming eq.([dhdm ] ) , multiplying the both sides by @xmath39 , and taking an ensemble average , we get the cross - power spectrum @xmath40 . because the bispectrum of the linear density field vanishes for gaussian fluctuations ,
the second term at the right hand side is zero .
therefore we have [ crops ] p_c(k ) = b^l p_m(k)+ ( 3rd and higher order terms ) , where @xmath21 is the linear power spectrum .
this equation serves as a base for our measuring @xmath41 .
the linear density field @xmath42 is known when we set the initial condition for the simulations .
the halo density field @xmath43 can be easily measured for a sample of the dm halos with the fft method .
the ensemble average in eq.([crops ] ) can be replaced in measurement by the average over different modes within a fixed range of the wavenumber @xmath44 . thus both @xmath45 and @xmath21 can be easily measured .
the bias factor @xmath41 is just the ratio of these two quantities , if higher order corrections are small and can be neglected .
this method has several important advantages over the conventional cf analysis . on the linear scale where the clustering of small halos is weak ( about 10% of the mass correlation ) ,
the cross - power spectrum can be estimated accurately , because it does not suffer from the finite volume effect or the uncertainty of the mean halo number density .
the errors of @xmath45 and @xmath21 are uncorrelated among different @xmath44-bins for a gaussian field , which ease our error estimate for @xmath41 .
the second order correction ( @xmath32-term ) vanishes in the cross - power spectrum .
the method yields a determination of @xmath31 , not the square of @xmath41 , thus we can see if the bias factor @xmath31 is positive for @xmath46 and negative for @xmath47 as eq.([mw96bl ] ) predicts , where @xmath6 is the characteristic mass defined by @xmath48 .
all these attractive features do not present in the cf analysis .
an additional interesting feature is that the shot noise of the finite number of halos is greatly suppressed in the estimate of @xmath45 , because the linear density field dose not contain any shot noise and the cross - power spectrum of this field with the shot noise ( of a random sample ) is zero in the mean .
it is quite different from the ( self ) power spectrum estimate of the halos which we must correct for the shot noise @xmath49 ( @xmath50 is the number of halos ) . in the next section
, we will quantitatively show the shot noise effect is indeed negligible in our measurement of @xmath41 even for a sample containing as many as @xmath51 halos .
the halo catalogs analyzed here are the same as those used in jing ( @xcite ) .
the cosmological models , the simulations , and the halo catalogs were described in detail by jing ( @xcite ) .
here we only briefly summarize the features that are relevant to the present work .
the catalogs were selected , with the friends - of - friends algorithm with the linking length 0.2 times the mean particle separation , from a set of @xmath52 n - body simulations of @xmath0 particles .
the simulations cover four scale - free models @xmath53 with @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 and three typical cold dark matter ( cdm ) models which are scdm , lcdm and ocdm models respectively .
each of the @xmath54 scale - free simulations has seven outputs , and that of the @xmath29 has eight outputs .
the cdm models are simulated with two different box sizes , @xmath55 and @xmath56 .
three to four realizations were run for each model and for each box size in the case of the cdm models . in order to study the halo distribution in the lagrangian space ,
we trace back each of the halo members to its initial position before the zeldovich displacement , i.e. the position in the lagrangian space .
the position of a halo is defined as the center of the mass of its members in the lagrangian space . in this way
our halo catalogs in the lagrangian space are compiled .
we present our results for the linear clustering scales where the variance @xmath57 is less than @xmath58 . in this paper , we take @xmath59 , but our results change little if we take @xmath60 or @xmath61 . figure 1 shows the ratio of the cross - power spectrum @xmath45 to the linear power spectrum @xmath21 as a function @xmath44 for two halo masses in the @xmath1 scale - free model .
the ratios , i.e. the bias factors , do not depend on the scale @xmath44 , so the linear bias approximation is valid .
the bias factor is positive for the large halos of @xmath62 , but negative for the small halos of @xmath63 , consistent with the mw96 prediction eq.([mw96bl ] ) .
here we only show two examples , but the above features are found in all the models . to quantitatively examine the shot noise effect caused by the finite number of the halos ( 2 ) , we repeat our calculation for random samples . for each halo sample ,
we generate ten random samples .
the mean bias factor calculated for the random samples is zero , as expected .
more interesting is that the fluctuation of the bias factor between the random samples is always small compared to the halo bias factor .
this is shown in figure 1 , where the dashed lines are the @xmath64 upper limits of the shot noise .
the catalog of @xmath65 contains only @xmath66 halos in each realization . even in this case , the shot noise leads to an uncertainty of only @xmath67 of the halo bias at every @xmath68bin ( except for the first bin ) .
the shot noise is indeed effectively suppressed in our cross - power spectrum measurement . from figure 1 , we know that the lagrangian bias @xmath41 , on the linear clustering scale , is a function of the halo mass @xmath10 only .
the self - similar nature of the scale - free models makes the bias depend only on @xmath69 .
three panels of figure 2 show our result of @xmath70 for the models @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath4 at different output times .
we do not plot , for the limited space , our result for the @xmath71 model , but all of our following discussion still includes this model .
the excellent scaling exhibited by @xmath72 at different outputs supports that our measurement is not contaminated by any numerical artifacts .
the bias factor is negative for @xmath7 , zero for @xmath73 , and positive for @xmath74 , in agreement with the mw96 formula .
more quantitatively , the mw96 formula describes very well the lagrangian clustering for large halos @xmath75 , but systematically underestimates ( more negative bias ) for small halos @xmath76 .
if the linear mapping is valid , i.e. @xmath77 , these results are fully consistent with our previous finding ( jing @xcite ) that the mw96 formula systematically underestimates the eulerian bias for small halos .
more interestingly , with the linear mapping assumption and with our fitting formula eq.([fitting ] ) for the eulerian bias , we can get a lagrangian bias @xmath78 that agrees very well with our simulation results ( the solid lines on fig . 2 ) .
so the inaccuracy of the mw96 eulerian bias formula eq .
( [ mw96b ] ) already exists in their derivation for the lagrangian bias .
our results for the @xmath28 and @xmath29 models are qualitatively in good agreement with porciani et al .
( @xcite ) .
quantitatively , we note that their lagrangian bias is significantly lower than the mw96 formula for @xmath74 in the @xmath28 model , in contrast to the good agreement we find with the mw96 formula for all models for @xmath79 .
our result for the lcdm model is shown in the lower - right panel of figure 2 . comparing to the mw96 analytical formula eq([mw96b ] ) and the fitting formula eq([fitting ] )
, we have the same conclusion as we got for the scale - free models : the analytical formula underestimates the lagrangian bias value for small halos and the fitting formula agrees quite well with the simulation results after the difference between the eulerian and the lagrangian spaces is considered with the linear mapping .
the scdm and ocdm models give essentially the same results , and we omit their plots .
our fitting formula for the eulerian bias can accurately describe the lagrangian bias under the assumption of the linear mapping . the difference between the fitting formula and the simulation result is generally less than @xmath80 or @xmath81 ( @xmath82 is the error derived from the different realizations ) except for one bin of the smallest halos in the @xmath1 model .
the simulation result is slightly higher in the @xmath1 model but lower in the @xmath83 model ( both about 15% ) than the fitting formula for small halos ( @xmath84 ) .
the difference could come from the possible effect of non - linear mapping ( catelen et al .
@xcite ) and/or from higher order contributions which depend on measurement methods ( for the eulerian bias we used the cf analysis ) . we will address this problem more closely in a future paper .
in this letter , we use a new method , the cross - power spectrum between the linear density field and the halo number density field , to determine the lagrangian bias .
the method has several apparent advantages over the conventional correlation function estimator in determining the bias factor . applying this method to the halo catalogs of jing ( @xcite ) , we find that the lagrangian bias is linear on the linear clustering scale .
the lagrangian bias @xmath26 is positive for halo mass @xmath74 , zero for @xmath73 , and negative for @xmath7 , qualitatively consistent with the mw96 prediction for the lagrangian bias .
quantitatively , our simulation results of @xmath26 are in good agreement with the mw96 formula for large halos @xmath85 , but the mw96 formula significantly underestimates the lagrangian clustering for small halos @xmath86 .
our measured lagrangian bias can be described very well by our fitting formula for the eulerian bias eq.([fitting ] ) under the linear mapping assumption .
our results therefore unambiguously demonstrate that the inaccuracy of the mw96 formula for the eulerian bias already exists in their derivation for the lagrangian bias .
a very subtle point is that there exists a small difference ( @xmath87 ) between our measured lagrangian bias and our fitting formula [ eq.([fitting ] ) ] for eulerian bias after the linear mapping is applied .
this difference could be due to the difference of the measurement methods or / and the non - linear mapping effect .
our result however assures that the non - linear effect in the mapping , if any , must be small compared to the linear mapping .
the result of this paper has important implications for the press - schechter theories .
the spherical collapse model that connects the halo formation with the density peaks has to be replaced with a model that can better describe the formation of small halos .
this might be related to solving the long standing problem that the halo number density predicted by the press - schechter theories has a factor of a few difference from simulation results ( e.g. , gelb & bertschinger @xcite ; lacey & cole @xcite ; ma & bertschinger @xcite ; jing 1998 , unpublished ; tormen @xcite ; kauffmann et al .
@xcite ; somerville et al .
@xcite ; governato et al .
@xcite ; lee & shandarian @xcite ; jing , kitayama , & suto @xcite ) . because galaxies are believed to form within small halos ( @xmath7 ) , solving these problems is of fundamental significance to studying galaxy formation .
it is also my pleasure to thank an anonymous referee for a constructive report and the jsps foundation for a postdoctoral fellowship .
the simulations were carried out on vpp/16r and vx/4r at the astronomical data analysis center of the national astronomical observatory , japan . | we use a new method , the cross - power spectrum between the linear density field and the halo number density field , to measure the lagrangian bias for dark matter halos .
the method has several important advantages over the conventional correlation function analysis . by applying this method to a set of high - resolution simulations of @xmath0 particles
, we have accurately determined the lagrangian bias , over 4 magnitudes in halo mass , for four scale - free models with the index @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 and three typical cdm models .
our result for massive halos with @xmath5 ( @xmath6 is a characteristic non - linear mass ) is in very good agreement with the analytical formula of mo & white for the lagrangian bias , but the analytical formula significantly underestimates the lagrangian clustering for the less massive halos @xmath7 .
our simulation result however can be satisfactorily described , with an accuracy better than 15% , by the fitting formula of jing for eulerian bias under the assumption that the lagrangian clustering and the eulerian clustering are related with a linear mapping .
it implies that it is the failure of the press - schechter theories for describing the formation of small halos that leads to the inaccuracy of the mo & white formula for the eulerian bias .
the non - linear effect in the mapping between the lagrangian clustering and the eulerian clustering , which was speculated as another possible cause for the inaccuracy of the mo & white formula , must be negligible compared to the linear mapping .
our result indicates that the halo formation model adopted by the press - schechter theories must be improved .
# 1*s*_#1 # 1|n(*r*_#1 ) # 1|n(*s*_#1 ) # 1_z(r_p#1,_#1 ) # 1(r_#1 ) # 1(s_#1 ) # 1w(r_p#1 ) |
constant width bodies , i.e. , convex bodies for which parallel supporting hyperplanes have constant distance , have a long and rich history in mathematics @xcite . due to meissner @xcite ,
constant width bodies in euclidean space can be characterized by _
diametrical completeness _
, that is , the property of not being properly contained in a set of the same diameter .
constant width bodies also belong to a related class of _ reduced _ convex bodies introduced by heil @xcite .
this means that constant width bodies do not properly contain a convex body of same minimum width .
remarkably , the classes of reduced bodies and constant width bodies do not coincide , as a regular triangle in the euclidean plane shows .
reduced bodies are extremal in remarkable inequalities for prescribed minimum width , as in steinhagen s inequality @xcite ( minimum inradius ) , or others that surprisingly still remain unsolved , namely , pl s problem @xcite ( minimum volume ) . while the regular simplex ( and any of its reduced subsets ) is extremal for steinhagen s , it is extremal only in the planar case for pl s problem .
the reason is that while the regular triangle is reduced , this is no longer the case for the regular simplex in @xmath2 , @xmath1 . indeed , heil conjectured @xcite that a certain reduced subset of the regular simplex is extremal for pl s problem .
heil also observed that some reduced body has to be extreme for pl s problem when replacing volume by quermassintegral .
the existence of reduced polytopes , and the fact that smooth reduced sets are of constant width ( cf .
@xcite ) , opens the door to conjecture some of them as minimizers .
in full generality , any non - decreasing - inclusion functional of convex bodies with prescribed minimum width , attains its minimum at some reduced body .
pl s problem restricted to constant width sets is the well - known blaschke - lebesgue problem , cf .
@xcite , solved only in the planar case , where the reuleaux triangle is the minimizer of the area , and meissner s bodies are conjectured to be extremal in the three - dimensional space , see @xcite for an extended discussion .
note that pl s problem has also been investigated in other geometrical settings such as minkowskian planes @xcite or spherical geometry , cf .
@xcite and @xcite . reduced bodies in the euclidean space have been extensively studied in @xcite , and the concept of reducedness has been translated to finite - dimensional normed spaces @xcite . in reference to the existence of reduced polygons in the euclidean plane ,
lassak @xcite posed the question whether there exist reduced polytopes in euclidean @xmath0-space for @xmath1 .
several authors addressed the search for reduced polytopes in finite - dimensional normed spaces @xcite . for euclidean space starting from dimension @xmath3 several classes of polytopes such as * polytopes in @xmath2 with @xmath4 vertices , @xmath4 facets , or more vertices than facets ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 7 ) , * centrally symmetric polytopes ( * ? ? ?
* claim 2 ) , * simple polytopes , i.e. , polytopes in @xmath2 where each vertex is incident to @xmath0 edges ( like polytopal prisms , for instance ) ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 8) , * pyramids with polytopal base ( * ? ? ? * theorem 1 ) , and in particular simplices @xcite , * polytopes in @xmath5 which have a vertex @xmath6 with a strictly antipodal facet @xmath7 ( see ) such that the edges and facets incident to @xmath6 are strictly antipodal to the edges and vertices of @xmath7 , respectively , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) , were proved to be _ not _ reduced .
the theoretical results on reduced polytopes in @xmath5 in the mentioned preprint @xcite by polyanskii are accompanied with an unfortunately erroneous example , as we will show in .
the purpose of the present article is to fix polyanskii s polytope and to present a reduced polytope in three - dimensional euclidean space in .
the validity of our example can be checked using the algorithm provided in .
throughout this paper , we work in @xmath0-dimensional euclidean space , that is , the vector space @xmath2 equipped with the inner product @xmath8 and the norm @xmath9 , where @xmath10 and @xmath11 denote two points in @xmath2 .
a subset @xmath12 is said to be _ convex _ if the line segment @xmath13{\mathrel{\mathop:}=}{\left\{\lambda x+(1-\lambda)y \::\ : 0\leq\lambda\leq 1\right\}}\ ] ] is contained in @xmath14 for all choices of @xmath15 .
convex compact subsets of @xmath2 having non - empty interior are called _
convex bodies_. the smallest convex superset of @xmath12 is called its _ convex hull _ @xmath16 , whereas the smallest affine subspace of @xmath2 containing @xmath14 is denoted by @xmath17 , the _ affine hull _ of @xmath14 . the _ affine dimension _
@xmath18 of @xmath14 is the dimension of its affine hull .
the _ support function _
@xmath19 of @xmath14 is defined by @xmath20 for @xmath21 , the hyperplane @xmath22 is a _ supporting hyperplane _ of @xmath14 .
the _ width _ of @xmath14 in direction @xmath23 , defined by @xmath24 equals the distance of the supporting hyperplanes @xmath25 multiplied by @xmath26 .
the _ minimum width _ of @xmath14 is @xmath27 .
a _ polytope _ is the convex hull of finitely many points .
the boundary of a polytope consists of _ faces _ , i.e. , intersections of the polytope with its supporting hyperplanes .
we shall refer to faces of affine dimension @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 as _ vertices _ , _ edges _ , and _ facets _ , respectively .
faces of polytopes are lower - dimensional polytopes and shall be denoted by the list of their vertices .
( a face which is denoted in this way can be reconstructed by taking the convex hull of its vertices . ) by definition , attainment of the minimal width of a polytope @xmath31 is related to a binary relation on faces of @xmath31 called _ strict antipodality _ , see @xcite .
[ def : antipodal ] let @xmath32 be a polytope .
distinct faces @xmath33 , @xmath34 of @xmath31 are said to be _ strictly antipodal _ if there exists a direction @xmath23 , @xmath35 , such that @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
gritzmann and klee ( * ? ? ?
* ( 1.9 ) ) formulated a necessary condition on strictly antipodal pairs whose distance equals the minimum width .
[ thm : width_polytope ] suppose that @xmath32 is a polytope with non - empty interior , and that @xmath33 and @xmath34 are a strictly antipodal pair of faces of @xmath31 whose distance is equal to @xmath38 .
then , @xmath39 with @xmath40 when @xmath31 is centrally symmetric . by @xmath41
we shall denote the euclidean distance of a strictly antipodal facets @xmath33 , @xmath34 of @xmath31 which , additionally , satisfy .
the following definition by heil @xcite is central to the present investigation .
a convex body @xmath14 is said to be _ reduced _ if we have @xmath42 for all convex bodies @xmath43 .
reduced polytopes can be characterized using vertex - facet distances , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) for the following result .
[ thm : polytope_reduced ] a polytope @xmath32 is reduced if and only if for every vertex @xmath6 of @xmath31 , there exists a strictly antipodal facet @xmath7 of @xmath31 such that the distance between @xmath6 and @xmath44 equals @xmath38 .
strongly related , there is also the following necessary condition on the orthogonal projection of a vertex onto one of its strictly antipodal facets at the correct distance , see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2 ) .
[ thm : reduced_implication ] assume that @xmath32 is a reduced polytope .
then for every vertex @xmath6 of @xmath31 there exists a facet @xmath7 of @xmath31 such that @xmath45 is strictly antipodal to @xmath7 , the orthogonal projection @xmath46 of @xmath6 onto @xmath44 lies in the relative interior of @xmath7 , and the distance from @xmath6 to @xmath46 is equal to @xmath38 .
in his recent arxiv preprint @xcite , polyanskii claims that he has found a reduced polytope in three - dimensional euclidean space . unfortunately , his example is invalid . in this section ,
we revisit polyanskii s polytope to find its flaw .
the polytope @xmath31 considered by polyanskii is the convex hull of eight points @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 . for properly chosen parameters @xmath55 and @xmath56
, the points @xmath57 are the vertices of @xmath31 , see for an illustration .
note that @xmath31 has the same combinatorial structure as johnson s solid @xmath58 .
there are two types of vertices : the four vertices @xmath59 are incident to four edges each , and the remaining four vertices @xmath60 belong to five edges each . by symmetry , it is sufficient to take one vertex of each group and specify which faces should be strictly antipodal and at distance @xmath38 to the chosen vertices .
polyanskii decides to pair the vertices @xmath61 and @xmath62 up with the facets @xmath63 and @xmath64 , respectively .
additionally , he also sets the distances between the skew edges @xmath65 and @xmath66 , and between @xmath67 , @xmath68 equal to the minimum width of @xmath31 .
therefore , the parameter @xmath69 will be this common distance .
this yields the four equations formulated in the appendix of @xcite .
these equations may be manipulated as follows . from @xmath70 and @xmath71 ,
we get @xmath72 this can be plugged into the equation @xmath73 in order to write @xmath74 as a function of @xmath75 , namely @xmath76 plugging and in @xmath77 we obtain one equation with variable @xmath75 .
this equation is equivalent to the polynomial equation @xmath78 . using the relevant solution of this equation
, we obtain the parameters @xmath79 if we compute the outer normal vectors of the facets @xmath80 and @xmath63 , assume their orthogonality , and substitute @xmath74 and @xmath69 according to and again , we obtain the same polynomial equation @xmath78 .
in other words , provided three of polyanskii s distances are equal , the fourth distance equals the other three if and only if the orthogonal projections of the vertices @xmath59 onto their strictly antipodal faces lie on edges , i.e. , not in the relative interior of any facet .
hence polyanskii s polytope is not reduced , see again .
another evidence of this fact can be seen in the polyanskii s list of pairs of skew edges whose distance is larger than the presumed minimal width . in this list ,
pairs of edges of type @xmath81 , @xmath82 are missing , and these pairs are exactly those where the actual minimum width @xmath83 of @xmath31 is attained .
\(a ) at ( axis cs:1,0,0 ) ; ( b ) at ( axis cs:-1,0,0 ) ; ( c ) at ( axis cs:0,1 , ) ;
( d ) at ( axis cs:0,-1 , ) ; ( e ) at ( axis cs:0 , , ) ; ( f ) at ( axis cs:0,- , ) ; ( g ) at ( axis cs:,0 , ) ; ( h ) at ( axis cs:-,0 , ) ; at ( a ) ; at ( b ) ; at ( c ) ; at ( d ) ; at ( e ) ; at ( f ) ; at ( g ) ; at ( h ) ; /in f / a , f / b , e / c , f / h , e / g , c / d , c / g , d / h , d / g , a / b , a / g , b / h , f / g , f / d /in e / a , e / b , e / h , c / h \(a ) at ( axis cs:1,0,0 ) ; ( b ) at ( axis cs:-1,0,0 ) ; ( c ) at ( axis cs:0,1 , ) ; ( d ) at ( axis cs:0,-1 , ) ; ( e ) at ( axis cs:0 , , ) ; ( f ) at ( axis cs:0,- , ) ; ( g ) at ( axis cs:,0 , ) ; ( h ) at ( axis cs:-,0 , ) ; at ( a ) ; at ( b ) ; at ( c ) ; at ( d ) ; at ( e ) ; at ( f ) ; at ( g ) ; at ( h ) ; /in e / h , e / c , f / h , e / g , c / d , c / h , c / g , d / h , d / g , f / g , f / d /in a / b , e / a , e / b , f / a , f / b , a / g , b / h \(a ) at ( axis cs:1,0,0 ) ; ( b ) at ( axis cs:-1,0,0 ) ; ( c ) at ( axis cs:0,1 , ) ; ( d ) at ( axis cs:0,-1 , ) ; ( e ) at ( axis cs:0 , , ) ; ( f ) at ( axis cs:0,- , ) ; ( g ) at ( axis cs:,0 , ) ; ( h ) at ( axis cs:-,0 , ) ; at ( a ) ; at ( b ) ; at ( d ) ; at ( f ) ; at ( g ) ; at ( h ) ; /in f / a , f / b , e / c , f / h , e / g , c / d , c / h , c / g , d / h , d / g , a / b , a / g , b / h , f / g , f / d /in e / a , e / b , e / h
however , polyanskii s polytope can be modified in order to obtain a reduced polytope .
we do this by introducing a new parameter @xmath84 and replacing each of the four vertices of degree @xmath85 in polyanskii s polytope by a line segment of length @xmath86 .
consider the points @xmath87 note that we slightly changed the meaning of the parameters @xmath69 and @xmath74 .
for properly chosen parameters @xmath88 the points @xmath89 are the vertices of our polytope @xmath31 .
the combinatorial structure of our polytope is shown in .
\(a ) at ( axis cs : , 0 , - ) ; ( b ) at ( axis cs:- , 0 , - ) ; ( c ) at ( axis cs : 0 , , ) ; ( d ) at ( axis cs : 0 , - , ) ; ( e ) at ( axis cs : , , ) ; ( f ) at ( axis cs:- , , ) ; ( g ) at ( axis cs : , - , ) ; ( h ) at ( axis cs:- , - , ) ; ( i ) at ( axis cs : , , - ) ; ( j ) at ( axis cs : , - , - ) ; ( k ) at ( axis cs:- , , - ) ; ( l ) at ( axis cs:- , - , - ) ; at ( a ) ; at ( b ) ; at ( c ) ; at ( d ) ; at ( e ) ; at ( f ) ; at ( g ) ; at ( h ) ; at ( i ) ; at ( j ) ; at ( k ) ; at ( l ) ; /in a / b , c / d , a / i , a / j , c / i , d / j , i / j , b / l , d / l , g / h , d / g , d / h , h / l , g / j , e / i , c / e , a / g , b / h /in b / k , e / f , c / f , f / k , a / e , b / f , c / k , k / l \(a ) at ( axis cs : , 0 , - ) ; ( b ) at ( axis cs:- , 0 , - ) ; ( c ) at ( axis cs : 0 , , ) ; ( d ) at ( axis cs : 0 , - , ) ; ( e ) at ( axis cs : , , ) ; ( f ) at ( axis cs:- , , ) ; ( g ) at ( axis cs : , - , ) ; ( h ) at ( axis cs:- , - , ) ; ( i ) at ( axis cs : , , - ) ; ( j ) at ( axis cs : , - , - ) ; ( k ) at ( axis cs:- , , - ) ; ( l ) at ( axis cs:- , - , - ) ; at ( a ) ; at ( b ) ; at ( c ) ; at ( d ) ; at ( e ) ; at ( f ) ; at ( g ) ; at ( h ) ; at ( i ) ; at ( j ) ; at ( k ) ; at ( l ) ; /in c / d , c / i , d / j , i / j , d / l , g / h , d / g , d / h , h / l , g / j , c / k , k / l , e / i , c / e , c / f , f / k , e / f /in a / b , a / i , a / j , a / g , a / e , b / k , b / h , b / f , b / l \(a ) at ( axis cs : , 0 , - ) ; ( b ) at ( axis cs:- , 0 , - ) ; ( c ) at ( axis cs : 0 , , ) ; ( d ) at ( axis cs : 0 , - , ) ; ( e ) at ( axis cs : , , ) ; ( f ) at ( axis cs:- , , ) ; ( g ) at ( axis cs : , - , ) ; ( h ) at ( axis cs:- , - , ) ; ( i ) at ( axis cs : , , - ) ; ( j ) at ( axis cs : , - , - ) ; ( k ) at ( axis cs:- , , - ) ; ( l ) at ( axis cs:- , - , - ) ; at ( a ) ; at ( b ) ; at ( d ) ; at ( g ) ; at ( h ) ; at ( j ) ; at ( l ) ; /in a / b , c / d , a / i , a / j , c / i , d / j , i / j , b / l , d / l , g / h , d / g , d / h , h / l , g / j , c / k , k / l , a / g , b / h /in b / k our polytope possesses the same symmetry as polyanskii s . hence , it is again sufficient to control some of the facet - vertex and edge - edge distances .
in fact , we are going to solve the equations @xmath90 w.r.t .
@xmath91 . here
, @xmath92 are suitably chosen . by introducing the normal vectors @xmath93 where @xmath94 denotes the usual cross product of the vectors @xmath95 , these equations can be rewritten as @xmath96 now
, it is easy to see that the third equation ( counting in columns ) is equivalent to @xmath97 .
moreover , it is tedious to check that we can factor out @xmath98 in the first equation and @xmath99 in the fifth .
hence , we are going solve the four equations @xmath100 under @xmath101 w.r.t .
the remaining variables @xmath102 .
note that each left - hand side of the four equations in are multivariate polynomials of degree at most @xmath103 in the four unknowns @xmath102 .
numerically , we used @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 and solved equations by newton s method starting with @xmath107 .
this results in @xmath108 and the numerical residuum in the four equations is below @xmath109 . using kantorovich s theorem , see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem xviii.1.6 ) , it is possible to prove that equations possess an exact root in the neighborhood of our numerical solution . using these parameters , we can check that the remaining distances are @xmath110 thus , the width of our polytope using these parameters is really @xmath111 , see .
consequently , our polytope is reduced by . since the jacobian of the ( left - hand sides of ) equations w.r.t .
@xmath112 is invertible at our point of interest , it follows from the implicit function theorem that we also obtain a solution for small changes of the parameters @xmath113 and @xmath114 .
hence , we obtain a whole family of reduced polytopes possessing three degrees of freedom .
it is quite a delicate and tedious procedure to check the reducedness of a given polytope @xmath115 .
hence , we present an algorithm based on and[thm : polytope_reduced ] .
it consists of two steps : 1 .
compute the width of @xmath31 , compare . 2 . check whether each vertex has a strictly antipodal facet , compare . an implementation in pseudocode
is given in . in step 4 of the algorithm , we denoted by @xmath116 a vector normal to the skew edges @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
using and[thm : polytope_reduced ] , it is easy to check its correctness .
a matlab implementation is provided at zenodo , see @xcite .
* input : * polytope @xmath115 set @xmath119 set @xmath120 unmark all vertices of @xmath31 compute the strictly antipodal face @xmath121 set @xmath122 unmark all vertices of @xmath31 set @xmath123 mark vertex @xmath6 are all vertices of @xmath31 marked ?
in this paper , we presented the first to our best knowledge example of a reduced polytope in three - dimensional euclidean space .
as polyanskii @xcite has already pointed out , the existence of reduced polytopes in euclidean space remains open starting from dimension four .
moreover , already finding a reduced polytope in three - dimensional space with different combinatorial structure than the one presented in seems to be a non - trivial task .
finally , it has to be checked to which amount polyanskii s negative result ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2 ) can be generalized to higher dimensions .
* acknowledgements .
* we would like to thank horst martini for encouraging us in the search of reduced polytopes , and ren brandenberg and undine leopold for fruitful discussions , and alexandr polyanskii for his ideas and his talk at the conference _ discrete geometry days _ , which took place in budapest , hungary , in june 2016 .
g. averkov , _ on planar convex bodies of given minkowskian thickness and least possible area _ , arch . math .
( basel ) * 84 * ( 2005 ) , no . 2 , pp .
183192 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00013-004-1152-6[doi : 10.1007/s00013 - 004 - 1152 - 6 ] .
chakerian and h. groemer , _ convex bodies of constant width _ , convexity and its applications ( p. m. gruber and j. m. wills , eds . ) , birkhuser , basel , 1983 , pp . 4996 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-0348-5858-8[doi : 10.1007/978 - 3 - 0348 - 5858 - 8 ] .
p. gritzmann and v. klee , _ inner and outer @xmath124-radii of convex bodies in finite - dimensional normed spaces _ , discrete comput
* 7 * ( 1992 ) , no . 1
255280 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/bf02187841[doi : 10.1007/bf02187841 ] .
to3em , _ reduced convex bodies in finite - dimensional normed spaces : a survey _ , results math . * 66 * ( 2014 ) , no . 3 - 4 , pp .
405426 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00025-014-0384-4[doi : 10.1007/s00025 - 014 - 0384 - 4 ] . | by correcting an example by polyanskii , we show that there exist reduced polytopes in three - dimensional euclidean space .
this partially answers the question posed by lassak @xcite on the existence of reduced polytopes in @xmath0-dimensional euclidean space for @xmath1 .
* keywords : * polytope , reducedness * msc(2010 ) : * http://www.ams.org/mathscinet/msc/msc2010.html?t=52b10[52b10 ] |
the asteroid belt is challenging to understand but is critical for studies of the formation and early evolution of the solar system .
the orbital configuration of the asteroid belt is believed to have been established in two phases .
the first phase dates back to the first few million years of solar system s formation and should be studied in conjunction with the formation of the inner and outer planets , especially jupiter and saturn .
the second phase occurred when the asteroid belt witnessed a giant planet instability , long after the damping effects of the gaseous solar nebula had dissipated in general , simulations of the dynamical re - shaping of the asteroid belt are made in conjunction with the formation of the inner planets .
the first simulations of terrestrial planet formation @xcite included a set of planetary embryos uniformly distributed in the inner region of the solar system with orbits initially dynamically cold ( low eccentricity and inclination ) . through numerical integrations of the equations of motion of these embryos , adding a model of accretion by collisions , the system evolves to form planets in the inner region of the solar system on stable orbits . while early results about the formation of terrestrial planets were promising , one of the problems found in these integrations was related with the final eccentricities of the planets , which were systematically larger than the real ones .
the models produced more promising results when the presence of a substantial population of planetesimals was also accounted for ; in fact , the dynamical friction exerted by the planetesimals acted to decrease the excitation of the planet s final orbits @xcite .
an important ingredient was the presence of jupiter , which should have completed its formation much earlier than the inner planets @xcite .
primarily , the influence of jupiter on the asteroid belt is to promote destructive collisions ( fragmentation ) rather than constructive collisions ( accretion ) @xcite .
however , jupiter alone can not excite the eccentricity of planetesimals so much as to explain the current excited orbits of asteroids @xcite .
in addition , there is significant diversity in the physical properties of asteroids found in the main asteroid belt , but their main taxonomic classes are found in roughly overlapping distributions although s - class bodies predominate in the inner regions and c - class bodies in the outer regions ( see * ? ? ? * ) .
the solution of these issues have been attributed to the original presence of planetary embryos in the asteroid belt @xcite .
these embryos , once excited by jupiter , would have scattered the orbits of the planetesimals . in the end
, the asteroid belt would have been depleted of planetesimals and totally devoid of embryos . despite the many successes in the modeling of the terrestrial planets and asteroid belt by the simulations described above , systematic problems persisted .
the planet formed in the approximate region of mars systematically showed a much larger mass than the real mars ( see * ? ? ?
an experiment by @xcite found that if there is sharp outer edge in the initial mass distribution of solids at about 1.0 au , then the models consistently reproduce the mass of mars .
@xcite proposed a mechanism to modify the original mass distribution of solids and produce the truncated disk explored by @xcite , by accounting for the early migration of jupiter and saturn when they were still embedded in the gaseous proto - planetary disk .
an outcome found in many hydrodynamical models @xcite of the interaction between giant planets and gaseous disks is that the type - ii inward migration of a jupiter - mass planet is halted and even reversed when a second , less massive planet , is formed external to the first one .
this provides the explanation for why jupiter did not migrate to very close the sun , as is seen for giant planets in many other planetary systems @xcite . instead
, jupiter would have migrated first inwards , then outwards .
because of the change in direction of the orbital motion of jupiter ( a `` tack '' in sailor s jargon ) , the @xcite model is named the `` grand tack '' . the timing of the formation of saturn is constrained by the mass distribution of the terrestrial planets , which are best reproduced when jupiter reverses migration at 1.5 au and truncates the disk at 1 au .
the migration of jupiter would have strongly affected any planetesimals formed in the present - day asteroid belt , with a primary consequence of substantially depleting the entire region of small bodies .
the inward migration phase primarily pushes the asteroids originally inside of jupiter s orbit ( named `` s - class '' in @xcite ) down to lower semimajor axes ( inside of 1 au ) , though @xcite found that about 10% of these bodies are scattered outward onto orbits with semimajor axis @xmath0 between 4 - 10 au . during the outward migration of jupiter and saturn ,
these bodies are encountered again , and about 1% are scattered back into the asteroid belt .
meanwhile jupiter and saturn eventually encounter primitive planetesimals ( titled `` c - class '' in @xcite ) , and a fraction of a percent of these are also scattered into the asteroid belt .
this provides , at the time when the gas nebula has dispersed , a final belt which is depleted in mass by a factor of about 1,000 , that contains two different classes of bodies partially mixed in heliocentric distance and with orbits excited in eccentricities and inclinations ( although the final eccentricity distribution does not match well the current one , as discussed below ) .
numerous constraints , such as the ages of the last impact basins on the moon @xcite , the impact age distribution of he d meteorites @xcite , and the small total chondritic mass accreted by the moon since its formation @xcite , point to an epoch of increased bombardment in the inner solar system about @xmath1400@xmath2700 my after the removal of gas from the proto - planetary disk ( whereas the grand tack happened before the removal of the gas ) .
this period of increased bombardment is usually called `` terminal lunar cataclysm '' or `` late heavy bombardment '' ( lhb ) ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* for reviews ) , and we will adopt the lhb nomenclature here . the origin of the lhb has been linked to a dynamical upheaval in the outer solar system frequently referred to as the `` nice model '' @xcite . during this dynamical upheaval
the giant planets would have suffered an instability and a period of mutual close encounters that radically changed their orbits . in turn , the orbital change of the giant planets would have severely affected the distribution of the asteroids in the main belt @xcite .
the best guess on when this instability occurred , from various constraints , is 4.1 gy ago @xcite .
this is important because the final asteroid belt in @xcite lacks objects with small eccentricities . indeed , according to the grand tack model , the eccentricity distribution expected for the asteroid belt at the time when the gas nebula dispersed , some 3 - 10 myr after the emergence of first solids and roughly 4.5 gyr ago , peaks around 0.4 . on the other hand , the current distribution of the asteroid belt peaks around 0.1 @xcite .
it has never been studied whether the grand tack final distribution could evolve to one similar to what we see today due to the perturbations caused by the giant planet instability during the nice model .
the goal of this paper is to present such a study . in this work
, we will study in detail the evolution of the asteroid belt orbital structure , from the end of the grand tack model to the giant planet orbital instability , through the instability phase , and finally during the last @xmath14 gy until today .
this work will therefore unfold as follows : section [ method ] explains our solar system s configuration and the method used for the numerical simulations . in section [ results ] we discuss the dynamical evolution of the asteroid belt throughout the various phases of the solar system s evolution , as well as the influence of the primordial eccentricities of jupiter and saturn on the final structure of the asteroid belt .
finally , section [ conclusion ] summarizes the main conclusions of this paper .
a complementary study , approaching the problem from a different perspective , has been recently presented in @xcite .
we will compare our results with theirs at the end of section [ post - lhb ] .
2 our numerical simulations contain five planets , venus , earth , mars , jupiter , and saturn ( all with their current masses ) , plus 10,000 massless particles representing the final outcome of the asteroid belt in the grand tack simulations ( described below ) .
uranus , neptune , and the putative extra ice giant invoked in @xcite are not included in any of our simulations ( the same applies for the planet mercury ) .
these planets are indeed too far from the asteroid belt to have any important direct effect on its structure . a caveat
, however , is that in some simulations the extra ice giant is sent temporarily onto an asteroid belt - crossing orbit before being ultimately ejected from the solar system . in the case
the asteroid belt - crossing phase last for sufficiently long time , the effects of this body on the asteroid belt should be taken into account ( see * ? ? ? * ) . nevertheless , because we have limited understanding on how exactly the evolution of the planets occurred ( i.e. how deep a planet crossed the asteroid belt and for how long ) , we prefer to neglect this putative asteroid belt - crossing event and focus only on the effects induced by jupiter , saturn and the terrestrial planets , whose evolution is better constrained .
the orbital configuration of the five planets was chosen as follows : * _ before the planetary instability : _ the terrestrial planets are modeled to be on simple planar orbits @xcite .
jupiter and saturn , also on planar orbits , were locked in their mutual 3:2 mmr with jupiter at 5.4 au .
two cases , differing for the eccentricity of the giant planets ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) are considered .
case 1 ( left ) is an initial configuration from the hydrodynamical simulations of @xcite , where the planets migrated into the resonance and preserved orbits with very small eccentricities due to the tidal damping effect exerted by the gas disk .
case 2 ( right ) is an arbitrary case where the planets are placed in resonant orbits , but with larger eccentricities ( although still smaller than their current values ) . for this phase ( for both cases ) , the numerical integrations are continued for 400 my ( i.e. until 4.1 gy ago ) , the best estimate of the time of the giant planet instability @xcite . * _ after the planetary instability : _ the initial asteroid s orbits are those recorded at the end of the simulations of the previous phase , but the planets are placed onto their present - day orbits . by doing this , we model the instantaneous transition of the planets from their pre - instability orbits to the current orbits . in other words ,
we simulate the response of the asteroid belt to the change of the planetary orbits , but we assume that the actual dynamical path that the planets followed in this transition had no important effects . we take this simple approach because precisely what happened during the planetary instability is unknown , and many different paths could have been followed by the giant planets @xcite .
certainly , no instability simulation can have the pretension to reproduce exactly what happened .
we know from previous studies @xcite that the change of the giant planets orbits had to be fast and of the `` jumping - jupiter '' type , i.e. dominated by a few impulsive events due to mutual planetary encounters .
thus , we believe that substituting the original planetary orbits with the current orbits is the best approximation of the real planetary evolution we can implement without the risk of incurring into arbitrary simulation artefacts . in particular , by using the current planetary system , the locations and strengths of all resonances exactly match the real ones , whereas no singular instability simulation would finish with precisely a replica of the current - day planetary system .
for the same reasons , this approach has already been adopted by @xcite in their study of the projectile flux from the asteroid belt to the terrestrial planets . the opposite approach
( i.e. simulating the dynamics of the giant planets during the instability phase ) has been taken by @xcite .
the second phase of simulations were conducted for 4.1 gy , until a total timescale of 4.5 gy was covered by the combination of the two phases of the solar system evolution . concerning the asteroid distribution we consider two cases .
in our nominal case we use the asteroid distribution resulting from the simplest of all grand tack scenarios , namely the one that only included jupiter and saturn ( figure 2 .
of supplementary information of @xcite , referenced as `` 2-planet grand tack simulation '' hereafter ) .
however , for comparison we also consider the distribution generated in the grand tack scenario that also include uranus and neptune ( presented in the main paper of @xcite , referenced as `` 4-planet grand tack simulation '' hereafter ) . because the original grand tack simulations had only @xmath11,000 particles in the final sample in the asteroid belt , in order to improve statistics we generated 10,000 massless particles matching the basic traits of the @xmath3 distribution obtained in the 2-planet grand tack simulation , with the following properties : * eccentricity distribution is a normal distribution with mean of 0.38 and sigma of 0.17 .
* inclination distribution is a rayleigh distribution with a sigma of 10 degrees .
* semimajor axis distribution is nearly an uniform distribution spread over the range 1.83.6 au .
while these functional fits reproduce each distribution individually , combined they produced an excess of objects with high - eccentricity and low - inclination compared to the distribution of asteroids at the end of the grand tack simulations . to remove this excess ,
the 10,000 particles were re - sampled in bins of width 0.05 in eccentricity and 5 degrees in inclination . in each bin
, we allowed the total number of particles to be at most 4 times more numerous than the asteroids at the end of the grand tack simulations in the same bin .
if there were no original grand tack asteroids in the bin , a maximum of 4 particles from the functional fits was allowed .
this re - sampling limited the excess population of high - eccentricity and low - inclination bodies found in the 10,000 particle distributions , and resulted in a final population of 6,424 bodies .
the advantage of this procedure , relative to using directly the grand tack asteroids as initial conditions , is that the functional fits allow us to generate more particles ( but this could have been achieved also by cloning the grand tack asteroids ) and also place some particles in bins originally with zero grand tack asteroids , thus making the distribution smoother . for the 4-planet grand tack simulation we simply resampled the above distribution attributing to each particle a `` weight '' , representing the probability that said particle exists at the end of the 4-planet grand tack run .
because the semimajor axis and inclination distributions in the 2-planet and 4-planet grand tack simulations are basically the same , these weights are computed from the eccentricity distributions only , which are significantly different .
these weights are then used to build a new final distribution from that obtained in our nominal case . in all simulations
all planets interact with each other while also perturbing the test particles .
test particles interact with the planets but not among themselves .
the integrations have been conducted using mercury @xcite , in the hybrid option with a time step of 10 days ( more than 20 steps per orbital period of venus ) .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the current structure of the asteroid belt plotting all objects with absolute magnitude h@xmath410 from the minor planet center catalog , where the main asteroid belt is assumed to be observationally complete at this size @xcite .
our goal is to verify if it is possible that the orbital configuration of the asteroid belt at the end of the grand tack model could evolve to one similar to that shown in this figure .
to do so , we considered the two phases of the solar system evolution previously discussed in section [ method ] . 10 objects from the minor planet center catalog .
gray dots represent the asteroids .
curved dashed lines in the top panel represent the boundaries for earth- , mars- , and jupiter - crossing orbits ( from left to right ) . in the bottom panel ,
the curved dashed line represents the current location of the @xmath5 secular resonance , which occurs when the precession rate of an asteroid s longitude of perihelion is equal to the mean precession rate of the perihelion of saturn .
vertical dashed lines show mmrs between asteroids and jupiter .
[ fig2 ] ] figure [ fig3 ] shows the current asteroid belt orbital distribution ( gray line ) compared with the initial conditions used in this experiment that were generated from the grand tack simulations ( as described in section [ method ] ) ; the solid line is for the result of the 2-planet grand tack simulation and the dashed line is for the 4-planet simulation . with the exception of the inclination distributions , which match fairly well ,
the grand tack and the real distributions are clearly different , i.e. , the eccentricity distributions in the grand tack simulations are skewed towards large values , and the semimajor axis distributions are nearly uniform instead of having the clear gaps found in today s population .
the 2-planet and 4-planet grand tack simulations also give eccentricity distributions quite different from each other , with the distribution obtained in the 4-planet simulation being even more skewed to large values .
many particles in the final grand tack distributions , however , must clearly be unstable , because their small semimajor axis and/or large eccentricity make them planet - crossing .
2 figure [ fig4 ] , shows snapshots of the evolution of the asteroid belt in our simulations , starting from the final 2-planet grand tack configuration .
the left panel illustrates the initial system , corresponding to the solid black lines of fig .
[ fig3 ] . considering the evolution described in section [ method ] ( with planets on pre - instability orbits ) , and using case 1 ( low - eccentricity giant planets orbits from @xcite ) , after 400 my of evolution we obtain the distribution depicted in the right panel of figure [ fig4 ] .
the colors of the particles in the left panels correspond to the particles lifetimes in this simulation .
results related to case 2 ( giant planets with more eccentric orbits ) , will be considered only for measuring the influence of the primordial eccentricities of jupiter and saturn and presented in section [ ejs ] . 2 the distribution after 400 my is already closer to the current one ( see fig .
[ fig2 ] ) because the very high eccentricity objects have been removed due to interactions with the planets whose orbits they crossed .
the main difference with the current main belt distribution is that our simulated belt extends inwards of 2.2 au in semimajor axis .
this is because the powerful @xmath5 resonance is not in place yet , given that jupiter and saturn are still in resonance and on quasi - circular orbits .
this extension of the main belt towards the terrestrial planets is precisely the _ e - belt _ advocated in @xcite .
although not shown , the distribution after 700 my of evolution is nearly indistinguishable from that shown in the right panel of fig .
this demonstrates that the exact timing of the giant planet instability is not important for this study . in order to better understand the evolution during the first 400 my , by looking in more detail at fig .
[ fig4 ] , we see that a very strong depletion ( @xmath1 71% ) has occurred , approximately half in the first 100 my .
this is due to the large collection of particles on clearly unstable orbits , as noted above .
in fact , this happened mostly to objects with @xmath6 0.4 , due to either collision with the terrestrial planets ( 10% of the removed particles ) or jupiter ( 1.5% ) or ejections onto hyperbolic orbits ( 88% of the removed particles ) .
only 0.5% of the removed particles collided with the sun .
this number is much smaller than that for the current near - earth asteroids @xcite .
this is because the giant planets are on more circular orbits , which makes the mean motion resonances much less effective in rising eccentricities than in the current solar system ( mean motion resonances are stable if jupiter is on a circular orbit and would not open gaps , @xcite ) . also , the orbits of the giant planets are closer to each other , so the @xmath5 secular resonance is further out in the belt . consequently ,
neither the mean motion nor the secular resonances are able to lift the particles eccentricities to unity .
although the distribution of particles at the end of the grand tack evolution covers a wide range of eccentricities , semimajor axes , and inclinations ( as shown in the left panel of fig .
[ fig4 ] ) , in order to estimate the asteroid belt mass @xcite consider only particles in the `` belt region '' , with @xmath7 1.9 au and @xmath8 3.2 au . in this region ,
our depletion ratio is @xmath1 24% during the first 400 my and @xmath1 16% within the first 100 my .
the grand tack model places @xmath9 10@xmath10 m@xmath11 of s - types asteroids in the `` belt region '' , and three times as much of c - types asteroids , which implies a total mass of @xmath1210@xmath10 m@xmath11 for the post - grand tack main belt .
thus , after 400 my , we still have @xmath176% of the mass remaining in the primordial main belt , which is @xmath13.9@xmath1310@xmath10 m@xmath11 , or about 6 - 7 the current mass of the current asteroid belt ( @xmath16@xmath1310@xmath14 m@xmath11 ) .
the second phase of the numerical simulations begin after the planetary instability . here , as explained in section [ method ] ,
the planets are instantaneously placed onto their current orbits . with the new orbits
, the secular resonances ( particularly the @xmath5 resonance at 2.05 au ) appear with their full power and several mean motion resonances with jupiter become unstable due to the larger eccentricities of jupiter and saturn .
the lifetimes of the particles that constituted the initial conditions for this second simulation are illustrated via a color scale in the right panels of fig .
[ fig4 ] .
figure [ fig5 ] shows the final orbital distribution of the particles surviving at the end of the full simulation , at 4.5 gy .
one may note that there is a nice qualitative match between the current asteroid belt distribution and that produced in the simulation ( compare with fig .
[ fig2 ] ) .
the range of distribution in semimajor axes , eccentricities , inclinations , and the structure of the kirkwood and secular resonant gaps look very similar in the two cases . secular resonance .
vertical dashed lines show mmrs between asteroids and jupiter .
[ fig5 ] ] fig .
[ fig6 ] compares the final distribution of the surviving simulated particles with the current asteroid belt orbital distribution , in a manner similar to what we did in fig .
[ fig3 ] for the initial distribution . 2 fig .
[ fig6 ] ( bottom left panel ) compares the final semimajor axis distributions .
the visual comparison is very satisfactory , with the exception of the zone between the 7:3 and 2:1 mmrs , which is more relatively populated by real asteroids than in our model . to be more quantitative , the fraction of the total asteroid population orbiting between major kirkwood gaps
is reported in table [ ratios ] for both the observed and the model populations .
again , we see a fairly good agreement .
.fraction of the asteroid population orbiting between major kirkwood gaps .
all fractions are caulculated dividing the number of asteroids in between two adjacent kirkwood gaps by the total number of asteroids between the 7:2 and the 2:1 mmrs .
thus : zone 1 represents the fraction of asteroids between the mmrs 7:2 and 3:1 .
zone 2 the fraction between the 3:1 and 5:2 mmrs .
zone 3 between the 5:2 and 7:3 mmrs , and zone 4 between the 7:3 and 2:1 mmrs . [ cols="<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] the inclination distribution ( fig .
[ fig6 ] top right ) does not change very much ( compare with fig .
[ fig3 ] ) from the beginning to the end of our simulations , moving just slightly towards larger inclination values .
indeed low inclination asteroids are removed somewhat more frequently than high inclination asteroids during the giant planet instability .
thus , our final inclination distribution is moderately more excited than the observed distribution .
this is particularly apparent in fig .
[ fig5 ] , in which we see ( by comparison with the observed distribution in fig .
[ fig2 ] ) that the ratio between the number of asteroids above and below the @xmath5 resonance in the inner belt ( @xmath8 2.5 au ) is much larger in our model ( @xmath11.2 ) than in reality ( @xmath10.09 ) . however , if the initial inclination distribution ( at the end of the grand tack ) had been less excited , the final population ratio would have been much closer ( for instance we obtain a population ratio of @xmath10.1 if we truncate the initial distribution at 20 degrees ) .
thus , this is clear evidence that the inclination distribution at the end of the grand tack is too excited .
this result may suggest that the grand tack evolution occurred faster than simulated in @xcite , or that the planets had not yet reached their current masses , or there was a stronger gas - drag effect . in the eccentricity panel ( fig .
[ fig6 ] top left ) , despite some differences that are still observed between the real and the model distributions , the match appear reasonably good , particularly if one considers how different the grand tack eccentricity distributions were originally ( compare with fig .
[ fig3 ] ) .
this shows that the grand tack model can be consistent with the current eccentricity distribution .
the reason for which the final eccentricity distribution is much more in agreement with the observed distribution than the initial one is twofold .
first , as explained above , large eccentricity asteroids tend to be removed because they are unstable on a timescale shorter than the solar system lifetime .
second , when jupiter transitions form a quasi - circular to an eccentric orbit , the asteroid s secular motion sees a value of the forced eccentricity different from before ( which was almost zero ) .
depending on the values of the difference in longitude of perihelia between the asteroid and jupiter when this happens , some asteroids will find themselves at the minimum of the new secular eccentricity cycle ( and , possibly , by achieving a larger eccentricity they will be removed by encounters with the terrestrial planets ) while others will be at the maximum of the secular eccentricity cycle .
others , of course , will be at intermediate values . by this mechanism , the mean eccentricity of some asteroids can either decrease or increase during the jump in jupiter s eccentricity ( fig .
[ fig7 ] ) .
@xcite discuss an analog process in the case of a secular resonance sweeping through an excited belt .
specifically , in our simulations we observed that @xmath177% of the survivor asteroids kept their mean eccentricity nearly unchanged ( @xmath15@xmath16 @xmath4 0.05 ) when passing through the dynamical instability ( fig .
[ fig7 ] , bottom panel ) . on the other hand , within those @xmath123% that have had their mean eccentricity changed in more than 0.05 in this phase , the ratio decrease / increase in mean eccentricity values was about half ( @xmath151% decrease and @xmath149% increase fig .
[ fig7 ] , top left and right panels , respectively ) .
we considered the first and last 100 my of simulation to compute and compare the mean values of eccentricities .
this reshuffling of eccentricities explains why the solid and dashed black curves in the top left panel of fig .
[ fig6 ] are so similar to each other
. remember ( see sect .
[ method ] ) that the dashed distribution is obtained from our nominal final distribution ( solid curve ) by weighting each integrated particle according to its probability to exist at the end of the 4-planet grand tack simulation . because the distribution at the end of the 4-planet grand tack simulation is more skewed to large values than that in the 2-planet case ( see fig . [ fig3 ] ) , the particles in our integration with an initial low eccentricity have a weight well smaller than 1 , while those with an initial large eccentricity have a weight larger than 1 . thus , if the evolution just following the grand tack had just preserved low - eccentricity asteroids , the final solid and dashed distribution would have been very different . instead , the fact that a significant number of initially large-@xmath17 particles acquire a small eccentricity erases the initial difference in eccentricity distributions .
this result is important because it shows that the evolution subsequent to the grand tack generates a final eccentricity distribution of asteroids that is quite insensitive of the initial one and in broad agreement with the observed one . 2 concerning the mass depletion of the asteroid belt
, we find that during the second phase of the simulation , from 400 my to 4.5 gy , there was a depletion of @xmath177% of the particles .
this depletion is consistent with that observed in the simulations of @xcite of the instability phase ( about 50% depletion ) , followed by the additional 50% depletion observed in @xcite due to asteroids in diffusive regions , unstable on a longer timescale . in terms of mass
, we need again to consider the `` belt region '' . in this region , the depletion from 400 my to 4.5 gy was @xmath158% .
recall that after the first 400 my , @xmath176% of the particles survived in the `` belt region '' ( representing @xmath13.9@xmath1310@xmath10 m@xmath11 ) .
thus , additionally , @xmath12.3@xmath1310@xmath10 m@xmath11 was lost during this phase .
therefore , the final estimate for the surviving mass in the asteroid belt in our simulation is @xmath11.6@xmath1310@xmath10 m@xmath11 , which represents about 2 - 3 the current mass . given the uncertainties in the implementations of the grand tack model ( see the supplementary information in @xcite for information on the wide range of test cases explored ) , we consider this to be a satisfactory match of the current asteroid belt mass .
lastly , although there is overall consistency between our results and the current main belt , our results ( bottom right panel of fig . [ fig6 ] )
show a lack of particles with low inclination at low eccentricity . in order to improve the results ,
either the grand tack simulations should have produced more particles in this region , or during the instability phase jupiter should have had acquired a temporary orbit with a larger eccentricity than the current one , enhancing the reshuffling of the eccentricity distribution discussed above .
the last option is actually likely to have taken place , because simulations of the instability @xcite show that the eccentricity of jupiter s orbit is partially damped afterwards , which implies that it had to be larger in the past . by substituting the primordial jupiter s orbit with the current orbit
, we clearly missed this phase .
our results are complementary to those of @xcite . in that paper
the authors considered the dynamics of the giant planet instability from the most successful simulations of @xcite but did not include the presence of the terrestrial planets .
they concluded that in order to reproduce the present main belt , the primordial belt should have had a distribution peaked at @xmath18 in inclination and at @xmath19 in eccentricity .
here we start from the actual asteroid distribution at the end of the grand tack model , include the effects of terrestrial planets , but simplify the dynamical instability phase .
we find that the grand tack inclination distribution is indeed peaked at 10 degrees and the eccentricity distribution , once reshaped mostly due to scattering by the terrestrial planets , rapidly evolves to one that peaks at about 0.1 - 0.2 .
hence , our final distribution is in good agreement with the observed one , with a sight deficit of asteroids in orbits with low eccentricity and a slight overabundance of large inclination bodies . up to this point
we have only considered pre - instability orbits of the giant planets as shown in case 1 ( fig .
[ fig1 ] left , section [ method ] ) . here
we explore the putative case of more eccentric pre - instability giant planet orbits , case 2 ( fig .
[ fig1 ] right , section [ method ] ) , and compare with the results of case 1 presented above .
the comparison between the results of the simulations in case 1 and case 2 is shown with snapshots of the evolution in fig .
[ fig8 ] ( with case 1 in the left column and case 2 in the right column ) and final distribution histograms in fig .
the distributions are shown both before and after the planetary instability phases ( up to 1.5 gy and [ fig9 ] ( bottom left panel ) , as well as by the analysis of the animation found electronically at extranet.on.br/rodney/rogerio/asteroids.mp4 ] ) .
case 2 results in a larger depletion .
after 0.4 gy case 1 lost 72% , and case 2 84% of the primordial asteroids . more importantly , case 2 shows a wide gap just outside of the 3:1 mmr at 2.5 au .
this gap is not visible in the simulation of case 1 and it does not exist in today s asteroid belt .
such a gap corresponds to the location of the 3:1 mean motion resonance with jupiter , when jupiter was on the pre - instability orbit at @xmath20 5.4 au . with the moderate eccentricity orbits of the giant planets considered in case 2 ,
the resonance is unstable and opens a gap in the asteroid distribution in 400 my . assuming that the instability happened late , so that there is enough time to open the gap at the 3:1 mmr and that there was no interloper planet that would cause scattering of the asteroids semimajor axes , this gap becomes fossilized and is never refilled in the subsequent , post - instability evolution .
the same is true for other resonances with jupiter ( 5:2 mmr at @xmath12.9 au , 7:3 mmr at @xmath13.1 au , 2:1 mmr at 3.4 au ) . instead , in case 1 , where the eccentricities of the giant planets are much smaller
, these resonances are far less powerful and do not open gaps .
this result is consistent with that in @xcite and constrains the eccentricities of jupiter and saturn characterizing their pre - instability orbits , i.e. , the primordial eccentricities of jupiter and saturn were likely quite low ( as in case 1 simulation ) . 2 2
in this paper we evaluated the evolution of the primordial asteroid belt resulting from the grand tack model throughout the entire age of the solar system .
we assumed that the configuration just after the end of the grand tack phase is the one that emerges when the gas nebula dissipates and only solid material remains in the asteroid belt and planetary regions .
the grand tack model can explain the mixing of the taxonomic classes of the bodies within the asteroidal region .
however , as a major drawback , it predicts a primordial asteroid belt that seems too excited when compared to the real asteroid belt . in order to see how the subsequent evolution of the solar system would affect the excited primordial belt , and
if the grand tack model predictions are coherent with the current asteroid belt , we considered two phases of evolution : * the first dates back to the first 400 my , before the planetary instability , but after the terrestrial planets have been fully formed in orbits more planar and circular than today @xcite .
also in this phase we considered jupiter and saturn locked in their 3:2 mmr with jupiter initially at @xmath0 = 5.4 au , with both planets in quasi planar and circular orbits as well . during this phase we noticed a huge depletion of the asteroid population ( about @xmath171% ) , mostly due to ejection ( @xmath188% ) .
most of the removed asteroids had initially @xmath6 0.4 .
thus , in the `` belt region '' ( @xmath21 au and @xmath22 au ) only about @xmath124% of the initial mass was lost , leaving @xmath13.9@xmath1310@xmath23 ( 67 the current mass of the current asteroid belt ) . *
the second phase starts just after the end of the planetary instability .
we simulated the planetary instability as a discontinuous event , by instantaneously moving all planets to their current orbits .
in other words , as explained in section [ method ] , we considered that the planetary instability happened fast enough that the actual dynamical path that the planets followed between the transition from the pre - instability orbits to the current orbits had no important effects .
thus , by using the current planetary system , the locations and strengths of all resonances match exactly the real ones , and we could simulate the response of the asteroid belt to the change of the planetary orbits . this phase was carried from 400 my to 4.5 gy and as a major result , it substantially changed the eccentricity distribution that , at the end , mostly resembles the current asteroid belt . during the second phase , when the mmrs with jupiter are unstable , and the @xmath5 destabilizes the extended part of the asteroid belt ( e - belt ) , another period of strong depletion occurs ( @xmath177% of the bodies remaining from phase 1
were lost ) .
again , most of the depletion is due to ejections and concerns bodies not in the `` belt region '' . in terms of the remaining mass ,
the `` belt region '' had an additional @xmath158% of loss , ending with @xmath11.6@xmath1310@xmath23 ( 23 the current mass of the current asteroid belt ) , which is a satisfactory match of the current asteroid belt s mass given the uncertainties in the implementations of the grand tack model .
as for the orbital structure of the final asteroid belt , even considering that we have a deficit of objects with low eccentricity with low inclinations in our final distribution , the results are quite good .
in fact , the inclination distribution evolves slightly towards a more excited distribution and is in the end somewhat too excited relative to the observed one .
we infer that the inclination distribution at the end of the grand tack phase should have extended only up to @xmath24 , instead of @xmath25 as in @xcite .
the semimajor axis distribution evolves from an almost uniform distribution to one quite similiar to that of the real asteroid belt , not only in terms of location of kirkwood gaps but also in terms of the relative number of objects in each sub - belt region .
the eccentricity distribution produced by the grand tack , initially skewed to large values , evolves to one similar to the observed distribution once we take into account the post - grand tack dynamics .
remarkably , this is the case both starting from the final distributions in the 2-planet and 4-planet grand tack simulations , despite these distributions being quite different from each other . the fact that @xcite , with a very different approach , found a similar result gives support to the claim that the grand tack scenario is compatible with the current properties of the asteroid belt . finally , assuming that the instability happened late and that there was no interloper planet that would disperse the semimajor axes of the asteroids during the planetary instability , we show that primordial eccentric orbits for jupiter and saturn would have produced fossil kirkwood gaps at misplaced positions that are not observed .
thus , our results support the idea that the orbits of the giant planets remained quasi - circular until the time of the instability .
the authors would like to thank david p. obrien and nathan kaib for the detailed review , comments , and suggestions made to improve the manuscript .
r.d . acknowledges support provided by grants # 2014/02013 - 5 and # 2015/18682 - 6 , so paulo research foundation ( fapesp ) and capes .
r. s. g. was supported by cnpq ( grant # 307009/2014 - 9 ) .
k. j. w. acknowledges support through i - set , a nasa sservi program at swri .
a. m. acknowledges support from anr project number anr-13\{13-bs05- 0003 - 01 projet mojo .
d. n. was supported by nasa s outer planet research program .
00 bottke , w. f. , vokrouhlick , d. , minton , d. , nesvorn , d. , morbidelli , a. , brasser , r. , simonson , b. , levison , h. f. 2012 .
an archaean heavy bombardment from a destabilized extension of the asteroid belt .
nature 485 , 78 - 81 .
brasser , r. , morbidelli , a. , gomes , r. , tsiganis , k. , levison , h. f. 2009 . constructing the secular architecture of the solar system ii : the terrestrial planets .
astronomy and astrophysics 507 , 1053 - 1065 .
cumming , a. , butler , r. p. , marcy , g. w. , vogt , s. s. , wright , j. t. , fischer , d. a. 2008 .
the keck planet search : detectability and the minimum mass and orbital period distribution of extrasolar planets .
publications of the astronomical society of the pacific 120 , 531 - 554 .
gladman , b. j. , migliorini , f. , morbidelli , a. , zappala , v. , michel , p. , cellino , a. , froeschle , c. , levison , h. f. , bailey , m. , duncan , m. 1997 .
dynamical lifetimes of objects injected into asteroid belt resonances .
science 277 , 197 - 201 .
levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , tsiganis , k. , nesvorn , d. , gomes , r. 2011 .
late orbital instabilities in the outer planets induced by interaction with a self - gravitating planetesimal disk . the astronomical journal 142 , 152 .
morbidelli , a. , tsiganis , k. , crida , a. , levison , h. f. , gomes , r. 2007 .
dynamics of the giant planets of the solar system in the gaseous protoplanetary disk and their relationship to the current orbital architecture . the astronomical journal 134 , 1790 - 1798 . | the asteroid belt is characterized by the radial mixing of bodies with different physical properties , a very low mass compared to minimum mass solar nebula expectations and has an excited orbital distribution , with eccentricities and inclinations covering the entire range of values allowed by the constraints of dynamical stability .
models of the evolution of the asteroid belt show that the origin of its structure is strongly linked to the process of terrestrial planet formation .
the grand tack model presents a possible solution to the conundrum of reconciling the small mass of mars with the properties of the asteroid belt , including the mass depletion , radial mixing and orbital excitation .
however , while the inclination distribution produced in the grand tack model is in good agreement with the one observed , the eccentricity distribution is skewed towards values larger than those found today . here
, we evaluate the evolution of the orbital properties of the asteroid belt from the end of the grand tack model ( at the end of the gas nebula phase when planets emerge from the dispersing gas disk ) , throughout the subsequent evolution of the solar system including an instability of the giant planets approximately 400 my later . before the instability
, the terrestrial planets were modeled on dynamically cold orbits with jupiter and saturn locked in a 3:2 mean motion resonance .
the model continues for an additional 4.1 gy after the giant planet instability .
our results show that the eccentricity distribution obtained in the grand tack model evolves towards one very similar to that currently observed , and the semimajor axis distribution does the same .
the inclination distribution remains nearly unchanged with a slight preference for depletion at low inclination ; this leads to the conclusion that the inclination distribution at the end of the grand tack is a bit over - excited . also , we constrain the primordial eccentricities of jupiter and saturn , which have a major influence on the dynamical evolution of the asteroid belt and its final orbital structure .
asteroids , dynamics , origin , solar system , planetary dynamics , planets , migration |
it is well known that initial conditions influence the temporal evolution of nonequilibrium systems .
the systems `` memory '' for the initial state usually depends on the dynamical rules .
for example , stochastic processes with a finite temporal correlation length relax to their stationary state in an exponentially short time .
an interesting situation emerges when a system undergoes a nonequilibrium phase transition where the temporal correlation length diverges .
this raises the question whether it is possible construct initial states that affect the _ entire _ temporal evolution of such systems . to address this question , we consider the example of directed percolation ( dp ) which is the canonical universality class for nonequilibrium phase transitions from an active phase into an absorbing state @xcite .
dp is used as a model describing the spreading of some non - conserved agent and may be interpreted as a time - dependent stochastic process in which particles produce offspring and self - annihilate . depending on the rates for offspring production and self - annihilation such models display a continuous phase transition from a fluctuating active phase into an absorbing state without particles from where the system can not escape .
close to the phase transition the emerging critical behavior is characterized by a particle distribution with fractal properties and long - range correlations .
the dp phase transition is extremely robust with respect to the microscopic details of the dynamical rules @xcite and takes place even in 1 + 1 dimensions .
monte - carlo ( mc ) simulations of critical models with absorbing states usually employ two different types of initial conditions . on the one hand
_ random initial conditions _ ( poisson distributions ) are used to study the relaxation of an initial state with a finite particle density towards the absorbing state . in this case
the particle density @xmath6 _ decreases _ on the infinite lattice asymptotically as ( for the definition of the dp scaling exponents @xmath7,@xmath8,@xmath9,@xmath10 see ref .
@xcite ) @xmath11 on the other hand , in so - called dynamic mc simulations @xcite , each run starts with a _ single particle _ as a localized active seed from where a cluster originates .
although many of these clusters survive for only a short time , the number of particles @xmath12 averaged over many independent runs _ increases _ as @xmath13 where @xmath14 .
these two cases seem to represent extremal situations where the average particle number either decreases or increases .
a _ crossover _ between these two extremal cases takes place in a critical dp process that starts from a random initial condition at very low density . here
the particles are initially separated by empty intervals of a certain typical size wherefore the average particle number first increases according to eq .
( [ increase ] ) .
later , when the growing clusters begin to interact with each other , the system crosses over to the algebraic decay of eq .
( [ decrease ] ) a phenomenon which is referred to as the `` critical initial slip '' of nonequilibrium systems @xcite . in the present work
we investigate whether it is possible to interpolate _ continuously _ between the two extremal cases .
as will be shown , one can in fact generate certain initial states in a way that the particle density on the infinite lattice varies as @xmath15 with a continuously adjustable exponent @xmath3 in the range @xmath16 to this end we construct artificial initial configurations with algebraic long - range correlations of the form @xmath17 where @xmath18 denotes the average over many independent realizations , @xmath0 the spatial dimension , and @xmath19 inactive and active sites .
the exponent @xmath4 is a free parameter and can be varied continuously between @xmath20 and @xmath21 . the limit of long - range correlations @xmath22 corresponds to a constant particle density and thus we expect eq .
( [ decrease ] ) to hold . on the other hand
, the short - range limit @xmath23 represents an initial state where active sites are separated by infinitely large intervals so that the particle density should increase according to eq .
( [ increase ] ) . in between we expect @xmath6 to vary algebraically according to eq .
( [ decay ] ) with an exponent @xmath3 depending continuously on @xmath4 .
our aim is to investigate the functional dependence of @xmath24 .
the effect of power - law correlated initial conditions @xmath25 in case of a quench to the ordered phase of systems with nonconserved order parameter has been investigated some time ago by bray et .
al . @xcite .
such systems are characterized by coarsening domains that grow with time as @xmath26 .
an important example is the ( 2 + 1)-dimensional glauber - ising model quenched to zero temperature .
it was observed that long - range correlations are relevant only if @xmath4 exceeds a critical value @xmath27 .
furthermore , it was shown that the relevant regime is characterized by a continuously changing exponent in the autocorrelation function @xmath28 \sim t^{-(d-\sigma)/4}$ ] , whereas the usual short - range scaling exponents could be recovered below the threshold .
the results were found to be in agreement with the simulation results for the two - dimensional ising model quenched from @xmath29 to @xmath30 . the dp process
the prototype of models with a phase transition from an active phase into an absorbing state is different from coarsening processes . instead of growing domains
the dp process generates fractal clusters of active sites with a coherence length @xmath31 which grows as @xmath32 where @xmath33 .
thus the scaling forms assumed in ref .
@xcite are no longer valid in the present case .
in addition , the field - theoretical description of dp involves nontrivial loop corrections and thus we are interested to find out to what extent the results are different from those in ref .
our investigation also sheds some light on the relation between the observed phenomena for correlated initial states , the critical initial slip , and scaling laws in time dependent simulations . in the present work we focus on the following aspects of the problem : in sect .
[ initcondsection ] we describe in detail how correlated initial states can be constructed in one dimension . using these states
we then perform mc simulations in order to numerically estimate the exponent @xmath3 as a function of @xmath4 ( see sect .
[ numsection ] and fig .
[ kappa ] ) . in sect .
[ rgsection ] we present a field - theoretical renormalization group calculation which generalizes recent results obtained by wijland et .
al . @xcite .
because of a special property of the vertex diagrams and the loop diagrams for the initial particle distribution it is possible to derive an exact scaling relation , leading to our main result @xmath34 \frac{1}{z } ( d-\sigma-\beta/\nu_\perp ) & \mbox{for } & \sigma>\sigma_c \end{array } \right.\ ] ] with the critical threshold @xmath35 . because of the scaling relation @xmath14 this function is continuous at @xmath36 .
the theoretical result is found to be in agreement with our simulation results in one spatial dimension . in sect .
[ naturalcorrsection ] we compare the correlations of our constructed initial states with the `` natural '' correlations that are generated by the dp process itself .
finally we summarize our conclusions in sect .
[ conclusionsection ] .
the construction of artificial correlated particle distributions on a lattice is a highly nontrivial task since the lattice spacing and finite size effects lead to deviations that strongly affect the accuracy of the numerical simulations .
therefore one has to carefully verify the correlation exponent and fractal dimension of the generated distribution . in this section
we describe in detail how such particle distributions can be generated and tested . for simplicity we restrict ourselves to initial states in one spatial dimension .
let us consider a particle distribution on the real line where particles are separated by empty intervals of length @xmath37 .
we assume that these intervals are uncorrelated and power - law distributed according to @xmath38 this distribution corresponds to a simple fractal set with the fractal dimension @xmath39 , hence the range of @xmath40 is restricted by @xmath41 . on a lattice
, however , the lattice spacing and the system size @xmath42 have to be taken into account as lower and upper cutoffs for the distribution @xmath43 .
the quality of a lattice approximation depends on the actual implementation of these cutoffs .
it turns out that the accuracy of mc simulations depends strongly on the quality of the initial states and therefore the proper implementation of the cutoffs is crucial in the present problem .
we find that a good approximation is obtained when an ( almost ) perfect fractal set is projected onto the lattice in a way that site @xmath44 becomes active if at least one element of the fractal belongs to the interval @xmath45 $ ] .
the resulting lattice configuration is the minimal set of boxes on the lattice that is needed to cover the fractal set .
this projection can be efficiently realized on a computer by generating a sequence of points @xmath46 on the real line separated by intervals distributed according to eq .
( [ distribution ] ) with a very small cutoff @xmath47 and projecting it onto the lattice by the following prescription ( see fig .
[ figprojection ] ) : 1 .
start with the empty lattice @xmath48 ( i=1, ,l ) and let @xmath46 be a real variable with the initial value @xmath49 .
2 . let @xmath44 be the maximal integer for which @xmath50 and turn site @xmath44 into the active state by setting @xmath51 .
3 . let @xmath52 be the current upper cutoff and generate a random number @xmath53 from a flat distribution . if @xmath54 the construction of the initial state is finished , otherwise continue .
generate another random number @xmath10 from a flat distribution in the interval @xmath55 and increment @xmath46 by @xmath56 , and continue at step @xmath57 .
notice that step @xmath58 takes the upper cutoff into account by finishing the loop when the generated interval @xmath37 would exceed the remaining size of the chain @xmath59 .
the lower cutoff is processed in step @xmath60 by truncating the allowed range of @xmath10 . in order to verify the quality of this approximation
, we numerically estimate the fractal dimension @xmath61 of the generated initial states by box counting . to this end
we divide the whole system into @xmath62 boxes and count the number @xmath63 of boxes that contain at least one active site , averaging over many independent realizations . in fig .
[ figfractaldim]a @xmath63 is plotted against @xmath62 in a double - logarithmic scale .
the straight lines indicate that the `` true '' fractal is well approximated . from the slopes we estimate the fractal dimension @xmath61 which is shown in fig .
[ figfractaldim]b as a function of @xmath40 .
we also measure the two - point correlations in the generated states which should be precisely those of eq .
( [ twopointcorrelations ] ) with @xmath64 .
this can be proven by assuming that the intervals are uncorrelated and evaluating a geometric series of the laplace transform of @xmath43 . in order to verify this relation , we estimated @xmath65 numerically in fig .
[ figfractaldim]c-[figfractaldim]d . in both measurements
we find a fairly good agreement with the exact results ( dashed lines in fig .
[ figfractaldim ] ) .
it turns out the deviations close to @xmath66 can be reduced by increasing the system size while the deviations close to @xmath67 are due to the lattice spacing and the lower cutoff @xmath68 .
it should be emphasized that these artificial initial states have a vanishing particle density in the limit @xmath69 . on a finite lattice ,
however , a finite density is generated which depends on @xmath40 and may vary over several decades . by increasing the lattice size
we therefore reduce the initial particle density which leads to a higher statistical error in the subsequent dp process .
thus the optimal system size has to be determined by balancing discretization errors of the initial states against statistical errors of the dp process .
the time dependent simulations have been performed by using a domany - kinzel stochastic cellular automaton @xcite with parallel updates and periodic boundary conditions .
the domany - kinzel model is controlled by two parameters @xmath70 and @xmath71 and has a whole phase transition line where a dp transition takes place .
we performed simulations for three different realizations , namely * @xmath72 , @xmath73 : wolfram-18 transition , * @xmath74 ; site percolation , * @xmath75 , @xmath76 : bond percolation .
the results turned out to be the same in all cases within numerical accuracy , although the bond and site percolation showed a better scaling law behavior .
an efficient , multi - spin coded program has been employed that simulates @xmath77 replicas for different values @xmath78 , exploiting the advantage that the same random numbers can be used on each replica at a given site .
this allows us to update @xmath77 systems in parallel stored as an integer vector of length @xmath42 .
the lattice size has been varied between @xmath79 and @xmath80 , while the number of independent samples was @xmath81 respectively .
finite size effects turned out to be negligible for @xmath82 .
as shown in fig .
[ rho ] the quality of the power - law for @xmath6 is quite convincing and extends over the first three decades in the case of a system with @xmath83 sites . for finite systems
all these curves will eventually cross over to the @xmath84 decay after very long time .
the slopes of the lines in the log - log plot measuring the exponent @xmath85 have been extrapolated from the last two decades by standard linear regression analysis .
for each @xmath40 we also determine the corresponding correlation exponent @xmath65 as explained in the previous section ( see fig .
[ figfractaldim ] ) . in fig .
[ kappa ] we plot @xmath85 versus @xmath65 . using the numerically known estimates for the dp exponents @xcite @xmath86 our results are in a fairly good agreement with the theoretical prediction of eq .
( [ exactsolution ] ) ( solid line ) .
the deviations for small @xmath4 originate from the lattice cutoff and could be reduced by further increasing the computational effort .
in this section we derive eq .
( [ exactsolution ] ) by an exact rg calculation . to this end
the dp langevin equation @xcite has to be extended by an additional term @xmath87 where @xmath88 represents the initial particle distribution and @xmath89 is a @xmath90-dependent noise field with correlations @xmath91 although in principle we could directly analyze the langevin equation , it is often more convenient to derive the corresponding effective field theory by introducing a second - quantized bosonic operator representation @xcite .
the langevin equation it then transformed into an effective action @xmath92 , where @xmath93 , @xmath94 , and @xmath95 denote the free part , the non - linear interaction , and the contribution for the initial particle distribution . following the notation of ref .
@xcite , the respective parts are given by : @xmath96 & = & \int d^dx\,dt\ , \bar{\psi}(x , t)\ , [ \partial_t + \lambda(\sigma-\nabla^2 ) ] \ , \psi(x , t ) \\
\label{interaction } s_{int } [ \psi,\bar{\psi } ] & = & \int d^dx\,dt\ , g \psi(x , t ) \ , \bar{\psi}(x , t ) \ , [ \psi(x , t ) - \bar{\psi}(x , t ) ] \\
\label{initialparticledistribution } s_{ipd } [ \bar{\psi},\phi ] & = & \int d^dx\ , \sum_{j=1}^\infty \delta_j \bar{\psi}^j(x,0 ) \phi(x ) \,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the part @xmath97 is just the usual action of reggeon field theory @xcite . the additional contribution @xmath95 couples the field @xmath98 with the initial particle distribution @xmath88 .
it is written in its most general form containing contributions of all orders in @xmath99 with independent coefficients @xmath100 .
the lowest order contribution @xmath101 in eq .
( [ initialparticledistribution ] ) corresponds to the term @xmath102 in the langevin equation ( [ langevin ] ) .
the higher order terms for @xmath103 are included because they may be generated under rg transformations .
however , as we will see below , it is actually sufficient to consider the first two contributions . the relaxation of a dp process with random initial conditions @xmath104 to its stationary state has been studied recently by wijland et .
@xcite using wilson s dynamic renormalization group approach . at the critical dimension @xmath105 the constant contribution @xmath101 was shown to be relevant while the `` poissonian '' contribution @xmath106 turned out to be marginal . for @xmath107 , however , fluctuations corrections cause the coefficient @xmath108 to vanish under rg transformations .
this allowed the authors to express the so - called critical initial slip exponent @xmath109 ( @xmath110 in their notation ) by an exact scaling relation .
as mentioned in the introduction , this exponent describes the initial short - time behavior of @xmath6 until the correlations generated by the dynamical process are longer than the typical size of empty intervals in the initial state @xcite so that the system crosses over to the usual decay of eq .
( [ decrease ] ) . in the present case , however , the interval sizes of the initial state are power - law distributed and affect not only the initial but in principle the whole temporal evolution
. nevertheless we can use the formalism of ref .
@xcite in order to determine the exponent @xmath3 as a function of @xmath4 .
the only difference is that we introduce a field @xmath88 that carries a non - trivial scaling dimension @xmath111 .
let us first consider a scaling transformation @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the anisotropy exponent of dp . under this transformation the fields in eqs .
( [ bilinearcontribution])- ( [ initialparticledistribution ] ) change according to @xmath114 as in reggeon field theory , the fields @xmath115 carry the same scaling dimension @xmath116 .
the _ scaling _ dimension of the initial state @xmath111 is related to the _ fractal _ dimension @xmath61 as follows .
the number of active sites @xmath117 on a lattice with @xmath42 sites grows as @xmath118 . on the other hand , @xmath119 , where @xmath120 denotes the average density of active sites , i.e. , @xmath121 . under rescaling this relation turns into @xmath122 , hence @xmath123 under rescaling the contribution @xmath95 changes by
@xmath124 i.e. , the coefficients @xmath100 transform according to @xmath125 defining the anomalous scaling dimensions @xmath126 of the fields @xmath127 by @xmath128 the scaling dimensions of the coefficients @xmath100 in the mean field approximation is given by @xmath129 \,.\ ] ] this result is expected to hold at the critical dimension @xmath105 .
notice that the relevance of the contributions @xmath100 decreases with increasing @xmath130 . in systems with less than four spatial dimensions ,
fluctuation corrections have to be taken into account . assuming that contributions with @xmath131 in eq .
( [ initialparticledistribution ] ) are irrelevant , these corrections have been computed in ref .
@xcite in a one - loop approximation .
it was shown that in @xmath132 dimensions the coefficients @xmath133 and @xmath108 change under infinitesimal scaling @xmath134 according to @xmath135 where @xmath136 denotes the surface area of the unit sphere in four dimensions divided by @xmath137 and @xmath138 is the ultraviolet cutoff in momentum space .
let us first consider the renormalization of @xmath108 . as already noticed in ref .
@xcite , the diagrams in eq .
( [ delta2 ] ) which are linear in @xmath108 are formally identical with those for the renormalization of the nonlinear vertex @xmath139 to _ all _ orders in @xmath140 ( see fig .
[ figdiagrams ] ) .
this observation plays a crucial role in the present problem : since the renormalization of the vertex @xmath139 is given by @xmath141 + 0(\epsilon^2)\ ] ] we may replace the diagrams of the form @xmath142 $ ] in eq .
( [ delta2 ] ) by the scaling part @xmath143 $ ] of eq .
( [ vertexrenorm ] ) , resulting in @xmath144 \,.\ ] ] the linear part of this equation is now exact to all orders in @xmath140 . since @xmath145
we arrive at the conclusion that @xmath108 scales to zero for arbitrary initial states in @xmath146 spatial dimensions .
thus eq .
( [ delta1 ] ) reduces to its scaling part and hence the scaling dimension of @xmath133 is given by @xmath147 depending on the sign of @xmath148 , the loop corrections for the initial particle distribution are _ relevant _ for @xmath149 , _ irrelevant _ for @xmath150 , and _ marginal _ for @xmath36 .
continuously changing exponents usually appear when we modify a model with a marginal parameter which is invariant under rg transformations .
for example , in case of models with infinitely many absorbing states the initial density plays that role @xcite . in our case
the two - point correlation of the field @xmath151 is characterized by @xmath152 for @xmath153 and is left invariant under the coarse - graining rg transformation , where @xmath154 is a growing spatial scale . in the infinite time
limit this scaling crosses over to @xmath155 .
the marginality of the operator @xmath95 requires @xmath156 and hence in the infinite time limit we arrive at @xmath157 in the regime @xmath149 the exponent @xmath3 is related to the scaling dimension @xmath148 as follows .
the particle density is expected to vary in the long time limit as @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the initial particle density . under rescaling ( [ rescaling ] ) the density @xmath6 [ which is essentially the average of @xmath151 ] scales as @xmath161 while the initial density transforms according to @xmath162 . thus scaling invariance of eq .
( [ rhooft ] ) requires that @xmath163 , i.e. , @xmath164 in the irrelevant regime @xmath150 , however , the initial density @xmath165 scales to zero under rg transformations which may be interpreted as an initial state with non - interacting active seeds leading to an increase according to eq .
( [ increase ] ) . combining these results
we arrive at eq .
( [ exactsolution ] ) which is exact to all orders in @xmath140 .
it is interesting to compare the artificial initial states of sect .
[ initcondsection ] with `` natural '' dp scaling states .
scaling invariance predicts that a critical dp process , starting from a fully occupied lattice , evolves towards a state with correlations @xmath166 i.e. , the `` natural '' correlations of the critical dp are given by @xmath167 .
interestingly , the corresponding exponent @xmath168 vanishes .
this means that these correlations characterize a situation where the critical dp process is almost stationary . from the field - theoretical point of view
this is not surprising since @xmath3 is determined solely by the scaling dimension of the initial particle distribution .
nevertheless the result is surprising from the physical point of view since the empty intervals in our artificial initial states are uncorrelated whereas such correlations may exist in dp scaling states .
it seems that these correlations are rather weak @xcite so that states with uncorrelated intervals can be used as an approximation of dp scaling states .
this offers an interesting practical application in dp simulations : instead of starting a critical dp process from random initial conditions and simulating over long transients , one could use the artificial states of sect .
[ initcondsection ] with @xmath169 as an approximation , followed by a short equilibration period to reach the ` true ' scaling state of dp .
in the present work we numerically studied the temporal evolution of a ( 1 + 1)-dimensional critical dp process starting from artificially generated correlated initial states . these states approximate a simple fractal set in which uncorrelated empty intervals are distributed by @xmath170 .
it can be shown that such particle distributions are characterized by long - range correlations of the form @xmath171 where @xmath64 .
the construction of such correlated states is a technically difficult task since lattice spacing and finite - size effects strongly influence the quality of the numerical results , especially close to @xmath172 and @xmath173 . in order to minimize these errors
, we proposed to project an almost perfect fractal set onto the lattice . using these states as initial conditions we determined the density @xmath6 in a critical dp process by mc simulations .
it varies algebraically with an exponent @xmath3 that depends continuously on @xmath4 .
therefore correlated initial conditions affect the _ entire _ temporal evolution of a critical dp process .
the numerical estimates for @xmath24 are in good agreement with theoretical results from a field - theoretical rg calculation ( see fig .
[ kappa ] ) .
discrepancies for small values of @xmath4 can be further reduced by increasing the numerical effort .
the rg calculation is valid for arbitrary spatial dimensions @xmath146 and predicts a critical threshold @xmath35 where @xmath24 starts to vary _ linearly _ between @xmath174 and @xmath175 .
thus our result in eq .
( [ exactsolution ] ) qualitatively reproduces the scenario predicted by bray et .
al . in the context of coarsening processes @xcite .
the exact prediction the critical threshold @xmath27 is possible because of the irrelevance of @xmath108 for arbitrary initial conditions which can be proven by using the formal equivalence of the loop expansions in @xmath139 and @xmath108 .
it is this property that also allows one to express the critical initial slip exponent @xmath109 by an exact scaling relation @xmath176 .
it should be emphasized that some dp models with more complicated dynamical rules violate this scaling relation as , for example , the two - species spreading model discussed in ref . @xcite . in such models the mentioned equivalence of loop expansions in fig .
[ figdiagrams ] is no longer valid .
consequently , the corresponding slip exponent @xmath109 takes a different value so that eq .
( [ exactsolution ] ) has to be modified appropriately .
acknowledgements : we would like to thank m. howard , k. b. lauritsen , n. menyhrd , i. peschel , and u. c. tuber for interesting discussions and helpful hints .
the simulations were performed partially on the fujitsu ap-1000 parallel supercomputer .
g. dor gratefully acknowledges support from the hungarian research fund otka ( nos . t025286 and t023552 ) . | we investigate the influence of correlated initial conditions on the temporal evolution of a ( @xmath0 + 1)-dimensional critical directed percolation process .
generating initial states with correlations @xmath1 we observe that the density of active sites in monte - carlo simulations evolves as @xmath2 .
the exponent @xmath3 depends continuously on @xmath4 and varies in the range @xmath5 .
our numerical results are confirmed by an exact field - theoretical renormalization group calculation . |
the discovery of charged higgs bosons @xcite will provide a concrete evidence of the multi - doublet structure of the higgs sector .
recent efforts have focused on their relevance to supersymmetry ( susy ) , in particular in the mssm , which incorporates exactly two higgs doublets , yielding after spontaneous ew symmetry breaking five physical higgs states : the neutral pseudoscalar ( @xmath11 ) , the lightest ( @xmath4 ) and heaviest ( @xmath12 ) neutral scalars and two charged ones ( @xmath13 ) . in much of the parameter space preferred by susy , namely @xmath14 and @xmath15 @xcite , the lhc will provide the greatest opportunity for the discovery of @xmath13 particles .
in fact , over the above @xmath6 region , the tevatron ( run 2 ) discovery potential is limited to charged higgs masses smaller than @xmath16 @xcite .
however , at the lhc , whereas the detection of light charged higgs bosons ( with @xmath17 ) is rather straightforward in the decay channel @xmath18 for most @xmath6 values , thanks to the huge top - antitop production rate , the search is notoriously difficult for heavy masses ( when @xmath19 ) , because of the large reducible and irreducible backgrounds associated with the main decay mode @xmath20 , following the dominant production channel @xmath21 @xcite .
( notice that the rate of the latter exceeds by far other possible production modes @xcite@xcite , this rendering it the only viable channel at the cern machine in the heavy mass region . ) the analysis of the @xmath20 signature has been the subject of many debates @xcite@xcite , whose conclusion is that the lhc discovery potential is satisfactory , but only provided that @xmath6 is small ( @xmath22 ) or large ( @xmath23 ) enough and the charged higgs boson mass is below 600 gev or so .
a recent analysis @xcite has shown that the @xmath24 decay mode , indeed dominant for light charged higgs states and exploitable below the top threshold for any accessible @xmath6 @xcite , can be used at the lhc even in the large @xmath25 case , in order to discover @xmath13 scalars in the parameter range @xmath26 and 200 gev @xmath27 tev .
besides , if the distinctive @xmath28 polarisation @xcite is used in this channel , the latter can provide at least as good a heavy @xmath13 signature as the @xmath20 decay mode ( for the large @xmath6 regime @xcite ) . at present
then , it is the @xmath29 region of the mssm which ought to be explored through other decay modes , especially those where direct mass reconstruction is possible .
the most obvious of these is the @xmath30 channel @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , proceeding via the production of a charged gauge boson and the lightest higgs scalar of the mssm , with the former on- or off - shell depending on the relative values of @xmath25 and @xmath31 .
in fact , its branching ratio ( br ) can be rather large , competing with the bottom - top decay mode and overwhelming the tau - neutrino one for @xmath32 at low @xmath6 : see figs .
[ fig : brs][fig : brh ] . besides
, under the assumption that the @xmath4 scalar has previously been discovered ( which we embrace here ) , its kinematics is rather constrained , around two resonant decay modes , @xmath33 2 jets ( or lepton - neutrino ) and @xmath1 , an aspect which allows for a significant reduction of the qcd background . as demonstrated in ref .
@xcite , signals of charged higgs bosons in the @xmath34 range can be seen in this channel , provided that 200 gev @xmath35 gev ( see also @xcite for an experimental simulation ) .
the above lower limit on @xmath6 corresponds to the border of the exclusion region drawn from lep2 direct searches for the mssm @xmath4 scalar , whose mass bound is now set at @xmath36 gev or so @xcite .
it is the purpose of this letter that of resuming the studies of ref .
@xcite , by analysing the contribution to the background due to several irreducible processes , not considered there , whose presence could spoil the feasibility of charged higgs searches in the @xmath37 mode of the mssm .
the plan of this paper is as follows . in the next section
we discuss possible signals and backgrounds , their implementation and list the values adopted for the various parameters needed for their computation .
section 3 is devoted to the presentation and discussion of the results .
conclusions are in section 4 .
we generate the signal cross sections by using the formulae of ref .
that is , we implement the @xmath38 matrix element ( me ) for the process @xmath39 this nicely embeds both the @xmath40 subprocess of top - antitop production and decay , which is dominant for @xmath41 , as well as the @xmath42 + c.c .
one of @xmath43-fusion and @xmath13-bremsstrahlung , which is responsible for charged higgs production in the case @xmath44 @xcite . the me of process ( [ signalme ] ) has been computed by means of the spinor techniques of refs .
@xcite@xcite . in the @xmath45 channel , assuming high efficiency and purity in selecting / rejecting @xmath46-/non-@xmath46-jets , possible irreducible background processes are the following ( we consider only the @xmath47-initiated channels ) : 1 .
the @xmath48 continuum ; 2 . @xmath49 production , especially when @xmath50 ; 3 . the qcd induced case @xmath51 ; 4 . and , finally , @xmath52 and @xmath53 intermediate states ; in which @xmath54 , plus their c.c . channels .
once the top quark appearing in the above reactions decays , two @xmath3 bosons are present in each event
. we will eventually assume the @xmath55 pair to decay semi - leptonically to light - quark jets , electrons / muons and corresponding neutrinos .
furthermore , we will require to tag exactly three @xmath46-jets in the final state ( e.g. , by using @xmath56-vertex or high @xmath57 lepton techniques ) .
the same ` signature ' was considered in ref .
@xcite , where only the ` intrinsic ' @xmath58 background and the qcd noise due to ` @xmath59 + jet ' events were studied ( with jet signifying here either a @xmath46- , light - quark or gluon jet , the latter two mistagged for the former ) . both signal and background mes have been integrated numerically by means of vegas @xcite and , for test purposes , of rambo @xcite and metropolis @xcite as well .
while proceeding to the phase space integration , one also has to fold in the @xmath60-dependent parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) for the two incoming gluons .
these have been evaluated at leading - order , by means of the package mrs - lo(05a ) @xcite .
the numerical values of the sm parameters are ( @xmath61 ) : @xmath62 @xmath63 @xmath64 @xmath65 as for the top width @xmath66 , we have used the lo value calculated within the mssm ( i.e. , @xmath67 gev if @xmath68 ) . concerning the mssm parameters , we proceed as follows .
for a start , we assume that the mass of the lightest neutral higgs particle ( but not @xmath6 ) is already known , thanks to its discovery at either lep2 , tevatron ( run 2 ) or from early analyses at the lhc itself . thus , for us , @xmath69 is a fixed parameter , assuming for reference the following discrete values : e.g. , 90 , 100 , 110 , 120 and 130 gev .
then we express all other higgs masses as a function of @xmath25 and @xmath6 . for the pseudoscalar higgs boson mass ,
the tree - level relation @xmath70 is assumed .
radiative corrections then , of arbitrary perturbative order , are in practice embedded in the @xmath12 mass and the mixing angle @xmath71 . in general , notice that , at the ` renormalisation group improved ' one - loop level @xcite , it is only for very large values of the lightest stop mass and of the squark mixing parameters that @xmath2 can escape the lep2 bound in the low @xmath6 region , on which we will focus most of our attention .
finally , notice that we develop our discussion at the parton level , without considering fragmentation and hadronisation effects .
thus , jets are identified with the partons from which they originate and all cuts are applied directly to the latter .
in particular , when selecting @xmath46-jets , a vertex tagging is implied , with a finite efficiency , @xmath72 , per each tag . moreover , we assume no correlations among multiple tags , nor do we include misidentification of light - quark ( including @xmath73-quark-)jets produced in @xmath3 decays as @xmath46-jets .
as a preliminary exercise , we study the total production and decay cross sections before any cuts , as all our reactions are finite over their entire phase spaces ( recall that @xmath74 ) .
this is done in figs .
[ fig : cross90][fig : cross100 ] for the signal and the five background processes discussed in the previous section , for five values of @xmath6 , over the range 140 gev @xmath75 500 gev , for @xmath76 and 100 gev , in the channel @xmath77 , where @xmath78 or @xmath11 .
( of course , the @xmath79 and @xmath80 backgrounds have no dependence on any of the three parameters above[fig : cross100 ] account for the c.c .
production modes as well . ] . ) as for the decay rates of the top ( anti)quark and the @xmath3 boson , for sake of simplicity , we take them equal to @xmath81 for the time being .
the signal is always dominated by the qcd background and at large @xmath6 also by the ew ones . notice the local maxima of the signal rates at @xmath82 , as induced by the opening of the @xmath83 decay ( compare to figs .
[ fig : brs][fig : brh ] ) , and the minima as well , due to the onset of the @xmath20 channel instead . in the reminder of our analysis , we assume semi - leptonic decays of @xmath55 pairs , as in ref .
@xcite : i.e. , @xmath84 ( hereafter , jet refers to a non-@xmath46-jet and @xmath61 ) .
however , as compared to that analysis , we make one simplification .
namely , we assume that _ one _ top ( anti)quark and the @xmath3 boson generated in its decay have already been reconstructed , e.g. , by using the mass selection procedure advocated in ref .
@xcite , either leptonically or hadronically .
this allows us to greatly reduce the complexity of our numerical calculation while we believe substantially un - affecting the relative rates of signal and backgrounds ( in fact , all processes described produce the same final state and all involve at least one top quark ) .
then we apply the following cuts on the remaining particles ( here , the label @xmath85 refers to the decay products of the second @xmath3 boson present in the event , which can be either light - quarks or leptons ) : @xmath86 on the transverse momentum ( including the missing one ) , @xmath87 on the pseudorapidity , and @xmath88 on the relative separation of @xmath46- and light - quark jets / leptons j , where @xmath89 is defined in terms of relative differences in pseudorapidity @xmath90 and azimuth @xmath91 , with @xmath92 , j@xmath93 .
furthermore , we impose ( see also ref .
@xcite ) latexmath:[\[\label{mhcut } @xmath46-jets , @xmath95 on the light - jet ( or lepton - neutrino ) pair ( recall that the @xmath3 can be off - shell ) , and , finally , @xmath96 around the top mass if three @xmath46 s are present in the event ( in addition to the one already used to reconstruct the top ( anti)quark ) . in such a case , one may assume that the charged higgs boson has predominantly been produced in the decay of a top ( anti)quark ( when @xmath97 ) .
if instead only two appear , then one should conclude that the higgs has mainly been generated in a bremsstrahlung / fusion process ( because @xmath32 ) with a @xmath46-(anti)quark lost along the beam pipe .
our @xmath38 production mechanism naturally allows one to emulate both dynamics in a gauge invariant fashion , including all interference effects . as already mentioned , however
, we will assume a triple @xmath46-tagging , this implying an overall efficiency factor of @xmath98 multiplying our signal and background rates .
( thus , the third @xmath46-jet in eq .
( [ mtcut ] ) is actually non-@xmath46-tagged : it can be interpreted as the jet system satisfying neither eq . ( [ mhcut ] ) nor eq.([mwcut ] ) . )
we take @xmath99 , like in @xcite ( and assume 100% lepton identification efficiency ) .
given the signal production rates before acceptance and selection cuts , it is clear that for such an @xmath72 even at high collider luminosity ( i.e. , @xmath100 fb@xmath101 per annum ) , hopes of disentangling the charged higgs boson of the mssm in the @xmath37 decay channel are only confined to the very low @xmath6 region .
we will thus restrict ourselves to study in the reminder of the paper @xmath6 values which are , e.g. , below seven .
the total signal rates after the cuts ( [ pt])([mtcut ] ) have been applied can be found in fig .
[ fig : final ] , for the choices @xmath102 and @xmath103 , as a function of @xmath25 . for reference
, we illustrate the ` borderline ' case @xmath104 gev .
( indeed , a lower @xmath2 value at @xmath105 is in contradiction with lep2 data , whereas higher masses induce a far too large suppression on br(@xmath106 ) : see fig .
[ fig : brh ] . )
the trends in the figure are the consequence of two effects . on the one hand , the production cross section of @xmath107 + c.c .
is roughly proportional to @xmath108 , so that its maxima occur at very low or very high @xmath6 . on the other hand ,
we have seen how the largest @xmath109 decay fraction is attained for @xmath110 . in the end ,
the largest values for @xmath111 + c.c . are obtained for @xmath112 : see fig .
[ fig : final ] .
unfortunately , such a @xmath6 value is already excluded in the mssm from lep2 data @xcite .
for the optimal remaining choice , i.e. , @xmath105 , the annual rate never exceeds 140 events ( before any @xmath46-tagging efficiency but after acceptance and selection cuts ) .
the maximum occurs at @xmath10 gev , significantly above the real threshold at @xmath113 gev .
we now compare such a signal with the irreducible backgrounds 1.4 .
, for the same choice of @xmath6 and @xmath2 ( where relevant ) .
this is done in the upper half of fig .
[ fig : last ] , at the level of total production rates . after the cuts ( [ pt])([mtcut ] ) are enforced ,
all background components in 2.4 . are overwhelmed by the signal in the vicinity of @xmath114 gev , whereas the @xmath0 continuum production is always larger than the @xmath5 resonant channel .
thus , it is relevant to compare the last two processes in the ` reconstructed ' invariant mass @xmath115 , i.e. , that obtained from pairing the two @xmath46-jets fulfilling condition ( [ mhcut ] ) and the two light - quark jets ( or , alternatively , the lepton - neutrino pair ) satisfying eq .
( [ mwcut ] ) and not already reconstructing @xmath116 on their own and @xmath16 in association with any of the @xmath46 s ( see ref .
the spectrum in this variable is presented in the lower half of fig .
[ fig : last ] , for our ideal case @xmath114 gev ( and , again , @xmath105 and @xmath104 gev ) . for such mssm parameter combination ,
the charged higgs signal is well above the continuum for values of @xmath115 which are @xmath117 gev from @xmath25 .
( to vary @xmath25 and/or @xmath6 basically corresponds to rescale the solid line in the last plot by a constant factor , according to the rates in fig .
[ fig : final ] . ) for reference , tab .
[ tab : cuts ] presents the number of events of resonant and continuum @xmath0 production at the lhc , after 300 inverse femtobarns of collected luminosity , for @xmath118 , in the window @xmath119 40 gev , for the three values @xmath120 and 220 gev .
although very small , a @xmath121 signal is generally observable above the @xmath122 continuum for @xmath25 around @xmath123 gev .
our numbers are roughly consistent with those in ref .
@xcite , if one considers that we neglect the finite efficiency of reconstructing one @xmath3 boson and the associated top ( anti)quark and since we have chosen somewhat different cuts .
therefore , in the end , the dominant backgrounds remain ( in the @xmath7-tagged channel ) the @xmath124 + c.c .
decay and the qcd noise involving misidentified gluons , i.e. , those already identified in ref . @xcite .
in summary , in this paper , we have complemented a previous analysis @xcite of the production and decay of charged higgs bosons of the mssm at the lhc , in the channels @xmath107 and @xmath109 ( and charged conjugated modes ) , respectively , by considering several irreducible backgrounds in the @xmath7-tagged channel , i.e. , @xmath125 + c.c .
@xmath126 + ` missing energy ' ( where the initial @xmath46-(anti)quark is usually lost along the beam pipe ) , which had not yet been considered .
we have found that , after standard acceptance cuts and a kinematic selection along the lines of the one outlined in ref .
@xcite , the dominant background among those considered here is the continuum production @xmath127 + c.c .
however , the latter has been found to lie significantly below the signal in the only region where this is detectable : when @xmath128 and @xmath129 gev ( with @xmath2 around 100 gev , close to the latest lep2 constraints )
. thus , the chances of detecting the @xmath130 decay in such a ( narrow ) region of the mssm parameter space depend mainly on the interplay between this mode , the competing one @xmath131 and the qcd background with mistagged gluons , as are the latter two that clearly overwhelm the former ( recall the last figure in @xcite ) .
we have carried out our analysis at parton level , without showering and hadronisation effects but emulating typical detector smearing .
we are confident that its salient features should survive a more sophisticated simulation , such as the one presented in ref .
besides , our results concerning the backgrounds can be transposed to the case of non - minimal susy models ( where the @xmath13 discovery potential can extend to a much larger portion of parameter space ) , such as those considered in ref .
@xcite , so that also in these scenarios the irreducible backgrounds analysed here can be brought under control .
the author is grateful to the uk - pparc for financial support .
furthermore , he thanks d.p .
roy for his remarks , which induced him to eventually considering the subject of this research .
he also thanks k.a .
assamagan for several useful discussions . finally , many conversations with k. odagiri are acknowledged , as well as many numerical comparisons against and the use of some of his programs .
assamagan , atlas internal note atl - phys-99 - 013 ( 1999 ) ; k.a .
assamagan , a. djouadi , m. drees , m. guchait , r. kinnunen , j.l .
kneur , d.j .
miller , s. moretti , k. odagiri and d.p .
roy , contribution to the workshop ` physics at tev colliders ' , les houches , france , 8 - 18 june 1999 , hep - ph/0002258 ( to appear in the proceedings ) .
e. barradas , j.l .
diaz - cruz , a. gutierrez and a. rosado , _ phys .
rev . _ * d53 * ( 1996 ) 1678 ; a. djouadi , j. kalinowski and p.m. zerwas , _ z. phys .
_ * c70 * ( 1996 ) 435 ; e. ma , d.p .
roy and j. wudka , _ phys .
* 80 * ( 1998 ) 1162 .
+ @xmath25 ( gev ) & @xmath125 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 + @xmath123 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 + @xmath141 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 & @xmath103 + + + | we analyse the chances of detecting charged higgs bosons of the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) at the large hadron collider ( lhc ) in the @xmath0 mode , followed by the dominant decay of the lightest higgs scalar , @xmath1 .
if the actual value of @xmath2 is already known , this channel offers possibly the optimal final state kinematics for charged higgs discovery , thanks to the narrow resonances appearing around the @xmath3 and @xmath4 masses . besides , within the mssm
, the @xmath5 decay rate is significant for not too large @xmath6 values , thus offering the possibility of accessing a region of mssm parameter space left uncovered by other search channels .
we consider both strong ( qcd ) and electroweak ( ew ) ` irreducible ' backgrounds in the @xmath7-tagged channel to the @xmath8 production process that had not been taken into account in previous analyses . after a series of kinematic cuts ,
the largest of these processes is @xmath9 production in the continuum .
however , for optimum @xmath6 , i.e. , between 2 and 3 , the charged higgs boson signal overcomes this background and a narrow discovery region survives around @xmath10 gev . 0 pt .7truecm 33by .05 truein .05 truein 1 in 0.75 in 6.125 truein = 100000 # 1 # 2 # 3 _
phys .
lett . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ nucl .
phys . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ z. phys .
_ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ phys .
rev . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ phys .
rep . _
* # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ mod .
phys .
lett . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ rev .
mod .
phys . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ sov .
j. nucl .
phys . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 _ comp .
phys .
comm . _ * # 1 * ( # 2 ) # 3 # 1 # 2 # 3 * # 1 * , ( # 2 ) # 3 ral - tr-2000 - 005 + march 2000
+ * the @xmath0 decay channel + as a probe of charged higgs boson production + at the large hadron collider * + stefano moretti + _ rutherford appleton laboratory , _ + _ chilton , didcot , oxon ox11 0qx , uk . _ |
there is an ever increasing wealth of observational evidence indicating the non - sphericity of almost every type of astronomical object ( e.g. , extended circumstellar environments , novae shells , planetary nebulae , galaxies , and agns ) . to accurately interpret this data
, detailed two- and three - dimensional radiation transfer techniques are required . with the availability of fast workstations , many researchers are turning to monte carlo techniques to produce model images and spectra for the asymmetric objects they are investigating . in monte carlo radiation transfer simulations , packets of energy or `` photons '' are followed as they are scattered and absorbed within a prescribed medium .
one of the features of this technique is that the locations of the packets are known when they are absorbed , so we can determine where their energy is deposited .
this energy heats the medium , and to conserve radiative equilibrium , the absorbed energy must be reradiated at other wavelengths , depending on the opacity sources present . tracking these photon packets , while enforcing radiative equilibrium , permits the calculation of both the temperature structure and emergent spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of the envelope .
the ability of monte carlo techniques to easily follow the transfer of radiation through complex geometries makes them very attractive methods for determining the temperature structure within non - spherical environments a task which is very difficult with traditional ray tracing techniques .
previous work on this problem for spherical geometries includes the approximate solutions by scoville & kwan ( 1976 ) , who ignored scattering , leung ( 1976 ) , and diffusion approximations by yorke ( 1980 ) .
the spherically symmetric problem has been solved exactly by rowan - robinson ( 1980 ) , wolfire & cassinelli ( 1986 ) , and ivezi & elitzur ( 1997 ) , who used a scaling technique .
extensions of the exact solution to two dimensions have been performed by efstathiou & rowan - robinson ( 1990 , 1991 ) , while approximate two - dimensional models have been presented by sonnhalter , preibisch , & yorke ( 1995 ) and menshchikov & henning ( 1997 ) .
radiative equilibrium calculations using the monte carlo technique have been presented by lefevre , bergeat , & daniel ( 1982 ) ; lefevre , daniel , & bergeat ( 1983 ) ; wolf , henning , & secklum ( 1999 ) ; and lucy ( 1999 ) .
most of these authors ( lucy being exceptional ) use a technique in which stellar and envelope photon packets are emitted separately .
the number of envelope packets to be emitted is determined by the envelope temperature , while the envelope temperature is determined by the number of absorbed packets .
consequently these techniques require iteration , usually using the absorbed stellar photons to provide an initial guess for the envelope temperature .
the iteration proceeds until the envelope temperatures converge .
note that the stellar luminosity is not automatically conserved during the simulation ; only after the temperatures converge is the luminosity approximately conserved .
in contrast , lucy adopts a strategy in which absorbed photon packets are immediately re - emitted , using a frequency distribution set by the current envelope temperature .
although the frequency distribution of the reprocessed photons is incorrect ( until the temperatures have converged ) , his method automatically enforces local radiative equilibrium and implicitly conserves the stellar luminosity .
the insight of lucy s method is that conservation of the stellar luminosity is more important than the spectral energy distribution when calculating the radiative equilibrium temperatures .
nonetheless , this method requires iteration .
the primary problem faced by lucy s method is the incorrect frequency distribution of the re - emitted photons . in this paper
we develop an adaptive monte carlo technique that corrects the frequency distribution of the re - emitted photons .
essentially , our method relaxes to the correct frequency and temperature distribution .
furthermore it requires no iteration as long as the opacity is independent of temperature .
such is the case for astrophysical dust . in section 2
, we describe the temperature correction algorithm .
we compare the results of our code with a spherically symmetric code in section 3 , and in section 4 we present results for two dimensional axisymmetric density structures .
we wish to develop a method to calculate the temperature distribution throughout an extended dusty environment for use with monte carlo simulations of the radiation transfer .
the radiation transfer technique we employ has been described in detail in other papers : code & whitney ( 1995 ) ; whitney & hartmann ( 1992 , 1993 ) ; wood et al .
( 1996 ) , so we only summarize it here .
the basic idea is to divide the luminosity of the radiation source into equal - energy , monochromatic `` photon packets '' that are emitted stochastically by the source .
these packets are followed to random interaction locations , determined by the optical depth , where they are either scattered or absorbed with a probability given by the albedo .
if the packet is scattered , a random scattering angle is obtained from the scattering phase function ( differential cross section ) .
if instead the packet is absorbed , its energy is added to the envelope , raising the local temperature . to conserve energy and enforce radiative equilibrium ,
the packet is re - emitted immediately at a new frequency determined by the envelope temperature .
these re - emitted photons comprise the diffuse radiation field . after either scattering or absorption plus reemission
, the photon packet continues to a new interaction location .
this process is repeated until all the packets escape the dusty environment , whereupon they are placed into frequency and direction - of - observation bins that provide the emergent spectral energy distribution . since all the injected packets eventually escape ( either by scattering or absorption followed by reemission ) , this method implicitly conserves total energy .
furthermore it automatically includes the diffuse radiation field when calculating both the temperature structure and the emergent spectral energy distribution .
we now describe in detail how we calculate the temperature structure and seds of dusty environments illuminated by a radiation source .
this radiation can come from any astrophysical source , either internal or external , point - like or extended .
initially we divide the source luminosity , @xmath1 , into @xmath2 photon packets emitted over a time interval @xmath3 .
each photon packet has the same energy , @xmath4 , so @xmath5 note that the number of physical photons in each packet is frequency - dependent .
when the monochromatic photon packet is injected into the envelope , it will be assigned a random frequency chosen from the spectral energy distribution of the source .
this frequency determines the dust absorptive opacity , @xmath6 , and scattering opacity , @xmath7 ( both per mass ) , as well as the scattering parameters for the ensuing random walk of the packet through the envelope .
the envelope is divided into spatial grid cells with volume @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the cell index .
as we inject source photon packets , we maintain a running total , @xmath10 , of how many packets are absorbed in each grid cell .
whenever a packet is absorbed in a grid cell , we deposit its energy in the cell and recalculate the cell s temperature . the total energy absorbed in the cell
@xmath11 we assume that the dust particles are in local thermodynamic equilibrium ( lte ) , and for simplicity we adopt a single temperature for the dust grains . note that although we use dust for the continuous opacity source , we could replace the dust by any continuous lte opacity source that is independent of temperature . in radiative equilibrium , the absorbed energy , @xmath12 ,
must be reradiated .
the thermal emissivity of the dust @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the planck function at temperature @xmath15 , so the emitted energy is @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the planck mean opacity , and @xmath18 is the frequency integrated planck function .
if we adopt a temperature that is constant throughout the grid cell , @xmath19 , then @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the mass of the cell . equating the absorbed ( [ eq : eabs ] ) and emitted ( [ eq : eem ] ) energies , we find that after absorbing @xmath10 packets , the dust temperature is given by @xmath22 note that the planck mean opacity , @xmath23 , is a function of temperature , so equation ( [ eq : retemp ] ) is actually an implicit equation for the temperature , which must be solved _ every time a packet is absorbed_. since this equation is solved so many times , an efficient algorithm is desirable . fortunately @xmath23 is a slowly varying function of temperature , which implies a simple iterative algorithm may be used to solve equation ( [ eq : retemp ] ) .
to do so efficiently , we pre - tabulate the planck mean opacities for a large range of temperatures and evaluate @xmath24 by interpolation , using the temperature from the previous guess .
after a few steps , we have the solution for @xmath19 .
note that because the dust opacity is temperature - independent , the product @xmath25 , which is proportional to @xmath26 , increases monotonically with temperature .
consequently @xmath19 always increases when the cell absorbs an additional packet . now that we know the temperature after absorbing an additional packet within the cell , we must reradiate this energy so that the heating always balances the cooling . prior to absorbing this packet ,
the cell previously has emitted packets that carried away an energy corresponding to the cell s previous emissivity @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the temperature increase arising from the packet absorption .
note that these previous packets were emitted with an incorrect frequency distribution corresponding to the previous temperature , @xmath29 .
the total energy that should be radiated now corresponds to @xmath30 at the new temperature , @xmath19 .
thus the additional energy to be carried away is given by @xmath31 \ ; , \label{eq : deltakappab}\ ] ] which is the shaded area shown in figure [ fig : tempcorrect ] . as long as the packet energy @xmath4 is not too large ( this may be assured by choosing a large enough number of photon packets , @xmath2 , to use for the simulation ) , the temperature change @xmath28 is small , so the temperature correction spectrum @xmath32 note that @xmath33 is everywhere positive because @xmath34 , and the planck function is a monotonically increasing function of temperature . therefore to correct the previously emitted spectrum
, we immediately re - emit the packet ( to conserve energy ) , and we choose its frequency using the shape of @xmath33 .
this procedure statistically reproduces @xmath33 for the distribution of the re - emitted packets .
normalizing this distribution , we find the temperature correction probability distribution @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the probability of re - emitting the packet between frequencies @xmath37 and @xmath38 , and the normalization constant @xmath39 . now that the packet s frequency has changed , we change the opacity and scattering parameters accordingly and continue with scattering , absorption , temperature correction , and re - emission until all the photon packets finally escape from the system . in principle
we could also account for back - warming of the source .
whenever a packet hits the source , the source must reradiate this new energy .
this will change the temperature of the source , and the new source photons can be emitted using a difference spectrum similar to equation ( [ eq : tcorrect ] ) .
when we begin our calculation , no packets have been absorbed , so the initial temperature is zero throughout the envelope .
this means that the initial temperature change is not small as is required by equation ( [ eq : deltajnu ] ) .
one could use equation ( [ eq : deltakappab ] ) to re - emit the first packet that is absorbed ; however , this is not necessary .
the number of packets producing this initial temperature change is small ; it is of order the number of spatial grid cells .
furthermore , these packets generally are re - emitted at such long wavelengths that they are not observable .
consequently the error arising from using equation ( [ eq : deltajnu ] ) to re - emit every packet is too small to be of importance .
as the simulation runs , the envelope starts at zero temperature .
it then heats up , and the radiation field `` relaxes '' to its final spectral shape .
the temperature correction procedure is simply a way of re - ordering the calculation ( which frequencies are being used at a given moment ) so that in the end , all the frequencies have been properly sampled .
consequently , after all the stellar photon packets have been transported , the final envelope temperature is the correct radiative equilibrium temperature , and the emergent spectral energy distribution has the correct frequency shape .
furthermore , the photon re - emission automatically accounts for the diffuse envelope emission .
note that energy is necessarily conserved , and there is no time - consuming iteration in our scheme ; calculating the radiative equilibrium temperature requires no more computational time than an equivalent pure scattering calculation in which the temperature structure is held fixed .
similarly , there is no issue of convergence in our method . unlike @xmath0-iteration
, the photon packets carry energy over large distances throughout the envelope because they are never destroyed , and of course there is no iteration at all . after running @xmath2 packets
, we have the final answer .
the simulation does not continue running until some convergence criterion is met , and the only source of error in the calculation is the statistical sampling error inherent in monte carlo simulations .
to validate our method for determining the radiative equilibrium temperatures and emergent fluxes , we compared our results against a set of benchmark calculations recently developed by ivezi ' c et al .
( 1997 ) for testing spherically symmetric dust radiative equilibrium codes .
the parameters listed by ivezi ' c et al . enable us to exactly reproduce the same set of physical conditions ( i.e , input spectrum , dust destruction radius , optical depth , opacity frequency distribution , and radial density structure ) . for all benchmark tests , ivezi ' c et al .
used a point source star , radiating with a black body spectrum whose temperature @xmath40k .
the dust density distribution was a power law with radius , @xmath41 where @xmath42 the inner radius of the envelope is the dust destruction radius , @xmath43 , the outer radius is @xmath44 , and the total radial optical depth is @xmath45 , specified at @xmath46 .
the dust absorptive opacity , @xmath6 , and scattering opacity , @xmath7 , were taken to be @xmath47 since the total optical depth at @xmath48 is independently specified , these opacities have been normalized to that at @xmath49 for convenience .
the wavelength - dependent scattering albedo is given by @xmath50 , and the scattering was assumed to be isotropic ( note that in dust simulations , we would normally use a non - isotropic phase function for the scattering ) . in principle , the inner radius of the dust shell , @xmath43 , is determined by the dust condensation temperature , chosen by ivezi ' c et al . to be @xmath51 .
however , we are only testing the temperature correction procedure , so we have not implemented a scheme to solve self consistently for the dust destruction radius .
the values for @xmath43 were calculated instead using ivezi ' c et al.s eq .
( 4 ) and data from their table 1 . finally
, the outer radius of the dust shell was set to be @xmath52 .
the parameters describing the various test simulations are summarized in table [ table : benchmarkparms ] .
lcccc 0 & 1 & 8.44 0 & 10 & 8.46 0 & 100 & 8.60 2 & 1 & 9.11 2 & 10 & 11.37 2 & 100 & 17.67 [ table : benchmarkparms ] lcccc 1000 & 10 & 200 & 0.2 1000 & 10 & 20 & 0.02 10 & 10 & 200 & 20 10 & 10 & 20 & 2 [ table : ellipsoidparms ] to begin the simulation , we release stellar photon packets with a black body frequency distribution , given by the normalized planck function @xmath53 where @xmath54 . a particularly simple method for sampling the black body distribution is given by carter & cashwell ( 1975 ) .
since this reference is somewhat obscure and difficult to obtain , we summarize the method here .
first , generate a uniform random number , @xmath55 , in the range 0 to 1 , and determine the minimum value of @xmath56 , @xmath57 , that satisfies the condition @xmath58 next obtain four additional uniform random numbers ( in the range 0 to 1 ) , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , and @xmath62 .
finally , the packet frequency is given by @xmath63 after emitting these packets from the star , we track them through the envelope . to determine the envelope temperature , we must count how many packets are absorbed in each grid cell . since the envelope is spherically symmetric , we employ a set of spherical shells for our grid . to obtain the best poisson error statistics , we should ideally construct the grid positions so that equal numbers of packets are absorbed in each cell . since the probability of absorbing a photon packet is proportional to the optical depth ,
we choose equal radial optical depth grid locations , @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the total number of cells we used , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 . integrating the density , eq .
( [ eq : rho ] ) , over the cell volume to obtain the mass , we find from eq .
( [ eq : retemp ] ) that the temperature in each grid cell is given by @xmath68 } \over { 4 n_\gamma \tau_{1\mu{\rm m } } [ ( i^2-i+1/3)\delta r^2+(2i-1)\delta r+1 ] } } & ( $ p=0$),\cr { { n_i(n_f - i)(n_f - i+1)(r_\star / r_{\rm dust})^2 ( 1-r_{\rm dust}/r_{\rm max } ) } \over { 4 n_\gamma \tau_{1\mu{\rm m } } n_f [ \kappa_p(t_i ) / ( \kappa_{1\mu{\rm m}}+\sigma_{1\mu{\rm m } } ) ] } } & ( $ p=2$),\cr}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath69 for the stellar luminosity .
we then proceed with the radiation transfer , temperature calculation , and reemission as described in section 2 until all packets exit the envelope .
when the packets escape , they are placed into @xmath70 uniform frequency bins , @xmath71 where @xmath72 . the width of each bin @xmath73 . since the envelope is spherically symmetric , the observed flux @xmath74 , where @xmath75 is the number of packets in the @xmath76 frequency bin , and @xmath77 is the observer s distance from the star
normalizing to the total flux , @xmath78 , the sed is given by @xmath79 the factor @xmath80 arises from using the frequency at the center of the bin . in figures [ fig : benchmarksed ] and [ fig : benchmarktemp ] we show the results of our simulation compared with the output of one of the codes tested by ivezi et al .
this code , called dusty , is publicly available and is described in ivezi & elitzur ( 1997 ) .
we see that our monte carlo calculations reproduce both the correct temperature structure and sed .
note the large errors at the longest and shortest wavelengths in the monte carlo calculations . at these wavelengths , the number of emerging packets is small , resulting in large errors ( the relative error in each flux bin equals @xmath81 , owing to the poisson sampling statistics inherent in monte carlo simulations ) .
the excellent agreement of the comparisons shown in figures 2a and 2b ( the differences are smaller than the numerical error of the dusty calculations ) demonstrates the validity of our temperature correction procedure described in section 2 .
now that we have verified our our basic radiative equilibrium algorithm , we can proceed to investigate the temperature structure and seds of other geometries . owing to the inherently three - dimension nature of monte carlo simulations ( even our 1-d spherically symmetric code internally tracks the photon packets in three dimensions ) ,
our code is readily modified for arbitrary geometries .
we now show the results of an application to axisymmetric circumstellar environments .
for the purpose of this illustrative simulation , we adopt a stellar blackbody with @xmath82 , envelope inner radius @xmath83 , and a simple ellipsoidal parameterization for the circumstellar density .
the isodensity contours are elliptical with @xmath84 being the ratio of the semi - major to semi - minor axis .
the density is given by @xmath85 where @xmath86 is given by eq .
( [ eq : rho0 ] ; @xmath87 case ) , @xmath88 is the polar angle , and the `` flattening factor '' @xmath89 note that the equatorial to polar density ratio at a given radius is @xmath90 . as before ,
we divide the circumstellar environment into cells with @xmath91 radial and @xmath92 latitudinal grid points .
note that the envelope is symmetric about the equator , so we combine the cells below the equator with their counterparts above the equator .
this is automatically accomplished by using @xmath93 for the latitudinal grid point coordinate .
spacing the grid so that the radial and latitudinal optical depths are the same for each cell , we find @xmath94 with these cell coordinates , equation ( [ eq : retemp ] ) for the temperature in cell @xmath95 becomes @xmath96 [ \tan^{-1}(f\mu_{j-1})-\tan^{-1}(f\mu_{j } ) ] } } \ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath97 is the number of packets absorbed in the cell , and we have chosen @xmath98 ( @xmath99-band ) for our equatorial radial optical depth parameter , @xmath100 . for the dust opacity , we adopt a standard mrn interstellar grain mixture ( mathis , rumpl , & nordsieck 1977 ) , using optical constants from draine & lee ( 1984 ) .
figure [ fig : dustopac ] shows the opacity and albedo in graphical form . the data for this figure is available in tabular form from the dusty web site , http://www.pa.uky.edu/@xmath101moshe/dusty .
note the prominent silicate absorption features at @xmath102 m and @xmath103 m .
for the current demonstration , we assume that the scattering is isotropic , but we can easily accommodate any phase function , analytic or tabulated when calculating the emergent sed . unlike the spherically symmetric benchmarks , the sed now depends on viewing angle ,
so we must bin the escaping packets both in direction and frequency .
since the envelope is axisymmetric , the observed flux only depends on the inclination angle , @xmath9 , of the envelope symmetry axis ( i.e. , the stellar rotation axis ) . to obtain approximately equal numbers of escaping packets
, we choose @xmath104 direction bins , with equal solid angles , @xmath105 .
the escaping directions ( inclination angles ) , @xmath106 , for these bins are given by @xmath107 where @xmath108 .
in addition to the direction bins , we use the frequency bins given by eq .
( [ eq : freqbins ] ) .
now that we have specified both the direction and frequency bins , the observed flux is @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the number of escaping packets in the @xmath111 bin .
normalizing to the bolometric flux f gives the emergent sed , @xmath112 we now choose to investigate the seds produced by two density structures with different degrees of flattening .
the first has a density ratio @xmath113 to represent a disk - like structure .
the second has a density ratio @xmath114 , which is mildly oblate , representative of an infalling protostellar envelope . for each density structure , we perform optically thick ( in the mid - ir ) and optically thin calculations .
the optically thick calculations have an equatorial @xmath99-band optical depth @xmath115 , while the optically thin calculations have @xmath116 . table [ table : ellipsoidparms ] summarizes these density structures . for comparison , we also have performed calculations for @xmath87 spherically symmetric models containing the same total mass as our disk and envelope densities . keeping the same inner and outer radii ,
the optical depth for the equivalent spherical model is @xmath117 figure [ fig : disksed ] shows the incident stellar spectrum and the emergent sed as a function of viewing angle for the disk - like model , as well as the result of the equivalent spherically symmetric calculation . for both disk simulations ,
when viewing the system pole - on , we are looking through optically thin circumstellar dust ( see table [ table : ellipsoidparms ] ) and can see the star at optical wavelengths . in the ir , there is an excess arising from the circumstellar disk , which reprocesses the stellar radiation .
note that , for pole - on viewing , we see the silicate features in emission , since the disk is optically thin in the vertical direction . as we go to higher viewing angles , the optical depth to the central star increases , and as a result
, the star becomes more extincted in the optical region .
note that at almost edge - on viewing , a `` shoulder '' appears around @xmath118 m for the optically thick case .
this arises due to the dominant effects of scattering the stellar radiation at these wavelengths .
these scattering shoulders are also present in the axisymmetric calculations presented by efstathiou & rowan - robinson ( 1991 ) , sonnhalter et al .
( 1995 ) , menschikov & henning ( 1997 ) , and dalessio et al .
( 1999 ) . at wavelengths
longer than about @xmath118 m , the albedo begins to drop rapidly ( see fig . [
fig : dustopac ] ) , and the disk thermal emission begins to dominate , so the shoulder terminates . beyond @xmath119 m ,
the envelope becomes optically thin , so the spectrum is independent of inclination and is dominated by the dust emission .
the two dimensional temperature structure for the disk - like models is displayed in figure 4b .
we see that at the inner edge of the envelope ( @xmath43 ) there is little variation of the temperature with latitude , while at large radii there is a clear latitudinal temperature gradient , with the dust in the denser equatorial regions being cooler than dust at high latitudes . in the polar region ,
the material is optically thin to the stellar radiation , so it heats up to the optically thin radiative equilibrium temperature .
this temperature has a power law behavior , @xmath120 for dust opacity ( @xmath121 ) .
as can be seen in figure [ fig : disktemp ] , the polar temperature does indeed have a power law decrease with a slope of approximately @xmath122 .
in contrast , the disk only displays this power law behavior at large radii . at the inner edge of the disk ,
the disk sees the same mean ( stellar ) intensity as is present in the polar region ( @xmath123 , where @xmath124^{1/2}\}$ ] is the dilution factor ) .
consequently , the inner edge of the disk heats up to the optically thin radiative equilibrium temperature the same as the polar temperature .
however at larger radii , the opaque material in the inner regions of the disk shields the outer regions from direct heating by the stellar radiation .
this shielding reduces the mean intensity ( @xmath125 ) . as a result ,
the outer disk is only heated to a fraction of the optically thin radiative equilibrium temperature .
thus the equatorial region is cooler than the polar region . eventually at large enough radii ,
the disk becomes optically thin to the heating radiation . at that point
, it sees a radially streaming radiation field from an effective photosphere that has a much lower temperature than the star . from that point
outward , the disk temperature displays an optically thin power law decrease with a slope that parallels the polar temperature .
the spherically symmetric calculation overestimates both the emergent flux and the disk temperature . in the optically thin limit ,
the ir continuum is proportional to the mass of the circumstellar material , so one would expect that a spherically equivalent mass would reproduce the long wavelength spectrum .
recall however that we can see the star at pole - on viewing angles .
this implies that the disk does not reprocess the entire bolometric luminosity of the star .
consequently , the ir excess is less than that in the spherical model .
note that one can nonetheless reproduce the edge - on sed using a spherical model if we allow the density power law to depart from @xmath126 and change the size of the spherical envelope .
this also was noted by sonnhalter et al .
( 1997 ) , who found that they could fit the ir continuum of their disk models by changing the radial dependence of the circumstellar density and the outer radius for the same total envelope mass .
the spectral energy distribution and temperature structure for the oblate envelope are shown in figures [ fig : envelopesed ] and [ fig : envelopetemp ] . the optically thin envelope displays significant extinction of the star at all viewing angles .
close to edge - on , scattering shoulders appear around @xmath118 m that are similar to those seen in the disk model ( fig .
[ fig : disksed ] ) . finally , because the model is optically thin in the mid - ir , the silicate feature is always in emission , and the sed is independent of viewing angle for wavelengths longer than a few microns . for the denser envelope ,
the star is extremely faint at optical wavelengths . along with
the increased extinction in the optical , the scattering shoulders are less prominent , due to the thermal emission by the envelope . in the mid - ir ,
the envelope is optically thick edge - on and optically thin pole - on .
consequently , the silicate features go from absorption to emission as the viewing angle changes from edge - on to pole - on .
the general shape of the seds , which now peak in the mid - ir for all inclinations , are reminiscent of spectra from embedded ( class i ) t tauri stars , which are commonly modeled using flattened axisymmetric dusty envelopes ( e.g. , adams , lada , & shu 1987 ; kenyon , calvet , & hartmann 1993 ; menshchikov & henning 1997 ; dalessio , calvet , & hartmann 1997 ) . of these t tauri simulations ,
only efstathiou & rowan - robinson ( 1991 ) have performed an exact calculation for the sed and circumstellar temperature for the terebey , shu , & cassen ( 1984 ) collapse model . the temperature structure for our envelope models ( fig . [ fig : envelopetemp ] )
is qualitatively similar to the temperature structure of the disk models ( fig .
[ fig : disktemp ] ) .
the temperature at the inner edge of the envelope is independent of latitude , while at larger radii the equatorial regions are cooler than the polar regions .
the primary difference is that the latitudinal temperature gradient is not as extreme .
finally , we note that the equivalent spherically symmetric model better reproduces the far ir spectrum of the envelope models than the disk models .
this is because the envelope models reprocess the entire bolometric luminosity , while in disk models , some of the stellar luminosity escapes through the polar region .
we have developed a temperature correction procedure for use in monte carlo radiation transfer codes .
we have tested our method against other spherically symmetric benchmark codes and successfully matched their results . after verifying our method
, we applied it to obtain sample temperature distributions and seds for 2-d axisymmetric disk - like models and mildly oblate envelopes .
these simulations illustrate the important role envelope geometry can play when interpreting the seds of embedded sources .
the primary limitation of our temperature correction procedure is that it only applies if the opacity is independent of temperature .
this is not true for free - free opacity or hydrogen bound - free opacity , but it is true for dust opacity , which is the dominant opacity source in many astrophysical situations .
the reason our method is limited to temperature - independent opacities is that two associated problems occur if the opacity varies when the cell s temperature changes .
the first is that the cell will have absorbed either too many or too few of the previous packets passing through the cell .
the second is the associated change in the interaction locations of the previous packets , which implies that the paths of the previous photon packets should have been different .
these problems do not occur if the opacity is independent of temperature .
lucy ( 1999 ) has proposed a slightly different method to calculate the equilibrium temperature . instead of sampling photon absorption
, he directly samples the photon density ( equivalent to the mean intensity ) by summing the path length of all packets that pass through a cell .
typically more packets pass through a cell than are absorbed in the cell , so this method potentially produces a more accurate measurement of the temperature for a given total number of packets , especially when the envelope is very optically thin .
the disadvantage of his method is that it requires iteration to determine the envelope temperature . in principle
one could partially combine both methods .
first , run our simulation , adding pathlength counters to each cell . after running all packets , use the pathlength information to calculate a final temperature .
this will provide a more accurate temperature that can be used to calculate the source function .
after obtaining the source function for each cell , it is a simple matter to integrate the transfer equation to obtain the sed .
another limitation of the monte carlo method is that it is not well suited to envelopes with very high optical depths ( @xmath127 1000 ) , unless there is an escape channel for the photons .
for example , geometrically thin disks can be extremely optically thick in the radial direction but optically thin in the polar direction , providing an escape channel for the photons .
similarly , dense envelopes can be very optically thick to the illumination source , but optically thin to the reprocessed radiation , which is a another escape channel . in the event no such escape channels exist
, one must turn to other methods .
we are currently investigating how to couple monte carlo simulation in the optically thinner regions with other methods in the optically thick interior .
the focus of the present paper has been on the development and implementation of the temperature correction procedure . for this reason
, we have made several simplifying assumptions regarding the circumstellar opacity and geometry .
for example , we have assumed a single temperature for all dust grains regardless of their size and composition .
this differs from other investigations where different types of grains can have different temperatures at the same spatial location ( e.g. , the spherically symmetric radiation transfer code developed by wolfire & cassinelli 1986 ) .
similarly , we have not implemented a procedure to solve for the location of the dust destruction radius , which will be different for grains of differing size and composition .
these issues are currently under investigation . with the speed of today
s computers , monte carlo radiation transfer simulations can be performed in a reasonably short time .
the 2-d simulations presented in this paper employed @xmath128 packets , requiring about two hours of cpu time ; the spherically symmetric cases used @xmath129 packets , requiring about one minute .
so for continuum transfer , monte carlo simulation is proving to be a very powerful technique for investigating arbitrary density structures and illuminations .
we would like to thank barbara whitney and mrio magalhes for many discussions relating to this work .
an anonymous referee also provided thoughtful comments which helped improved the clarity of our presentation .
this work has been funded by nasa grants nag5 - 3248 , nag5 - 6039 , and nsf grant ast-9819928 . | we describe a general radiative equilibrium and temperature correction procedure for use in monte carlo radiation transfer codes with sources of temperature - independent opacity , such as astrophysical dust .
the technique utilizes the fact that monte carlo simulations track individual photon packets , so we may easily determine where their energy is absorbed .
when a packet is absorbed , it heats a particular cell within the envelope , raising its temperature . to enforce radiative equilibrium ,
the absorbed packet is immediately re - emitted .
to correct the cell temperature , the frequency of the re - emitted packet is chosen so that it corrects the temperature of the spectrum previously emitted by the cell .
the re - emitted packet then continues being scattered , absorbed , and re - emitted until it finally escapes from the envelope .
as the simulation runs , the envelope heats up , and the emergent spectral energy distribution ( sed ) relaxes to its equilibrium value , _ without iteration_. this implies that the equilibrium temperature calculation requires no more computation time than the sed calculation of an equivalent pure scattering model with fixed temperature .
in addition to avoiding iteration , our method conserves energy exactly , because all injected photon packets eventually escape .
furthermore , individual packets transport energy across the entire system because they are never destroyed .
this long - range communication , coupled with the lack of iteration , implies that our method does not suffer the convergence problems commonly associated with @xmath0-iteration . to verify our temperature correction procedure
, we compare our results to standard benchmark tests , and finally we present the results of simulations for two - dimensional axisymmetric density structures . |
in the past a lot of emphasis has been put on studying the radio variability of radio - loud agn and specifically those of blazars @xcite . there
the radio emission is most certainly due to a relativistically beamed jet and one goal of multi - wavelength monitoring , including radio , is to understand particle acceleration processes in the jet plasma as well as the relativistic effects associated with the changing geometry and structure of jets . on the other hand , for radio - weak agn
here meant to include everything but radio - loud quasars the situation is somewhat different and the database is much sparser .
in fact , very few surveys exist that address the issue of radio variability in either radio - quiet quasars or low - luminosity agn such as liners and dwarf - seyferts ( e.g. , ) . in many of these cases we are not even entirely sure that the radio emission is indeed related to the agn itself .
it has been proposed that radio jets are a natural product of agn , even that accretion flow and jet form a symbiotic system @xcite , and this view seems to catch on ( e.g. , ) .
this also implies a prediction for radio emission from nuclear jets across the astrophysical spectrum of agn , including those being of low power or being radio - weak @xcite . for radio - quiet quasars
some evidence exists that this is indeed the case , like the finding of optical / radio correlations ( e.g. , ) , or the detection of high - brightness temperature radio cores in a few radio - quiet quasars @xcite .
clearly , if ( some of ) the radio - emission in radio - weak agn is coming from the central engine , we would expect to see a certain degree of radio variability as seen in other wavebands . finding this
would , firstly , confirm the agn nature of the radio emission and , secondly , allow us to study the link between accretion flows and radio jet in more detail . in a symbiotic picture of accretion disk and radio jet
one would expect to see a change in the accretion rate first reflected in a change in optical emission and then later in a change in the radio emission .
the type of radio variability found in radio - weak agn should also depend on whether or not the jets are relativistic and whether or not they are pointing towards the observer .
to start addressing some of these questions we have started a number of projects targeted at different classes of agn mainly radio - quiet quasars and liners . in the following
we will present a report of first and preliminary results of these projects .
to study the radio - variability of quasars we selected a sample of thirty sources from the pg quasar sample @xcite , the lbqs sample @xcite , and the nvss @xcite .
the sources were selected to give a detectable flux density at 3.6 cm ( 8.5 ghz ) above 0.3 mjy and to roughly equally fill the parameter space of the radio - to - optical flux ratio ( @xmath0 ) , including radio - quiet ( rqq , @xmath1 ) , radio - intermediate ( riq , @xmath2 ) , and radio - loud quasars ( rlq , @xmath3 , see ) . in the end we had 10 , 13 , and 7 objects respectively in each category .
the quasars were observed with the vla roughly every month for eight epochs and then at one more epoch a year later .
integration times varied between 2 and 12 minutes .
where applicable , i.e. for some radio - loud quasars , we picked out the compact core and ignored emission from the extended lobes .
the other sources appeared point - like on the maps .
[ lcurve ] a few sample light curves are shown in figure 1 .
error bars include statistical and systematic ( calibration uncertainties ) errors .
the figure shows that in some cases we have distinct flux density variations within one year . despite the rather low , i.e. milli - jansky , flux density level we are able to clearly trace the variations from month to month in some of these galaxies . for comparison
we also show one rather faint quasar where we consistently measure a constant flux density from epoch to epoch .
this demonstrates that measuring radio - variability even in radio quiet quasars is not too much of a daunting task anymore .
[ rqqvar ] the overall result of our survey is shown in fig . 2 , where we plot a debiased variability index @xmath4 against the @xmath0-parameter .
the index is defined here as @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the number of data points , @xmath7 is the measurement error , and @xmath8 is the mean flux density ( see ) .
we set the index to be negative when the value inside the square root becomes negative ( i.e. , for non - variable sources where the error bars are too conservative ) . in about 80% of the sources we find at least some marginal evidence for variability .
the variability index is about 10 - 20% in the rqqs and riqs and only a few percent for rlqs .
most of the radio cores in the riqs and rlqs have flat to inverted radio spectra and there may be a trend for higher variability with more inverted spectra .
we point out , that our sample does not include blazars .
however , many of our phase calibrators naturally are .
surprisingly , these heterogeneously selected calibrators do show a variability that is not too distinct from the rlqs & riqs in our sample .
the nature of riqs had been discussed in the literature before . and had suggested that they could be the relativistically boosted counter - parts to radio - quiet quasars . and
indeed three out of the two riqs discussed by , iii zw 2 and pg2209 + 18 , are included here and show some of the highest variability amplitudes observed in our survey .
recently detected superluminal expansion a clear indication of relativistic motion in the former .
the fact that we find similarly strong variability in some rqqs could also point to the activity of relativistic jets .
clearly , since the radio emission at centimeter wavelengths should come from the parsec scale ( because of self - absorption arguments , e.g. , ) a variability timescale of months could not be achieved by jets with highly sub - luminal speeds .
overall , the finding of variability in many rqqs and riqs strengthens the conclusion that the radio emission detected in these quasars is indeed produced by the agn .
the rather low level of variability in the cores of radio - loud quasars is rather puzzling and might be related to larger black hole masses and thus longer timescales .
the absence of relativistic beaming due to larger inclination angles ( in contrast to blazars ) and perhaps the presence of slow - moving cocoons surrounding the inner fast jets ( e.g. , cygnus a , ) could also play a role .
another group of agn for which radio variability has not been studied in a coherent fashion are low - luminosity agn ( llagn ) .
almost a third of all galaxies in our cosmic neighborhood show evidence for low - level nuclear activity in emission lines , i.e. show liner or seyfert spectra @xcite . in many of these cases
it is not entirely clear whether the activity is due to stars or a central black hole .
we have used the vla and vlba to observe two samples of nearby llagn .
one of them was a distance - limited sample of llagn within 19 mpc , the other consisted of a collection of 48 well - studied liners and a few dwarf - seyferts .
the vla survey revealed a remarkable high detection rate of compact radio cores at 15 ghz @xcite .
initial vlba observations of the smaller sample confirm that these sources have high brightness temperature radio cores indicative of agn @xcite .
for the sources in our combined samples with flux densities above 3 mjy at 15 ghz and a flat radio spectrum we have now a 100% detection rate with vlbi @xcite .
this shows that a large fraction ( @xmath950% ) of liners and dwarf - seyferts are indeed genuine agn .
in addition , having two frequencies and in some cases more , we find no evidence for highly inverted radio cores as predicted in the adaf model : the ( non - simultaneous ) spectral indices are on average around @xmath10 . in the six brightest sources we detect extended emission which appears to originate in jets . together with the spectral indices this suggests that the nuclear emission at centimeter radio waves is largely dominated by emission from radio jets rather than an adaf @xcite , very similar to the situation in more luminous agn .
the energy released in these jets could be a significant fraction of the energy budget in the accretion flow .
hence , there is ample reason to also consider the radio variability of llagn and perhaps learn more about the underlying black hole / accretion flow system powering them . as a by - product of our observing program
, we have a number of sources that were observed several times and hence can be used to obtain some initial and basic information on llagn radio variability .
in fact , all 18 sources in our combined samples with flux densities above 3 mjy ( the sample studied also by the vlba ) were observed at least two times ; those who were part of our first sample ( 48 llagn ) were observed three times , all epochs separated by roughly 1.5 years .
all observations were made in a similar manner at 15 ghz with the vla in a - configuration .
this way we are not affected by resolution effects from the vlbi observations we know that basically all the flux on this scale and at this frequency comes from a compact mas - component , i.e. the core .
[ llagnvar1 ] as an example , simple light curves are shown in figure 3 . again
, the milli - jansky level radio flux density is not a major problem in detecting variability .
surprisingly , we find a number of sources with rather large variations .
highly significant peak - to - peak variability of 200 - 300% is seen for example in the radio cores of ngc2787 , ngc4143 , and ngc4565 .
[ histovar ] for such sparsely sampled light curves a variability index is rather ill - defined for individual sources .
nevertheless , we can assume that in a statistically useful sample as ours the distribution of the variability index ( i.e. the r.m.s .
divided by the mean ) , as shown in fig . 4 ,
will have some meaning .
the general trend of this distribution confirms the first impression from looking at the light curves : variability on a timescale of years is common place among llagn and amplitudes can reach rather large values from 20 - 70% .
this variability is even larger than the one seen in quasars .
the rather large fraction of llagn with radio cores and the fact that our sample was initially optically selected , speaks for a rather broad range of inclination angles .
strong variations in the accretion rate rather than effects of relativistic boosting therefore seem to be a more likely explanation for the variability .
this would be in line with some of the x - ray variability seen in llagn where on scales of years the flux has changed by factors of a few ( e.g. , ) .
the apparent difference in variability index between llagn and rqqs seen here could be related to possibly smaller black hole masses in the former .
since we are probing only a narrow range of time scales in our programs it could well be that for larger black hole masses the time scale of strong variability is significant larger than a year and hence remains undetected .
alternatively , one could postulate a different type of accretion which is more volatile in llagn than in quasars . for example , if the accretion onto the central black hole is fed by stellar winds from a few sources only , as speculated for example for the galactic center @xcite , then evolution and change in orbits of individual stars can have a much more pronounced effect on the overall accretion rate than in a situation where the accretion proceeds through a large scale and massive accretion disk .
we have established significant intra - year variability in a sample of radio - quiet and radio - intermediate quasars as well as in a sample of low - luminosity agn .
the variability in quasars strengthens the notion that also in supposedly radio - quiet quasars the radio emission is produced by the agn a large fraction of that very close to the central engine .
the strong variability could be related to the presence of relativistic jets in at least some rqqs and riqs .
the detection of radio cores and radio - variability in these sources opens up the possibility to obtain a closer look on the connection between jet formation and accretion flows through coordinated optical / x - ray / radio monitoring also for radio - weak agn .
changes in the accretion rate should be reflected also in the radio emission .
already now one can speculate that from the large radio - variability of some liners and dwarf - seyfert rather large fluctuations in the accretion rate are expected .
future long - term monitoring campaigns should therefore seriously consider including radio monitoring as well , even if the flux densities are only a few milli - jansky in a compact core .
this works summarizes two partially unpublished results from various projects .
the work was split in the following manner : rb & jl were involved in the quasar monitoring while aw & nn were involved in the llagn observations . | we report on two surveys of radio - weak agn to look for radio variability .
we find significant variability with an rms of 10 - 20% on a timescale of months in radio - quiet and radio - intermediate quasars .
this exceeds the variability of radio cores in radio - loud quasars ( excluding blazars ) , which vary only on a few percent level .
the variability in radio - quiet quasars confirms that the radio emission in these sources is indeed related to the agn .
the most extremely variable source is the radio - intermediate quasar iii zw 2 which was recently found to contain a relativistic jet .
in addition we find large amplitude variabilities ( up to 300% peak - to - peak ) in a sample of nearby low - luminosity agn , liners and dwarf - seyferts , on a timescale of 1.5 years .
the variability could be related to the activity of nuclear jets responding to changing accretion rates .
simultaneous radio / optical / x - ray monitoring also for radio - weak agn , and not just for blazars , is therefore a potentially powerful tool to study the link between jets and accretion flows .
# 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
an important class of problems in mathematics take the following prototypical form : given a riemmanian manifold , find a conformally equivalent metric satisfying certain prescribed properties .
conformal mapping problems _ arise ubiquitiously , and their solutions are invaluable to many areas of applied mathematics , physics , and engineering . inspired largely by these applications , considerable
work has been done in developing notions of _ discrete conformal maps_. of particular interest have been discretizations that preserve certain structural properties and characteristics of their continuum counterparts .
such discretizations have shown to contain a surprisingly profound and rich theory of their own , and their study is an exciting and flourishing area of mathematics today . the main purpose of this paper is to note a correspondence between continuum conformal mapping problems that arise in the study of vortices in the abelian higgs field theory ( see @xcite ) and certain discrete conformal mapping problems studied in @xcite .
the abelian higgs field theory first arose as a phenomenological model of superconductivity .
the model admits vortex solutions , which are topogically stable , finite energy solutions to the field equations .
physically , the vortices are crucial in understanding the meissner effect of magnetic repulsion in superconductors
. it was observed by witten @xcite that in some circumstances , the equations describing vortices are closely related to the liouville equation for the conformal factor of constant curvature surfaces , which he exploited to construct explicit vortex solutions .
this was further generalized by recent work by @xcite , who showed that the vortex equations can be reformulated as a conformal mapping problem involving prescribed linear combinations of the gaussian curvature and the riemannian volume form . on the other hand , @xcite studied discrete conformal maps of triangulations , in which metrics correspond to edge lengths and conformal transformations to scale factors associated with vertices .
these notions were generalized to hyperbolic and spherical triangulations ( see @xcite ) .
several types of associated mapping problems were studied and shown to be solvable by variational principles .
we argue that these discrete conformal problems correspond naturally to continuum problems involving combinations of the curvature and volume form .
we then explain how the discrete conformal theory can be used to construct discrete vortex solutions .
acknowledgements : we graciously thank thilo rrig for help producing figure [ fig : vortices ] using the software varylab @xcite .
this research was supported by the dfg collaborative research center trr 109 `` discretization in geometry and dynamics . ''
the classical abelian higgs field theory is defined on a hermitian line bundle @xmath0 over a closed , oriented two dimensional riemannian manifold @xmath1 .
the fields are a section @xmath2 of @xmath3 , and a hermitian @xmath4-connection @xmath5 on @xmath3 .
the action functional of the higgs field theory is given by @xmath6 = \int_m \left ( | f_a|^2 - 2 c \ ; | d_a \phi |^2 + \left(c | \phi |^2 - c_0 \right)^2 \right ) \ ; dv,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath7 and @xmath8 are real constants , @xmath9 is the curvature of the connection , and @xmath10 is the covariant derivative , and @xmath11 is the riemannian volume element . in a trivializing coordinate chart , the connection can be represented by a differential one form @xmath12 .
the curvature two form is @xmath13 , and the covariant derivative @xmath14 .
the euler - lagrange equations are given by @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the hodge star .
the vortex equations are a set of first order equations describing stationary points of the abelian higgs action ; when @xmath17 , solutions of the vortex equations are global minima of the action functional .
the equations are found after rearranging the action by exploiting the complex structure on @xmath1 .
recall that the hodge star induces a complex structure and gives a decomposition of complexified forms @xmath18 , and of the exterior derivative @xmath19 .
there is correspondingly a decomposition @xmath20 and a splitting @xmath21 .
in addition , denote by @xmath22 the contraction with volume form ; on a two dimensional manifold , @xmath23 for any @xmath24 , and @xmath25 is the pointwise inner product on forms induced by the riemannian metric . the action ( [ eq : action ] ) can then be rewritten ( see @xcite ) as @xmath26 & = \int_m \left ( \left ( \lambda f_a + ( c_0 - c | \phi |^2 ) \right)^2 - c | \bar \partial_a \phi | ^ 2 \right)\ ; dv + \int_m
c_0 f_a.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the integral of the curvature is quantized and independent of the connection @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the chern number and an invariant of the bundle @xmath29 , the action can then be written @xmath30= \int_m \left ( \left ( \lambda f_a + ( c_0 - c | \phi |^2 ) \right)^2 - 2 c | \bar \partial_a \phi | ^ 2 \right ) \ ; dv + 4 \pi n c_0 .
\label{eq : action2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the _ vortex equations _ demand that the each term of the integrand vanishes : @xmath31 the vortex equations imply the euler - lagrange ( [ eq : el ] ) equations . moreover , when @xmath32 , each term of the integrand ( [ eq : action2 ] ) is positive definite , from which it follows that solutions to the vortex equations minimize the action .
the first vortex equation ( [ eq : vorteq1 ] ) says that @xmath33 is gauge - covariantly holomorphic .
it is convenient to assume complex coordinates @xmath34 , in which the metric takes the conformal form @xmath35 the connection can be written @xmath36 , where by unitarity , @xmath37 . in these coordinates , the equation ( [ eq : vorteq1 ] )
can be expanded as @xmath38 and be integrated @xmath39 this yields for the curvature @xmath40 since @xmath33 is gauge covariantly holomorphic , it has isolated zeroes at points @xmath41 , called the _ vortex centers _ , with multiplicities @xmath42 , called _ vortex numbers_. from ( [ eq : vorcurv ] ) , near each vortex center @xmath41 , the curvature has a singularity as @xmath43 of the form @xmath44 it follows that the total vortex number is given by @xmath45 turning to the second vortex equation ( [ eq : vorteq2 ] ) , using @xmath46 , one finds @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the laplace - beltrami operator . in terms of the function @xmath49 defined by @xmath50
, this can be written as @xmath51 by rescaling first the metric and then shifting @xmath52 ( rescaling @xmath33 ) , the constants @xmath7 and @xmath8 can without loss of generality be assumed to take the values @xmath53 , giving nine vortex equations .
however , since @xmath33 is covariantly holomorphic and has only zeroes , ( [ eq : vortnumber ] ) implies that @xmath54 . then , since by ( [ eq : vorteq2 ] ) @xmath55 it follows that solutions only exist if the integrand on the right side can be positive .
this discludes the four cases @xmath56 , and yields five remaining vortex equations : 1 .
taubes vortex .
2 . @xmath58 .
bradlow vortex .
3 . @xmath59 .
ambjrn - olesen vortex .
( see @xcite ) 4 .
@xmath60 . jackiw - pi vortex .
popov vortex .
the gaussian curvature @xmath62 under conformal scaling of the metric @xmath63 transforms as @xmath64 so the taubes vortex equation corresponds to the liouville equation in constant negative curvature .
this was pursued further in @xcite , who study the conformally rescaled metric @xmath65 the baptista metric is degenerate , with cone type singularities at the vortex centers where @xmath66 vanishes , with excess angle @xmath67 .
the curvature @xmath68 of the baptista metric away from the vortex centers can be computed using liouville s equation , and using the vortex equation ( [ eq : vortliouville ] for @xmath69 to obtain @xmath70 rearranging gives @xmath71 denoting by @xmath72 and @xmath73 the volume forms , the baptista equation can equivalently be written as @xmath74 a field configuration @xmath75 is a solution to the vortex equations if and only if the associated baptista metric satisfies ( [ eq : bapt ] ) away from the vortex centers .
a _ triangulated surface _ consists of a compact oriented surface @xmath76 , a finite simplicial complex @xmath77 , and a homeomorphism @xmath78 .
combinatorially , the complex @xmath77 consists of vertices @xmath79 , edges @xmath80 , and faces @xmath81 .
we will enumerate vertices , and denote by @xmath82 the edge adjacent to vertices @xmath83 and @xmath84 , and by @xmath85 the face adjacent to vertices @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
a _ geodesically triangulated surface _ is a triangulated surface such that image of each edge of @xmath77 under the homeomorphism @xmath88 is geodesic in @xmath76 .
a _ euclidean triangulated surface _ is a geodesically triangulated surface with a smooth riemannian metric defined on @xmath89 such each point of @xmath89 is locally isometric to the euclidean plane . in a _ hyperbolic triangulated surface _
, each point of @xmath89 is locally isometric to the hyperbolic plane . in a _
spherical triangulated surface _
, each point of @xmath89 is locally isometric to the sphere .
such triangulated surfaces can be obtained by gluing a finite collection of either euclidean , hyperbolic , or spherical triangles along edges .
these surfaces have constant gaussian curvature except at vertices where , the metric may have a conical singularity .
we denote by @xmath90 the total angle about vertex @xmath91 .
a discrete metric on @xmath77 is the pair @xmath92 , where @xmath93 describes the geometry of the faces , and @xmath94 the length of edges .
the map @xmath95 satisfies the triangle inequalities @xmath96 in addition , for the case of spherical geometry @xmath97 must satisfy @xmath98 a discrete metric satisfying these inequalities defines a unique triangulated surface that we will denote @xmath99
. the distance function @xmath100 on a triangulated surface @xmath101 is defined as @xmath102 the distance function can be understood by imagining the hyperbolic plane and sphere as isometrically embedded in @xmath103 and @xmath104 respectively ; then @xmath105 is the ambient distance of two points seperated by intrinsic distance @xmath95 , see figure [ fig : ll ] .
two discrete metrics @xmath106 and @xmath107 are _ discrete conformally equivalent _ if there exists a function ( logarthmic scale factor ) @xmath108 such that @xmath109note that we do not require the geometries @xmath110 and @xmath111 to be the same . for the euclidean geometry , this definition first appeared in @xcite , for the spherical and hyperbolic geometry in @xcite , and in all generality in @xcite . in @xcite ,
several conformal mapping and uniformization problems were studied in detail . in this note , we focus in particular on the following special case : [ cmp ] given a triangulated surface with discrete metric @xmath92 , find a conformally equivalent metric @xmath112 with prescribed conical angle @xmath113 and prescribed geometry @xmath114 \{euclidean , hyperbolic , spherical}. let us now describe the analagous continuum conformal mapping problem .
the conical defect angle has often been considered as a discretization of the guassian curvature .
more precisely ( see @xcite ) , for a euclidean triangulation , the defect angle is a discretization of curvature two form @xmath115 .
this is evident from the scaling behaviour : upon rescaling , both the curvature form and angular defect are preserved . for the more general case of hyperbolic and spherical triangulations ,
the conical defect angle should be understood as a discretization of a linear combination of the curvature two form and the volume form .
this is motivated as follows : consider the voronoi cell @xmath116 of a vertex @xmath117 .
it consists of a finite number of geodesic triangles @xmath118 for @xmath119 , and has a piecewise geodesic boundary @xmath120 consisting of smooth segments @xmath121 as shown in figure [ fig : vor ] .
( p0 ) at ( -1,.1 ) ; ( p1 ) at ( -.6,-.5 ) ; ( p2 ) at ( 0,-.8 ) ; ( p3 ) at ( .6,-.3 ) ; ( p4 ) at ( .5,.5 ) ; ( p5 ) at ( -.4,.8 ) ; ( c0 ) at ( 0,0 ) ; ( e0 ) at ( 0.3 , -0.95 ) ; ( p0)(p1)(p2)(p3)(p4)(p5)(p0 ) ; ( c0)(p0 ) ; ( c0)(p1 ) ; ( c0)(p2 ) ; ( c0)(p3 ) ; ( c0)(p4 ) ; ( c0)(p5 ) ; ( p2)(e0 ) ; ; ; ; ; the integral of the curvature form over @xmath116 is given by the gauss - bonnet theorem , including terms accounting for boundary as @xmath122 here @xmath123 is the turning angle between the adjacent segments @xmath124 and @xmath125 ( see figure [ fig : vor ] ) .
rewriting in terms of internal angles gives : @xmath126 for spherical / hyperbolic triangles , the area @xmath127 of a triangle is related to the angles of the triangle by @xmath128 so that in any case @xmath129 where @xmath130 for @xmath131 spherical , euclidean , and hyperbolic respectively . substituting this expression into the sum ( [ eq : sum2 ] )
gives : @xmath132 or upon rearranging @xmath133 thus , the conical angle @xmath134 corresponds most naturally to the two form @xmath135 .
the analogous continuous mapping problem is : [ ccmp ] given a riemannian manifold @xmath136 , find a conformally equivalent metric with prescribed linear combination of curvature form and area form @xmath137 where @xmath138 .
the discrete conformal mapping problem [ cmp ] can be solved by variational principles that we briefly review now ( see @xcite for further details ) .
fix a triangulated surface @xmath139 , along with a target geometry @xmath140 and target angles @xmath141 .
the _ feasible region _
@xmath142 is the subset of logarthmic conformal factors @xmath143 such that conformally transformed @xmath144 defined via equation ( [ eq : confrmequiv ] ) defines a discrete metric in the @xmath111 geometry ; i.e. @xmath145 should satisfy the triangle inequalities ( [ eq : tri ] ) , and also inequality ( [ eq : sphc ] ) in the case that @xmath140 is spherical .
it is convenient to introduce the logarithmic lengths @xmath146 in terms of @xmath147 , equation ( [ eq : confrmequiv ] ) takes the form @xmath148 the functional @xmath149 is defined as @xmath150 the function @xmath151 here is defined as @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the lobachevsky function @xmath154 the angles @xmath155 and @xmath156 are related to the triangle ( in @xmath140 geometry ) with edge lengths @xmath157 and its circumcircle as shown in figure ( [ fig : tricirc ] ) .
\(a ) at ( 0.173648 , 0.984808 ) ; ( b ) at ( -0.939693 , -0.34202 ) ; ( c ) at ( 0.642788 , -0.766044 ) ; ( c1 ) at ( 0.939693 , -0.34202 ) ; ( a1 ) at ( 0.642788 , 0.766044 ) ; plot ( cos(),sin ( ) ) ; ( a)(b ) node [ above , left , midway ] ; ( b)(c ) node [ below , midway ] ; ( c)(a ) node [ right , midway ] ; ; ; ; [ fig : tricirc ] algebraically , the @xmath158 and @xmath159 are related by @xmath160 and the @xmath158 can be computed explicitly from the edge lengths using the formulas @xmath161 every solution of the conformal mapping problem [ cmp ] corresponds via ( [ eq : confrmequiv ] ) to a critical point of the functional @xmath162 .
conversely , a critical point of @xmath162 within the feasible region @xmath142 gives a solution to the conformal mapping problem [ cmp ] .
furthermore it was shown in @xcite for @xmath111 euclidean , and in @xcite for @xmath111 hyperbolic that the functional @xmath162 is convex in @xmath142 , and can be extended to a convex function defined on @xmath163 .
this is crucial both theoretically and practically .
the convexity implies that critical points of @xmath162 are global minima of the functional .
moreover , when @xmath111 is hyperbolic , the functional is strictly convex and so has a unique minimum direction .
when @xmath111 is euclidean , the minimum of the functional is unique up to an overall scale .
practically , for numerical calculations , this implies that one can utilize powerful numerical tools developed for convex optimization . in the case
@xmath111 is spherical , @xmath164 is not convex , and solutions may not correspond to minima . in the context of the vortex equations
, this corresponds to the fact that vortices with @xmath165 do not correspond to minima of the higgs action functional , and are not stable .
nonetheless , with some modification ( see @xcite ) , the standard numerical methods can be succesfully employed .
on the other hand , the existence of solutions to the conformal mapping problem [ cmp ] is more complicated .
solutions to the discrete conformal mapping problem may fail to exist due to violated triangle equalities ( [ eq : tri ] ) . on the other hand ,
if we regard the underlying surface @xmath76 with constant curvature and conical singularities as the fundamental independent of its triangulation , then it is natural to consider re - triangulations .
indeed , the theory of discrete conformal equivalence can be extended to combinatorially inequivalent triangulations ( see @xcite ) .
this generalization leads to progress with the existence problem .
in particular , for compact surfaces , a discrete uniformization theorem has been proven in @xcite .
in this section , we demonstrate how the discrete conformal mapping problem can be used to construct vortex solutions . comparing the vortex equation in the form ( [ eq : bapt ] ) to the conformal mapping problem [ ccmp ] ,
it is clear how to proceed : given a riemannian manifold , we choose a triangulation @xmath166 with @xmath110 chosen so that @xmath167 .
the conical angles @xmath168 can then be calculated at each vertex .
a solution to the vortex equation then corresponds to solving the conformal mapping problem [ cmp ] with geometry @xmath111 chosen so that @xmath169 , and identical conical angles @xmath170 except at vortex centers , where @xmath171 .
bobenko , s. sechelmann , b. springborn .
discrete conformal maps : boundary value problems , circle domains , fuchsian and schottky uniformization .
_ advances in discrete differential geometry
. _ springer berlin ( 2016 ) , 156 | we establish a connection between recent developments in the study of vortices in the abelian higgs models , and in the theory of structure - preserving discrete conformal maps .
we explain how both are related via conformal mapping problems involving prescribed linear combinations of the curvature and volume form , and show how the discrete conformal theory can be used to construct discrete vortex solutions . |
it is generally accepted that the final stage of terrestrial planet formation is the giant impact stage where protoplanets or planetary embryos formed by oligarchic growth collide with one another to form planets ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this stage has been mainly studied by @xmath0-body simulations .
so far all @xmath0-body simulations have assumed perfect accretion in which all collisions lead to accretion ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . however , this assumption would be inappropriate for grazing impacts that may result in escape of an impactor or hit - and - run . by performing smoothed - particle hydrodynamic ( sph ) collision simulations
, @xcite estimated that more than half of all collisions between like - sized protoplanets do not simply result in accumulation of a larger protoplanet , and this inefficiency lengthens the timescale of planet formation by a factor of 2 or more , relative to the perfect accretion case .
the accretion inefficiency can also change planetary spin .
@xcite found that under the assumption of perfect accretion , the typical spin angular velocity of planets is as large as the critical spin angular velocity for rotational instability .
however , in reality , the grazing collisions that have high angular momentum are likely to result in a hit - and - run , while nearly head - on collisions that have small angular momentum lead to accretion . in other words ,
small angular momentum collisions are selective in accretion .
thus , the accretion inefficiency may lead to slower planetary spin , compared with the perfect accretion case .
the goal of this paper is to clarify the statistical properties of terrestrial planets formed by giant impacts among protoplanets under a realistic accretion condition .
we derive an accretion condition for protoplanet collisions in terms of collision parameters , masses of colliding protoplanets and impact velocity and angle , by performing collision experiments with an sph method .
we implement the realistic accretion condition in @xmath0-body simulations and probe its effect to further generalize the model of terrestrial planet formation .
we derive the statistical dynamical properties of terrestrial planets from results of a number of @xmath0-body simulations and compare the results with those in @xcite and @xcite where perfect accretion is adopted .
in section 2 , we outline the initial conditions of protoplanets and the realistic accretion condition .
section 3 presents our results , where we show the statistics of collision parameters and basic dynamical properties of planets .
section 4 is devoted to a summary and discussions .
we perform @xmath0-body simulations of terrestrial planet formation starting from protoplanets .
we consider gas - free cases without giant planets residing outside the terrestrial planet region to clarify the basic dynamics . to compare with the results with perfect accretion
, we adopt the same protoplanet system as those in @xcite and @xcite , which is formed by oligarchic growth from a planetesimal disk whose surface density distribution is given by @xmath2 with inner and outer edges , @xmath3au and @xmath4au , where @xmath5 is the radial distance from the central star .
this disk model is the standard disk model for solar system formation and 50% more massive than the minimum - mass disk @xcite . in the oligarchic growth model ,
the mass of a protoplanet @xmath6 is given by the isolation mass @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the semimajor axis , @xmath9 is the orbital separation between adjacent protoplanets , @xmath10 , @xmath11 is the hill radius @xmath12 of the protoplanet , @xmath13 is the mass of the central star , and @xmath14 is earth mass @xcite .
we set the orbital separation of protoplanets as @xmath15 that is the typical value in @xmath0-body simulations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the initial eccentricities @xmath16 and inclinations @xmath17 of protoplanets are given by the rayleigh distribution with dispersions @xmath18 ( the unit of @xmath17 is radian ) @xcite .
we set the bulk density of protoplanets as @xmath19 g@xmath20 .
the initial protoplanet system has the number of protoplanets @xmath21 in @xmath22 , total mass @xmath23 , specific angular momentum @xmath24 , and mean semimajor axis @xmath25au , where @xmath26 and @xmath27 is the semimajor axis of earth . for each accretion model ,
we perform 50 runs with different initial angular distributions of protoplanets .
the orbits of protoplanets are calculated by numerically integrating the equations of motion of protoplanets .
we set the mass of the central star equal to solar mass . for numerical integration
, we use the modified hermite scheme for planetary @xmath0-body simulation @xcite with the hierarchical timestep @xcite . for the calculation of mutual gravity among protoplanets
, we use the phantom grape scheme @xcite .
the simulations follow the evolution of protoplanet systems for @xmath28 years until only a few planets remain . during orbital integration ,
when two protoplanets contact , a collision occurs .
we define an impactor / target as a smaller / larger one of two colliding bodies .
we obtained a realistic accretion condition of protoplanets by performing sph collision simulations .
the standard sph method @xcite was used with the tillotson equation of state @xcite .
we assumed differentiated protoplanets with 30% core and 70% mantle in mass .
protoplanets were represented by 20,000 particles in most runs and 60,000 particles in high - resolution runs .
we systematically varied the mass ratio of the impactor and target as @xmath29 , 2/3 , 1/2 , 1/3 , 1/4 , 1/6 , and 1/9 , their total mass as @xmath30-@xmath31 , and the impact velocity and angle as @xmath32-@xmath33 at 0.02 or @xmath34 intervals and @xmath35-@xmath36 at @xmath37 intervals , where @xmath38 is the mutual surface escape velocity @xmath39^{1/2}$ ] , @xmath40 and @xmath41 are the radii of the impactor and target , and @xmath42 is the angle between the surface normal and the impact trajectory ( @xmath35 for a head - on collision and @xmath43 for a grazing encounter ) . based on the results of sph collision simulations , we derived an empirical formula for the critical impact velocity , below which a collision leads to accretion , in terms of the masses of the impactor and target and the impact angle as @xmath44 where @xmath45 , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , and @xmath48 are numerical constants . the critical impact velocity is a decrease function of @xmath49 as seen in figure [ fig : sintheta - nu ] . for collisions of equal - mass protoplanets , this condition agrees well with the results of sph collision simulations by @xcite .
the reason for this agreement is that we performed almost the same collision simulations by essentially the same method , which confirms the robustness of the results .
the details of the collision simulations and the accretion condition will be presented in a separate paper . in the realistic accretion model
we use this accretion condition . in accretion ,
the position and velocity of the center of mass and the angular momentum are conserved .
if the impact velocity @xmath50 is higher than @xmath51 , two colliding bodies are bounced with the rebound velocity @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 , where subscripts n and t mean normal and tangential components of the velocity , respectively . the change in spin angular momentum brought about by hit - and - run collisions is not taken into account since it is usually much smaller than that caused by accretionary collisions .
these prescriptions follow the results of the collision experiments .
we assume that , initially , protoplanets have no spin angular momenta .
we track the spin angular momentum of planets resulting from accretion .
when accretion occurs , the orbital angular momenta of two colliding bodies about their center of mass and their spin angular momenta are added to the spin angular momentum of a merged body .
the spin angular velocity of planets is computed by assuming a sphere of uniform density , in other words , the moment of inertia @xmath55 , where @xmath6 and @xmath56 are the planetary mass and radius , respectively .
we compare the results of the realistic accretion model to those of the perfect accretion model @xcite .
the statistics of collision parameters and basic dynamical properties of planets derived from 50 runs for each accretion model are summarized in tables [ tab : number ] and [ tab : spin ] .
we record the collision parameters in all runs .
the numbers of hit - and - run @xmath57 and accretionary @xmath58 collisions are summarized in table [ tab : number ] . in the realistic accretion model ,
the total number of collisions in 50 runs is 1211 . in a run , the average numbers of hit - and - run and accretionary collisions are @xmath59 and @xmath60 , respectively , which means on average 49% of collisions results in hit - and - run .
note that the average number of accretionary collisions for the realistic accretion model is almost the same as that for the perfect accretion model .
this suggests that the growth timescale of planets is independent of the accretion model .
we will discuss this later . on the giant impact stage , the last one or a few large collisions determine the final spin angular momentum of planets @xcite .
in this case , the spin angular velocity is estimated as @xmath61 where @xmath62 , @xmath63^{1/2}$ ] , and @xmath64 .
the critical spin angular velocity for rotational instability @xmath65 is given by @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the material density .
in figure [ fig : sintheta - nu ] , we plot the scaled impact velocity @xmath68 against @xmath49 for all collisions in all runs for the realistic accretion model .
we show that only collisions with small @xmath68 and/or @xmath49 can lead to accretion due to the realistic accretion condition . for collisions forming earth - sized planets ( @xmath69 ) ,
the rms values of the collision parameters are @xmath70 , @xmath71 , and @xmath72 for the realistic accretion model , and @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 for the perfect accretion model .
the rms impact parameter @xmath76 for the realistic accretion model is smaller than that for the perfect accretion model since small impact parameters are selective in the realistic accretion model . also , for the same reason
, the rms impact velocity @xmath68 for the realistic accretion model is slightly smaller than that for the perfect accretion model . using these rms values
, we obtain the typical spin angular velocity resulting from an accretionary collision as 2.0 hr@xmath77 and 2.8 hr@xmath77 for the realistic and perfect accretion models , respectively . the average values with standard deviations for basic dynamical properties of planets : the number of planets , @xmath78 , the number of earth - sized planets with @xmath79 , @xmath80 , the number of planets in @xmath22 , @xmath81 , the in - situ accretion efficiency @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the total mass of planets in @xmath22 , and the growth timescale @xmath84 defined as duration of accretion for each planet that undergoes at least two accretionary collisions are summarized in table [ tab : number ] . the mass and orbital elements ( semimajor axis @xmath8 , eccentricity @xmath16 , and inclination @xmath17 ) of the largest and second - largest planets are summarized in table [ tab : number ] .
first , we find no substantial differences between the results of the two accretion models . in both models ,
a typical resultant system consists of two earth - sized planets and one or two smaller planets that are as large as the initial protoplanets @xcite .
the two earth - sized planets tend to form inside the initial distribution of protoplanets . the resultant system for the realistic accretion model tends to be slightly wider than that for the perfect accretion model , which can be seen as having slightly larger @xmath85 and smaller @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
this is because the realistic accretion model experiences more close encounters between protoplanets that diffuse the system .
it should be noted that though about half of collisions do not lead to accretion , this accretion inefficiency does not lengthen the growth timescale by a factor of two or more , relative to the perfect accretion model as expected by @xcite .
the growth timescale for the realistic accretion model is only slightly longer than that for the perfect accretion model .
this is because even though collisions do not lead to accretion , the colliding bodies stay on the colliding orbits after the collision and thus the system is unstable and the next collision takes place shortly .
in fact , the mean accretionary collision time for the realistic accretion model is @xmath88 years , which is as long as the mean collision time for the perfect accretion model @xmath89 years .
on the other hand , in the realistic accretion model , the mean collision time after a hit - and - run collision is short as @xmath90 years , where 38% of collisions is for the same pair and its mean collision time is even shorter as @xmath91 years .
figure [ fig : a - m ] shows the average masses of the largest and second - largest planets against their average semimajor axes .
we find that there are no differences in either mass or semimajor axis of the planets for the realistic and perfect accretion models .
the largest planets with @xmath92 tend to form around @xmath93 au , while the second - largest planets with @xmath94 is widely scattered in the initial protoplanet region .
we also find no difference in their eccentricities and inclinations , and those are @xmath95 .
these eccentricities and inclinations are an order of magnitude larger than the proper eccentricities and inclinations of the present terrestrial planets .
some damping mechanism such as gravitational drag ( dynamical friction ) from a dissipating gas disk @xcite or a residual planetesimal disk @xcite is necessary after the giant impact stage . in 50 runs of the realistic and perfect accretion models , we have 128 and 124 planets that experience at least one accretionary collision , respectively .
the average values of each component of the spin angular velocity @xmath96 of the planets and its dispersion @xmath97 are summarized in table [ tab : spin ] together with the root - mean - square ( rms ) spin angular velocity @xmath98 and the spin anisotropy parameter @xmath99 .
the spin angular velocity averaged in mass bins against mass is shown in figure [ fig : m - w_ave_cmp]a .
we show clearly that the average angular velocity is almost independent of mass for both accretion models . for the perfect accretion model , the average values are as high as the critical angular velocity @xmath65 .
these are natural outcomes for the giant impact stage under the assumption of perfect accretion @xcite .
the rms spin angular velocity for the realistic accretion model is about 30% smaller than that for the perfect accretion model .
this is because in the realistic accretion model , grazing and high - velocity collisions that have high angular momentum result in a hit - and - run , while nearly head - on or low - velocity collisions that have small angular momentum lead to accretion . in other words , small angular momentum collisions are selective in accretion .
thus , the accretion inefficiency leads to slower planetary spin , compared with the perfect accretion model .
indeed , the rms spin angular velocity is almost consistent with the estimation by equation ( [ eq : w ] ) in section [ sec : collision_parameter ] .
the rms spin angular velocity slightly larger than the estimation based on a single dominant accretionary collision is due to the contribution of other non - dominant accretionary collisions .
we confirm that each component of @xmath100 follows a gaussian distribution .
we perform a kolmogorov - smirnov ( k - s ) test to confirm the agreement with a gaussian distribution . for the distribution of each component
, we obtain sufficiently high values of the k - s probability @xmath101 in both accretion models . in figure [
fig : m - w_ave_cmp]b , we show the obliquity distribution with an isotropic distribution , @xmath102 .
we find that the obliquity ranges from 0@xmath103 to 180@xmath103 and follows an isotropic distribution @xmath102 , which is consistent with @xcite and @xcite . by a k - s test
, we obtain high k - s probabilities of 0.3 and 0.9 for the realistic and perfect accretion models , respectively .
this is also confirmed by the spin anisotropy parameter @xmath104 in table [ tab : spin ] .
the isotropic distribution of @xmath105 is a natural outcome of giant impacts since the impacts are three - dimensional and add equally random contributions to each component of the spin angular momentum @xcite . for an earth mass planet , the rms spin angular velocity 2.35 hr@xmath77 of the realistic accretion model corresponds to the spin angular momentum of @xmath106 g @xmath107 s@xmath77 , which is 2.7 times larger than the angular momentum of the earth - moon system .
so the angular momentum of the earth - moon system is not a typical value of the realistic accretion model but it is reasonably within the distribution of @xmath96 .
we have investigated the basic dynamical properties of the terrestrial planets assembled by giant impacts of protoplanets by using @xmath0-body simulations .
for the first time , we adopted the realistic accretion condition of protoplanets obtained by the sph collision experiments .
the basic dynamical properties have been studied statistically with numbers of @xmath0-body simulations . for the standard protoplanet system ,
the statistical properties of the planets obtained are the following : * about half of collisions in the realistic accretion model do not lead to accretion .
however , this accretion inefficiency barely lengthens the growth timescale of planets . *
the numbers of planets are @xmath108 and @xmath109 .
the growth timescale is about @xmath110 years .
the masses of the largest and second - largest planets are @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
the largest planets tend to form around @xmath93au , while @xmath113 is widely scattered in the initial protoplanet region .
their eccentricities and inclinations are @xmath95 .
these results are independent of the accretion model . *
the rms spin angular velocity for the realistic accretion model is about 30% smaller than that for the perfect accretion model that is as large as the critical spin angular velocity for rotational instability .
the spin angular velocity and obliquity of planets obey gaussian and isotropic distributions , respectively , independently of the accretion model .
we confirm that except for the magnitude of the spin angular velocity , the realistic accretion model gives the same results as the perfect accretion model .
this agreement justifies the use of the perfect accretion model to investigate the basic dynamical properties of planets except for the magnitude of the spin angular velocity . in the present realistic accretion condition
, we do not consider the effect of the spin on the accretion condition that would potentially change collisional dynamics .
it is difficult to derive an accretion condition in terms of spin parameters by sph collision simulations since the collision parameter space becomes huge and it is almost impossible to cover all parameter space .
the fragmentation of planets is not taken into account , either . including the fragmentation may be able to further reduce the spin angular velocity of planets by producing unbound collisional fragments with high angular momentum .
furthermore , the collisional fragments can potentially alter orbital dynamics of planets through dynamical friction if their mass is large enough .
the high eccentricities and inclinations of planets may be damped by dynamical friction from the collisional fragments . in order to take into account these effects and make the model of terrestrial planet formation more realistic
, we plan to perform @xmath0-body simulations for orbital dynamics and sph simulations for collisional dynamics simultaneously in a consistent way in future work .
we thank shigeru ida for his continuous encouragement .
this research was partially supported by mext ( ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ) , japan , the grant - in - aid for scientific research on priority areas , `` development of extra - solar planetary science , '' and the special coordination fund for promoting science and technology , `` grape - dr project . ''
rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr realistic & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + perfect & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] | the final stage of terrestrial planet formation is known as the giant impact stage where protoplanets collide with one another to form planets .
so far this stage has been mainly investigated by @xmath0-body simulations with an assumption of perfect accretion in which all collisions lead to accretion . however , this assumption breaks for collisions with high velocity and/or a large impact parameter .
we derive an accretion condition for protoplanet collisions in terms of impact velocity and angle and masses of colliding bodies , from the results of numerical collision experiments .
for the first time , we adopt this realistic accretion condition in @xmath0-body simulations of terrestrial planet formation from protoplanets .
we compare the results with those with perfect accretion and show how the accretion condition affects terrestrial planet formation .
we find that in the realistic accretion model , about half of collisions do not lead to accretion .
however , the final number , mass , orbital elements , and even growth timescale of planets are barely affected by the accretion condition . for the standard protoplanetary disk model , typically two earth - sized planets form in the terrestrial planet region over about @xmath1 years in both realistic and perfect accretion models .
we also find that for the realistic accretion model , the spin angular velocity is about 30% smaller than that for the perfect accretion model that is as large as the critical spin angular velocity for rotational instability .
the spin angular velocity and obliquity obey gaussian and isotropic distributions , respectively , independently of the accretion condition . |
gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) are brief pulses of @xmath9-ray radiation observed on average once a day at random directions in the sky .
they are the brightest sources in this region of the electromagnetic spectrum , and they have been systematically studied in the past two decades ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the origin of grbs is cosmological , as determined from the measurement of their redshifts ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and in many cases , their host galaxies have been identified ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
their distances imply the release of large amounts of energy ( @xmath10 ) in a short time - scale , which suggests that the origin of these phenomena could be associated to the accretion of matter onto a compact object @xcite .
two populations of grbs are apparent from the distribution of their duration @xcite .
those lasting less than @xmath11 are known as short grbs , while longer events are called long grbs ( lgrbs ) .
these are more frequently observed and more precisely located , which makes their properties better known .
lgrbs are always found in host galaxies with ongoing star formation activity @xcite , and some of them were observed to be associated with type ib / c core - collapse supernovae @xcite .
these observations suggest that the progenitors of lgrbs are massive stars .
stellar evolution models have tried to provide a consistent scenario where a lgrb can develop .
the result is the so called _ collapsar model _
@xcite , in which this phenomenon is produced during the collapse of a massive star , due to the accretion of part of the envelope onto the recently formed black hole .
nevertheless , the properties of lgrb progenitors ( mass , metallicity , rotation velocity , binarity , etc . ) are still a matter of discussion .
lgrbs have been associated to single massive stars @xcite , perhaps in metallicity biased environments @xcite , and also to stars in binary systems @xcite .
the importance of understanding the nature of the lgrb progenitors is beyond the interest of only stellar evolution and black hole formation . given their connection to massive stars and their large luminosities , lgrbs might be a powerful tool to investigate the star formation in the early universe , at redshifts for which standard tools become ineffective ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the knowledge of the properties of the stellar progenitors would allow the assessment of possible biases originated when lgrbs are used as tracers of star formation .
several authors suggest that the cosmic lgrb rate does not follow the star formation rate @xcite .
the interpretation of their data requires the assumption of a differential evolution of the comoving lgrb rate density with respect to the comoving star formation rate ( sfr ) density .
the same conclusion arises from the work of @xcite , who show that the luminosity function of lgrb hosts differs from that of core - collapse supernovae hosts , which are considered unbiased tracers of star formation . according to these authors
, the lgrb host luminosity function can be reproduced by requiring lgrb progenitors to have metal abundances lower than that of the sun .
an indirect procedure to investigate lgrb progenitors is to characterise the stellar populations of their host galaxies . given the connection between lgrbs and star formation , galaxy formation models can be used to assess the validity of lgrb progenitor models , comparing their predictions about the properties of these stellar populations to host galaxies observations .
recent works such as that of @xcite , suggest that there is a strong relation between star formation and nuclear activity in a galaxy with its environment , at constant stellar mass .
hence , the environment of host galaxies might constitute an independent probe for progenitor models .
observational works on host galaxies environment are still inconclusive on whether host galaxies inhabit regions with certain characteristics @xcite .
@xcite suggest that host galaxies are field galaxies , while @xcite find that a considerable fraction of their sample of 42 host galaxies shows evidence of interaction with other galaxies .
the question of whether there is a connection between the occurrence of a lgrb and the local density of galaxies remains unanswered .
since galaxy formation is a highly non - linear process , the properties of host galaxies predicted by different progenitor scenarios are better studied by means of cosmological numerical simulations @xcite .
@xcite use hydrodynamical simulations of structure formation to identify a galaxy population whose properties reproduce the observed ones .
according to these authors , the luminosity distribution of host galaxies is reproduced if galaxies are required to have high star formation efficiency .
however , their simulations do not make any prediction on the properties of the lgrb progenitors .
@xcite developed a monte carlo code to simulate the production of lgrbs in hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation , assuming that their progenitors are massive stars as proposed by the collapsar model .
these authors follow the lgrb production as the structure forms and evolves in the universe .
their results suggest that lgrb progenitors would be low metallicity stars ( @xmath12 ) , and hence lgrbs would be biased tracers of star formation principally at low redshift .
however , their simulations explore a small volume of @xmath13 dominated by field galaxies .
recently , @xcite have constructed a simulated population of host galaxies based on the semi - analytic model of galaxy formation of @xcite applied to cosmological simulations developed by @xcite .
these simulations describe a larger volume of the universe ( a square box of @xmath14 in a side ) .
@xcite explore three lgrb progenitor models based on the collapsar model , one of them assuming a given stellar mass value and an age cut - off and the other two also including metallicity cut - offs .
these authors find that models with very low metallicity progenitors ( @xmath15 ) could explain the luminosities , colours and metallicities of the observed host galaxies .
their results support previous claims of lgrbs being biased tracers of the star formation .
clearly , the use of larger simulations with better resolution and more detailed descriptions of the physical processes driving the dynamical , chemical and star formation histories of galaxies allows a better modelling of the host galaxies of lgrbs .
however , an important aspect that should not be disregarded is that , for a proper comparison with observed host galaxies , the effects of the detectability of these galaxies must be taken into account . and
this is the main contribution of our work where we developed an observational pipeline which allows us to mimic , at least in part , biases affecting the observations . with this new tool
we build an observable host galaxy catalogue which can be more fairly compared to current available observations . in this work
, we develop a semi - analytical model for the host galaxies of lgrbs adopting the collapsar model for the progenitor stars .
we apply it to one of the largest cosmological simulations available , the _ millennium simulation _ @xcite .
the _ millennium simulation _ follows the evolution of dark matter in a box of @xmath16 in a side , hence providing a cosmologically representative volume a factor of 64 larger than that of @xcite and factor of @xmath17 larger than that of @xcite .
we take the galaxy catalogue built up by @xcite , who describe the evolution of baryonic matter including star formation , active galactic nuclei and supernova feedback . using the star formation and chemical properties of galaxies in this catalogue to implement different lgrb progenitor scenarios ,
we determine the properties of the overall host galaxy population and its environment .
we compute the detectability of the host galaxies in order to compare the predictions of these scenarios to the observations compiled by @xcite .
this work is organized as following . in section [ sim ] , we briefly describe the cosmological simulation and semi - analytic galaxy catalogue used in our work . in section [ mod ] ,
we develop our implementation of lgrb progenitor scenarios .
sections [ hgs ] and [ env ] show our results on host galaxy properties and environment , respectively .
finally , section [ con ] presents our conclusions .
the _ millennium simulation _ @xcite is one of the largest cosmological simulations of structure formation publicly available .
it describes the evolution of the cold dark matter while the baryonic matter can be included via semi - analytic models on top of the numerical simulation .
the _ millennium simulation _ describes the formation of structure tracking @xmath18 dark matter particles of mass @xmath19 distributed in a cubic region of 500 @xmath20 side , using the @xmath21 cosmogony .
the adopted cosmological parameters are @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 , where the hubble constant is @xmath27 with @xmath28 .
these parameters are chosen in consistency with results obtained by the joint analysis of the two - degree field galaxy redshift survey ( 2dfgrs ) and the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) data @xcite .
the simulation was performed using a modified version of gadget-2 hydrodynamical code @xcite . a _ friends - of - friends _ ( fof ) algorithm identified non - linear dark matter haloes within the simulation in an automatic manner .
two particles belong to the same halo if their separation is less than @xmath29 times the mean separation between particles .
only groups of more than @xmath30 particles are identified as haloes .
this restriction sets a lower limit on the mass of a halo of @xmath31 .
substructures orbiting within each virialized halo are identified applying a subfind algorithm @xcite .
each dark matter halo has a central ( type 0 ) galaxy and one or more satellite galaxies .
satellites were at some point central galaxies of smaller haloes which suffered a merger with the halo their currently inhabit .
there are two types of satellite galaxies , type 1 galaxies are located at the centre of a subhalo associated with a fof group , while type 2 galaxies have lost their dark matter subhalo after falling onto a more massive halo .
mean properties of synthetic galaxies ( e.g. sfr , stellar mass , gas mass , metallicity ) are obtained by applying semi - analytic models to the structure formation simulation @xcite .
essentially , semi - analytical models describe the collapse of baryonic matter following dark matter haloes . after collapsing
, the gas cools and gravitational instabilities produce episodes of star formation . to reproduce observations , models incorporate photoionization processes in the intergalactic medium , the growth of supermassive black holes during galactic mergers , supernova and agn feedback , star formation rate enhancement in mergers , and formation of heavy elements for each formed stellar population .
the galaxy catalogue we use in this work is that of @xcite .
there is recent evidence for an excessive reddening of type 2 galaxies @xcite which might be due to the poor physical treatment of this type of galaxies . in order to avoid spurious trends ,
we exclude type 2 galaxies from our analysis in section [ mod ] and section [ hgs ] .
however , type 2 galaxies ought to be included in the environmental analysis performed in section [ env ] in order to correctly trace the underlying mass distribution .
hence , the catalogue of @xcite provides us with the spatial galaxy distribution , their stellar masses , dark matter haloes , star formation activity , colours , luminosities and mean metallicities .
regarding the latter , the public catalogue makes available the mean metallicity of the cold gas component and of the stellar population as a whole ( i.e. averaged over new and old stars in a galaxy ) .
therefore , as a proxy for the metallicity of the lgrb progenitors , we take the mean metallicity of the cold gas component at the time these stars were born . because the @xcite model assumes instantaneous recycling , this metallicity is slightly higher than that of the newly born stars , but this correction is negligible compared to the uncertainties in the measured metallicities ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
we consider two scenarios for lgrb production , both of them based on the collapsar model @xcite . in our scenario
i we take as lgrb progenitors all stars above a certain minimum mass @xmath32 , with no other restriction whatsoever . in this scenario
lgrbs are unbiased tracers of star formation .
accordingly , we obtain the intrinsic lgrb rate in a given galaxy @xmath33 at a particular redshift @xmath34 as @xmath35 where @xmath36 and @xmath37 are the lower and upper mass cut - offs of the imf @xmath38 given by @xcite . according to eqn .
[ rateint ] , the production of lgrbs is not delayed with respect to the starburst that created the progenitor stars , which is justified because in the collapsar model only massive stars are lgrb progenitors . in our scenario
ii , we assume that only massive stars ( @xmath39 ) below some metallicity threshold ( @xmath40 ) are able to produce lgrbs , as in the progenitor models of @xcite or @xcite . as explained before , we take the mean metallicity of cold gas in each galaxy as representative of the metallicity of the progenitor stars .
the consequences of this hypothesis will be discussed in later sections . in this scenario ,
the intrinsic lgrb rate is given by eqn .
[ rateint ] for galaxies @xmath33 with metallicity @xmath41 , and is null for those with @xmath42 .
three realizations of this scenario were computed , adopting @xmath43 ( scenarios ii.1 , ii.2 and ii.3 , respectively ) . given a metallicity threshold , we adjusted the only free parameter of our scenarios ( @xmath32 ) to reproduce the lgrb rate measured by the batse experiment .
for this purpose , we took the off - line grb search of @xcite , which detected 3475 grbs with @xmath44 during a live - time of @xmath45 ( 70 per cent of the @xmath46 that batse was active ) , scanning 67 per cent of the sky .
this translates into a full - sky lgrb rate of @xmath47 above the threshold of the off - line search .
the choice of this particular experiment was motivated by its good statistics and the availability of an accurate model for its detection efficiency . to obtain the observable rate predicted by a given scenario , we first compute the comoving lgrb rate density for each redshift as @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the comoving volume of the _
millennium simulation_. the full - sky observed lgrb rate is then @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the derivative of the comoving volume with respect to @xmath34 at fixed solid angle , @xmath52 is the maximum redshift of the simulation , @xmath53 the luminosity distance and @xmath54 the hubble constant at redshift @xmath34 , and @xmath55 the probability of detecting a lgrb at redshift @xmath34 with batse ( i.e. the probability that a particular lgrb has a peak flux above the experiment threshold ) .
the integration was performed numerically , and the described procedure iterated over @xmath32 , until agreement with the observed rate was attained .
the value of @xmath56 depends on the lgrb luminosity function and spectrum .
it was computed using a monte - carlo scheme to simulate , at a given redshift , a large population of lgrbs with different luminosities and spectra .
then , their photon fluxes in the batse energy band were estimated . for each lgrb in this population , a second monte - carlo procedure rejected those events which would be undetectable , taking into account the trigger efficiency of the @xcite off - line search .
if the lgrb emission were isotropic , the fraction of retained lgrbs would directly give the detection probability due to the off - line search threshold . to account for the beamed emission of lgrbs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , and assuming that the distribution of jet opening angles is independent of the lgrb luminosity , spectrum and redshift , we obtain @xmath55 by multiplying this fraction by the mean beaming fraction of the jets @xmath57 .
the luminosity function and spectral parameters distributions were taken from @xcite .
this procedure not only allows us to mimic the observational process but also has provided us with estimates of the minimum mass for the progenitor stars .
the values of @xmath32 obtained , in solar masses , are @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 for scenarios i , ii.1 , ii.2 and ii.3 , respectively ; the uncertainties reflect poissonian errors in the number of observed lgrbs ( see also table 1 ) .
.main characteristics of our scenarios for the simulated host galaxies of lgrbs .
column ( 1 ) gives the name of the scenario .
column ( 2 ) lists the minimum stellar mass obtained for progenitor stars of lgrbs to reproduce batse observations , adopting @xcite imf .
column ( 3 ) gives the cold gas maximum metallicity cut - off .
column ( 4 ) shows ratio between the percentage of simulated host galaxies over the mass range @xmath62 and the corresponding value obtained from the sample of @xcite . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] a meaningful definition of a lgrb host galaxy in our scenarios is not as straightforward as it might seem at first sight . the nave definition of a host galaxy , at a given redshift @xmath34 , as being any galaxy @xmath33 with a lgbr rate of @xmath63 ( or identically , @xmath64 ) is not useful because the resulting host population would include galaxies with arbitrarily low lgrb rates .
low rates are better understood in statistical terms , as very low probabilities of producing a lgrb per unit time .
this implies that the corresponding galaxies have a low probability of being observed as host galaxies .
hence , this nave definition would generate a host galaxies sample biased to low sfr galaxies . to fix this problem
, the definition of a host galaxy could be based on the number of lgrbs @xmath65 produced in each galaxy during a time interval @xmath66 in its rest frame , so that host galaxies are only those with @xmath67 , as in @xcite .
however this cut - off , and the resulting population , would be dependent on the more or less arbitrary choice of @xmath66 . given the above arguments , we preferred instead a probabilistic approach , defining the likelihood of a galaxy being observed as a lgrb host .
this likelihood is then used as a weight to compute the properties of the observable host galaxies sample , which would be in this way comparable to the observed sample . for a galaxy to be detected as a host
at least one lgrb must be detected within it by a high - energy observatory .
then , the galaxy itself must be detected , usually by optical / nir telescopes .
we would treat the biases introduced by each of these observations separately . to model the first bias
, we compute the probability of detecting at least one lgrb within it by any of the high - energy observatories monitoring grbs . given that event
detection processes follow poissonian statistics , if @xmath68 is the contribution of galaxy @xmath33 at redshift @xmath34 to the lgrb rate observed by experiment @xmath69 , the probability of observing at least one lgrb in a galaxy is @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the time interval of the lgrb search conducted by experiment @xmath69 .
[ phg ] assumes that the searches by different observatories are independent .
previous works estimate the intrinsic lgrb rate in a typical galaxy to be of the order of @xmath72 @xcite , hence the lgrb rate observed in the galaxy by any mission must be lower than this value .
given that current searches for lgrbs have spanned a few years , @xmath73 , and @xmath74 , which means that the likelihood of a galaxy being observed as a host is proportional to its contribution to the mean _ observed _ number of lgrbs , @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the sky coverage of the experiment @xmath69 .
note that , for a fixed @xmath34 , cosmological and observatory dependent factors in eqn .
[ rateobsgal ] become constant , independently of the number of observatories considered , and cancel out in the normalization of the weights .
this means that when computing mean hg properties such as mass or sfr as a function of @xmath34 , the first bias can be modeled simply by weighting the corresponding properties of each galaxy by its _
intrinsic _ lgrb rate . in the computation of the integrated properties of the whole population of host galaxies ( like the integrated mass distribution , for example ) , also the effects of volume variation , time dilation and detectability of the different observatories must be taken into account ( pellizza et al . in preparation ) . in this case
it is better to compute first the mass distribution observed by each experiment at each redshift @xmath34 , weighting the galaxies in the corresponding snapshot by @xmath77 .
second , the integration in @xmath34 can be performed for each experiment , and the resulting distribution can be normalized .
this has the advantage of avoiding the use of the values of @xmath71 and @xmath76 , which are poorly known for some of the observatories that detected the lgrbs in the sample of @xcite .
only @xmath78 for each experiment is needed , which is computed as described in sect .
[ obsrate ] for @xmath56 .
finally , these distributions can be combined into a single one by adding them , previously scaled to the number of lgrbs detected by each observatory .
the relevant data for computing the detectability were taken from @xcite for batse , @xcite for _ swift _ , @xcite for _ beppo - sax _
, @xcite for _ hete-2 _ and @xcite for _ ulysses_. these experiments detected 36 of the 38 lgrbs in the sample of @xcite .
for statistical reasons , only experiments that detected at least five lgrbs in the sample were considered .
konus-_wind _ and _ near_-xgrs were discarded because all their lgrbs were observed also by other experiments above . to be consistent ,
the observed mass distribution to which the model predictions were compared was constructed from the data of @xcite by adding the individual distributions observed by each experiment .
the second bias is more difficult to model .
given that the search for host galaxies is guided by the discovery of the lgrbs themselves and usually done with a variety of different telescopes and detectors , in different bands of the electromagnetic spectrum and with different sensitivities , the biases introduced are unclear .
galaxies with surface brightness below the detectability threshold of available instruments could introduce a bias towards low metallicity galaxies .
an extra problem could be caused by dust obscuration which could affect the detection of the afterglows and produce a bias towards high metallicity galaxies @xcite .
hence , at least these two effects might combine themselves to determine the detectability of a host galaxy .
considering also the fact that we have only access to the public galaxy catalogue of the _ millennium simulation _ which provides only mean global properties and magnitudes , we adopt the observed integrated stellar mass distribution as a tool to apply the combined effect of observational biases to the simulated galaxy sample .
we use the fact that the observed integrated stellar mass distribution has been affected by observational biases although we can not disentangle their individual effects .
hence , we require the simulated lgrb hosts to reproduce the observed stellar mass distribution in order to build up the observable simulated lgrb hosts . the procedure is explained in detail in next section .
note that , hereafterin , we will discuss the trends of the observable simulated hosts and the general galaxy population .
the former can be compared to the current observed hosts , but , if this later sample changes due to better or different observational techniques , our simulated sample should be also consistently modified to match the new observed stellar mass distribution .
the largest and most comprehensively uniform sample of host galaxy properties available at present is that compiled by @xcite .
stellar masses , star formation rates , metallicities , absolute magnitudes and colours of 46 observed host galaxies up to @xmath79 were obtained by these authors comparing their spectral energy distributions to those of synthetic stellar populations , using the method described in @xcite .
a key point of our models is that we require the stellar mass distribution of the predicted host galaxies to match that of the observed host galaxies .
the stellar mass is adopted as the property to be reproduced by the models since it is now widely accepted that stellar mass is a more fundamental quantity for galaxies than luminosity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
it could be possible that those lgrb events with no detected hosts occured in very low surface brightness galaxies and hence , with low stellar masses . as mentioned before the effects of dust could also prevent the detection of events in high metallicity ( and dusty ) galaxies . in our models
these host galaxies exist ( and are part of the global galaxy population ) but the observability cut - off has been determined by using the current observed stellar mass distribution .
[ mass ] shows the distribution of stellar masses of observed host galaxies constructed from the data of @xcite , together with those predicted by our scenarios . as it can be seen from fig .
[ mass ] , the scenario which best reproduces the observed stellar mass distribution is that with @xmath80 ( scenario ii.3 , see also table 1 ) .
lower metallicity thresholds predict lower observed stellar masses for the host galaxies , while no metallicity threshold ( scenario i ) predicts larger ones . in the sample of @xcite
, we find that @xmath81 per cent of the studied galaxies have stellar masses over the range @xmath62 ( see also * ? ? ?
the probability of getting a host galaxy within this stellar mass range in scenario ii.3 is 88 per cent , while for scenarios i , ii.1 and ii.2 it is 70 , 2 , and 43 per cent , respectively . then we conclude that scenario ii.3 predictions agree fairly well with observations while others fail , and therefore in the following sections , we will focus only on this scenario .
we stress the fact that its predictions include the effects of host galaxies observability , hence , a proper comparison with observations can be made . in order to contribute to the understanding of the nature of lgrb host galaxies
, we will also compare these predictions with the properties ( not weighted by host galaxy observability ) of both the sample of all galaxies with mean cold gas metallicities below @xmath82 ( hereafter low metallicity sample ) and the complete galaxy population of the catalogue of @xcite .
as a first step towards understanding the nature of host galaxies , we analyse their stellar masses as a function of redshift . as shown in fig .
[ massred ] , the mean stellar mass of the host galaxies as a function of redshift predicted by scenario ii.3 reproduces the observed mean trend quite well . from this figure
, we can also see that host galaxies are , on average , more massive than galaxies in the complete galaxy population while the latter are more massive than those in the low metallicity sample .
this can be understood taking into account that the host galaxy observability is a strong function of the star formation rate , and that the complete galaxy population in the catalogue of @xcite follows a mass - metallicity relationship ( e.g. * ? ? ?
then , the cut - off adopted for the mean cold gas metallicity to reproduce the observed stellar mass distribution implies a cut - off in stellar mass since low metallicity galaxies are , on average , less massive than the general galaxy population ( see also fig .
[ mass ] ) .
however , as the observability of a host galaxy depends strongly on its star formation activity and most of the small galaxies have low star formation rates , the observable host galaxies tend to be , on average , the more massive ones among them . as a result , our observable sample tends to be populated by systems more massive than those in the low metallicity sample or in the complete galaxy population . in fig .
[ gsfr ] , we display the mean sfr of host galaxies as a function of redshift predicted by scenario ii.3 , together with the corresponding mean values for the low metallicity sample and the complete galaxy population .
as it can be seen , the prediction of scenario ii.3 reproduces very well the behaviour of the observed host galaxies .
these have higher sfr than the mean of the complete galaxy population , and much higher than that of the low metallicity sample .
the good agreement between our scenario ii.3 and observations suggests that the observed host galaxies are biased towards galaxies with stellar masses in the range @xmath83 , high star formation activity and relatively low gas metal content , compared to the mean properties of the complete galaxy population at a given @xmath34 . regarding the mean specific sfr ( ssfr ) , defined as the ratio between the sfr and the stellar mass of a given galaxy ( fig . [ gssfr ] ) ,
host galaxies are predicted to show ssfrs similar to those in the low metallicity sample , and higher than those in the complete galaxy population , for @xmath84 . between @xmath85 and @xmath86 , there are no significant differences in mean ssfrs among the three samples , which have larger ssfrs that low redshift galaxies .
this can be understood because , at higher redshift , galaxies have larger gas reservoirs which can feed stronger star formation activity and are , on average , less chemically enriched . at low redshift ,
host galaxies seem to be particularly efficient at transforming gas into stars .
note , however , that the mean ssfr predicted by scenario ii.3 at low redshift is half an order of magnitude lower than the mean observed ssfr .
observations show that host galaxies tend to be bluer than the general population of galaxies observed at a given redshift , and fainter than a typical @xmath87 galaxy .
in fact , this trend can be nicely reproduced by our scenario ii.3 , as shown in fig .
[ colours ] .
the luminosities and colours of the predicted host galaxies are in excellent agreement with the observations compiled by @xcite . from this figure
, we can see that host galaxies are bluer than the complete galaxy population for @xmath88 , but have similar mean colours for higher redshfits .
our scenario predicts that host galaxies are more luminous systems in the @xmath89-band , compared to the mean luminosity of the global galaxy population at all redshifts .
-band luminosity ( upper panel ) and @xmath90 colour ( lower panel ) as a function of redshift predicted by scenario ii.3 ( dotted line ) with its standard deviation ( shaded grey band ) .
open diamonds represent the observed host galaxies by @xcite , while filled circles correspond to their mean values in redshift intervals of 0.5 . for comparison
, we also include the corresponding mean trends for the low metallicty sample ( dashed line ) and the complete galaxy population ( solid line).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] -band luminosity ( upper panel ) and @xmath90 colour ( lower panel ) as a function of redshift predicted by scenario ii.3 ( dotted line ) with its standard deviation ( shaded grey band ) .
open diamonds represent the observed host galaxies by @xcite , while filled circles correspond to their mean values in redshift intervals of 0.5 . for comparison
, we also include the corresponding mean trends for the low metallicty sample ( dashed line ) and the complete galaxy population ( solid line).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] in fig .
[ metal ] , we compare the mean cold gas metallicity of the host galaxies predicted by scenario ii.3 to different metallicity estimations reported by @xcite . since at @xmath91 it is very difficult to distinguish hii regions with enough resolution , these authors generally measured the optical luminosity - weighted mean metallicity in a galaxy . for consistency ,
host galaxies at @xmath92 were treated by them as the rest of the sample ( i.e. integrating fluxes over the whole galaxy ) . in this figure
, we have included metallicities obtained by using different indicators ( see * ? ? ?
* for more details ) . in some cases ,
absorption lines in the optical afterglow can be used to obtain the metallicity of neutral cold gas along the line of sight of the grb ( the so - called grb - dlas ) .
this is the case of 9 grb - dla systems studied by @xcite , all of them at @xmath93 . in this case , the metallicity could be associated more directly to the metallicity of the host galaxy , contrary to qso - dlas which are associated to hi clouds in the intergalactic medium . at @xmath94 ,
measurements of metallicity by @xcite are derived from hot gas and , in this case , the lower branch solution is preferred for the hosts . as shown in fig .
[ metal ] , the predicted host galaxies metallicities are systematically higher than the grb - dla metallicities .
this might indicate that lgrbs occur in regions of even lower metallicity than the mean metallicity of the cold gas of the host galaxies . in this sense , @xcite , adopting similar hypotheses to generate synthetic lgrb populations , but using full cosmological simulations where the chemical enrichment of baryons was consistently followed with redshift , claimed a metallicity threshold of @xmath95 for the progenitor stars in order to reproduce observations .
more detailed information on the metallicity of individual stellar populations , which also takes into account the inhomogeneities of the interstellar medium , are needed to improve our understanding of this issue ( see @xcite and artale et al . in preparation ) . also along these lines , a work by @xcite compares the metallicity of grb hosts associated to type ic supernovae ( sn ic ) to broad - line sn ic without grb detection at @xmath96 .
the metallicity of sn - grb host galaxies are estimated by computing the nebular oxygen abundance by three different methods . in this case , they directly probe the environments of the progenitors because either they were measured at that location or they correspond to metallicities of homogeneous dwarf galaxies .
@xcite results are in agreement with the values obtained by @xcite and with our own results at low redshifts .
we also include those measured by the r32 upper branch ( triangles ) or lower branch ( diamonds ) , and grb - dlas ( asterisks ) . for comparison , we include the corresponding mean trends for the low metallicty sample ( dashed line ) and the complete galaxy population ( solid line).,scaledwidth=45.0% ]
it is still under discussion if host galaxies are always located in regions of a given characteristic local density or if , depending on @xmath34 , they inhabit different environments .
recently , @xcite estimated the cross - correlation function of their simulated host galaxies finding that these systems tend to map underdense regions .
observations provide somehow contradictory results .
@xcite found host galaxies to inhabit field regions .
lately , @xcite suggested that host galaxies might be biased towards interacting or merging galaxies .
it is yet too soon for observations to provide a robust answer to these questions but theoretical predictions could positively contribute to this area .
the advantage of our model is that taking into account the observability allows us to make a more robust prediction . in this section ,
we investigate the environment of the simulated host galaxies by means of three different estimators .
the distance to the closest neighbour ( @xmath97 ) of a host galaxy provides an estimation of the possibility of a host galaxy being interacting with another galaxy .
the distance to the fifth neighbour ( @xmath98 ) of a host galaxy provides an estimation of the density of the region the galaxy inhabits .
finally , the central halo virial mass ( @xmath99 ) is an estimator of the global potential well to which the host galaxy is bound . in the particular case of the closest neighbour
, it is well known that pair interactions can enhance the star formation activity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and if lgrb progenitors are massive stars this would imply an increase in the probability of detecting a lgrb event .
since semi - analytical codes do not model tidally - induced star formation , we modified the sfr for galaxies with their closest neighbour located at distances smaller than @xmath100 by a factor of two , motivated by observational and numerical results ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . however , this correction does not change any of the trends reported in this work .
but the role of interactions should be further tested with models that properly include their effects .
we estimate the cumulative distribution of these three environmental estimators ( @xmath101 ) predicted by scenario ii.3 . to quantify behaviours as a function of redshift
, we determine the values @xmath102 and @xmath103 at which the corresponding cumulative fractions reach @xmath104 per cent in the case of @xmath97 and @xmath98 , and @xmath105 per cent in the case of @xmath106 . in fig .
[ d1 ] ( upper panel ) , we show @xmath107 as a function of redshift according to scenario ii.3 , together with the trend for the low - metallicity sample and the complete galaxy population . at high redshift ,
the three samples tend to have the nearest neighbour at approximately similar distances .
we only note a slight trend for host galaxies to systematically have a closer first neighbour than galaxies in the other two samples for @xmath108 . from @xmath109 ,
low metallicity galaxies tend to have their closest neighbour further away than either a galaxy in the complete population or a host galaxy .
the latter tend to inhabit lower density regions than galaxies in the complete population .
our models indicate that observable host galaxies would only have a slightly higher probability to be in a galaxy pair compared with the general galaxy population at high redshift ( i.e. @xmath104 per cent of galaxies have the first neighbour closer than @xmath110 ) . the global environment is quantified by @xmath111 . as shown in fig .
[ d1 ] ( middle panel ) at high redshift ( @xmath112 ) , galaxies in the three samples reside in similar environments . for lower redshift
there is a clear trend for galaxies in the low metallicity sample and host galaxies to inhabit lower density regions than galaxies in the complete galaxy population .
this results agree with the numerical work of @xcite , and also with the observational findings of @xcite , taking into account that the mean redshift of lgrbs observed at that time was @xmath113 . in the case of the virial mass , as shown in fig .
[ d1 ] ( lower panel ) , we find that @xmath105 per cent of observable host galaxies have haloes less massive than @xmath114 at any redshift . as the structure forms and groups and clusters aggregate hierarchically , galaxies tend to inhabit larger dark matter haloes .
however , host galaxies stay within a narrower range of mass haloes .
the inversion in the relation observed in this figure can be understood considering that host galaxies observability depends strongly on the star formation activity which , in turn , depends strongly on environment @xcite .
hence , from @xmath85 active star forming galaxies ( i.e. those which are important generators of lgrbs ) with mean stellar masses of @xmath115 reside again in slightly smaller dark matter haloes ( fig .
[ massred ] and fig .
[ gsfr ] ) .
note that this is not the case for the general low metallicity sample which although residing , on average , in smaller haloes than the global galaxy population , tend to systematically inhabit larger ones with decreasing redshift , as expected in a hierarchical scenario .
the observability condition which is closely linked to the star formation activity produces this kind of halo downsizing scenario for host galaxies at low redshift , while the mean stellar mass remains approximately constant . ) . _
middle panel : _ median distance to the fifth neighbour ( @xmath111 ) .
_ left panel : _ virial mass of the central halo at the @xmath105 percentile ( @xmath103).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] ) .
_ middle panel : _ median distance to the fifth neighbour ( @xmath111 ) .
_ left panel : _ virial mass of the central halo at the @xmath105 percentile ( @xmath103).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ] ) . _
middle panel : _ median distance to the fifth neighbour ( @xmath111 ) .
_ left panel : _ virial mass of the central halo at the @xmath105 percentile ( @xmath103).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=45.0% ]
our results indicate that the observed lgrb host galaxies properties can be reproduced assuming that lgrb progenitors are massive stars and occur in galaxies with moderately low mean cold gas metallicities .
the joint requirement for the synthetic lgrbs to reproduce the observations of batse and for the simulated systems that host them to reproduce the stellar mass distribution of the observed host galaxies determines the minimum mass for the progenitor star ( @xmath116 ) if a @xcite imf had been used , instead . ] and the maximum metallicity cut - off ( @xmath117 ) for the cold gas metallicity of the simulated host galaxies .
our scenario ii.3 , which satisfies these conditions , succeeds at reproducing the dependence on redshift of stellar mass , luminosity , colour , sfr , ssfr and metallicity of the observed host galaxies compiled by @xcite over the redshift range @xmath118 .
our main findings are : 1 . the average stellar mass of host galaxies is higher than the average stellar mass of the complete galaxy population , and remains within a narrow mass range around @xmath119 , with a very weak trend to lower mass for higher redshifts , due to the double requirement of low mean gas metallicity and high star formation rates .
we note that the dispersion is approximately 0.5 dex around the @xmath120 mean stellar mass .
2 . compared to the characteristic stellar mass @xmath121 estimated by @xcite , host galaxies are low stellar mass systems ( 88 per cent of our host galaxies have stellar masses between @xmath122 ) .
however , compared to the mean stellar mass of the complete galaxy population , host galaxies tend to be massive galaxies .
the sfr of host galaxies is larger than that of galaxies in the complete population at all redshifts . at @xmath112 ,
the ssfr of observable host galaxies is comparable to the complete galaxy population , but at lower redshift it is systematically higher . as a consequence ,
host galaxies are , on average , bluer than the global galaxy population .
the dispersion found for the properties of the observable host galaxies reflect the different histories of formation of galaxies at a given stellar mass .
4 . our results support the claims for a metallicity threshold to reproduce the properties of the current observed host galaxies .
the global metallicity threshold of @xmath82 we derived from our models is an upper limit for the metallicity of the lgrb progenitor stars in the case of no dust effects .
the comparison of the mean metallicity of host galaxies predicted by our model with grb - dlas observations suggests that lgrbs might be produced in stars of even lower metallicity as pointed out by other authors ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . at low redshift ,
our results are in agreement with sn - grb local metallicity estimations by @xcite .
however , observations show a large spread in metallicity and there are also observational uncertainties that can affect its determination .
hence , results should be taken with caution .
5 . for @xmath123 ,
host galaxies seem to be slightly more likely to be in pairs than galaxies belonging to the other samples . there is , however , a change of behaviour for @xmath124 , where the at least 50 per cent of the host galaxies seems to have their closest neighbour further away than galaxies in the complete population , but closer than galaxies in the low metallicity sample .
we highlight that we are considering neighbouring galaxies of a mass above @xmath125 .
this limit is set by the numerical resolution of the _ millennium simulation_. lower mass companions could also imprint morphological perturbations and trigger star formation activity ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) but we can not pursue this analysis further on with this galaxy catalogue . 6 .
regarding global environment , our model suggests that , at @xmath108 , observable host galaxies would preferentially inhabit environments of similar density to those populated by the general population and of slightly higher density than those inhabited by the low metallicity sample . towards @xmath126 ,
observable host galaxies tend to be progressively located in less dense environments , which becomes as subdense as the regions where low metallicity galaxies reside ( see also * ? ? ? * ) .
our results suggest that observable host galaxies tend to have dark matter haloes in the range @xmath127 , regardless of redshift , and show a slight signal for halo downsizing from @xmath109 , distinguishing them from the other two samples which follow the expected halo mass growth in a hierarchical scenario .
this result is consistent with observable host galaxies being systems with mean stellar masses approximately constant , regardless of the age of the universe .
our results are mainly a consequence of the joint requirements to have high star formation activity to ensure observability and to reproduce the current distribution of stellar masses of observed host galaxies . however , within the current constrains , galaxies with high masses would be too metal - rich to produce lgrbs and low mass systems would have low probability of being observed . if the observed sample were modified by the incorporation of other galaxies , for example dusty hosts , then our model would need to be readjusted accordingly .
we thank m.e . de rossi and gerard lemson for helping us to manage the _ millennium simulation _ , and sandra savaglio for her useful comments and suggestions .
this work was partially supported by grants pict 2005 - 32342 , pict 2006 - 245 max planck , and pict 2006 - 2015 from argentine anpcyt . | in this work , we investigate the nature of the host galaxies of long gamma - ray bursts ( lgrbs ) using a galaxy catalogue constructed from the _ millennium simulation_. we developed a lgrb synthetic model based on the hypothesis that these events originate at the end of the life of massive stars following the collapsar model , with the possibility of including a constraint on the metallicity of the progenitor star . a complete observability pipeline was designed to calculate a probability estimation for a galaxy to be observationally identified as a host for lgrbs detected by present observational facililties .
this new tool allows us to build an observable host galaxy catalogue which is required to reproduce the current stellar mass distribution of observed hosts .
this observability pipeline predicts that the minimum mass for the progenitor stars should be @xmath0 m@xmath1 in order to be able to reproduce batse observations .
systems in our observable catalogue are able to reproduce the observed properties of host galaxies , namely stellar masses , colours , luminosity , star formation activity and metallicities as a function of redshift . at @xmath2 ,
our model predicts that the observable host galaxies would be very similar to the global galaxy population .
we found that @xmath3 per cent of the observable host galaxies with mean gas metallicity lower than @xmath4 have stellar masses in the range @xmath5@xmath6m@xmath1 in excellent agreement with observations .
interestingly , in our model observable host galaxies remain mainly within this mass range regardless of redshift , since lower stellar mass systems would have a low probability of being observed while more massive ones would be too metal - rich .
observable host galaxies are predicted to preferentially inhabit dark matter haloes in the range @xmath7@xmath8m@xmath1 , with a weak dependence on redshift .
they are also found to preferentially map different density environments at different stages of evolution of the universe . at high redshifts ,
the observable host galaxies are predicted to be located in similar environments as the global galaxy population but to have a slightly higher probability to have a close companion .
[ firstpage ] gamma - rays : bursts methods : numerical stars : formation galaxies : evolution , interactions . |
the canonical core accretion theory of planet formation , in which planetesimals collide to form solid cores which then destabilize the surrounding gas to accrete an atmosphere ( safronov 1969 ; pollack et al.1996 ) , has at least two fundamental problems explaining the origins of uranus and neptune .
first , dynamical times in the trans - saturnian solar nebula are so long and solid surface densities @xmath4 are so low ( @xmath5 g @xmath6 ) according to the assumed @xmath7 mass distribution ( pollack et al .
1996 ) that planet growth takes @xmath0 myr , far longer than both observed and theoretical protostellar disk lifetimes ( haisch et al . 2001
; alexander et al .
second , runaway gas accretion begins when solid cores reach 10 to 15 @xmath8 , requiring a sudden and complete gas accretion cutoff just as uranus and neptune reach their current masses .
@xcite pointed out these problems in their seminal paper on the viability of the core accretion theory .
more recently , benvenuto et al . ( 2009 ) showed that uranus and neptune could grow within a few myr in a population of planetesimals with a distribution of radii between 30 and 100 km .
however , planetesimals as small as 30 km are not consistent with the prevailing theory of planetesimal formation , based on the streaming instability , which produces planetesimals around 100 km and in some cases up to the radius of ceres ( 457 km ; johansen et al . 2007 ) .
uranus and neptune s total masses , 14.5 and 17.2 @xmath8 respectively , place them squarely in the predicted critical mass range for nucleating an instability in the surrounding gas and accreting jupiter s mass or more in under 1000 years ( mizuno 1980 ; papaloizou and nelson 2005 ) . _
the first challenge for theorists is to find a combination of the parameters that control core accretion feeding zone location , ice inventory and planetesimal surface density that leads to solid planet cores of _ @xmath9 _ that form within observed protostellar disk lifetimes and are subcritical with respect to the surrounding gas density . _ an ice giant formation theory should also account for the planets bulk composition , particularly their 2050 @xmath10 solar tropospheric c / h ratios ( encrenaz 2005 ) . treating feeding zone location as a free parameter creates the further challenge of moving uranus and neptune into their current orbits .
two previous theories attempted to explain both the timely formation and subsequent orbital evolution of the ice giants .
thommes et al .
( 1999 , 2002 ) proposed that uranus and neptune are failed gas giants that formed between jupiter and saturn .
jupiter scattered the ice giants into orbits with semimajor axes @xmath11 au once it reached runaway gas accretion , while interactions with planetesimals further forced the ice giants slowly outward .
the `` collisional damping scenario '' was put forth by goldreich et al .
( 2004a , 2004b ) . according to goldreich
uranus and neptune formed _ in situ _ from a dynamically cold planetesimal disk that also produced three other proto - ice giants .
the protoplanets formed quickly despite long dynamical times because the planetesimal disk scale height fit within the hill sphere ( the protoplanet s zone of gravitational dominance ) , leading to high solid accretion rates .
dynamical friction could no longer damp the eccentricities of the @xmath12 trans - saturnian oligarchs once they attained a surface density comparable to the surrounding planetesimal disk .
the oligarchs suffered close encounters and the resulting instability ejected all proto - ice giants but uranus and neptune .
the assumptions underlying the order - of - magnitude analysis in goldreich et al .
( 2004a , 2004b ) have ultimately proven unreliable .
@xcite demonstrated that the collisional damping scenario can not reproduce the current solar system : rather than ejecting three of five ice giants , the trans - saturnian protoplanets simply spread out and all planets were retained .
furthermore , the collisional damping scenario requires that oligarchs grow while planetesimals fragment to sizes @xmath13 km . since low - velocity particles ( @xmath14 cm s@xmath15 ) in the collide-2 microgravity experiment burrowed into the target material without producing ejecta ( colwell 2003 )
, there is no reason planetesimals should fragment in the dynamically cold planetesimal disk required to produce uranus and neptune _ in situ_. the thommes et al .
( 1999 , 2002 ) `` failed gas giant '' model has substantial success reproducing the current solar system and does not require finely tuned planetesimal behavior .
studies of planet formation in the 5 - 10 au region demonstrate the efficiency of growing ice giant - sized cores between jupiter and saturn [ @xcite , @xcite ] .
however , the compositions of uranus and neptune strongly indicate an origin in the trans - saturnian solar nebula . tropospheric abundances of methane show carbon enrichments of 2050 times solar ( encrenaz 2005 ) , and interior models find methane mass fractions of @xmath16% ( marley et al . 1995 ; podolak et al .
1995 ) . the combined dynamical and chemical model of the solar nebula calculated by @xcite shows that the methane condensation front is beyond saturn s orbit during the first @xmath17 of solar nebula evolution . without methane ice present during the planetesimal - building epoch which lasts only @xmath18 years according to johansen et al .
2007neither planet could obtain its methane - rich composition .
the nice model of planetary dynamics @xcite , @xcite , @xcite uses initial conditions that place uranus and neptune initially in the methane ice - rich regions beyond 10 au . in the nice model ,
neptune and uranus assume initial semimajor axes of @xmath19 and @xmath20 to 17 au . when planetesimal perturbations pull jupiter and saturn across their 1:2 mean motion resonance ( mmr ) , their eccentricities suddenly increase , forcing close encounters between all possible pairs of giant planets except jupiter and saturn . in about half of the simulations
, neptune is scattered across uranus orbit , leapfrogging to @xmath21 au within a few @xmath22 years .
slow outward migration due to interaction with a planetesimal disk pulls uranus and neptune into their current orbits over the course of @xmath23 myr .
although the nice model explains the current orbits of the giant planets , it is incomplete without an assessment of the planets ability to form in their predicted initial orbits . with high solid surface- density , methane - rich planetesimals , the protostellar disk model of @xcite contains promising initial conditions for ice giant formation between 12 and 15 au .
none of the three dynamical theories discussed the nice model , the failed gas giant theory and the collisional damping scenario treats the growth of the ice giants envelopes , a gap in the literature that this work is partly intended to fill . verifying that @xmath24 solid cores can form is an important step
one which n - body simulations show is extremely difficult even in the inner nebula ( mcneil et al .
2005 ; chambers 2008)but one also has to verify that the ice giant atmospheres stay under @xmath25 of the total planet mass and do not experience runaway growth . in this paper
, we demonstrate that uranus and neptune can form by core accretion , in the feeding zone approximation , in the trans - saturnian solar nebula using the nice model initial semimajor axis distribution . in [ simulation ] we describe the numerical methods used in our experiments . in [ results ] we discuss the results of our core accretion simulations , focusing on formation timescale , accretion efficiency and solid / gas ratio . in [ discussion ] we discuss the strengths and weaknesses of our model as a realistic descriptor of uranus and neptune s formation .
we present our conclusions in [ conclusions ] .
the contraction and buildup of protoplanetary cores and their gaseous envelopes embedded in our model evolving disk are computed with a henyey - type code ( henyey et al .
1964 ) , which solves the standard equations of stellar structure for the envelope .
a detailed description of the core accretion - gas capture code is available in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . here
we explain the initial conditions used for our experiments and give an overview of our numerical method , describing its strengths and weaknesses .
we use a core accretion rate of the form @xmath26 ( papaloizou and terquem 1999 ) , where @xmath27 is the surface density of solid material in the disk , @xmath28 is the orbital frequency at the position of the planet , @xmath29 is the effective capture radius of the protoplanet for solid particles , @xmath30^{1/3}$ ] is the tidal radius of the protoplanet ( where @xmath31 is the semimajor axis of the protoplanet s orbit ) , and @xmath32 is a constant near unity .
our numerical experiments are based on the feeding zone approximation , in which the growing embryo accretes planetesimals from an annulus extending @xmath33 on either side of its semimajor axis ( kary & lissauer 1994 ) .
planetesimals in the feeding zone exit only by being accreted ; they are not scattered out of the system , and they encounter the core at the hill velocity , @xmath34 . as the protoplanet grows , its tidal radius expands to include previously undepleted regions of the solar nebula .
new planetesimals enter the feeding zone as it expands , and the solid surface density evolves according to the competing effects of planetesimal loss by accretion and gain by feeding zone expansion . the fact that the feeding zone model does not include planetesimal loss by scattering limits its accuracy in the trans - saturnian region , where planetesimals may be stirred to velocities near the local escape speed of the solar system ( levison & stewart 2001 ; levison & morbidelli 2007 ) .
we view our core accretion experiments as a `` first pass '' at reconciling the nice model with planet formation theory .
our simulations will tend to overestimate the solid accretion rate , so if we can not form uranus and neptune on a reasonable timescale , the initial conditions in the nice model can not possibly represent uranus and neptune s formation zones .
if we can successfully produce planets with the proper ice giant mass and composition , the detailed planetesimal dynamics at 1215 au will warrant further investigation with n - body simulations .
simulations such as those of chambers ( 2008 ) can establish whether or not the initial @xmath35 seed core can form and resist orbital decay between 12 and 15 au , and whether our low - velocity planetesimals are an adequate approximation .
once the protoplanet reaches @xmath36 it begins to accrete gas at the combined rate at which ( 1 ) its bondi sphere is evacuated due to cooling and contraction , and ( 2 ) its bondi sphere expands due to increasing mass .
gas flows freely from the nebula into the evacuated volume .
the outer boundary conditions of the gaseous atmosphere include the decrease with time in the background nebular density and temperature , modeled by @xcite .
since ice giants are not massive enough to limit their gas accretion by opening a gap in the gaseous disk , we carry the simulations beyond uranus and neptune s present masses in order to assess the likelihood that they remain low - mass ice giants .
since grain settling in the protoplanetary envelope reduces envelope opacity where grains exist ( podolak 2003 ) , we adopt grain opacities of @xmath37 of the interstellar values used in @xcite .
however , @xcite demonstrated that grain opacity has little effect on formation timescale and planet composition in the trans - saturnian region of the solar nebula .
since the ice giants swap orbits in @xmath38 of the nice model simulations , we generically simulate the formation of two ice giants in trans - saturnian orbits without identifying which planet embryo is proto - uranus and which is proto - neptune . in accordance with the initial conditions for the nice model , we place `` planet i '' , the innermost ice giant during the formation epoch , at 12 au . `` planet o '' , the outermost ice giant ,
begins forming at 15 au .
which embryo eventually becomes which planet depends on whether or not the ice giants swap orbits .
solid durface densities available for planet formation are taken from @xcite and are based on a detailed chemical inventory of 211 gas and ice species . to allow for the time needed to build the @xmath39 seed core and the planetesimals
, we adopt a 0.15 myr offset between the initial formation of the solar nebula and the beginning of planet formation ( dodson - robinson et al .
planetesimal formation models based on the streaming instability show that the timescale can be as short as @xmath18 years and is not a strong function of location in the disk ( youdin and goodman 2005 ; johansen et al . 2007 ) , so our 0.15 myr planetesimal and seed embryo formation timescale is realistic .
planet i at 12 au begins forming in a feeding zone with 8.4 g @xmath6 of solids while planet o s feeding zone at 15 au contains 6.4 g @xmath6 of solids .
for comparison , @xcite assumed only 0.75 g @xmath6 of planetesimals were available in uranus _ in situ _ feeding zone at 19 au . since the goal of our simulations is to bridge the initial solar nebula inventory and the final planet composition both bulk gas / solid ratio and measured atomic abundances
our numerical experiments are designed to be as deterministic as possible .
the three `` free parameters '' in our core accretion model are semimajor axis , solid surface density of planetesimals , and atmospheric opacity .
initial planet semimajor axes are taken from the nice model of planetary dynamics so as to be consistent with late - stage orbital evolution ; solid surface densities come from a detailed chemical model whose few free parameters were constrained by observational and laboratory data ; and dodson - robinson et al .
( 2008 ) convincingly demonstrated that atmospheric opacity has little effect on planet composition or formation timescale in the outer solar nebula , where isolation masses are high .
here we are testing whether or not one single disk model ( dodson - robinson et al .
2009 ) can serve as a formation platform for all four giant planets .
if it can , we will have made substantial progress toward determining the physical conditions in the true solar nebula .
figure 1 shows the result of our core accretion simulations .
planet i reaches its present mass in 3.8 myr while planet o requires 5.3 myr to form .
however , there is enough solid material remaining in the nebula to allow the ice giants to continue growing beyond @xmath40 ( neptune ) and @xmath41 ( uranus ) .
one characteristic of planet formation in solid - rich feeding zones is that the solid cores do not reach isolation mass ( dodson - robinson and bodenheimer 2009 ) . in the solid - rich solar nebula of @xcite , planet
i s isolation mass is @xmath42 while planet o s is @xmath43 .
previous simulations of forming planets that do nt reach isolation mass ( dodson - robinson et al .
2008 , dodson - robinson and bodenheimer 2009 ) show that @xmath44 monotonically increases with time .
the canonical phase ii , in which the planet s growth is limited by the rate at which gas can enter the hill sphere ( pollack et al .
1996 , hubickyj et al.2005 ) , does not occur . upon attaining their current masses ,
both planet cores are still subcritical and have yet to trigger rapid gas accretion . here
our results agree with those of rafikov ( 2006 ) , who showed that critical core mass is not simply a constant @xmath45 ( e.g. mizuno 1980 ) , but is a strong function of planetesimal accretion rate , semimajor axis and gas density . in our simulations , the continued fast accretion of planetesimals deposits kinetic energy that stabilizes the ice giant atmospheres against collapse even as the planet masses reach @xmath46 . in the trans - saturnian nebula , dynamical times are so long and isolation masses are so large ( @xmath47 ) that is not possible for any protoplanet to cleanly sweep up the planetesimals in its feeding zone .
if allowed to grow beyond its present mass , planet i would enter rapid gas accretion at 4.3 myr with a total mass of @xmath48 . at 5.7 myr ,
planet o had not yet begun hydrodynamic gas accretion .
we therefore can not evaluate the critical core mass in the feeding zone at 15 au , but suspect it is somewhat higher than on planet i s orbit at 12 au because of the lower nebular gas density .
we calculate that both planets contain 7% hydrogen and helium gas by mass and 93% heavy elements , in agreement with bulk compositions inferred from rotation rates ( podolak and reynolds 1981 , guillot 2005 ) .
is it realistic that all but 1015 @xmath8 of planetesimals are lost from each feeding zone , without forming planet cores ?
if uranus and neptune are to remain at their present masses , the planetesimal - to - planet conversion efficiency in this model is extremely low at 17% for planet i and 9% for planet o. fortunately , we can perform a sanity check on the planet formation efficiency by calculating the accretion - to - ejection probability ratio in the strongly scattering regime , where the protoplanet stirs planetesimals to of order the local solar system escape velocity .
n - body simulations by levison & stewart ( 2001 ) and levison & morbidelli ( 2007 ) show that the strong - scattering assumption is appropriate for the trans - saturnian solar nebula .
ida & lin ( 2004 ) demonstrate that the accretion - to - ejection probability ratio of strongly scattered planetesimals is @xmath49 where the denominator is the square of the typical planetesimal velocity with respect to the core and the numerator is the square of the local escape velocity from the sun . in eq .
[ fcap ] , @xmath50 is the physical radius of the core , not a gravitationally enhanced capture radius .
the probability that a given planetesimal will be scattered , rather than accreted , is therefore @xmath51 for a core density of 3 g @xmath52 and mass @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 at 12 au . at 15 au , @xmath56 and @xmath57
once reaching ice giant mass , growing embryos can accrete less than @xmath58 of the available planetesimals and should reach a stage of self - limited solid accretion .
scattering therefore limits the core masses of uranus and neptune and efficiently clears away the remaining planetesimals .
we have demonstrated that timely formation of uranus and neptune in the trans - saturnian solar nebula , within the @xmath59 myr disk lifetimes found by young cluster observations and photoevaporative models of t - tauri disks ( alexander et al .
2006 ; currie et al .
2009 ) and without extreme planetesimal eccentricity damping ( goldreich et al . 2004a , 2004b ) , is possible in the feeding zone approximation . in this section
we assess the extent to which our core accretion simulations , which use the initial semimajor axes of the nice model and the solid - rich disk of @xcite , provide a realistic picture of the formation of uranus and neptune .
our model s strengths include the ice giants predicted compositions and the fact that both are comfortably below critical mass .
our model s weaknesses are lack of coevality the outer ice giant o requires 1.5 myr more for formation than the inner ice giant i and the simplified description of planetesimal accretion provided by the feeding zone approximation . although our cores stay subcritical and we do not need to cut off hydrodynamic gas accretion to replicate uranus and neptune s gas - poor composition , both planets reach their present masses in the midst of rapid solid accretion , well past the `` elbow '' of the @xmath60 curve ( fig . 1 )
. why should they not continue to grow into massive cores analogous to hd 149026b ( sato et al .
2005 ) ? from fig . 1
, we see that planet i reaches @xmath61 at the end of the simulation . in the feeding zone approximation
, there is nothing to stop it growing to saturn s mass or greater while planet o slowly moves toward @xmath46 .
the simplest explanation is self - limiting accretion due to planetesimal scattering , as discussed in [ results ] .
planet i would reach @xmath62 , begin to scatter far more planetesimals than it accretes , and dramatically slow its core growth . planet o would similarly halt its growth in due course . if a self - regulating mechanism impedes core growth in the trans - saturnian nebula , there may be no need for planet i and planet o to be coeval . based on an accretion - to - ejection probability ratio of 0.1 ( lin & ida 1997 ) , ida & lin ( 2004 ) derive a maximum planet core mass of @xmath63 planet i s core could not grow beyond @xmath64 while planet o s core would be limited to @xmath65 . furthermore , as demonstrated in [ results ] , the accretion rate reduction kicks in before the cores reach their absolute maximum mass .
strong scattering of planetesimals by the growing protoplanets could hold off rapid solid growth long enough for planet o s mass to catch up with planet i s . to demonstrate the effects of planetesimal scattering on ice giant composition and growth rate , we simulated the growth of both planets , this time modifying the accretion rate to take into account planetesimal scattering .
we first calculated the solid growth rate @xmath44 according to equation [ coregrowth ] .
then , since @xmath66 ( equation [ fcap ] ) is defined as the ratio of the probabilities of accretion and ejection for a given planetesimal , it follows that planetesimals are ejected from the feeding zone at a rate of @xmath67 at each timestep , we subtracted the sum of the accreted and the ejected planetesimal mass , @xmath68 , from the total solid feeding zone mass .
figure 2 shows the results of the simulations that include planetesimal ejection . as expected , both ice giants take longer to reach their current masses when their solid accretion is slowed by scattering : planet i forms in 4.0 myr and planet o forms in 6 myr . with self - limiting accretion , however , we risk losing our solid - rich composition .
continual planetesimal accretion is what stabilizes the ice giant atmospheres against hydrodynamic collapse . as demonstrated by hubickyj et al .
( 2005 ) , suddenly cutting off accretion once a planet core reaches @xmath45 _ hastens _ the onset of rapid gas accretion .
we see this behavior in the left panel of figure 2 as planet i , within a few @xmath22 years after reaching ice giant mass , begins to accrete gas at an exponential rate .
since planet i begins to halt clear its feeding zone and slow its solid accretion before planet o finishes forming , it evolves toward jupiter s mass and composition . even where planetesimal scattering is efficient
, we still require a way of halting the innermost ice giant s growth
. strong planetesimal scattering does not mitigate the need for uranus and neptune to form on similar timescales . for planet o , with its formation timescale of 6 myr coming uncomfortably close to the upper limit of protostellar disk lifetimes ( haisch et al.2001 , alexander et al .
2006 ) , it is sensible to speculate that its growth was halted by the dissipation of the solar nebula . even though planet o is primarily accreting solids , rather than gas , between 5 and 6 myr , nebular gas provides eccentricity damping to the planetesimals , helping keep them in the feeding zone . without the gas , the planetesimal velocity dispersion rapidly increases , cutting off solid accretion except in the case of stochastic , high - velocity collisions ( e.g. fernandez and ip 1984 ) .
such a collision could be responsible for uranus extreme rotation axis tilt .
postulating the dissipation of the nebula as the mechanism for halting planet o s solid growth , however , does nothing to rectify the coevality problem .
a second possibility for keeping both ice giants at the same mass is that planet i was scattered to a wide orbit with correspondingly long dynamical time and low surface density during the dynamical instability of the four outer planets . in roughly half of the nice model simulations , neptune and uranus cross orbits , with neptune ( corresponding to planet i in this scenario ) moving from @xmath69 to @xmath21 au in about @xmath22 years . given the long orbital timescale at 23 au ( 110 years vs. 41 years at 12 au ) , neptune s accretion would be nearly cut off , especially in light of its subsequent outward migration due to planetesimal scattering . although the authors of the nice model use the jupiter
saturn 1:2 mmr crossing to explain the late heavy bombardment occurring 600 myr after the birth of the solar system ( gomes et al .
2005 ) , this resonance crossing could have occurred at any time ( or multiple times ) during the evolution of the solar nebula . if the jupiter - saturn 1:2 mmr crossing caused the ice giants to remain at similar masses by halting planet i s accretion
, neptune must have formed interior to uranus . within the feeding zone approximation ,
there is no entirely satisfying way to explain why uranus and neptune have nearly the same mass .
more detailed n - body simulations are needed to investigate the degree to which the ice giants limit their own accretion in the 1215 au region of the solar nebula .
although traditional core accretion - gas capture simulations can not entirely explain the coeval formation of the ice giants without requiring an external growth - limiting mechanism , they still provide strong constraints on the conditions required to produce ice giants . in this section , we discuss the characteristics of feeding zones that can produce solid - rich , gas - poor planets .
in section [ results ] we showed that by keeping uranus and neptune s cores subcritical , we reproduce their solid - rich compositions of @xmath70 solid by mass ( podolak and reynolds 1981 ) without needing to halt gas accretion during the extremely short hydrodynamic growth phase .
we also bypass the long opacity - limited gas contraction phase ( phase ii ) , which lasted @xmath71 myr in the simulations of @xcite , because our ice giants never reach isolation mass .
protoplanetary envelope opacity should not substantially affect the formation timescale or bulk composition of uranus or neptune ( dodson - robinson et al .
the solid / gas ratios we calculate are therefore insensitive to the composition and size of grains in the ice giant envelopes .
figures 2 suggests that continual planetesimal accretion is required to limit the mass of the protoplanet atmosphere .
rapid gas accretion begins as soon as planet i s solid growth rate begins to level off , at the inflection point of the @xmath72 curve . the more massive the protoplanet , the more thermal energy is required to stabilize its atmosphere .
our results suggest that _ once a protoplanet core grows beyond the fiducial critical core mass of _
@xmath73 _ it will trigger runaway gas accretion unless its solid accretion rate keeps increasing with time .
_ indeed , we conducted one experiment in which solid accretion was suddenly cut off after 3.5 myr of planet growth with a core mass of @xmath74 . as expected from the results of hubickyj et al .
( 2005 ) , the onset of rapid gas accretion was immediate . to keep the solid / gas mass ratio high and ensure the planetary composition
does not become jupiter - like , a large supply of available planetesimals is critical .
planetesimals could either come from the initial feeding zone or be accreted as the protoplanet migrates into undepleted regions of the disk ( alibert et al .
we tested the effect of planetesimal availability on final planet composition by varying the initial solid surface density in the feeding zones and calculating the solid / gas ratio once the protoplanet reached ice giant mass ( @xmath41 for uranus and @xmath40 for neptune ) .
these tests included planetesimal scattering in the accretion rate calculation .
high values of initial planetesimal surface density @xmath75 ensure that either the feeding zone will never be depleted of planetesimals , or in the case of migration , mimic a protoplanet always moving into areas of the solar nebula with a fresh planetesimal supply .
figure 3 shows solid / gas ratio as a function of @xmath75 .
since we do not know which ice giant formed in which feeding zone , we calculate pairs of solid / gas ratios for each initial value of @xmath75 , one corresponding to the final mass of uranus and the other to the final mass of neptune . for both feeding zones , at distances of 12 and 15 au , solid / gas ratios within 25% of the fiducial ice giant composition of @xmath76 solids
can only be reached for a narrow range of initial surface densities between 6 and 11 g @xmath6 . note that while pollack et al .
( 1996 ) reproduced uranus composition by requiring the planet to form _ in situ _ in a 19 au feeding zone with only @xmath77 g @xmath6 of planetesimals , its formation timescale was 16 myr far longer than observed protostellar disk lifetimes . for surface densities from 6 to 11 g @xmath6
, we find formation timescales of 8.82.9 myr at 12 au and from 9.53.0 myr at 15 au .
_ solid - rich feeding zones with
_ @xmath78
g @xmath6 _ at positions consistent with the nice model can give both appropriate formation timescales and bona fide ice giant compositions .
_ even though we require that planetesimals always be present in the ice giant feeding zones as long as the gas disk lasts , our work does not necessarily conflict with the nice model results .
gomes et al .
( 2005 ) invoke a sharp inner edge of the planetesimal distribution at 15.3 au in order to delay the onset of jupiter and saturn s 1:2 mmr crossing and allow the resulting dynamical shakeup to coincide with the late heavy bombardment 700 myr after the birth of the solar system .
their figure 1b shows that the time of the 1:2 mmr crossing is a strong function of the location of the inner disk edge : the greater the distance between jupiter and saturn and the planetesimals that perturb their orbits , the smaller the perturbations to the gas giant orbits and the longer it takes to force them through the resonance .
gomes et al . chose 15.3 au because planetesimals outside that radius have a dynamical lifetime , defined as the time required for the planetesimal to pass within the hill sphere of a planet , longer than their assumed gas disk lifetime of 3 myr .
however , in order to build the planets , the dynamical lifetime of planetesimals in their feeding zones can not possibly be longer than the nebula lifetime
otherwise , no protoplanet could ever grow . for a planetesimal disk with an inner edge at 12 au , coinciding with our innermost ice giant
, we see from figure 1 of gomes et al .
( 2005 ) that the time till jupiter and saturn s 1:2 mmr crossing is @xmath59 myr .
tsiganis et al .
( 2005 ) found a 6 myr lag time between the beginning of their simulations and the 1:2 mmr crossing .
our simulations demonstrate that the orbital evolution of the giant planets must take place shortly after uranus and neptune finish forming .
sculpting the planetesimal distribution to allow the giant planets orbital evolution to trigger the late heavy bombardment does not allow uranus and neptune to retain their solid - rich composition . in the @xcite solid - rich disk model ,
the methane condensation front is at 10 au at the beginning of planet formation .
any planetesimals beyond 10 au contain 10% methane ice by mass .
@xcite calculated a series of ice giant interior models using three concentric layers : a rock+metal core , an ice shell with h@xmath79o , ch@xmath80 , nh@xmath81 and h@xmath79s in solar proportions , and an atmosphere of h@xmath79 , he and small amounts of the aforementioned ices . for both planets , the models that best reproduced the gravitational moments measured by
_ voyager _ had ice shells of @xmath82 .
podolak et al
. found that total methane mass fraction in the ice giants is @xmath16% , whereas our simulations construct planets that are @xmath83% methane by mass .
the reason for this discrepancy is that we include refractory chon material in the planet cores , while podolak et al.assume iron and silicate cores .
we calculate total carbon mass fractions of @xmath84 , in agreement with those derived by @xcite and @xcite .
_ we have thus created the first planet formation model to reproduce the observed carbon enrichment of both ice giants ( encrenaz 2005 ) .
_ we predict that the methane present on triton s surface ( e.g. hicks and buratti 2004 ) and in the ice giant atmospheres was accreted as ice from the primordial solar nebula .
the saturn formation model of dodson - robinson et al.(2008 ) came to the same conclusion about the ammonia ice present in saturnian satellites ( prentice 2007 ; freeman et al .
2007 ) .
the fact that we have reproduced uranus and neptune s bulk composition and carbon enrichment so closely places an important constraint on their feeding zone location : the presence of methane ice in planetesimals is required during the ice giant formation epoch . based on both chemically evolving models of the solar nebula ( dodson - robinson et al .
2009 ) and the relatively carbon - poor compositions of jupiter and saturn ( encrenaz 2005)which indicate that they did not form in methane ice - rich regions_we can reject any formation model in which the ice giants form inward of saturn s orbit . _
we have shown that it is possible to assemble uranus and neptune from @xmath39 seed cores in a @xmath85 solar nebula , with initial semimajor axes of 12 au and 15 au as predicted by the nice model ( gomes et al .
2005 ; morbidelli et al . 2005 ; tsiganis et al .
the resulting growth timescales are 3.8 myr for the innermost ice giant and 5.3 myr for the outermost ice giant .
however , numerous details still remain to be fully resolved : 1 .
what is the migration history of the planets after formation and can we explain the current orbits ? 2 . if planets i and o do not change places , how can planet i s lack of a massive gaseous atmosphere be explained ?
if planets i ( neptune ) is scattered to a wide orbit while the disk is still gas - rich , what happens to planet o ( uranus ) ?
4 . how can the late heavy bombardment be explained if the giant planets orbital evolution must take place soon after they finish forming ? because we chose the initial semimajor axes of the nice model , both ice giants post - formation orbital evolution may be explained according to that model .
if uranus and neptune form between 12 and 15 au in the feeding zone approximation , they end up with either different formation timescales or different masses . if the proto - ice giants begin limiting their own solid accretion rates by ejecting planetesimals , the outermost planet core can continue to grow after the innermost core has assembled the bulk of its mass , but the inner planet may evolve into a gas giant .
one way to form uranus and neptune at 12 au and 15 au but keep their near - equal masses may be for neptune ( the innermost planet in this scenario ) to get scattered out to a wide orbit upon reaching its present mass but in this scenario we can not be assured of uranus survival and continued growth .
one way our results differ from the scenario described by the nice model suite of papers is that the orbital evolution of the giant planets must take place shortly after uranus and neptune finish forming .
no disk where uranus and neptune fall in a gap in the planetesimal distribution _ at any time during their growth _ can form planets with @xmath86 solids by mass . as stated in
[ discussion ] , we still lack a mechanism for checking planet i s growth while planet o finishes forming .
if neptune is the innermost ice giant , jupiter and saturn s 1:2 mmr crossing might perform such a function by suddenly sending neptune into an extremely wide orbit .
the formation timescale of the ice giant forming at 15 au is quite close to both the upper limit of observed protostellar disk lifetimes ( haisch et al .
2001 ; currie et al . 2009 ) and the predicted onset of photoevaporation for the solar nebula ( alexander et al .
2006 ) , indicating that quick ice giant formation in the trans - saturnian nebula is only marginally possible even in the optimistic feeding zone approximation .
since the compositions of uranus and neptune strongly indicate that they originated in the trans - saturnian solar nebula , however , we encourage more detailed n - body investigations of embryo growth rates between 12 and 15 au . without knowing for sure whether uranus and neptune swapped orbits
, we can not pair each planet with its unique formation zone .
however , the chemically evolving solar nebula simulations of @xcite show that the co and n@xmath79 ice lines fall between 12 and 15 au . detailed measurements of the carbon and nitrogen abundances of both planets and their satellites could resolve the question of which planet formed outermost in the solar nebula : the planet that formed near 15 au should be slightly more carbon- and nitrogen - rich than the planet that formed near 12 au
. such detailed measurements of uranus and neptune s atmospheric compositions await another space mission to the outer planets , but ground - based spectroscopy of their satellites ( e.g. stern & mckinnon 2000 ; bauer et al .
2002 ) may make some progress on this question .
our formation model reproduces the ice giants solid / gas ratios and carbon abundances inferred from gravitational moment measurements and spectroscopy .
our results indicate that planet formation in the outer nebula is a fundamentally inefficient process . even in the feeding zone approximation , where we calculate what is best viewed as an upper limit to accretion rate , building ice giants within the lifetime of the solar nebula requires substantially more solid and gas mass than the planet can ever accrete .
the dynamical times in the massive @xcite disk ( total mass @xmath85 ) beyond 15 au are still too long to allow gas or ice giant formation . from the combined constraints of the methane ice line location and the upper limits to ice giant growth rates
, we can constrain the ice giant formation zone to between 10 and 15 au .
the fact that the solar nebula model of @xcite can form all the giant planets at locations at or near those predicted by the nice model , as well as reproduce important features of the compositions of the planets and their satellites such as ammonia enrichment in the saturnian system ( dodson - robinson et al .
2008)indicates that substantial progress has been made at modeling the ice inventory and chemical evolution of the solar nebula .
here we have created the first successful progression ( to the best of our knowledge ) from primordial solar system ice inventory to detailed planet composition .
this research marks a substantial step forward in connecting both the dynamical and chemical aspects of planet formation .
although we can not say that the solid - rich solar nebula model ( dodson - robinson et al.2009 ) gives _ exactly _ the appropriate initial conditions for planet formation , rigorous chemical and dynamical tests have at least revealed it to be a _
viable _ model of the early solar system .
support for s.d.r.s work was provided by nasa through the spitzer space telescope fellowship program .
p.b . received support from the nasa origins grant nnx08ah82 g .
we thank both referees for comments that improved the clarity and focus of the manuscript .
alexander , r. d. , clarke , c. j. , pringle , j. e. 2006 .
photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs - ii .
evolutionary models and observable properties .
monthly notices of the royal astronomical society 369 , 229 - 239 .
bauer , j. m. , roush , t. l. , geballe , t. r. , meech , k. j. , owen , t. c. , vacca , w. d. , rayner , j. t. , jim , k. t. c. 2002 .
the near infrared spectrum of miranda : evidence of crystalline water ice .
icarus 158 , 178 - 190 .
currie , t. , lada , c. j. , plavchan , p. , robitaille , t. p. , irwin , j. , kenyon , s. j. 2009 .
the last gasp of gas giant planet formation : a spitzer study of the 5 myr old cluster ngc 2362 .
astrophysical journal 698 , 1 - 27 .
stern , s. a. , mckinnon , w. b. 2000 .
triton s surface age and impactor population revisited in light of kuiper belt fluxes : evidence for small kuiper belt objects and recent geological activity .
astronomical journal 119 , 945 - 952 .
thommes , e. w. , bryden , g. , wu , y. , rasio , f. a. 2008 . from mean motion resonances to scattered planets : producing the solar system , eccentric exoplanets , and late heavy bombardments .
astrophysical journal 675 , 1538 - 1548 | the core accretion theory of planet formation has at least two fundamental problems explaining the origins of uranus and neptune : ( 1 ) dynamical times in the trans - saturnian solar nebula are so long that core growth can take @xmath0 myr , and ( 2 ) the onset of runaway gas accretion that begins when cores reach @xmath1 necessitates a sudden gas accretion cutoff just as uranus and neptune s cores reach critical mass .
both problems may be resolved by allowing the ice giants to migrate outward after their formation in solid - rich feeding zones with planetesimal surface densities well above the minimum - mass solar nebula .
we present new simulations of the formation of uranus and neptune in the solid - rich disk of @xcite using the initial semimajor axis distribution of the nice model ( gomes et al .
2005 ; morbidelli et al . 2005 ; tsiganis et al .
2005 ) , with one ice giant forming at 12 au and the other at 15 au .
the innermost ice giant reaches its present mass after 3.8 - 4.0 myr and the outermost after 5.3 - 6 myr , a considerable time decrease from previous one - dimensional simulations ( e.g. pollack et al .
1996 ) .
the core masses stay subcritical , eliminating the need for a sudden gas accretion cutoff .
our calculated carbon mass fractions of @xmath2 are in excellent agreement with the ice giant interior models of @xcite and @xcite . based on the requirement that the ice giant - forming planetesimals contain @xmath3 mass fractions of methane ice
, we can reject any solar system formation model that initially places uranus and neptune inside of saturn s orbit .
we also demonstrate that a large population of planetesimals must be present in both ice giant feeding zones throughout the lifetime of the gaseous nebula .
this research marks a substantial step forward in connecting both the dynamical and chemical aspects of planet formation .
although we can not say that the solid - rich solar nebula model of dodson - robinson et al .
( 2009 ) gives _ exactly _ the appropriate initial conditions for planet formation , rigorous chemical and dynamical tests have at least revealed it to be a _
viable _ model of the early solar system . |
nowadays , it has been prevailing in both experimental and theoretical explorations that quantum coherence effect due to the role of phase in quantum superposition may exist in living processes .
this essentially implies that there may exist quantum coherence effect in chemical reactions in some living processes , such as charge and energy transfer in photosynthesis @xcite and singlet - and - triplet transition in avian compass @xcite .
it has long been questioned how migratory birds can navigate to their destination over hundreds of miles .
one of the possible answers is given by the radical pair mechanism @xcite .
two unpaired electron spins in the radical pair are initially prepared in the singlet state . due to their interactions with the geomagnetic field and their environmental nuclear spins
, the election spins coherently transit between the singlet and triplet states .
since the singlet and triplet states could result in different products of chemical reactions , the direction and magnitude of the geomagnetic field determine the relative yields of two distinct products . by sensing the information incorporated in the final products of the chemical reactions in their retinas
, the birds can find their way to their destination .
therefore , the quantum coherence underlies in the avian compass since the singlet and triplet spin states correspond to different types of quantum entanglement .
ever since it was proposed a decade ago , the radical - pair - mechanism - based avian compass has been in favor by a series of biological and chemical experiments @xcite . in this hypothesis ,
the nuclear spins play a crucial role because there would be no coherent transition between the singlet and the triplet states if there were no nuclear spins @xcite .
previous studies mainly concentrated on the nuclear - spin environment without inter - coupling @xcite .
mostly recently , by taking into account the inter - coupling of the nuclear spins , we studied a special avian compass model with the nuclear environments modeled by an ising model in a transverse field @xcite .
the rationality of this model lies in the fact that the weak inter - nuclear - spin coupling is comparable with the zeeman energy splitting induced by the weal geomagnetic field .
it was discovered that the quantum criticality in the environments enhances the sensitivity of magneto - reception . on the other hand , although various master - equation approaches were proposed to deal with such spin - dependent chemical reactions in the avian compass @xcite , the underlying physical mechanism is still missing in studying the quantum coherence with microscopic models .
thus , it is urgent to propose appropriate microscopic models for different kinds of chemical reactions to make the quantum coherence effect in those processes better understood .
a case in point is the holstein s molecular crystal model , which is also regarded as a microscopic model of chemical reactions with electron transfer ( et ) @xcite .
the holstein model was originally proposed to characterize the vibration - assisted et in one - electron molecular crystal @xcite . here , in order to describe the chemical reaction of spin dependence as well as direction dependence , the holstein model is generalized to incorporate the degrees of freedom of spin to make electrons naturally interact with a magnetic field . additionally ,
due to the presence of the nuclear - spin environments surrounding the electron spins , there would be coherent transition between the singlet and triplet states of the two electron spins .
in contrast to the previous investigation using anisotropic hyperfine coupling @xcite , the hyperfine interaction between the electron spin and its nuclear environment is isotropic in our model . based on this generalized model ,
we calculate the chemical reaction rates of the singlet and triplet states of the electron spins . here , the chemical reaction rate is determined by the transition rate of one electron in a localized molecular orbit to another at a distance .
it is discovered that the reaction rate of the triplet state sensitively responses to the variation of the direction of the magnetic field with respect to the polarization of two electron spins . on the contrary ,
the chemical reaction of the singlet state does not demonstrate such dependence on the direction of the magnetic field .
the above results are attributed to the invariance of the singlet state under the rotation of the system around @xmath0-axis , while the triplet one will be changed along with the rotation according to irreducible tensor of @xmath1 group .
therefore , our proposed model may serve as a microscopic origin for the chemical reaction in the avian compass . in the next section ,
we generalize the holstein model to incorporate the electron spin degrees . in sec .
iii , we consider a general case with an external magnetic field and nuclear - spin environments . in sec .
iv , we study the dynamic evolution of the radical pair and obtain the chemical reaction rates for different initial states .
finally , we summarize our main results in the conclusion . furthermore , we show the detailed calculations for the chemical reaction probability , the chemical reaction rate and the transition probability from the triplet state to the singlet state in appendix a and b respectively .
many chemical reactions are accompanied by et , where the electron is transfered from one site to another ( fig . 1 ) .
a very important but simple quantum - mechanical model for et reactions is the molecular crystal model , which was originally developed by holstein to describe so - called polaron motion in narrow - band conductors @xcite and then understood as a microscopic model in describing simple chemical reactions @xcite .
the model hamiltonian @xmath2 is decomposed into two parts , i.e. , the ionic vibration part @xmath3 and the electron - phonon hybrid part @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the displacement of the @xmath6th ion , @xmath7 the harmonic vibration frequency with the reduced mass @xmath8 , @xmath9 the coupling constant of the two molecules , and @xmath10 the fermionic annihilation ( creation ) operator of the electron at molecule @xmath6 with spin @xmath11 .
since the orbital energy @xmath12 is linearized as @xmath13 we explicitly obtain the electronic hamiltonian @xmath14 and the electron - vibration coupling @xmath15 here , the molecular orbital energy @xmath16 is spin - independent . in the next section
, we will consider a more general case with an external magnetic field .
the tunneling integral @xmath17 is assumed to be independent of the displacement @xmath5 and @xmath18 denotes the electron - vibration coupling , where the term @xmath19 for @xmath20 is neglected because the molecular orbital energy of the @xmath6th molecule changes negligibly when the displacement of the @xmath21th molecule varies .
for simplicity , we assume two identical molecules , i.e. , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 . choosing coordinates @xmath25 and @xmath26 , we decompose the hamiltonian @xmath27 into two decoupled parts , i.e. , the one for the motion of the center of mass @xmath28 with @xmath29 , and the other for the relative motion @xmath30 where we have introduced the bosonic operators @xmath31 @xmath32 is the effective frequency .
next , we make the van vleck transformation , also called the polaron transformation @xcite , @xmath33 for the above generalized holstein model , where @xmath34 is the transformation kernel and @xmath35 thus we can formally decouple the degrees of freedom of electron and vibration , obtaining @xmath36 , with @xmath37 and @xmath38 this molecular crystal hamiltonian ( [ eq : holstein ] ) describes the et process for a two - local - orbit system . here , we generalize the holstein model by taking into consideration the degrees of freedom of the electron spins . up to now
, the above generalization seems to be trivial , since we could totally separate the spin and orbital degrees of freedom .
however , when a local external magnetic field is applied to the radical pair to form asymmetric couplings to the two electron spins , the spin - orbit coupling is induced . in this case
, a spin - dependent et process takes place .
these asymmetric couplings can also be implemented by coupling to their nuclear - spin environments .
in the previous section , we described the generalized holstein model , with spin degree of freedom . in this section , on account of an external magnetic field and nuclear - spin environments , we investigate how a chemical reaction responses to its magnetic environment . choosing the polarization direction of the spin state as the @xmath39-direction
, we define the singlet state @xmath40 and triplet state @xmath41 of the electron spins as @xmath42 and @xmath43 respectively with @xmath44 being the vacuum state .
-direction is @xmath45 , and the coordinate system is rotated around the @xmath0-axis with @xmath45 to coincide with the direction of the the magnetic field .
the hyperfine coupling induced interconversion between the singlet and triplet states is modulated by the direction of the magnetic field , i.e. , @xmath45.,width=302 ] in a simple case where the hyperfine couplings are isotropic , the hamiltonian , which describes the interaction between the electron spins and their asymmetric magnetic environments ( the magnetic field plus the nuclear spins ) , reads @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the external geomagnetic field with the inclination angle @xmath45 , @xmath48 the bohr magneton , @xmath49 the pauli operators for @xmath6th electron spin , @xmath50 the pauli operators for @xmath6th nuclear spin , and @xmath51 the hyperfine coupling constant between the @xmath6th electron spin and its environmental nuclear spin . combining the relative vibration and spin hamiltonians , the total hamiltonian for a spin - dependent et reaction
is obtained @xmath52 . after a rotation around @xmath0-axis with the angle @xmath45 ( fig .
2 ) , combined with the van vleck transformation defined in eq .
( [ van vleck transformation ] ) , we obtain @xmath53 , where the relative vibration hamiltonian @xmath54 is the same as that given in eqs .
( [ eq : holstein]-[holstein1 ] ) , but the hamiltonian of the spin part is changed into meanwhile , we make the same rotation and transformation for the quantum states of the whole system as in eq .
( [ van vleck transformation ] ) .
straightforwardly , after the combined transformation , the singlet and triplet states read as @xmath56 and latexmath:[\ ] ] the eigenfunction of @xmath142 is approximated to the first order as @xmath143 with @xmath144 while the eigen energy is obtained to the second order as @xmath145 as a result , the time evolution operator is approximated as @xmath146 neglecting the the second - order terms , we obtain the conversion probability as @xmath147 where the coefficients @xmath148 are listed in table iii . | some chemical reactions are described by electron transfer ( et ) processes .
the underlying mechanism could be modeled as a polaron motion in the molecular crystalthe holstein model . by taking spin degrees of freedom into consideration
, we generalize the holstein model ( molecular crystal model ) to microscopically describe an et chemical reaction . in our model ,
the electron spins in the radical pair simultaneously interact with a magnetic field and their nuclear - spin environments . by virtue of the perturbation approach ,
we obtain the chemical reaction rates for different initial states .
it is discovered that the chemical reaction rate of the triplet state demonstrates its dependence on the direction of the magnetic field while the counterpart of the singlet state does not .
this difference is attributed to the explicit dependence of the triplet state on the direction when the axis is rotated .
our model may provide a possible candidate for the microscopic origin of avian compass . |
in the case of most pulsars , their observed radio spectra can be described using a power law with a negative spectral index of @xmath01.8 or ( for a small fraction of sources ) two power laws with spectral indices of @xmath00.9 and @xmath02.2 with a break frequency @xmath1 on average of 1.5 ghz @xcite .
some pulsars also exhibit a low - frequency turnover in their spectra @xcite .
a spectrum of that kind is characterized by a positive spectral index below a peak frequency @xmath2 of about 100 mhz ( with a few exceptions when the spectrum peaks at frequencies up to several hundred mhz ) .
however , @xcite pointed out a small sample of pulsars that peak around 1 ghz and above .
such an object , called the gigahertz - peaked spectrum ( gps ) pulsar , is described as a relatively young source that has a high dispersion measure ( dm ) and usually adjoins a dense , sometimes extreme vicinity .
this suggests that the gps in pulsars might be caused by either the conditions around neutron stars or the physical properties of the interstellar medium .
the strongest argument for environmental origin of the high - frequency turnover in radio pulsars spectra is the evolution of psr b1259@xmath063 spectrum .
@xcite showed that the spectrum of the pulsar at the various orbital phases exhibits both a shape and a peak frequency evolution due to the orbital motion of the pulsar around its companion be star ls 2883 on a very elliptical orbit .
the psr b1259@xmath063 spectrum demonstrates a strong similarity with the gigahertz - peaked spectra , especially when the pulsar in its motion gets closer to its companion star .
@xcite proposed two effects which can be responsible for the observed variations , the free - free absorption in the stellar wind and the cyclotron resonance in the magnetic field associated with the disk of be star .
both these processes assume the absorption to be caused by external factors , like in the cases of the isolated gps pulsars @xcite .
@xcite studied the radio spectra of two magnetars psrs j1550@xmath05418 and j1622@xmath04950 and in both cases their radio spectra clearly peak at the frequencies of a few ghz .
both these magnetars are associated with supernova remnants and hence surrounded by ionized gas which can be responsible for the free - free absorption of the radio waves .
the authors concluded that the gps feature in radio magnetars spectra can be of environmental origin , in the same way as it occurs in the vicinity of gps pulsars .
pulsars with a high - frequency turnover in their spectra have represented the smallest group of the radio pulsar spectra types .
however , @xcite estimated that the number of such sources may constitute up to 10% of the whole pulsar population .
the sample of gps pulsars was extended to include psr j2007 + 2722 , whose flux density measurements were presented by @xcite . recently , @xcite reported two newly - identified gps pulsars .
one of them , psr b1740 + 1000 , is the first low - dm pulsar that exhibits the gigahertz - peaked spectrum .
this case , along with the gps phenomenon in radio magnetars , led the authors to conclude that the gps candidate selection criteria need to be revisited .
in future searches for new gps pulsars , the presence of interesting ( or extreme ) environments , instead of the high dm , could play a crucial role in the source selection process .
@xcite also pointed out that the small number of the currently known gps pulsars may be the result of our limited knowledge of pulsar spectra in general , especially below 1 ghz .
the authors outlined the need for a more extensive sample of gps sources to establish a plausible statistics about those objects .
however , in the cases of some gps candidate pulsars the standard pulsar flux measurement methods are affected by strong scattering at low frequencies .
the phenomenon causes the pulse profiles to become broader , i.e. pulses attain roughly exponentially decaying scattering tail .
it has been shown that the characteristic broadening of the pulse , @xmath3 , depends on both the observing frequency , as well as dm ( the empirical relation was given by @xcite @xcite ) .
recent results on scattering were discussed by @xcite in their analysis of 45 pulsars , based on the giant metrewave radio telescope ( gmrt ) and the effelsberg radio telescope observations .
since the scattering becomes stronger at lower frequencies , for a given pulsar the flux becomes increasingly underestimated then . for high - dm pulsars at low frequencies ,
when the scattering time is greater than the pulsar period by a significant factor , one will see no pulsed emission .
thus , the flux density measurements required to construct radio pulsar spectra using traditional " methods can be difficult or sometimes impossible to conduct .
for these cases the only way to determine the pulsar flux is using the interferometric imaging techniques ( see for example @xcite @xcite ) .
the interferometric measurements of pulsar fluxes at both 325 mhz and 610 mhz using the gmrt have been demonstrated in @xcite and @xcite .
the imaging techniques provide a superior alternative to the standard flux measurements , especially in our studies since the sources we selected for observations are high - dm pulsars .
for some of them the imaging techniques are the only secure means to estimate their flux .
there is at least two reasons for employing imaging techniques .
firstly , flux calibration in an interferometer is more robust due to the baseline lying at zero level thereby reducing errors made during the baseline subtraction of a normal pulsar observation .
secondly , the instrumental and atmospheric gain fluctuations on very short time scales can be corrected using self - calibration of the interferometric data .
the corrections are determined by flux densities of constant and bright background sources in the field and hence would not be affected by the pulse variation of the relatively weak pulsar at a field center . in this paper we present flux measurements of six pulsars observed at the 610 mhz frequency band of the gmrt using interferometric imaging technique .
the sources selected for our studies are gps pulsars or gps candidates .
we chose the 610 mhz band for these studies , firstly , because the frequency is low enough to estimate whether a given object is indeed a gps pulsar , secondly , due to the higher probability of detecting gps pulsars at 610 mhz than at lower frequencies as a result of their inverted spectra at sub - ghz frequencies and finally , to avoid the rfi and other systematic effects that are prominent at lower frequencies .
this analysis allowed us to inspect flux densities of some objects and select a strong gps candidate pulsar .
we were able to confirm that the the interferometric imaging technique can be successfully applied to estimate flux density of pulsars .
24 and b1849 + 00 at the field centers were identified and their average flux across the three sessions were calculated .
the ratio of the flux of each source with respect to the average flux and as a function of the average flux is plotted in the figure , with each session marked with different symbols .
the ratios are scattered around unity with the noise in the scatter decreasing with the increasing flux levels .
this demonstrates the analysis process to be correct and consistent for all the three observing sessions.,width=321 ] we recorded the interferometric data on six pulsars using the gmrt that is located near pune , india and consists of an array of 30 distinct dishes , each with a diameter of 45 meters , and a total of 435 baselines .
the dishes are spread out over a region of @xmath4 27 km and roughly resemble a y - shaped array .
the data were recorded at the 610 mhz frequency band with a bandwidth of 33 mhz spread over 256 frequency channels .
all the six sources were observed on three separate dates : 30 december 2012 , 6 january 2013 and 13 january 2013 , each observation separated by a week , to account for variations in the pulsar flux over long time scales .
the observations were carried out using standard schemes where strategically placed calibrators were interspersed with the sources .
we recorded flux calibrators 3c48 and 3c286 before and after each observing run for 10 min .
the antenna gain variations were determined using a phase calibrator observed every half hour .
the sources in our sample are nearby in terms of their position in the sky and the phase calibrator 1822@xmath0096 was used for all the sources to carry out amplitude and phase calibrations as well as bandpass calibration to correct for variation across frequency band .
each of the pulsars was observed for 10 minutes at a time and six such observations on each source were well spaced out during each of the observing sessions which lasted for about eight hours .
we recorded one hour of data on each pulsar during each observing run with all the sources having a wide coverage in the u - v plane due to our strategy of spacing out their pointings .
the data reduction was done using the astronomical image processing system ( aips ) where we used standard techniques of rfi flagging , calibration and imaging .
the flux scales were determined using the measurements of @xcite with latest corrections by perley et al .
2010 ( in aips ) .
all the pulsar fields during each observing run was passed through multiple rounds of self - calibration and imaging to improve noise characteristics in the maps .
the following checks were performed to test the fidelity of the images : + 1 .
the flux of the source 1822@xmath0096 ( phase calibrator ) was determined for each of the three observing sessions using both the flux calibrators 3c48 and 3c286 .
the flux value for each of the sessions were [email protected] on 30 december 2012 , [email protected] on 6 january 2013 and [email protected] on 13 january 2013 .
this shows that the various independent calibrations applied during each separate observations and also different flux calibrators gave identical results demonstrating the technique to be correct .
in addition the correctness of the flux scale was demonstrated by comparing the flux value of the phase calibrator to the expected value ( between 325 mhz and 1.4 ghz ) which yielded consistent results .
we performed an additional test for determining the correctness of the analysis techniques .
the same fields were observed on multiple days with independent calibrations for the system .
each of the pulsar fields imaged , with the pulsar at a field center , had a half power radius of @xmath4 40 arcmin with a large number of sources in each field of view .
if an analysis is correct then the flux of all these sources , in an ideal scenario , should be identical for all the observations .
however , under realistic conditions one expects some noise across the different observing runs . to demonstrate this we used two ( out of six ) pulsar fields and determined the flux values of all the strong sources ( flux greater than 10 times the rms noise in a map ) for all the three observing runs .
an average flux for each source across the three observing runs was calculated and the ratio of the flux to average flux was plotted as a function of the source flux value ( see figure [ flux_ratio ] ) . as is clear from the figure the flux ratios are concentrated around unity with the noise increasing with decreasing flux level of a source .
this is exactly as per our expectations and clearly demonstrates the correctness of our calibration and analysis techniques across the three observing sessions .
table [ tabgmrt1 ] gives the list of sources with some of their basic parameters ( dm , age and period ) .
all these objects are either confirmed or candidate gps sources .
as it is clear from the table , the sample was subdivided into two categories .
we have made rough estimates of the scattering timescales using either observational data @xcite or the predictions derived from a single thin screen model ( using the scatter time frequency scaling index @xmath6 ) .
for the first group of pulsars , psrs b1750@xmath024 , b1815@xmath014 and b1849 + 00 , the pulse broadening at 610 mhz is large , hence the interferometric imaging provides the only mean to estimate flux for these sources .
the flux density of the remaining pulsars , psrs b1800@xmath021 , b1822@xmath014 and b1823@xmath013 , was measured at low frequencies by conventional pulsar observations @xcite , however since the predicted ( or measured ) scatter time estimates are a significant fraction of the pulsar periods , there is a possibility for the flux densities measured that way to be underestimated . additionally , these three sources have counterparts in the high energy stereoscopic system ( hess ) observations with indications of pulsar wind nebula ( pwn ) around them . @xcite and
@xcite reported psrs b1822@xmath014 and b1823@xmath013 as gps pulsars , and psr b1800@xmath021 is considered as a gps candidate .
we included these pulsars in our studies to re - examine their flux values at 610 mhz where some profile broadening due to scattering is also present .
24 , b1815@xmath014 and b1849 + 00 , pulsars with high dms ( see tab . [ tabgmrt1 ] ) .
open circles denote the gmrt interferometric observations .
measurements marked with black dots are taken from literature ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) and the atnf pulsar catalogue .
the straight lines represent our fits to the data using power - law function ( in the case of psr b1815@xmath014 the flux measurements at 610 mhz marked with black dots were excluded from the fitting procedure ) .
the power indices resulted from the fitting procedure are given on each panel , for more details see tab .
[ fits].,width=309 ] for the six pulsars we constructed radio spectra , combining flux density measurements from the literature ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) and the atnf ( australian telescope national facility ) pulsar catalogue together with the new results shown in table [ tabgmrt2 ] ( see online material for the maps of the pulsars that were used to estimate their flux density at 610 mhz ) .
the spectra are presented in groups , depending on their morphological properties .
our studies show that for the high - dm pulsars , namely psrs b1750@xmath024 , b1815@xmath014 and
b1849 + 00 , their spectra resemble a simple power law .
we were able to confirm the gps feature in the spectrum of psr b1823@xmath013 and pointed out two sources , psrs b1822@xmath014 and b1800@xmath021 , suspected to be gigahertz - peaked spectra pulsars which require further investigation .
the fits presented in the paper were obtained by the implementation of the nonlinear least - squares levenberg - marquardt algorithm.the results of the fitting procedure are given in tab .
[ fits ] . + * psrs b1750@xmath024 , b1815@xmath014 and b1849 + 00 * have very high dms in excess of 600 pc @xmath7 . their spectra are shown in figure [ highdm ] .
these objects are characterized by a significant pulse broadening due to interstellar scattering ( of the order of several periods ) . as mentioned above ,
the sources were suspected to be gps pulsars but our analysis suggest that their spectra can be fit by a power law . in the case of psr b1815@xmath014
the interferometric imaging technique was used to inspect its flux density measurements at 610 mhz due to a strong pulse scatter - broadening ( over a full pulse period , see * ? ? ?
previous observations suggested that the pulsar spectrum shows a turnover feature .
our new result , accompanied by a large scatter time estimate , suggests a significant underestimation in the previous flux measurements for this pulsar at 610 mhz .
the classification of the psrs b1750@xmath024 and b1849 + 00 spectra was not possible before due to very limited flux density measurements at frequencies below 1 ghz .
it seems clear that the spectrum of psr b1849 + 00 one is a typical steep pulsar spectrum .
the psr b1750@xmath024 spectrum can also be described by a single power law but at the same time it is relatively flatter than a usual pulsar spectrum ( a spectral index of @xmath8 ; the fits and the resulting spectral indices are presented in fig . [ highdm ] ) .
+ * psr b1823@xmath913 * , whose spectrum is presented in figure [ gps ] , was classified as a gps pulsar by @xcite .
the object was included in our sample to re - examine its flux density measurement at 610 mhz .
it is noteworthy that new measurements indicate a larger flux density than previous gmrt observations which were carried out using the instrument in phased array mode , thus standard pulsar flux measurement methods were applied @xcite .
even if one disregards the earlier measurements and uses only the interferometrically derived flux , the spectrum continues to exhibit a gps feature .
however , it seems clear that this object requires further observations at frequencies below 600 mhz which we plan to perform in future projects . +
* psr b1800@xmath021 * , whose spectrum is presented in fig . [ 1800 ] , can be treated as a new , very promising gps candidate pulsar .
it is a young , vela - like pulsar , associated with a supernova remnant @xcite .
previously the spectrum seemed to be flat at low frequencies but our estimate , which indicates a much smaller flux density than in the previous measurements at 610 mhz , suggests a positive spectral index in the low - frequency range .
new results clearly imply that the earlier flux measurements should be verified .
* psr b1822@xmath014 * is the last pulsar in our sample .
its spectrum is presented in figure [ 1822 ] , similar to the case of psr b1823@xmath013 , the flux density measured using the interferometric imaging techniques is greater than the values from standard method .
psr b1822@xmath014 was identified as a gps pulsar @xcite , however the interferometric measurements suggest otherwise the spectrum of the pulsar seems to be a power law ( with spectral index of @xmath10 ) when including new measurements which may indicate that the earlier measurements were affected by interstellar scattering .
this pulsar definitely needs further investigation and possibly additional measurements at lower frequencies .
the interferometric imaging technique allowed us to measure flux density for six pulsars with the gmrt at 610 mhz .
the frequency was chosen to verify whether the objects are gps pulsars . in our studies we included three pulsars which had previous flux measurements at 610 mhz ( obtained by using the standard techniques ) in order to re - examine these estimates . in the case of the remaining three sources , due to a strong pulse broadening , the interferometric observations are the only way to estimate their flux at this frequency ( see the scatter time estimates in tab .
[ tabgmrt1 ] ) .
we inspected the spectra of these three pulsars with very high - dms ( @xmath11600 pc @xmath7 ) .
psrs 1750@xmath024 , 1815@xmath014 and b1849 + 00 were suspected to be gps sources but with the addition of new measurements their spectra appear to resemble a typical single power - law pulsar spectrum .
we can also confirm the gps feature in the psr b1823@xmath013 spectrum and select a new strong gps candidate : psr 1800@xmath021 .
its spectrum as well as the spectrum of psr b1822@xmath014 , require however some further investigation . 13 .
open circle denotes the gmrt interferometric observations , whereas black dots denote data from literature ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) and the atnf pulsar catalogue .
the curve represents our fits to the data using the same function ( 1 ) as in @xcite .
the measurement at 610 mhz marked with the black dot was excluded from the fitting procedure . for fitted parameters see tab .
[ fits],width=309 ] 21 .
open circle denotes the gmrt interferometric observations .
measurements marked with black dots are taken from literature ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) and the atnf pulsar catalogue.,width=309 ] the variations in flux density values resulted when applying different observing techniques can be caused by interstellar scintillations .
the pulsars in our sample have dms ranging from @xmath4200 to @xmath4800 pc @xmath7 which means that any scintillations will occur in a strong scintillation regime .
hence we have to take into consideration both diffractive and refractive scintillations . as the diffractive time scales , @xmath12 , where @xmath13 denotes distance , in a case of high - dm and
hence distant sources should be up to a few minutes at the observing frequency @xmath14 of 610 mhz , thereby a single 1 hour observing run should be enough to averaged - out any variations of the measured flux density .
the discrepancies with the earlier flux density measurements ( if present ) can be at least partially caused by the refractive interstellar scintillations , as the refractive time scales , @xmath15 , may vary from days to months .
however , the refractive modulation index @xmath16 for high - dm pulsars should be relatively small at the frequency of 610 mhz . to account for refractive scintillations influence
, we performed our flux measurements on three epochs ( separated by no less than a week ) .
for the purpose of constructing pulsar spectra we are using an average of values obtained from these measurements .
we have to note however , that in this regard the interferometrically measured flux density values are not affected any more than the ones resulting from the standard observing procedure .
pulsar flux measurements regardless of the method used will be affected by the scintillation - driven flux variation in exactly the same way .
as mentioned in the introduction , for high - dm pulsars , and especially when the observations are conducted at low observing frequencies , the pulsar profiles can be affected by interstellar scattering to such an extent that it is difficult , or even impossible to perform flux measurement using the standard profile - based method .
strong scattering causes the profiles to attain scattering tails , what may significantly affect the observed profile background level so that the proper baseline required for the standard flux measurement can not be found . especially prone to such errors will be the cases where the scatter time is comparable to the pulse period , as one will still be able to see a prominent pulse , while the scattering tail will hide the proper baseline level .
one has to remember that even a `` moderate '' length of the scattering tail may still affect the profile baseline and cause erroneous results , especially when the observations are affected by a high noise level @xcite . in some circumstances the influence of scattering may even change the appearance of the spectrum by mimicking a turnover feature , which may lead to an erroneous identification of a pulsar as a gps source , like in the case of psr b1815@xmath014 . since there is no simple way to account for the scattering - induced baseline level change one should refrain from using the standard method in such cases .
practically , however , it can be hard to judge if we are dealing with a profile where scattering led to an erroneous flux density estimation .
we believe that at least some of the past flux measurements performed for the pulsars from our sample might have been affected by the scattering , which is discussed below .
regardless , to avoid the scattering - induced issues one needs a reliable method of pulsar flux density measurement that will not be affected by scattering .
interferometric imaging techniques at low radio frequencies have been used to determine flux density of a wide class of astronomical sources and can be easily extended to determine pulsar flux values .
the estimated flux of the phase calibrator 1822@xmath0096 at 610 mhz was identical over the three widely separated observing sessions and using two different flux calibrators 3c48 and 3c286 .
in addition its flux estimates are in the expected range when compared with the flux densities at 325 mhz and 1.4 ghz ( from the very large array calibrator manual ) .
the consistency of our calibrations over the different observing sessions was also demonstrated by the flux ratios of the surrounding background sources in the field of view , which hovered around unity ( see figure [ flux_ratio ] ) .
additional vindication of our results is provided by the flux density measurements of the three pulsars b1750@xmath024 , b1815@xmath014 and b1849 + 00 which could not be determined at 610 mhz using conventional pulsar flux measurement techniques due to their highly scattered profiles .
our flux estimates at 610 mhz for all the three cases are consistent with the pulsar spectra determined from higher frequencies , where interstellar scattering should not affect the measurement ( see figure [ highdm ] ) .
we now examine the cases of the three other pulsars b1800@xmath021 , b1822@xmath014 and b1823@xmath013 where traditional pulsar flux measurements have been carried out in the past .
all of these sources adjoin interesting environments which may cause an additional absorption at frequencies below 1 ghz .
@xcite suggested that an influence of such environment on pulsar radio emission can manifest itself as a reverse spectrum with positive spectral index , which made these objects a plausible gps candidates .
two of the pulsars , psrs b1822@xmath014 and b1823@xmath013 , were classified by @xcite and @xcite as gps pulsars .
obviously , one can note the discrepancies between standard and interferometric flux measurements for both sources .
the interferometrically measured flux densities are larger than the ones which resulted from standard observations . we know that the pulse profile of psr b1822@xmath014 at 610 mhz shows a significant scattering @xcite ,
thus the flux density obtained using the standard method is very likely to be underestimated . in the case of psr
b1823@xmath013 the profile that was used by @xcite to estimate the flux density of the pulsar at 610 mhz was not published .
however , the estimated scatter time at this frequency is a significant fraction of the pulsar period ( as in the case of psr b1822@xmath014 ) .
hence one can not rule out the possibility that conventional observations were in this case also affected by scattering . 14 .
open circle denotes the gmrt interferometric observations , whereas black dots denote data from literature ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) and the atnf pulsar catalogue .
the dashed curve represents the fit to the data made by ( * ? ? ?
* see their fig .
1 , a point marked with an open circle was not included ) .
we present our power - law fit ( the straight line ) to the data , excluding two measurements at 610 mhz marked with black dots .
the fitted power index is given with the fit , for more details on the fitting results see tab .
[ fits].,width=302 ] as we pointed out above , usually the interferometric observations give better estimations of previously underestimated flux density values .
yet , one can note that in the case of psr b1800@xmath021 its interferometrically measured flux value is lower that the one resulted from previous measurements by @xcite and @xcite .
the discrepancy can not be explained in a simple way and it is not possible to definitely point out the reason behind it .
however , one still can propose possible effects causing such a variation .
assuming our latest result to be accurate and precise , there appears a chance that the difference is caused by rather external ( i.e. environmental ) factors .
psr b1800@xmath021 is a young vela - like pulsar , located at the southwestern edge of the g8.70.1 nebula , a shell - type supernova remnant @xcite .
it has a plausible association with the @xmath17-ray source hess j1804 - 216 @xcite .
all these objects , together with a number of discrete ultracompact hii regions , compose the w30 complex of peculiar morphology @xcite , which emits over frequencies ranging from radio to @xmath17-rays .
thus , it is possible that during our interferometric observations the observed psr b1800@xmath021 flux was affected by an additional absorption , which manifested itself at lower frequencies .
such transient absorption may appear due to relative motion of the components of the w30 complex .
one should note that the two standard measurements which yielded higher flux values were separated in time ( by more than 10 years ) and conducted independently using different observing facilities .
nevertheless , one can not exclude the influence of the classical pulsar flux measurement procedure , such as non - linearity of a receiver or some non - typical flux calibration issues . either way
, psr b1800@xmath021 definitely requires further investigation .
we have already conducted another set of interferometric observations of this source at 610 mhz with the gmrt to verify its flux density .
the data is still to be analysed , however preliminary results show that the flux density resulted from our observations conducted on 28 december 2013 is @xmath18 mjy which is in a good agreement with values presented in tab .
[ tabgmrt2 ] .
moreover , we have time allocation for 325 mhz observations of this source these observations are to be conducted in january 2015
. consequently , we will be able to re - examine our results and hopefully resolve the discrepancy with the standard method measurements .
the interferometric imaging technique allowed us to estimate pulsar flux density , making it possible to observe weak or high - dm pulsars at frequencies below 1 ghz and re - examine our previous results . in the cases of objects
for which determining their flux at low frequencies using standard pulsar observing methods is not possible ( i.e. for a large @xmath19 when comparing to pulsar period ) , it is the only way to estimate flux for these sources . thus , the interferometric imaging technique provides a superior alternative to the pulsar flux measurements .
we believe that the technique will help us to confirm more gps pulsars in future .
+ moreover , we used this method to rule out three gps pulsar candidates and confirm one gps pulsar , psr b1823@xmath013 .
we also pointed out two gps candidates , including a very promising one , psr 1800@xmath014 , that require further investigation .
hence , our analysis clearly shows that the interferometric imaging technique can be successfully applied to estimate flux density of pulsars .
the method is the only secure way to determine the flux density of high - dm pulsars which are highly scattered at low radio frequencies .
we thank the staff of the gmrt who have made these observations possible .
the gmrt is run by the national centre for radio astrophysics of the tata institute of fundamental research .
this research was partially supported by the grant dec-2013/09/b
/ st9/02177 of the polish national science centre .
md was a scholar within sub - measure 8.2.2 regional innovation strategies , measure 8.2 transfer of knowledge , priority viii regional human resources for the economy human capital operational programme co - financed by european social fund and state budget .
we thank m. jamrozy for this support on the preparation of the observing proposal . | we conducted radio interferometric observations of six pulsars at 610 mhz using the giant metrewave radio telescope ( gmrt ) .
all these objects were claimed or suspected to be the gigahertz - peaked spectra ( gps ) pulsars . for a half of the sources in our sample
the interferometric imaging provides the only means to estimate their flux at 610 mhz due to a strong pulse scatter - broadening . in our case , these pulsars have very high dispersion measure values and we present their spectra containing for the first time low - frequency measurements .
the remaining three pulsars were observed at low frequencies using the conventional pulsar flux measurement method .
the interferometric imaging technique allowed us to re - examine their fluxes at 610 mhz .
we were able to confirm the gps feature in the psr b1823@xmath013 spectrum and select a gps candidate pulsar .
these results clearly demonstrate that the interferometric imaging technique can be successfully applied to estimate flux density of pulsars even in the presence of strong scattering .
[ firstpage ] pulsars : general - pulsars : individual : b1750@xmath024 , b1800@xmath021 , b1815@xmath014 , b1822@xmath014 , b1823@xmath013 , b1849 + 00 |
the orion bn / kl complex , at a distance of @xmath6 pc @xcite , contains the nearest region of ongoing high - mass star formation .
a dense protostellar cluster lies within the region containing three radio sources that are believed to be massive young stellar objects ( ysos ) : the highly embedded radio source i , @xcite ; the bn object , which is the brightest source in the region in the mid - infrared ( ir ) at 12.4 @xmath7 m @xcite ; and source _ n _ , a relatively evolved yso with a disk observed in the mir @xcite and a jet observed in the radio at 8.4 ghz @xcite . despite intensive investigations at radio and ir wavelengths , the primary heating source(s ) for the orion kl region ( @xmath8 l@xmath3 )
is ( are ) still not known .
another long - standing puzzle is the geometry of outflow and the identification of driving sources .
there are two large - scale outflows in the region . a powerful ( @xmath9 ergs ) , high - velocity ( 30@xmath10200 km s@xmath1 ) , wide - angle ( @xmath11 rad ) outflow extends northwest - southeast ( nw - se ) over @xmath12 pc .
this so - called `` high - velocity '' outflow is traced in co emission @xcite and in 2.12 @xmath7 m h@xmath4 shocked emission originating in finger - like structures that end in bow shocks @xcite . a second , `` low - velocity '' outflow ( @xmath13 km s@xmath1 )
is identified by a cluster of bright @xmath14 sio and h@xmath4o masers , concentrated within a few arcsec around source i and elongated northeast - southwest ( ne - sw ; @xcite , and in prep . ) .
source i has been proposed as a possible driver of both the high - velocity nw - se outflow ( e.g. , wright et al .
1995 ; @xcite ) and the low - velocity ne - sw outflow ( @xcite and in prep . ) .
confusion arises because the radio continuum emission from source i shows an elongated structure , which has been interpreted as both an ionized jet along a nw - se direction @xcite and as an ionized disk with a ne - sw spin axis @xcite .
based on a multi - epoch observational campaign of several sio maser transitions using the very large array ( vla ) and the very long baseline array ( vlba ) , @xcite and greenhill et al .
( in prep . )
provide convincing evidence that source i is associated with a disk / outflow system with a ne - sw axis .
in particular , based on a vlba monitoring of @xmath15 sio maser transitions , @xcite presented a movie of bulk gas flow tracing a compact disk and the base of a protostellar outflow at radii @xmath16 au from source i. in addition , greenhill et al .
measured proper motions of @xmath14 sio masers , which trace the bipolar outflow expanding with a characteristic velocity @xmath13 km s@xmath17 and extending to radii of 100 - 1000au from source i along a ne - sw axis , parallel to the axis of the disk / outflow system traced by @xmath18 masers at radii @xmath16 au .
the origin and nature of the wide - angle nw - se oriented outflow , traced in shocked h@xmath4 and co emission , is still a matter of debate .
@xcite proposed that source i and bn had a close encounter about 500 yrs ago , which resulted in the ejection of interacting sources and the formation of a tight binary ( source i ) .
based on a proper motion study of radio sources at 8.4 ghz , @xcite proposed that source i , bn , and source _
n _ participated in the same dynamical interaction 500 yrs ago and that all three sources are moving away from the putative center of interaction
. the energy liberated in the process may provide in principle sufficient energy to power the fast nw - se outflow @xcite .
it is not clear , however , what effect a close passage and consequent formation of a tight binary would have on a well - organized accretion / outflow structure such as observed in source i @xcite .
@xcite proposed an alternatively scenario where a close passage between source i and bn ( a runaway star from the trapezium ) would trigger a tidally - enhanced accretion and subsequent outburst of outflow activity , resulting in the powerful high - velocity outflow . in this paper , we present new multi - epoch , high - angular resolution observations of the radio continuum emission in orion bn / kl at 7 mm ( 43 ghz ) from the vla . the main goals of the new observations were to investigate the nature of the radio continuum in source i and reconstruct the dynamical history of bn / kl . in particular , we investigate changes in morphology , size , and flux density as a function of time ( over a decade ) and frequency ( 43 vs 8.4 ghz ) to obtain insights into the nature of the radio sources , mainly to test the ionized disk and jet hypotheses proposed for source i. in addition , we measured absolute proper motions of radio sources based on accurate absolute astrometry , with the aim of constraining the dynamical history of the bn / kl region . in order to quantify probabilities of different dynamical scenarios ,
we present also new n - body simulations of decaying protostellar clusters with a varying number of objects .
previous n - body simulations for bn / kl @xcite assumed a five - member cluster having large masses ( in the range 8 - 20 m@xmath3 ) , which resulted in the formation of binaries with total mass of 36 m@xmath3 .
however , there is no evidence of such massive objects in the bn / kl region , based on present data .
our new simulations assume more plausible masses of individual objects as well as investigate a larger number of possible scenarios .
the current paper is structured as follows .
the observational setup and data calibration procedures are described in 2 .
[ res ] reports the results of the multi - epoch study . in [ srci ] , we discuss the morphological evolution of the radio continuum from source i and its interpretation in terms of an ionized disk . in
[ pas ] we suggest that source i and bn had a past close passage , based on proper motion measurements . in [ dyn ] , we discuss dynamical scenarios that can explain the origin of the proper motions measured for source i and bn . 7 and 8 discuss problems related to the mass of source i and a possible origin for the fast , wide - angle h@xmath4 outflow , respectively .
finally , conclusions are drawn in 9 .
lllllll am668a & 2000/11/10 & 6.6 & 0.041 @xmath19 0.028 ; -30 & 0.14 & @xmath20 & 0.13 + ag622 & 2002/03/31 & 2.7 & 0.046 @xmath19 0.034 ; -4 & 0.16 & @xmath21 & 0.14 + ac817 & 2006/04/15 & 0.9 & 0.051 @xmath19 0.030 ; 11 & 0.28 & @xmath22 & 0.24 + ac952 & 2009/01/12 & 3.3 & 0.058 @xmath19 0.039 ; 3 & 0.11 & @xmath23 & 0.11 + [ obs ] cccccccc bn & & 05 35 14.1094 & -05 22 22.724 & 5 0.3 1 @xmath24 & @xmath25 & @xmath26 + i & & 05 35 14.5141 & -05 22 30.575 & 5 1 1 @xmath24 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 + n & & 05 35 14.3571 & -05 22 32.719 & 5 4 0 @xmath24 & @xmath29 & @xmath30 + h & & 05 35 14.5008 & -05 22 38.691 & 5 2 0 @xmath24 & @xmath31 & @xmath32 + [ sources ]
observations of the @xmath0 mm continuum emission in orion bn / kl were made using the very large array ( vla ) of the national radio astronomy observatory ( nrao ) .
we present data obtained in four distinct epochs spanning over 8 years ( see table 1 ) .
all data were obtained while the vla was in the a - configuration , yielding a resolution of approximately 0@xmath3305 . in order to image the continuum emission from radio sources in bn / kl and to provide a strong signal as a phase - reference to calibrate the phase and amplitude of the ( weak ) continuum signal , we employed a dual - band continuum setup with a narrow band ( 6.25 mhz in programs ac952 and ac817 ; 3.25 mhz in ag622 ; and 1.56 mhz in am668a ) , centered on the sio @xmath34 line ( rest frequency 43122 mhz ) , and a broad band ( 50 mhz ) centered on a line - free portion of the spectrum ( offset in frequency from the maser by : @xmath35350 mhz for ac952 , @xmath35100 mhz for ac817 and ag622 , @xmath3540 mhz for am668 ) .
both frequency bands were observed in dual - circular polarizations .
absolute flux density calibration was obtained from observations of 3c286 or 3c48 ( depending on the epoch )
. short ( 60 s ) scans of the nearby ( 1.3@xmath36 ) qso j0541@xmath100541 ( measured flux density in the range 0.7 - 1.5 jy , depending on the epoch ) were alternated with 60 s scans of source i to monitor amplitude gains , tropospheric and instrumental phase variations , and to determine the electronic phase offsets between the bands.019 was observed every 25 minutes ( relatively infrequently compared with the timescale of tropospheric and instrumental phase variations ) , so no absolute astrometry was available for that program . ]
we then self - calibrated the narrow - band @xmath37 sio maser data , applied the derived phase and amplitude corrections to the broadband continuum data , and produced a high - quality map of the continuum emission .
a detailed description of this calibration procedure can be found in @xcite . using the astronomical image processing system ( aips ) task imagr , we made images of the bn / kl region with 4096@xmath194096 pixels and cell size 0@xmath33005 to cover a 20@xmath38 field .
we produced maps with two different weightings of the ( u , v ) data , first setting the imagr `` robust '' weighting parameter to @xmath39 ( equivalent to natural weighting ) and then to @xmath40=0 .
we restored these image with a circular beams with fwhm 59 mas and 47 mas , respectively .
the sizes of these restoring beams are approximately the average of the geometric - mean sizes among different epochs ( see table [ obs ] ) . since the synthesized beam size in the ac952 program was larger ( @xmath3520% ) than that in other programs , this choice resulted in a degradation of the resolution for other epochs .
for this reason , we also produced images with round restoring beams of 40 mas ( @xmath41 weighting ) and 50 mas ( @xmath42 weighting ) , equal to the geometric - mean size of the beams in projects ac817 and ag622 , thus slightly `` super - resolving '' ac952 .
the high - resolution " maps were used to analyze structural changes in the continuum emission from source i ( sect . [ srci ] ) , whilst the low - resolution " images were used to fit positions and track proper motions of the continuum sources in bn / kl ( sect .
[ pas ] ) , since they minimize structural effects in locating the peak of emission .
four continuum sources were detected above a @xmath43 lower limit of @xmath44 mjy beam@xmath17 in the most sensitive epoch ( 2009 january 12 ) : bn , i , _ n _ , h @xcite .
for each detected source , a two - dimensional ellipsoidal gaussian model was fitted in a @xmath45 pixel area around the peak emission , using the aips task jmfit .
for source i , we used the aips task omfit to directly fit the visibilities using a disk model geometry , which is more appropriate for the elongated morphology of the emission than the gaussian model fitted by jmfit ( see below ) .
the positions , flux densities , and deconvolved angular sizes of the detected sources for the 2009 january 12 epoch are given in table [ sources ] .
the flux densities obtained for bn and source i are in good agreement with the values previously reported in the literature @xcite . source _ n _ was recently detected with the vla for the first time at 7 mm by @xcite , who reports a flux density of @xmath46 mjy .
this a factor @xmath352 higher than what we found in 2009 january 12 .
the discrepancy might be due either to a different filtering of the total flux in the two observations ( 0@xmath3305 vs 0@xmath332 beam ) or to intrinsic variability of source _ n _ , possibly due to non - thermal nature of the continuum emission @xcite . based on a comparison between 7 mm and 3.6 cm observations
, however , @xcite estimated a spectral index of 0.2 for the continuum emission from source _ n _ , suggestive of marginally thick free - free thermal emission , as expected in an ionized outflow .
since the 3.6 cm emission is extended over 0@xmath336 ( i.e. , an order of magnitude more than the restoring beam in a - configuration ) , the variation in flux between measurements with different angular resolutions is most probably due to filtering of the total flux in the most extended configuration .
our images of the continuum emission from source i at 43 ghz for the 2009 january 12 epoch are shown in figure [ srci_ima ] , where different weightings and restoring beams were used ( 59 mas , top panel ; 47 mas , middle panel ) .
the emission is composed of a compact component at the center and a component elongated nw - se . in order to better demonstrate the structure of the elongated component
, we have subtracted a 6 mjy ( beam - sized ) gaussian component at the centroid of the emission . the resulting image ( fig .
[ srci_ima ] , bottom panel ) reveals a structure with a radius of @xmath47 au and a brightness of about 4.5 mjy beam@xmath17 , elongated at a position angle ( p.a . ) of @xmath48 .
it is barely resolved along the minor axis and has a deconvolved axial ratio of about 2:1 .
the radius of this elongated structure agrees to within uncertainties with previous measurements reported by @xcite .
@xcite report a smaller size for source i at 7 mm ( 009@xmath49001@xmath50006@xmath49002 ) . their image , however , has lower sensitivity than the ones reported here , owing to shorter integration time and narrow bandwidth employed ( line - free channels were used to map the continuum ) , hence the quoted size refers to the central compact component while the elongated component is not detected .
figure [ struct ] shows a comparison among images of source i at different epochs .
both size and position angle of the continuum emission appear to be remarkably constant over the last decade .
extreme care was used in computing the absolute astrometry for the three new ( non - archival ) datasets reported here , the accuracy of which we quantify as @xmath355 mas ( see appendix ) .
this accurate absolute astrometry enabled us to track proper motions for bn and source i over three epochs .
figure [ cont ] shows the contour images of bn and source i at different epochs .
the displacement of the peaks in each image shows the absolute proper motions of the radio continuum emission for both sources .
the consistency of morphology in the continuum emission at different epochs reinforces the robustness of the motion measurements .
the proper motions have been calculated by performing an error - weighted linear least - squares fit of positions with time ( figure [ fits ] ) .
the uncertainties of the absolute proper motions are the formal errors of the linear least - squares fits and depend mainly on the error of the absolute position of individual sources at different epochs .
the derived absolute proper motions and associated uncertainties are reported in table [ pmt ] .
the measured proper motions are in the range 15 - 22 km s@xmath1 , confirming the large proper motions of sources i and bn found previously at 8.4 ghz by @xcite . in table [ pmt ] , we also report the absolute proper motions of both sources in the orion nebular cluster ( onc ) rest - frame and relative proper motion of bn with respect to source i. the onc rest - frame is obtained by subtracting the mean absolute proper motions of 35 radio sources located within a radius of 0.1 pc from the core of the onc , @xmath51 mas yr@xmath17 ; @xmath52 mas yr@xmath17 , pa=@xmath53 @xcite .
based on only two epochs , source _ n _ and h do not show significant proper motions in right ascension or declination at a typical 3@xmath54 upper limit of @xmath55 mas yr@xmath17 .
weighting and a round restoring beam of 47 mas ( _ middle and lower panel _ ) , respectively . in order to demonstrate the elongated structure
, we subtracted a ( 6 mjy , 50 mas size ) gaussian component at the centroid of the emission ( _ lower panel _ ) . in all images the contour levels are at integer multiples of 0.4 mjy beam@xmath17
the fwhm of the restoring beams are shown in the bottom right corner of each panel .
we interpret the northwest - southeast elongated emission , as coming from an ionized disk surrounding source i ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) .,scaledwidth=50.0% ] ( 2000 ) , 0.5 mjy beam@xmath17 ( 2002 ) , 0.7 mjy beam@xmath17 ( 2006 ) , 0.4 mjy beam@xmath17 ( 2009 ) .
the choice of contours is dictated by differing sensitivity and uv - coverage in different experiments ( table [ obs ] ) .
there is no significant change in the morphology or position angle of the structure over @xmath358 years ( @xmath56 ) .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ]
the continuum emission from source i shows an elongated structure with a position angle of @xmath57 and a size @xmath3545 au ( fig . [ srci_ima ] ) .
the uncertainty quoted here for the position angle represents the dispersion of values measured in several epochs , which is not significantly larger than the uncertainty in a single epoch ( @xmath58 ) reported in table [ sources ] .
a comparison among images at different epochs does not show any evidence of changes in structure , size or position angle over 8 years ( fig .
[ struct ] ) .
in addition , we found no evidence for significant variations in the total 7 mm continuum flux density of source i over the last decade , with all values being consistent with @xmath59 mjy .
what is the nature of this ionized emission ?
the centimeter - to - millimeter wavelength spectrum of the entire source can be characterized as a power law with flux density @xmath60 @xcite .
the emission is optically thick up to 100 ghz , with a dust component dominating above 300 ghz @xcite .
the radio emission has been interpreted either as an ionized jet with a nw - se axis @xcite or as an ionized disk with a ne - sw axis @xcite . in the following
, we will discuss three alternative interpretations of the radio continuum emission from source i : 1 ) an ionized jet , 2 ) an equatorial wind , and 3 ) an accreting disk .
we will show that only the latter is consistent with our multi - epoch data .
if the emission originates in an ionized jet , one would expect to detect structural variations owing to motions of individual jet components .
in fact , when observed with high - angular resolution , radio jets do not show a smooth structure , but contain clumps . using multi - epoch vla observations , detection of proper motions as large as @xmath35100 - 500 km
s@xmath1have been reported in the components of radio continuum jets associated with both low - mass ysos ( e.g. , hh1 - 2 -@xcite ) and high - mass ysos ( e.g. , cepheus - a - @xcite ; hh80 - 81 - @xcite ) .
assuming 20 km s@xmath1as a lower limit for the expansion velocity of the jet associated with source i ( as estimated from the sio maser flow by @xcite ) , displacements of @xmath3540 au are expected on a temporal baseline of 9 years .
such displacements are comparable to the radius of the continuum emission and are easily detectable with the linear resolution of our observations ( @xmath3525 au ) . in principle , no structural changes would be expected from an optically thin , homogeneous ionized region . however , even in the case of uniform density , thermal pressure would drive expansion of the ionized region as a whole , as seen for ionized winds and hii regions ( e.g. , @xcite ) . as well , classic models of spherical winds @xcite and ionized jets @xcite predict the size of the ionized region to vary as a function of frequency as @xmath61 , which would imply a factor of 3 change in size between 8.4 ghz and 43 ghz .
nonetheless , deconvolved sizes obtained for the radio continuum emission around source i are similar at the two frequencies : 0@xmath3323 @xmath19 0@xmath33115 at 43 ghz ( this work ) and 0@xmath3319 @xmath620@xmath3315 at 8.4 ghz @xcite .
an alternative interpretation is that the radio emission from source i arises in a disk - like structure rather than in a jet , where the gas is not accreting but rather consists of an equatorial ionized wind .
such an equatorial wind has been modeled by @xcite .
the model predicts that the radiation pressure ( mediated by line opacity ) from a massive yso accelerates material from the surface of the disk and blows it away mainly in the equatorial plane .
the velocities obtained for the gas are of the order of a few hundreds km s@xmath1 .
also in this scenario , large changes in morphology are expected over short time intervals ( i.e. , a few years ) owing to fast motions of clumps in the wind , as observed in the luminous yso s140 irs1 @xcite .
in addition to fast motions , rapid changes in the wind structure are expected as well , owing to small changes in illumination by the ionizing yso and to the inherently unstable nature of the radiation - driven winds ( owocki et al .
hence , we conclude that our multi - epoch data are not consistent with the picture of a radiation - driven disk - wind model .
finally , we consider the case that the elongated structure traces ionized accreting gas in a disk .
@xcite has shown that , even when the inner portion of a disk is fully ionized , accretion of ( ionized and neutral ) material can continue onto a massive yso . in this spherically symmetric model , the gravitational attraction of the star exceeds the outward force of the ( radiation and thermal ) pressure inside a critical radius @xmath63 , where g is the gravitational constant ,
m is the mass of the yso , and @xmath64 is the sound speed in the ionized material . in the hypothesis of spherical accretion , by scaling the stellar parameters in table 1 from @xcite to a 10 m@xmath3 star
, ionized accretion can proceed inside of the critical radius @xmath3525 au with an accretion rate @xmath65 m@xmath3 yr@xmath17 .
this critical radius is reasonably consistent with the disk size observed at 43 ghz in source i. in sect .
[ dyn ] , we report evidence for source i being a binary of total mass of the order of 20 m@xmath3 . in the most probable case of an equal - mass binary , this would slightly increase the critical radius above , estimated in the assumption of one 10 m@xmath3 single star .
we note that similar values for the critical radius and accretion rates are obtained for models of ionized accretion in the presence of significant angular momentum @xcite , as required by the disk geometry in source i. we also note that an accretion rate of @xmath66 m@xmath3 yr@xmath17and a central stellar mass of 10 to 20 m@xmath3 is consistent with a luminosity of a few times @xmath67 l@xmath3 for source i. the interpretation of the ionized elongated structure as a disk versus a jet is relevant to a key longstanding question regarding orion bn / kl : what are the drivers of the region s outflows ? in our interpretation , the elongated radio continuum structure traces a nearly edge - on disk , with a spin axis aligned ne - sw , parallel to the low - velocity outflow ( see [ int ] ) .
this is consistent with the model for source i based on high - resolution monitoring of several sio maser transitions ( @xcite and in prep ) .
greenhill et al .
( in prep . ) estimated a _
mass - loss rate _ of the ne - sw outflow to be @xmath68 m@xmath3 yr@xmath17 , assuming a gas density of @xmath69 @xmath70 ( required for the excitation of @xmath14 sio masers ) , a typical velocity of 18 km s@xmath1for the outflow , and a radius of 100 au . based on the models of @xcite
, we estimate an _ accretion rate _
@xmath71 m@xmath3 yr@xmath17
. a ratio of o(0.1 ) for the mass - loss rate to the accretion rate is typical of values inferred from observations of low - mass pre - main - sequence stars ( e.g. , @xcite ) and of values predicted in mhd ejection models @xcite .
this might indicate that source i is still in an active accretion stage .
we caution that the mass - loss rate of the outflow from source i estimated from the sio masers is accurate only to within an order of magnitude ( greenhill et al .
, in prep . )
nevertheless , the preponderance of evidence strongly supports a picture where the high - mass yso source i is powering a disk / outflow system along a ne - sw axis .
llllllll + i & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 + bn & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 + & & & & & & & + + bn & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 + & & & & & & & + + i & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 + bn & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 + [ pmt ] , @xmath107@xmath33536 . in each panel ,
the dotted line shows the proper motion calculated by the ( variance - weighted ) linear least - squares fit of the positional offsets with time.,title="fig:",width=158 ] , @xmath107@xmath33536 . in each panel ,
the dotted line shows the proper motion calculated by the ( variance - weighted ) linear least - squares fit of the positional offsets with time.,title="fig:",width=158 ]
we observe bn and source i moving with high speeds in opposite direction with respect to one another .
this result confirms previous independent proper motion measurements at 8.4 ghz @xcite and at multiple frequencies ranging from 8.4 to 43 ghz @xcite .
figure [ pm ] shows maps of the absolute proper motions of both sources in the onc rest - frame ( upper panel ) and relative proper motion of bn with respect to source i ( lower panel ) .
the more accurate relative proper motions show that source i falls within the error cone of the bn past motion ( fig .
[ pm ] , lower panel ) . based on our accurate relative astrometry
, we can estimate the minimum separation bn and source i had in the past in the plane of the sky by extrapolating the velocity vector backward in time and assuming no acceleration .
following @xcite , the minimum separation is @xmath108 which occurs at an epoch @xmath109 given by @xmath110 where both quantities are expressed as a function of the relative position for program ag622 ( @xmath111 , @xmath112 ) and relative proper motions of bn with respect to source i ( @xmath113 , and @xmath114 ) . by substituting these values ,
we obtain : @xmath1150@xmath33109@xmath490@xmath33175 and @xmath116 years .
hence , our new measurements indicate that , about 560 years ago , bn and source i were as close as @xmath117 au in projection on the plane of the sky .
although we do not have position information along the line - of - sight that confirms the close passage in 3-dimensions ( proper motion analysis gives only a 2-dimension description of the dynamics ) , the line of sight velocities of bn and source i are also consistent with a dynamical encounter .
based on the measured radial velocities of the ambient molecular cloud ( @xmath118=9 km s@xmath1 : @xcite ) , bn ( @xmath118=20 km s@xmath1 , or 11 km s@xmath1with respect to the ambient cloud : @xcite ) , and source i ( @xmath118=5 km s@xmath1 , or @xmath104 km s@xmath1with respect to the ambient cloud : @xcite ) , the ratio of radial velocities between bn and source i is @xmath352.7 , which is consistent with the value of 2.3 determined from the ( onc - frame ) velocities in the plane of the sky . hence , 5 to 6 observables are consistent with the hypothesis of a close passage between source i and bn . we also note that the closest approach separation of 50 au is comparable to the radius of the ionized disk observed today around source i ( sect .
[ srci ] ) .
as this is compact for a high - mass yso accretion disk , we suggest that it may have been truncated in the close encounter with bn .
we note also that the ionized envelope surrounding bn has a comparable radius of @xmath119 au ( table [ sources ] ) , consistent with the truncation hypothesis .
@xcite measured a large proper motion for source _ n _ as well ( @xmath120 mas yr@xmath17 , @xmath121 km s@xmath1 , p.a.@xmath122 ) using position measurements at 8.4 ghz and proposed a close passage with bn and source i. this result however disagrees with our measurements . using two epochs in which we achieved @xmath123 detections at 7 mm wavelength , we measured a much smaller proper motion of @xmath124 mas yr@xmath17 and pa@xmath125 in the onc rest - frame .
this indicates that source _ n _ is moving either very slowly or not at all ( our measurement is consistent with 0 within @xmath126 mas yr@xmath17 ) .
in addition , the proper motion vector points towards and not away from the interaction center , as it would be required if source _ n _ were truly ejected by a close passage with source i and bn . as a final point , the proper motion of source _ n _ at 8.4 ghz reported by @xcite should be viewed with a degree of caution .
the emission at 8.4 ghz from source _ n _ is resolved into a bipolar or elongated structure , depending on epoch ( size@xmath350@xmath336 ) , and the systematic error in the motion may arise from internal variability .
tracking of northern and southern components of source _ n _ by @xcite may be possible , but a longer time baseline is required for certainty . of some concern , the dataset from @xcite is not homogeneous in terms of observing set - up among epochs , and hence changes in uv - coverage could mimic change in structure / position .
finally , in their figure 2 , @xcite show that the displacement of source _ n _ in the plane of the sky from the cluster origin is approximately half that of bn .
however , this is inconsistent with the two objects having comparable proper motions and starting their outward motion from the same point of origin and epoch ( assuming linearity and constancy of motion ) .
further observation of source _ n _ is required to confirm the proper motion measured at 8.4 ghz and hence the dynamical interaction with bn and source i. in the following section , we will reconstruct the dynamical history of bn / kl based on the proper motions measured for source i and bn . section [ quadruple ] will discuss the possible dynamical role of source _ n _ , in the assumption that the 8.4 ghz proper motion measurement of source _ n _ derived by @xcite is correct .
observations have increasingly shown that stars are almost never born in isolation but favor formation in clusters , where interactions can occur among members of a collapsing protostellar group .
interactions with sibling stars play an even more important role in the formation of high - mass stars @xcite .
ysos are also surrounded by circumstellar disks and envelopes , which can play a role in this context by increasing the interaction radius among members of the collapsing protostellar cluster ( e.g. * ? ? ?
the anamolously large relative motions between bn and source i suggest that interactions have also played an important role in orion bn / kl . in the following sections , we investigate four scenarios to account for the observed dynamics of the region : 1 ) the motions are independent and bn is a runaway star from the trapezium cluster ( sect [ teta1 ] ) ; 2 ) a close passage between the two protostars resulted in a star - disk interaction ( sect [ double ] ) ; 3 ) the motions are the result of a multiple ( @xmath127 ) body interaction within a cluster of individual ysos , where a tight massive binary is formed ( source i ) that carries away the binding energy of the system and bn
is ejected ( sect [ multiple ] ) ; 4 ) a close passage between bn and source i , a pre - existing massive binary , resulted in the acceleration of both stars and the hardening of the original binary ( sect [ bin ] ) .
we consider first the possibility that the motions of bn and source i are independent .
@xcite proposed that bn was ejected from the trapezium by dynamical interaction involving the @xmath128 ori c binary system . in a triple system
usually the lightest member is ejected , sometimes as a runaway star , while an eccentric binary is formed between the remaining stars .
the formation of a tight binary is required if the system was originally bound , as a consequence of energy conservation .
usually , both components ( star and close binary ) leave their parental envelope , with velocities inversely proportional to their masses , as a consequence of momentum conservation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
@xmath129 ori c seems to have the physical properties predicted for such a dynamical event : an eccentric , massive binary with primary and secondary masses greater than that of bn @xcite ; a total orbital energy ( @xmath130 erg ) greater than the kinetic energy of bn ( @xmath131 erg ) ; a proper motion roughly in the opposite direction to the motion of bn and with approximately the predicted magnitude ( for the dynamical mass of bn ) .
however , our absolute proper motion measurement is inconsistent with a close encounter between bn and @xmath129 ori c in the past .
figure [ teta1cfig ] shows the radio - onc - frame mas yr@xmath17 ; @xmath52 mas yr@xmath17 , pa=@xmath53 @xcite . ]
proper motion of bn , @xmath132 , @xmath133 ( table [ pmt ] ) , and the optical - onc - frame located within a radius of one - half degree of the trapezium , corresponding to an average proper motion dispersion of @xmath134 mas yr@xmath17 @xcite . ] proper motion of @xmath129 ori c , @xmath135 @xcite .
the plot shows that past trajectories of bn and @xmath128 ori c in fact intersect far from the trapezium cluster . by repeating the same analysis we made for the relative motions of bn with respect to source
i ( this time referring positions and velocities to @xmath128 ori c ori c we took the absolute position from the coup x - ray survey : @xmath136 , known to an accuracy of 0@xmath333 @xcite . ] ) , we obtain @xmath137 , @xmath138 , @xmath139 yr@xmath17 , and @xmath140 yr@xmath17 ( p.a.=@xmath141 ) for the _ relative _ proper motions between bn and @xmath129 ori c ( today ) .
this yields @xmath142 and @xmath143 years .
hence , our measurements indicate that probably bn and @xmath129 ori c did not get closer than @xmath355000 au in the past . this large separation is much greater than the gravitational radius that corresponds to the inferred escape speed of bn , which argues against a close encounter .
nevertheless , the accuracy of our measurement ( at a 2.3@xmath54 level ) does not conclusively exclude it .
we note that the uncertainties here are a factor of 5 larger than quoted by @xcite , whose analysis used the relative motion of bn with respect to source i to achieve a greater accuracy .
however , since source i has a large absolute proper motion ( see table [ pmt ] ) , using the bn motion relative to source i is undesirable . apart from the measurements reported in this paper , there is a number of pieces of evidence that are inconsistent with an ejection of bn from @xmath129 ori c. first
, @xmath144 ori c and bn have similar absolute radial velocities measured in the onc rest - frame , @xmath145 km s@xmath1@xcite and 11 km s@xmath1@xcite , respectively , which is inconsistent with momentum conservation , since bn is approximately five times less massive than @xmath144 ori c. second , a close passage of bn and @xmath129 ori c would explain the large proper motion of only bn but not that of source i. we note that in order to reach a velocity dispersion of 15 km s@xmath1 , a stellar cluster on the order of 1000 au in extent would have to reach 250 m@xmath3 , which is greater than the mass concentrations believed to exist in the part of bn / kl local to source i. third , this scenario would not explain the close passage ( @xmath350@xmath331 ) of bn with source i , since it would be a notable coincidence for a high - velocity yso ejected from a massive binary to pass so close to another high - mass yso . finally , bn exhibits characteristics of a star much younger than any of the trapezium members , which according to @xcite are a few million years old .
while none of the trapezium stars are surrounded by obvious circumstellar material , bn is surrounded by a molecular disk @xcite and by a hypercompact hii region with a @xmath3520 au radius , implying that this star is dragging along a significant amount ( @xmath146 m@xmath3 ) of dense circumstellar gas @xcite .
ori c ( optical , * ? ? ?
* ) measured in the onc - rest - frame .
the arrows indicate proper motion direction and displacement on the plane of the sky over 1000 years .
the dash - dot line indicates motion backward over 4400 years , assuming it is linear .
the dashed lines indicate 1 @xmath54 uncertainties in position angles .
the minimum separation on the sky between bn and @xmath144 ori c was @xmath147 .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] we now consider the case where bn and source i were initially unbound and approached to within @xmath3550 au ( sect .
[ pas ] ) .
source i is surrounded by an ionized disk , indicating a massive ( possibly still accreting ) protostar ( sect .
[ srci ] ) .
a close passage by a massive star ( bn ) should produce tides in the disk and enhance accretion ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) .
in particular , @xcite has shown that disks around massive ysos located in clusters can experience angular momentum losses of up to @xmath3550%-95% ( with consequent increases in accretion ) , as a result of gravitational interaction during stellar encounters ; this is termed _ cluster - assisted accretion_. although star - disk interaction at the center of clusters can affect accretion , it can not itself lead to stellar ejection . in fact , a two - body interaction does not allow efficient transfer of momentum and/or energy between the two objects .
on the contrary , simulations show that disk - assisted capture increases binary formation rates @xcite . in order to account for the large ( positive ) total energy of the bn - i system , the formation of a tight binary that develops a large negative - binding energy is required , a consequence of momentum and energy conservation . in conclusion , in order to end up with stellar ejections ,
the original system must have contained three or more objects , and one of the successor systems must now be a tight binary .
cccccc 3-body : * * * @xmath148 * ( * * ) & 10,10,10 & 10 + 10 & 0.1 & 7 & [ triple ] + bn , i ( new binary ) & & & & & + & & & & & + 4-body : * * * * @xmath148 * * ( * * ) & 10,10,5,5 & 5 + 5 & @xmath149 & - & [ quadruple ] + bn , i , n ( new binary ) & 10,10,9,1 & 9 + 1 & @xmath149 & - & [ quadruple ] + & & & & & + 11-body : 11@xmath19 ( * ) @xmath148 9@xmath19 ( * ) ( * * ) & 0.5(@xmath192),1(@xmath192),2(@xmath192 ) & 10 + 10 & 0.2 & 5 & [ cluster ] + ircx , bn ,
n , i ( new binary ) & 3(@xmath191),5(@xmath191),10(@xmath193)&10 + 5&0.2&4 & [ cluster ] + & & & & & + 3-body : * ( * * ) @xmath148 * ( * * ) & 10,10 + 10 & 10 + 10 & 38 & 16 & [ bin ] + bn(single ) , i ( old binary ) & & & & & + [ scenarios ] in this section , we describe different scenarios that can result in the high proper motion of multiple stars : a triple system ( sect . [ triple ] ) , a quadruple system ( sect . [ quadruple ] ) , and a stellar cluster ( sect . [ cluster ] ) . in order to test different scenarios and quantify statistical probabilities , we ran n - body simulations using the nbody0 code from @xcite .
we numerically integrated several thousand cases of cluster decays with different initial numbers of bodies .
table [ scenarios ] summarizes the key aspects and likelihood of different scenarios , which will be described in detail in the following subsections .
we note that each scenario involves the ejection of individual stars and concomitant formation of a tight binary .
the presence of a disk around source i poses a challenge for some arrangements ( sect .
[ disksurv ] ) .
the existence of a binary before the encounter provides an evolutionary path that may agree best with the available data ( see sect .
[ bin ] ) .
in the simplest dynamical scenario of a triple system , we assume that source i , which is apparently moving slower than bn , forms an eccentric massive binary , and leaves the system along with bn , as previously proposed by @xcite and @xcite . in order to explain the observed velocities , we need to estimate the mass of both objects . based on a luminosity of 2500 l@xmath3 for bn from mid - ir imaging @xcite and an ionizing photon rate of @xmath150 from optically thin emission at @xmath151 ghz @xcite , @xcite report a mass @xmath152 m@xmath3 . in the following , we will assume a fiducial value of 10 m@xmath3 .
constraining the mass of source i based on an infrared or bolometric luminosity is hindered by the very high extinction toward the source @xcite .
@xcite estimate a dynamical mass of @xmath1537 m@xmath3 from sio masers , whereas @xcite report a mass @xmath154 based on modeling of proton - electron bremsstrahlung at 7 mm .
however , from conservation of linear momentum for the bn - i system , one would estimate a mass : @xmath155 m@xmath3 for @xmath156 m@xmath3 .
this result requires explanation of systematic errors in estimation of the dynamical mass from sio masers by @xcite .
we discuss implications in sect [ mass ] .
given mass estimates for the stars , the orbital separation of the binary can be estimated from conservation of mechanical energy . by assuming that the total kinetic energy of the system today , @xmath157 erg , is approximately equal to the final binding energy of the binary , @xmath158 , where @xmath159 and @xmath160 are the masses of the primary and secondary stars , respectively , and @xmath161 is the binary semi - major axis , we obtain @xmath162 , where @xmath163 is the primary s mass fraction in the binary ( @xmath164 ) . in the assumption of an equal - mass binary ( @xmath165 ) ,
the semi - major axis is 10 au for @xmath166 m@xmath3 , corresponding to a period of @xmath357 yr .
we note that an unequal - mass binary with the same total mass would imply an even smaller orbital separation , but it would be dynamically less favorable for ejection ( see discussion in following sections ) . hence , a @xmath167 m@xmath3 equal - mass binary with a semi - major orbital axis @xmath168 au will have a binding energy sufficient to compensate the positive kinetic energy of the bn+source i system .
direct observation of such a tight binary may be beyond what can be achieved with current data .
size scales of 10 au can not be resolved with the vla , and no maser emission has been detected with the vlba at such small radii ( resulting in the dark band " reported by @xcite ) . however , highly eccentric orbits may be anticipated to generate local fluctuations in disk heating over just one quarter orbital period ( @xmath169 years ) , and these might be recognizable over time .
the simple analysis above allows estimation of physical parameters of the binary using basic physics ( mass from linear momentum conservation and orbital separation from mechanical energy conservation ) . in order to quantify the probability of such a triple - body interaction
, we simulated a system composed of three single stars of 10 m@xmath3 mass randomly distributed inside a sphere of 1000 au diameter .
this corresponds approximately to the area subtended by the error cones of proper motions of bn and i ( fig . 5 , top panel ) .
we ran 1000 simulations for durations of 800 years , adopting a velocity dispersion of 0.4 km s@xmath1 , corresponding to a thermal velocity in a molecular cloud at @xmath170 k. we found that only 0.1% of configurations ( 1 out of 1000 ) gave ejections with speed higher than 25 km s@xmath1 . in the case with ejection ,
a 10 + 10 m@xmath3 binary forms with orbital separation @xmath171 au ( table [ scenarios ] ) .
the single 10 m@xmath3 star is ejected with a velocity @xmath172 km s@xmath1 , while the massive binary leaves the interaction area with a velocity @xmath173 km s@xmath1 , as expected from conservation of linear momentum .
these simple simulations show that the bn - i system is unlikely ( probability 0.1% ) to arise from chance encounters among three single stars .
source i and the bn object may not be the only massive objects in bn / kl .
radio source @xmath174 , a yso associated with a bipolar jet @xcite and an accretion disk @xcite , has been proposed as a possibly significant source of luminosity in bn / kl @xcite . using mir measurements , @xcite estimated a luminosity of @xmath175 l@xmath3 , corresponding to a stellar mass @xmath176 m@xmath3 . based on position measurements at 8.4 ghz , @xcite proposed for source _ n _ an origin in the cluster decay along with bn and source i. in the following , we investigate this possibility by assuming a proper motion @xmath177 km s@xmath1and @xmath178 km s@xmath1 , as derived by @xcite at 8.4 ghz in the onc rest - frame ( but see discussion in section [ pas ] for arguments as to why this measurement is questionable ) . for @xmath179
m@xmath3 @xcite and @xmath156 m@xmath3 ( sect . [ triple ] ) , conservation of linear momentum ( along right ascension and declination ) gives a mass @xmath180 m@xmath3 , much lower than that estimated for the triple - system decay ( sect .
[ triple ] ) . in this scenario ,
at least three ysos ( bn , i , and @xmath181 ) with comparable masses ( @xmath358 - 10 m@xmath3 ) would be running away from each other with high velocities , after a dynamical interaction occurred about 500 years ago . however , formation of a binary is required to enable ejection of stars from a cluster .
it is unlikely to be source i because an equal - mass binary of 10 m@xmath3 total would not produce ionizing radiation , while a binary with very different masses for primary and secondary is an unlikely outcome for an n - body interaction ( see below ) .
hence , in the following analysis , we assume that _ n _ is the binary .
a couple of arguments support this hypothesis .
first , source _ n _ has been identified as a hard x - ray source , and since a b - type star is unlikely to be active , @xmath181 might be an unequal - mass binary with one low - mass member .
second , based on @xmath182 and @xmath183 magnitudes , @xcite stated that the sed of source _ n _ can not be modeled as a high - mass star with a single extinction value .
an additional source of ir luminosity must be added ( e.g. , circumstellar dust or stellar companion ) .
although @xmath182 and @xmath183 band observations have not revealed bright companion ir sources with separations down to @xmath18420 au , a tighter binary remains a possibility . in order to estimate the probability that three @xmath185 m@xmath3 stars are ejected after interaction , we simulated two 4-body interactions that could generate a 10 m@xmath3 binary : 1 ) two 10 m@xmath3 and two 5 m@xmath3 stars and 2 ) two 10 m@xmath3 , one 9 m@xmath3 , and one 1 m@xmath3 stars .
initial conditions were set as described in sect .
[ triple ] . among 1000 simulations ,
not a single event ends with ejection of a 10 m@xmath3 star and formation of a binary 5 + 5 m@xmath3 or 9 + 1 m@xmath3 . in system 1 ) we observed ejections in 0.8% of cases with masses 5 m@xmath3 ( 0.7% of cases ) and 10 m@xmath3 ( 0.1% of cases ) .
the new binaries formed in those cases had total masses of 10 + 5 m@xmath3 and 10 + 10 m@xmath3 in four cases ( 0.4% of total ) each .
orbital separations varied in the range 2 - 11 au ( average 9 au ) and 11 - 23 au ( average 14 au ) , for the 10 + 5 m@xmath3 and 10 + 10 m@xmath3 binaries , respectively . in system 2 ) we observed ejections in 2.8% of cases but only one with mass 9 m@xmath3 ( 0.1% of cases ) , when a binary 10 + 10 m@xmath3 formed with an orbital separation of 10 au ( the low mass member was ejected in almost all cases ) . even assuming source _ n _ was a binary before the encounter ( with component masses of 5 + 5 m@xmath3 or 9 + 1 m@xmath3 )
, an exchange interaction would eject the low - mass companion and form a quasi - equal mass binary of @xmath186 m@xmath3 . hence , unless source _ n _ is about twice as luminous as believed , the star is unlikely ( probability @xmath149% ) to be the binary that enables ejections from 4-body interaction ( table [ scenarios ] ) .
the conclusion is consistent with other pieces of evidence .
@xcite detected a disk around _
n _ with a radius @xmath187 au , larger than the separation estimated for the bn - i encounter ( @xmath188 au ) , indicating that either source _ n _ did not take part in the encounter at all or that the passage occurred at large separation ( @xmath153200 au ) . in this last case , source _ n _ could not have exchanged momentum / energy efficiently , making this hypothesis unlikely .
in addition , @xcite report detection of a brown dwarf separated by @xmath35300 au from source _ n_. if this is indeed a bound system , then it is unlikely to have survived an earlier dynamical interaction with bn and source i. we conclude that , even assuming that the 8.4 ghz proper motion measurement of source _ n _ derived by @xcite is correct , source _ n _ is unlikely to have played a major role in the dynamical interaction between source i and bn . to explain the observed motion of bn with respect to source i , @xcite proposed an interaction among several members of a collapsing protostellar cluster .
in addition to the radio sources studied here , many individual peaks of thermal ir ( @xmath189 m ) emission have been identified in the bn / kl region from high angular resolution ir studies @xcite .
some of these may be embedded , self - luminous protostars @xcite , suggesting a protostellar density even higher than that of the trapezium cluster .
for example , the 5 knots in irc2 plus source i would constitute a cluster core of @xmath190 pc@xmath191 over @xmath192 au within the larger ( @xmath193 ) ir cluster @xcite .
apart from irc2 , also irc7 and irc4 ( and possibly irc3 ) appear to be clustered around the putative expansion center within a few arcseconds ( fig .
[ pm ] ) .
we propose that the original bound cluster may disintegrate resulting in the expansion of multiple objects with different velocities and the recoil of one ( or more ) of the protostars as tight binaries .
this scenario would explain why the putative center of expansion is presently devoid of infrared sources ( see fig .
we explicitly note that , owing to the lack of astrometric ir observations , the possibility that the members of the ir cluster in bn / kl are participating in the expansion measured for source i and bn , remains speculative . in order to test the present scenario ,
we ran simulations of a protostellar cluster with eleven members , adopting masses of 0.5 ( 2 stars ) , 1 ( 2 stars ) , 2 ( 2 stars ) , 3 ( 1 star ) , 5 ( 1 star ) , and 10 ( 3 stars ) m@xmath3 ( total mass of 45 m@xmath3 ) , randomly distributed inside a sphere of 1000 au diameter .
the implied stellar density is @xmath194 stars pc@xmath191 , comparable to that found in the orion trapezium and the cepheus a hw2 stellar complex ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
the choice of masses reflects plausible masses for the objects present in the region , based on radio and ir data .
the three stars with 10 m@xmath3 are meant represent bn , i , and _
n _ , while the low - to - intermediate mass objects represent the ir knots associated with irc2 , irc3 , irc4 , and irc7 .
we ran 1000 simulations with durations of 800 years , adopting a velocity dispersion of 0.4 km s@xmath1 . in a significant fraction of configurations ( 17% ) , stars escaped from the cluster with velocities greater than that of bn ( 25 km s@xmath1 ) ; we define these as runaway stars .
the runaway stars had a maximum mass of 10 m@xmath3 in 0.4% of cases .
high - mass runaways always required the formation of a binary with 10 + 5 m@xmath3 ( 0.2% of total cases ) or 10 + 10 m@xmath3 total mass ( 0.2% of total cases ) .
orbital separations varied in the range 3 - 7 au , with an average value of 5 au ( table [ scenarios ] ) . in the case
that two of the massive objects in the system form a binary and source _ n _ is a high - mass yso of 8 m@xmath3 @xcite , the total mass of the cluster can be increased by swapping one of the 0.5 m@xmath3 stars for an 8 m@xmath3 star , keeping the same stellar density ( total mass of 52.5 m@xmath3 ) .
this would describe a system where @xmath195 m@xmath3 , @xmath166 m@xmath3 , and @xmath179 m@xmath3 .
simulations of the new system resulted in a similar number of total runaway stars ( 19% ) of maximum 8 - 10 m@xmath3 in 0.7% of cases .
of these , one case out of 7 ( 0.1% of total ) gave runaways without formation of a binary .
new binaries had total masses of 10 + 5 m@xmath3 in one case ( 0.1% of total ) , 10 + 8 m@xmath3 in one case ( 0.1% of total ) , and 10 + 10 m@xmath3 in four cases ( 0.4% of total ) .
orbital separations varied in the range 4 - 11 au , with an average value of 6.5 au . since results are qualitatively similar to the system with total mass of 45 m@xmath3 , we did not report the outcome of the simulations for this case in table [ scenarios ] .
our simulations show that , without the inclusion of very massive objects ( @xmath3520 m@xmath3 ) in the cluster , the probability of ejecting massive members ( @xmath196 m@xmath3 ) from the system is very low ( @xmath197% ) .
we note that previous n - body simulations from @xcite resulted in a larger fraction of ejections of objects with 8 m@xmath3 ( 15% ) because they assumed several cluster members with masses in the range 8 - 20 m@xmath3 and allowed for formation of binaries as massive as 36 m@xmath3 .
however , such massive objects can not readily be identified with any of the known objects in the bn / kl region .
as argued from the results of n - body simulations for systems of three or more stars , source i is likely to be a binary comprising stars of comparably high mass .
the formation of a tight binary implies a close passage ( o(10 au ) or less ) , well within the uncertainties in the analysis of proper motion data ( see sect .
[ pas ] ) .
however , the existence of disks or other structures in close proximity to bn and source i poses a challenge to explain .
we observe an ionized disk with a @xmath2 au radius around source i , while bn has associated dust and ( molecular and ionized ) gas material in a disk - like structure of tens of au in radius @xcite .
close passages truncate disks larger in radius than the minimum stellar separation or destroy them all together . in the following , we discuss two possibilities : 1 ) the original disks are destroyed in the encounter and then rebuilt in the following 500 years ; 2 ) the disks are truncated but survive the encounter . in the first hypothesis , evidence of a disk around source i today is indicative of a viable rebuilding mechanism fueled by either residual material dispersed from the original disks or interstellar gas in the region .
we consider two possible mechanisms for rebuilding the disk : bondi - hoyle ( b - h ) accretion and tidal disruption of a low - mass object .
bh accretion is the physical mechanism through which a compact object passing through an ambient medium gains mass @xcite .
material within a critical radius ( bh radius ) becomes bound and accreted by the protostar . equating the potential and kinetic energies
, we define the bh radius @xmath198 , an associated accretion rate @xmath199 , an accretion timescale @xmath200 , and a disk mass @xmath201 , where @xmath202 is the compact - object mass and @xmath203 is the velocity relative to the surrounding medium of density @xmath204 . assuming @xmath205
m@xmath3 ( sect . [ multiple ] ) and @xmath206 km s@xmath1for source i ( sect .
[ res ] ) , and @xmath207 @xmath70 for the molecular gas in the region ( as in the hot core ) , we obtain : @xmath208 au , @xmath209 years , @xmath210 m@xmath3 yr@xmath17 , m@xmath211 m@xmath3 . although the radius estimate is consistent with the observations , a more sophisticated modeling of bh flow , using 2d and 3d simulations for both subsonic and turbulent flows ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , demonstrates that gravitational focusing occurs from the initial scale of @xmath212 to the scale of an irregular accretion pseudo - disk of radius @xmath213 ( e.g. see fig . 1 of * ? ? ?
hence , it appears unlikely that bh accretion would support a disk with comparable radius and symmetry to that observed .
in addition , @xcite report a lower - limit of @xmath214 m@xmath3 to the disk mass , as estimated from sio maser emission , whereas @xcite report an upper limit of 0.2 m@xmath3 estimated from the continuum flux density at 345 ghz , indicating that the mass gathered in 500 years via bh would be quite low .
we conclude that bh accretion can not explain the symmetric morphology , the size , and the mass of the disk we observe around source i. another possible mechanism for building the disk around source i is suggested by simulations from @xcite , which show that a close encounter between 10 m@xmath3 and 3 m@xmath3 stars can lead to a tidal disruption of the low - density 3 m@xmath3 star and subsequent formation of a massive disk around the massive star . if , in the encounter , one low - mass star were stripped away , this process would contribute to create a massive disk / envelope around source i , with possible rapid accretion of a significant fraction of it onto the protostar .
this scenario , however , faces two major challenges .
first , in order for the tidal disruption to be effective , the two stars must pass each other to within roughly one stellar radius , and by implication , the stellar density of the cluster must be quite high , @xmath215 m@xmath3 pc@xmath191 @xcite .
second , material following a disruption must be redistributed from a characteristic radius of a few tenths of an au ( orbital separation of the two stars ) to the observed disk radius of tens of au .
the timescale for disk spreading by viscosity is @xmath216 , for disk radius @xmath217 and viscosity @xmath218 ( @xmath219 is the viscosity parameter ) .
we obtain viscous timescales ranging from @xmath220 yr ( @xmath221 au , @xmath222 ) up to @xmath223 yr ( @xmath224 au , @xmath225 ; @xcite ) .
tidal disruption is hence an improbable mechanism for the reformation of the disk around source i in 500 years .
we conclude that the observation of a relatively large and symmetric disk around source i is inconsistent with the formation of a binary and reformation of a circumbinary disk after 500 years .
we consider then the alternative hypothesis where the original disks survive , although severely affected by the dynamical interaction ( e.g. , truncation , mass redistribution , accretion burst , etc . ) . in order to assess conditions under which a circumstellar disk is retained in a dynamical encounter or close passage
, one should include disk particles in the simulations , which is beyond the scope of this article . a follow - up paper ( moeckel et al . in prep .
) will consider a dynamical interaction between a binary associated with a disk and a single star .
the probability of disk survival in an interaction between a binary and a single is higher than a complex three - body interaction .
the main result is that a significant fraction of the disk is retained in the case of either a clean and fast exchange of companion in the binary ( one or two close passages ) or in the case of survival of the binary , where the original circumbinary disk is truncated at the radius of the close passage with the single star . ; shown in red ) and bn ( 10 m@xmath3 ; shown in black ) at two epochs .
initial positions for the simulations are marked by filled circles , with the source i binary components separated by 10 au and bn at a distance of 500 au .
initial velocities are due to the thermal velocity of the region , v@xmath226=0.4 km s@xmath17 .
arrows mark source positions and 3d motion directions at times after closest source i - bn approach of _ ( a ) _ t@xmath22750 years and _ ( b ) _ t@xmath227500 years . after 500 years , the source i binary and bn have positions that are @xmath353200 au apart and are moving away from each other with 3d velocities of 14 and 29 km s@xmath1respectively , in agreement with the observations .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] ejection of massive stars and formation of tight binaries in multiple - body ( @xmath2283 ) interactions have relatively low probability ( @xmath229% ) in the range of stellar densities and masses assumed in our n - body simulations ( sect . [ multiple ] ) .
despite the fact that binaries are unlikely to arise by chance encounters , observations show that a large fraction ( @xmath230% ) of massive stars in ob clusters and/or associations are binary and multiple systems @xcite .
the abundance of binaries and triples inferred from observations suggests that most stars are born that way ( primordial " binaries ) .
combined hydrodynamic and n - body simulations have shown that primordial binaries can form from both fragmentation of collapsing cores and accretion disks @xcite . in the following , we reconsider a 3-body interaction where two stars lie in a ( primordial ) binary ( source i ) , and a close passage occurs by the third ( bn ) .
we assume a binary of total mass 20 m@xmath3 , with equal primary and secondary masses of 10 m@xmath3 and an orbital separation of 10 au .
the third star has a mass of 10 m@xmath3 and is at an initial distance of 500 au .
we have numerically integrated 1000 cases with three bodies in a bound system starting with a velocity dispersion @xmath231 km s@xmath1 and followed their dynamical interactions for 1000 years .
figure [ nbody ] shows the outcome of our simulations for one specific case . in 39% of cases , both the single and
the binary stars acquire very high speeds in their interaction , flying apart in opposite directions with velocities in the range 10 - 90 km s@xmath1 . in all cases ,
the single 10 m@xmath3 star runs away from the center of interaction with approximately twice the velocity of the binary , in agreement with linear momentum conservation . in the cases with ejections , the original binary survives in 15% of cases , while in 24% of cases a new binary is formed by exchanging one component ( 39% total ) .
the orbital separation of binary components , averaged over the last 50 years of the simulation , varies in the range 1 - 9 au , with an average of 4 au .
the binding energy of the tighter binary ( initially at @xmath232 au ) compensates for the kinetic energy acquired by the two runaway stars , in agreement with conservation of mechanical energy . in the cases where the original binary survives ( 15% ) , the minimum periastron ( over 1000 years ) between the single and the binary varied in the range 1 - 60 au , with an average value of 16 au .
the new 3-body simulations show that in a high fraction of cases , massive stars are ejected ( 39% ) and the original binary survives ( 15% ) .
stellar ejections require a massive binary ( @xmath167 m@xmath3 ) as initial condition . in exploring parameter space
, we also simulated a 10 m@xmath3 star in parabolic orbit about a binary of total mass 11 m@xmath3 , with mass distributed in 10 + 1 m@xmath3 or 8 + 3 m@xmath3 units . with these starting conditions ,
only a small fraction ( @xmath233% ) resulted in ejection , and the star that was lost was the lower mass member .
the process necessarily involved exchange of binary members , where the more massive companion and the third massive object formed an almost equal - mass binary whereas the lower mass member was ejected from the system . at the moment
, we favor the cases where the binary survives without exchanging components , because therein the inner reaches of the accretion disk can be preserved ( sect .
[ disksurv ] ) . a follow - up paper ( moeckel et al . in prep . ) will investigate the effects of a stellar dynamical interaction on a circumbinary disk as a function of stellar mass , binary orbital separation , single - binary periastron , and swapping of binary members .
the assumed dynamical interaction between source i and bn , is concomitant with an estimated mass of @xmath234 m@xmath3 for source i. recently @xcite estimated a dynamical mass using sio maser proper motion data .
this provided a lower limit of @xmath5 m@xmath3 .
the influence of non - gravitational forces on gas dynamics may be responsible for the discrepancy between dynamical masses .
@xcite detected both radial and rotational motions in the inferred disk around the yso , at radii @xmath235 au .
although doppler velocity data in the outflow show differential rotation of material , the actual rotation curve may be sub - keplerian , e.g. , due to radiative and/or magnetic forces , which can lead to underestimates of the central object mass .
in particular , @xcite reported possibly bent trajectories among proper motions and suggest that magnetic fields may play a role in shaping the gas dynamics around source i. @xcite found recently that the evolution of the gravitational collapse of a massive hot molecular core in g31.41 + 0.31 is controlled by magnetic fields ( on scales @xmath236 au ) , which appear to be effective in removing angular momentum and slowing down circumstellar gas rotation , as expected from magnetic braking @xcite . @xcite
considered the case of an accretion disk threaded with magnetic fields that are squeezed in ( scales @xmath237 au ) from the interstellar medium by gravitational collapse .
they find that the poloidal component of the magnetic field produces , as a consequence of its rotation , a change in the radial force balance in the disk , giving a deviation from a keplerian profile .
the resulting rotation law has the same power - law dependence with radius as a keplerian profile , but scaled with a coefficient @xmath238 , which includes the effects of the magnetic field . as a consequence of this deviation from keplerian rotation ,
the dynamical mass of the central object derived from an observed rotation curve will be smaller than its actual value of a factor @xmath239 , where @xmath240 is the true mass and @xmath241 is the observed mass .
the departure from keplerian rotation can be analytically expressed in terms of the magnetic coefficient @xmath242 as : @xmath243 @xcite , where @xmath244 is the accretion rate onto the protostar with mass @xmath245 , @xmath246 is the stellar age , and @xmath247 is a numerical coefficient from the model ( assumed to be 4 ) . assuming for source i @xmath248 m@xmath3(from conservation of linear momentum of the bn - i system ) and @xmath249 m@xmath3(from sio maser dynamics ) , we derive @xmath250 . based on the formula above , this value can be readily achieved by assuming reasonable values for mass accretion rates and age : @xmath251 m@xmath3 yr@xmath17and @xmath252 years ( for @xmath253 ) .
this analysis shows that , in the assumption that magnetic fields support the disk , more than half of the mass of the central object can be easily hidden from observations .
nevertheless , we caution that the estimated parameters are indicative and that careful modeling is required to determine the true mass of source i. future direct measurements of magnetic field amplitude in the disk around source i , and an accurate estimate of the mass - accretion rate as well as the stellar age , will enable a better understanding of the effects of magnetic fields on mass measurement from gas dynamics .
the origin , nature , and powering source of the fast , poorly collimated bipolar outflow in bn / kl have been long debated .
the h@xmath4 finger structure consists of over 100 individual bow shocks with a large opening angle and indicates that a powerful event occurred in the center of bn / kl ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
proper motion studies of herbig - haro ( hh ) objects in bn / kl from the ground @xcite and with the _ hubble space telescope _
@xcite showed that more distant bullets are moving faster and indicate an origin about 1000 years ago ( assuming no deceleration ) .
@xcite observed the co(21 ) line with the submillimeter array and identified several filaments arising from a common center and showing linear velocity gradients with distance from the center .
@xcite proposed that the outflow was produced by the disintegration of the young protostellar cluster formed by bn , i , and _
n_. we propose a similar scenario , where the dynamical interaction between bn and the source i binary , as described in sect .
[ bin ] , may have produced the fast co outflow and associated h@xmath4 fingers in bn / kl .
the outflow has a mass of about 10 m@xmath3 and a kinetic energy of about @xmath254 ergs @xcite .
the hardening of a 20 m@xmath3 binary to an orbital separation of 2 au would release about @xmath255 ergs of gravitational potential energy , enough to drive the powerful outflow ( @xmath254 ergs ) and compensate for the kinetic energy of the bn - i system ( @xmath131 erg ) .
this outflow would not be the typical outflow powered by accretion onto a protostar , but rather the relic of a one - time event . in this picture , the expanding material was ejected at about the same time and accelerated from the area where the bn - i encounter took place , in agreement with the general `` hubble - flow '' trend evidenced by proper motions of hh objects and velocity gradients in co emission @xcite . since the disrupted circumstellar material is dispersed in all directions , this picture explains why the present structure of source i is not related to the geometry of the outflow on large scales .
we note that , although the formation or hardening of a massive binary in a dynamical interaction can explain energetically the expansion of the outflowing gas , the physical mechanism at its origin remains unknown .
more sophisticated combined n - body and hydrodynamic simulations that include also material in circumstellar disks and envelopes may help to understand the fate of circumstellar gas associated with individual protostars participating in a dynamical encounter .
we have presented high - sensitivity , multi - epoch vla @xmath0 mm continuum observations of the radio sources in the orion bn / kl star - forming region .
these observations have shown that the radio emission from source i is elongated nw - se and is stable over a decade .
the morphology and the stability of the emission is consistent with an ionized edge - on disk .
we measured the proper motions of source i and the bn object for the first time at 43 ghz , confirming that they are moving with high speeds ( 12 and 26 km s@xmath1 , respectively ) approximately in opposite direction with respect to each other .
we discussed possible dynamical scenarios that can explain the anomalously large motions of both bn and source i , and implications for the dynamics of the whole bn / kl region .
our new measurements are inconsistent with a close encounter between bn and @xmath129 ori c in the past , as proposed by @xcite .
they confirm the previously proposed scenario of a dynamical interaction between source i and bn 500 years ago .
in particular , @xcite proposed that a dynamical decay of a protostellar cluster resulted in the formation of a tight binary ( source i ) and the ejection of other two sources ( bn and _
however , the presence of a relatively large , massive disk around source i and the low - probability of a multiple - body interaction among single stars , excludes that source i formed a binary in the course of the encounter and subsequently managed to rebuild its disk in 500 years .
we propose that source i was a binary system _ before _ the close passage with bn , which possibly truncated the original circumbinary disk to @xmath2 au .
inference that this is the natal accretion disk is in agreement with disk - mediated accretion for source i , as recently proposed by @xcite .
this dynamical event would have resulted in the ejection of both stars and the hardening of the original binary .
the dynamical scenarios discussed in this paper were tested with n - body numerical simulations of dynamical interactions among members of a protostellar cluster .
these simulations , however , illustrate a simplified physical process of gravitational interaction among point - masses .
a follow - up study will include the effects of a circumbinary disk in the dynamical interactions between protostars .
the mass of source i is still controversial . from linear momentum conservation of the bn - i system , we estimate @xmath167 m@xmath3much higher than the value estimated from sio maser dynamics , @xmath5 m@xmath3@xcite . on one hand , a strong argument in support of the dynamical estimate is that two independent families of motions , keplerian rotation in a disk and escape speed in an outflow , provide similar mass values , although relevant to different radii and force balance . on the other hand ,
the analysis in this paper is strongly based on the fact that 5 to 6 observables ( proper motions , los velocities , and positions in the plane of the sky ) are consistent with the hypothesis of a close passage between source i and bn . one possibility for reconciling the two models is that non - gravitational forces may play a significant role in driving the dynamics of molecular gas around source i. assuming the disk is magnetically supported , a significant fraction of the mass of the central object can be hidden in the keplerian velocity profile of maser emission , leading to an underestimate of the mass @xcite .
we note that an equal - mass binary with total mass 10 m@xmath3 would not produce an hii region , and an unequal - mass binary with the same total mass would have a very low - probability of surviving in a dynamical interaction with an equally - massive body ( e.g. , sect . [ bin ] ) . hence , unless we assume the presence of another very massive source in the region ( e.g. , _
n _ ) , the dynamic scenario proposed here suggests a central mass @xmath167 m@xmath3 for source i. we explicitly note that , owing to the non - linear dependence of luminosity on mass , the total luminosity developed by a binary composed of two 10 m@xmath3 stars _ can not _ explain the high luminosity ( @xmath256 l@xmath3 ) of the bn / kl nebula . the gravitational energy released by the hardening of a binary with total mass 20
m@xmath3 would , however , be sufficient to power the gas expansion observed in h@xmath4 and co emission in the bn / kl nebula , although a detailed physical mechanism for such a process is still lacking . a final , general remark concerns models of massive star formation .
source i is probably the best case known of a massive protostar with ongoing disk - mediated accretion @xcite .
this work shows that recent dynamical interactions played a fundamental role in shaping the protostellar properties in orion bn / kl .
star formation in this region might be then _ atypical _ in the context of the classic theory of isolated low - mass star formation @xcite . nevertheless , considering that most ( although not all ) massive stars are formed in dense protostellar clusters @xcite , dynamical interactions in very early stages of cluster evolution may be _ common _ in the context of crowded , massive star formation .
proper motion studies of the radio / mm continuum sources in similar regions are required to confirm this hypothesis .
the evla , when fully commissioned , will offer broadband ( up to 8 ghz ) imaging , resulting in a factor of 10 improvement in continuum sensitivity , making this kind of study possible in principle for regions three times more distant .
alma , with a similar or even better resolution , will enable similar studies at ( sub)mm wavelengths .
systematic studies with these instruments will allow us to assess the role of dynamical interactions in massive star formation .
the absolute astrometry in each of the program datasets reported here has been determined with high accuracy ( of order @xmath355 mas ) . the error at each epoch is taken to be the square root of the sum in quadrature of the 4 main contributions to the total error budget : where individual contributions account for angular separation ( calibrator to target ) , noise limited or fitting uncertainty , source structure , and frequency - dependent errors .
below we describe in detail individual error contributions : * @xmath258 is the theoretical error in computing the absolute astrometry from a calibrator with a separation of @xmath259 from the target . for a typical baseline length of 10 km and accuracy of 1 cm ( appropriate for the vla in a configuration ) , and a calibrator - target separation of @xmath260 ,
one derives @xmath261 mas .
this is the dominant contribution to the overall error budget .
* @xmath262 is the theoretical , noise - limited positional uncertainty , given by @xmath263 , where @xmath264 is the fwhm of the synthesized beamwidth of the array , and snr is the peak intensity divided by the rms noise in the map .
we compared this error with the fitting error from jmfit and took the larger of the two ( typically @xmath11 mas ) .
* @xmath265 is the uncertainty introduced by the source structure .
since both bn and source i are resolved at 7 mm in a - configuration , different weighting schemes result in slight changes in morphology , and possibly in different peak positions .
we quantified this contribution by taking the dispersion ( i.e. , max separation ) of the positions in the images with different weighting and restoring beams : @xmath2661 mas for bn and i ( resolved sources ) and @xmath2660 mas for h and @xmath181 ( point sources ) .
* @xmath267 is the error introduced by the application of the self - calibration solutions from the maser to the continuum data , having a frequency separation @xmath268 mhz . in previous vla experiments , we established an angular offset per mhz as large as 0.01 mas / mhz introduced by calibrating one band by another @xcite .
we can not quantify this contribution for the programs described here ( we observed only at one frequency offset from the @xmath37 maser line ) , but assuming this contribution does not change much from program to program , one can anticipate a contribution at most of a few mas .
aarseth , s. j. 1985 , multiple time scales , p. 377 - 418 , 377 acord , j. m. , churchwell , e. , & wood , d. o. s. 1998 , , 495 , l107 alexander , r. d. , armitage , p. j. , & cuadra , j. 2008 , , 389 , 1655 allen , d. a. , & burton , m. g. 1993 , , 363 , 54 apai , d. , bik , a. , kaper , l. , henning , t. , & zinnecker , h. 2007 , , 655 , 484 bally , j. , & zinnecker , h. 2005 , , 129 , 2281 beuther , h. , et al .
2004 , , 616 , l31 beuther , h. , et al .
2005 , , 632 , 355 beuther , h. , et al .
2006 , , 636 , 323 beuther , h. , linz , h. , bik . , a. , goto , m. , & henning , t. 2010 , arxiv:1001.0650 bondi , h. , & hoyle , f. 1944 , , 104 , 273 bontemps , s. , andre , p. , terebey , s. , & cabrit , s. 1996 , , 311 , 858 chernin , l. m. , & wright , m. c. h. 1996 , , 467 , 676 churchwell , e. , felli , m. , wood , d. o. s. , & massi , m. 1987 , , 321 , 516 comito , c. , schilke , p. , endesfelder , u. , jimnez - serra , i. , & martn - pintado , j. 2007 , , 469 , 207 curiel , s. , et al .
2006 , , 638 , 878 davies , m. b. , bate , m. r. , bonnell , i. a. , bailey , v. c. , & tout , c. a. 2006 , , 370 , 2038 doi , t. , odell , c. r. , & hartigan , p. 2002
, , 124 , 445 drew , j. e. , proga , d. , & stone , j. m. 1998 , , 296 , l6 edgar , r. 2004 , new astronomy review , 48 , 843 galli , d. , lizano , s. , shu , f. h. , & allen , a. 2006 , , 647 , 374 garay , g. , moran , j. m. , & reid , m. j. 1987 , , 314 , 535 genzel , r. , & stutzki , j. 1989 , , 27 , 41 getman , k. v. , et al .
2005 , , 160 , 319 gezari , d. y. , backman , d. e. , & werner , m. w. 1998 , , 509 , 283 girart , j. m. , beltrn , m. t. , zhang , q. , rao , r. , & estalella , r. 2009 , science , 324 , 1408 goddi , c. , greenhill , l. j. , chandler , c. j. , humphreys , e. m. l. , matthews , l. d. , & gray , m. d. 2009 , , 698 , 1165 gmez , l. , rodrguez , l. f. , loinard , l. , lizano , s. , poveda , a. , & allen , c. 2005 , , 635 , 1166 gmez , l. , rodrguez , l. f. , loinard , l. , lizano , s. , allen , c. , poveda , a. , & menten , k. m. 2008 , , 685 , 333 goodman , j. , & hut , p. 1993
, , 403 , 271 greenhill , l. j. , gwinn , c. r. , schwartz , c. , moran , j. m. , & diamond , p. j. 1998 , , 396 , 650 greenhill , l. j. , reid , m. j. , chandler , c. j. , diamond , p. j. , & elitzur , m. 2004a , star formation at high angular resolution , 221 , 155 greenhill , l. j. , gezari , d. y. , danchi , w. c. , najita , j. , monnier , j. d. , & tuthill , p. g. 2004b , , 605 , l57 hillenbrand , l. a. 1997 , , 113 , 1733 hollenbach , d. j. , yorke , h. w. , & johnstone , d. 2000 , protostars and planets iv , 401 hoare , m. g. 2006 , , 649 , 856 jiang , z. , tamura , m. , fukagawa , m. , hough , j. , lucas , p. , suto , h. , ishii , m. , & yang , j. 2005 , , 437 , 112 jimnez - serra , i. , martn - pintado , j. , caselli , p. , martn , s. , rodrguez - franco , a. , chandler , c. , & winters , j. m. 2009 , , 703 , l157 keto , e. 2003 , , 599 , 1196 keto , e. 2007 , , 666 , 976 kim , m. k. , et al .
2008 , , 60 , 991 konigl , a. , & pudritz , r. e. 2000 , protostars and planets iv , 75 kraus , s. , et al .
2007 , , 466 , 649 kroupa , p. 1995
, , 277 , 1491 krumholz , m. r. , mckee , c. f. , & klein , r. i. 2005 , , 618 , 757 kwan , j. , & scoville , n. 1976 , , 210 , l39 lada , c. j. , & lada , e. a. 2003 , , 41 , 57 lagrange , a .- m . , et al
. 2004 , , 417 , l11 lee , j .- k .
, & burton , m. g. 2000 , , 315 , 11 lonsdale , c. j. , becklin , e. e. , lee , t. j. , & stewart , j. m. 1982 , , 87 , 1819 marti , j. , rodriguez , l. f. , & reipurth , b. 1995 , , 449 , 184 mason , b. d. , hartkopf , w. i. , gies , d. r. , henry , t. j. , & helsel , j. w. 2009 , , 137 , 3358 matthews , l. d. , greenhill , l. j. , goddi , c. , chandler , c. j. , humphreys , e. m. l. , & kunz , m. w. 2010 , , 708 , 80 menten , k. m. , & reid , m. j. 1995 , , 445 , l157 menten , k. m. , reid , m. j. , forbrich , j. , & brunthaler , a. 2007 , , 474 , 515 moeckel , n. , & bally , j. 2006 , , 653 , 437 moeckel , n. , & bally , j. 2007 , , 661 , l183 moeckel , n. , & throop , h. b. 2009 , , 707 , 268 moeckel , n. , & bate , m. r. 2010 , , 274 monin , j .- l . , clarke , c. j. , prato , l. , & mccabe , c. 2007 , protostars and planets v , 395 ostriker , e. c. 1994 , , 424 , 292 panagia , n. , & felli , m. 1975 , , 39 , 1 pfalzner , s. 2006 , , 652 , l129 plambeck , r. l. , wright , m. c. h. , mundy , l. g. , & looney , l. w. 1995 , , 455 , l189 preibisch , t. , balega , y. , hofmann , k .- h . , weigelt , g. , & zinnecker , h. 1999 , new astronomy , 4 , 531 reid , m. j. , menten , k. m. , greenhill , l. j. , & chandler , c. j. 2007 , , 664 , 950 reipurth , b. 2000 , , 120 , 3177 reynolds , r. j. 1986 , , 92 , 653 rodrguez , l. f. , delgado - arellano , v. g. , gmez , y. , reipurth , b. , torrelles , j. m. , noriega - crespo , a. , raga , a. c. , & cant , j. 2000 , , 119 , 8 rodrguez , l. f. , poveda , a. , lizano , s. , & allen , c. 2005 , , 627 , l65 rodrguez , l. f. , zapata , l. a. , & ho , p. t. p. 2009
, , 692 , 162 scoville , n. , kleinmann , s. g. , hall , d. n. b. , & ridgway , s. t. 1983 , , 275 , 201 shu , f. h. , adams , f. c. , & lizano , s. 1987 , , 25 , 23 shu , f. h. , najita , j. r. , shang , h. , & li , z .- y .
2000 , protostars and planets iv , 789 shu , f. h. , galli , d. , lizano , s. , glassgold , a. e. , & diamond , p. h. 2007 , , 665 , 535 shuping , r. y. , morris , m. , & bally , j. 2004 , , 128 , 363 stahler , s. w. , & palla , f. 2005 , the formation of stars , by steven w. stahler , francesco palla , pp . 865 .
isbn 3 - 527 - 40559 - 3 .
wiley - vch stahl , o. , wade , g. , petit , v. , stober , b. , & schanne , l. 2008 , , 487 , 323 tan , j. c. 2004 , , 607 , l47 tan , j. c. 2008a , massive star formation : observations confront theory , 387 , 346 tan , j. c. 2008b , arxiv:0807.3771 throop , h. b. , & bally , j. 2008 , , 135 , 2380 van altena , w. f. , lee , j. t. , lee , j .- f . , lu , p. k. , & upgren , a. r. 1988 , , 95 , 1744 wright , m. c. h. , plambeck , r. l. , mundy , l. g. , & looney , l. w. 1995 , , 455 , l185 zapata , l. a. , schmid - burgk , j. , ho , p. t. p. , rodrguez , l. f. , & menten , k. m. 2009 , , 704 , l45 zinnecker , h. , & yorke , h. w. 2007 , , 45 , 481 | we present new @xmath0 mm continuum observations of orion bn / kl with the very large array ( vla ) .
we resolve the emission from the young stellar objects ( yso ) radio source i and bn at several epochs .
radio source i is highly elongated northwest - southeast , and remarkably stable in flux density , position angle , and overall morphology over nearly a decade .
this favors the extended emission component arising from an ionized edge - on disk rather than an outwardly propagating jet .
we have measured the proper motions of source i and bn for the first time at 43 ghz .
we confirm that both sources are moving at high speed ( 12 and 26 km s@xmath1 , respectively ) approximately in opposite directions , as previously inferred from measurements at lower frequencies .
we discuss dynamical scenarios that can explain the large motions of both bn and source i and the presence of disks around both .
our new measurements support the hypothesis that a close ( @xmath2 au ) dynamical interaction occurred around 500 years ago between source i and bn as proposed by gomez et al . from the dynamics of encounter
we argue that source i today is likely to be a binary with a total mass on the order of 20 m@xmath3 , and that it probably existed as a softer binary before the close encounter .
this enables preservation of the original accretion disk , though truncated to its present radius of @xmath2 au .
n - body numerical simulations show that the dynamical interaction between a binary of 20 m@xmath3 total mass ( source i ) and a single star of 10 m@xmath3 mass ( bn ) may lead to the ejection of both and binary hardening .
the gravitational energy released in the process would be large enough to power the wide - angle , high - velocity flow traced by h@xmath4 and co emission in the bn / kl nebula .
assuming the proposed dynamical history is correct , the smaller mass for source i recently estimated from sio maser dynamics ( @xmath5 m@xmath3 ) by matthews et al .
, suggests that non - gravitational forces ( e.g. magnetic ) must play an important role in the circumstellar gas dynamics . |
the major preoccupation of particle physics is the search for physics beyond the standard model or equivalently , for deviations from standard model predictions . to this end ,
measurements at the cern lep-100 @xmath3 collider and the slac slc @xmath3 collider@xcite have provided stringent tests @xcite of the standard model of the electroweak interactions @xcite . however , it is mainly the fermion - gauge boson couplings that have been tested and the gauge sector of the standard model remains poorly constrained .
a stringent test of the gauge structure of the standard model is provided by the tri - linear gauge vertices ( tgv s ) ; the @xmath1 and @xmath11 vertices . within the standard model ,
these couplings are uniquely determined by @xmath12 gauge symmetry so that a precise measurement of the vertex poses a severe test of the gauge structure of the theory . if these couplings were observed to have different values than their standard model values
, it would indicate the need for physics beyond the standard model .
the study of the trilinear gauge boson couplings by studying @xmath13 pair production is one of the primary motivations for the lep200 upgrade @xcite with a precision of 30 - 40% is expected from cross section and @xmath13 angular distribution measurements . in the far future
there is growing interest in the physics that can be done at high energy @xmath3 colliders with @xmath4 gev or @xmath14 tev , referred to as the next linear collider ( nlc ) , the japan linear collider ( jlc ) or the cern linear collider ( clic ) @xcite .
various options are being studied including @xmath15 and @xmath16 collisions where the energetic photons are obtained by backscattering a laser on one of the incident leptons .
measurements at these colliders are very sensitive to anomalous couplings with @xmath15 and @xmath16 collisions putting some of the more stringent bounds on anomalous @xmath10 couplings @xcite .
a problem common to many processes used to study tgv s is that they involve both the @xmath10 and @xmath17 vertices making it difficult to disentangle the contributions . in a previous paper we presented a detailed study of the process @xmath18 motivated by our interest in isolating the @xmath17 and @xmath10 vertices by appropriate kinematic cuts on the invariant mass of the @xmath19 @xcite . included in this final state
are contributions from the underlying process @xmath20 which shows up most dramatically when @xmath21 . however , because of the muons masses it does not quite isolate the process we are interested in . in this paper
we take the obvious limit and study the sensitivity of the process @xmath22 to anomalous @xmath10 couplings@xcite .
this process has also been used as a means of counting the number of light neutrino species@xcite . to parametrize the @xmath10 vertex we use the most general parametrization possible that respects lorentz invariance , electromagnetic gauge invariance and @xmath23 invariance @xcite since it has become the standard parametrization used in phenomenology and
therefore makes the comparison of the sensitivity of different measurements to the tgv s straightforward .
we do not consider cp violating operators in this paper as they are tightly constrained by measurement of the neutron electron dipole moment which constrains the two cp violating parameters to @xmath24 @xcite . therefore the @xmath10 vertex has two free independent parameters , @xmath5 and @xmath6 and
is given by @xcite : @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 represents the photon and @xmath28 fields respectively , @xmath29 and @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the photon and @xmath32 is the @xmath13 boson mass .
higher dimension operators would correspond to momentum dependence in the form factors which we ignore . at tree level
the standard model requires @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
note that the presence of the w - boson mass factor in the @xmath35 term is _ ad hoc _ and one could argue that the scale @xmath36 of new physics would be more appropriate
. we will conform to the usual parametrization and will not address this issue any further .
we studied the sensitivity of this process at tristan and lep / slc energies where there exists data@xcite that we could in principle use to bound the @xmath10 couplings .
however , we found that the process was insufficiently sensitive at these energies to put meaningful bounds on the @xmath10 coupling with the integrated luminosities already accumulated or expected in the foreseeable future .
we therefore start with @xmath2 gev appropriate to lep200 since this machine will be operational in the relatively near future @xcite .
we then turn to the proposed jlc / nlc / clic @xmath3 colliders with possible center of mass energies of @xmath4 gev and 1 tev@xcite .
we do not include any beamsstrahlung radiation effects in our calculation @xcite .
these effects are very much machine dependant ( beam intensity , bunch geometry , etc ) and known to be negligible at 200 gev , and small at 500 gev . however , although they can be quite important at 1000 gev , there has been progress in strategies to minimize the effects of beamstrahlung radiation .
the diagrams contributing to the process @xmath0 are shown in fig .
the main advantage of this process is that it depends only on the @xmath10 vertex .
in addition , our signal ( fig .
1(a ) ) should increase with energy , for two reasons : it is a t - channel process and should not decrease as fast with energy as the other contributions to the total process , especially when suitable kinematic cut are imposed to eliminate the on - shell @xmath37 contribution . also , anomalous couplings , in general , become more important at higher energies . to evaluate the cross - sections and different distributions
, we used the calkul helicity amplitude technique @xcite to obtain expressions for the matrix elements and performed the phase space integration using monte carlo techniques @xcite .
the expressions for the helicity amplitudes are lengthy and unilluminating so we do not include them here . the interested reader can obtain them directly from the authors . to obtain numerical results we used the values @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 gev , @xmath41 gev , @xmath42 gev , and @xmath43 gev .
the signal we are studying is an energetic @xmath44 plus missing transverse momentum .
the largest potential background is bhabba scattering with a hard photon and the electron and positron going down the beam pipe .
this should not be a serious problem given that we are interested in energetic photons and the luminosity monitors , based on bhabba scattering , should be able to veto any such events . in order to take into account finite detector acceptance , we require that the photon be at least 10 degrees away from the beam line although in practice the cuts we use to enhance the signal are much more restrictive than this ( typically @xmath45 ) . in principle we should include qed radiative corrections from soft photon emission and the backgrounds due to a second photon either that is lost down the beam pipe or collinear to the hard photon being measured and therefore unresolved @xcite .
although soft photon emission can reduce the cross section substantially , their inclusion does not substantially effect the bounds we obtain and therefore our conclusions .
the effects of an unseen second photon turn out to be quite small . since
both these contributions depend on details of detector such as energy resolution and do not alter our conclusions we leave them out but stress that they must be included in detailed detector monte carlo simulations . the approach we followed was to examine various kinematic distributions , @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and kinematic cuts to find which ones optimized the sensitivity to anomalous couplings . in general ,
the tightest constraints were obtained by imposing cuts on the photon energy which eliminated contributions from on - shell @xmath49 production ( diagrams 1(d ) and 1(e ) ) .
0.3 cm a. @xmath2 gev 0.2 cm in fig .
2 we show the @xmath50 distribution for @xmath2 gev for several values of @xmath5 and @xmath6 .
the most prominent feature of the distribution comes from the contribution of the on - shell @xmath49 ( diagrams 1(d ) and 1(e ) ) . from fig .
2 it can be seen that the regions off the @xmath49 resonance are most sensitive to anomalous couplings with the greatest sensitivity in the region above the @xmath49 resonance . this is because that region probes the largest momentum transfer through the @xmath13-boson t - channel propagators .
we found that the tightest constraints could be obtained by imposing an angular cut of @xmath51 and on the two regions of @xmath50 : 25 gev@xmath5265 gev and @xmath5388 gev . for 25 gev@xmath5265 gev
the cross section is 0.14 pb which for an integrated luminosity of 500 pb@xmath54 results in about a 12% statistical error .
similarly for @xmath5388 gev @xmath55 pb which gives a 50% statistical error .
monte carlo studies of sld type detectors give very crude estimates of systematic errors of 5% for cross section measurements @xcite .
therefore the effects of including a 5% systematic error are not particularly important .
the 68% c.l . , 90% c.l . , and 95% c.l .
bounds that could be obtained with these cuts for @xmath2 gev and integrated luminosity of l=500 pb@xmath54 are shown in fig .
3 with numerical values when varying one parameter at a time given in table i. it is worth mentioning that the _ most efficient _ energy and angular cuts will vary slightly with the domain of @xmath5 and @xmath6 being probed .
however , this dependance is mild and the limits will not vary much if one uses a fixed set of cuts . an important question for lep200
is the effect on the _ physics reach _ of different center of mass energies . to gauge the change of the sensitivity to the tgv s for different energies we plot in fig .
4 the 90% c.l . for @xmath56 gev , 200 gev , and 230 gev . clearly ,
the higher the energy the tighter the constraints that can be obtained . roughly speaking , increasing the c.m .
energy by 15% will increase the sensitivity to anomalous couplings by 30% .
however , even for the highest possible energies at lep200 of @xmath57 gev the obtainable bounds are not competitive with the @xmath13-pair production process or for that matter with bounds obtained by the tevatron experiments via associated @xmath58 production , and will , at best , be a consistency check of other measurements . 0.3 cm b. @xmath4 gev 0.2 cm we next turn to an `` nlc '' type @xmath3 collider with @xmath4 gev .
we consider integrated luminosities of 10 and 50 @xmath59 .
the photon energy distributions for a several values of @xmath5 and @xmath6 are shown in fig .
5 . as before ,
the values of @xmath50 most sensitive to anomalous couplings are off the @xmath49 resonance and @xmath5 and @xmath6 are sensitive to different values of @xmath50 .
for example , @xmath5 is most sensitive to @xmath60 gev while @xmath6 is most sensitive to @xmath61 gev .
the bounds obtained from these observables are shown in fig . 6 with numerical values obtained by varying one parameter
at a time given in table i. one could obtain additional information by using the transverse energy distribution of the photons with and without left - handed polarized electrons . for @xmath60 gev the cross section is @xmath62 pb which for an integrated luminosity of 50 fb@xmath54 gives a statistical error of 0.8% . likewise for @xmath61 gev we obtain @xmath63 pb and @xmath64% and for @xmath65 gev @xmath66 pb and @xmath67% .
given the small statistical errors including a 5% systematic errors will have a considerable effect on the bounds that can be obtained .
for example for @xmath60 gev where the statistical error is smallest including a 5% systematic error reduces the sensitivity by roughly a factor of 5 while for @xmath61 gev where the statistical error is larger it has only a small effect and for @xmath65 gev where the statistical error is largest the effect of the systematic error is neglegible .
0.3 cm c. @xmath14 tev 0.2 cm the final case we consider is a 1 tev @xmath3 collider . in fig .
7 we show the photon energy distribution for several values of @xmath5 and @xmath6 . as in the 500 gev case
we find that @xmath5 and @xmath6 are sensitive to different values of @xmath50 .
for the photon energy range @xmath68 gev @xmath69 pb which for an integrated luminosity of 200 fb@xmath54 gives @xmath70% while for @xmath71 gev @xmath72 pb @xmath73% . including a 5% systematic error
weakens the bounds on the tgv s considerably , even more so at @xmath14 tev than at 500 gev . in fig .
8 we show the bounds that could be obtained using @xmath68 gev and @xmath71 gev and give some numerical values in table i. the bounds obtainable on @xmath5 are down to the percent level necessary to probe radiative corrections to the gauge boson vertices . although the bounds on @xmath6 are also down to this level radiative corrections are about an order of magnitude smaller so that it is unlikely that deviations from the tree - level value could be observed unless there was a radical departure from the standard model by , for example , compositeness .
we have examined the usefulness of the process @xmath0 for measuring the @xmath74 vertex . the sensitivity of this process to anomalous coupling is greatly enhanced ( by a factor of 5 - 8 generally ) by eliminating the on - shell @xmath37 and by splitting the energy domain of the photon into more than one bin .
the process turned out to be too insensitive at tristan and lep-100/slc energies to obtain bounds competitive with recent results from the tevatron .
in fact , the same is also true for lep-200 energies which at best will offer a consistency check of bounds extracted from @xmath13-pair production at lep-200 and the tevatron . at higher energy @xmath3 colliders , this process can lead to very stringent bounds , precise enough to test the tgv s at the level of radiative corrections .
we used the high luminosities planned for at the high energy @xmath3 colliders to estimate statistical errors . when we included reasonable estimates of systematic errors we found that the limiting factor in high precision measurements will likely be systematic errors not statistical errors
however , we based our analysis on optimizing cuts on @xmath50 and @xmath75 and it is likely that performing a more detailed maximum likelihood fit of real data would make fuller use of the information in the data thereby obtaining tighter bounds
. the challenge will be to reduce the systematic errors and one should be very careful with respect to the conclusions one makes by considering only statistical errors .
m. swartz , invited talk at the xvi international symposium on lepton - photon interactions , cornell university , ithaca new york , august 10 - 15 , 1993 .
w. hollik , invited talk at the xvi international symposium on lepton - photon interactions , cornell university , ithaca new york , august 10 - 15 , 1993 .
burgess , s. godfrey , h. knig , d. london , and i. maksymyk , carleton university report ocip / c-93 - 6 ( 1993 ; unpublished ) .
glashow , nucl . phys . * 22 * , 579 ( 1961 ) ; s. weinberg , phys .
* 19 * , 1264 ( 1967 ) ; a. salam , proc . of the 8th nobel symposium , ed .
n. svartholm ( willey , new york 1968 )
. k. hagiwara _
et al _ , nucl . phys .
* b282 * , 253 ( 1987 ) .
d. zeppenfeld , phys .
let . * 183b * , 380 ( 1987 ) ; d. treille _
et al _ , proceedings of the ecfa workshop on lep 200 , ed .
a. bhm and w. hoogland , aachen ( 1986 ) , cern 87 - 08 , vol.2 , p.414 .
dicus , k. kallianpur , phys . rev . *
d32 * , 35 ( 1985 ) ; m.j .
duncan , g.l .
kane , phys .
lett . * 55 * , 773 ( 1985 ) ; e.n.argyres and c.g.papadopoulos , phys . lett . *
b263 * , 298(1991 ) .
g.kane , j. vidal , c.p .
yuan , phys . rev . * d39 * , 2617 ( 1990 ) , and references therein .
d. treille , proceedings of the workshop on physics and experiments with linear @xmath3 colliders , waikoloa hawaii , april 1993 ( world scientific ; in press ) ; a. djouadi and p.m. zerwas , proceedings of _ beyond the standard model iii _ , ed .
s. godfrey and p. kayniak , ottawa canada , june 1992 , ( world scientific , singapore , 1993 ) p. 204 .
a. miyamoto , proceedings of workshop on physics and experiments with linear @xmath3 colliders , waikoloa , hawaii , ed . f.a .
harris , s.l .
olsen , s. pakvasa , and x. tata , ( world scientific , singapore , 1994 ) p 141 .
see for example , b. wiik , proceedings of the workshop on physics and experiments with linear @xmath3 colliders , waikoloa hawaii , april 1993 ( world scientific ; in press ) .
proceedings of the first workshop on japan linear collider ( jlc ) , kek , oct 24 - 25 , 1989 , kek report 90 - 2 ( 1990 ) ; proceedings of the second workshop on japan linear collider , ed .
s. kawabata , nov .
6 - 8 , 1990 kek proceedings 91 - 10 nov . 1991 . c. ahn _
_ , _ opportunities and requirments for experimentation at a very high energy @xmath3 collider _ , slac report slac-0329 ( 1988 ) ; proceedings of the workshop on physics at future accelerators , cern yellow report 87 - 07 ( 1987 ) .
e. yehudai , phys . rev . * d 41 * , 33 ( 1990 ) ; * d44 * , 3434 ( 1991 ) ; s. godfrey and a.k .
peterson , carleton university report ocip / c-92 - 7 .
g. couture , s. godfrey , p. kalyniak phys .
rev * d39 * , 3239 ( 1989 ) , phys . rev . * d42*,1841 ( 1990 ) , phys . lett . *
b218 * , 361 ( 1989 ) and references therein .
choi and f. schrempp , phys .
272b * , 149 ( 1991 ) , g. couture and g. blanger , phys . rev .
* d49 * ( in press ) . g. couture , s. godfrey , and r. lewis , phys . rev . *
d45 * , 777 ( 1992 ) ; g. couture and s. godfrey , phys . rev . *
d49 * , ( 1994 , in press ) ; g.v .
borisov , v.n .
larin , and f.f .
tikhonin , zeit .
c41 * , 287 ( 1988 ) .
et al . _ , slac report slac - pub-4990 ( 1989 , unpublished ) ,
ware , m.e .
machacek , phys . lett . *
147b * , 415 ( 1984 ) , g. couture and j.n .
ng , phys . rev .
* d34 * , 744 ( 1986 ) .
k. gaemers and g. gounaris , z. phys .
* c1 * , 259 ( 1979 ) .
i hikasa phys . rev .
* d33 * , 3203 ( 1986 ) ; k. hagiwara _ et al _ , nucl . phys .
* b282 * , 253 ( 1987 ) ; j.fleischer et al . z. phys . , * c42 * , 409 ( 1989 ) .
marciano , a. queijeiro , phys . rev .
* d 33 * , 3449 ( 1986 ) ; f. boudjema , k. hagiwara , c. hamzaoui , and k. numata , phys . rev . *
d43 * , 2223 ( 1991 ) .
venus collaboration , n. hosoda _
et al . _ , kek preprint 93 - 194 ( 1994 , unpublished ) .
opal collaboration , m.z .
et al . _ ,
c50 * , 373 ( 1991 ) ; l3 collaboration , b. adeva _
et al . _ ,
b275 * , 209 ( 1992 ) ; phys . lett . *
b297 * , 468 ( 1992 ) ; aleph collaboration , d. buskulic _ et al .
_ , phys . lett .
* b313 * , 520 ( 1993 ) .
r. j. noble , nucl .
methods * a256 * , 427
( 1987 ) ; r. blankenbecler and s.d .
drell , phys .
* d36 * , 277 ( 1987 ) ; * d37 * , 3308 ( 1988 ) ; phys .
lett . * 61 * , 2324 ( 1988 ) ; r. blankenbecler , s.d . drell and n. kroll , phys . rev . *
d40 * , 2462 ( 1989 ) ; d. v. schroeder , phd thesis , slac report slac-371 ( 1990 , unpublished ) .
r. kleiss and w. j. stirling , nucl . phys . *
b262 * , 235 ( 1985 ) ; z.xu d .-
h.zhang l. chang nucl .
b291 * , 392 ( 1987 ) .
see for example v. barger and r. phillips , _ collider physics _ , ( addison - wesley publishing company , 1987 ) .
o. nicrosini and l. trendadue , nucl . phys . *
b318 * , 1 ( 1989 ) ; l. trentadue _
_ , in : z physics at lep1 , ed .
g. altarelli , cern yellow report cern 89 - 08 ( cern , geneva , 1989 ) p129 .
t. barklow , private communication .
llll + observable & & @xmath76(l=250 pb@xmath54 ) & @xmath77(l=500
pb@xmath54 ) + @xmath78 gev & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 + @xmath82 gev & @xmath79 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 + & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 + @xmath88 gev & @xmath79 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 + & @xmath85 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 + + observable & & @xmath76(l=10 fb@xmath54 ) & @xmath77(l=50 fb@xmath54 ) + @xmath60 gev & @xmath79 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 + @xmath95 gev & @xmath79 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 + & @xmath85 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 + @xmath100 gev & @xmath85 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 + + observable & & @xmath76(l=50 fb@xmath54 ) & @xmath77(l=200 fb@xmath54 ) + @xmath103 gev & @xmath79 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 + @xmath106 gev & @xmath85 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 + | we perform a detailed study of the process @xmath0 and its sensitivity to anomalous gauge boson couplings of the @xmath1 vertex .
we concentrate on lep ii energies , @xmath2 gev , and energies appropriate to the proposed next linear collider ( nlc ) high energy @xmath3 collider with center of mass energies @xmath4 and 1 tev . at 200 gev ,
the process offers , at best , a consistency check of other processes being considered at lep200 . at 500 gev , the parameters @xmath5 and @xmath6 can be measured to about @xmath7 and @xmath8 respectively at 95% c.l . while at 1 tev
, they can be measured to about @xmath9 . at the high luminosities anticipated at high energy linear colliders precision measurements
are likely to be limited by systematic rather than statistical errors . 1.0 cm measurement of the @xmath10 vertex through + single photon production at @xmath3 colliders dpartement de physique , universit du qubec montral + c.p . 8888 , succ .
centre - ville , montral , qubec , canada , h3c 3p8 ottawa - carleton institute for physics + department of physics , carleton university , ottawa canada , k1s 5b6 |
early investigations of black hole accretion flows indicated that tenuous flows can develop a two - temperature structure , with proton temperature sufficient to produce a significant @xmath0-ray luminosity above 10 mev through @xmath9 production ( e.g. dahlbacka , chapline & weaver 1974 ) .
the two - temperature structure is an essential feature of the optically - thin , advection dominated accretion flow ( adaf ) model , which has been extensively studied and successfully applied to a variety of black hole systems ( see , e.g. , reviews in yuan 2007 , narayan & mcclintock 2008 , yuan & narayan 2013 ) over the past two decades , following the work of narayan & yi ( 1994 ) .
mahadevan , narayan & krolik ( 1997 ; hereafter m97 ) pointed out that @xmath0-ray emission resulting from proton - proton collisions in adafs may be a signature allowing to test their fundamental nature .
the model of m97 relied on a non - relativistic adaf model and their computations were improved by oka & manmoto ( 2003 ; hereafter om03 ) who used a fully general relativistic ( gr ) model of the flow . however , both m97 and om03 neglected the doppler and gravitational shifts of energy as well as gravitational focusing and capturing by the black hole , which is a major deficiency because the @xmath0-ray emission is produced very close to the black hole s horizon . furthermore
, both works neglected the internal absorption of @xmath0-ray photons to pair creation , which effect should be important in more luminous systems .
adafs are supposed to power low - luminosity agns , like fanaroff - riley type i ( fr i ) radio galaxies or low - luminosity seyfert galaxies , and a measurement , or even upper limits on their @xmath0-ray emission , may put interesting constraints on the properties of the source of high - energy radiation in such objects .
m97 and om03 considered only the _
cgro_/egret source in the direction of the galactic center for such an analysis .
significant progress in exploration of the @xmath0-ray activity of agns which has been made after their works , thanks to the _ fermi _ mission , motivates us to develop a more accurate model of the hadronic @xmath0-ray emission from adafs .
detections of @xmath0-ray emission from objects with misaligned jets ( e.g. abdo et al .
2010b ) are most relevant for our study .
their @xmath0-ray radiation is usually explained as a jet emission ; we show that emission from an accretion flow may be a reasonable alternative , at least in some fr is .
we focus on modelling of radiation in 100 mev 10 gev energy range , relevant for the _ fermi_-lat measurements of the fr i radio galaxies ( abdo et al .
2010b ) and over which the upper limits in seyfert galaxies are derived ( ackermann et al .
2012 ) .
the dependence of the @xmath0-ray luminosity on the black hole spin parameter makes a particularly interesting context for such an investigation .
already a rough estimate by shapiro , lightman & eardley ( 1976 ) indicated a strong dependence of the @xmath0-ray luminosity from a two - temperature flow on the spin of the black hole and , then , they suggested that this effect may serve as a means to measure the spin value ( see also eilek & kafatos 1983 and colpi , maraschi & treves 1986 ) .
om03 , who made gr calculations for the modern adaf model , found a dramatic dependence of the @xmath0-ray luminosity on the spin value in models with thermal distribution of proton energies , however , they concluded that the dependence is weak if protons have a nonthermal distribution . in this work
we extend the analysis of this issue and clarify some related properties .
we find global solutions of the hydrodynamical adaf model , which follows manmoto ( 2000 ) , and use them to compute the @xmath0-ray emission . similarly to m97 and om03 we take into account emission resulting from thermal and nonthermal distribution of proton energies ; we use similar phenomenological models , with some modifications which allow to illustrate separately effects due to local distribution of proton energies and to radial profile of @xmath0-ray emissivity .
we also use our recently developed model of global comptonization ( niedwiecki , xie & zdziarski 2012 ; hereafter n12 , see also xie et al .
2010 ) to compute the x - ray emission , which allows to investigate the internal absorption of @xmath0-ray photons to pair creation in the flow . in our computations
we assume a rather weak magnetic field , with the magnetic pressure of 1/10th of the total pressure , supported by results of the magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations in which amplification of magnetic fields by the magneto - rotational instability typically saturates at such a ratio of the magnetic to the total pressure ( e.g. machida , nakamura & matsumoto 2004 , hirose et al .
2004 , hawley & krolik 2001 ) .
we investigate the dependence on the poorly understood parameter in adaf theory , @xmath10 , describing the fraction of the turbulent dissipation that directly heats electrons in the flow .
we take into account only one value of the accretion rate , but the considered ranges of the spin and @xmath10 parameters yield a rather large range of bolometric luminosities of @xmath11 to @xmath12 of the eddington luminosity . in our paper
we present both the spectra affected by @xmath13 absorption and those neglecting the absorption effect ; the latter may be easily scaled to smaller accretion rates , for which the @xmath13 absorption becomes unimportant .
we consider a black hole , characterised by its mass , @xmath14 , and angular momentum , @xmath15 , surrounded by a geometrically thick accretion flow with an accretion rate , @xmath16 .
we define the following dimensionless parameters : @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , where @xmath20 , @xmath21 is the gravitational radius and @xmath22 is the eddington luminosity .
most results presented in this work correspond to @xmath23 , in fig [ fig:6]a we present also results for @xmath24 .
we consider @xmath25 and three values of the spin parameter , @xmath26 , 0.95 and 0.998 .
the inclination angle of the line of sight to the symmetry axis is given by @xmath27 .
we assume that the density distribution is given by @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the scale height at @xmath30 .
we assume the viscosity parameter of @xmath31 and the ratio of the gas pressure ( electron and ion ) to the total pressure of @xmath32 .
the fraction of the dissipated energy which heats directly electrons is denoted by @xmath10 .
our calculations of hadronic processes are based on global solutions of the fully gr hydrodynamical model of two - temperature adafs , described in n12 , which follows closely the model of manmoto ( 2000 ) . here
we recall only the ion energy equation , which is most important for the present study : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the coulomb rate , the compressive heating and the advection of the internal energy of ions , respectively , are given by @xmath35 and the viscous dissipation rate , per unit area , is given by @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath38 is the ion pressure , @xmath39 is the electron pressure , @xmath40 is the ion adiabatic index , @xmath41 is the angular velocity of the flow , @xmath42 is the lorentz factor of the azimuthal motion and @xmath43 .
the form of the energy equation given in equation ( [ eq : ions ] ) is standard in adafs theory , although actually it should include an additional term describing the direct cooling of protons to pion production , @xmath44 . in our calculation of hadronic processes
we find that @xmath44 is approximately equal to @xmath34 at @xmath45 . at @xmath46 ,
considered in this work , both @xmath44 and @xmath34 are much smaller , by over 3 orders of magnitude , than the effective heating @xmath47 and the heating is fully balanced by the advective term , @xmath48 .
this justifies our neglect of the direct hadronic cooling .
the only difference between our gr model and that of manmoto ( 2000 ) involves the simplifying assumption of @xmath49 adopted in the latter ; we do not follow this simplification and an exact @xmath50 profile is considered in all our hydrodynamic equations .
we note that the simplification has a considerable effect in the central part of the flow , e.g. it results in an underestimation of the proton temperature by a factor of @xmath51 within the innermost @xmath52 .
applying the above simplifying assumption we get exactly the same flow parameters as manmoto ( 2000 ) ; note , however , that manmoto ( 2000 ) assumed an equipartition between the gas and plasma pressures , with @xmath53 , which in general gives a smaller proton temperature than @xmath54 assumed here . in particular , for @xmath26 and @xmath55 , models with @xmath54 give the proton temperature larger by a factor of @xmath56 , close to the horizon , than models with @xmath53 .
this underlies also the differences in the @xmath0-ray luminosity levels between the thermal models of oka & manmoto ( 2003 ) and ours , as discussed in section 3 . to obtain global transonic solutions we have to adjust the specific angular momentum per unit mass accreted by the black hole , for which the accretion flow passes smoothly through the sonic point , @xmath57 .
we note that this condition permits for two kinds of solutions , below referred to as a standard and a superhot solution .
the latter ( superhot ) has much larger proton temperature and density , furthermore , the sound speed is large and the sonic point located in the immediate vicinity of the event horizon , e.g. @xmath58 for @xmath59 . in the standard solutions the sonic point
is located at larger distances , @xmath60 .
taking into account rather extreme properties of the superhot solutions ( specifically , a very large magnitude of @xmath61 illustrated in fig .
[ fig:1](a ) and discussed in section [ sec : diss ] ) we neglect them in this work and for all values of @xmath8 we consider only the standard solutions which are consistent with solutions of the model investigated in several previous studies ( e.g. manmoto 2000 , yuan et al 2009 , li et al .
note , however , that in our previous works ( n12 , niedwiecki , xie & beckmann 2012 ) we considered the superhot solution with @xmath59 , then , the results for @xmath59 discussed in those works correspond to flows with larger proton temperature and density ( both by a factor of @xmath62 ) than these considered in the present study .
[ fig:1 ] shows the dependence on the black hole spin of some parameters from our solutions which are crucial for the hadronic @xmath0-ray production .
rotation of the black hole stabilizes the circular motion of the flow which yields a higher density ( through the continuity equation ) .
furthermore , the stabilized rotation of the flow results in a stronger dissipative heating giving a larger proton temperature for larger @xmath8 .
all these differences are significant only within the innermost @xmath63 .
the hydrodynamical solutions set the proton density , @xmath64 , and temperature , @xmath65 , as a function of radius . in principle , this should allow to determine the @xmath0-ray emissivity , resulting from neutral pion production in proton - proton collisions and their subsequent decay into @xmath0-ray photons , in the rest frame of the flow .
however , details of this process are subject to an uncertainty related to the distribution of proton energies , which is unlikely to be thermal in optically thin flows ( see discussion in section [ sec : protons ] ) . following m97 and om03
we assume that the temperature from the global solution functions as a parameter specifying the average energy of protons in the plasma which , however , does not have to have a thermal distribution .
we consider several phenomenological models which must satisfy the obvious requirements that at each radius ( 1 ) the number density of protons equals @xmath66 , determined by the global adaf solution and ( 2 ) the average energy of protons equals the average energy @xmath67 of the maxwellian proton gas with temperature , @xmath68 , determined by the global adaf solution , where @xmath69 and we use the simplified ( cf .
gammie & popham 1998 ) relativistic form of @xmath70 .
we consider models involving various combinations of thermal @xmath71 , \label{eq : thdist}\ ] ] and power - law @xmath72 distributions of proton energies , where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the local densities of these two populations . the thermal model ( model t ) assuming a purely maxwellian distribution of protons and the nonthermal model ( model n , same to nonthermal models of m97 and om03 ) , assuming that the total energy is stored in the power - law distribution of a small fraction of protons , allow us to estimate the _ minimum _ and _ maximum _ level of @xmath0-ray luminosity , respectively , for a given set of ( @xmath14 , @xmath75 , @xmath8 , @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath10 ) .
mahadevan ( 1999 ) and om03 considered the model involving the mixture of the thermal and power - law distributions , with the radius - independent parameter characterizing the fraction of energy that goes into the two distributions .
deviations of such a model from model n are trivial , with the @xmath0-ray luminosity linearly proportional to the fraction of energy going to the power - law distribution . in this work
we consider a different hybrid model ( model h ) with the radius dependent normalization between the power - law and the thermal distribution , which allows us to illustrate some additional effects .
the detailed assumptions on the parameters of these models are as follows ( @xmath66 and @xmath68 denote values given by the global adaf solution ) : * model t * assumes a purely maxwellian distribution of protons , equation ( [ eq : thdist ] ) , with @xmath78 and @xmath79 .
* assumes that a fraction @xmath80 of protons form the power - law distribution , equation ( [ eq : pldist ] ) , with the radius - independent index @xmath81 and @xmath82 , and the remaining protons are cold , with the lorentz factor @xmath83 ( @xmath84 is assumed in the computations ) .
the radius - dependent fraction @xmath80 is determined by @xmath85 .
\label{psi1}\ ] ] * model h * assumes that an efficient nonthermal acceleration operates only within the central @xmath86 , where the average proton energies resulting from the adaf solutions become relativistic .
specifically , we assume that at each radius at @xmath87 a fraction of protons form a thermal distribution at a subrelativistic temperature of @xmath88 k ( @xmath89 ) , and the remaining form a power - law distribution ( equation [ eq : pldist ] ) with a constant ( i.e. radius - independent ) index @xmath81 and @xmath82 . the relative normalization of these two distributions is determined by @xmath90 , \label{psi2}\ ] ] ( where the factor @xmath91 results from equation ( [ eq : uth ] ) with @xmath92 ) . at @xmath93 , where @xmath94 k , there are no non - thermal protons in this model , which then results in a negligible pion production at such distances , similar as in model t. the chosen value of @xmath88 k gives a smooth transition between a purely thermal and a hybrid plasma at @xmath95 , however , radiative properties of model h are roughly independent of the specific value of the temperature of the subrelativistic thermal component .
we remark also that @xmath96 k is close to the limiting temperature above which the pion production prevents thermalization of protons ( see stepney 1983 , dermer 1986b ) the efficiency of pion production by protons with the power - law distribution increases with the decrease of the power - law index @xmath81 . on the other hand ,
the fraction @xmath80 decreases with decreasing @xmath81 , roughly as @xmath97 .
these two effects balance each other yielding the largest luminosity in 0.110 gev range , @xmath98 , for @xmath99 . for @xmath100 ,
the dependence of @xmath98 on @xmath81 is weak ; for @xmath101 , @xmath98 is by a factor of @xmath102 smaller than for @xmath103 . to estimate the maximum value of @xmath98 that can be produced in a flow with given parameters , in our computations for models n and h we use @xmath103 . for all values of @xmath8 ,
@xmath104 , and also @xmath105 in models h and n with @xmath103 , within the innermost several @xmath106 . in our solutions of the flow structure
we assume that protons are thermal and we use the thermal form of the gas pressure
. then , our models n and h with non - thermal proton distributions are not strictly self - consistent , as their pressure may deviate from the thermal prescription
. however , this is a rather small effect , e.g. the pressure of the purely non - thermal distribution ( model n ) differs by 2030 per cent from the pressure of a thermal gas with the same internal energy . for a given distribution of proton energies
we determine the @xmath0-ray spectra in the flow rest frame , strictly following dermer ( 1986a,1986b ) , in a manner similar to m97 and om03 ; however , we do not apply the following simplification underlying their nonthermal model .
as argued in m97 , the fraction of nonthermal protons should be small , @xmath107 , and , therefore , interactions of nonthermal protons with other nonthermal protons may be neglected ; hence , only interaction of nonthermal protons with cold protons are taken into account in their computations .
we remark that such an approach underestimates the @xmath0-ray luminosity , e.g. by a factor of @xmath102 in model n with @xmath108 and @xmath103 ( for which @xmath109 in the innermost region ) . in all our models
we take into account interaction of protons with all other protons . to compute the @xmath0-ray luminosity and spectra received by distant observers we use a monte carlo method similar to that described in niedwiecki ( 2005 ) .
we generate @xmath0-ray photons isotropically in the plasma frame , make a lorentz transformation from the flow rest frame to the locally non rotating ( lnr ) frame and then we compute the transfer of @xmath0-ray photons in curved space - time ; see , e.g. , bardeen et al .
( 1972 ) for the definition of lnr frames and the equations of motion in the kerr metric . the dashed lines in fig . [ fig:7 ]
show the radial profiles of the vertically - integrated @xmath0-ray emissivity , @xmath44 ( @xmath44 gives the energy emitted from the unit area per unit time ) for models t , h and n with @xmath108 .
the solid lines in fig . [ fig:7 ]
show the radial profiles of the vertically - integrated local luminosity ( the energy per unit time reaching infinity from the unit area at a given @xmath30 ) .
the local luminosity profiles shown by the solid lines neglect the @xmath13 absorption , so the difference between the dashed and solid lines is only due to the relativistic transfer effects .
[ fig:3 ] shows the corresponding @xmath0-ray spectra and compares them with the spectra for @xmath26 .
at @xmath45 both models n and h are characterised by similar values of @xmath80 and produce similar amounts of @xmath0-rays . in both models t and h the contribution from @xmath110 is very weak ; in model n the radial emissivity is much flatter despite @xmath80 being small , e.g. @xmath111 at @xmath112 . comparing models t and h
we can see the effect of the local proton distribution function and by comparing models h and n we can see the effect of the radial emissivity . for the thermal distribution of protons ,
the rest - frame photon spectra are symmetrical , in the logarithmic scale , around @xmath113 mev but in @xmath114 units they peak around 200 mev ; the position of the maximum in the spectra observed by distant observes is slightly redshifted .
note that the difference of @xmath0-ray luminosities , @xmath115 , between @xmath26 and 0.95 in our model t is much smaller than that derived by om03 , whose thermal models with @xmath26 and 0.95 give @xmath115 differing by approximately three orders of magnitude .
the difference is due to different values of @xmath116 assumed here and by om03 , which result in different @xmath117 , as discussed in section [ sec : flow ] .
the dependence of @xmath115 on @xmath117 changes around @xmath118 ( see , e.g. , fig . 3 in dermer 1986b ) . at lower temperatures
, @xmath115 is extremely sensitive to @xmath117 , with the increase of @xmath117 by a factor of 2 yielding the increase of @xmath115 by over two orders of magnitude . at @xmath104 ,
the dependence is more modest , e.g. the increase of @xmath117 from 0.2 to 0.4 results in the increase of @xmath115 by only a factor of @xmath102 . for @xmath54
assumed in this work , @xmath119 at small @xmath30 for all values of @xmath8 , making the @xmath0-ray luminosity much less dependent on the black hole spin . for @xmath53 , assumed by om03 , the proton temperature is small , with the maximum value of @xmath120 for @xmath26 , which leads to the strong dependence of @xmath115 on @xmath8 .
-ray spectra , respectively , for model t ( ab ) and model h with @xmath103 ( cd ) .
dotted ( red ) and dot - dashed ( magenta ) lines in ( cd ) show the rest frame and the observed @xmath0-ray spectra , respectively , for model n with @xmath103 .
all spectra are for @xmath55 ; panels ( a ) and ( c ) are for @xmath26 , panels ( b ) and ( d ) are for @xmath108 . in this figure , the observed spectra neglect @xmath13 absorption , so they are effected only by gr effects . , title="fig:",height=120 ] -ray spectra , respectively , for model t ( ab ) and model h with @xmath103 ( cd ) .
dotted ( red ) and dot - dashed ( magenta ) lines in ( cd ) show the rest frame and the observed @xmath0-ray spectra , respectively , for model n with @xmath103 .
all spectra are for @xmath55 ; panels ( a ) and ( c ) are for @xmath26 , panels ( b ) and ( d ) are for @xmath108 . in this figure ,
the observed spectra neglect @xmath13 absorption , so they are effected only by gr effects .
, title="fig:",height=120 ] -ray spectra , respectively , for model t ( ab ) and model h with @xmath103 ( cd ) .
dotted ( red ) and dot - dashed ( magenta ) lines in ( cd ) show the rest frame and the observed @xmath0-ray spectra , respectively , for model n with @xmath103 .
all spectra are for @xmath55 ; panels ( a ) and ( c ) are for @xmath26 , panels ( b ) and ( d ) are for @xmath108 . in this figure ,
the observed spectra neglect @xmath13 absorption , so they are effected only by gr effects .
, title="fig:",height=132 ] -ray spectra , respectively , for model t ( ab ) and model h with @xmath103 ( cd ) .
dotted ( red ) and dot - dashed ( magenta ) lines in ( cd ) show the rest frame and the observed @xmath0-ray spectra , respectively , for model n with @xmath103 .
all spectra are for @xmath55 ; panels ( a ) and ( c ) are for @xmath26 , panels ( b ) and ( d ) are for @xmath108 . in this figure ,
the observed spectra neglect @xmath13 absorption , so they are effected only by gr effects .
, title="fig:",height=132 ] for both model h and n , the spectrum at @xmath121 gev has the same slope as the power - law distribution of proton energies . for model
h with @xmath103 , @xmath115 is by a factor of 3 larger than in model t. rather small difference between @xmath115 in our thermal and nonthermal models is again due to our assumption of a weak magnetic field . at smaller
@xmath116 , resulting in smaller @xmath117 , the presence of even a small fraction of non - thermal electrons leads to the increase of @xmath122 by orders of magnitude , as can be seen by comparing the emissivities of our models n and t at @xmath110 ( see also m97 ) .
-ray spectra taking into account and neglecting the @xmath13 absorption for model h with @xmath103 ; @xmath59 ( a ) and @xmath26 ( b ) . the dot - dashed ( red ) and dashed ( blue ) lines show the spectra observed at @xmath123 , with and without absorption , and the solid ( magenta ) and dotted ( black ) lines show the spectra observed at @xmath124 , with and without absorption , respectively . ,
title="fig:",height=132 ] -ray spectra taking into account and neglecting the @xmath13 absorption for model h with @xmath103 ; @xmath59 ( a ) and @xmath26 ( b ) .
the dot - dashed ( red ) and dashed ( blue ) lines show the spectra observed at @xmath123 , with and without absorption , and the solid ( magenta ) and dotted ( black ) lines show the spectra observed at @xmath124 , with and without absorption , respectively .
, title="fig:",height=132 ] for models t and h the bulk of the @xmath0-ray emission comes from @xmath125 ( fig .
[ fig:7]ab ) and the gr transfer effects reduce the detected @xmath0-ray flux by approximately an order of magnitude . in model
n the magnitude of the gr effects on the total flux is reduced due to strong contribution from @xmath126 ( which is weakly affected by gr ) . also in model n , the contribution from @xmath126 , which for @xmath26 approximately equals the contribution from @xmath45 , reduces the difference between the @xmath0-ray fluxes observed for @xmath26 and @xmath108 to only a factor of @xmath102 , see fig .
[ fig:3](cd ) .
the viewing - angle dependent spectra for model h , which would be observed ( if unabsorbed ) by distant observers , are shown by the dashed and dotted lines in fig .
[ fig:8 ] .
the flows considered in this work are quasi - spherical and optically thin and hence their appearance depends on the viewing angle primarily due to the relativistic transfer effects .
most importantly , trajectories of photons emitted close to a rapidly rotating black hole are bent toward its equatorial plane . therefore , the @xmath0-ray radiation has a significant intrinsic anisotropy in models with large @xmath8 , with edge - on directions corresponding to larger @xmath0-ray fluxes .
the absorption of @xmath0-rays in the radiation field of the flow has been calculated in a fully gr model by li et al .
( 2009 ) . here
we use a similar approach with the major difference involving the computation of target photon density .
li et al . ( 2009 ) considered the propagation of photons with energies of 10 tev , which are absorbed mostly in interactions with infra - red photons .
those low energy photons are produced primarily by the synchrotron emission which can be simply modelled using its local emissivity . in turn
, photons with energies in 0.110 gev range , considered in this work , are mostly absorbed by the uv and soft x - ray photons , which are produced by comptonization .
then , an exact computation of the angular- , energy- and location - dependent distribution of the target photon field requires the precise modelling of the comptonization taking into account its global nature . in our model
we apply the monte carlo ( mc ) method , described in detail in n12 , with seed photons for comptonization from synchrotron and bremsstrahlung emission .
we find self - consistent electron temperature distributions using the procedure described in n12 ; we iterate between the solutions of the electron energy equation ( analogous to equations [ eq : ions][eq : qdiss ] ; note that here we include the direct electron heating , while n12 assumes @xmath127 ) and the gr mc comptonization simulations until we find mutually consistent solutions . in fig .
[ fig:6 ] we show the resulting spectra . fig .
[ fig:4 ] shows the radial profiles of the radiative cooling of electrons ( strongly dominated by comptonization ) , @xmath128 , for @xmath55 and compares them with the @xmath0-ray emissivity , @xmath44 , for model t. note that @xmath44 is much steeper than @xmath128 so the gr effects are more important for the @xmath0-ray than for the x - ray emission . as we can see in fig .
[ fig:4 ] and also in the corresponding spectra in fig .
[ fig:6]a , for @xmath129 the black hole spin negligibly affects the comptonized radiation ; this property results from a large magnitude of the compression work , which is roughly independent of @xmath8 and dominates the heating of electrons for small values of @xmath10 ( cf .
n12 ) . for @xmath130
the direct heating contributes significantly to the heating of electrons and for @xmath131 it dominates over other heating processes at @xmath132 for all values of @xmath8 .
then , the dependence of @xmath61 on @xmath8 results in a noticeable dependence of the comptonized radiation on @xmath8 for @xmath130 ( see also xie & yuan 2012 for a recent study of the dependence of x - ray luminosity on @xmath10 ) . the radiative efficiency increases from @xmath133 for all values of @xmath8 at @xmath55 to @xmath134 for @xmath26 , @xmath135 for @xmath108 and @xmath136 for @xmath59 at @xmath131 . despite considering only one value of accretion rate , our solutions span a range of bolometric luminosities , from @xmath137 ( for @xmath55 ) to @xmath138 ( for @xmath131 and @xmath139 ) .
the corresponding x - ray spectral slopes harden from @xmath140 to @xmath141 with the increase of @xmath4 .
note that these values correspond to the range of parameters close to the turning point in the @xmath4@xmath142 correlation observed in agns ( e.g. gu & cao 2009 ) .
then , we likely consider here the range of the largest luminosities of the flows in which synchrotron emission is the dominant source of seed photons for comptonization ( see discussion and references in n12 ) .
having found the self - consistent solutions , described above , we apply our mc model to tabulate the distribution of all photons propagating in the central region ( up to @xmath143 ) , @xmath144 ( in photons @xmath145
ev@xmath146 sr@xmath146 ) , where @xmath147 and @xmath148 are the boyer - lindquist coordinates , @xmath149 is the photon energy in the lnr frame and @xmath150 is the solid angle element in the lnr frame . to compute the optical depth to pair creation , @xmath151 , we closely follow the method for determining an optical depth to compton scattering in the kerr metric , see niedwiecki ( 2005 ) and niedwiecki & zdziarski ( 2006 ) , however , here we calculate the probability of pair creation in the lnr frame whereas for the compton effect an additional boost to the flow rest frame is applied .
while compton scattering is most conveniently described in the plasma rest frame , pair production can be simply modelled in the lnr frame and , thus , the transformation to the flow rest frame is not necessary here .
we solve equations of the photon motion in the kerr metric and we determine the increase of the optical depth along the photon trajectory from @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the length element in the lnr frame , @xmath154 is the pair production cross section ( e.g. , gould & schreder 1967 ) , @xmath155 is the energy of the @xmath0-ray photon in the lnr frame and @xmath156 is the angle between the interacting photons in the lnr frame .
-ray emissivity , @xmath44 ( for model t ) , and the comptonization rate @xmath128 , for @xmath59 ( dashed , red ) , 0.95 ( solid , black ) and 0 ( dotted , blue ) in models with @xmath55 .
@xmath157 denotes the vertically integrated rates .
, width=226 ] gr affects the @xmath13 opacity through ( 1 ) bending the trajectories of both the @xmath0-ray photon and target photons and ( 2 ) changing energies of both the @xmath0-ray photon and target photons . as an example , the neglect of the gravitational shift of the @xmath0-ray photon energy , by using @xmath158 ( where @xmath159 is the energy at infinity ) instead of @xmath154 in equation ( [ eq : sgg ] ) , underestimates @xmath151 by a factor of @xmath1603 for photons emitted from the innermost region . in fig .
[ fig:5 ] we show values of the total optical depth , @xmath161 , integrated along the outward radial direction in the equatorial plane from the emission point at the radial coordinate @xmath30 to the outer boundary at @xmath162 . as we can see , the @xmath13 opacity is a strong function of both the @xmath0-ray energy and the location in the flow .
the dotted lines in fig .
[ fig:7 ] show how the @xmath13 absorption attenuates @xmath0-rays observed from a given @xmath30 .
-ray photons with @xmath163 mev , 1 gev and 10 gev from bottom to top , as a function of the radial distance of their point of emission for @xmath108 and @xmath55 are shown by the solid ( black ) lines .
the dotted ( blue ) and dashed ( red ) lines are for @xmath108 and 0 in models @xmath131 ; in these models @xmath151 is shown only for @xmath164 gev for clarity .
, width=226 ] it is apparent that around @xmath165 flows undergo transition from being fully transparent to mostly opaque to @xmath0-rays . in our models with the eddington ratio @xmath166 , the flow is fully transparent to photons with energies @xmath167 mev ; at higher energies the absorption leads to moderate attenuation , with the increase of the photon index at @xmath121 gev by @xmath168 , see fig .
[ fig:8 ] .
the size of the @xmath0-ray photosphere ( the surface of @xmath169 ) increases with increasing @xmath4 and for @xmath170 the gev photons can not escape from @xmath45 . at such @xmath4 ,
our model h gives spectra with a clear cut - off around 1 gev ( see the solid line in fig .
[ fig:6]b ) which could be measured by _ fermi_. in other cases absorption leads to a smooth softening of the spectra . in terms of the 2 - 10
kev luminosity , @xmath171 , flows with @xmath172 should be fully transparent to mev / gev photons
. flows with @xmath173 can emit significant amounts of unabsorbed @xmath0-rays only if their @xmath0-ray emissivities are strong at large @xmath30 .
e.g. in our model n , the luminosity of the flow at @xmath174 , which region would be outside the photosphere of 1 gev photons even at much larger @xmath175 , is @xmath176 erg / s .
then , the @xmath0-ray luminosity exceeding @xmath177 erg / s can be expected at @xmath178 if the @xmath0-ray emitting flow extends out to several tens of @xmath106 , which property is , however , unclear as objects with high luminosities often show signs of a cold disc extending to rather small radii ( so the transition between the hot and cold flow may occur within the @xmath0-ray photosphere ) .
note that for such a scenario , with @xmath0-ray emission from a hot flow at large @xmath4 , we expect a small luminosity ratio of @xmath179 regardless of the value of @xmath8 .
in fig . [ fig:9 ] we summarize our results regarding the relation between the x - ray and @xmath0-ray luminosities .
the range of expected @xmath98 is constrained from below by values indicated in fig .
[ fig:9]a for model t , and from above by values in fig .
[ fig:9]b for model n. as we can see , the models give the luminosity ratios @xmath180 between @xmath181 and 0.2 . in model t ,
@xmath182 for @xmath26 and @xmath59 differ by a factor of several ; the unabsorbed luminosities differ by over an order of magnitude but for @xmath4 close to @xmath183 the @xmath13 absorption reduces the difference to a factor of @xmath184 . in model
n , @xmath182 for @xmath26 and @xmath59 differ by only a factor of @xmath102 ; as noted before , the difference is reduced here due to contribution from large @xmath30 .
model n for @xmath26 gives similar @xmath182 as model t with large @xmath8 ; larger density and average energy for large @xmath8 is approximately compensated by a larger fraction of protons above the pion production threshold for model n. note , however , that - despite similar luminosities - the spectra for these two regimes differ significantly , see fig .
[ fig:3 ] . in model h , @xmath182 has a similar dependence on @xmath8 as in model t , with a large difference between small and high values of @xmath8 .
we conclude that it is the radial distribution of @xmath0-ray emissivity , rather than the local proton distribution function , which reduces the dependence on @xmath8 .
this is even more hindering for attempts of assessing the spin value basing on the @xmath0-ray luminosity level .
the proton energy distribution function is reflected in the produced spectral shape and , therefore , it could be constrained observationally and taken into account in this kind of analysis .
on the other hand , one can not expect to derive information on the radial emissivity profile from observations , so an investigation of black hole spin values using the @xmath0-ray luminosity should be subject to significant uncertainty . in models with a dominant contribution from the central @xmath63 , intrinsic @xmath0-ray luminosities of flows around submaximally ( @xmath108 ) and maximally ( @xmath59 ) rotating black holes differ by a factor of @xmath102 .
for the latter , the flow extends to smaller radii and hence a larger proton temperature and density are achieved , see fig .
[ fig:1 ] . however , a strong contribution from @xmath110 as well as @xmath13 absorption make the difference between the observed luminosities insignificant .
regarding the dependence on @xmath10 , we notice a somewhat surprising property of models with @xmath131 , which predict a larger @xmath0-ray luminosity than models with smaller @xmath10 ( the effect is more pronounced for larger values of @xmath8 ) .
the physical reason is that for @xmath131 , the slight decrease of proton temperature is outweighed by the increase of density ( through the decrease of both the radial velocity and the scale height with decreasing temperature ) , cf .
manmoto ( 2000 ) , which leads to the increase of @xmath185 . at smaller values of @xmath10 ,
the intrinsic @xmath122 depends negligibly on @xmath10 , in agreement with the results of om03 for @xmath26 and @xmath186 in their nonthermal model .
the scaling of density with @xmath75 and @xmath14 in our global gr solutions only weakly differs from that of self - similar adaf model , i.e. @xmath187 ( e.g. mahadevan 1997 ) .
then , the intrinsic @xmath0-ray luminosity can be estimated as @xmath188 erg / s , where @xmath189 is the unabsorbed luminosity shown by the open symbols in fig .
[ fig:9](ab ) .
this gives also the observed luminosity at @xmath190 , when the absorption effects are unimportant .
obviously , the above scaling with @xmath75 is not relevant for @xmath191 , for which the increase of @xmath75 results in the decrease of the observed @xmath98 due to @xmath13 absorption . on the other hand
, the linear scaling of the @xmath0-ray luminosity with @xmath14 holds even when the @xmath13 absorption is important .
the spectral distribution of comptonized radiation changes slightly with the black hole mass ( due to the change of the synchrotron emission , which affects the position of comptonization bumps , see fig 5a ) , however , the effect is insignificant for the @xmath13 opacity and we have checked that it negligibly affects the observed @xmath0-ray spectra .
the form of the dissipation rate and the proton distribution function are two major uncertainties for predicting the @xmath0-luminosity .
we briefly discuss here the related effects in accretion flows .
the form of the viscous dissipation rate given by equation ( [ eq : ions ] ) results from the usual assumption that the viscous stress is proportional to the total pressure , with the proportionality coefficient @xmath76 .
we use this form of the viscous stress for computational simplicity , however , as we discuss in n12 , this may be an oversimplified approach ( although it has support in mhd simulations , see below ) . below
we briefly compare the dissipation rate in our models with that predicted by the classical novikov & thorne ( 1973 ) model .
we define @xmath61 integrated over the whole body of the flow as the total dissipation rate , @xmath192 , in our solutions and compare it to the dissipation rate in a keplerian disc for the corresponding value of @xmath8 , @xmath193 , given by the novikov & thorne model .
obviously , @xmath192 does not need to match @xmath193 closely .
the latter value is calculated under the assumption that the shear stress vanishes at the radius of the innermost stable circular orbit ( isco ) , which condition is not applicable to geometrically thick adafs and its release should lead to stronger dissipation . on the other hand ,
adafs are sub - keplerian which property decreases the dissipation rate .
our @xmath192 does not differ significantly from @xmath193 , however , the efficiency of dissipation in our model comparatively increases with increasing @xmath8 .
specifically , @xmath194 for @xmath26 , @xmath195 for @xmath108 and @xmath196 for @xmath59 . note that in an adaf with a large value of @xmath8 most of the dissipation occurs very deep in the potential , where relativistic effects strongly reduce the energy escaping to infinity , whereas in a keplerian disc the dissipation is less centrally concentrated and its radiation is subject to less severe reduction .
for example , the gravitational redshift alone ( neglecting , e.g. , the photon capture under the event horizon ) would give similar luminosities received by distant observers ( @xmath197 ) both in our adaf and in novikov & thorne models with @xmath59 , if all of the dissipated energy were converted into radiation .
obviously , in optically thin adafs only a small part of the dissipated energy is radiated away and most of it is accreted by the black hole , so the radiative efficiency is much smaller than 0.3 . as we mentioned in section
[ sec : flow ] , the model formally allows for two solutions and the above values of @xmath192 correspond to the standard solution , considered in previous sections .
the superhot solution has an extreme dissipation , with @xmath198@xmath199 .
this is not necessarily an unphysical property ( note that @xmath192 is defined in the rest frame of the flow ) , as the observed luminosity of such flows does not exceed the accretion rate of the rest mass energy .
nevertheless , the magnitude of @xmath61 suggests that the underlying assumption of @xmath200 breaks down at very large @xmath201 .
the issue of the proper description of the @xmath61 term could be partially resolved by comparing analytic models such as our , aiming at a precise calculation of the produced radiation , with mhd simulations .
the latter currently neglect radiative cooling , or use very approximate descriptions for it , in turn , they provide more accurate accounts of the dissipation physics .
such mhd simulations support some properties of our model , e.g. the @xmath200 prescription of viscous heating ( ohsuga et al .
furthermore , the gr mhd simulations have shown that flows cross the isco without any evidence that the shear stress goes to zero , which leads to the increase of the radiative efficiency , and the deviations from novikov & thorne model increase with increasing @xmath202 ratio ( e.g. noble , krolik & hawley 2009 , penna et al .
we could not , however , quantitatively compare our models with such simulations , as the published results have a much smaller aspect ratio than our solutions ( @xmath203 ) .
lastly , we remark that gammie & popham ( 1998 ) and popham & gammie ( 1998 ) present a model similar to ours but with a more elaborate description of the shear stress ( in turn , they neglect radiative processes ) .
we note that their results indicate a similar in magnitude stabilizing effect of the rotation of black hole .
as pointed out by mahadevan & quataert ( 1998 ) , coulomb collisions are too inefficient to thermalize protons in optically thin flows and the proton distribution function is determined by the viscous heating mechanism , which is poorly understood
. our solutions , with @xmath23 and @xmath46 , give the accretion time - scale , @xmath204 , much shorter than the proton relaxation time - scale , @xmath205 ; e.g. at @xmath206 , @xmath207 hours and @xmath208 hours .
clearly , the protons can not redistribute their energy through coulomb collisions . in solar flares ,
the best observationally studied example of particle acceleration / heating in a magnetised plasma , a significant fraction of the released energy is carried by non - thermal , high energy particles ( e.g. aschwanden 2002 ) , which strongly motivates for considering the nonthermal distribution of protons , as originally proposed in m97 . applying the generic description of particle acceleration , see e.g. section 3 in zdziarski , malzac & bednarek ( 2009 ) , we check whether the conditions in adafs allow for proton acceleration to ultrarelativistic energies , as assumed in our computations for the power - law distributions .
the magnetic field strength in our adaf solutions is @xmath209 g , 100 g and 1000 g at @xmath210 , 10 and 2 , respectively .
assuming an acceleration rate @xmath211 , where @xmath212 is the elementary charge and @xmath213 is the acceleration efficiency ( @xmath214 ) , we find that the maximum lorentz factor limited by the synchrotron energy loss is @xmath215 , depending on @xmath30 .
another condition , of the larmor radius being smaller than the acceleration site size , @xmath216 , gives @xmath217 at @xmath218 , and larger values of @xmath219 at smaller @xmath30 , even if we safely assume @xmath220 ( @xmath221 cm ) .
we conclude that the central region of a hot accretion flow may be a site of the acceleration of protons to energies which easily allow hadronic emission of photons even in the tev range .
this conclusion remains valid for the whole relevant range of accretion rates and masses of supermassive black holes , as the strength of the magnetic field scales as @xmath222 .
considering processes which could compete with proton - proton interactions , we note that proton - photon interactions are much less efficient in the central region of the flow .
namely , the number density of @xmath0-ray photons , which can effectively interact with protons in photomeson production , is by a factor of @xmath223 smaller than the number density of protons within the innermost few @xmath106 ; the number density of hard x - ray photons , which can interact with protons in photopair production , is similar to @xmath64 .
the cross - section for both channels of proton - photon interactions is by over two orders of magnitude smaller than the cross - section for proton - proton interaction , making the photo - hadronic production of secondary particles negligible .
we briefly compare here predictions of our model with @xmath0-ray observations of objects which may be powered by adafs .
we note , however , that for a more detailed comparison additional physical processes , related to charged pion production ( cf .
mahadevan 1999 ) , should be taken into account .
in particular , relativistic electrons produced by the pion decay should be important in modelling the emission in the mev range .
we also tentatively discuss the origin in the accretion flow of the very high energy radiation detected from m87 and sgr a@xmath224 , for the latter under assumption that the contributions from two separate sources dominate above 100 gev ( sgr a@xmath224 ) and at lower energies ( diffuse emission ) in the radiation observed from the galactic center region .
however , we note that the opacity at very high energies may be affected by the nonthermal synchrotron emission of the relativistic electrons .
the work on the model implementing the effects of charged pions is currently in progress .
the misaligned agns detected by the _
fermi_-lat include seven fr i radio galaxies and four fr iis ( abdo et al .
the low - power fr i galaxies are supposed to be powered by radiatively inefficient accretion flows ( e.g. balmaverde , baldi & capetti 2008 ) and , thus , are more relevant for application of our results .
interestingly , wu , cao & wang ( 2011 ) assess that supermassive black holes in fr is rotate rapidly , with @xmath225 .
the x - ray emission of more luminous fr is is supposed to come from an accretion flow ( e.g. wu , yuan & cao 2007 ) , but their @xmath0-ray emission tends to be interpreted in terms of jet emission ( e.g. abdo et al .
2009 , 2010ab ) .
fr is are supposed to be the parent population of bl lac objects , however , the lorentz factors required by a jet model are much lower than typical values found in models of bl lac objects ( see , e.g. , abdo et al
. 2010b ) .
therefore , the radiation observed in fr is and bl lacs must have a different origin , which adds some complexity to the jet model for fr is .
at least two fr i galaxies reported in abdo et al .
( 2010b ) , m87 and centaurus a , are detected because of their proximity rather than a small inclination angle of their jets and , then , they are interesting targets for searching for the @xmath0-ray emission from accretion flows . in niedwiecki
et al . ( 2012a ) we roughly compared preliminary results of our model with the x/@xmath0-ray observational data of centaurus a from _ integral _ and _ fermi_-lat .
we found that the adaf model , which matches the x - ray emission in this object , predicts the @xmath0-ray emission significantly weaker than measured by _ fermi _ if the value of the spin parameter @xmath8 is small .
we should emend , however , that this conclusion is valid only for models assuming a significant @xmath0-ray emission only from the central @xmath226 , such as our models t and h. regardless of the values of @xmath8 and @xmath10 , our model n with @xmath103 predicts the absorbed @xmath98 approximately consistent with @xmath227 erg / s measured in cen a by _ fermi _ ( abdo et al .
also regardless of the value of @xmath8 , our models with @xmath55 predict the 2 - 10 kev flux as well as the x - ray spectral index consistent with that observed in cen a ; for @xmath228 the model overpredicts the flux and hardness of the x - ray radiation . in the above we assumed the black hole mass of @xmath229 ( e.g. marconi et al .
2001 ) , which is also within the range allowed by the recent measurement of gnerucci et al .
( 2011 ) .
the central core of the accretion system in m87 has been considered as the @xmath0-ray emitting region e.g. by neronov & aharonian ( 2007 ) in their model with particle acceleration in the black hole magnetosphere .
the accretion rate assessed from the high - resolution observations of the nucleus of m87 by _ chandra _ , and used to model the multiwavelength spectrum of the nucleus by emission from an adaf , by di matteo et al .
( 2003 ; note that their definition of @xmath75 differs from ours by a factor of 10 ) , @xmath230/year , corresponds to @xmath231 for a black hole with @xmath232 . at
such @xmath75 the central region should be transparent to @xmath0-ray photons .
then , we compare the unabsorbed luminosities from our nonthermal models with @xmath233 ( approximately consistent with the slope of the _ fermi _ data above 200 mev ; abdo et al . 2009 ) and @xmath232 with the @xmath0-ray measurements of m87 .
we find that the luminosity derived in the 0.2 - 10 gev range by _ fermi _ ( abdo et al .
2009 ) , and above 100 gev by ground - based telescopes ( e.g. aleksi et al .
2012 ) in the low state of m87 , can be reproduced by our model with @xmath139 and @xmath234/year ( for @xmath235 ) . the required accretion rate , larger by 40 per cent than the face value of the estimate in di matteo et al .
( 2003 ) , is allowed by the precision of the estimation of the accretion rate using bondi accretion theory .
we conclude that hadronic processes in adaf can contribute significantly to the @xmath0-ray emission observed in m87 in the low state , or even explain these observations entirely .
however , such a model requires that all the available material forms the innermost flow , i.e. it does not allow a strong reduction the accretion rate in the central region by outflows ( assumed in models of sgr a@xmath224 , see below ) .
the value of @xmath75 in the central region is the major issue for applications of adaf models to the supermassive black hole in the galactic center .
the bondi accretion rate corresponds to @xmath236 for @xmath237 and early models used such @xmath75 to explain the broad - band spectra of sgr a@xmath224 ( e.g. narayan et al .
the measurement of the millimetre / submillimetre polarization of sgr a@xmath224 is often assumed to limit the accretion rate to @xmath238 ( e.g. marrone et al .
2007 ) , but counterarguments are presented , e.g. , by mocibrodzka , das & czerny ( 2006 ) and ballantyne , zel & psaltis ( 2007 ) . an updated adaf model to sgr a@xmath224 , with @xmath239 and strong electron heating , is presented in yuan , quataert & narayan ( 2003 ) .
an alternative to adaf model , proposed by mocibrodzka et al .
( 2006 ) and recently applied by okuda & molteni ( 2012 ) , with the low angular momentum flow , assumes @xmath240 .
the low angular momentum flow has a similar density in the innermost region as an adaf with the same @xmath75 , but much smaller proton temperature @xmath241 k. then , the magnitude of hadronic processes could be used to distinguish the two classes of models ; however , the low @xmath242 may be an artificial effect resulting from the neglect of viscosity in the former ( low angular momentum ) class .
the _ cgro_/egret source , 3eg j1746 - 2851 , was initially considered as a possible @xmath0-ray counterpart of sgr a@xmath224 ; narayan et al .
( 1998 ) and om03 found that their adaf models underpredicted the @xmath0-ray luminosity implied by the egret measurement
. however , improved analyses ( e.g. pohl 2005 ) subsequently indicated that 3eg j1746 - 2851 is displaced from the exact galactic center and excluded sgr a@xmath224 , as well as the tev source observed with hess which may be directly related with sgr a@xmath224 , as its possible counterparts .
recently , chernyakova et al . ( 2011 ) analysed the _
fermi_-lat observations of the galactic center and combined them with the hess observational data of the point - like source ( aharonian et al .
the spectrum of the source seen in the mev / gev band by _ fermi _ is consistent with a @xmath9-decay spectrum .
the hess data indicate flattening of the spectrum above 100 gev , suggesting that at the highest energies a different spectral component dominates , with rather hard spectrum , @xmath243 . in the @xmath244 plot
, the normalization of the hess source is an order of magnitude larger than the quiescent x - ray emission of sgr a@xmath224 . to explain these observations , chernyakova et al .
( 2011 ) discuss a model , following previous works ( e.g. atoyan & dermer 2004 ) , with protons accelerated in the accretion flow and then diffusing outwards to interact with dense gas at distances of @xmath245 pc .
the emission at energies below 100 gev may be explained by interactions of protons injected into the interstellar medium during a strong flare of sgr a@xmath224 that occurred 300 years ago , as protons generating photons with such energies are still diffusively trapped in the @xmath0-ray production region . on the other hand ,
most of the higher energy protons have already escaped and hence an additional , persistent injection of high - energy protons has to be assumed to account for the hess observations , with the required rate of @xmath246 erg / s implying a very high efficiency of the conversion of the accreting rest mass energy into the proton energy .
we remark that alternatively the spectral component above 100 gev can be explained by proton - proton interactions in an accretion flow around a rapidly rotating black hole . our model with @xmath59 , @xmath233 and edge - on viewing direction
predict the flux consistent with the hess detection for @xmath247 .
the scenario with the @xmath0-ray emission produced in the accretion flow may be tested over the following years , if the fall of the gas cloud into the accretion zone of sgr a@xmath224 ( gillessen et al .
2012 ) results in the increase of the mass accretion rate .
spectral properties of the seyfert galaxy , ngc 4151 , are consistent with the model of an inner hot flow surrounded by an outer cold disc ( e.g. lubiski et al .
2010 ) , however , its rather large luminosity , @xmath248 indicates that a potential @xmath0-ray emission from innermost region would be strongly absorbed .
the constraint of @xmath249 derived for this object in ackermann et al .
( 2012 ) can still give interesting information if the spectral model constrains the parameters of the inner hot / outer cold accretion system ( in particular , the distance of transition between the two modes of accretion ) .
the constraint of @xmath250 , or even @xmath251 for some objects , found for other seyfert galaxies by ackermann et al .
( 2012 ) is not strongly constraining for the spin value , as can be seen in fig .
[ fig:9 ] ( note that @xmath252 is by a factor of a few , depending on @xmath253 , larger than @xmath171 ) , especially for large x - ray luminosities ( and hence strong @xmath13 absorption ) characterising most of objects analysed in that paper .
we have studied the @xmath0-ray emission resulting from proton - proton interactions in two - temperature adafs .
our model relies on the global solutions of the gr hydrodynamical model , same as om03 , but we improve their computations by taking into account the relativistic transfer effects as well as the @xmath13 absorption and by properly describing the global comptonization process .
we have found that the spin value is reflected in the properties of @xmath0-ray emission , but the effect is not thrilling .
the speed of the black hole rotation strongly affects the @xmath0-ray emission produced within the innermost @xmath52 .
if emission from that region dominates , the observed @xmath0-ray radiation depends on the spin parameter noticeably ; the intrinsic @xmath0-ray luminosities of flows around rapidly - rotating and non - rotating black holes differ by over a factor of @xmath1 .
however , if the @xmath0-ray emitting region extends to larger distances , the dependence is reduced . in the most extreme case with protons
efficiently accelerated to relativistic energies in the whole body of the flow , the regions within and beyond @xmath52 give comparable contributions to the total emission , reducing the difference of @xmath0-ray luminosities between high and low values of @xmath8 to only a factor of @xmath102 .
the radial emissivity profile of @xmath0-rays is very uncertain ( as the acceleration efficiency may change with radius ) , then , the level of the @xmath0-ray luminosity can not be regarded as a very sensitive probe of the spin value .
still , it may be possible to assess a slow rotation in a low luminosity object by putting an upper limit on the @xmath0-ray luminosity at the level of @xmath254 of the x - ray luminosity .
the presence of nonthermal protons may be easily assessed from the @xmath0-ray spectrum as for a purely thermal plasma the total @xmath0-ray emission would be observed only at energies lower than 1 gev .
we have considered the accretion rate of @xmath46 , for which our model gives the bolometric luminosities between @xmath255 and @xmath256 .
such @xmath75 , with the corresponding range of @xmath257 , seems to be favoured for investigation of the hadronic @xmath0-ray emission , with the related effects of the space - time metric , because the internal @xmath0-ray emission is large and its attenuation by @xmath13 absorption is weak .
flows with @xmath258 can produce observable @xmath0-ray radiation only if the emitting region extends out to a rather large distance of several tens of @xmath106 .
we have found the x - ray to @xmath0-ray luminosities ratio as a function of the black hole spin and the efficiency of the direct heating of electrons .
the @xmath180 ratios reaching @xmath259 , with the corresponding levels of the @xmath0-ray luminosities which may be probed in nearby agns at the current sensitivity of _ fermi_-lat surveys , encourage to consider contribution from an accretion flow to the @xmath0-ray emission observed in low - luminosity objects .
we point out that such a contribution should be strong at least in cen a. the @xmath0-ray luminosity decreases rapidly ( @xmath260 ) with decreasing @xmath75 .
m87 and sgr a@xmath224 are the obvious , however possibly also unique , objects for which the @xmath0-ray emission from the flow can be searched at @xmath261 . obviously , contribution from other @xmath0-ray emitting sites should be properly subtracted to establish the luminosity of an accretion flow , which may be particularly difficult in sgr a@xmath224 . the adaf model with a hard ( acceleration index @xmath262 )
nonthermal proton distribution can explain the @xmath0-ray detections of both sgr a@xmath224 ( above 100 gev ) and m87 , however , it does not allow for strong reduction of the accretion rate by outflows .
nevertheless , it seems intriguing that in both nearby , low accretion - rate objects , in which the @xmath0-ray radiation is not suppressed by @xmath13 absorption , observations reveal very high energy components , consistent with predictions of such a model . in both objects
the model requires a large black hole spin .
the luminosity ratio should decrease rather slowly ( @xmath263 , as the radiative efficiency of hot flows varies as @xmath264 at small @xmath75 ; cf .
xie & yuan 2012 ) with decreasing @xmath75 .
the presence of the @xmath0-ray signal in low - luminosity agns is often considered as the evidence for the origin of their radiation in a jet ( see , e.g. , takami 2011 ) .
we note that such a diagnostic is not valid because accretion flows may produce a similarly strong @xmath0-ray emission as jets in such objects .
we are grateful to wodek bednarek for helpful discussions and to the referee for a very careful review and comments which helped us to improve the presentation of the results .
this research has been supported in part by the polish ncn grant n n203 582240 .
fgx has been supported in part by the nsfc ( grants 11103059 , 11121062 , 11133005 , and 11203057 ) , the nbrpc ( 973 program 2009cb824800 ) , and shao key project no . | we present a model of @xmath0-ray emission through neutral pion production and decay in two - temperature accretion flows around supermassive black holes .
we refine previous studies of such a hadronic @xmath0-ray emission by taking into account ( 1 ) relativistic effects in the photon transfer and ( 2 ) absorption of @xmath0-ray photons in the radiation field of the flow .
we use a fully general relativistic description of both the radiative and hydrodynamic processes , which allows us to study the dependence on the black hole spin .
the spin value strongly affects the @xmath0-ray emissivity within @xmath1 gravitational radii .
the central regions of flows with the total luminosities @xmath2 of the eddington luminosity ( @xmath3 ) are mostly transparent to photons with energies below 10 gev , permitting investigation of the effects of space - time metric . for such @xmath4 , an observational upper limit on the @xmath0-ray ( 0.1 10 gev ) to x - ray ( 2 10 kev ) luminosity ratio of @xmath5 can rule out rapid rotation of the black hole ; on the other hand , a measurement of @xmath6 can not be regarded as the evidence of rapid rotation , as such a ratio can also result from a flat radial profile of @xmath0-ray emissivity ( which would occur for nonthermal acceleration of protons in the whole body of the flow ) . at @xmath7 , the @xmath0-ray emission from the innermost region
is strongly absorbed and the observed @xmath0-rays do not carry information on the value of @xmath8 .
we note that if the x - ray emission observed in centaurus a comes from an accretion flow , the hadronic @xmath0-ray emission from the flow should contribute significantly to the mev / gev emission observed from the core of this object , unless it contains a slowly rotating black hole and protons in the flow are thermal .
[ firstpage ] accretion , accretion discs black hole physics
gamma - rays : theory |
40004000 = 1000 # 1
40004000 = 1000 recent spectroscopic observations of @xmath5 quasars discovered by the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) have opened up new windows into the study of the high redshift intergalactic medium ( igm ) ( fan et al .
2000 , zheng et al .
2000 , schneider et al .
2001 , anderson et al .
2001 fan et al
. 2001a , becker et al .
2001 , djorgovski et al .
in particular , becker et al .
( 2001 ) observed gunn - peterson troughs ( gunn & peterson 1965 ) in the spectrum of a @xmath6 quasar , which were interpreted as suggesting that the universe was close to the reionization epoch at @xmath0 .
that the absorption increases quickly with redshift is not by itself surprising : ionization equilibrium tells us that the neutral hydrogen density is proportional to the gas density squared , which is proportional to @xmath7 at the cosmic mean . the evolution of the ionizing background and gas temperature will modify this redshift dependence , but the rapid evolution of absorption remains a robust outcome . what is interesting , as becker et al .
( 2001 ) emphasized , is that the observed mean transmission at redshift @xmath0 is lower than what one would expect based on an extrapolation of the column density distribution and its redshift evolution ( number density of clouds scaling as @xmath8 ) from lower redshifts . on the other hand ,
the popular gravitational instability theory of structure formation provides detailed predictions for how the igm should be clustered , and how this clustering evolves with redshift , which has been shown to be quite successful when compared with observations at @xmath9 ( see e.g. cen et al .
1994 , zhang et al .
1995 , reisenegger & miralda - escud 1995 , hernquist et al .
1996 , miralda - escud 1996 , muecket et al .
1996 , bi & davidsen 1997 , bond & wadsley 1997 , hui et al .
1997 , croft et al .
1998 , theuns et al .
1999 , bryan et al .
1999 , mcdonald et al .
these predictions allow us to directly infer the neutral fraction of the igm from the observed absorption ( the relation between the two depends on the nature of clustering of the igm ) , and so can further inform our interpretations of the recent @xmath0 results .
how neutral is the igm at @xmath0 , and how different is the neutral fraction compared to lower redshifts ?
these are the questions we would like to address quantitatively , making use of the gravitational instability model of the igm .
the paper is organized as follows .
first , we start with a brief description of the gravitational instability model for the igm and the simulation technique in [ method ] . in [ meantlya ] , we derive the neutral hydrogen fraction @xmath10 , and equivalently the level of ionizing flux @xmath11 , at several different redshifts leading up to @xmath0 from the observed mean lyman - alpha ( ly@xmath12 ) transmission .
this exercise using the ly@xmath12 spectrum is similar to the one carried out in mcdonald & miralda - escud ( 2001 ) , except for the addition of new high redshift data .
transmission is also similar to a number of earlier papers where the primary quantity of interest is the baryon density ( e.g. rauch et al . 1997 , weinberg et al .
1997 , choudhury et al .
2000 , hui et al .
2001 ) . here
, we fix the baryon density and study the ionizing background or the neutral fraction instead ( see [ method ] ) . ]
we then examine in [ lyman beta ] the constraints on the same quantities @xmath10 and @xmath11 from the observed mean lyman - beta ( ly@xmath13 ) transmission , ly@xmath13 being particularly useful at high ly@xmath12 optical depth , because the ly@xmath13 absorption cross - section is a factor of @xmath14 smaller than the ly@xmath12 cross - section . the goal here is to use ly@xmath13 absorption to obtain constraints on @xmath10 and @xmath11 that are as stringent as possible . in
[ lyman beta ] , we also examine the sensitivity of our conclusions to the power spectrum normalization . an intriguing question is : instead of focusing on the mean transmission , can one make use of the fact that the observed spectrum at @xmath0 contains a continuous and long stretch ( @xmath15 ) with little or no detected flux to obtain more stringent limits on the neutral fraction or @xmath11 ?
the idea is that since the igm gas density naturally fluctuates spatially , it seems a priori unlikely to have no significant upward fluctuation in transmission for many pixels in a row unless of course the neutral fraction @xmath10 is indeed quite high .
we will show in [ los constraint ] this provides constraints that are slightly weaker to those obtained using the mean transmission .
in all the simulations discussed in this paper , the ionizing background is assumed uniform spatially , just as in the majority of high redshift igm simulations .
a natural worry is that as the universe becomes more neutral at higher redshifts , the ionizing background would be more non - uniform .
one way to test this is to use several lines of sight , available at @xmath16 , and compare the observed line - of - sight scatter in mean transmission against the predicted scatter based on simulations with a uniform background .
we discuss this in
[ variance of mean t ] , estimate the level of ionizing background fluctuations , and make predictions for the scatter at @xmath0 . here
, we also introduce a technique to handle the problem of limited box - size .
readers who are not interested in details can skip to [ conclusions ] where we summarize the constraints obtained .
we also discuss in [ conclusions ] the issue of continuum placement , and how the associated uncertainties can be estimated . while the work described in this paper was being carried out , several papers appeared which investigate related issues ( barkana 2001 , razoumov et al .
2001 , cen & mcdonald 2001 , gnedin 2001 , fan et al .
where there is overlap , our results are in broad agreement with these papers .
we present a comparision with other authors at the end of [ lyman beta ] .
our approach here is most similar to that of cen & mcdonald ( 2001 ) .
in addition to obtaining constraints on the ionizing background from the ly@xmath12 and ly@xmath13 transmission as was considered by cen & mcdonald , we consider the possible constraint from the gunn - peterson trough itself , examine the dependence on power spectrum normalization , and develop a method to predict the scatter in mean transmission by relating it to the power spectrum , which might be of wider interest .
we also place a slightly stronger emphasis on the neutral fraction , which is more robustly determined compared to the ionizing background or photoionization rate .
the ly@xmath12 optical depth is related to the igm density , assuming ionization equilibrium , via @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the gas overdensity ( @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the gas density and @xmath21 its mean ) , @xmath22 is the equation of state index for the igm , where @xmath23 is the gas temperature and @xmath24 is its value at the cosmic mean density ( see hui & gnedin 1997 ) .
we caution that close to reionization , these quantities may not be a function of @xmath18 alone .
the igm may be heated inhomogenously , causing spatial fluctuations in @xmath24 and @xmath22 . ] , and @xmath25 is given by ( see e.g. hui et al . 2001 and references therein ) : where @xmath27 ( @xmath28 is the total density of neutral and ionized hydrogen , and @xmath29 is the neutral hydrogen density ) is the neutral hydrogen fraction at mean density ( @xmath30 ) . is given by @xmath10 times @xmath31 . throughout this paper ,
whenever we quote values for @xmath10 , we refer to the neutral hydrogen fraction at the cosmic mean density @xmath30 . ] here @xmath32 is the hubble parameter at redshift @xmath33 , @xmath34 is the hubble parameter today , @xmath35 km / s / mpc , @xmath36 is the baryon density in units of the critical density .
the value of @xmath37 for @xmath38 above corresponds to that appropriate for a cosmology with @xmath39 and @xmath40 at @xmath41 , where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are the matter and vacuum densities in units of the critical density today .
the neutral fraction @xmath10 is related to the ionizing background by and @xmath10 will be changed slightly : the right hand side of eq ( [ xhi ] ) will be multiplied by @xmath44 . ]
@xmath45 \left[2.55 \times 10^{-2 } \over j_{\rm hi}\right ] \left[{t_0
\over 2 \times 10 ^ 4 { \ , \rm k}}\right]^{-0.7 } \left[{1+z \over 7}\right]^3\ ] ] where the dimensionless quantity @xmath11 is related to the photoionization rate @xmath46 by @xmath47 the quantity @xmath11 provides a convenient way of describing the normalization of the ionizing background , without specifying the exact spectrum , in a way that is directly related to the physically relevant @xmath46 ( e.g. miralda - escud et al .
it is related to the specific intensity at @xmath48 @xmath49 by @xmath50 $ ] , where @xmath13 is the slope of the specific intensity just blueward of @xmath48 ( @xmath51 where @xmath52 is frequency ) , and @xmath49 is measured in the customary units of @xmath53 ( for non - power law @xmath54 , eq .
[ [ gamma ] ] provides the exact definition for @xmath11 ; see e.g. hui et al .
2001 ) .
two more ingredients should be mentioned to complete the specification of our model for the ly@xmath12 absorption ( see e.g. hui et al .
1997 for details ) .
first , the optical depth as a function of velocity is computed by taking the right hand side of eq .
( [ taualpha ] ) in velocity space ( i.e. taking into account peculiar velocities ) and smoothing it with a thermal broadening window .
second , the gas density and velocity fields are predicted by some cold dark matter ( cdm ) cosmological model using numerical simulations . throughout this paper , we assume @xmath55 , as supported by recent cosmic microwave background measurements ( netterfield et al .
2001 , pryke et al . 2001 ) and the nucleosynthesis constraint from primordial deuterium abundance ( burles et al .
we also assume throughout @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 .
variations of these parameters within the current bounds do not contribute significantly to the uncertainties of the constraints obtained in this paper ( see hui et al .
2001 ) .
the temperature @xmath24 and equation of state index @xmath22 at the redshifts of interest in this paper are somewhat uncertain .
there are no direct measurements of the thermal state of the igm at our redshifts of interest , @xmath59 .
measurements at @xmath60 yield values consistent with @xmath61 k and @xmath62 ( mcdonald et al .
2000b , ricotti et al .
2000 , zaldarriaga et al . 2001 .
schaye et al . 2000
, however , measure a slightly lower temperature ) . given that the temperature right after reionization is expected to be about @xmath63 k with @xmath62 ( with some dependence on the hardness of the ionizing spectrum ; see e.g. hui & gnedin 1997 ) , which is not too different from the measurements at @xmath60 , we will assume throughout this paper , when making use of eq .
( [ xhi ] ) to infer @xmath11 , that @xmath61 k and @xmath62 .
note that while the theoretically allowed range for @xmath22 is from @xmath64 to @xmath65 ( hui & gnedin 1997 ) , what matters for our purpose is @xmath66 ( eq . [ [ taualpha ] ] ) , which only ranges from @xmath67 to @xmath68 , and does not significantly affect our results .
it is also important to emphasize that _ the inference of @xmath10 from observations , unlike the case for @xmath11 , is not subject directly to uncertainties in the temperature @xmath24_. this is because observations constrain @xmath25 from which we can obtain @xmath10 without knowing @xmath24 ( see eq . [ [ aalphanew ] ] ) . )
has to be smoothed with a thermal broadening window whose width depends on @xmath24 .
we find that in practice , the exact width of the thermal broadening kernel does not affect very much quantities such as the mean transmission , which is what we will be interested in .
second , @xmath24 also affects the gas dynamics via the pressure term in the equation of motion . as we will discuss below
, the effect of varying @xmath24 also appears to be small in this regard . ] to generate realizations of the density and velocity fields for a given cosmology , we run hydro - particle - mesh ( hpm ) simulations ( gnedin & hui 1998 ) .
the hpm algorithm is essentially a particle - mesh code , modified to incorporate a force term due to gas pressure in the equation of motion .
miralda - escud ( 2001 ) and linearly interpolate between @xmath69 k and @xmath70 at @xmath71 and @xmath72 k and @xmath62 at the redshift of reionization @xmath73 .
we found that assuming @xmath74 versus @xmath75 results in negligible difference in our results , in particular concerning the mean decrement and the probability distribution of transmission .
all results in this paper are quoted from the @xmath74 hpm simulations . note that in inferring @xmath10 and @xmath11 from eq .
( [ aalphanew ] ) and ( [ xhi ] ) , we always use @xmath76 k and @xmath62 for simplicity , as mentioned before . ] for the initial power spectrum , we use a cold dark matter ( cdm ) type transfer function , as parameterized by ma ( 1996 ) , which is very similar to the commonly used bardeen et al .
( 1986 ) transfer function . for the primordial spectral slope ,
we adopt @xmath77 ( croft et al . 2000 , mcdonald et al .
for the linear power spectrum normalization , we employ the range suggested by measurements from the ly@xmath12 forest of croft et al .
( 2000 ) : @xmath78 at @xmath79 at a velocity scale of @xmath80 .
we , however , caution that the error - bar given is somewhat dependent on the assumed error of the mean transmission measurements , which is sensitive to the accuracy of the continuum - fitting procedure ( see e.g. zaldarriaga et al .
2001 for a slightly different assessment of the error - bar ) .
the power spectrum in this model has a similar shape to that of favored cosmological models , but slightly lower amplitude ( croft et al .
2000 ) . in [ lyman beta ] we demonstrate that our main conclusion , that the neutral fraction increases dramatically near @xmath0 , is insensitive to our assumptions about the amplitude of the power spectrum . in practice , we examine models with different normalizations by running a simulation with outputs at several different redshifts : each redshift then corresponds to a different power spectrum normalization , and linear interpolation is performed to reach any desired normalization . here .
quantities such as the mean transmission which we are interested in here are generally sensitive to power on only a small range of scales .
varying @xmath81 is therefore largely degenerate with varying @xmath82 . ]
our simulations have a box size of @xmath83 mpc / h , with a @xmath84 grid .
mcdonald & miralda - escude ( 2001 ) found this box size and resolution to be adequate for igm studies up to @xmath85 .
we have verified that the same is true up to @xmath86 , in the sense that the transmission probability distribution has converged for our choice of simulation size and resolution .
finally , we should say a few words about simulations of the ly@xmath13 region . in regions of the quasar spectrum that are between @xmath87 and @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the redshift of the quasar
, two kinds of absorption can exist : one is ly@xmath13 due to material at redshift @xmath90 , the other is ly@xmath12 due to material at redshift @xmath91 .
in other words , in such a region , the observed optical depth would be given by @xmath92 where @xmath93 and @xmath94 arises at different redshifts .
the ly@xmath12 optical depth can be computed as before .
the ly@xmath13 optical depth @xmath93 can be computed using eq .
( [ taualpha ] ) , except that @xmath25 is replaced by @xmath95 : @xmath96 the factor of @xmath97 reflects the fact that the ly@xmath13 transition has a cross - section that is @xmath97 times smaller than ly@xmath12 . using eq .
( [ taualpha ] ) and ( [ aalphanew ] ) , we compute the @xmath10 , which also fixes @xmath11 ( eq . [ [ xhi ] ] ) , necessary to match the observed ly@xmath12 mean transmission @xmath98 at @xmath99 ( see table 1 for a summary of the measurements ) . the results of our calculation are presented in fig .
[ meantalpha ] .
this plot also contains a point at @xmath100 which is the result of matching the mean transmission in the ly@xmath13 forest , as we describe in [ lyman beta ] .
also shown in the figure is a dotted line which shows @xmath101 , which appears to be a good fit to the data from @xmath102 to @xmath103 . from eq .
( [ xhi ] ) , one can see that such a trend for the neutral fraction is equivalent to assuming constant @xmath11 ( or more accurately , constant @xmath104 ; see eq .
[ [ xhi ] ] ) .
as one can see , ignoring for now the ly@xmath13 point , the neutral fraction does appear to have a modest jump around @xmath0 : it increases by a factor of @xmath105 from @xmath103 to @xmath100 , while it changes at most by @xmath106 from @xmath107 to @xmath103 . a similar trend ( but opposite in sign ) can be seen in the ionizing flux @xmath11 .
the 1 @xmath108 error - bar here takes into account the measurement error in mean transmission , and the range of power spectrum normalization stated in
[ method ] . as we have explained in [ method ] , while @xmath10 is not sensitive to the assumed temperature of the igm ( @xmath24 ) , our constraints on @xmath11 are directly influenced by it . as emphasized before , we assume @xmath61 k. in other words , our constraints on @xmath11 are really constraints on the quantity @xmath109 ( see eq . [ [ xhi ] ] ) .
it is therefore straightforward to rescale our constraints on @xmath11 if the temperature were a little bit different .
[ [ aalphanew ] ] ) is small ; see discussion in
[ method ] . ]
it is an interesting question to ask whether the apparent jump in the ionizing flux can instead be attributed to a jump in the temperature . in general
, the temperature is expected to evolve slowly with redshift after reionization ( hui & gnedin 1997 ) . regarding the measurement error
, we should also emphasize that the becker et al.s 2 @xmath108 error actually includes the possibility of having zero transmission at @xmath110 .
this means that at 2 @xmath108 , we would only have a lower limit on @xmath10 , or an upper limit on @xmath11 , for the highest redshift point in fig .
[ meantalpha ] , allowing the possibility that the igm is neutral at @xmath0 , @xmath111 . in this section
we consider the constraints placed by becker et al.s measurement of the mean transmission in the ly@xmath13 region .
absorption in the ly@xmath13 region has two components : @xmath112 , where the ly@xmath12 optical @xmath94 and the ly@xmath13 optical depth @xmath93 originate at different redshifts .
ly@xmath13 absorption due to material at @xmath86 coincides in wavelength with ly@xmath12 absorption due to material at @xmath113 . because the points of origin are so widely separated ,
they can be effectively treated as statistically independent i.e. @xmath114 .
becker et al . measured @xmath115 at @xmath0 by dividing the net mean transmission @xmath116 in the ly@xmath13 region by the mean transmission in ly@xmath12 at @xmath85 .
they obtained @xmath117 .
clearly , this measurement is consistent with a completely neutral igm .
however , the interesting question is : what kind of lower limit does it set on the neutral fraction , and does it improve upon the lower limit from the mean ly@xmath12 absorption ?
we carry out a calculation that is analogous to what is described in
[ meantlya ] , except for the key difference that in computing @xmath93 from the simulated density and velocity fields , we employ @xmath95 which is a factor of @xmath97 smaller than @xmath25 ( see eq . [ [ taualpha ] ] & [ [ abeta ] ] ) .
the results of our calculation are shown in fig .
[ meantalpha ] , as the highest redshift points in the plot , which have error bar arrows pointing towards a completely neutral igm and a vanishing ionizing background .
it can be seen that the ( @xmath118 ) lower limit on @xmath10 is @xmath119 .
this is a factor of @xmath120 larger than the neutral fraction required to match the upper limit on the mean transmission in ly@xmath12 for our fiducial normalization , and a slightly stronger constraint than that obtained in section [ meantlya ] , including the uncertainty in power spectrum normalization .
similarly , the upper limit on @xmath11 is @xmath121 .
the moral here is that because the ly@xmath13 absorption cross - section is a factor of @xmath97 smaller than the ly@xmath12 cross - section , ly@xmath13 offers a more sensitive probe of the neutral fraction , especially when the ly@xmath12 optical depth is high .
the neutral fraction at @xmath0 is thus a factor of @xmath122 higher than that at redshift @xmath123 , where it is @xmath124 .
this dramatic change in the neutral fraction is suggestive , probably indicating that the reionization epoch is nearby .
furthermore , this conclusion is not sensitive to our assumptions about the amplitude of the power spectrum .
although the neutral fraction at redshift @xmath100 is itself sensitive to the amplitude of the power spectrum , we find that the factor by which the neutral fraction increases from @xmath103 to @xmath100 depends only weakly on the amplitude . in fig .
[ xbreak ] we plot both the neutral fraction at @xmath100 and the jump in the neutral fraction for a range of different power spectrum normalizations .
the jump is defined as the ratio @xmath125 . here
@xmath126 is the lower limit resulting from the 1 @xmath108 error in the mean transmission in ly@xmath13 at @xmath100 and the error bars in the jump arise from the 1 @xmath108 error in the mean transmission in ly@xmath12 at @xmath103 .
as one can see in the plot , the lower limit on the neutral fraction at @xmath100 varies from @xmath127 to @xmath128 as @xmath129 varies from @xmath130 to @xmath131 .
the neutral fraction itself varies significantly with power spectrum normalization , scaling approximately as @xmath132^{1.1}$ ] , for this range of normalizations .
the jump , however , changes only slightly over a large range of normalizations .
as @xmath129 varies from @xmath130 to @xmath131 , the jump changes only from @xmath133 to @xmath134 .
our conclusion that the neutral fraction of the igm increases dramatically near @xmath0 seems robust .
one can also consider the absorption in the ly@xmath22 region , or even the higher lyman series . in practice
, the accumulated amount of absorption from ly@xmath12 as well as ly@xmath13 at different redshifts makes it harder to measure the ly@xmath22 transmission itself with good accuracy . our constraints on the neutral fraction and the intensity of the ionizing background
are consistent with those found by other authors , given our different choices of power spectrum normalization .
fan et al .
( 2001b ) found , from the mean ly@xmath13 transmission , that @xmath135 , where @xmath136 is the photoionization rate of eq ( [ gamma ] ) in units of @xmath137 .
although this constraint is somewhat stronger than the constraint implied by our fiducial model , @xmath138 , we expect the difference due to our different power spectrum normalizations .
fan et al.s ( 2001b ) constraint comes from semi - analytic arguments , shown consistent with an lcdm simulation with @xmath139 , @xmath140,@xmath141 , @xmath55 , and @xmath142 .
this model has a substantially larger normalization , @xmath143 , than our fiducial model of @xmath144 .
the difference in normalization reflects some tension between the normalization derived from the observed cluster abundance , which fan uses , and that from the lyman-@xmath12 forest which our model is based on ( croft et al .
fan et al .
( 2001b ) assume @xmath145 k in placing their constraint .
their limit , @xmath135 , includes only uncertainties in the mean transmission and not additional uncertainties from the power spectrum normalization . from figure ( [ xbreak ] )
, we infer that fan et al.s ( 2001b ) normalization implies @xmath146 in our cosmology .
rescaling this result from our assumed @xmath39 to an @xmath139 cosmology , and using eqs .
( [ xhi ] ) and ( [ gamma ] ) we predict @xmath147 , or @xmath148 , for fan et al.s ( 2001b ) model .
the constraint of fan et al .
( 2001b ) is thus consistent with our constraint given our different choice of normalization .
cen & mcdonald ( 2001 ) , using a model similar to that of fan et al .
( 2001b ) , obtained the constraint @xmath149 , using the ly@xmath13 mean transmission .
the constraint is slightly weaker than that of fan et al .
( 2001b ) and our extrapolation to their normalization , because cen & mcdonald ( 2001 ) consider a larger upper limit to the observed mean transmission , including an estimate of the uncertainty due to sky subtraction . at slightly lower redshifts , we can also compare with the results of mcdonald & miralda - escud ( 2001 ) derived from matching the mean ly@xmath12 transmission .
for example , at @xmath150 , these authors found @xmath151 to match the observed mean transmission of @xmath152 .
mcdonald & miralda - escud ( 2001 ) consider a model whose normalization we infer to be @xmath153 . to match the same mean transmission with this normalization
we infer a somewhat higher photoionization rate , @xmath154 .
part of the difference may be that the @xmath136 necessary to match a given mean transmission varies by @xmath155 between two different realizations of the density field .
the remaining difference may come from the procedure of linearly interpolating between outputs or from some modeling difference . at any rate ,
our results are roughly consistent with those of other authors given our different power spectrum normalizations . the fact that becker et al .
( 2001 ) observed a gunn - peterson trough , where a long stretch of the spectrum contains little or no flux , can conceivably be used to further tighten the constraints obtained from the previous sections . since the igm is expected to have spatial fluctuations , the probability of having many pixels in a row turning up a very small transmission must be low , unless the neutral fraction is intrinsically quite high .
the same reasoning can be applied to either the ly@xmath12 or ly@xmath13 absorption .
we will discuss our method for ly@xmath12 in detail .
the method for ly@xmath13 is a straightforward extension . for simplicity
, we will call this method , the fluctuation method .
becker et al . ( 2001 ) finds from the spectrum of sdss 1030 + 0524 , the @xmath6 quasar , the ly@xmath12 transmission is consistently below about 0.06 for a region that spans @xmath156 , between @xmath157 to @xmath158 .
the noise level per @xmath159 pixel is @xmath160 , where @xmath81 represents the photon noise fluctuation .. this is estimated from a chunk of the spectrum which is @xmath156 long , and so the dispersion per @xmath159 pixel should be approximately @xmath161 .
note that the actual dispersion varies across the spectrum , but this should suffice as a rough estimate .
this estimate also agrees with an estimate of the error by comparing fig . 1 and fig . 3 of becker et al .
] the observed transmission @xmath162 at a given pixel is @xmath163 , where @xmath164 is the true transmission .
the noise here should be dominated by poisson fluctuations of the subtracted sky background ( as well as perhaps read - out error ) .
let @xmath165 be the probability that @xmath166 consecutive pixels have observed transmission fall into the range @xmath167 ... @xmath168 . in our case , @xmath169 for the pixel size of @xmath159 .
the problem is then to find the probability @xmath170 as a function of @xmath11 , and ask what maximal @xmath11 ( or equivalently , minimal @xmath10 ) would give an acceptable probability . by choosing the `` acceptable probability '' to be within @xmath171 of the maximum likelihood
( maximum likelihood is achieved when the neutral fraction is unity ) , we obtain the 1 @xmath108 upper limit on @xmath11 or 1 @xmath108 lower limit on @xmath10 .
our simulation has a comoving box size of @xmath83 mpc / h , corresponding to @xmath172 for ly@xmath12 at @xmath0 , which falls short of the wavelength range we need for this problem , which is @xmath156 . in other words ,
the probability @xmath165 can be estimated directly from our simulation only for @xmath173 . however , the mass correlation length scale at this redshift ( @xmath174 mpc / h ) is actually a fraction of the box size , which means one can treat fluctuations on scales beyond the box size as roughly uncorrelated .
assuming so , we estimate @xmath175 from the simulation , and then take its @xmath176-th power , which would give us the probability that @xmath177 consecutive pixels have transmission below @xmath178 .
this is slightly smaller than the number @xmath179 that we need , but at least will provide us conservative constraints on @xmath10 and @xmath11 .
we have also tested our approach by using fractions of the box - size as a unit , and find that our results do not change significantly ( less than @xmath180 ) .
[ problong]a ( dotted curve ) shows our estimate of the probability @xmath181 for @xmath182 and pixel size @xmath159 , as a function of @xmath11 .
our simulated spectra have been convolved with the observation resolution ( full - width - at - half - maximum of @xmath183 ) , rebinned into pixels of @xmath159 each and added gaussian noise with a dispersion of @xmath184 . from the dotted curve in fig .
[ problong]a , applying a likelihood analysis , we obtain a 1 @xmath108 upper limit on @xmath11 of @xmath185 , and a corresponding lower limit on @xmath10 of @xmath186 .
this is for a model with a power spectrum normalization of @xmath187 ( see [ method ] ) .
the mean ly@xmath12 transmission constraints for the same model are @xmath188 and @xmath189 .
_ this means that considering ly@xmath12 alone , the fluctuation method yields somewhat stronger constraints compared to using simply the mean transmission .
[ problong]b ( dotted curve ) shows the same methodology applied to the ly@xmath13 gunn - peterson trough .
a new ingredient here is that one needs an additional simulation of the same model at redshift @xmath190 to produce the ly@xmath12 absorption that can be overlaid on top of the ly@xmath13 absorption from @xmath110 .
this additional simulation should have different initial phases to mimic the fact that fluctuations at @xmath190 and those at @xmath110 should be uncorrelated .
we obtain 1 @xmath108 limits of @xmath191 and @xmath192 .
this is about @xmath193 weaker than the constraints we obtain from the ly@xmath13 mean transmission . _ in other words , from ly@xmath13 absorption , the fluctuation method yields slightly weaker constraints compared to using the mean transmission .
_ it is also only slightly stronger than the constraint obtained from the fluctuation method applied to ly@xmath12 .
it is an interesting question to ask how many sightlines one would need to improve the constraints by , say a factor of @xmath68 .
our approach can be easily extended to multiple ( uncorrelated ) sightlines , and we find that about @xmath194 sightlines ( each containing a gunn - peterson trough of the same length and same signal to noise ) are necessary for such an improvement . part of the difficulty with obtaining stronger constraints , in addition to the small number of sightlines , is the dominance of noise
. the lower panel of fig .
[ pdf ] shows the one - pixel ( @xmath159 ) probability distribution function ( pdf ) of the true transmission @xmath164 ( i.e. no noise added ) , for three different values of @xmath11 ( the power spectrum normalization is the same as that in fig . [ problong ] ) .
the upper panel shows the corresponding pdf s of the observed transmission @xmath162 ( i.e. after convolving @xmath195 with a gaussian of dispersion @xmath184 ) .
as expected , noisy data make the pdf s more similar .
nonetheless , as we pointed out above , with sufficient number of sightlines , there might be a non - negligible chance of seeing pixels with high transmission that take place at the tail of the pdf s , hence allowing us to distinguish between the different levels of the ionizing background .
alternatively , one can try improving the signal - to - noise per pixel . in fig .
[ problong]b , we show with a dashed curve the corresponding probability if the noise per pixel is lowered by a factor of @xmath196 .
the constraints improve by a little more than a factor of @xmath68 .
we should emphasize , however , systematic errors are likely important here we will discuss them in the next two sections . if , as is suggested by our discussion in [ lyman beta ] ( see fig .
[ meantalpha ] ) , the igm is close to the epoch of reionization at @xmath0 , one might expect large fluctuations in the ionizing background near that time .
for instance , one line of sight might probe a region of the igm where the ionized bubbles around galaxies or quasars have percolated , while another might probe the pre - percolation igm . as mentioned before
, the simulations we employ do not take into account fluctuations in the ionizing background .
( for simulations incorporating radiative transfer see e.g. , gnedin & abel 2001 , razoumov 2001 ) .
one useful check would then be to predict the sightline to sightline scatter in mean transmission from our simulations , and compare that against the observed scatter . at @xmath16 ,
4 lines of sight are available for a measurement of the scatter .
we will examine this , as well as make predictions for the scatter at @xmath0 , which more high redshift quasars in the future will allow us to measure .
our estimate relies on simulation measurements of the transmission power spectrum .
this is in contrast to an estimate of the same quantity made by zuo ( zuo 1993 ) who makes a prediction based on extrapolations of the column density distribution and of the number of absorbing clouds per .
unit redshift ( zuo & phinney 1993 ) .
zuo also assumes that the clouds are poisson distributed , while our measurement incorporates the clustering in the igm via our numerical simulation .
an immediate problem presents itself : sightlines from which the mean transmission is measured are typically longer than the usual simulation box .
we tackle this problem by expressing the variance of mean transmission in terms of the transmission power spectrum , and making use of a reasonable assumption about the behavior of the power spectrum on large scales .
the mean transmission from one sightline is estimated using @xmath197 where @xmath166 is the number of pixels , @xmath198 is the observed transmission at pixel @xmath199 , @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the true transmission and @xmath81 is the noise fluctuation .
we use the symbol @xmath202 to represent the estimator , and @xmath203 to denote the true mean transmission .
the variance of the estimated mean transmission is then @xmath204 \\ \nonumber & & = { 1\over n^2 } \sum_{i , j } \xi_{ij } + { 1\over n } \sigma_n^2 = 2 \int_0^\infty { dk \over 2 \pi } \left[{\,\rm sin } ( k l /2 ) \over kl/2 \right]^2 p_f ( k ) + { \sigma_n^2 \over n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath205 is assumed roughly independent of position , and @xmath206 is the un - normalized two - point correlation of the transmission i.e. @xmath207 , and @xmath208 is its one - dimensional fourier transform .
the symbol @xmath209 denotes the comoving length of the spectrum from which the mean transmission is measured , and @xmath210 is the comoving wavenumber . to evaluate @xmath211
, we need to know the transmission power spectrum on scales generally larger than the size of the typical simulation box .
it is expected that the transmission power spectrum takes the shape ( not the normalization ) of the linear mass power spectrum on large scales ( i.e. essentially linear biasing ; see scherrer & weinberg 1998 , croft et al .
1997 , hui 1999 ) .
we therefore use this to extrapolate the simulation @xmath208 to large scales ( small @xmath210 s ) .
we find that @xmath208 is well approximated by @xmath212 where @xmath213 is the three - dimensional linear mass power spectrum .
becker et al . gave an estimate of @xmath214 , @xmath215 , at @xmath216 using 4 different sightlines , each spanning @xmath217 , which corresponds to @xmath218 mpc / h .
is estimated assuming gaussian statistics and that the four lines of sight are independent .
then @xmath219 ( see e.g. kendall & stuart 1958 ) . ] an estimate of the noise term is provided by the error in the mean transmission , @xmath220 . for the @xmath221 case ,
the fitting parameters are @xmath222 and @xmath223 . using eq .
( [ sigmat ] ) , we then find @xmath224 for @xmath225 , @xmath226 for @xmath227 , and @xmath228 for @xmath229 .
the variance is similar between the different normalizations because each normalization requires a different @xmath25 in eq .
( [ taualpha ] ) to match the mean transmission .
this difference in @xmath25 probably compensates for the effect of the different normalizations on @xmath211 .
the predicted scatter of @xmath230 is consistent with the measured @xmath211 of @xmath231 .
we apply the same methodology as the above to estimate @xmath211 at @xmath0 . in fig .
[ sigmat ] , we show the results for a range of different @xmath11 s for each of our canonical power spectrum normalizations , ( @xmath232 and @xmath233 ) . while at @xmath216 we compared the results of different normalizations at fixed mean transmission .
we find that the dependence on normalization is larger at fixed @xmath11 than at fixed mean transmission . ]
photon noise is not included in the estimates of this figure .
even for relatively large @xmath11 s the scatter is small .
for instance , for @xmath234 , @xmath235 , assuming our fiducial normalization .
this @xmath11 is large in that it already gives a mean transmission , @xmath236 , in excess of the observations .
by @xmath237 , the scatter is only @xmath238 for our fiducial normalization .
the scatter depends somewhat on normalization , as one can see in the figure . to measure the scatter
well would require data that are less noisy than the one discussed here , which has photon noise of @xmath220 , comparable to the predicted scatter .
on the other hand , the smallness of this scatter makes it a possibly interesting diagnostic .
as we have emphasized before , this predicted scatter ignores fluctuations in the ionizing background . for sufficiently small @xmath11 s , the igm should be close to the epoch of reionization , and one would expect large sightline by sightline variations .
an observed scatter well in excess of what is predicted would be an interesting signature .
* the most stringent ( 1 @xmath108 ) lower limit on the neutral hydrogen fraction @xmath10 ( eq . [ [ xhi ] ] ) or upper limit on the ionizing background @xmath11 ( eq . [ [ gamma ] ] ) at @xmath0 is obtained from the observed mean ly@xmath13 transmission : @xmath119 .
a comparison of this limit versus constraints at lower redshifts is presented in fig .
[ meantalpha ] .
the fact that the neutral fraction increases by a factor of @xmath239 from redshift of @xmath240 to @xmath176 even though it changes by no more than a factor of about @xmath68 from @xmath107 to @xmath103 suggests that @xmath0 might be very close to the epoch of reionization .
we emphasize that current constraints are still consistent with a highly ionized igm at @xmath0 it is the steep rise in @xmath10 that is suggestive of dramatic changes around or just before that redshift .
we should also mention that the constraints on @xmath10 are less subject to uncertainties in the igm temperature compared to those on @xmath11 ( see [ method ] ) . *
the existence of a long gunn - peterson ( ly@xmath12 or ly@xmath13 ) trough at @xmath0 , where little or no flux is detected , can also be used to obtain constraints on @xmath10 or @xmath11 .
this we call the fluctuation method : the fact that a long stretch of the spectrum exhibits no large upward fluctuations in transmission provides interesting information on the neutral fraction or ionizing background .
the constraints obtained this way turn out to be fairly similar to those obtained using the mean transmission .
we estimate that a reduction in noise by a factor of 4 , or an increase in number of sightlines to 5 , would result in constraints that are 2 times stronger ( [ los constraint ] ) . *
we develop a method to predict the dispersion in mean transmission measured from sightlines that are longer than the typical simulation box ( eq . [ [ sigmateq ] ] and fig . [ sigmat ] ) .
our predicted dispersion is consistent with that observed at @xmath216 ( becker et al .
we also predict the scatter at redshift @xmath86 , which can be measured when more sightlines become available . assuming a spatially homogeneous ionizing background
, we predict a small scatter at @xmath41 , @xmath241 a few @xmath242 , neglecting photon noise . the dispersion provides a useful diagnostic of fluctuations in the ionizing background close to the epoch of reionization , one expects large fluctuations from one line of sight to another depending on whether it goes through regions of the igm where percolation of hii regions has occurred .
there are at least three issues that will be worth exploring .
first , with more quasars at @xmath0 or higher discovered in the future , applying some of the ideas mentioned above would be extremely interesting , such as the measurement of the line of sight scatter in mean transmission , or the use of the gunn - peterson trough to obtain stronger constraints on the neutral fraction .
second , as we have commented on before , fluctuations in the ionizing background are expected to be important as we near the epoch of reionization .
we have not discussed it here , but a calculation of the size of these fluctuations would be very interesting . such a calculation will depend both on the mean free path of the ionizing photons as well as the spatial distribution of ionizing sources .
the latter is probably quite uncertain , but useful estimates might be made ( e.g. razoumov et al . 2001 ) .
lastly , a main source of systematic error which we have not discussed is the continuum placement . the mean transmissions at various redshifts given by becker et al
. are all obtained by extrapolating the continuum from the red side of ly@xmath12 by assuming a power law of @xmath243 .
the continuum likely fluctuates from one quasar to another , and therefore , it would be very useful to apply exactly the same procedure to quasars at lower redshifts where the continuum on the blue side can be more reliably reconstructed .
this will tell us how much scatter ( and possibly systematic bias ) the continuum placement procedure introduces to the measured mean transmission .
this kind of error is especially important to quantify given the limited number of quasars available for high redshift measurements at the moment .
al and lh are supported in part by the outstanding junior investigator award from the doe , and ast-0098437 grant from the nsf .
mz is supported by nsf grants ast 0098606 and phy 0116590 and by the david and lucille packard foundation fellowship for science and engineering .
we thank nick gnedin for the use of an hpm code and rupert croft for providing us with a revised draft of his paper .
.[meanttab ] a summary of the observed mean transmission .
the observation at redshift @xmath244 is from songaila et al .
( 1999 ) . for this observation
no error bars were provided by the authors .
the observation at @xmath245 is from fan et al .
the other observations are from becker et al .
becker et al . (
2001 ) have two observations at @xmath246 .
the above mean transmission at @xmath246 is the average of these two observations . [
cols="^,^",options="header " , ] | recent observations of high redshift quasar spectra reveal long gaps with little flux . a small or no detectable flux does not by itself imply the intergalactic medium ( igm ) is neutral . inferring the average neutral fraction from the observed absorption requires assumptions about clustering of the igm , which the gravitational instability model supplies .
our most stringent constraint on the neutral fraction at @xmath0 is derived from the mean lyman - beta transmission measured from the @xmath1 sdss quasar of becker et al .
the neutral hydrogen fraction at mean density has to be larger than @xmath2 .
this is substantially higher than the neutral fraction of @xmath3 at @xmath4 , suggesting that dramatic changes take place around or just before @xmath0 , even though current constraints are still consistent with a fairly ionized igm at @xmath0 .
these constraints translate also into constraints on the ionizing background , subject to uncertainties in the igm temperature .
an interesting alternative method to constrain the neutral fraction is to consider the probability of having many consecutive pixels with little flux , which is small unless the neutral fraction is high .
it turns out that this constraint is slightly weaker than the one obtained from the mean transmission .
we show that while the derived neutral fraction at a given redshift is sensitive to the power spectrum normalization , the size of the jump around @xmath0 is not .
we caution that the main systematic uncertainties include spatial fluctuations in the ionizing background , and the continuum placement .
tests are proposed .
in particular , the sightline to sightline dispersion in mean transmission might provide a useful diagnostic .
we express the dispersion in terms of the transmission power spectrum , and develop a method to calculate the dispersion for spectra that are longer than the typical simulation box .
psfig.sty ifundefinedchapter # 1 |
the non - thermal radiation emitted in pulsar wind nebulae is commonly associated with ultra - relativistic electron - positron pairs injected by the pulsar and accelerated at the termination shock . in the crab nebula
, the particle spectrum above @xmath2tev responsible for the x - ray to gamma - ray synchrotron emission is well modeled by a single power - law distribution of index @xmath3 , which is usually associated with first - order fermi acceleration at the shock front ( see e.g. , @xcite ) . since the detections of the first flares of high - energy gamma rays in 2010 and the following ones detected since then @xcite , we know that the crab nebula occasionally accelerates particles up to a few @xmath4 ev ( see reviews by @xcite and @xcite ) .
this discovery is very puzzling because the particles are accelerated to such energies within a few days , which corresponds to their larmor gyration time in the nebula .
this is far too fast for fermi - type acceleration mechanisms which operate over multiple crossings of the particles through the shock ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
in addition , the observed particle spectrum is very hard , which is not compatible with the steep power - law @xmath5 expected with diffuse shock - acceleration @xcite .
even more surprising , the particles emit synchrotron radiation above the well - established radiation reaction limit photon energy of @xmath1mev @xcite .
it implies that the particles must be subject to extreme synchrotron cooling over a sub - larmor timescale .
hence , in principle , synchrotron cooling should prevent the acceleration of pairs to such high energies in the first place .
fortunately , there is a simple way to circumvent these tight constraints on particle acceleration if there is a region of strong coherent electric field associated with a low magnetic field perpendicular to the particle motion , i.e. , if @xmath6 .
this supposes that a non - ideal , dissipative magnetohydrodynamic process is at work somewhere in the nebula . using a simple semi - analytical approach , @xcite and @xcite showed that such extreme particle acceleration can occur within a sweet - parker - like reconnection layer , where the reversing reconnecting magnetic field traps and confines the highest energy particles deep inside the layer where @xmath6 .
the reconnection electric field accelerates the particles almost linearly along a few light - day long layer .
this solution solves the sub - larmor acceleration problem at the same time .
two - dimensional ( 2d ) particle - in - cell ( pic ) simulations of relativistic pair plasma reconnection with radiation reaction force have confirmed and strengthened the viability of this scenario @xcite .
these simulations can also explain the observed rapid intra - flare time variability of the @xmath7mev synchrotron flux , the apparent photon spectral shape , as well as the flux / cutoff energy correlation @xcite .
although these 2d pic simulations provide a fairly complete assessment of extreme particle acceleration in reconnection layers , it is still a simplified picture of a truly three - dimensional process .
we know from previous 3d reconnection studies @xcite that the reconnection layer is unstable to the relativistic tearing and kink modes , and a combination of these two into oblique modes .
the kink ( and oblique ) instabilities , which can not arise in the 2d simulations of @xcite , can lead to significant deformation or even disruption of the reconnection layer in 3d simulations , subsequently suppressing particle acceleration .
however , a moderate guide magnetic field can stabilize the layer @xcite . in this work ,
we extend the previous 2d study of @xcite by performing large 3d pic simulations of pair plasma reconnection with radiative feedback and with guide field , in the context of the crab flares . in the next section ,
we first present the numerical techniques and the setup of the simulations chosen for this study .
then , we investigate separately the effect of the tearing and the kink instabilities on the efficiency of particle acceleration , using a set of 2d simulations in section [ results2d ] . in section [ results3d ] , we establish the conditions for particle acceleration above the radiation reaction limit and emission of @xmath7mev synchrotron radiation in 3d reconnection .
in addition , we report in this section on strong anisotropy and inhomogeneity of the highest - energy particles in 3d reconnection consistent with 2d results , and their important role in explaining the observed _ fermi_-lat gamma - ray flux of the crab flares .
we summarize and discuss the results of this work in section [ ccl ] .
all the simulations presented in this work were performed with zeltron , a parallel three - dimensional electromagnetic pic code @xcite .
zeltron solves self - consistently maxwell s equations using the yee finite - difference time - domain ( fdtd ) algorithm @xcite , and newton s equation following the boris fdtd algorithm @xcite .
unlike most pic codes , zeltron includes the effect of the radiation reaction force in newton s equation ( or the so - called `` lorentz - abraham - dirac equation '' ) induced by the emission of radiation by the particles ( see also , e.g. , @xcite ) . in the ultra - relativistic regime , the radiation reaction force , @xmath8 , is akin to a continuous friction force , proportional to the radiative power and opposite to the particle s direction of motion ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the expression of the radiation reaction force used in zeltron is given by @xmath9\mathbf{u } , \label{gforce}\ ] ] where @xmath10 cm is the classical radius of the electron , @xmath11 is the lorentz factor of the particle , @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the electric and magnetic fields , and @xmath14 is the four - velocity divided by the speed of light .
this formulation is valid if @xmath15 , where @xmath16 g is the quantum critical magnetic field .
because of the relativistic effects , the typical frequency of the expected radiation is @xmath17 times the relativistic cyclotron frequency .
hence , the radiation is not resolved by the grid and time step of the simulation .
it must be calculated separately .
zeltron computes the emitted optically thin radiation ( spectrum , and angular distributions ) assuming it is pure synchrotron radiation .
this is valid if the change of the particle energy is small , @xmath18 , during the formation length of a synchrotron photon , given by the relativistic larmor radius divided by @xmath11 .
we checked _
a posteriori _ that this assumption is indeed correct .
the code also models the inverse compton drag force on the particle motion in an imposed photon field , but this effect is negligible in the context of the crab flares @xcite , hence this capability will not be utilized in the following . to perform the large 3d simulations presented in this paper , zeltron ran on 97,200 cores on the kraken supercomputer with nearly perfect scaling . with periodic boundary conditions in all directions .
the box initially contains two flat , anti - parallel , relativistic harris layers in the @xmath19-plane centered at @xmath20 and @xmath21 , of some thickness @xmath22 .
the magnetic field structure is composed of the reconnecting field , @xmath23 , along the @xmath24-direction , which reverses across the layers , and a uniform guide field , @xmath25 , along the @xmath26-direction.,width=340 ] ccccccc 2dxy0 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath30 + 2dxy025 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath31 + 2dxy050 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath32 + 2dxy075 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath33 + 2dxy1 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath34 + & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath30 + 2dyz025 & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath31 + 2dyz040 & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath35 + 2dyz050 & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath32 + 2dyz060 & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath36 + 2dyz075 & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath33 + 2dyz1 & & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & @xmath34 + & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath30 + 3d050 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath27 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath32 + the simulation setup chosen here is almost identical to our previous two - dimensional pair plasma reconnection simulations with radiation reaction force in @xcite .
the computational domain is a rectangular box of dimensions @xmath39 , @xmath40 and @xmath41 , respectively along the @xmath24- , @xmath42- and @xmath26-directions , with periodic boundary conditions in all directions .
we set up the simulation with two flat anti - parallel relativistic harris current layers @xcite in the @xmath19-plane located at @xmath20 and @xmath21 ( figure [ fig_config ] ) .
having two current sheets is only a convenient numerical artifact that allows us to use periodic boundary conditions along the @xmath42-direction , but it does not have a physical meaning in the context of our model of the crab flares where only one reconnection layer is involved .
the electric current , @xmath43 , flows in the @xmath44-directions , and is supported by electrons counter - streaming with positrons at a mildly relativistic drift velocity ( relative to the speed of light ) @xmath45 . the plasma ( electrons and positrons ) is spatially distributed throughout the domain , with the following density profile @xmath46^{-2}+0.1n_0 & \mbox{if } & y < l_{\rm y}/2\\ n_0\left[\cosh\left(\frac{y-3l_{\rm y}/4}{\delta}\right)\right]^{-2}+0.1n_0 & \mbox{if } & y > l_{\rm y}/2 \end{array } \right . . \label{plasma_density}\ ] ] the first term is the density of the drifting pairs carrying the initial current , concentrated within the layer half - thickness @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the relativistic debye length @xcite . this population is modeled with a uniform and isotropic ( in the co - moving frame ) distribution of macro - particles with variable weights to account for the density profile and to decrease the numerical noise in low - density regions .
the second term is a uniform and isotropic background pair plasma at rest in the laboratory frame with a density chosen to be 10 times lower than at the center of the layers ( i.e. , @xmath49 ) .
the drifting and the background particles are distributed in energy according to a relativistic maxwellian with the same temperature @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath52 is the rest mass of the electron . the temperature of the drifting particles is defined in the co - moving frame .
this temperature models the ultra - relativistic plasma already present in the crab nebula , prior to reconnection , whose particles could have been accelerated at the wind termination shock or even by other reconnection events throughout the nebula .
however , observations show that in reality the background plasma is distributed according to a broad and steep power - law , extending roughly between @xmath53 and @xmath54 ( responsible for the uv to 100 mev synchrotron spectrum ) .
this large dynamic range of particle energies translates directly into an equally large dynamic range of relativistic larmor radii and hence of length scales that must be resolved in the simulation , which is beyond the reach of our numerical capabilities .
the initial electromagnetic field configuration is @xmath55 where @xmath56 are unit vectors along the @xmath24- and @xmath26-directions .
@xmath23 is the upstream reconnecting magnetic field and @xmath57 is a dimensionless parameter of the simulation that quantifies the strength of the guide field component @xmath58 in units of @xmath23 ( figure [ fig_config ] ) .
observations constrain the magnetic field in the emitting region to about @xmath59 mg , which is much higher than the expected average quiescent field of order @xmath60-@xmath61 g . in this work , we choose @xmath62 mg to be consistent with our previous studies of the flares @xcite .
hence , the energy scale at which the radiation reaction force equals the electric force , assuming that @xmath63 mg , is @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the fundamental electric charge .
below , we express lengths in units of the typical initial larmor radius of the particles in the simulations , i.e. , @xmath66 cm . in all the simulations ,
the layer half - thickness is then @xmath67 and the relativistic collisionless electron skin - depth @xmath68 .
similarly , timescales are given in units of the gyration time of the bulk of the particles in the plasma , i.e. , @xmath69s .
the initial distribution of fields and plasma results in a low plasma-@xmath70 or high magnetization of the upstream plasma ( i.e. , outside the layers ) . here
, the magnetization parameter is @xmath71 .
the system is initially set at an equilibrium , i.e. , there is a force balance across the reconnection layers between the magnetic pressure and the drifting particle pressure .
this equilibrium is unstable to two competing instabilities , namely the relativistic tearing and kink instabilities , as well as oblique modes that combine tearing and kink modes @xcite .
in contrast to @xcite , we choose here not to apply any initial perturbation in order to avoid any artificial enhancement of one type of instability over the other .
instabilities are seeded with the numerical noise only .
this choice has a direct computational cost because the lack of perturbation significantly delays the onset of reconnection ( see sections [ evol ] , [ evol3d ] ) , but it enables a fair comparison between the growth rates of both instabilities ( sections [ fou ] , [ fou3d ] ) .
another important consequence of this choice specific to this study is the significant radiative cooling of the particles before reconnection can accelerate them ( section [ spec2d ] ) . in this work
, we performed a series of @xmath72 simulations .
this set includes @xmath73 2d simulations , and @xmath74 3d simulations .
the 2d simulations are designed to study the effect of the guide field strength , @xmath75 and @xmath34 on the developments of instabilities ( kink and tearing ) and on particle acceleration / emission . to analyze the developments both instabilities separately ,
we follow the same approach as @xcite , i.e. , we consider the dynamics of the harris current layers in the @xmath76-plane where the tearing modes alone develop similarly to our previous study in @xcite , and in the @xmath77-plane where the kink modes alone develop ( the kink and the tearing modes are perpendicular to each other ) . the box is square of size @xmath78 and @xmath79 with @xmath28 cells and 16 particles per cell ( all species together ) . the spatial resolution is @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is the grid spacing in the @xmath24-direction ( @xmath82 ) , which ensures the conservation of the total energy to within @xmath83 error throughout the simulation . from this 2d scan
, we identify the best / worst conditions for efficient particle acceleration and emission above the radiation reaction limit in 3d .
the 3d box is cubical of size @xmath84 with @xmath37 grid cells and @xmath85 particles per cell ( all species together ) .
the simulation time step is set at @xmath86 times the critical courant - friedrichs - lewy time step , @xmath87 in 2d and @xmath88 in 3d , in order to maintain satisfactory total energy conservation in the presence of strong radiative damping .
table [ tab_simu ] enumerates all the simulations presented here .
in this section , we present and discuss the results of the 2d runs listed in table [ tab_simu ] .
after describing the overall time evolution of the reconnection layers in the @xmath76- and @xmath77-planes ( section [ evol ] ) , we present a fourier analysis of the tearing and kink instabilities as a function of the guide field strength ( section [ fou ] ) .
then , we deduce from the particle and photon spectra the most / least favorable conditions for particle acceleration beyond @xmath89 and synchrotron emission @xmath7mev in 3d ( section [ spec2d ] ) . figure [ fig_xy ] shows the time evolution of the total plasma density and field lines at four characteristic stages of 2d magnetic reconnection in the @xmath76-plane with @xmath90 ( run 2dxy0 ) . because there is no initial perturbation ,
the layers remain static until @xmath91 when the layer tears apart into about 7 plasmoids per layer separated by x - points where field lines reconnect .
the noise of the macro - particles in the pic code is sufficient to seed the tearing instability .
the reconnection electric field @xmath92 is maximum at x - points and is responsible for most of particle acceleration .
the high magnetic tension of freshly reconnected field lines pushes the plasma towards the @xmath93-directions and drives the large scale reconnection outflow that forces magnetic islands to merge with each other .
reconnection proceeds until there is only one big island per layer remaining in the box . at the end of the simulation ( @xmath94 ) , about @xmath95 of the initial magnetic energy
is dissipated in the form of particle kinetic energy .
all the energy gained by the particles is then lost via the emission of synchrotron radiation . adding a guide field
does not suppress the tearing instability , but it creates a charge separation across the layer that induces a strong @xmath96 electric field ( see also @xcite ) .
figure [ fig_zy ] presents the time evolution of the 2d simulation in the @xmath77-plane with no guide field ( run 2dyz0 ) .
the initial setup of fields and particles is identical to run 2dxy0 , except that the reconnecting field ( @xmath97 ) is now perpendicular to the simulation plane .
hence , reconnection and tearing modes can not be captured by this simulation .
instead , we observe the development of the kink instability as early as @xmath98 in the form of a small sinusoidal deformation of the current sheets with respect to the initial layer mid - plane .
the sinusoidal deformation proceeds along the @xmath26-direction , with the deformation amplitude in the @xmath42-direction increasing rapidly up to about a quarter of the simulation box size ( about @xmath99 ) . at this stage ,
the folded current layers are disrupted , leading to fast and efficient magnetic dissipation .
about @xmath100 of the total magnetic energy is dissipated by the end of the simulation .
the guide field has a dramatic influence on the stability of the layers .
the amplitude of the deformation as well as the magnetic energy dissipated decreases with increasing guide field . for @xmath101 ,
the layers remain flat during the entire duration of the simulation and no magnetic energy is dissipated . in this case , the only noticeable time evolution is a slight decrease of the layer thickness due to synchrotron cooling . to maintain pressure balance across the layers with the unchanged upstream magnetic field
, the layer must compress to compensate for the radiative energy losses @xcite .
we observed also a compression of the reconnection layer in the @xmath76-reconnection simulations .
to compare the relative strength of the tearing instability versus the kink instability , we perform a spectral analysis of the fastest growing modes that develop in the simulations . to study the kink instability , we do a fast fourier transform ( fft ) along the @xmath26-direction of the small variations of the reconnecting magnetic field in the bottom layer mid - plane , @xmath102 , during the early phase of the 2d simulations in the @xmath77-plane .
for the tearing modes , we follow the same procedure for the fluctuations in the reconnected field along the @xmath24-direction , @xmath103 , in the 2d simulations in the @xmath76-plane .
we present in figure [ fig_disp ] the time evolution of the fastest growing modes as well as the dispersion relations for the tearing and kink modes , with no guide field . in the linear regime ( @xmath104 ) , we infer the growth rates by fitting the amplitude of each mode with @xmath105 , where @xmath106 is the growth rate of the mode of wave - number @xmath51 .
we find that the fastest growing tearing mode is at @xmath107 , which coincides with the analytical expectation of @xmath108 @xcite as found by @xcite .
the wavelength of this mode is @xmath109 ; this explains the number of plasmoids formed in the early stages of reconnection ( see top right panel in figure [ fig_xy ] ) .
the fastest growing kink mode has a wavelength @xmath110 ( or @xmath111 ) which is consistent with the deformation of the current layers observed in figure [ fig_zy ] , top right panel .
the corresponding growth rate is @xmath112 , which is comparable with the fastest tearing growth rate , @xmath113 ( figure [ fig_disp ] , bottom panel ) .
this is expected for an ultra - relativistic plasma ( @xmath114 ) with a drift velocity @xmath45 @xcite .
it is worth noting that the dispersion relations for both the kink and the tearing instabilities are not sharply peaked around the fastest growing modes ; a broad range of low - frequency modes is almost equally unstable ( i.e. , for @xmath115 ) . in agreement with @xcite and
as pointed out in section [ evol ] , we find that the kink instability depends sensitively on the guide field strength .
figure [ fig_rate ] shows that the fastest growth rate decreases rapidly between @xmath116 and @xmath117 from @xmath112 to undetectable levels .
thus , the guide field stabilizes the layer along the @xmath26-direction .
in contrast , as mentioned earlier in section [ evol ] , the tearing growth rate depends only mildly on @xmath57 ; we note a decrease from @xmath113 for @xmath90 to @xmath118 for @xmath119 . for @xmath120 ,
the tearing instability dominates over the kink . ) and kink ( blue dashed line , @xmath111 ) modes , in the simulation 2dxy0 and 2dyz0 where @xmath90 .
the duration of the linear phase is @xmath121 ( delimited by the vertical dotted line ) and is about the same in both simulations .
bottom : dispersion relations of the tearing ( red solid line ) and kink ( blue dashed line ) instabilities during the linear stage .
this plot shows only the region of small wavenumber @xmath122 where the most unstable modes are found .
the vertical black dotted lines mark the fastest growing modes.,title="fig:",width=321 ] ) and kink ( blue dashed line , @xmath111 ) modes , in the simulation 2dxy0 and 2dyz0 where @xmath90 .
the duration of the linear phase is @xmath121 ( delimited by the vertical dotted line ) and is about the same in both simulations .
bottom : dispersion relations of the tearing ( red solid line ) and kink ( blue dashed line ) instabilities during the linear stage .
this plot shows only the region of small wavenumber @xmath122 where the most unstable modes are found .
the vertical black dotted lines mark the fastest growing modes.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , red solid line ) and the kink ( for @xmath123 , blue dashed line ) instabilities multiplied by @xmath124 , as a function of the guide field strength @xmath57 .
each dot represents one simulation .
the analysis of the kink / tearing instability was performed using the set of 2d simulations in the @xmath77-/@xmath76-plane.,width=321 ] the critical quantities of interest here are the particle energy distributions , @xmath125 , and the instantaneous optically thin synchrotron radiation spectral energy distribution ( sed ) emitted by the particles , @xmath126 , where @xmath127 is the photon energy . figure [ fig_spec_time ] shows the time evolution of the total particle spectra at different times with no guide field in the @xmath76-plane ( top panel ) and in the @xmath77-plane ( bottom panel ) . in the early stage ( @xmath128 ) , both simulations are subject to pure synchrotron cooling ( i.e. , with no acceleration or heating ) of the plasma that results in a decrease of the typical lorentz factor of the particles from @xmath129 at @xmath130 to @xmath131 at @xmath132 .
the decrease of the mean particle energy within the layer explains the shrinking of the layer thickness described in section [ evol ] . at @xmath133 ,
the instabilities trigger magnetic dissipation and particles are energized , but the particle spectra differ significantly in both cases . in run 2dxy0 ,
where the tearing instability drives reconnection , the particle spectrum extends to higher and higher energy with time until the end of the simulation , where the maximum energy reaches @xmath134 , i.e. , well above the nominal radiation reaction limit .
the spectrum above @xmath135 can not be simply modeled with a single power - law , but it is well contained between two steep power laws of index @xmath136 and @xmath137 . we know from our previous study that the high - energy particles are accelerated via the reconnection electric field at x - points and follow relativistic speiser orbits @xcite .
the maximum energy is then given by the electric potential drop along the @xmath26-direction ( neglecting radiative losses ) , i.e. , @xmath138 for a dimensionless reconnection rate @xmath139 .
particles above the radiation reaction limit ( @xmath140 ) account for about @xmath141 of the total energy of the plasma at @xmath142 ( figure [ fig_spec_tearing ] , top panel ) , and are responsible for the emission of synchrotron radiation above @xmath1mev .
figure [ fig_spec_tearing ] ( bottom panel ) shows the resulting isotropic synchrotron radiation sed at @xmath142 , where about @xmath143 of the radiative power is @xmath7mev .
the sed peaks at @xmath144mev and extends with a power - law of index @xmath145 up to about @xmath146-@xmath147 mev before cutting off exponentially .
in contrast , in run 2dyz0 , where the kink instability drives the annihilation of the magnetic field , the particles are heated up to a typical energy @xmath129
. the particle spectrum is composed of a maxwellian - like distribution on top of a cooled distribution of particles formed at @xmath128 ( figures [ fig_spec_time ] , [ fig_spec_kink ] ) .
the mean energy of the hot particles corresponds to a nearly uniform redistribution of the total dissipated magnetic energy to kinetic energy of background particles , i.e. , @xmath148 where the numerical factor @xmath149 accounts for the fraction of the total magnetic energy dissipated at the end of the simulation .
hence , the development of the kink prevents the acceleration of particles above @xmath89 and the emission of synchrotron photons above @xmath1mev .
figure [ fig_spec_kink ] ( bottom panel ) shows that the total synchrotron radiation sed peaks and cuts off at @xmath144mev , far below the desired energies @xmath7mev . because a moderate guide field suppresses the effect of the kink instability , hence magnetic dissipation , the particles are not heated for @xmath120 , and the initial spectrum continues cooling until the end of the @xmath77-plane simulation where the particles radiate low - energy ( @xmath150 mev ) synchrotron radiation ( figure [ fig_spec_kink ] ) . in the @xmath76-plane reconnection simulations
, the guide field tends to decrease the maximum energy of the particles and of the emitted radiation ( figure [ fig_spec_tearing ] , see also @xcite ) .
the guide field deflects the particles outside the layer , reducing the time spent by the particle within the accelerating region . ) of the 2d simulations in the @xmath76-plane ( top ,
run 2dxy0 ) and @xmath77-plane ( bottom , run 2dyz0 ) for @xmath90 .
the spectra are obtained at time @xmath130 ( dotted line)@xmath151 and @xmath152 ( dashed line ) and are averaged over all directions .
the particle lorentz factor is normalized to the nominal radiation reaction limit @xmath153.,title="fig:",width=321 ] ) of the 2d simulations in the @xmath76-plane ( top , run 2dxy0 ) and @xmath77-plane ( bottom , run 2dyz0 ) for @xmath90 .
the spectra are obtained at time @xmath130 ( dotted line)@xmath151 and @xmath152 ( dashed line ) and are averaged over all directions .
the particle lorentz factor is normalized to the nominal radiation reaction limit @xmath153.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , top ) and synchrotron radiation spectral energy distribution normalized by the total ( frequency - integrated ) photon flux ( @xmath154 , bottom ) of the 2d simulations in the @xmath76-plane at @xmath142 , averaged over all directions .
the spectra are obtained for @xmath75 and @xmath34 .
the particle lorentz factor in the top panel is normalized to the nominal radiation reaction limit @xmath153 . in the bottom panel ,
the blue dashed line is a power - law fit of index @xmath155 of the @xmath90 sed between @xmath156 mev and @xmath157 mev.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , top ) and synchrotron radiation spectral energy distribution normalized by the total ( frequency - integrated ) photon flux ( @xmath154 , bottom ) of the 2d simulations in the @xmath76-plane at @xmath142 , averaged over all directions .
the spectra are obtained for @xmath75 and @xmath34 .
the particle lorentz factor in the top panel is normalized to the nominal radiation reaction limit @xmath153 . in the bottom panel ,
the blue dashed line is a power - law fit of index @xmath155 of the @xmath90 sed between @xmath156 mev and @xmath157 mev.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , but for the 2d simulations in the @xmath77-plane.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , but for the 2d simulations in the @xmath77-plane.,title="fig:",width=321 ]
from the previous section , we find that the tearing and kink modes grow at a similar rate and wavelength in our setup .
both instabilities lead to fast dissipation of the magnetic energy in the form of thermal and non - thermal particles .
the kink instability tends to disrupt the layer , which prevents non - thermal particle acceleration and emission above the standard radiation reaction limit .
it is desirable to impose a moderate guide field to diminish the negative effect of the kink on particle acceleration , but too strong a guide field is not advantageous either , as it decreases the maximum energy reached by the particles and radiation .
hence , we decided to run a 3d simulation with an @xmath158 guide field ( run 3d050 , see table [ tab_simu ] ) , which appears to be a good compromise . for comparison
, we also performed a 3d simulation without guide field ( run 3d0 ) . in this section ,
we first describe the time evolution of 3d reconnection in the two runs ( section [ evol3d ] ) .
then , we provide a quantitative analysis of the most unstable modes in the @xmath159-plane in the linear regime ( section [ fou3d ] ) .
in addition , we address below the question of particle acceleration , emission ( section [ spec3d ] ) , particle and radiation anisotropies ( section [ anis3d ] ) , the expected radiative signatures ( i.e. , spectra and lightcurves ) and comparison with the _ fermi_-lat observations of the crab flares ( sections [ comp_obs ] , [ light ] ) .
figure [ fig_3d ] ( left panels ) shows the time evolution of the plasma density in the zero - guide field simulation at @xmath160 and @xmath161 .
the initial stage where the layer remains apparently static lasts for about @xmath162 , i.e. , half of the whole simulation time . at @xmath163 , overdensities appear in the layers in the form of 7 - 8 tubes ( flux ropes ) elongated along the @xmath26-direction .
these structures are generated by the tearing instability and are the 3d generalization of the magnetic islands observed in 2d reconnection .
as the simulation proceeds into the non - linear regime , the flux ropes merge with each other creating bigger ones , as magnetic islands do in 2d reconnection .
however , in 3d this process does not happen at the same time everywhere along the @xmath26-direction , which results in the formation of a network of interconnected flux ropes at intermediate times ( @xmath164 ) . in parallel
to this process , the kink instability deforms the two layers along the @xmath26-direction in the form of sine - like translation of the layers mid - planes in the @xmath165-directions . during the most active period of reconnection ( @xmath166 ) , the kink instability takes over and eventually destroys the flux ropes formed by the tearing modes ( see left bottom panel in figure [ fig_3d ] ) .
only a few coherent structures survive at the end of the simulation ( @xmath167 ) .
in particular the reconnection electric field , which is strongest along the x - lines between two flux ropes , loses its initial coherence .
this results in efficient particle heating but poor particle acceleration ( see below , section [ spec3d ] ) . at the end of this run about @xmath168 of the total magnetic energy
is dissipated , although the simulation does not reach the fully saturated state .
the right panels in figure [ fig_3d ] shows the time evolution of the plasma density for @xmath158 guide field .
one sees immediately that the guide field effectively suppresses the kink deformations of the layers in the @xmath169directions , as expected from the 2d simulations in the @xmath77-plane ( see section [ results2d ] ) and from @xcite .
in contrast , the tearing instability seems undisturbed and breaks the layer into a network of 8 flux tubes . towards the end of the simulation ,
there are about 3 well - defined flux ropes containing almost all the plasma that went through reconnection . at this point in time , @xmath170 of the total magnetic energy ( i.e. , including the reconnecting and the guide field energy ) has dissipated , in agreement with the 2d run 2dxy050 .
-plane , blue dotted line , and in the @xmath77-plane , green dashed line ) and 3d ( red solid line ) with no guide field.,title="fig:",width=321 ] -plane , blue dotted line , and in the @xmath77-plane , green dashed line ) and 3d ( red solid line ) with no guide field.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , but with an @xmath158 guide field.,title="fig:",width=321 ] , but with an @xmath158 guide field.,title="fig:",width=321 ] following the analysis presented in section [ fou ] , we perform a fourier decomposition of the magnetic fluctuations in the bottom layer mid - plane , @xmath171 , to study the most unstable modes that develop in the 3d simulations .
figure [ fig_disp2d ] presents the growth rate of each modes in the @xmath159-plane estimated from the variations of @xmath97 ( left panel ) and @xmath172 ( right panel ) , for @xmath90 . as pointed out in section [ fou ] and by @xcite and @xcite , we find that the reconnecting field @xmath97 effectively captures the kink - like modes along @xmath173 whereas the reconnected field @xmath172 is most sensitive to tearing - like modes along @xmath174 .
the dispersion relations show that pure kink ( along @xmath173 for @xmath175 ) and pure tearing ( along @xmath174 for @xmath176 ) modes grow at rates in very good agreement with the corresponding 2d simulations . with a growth rate @xmath177 ,
the fastest growing mode in the simulation is a pure kink mode of wavenumber @xmath178 , or @xmath110 consistent with the deformation of the layer observed in the earlier stage of reconnection ( figure [ fig_3d ] , left panels ) and with the 2d run 2dyz0 .
the fastest tearing mode has a growth rate @xmath179 at @xmath180 and generates the @xmath181 initial flux ropes obtained in the simulation .
the @xmath159-plane is also filled with oblique modes , i.e. , waves with a non - zero @xmath174- and @xmath173-component , with growth rates comparable to the fastest tearing and kink modes .
the existence of these modes is reflected by the flux ropes being slightly tilted in the @xmath19-plane .
adding an @xmath158 guide field decreases the amplitude of the low - frequency ( @xmath182 ) growth rates of the kink modes ( figure [ fig_disp2d_guide ] ) .
in particular , the growth rate of the fastest mode for @xmath90 , @xmath183 , decreases from @xmath184 to @xmath185 . as a result , the fastest growing kink mode is now at @xmath186 with a rate @xmath187 , while the fastest growing tearing modes is approximatively unchanged , in excellent agreement with the 2d runs ( figure [ fig_disp2d_guide ] ) .
figure [ fig_spec_3d ] presents the particle and photon energy distributions averaged over all directions at @xmath188 , with no guide field .
the distributions are remarkably similar to the 2d run 2dyz0 ones , and differ significantly from run 2dxy0 . the high - energy part of the particle spectrum peaks at @xmath189 which is the signature of particle heating via magnetic dissipation rather than particle acceleration through tearing - dominated reconnection ( section [ spec2d ] , eq . [ gmax_kink ] ) .
we note that the spectrum extends to higher energy than the pure magnetic dissipation scenario , slightly above @xmath89 , suggesting that there is a non - thermal component as well . on the contrary , in the @xmath158 guide field case ( run 3dg050 , figure [ fig_spec_3d_guide ] ) , things are closer to the pure tearing reconnection case of run 2dxy050 .
the particle energy distribution is almost flat in the @xmath190 range , but barely reaches above @xmath89 as in the zero - guide field case .
nevertheless , the synchrotron emission @xmath7mev is more intense than in the zero guide field case .
even though there is clear evidence for particle acceleration above the radiation reaction limit , the effect remains slightly weaker than in 2d with no guide field .
a bigger box size would help to improve the significance of this result .
the angular distribution of the particles is of critical interest for determining the apparent isotropic radiation flux seen by a distant observer who probes one direction only . in 2d reconnection
, we expect a pronounced beaming of the particles that increases rapidly with their energy @xcite .
we confirm here that this phenomenon exists also in 3d , even with a finite guide field .
figure [ fig_anis ] presents energy - resolved maps of the angular distribution of the positrons ( left panels ) and their optically thin synchrotron radiation ( right panel ) in run 3d050 .
the direction of motion of the particles is measured with two angles : the latitude , @xmath191 , varying between @xmath192 and @xmath193 , defined as @xmath194 and the longitude , @xmath195 , defined between @xmath196 and @xmath197 given by @xmath198 where @xmath199 , and @xmath200 are the components of the particle 4-velocity vector .
we find that the low - energy particles ( @xmath201 ) nearly conserve the initially imposed isotropy , because they are still upstream and have not been energized by reconnection .
in contrast , the high - energy particles ( @xmath202 ) are significantly beamed along the reconnection plane ( at x - lines and with flux ropes ) within @xmath203 and @xmath204 .
the @xmath204 angle is of special interest here because it coincides with the direction of the undisturbed magnetic field lines outside the reconnection layers for a @xmath158 guide field ( @xmath205 ) .
the particles are accelerated along the @xmath26-direction by the reconnection electric field , and move back and forth across the layer mid - plane following relativistic speiser orbits @xcite . at the same time , the particles are deflected away by the reconnected field and the guide field creating a characteristic `` s '' shape in the angular maps . to a lesser extent , the zero - guide field case also presents some degree of anisotropy , but the deformation and then the disruption of the layer by the kink instability effectively broaden the beams .
the synchrotron angular distribution closely follows the particle one , essentially because relativistic particles radiate along their direction of motion within a cone of semi - aperture angle @xmath206 .
however , there is a noticeable offset between the distribution of the highest - energy particles with @xmath207 and the radiation above @xmath60 mev .
this discrepancy is due to the different zones where particles accelerate and where particles radiate . in the accelerating zone
, the electric field is intense and leads to linear particle acceleration along the @xmath26-axis , whereas the perpendicular magnetic field , @xmath208 , is weak deep inside the reconnection layers , yielding little synchrotron radiation .
these high - energy particles then radiate @xmath209 mev emission abruptly , i.e. , within a fraction of a larmor gyration , only when they are deflected outside the layer where @xmath210 .
the beam dump is well localized at @xmath204 , i.e. , along the upstream magnetic field lines ( see hot - spots in figure [ fig_anis ] , bottom - right panel ) .
direction ( solid line ) .
bottom : comparison between the isotropically averaged synchrotron sed ( dashed line ) , the apparent isotropic sed in the @xmath211 direction at @xmath212 , for @xmath158 ( solid line ) , and the observed _ fermi_-lat spectra ( data points ) during the flares in february 2009 , september 2010 , and in april 2011 , as well as the average quiescent spectrum from 1 mev to 10 gev @xcite .
observed fluxes are converted into isotropic luminosities , assuming that the nebula is at 2 kpc from earth.,title="fig:",width=321 ] direction ( solid line ) .
bottom : comparison between the isotropically averaged synchrotron sed ( dashed line ) , the apparent isotropic sed in the @xmath211 direction at @xmath212 , for @xmath158 ( solid line ) , and the observed _ fermi_-lat spectra ( data points ) during the flares in february 2009 , september 2010 , and in april 2011 , as well as the average quiescent spectrum from 1 mev to 10 gev @xcite .
observed fluxes are converted into isotropic luminosities , assuming that the nebula is at 2 kpc from earth.,title="fig:",width=321 ] as a consequence of this strong anisotropy , the observed spectra of particles and radiation depend sensitively on the viewing angle .
figure [ fig_spec_anis ] compares the isotropic particle ( top panel ) and photon energy distributions ( apparent intrinsic isotropic luminosities , @xmath213 , bottom panel ) with the distributions along one of the directions dominated by the highest energy particles ( @xmath214 ) and radiation ( @xmath211 ) as it appears to a distant observer at @xmath212 , for @xmath158 ( see section [ anis3d ] and figure [ fig_anis ] ) . the bottom panel in figure [ fig_spec_anis ] also compares the _ fermi_-lat measurements of the gamma - ray spectra of the february 2009 , september 2010 and april 2011 flares and the average quiescent spectrum of the crab nebula @xcite with the simulated gamma - ray spectra .
the particle spectrum in the ( @xmath214 ) direction is very hard , and peaks at @xmath215 with a total apparent isotropic energy @xmath216erg , which corresponds to about half the total magnetic energy dissipated by the end of the simulation , or about 10 times more energy than in the isotropic distribution . the photon spectrum in the ( @xmath211 ) direction peaks at about @xmath0mev but extends up to @xmath217gev .
the resulting gamma - ray luminosity above 100 mev is @xmath218erg / s , which is about 40 times brighter than the isotropically averaged flux from the layer , and about 3 times brighter than the observed average ( quiescent ) luminosity of the crab nebula ( @xmath219erg / s , assuming a distance of 2 kpc between the nebula and the observer ) .
thanks to beaming , the level of gamma rays expected from the model is consistent with the moderately bright flares , such as the february 2009 or september 2010 ones ( see figure [ fig_spec_anis ] , bottom panel ) , but the simulation can not reproduce the flux of the brightest flares , such as the april 2011 event .
presumably , increasing the box size would be enough to increase the density of the emitting particles @xmath220mev and account for the most intense flares .
mev as a function of time in the directions @xmath211 ( blue solid line ) , @xmath221 ( green dot - dashed line ) , and isotropically averaged ( red dotted line ) in run 3d050 .
fluxes are given in ph / s/@xmath222 , assuming a distance of @xmath223kpc between the layer and the observer .
the horizontal gray band shows the average observed flux of the crab nebula above 100 mev measured by the _
fermi_-lat , equal to @xmath224 ph / s/@xmath222 @xcite.,width=321 ] the beam of high - energy radiation is also time variable , both in direction and in intensity .
figure [ fig_lightcurve ] presents the computed time evolution of the synchrotron photon flux integrated above @xmath60 mev in the directions defined by @xmath211 and @xmath221 , as well as the computed time evolution of the isotropically - averaged flux and the observed average flux in the crab nebula measured by the _
fermi_-lat @xcite for comparison .
this calculation assumes that all the photons emitted at a given instant throughout the box reach the observer at the same time , i.e. , it ignores the time delay between photons emitted in different regions with respect to the observer . along the directions probed here ,
the @xmath225 mev flux doubling timescale is of order @xmath226 or @xmath227-@xmath228 hours , for both the rising and the decaying time , which is compatible with the observations of the crab flares @xcite , as well as with our previous 2d simulations in @xcite .
shorter variability timescales may still exist in the simulation but our measurement is limited by the data dumping period set at @xmath229 .
these synthetic lightcurves also clearly illustrate the effect of the particle beaming on the observed flux discussed in section [ comp_obs ] . along the direction of the beam
, the @xmath220mev flux can be @xmath230 times more intense than the isotropically - averaged one , and even exceeds the measured quiescent gamma - ray flux of the crab nebula by a factor @xmath231-@xmath227 at the peak of the lightcurves 3.5 to 4 days after the beginning of the simulation .
each time the beam crosses our line of sight , we see a rapid bright flare of the most energetic radiation emitted in the simulation . the high - energy particles are strongly bunched within the magnetic flux ropes ( within magnetic islands in 2d , see @xcite ) . as a result ,
the typical size of the emitting regions is comparable to the dimensions of the flux ropes , i.e. , of order @xmath232 along the @xmath24- and @xmath42-directions ( figure [ fig_3d ] ) , which corresponds to about @xmath228 light - hours .
we conclude that particle bunching is at the origin of the ultra - short time variability ( @xmath227-@xmath228 hours ) found in the reconstructed lightcurve ( figure [ fig_lightcurve ] ) .
particle bunching and anisotropy help to alleviate the severe energetic constraints imposed by the crab flares .
we found that , unlike classical models of particle acceleration , 3d relativistic pair plasma reconnection can accelerate particles above the standard radiation reaction limit in the crab nebula .
we also confirm the existence of a strong energy - dependent anisotropy of the particles and their radiation , resulting in an apparent boosting of the high - energy radiation observed when the beam crosses our line of sight . in this case , the simulated gamma - ray flux @xmath220mev exceeds the measured quiescent flux from the nebula by a factor 2 - 3 , and reproduces well the flux of moderately bright flares , such as the february 2009 or the september 2010 events . simulating brighter flares ( e.g. , the april 2011 flare ) may be achieved with a larger box size .
in addition , the bunching of the energetic particles within the magnetic flux ropes results in rapid time variations of the observed gamma - ray flux ( @xmath233 hours ) .
the results are consistent with observations of the crab flares and with our previous 2d simulations @xcite , although this extreme acceleration is less pronounced than in 2d due to the deformation of the layer by the kink instability in 3d .
if there is no guide field , we found that the kink instability grows faster than the tearing instability , resulting in the disruption of the reconnection layers and significant particle heating rather than reconnection and non - thermal particle acceleration . in agreement with @xcite , we observe that a moderate guide field ( @xmath234 ) is enough to reduce the negative effect of the kink on the acceleration of particles . however , a strong guide field ( i.e. , @xmath235 ) quenches particle acceleration and the emission of high - energy emission because it deflects the particles away from the x - lines too rapidly . applying a guide field
is probably not the only way to suppress kink instability . in the harris configuration , an initial ultra - relativistic drifting particle flow ( with @xmath236 )
is expected to foster tearing - dominated reconnection @xcite as observed by @xcite .
alternatively , starting with an out - of - equilibrium layer could also drive a fast onset of reconnection @xcite . in real systems ,
the reconnection layer is not likely to be smooth , flat , undisturbed , and in equilibrium .
a small perturbation in the field lines , like a pre - existing x - point , can favor fast reconnection before the kink instability has time to grow .
hence , while we have shown one set of conditions emitting @xmath7mev radiation , there may be other conditions allowing reconnection to produce similar results .
the reconnection model could be refined if future multi - wavelength observations can pin down the location of the flares in the crab nebula ( so far there is nothing obvious , see e.g. , @xcite ) .
one promising location for reconnection - powered flares could be within the jets in the polar regions where the plasma is expected to be highly magnetized ( i.e. , @xmath237 ) with stronger magnetic field close to the pulsar rotational axis @xcite . in addition , theoretical studies @xcite , numerical simulations @xcite , and possibly x - ray observations @xcite indicate that the jets are unstable to kink instabilities .
the non - linear development of these instabilities could lead to the formation of current sheets , presumably with a non - zero guide field , and then to magnetic dissipation in the crab nebula in the form of powerful gamma - ray flares , which may contribute to solving the `` @xmath238-problem '' in pulsar wind nebulae @xcite .
relativistic reconnection may also be at the origin of other astrophysical flares .
most notably , tev gamma - ray flares observed in blazars ( e.g. , @xcite ) present challenges similar to the crab flares ( e.g. , ultra - short time variability , problematic energetics ) that could be solved by invoking relativistic reconnection in a highly magnetized jet @xcite .
the physical conditions in blazar jets are quite different than in the crab nebula ( e.g. , composition , inverse compton drag , pair creation ) , which may change the dynamics of reconnection . the current sheet that forms beyond the light - cylinder in pulsars offers another interesting environment for studying relativistic reconnection subject to strong synchrotron cooling .
pairs energized by reconnection may be at the origin of the gev pulsed emission in gamma - ray pulsars .
we speculate that synchrotron radiation from the particles could even account for the recently reported @xmath220gev pulsed emission from the crab ( see , e.g. , ) if particle acceleration above the radiation reaction limit operates in this context .
bc thanks g. lesur for discussions about the linear analysis of the unstable modes in the simulations .
the authors thank the referee for his / her useful comments .
bc acknowledges support from the lyman spitzer jr .
fellowship awarded by the department of astrophysical sciences at princeton university , and the max - planck / princeton center for plasma physics .
this work was also supported by nsf grant phy-0903851 , doe grants de - sc0008409 and de - sc0008655 , nasa grant nnx12ap17 g through the fermi guest investigator program .
numerical simulations were performed on the local cips computer cluster verus and on kraken at the national institute for computational sciences ( www.nics.tennessee.edu/ ) .
this work also utilized the janus supercomputer , which is supported by the national science foundation ( award number cns-0821794 ) , the university of colorado boulder , the university of colorado denver , and the national center for atmospheric research .
the janus supercomputer is operated by the university of colorado boulder .
the figures published in this work were created with the matplotlib library @xcite and the 3d visualization with mayavi2 @xcite . | the discovery of rapid synchrotron gamma - ray flares above @xmath0mev from the crab nebula has attracted new interest in alternative particle acceleration mechanisms in pulsar wind nebulae .
diffuse shock - acceleration fails to explain the flares because particle acceleration and emission occur during a single or even sub - larmor timescale . in this regime ,
the synchrotron energy losses induce a drag force on the particle motion that balances the electric acceleration and prevents the emission of synchrotron radiation above @xmath1mev .
previous analytical studies and 2d particle - in - cell ( pic ) simulations indicate that relativistic reconnection is a viable mechanism to circumvent the above difficulties . the reconnection electric field localized at x - points
linearly accelerates particles with little radiative energy losses . in this paper
, we check whether this mechanism survives in 3d , using a set of large pic simulations with radiation reaction force and with a guide field . in agreement with earlier works , we find that the relativistic drift kink instability deforms and then disrupts the layer , resulting in significant plasma heating but few non - thermal particles
. a moderate guide field stabilizes the layer and enables particle acceleration .
we report that 3d magnetic reconnection can accelerate particles above the standard radiation reaction limit , although the effect is less pronounced than in 2d with no guide field .
we confirm that the highest energy particles form compact bunches within magnetic flux ropes , and a beam tightly confined within the reconnection layer , which could result in the observed crab flares when , by chance , the beam crosses our line of sight . |
ic4846 ( [email protected] ) is a compact planetary nebula ( pn ) whose morphology has not been studied in detail yet .
the only available information on its structure is provided by the vla 6 cm continuum observations by kwok ( 1985 , see also aaquist & kwok 1990 ) , showing several knots embedded in a faint elongated structure of @xmath1 3@xmath52 arcsec@xmath6 in size .
the h@xmath7 surface brightness ( @xmath8 , acker et al . 1992 ) suggests that ic4846 has a high electron density .
this is corroborated by the small [ s ii]@xmath96717,@xmath96731 doublet ratio ( barker 1978 ; acker et al .
1992 ) which reaches the limiting ratio for high electron density ( @xmath10 @xmath11 ) .
both its small angular size and high density indicate that ic4846 is a young pn .
the line intensity ratios ( acker et al . 1992 ) point to a moderate excitation ( [ n ii]@xmath96583/h@xmath12 , [ o iii]@xmath94959/h@xmath13 , and very faint he ii @xmath94686 ) .
_ iue _ low - resolution uv spectra of the central star show a strong p - cygni profile in the n v line with a terminal velocity of @xmath1 1300 km s@xmath2 .
the occurrence of a strong stellar wind in the central stars of pne is indicative of their early evolutionary stage ( cerruti - sola & perinotto 1985 ) .
the shaping processes of pne occur early in their formation .
therefore , the signatures of these processes in the nebula are more recent and more likely to have withstood the fast nebular evolution in young pne .
this turns the observations of young pne of chief importance in the understanding of their formation mechanisms .
accordingly , ic4846 was included in our observational program of compact young pne ( see miranda 1999 and references therein ) , and narrow band h@xmath0 and [ n ii ] images and long slit high resolution spectra were obtained to study its structure and internal kinematics .
the results reported in this paper evidence the existence of bipolar , precessing collimated outflows in ic4846 .
direct images of ic4846 were obtained in 1997 july 24 with the nordic optical telescope ( not ) at roque de los muchachos observatory on la palma .
the detector was a loral 15 @xmath14 m ccd at the hirac camera providing a plate scale of 0.11 arcsecpixel@xmath2 .
the filters were h@xmath0 ( @xmath15 6563 , fwhm @xmath1 10 ) , and [ n ii ] ( @xmath15 6584 , fwhm @xmath1 10 ) .
exposure times were 900s in each case .
the spatial resolution is @xmath1 1 arcsec .
the images were bias subtracted and flat fielded following standard procedures within midas package .
long slit echelle spectra of ic4846 were taken with the iacub spectrograph at the not in 1998 august 2 .
the detector was a thompson 19 @xmath14 m ccd with 1024@xmath51024 pixels .
a filter was used to isolate the h@xmath0 and [ n ii]@xmath96583 emission lines in the 9@xmath16 echelle order .
a thorium argon spectrum was taken after each object spectrum for wavelength calibration purposes .
exposure time was 1800s for each spectrum .
the observed position angles ( pas ) were 11@xmath17 , 30@xmath17 , 54@xmath17 , and 140@xmath17 with the slit centered on the object .
the dispersion was 2.5 mm@xmath2 , and the achieved spectral resolution ( fwhm ) @xmath1 7.5 kms@xmath2 .
the spatial resolution is @xmath1 1.5 arcsec .
absolute errors in the radial velocity are @xmath18 1.5 kms@xmath2 , whereas relative errors ( within each long - slit spectrum ) are @xmath18 0.5 kms@xmath2 .
the data were reduced following standard procedures for long slit spectroscopy within the iraf and midas packages .
thereafter the [ n ii]@xmath96583 emission line will be referred to as the [ n ii ] line .
figures 1 and 2 present grey scale and contour maps , respectively , of ic4846 in the light of [ n ii ] and h@xmath0 .
the morphology of ic4846 , resolved in these images for the first time , displays a great wealth of structures . at the lowest intensity levels ,
the appearance of the nebula is elliptical with two bipolar features protruding at pa @xmath1 54@xmath17 .
these features , denoted a1a2 ( fig .
2 ) , are curved filaments enhanced in [ n ii ] . a second , inner ellipse , observed in h@xmath0 and [ n ii ] at intermediate intensity levels , can be recognized with its major axis at pa @xmath1 11@xmath17 .
two compact knots , b1b2 , are observed at the tips of this inner ellipse .
the innermost regions of ic4846 are dominated in [ n ii ] at the highest intensity levels by two bright structures , c1c2 , which are not clearly distinguished in the h@xmath0 image .
an additional attached circular shell with a size of @xmath1 10@xmath19 can also be identified in the h@xmath0 image . in order to emphasize the different structures of ic4846 described before
, we have obtained deconvolved images using the lucy - richardson algorithm as implemented in the midas package . deconvolved h@xmath0 and [ n ii ] images to a resolution of @xmath1 0.5 arcsec ( obtained with 30 iterations )
are also presented in fig . 2 .
these images clearly show the structural richness of the nebula .
in particular , the curvature and filamentary appearance of a1a2 can easily be recognized as well as the compactness of b1b2 .
c1c2 appear as point
symmetric structures elongated perpendicular to the radial direction from the center . in h@xmath0 the inner regions appear as an arc with an asymmetric intensity distribution .
we note that the inner regions of the nebula resemble the morphology observed at 6 cm ( kwok 1985 ) .
in addition , the inner shell presents a very low ellipticity .
figure 3 shows position velocity ( pv ) contour maps of the high resolution long slit spectra of the [ n ii ] emission line at pas 11@xmath17 , 54@xmath17 and 140@xmath17 .
the spectrum at pa 30@xmath17 is similar to that at pa 11@xmath17 and is not shown here .
the bipolar features a1a2 , b1b2 and c1c2 can be identified in the pv maps with point - symmetric pairs of components .
we also note that no _ closed _ velocity ellipse can be identified in the pv maps of the [ n ii ] emission line , which could be expected from the elliptical structures observed in the images . the h@xmath0 spectra ( not shown here )
are dominated by emission from the inner regions .
these regions show a tilt in the pv maps similar to the tilt of c1c2 ( fig.3 ) .
a1a2 are clearly distinguished because of their high radial velocity .
b1b2 seem to be present , too , although the h@xmath0 line is not useful for a detailed kinematic study owing its large thermal width . a [ n ii]/h@xmath0 ratio map
is also presented in fig 1 .
a1a2 and b1b2 are highlighted due to their relatively strong [ n ii ] emission .
c1c2 can also be recognized , although the line ratio seems to have lower values . a quantitative estimate of [ n
ii]/h@xmath0 should be worked out using the long - slit spectra in order to single out both spatially and kinematically the different components .
pv maps of the [ n ii]/h@xmath0 ratio for pas 11@xmath17 and 54@xmath17 are shown in fig .
. a mean value of [ n ii]/h@xmath0 in the nebula of @xmath1 0.06 is obtained , similar to that obtained by acker et al .
the three pairs present enhanced [ n ii ] emission , with mean [ n ii]/h@xmath0 values of @xmath1 0.8 ( a1a2 ) , @xmath1 0.15 ( b1b2 ) , and @xmath1 0.2 ( c1c2 ) , which are a factor 2.5 to 13 higher than the mean ratio in the nebula .
furthermore , peak values of this ratio up to @xmath1 1.5 are found in a1a2 , and up to @xmath1 0.3 in b1b2 and c1c2 .
common to all three pairs is that [ n ii]/h@xmath0 peaks at larger distances from the center than the [ n ii ] emission peaks ( see also fig . 1 ) .
table 1 lists different parameters of the bipolar pairs as deduced from the [ n ii ] images and long slit spectra . in order to deduce systemic velocities ,
we have first considered the centroid of each bipolar pair as representative of its own systemic velocity .
the systemic velocity obtained for each pair is listed in table 1 .
secondly , we have obtained the centroid velocity of the [ n ii ] emission line as representative of the systemic velocity of the whole nebula . in order to avoid the contribution of the bipolar pairs
, the centroid velocity was obtained from the middle point of the spatially integrated emission at 10% level of the intensity peak .
we obtain v@xmath20(centroid ) @xmath1 168 kms@xmath2 and note that an identical value is obtained if the middle point is considered at 5% or 15% levels of the intensity peak .
the values for v@xmath20(centroid ) , v@xmath20(b1b2 ) and v@xmath20(c1c2 ) agree within the absolute errors with the value quoted by bianchi ( 1992 ) and durand et al .
( 1998 ) for the systemic velocity of ic4846 .
the systemic velocity of b1b2 and c1c2 are almost identical to each other ; both are slightly blueshifted ( @xmath1 3.5 kms@xmath2 ) with respect to the centroid velocity . in the case of a1a2
, its systemic velocity is noticeably blueshifted by @xmath1 10 kms@xmath2 with respect to the centroid velocity .
we will discuss in 4 possible interpretations for these systemic velocity shifts . in the following , radial velocities of each pair
will be quoted with respect to its own systemic velocity .
ic4846 displays three pairs of structures , a1a2 , b1b2 , and c1c2 , which are highly evocative of collimated outflows .
we describe as follows the properties of these components .
a1a2 appear detached and off - axis ( @xmath21(pa ) @xmath1 43@xmath17 ) with respect to the major axis of the inner ellipse .
their orientation changes by @xmath1 5@xmath1710@xmath17 .
a1a2 can be traced along @xmath1 6 arcsec , which represents a considerable fraction of the total nebular size .
an upper limit of @xmath1 1 arcsec is obtained for their lateral size .
the radial velocity systematically varies along a1a2 : a minimum velocity of @xmath1 @xmath18 36 kms@xmath2 is observed at the minimum angular distance ; the velocity then steadily increases with the distance up to @xmath1 @xmath18 52 kms@xmath2 ; finally , it slightly decreases at the tips of the features .
the velocity width is small as compared with the velocity difference between a1 and a2 ( see table 1 ) , which implies a high degree of collimation .
according to their properties , a1a2 are highly suggestive of a precessing bipolar jet .
b1b2 present a rather moderate radial velocity and the velocity width is small and comparable to that of a1a2 ( table 1 ) .
the small velocity width and the compactness indicate that b1b2 are highly collimated outflows .
the radial velocity of c1c2 does not depend on the pa ( fig . 3 , table 1 ) , although some small variations ( @xmath1 7 kms@xmath2 ) within c1c2 are observed .
possible interpretations of this pair will be discussed in 4 .
the observations of ic4846 have disclosed a complex structure composed of three different elements : ( 1 ) two apparent elongated shells with different orientations , ( 2 ) an attached circular shell and ( 3 ) three pairs of point - symmetric components at different orientations with typical properties of collimated outflows . in the following we discuss about the nature , models and possible interpretations of these components .
as already mentioned , there is no kinematic evidence for the elliptical shells in the pv maps of the [ n ii ] line , although the extended emission observed in the pv maps may be related to these shells .
we also note that the major axis of the outer ellipse is only defined by a1a2 .
in fact , without a1a2 the outer ellipse could not be recognized .
images at higher resolution would be necessary to elucidate the precise geometry of these shells . while a1a2 and b1b2 can be interpreted as precessing bipolar outflows , the interpretation of the pair c1c2 is somewhat difficult .
its kinematic properties and the elongation perpendicular to the radial direction suggest that c1c2 could represent collimated ejections in which the orientation of the ejection axis has remarkably changed over the ejection time .
however , we can not completely rule out that c1c2 represents a ring - like structure containing two bright opposite regions .
the attached circular shell probably represents a previous slow wind ejected by the agb progenitor of ic4846 .
it is similar to other attached shells observed in pne and its formation may be related to the dynamics of ionization fronts ( see mellema 1995 and references therein ) . in the scenario that a1a2
are precessing bipolar jets , we can obtain estimates for the inclination angle and velocity by assuming that the expansion velocity is constant and that the variation of the radial velocity is due to a systematic change of the angle between the observer and the precessing jet along a precession cone with aperture angle @xmath1 5@xmath1710@xmath17 .
the observed minimum and maximum radial velocities are assumed to be related to the far and rear side of the precession cone , respectively . using the model for a biconical flow described by miranda & solf ( 1992 )
, we obtain an inclination angle for the precession axis of @xmath1 13@xmath1726@xmath17 with respect to the plane of the sky , and a velocity of @xmath1 100190 kms@xmath2 .
the ( mean ) kinematic age is @xmath1 200@xmath5d(kpc ) yr , where d is the distance to ic4846 , which is extremely uncertain with published values between 2 and 11 kpc ( see acker et al .
the images also show that a1a2 protrude from the circular shell .
this result , the increase of the [ n ii]/h@xmath0 ratio at larger distances and the decrease of the radial velocity at the tips of a1a2 suggest an interaction between the jet fronts and the circular shell , in a similar way to that reported in , e.g. , ngc6891 ( guerrero et al . 2000 ) .
it is worthwhile to emphasize the extraordinary similarity between ic4846 and the well - known pn ngc6543 ( see miranda & solf 1992 and reed et al .
the following structural components are common to these two pne ( we will use for ngc6543 the nomenclature of miranda & solf 1992 ) : 1 . _ basic elongated shell(s ) . _ in ngc6543 two shells
are observed , an outer bipolar shell with a bright ring between the lobes and an inner elliptical one . in ic4846 two elongated shells
are suggested by the images ( but see above ) .
the possible existence of an equatorial ring should be confirmed by new data .
2 . _ bipolar knots at the tips of the shell . _
the knots ff in ngc6543 correspond to b1b2 in ic4846 .
_ precessing bipolar jets . _
the bipolar jets jj in ngc6543 correspond to a1a2 in ic4846 .
the similarity between jj and a1a2 is extraordinary . both appear off - axis with respect to the orientation of the basic shell and are curved , with a change of orientation of 5@xmath1710@xmath17 .
the radial velocity presents an identical variation along the jets with a steady increase up to a maximum radial velocity and a small decrease at their tips .
finally , an expansion velocity of @xmath1 100200 kms@xmath2 is obtained in both cases .
4 . _ point - symmetric components perpendicular to the radial direction . _
c1c2 in ic4846 could correspond to dd in ngc6543 .
there are some differences between both objects , but these are most likely attributable to different orientations , ages and distances .
whatever these differences , the conspicuous kinematic and structural similarities lead us to conclude that ngc6543 and ic4846 have shared a similar formation history .
an interesting result in ic4846 is the systemic velocity shifts among the different components and the centroid of the nebula . in the case of b1b2 and c1c2 , the shifts are only slightly larger than the relative errors and we can not conclude whether they are real . in the case of a1a2 , however , the shift is noticeable and we consider it real . both the remarkable spatial and velocity symmetry observed in a1a2 exclude that this shift may be ascribed to different ejection velocity , changes ( deceleration ) in the velocity in one of the components of the pair , different ejection angle or a combination of the three .
a more plausible explanation is that the systemic velocity of a1a2 is indeed intrinsically different from that of the other components and , in particular , from that of the emission centroid .
similar shifts in the systemic velocity of collimated outflows and shell have been recently reported in the pn hu2 - 1 ( miranda et al .
furthermore , both pne share the presence of two systems of collimated outflows at different orientations , one of them projected along the nebular major axis and one off - axis , suggesting a parallel formation history .
moreover , inspection of the kinematic data of ngc6543 ( see miranda & solf 1992 ) suggests that a difference of @xmath22 7 kms@xmath2 could exist between the systemic velocity of jj and the systemic velocity of the nebula as defined by the rest of components . in the case of hu2 - 1 ,
the shifts of systemic velocity have been interpreted as a direct evidence of orbital motion of the ejection source in a binary central star ( miranda et al .
the velocity shifts detected in ic4846 fit also into this framework . if a1a2 are ejected from a star in a binary system , the space velocity of the a1a2 will contain an additional velocity component due to the orbital motion , besides to the component due to the own ejection velocity .
accordingly , the systemic velocity of a1a2 will be shifted from that of the emission centroid of the nebula ( see miranda et al . 2000 for details ) .
we note that the same would apply to b1b2 and c1c2 if their observed velocity shifts were real .
the systemic velocity shift of a1a2 ( 10 kms@xmath2 ) is very similar to that found in hu2 - 1 ( 8 kms@xmath2 ) and in ngc6543 ( 7 kms@xmath2 ) .
consequently , the orbital parameters of their binary central stars should be rather similar as well , with an orbital separation @xmath3 30 au and an orbital period @xmath3 100 yr , thus linking the central stars of these nebulae to symbiotic stars .
these results strongly suggest that the central star of ic4846 , similarly to that of hu2 - 1 and ngc6543 , is a binary star in which mass transfer from a red giant leads to the formation of an accretion disk about a secondary ( mastrodemos & morris 1998 , 1999 ) , from which collimated ejections may be generated .
narrow band imaging and high resolution spectroscopy of the pn ic4846 in the [ n ii]@xmath96583 and h@xmath0 lines have revealed a complex structure similar in many respects to that of ngc6543 .
the most remarkable components in ic4846 are three pairs of point - symmetric structures oriented at different directions .
two ( and probably the three ) pairs represent collimated bipolar outflows . the kinematics and morphology of the pair observed at pa 54@xmath17 ( a1a2 )
are highly suggestive of a precessing jet moving at @xmath1 100200 kms@xmath2 .
furthermore , the velocity shift between their systemic velocity and that of the nebula can be interpreted as a result of orbital motion of the ejection source in a binary central star .
this kind of systemic velocity differences has also been observed in hu2 - 1 and could be present in ngc6543 .
thus , the formation of ic4846 ( and hu2 - 1 and ngc6543 ) could be related to physical processes in the own evolution of interacting binary stars .
we thank our referee for his / her valuable comments which have improved the presentation of the paper .
lfm and jmt are supported partially by dgesic pb98 - 0670-c02 and junta de andaluca ( spain ) .
mag is supported partially by dgesic of the spanish ministerio of educacin y cultura .
lcccccc pair & @xmath24v@xmath25@xmath26 & @xmath21v@xmath27 & v@xmath28(lsr)@xmath29 & @xmath24v@xmath28@xmath30 & @xmath24x@xmath31 & pa@xmath32 + & ( kms@xmath2 ) & ( kms@xmath2 ) & ( kms@xmath2 ) & ( kms@xmath2 ) & ( arcsec ) & ( degrees ) + a1a2 & 96 & 20 & 158 & @xmath410 & 7.4 & 54 + b1b2 & 26 & 18 & 164 & @xmath44 & 5.4 & 11 + c1c2 & 38 & 22 & 165 & @xmath43 & 1.8 & 25 + @xmath23 obtained from the images and long slit [ n ii ] spectra shown in figs . 1 and 3 , respectively .
+ @xmath26 separation in radial velocity between intensity peaks of the components of each pair .
+ @xmath27 velocity dispersion ( fwhm ) corrected of instrumental resolution .
+ @xmath29 systemic velocity .
+ @xmath30 maximum difference between v@xmath28(lsr ) for each pair and v@xmath28(lsr ) for the centroid of the [ n ii ] emission line = 168 kms@xmath2 + @xmath31 projected angular separation between the intensity peak of the components of each pair .
+ @xmath32 orientation ( position angle ) . | we present [ n ii ] and h@xmath0 images and high resolution long slit spectra of the planetary nebula ic4846 , which reveal , for the first time , its complex structure and the existence of collimated outflows .
the object consists of a moderately elongated shell , two ( and probably three ) pairs of collimated bipolar outflows at different orientations , and an attached circular shell .
one of the collimated pairs is constituted by two curved , extended filaments whose properties indicate a high velocity , bipolar precessing jet .
a difference of @xmath1 10 kms@xmath2 is found between the systemic velocity of the precessing jets and the centroid velocity of the nebula , as recently report for hu2 - 1 .
we propose that this difference is due to orbital motion of the ejection source in a binary central star .
the orbital separation of @xmath3 30 au and period @xmath3 100 yr estimated for the binary are similar to those in hu2 - 1 , linking the central stars of both planetary nebulae to interacting binaries .
extraordinary similarities also exist between ic4846 and the bewildering planetary nebula ngc6543 , suggesting a similar formation history for both objects . |
the statistics of earthquakes has been a subject of research for a long time .
one spectacular feature is the wide range of observed earthquake sizes , spanning over ten decades in earthquake moment magnitude ( which is defined to scale as the logarithm of the integral of slip along the fault during the earthquake@xcite ) .
gutenberg and richter@xcite found in the 50 s that the size distribution of regional earthquakes follows a power law over the entire range of observed events .
the exponent @xmath2 of the power law distribution appears to be universal , _
i.e. _ it is approximately the same ( within statistical errors and possible secondary dependency on the tectonic domain ) for all studied regions .
this type of power law distribution is called the `` gutenberg richter '' distribution . recently
, enough data has been collected to extract statistics on individual systems of earthquake faults , or more precisely on systems of narrow fault zones .
interestingly , it was found that the distribution of earthquake magnitudes may vary substantially from one fault system to another .
in particular , wesnousky and coworkers@xcite found that fault systems with highly irregular geometry , such as the san jacinto fault zone in california , which have many offsets and branches , display `` power law '' statistics over the whole range of observed magnitudes .
not all fault systems , however , display a power law distribution on all scales up to the largest earthquakes .
the available data@xcite indicate that fault systems with more regular geometry ( presumably generated progressively with increasing cumulative slip ) such as the san andreas fault in california display power law distributions only for small events , which occur in the time intervals between roughly quasi - periodic earthquakes of a much larger `` characteristic '' size which rupture the entire fault .
there are practically no observed earthquakes of intermediate magnitudes on such geometrically regular fault systems .
distributions of this type are called the `` characteristic earthquake '' distribution . in previous work@xcite it was demonstrated that a class of simple models of ruptures along a heterogeneous fault zone displays both types of behavior .
the universal power law scaling behavior of earthquake statistics was seen to be due to an underlying critical point , which becomes mean - field - like for fault geometries with more than two spatial dimensions . in the limit of
_ weak _ dynamical effects , the mean - field approximation to the 2 dimensional fault provides a more appropriate approximation than , for example , traditionally studied one dimensional approximations to the models .
in fact , _ exact _
results for the scaling exponents ( up to logarithmic corrections ) could be obtained from mean - field theory .
the reason is that the elastic stresses along the fault are effectively long range ( decaying like the inverse cube of the distance ) , such that in two and higher dimensions the fluctuations due to interaction with other points on the fault decrease as the fault size is increased on long length scales the behavior becomes the same as that of a system with infinite ranged elastic interactions ( up to logarithmic corrections in two dimensions ) .
in other words , the upper critical dimension is equal to the physical dimension of the fault , which is 2@xcite .
( some of the static mean - field exponents turned out to be the same as in other quasi - static models@xcite . ) in the presence of small but nonzero weakening effects of amplitude @xmath3 a critical rupture size ( slipping area ) @xmath4 for `` runaway '' or `` characteristic fault size '' events was calculated perturbatively @xcite and was found to scale as @xmath5 .
faults of larger area than this size are expected to display the characteristic earthquake distribution , with small events up to size @xmath4 , and no events of intermediate size between @xmath4 and the characteristic fault size events . for faults of smaller total area than @xmath4 only the power law scaling region of the small events is seen , so the distribution is of the gutenberg richter type . in this paper
we examine a mean - field model with a range of dynamical weakening effects from weak to strong , and different levels of disorder in the brittle properties . specifically , we study the model of ben - zion and rice@xcite , which involves simple approximations of dynamic frictional weakening ( similar to static versus dynamic friction ) , but replace the physical long range elastic interactions with infinite range interactions .
in addition to exhibiting both `` power law '' and `` characteristic '' scaling of event sizes , this model exhibits the possibility of _ coexistence _ of these two types of behavior .
that is , for a given set of model parameters , the system has _ two distinct persistent stationary states_. in an infinitely large system it will depend on the initial conditions whether the system displays gutenberg richter or characteristic earthquake type behavior .
faults of _ finite _ size can spontaneously switch from one state to the other on time scales that are exponentially large in system size . the switching times ( or `` persistence times '' ) are determined by nucleation processes from one state to the other , similar to flips back and forth at coexistence in finite thermally equilibrated systems .
many of the qualitative features seem to be sufficiently robust to be applicable to real fault zones .
interesting to note , such `` switching '' behavior appears to characterize long paleoseismic records observed along the dead sea transform fault system in israel@xcite , and is compatible with other paleoseismic @xcite and geologic@xcite data .
in addition , qualitatively similar switching has been recently found in regional models of disordered fault systems@xcite .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows : in section [ secmodel ] , we define the model and provide a summary of the main results . in section [ secanalysis ] , we present a detailed analysis of the model along with comparisons with numerical simulations . in section [ secdiscuss ] , we compare our results with earlier studies of similar models and discuss their potential relevance to natural fault systems modeled as a narrow fault zone in a three dimensional elastic surrounding media .
ben - zion and rice@xcite suggested that a heterogeneous fault system with offsets and branches may be represented by an array of discrete cells in a two dimensional plane , with spatially varying `` macroscopic '' constitutive parameters that model the heterogeneity of the original fault system .
this model fault on the @xmath6 plane can be considered as a collection of brittle patches mapped onto the interface between two tectonic blocks , which move with ( small ) relative transverse velocity @xmath7 far away from the fault . in the simple realizations used in refs.@xcite , and here , ( as in related models @xcite )
, the fault plane is segmented into @xmath8 geometrically equal cells . in the mean field approximation of infinite range elastic interactions , the local stress @xmath9 on cell @xmath10
is given by @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the total fault
offset of cell @xmath10 in the horizontal @xmath13 direction , @xmath14 , @xmath15 is the elastic coupling between cells in the mean - field approximation , and @xmath16 is the effective loading stiffness of the bulk material surrounding the fault patch . initially , the fault is in a relaxed configuration , i.e. all stresses are less than a local _ static _ failure threshold stress @xmath17 . in the absence of brittle failures
the stresses at the cells increase uniformly due to the external loading and @xmath18 . as long as no cell reaches its failure threshold , @xmath19 everywhere . when the stress at a cell becomes larger than @xmath20 , the cell slips by an amount @xmath21 , to reduce its stress from @xmath17 to an arrest stress @xmath22 .
( the nonuniformity of failure and arrest stresses across the fault plane models the spatial heterogeneity of real fault zones@xcite . ) consequently , during failure cell stresses change by [ cf .
eq.([eqstress ] ) ] [ eqfailure ] @xmath23 where @xmath24 is a `` conservation parameter '' giving the fraction of the stress drop of the failing cell retained in the system after the slip .
as pointed out in refs.@xcite , for fault zones with characteristic linear dimensions of @xmath25 , the `` loading spring constant '' is @xmath26 provided that the stress loading of the fault is either due to uniformly moving ( creeping ) boundaries or applied forces at distances of @xmath25 away from the fault plane . for the case
@xmath27 , @xmath28 a value @xmath29 for a large system would be physically realized if the external drive is closer to the fault than its linear extent . during the failure process
, the slipped cell is assumed to be weakened by the rupture , such that its failure strength is reduced to a _
value @xmath30 , with @xmath31 parameterizing the relative importance of dynamical weakening effects in the system .
if the failure stress transfer brings other cells to their failure threshold , an avalanche of cell failures , i.e. , `` rupture propagation '' , occurs according to eqs.([eqfailure ] ) until all cells are at stresses @xmath32@xcite .
it is assumed that these avalanches happen on time scales short compared to the external loading time ( i.e. @xmath33 is adiabatically small ) , so that the external load is kept constant during an earthquake . in time intervals between earthquakes ,
all cells are assumed to heal completely , thus failure thresholds are reset to their static value @xmath17 and the external loading resumes until the next cell failure .
in order to simplify notation , it is useful to introduce rescaled stress variables @xmath34 such that cell failure always occurs when @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
( here , @xmath37 symbolizes averaging over all cells in the fault zone . ) the arrest stress @xmath38 is uncorrelated from cell to cell , and is picked once for each segment from a probability distribution @xmath39 with mean @xmath40 and a compact support @xmath41 of width @xmath42 , which characterizes the heterogeneity of the fault system .
[ in our simulations we have used the parabolic distribution @xmath43 , for @xmath44 and @xmath40 otherwise . ] unless stated otherwise , the focus is on the small disorder limit @xmath45 @xmath46 and moderate values for @xmath0 , which are considered fixed , and the properties of the system are analyzed as a function of varying conservation parameter @xmath47 and system size @xmath8 .
( in the last section of the paper we discuss the effects of larger values of @xmath45 as well . )
the size of an earthquake refers to the number of cells that failed , ( i.e. the `` area '' on the fault that slips in an earthquake ) . for @xmath48 , depending on relative values of the system parameters , there are in general two possible steady - state distributions of cell stresses and of earthquake magnitudes .
we refer to these as as `` phases '' : \(a ) _ the `` gutenberg - richter '' ( g - r ) phase : _ this phase , possible in both regions @xmath49 and @xmath50 of fig .
[ phasediag ] , is characterized by a distribution of earthquake sizes @xmath51 of power law form . in infinite systems ( @xmath52 ) , it is given by @xmath53 with a characteristic cutoff size @xmath54 that diverges as @xmath55 .
( finite size corrections are given in equation ( [ eqpefc ] ) below ) .
the stress @xmath56 at a given cell is independent of all others and is equally likely to take any allowable value , i.e. , @xmath57 thus , the stress distribution in the g - r phase is given by @xmath58 which is uniform and equal to @xmath59 in the interval @xmath60 [ see fig .
[ figpe](a ) , inset ] . in this phase
each cell fails at most once during an earthquake , and therefore dynamical effects are largely irrelevant .
an infinitely large system which started in the g - r phase will remain it this phase .
in finite systems @xmath61 , with parameters in region @xmath50 of figure [ phasediag ] , however , a very large earthquake of size @xmath62 or greater occasionally triggers dynamical effects that lead to a catastrophic `` runaway '' event in which all cells eventually fail and cause a substantial change in the stress distribution and subsequent evolution of the system , as outlined next .
\(b ) _ the `` runaway '' phase : _ this phase is characterized by a quasi - periodic occurrence of system wide earthquakes in which all cells fail . as a result of dynamical effects , the stress @xmath56 in a cell immediately after such a `` runaway '' event is independent of other cells and is equally likely to take any value between its arrest stress and dynamical failure stress , i.e. , @xmath63 the stress distribution is thus given by @xmath64 which is uniform and equal to @xmath65 in the interval @xmath66 [ see fig .
[ figpe](b ) , inset ] .
the runaway event is followed by a quiescent period during which stresses on the cells build back up from their dynamic failure value to near their static failure value .
subsequent small events are followed by the next runaway event , at which point the stress distribution is reset to eq.([eqpr ] ) .
these background small events have a size distribution similar to events in the g - r phase , but with a different cutoff size . in an infinite system ( for finite size corrections
see equation ( [ eqperc ] ) below ) : @xmath67 which diverges as @xmath68 . however , this divergence is never observed , as the runaway phase becomes unstable against breakup into the g - r phase when @xmath69 for the following reason : if the background small events during a cycle involve at least a fraction @xmath70 of the cells , the subsequent large event is unable to cause all of the cells to fail , since the cells that failed during background activity are farther away from their failure stress .
this typically causes a spontaneous breakup of the bunched stress distribution and a resumption of the g - r phase .
the fraction of cells needed to cause this breakup is given by @xmath71 as is derived in section [ secanalysis ] .
when @xmath72 the size of background events necessary to cause breakup vanishes and the runaway phase becomes unstable , _
i.e. _ for @xmath73 the g - r phase is the only persistent phase , regardless of the initial conditions . for @xmath74 , the g - r phase and the runaway phase
are both persistent in an infinite system . in an infinite system
the initial conditions determine which one the system displays . in a finite system , however , exponentially rare earthquakes can lead to nucleation from the g - r phase into the runaway phase and vice versa . equations ( [ timefr ] ) and ( [ timerf ] ) below give estimates of the times spent in the respective phases between such nucleation ( or `` switching '' ) events .
the results quoted above have been obtained by mapping earthquakes in the model to corresponding events in a stochastic process , which is approximated by a series of bernoulli trials@xcite in order to be able to obtain analytical estimates for the various quantities of interest , such as distributions of earthquake sizes and persistence times for the two phases .
let us first focus on the g - r phase . at some instant @xmath75 immediately preceding a cell failure , consider the sequence @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the index of the cell that has the @xmath78th largest stress in the system [ see fig .
[ figpoisson ] ] . for a large system ,
the stress gaps @xmath79 are ( almost ) independent of each other , drawn from an exponential probability distribution , i.e. , prob@xmath80 , with @xmath59 . for @xmath81
resembles a biased random walk with a mean @xmath82 and variance @xmath83 . as long as dynamical effects are absent ,
the stress redistributed to each cell following the failure of the first @xmath84 cells is given by a random variable @xmath85 with mean @xmath86 and variance @xmath87 a triggered earthquake can sustain itself only if the redistributed stresses exceed the stress gaps .
therefore , @xmath88 during an earthquake and it immediately follows that the distribution of earthquake sizes for @xmath89 are given in terms of the distribution of first passage times of biased random walks . approximating the continuous probability distribution of the step sizes of @xmath90 with a bernoulli process ( where steps of equal size are taken up or down with probability @xmath91 and @xmath92 respectively ) , we can utilize results available for bernoulli trials@xcite , @xmath93 i.e. the probability for the _ first _ return to the origin after @xmath84 steps equals the total probability of reaching the origin after @xmath84 steps divided by @xmath84 .
@xmath94 $ ] can easily be calculated@xcite for @xmath95 .
one obtains eq.([eqpef ] ) with @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 are the mean and variance of the step size for the process @xmath99 respectively . substituting the values @xmath100 and
@xmath101 the cutoff length is given by @xmath102 \right\ } , \label{eqncf}\ ] ] where the last approximation is justified since treating @xmath103 as a bernoulli process is expected to yield relative errors of @xmath104 for finite - sized systems , when the fraction of failed cells @xmath105 is no longer small , eq.([eqpef ] ) needs to be modified since the stress gaps are not entirely independent : in order to correctly reflect the fact that @xmath106 to within @xmath107 the bernoulli process should be constrained to return to its mean value after @xmath8 steps .
this can be achieved by calculating the corresponding conditional probabilities : @xmath108 which reduces to eq.([eqpef ] ) in the limit @xmath109 ( @xmath110 is a constant fixed by normalization . ) figure [ figpe](a ) shows the distribution of event sizes for numerical simulations of the model with @xmath111 for values @xmath112 and @xmath113 ( in all presented simulation results , @xmath114 and @xmath115 the continuous lines are one - parameter fits to the form ( [ eqpefc ] ) .
the discrepancy between the fitted and theoretical [ from eq.([eqncf ] ) ] values of @xmath116 is consistent with the expected relative error .
as mentioned earlier , the failure of all the remaining cells becomes very likely once @xmath117 cells have failed , since the initially failed cells reach their dynamical failure stress .
the mean event size is roughly equal to @xmath118 , therefore the mean time between events is @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is the characteristic time over which a cell is loaded from its arrest stress to its failure stress . the typical waiting time to see a switch to the runaway phase yields [ cf .
eq.([eqpefc ] ) ] @xmath121 with @xmath122 a factor of order unity which varies weakly with @xmath3 and @xmath47 in the region of interest , provided that each attempt is statistically independent of each other .
we verified that in our simulations indeed no time correlations of event sizes were present , out to many times the characteristic time @xmath123 ( see also the discussion section ) .
the distribution of persistence times should then obey poisson statistics with mean @xmath124 .
figure [ figswitchtimes ] depicts the distribution of persistence times ( with a fit to poisson statistics ) for @xmath125 and @xmath126 .
mean persistence times depend very sensitively on the conservation parameter @xmath127 as shown in the inset of fig .
[ figswitchtimes]@xcite .
let us next consider the runaway phase .
immediately preceding the first cell failure after a runaway event , the stress gaps @xmath128 have the probability distribution prob@xmath129 .$ ] hence , @xmath130 has a mean @xmath131 and variance @xmath132 .
as long as dynamical effects are absent , the stress redistributed to each cell following the failure of the first @xmath84 cells is still given by @xmath133 with mean @xmath134 and variance @xmath135 thus , the mean and variance of the step size for @xmath90 is @xmath136 and @xmath137 the probability for an earthquake to terminate after @xmath84 cell failures is [ including finite size corrections in analogy with eq.([eqpefc ] ) ] @xmath138 ^{2}}\left\ { 1+o\left ( \left [ c-(1-\epsilon ) \right ] ^{2}\right ) \right\ } , \qquad c>1-\epsilon . \label{eqperc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath139 for @xmath140 , @xmath141 with finite probability for all @xmath84 and a runaway event occurs .
in fact , a runaway event is inevitable since @xmath142 and the runaway event will commence once @xmath90 reaches its maximum .
the total number of cells that fail before a runaway event is given by the position of the maximum of @xmath90 , whose probability distribution is proportional to @xmath4 @xmath143 for @xmath144 .
the mean number of these `` precursor '' cells is of order @xmath145 , which remains a finite constant as @xmath48 , _
i.e. _ , for big systems almost all the slip happens during the runaway events@xcite .
the remaining cells will all fail during the runaway event .
imagine a situation where a fraction @xmath146 of the cells have failed .
at that point , the total redistributed stress per cell , is @xmath147 \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{c[r-(1-\epsilon ) ] } { 1-c},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second term arises from repeat failures of some cells .
@xmath148 is needed to ensure that small event cells fail again and recreate the stress distribution ( [ eqpr ] ) .
this is achieved if @xmath149 thus , the large event can not recreate the stress distribution ( [ eqpr ] ) if more than @xmath150 cells fail during background activity .
this usually leads to a breakup of the bunched stress distribution and subsequent evolution towards the g - r stress distribution ( [ eqpf ] ) .
the typical persistence time of the runaway phase before a switch to the g - r phase is @xcite @xmath151n}{c^{*}c\,n_{cr}}\right\ } , \qquad c > c^{*},\ ] ] provided that all attempts are statistically independent of each other .
( we have explicitly checked in the simulations that in the runaway phase , the particular realizations of stress distributions immediately following a large event are statistically independent of each other@xcite ) .
@xmath152 becomes comparable to the typical time between runaway events when @xmath153 as expected@xcite .
figure [ figswitchtimes ] depicts the distribution of persistence times and a fit to poisson statistics for @xmath154 and @xmath126 .
the inset shows the dependence of mean persistence times on @xmath47 for @xmath154 .
although agreement with eqs.([timefr ] ) and ( [ timerf ] ) is rather poor , the strong exponential dependence as a function of conservation parameter is evident .
the persistence times in both the g - r phase and the runaway phase diverge exponentially with system size for @xmath155 , and the system remains in either phase for extremely long times , thus the phase space has two almost stable attractors . clearly , the runaway phase represents a more `` ordered '' stress distribution .
indeed , the basin of attraction for the runaway phase is extremely small . in order to quantify this aspect ,
consider the `` configurational entropy '' for a given stress distribution @xmath156 with @xmath157@xmath158 .\ ] ] for the g - r phase , @xmath159 indicating that a `` generic '' stress distribution characterizes the g - r phase .
on the other hand , in the runaway phase @xmath160 = \ln ( 1-\epsilon ) , \ ] ] indicating that the stress distribution is highly organized in that phase . for discrete @xmath8
the stress distribution is approximated by a histogram of the stress values , and the integral is replaced by the sum over all bins of the histogram .
the time evolution of the configurational entropy of the stress distribution , calculated with a 10 bin histogram , is depicted in fig .
[ figtimeseries ] along with event sizes .
it is clear that @xmath161 can be used as an `` order parameter '' , a number that distinguishes the g - r phase and the runaway phase , with the advantage that it can be determined at any instant .
histograms of event sizes require a finite time interval to collect , and there is always the danger of mixing events from one phase with the other , thereby confusing the picture : the cumulative event size distribution over many persistence times is a weighted average of two entirely different event distributions , which obscures the underlying physical phenomena .
@xmath162 provides a reliable way to separate the two phases and makes it possible to accumulate accurate event size distributions for both of them .
unfortunately , such a quantity can not be determined from existing field data since the spatial distribution of stress is unknown .
so far , the discussion has centered around the @xmath163 limit , and the main role played by the heterogeneities has been the `` randomization '' of the stress distribution at time scales over which all cells fail a few times .
the distribution of loading times , over which the cells are loaded from the individual arrest stress to the failure stress , has a mean @xmath164 and standard deviation of order @xmath165 .
therefore , the randomization " time , over which the stress variables @xmath166 become roughly uncorrelated , is of order @xmath167 .
thus , even for small @xmath45 , for large enough @xmath8 this will be small compared to the persistence times , which scale exponentially in n [ see eqs.([timefr ] ) and ( [ timerf ] ) ] .
this ensures the consistency of the assumption that the earthquakes are basically statistically independent of each other .
the validity of this assumption of statistical independence can be explicitly verified by examining the time correlations of event sizes numerically ; indeed no trace of any correlation was found in our simulations , out to many times the randomization time @xmath168 .
likewise , we have explicitly checked that in the runaway phase , the particular realizations of stress distributions immediately following a large event are statistically independent of each other@xcite . for finite values of @xmath169
we expect most of the features to remain qualitatively unchanged : in the g - r phase , the exponential cutoff size still diverges as @xmath170 and although @xmath171 in general depends on @xmath45 and the shape of @xmath172 there is still a persistent runaway phase for @xmath173 however , the situation is likely to change qualitatively once arrest stresses can be arbitrarily close to failure stresses , i.e. @xmath174 _ and _ new values for the arrest stresses are picked every time a cell fails@xcite .
this corresponds to the situation discussed in ref.@xcite for finite - dimensional systems . immediately upon introduction of dynamical weakening @xmath175 , @xmath176
when @xmath47 approaches @xmath177 i.e. the cutoff size no longer diverges .
furthermore , for @xmath178 the g - r phase is no longer persistent since the persistence time @xmath124 remains finite for large @xmath179 some of the results presented for the mean - field model , especially the qualitative phase diagram , calculated exponents for the power law earthquake distributions , and the divergence of the cutoff length scale , can be expected to apply to models with realistic interactions , up to logarithmic corrections .
such is because the underlying critical points that control these exponents remain mean - field - like down to @xmath50 dimensional faults .
this result is firmly established for the @xmath180 case@xcite . at finite @xmath0
one expects the nucleation size for the runaway phase , which equals @xmath117 in mean field theory , to become independent of the system size , since elastic forces in the fault plane concentrate stresses along the earthquake rupture front as the earthquake progresses .
earthquakes bigger than a finite nucleation size @xmath181 become unstoppable in the presence of dynamic weakening effects and small disorder@xcite , and rupture the entire fault .
nevertheless , for @xmath182 the mean - field scaling results may still apply at finite @xmath0 , provided that @xmath169 i.e. , there is a finite minimum stress drop associated with each cell failure . for systems with @xmath183 this range will extend all the way to the fault size . in this case , one remarkable consequence is that since generically @xmath184@xcite , the cutoff size in the g - r phase @xmath116 @xmath185 i.e. , earthquakes on individual fault zones obey power law statistics for events up to a finite fraction of the entire system size .
an important result is the possibility that a fault system might switch from a `` gutenberg - richter '' earthquake distribution spontaneously to a `` characteristic '' earthquake distribution , as in the mean - field model .
we note that calculations based on an entirely different model , simulating the coupled evolution of regional earthquakes and faults in a rheologically layered @xmath186 solid@xcite , show similar behavior .
clear observation of such mode switching in nature requires data sets spanning many thousands of years .
paleoseismic studies attempt to construct long histories of seismic events at given locations from sequences of displaces and highly disturbed rock layers .
remarkably , the longest available paleoseismic records , documenting large earthquake activity along the dead sea transform in israel@xcite appear to be characterized by alternating phases of intense seismic activity lasting a few thousands of years , and periods of comparable length without large seismic events .
other , qualitatively similar alternating deformation phases have been documented in the eastern ca shear zone@xcite and the great basin province in the western us@xcite .
another intriguing possibility might arise in a fault system of weakly coupled segments driven under similar conditions .
the seismic response of such systems might exhibit a sort of `` coexistence '' , i.e. , a fraction of the patches might follow characteristic scaling whereas the others obey gutenberg - richter scaling , giving rise to a hybrid event size distribution .
this may explain examples in the data of reference@xcite , where the characteristic `` bump '' in the distribution was not very pronounced .
finally , we note that part or all of the low magnitude seismicity in the g - r phase may be too small to be detected by a seismic network . in this case the spontaneous switching between the runaway and g - r phases may be interpreted as transitions from seismic response of a fault system to creep - like behavior .
we have greatly benefited from extensive discussions with daniel s. fisher , jim rice , and sharad ramanathan .
kd gratefully acknowledges support from the society of fellows of harvard university , and nsf via dmr 9106237 , 9630064 , harvard s mrsec and harvard s milton fund .
de acknowledges support by the nsf through grants no .
dmr-9106237 , no .
dmr-9417047 , and no .
ybz was supported by the southern california earthquake center ( based on nsf cooperative agreement ear-8920136 and usfs cooperative agreement 14 - 08 - 0001-a0899 ) .
b. gutenberg , and c.f .
richter , _ ann .
geophys . _
* 9 * , 1 ( 1956 ) .
the development and dynamics of fault systems has been studied as a non - equilibrium critical phenomenon by e.g. : k. chen , p. bak , and s.p .
obukhov , _ phys .
a _ * 43 * , 625 ( 1991 ) ; p. miltenberger , d. sornette and c. vanneste , _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 71 * , 3604 ( 1993 ) ; p. a. couie , c. vanneste , and d. sornette , _ j. geophys .
* 98 * , 21 809 ( 1993 ) .
burridge and knoppoff , _ bull .
am _ * 57 * , 341 ( 1967 ) ; j.m .
carlson , j.s .
langer , b.e .
shaw , _ rev .
phys . _ * 66 * , 658 , 1994 , and references therein ; c.r .
myers , b.e .
shaw , j.s .
langer , _ phys . rev
* 77 * , 972 ( 1996 ) ; j.b .
rundle , w. klein , s. gross _ phys .
lett . _ * 76 * 4285 ( 1996 ) ; d. cule , t. hwa _ phys .
lett . _ * 77 * , 278 ( 1996 ) .
note that cell stresses do not necessarily get arrested at @xmath22 during an earthquake ; which would have required the slip amount to be @xmath187 instead .
we use eqs.([eqfailure ] ) in order to mimic continuous time .
this choice also makes the model abelian , i.e. whether a given cell will fail during an earthquake does not depend on which order they fail , simplifying the analysis .
the estimate for the persistence time does not take into account possible two or many step channels to nucleate from one phase into the other .
such corrections , however , are not expected to change the exponential dependence of the persistence time on the system size , _
i.e. _ the metastability of the two phases in the considered parameter regime . for larger disorder @xmath45
there are yet another kind of background events .
their number is proportional to @xmath8 . in the regime
considered here ( small @xmath45 , and moderate @xmath8 ) , however , those effects are negligible , as is also confirmed by our simulation results .
one exception to the statistical independence of events happens during the breakup of the runaway stress distribution , where atypically large ( for the g - r phase ) earthquakes occur within a few @xmath189 of the initiation of breakup .
these events should not be included in an analysis of the event size distributions , since they are simply transients and not representative of events in steady - state .
the nature of the heterogeneities in our model differs significantly from those considered in ref.@xcite , in that they are _ long - range _ in the displacements @xmath190 , although short - range in position .
this is the physically relevant situation when typical slips of a cell are smaller than the linear cell size , so that substantially , same portions of the the two plates face each other before and after a slip . in reference ,
the heterogeneities evolve as a function of the deformation in a damage rheology model . | the statistics of earthquakes in a heterogeneous fault zone is studied analytically and numerically in a mean field version of a model for a segmented fault system in a three - dimensional elastic solid@xcite .
the studies focus on the interplay between the roles of disorder , dynamical effects , and driving mechanisms .
a two - parameter phase diagram is found , spanned by the amplitude of dynamical weakening ( or `` overshoot '' ) effects @xmath0 and the normal distance @xmath1 of the driving forces from the fault . in general , small @xmath0 and small @xmath1
are found to produce gutenberg - richter type power law statistics with an exponential cutoff , while large @xmath0 and large @xmath1 lead to a distribution of small events combined with characteristic system - size events . in a certain parameter regime
the behavior is bistable , with transitions back and forth from one phase to the other on time scales determined by the fault size and other model parameters .
the implications for realistic earthquake statistics are discussed . |
the study of non - bps objects such as non - bps branes , brane - antibrane configurations and spacelike branes has recently attracted great attention given its implications for string / m - theory and cosmology . the tachyon field associated with unstable d - branes ,
might be responsible for cosmological inflation at early epochs due to tachyon condensation near the top of the effective potential @xcite , and could contribute to some new form of cosmological dark matter at late times @xcite .
several authors have investigated the process of rolling of the tachyon in the cosmological background @xcite . in the slow roll limit in frw cosmology , the exact solution of tachyonic inflation with exponential potential is found @xcite .
a question which has not yet been addressed in the literature on tachyonic inflation is the issue of constraints on the phase space of initial conditions for inflation which arise when one takes into account the fact that in the context of cosmology the momenta of the tachyon field can not be neglected in the early universe . for models of the type of chaotic inflation
, the work of @xcite shows that most of the energetically accessible field value space give rise to a sufficiently long period of slow roll inflation .
however , for models of the type of new inflation , allowing for non - vanishing initial field momenta may dramatically reduce the phase space of initial conditions for which successful inflation results , and the attractor is the slow rolling solution @xcite . in this paper
we investigate the constrains on the initial conditions of inflation with tachyon rolling down an exponential potential in phase space required for successful inflation .
we demonstrate the attractor behaviour of the tachyonic inflation using the hamilton - jacobi formalism .
we else use an explicitly numerical computation of the phase space trajectories and obtain analytical approximations to the trajectories of the tachyon in different regions .
we find that in phase space there exists a curve that attracts most of the solutions .
according to sen @xcite , the effective action of the tachyon field in the born - infeld form can be written as @xmath0 where t is the tachyon field minimally coupled to gravity .
the rolling tachyon in a spatially flat frw cosmological model can be described by a fluid with a positive energy density @xmath1 and a negative pressure @xmath2 given by @xmath3 thus @xmath4 note that @xmath5 , and a universe dominated by this rolling tachyonic matter will smoothly evolve from a phase of accelerating expansion to a phase dominated by a non - relativistic fluid @xcite .
the evolution equation of the tachyon field minimally coupled to gravity , and the friedmann equation are @xmath6 where @xmath7 denotes the velocity of tachyon .
a universe dominated by tachyon field would go under accelerating expansion as long as @xmath8 which is very different from the condition of inflation for non - tachyonic field , @xmath9 .
the tachyon potential @xmath10 as @xmath11 , but its exact form is not known at present @xcite .
sen has argued that the qualitative dynamics of string theory tachyons can be described by ( [ e1 ] ) with the exponential potential @xcite @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the tachyon mass .
the cosmological aspects of rolling tachyon with exponential potential are investigated @xcite . in what follows we will consider ( [ e1 ] ) with exponential potential in purely phenomenological context without claiming any identification of @xmath14 with the string tachyon field .
the hamilton - jacobi formulation @xcite is a powerful way of rewriting the equations of motion , which allows an easier derivation of many inflation results .
we concentrate here on the homogeneous situation as applied to spatially flat cosmologies , and demonstrate the attractor behaviour of the tachyonic inflation using the hamilton - jacobi formalism @xcite . differentiating eq.([5f ] ) with respect to @xmath15 and substituting in eq.([4 t ] )
gives @xmath16 where primes denote derivatives with respect to the tachyon field @xmath14 , which gives the relation between @xmath14 and @xmath15 .
this allows us to write the friedmann equation in the first - order form @xmath17 ^ 2-\frac{9}{4}h^4(t)=-\frac{\kappa ^4}{4}v^2(t)\ ] ] eq.([hj ] ) is the hamilton - jacobi equation .
it allows us to consider @xmath18 , rather than @xmath19 , as the fundamental quantity to be specified .
suppose @xmath20 is any solution to eq.([hj ] ) , which can be either inflationary or non - inflationary .
add to this a linear homogeneous perturbation @xmath21 ; the attractor condition will be satisfied if it becomes small as @xmath14 increases . substituting @xmath22 into eq.([hj ] ) and linearizing , we find that the perturbation obeys @xmath23 which has the general solution @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the value at some initial point @xmath26 .
because @xmath27 and @xmath28 have opposing signs , the integrand within the exponential term is negative definite , and hence all linear perturbations do indeed die away . if there is an inflationary solution , all linear perturbations approach it at least exponentially fast as the tachyon field rolls .
we choose different initial conditions @xmath14 , in the range @xmath29 , and @xmath30 in the range @xmath31 and we obtain the phase portrait in the @xmath32 plane . figure 1 shows that there exists a curve that attracts most of the trajectories , in the @xmath33 plane where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are dimensionless coordinates .
the initial kinetic term decays rapidly and does not prevent the onset of inflation .
= 6.6 cm the behavior of the trajectories can be also analyzed analytically . to understand the evolution of the tachyon field we define two regions @xmath2 and @xmath36 in the @xmath32 plane as indicated in figure 2 .
the region @xmath2 is the region where the potential dominates over the energy density , and the region @xmath36 is the region where the kinetic energy dominates .
= 5.7 cm * curve @xmath37 .
* this curve describes the slow rolling solution where the evolution eq .
( [ 4 t ] ) and the friedman eq.([5f ] ) in expanding universe can be approximated by @xmath38 from which it follows that @xmath39 where @xmath40 .
the expression for the number @xmath41 of e - foldings of inflation can be written as @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the value of the field at the point where it reaches curve @xmath37 and @xmath44 is the value of the field at the end of the slow rolling phase . in order to obtain enough e - foldings of slow roll inflation the value of @xmath43 for such a trajectory must satisfy @xmath45 where @xmath46 is calculated from eq.([en ] ) with @xmath47 .
* region @xmath2 . * in this region
, the potential dominates over the energy density .
the potential force @xmath48 is negligible compared to the friction term since the friction coefficient is proportional to the potential .
the evolution eq.([4 t ] ) and friedman eq.([5f ] ) are approximately @xmath49 so that @xmath50}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath51 and @xmath52 are the values at the boundary between region @xmath2 and region @xmath36 .
let us now denote by @xmath43 and @xmath53 the values of the inflaton and its momentum when the trajectory reaches the slow roll curve .
@xmath54}\ ] ] where we have neglected @xmath53 since it is exponentially smaller than @xmath52 . in general the unconventional forms of the tachyonic energy density and pressure make the cosmology with tachyon field differ from that with a normal scalar field , and make it difficult to separate kinetic term from potential term .
we assume that @xmath19 and @xmath55 are regarded as potential and kinetic term respectively .
therefore , the boundary value between region @xmath2 and region @xmath56 is @xmath57 .
so @xmath58}\ ] ] to lead to sufficient inflation , from ( [ tb ] ) such initial conditions must satisfy @xmath59}<t_b^{60}\ ] ] * region @xmath36 .
* it is the region of kinetic energy domination where @xmath48 is negligible compared to the friction term and ( [ 4 t ] ) and ( [ 5f ] ) become @xmath60 these can be integrated and we find : @xmath61 @xmath62}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath63 is gauss hypergeometric function .
to demonstrate the attractor behaviour of the tachyonic inflation , we use the hamilton - jacobi formalism , which greatly simplifies the analysis . adding to any solution to eq.([hj ] ) a linear homogeneous perturbation
, we find the perturbation die away exponentially .
the attractor behaviour indicates that , regardless of initial conditions , the late - time solutions are the same up to a time shift , which can not be measured @xcite .
we else use an explicitly numerical computation of the phase space trajectories and obtain analytical approximations to the trajectories of the tachyon in different regions .
one can easily verify from figure 1 and figure 2 that these approximations are in very good agreement with the numerical results , and that the slow rolling solution is the late - time attractor .
although the initial kinetic term decays rapidly and does not prevent the onset of inflation , allowing for non - vanishing initial field momenta around @xmath64 may dramatically reduce the phase space of initial conditions for which successful inflation results . according to the picture of tachyonic inflation , the homogeneous tachyon field near the top of the potential rolls down towards the minimum of the potential at @xmath11 .
tachyonic matter behaves at late time as a pressureless gas of massive particles . in most versions of the theory of reheating
, production of particles occurs only when the inflaton field oscillates near the minimum of its effective potential .
however , the effective potential of the rolling tachyon does not have any minimum at finite @xmath14 , so this mechanism does not work .
it is unclear how the universe could be reheated in the framework of tachyon cosmology .
recently , some studies pointed out that as the tachyon evolves into the late - time , the coupling to the closed string becomes more and more large @xcite .
these results motivate us to expect that the tachyon could emit closed string radiation @xcite , such as graviton and dilation , into the bulk and eventually settles in the finite minimum .
it is a pleasure to acknowledge helpful discussions with g.n.felder and r.s.tung .
this project was in part supported by nnsfc under grant nos .
10175070 and 10047004 as well as also by nkbrsf g19990754 . 99 d.choudhury , d.ghoshal , d.p.jatkar and s.panda , hep - th/0204204 ; + m.fairbairn and m.h.tytgat , hep - th/0204070 .
a.sen , hep - th/0203211 ; + a.sen , hep - th/0203265 .
g.w.gibbons , hep - th/0204008 . g.shiu and i.wasserman , hep - th/0205003 ; + a.frolove , l.kofman and a.starobinsky , hep - th/0204187 ; + l.kofman and a.linde , hep - th/0205121 ; + m.c.bento , o.bertolami and a.a.sen , hep - th/0208124 ; + a.mazumdar , s.panda and a.perez-lorenzana , nucl.phys . *
b614 * ( 2001 ) 101 , hep - ph/0107058 ; + y.piao , r.cai , x.zhang and y.zhang , hep - ph/0207143 ; + y.piao , q.huang , x.zhang and y.zhang , hep - ph/0212219 .
m.sami , p.chingangbam and t.qureshi , hep - th/0205179 ; + m.sami , hep - th/0301140 .
h.a.feldman and r.h.brandenberger , phys.lett .
* b227 * ( 1989 ) 359 ; + g.n.felder , a.frolov , l.kofman and a.linde , phys.rev . *
d66 * ( 2002 ) 023507 .
d.s.goldwirth , phys.lett . *
b243 * ( 1990 ) 41 ; + d.s.goldwirth and t.piran , phys.rept .
* 214 * ( 1992 ) 214 .
a.a.gerasimov , s.l.shatashvili , jhep * 0010 * ( 2000 ) 034 , hep - th/0009103 ; + a.minahan and b.zwiebach , jhep * 0103 * ( 2001 ) 038 , hep - th/0009246 ; + d.kutasov , a.tseytlin , j.math.phys .
* 42 * ( 2001 ) 2854 .
a.sen , hep - th/0204143 .
d.s.salopek and j.r.bond , phys.rev .
* d42 * ( 1990 ) 3936 ; + a.g.muslimov , class.quant.grav .
* 7 * ( 1990 ) 231 ; + j.e.lidsey , phys.lett .
* b273 * ( 1991 ) 42 .
a.r.liddle , p.parsons and j.d.barrow , phys.rev .
* d50 * ( 1994 ) 7222 , + astro - ph/9408015 ; + a.r.liddle and d.h.lyth , _
cosmological inflation and large - scale structure _ , ( 2000 ) cambridge , uk .
a.r.liddle , a.mazumdar and f.e.schunck , phys.rev .
* d58 * ( 1998 ) 061301 , astro - ph/9804177 ; + e.j.copeland , a.mazumdar and n.j.nunes , phys.rev . *
d60 * ( 1999 ) 083506 , astro - ph/9904309 .
g.gibbons , k.hashimoto and p.yi , jhep * 0209 * ( 2002 ) 061 , hep - th/0209034 ; + t.okuda and s.sugimoto , hep - th/0208196 ; + n.d.lambert and i.sachs , hep - th/0208217 .
m.gutperle and a.strominger , jhep * 0204 * ( 2002 ) 018 , hep - th/0202210 ; + h.liu , g.moore and n.seiberg , jhep * 0210 * ( 2002 ) 031 , hep - th/0206182 ; + p.mukhopadhyay and a.sen , hep - th/0208142 ; + a.strominger , hep - th/0209090 ; + b.chen , m.li and f.l.lin , hep - th/0209222 .
k.ohta and t.yokono , hep - th/0207004 ; + s.mukohyama , hep - th/0208187 ; + m.alishahiha and s.parvizi , jhep * 0210 * ( 2002 ) 047 , hep - th/0208187 ; + g.dvali and a.vilenkin , hep - th/0209217 ; + e.j.martinec , hep - th/0210231 . | we study the complete evolution of a flat and homogeneous universe dominated by tachyonic matter .
we demonstrate the attractor behaviour of the tachyonic inflation using the hamilton - jacobi formalism .
we else obtain analytical approximations to the trajectories of the tachyon field in different regions .
the numerical calculation shows that an initial non - vanishing momentum does not prevent the onset of inflation .
the slow - rolling solution is an attractor . |
we are grateful to dr .
d. divincenzo for some helpful comments on the manuscript .
financial support for this research has been provided by the national science foundation through grant phy-9220726 .
11 p. w. shor , in _ proceedings of the 35th annual symposium on foundations of computer science , santa fe , 1994 _ , edited by s. goldwasser ( ieee computer society press , los alamitos , california , 1994 ) , p. 124 .
w. shor , preprint ( quant - ph/9508027 ) , submitted to siam j. computing .
d. deutsch , proc .
london , ser .
a * 400 * , 97 ( 1985 ) ; proc .
london , ser .
a * 425 * , 73 ( 1989 ) c. h. bennett , phys . today * 48 * , 24 ( oct . 1995 ) .
d. p. divincenzo , science * 270 * , 255 ( 1995 ) .
s. lloyd , sci . am . oct .
1995 , 140 ( 1995 ) .
s. lloyd , science * 261 * , 1569 ( 1993 ) .
a. barenco , d. deutsch , a. ekert and r. jozsa phys .
lett . * 74 * , 4083 ( 1995 ) .
t. sleator and h. weinfurter , phys .
rev . lett . * 74 * , 4087 ( 1995 ) .
j. i. cirac and p. zoller , phys .
. lett . * 74 * , 4091 ( 1995 ) .
i. l. chuang and y. yamamoto , preprint ( quant - ph/9505011 ) .
d. p. divincenzo , phys .
a * 51 * , 1015 ( 1995 ) .
d. deutsch , a. barenco and a ekert , proc .
a * 449 * , 669 ( 1995 ) .
s. lloyd , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 346 ( 1995 ) .
a. barenco et al .
a * 52 * , 3457 ( 1995 ) . using the result of a classical measurement to determine
a subsequent unitary transformation on a quantum system has been proposed in connection with teleportation ; see c. h. bennett et al .
lett . * 70 * , 1895 ( 1993 ) , as pointed out to us by d. divincenzo . or
, if one prefers , a reduced density matrix ; this makes no difference for the following discussion . according to @xcite ,
this scheme was invented independently by d. coppersmith , _ ibm research report rc 19642 _ ( 1994 ) and by d. deutsch ( unpublished ) .
r. b. griffiths , j. stat .
phys . * 36 * , 219 ( 1984 ) .
see , in particular , sec .
r. b. griffiths , in _ new techniques and ideas in quantum measurement theory _ , edited by d. m. greenberger ( new york academy of sciences , new york , 1986 ) p. 512 .
r. omns , rev .
phys . * 64 * , 339 ( 1992 ) .
r. b. griffiths , phys .
* 70 * , 2201 ( 1993 ) .
r. omns , _ the interpretation of quantum mechanics _ ( princeton university press , princeton , 1994 ) .
w. shor , phys .
a * 52 * 2493 ( 1995 ) . for a compact review , see r. b. griffiths , in _
symposium on the foundations of modern physics 1994 _ , edited by k. v. laurikainen , c. montonen and k. sunnarborg ( editions frontires , gif - sur - yvette , france , 1994 ) p. 85 | shor s algorithms for factorization and discrete logarithms on a quantum computer employ fourier transforms preceding a final measurement .
it is shown that such a fourier transform can be carried out in a semi - classical way in which a `` classical '' ( macroscopic ) signal resulting from the measurement of one bit ( embodied in a two - state quantum system ) is employed to determine the type of measurement carried out on the next bit , and so forth . in this way the two - bit gates in the fourier transform
can all be replaced by a smaller number of one - bit gates controlled by classical signals .
success in simplifying the fourier transform suggests that it may be worthwhile looking for other ways of using semi - classical methods in quantum computing .
0 cm 0 cm -2.0 cm 23.5 cm 16.5 cm recently shor @xcite has shown that a quantum computer @xcite , if it could be built , would be capable of solving certain problems , such as factoring long numbers , much more rapidly than is possible using currently available algorithms on a conventional computer .
this has stimulated a lot of interest in the subject @xcite , and various proposals have been made for actually constructing such a computer @xcite .
the basic idea is that bits representing numbers can be embodied in two - state quantum systems , for example , in the spin degree of freedom of a spin half particle , and the computation proceeds by manipulating these bits using appropriate gates .
it turns out that quantum computations can be carried out using circuits employing one - bit gates , which produce a unitary transformation on the two - dimensional hilbert space representing a single bit , together with two - bit gates producing appropriate unitary transformations on a four - dimensional hilbert space @xcite .
one - bit gates should be much easier to construct than two - bit gates , since , for example , an arbitrary unitary transformation on the spin degree of freedom of a spin half particle can be produced by subjecting it to a suitable time - dependent macroscopic magnetic field .
on the other hand , a two - bit gate requires that one of the bits influence the other in a non - trivial way , and this without leaving any record in the environment , since the computer utilizes coherent quantum states . in this letter
we shall show how the quantum fourier transforms which in shor s algorithms immediately precede a final measurement can be carried out in a semi - classical fashion which requires no two - bit gates .
the trick is to measure a particular bit and then use the result to produce a classical signal which controls a one - bit transformation carried out on the next bit just before it is measured , and so forth .
it is of interest for at least three reasons .
first , it represents a completely new ( so far as we know ) technique for quantum computation , in which the results of certain measurements , converted into `` classical '' signals ( imagine a pulse of several volts traveling down a coaxial cable ) , can be used to influence a later step in the computation @xcite .
second , computing the fourier transform is considerably simplified in the sense that it requires no two - bit gates .
third , a simple way of seeing why the semi - classical method actually works is to adopt a point of view in technical terms , a particular family of consistent histories in which the results of a measurement are used to infer the state of a quantum system before the measurement was carried out .
this perspective may prove useful in thinking about other issues in quantum computing , quantum optics , and quantum effects in atomic physics .
since shor has described his algorithms in considerable detail in his publications @xcite , we shall not discuss them here .
it will be sufficient to note that after a certain number of steps of the quantum computation have been carried out , the relevant quantum state @xmath0 is a coherent superposition @xcite of different states @xmath1 labeled by an integer @xmath2 between 0 and @xmath3 , where @xmath4 .
the state @xmath0 is then subjected to a unitary transformation @xmath5 , a sort of discrete fourier transform , which carries each basis state @xmath1 of the @xmath6-dimensional hilbert space into @xmath7 this is followed by a measurement of the integer @xmath8 , that is , a measurement of each of its @xmath9 bits .
a set of gates which carries out this fourier transform @xcite is shown in fig . 1 for @xmath10 .
the bits to be transformed enter from the left .
one can imagine that they are spin 1/2 particles , with the results of the preceding computation embodied ( as a coherent superposition ) in their collective spin degrees of freedom .
these particles then move through a series of gates , indicated by circles , and eventually arrive at measuring devices , shown as squares , where a particular component of spin , say @xmath11 , is measured by a stern - gerlach device , with @xmath12 in units of @xmath13 interpreted as the bit @xmath14 , and @xmath15 as the bit @xmath16 . if the binary representation of the number @xmath2 is @xmath17 with each @xmath18 zero or one , the state @xmath1 can be conveniently written as a tensor product @xmath19 using the same notation for @xmath20 , we can rewrite ( [ e.1 ] ) in the form @xmath21 where the state @xmath22 will be said to have a _ phase _
@xmath23 between 0 and 1 .
the phases @xmath24 in ( [ e.4 ] ) take the values : @xmath25 in terms of our picture of a spin half particle , @xmath26 represents a spin component of @xmath27 in a direction in the @xmath28 plane determined by @xmath23 . the one - bit gates in the top row of fig . 1
transform the bit entering on the left to one leaving on the right through : @xmath29 ( in a spin picture , the spin is rotated by @xmath30 about the @xmath31 axis . )
the two bit gate labeled with an integer @xmath32 converts the bits entering on the left into those leaving on the right according to the scheme : @xmath33|11\rg .
\end{array } \label{e.8}\ ] ] here we use the convention that the left element in each ket @xmath34 in ( [ e.8 ] ) is the bit which in fig .
1 enters the two - bit gate at a point marked by a black dot and also leaves at a black dot , while the right element in each ket denotes the bit which enters and leaves the gate at a point labeled by a circle .
it is helpful to think of ( [ e.8 ] ) as a transformation in which one bit acts as a `` control '' which enters and leaves the gate as a zero or one , while the other `` target '' bit enters as @xmath26 and undergoes a phase shift , so that it leaves as @xmath35 , where @xmath36 . from this perspective
it is easy to see how the network in fig .
1 produces the desired result .
suppose that the bit @xmath37 enters the left - most one - bit gate in fig . 1 in the state @xmath16 .
it emerges at the point @xmath38 in the state @xmath39 .
as it passes downwards through the successive two bit gates its phase is shifted by the bits @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 , acting as control bits , by an amount @xmath43 if , on the other hand , @xmath37 arrives as @xmath14 , the one - bit gate converts it to @xmath44 , so that the bit which emerges as @xmath45 has a phase @xmath46 , in agreement with ( [ e.6 ] ) .
the same sort of analysis can be applied to the rest of the circuit .
however , one can equally well regard the bits entering and leaving the gates through the black dots in fig . 1 as the control bits , and it is this point of view which is useful for constructing the semiclassical fourier transform .
suppose that the final measurement reveals that the bit @xmath45 is 1 , corresponding to @xmath14 .
then , since a control bit enters and leaves the two - bit gates unchanged , we conclude that this bit was also in the state @xmath14 at point @xmath38 , just after emerging from the first one - bit gate . similarly ,
if the measurement yields @xmath47 , we conclude that the bit was in the state @xmath16 at the point @xmath38 .
hence the circuit would work equally well if the measurement on this bit were actually carried out at the point @xmath38 in fig . 1
, were it not for the fact that this bit is also needed in order to influence @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 , now regarded as target bits , as they pass through the two - bit gates controlled by @xmath45 . however , if @xmath45 is measured at @xmath38 and the result is converted to a classical signal , this signal can be used to determine the action of a corresponding set of one - bit gates acting upon @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 . applying this type of analysis to the other parts of fig . 1 ,
one is led to the arrangement shown in fig
. 2 , where all the two bit gates in fig . 1 have been eliminated , and their work taken over by one - bit gates controlled by classical signals ( double lines ) and followed by measurements .
each of the boxes in fig .
2 performs the following operations .
the incoming bit is first subjected to a unitary transformation , equivalent to a phase shift followed by ( [ e.7 ] ) : @xmath48 where @xmath23 is the phase transmitted as a classical signal from the previous box .
the bit is then measured to yield the result @xmath49 or @xmath50 . the outputs are two classical signals represented by double lines : one is the result of the measurement , and the other represents a phase @xmath51 which is sent to the next box .
the very first box uses @xmath52 in ( [ e.10 ] ) .
readers unfamiliar with the rules which allow one to use the results of a measurement to infer the state of a quantum system prior to the measurement are referred to the relevant literature @xcite .
the basic idea is that one can add to a quantum history , consisting of an initial state and the result of a measurement , a projector , for example @xmath53 representing property of the quantum system at a time just prior to the measurement .
the conditional probability of @xmath54 is one , given that the measurement yields @xmath55 .
but in the situation shown in fig . 1 , @xmath54 commutes with the unitary transformations corresponding to the three 2-bit gates which precede the measurement of @xmath45 , and therefore one can `` push '' the corresponding property backwards in time to the point @xmath38 in fig . 1 , and again conclude that it occurred with probability one .
anyone who feels uncomfortable with this method of reasoning can , of course , use traditional techniques to verify that the arrangement in fig .
2 will yield the same probability to observe a number @xmath8 as that in fig . 1 .
( note that it is necessary to check this for an initial state @xmath0 which is an arbitrary linear combination of the different @xmath1 states . )
the scheme in fig . 2 should be quite a bit simpler to realize than that in fig . 1 , because it only requires one - bit operations controlled by classical signals rather than the more difficult and more numerous two - bit operations indicated in fig . 1
however , the need to carry out a measurement on one bit before beginning to measure another could be a disadvantage if the physical elements representing the bits are short lived or decohere rapidly on the time scale required to carry out a measurement and convert it into a classical signal . if this turns out to be a problem , a possible remedy might be to arrange the earlier part of the quantum computation in such a way that the more significant bits of @xmath2 are produced earlier than the less significant bits .
an important question is whether other parts of shor s algorithms ( or other applications of quantum computing ) can make use of similar semi - classical operations .
we have no specific proposals , but we think the idea is worth further study .
there are bits other than those entering the final fourier transform which are produced elsewhere in the computation , and it is conceivable that measuring some of these could be used in modify later steps in the calculation , or perhaps for the non - trivial task of correcting errors . in connection with the latter ,
see @xcite .
finally , we note that adopting alternative perspectives or points of view about what is going on in a quantum computation can yield useful insights .
the traditional perspective , represented in almost all work on quantum computing up till now , in which the `` wave function of the computer '' develops unitarily in time until a measurement is made , has demonstrated its value through the work of various people who have brought quantum computation to its current state of development . in this letter
we have shown that an alternative point of view , in which the results of measurements are traced backwards in time , can also be valuable .
the general principles of quantum mechanics allow for a variety of viewpoints or , to use the technical term , consistent families , and recent developments in the foundations of quantum theory @xcite permit one to make effective use of these without becoming entangled in paradoxes , mysterious long - range influences , and the like . |
the gapless energy spectrum of graphene @xcite enables using single- or multiple graphene - layer ( gl ) structures for different terahertz ( thz ) and infrared ( ir ) photodetectors based on involving the interband transitions @xcite ( see , also refs @xcite ) , where different thz and ir photodetectors based on gls were explored ) .
the interband photodetectors use either the gls serving as photoconductors or the lateral p - i - n junctions . in the latter case , the electrons and holes are generated in the depleted i - region and move to the opposite gl contacts driven by the electric field in the depletion region @xcite .
the multiple - gl structures with the lateral p - i - n junctions can consist of either several non - bernal stacked twisted ) gls as in ref .
@xcite or gls separated by the barrier layers such as thin layers of boron nitride ( hbn ) , tungsten disulfide ( ws@xmath2 ) , or similar materials .
such heterostructures have recently attracted a considerable interest and enabled several novel devices being proposed and realized @xcite .
the gl - photodetectors , especially those based on the multiple - gl structures , can combine a high responsivity with a relatively low dark current at elevated temperatures ( up to room temperatures ) .
this is because the dark current in the photodetectors in question is mainly determined by the absorption of the optical phonons .
since the optical phonon energy @xmath3 in gls is rather large ( about 0.2 ev ) , the number of optical phonons is small even at the room temperature .
this results in a low thermal generation rate .
the mechanisms of the thermal generation associated with the absorption of the acoustic phonons and the auger processes are forbidden due to the features of the gl energy spectrum .
however , the interband tunneling in strong lateral electric fields in the i - region can lead to an enhanced generation of the electron - hole pairs and an elevated dark current limiting the photodetector detectivity @xcite .
effective thz detection can be achieved in the lateral diodes with the absorbing gl source and drain sections separated by an array of grapnene nanoribbons ( gnrs ) , which form the potential barriers for hot electrons injected from the source to the drain @xcite .
as shown in this paper , an effective thz detection can be achieved in the photodetectors based on double - gl and cascade multiple - gl structures with the vertical transport of hot electrons over the barrier layers .
we propose and evaluate such thz detectors operating in the regime of the thermionic emission of hot electrons from gls and their vertical transport over the barrier layers .
the advantages of the thz detectors under consideration include high responsivity and detectivity in a wide spectral range at room temperature and a relatively high - speed operation .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we discuss the device structures under consideration and the gld operation principle . section iii deals with general formulas for the dark current and photocurrent associated with the thermionic emission of electrons from gl and controlled by their capture into gls . in sec .
iv , we calculate the variations of the electron temperature in gls cause by the intraband ( drude ) absorption of the incident thz radiation . in sections
v and vi , using the formulas obtained in sections iii and iv , we derive the expressions for the gld responsivity and dark - current - limited detectivity , respectively . in sec .
vii , we discuss how the electron capture in the gls affects the gld responsivity and detectivity . in sec .
viii , we consider the possibility to use the plasmonic resonances and get an enhanced response at elevated frequencies .
section ix deals with the analysis of the limitations of our model . in sec .
x we evaluate the gld operation in the ir spectral range and compare glds with some other photodetectors . in conclusions , we summarize the main results of the paper .
the appendix deals with the heat removal problem ) .
, width=188 ]
we consider two types of the glds : ( a ) based on the n - doped double - gl structure and ( b ) n - doped multiple - gl structure with the gls separated by the barrier layers made of ws@xmath2 or similar material with a relatively small conduction band off - set . as an example , fig .
1 shows a gld using a four - gl structure .
the double - glds consist of only the top and bottom gls serving as the emitter and collector , respectively ( no inner gls ) . in the multiple - glds , the inner gls clad by the emitter and collector gls are disconnected from the contacts . in the double - glds ( with a single barrier ) ,
the bias voltage @xmath4 applied between the top and bottom gls induces the negative electron charge in the emitter gl the equal positive charge in the collector gl .
if the equilibrium electron concentration is low and the bias voltage is sufficiently strong , the hole gas will be formed in the collector gl . in glds with multiple - gl structures ,
the inner gls remain quasi - neutral , so that the electron gas in each gl is formed primarily due the n - type doping , whereas the top and bottom gls can be charged due to the bias voltage .
figure 2 shows the glpd band diagrams under the bias .
it is assumed that the glds under consideration are irradiated by the normally incident thz photons with the energy @xmath5 .
the operation of glds is associated with the electron heating due to the intraband absorption ( drude absorption ) and the interband absorption ( see , for example , @xcite ) of the incident radiation resulting in an increase of the thermionic current over the barrier layers .
thus , the proposed glds are the barrier hot - electron bolometers . in glds with the double - gl structures , the electrons entering from the emitter gl and exiting to the collector gl support the lateral current flowing via the contacts , so that the carrier densities in the gls are maintained . in the multiple - gl structures , the electron density in each gl between the emitter and collector gls is maintained due to the balance between the electrons leaving and entering gls via the adjacent barriers due to the thermal emission and the capture processes . if the probability of the capture of an electron crossing a gl is smaller than unity , the gld operation can exhibit the effect of photoelectric gain .
the origin of this gain is of the same nature as in the vertical quantum - well infrared photodetectors ( qwips ) @xcite .
the donor density @xmath6 and the bias voltage @xmath4 determine the electron fermi energies @xmath7 and @xmath8 in the top ( emitter ) and bottom ( collector ) gls , respectively , ( @xmath9 , because the bias voltage increases the electron density in the emitting gl and decreases it in the collecting gl ) .
considering the geometrical and quantum capacitances @xcite and taking into account the energy gap between the dirac points in gls [ see fig .
2(a ) ] in the double - gl structure , at relatively low bias voltages one can obtain : @xmath10 , \
, \mu_c \simeq \mu_i\biggl[1 - \frac{ev}{2(ev_i + \mu_i)}\biggr],\ ] ] @xmath11 here @xmath12 , @xmath13 is the electron charge , @xmath14 is the planck constant , @xmath15 cm / s is the characteristic velocity of electrons and holes in gls , and @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the dielectric constant and the thickness of the barrier , respectively . at @xmath18
@xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 nm , one obtains @xmath22 mev and @xmath23 mv .
relatively large values of @xmath24 imply that for the realistic moderate values of @xmath4 considered in the following , the correction of the fermi energies in the emitter and collector gls is small in comparison with @xmath25 . in the multiple - gl structures ( with a large number of gls and the inter - gl barriers @xmath26 ) , all the gls except the top and bottom one s are quasi - neutral .
although the electrically - induced variation of the fermi energies in the emitter and collector gls can be essential ( for the mechanism of the photoelectric gain ) , we will assume that in all gls , including the top and bottom one s , the fermi energies are close to each other and approximately equal to the value determined by the donor density : @xmath27
we restrict our consideration to the double- and multiple - gl structures with relatively thick inter - gl barriers , so that the tunneling current between the gls can be neglected ( the pertinent calculations can be done using the approach developed in refs .
we assume that the main contribution to the vertical current is due to the thermoemission of electrons resulting in the inter - gl transitions ( producing the dark current ) .
the impinging thz irradiation heats the electron gas in gls .
this leads to an increase in the thermoemission rate intensifying of the inter - gl transitions , and , hence , the vertical current .
the direct electron photoemission is insignificant when the energy of photons @xmath5 is smaller than the gl - barrier conduction band off - set @xmath28 ( the height of the barrier with respect of the dirac point ) . for the gl structures with the ws@xmath2 barriers
@xcite it implies @xmath29 ev .
hence , this inequality is well satisfied for the thz radiation .
the rate of the thermionic emission from a gl ( per unit of its area ) is given by @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the effective electron temperature which ( under the irradiation ) is higher than the lattice temperature @xmath32 ) , @xmath33 is the boltzmann constant , and @xmath34 is the characteristic time of escape from the gls of the electrons with the energy @xmath35 , @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the momentum relaxation time . using eq .
( 4 ) and assuming for simplicity that @xmath38 ( @xmath39 is the voltage drop across the barrier , and taking into account the electrons photoexcited from the emitter and the photoexcited from and captured to the internal gls ( in multiple - glds ) , we find the thermionic current density , @xmath40 : @xmath41 @xmath42 here @xmath43 is the probability of the capture of an electron crossing a gl . in the gl structures with at least one internal gl ( and in the multiple - gl structures ) , the effects of the balance of thermogeneration from and capture to each gl , are taken into account by introducing the capture probability @xmath43 , as in the standard models of qwips @xcite . in such an approach ,
the rate of the electron capture into each gl is equal to @xmath44 . equating the capture rate @xmath44 and the thermogeneration rate @xmath45
, one obtains @xmath46 [ eq .
the quantity @xmath47 can be relatively large if the capture probability is small .
this quantity essentially determines the dark current and photocurrent gain @xmath48 .
equation ( 5 ) yields the following formula for the current density @xmath49 without irradiation ( i.e. , for the dark current ) when the dark electron temperature @xmath31 is equal to the lattice temperature @xmath50 : @xmath51 in the double - glds all the electrons generated by the emitter gl are captured by the collector gl , so that in such a case @xmath52 . considering the variation of the electron temperature @xmath53
, the photocurrent density @xmath54 can be presented as @xmath55
as previously @xcite , we assume that the electron energy relaxation is associated with the processes of the emission and absorption of optical phonons . in this case , for the rate , @xmath56 , of the energy transfer from the electron system to the optical phonon system is determined by ( see , for example , @xcite ) : @xmath57\ ] ] here @xmath3 and @xmath58 are the energy and the number of optical phonons , respectively , @xmath59 is the characteristics time of the optical phonon spontaneous emission for the electron energy @xmath60 .
if the characteristic time of the optical phonons decay @xmath61 , @xmath58 is close to its equilibrium value : @xmath62^{-1 } \simeq \exp(- \hbar\omega_0/k_bt_0)$ ] . in the case of @xmath63 ,
the effective energy relaxation time @xmath59 should be replaced by @xmath64 ( where @xmath65 ) @xcite .
when the effective electron temperature in gls deviates from its equilibrium value ( due to the absorption of thz radiation ) , the energy relaxation rate can be presented as [ see eq .
( 8) ] @xmath66 the rate of the energy transfer from the electron system to the optical phonon system @xmath56 is equal to the rate , @xmath67 , of the energy transferred from the thz radiation to the electron system : @xmath68 considering the intraband , i.e. , the so - called free electron absorption ( the drude absorption ) and the interband absorption , the net absorption rate can approximately be presented as @xmath69 @xmath70.\ ] ] here @xmath71 , @xmath72 is the speed of light in vacuum , @xmath73 is the thz photon flux entering into the device ( or the incident photon flux in the case of the anti - reflection coating ) , and @xmath74 \simeq \frac{4\mu_i\tau}{\pi\hbar}\ ] ] is the drude weight , the factor determining the contribution of the drude absorption ( it is proportional for the real part of the intraband conductivity of gls ) . for the realistic values of @xmath37 , the factor @xmath75 can markedly exceed unity . indeed , assuming @xmath76 mev and @xmath77 s , one obtains @xmath78 . strictly speaking , eq .
( 11 ) is valid at not too strong absorption . since the fermi energy in the gld under consideration should be sufficiently large , the processes of the interband absorption of thz photons ( their energy @xmath79 ) , corresponding to the second term in eq . ( 11 )
, are effectively suppressed due to the pauli blocking .
this implies that the electron heating by thz radiation is primarily associated with the intraband absorption ( with the drude or the so - called free - electron absorption ) . in eq . ( 11 ) and in the following equations we disregard the attenuation in the multiple - glds of the thz photon flux associated with the absorption of in gls , which are closer to the irradiated surface ( emitter ) .
this should be valid at not too large values of @xmath80 .
taking into account the energy balance in each gl governed by eq .
( 10 ) and using eq . ( 11 ) ( omitting the term describing the interband absorption ) , we arrive to the following expression for the variation of the effective electron energy caused by the thz of ir radiation of moderate intensity : @xmath81 equation ( 13 ) corresponds to the electron energy relaxation time ( determined by the optical phonons ) , which is equal to @xcite @xmath82
using eqs . ( 6 ) and ( 8) , for the gld responsivity @xmath83 , we obtain @xmath84 @xmath85 using eqs .
( 13 ) and ( 15 ) , we arrive at the following expressions for the responsivity : @xmath86 here @xmath87 as seen from eq .
( 16 ) , the gld responsivity is proportional to an exponential factor . to achieve reasonable gld characteristics
, the fermi energy @xmath25 should not be too small in comparison with the barrier height @xmath28 .
one can also see that @xmath88 . as stated above
, in the glds with the multiple - gl structures , the factor @xmath89 can be fairly large .
equation ( 16 ) describes the gld responsivity as a function of the thz radiation frequency @xmath90 , the temperature @xmath50 and the gl doping ( via the dependence of @xmath25 on @xmath6 ) .
assuming @xmath91 mev , @xmath92 ps , @xmath93 , and @xmath52 for @xmath94 k , from eq .
( 17 ) we obtain from eq .
( 17 ) @xmath95 a / w .
figure 3 shows the gld responsivity versus the photon frequency @xmath96 calculated for different donor densities @xmath6 using eqs .
( 16 ) and ( 17 ) for @xmath97 mev and the same other parameters as in the above estimate .
this corresponds to the glds based on the double - gl structure or to the glds based on the multiple - glds with a strong electron capture in the internal gls .
the responsivity of the latter can be much higher than that shown in fig . 3 if @xmath98 ( see below ) . )
considering that the shot noise current ( at the value of the signal current equal to the dark current ) is given by @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the bandwidth and @xmath101 is the dark current and photoelectric gain , the dark current limited detectivity ( see , for example , ref .
@xcite ) , can be presented in the following form : @xmath102 accounting for eq .
( 16 ) , we arrive at @xmath103 @xmath104 where @xmath105.\ ] ] for @xmath92 ps , @xmath106 , ps , @xmath107 ps , and @xmath94 k , @xmath97 mev , @xmath108 @xmath19 ( @xmath109 mev ) , @xmath110 , and @xmath111 thz from eqs .
( 19 ) and ( 20 ) we obtain @xmath112 cm hz@xmath113/w and @xmath114 cm hz@xmath113/w .
figure 4 shows the spectral characteristics of glds with @xmath115 @xmath19 ( @xmath22 mev ) calculated using eqs .
( 19 ) and ( 20 ) for the same other parameters as from the latter estimate and fig . 3 . from eqs
( 16 ) , ( 17 ) , ( 19 ) , and ( 20 ) , one can see that the gld responsivity is independent on @xmath80 ( in the framework of the present model ) , whereas the gld detectivity is proportional to @xmath116 ( as in qwips @xcite ) .
for different radiation frequencies ( @xmath108 @xmath19 ) . , width=283 ] for glds with different number of the inter - gl barriers @xmath80 ( @xmath117 @xmath19 and @xmath118 thz).,width=283 ] as follows from eqs .
( 16 ) , ( 17 ) , ( 19 ) , and ( 20 ) , both the responsivity and detectivity of the multiple glds increase with decreasing capture probability @xmath43 , i.e. , with increasing photoelectric gain .
the latter quantity is determined by several factors , in particular , by the degree of the electron heating in the inter - gl barriers and , hence , by the potential drop across these barriers and their thickness .
the detailed calculations of @xmath43 require additional quantum - mechanical calculations of the electron transitions from the continuum states above the barriers to the bound states in gls coupled with the ensemble monte carlo modeling of the electron propagation across the gl - structure similar to that made previously for multiple - qw structures based on the standard semiconductor heterostructures ( see , for example , refs .
this is , however , beyond the scope of this work , so that here we consider @xmath119 as a phenomenological parameter .
figures 5 and 6 show the gld responsivity and detectivity as functions of the capture parameter .
one can see that a decrease in the capture parameter @xmath43 leads to a substantial rise of @xmath120 . at low @xmath43
, the gld responsivity can be fairly high .
the detectivity @xmath121 of glds with the multiple - gl structure also rises with decreasing @xmath43 as well as with increasing @xmath80 .
since the capture probability @xmath43 in the multiple - gl structures should markedly decrease with increasing electric field in the barrier layers @xmath122 ( as in multiple - qwips @xcite ) , the gld responsivity and detectivity can be rising functions of the bias voltage if the proper heat removal is provided .
since the absorption of the incident thz radiation is associated with the drude mechanism , the absorption efficiency and , hence , the gld responsivity and detectivity can be relatively small in the frequency range @xmath123 . if @xmath124 ps , this corresponds to @xmath125 thz .
however , the operation of glds can be extended to much higher frequencies if the gld structure is supplied by a metal grating over the top gl ( not shown in fig . 1 ) .
in this case , the incident thz radiation can result in an efficient excitation of plasma oscillations in the electron - hole system in the double - gl glds and in the system of electrons in all gls ( in the multiple - gl structures ) . simplifying the equations from ref . 43 for the glds with a metal grating , the rate of the thz radiation absorption @xmath126 at the frequency near the @xmath127-th plasmon resonance ( @xmath128 ) can be presented as @xcite : @xmath129 here @xmath130 and @xmath131 are determined by the ratio of the collisional damping ( which is actually close to @xmath132 ) and the parameter of the radiative damping @xcite .
equation ( 21 ) does not contain any geometrical parameters such as the grating period , length of grating strips , and the spacing between the grating and the top gl .
these parameters only determine the dependence of the resonant plasma frequencies @xmath133 on the device geometry .
this is valid as long as those dimensions are much shorter than the thz radiation wavelength and the net length of the grating is of the same order of magnitude as the wavelength .
the quantities @xmath133 depend on the net electron density in all gls @xmath134 , the spacing between the top gl and the metal grating @xmath135 , and the period of the grating .
the latter determines the `` quantized '' wave - number @xmath136 of the excited plasma modes ( standing plasma waves ) .
one can put @xmath137 , @xmath138 , the length of the gl - structure in the lateral direction , and @xmath139 is the plasma mode index . for simplicity , one can use the following equation for the frequency of the plasma modes ( corresponding to @xmath140 ) : @xmath141 or @xmath142 the square - root dependence of @xmath133 on @xmath80 appears because the net electron density , which determines the contribution to the self - consistent electric field in the plasma waves by all the gls is proportional to @xmath143 , whereas the electron fictitious mass @xmath144 in gls is proportional to @xmath145 ( see , for example , ref .
@xcite ) . setting @xmath109 mev , @xmath146 m ( i.e. @xmath147 m and @xmath148 ) , and @xmath149 , from eq .
( 23 ) we obtain @xmath150 thz . if @xmath151 and @xmath152 , the gld responsivity at the resonance is of the same order of magnitude as at the low edge of the thz range @xmath153 ( see figs . 3 and 5 ) .
thus , the resonant excitation of plasma oscillations results in a strong absorption of the incident thz radiation and , hence , in elevated values of the gld responsivity ( and detectivity ) at relatively high frequencies ( several thz ) .
such glds can cover the frequency range @xmath154 thz ( @xmath155 mev ) , which is not accessible by a@xmath0b@xmath1-based detectors , in particular , thz quantum - well detectors ( qwds ) @xcite .
the model used in the above calculations some simplifications .
these simplifications are : ( i ) the capture probability is the same for all gls in the gl - structures ; ( ii ) the thermoassisted tunneling is insignificant ; ( iii ) the heating the joule heating of the structure .
since the capture probability @xmath43 depends on the heating of electrons in the barriers , it can be determined on only by the average electric field in the gl - structure but partially by the electric field in the adjacent barriers . in this case , the probability of the electron capture to the particular gl can depend on its index .
such kind of non - locality of the electric - field dependence can lead to more nontrivial spatial distributions ( as in qwips @xcite ) .
however , in the gl - structures with the barrier thickness much smaller than the characteristic energy relaxation length , the pertinent effect should be weak .
this justifies the assumption that @xmath43 is a constant ( which generally depends on the average electric field ) . at sufficiently high bias voltages ( much higher than those assumed above ) ,
the electron escape from gls can be associated with the thermoassisted tunneling from the bound states in gls to the continuum states above the barriers .
this tunneling can also be used in double- and multiple - glds with the structures similar to those considered above . since the effective activation energy for this mechanism can be markedly smaller that @xmath156 , glds with the thermoassisted tunneling
can comprise the barriers with larger conduction band offsets than between gls and ws@xmath157 , for example , with the @xmath158 barriers .
however , this problem requires a separate consideration . above we considered the case of not too low bias voltages ( @xmath38 ) .
the joule power @xmath159 can result in an overheating of the gl structure if @xmath4 is relatively strong .
such an overheating can be avoided either by decreasing @xmath25 ( decreasing the gl doping level ) or by lowering the bias voltage @xmath4 . in the range of bias voltages @xmath160 , the gld responsivity and detectivity given by eqs .
( 16 ) and ( 19 ) should be multiplied by the factors @xmath161\ } \simeq ev / nk_bt$ ] and @xmath162 } \simeq \sqrt{ev / nk_bt}$ ] , respectively .
the transfer to the range of relatively low bias voltages leads to a decrease in the joule power as @xmath163 , but at the expense of a decrease in the responsivity and detectivity ( @xmath164 and @xmath165 ) .
the joule heating can lead to overheating of glds if the joule power exceeds the maximum heat energy which can be removed from the gld unit area , @xmath166 , without a substantial heating .
this results in the following limitation : @xmath167 where @xmath168 is the device area . assuming a typical voltage drop cross the gl - structure to be on the order of 50 - 500 mv and the thermal resistance of the package to be on the order of 10 k / w
, we obtain that @xmath169 and the current leading to the ten degrees overheating @xmath170 are equal to 1 w and 2 - 20 a , respectively . for a typical 300@xmath171m@xmath172 device
, this corresponds to a fairly reasonable current density of @xmath173 a / cm@xmath172 .
setting @xmath175 @xmath19 , @xmath176 ps , and @xmath177 , we obtain @xmath178 a / cm@xmath172 ( i.e. , @xmath179 .
much higher current densities could be achieved with improved heat sinks ( see , for example , ref .
@xcite ) and/or in the pulsed regime of operation .
tunneling can be based on the materials with larger conduction band offsets than between gls and ws@xmath2 . in principle , glds can also effectively operate in the mid- and near - ir ranges . at sufficiently high photon energies ,
the intraband absorption is negligible , whereas the interband radiative processes , corresponding to the second term in the right - hand side of eq .
( 11 ) , can efficiently contribute to the heating of the electron gas in gls if @xmath180 .
in such a case for the photon energies @xmath181 , the gld responsivity is given by @xmath182 @xmath183 at @xmath184 @xmath19 ( @xmath22 mev ) , eqs .
( 25 ) and ( 26 ) yield the values of the responsivity @xmath185 about 20 - 30 times smaller than @xmath120 in the range @xmath186 ( see figs . 3 and 5 ) .
in particular , at @xmath187 @xmath19 , assuming @xmath188 , we obtain rather high values @xmath189 a / w .
the gld detectivity in the mid- and near - ir range @xmath190 , being much lower than @xmath121 in the thz range , can be still relatively high ( for room temperature ) . note that @xmath191 are @xmath190 independent of the photon energy in its wide range ( from @xmath192 mev to 800 mev ) . comparing the glds based on the vertical double - gl structure under consideration with the glds with a lateral structure and the barrier region consisting of an array of graphene nanoribbons using the electron heating in n - gl contact region , @xcite
one can see that both types of thz detectors at the room temperature exhibit close spectral characteristics . however , the glds with the vertical multiple - gl structure can have much higher responsivity and , especially , detectivity if @xmath193 and @xmath26 . in principle
, room - temperature thz detectors utilizing the thermionic emission of electrons heated by the absorbed thz radiation from qws can be made of a@xmath0b@xmath1 or si - ge heterostructures .
such detectors on the base of vertical multiple - qw structures were proposed and realized a long time ago(see refs .
@xcite and @xcite , respectively , as well as a recent paper @xcite ) .
the thz detectors based on lateral structures with the barrier regions formed by the metal gates were also realized @xcite ( see also ref .
. however , the responsivity and detectivity of glds under consideration can be markedly higher than that using the a@xmath0b@xmath1 multiple - qw structures . comparing the drude factor @xmath75 for gl - structures
[ see eq .
( 12 ) ] and the same factor @xmath194 for qw - structures with gaas qws , one can find the ratio of these factors at the equal electron density @xmath6 and momentum relaxation time @xmath37 is given by @xmath195 where @xmath196 and @xmath144 are the effective and fictitious electron masses in qws and gls , respectively . for gaas qws and gls with @xmath197 mev ,
these masses are approximately equal to each other .
this implies that the thz power absorbed in qws and gls are close .
however , the electron energy relaxation time in gls is longer than that in gaas - qws and other standard semiconductor qws .
this is mainly due to relatively large optical phonon energy in gls . indeed , using eq .
( 14 ) and assuming that @xmath198 ps at the room temperature we obtain @xmath199 ps , while for gaas ( @xmath200 mev and @xmath201 ps ) , inas ( @xmath202 mev and @xmath203 ps ) , and insb ( @xmath204 mev and @xmath205 ps ) qws one obtains @xmath206 , 0.93 and 3.93 ps , respectively .
longer electron energy relaxation time corresponds to more effective heating of the electron gas and , hence , higher responsivity .
an other factor promoting higher responsivity ( and detectivity ) of glds is the possibility to achieve higher photoelectric gain due to smaller values of the expected capture parameter @xmath43 .
the thz qwps using the direct intersubband photoexcitation from qws require the heterostructures with rather small band off - sets ( @xmath207 ) .
they exhibit a modest responsivity ( about few tens of ma / w or less @xcite ) with @xmath208 cm hz@xmath113/w at @xmath209 k @xcite . hence , in the few - thz range , glds surpass qwps
. glds with the grating using the plasmonic effects although should exhibit advantages over qwps in the range 6 - 10 thz ( see above )
. additional advantages of glds might be associated with better heat removal conditions @xcite than in the case of different a@xmath0b@xmath1 devices .
due to a substantial progress in fabrication and experimental studies of the multiple - gl structures with the inter - gl barrier layers made of transition metal dichalcogenides @xcite ( see also refs .
@xcite ) , the realization of the proposed glds appears to be feasible .
in particular , similar gl - structures with five periods and 20 nm thick barriers @xcite and with ten periods @xcite were demonstrated .
we proposed thz glds based on the double - gl and multiple - gl structures with the barrier layers made of ws@xmath2 exploiting the enhanced thermionic electron emission from gls due to the intraband ( drude ) absorption , developed the device model , and calculate the gld responsivity and detectivity at the room temperature .
we demonstrated that glds , especially , those based on the multiple - gl structures can exhibit fairly high responsivity and detectivity surpassing hot - electron detectors based on the standard heterostructures .
the main advantages of glds are associated with relatively long electron energy relaxation time and the pronounced effect of photoelectric gain at a low capture probability of the electron capture into gls .
as shown , glds using the resonant electron heating associated with the plasmonic effects and glds exploiting the electron heating due to the interband absorption can also operate in the far- , mid , and near - ir ranges of the radiation spectrum .
this work was supported by the japan society for promotion of science ( grant - in - aid for specially promoting research @xmath210 ) , japan . v. r. and m. r.
acknowledge the support of the russian scientific foundation ( project @xmath211 ) .
the work at the university at buffalo was supported by the nsf terano grant and the us air force office of scientific research .
the work at rpi was supported by the us army cooperative research agreement .
l. viti , d. coquillat , d. ercolani , l. sorba , w. knap , and m. s. vitiello , opt . exp . * 22 * , 8996 ( 2014 ) .
c. oh kim , s. kim . d. h. shin , s. s. kang , j. m. kim , c. w. jang , s. s.j , j.s .
lee , ju h. kim . s .-
ho choi , and e. hwang , nat . com . * 5 * , 3249 ( 2014 ) .
l. britnell , r. v. gorbachev , r. jalil , b.d .
belle , f. shedin , a. mishenko , t. georgiou , m. i. katsnelson , l. eaves , s. v. morozov , n. m. r. peres , j. leist , a. k. geim , k. s. novoselov , and l. a. ponomarenko , science , 335 , 947950 ( 2012 ) .
t. georgiou , r. jalil , b. d. bellee , l. britnell , r. v. gorbachev , s. v. morozov , y .- j .
kim , a. cholinia , s. j. haigh , o. makarovsky , l. eaves , l. a. ponomarenko , a. k. geim , k. s. nonoselov , and a. mishchenko , nature nanotechnology * 7 * , 100103 ( 2013 ) .
h. yan , x. li , b. chandra , g. tulevski , y. wu , m. freitag , w. zhu , p. avouris , and f. xia , nature nanotech . * 7 * , 330 ( 2012 ) .
s. j. haigh , a. gholinia , r. jalil , s. romani , l. britnell , d. c. elias , k. s. novoselov , l. a. ponomarenko , a. k. geim , and r. gorbachev , nature materials * 11 * , 764 ( 2012 ) m. xu , t. lian , m. shi , and h. chen , chem .
rev . * 113 * , 3766 ( 2013 ) . | we propose and analyze the concept of the vertical hot - electron terahertz ( thz ) graphene - layer detectors ( glds ) based on the double - gl and multiple - gl structures with the barrier layers made of materials with a moderate conduction band off - set ( such as tungsten disulfide and related materials ) .
the operation of these detectors is enabled by the thermionic emissions from the gls enhanced by the electrons heated by incoming thz radiation .
hence , hence , these detectors are the hot - electron bolometric detectors . the electron heating is primarily associated with the intraband absorption ( the drude absorption ) . in the frame of the developed model
, we calculate the responsivity and detectivity as functions of the photon energy , gl doping , and the applied voltage for the gl detectors ( glds ) with different number of gls .
the detectors based on the cascade multiple - gl structures can exhibit a substantial photoelectric gain resulting in the elevated responsivity and detectivity .
the advantages of the thz detectors under consideration are associated with their high sensitivity to the normal incident radiation and efficient operation at room temperature at the low end of the thz frequency range .
such glds with a metal grating , supporting the excitation of plasma oscillations in the gl - structures by the incident thz radiation , can exhibit a strong resonant response at the frequencies of several thz ( in the range , where the operation of the conventional detectors based on a@xmath0b@xmath1 materials , in particular thz quantum - well detectors , is hindered due to a strong optical phonon radiation absorption in such materials ) .
we also evaluate also the characteristics of glds in the mid- and far - infrared ranges where the electron heating is due to the interband absorption in gls . |
main - belt comets ( mbcs ; * ? ? ?
* ) exhibit cometary activity indicative of sublimating ice , yet orbit entirely within the main asteroid belt ( figure [ fig_aeimbcs ] ) .
seven mbcs 133p / elst - pizarro , 176p / linear , 238p / read , 259p / garradd , p/2010 r2 ( la sagra ) , p/2006 vw@xmath6 , and p/2012 t1 ( panstarrs ) are currently known .
in addition , three other objects p/2010 a2 ( linear ) , ( 596 ) scheila , and p/2012 f5 ( gibbs ) have been observed to exhibit comet - like dust emission , though their active episodes have been attributed to impact events and are not believed to be sublimation - driven @xcite . as such
, we do not consider these objects to be ice - bearing main - belt objects , and refer to them as disrupted asteroids ( figure [ fig_aeimbcs ] ) .
p/2012 t1 was discovered on 2012 october 6 by the 1.8 m pan - starrs1 ( ps1 ) survey telescope on haleakala @xcite .
ps1 employs a @xmath7 1.4 gigapixel camera , consisting of 60 orthogonal transfer arrays , each comprising 64 @xmath8 pixel ccds .
our discovery observations were made using sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xmath9- and @xmath10-like filters designated @xmath11 and @xmath12 @xcite .
comet candidate identification in ps1 data is accomplished using automated point - spread function ( psf ) analysis procedures @xcite implemented as part of ps1 s moving object processing system ( mops ; * ? ? ?
follow - up observations were obtained in photometric conditions between october 2012 and february 2013 using the university of hawaii ( uh ) 2.2 m and the 10 m keck i telescopes , both on mauna kea , the 6.5 m baade and clay magellan telescopes at las campanas , the 2.0 m faulkes telescope south ( fts ) at siding spring , the 1.8 m perkins telescope ( pt ) at lowell observatory , and the southern astrophysical research ( soar ) telescope on cerro pachon ( table [ table_obslog ] ; figure [ fig_observations]a , b ) .
we employed a 2048@xmath132048 pixel textronix ccd for uh observations , the low resolution imaging spectrometer ( lris ; * ? ? ?
* ) for keck observations , the inamori magellan areal camera and spectrograph ( imacs ) for baade observations , the megacam mosaic camera ( consisting of 36 2048@xmath134608 pixel ccds ) for clay observations , a 4096@xmath134096 pixel fairchild ccd for fts observations , the perkins reimaging system for lowell observations , and the soar optical imager ( soi ; * ? ? ?
* ) for soar observations .
we used sdss - like filters for clay observations , bessell filters for fts observations , and kron - cousins filters for all other observations .
uh 2.2 m , keck , lowell , and soar observations were conducted using non - sidereal tracking at the apparent rate and direction of motion of p/2012 t1 on the sky , while other observations were conducted using sidereal tracking .
ps1 data were reduced using the system s image processing pipeline ( ipp ; * ? ? ? * ) .
we performed bias subtraction and flat - field reduction for follow - up data using image reduction and analysis facility ( iraf ; * ? ? ?
* ) software and using flat fields constructed either from images of the illuminated interior of the telescope dome or dithered images of the twilight sky .
some photometric calibration was performed using field star magnitudes provided by the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; * ? ? ?
* ) converted to kron - cousins @xmath14-band equivalents using the transformation equations derived by r. lupton ( available online at http://www.sdss.org/ ) .
photometry of @xcite standard stars and field stars was performed for all data using iraf and obtained by measuring net fluxes within circular apertures , with background sampled from surrounding circular annuli .
conversion of @xmath9-band magnitudes measured from ps1 and clay data to their @xmath14-band equivalents was performed assuming approximately solar colors for the object .
comet photometry was performed using circular apertures , where to avoid dust contamination from the comet itself , background sky statistics are measured manually in regions of blank sky near , but not adjacent , to the object .
photometry aperture sizes were chosen to encompass @xmath1595% of the total flux from the comet ( coma and tail ) while minimizing interference from nearby field stars or galaxies , and varied from @xmath16 to @xmath17 in radius depending on seeing conditions .
field stars in comet images were also measured to correct for any extinction variations during each night .
in addition to imaging , we also obtained optical spectra of p/2012 t1 on 2012 october 19 with lris in spectroscopic mode on keck .
two g2v solar analog stars , hd28099 and hd19061 , were also observed to allow removal of atmospheric absorption features and calculation of p/2012 t1 s relative reflectance spectrum .
we utilized a @xmath18-wide long - slit mask and lris s d500 dichroic , with a 400/3400 grism on the blue side ( dispersion of 1.09 pixel@xmath3 and spectral resolution of @xmath07 ) , and 150/7500 grating on the red side ( dispersion of 3.0 pixel@xmath3 and spectral resolution of @xmath018 ) .
exposure times totaled 1320 s and 1200 s on the blue and red sides , respectively , where the comet was at an airmass of @xmath01.2 during our observations .
data reduction was performed using iraf .
photometry results from follow - up observations are listed in table [ table_obslog ] . for reference
, we also compute @xmath19 @xcite for each of our observations , though we note that it is not always a reliable measurement of the dust contribution to comet photometry in cases of non - spherically symmetric comae ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
while much of our photometry are based on snapshot observations ( meaning that unknown brightness variations due to nucleus rotation could be present ) , we find that the object s intrinsic brightness roughly doubles from the time of its discovery in early october until mid - november ( @xmath040 days ; over a true anomaly range of @xmath20 ) , and then decreases by @xmath060% between late december and early february ( @xmath050 days ; @xmath21 ) ( figure [ fig_observations]c ) . similar photometric behavior is observed for several other mbcs @xcite . for comparison , the brightness of disrupted asteroid ( 596 ) scheila declined by 30% in just 8 days @xcite .
mbcs 133p and 238p both exhibited long - lived brightening and did so during multiple apparitions , making us extremely confident in their cometary natures @xcite .
while long - lived activity is no guarantee of cometary activity @xcite , the photometric behavior of p/2012 t1 is certainly inconsistent with dust particles ejected impulsively in an impact .
its steady brightening implies the action of a prolonged dust ejection mechanism like sublimation .
furthermore , while apparently long - lived activity could be due to the long dissipation times of large particles ejected by an impact , p/2012 t1 s eventual fading after several weeks suggests that this is not the case here , since such large particles would be expected to persist much longer ( cf .
* ; * ? ? ?
multi - filter observations using lris on keck i ( which permits simultaneous @xmath22- and @xmath14-band imaging , eliminating the effects of rotational brightness variations ) and the baade telescope indicates that coma of p/2012 t1 had approximately solar colors of @xmath23 ( measured on keck ) , and @xmath24 and @xmath25 ( measured on baade ) .
our lris red - side spectrum ( figure [ fig_spectra ] ) of p/2012 t1 is approximately linear with a slightly blue slope of @xmath26 % /1000 , similar to the spectrum of 133p when it was active during its 2007 perihelion passage @xcite .
this result differs significantly , however , from the red slopes measured for mbc p/2006 vw@xmath6 when it was active ( 7.2%/1000 ; * ? ? ?
* ) as well as for other cometary dust comae @xcite . to derive the cn production rate ( cf
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , we employ a simple @xcite model , using a resonance fluorescence efficiency of @xmath27=3.63\times10^{-13}$ ] erg s@xmath3 molecule@xmath3 @xcite .
we find an upper limit to the cn production rate of @xmath2 mol s@xmath3 .
the cn to water production rate in mbcs is unknown , but we adopt the average ratio in other observed comets ( @xmath28\sim-2.5 $ ] ; @xmath29% ) @xcite , and infer a water production rate of @xmath30 mol s@xmath3 .
we also search for 0.7 @xmath1 m absorption due to a charge transfer transition in oxidized iron in phyllosilicates , indicative of the presence of hydrated minerals @xcite .
thermal evolution models suggest that aqueous alteration occurred within asteroid parent body interiors @xcite
. if these models are correct , mbcs could be icy fragments from the outer shells of asteroid parent bodies where temperatures were never high enough to melt ice .
if an mbc happened to be a fragment from near an ice and hydrated rock boundary in such a parent body , it could contain hydrated minerals . to date , no mbcs have shown evidence of having hydrated minerals on their surfaces .
our keck spectrum of p/2012 t1 likewise shows no signs of absorption at 0.7 @xmath1 m , and thus , no detectable evidence of hydrated minerals . to determine whether p/2012 t1 is likely to be native to the main belt , or if it could be a recently implanted interloper from the outer solar system , we analyze its long - term dynamical stability in a manner similar to that performed for other mbcs ( cf .
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we generate nine sets of 100 dynamical clones of p/2012 t1 that are gaussian - distributed in orbital element space and centered on the object s osculating orbital elements as of 2012 december 1 .
three of these sets are characterized by @xmath31 values equivalent to the uncertainties on those orbital elements ( @xmath32 au , @xmath33 , @xmath34 ) , three sets are characterized by @xmath31 values 10 times larger than those uncertainties , and three sets are characterized by @xmath31 values 100 times larger .
we then perform forward integrations for 100 myr using the n - body integration package , mercury @xcite .
we include the gravitational effects of all eight major planets and treat all dynamical clones as massless test particles .
non - gravitational forces are not considered in this analysis . in these simulations , less than 5% of the test particles reach heliocentric distances of @xmath35 au ( and are therefore considered to have been ejected from the asteroid belt ) over the 100 myr test period .
the remaining test particles diverge to occupy regions of orbital element space that are larger than their initial distributions but that are also essentially independent of those initial distributions , i.e. , the 1-@xmath31 sets of test particles diverge to occupy similar regions as the 100-@xmath31 sets ( figure [ fig_stability ] ) .
this divergence occurs quickly ( within @xmath36 years ) and remains approximately constant over the 100 myr test period .
we therefore find that p/2012 t1 is largely dynamically stable and is unlikely to be a recently implanted interloper , though we do note that the ejection of a small number of test particles indicates that the region is not perfectly stable over the considered time period .
mbcs 133p and p/2006 vw@xmath6 have recently been found to be dynamical members of very young ( @xmath3710 myr ) asteroid families @xcite .
these findings are interesting because the surfaces of ice - bearing main - belt objects may become significantly collisionally devolatilized on timescales of @xmath38 gyr @xcite . however , if mbcs only originated in the recent fragmentation events that created the aforementioned young families , their surfaces should have experienced far less collisional devolatilization , and thus remain susceptible to activation by small impactors ( cf .
* ; * ? ? ?
while we currently lack a sufficient sample size to ascertain whether there is a significant overabundance of mbcs in young families , the fact that two of seven mbcs ( @xmath030% ) are found to belong to such families is suggestive of a physical correlation . to test whether p/2012 t1 originated in a recent fragmentation event , we search for an associated dynamical family utilizing a hierarchical clustering analysis @xcite . using computed proper elements of @xmath39 au , @xmath40 , and @xmath41
, we find that p/2012 t1 belongs to the @xmath0155 myr - old lixiaohua asteroid family @xcite .
while the lixiaohua family is of intermediate age , p/2012 t1 could belong to an even younger sub - family , much as the young beagle and p/2006 vw@xmath6 families are both sub - groups of the much older themis family @xcite .
unfortunately , the density of asteroids in the region of orbital element space occupied by the lixiaohua family is extremely high .
in fact , most lixiaohua family members , including p/2012 t1 , are linked to the family at cut - off velocities as low as 20 m s@xmath3 . as such , identification of a younger sub - family for p/2012 t1
will be extremely difficult .
the slight instability of the p/2012 t1 s orbit ( section [ stability ] ) also interferes with our ability to establish young family linkages using techniques such as those applied in the case of p/2006 vw@xmath6 @xcite .
currently , the key question that must be answered when a main - belt object exhibits comet - like activity is whether that activity is sublimation - driven , implying the presence of ice , or is produced by another means .
definitive evidence of sublimation would be the direct detection of a gaseous sublimation product such as cn or h@xmath42o in the coma of such an object .
unfortunately , unsuccessful attempts to detect cn have now been made for four of the most recently discovered mbcs ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* this work ) , where each work has found similar upper limit cn production rates of @xmath43 mol s@xmath3 , corresponding to water production rates of @xmath44 mol s@xmath3 .
searches for line emission from the ( @xmath45 ) rotational transition of ortho - water at 557 ghz with the _ herschel _ space observatory for 176p and p/2012 t1 were also unsuccessful , finding @xmath46 mol s@xmath3 and @xmath47 mol s@xmath3 , respectively ( * ? ? ?
* orourke et al . ,
private communication ) . while these results do not definitively rule out sublimation
, they do indicate that the production rates of sublimation products by mbcs are too low to detect from current earth - bound facilities .
as such , we must rely on indirect evidence to determine the likely source of comet - like activity in main - belt objects .
@xcite examined various mechanisms by which an asteroid - like body could undergo comet - like mass loss , including ice sublimation , impact ejection , rotational instability , and electrostatic levitation , finding that in many individual cases of comet - like objects , the cause of observed mass loss could not be definitively identified due to insufficient observational data .
nonetheless , certain mechanisms could sometimes be ruled out based on physical and observational constraints .
for example , electrostatic levitation was ruled out as a cause of 133p s observed activity because it would have depleted the supply of mobile surface dust during a single active episode , leaving no obvious source of mobile dust for subsequent active episodes @xcite .
the rapid rotation of 133p also minimizes the amount of electrostatic charging that can occur given the short time that any portion of the object s surface spends in sunlight @xcite .
this mechanism s efficacy furthermore depends on unknown cohesive properties of asteroid regolith dust grains @xcite .
finally , given the many asteroids similar to 133p with more favorable rotational properties , it is unclear why 133p would exhibit observable dust levitation while other asteroids do not .
dust ejection via rotational spin - up , perhaps via the yarkovsky - okeefe - radzievsky - paddack ( yorp ) effect @xcite , was also ruled out due to the lack of a plausible mechanism for producing repeated activity or explaining the rarity of similar activity on other asteroids .
@xcite did note that for an object exhibiting repeated activity , sublimation appears to be the only reasonable explanation .
repeated activity has only been established for 133p and 238p , however , with others either failing to exhibit repeated activity upon completion of a full orbit period since its previously observed active episode ( 176p ) , or not yet having completed one full orbit since their first observed active episodes ( 259p , p/2010 r2 , p/2006 vw@xmath6 , and p/2012 t1 ) . as discussed in section [ photresults ] ,
p/2012 t1 s observed photometric behavior indicates ongoing and even increasing dust production over several weeks ( figure [ fig_observations]c ) , consistent with continuous sublimation - driven dust ejection and inconsistent with impulsive impact - driven dust ejection .
the comet also exhibits a diffuse coma and a featureless fan - like tail that remains aligned with the antisolar direction , distinctly different from the crossed filamentary structure of p/2010 a2 s tail , the three - plumed morphology of ( 596 ) scheila s dust tail , and the orbit - plane - aligned dust trail of p/2012 f5 @xcite .
the post - perihelion peaking of p/2012 t1 s activity is also consistent with the post - perihelion peaking of activity for other mbcs @xcite . while we can not yet definitively conclude that p/2012 t1 s activity is sublimation - driven , we note that all evidence examined thus far is consistent with sublimation .
we therefore find that p/2012 t1 is most likely a true mbc , and not a disrupted asteroid , though additional observations ( e.g. , to search for repeated activity during its next perihelion passage in mid-2018 ) and more detailed dust modeling will be required to definitively rule out other dust ejection mechanisms .
a primary ultimate objective of mbc studies is to connect observations of the distribution and composition of volatiles in small primitive bodies to the distribution of volatiles in the protoplanetary disk , and to link this through disk observations to other forming planetary systems @xcite .
presently , we have insufficient information to make these connections , in part because we have few direct constraints on the volatile content of small bodies and because our solar system s precise dynamical history remains poorly understood
. further work on both fronts would help this situation , though significantly advancing our understanding of volatile material in the asteroid belt may require in - situ investigation , e.g. , by a visiting spacecraft .
is supported by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hf-51274.01 awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, for nasa , under contract nas 5 - 26555 .
, n.h . , and k.j.m .
acknowledge support through the nasa astrobiology institute under cooperative agreement nna09da77a .
is supported by the ministry of education and science of serbia under project 176011 .
, t.r . , and l.u .
acknowledge support through nsf grant ast-1010059 .
we thank larry wasserman and brian taylor at lowell for assistance in obtaining observations .
some data presented was acquired using the ps1 system operated by the ps1 science consortium ( ps1sc ) and its member institutions .
the ps1 survey was made possible by contributions from ps1sc member institutions and nasa through grant nnx08ar22 g issued through the planetary science division of the nasa science mission directorate .
sdss - iii ( http://www.sdss3.org/ ) is funded by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , nsf , and the u.s .
department of energy office of science , and managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the sdss - iii collaboration .
ahearn , m. f. , schleicher , d. g. , millis , r. l. , feldman , p. d. , thompson , d. t. 1984 , , 89 , 579 ahearn , m. f. , millis , r. l. , schleicher , d. g. , osip , d. j. , & birch , p. v. 1995 , icarus , 118 , 223 bodewits , d. , kelley , m. s. , li , j .- y . , landsman , w. b. , besse , s. , & ahearn , m. f. 2011 , , 733 , l3 capria , m. t. , marchi , s. , de sanctis , m. c. , coradini , a. , & ammannito , e. 2012 , , 537 , a71 chambers , j. e. 1999 , , 304 , 793 cohen , b. a. , & coker , r. f. 2000 , icarus , 145 , 369 denneau , l. , et al .
2013 , , 125 , 357 fink , u. , & rubin , m. 2013 , icarus , 221 , 721 haser , l. 1957 , bulletin de la socit royale des sciences de lige , 43 , 740 hsieh , h. h. 2009 , a&a , 505 , 1297 hsieh , h. h. , & jewitt , d. 2006 , science , 312 , 561 hsieh , h. h. , jewitt , d. , & fernndez , y. r. 2004 , , 127 , 2997 hsieh , h. h. , jewitt , d. , lacerda , p. , lowry , s. c. , & snodgrass , c. 2010 , , 403 , 363 hsieh , h. h. , meech , k. j. , & pittichov , j. 2011 , , 736 , l18 hsieh , h. h. , yang , b. , & haghighipour , n. 2012a , , 744 , 9 hsieh , h. h. , et al .
2012b , , 748 , l15 hsieh , h. h. , et al . 2012c , , 143 , 104 ishiguro , m. , et al .
2011 , , 741 , l24 jewitt , d. 2012 , , 143 , 66 jewitt , d. , & guilbert - lepoutre , a. 2012 , , 143 , 21 jewitt , d. , yang , b. , & haghighipour , n. 2009 , , 137 , 4313 jewitt , d. , weaver , h. , agarwal , j. , mutchler , m. , & drahus , m. 2010 , nature , 467 , 817 jewitt , d. , weaver , h. , mutchler , m. , larson , s. , & agarwal , j. 2011 , , 733 , l4 kolokolova , l. , hanner , m. s. , levasseur - regourd , a .- c . , gustafson , b. .
s. 2004 , in comets ii , ed .
m. c. festou , h. u. keller , & h. a. weaver ( tucson , az : univ .
arizona press ) , 577 landolt , a. u. 1992 , , 104 , 340 licandro , j. , campins , h. , tozzi , g. p. , de leon , j. , pinilla - alonso , n. , boehnhardt , h. , & hainaut , o. r. 2011 , a&a , 532 , a65 licandro , j. , moreno , f. , de len , j. , et al .
2013 , , 550 , a17 magnier , e. 2006 , proceedings of the advanced maui optical and space surveillance technologies conference , ed . :
s. ryan , the maui economic development board , p.e5 moreno , f. , licandro , j. , & cabrera - lavers , a. 2012 , , 761 , l12 nesvorn , d. , bottke , w. f. , vokrouhlick , d. , sykes , m. , lien , d. j. , & stansberry , j. 2008 , , 679 , l143 novakovi , b. , tsiganis , k. , & kneevi , z. 2010 , , 402 , 1263 novakovi , b. , hsieh , h. h. , & cellino , a. 2012 , , 424 , 1432 oke , j. b. , cohen , j. g. , carr , m. , cromer , j. , dingizian , a. , harris , f. h. , labrecque , s. , lucinio , r. , schaal , w. , epps , h. , & miller , j. 1995 , , 107 , 375 pontoppidan , k. m. , salyk , c. , blake , g. a. , et al .
2010 , , 720 , 887 rubincam , d. p. 2000 , icarus , 148 , 2 schwarz , h. e. , et al .
2004 , , 5492 , 564 schleicher , d. g. 2010 , , 140 , 973 snodgrass , c. , et al .
2010 , nature , 467 , 814 stevenson , r. , kramer , e. a. , bauer , j. m. , masiero , j. r. , & mainzer , a. k. 2012 , 759 , 142 tody , d. 1986 , , 627 , 733 tonry , j. l. , et al .
2012 , , 750 , 99 de val - borro , m. , rezac , l. , hartogh , p. , et al .
2012 , , 546 , l4 vilas , f. 1994 , icarus , 111 , 456 wainscoat , r. , hsieh , h. , denneau , l. , et al . 2012 , central bureau electronic telegrams , 3252 , 1 wilson , l. , keil , k. , browning , l. b. , krot , a. n. , & bourcier , w. 1999 , meteoritics and planetary science , 34 , 541 york , d. g. , et al .
2000 , , 120 , 1579 zappal , v. , cellino , a. , farinella , p. , & kne@xmath48evi , z. 1990 , , 100 , 2030 lcrrcrrrrrrrccc 2012 sep 11 & & 0.0 & 2.411 & 1.753 & 21.4 & 262.1 & 243.5 & 6.3 & ... & ... & ... + 2012 oct 06 & ps1 & 1 & 40 & @xmath49 & 7.4 & 2.414 & 1.540 & 14.4 & 273.5 & 244.1 & 6.8 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 08 & ps1 & 1 & 40 & @xmath49 & 8.0 & 2.415 & 1.527 & 13.7 & 274.9 & 244.1 & 6.8 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 12 & clay & 38 & 2280 & @xmath9 & 9.1 & 2.416 & 1.507 & 12.4 & 278.1 & 244.2 & 6.7 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 14 & uh2.2 & 1 & 300 & @xmath14 & 9.8 & 2.418 & 1.496 & 11.5 & 280.3 & 244.3 & 6.6 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 15 & uh2.2 & 2 & 600 & @xmath14 & 10.0 & 2.418 & 1.491 & 11.2 & 281.4 & 244.3 & 6.6 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 15 & fts & 8 & 480 & @xmath14 & 10.0 & 2.418 & 1.491 & 11.1 & 281.6 & 244.3 & 6.6 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 18 & keck & 4 & 1440 & @xmath22 & 10.9 & 2.419 & 1.479 & 10.0 & 285.3 & 244.4 & 6.4 & [email protected] & ... & ... + & & 4 & 1200 & @xmath14 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 19 & keck & 4 & 1440 & @xmath22 & 11.2 & 2.419 & 1.475 & 9.7 & 286.8 & 244.4 & 6.4 & [email protected] & ... & ... + & & 4 & 1200 & @xmath14 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 22 & uh2.2 & 14 & 4200 & @xmath14 & 12.0 & 2.421 & 1.466 & 8.5 & 292.0 & 244.5 & 6.2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 oct 25 & baade & 3 & 180 & @xmath22 & 12.9 & 2.422 & 1.459 & 7.6 & 298.2 & 244.5 & 6.0 & [email protected] & ... & ... + & & 2 & 120 & @xmath51 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & [email protected] & ... & ... + & & 5 & 300 & @xmath14 & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & ... & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 nov 8 & uh2.2 & 2 & 600 & @xmath14 & 17.0 & 2.431 & 1.455 & 5.3 & 0.5 & 244.8 & 4.8 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 nov 9 & uh2.2 & 2 & 1200 & @xmath14 & 17.2 & 2.432 & 1.457 & 5.4 & 5.5 & 244.8 & 4.7 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 nov 13 & uh2.2 & 26 & 7800 & @xmath14 & 18.4 & 2.434 & 1.467 & 6.3 & 22.6 & 244.8 & 4.2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 nov 14 & uh2.2 & 14 & 4200 & @xmath14 & 18.7 & 2.435 & 1.470 & 6.5 & 26.1 & 244.8 & 4.1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 nov 22 & lowell & 4 & 2400 & @xmath14 & 21.0 & 2.441 & 1.502 & 9.1 & 44.9 & 244.7 & 3.1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 nov 23 & lowell & 2 & 1400 & @xmath14 & 21.3 & 2.442 & 1.507 & 9.5 & 43.9 & 244.7 & 3.0 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 dec 18 & uh2.2 & 30 & 9000 & @xmath14 & 28.3 & 2.467 & 1.712 & 17.7 & 64.5 & 244.1 & 0.1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 dec 19 & uh2.2 & 49 & 15000 & @xmath14 & 28.6 & 2.468 & 1.723 & 17.9 & 64.8 & 244.1 & 0.2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2012 dec 20 & lowell & 4 & 4800 & @xmath14 & 28.9 & 2.470 & 1.734 & 18.2 & 65.1 & 244.1 & 0.3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2013 jan 08 & uh2.2 & 10 & 8400 & @xmath14 & 34.2 & 2.493 & 1.962 & 21.6 & 69.5 & 243.7 & 2.1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2013 feb 04 & soar & 1 & 600 & @xmath14 & 41.4 & 2.531 & 2.334 & 22.9 & 73.3 & 243.9 & 3.5 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2015 jun 27 & & 180.0 & 3.896 & 3.656 & 15.0 & 114.2 & 296.1 & 0.5 & ... & ... & ... + 2018 apr 12 & & 0.0 & 2.402 & 3.392 & 3.1 & 134.3 & 243.4 & 2.9 & ... & ... & ... | we present initial results from observations and numerical analyses aimed at characterizing main - belt comet p/2012 t1 ( panstarrs ) .
optical monitoring observations were made between october 2012 and february 2013 using the university of hawaii 2.2 m telescope , the keck i telescope , the baade and clay magellan telescopes , faulkes telescope south , the perkins telescope at lowell observatory , and the southern astrophysical research ( soar ) telescope .
the object s intrinsic brightness approximately doubles from the time of its discovery in early october until mid - november and then decreases by @xmath060% between late december and early february , similar to photometric behavior exhibited by several other main - belt comets and unlike that exhibited by disrupted asteroid ( 596 ) scheila .
we also used keck to conduct spectroscopic searches for cn emission as well as absorption at 0.7 @xmath1 m that could indicate the presence of hydrated minerals , finding an upper limit cn production rate of @xmath2 mol s@xmath3 , from which we infer a water production rate of @xmath4 mol s@xmath3 , and no evidence of the presence of hydrated minerals .
numerical simulations indicate that p/2012 t1 is largely dynamically stable for @xmath5 myr and is unlikely to be a recently implanted interloper from the outer solar system , while a search for potential asteroid family associations reveal that it is dynamically linked to the @xmath0155 myr - old lixiaohua asteroid family . |
the angular momentum content of a star at birth impacts on most of its subsequent evolution ( e.g. ekstrm et al . 2012 )
. the star s instantaneous spin rate and/or on its rotational history plays a central role in various processes , such as dynamo - driven magnetic activity , mass outflows and galactic yields , surface chemical abundances , internal flows and overall structure , and it may as well influences the planetary formation and migration processes .
it is therefore of prime importance to understand the origin and evolution of stellar angular momentum , indeed one of the most challenging issues of modern stellar physics .
conversely , the evolution of stellar spin rate is governed by fundamental processes operating in the stellar interior and at the interface between the star and its immediate surroundings .
the measurement of stellar rotation at various evolutionary stages and over a wide mass range thus provides a powerful means to probe these processes . in this introductory course , an overview of the rotational properties of stars and of angular momentum evolution models
is provided . in section [ tech ] , various techniques used to measure stellar rotation are described . in section [ lowmass ] ,
the rotational properties of solar - type and low - mass stars are reviewed .
angular momentum evolution models developed for low - mass stars are discussed in section [ models ] .
finally , the rotational properties of intermediate - mass and massive stars are briefly outlined in section [ highmass ] .
stellar rotation can be measured through a variety of techniques .
i illustrate here some of the most commonly applied ones to measure the rotation rates of non - degenerated objects .
the various techniques are summarized in figure [ meas ] .
abney ( 1877 ) was apparently the first to consider the effect rotation would have on a stellar spectrum .
he suggested that doppler broadening of the photospheric line profiles should occur , as the light from the rotating surface goes through the entrance slit of the spectrograph . for a star with a linear equatorial velocity @xmath0 ,
the spectral broadening of photospheric lines amounts to @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the inclination angle between the line of sight and the rotation axis .
a star seen pole - on ( @xmath2=0 ) exhibits no doppler broadening , while a direct measurement of @xmath0 is obtained for an equator - on star ( @xmath2=90@xmath3 ) .
the isorotation locus on the stellar disk , i.e. , points of the stellar surface having the same projected velocity , follows vertical stripes parallel to the rotational axis , whose wavelength shift is given by @xmath4 , where @xmath5 and @xmath6 are respectively the latitude and longitude of a point at the stellar surface .
the integrated line profile of a rotating star is the sum of the intrinsic line profiles of all points on the stellar disk affected by their respective doppler shifts . to first order
, it can be described as the convolution product of the intrinsic , non - rotating line profile with a `` broadening '' function given by ( cf .
carroll 1933 ; gray 1973 ) : @xmath7^{1/2 } + { 1\over 2 } \pi\epsilon ) [ 1-(\delta\lambda/\delta\lambda_l)^2]\over\pi \delta\lambda_l(1-\epsilon/3)}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the temperature- and wavelength - dependent limb - darkening coefficient . in the fourier domain ,
the convolution product becomes an arithmethic product , and the fourier transform of @xmath9 ) has the interesting property of having successive zeroes at frequencies inversely proportional to @xmath10 ( e.g. , dravins et al . 1990 ) , with the first zero occuring at @xmath11 .
thus , even without the knowledge of the intrinsic line profile , the projected stellar velocity can be precisely derived from the location of the first and subsequent zeroes in the fourier transform of the observed profile .
this powerful technique has been most succesfully applied to fast rotators ( @xmath1230 kms@xmath13 ) as their first zero occurs in the well - sampled , high s / n low frequency fourier domain .
the highest @xmath14 measured so far with this technique , @xmath15600 kms@xmath13 , was reported for an o - type star in the large magellanic cloud ( dufton et al .
for a few bright stars , the fourier technique may even provide an estimate of surface latitudinal differential rotation ( gray 1977 ; reiners & schmitt 2002 ) .
in contrast , this method is not well suited to slowly rotating stars ( @xmath1620 kms@xmath13 ) whose first zero is usually lost in the high frequency fourier noise . a more common method used to measure the rotation rate of slow rotators is the cross - correlation analysis . instead of measuring the doppler broadening of a single line profile ,
this method consists in cross - correlating the observed photospheric spectrum with either a template spectrum of a star of similar effective temperature and negliglible rotation ( tonry & davies 1979 ) ( alternatively , a non - rotating model spectrum can be used ) or with a digital mask that let light go through predefined wavelength ranges corresponding to the location of major photospheric lines ( griffin 1967 ; baranne et al .
the result of either process is a cross - correlation profile or function ( ccf ) whose width is proportional to @xmath14 and whose signal - to - noise ratio has been greatly enhanced thanks to the inclusion of thousands of spectral lines in its computation .
the relationship between the ccf width and @xmath14 has to be properly calibrated using stars with known rotation rates ( benz & mayor 1981 , 1984 ; hartmann et al . 1986 ) .
other applications of the cross - correlation technique include the derivation of accurate radial velocities ( ccf peak location ) and metallicity ( ccf area ) .
more sophisticated spectroscopic techniques have also been used to measure rotation rates . the doppler imaging technique ( vogt & penrod 1983 ) and the related zeeman - doppler imaging technique ( semel 1989 ; donati et al .
1997 ) both take advantage of the relationship existing between the location of a feature at the surface of a rotating star and its position within the line profile ( khokhlova 1976 ) .
as the star rotates , the signatures of stellar spots ( or magnetic components in polarized light ) move across the line profile and their monitoring allows the reconstruction of surface brightness and/or magnetic maps .
the shape of the line profiles is thus periodically modulated by surface inhomogeneities , and the modulation period provides a direct measurement of the star s rotational period .
furthermore , the latitudinal drift of spots on the stellar surface probes the rotational period at different latitudes , thus yielding an estimate of differential rotation at the stellar surface .
specifically , the quantity @xmath17 is derived by assuming a simplified solar - like differential rotation law of the form : @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the angular velocity at the stellar equator and @xmath20 the latitude at the stellar surface .
the relationships between surface differential rotation on the one hand and effective temperature , convective zone depth , and rotation rate on the other , have been investigated for solar - type and lower mass stars by , e.g. , barnes et al .
( 2005 ) and marsden et al .
( 2011 ) .
for relatively nearby stars , the stellar disk may be resolved by interferometry ( e.g. kervella et al . 2004 ) .
in such a case , the stellar oblateness , i.e. , the decimal part of the ratio between the equatorial to the polar radii can be measured .
for rapidly - rotating stars , the stellar oblateness can be quite substantial . according to the roche model for stellar equipotential surfaces ,
the latitude - dependent radius of a fast - rotating star is given by : @xmath21\ ] ] where @xmath20 is the co - latitude and @xmath22 is the ratio between the star s angular velocity and the critical velocity at which centrifugal forces at the equator balance gravity , @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the stellar mass and @xmath25 the polar radius , ekstrm et al . 2008 ) .
for a star rotating at critical velocity , the equatorial radius is 1.5 times larger than the polar radius , yielding a stellar oblateness of 0.5 .
a stellar oblateness with values up to 0.35 has been measured by interferometry for a handful of massive stars rotating close to break - up velocity ( cf .
van belle 2012 ) . whenever interferometry can provide a fully reconstructed surface brightness map for a rapidly rotating star
, the gravity darkening effect can be directly observed .
von zeipel ( 1924 ) s theorem relates radiative flux to surface gravity and thus predicts that a star rotating close to break - up will be brighter at the pole than at the equator .
this has actually been observed in altair ( @xmath26240 kms@xmath13 ) by monnier et al .
( 2007 ) who modeled the surface brightness map of this star to derive both the inclination angle of the rotational axis on the line of sight and its position angle on the sky plane .
this illustrates the complementary power of interferometry compared to spectroscopy , as the former delivers the orientation of the angular momentum vector in space while the latter yields its ( projected ) modulus . in fact , interferometry and spectroscopy can be combined , a technique called spectro - interferometry , to measure the position angle of the rotational axis of stars whose surface is not fully spatially resolved .
the method consists in measuring the position of the star s photocenter across a spectral line .
each velocity channel within the line profile corresponds to one isorotation stripe at the stellar surface , parallel to the rotational axis .
for instance , the far redward wing of the line profile spatially coincides with the limb of the receding hemisphere .
as the photocenter is recorded across the line in successive velocity channels , its location slightly moves on the sky plane in a direction perpendicular to the rotational axis . using several interferometric baselines with different orientations , the direction of the projected rotational axis
can thus be derived .
this challenging technique was successfully applied by le bouquin et al .
( 2009 ) to demonstrate that the position angle of fomalhaut s rotational axis is perpendicular to the major axis of its planet - hosting debris disk .
the oldest method used to measure stellar rotation consists in monitoring the visibility of magnetic spots on the stellar surface .
in the western world , galileo galilei was amongst the first observers of the early 17@xmath27 century to provide an estimate of the sun s rotational period by observing the sunspots being carried across the stellar disk by the star s rotation ( casas et al .
when the stellar surface is not resolved , starspots still modulate the star s luminosity in a periodic way .
hence , the recording of the photometric light curve and the detection of a periodically modulated signal provide a direct estimate of the star s rotational period @xmath28 .
this technique has the advantage over spectroscopy of yielding a measurement of the stellar rotation rate that is free of geometric effects and is straighforwardly converted to angular velocity , @xmath29 .
however , this is at the expense of requiring intense photometric monitoring over several rotational periods and applying dedicated signal processing techniques in order to recover the periodic component of the light curve that truly corresponds to the star s rotational period ( e.g. irwin et al . 2009 ) .
this technique recently flourished with the corot and kepler satellites that acquired continuous stellar light curves of exquisite precision over timescales of months to years ( e.g. affer et al .
2012 ; mcquillan et al . 2013 ) .
the large number of rotational cycles recorded by these light curves allows not only the stellar rotational period to be derived with extreme accuracy but also to detect latitudinal differential rotation by traking spots located at different latitudes that have slightly different rotational periods ( e.g. mosser et al .
the application of this technique is obviously most suited to magnetically active stars that exhibit starspots at their surface , i.e , usually solar - type and lower mass stars with a spectral type from late - f to m , extending even to brown dwarfs ( e.g. herbst et al .
2007 ) .
the oscillation spectrum of a star encodes its rotational properties from the surface down to the deep interior .
to first order , the oscillation frequencies of radial order @xmath30 , degree @xmath5 , and azimuthal order @xmath31 of a rotating star are related to the same frequencies in a non - rotating star by : @xmath32 where @xmath33 $ ] and @xmath34 ( goupil et al . 2004 ) .
stellar rotation lifts the @xmath31-degeneracy of the oscillation modes of a non - rotating star by producing a rotational splitting whose amplitude is directly proportional to angular velocity . in case of uniform rotation
, the rotational splitting of the modes provides a direct measurement of surface angular velocity . for more complex rotational profiles , modeling the frequency
splitting with rotating stellar models offers a way to estimate the internal rotation profile of the star .
this technique was first applied to the sun to recover the latitudinal and radial variations of the solar rotation rate through the convective envelope and down into the radiative core ( e.g. , schou et al .
more recently , a similar approach based on the analysis of the rotational splitting of mixed pressure and gravity modes allowed deheuvels et al .
( 2012 ) to probe the internal rotation profile of a low - mass giant evolving off the main sequence , thus revealing a rapidly rotating inner core .
additional information can be retrieved from the amplitude of the rotationally splitted modes .
for instance , the ratio of the amplitudes of the @xmath35 mode components depends on the inclination of the rotational axis on the line of sight ( gizon & solanki 2003 ) .
a first application of this technique has recently allowed chaplin et al .
( 2013 ) to demonstrate that the rotational axis of 2 transiting exoplanet hosts detected by kepler is perpendicular to the orbital plane of the planets . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] @xmath36 pinto et al .
( 2011 ) ; @xmath37 cf .
ruciski ( 1988 )
we review in this section the rotational properties of stars with a mass less than 1.2m@xmath38 , from early studies to the most recent determinations of rotational period distributions ranging from the early pre - main sequence ( pms ) to the end of the main sequence ( ms ) .
the definition of physical quantities related to stellar rotation that we use in this section are summarized in table [ def ] .
solar values are listed for reference .
kraft ( 1970 ) provided one of the first reviews on the rotational properties of stars on the main sequence .
the main characteristics of the rotation rate distribution was a sharp break in velocity at a spectral type around f4 , i.e. , around a mass of @xmath151.2 m@xmath38 , with more massive stars having mean rotation rates of order of 100 - 200 kms@xmath13 , while lower mass stars had much lower rotational velocities of order of a few kms@xmath13 .
the sharp decline of rotation rate for stars with deep convective envelopes had readily been interpreted by schatzman ( 1962 ) as the result of angular momentum loss due to magnetized winds . in this framework ,
all stars were born with high rotation rates , and only magnetically active stars with surface convective envelopes would undergo strong braking as angular momentum is removed from their surface by magnetized stellar winds . in magnetically active stars ,
the ionised outflow remains coupled to the magnetic field out to a distance where the magnetic tension becomes unable to compensate for coriolis force , i.e. : @xmath39 where b is the magnetic field intensity , @xmath40 the surface angular velocity , @xmath41 the poloidal velocity of the wind flow , and @xmath42 its density .
the magnetic lever arm up to this radius yields angular momentum loss rates that are orders of magnitude larger than in the absence of magnetically - coupled winds . as shown by weber & davis ( 1967 ) , the angular momentum loss rate can be expressed as : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the stellar angular velocity , @xmath45 the mass - loss rate , @xmath46 the alfvn radius , and @xmath47 the braking timescale .
for the sun , the alfvn radius is about 30 times larger than the solar radius , which translates into a braking timescale by the magnetized wind of order of 1 gyr , i.e. , short enough to account for the slow rotation of the sun on the mid - main sequence .
a spectacular confirmation of this magnetic wind braking concept came with one of the first studies of rotational evolution among main sequence stars .
based on an earlier suggestion by kraft ( 1967 ) , skumanich ( 1972 ) used published measurements of the mean rotation rate of solar - type stars in 2 young open clusters , the pleiades and the hyades , and comparing them to the sun s rotation , derived his famous time - dependent velocity relationship @xmath48 , for ages between 0.1 and 5 gyr .
this relationship is indeed what is asymptotically expected from the magnetic wind braking process , as shown by durney & latour ( 1978 ) . combining the following expression for mass - loss : @xmath49 where @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the density and poloidal velocity of the outflow at the alfvn radius @xmath52 , with the definition of alfvn velocity : @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the stellar magnetic field at the alfvn radius , and with the condition of magnetic flux conservation : @xmath55 and replacing the expressions above in eq .
[ jdot ] , yields:@xmath56 further assuming that the poloidal velocity of the outflow at the alfvn radius reaches the escape velocity ( @xmath57 ) and that the stellar magnetic field is powered by an internal dynamo process wich scales as @xmath58 , finally yields:@xmath59 which asymptotically integrates to @xmath60 , i.e. , the skumanich relationship .
while extremely satisfying conceptually , this derivation makes a number of symplifying assumptions including spherically symmetric radial magnetic field and wind , thermally - driven outflows , and linear dynamo relationship , none of which strictly apply to active young stars ( see section 4 ) . as @xmath14
measurements accumulated in the mid-80 s especially for stars located close to or on the zero - age main sequence ( zams ) at an age of about 100 myr , it became clear that , at these young ages , a large dispersion of rotation rates exists for solar - type and lower mass stars .
thus , stauffer ( 1987 ) reported @xmath14 ranging from less than 10 kms@xmath13 up to more than 150 kms@xmath13 for g and k - type stars in the alpha persei ( 80 myr ) and pleiades ( 120 myr ) young open clusters , at the start of their main sequence evolution .
clearly , this unexpectedly large scatter of rotation rates at zams pointed to a rotational evolution during the pre - main sequence that was far more complex than envisioned from the skumanich relationship on the main sequence . extrapolating the skumanich relationship back in time to the pre - main sequence ( pms ) , at an age of @xmath151 myr , would predict rotational velocities of order of 200 kms@xmath13 .
additionally , if protostellar collapse is dominated by gravity , one should expect protostars to rotate close to their break - up velocity .
it therefore came as a surprise when the first measurements of rotational velocities for solar - mass pms stars revealed that their rotation rate rarely exceeds 25 kms@xmath13 , i.e. , about a tenth of the break - up velocity ( vogel & kuhi 1981 ; bouvier et al . 1986 ; hartmann et al . 1986 ) .
even deeply embedded protostars appear to exhibit quite moderate rotation , with a mean value of about 40 kms@xmath13 ( covey et al .
clearly , significant angular momentum loss must occur during protostellar collapse and/or during the embedded protostellar phase of evolution to account for such low rotation rates as the stars first appear in the hr diagram ( see hennebelle , this volume ; belloche , this volume ) .
like on the main sequence , higher mass pms stars exhibit larger rotational velocities than their lower - mass counterparts ( dahm et al .
most of the so - called herbig ae - be stars actually have similar velocities than their ms counterpart , which suggests they lose little angular momentum during the pms , except for the precursors of the peculiar subgroup of magnetic a and b stars ( cf .
alecian et al .
2013 ) .
the low rotation rates of pms low - mass stars is even more surprising when considering that they accrete high specific angular momentum material from their circumstellar disk for a few million years ( hernandez et al .
as shown by hartman & stauffer ( 1989 ) , a star accreting at a rate @xmath45 from its disk will gain angular momentum at a rate : @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the keplerian velocity of the disk material .
it is then expected to spin up to an equatorial velocity of : @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the stellar moment of inertia and @xmath65 the break - up velocity .
thus , for a mass accretion rate of a few 10@xmath66 m@xmath38yr@xmath13 lasting for about 3 myr , one expects the young star to rotate at more than half the break - up velocity . clearly , since most low - mass pms stars have much slower rotation rates , the accretion of high angular momentum material from the disk must be balanced by a process that efficiently removes angular momentum from the central star .
based on a physical process thought to be at work in compact magnetized objects such as accreting neutron stars , knigl ( 1991 ) was first to suggest that the magnetic interaction between the inner disk and a young magnetized star might provide a way to remove part of the angular momentum gained from accretion .
shortly after , evidence for a correlation between rotation rate and accretion was reported ( bouvier et al . 1993 ; edwards et al . 1993 ) , with accreting young stars rotating on average more _ slowly _ than non - accreting ones , thus providing a strong support to knigl s suggestion . yet , more than 20 years later , the controversy is still very much alive as to whether the magnetic star - disk interaction is efficient enough to counteract the accretion - driven angular momentum gain in young stars ( see ferreira , this volume ) . also , even though a number of recent studies appear to confirm the early evidence for a rotation - accretion connection in young stars ( e.g. rebull et al .
2006 ; cieza & baliber 2007 ; cauley et al .
2012 ; dahm et al .
2012 ; affer et al .
2013 ) , some discrepant results have also been reported ( e.g. le blanc et al .
thus , while there is a general consensus for young accreting stars being somehow prevented from spinning up as they evolve towards the main sequence ( e.g. , rebull et al .
2004 ) , the underlying physical mechanism responsible for this behaviour is not totally elucidated yet . while the early studies from the 60 s to the 80 s mostly focused on the determination of projected rotational velocities , @xmath14 , large - scale photometric monitoring campaigns started in the 90 s that provided complete rotational period distributions for thousands of low - mass stars in the pms and ms stages .
figure [ prot ] ( from irwin & bouvier 2009 , see references therein ) illustrates a compilation of some of these results .
it shows how the distribution of rotational periods evolves from the start of the pms at about 1 myr to the mid - ms at 0.6 gyr .
a number of clear evolutionary trends emerge , which have been confirmed by more recent studies .
the initial distribution in the orion nebulae cluster at @xmath671 myr is quite broad .
it was found to be bimodal for stars more massive than 0.3 m@xmath38 with a slow rotator peak with periods around 8 days and a fast rotator group with periods around 2 days ( herbst et al .
the peak of slow rotators is usually attributed to pms stars still interacting with their disk , hence being prevented from spinning up , while the fast rotators are thought to mainly consist of stars that have already dissipated their circumstellar disks and therefore have started to spin up as they evolve towards the zams .
in constrast , the rotational period distribution of very low - mass stars appears unimodal and skewed towards faster rotators .
as time progresses towards the zams , which is reached in about 40 myr for a solar - mass star and 150 myr for a 0.5 m@xmath38 star , the period distributions evolve towards faster rotation , especially in the low mass domain where rotational periods at zams converge to values less than 1 day .
however , for stars more massive than about 0.4 m@xmath38 , a large dispersion of rotation rates remains up to the zams .
it is only later on the ms , by an age of about 0.5 gyr , that all but the lowest mass stars are significantly braked , to reach periods larger than about 10 days ( delorme et al . 2011 ; meibom et al .
2011 ) , and exhibit a tight rotation - mass relationship . at the low mass end , below 0.6 m@xmath38 ,
a significant dispersion still subsists at that age ( scholz et al .
2011 ; ageros et al . 2011 ) and even beyond for most late - type field dwarfs ( mcquillan et al . 2013 ) , lasting for perhaps as long as 10 gyr for the lowest mass stars ( [email protected] m@xmath38 ; irwin et al . 2011 ) .
hence , the spin down timescale on the main sequence significantly increases towards lower mass objects , from a few 0.1 gyr for solar - type and low - mass stars up to a few gyr for very low - mass stars ( delfosse et al 1998 ) .
these recent studies have highlighted that the angular momentum ( am ) evolution of cool stars is strongly mass dependent , both during the pms and on the ms , as can be clearly seen from fig .
schematically , solar - type and low - mass stars ( 0.5 - 1.1 m@xmath38 ) have a large initial dispersion of rotational periods that subsists and even widens to the zams , and is eventually erased on the ms as all stars in this mass range are efficiently braked on a timescale of a few 0.1 gyr , thus yielding a well - defined rotation - mass sequence with little scatter .
the rotational convergence of solar - type stars on the early ms has led to the developement of gyrochronology , i.e. , the measurement of stellar age from rotation rate ( e.g. , barnes 2003 ; delorme et al .
2011 ; epstein & pinsonneault 2012 ) .
in contrast , very low - mass stars ( [email protected] m@xmath38 ) , while also exhibiting some dispersion of rotation rates at the start of the pms evolution , seems to all converge towards fast rotation at zams , and resume building up a large rotational scatter on a timescale of a few gyr on the ms .
this different behaviour is well illustrated by the changing shape of the period - mass diagrams shown in fig [ prot ] as time goes by .
going deeper into the mass spectrum , brown dwarfs ( bd s , [email protected] m@xmath38 ) rotational properties seem to mimic and extend those of very low - mass stars ( herbst et al . 2007 ; rodrguez - ledesma et al .
2009 ) , with no apparent rotational discontinuity at the stellar / substellar boundary . as a group
, they tend to rotate faster than stars at all ages ( mohanty & basri 2003 ) , with a median period of order of 15 hours at young ages , and some indeed with rotational periods as short as a few hours , i.e. , reaching close to the rotational break - up ( scholz & eislffel 2004 , 2005 ) .
rapid rotation is still measured for evolved bd s at an age of a few gyr , which suggests that they suffer much weaker angular momentum losses than stars ( reiners & basri 2008 ) .
the wealth of new data acquired since the mid-90 s , now encompassing several thousands of rotational periods measured for cool stars over an age range covering from the start of the pms to the late - ms prompted renewed interest in the development of angular momentum evolution models .
while a review of all existing models and their origin is far beyond the scope of this introductory course , we outline in this section the main physical processes that are thought to drive the rotational evolution of low - mass stars and how they are currently implemented in parametrized models of angular momentum evolution .
the rotational evolution of low - mass stars is believed to be dictated by 3 main physical processes : star - disk interaction in the early pms , magnetized wind braking , and am transport in the stellar interior .
we only briefly summarize these processes below , as they are reviewed in much more detailed in other contributions to this volume .
camenzind ( 1990 ) and knigl ( 1991 ) were first to suggest that the low rotation rates of pms stars may result from the magnetic star - disk interaction .
the picture envisioned at that time was inspired by the ghosh et al.s ( 1977 ) model developed for accreting neutron stars ( e.g. collier cameron et al .
1995 ) . while this model now does not seem to be efficient enough to apply to young stars , a number of alternatives have been proposed still relying on the inner disk interacting with a strong stellar magnetosphere . indeed , young stars are known to host strong magnetic fields ( cf .
donati , this volume ) that are able to disrupt the inner disk regions and channel the accretion flow onto the star through magnetic funnels ( cf .
bouvier et al .
2007 for a review ) .
bessolaz et al .
( 2008 ) derived the following expression for the magnetospheric truncation radius : @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the sonic mach number at the disc midplane , @xmath71 the stellar magnetic field , and @xmath72 the mass accretion rate . for values of the parameters relevant to a young accreting solar - mass system
, the magnetospheric truncation radius is located a few stellar radii above the stellar surface , a prediction borne out by observations ( e.g. najita et al .
this distance is of the same order as the disk corotation radius , i.e. , the radius at which the keplerian angular velocity in the disk equals the star s angular velocity : @xmath73 the net flux of angular momentum exchanged between the star and the disk strongly depends upon whether the magnetospheric truncation radius is located within or beyond the disk corotation radius .
therefore , the changing magnetic topology of solar - type stars evolving on their convective and radiative pms tracks will most likely impact their early rotational evolution ( e.g. gregory et al .
2012 ) . within this general framework
, various scenarios have been developed to attempt to produce a negative net angular momentum torque onto the star , so as to explain why young stars are slow rotators in spite of both accretion and contraction .
these include accretion - driven winds ( matt & pudritz 2008 ) , x - winds and their variants ( mohanty and shu 2008 ; ferreira et al .
2000 ) , and magnetospheric ejections ( zanni & ferreira 2013 ) .
these models are discussed at length in j. ferreira s contribution to this volume .
whether any of these processes is actually able to counteract the spin up due to accretion and contraction during the early pms is , however , unsettled .
pending a satisfactory model for pms spin down , most current angular momentum evolution models assume that accreting pms stars evolve at constant angular velocity ( cf .
[ ammodels ] ) . starting from the general expression of angular momentum loss due to magnetized stellar winds ( eq .
3.1 above ) , kawaler ( 1988 ) worked out a parametrized formulation that can be straightforwardly implemented in evolutionary models .
following mestel ( 1984 ) , the am loss rate is given by : @xmath74^n\ ] ] where @xmath45 is the mass loss rate , @xmath75 the stellar angular velocity , @xmath76 the stellar radius , @xmath46 the alfvn radius , and the exponent @xmath30 reflects the magnetic field geometry with @xmath77 for a radial field and @xmath78 for a dipolar field . from eq .
3.2 , 3.3 , and 3.4 above , the expression of the alfvn radius is given by : @xmath79 where @xmath71 is the stellar magnetic field intensity , and @xmath51 the flow velocity at the alfvn radius .
further assuming that the flow velocity at the alfvn radius is of order of the escape velocity , and adding a dynamo relationship for the generation of the stellar magnetic field of the form : @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the dynamo exponent , finally leads to : @xmath82 for an asumed linear dynamo relationship ( @xmath81=1 ) , and a magnetic topology intermediate ( in some sense ) between a radial and a dipolar field with @xmath30=1.5 , eq.4.6 simplifies to : @xmath83 which is easily implement in an evolutionary model .
direct application of this prescription , however , proved to produce too strong braking for fast rotators compared to observations ( stauffer & hartmann 1987 ) .
most models have therefore adopted a variant of kawaler s prescription , first proposed by chaboyer et al .
( 1995 ) , that assumes that the dynamo saturates ( @xmath84 ) above some angular velocity @xmath85 , i.e. : @xmath86 the shallower slope of the rotation - dependent angular momentum loss at high rotation , i.e. , @xmath87 instead of @xmath88 , provides a better agreement with the observation of very fast rotators at the zams .
magnetic field measurements suggest that dynamo saturation occurs at a fixed rossby number @xmath89 in cool stars ( reiners et al .
2009 ; wright et al .
2011 ) , with @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the turnover convective time .
as @xmath91 lengthens towards lower mass stars , @xmath92 is expected to decrease with mass , i.e. , lower mass stars suffer less angular momentum loss than solar - type ones .
this rossby scaling thus naturally accounts for the longer spin down timescale of lower mass stars on the main sequence ( krishnamurthi et al .
1997 ; bouvier et al .
however , sills et al .
( 2000 ) showed that very low - mass stars ( [email protected] m@xmath38 ) experience much less spin down than the extrapolation of the rossby scaling to very low masses would predict .
recently , reiners & mohanty ( 2012 ) proposed a modification to kawaler s prescription , based on a more physically - funded dynamo relationship , that appears to alleviate this issue .
recent mhd numerical simulations of stellar winds have considerably improved our understanding of wind - driven angular momentum loss ( e.g. aarnio et al .
2012 ; vidotto et al .
2009 , 2011 ) .
based on 2d numerical simulations of mhd winds originating from stars with a dipolar magnetic field , matt et al .
( 2012 ) derived the following expression for the alfvn radius : @xmath93^{m}\ ] ] where @xmath94 is the ratio of the stellar rotation rate to the break - up velocity and @xmath95 where @xmath71 is the magnetic field strength at the stellar equator , @xmath96 the wind mass loss rate , and @xmath97 the escape velocity .
the value of the constants appearing in eq .
[ matt ] are derived from numerical simulations that explore the parameter space , yielding @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath100 .
provided the stellar magnetic field can be tied to the angular velocity through a dynamo prescription , and the wind mass loss rate can be computed as a function of stellar rotation and other fundamental stellar parameters ( e.g. cranmer & saar 2011 ) , the expression given by eq .
[ matt ] for the alfvn radius can be implemented in eq .
[ jdot ] to compute the amount of wind - driven angular momentum losses during stellar evolution .
models using this new prescription for am losses are illustrated below ( cf .
[ ammodels ] ) . as angular momentum
is carried away by stellar winds at the stellar surface , several mechanisms may operate to redistribute angular momentum in the stellar interior .
these range from various classes of hydrodynamical instabilites ( e.g. lagarde et al .
2012 , see also the contributions of palacios and rieutord in this volume ) , magnetic fields ( e.g. eggenberger et al .
2005 ) , and gravity waves ( talon & charbonnel 2008 ; charbonnel et al .
2013 ; see also mathis , this volume ) . the recent report of rapidly rotating cores in red giants from asterosismology ( e.g. mosser et al .
2012 ) and the discrepancy between the measured angular velocity gradient and model expectations indicate that angular momentum transport mechanisms in stellar interiors are still not totally elucidated ( e.g. eggenberger et al .
2012 ) . lacking a detailed physical modeling of the processes involved
, macgregor & brenner ( 1991 ) introduced a parametrized prescription for angular momentum transport between the radiative core and the convective envelope .
each region is considered as rotating uniformely but not necessarily at the same rate , as the convective envelope is slowed down .
they assumed that am transport processes would act to erase angular velocity gradients at the boundary between the radiative core and the convective envelope ( the tachocline , cf .
spiegel & zahn 1992 ) , on a timescale @xmath101 , the so - called core - envelope coupling timescale . to reach a state of uniform rotation on a timescale @xmath101 throughout the star ,
a quantity @xmath102 of angular momentum has to be exchanged between the radiative core and the convective envelope , with : @xmath103 where @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 , @xmath107 are the moment of inertia and the angular momentum content of the convective envelope and the radiative core , respectively .
then , the angular momentum evolution of the radiative core and the convective envelope can be written as : @xmath108 and @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the wind braking timescale .
this prescription has been used in two - zone angular momentum evolution models ( e.g. allain 1998 ) that provide some insight into the value of @xmath101 and its dependence upon rotation rate and stellar parameters .
a short coupling timescale corresponds to an efficient am redistribution and leads to solid - body rotation , while a long @xmath101 allows for strong angular velocity gradients to develop at the tachocline as the star evolves .
thus , this parametrization offers some empirical guidance to identify the actual underlying physical mechanisms at work for angular momentum transport in stellar interiors based on the timescales involved .
angular momentum evolution models have been developed in an attempt to reproduce the run of surface rotation as a function of time , as derived from observations for solar - type stars , low - mass and very low - mass stars . in this section
, we illustrate a class of semi - empirical models that use parametrized prescriptions to implement the physical processes described in the previous section .
figure [ gallet ] ( from gallet & bouvier 2013 ) illustrates the observed and modeled angular momentum evolution of solar - type stars , in the mass range 0.9 - 1.1 m@xmath38 , from the start of the pms at 1 myr to the age of the sun .
the rotational distributions of solar - type stars are shown at various time steps corresponding to the age of the star forming regions and young open clusters to which they belong ( see fig.2 ) .
three models are shown , which start with initial periods of 10 , 7 , and 1.4 days , corresponding to slow , median , and fast rotators .
the models assume constant angular velocity during the star - disk interaction phase in the early pms ( cf . [ sdi ] ) , implement the matt et al .
( 2012 ) wind braking prescription ( cf .
[ wind ] ) , as well as core - envelope decoupling ( cf .
[ decoupling ] ) .
the free parameters of the models are the initial periods , scaled to fit the rotational distributions of the earliest clusters , the star - disk interaction timescale @xmath111 during which the angular velocity is held constant at its initial value , the core - envelope coupling timescale @xmath101 , and the calibration constant @xmath112 for wind - driven am losses .
the latter is fixed by the requirement to fit the sun s angular velocity at the sun s age .
these parameters are varied until a reasonable agreement with observations is obtained . in this case , the slow , median , and fast rotator models aim at reproducing the 25 , 50 , and 90@xmath27 percentiles of the observed rotational distributions and their evolution from the early pms to the age of the sun .
the models provide a number of insights into the physical processes at work .
the star - disk interaction lasts for a few myr in the early pms , and possibly longer for slow rotators ( @xmath1135 myr ) than for fast ones ( @xmath1132.5 myr ) .
as the disk dissipates , the star begins to spin up as it contracts towards the zams .
the models then suggest much longer core - envelope coupling timescales for slow rotators ( @xmath11430 myr ) than for fast ones ( @xmath11412 myr ) . hence , once they have reached the zams , slow rotators exhibit much lower surface velocities than fast rotators but significantly larger angular velocity gradients at the tachocline . indeed , most of the initial angular momentum is hidden in the core of the slow rotators at zams .
as they evolve on the early ms , wind braking eventually leads to the convergence of rotation rates for all models by an age of @xmath671 gyr , to asymptotically reach the skumanich s relationship .
these models thus clearly illustrate the different rotational histories solar - type stars may experience , depending mostly on their initial period and disk lifetime . in turn , the specific rotational history a star undergoes may strongly impact on its properties , such as lithium content , even long after rotational convergence has taken place ( cf .
bouvier 2008 ; randich 2010 ) .
the models discussed above describe the rotational evolution of single stars while many cool stars belong to multiple stellar systems . in short period binaries ( @xmath11512 days )
, tidal interaction will enforce synchronization betweeen the orbital and rotational period ( zahn 1977 ) .
clearly , the rotational evolution of the components of such systems is totally different from that of single stars , and rapid rotation is usually maintained over the whole main sequence ( zahn & bouchet 1989 ) and even beyond , like in , e.g. , the magnetically - active rapidly - rotating rs cvn systems .
however , the fraction of such tight , synchronized systems among solar - type stars is low , of order of 3% ( raghavan et al .
2010 ) , so that tidal effects are unlikely to play a major role in the angular momentum evolution of most cool stars .
presumably much more frequent is the occurrence of planetary systems around solar - type and low - mass stars ( e.g. mayor et al .
2011 ; bonfils et al .
the frequency of hot jupiters , i.e. , massive planets close enough to their host star to have a significant tidal influence ( cf .
dobbs - dixon et al .
2004 ) , is a mere 1% around fgk stars ( e.g. wright et al .
. however , there is mounting evidence that the planetary formation process is quite dynamic , with gravitational interactions taking place between forming and/or migrating planets ( albrecht et al .
this may lead to planet scattering and even planet engulfment by the host star .
the impact of such catastrophic events onto the angular momentum evolution of planet - bearing stars has been investigated by bolmont et al .
( 2012 ) who showed it could be quite significant both during the pms and on the main sequence .
models similar to those described above for solar - type stars have been shown to apply to lower mass stars , at least down to the fully convective boundary ( @xmath670.3 m@xmath38 ) , with the core - envelope coupling timescale apparently lengthening as the convective envelope thickens ( e.g. , irwin et al .
2008 ) . in the fully convective regime ,
i.e. , below 0.3 m@xmath38 , models ought to be simpler as the core - envelope decoupling assumption becomes irrelevant and uniform rotation is usually assumed instead throughout the star . yet ,
the rotational evolution of very low - mass stars actually appears more complex than that of their more massive counterparts and still challenges current models .
rotational period measurements for field m - dwarfs show a bimodal distribution with a peak of fast rotators in the period range 0.2 - 10 days , and a peak of slow rotators with rotational periods ranging from 30 days to at least 150 days ( irwin et al . 2011 ) .
most of the slow rotators appear to be thick disk members , i.e. , they are on average older than the fast ones that are kinematically associated to the thin disk .
the apparent bimodality coud thus simply result from a longer spin down timescale of order of a few gyr , as advocated by reiners & mohanty ( 2012 ) . however , as shown in figure [ irwin ] ( from irwin et al .
2011 ) , this bimodality may not be easily explained for field stars at an age of several gyr .
it is seen that the large dispersion of rotation rates observed at late ages for very low - mass stars requires drastically different model assumptions .
specifically , for a given model mass ( 0.25 m@xmath38 in fig .
[ irwin ] ) , the calibration of the wind - driven angular momentum loss rate has to differ by one order of magnitude between slow and fast rotators ( irwin et al .
why does a fraction of very low - mass stars remain fast rotators over nearly 10 gyr while another fraction is slowed down on a timescale of only a few gyr is currently unclear . a promising direction to better understand the rotational evolution of very low mass stars is the recently reported evidence for a bimodality in their magnetic properties . based on spectropolarimetric measurements of the magnetic topology of late m dwarfs ( morin et al .
2010 ) , gastine et al .
( 2013 ) have suggested that a bistable dynamo operates in fully convective stars , which results in two contrasting magnetic topologies : either strong axisymmetric dipolar fields or weak multipolar fields .
whether the different magnetic topologies encountered among m dwarfs is at the origin of their rotational dispersion at late ages remains to be assessed .
as outlined in sect . [ early ] , stars more massive than 1.2 m@xmath38 have significantly larger rotation rates than solar - type and low - mass stars . in comparison to low - mass stars , more massive stars have higher initial angular momenta , shorter contraction timescales to the zams and shorter evolution timescales on the ms , they lack deep convective envelopes and strong magnetic fields ( except for peculiar sub - classes , such as ap - bp stars ) , and drive dense radiative winds . for all these reasons ,
their rotational evolution is expected to be quite different from that of their low - mass counterparts .
we briefly review in the next sections the rotational properties of massive and intermediate - mass stars .
braganca et al .
( 2012 ) have recently summarized the rotational distributions of 350 nearby o9-b6 stars in the galactic disk from @xmath14measurements . after correcting for projection effect ( i.e. , @xmath116 , cf .
gaig 1993 ) , they find that the mean equatorial velocity is of order of 125 kms@xmath13and relatively uniform over the whole mass range they probe .
a similar study was performed by huang & gies ( 2006 ) for 496 o9-b9 stars belonging to 19 young open clusters yielding an average equatorial velocity of 190 kms@xmath13 , i.e. , significantly higher than the mean rotation rate of massive field stars .
specifically , the difference in mean velocity between cluster and field stars at high masses stems from the much smaller fraction of slow rotators observed in clusters , while the two populations have similar @xmath14 distributions above @xmath67100 kms@xmath13 . even though cluster members are on average younger than field dwarfs , meynet & maeder ( 2000 ) rotating evolutionary models predict only modest spin down for massive stars on the main sequence , with a braking rate of order of 15 - 20% for 9 - 12 m@xmath38 stars .
indeed , the comparison of massive field dwarfs and cluster members over the same age range ( 12 - 15 myr ) still result in differing average velocities , thus suggestive of an intrinsic rather than an evolutionary effect ( strom et al . 2005 ) .
wolff et al . ( 2007 ) further confirmed that massive stars formed in high - density regions , e.g. rich clusters , lack the numerous slow rotators seen for stars of similar masses in low - density regions and the field .
these authors suggested that the density - dependent rotational distribution observed for massive stars may reflect a combination of initial conditions , e.g. , higher turbulence in massive proto - clusters yielding larger initial angular momenta , and environmental conditions , where the stronger ambient uv flux from o - type stars in rich clusters may shorten the disk lifetimes , thus minimizing the braking efficiency of the star - disk interaction during the early angular momentum evolution of massive stars .
yet , it is unclear whether the disk locking scenario discussed above for low - mass pre - main sequence stars does apply to more massive stars ( cf .
rosen et al .
nevertheless , regardless of the actual physical processes at work , the observed relationship between the shape of the rotational distributions of massive stars and the specific properties of their birthplace seems to indicate that initial conditions have a long - lasting impact on their rotational properties . as mentionned in previous sections ( see [ pms ] ) , intermediate - mass pms stars , the so - called herbig ae - be stars , have on average much higher rotational velocities than their lower mass t tauri counterparts at an age of a few myr .
wolff et al . ( 2004 ) investigated the rotational evolution of intermediate - mass pms stars ( 1.3 - 2 m@xmath38 ) as they evolve from convective to radiative tracks towards the zams .
comparing the measured velocities on convective tracks to those of stars landing on the zams over the same mass range , they concluded that angular momentum is conserved in spherical shells within the star , i.e. , that the pms spin up is directly proportional to the contraction of the stellar radius . the lack of angular momentum redistribution in the predominantly radiative interiors of intermediate - mass pms stars
would then imply that they develop a large degree of radial differential rotation from the center to the surface as they approach the zams .
further insight into the rotational properties and evolution of intermediate - mass stars is provided by the large - scale study of zorec & royer ( 2012 ) who reported @xmath14 measurements for 2,014 b6- to f2-type stars . by tracing the evolution of rotation as a function of age
, they confirm that intermediate - mass stars seem to evolve on the main sequence as differential rotators .
striking differences between the rotational distribution of 1.6 - 2.4 m@xmath38 stars and that of 2.4 - 3.8 m@xmath38 stars , the former being unimodal while the latter is bimodal , remain to be understood .
similarly , the complex rotational behaviour of stars over this mass range as they evolve onto the ms , with an apparent spin up during the first half of the ms evolution followed by a significant spin down during the second half , represents a real challenge for angular momentum evolution models . a specific sub - group of intermediate - mas stars , the magnetic ap - bp stars host surface magnetic fields of a few kg to a few 10 kg .
this sub - group represents about 5 - 10% of the population and is known to exhibit systematic lower velocities that their non - magnetic counteparts ( abt & morrell 1995 ) .
alecian et al .
( 2012 ) showed that their precursors , i.e. , the magnetic herbig ae - be stars , already are slower rotators that non - magnetic intermediate - mass pms stars , indicating that magnetic braking is already efficient during the pms for this particuliar subgroup . as the spin down continues on the ms , ap stars can reach very slow rotation indeed , with the longest rotational period ever reported amounting to 77@xmath11710 years ( leroy et al .
the last decade has seen tremendous progress in the characterization of the rotational properties of stars at various stages of evolution and over the whole mass range from brown dwarfs to the most massive objects .
these new observational results bring formidable constraints to the development of angular momentum evolution models . while the dominant processes thought to dictate the rotational evolution of stars
are probably identified , much remains to be done to understand their detailed physics and their respective roles .
the confrontation between models and observations , though much improved in recent years , still indicate a number of shortcomings related to transport processes in radiative interiors , the physics of stellar winds , and the interaction between the star and its environment .
major advances are expected to arise from multi - dimensional numerical simulations of stellar interiors and stellar atmospheres , which will hopefully provide new clues to the elusive physical processes that govern the rotational evolution of stars from their birth to the last stages of their evolution .
it is a pleasure to thank the organisers of the evry schatzman school for a very enjoyable week , the friendly atmosphere , and the unexpected celebration event during the school .
i would also like to thank florian gallet and jonathan irwin for providing fig.3 and 4 , respectively , of this contribution , jean - baptiste le bouquin for interesting discussions on interferometry , rafael garcia and jrme ballot for guidance in asterosismology , juan zorec for providing useful references on the rotation of intermediate - mass stars , gaspard duchne for help on binary statistics , gauthier mathys for discussions on ap stars , and nadge meunier for an historical review of the first measurements of the sun s rotation , whose paternity remains controversial .
aarnio , a. n. , matt , s. p. , & stassun , k. g. 2012 , apj , 760 , 9 abney , w. d. w. 1877 , mnras , 37 , 278 abt , h. a. , & morrell , n. i. 1995 , apjs , 99 , 135 affer , l. , micela , g. , favata , f. , & flaccomio , e. 2012 , mnras , 424 , 11 affer , l. , micela , g. , favata , f. , flaccomio , e. , & bouvier , j. 2013 , mnras , 430 , 1433 ageros , m. a. , covey , k. r. , lemonias , j. j. , et al . 2011 , apj , 740 , 110 albrecht , s. , winn , j. n. , johnson , j. a. , et al .
2012 , apj , 757 , 18 alecian , e. , wade , g. a. , catala , c. , et al .
2013 , mnras , 429 , 1027 allain , s. 1998 , a&a , 333 , 629 baranne , a. , mayor , m. , & poncet , j. l. 1979 , vistas in astronomy , 23 , 279 barnes , j. r. , collier cameron , a. , donati , j .- f . , et al .
2005 , mnras , 357 , l1 barnes , s. a. 2003 , apj , 586 , 464 benz , w. , & mayor , m. 1981 , a&a , 93 , 235 benz , w. , & mayor , m. 1984 , a&a , 138 , 183 bessolaz , n. , zanni , c. , ferreira , j. , keppens , r. , & bouvier , j. 2008 , a&a , 478 , 155 bolmont , e. , raymond , s. n. , leconte , j. , & matt , s. p. 2012 , a&a , 544 , a124 bonfils , x. , delfosse , x. , udry , s. , et al .
2013 , a&a , 549 , a109 bouvier , j. 2008 , a&a , 489 , l53 bouvier , j. , forestini , m. , & allain , s. 1997 , a&a , 326 , 1023 bouvier , j. , bertout , c. , benz , w. , & mayor , m. 1986 , a&a , 165 , 110 bouvier , j. , alencar , s. h. p. , harries , t. j. , johns - krull , c. m. , & romanova , m. m. 2007 , protostars and planets v , 479 bouvier , j. , cabrit , s. , fernandez , m. , martin , e. l. , & matthews , j. m. 1993 , a&a , 272 , 176 bragana , g. a. , daflon , s. , cunha , k. , et al .
2012 , aj , 144 , 130 camenzind , m. 1990 , reviews in modern astronomy , 3 , 234 carroll , j. a. 1933 , mnras , 93 , 478 casas , r. , vaquero , j. m. , & vazquez , m. 2006 , sol .
phys . , 234 , 379 cauley , p. w. , johns - krull , c. m. , hamilton , c. m. , & lockhart , k. 2012 , apj , 756 , 68 chaboyer , b. , demarque , p. , & pinsonneault , m. h. 1995 , apj , 441 , 865 chaplin , w. j. , sanchis - ojeda , r. , campante , t. l. , et al .
2013 , arxiv:1302.3728 charbonnel , c. , decressin , t. , amard , l. , palacios , a. , & talon , s. 2013 , arxiv:1304.5470 cieza , l. , & baliber , n. 2007 , apj , 671 , 605 cohen , o. , drake , j. j. , kashyap , v. l. , sokolov , i. v. , & gombosi , t. i. 2010 , apjl , 723 , l64 collier cameron , a. , campbell , c. g. , & quaintrell , h. 1995 , a&a , 298 , 133 covey , k. r. , greene , t. p. , doppmann , g. w. , & lada , c. j. 2005 , aj , 129 , 2765 cranmer , s. r. , & saar , s. h. 2011 , apj , 741 , 54 dahm , s. e. , slesnick , c. l. , & white , r. j. 2012 , apj , 745 , 56 deheuvels , s. , garca , r. a. , chaplin , w. j. , et al .
2012 , apj , 756 , 19 delfosse , x. , forveille , t. , perrier , c. , & mayor , m. 1998 , a&a , 331 , 581 delorme , p. , collier cameron , a. , hebb , l. , et al .
2011 , mnras , 413 , 2218 dobbs - dixon , i. , lin , d. n. c. , & mardling , r. a. 2004 , apj , 610 , 464 donati , j .- f . ,
semel , m. , carter , b. d. , rees , d. e. , & collier cameron , a. 1997 , mnras , 291 , 658 dravins , d. , lindegren , l. , & torkelsson , u. 1990 , a&a , 237 , 137 dufton , p. l. , dunstall , p. r. , evans , c. j. , et al .
2011 , apjl , 743 , l22 durney , b. r. , & latour , j. 1978 , geophysical and astrophysical fluid dynamics , 9 , 241 edwards , s. , strom , s. e. , hartigan , p. , et al .
1993 , aj , 106 , 372 eggenberger , p. , maeder , a. , & meynet , g. 2005 , a&a , 440 , l9 eggenberger , p. , montalbn , j. , & miglio , a. 2012 , a&a , 544 , l4 ekstrm , s. , meynet , g. , maeder , a. , & barblan , f. 2008 , a&a , 478 , 467 ekstrm , s. , georgy , c. , eggenberger , p. , et al .
2012 , a&a , 537 , a146 epstein , c. r. , & pinsonneault , m. h. 2012 , arxiv:1203.1618 ferreira , j. , pelletier , g. , & appl , s. 2000 , mnras , 312 , 387 gaig , y. 1993 , a&a , 269 , 267 gallet , f. , & bouvier , j. 2013 , arxiv:1306.2130 gastine , t. , morin , j. , duarte , l. , et al .
2013 , a&a , 549 , l5 ghosh , p. , pethick , c. j. , & lamb , f. k. 1977 , apj , 217 , 578 gizon , l. , & solanki , s. k. 2003 , apj , 589 , 1009 goupil , m. j. , samadi , r. , lochard , j. , dziembowski , w. a. , & pamyatnykh , a. 2004 , stellar structure and habitable planet finding , 538 , 133 gray , d. f. 1973 , apj , 184 , 461 gray , d. f. 1977 , apj , 211 , 198 gregory , s. g. , donati , j .- f . , morin , j. , et al .
2012 , apj , 755 , 97 griffin , r. f. 1967 , apj , 148 , 465 hartmann , l. , & stauffer , j. r. 1989 , aj , 97 , 873 hartmann , l. , hewett , r. , stahler , s. , & mathieu , r. d. 1986 , apj , 309 , 275 hernndez , j. , hartmann , l. , megeath , t. , et al .
2007 , apj , 662 , 106 herbst , w. , bailer - jones , c. a. l. , & mundt , r. 2001 , apjl , 554 , l197 herbst , w. , eislffel , j. , mundt , r. , & scholz , a. 2007 , protostars and planets v , 297 huang , w. , & gies , d. r. 2006 , apj , 648 , 580 irwin , j. , & bouvier , j. 2009 , iau symposium , 258 , 363 irwin , j. , aigrain , s. , bouvier , j. , et al .
2009 , mnras , 392 , 1456 irwin , j. , berta , z. k. , burke , c. j. , et al .
2011 , apj , 727 , 56 irwin , j. , hodgkin , s. , aigrain , s. , et al .
2008 , mnras , 383 , 1588 kawaler , s. d. 1988 , apj , 333 , 236 kervella , p. , thvenin , f. , di folco , e. , & sgransan , d. 2004 , a&a , 426 , 297 khokhlova , v. l. 1976 , astronomische nachrichten , 297 , 203 knigl , a. 1991 , apjl , 370 , l39 kraft , r. p. 1967 ,
apj , 150 , 551 kraft , r. p. 1970
, spectroscopic astrophysics .
an assessment of the contributions of otto struve , 385 krishnamurthi , a. , pinsonneault , m. h. , barnes , s. , & sofia , s. 1997 , apj , 480 , 303 lagarde , n. , decressin , t. , charbonnel , c. , et al .
2012 , a&a , 543 , a108 lanza , a. f. 2010 , a&a , 512 , a77 le blanc , t. s. , covey , k. r. , & stassun , k. g. 2011 , aj , 142 , 55 le bouquin , j .- b . , absil , o. , benisty , m. , et al .
2009 , a&a , 498 , l41 leroy , j. l. , bagnulo , s. , landolfi , m. , & landi deglinnocenti , e. 1994 , a&a , 284 , 174 macgregor , k. b. , & brenner , m. 1991 , apj , 376 , 204 marsden , s. c. , jardine , m. m. , ramrez vlez , j. c. , et al .
2011 , mnras , 413 , 1939 matt , s. , & pudritz , r. e. 2008 , apj , 681 , 391 matt , s. p. , macgregor , k. b. , pinsonneault , m. h. , & greene , t. p. 2012 , apjl , 754 , l26 mayor , m. , marmier , m. , lovis , c. , et al .
2011 , arxiv:1109.2497 mcquillan , a. , aigrain , s. , & mazeh , t. 2013 , arxiv:1303.6787 meibom , s. , barnes , s. a. , latham , d. w. , et al .
2011 , apjl , 733 , l9 mestel , l. 1984 , cool stars , stellar systems , and the sun , 193 , 49 meynet , g. , & maeder , a. 2000 , a&a , 361 , 101 mohanty , s. , & basri , g. 2003 , apj , 583 , 451 mohanty , s. , & shu , f. h. 2008 , apj , 687 , 1323 monnier , j. d. , zhao , m. , pedretti , e. , et al .
2007 , science , 317 , 342 morin , j. , donati , j .- f . , petit , p. , et al .
2010 , mnras , 407 , 2269 mosser , b. , baudin , f. , lanza , a. f. , et al .
2009 , a&a , 506 , 245 mosser , b. , goupil , m. j. , belkacem , k. , et al .
2012 , a&a , 548 , a10 najita , j. r. , carr , j. s. , glassgold , a. e. , & valenti , j. a. 2007 , protostars and planets v , 507 pinto , r. f. , brun , a. s. , jouve , l. , & grappin , r. 2011 , apj , 737 , 72 raghavan , d. , mcalister , h. a. , henry , t. j. , et al .
2010 , apjs , 190 , 1 randich , s. 2010 , iau symposium , 268 , 275 rebull , l. m. , wolff , s. c. , & strom , s. e. 2004 , aj , 127 , 1029 rebull , l. m. , stauffer , j. r. , megeath , s. t. , hora , j. l. , & hartmann , l. 2006 , apj , 646 , 297 reiners , a. , & basri , g. 2008 , apj , 684 , 1390 reiners , a. , & mohanty , s. 2012 , apj , 746 , 43 reiners , a. , & schmitt , j. h. m. m. 2002 , a&a , 384 , 155 reiners , a. , basri , g. , & browning , m. 2009 , apj , 692 , 538 rodrguez - ledesma , m. v. , mundt , r. , & eislffel , j. 2009 , a&a , 502 , 883 rosen , a. l. , krumholz , m. r. , & ramirez - ruiz , e. 2012 , apj , 748 , 97 rucinski , s. m. 1988 , aj , 95 , 1895 schatzman , e. 1962 , annales dastrophysique , 25 , 18 scholz , a. , & eislffel , j. 2004 , a&a , 419 , 249 scholz , a. , & eislffel , j. 2005 , a&a , 429 , 1007 scholz , a. , irwin , j. , bouvier , j. , et al .
2011 , mnras , 413 , 2595 schou , j. , antia , h. m. , basu , s. , et al .
1998 , apj , 505 , 390 semel , m. 1989 , a&a , 225 , 456 sills , a. , pinsonneault , m. h. , & terndrup , d. m. 2000 , apj , 534 , 335 skumanich , a. 1972 , apj , 171 , 565 spiegel , e. a. , & zahn , j .- p .
1992 , a&a , 265 , 106 stauffer , j. r. 1987 , cool stars , stellar systems and the sun , 291 , 182 stauffer , j. r. , & hartmann , l. w. 1987 , apj , 318 , 337 strom , s. e. , wolff , s. c. , & dror , d. h. a. 2005 , aj , 129 , 809 talon , s. , & charbonnel , c. 2008 , a&a , 482 , 597 tonry , j. , & davis , m. 1979 , aj , 84 , 1511 van belle , g. t. 2012 , a&ar , 20 , 51 vidotto , a. a. , opher , m. , jatenco - pereira , v. , & gombosi , t. i. 2009 , apj , 699 , 441 vidotto , a. a. , jardine , m. , opher , m. , donati , j. f. , & gombosi , t. i. 2011 , mnras , 412 , 351 vogel , s. n. , & kuhi , l. v. 1981 , apj , 245 , 960 vogt , s. s. , & penrod , g. d. 1983 , pasp , 95 , 565 von zeipel , h. 1924 , mnras , 84 , 665 weber , e. j. , & davis , l. , jr . 1967 , apj , 148 , 217 wolff , s. c. , strom , s. e. , & hillenbrand , l. a. 2004 , apj , 601 , 979 wolff , s. c. , strom , s. e. , dror , d. , & venn , k. 2007 , aj , 133 , 1092 wright , j. t. , marcy , g. w. , howard , a. w. , et al .
2012 , apj , 753 , 160 wright , n. j. , drake , j. j. , mamajek , e. e. , & henry , g. w. 2011 , apj , 743 , 48 zahn , j .-
1977 , a&a , 57 , 383 zahn , j .-
p . , & bouchet , l. 1989 , a&a , 223 , 112 zanni , c. , & ferreira , j. 2013 , a&a , 550 , a99 zorec , j. , & royer , f. 2012 , a&a , 537 , a120 | this course reviews the rotational properties of non - degenerate stars as observed from the protostellar stage to the end of the main sequence .
it includes an introduction to the various observational techniques used to measure stellar rotation .
angular momentum evolution models developed over the mass range from the substellar domain to high - mass stars are briefly discussed . |
despite the absence of an explicit minimization principle , variational methods have been used successfully in many problems of quantum scattering theory .
such calculations typically exploit a stationary principle in order to obtain an accurate description of scattering processes .
the kohn variational method @xcite has been applied extensively to problems in electron - atom @xcite and electron - molecule @xcite scattering , as well as to the scattering of positrons , @xmath1 , by atoms @xcite and molecules @xcite .
it has been widely documented , however , that matrix equations derived from the kohn variational principle are inherently susceptible to spurious singularities .
these singularities were discussed first by schwartz @xcite and have subsequently attracted considerable attention @xcite . in the region of these singularities
, results of kohn calculations can be anomalous .
although sharing characteristics similar to those exhibited by scattering resonances @xcite , schwartz singularities are nonphysical and arise only because the trial wavefunction , used in kohn calculations to represent scattering , is inexact @xcite . for projectiles of a given incident energy ,
anomalous results are confined to particular formulations of the trial wavefunction and can , in principle , be mitigated by a small change in boundary conditions or some other parameter .
it has also been shown @xcite that the use of a complex - valued trial wavefunction avoids anomalous behaviour except in exceptional circumstances .
alternative versions of the kohn method have been developed in terms of a feshbach projection operator formalism @xcite and have been found @xcite to give anomaly - free results . in this article
we will discuss our investigations of schwartz - type anomalies for generalized kohn calculations involving the elastic scattering of positrons by molecular hydrogen , @xmath2 .
we will find that our choice of trial wavefunction contains a free parameter that can be varied in such a way as to produce singularities which are legitimate in the context of the scattering theory and which do not give rise to anomalous results . indeed
, these singularities can be used to formulate an optimization scheme for choosing the free parameter so as to automatically avoid anomalous behaviour in calculations of the scattering phase shift .
the novelty of determining the phase shift in this way is that an explicit solution of the linear system of kohn equations is not required .
we will also develop an alternative optimization and show that the two schemes give results in close agreement .
further , the results obtained will be seen to be in excellent agreement at all positron energies with those determined via the complex kohn method .
we will give examples of anomalous behaviour which can not be avoided with either optimization , and show that the same anomalies appear in our application of the complex kohn method .
we will discuss circumstances under which these anomalies might occur .
we will show also that such results are nonphysical by considering small changes in the nonlinear parameters of the trial wavefunction .
our investigations of singular behaviour have been carried out as part of a wider study on @xmath0scattering and annihilation using extremely flexible wavefunctions . our ability to recognize clearly and analyze the anomalous behaviour is as good for this system as it would be for a simpler model system , with the advantage that our calculations can be used to provide meaningful and physically relevant results @xcite .
the kohn variational method is used to calculate approximations to exact scattering wavefunctions .
determining an approximation , @xmath3 , allows a variational estimate , ps .
, of the scattering phase shift to be calculated , the error in which is of second order in the error of @xmath3from the exact scattering wavefunction , @xmath4 @xcite .
the standard approach in kohn calculations is to assume an overall form for @xmath3that depends linearly on a set of unknown parameters , optimal values for which are then determined by the application of a stationary principle . in our investigations of anomalous behaviour in kohn calculations for @xmath0scattering
, we have studied the lowest partial wave of @xmath5 symmetry .
this partial wave has been shown @xcite to be the only significant contributor to scattering processes for incident positron energies below @xmath6 ev .
the first significant inelastic channel is positronium formation which has a threshold at @xmath7 ev @xcite .
although we will here consider positron energies higher than these thresholds , it is not our intention to provide a comprehensive physical treatment of the scattering problem taking higher partial waves and inelastic processes into account .
the purpose of the present study is to give a correct and , as far as possible , anomaly - free treatment of the lowest partial wave .
it is important to examine the single channel case as accurately as possible as a preliminary for more sophisticated calculations . by not taking into account additional channels ,
it is possible that anomalous behaviour could occur due to physical inaccuracies in the trial wavefunction at higher energies .
however , we will demonstrate that all of the anomalies in our results ultimately can be attributed to purely numerical effects .
we have initially used a trial wavefunction having the same general form as described in our earlier calculations @xcite , @xmath8 where @xmath9 = \left [ \begin{array}{cc } \cos(\tau ) & \sin(\tau)\\ -\sin(\tau ) & \cos(\tau)\\ \end{array}\right ] \left [ \begin{array}{c } { s}\\ { c}\\ \end{array}\right],\ ] ] for some phase parameter , @xmath10 , with @xmath11,\ ] ] and @xmath12 \lbrace 1-\exp\left[-\gamma\left ( \lambda_{3}-1\right)\right]\rbrace.\ ] ] as before @xcite , we have carried out calculations using the fixed - nuclei approximation @xcite , taking the internuclear separation to be at the equilibrium value , @xmath13 au .
we have labelled the electrons as particles @xmath14 and @xmath6 , taking the positron to be particle @xmath15 .
the position vector , @xmath16 , of each lepton is described by the prolate spheroidal coordinates @xcite @xmath17 , @xmath18 .
these coordinates are defined implicitly in terms of the cartesian coordinates , @xmath19 , as @xmath20^{\frac{1}{2 } } \cos \left(\phi_{j}\right),\\ y_{j } & = & \frac{1}{2}r\left[\left ( \lambda_{j}^{2}-1\right ) \left ( 1-\mu_{j}^{2}\right)\right]^{\frac{1}{2 } } \sin \left(\phi_{j}\right),\\
z_{j } & = & \frac{1}{2}r\lambda_{j } \mu_{j}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the functions @xmath21 and @xmath22 represent , respectively , the incident and scattered positrons asymptotically far from the target .
the shielding parameter , @xmath23 , ensures the regularity of @xmath22 at the origin and is taken to have the value @xmath24 .
the constant , @xmath25 , is defined to be @xmath26 , @xmath27 being the magnitude of the positron momentum in atomic units .
@xmath28 is a normalization constant and can here be regarded as arbitrary .
the unknowns , @xmath29 and @xmath30 , are constants to be determined .
the inclusion of the parameter , @xmath31 , in @xmath3is a generalization of the kohn method due to kato @xcite .
this parameter is of only minor physical significance , playing the role of an additive phase factor in the part of the wavefunction representing the incident and scattered positrons asymptotically far from the target .
however , at each value of @xmath27 , the value of @xmath31 can be varied to avoid spurious singularities in the kohn calculations .
away from the spurious singularities , for an accurate trial wavefunction we can expect the variation in the calculated values of ps . over @xmath31 to be small . in the original application of the kohn method @xcite , only wavefunctions corresponding to @xmath32 were considered .
the function , @xmath33 , is an approximation to the ground state wavefunction of the unperturbed hydrogen molecule and is determined by the rayleigh - ritz variational method @xcite . in the calculations presented here , we have taken
@xmath33to be the target wavefunction described in detail in another of our previous calculations @xcite , accounting for @xmath34 of the correlation energy @xcite of @xmath2 .
the function , @xmath35\\ \label{eq : chi}&\times&\lbrace 1-\exp\left[-\gamma\left ( \lambda_{3}-1\right)\right]\rbrace\exp\left[-\gamma\left ( \lambda_{3}-1\right)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] is the same as has been used in our earlier calculations @xcite and was introduced first by massey and ridley @xcite .
the remaining short - range correlation functions , @xmath36 , allow for the description of direct electron - positron and electron - electron interactions . here , we have used the same set of @xmath37 correlation functions described in detail in equations ( 5 - 8 ) of @xcite .
the general form of each function , @xmath38 , is @xmath39 \quad \left(1\leq i \leq m\right),\ ] ] where each @xmath40 is symmetric in the coordinates of the electrons .
they are a mixture of separable correlation functions and hylleraas - type functions @xcite containing the electron - positron distance as a linear factor .
as discussed previously @xcite , the hylleraas - type functions in particular allow for high accuracy of results away from anomalous singularities .
unless otherwise noted , we have here chosen values of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , rather than the values of @xmath43 and @xmath44 used earlier @xcite .
this choice of nonlinear parameters highlights the interesting aspects of schwartz - type anomalies more clearly . in our application of the kohn variational principle @xcite , the functional @xmath45=\tan\left(\eta_{\mathrm{v}}-\tau+c\right)=a_{\mathrm{t}}-\frac{2}{\pi n^2 r^2 k}\langle\psi_{\mathrm{t}},\psi_{\mathrm{t}}\rangle\ ] ] is made stationary with respect to variations in @xmath29 and @xmath30 . here ,
we have denoted by @xmath46 the integral , @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the nonrelativistic hamiltonian for the scattering system and @xmath49 is the sum of the positron kinetic energy and the ground state energy expectation value of @xmath33 .
the integral is evaluated over the configuration space of the positron and the two electrons .
we will , henceforth , use this notation more generally to denote by @xmath50 integrals of the form @xmath51 .
the stationary principle imposed upon ( [ eq : principle ] ) leads to the linear system of equations @xmath52 where @xmath53,\\ \label{eq : vecb}b&=&\left[\begin{array}{c } \langle\bar{c}\psi_{\mathrm{g}},\bar{s}\psi_{\mathrm{g}}\rangle \\
\langle\chi_{0}\psi_{\mathrm{g}},\bar{s}\psi_{\mathrm{g}}\rangle \\ \vdots \\ \langle\chi_{m},\bar{s}\psi_{\mathrm{g}}\rangle \\ \end{array}\right],\\ x&=&\left[\begin{array}{c } a_{t}\\ p_{0}\\ \vdots\\ p_{m } \end{array}\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] solving ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) determines the values of @xmath29 and @xmath30 , allowing @xmath46 and , hence , ps . to be calculated via ( [ eq : principle ] ) .
however , as has been discussed extensively ( see , for example , @xcite ) , the particular form of the functions , @xmath40 , used in our calculations does not , in general , permit analytic evaluation of the integrals comprising the matrix elements of @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
sophisticated methods to determine these integrals numerically have been developed @xcite .
however , the numerical approaches can give only accurate approximations to the exact values of the integrals , so that small errors in determining the elements of @xmath54 and @xmath55 are unavoidable .
singularities in our generalized kohn calculations arise from zeros of @xmath56 , the determinant of ( [ eq : mata ] ) . under these circumstances , the linear system ( [ eq : kohneq ] )
has no unique solution .
close to these singularities , it is well known @xcite that values of ps . obtained by solving ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) can be anomalous ; small errors in the elements of @xmath54 or @xmath55 can correspond to large errors in the solution , @xmath57 , particularly when @xmath54 is close to singularity in a sense that can be defined formally in terms of the condition number @xcite of @xmath54 .
a more detailed discussion of the condition number will be given in section [ ss : persistent ] .
it is appropriate at this point to define a convention that we will adopt in our discussion of singularities in the generalized kohn method .
the type of spurious singularities mentioned by schwartz @xcite here correspond to zeros in @xmath56for the particular case when @xmath32 .
we will , however , find it convenient to label as schwartz singularities those zeros of @xmath56occurring at any @xmath58 which give rise to anomalous behaviour in the calculations of @xmath59 when @xmath31 is near @xmath60 .
this is an important clarification for the following reason : we claim that , because of our inclusion of @xmath31 in @xmath3 , there exist zeros of @xmath56which are not spurious and which do not correspond to anomalous behaviour in the values of ps . .
we will refer to such singularities as anomaly - free singularities . to understand how anomaly - free singularities might arise
, it is helpful to consider the component , @xmath61 , of the exact scattering wave function , @xmath4 , corresponding to the lowest partial wave .
@xmath61 can be expanded as @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the exact ground state target wavefunction and the complete set of correlation functions , @xmath64 , describes exactly the leptonic interactions at short - range .
as noted by takatsuka and fueno @xcite in their kohn calculations for single channel scattering , the exact phase shift , @xmath65 , determined by @xmath61 is independent of the choice of @xmath31 in ( [ eq : exact ] ) . as a result , there is precisely one value , @xmath66 , at each positron energy such that @xmath67 for some odd value of @xmath68 , where either @xmath69 or @xmath70 is chosen to keep @xmath71 $ ] .
the value of @xmath72 will then pass continuously through zero as @xmath31 passes through @xmath73 .
returning to the trial wavefunction ( [ eq : trialwave ] ) , for nonsingular @xmath54 it can be shown using ( [ eq : principle ] ) and ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) that @xmath74 where we have defined @xmath75 b,\ ] ] @xmath76 being the adjugate matrix of ( [ eq : mata ] ) .
we note that @xmath76 exists even if @xmath54 is singular . in section [ ss : pscalcs ]
we will provide numerical evidence that the limit of @xmath77 as @xmath78 exists and is equal to zero .
we can , therefore , assert a correspondence between zeros of @xmath77 and zeros of @xmath56 .
suppose that , at each @xmath27 , there are @xmath79 values of @xmath31 making @xmath54 singular , which we will denote by @xmath80
. if our previous assertion is correct , each element of @xmath81 will correspond to a zero of @xmath77 .
we can reasonably claim that if @xmath3is , in some sense , sufficiently accurate , precisely one of these zeros will correspond to the zero of @xmath72 necessarily found at @xmath73 for @xmath61 .
assuming that this is the case , we will denote by @xmath82 the element of @xmath81 corresponding to @xmath73 .
values of ps . determined in the generalized kohn method
should then vary slowly and smoothly with @xmath31 as it passes through @xmath82 .
indeed , as @xmath83 from either side , we would expect the values of ps .
calculated by solving ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) to converge to the value , @xmath84 , determined directly from @xmath85 where @xmath86 is again chosen so that @xmath87 $ ] . in the following section we will present results of generalized kohn calculations exhibiting anomalous behaviour due to schwartz singularities and , further , demonstrate empirically that the anomaly - free singularities do exist and that values of @xmath88 can be found . at each @xmath27 , choosing @xmath89 then defines an optimization of @xmath31 that will be seen to avoid anomalies in ps .
due to schwartz singularities .
in our generalized kohn calculations , we have obtained values of @xmath90 $ ] using ( [ eq : principle ] ) and ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) , for a range of positron momenta .
spurious singularities have been accounted for by performing calculations over @xmath91 different values of @xmath31 equidistant in the range @xmath10 . for the results presented here ,
we have taken @xmath92 .
calculations for a large number of @xmath31 values can be carried out with minimal additional computational effort , as it can be shown that the matrix elements of @xmath54 and @xmath55 for any @xmath31 are readily available from the elements of @xmath93 and @xmath94 via an orthogonal transformation .
it is helpful to carry out calculations for large @xmath91 as it allows a detailed examination of the behaviour of ps .
very close to schwartz singularities to be made .
values of ps . over the @xmath91 values of @xmath31 are given in figure [ fig : ps2d ] for @xmath95 , corresponding to a positron energy of @xmath96 ev .
anomalous results due to a schwartz singularity are clearly evident around @xmath97 .
we have indicated the value of @xmath31 giving rise to the singularity by a dashed line . away from this value of @xmath31 , the variation in ps .
is small . at @xmath95 . ] in figure [ fig : cot ] we have studied the behaviour of @xmath77 close to the singularity at @xmath97 , by calculating @xmath77 for @xmath98 values of @xmath31 equidistant in the range @xmath99 $ ] .
we have again indicated the position of the singularity in this figure by a dashed line .
the results shown in the figure suggest that @xmath77 converges smoothly to zero as @xmath100 from either side , supporting the assertion made in section [ ss : singularities ] regarding the correspondence of the zeros in @xmath77 and @xmath56 .
we have found that behaviour of the type shown in figure [ fig : cot ] is a general feature of the calculation . at @xmath95 for values of @xmath31 either side of a singularity . ] using ( [ eq : tautrans ] ) and ( [ eq : mata ] ) , it is straightforward to show that @xmath101 where @xmath102 , @xmath103 and @xmath104 are constants with respect to variations in @xmath31 . for a given positron momentum , the constants , @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 , can be determined by calculating @xmath56directly from @xmath108 at particular values of @xmath31 . strictly speaking , in our calculations
we have evaluated @xmath109 , @xmath110 being the approximation to @xmath54 whose elements have been determined using numerical integration .
we will assume that the values of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 are not unduly sensitive to small changes in the elements of @xmath54 and henceforth take @xmath111 and @xmath109 to be essentially equivalent . at each @xmath27 ,
provided that @xmath112 , the values , @xmath60 , making @xmath54 singular can be found by solving the quadratic equation in @xmath113 , @xmath114 if only @xmath31 is varied , and unless @xmath115 , there will be no more than two zeros of @xmath56 in the range @xmath10 .
figure [ fig : det2d ] shows @xmath56as a function of @xmath31 at @xmath95 .
the scale on the vertical axis is unimportant , since the value of @xmath56at each @xmath27 can be made arbitrarily large or small by a choice of the normalization constant , @xmath28 .
the result of interest in the figure is that it indicates two values of @xmath31 at which @xmath54 is singular . at @xmath95 for @xmath116 . ]
the anomalous behaviour in figure [ fig : ps2d ] corresponds directly to the singularity observed at @xmath97 in figure [ fig : det2d ] . however , there are no anomalies in figure [ fig : ps2d ] corresponding to the singularity at @xmath117 in figure [ fig : det2d ] , suggesting that this singularity is of the anomaly - free type described in the previous section .
we have examined this phenomenon at other values of the positron momentum .
figure [ fig : smap ] indicates the roots of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) for @xmath118 different positron momenta equidistant in the range @xmath119 , corresponding to a positron energy range from @xmath120 mev to @xmath121 ev . for the majority of positron momenta considered here , @xmath105 ,
@xmath106 and @xmath107 are such that there are two values of @xmath60 at each @xmath27 , the exceptions being @xmath122 and @xmath123 , for which we have found no real - valued solutions of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) .
it is apparent from figure [ fig : smap ] that the roots of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) lie in two families of curves .
the first family spans the entire range , @xmath58 , for @xmath124 .
the second family is confined to values of @xmath60 in the range @xmath125 $ ] for all positron momenta considered here . for almost every @xmath27 where real roots exist ,
there is precisely one root corresponding to each family .
the exception is the result at @xmath126 , where there is an irregularity in the otherwise smooth behaviour of @xmath60 over @xmath27 .
we will discuss this phenomenon in more detail in section [ ss : persistent ] . for @xmath127 . ] to illustrate anomalies in ps . at different values of @xmath27 , it is convenient to define the function , @xmath128 where , at each @xmath27 , @xmath129 is the median value of @xmath59 evaluated over the @xmath91 values of @xmath31 .
@xmath130 measures the degree to which a given @xmath131 can be considered anomalous .
the values of @xmath130 are shown in figure [ fig : psmap ] .
for clarity , we have included results only for @xmath132 values of @xmath27 equidistant in the range @xmath133 , rather than the @xmath118 values used for figure [ fig : smap ] .
the omission of the results for @xmath126 in this figure also allows us to delay until section [ ss : persistent ] the discussion of the atypical singularity observed at this value of @xmath27 in figure [ fig : smap ] . for @xmath133 . ]
it is clear from figure [ fig : psmap ] that anomalies are observed corresponding to only the first of the two families of curves identified from figure [ fig : smap ] .
this is strong evidence that the curve for which no anomalies are observed comprises legitimately occurring singularities .
it is interesting to note that the size of the anomalies due to the schwartz singularities become noticeably smaller in figure [ fig : psmap ] as they tend to coincide with the apparently anomaly - free singularities . denoting by @xmath134 the values of @xmath31 describing the anomaly - free curve , at each @xmath27 we expect that , as @xmath135 , the values of ps .
calculated over @xmath31 will converge smoothly to the value , @xmath84 , determined directly from ( [ eq : afm ] ) and taking @xmath136 .
we have found in our calculations that this is indeed the case , and an example is shown in figure [ fig : convergence ] for @xmath95 .
@xmath59 to [ ] @xmath84 as @xmath83 at @xmath95 . ]
we can reasonably conclude that we have encountered anomaly - free singularities .
before we can develop an optimization for @xmath31 based on these singularities , however , there are two outstanding issues to be addressed .
firstly , we have already noted that no real - valued solutions of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) were found at @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
this is potentially problematic as , for a sufficiently accurate trial function , we should expect at least one real root of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) at each @xmath27 , corresponding to an anomaly - free singularity .
however , inspection of figure [ fig : smap ] shows that the solutions of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) are close together in the regions either side of @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
were the two roots to coincide at some @xmath27 , then @xmath137 .
near a point of coincidence , @xmath138 and small errors in the values of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 could erroneously give rise to @xmath139 .
the values of @xmath31 solving ( [ eq : qeq ] ) at @xmath122 and @xmath123 were found to be , respectively , @xmath140 and @xmath141 . in both cases ,
the fact that @xmath142\ll\re\left[\tau_{\mathrm{s}}\right]$ ] suggests that singularities do genuinely exist for @xmath143 at these values of @xmath27 , but small errors in our calculations of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 due to inexact numerical integration have prevented us from finding them .
having investigated this problem in more detail , in figure [ fig : imroot ] we show the calculated values of @xmath142 $ ] for @xmath144 values of @xmath27 equidistant in the range @xmath145 .
there is a clearly defined region of @xmath27 where no real roots of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) have been found . the smoothness of @xmath142 $ ] over @xmath27 in this region does not necessarily preclude the notion that the failure to find real - valued solutions is due to small numerical errors in our calculations .
it is conceivable that inaccuracies in the calculated values of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 could also arise from systematic errors in the algorithm @xcite used to calculate the determinants .
nevertheless , the results illustrated in figure [ fig : imroot ] are interesting ; their exact origin may be speculated upon and will remain a subject of our ongoing investigations .
$ ] for @xmath145 . ]
the second difficulty concerns the choice of @xmath146 from the two available solutions of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) .
a method is needed for identifying at each @xmath27 the root of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) corresponding to a legitimate singularity .
this can easily be achieved by inspecting values of ps . at values of @xmath31 either side of each singularity , although this approach is not ideal as it requires solutions of ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) to be found . in practice , at each @xmath27 it should be possible to determine by inspection which of the two phase shifts is anomaly - free by examining corresponding results at singularities for nearby values of @xmath27 .
for example , figure [ fig : smap ] clearly shows that only one curve in the @xmath147 plane corresponds to a physically acceptable variation of phase shift over @xmath27 . with these considerations in mind
, we claim that choosing @xmath148 at each @xmath27 defines a consistent optimization that can be used to avoid anomalies due to schwartz singularities appearing at other values of @xmath31 . to evaluate the success of this approach , we have found it helpful to consider an alternative optimization of @xmath31 . for the calculations of ps .
carried out with @xmath92 , choosing the value of @xmath31 at each @xmath27 giving rise to the median phase shift , @xmath149 , should also mitigate anomalous behaviour . in figure
[ fig : comparison ] we have compared results for @xmath150 and @xmath151 for momenta in the range @xmath124 . here , of the two candidates for @xmath84 corresponding to the two singularities , at each @xmath27
we have chosen the one whose absolute value is closest to @xmath152 .
for clarity , we have included in the figure values of @xmath151 for only @xmath132 values of @xmath27 equidistant in the range @xmath153 . , [ ] @xmath150 and [ ] @xmath151 . ] both optimization schemes successfully avoid anomalous behaviour at most values of @xmath27 and there is good agreement between the two sets of results at all momenta .
however , the intriguing feature of the figure is the anomaly appearing in both sets of results at @xmath154 . for @xmath150
, we have shown this anomaly in greater detail by including in the figure results of a further @xmath118 kohn calculations for momenta equidistant in the range @xmath155 , although it is practical to consider henceforth only the anomalous behaviour occurring precisely at @xmath126 .
we believe the anomaly shown in figure [ fig : comparison ] is of a different type to those shown in figure [ fig : psmap ] , which are due to singularities found by varying only @xmath31 at a given @xmath27 . in the following section we will examine the circumstances under which persistent anomalies of the kind shown in figure [ fig : comparison ] could appear , before going on to discuss methods designed to avoid them . it is often claimed that anomalous results observed in the region of singularities arise from @xmath54 having a determinant close to zero .
statements of this kind can be misleading , as the determinant of any nonsingular @xmath54 can be made arbitrarily close to zero by an appropriate scalar multiplication , without altering the sensitivity of the solution , @xmath57 , to small errors in the elements of @xmath54 or @xmath55 . a better measure for identifying regions where anomalies may occur
is the condition number , @xmath156 , defined for nonsingular @xmath54 .
the condition number is independent of the normalization constant , @xmath28 , and for the linear system ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) is defined as the maximum ratio of the relative error in @xmath57 and the relative error in @xmath55 .
formally , it can be shown that @xmath157 with respect to some matrix norm , @xmath158 @xcite .
the value of @xmath156is dependent upon the choice of norm . in our calculations
, we have considered the matrix 1-norm @xcite of @xmath54 , @xmath159 where @xmath160 is the element in the @xmath161 row and @xmath162 column of @xmath54 . in
what follows , the particular choice of the 1-norm in our calculations will implicitly be assumed .
a matrix with a large condition number is said to be ill - conditioned , and the solution of the corresponding linear system may not be reliable if the elements of @xmath54 and @xmath55 are not known exactly . for any invertible @xmath54 , the condition number can be used to formalize the definition of closeness to singularity in the following way .
if @xmath163 is defined to be any matrix such that @xmath164 is singular , then the relative distance to singularity , @xmath165 , for @xmath54 , is defined @xcite to be @xmath166 this definition holds for any consistent norm . further , if @xmath165and @xmath156are evaluated using the same choice of norm , it can be shown @xcite that @xmath167^{-1}.\ ] ] in section [ ss : pscalcs ] we noted that ( [ eq : qeq ] ) has , in general , no more than two zeros if only variations of @xmath10 are considered .
however , if @xmath115 then @xmath56is identically zero independently of @xmath31 and no consistent value of phase shift can be calculated , either by solving ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) or directly from ( [ eq : afm ] ) .
there is no obvious physical reason why this circumstance should arise at any @xmath168 .
however , it is conceivable that @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 could coincidentally be close to zero , in some sense , over a narrow range of @xmath27 .
small errors in the evaluation of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 could then give rise to both unreliable solutions of ( [ eq : qeq ] ) and persistent anomalies in the calculation of ps .
due to ill - conditioning in the kohn equations ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) . to see how the latter case arises , using ( [ eq : detan ] ) we note that @xmath169,\\ \mathcal{a}&=&\det\left[a\left(\tau=\frac{\pi}{2}\right)\right],\\ \mathcal{b}&=&2\det\left[a\left(\tau=\frac{\pi}{4}\right)\right]-\mathcal{a}-\mathcal{c},\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that the notion of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 being close to zero is immediately formalized in terms of @xmath165at @xmath32 , @xmath170 and @xmath171 . in our calculations , we have used a numerical algorithm @xcite to calculate @xmath172 , an estimate of @xmath165 .
values of @xmath172at @xmath32 , @xmath170 and @xmath171 are shown in figure [ fig : abc ] for @xmath118 values of @xmath27 in the range @xmath173 .
values of @xmath172for @xmath32 and @xmath170 are anomalously small at @xmath154 , with the values for @xmath172at @xmath171 also passing through a clear minimum at @xmath174 .
ordinarily , we would not expect ill - conditioning to occur over a very broad range of @xmath31 at a given @xmath27 . at @xmath126
, the small values of @xmath172at @xmath32 , @xmath170 and @xmath171 therefore point to a manifestation of ill - conditioning which is unusually widespread in @xmath31 .
in fact , in our calculations we have failed to find any value of @xmath10 such that @xmath54 is sufficiently well - conditioned to avoid anomalous results at @xmath126 . we have also confirmed that @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 all pass through zero at least once between @xmath126 and @xmath175 . over @xmath27 for [ ] @xmath32 , [ ] @xmath176 and [ ] @xmath177 .
] we can conclude that both optimization schemes developed in section [ ss : pscalcs ] successfully avoid anomalies due to schwartz singularities whose existence depends only upon the choice of @xmath31 .
however , at certain values of @xmath27 , @xmath54 can become close to singularities whose existence is independent of @xmath31 , resulting in anomalies in the calculation of ps .
that persist even after @xmath31 has been optimized . in attempting to address this problem ,
a number of methods are available . in principle ,
anomalous behaviour can be reduced dramatically by allowing the kohn trial wavefunction to be complex - valued @xcite .
an alternative approach for avoiding anomalies persistent in @xmath31 is to make a small change in some other parameter of the trial wavefunction .
we will explore both of these techniques in the following section .
the complex kohn method is an extension of the original variational approach in which the boundary conditions of the trial wavefunction are complex .
it was originally believed @xcite that this method was anomaly - free , although anomalies were subsequently reported by lucchese @xcite . for our complex kohn calculations on @xmath0scattering ,
we have used a trial wavefunction , @xmath178 , of the form @xmath179 where @xmath180 the functions @xmath33and @xmath36 being the same as in ( [ eq : trialwave ] ) .
the unknowns @xmath181 and @xmath182 will not , in general , be real .
application of the variational principle to ( [ eq : complextrialwave ] ) leads to a matrix equation analogous to ( [ eq : kohneq ] ) , @xmath183 where @xmath184 and @xmath185 are identical to @xmath54 and @xmath55 , but for the function , @xmath186 , replacing @xmath187 in ( [ eq : mata ] ) and ( [ eq : vecb ] ) .
the determinant , @xmath188 , conveniently reduces to @xmath189 where @xmath190 is a complex constant with respect to variations in @xmath31 .
the values of @xmath188 then describes a circle of radius @xmath191 in the complex plane for variations of @xmath10 .
hence , singularities are obtained only if both the real and imaginary parts of @xmath192 are zero ; they can neither be located nor avoided by varying only @xmath31 .
we would therefore expect anomalous results due to singularities arising from the choice of @xmath31 at a given @xmath27 to be eliminated in the complex kohn method .
however , from ( [ eq : dabc ] ) we would also expect @xmath192 to be close to zero at @xmath126 , in the same sense that @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 have already been seen to be close to zero at this value of @xmath27 .
it is therefore likely that the anomalies already seen to occur due to relationships between @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 rather than the choice of @xmath31 , will persist even in the complex kohn method .
we have obtained values of ps . using the trial function , @xmath178 .
we have found that the differences in the calculated values of ps . at different values of @xmath10 are negligible , for all positron momenta considered here . without loss of generality , we can regard the complex kohn calculation as effectively independent of @xmath31 and choose @xmath32 for simplicity . in figure
[ fig : methcomp ] we have compared results for @xmath193 obtained with the trial function , @xmath178 , with the results for @xmath150 obtained in section [ ss : pscalcs ] with @xmath3 .
@xmath150 , determined using the trial function , @xmath3 , with [ ] @xmath193 , evaluated using the complex kohn method with the trial function , @xmath178 . ]
the results of the two methods are essentially equivalent at all positron momenta , with the optimized results for @xmath3differing from the results for @xmath178by no more than @xmath194 at each @xmath27 .
as expected , the complex kohn method automatically avoids anomalies at most values of @xmath27 without the need for an optimization of @xmath31 .
nevertheless , the use of the complex trial function has predictably failed to remove the persistent anomaly at @xmath126 . in figure
[ fig : d ] we verify that @xmath195 is anomalously small at @xmath154 for @xmath32 .
we have found that differences between the results shown in figure [ fig : d ] and values of @xmath195 calculated at other values of @xmath31 are negligible .
over @xmath27 for @xmath32 . ] having failed to find a systematic remedy for the persistent anomalous behaviour , we consider a more _ ad hoc _ approach .
it should be possible to avoid any schwartz - type anomaly by some variation of parameters in the trial wavefunction .
we have found that variations in @xmath31 are not always successful , but other candidates exist . in our complex kohn calculations ,
we have varied the values of @xmath196 and @xmath197 in ( [ eq : srcf ] ) , fixing @xmath32 .
recall that the values of the these parameters have so far remained fixed at @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
we now consider the results of kohn calculations carried out for @xmath144 different values of @xmath196 in the range @xmath198 $ ] and @xmath199 different values of @xmath197 in the range @xmath200 $ ] . at @xmath126 . ] to illustrate persistent anomalous behaviour , it is helpful to define a function analogous to ( [ eq : delta1 ] ) , @xmath201 where , for each of the values of @xmath196 considered , @xmath202 is the median value of ps . evaluated across the range of values of @xmath197 .
values of @xmath203 are shown in figure [ fig : psssurf ] , from which it is clear that persistent anomalies appear distributed about a curve in the @xmath204 plane . for values of @xmath196 and
@xmath197 away from this curve , the calculations are free of anomalies .
hence , a small change in the values of @xmath196 or @xmath197 can indeed be shown to successfully avoid persistent anomalous behaviour . at @xmath126 . ] finally , we consider briefly that the shielding parameter , @xmath23 , in ( [ eq : cosopenchannel ] ) and ( [ eq : chi ] ) might also be varied in an effort to avoid anomalous behaviour .
values of ps . at @xmath126 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 for @xmath205 are shown in figure [ fig : varygamma ] .
it is apparent that small changes in the value of @xmath23 have relatively little effect on the persistent anomaly at @xmath126 .
this is not unexpected , being consistent with the findings of lucchese @xcite , who investigated the effect of varying a parameter analogous to @xmath23 in his model potential calculations .
he noted that singularities due to the choice of @xmath23 occurred when the values of @xmath23 and @xmath196 were not similar , most typically when @xmath206 . with this in mind , and from inspection of figures [ fig : psssurf ] and [ fig : varygamma ] , we can conclude that the anomaly observed in figure [ fig : methcomp ] is due primarily to the choices of @xmath196 and @xmath197 rather than the choice of @xmath23 .
we have carried out a thorough examination of singularities and related anomalous behaviour in generalized kohn calculations for @xmath0scattering . we have argued that singularities do not always occur spuriously and that variational calculations of the scattering phase shift can be anomaly - free at these singularities .
subsequently , we have developed an optimization scheme for choosing a free parameter of the trial wavefunction allowing anomaly - free values of the phase shift to be determined without the need to solve the linear system of equations derived from the kohn variational principle .
this approach has been seen to be largely successful , giving phase shifts in close agreement with those determined by a conventional generalization of the kohn method , as well as those obtained with the complex kohn method .
persistent anomalies in both sets of calculations have been identified and attributed to singularities that can not be avoided with any choice of the parameter , @xmath31 .
further , we have found that our implementation of the complex kohn method is susceptible to the same behaviour .
we have demonstrated , however , that persistent anomalies can be avoided by small changes in the nonlinear parameters of the short - range correlation functions .
hence , by studying the behaviour of @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 over @xmath27 , we can predict the appearance of persistent anomalous behaviour quantitatively and avoid it by an appropriate change in @xmath196 or @xmath197 .
we wish to thank john humberston for valuable discussions .
this work is supported by epsrc ( uk ) grant ep / c548019/1 .
99 kohn w 1948 176372 nesbet r k 1980 _ variational methods in electron - atom scattering theory _
( new york : plenum ) massey h s w and ridley r o 1956 _ proc .
soc . _ a * 69 * 65967 schneider b i and rescigno t n 1988 a * 37 * 374954 van reeth p and humberston j w 1995 l5117 van reeth p , humberston j w , iwata k , greaves r g and surko c m 1996 l46571 van reeth p and humberston j w 1999 365167 armour e a g , baker d j and plummer m 1990 305774 cooper j n and armour e a g 2008 b * 266 * 4527 cooper j n , armour e a g and plummer m 2008 245201 schwartz c 1961 3650 schwartz c 1961 146871 nesbet r k 1968 13442 brownstein k r and mckinley w a 1968 125566 shimamura i 1971 85270 takatsuka k and fueno t 1979 a * 19 * 10117 mccurdy c w , rescigno t n and schneider b i 1987 a * 36 * 20616 lucchese r r 1989 a * 40 * 687985 feshbach h 1962 287313 chung k t and chen j c y 1971 11124 charlton m and humberston j w 2005 _ positron physics _ ( _ cambridge monographs on atomic , molecular and chemical physics _
vol 11 ) ed a dalgarno ( cambridge : cambridge university press ) temkin a and vasavada k v 1967 10917 temkin a , vasavada k v , chang e s and silver a 1969 5766 flammer c 1957 _ spheroidal wave functions _
( stanford : stanford university press ) kato t 1950 475 kato t 1951 _ prog .
* 6 * 394407 bransden b h and joachain c j 2003 _ physics of atoms and molecules _
( harlow : prentice hall ) hylleraas e a 1929 34766 armour e a g and baker d j 1987 610519 armour e a g 1988 _ phys .
rep . _ * 169 * 198 armour e a g , todd a c , jonsell s , liu y , gregory m r and plummer m 2008 b * 266 * 3638 higham n j 2002 _ accuracy and stability of numerical algorithms _
( philadelphia : society for industrial and applied mathematics ) armour e a g and humberston j w 1991 _ phys .
rep . _ * 204 * 165251 http://www.nag.co.uk/numeric/fl/manual20/pdf/f03/f03aaf.pdf http://www.nag.co.uk/numeric/fl/manual20/pdf/f07/f07agf.pdf | we have carried out an analysis of singularities in kohn variational calculations for low energy @xmath0elastic scattering . provided that a sufficiently accurate trial wavefunction is used , we argue that our implementation of the kohn variational principle necessarily gives rise to singularities which are not spurious .
we propose two approaches for optimizing a free parameter of the trial wavefunction in order to avoid anomalous behaviour in scattering phase shift calculations , the first of which is based on the existence of such singularities .
the second approach is a more conventional optimization of the generalized kohn method .
close agreement is observed between the results of the two optimization schemes ; further , they give results which are seen to be effectively equivalent to those obtained with the complex kohn method .
the advantage of the first optimization scheme is that it does not require an explicit solution of the kohn equations to be found .
we give examples of anomalies which can not be avoided using either optimization scheme but show that it is possible to avoid these anomalies by considering variations in the nonlinear parameters of the trial function . |
advances in nanofabrication and characterization techniques have enabled the engineering of nanostructured surfaces with geometric features as small as a few nanometers @xcite . at nanoscales , the interplay between intermolecular forces , brownian motion , and surface structure can give rise to complex interfacial phenomena that are challenging for the application of conventional , continuum - based and deterministic , models @xcite .
for example , nanoscale surface structures can induce energy barriers that lead to wetting processes governed by thermally - activated transitions between metastable states @xcite .
these thermally - activated transitions can result in directed transport of fluids and solutes when there is directional asymmetry of the energy barriers induced by the physicochemical structure of the confining surfaces @xcite .
analogous mechanisms for rectification of thermal motion into directed transport underlie fundamental biological processes such as selective charge transport in ion channels or translocation of proteins across cellular membranes .
physical systems where thermal fluctuations are able to drive net directional motion , while performing work against `` load '' or resistance forces , are known as thermal ratchets or brownian motors and have been extensively studied in the framework of statistical physics @xcite .
thermal ratchets can operate without thermal or chemical gradients provided that the system has not reached all necessary conditions for thermodynamic equilibrium @xcite .
a variety of novel nano / microfluidic devices perform as thermal ratchets to accomplish the handling , separation , and detection of diverse solutes ( e.g. , dna , macromolecules , ionic species ) and/or colloidal particles with an unprecedented precision @xcite
. these devices usually work with single - phase fluid solvents and must combine external electromagnetic fields , electrolyte solutes in proper concentration , and formation of electric double layers in order to induce energy landscapes with directional asymmetry ( i.e. , ratchet potentials ) .
a different class of ratchet systems involving multiphase fluids has been demonstrated to produce `` self - propulsion '' of micro- or millimeter - sized droplets by combining micro / nanostructured surfaces , thermal / chemical gradients , and/or mechanical vibration @xcite .
self - propulsion mechanisms in these multiphase systems are attributed to diverse dynamic phenomena , such as capillarity and contact angle hysteresis @xcite , or evaporation flows and the leidenfrost effect @xcite , where thermal fluctuations play a secondary role .
there is a class of multiphase ( two fluid ) system that can perform as a thermal ratchet under isothermal and incompressible conditions , with or without the presence of electrolyte solutes and net surface charge . in this class of system
the thermal ratchet mechanism is enabled by surface nanostructures that induce surface energy barriers with directional asymmetry . the particular configuration considered in this work , illustrated in fig .
[ fig:1]a , consists of two macroscopically immiscible liquids ( fluid-1 and fluid-2 ) confined in a slit - shaped channel or pore of height @xmath0 , length @xmath1 , and width @xmath2 . the surfaces confining the fluids are chemically homogeneous and neutrally charged .
one of the surfaces has a terraced structure with regular tread length @xmath3 and riser height @xmath4 [ cf .
[ fig:1]a ] of nanometric dimensions .
similar terraced structures have been synthesized on crystalline substrates via diverse nanofabrication techniques such as wet etching , high - temperature annealing , and deposition of epitaxial films @xcite .
the studied terraced structure with @xmath5 steps reduces the local height of the channel according to @xmath6 for @xmath7 ( here , @xmath8 is the floor function and @xmath9 is the coordinate in the longitudinal direction ) . in the presence of an interface between two immiscible fluids ,
the interplay between thermal motion and surface energy barriers induced by the nanoscale structure can drive imbibition and filling / drainage processes in micro / nanoscale channels or pores for a range of wettability conditions unanticipated by conventional wetting models .
analytical descriptions of thermally - driven wetting processes must consider that atoms or molecules in a liquid - fluid interface undergo thermal motion .
we will analyze the case of unidirectional motion described by the average position @xmath10 of all atoms of the first fluid species ( fluid-1 ) that lie at the front liquid - liquid interface [ cf .
[ fig:1]a ] . adopting the average interface position to describe the dynamics of the confined molecular fluids implies projecting the ( multidimensional ) system energy landscape onto a one - dimensional profile @xmath11 along a `` reaction coordinate '' @xmath9 .
the sequence of random displacements of the front interface position can be statistically described by the conditional probability density @xmath12 ; here , @xmath13 is the average interface position observed at a time @xmath14 .
the stationary probability density @xmath15 $ ] is prescribed by the free energy profile @xmath11 and the thermal energy @xmath16 ; here , @xmath17 is the corresponding partition function , @xmath18 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath19 is the system temperature . assuming overdamped brownian dynamics
, the time evolution of the probability density @xmath20 is governed by the smoluchowski diffusion equation @xmath21 p(x , t ) \label{eq : smoluchowski}\ ] ] where @xmath22 is the local friction coefficient or resistivity ( i.e. , the inverse of the mobility ) . for the studied conditions we consider a linear friction force @xmath23 that is mainly due to hydrodynamic effects and thus @xmath24 \label{eq : xi}\ ] ] where @xmath25 is a drag coefficient
, @xmath26 is the shear viscosity of the confined fluids , and @xmath5 is the total number terraces in the structure . for analytical simplicity ,
we consider in eq .
[ eq : xi ] the case that both fluid-1 and fluid-2 have the same viscosity @xmath27 ; expressions for @xmath28 can be readily derived using similar hydrodynamic arguments .
analytical estimates of the drag coefficient @xmath25 in eq .
[ eq : xi ] can be obtained by making simplifying assumptions about the modes of translation of the interface and the hydrodynamic velocity profiles induced .
a drag coefficient @xmath29 is obtained by naively assuming that a linear flow profile ( i.e. , couette flow between two flat surfaces ) develops after the sudden displacement of the contact line on one wall , while the contact line on the opposite wall remains stationary . + for isothermal and incompressible conditions and assuming sharp interfaces , the free energy profile is determined by surface energy contributions @xmath30 + \mathrm{const}. \label{eq : u}\ ] ] here , @xmath31 is the interfacial energy of the liquid - liquid interface , @xmath32 is the young contact angle measured on the fluid-1 phase , and @xmath33 is the area of the interface between the fluid-1 and solid phases . in the studied configuration the distance between the front and
rear liquid - liquid interfaces is larger than the length of the terraced structure , which allows us to simplify the analysis . while the front interface moves inside each terrace there is a linear change in the interfacial area @xmath34 that results from conservation of volume , and
thus we have @xmath35 for @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) .
+ the energy profile @xmath11 ( eq . [ eq : u ] ) exhibits sharp energy increments @xmath38 when moving in the negative @xmath9-direction across the edge of a terrace at position @xmath39 ( @xmath37 ) . hence ,
periodic energy barriers @xmath40 at regular steps @xmath3 hinder backward random displacements as the liquid - liquid interface undergoes thermal motion along the terraced surface .
the time to cross over an energy barrier induced by nanoscale surface features can be predicted via kramers theory of thermally - activated transitions , as documented in prior work @xcite . for the present analysis
, it suffices to recognize that a mean time @xmath41 must elapse before observing a backward displacement of the interface over a terrace edge .
therefore , over a time interval @xmath42 the presence of the energy barrier @xmath40 can be treated as a reflective boundary condition for eq .
[ eq : smoluchowski ] imposed at the edge of each terrace .
furthermore , the friction coefficient ( eq . [ eq : xi ] ) and the wetting or capillary force ( eq . [ eq : dudx ] ) remain constant within each of the @xmath5 terraces .
hence , we have @xmath43 and @xmath44 for @xmath45 , which facilitates the analytical solution of eq .
[ eq : smoluchowski ] . in order to solve eq .
[ eq : smoluchowski ] within each terrace for which the edge lies at @xmath39 , it is convenient to introduce the dimensionless position @xmath46 and time @xmath47 .
in addition , we introduce the dimensionless force parameter @xmath48 given by the ratio of the work performed by the wetting force to the thermal energy within each terrace . for a reflective boundary at @xmath49 and initial condition @xmath50 the analytical solution of eq .
[ eq : smoluchowski ] is given by @xcite @xmath51 , where @xmath52 + \frac{1}{2 } c_n \exp\left[-c_n\overline{x}\right ] \mathrm{erfc}\left[\frac{(\overline{x}-c_n \overline{t})}{\sqrt{4\overline{t}}}\right ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] is a dimensionless function determined by the variables @xmath53 and @xmath54 for a given force parameter @xmath55 .
the mean displacement of the front liquid - liquid interface according to eq .
[ eq : pn ] is @xmath56 , where @xmath57 is the dimensionless mean displacement within the @xmath58-th terrace . taking the upper integration limit to infinity in eq .
[ eq : meandx ] is an approximation valid for finite times @xmath59 . from eq .
[ eq : meandx ] we can estimate the mean time @xmath60 at which @xmath61 ( @xmath62 ) . here , @xmath63 is the inverse of the dimensionless mean displacement function in eq .
[ eq : meandx ] and @xmath64 is the time at which @xmath65 .
a few comments aobout the derived expressions are in order .
analytical integration in eq .
[ eq : meandx ] is feasible and thus the dimensionless time @xmath66 to traverse the @xmath58-th terrace ( @xmath37 ) can be obtained by solving the implicit equation @xmath67 . the inverse function @xmath68 in eq .
[ eq : tn ] is uniquely determined by the dimensionless force parameter @xmath48 ; the function @xmath69 diverges at @xmath70 and decays @xmath71 for @xmath72 .
an approximate explicit expression @xmath73 can be obtained from a first - order taylor expansion of eq .
[ eq : pn ] about @xmath74 ; this approximation yields less than 10% error for @xmath75 .
for a neutral contact angle @xmath76 the wetting force vanishes @xmath77 and thus @xmath78 for @xmath37 . moreover , under neutral wetting conditions eq .
[ eq : meandx ] predicts a mean displacement @xmath79 characteristic of diffusive processes , with an effective diffusivity @xmath80 .
notably , forward liquid displacements @xmath81 against wetting forces @xmath82 are expected to occur for contact angles @xmath83 provided that @xmath84 .
, length @xmath1 , and width @xmath85 ) confining two immiscible liquids . a terraced structure ( tread @xmath3 and riser @xmath4 ) of nanoscale dimensions lies on the bottom wall .
( b ) volume fraction @xmath86 in different md realizations and its ensemble average @xmath87 ( time reported in md units @xmath88 @xmath89 1 ps ) .
md simulations correspond to @xmath90 and @xmath91 under neutral wetting conditions @xmath76 .
dashed lines indicate filling fractions @xmath92 for @xmath93 ( @xmath62 ) .
( c ) sequence of three time instances in md simulations for contact angles @xmath32 @xmath89 8595@xmath94 .
imbibition of fluid-1 into the volume @xmath95 above the terraced structure is observed for @xmath96 when capillary forces are neutral or negative @xmath97 .
, title="fig : " ] -5pt -10pt in order to verify analytical predictions and underlying assumptions we perform fully atomistic molecular dynamics ( md ) to simulate the dynamics arising from couplings between brownian motion , hydrodynamic effects , and wetting forces
. the md techniques employed in this work are extensively described in the literature @xcite and prior work by the authors @xcite .
the simulated system [ see fig .
1a ] comprises two monatomic liquids ( atomic species @xmath98 ) labeled as fluid-1 and fluid-2 , and a crystalline solid ( atomic species @xmath99 ) .
atomic interactions are modeled by pairwise lennard - jones potentials @xmath100 $ ] , where @xmath101 is a characteristic interaction energy , @xmath102 is a symmetric attraction coefficient between species ( @xmath103 ) , @xmath4 is the interatomic distance between any two atoms , and @xmath104 is the diameter of the repulsive core , which roughly correspond to the atomic diameter . following conventional techniques for computational efficiency ,
atomic interactions are not computed for @xmath105 .
the time scale of atomic displacements is @xmath106 and is in the order of picoseconds for simple molecular liquids ; the atomic mass @xmath107 of the liquid species is set to be equal for both modeled liquids .
the equations of motion are integrated using a fifth - order prediction - correction algorithm with a time step @xmath108 .
a nose - hoover thermostat @xcite models the interaction with a thermal bath , regulating the system temperature to a prescribed value . in all md simulations in this work
the prescribed temperature is @xmath109 , the mean number density is @xmath110 and the shear viscosity is @xmath111 for both liquids .
solid atoms form a face - cubic - centered ( fcc ) lattice with uniform spacing @xmath112 ; typical values of @xmath113 for crystalline solids range between 0.2 and 0.5 nm .
the set of values employed for the attraction coefficients ( @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , and @xmath117 ) render two macroscopically immiscible fluids with a liquid - liquid interfacial tension @xmath118 and young contact angles near neutral wetting conditions @xmath119 .
the studied geometric configuration [ cf . fig . [ fig:1]a ] consists of a slit nanoscale channel of height @xmath0 = 3060@xmath113 , length @xmath1 = 70@xmath113 , and width @xmath85 = 10@xmath113 ; periodic boundary conditions are applied in the @xmath9- and @xmath120-direction .
the bottom wall has different surface structures with @xmath5 = 511 terraces of length @xmath3 = 39@xmath113 and riser height @xmath4 = 12@xmath113 .
the volume confined above the terraced structure is @xmath121 $ ] .
the fluid-1 phase fills a fraction @xmath122 of the volume @xmath95 as the front liquid interface moves within @xmath123 [ cf .
[ fig:1]a ] . in our md simulations ,
the number density is constant and the filling fraction @xmath124 is directly computed from the number of atoms of fluid-1 , @xmath125 , and fluid-2 , @xmath126 , occupying the volume @xmath95 . at initialization ,
the volume @xmath95 is fully occupied by the fluid-2 phase and thus @xmath127 .
the filling fraction @xmath86 for six md realizations and the ensemble average @xmath128 are reported in fig .
[ fig:1]b for one of the studied structures ( @xmath90 , @xmath129 ) and neutral wetting conditions ( @xmath130 ) . as seen in figs .
[ fig:1]b , the mean filling fraction @xmath128 uniformly increases with time while individual md realizations exhibit rapid transitions between `` long - lived '' metastable states at specific values @xmath131 ( @xmath62 ) .
the imbibition process occurs within a range of young contact angles @xmath132 [ cf .
fig [ fig:1]c ] for which capillary forces can be neutral or negative ( @xmath133 ) .
displacement beyond the last terrace edge , where @xmath134 , is prevented by a large energy barrier @xmath135 . , @xmath136 ) ; @xmath39 ( @xmath62 ) and @xmath136 given by eq .
[ eq : tn ] .
markers : ensemble average quantities from md simulations [ see legends ] .
geometric dimensions are in lattice units : channel height @xmath137 = 3060 , terrace length @xmath138 = 36 , riser height @xmath139 = 12 . ( a)(c )
imbibition under neutral wetting @xmath76 : ( a ) mean filling fraction @xmath128 ( time in md units @xmath88 ) ; ( b ) dimensionless displacement @xmath140 where @xmath141 ; ( c ) dimensionless displacement @xmath142 for different channel heights .
( d ) dimensionless displacement @xmath140 for contact angles @xmath32 = 85@xmath94 , 90@xmath94 , 95@xmath94 , and 98@xmath94 for which @xmath143 = 0.7 , 0 , -0.7 , and -1 , respectively .
, title="fig : " ] -5pt -20pt [ fig:2 ] theoretical predictions from eq .
[ eq : tn ] for mean displacements , @xmath61 , and filling fractions , @xmath144 , are in close agreement with md simulations reported in figs .
[ fig:2][fig:3 ] when using @xmath25 = 45.5 in eq .
[ eq : xi ] for different structures . as seen in fig .
[ fig:2]a , the mean filling rate is approximately constant @xmath145 under neutral wetting conditions @xmath146 for the different studied structures .
notably , mean displacements @xmath147 collapse to a unique curve when scaling by the terrace length @xmath3 and diffusion time @xmath148 as showed in fig .
[ fig:2]b ; here , @xmath149 is the resistivity in eq .
[ eq : xi ] for @xmath150 . as shown in fig .
[ fig:2]c , increasing the channel height @xmath0 for a given length @xmath1 enhances the interface displacement rate by decreasing the local resistivity @xmath22 .
the effect of varying the contact angle @xmath32 and thus the wetting force @xmath151 ( eq .
[ eq : tn ] ) can be seen in fig .
[ fig:2]d .
for @xmath152 the mean displacement is enhanced by positive wetting forces @xmath153 . as predicted ,
positive displacements still can be observed for @xmath154 when @xmath155 ; the most adverse wetting force @xmath156 corresponds to @xmath157 ( @xmath158 , @xmath159 ) in fig .
[ fig:2]d . in md simulations for large terrace length @xmath160 and two riser heights @xmath161 = 12 ( @xmath32 = 90@xmath94 , @xmath162 ) .
( b ) schematic of the failure and onset of diffusive motion with zero mean displacement for @xmath163 .
, title="fig : " ] -10pt
-20pt [ fig:3 ] results reported in fig . [ fig:2 ] confirm that a thermal ratchet mechanism mediated by surface energy barriers @xmath38 can lead to thermally - driven transport of immiscible liquids in slit channels or pores .
this phenomenon is expected to occur provided that the time @xmath164 to cross over each energy barrier is larger than the time @xmath165 ( eq . [ eq : tn ] ) to traverse the @xmath58-th terrace .
indeed , md simulations for large terrace length @xmath166 and small riser height @xmath167 [ see fig [ fig:3]a ] report a decay in the mean displacement rate after a time @xmath168 . increasing the energy barrier @xmath169 by increasing the riser height to @xmath129 prevents the observed decay in the displacement rate [ see fig [ fig:3]a ] .
as illustrated in fig [ fig:3]b , the mean displacement rate is expected to vanish @xmath170 for @xmath171 , after which unbiased brownian motion persists over a time @xmath172 . for @xmath173
brownian motion with a mean square displacement @xmath174 causes the liquid - liquid interface to diffuse to the next terrace edge , after which thermal motion becomes biased , @xmath175 , and the cycle repeats .
theoretical description in the framework of statistical physics predicts that surface nanostructures with directional asymmetry can induce nontrivial wetting processes that are beyond the reach of conventional continuum - based models ( e.g. , lucas - washburn equation ) .
fully - atomistic simulations showing close agreement with theoretical predictions document the thermally - induced displacement of immiscible fluids confined in a slit channel or pore with a nanoscale terraced structure . for
the studied nanoscale systems under neutral wetting conditions , a water - air interface would exhibit mean displacement rates between 0.1 and 1 m / s . moreover
, the observed fluid displacement can oppose the action of wetting or capillary forces .
hence , the studied mechanism can induce the wetting and dewetting of nanostructured pores or capillaries under unexpected wettability conditions .
the maximum contact angle for which thermally driven imbibition or drainage occurs against the action of capillary forces is largely determined by the geomtry of the channel and terraced structure .
the analytical approach presented in this work indicates the necessity to consider the thermal motion of liquid - fluid interfaces in order to predict novel phenomena and associated useful effects . the proposed thermal ratchet mechanism enabled by engineered surface nanostructures could enable novel nanofluidic devices for passive handling and separation .
micro / nanostructured surfaces for superhydrophobic or superoleophobic behavior could exploit the thermally driven drainage of micropores and cavities to enhance their performance . in the presence of electrolyte solutes , the studied thermal ratchet mechanism could be employed to direct the transport of charges , which can potentially enable microfluidic applications for energy harvesting .
we thank a. checco and m. sbragaglia for useful discussions .
we acknowledge support from the seed grant program by brookhaven national laboratory ( bnl ) and stony brook university .
this work employed computational resources at the bnl center for functional nanomaterials supported by the u.s .
doe under contract no .
de - sc0012704 .
42ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ , ed .
( , ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) | theoretical analysis and fully atomistic molecular dynamics simulations reveal a brownian ratchet mechanism by which thermal fluctuations drive the net displacement of immiscible liquids confined in channels or pores with micro- or nanoscale dimensions .
the thermally - driven displacement is induced by surface nanostructures with directional asymmetry and can occur against the direction of action of wetting or capillary forces .
mean displacement rates in molecular dynamics simulations are predicted via analytical solution of a smoluchowski diffusion equation for the position probability density .
the proposed physical mechanisms and derived analytical expressions can be applied to engineer surface nanostructures for controlling the dynamics of diverse wetting processes such as capillary filling , wicking , and imbibition in micro- or nanoscale systems . |
in recent years the environment of andromeda has been a prime location for the discovery of dwarf galaxies and tidal structures , much of which has been enabled by large surveys on the isaac newton telescope @xcite and the canada - france - hawaii telescope @xcite .
these surveys have obtained deep observations over a significant fraction of the area within 180 kpc of andromeda , and yielded a considerable number of new discoveries .
in addition to these dedicated surveys , two satellites of andromeda have been found in the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) imaging ( and ix and x , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , using an early sdss scan targeting andromeda specifically .
more recently , the sdss project has released data release 8 ( dr8 , * ? ? ?
* ) , which adds @xmath4 deg@xmath5 of imaging coverage in the south galactic cap and covers almost half of the area within @xmath6 of andromeda . while the sdss is substantially shallower than the dedicated m31 surveys , it is deep enough to enable the discovery of relatively bright ( by today s standards ) dwarf galaxies .
it is in this new sdss coverage that we report the discovery of a dwarf galaxy , which we are preliminarily calling andromeda xxviii .
the dwarf is separated from andromeda by @xmath7 on the sky , which gives it a minimum distance to m31 of @xmath8 kpc .
this distance is significantly larger than the virial radius of andromeda ( @xmath9 kpc , * ? ? ?
* ) . and xxviii is therefore one of a handful of known examples of dwarf galaxies that are less likely to be significantly influenced by the environment of their host galaxy , which makes them important test cases for theories of dwarf galaxy formation and evolution .
at the distance of andromeda ( @xmath10 kpc , * ? ? ?
* ) , searches for dwarf galaxies in the sdss are limited to using red giant branch ( rgb ) stars as tracers of the underlying population of main - sequence and subgiant stars .
alternative tracers commonly used for detecting dwarf galaxies around the milky way , such as horizontal branch or main sequence turn - off stars , are much too faint to be detected . to detect dwarf galaxies in sdss we compute star counts in @xmath11 bins , selecting only stars with @xmath12 , colors roughly similar to metal - poor giant branch stars .
overdensities are readily apparent upon visual inspection of the resulting map as `` hot pixels '' , typically with counts of 10 - 15 objects as compared to the background of 1 - 3 objects per bin .
most of these overdensities are galaxy clusters at intermediate redshift , which contain many spatially - unresolved member galaxies that are erroneously classified as stars and have similar colors as giant branch stars
. visual inspection of the sdss image along with the color - magnitude diagram is sufficient to reject these false - positives .
the sdss image of and xxviii is shown in figure [ sdss_image ] , along with an image of and ix for comparison , and the properties of and xxviii are summarized in table [ properties_table ] .
the color - magnitude diagram of the dwarf is shown in figure [ cmd ] , along with a cmd of the field region surrounding the dwarf , a plot of measured star positions , and a histogram as a function of i - band magnitude .
these plots are also shown for and ix , another dwarf galaxy that was discovered in sdss .
an isochrone from @xcite of an old , metal - poor system ( @xmath13 gyr old , [ fe / h ] = -2.0 ) is also shown on the cmd to illustrate the position of the red giant branch .
an overdensity at @xmath14 is clearly visible .
the rgb is very wide in color , owing to considerable photometric uncertainty at very faint magnitudes in sdss , which is illustrated by the error bar on the left side of the cmd ( estimated from repeat imaging of sdss stripe 82 ; @xcite ) .
l c parameter & + @xmath15 ( j2000 ) & @xmath16 @xmath17 @xmath18 + @xmath19 ( j2000 ) & @xmath20 @xmath21 @xmath22 + e(b - v ) & 0.087 + ellipticity & @xmath23 @xmath24 @xmath25 + position angle ( n to e ) & @xmath26 @xmath24 @xmath27 + @xmath28 & @xmath29
@xmath24 @xmath30 + @xmath28 & @xmath31 pc + @xmath32 & @xmath1 kpc + @xmath33 & @xmath34 + @xmath35 & @xmath0 kpc + @xmath36 & @xmath37 +
we computed the distance to and xxviii by measuring the magnitude of the tip of the red giant branch ( trgb ) , which has a roughly constant absolute magnitude in metal - poor stellar systems @xcite .
this method has been used extensively for dwarf galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , since the trgb is often the only distinguishable feature in the color - magnitude diagram of distant systems . quantitatively measuring the position of the trgb is more complicated than it would appear from looking at the color - magnitude diagram .
this is especially true in dwarf galaxies , where the giant branch is sparsely populated and the small number counts lead to significant `` shot noise '' @xcite .
we used the maximum - likelihood estimator described in @xcite , which modeled the trgb luminosity function as @xmath38 this broken power - law form takes three parameters : @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the slopes of the luminosity function fainter and brigher than the trgb , while @xmath41 is the strength of the transition at the trgb .
we adopted the values from @xcite of @xmath42 and @xmath43 , and @xmath44 . for the trgb fit we selected stars in our rgb color cuts with magnitudes
@xmath45 to avoid incompleteness at faint magnitudes .
though the data at the faintest magnitudes are not critical for finding the position of breaks in the luminosity function that might correspond to the trgb , the faint end of the luminosity function does affect our ability to determine the statistical significance of a measured trgb position . as a result
we try to use as deep of data as possible without reaching significant photometric incompleteness .
the sdss photometry was converted to johnson i - band using the prescriptions of @xcite , and an intrinsic i - band magnitude of the trgb was assumed of @xmath46 @xcite .
the likelihood function of the model as a function of trgb position is shown in figure [ trgb_likelihood ] .
we find that the likelihood is maximized at @xmath47 , but a second peak also appears at @xmath48 ( in the gunn - i filter , @xmath49 and @xmath50 , respectively ) .
this is the result of a clump of stars slightly fainter than @xmath51 , which causes the trgb magnitude to change significantly depending on whether or not they are included as part of the rgb . though the fainter peak can not be ruled out , the trgb magnitude we quote of @xmath52 is the center of the more likely peak .
the uncertainty on this trgb value is the 67% confidence interval , which was computed by creating a cumulative probability distribution function and measuring the 16.5% through 83.5% region .
the resulting uncertainties are asymmetric , and this asymmetry will propagate into all derived quantities , but this is a natural result of the bimodal likelihood function .
the measured trgb position yields a distance modulus of @xmath34 , which places the dwarf at a heliocentric distance of @xmath1 kpc . because this is very similar to the point of closest approach to andromeda along this line of sight ( the `` tangent point '' ) , the distance between and xxviii and m31 is largely insensitive to errors in the heliocentric distance , and is measured to be @xmath53 kpc . to measure the luminosity of and xxviii , we computed luminosity functions from sdss data for three similar dwarf galaxies with known distances and luminosities ( and iii , @xmath54 , @xcite ; and v , @xmath55 , @xcite ; and x , @xmath56 , @xcite ) .
we scaled these galaxies to a fiducial luminosity and distance by correcting the dereddened apparent magnitude of each galaxy s stars for their respective distances , and by scaling the number of stars in each luminosity bin by the total luminosity of the galaxy .
we then took the mean of these profiles to produce a composite luminosity function that was less affected by the `` shot noise '' inherent in such low number count systems . since our comparison objects span a range of distances , we applied a faint - magnitude cut to ensure that the luminosity function of even the most distant comparison dwarf was still photometrically complete . for stars with colors typical of rgb stars we find that the data are complete to approximately @xmath57 ( non - dereddened ) . since the most distant comparison dwarf has a distance modulus that is greater than than of and xxviii by 0.4 , our corresponding completeness cut on and xxviii for the luminosity function comparison was @xmath58 ( @xmath59 ) .
this binned , composite luminosity function was then scaled to match that of and xxviii ( again using a maximum likelihood method to properly account for poissonian uncertainties , and with uncertainties on the comparison dwarfs luminosities included ) , and the scaling factor thus determined the luminosity of the galaxy relative to the fiducial luminosity .
this method produces results largely equivalent to the method of @xcite for relatively bright dwarfs .
the luminosity determined by this method is @xmath2 ( the large uncertainty is primarily due to the uncertainity in the distance measurement ) is generally similar to that of other local group dwarfs . to ensure that issues of photometric completeness or other systematics did not bias our composite luminosity function
, we also constructed a luminosity function from deep observations of the draco dwarf ( obtained on the canada - france - hawaii telescope , * ? ? ?
* ) , and used the same scaling method to measure the luminosity of and xxviii , which resulted in an identical value . as a final check , we compared and xxviii to the model luminosity functions of @xcite , and again obtained a luminosity that is in good agreement with the other methods ( @xmath60 ) . the considerable scatter in color of the rgb stars due to photometric error makes it difficult to determine the metallicity of the galaxy .
this uncertainty is illustrated by the cmd of and ix ( figure [ cmd ] , bottom middle - left ) , which was measured by @xcite with deep imaging to have [ fe / h ] = @xmath61 @xmath24 @xmath62 .
though the fit to the dotter isochrone is very good in the @xcite data , the sdss data show significant scatter in color and appear to be systematically offset in color from the isochrone .
it is unclear whether this is the result of inaccuracies in the isochrone or calibration error at very faint magnitudes in the sdss , but because of these uncertainties , it is not be possible to constrain the metallicity of the galaxy with the observations available .
we can nevertheless say that the cmd of and xxviii is not obviously dissimilar to other metal - poor dwarf galaxies .
we computed the radial profile of and xxviii , along with the position , half - light radius , eccentricity , and position angle using the maximum likelihood technique described by @xcite .
this method assumes an exponential profile for the dwarf galaxy and a constant background level .
figure [ profile_structure ] shows on the left maximum likelihood contours of the half - light radius , ellipticity ( @xmath63 ) , position angle ( @xmath64 ) , and number of detected stars in the overdensity within the sdss data ( @xmath65 ) , while the right side shows the radial profile fit .
the structural parameters have one - dimensional 1- , 2- , and 3-@xmath66 confidence areas overlaid .
and xxviii is well - populated enough , even in the relatively shallow sdss data , to permit easy determination of these parameters without large uncertainties .
the fact that @xmath67 is excluded at @xmath68 provides a quantitative indication that this overdensity is unlikely to be a statistical artifact .
the fact that the half - light radius is well - determined also gives confidence that the overdensity is real , since the fitting procedure usually finds unreasonably large values for @xmath28 when run on non - galaxies .
the half - light radius of @xmath69 pc is typical of other local group dwarf galaxies and is roughly the size of draco .
the position angle has a considerable uncertainty associated with it , along with some covariance with ellipticity .
these factors may make the ellipse in the top - left panel of figure [ cmd ] appear slightly misaligned when juding the fit by eye .
throughout this work we have referred to the newly discovered dwarf galaxy as andromeda xxviii , but this may not be the most accurate identifier to use .
the dwarf is actually located in the constellation pegasus , and could also be identified as pegasus ii , as is the convention with milky way and local group satellites .
however , its properties make it a likely satellite of m31 , and hence we follow the convention of naming satellites of m31 with the prefix andromeda regardless of their actual position .
since we have neither its radial velocity nor its proper motion , we certainly can not say whether the dwarf galaxy is bound to m31 , but its distance to m31 is within the range of other galaxies in the m31 system , and it is much further from the milky way than we would expect for dwarfs bound to the milky way .
if , on further study , the galaxy is determined to be unbound from m31 , then it should properly be referred to as pegasus ii .
further discussion of the complexities of dwarf galaxy names can be found in the appendix of @xcite .
the most intriguing feature of and xxviii is its large distance from andromeda , which suggests that it might not have been strongly affected by interactions with other galaxies .
this could make it a prime test case for studies of dwarf galaxy formation .
the morphology and star formation history of and xxviii are of particular interest , as dwarf galaxies in the local group that lay beyond 300 - 400 kpc from their host tend to be dwarf irregular galaxies , while those in close proximity with their host tend to be dwarf spheroidals .
this morphology - density relationship @xcite is not without exceptions ; for instance , the dwarf spheroidals tucana , cetus , and the possible dwarf spheroidal and xviii are all more than @xmath70 kpc from the nearest non - dwarf galaxy .
these distant dwarf spheroidals are a unique test for theories which suggest that dwarf spheroidals form from dwarf irregulars via tidal interactions or ram pressure stripping @xcite , since these galaxies could be in the beginning stages of such a process and could exhibit evidence of such an ongoing transformation .
if and xxviii were confirmed to be a dwarf spheroidal without any recent star formation , it would add another test case for these theories .
alternatively , if star formation is detected in and xxviii , it would be one of the lowest mass star - forming galaxies known , and roughly analagous to lgs 3 @xcite or leo t @xcite .
the ability of such low mass galaxies to retain gas and form stars is poorly understood , and identifying another member of this class of galaxies would be a benefit to efforts to further elucidate their nature . unfortunately , with shallow sdss imaging we can not conclusively determine whether or not and xxviii has ongoing or recent star formation . from the cmd of leo t , the blue - loop stars that indicate recent star formation are roughly 1.5 - 2 magnitudes fainter than the tip of the red giant branch . since the sdss data of and xxviii only extend approximately one magnitude below the trgb , blue - loop stars are not detectable .
we have also looked for hi in the galaxy using the leiden / argentine / bonn survey @xcite .
this survey clearly detects the hi gas present in lgs 3 and leo t ( @xmath71 , @xmath72 , respectively , * ? ? ?
* ) , but shows no emission from and xxviii .
this could , however , be the result of the velocity of the dwarf falling outside the bandwidth used for the survey ( @xmath73 km s@xmath74 ) , so a conclusive determination of the hi gas content will require a measurement of the radial velocity of the galaxy .
though the exact significance of and xxviii will not be known until follow - up observations are conducted , it is clear that dwarf galaxies in the outer regions of the local group are in a unique environment that enables their detailed study before their properties are significantly altered by interactions with their host galaxy upon infall .
increasing the sample of nearby but isolated dwarfs thus provides the data necessary to advance theories of dwarf galaxy formation and evolution .
this work was partially supported by nsf grant ast 1008342 .
nfm acknowledges funding by sonderforschungsbereich sfb 881 `` the milky way system '' ( subproject a3 ) of the german research foundation ( dfg ) .
we would like to thank the referees for their careful comments which improved the work .
funding for sdss - iii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s .
department of energy .
the sdss - iii web site is http://www.sdss3.org/. sdss - iii is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions of the sdss - iii collaboration including the university of arizona , the brazilian participation group , brookhaven national laboratory , university of cambridge , university of florida , the french participation group , the german participation group , the instituto de astrosica de canarias , the michigan state / notre dame / jina participation group , johns hopkins university , lawrence berkeley national laboratory , max planck institute for astrophysics , new mexico state university , new york university , the ohio state university , university of portsmouth , princeton university , university of tokyo , the university of utah , vanderbilt university , university of virginia , university of washington , and yale university .
aihara , h. , et al .
2011 , , 193 , 29 bellazzini , m. , ferraro , f. r. , & pancino , e. 2001 , , 556 , 635 bramich , d. m. , vidrih , s. , wyrzykowski , l. , et al .
2008 , , 386 , 887 collins , m. l. m. , et al . 2010 , , 407 , 2411 dotter , a. , chaboyer , b. , jevremovi , d. , kostov , v. , baron , e. , & ferguson , j. w. 2008 , , 178 , 89 ferguson , a. m. n. , irwin , m. j. , ibata , r. a. , lewis , g. f. , & tanvir , n. r. 2002 , , 124 , 1452 grcevich , j. , & putman , m. e.2009 , , 696 , 385 grebel , e. k. , gallagher , j. s. , iii , & harbeck , d. 2003 , , 125 , 1926 ibata , r. , martin , n. f. , irwin , m. , chapman , s. , ferguson , a. m. n. , lewis , g. f. , & mcconnachie , a. w. 2007 , , 671 , 1591 irwin , m. j. , et al .
2007 , , 656 , l13 irwin , m. j. , ferguson , a. m. n. , huxor , a. p. , tanvir , n. r. , ibata , r. a. , & lewis , g. f. 2008 , , 676 , l17 jordi , k. , grebel , e. k. , & ammon , k. 2006 , , 460 , 339 kalberla , p. m. w. , burton , w. b. , hartmann , d. , arnal , e. m. , bajaja , e. , morras , r. , pppel , w. g. l. 2005 , , 440 , 775 klypin , a. , zhao , h. , & somerville , r. s. 2002 , , 573 , 597 makarov , d. , makarova , l. , rizzi , l. , tully , r. b. , dolphin , a. e. , sakai , s. , & shaya , e. j. 2006 , , 132 , 2729 martin , n. f. , ibata , r. a. , irwin , m. j. , chapman , s. , lewis , g. f. , ferguson , a. m. n. , tanvir , n. , & mcconnachie , a. w. 2006 , , 371 , 1983 martin , n. f. , de jong , j. t. a. , & rix , h .- w .
2008 , , 684 , 1075 martin , n. f. , et al .
2009 , , 705 , 758 mayer , l. , mastropietro , c. , wadsley , j. , stadel , j. , & moore , b. 2006 , , 369 , 1021 mcconnachie , a. w. , irwin , m. j. , ferguson , a. m. n. , ibata , r. a. , lewis , g. f. , & tanvir , n. 2005 , , 356 , 979 mcconnachie , a. w. , & irwin , m. j. 2006 , , 365 , 1263 mcconnachie , a. w. , et al .
2009 , , 461 , 66 sgall , m. , ibata , r. a. , irwin , m. j. , martin , n. f. , & chapman , s. 2007 , , 375 , 831 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , , 500 , 525 thuan , t. x. , & martin , g. e. 1979 , , 232 , l11 weisz , d. r. , et al .
2011 , arxiv:1101.1093 zucker , d. b. , et al .
2004 , , 612 , l121 zucker , d. b. , et al .
2007 , , 659 , l21 | we report the discovery of a new dwarf galaxy , andromeda xxviii , using data from the recently - released sdss dr8 .
the galaxy is a likely satellite of andromeda , and , at a separation of @xmath0 kpc , would be one of the most distant of andromeda s satellites .
its heliocentric distance is @xmath1 kpc , and analysis of its structure and luminosity show that it has an absolute magnitude of @xmath2 and half - light radius of @xmath3 pc , similar to many other faint local group dwarfs . with presently - available imaging
we are unable to determine if there is ongoing or recent star formation , which prevents us from classifying it as a dwarf spheroidal or dwarf irregular . |
surface plasmon polaritons ( spps ) are collective oscillations of electrons occuring at the interface of materials .
more than hundred years after their discovery @xcite , spps have promoted new applications in many fields such as microelectronics @xcite , photovoltaics @xcite , near - field sensing @xcite , laser techonology @xcite , photonics @xcite , meta - materials design @xcite , high order harmonics generation @xcite , or charged particles acceleration @xcite .
most of these applications are based on expensive noble metals such as gold , silver or platinum , as these materials greatly support the plasmonic phenomena , exhibit very small ( plasmonic ) losses and the experimental results match well with the associated theory @xcite .
although there were numerous studies addressing spps in lossy materials @xcite , some specific aspects remain to be investigated . in this paper , a mathematical condition for spp excitation at flat interfaces is provided .
this approach includes the widely accepted theory but reveals a wider ( material dependent ) domain of spp excitation than predicted by the existing literature .
the importance of the terms originating from losses is underlined and complemented by formula of the spp near - field period and lifetime .
at a planar interface between two different materials , the electric field components ( @xmath0 ) and magnetic field components ( @xmath1 ) can be calculated by solving the helmholtz equation for transverse magnetic ( tm ) and transverse electric ( te ) boundary conditions @xcite . for the geometry provided in fig .
[ fig : scheme ] , the mathematical solutions crucially depend on two complex - valued properties : the dielectric permittivities @xmath2 ( linked to the optical refractive indices @xmath3 of medium @xmath4 by @xmath5 ) , and the complex - valued wavenumbers @xmath6 ( associated with electromagnetic field modes in the medium @xmath4 ) . at the interface between two media ( 1 and 2 ) , the conservation of light momentum results in the condition @xcite
@xmath7where @xmath8 is the spp wavenumber along the interface , @xmath9 is the wavenumber of the incident light ( @xmath10 : light angular frequency , @xmath11 : light velocity in vacuum ) .
scheme of a planar interface between medium 1 and 2 at which surface plasmon polaritons are considered .
the wavevector components along the surface normal axis are indicated as @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the complex dielectric permittivities of both media .
@xmath14 is the complex wavenumber of the spps propagating along the surface plane .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] [ fig : fig1 ] in tm geometry , the continuity conditions for the electromagnetic fields results in the relation @xcite @xmath15equation ( [ eq : mainsppcondition ] ) represents the _ dispersion relation of surface plasmon polaritons _ at the interface between two semi - infinite media .
the signs of @xmath16 and @xmath17 were taken positive here , accounting for the exponential decay of the electromagnetic field amplitude in the direction perpendicular to ( away from ) the interface .
the combination of eqs .
( [ eq : definitionofsppwavenumber ] ) and ( [ eq : mainsppcondition ] ) provides the solutions of the spp wavenumber @xmath14 : @xmath18 it must noted that in a generalized view , the characterization of lossy waves can be treated by calculating an observable response function @xmath19 which allows to construct a dispersion relation by locating its complex zeros / poles @xcite . as already noted by ritchie et al .
@xcite , when damping is relevant , the dispersion relation @xmath20 for @xmath21 may have complex solutions ( @xmath22 ) .
conversely , if @xmath23 is real - valued , @xmath14 may be complex - valued . although straightforward in a theoretical framework , there is some ambiguity about the significance of complex values of @xmath23 or @xmath14 in the interpretation of experiments @xcite . in experiments it may be difficult to observe temporal or spatial decay of a resonance due to its rapidity or smallness .
the properties of such excitations are usually extracted from the transfer of energy and momentum to the system , involving both real @xmath23 and real @xmath24 . as an example
, dispersion relations have been determined by attenuated total reflection ( atr ) in otto configuration @xcite . in this approach , a beam is totally reflected at the basis plane of an optical prism .
excitation of spp in a neighbored metal surface may be realized via coupling through a gap of a dielectric medium ( air ) .
spp manifest as drops in the totally reflected signal , when momentum matching between light and spp occurs .
experimentally , as underlined by kovener et al .
@xcite , this can be realized either for a variation of frequency @xmath23 at a fixed angle of incidence @xmath25 , or via a variation of @xmath25 at a fixed @xmath23 .
the first procedure produces dispersion curves with a specific `` bend back '' feature , while the second procedure results in curves without that feature @xcite .
spps can be excited only if the dispersion relation [ eq .
( [ eq : mainsppcondition ] ) ] is fulfilled . in order to extract the spp excitation conditions from the dispersion relation ,
a sign analysis can be performed on the real and imaginary parts of eq .
( [ eq : mainsppcondition ] ) , which can be mathematically developed to : @xmath26 by assuming @xmath27 this equation can be used to deduce a constraint on the sign of real part of the dielectric permittivities @xmath13 , resulting in @xmath28 equation ( [ eq : conditionsymmetricspp ] ) defines the first necessary condition for excitation of surface plasmon polaritons , which is equivalent to @xmath29 the physical meaning of eq .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) , named _ condition 1 _ for spp excitation , is the following : in presence of a perfect dielectric medium ( e.g. for @xmath30 or @xmath31 ) , eq .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) implies that spps can only be excited at a dielectric - metal interface .
this is usually fulfilled when @xmath32 .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) reduces to the widely accepted expression @xcite @xmath33 however , in presence of _ two absorbing media _ ( having then @xmath34 and @xmath35 ) , the physical meaning is less intuitive . the condition given by eq .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) is more complex due to non - vanishing contributions of the imaginary parts of the dielectric permittivities .
consequences of this additional term , important for lossy materials , will be discussed in section [ sec : exploration ] .
assuming purely real - valued dielectric permittivities , eq .
( [ eq : betadefinition ] ) is typically used to derive another condition for spp excitation .
this approach is called _ perfect medium approximation _ ( pma ) and will be outlined in the following . for simplicity , we adopt the following notations : @xmath36 and @xmath37 . if @xmath38 and @xmath39 , then @xmath14 is real - valued ( @xmath40 ) , and eq .
( [ eq : betadefinition ] ) becomes and widely used in literature @xcite .
in particular , when medium 1 is air ( @xmath45 ) , the joint application of eqs .
( [ eq : condition1-re ] ) and ( [ eq : realcondition ] ) leads to the well admitted condition @xmath46 however , beyond the perfect medium approximation , it must be noted that eq .
( [ eq : betadefinition ] ) can be treated using fully complex permittivity values since @xmath14 is defined in @xmath47 for _ any _ value of the dielectric permittivities @xmath48 . as a consequence , in presence of one ( or more ) `` lossy '' materials , e.g. , when @xmath34 or @xmath35 , _ there is no other restriction for spp excitation than the condition 1 _ given by eq .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) . in other words , performing an _ ad - hoc _ restriction of the dielectric permittivity to its real part(s ) may lead to an oversimplified spp excitation condition .
[ [ exploration - of - plasmon - active - material - combinations - secexploration ] ] exploration of plasmon - active material combinations [ sec : exploration ] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ in this section , the plasmon activity of a wide set of material combinations is explored by comparing predictions of the pma [ real - valued eqs .
( [ eq : condition1-re ] ) and ( [ eq : realcasescondition2 ] ) ] with the more general case [ complex - valued eq .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) ] . for that , if not stated differently , data of the optical constants were taken from ref .
values are listed in [ sec : appendixoptical ] . in a first step ,
a selection of different metals exposed to air are analyzed .
the results for the spp - activity for 12 different noble and transition metals are provided in tab .
[ tab : spp - active - interfaces - air ] .
here we restrict the study to two wavelengths frequently used in laser processing : 800 nm and 400 nm .
however , these calculations can be generalized to other material combinations and wavelengths .
the spp - activity of the metal - air interfaces is indicated by a green tick ( ) , whereas the interfaces which do not support spps are marked by a red cross ( ) . at both wavelengths the generalized model [ eq .
( [ eq : conditionsspp1 ] ) ] predicts similar results as the pma .
interestingly , and opposed to the pma , niobium ( nb ) is predicted to support spps when interfaced with air , upon 400 nm irradiation .
.[tab : spp - active - interfaces - air]analysis of spp - activity of several metal ( @xmath49 ) surfaces irradiated in air ( @xmath50 ) at @xmath51 nm and @xmath52 nm wavelengths .
meaning of the symbols : @xmath53 spp are excited , @xmath54 : spp are not excited at the interface .
bold font indicates interfaces where the prediction deviates from accepted theories . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] | the possibility to excite surface plasmon polaritons ( spps ) at the interface between two media depends on the optical properties of both media and geometrical aspects .
specific conditions allowing the coupling of light with a plasmon - active interface must be satisfied .
plasmonic effects are well described in noble metals where the imaginary part of the dielectric permittivity is often neglected ( perfect medium approximation ) .
however , some systems exist for which such approximation can not be applied , hence requiring a refinement of the common spp theory . in this context
, several properties of spps such as excitation conditions , period of the electromagnetic field modulation and spp lifetime then may strongly deviate from that of the perfect medium approximation . in this paper ,
calculations taking into account the imaginary part of the dielectric permittivities are presented .
the model identifies analytical terms which should not be neglected in the mathematical description of spps on lossy materials .
these calculations are applied to numerous material combinations resulting in a prediction of the corresponding spp features . a list of plasmon - active interfaces is provided along with a quantification of the above mentioned spp properties in the regime where the perfect medium approximation is not applicable .
may 21st , 2016 _ keywords _ : surface plasmon polaritons , lossy materials , plasmon lifetime |
there are currently two grb afterglows for which a fast falling - off optical emission was detected at early times , only @xmath1 seconds after the burst .
the general consensus is that this emission arises from the grb ejecta which is energized by the reverse shock ( * rs * ) crossing the ejecta and caused by the interaction of the ejecta with the circumburst medium ( * cbm * ) .
this interaction also drives a forward shock ( * fs * ) energizing the swept - up cbm , to which the later afterglow emission is attributed ( the `` reverse - forward shock '' scenario ) .
the rs emission was first calculated by & rees ( 1997 ) , who considered the cases of a frozen - in and turbulent magnetic field in the ejecta , and showed that , in either case , a bright optical emission ( @xmath2 ) is obtained at the end of the burst . & rees ( 1999 ) extended their previous calculations of the rs emission to a radiative evolution of the fireball lorentz factor and pointed out the importance of spectral information in constraining the rs dynamics and the magnetic field origin from the observed @xmath3 power - law decay of the very early optical light - curve of the afterglow 990123 ( akerlof 1999 ) .
they also pointed out the possibility that optical flashes arise in the same internal shocks which generate the burst emission .
sari & piran ( 1999 ) have shown that , if the peak frequency of the rs emission is assumed to be in the optical at the time when the optical emission of the afterglow 990123 peaks ( 50 seconds after the burst ) , then the expected softening of the rs emission and self - absorption effects can account for the radio flare reported by kulkarni ( 1999a ) .
kobayashi & sari ( 2000 ) confirm the rs interpretation of this radio flare through numerical calculations of the rs dynamics .
chevalier & li ( 2000 ) have presented calculations of the rs synchrotron emission until it crosses the grb ejecta , for the case of a wind - like cbm . for their choice of a high magnetic field parameter ,
the rs cooling frequency falls well below the optical domain , which leads to a rs optical emission much dimmer than that observed for the afterglow 990123 at its peak ( 40 seconds after the burst ) .
furthermore , such a low cooling frequency implies that the early afterglow optical emission should cease when the rs has crossed the ejecta shell , at the peak time of the rs emission .
since this is in contradiction with the observations of the afterglow 990123 , chevalier & li ( 2000 ) have concluded that a wind - like cbm can not explain the early optical emission of the afterglow 990123 .
constraints on the fireball initial lorentz factor have been obtained by soderberg & ramirez - ruiz ( 2003 ) for several afterglows by comparing the observed radio emission at @xmath4 day with the model rs emission , under the assumption that the rs magnetic field and typical electron energy parameters ( which we shall call * microphysical parameters * ) are those determined for the fs from fits to the broadband emission of those afterglows ( panaitescu & kumar 2001 ) .
zhang , kobayashi & ( 2003 ) have noted that the ratios of the rs and fs peak fluxes , and peak and cooling frequencies depend only on the fireball initial lorentz factor and the ratio of the magnetic fields , to develop a method of constraining these two quantities , and have shown that the optical emission of the afterglow 990123 requires a magnetized outflow . in this work
we use the general properties ( flux , epochs during which power - law decays are observed , decay slopes see table 1 ) of the radio and optical emissions of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 to constrain the ejecta ( isotropic - equivalent ) kinetic energy , cbm density , and the microphysical parameters for the reverse - forward shock scenario ( [ rf ] ) , for either a homogeneous or wind - like profile of the cbm .
in contrast with other works , we take into account all constraints arising from the radio and optical measurements of the grb afterglows 990123 and 021211 and we do not assume certain values for any of the model parameters .
we also investigate a `` wind - bubble '' scenario ( [ bb ] ) , where all the radio and optical emission arises in the fs , with a negligible contribution from the rs ( which is verified numerically ) , the mitigation of the optical decays observed in the afterglows 990123 and 021211 being due to the fs crossing the bubble termination shock , i.e. transiting from a wind - like cbm structure to a homogeneous region of shocked wind .
for both scenarios , we consider either adiabatic or radiative dynamics , the resulting microphysical parameters being checked for consistency with the assumed dynamical regime .
we begin by calculating the spectral properties ( break frequencies and peak flux ) of the rs emission at the radius @xmath5 where the rs finishes crossing the ejecta shell and the injection of fresh electrons by the rs ceases . because most of the ejecta kinetic energy has been transferred to the forward shock at @xmath5 , the radius @xmath5 marks the onset of a steeper power - law decrease of the bulk lorentz factor @xmath6 with radius .
after @xmath5 , the spectral properties of the rs emission can be calculated from the adiabatic evolution of the electrons and magnetic field .
the spectral properties of the fs emission can also be calculated from those at @xmath5 or directly from the dynamics of the fireball after @xmath5 ( without passing through the parameters at @xmath5 ) if the shock dynamics is adiabatic .
each shock compresses the fluid ahead of it by a factor @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the lorentz factor of the shocked fluid as measured in the frame of the yet unshocked gas , and heats it to a energy per particle equal to @xmath9 .
therefore , the pressure equality at the contact discontinuity which separates the shocked ejecta and cbm , implies that @xmath10 where @xmath6 is the lorentz factor of the shocked fluid in the laboratory frame , and @xmath11 , @xmath12 are the proton number densities of the unshocked ejecta and of the cbm , respectively , each measured in the corresponding comoving frame .
from addition of velocities in special relativity , @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the initial lorentz factor of the ejecta , @xmath15 denotes velocities and @xmath16 , @xmath17 were used in the approximation . substituting equation ( [ g2 ] ) in ( [ g1 ] ) ,
one obtains a fourth - degree equation for @xmath6 , which can be cast in the form @xmath18 n_{ej } = 4 \gamma^2 n \;. \label{g3}\ ] ] because @xmath19 , the first term in the square bracket is at least eight times larger than the last term .
ignoring the @xmath20 term , the solution of equation ( [ g3 ] ) is @xmath21^{1/2 } } \;. \label{g4}\ ] ] the limiting cases for the lorentz factor are @xmath22 therefore , in the limit of very dense ejecta , the lorentz factor of the shocked fluid is the same as that of the unshocked ejecta , while for more tenuous ejecta , @xmath6 depends on the ratio of the comoving densities .
note that the ratio @xmath11 and @xmath23 changes with the fireball radius @xmath24 : @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the fireball ejecta energy ( or , if the outflow is collimated , its isotropic equivalent ) , @xmath27 is the proton s mass , @xmath28 is the ejecta geometrical thickness measured in the laboratory frame ( thus @xmath29 is the comoving frame thickness ) , and we restricted our calculations to two simple radial structures of the cbm , either homogeneous ( @xmath30 ) of particle density @xmath12 or a @xmath31 stratification ( @xmath32 ) corresponding to a wind expelled by the grb progenitor . in the latter case , @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the mass - loss rate to wind speed ratio , normalized to @xmath35 . by denoting @xmath36
the ratio of the comoving densities is @xmath37 the ejecta - shell thickness , @xmath38 , is the largest of its initial thickness @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the laboratory frame duration of the grb ejecta release by their source , and the expansion due to a spread in the radial outflow velocity of the ejecta particles .
this velocity spread can be either a relic of the initial , super - eddington radiation pressure in the fireball , or to an imperfect collimation in the radial direction of the ejecta particles at the end of the fireball acceleration .
the former leads to a comoving - frame expansion of the shell at the sound speed , the latter is expected to produce a spread of order @xmath41 in the ejecta particles direction of motion ( , laguna & rees 1993 ) . in either case , the resulting contribution to the shell thickness evolution is @xmath42 , therefore @xmath43 as shown by kumar & panaitescu ( 2003 ) , the difference between the laboratory frame speeds of the unshocked ejecta and that of the rs is @xmath44 for a wide range of the ratio @xmath45 . from here , one can calculate the radius @xmath5 at which the rs finishes crossing the ejecta shell : @xmath46 once @xmath5 is known , equations ( [ g4 ] ) , ( [ n ] ) and ( [ d ] ) give the lorentz factor @xmath6 at the shock - crossing radius @xmath5 and all the properties of the rs and fs emissions at @xmath5 , which can be then extrapolated at @xmath47 .
we proceed by considering separately ejecta shells for which @xmath48 and @xmath49 . in the former case
, the ejecta shell undergoes a significant spreading while the rs propagates into it , while in the latter case the spreading is negligible . the usual terminology
( sari & piran 1995 ) is that of `` thin ejecta '' for the former and `` thick ejecta '' for the latter .
the substitution of equations ( [ n ] ) and ( [ bdiff ] ) in ( [ rcross ] ) leads to @xmath51 @xmath52 where the usual notation @xmath53 has been used . the defining condition for this case , @xmath54 , becomes @xmath55^{1/8 } = 670\ ; \left ( \frac{e_{53}}{n_0 \tau_0 ^ 3 } \right)^{1/8 } \;\ ; { \rm for } \;\ ; s=0 \label{gmin0}\ ] ] @xmath56 from equation ( [ n ] ) , the density ratio at @xmath5 is @xmath57 comparing with equation ( [ g4 ] ) , this shows that at @xmath5 the lorentz factor of shocked gas is in an intermediate regime : @xmath58 besides @xmath59 , two other quantities are of interest at the ejecta shock - crossing radius : the energy of the swept - up cbm , @xmath60 , and the corresponding observer frame time , @xmath61 .
the total energy of the shocked cbm is @xmath62 larger than its rest - mass energy , thus @xmath63 the arrival time @xmath64 corresponding to the contact discontinuity and the fluid moving toward the observer is given by @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the burst redshift . substituting @xmath6 from equation ( [ g4 ] ) in equations ( [ ecbm ] ) and ( [ dt ] ) ,
one obtains @xmath67 @xmath68 thus less than half of the initial ejecta energy has been dissipated by the fs by the time when the rs crosses the ejecta shell .
this means that the shock crossing radius @xmath5 is slightly smaller than the usual deceleration radius @xmath69 defined by @xmath70 .
once again , using equations ( [ n ] ) and ( [ bdiff ] ) in ( [ rcross ] ) , one obtains that @xmath72 @xmath73 the requirement that @xmath49 leads to the reversed inequalities given in equations ( [ gmin0 ] ) and ( [ gmin2 ] ) .
the density ratio ( equation [ n ] ) at @xmath5 is @xmath74 because in the thick shell case the ejecta density is lower than for a thin shell , the values given in the @xmath75 of equation ( [ nratio ] ) are upper limits for the density ratio . substituting equation ( [ nr ] ) in the second regime given in equation ( [ g5 ] ) leads to @xmath76^{1/8 } = 530\ ; \left ( \frac{e_{53}}{n_0 \tau_0 ^ 3 } \right)^{1/8 } \label{g7}\ ] ] @xmath77 note from equations ( [ g7 ] ) and ( [ g8 ] ) that , for a thick ejecta shell , the lorentz factor @xmath6 of the shocked ejecta is independent of that of the unshocked ejecta , @xmath14 . thus , for a sufficiently tenuous ejecta , the contrast between @xmath14 and @xmath6 can be sufficiently large that the rs is relativistic ( equation [ g2 ] ) in the frame of the incoming ejecta .
in contrast , in the thin ejecta case , equations ( [ g2 ] ) and ( [ g6 ] ) lead to @xmath78 for @xmath30 and @xmath79 for @xmath32 , the rs propagating in a thin ejecta shell is trans - relativistic
. the energy dissipated by the fs at @xmath80 and the ejecta shell shock - crossing time are @xmath81 for either type of medium .
note that , as for a thin ejecta shell , the shock - crossing radius @xmath5 is close to the usual deceleration radius .
furthermore , for a thick ejecta shell , the observer frame shock - crossing time @xmath61 is fairly close to the laboratory frame duration of the ejecta release . given that @xmath61 is roughly the timescale for dissipating the ejecta kinetic energy and that , most likely , the shock - accelerated electrons cool faster than the dynamical timescale , we expect that the duration of an external shock grb is close to @xmath61 .
the simple temporal structure of the grbs 990123 and 021211 may suggest that they originate in an external shock , nevertheless it is entirely possible that both bursts were produced in internal shocks occurring in an outflow with a fluctuating ejection lorentz factor ( rees & 1994 ) . in this case , the internal shocks take place at the radius @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the lorentz factor of the slower shells ; the shocked fluid moves at @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the lorentz factor of the faster shells ; therefore the observed burst duration is @xmath86 . since a high dissipation efficiency requires a large contrast between the lorentz factors of various ejecta shells ( @xmath87 ) , the burst duration sets only a lower limit on the duration of the ejecta release , @xmath40 .
we shall use this constraint when choosing the shock - crossing time @xmath61 for the grbs 990123 and 021211 for the case of a thick ejecta shell .
the synchrotron emission from either shock at any observing frequency is determined by the peak flux @xmath88 , the three break frequencies absorption @xmath89 , injection @xmath90 , and cooling @xmath91 and the slope of the afterglow spectrum between its break frequencies .
the peak of the @xmath92 synchrotron spectrum , which is at the frequency @xmath93 , is given by @xmath94 where @xmath66 is the burst redshift , @xmath95 the luminosity distance ( in a @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 universe ) , @xmath99 is the number of radiating electrons , and the factor @xmath6 accounts for the average relativistic boost of the comoving frame synchrotron power @xmath100 per electron at the peak frequency @xmath101 .
the doppler boost @xmath6 appears at only the first power in equation ( [ fp ] ) because the observer receives emission for an area subtending an angle of @xmath102 radians , from a fraction @xmath103 of the total number of electrons @xmath99 .
since we will be interested in the early time afterglow emission , the possible collimation of the outflow is not an issue here . after the shock crossing radius @xmath5 ,
the number of electrons energized by each shock is @xmath104 the comoving power per electron of equation ( [ fp ] ) is @xmath105 where @xmath106 is the order - unity coefficient calculated by wijers & galama ( 1999 ) , @xmath107 is the electron charge , and @xmath108 is the magnetic field strength .
the magnetic field is parameterized by the fraction @xmath109 of the post - shock energy density stored in it .
taking into account that the fs compresses the cbm by a factor @xmath110 and heats it is to an energy per proton of @xmath111 , the magnetic field is @xmath112 the break frequencies are calculated from the corresponding electron lorentz factors @xmath113 @xmath114 where @xmath115 is another order - unity factor calculated by wijers & galama ( 1999 ) and the last factor in the @xmath75 is for the average relativistic boost of the fireball emission by its relativistic expansion . the typical electron lorentz factor after shock - acceleration is parameterized as @xmath116 where @xmath117 for the fs , while @xmath118 for the rs is that given in equation ( [ g2 ] ) for @xmath119 .
we assume that each shock injects in the downstream fluid electrons with a power - law energy distribution @xmath120 the acceleration of new electrons by the rs ceases at @xmath5 , when all the ejecta have been swept - up , but continues at the fs .
the cooling electron lorentz factor is that for which the radiative losses timescale is equal to the dynamical timescale : @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the thomson cross - section for electron scattering and @xmath123 is the compton parameter , the ratio of inverse compton to synchrotron power .
the compton parameter is calculated from the electron distribution , as described by panaitescu & kumar ( 2000 ) .
the random lorentz factor of the electrons radiating at the self - absorption frequency @xmath89 is given by @xmath124 where @xmath125 and @xmath99 is given in equation ( [ ne ] ) .
equations ( [ fp ] ) ( [ ga ] ) provide the characteristics of the rs and fs synchrotron emissions at @xmath126 , with the values of @xmath108 , @xmath127 and @xmath128 for the rs calculated at @xmath129 from equations ( [ b1 ] ) , ( [ gi ] ) and ( [ gc ] ) , respectively ( using equations [ r1 ] , [ r2 ] , [ g6 ] , [ r3 ] , [ r4 ] , [ g7 ] , [ g8 ] ) and then extrapolated at @xmath47 as described in [ rs ] . once @xmath130 is known , the fireball radius can be related with the observer - frame arrival - time of the photons emitted at that radius and the evolution of the rs and fs spectral characteristics can be calculated .
the slopes of the piece - wise synchrotron spectrum from the broken power - law electron distribution with energy resulting from shock - acceleration and radiative cooling are described in detail by sari , piran & narayan ( 1998 ) .
note that , for @xmath47 , the rs electron distribution has a sharp cut - off at @xmath128 , as the injection of electrons stops when the rs has crossed the ejecta shell , which leads to an abrupt switch - off of the rs emission at a given frequency when @xmath91 drops below that frequency .
if the dynamics of the fs is adiabatic , the lorentz factor @xmath131 of the fs follows immediately from energy conservation @xmath132 , where @xmath133 is the mass of the swept - up cbm . from here
one obtains the blandford - mckee solution ( blandford & mckee 1976 ) : @xmath134 equation ( [ dt ] ) also gives the photon arrival time for the emission arising from a patch on the fs moving at an angle @xmath135 relative to the fireball center
observer axis , from where most of the emission arises .
its integration with @xmath6 from equation ( [ gfadb ] ) leads to @xmath136 \label{time}\ ] ] where the weak deceleration at @xmath137 has been ignored in the calculation of the last term in the @xmath75 . for @xmath138 , equations ( [ gfadb ] ) and ( [ time ] )
lead to @xmath139 substituting in equations ( [ ne ] ) , ( [ b1 ] ) , ( [ gi ] ) , ( [ gc ] ) and ( [ ga ] ) , one obtains the following scalings @xmath140 @xmath141 where @xmath142 was assumed for the last equation .
these scalings are used to calculate the characteristics of the fs synchrotron emission at any @xmath143 from those at @xmath144 .
if the swept - up cbm radiates half of its internal energy faster than the dynamical timescale , the dynamics of the afterglow is described by @xmath145 , which leads to @xmath146 .
therefore the two extreme regimes of the fireball dynamics are @xmath147 where the former is the adiabatic case and the latter is a highly radiative regime . to estimate the effect of high radiative losses , we calculate the dependence of the observed flux on the fireball lorentz factor , @xmath148 ( with @xmath149 frequency - dependent ) , and adjust the fluxes obtained in the adiabatic case by a factor @xmath150 } \;.
\label{rad}\ ] ] the radiative correction factors at @xmath151 day are close to those resulting from the expressions of the afterglow flux in the adiabatic case ( equations b1-b9 and c1-c9 in panaitescu & kumar 2000 ) if the fireball energy is decreased by a factor around 10 .
this means that a highly radiative regime corresponds to a fractional energy loss of about 90% within the first day after the burst .
note that for such high radiative losses to occur in an afterglow , fs electrons should acquire a substantial fraction of the energy dissipated by the shock and should radiate it quicker that the dynamical timescale , which requires a sufficiently high magnetic field , a sufficiently large parameter @xmath109 and dense cbm .
we calculate the dynamics of the shocked ejecta by assuming adiabatic dynamics and that the ejecta is in equilibrium pressure with the energized cbm , whose radial profile ( lorentz factor , density , pressure ) is described by the blandford - mckee solution . for adiabatic dynamics , the pressure in the ejecta shell evolves as @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the comoving thickness of the ejecta and @xmath154 is the adiabatic index . from the blandford - mckee solution , the pressure equilibrium at the contact discontinuity implies that @xmath155 where @xmath156 is the pressure of the shocked cbm at the coordinate @xmath157 of the rs , and @xmath158 is the pressure immediately behind the fs , the last relation resulting from the dynamics of the fs ( equation [ gfadb ] ) .
equations ( [ pr])([pf ] ) imply that the blandford - mckee coordinate for the rs satisfies @xmath159 equations ( [ gfadb ] ) and ( [ chir ] ) and the blandford - mckee solution for the post - fs lorentz factor @xmath160 lead to that the lorentz factor at the location of the contact discontinuity , the rs lorentz factor , evolves as @xmath161 the adiabatic index @xmath154 ( equation [ gr ] ) of the ejecta is initially @xmath162 if the rs is relativistic , which corresponds to the thick ejecta case discussed in [ thick ] , and lower for a mildly relativistic shock ( thin ejecta [ thin ] ) , decreasing to @xmath163 due to the ejecta cooling . between these limiting cases , the exponents of @xmath24 and @xmath153 given in equation ( [ gr ] ) change by 0.24 and 0.14 , respectively .
such variations do not lead to significant changes in the solutions presented in
for ease of further calculations , we will use @xmath164 in equation ( [ gr ] ) .
the only uncertainty left in the evolution of @xmath165 is that of the ejecta shell comoving thickness @xmath153 .
this uncertainty also affects the adiabatic cooling of the electrons and the evolution of the magnetic field in the ejecta . the evolution of the electron lorentz factors @xmath127 and @xmath128 at @xmath47 is @xmath166 where @xmath167 is the comoving frame ejecta volume and an adiabatic index @xmath168 for the relativistic electrons has been used for the last term .
because the ejecta emission switches off when the decreasing cooling frequency @xmath169 falls below the observing frequency @xmath170 , we will search for afterglow parameters for which @xmath171 , where @xmath172 is the latest time when the rs emission was ( or thought to have been ) observed .
therefore the electrons radiating at frequency @xmath170 cool mostly adiabatically and the ejecta radiative cooling after @xmath5 can be ignored . for the magnetic field , the flux - freezing condition yields @xmath173 where @xmath174(@xmath175 ) is the magnetic field perpendicular ( parallel ) to the radial direction of the fireball motion . to assess the effect of the uncertainty of the behaviour of @xmath153 on the ejecta synchrotron emission , we consider two extreme cases : @xmath176 , as could result from the compression ejecta against the decelerating contact discontinuity , and @xmath177 , corresponding to a comoving - frame expansion of the ejecta shell at a speed comparable to the speed of light . for the former case ,
relating the ejecta radius with the observer time through @xmath178 , leads to @xmath179 for @xmath30 and @xmath180 for @xmath32 ( just as for the fs ) . substituting in equation ( [ b2 ] )
shows that @xmath181 decays slower than @xmath175 .
then , equations ( [ fp ] ) , ( [ nuaic ] ) , ( [ ga ] ) , and ( [ gic ] ) yield @xmath182 @xmath183 for an ejecta shell spreading law @xmath177 , one obtains that @xmath184 for @xmath30 and @xmath185 for @xmath32 . equation ( [ b2 ] ) shows that @xmath186 decays slower than @xmath174 , leading to @xmath187 @xmath188 from the above scalings , it can be seen that the temporal index of the break frequencies changes by @xmath189 ( @xmath190 ) for @xmath30 ( @xmath32 ) , while that of the peak flux by 0.05 for either type of medium .
the solutions presented in [ rf ] vary little between the above assumed behaviours of @xmath153 . equations ( [ scale0 ] ) and ( [ scale2 ] ) are used to calculate the characteristics of the rs synchrotron emission at @xmath143 from those at @xmath61 .
the effect of radiative losses on the rs emission is estimated in a similar way as for the fs ( equation [ rad ] ) , by adjusting the fluxes obtained in the adiabatic case by a factor which accounts for the faster deceleration of the fs due to the radiative losses .
for the highly radiative regime , the evolution of the rs lorentz factor @xmath165 is calculated as in the adiabatic case ( equations [ pr ] and [ gr ] ) but using the scaling of the fs lorentz factor @xmath131 with radius corresponding to the radiative dynamics case ( equation [ gfrad ] ) .
the absorption of the rs radio emission in the fs is also taken into account .
the formalism presented in [ dynamics ] and [ radiation ] allows the calculation of the rs and fs emission at a given observer time and observing frequency .
these emissions depend on the dynamics of the fs and ejecta shell , on the fireball kinetic energy @xmath26 and the particle density of the cbm ( @xmath12 for a homogeneous medium or @xmath34 for a wind surrounding a massive star ) .
the ejecta - shell shock - crossing time @xmath61 also depends on the fireball initial lorentz factor @xmath14 , for thin ejecta , or on the duration @xmath40 of the fireball ejection , for thick ejecta .
the initial lorentz factor also determines the number of electrons in the ejecta and , therefore , the rs emission .
finally , the rs and fs emissions depend on the two microphysical parameters @xmath191 and @xmath109 which quantify the typical electron energy and the magnetic field .
thus , the rs emission is determined by five parameters in the thin ejecta case , or six in the opposite case , while the fs emission depends on four parameters .
note that @xmath26 and @xmath12 ( or @xmath34 ) determine the emission of both shocks . in this section
we determine in the framework of the reverse - forward shock scenario the values of the above parameters allowed by the radio and optical emissions of the grb afterglows 990123 and 021211 , the only two afterglows for which an optical emission has been detected at early times , @xmath1 seconds after the burst .
table 1 lists the properties of the burst , optical , and radio emissions of the two afterglows . for
the afterglow 021211 , the optical emission is decaying since the first measurement , at @xmath192 seconds after the burst ( li 2003 ) .
for the afterglow 990123 , the emission begins to decay at @xmath193 seconds ( akerlof 1999 ) , after which the burst exhibits some variability .
this raises the possibility of some energy injection in the rs after 45 seconds . for this reason ,
we choose @xmath194 seconds as the beginning of the afterglow decay , as after this epoch the burst exhibits a weaker , decaying emission . in both cases ,
the early optical emission fall - offs steeper than at later times . for the afterglow 021211
, the transition between these two regimes has been observed : it occurs at @xmath195 seconds ( li 2003 ) . for grb 990123
, the transition is inferred to occur at @xmath196 seconds ( li 2003 ) , around or after the last early optical measurement at @xmath197 seconds ( akerlof 1999 ) but prior to the next available measurement at @xmath198 hours after the burst ( kulkarni 1999b ) . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] ( 1 ) : burst redshift , ( 2 ) : range of burst duration in various @xmath199-ray bands , ( 3 ) : selected epoch for early optical measurement , ( 4 ) : @xmath24-band flux at @xmath200 ( akerlof 1999 , li 2003 ) , ( 5 ) : @xmath201 temporal index ( li 2003 ) of the early optical light - curve , @xmath202 , ( 6 ) : last available measurement or end of the steeply falling - off optical afterglow , ( 7 ) : beginning of slower decaying optical emission , ( 8) : @xmath203 optical light - curve index ( kulkarni 1999a ; li 2003 ) , @xmath204 , ( 9 ) : selected epoch after @xmath205 , ( 10 ) : @xmath24-band flux at @xmath206 ( fox 2003 ) , ( 11 ) : slope of optical continuum measured after @xmath205 ( holland 2000 ; pandey 2003 ) , @xmath207 , ( 12 ) : selected epochs of radio measurements , ( 13 ) : @xmath208 upper limits on radio fluxes ( kulkarni 1999b ; fox 2003 ) . the slower decaying optical emission lasting for days is naturally attributed to the fs energizing the cbm .
its @xmath209 decay implies that the fs injection frequency is below the optical domain at the first epoch , @xmath205 , when the slower decay begins : @xmath210 a second constraint is set by the optical flux normalization ; for this we choose an epoch @xmath211 when the model flux , @xmath212 , is required to be within a factor 3 of the observed flux , @xmath213 , making allowance for some uncertainty in our calculations : @xmath214 with the exception of the flare seen at @xmath215 days in the radio afterglow of grb 990123 , there are no other detections in the radio down to 0.1 mjy or less .
we use the @xmath208 upper limits on the radio flux at three epochs ( @xmath216 ) spanning the interval 0.14 days , to constraint the radio fs emission , @xmath217 : @xmath218 that the early afterglow exhibits a steep fall - off requires that the rs has crossed the ejecta . the burst duration , @xmath219 ,
sets a lower bound on the ejecta crossing - time @xmath61 , as discussed in
[ thick ] , thus @xmath61 is constrained by @xmath220 furthermore , the steep @xmath221 decay of the rs emission at @xmath200 requires that the rs injection frequency is below the optical domain at that time : @xmath222 matching the observed flux to within a factor of 3 , @xmath223 is another requirement set on the calculated rs emission . the detection of rs emission until epoch @xmath224 , when the early observations end ( grb 990123 ) or when the transition to the fs emission is observed ( grb 021211 ) , implies that the rs cooling frequency remains above the optical domain until at least epoch @xmath224 @xmath225 otherwise , the rs optical emission would exhibit a sharp drop when @xmath169 falls below optical .
finally , the radio upper limits are imposed on the rs emission as well : @xmath226 we search for afterglow parameters @xmath227 that lead to fs and rs emissions satisfying the constraints 13 and 58 , respectively . for grb 990123 ,
constraint 4 requires that @xmath228 s , as for this burst @xmath229 . for grb 021211
, the same constraint allows that @xmath230 . in the thin ejecta case
, @xmath61 determines the ejecta initial lorentz factor , @xmath14 ( equations [ et0 ] and [ et1 ] ) .
for thick ejecta , @xmath61 determines the duration of the ejecta release , @xmath40 , ( equation [ et2 ] ) .
note that in the case of a thick ejecta shell , the reversed inequalities given in equations ( [ gmin0 ] ) and ( [ gmin2 ] ) provide only a lower limit on @xmath14 .
nevertheless , @xmath14 remains a relevant parameter because its sets the number of electrons in the ejecta .
the index @xmath231 of the electron energy distribution ( equation [ dndg ] ) is determined from the exponent @xmath232 of the optical power - law decay , @xmath233 , for each shock .
the available measurements of the slope @xmath15 of the optical continuum , @xmath207 , at @xmath234 day , constrain the index @xmath231 through that the intrinsic afterglow spectral slope @xmath235 can not be larger than observed , as intrinsic spectra harder than observed ( @xmath236 ) can be attributed to dust reddening in the host galaxy .
the search for afterglow parameters is done by choosing various combinations of parameters @xmath237 ( for @xmath30 ) or @xmath238 ( for @xmath32 ) and by identifying the regions in the @xmath239 parameter space which satisfy the above constraints .
various values of the initial lorentz factor @xmath14 satisfying constraint 4 are tried , to maximize the allowed @xmath239 parameter range . for thin ejecta ,
the @xmath240 parameter space for the rs is significantly smaller than for thick ejecta . for brevity , we present here only solutions for the latter case
. figures [ jans0][decs2 ] show the rs and fs solutions @xmath241 for various combinations @xmath237 or @xmath238 for which both rs and fs solutions exist .
@xmath26 , @xmath12 ( or @xmath34 ) different by a factor 10 than those shown , the emission from one of the shocks , or from both , fails to satisfy the above constraints .
for all these three figures , the adiabatic index in the shocked ejecta ( [ rs ] ) was set to @xmath164 and the comoving thickness of the ejecta was assumed to evolve as @xmath177 , where @xmath165 is the bulk lorentz factor of the shocked ejecta at @xmath47 .
taking @xmath242 , as for a relativistic rs , or assuming a constant @xmath153 lead to a modest change in the solutions shown and leave unaltered the conclusions below . to assess the effect of radiative losses , the fluxes obtained in the adiabatic case were decreased as expected from the faster deceleration of @xmath6 in the case of radiative dynamics ( equation [ rad ] ) .
for the reverse - forward shock scenario we reach the following conclusions about the rs and fs parameters : \(1 ) _ grb 990123 , homogeneous cbm ( figure [ jans0 ] ) : _ rs and fs microphysical parameters differ , with @xmath243 and @xmath244 . a rs magnetic field larger than that behind the fs points to an ejecta which was initially magnetized .
fs solutions correspond to a cooling frequency , @xmath245 , above the optical domain .
the power - law decay of the fs optical light - curve , @xmath246 , sets the electron index : @xmath247 .
this implies that the slope of the intrinsic optical continuum is @xmath248 , consistent with the value reported by holland ( 2000 ) , at @xmath249 days after the burst .
fs solutions are obtained only for high radiative losses .
for the fs parameters shown in figure [ jans0 ] , the ratio of the ( inverse - compton ) cooling to injection electron lorentz factors is @xmath250 , therefore the energy given to electrons which cool radiatively ( @xmath251 ) is a fraction @xmath252 of the total electron energy .
if the injected electron distribution extends to arbitrarily high energies , the fraction of the post - shock energy in electrons is @xmath253 \epsi = 3\ , \epsi \in ( 0.3 , 1)$ ] .
then , at @xmath254 day , the radiative losses over one dynamical timescale are a fraction @xmath255 of the fs energy .
if the total electron energy does not exceed equipartition ( @xmath256 ) , then @xmath257 . therefore , for the fs solutions shown in figure [ jans0 ] , the fireball dynamics is between the adiabatic and highly radiative regimes .
the ejecta kinetic energy @xmath258 ergs ( if spherical ) and the ambient medium density @xmath259 for which the rs emission accommodates the early optical emission of the afterglow 990123 are 10 and 50 times larger than their upper limits found by us ( panaitescu & kumar 2001 ) from multiwavelength afterglow modelling .
the difference is caused by the inclusion in the current calculations of the early ( @xmath260 ) optical emission , which can not be accommodated by the rs if the fireball energy and cbm density were those determined from modelling the afterglow emission at @xmath261 hours , as the constraints 6 and 8 in [ rf ] can not be satisfied simultaneously .
conversely , for the ( @xmath262 ) values for which the rs emission accounts for the early optical emission , the fs solutions identified in this work satisfy the general constraints imposed by observations ( [ rf ] ) but provide a @xmath263-wise poorer fit to the afterglow data after 4 hours than the best fit obtained numerically with more accurate calculations of radiative losses and the integration of received emission over the photon equal arrival time surface .
\(2 ) _ grb 990123 , @xmath0 cbm ( figure [ jans2 ] ) : _ there are rs and fs solutions with the same microphysical parameters .
rs solutions exist only for radiative dynamics .
denser wind environments are found to allow rs solutions if the kinetic energy @xmath26 is increased , but even for @xmath264 ergs , which is 30 times larger than the grb output , the allowed wind density is well below that of a wolf - rayet ( wr ) star ( @xmath265 ) .
fs solutions correspond to @xmath245 above the optical domain , therefore the electron index is @xmath266 , leading to @xmath267 , significantly harder than any reported measurement .
the rs and fs solutions shown in figure [ jans2 ] with @xmath268 are consistent with high radiative losses if electrons reach equipartition ( @xmath269 ) , because @xmath270 allows most of the electron energy to be at @xmath251 . however
, for the solutions with @xmath271 , equipartition energies require a cut - off in the accelerated electron distribution at @xmath272 .
the synchrotron characteristic frequency for the @xmath273 electrons is above the optical domain ( thus the cut - off does not affect the optical afterglow ) , but @xmath272 implies that all injected electrons are cooling adiabatically , the assumption of high radiative losses becomes invalid for @xmath274 .
\(3 ) _ grb 021211 , homogeneous cbm : _ in our previous study ( kumar & panaitescu 2003 ) we have shown that , in the thin ejecta shell case , the rs magnetic field parameter must be @xmath275 times larger than for the fs . for a thick ejecta shell , corresponding to a rs shell - crossing time longer than the burst duration ( 28 s ) but shorter the time of the first optical measurement ( 130 s )
, there are rs and fs solutions with the same microphysical parameters if the dynamics is radiative .
\(4 ) _ grb 021211 , @xmath0 cbm ( figure [ decs2 ] ) : _ rs and fs may have the same microphysical parameters , for either adiabatic or radiative dynamics .
there are also solutions with the same parameter @xmath191 and a rs magnetic field parameter larger than for the fs , indicative of a frozen - in magnetic field .
fs solutions correspond to @xmath245 above the optical domain , leading to @xmath276 and @xmath277 , which is @xmath208 below the hardest slope reported ( pandey 2003 , at @xmath278 hours ) .
because @xmath270 , the dynamics may be radiative for @xmath279 and @xmath269 , while a significantly lower @xmath280 would ensure an adiabatic dynamical regime .
note that a high @xmath281 ergs , more than 100 times larger than the burst output , is required by a wind density corresponding to @xmath282 , slightly below that of a wr star . from the constraints on the fs parameters , chevalier , li & fransson ( 2004 ) have also concluded that a weak wind with @xmath283 is required for the afterglow 021211 , however , in their calculations , the fs cooling frequency was placed below the optical .
if we impose the same constraint here , we do not find any solutions for the rs microphysical parameters .
the similarity of the decay indices of the optical light - curves of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 before and after @xmath284 may suggest that a single mechanism produces the entire optical afterglow emission .
time - varying microphysical parameters , including the slope of the power - law electron energy distribution , could cause a change in the optical light - curve decay index , however such an explanation is in contradiction with the consistency seen in many afterglows between the optical spectral slope and light - curve decay index at times of order 1 day .
if the fs is the only mechanism producing the detected afterglow emission and if microphysical parameters are constant , then the non - monotonic behaviour of the optical light - curves of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 at @xmath284 seconds must be tied with the fireball dynamics .
the fireball dynamics is determined by the ejecta initial energy and cbm density .
a substantial energy injection can mitigate the afterglow dimming rate , however the energy deposition would have to last for the entire duration of the slower power - law decay , until at least a few days , and could lead to a too bright radio emission from the rs .
besides energy injection , a sudden variation in the radial profile of the cbm could also alter the afterglow behaviour .
such a variation is suggested by the association of grbs with the death of massive stars , which drive powerful winds , and that the modelling of multiwavelength afterglow measurements starting a few hours after the burst leads to better fits for a homogeneous medium than a wind .
this discrepancy may be resolved if the afterglow does not arise in a freely expanding wind , but in the environment resulting from the interaction of the wind with the circumstellar gas ( wijers 2001 ) or with the winds blown by other stars ( scalo & wheeler 2001 ) .
it is then possible that the grb ejecta run into a cbm whose density profile at smaller radii is the @xmath0 expected for a uniform , free wind , and closer to uniformity at larger distances .
then , if the fs cooling frequency is above the optical domain , the optical afterglow light - curve index should decrease by @xmath285 when the wind termination shock is reached .
the resulting index decrease is slightly smaller than observed , but it is possible that deviations from uniformity of the environment outside the unperturbed wind account for the difference .
one important issue for this wind - bubble scenario is under what conditions the wind termination shock is located at the radius @xmath286 of the afterglow at the time @xmath287 when the light - curve transits from a steeper to a slower decay . from equations ( [ r2 ] ) and ( [ time ] ) , one obtains @xmath288 @xmath286 is higher by a factor of a few for the wind parameters @xmath289 which we find for this scenario , and by an extra factor @xmath290 for the high ejecta kinetic energy obtained for the afterglow 990123 .
thus , we shall find that @xmath291 pc for the afterglow 990123 and @xmath292 pc for the afterglow 021211 . because the afterglow radius increases as @xmath179 at @xmath293 and because the slower decay of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 is seen from @xmath294 untill @xmath295 few days , the uniform part of the cbm must extend up to at least @xmath296 .
castor , mccray & weaver ( 1975 ) have derived the major physical properties of a bubble resulting from the interaction of stellar winds with the interstellar gas , taking into account the cooling and the diffusion of the interstellar gas into the shocked wind .
the radius of the wind termination shock @xmath297 can be estimated from the equality of the wind ram pressure and that inside the bubble , leading to @xmath298 pc , where @xmath299 is the mass - loss rate in @xmath300 , @xmath301 is the wind velocity in km / s , @xmath302 is the interstellar gas density in @xmath303 , and and @xmath304 is the duration of the wind measured in @xmath305 years . from here , the ratio of the contact discontinuity radius @xmath306 to that of the wind termination shock is @xmath307 .
thus for a grb occurring in a dense cloud ( @xmath308 ) , the termination shock radius could be at location required by the cbm scenario ( equation [ rtrans ] ) and the shocked wind shell could be sufficiently thick .
however , wr winds do not interact with the interstellar medium but with the wind expelled during the red supergiant ( rsg ) phase , which collides with the main - sequence phase wind decelerated by the interaction with the interstellar medium .
the numerical hydrodynamical calculations of ramirez - ruiz ( 2001 ) take into account the wind history and show that @xmath309 pc for @xmath310 and @xmath311 years .
such a termination shock radius is suitable for the wind - bubble scenario and the afterglow 021211 , however the wind - bubble size ( 0.3 pc ) shown by ramirez - ruiz ( 2001 ) is surprisingly small , being 100 times less than that expected from the analytical results of castor ( 1975 ) .
chevalier ( 2004 ) have considered the possibility that a high interstellar pressure may stall the bubble expansion . for the external pressure expected in a intense starburst region ,
their numerical simulations lead to a wind shock termination radius @xmath312 pc and a contact discontinuity located at @xmath313 , which is about right for the wind - bubble scenario and the afterglow 990123 . alternatively
, the uniformity of the cbm at @xmath293 required by the wind - bubble scenario might arise from a sudden increase in the wind speed , leading to a inner shock propagating into the incoming wind .
the self - similar solutions derived by chevalier & imamura ( 1983 ) for colliding winds show that a thick , uniform density shell forms behind the inner shock if the termination shock moves at less than 1% of the unshocked wind speed , which requires the fluctuation in the wind to consist of a decrease in the mass - loss rate by a factor 100 and an increase of the wind speed increases by a factor 100 or larger .
such a dramatic change in the wind properties exceeds that expected at the transition from a luminous blue variable ( lbv ) wind ( @xmath314 , @xmath315 ; garcia - segura , mac low , & langer 1996 ) or a rsg wind ( @xmath316 , @xmath317 ; garcia - segura , langer & mac low 1996 ) to a wolf - rayet wind ( @xmath318 , @xmath319 ) . the inner shock speed @xmath320 and the location of the termination shock required by the afterglows 990123 and 021211
imply a wr lifetime @xmath321 and @xmath322 years , respectively , much shorter than predicted by evolutionary models for such stars .
having found some support for the wind - bubble scenario in the stalled wr wind - bubble model of chevalier ( 2004 ) , and less so in the interaction between the rsg / lbv and wr winds , we proceed with testing it against the radio and optical observations of the afterglow 990123 and 021211 .
the wind - bubble scenario must satisfy the constraints given in
[ rf ] , the first three pertaining to the emission from the fireball interacting with the homogeneous portion of the cbm , while the last three referring to the fs propagating in the @xmath0 bubble ( instead of the `` rs '' , as indicated in those equations ) .
in addition , the constraint @xmath323 must be imposed , to explain the decrease of the afterglow dimming rate at @xmath287 , when the uniform medium is encountered .
we note that , for @xmath32 , @xmath91 increases in time , while for @xmath30 it decreases .
thus , if condition ( [ nuc ] ) is satisfied , then @xmath245 is above the optical domain for any @xmath324
. we also note that this scenario has only four parameters , two ( @xmath26 and @xmath34 ) for the fs dynamics and two ( @xmath191 and @xmath109 ) for the emission .
the density of the uniform region of the cbm is determined by the compression by a factor 4 of the wind density at the location of the termination shock . from equation
( [ rtrans ] ) , one obtains that this density is @xmath325 the density jump across the termination shock should lead to a brief brightening of the afterglow ( wijers 2001 ) . such a behaviour may have been missed in the afterglow 990123 , where there is a gap in the optical observations from 10 minutes to 4 hours .
it is not seen in the optical measurements of the afterglow 021211 at the `` break '' time of 10 minutes determined by li ( 2003 ) , instead an optical emission brighter by 0.5 magnitudes than the double power - law fit used there is seen at 2 hours after the burst .
the lack of a brightening at the right time in the afterglow 021211 may be problematic for the wind - bubble scenario considered here .
figures [ janwb ] and [ decwb ] display separately the fs microphysical parameters which accommodate the observations before and after @xmath287 , for a few combinations of fireball energy @xmath26 and wind parameter @xmath34 .
smaller values of the former parameter or larger values for the latter do not allow the fs to accommodate the @xmath326 radio and optical emission of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 .
note that , because the rs emission has at least one free parameter ( @xmath40 and @xmath14 ) , requiring that it does not exceed the measured optical fluxes or the radio upper limits , does not constrain the fs parameters .
as shown in figure [ janwb ] , the parameters @xmath191 and @xmath109 satisfying the observational constraints can not be constant across @xmath286 for the afterglow 990123 , with the electron energy parameter increasing by a factor @xmath327 and the magnetic field parameter decreasing by a factor @xmath327 when the fireball crosses the wind termination shock .
a similar conclusion is reached for the afterglow 021211 ( figure [ decwb ] ) .
we have investigated two scenarios that can account for the behavior of the early optical emission of grb afterglows 990123 and 021211 , whose light - curves fall - off as @xmath328 at @xmath329 seconds , while the decay at @xmath326 follows @xmath330 .
the first scenario is the widely used reverse - forward shock scenario , where the fast decay of the early optical emission is attributed to the grb ejecta energized by the reverse shock ( rs ) , and the slower decaying phase is associated with circumburst medium ( cbm ) swept - up by the forward shock ( fs ) .
figure [ jans0 ] shows that , for a homogeneous medium , the reverse - forward shock scenario can accommodate the radio and optical measurements of the afterglow 990123 if the ejecta magnetic field is @xmath290 times larger than in the shocked cbm , which implies an ejecta frozen - in magnetic field ( & rees 1997 , zhang 2003 ) , and if the rs parameter for the typical electron energy is @xmath290 times smaller than for the fs .
this differences between the microphysical parameters behind the two shocks are too large to be explained away by the inaccuracies in the calculations of the afterglow emission presented in [ radiation ] . for a wind - like cbm ( figure [ jans2 ] ) , the reverse - forward shock scenario can explain the major properties of the radio and optical emissions of the afterglow 990123 with the same microphysical parameters behind both shocks ( figure [ jans2 ] ) , but it requires a wind density corresponding to a mass - loss rate to speed ratio less than @xmath331 ( @xmath332 ) .
we obtain a similarly tenuous wind also from modelling the broadband data of the afterglow 990123 at @xmath333 days , but it should be noted that the best fit with a wind - like cbm provides a poorer fit to the data than a uniform medium . within the framework of the reverse - forward shock scenario ,
the same microphysical parameters are obtained for the afterglow 021211 , for a thick ejecta shell and either a uniform or a wind - like cbm ( the latter case is shown in figure [ decs2 ] ) . for a uniform cbm
, we obtain @xmath334 , larger than the @xmath335 inferred by us ( kumar & panaitescu 2003 ) for a thin ejecta shell . for a wind - like cbm
, the afterglow 021211 requires a wind density corresponding to a mass - loss rate to speed ratio below @xmath331 , a result similar to that obtained for the afterglow 990123 . the second scenario considered in this work ( [ bb ] ) , that of wind - bubble having a inner @xmath0 wind - like region surrounded by a zone of uniform density , is motivated by that the decrease in the dimming rate of the optical afterglows 990123 and 021211 seen at @xmath336 seconds matches fairly well the expectations for such a density profile .
the required cbm structure finds support in the scenario of wr wind - bubbles stalled by a high interstellar pressure discussed by chevalier ( 2004 ) . for this scenario to explain the general properties of the radio and optical emissions of the afterglows 990123 and 021211
, the magnetic field and electron energy parameters would have to decrease and increase , respectively , by a factor of about 100 at @xmath337 , when the wind termination shock is reached ( figures [ janwb ] and [ decwb ] ) , a contrived feature without a physical foundation .
we also find that the wind - bubble scenario requires winds which are as tenuous as those for the reverse - forward shock scenario .
thus the reverse - forward shock scenario provides a more natural explanation than the wind - bubble scenario for the steep early decay of the optical emission of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 .
given that the grb ejecta can be initially magnetized and that the rs is less relativistic than the fs , the microphysical parameters might differ behind the two shocks .
if their equality is required for a simpler scenario , with fewer assumptions , then a wind - like cbm is favoured by the reverse - forward shock scenario , though a problem still exists : the low wind density inferred in each case ( @xmath332 ) , which is similar to that derived by chevalier ( 2004 ) for the afterglows 020405 and 021211 and by price ( 2002 ) for the afterglow 011211 . in the sample of 64 galactic wr stars analyzed by nugis & lamers ( 2000 )
there is only one star with @xmath332 , the majority of the other stars having a mass - loss rate @xmath338 , a wind velocity @xmath339 , and @xmath340 .
the dependence of the mass - loss rate on stellar mass and metallicity inferred by nugis & lamers ( 2000 ) lead to @xmath341 for wn stars and @xmath342 for wcs , which may suggest that the tenuous winds required by the reverse - forward shock scenario for the afterglows 990123 and 021211 arise wr stars which are less massive and less metal rich than galactic wrs ( wijers 2001 , chevalier 2004 ) . if such stars do not exist , then either the microphysical parameters must be different behind the rs crossing the grb ejecta and the fs sweeping - up the cbm or the fast declining early optical emission of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 is not arising in the rs .
one possibility is that the early optical afterglow emission is produced in internal shocks occurring in an unsteady wind ( & rees 1999 ) , a scenario which was not investigated in this work . 99 akerlof c. , 1999 , nature , 398 , 400 blandford , r. & mckee , c. 1976 , phys . of fluids , vol .
8 , 1130 castro j. , mccray r. , weaver r. , 1976 , apj , 200 , l107 chevalier l. & imamura j. , 1983 , apj , 270 , 554 chevalier l. & li z .- y . , 2000 , apj , 536 , 195 chevalier l. , li z .- y . & fransson c. , 2004 , apj , submitted ( astro - ph/0311326 ) fox d. , 2003 , apj , 586 , l5 garcia - segura g. , mac low m .-
& langer n. , 1996 , a&a , 305 , 229 garcia - segura g. , langer n. & mac low m .-
, 1996 , a&a , 316 , 133 holland s. , bjornsson g. , hjorth j. , thomsen b. , 2000 , a&a , 364 , 467 kobayashi s. & sari r. , 2000 , apj , 542 , 819 kulkarni s. , 1999a , apj , 522 , l97 kulkarni s. , 1999b , nature , 389 , 398 kumar p. & panaitescu a. , 2003 , mnras , 346 , 905 li w. , filippenko a. , chornock r. , jha s. , 2003 , apj , 586 , l9 p. , laguna p. & rees m.j . , 1993 , apj , 415 , 181 p. & rees m. , 1997 , apj , 476 , 232 p. & rees m. , 1999 , mnras , 306 , l39 nugis t. & lamers h. , 2000 , a&a , 360 , 227 pandey s. , 2003 , a&a , 408 , l21 panaitescu a. & kumar p. , 2000 , apj , 543 , 66 panaitescu a. & kumar p. , 2001 ,
apj , 560 , l49 price p. , 2002
, apj , 572 , l51 ramirez - ruiz e. , dray l. , madau p. & tout c. 2001 , mnras , 327 , 829 rees m.j . & p. , 1994 ,
apj , 430 , l93 sari r. & piran t. , 1995 , apj , 455 , l143 sari r. , piran t. & narayan r. , 1998 , apj , 497 , l17 sari r. , & piran t. , 1999 , apj , 517 , l109 scalo j. & wheeler j. , 2001 , apj , 562 , 664 vreeswijk p. , fruchter a. , hjorth j. , kouveliotou c. , 2002 , gcn circ .
1785 wijers r. & galama t. , 1999 , apj , 523 , 177 wijers r. 2001 , `` gamma - ray bursts in the afterglow era '' , eds .
e. costa , f. frontera , j. jorth ( berlin : springer - verlag ) , 306 zhang b. , kobayashi s. , & p. , 2003 ,
apj , 595 , 950 | the optical light - curves of grb afterglows 990123 and 021211 exhibit a steep decay at 100600 seconds after the burst , the decay becoming slower after about 10 minutes .
we investigate two scenarios for the fast decaying early optical emission of these grb afterglows . in the _ reverse - forward shock _
scenario , this emission arises in the reverse shock crossing the grb ejecta , the mitigation of the light - curve decay occurring when the forward shock emission overtakes that from the reverse shock .
both a homogeneous and wind - like circumburst medium are considered . in the _ wind - bubble _ scenario ,
the steeply decaying , early optical emission arises from the forward shock interacting with a @xmath0 bubble , with a negligible contribution from the reverse shock , the slower decay starting when the blast wave reaches the bubble termination shock and enters a homogeneous region of the circumburst medium .
we determine the shock microphysical parameters , ejecta kinetic energy , and circumburst density which accommodate the radio and optical measurements of the grb afterglows 990123 and 021211 .
we find that , for a homogeneous medium , the radio and optical emissions of the afterglow 990123 can be accommodated by the reverse - forward shock scenario if the microphysical parameters behind the two shocks differ substantially .
a wind - like circumburst medium also allows the reverse - forward shocks scenario to account for the radio and optical properties of the afterglows 990123 and 021211 , but the required wind densities are at least 10 times smaller than those of galactic wolf - rayet stars .
the wind - bubble scenario requires a variation of the microphysical parameters when the afterglow fireball reaches the wind termination shock , which seems a contrived feature . |
we prove the following classification theorem for absolutely cartesian squares : [ thm : abscartsq ] a square of spaces is absolutely cartesian if and only if it is a map of two absolutely cartesan 1-cubes .
that is , of the following form ( the other two maps may also be equivalences ) : @xmath16^{\sim}\ar[d ] & b\ar[d]\\ c \ar[r]^{\sim } & d\\ } \ ] ] theorem [ thm : abscartsq ] is the base case of our following conjecture : [ conj1 ] an @xmath17-cube of spaces is absolutely cartesian if and only if it can be written as either a map of two absolutely cartesian @xmath18-cubes or a chain of compositions of @xmath17-cubes of these types
. it should be clear that building up an @xmath17-cube inductively as maps of these absolutely cartesian squares and compositions of such cubes will yield an absolutely cartesian @xmath17-cube , which is the @xmath19 direction of the if and only if . to be clear , two cubes @xmath20
may be composed if they can be written @xmath21 and @xmath22 ; their composition is then @xmath23 .
geometrically , this looks like `` glueing '' the cubes along their shared face .
we give an example in the next section . by chain of compositions ,
we mean compositions of possibly more than two cubes , e.g. @xmath24 where @xmath25 are all @xmath17-cubes built inductively up from maps of absolutely cartesian squares .
it is not yet certain if the other direction is true .
we may observe that the absolutely cartesian squares are also absolutely cocartesian .
thus , we make an additional conjecture that [ conj2 ] an @xmath17-cube is absolutely cartesian if and only if it is absolutely cocartesian .
if we include contravariant functors , we can show this conjecture for @xmath26 , and we will comment on this after the proof for cartesian squares , which is in the following section .
we will present partial results towards conjecture [ conj2 ] in section [ sec : conj2 ] ; this includes a positive verification of the conjecture when restricting to functors which land in 1-connected spaces ( including the identity implies that the spaces in the diagram must originally be 1-connected as well ) . the section after that is about a family of 3-cubes which are absolutely cocartesian and cartesian and which are not expressible as a map of two absolute cartesian squares , but as a composition of 3-cubes of that form .
we end with applications and related work .
this relies on switching briefly to the setting of spectra and using this to deduce properties of the original diagram of spaces .
we also point out that it suffices to prove that either @xmath27 or @xmath28 is an equivalence , since equivalences are stable under homotopy pullback .
that is , it implies that the mirroring map , @xmath29 or @xmath30 , is also an equivalence .
consider an absolutely cartesian square of spaces : @xmath16 \ar[d ] & b \ar[d]\\ c \ar[r ] & d\\ } \ ] ] now apply the functor @xmath31 to our square : @xmath32 \ar[d ] & \sigma^{\infty}{\text{map}}(d , b ) \ar[d]\\ \sigma^{\infty}{\text{map}}(d , c ) \ar[r ] & \sigma^{\infty}{\text{map}}(d , d)\\ } \ ] ] by assumption , this resultant square is still cartesian .
since the square is in spectra , we know that it is also cocartesian . recall that @xmath33 commutes with colimits .
we then have the following chain of equivalences : @xmath34 & & { \mathbb{z}}[\pi_0 { \text{map}}(d , d)]\\ \end{array}\ ] ] we can interpret this as telling us that @xmath35 surjects onto @xmath36 . consider @xmath37 .
this then has a preimage ( up to homotopy ) in @xmath38 and/or @xmath39 ; assume @xmath38 .
this gives a section @xmath40 .
we can then rewrite our original diagram with our new map in the pre - image of the identity .
this is figure [ fig : setup ] .
@xmath41 \ar@/^/[dd]^{id}\\ a \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & b \ar[d]\\ c \ar[r ] & d\\ } \ ] ] we can add the homotopy pullback of @xmath42 to the diagram .
then the whole diagram is a pullback , being a composition of pullback squares .
this lets us pull back the identity map , as in figure [ fig : pullbackid ] .
@xmath43_{id}c\ar[r]\ar[d ] & d \ar[d ] \ar@/^/[dd]^{id}\\ a \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & b \ar[d]\\ c \ar[r ] & d\\ } \ ] ] the whole diagram is itself absolutely cartesian ( having two facing maps which are equivalences ) . since the bottom and entire squares are both absolutely cartesian , so is the top square , shown again in figure [ fig : top1 ] .
@xmath44\ar[d ] & d \ar[d]\\a \ar[r ] & b\\ } \ ] ] now that the top square is known to be absolutely cartesian , we can proceed in the same as we did with the original square , and obtain a section from @xmath45 to @xmath46 or @xmath47 .
if the section is to @xmath46 , we are done , as we already have a splitting from @xmath46 to @xmath45 and having another the other direction gives us an equivalence between @xmath45 and @xmath46 .
otherwise , we work in the other direction .
we add our section @xmath48 to our diagram , in figure [ fig : wbsec ] , shown without the other equivalences .
@xmath49\ar[r ] & d\ar[d]\\ b \ar@/_/[rr ] \ar[r ] & a\ar[d ] \ar[r ] & b\ar[d]\\ & c \ar[r ] & d\\ } \ ] ] then we pull back the upper left square .
the square comprised of the upper left and right squares together is then a cartesian square , with bottom map an equivalence .
these are stable under pullback , meaning that the identity map @xmath50 is pulled back , this time to the `` top '' .
thus we know the pullback of the left square is equivalent to @xmath46 , so the top two squares are as in figure [ fig : pbbd ] .
this implies that the left square is also absolutely cartesian , as the entire and the right ones are .
@xmath51\ar[d]\ar@/^/[rr]^{id } & c \ar[d]\ar[r ] & d\ar[d]\\ b \ar[r]\ar@/_/[rr]_{id } & a \ar[r ] & b\\ } \ ] ] then we return to @xmath47 , and the ( now ) absolutely cartesian square in the left of figure [ fig : pbbd ] . in the same way as before ,
we get a section @xmath52 or @xmath30 .
if @xmath30 is a section , we are done the one - sided inverse ( our original section )
has an inverse on the other side and @xmath53 , which implies immediately that @xmath54 since it occurs in the cartesian diagram on the left side of figure [ fig : pbbd ] .
if @xmath52 instead is a section , we are done .
this is because the map @xmath55 was a section obtained earlier .
we conclude @xmath56 , which implies immediately that @xmath57 since it occurs in the cartesian diagram on the left side of figure [ fig : pbbd ] and equivalences are pulled back .
false @xmath58\ar[d ] & d\ar[d]\\ a \ar[r]^{\sim } & b\\ } \ ] ] @xmath59 \ar[d ] & c\ar[d]^{\sim}\\ b \ar[r ] & a } \ ] ] for absolutely * cocartesian * squares , if we allow our homotopy functors to also be possibly contravariant , then we can establish that they are of the same form as absolutely cartesian squares .
the proof is parallel to that for cartesian squares , with the functor @xmath60 replaced by @xmath61 .
as observed by the anonymous reviewer , the following weakened form of the conjecture already holds : [ prop : rev ] if one restricts to @xmath17-cubes of 1-connected spaces and homotopy functors which take values in 1-connected - spaces , conjecture [ conj2 ] holds . the direction
( absolutely cocartesian implies absolutely cartesian ) holds in the weaker condition of nilpotent is nilpotent when @xmath62 is a nilpotent group .
1-connected spaces are trivially nilpotent . ]
spaces and functors taking values in nilpotent spaces .
this is also following the reviewer .
* functors with nilpotent target , abs cocartesian @xmath63 abs cartesian*. let @xmath64 be absolutely cocartesian .
the functor @xmath65 from spaces to spectra preserves the cocartesianness , and in spectra , diagrams are cocartesian iff cartesian .
@xmath66 from spectra to spaces preserves cartesianness , so @xmath67 is cartesian , in addition to remaining cocartesian .
repeated applications of @xmath68 will clearly retain this property ; that is , @xmath69 will be cartesian and cocartesian .
+ as @xmath66 and @xmath65 are an adjoint pair and @xmath68 the associated monad , there is an associated cosimplicial @xmath68-completion " ( a.k.a @xmath70-nilpotent completion ) for any space . for a space @xmath71 ,
the @xmath68-completion of @xmath71 is the homotopy limit of the cosimplicial space which arises naturally from iterating the monadic maps @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
@xmath74\ar@<-3pt>[r ] & \ar[l ] qqx \ar[r]\ar@<6pt>[r]\ar@<-6pt>[r ] & \ar@<-3pt>[l]\ar@<3pt>[l]\cdots } \ ] ] the same line of reasoning holds with @xmath64 replaced by @xmath75 ( since @xmath75 is also absolutely cocartesian ) , so @xmath64 is absolutely cartesian .
* functors with 1-connected target , absolutely cartesian @xmath63 absolutely cocartesian*. let @xmath64 be absolutely cartesian . then @xmath75 and @xmath76 for all hofunctors @xmath77 are also cartesian
; in particular , @xmath76 is also cocartesian .
since @xmath2 takes values in 1-connected spaces , this is sufficient to conclude that @xmath75 itself is cocartesian .
this is for all hofunctors @xmath2 , so @xmath64 is absolutely cocartesian .
it was also pointed out by goodwillie in a discussion with the author that [ prop : tom ] if ( absolutely cocartesian @xmath63 absolutely cartesian ) , then ( absolutely cartesian @xmath63 absolutely cocartesian ) .
let @xmath64 be absolutely cartesian .
then for all @xmath78 hofunctors and @xmath79 in the appropriate categories , @xmath80 is also cartesian .
unwrapping the dependencies and keeping in mind that @xmath81 takes cocartesian to cartesian , we get that @xmath82 is absolutely cocartesian .
apply our hypothesis and that @xmath81 takes cocartesian to cartesian to conclude that @xmath64 is also absolutely cocartesian .
the original form of conjecture [ conj1 ] was as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ an @xmath13-cube of spaces @xmath64 is absolutely cartesian iff there are absolutely cartesian @xmath17-cubes @xmath83 such that @xmath84 .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this was corrected to the current form of the conjecture due to the following illustrative example ; a cube which may be expressed as the _ composition _ of two cubes of the aforementioned type without being a map of two such absolutely ( co)cartesian squares . given maps @xmath85 with the condition that @xmath86 is equivalent to the identity
, the following 3-cube may be assembled : : cubes . ]
@xmath87 \ar[dd ] & & c\ar@{=}[dd ] \\ a \ar@{=}[ur ]
\ar[rr ] \ar[dd ] & & b \ar[dd]\ar[ur]\\ & b \ar[rr ] & & c \\ d \ar@{=}[rr]\ar[ur ] & & d\ar[ur]\\ } $ } \ ] ] now that we have more complicated diagrams , we have chosen to denote equivalences by equality so that it is clear which maps are equivalences .
it is possible to first establish absolute cartesianness and cocartesianness independent of the decomposition , but this is superfluous once we have the decomposition .
we will then just provide the decomposition .
false we will first establish absolute cartesianness and cocartesianness independent of the decomposition , and then give the decomposition . while an @xmath17-cube is cartesian if and only if its @xmath18 cubes of fibers ( for all choices of point to fiber over ) is cartesian , there is only a partial dual to this statement .
if we know an @xmath17-cube is cocartesian , then it will follow that its @xmath18 cofiber cubes will also be cocartesian .
_ however _ , there are cubes with cocartesian cofiber cubes which are not themselves cocartesian .
this boils down to the difference between cartesian squares and cocartesian squares ; the former induces a long exact sequence in homotopy groups and the latter only in ( co)homology groups .
we are not totally bereft of tools to check for cocartesianness .
what is perhaps the most common is the covering lemma " ( * ? ? ?
* prop 0.2 and its dual ) , which we will state a restricted version of for cubical diagrams : [ lem : cover ] let @xmath0 be an @xmath17-cubical diagram ( of spaces or spectra ) .
it may be expressed as a map of @xmath18 cubes in @xmath17 ways . for any such expression , @xmath88
, @xmath0 is cartesian precisely when @xmath89\ar[d ] & \operatorname{holim}_\emptyset x\ar[d]\\ y_\emptyset \ar[r ] & \operatorname{holim}_\emptyset y } \ ] ] is cartesian ; @xmath90 denotes the initial object of the diagram @xmath71 ( and likewise for @xmath91 ) .
@xmath0 is cocartesian precisely when @xmath92 \ar[d ] & x_{[n-1]}\ar[d]\\ \operatorname{hocolim}_1 y \ar[r ] & y_{[n-1]}\\ } \ ] ] is cocartesian ; here , @xmath93}$ ] is the final element of the diagram @xmath71 ( and similarly for @xmath91 ) .
this lemma allows us to determine cartesianness ( and cocartesianness ) by considering it as a map of two squares @xmath94 ( possibly in two ways , one for cartesianness and one for cocartesianness ) . for cartesianness
, we consider the 3-cube as a map @xmath16 \ar[d ] & b \ar[d]\\ d \ar[r]^{\simeq } & d\\ } \hspace{1 cm } \rightarrow \hspace{1 cm } \xymatrix { a \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c \ar[d]^{\simeq}\\ b \ar[r ] & c\\ } .\ ] ] let @xmath71 denote the source square and @xmath91 the target square .
the 3-cube is cartesian then if the following @xmath95\ar[d ] & ( \operatorname{holim}_\emptyset x ) \simeq b \ar[d]\\ a = y_\emptyset \ar[r ] & ( \operatorname{holim}_\emptyset y ) \simeq b\\ } \ ] ] is cartesian .
the property that composition the maps @xmath96 is the identity is what gives us that the induced map @xmath97 is also equivalent to the identity .
it is clear that this is true for any homotopy functor @xmath2 we apply , except the square will be of @xmath98 and @xmath99 . for cocartesianness
, we consider the 3-cube as a map @xmath16 \ar[d]^{\simeq } & c \ar[d]\\ a \ar[r ] & b\\ } \hspace{1 cm } \rightarrow \hspace{1 cm } \xymatrix { b \ar[r ] \ar[d ] & c \ar[d]\\ d \ar[r]^{\simeq } & d\\ } .\ ] ] let @xmath100 denote the source square and @xmath101 the target square . the 3-cube is cartesian then if the following @xmath102\ar[r ] & w_{[1]}=c\ar[d]\\ ( \operatorname{hocolim}_1 z ) \simeq b \ar[r ] & z_{[1]}=c\\ } \ ] ] is cocartesian . in this case , the maps @xmath96 compsing to the identity is what gives us that the map @xmath103 is an equivalence .
it is again clear that this is true for any homotopy functor @xmath2 we apply , except the square will be of @xmath99 and @xmath104 .
this 3-cube is not written as a map of two absolutely ( co)cartesian squares , but it has just been show to be absolutely cocartesian and cartesian . despite not being a map of two absolutely ( co)cartesian squares ,
the 3-cube may be expressed as a composition of two 3-cubes which _ are _ of that form .
this relies on the ability to express @xmath45 as a retract of @xmath46 .
we compose the cube @xmath105 \ar[dd ] & & c\ar@{=}[dd ] \\ a \ar@{=}[ur ]
\ar[rr ] \ar[dd ] & & b \ar@{=}[dd]\ar[ur]\\ & b \ar[rr ] & & c\\ b \ar@{=}[rr]\ar@{=}[ur ] & & b\ar[ur]\\ } $ } \ ] ] with @xmath106\ar@{=}[dd ] & & c\ar@{=}[dd ] \\ b \ar@{=}[rr]\ar@{=}[ur]\ar[dd ] & & b\ar[dd]\ar[ur]\\ & b \ar[rr ] & & c \\ d \ar@{=}[rr]\ar[ur ] & & d\ar[ur]\\ } $ } \ ] ] to get our original 3 cube as the total cube of the composition ( ` glueing ' the first cube atop the second ) : @xmath105 \ar[dd ] & & c\ar@{=}[dd ] \\ a \ar@{=}[ur ] \ar[rr ] \ar[dd ] & & b \ar@{=}[dd]\ar[ur]\\ & b \ar[rr]\ar@{=}[dd ] & & c\ar@{=}[dd ] \\ b \ar@{=}[rr]\ar@{=}[ur]\ar[dd ] & & b\ar[dd]\ar[ur]\\ & b \ar[rr ] & & c \\ d \ar@{=}[rr]\ar[ur ] & & d\ar[ur]\\ } $ } \ ] ] false and if the following is cartesian @xmath107 then the 3-cube is cartesian .
if the following is cocartesian , @xmath108 the 3-cube is cocartesian .
we end with a few remarks on extending this and other approaches .
par@xcite studies strict colimits which are preserved by all functors , and calls such colimits absolute , a naming convention which we have chosen to follow by calling our _ homotopy _ diagrams absolute when preserved by all homotopy functors .
street works in an enriched setting and states his results in terms of distributors@xcite .
it is not clear at the moment how applicable their results are in this setting .
the first step would be to switch to considering simplicial functors , which are ( roughly ) as good as homotopy functors , to work enriched .
the original goal to classifying absolutely cartesian cubes was to get `` wrong way '' maps , from holims of cubes of one dimension to ones of a higher dimension , in a certain diagram related to the @xmath109 page of the spectral sequence associated to a cosimplicial space .
these are going the wrong way inasmuch as natural maps between diagrams are usually from lower to higher dimension , which induces a map from the holim of the higher dimensional diagram to the holim of the lower dimensional diagram . a map of cubes _ of the same dimension
_ , @xmath110 , induces maps on the homotopy limits of the cubes @xmath111 ( also for the punctured homotopy limits , @xmath112 ) . if a and b are diagrams , with b cartesian , @xmath113 .
that is , a way to take an @xmath17 cube and produce an @xmath13 cube with equivalent ( punctured ) homotopy limit is to find a cartesian @xmath17 cube to which it maps naturally .
we would also like do these constructions only once for all homotopy functors , so the cube we are mapping to not only needs to be cartesian , but with cartesianness preserved by all homotopy functors . | we call a diagram @xmath0 absolutely cartesian if @xmath1 is homotopy cartesian for all homotopy functors @xmath2 .
this is a sensible notion for diagrams in categories @xmath3 where goodwillie s calculus of functors may be set up for functors with domain @xmath3 .
we prove a classification theorem for absolutely cartesian squares of spaces and state a conjecture of the classification for higher dimensional cubes .
[ multiblock footnote omitted ] let @xmath4 be a small indexing category with initial object @xmath5 and final object 1 .
a diagram @xmath0 in a category @xmath3 is a functor @xmath6 ; we restrict ourselves here to @xmath3 being spaces.this diagram is cartesian when @xmath7 is equivalent to the homotopy limit of @xmath0 over @xmath4 with @xmath5 removed , denoted @xmath8 or @xmath9 when @xmath4 is clear from context .
similarly , @xmath0 is cocartesian if @xmath10 is equivalent to the homotopy colimit over @xmath4 with the final object removed , denoted @xmath11 ; as in the cartesian case , the @xmath4 subscript is omitted if clear from context and we write @xmath12 .
a functor @xmath2 is a homotopy functor if it is weak - equivalence - preserving .
we call a diagram @xmath0 absolutely ( co)cartesian if @xmath1 is homotopy ( co)cartesian for all homotopy functors @xmath2 .
note that a diagram is an @xmath13 cube if it is indexed by @xmath14)$ ] , the powerset on @xmath15=\{0,1,\ldots n\}$ ] . |
one of the challenges in rl is the trade - off between exploration and exploitation . the agent must choose between taking an action known to give positive reward or to explore other possibilities hoping to receive a greater reward in the future . in this context ,
a common strategy in unknown environments is to assume that unseen states are more promising than those states already seen .
one such approach is optimistic initialization of values ( * ? ? ?
* section 2.7 ) .
several rl algorithms rely on estimates of expected values of states or expected values of actions in a given state @xcite .
optimistic initialization consists in initializing such estimates with higher values than are likely to be the true value . to do so , we depend on prior knowledge of the expected scale of rewards .
this paper circumvents such limitations presenting a different way to optimistically initialize value functions without additional domain knowledge or assumptions . in the next section
we formalize the problem setting as well as the rl framework .
we then present our optimistic initialization approach .
also , we present some experimental analysis of our method using the arcade learning environment @xcite as the testbed .
consider a markov decision process , at time step @xmath0 the agent is in a state @xmath1 and it needs to take an action @xmath2 .
once the action is taken , the agent observes a new state @xmath3 and a reward @xmath4 from a transition probability function @xmath5 .
the agent s goal is to obtain a policy @xmath6 that maximizes the expected discounted return @xmath7 $ ] , where @xmath8 $ ] is the discount factor and @xmath9 is the action - value function for policy @xmath10 . sometimes it is not feasible to compute @xmath9 , we then approximate such values with linear function approximation : @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is a learned set of weights and @xmath13 is the feature vector .
function approximation adds further difficulties for optimistic initialization , as one only indirectly specifies the value of state - action pairs through the choice of @xmath12 .
an approach to circumvent the requirement of knowing the reward scale is to normalize all rewards ( @xmath14 ) by the first non - zero reward seen ( @xmath15 ) , _ i.e. _ : @xmath16 .
then we can optimistically initialize @xmath17 as @xmath18 , representing the expectation that a reward the size of the first reward will be achieved on the next timestep to @xmath19 . for sparse reward domains , which is common in the arcade learning environment ,
the mild form is often sufficient . ] . with function approximation
, this means initializing the weights @xmath12 to ensure @xmath20 , _
e.g. _ : @xmath21
. however , this requires @xmath22 to be constant among all states and actions . if the feature vector is binary - valued then one approach for guaranteeing @xmath23 has a constant norm is to stack @xmath24 and @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is applied to each coordinate .
while this achieves the goal , it has the cost of doubling the number of features .
besides , it removes sparsity in the feature vector , which can often be exploited for more efficient algorithms .
our approach is to shift the value function so that a zero function is in fact optimistic .
we normalize by the first reward as described above .
in addition , we shift the rewards downward by @xmath27 , so @xmath28 .
thus , we have : @xmath29\\ & = & \underbrace{\mathbb{e}_\pi\bigg[\sum_{k = 0}^\infty \gamma^k \frac{r_{t+k+1}}{|r_{1\mbox{\tiny{st}}}| } \bigg]}_{\frac{q_\pi(s_t , a_t)}{|r_{1\mbox{\tiny{st}}}| } } + \underbrace{\sum_{k = 0}^\infty \gamma^k ( \gamma - 1)}_{-1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that since @xmath30 , initializing @xmath31 is the same as initializing @xmath32 .
this shift alleviates us from knowing @xmath33 , since we do not have the requirement @xmath34 anymore .
also , even though @xmath35 is defined in terms of @xmath15 , we only need to know @xmath15 once a non - zero reward is observed . in episodic tasks this shift will encourage agents to terminate episodes as fast as possible to avoid negative rewards . to avoid this
we provide a termination reward @xmath36 , where @xmath37 is the number of steps in the episode and @xmath38 is the maximum number of steps .
this is equivalent to receiving a reward of @xmath39 for additional @xmath40 steps , and forces the agent to look for something better .
we evaluated our approach in two different domains , with different reward scales and different number of active features .
these domains were obtained from the arcade learning environment @xcite , a framework with dozens of atari 2600 games where the agent has access , at each time step , to the game screen or the ram data , besides an additional reward signal .
we compare the learning curves of regular sarsa(@xmath41 ) @xcite and sarsa(@xmath41 ) with its q - values optimistically initialized .
basic _ features with the same sarsa(@xmath41 ) parameters reported by @xcite .
basic _ features divide the screen in to @xmath42 tiles and check , for each tile , if each of the 128 possible colours are active , totalling 28,672 features .
the results are presented in figure 1 .
we report results using two different learning rates @xmath43 , a low value ( @xmath44 ) and a high value ( @xmath45 ) , each point corresponds to the average after 30 runs .
the game freeway consists in controlling a chicken that needs to cross a street , avoiding cars , to score a point ( @xmath46 reward ) .
the episode lasts for 8195 steps and the agent s goal is to cross the street as many times as possible .
this game poses an interesting exploration challenge for ramdom exploration because it requires the agent to cross the street acting randomly ( @xmath47 ) for dozens of time steps .
this means frequently selecting the action `` go up '' while avoiding cars .
looking at the results in figure 1 we can see that , as expected , optimistic initialization does help since it favours exploration , speeding up the process of learning that a positive reward is available in the game .
we see this improvement over sarsa(@xmath41 ) for both learning rates , with best performance when @xmath44 .
the game private eye is a very different domain . in this game the agent
is supposed to move right for several screens ( much more than when crossing the street in the game freeway ) and it should avoid enemies to avoid negative rewards . along the path the agent can collect intermediate rewards ( @xmath48 ) but its ultimate goal is to get to the end and reach the goal , obtaining a much larger reward .
we can see that the optimistic initialization is much more reckless in the sense that it takes much more time to realize a specific state is not good ( one of the main drawbacks of this approach ) , while sarsa(@xmath41 ) is more conservative .
interestingly , we observe that exploration may have a huge benefit in this game as a larger learning rate guides the agent to see rewards in a scale that was not seen by sarsa(@xmath41 ) .
0.47 0.47 0.47 0.47 thus , besides our formal analysis , we have shown here that our approach behaves as one would expect optimistically initialized algorithms to behave .
it increased agents exploration with the trade off that sometimes the agent `` exploited '' a negative reward hoping to obtain a higher return .
rl algorithms can be implemented without needing rigorous domain knowledge , but as far as we know , until this work , it was unfeasible to perform optimistic initialization in the same transparent way .
besides not requiring adaptations for specific domains , our approach does not hinder algorithm performance .
the authors would like to thak erik talvitie for his helpful input throughout this research .
this research was supported by alberta innovates technology futures and the alberta innovates centre for machine learning and computing resources provided by compute canada through westgrid . | in reinforcement learning ( rl ) , it is common to use optimistic initialization of value functions to encourage exploration .
however , such an approach generally depends on the domain , viz . , the scale of the rewards must be known , and the feature representation must have a constant norm .
we present a simple approach that performs optimistic initialization with less dependence on the domain . |
the nature of the matter content of the universe is one of the mysteries in today s physical science .
the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) collaboration gives fairly accurate values on the contents of our universe @xcite @xmath4 where @xmath1 denotes the baryon - to - photon ratio , and @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7 denotes the density of total matter , baryonic matter and dark energy , respectively .
one sees that , coincidentally , the dark matter density is comparable to the dark energy density as well as to the baryonic matter density .
such coincidences need to be understood . while an explanation for the coincidence between dark matter and dark energy can be provided in the quintessence scenario , it is hard to give a natural explanation for the coincidence between dark matter and baryonic matter although some efforts have been devoted @xcite .
a natural explanation for such a coincidence requires some unification scenario which correlates the baryongenesis with the dark matter generation .
the affleck - dine ( ad ) mechanism @xcite is a promising scenario for baryogenesis .
it is based on the dynamics of a complex scalar field @xmath8 called ad field carrying baryon number . in the framework of supersymmetry ,
ad field can be realized as a linear combination of squark or slepton fields , which has a large expectation value during the inflationary stage .
the subsequent coherent oscillation creates a large net baryon asymmetry .
as the coherent oscillation of @xmath8 is generically unstable with spatial perturbation , it condenses into non - topological solitons called q - balls @xcite .
numerical estimations show that almost all the initial baryon asymmetry of @xmath8 is absorbed into these q - balls .
the baryonic content of the universe can arise from earlier q - ball evaporation which transforms leptonic asymmetry into baryonic asymmetry from sphaleron effects before electroweak scale or from the later decay of the baryonic q - ball . at the same time , if the q - ball is nonstable and its late decay into lsp ( after the freeze out of lsp ) will naturally generate the dark matter content of the universe @xcite . note that in the analysis of @xcite , the q - balls are assumed to decay before bbn era in order not to destruct the bbn predictions for light element abundances .
however , since the recent wmap data on light element abundances show some deviation with the bbn predictions ( as discussed later ) , it is possible that the q - balls may decay during the bbn era and affect the bbn predictions for light element abundances .
this possibility was first noted in @xcite .
such late decays are favorable if their effects on the bbn predictions can improve the fit with the observed data . throughout this work the _ late - decaying q - balls
_ refers to the q - balls which decay during the bbn era .
let us take a look at the bbn predictions for light element abundances compared with the observed values .
the bbn predictions are given by @xcite @xmath9 while the observed values are given by @xcite @xmath10 where @xmath11 denotes @xmath12he abundance .
we see that the @xmath13 and @xmath2 predictions , especially @xmath2 prediction , do not fit well with the observed values .
in this work we try to solve the above two problems , i.e. , the matter coincidence problem and the @xmath2 abundance problem , by considering the q - balls which decay during the bbn era .
we show that such late - decaying baryonic q - balls ( hereafter called b - balls ) with lifetime of about @xmath0 can provide a new developing mechanism for the bbn through a rolling @xmath1 , which can then naturally explain the discrepancy of the bbn prediction with the wmap data on the light element abundances . for the late - decaying leptonic q - balls ( hereafter called l - balls ) with lifetime of about @xmath3
, we find that their decay products , gravitinos , can serve as a dark matter candidate and give a possible explanation of the coincidence between baryonic matter and dark matter .
1 shows the bbn predictions for light element abundances versus @xmath1 @xcite .
we see that , to fit the observed values , bbn predictions for @xmath13 and @xmath2 require a @xmath1 value which is significantly lower than @xmath14 obtained from the cmb measurement @xcite . in order to solve the @xmath2 problem , we propose that _ @xmath1 is rolling and is small during the period of @xmath2 generation ; then @xmath1 rolls up to the ultimate observed value after @xmath2 generation_. this mechanism can be realized in the late - decaying b - ball scenario since the decays of b - balls can induce the baryonic asymmetry and lead to the rolling of @xmath1 value .
we propose that the bbn undergoes two stages : * the first stage is from the start of bbn till the time at which the @xmath2 synthesis finishes and thus its absolute abundance no longer changes later .
the baryonic asymmetry arises mainly from the lepton asymmetry through spharleon effects instead of from the b - ball decay because the b - ball decay occurs throughout a period which is much longer than the period of this stage .
this stage is similar to the standard bbn process except that the @xmath1 value is small and is rolling up . *
the second stage begins when the @xmath2 synthesis ends while other light elements continue to be synthesized . )
is not much diluted and thus continue to synthesize @xmath15 and @xmath13 . ] in this stage , the temperature drops so that the @xmath2 absolute abundance no longer changes . as a result ,
the relative abundance of @xmath2 , i.e. , @xmath16 , is decreasing since the number of protons is increasing due to the b - ball decays . at the transition point between the first and the second stages
, @xmath1 value is rolling up to @xmath17 .
we used the fastbbn code @xcite and adopted three families of neutrinos in getting such a @xmath1 value which gives the best fit value of @xmath2 abundance .
we assume that in this stage the ratio of the numbers of protons to neutrons produced from b - ball decays is @xmath18 because the baryonic content produced from b - balls reach approximate thermal equilibrium near the surface before they spread out .
taking into account the residual protons from the first stage , the ratio of the total proton number to neutron number should be larger than 7 .
so the proton consuming reaction is more efficient than in the first stage , which implies that during this stage @xmath13 ( @xmath15 ) synthesis efficiency is relatively lower ( higher ) than in the first stage .
therefore , we predict that the overall synthesis efficiency of @xmath13 ( @xmath15 ) is lower ( higher ) than the value @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) at @xmath21 .
this means that for @xmath15 our prediction is different from the standard bbn prediction shown in fig.1 .
the rolling of @xmath1 ends as the b - ball decays finish within the second stage .
obviously , such a rolling-@xmath1 scenario can give a final required value for the @xmath22 abundance which has little difference with standard bbn prediction with the ultimate @xmath1 value ( @xmath23 ) .
therefore , this new bbn generating mechanism through a rolling @xmath1 can not only solve the discrepancy between the predicted and observed values of @xmath2 abundance but also can qualitatively predict the required values for @xmath13 and @xmath22 abundances . for the abundance of @xmath15 our scenario predicted a higher value than the standard bbn prediction , which remains to be tested by future measurements . in the following
we show that the above scenario can indeed be realized by considering the late - decaying b - balls .
the flat directions @xcite in the minimal supersymmetric model carry baryon or lepton numbers , which can be identified as the ad fields @xmath24 .
we express the @xmath25 and @xmath26 directions as @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
although the flat directions are exactly flat when supersymmetry ( susy ) is unbroken , it will be lifted by susy breaking effects . in the gauge - mediated susy breaking ( gmsb ) scenario , susy breaks at low energy scales .
the shape of the effective potential has the curvature of the order of electroweak scale at low energy and almost flat at higher scales @xcite .
the gauge mediation part of the potential is given by @xcite @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the susy breaking scale , @xmath31 is the messenger mass scale and @xmath32 is a soft breaking mass of @xmath33 ( @xmath34 tev ) .
the flat direction can also be lifted by the susy breaking mediated by gravity .
the gravity lifted potential is given by @xmath35 { |\phi|}^2 \ , \ ] ] where @xmath36 is the reduced planck mass .
the @xmath37 term is the one - loop corrections and takes the absolute value @xmath38 to @xmath39 .
the different sign of @xmath37 can give different kinds of q - balls , i.e. , a positive @xmath37 gives delayed type and a negative @xmath37 gives new type. as noted in @xcite , the contribution to @xmath37 from yukawa interactions is positive while from gauge interactions is negative . since large yukawa couplings arise in the third family , we can choose @xmath40 flat direction to give a delayed type l - ball and @xmath41 flat direction to give a new type b - ball @xcite .
this gravity - mediated q - balls have typical values for their charge and radius @xcite @xmath42 where @xmath43 and @xmath44 since the long - life b - ball gives very small @xmath45 , we have the estimations @xmath46 the @xmath26 flat direction for b - ball can also be lifted by the non - renormalizable terms of the superpotential given by @xmath47 where the effective scale @xmath48 includes the coupling @xmath49 and hence can be larger than the cut - off scale .
so @xmath50 is given as @xmath51 .
the q - ball decay rate into fermions is proportional to the surface term , given by @xcite @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the surface of the q - ball . here
b - balls can decay into nucleons and the decay lifetime ( in seconds ) is given by @xmath54 where @xmath55 . if we choose the non - renormalizable scale naturally to be reduced planck scale , it can
gives a lifetime @xmath56 for a gravitino a little heavier than 1 gev .
this means that the decay of such `` new type '' b - balls into nucleon can indeed occur during the bbn era . since the b - ball decays can provide baryonic content
, the @xmath1 value is natually rolling up .
so the rolling-@xmath1 scenario can be naturally realized in such late - decaying b - ball case .
the q - balls may have very long lifetime in the pure gauge - mediated scenario and rather short lifetime in the pure gravity - mediated scenario .
as studied in @xcite , in the pure gauge - mediated scenario their lifetime can be so long that they may survive decaying and evaporating and exist in today s universe as the dark matter . in this section
we consider the late - decaying delayed - type l - balls with bbn lifetime in the general susy breaking model with both gravity and gauge effects and study the possibility for their decay products to serve as the dark matter .
we find that this approach is feasible and can provide an unified scenario to give an explanation for the coincidence between dark matter and baryonic matter contents . note that although such late - decaying l - ball decays occur throughout the bbn era and affect the bbn predictions for light elements abundances , we find that the effects can be within the allowed region . when the zero - temperature potential @xmath57 dominates at the onset of the coherent oscillations of ad fields , the gauge - mediated type q - balls are formed .
their mass @xmath58 and size @xmath59 are given by @xmath60 just as indicated in the numerical simulations @xcite , the produced q - ball almost absorb all the charges carried by the ad field and the typical charge is estimated as @xmath61 where @xmath62 .
when @xmath63 dominates the potential at the onset of the coherent oscillation of the ad fields , the delayed - type q - ball form when the ad field leaves this region and enters the @xmath57 dominated region if @xmath37 is positive .
however , if @xmath37 is negative , the gravity - mediated type q - balls ( new - type ) are produced , as discussed in the preceding section .
so when the ad field starts to oscillate ( @xmath64 ) in the @xmath63 dominated region for positive @xmath37 , the charge of the delayed - type q - ball is given by @xmath65 here the gravition term domination condition gives @xmath66 .
for l - ball , the upper limit of the decay rate can be estimated as in eq.([limit ] ) .
so the lower limit of the lifetime in seconds is given by @xmath67 the late decay of the l - balls will release electromagnetic energy and can alter some light element abundances since such electromagnetic energy injection can have dissociation effects on light elements . as shown in fig .
2 taken from @xcite , if such electromagnetic energy release is sufficiently small , it will be allowed .
so if we require that the l - balls keep on decaying until about @xmath3 with very small energy release , it will not affect the success of bbn .
( note that from fig . 2
one sees that the lifetime requirement is not stringent as long as the energy release is sufficiently small .
here we require a lifetime of about @xmath3 as an example . )
we found that such a lifetime requirement can be met by choosing a gravitino mass of @xmath68 mev for susy breaking scale of @xmath34 tev . in the following
we show that in this case the energy release can be sufficiently small , and the baryonic content and the dark matter content can be correctly related . in this case
the charge of l - ball can be estimated to be @xmath69 and the energy per l - ball charge is given by @xmath70 it is easy to see that the decay products can only inject electromagnetic energy .
the average electromagnetic energy release for each q - ball is given by @xmath71 where @xmath72 denotes the decaying rate of q - ball , @xmath73 is the average electromagnetic energy release per ad field decay , @xmath74 is the ad field number generated per q - charge and it is unity here .
since the tree - level two - body amplitude dominates , the decay mode is @xmath75 , where @xmath76 denotes the lightest supersymmetric particle and @xmath77 a sm particle . since in our analysis gravitino is quite light , much lighter than neutralino , it is assumed to be the lsp .
so the decay products of the ad fields provide a natural dark matter candidate gravitino .
the energy of the nearly massless particle @xmath77 in the decay is given by @xmath78 the energy release rate is given by the decay rate times the energy release per gravitino generation @xmath79 where @xmath80 denotes the charge per q - ball which decayed .
suppose some of the initial baryon asymmetry is induced from lepton asymmetry through l - ball evaporation with sphaleron effects before the @xmath81 scale , then we have @xmath82 where @xmath83 indicate initial charge per q - ball , and @xmath84 and @xmath85 are the number density for q - ball and baryon , respectively
. @xmath45 denotes the changed portion of lepton asymmetry into baryon asymmetry and @xmath86 be the baryon asymmetry contribution from l - ball to the total asymmetry .
finally we obtain @xmath87 as noted in @xcite , the daughter electron will immediately initiate an electromagnetic cascade to give @xmath88 .
for the relativistic daughter muon , it typically interacts with the background photons through thomson scattering .
as the scattering time is shorter than the time - dilated muon decay time , the muon energy can safely change into electromagnetic energy . for the daughter tau ,
the typical scattering life time is longer than the time - dilated tau decay time , the electromagnetic energy change ratio is 1/3 to 1 .
accounting all the branch ratio of its decay channel gives the 1/2 of the tau energy as electromagnetic energy release .
for simplicity , we chose the release of electromagnetic energy to be half of the average lepton energy .
sufficiently small electromagnetic energy release is possible and , for example , we require @xmath89 gev , which , combined with the lifetime requirement , is well allowed by the bbn constraints shown in fig .
2 . under such requirement
we get the approximate portion @xmath90
. then we can give an estimation of the baryonic content of the universe if all the dark matter is from l - ball decay @xmath91 we see that this scenario can give an explanation for the matter coincidence problem .
we studied the possibility for the q - balls to decay during the bbn era ( such possibility has not been studied in the literature ) and the cosmological consequences of such late decays .
our findings are : * the late - decaying baryonic q - balls with lifetime of about @xmath0 can provide a new developing mechanism for the bbn through a rolling baryon - to - photon ratio @xmath1 .
we proposed that in this scenario the bbn era undergoes two stages separated by a transition point @xmath92 and the @xmath2 synthesis finished in the first stage .
such a scenario can not only solve the discrepancy between the predicted and observed values of @xmath2 abundance , but also can qualitatively predict the required values for @xmath13 and @xmath22 abundances . for the abundance of @xmath15 this scenario predicted a higher value than the standard bbn , which leaves to be tested by future measurements . * the late - decaying leptonic q - balls with lifetime of about @xmath3 decay into gravitinos , which can serve as a dark matter candidate and give an explanation for the approximate equality of dark and baryon matter densities .
we are grateful to xiaotao he for providing us some useful nuclear data and junjie cao for helpful discussions .
this work is supported in part by national natural science foundation of china .
30 wmap collaboration , astrophys .
* 148 * , 1 ( 2003 ) ; * 148 * , 175 ( 2003 ) ; * 248 * , 195 ( 2003 ) .
f. wilczek , hep - ph/0408167 .
i. affleck and m.dine , 249 , 361 ( 1985 ) .
k. enqvist , j. mcdonald , 425 , 309 ( 1998 ) ; k. enqvist , a. mazumdar , phys . rept . * 380 * , 99 ( 2003 ) .
m. fujii , k. hamaguchi , 525 , 143 ( 2002 ) ; 66 , 083501 ( 2002 ) ; m. fujii , m. ibe , 69 , 035006 ( 2004 ) .
k. ichikawa , m. kawasaki , f. takahashi , 597 , 1 ( 2004 ) .
k. jedamzik , astro - ph/0402344 ; k. jedamzik,84 , 3248 ( 2000 ) .
k. hagiwara _
[ particle data group collaboration ] , 66 , 010001 ( 2002 ) .
p. d. serpico , s. esposito , f. iocco , g. mangano , g. miele , o. pisanti , astro - ph/0408076 ; a. cuoco , f. iocco , g. mangano , g. miele , o. pisanti , p.d .
serpico , astro - ph/0307213 .
r. h. cyburt , b. d. fields and k. a. olive , 567 , 227 ( 2003 ) .
g. fiorentini , e. lisi , s. sarkar and f. l. villante , 58 , 063506 ( 1998 ) ; e. lisi , s. sarkar and f.l .
villante , 59 , 123520 ( 1999 ) .
t. gherghetta , c. kolda , s. p. martin , 468 , 37 ( 1996 ) . g. dvali , a. kusenko , m. shaposhnikov , 417 , 99 ( 1998 ) .
a. kusenko , v. kuzmin , m. shaposhikov , p.g.tinyakov , 80 , 3185 ( 1998 ) . m. kawasaki , f. takahashi , m. yamaguchi , 66 , 043516 ( 2002 ) .
a. cohen , s. coleman , h. georgi and a. manohar , 272 , 301 ( 1986 ) s. kasuya , m. kawasaki , 85,2677 ( 2000 ) ; 64 , 123515 ( 2001 ) .
r. h. cyburt , j. ellis , b. d. fields , k. a. olive , 67 , 103521 ( 2003 ) . j. l. feng , a. rajaraman , f. takayama , 91 , 011302 ( 2003 ) ; 68 , 063504 ( 2003 ) ; j. l. feng , s. su , f. takayama , hep - ph/0404198 ; hep - ph/0404231 ; f. wang , j. m. yang , hep - ph/0405186 . | in the affleck - dine mechanism of baryogenesis , non - topological solitons called q - balls can be formed . in this work
we propose that such q - balls decay during the bbn era and study the cosmological consequence of such late decays .
we find that the late - decaying baryonic q - balls with lifetime of about @xmath0 can provide a new developing mechanism for the bbn through a rolling baryon - to - photon ratio @xmath1 , which can naturally explain the discrepancy of the bbn prediction with the wmap data on @xmath2 abundance .
for the late - decaying leptonic q - balls with lifetime of about @xmath3 , we find that their decay product , gravitinos , can serve as a dark matter candidate and give an explanation for the approximate equality of dark and baryon matter densities .
= # 1,nucl .
phys .
* b#1 * , # 1,phys .
lett .
b * # 1 * , # 1,phys .
rev .
d * # 1 * , # 1,phys .
rev .
. * # 1 * , # 1#20.5ex |
indirect methods to search for extra - solar planets do not measure emission from the planet itself , but instead seek to discover and quantify the tell - tale effects that the planet would have on the position ( astrometry ) and motion ( radial velocity ) of its parent star , or on the apparent brightness of its parent star ( occultation ) or random background sources ( gravitational microlensing ) .
all of these indirect signals have a characteristic temporal behavior that aids in the discrimination between planetary effects and other astrophysical causes .
the variability can be due to the changing position of the planet with respect to the parent star ( astrometry , radial velocity , occultation ) , or the changing position of the complete planetary system with respect to background stars ( microlensing ) .
the time - variable photometric signals that can be measured using occultation and microlensing techniques are the focus of this small series of lectures .
an occultation is the temporary dimming of the apparent brightness of a parent star that occurs when a planet transits the stellar disk ; this can occur only when the orbital plane is nearly perpendicular to the plane of the sky . because the planet is considerably cooler than its parent star ,
its surface brightness at optical and infrared wavelengths is less , causing a dip in the stellar light curve whenever the planet ( partially ) eclipses the star . since the fractional change in brightness is proportional to the fraction of the stellar surface subtended by the planetary disk , photometric measurements directly yield a measure of the planet s size . for small terrestrial planets ,
the effect is simply to occult a fraction of the stellar light ; the atmospheres of larger gaseous planets may also cause absorption features that can be measured during transit with high resolution , very high s / n spectroscopic monitoring .
the duration of a transit is a function of the size of the stellar disk and the size and inclination of the planetary orbit .
together with an accurate stellar typing of the parent star , measurement of the transit duration and period provides an estimate for the radius and inclination of the planet s orbital plane .
since large planets in tight orbits will create the most significant and frequent occultations , these are the easiest to detect .
if hundreds of stars can be monitored with significantly better than 1% photometry , the transit method can be applied from the ground to place statistics on jupiter - mass planets in tight orbits .
space - based missions , which could search for transits continuously and with higher photometric precision , may be capable of detecting earth - mass planets in earth - like environments via the occultation method .
moons or multiple planets may also be detectable , not through their eclipsing effect , but by the periodic change they induce in the timing of successive transits of the primary occulting body .
microlensing occurs when a foreground compact object ( a star , perhaps with orbiting planets ) moves between an observer and a luminous background source ( another star ) .
the gravitational field of the foreground lens alters the path of the light from the background source , creating multiple images with a combined brightness larger than that of the unlensed background source . for stellar or planetary mass lenses ,
the separation of these images is too small to be resolved , but the combined brightness of the images changes with time in a predictable manner as the lensing system moves across the sky with respect to the background source .
hundreds of microlensing events have been detected in the galaxy , a large fraction of which are due to ( unseen ) stellar lenses . in binary lenses with favorable geometric configurations ,
the lensing effect of the two lenses combines in a non - linear way to create detectable and rapid variations in the light curve of the background source star .
modeling of these features yields estimates for the mass ratio and normalized projected orbital radius for the binary lens ; in general , smaller - mass companions produce weaker and shorter deviations .
frequent , high - precision photometric monitoring of microlensing events can thus be used to discover and characterize extreme mass - ratio binaries ( planetary systems ) . with current ground - based technology , microlensing
is particularly suited to the detection of jupiter - mass planets in jupiter - like environments .
planets smaller than neptune will resolve the brightest background sources ( giants ) diluting the planetary signal . for planets above this mass ,
the planetary detection efficiency of microlensing is a weak function of the planet s mass and includes a rather broad range in orbital radii , making it one of the best techniques for a statistical study of the frequency and nature of planetary systems in the galaxy .
microlensing can discover planetary systems at distances of the galactic center and is the only technique that is capable of detecting unseen planets around _ unseen parent stars _ !
these lectures begin with a discussion of the physical basis of occultation and microlensing , emphasizing their strengths and weaknesses as well as the selection effects and challenges presented by sources of confusion for the planetary signal .
the techniques are then placed in the larger context of extra - solar planet detection .
speculative comments about possibilities in the next decade cap the lectures .
due to their small sizes and low effective temperatures , planets are difficult to detect directly . compared to stars , their luminosities are reduced by the square of the ratio of their radii ( factors of @xmath0@xmath1 in the solar system ) and the fourth power of the ratio of their effective temperatures ( factors of @xmath0@xmath2 in the solar system ) .
such planets may be detected indirectly however if they chance to transit ( as viewed by the observer ) the face of their parent star and are large enough to occult a sufficient fraction of the star s flux .
this method of detecting planets around other stars was discussed as early as mid - century ( sturve 1952 ) , but received serious attention only after the detailed quantification of its possibilities by rosenblatt ( 1971 ) and borucki and summers ( 1984 ) .
such occultation effects have been observed for many years in the photometry of binary star systems whose orbital planes lie close enough to edge - on as viewed from earth that the disk of each partner occults the other at some point during the orbit , creating two dips in the combined light curve of the system .
the depth of the observed occultation depends on the relative size and temperatures of the stars . for planetary systems ,
only the dip caused by the occultation of the brighter parent star by the transit of the smaller , cooler planet will be detectable .
the detection rate for a given planetary system will depend on several factors : the geometric probability that a transit will occur , the frequency and duration of the observations compared to the frequency and duration of the transit , and the sensitivity of the photometric measurements compared to the fractional deviation in the apparent magnitude of the parent star due to the planetary occultation .
we consider each of these in turn .
-3.55 cm fig . 1 geometry of a transit event of inclination @xmath3 and orbital radius @xmath4 as seen from the side ( top ) and observer s vantage point ( bottom ) at a moment when the planet lies a projected distance @xmath5 from the stellar center .
0.4 cm unless stated otherwise in special cases below , we will assume for the purposes of discussion that planetary orbits are circular and that the surface brightness , mass , and radius of the planet are small compared to that of the parent star .
we will also assume that the orbital radius is much larger than the size of the parent star itself .
consider a planet of radius @xmath6 orbiting a star of radius @xmath7 and mass @xmath8 at an orbital radius @xmath4 .
a transit of the stellar disk will be seen by an external observer only if the orbital plane is sufficiently inclined with respect to the sky plane ( fig . 1 ) .
in particular , the inclination @xmath3 must satisfy @xmath9 since @xmath10 is simply the projection of the normal vector ( of the orbital plane ) onto the sky plane , it is equally likely to take on any random value between 0 and 1 .
thus , for an ensemble of planetary systems with arbitrary orientation with respect to the observer , the probability that the inclination satisfies the geometric criterion for a transit is : @xmath11 geometrically speaking , the occultation method favors those planets with small orbital radii in systems with large parent stars . as can be seen in fig . 2 , for planetary systems like the solar system this probability is small : @xmath12 for inner terrestrial planets and about a factor of 10 smaller for jovian gas giants .
this means that unless a method can be found to pre - select stars with ecliptic planes oriented perpendicular to the plane of the sky , thousands of random stars must be monitored in order to detect statistically meaningful numbers of planetary transits due to solar systems like our own .
-0.5 cm fig . 2
probability of transits by solar system objects as seen by a random external observer .
0.4 cm under the assumption that the orbital angular momentum vector of a planetary system and the rotational angular momentum vector of the parent star share a common origin and thus a common direction , single stars can be pre - selected for transit monitoring programs on the basis of a measurement of their rotational spin . in this way
, one may hope to increase the chances of viewing the planetary orbits edge - on . through spectroscopy ,
the line - of - sight component of the rotational velocity @xmath13 of a star s atmosphere can be measured .
the period @xmath14 of the rotation can be estimated by measuring the periodic photometric signals caused by sunspots , and the radius @xmath7 of the star can be determined through spectral typing and stellar models .
an estimate for the inclination of the stellar rotation plane to the plane of the sky can then be made : @xmath15 and only those stars with high rotational inclinations selected to be monitored for transits .
how much are the probabilities increased by such pre - selection ?
3 shows the probability of the planetary orbital inclination being larger ( more edge - on ) than a particular value ranging from 89.5 @xmath16 , if the parent star is pre - selected to have a rotational plane with inclination @xmath17 .
-1.5cmfig . 3
increase of geometric transit probability through pre - selection of the inclination angle to be larger than @xmath18 , for example through measurement of the rotational spin of the parent .
0.4 cm in order to produce a detectable transit , most planets will require an orbital inclination @xmath19 from edge - on .
if planetary systems could be pre - selected to have @xmath20 , the geometric transit probability would be increased by a factor of @xmath010 . unfortunately , measurement uncertainties in the quantities required to determine @xmath21 are likely to remove much of the advantage that pre - selection would otherwise afford . since @xmath22 , even small errors in @xmath21 translate into large uncertainties in @xmath23 and thus the probability that a transit will occur .
furthermore , an accurate measurement of @xmath23 does not ensure that @xmath10 for the planetary orbital plane is known .
the planets in our own solar system are misaligned by about 7 with the sun s rotational plane , a result that is similar to that found for binaries orbiting solar - type stars ( hale 1994 ) .
it is thus reasonable to assume that an accurate measurement of @xmath24 will constrain the planetary orbital plane only to within @xmath010 . to enhance probabilities , current ground - based attempts to detect transits
have taken a different tack by concentrating on known eclipsing binary star systems in which the orbital plane of the binary is known to be close to edge - on . assuming that any other companions will have similarly aligned angular momentum vectors ,
it is hoped that such systems will have larger than random chances of producing a transit event .
the precession of orbital plane likely to be present in such systems may actually bring the planet across the face of the star more often than in single star systems ( schneider 1994 ) . on the other hand ,
the evolution and dynamics of single and double star systems is so different that the formation and frequency of their planetary companions is likely to be quite different as well . in particular
, it may be difficult for planets in some binary systems to maintain long - lived circular orbits and thus , perhaps , to become the birth place of life of the sort that has evolved on earth .
given the uncertainties involved , inclination pre - selection in single stars is unlikely to increase geometric transit probabilities by factors larger than 3 5 .
ambitious ground - based and space - based initiatives , however , may monitor so many stars that pre - selection is not necessary . the duration and frequency of the expected transits will determine the observational strategy of an occultation program .
the frequency is simply equal to one over the orbital period @xmath25 .
if two or more transits for a given system can be measured and confirmed to be due to the same planet , the period @xmath26 and orbital radius @xmath4 are determined . in principle
, the ratio of the transit duration to the total duration can then be used to determine the inclination of the orbital plane , if the stellar radius is known .
the duration of the transit will be equal to the fraction of the orbital period @xmath26 during which the projected distance @xmath27 between the centers of the star and planet is less than the sum of their radii @xmath28 . refering to fig .
4 we have @xmath29 which for @xmath30 becomes @xmath31 note that because the definition of a transit requires that @xmath32 , the quantity under the square root in eq .
4 does not become negative .
-2.25 cm -1 cm = 13.5 cm -6.25cmfig .
4 transit duration is set by fraction of total orbit ( left ) for which a portion of the planet eclipses the stellar disk ( right ) .
0.4 cm fig .
5 shows the maximum transit duration and period for planets in the solar system . in order to confirm a planetary detection with one or more additional transits after the discovery of the first eclipse , a 5-year experiment can be sensitive to planets orbiting solar - type stars only if their orbital radius is equal to or smaller than that of mars .
such planets will have transit durations of less than one day , requiring rapid and continuous sampling to ensure high detection probabilities .
the actual transit duration depends sensitively on the inclination of the planetary orbit with respect to the observer , as shown in fig .
the transit time of earth as seen by an external observer changes from 0.5 days to zero ( no transit ) if the observers viewing angle is more than 0.3 from optimal . since the orbital planes of any two of the inner terrestrial planets in the -1.15 cm -0.5 cm -4.6 cm fig .
5 edge - on transit durations and periods for solar system planets .
0.4 cm solar system are misaligned by 1.5 or more , if other planetary systems are like our own , a given observer would expect to see transits from only one of the inner planets .
this would decrease the detection probabilities for planetary systems , but also the decrease the probability of incorrectly attributing transits from different planets to successive transits of one ( mythical ) shorter period object .
-0.5 cm 1.5 cm -0.3cmfig . 6 `` inner planet '' transit durations for different inclinations ( @xmath33 )
. 0.4 cm if the parent star can be typed spectroscopically , stellar models can provide an estimate for the stellar radius @xmath7 in the waveband in which the photometric partial eclipse was measured .
( it is important to match wavebands since limb - darkening can make the star look larger at redder wavelengths which are more sensitive to the cooler outer atmosphere of the star . )
the temporal resolution of a single transit then places a lower limit on the orbital radius @xmath4 of the planet , but a full determination of @xmath4 requires knowledge of the period from multiple transit timings which remove the degeneracy due to the otherwise unknown orbital inclination . in principle , if the limb darkening of the parent star is sufficiently well - understood , measurements in multiple wavebands can allow an estimate for the inclination , and thus for @xmath4 from a single transit ; this is discussed more fully in 2.3.1 .
planets with orbital radii of 2 au or less orbiting stars even as close as 10 parsec will subtend angles @xmath34 microarcseconds ; any reflected or thermal radiation that they might emit thus will be confused by normal photometric techniques with that from the parent star . only exceedingly large and close companions of high albedo would be capable of creating a significant modulated signal throughout their orbit as the viewer sees a different fraction of the starlit side ; we will not consider such planets here .
all other planets will alter the total observed flux only during an actual transit of the stellar face , during which the amplitude and shape of the photometric dip will be determined by the fraction of the stellar light that is occulted as a function of time .
-0.5 cm 2.5 cm -0.5cmfig . 7 the area eclipsed by a planet as it crosses the stellar limb determines the wing shape of the resulting photometric dip .
0.4 cm the maximum fractional change in the observed flux is given by : @xmath35 the shape of the transit dip will depend on the inclination angle , the ratio of the planet to stellar size , and the degree of limb - darkening in the observational band .
begin by considering a star of uniform brightness ( no limb - darkening ) transited by a small planet .
the stellar limb will then describe a nearly straight chord across the planet at any time , and integration over planet - centered axial coordinates ( see fig .
7 ) yields an eclipsing area during ingress and egress of : @xmath36 where @xmath37 , @xmath27 is the projected star - planet separation and @xmath38 is constrained to lie in the region @xmath39 .
the last integral can be done analytically to yield , @xmath40 for larger planets , and to facilitate the introduction of limb - darkened sources , it is more useful to integrate over stellar - centered axial coordinates ; the law of cosines can then be used to show that @xmath41 } \ , dr_*\ ] ] @xmath42 the light curve resulting from the occultation of a uniform brightness source by a planet of arbitrary size , orbital radius and orbital inclination can now be constructed by substituting into eq .
9 the time dependence of the projected planet - star separation , @xmath43 @xmath44 , where @xmath45 .
the _ differential _ light curve is then given by : @xmath46 for spherical stars and planets , the light curve will be symmetric and have a minimum at the closest projected approach of planet to star center , where the fractional decrease in the total brightness will be less than or equal to @xmath47 . for jupiter - sized planets orbiting solar - type stars , this is a signal of @xmath01% ; for earth - sized planets the fractional change is @xmath48 0.01% ( fig .
8) . -4.3 cm 0.2 cm -0.6cmfig . 8 * left : * photometric light curves for earth - sized and jupiter - sized planets orbiting a solar - type star at 1 au .
* right : * a jupiter - sized planet orbiting a solar - type star at an orbital radius of 0.05 au ( 51 peg ) with inclinations ranging from 85 to 90 .
the parent star is assumed here to have constant surface brightness .
note change in time scale between two panels .
0.4 cm if proper care is taken , photometry of bright , uncrowded stars can be performed to @xmath00.1% precision from the ground ( henry 1997 ) , so that ground - based transit searches can in principle be sensitive to jupiter - sized planets at @xmath481 au planets perhaps similar to those being found by the radial velocity technique ( mayor & queloz 1995 , butler & marcy 1996 ) .
transit detections of terrestrial planets like those in our own solar system must await space observations in order to achieve the required photometric precision . because observations at different wavelengths probe material at different depths in stellar atmospheres , a stellar disk is differentially limb - darkened : the radial surface brightness profile @xmath49 of a star is wavelength dependent . in redder bands , which probe the cooler outer regions of the star
, the stellar disk will appear larger and less limb - darkened .
limb darkening is important to transit techniques for two reasons : it changes the shape of the photometric signal and it does so in a wavelength - dependent way .
since a given planet can produce dips of varying strength depending on the inclination @xmath3 of the orbit , the inclination must be known in order to estimate the planet s radius @xmath6 accurately . in principle , if the parent star has been typed so that its mass and stellar radius @xmath7 are known , kepler s law together with eq .
5 will yield @xmath3 once the transit time @xmath50 and period @xmath26 have been measured . ignoring the effects of limb darkening , however , will result in an underestimate of @xmath50 , and thus an underestimate for the inclination @xmath3 as well . in order to produce the required amplitude at minimum , the size of the planet @xmath6
will then be overestimated .
furthermore , the sloping shape of the limb - darkened profile might be attributed to the smaller inclination @xmath3 , reinforcing misinterpretation .
this difficulty will be removed if the limb darkening can be properly modeled .
in addition , transit monitoring in more than one waveband could confirm the occultation hypothesis by measuring the characteristic color signature associated with limb darkening . in principle
this signature can be used to determine the orbital inclination from a single transit , in which case eq .
5 can be inverted to solve for the period @xmath26 without waiting for a second transit .
how strong is the effect of limb darkening ? to incorporate its effect , the integral in eq .
9 used to determine the eclipsing area must be weighted by the surface brightness as a function of stellar radius , yielding the differential light curve : @xmath51 } \ , dr_*}{\pi \int^{^{r_*}}_{_0 } r _ * \ , b_{\lambda}(r _ * ) \ , dr_*}\ ] ] a commonly - used functional form for the surface brightness profile is @xmath52 $ ] , where @xmath53 and @xmath54 is the angle between the normal to the stellar surface and the line - of - sight . in terms of the projected radius @xmath55 from the stellar center
this can be written as @xmath56 $ ] . using this form and constants @xmath57 appropriate for the sun ,
light curves and color curves are shown in fig . 9 for a jupiter - sized planet orbiting 1 au from a solar - type star at inclinations of 90 and 89.8 .
as expected , the bluer band shows more limb darkening , which rounds the sharp edges of the occultation profile making it qualitatively degenerate with a larger planet at somewhat smaller inclination .
the color curves for different inclinations , however , are qualitatively different and can thus be used to break this degeneracy . during ingress and
egress the color curve becomes bluer as the differentially redder limb is occulted ; at maximum occultation the color curve is redder than the unocculted star for transits with inclination @xmath58 since the relative blue central regions are then occulted . for smaller inclinations , the planet grazes the limb blocking preferentially red light only , and the color curve stays blue through the event . since the size of the color signal is @xmath010% of the deviation in total flux , excellent photometry is required to measure this effect and use it to estimate the orbital inclination ; even for jovian giants it remains at or just beyond the current limits of photometric precision .
-0.3 cm -0.4cmfig . 9 * left : * light curves for a planet with @xmath59 orbiting a solar - type star with orbital inclinations of 90 ( top ) and 89.8 ( bottom ) normalized to the total ( unocculted ) flux in the indicated band .
black shows a uniformly bright stellar disk ; blue and red indicate observations in the r and k bands respectively . *
right : * color curves indicating the flux ratios at any given time between r ( blue ) and k - band ( red ) limb - darkened curves and a uniformly bright target star , and the observed limb - darkened @xmath60 flux ratio ( black ) . 0.4 cm in sum , what can be learned by observing a planetary object transiting the face of its parent star ?
the amplitude of the photometric signal places a lower limit on the ratio of the planetary radius to stellar radius @xmath61 , while the duration of the event places a lower limit on the orbital period @xmath26 and thus on the orbital radius @xmath4 as well .
if the inclination @xmath3 is known , these lower limits become measurements . in principle
@xmath3 could be determined by fitting the wings of the transit profile in different wavebands using the known limb - darkening of the star , but in practice this will probably prove too difficult . instead , multiple transits will be required to time the transits and thus measure the period @xmath26 of the planet , from which the inclination can be determined from the known transit duration ( eq .
this makes the transit method most appropriate for large planets orbiting their parent stars at ( relatively ) small radii @xmath4 .
the primary challenge then reduces to performing the very precise photometry required on a large enough sample of stars to place meaningful statistics on the numbers of planets at small @xmath4 . what limits the photometric accuracy and clear detection of a transit signal ?
the dwarf stars that have suitably small stellar radii @xmath7 must have apparent magnitudes bright enough ( ie , be close enough ) that enough photons can be captured in short exposures so that a sub - day transit event can be well - sampled .
this will limit the depth of the sample to only nearby stars .
fields with very high stellar densities ( like globular clusters or the galactic center ) or very wide fields that can capture hundreds of candidate stars simultaneously will be required in order to maintain the required temporal sampling on a large enough sample .
regions of high stellar density , however , will be hampered by the additional challenges associated with precision photometry in confused fields .
the use of reference constant stars in the field can reduce the effects of varying extinction to produce the best current photometry in uncrowded fields , precise to the @xmath00.1% level .
ultimately , scintillation , the rapidly - varying turbulent refocusing of rays passing through the atmosphere , limits earth - bound photometry to 0.01% .
detection of earth - mass transits is thus probably restricted to space - borne missions , although in special circumstances , periodicity analyses may be used to search for very short - period earth - sized transits from the ground ( henry 1997 ) . for larger , jovian gas - giants
, the signal can be measured from the ground , but must be distinguished from intrinsic effects that could be confused with transits .
late - type dwarf stars often undergo pulsations that cause their brightness to vary on the order of a few hours , but due to their cyclic nature these pulsations should be distinguished easily from all but very short period transits corresponding to @xmath62 au or so .
solar flares produce excess of flux at the @xmath63% level , and thus would not confuse a typical transit signal .
later - type dwarfs tend to have more surface activity , however , and thus produce flares that contain a larger fraction of the star s total flux
. since the flares are generally blue , the primary problem will be in confusing the chromatic signal expected due to limb - darkening effects during a transit .
more troublesome will be separating transits from irregular stellar variability due to star spots .
star spots are cool regions on the stellar surface that remain for a few rotations before disappearing .
they could mock a transit event and thus are probably the most important non - instrumental source of noise .
although the power spectrum of the solar flux does show variations on day and sub - day time scales , most of the power during periods of sunspot maximum occurs at the approximate 1-month time scale of the sun s rotation . even during sunspot maximum
, variations on day and sub - day scales are at or below the @xmath64 level ( borucki , scargle & hudson 1985 ) .
star spots on solar - type stars will therefore not be confused with the transit signal of a gas giant , but spots might be a source of additional noise for terrestrial - sized planets of small orbital radius ( @xmath65au ) and for parent stars that are significantly more spotted than the sun .
if the parent star can be well - characterized , the transit method involves quite simple physical principles that can perhaps be exploited further to learn more about planetary systems .
for example , if a system is discovered to contain large transiting inner planets , it can be assumed to have a favorable inclination angle that would make it a good target for more sensitive searches for smaller radius or larger @xmath4 planets in the same system .
if the inner giants are large enough , differential spectroscopy with a very large telescope before and during transits could reveal additional spectral lines that could be attributed to absorption of stellar light by the atmosphere of the giant ( presumably gaseous ) planet ( see laurent & schneider , this proceedings ) .
a large occulting ring inclined to the observer s line - of - sight would create a transit profile of a different shape than that of a planet ( schneider 1997 ) , though the signal could be confused with limb - darkening effects and would likely be important only for outer gas giants where icy rings can form more easily .
finally , variations in the ingress timing of inner planets can be used to search for cyclic variations that could betray the presence of moons ( schneider 1997 ) or in principle massive ( inner or outer ) planets that are nearly coplanar but too misaligned to cause a detectable transit themselves .
transit timing shifts would be caused by the slight orbital motion of the planet around the planet - moon barycenter or that of the star around the system barycenter .
( the latter is unobservable for a single - planet system since the star s motion is always phase - locked with the planet . )
microlensing occurs when a foreground compact object ( a star ) moves between an observer and a luminous background object ( another star ) .
the gravitational field of the foreground lens alters the path of the light from the background source , bending it more severely the closer the ray passes to the lens .
this results in an image as seen by a distant observer that is altered both in position and shape from that of the unlensed source . indeed since light from either side of a lens
can now be bent to reach the observer , multiple images are possible ( fig .
since the total flux reaching the observer from these two images is larger than that from the unlensed source alone , the lens ( and any planets that may encircle it ) betrays its presence not through its own luminous emission , but by its gravitational magnification of the flux of background objects .
einstein ( 1936 ) recognized microlensing in principle , but thought that it was undetectable in practice .
-0.5 cm -1.5 cm = 9.75 cm -10.5 cm 4.75 cm -2.5cmfig . 10 * left : * a compact lens ( l ) located a distance @xmath66 nearly along the line - of - sight to a background source ( s ) located at a distance @xmath67 will bend incoming light rays by differing amounts @xmath68 to create two images ( @xmath69 and @xmath70 ) on either side of the line - of - sight . *
right : * an observer @xmath71 does not see the microlensed source at its true angular sky position @xmath72 , but rather two images at positions @xmath73 and @xmath74 .
0.4 cm ray tracing , together with the use of general relatively to relate the bending angle @xmath68 with the lens mass distribution , produces a mapping from the source positions ( @xmath75 , @xmath76 ) to the image positions ( x , y ) for a given mass distribution . for `` point '' masses , the angle @xmath68 is just given by the mass of the lens @xmath77 and the distance of closest approach @xmath78 as : @xmath79 as long as @xmath78 is well outside the schwarzschild radius @xmath80 of the lens .
simple geometry alone then requires @xmath81 which can be rewritten to yield the lens equation @xmath82 giving the ( angular ) vector image positions @xmath83 for a source at the angular position @xmath72 as measured from the observer - lens line - of - sight .
@xmath67 and @xmath66 are the source and lens distances from the observer , respectively , and @xmath84 . for convenience ,
the characteristic angular size scale is defined as @xmath85 since @xmath86 , eq .
15 can now be rewritten to yield a quadratic equation in @xmath87 @xmath88 with two solutions @xmath89 giving the positions of images @xmath69 and @xmath70 .
when the source lies directly behind the lens as seen from the observer , @xmath90 and the two images merge into a ring of radius @xmath91 , the so - called `` einstein ring . '' for all other source positions , one image will lie inside @xmath91 and one outside .
the flux observed from each image is the integral of the image surface brightness over the solid angle subtended by the ( distorted ) image . since the specific intensity of each ray is unchanged in the bending process , so is the surface brightness .
the magnification @xmath92 for each image is then just the ratio of the image area to the source area , and is found formally by evaluating at the image positions the determinant of the jacobian mapping @xmath93 that describes the lensing coordinate transformation from image to source plane : @xmath94 where @xmath72 and @xmath87 are ( angular ) position vectors for the source and image , respectively .
what is most important for detection of extra - solar planets around lenses is not the position of the images but their magnification . for stellar lenses and typical source and lens distances within the milky way , the typical image separation ( @xmath95 ) is @xmath01 milliarcsecond , too small to be resolved with current optical telescopes .
the observer sees one image with a combined magnification @xmath96 that can be quite large . in order to distinguish intrinsically bright background sources from fainter ones that appear bright due to microlensing ,
the observer relies on the characteristic brightening and dimming that occurs as motions within the galaxy sweep the source ( nearly ) behind the lens - observer line - of - sight .
the unresolved images also sweep across the sky ( fig .
11 ) ; their combined brightness reaches its maximum when the source has its closest projected distance to the lens .
-1.75 cm -1.75cmfig . 11
as a background source ( open circle ) moves nearly behind a foreground lens ( central dot ) , the two microimages remain at every moment colinear with the lens and source .
( adapted from paczyski 1996 . )
0.4 cm for a single lens , the combined magnification can be shown from eqs .
17 and 18 to be : @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the angular source - lens separation in units of the einstein ring radius . for rectilinear motion , @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the time at which @xmath101 is minimum and the magnification is maximum , and @xmath102 is the characteristic time scale defined as the time required for the lens to travel a projected distance across the observer - source sightline equal to the einstein radius @xmath103 .
the result is a symmetric light curve that has a magnification of 1.34 as it cross the einstein ring radius and a peak amplification that is approximately inversely proportional to the source impact parameter @xmath104 .
since the @xmath104 are distributed randomly , all of the light curves shown in fig .
12 are equally probable .
-0.3 cm -2.25 cm = 10.5 cm -10 cm 4.5 cm -3cmfig . 12 * left : * equally - probable source trajectories . *
right : * the corresponding single microlens light curves .
0.4 cm typical event durations @xmath105 for microlensing events detected in the direction of the galactic bulge are on the order of a few weeks to a few months , generally matching expectations for stellar lenses distributed in the galactic disk and bulge .
microlensing was proposed as a method to detect compact baryonic dark matter in the milky way by paczyski in 1986 . in 1991 ,
mao and paczyski suggested that not only dark lenses , but possible dark planets orbiting them may be detected through their microlensing influence on background stars .
the magnification patterns of a single lens are axially symmetric and centered on the lens ; the einstein ring radius , for example , describes the position of the @xmath106 magnification contour .
binary lens structure destroys this symmetry : the magnification patterns become distorted and are symmetric only upon reflection about the binary axis . positions in the source place
for which the determinant of the jacobian ( eq . 18 ) is zero represent potential source positions for which the magnification is formally infinite .
the locus of these positions is called a `` caustic . '' for a single point - lens , the only such position is the point caustic at @xmath90 , but the caustics of binary lenses are extended and complicated in shape . in the lens plane , the condition @xmath107 defines a locus of points known as the critical curve ; when the source crosses a caustic a pair of new images of high amplification appear with image positions @xmath108 on the critical curve .
a static lens configuration has a fixed magnification pattern relative to the lens ; the observed light curve is one - dimensional cut through this pattern that depends on the source path . as fig .
13 illustrates , the exact path of the source trajectory behind a binary lens will determine how much its light curve deviates from the simple symmetric form characterizing a single lens . due to the finite size of the source , the magnification during a caustic crossing is not infinite , but will be quite large for sources that are small compared to the size of the caustic structure .
several binary - lens light curves have already been observed and characterized ( udalski 1994 , alard , mao & guibert 1995 , alcock 1997 , albrow 1998b , albrow 1999 ) .
-1 cm -1.25 cm -8.25 cm 5.25 cm -0.5cmfig . 13 * left : * the caustic ( thick closed line ) for two equal mass lenses ( dots ) is shown with several possible source trajectories .
angular distances are scaled to the einstein ring radius of the combined lens mass . *
right : * the light curves resulting from the source trajectories shown at left ; the temporal axis is normalized to the einstein time @xmath109 for the combined lens .
( adapted from paczyski 1996 . )
0.4 cm a single lens light curve is described by four parameters : the einstein crossing time @xmath109 , the impact parameter @xmath104 , the time of maximum amplification @xmath100 , and the unlensed flux of the source @xmath110 .
only the first of these contains information about the lens itself .
three additional parameters are introduced for binary lenses : the projected separation @xmath111 of the lenses in units of @xmath91 , the mass ratio @xmath112 of the two lenses , and the angle @xmath113 that the source trajectory makes with respect to the binary axis . given the large number of free parameters and the variety of complicated forms that binary light curves can exhibit , it may seem quite difficult to characterize the binary lens with any degree of certainty on the basis of a single 1-d cut through its magnification pattern .
in fact , with good data the fitting procedure is unique enough that the _ future _ behavior of the complicated light curve including the timing of future caustic crossings can be predicted in real time .
this is important since the ability to characterize extra - solar planets via microlensing requires proper determination of the planetary system parameters @xmath111 and @xmath112 through modeling of light curve anomalies .
the simplest planetary system is a binary consisting of a stellar lens of mass @xmath8 orbited by a planet of mass @xmath114 at an orbital separation @xmath4 .
the parameter range of interest is therefore @xmath115 for jovian - mass planets and @xmath116 for terrestrial - mass planets .
the normalized projected angular separation @xmath117 depends at any moment on the inclination and phase of the planetary orbit .
the light curve of a source passing behind a lensing planetary system will depend on the form of the magnification pattern of the lensing system , which is influenced by the size and position of the caustics .
how do the magnification patterns vary with @xmath111 and @xmath112 ? -1.5 cm -4.25cmfig . 14
positive ( magenta ) and negative ( blue ) 1% and 5% _ excess _ magnification contours for binary lenses ( black dots ) of different projected separations @xmath111 and mass ratios @xmath112 .
caustics are shown in red .
dimensions are normalized to the einstein ring radius of combined system ( green circle ) . dashed and solid lines are two possible source trajectories .
( adapted from gaudi & sackett 1998 . )
0.4 cm shown in fig .
14 is the _ excess _ magnification pattern of a binary over that of a single lens for different separations @xmath111 and mass ratios @xmath112 .
the deviations can be positive or negative .
high - mass ratio binaries ( @xmath112 not too much less than 1 ) are easier to detect since their excess magnification contours cover a larger sky area making it more likely that a source trajectory will cross an `` anomalous '' region . for a given mass ratio @xmath112 ,
the 1% and 5% excess magnification contours also cover more sky when the binary separation is comparable to the einstein ring radius of the system , whenever @xmath118 .
the symmetric caustic structure centered between equal mass ( @xmath119 ) binaries becomes elongated along the binary axis for smaller mass ratios , eventually splitting the caustic into a central caustic centered on the primary lens and outer `` planetary '' caustics . for planetary separations larger than the einstein ring radius @xmath120 ,
the planetary caustic is situated on the binary axis between the lens and planet .
for @xmath121 , the planetary caustics are two `` tips '' that are symmetrically positioned above and below the binary axis on the opposite side of the lens from the planet .
as the mass ratio decreases , all the caustics shrink in size and the two `` tips '' approach the binary axis , nearly but not quite merging . for the planetary ( small @xmath112 ) regime , a source that crosses the central caustic will generate new images near the einstein ring of the primary lens ; a source crossing a planetary caustic will generate new images near the einstein ring of the planet , near the position of the planet itself .
planets with separations @xmath122 create planetary caustics inside the einstein ring radius of the parent lensing star ; this is the region in which the source must be in order to be alerted by the microlensing survey teams . for this reason
, planets with projected separations @xmath122 are said to lie in the _ `` lensing zone . ''
_ since the separation @xmath111 is normalized to the size of the einstein ring , the physical size of the lensing zone will depend on the lens mass and on the lens and source distances .
most of the microlensing events in the milky way are detected in the direction of the galactic bulge where , at least for the bright red clump sources , it is reasonable to assume that the sources lie at @xmath123kpc .
table i shows the size of the lensing zone for foreground lenses located in the disk ( @xmath124kpc ) and bulge ( @xmath125kpc ) for typical stellar masses , assuming that @xmath126kpc .
one of the reasons that microlensing is such an attractive method to search for extra - solar planets is that the typical lensing zone corresponds to projected separations of a few times the earth - sun distance ( au ) a good match to many planets in the solar system .
planets orbiting at a radius @xmath4 in a plane inclined by @xmath3 with respect to the plane of the sky will traverse a range of projected separations @xmath127 , and can thus be brought into the lensing zone of their primary even if their orbital radius is larger than the values given in table i. l r r + & disk lens ( 4 kpc ) & bulge lens ( 6 kpc ) + 1.0 @xmath128 solar - type & 2.4 - 6.4 au & 2.1 - 5.5 au + 0.3 @xmath128 dwarf & 1.3 - 3.5 au & 1.1 - 3.0 au + 0.25 cm planets that are seldom or never brought into the lensing zone of their primary can still be detected by microlensing in one of two ways . either the light curve must be monitored for source positions outside the einstein ring radius of the primary ( for magnifications @xmath129 ) in order to have sensitivity to the isolated , outer planetary caustics ( distefano & scalzo 1999 ) , or very high amplification events must be monitored in order to sense the deviations that are caused any planet on the central primary caustic ( griest & safizadeh 1998 ) .
the generation of caustic structure and the anomalous magnification pattern associated with it makes planetary masses orbiting stellar lenses easier to detect than isolated lensing planets .
even so , most planetary light curves will be anomalous because the source passed near , but not across a caustic ( fig .
how is the projected planet - star separation @xmath111 and the planet - star + -4.25 cm -1 cm -3.75cmfig . 15
* left : * a background point source travels along the ( blue ) trajectory that just misses the ( red ) caustic structure caused by a `` jupiter '' with mass ratio @xmath130 located at 1.3 einstein ring radii ( several au ) from its parent stellar lens .
* right : * the resulting light curve is shown in the top panel ; the excess magnification @xmath131 associated with the planetary anomaly is shown in the bottom panel ; time scale is in days .
mass ratio @xmath132 extracted from a planetary anomaly atop an otherwise normal microlensing light curve ?
in practice , the morphology of planetary light curve anomalies is quite complex , and detailed modeling of the excess magnification pattern ( the anomalous change in the pattern due to the planet ) is required , but the general principles can be easily understood .
-1.5 cm -4.5cmfig . 16
excess magnifications @xmath131 for the ( solid and dotted ) trajectories of fig .
14 are shown for ( the same ) range of planetary mass ratios and projected separations .
`` super - jupiters '' with @xmath133 should create detectable anomalies for a significant fraction of source trajectories in high quality light curves .
( adapted from gaudi & sackett 1998 . )
0.4 cm since the planet and parent star lenses are at the same distance @xmath66 and travel across the line of sight with the same velocity @xmath134 ( ignoring the planet s orbital motion ) , eq .
16 shows that the mass ratio @xmath112 is equal to the square of the ratio of the einstein ring radii @xmath135 .
observationally this can be estimated very roughly by the square of the ratio of the planetary anomaly duration to the primary event duration , @xmath136 .
the time difference between the primary and anomalous peaks ( normalized to the einstein time ) gives an indication of the placement of the caustic structure within the einstein ring and thus the position of the planet relative to the primary lens , @xmath111 .
the amplitude of the anomaly @xmath137 , where @xmath138 is the unperturbed amplitude , indicates the closest approach to the caustic structure and , together with the temporal placement of the anomaly , yields the source trajectory angle through the magnification pattern .
since the magnification pattern associated with planetary caustics for @xmath120 and @xmath121 planets is qualitatively different , detailed dense monitoring should resolve any ambiguity in the planetary position .
light curve anomalies associated with @xmath120 planets , like the one in fig .
15 , will have relatively large central peaks in @xmath131 surrounded by shallow valleys ; @xmath121 anomalies will generally have more rapidly varying alterations of positive and negative excess magnification , though individual exceptions can certainly be found . from the shape of light curve anomalies alone ,
the mass of the planet is determined as a fraction of the primary lens mass ; its instantaneous projected separation is determined as a fraction of the primary einstein radius .
reasonable assumptions about the kinematics , distribution , and masses of the primary stellar lenses , together with measurements of the primary event duration @xmath139 and fraction of blended light from the lens should allow @xmath103 and @xmath8 to be determined to within a factor @xmath140 .
detailed measurements of the planetary anomaly would then yield the absolute projected separation and planetary mass to about the same precision .
it is clear from figs .
14 and 16 that , depending on the source trajectory , a range of anomaly durations @xmath141 and amplitudes @xmath131 are possible for a planetary system of given @xmath112 and @xmath111 ( see also wambsganss 1977 ) .
nevertheless , rough scaling relations can be developed to estimate the time scales and amplitudes that will determine the photometric sampling rate and precision required for reasonable detection efficiencies to microlensing planetary systems . for small mass ratios @xmath112
, the region of excess magnification associated with the planetary caustic is a long , roughly linear region with a width approximately equal to the einstein ring of the planet , @xmath142 , and a length along the planet - lens axis several times larger . since @xmath143 , both the time scale of the duration and the cross section presented to a ( small ) source vary linearly with @xmath144 and thus with @xmath145 . assuming a typical @xmath146 days ,
the duration of the planetary anomaly is given roughly by the time to cross the planetary einstein diameter , @xmath147 , @xmath148 caustic crossings can occur for any planetary mass ratio and should be easy to detect as long as the temporal sampling is well matched to the time scales above .
most anomalies , however , will be more gentle perturbations associated with crossing lower amplitude excess magnification contours . at the most favorable projected lens - planet separation of @xmath149 , and the most ideal lens location ( halfway to the galactic center ) , well - sampled observations able to detect 5% perturbations in the light curve would have planet sensitivities given roughly by ( gould & loeb 1992 ) : @xmath150 this ideal sensitivity is relevant only for planets at @xmath149 ; at the edges of the lensing zone the probabilities are about halved .
detection with this sensitivity requires photometry at the 1% level , well - sampled over the duration of the planetary event .
-0.5 cm 0.25 cm = 11.5 cm -1cmfig .
17 planet collaboration monitoring of macho - blg-95 - 13 in the i ( upper ) and v ( lower ) bands .
insets show a zoom around the peak of the event ; arrows indicate points taken many months to more than a year later .
vertical scale is magnitudes ; horizontal scale is days ( albrow 1998a ) .
0.4 cm can such photometric precision and temporal sampling be obtained in the crowded fields of the galactic bulge where nearly all microlensing events are discovered ?
17 shows observations of one bright microlensing event monitored by the planet collaboration during its month - long pilot season in 1995 ( albrow 1998a ) .
the residuals from the single point - lens / point source light curve are less than 1% for this event , and the typical sampling rate is on the order of once every 1 - 2 hours , even accounting for unavoidable longitudinal and weather gaps .
a true calculation of detection probabilities must integrate over the projected orbital separations and the distribution of lenses along the line of sight , must take into account the actual distribution of source trajectories probed by a particular set of observations , and the effect of uneven temporal sampling and photometric precision ( gaudi & sackett 1998 ) . in the following section we discuss the additional complication of finite source effects that is encountered for very small mass planets for which the size of the planetary einstein ring is comparable to or smaller than the source size , @xmath151 . what can be learned by observing a planetary anomaly in a microlensing light curve ?
the duration , temporal placement relative to the event peak , and relative amplitude of the anomaly can be used to determine the mass ratio @xmath112 of the planetary companion to the primary ( presumably stellar ) lens and their projected angular separation @xmath111 in units of the einstein ring radius @xmath91 . since in general
the lens will be far too distant to type spectrally against the bright background source ( except possibly with very large apertures , see mao , reetz & lennon 1998 ) , the absolute mass and separation must be determined statistically by fitting the properties of an ensemble of events with reasonable galactic assumptions .
measurements of other sorts of microlensing anomalies associated with source resolution , observer motion , or lens blending can produce additional constraints on the lens properties and thus on the absolute planetary characteristics . except for very large @xmath4 planets orbiting in nearly face - on ( @xmath152 ) orbits , cooperative lensing effects between the lens and companion boost the detectability of lensing planets over that expected for planets in isolation . since current detection and monitoring schemes focus on those events with an essentially random distribution of impact parameters @xmath104 for @xmath153 , the anomaly sensitivity is primarily restricted to planets in the `` lensing zone '' with projected separations of 0.6 1.6 times the einstein ring radii of the primary lens .
for typical distributions of lens masses , and lens and source distances , this translates into the highest probabilities for planets with instantaneous orbital separations _ projected onto the sky plane _ of @xmath154au , with a zone of reduced detectability extending to higher @xmath155 . since the efficiency of planetary detection in these zones is likely to be a few or a few tens of percent ( eq . 21 ) ,
many microlensing events must be monitored with @xmath01% photometry on the @xmath0hourly time scales ( eq . 20 ) to achieve statistically meaningful constraints on the number planets in the milky way , and their distribution in mass and orbital radius . what limits the photometric precision and temporal sampling ?
round - the - clock monitoring of events , necessary for maximum sensitivity to the 1 2 day durations of jupiter - mass anomalies requires telescopes scattered in geographical longitude , at the south pole , or in space .
temporal sampling is limited by the number of events monitored at any given time , their brightness , and the desired level of photometric precision .
higher signal - to - noise can generally be obtained for brighter stars in less exposure time , but ultimately , in the crowded fields that typify any microlensing experiment , photometric precision is limited by confusion from neighboring sources , not photon statistics . pushing below @xmath01% relative photometry with current techniques
has proven very difficult in crowded fields .
if an anomaly is detected , it must be distinguished from other intrinsic effects that could be confused with a lensing planet .
stellar pulsation on daily to sub - daily time scales in giant and sub - giant bulge stars is unlikely , but this and any form of regular variability would easily be recognized as periodic ( non - microlensing ) with the dense and precise sampling that is required in microlensing monitoring designed to detect planets .
star - spot activity may be non - negligible in giants , but will have a time scale characteristic of the rotation period of giants , and thus much longer than typical planetary anomalies .
in faint dwarf stars spotting activity produces flux changes below the photometric precision of current experiments .
flare activity should not be significant for giants and is expected to be chromatic , whereas the microlensing signal will always be achromatic ( except in the case of source resolution by exceedingly low - mass planets ) .
blending ( complete photometric confusion ) by random , unrelated stars along the line - of - sight can dilute the apparent amplitude of the primary lensing event .
this will have some effect on the detection efficiencies , but most significantly with data of insufficient sampling and photometric precision will lead to underestimates for the time scale @xmath109 and impact parameter @xmath104 of the primary event , and thus also to mis - estimates of the planetary mass ratio @xmath112 and projected separation @xmath111
. planets with very small mass ratio will have caustic structure smaller than the angular size of typical bulge giants .
the ensuing dilution of the anomaly by finite source effects will present a large , but perhaps not insurmountable , challenge to pushing the microlensing planet detection technique into the regime of terrestrial - mass planets ( peale 1997 , sackett 1997 ) . near small - mass planetary caustics ,
different parts of the source simultaneously cross regions of significantly different excess magnification ; an integration over source area is required in order to derive the total magnification .
the severity of the effect can be seen in fig .
earth - mass caustic crossings against even the smaller - radii bulge sources will present a challenge to current photometry in crowded fields , which is generally limited by seeing to stars above the turn - off mass .
the most numerous , bright microlensing sources in the bulge are clump giants with radii about 13 times that of the sun ( 13 @xmath156 ) , and thus angular radii of 7.6 microarcseconds ( @xmath157as ) at 8 kpc .
since a jupiter - mass planet with @xmath158 has an angular einstein ring radius of 32 @xmath157as at 4 kpc and 19 @xmath157as at 6 kpc , its caustic structure is large compared to the size of the source .
an earth - mass planet with @xmath159 , on the other hand , has an angular einstein ring radius of 1.7 @xmath157as at 4 kpc and 1 @xmath157as at 6 kpc , and will thus suffer slight finite source effects even against turn - off stars ( 1.7 @xmath157as ) , though the effect will be greatly reduced compared to giant sources ( bennett & rhie 1996 ) .
-0.75 cm -0.75 cm = 7.5 cm -7.5 cm 5.5 cm = 7.5 cm -0.75cmfig .
18 * left : * a source of angular size @xmath160 , typical of turn - off stars in the bulge , crosses the central caustic caused by a terrestrial - mass planet with mass ratio @xmath161 . _
right : _ due to source resolution effects , the resulting anomaly differs from single - lens microlensing only at the @xmath01%
note the expanded spatial and temporal scales .
( adapted from paczyski 1996 . )
0.4 cm for extreme source resolution , in which the entire planetary caustic lies inside the projected source radius , the _ excess fractional _ magnification associated with the planetary anomaly scales with the square of the ratio of the planetary einstein ring radius to the angular source size , @xmath162 . on the other hand , source - resolved small @xmath112 anomalies will have longer durations than implied by eq . 20 , since the characteristic time scale is the time to cross the source @xmath163 ( not @xmath142 ) .
furthermore , the cross section for magnification at a given threshold now roughly scales with @xmath164 ( not @xmath144 ) , and is thus approximately independent of planetary mass .
because the anomaly amplitude is suppressed by source resolution , unless the photometry is excellent and continuous , small - mass planetary caustic crossings can be confused with large impact parameter large - mass planetary anomalies .
this degeneracy can be removed by performing multi - band observations ( gaudi & gould 1997 ) : large impact parameter events will be achromatic , but sources resolved by small - mass caustics will have a chromatic signal due to source limb - darkening that is similar to ( but of opposite sign from ) that expected for planetary transits ( 2.3.1 ) .
source limb - darkening and chromaticity have now been observed during a caustic crossing of a stellar binary ( albrow 1998b ) .
-0.5 cm 1.5 cm = 9.5 cm -1.0cmfig . 19 * top : * probability that two planets with true orbital radii @xmath165 and @xmath166 ( in units of the einstein ring @xmath103 ) simultaneously have projected separations , @xmath167 and @xmath168 , in the standard `` lensing zone , '' defined as @xmath169 .
the probability is shown as function of @xmath166 , for fixed @xmath170 ( solid ) , @xmath171 ( dotted ) and @xmath172 ( dashed ) .
the probability for two planets with orbital radii of jupiter and saturn around solar - mass primary ( star ) and a @xmath173 primary ( dot ) are shown . *
middle : * same , but for the extended `` lensing zone , '' @xmath174 .
* bottom : * the conditional probability that both @xmath167 and @xmath168 lie in the extended `` lensing zone , '' given that either @xmath167 or @xmath168 satisfies this criterion .
( gaudi , naber & sackett 1998 . ) 0.3 cm finally , since all planetary lenses create a central caustic , low - impact parameter ( high magnification ) microlensing events that project the source close to the central caustic are especially efficient in producing detectable planetary anomalies ( griest & safizadeh 1998 ) . for the same reason , however , the central caustic is affected by _ all _ planets in the system , and so if possible degeneracies due to the increased caustic complexity can be removed rare , low impact parameter events offer a promising way of simultaneously detecting multiple planets brought into or near the lensing zone by their orbital motion around the primary lens ( gaudi , naber & sackett 1998 ) . as fig .
19 demonstrates , the statistical probabilities are large that a jupiter or 47uma orbiting a solar - mass star ( solid and dotted lines , respectively ) will instantaneously share the lensing zone with other planets of orbital radii of several au
. however , the light curves resulting from crossing a multiple - planet central caustic may be difficult to interpret since the caustic structure is so complicated ( fig .
-0.1 cm 0.5 cm = 9.5 cm -0.25cmfig .
20 contours of 5% and 20% fractional deviation @xmath131 , as a function of source position in units of the @xmath91 .
the parameters of planet 1 are held fixed at @xmath175 , @xmath176 ; the projected separation @xmath168 and the angle between the axes , @xmath177 , are varied for a second planet with @xmath178 .
only planet 1 is present in the bottom offset panel .
positive ( red ) , negative ( blue ) and caustic ( @xmath179 , thick line ) contours are shown .
( gaudi , naber & sackett 1998 . )
both the transit and microlensing techniques use frequent , high - precision monitoring of many stars to discover the presence of the unseen extra - solar planets .
the transit method monitors the light from the parent star in search of occultation by an unseen planet ; the microlensing technique monitors light from an unrelated background source in search of lensing by an unseen planet orbiting an unseen parent star .
indeed , microlensing is the only extra - solar planetary search technique that requires _ no photons from either the planet or the parent star _ and for this reason is the method most sensitive to the distant planetary systems in our galaxy .
the two techniques are complementary , both in terms of the information that they provide about discovered systems , and in terms of the range of planetary system parameters to which they are most sensitive .
multiple transit measurements of the same planet will yield its planetary radius @xmath6 and orbital radius @xmath4 .
characterization of a microlensing planetary anomaly gives the mass ratio @xmath181 of the planet to lensing star and their projected separation @xmath111 at the time of the anomaly in units of @xmath91 .
-0cmfig . 21 current detection thresholds for long - running programs that rely on planet orbital motion , shown as a function of planetary mass ratio and orbital radius .
the occultation threshold must be multiplied by the appropriate geometric probability of a transit to derive detection efficiencies . selected solar system planets
are shown .
0.4 cm current ground - based photometry is sensitive to jovian - size occultations ; space - based missions may extend this into the terrestrial regime .
the transit method is sensitive to planets with small @xmath4 because they create a detectable transit over a wider range of inclinations of their orbital planes , and because they transit more often within a typical 5-year experiment .
these constraints limit the range of orbital radii to about @xmath182au for jovian - size planets .
if improvements in photometric precision would allow the detection of earth - size planetary transits , this range would still be possible , but would suffer from noise due to star spot activity on time scales that could be confused with transits by small - mass planets with @xmath183 . since the planets in own solar system fall roughly on the same log@xmath184-log@xmath185 relationship
, it is reasonable to assume that jovian - size planets may also have jovian masses .
this assumption was used to place the current transit detection capability on the same plot ( fig .
21 ) with the current detection thresholds for radial velocity and astrometric techniques .
all three of these techniques require long - term projects to detect long - period ( large @xmath4 ) planets since the measurements of velocity , position , or flux must be collected over at least one full orbital period .
the occultation threshold must be convolved with the geometric transit probability to derive efficiencies _ per observed star_. photometric precision in crowded fields together with source resolution effects limit current microlensing planet searches to neptune masses and above .
the actual efficiency with which a given planetary system can be detected depends on its mass ratio and projected orbital separation . fig .
22 shows estimates of microlensing detection efficiency contours for planets of a given mass ratio and true orbital separation ( in units of the einstein radius ) .
the contours are based on the work of gaudi & gould ( 1997 ) for high - mass ratios , gould & loeb ( 1992 ) and gaudi & sackett ( 1998 ) for intermediate mass ratios , and bennett & rhie ( 1996 ) for small ratios .
integrations have been performed over the unknown but presumably randomly oriented inclinations and orbital phases .
although planets with @xmath4 in the lensing zone and orbiting in the sky plane are the easiest to detect , a tail of sensitivity extends to larger @xmath4 as well because inclination effects will bring large-@xmath4 planets into the projected lensing zone for some phases of their orbits .
the efficiencies assume @xmath1861% photometry well - sampled over the post - alert part of the microlensing light curve .
examination of fig .
22 makes it clear that different indirect planetary search techniques will are sensitive to different portions of the log@xmath184-log@xmath187 domain .
current ground - based capabilities favor the radial velocity method for short - period ( @xmath188 au ) planets ( see also queloz , this proceedings ) .
the occultation method will help populate the short - period part of the diagram , and if the programs are carried into space , will begin to probe the regime of terrestrial - sized planets in terrestrial environments .
ground - based astrometry is favored for very long - period ( @xmath189 au ) planets , although the time scales for detection and confirmation are then on the order of decades .
space - based astrometry promises to make this method substantially more efficient , perhaps by a factor of 100 ( see also colavita , this proceedings ) .
microlensing is the only technique capable of detecting in the near term substantial numbers of intermediate - period ( @xmath190 au ) planets .
somewhat longer period planets may also be discovered by microlensing survey projects as independent `` repeating '' events in which the primary lens and distant planet act as independent lenses ( distefano & scalzo 1999 ) . very short - period planets interior to 0.1 au may be detectable using the light echo technique ( bromley 1992 , seager & sasselov 1998 , charbonneau , jhu & noyes 1998 ) , at least for parent stars with substantial flare activity , such as late m dwarfs .
0.25cmfig . 22
estimated detection efficiency contours for microlensing planet searches as a function of the logarithm of the planetary mass ratio @xmath181 and the true orbital separation @xmath4 in units of the einstein ring radius .
efficiencies have been integrated over the phase and inclination of the orbits , under the assumption that they are circular . to make comparisons with other techniques ,
the einstein ring radius is taken to be 3.5 au .
solid lines indicate what can be achieved in an observational program of 5-years duration or less .
note that the vertical scale remains logarithmic , but the horizontal scale is now linear .
0.4 cm the techniques are complementary in another sense as well .
those that rely on light from the parent star will be limited to nearby planetary systems , but will benefit from the ability to do later follow - up studies , including spectroscopy and interferometry . microlensing , on the other hand , will see the evidence of a given planetary system only once , but can probe planetary frequency in distant parts of the milky way , and can collect statistics over a wide range of orbital separations in a relatively short time
. 0.25 cm l c c + & occultation & microlensing + parameters determined & @xmath6 , @xmath4 , @xmath3 & @xmath181 , + & & @xmath191 + photometric precision of & 0.1% & 1% + limits @xmath6 or @xmath114 to & neptune & neptune + orbital radius sensitivity & @xmath192au & @xmath193au + typical distance of systems & @xmath194kpc & @xmath195kpc + number of stars to be monitored & few @xmath196 & few @xmath197 + for meaningful jovian sensitivity at & @xmath481 au & @xmath05 au + & & + _ in principle possible to detect : _ & & + multiple planets & yes & yes + planets around binary parent stars & yes & yes + earth - mass planets in future & yes ( space ) & yes + the field of extra - solar planets is evolving rapidly
. the number of groups conducting transit and microlensing planet searches , planning future programs , and providing theoretical support is growing at an ever - increasing rate .
for that reason , this series of lectures has centered on the principles of the techniques rather than reviewing the current players . in order to help the reader keep pace with this accelerating activity , however , a list of relevant internet resources with links to occultation and microlensing planet search groups is provided at the end of this section .
what can we expect in the next decade from these research teams ?
several ground - based transit searches are already underway ( villanova university , tep , wasp , vulcan , and export ) .
some focus on high - quality photometry of known eclipsing binaries .
this is likely to increase the probability of transits if planets exist in such binary systems .
two transit - search teams recently issued ( apparently contradictory ) claims for a possible planet detection in the eclipsing m - dwarf system known as cm draconis ( iau circulars 6864 and 6875 , see also deeg 1998 ) , but no clear , undisputed planetary signal has seen . one class of planets known to exist in reasonable numbers and also relatively easy to detect via occultation is the `` hot jupiter ; '' the planet in 51 peg is a prototype of this class . if such a planet is the size of jupiter , its orbital plane would have a @xmath010% chance of being sufficiently inclined to produce a detectable eclipse of a solar - type parent as seen from earth .
an aggressive ground - based program should be able to detect large numbers of such planets in the next decade planets that could be studied with the radial velocity technique thereby yielding both planetary mass and radius .
space - based missions ( corot and kepler ) planned for launch within this decade should have the sensitivity to detect transits from terrestrial - mass objects , but in order to detect earth - like planets in earth - like environments ( orbiting solar - type stars at 1 au ) they will need long mission times . microlensing
planet searches are being conducted or aided by international collaborations ( planet , gman , mps , moa , and export ) that intensely monitor the events discovered by microlensing search teams ( eros , macho , ogle , and moa ) .
macho and ogle electronically alert on - going microlensing in the direction of the galactic bulge on a regular basis : at given time during the bulge observing season several events are in progress and available for monitoring . both the planet and gman
collaborations have issued real - time secondary alerts of anomalous behavior ( including binary lenses , source resolution , `` lensing parallax '' ) , but to date no clear detection of a lensing planet has been announced .
especially if caustics are crossed , it may be possible to obtain additional information on microlensing planets from the sky motion of the caustics during the event that is induced by planetary motion ( dominik 1998 ) .
the number of high - quality microlensing light curves monitored by the planet collaboration is already beginning to approach that required for reasonable jovian detection sensitivities ( albrow 1998a ) , so meaningful results on jupiter look - alikes can be expected within the next few years .
as more telescopes , more telescope time , and wider - field detectors are dedicated to dense , precise photometric monitoring capable of detecting planetary transits and planetary microlensing , we can feel certain that if jovian planets with orbital radii less than @xmath06 au exist in sufficient numbers they will be detected in the next few years by these techniques .
i am grateful to nato for financial support and to the institute s efficient and gracious scientific organizers , danielle alloin and ( the sorely missed ) jean - marie mariotti , for a productive and pleasant school .
it is also a pleasure to thank b. scott gaudi for assistance in the preparation of some of the figures in the microlensing section and for permission to show the results of our work before publication . | the fields of occultation and microlensing are linked historically .
early this century , occultation of the sun by the moon allowed the apparent positions of background stars projected near the limb of the sun to be measured and compared with their positions six months later when the sun no longer influenced the light path to earth .
the measured shift in the stellar positions was consistent with lensing by the gravitational field of the sun during the occultation , as predicted by the theory of general relativity .
this series of lectures explores the principles , possibilities and challenges associated with using occultation and microlensing to discover and characterize unseen planets orbiting distant stars .
the two techniques are complementary in terms of the information that they provide about planetary systems and the range of system parameters to which they are most sensitive .
although the challenges are large , both microlensing and occultation may provide avenues for the discovery of extra - solar planets as small as earth . #
1#1 _get ref _ |
the relativistic mean field theory ( rmf ) is one of the most popular methods in modern nuclear physics .
it has been successful in describing the properties of ordinary nuclei / nuclear matter and hyper - nuclei / nuclear matter .
appropriate effective meson - baryon interactions are essential to the rmf calculation . to describe the nuclear matter and/or finite nuclei , nonlinear self - interactions for @xmath5 and @xmath6 mesons
are introduced @xcite . in recent years , a number of effective interactions for meson - baryon couplings , e.g. , the nl - z @xcite , nl3 @xcite , nl - sh @xcite , tm1 , and tm2 @xcite etc . , have been developed .
given that rmf has been a favorite model in describing the properties of ordinary nuclei / nuclear matter and hyper - nuclei / nuclear matter , we will study the in - medium properties of @xmath7 within the framework of the relativistic mean field theory .
the pentaquark state @xmath7 ( 1540 ) was first predicted by diakonov _
@xcite , attained much support in the following years @xcite , and finally listed in the review of particle physics @xcite . presently , experimental results on @xmath0 are a little subtle ( see ref .
@xcite for a recent review ) , e.g. , the newly published data by the clas collaboration turn out to be significantly different from the previous results @xcite .
the negative results have higher statistics and are quite convincing , but they may not completely wash away the evidence yet , or , in other words , the pentaquark is not quite dead . just because of the uncertainties , it is necessary to study the in - medium properties of @xmath7 , which is helpful to look for signals in experiments to see whether it can exist as a bound state in nuclei .
in fact , the study of the in - medium properties of @xmath7 has been a hot topic for nuclear physicists @xcite . since miller predicted an attractive @xmath0 nuclear interaction which is strong enough to bind @xmath0 in a nucleus @xcite , cabrera et al .
found a large attractive @xmath0 potential of @xmath8 mev in the nuclear medium .
other investigations also show attractions , e.g. , the qcd sum - rules give an attractive @xmath0 potential @xmath9 mev @xcite , and the quark mean - field model provides an attractive potential about @xmath10 mev @xcite . in a previous paper
, we have also studied the properties of @xmath0 in the nuclear medium @xcite .
however , the internal structure of @xmath7 was not considered there .
in fact , the internal structure is very important @xcite .
it is well known that the internal structure of @xmath0 will be different if the mass of the constituents is different . in this paper
, we consider the possibility that @xmath0 is a k@xmath2n molecule state .
we then discuss a possible bound state of @xmath0 in nuclei . for comparison
, we also give the results without considering the internal structure .
the paper is organized as follows . in the subsequent section
, we present the general rmf theory for nuclear matter and for a baryon in nuclear matter .
then the medium modifications of the pentaquark as a k@xmath2n structure in medium are accordingly investigated within the framework of rmf in sec .
[ theta ] . finally a summary is given in sec .
in rmf , the effective lagrangian density @xcite can be written as @xmath11 \nonumber\\ & & + \frac{1}{2}\partial^{\mu}\sigma\partial_{\mu}\sigma -\frac{1}{2}m_{\sigma}^{2}\sigma^{2 } -\frac{1}{3}g_{2}^{2}\sigma^{3 } -\frac{1}{4 } g _ { 3}^{2}\sigma^{4 } \nonumber\\ & & -\frac{1}{4}\omega^{\mu\nu}\omega_{\mu\nu } + \frac{1}{2}m_{\omega}^{2}\omega^{\mu}\omega_{\mu } -\frac{1}{4 } r ^{a \mu\nu}r _ { \mu\nu}^{a } \nonumber\\ & & + \frac{1}{2 } m_{\rho}^{2 } { \rho^{a\mu } } { \rho^{a}_{\mu } } -\frac{1}{4 } f^{\mu\nu}f_{\mu\nu } \nonumber\\ & & -e\bar{\psi } _ { b}\gamma^{\mu}a^{\mu}\frac{1}{2}(1+\tau^{b}_{3})\psi_{b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath12
the standard rmf lagrangian involves baryons ( @xmath13 ) , scalar mesons ( @xmath5 ) , vector mesons ( @xmath14 ) , vector isovector mesons ( @xmath15 ) , and photons ( @xmath16 ) .
the sum on @xmath17 is over protons , neutrons , hyperons or exotic baryon @xmath0 .
the baryon mass is @xmath18 , while the masses of @xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath19 mesons are , respectively , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 .
@xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 are , respectively , the @xmath5-baryon , @xmath6-baryon and @xmath19-baryon coupling constants . the pauli matrices for baryons are written as @xmath26 with @xmath27 being the third component . using the mean - field approximation , i.e. , replacing the meson fields by their mean values , and neglecting the coulomb field
, we immediately have the equation of motion for baryons : @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the effective mass of baryons . for infinite nuclear matter ,
the equations of motion for the mean - field values of the scalar and vector mesons , i.e. , @xmath30 and @xmath31 , are given by @xmath32 where @xmath33 and @xmath19 are the baryon scalar density and vector density , respectively , which are given by @xmath34 and @xmath35 if , only one impurity baryon , e.g. , @xmath0 , is in symmetric infinite nuclear matter , the effect of impurity baryon on the mean field values can be neglected @xcite .
then , eqs .
( [ rhoss ] ) and ( [ rho ] ) are simplified , giving @xmath36 , \label{rhosms}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath37 where @xmath38 .three sets of parameters .
a , b , and c are , respectively , from nl - sh , nl3 , and ref .
the masses are given in mev and the coupling @xmath39 in @xmath40 .
the mass of @xmath19 mesons is @xmath41 mev , and the nucleon mass is @xmath42 mev for all the sets . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] ignoring the nonlinear @xmath30 terms in eq .
( [ eqsig0 ] ) , one then has a simple linear relation between the scalar mean field @xmath30 and the scalar density @xmath44 , i.e. , @xmath45 this approximation is often used to estimate some properties of nuclear matter . in fact , the nonlinear terms of @xmath46 are important to the rmf calculations , especially at dense matter . to see clearly the effects of the nonlinear terms of @xmath46 , we plot , in fig .
[ sig ] , the mean - field value @xmath46 as a function of the nuclear scalar density @xmath33 , with and without nonlinear @xmath46 terms . in the calculations , we adopt three sets of parameters , respectively from nl - sh , nl3 , and the parameters from ref.@xcite , which are marked with a , b , and c in tab .
i. in fig.[sig ] , the dotted , solid , and dashed lines correspond , respectively , to these three sets of parameters . obviously , the curves corresponding to the results with the nonlinear @xmath46 terms are different from the results without the nonlinear terms of @xmath46 ( the straight lines ) . from fig .
[ sig ] , we also see the parameter dependence of the relation @xmath43 , especially in the high - density region . it is interesting to note that the scalar density @xmath47 has , with the nonlinear @xmath30 terms , an upper limit ( @xmath48 for nl3 set and 2.14@xmath49 for nl - sh set ) , which does not exist with the linear relation . substituting eq .
( [ efs ] ) into ( [ rhosms ] ) , we have the following relation between the scalar density @xmath44 , the nucleon density @xmath19 , and the @xmath5 mean - field value @xmath30 : @xmath51 where the function @xmath52 is defined to be @xmath53/\pi^2\ ] ] with @xmath54 being the ratio of the nucleon s fermi momentum to its effective mass , i.e. , @xmath55 the mean - field value @xmath30 is connected to the scalar density @xmath44 by eq.([eqsig0 ] ) , i.e. , @xmath56 therefore , for a given nucleon density @xmath19 , we can first solve @xmath30 from @xmath57 and then the scalar density @xmath44 can be calculated from eq .
( [ rhossigma0 ] ) or ( [ rhosx ] ) .
numerical results are shown in fig .
[ rhosr ] , where the dotted curve is the result without nonlinear @xmath46 terms and the parameter set is from ref .
@xcite , the solid and dash - dotted curves are the results with the nonlinear @xmath46 terms corresponding , respectively , to nl3 and nl - sh .
one can see , from fig .
[ rhosr ] , that the differences among the three curves are nearly invisible in the region @xmath58 , which indicates that the effect from nonlinear @xmath46 terms on the scalar density @xmath33 is trivial , and there is little parameter dependence for scalar density @xmath33 in the region @xmath58 .
however , the differences become more and more obvious with increasing densities . thus , the nonlinear @xmath46 terms are more important for calculations at higher densities , and in the case , the scalar density is also sensitive to the parameter choice .
the study of the hadron properties in nuclear matter is one of the most interesting topics in nuclear physics .
the effective mass and nuclear potential of hadrons are two important aspects which should be studied . in the usual rmf framework ,
the effective mass of @xmath0 is given by @xcite @xmath59 and the nuclear potential for @xmath0 is @xmath60 according to the analysis in sec .
[ nn ] , the effective mass and nuclear potential of @xmath0 as functions of @xmath19 can be obtained easily .
the calculations from eqs.([mstheta0 ] ) and ( [ utheta0 ] ) will be discussed later . in the usual rmf model , the @xmath0
is roughly regarded as a point - like particle in the calculation .
however , it s very likely that @xmath0 is a bound state of quark aggregations such as diquark - triquark @xmath61 @xcite and k@xmath2n molecule state @xcite
. if the internal structure of @xmath0 is considered , its properties may be very different . in the following ,
we will consider @xmath0 as a k@xmath2n molecule state and study its in - medium properties within the framework of rmf . in the picture of qmc model@xcite , the mesons couple directly with the quarks in a nucleon .
similarly , we can also assume that the mesons couple directly with k , @xmath2 , and n in @xmath0 , given that we are considering @xmath0 as a k@xmath2n bound state . or , in other words , the investigation of the interaction between @xmath0 and nucleons in medium turns into the investigation of the interactions of kn , @xmath2n , and nn in medium . in the calculation
, we assume that the @xmath2 mesons , as goldstone bosons , do not change their properties in the medium @xcite , i.e. , we neglect the @xmath2n interaction in medium as an approximation
. the nn interaction has been investigated in sec .
[ nn ] . before investigating the in - medium properties of @xmath0 with a k@xmath2n structure , we will review the kn in - medium interaction , which is essential to the study of @xmath0 as a bound state in the nuclear medium .
roughly speaking , there are two popularly used methods for the study of kaons in nuclear medium .
one is rmf theory , and the other is chiral perturbation theory ( chpt ) . [ [ rmf - approach ] ] rmf approach + + + + + + + + + + + + kaons can be incorporated into the rmf model by using kaon - nucleon interactions motivated by one meson exchange models @xcite . in the meson - exchange picture , the scalar and vector interaction between kaons and nucleons
are mediated by the exchange of @xmath5 and @xmath6 mesons . for symmetric nuclear matter , the simplest kaon - meson interaction lagrangian is @xmath62 where @xmath5 and @xmath63 are the scalar and vector fields , respectively . @xmath64 and @xmath65 are the coupling constants between the kaon and the scalar and vector fields .
the @xmath5-k coupling constant is chosen from the su(3 ) relation by assuming ideal mixing @xcite , i.e. , @xmath66 the k-@xmath6 coupling constant can be obtained by fitting the experimental kn scattering length @xcite @xmath67 in the present work , we set @xmath68 , which is in the range of @xmath69 . at the mean - field level ,
the equation of motion for kaons is @xmath70 k = 0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath46 and @xmath31 are the mean - field value of the scalar and vector meson fields , respectively .
decomposing the kaon field into plan waves , we obtain the equation @xmath71 for the kaon ( anti - kaon ) energy @xmath72 and the momentum @xmath73 .
the energies of kaons and antikaons in nuclear medium are then given by @xmath74 where the effective mass of kaons is @xmath75 from the in - medium dispersion relations ( [ disper1 ] ) and ( [ disper2 ] ) , the kaon / antikaon potential can be defined as @xcite @xmath76 [ [ chiral - approach ] ] chiral approach
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for comparison , we also introduce another method , the chiral perturbation approach in our calculations . for symmetric nuclear matter , the effect of isospin is neglected . following refs .
@xcite , the kaon - nucleon chiral lagrangian is written as @xmath77 \nonumber\\ & & + \frac{\sigma_{\mathrm{kn}}}{f_{\mathrm{k}}^2}\bar{\psi}_\mathrm{n}\psi_\mathrm{n}\bar{k}k\nonumber\\ & & + \frac{\tilde{d}}{f_{\mathrm{k}}^2}\bar{\psi}_\mathrm{n}\psi_\mathrm{n}(\partial_{\mu}\bar{k}\partial^{\mu}k),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath78 mev is the kaon decay constant and @xmath79 is the kn sigma term .
the first term corresponds to the tomozawa - weinberg vector interaction .
the second term is the scalar interaction which will shift the effective mass of the kaon and the antikaon .
the last term , which is sometimes called the off - shell term , modifies the scalar interaction .
@xmath79 is not known very well , in the original work , it was chose to be @xmath80 in accordance with the born model @xcite .
more recently , the value @xmath81 mev is favored according to lattice gauge calculations @xcite .
thus , it may vary in the region from 270 mev to 480 mev . by fitting the kn scattering lengths
, one can determine the constant @xcite @xmath82 the equation of motion for kaon field in the mean - field approximation and in uniform matter reads @xmath83 k=0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath84 is the scalar density and @xmath85 is the vector density for nucleons .
plane wave decomposition of the equation of motion yields @xmath86 the kaon and antikaon energies in the nuclear medium are @xmath87^{1/2 } \right .
\nonumber\\ & & \phantom{\bigg [ } + \frac{3}{8f_{\mathrm{k}}^2}\rho \bigg\ } \left ( 1+\frac{\tilde{d}}{f_{\mathrm{k}}^2}\rho_s \right)^{-1 } , \\
\omega_{\bar{k } } & = & \left\ { \left [ \left({m_{\mathrm{k}}^*}^2+\vec{k}^2\right ) \left(1+\frac{\tilde{d}}{f_{\mathrm{k}}^2}\rho_s\right)^2 + ( \frac{3}{8f_{\mathrm{k}}^2 } \rho ) ^2 \right]^{1/2 } \right .
\nonumber\\ & & \phantom { [ } \left .
-\frac{3}{8f_{\mathrm{k}}^2 } \rho \right\ } \left ( 1+\frac{\tilde{d}}{f_{\mathrm{k}}^2}\rho_s \right)^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 is the kaon effective mass @xmath89 [ [ results ] ] results + + + + + + + the kaon energy @xmath90 at zero momentum ( @xmath91 ) as a function of the nuclear density @xmath19 is plotted in fig.[kmass ] .
for rmf approach , we adopt two sets of parameters : nl - sh and nl3 . for chpt method , we consider also three cases : @xmath92 mev , and in the calculation we have used the relation @xmath93 in rmf model with the nl - sh parameter set .
= 8.2 cm from fig .
[ kmass ] , we hardly see any difference between all the curves in the low density region @xmath94 .
and in the region of @xmath95 , the chpt approach always gives larger kaon energy than rmf model . at @xmath96 ,
the kaon energy is about @xmath97 mev , which is nearly independent of the models and parameter sets .
the kaon potential @xmath98 mev for rmf model and @xmath99 mev for chpt model at normal nuclear density , compatible with the prediction @xmath100 mev in ref.@xcite . at high densities ,
the uncertainty of the results from different parameter sets within rmf model is @xmath101 mev . at @xmath102 , the kaon energy @xmath103 mev ( @xmath104 mev for nl - z in ref .
@xcite ) for rmf model , and @xmath105 mev ( @xmath106 mev in ref .
@xcite ) for chpt model . all the results are compatible with the calculation in ref .
@xcite as a whole .
thus , they give us reliable bases for the following calculations and discussions .
now that the nn and kn interactions in nuclear matter have been known , it is convenient to investigate the k@xmath2n structure of @xmath0 in the nuclear medium .
the effective lagrangian for @xmath0 as a k@xmath2n bound state can be written as @xmath107 where @xmath108 , @xmath109 and @xmath110 are the effective lagrangian densities , respectively , for nucleons , kaons , and pions , and @xmath111 is for the internal interaction of k@xmath2n system . usually , the contributions from @xmath110 and @xmath112 are small .
therefor , we do not explicitly consider them in the following . in the rmf framework ,
the interactions between hadrons are mediated by the exchange of the scalar meson @xmath5 and vector meson @xmath6 . according to the above discussions , @xmath109 and @xmath108 for symmetric nuclear matter
can be written as @xmath113 then , at the mean - field level , the in - medium energy of nucleons is given by @xmath114 and the in - medium energy of @xmath0 is @xmath115 where @xmath116 is the @xmath2 energy and @xmath117 is the bound energy of k@xmath2n system , neither changes in nuclear medium . at zero momentum , the in - medium @xmath0 energy is given by @xmath118 where the effective mass of @xmath0 in nuclear matter is @xmath119 in free space , the @xmath0 mass is @xmath120 .
combining eqs .
( [ mbsdef ] ) and ( [ mksdef ] ) , the effective mass of @xmath0 can be expressed as @xmath121 the @xmath0 potential is defined to be the energy difference between @xmath0 in the medium and @xmath0 in free space , i.e. , @xmath122 at zero momentum ( @xmath123 ) , one then has @xmath124^{1/2 } % + \sqrt{m_{\mathrm{k}}^2+g_{\sigma\mathrm{k}}m_{\mathrm{k}}\sigma_0 } \nonumber\\ & & + g_{\omega\mathrm{k}}\omega_{0}-m_{\mathrm{k}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] = 8.2 cm now we can easily obtain the effective masses , respectively , for the point - like @xmath0 and for the @xmath0 with a k@xmath2n structure , according to the eqs .
( [ mstheta0 ] ) and ( [ mthetakpin ] ) .
the results are given in fig .
[ emass ] .
two parameter sets , i.e. , the nl - sh and nl3 are adopted in the calculations .
it is found that , when @xmath0 is regarded as a k@xmath2n bound state , its effective mass is dramatically enhanced . at normal nuclear density ,
the effective mass of k@xmath2n system is @xmath125 mev , much larger than that of the point - like @xmath0 ( @xmath126 mev ) .
the effective mass of @xmath0 is enhanced by about 90 mev ( 6% of @xmath127 ) due to its internal structure . at higher densities ,
say @xmath102 , the effective mass of @xmath0 with k@xmath2n structure is enhanced about 160 mev compared with that of point - like @xmath0 .
the effective mass depends obviously on the parameter sets in the region of @xmath128 , the mass difference is about @xmath129 mev between the nl - sh and nl3 parameter sets .
however , at lower densities @xmath130 , the difference is almost invisible between the two curves ( nl - sh and nl3 ) . as a whole
, the effective mass of @xmath0 depends strongly on its internal structure .
the difference is up to 90 mev between k@xmath2n structure and point - like @xmath0 at @xmath131 .
the effects on the effective mass for different parameter sets of the point - like @xmath0 are much smaller than those of the k@xmath2n system .
the potential depth is another important aspect for understanding the interactions between @xmath7 and nucleons . to see the @xmath0 potential in nuclear matter clearly ,
the @xmath0 potential of the k@xmath2n structure is plotted in fig .
[ pp ] . for comparison ,
the potential of the point - like @xmath7 as a function of the nuclear density @xmath19 is also plotted in the same figure .
= 8.2 cm from the figure , we can see that when @xmath7 is considered as a k@xmath2n bound state , the potential depth becomes much shallower than that of point - like @xmath0 . at normal nuclear density ,
the potential depth of @xmath0 with k@xmath2n structure is about @xmath3 mev , which is about 52 mev shallower than that of the point - like @xmath7 .
the potential depth of @xmath7 with k@xmath2n structure at normal nuclear density is also shallower than the previous predictions in other models @xcite .
therefore , if @xmath0 is indeed a k@xmath2n bound state , it should have a shallower in - medium potential in rmf .
this is a quite different observation from the previous result of strong binding ( several hundreds of mev ) in nuclei @xcite . on the other hand , we see , from the figure , that the results for nl3 and nl - sh are very similar in the region @xmath132
. however , there are strong parameters dependence in the higher density region @xmath133 .
considering the @xmath0 as a k@xmath2n structure , we have calculated the effective mass and optical potential of @xmath0 in the nuclear medium with both the rmf approach and the chpt theory .
we find that the potential depth is only @xmath134 mev at normal nuclear density , much shallower than @xmath135 mev for point - like @xmath0 .
the effective mass of @xmath0 with a k@xmath2n structure is also dramatically enhanced , which is @xmath136 mev at normal density , 90 mev larger than @xmath137 mev for point - like @xmath0 .
of course , our results depend on parameters .
also , @xmath0 may have other internal structures .
because different internal structure have different in - medium properties , further studies on the @xmath0 in nuclear medium are needed to clarify uncertainties .
the authors thank support from the natural science foundation of china ( 10275037 , 10375074 , 90203004 ) and the doctoral programme foundation of the china institution of higher education ( 20010055012 ) . | the properties of nuclear matter are discussed with the relativistic mean - field theory ( rmf ) .
then , we use two models in studying the in - medium properties of @xmath0 : one is the point - like @xmath1 in the usual rmf and the other is a k@xmath2n structure for the pentaquark .
it is found that the in - medium properties of @xmath0 are dramatically modified by its internal structure .
the effective mass of @xmath0 in medium is , at normal nuclear density , about 1030 mev in the point - like model , while it is about 1120 mev in the model of k@xmath2n pentaquark .
the nuclear potential depth of @xmath0 in the k@xmath2n model is approximately @xmath3 mev , much shallower than @xmath4 mev in the usual point - like rmf model . |
it is for some time that the high energy physics community is of the opinion that in the near future there will be a need for the facility of a high energy linear @xmath0 collider with a nominal energy around 0.5 tev in the centre of mass ( cm ) system . a conceptual design of such a collider , known under the name tesla , and its physics program is described in some details in ref .
it has further been pointed out that the option of longitudinal polarized electron beams in such high energy colliders , like tesla , will enrich significantly the physics capabilities of the device @xcite .
the use of polarised beams requires however a continuous monitoring and sufficient accurate measurement of the beam polarisation during the entire collider operation .
+ in addition to the widely used compton scattering polarimeter , the @xmath5 mller scattering process has also been utilised to evaluate the polarisation level of the electron beams .
unlike the compton polarimeter the operation of a mller polarimeter may need dedicated accelerator runs but its relatively simple construction and operation and the large counting rates makes it nevertheless a rather attractive device . here
one should note that the method applied for the mller polarimeter can also be applied almost without any change to the measurement of a positron beam polarisation by replacing the mller process with the bhabha scattering @xcite .
+ several colliders have in fact already used mller polarimeters to monitor their polarized electron beams . the stanford linear collider ( slc )
has primarily used a precise compton polarimeter to monitor the beam and measure the electron beam polarisation @xcite . in addition
it has also engaged two single - arm mller polarimeter for beam polarisation diagnosis .
many fixed target experiments , e.g. those described in references @xcite , were running with polarised beams monitored by mller polarimeters . finally the mller like scattering , @xmath6 , was used in the smc experiment at cern @xcite to measure the polarisation of the muon beam .
the mller measurement can be also be carried out after the colliding beams interaction point ( ip ) . from this point of view
, the mller polarimeters are more suited for the nlc , jlc or clic linear colliders , than for tesla , because of the non - zero crossing , the extraction does not require bending of the electron trajectories after the ip .
+ in this paper we describe the outcome of a detailed study which explored the feasibility and possibility to use the mller scattering process as a method for the longitudinal polarisation measurement of the tesla electron beam . in sections 2 and 3
we describe in some details the various properties of the mller scattering , with and without polarised beams , and also review some of the technical characteristics of the mller polarimeters used in recent high energy experiments emphasizing the specific tesla needs .
the expected event rates and the effects of the energy deposition in the target by the electron beam are dealt with in section 4 . in section 5
we consider two somewhat different methods for the beam polarisation measurement and evaluate their envisaged performance .
the lowest order @xmath7 mller elastic scattering diagrams are the t - channel and u - channel @xmath8 exchanges is less than 1 gev therefore the z@xmath9 gauge boson exchange contribution is negligible . ] shown in fig .
[ diagrams ] .
each of these two diagrams contributes to the two possible spin configurations of the initial electrons , namely the parallel and anti - parallel states . from the fermi - dirac statistics
follows that the relative phase between the two diagrams is negative .
this has important consequences on the spin dependence of the cross section . for the anti - parallel spin configuration the scattered spins are also anti - parallel .
the anti - parallel spin state contains an additional negative phase between the two possible orientations of the outgoing spins . as a result
the amplitudes add and the cross section is larger for anti - parallel spin configuration generating a non - zero asymmetry . +
the mller differential elastic cross section at tree level and in the cm system is given by : @xmath10 for high @xmath11 values so that the electron mass squared @xmath12 can be neglected . here
: + @xmath13 = the fine structure constant at low energies which is equal to 1/137 ; + @xmath14 = the cm frame polar scattering angle ; + @xmath15 = the cm azimuthal angle of the scattered electron ; + @xmath16 and @xmath17 = longitudinal polarisation of the beam and target ; + @xmath18 and @xmath19 = transverse polarisation of the beam and target ; + @xmath20 and @xmath21 = the azimuthal angles of the beam and target transverse polarisation vectors .
+ the longitudinal and transverse asymmetry functions , @xmath22 and @xmath23 , are defined as : + @xmath24 and shown as a function of @xmath25 in fig .
[ asyfun ] . to note
is that both @xmath22 and @xmath23 are small in the forward direction so that the asymmetries are small in the region where the t - channel diagram dominates .
+ in order to determine the beam polarisation , the rate of the electrons scattered in a given solid angle @xmath26 is measured in one orientation of the beam and target polarisation vectors @xmath27 and then with the beam polarisation vector inverted i.e. , @xmath28 . here
the polarisation vectors are defined as @xmath29 $ ] for the beam and @xmath30 $ ] for the target .
the longitudinal component , @xmath31 , is in the z - direction and @xmath32 , the transverse component , is perpendicular to that direction .
thus the two rates which one measures are : @xmath33 normalised to the same integrated luminosity . from these rates one constructs the asymmetry @xmath34 which is equal to : @xmath35 finally the beam polarisation is extracted from the measured values of @xmath34 , the measured target polarisation and the unpolarised asymmetry functions given in eq .
+ the expressions given in eqs .
[ mollerf ] and [ eq3 ] are derived for the lowest order diagrams for the @xmath36 process .
the contributions of higher diagrams , up to order 4 in the fine structure constant @xmath13 , were in the past investigated in @xcite and more recently in @xcite .
the qed corrections to the mller asymmetry can be evaluated through the bmollr code developed by s. jadach and b. ward @xcite .
this is an @xmath37 exponentiated monte carlo generator for @xmath38 with any @xmath39 value .
some obvious features of the mller scattering can be deduced from eq .
[ mollerf ] . + a ) the cross section is seen to diverge at @xmath25 = @xmath401 .
this is due to the fact that the electron mass was neglected . in a rigorous treatment , where @xmath41 is not neglected ,
the mller scattering formula remains finite even at @xmath25 = @xmath401 .
+ b ) the cross section magnitude decreases as @xmath42 increases , similar to the one photon annihilation process in @xmath43 annihilation . + c ) only if the beam and the target are simultaneously transverse and/or longitudinal polarised a change in the mller scattering will be observed .
+ d ) in the absence of transverse polarisation the cross section is independent of the azimuthal angle @xmath15 . this independence can also be achieved by integrating over the whole azimuthal angle @xmath15 provided of course that the experimental setup is @xmath15 independent .
+ e ) the asymmetry functions reach their maximum at a cm scattering angle of 90@xmath44 and approach zero in the forward and backward directions .
+ the cross sections and asymmetries were studied for a set of @xmath45 values and several beam - target polarisation configurations where we set everywhere @xmath46 to zero . in order to illustrate the effects of the beam and target polarisations we assume for the target a polarisation of 90@xmath47 realising that in practice an iron target has a maximum polarisation of 8@xmath47 .
the beam polarisation was taken to be 90@xmath47 . in fig .
[ moldiff ] we show , after integrating over the whole azimuthal angle @xmath15 , typical cm polar angular distributions of the mller scattering at different beam energies scattered by a stationary electron target , without and with longitudinal polarisation characterised by their @xmath48 values . for beam electrons of @xmath49 gev scattered over a stationary electron ,
we show in fig .
[ twod ] the two dimensional plots of the mller differential cross section @xmath50 with and without longitudinal polarisation and without and with transverse polarisation . in fig .
[ totalx ] we show the total mller cross section integrated over @xmath15 from @xmath51 to @xmath52 and over the polar angle region @xmath53 for unpolarised and polarised beam and target .
finally we show in fig .
[ asymm](left ) the mller scattering asymmetry @xmath34 as a function of @xmath25 and @xmath15 for a longitudinal polarisation value of @xmath54 and @xmath55 . in the same figure
we also show the asymmetry @xmath34 dependence on @xmath25 after integrating over the @xmath15 angle .
in the collision of two electrons the total centre of mass energy squared @xmath56 is written in the lorentz invariant form , and thus valid in any reference system , as : @xmath57 where @xmath45 and @xmath58 are the beam and target electron energies , @xmath59 is the angle between the incident particle s momenta and @xmath60 are the velocities of beam and target electrons .
+ at tesla , where the beam energy is planned to be a few hundreds gev , one has @xmath61 so that one can neglect @xmath12 and eq .
[ s_all ] reduces to : @xmath62 in the approximation that the target electron is in the laboratory system a free particle at rest ( @xmath63 ) , the square of the centre of mass energy , @xmath64 , is given by the expression : @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the beam momentum and @xmath41 is the electron mass .
the laboratory momentum of the scattered electron , @xmath67 , is given by : @xmath68 where @xmath69 are the momentum and energy of the incident electron in the cm system and @xmath70 .
the relation between the laboratory scattering angle @xmath71 and the cm scattering angle @xmath14 is given by : @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the ratio of the velocity of the center of mass system and the velocity of the electron in the cm system . for elastic scattering of a beam electron of @xmath74= 250 gev on an electron at rest one
has @xmath75 so that eqs .
[ p_labgeneral ] and [ angle_transform ] can be reduced to a simpler form .
+ using the relation between @xmath76 and @xmath77 and remembering that @xmath78 one obtains : @xmath79 in the cm system of the mller scattering the momentum and energy of the incident electron are expressed by : @xmath80 therefore @xmath81 here @xmath82 is the velocity of the incident electron calculated in the cm system . using eqs .
[ s_0 ] , [ lorentz ] and [ beta - rho ] we rewrite eq .
[ p_labgeneral ] to be : @xmath83 from this last equation follows that the momentum of the scattered electron does not depend on the cm total energy , but only on the beam energy and the cm scattering angle . from eq .
[ angle_transform ] one obtains , in a few simple steps , the expression : @xmath84 finally in the small angle approximation , where @xmath85 , one obtains from eqs .
[ p_lab ] and [ exact ] that @xmath86 the single - arm mller polarimetry is based on eq .
[ theta_0 ] which provides the identification of the elastic @xmath87 scattering through the relation , in the laboratory system , between @xmath71 and @xmath67 . in fig .
[ theta_correl ] we show the relation between the centre of mass polar angle @xmath14 and the angle of scattered electron @xmath71 , for three different @xmath45 values . + _ the analysing power _ of the mller polarimeter is proportional to the product of the unpolarized cross section and the square of the asymmetry @xcite .
the optimal scattering angle for polarimetry is thus the one that maximizes the analysing power of the method . for longitudinal polarisation measurements , _
the analysing power _ is maximum at @xmath88 . in fig .
[ theta_correl ] the region of @xmath89 around this optimal @xmath14 value is magnified . for @xmath88 one
has for any @xmath45 the following mller scattering relevant quantities : @xmath90 ; @xmath91 and @xmath92 so that for @xmath49 gev one has : + @xmath93barn , @xmath94 gev and @xmath95 mrad . +
these variables are listed in table [ mol - param ] for several beam - target polarisation configurations . in this subsection
we evaluate the effects of the non - zero momenta of the target electrons on the quantities relevant to the mller polarimetry .
the target electrons are in fact not free particles at rest but are bound to atomic shells which in the case of fe atoms , move with a momentum in the range of @xmath96 kev @xcite .
the kinematic effects of these non - zero momentum target electrons are similar to those produced by the initial state radiation , namely the @xmath87 cm energy is modified .
+ the detailed kinematics of the scattering of an energetic electron from a bound state electron moving with momentum @xmath97 is discussed in @xcite . to leading order ,
the cm energy is given by : @xmath98 where @xmath99 is the momentum of the target particle and @xmath100 is the unitary vector pointing in the direction of the beam particle momentum .
the presence of non - zero momentum target electron does not modify eq .
[ p_lab ] but eq . [ theta_0 ] is changed producing the levchuk effect namely , the line image in @xmath101 space is broader .
+ taking into account the corrected cm energy given by eq .
[ s_1 ] , one has to modify eq .
[ theta_0 ] to read : @xmath102 the laboratory scattering angle is smeared by the square root of the target momentum dependent factor @xmath103 , the same factor which modifies the cm energy .
+ in the experiments which operated during the last decade the targets used for the mller polarimeters have been fe alloy or pure fe foils @xcite . in these kind of materials the k- and l - shell electrons
are unpolarised ( with mean momentum of 90 kev and 30 kev ) and the polarised ones reside in the m- and n - shells ( with 10 kev and 2 kev average momenta ) .
only two electrons from the m - shell carry the fe magnetization , out of a total of 26 , yielding a maximum target polarisation of 8@xmath47 .
+ for the polarised target electrons the smearing factor is small but for unpolarised electrons it can achieve values around @xmath104 . in fig .
[ theta_correl2 ] we show the dependence of the scattering angle , @xmath71 , on the cm angle @xmath14 for the case of target electrons at rest ( solid line ) and for moving target electrons from the m and k shells ( dashed and dotted lines ) . + in fig .
[ p_correl ] we plot the momentum of elastic scattered mller electrons as a function of @xmath14 , the centre of mass angle , for @xmath105 gev .
as mentioned earlier , the momentum does not depend on @xmath106 , the total cm energy squared ( see eq .
[ p_lab ] ) , therefore it is not modified even when the fermi motion of the target electrons are accounted for .
this means that the lines shown in fig .
[ p_correl ] are not affected by the fermi motion of the electrons and have not to be split for m and k atomic shells as is the case in fig .
[ theta_correl2 ] .
+ in the case where the electron has a non - zero momentum , the cm energy squared @xmath56 is given by eq . [ s_tesla ] using the appropriate @xmath107 value .
( note that for target electron at rest @xmath63 and one obtains the cm energy squared @xmath108 ) . in order to evaluate the effect of the non - zero momentum target electrons we list in table [ mol - target ] the values for @xmath109 and @xmath107 for several value of @xmath110 and in fig .
[ factor ] we plot @xmath111 $ ] as a function of @xmath45 for various @xmath112 values setting @xmath113 and @xmath114 . from fig .
[ factor ] follows that for @xmath49 gev the factor @xmath115 , which enters in eq .
[ mollerf ] , changes by about 28@xmath47 when the target electron momentum increases from 0 to 150 kev .
+ the effect on the asymmetry however is smaller , namely @xmath116 and can be estimated by using a proper simulation of the elastic mller signal ( see e.g. reference @xcite ) .
finally the measured polarisation value is shifted by about @xmath117 pending on the material of the target , the resolution and acceptance of the polarimeter and the analysis procedure .
+ the correction needed to account for this shift depends on the details of polarimeter construction , the beam parameters and analysis technique as is pointed out in @xcite . at slc the effect was found to be large due to the low emittance of the beam and the fine resolution of the detector .
the solution to this problem , already adopted by e143 at slc and jlab @xcite experiments , is given by adopting the coincidence measurement method using a double - arm polarimeter .
these polarimeters have larger acceptance and poorer resolution so that the levchuk effect was shown to be very small .
+ a recent study @xcite on the performance of the double - arm polarimeter , has discovered a new effect arising from the fermi motion of the atomic electrons in the target .
namely , that there exists a dependence of the measured mller asymmetry on the relative position of the detectors in the double - arm operation mode .
here one should point out that the final decision and the technical design for a mller polarimeter and the corresponding simulation of the apparatus and its performance have to be postponed until a final design of the collider will be available .
a technical drawing of the tesla beam line section near the interaction point ( ip ) , where a mller polarimeter could in principle be placed , can be seen for example in fig .
3.7.2 of ref .
[ 1 ] , page 474 .
the final design and exact position of the mller polarimeter however does depend on the choice taken between a single or a double arm device and on the detailed knowledge on the beam transport and background conditions . in these two possibilities
the common elements of a mller polarimeter are : + @xmath118 a magnetized target made usually of a fe or fe - alloy foil or if technological possible a new type of target ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite ) ; + @xmath118 a set of magnets to steer the scattered electrons ; + @xmath118 a collimator to define the accepted scattering range in the azimuthal angle @xmath15 and the ( @xmath119 ) polar angle interval , for the elastic scattered electrons .
this is followed by a dipole magnet that selects electron momenta in the desired range of acceptance ; + @xmath118 finally the scattered electrons are detected and registered by an electromagnetic detector .
to this end one can envisage for example a microstrip silicon detector coupled to a electromagnetic calorimeter .
this will enable to measure simultaneously the position and energy of the scattered electrons .
the current design of the tesla beam consists of the set of parameters given in ref .
@xcite and listed here in table [ tesla_beam ] .
this information is used here to evaluate _ the effective luminosity _ ) . ] , the expected rate of mller scattering events and its heating effect on the target due to the energy deposited by the electron beam . to this end
we consider here the following target and electron beam features .
* for the target we take pure iron foil .
the electron density @xmath120 in such a pure iron target is : @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the avogadro number , @xmath123 is the density of the material and @xmath124 are the mean atomic number and atomic mass of the iron foil .
taking the density of this material to be @xmath123 = 7.87 g/@xmath125 and @xmath126 kg@xmath127 , one obtains : + @xmath128 * for the planned beam current of @xmath129a , the number of electrons which hit the target in a time interval of one second is : + @xmath130 the counting rate , defined as the number of mller scattering events / sec , is given by : @xmath131 where @xmath132 is the so called effective luminosity .
the mller scattering cross section , @xmath133 , is the result of the integration of eq .
[ mollerf ] over the whole azimuthal angle range and over the cm polar angle @xmath14 domain @xmath134 , chosen for our study , that is : @xmath135 where + @xmath136 + using the relevant values obtained in subsection 4.1 , we evaluate for a high beam polarisation of @xmath137 and a fe target polarisation of @xmath138 , namely @xmath139 , the cross section and effective luminosity to be : + @xmath140 and @xmath141 @xmath142sec@xmath127 .
+ from eq .
[ n_events ] the expected rate of mller events is then : + @xmath143 one should point out that the numbers given here are summed over the whole @xmath15 angle range from 0 to @xmath144 . in practice
, the polarimeter acceptance covers only a small part of this range , denoted here by @xmath145 .
therefore the last quoted rate has to be scaled down by the factor @xmath146 . for a polarimeter acceptance of @xmath147 rad and @xmath148
the expected rate is @xmath149 which is well within the range of the current capabilities of the data acquisition systems used for mller polarimeters .
the target frequently used in mller polarimeters consisted of thin foils of ferromagnetic alloy with the composition 49@xmath47 fe(z=26 , a=57.9 ) , 49@xmath47 co(z=27 , a=58.9 ) and 2@xmath47 vanadium(z=23 , a=50.9 ) known under the name of vanadium - permendur alloy .
it is magnetised _ in - plane _ using a pair of helmholtz coils producing a small magnetic field of 0.01 tesla .
the foils are usually mounted under an angle of @xmath150 with respect to the beam .
the disadvantages of a target with _ in - plane _ magnetisation are : a poor knowledge of the target polarisation i.e. having an uncertainty of @xmath151 as reported in refs.@xcite ; the demagnetisation due to the target heating is undetected and the target polarisation forms a non - zero angle ( typically 20@xmath44 ) with the beam direction . + in order to achieve a precision measurements of the beam polarisation of @xmath152 these limitations have to be overcome given their massive contributions to the systematic error of such method .
a novel approach has been recently developed and put to use @xcite .
this new target is made out of a thin _ pure iron _
foils polarised _ out - of - plane _ in saturation with a 4 tesla magnetic field parallel to the electron beam . the online measurement of the relative foil polarisation during the polarimeter operation is carried out with a laser beam making use of the polar kerr effect @xcite .
+ this new target design allows to reach an accuracy of 0.5@xmath47 on the target polarisation and thus meets the precision beam polarisation measurements requested by tesla .
this precision , in fact , was obtained in the experiment which operated with an electron beam of few @xmath153a having the energies of 1 - 6 gev at jlab ( see ref .
@xcite ) . in this subsection
we address the question of the target heating due to the energy deposited by the impinging beam and its possible effect on the polarimeter performance . to this end
we consider a pure fe foil target with a thickness of @xmath154 m and an area of about 30 @xmath155 so that the target material seen by the beam is @xmath156 g/@xmath155 .
the target , which is cooled down to about 110 k , is polarised in saturation _ out of plane _ , so that when it is placed perpendicular to the beam direction the projected longitudinal polarisation of the target electrons is at its maximum relative to the beam with the result that the longitudinal polarisation of the target electrons is reduced to @xmath157 and its effective thickness is increased to @xmath158 . ] .
the tesla beam design envisages a pulse cycle of 5 hz . the duration of each pulse is @xmath159 msec followed by a pause of @xmath160 msec .
each pulse contains 2820 bunches of 1 psec length which succeeded every 337 nsec . +
the ionisation energy loss in the target of one beam electron with an energy of 250 gev , is @xmath161 ev / g/@xmath155 ( see e.g. ref @xcite ) .
the energy , @xmath162 , deposited in the target by one bunch is : @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the number of beam electrons in one bunch namely , @xmath165 . from eq .
[ e_heat_b ] follows that the quantity of energy deposited in the target is @xmath166 ev / bunch corresponding to @xmath167 j / bunch .
the local temperature rise induced by this energy depends on the beam spot size at the position of the polarimeter . in the present design of the beam delivery system of tesla
a possible position for the compton and mller polarimeters is the straight section of the e@xmath168 linac , some few hundred meters before the ip just outside the quads @xcite . within this straight section
it is advantageous to place the mller polarimeter in the region where the beam profile is the largest having the dimensions of about : @xmath169 and @xmath170 . for the heating calculations
we then take the beam spot to be @xmath171 and @xmath172 .
the instantaneous temperature rise @xmath173 t , of the target area hit by one beam bunch over that of the liquid nitrogen , is shown in table [ tab_temp ] .
the @xmath173 t values given in this table are calculated for a pure iron target of 10 @xmath153 m thickness taking the beam spot area to be @xmath174 for several beam profile values .
+ in particular for the case @xmath175 and @xmath170 , @xmath173 t = 200 k. from the values given in table [ tab_temp ] it is obvious that the local temperature will be above the melting point if all the bunches within one pulse will hit the same small region of the target foil .
to avoid this situation one needs to spread out over the target the individual hitting positions of the train of bunches .
such a solution is the subject of the next subsection . in the present design of the next generation of linear colliders with large beam currents of 30 - 45 @xmath153a and high luminosity values
the typical beam sizes are few tens of microns .
therefore when using for the beam polarisation measurements a mller polarimeter , the local target heating requires a special care . +
a possible solution to this local heating problem can be the implementation of a rotating disk target cooled down , all around its circumference , to about 110 k by liquid nitrogen .
we note in passing that such a solution for the heating problem has been applied to a mller polarimeter @xcite which operated in an electron beam of 0.8 to 5.0 gev with a current of 0.5 to 5.0 @xmath153a where the needed polarisation measurement time was about 20 min .
+ the envisaged target is placed in such a way that its rotation axis is parallel displaced to the beam direction so that successive bunches hit different regions of the target and in fact they will be distributed over a circle .
here we note that a rotating target has already been applied in the experiment described in ref .
@xcite . if the disk rotates with a frequency of about 1000 hz , around an axis displaced by 2.7 cm from the beam direction , all the impact points of the 2820 bunches of a single pulse , will be spaced by about 60 @xmath153 m over an annular zone having a width of 300 @xmath153 m .
+ inasmuch that one can neglect the interference effects of one heated point by the others we evaluate , using the well known heat conduction formulae @xcite , that each heated spot will be cooled down within about 2 msec to 0.1 k above the liquid nitrogen temperature .
this short time is mainly determined by the shortest distance to the cooled edge of the target .
the residual heating of about 0.5 k / sec results in a final temperature rise of 50 k at the end of a 80 sec operation time needed for a polarisation measurement with a precision of about 1 % .
finally the fact that the pause between pulses is even 199 msec one has a sufficient safety margin to cover possible additional minor factors which may affect the cooling time calculations .
+ the local rise in temperature of about 200 k , causes a relatively negligible target depolarisation since the working point at @xmath176 k lies in the plateau region of the magnetisation curve shown in fig .
[ magnet ] .
this curve is derived from equation @xmath177 which describes the magnetisation m of the material as a function of t / t@xmath178 where t@xmath178 is the curie temperature , e.g. 1043 k for fe ( see e.g. @xcite ) . for temperatures above t@xmath178 the spontaneous magnetisation vanishes . as seen from fig .
[ magnet ] at room temperature ( @xmath179 300 k ) or less , the magnetisation depends weakly on t. assuming the cooling temperature of the target to be 110 k , the increase @xmath173 t of the local temperature given in table [ tab_temp ] corresponds to a change in the magnetisation of @xmath173 m = 0.3 @xmath47 for a beam profile of @xmath180m@xmath181 .
thus the heating of the target does not damage its magnetisation and the corresponding polarisation characteristics .
the level of the electron beam longitudinal polarisation @xmath16 is extracted from the measured @xmath34 asymmetry defined in eq .
[ eq3 ] , which is calculated from the results of the two measured rates obtained from the mller scattering with two different relative orientations of the beam polarisation vector with respect to that of the target . to this end
we consider two possible variations for the polarisation evaluation : * * integrated polarisation measurement * + in this method the number of mller scattering events is summed over the whole polarimeter acceptance region .
if we denote by @xmath182 and @xmath183 the recorded scattered events in the relative parallel and anti - parallel beam and target polarisation vectors , properly normalised and corrected for efficiency , then the measured @xmath34 asymmetry is given by @xmath184 .
the final beam polarisation is then derived from this measured asymmetry and the known target polarisation .
* * differential polarisation measurement * + if the polarimeter is equipped with a detector which measures also the momentum of the mller scattered electrons one is able not only to measure the total rate of the scattering events but also their momentum distribution .
this allows a more precise measurement of @xmath16 and facilitates a better control of possible systematic effects .
moreover it allows to optimise the the polarisation measurement even in those cases where the beam is tuned to an energy somewhat different from its nominal designed value , e.g. 250 gev in tesla . in the differential polarisation measurement
one considers the momentum distribution of the scattered electrons . for
a given set @xmath185 of @xmath67 momentum bins the numbers @xmath186 and @xmath187 of the mller electrons are counted .
the asymmetry is calculated for each @xmath188 bin and the beam polarisation @xmath189 is at first determined bin by bin .
the weighted mean of these values provides the final value of the beam polarisation .
the numbers of elastic mller scattering events are counted for two different relative beam - target polarisation vectors , namely @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
the number of mller events integrated over the range @xmath190 to @xmath191 where @xmath192 is defined as : @xmath193 and summed over the measurement time @xmath194 and @xmath195 are given by : @xmath196 where @xmath197 and @xmath198 describe the efficiencies of the polarimeter as a function of @xmath192 and @xmath199 and @xmath200 are the luminosity values for the parallel and anti - parallel beam - target spin states .
the functions @xmath201 and @xmath202 are the unpolarised mller cross section and the asymmetry .
these are given by the expressions : @xmath203 ^ 2}{[1-(x-1)^2]^2 } ~;\\ a_{l}(x ) & = & \frac{[7+(x-1)^2][1-(x-1)^2]}{[3 + ( x-1)^2]^2 } ~. \label{asyx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs .
27 and [ asyx ] are derived from eqs .
[ mollerf ] , [ eq2 ] and the relation [ p_lab ] after integration over the whole azimuthal angle range .
+ to evaluate the polarimeter performance we choose our optimal measurement domain the one shown by the stripped area in fig .
[ p_correl ] , which confines the @xmath192 range to the limits @xmath204 and @xmath205 . for simplicity
we consider the case where the integrated luminosities and efficiencies for the parallel and anti - parallel polarisations of the beam and target electrons are the same i.e. , @xmath206 and @xmath207 .
the experimental measured asymmetry @xmath208 is written as : @xmath209 where the mean value @xmath210 is given by : @xmath211 thus the beam polarisation , @xmath212 is proportional to the inverse of the mean longitudinal asymmetry .
the relative error of the measured beam polarisation @xmath16 is evaluated from eq .
[ p - l , int ] to be : @xmath213 where the error on the measured asymmetry is : @xmath214 here n is the total scattering events number recorded within the domain i.e. , @xmath215 with @xmath216 + by using eqs .
[ asy - error ] and [ p - l , int ] we can rewrite eq .
[ plb_error ] as follows : @xmath217 since the term @xmath218 is @xmath219 ( see table 4 ) , it is negligible in comparison to 1 , so that one can simplify eq .
[ plb2_error ] to : @xmath220 thus the time @xmath221 needed to reach a desired relative polarisation precision @xmath222 is given by : @xmath223 \left ( p_l^bp_l^t \right)^2 \sigma_t < a_l>^2 , \ ] ] which corresponds to the number of scattering events @xmath224 needed to perform the polarisation measurement . in table [ tab_mol1 ] we present the characteristic unpolarised cross section and the averaged asymmetry values for several regions around @xmath88 which may be of interest in a mller polarimeter design . in table
[ tab_mol2 ] we list some of the values concerning the characteristics and performance of a tesla mller polarimeter . using eqs .
[ asy_int ] and [ asy - error ] and the values listed in columns 1 to 3 of the table [ tab_mol2 ] , we calculated the number of events needed to obtain a relative statistical error of @xmath225 for the measured asymmetry @xmath226 . from this
we obtain the needed number of events and the corresponding run duration for a beam polarisation measurement with a relative error of about @xmath227 which includes an assumed over - all 0.85 @xmath47 systematic which includes also the uncertainty in the target polarisation level .
these values are shown in the last two columns of table [ tab_mol2 ] .
the precision expected from the tesla polarimeter in a measurement duration of 80 sec is compared in table [ mol - param2 ] with three existing mller polarimeters attached to high energy electron accelerators .
the distribution of the measured momentum of the mller scattered electrons is grouped in several @xmath188 regions . in each region
the recorded mller scattering events with parallel and anti - parallel spin configurations are given by : @xmath228 where @xmath201 and @xmath229 are the unpolarised mller cross section and the asymmetry given in eqs .
27 and [ asyx ] .
+ the experimental asymmetry , in a given @xmath188 bin , is expressed in terms of the beam and target polarisations as : @xmath230 as previously this formula is for the case where the integrated luminosities and efficiencies for the parallel and the anti - parallel electrons polarisation are identical .
specifically this means @xmath206 and @xmath231 .
+ for each bin one can then evaluate the beam polarisation as : @xmath232 the final beam polarisation is obtained as the weighted mean of the measured polarisations @xmath189
, i.e. : @xmath233 the calculation of the relative error , @xmath234 , follows very closely the one done before for the integrated polarisation measurement .
next we derived an expression for the needed time @xmath235 to achieve a requested polarisation measurement accuracy of @xmath236 , namely : @xmath237 \left ( p_l^bp_l^t \right)^2 \sigma_t < a_l^2 > ~.\ ] ] which translates to the needed scattering events @xmath238 here it should be noted that in the differential method a somewhat smaller number of events is needed to achieve the same precision for the relative @xmath16 measurement .
another advantage of this method is the fact that it permits a better control on systematic errors and background contributions .
+ above all the differential polarisation measurement allows to handle also cases where the linear collider runs at beam energies slightly away from the nominal designed beam energy , which in the tesla case is 250 gev .
in fact one can not exclude the necessity to operate the collider at beam energies away by several gev from the nominal value due to technical problems or physics needs .
if the beam energy changes the @xmath67 value corresponding to @xmath88 is moving and therefore a momentum measurement of the mller scattered electrons will still allow to utilise those scattered events which yield the maximum precision .
this is best illustrated in fig .
[ theta_p ] where in the plane of @xmath71 versus @xmath67 the position of the 90@xmath44 centre of mass scattering angle is shown for several beam energies around the nominal tesla value of 250 gev .
we would like to acknowledge the help and support of many members of the tesla collaboration .
in particular our thanks are due to t. behnke , k. mnig and p. schler for encouraging us to study the mller polarimeter option for tesla .
one of us ( g.a . ) would like to thank profs .
t. hebbeker , t. lohse and p. sding for their very kind hospitality during his stay in the physics institute of the humboldt university , berlin and in desy / zeuthen .
finally this work would not have been possible without the generous financial support extended to him by the dfg during his stay in berlin .
see e.g. r. casalbuoni et al .
, _ study of the anomalous couplings at nlc with polarized beams _ , hep - ph/9912377 ; + a.a .
babich et al . , _ contact interaction probes at the linear collider with polarized electron and positron beams _ , phys .
lett * b481 * ( 2000 ) 263 ; + g.j .
gounaris , c.g .
papadopoulos , _ studying trilinear gauge couplings at linear collider energies _ , eur .
phys j. * c2 * ( 1998 ) 365 ; + m. woods , _ polarimetry at a future linear collider - how precise ?
_ , slac - pub-8397 , hep - ex/0004004 .
m. swartz et al . , _ observation of target electron momentum effects in single - arm mller polarimetry _ , nucl .
inst . and meth .
* a363 * ( 1995 ) 526 .
p. steiner , a. feltham , i. sick et al .
, _ a high - rate coincidence mller polarimeter _ ,
inst . and meth .
* a419 * ( 1998 ) 105 .
m. hauger et al .
, _ a high - precision polarimeter _ , nucl - ex/9910013 .
spin muon collab . , _ measurement of the smc muon beam polarisation using the asymmetry in the elastic scattering of polarised electrons _ , + cern - ep-99 - 090 , sub . to nucl .
; + e. burtin , _ mesure de la polarisation dun faisceau de muons de 190 gev par diffusion sur une cible delectrons polarises , _ ph .
d. thesis , university paris xi , orsay , ( 1996 ) .
deraad jr . and
ng , _ electron - electron scattering .
helicity cross sections for electron - electron scattering _ , phys .
* d11 * ( 1975 ) 1586 .
s. jadach and b.f.l .
ward , _ multiple photon monte carlo simulation for polarized mller scattering with yennie - fraustchi - suura exponentiation at high energies _ , phys .
* d54 * ( 1996 ) 743 .
levchuk , _ the intra - atomic motion of bound electrons as a possible source of the systematic error in electron beam polarization measurements by means of a mller polarimeter _ , nucl .
inst . and meth .
* a345 * ( 1994 ) 496 .
a. afanasev and a. glamazdin , _ atomic electron motion for mller polarimetry in a double - arm mode _ , cebaf - pr-96 - 003 , hep - ex/9602002 .
particle data group , _ review of particle physics _ ,
j. * c15 * ( 2000 ) 164 .
see e.g. , h. stcker , _ taschenbuch der physik _
, 3 . , auflage , ( verlag harri deutsch ) , 1998 , section 22.10 .
+ u. grigull and h. sandner , _ heat conduction _ ,
( international series in heat and mass transfer ) . c. kittel , _ introduction to solid state physics _ , 6th edition , ( john wiley @xmath239 sons inc . )
desy - proc-99 - 03 . .[mol - param ] some relevant parameters of a mller polarimeter designed for a 250 gev electron beam operated at centre of mass angle @xmath240 i.e. , at its maximum analysing power . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] | the general features of the mller scattering and its use as an electron polarimeter are described and studied in view of the planned future high energy @xmath0 linear colliders .
in particular the study concentrates on the tesla collider which is envisaged to operate with longitudinal polarised beams at a centre of mass energy of the order of 0.5 tev with a luminosity of about @xmath1 = @xmath2 . *
desy 00 - 118 * + * mller scattering polarimetry + * for + high energy @xmath3 linear colliders + gideon alexander@xmath4 + institut fr physik + humboldt - universitt zu berlin , germany + 11015 berlin , germany + and + iuliana cohen school of physics and astronomy + raymond and beverly sackler faculty of exact sciences + tel - aviv university , tel - aviv 69978 , israel + |
the process of phase separation in chemically reactive mixtures has been considered by several authors .
et al _ @xcite and christensen _ et al _
@xcite used a modification of the cahn - hilliard equation to investigate the effects of a linear reaction of the type @xmath0 occurring simultaneously with phase separation following an instantaneous quench .
in contrast to phase separation alone , domain coarsening was halted at a length - scale dependent on system parameters resulting in the ` freezing in ' of a spatially heterogeneous pattern .
it was recognized that the steady - states resulted from competition between the demixing effects of phase separation and the equivalence of the chemical reaction term to an effective long - range repulsion @xcite .
similar physics is seen in the phase ordering of block copolymers where an effective long - range interaction arises because of an interplay between interactions and steric constraints @xcite .
in such systems pattern formation is a result of thermodynamic equilibrium .
by contrast , in the systems we consider , the steady - states are maintained dynamically by the interplay of reaction and diffusion .
a number of chemically and structurally more complicated systems have been considered , numerically and theoretically , within the same framework of a modified cahn - hilliard equation .
these include ternary mixtures @xcite and systems with orientational order @xcite . here
we investigate the effect of hydrodynamic interactions on phase ordering in a binary fluid mixture with chemical reactions using a lattice boltzmann method . the case of the linear reaction
has been considered before by hou _
et al _ @xcite by a different numerical method .
we duplicate some of their results as a means of testing our approach and then consider the quadratic reaction mechanism @xmath1 .
the inclusion of hydrodynamics is known to strongly affect the way in which an unreactive fluid mixture coarsens in the aftermath of a quench @xcite .
the growth exponent is found to increase from @xmath2 , for the purely diffusive case , to @xmath3 or @xmath4 for the viscous and inertial hydrodynamic regimes respectively . the new pathway for growth provided by hydrodynamics is transport of the bulk fluid down a pressure gradient established by variations in curvature @xcite . in two dimensions this minimises curvature by making domains circular , whereupon the effect vanishes and further coarsening can only occur by diffusion @xcite .
in addition there is the possibility , investigated by tanaka @xcite , that the rapid decrease in interfacial area resulting from the hydrodynamic mechanism may leave the bulk phases unequilibrated and subject to a round of secondary phase separations .
this suggests that coupling a modified cahn - hilliard equation to the navier - stokes equations for fluid flow may uncover behaviour different to that observed for the purely diffusive case .
experimental work @xcite-@xcite has shown that a variety of mesoscopic structures can be formed when chemical reactions are photo - induced in phase separating polymer mixtures .
the effects of two kinds of photo - chemistry have been considered : intermolecular photodimerisations @xcite and intramolecular photoisomerisation @xcite .
both give rise to a long - range inhibition which prevents phase separation proceeding beyond a certain domain size . in the first case
the inhibition is due to the formation of a network of cross - linked polymer molecules whereas in the second case it arises from the differing chemical properties of the two isomers .
the similarities in the patterns formed due to phase separation arrest in simple fluids and in reactive polymer blends suggest the latter may be approached by considering first a small - molecule system . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : modelsection ] we present a model of a chemically reactive binary fluid which couples the processes of reaction and diffusion to flow .
we then outline the linear theory of pattern formation in the absence of hydrodynamic effects . in section [ sec : latticeboltzmethod ] we construct a lattice boltzmann scheme which solves the equations of motion of section [ sec : modelsection ] in the continuum limit . in sections [ sec :
linearreact ] and [ sec : quadreact ] results are presented for the evolution of both high and low viscosity systems after a critical quench for a linear and a quadratic reaction mechanism respectively . for the reaction of type @xmath0 , comparison is made with the results of @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
in this section we summarize a model which describes the phase behavior and hydrodynamics of a two - component fluid . labeling the components @xmath5 and @xmath6
, we choose a description of the fluid in terms of the following variables : the total density , @xmath7 ; the total momentum , @xmath8 , and a compositional order - parameter , @xmath9 .
the composition of the fluid evolves according to a modified version of the cahn - hilliard equation which includes the effects of chemical reaction ; advection of the order - parameter by the flow - field , * u * , and diffusion in response to gradients in chemical potential : @xmath10 here @xmath11 is a mobility constant and @xmath12 , which depends on the reaction rate constants , is the change in @xmath13 per unit time due to chemical reactions .
the chemical potential of the system , @xmath14 , is given by the functional derivative of the free energy , @xmath15 , with respect to @xmath13 .
we choose a free energy @xmath16(t ) = \int d{\bf x}\left(\frac{\varepsilon}{2}\phi^{2}+\frac{\gamma}{4}\phi^{4}+\frac{\kappa}{2}(\nabla\phi)^{2 } + t\rho\ln~\rho \right).\ ] ] @xmath17 is taken to be greater than zero for stability and the sign of @xmath18 determines whether the polynomial contribution to the free - energy density has one or two minima , and hence whether the fluid is above ( @xmath19 ) or below ( @xmath20 ) its critical temperature . for @xmath20
the mixture will separate into two bulk components separated by a narrow , but smooth , interface .
the gradient - squared term in @xmath13 associates an energy cost with variations in composition and the parameter @xmath21 is related to the surface tension and governs the width of the interface between the two phases .
the parameter @xmath22 appears in the isotropic part of the pressure tensor and is related to the degree of incompressibility of the fluid @xcite .
a suitable choice is @xmath23 .
we consider two types of reactive source term , @xmath12 . a linear source @xmath24 = \rho ( \gamma_{2 } - \gamma_{1 } ) - \phi ( \gamma_{1 } + \gamma_{2}),\ ] ] corresponding to the reversible chemical reaction @xmath25 . and a quadratic source @xmath26 = \frac{1}{2 } ( \gamma_{1 } + \gamma_{2 } ) ( \phi - \rho ) \left ( \phi - \frac{(\gamma_{2}-\gamma_{1})\rho}{\gamma_{1 } + \gamma_{2 } } \right),\ ] ] corresponding to the reversible chemical reaction @xmath1 .
the constants @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the rates of the forward and backward reactions respectively .
we note that , for a spatially homogeneous system , the linear mechanism has a single stable fixed point whereas the quadratic mechanism has a stable fixed point at @xmath29 and an unstable one at @xmath30 . here
we consider only cases where @xmath31 .
the velocity field obeys a navier - stokes equation , @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the pressure tensor , @xmath34 is the viscosity and @xmath35 is the viscous stress tensor .
the pressure tensor is derived from the free - energy : @xmath36 this provides a further coupling between the evolution of @xmath13 and @xmath37 in addition to the advection term in ( [ eq : rda ] ) . from ( [ eq : pressurerelation ] ) and ( [ eq : freeenergy ] ) it follows that @xmath38 \delta_{\alpha\beta } + \kappa \partial_{\alpha}{\phi } \partial_{\beta}{\phi},\ ] ] where @xmath39 denotes the polynomial contribution to the free - energy density .
the total mass density of the fluid @xmath40 is also conserved and obeys @xmath41 linear stability analysis of the reaction - diffusion equation ( [ eq : rda ] ) with @xmath42 and source term ( [ eq : linearsource ] ) shows that only those modes , @xmath43 , with @xmath44 are unstable , where @xmath45 and @xmath46 depend on the parameters @xmath18 , @xmath17 and @xmath11 in equation ( [ eq : rda ] ) @xcite .
this is in contrast to spinodal decomposition ( the case @xmath47 ) where only short - wavelength modes are stable .
the damping of long - wavelength modes in the reactive case prevents continued growth of domains .
instead , phase separation is halted at some length - scale set by the reaction .
in addition , there is a threshold value of @xmath48 , @xmath49 above which the reaction is strong enough to completely inhibit phase separation by rendering all linear modes stable .
we also note , following @xcite and @xcite , that there is an equivalence between this behaviour and phase ordering in a system with competing short and long - range interactions .
the equivalence can be demonstrated by incorporating the reactive source into an effective free - energy for the system where it appears as a non - local term .
formally , we rewrite ( 1 ) as @xmath50,\ ] ] where @xmath51 and @xmath52 is the green s function of the laplace operator .
the reaction is then seen to act as an effective long - range , intra - species repulsion , with strength governed by @xmath48 , in contrast to the short - range attraction of like - molecules which drives phase separation . for the case of equal forward and backward rates ,
the linearised behaviour of the quadratic source ( [ eq : quadsource ] ) with reaction rate @xmath48 is the same as for the linear source with reaction rate @xmath53 .
this can be seen from the linearisation of ( [ eq : rda ] ) with @xmath54 and source term ( [ eq : quadsource ] ) .
hence , at early times , the linear and quadratic cases segregate in the same way .
however , after the formation of separate a and b - rich regions , non - linear contributions to the source term become important and this is expected to lead to growth of the a - rich phases at the expense of the b - rich ones .
this follows from the asymmetry of @xmath12 between the two phases : in the a - rich phase the production of b is limited by the amount of b already present .
hence it is limited by the _ minority _ component of the fluid in these regions . in the b - rich regions
the production of a is limited by the amount of the majority phase present .
therefore production of a in the b - rich phase is the more rapid process .
the lattice boltzmann method is a well - established numerical technique for hydrodynamic problems @xcite .
initially it was a kinetic - theory based method for the simulation of isothermal ideal flows which was introduced to circumvent some of the problems which rendered its predecessor , lattice - gas cellular automata , impractical .
however , it has since been modified and applied to a variety of problems in the simulation of complex fluids .
examples include binary fluids @xcite , liquid - gas systems @xcite , liquid - crystals @xcite and colloidal suspensions @xcite .
a lattice boltzmann scheme for the simulation of two or more species undergoing reaction and diffusion in a moving , viscous solvent was formulated by dawson _
et al _ @xcite .
in comparision , our model incorporates the thermodynamics of the multi - component fluid via the cahn - hilliard equation . to simulate the binary fluid model described in section [ sec : modelsection ] we utilise the free - energy lattice boltzmann method of swift _ et al _ @xcite . to this end
we define two populations of dynamical variables @xmath55 and @xmath56 on the sites of a simple lattice in three - dimensions . on each site the variables @xmath57 and @xmath58 correspond to a velocity direction @xmath59 for @xmath60 .
the dynamical variables are referred to as distribution functions since their moments over the velocity set define the macroscopic physical quantities : @xmath61 the distribution functions on each site are updated in discrete time with a time - step @xmath62 . the velocities are chosen so that @xmath63 and , for all @xmath64 , @xmath65 lies between two lattice sites .
the choice of lattice and velocity set are subject to certain restrictions @xcite . for this work we used a face - centred cubic lattice in three dimensions with the set of fifteen velocities , @xmath66 , illustrated in figure [ fig : lattice ] . , and time - step , @xmath62 , are set to unity .
, width=226 ] the distribution functions @xmath57 and @xmath58 evolve according to @xmath67 , \\
\label{eq : evolg } g_{i}({\bf x}+\delta t { \bf e}_{i};t+\delta t ) = g_{i}({\bf x};t ) + \delta_{i}^{\tau_{g}}[g ] + f_{i } , \ ] ] where @xmath68 = - \frac{\delta t}{\tau } \left ( f_{i}({\bf x};t ) - f_{i}^{eq}({\bf x};t ) \right),\ ] ] and the relaxation times @xmath69 and @xmath70 are free parameters
. equations ( [ eq : evolf ] ) and ( [ eq : evolg ] ) are both lattice equivalents of the bhatnager - gross - krook ( bgk ) , or single relaxation time , approximation to the full continuum boltzmann equation @xcite . we now need to specify the local equilibria functions @xmath71 and @xmath72 and the forcing term @xmath73 .
@xmath74 and @xmath75 are taken to be series expansions in the velocity @xmath76 the coefficients in ( [ eq : fequil ] ) and ( [ eq : gequil ] ) are chosen so the moments of the equilibrium distributions satisfy @xmath77 in addition , the lattice forcing term is chosen to obey @xmath78 , \;\;\ ; \sum_{i=0}^{n } e_{i\alpha } f_{i } = 0.\end{gathered}\ ] ] one possible choice of the coefficients , such that constraints ( [ eq : fmoments])-([eq : fmoments ] ) hold , is given by @xmath79 , \\ e_{1 - 6}^{\alpha\beta } = 8e_{7}^{\alpha\beta } , \\
h_{1 - 14 } = \frac{1}{10}d\mu,\;\;\ ; h_{0 } = \phi - 14h_{1 } , \\
j_{7 - 14 } = \phi/24,\;\;\ ; j_{1 - 6 } = 8j_{7 } , \\
k_{7 - 14 } = -\phi/24,\;\;\ ; k_{0 } = 16k_{7 } , \;\;\ ; k_{1 - 6 } = 2k_{7 } , \\
q_{7 - 14 } = \phi/16,\;\;\ ; q_{1 - 6 } = 8q_{7 } \\
f_{0 } = \delta t\frac{1}{2}j,\;\;\ ; f_{1 - 6 } = \delta t\frac{1}{24}j,\;\;\ ; f_{7 - 14 } = \delta t\frac{1}{32}j.\end{gathered}\ ] ] the constraints ( [ eq : fmoments])-([eq : fmoments ] ) ensure that , on length and time - scales large compared to the lattice - spacing and time - step , the evolution of the moments ( [ eq : moments ] ) satisfies the partial differential equations set out in section [ subsec : eqnmotion ] . to check that this is indeed the case the task of reducing the description of the dynamics in terms the distribution functions to one in terms of their moments
must be addressed .
the reduction can be performed by a chapman - enzkog expansion of equations ( [ eq : evolf ] ) and ( [ eq : evolg ] ) . since the details of this are essentially no different to those found in @xcite we present only the result here .
the zeroth moment of the @xmath57 satisfies equation ( [ eq : consmass ] ) for conservation of mass .
the first moment of the @xmath57 satisfies the navier - stokes equation ( [ eq : ns ] ) with @xmath80 and @xmath81 where the @xmath82 denotes unwanted error terms @xcite .
the first moment of the @xmath58 satisfies the reaction - diffusion - advection equation @xmath83 + \omega_{g}\partial_{\alpha } \left ( u_{\alpha } j \right ) + j[\phi ] , \label{eq : rda2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath84 and @xmath85 is defined in ( [ eq : secondgmoments ] ) .
equation ( [ eq : rda2 ] ) corresponds to equation ( [ eq : rda ] ) with mobility @xmath86 but with two extra terms .
the term in gradients of the components of the pressure tensor is present in some other free - energy lattice boltzmann methods and has been shown numerically to be small in comparison to the desired terms @xcite .
the term in gradients of the reactive source can be seen , to first order in @xmath13 , to be a correction to the advecting velocity of order @xmath87 . for our choices of parameters , this contribution is small in the low viscosity regime where the advecting flow field is important .
this completes the specification of our lattice boltzmann method .
although the model is inherently three - dimensional , we consider only its restriction to two dimensions . as an initial condition we choose the total density of the fluid @xmath88 at each lattice lattice .
the near - incompressibility of the fluid ensures that this value remains approximately the same at later times . to imitate the conditions following a rapid cooling of a fluid from above to below its critical temperature we initialise @xmath89 where @xmath90 is random noise with @xmath91 .
the parameters @xmath18 and @xmath17 in the free - energy are chosen so that in the unreactive case the fluid phase separates into regions where @xmath92 .
we choose @xmath93 to ensure a narrow interface and choose @xmath94 and @xmath95 which fixes the diffusion constant @xmath96 .
we also choose @xmath97 and the system size @xmath98 , throughout .
the viscosity of the fluid is controlled by varying the relaxation time @xmath69 . for @xmath99 , domains in the unreactive fluid grow as @xmath100 and the fluid can be taken to be in the diffusive regime where hydrodynamic flows are negligible . to ensure a hydrodynamic growth exponent of @xmath101 we choose @xmath102 .
we consider first the case of the linear reaction mechanism ( [ eq : linearsource ] ) .
figure [ fig : lsteadystates ] [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] the evolution of the inverse interfacial length for different values of @xmath48 and @xmath34 .
it can be seen that when hydrodynamic effects are present the rate of reduction of interfacial length is faster .
moreover , @xmath103 is no longer monotonically increasing : it attains a maximum due to the creation of more interface during secondary phase separation events .
in conclusion , we have extended the lattice boltzmann method to study the effect of hydrodynamics on structures arising in phase - separating reactive mixtures for two simple reaction mechanisms .
we have found that hydrodynamic flow significantly alters both the way in which the domain structure in these fluids evolves and the eventual steady states of the system .
the results obtained for the linear reaction are in agreement with previous work on the subject . for a quadratic reaction
an asymmetric domain structure was obtained , with the inclusion of hydrodynamic effects leading to secondary phase separation within majority phase .
it would be interesting to extend the model to incorporate viscoelastic effects arising from constituent molecules with internal microstructure : one can envisage chemical processes which can change the local microstructural elements .
the technique also makes feasible a study of the interaction of reaction and diffusion with imposed flow - fields .
we would like to thank c. pooley for intersting discussions .
k.f . acknowledges funding from eprsc grant no .
gr / r83712/01 .
glotzer , e.a .
di marzio and m. muthukumar , phys .
lett . * 74 * 2034 ( 1995 ) .
christensen , k. elder and h.c .
fogedby , phys .
e * 54 * r2212 ( 1996 ) .
s.c . glotzer and a. coniglio , phys .
e * 50 * 4241 ( 1994 ) .
l. leiber , marcomolecules * 13 * 1602 ( 1980 ) .
t. ohta and k. kawasaki , marcomolecules * 19 * 2621 ( 1986 ) .
t. okuzono and t. ohta , phys .
e * 67 * 056211 ( 2003 ) .
b. liu , c. tong and y. yang , j. phys .
b * 105 * 10091 ( 2001 ) . c. tong , h. zhang and y. yang , j. phys .
b * 106 * 7869 ( 2002 ) .
travasso , g.a .
buxton , o. kuksenok , k. good and a.c .
balazs , j. chem . phys .
* 122 * 194906 ( 2005 ) .
r. reigada , f. sagues and a.s .
mikhailov , phys .
lett . * 89 * 038301 ( 2002 ) ; r. reigada , a.s . mikhailov and f. sagues ,
e * 69 * 041103 ( 2004 ) .
a.j . wagner and j.m .
yeomans , phys .
* 80 * 1429 ( 1998 ) .
y. huo , x. jiang and y. yang , j. chem . phys . *
118 * 9830 ( 2003 ) ; macromol .
theory simul .
* 13 * 280 ( 2004 )
. q. tran - cong and a. harada , phys .
lett . * 76 * 1162 ( 1996 ) ; q. tran - cong , a. harada , k. kataoka , t. ohta and o. urakawa , phys .
e * 55 * r6340 ( 1997 ) ; qui tran - cong , katsunari kataoka and osamu urakawa , phys .
e * 57 * r1243 ( 1998 ) .
qui tran - cong , takashi ohta and osamu urakawa , phys .
e * 56 * r59 ( 1997 ) ; t. ohta , o. urakawa and q. tran - cong , macromolecules * 31 * 6845 ( 1998 ) .
q. tran - cong , j. kawai and k. endoh , chaos * 9 * 298 ( 1991 ) .
kendon , m.e .
cates , i. pagonanarraga , j - c .
desplat and p. bladon , j. fluid . mech . * 440 * 147 ( 2001 ) .
bray , adv . phys . * 43 * 357 ( 1994 ) .
siggia , phys .
a * 20 * 595 ( 1979 ) .
h. tanaka , phys .
e * 51 * 1313 ( 1995 ) .
cahn , j. chem .
phys . * 42 * 93 ( 1964 ) .
s. succi , _ the lattice boltzmann equation for fluid dynamics and beyond _ ( clarendon press , oxford , 2001 ) .
xiaowen shan and hudong chen , phys .
e * 47 * 1815 ( 1993 ) .
swift , e. orlandini , w.r .
osborn and j.m .
yeomans , phys .
e * 54 * 5041 ( 1996 ) .
luo and s.s .
girimaji , phys .
e * 67 * 036302 ( 2003 ) .
xiaowen shan and hudong chen , phys .
e * 49 * 2941 ( 1994 ) .
li - shi luo , phys .
lett . * 81 * 1618 ( 1998 ) .
s. pounce dawson , s. chen and g.d .
doolen , j. chem . phys . * 98 * 1514 ( 1992 ) . c. denniston , e. orlandini and j.m .
yeomans , europhys .
lett . * 52 * 481 ( 2000 ) .
ladd and r. verberg , j. stat .
phys . * 104 * 1191 ( 2001 ) . | we use a lattice boltzmann method to study pattern formation in chemically reactive binary fluids in the regime where hydrodynamic effects are important .
the coupled equations solved by the method are a cahn - hilliard equation , modified by the inclusion of a reactive source term , and the navier - stokes equations for conservation of mass and momentum .
the coupling is two - fold , resulting from the advection of the order - parameter by the velocity field and the effect of fluid composition on pressure .
we study the the evolution of the system following a critical quench for a linear and for a quadratic reaction source term .
comparison is made between the high and low viscosity regimes to identify the influence of hydrodynamic flows . in both cases
hydrodynamics is found to influence the pathways available for domain growth and the eventual steady - states . |
we consider a piece of cortex @xmath5 ( the _ neural field _ ) , which is a regular compact subset when representing locations on the cortex , or periodic domains such as the torus of dimension 1 @xmath6 in the case of the representation of the visual field , in which neurons code for a specific orientation in the visual stimulus : in that model , @xmath5 is considered to be the feature space @xcite . ] of @xmath7 for some @xmath8 , and the density of neurons on @xmath5 is given by a probability measure @xmath9 assumed to be absolutely continuous with respect to lebesgue s measure @xmath10 on @xmath5 , with strictly positive and bounded density @xmath11 $ ] . on @xmath5
, we consider a spatially extended network composed of @xmath12 neurons at random locations @xmath13 drawn independently with law @xmath14 in a probability space @xmath15 , and we will denote by @xmath16 the expectation with respect to this probability space . a given neuron @xmath17 projects local connections in its neighborhood @xmath18 , and long - range connections over the whole neural field .
we will consider here that the local microcircuit connectivity consists of a fully connected graph with @xmath1 nearest - neighbors .
the synaptic weights corresponding to these connections are assumed equal to @xmath19 where @xmath20 ( it is generally positive since local interactions in the cortex tend to be excitatory ) .
a central example is the case @xmath21 with @xmath22 . with zero probability
, it may occur for a given neuron @xmath23 that its local microcircuit @xmath18 is not well defined .
this occurs if there exists @xmath24 such that the number of neurons at distance strictly smaller than @xmath25 of neuron @xmath23 , denoted @xmath26 , is strictly smaller than @xmath0 and the number of neurons at a distance smaller or equal to @xmath25 is strictly larger than @xmath0 , meaning in particular that there exists several neurons at distance precisely @xmath25 .
this event has a null probability , @xmath18 is defined as the union of all neurons at distance strictly smaller than @xmath25 , completed by @xmath27 neurons randomly chosen among those at distance exactly @xmath25 of neuron @xmath23 .
the neurons also send non - local connections which are specific ( i.e. depend on the type of neurons , indexed here by the spatial location ) , which are much sparser than the local microcircuit .
we will consider that the macro - connections are random variables @xmath28 drawn in @xmath15 and frozen during the evolution of the network , with law : @xmath29 where @xmath30 is a bernoulli random variable with parameter @xmath31 @xmath32 the coefficient @xmath33 governs the connectivity weight between neurons at location @xmath34 and @xmath35 .
for instance , in the visual cortex , if the neurons of the cortical column at location @xmath34 codes for the collinear ( resp , orthogonal ) orientation as neurons in the column at @xmath35 , @xmath33 is positive ( negative ) .
these coefficients are assumed to be smooth ( see assumption [ assump : spacecontinuity ] ) and bounded , and we denote : @xmath36 the scaling coefficient @xmath37 corresponds to the total incoming connections from the microcircuit related to neuron @xmath38 .
the parameter @xmath31 accounts for the connectivity level of the macrocircuit .
in particular , if populations are not connected , we will set @xmath39 . in that sense , the function @xmath31 does not account for all absent links in the network , but rather for the sparsity of the macro - circuit .
motivated by the fact that the macro - circuit is very sparse and that micro - circuits form non - trivial patches of connectivity , we will assume that , when @xmath40 , @xmath41 the hypothesis on the connectivity ensure the following facts , desirable for a modeling at the neural field scale ( see fig .
[ fig : neurons ] ) : * the local micro - circuit shrinks to a single point in the limit @xmath40 ( see lemma [ lem : sizemicro ] ) , and * the macro - circuit is sparse at the level of single cells ( @xmath42 ) , but non - sparse at the level of cortical columns ( @xmath43 ) . note that in all our developments , one only needs the assumption that @xmath44 as @xmath45 .
this is of course a consequence of our current assumption .
a schematic topology usually considered could be the 2-dimensional regular lattice @xmath46 approximating the unit square @xmath47 ^ 2 $ ] with @xmath48 points . in this model ,
typical micro - circuit size could be chosen to be @xmath49 with @xmath22 , and @xmath31 of order @xmath50 with @xmath51 .
our model takes into account the fact that in reality , neurons are not regularly placed on the cortex , and therefore such a regular lattice case is extremely unlikely to arise ( this architecture has probability zero ) .
moreover , in contrast with this more artificial example , the probability distribution of the location of one given neuron do not depend on the network size . in our setting ,
@xmath14 accounts for the density of neurons on the cortex , and as the network size is increased , new neurons are added on the neural field at locations independent of that of other neurons , with the same probability @xmath14 , so that neuron locations sample the asymptotic cell density .
these elements describe the random topology of the network .
prior to the evolution , a number of neurons @xmath12 and a configuration @xmath52 is drawn in the probability space @xmath15 .
the configuration of the network provides : * the locations of the neurons @xmath53 i.i.d . with law
@xmath14 * the connectivity weights , in particular the values of the i.i.d .
bernoulli variables @xmath54 of parameter @xmath31 .
let us start by analyzing the topology of the micro - circuit .
at the macroscopic scale , we expect local micro - circuits to shrink to a single point in space , which would precisely correspond to the scale at which imaging techniques record the activity of the brain ( a pixel in the image ) .
the micro - circuit connects a neuron to its @xmath0 nearest neighbors .
we made the assumptions that @xmath0 tends to infinity as @xmath40 while keeping @xmath1 .
this property ensures that for a fixed neuron @xmath55 and for any @xmath56 , the distance and @xmath57 , @xmath58 the euclidean norm of @xmath59 , regardless of the space involved and the dimension @xmath60 considered . ]
@xmath61 is , with overwhelming probability , upperbounded by a constant multiplied by @xmath62 . in the regular lattice case ,
this property is trivial . in our random setting
, we introduce the maximal distance between two neurons in the microcircuit associated to neuron @xmath23 is noted : @xmath63 this quantity has a law that is independent of the specific neuron @xmath23 chosen . [
lem : sizemicro ] the microcircuit shrinks to a single point in space as @xmath12 to infinity .
more precisely , for any @xmath17 , the maximal distance @xmath64 between two neurons in the microcircuit associated to neuron @xmath23 decreases towards @xmath65 , in the sense that there exists @xmath66 such that the maximal distance between two points in a microcircuit satisfies the inequality : @xmath67 \leq c \left(\left(\frac{v(n)}{n}\right)^{\frac 1 d } + \frac{1}{v(n)}\right).\ ] ] we have assumed that the locations @xmath34 are iid with law @xmath14 absolutely continuous with respect to lebesgue s measure with density lowerbounded by some positive quantity @xmath68 .
let us fix a neuron @xmath23 at location @xmath34 which is almost surely in the interior of @xmath5 .
we are interested in the distances between different neurons within the microcircuit around @xmath23 , and will therefore consider the distribution of relative locations of neurons belonging to @xmath18 conditionally to the location @xmath34 of neuron @xmath23 .
we will denote @xmath69 the expectation under this conditioning .
it is clear that the set of random variables @xmath70 are identically distributed .
moreover , these are independent conditionally on the value of @xmath34 .
we will show that , for any neuron @xmath71 , the distance @xmath72 tends to zero as @xmath12 increases with probability one . to this end
, we use the characterization of the maximal distance @xmath73 as the minimal radius @xmath74 such that the ball centered at @xmath34 with diameter @xmath74 contains @xmath0 points : @xmath75 we will show that there exists a quantity @xmath76 tending to zero such that @xmath77 with large probability , i.e. @xmath78 . to this end , we start by noting that conditionally on @xmath34 , the random variables @xmath79 are independent , identically distributed
. moreover , for @xmath34 fixed , there exists @xmath80 such that for any @xmath81 , @xmath82 .
therefore , for @xmath81 , the random variables @xmath83 are such that : @xmath84}=\int_{b(r_i,\alpha(n ) ) } d\lambda(r)\in [ \lambda_{min},\lambda_{max}]\times \gamma(n)\\ \text{var}_i(z_j^n ) = { \mathcal{e}}_i{[z_j^n ] } - { \mathcal{e}}_i{[z_j^n]}^2 \in [ \lambda_{\min } - \lambda_{\max } \gamma(n),\lambda_{\max}-\lambda_{\min } \gamma(n ) ] \times \gamma(n ) \end{cases}\ ] ] where @xmath85\times c = [ ac , bc]$ ] and @xmath86 with @xmath87 the volume of the unit ball in @xmath7 . the radius @xmath76 is chosen such that : @xmath88 with @xmath89 .
this assumption implies that @xmath90\geq \eta^d \frac{v(n)}{n}\ ] ] we have : @xmath91}= \frac 1 { v(n)}\sum_{j=1}^n ( z_j^n-{\mathcal{e}}_{i}{[z_j^n ] } ) .\ ] ] which tends to zero in probability , since ( we recall that the variance is of order @xmath92 for @xmath12 large ) @xmath93}\right)\right)^2\right ] = \frac n { v^2(n ) } \text{var}_i(z_j^n ) = o \left(\frac 1 { v(n)}\right ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the quantity @xmath94 is therefore lowerbounded , with overwhelming probability , by @xmath95 which is , under our assumption on @xmath96 , is greater than @xmath97 for @xmath12 large enough : with overwhelming probability , for large @xmath12 , the microcircuit is fully included in the ball of radius @xmath76 .
we have assumed that the set @xmath5 is bounded .
let us denote by @xmath98 its diameter ( i.e. the maximal distance between two points in @xmath5 ) .
we have : @xmath99 & = { \mathcal{e}}_i[d^n_m(i ) \mathbbm{1}_{d^n_m(i)\leq 2\alpha(n ) } ] + { \mathcal{e}}_i[d^n_m(i ) \mathbbm{1}_{d^n_m(i ) > 2\alpha(n)}]\\ & \leq 2\alpha(n ) + d(\gamma){\mathcal{p}}_i\left[m_n(\alpha(n))<v(n ) \right]\\ & \leq 2\alpha(n ) + d(\gamma){\mathcal{p}}_i\left [ \left \vert \frac{m_n(\alpha(n))}{v(n)}-\frac{n}{v(n ) } { \mathcal{e}}_i{[z_j^n ] } \right\vert > \eta^d-1 \right]\\ & \leq 2\alpha(n ) + d(\gamma)\frac{{\mathcal{e}}_i { \left[\left(\frac 1 { v(n)}\sum_{j=1}^n \left(z_j^n-{\mathcal{e}}_i{[z_j^n]}\right)\right)^2\right]}}{(\eta^d-1)^2 } \\ & \leq c \left(\left(\frac{v(n)}{n})\right)^{\frac 1 d } + \frac{1}{v(n)}\right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] which ends the proof .
let us now introduce the dynamics of the neurons activity .
the state of each neuron @xmath23 in the network is described by a @xmath100-dimensional variable @xmath101 , typically corresponding to the membrane potential of the neuron and possibly additional variables such as those related to ionic concentrations and gated channels .
these variables have a stochastic dynamics . in order to deal with these stochastic evolutions ,
we introduce a new complete probability space @xmath102 endowed with a filtration @xmath103 satisfying the usual conditions , and we denote by @xmath104 the expectation with respect to this probability space . note that this space is distinct from the configuration space @xmath15 .
once a configuration @xmath52 is fixed for a @xmath12-neurons network , it is frozen and each neuron will have a random evolution following the equations : @xmath105 where @xmath106 governs the intrinsic dynamics of each cell , @xmath107 is a sequence of independent @xmath108 brownian motions of dimension @xmath109 modeling the external noise , @xmath110 a bounded and measurable function of @xmath111 modeling the level of noise at each space location , and @xmath112 the interaction function . the map @xmath113 is the interaction delay between neurons located at @xmath74 and those at @xmath114 which is assumed to be of the form : @xmath115 where @xmath116 is the synaptic transmission time and @xmath117 the transport time ( @xmath118 is the transmission speed assumed constant ) . since @xmath5 is bounded , all delays are bounded by a finite quantity @xmath119 ( in our notations , @xmath120 ) . in what follows , we will use the shorthand notation @xmath121 .
the parameters of the system are assumed to satisfy the following assumptions : 1 .
[ assump : loclipschspace ] @xmath122 is @xmath123-lipschitz - continuous with respect to all three variables , 2 .
[ assump : loclipschbspace ] @xmath124 is @xmath125-lipschitz - continuous with respect to both variables and bounded . we denote @xmath126 3 .
[ assump : lineargrowth ] the drift satisfies uniformly in space ( @xmath74 ) and time ( @xmath127 ) , the inequality : @xmath128 4 .
[ assump : spacecontinuity ] the drift , delay , diffusion and connectivity functions are regular with respect to the space variables @xmath129 ( we will assume for instance that these are all @xmath130-lipschitz continuous ) .
let us first state the following proposition ensuring well - posedness of the network system under the assumptions of the section : [ pro : existenceuniquenessnetwork ] let @xmath131}$ ] a square integrable process with values in @xmath132 .
under the current assumptions , for any configuration @xmath52 of the network , there exists a unique strong solution to the network equations with initial condition @xmath133 .
this solution is square integrable and defined for all times .
the proof of this proposition is classical .
it is a direct application of the general theory of sdes in infinite dimensions ( * ? ? ?
* chapter 7 ) , and elementary proof in our particular case of delayed stochastic differential equations can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 5.2.2 ) : for any fixed configuration , we have a regular @xmath12-dimensional sde with delays satisfying a monotone growth condition [ assump : lineargrowth ] ensuring a.s .
boundedness for all times of the solution .
the proof of this property is essentially based on the same arguments as those of the proof of theorem [ thm : existenceuniquenessspace ] , and the interested reader is invited to follow the steps of that demonstration .
it is important to note that the bound one obtains on the expectation of the squared process depends on the configuration of the network .
indeed , the macroscopic interaction term involves the sum of a random number of terms @xmath134 rescaled by @xmath135 .
the quantity @xmath136 can take large values ( up to @xmath12 ) with positive ( but small ) probability , and therefore the scaling coefficient is not enough to properly control such cases .
the bound obtained by classical methods will therefore diverge in @xmath12 , and this will be a deep question for our aim to prove convergence results as @xmath45 . in the present manuscript , we will be able to handle these terms properly in that limit by using fine estimates related to @xmath137 , see lemma [ lem : sumchi ] .
we are interested in the limit , as @xmath45 , of the behavior of the neurons .
since we are dealing with diffusions in random environment , there are at least two notions of convergence : _ quenched _ convergence results valid for almost all configuration @xmath138 , and _ annealed _ results valid for the law of the network averaged across all possible configurations . here
, we will show averaged convergence results as well as quenched properties along subsequences .
similarly to what was observed in @xcite , the limit of such spatially extended mean - field models will be stochastic processes indexed by the space variable , which , as a function of space , are not measurable with respect to the borel algebra @xmath139 . as noted in @xcite ,
this is not a mathematical artifact of the approach , since neurons accumulating on the neural field are driven by independent brownian motions , and therefore no regularity is to be expected in the limit . however , even if trajectories are highly irregular , this will not be the case of the law of these solutions . in order to handle this irregularity
, we will use the _ spatially chaotic _
brownian motion on @xmath5 , a two - parameter process @xmath140 such that for any fixed @xmath111 , the process @xmath141 is a @xmath109-dimensional standard brownian motion , and for @xmath142 in @xmath5 , the processes @xmath143 and @xmath144 are independent of _ spatially chaotic _ if the processes @xmath145 and @xmath146 are independent for any @xmath142 . ] .
this process is relatively singular seen as a spatio - temporal process : in particular , it is not measurable with respect to @xmath147 .
the spatially chaotic brownian motion is distinct from other more usual spatio - temporal processes . in particular
, its covariance is @xmath148}=(t\wedge t ' ) \delta_{r = r'}$ ] : the covariance is not measurable with respect to @xmath139 .
in contrast , the more classical space - time brownian motion ( the process corresponding to space - time white noise differential terms ) on the positive line ( @xmath149 ) has a covariance @xmath150 : it is continuous with respect to space . it is also distinct from wiener processes on hilbert spaces ( * ? ? ? * chapter 4.1 . ) ( a.k.a .
cylindrical brownian motions ) which have a covariance defined through a trace - class operator on the hilbert space , and may be decomposed as the sum of standard brownian motions on a basis of that hilbert space ( i.e. , there is a countable number of brownian motions involved ) . the chaotic brownian motion , due to his high singularity as a space - time process ,
is more suitably seen as an infinite collection of wiener processes .
we will show that the network equations satisfies the propagation of chaos property in the limit where @xmath12 goes to infinity , and that the state of the network converges towards a very particular mckean - vlasov equation involving a spatially chaotic brownian motion .
the propagation of chaos property ( boltzmann s molecular chaos hypothesis , or stozahlansatz ) states that , provided that the initial conditions of all neurons are independent , the law of any finite set of neurons converge to a product of laws ( loosely speaking , are asymptotically independent ) for all times ( see @xcite ) . in our network , this property means that the heuristic notion of boltzmann s stozahlansatz applies in that the dependence relationship between the state of , say 2 , fixed neurons in the network , dilute away in the thermodynamic limit , and these end up being independent in the large @xmath12 limit . in detail , for almost all configuration of the network , the asymptotic law of neurons located at @xmath74 in the support of @xmath14 will be measurable with respect to @xmath151 and converge towards the stochastic neural field mean - field equation with delays : @xmath152\,dt\\ + \int_{\gamma } j(r , r'){\mathbbm{e}}_{\bar{z}}[b(\bar{x}_t(r),\bar{z}_{t-\tau(r , r')}(r ' ) ) ] \ , d\lambda(r ' ) \,dt \end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath153 is a spatially chaotic brownian and the process @xmath154 is independent and has the same law as @xmath155 . in other words
, we will show that the law of the solution @xmath156 , noted @xmath157 , is measurable with respect to @xmath147 , and that the mean - field equation can be expressed as the integro - differential mckean - vlasov equation : @xmath158 let us eventually give the fokker - planck equation on the possible density @xmath159 of @xmath160 with respect to lebesgue s measure : @xmath161 .
\end{gathered}\ ] ] the mean - field equations are similar to those found in the setting of @xcite but present an additional term related to the presence of a micro - circuit , showing the local averaging effects arising in our setting .
interestingly , this shows a kind of universal behavior across all possible choices of parameters @xmath0 and @xmath31 , i.e. across possible local statistics of the topology .
the limit equations are very complex : similarly to what was discussed in @xcite , they resemble mckean - vlasov equations but involve delays , spatially chaotic brownian motions and an ` integral over spatial locations ' ( in a sense that will be made clearer in the sequel ) .
this is hence a very unusual stochastic equation we need to thoroughly study in order to ensure that these make sense and are well - posed .
the existence and uniqueness of solutions to this mean - field equation are addressed in section [ sec : existenceuniquenessspace ] , and the proof of the propagation of chaos and convergence of the network equations towards the solution of the mean - field equation is performed in section [ sec : propachaspace ] .
the mean - field equation involves two unusual terms : a stochastic integral involving spatially chaotic brownian motions and an integrated mckean - vlasov mean - field term with delays .
the spatially chaotic brownian motion was introduced in @xcite . in order to handle these equations , we start by introducing and discussing the functional spaces in which we are working , and the notion of solutions to these singular equations . first of all , in order to make sense of the mean - field equation , we need to show that the lebesgue s integral over @xmath5 term is well defined .
this integral involves the expectation of the process , so even though the solution is not measurable with respect to space , its expectation may be depending on the regularity of its law with respect to space . in this view
, we consider the set @xmath162 of spatially chaotic processes @xmath163 defined for times @xmath164 $ ] that have the following continuity property : there exists a _ coupled process _ @xmath165 indexed by @xmath111 , such that for any fixed @xmath111 , @xmath165 has the same law as @xmath156 , and moreover , there exists a constant @xmath66 such that for any @xmath166 : @xmath167}\left\vert \hat{x}_t(r)-\hat{x}_t(r')\right\vert \right]}\leq c ( \vert r - r'\vert + \sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert}).\ ] ] note that in this case , for any lipschitz - continuous function @xmath168 , the map @xmath169}$ ] is continuous ( hlder @xmath170 ) . in particular
, it is measurable .
one can then define the lebesgue s integral of it over @xmath5 .
such processes are called _ chaotic processes with regular law_. we note that in the absence of space - dependent delays , the process is more regular ( lipschitz - continuous ) .
moreover , stochastic processes @xmath171 are said square integrable for all @xmath111 if : @xmath172}<\infty.\ ] ] we further consider the subset @xmath173 composed of processes @xmath163 that satisfy the following regularity in time : there exists @xmath66 such that : @xmath174}\leq c ( \sqrt{\vert t - t'\vert } + \vert t - t'\vert).\ ] ] eventually , for a process @xmath175 , we define the squared norm : @xmath176}\vert{z_s({r})}\vert^2 \right]}\,d\lambda(r)\ ] ] and the @xmath177 norm : @xmath178}\vert{z_s({r})}\vert \right]}\,d\lambda(r).\ ] ] these clearly define norms on random variables indexed by @xmath111 , when identifying processes that are @xmath179-a.s .
we denote @xmath180 the set of of random variables in @xmath162 such that @xmath181 .
note that this norm depends on @xmath14 the distribution over @xmath5 of neurons .
it is of course possible to define a norm using lebesgue s measure on @xmath5 , which would be in that case independent of the choice of @xmath14 .
the two obtained measures will be of course equivalent since here we assumed that @xmath14 was equivalent to lebesgue s measure .
let us start by giving a simple yet informative example of such process .
let @xmath143 be a spatially chaotic brownian motion , and consider @xmath182 , r\in\gamma}$ ] a @xmath183-progressively measurable real - valued process indexed by @xmath184 that belongs to @xmath185 and which is independent of the collection of brownian motions @xmath186 .
we denote by @xmath187 the coupled process corresponding to the regularity condition .
we assume that for any @xmath188 we have @xmath189 } < c<\infty , \text { and}\\ { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \vert \hat{\delta}_t(r)-\hat{\delta}_t(r')\vert^2 \right]}\leq c^2 ( \vert r - r'\vert + \sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert})^2 \end{cases}\ ] ] since for any fixed @xmath111 , the process @xmath143 is a standard brownian motion , the process @xmath190 defined by the stochastic integral : @xmath191 is well defined .
it is spatially chaotic since for @xmath142 the brownian motions @xmath143 and @xmath144 and the processes @xmath192 and @xmath193 are independent .
moreover , they have a regular law in the sense of our definition .
indeed , let @xmath194 be a standard brownian motion independent of @xmath187 .
the process @xmath195 has the same law as @xmath190 , and moreover , @xmath196}\leq \left(\int_0^t { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \vert \hat{\delta}_s(r)-\hat{\delta}_s(r')\vert^2 \right]}\,ds\right)^{1/2}\leq \sqrt{t } c ( \vert r - r'\vert+\sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert}).\ ] ] the process @xmath190 therefore belongs to @xmath162 .
moreover , it is a square integrable martingale with quadratic variation @xmath197}\,ds$ ] .
this implies that for any @xmath198 in @xmath199 $ ] : @xmath200 } = { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \vert\int_t^{t ' } \delta_s(r ) dw_s(r)\vert \right]}\leq \left(\int_{t}^{t ' } { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \vert\delta_s(r)\vert^2 \right]}\,ds\right)^{1/2}\leq c \sqrt{t'-t}.\ ] ] the process therefore belongs to @xmath201 .
note that this example illustrates an important fact .
the process @xmath190 involves two processes , @xmath192 and @xmath143 , and in order to build up the coupled @xmath202 , we used the fact that we were able to find two processes @xmath187 and @xmath203 such that the pairs @xmath204 and @xmath205 had the same law ( here , the two components are independent ) .
this fact will be also prominent in the definition of the solutions to the mean - field equation .
[ def : solution ] a _ strong solution _ to the mean - field equation on the probability space @xmath206 , with respect to the chaotic brownian motion @xmath186 and with an initial condition @xmath207 is a spatially chaotic process @xmath208 , i.e. with continuous sample paths and regular law , such that : 1 .
there exists a coupling @xmath209 , r\in\gamma)$ ] , such that for any fixed @xmath184 @xmath210 and moreover : @xmath211}\left\vert \hat{\zeta}^0_t(r)-\hat{\zeta}^0_t(r')\right\vert \right]}\leq c ( \vert r - r'\vert + \sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert}),\\ { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \sup_{t\in [ -\tau,0]}\left\vert \hat{x}_t(r)-\hat{x}_t(r')\right\vert \right]}\leq c ( \vert r - r'\vert + \sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert } ) .
\end{cases}\ ] ] this regularity ensures that for any lipschitz - continuous map @xmath212 , the map @xmath213}$ ] is continuous . in particular , it is measurable and hence the integral @xmath214}d\lambda(r)$ ] can be computed in the usual ( lebesgue s ) sense .
2 . for any @xmath184 ,
@xmath215)$ ] is a strong solution , in the usual sense ( see ( * ? ? ?
* defintion 5.2.1 ) ) , i.e. it is adapted to the filtration @xmath216 , almost surely equal to @xmath217 for @xmath218 $ ] , and the equality : @xmath219 \,ds\\ \quad+ \int_0^t \int_{\gamma
} j(r , r'){\mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ b(x_s(r ) , z_{s-\tau(r , r ' ) } ( r ' ) ) ] d\lambda(r')\,ds ,
\qquad t>0\\ \zeta^0_t(r ) , \qquad t\in [ -\tau , 0]\\ ( z_t)\operatorname{\stackrel{\mathcal{l}}{=}}(x_t ) \text { independent of $ ( x_t)$ and $ ( w_t(\cdot))$ } \end{cases}\ ] ] holds almost surely .
[ thm : existenceuniquenessspace ] let @xmath220,\ ; r\in\gamma ) \in \mathcal{z}_{0}^2 $ ] a square - integrable process with a regular law . the mean - field equation with initial condition @xmath221 has a unique strong solution on @xmath222 $ ] for any @xmath223 .
the solution belongs to @xmath224 .
this theorem is proved through a usual fixed point argument for a map @xmath225 acting on stochastic processes @xmath226 in @xmath180 defined by : @xmath227 \,ds\\ \quad+ \int_0^t \int_{\gamma } j(r , r'){\mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ b(x_s(r ) , z_{s-\tau(r , r ' ) } ( r ' ) ) ] d\lambda(r')\,ds , \qquad t>0\\ \zeta^0_t(r ) \qquad , \qquad t\in [ -\tau , 0]\\ ( z_t)\operatorname{\stackrel{\mathcal{l}}{=}}(x_t ) \text { independent of $ ( x_t)$ and $ ( w_t(\cdot))$ } \end{cases } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we aim at building a sequence of processes by iterating the map @xmath225 starting from a given initial process , and showing that this constitutes a cauchy sequence , converging to the unique fixed point of the map , i.e. the unique solution of the mean - field equations .
this classical scheme appears relatively complex to handle in our present case .
indeed , the construction of the sequence is not trivial , as we need to be able to integrate the expectation of a function of the processes , hence we need this expectation to be measurable with respect to space .
second is the fact that we aim at showing existence and uniqueness in a relatively strong sense ( condition ( ii ) of the definition ) valid for any @xmath111 ( and not @xmath14-almost surely as would be the case under the norm ) .
let us start by showing that we can iterate the map @xmath225 . to this end
, we analyze the processes @xmath228 , image of processes @xmath229 under the map @xmath225 .
it is easy to see that @xmath230 is spatially chaotic .
let us start by showing that @xmath230 is square integrable ( in what follows , @xmath231 denotes a constant independent of time , that may vary from line to line ) .
we note that : @xmath232 + \int_{\gamma } j(r , r ' ) { \mathbbm{e}}_z[b(x , z_{s-\tau(r , r')})]d\lambda(r')\ ] ] is lipschitz - continuous with respect to @xmath233 ( with constant @xmath234 ) , and hence @xmath235 .
standard inequalities allow showing that the value @xmath236 } \vert y_s(r)\vert^2 \right]}$ ] satisfies the relationship : @xmath237 } \vert \zeta^0_s(r)\vert^2 \right ] } + t \,c\int_0^t ( 1+n_s^x(r))\,ds
+ 4\,t \vert\sigma(r)\vert^2 \bigg ) \ ] ] which is finite under the assumption that @xmath156 and @xmath221 are square integrable .
note that this property readily implies , by application of gronwall s lemma , that any possible solution is square integrable .
the regularity in time is then a direct consequence of this inequality and of the fact that the lipschitz continuity of @xmath238 implies that @xmath239 . indeed , for @xmath198 , we have @xmath240 } & \leq \int_{t}^{t ' } { \mathbbm{e}\left
[ \vert \psi(r , s , x_s(r))\vert \right ] } ds + { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \vert \sigma(r ) ( w_{t'}(r)-w_t(r))\vert \right]}\\ & \leq c ( 1+n_t^x(r)^{1/2 } ) ( t'-t ) + \vert \sigma(r)\vert \sqrt{t'-t}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] it therefore remains to show that @xmath230 is regular in law .
let @xmath203 be a standard brownian motion , and assume that @xmath241 is a coupling of @xmath242 in the sense that they are equal in law for any fixed @xmath74 , and that both @xmath165 and @xmath243 have the regularity property ( @xmath226 is a process satisfying the assumptions of definition [ def : solution ] ) .
we define @xmath244 as : @xmath245 \,ds\\ + \int_0^t \int_{\gamma } j(r , u){\mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ b(\hat{x}_s(r ) , z_{s-\tau(r , u ) } ( u ) ) ] d\lambda(u)\,ds \end{gathered}\ ] ] it is clear that this process has the same law as @xmath230 since @xmath246 , and this obviously also holds for the processes @xmath247 and @xmath248 .
let us denote @xmath249 } \vert \hat{x}_s(r)-\hat{x}_s(r')\vert \right]}$ ] .
we have : @xmath250 } \int_0^s \bigg\{k_f(\vert r - r'\vert + \vert \hat{x}_u(r)-\hat{x}_u(r')\vert ) + \vert \bar{j}\vert l \big(\vert \hat{x}_u(r)-\hat{x}_u(r')\vert \\ & + d_{u-\tau_s } \big)+ k_{\gamma } ( 1+\vert b\vert_{\infty})\vert r - r'\vert + \vert j\vert_{\infty } l \vert \hat{x}_u(r)-\hat{x}_u(r')\vert + \int_{\gamma } \mathbbm{e}[\vert \hat{x}_{u-\tau_s(r , v)}(v)-\hat{x}_{u-\tau_s(r',v)}(v)]d\lambda(v)\bigg\}\,du\bigg]\\ & \leq \big(c+t ( k_{\gamma}(1+\vert b\vert_{\infty})+k_f)\big ) \vert r - r'\vert + c\big(1+t\sqrt{k_{\gamma}}\vert j\vert_{\infty } l \big)\sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert } + \int_0^t
\big(k_f + 2\vert\bar{j}\vert l + \vert j\vert_{\infty}\big ) d_s^x\,ds \end{aligned}\ ] ] and we conclude , using the assumption that @xmath251 , on the regularity of the law of the process @xmath244 . in particular ,
let us emphasize the fact that for any @xmath252 a @xmath97-lipschitz - continuous function , @xmath253 } \vert { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \varphi(x_t(r))-\varphi(x_t(r ' ) ) \right ] } \vert\leq c \big(\vert r - r'\vert + \sqrt{\vert r - r'\vert}\big),\ ] ] which implies that the expectation @xmath254 $ ] is measurable with respect to the borel algebra @xmath139 in @xmath114 , allowing to make sense of the integral over the space variable @xmath114 .
let us eventually remark that , again , by gronwall s lemma , any possible solution has a coupled process satisfying the regularity condition .
these properties ensure that we can make sense of the spatial integral term in the definition of @xmath225 for iterates of that function .
a sequence of processes can therefore be defined by iterating the map .
we fix @xmath226 a process in @xmath255 satisfying the coupling assumptions above ( related to definition [ def : solution ] ) , and build the sequence @xmath256 by induction through the recursion relationship @xmath257 .
we show that these processes constitute a cauchy sequence for @xmath258
. this will not be enough for our purposes : we are interested in proving existence and uniqueness of solutions for all @xmath74 . equipped with the estimates on the distance , we will come back to the sequence of processes at single locations , show that these also constitute a cauchy sequence in the space of stochastic processes in @xmath259 ( which is complete ) and conclude .
again , one needs to be careful in the definition of the above recursion and build recursively a sequence of processes @xmath260 independent of the collection of processes @xmath261 and having the same law as follows : * @xmath262 is independent of @xmath133 and has the same law as @xmath133 * for @xmath263 , @xmath264 is independent of the sequence of processes @xmath265 and is such that the collection of processes @xmath266 has the same joint law as @xmath265 , i.e. @xmath267 is chosen such as its conditional law given @xmath268 is the same as that of @xmath256 given @xmath269 . once all these ingredients have been introduced , it is easy to show that @xmath270 satisfies a recursion relationship , by decomposing this difference into the sum of elementary terms : @xmath271\\ & \quad + \int_0^t \int_{\gamma } j(r , r')\big\{\big ( { \mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ b(x_s^{k}(r ) , z^{k}_{s-\tau(r , r ' ) } ( r ' ) ) ] \\ & \qquad \qquad \qquad-{\mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ b(x^{k-1}_s(r ) , z^{k-1}_{s-\tau(r , r ' ) } ( r ' ) ) ] \big)\big\}d\lambda(r')\,ds \\ & = : a_t(r ) + b_t(r)+ c_t(r ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] and checking that the following inequalities apply : @xmath272 through the use of cauchy - schwarz inequality , @xmath273 by standard mckean - vlasov arguments , and @xmath274 } \bigg \vert \int_{\gamma}j(r , r')\int_0^s \big({\mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ b(x_u^{k}(r ) , z_{u-\tau(r , r')}^{k } ( r ' ) ) - b(x_u^{k-1}(r ) , z_{u-\tau(r , r')}^{k-1 } ( r ' ) ) ] \big ) { du\,}d\lambda(r ' ) \bigg\vert d\lambda(r)\bigg]\\ & \leq \vert j\vert_{\infty } \;\int_{\gamma^2 } \int_0^t{\mathbbm{e}}\bigg [ { \mathbbm{e}}_{z } [ \big \vert b(x_u^{k}(r ) , z_{u-\tau(r , r')}^{k } ( r ' ) ) - b(x_u^{k-1}(r ) , z_{u-\tau(r , r')}^{k-1 } ( r ' ) ) ] \big\vert\big ) du\bigg]d\lambda(r)d\lambda(r ' ) \quad ( cs)\\ & \leq 2 \ , l\vert j\vert_{\infty } \int_{\gamma^2 } \int_0^t { \mathbbm{e}\left [ \vert x_s^{k}(r)-x_s^{k-1}(r)\vert \right]}\,ds d\lambda(r)d\lambda(r')\quad \ref{assump : loclipschbspace}\\ & \leq 2 \;l\vert j\vert_{\infty } \int_0^t \vert{x^{k}-x^{k-1}}\vert_s^1\,ds \end{aligned}\ ] ] these inequalities imply : @xmath275 with @xmath276 .
let us now denote for @xmath277 the norm @xmath278 } \vert
z_s(r ) \vert \right]}$ ] consider @xmath279 .
similar developments yield to the inequality : @xmath280 where @xmath281 and @xmath282 correspond to the constants of the penultimate equation . we denote @xmath283 and @xmath284 . by recursion and using equation
, we obtain : @xmath285 this implies that the processes @xmath286 for fixed @xmath74 constitute a cauchy sequence in the space of stochastic processes . from this relationship
, routine methods allow proving existence and uniqueness of fixed point for @xmath225 ( see e.g. @xcite ) , and that this fixed point is adapted and almost surely continuous .
proving uniqueness of the solution using equation is then classical .
we therefore proved that there exists a unique solution to the mean - field equation , which moreover is regular in space in the sense defined above .
of course , as stated , the solutions are discontinuous at all points @xmath111 .
the proposition nevertheless ensures a form of regularity in law , which will be central in the sequel to prove averaging effects in the microcircuit .
now that we have introduced suitable spaces in which the mean - field equations are well - defined , and proved that the equation was well - posed , we are in a position to demonstrate the main result of the manuscript , namely the convergence in law of the solutions of the network equations towards the equations , and the fact that the propagation of chaos property occurs .
we consider that the network equations have chaotic initial conditions with law continuous in space @xmath287 . in detail , the initial conditions of the @xmath12 neurons in the network are considered independent processes @xmath288 , e)$ ] ( the space of square integrable processes from @xmath289 $ ] on @xmath259 ) with law equal to @xmath290 .
our convergence result raises several difficulties compared to more standard models : * first is the fact that at the micro - circuit scale , there will be a local averaging principle ( yielding the convergence towards a local term @xmath291 $ ] .
this property is not classical : indeed , in the network equation , the microcircuit interaction term is @xmath292 , and therefore involve the state of neurons located at different places on @xmath5 and different delays .
the convergence will be handled using ( i ) the fact that in the limit considered , the neurons belong to the microcircuit collapse at a single space location , and ( ii ) regularity properties of the law of the solution as a function of space and time
. this convergence will be the subject of lemma [ lem : convmicro ] .
* second , the macro - circuit interaction term involve delocalized terms across the neural field . the sum will be shown to converge to a non - local averaged term involving an integral over space .
this will be proved through the use of lemma [ lem : convmacro ] and [ lem : sumchi ] .
moreover , we will prove our convergence through a non - classical coupling method that we now describe .
let us now fix a configuration @xmath52 of the network .
the neuron labeled @xmath23 in the network is driven by the @xmath109-dimensional brownian motion @xmath293 , and has the initial condition @xmath294 .
we aim at defining a spatially chaotic brownian motion @xmath295 on @xmath296 such that the standard brownian motion @xmath297 is equal to @xmath298 , and proceed as follows .
let @xmath299 , r\in\gamma}$ ] be a @xmath300-dimensional spatially chaotic brownian motion independent of the processes @xmath301 .
the process @xmath295 defined by the coupling : @xmath302 is clearly a spatially chaotic brownian motion , and will be used to construct a particular solution of the mean - field equations . in order to completely define a solution of the mean - field equations , we need to specify an initial condition , and aim at coupling it to the initial condition of neuron @xmath23 . to this end
, we define a spatially chaotic process @xmath303 equal in law to @xmath304 and independent of @xmath305 , and define a coupled process @xmath306 as : @xmath307 here again , it is clear that this process is spatially chaotic , i.e. that for any @xmath142 , the processes @xmath308 and @xmath309 are independent , and that @xmath308 has the law of @xmath310 . now that these processes have been constructed , we are in a position to define the process @xmath311 as the unique solution of the mean - field equation , driven by the spatially chaotic brownian motion @xmath312 and with the spatially chaotic initial condition @xmath313 : @xmath314d\lambda(r')\,dt } \\ &
\displaystyle{\quad + \bar{j}{\mathbbm{e}}_{z}[b(x_t(r),z_{t-\tau_s}(r))]\,dt+ \sigma(r)\ , dw^i_t(r ) \qquad \text{for } t\geq 0}\\ \\
\bar{x}^i_t(r ) & = \zeta^{i,0}_t ( r ) \qquad \text{for } t\in [ -\tau , 0]\\ \\ ( z_t)&\operatorname{\stackrel{\mathcal{l}}{=}}(\bar{x}^i_t ) \in { \mathcal{m}}\quad \text { independent of $ ( \bar{x}^i_t)$ and $ ( w^{i}_t(\cdot))$}. \end{array } \right .\ ] ] the same procedure applied for all @xmath315 allows building a collection of independent stochastic processes @xmath316
. these are clearly independent of the configurations of the finite - size network .
let us denote by @xmath317 the probability distribution of @xmath318 solution of the mean - field equation .
as previously , the process @xmath319 generically denotes a process belonging to @xmath162 and distributed as @xmath109 .
we start by analyzing the local averaging property on the micro - circuit .
this is the subject of the following lemma .
[ lem : convmicro ] there exists a positive constant @xmath281 such that , for any @xmath12 sufficiently large , averaged across all configurations @xmath52 : @xmath320\right \vert \right]}\right\ } \leq k_1 \sqrt{\left({\frac{v(n)}{n}}\right)^{\frac{1}{d}}+\frac{1}{{v(n)}}}\ ] ] conditioned on @xmath34 , the set @xmath321 is a collection of independent identically distributed random variables .
the map @xmath322 is lipschitz continuous .
therefore , the regularity properties proved in theorem [ thm : existenceuniquenessspace ] ensure that we have ( in what follows , @xmath281 denotes a constant , independent of @xmath12 , that may change from line to line ) : @xmath323-{\mathbbm{e}}_{{z}}[b(\bar{x}^i_t(r),{z}_{t-\tau_{s}}(r_i ) ] \vert \leq k_1(\sqrt{\vert \tau_{ij}-\tau_s \vert } + \vert r_j - r_i\vert+ \sqrt{\vert r_j - r_i\vert})=k_1(\sqrt{d_{ij}}+d_{ij}).\ ] ] for almost any configuration @xmath52 and any @xmath71 , we have seen that for @xmath12 sufficiently large , by application of proposition [ lem : sizemicro ] , the distances @xmath72 are small ( of order @xmath62 ) .
moreover , we have : @xmath324 \\ & \quad = \frac{1}{v(n ) } \sum_{j\in { \mathcal{v}}(i)}\left ( b(\bar{x}^i_t(r_i),\bar{x}^j_{t-\tau(r_i , r_j)}(r_j ) ) - { \mathcal{e}}[{\mathbbm{e}}_{z}[b(\bar{x}^i_t(r_i),z_{t-\tau_{ij}}(r_j))]]\right)\\ & \qquad + \frac{1}{v(n ) } \sum_{j\in { \mathcal{v}}(i)}{\mathcal{e}}[{\mathbbm{e}}_{z}[b(\bar{x}^i_t(r_i),z_{t-\tau_{ij}}(r_j ) ) ] ] - { \mathbbm{e}}_{z}[b(\bar{x}^i_t(r_i),{z}_{t-\tau_s}(r_i ) ) ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] for any measurable function @xmath325 , the quantity @xmath326 $ ] is precisely the average of the random variable @xmath327 .
therefore , a quadratic control argument ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.4 . ) ) allows to show that the first term is of order @xmath328 , in the sense that : @xmath329\right)]]\leq \frac{k_1}{\sqrt{v(n)}}.\ ] ] this argument consists in showing that the expectation of the square of the sum is of order @xmath330 , which is performed by showing that ( i ) the terms of the sum are centered ( i.e. that the expectation term introduced which was chosen to this purpose is precisely the expectation with respect to @xmath331 of @xmath332 for @xmath331 equal in law to @xmath333 which all have the same law ) and ( ii ) using cauchy - schwarz inequality to bound the term by the square root of the expectation of the squared sum , developing the square and showing that the number of null terms is bounded by some constant multiplied by @xmath0 .
this argument is not developed here as it will be the core of the proof of lemma [ lem : convmacro ] .
the second term is handled by using the control given by equation and the result of proposition [ lem : sizemicro ] , ensuring that @xmath334 - { \mathbbm{e}}_{z}[b(\bar{x}^i_t(r_i),{z}_{t-\tau_s}(r_i))]\big]\big]\\\leq k_1\bigg(\sqrt{\left({\frac{v(n)}{n}}\right)^{\frac{1}{d}}+\frac 1 { v(n ) } } + \left({\frac{v(n)}{n}}\right)^{\frac{1}{d}}+\frac 1 { v(n)}\bigg ) .
\end{gathered}\ ] ] put together , the two last estimates yield the desired result .
[ lem : convmacro ] the coupled macroscopic interaction term converges towards a non - local mean - field term with speed @xmath335 , in the sense that there exists a constant @xmath336 independent of @xmath12 such that : @xmath337d\lambda(r)\right \vert\big]\big]\leq \frac{k_2}{\sqrt{n\beta(n)}}.\ ] ] conditioned on the location @xmath34 of neuron @xmath23 , the collection of @xmath338-random variables @xmath339 are independent and identically distributed .
the sum @xmath340 is therefore , conditionally on @xmath341 and @xmath34 , the sum of independent and identically distributed processes , with finite mean and variance ( since @xmath124 is a bounded function ) .
the expectation of each term in the sum , conditionally on @xmath342 and @xmath34 , is equal to : @xmath343 d\lambda(r).\ ] ] let us denote by @xmath344 the term under consideration is simply the empirical average @xmath345 , and conditionally on @xmath341 and @xmath34 , the terms are independent , identically distributed , centered @xmath346-random variables with second moment : @xmath347\leq \frac{1}{\beta(n)}m_2\ ] ] where @xmath348 is a finite constant independent of @xmath12 , @xmath34 and @xmath341
. let us denote by @xmath349 $ ] the expectation on @xmath338 conditioned on @xmath34 and @xmath342 .
we have : @xmath350 & \leq \sqrt{\hat{{\mathbbm{e}}}_i\big[\big(\frac 1 n \sum_{j=1}^n \phi_{ij}\big)^2\big]}\\ & \leq \frac 1 n \sqrt{\sum_{j=1}^n \hat{{\mathbbm{e}}}_i\big[\phi_{ij}^2\big ] } \leq \sqrt{\frac{m_2}{n\beta(n)}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] thanks to the fact that @xmath348 is independent of @xmath342 , we conclude that : @xmath351 \big ] = { \mathbbm{e}}\big[\hat{{\mathbbm{e}}}_i\big[\vert \frac 1 n \sum_{j=1}^n \phi_{ij}\vert\big]\big\vert r_i\big]\leq \sqrt{\frac{m_2}{n\beta(n)}}\ ] ] now that we have analyzed the local and macroscopic interaction terms defined with the coupled processes , we are in a position to demonstrate our main result , namely the full multiscale convergence result .
[ thm : propagationchaosspace ] let @xmath352 a fixed neuron in the network . under the assumptions [ assump : loclipschspace]-[assump
: spacecontinuity ] , for almost all configuration @xmath52 of the neuron locations @xmath353 and connectivity links @xmath354 , the process @xmath355 solution of the network equations converges in law towards the process @xmath356 solution of the mean - field equations with initial condition @xmath304 and moreover , the speed of convergence is given by : @xmath357\right ) = o\left(\sqrt{\left(\frac{v(n)}{n}\right)^{\frac 1 { d}}+\frac 1 { { v(n)}}}+\frac 1 { \sqrt{n\beta(n)}}\right)\ ] ] the notation @xmath358 denotes the expectation on @xmath15 the distribution of network configurations @xmath52 ,
i.e. space locations @xmath359 and connectivity links @xmath360 .
the expectation @xmath361 $ ] is therefore the global expectation , i.e. on @xmath362 .
the result shows that the expectation tends to zero .
this implies quenched convergence ( i.e. for almost all configuration @xmath52 ) along subsequences . in detail
, the speed of converge @xmath363 announced in the theorem ( on the righthand side of equation ) allows to define subsequences ( i.e. a sequence of network size @xmath364 ) for which we have almost sure convergence .
these sequences are such that borel - cantelli lemma can be applied , namely subsequences extracted through a strictly increasing application @xmath365 such that @xmath366 is summable .
we prepare for the proof by demonstrating the following fine estimate that will be used to control configurations with more links than the expected value : [ lem : sumchi ] under our assumptions , for any @xmath17 and @xmath367 , we have for @xmath12 sufficiently large : @xmath368 where @xmath369 . in order to demonstrate the result , we make use of chernoff - hoeffding theorem @xcite controlling the deviations from the mean of bernoulli random variables with fixed mean @xmath60 , is such that , for any @xmath370 , @xmath371\leq \left(\left(\frac p { p+\varepsilon}\right)^{p+\varepsilon}\left(\frac { 1-p } { 1-p-\varepsilon}\right)^{1-p-\varepsilon}\right)^m.\ ] ] ] .
let us denote by @xmath372 .
this is a binomial variable of parameters @xmath373 .
chernoff - hoeffding theorem ensures that : @xmath374 & \leq \left(\left(\frac{\beta(n)}{\gamma\beta(n)}\right)^{\gamma \beta(n)}\left(\frac{1-\beta(n)}{1-\gamma\beta(n)}\right)^{1-\gamma \beta(n)}\right)^n\\ & \leq \exp\left(-\gamma \log(\gamma ) n \beta(n ) + n\big(1-\gamma\beta(n)\big)\big(\log\big(1-\beta(n)\big)-\log\big(1-\gamma\beta(n)\big)\big)\right ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] using a taylor expansion of the logarithmic terms for large @xmath12 ( using the fact that @xmath31 tends to zero at infinity ) , it is easy to obtain @xmath375 \leq \exp\left ( ( -\gamma\log(\gamma)+\gamma-1 ) n\beta(n ) + o(n\beta(n)^2)\right)\ ] ] note that for @xmath367 , the quantity @xmath376 is strictly positive .
we therefore have , for @xmath12 sufficiently large , that the probability is bounded by : @xmath375 \leq \exp\left ( -\frac 1 2 ( \gamma\log(\gamma)-\gamma+1 ) n\beta(n))\right).\ ] ] this allows to conclude the lemma as follows .
it is clear by definition that @xmath377 .
therefore , @xmath378
\end{aligned}\ ] ] yielding the desired result .
we are now in a position to perform the proof of theorem [ thm : propagationchaosspace ] . the proof is based on evaluating the distance @xmath379 $ ] , and breaking it into a few elementary , easily controllable terms .
a substantial difference with usual mean - field proofs is that network equations correspond to processes taking values in @xmath259 in which the interaction term is sum over a finite number of neurons in the network equation , while the mean - field equation is a spatially extended equation with an effective interaction term involving an integral over @xmath5 .
this will be handled using the result of lemma [ lem : convmacro ] .
we introduce in the distance coupled interaction terms that were controlled in lemmas [ lem : convmicro ] and [ lem : convmacro ] and obtain the following elementary decomposition ( each line of the righthand side corresponds to one term of the decomposition , @xmath380 ) : @xmath381\big)\ , ds\\ & \quad + \frac{1}{n\beta(n ) } \sum_{j=1}^{n } \int_0^t j(r_i , r_j)\chi_{ij } \big(b(x^{i,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_s , x^{j,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_{s-\tau_{ij}})-b(\bar{x}^{i}_s(r_{i}),\bar{x}^{j}_{s-\tau_{ij}}(r_{j } ) ) \big)\,ds\\ & \quad + \int_0^t \big(\frac{1}{n\beta(n ) } \sum_{j=1}^{n
} j(r_i , r_j)\chi_{ij } b(\bar{x}^{i}_s(r_{i}),\bar{x}^{j}_{s-\tau_{ij}}(r_{j } ) ) -\int_{\gamma } j(r_i , r ' ) { \mathbbm{e}}_z[b(\bar{x}^i_s(r_{i}),z_{s-\tau(r_{i},r')}(r'))]d\lambda(r')\big)\,ds\\ & \nonumber \qquad = : a^i_t(n)+b^i_t(n)+c^i_t(n)+d^i_t(n)+e^i_t(n ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to show , using assumptions [ assump : loclipschspace ] and [ assump : loclipschbspace ] , that the terms @xmath382 and @xmath383 satisfy the inequalities : @xmath384 & \leq k_f\,\int_0^{t } { \mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{-\tau\leq u\leq s } \vert x_u^{i,{\mathcal{a}}_n}-\bar{x}_u^i(r_{i})\vert \big]\ , ds\\ \max_{i=1\cdots n}\mathcal{e}\big[{\mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{-\tau\leq s\leq t } \vert b_s^i(n ) \vert\big]\big ] & \leq \frac{v(n)+1}{v(n ) } l\ , \int_0^{t } \max_{k=1\cdots n}{\mathcal{e}}\big[{\mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{-\tau\leq u\leq s}\vert x^{k,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_u-\bar{x}^k_u(r_{i } ) \vert\big]\big ] \ , ds \end{aligned}\ ] ] the term @xmath385 requires to be handled with care , because of the sparsity of the macrocircuit .
indeed , this term involves the sum of @xmath12 random variables and is rescaled by @xmath386 . as we assumed @xmath42 in order to account for the sparsity in the macrocircuit , most terms in the sum are equal to zero such that @xmath387 .
we have : @xmath388\leq \vert j\vert_{\infty } \frac 1 { n\beta(n ) } \sum_{j } \chi_{ij } \int_0^t { \mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{0 \leq u \leq s } \vert b(x^{i,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_u , x^{j,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_{u-\tau_{ik}})-b(\bar{x}^i_u,\bar{x}^j_{u-\tau_{ik } } ) \vert \big]\,ds\ ] ] this expression shows how critical the singular sparse coupling is to our estimates .
indeed , the random variable @xmath389 almost surely tends to @xmath97 as @xmath12 goes to infinity , but it can reach very large values ( up to @xmath390 which diverges as @xmath12 goes to infinity ) .
configurations @xmath52 for which the sum is large are increasingly improbable , but for these configurations , the deterministic scaling @xmath391 is not fast enough to overcome the divergence of the input term .
there is therefore a competition between the probability of having configurations with large values of @xmath392 and the divergence of the solutions .
however , in the present case , this control will be possible using the estimate of the probability that the number of links exceeds @xmath393 using the result of lemma [ lem : sumchi ] .
indeed , fixing @xmath367 , and distinguishing whether @xmath394 or not , we obtain : @xmath395\big ] & \leq 2 \gamma \ ; l \ ; \vert j \vert_{\infty } \int_0^t \max_{k=1\cdots n}{\mathcal{e}}\big [ { \mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{-\tau \leq u \leq s } \vert x^{k,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_{u}-\bar{x}^k_{u } \vert \big]\big]\,ds\\ & \qquad + 2 \vert b\vert_{\infty}\vert j\vert_{\infty } { \mathcal{e}}\left(\frac 1 { n\beta(n ) } \sum_{j } \chi_{ij } { \mathbbm{1}_{\mathcal{d}_{\gamma}}}\right ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath369 as defined in lemma [ lem : sumchi ] . by application of this lemma , and using the fact that the second term of the upper bound is negligible compared to @xmath396 , we conclude that : @xmath397\big ] & \leq 2 \gamma \ ; l \ ; \vert j \vert_{\infty } \int_0^t \max_{k=1\cdots n}{\mathcal{e}}\big
[ { \mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{-\tau \leq u \leq s } \vert x^{k,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_{u}-\bar{x}^k_{u } \vert \big]\,ds + \frac{k_c}{\sqrt{n\beta{(n)}}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] we are left with controlling the terms @xmath398 and @xmath399 .
these consist of sums only involving the coupled processes , and were analyzed in the previous sections . by direct application of the results of lemmas [
lem : convmicro ] and [ lem : convmacro ] , we have : @xmath400\big ] } & \leq \displaystyle{k_1\sqrt{\left(\frac{v(n)}{n}\right)^{\frac{1}{d}}+\frac 1 { { v(n)}}}}\\ \displaystyle{\max_{k=1\cdots n}{\mathcal{e}}\big [ { \mathbbm{e}}\big[\sup_{-\tau\leq s \leq t } \vert e^k_t \vert \big]\big ] } & \leq \displaystyle{\frac{k_2}{\sqrt{n\beta{(n ) } } } } \end{cases}\ ] ] all together , we hence have , for some constants @xmath401 and @xmath402 independent of @xmath12 @xmath403\right),\ ] ] the inequality : @xmath404 which proves the theorem by application of gronwall s lemma . [ cor : propachaosspace ]
let @xmath405 and fix @xmath406 neurons @xmath407 . under the assumptions of theorem [ thm : propagationchaosspace ]
, the process @xmath408 converges in law towards @xmath409 .
we have : @xmath410\right ) \\ & \quad \leq l \max_{k=1\cdots
n}\mathcal{e}\left({\mathbbm{e}}\left [ \sup_{-\tau\leq t \leq t } \left\vert x^{k,{\mathcal{a}}_n}_t-\bar{x}^{k}_t\right\vert^2 \right]\right)\\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] which tends to zero as @xmath12 goes to infinity , hence the law of @xmath408 converges towards that of @xmath411 which is equal by definition to @xmath412 .
the dynamics of neuronal networks in the brain lead us to analyze a class of spatially extended networks which display multiscale connectivity patterns that are singular in at least two aspects : * the network display local dense connectivity patterns in which neurons are connected to their @xmath0-nearest neighbors , where @xmath1 . * the macro - circuit was also singular , in the sense that the probability of two neurons @xmath23 and @xmath38 to be connect tends towards zero .
this is very far from usual mean - field models that consider full connectivity patterns , or partial connectivity patterns proportional to the network size @xcite . in these cases ,
the convergence is substantially slower , and the rescaling actually required thorough controls on the number of incoming connections to each neurons .
the introduction of local microcircuits with negligible size was suggested in @xcite , in the context of the fluctuations induced by the microcircuit .
our scaling , motivated by characterizing the macroscopic activity at the scale of the neural field @xmath5 , lead us to consider local microcircuits with spatial extension of order @xmath413 , which tends to zero in the limit @xmath45 . at this scale ,
the fluctuations related to the microcircuit vanish , which allowed identifying the large @xmath12 limit process .
however , at the scale of one neuron ( or considering , similarly to @xcite , a field of size @xmath12 , i.e. typical distances between neurons of order @xmath97 ) , the microcircuits may induce more complex phenomena in which fluctuations become prominent .
this interesting problem remains largely open and can not be addressed with the techniques presented in the manuscript .
the developments presented in this article also go way beyond what was done in the domain of mean - field analysis of large spatially extended systems . in that domain ,
probably the two most relevant contributions to date are @xcite and @xcite . in @xcite , a relatively sketchy model of neural field
was proposed , in which the system was fully connected and neurons gathered at discrete space location that eventually filled the neural field .
the model presented here is considerably more relevant from the biological viewpoint , and necessitated to deeply modify the proofs proposed in that manuscript . in particular , the connectivity patterns are now randomized , and the proof is now made independent of results arising in finite - populations networks .
moreover , the two main contributions of the article , namely the singular coupling , was absent of the above cited manuscript .
such coupling was discussed in @xcite , where the authors consider the case of network with nearest - neighbors topology ( only a local micro - circuit ) in which neurons connect to a non - trivial proportion of neurons @xmath3 .
there is a substantial difficulty in considering only very local micro - circuits connectivity and sparse macro - circuits .
here , we solved this problem and framed it in a more general setting with multiscale coupling .
the proof presented in the present manuscript is relatively general .
in particular , it can be extended to models with non locally lipchitz continuous dynamics ( as is the case of the classical fitzhugh - nagumo model @xcite ) as was presented in @xcite , or to networks with multiple layers .
the results enjoy a relatively broad universality . indeed , we observe that the limit obtained is independent of the choice of the size of the micro - circuit and sparsity of the macro - circuit ( as long as proper scaling is considered ) .
this property shows that the limit is universal : for any choice of function @xmath0 and @xmath31 , the macroscopic limit of our networks are identical .
an interesting question is then what would be an optimal choice of functions @xmath0 and @xmath31 so that the convergence is the fastest .
the speed of convergence towards the mean - field equation is hence governed by three quantities : * the term @xmath414 controls the regularity of the law solution of the mean - field equation with respect to space .
the larger @xmath0 , the wider the micro - circuit , and therefore the slowest the local convergence . * the term @xmath415 controls the speed of averaging at the micro - circuit scale , which decreases with the size of the micro - circuit @xmath0 . * the term @xmath396 controls the speed of the averaging at the macro - circuit scale .
this term is of course the smallest when @xmath31 is large . in the biological system under consideration
, there is nevertheless an energetic cost to increasing the connectivity level .
the two first term corresponding to the micro - circuit convergence properties can give an information on the order of the optimal micro - circuit size .
minima are obtained when @xmath0 is of order @xmath416 , e.g. @xmath417 in dimension @xmath97 .
other choices may be analyze to optimize other criteria such that information capacity vs energetic considerations , anatomical constraints , size of clusters sharing resources , .
eventually , this result has also implications in neuroscience modeling . in this domain
, authors widely use the so - called wilson - cowan neural field model ( see @xcite for a review ) .
this model is given by non - local differential equations of type : @xmath418 where @xmath419 represents the mean firing - rate of neurons and @xmath420 corresponds to a sigmoidal function .
this type of equations is similar to those obtained in the analysis of fully connected neural fields , as shown in @xcite , when considering a discrete wilson - cowan type of dynamics for the underlying network , i.e. a case where @xmath421 and @xmath422 for @xmath420 a smooth sigmoidal function . in this case
, we showed @xcite that the solutions were attracted by gaussian spatially chaotic processes with mean @xmath423 and standard deviation @xmath424 satisfying the integro - differential equations : @xmath425 where @xmath426 .
these are compatible with the neural field equations .
however , these actually appear to overlook the complex connectivity pattern , and in particular neglect the additional local averaging term that we found here using rigorous probabilistic methods . taking into account local microcircuitry would actually yield an additional term in the equation on @xmath423 : @xmath427 the study of these new equations will , with no doubt , present substantial different dynamics , are offer a new neural field model well worth analyzing in order to understand the qualitative role of local microcircuits on the dynamics . | the cortex is a very large network characterized by a complex connectivity including at least two scales : a microscopic scale at which the interconnections are non - specific and very dense , while macroscopic connectivity patterns connecting different regions of the brain at larger scale are extremely sparse .
this motivates to analyze the behavior of networks with multiscale coupling , in which a neuron is connected to its @xmath0 nearest - neighbors where @xmath1 , and in which the probability of macroscopic connection between two neurons vanishes .
these are called singular multi - scale connectivity patterns .
we introduce a class of such networks and derive their continuum limit .
we show convergence in law and propagation of chaos in the thermodynamic limit .
the limit equation obtained is an intricate non - local mckean - vlasov equation with delays which is universal with respect to the type of micro - circuits and macro - circuits involved . ' '' '' ' '' ''
the purpose of this paper is to provide a general convergence and propagation of chaos result for large , spatially extended networks of coupled diffusions with multi - scale disordered connectivity .
such networks arise in the analysis of neuronal networks of the brain .
indeed , the brain cortical tissue is a large , spatially extended network whose dynamics is the result of a complex interplay of different cells , in particular neurons , electrical cells with stochastic behaviors . in the cortex , neurons interact depending on their anatomical locations and on the feature they code for .
the neuronal tissue of the brain constitute spatially - extended structures presenting complex structures with local , dense and non - specific interactions ( microcircuits ) and long - distance lateral connectivity that are function - specific .
in other words , a given cell in the cortex sends its projections at ( i ) a local scale : the neurons connect extensively to anatomically close cells ( the _ microcircuits _ ) , forming a dense local network , and ( ii ) superimposed to this local architecture , a very sparse functional architecture arises , in which long - range connections are made with other cells that are anatomically more remote but that respond to the same stimulus ( the functional _ macrocircuit _ ) .
this canonical architecture was first evidenced by electrophysiological recordings in the 70 s @xcite and made more precise as experimental techniques developed ( see @xcite for striking representations of this architecture in the striate cortex ) .
the primary visual cortex of certain mammals is a paradigmatic well documented cortical area in which this architecture was evidenced . in
such cortical areas , neurons organize into columns of small spatial extension containing a large number of cells ( on the order of tens of thousands cells ) responding preferentially to specific orientations in visual stimuli @xcite , constituting local microcircuits that distribute across the cortex in a continuous map , each cell connecting densely with its nearest neighbors and sparsely with remote cells coding for the same stimulus @xcite .
these spatially extended networks are called _ neural fields_. such organizations and structures are deemed to subtend processing of complex sensory or cortical information and support brain functions @xcite . in particular , the activity of these neuronal assemblies produce a mesoscopic , spatially extended signal , which is precisely at the spatial resolution of the most prominent imaging techniques ( eeg , meg , mri ) .
these recordings are good indicators of brain activity : they are a central diagnostic tool used by physicians to assert function or disfunction . in these spatially extended systems , the presence of delays in the communication of cells , chiefly due to the transport of information through axons and to the typical time the synaptic machinery needs to transmit it , is essential to the dynamics .
these transmission delays will chiefly affect the long connections of the macrocircuit , which are orders of magnitude longer than those of the microcircuit .
the mathematical and computational analysis of the dynamics of neural fields relies almost exclusively on the use of heuristic models since the seminal work of wilson , cowan and amari @xcite .
these propose to describe the mesoscopic cortical activity through a deterministic , scalar variable whose dynamics is given by integro - differential equations .
this model was widely studied analytically and numerically , and successfully accounted for hallucination patterns , binocular rivalry and synchronization @xcite . justifying these models starting from biologically realistic settings
has since then been a great endeavor @xcite .
this problem was undertaken recently using probabilistic methods .
the first contribution @xcite introduced an approximation of the underlying connectivity of the neural network involved , considering a fully connected architecture ( each neuron was connected to all the others ) and neurons in the same column were considered to be precisely at the same spatial location .
they showed propagation of chaos and convergence to some intricate mckean - vlasov equation .
more recently , an heterogeneous macrocircuit model was analyzed in @xcite . in that paper , the authors considered a network with heterogeneous and non - global connectivity : neurons were connected with their @xmath2-nearest neighbors , where @xmath3 with @xmath4 , or with power - law synaptic weights , and obtained a limit theorem for the behavior of the empirical density . in both cases ,
the connectivity was considered at a single scale , and did not reproduce the actual type of connectivity pattern observed in the brain . in the present manuscript
, we come back to these models with a more plausible architecture including local microcircuit together with non - local macroscopic sparse connectivity . using statistical methods and in particular an extension of the coupling method @xcite
, we will demonstrate the propagation of chaos property , and convergence towards a complex nonlinear markov equation similar to the classical _ mckean - vlasov _
equations , but with a non - local integral over space locations and delays .
interestingly , this object presents substantial differences with the usual mckean - vlasov limits : beyond the presence of delays , the neural field limit regime is at a mesoscopic scale where averaging effects locally to occur , but is fine enough to resolve brain s structure and its activity , resulting in the presence of an integral term over space .
the solution , seen as a function of space , is everywhere discontinuous , which makes the limiting object highly singular .
the present work is distinct of that of @xcite in that we consider local connectivity patterns in which neurons connect to a negligible portion of the neurons .
this includes non - trivial issues , and necessitate to thoroughly control the regularity of the law of the solution as a function of space . on the other hand , beyond the presence of random locations of individual neurons and the presence of a dense microcircuit , the sparse macro - circuit generalizes non - trivially the work done in @xcite .
indeed , at the macro - circuit scale , the probability of connecting two fixed neurons tends to zero .
we therefore need to deal with a non - globally connected network , and address the problem by using fine estimates on the interaction terms and chernoff - hoeffding theorem @xcite .
the speed of convergence towards the mean - field equations is quantified and involves three terms , one governing the local averaging effects arising from the micro - circuits , one arising from the regularity properties of the solutions , and one corresponding to the speed of convergence of the macro - circuit interaction term towards a continuous limit . in the neural field regime ,
the limit equations are very singular , in particular trajectories are not measurable with respect to the space .
these limits are very hard to analyze at this level of generality .
however , in the type of models usually considered in the study of neural fields , namely the firing - rate model , it was shown in @xcite that the behavior can be rigorously and exactly reduced to a system of deterministic integro - differential equations that are compatible with the usual wilson and cowan system in the zero noise limit .
noise intervenes in these equations a nonlinear fashion , fundamentally shaping in the macroscopic dynamics .
the paper is organized as follows .
we start in section [ sec : model ] by introducing precisely our model and proving a few simple results on the network equations and on the topology of the micro - circuit .
this being shown , we will turn in section [ sec : existenceuniquenessspace ] to the analysis of the network equations , and will in particular make sense of the intricate non - local mckean - vlasov equation , show well - posedness and some regularity estimates on the law of the mean - field equations . section [ sec : propachaspace ] will be devoted to the demonstration of the convergence of the network equations towards the mean - field equations . |
the pamela telescope @xcite will be put in orbit within the 2005 on board of the resurs dk1 russian satellite for a three year long mission on a orbit ( @xmath1 deg .
inclination , @xmath2 to @xmath3 km height ) to study the cosmic ray flux , with a special interest on the antimatter component .
the detector is composed of several subsystems , schematically shown in fig .
[ fig : pamela ] : a time of flight ( tof ) apparatus , which also provides the trigger signal , a solid state magnetic spectrometer @xcite , surrounded by an anticoincidence shield , and an electromagnetic calorimeter @xcite in which single sided silicon detector planes are interleaved with tungsten absorber up to a total thickness of about @xmath4 radiation lengths .
anticoincidence scintillators define the external geometry of the detector and their signals will be exploited in the off line rejection of spurious tracks ; below the calorimeter another scintillator plane ( s4 ) and a neutron detector can provide additional information when showers are not fully contained in the calorimeter .
.,width=291 ] .,width=275 ] the whole detector can discriminate protons and electrons from their antiparticles and provide energy measurements ; also @xmath5 nuclei may cross the entire spectrometer and consequently can be detected .
antimatter acquisitions will cover the energy range @xmath6 mev@xmath7 gev for antiprotons and @xmath8 mev@xmath9 gev for positrons , so extending the current upper limit ( about @xmath8 gev ) given by balloon
borne missions @xcite .
in addition , the long duration of the flight will provide larger statistics in particular in the high energy range , where the power law spectrum of cosmic rays requires either large acceptances or long exposure times astronomical unit from the sun is proportional to @xmath10 in the energy range @xmath11 @xcite . ] .
the obtained high energy antiparticle flux will constrain the models describing the origin of antimatter in the universe .
the apparatus can be exploited also to find dark
matter signatures through the detection of high energy antiprotons originating from neutralino annihilations @xcite .
the magnetic spectrometer is the core of the pamela apparatus : it is based on a permanent magnet and consists of six detector planes which measure both the impact coordinates of the incoming particles .
the magnet is made of a nd fe b alloy , with a high value of the residual magnetization ( about @xmath12 t ) .
blocks of magnetic material define a rectangular cavity ( @xmath13 ) where particles are detected . here
the magnetic field is roughly uniform and oriented along the y coordinate in the pamela reference frame ( fig .
[ fig : pamela ] ) . as a consequence ,
particles are bent in the xz plane within the cavity , due to the lorentz force @xmath14 .
five identical magnetic modules , each one @xmath6 mm high , are superimposed each other and interleaved with six detector planes , which are inserted in the magnetic tower by means of dedicated slits .
the magnetic field in the centre of the cavity is @xmath15 t. measurements of the three components of the magnetic field have been taken at a fixed pitch in about @xmath16 points inside the cavity .
such values will be used during the off line analysis to precisely determine the particle s momentum through a numerical integration of its equation of motion inside the cavity . when the characteristics of the pamela experiment were studied , the main requirements of the detectors to be used in the magnetic spectrometer were defined .
essentially they can be listed as in the following : 1 .
provide two coordinates per detector ; 2 .
maximize the spatial resolution , in particular for the bending coordinate ; 3 .
minimize the multiple scattering .
the best candidates to comply with such requirements appeared to be double sided silicon microstrip detectors with a small strip pitch , associated with low noise electronics .
the multiple scattering was limited by excluding any dead layer above or beneath the detectors . in the resulting configuration
six detectors , manufactured by hamamatsu photonics @xcite , are arranged in each plane ( fig .
[ fig : photoplane ] ) .
a detector is made of a @xmath17 m thick @xmath18type silicon wafer , with @xmath19type strips implanted at @xmath20 m pitch on the junction side .
these strips are used to determine the x coordinate of the incoming particle .
@xmath21type strips , orthogonal to the previous ones , are implanted with @xmath22 m pitch on the y ( ohmic ) side .
the read out pitch on the junction side is actually @xmath23 m , since a @xmath19 strip out of two is left floating : charge collected by that strip influences the output of the adjacent read out channels @xcite . on the ohmic side
a @xmath19 blocking strip is added between two consecutive @xmath18 strips in order to increase the interstrip resistance .
integrated decoupling capacitors are present on both sides : they are obtained by depositing an insulating layer ( @xmath24 m @xmath25 ) and metallic strips above the implants . on the ohmic view a second metal layer , separated by another @xmath25 deposition , @xmath26 m thick , brings the read out metallic strips parallel to the junction side s ones . both surfaces of the detectors are passivated ; electrical signals can be taken out from metallic pads located at both ends of the strips . the depletion voltage given by
the manufacturer is @xmath27 v and @xmath6 v bias will be supplied during the operational phase .
the detectors are arranged in three modules named ladders : two sensors and a double sided hybrid circuit form each ladder .
these elements are glued in such a way that x side strips meet at their ends : electrical connections among the corresponding strips are provided by @xmath28 m wire bonds on both sides . on the ohmic view two distinct strips , about @xmath29 apart , are connected to the same electronic channel , so giving rise to a position ambiguity , that can be easily resolved on the basis of the other pamela s subdetectors .
the percentage of bad strips , due mainly to unconnected or noisy channels , ranges between @xmath30% and @xmath31% for all the ladders .
the mechanical structure of the plane is shown in fig . [
fig : photoplane ] and it minimizes the multiple scattering since no additional dead layer is present on the particle s trajectory .
nevertheless , in order to increase the rigidity of the structure , four carbon
fibre bars ( visible in the photograph ) with very high young modulus ( about @xmath32 gpa ) are glued at both sides of each ladder .
the resulting plane has the first resonance frequency located beyond @xmath32 hz and it has survived vibrational tests whose intensities were twice those expected during the launch of the satellite @xcite . a summary of geometrical and electrical characteristics of the detectors is given in table [ tab : charact ] .
.geometrical and electrical characteristics of the silicon microstrip detectors . [
cols="<,^,^ " , ] in fig .
[ fig : rms ] the results provided by the mentioned methods on both sides are shown . on the junction side it can be noticed that the @xmath33 algorithm gives the best resolution for orthogonal or slightly inclined tracks , as already stated in literature @xcite : in our configuration @xmath33 is the preferable method up to about @xmath34 deg .
for larger angles , the original methods @xmath35 and @xmath36 give a more accurate particle position , compared to the centre of gravity , suggested in the ref .
@xcite for intermediate incidence angles .
in particular , @xmath35 can be used from about @xmath34 to @xmath37 deg . and
@xmath36 from @xmath37 to @xmath38 deg .
the spatial resolution ranges between less than @xmath0 m and about @xmath39 m on the angular interval corresponding to the acceptance of the spectrometer . on the ohmic side
a better resolution ( about @xmath40 m rms ) is achieved for inclined ( @xmath41 deg . )
this is due to a greater percentage of clusters with multiplicity @xmath42 compared to case of perpendicular tracks , which result in a higher accuracy of the reconstructed position .
let us now briefly discuss how the spatial resolution , achieved at a given angle , influences the scientific objectives of the pamela experiment .
the silicon microstrip detectors are the sensitive elements of a magnetic spectrometer that determines the momentum of the crossing charged particles .
the obtained uncertainty @xmath43 in the reconstructed momentum is directly related , besides the magnetic field value and the geometry of the spectrometer , to the spatial resolution on the x ( bending ) view .
usually the performances of the instrument are given in terms of the rigidity @xmath44 , defined as momentum to charge ratio : when @xmath45 % the spectrometer has reached the maximum detectable rigidity ( mdr ) .
in pamela the value @xmath46 @xcite has been measured on a test beam for electrons whose arrival directions are orthogonal to the sensors .
this value is influenced by the presence of tails in the distribution of residuals that can in principle be associated with errors in the charge sign of the reconstructed events .
this problem becomes relevant in pamela because few antiparticles have to be identified in a large particle background ( the antiparticle / particle ratio is of the order of @xmath47 ) .
this drawback is known as _ spillover _ and actually limits the measurements of antiparticle abundances in pamela to about @xmath48 for antiprotons and @xmath49 for positrons @xcite , in spite of a much larger mdr . for these reasons
the data analysis needs accurate procedures that do not disperse the peculiar characteristics of the detectors .
results from this simulation will be therefore exploited to obtain the best algorithm of position reconstruction depending on the particle incidence angle and on the cluster multiplicity . moreover
, the knowledge of the width of the distribution of residuals in different conditions enables us to `` weight '' each impact point determination while tracking a particle through the spectrometer .
for instance , a high multiplicity cluster , occurring in a quasi orthogonal track , is probably connected with a @xmath50 ray emission : so the corresponding position should reasonably have a lower weight in the track fit .
if such a correlation is considered , the accuracy in the momentum reconstruction will be significantly improved .
the simulation described in this paper takes into account the characteristics of the double sided silicon microstrip detectors of the pamela spectrometer and correctly reproduces their observed performances .
in particular the simulation has been applied to the analysis of the best obtainable spatial resolution as a function of the incidence angle of the incoming particle .
new position finding algorithms ( @xmath35 and @xmath36 ) have been successfully introduced to improve the resolution for non orthogonal tracks on the bending view .
the obtained distributions of the spatial residuals at different angles and multiplicities can be used in a simulation of the whole tracking system to study the particle contamination in antiparticle measurements and to calibrate in the best way the tracking procedure . | the pamela apparatus has been assembled and it is ready to be launched in a satellite mission to study mainly the antiparticle component of cosmic rays . in this paper
the performances obtained for the silicon microstrip detectors used in the magnetic spectrometer are presented .
this subdetector reconstructs the curvature of a charged particle in the magnetic field produced by a permanent magnet and consequently determines momentum and charge sign , thanks to a very good accuracy in the position measurements ( better than @xmath0 m in the bending coordinate ) .
a complete simulation of the silicon microstrip detectors has been developed in order to investigate in great detail the sensor s characteristics .
simulated events have been then compared with data gathered from minimum ionizing particle ( mip ) beams during the last years in order to tune free parameters of the simulation . finally some either widely used or original position finding algorithms , designed for such kind of detectors , have been applied to events with different incidence angles . as a result of the analysis , a method of impact point reconstruction
can be chosen , depending on both the particle s incidence angle and the cluster multiplicity , so as to maximize the capability of the spectrometer in antiparticle tagging .
silicon microstrip detectors , spatial resolution , position finding algorithms 29.40.gx , 29.40.wk , 07.05.tp |
in an attempt to account for the coplanar nature of the orbits of all known solar - system planets , laplace ( 1796 ) postulated that they were formed in a common disk around the protosun .
today , the detection of protostellar disks around most young t - tauri stars ( prosser _ et al .
_ 1994 ) is a strong evidence that the laplace nebula hypothesis is universally applicable .
the recent discovery of planets around at least 10% of nearby solar - type stars ( marcy _ et al .
_ 2000 ) suggests that their formation may be a robust process .
conventional cosmogonical scenarios are based on the assumption that heavy elements in gas - phase condensed to form grains which then coagulated into planetesimals and grew into protoplanetary cores which can accrete , at least in some regions of the disk , massive gaseous envelopes around themselves ( pollack _ et al .
the coexistence of gas and solid ice has been detected in some protostellar disks ( thi _ et al .
in fact , protostellar disks are most conspicuous in their continuum radiation associated with the re - processing of stellar light by the grains ( adams , lada , & shu 1987 ) .
the apparent wavelength dependence in the thickness of the disk dust layer has been interpreted as evidence of grain growth ( throop _ et al .
_ 2001 , dalessio _ et al . _ , 2001 , clarke _
et al . _ , 2003 ) and settling ( shuping _ et al . _ , 2003 ) .
the @xmath0m - to - cm continuum radiation signatures of the dust are observed to fade on the timescale of a few myr ( beckwith , 1999 , haisch _ et al .
_ 2001 ) , signaling the depletion of grains in this size range .
this suggests that heavy elements initially contained in this size range are either evaporated , ejected to large distance , accreted onto the host stars , or have coagulated into larger particles .
the first possibility is constrained by the concurrent decline in the co - gas ( zuckerman _ et al .
_ 1995 ) whereas the last possibility is directly relevant to the process of planet formation
. theoretical analysis suggests a very strong constraint on the growth of @xmath0m - size grains into km - size planetesimals .
indeed , the orbital evolution of the particles is determined by both the gravity of the central star and the drag of the disk gas . in the absence of turbulence
, the disk gas attains a dynamical equilibrium between gravity , pressure , and centrifugal forces with zero velocity in both radial and normal - to - the - disk directions and a slightly sub - keplerian velocity in the azimuthal direction .
particles in the disk undergo both sedimentation toward the mid - plane and inward drift in the radial direction ( whipple 1972 , weidenschilling 1977 ) . in a minimum mass nebula ( hayashi _
_ 1985 ) , the resulting orbital decay timescale at 1au ( for instance ) is smallest for m - size particles ( adachi _ et al .
_ 1976 ) , and is then less than about @xmath1 yr .
unless the growth of planetesimals across this `` most vulnerable size '' can occur faster than their orbital decay , there would be no residual planetesimals left to provide the building blocks of planets .
one possible channel of rapid grain growth is through sedimentation into a sufficiently thin , gravitationally unstable disk ( goldreich & ward 1973 ) .
the critical thickness for gravitational instability of such disks is less than @xmath2 of their radii and the characteristic size of the resulting fragment is @xmath3 a few km .
however , even a modest amount of turbulence can provide adequate stirring to prevent the sedimentation of grains into such a thin unstable layer ( weidenschilling 1984 , supulver & lin 2000 ) . though turbulence is likely to occur in a magnetized disk ( balbus & hawley , 1990 ) through magneto - rotational instability
, this mechanism could well fail in regions of the disk where the ionization fraction is too small . in these regions only , the following alternative mechanism for turbulence has been proposed . in a laminar disk ,
the sedimentation of dust toward the disk s mid - plane leads to a local concentration of massive particles ; these particles entrain the gas to a near - keplerian velocity through drag , thereby introducing a shear layer between the dust - dominated mid - plane and the rest of the disk gas ( weidenschilling & cuzzi 1993 ) .
such a flow pattern in the disk has the potential to cause the onset of a shearing instability ( sekiya 1998 , youdin & shu 2002 ) .
however , the stability analysis used by these authors for such flow is based on a single - fluid approximation in which the dust particles are assumed to be well - coupled to the gas .
since the concentration of the dust particles not only causes the shear but also a stabilizing density stratification , the flow of dust and gas should be treated separately . in a companion paper ( garaud _
_ in preparation ) , we will carry out a two - component stability analysis of the disk s dust layer . such a study is greatly simplified by the treatment of the particles as a separate fluid rather than a collection of particles .
it is with this goal in mind that we now present a system of averaged equations for the evolution of a collection of dust particles in the form of moments of the boltzmann equation .
this prescription could also in principle be applied for the studies of dust particles evolution due to coagulation , sublimation , condensation ( supulver & lin 2000 ) and under their interaction with embedded planets ( wyatt _ et al .
_ 1999 ) and stellar radiation ( takeuchi & artymowicz 2001 , klahr & lin 2001 , takeuchi & lin 2002 ) . for the present calculation
, we assume the particles are collisionless and indestructible spheres in a gaseous laminar disk with no embedded planets and negligible stellar radiation . in this paper
, we also neglect the feedback of the particles drag on the motion of the gas . in 2 , we recall the general gas drag laws and their effects on particle trajectories in a protoplanetary accretion disk . in 3 , and 4
we solve for individual particles orbits , and derive the complementary set of dynamical equations for a collection of particles in the form of low - order moments of the boltzmann equation ( boltzmann , 1872 ) . in 3 ,
we focus only on small particles , which have sizes smaller than the mean - free - path of the gas molecules , whereas in 4 , we develop analogous equations for particles with sizes larger than the mean - free - path of gas .
these initial calculations are purely analytic ; in order to perform them , we need to assume separation of the radial and normal - to - the - disk variables , as well as a constant background gas density . in 5 , we check the validity of these assumptions with a complete numerical calculation of the particles orbits in a simple - to - use model for the gas nebula .
we compare both the results for individual orbits and for the moments ( typically , the average velocity and average velocity dispersion ) obtained from the boltzmann averaging procedure .
we also consider the spatial and temporal evolution of a given size - distribution of particles in 6 and show that particles with a narrow selected size - range sediment most rapidly toward the mid - plane .
finally in 7 , we summarize our results and discuss their implications .
in this section , we briefly recall the effect of gas drag and gravitational forces on individual particle trajectories . in dust - particle number - density regimes where particle collisions are negligible , the trajectory of a particle is given by @xmath4 where @xmath5 denote derivatives of @xmath6 with respect to time , @xmath7 is the position vector of the particle , @xmath8 is the externally imposed gravitational potential , @xmath9 is the mass of the particle and @xmath10 is the drag force between the particle and the gas .
the amplitude of the drag force depends on the size of the particle @xmath11 compared to the mean free path of the gas @xmath12 and one typically distinguishes two regimes , @xmath13 ( epstein regime ) and @xmath14 ( stokes regime ) . in the small particle limit , _
i.e. _ the epstein regime , the drag is caused by the thermal agitation of the gas and is proportional to the velocity of the particle relative to the gas : @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the gas velocity , @xmath17 is the local density of the gas , @xmath18 is the local sound speed and @xmath19 is the solid ( i.e. internal ) density of the particle . in a standard solar nebula ,
this formula is typically valid up to decimeter - sized particles at 1 au . in the other limit
, large particles see the gas as a fluid , and experience a drag force through the laminar or turbulent wake that they create as they move through the gas .
this is the stokes regime .
whipple ( 1972 ) reported that the drag force on a sphere is @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the norm of @xmath22 and @xmath23 is the particle reynolds number of the flow ( @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the molecular viscosity of the gas ) .
experimental results suggest that the drag coefficient @xmath26 varies like @xmath27 this prescription ensures a smooth transition between the epstein regime and the stokes regime for intermediate particle sizes ( @xmath28 ) .
note that in the stokes regime ( for @xmath29 ) , the amplitude of the drag force depends on the total velocity of the particle with respect to the gas , and not simply its component parallel to the particle s velocity .
this expresses the fact that a strong wake caused by the particles motion in one direction also affects even the slightest motion in another perpendicular direction .
as particles undergo gas drag , they lose angular momentum which causes them to drift slowly inwards . for particles
strongly coupled to the gas ( i.e. very small particles ) , this drift is slowed down by the support provided by the gas pressure itself . for weakly coupled particles ( i.e. very large particles ) ,
the angular - momentum loss is very small and the drift is equally slow ( see the next section ) .
there exists an intermediate regime , however , where orbital decay can occur very rapidly .
weidenschilling ( 1977 ) carried out a first quantitative study of the effect of the gas drag on particles of various sizes , and determined the inward drift velocity as a function of particle size .
he found that the maximal drift occurs for particles for which the typical stopping timescale @xmath30 is of order of the orbital timescale @xmath31 , and decays very quickly for particles much larger , or much smaller than that .
as a result , unless the particle is of intermediate size , there will be a marked separation between the dynamical timescale and the orbital decay timescale .
moreover , there is also a marked separation between radial and vertical length scales ; indeed , numerical integration of the orbits of particles in a gaseous disk shows that the typical radial drift velocity is of the same order ( in the case of small particles ) or much smaller ( in the case of large particles ) than the vertical settling velocity ( see section [ sec : numint_traj ] ) .
hence in a thin disk the particles settle to the mid - plane with very little radial excursion , then undergo radial decay within a very thin dust layer . for this reason it is justified to assume that the vertical motion of particles is more or less independent of their radial motion ( although not of their radial _ position _ ) , and that their radial motion occurs mostly at @xmath32 . since weidenschilling ( 1977 ) has already derived an analytical description of the particles motion in the radial direction , we shall concentrate on the problem of vertical settling .
a short derivation of the case of radial and azimuthal motion of the particles in a gas disk is presented in the appendix for completeness .
from the previous sections , we infer the vertical equation of motion of a small dust - particle in the epstein regime : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the height above the disk . in a central potential ,
the gravitational force close to the mid - plane can be rewritten as @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the keplerian angular velocity at the radius considered .
we re - normalize the time variable to the orbital timescale @xmath37 at the radial position considered , and the distances to astronomical units ( au ) ; we deduce the non - dimensional equation @xmath38 where @xmath39 . in terms of this normalization
, the magnitude of @xmath0 in this regime is typically much larger than unity , which means that the stopping time @xmath40 is much smaller than the orbital time .
the solution to equation ( [ eq : epseq ] ) is straightforward , and the trajectory of a particle initially positioned at height @xmath41 with initial velocity @xmath42 is @xmath43 \mbox { . }
\label{eq : epstraj}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that for @xmath44 this expression simplifies to @xmath45 the second term of this expression describes the rapid deceleration of the particle by the gas drag , the first represents a slow settling toward the mid - plane .
let us recast this equation into @xmath46 which defines the functions @xmath47 and @xmath48 uniquely .
the instantaneous vertical velocity of these particles is then given by @xmath49 note that for @xmath50 ( which describes the intermediate parameter range between the epstein regime and the stokes regime ) the particle motion contains an oscillatory component decaying exponentially on timescale @xmath51 .
given a set of particles at initial positions @xmath41 and with initial velocities @xmath52 , the boltzmann distribution function of these particles is @xmath53 one can also take the continuum limit of this description in the case of a very large number of particles : @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the initial particle density distribution , and @xmath56 is the initial velocity distribution of particles .
the freedom in the relative choices of the initial distribution functions @xmath55 and @xmath56 is lifted by requiring that for all @xmath41 @xmath57 the mass density of the particles is obtained by integrating @xmath58 over all possible velocities : @xmath59 substitution of the equations for the particle trajectories into ( [ eq:1 ] ) and integration over all possible initial positions yields @xmath60 the first moment of the boltzmann function is the average vertical velocity : @xmath61 the same manipulations yield @xmath62 let us assume for a short while that the distribution of the initial velocities is independent of height above the mid - plane .
then we can verify easily that the quantities determined above in equations ( [ eq:2 ] ) and ( [ eq:3 ] ) satisfy the standard continuity equation @xmath63 regardless of the form of the `` trajectory functions '' @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
however , the original collisionless boltzmann equation ( boltzmann , 1872 ) describes the evolution of the distribution function @xmath58 in phase space through @xmath64 where @xmath65 is a collision term that reproduces the interaction of the particles with themselves and with the surrounding medium .
if we integrate the boltzmann equation with respect to the velocity space , we get @xmath66 substitution of the equation of motion equation ( [ eq : epseq ] ) into the last term of the left - hand - side provides an expression for the interaction term @xmath65 as a condition for the mass continuity equation to be satisfied : @xmath67 this result can be generalized in the case where @xmath56 depends on @xmath41 .
subtracting the mass continuity equation from the first moment of the boltzmann equation reveals the importance of the particle velocity correlations @xmath68 @xmath69 where @xmath70 represents the particles velocity dispersion function .
this equation is very similar to that of a standard fluid , with the following caveats : ( i ) it contains an explicit drag term in the form of @xmath71 , and ( ii ) the very last term , which usually represents the pressure term in a standard fluid , must be written explicitly as a function of known quantities .
we expect this term to be null in the case of collisionless particles with negligible relative velocity with respect to the gas ; in order to double check this conjecture , we now evaluate @xmath72 explicitly .
let us first evaluate @xmath68 : @xmath73 the behavior of @xmath72 at short times ( i.e. for times shorter than the stopping time @xmath74 ) is difficult to extract analytically while keeping the functions @xmath55 and @xmath56 unprescribed .
however , for large @xmath0 and large times one can simplify the expressions for the functions @xmath47 and @xmath48 to @xmath75 in that case , the expressions for the first and second velocity moments simplify largely to @xmath76 and one can show that provided @xmath56 is an even function of velocity @xmath77 this result is expected : any initial velocity dispersion is quickly damped out by the surrounding gas on the short stopping timescale @xmath78 .
note that in the case where @xmath55 and @xmath56 are uniformly distributed , this expression is also valid for very short times .
the long - term evolution of the collection of particles becomes a slow collective settling , on a timescale @xmath0 .
therefore , in the epstein case , one can approximate the particles as a fluid with a linear drag force and zero pressure .
the main drag effect of the gas on a large particle occurs through the formation of a wake behind the particle .
if the velocity of the particle relative to the gas is small enough , the wake is laminar and the drag force is a linear function of the relative velocity . in that case
, the particle trajectory is actually the same as that obtained in the case of the epstein regime , and the results of the previous section apply . however , as the relative velocity between the particle and the gas increases , the wake becomes turbulent and the amplitude of the drag force becomes a power law of the particle s reynolds number . as a result , though the component of the drag force in any direction is still proportional to the relative velocities of the particle and the gas in that same direction , its amplitude also depends on the total relative velocity of the particle with respect to the fluid .
hence the vertical component of the drag force is : @xmath79 if one assume the only important component of the gas velocity is in the azimuthal direction .
this formula can in principle be used only in conjunction with a complete evaluation of the particle s orbit .
however , one can assume that the largest typical contrasts in velocity between particle and gas occurs in the vertical direction , where the particles oscillate across the mid - plane with an epicyclic frequency whereas the gas is more - or - less stationary ( so that @xmath80 and @xmath81 )
. in that case , the expression for the vertical component of the drag force reduces to @xmath82 note that since the typical velocity of the particles across the mid - plane is of order of @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the typical height of particles above the disk , the asymptotic stokes regime occurs for particles of size @xmath85 where @xmath86 .
this condition corresponds for example to 10 m size particles at @xmath87 au and @xmath88th of the disk scale height in a standard solar nebula . using the same normalizations as in the epstein regime , the particle s vertical equation of motion
can then be written as @xmath89 where @xmath90 and @xmath91 au . in the asymptotic stokes regime
, @xmath26 is simply a constant , and @xmath92 is typically of order of unity , or smaller .
this equation can be solved exactly through the introduction of the quantity @xmath93 . on the positive branch (
when @xmath94 ) and negative branch ( @xmath95 ) the solutions are , respectively , @xmath96 as the particle oscillates about the mid - plane , it follows one branch or the other .
the constants @xmath97 and @xmath98 are determined by matching the first branch to the boundary conditions and the successive alternative ones to each other at the turning point ( i.e. when @xmath99 ) . for instance , the trajectory of a particle starting from rest at @xmath100 above the mid - plane satisfies the equation @xmath101 it accelerates toward the mid - plane , then decelerates on the other side until it reaches a turning point @xmath102 which satisfies @xmath103 these solutions indicate the existence of two regimes . when the initial height @xmath104 is much larger than the scale height @xmath40 the turning point
@xmath102 is roughly equal to @xmath105 regardless of the height from which it originated .
this pattern corresponds to a rapid stopping phase , when the particle quickly drops toward the mid - plane .
when the amplitude of @xmath104 is reduced much below @xmath40 , the turning point @xmath102 is roughly equal to @xmath106 , which corresponds to the oscillatory phase , when the particle follows an epicyclic motion about the mid - plane with a slowly decaying amplitude .
the stopping phase corresponds to the limit where @xmath34 is much larger than the scale height @xmath40 .
note that this situation may not always occur since in the stokes regime , @xmath107 .
this condition corresponds to particles which start at a considerable distance above or below the disk itself .
nonetheless , in this case the solutions simplify to : @xmath108 ( for the downward branch ) and this differential equation can easily be solved with @xmath109 note that the particle velocity in that case varies linearly with time : @xmath110 so that the typical duration of the settling phase is @xmath111
. finally , we also note that for a particle starting from @xmath104 above the disk , for example , the lower turning point is more or less independent of @xmath104 and is roughly equal to @xmath112 .
the oscillating phase corresponds to the limit @xmath113 . in that case
, the equation for the trajectory of the particle ( in the downward branch , for example ) simplifies to @xmath114 this first order differential equation can be solved with conventional substitutions to yield @xmath115 \mbox { . } \ ] ] the lower turning point is then simply @xmath116 starting from that point , the upward branch is then obtained through a similar analysis and becomes @xmath117 \mbox { . } \ ] ] the following upper turning point is @xmath118 such that @xmath119 these equations show that the amplitude @xmath120 of the oscillation slowly decays with time , and can be approximated by @xmath121 where @xmath122 is a constant which is determined in such a way as to satisfy the initial conditions . if the particle is released from rest from @xmath100 at @xmath123 ( with @xmath124 ) , @xmath125 .
moreover the frequency of the oscillation also varies with time , and converges to the epicyclic frequency . to recapitulate briefly
, we find that after a brief stopping phase on a timescale proportional to @xmath126 , the particle oscillates around the mid - plane with frequency which is close to the epicyclic frequency , and with an amplitude that decays slowly in time roughly as given by equation ( [ eq:4 ] ) .
these solutions are illustrated in figure [ fig : veloc ] .
the true particle trajectory in the asymptotic stokes regime can not be expressed analytically in any simple way . as in the epstein case
, we will only look at long - term behavior .
in that case , we can approximate the trajectory of a particle by @xmath127 where @xmath128 and @xmath129 are complicated functions of the initial position and velocity of the particle . for simplicity
, we will consider the asymptotic limit for times @xmath130 . in this limit ,
equation ( [ eq : stotraj ] ) with @xmath131 is a good approximation , since the amplitude of the particle trajectory becomes independent of the point of release ( see fig .
[ fig : veloc ] ) .
let us also assume for the purpose of this work that the phase simply has a given distribution function @xmath132 so that boltzmann function for the stokes regime is @xmath133 where @xmath134 is the column density of particles , and the normalization of @xmath56 is chosen such that @xmath135 .
the function @xmath56 is periodic with period @xmath136 but the initial distribution of particles can be described with @xmath137 . using the well - known relation @xmath138 we can determine the particle mass density profile , @xmath139 \mbox { , } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath140 is a heaviside function and the function @xmath141 takes values in the interval @xmath142 $ ] . as in the epstein case
, we can compare the fluid equation for mass conservation to the first moment of the boltzmann equation and obtain an expression for the collision term in the stokes regime : @xmath143 similar operations with the second moment of the boltzmann equation yields the equivalent of the fluid equation of motion , @xmath144 however , a proper evaluation of the left - hand - side integral shows that this can not be done formally , and the complete expression for the drag force term should be kept . from equations ( [ eq : stotraj ] ) and ( [ eq : fsto ] ) , @xmath145 \mbox { . } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case where @xmath56 is uniformly distributed , this expression reduces to @xmath146 \mbox { , } \end{aligned}\ ] ] whereas the simpler expression @xmath147 in equation ( [ eq : wrongdrag ] ) , which is rewritten @xmath148 in that case , would be wrongly applied .
as before , we are interested in evaluating the velocity dispersion @xmath72 . we need to calculate @xmath149 in the asymptotic limit @xmath150 \\ = & \frac{{\rho_{\rm p}}}{\sigma_{\rm p } } \frac{\dot{\gamma}}{\gamma}z - { { \mathcal h}}(\gamma - |z| ) \nonumber \\ \cdot & \left [ g\left(\cos^{-1}(z/\delta ) - t \right ) - g\left(-\cos^{-1}(z/\delta ) - t \right ) \right ] \mbox {
. } \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , one can show that @xmath151 so that in the asymptotic limit @xmath152 \mbox {
. } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case where the initial distribution function @xmath56 is uniform , we can simplify these expressions greatly and show that for @xmath153 ( which corresponds to the thickness of the dust layer ) then @xmath154 this expression means that within the dust disk , the particle velocity dispersion remains important at all times .
the velocity dispersion mimics the effect of a pressure term which effectively slows down the settling . in this simplified case where @xmath132 was taken to be a uniform distribution
, it is actually possible to relate @xmath155 to intrinsic large - scale properties of the system .
however in the more general case where @xmath132 is not a uniform distribution there exists no simple relationship between @xmath72 and the local density of the gas as there would normally be in a standard fluid . instead , this mock - pressure terms would depend in a complicated manner on the initial configurations of the particles in phase - space .
this prevents any further progress , at this stage , in the use of a fluid description for these large particles .
with this simplified analytical approach , we have explored what effects the gas drag may have on particles of various sizes .
three principal approximations were performed : * we neglected the radial motion of the particles , and therefore implicitly assumed that it is possible to perform a separation of the variables and of the equations of motion into individual components ; * we neglected the vertical variation of @xmath0 and used a simplified expression for the gravity , * we neglected the contribution of the azimuthal motion of the particles through the gas in the calculation of the gas drag in the stokes regime .
this approximation effectively underestimates the gas drag . in order to check the validity of these approximations ,
we begin by integrating the orbits of particles in a realistic gaseous protoplanetary nebula , with the complete expression for the gas drag force .
we compare them to the corresponding analytical expressions .
we then release various single - size sets of 10,000 particles in the disk from a small region and follow their evolution in time . at a given time @xmath156
we then perform the boltzmann averaging procedure and compare the results with those obtained in sections [ sec : eps ] and [ sec : sto ] .
the equation of motion of a particle in a gaseous accretion disk is given by equation ( [ eq : firsteq ] ) .
expanding this equation into its components in a cylindrical coordinate system @xmath157 yields @xmath158 where for small particles , we use the epstein drag force expression @xmath159 and for very large particles , we use the stokes drag force @xmath160 we normalize these expressions using @xmath161 cm as unit distance , and @xmath162s as a unit time .
this yields @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the linear azimuthal keplerian velocity at @xmath165 and where in the epstein regime , @xmath166 and in the stokes regime @xmath167 the numerical integration the particles trajectories in this model is performed using a fourth order range - kutta integrator .
the quantities related to the disk structure ( as the gas density @xmath17 , the gas velocity @xmath168 and the sound speed @xmath18 ) are derived from the protoplanetary nebula model of supulver & lin ( 2000 ) . in this model
, the gas follows a polytropic equation of state with @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the gas pressure , with @xmath171 dyn @xmath172 g@xmath173 , @xmath174 for an ideal diatomic gas ( composed of pure molecular hydrogen for example ) and @xmath175 where @xmath176 is in au and @xmath177 is the square of the disk scale height ( in the dimensionless units ) .
finally , the dimensionless gas velocity is @xmath178 if we ignore the variation of the gas density scale height with radius .
this expression defines @xmath179 uniquely ; with the numerical values of @xmath122 , @xmath180 , given above and using @xmath181 we have @xmath182 .
this expression describes how gas pressure reduces the effective gravity on the gas ; this results in the slightly sub - keplerian character of the gas velocity as found in equation ( [ eq : subk ] ) .
figure [ fig : epstraj ] shows the trajectories of small particles ( 0.1 mm to 1 m ) released at 1au from height 0.01 au , as calculated numerically using the procedure described in section [ sec : numint_desc ] .
it compares the results to those obtained analytically assuming separation of variables and constant @xmath0 which are summarized in equation ( [ eq : epstraj ] ) .
the analytical fit is indistinguishable from the complete numerical solution , despite these approximations .
figure [ fig : stotraj ] shows the numerically integrated orbit of a 10 m sized particle in a protoplanetary nebula , when released from rest at radius 1au and height 0.01 above the mid - plane .
it compares the numerical results to the theoretical predictions given by equation ( [ eq : stotraj ] ) , and here again , despite the approximations , the analytical fit is excellent .
note that integration for much longer times ( about 1000 orbits ) reveals a small but growing discrepancy in the amplitude of the oscillation .
this is due to the mis - representation of the analytical expression for the amplitude of the drag force compared to its true value ( see equations ( [ eq : realf ] ) and ( [ eq : badf ] ) ) .
this discrepancy is discussed in more detail later . in this section
, we now follow the evolution of a collection of 10,000 uniformly sized particles , in the epstein regime ( of size 1 mm ) and in the stokes regime ( with size 10 m ) .
we release all particles from a small interval in radius , for @xmath183 .
the initial radial positions are uniformly distributed in that interval .
other initial conditions depend on the regime studied , in order to be best able to perform the adequate comparisons between theory and numerical experiment . after a time @xmath156 ,
the particles positions and velocities are gathered , and binned into regular intervals in radius and in height . the total number of particles , the average velocity and the average second velocity moment are then calculated for each bin according to the formulae : @xmath184 where the sums are carried out over all particles found within the individual bin centered on the position @xmath185 .
when comparing the numerical data to the analytical solutions of the previous sections , we are careful to apply the correct normalization to the analytical formulae : indeed the normalization of the time variable depends on radial position in the analytical solutions , whereas in the numerical computations , it is normalized to the orbital frequency at 1au . using the normalizations adequate to the numerical calculations , the theoretical solutions for the average particle velocity and dispersion becomes @xmath186 figure [ fig : stateps1 ] shows the very short time evolution of a collection of 10,000 mm - size particles released with a uniform distribution in heights in the interval @xmath187 $ ] au and a uniform distribution in velocities with @xmath188 ( in units of the keplerian velocity at @xmath87 ) .
for this figure , the binning in the averaging process is fairly coarse ( 10 bins in each direction ) in order to generate adequate statistics and to visualize the results more clearly .
the velocity dispersion is indeed found to decay exponentially in accordance with equation ( [ eq : epscomp ] ) .
the trajectory of these particles are then followed up to time @xmath189
( i.e. about 16 orbits ) and their average velocity is computed with a finer binning ( 50 bins in each direction ) .
the results are presented in figure [ fig : stateps2 ] , and compared to the analytical solutions in equation ( [ eq : epscomp ] ) . once again in this regime , the analytical solutions are found to match the numerical results very precisely . in the asymptotic stokes regime , particles oscillate across the mid - plane with an algebraically decaying amplitude
. theoretical analysis of the particles trajectories and velocities shows the velocity dispersion should remain important at all times . in order to simplify the comparison between the analytical solutions in section [ sec : sto ] and the full numerical results , we begin by releasing 10,000 10m - size particles in the disk with similar initial conditions as the ones that were used in the analytical work .
though these initial conditions may seem perhaps artificial , they are the only ones that actually provided any analytical solution .
we specify the initial values @xmath190 where @xmath129 is uniformly distributed in the interval @xmath191 $ ] .
the azimuthal velocity of the particles is the keplerian velocity at the point of release .
we choose these initial values in order to simulate a set of particles released with a large range of velocities and heights above the mid - plane .
the gravitationally bound particles converge toward the mid - plane during the settling phase , and continue to oscillate coherently across the mid - plane with a random phase but roughly all the same slowly decaying amplitude .
the simulation is then started at @xmath123 when all the particles have an oscillation amplitude @xmath192 , the corresponding velocity as given by equation ( [ eq : initzw ] ) with a random phase . in that case , using the same normalization we adopted in our the numerical simulations , we find the theoretical solutions for the velocity dispersion to be @xmath193 figure [ fig : statsto ] compares the results of the numerical calculations to the theoretical solutions given by equation ( [ eq : stopred ] ) . for relatively short time after the onset of the calculation , the numerically obtained dispersion is indeed extremely well approximated by the analytical formula . however , over much longer times , a systematic shift emerges , in which the numerical values are slightly lower than the theoretical solutions .
this slight overestimate of the velocity dispersion comes from the fact that the analytical solutions underestimate the total drag force by neglecting the contributions from the particles motion in the radial and azimuthal direction . in order to verify this conjecture ,
another numerical experiment is carried out in which the drag force is artificially set to @xmath194 in that case , the contribution of the drag force in the vertical direction is exactly that used in analytical calculation . as expected
, the analytical expression is now able to reproduce the experimental results much more accurately .
having gained some experience with the boltzmann averaging methods , and having moreover established the adequacy of the analytical approximations to the particles trajectories in the stokes regime , we now attempt to use the results of the numerical simulations to find the evolution of the particles dispersion in the case where the initial conditions are chosen randomly ( rather than in such a way as to allow easy analytical calculations ) . in the follow up numerical computation ,
10,000 10m - size particles are released with a uniform initial height and vertical velocity distribution chosen in the intervals @xmath187 $ ] au and @xmath187v_{\rm k}(r)$ ] .
the azimuthal velocity of the particles is set to be the keplerian velocity at the point of release . with these initial conditions
, the initial velocity dispersion should be uniform within the dust layer .
figure [ fig : storand ] shows the evolution with time of this dispersion profile at radius @xmath87 au , when the particles are binned in 20 intervals in radius and heights . after a brief adjustment phase ( not shown in the figure ) , the dispersion profile seems to be well approximated by a gaussian distribution .
we attempt to match such a gaussian profile to the numerical data points , and find that the best fit is given by @xmath195 where @xmath196 .
this formula was obtained from the following heuristic arguments : according to the formula for the particles vertical motion ( see equation [ eq : stotraj ] ) , the typical vertical velocity of the particles near the mid - plane is of the order of @xmath197 , where @xmath84 is the maximum height of the particles above the mid - plane .
moreover , @xmath84 decays with time due to gas drag according to equation ( [ eq:4 ] ) , so that one can readily deduce the evolution of @xmath197 for a set of particles released at @xmath123 from typical heights ranging between 0 and @xmath198 .
the numerical factors have been fitted to the data .
the analytical fit is also shown in figure [ fig : storand ] , and is found to reproduce the evolution of @xmath155 satisfactorily .
finally , recalling that the analytical expression for the particles vertical motion slightly underestimates the true drag force , we compare the analytical fit given by equation ( [ eq : sigmafit1 ] ) to an artificial simulation in which the drag force is given by equation ( [ eq : fakef ] ) . in principle , the fit should be much better in this case .
however , we find that the evolution of the dispersion in that case is better fitted by @xmath199 whilst keeping the expression for @xmath197 the same ( see figure [ fig : storand ] ) .
though this difference is small , it still suggests that any attempt to find an analytical fit to the collective motion of stokes particles should be carefully calibrated before being used in further simulations . to conclude this section , it was found that the analytical evaluation of one particle s orbit was extremely useful toward the determination of the collective motion of a large number of particles , and that the resulting averaged equations fit the numerical experiments extremely well .
we have also been able to determine a simple heuristic way of closing the moments equations at low order in the case of particles in the stokes regime , which emulates the effect of the particles dispersion by a mock pressure term that _ can _ be related to large - scale properties ( and initial conditions ) of the fluid .
having discussed the time - evolution of a large number of particles of equal size , we now consider a population of different - size particles .
again , the boltzmann approach proves useful and simple to use .
let us assume for simplicity that for a given size , and at a given radius , the _ initial _ particles to gas mass ratio is independent of @xmath34 .
hence the initial distribution of particles of a given size @xmath11 at time @xmath123 is @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the typical gas disk height ; for an isothermal disk , @xmath202 .
let us also assume ( again for simplicity ) that the initial vertical velocity of particles is null .
this idealized _ ad hoc _ setup could correspond to a condensation front where , at time @xmath123 , both hydrogen and heavy elemental gas diffuses into a cool region of the disk .
the condensation and sublimation time scales are generally much shorter than the dynamical time scales ( supulver & lin 2000 ) so that , at least the small grains may form with a similar density distribution as the gas and without any initial in - falling motion .
the coexistence of large and small particles well above the mid plane requires runaway coagulation of initially steady , microscopic dust grains into grains up to a size @xmath11 .
this rapid _ in situ _ growth is possible in regions where the particles have large surface density and much greater than unity area filling factor because the particles collision and growth time scales are short compared with their dynamical time scale .
the particles then start settling from their initial positions , and interact with the gas mostly with an epstein drag law .
the particles density distribution at time @xmath156 is then simply : @xmath203 where @xmath47 is defined by equation ( [ eq:5 ] ) , and @xmath204 is the evolving dust layer thickness .
this equation was derived from ( [ eq:3 ] ) using the ansatz ( [ eq:6 ] ) and @xmath205 .
we can deduce from this result the number distribution of particles of size @xmath11 @xmath206 where we have defined the constant @xmath207 such that @xmath208 in order to write explicitly this equation in terms of its dependence on the particle size .
the initial particle size distribution function is taken to be that given by hellyer ( 1970 ) and mathis _ et al . _
( 1977 ) @xmath209 at a given height above the disk , this distribution function peaks for small particle sizes ( which corresponds to the initial peak in @xmath210 ) , but has another maximum , which evolves with time , at approximately @xmath211 regardless of the initial size distribution function of the particles .
this result is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : nheight ] .
these results shown in figures [ fig : ntime ] and [ fig : nheight ] suggest the following comments .
firstly , at a given height , successive fronts of particles with decreasing sizes pass through the gas as they settle , to leave the region completely depleted of the intermediate sized particles . secondly , at a given time , there is a definite stratification of the particles in terms of their respective sizes , with the larger particles concentrating tightly around the mid - plane .
note that this method is only valid for particles with sizes up to the order of the mean - free - path of the gas .
for the very large particles , the stokes drag law must be applied . in that case , we have shown in section [ sec : sto ] that the large particles only settle algebraically toward the mid - plane . as a result , although their number density is small , the large particles remain important at all times and at all heights in the disk .
this work shows that after a few settling times ( which are of the order of a few thousands of orbits for cm - sized particles ) , the bulk of the disk will be depleted of intermediate sized particles , which have all settled down to the mid - plane .
there remains , at all heights , very small particles that have not had time to settle , and very large ones which are in a phase of oscillation around the mid - plane .
in this paper , we provide a set of analytic solutions to describe the sedimentation of dust particles due to gas drag in a protostellar accretion disk .
the main effect of the gas drag is to induce a loss of angular momentum and linear momentum for the particle , which in turn leads to orbital decay and vertical settling .
numerical integration of the particles trajectories in a protoplanetary accretion disk is straightforward if we assume that the gas flow is laminar and occurs mostly in the azimuthal direction .
however , analytical integration is also possible given a set of assumptions ( which have been checked here to be reasonably well justified ) , including the separability of the radial and vertical motion , and locally uniform density .
accordingly , we have extracted analytical formulae for the vertical motion of particles in a disk , both in the epstein regime ( for particles with size much smaller than the mean - free - path of the gas molecules ) and in the stokes regime ( for particles much larger than the mean - free - path ) .
comparison of these analytical expressions with the complete numerically integrated orbits shows an excellent match in both cases . by using the analytical expression for the particles orbits
, we were able to extract their average behavior using a standard boltzmann analysis ( i.e. local averaging , or rather , coarse - graining , of the particles positions and velocities in phase space ) .
the successive moments of the boltzmann distribution function provide the evolution of the coarse - grained particle density , velocity and velocity dispersion .
the successive moments of the boltzmann equation yield the equivalent of `` fluid '' equations for the collection of particles , and in particular a mass conservation equation and a momentum equation .
numerical experiments were performed in which 10,000 single - size particles were released in the disk from a localized region of phase - space ( typically uniformly distributed in space and with a uniform vertical velocity distribution ) . using a similar coarse - graining method as the one used in the analytical analysis , we were able to extract the particle density profile , their average velocity and velocity dispersion from the numerical integration .
we compared them to the analytical formulae obtained previously .
the main results are summarized here . in the epstein regime
, there is an excellent agreement between the analytic formulae and the results of the numerical calculation .
individual particles have their velocity with respect to the gas quickly damped out on a very short stopping timescale .
correspondingly , their collective behavior is coherent : the typical velocity dispersion is found to decay on the particle stopping timescale , which is usually much smaller than the orbital timescale . for times longer than the stopping timescale
, individual particles settle exponentially toward the mid - plane and the corresponding average momentum equation reduces to a simple standard fluid equation with a linear drag term , and null pressure . in the stokes regime , there is a good agreement between the theory and the results of the numerical experiments .
individual particles are found to oscillate across the mid - plane with an algebraically decaying amplitude .
although this behavior is very well reproduced by the analytical work , there exists a small discrepancy between analytical formulae and the results of numerical computation in the form of a slight systematic overestimate of the particles oscillation amplitude .
this problem is due to an ( unfortunately unavoidable ) over - simplification of the amplitude of the drag force in the analytical work , and results in similar discrepancies in the comparison of averaged quantities .
nonetheless , apart from this small identifiable and controllable error , the predictions of the analytical work match very well the numerical results .
as expected , the particles velocity dispersion is found to remain large at all times within the dust layer , with a maximum near the mid - plane .
this large dispersion is directly related to the continuous oscillatory motion of the particles across the mid - plane .
we found it extremely difficult to obtain analytical predictions of the temporal evolution of the dispersion for anything but the simplest initial conditions - which were not necessarily always realistic .
however , we were able to deduce from the numerical experiments a heuristic fit to the observed evolution of the particles dispersion , for more general initial conditions .
this result has interesting consequences with respect to the possibility of closing the moments equations at low order , and describing accordingly the evolution of a collection of large particles with averaged fluid equations .
we will test this theory in future work .
finally , by combining the average evolution equations for single - size particles obtained in the epstein regime to a plausible size - distribution function for dust - grains in the ism ( hellyer , 1970 , mathis _ et al . _ , 1977 ) , we showed that it is possible to follow analytically the spatial and temporal evolution of such a size - distribution as the particles settle toward the mid - plane .
this analytical calculation was done for collisionless particles , and the extension of this work to include collisions , coagulation and sublimation would probably require numerical analysis .
nonetheless , within this approximation we found that the sedimentation process results in a very strong segregation of particles according to their sizes , within a timescale of a few hundreds of years only .
all intermediate - size particles quickly converge to the mid - plane , leaving behind only the very small particles , indirectly supported against the settling by gas pressure , and the very large particles , which keep oscillating across the mid - plane with a slowly decaying amplitude .
this segregation process may well suggest that within the very thin dust layer at the mid - plane , one could approximate the population of dust particles by a single - size population . in future work , we shall apply the results obtained here to two essential purposes : * the description of the particles as a continuum fluid will be used to study the stability of the dust layer against shearing ( garaud _ et al .
_ , in preparation ) , in order to test whether gravitational instability can indeed take place in the dust layer .
more generally , we intend to implement this description into existing 3d hydrodynamics codes for the computation of accretion disks , in order to obtain a fully self - consistent description of dust evolution and growth in these disks ; * the temporal and spation evolution of the size - distribution of particles can be compared directly with observations of dust .
we plan to construct models with which we can infer the extent of particle coagulation and infer the surface density distribution of the gas from high resolution , multi - wavelength ( mostly in the sub - mm and mm range ) maps of protostellar disks .
pascale garaud thanks new hall ( cambridge ) and pparc for financial support towards the completion of this work .
it was also supported in part by nasa through grant nag5 - 10612 and the california space institute .
the authors thank neil balmforth and taku takeuchi for many useful discussions .
neglecting the vertical motion of the particles , the equations of motion in the radial and azimuthal directions in the epstein regime are @xmath212 where @xmath213 is the slightly sub - keplerian azimuthal velocity of the gas @xmath214 which defines @xmath215 . as in section 2.3 , we use the normalizations @xmath216 = r = 1 $ ] and @xmath217 = { \omega_{\rm k}}^{-1}(r)$ ] to obtain @xmath218 it is not possible to find simple analytical solutions of the full system .
however , we can assume that deviations from keplerian motions are small , and that the particle velocity can be written as @xmath219 the linearized system yields ( assuming that the background quantities vary very little with @xmath176 ) @xmath220 substituting the first into the second yields @xmath221 hence the local solution is @xmath222 this solution represents the local difference between the particle velocity and the keplerian velocity , in units of the keplerian velocity . as in the solution found in section [ sec : sto ] , the first term represents a very quick stopping of the particle on timescale @xmath40 and the second term represents a constant inward drift .
the variation of this drift velocity with particle size is given by the function @xmath223 which has a maximum for @xmath224 .
this result reproduces the results found by weidenschilling ( 1977 ) .
adachi i. , hayashi c. , nakazawa k. , 1976 , prog .
phys . , 56 , 1756 adams , f. c. , lada , c. j. , shu , f. h. 1987 , , 312 , 788 balbus , s. a , hawley , j. f. , 1990 , , 376 , 214 beckwith , s.v.w . 1999 , in _ the origin of stars and planetary system _ , eds c.j .
lada and n.d .
kylafis , kluwer academic , 579 boltzmann , l. , 1872 , wien berichten , 66 , 275 clarke , c. j. , gendrin , a. , & sotomayor , m. 2001 , mnras , 328 , 485 dalessio , p. , calvet , n. , & hartmann , l. 2001 , , 553 , 321 goldreich p. , ward w. r. , 1973 , , 183 , 1051 haisch , k. e. jr . , lada , e. a. & lada , c. j. 2001 , , 553 , 153 hellyer b. , 1970 , mnras , 148 , 383 hayashi , c. nagazawa , k. , nagagawa , y. 1985 , in _ protostars and planets ii _
, eds d. black and m. mathews , u arizona press , 1100 klahr , h. h. , lin , d. n. c. , 2001 , , 554 , 1095 laplace , p.s . de 1796 , _ exposition du systme du monde _ , paris marcy , g. w. , cochran , w. d. , & mayor , m. 2000 , in protostars and planets iv , ed v. mannings , a. p. boss , & s. s. russell ( tucson : univ . of arizona press ) , 1285 mathis j. s. , rumpl w. , nordsieck k. h. , 1977 , , 217 , 425 pollack , j.b . , hubickyj , o. , bodenheimer , p. , lissauer , j.j . , podolak , m. , & greenzweig , y. 1996 , icarus , 124 , 62 prosser , c. f. , stauffer , j. r. , hartmann , l. , soderblom , d. r. , jones , b. f. , werner , m. w. , mccaughrean , m. j. 1994 , , 421 , 517 sekiya , m. , 1998 , icarus , 133 , 298 shuping , r. y. , bally , j. , morris , m. & throop , h. 2003 , 587 , 109 supulver k. d. , lin d. n. c. , 2000 , icarus 146 , 525 takeuchi , t , artymowicz , p. , 2001
, , 557 , 990 takeuchi , t. , lin , d. n. c. , 2002 , , 581 , 1344 thi , w.f . ,
pontoppidan , k. m. , van dishoeck , e.f . , dartois , e. & dhendecourt , l. 2002 , a & a , 394 , 27 throop , h. b. , bally , j. , esposito , l. w. , mccaughrean , m. j. 2001 , science , 292 , 1686 weidenschilling s. j. , 1977 , mnras , 180 , 57 weidenschilling , s.j .
1984 , icarus , 60,553 weidenschilling s. j. , cuzzi , j. n. , 1993 , _ protostars & planets iii _ , 1031 wyatt , m. c. , dermott , s. f. , telesco , c. m. , fisher , r. s. , grogan , k. , holmes , e. k. , pina , r. k. 1999 , , 527 918 whipple f. l. , 1972,_from plasma to planet _ , ed .
a. elvius , wiley , london youdin , a. n , shu , f. h. , 2002 , , 580 , 494 zuckerman , b. , forveille , t. , & kastner , j. h. 1995 , nature , 373 , 494 | we study the interaction between gas and dust particles in a protoplanetary disk , comparing analytical and numerical results .
we first calculate analytically the trajectories of individual particles undergoing gas drag in the disk , in the asymptotic cases of very small particles ( epstein regime ) and very large particles ( stokes regime ) . using a boltzmann averaging method
, we then infer their collective behavior .
we compare the results of this analytical formulation against numerical computations of a large number of particles . using successive moments of the boltzmann equation
, we derive the equivalent fluid equations for the average motion of the particles ; these are intrinsically different in the epstein and stokes regimes .
we are also able to study analytically the temporal evolution of a collection of particles with a given initial size - distribution provided collisions are ignored . |
trapped ions are among the most promising physical systems for implementing quantum information due to their long coherence time as compared with the times required for quantum logic operations @xcite .
a robust quantum memory is a crucial part of the realization of an ion trap based quantum computer @xcite .
one may distinguish different possibilities for encoding a qubit in a trapped ion , either one uses a long lived metastable state and drives coherent transitions on the corresponding optical transition @xcite , which sets challenging requirements on the laser source and ultimately limits the coherence time to the lifetime of the metastable state .
alternatively , a qubit can be encoded in sublevels of the electronic ground state .
this may be either hyperfine ground state levels @xcite or zeeman ground states @xcite which are coherently manipulated by means of stimulated raman transitions . for conventional single - ion qubits encoded in the zeeman sublevels as in @xmath0ca@xmath1
are less favorable , as compared with hyperfine qubits in magnetically insensitive clock states @xcite , as their energy splitting depends linearly on the magnetic field
. already small magnetic field fluctuations of about 0.2 t limit the coherence to 250 @xmath2s @xcite .
we follow in our proposal an elegant alternative @xcite to boost the robustness of such qubits by using a decoherence - free subspace ( dfs ) @xcite .
we employ odd bell states as the computational basis of _ logical qubits _ @xmath3 and @xmath4 with the overhead of having two physical spin qubits .
ground states @xmath5 and @xmath6 do not perform any bit flip errors . magnetic field or laser phase fluctuation
would lead to errors for a single ion , but in the chosen bell states such fluctuations are identical for both ions in the logical qubit .
this assures that such states can maintain coherent of up to 20 s and single qubit operations in dfs , have been demonstrated @xcite .
a universal set of single and two qubit operations between logical qubits has been proposed @xcite and recently performed with a fidelity of @xmath7 @xcite , and it would be desirable to reach a fidelity of better than 99@xmath8 also for dfs gates . in this paper we show how these two - qubit gate operations could be improved by a novel scheme , which do not require individual ion addressing .
the single ion addressing was identified as one of the major difficulties and one of the main source of loss in fidelity in the experiment .
our scheme is based on _ homogeneous _ illumination of the four ions .
additionally , our proposed gate operates in a raman type of laser excitation between ground state dfs logic qubits , an additional promising a fidelity improvement as compared with the metastable , thus 1.2 s long lived basis states in ref .
we carefully investigated all contributions to the spin - dependent light force @xcite , and optimized the scheme .
furthermore , we generalize the scheme for a scalable approach of quantum computing , fig.[fig1 ] . with gate times of about 25 @xmath2s , more that 5 orders of magnitude faster the decoherence time , the required overhead to handle two ions for one qubit appears to be relatively small .
even more important , such favorable separation of time scales would pave the way to realize quantum error correction @xcite .
it further allows for transporting ion crystals in segmented micro ion traps @xcite for the creation of cluster states @xcite and operations with a large number of ions for ultimate scalability of quantum information processing .
the present paper is organized as follows : sec .
[ 2 ] describes the optimized scheme of the dfs gate between two logical qubits . in sec . [ 3 ] we show that the gate is suitable for the scalable gate operations of many logical qubits and specifically for the creation of cluster states without leaving the dfs . in sec . [ 4 ] we analyze several error sources relevant to an experimental implementation of our method .
some of the errors stem from a single gate operation , some of them occur when transporting logical qubits to achieve scalability . finally , in sec .
[ 5 ] we give a summary of the results .
we consider a linear crystal of four ions confined in a linear paul trap with trap frequency @xmath9 .
the qubit is encoded in the zeeman ground states levels @xmath10 @xmath11 and @xmath12 of the s@xmath13 ground state of the ion @xcite .
the linear ion crystal simultaneously interacts with two non - copropagating laser beams with frequency difference @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the @xmath16th vibrational frequency of the ion crystal and @xmath17 is the detuning from the vibrational frequency ( @xmath18 ) .
in contrast to the center - of - mass mode , the higher energy vibrational modes are less sensitive to the heating due to fluctuating ambient electric field because it requires short - wavelength components of the field to heat it @xcite . the laser is detuned from the s@xmath19 @xmath20p@xmath19 transition with large detuning @xmath21 and couples only the vibrational levels for each of the spin states according to fig .
[ fig2]a .
the qubit is encoded in the zeeman sublevels @xmath22 and @xmath23 of the s@xmath19 ground state .
s@xmath19 @xmath24 p@xmath19 transition is driven by a pair of laser beams .
each of the lasers is circularly polarized with balanced @xmath25 and @xmath26 components .
@xmath27 is the single beam rabi frequency of the coupling between the ground states @xmath28 and the excited state of the @xmath29th ion .
b ) logical qubits basis states are indicated by the dashed boxes . when the spins of middle two ions are aligned in opposite directions the light force driving
the gate cancels .
if and only if the middle two spins are aligned in the same directions the force pushes the ions in different direction.,width=340 ] the interaction hamiltonian for a string of four ions simultaneously interacting with a single laser pulse in the lamb - dicke limit and rotating wave approximation is given by @xcite @xmath30here @xmath31 and @xmath32 are the creation and annihilation operators of phonons in the @xmath16th vibrational mode , @xmath33 is the spread of the ground state wavepacket for the respective vibrational mode , @xmath34 is the ion mass and @xmath35 runs over all spin configurations of the four ions .
the absolute static ac stark shift of the energies of the qubit states is given by @xmath36 , where @xmath37 ( @xmath38 ) is the rabi frequency pertaining to single beam , fig .
this shift is generally different for the qubit states @xmath39 and @xmath40 , thereby induces additional phase in the qubit evolution .
the spatiotemporally varying differential shift , which gives rise to the spin - dependent force is @xmath41 . for the e - mode ( @xmath42 )
the first and fourth ions oscillate out of phase and with equal amplitudes with the second and third ions @xcite .
therefore , the magnitude of the laser - ion coupling is the same for all four ions , but opposite in sign with respect to the middle two ions .
the force on the collective spin states due to differential stark shift for the e - mode is given by @xmath43where @xmath44 is the laser wave vector difference along the trap axis .
the position - dependent phase is equal to @xmath45 , where @xmath46 with @xmath47 is the dimensionless equilibrium position of the @xmath29th ion and @xmath48 is the length scale parameter .
@xmath49 is the phase difference between the driving fields .
the unitary operator for the hamiltonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) is given by@xmath50where @xmath51 \left\vert \mathbf{s}_{i}\right\rangle \left\langle \mathbf{s% } _ { i}\right\vert \label{d}\]]is the state - dependent displacement operator with @xmath52the state - dependent geometric phase @xmath53appears due to non - commutativity of the interaction hamiltonian at different times .
we project the unitary operator ( [ propagator ] ) onto the dfs under consideration : \{@xmath54 , @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57}. these states are immune to collective dephasing caused by magnetic field fluctuations .
we adjust the trap potential such that @xmath58where @xmath59 is integer .
this optimizes the motional coupling to the e - mode as can be seen from eq .
( [ force ] ) . in fig .
[ fig3 ] we plot the spin - dependent forces for the e - mode as a function of the length scale parameter @xmath60 .
the spin - dependent forces @xmath61 and @xmath62 vary as a function of @xmath63 and vanish for @xmath64 , while the forces @xmath65 and @xmath66 displace the motional state in opposite directions . at the same point two of the spin - dependent forces for the center - of - mass mode
are zero , hence the off - resonant excitations of this mode do not take place . during the time evolution the motional state moves along a circular path in phase space and returns to the origin after time @xmath67 , while the spin states acquire geometric phases @xmath68 . in this case
the force displaces the ions if the spins of the middle two ions are aligned in the same direction and cancel if the spins are opposite , fig .
after time @xmath69 the states for which the force is not canceled acquire geometric phases @xmath70 . by proper choice of the rabi frequencies @xmath71 and @xmath72 one can adjust the geometric phases to be @xmath73 and the action of the gate onto the dfs states is given by @xmath74the dfs gate ( [ gate ] ) is a controlled - phase gate between two logical decoherence - free qubits .
hence , the unitary evolution transforms any superposition of the states belonging to the dfs into another superposition of those states .
note that the gate operation does require an ion localization well within the lamb dicke regime but no ground state cooling of the gate mode , similar to the geometric phase two - qubit gate @xcite . additionally to the geometric phase the qubit states acquire extra phase due to ac stark shift @xmath75 so that we have @xmath76 and @xmath77 , where @xmath78 .
the phase is proportional to the laser intensity thereby it is making the gate implementation very sensitive to laser - intensity fluctuations .
however , as long as the four ion chain is addressed uniformly and the quantum information is encoded in the dfs the ac stark shift causes only global phase in eq .
( [ gate ] ) .
the effect of slightly inhomogeneous illumination of the ions - accounting for the experimental reality - and the implication of the gate fidelity will be discussed in section [ 4 ]
in general , two approaches for scalable quantum computing with ion string are viable .
the one aims for a long ion crystal , where all ions share common modes of vibration which allow to drive gate operations between them . the seminal paper by cirac and zoller @xcite proposed axial modes and more recently it has been proposed to use the radial modes of a large ion crystal @xcite .
the fundamentally different approach aims to shuttle ions in segmented traps @xcite , such that only two logical qubits are in the processor region during the quantum gate operation .
if the second approach is joined with gate operations in dfs and logical qubits , a maximum of four ions is kept in the central processor unit and pairs of ions are shuttled together using the control segments of the trap ( [ fig1 ] ) .
a large separation of time scales for a gate with about 100 ms transport operations are viable in the ms range @xcite , as well as a obtaining error syndromes if one aims for quantum error correction , where the readout of fluorescence is necessary . in order to implement a multi qubit controlled phase gate we can decompose it in a sequence of single qubit gates and geometric phase gates between the logical qubits @xcite .
the single logical qubits ( pair of ions ) can be trapped in the storage zone and then can be transported to the processing zone where the gate operations are performed , fig .
for instance , a three bit decoherence - free geometric gate is decomposed as @xmath79 . here
@xmath80 is the toffoli gate between the first two control logical qubits and the auxillary logical qubit which is prepared initially in the state @xmath81 .
the second operation @xmath82 is the geometric phase gate between the target logical qubit and the auxillary qubit .
the final toffoli gate is applied to restore the auxillary qubit in the state @xmath81 .
the toffoli gate also can be decomposed as a succession of hadamard gates and geometric phase gates between the logical qubits .
therefore any of the gate operations is realized with two ions ( single qubit operations ) and with four ions ( two qubit operations ) where the proposed method can be applied .
the generalization to n - bit geometric phase gate is straightforward : @xmath83 . as an example
we describe the method for the generation of a linear cluster state .
cluster states are highly entangled states , which are the fundamental resource of the one - way quantum computer @xcite .
cluster states have been experimentally created with atoms in optical lattice @xcite and with photons @xcite .
multi - qubit cluster states have yet not been created with trapped ions .
an ion - trap architecture for high - speed measurement - based quantum computer was proposed @xcite .
@xcite proposed an efficient technique for the creation of four , five , and six qubit linear cluster states by collective bichromatic interaction , while in @xcite creation of two - dimensional cluster state was suggested by using a spin - spin coupling induced by a magnetic - field gradient . here , we propose the creation of four linear cluster state , without leaving the dfs .
if the gate ( gate ) is applied onto the decoherence - free initial state @xmath84 , which is a product of two bell states @xmath85 , then the geometric phase gate transforms the state to @xmath86the final state is highly entangled four qubit cluster state . since the spin states are not mixed due to the unitary evolution ( [ propagator ] ) , the initial state is transformed into the final cluster state without leaving the dfs . combining the ion trap architecture and the transport of such states in a segmented trap , ( see fig .
[ fig1 ] ) large cluster states can be created by fusing several four linear cluster states with the dfs gate .
during the gate evolution on the axial e - mode , also the other vibrational modes are off - resonantly excited there might be a non - vanishing coupling strength ; however all radial motional degrees of freedom of the four ion crystal are excluded by the geometry of the laser excitation .
we try to optimize the gate fidelity by analyzing and avoiding spurious ac light force driving on all other modes . for general coupling strengths and @xmath87 ,
the displacement and geometric phase associated with the @xmath16th vibrational mode is given by @xmath88 .
\label{alfa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as now the absolute force magnitude and the final time are fixed such that the geometric phase gate condition is fulfilled , @xmath89 , one obtains parasitic displacement and geometric phases @xmath90 .
\label{alfa}\end{aligned}\]]an appropriate measure of the gate fidelity is given by @xcite : @xmath91where @xmath92 is the dimension of the dfs and @xmath93 each run over all spin configurations belonging to dfs .
@xmath94 is the desired unitary transform given by eq .
[ gate ] and @xmath95 is the actual one . neither @xmath94 nor @xmath96 is mixing the spin states .
the action of @xmath95 on any basis state is simply given by @xmath97where @xmath98 indicates the ground state of all axial modes .
the fidelity can then be evaluated under consideration of the matrix element @xmath99 .
hence , we obtain for the fidelity at time @xmath100 @xmath101 .
the values of the axial trap frequency @xmath102 and the rabi frequency @xmath103 required for implementation of the dfs gate for three different vibrational modes .
the infidelity due to the off - resonant excitation is also presented .
the frequency plateaus , where the gate fidelity is better than @xmath104 are listed in order to elucidate the sensitivity on this parameter . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] as an example of qubit we consider the @xmath0ca@xmath1 ion with qubit states encoded in the zeeman sublevels of s@xmath19 state .
the two - photon raman transition is driven by a laser field with a wave length of @xmath105 nm and a wave vector difference along the trap axis @xmath106 . in order to cancel the spin forces @xmath107 and @xmath108 , eq . ( [ condition ] ) we choose distance parameter @xmath109 .
the rabi frequencies are @xmath110 with gate time @xmath111 @xmath112s and a laser detuning @xmath113 khz .
table i lists the values of the axial trap frequency @xmath102 and the rabi frequency @xmath103 needed for the synthesis of the dfs gate for the three different vibrational modes .
we compare the minimum gate infidelity @xmath114 mediated by different vibrational modes due to the off - resonant excitations , ( see , fig .
[ fig4 ] ) . even for one cycle in phase space
@xmath115 the infidelity for the e - mode is smallest since the off - resonant excitation of the center - of mass mode for spin states @xmath116 and @xmath117 vanishes . in fig .
[ fig5 ] we show the fidelity ( [ fidelity ] ) as a function of the axial trap frequency @xmath102 for fixed gate time @xmath69 .
the rabi frequency is chosen such that the condition @xmath118 is fulfilled .
the frequency plateaus , where the minimum fidelity is better than @xmath104 for the gate implementation mediated by the different vibrational modes are listed in table [ table ] .
additionally , the proposed gate scheme shows a remarkable robustness against laser intensity fluctuations .
as both laser beams are derived from the same laser source , we assume that the intensity fluctuations are common .
the corresponding rabi frequencies fluctuate therefore simultaneously for all ions . as a result
, we observe that the fidelity only decrease quadratically with the fluctuations , see fig .
[ fig6 ] .
the ac stark shift from the raman beams can be compensated by a proper choice of polarizations of both beam or by employing an additional compensation beam @xcite .
the precision of this compensation is only limited by the spin coherence time , in a typical experiment one might reach an accuracy @xmath119 well below 1 khz .
such shifts scramble the spin qubit phases as they translate laser intensity fluctuations into effective magnetic field fluctuations . however , the logical qubits are inherently robust against spin phase fluctuations .
errors might only occur when the when an uncompensated ac stark shift is accompanied by an inhomogeneous illumination of two ions which comprise a logical qubit . as this error of higher order , with a fraction of the above number
, we do not take it into further consideration . in a fusing process of three logical qubits for the scalable scheme discussed above , when in the first step two of the qubits are exposed to the gate laser field while the third qubit is not illuminated , even an uncompensated ac stark shift would not lead to errors as long as the logical qubits are illuminated equally . finally , the coherence of qubits in dfs is limited by the fluctuations of the gradient of the magnetic field over the distance of the two ion crystal , a few @xmath2 m .
when transporting such logical qubits in the trap one may expose them to varying magnetic gradients , however the phase evolution of the logical qubits is deterministic @xcite and can be easily corrected for .
the motional decoherence of the vibrational motion of the trapped ions is the most serious limiting factor in ion trap quantum information processing . in order to achieve high fidelity
the gate time @xmath69 required for the implementation of dfs gate ( [ gate ] ) must be much shorter than the heating time @xmath120 .
the measured heating time of the center of mass mode for @xmath0ca@xmath1 ion in a segmented micro - ion traps @xcite was found to be 3.3 ms , a typical value for this devices .
the heating time for higher energy modes is expected to be much larger .
hence the gate time is more than two orders of magnitude faster than the heating time such that the fidelity of the gate is not affected .
in conclusion we proposed a simple and robust technique for a decoherence - free controlled phase gate between two logical qubits .
we studied in detail the fidelity of the gate implementation taking into account various error sources such as off - resonant transitions , laser fluctuations , and the deviation of the right choice of the axial trap frequency .
we have compared the error sources for a gate mediated by three different modes , and we have shown that the gate mediated by the egyptian mode minimizes the off - resonant transitions .
our scheme includes the creation of a linear cluster state within a decoherence free subspace manifold of four qubits - a starting point for decoherence - free ion trap one way quantum computing .
this work has been supported by the european commission projects emali ( contract no mrtn - ct-2006 - 035369 ) , microtrap ( contract no .
517675 ) , the bulgarian nsf grants vu - f-205/06 , vu - i-301/07 , d002 - 90/08 , and the elite programme of the landesstiftung baden - wrttemberg . | we propose a geometric phase gate in a decoherence - free subspace with trapped ions .
the quantum information is encoded in the zeeman sublevels of the ground state and two physical qubits to make up one logical qubit with ultra long coherence time .
single- and two - qubit operations together with the transport and splitting of linear ion crystals allow for a robust and decoherence - free scalable quantum processor .
for the ease of the phase gate realization we employ one raman laser field on four ions simultaneously , i.e. no tight focus for addressing .
the decoherence - free subspace is left neither during gate operations nor during the transport of quantum information . |
for the purposes of the discussion in this section , we assume that appropriate approximate marginal distributions are available .
as discussed in a later section , they may be provided by coarse models of the physical problem as in the examples below , or they may be calculated via the methods in @xcite and @xcite .
assume that the @xmath0 dimensional system of interest has a probability density , @xmath1 , where @xmath2 .
suppose further that , by the metropolis - hastings or any other method ( see @xcite ) , we can construct a markov chain , @xmath3 , which has @xmath4 as its stationary measure .
that is , for two points @xmath5 @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the probability density of a move to @xmath8 given that @xmath9 .
here , @xmath10 is the algorithmic step . under appropriate conditions ( see @xcite ) , averages over a trajectory of @xmath11 will converge to averages over @xmath4 , i.e. for an objective function @xmath12 @xmath13\ ] ] the size of the error in the above limit decreases as the rate of decay of the time autocorrelation @xmath14 = \\ \frac{\mathbf{e}\left [ \left(g\left(y_0^n\right)-\mathbf{e}\left[g\left(x_0\right)\right]\right ) \left(g\left(y_0
^ 0\right)-\mathbf{e}\left[g\left(x_0\right)\right]\right)\right ] } { \mathbf{var}\left[g\left(x_0\right)\right]}\end{gathered}\ ] ] increases . in this formula , @xmath15 is assumed to be drawn from @xmath4 . it is well known that judicious elimination of variables by renormalization can reduce long range spatial correlations ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
the variables are removed by averaging out their effects on the full distribution . if the original density is @xmath16 and we wish to remove the @xmath17 variables , the distribution of the remaining @xmath18 variables is given by the marginal density ( see @xcite ) @xmath19 the full distribution can be factored as @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the conditional density of @xmath17 given @xmath18 . because they exhibit shorter correlation lengths , the marginal distributions are useful in the acceleration of markov chain monte carlo methods . with this in mind
we consider a collection of lower dimensional markov chains @xmath22 which have stationary distributions @xmath23 where @xmath24 .
for each @xmath25 let @xmath26 be the transition probability density of @xmath27 , i.e. @xmath28 is the probability density of @xmath29 given that @xmath30 .
the @xmath31 are approximate marginal distributions .
for example , divide the @xmath32 variables into two subsets , @xmath33 and @xmath34 , so that @xmath35 .
the @xmath36 variables represent the variables of @xmath32 that are removed by marginalization , i.e. @xmath37 after arranging these chains in parallel we have the larger process @xmath38 the probability density of a move to @xmath39 given that @xmath40 for @xmath41 is given by @xmath42 since @xmath43 the stationary distribution of @xmath44 is @xmath45 the next step in the construction is to allow interactions between the chains @xmath46 and to thereby pass information from the rapidly equilibrating chains on the lower dimensional spaces ( large @xmath47 ) down to the chain on the original space ( @xmath48 ) .
this is accomplished by swap moves . in a swap move between levels @xmath47 and @xmath49 , we take a @xmath50 dimensional subset , @xmath51 , of the @xmath32 variables and exchange them with the @xmath52 variables .
the remaining @xmath53 @xmath36 variables are resampled from the conditional distribution @xmath54 . for the full chain , this swap takes the form of a move from @xmath40 to @xmath39 where @xmath55 and @xmath56 the ellipses represent components of @xmath44 that remain unchanged in the transition and @xmath57 is drawn from @xmath54 . if these swaps are undertaken unconditionally , the resulting chain with equilibrate rapidly , but will not , in general , preserve the product distribution @xmath58 . to remedy this
we introduce the swap acceptance probability @xmath59 in this formula @xmath60 is the function on @xmath61 resulting from marginalization of @xmath62 as in equation [ def : marginal ] .
given that @xmath40 , the probability density of @xmath39 , after the proposal and either acceptance with probability @xmath63 or rejection with probability @xmath64 , of a swap move , is given by @xmath65 for @xmath66 .
@xmath67 is the dirac delta function .
we have the following lemma .
the transition probabilities @xmath68 satisfy the detailed balance condition for the measure @xmath69 i.e. @xmath70 where @xmath71 the detailed balance condition stipulates that the probability of observing a transition @xmath72 is equal to that of observing a transition @xmath73 and guarantees that the resulting markov chain preserves the distribution @xmath58 .
therefore , under general conditions , averages over a trajectory of @xmath74 will converge to averages over @xmath58 . since @xmath75
we can calculate averages over @xmath4 by taking averages over the trajectories of the first @xmath0 components of @xmath44 .
notice that the formula [ def : a_i ] for @xmath63 requires the evaluation of @xmath60 at the points @xmath76 while the approximation of @xmath60 by functions on @xmath61 is in general a very difficult problem , its evaluation at a single point is often not terribly demanding . in fact , in many cases , including the examples in this paper , the @xmath51 variables can be chosen so that the remaining @xmath36 variables are conditionally independent given @xmath77 despite these mitigating factors , the requirement that we evaluate @xmath60 before we accept any swap is a little onerous . fortunately , and somewhat
surprisingly , this requirement is not necessary .
in fact , standard strategies for approximating the point values of the marginals yield markov chains that themselves preserve the target measure . thus even a poor estimate of the ratio appearing in [ def : a_i ] can give rise to a method that is exact in the sense that the resulting markov chain will asymptotically sample the target measure . to illustrate this point , we consider the following example of a swap move .
assume that the current position of the chain is @xmath40 where @xmath55 the following steps will result in either @xmath78 or @xmath39 where @xmath79 and @xmath80 . 1 .
let @xmath81 and let @xmath82 for @xmath83 be independent samples from @xmath84 where @xmath85 is a reference density conditioned by @xmath51 .
for example , @xmath85 could be a gaussian approximation of @xmath86 .
how @xmath87 is chosen depends on the problem at hand ( see numerical examples below ) . in general @xmath85 should be easily evaluated and independently sampled , and it should `` cover '' @xmath88 in the sense that areas of @xmath89 where @xmath88 is not negligible should be contained in areas where @xmath85 is not negligible . 2 .
let @xmath90 for @xmath91 be independent random variables sampled from @xmath92 ( recall that we are considering a swap of @xmath51 and @xmath93 which live in the same space ) .
notice that the @xmath94 variables depend on @xmath52 while the @xmath95 variables depend on @xmath51 .
3 . define the weights @xmath96 the choice of @xmath87 made above affects the variance of these weights , and therefore the variance of the acceptance probability below .
4 . choose @xmath57 from among the @xmath94 according to the multinomial distribution with probabilities @xmath97 notice that @xmath57 is an approximate sample from @xmath98 5
. set @xmath99 with probability @xmath100 and @xmath101 with probability @xmath102 . the transition probability density for the above swap move from @xmath72 for @xmath66is given by @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath67 is again the dirac delta function . in other words
, @xmath105 dictates that the markov chain accepts the swap with probability @xmath106 and rejects it with probability @xmath107 .
while the preceding swap move corresponds to a method for approximating the ratio @xmath108 appearing in the formula for @xmath63 above , it also has some similarities with the multiple - try metropolis method presented in @xcite which uses multiple suggestion samples to improve acceptance rates of standard mcmc methods .
the following lemma is suggested by results in @xcite .
the transition probabilities @xmath105 satisfy the detailed balance condition for the measure @xmath109 as before the detailed balance condition guarantees that averages over trajectories of the first @xmath0 dimensions of @xmath44 will converge to averages over @xmath4 .
the @xmath110 contain an approximation to the ratio of marginals in [ def : a_i ] @xmath111{a.s .
} & \frac{\mathbf{e}_{p_i}\left[\frac{\pi_i\left(x_{i+1},\widetilde{x}_i\right ) } { p_i\left(\widetilde{x}_i\vert x_{i+1}\right)}\ \vert \left\{\widehat{x}_i = x_{i+1}\right\}\right ] } { \mathbf{e}_{p_i}\left[\frac{\pi_i\left(\hat{x}_i,\widetilde{x}_i\right ) } { p_i\left(\widetilde{x}_i\vert \hat{x}_i\right)}\ \vert \left\{\widehat{x}_i=\hat{x}_i\right\}\right]}\\ = & \frac{\overline{\pi}_i(x_{i+1})}{\overline{\pi}_i(\hat{x}_i)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath112 denotes expectation with respect to the density @xmath113 when @xmath114<\infty$ ] , the convergence above follows from the strong law of large numbers and the fact that @xmath115 = \int \frac{\pi_i(\hat{x}_i,\tilde{x}_i)}{p_i(\tilde{x}_i\vert\hat{x}_i ) } p_i(\tilde{x}_i\vert\hat{x}_i)\ d\tilde{x}_i\\ = \int \pi_i(\hat{x}_i,\tilde{x}_i)\ d\tilde{x}_i = \overline{\pi_i}(\hat{x}_i)\end{gathered}\ ] ] for small values of @xmath116 in [ def : a^m_i ] , calculation of the swap acceptance probabilities is very cheap .
however , higher values of @xmath116 may improve the acceptance rates .
for example , if the @xmath117 are exact marginals of @xmath118 then @xmath119 while @xmath120 results similar to lemma 2 hold when more general approximations replace the one given above ; for example when the @xmath94 and @xmath95 are generated by a metropolis - hastings rule .
in practice one has to balance the speed of evaluating @xmath121 for small @xmath116 with the possible higher acceptance rates for @xmath116 large .
it is easy to see that a markov chain which evolves only by swap moves will only sample a finite number of configurations .
these swap moves must therefore be used in conjunction with a transition rule that can reach any region of space , such as @xmath122 from expression [ def : t ] .
more precisely , @xmath122 should be @xmath58-irreducible and aperiodic ( see @xcite ) .
the the transition rule for parallel marginalization is @xmath123 where @xmath124 and @xmath125 is the probability that a swap move occurs .
@xmath126 dictates that , with probability @xmath127 , the chain attempts a swap move between levels @xmath128 and @xmath129 where @xmath128 is a random variable chosen uniformly from @xmath130 .
next , each level of the chain evolves independently according to the @xmath131 . with probability @xmath132
the chain does not attempt a swap move , but does evolve each level .
the next result follows trivially from lemma 2 and guarantees the invariance of @xmath58 under evolution by @xmath126 .
the transition probability @xmath126 satisfies the detailed balance condition for the measure @xmath69 i.e. @xmath133 where @xmath134 thus by combining standard mcmc steps on each component governed by the transition probability @xmath122 , with swap steps between the components governed by @xmath135 , an mcmc method results which not only uses information from rapidly equilibrating lower dimensional chains , but is also convergent .
in the bridge path sampling problem we wish to approximate conditional expectations of the form @xmath136\ ] ] where @xmath137 and @xmath138 is the real valued processes given by the solution of the stochastic differential equation @xmath139 @xmath140 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 are real valued functions of @xmath143 . of course we can also consider functions @xmath140 of more than one time .
this problem arises , for example , in financial volatility estimation . because in general we can not sample paths of [ sde1 ] we must first approximate @xmath138 by a discrete process for which the path density is readily available . let @xmath144 be a mesh on which we wish to calculate path averages .
one such approximate process is given by the linearly implicit euler scheme ( a balanced implicit method , see @xcite ) , @xmath145 the @xmath146 are independent gaussian random variables with mean 0 and variance 1 , and @xmath147 @xmath148 is assumed to be a power of 2 .
the choice of this scheme over the euler scheme ( see @xcite ) is due to its favorable stability properties as explained later . without the condition @xmath149 above , generating samples of @xmath150 is a relatively straitforward endeavor .
one simply generates a sample of @xmath151 , then evolves the system with this initial condition .
however , the presence of information about @xmath152 complicates the task . in general ,
some sampling method which requires only knowlege of a function proportional to conditional density of @xmath153 must be applied .
the approximate path density associated with discretization [ def : lie ] is @xmath154 where @xmath155 ^ 2 } { 2\sigma^2\left(x\right)\triangle}\ ] ] at this point we wish to apply the parallel marginalization sampling procedure to the density @xmath4 .
however , as indicated above , a prerequisite for the use of parallel marginalization is the ability to estimate marginal densities . in some important problems homogeneities in the underlying system yield simplifications in the calculation of these densities by the methods in @xcite .
these calculations can be carried out before implementation of parallel marginalization , or they can be integrated into the sampling procedure . in some cases , the numerical estimation of the @xmath117 can be completely avoided .
the examples presented here are two such cases .
let @xmath156 .
decompose @xmath68 as @xmath157 where @xmath158 and @xmath159 in the notation of the previous sections , @xmath35 where @xmath160 and @xmath161 in words , the hat and tilde variables represent alternating time slices of the path . for all @xmath47 fix @xmath162 and @xmath163 .
we choose the approximate marginal densities @xmath164 where for each @xmath47 , @xmath165 is defined by successive coarsenings of [ def : lie ] .
that is , @xmath166 since @xmath62 will be sampled using a metropolis - hastings method with @xmath167 and @xmath168 fixed , knowlege of the normalization constants @xmath169 is unnecessary .
notice from [ def : pi_0:ex1 ] that , conditioned on the values of @xmath170 and @xmath171 , the variance of @xmath172 is of order @xmath173 .
thus any perturbation of @xmath172 which leaves @xmath174 fixed for @xmath175 and which is compatible with joint distribution [ def : pi_0:ex1 ] must be of the order @xmath176 .
this suggests that distributions defined by coarser discretizations of [ def : pi_0:ex1 ] will allow larger perturbations , and consequently will be easier to sample .
however , it is important to choose a discretization that remains stable for large values of @xmath173 .
for example , while the linearly implicit euler method performs well in the experiments below , similar tests using the euler method were less successful due to limitations on the largest allowable values of @xmath173 . in this numerical example
bridge paths are sampled between time 0 and time 10 for a diffusion in a double well potential @xmath177 the left and right end points are chosen as @xmath178 .
@xmath179 is the @xmath180 level of the parallel marginalization markov chain at algorithmic time @xmath10 .
there are 10 chains ( @xmath181 in expression [ def : t ] ) .
the observed swap acceptance rates are reported in table 1 .
let @xmath182 denote the midpoint of the path defined by @xmath183 ( i.e. an approximate sample of the path at time 5 ) . in fig .
1 the autocorrelation of @xmath184 @xmath185\ ] ] is compared to that of a standard metropolis - hastings rule . in the figure ,
the time scale of the autocorrelation for the metropolis - hastings method has been scaled by a factor of 1/10 to more than account for the extra computational time required per iteration of parallel marginalization .
the relaxation time of the parallel chain is clearly reduced . in these numerical examples ,
the algorithm in the previous section is applied with a slight simplification .
first generate m independent gaussian random paths @xmath186 with independent components @xmath187 of mean 0 and variance @xmath188 .
for each @xmath189 and @xmath190 let @xmath191 if in step 4 , @xmath192 , then in step 1 we set @xmath81 and for each @xmath190 @xmath193 all other steps remain the same .
this change yields a slightly faster though less generally applicable swap step that also preserves the density @xmath58 .
notice that this modification implies that the reference density @xmath87 is given by @xmath194 for this problem , the choice of @xmath116 in [ def : a^m_i ] , the number of samples of @xmath94 and @xmath95 , seems to have little effect on the swap acceptance rates . in the numerical experiment @xmath195 for swaps between levels @xmath47 and @xmath49 .
in the non - linear smoothing and filtering problem we wish to approximate conditional expectations of the form @xmath196\ ] ] where @xmath137 and the real valued processes @xmath138 and @xmath197 are given by the system @xmath198 @xmath140 , @xmath141 , @xmath142 , and @xmath199 are real valued functions of @xmath143 .
the @xmath200 are real valued independent random variable drawn from the density @xmath201 and are independent of the brownian motion @xmath202 @xmath203 and @xmath204 the process @xmath205 is a hidden signal and the @xmath197 are noisy observations .
again , the system must first be discretized .
the linearly implicit euler scheme gives @xmath206 the @xmath146 are independent gaussian random variables with mean 0 and variance 1 , and @xmath147 the @xmath146 are independent of the @xmath200 .
@xmath148 is again assumed to be a power of 2 .
the approximate path measure for this problem is @xmath207 the approximate marginals are chosen as @xmath208 where @xmath209 , @xmath165 and @xmath68 are as defined in the previous section . in this example , samples of the smoothed path are generated between time time 0 and time 10 for the same diffusion in a double well potential .
the densities @xmath201 and @xmath210 are chosen as @xmath211 the observation times are @xmath212 with @xmath213 for @xmath214 and @xmath215 for @xmath216 .
there are 8 chains ( @xmath217 in expression [ def : t ] ) .
the observed swap acceptance rates are reported in table 1 .
again , @xmath182 denotes the midpoint of the path defined by @xmath183 ( i.e. an approximate sample of the path at time 5 ) . in fig .
2 the autocorrelation of @xmath184 is compared to that of a standard metropolis - hastings rule .
the figure has been adjusted as in the previous example .
the relaxation time of the parallel chain is again clearly reduced .
the algorithm is modified as in the previous example . for this problem ,
acceptable swap rates require a higher choice of @xmath116 in [ def : a^m_i ] than needed in the bridge sampling problem . in this numerical experiment @xmath218 for swaps between levels @xmath47 and @xmath49 .
a markov chain monte carlo method has been proposed and applied to two conditional path sampling problems for stochastic differential equations .
numerical results indicate that this method , parallel marginalization , can have a dramatically reduced equilibration time when compared to standard mcmc methods .
note that parallel marginalization should not be viewed as a stand alone method .
other acceleration techniques such as hybrid monte carlo can and should be implemented at each level within the parallel marginalization framework .
as the smoothing problem indicates , the acceptance probabilities at coarser levels can become small .
the remedy for this is the development of more accurate approximate marginal distributions by , for example , the methods in @xcite and @xcite .
i would like to thank prof .
a. chorin for his guidance during this research , which was carried out during my ph.d .
studies at u. c. berkeley .
i would also like to thank dr .
p. okunev , and dr .
p. stinis for very helpful discussions and comments .
this work was supported by the director , office of science , office of advanced scientific computing research , of the u. s. department of energy under contract no .
de - ac03 - 76sf00098 .
chorin , a. ( 2003 ) _ multiscale model .
simul . _ * 1 * , 105118 .
stinis , p. ( 2005 ) _ j. comput
. phys . _ * 208 * , 691703 .
goodman , j. and sokal , a. ( 1989 ) _ physical review d _ * 40 * , 20352071 .
brandt , a. and ron , d. ( 2001 ) _
phys . _ * 102 * , 163 - 186 .
okunev , p. ( 2005 ) _ renormalization methods with applications to spin systems and to finance _ _ ph.d .
( u. c. berkeley ) liu , j. ( 2002 ) _ monte carlo strategies in scientific computing . _
( springer ) binder , k. and heermann , d. ( 2002 ) _ monte carlo simulation in statistical physics . _ ( springer ) binney , j. , dowrick , n. , fisher , a. and newman , m. ( 1992 ) _ the theory of critical phenomena : an introduction to the renormalization group . _
( oxford university press , usa ) kadanoff , l. ( 1966 ) _ physics _ * 2 * , 263 .
liu , j. , liang , f. and wong , w. ( 2000 ) _
assoc . _ * 95 * , 121 - 134 .
tierney , l. ( 1994 ) _ annals of statistics _ * 22 * , 1701 - 1728 .
milstein , g. , platen , e. and schurz , h. ( 1998 ) _ siam j. numer .
* 35 * , 1010 - 1019 .
kloeden , p. and platen , e. ( 1992 ) _ numerical solution of stochastic differential equations . _
( springer ) apte , a. , hairer , h. , stuart , a. and voss , j. ( 2001 ) _ physica d _ to appear .
chorin , a. and hald , o. ( 2005 ) _ stochastic tools for mathematics and science . _
( springer ) .
chorin , a. , hald , o. and kupferman , r. ( 2002 ) _ phys .
d _ * 166 * , 239257 .
e , w. , liu , d. and vanden - eijnden , e. ( 2005 ) _ comm .
pure appl .
_ * 11 * , 15441585 .
e , w. , ren , w. and vanden - eijnden , e. ( 2003 ) _
b _ * 109 * , 6688 - 6693 .
efendiev , y. and hou , t. and luo , w. ( 2006 ) _ siam j. sci . comput _ * 28 * , 776803 .
gear , c. and kevrekidis , i. ( 2003 ) _ siam j. sci .
* 24 * , 10911106 .
goldenfeld , n. ( 1992 ) _ lectures on phase transitions and the renormalization group . _
( westview press ) kadanoff , l. ( 2000 ) _ statistical physics .
statics , dynamics and renormalization . _
( world scientific ) stinis , p. ( 2004 ) _ multiscale model .
* 2 * , 580612 .
stuart , a. , voss , j. and wiberg , p. ( 2004 ) _ commun .
* 2 * , 685697 .
@rrrrrrrrrrrrr 1clevels & 1c0/1&1c1/2 & 1c2/3&1c3/4 & 1c4/5&1c5/6 & 1c6/7&1c7/8 & 1c8/9 1cbs & 1c0.86&1c0.83 & 1c0.75&1c0.69 & 1c0.54&1c0.45 & 1c0.30&1c0.22 & 1c0.26 1cfs & 1c0.86&1c0.83 & 1c0.74&1c0.65 & 1c0.46&1c0.23 & 1c0.04&1cna & 1cna | markov chain monte carlo sampling methods often suffer from long correlation times .
consequently , these methods must be run for many steps to generate an independent sample . in this paper
a method is proposed to overcome this difficulty .
the method utilizes information from rapidly equilibrating coarse markov chains that sample marginal distributions of the full system .
this is accomplished through exchanges between the full chain and the auxiliary coarse chains .
results of numerical tests on the bridge sampling and filtering / smoothing problems for a stochastic differential equation are presented .
n order to understand the behavior of a physical system it is often necessary to generate samples from complicated high dimensional distributions .
the usual tools for sampling from these distributions are markov chain monte carlo methods ( mcmc ) by which one constructs a markov chain whose trajectory averages converge to averages with respect to the distribution of interest . for some simple systems it is possible to construct markov chains with independent values at each step . in general , however , spatial correlations in the system of interest result in long correlation times in the markov chain and hence slow convergence of the chain s trajectory averages . in this paper , a method is proposed to alleviate the difficulties caused by spatial correlations in high dimensional systems .
the method , parallel marginalization , is tested on two stochastic differential equation conditional path sampling problems .
parallel marginalization takes advantage of the shorter correlation lengths present in marginal distributions of the target density .
auxiliary markov chains that sample approximate marginal distributions are evolved simultaneously with the markov chain that samples the distribution of interest . by swapping their configurations ,
these auxiliary chains pass information between themselves and with the chain sampling the original distribution .
as shown below , these swaps are made in a manner consistent with both the original distributions and the approximate marginal distributions .
the numerical examples indicate that improvement in efficiency of parallel marginalization over standard mcmc techniques can be significant .
the design of efficient methods to approximate marginal distributions was addressed in @xcite by chorin and in @xcite by stinis .
the use of monte carlo updates on coarse subsets of variables is not a new concept ( see @xcite and the references therein ) .
the method presented in @xcite does not use marginal distributions .
however , attempts have been made previously to use marginal distributions to accelerate the convergence of mcmc ( see @xcite ) .
in contrast to parallel marginalization , the methods proposed in @xcite and @xcite do not preserve the distribution of the full system and therefore are not guaranteed to converge .
the parallel construction used here is motivated by the parallel tempering method ( see @xcite ) , and allows efficient comparison of the auxiliary chains and the original chain .
see references @xcite and @xcite for expositions of standard mcmc methods .
parallel marginalization for problems in euclidean state spaces is described in detail in the next two sections . in the final sections
the conditional path sampling problem is described and numerical results are presented for the bridge sampling and smoothing / filtering problems . |
neutrinos are unique messengers to study the high - energy universe as they are neutral and stable , interact weakly and therefore travel directly from their point of creation to the earth without absorption .
neutrinos could play an important role in understanding the mechanisms of cosmic ray acceleration and their detection from a cosmic source would be a direct evidence of the presence of hadronic acceleration .
the production of high - energy neutrinos has been proposed for several kinds of astrophysical sources , such as active galactic nuclei ( agn ) , gamma - ray bursters ( grb ) , supernova remnants and microquasars , in which the acceleration of hadrons may occur ( see ref .
@xcite for a review ) .
flat - spectrum radio quasars ( fsrqs ) and bl lacs , classified as agn blazars , exhibit relativistic jets pointing almost directly towards the earth and are some of the most violent variable high energy phenomena in the universe @xcite .
these sources are among the most likely sources of the observed ultra high energy cosmic rays .
blazars typically display spectra with enhanced emission over two energy ranges : the ir / x - ray and mev / tev peaks .
the lower energy peak is generally agreed to be the product of synchrotron radiation from accelerated electrons . however
, the origin of the higher energy peak remains to be clarified .
in leptonic models @xcite , inverse compton scattering of synchrotron photons ( or other ambient photons ) by accelerated electrons generates this high energy emission . in hadronic models @xcite , mev - tev gamma - rays and high energy neutrinos are produced through hadronic interactions of the high energy cosmic rays with radiation or gas clouds surrounding the source . in the latter scenario , a strong correlation between the gamma - ray and the neutrino fluxes is expected .
the gamma - ray light curves of bright blazars measured by the lat instrument on board the fermi satellite reveal important time variability on timescales of hours to several weeks , with intensities much larger than the typical flux of the source in its quiescent state @xcite .
this paper presents the results of the first time - dependent search for cosmic neutrino sources by the antares telescope .
the data sample used in this analysis and the comparison to monte carlo simulations are described in section 2 , together with a discussion on the systematic uncertainties . the point source search algorithm used in this time - dependent analysis
is explained in section 3 .
the search results are presented in section 4 for ten selected candidate sources .
the antares collaboration completed the construction of a neutrino telescope in the mediterranean sea with the connection of its twelfth detector line in may 2008 @xcite .
the telescope is located 40 km off the southern coast of france ( 42@xmath048n , 6@xmath010e ) at a depth of 2475 m. it comprises a three - dimensional array of photomultipliers housed in glass spheres ( optical modules @xcite ) , distributed along twelve slender lines anchored at the sea bottom and kept taut by a buoy at the top .
each line is composed of 25 storeys of triplets of optical modules ( oms ) , each housing one 10-inch photomultiplier .
the lines are subject to the sea currents and can change shape and orientation . a positioning system based on hydrophones , compasses and tiltmeters is used to monitor the detector geometry with an accuracy of @xmath1 cm .
the main goal of the experiment is to search for high energy neutrinos with energies greater than 100 gev by detecting muons produced by the neutrino charged current interaction in the vicinity of the detector . due to the large background from downgoing atmospheric muons ,
the telescope is optimized for the detection of upgoing muons as only they can originate from neutrinos .
muons induce the emission of cherenkov light in the sea water . the arrival time and intensity of the cherenkov light on the oms
are digitized into hits and transmitted to shore .
events containing muons are selected from the continuous deep sea optical backgrounds due to natural radioactivity and bioluminescence .
a detailed description of the detector and the data acquisition is given in @xcite .
the arrival times of the hits are calibrated as described in @xcite .
a l1 hit is defined either as a high - charge hit , or as hits separated by less than 20 ns on oms of the same storey .
at least five l1 hits are required throughout the detector within a time window of 2.2 @xmath2s , with the relative photon arrival times being compatible with the light coming from a relativistic particle .
independently , events which have l1 hits on two sets of adjacent or next - to - adjacent floors are also selected .
the data used in this analysis were taken in the period from september 6 to december 31 , 2008 ( 54720 to 54831 modified julian days , mjd ) with the twelve line detector .
this period overlaps with the availability of the first data from the lat instrument onboard the fermi satellite .
the corresponding effective live time is 60.8 days .
atmospheric neutrinos are the main source of background in the search for astrophysical neutrinos .
these upgoing neutrinos are produced by the interaction of cosmic rays in the earth s atmosphere . to account for this background , neutrino events
were simulated according to the parametrization of the atmospheric neutrino flux from ref .
only charged current interactions of muon neutrinos and antineutrinos were considered .
an additional source of background is due to downgoing atmospheric muons mis - reconstructed as upgoing .
downgoing atmospheric muons were simulated with the mupage package @xcite . in both cases , the cherenkov light was propagated taking into account light absorption and scattering in sea water @xcite . from the timing and position information of the hits ,
muon tracks are reconstructed using a multi - stage fitting procedure , based on ref .
the initial fitting stages provide the hit selection and starting point for the final fit .
the final stage consists of a maximum likelihood fit of the observed hit times and includes the contribution of optical background hits .
upgoing tracks are also required to have a good reconstruction quality .
the latter is quantified by a parameter , @xmath3 which is based on the value of the likelihood function obtained for the fitted muon ( see ref .
@xcite for details ) . the cumulative distribution of @xmath3 for muons reconstructed as upgoing is shown in figure [ fig : fitquality ] along with the simulated contributions from atmospheric muons and neutrinos .
the angular uncertainty obtained from the muon track fit is required to be smaller than 1 degree . for this analysis , events are selected with @xmath4 .
this value results in an optimal compromise between the atmospheric neutrino and muon background reduction and the efficiency of the cosmic neutrino signal with an assumed spectrum proportional to @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the neutrino energy , which gives the best 5@xmath7 discovery potential .
the resulting sample consists of 628 events obtained in 60.8 days .
the simulations indicate that the selected sample contains 60 % atmospheric neutrinos ; the rest being mis - reconstructed atmospheric muons . )
distribution for upgoing events in data ( dots ) and monte carlo samples ( atmospheric muons : dashed line ; atmospheric neutrinos : continuous line ) .
events are selected with an error estimate lower than 1 degree .
the green dashed vertical line corresponds to the optimized event selection ( @xmath4).,scaledwidth=90.0% ] the angular resolution of the reconstructed neutrino direction can not be determined directly from the data and has to be estimated from simulation .
however , comparison of data and monte carlo in which the time accuracy of the hits was degraded by up to 3 ns constrains the uncertainty of the angular resolution to about 0.1@xmath0 @xcite .
figure [ fig : angres ] shows the cumulative distribution of the angular difference between the reconstructed muon direction and the neutrino direction for an assumed spectrum proportional to @xmath5 . for the considered period , the median resolution is estimated to be 0.5 @xmath8 0.1 degrees . ) and the reconstructed muon direction ( @xmath9 ) for an e@xmath10 flux of upgoing neutrino events selected for this analysis.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] the effective area for muon neutrinos is defined as the ratio between the rate of selected neutrino events and the cosmic neutrino flux .
figure [ fig : seff ] shows the muon neutrino and antineutrino effective area of the antares telescope as a function of the declination of the source , after integrating over the energy with an assumed spectrum proportional to @xmath5 between 10 gev and 10 pev . in the flux limits ( see section 4 ) , a conservative uncertainty on the detection efficiency of about 30 % was taken into account .
this number includes contributions on the uncertainty of the sea water optical parameters @xcite and the om properties such as efficiency and angular acceptance .
flux of upgoing muons selected for this analysis .
the product of the effective area by the visibility ( i.e. fraction of the time the source is visible at the antares location ) is shown with the dashed line.,scaledwidth=80.0% ]
the time - dependent point source analysis is performed using an unbinned method based on a likelihood ratio maximization .
the data are parametrized as a mixture of signal and background .
the goal is to determine , at a given point in the sky and at a given time , the relative contribution of each component and to calculate the probability to have a signal above background in a given model .
the likelihood ratio , @xmath11 , is the logarithm of the ratio of the probability density for the hypothesis of signal and background ( @xmath12 ) over the probability density of only background ( @xmath13 ) : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the unknown number of signal events determined by the fit and n is the total number of events in the considered data sample . @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the probability density functions ( pdf ) for signal and background respectively . for a given event _
i _ , @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 represent the time of the event , its declination and the angular separation from the source under consideration . the probability densities @xmath21 and
@xmath22 are factorized into a purely directional and a purely time - related component .
the shape of the time pdf for the signal event is extracted directly from the gamma - ray light curve assuming proportionality between the gamma - ray and the neutrino fluxes .
it is assumed that the muon neutrino velocity in vacuum is equal to that of light in vacuum .
for signal events , the directional pdf is described by the one dimensional point spread function ( psf ) , which is the probability density of reconstructing an event at an angular distance @xmath23 from the true source position .
the directional and time pdf for the background are derived from the data using the observed declination distribution of the selected events and the observed one - day binned time distribution of all the reconstructed muons respectively .
figure [ fig : timedistri ] shows the time distribution of all the reconstructed events and the selected upgoing events for this analysis . once normalized to an integral equal to 1 , the distribution for all reconstructed events is used directly as the time pdf for the background .
empty bins in the histograms correspond to periods with no data taking ( i.e. detector in maintenance ) or with very poor quality data ( high bioluminescence or bad calibration ) .
the statistical interpretation of the search result relies on simulated pseudo experiments ( pe ) in which the background events are randomly generated by sampling the declination and the time from the parametrization @xmath17 and the right ascension from a uniform distribution .
events from a neutrino point source are simulated by adding events around the desired coordinates according to the point spread function and the time distribution of the studied source .
systematic uncertainties ( cf section 2 ) are incorporated directly into the pseudo experiment generation .
the null hypothesis corresponds to @xmath24 .
the obtained value of @xmath25 on the data is then compared to the distribution of @xmath26 .
large values of @xmath25 compared to the distribution of @xmath26 reject the null hypothesis with a confidence level ( c.l . )
equal to the fraction of the number of pe above @xmath25 .
the fraction of pe for which @xmath26 is above @xmath25 is referred to as the p - value .
the discovery potential is then defined as the average number of signal events required to achieve a p - value lower than 5@xmath7 in 50 % of the pes . in the same way
, the sensitivity is defined as the average signal required to obtain a p - value less than that of the median of the @xmath26 distribution in 90 % of the pes . in the absence of evidence of a signal ,
an upper limit on the neutrino fluence is obtained and defined as the integral in energy and time of the flux upper limit with an assumed energy spectrum proportional to @xmath5 from 10 gev to 10 pev .
the limits are calculated according to the classical ( frequentist ) method for upper limits @xcite .
the performance of the time - dependent analysis was computed by applying this unbinned algorithm for a single source assuming a single square - shape flare with a width varying from 0.01 days to 84 days .
the solid line in figure [ fig : nev5sigma ] shows the average number of events required for a discovery from one source located at a declination of -40@xmath0 as a function of the width of the flare .
the numbers in the black line are compared to that obtained without using the timing information ( dashed line ) .
the flare timing information yields an improvement of the discovery potential by about a factor 2 - 3 with respect to a standard time - integrated point source search @xcite .
discovery ( 50 % probability ) from a single source located at a declination of -40@xmath0 as a function of the width of the flare period ( @xmath27 ) for the 60.8 day analysis .
these numbers are compared to that obtained without using the timing information ( dashed line).,scaledwidth=80.0% ]
the time - dependent analysis was applied to bright and variable fermi blazar sources reported in the first - year fermi lat catalogue @xcite and in the lbas catalogue ( lat bright agn sample @xcite ) .
sources were selected in the sky visible to antares and that had at least one day binned gamma - ray flux in the high state periods greater than 80x10@xmath28 photons @xmath29 s@xmath30 above 100 mev and showed significant time variability on time scales of days to weeks in the studied time period .
a source is assumed variable in the lbas catalogue when the observation has a probability of less than 1 % of being a steady source .
this list includes six flat - spectrum radio quasars and four bl - lacs .
only four bright and nearby sources in the considered sample , pks2155 - 304 @xcite , pks1510 - 089 @xcite , 3c279 @xcite and wcomae @xcite , have been detected by the ground cherenkov telescopes hess , magic or veritas .
table [ tab : sources ] lists the characteristics of the ten selected sources .
.list of bright variable fermi blazars selected for this analysis @xcite . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
this paper presents the first time - dependent search for cosmic neutrinos using the data taken with the full twelve line antares detector during the last four months of 2008 . for variable sources ,
time - dependent point searches are much more sensitive than time - integrated searches due to the large reduction of the background .
this search was applied to ten very bright and variable fermi lat blazars .
one neutrino event was detected in time / direction coincidence with the gamma - ray emission in only one case , for a flare of 3c279 in november 2008 , with a post - trial probability of 10 % .
upper limits were obtained on the neutrino fluence for the ten selected sources .
the authors acknowledge the financial support of the funding agencies : centre national de la recherche scientifique ( cnrs ) , commissariat lnergie atomique et aux nergies alternatives ( cea ) , agence national de la recherche ( anr ) , commission europenne ( feder fund and marie curie program ) , rgion alsace ( contrat cper ) , rgion provence - alpes - cte dazur , dpartement du var and ville de la seyne - sur - mer , france ; bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung ( bmbf ) , germany ; istituto nazionale di fisica nucleare ( infn ) , italy ; stichting voor fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom ) , nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo ) , the netherlands ; council of the president of the russian federation for young scientists and leading scientific schools supporting grants , russia ; national authority for scientific research ( ancs ) , romania ; ministerio de ciencia e innovacin ( micinn ) , prometeo of generalitat valenciana and multidark , spain .
we also acknowledge the technical support of ifremer , aim and foselev marine for the sea operation and the cc - in2p3 for the computing facilities .
bloom , s.d .
, marscher a.p .
1996 , apj , 461 , 657 ; maraschi , l. , ghisellini , g. , celotti , a. 1992 , apjl , 397 , l5 ; dermer c.d .
, schlickeiser r. 1993 , apj , 416 , 458 ; sikora , m. , begelman , m. c. , rees , m. j. 1994 , apj , 421 , 153 .
gaisser , t.k . ,
halzen , f. , stanev , t. phys . rep . 258 ( 1995 ) 173 ; learned , j.g . ,
mannheim , k. ann .
nucl . part .
50 ( 2000 ) 679 ; halzen , f. , hooper , d. rep .
65 ( 2002 ) 1025 ; neronov , a. , ribordy , m. 2009 , phys.rev . , d80 , 083008 ; bttcher , m. 2007 , astrophys .
space sci .
, 309 , 95 .
abdo , a. a. _ et al .
_ 2010 , apjs , 188 , 405 .
abdo , a. a. _ et al .
_ 2010 , apj , 715 , 429 .
aharonian , f. et al . , a@xmath31a 430 865 - 875 ( 2005 ) .
wagner , s. _ et al .
_ , head 2010 27.06 .
albert , j. _ et al .
_ , 2008a , science , 320 , 1752 .
acciari , v.a .
_ et al . _ , 2008
apj 684 73 - 77 .
monitored source list , http://fermi.gsfc.nasa.gov/ssc/data/access/lat/ | the antares telescope is well - suited to detect neutrinos produced in astrophysical transient sources as it can observe a full hemisphere of the sky at all times with a high duty cycle .
radio - loud active galactic nuclei with jets pointing almost directly towards the observer , the so - called blazars , are particularly attractive potential neutrino point sources .
the all - sky monitor lat on board the fermi satellite probes the variability of any given gamma - ray bright blazar in the sky on time scales of hours to months .
assuming hadronic models , a strong correlation between the gamma - ray and the neutrino fluxes is expected . selecting a narrow time window on the assumed neutrino production period can significantly reduce the background . an unbinned method based on the minimization of a likelihood ratio
was applied to a subsample of data collected in 2008 ( 61 days live time ) . by searching for neutrinos during the high state periods of the agn light curve ,
the sensitivity to these sources was improved by about a factor of two with respect to a standard time - integrated point source search .
first results on the search for neutrinos associated with ten bright and variable fermi sources are presented . , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , antares , neutrino astronomy , fermi lat transient sources , time - dependent search , blazars + pacs 95.55.vj |
the gauge sector of electroweak interactions has been checked to coincide with the standard model ( sm ) prediction to the per - mil level , at lep and slc . on the contrary , there is no direct experimental evidence for the higgs mechanism , supposed to be responsible for electroweak symmetry breaking and the generation of masses .
direct search of the higgs boson at lep yields the lower limit @xcite : @xmath2 gev / c@xmath1 at @xmath3 cl .
precision measurements on the other hand give @xcite : @xmath4 gev / c@xmath1 at @xmath5 cl . once a higgs particle is found , if ever , all its properties should be measured precisely to completely characterise the higgs mechanism . among those ,
the coupling of the higgs boson to fermions ( the yukawa coupling ) , which is supposed to scale with the fermion mass : @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the yukawa coupling of a fermion f of mass @xmath8 and @xmath9 is the vacuum expectation value of the higgs field , @xmath10 gev .
the top quark is the heaviest fermion , thus the top - higgs yukawa coupling should be the easiest to measure . if @xmath11 , this parameter can be measured through the branching ratio of the higgs boson decay into a pair of top quarks .
otherwise , i.e. for lower values of the higgs boson mass , the process @xmath0 allows in principle a direct measurement of this coupling .
feasibility studies of the measurement of the top - higgs yukawa coupling via the process @xmath0 at a linear collider have already been performed @xcite @xcite for a higgs boson mass of 120 - 130 gev / c@xmath1 .
this is the most favourable case ( taking into account the lower mass bound ) as the cross - section of this process decreases with increasing higgs boson mass and as a higgs boson of such a mass decays predominantly to a pair of b quarks , allowing a very effective signal and background separation using b - tagging algorithms .
one of the studies ( @xcite ) showed that a neural network analysis was essential to get a precise result .
we repeated this work and extended it up to @xmath12 150 gev / c@xmath1 .
when @xmath13 135 gev / c@xmath1 , the @xmath14 decay mode dominates .
this channel was also studied , for masses up to 200 gev / c@xmath1 .
the lowest order feynman diagrams contributing to the @xmath0 process are shown in figure [ diagrammetth ] . the amplitude of the diagram where the higgs boson is radiated from the z boson is not expressing the top - higgs yukawa coupling .
however , since it modifies only slightly the cross - section of the process , it can safely be neglected . the cross - section and
the top - higgs yukawa coupling thus verify to a good approximation : @xmath15 . for this work ,
the following assumptions were made : @xmath16 gev / c@xmath1 and @xmath17 .
the higgs branching ratios were calculated with the hdecay @xcite program .
the values obtained for the @xmath18 and @xmath14 modes , which are the main decays within the higgs mass range considered in this paper , are shown in table [ brhiggs ] and figure [ crosssectiontth ] . .__higgs branching ratios for the @xmath18 and @xmath14 modes ( as given by hdecay ) and cross - section at lowest order of the process @xmath0 ( as given by comphep ) , for various higgs mass values and for @xmath19 800 gev . in the calculation of the cross - section ,
initial state radiation and beamstrahlung were taken into account . _ _ [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ]
i thank marc winter and iouri gornouchkine for valuable discussions .
s. dittmaier , m. kramer , y. liao , m. spira and p. zerwas , phys . lett .
* b441 * ( 1998 ) 383 .
+ s. dawson and l. reina , phys
* d59 * ( 1999 ) 054012 .
+ g. blanger _
et al . _ , hep - ph/0307029 .
+ c. farrell , a. hoang , phys . rev .
* d72 * ( 2005 ) 014007 . via the process @xmath0 for various channels and their combination , for various higgs boson masses and for two values of the relative uncertainty on the residual background normalisation.__,width=566,height=793 ] | understanding the mechanism of electroweak symmetry breaking and the origin of boson and fermion masses is among the most pressing questions raised in contemporary particle physics .
if these issues involve one ( several ) higgs boson(s ) , a precise measurement of all its ( their ) properties will be of prime importance . among those , the higgs coupling to matter fermions ( the yukawa coupling ) . at a linear collider ,
the process @xmath0 will allow in principle a direct measurement of the top - higgs yukawa coupling .
we present a realistic feasibility study of the measurement in the context of the tesla collider .
four channels are studied and the analysis is repeated for several higgs mass values within the range 120 gev / c@xmath1 - 200 gev / c@xmath1 .
addtoresetequationsection = 20 cm = 15 cm |
random molecular interactions can have profound effects on gene expression . because the expression of a gene can be regulated by a single promotor , and because the number of mrna copies and protein molecules is often small , deterministic models of gene expression
can miss important behaviors .
a deterministic model might show multiple possible stable behaviors , any of which can be realized depending on the initial conditions of the system .
different stable behavior that depend on initial conditions allows for variability in response and adaptation to environmental conditions @xcite .
although in some cases , noise from multiple sources can push the behavior far from the deterministic model , here we focus on situation where the system fluctuates close to the deterministic trajectory ( i.e. , weak noise ) . of particular interest
is behavior predicted by a stochastic model that is qualitatively different from its deterministic counterpart @xcite , even if the fluctuations are small .
several interesting questions emerge when including stochastic effects in a model of gene expression . for example , what are the different sources of fluctuations affecting a gene circuit ? can noise be harnessed for useful purpose , and if so , what new functions can noise bring to the gene - regulation toolbox ?
one way in which noise can induce qualitatively different behavior occurs when a rare sequence of random events pushes the system far enough away from one of the stable deterministic behaviors that the system transitions toward a different stable dynamic behavior , one that would never be realized in the deterministic model without changing the initial conditions .
for example , if the deterministic model is bistable , fluctuations can cause the protein concentration to shift between the different metastable protein concentrations .
this happens when fluctuations push the system past the unstable fixed point that separates two stable fixed points .
while often times a spontaneous change in gene expression might be harmfull , it might also be beneficial .
for example , in certain types of bacteria , a few individuals within a population enter a slow - growth state in order to resist exposure to antibiotics . in a developing organism
, a population of differentiating cells might first randomly choose between two or more expression profiles during their development and then later segregate into distinct groups by chemotaxis . in both examples , switching between metastable states
leads to mixed populations of phenotypic expression @xcite .
this leads to the question of how cells coordinate and regulate different sources of biochemical fluctuations , or noise , to function within a genetic circuit . in many cases ,
the genes within a given circuit are turned on and off by regulator proteins , which are often the gene products of the circuit . if a gene is switched on , its dna is transcribed into one or more mrna copies , which are in turn translated into large numbers of proteins . typically , the protein products form complexes with each other or with other proteins that bind to regulatory dna sequences , or operators , to alter the expression state of a gene . for example
, a repressor binds to an operator which blocks the promotor the region of dna that a polymerase protein binds to before transcribing the gene so that the gene is turned off and no mrna are transcribed .
this feedback enables a cell to regulate gene expression , and often multiple genes interact within groups to form gene circuits . understanding how different noise sources affect the behavior of a gene circuit and comparing this with how the circuit behaves with multiple noise sources is essential for understanding how a cell can use different sources of noise productively .
fluctuations arising from the biochemical reactions involving the dna , mrna , and proteins are commonly classified as `` intrinsic '' noise @xcite .
one important source of intrinsic noise is fluctuations from mrna transcription , protein translation , and degradation of both mrna and protein product .
this type of noise is common among many of the biochemical reactions within a cell , and its effect is reduced as the number of reacting species within a given volume grows large .
another source of intrinsic noise is in the expression state of the genes within the circuit .
typically there is only one or two copies of a gene within a cell , which means that thermal fluctuations within reactions with regulatory proteins have a significant effect on mrna production . here , we consider the situation where transitions in the behavior of a gene circuit are primarily driven by fluctuations in the on / off state of its promotor and examine the effect of removing all other sources of noise .
stochastic gene circuits are typically modelled using a discrete markov process , which tracks the random number of mrna and/or proteins along with the state of one or more promotors @xcite ( but see also @xcite ) .
monte - carlo simulations using the gillespie algorithm can be used to generate exact realizations of the random process .
the process can also be described by its probability density function , which satisfies a system of linear ordinary differential equations known as the master equation .
the dimension of the master equation is the number of possible states the system can occupy , which can be quite large , leading to the problem of dimensionality when analyzing the master equation directly .
however , for the problem considered here , the full solution to the master equation is not necessary in order to understand metastable transitions .
the motivating biological question we consider here is what percentage of a population of cells can be expected to exhibit a metastable transition within a given timeframe .
if a spontaneous transition is harmfull to the cell , one expects that reaction rates and protein / dna interactions should evolve so that transition times are likely to be much larger than the lifetime of the cell . on the other hand ,
if spontaneous transition are functional , transition times should be tuned to achieve the desired population in which the transition occurs . in either case
, the key quantity of interest is the distribution of transition times between metastable states , regardless of the noise source driving the transition . except for a few special cases @xcite exact results , even for the mean transition time , are not possible and approximation techniques or monte - carlo simulations
must be used .
however , because rare events typically involve long simulation times where large numbers of jumps occur , monte - carlo simulations are computationally expensive to perform , leaving perturbation analysis ideally suited for the task .
past studies of metastable transitions , where perturbation methods are applied to the master equation , have used a simplifying assumption so that the state of the promotor is not accounted for explicitly @xcite .
the assumption is that proteins are produced in `` bursts '' during which one or more mrna copies are translated to rapidly produce many proteins . in these models ,
production bursts occur as instantaneous jumps , with a predefined distribution determining the number of proteins produced during a given burst .
more recently , assaf and coworkers analyzed a model where the on / off state of a single stochastic promotor is accounted for explicitly , and mrna copies are produced stochastically at a certain rate when the promotor is turned on @xcite .
however , the case where the model contains an arbitrary number of promotors or promotor states has not been addressed , and as we show in this paper , accounting for even just three promotor states is nontrivial .
similar asymptotic methods have also been developed to study metastable transitions in continuous markov processes @xcite , but can not be applied to a discrete chemical reaction system because continuous approximations , such as the system - size expansion , of discrete markov processes do not , in general , accurately capture transition times @xcite .
another source of difficulty that arises from isolating promotor state fluctuations as the only source of noise is that the resulting state space of the markov process is both continuous and discrete . after removing all sources of intrinsic noise except for the fluctuating promotor by taking the thermodynamic limit
the protein levels change deterministically and continuously , and the promotor s state jumps at exponentially - distributed random times .
the random jumps in the promotor s state makes the protein levels appear random , even though they are only responding deterministically to changes in the promotor state .
such random processes are sometimes called hybrid systems , or piecewise deterministic @xcite . here
we refer to it as the quasi - deterministic ( qd ) process because we are taking part of the randomly fluctuating discrete state of the system ( the number of protein molecules ) and replacing it with a deterministically - changing continuous state .
recently , we have developed asymptotic methods for metastable transitions
similar to those applied to the discrete master equation for markov processes with both discrete and continuous state spaces @xcite .
however , these methods do not account for two or more continuous state variables , which restricts the genetic circuit the method can analyze to one with a single protein product . in this paper
, we develop new perturbation methods so that we can study metastable transitions in genetic circuits driven by promotor fluctuations .
these methods are based on previous theory developed for one - dimensional velocity jump processes , and are generalized to account for the multiple continuous states representing the quantity of proteins produced by the genetic circuit .
they also fit within a larger framework of methods to study metastable transitions in continuous markov processes @xcite and in discrete markov processes @xcite . for illustration
, we use a simple model known as the `` mutual repressor '' model @xcite , which contains two genes , two promotors , and three promotor states .
although our example considers only three promotor states , the methods presented are general and can account for an arbitrary number of promotor states . for a range of parameter values , the deterministic limit of the mutual repressor model
is bistable , having two stable fixed points separated by an unstable saddle point . for the stochastic model ,
the deterministic forces create two confining wells surrounding each stable fixed point , separated by a stability barrier along the separatrix that contains the unstable saddle .
this geometric interpretation is given by taking the logarithm of the stationary probability density function , which we refer as the `` stability landscape . ''
an approximation of the first exit time density is found for the random process to escape over the stability barrier from one of the stability wells to the other . using this model
, we seek to answer the following question . how does the random process change when protein noise is removed , leaving the state of the promotor as the only source of randomness ?
that is , are there any qualitative differences in the behavior of the system without other sources of intrinsic noise ? the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : model ]
the mutual repressor model is presented along with its reduction to the qd process , and then in section [ sec : trt ] , perturbation methods for estimating the exit time density are applied to the qd process . for comparison ,
the stability landscape is also computed for the full process in section [ sec : full ] , which includes fluctuations in protein production / degradation .
finally , results are presented in section [ sec : results ] , and the qd process is compared to the full process , using analytical / numerical approximations and monte - carlo simulations .
the mutual repressor model @xcite is a hypothetical gene circuit consisting of a single promotor driving the expression of two genes : @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
each protein product can dimerize and bind to the promotor to repress the expression of the other .
when no dimer is bound to the promotor , both genes are expressed equally .
thus , the promotor can be in one of three states : bound to a dimer of protein one @xmath2 , unbound @xmath3 , or bound to a dimer of protein two @xmath4 .
let the number of protein product of gene @xmath0 and @xmath1 be @xmath5 and @xmath6 , respectively .
it is assumed that the mrna and protein production steps can be combined into a single protein production rate and that the dimerization reaction is fast so that it can be taken to be in quasi - steady - state .
we then have the following transition between the three promotor states @xmath7 where @xmath8 is a rate and @xmath9 is a nondimensional dissociation constant . protein @xmath0 ( @xmath1 )
is produced at a rate @xmath10 while the promotor is in states @xmath11
( @xmath12 ) , and both proteins are degraded at a rate @xmath13 in all three promotor states
. the probability density function @xmath14 , for promotor state @xmath15 and protein numbers @xmath16 , satisfies the master equation @xmath17\mathbf{p},\ ] ] where @xmath18\ ] ] is the matrix responsible for promotor state transitions .
the diagonal matrix @xmath19 , responsible for changes in protein numbers , has elements @xmath20 with @xmath21.\ ] ] the shift operators @xmath22 are defined according to @xmath23 we now introduce the nondimensional variables @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 , where @xmath27 .
then , the master equation ( [ eq:2 ] ) for the rescaled probability density , @xmath28 , becomes @xmath29\bm{\rho},\ ] ] with dimensionless parameters @xmath30 and @xmath31 .
the matrices are given by @xmath32,\ ] ] and @xmath33 the operators @xmath34 and @xmath34 are defined in terms of taylor series expansions ( in small @xmath35 ) which replace the shift operators @xmath36 with @xmath37 assume that @xmath38 is a small parameter , so that there is a large average number of proteins , and assume also that the parameter @xmath39 is small , which reflects rapid switching between promotor states compared to the rate of protein production / degradation .
because we have two small parameters in our system , @xmath35 and @xmath40 , when perusing an asymptotic solution , we must carefully consider how the limit @xmath41 and @xmath42 is taken , or more practically , how large @xmath40 is compared to @xmath35 .
the fluctuations in the promotor state are controlled by @xmath40 , and in the limit @xmath41 , the transitions are infinitely fast so that the promotor behaves deterministically .
the fluctuations in protein levels is controlled by @xmath35 , and in the limit @xmath42 the protein production / degradation behaves deterministically .
since we are concerned primarily with rare transitions driven by promotor fluctuations and not by fluctuations in the protein production / degradation reaction , we assume that @xmath43 ( i.e. , @xmath44 ) .
taking both limits , @xmath45 and @xmath46 , yields the fully - deterministic dynamics , @xmath47 where @xmath48 note the symmetry in the problem ; the deterministic system is unchanged if we exchange @xmath49 .
dynamically , the system is bistable for @xmath50 . at @xmath51
there is a saddle - node bifurcation , and for @xmath52 there is a single stable fixed point .
we consider the case of bistability and chose @xmath53 . in fig .
[ fig : det ] the nullclines and fixed points are shown . .
the black curve shows the @xmath54-nullcline and the grey curve shows the @xmath55-nullcline .
the green circles show the stable fixed points , the red circle shows the unstable saddle .
the blue curve shows a stochastic trajectory leaving the lower basin of attraction to reach the separatrix.,width=377 ] the two stable fixed points are located near the corners , and the unstable saddle point is located along the separatrix .
arrows show the eigenvectors of the jacobian with their direction determined by the sign of the eigenvalues , all of which are real .
a stochastic trajectory that starts at the lower stable fixed point remains nearby for a long period of time until a rare sequence of jumps carries it to the separatrix . because the separatrix is the stable manifold , trajectories are most likely to exit near the unstable saddle point .
to remove protein noise from the system , consider the limit @xmath42 , with @xmath39 fixed , so that the protein production / degradation process is deterministic within each promotor state , while the promotor state remains random .
the master equation ( [ eq:7 ] ) becomes @xmath56 where @xmath57 and @xmath58.\ ] ]
the focus of the remaining analysis is to obtain an accurate approximation of the first exit time density function ( fetd ) for the qd process to evolve from one metastable state to the another . to obtain the fetd ,
we supplement an absorbing boundary condition to the governing equation along the separatrix , @xmath59 of the deterministic dynamics , which is the barrier the process must surmount in order to transition to the other metastable state . for the master equation ( [ eq:2 ] )
, the absorbing boundary condition is simply @xmath60 for the qd ck equation ( [ eq:13 ] ) , the absorbing boundary condition is @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the unit vector normal to the boundary @xmath63 .
then , the domain for the qd process with the absorbing boundary is given by @xmath64 note the choice of the lower triangular region ( instead of the upper triangular region with @xmath65 ) is arbitrary due to the symmetry in the problem .
to see how the absorbing boundary on @xmath63 sets up the exit time problem , define @xmath66 to be the random time at which the separatrix is reached for the first time , given that the process starts at the stable fixed point @xmath67 .
consider the survival probability @xmath68 which is the probability that @xmath69 .
the fetd ( or probability density function for @xmath66 ) is then @xmath70 the fetd for the qd process can be approximated using perturbation methods as follows .
suppose we have a ck equation of the form @xmath71 where @xmath72 is a linear operator acting on the continuous and discrete state variables of the density function . in the case of the qd ck equation ( [ eq:13 ] )
, we have @xmath73 assume that @xmath72 has a complete set of eigenfunctions , @xmath74 , so that the solution can be written @xmath75 for some constants @xmath76 , and that all of the eigenvalues , @xmath77 , are nonnegative .
assume further that if we impose a reflecting boundary condition on @xmath63 then the principal eigenvalue , @xmath78 , is the only zero eigenvalue and the eigenfunction , @xmath79 , is the stationary density of the process ( after appropriate normalization ) .
furthermore , we assume that the stationary density is exponentially small on the boundary .
then , if instead we place an absorbing boundary condition on @xmath63 , the stationary density no longer exists and the principal eigenvalue is exponentially small in @xmath40 , while the remaining eigenvalues are much larger so that the solution resembles the stationary density after some initial transients .
it is this difference in time scales that we exploit to approximate the fetd .
a universal feature of the fetd for rare events is its exponential form ( which follows from the separation of time scales ) because the time dependence is @xmath80 , for @xmath81 . indeed
the fetd ( [ eq:24 ] ) is @xmath82 thus , for large times the fetd is completely characterized by the principal eigenvalue , @xmath83 .
the mean exit time is simply @xmath84 , which means that the eigenvalue also has the physical interpretation of the rate at which metastable transitions occur . to obtain an approximation of this eigenvalue
, we use a spectral projection method , which makes use of the adjoint operator @xmath85 .
consider the adjoint eigenfunctions , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , satisfying @xmath88 and @xmath89 so that the two sets of eigenfunctions are biorthogonal .
soppose that the boundary condition is ignored and @xmath79 is approximated by the stationary density , @xmath90 . by application of the divergence theorem ,
the adjoint operator is such that @xmath91 where the boundary contribution is nonzero because @xmath90 does not satisfy the absorbing boundary condition .
then , since @xmath92 , the principal eigenvalue is @xmath93 in the remainder of this section , we use ( [ eq:30 ] ) to approximate the principle eigenvalue by approximating the stationary density , @xmath90 , and the adjoint eigenfunction , @xmath94 .
in this section , we obtain an approximation to the quasi - stationary density , @xmath95 , using a wkb approximation method .
we begin by illustrating the procedure for the qd process .
that is , we seek an approximation of the solution to the equation @xmath96{\bar{\bm{\rho}}}(x , y ) = 0.\ ] ] consider the anzatz @xmath97},\ ] ] where @xmath98 are @xmath99-vectors and both @xmath100 and @xmath101 are scalar functions .
note that in other studies of gene regulation models where similar methods are used , the small parameter in the exponential is @xmath35 .
this difference in scaling arrises from the assumption that the metastable transitions are driven by fluctuation in the promotor and not the production of protein .
substituting ( [ eq:32 ] ) into ( [ eq:31 ] ) and collecting leading order terms in @xmath40 yields @xmath102\mathbf{r}_{0 } = 0,\ ] ] where @xmath103 the prefactor term @xmath104 ( up to a normalization factor ) is simply the nullspace of the matrix @xmath105 $ ] , and we assume that it is normalized so that @xmath106 . using theorem 3.1 in ref .
@xcite , we can provide necessary and sufficient conditions for @xmath104 to be unique and positive . for any fixed @xmath107
, there exists a unique vector @xmath108 , satisfying ( [ eq:33 ] ) if and only if the diagonal matrix @xmath109 is such that at least two of its elements have oposite sign .
that is , there exist @xmath110 , with @xmath111 , such that @xmath112 .
it is interesting to speculate that once the solution @xmath113 to ( [ eq:61 ] ) is substituted into the matrix @xmath1 that this requirement is satisfies for all @xmath114 .
however , this is not necessarily the case , which means that the quasi - stationary density is restricted to a subdomain where @xmath115 .
it is obvious that the protein levels must be bounded within the domain @xmath116 when protein production / degradation is deterministic .
that is , if the gene remains in the unrepressed state , the protein level tends toward the mean value ( @xmath117 or @xmath118 ) but never exceeds it since protein levels do not fluctuate ( unless the promotor state fluctuates ) .
however , it is not as obvious that the total amount of protein is further bounded so that @xmath119 , which means the domain is further restricted to the upper triangular portion of the unit square .
this means that once a trajectory enters , it remains in this domain for all time and can not escape . to show this ,
we need simply look at the rate of protein production / degradation for each state normal to the line @xmath120 .
this gives the rate for each of the promotor states ( @xmath55 on , both on , @xmath54 on ) when both protein levels satisfy @xmath120 .
these rates are given by the diagonal components of the matrix @xmath121 , where @xmath122 and @xmath123 are defined in ( [ eq:14 ] ) .
it is evident that when no repressor is bound and both proteins are produced , the flux across this line is in the positive direction , and when one repressor is bound , there is no flux across this line .
the leading order result ( [ eq:33 ] ) defines a nonlinear partial differential equation for @xmath124 , @xmath125 = 0.\ ] ] the function @xmath126 is referred to as the hamiltonian for the system , due to the similarity to classical hamiltonian dynamics .
an implicit assumption , @xmath127 is present to ensure that @xmath128 is the gradient of the scalar field @xmath124 .
the above system can be solved by the method of characteristics to obtain the system of ordinary differential equations ( see @xcite pg . 360 ) , @xmath129 where each variable is parameterized by @xmath130 , which should not be confused with physical time .
the above system of ordinary differential equations is supplemented with an equation for the stability lanscape @xmath131 and solutions specify @xmath124 along a curve in the plane @xmath132 .
a family of curves is defined by specifying cauchy data @xmath133 along a curve parameterized by @xmath134 .
one of the difficulties found in this method is determining cauchy data . at the stable fixed points ,
the value of each of the variables is known ( i.e. , @xmath135 and @xmath136 ) but data at a single point can not hope to generate a family of rays .
therefore , data must be specified on an ellipse surrounding the fixed point , using the hessian matrix , @xmath137.\ ] ] expanding the function @xmath124 in a taylor series around the fixed point yields the quadratic form , @xmath138 as its leading order term .
cauchy data is specified on the ellipse @xmath139 for some suitably small @xmath140 . in practice
, @xmath141 must be small enough to generate accurate numerical results , but large enough so that trajectories can be generated to cover the domain .
on the elliptical contour , the initial values for @xmath142 are @xmath143 it can be shown @xcite that the hessian matrix is the solution to the algebraic riccati equation , @xmath144 where @xmath145,\quad c = \left [ \begin{array}{c c } \frac{\partial^{2 } \mathcal{h}}{\partial p \partial x } & \frac{\partial^{2 } \mathcal{h}}{\partial p \partial y } \\
\frac{\partial^{2 } \mathcal{h}}{\partial q \partial x } & \frac{\partial^{2 } \mathcal{h}}{\partial q \partial y } \end{array}\right],\ ] ] evaluated at @xmath135 , @xmath146 , and @xmath147 .
this equation can be transformed into a linear problem ( in order to actually solve it ) by making the substitution @xmath148 to get @xmath149 an equation for the scalar function @xmath101 is found by substituting ( [ eq:32 ] ) into ( [ eq:31 ] ) and keeping second order terms in @xmath40 , to get @xmath150 \mathbf{r}_{1 } = { \frac{\partial } { \partial x}}(f\mathbf{r}_{0 } ) + { \frac{\partial } { \partial y}}(g\mathbf{r}_{0 } ) - \left({\frac{\partial { k}}{\partial x}}f - { \frac{\partial { k}}{\partial y}}g\right)\mathbf{r}_{0}.\ ] ] for solutions @xmath151 to exist , the fredholm alternative theorem requires that for @xmath152 = 0\ ] ] it must be that @xmath153 = 0.\ ] ] note that if @xmath104 spans the right nullspace of @xmath154 , then the left nullspace is also one dimensional . after rewriting ( [ eq:49 ] )
, we have the pde for @xmath155 given by @xmath156 although the solution to this equation can be formulated by the method of characteristics , it requires values of the vectors @xmath104 and @xmath157 , which in turn require the solution to the ray equations ( [ eq:38 ] ) . since rays must be integrated numerically in most cases , solving ( [ eq:50 ] ) along its own characteristics is impractical .
however , ( [ eq:50 ] ) can be computed along the characteristic curves of ( [ eq:38 ] ) as follows .
first , differentiating ( [ eq:50 ] ) along characteristics yields @xmath158 using the fact that @xmath159 along characteristics , we can define @xmath160 then , after combining ( [ eq:50 ] ) and ( [ eq:51 ] ) we have that @xmath161.\ ] ] the above requires values of @xmath162 and @xmath162 , which are not provided by the system ( [ eq:38 ] ) . to obtain these ,
a formula is needed to relate the hessian matrix , @xmath163 , of @xmath100 to @xmath164 .
then , the hessian matrix can be computed by expanding the system of ray equations ( [ eq:38 ] ) .
first , differentiate both sides of equation ( [ eq:33 ] ) to get @xmath165\nabla \mathbf{r}_{0 } = -\left ( \nabla a + \nabla ( p f ) + \nabla ( q g ) \right ) \mathbf{r}_{0},\ ] ] the fredholm alternative theorem requires that @xmath166 which is always true since @xmath167 and @xmath168 the general solution to ( [ eq:54 ] ) is @xmath169 where @xmath170 is the pseudoinverse of the matrix @xmath1 and @xmath10 is an unknown constant . since the vector @xmath104 is normalized so that its entries sum to one , it follows that @xmath171 . summing over both sides of equation ( [ eq:114 ] )
then yields @xmath172 thus , we have that @xmath173 equation ( [ eq:125 ] ) gives a relationship between @xmath174 , @xmath104 , and @xmath164 . to obtain the hessian matrix , @xmath163 ,
away from the fixed point , the ray equations are extended to include the variables @xmath175 for @xmath176 .
a good choice for the current problem is to take @xmath177 and @xmath178 , where @xmath179 is a point on the initial curve defined by ( [ eq:42 ] ) .
the hessian matrix is then obtained using @xmath180 = z \left[\begin{array}{c c } x_{1 } & x_{2}\\ y_{1 } & y_{2 } \end{array}\right].\ ] ] as long as the matrix on the rhs is invertible , the matrix @xmath174 can be obtained along characteristics and @xmath155 can be integrated numerically using ( [ eq:53 ] ) and ( [ eq:54 ] ) . the dynamics for the extended variables ( [ eq:55 ] ) is given by @xmath181 where @xmath182 and @xmath183 is the jaciobian matrix for the system ( [ eq:38 ] ) .
one can choose different variables @xmath184 with which to extend the system based on what works in practice , and the only thing one must change are the initial conditions . for our choice , the initial conditions are @xmath185 where the matrix @xmath186 is the solution to ( [ eq:44 ] ) .
the above analysis can be repeated to obtain a hamiltonian system for the full process ( with protein noise ) , but a choice must be made for how the limit @xmath45 , @xmath46 is taken .
first consider the equation for the quasi - stationary density , @xmath90 , for the full process ( [ eq:7 ] ) @xmath187{\bar{\bm{\rho}}}(x , y ) = 0.\ ] ] here , the domain is the cone @xmath188 .
the quasi - stationary density is assumed to have the form @xmath189},\ ] ] where again @xmath190 is a @xmath99-vector and @xmath124 is a scalar function representing the stability landscape . note that we have ignored higher order terms here because we only want the hamiltonian function for comparison to the qd process . substituting ( [ eq:58 ] ) into ( [ eq:57 ] ) does not lead to any meaningful equation for @xmath124 at leading order unless we make an assumption about how the limit @xmath46 is taken .
there are two relevant cases : @xmath191 and @xmath192 . in the former case ,
one recovers the qd process ( [ eq:33 ] ) , and in the latter case , collecting terms of leading order in @xmath40 , with @xmath193 , yields @xmath194\mathbf{r } = 0,\ ] ] where @xmath195 and @xmath196 thus , the hamiltonian for the full process is @xmath197,\ ] ] which we refer to as the full hamiltonian the differences between the full process and the qd process is nicely illustrated by comparing their associated hamiltonians .
notice that the full hamiltonian ( [ eq:61 ] ) is a transcendental function of @xmath198 and @xmath199 , whereas the hamiltonian for the qd process ( [ eq:36 ] ) is a cubic polynomial in @xmath198 and @xmath199 .
one can view this as a taylor series expansion of the full hamiltonian about @xmath200 . for this reason ,
the qd process , as an approximation for the full process with a small amount of protein noise , is only valid within a neighborhood of a deterministic fixed point .
this is , of course , just a reflection of the fluctuation dissipation theorem @xcite .
an example of numerical integration ( for details regarding numerics see the appendix ) of the ray equations ( [ eq:38 ] ) for the qd ( [ eq:36 ] ) and full ( [ eq:61 ] ) hamiltonian is shown in fig .
[ fig : rays ] . .
the triangular restricted domain boundary for the qd process is shown with black lines .
the two symmetric stable fixed points are represented by green circles , and the unstable fixed point by a red circle .
the separatrix along which an absorbing boundary condition is imposed is shown by a dashed black line .
parameter values used are @xmath201 , @xmath202 for the qd hamiltonian , and @xmath203 for the full hamiltonian.,width=453 ] the qd rays are shown above the separatrix for comparison . notice that the qd rays are contained within a triangular domain , while the rays from the full hamiltonian cover the entire domain .
this is due to the domain restriction that occurs when removing the protein fluctuations from the process . up to terms that are exponentially small in @xmath40
, the adjoint eigenfunction , @xmath94 , satisfies @xmath204{\bm{\xi}_{0 } } = 0.\ ] ] to make things easier , we change coordinates with @xmath205 so that @xmath206 this transforms the absorbing boundary , @xmath207 , to the vertical line , @xmath208 .
then , ( [ eq:66 ] ) becomes @xmath209{\bm{\xi}_{0}}(\tau,\sigma ) = 0.\ ] ] where @xmath210 where @xmath211 , @xmath122 , and @xmath123 are defined in ( [ eq:14 ] ) and ( [ eq:15 ] ) .
the absorbing boundary condition is then @xmath212 before proceeding , it is convenient to make the following definitions . in the rest of this section , we make frequent use of the eigenvectors ( right eigenvectors @xmath213 and left eigenvectors @xmath214 ) and eigenvalues , @xmath215 , satisfying @xmath216 we normalize the two sets of eigenvectors ( which are biorthogonal ) so that @xmath217 .
note that because the matrices @xmath218 and @xmath219 are functions of @xmath220 , so are the eigenpairs .
it is easily shown that one of the eigenvalues is zero for all values of @xmath220 , which we set to @xmath221 .
the right eigenvector , @xmath222 , is then given by the nullspace of the matrix @xmath218 @xmath223 furthermore , the corresponding left eigenvector is simply @xmath224 it is convenient to define distinct notation for the eigenpairs evaluated on @xmath63 , with @xmath225 at the boundary one of the eigenvalues , @xmath226 say , vanishes and the eigenspace for the zero eigenvalue is degenerate ( i.e. there are two zero eigenvalues but the nullspace is one dimensional ) which means that @xmath227 , @xmath228 and @xmath229 . the approximation of the adjoint eigenfunction proceeds using singular perturbation methods , along the lines of @xcite .
three solutions are found which are valid in different regions of the domain : an outer solution , a boundary layer solution for the @xmath230 strip near the absorbing boundary , and a transition layer solution in the @xmath231 overlap region between the other two .
away from the boundary , the exact solution ( that does not satisfy the boundary condition ) is @xmath232 to obtain a uniform asymptotic approximation that also satisfies ( [ eq:71 ] ) , a boundary - layer solution is needed .
consider the stretched variable @xmath233 . to leading order in @xmath40 , the boundary - layer solutions , @xmath234 ,
satisfies @xmath235 where @xmath236 .
the solution has the form @xmath237 where @xmath238 , @xmath239 is the only eigenpair ( on the boundary ) with a nonzero eigenvalue .
however , the eigenvalue , @xmath240 , is negative for all values of @xmath241 , and in order to obtain a bounded solution in the limit @xmath242 we set @xmath243 .
the vector @xmath244 is the generalized left eigenvector satisfying @xmath245 and is given by @xmath246 at the boundary , the solution is @xmath247 and the boundary condition ( [ eq:71 ] ) requires @xmath248 so that @xmath249 .
thus , up to a single unknown constant , @xmath250 , which must be determined by matching , the boundary - layer solution is @xmath251 because @xmath234 is unbounded in the limit @xmath252 , it is not possible to match it to the outer solution , @xmath253 .
we can think of the term , @xmath254 , in the boundary - layer solution is a truncated taylor series expansion of the true solution around @xmath255 . to match the boundary - layer and outer solutions ,
a transition - layer solution is required for the strip of width @xmath256 along the boundary .
consider the stretched coordinate @xmath257 .
keeping terms to @xmath231 , the transition - layer solution , @xmath258 , satisfies @xmath259 it is less clear how to truncate the above equation to obtain a leading order transition - layer solution .
because we must match the outer solution , @xmath260 , to the boundary layer solution that has the generalized eigenvector @xmath244 , we try a solution of the form @xmath261 where @xmath262 and @xmath263 are unknown scalar functions . in the limit @xmath264 , the deterministic flux across the boundary , @xmath265 ( with @xmath266 given by ( [ eq:12 ] ) )
vanishes and the eigenvector @xmath267 .
that is , the eigenvalue @xmath226 , corresponding to the eigenvector @xmath268 , vanishes on the boundary .
furthermore , it can be shown that @xmath269 where @xmath270 substituting ( [ eq:84 ] ) into ( [ eq:83 ] ) yields @xmath271 to obtain the unknown functions @xmath272 we project ( [ eq:87 ] ) with the right eigenvectors , @xmath273 , @xmath274 .
after applying these projections ( using the fact that @xmath275 , @xmath276 , @xmath277 , and @xmath278 ) and collecting leading order terms in @xmath40 , we get @xmath279 where @xmath280 it turns out that @xmath281 is related to the curvature of the stability landscape normal to the separatrix ; that is , if we define @xmath282 then @xmath283 at @xmath284 , the curvature vanishes and changes sign but is always negative ( with @xmath285 ) at the unstable fixed point , @xmath286 .
divide the separatrix ( @xmath208 and @xmath287 ) into three regions : @xmath288 , @xmath289 , and @xmath290 .
the first region is ignored because it is in part of the domain @xmath291 excluded from the stationary density function ( see sec .
[ sec : qsd ] ) .
the second region contains the unstable fixed point , and the third we can ignore as only extremely rare trajectories cross the separatrix in this region . up to an unknown constant , the solutions to ( [ eq:88 ] ) and ( [ eq:89 ] ) are @xmath292}du,\\ a_{1}(\tau , s ) & \sim & \hat{a}{\exp\left [ -\frac{1}{2}\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau ) s^{2 } \right]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the transition layer solution is then @xmath293}du{\mathbf{1}}\right .
\\ \nonumber & & \qquad\left .
+ { \exp\left [ -\frac{1}{2}\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau ) s^{2 } \right]}\bm{\chi}(\tau , s)\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the three solutions can now be matched .
first , matching the transition layer solution to the boundary layer solution is done using the van - dyke rule . in terms of the boundary layer variable , @xmath294 ,
the transition layer solution is @xmath295 matching terms with the boundary layer solution yields @xmath296 the composite boundary / transition layer solution is then @xmath297}du{\mathbf{1}}\right.\right.\\ \nonumber & & \qquad\qquad \left.\left.+{\exp\left [ -\frac{1}{2}\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau ) \frac{\sigma^{2}}{\epsilon } \right]}\frac{\tilde{{\nu}}^{(\sigma)}(\tau)}{\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau ) } \bm{\chi}(\tau,\frac{\sigma}{\sqrt{\epsilon}})\right)\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] the final unknown constant , @xmath250 , is determined by matching to the outer solution so that @xmath298 which implies that @xmath299 in order to evaluate the term in the numerator of the eigenvalue formula ( [ eq:30 ] ) , we require the adjoint eigenfunction evaluated on the boundary ( in a neighborhood of the unstable fixed point ) which is @xmath300 we now have all of the components necessary to approximate the principal eigenvalue , using the formula ( [ eq:30 ] ) .
first , for the term in the denominator , we can approximate the adjoint eigenfunction with the outer solution @xmath301 and the ( unnormalized ) stationary density with ( [ eq:32 ] ) ( the higher order term @xmath151 can be ignored ) .
then the term in the denominator is simply the normalization factor , which can be approximated using laplace s method to get @xmath302 } da \sim \frac{2\pi\epsilon}{\sqrt{\mbox{det}(z)}},\ ] ] where @xmath174 is the hessian matrix ( [ eq:40 ] ) of @xmath124 at the stable fixed point @xmath303 .
note that we have used the fact that @xmath304 and that the vector @xmath104 is normalized so that its entries sum to one .
the term in the numerator of ( [ eq:32 ] ) requires the approximation ( [ eq:99 ] ) of the adjoint eigenfunction on the absorbing boundary .
the integral can also be approximated using laplace s method , with @xmath305}d\tau \\ \nonumber & \sim & \frac{\epsilon b\sqrt{\pi}e^{-{k}(x_{u},y_{u})}}{b\sqrt{\pi } - \epsilon \sqrt{2\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau_{u } ) } } \sqrt{\frac{2\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau_{u})}{\tilde{\phi}''(\tau_{u})}}\bm{\zeta}^{t}\hat{g}(0)\tilde{\mathbf{r}}_{0}(\tau){\exp\left [ -\frac{1}{\epsilon}\phi(x_{u},y_{u } ) \right]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for convenience , we have defined functions on the boundary in the variable @xmath306 with @xmath307 where @xmath308 and @xmath309 are defined in ( [ eq:67 ] ) . although the quantities @xmath310 and @xmath311 must be computed numerically , the remaining unknown terms can be computed analytically by exploiting the reflection symmetry of the problem . along @xmath63
, we have that @xmath312 and @xmath313 so that the equation for @xmath124 and @xmath104 ( [ eq:33 ] ) can be written as @xmath314\tilde{\mathbf{r}}_{0}(\tau ) = 0,\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath315 the stability landscape function on the boundary is then @xmath316 the above is just an eigenvalue problem with three possible solutions , one of which can be excluded because there is a zero eigenvalue corresponding to the nullspace of @xmath218 .
it can be shown @xcite that if the diagonal elements of @xmath317 are such that at least two have oposite sign then only one of the remaining two eigenvalues has a corresponding positive eigenvector ( @xmath318 must have positive elements ) making the solution to ( [ eq:103 ] ) unique .
it turns out that this is only true for @xmath319 , which is due to the domain restriction caused by removing protein fluctuations .
the result is @xmath320 we also have that @xmath321 and finally , using ( [ eq:79 ] ) , ( [ eq:70 ] ) , and ( [ eq:106 ] ) we get @xmath322 combining these components together , we have the final result that @xmath323 \sqrt{\frac{\tilde{\mu}_{1}^{(\sigma)}(\tau_{u})\mbox{det}(z)}{\tilde{\phi}''(\tau_{u } ) } } { \exp\left [ -\frac{1}{\epsilon}\phi(x_{u},y_{u } ) \right]},\ ] ] where @xmath324 , and @xmath325 is given by ( [ eq:90 ] ) .
as expected , the eigenvalue is exponentially small in @xmath40 , which means that the height of the stability lanscape at the unstable fixed point , @xmath310 , must be approximated as accurately as possible .
the remaining terms are often referred to as the ` prefactor ' , and except for the quantity @xmath311 , all of the terms in the prefactor ( the derivatives of the stability landscape function and ( [ eq:108 ] ) ) represent properties local to the fixed points .
the remaining term in the prefactor depends on the function @xmath101 , which depends on properties of the process not local to the fixed points and must be computed numerically .
in this section , the results gathered throughout this paper are used to explore how removing the intrinsic noise that arises from protein production / degradation effects the random process .
in particular , we examine the stability landscape and the metastable transition times .
first , in fig . [ fig : level_curves ] the numerical solutions to the ray equations ( [ eq:38 ] ) are used to generate level curves of the stability landscape function , @xmath124 , for both the qd ( [ eq:36 ] ) and the full ( [ eq:61 ] ) hamiltonians . .
black lines show the domain boundary for the qd process , and the dashed line shows the boundary of positive protein levels .
( a ) the qd result is compared to the full process with @xmath326 so that the protein noise is weak compared to promotor noise .
( b ) same as ( a ) but with @xmath327 so that the protein noise strength is comparable to promotor noise .
parameter values are the same as fig .
[ fig : rays].,width=453 ] for presentation , the level curves are shown in the @xmath328 plane , with the separatrix along the left edge ( @xmath207 ) of each frame . in fig .
[ fig : level_curves]a , level curves for the full process are shown for @xmath326 so that the protein noise is small compared to promotor noise . recall that the parameter @xmath329 controls the strength of protein noise relative to the strength of promotor noise so that there is no protein noise in the limit @xmath330 .
the resulting curves match closely in a neighborhood of the stable fixed point and extend out toward the unstable saddle point .
as expected , the level curves begin to diverge the farther away from either fixed point they are . in fig .
[ fig : level_curves]b , the strength of the protein noise is increased , with @xmath331 , and in this case , the stability landscape of the two processes are quite different , matching only near the fixed points of the deterministic dynamics . as a result of the domain restriction effect , level curves of the full process extend into regions the qd process is excluded from .
this is because protein levels can only cross above the line @xmath120 , not below it , when there is no protein noise .
this is also true of the lines @xmath332 and @xmath333 .
the domain restriction effect is eliminated when protein noise is added back into the process , even if it is very small compared to promotor noise . for the model considered here ,
the effect is of no serious consequence for metastable transitions as the restricted domain still contains all three fixed points .
however , a model of a more complex gene circuit might be significantly affected by removing protein noise especially if this restricts the domain for the protein levels in such a way as to generate qualitatively different behavior , which would imply a nontrivial contribution of protein noise , no matter how negligible it may be .
because of the symmetry in the problem , we obtained analytical results for various quantities on the separatrix , including the shape stability landscape .
we can use these results to obtain an analytical approximation of the probability density for the position along the separatrix a trajectory passes through as it transitions from one basin of attraction to another . using the results of sec .
[ sec : eval ] , the stationary density along the separatrix is given by @xmath334}}{\int_{0}^{1}e^{-\tilde{{k}}(\tau)}{\exp\left [ -\frac{1}{\epsilon}\tilde{\phi}(\tau ) \right]}d\tau},\ ] ] where we remind the reader that @xmath335 and @xmath312 along the separatrix .
the only term that can not be obtained analytically is the function @xmath336 , which can be ignored as a first approximation . for simplicity
, we also average over the promotor state to get the scalar marginal probability density for the exit point .
then , using laplace s method , the exit density is @xmath337},\quad \tau\in(0,1),\ ] ] where @xmath338 is given by @xmath339 the qd exit density approximation is shown in fig .
[ fig : exitdist ] along with two histograms obtained from monte - carlo simulations . , with @xmath312 .
the black curve shows the analytical approximation for the qd ( @xmath340 ) process , and the symbols show histograms from @xmath341 monte - carlo simulations for different values of @xmath329.,width=377 ] while the histogram for @xmath326 is close to the qd approximation , it is evident that some trajectories pass through the separatrix in the interval @xmath342 , which is impossible without protein noise .
this effect becomes negligible when the protein noise is reduced to @xmath343 .
the fetd for a trajectory , starting from a stable fixed point , to reach the separatrix is asymptotically exponential in the large time limit , and the timescale is determined by the principal eigenvalue , @xmath83 , from equation ( [ eq:109 ] ) .
we can then approximate the mean exit time with @xmath344 . in fig .
[ fig : mfpt ] the mean exit time is shown on a log scale as a function of @xmath345 along with results from monte - carlo simulations . .
symbols represent @xmath346 averaged monte carlo simulations for various values of @xmath329 .
the dashed black line is the approximation , @xmath347 , for the qd process ( @xmath340).,width=453 ] notice that the approximation and the monte - carlo simulations are asymptotically linear as @xmath348 . for the approximation ,
the slope of this line is determined by the height of the stability barrier , @xmath310 , while the prefactor affects the vertical shift .
from the monte carlo results ( symbols with grey lines ) we see that the mean exit time converges to the approximation as @xmath349 .
however , it is clear that the slope of the analytical curve is slightly different then that of the monte carlo results even when @xmath329 is small .
thus , we may think of the mean exit time approximation for the qd process as an asymptotic approximation of the full process in terms of the small parameter @xmath350 so long as @xmath40 is also small but not too small .
understanding how different noise sources affect the dynamics of a gene circuit is essential to understand how different regulatory components interact to produce the complex variety of environmental responses and behaviors . even if one excludes extrinsic noise sources such as environmental and organism - to - organism variations
there are several sources of intrinsic noise , such as fluctuations in translation , transcription , and the conformational state of dna regulatory units .
the behavior we are interested in understanding is a transition from one metastable state to another .
each metastable state corresponds to the stable steady - state solutions of the underlying deterministic system .
the bistable mutual repressor model has two identical stable steady states separated by an unstable saddle node . on small time scales ,
the protein levels fluctuate near one of the two stable steady states . on large time scales , fluctuations cause a metastable transition to occur , where the protein levels shift to the other steady state by crossing the separatrix containing the unstable saddle point . to understand how metastable transitions can be induced by promotor noise , we consider a discrete stochastic model of a mutual repressor circuit where the protein levels change deterministically , which we call the qd process .
this is done by fixing the promotor state and then taking the thermodynamic , or large system size , limit of the protein production / degradation reactions .
we then compare the qd process to the full process that includes protein noise .
we find important qualitative differences that persist even when the magnitude of the protein noise is small compared to promotor noise .
in particular , without protein noise and after initial transients , the protein levels are restricted such that the total amount of protein is never less than half its maximum possible value ; that is , the total number of proteins is such that @xmath351 , where @xmath10 is the protein production rate and @xmath13 is the degradation rate . said another way , assuming that the random process starts at one of the deterministic stable fixed points , promotor fluctuations could never push the protein copy numbers so that , for example , only a single copy of each protein is present . in contrast , the stability landscape for the full process and monte - carlo simulations show that protein levels are able to reach all positive values . while this restriction does not stop the qd process from exhibiting metastable transitions
, more complex gene circuits may require protein fluctuations , even if they are very small , in order to function correctly .
in this appendix , we summarize the numerical methods and tools used throughout the paper . most numerical work is performed in python , using the numpy / scipy package . for more computationally - expensive tasks
, we use scipy s weave package to include functions written in c , which allows us to use the gnu scientific library for numerical integration of the ray equations ( [ eq:38 ] ) , and for random number generators used in monte carlo simulations .
there are a few notable observations regarding integration of the ray equations .
first , characteristic projections , @xmath132 , have a tendency to stick together along certain trajectories , peeling off one at a time ( see fig . [
fig : rays ] ) . to adequately cover the domain with rays ,
a shooting method must be used to select points on the cauchy data . for
more details on this see ref .
we found that the simplest method was to use the secant method ( we use the `` brentq '' function in the scipy.integrate package ) to minimize the euclidian distance between the final value of @xmath132 along the separatrix and the saddle node .
this method is convenient since it does not require knowledge of the hessian matrix , @xmath163 .
second , the value of @xmath141 used to generate cauchy data must be chosen small enough to get accurate results
. however , we found that if it is chosen too small , rays are no longer able to cover the domain , and more importantly , we could no longer generate a ray that reaches the unstable fixed point on the separatrix .
for the mutual repressor model , the trajectory connecting the stable fixed point to the saddle is one of the curves along which characteristics tend to stick to each other .
suppose that @xmath352 is the point on the cauchy data ( [ eq:126 ] ) that generates the ray that connects the fixed points .
then small perturbations @xmath353 , @xmath354 , cause the characteristic , @xmath132 , to diverge sharply away from the saddle .
this not only makes it difficult to compute @xmath352 , but also creates difficulties for computing the function @xmath355 ( see sec .
[ sec : prefac ] ) . since the expanded set of ray equations ( [ eq:110 ] ) track the derivatives of @xmath55 , @xmath54 , @xmath198 , and @xmath199 with respect to the point on the cauchy data , which , for values of @xmath134 near @xmath352 , becomes very large as the ray approaches the saddle point . as the expanded variables become very large , computing @xmath174 using equation ( [ eq:56 ] ) is unstable . furthermore , this effect becomes worse as the initial value , @xmath356 , goes to zero .
jmn would like to thank james p. keener for valuable discussions throughout this project .
this work was supported by award no kuk - c1 - 013 - 4 made by king abdullah university of science and technology ( kaust ) .
10 charles doering , khachik sargsyan , and leonard sander .
extinction times for birth - death processes : exact results , continuum asymptotics , and the failure of the fokker
planck approximation .
, 3(2):283299 , 2005 . | the stochastic mutual repressor model is analysed using perturbation methods .
this simple model of a gene circuit consists of two genes and three promotor states .
either of the two protein products can dimerize , forming a repressor molecule that binds to the promotor of the other gene .
when the repressor is bound to a promotor , the corresponding gene is not transcribed and no protein is produced .
either one of the promotors can be repressed at any given time or both can be unrepressed , leaving three possible promotor states .
this model is analysed in its bistable regime in which the deterministic limit exhibits two stable fixed points and an unstable saddle , and the case of small noise is considered . on small time scales ,
the stochastic process fluctuates near one of the stable fixed points , and on large time scales , a metastable transition can occur , where fluctuations drive the system past the unstable saddle to the other stable fixed point . to explore how different intrinsic noise sources affect these transitions , fluctuations in protein production and degradation are eliminated , leaving fluctuations in the promotor state as the only source of noise in the system .
perturbation methods are then used to compute the stability landscape and the distribution of transition times , or first exit time density . to understand how protein noise affects the system ,
small magnitude fluctuations are added back into the process , and the stability landscape is compared to that of the process without protein noise .
it is found that significant differences in the random process emerge in the presence of protein noise . |
the _ ab initio _ calculation of the light hadron spectrum is a major goal of lattice qcd .
a calculation of the light - hadron spectrum giving results in good agreement with experiment would be a demonstration that qcd describes long - distance strong - interaction physics .
furthermore , the calculation is an essential precursor to the calculation of other non - perturbative observables in qcd , such as @xmath13 , @xmath14 , leptonic and semi - leptonic decay matrix elements and the moments of the nucleon structure function .
lattice calculations are however subject to systematic errors from the non zero lattice spacing , the finite volume of the lattice , the extrapolation in the valence quark mass to the chiral limit , and the quenched approximation . in this paper
, the effects of the first two sources of error will be examined .
symanzik @xcite proposed an improvement programme for reducing the dependence of observables on the lattice spacing , @xmath15 , by adding to the action higher - dimension operators with appropriately calculated coefficients .
this should enable a more reliable extrapolation to the continuum limit , using data at larger values of the lattice spacing .
given that the computational effort scales as @xmath16 in the quenched approximation , the potential savings are considerable .
the standard gluon action has discretisation errors of @xmath17 .
the wilson fermion action , on the other hand , has discretisation errors of @xmath1 .
therefore , the first step in the symanzik improvement programme is to reduce the leading - order error of the fermion action to the same order as that of the gluon action .
the resulting sheikholeslami - wohlert ( sw ) action @xcite introduces an extra operator , @xmath18 , the so - called clover term , to the original action , multiplied by a parameter @xmath5 : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the standard wilson action defined as @xmath21 and @xmath22 @xmath23 is a lattice definition of the field strength tensor , detailed in @xcite .
there is a value of the parameter @xmath5 , @xmath24 , which removes all @xmath1 errors from spectral quantities @xcite . in this paper , we compare the spectrum obtained using the wilson fermion action ( @xmath4 ) with that obtained using the sw fermion action with two choices of @xmath5 : the classical value , @xmath2 , and a mean - field or tadpole - improved estimate of @xmath24 . other approaches to improvement are described in refs .
@xcite .
the tadpole improved estimate of @xmath5 is obtained following lepage and mackenzie @xcite by replacing the gauge links , @xmath25 by @xmath26 we choose @xmath27 consequently , the effect of tadpole improvement on the sw action is to set @xmath28 tree
level theory should then provide more reliable estimates of @xmath29 and the critical value of @xmath30 which we denote @xmath31 ; we take @xmath32 and expect @xmath31 to be close to @xmath33 .
this prescription maintains the @xmath1 improvement and it is believed that the size of the remaining discretisation error will be reduced .
the paper is organised as follows . in the next section we outline the computational methods . in section iii
, we explore three values of the clover coefficient at @xmath0 by including the results from the gf11 collaboration @xcite .
the observables studied are : the @xmath34 and @xmath35 masses , vector pseudoscalar mass splittings , the @xmath8 parameter ( proposed by lacock and michael @xcite ) , valence @xmath36 meson masses , the spin @xmath37 and @xmath38 baryon masses and the edinburgh plot . a study is also made of possible finite size effects by computing the spectrum at a smaller lattice volume , using one value of the clover coefficient
. finally , in section iv , we present our conclusions .
two lattice sizes , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , at @xmath0 , were used , with 482 configurations generated on the former and 142 configurations on the latter .
we used a combination of the over relaxation ( or ) algorithm @xcite and the cabbibo
marinari ( cm ) algorithm @xcite .
the gauge configurations were separated by 100 compound sweeps , where a compound sweep is defined as five or sweeps followed by one cm sweep . a detailed description of the algorithms used can be found in @xcite .
quark propagators were calculated at two @xmath41 values .
these values were chosen so that the corresponding quark masses straddle the strange quark mass .
on the larger lattice , propagators were calculated using both @xmath2 and the tadpole improved value of @xmath3 . on the smaller lattice , propagators were calculated using the tadpole improved value of @xmath5 only . to increase the overlap of the operators with the ground state , all of the propagators were calculated using both a local source and a jacobi smeared source with r.m.s .
radius of @xmath42 @xcite .
local sinks were used for all propagators .
the propagators were calculated using the minimal residual algorithm , which is described in detail in @xcite .
the correlators used to extract the hadron masses are listed in table [ operator - list ] ; for further details see @xcite .
we computed meson correlators using quarks degenerate and non - degenerate in mass , giving three possible mass combinations for each meson state .
furthermore , each quark propagator can be either local or smeared , giving three possible correlators for each mass combination .
however , we computed baryon correlators only for degenerate quark masses , using either all smeared or all local quark propagators . therefore , for each baryon state we have two mass combinations each with two types of sources . in order to maximise the sample size , the discrete time symmetry of the correlators was utilised and the data for @xmath43 $ ] averaged with the data at @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is the temporal size of the lattice .
these calculations were performed on the meiko i860 computing surfaces at the edinburgh parallel computing centre .
we have performed multi - exponential fits of meson correlators to @xmath46 and baryon correlators to @xmath47 @xmath48 is the amplitude of the state labelled by @xmath49 , and @xmath50 is that of the ( heavier ) parity partner and @xmath51 .
the following criteria for multi exponential fits have been used : * acceptable values for the quality of fit , q , and @xmath52 ; * stability of the result for the ground state mass ; * agreement between the result obtained using a single - exponential fit and a double - exponential fit ; * ability of of the fitting algorithm to resolve two masses .
the variable @xmath53 , which is a function of @xmath54 and @xmath55 is defined @xcite
as @xmath56 it represents the probability that given @xmath57 normal , random , uncorrelated variables , with a mean of @xmath58 and unit variance , have a sum of squares which is greater than @xmath54 .
an acceptable value for @xmath53 lies around @xmath59 ; a much smaller value indicates that the model used is incorrect , whereas a value approaching 1 indicates that too many parameters are being used . a criterion of stability which we used is that the mass obtained does not change noticeably when the minimum time slice of the fit was changed slightly .
the parameters were determined by minimising the @xmath54 using the levenberg
marquardt algorithm @xcite .
correlations between all time slices , and types of operator for simultaneous fits , were included .
the covariance matrix was inverted using singular value decomposition , without eliminating any eigenvalues .
the bootstrap algorithm @xcite , using 1000 bootstrap subsamples , was used to determine the 68% confidence levels , regenerating the covariance matrix for each subsample .
examples of the multi exponential fits for the pseudoscalar , vector , nucleon and @xmath6 are shown in fig .
( [ fig : ps-57-multi - fit ] ) to fig .
( [ fig : delta-57-multi - fit ] ) .
we emphasise that these are _ not _ effective mass plots , but plots of the mass obtained for a given fixed @xmath60 and varying @xmath61 . in obtaining results for the smaller lattice , despite having significantly larger statistics
, it was more difficult to satisfy the above fit criteria than for the larger lattice . the pseudoscalar mass was determined using all available smearing types and a 2exponential fit .
fit ranges of 312 and 316 were chosen for the smaller and larger volumes repectively . in the case of the vector ,
the high statistics at the smaller volume allowed the use of both @xmath62 matrices , listed in table [ operator - list ] , while for the larger lattice , only @xmath63 was used .
all three different smearing types were used in both fits .
fit ranges of 412 and 416 were used and a 2exponential fit . as can be seen in fig .
( [ fig : nuc-57-multi - fit ] ) there is significant second and even third state contamination for the nucleon when local and smeared operators are used in the fit .
hence only those correlators calculated with smeared operators , with overlap onto the @xmath64 state , were used to determine @xmath65 .
the contribution of the parity partner of eq.([eq : baryon - twopt ] ) was found to be sufficiently suppressed if @xmath60 was chosen to be @xmath66 .
the fit ranges , using a 2exponential fit , were 211 and 215 . in the case of the @xmath6 ,
the higher state contamination was not as large as for the nucleon .
therefore local and smeared operators were used .
the fit ranges were 511 and 515 with a 2exponential fit .
the masses obtained for the pseudoscalar , vector , nucleon and @xmath6 for each value of the clover coefficient and combination of quark masses , are listed in table [ mps - c - coarse ] to table [ mdelta - c - coarse ] .
the larger lattice size corresponds to one used by the gf11 collaboration with the wilson fermion action and the same @xmath67 @xcite , so that we are also able to compare results for non - zero @xmath5 with those for @xmath4 .
one expects the effect of changing @xmath5 will be more noticeable at our coarse lattice spacing than at a larger @xmath67 .
the effect of reducing the physical volume to @xmath39 was also investigated , using the tadpole - improved sw action . for small quark masses ,
the bare mass of a quark on the lattice can be defined as @xmath68 where @xmath69 is _ a priori _ an undetermined function of @xmath67 .
we use the standard extrapolation in quark mass for pseudoscalar mesons , neglecting possible logarithmic divergences described by sharpe @xcite , @xmath70 where @xmath71 however , as noted by bhattacharya _
_ @xcite and collins _ et al . _
@xcite , the terms which are @xmath72 can not be entirely neglected for the quark masses used in this study .
a linear extrapolation in @xmath73 leads to a large @xmath52 , as can be seen in table [ kappa - crit ] .
an estimate of the systematic uncertainty was obtained by performing a quadratic fit through the three masses and a linear fit to the two lightest masses . in all the cases considered ,
the deviation from the original linear fit was greater for the quadratic fit than for the linear fit to the two lightest masses .
the systematic error quoted in table [ kappa - crit ] is conservatively estimated to be the deviation of the quadratic fit from the original linear fit .
we note that the value for @xmath69 is always larger when the quadratic form is employed , regardless of the clover coefficient or lattice size used .
hence , results for other observables will always be quoted with an entirely positive or negative systematic error . as can be seen from table [ kappa - crit ] ( including the gf11@xcite data for comparison ) , @xmath69 approaches @xmath74 as @xmath5
is increased from @xmath58 to @xmath75 and that @xmath31 in the tadpole improved case is closer still . in this section ,
the physical pseudoscalar and vector masses are evaluated by extrapolation and interpolation in the quark masses to the appropriate physical values .
certain input parameters are necessary to do this . in particular , for mesons containing up and down valence quarks ( which are assumed to be degenerate in mass and will be referred to here as `` normal '' ) , one may use the experimental values for @xmath76 and @xmath77 ( we apply a convention that experimentally determined masses are labelled with an `` m '' , while those calculated on the lattice are labelled with an `` m '' ) .
effectively , one of these sets the quark mass while the other sets the lattice spacing .
the vector mass extrapolation has the following form @xmath78 where logarithmic terms due to the quenched approximation have been discarded .
the constant term @xmath79 corresponds to the vector mass in the chiral limit .
following the procedure outlined by the gf11 collaboration , values of @xmath80 and @xmath81 are determined using the physical ratio @xmath82 once again , the systematic error due to higher order corrections is estimated by quadratically fitting all three masses and performing a linear fit in the two lightest masses .
the deviation due to the quadratic fit was again found to be consistently larger .
an example of this is shown in fig .
( [ fig : mv - vs - mpisq ] ) .
the resulting values for @xmath81 ( including the gf11 @xcite data ) are quoted in table [ chiral - mesons ] .
having used the ratio of eq.([eq : pi - rho - phys ] ) to fix the normal quark mass , the scale can be determined using either @xmath83 or @xmath84 .
it is useful to compare @xmath84 with the lattice measurement of a gluonic quantity , where discretisation errors are @xmath17 and hence can be expected to be smaller .
we choose sommer s force parameter , @xmath85 @xcite .
we can extrapolate the gf11 values for @xmath86 versus @xmath87 to the continuum limit which yields @xmath88 this includes a correction which the gf11 collaboration have used to eliminate finite volume effects , which rounds the result down by approximately 4% . assuming that @xmath85 and the string tension , @xmath89 are related by @xmath90 and interpolating the available string tension data from @xmath91
, one finds @xmath92 at @xmath0 to be @xmath93 .
one can then compare our data for @xmath86 at @xmath0 as a function of @xmath5 with the continuum limit from gf11 .
these results are plotted as a function of @xmath5 in fig .
( [ fig : mrhor0-vs - c ] ) , noting that there are significant discretisation effects in the force parameter at @xmath0 which have not been taken into account .
there is a clear trend toward the continuum limit as the clover coefficient is increased to its tadpole improved value .
the determination of meson masses containing strange valence quarks requires as input the experimental mass of a strange meson , for example @xmath94 . with this mass as input
, one can determine @xmath95 by requiring : @xmath96 from the condition of eq.([eq : amk - from - ratio ] ) and employing eq.([eq : mv - vs - mpssq ] ) , one can then predict @xmath97 fixed from @xmath95 , which we refer to as @xmath98 .
our results for @xmath98 and the ratio @xmath99 can be found in columns 3 and 4 of table [ strange - masses ] .
we note that the ratio @xmath99 at @xmath2 is consistent to within 1 standard deviation with that at @xmath3 and that the central value lies several standard deviations below the experimental value .
there are large systematic errors due to the chiral extrapolation at both values of the clover coefficient , however this error is smaller than the difference between our results and experimental data .
the discrepancy in this ratio has also been noted at @xmath100 , with @xmath4 by bhattacharya _
_ @xcite .
the choice of strange meson is not unique .
instead , one could have fixed @xmath97 from @xmath101 and through eq.([eq : mv - vs - mpssq ] ) one can then predict @xmath95 fixed from @xmath97 , which we refer to as @xmath102 .
our results at both clover coefficients for this mass and the ratio @xmath103 are listed in columns 5 and 6 of table [ strange - masses ] .
we note that the ratio @xmath103 is also constant to within one standard deviation as @xmath5 is changed from 1 to @xmath104 and that the central value lies several standard deviations above the experimental value .
however , in this case , the systematic errors due to the chiral extrapolation at both values of the clover coefficient are so large that we can not demonstrate that these ratios are inconsistent with experiment .
the mass @xmath105 of the pure valence @xmath106 vector state can be determined similarly , but a valence @xmath106 pseudoscalar , @xmath107 , is not observed .
however , using an estimate of @xmath108 by lipps _
@xcite , we can estimate the ratio of these masses : @xmath109 it is therefore possible to determine @xmath110 , from eq.([eq : mv - vs - mpssq ] ) and eq.([eq : mvss - mpss - ratio ] ) without extrapolating to the chiral limit , which we have seen previously , has large systematic errors .
the resulting masses are shown in table [ phi - masses ] . using the data from the gf11 collaboration
, it is possible to calculate @xmath110 for @xmath4 for @xmath0 and the other gauge couplings . assuming a linear behaviour with respect to the lattice spacing , the continuum limit of @xmath111 using the gf11 data has been evaluated .
it should be noted , however that the linear extrapolation in the lattice spacing for the gf11 data is very poor , having a @xmath52 of approximately 13 , even though the fit is uncorrelated .
it is likely therefore that the continuum limit for @xmath112 has a large systematic error due to this fit .
there is also a correction to infinite volume which shifts the value downwards .
the behavour of @xmath112 with respect to @xmath5 at @xmath0 is shown in fig .
( [ fig : mphir0-vs - c ] ) .
the absence of the systematic error due to the chiral extrapolation demonstrates the effect of the clover coefficient more clearly than from @xmath86 .
again , we find there is a clear trend toward the continuum limit as the clover coefficient is increased to its tadpole improved value .
heavy quark effective theory ( hqet ) predicts that for heavy
light mesons , the vector - pseudoscalar mass splitting , @xmath113 , is constant .
this is borne out by experiment , with @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
a somewhat unexpected experimental result is that this trend is continued into the light quark regime , where the hyperfine splitting , @xmath116 , remains approximately constant at @xmath117 .
quenched lattice simulations fail noticeably to reproduce this behaviour .
hqet predicts that @xmath116 is proportional to @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the heavy quark field . as the clover term is of this form
, naively one would then expect that increasing the size of clover coefficient would reduce this discrepancy at least for heavy light systems .
tentative comparisons with the @xmath4 and @xmath2 actions at @xmath120 with low statistics indicated that the fall off in the splitting had decreased @xcite . in fig .
( [ fig : mvsq - mpssq - comp ] ) the splittings from the three different values of the clover coefficient are compared .
the scale for each action is chosen from @xmath121 .
the slope @xmath122 is unaffected by this choice . while there is a noticeable change in the slope on going from @xmath4 to @xmath2 , the slopes at @xmath2 and @xmath3 are consistent with each other .
the remaining discrepancy is presumably due to the error of the quenched approximation . as noted previously , it is useful to be able to compare lattice spectrum results with existing experimental data without an extrapolation to the chiral limit .
the parameter @xmath8 , defined as@xcite @xmath123 allows such a comparison .
existing quenched wilson like fermion actions yield values around @xmath124 whereas an estimate of @xmath8 using experimental data yields @xmath125 . in fig .
( [ fig : jplot ] ) , @xmath8 versus @xmath5 ( including the calculated value of j at two volumes from the gf11 collaboration ) is plotted .
we find @xmath126 the values of @xmath8 from eq.([eq : j - bigvol ] ) and eq.([eq : j - smallvol ] ) below , for both non zero values of @xmath5 and both volumes , agree with the world average of the quenched data , and disagree with the experimental estimate . it should be noted that @xmath8 is trivially related to the slope @xmath122 outlined in the previous section .
we therefore expect that the prescription that solves the anomalous behaviour of @xmath116 will also solve the disagreement in @xmath8 .
we extrapolate the nucleon mass to the normal - quark limit assuming a linear dependence on the quark mass : @xmath127 we extrapolate the @xmath6 mass likewise .
the final results for the nucleon and @xmath6 are quoted in table [ chiral - nucleon ] and table [ chiral - delta ] respectively . from the combined results for the pseudoscalar , vector and nucleon masses
, we show the `` edinburgh '' plot in fig .
( [ fig : edin - plot - fiveseven ] ) .
one finds a statistically significant difference between the ratios at each value of @xmath5 . as @xmath5
is increased , the trend of the data is towards the phenomenological curve of ono @xcite .
furthermore , the ratio @xmath128 approaches the experimental value @xmath129 , but even at @xmath3 is still approximately @xmath130 too large .
the masses obtained for the @xmath39 lattice are listed in table [ mps - c - coarse ] to table [ mdelta - c - coarse ] .
as stated previously , it proved to be somewhat more difficult to extract reliable masses for this volume .
as before , @xmath31 is evaluated with a statistical and systematic error to be @xmath131 which agrees with the result from the larger volume and has a similarly sized systematic error . likewise , as shown in fig .
( [ fig : hyperfine - volume ] ) , the hyperfine splittings are consistent to within 1 standard deviation . the chirally extrapolated and strange meson masses are determined as in section iii.a.2 and the results listed in table [ chiral - mesons ] and table [ strange - masses ] . once again , the results are consistent to within one standard deviation with those on the larger volume .
similarly , the parameter @xmath8 is determined to be @xmath132 which is consistent with the larger volume .
both baryons are more strongly affected by the size of the lattice .
the nucleon masses at both @xmath41 s are approximately two standard deviations smaller than in the larger volume .
this is somewhat unexpected as other studies in quenched qcd using wilson like fermions indicate that the nucleon mass falls with increasing size over a similar range of volumes ( using @xmath81 to determine the lattice spacing , we see that our volumes vary from @xmath11 to @xmath12 approximately ) .
we note that the @xmath53 values for the fit to the nucleon masses on the @xmath39 lattice are very close to 1 , which may indicate that the statistical errors are underestimated .
we find the extrapolated value @xmath133 which is also two standard deviations smaller than in the larger volume .
the @xmath6 masses at both @xmath41 s lie approximately two standard deviations above the values on the larger lattice , and @xmath134
in this paper , we have examined the effect , at @xmath135 , of changing the clover coefficient and volume on the quenched light - hadron spectrum computed using the sw fermion action .
as the clover coefficient is increased there is better agreement between the perturbative ( tree level ) and non - perturbative calculation of @xmath69 . when the clover coefficient is changed from @xmath4 ( the wilson action ) to @xmath2 ( the sw action ) and @xmath3 ( the tadpole
improved sw action ) there is a significant difference in the masses of the chirally extrapolated and strange pseudoscalar and vector mesons , in the nucleon and @xmath6 masses and in the edinburgh plot .
interestingly , a number of other quantities , for example @xmath136 , @xmath8 and the ratios @xmath9 and @xmath10 do not appear to change significantly as @xmath5 is changed from @xmath137 to @xmath104 . as the finite volume effects appear to be under control , and these observables have been chosen to avoid the systematic errors due to the chiral extrapolation , the possible remaining systematic errors are the effect of quenching the gauge configurations and a possibly large deviation of the mean field estimate of the clover coefficient from @xmath24 .
it would therefore be very interesting then to examine the behaviour of these quantities in any future studies in full qcd under changes in the value of the clover coefficient . in changing the volume from approximately @xmath11 to @xmath12 the mesonic observables are consistent to within one standard deviation .
baryon masses are consistent to within two standard deviations .
unfortunately , with this data , one can not differentiate between different _ anstze _ used for describing the volume behaviour of masses @xcite , @xcite .
the alpha collaboration @xcite , @xcite has calculated the clover coefficient non perturbatively for @xmath138 . in general , the coefficients obtained through this approach are significantly larger than those obtained via tadpole improvement , although the coefficients converge as @xmath67 is increased .
our data appears to suggest that @xmath24 could at @xmath0 be somewhat larger than the tadpole improved value .
currently , we are carrying out an analysis of the quenched light hadron mass spectrum at @xmath100 and @xmath120 using the tadpole improved sw action@xcite .
this will directly explore whether better scaling is achieved using @xmath139 than with @xmath2 .
hps would like to thank the staff at brookhaven national laboratory for their kind hospitality during his stay there .
dgr acknowledges the support of pparc through an advanced fellowship , and the support of argonne national laboratory during the completion of this work .
the ukqcd collaboration wish to express their thanks to the edinburgh parallel computing centre for their support and maintenance of the meiko computing surfaces .
k. symanzik , proc . of the trieste workshop on non - perturbative field theory and qcd , ( world scientific , 1982 ) , 61 .
b. sheikholeslami and r. wohlert , nucl.phys .
* b * 259 ( 1985 ) 572596 .
allton _ et al .
_ , ukqcd collaboration , nucl.phys .
* b * 407 ( 1993 ) , 331355 . m. lscher and p. weisz , commun.math.phys . , 97 , 5977 ( 1985 ) .
k. jansen _ et al .
_ , alpha collaboration , phys.lett .
* b * 372 , ( 1996 ) 275282 . s. collins _ et al .
_ , nucl.phys .
* b * 47 ( proc suppl . ) , 366369 , ( 1996 ) , hep lat/9509043 . m. alford _
et al . _ , nucl.phys . *
b * 47 ( proc suppl . ) , 370373 , ( 1996 ) , hep lat/9509087 . c. morningstar and m.peardon , nucl.phys .
* b * 47 ( proc suppl . ) , 258261 , ( 1996 ) , hep
fiebig and r.m .
woloshyn , tri pp961 , hep lat/9603001 ( 1996 ) .
p. hasenfratz and f. niedermayer , nucl.phys .
* b * 414 , 785814,(1994 ) .
lepage and p.b .
mackenzie , phys.rev . *
d * 48 ( 1993 ) , 2250 . f. butler _ et al .
_ , gf11 collaboration , nucl.phys .
* b * 430 ( 1990 ) 179228 .
p. lacock and c. michael , ukqcd collaboration , phys.rev * d * 52 , ( 1995 ) 5213 .
m. creutz , phys.rev .
* d * 36 ( 1987 ) 515 ; f.r .
brown and t.j .
woch , phys.rev.lett .
58 ( 1987 ) 2394 .
n. cabibbo and e. marinari , phys.lett .
* b * 119 ( 1982 ) 387 .
allton _ et al .
_ , ukqcd collaboration , phys.rev .
* d * 47 ( 1993 ) , 5128 .
allton _ et al .
_ , ukqcd collaboration , phys.rev .
* d * 49 ( 1994 ) , 474 .
w.h . press _ et al _ `` numerical recipies in c '' , 2nd edition , cambridge university press , ( 1992 ) .
marquardt , journal of the society for industrial and applied mathematics , * 11 * , 431441 , ( 1963 ) .
b. efron , siam review * 21 * , 460 , ( 1979 ) .
s. sharpe , phys.rev .
* d * 41 ( 1990 ) 3233 , phys.rev .
* d * 46 ( 1992 ) 3146
. t. bhattacharya _ et al .
_ , phys.rev .
* d * 53 , 6486 - 6508 , ( 1996 ) . s. collins _ et al .
_ , nucl.phys .
* b * 47 ( proc suppl . ) , 451454 , ( 1996 ) , hep lat/9512027 .
r. sommer , nucl .
* b*411 , ( 1994 ) 839 .
et al . _ ,
phys.lett .
* b*126 , ( 1983 ) 250 .
s. ono , phys .
* d * 17 , 888 , ( 1978 ) .
m. lscher , commun.math.phys .
104 , 177206 , ( 1986 ) .
m. fukugita _ et al .
* b * 294 , ( 1992 ) 380 .
m. lscher _
et al . _ , alpha collaboration , to appear in nucl.phys .
* b * ( proc . suppl . ) , proceedings of lattice 96
, st . louis , hep - lat/9608049 .
kenway _ et al .
_ , ukqcd collaboration , to appear in nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . )
proceedings of lattice 96
, st . louis and ukqcd collaboration , in preparation . | we compute the light hadron mass spectrum at @xmath0 using the @xmath1-improved sheikholeslami - wohlert ( sw ) fermion action with two choices of the clover coefficient : the classical value , @xmath2 , and a mean - field or tadpole - improved estimate @xmath3 .
we compare our results with those of the gf11 collaboration who use the wilson fermion action ( @xmath4 ) .
we find that changing @xmath5 from zero to 1 and 1.57 leads to significant differences in the masses of the chirally extrapolated and strange pseudoscalar and vector mesons , the nucleon , the @xmath6 , and also in the edinburgh plot .
a number of other quantities , for example @xmath7 , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 do not appear to change significantly .
we also investigate the effect of changing the lattice volume from approximately @xmath11 to @xmath12 .
we find that the meson masses are consistent to within one standard deviation and baryon masses are consistent to within two standard deviations . |
macroscopic metastable states of trapped cold atom systems have been a subject of active experimental and theoretical study for more than a decade @xcite . unlike a homogeneous system of bosons , where infinitesimally small attractive interaction between atoms leads to a collapse , trapped bosons
are known to form long lived bose - einstein condensates @xcite ( bec ) due to zero - point energy which , for sufficiently low densities , can compensate the negative interaction energy thus maintaining the system in equilibrium . upon
increasing the bec density , interaction energy grows , and , at some instability point ( i.e. , at a certain number of particles in the trap @xmath0 , with @xmath1 for a typical trap ) , zero - point energy can no longer sustain the negative pressure due to the interactions and the system collapses .
it has been argued in the literature @xcite that near the instability point ( for bec densities slightly lower than the instability density ) , the effective energy barrier that prevents bec from collapsing becomes so low that the system can quantum mechanically tunnel into the dense ( collapsed ) state .
such phenomenon of macroscopic quantum tunneling ( mqt ) , however , has never been observed experimentally due to a strong dependence of the barrier height on the total number of particles in the trap ( @xmath2 ) .
indeed it has been shown @xcite that the tunneling exponent for such a transition near the instability point scales as @xmath3 and therefore very fine tuning of the total particle number @xmath2 is required in order to keep the tunneling exponent relatively small [ @xmath4 . since for most bec setups
the total number of the trapped atoms fluctuates and typically obeys poissonian statistics , the error in @xmath2 scales as @xmath5 and therefore such a stringent requirement is hard to fulfill .
thus the system is typically either in a sub - critical state with no barrier present ( @xmath6 ) or is in the state with very high energy barrier and therefore very low mqt rate . in this paper
we propose another paradigm for observation of tunneling driven phase transition effects in cold atom systems based on the theory of quantum nucleation @xcite .
it has long been known that a mixture of @xmath7he-@xmath8he undergoes a phase separation transition at relative concentration of @xmath7he in @xmath8he of around @xmath9 at temperatures close to the absolute zero @xcite .
since such a phase separation is a first order phase transition ( it is observed to be accompanied by the latent heat release down to mk temperatures ) , the order parameter must have some finite ( microscopic ) correlation length and therefore the transition is expected to occur through the formation of nuclei of the new stable phase in the old metastable one . as usual ,
dynamics of the nucleation process is controlled by the competition of the surface and bulk energies of the nuclei and therefore , in order for a given nucleus to become stable ( supercritical ) , it must overcome a potential barrier formed by the two above contributions .
while in most systems such a transition is a thermally activated process , it has been argued that in the @xmath7he-@xmath8he mixture at sufficiently low temperatures ( below 100 mk ) the transition is driven by the quantum tunneling . in particular ,
it was predicted @xcite that near the transition line the tunneling exponent for such a transition rate is proportional to @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the difference in the chemical potentials of the two phases .
it has later been found experimentally @xcite that below 80 mk kinetics of such phase separation transition becomes independent on temperature and therefore it must be driven by the quantum tunneling . however , the experiments have been unable to verify the expected dependence of the nucleation rate on the systems s parameters ( i.e. , @xmath12 , etc ) - partly due to the poor knowledge of microscopic interactions between particles in such a strongly correlated system .
we argue that contemporary cold atom systems provide an excellent candidate for studying and observing the kinetics of such a phase separation transition in boson - fermion mixtures @xcite .
mixtures of boson and fermion atoms are typically realized in experiments studying fermionic superfluidity , where bosons play role of a coolant @xcite .
another interesting realization of boson - fermion mixture has been demonstrated in two - component fermion system , where strongly bound cooper pairs correspond to bosons interacting with unpaired fermion atoms @xcite . in the present paper
we begin with detailed derivation and analysis of the results outlined in ref . .
significant attention is given to supercritical dynamics , which reflects the dissipative mechanisms and is measurable in less interacting system .
starting from a microscopic description of a boson - fermion mixture we derive an effective action for the order parameter ( the bec density ) taking into account fermion - boson interaction .
we show explicitly that the classical potential for the order parameter due to such interaction has two minima corresponding to the two phases of the system ( mixed and phase separated ) , see sec .
[ sec : phases ] .
we analyze the coherence length associated with the system and demonstrate that it varies from finite to divergent and therefore allows different mechanisms for the phase transition , see sec .
[ sec : equil ] . at low fermion densities
the two minima of the potential are separated by the finite energy barrier resulting in finite coherence length , which points out that such a transition is of the first order @xcite .
we then derive an expression for the nucleation ( tunneling ) rate of the critical droplet of the pure fermion phase near the phase transition line and near the line of absolute ( spinodal ) instability of the mixed phase in secs .
[ sec : i - ii ] and [ sec : spinodal ] .
we show that the transition rate is measurable ( of the order @xmath13s@xmath14m@xmath15 ) for densities reasonably close to the phase transition line and small fermion - boson mass ratio .
the limitation on the mass ratio comes as the result of dissipative dynamics due excitations in fermion system . near the phase transition line it leads to significant modification ( increase ) of the transition rate for the system with high fermion - boson mass ratio , in which case the observable transition rates exist closer to the line of absolute instability ( where the dissipation is less effective and the tunneling exponent becomes reasonably small ) .
our results for this regime are similar to those obtained in ref .
for the mqt in the systems of trapped bosons with attractive interactions .
however , in the case of boson - fermion separation transition the height of the potential barrier and , thus , the tunneling exponent are controlled not by the total number of particles in the trap , but their densities , scaling as @xmath16 .
therefore , for sufficiently large numbers of particles in the trap the tunneling exponent can be fine - tuned with a desired accuracy which makes it possible to observe the mqt rate in a well controlled and predictable regime .
we consider a bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) interacting with a single species of fermions ( in the same spin state ) .
interactions in such the mixture are characterized by two scattering lengths @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
fermions and bosons interact through contact potential @xmath19 , contributing term @xmath20 , where @xmath21 ; @xmath22 and @xmath23 are boson and fermion fields respectively . in addition , boson - boson particle interaction give rise to another term @xmath24 in the hamiltonian density , with @xmath25 .
the direct coupling between fermions is negligible : s - scattering channel is forbidden for the fermions in the same spin state , while p - wave scattering is small compared to boson - boson and boson - fermion contact interaction .
the potential part of the energy density can be cast in the form @xmath26 for the purposes of the present calculation we can neglect the spatial dependence of the trapping potential and assume that the local densities of fermions and bosons are set by the constant chemical potentials @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
indeed , since the nucleation occurs at finite coherence length ( to be defined below ) , the shape of the trapping potential should play little role in the dynamics of the phase transition as long as the effective size of the trap is much greater than the coherence length .
it is convenient to describe the system in terms of the boson field only , tracing @xmath29 ( @xmath30 is the overall hamiltonian ) with respect to the fermion field .
such averaging can be easily carried out within mean field , i.e. , the thomas - fermi approximation @xcite , so that the calculation reduces to the evaluation of the canonical partition function ( or free energy ) of the free fermions with effective chemical potential @xmath31 .
later , in sec .
[ sec : equil ] , we will proceed beyond this approximation and account for the fermion excitations interacting with the condensate . for the purpose of this and the following section such
a correction is not necessary . within thomas - fermi approximation
@xcite we deal with the energy density of free fermions in the zero - temperature limit . it can be easily found differentiating fermion free energy @xmath32 with respect to the volume ( note that @xmath33 ) .
we finally obtain the effective classical potential density for the bosons @xmath34 where @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , and we have used the density phase variables , i.e. @xmath38 , for the condensate field .
the approximation discussed above ignores gradient terms in the diagrammatic expansion of the partition function @xcite .
this terms are not important for the phase structure of the equilibrium system and will be discussed in sec .
[ sec : equil ] . in the next section
we discuss the structure of the phase diagram describing possible configurations in the equilibrium boson - fermion system .
subsequent sections are devoted to the kinetics of the transition .
the transition rates are calculated in secs .
[ sec : i - ii ] and [ sec : spinodal ] . sections [ sec : thermal ] and [ sec : expansion ] are devoted to the discussion of thermal activation and supercritical expansion .
the results are discussed in sec .
[ sec : discus ] .
equation ( [ eq : intro : eeff ] ) was obtained tracing over the fermionic part of the partition function . in this respect
, it can be viewed as effective potential energy of boson condensate .
the structure of the fast fermionic part of the system , in particular the density of fermions , is directly related to the state of the boson condensate . in the limit of zero temperatures
we obtain the fermion density in the form @xmath39 where the chemical potential @xmath27 is the same for all parts of the system in the mixture as far as the time scale of slow boson subsystem is of interest .
it was shown within thomas - fermi approximation @xcite that the equilibrium boson - fermion system with interactions introduced above can exist in three configurations ( phases ) : ( i ) mixture , ( ii ) coexistence of pure fermion fraction with ( spatially separated ) mixture , and ( iii ) coexistence of pure boson and pure fermion fractions , see fig .
[ fig1.eps ] . in this section
we show that the structure of the entire phase diagram can be obtained from the energy density ( [ eq : intro : eeff ] ) .
indeed , we notice that @xmath40 has either one or two local minima .
the first one ( if present ) is at @xmath41 .
it clearly describes pure fermion fraction with the density of fermion @xmath42 .
the position of the second minimum is found from @xmath43 .
it describes either the mixture with fermion density @xmath44 , or the pure boson fraction with @xmath45 due to the step function in eq .
( [ eq : phases : nf - gen ] ) .
we first discuss the situation when the thickness of the transition region ( boundary ) between the fractions , or the coherence length , @xmath46 , is microscopic ( i.e. small with respect to the characteristic size of the fractions ) . in this case
it is natural to introduce the overall ( average ) fermion @xmath47 and boson @xmath48 densities of a larger system . here
@xmath49 and @xmath50 are relative volumes for each fraction . when the densities @xmath51 and @xmath52 are small , the minimum at @xmath53 is the only one present . at low temperatures
the equilibrium system will occupy this minimum creating uniform mixture ( phase i ) with @xmath54 and @xmath55 ( @xmath56 ) . at higher densities the minimum at @xmath41the pure fermion fraction forms . as a result , in equilibrium , the two minima align , @xmath57 , which defines the volume of the spatially separated fermion fraction . for clarity of further discussion
it is convenient to introduce dimensionless densities @xcite as @xmath58 here and throughout the paper we adopt the convention of using
n " for dimensionless densities corresponding to original densities denoted by @xmath59 " .
the conversion parameters of eq .
( [ eq : phases : nfb ] ) are @xmath60 and @xmath61 where @xmath62 is related to boson gas parameter ( defined @xcite via @xmath63 ) as @xmath64 .
the separation between phases i and ii on the phase diagram ( @xmath65 vs @xmath66 ) occurs when @xmath49 sets to zero . the corresponding phase separation curve can be easily obtained in a parametric form as follows . introducing @xmath67 and @xmath68 one can write the boson and fermion densities in the mixture fraction as @xmath69 the equilibrium mixture coexists with unoccupied ( @xmath70 ) pure fermion minima only at the i - ii phase transition curve . in terms of @xmath71 and @xmath72 , the equation @xmath57 takes the form @xmath73 which , together with eq .
( [ eq : phases : nfb - ay ] ) defines the phase transition curve : @xmath74 vs @xmath75 . from eq .
( [ eq : phases : ya ] ) we also see that @xmath71 varies within @xmath76 ( since by definition @xmath77 within phase ii ) .
the complete separation on pure fermion and pure boson fractions ( phase iii ) occurs for higher densities when @xmath78 .
this situation is not considered in the present paper . in the discussion above
, it was assumed that in the phase ii the fermion fraction is spatially separated from the mixture and the volume of the surface layer is negligible .
this is not always the case as will be demonstrated in the next section .
however when @xmath46 is large , one can still define effective partial volumes @xmath49 and @xmath79 , assuming that the densities discussed above are the peak densities .
while the relation between @xmath49 and @xmath79 is now complicated , the limit @xmath70 with @xmath80 still exists .
therefore , the i - ii separation curve found above is valid . and @xmath81 for bosons and fermions respectively , as defined in eq .
( [ eq : phases : nfb ] )
. the inset ( b ) shows the sketch of @xmath40 at equilibrium for the corresponding phases .
the inset ( c ) gives the sketch of @xmath40 near ( below ) the instability line and ( above ) the phase separation curve .
the arrow indicates ( schematically ) modification of @xmath40 during the equilibration.,width=306 ]
we are interested in the kinetics of the phase transition between phases i and ii , which is manifested by separation of pure fermion fraction out of the mixture .
when the uniform mixture is prepared with the densities @xmath65 and @xmath66 above the i - ii separation curve , e.g. point x , it occupies the second minima of @xmath40 and is metastable , see fig .
[ fig1.eps]c . as @xmath65 increases towards the point y ( and further )
the barrier that separates local minima @xmath82 becomes smaller and eventually disappears from @xmath83 , with @xmath84 ( the absolute , spinodal , instability line ) . from this point
the mixture becomes unstable .
the decay of the metastable mixture results in spatial separation of pure fermion fraction . at low temperatures
this transition is governed by quantum tunneling ( in contrast to high temperatures , when thermal activation becomes effective and transition is due to thermal fluctuations rather then tunneling ) . to illustrate the equilibration process ,
let us assume that the coherence length , @xmath46 , is small enough so that the spatial separation of the fermion fraction is well defined .
towards the end of this section we will show where such condition is met . during the equilibration , the relative volume @xmath49 of the fermion fraction increases from 0 to some equilibrium value @xmath85 .
the densities @xmath82 and @xmath86 of the remaining mixture will change , as well as @xmath40 .
the point @xmath87 will drift towards i - ii separation curve where @xmath88 , as shown by the arrow in figs .
[ fig1.eps]a and [ fig1.eps]c .
as it can be easily verified , the drift line is parallel to ii - iii separation line and its intersection with the @xmath65 axis gives the equilibrium value for the density in pure fermion fraction , @xmath42 .
the partial volume of the later is @xmath89 . in what follows
we will obtain the density profile for the fermion droplet in various regions of the phase diagram ( within phase ii ) and set up equations to describe the transition rate in the system .
the rates are calculated in the next sections .
the dynamics of the boson condensate due to tunneling part of the equilibration is given by the transition amplitude @xmath90 , where the rhs is feynman s sum over the histories @xcite .
the state @xmath91 represent the ( non - equilibrium ) metastable mixture residing in the second minimum of @xmath40 , at @xmath92 .
the state @xmath93 correspond to the state after the tunneling with @xmath94 , @xmath95 . beyond this point
the system hydrodynamically equilibrates to the state @xmath96 where the two minima get aligned , see fig [ fig1.eps]b , curve ii .
the lagrangian density is defined as @xmath97 , where the hamiltonian density contains the kinetic @xmath98 and potential @xmath40 contributions , where the latter is considered within the thomas - fermi approximation , see eq .
( [ eq : intro : eeff ] ) .
as it has been pointed out earlier , approximation for @xmath40 , i.e. eq . ( [ eq : intro : eeff ] ) , does not account for the gradient terms which arise due to inhomogeneity of the fermion subsystem and add to @xmath98 term of the lagrangian density . in other words , the approximation implies that renormalization of the boson kinetic energy arising due to the non - locality of the fermionic response function is relatively small .
a straightforward perturbative estimate @xcite to the second order in @xmath99 yields the gradient term correction to the thomas - fermi of the order @xmath100 .
comparing this term with the bare boson kinetic energy , we see that near the phase transition line it is smaller by the factor of @xmath101 .
therefore , for sufficiently low @xmath102 and not very small fermion densities the renormalization correction is negligible .
this is clearly the case in the region near the spinodal instability line . in the vicinity of the phase separation line
the renormalization correction can become important ( e.g. closer to the tricritical point where @xmath103 ) . in this case the correction is given by the factor of @xmath104 , where the coherence length @xmath46 is of the order @xmath105 or greater ( as will be demonstrated shortly ) . for @xmath106 and not too small @xmath65 ( e.g. for @xmath107 ) , @xmath108 , and
thus the thomas - fermi approximation is well justified . considering the above arguments
, the transition can be described by the effective lagrangian density of the form @xmath109 here the first term can be viewed as the berry phase ; the second and the third terms arise due to the kinetic energy ; the dissipative terms due to particle - whole excitations in the fermion subsystem will be included later . the contribution due to non - condensate component of bosonic system
is already accounted for by the above treatment and therefore separate consideration is not necessary for the purpose of the present calculation .
the decay rate from a metastable state can be obtained @xcite by calculating the classical action for the transition amplitude in imaginary time formalism , @xmath110 .
namely , @xmath111 where the action @xmath112 is evaluated over the classical ( extremal ) trajectory , @xmath113 . as will be shown below , for the parameters of interest , the rate is dominated by the exponent and is less sensitive to the changes in prefactor @xmath114
. therefore precise evaluation of @xmath114 is not crucial .
it can be estimated as @xmath115 , where @xmath46 is boson coherence length as before , and @xmath116 is an `` attempt '' frequency . from the uncertainty principle @xmath117 and thus @xmath118 .
the extremal action @xmath119 is calculated by setting the corresponding functional derivatives to zero , i.e. @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
the second derivative is trivial .
it leads to the continuity equation @xmath122 with @xmath123 and can be used to eliminate @xmath124 .
equation .
( [ eq : equil : continuityeq ] ) can be easily solved for the velocity of the condensate assuming spherical symmetry .
the result is @xmath125 . after a straightforward algebra
the action becomes @xmath126.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the pure fermion fraction to be formed during the equilibration corresponds to the bubble in the boson system .
its shape is defined by the last two terms of eq .
( [ eq : equil : s ] ) , i.e. the equation @xmath127 in the static case , @xmath128 to solve it , let us first ignore the the second term of the left - hand side , which is a reasonable approximation for large enough bubbles .
the solution of the remaining equation can be easily estimated for all relevant area of the pase diagram , see appendix [ app : shape ] .
near the i - ii separation curve we obtain @xmath129}\ ] ] where the coherence length , @xmath130 is @xmath131 near the spinodal instability the first - derrivative term becomes important .
the density @xmath132 varies between @xmath133 and @xmath82 .
the coherence length @xmath134 is found , see appendix [ app : shape ] , in the form @xmath135 the estimate of @xmath46 for all the densities of phase ii below instability is given in fig .
[ fig2.eps]a ( see appendix [ app : shape ] for derivations ) . for not too small @xmath62
the characteristic length associated with the transition region is microscopic , i.e. @xmath136 .
this is the case for large part of the interval @xmath137 , see fig .
. therefore formation of a distinct fermion fraction with thin boundary ( nucleation ) is expected for this range of parameters .
it is straightforward to obtain the characteristic ( critical ) radius , @xmath138 of such a nuclei . integrating both sides of eq .
( [ eq : equil : difeqstatic ] ) with respect to @xmath139 we obtain @xmath140 . when @xmath141 , we have @xmath142 , where @xmath143 is the surface tension . , for different values of dimensionless boson density of the mixture : @xmath144 ( from bottom to top ) .
the dashed curve represents reciprocal coherence length at the i - ii phase separation curve.,width=188 ]
we now consider the effect of dissipation which was ignored so far in our description of the kinetics .
excitation of the particle - hole pairs in the fermion subsystem interacting with the condensate affects the transition , as it happens for other systems with quantum tunneling @xcite .
as will be demonstrated further , the resulting dissipation is important and can lead to significant modifications of the transition rate .
the dissipation terms arise naturally from more accurate treatment of the boson - fermion interaction .
indeed , the thomas - fermi approximation utilized in the derivation of the effective potential @xmath40 , see secs .
[ sec : model ] and [ sec : equil ] , implies that fermions instantaneously ( on a much shorter time scale ) adjust to the local variation of boson density : it ignores the @xmath145-dependent terms in the diagrammatic expansion of the partition function .
the effect can be analyzed by considering the second order correction produced by the interaction @xmath146 .
@xmath147 the first @xmath145 independent term is already present in eq .
( [ eq : intro : eeff ] ) .
we are after the frequency dependent term @xmath148 responsible for landau damping . in the limit @xmath149 ,
i.e. near the phase separation curve and far enough from the instability line , we can use @xmath150 as suggested by eq .
( [ eq : equil : rho_i - ii ] ) . substitution into eq .
( [ eq : equil : dec - vac - pol ] ) gives the correction to @xmath119 in the form @xmath151 ^ 2 \ln\left|\frac{r(t)-r(t ' ) } { r(t)+r(t')}\right|\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath152 .
the first two terms in the right - hand side arise due to the restructuring of the fermionic density of states inside the droplet in the course of its expansion , while the last term can be viewed as coupling between droplet s surface and particle - hole excitation in fermi sea . near spinodal instability
the tunneling barrier is small and the correction is due to small variation of the density @xmath153 around the metastable minima , thus @xmath154
in this section we evaluate the i - ii transition rate near the phase separation curve , see fig .
[ fig1.eps]a .
evaluation of the extremum action with the structure of eq .
( [ eq : equil : s ] ) has been address in ref . .
in the vicinity of the transition curve the coherence length , @xmath130 , is given by eq .
( [ eq : equil : l0 ] ) . at the same time
@xmath155 as we approach the i - ii transition curve ( the two minima of @xmath40 align ) and , therefore , @xmath156 . as the result @xmath157 and the boson density entering eq .
( [ eq : equil : rho_i - ii ] ) can be approximated by a step function @xmath158 $ ] ( the thin wall approximation ) , where @xmath82 is bosonic density of the mixed phase as before .
within such an approximation the action @xmath119 can be formulated @xcite in terms of @xmath159 . evaluating the integral in eq .
( [ eq : equil : s ] ) over @xmath160 we obtain @xmath161,\ ] ] here @xmath162 is the surface tension defined earlier . in the present case ( since @xmath149 ) , the second term of eq .
( [ eq : equil : difeqstatic ] ) is negligible and a simple energy conservation equation @xmath163 corresponding to the static part of action @xmath119 holds .
therefore we can rewrite the surface tension as @xmath164 this integral is evaluated in appendix [ app : sigma ] .
the numerical result is shown in fig .
[ fig3.eps ] .
it can be approximated by @xmath165 with the error of a few percents along the entire curve , see appendixes [ app : shape ] and [ app : sigma ] . .
approximation , eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : sigma - aprox ] ) , is shown by the dashed curve.,width=188 ] it is expected that the surface tension coefficient will decrease as one departs from the phase separation curve .
however near the transition line this change is not significant compared to the change in the bulk energy .
therefore to estimate nucleation rates it is sufficient to use eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : sigma - aprox ] ) .
the bulk energy is given by the integral of @xmath40 over the volume of the bubble .
therefore @xmath166 is the energy difference @xmath167 or the degree of metastability , see fig .
[ fig1.eps]c .
when @xmath168 , @xmath12 vanishes and therefore along the large part of the phase separation curve @xmath169 .
however , this in not the case near the end of the curve when @xmath170 . generally , @xmath171\ ] ] where @xmath172 one can see that when @xmath173 the second term in eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : delta - mu ] ) vanished and we can use @xmath174 as pointed out earlier . in the opposite case @xmath175 and @xmath176 . in this last limit , however , one has to account for renormalization of the boson kinetic term and , thus , the surface tension coefficient @xmath162 , as discussed earlier .
the phase transition and formation of the fermion droplet is due to the interplay between the surface tension and bulk energy of the droplet [ the last two term in @xmath119 , see eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : s0 ] ) ] , which creates a potential barrier .
the system ( instanton ) has to tunnel through this barrier creating the critical droplet of radius @xmath177 .
the rate of such the nucleation process is found from @xmath178 , with the result @xmath179 . in terms of dimensionless densities of fig .
[ fig1.eps]a , for @xmath173 we obtain @xmath180 here @xmath102 is the conventional boson gas parameter as define earlier . as expected , the tunneling exponent , i.e. the rhs of eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) , is singular in the degree of metastability @xmath181 and diverges as @xmath182 .
equation ( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) also indicates that the rate of nucleation is exponentially small in the dilute limit , i.e. , for @xmath183 . since the thin wall approximation ( nucleation ) requires sufficiently high energy barrier , e.g. fig .
[ fig1.eps](b,c ) , the rhs of eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) can not be reduce significantly decreasing @xmath66 , see eq .
( [ eq : equil : l0 ] ) and fig .
[ fig2.eps]a .
however , due to the smallness of the numerical coefficient one can hope that quantum nucleation is observable in sufficiently strongly coupled systems ( which are presently realizable with the use of feshbach resonance ) .
indeed , for @xmath184 , @xmath107 , and @xmath185 , the coefficient @xmath186 and the tunneling exponent , is @xmath187 .
for the same parameters and @xmath188 a.u .
the estimate of the prefactor @xmath114 gives @xmath189 s@xmath14m@xmath15 . as the result
the nucleation rate @xmath190 is of the order @xmath191 s@xmath14m@xmath15 .
this is readily observable .
let us now include dissipation terms ( [ eq : equil : deltas ] ) .
exact evaluation of extremal action @xmath192 , eqs .
( [ eq : i - ii : s0 ] ) and ( [ eq : equil : deltas ] ) , is not possible and we use the variational technique .
a natural anzats is @xmath193 , where coefficients @xmath194 and @xmath195 are variational parameters .
the expression for @xmath196 , eq .
( [ eq : equil : deltas ] ) , does not depend on the time scale of @xmath159 .
rescaling of @xmath159 yields @xmath197 .
the proportionality coefficient depends only on the shape of the trial function , and , thus , can be estimated separately .
the system @xmath198 , @xmath199 leads to the solution @xmath200 where for @xmath173 @xmath201 note that @xmath202 for @xmath203 and @xmath204 for @xmath205 .
the second limit gives the leading asymptotic in the vicinity of the phase separation curve @xmath206 the other limit gives expression ( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) with slight overestimate of the numerical prefactor due to variational nature of the calculation .
the overall solution is @xmath207\ ] ] where we have rescaled the overall numerical coefficient to mach expression ( [ eq : i
- ii : gammax ] ) in the underdamped limit @xmath203 .
the exponent @xmath208 as a function of @xmath209 is shown in fig .
[ fig4.eps ] .
the crossover between power @xmath210 and @xmath211 asymptotic curves take place at @xmath212 , or @xmath213 thus , we find that correction due to dissipation term , @xmath196 , strongly alters the tunneling exponent in the region @xmath214 , while in the opposite ( non - dissipative ) limit the tunneling exponent is given by eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) . from eqs .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammadec ] ) and ( [ eq : i - ii : deccrossover ] ) we conclude that the influence of dissipation is significant for large @xmath215 mass ratio . from the crossover condition
we also see that the dissipative regime is realized near the phase separation curve within a band " of width @xmath181 determined by the relation ( [ eq : i - ii : deccrossover ] ) . for mixtures with small fermion - boson mass ratio this band "
is relatively narrow and for large enough fermion density the system stays in non - dissipative regime , where the nucleation rate is given by eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) .
let us consider the previous example ( with @xmath184 , @xmath216 , etc . ) assuming @xmath217 .
for this set of parameters the system is in the crossover region ( at the edge of the dissipative band " on the phase diagram ) . using eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammaall ] ) we obtain @xmath218 , which means that the transition is not observable . choosing a smaller mass ratio , e.g. @xmath219 ( the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : deccrossover ] ) becomes smaller by an order of magnitude ) , we shrink the dissipative region around the phase transition curve .
the system now is in quiet " ( non - dissipative ) regime and the previous estimates for the rate obtained with eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) are valid
. therefore the dynamics of quantum nucleation can be systematically observable only for cold atom systems with sufficiently small mass ratio @xmath215 .
in this section we evaluate the transition rate near the absolute instability line , i.e. @xmath220 . in this case the barrier separating the metastable mixture becomes small , see fig .
[ fig1.eps]c , curve y. to compute the tunneling part of the transition based on action ( [ eq : equil : s ] ) it is sufficient to retain only a few terms in the expansion of @xmath40 at @xmath92 .
the terms of the second and the third order in @xmath221 will form the barrier ( we set @xmath222 for convenience ) . it is clear that in the kinetic part of the action only the second order terms should be kept ( the third order terms containing gradients are small compared to the third order potential terms ) .
we obtain @xmath223,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath224 and @xmath225 the dependence of action ( [ eq : spinodal : s ] ) on @xmath65 and @xmath66 can be obtained rescaling @xmath160 , @xmath226 , and @xmath227 , similarly to ref . . by introducing dimensionless variables @xcite @xmath228 , @xmath229 , and @xmath230 ,
the action @xmath119 can be rewritten as @xmath231 , where @xmath232 $ ] is a parameter - independent functional , the extremum of which is a c - number .
its value can be estimated by variational anzats @xmath233 , where @xmath194 , @xmath234 and @xmath235 are variational parameters .
we find @xmath236 , @xmath237 , and @xmath238 . upon a straightforward calculation one
obtains @xmath239 again we see that tunneling exponent is controlled by the inverse boson gas parameter @xmath102 .
the exponent vanishes when fermion density @xmath65 reaches the instability line @xmath240 , where effective energy barrier disappears , see fig .
[ fig1.eps]c . in this case
the transition rate is defined by the prefactor @xmath114 rather then exponent , which is especially troublesome for a dense system .
this limit , however , is not of interest here .
moreover , for not very small @xmath66 the observable transition occurs much closer to the phase separation curve ( far from the instability point ) and is described by eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammaall ] ) of sec .
[ sec : i - ii ] .
when @xmath241 and @xmath242 , the phase transition is not observable near the transition curve , see eqs .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) and ( [ eq : i - ii : gammadec]),one has to chose the values of @xmath65 closer to the spinodal instability . in this case the exponent ( [ eq : spinodal : gamma ] ) is significant .
it rises rapidly as the function of @xmath243 defining the transition rate near the instability region . in this respect eq .
( [ eq : spinodal : gamma ] ) is similar to the results on macroscopic quantum tunneling ( mqt ) in systems of trapped bosons with attractive interactions @xcite . when the coherence length @xmath244 , see eq .
( [ eq : equil : ls ] ) is still much smaller then the size of the condensate , the height of the potential barrier and thus the tunneling exponent for the critical droplet are controlled not by the total number of particles in the trap , but the local densities .
therefore , for sufficiently large numbers of particles in the trap the tunneling exponent can be fine - tuned with a desired accuracy , which can make observation of the mqt rate possible in a well controlled and predictable regime . the contribution of dissipation , e.g. , action @xmath196 in eq .
( [ eq : equil : deltas - spinodal ] ) , can be estimated by using the same variational anzats as above . rewriting the integral in eq .
( [ eq : equil : deltas - spinodal ] ) in terms of @xmath245 , @xmath246 and @xmath195 one finds that @xmath196 does not depend on @xmath247 and thus @xmath248 .
therefore for large enough @xmath248 and small @xmath102 one can treat the dissipation perturbatively substituting @xmath249 from the above calculations . as the result the tunneling exponent acquires an additional term @xmath250 .
this term is again controlled by the mass ratio @xmath215 . for not too high fermion / boson mass ratio ,
it is of the order @xmath102 and thus dissipation does not significantly alter the dynamics of the phase transition ( mqt ) in this region , see fig .
[ fig4.eps ] .
, as a function of fermion density , @xmath251 , for @xmath252 , @xmath253 ( left ) and @xmath254 ( right ) .
asymptotics near the i - ii phase separation curve are plotted for @xmath255 ( solid curves , bottom to top ) .
the dashed line represents the rate without dissipation , see eq .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) .
the asymptotic near the instability region , eq .
( [ eq : spinodal : gamma ] ) , is given in the right plot ( for the same variation of @xmath215).,width=306 ]
it is instructive to analyze the influence of the classical ( thermal ) activation mechanism . in
order leave the metastable state finite temperature system can ( in addition to direct tunneling leakage from its false ground " state ) use its entire spectrum tunneling from high energy states or going over the barrier .
the rate of such transition is proportional to the sum @xcite of @xmath256 $ ] , where the prefactor accounts for possible tunneling from @xmath257-th exited state of the metastable mixture .
this regime becomes effective when the largest energy gap between the first exited and the ground state energies of the mixture is of the order @xmath258 .
this energy difference enters the expression for quantum nucleation rate and can be easily estimated in a similar manner @xmath259 here the characteristic length scale is the coherence length of boson - fermion mixture .
near the phase transition curve @xmath46 is given by eq .
( [ eq : equil : l0 ] ) , i.e. @xmath260 .
this gives the relation @xmath261 critical temperature of bec transition can be estimate by that of the uniform non - interacting three - dimensional boson gas @xmath262 , and we finally obtain condition for thermal assisted transition in the form @xmath263 our boson system is in deep bec state , i.e. @xmath264 , therefore thermal fluctuations are not significant for observable quantum nucleation that occurs in sufficiently dense systems ( @xmath265 ) . in dilute systems , where direct tunneling from low laying states is extremely slow ,
one has two compute the entire sum @xmath266 up to the continuum states where @xmath267 .
the summation can be carried out semiclassically minimizing the new energy functional , i.e. exponent of eq .
( [ eq : expansion : gamma - gen ] ) , see e.g. ref . .
closer to the spinodal instability the barrier becomes smaller and the tunneling is effective even for relatively dilute systems . for the crossover temperature
we obtain @xmath268 in this case , as expected , the zero - temperature mqt mechanism can be observed in certain distance from the instability line , i.e. when the left - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : expansion : spinodal - tc ] ) is greater .
as soon as a critical droplet is created as the result of tunneling or temperature fluctuations , it should grow equilibrating the system as pointed out in sec . [ sec : equil ] . below
we discuss only the case of finite coherent length
the situation when a distinct stable droplet is created ( thin - wall approximation ) .
we will estimate the expansion rate for @xmath269 in the limits of large and small dissipation .
after a given nuclei passes ( tunnel trough ) the energy barrier , its growth can be described by classical equation of motion for radius @xmath270 , @xmath271 . here
@xmath272 is the dissipative force ( external time - dependent force is negligible at low temperatures ) , and the action @xmath119 should be formulated in real ( original ) time , i.e. in action ( [ eq : i - ii : s0 ] ) one replaces @xmath110 . in the underdamped limit , @xmath273 ( energy conserved ) ,
the expansion is described by @xmath274 for large droplets ( @xmath275 ) the surface tension term is negligible and the expansion is linear in time @xmath276 , with @xmath277 fermion particle - hole excitations affect the the expansion dynamics , renormalizing the expansion rate @xmath278 . to estimate this effect we need to account for the dissipative part of the action .
this can be done by analytical continuation of matsubara action , eq .
( [ eq : equil : dec - vac - pol ] ) , to keldysh contour .
following ref .
we obtain @xmath279 where @xmath280 and @xmath281 resides on forward ( backward ) branch . in the nucleation limit ( thin wall approximation )
the time dependance of @xmath282 enters only via radius of the droplet , @xmath159 , therefore @xmath283 . in the classical limit
we keep only terms linear in @xmath284 .
the dissipative force becomes @xmath285 substitution of @xmath286 will lead to the logarithmic divergence in the integration over the momentum .
the divergence is due to the high @xmath287 .
the cutoff comes from the thickness of the surface area of the droplet . using a more accurate expression for @xmath282 ,
i.e. eq . ( [ eq : equil : rho_i - ii ] ) , we obtain @xmath288 where @xmath289 is the euler constant , and @xmath46 is the coherence length .
as the result , expansion of a large supercritical droplet is governed by @xmath290 this equation can be analyzed numerically for dimensionless variables .
define @xmath291 , @xmath292 , then eq .
( [ eq : expansion : diss - eq ] ) becomes @xmath293 here @xmath294 , @xmath295 , and @xmath296 .
numerical integration shows that for @xmath297 and @xmath298 the first and the second terms remain smaller by several orders of magnitude .
therefore we can ignore this terms in such the limit .
moreover , we notice that logarithmic pre - factor of the third term does not change significantly for large supercritical droplets .
therefore with sufficient accuracy the growth is still linear in time @xmath299 with @xmath300 one can notice that @xmath301 and therefore diverges at the phase separation curve . as the result , the above solution is valid near the phase separation line .
when the system is placed farther away from the phase separation curve , @xmath12 increases and @xmath302 becomes smaller . in this case
we have to retain the first two derivative terms in eq .
( [ eq : expansion : diss - eq - dless ] ) .
it changes the asymptotic behavior . in the limit @xmath303
we arrive to eq .
( [ eq : expansion : econsrv ] ) with the solution @xmath304 , where @xmath278 is given by eq .
( [ eq : expansion : alpha_0 ] ) .
similar to nucleation , the expansion of a supercritical droplet is controlled by particle - whole excitations if the system is prepared within a certain dissipative " region around the phase separation line , e.g. , sec .
[ sec : i - ii ] . for larger degree of supersaturation
, dissipation is less effective .
the dissipative " region can be approximately estimated from condition @xmath305 .
we should note that measurement of the growth rate does not necessarily require extremely dense systems in which nucleation is observable .
supercritical droplet can be created externally , e.g. by some laser fields or trapped atoms of different sort . for such initiated supercritical droplet the growth rate could be readily observable .
in the previous sections we have considered dynamics of the nuclei of a new phase ( i.e. , pure fermion phase ) in the fermion - boson mixture in the metastable state .
we have derived asymptotic expressions for the nucleation rates for the system in two regimes : in the regime of weak metastability , e.g. , near the phase transition line ( sec . [ sec : i - ii ] ) and near the spinodal ( absolute ) instability .
analysis of sec .
[ sec : i - ii ] leads to the conclusion that in the vicinity of the phase transition line the nucleation dynamics is practically not observable for sufficiently dilute systems .
e. g. , with @xmath183 .
it may appear that the dependence of eqs .
( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) , ( [ eq : i - ii : gammadec ] ) , and ( [ eq : i - ii : gammaall ] ) on @xmath66 contradicts to this statement .
indeed the transition rate decreases with @xmath66 if @xmath181 is kept constant .
such limit , however , is incorrect , since the nucleation condition @xmath306 in not satisfied , @xmath307 ( or @xmath308 if @xmath102 is constant ) . evaluating @xmath138 in terms of @xmath181 one obtains the condition on @xmath181 for which the asymptotes ( [ eq : i - ii : gammax ] ) , ( [ eq : i - ii : gammadec ] ) , and ( [ eq : i - ii : gammaall ] ) are valid .
we have @xmath309 . in the limit
@xmath310 it gives @xmath311 ( where the densities are dimensionless , i.e. in units of fig .
[ fig1.eps]a , as before ) . therefore in @xmath312 limit the power @xmath211 and @xmath210 asymptotes are not measurable .
measurable transition rates for dilute systems can be found closer to the instability region . in this case one
enters a crossover between nucleation and mqt regimes . as an example , let us consider the mixture with the boson gas parameter @xmath313 .
for @xmath314 nm and about @xmath315 confined particles .
this corresponds to the densities of the order @xmath316cm@xmath15 with size of the trapped condensate @xmath318 m . for this parameters
the position of the metastable mixture on the phase diagram , fig .
[ fig1.eps]a , is primarily defined by the ratio @xmath319 , see eqs .
( [ eq : phases : g0 ] ) and ( [ eq : phases : g1 ] ) , and can be controlled by changing the scattering lengths .
the transition rate is @xmath320 where @xmath321 , see eqs .
( [ eq : spinodal : gamma ] ) , ( [ eq : equil : ls ] ) .
the change of the prefactor is not significant due to fast decay of the exponent form @xmath322 ( for smaller @xmath245 accurate evaluation of @xmath114 is necessary ) .
therefore we conclude that for @xmath323 and @xmath324 the dependence of the exponent ( [ eq : spinodal : gamma ] ) on the densities is measurable . in this case
the coherence length @xmath325 m .
it rises for small @xmath243 , however at @xmath326 m ( or @xmath327 ) the transition is still controlled by local densities .
we have also found , e.g. sections [ sec : dissipation ] and [ sec : i - ii ] , that dissipation can rather strongly alter the dependence of the nucleation rate in the vicinity of the phase transition line . while the results obtained in these sections are likely to be correct only quantitatively , they show that in the vicinity of the transition line excitation of particle - hole pairs in the fermi sea plays crucial role . as a result
the thomas - fermi approximation is inapplicable within the `` band '' controlled by the fermion - boson interaction strength as well as fermion - boson mass ratio ; see sec .
[ sec : i - ii ] .
finally we considered the dynamics of supercritical droplets , i.e , the ones which have tunneled to the supercritical size .
we have found that in the non - dissipative regime the radius of the droplet grows linearly with time with the expansion rate coefficient proportional to @xmath328 . in dissipative region , which occurs near the phase transition line ,
the situation is quite similar : up to logarithmic corrections the radii of the droplets still grow linearly with time , with rate now being dependent on friction coefficient , see sec .
[ sec : expansion ] .
we thank eddy timmermans for valuable discussions and comments .
ds acknowledges stimulating discussions with vladimir privman .
the work is supported by the us doe .
to analyze the shape of the condensate density function @xmath132 of the bubble , i.e. the solution of eq .
( [ eq : equil : difeqstatic ] ) , it is convenient to introduce dimensionless quantities as @xmath329 , @xmath330 , @xmath331 , @xmath332 , @xmath333 , and write the action ( [ eq : equil : s ] ) in the form @xmath334\ ] ] with @xmath335u + \frac{5}{2}au^2 - ( 1-u)^{5/2}\ ] ] where @xmath336 , @xmath337 , @xmath338 , and @xmath339 .
note that the parameters @xmath71 and @xmath72 ( or @xmath340 ) , introduced in sec .
[ sec : phases ] , are generally independent and define the position on the phase diagram via the same relation as in eq .
( [ eq : phases : nfb - ay ] ) .
the relation ( [ eq : phases : ya ] ) between them defines the special case the equilibrium state ( residing on the phase separation curve ) .
here we are after the time - independent part of the action @xmath341 . in the current notation equation ( [ eq : equil : difeqstatic ] )
reads @xmath342 let us first discuss the case when the second term of the left - hand side is negligible ( which is clearly the case near the phase transition curve ) . equation ( [ eq : shape : difeqstatic ] ) can , then , be simplified to @xmath343 noticing that @xmath344 .
this is also the consequence of energy conservation at large @xmath245 corresponding to the static part of action @xmath341 .
the right - hand side of ( [ eq : shape : deq ] ) is too complicated for the equation to be solved analytically .
however , for the purpose of integration , @xmath345 can be approximated in the range @xmath346 , where @xmath347 , as @xmath348 with @xmath349 here @xmath350 and @xmath351 .
this approximation is exact at @xmath352 , i.e. close to the maximum of the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : shape : deq ] ) and therefore should lead to correct estimate of the characteristic length scale of @xmath353 .
the maximal absolute deviation @xmath354 $ ] occurs at @xmath355 and @xmath356 at the end of the i - ii separation curve ( @xmath357 ) , as can be easily verified numerically . at that point
we obtain @xmath358 .
the error vanishes at the limit of small barrier , i.e. near the instability line on the phase diagram . with this approximation eq .
( [ eq : shape : deq ] ) can be easily solved with the result @xmath359 = \\ \nonumber & & = \frac{{\left ( { \sqrt u + \sqrt { u_0 } } \right)\left ( { \sqrt { uu_0 } + \sqrt { u - u_1 } \sqrt { u_0 - u_1 } - u_1 } \right)}}{{\left ( { \sqrt u - \sqrt { u_0 } } \right)\left ( { \sqrt { uu_0 } - \sqrt { u - u_1 } \sqrt { u_0 - u_1 } - u_1 } \right)}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the characteristic size of the bubble , @xmath270 , enters into the constant of integration .
the characteristic length - scale on the surface of the bubble ( the coherence length ) is @xmath360 where @xmath361 . in the vicinity of _ the i - ii separation curve _ @xmath362
, @xmath71 is a function of @xmath340 according to eq.([eq : phases : ya ] ) , and we use @xmath363
. substitution to eq .
( [ eq : shape : w ] ) yields @xmath364 as the function of @xmath340 , @xmath365 varies from @xmath366 to @xmath367 with the mean value of @xmath368 ( the root - mean - square deviation is @xmath369 ) .
therefore near the i - ii separation curve with the same precision the coherence length , @xmath370 , becomes @xmath371 in the vicinity of _ spinodal instability _
@xmath372 as can be verified by expanding @xmath373 in powers of @xmath374 , and we use @xmath375 .
substitution into eq .
( [ eq : shape : w ] ) yields @xmath376 therefore the coherence length , @xmath244 , clearly diverges as @xmath377 . collecting all dimensional factors we obtain @xmath378 in the above analysis
we have ignored the first derivative term in eq .
( [ eq : shape : difeqstatic ] ) .
it is strictly speaking negligible only near the phase transition curve for large thin - boundary bubbles . in the instability region solution ( [ eq :
shape : solution ] ) will change . nevertheless , the analysis of eq .
( [ eq : shape : difeqstatic ] ) shows taht the characteristic length scale still has to be inverse - proportional to @xmath379 and incorporate the divergence of @xmath380 . therefore relation ( [ eq :
shape : l ] ) still holds .
this can be demonstrated by expanding the right - hand side of eq .
( [ eq : shape : difeqstatic ] ) in terms of @xmath381 . in the intermediate region ,
i.e. @xmath382 , the order - of - magnitude agrement is expected since no other features are present , as can also be verified numerically . ) , for @xmath383 .
inset ( a ) gives absolute error of this expression with respect to a straight line approximation ( for the same set of @xmath340 ) .
inset ( b ) shows the relative error between the result of numerical integration in the lhs of eq .
( [ eq : app : sigma : int ] ) and @xmath384 as a function of @xmath66 ( solid line ) .
the dashed line is a linear fit of the form @xmath385.,width=306 ]
the surface tension has been defined as @xmath386 where we used the notations of appendix [ app : shape ] . utilizing the approximation ( [ eq : shape : approxe ] ) at the i - ii transiiton curve ,
i.e. setting @xmath387 , we obtain @xmath388\ ] ] the left - hand side can be integrated numerically for various @xmath340 to verify the result , see fig .
[ figb.eps ] .
significant relative error of eq .
( [ eq : shape : approxe ] ) at @xmath355 is suppressed in the above integral and the approximation ( [ eq : app : sigma : int ] ) is accurate along the entire phase separation curve . using the value of @xmath389 found earlier ( see appendix [ app : shape ] ) we finally obtain @xmath390\ ] ] for large @xmath66 , closer to tricritical " point , the effective surface tension will deviate from the one obtained above due to additional gradient terms in eq .
( [ eq : equil : s ] ) .
this is due to renormalization of the boson kinetic energy which is ignored by the thomas - fermi approximation .
this correction is negligible for the parameters of interest , as explained in sec .
[ sec : equil ] . | kinetics of phase separation transition in boson - fermion cold atom mixtures is investigated .
we identify the parameters at which the transition is governed by quantum nucleation mechanism , responsible for the formation of critical nuclei of a stable phase .
we demonstrate that for low fermion - boson mass ratio the density dependence of quantum nucleation transition rate is experimentally observable .
the crossover to macroscopic quantum tunneling regime is analyzed .
based on a microscopic description of interacting cold atom boson - fermion mixtures we derive an effective action for the critical droplet and obtain an asymptotic expression for the nucleation rate in the vicinity of the phase transition and near the spinodal instability of the mixed phase .
we show that dissipation due to excitations in fermion subsystem play a dominant role close to the transition point . |
the standard model ( sm ) of elementary particle physics , which is based on the gauge group @xmath5 is very successful in explaining the fundamental interactions of nature . with the recent discovery of higgs at lhc
, the sm seems to be complete .
however , it has certain limitations .
for example , the muon @xmath1 anomaly , which is a discrepancy between the observation and sm measurement with more than @xmath6 confidence level @xcite .
similarly , it does not explain sub - ev masses of active neutrinos as confirmed by long baseline oscillation experiments @xcite .
moreover , it does not accommodate any particle candidate of dark matter ( dm ) whose existence is strongly supported by galaxy rotation curve , gravitational lensing and large scale structure of the universe @xcite . in fact , the dm constitutes about @xmath7 of the total energy budget of the universe as precisely measured by the satellite experiments wmap @xcite and planck @xcite . at present lhc
is the main energy frontier and is trying to probe many aspects of physics beyond the sm . an attractive way of probing new physics is to search for a @xmath8-gauge boson which will indicate an existence of @xmath9 symmetry . within the sm , we have accidental global symmetries @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the baryon number , and @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the total lepton number .
note that @xmath10 and @xmath12 are anomalous and can not be gauged without adding any ad hoc fermions to the sm .
however , the differences between any two lepton flavours , i.e. , @xmath14 , with @xmath15 , are anomaly free and can be gauged without any addition of extra fermions to the sm . among these extensions
the most discussed one is the gauged @xmath16 @xcitethe interactions of corresponding gauge boson @xmath8 are restricted to only @xmath17 and @xmath18 families of leptons and therefore it significantly contribute to muon @xmath1 anomaly , which is a discrepancy between the observation and sm measurement with more than @xmath6 confidence level .
moreover , @xmath8 does not have any coupling with the electron family .
therefore , it can easily avoid the lep bound : @xmath19 tev @xcite .
so , in this scenario a @xmath8- mass can vary from a few mev to tev which can in principle be probed at lhc and at future energy frontiers . in this paper
we revisit the gauged @xmath0 model in light of muon @xmath1 anomaly , neutrino mass and dm phenomenology .
we augment the sm by including three right handed neutrinos : @xmath20 , @xmath21 and @xmath22 , which are singlets under the sm gauge group , and a vector like colorless neutral fermion @xmath23 .
we also add an extra sm singlet scalar @xmath24 .
all these particles except @xmath20 , are charged under @xmath0 , though singlet under the sm gauge group .
when @xmath24 acquires a vacuum expectation value ( vev ) , the @xmath0 breaks to a remnant @xmath25 symmetry under which @xmath23 is odd while all other particles are even . as a result @xmath23 serves as a candidate of dm .
the smallness of neutrino mass is also explained in a type - i see - saw framework with the presence of right handed neutrinos @xmath20 , @xmath21 and @xmath22 whose masses are generated from the vev of scalar field @xmath24 . in this model
the relic abundance of dm ( @xmath23 ) is obtained via its annihilation to muon and tauon family of leptons through the exchange of @xmath0 gauge boson @xmath8 .
we show that the relic density crucially depends on @xmath0 gauge boson mass @xmath26 and its coupling @xmath27 .
in particular , we find that the observed relic density requires @xmath28 for @xmath29 mev .
however , if @xmath30 then we get an over abundance of dm , while these couplings are compatible with the observed muon @xmath1 anomaly .
we resolve this conflict by adding an extra singlet scalar @xmath31 doubly charged under @xmath0 , which can drain out the large dm abundance via the annihilation process : @xmath32 . as a result
, the parameter space of the model satisfying muon @xmath1 anomaly can be reconciled with the observed relic abundance of dm .
we further show that the acceptable region of parameter space for observed relic density and muon @xmath1 anomaly is strongly constrained by null detection of dm at xenon-100 @xcite and lux @xcite .
moreover , the compatibility of the present framework with indirect detection signals of dm is also checked . in particular , we confront the acceptable parameter space with the latest positron data from pamela @xcite , fermi - lat @xcite and ams-02 @xcite .
the paper is arranged as follows . in section - ii
, we describe in details the different aspects of the model .
section - iii is devoted to show the allowed parameter space from muon @xmath1 anomaly . in section - iv
, we estimate the neutrino mass within the allowed parameter space .
section v , vi and vii are devoted to obtain constraints on model parameters from the relic density , direct and indirect search of dm . in section - viii
, we lay the conclusions with some outlook .
we consider the gauge extension of the sm with extra @xmath0 symmetry ( from now on referred to as `` gauged @xmath0 model '' ) where difference between muon and tau lepton numbers is defined as a local gauge symmetry @xcite .
the advantage of considering the gauged @xmath0 model is that the theory is free from any gauge anomaly without introduction of additional fermions .
we break the gauge symmetry @xmath0 to a residual discrete symmetry @xmath25 and explore the possibility of having non - zero neutrino mass and a viable candidate of dm .
the spontaneous symmetry breaking of gauged @xmath0 model is given by : @xmath33 where @xmath34 at first , the spontaneous symmetry breaking of @xmath35 is achieved by assigning non - zero vacuum expectation values ( vevs ) to complex scalar field @xmath24 and @xmath31 .
the subsequent stage of symmetry breaking @xmath36 is obtained with the sm higgs @xmath37 providing masses to known charged fermions .
the complete spectrum of the gauged @xmath0 model in light of dm and neutrino mass is provided in tablei where the respective quantum numbers are presented under @xmath38 . to the usual quarks and leptons ,
we have introduced additional neutral fermions @xmath39 for light neutrino mass generation via seesaw mechanism and a vector like dirac fermion @xmath23 for the candidate of dm , being odd under the residual discrete symmetry @xmath25 .
we note that except @xmath23 all other particles are even under the @xmath25 symmetry .
[ tab : sm ] .particle content of the minimal @xmath40 gauge extension of the sm and their transformation under the sm gauge group . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
we discussed a gauged @xmath41 extension of the sm in light of the non - zero neutrino mass , dm and the observed muon @xmath1 anomaly which is a more than @xmath2 discrepancy between the experimental measurement and the sm prediction .
in adition to that , three right handed neutrinos @xmath39 and a dirac fermion @xmath23 were introduced which are charged under @xmath41 symmetry except @xmath20 which is a complete singlet fermion .
the @xmath41 was allowed to break to a survival @xmath25 symmetry at a tev scale by giving vev to a sm singlet scalar @xmath24 which bears an unit @xmath42 charge .
the vev of @xmath24 gave masses not only to the additional gauge boson @xmath43 , but also to the right handed neutrinos : @xmath39 .
as a result , below electroweak symmetry breaking , the light neutrinos acquired masses through the type - i seesaw mechanism . under the survival @xmath25 symmetry , @xmath23 was chosen to be odd while rest of the particles were even .
thus @xmath23 became an excellent candidate of dm .
we obtained the relic abundance of dm via its annihilation to muon and tauon families of leptons through the exchange of @xmath43 gauge boson .
it is found that for @xmath43 mass greater than 100 mev and its coupling to leptons : @xmath44 correct relic abundance can be obtained . on the other hand , the muon @xmath1 anomaly required smaller values of the gauge coupling @xmath45 for @xmath43 mass greater than 100 mev ( see fig .
[ fig : mz_copling ] ) .
so the two problems could not be solved simultaneously .
therefore , we introduced an additional scalar @xmath31 which is doubly charged under @xmath41 but singlet under the sm gauge group . in presence of @xmath31 ,
the dm dominantly annihilates to @xmath31 fields . as a result we found a large region of parameter space in which the constraints from muon @xmath1 anomaly and relic abundance of dm could be satisfied simultaneously .
the hitherto null detection of dm at direct search experiments , such as lux , also give strong constraints on the model parameters as discussed in fig .
[ fig : mz_copling ] .
we found that for @xmath43 mass greater than 100 mev we need the corresponding gauge coupling : @xmath46 .
in fact such values of @xmath45 hardly agree with muon @xmath1 constraint .
however , in presence of @xmath31 we can allow small values of the gauge coupling @xmath45 which can satisfy muon @xmath1 anomaly while direct detection limit can be satisfied through @xmath47 mixing diagram .
the annihilation of dm to only muon and tauon families of leptons dictates its nature to be leptophilic .
so , the observed positron flux by pamela , fermi - lat and recently by ams-02 in the cosmic ray shower with suppressed anti - proton flux could be explained in our model .
we showed in fig .
[ ams2 ] that the constraints from muon @xmath1 anomaly and ams-02 positron excess can be satisfied simultaneously in our model .
the work of sr is supported by the university of adelaide and the australian research council through the arc center of excellence in particle physics at the terascale .
narendra sahu is partially supported by the department of science and technology , govt . of india under the financial grant sr / ftp / ps-209/2011 .
j. p. miller , e. de rafael and b. l. roberts , rept .
phys . * 70 * , 795 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0703049 ] .
s. fukuda _ et al .
_ [ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , phys . rev .
lett . * 86 * , 5656 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ex/0103033 ] .
g. bertone , d. hooper and j. silk , phys .
405 , 279 ( 2005 ) , arxiv : hep - ph/0404175 ; g. jungman , m. kamionkowski and k. griest , phys .
267 , 195 ( 1996 ) , arxiv : hep - ph/9506380 .
g. hinshaw _ et al . _
[ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. suppl .
* 208 * , 19 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1212.5226 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
p. a. r. ade _ et al .
_ [ planck collaboration ] , astron .
astrophys .
* 571 * , a16 ( 2014 ) , arxiv:1303.5076 [ astro-ph.co ] . x. g. he , g. c. joshi , h. lew and r. r. volkas , phys .
d * 44 * , 2118 ( 1991 ) .
w. altmannshofer , m. carena and a. crivellin , arxiv:1604.08221 [ hep - ph ] . w. altmannshofer , s. gori , m. pospelov and i. yavin , phys .
d * 89 * , 095033 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.1269 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. heeck , phys .
b * 758 * , 101 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1602.03810 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. fuyuto , w. s. hou and m. kohda , phys .
d * 93 * , no . 5 , 054021 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1512.09026 [ hep - ph ] ] . t. araki , f. kaneko , t. ota , j. sato and t. shimomura , phys . rev .
d * 93 * , no . 1 , 013014 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1508.07471 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. crivellin , g. dambrosio and j. heeck , phys .
d * 91 * , no . 7 , 075006 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1503.03477 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. crivellin , g. dambrosio and j. heeck , phys .
lett . * 114 * , 151801 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1501.00993 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. heeck , m. holthausen , w. rodejohann and y. shimizu , nucl .
b * 896 * , 281 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1412.3671 [ hep - ph ] ] .
b. shuve and i. yavin , phys .
d * 89 * , no .
11 , 113004 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1403.2727 [ hep - ph ] ] .
e. salvioni , a. strumia , g. villadoro and f. zwirner , jhep * 1003 * , 010 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.1450 [ hep - ph ] ] .
f. yin , j. liu and s. h. zhu , phys . lett .
b * 679 * , 362 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.4644 [ hep - ph ] ] .
x. j. bi , x. g. he and q. yuan , phys .
b * 678 * , 168 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0903.0122 [ hep - ph ] ] .
b. adhikary , phys .
d * 74 * , 033002 ( 2006 ) [ hep - ph/0604009 ] .
e. ma and d. p. roy , hep - ph/0111385 .
n. f. bell and r. r. volkas , phys .
d * 63 * , 013006 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0008177 ] .
x. g. he , hep - ph/9409237 .
j. c. park , s. c. park and j. kim , phys .
b * 752 * , 59 ( 2016 ) [ arxiv:1505.04620 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. harigaya , t. igari , m. m. nojiri , m. takeuchi and k. tobe , jhep * 1403 * , 105 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1311.0870 [ hep - ph ] ] . k. fuki and m. yasue , nucl .
b * 783 * , 31 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0608042 ] .
e. aprile _ et al .
_ [ xenon100 collaboration ] , phys . rev .
lett . *
109 * , 181301 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1207.5988 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
d. s. akerib _ et al . _
[ lux collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 112 * , 091303 ( 2014 ) [ arxiv:1310.8214 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
m. ackermann _ et al .
_ [ fermi - lat collaboration ] , phys . rev .
lett . *
108 * , 011103 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1109.0521 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
m. aguilar _ et al .
_ [ ams collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 141102 ( 2013 ) .
r. essig , phys .
d * 78 * , 015004 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0710.1668 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. koch , z.physik c 15 161 ( 1982 ) ; j. gasser , h. leutwyler and m. e. sainio , phys .
b 253 260 ( 1991 ) ; m. m. pavan , r. a. arndt , i. i. strakovski and r. l. workman , pin newslett .
16 110 ( 2002 ) ; a. bottino , f. donato , n. fornengo and s. scopel , phys . rev .
d 78 083520 ( 2008 ) , [ arxiv:0806.4099 ] .
a. hook , e. izaguirre and j. g. wacker , adv .
high energy phys .
* 2011 * , 859762 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1006.0973 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. s. babu , c. f. kolda and j. march - russell , phys .
d * 57 * , 6788 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9710441 ] .
d. tucker - smith and n. weiner , phys .
d * 64 * , 043502 ( 2001 ) [ hep - ph/0101138 ] .
y. cui , d. e. morrissey , d. poland and l. randall , jhep * 0905 * , 076 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0901.0557 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. arina and n. sahu , nucl .
b * 854 * , 666 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1108.3967 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. arina , j. o. gong and n. sahu , nucl .
b * 865 * , 430 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1206.0009 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. arina , r. n. mohapatra and n. sahu , phys .
b * 720 * , 130 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1211.0435 [ hep - ph ] ] .
o. adriani _ et al . _
[ pamela collaboration ] , phys .
* 105 * , 121101 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1007.0821 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
ams-02 collaboration , talks at the ams days at cern , 15 - 17 april , 2015 .
g. giesen , m. boudaud , y. gnolini , v. poulin , m. cirelli , p. salati and p. d. serpico , jcap * 1509 * , no .
09 , 023 ( 2015 ) [ arxiv:1504.04276 [ astro-ph.he ] ] .
a. w. strong , i. v. moskalenko and v. s. ptuskin , ann .
nucl . part .
* 57 * , 285 ( 2007 ) [ astro - ph/0701517 ] .
i. v. moskalenko and a. w. strong , astrophys .
j. * 493 * , 694 ( 1998 ) [ astro - ph/9710124 ] ; a. e. vladimirov _ et al .
_ , comput .
commun .
* 182 * , 1156 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1008.3642 [ astro-ph.he ] ] . | gauged @xmath0 model has been advocated for a long time in light of muon @xmath1 anomaly , which is a more than @xmath2 discrepancy between the experimental measurement and the standard model prediction .
we augment this model with three right - handed neutrinos @xmath3 and a vector - like singlet fermion @xmath4 to explain simultaneously the non - zero neutrino mass and dark matter content of the universe , while satisfying anomalous muon @xmath1 constraints .
it is shown that in a large parameter space of this model we can explain positron excess , observed at pamela , fermi - lat and ams-02 , through dark matter annihilation , while satisfying the relic density and direct detection constraints . |
organic charge - transfer ( ct ) crystals made up by @xmath1 electron - donor ( d ) and electron acceptor ( a ) molecules often exhibit a typical stack structure , with d and a molecules alternating along one direction.@xcite the quasi - one - dimensional electronic structure is stabilized by the ct interaction between d and a , so that the ground state average charge on the molecular sites , or degree of ionicity , @xmath2 , assumes values between 0 and 1 .
crystals characterized by @xmath3 0.5 are _ conventionally _ classified as quasi - neutral ( n ) , as opposed to the quasi - ionic ( i ) ones , with @xmath4 0.5 .
as discussed for the prototypical system of tetrathiafulvalene - chloranil ( ttf - ca),@xcite a few ct salts have n - i and peierls transition , in which @xmath2 changes rapidly and the regular stack dimerizes , yielding a potentially ferroelectric ground state.@xcite n - i transitions are valence instabilities implying a _ collective _ ct between d and a sites , and as such are accompanied by many intriguing phenomena , such as dielectric constant anomalies , current - induced resistance switching , relaxor ferroelectricity , and so on.@xcite the isostructural series formed by 4,4-dimethyltetrathiafulvalene ( dmttf ) with substituted cas , in which one or more chlorine atom is replaced by a bromine atom , is particularly interesting . in this case , in fact , the transition temperature and related anomalies can be lowered towards zero by chemical or physical pressure , attaining the conditions of a quantum phase transition.@xcite albeit several aspects of the n - i transition in br substituted dmttf - ca family are worth further studies , the motivation of the present work is far more limited , as we want first of all clarify the mechanism of the transition in the pristine compound , dmttf - ca . despite intensive studies,@xcite the transition still presents controversial aspects . through visible reflectance spectra of single crystals and absorption spectra of the powders , aoki@xcite suggested that by lowering the temperature below 65 k , dmttf - ca does not undergo a full n - i transition , but forms a phase in which both n ( @xmath5 ) and i ( @xmath6 ) species are present . the structural investigation as a function of temperature@xcite put in evidence a fundamental aspect of the transition , only implicit in aoki s
work:@xcite at 65 k the unit cell doubles along the _ c _ axis ( _ a _ is the stack axis ) .
the order parameter of the transition , which is second - order , is the cell doubling coupled with the dimerization.@xcite so above 65 k the cell contains one stack , and at 40 k contains two stacks , both dimerized , and inequivalent ( space group @xmath7 ) . from the bond distances , @xmath2 is estimated at 0.3 and 0.7 - 0.8 for the two stacks , respectively.@xcite in this view , and considering that the two stacks are dimerized in anti - phase , at low temperature dmttf - ca has a _ ferrielectric _ ground state .
however , the above scenario has been questioned.@xcite polarized single crystal infrared ( ir ) reflectance measurements suggests that n and i stacks do not cohexist .
only one ionicity is observed , changing continuously from about 0.25 at room temperature to about 0.48 at 10 k , the maximum slope in the @xmath8 occurring around 65 k. the crystal structure at 14 k indicates a @xmath9 space group , with two equivalent , dimerized stacks in the unit cell , and _ anti - ferroelectric _ ground state.@xcite according to this picture , the mechanism of dmttf - ca phase transition is very similar to the other n - i transitions.@xcite the madelung energy change yields an appreciable change of @xmath2 ( about 0.1 ) within a few degrees of temperature , accompanied by a stack dimerization .
the cell doubling appears to be a secondary aspect , whereas the most important feature is the continuous variation of @xmath2 , as opposed for instance to the discontinuous , first order transition of ttf - ca.@xcite some questions remain however unanswered in the above picture.@xcite the transition displays a continuous ionicity change with @xmath10 , and consequently one would expect huge anomalies at the transition , whereas for instance the dielectric constant increase at @xmath11 is less than in the case of ttf - ca.@xcite furthermore , what is the driving force of the transition ?
in ttf - ca , the n - i transition is attributed to the increase of madelung energy by the lattice contraction.@xcite if it is so also for dmttf - ca , what is the role of cell doubling ? finally ,
although @xmath7 and @xmath9 space groups are sometimes difficult to disentangle by x - ray diffraction , the issue of the different published structures is not solved , both exhibiting good confidence factors in the refinement process @xcite in order to clarify these open questions , and to understand the mechanism of the phase transition in dmttf - ca , we have decided to collect and re - analyze complete polarized ir and raman spectra of dmttf - ca single crystals , along the same lines followed for ttf - ca.@xcite indeed , a careful analysis can give information about @xmath2 , stack dimerization , and the peierls mode(s ) inducing it .
vibrational spectra give information about the _
local _ structure , and from this point of view are complementary to the x - ray analysis , which probes long range order .
we shall show that dmttf - ca transition can hardly be classified as a n - i transition , the most important aspect being the stack dimerization and cell doubling .
we shall also offer some clues about the origin of the discrepancies in the two x - ray determinations.@xcite
dmttf - ca single crystals have been prepared as previously described.@xcite the ir spectra ( 600 - 8000 ) have obtained with a bruker ifs66 ftir spectrometer , equipped with a590 microscope .
raman spectra have been recorded with a renishaw 1000 micro - spectrometer .
the excitation of raman has been achieved with a lexel krypton laser ( @xmath12 = 647.1 nm ) , backscattering geometry , with less than 1 mw power to avoid sample heating .
a pre - monochromator has been used for the low - frequency spectra ( below 200 ) .
for the high frequency raman spectra we report only the spectra obtained for incident and scattered light both polarized perpendicularly to the stack axis , ( @xmath13 ) in the conventional notation . in this arrangment
the in - plane molecular modes , notably the totally symmetric ones , are more clearly visible .
the spectral resolution of ir and raman spectra is 2 .
temperatures down to 10 k have been reached with a ars closed - circle cryostat , fitted under the ir and raman microscopes .
the temperature reading on the cold finger has been tested and considered accurate to @xmath142 k for the raman and ir reflectance measurement , where silver paste has been used to glue the sample to the cold finger . for ir absorption
the temperature reading is far less accurate , due to the unperfect thermal contact between the sample and the kbr window on the cold finger .
temperature reading corrections have been applied based on the comparison with the reflectivity data .
dmttf - ca reflectivity has been normalized to that of an al mirror , without further corrections .
therefore the reflectance values are not absolute , and relative values can be compared with confidence only within each low - temperature run .
we consider reflectance values of the spectra below 20 k not reliable in any case , because the deposition of an unknown contaminant on the dmttf - ca surface introduces high noise above @xmath0 2000 .
the first question we address is that of the ionicity as a function of temperature . to such aim ,
we have collected both ir reflectance and absorbance spectra , with polarization perpendicular to the stack axis .
the two types of spectra allow us to ascertain whether probing the surface or the bulk yields the same result .
unfortunately , we were unable to obtain crystals sufficiently thin to avoid saturation of the most intense absorption bands , so the information provided by the two types of spectra are complementary .
[ fig : irperp ] shows some examples of spectra as a function of temperature in the frequency range 1500 - 1700 .
the two structures at 1649 and 1539 ( at 150 k ) are assigned to the @xmath15 and @xmath16 modes of the ca moiety , corresponding to the c = o and c = c antisymmetric stretching vibrations , respectively.@xcite the c = o stretching mode is the most sensitive to the molecular charge , so it has been almost invariably used to estimate the ionicity .
however , recent investigations on ca and ca@xmath17 molecular vibrations have shown that also the c = c mode should be a good @xmath2 indicator.@xcite therefore we shall use c = o @xmath15 as a primary @xmath2 indicator , and c = c @xmath16 mode as secondary , internal consistency probe . as the c = o stretching mode saturates in absorption ( fig .
[ fig : irperp ] , bottom panel ) , we have performed the usual kramers - kronig transformation of the reflectance spectra . from the frequency reading of the c = o @xmath15 mode
we have estimated the ionicity by the usual relationship : @xmath18/\delta_{ion}$ ] where @xmath19 is the c = o stretching frequency of the neutral molecule and @xmath20 is the ionization frequency shift.@xcite the resulting @xmath8 is reported in the top panel of fig .
[ fig : ionint ] . the top panel of fig .
[ fig : ionint ] is rather similar to the corresponding one of ref . . indeed , our spectra ( fig .
[ fig : irperp ] ) do not show the onset of a strong band around 1580 below 65 k , that according to aoki _ _ et al.__@xcite signals the presence of @xmath21 species .
following ref .
, we attribute the band around 1580 to an activated @xmath22 mode , present in the spectra polarized parallel to the stack ( see section [ sec : dimerization ] ) .
however , our data show two significant differences compared with horiuchi _
results.@xcite first of all , our @xmath8 curve is consistently shifted downward by about 0.05 @xmath2 units with respect to the corresponding one of ref . .
as a consequence , the maximum ionicity at the lowest temperature is well below the n - i borderline , namely 0.43 instead of 0.48 .
we believe the discrepancy is due to the extrapolation involved in the kramers - kronig transformation from reflectance to conductivity .
we have indeed verified that different extrapolation procedures may yield different frequencies , and we have chosen extrapolation parameters giving conductivity spectra with frequencies matching those read in absorption ( bottom panel of fig . [
fig : irperp ] ) .
our datum is also in agreement with what reported by aoki,@xcite who assigned a @xmath2 value of @xmath23 to the n species at 20 k ( although , as stated above , we do not see the insurgence of bands due to i species ) .
the second important difference of our results compared with those of horiuchi _ et al . _
@xcite is that just below the phase transition temperature , between 62 and 54 k , the c = o stretching mode shows a clear doublet structure ( fig .
[ fig : irperp ] , top panel ) , suggesting the presence of two slightly differently charged molecular species .
the indication is confirmed by the band due to the c = c stretching mode , which also shows a doublet structure , clearly seen in absorption ( bottom panel of fig . [ fig : irperp ] ) .
the frequency ( and ionicity ) difference is small , but clearly visible irrespectively of the direction of temperature change , and reproducible in different runs .
actually , a hint of a doublet structure is visible also in ref .
spectra , but it was interpreted as a band broadening . in fig .
[ fig : irperp ] the dashed area indicates the temperature interval of this coexistence . .
middle panel : normalized intensity of ir vibronic bands , connected to the stack dimerization amplitude .
bottom panel : intensity of x - ray reflections signaling the cell doubling ( from ref . ) .
the vertical dashed line marks the critical temperature @xmath24 65 k. ] to summarize , our results present a valence instability scenario different from both the previously reported ones.@xcite the ionicity change appears to be continuous across the phase transition .
the crystal remains neutral ( @xmath25 at 20 k ) , therefore excluding the simple term of n - i transition : it is better to refer to it as a valence instability .
finally , in a temperature interval of less than 10 k below 65 k there is coexistence of two species with slightly different molecular ionicity , both on the neutral side , with @xmath26 0.36 and 0.38 .
it is well known that ir spectra polarized along the stack are sensible to the symmetry breaking associated with stack distortions . in fact
, the loss of inversion center on the molecular units makes the raman - active totally - symmetric ( @xmath22 ) molecular modes also ir active , with huge intensity due to their coupling with the ct electronic transition ( ir `` vibronic bands'').@xcite in addition , it has been recently shown that the ir spectra polarized parallel to the stack , associated with raman , also yield information about pre - transitional phenomena , like the softening of the phonons inducing the stack distortion.@xcite to investigate these aspects of the dmttf - ca phase transition , we have collected the ir reflection spectra polarized parallel to the stack axis .
[ fig : reflpar ] shows some examples of the spectra at different temperatures across the phase transition .
[ fig : reflpar ] shows the insurgence of strong features below @xmath11 .
the spectra are identical to those of ref . , and we follow a similar analysis .
we focus the attention on the two main features around 1400 and 980 , associated with the @xmath27 mode of the ttf skeleton in the dmttf moiety , and to the @xmath28 mode of ca , respectively.@xcite their intensity @xmath29 as a function of @xmath10 is extracted by fitting the reflectance spectra with a drude - lorentz oscillator model , where the dielectric constant is given by : @xmath30 in this equation @xmath31 is the high - frequency dielectric constant , and @xmath32 is the line width .
now , @xmath29 is related to @xmath33 , the dimerization amplitude.@xcite the relationship is not of direct proportionality , but in any case @xmath29 gives an indication of the increase of the dimerization amplitude at the transition.@xcite the @xmath34 for the two modes , normalized at the lowest temperature value ( 20 k ) , are reported in the middle panel of fig .
[ fig : ionint ] for temperatures below 65 k. indeed , around the critical temperature one can not disentangle the contribution to the intensity coming from the combination modes , as discussed in detail in the next section . in the same panel
we report , for comparison , the normalized intensity relevant to the dmttf @xmath22 mode , as given in ref . for the same temperature range .
the middle panel of fig .
[ fig : ionint ] shows that the ir oscillator strengths , related to the stack dimerization amplitude @xmath33,@xcite display a behavior typical of an order parameter relevant to a second - order phase transition .
it is instructive from this point of view to compare the present data with the intensity of the x - ray diffraction spots related to the cell doubling , as reported in ref . and
shown in the bottom panel of fig .
[ fig : ionint ] .
the two sets of data exhibit the same behavior , demonstrating that the cell doubling , as detected by x - ray , and stack dimerization amplitude , as detected by ir , occur at the same time , representing two inseparable aspects of dmttf - ca phase transition . on the other hand , the comparison of the three panels in fig .
[ fig : ionint ] puts in evidence that the valence instability actually _ follows _ the structural modification .
dimerization and cell doubling start at @xmath24 65 k , whereas the rapid increase in @xmath2 occurs slightly below , and implies the simultaneous presence of species with two slightly different ionicities in a @xmath10 interval of about 10 degrees .
if dmttf - ca phase transition is displacive , it should imply the occurrence of soft phonon(s ) yielding the stack dimerization and the cell doubling . in a simplified but effective view
, we can think of the phase transition as due to just one critical phonon , with wavevector @xmath35 .
such a phonon belongs to a phonon branch that corresponds to stack dimerization along the @xmath36 crystal axis , and at the zone - center is optically active .
the driving force of the transition is then provided by the peierls mechanism , which couples the zone - center dimerization mode , i.e. , the peierls mode , with the ct electronic structure.@xcite the electron - phonon causes the softening of the peierls mode , eventually laeding to stack dimerization . however , in the proximity of the phase transition , where interstack interactions are more effective,@xcite the peierls mode evolves to a stack dimerization out - of - phase in nearest - neighbors cells , when it softens yielding the cell doubling along the crystallographic direction @xmath37 .
of course , in the complicated phonon structure of a molecular crystal like dmttf - ca , the peierls mode may result from the superposition ( mixing ) of several phonons , all directed along the stack . a spectroscopic investigation of dmttf - ca , along the lines already developed for
ttf - ca,@xcite should yield the identification of these phonons or of the resulting `` effective '' peierls mode .
phonons coupled to the ct electrons along the chain are most likely inter - molecular , or lattice , phonons.@xcite we start by classifying the lattice phonons and their raman and ir activity by adopting the rigid molecule approximation .
this approximation is known to be not fully valid for ttf - ca,@xcite but is the only reasonable starting point in the lack of explicit calculations of dmttf - ca phonon dynamics .
then , in the high temperature ( ht ) phase ( @xmath38)@xcite we expect 9 opticallly active lattice modes , @xmath39 .
the raman active @xmath40 modes can be described as molecular librations ( @xmath41 ) , and are decoupled from the ct electrons .
coupling is instead possible for the ir active @xmath42 phonons , which indeed correspond to translations ( @xmath43 ) .
there are no symmetry constraint about the direction of molecular displacements , so we may have some component of all the three @xmath42 phonons along the stack axis , contributing to the peierls mode . in the low - temperature ( lt ) phase it is not clear if the two stacks inside the unit cell are inequivalent , with space group @xmath7,@xcite or equivalent , with space group @xmath9.@xcite since in any case the inequivalence is small , for the spectral predictions we find more convenient to use the centro - symmetric description .
the center of inversion is between the two stacks in the unit cell , then we expect 21 optically active modes , @xmath44 and @xmath45 . therefore , the phonons modulating the ct integral are ir active in both ht and lt phases , whereas the cell doubling in the lt phase makes raman active 6 translational phonons , which correspond to the coupled in - phase displacements of the two chains . direct investigation of peierls coupled modes in the far - ir ( 5 - 200 ) is not an easy task.@xcite however , in the case of ttf - ca it has been shown@xcite that useful information can be obtained from the comparison between raman and ir spectra polarized parallel to the stack , in the frequency region of molecular vibrations .
we have then performed the kramers - kronig transformation of the reflectivity data of section [ sec : dimerization ] ( fig .
[ fig : reflpar ] ) , obtaining the optical conductivity spectra which are compared with raman in fig . [ fig : ramanir ] . and
ca @xmath27 bands and the corresponding ir sidebands of fig .
[ fig : ramanir ] as a function of temperature .
bottom panel : temperature evolution of the most intense low - frequency raman bands .
the vertical dashed line marks the critical temperature . ]
we again focus attention on the @xmath28 mode of the ttf skeleton in the dmttf moiety and to the @xmath28 mode of ca , which correspond to the two most prominent raman bands of fig .
[ fig : ramanir ] , located around 1400 and 980 , respectively.@xcite the ir spectra above 80 k exhibit pairs of absorptions ( `` side - bands '' ) , symmetrically located above and below the just mentioned raman bands .
the side - bands are quite naturally interpreted as sum and difference combination bands between the corresponding @xmath22 mode and a lattice phonon.@xcite by lowering temperature the side - bands approach each other , and around 80 k they start to coalesce and to overlap to the central raman band . on the other hand , below the transition temperature ( for instance , 60 k in fig . [
fig : ramanir ] ) there is coincidence between raman and ir bands . as discussed in section [ sec : dimerization ] , both are indeed due to the same @xmath22 molecular vibration , active in both type of spectra due to the symmetry breaking connected to the stack dimerization .
analysis of the side - bands therefore gives information on the peierls mode in the ht phase.@xcite in the top panel of fig .
[ fig : peierls ] the frequency difference between the dmttf @xmath27 raman band and the corresponding ir side - bands is plotted as a function of temperature .
we also plot the frequency semi - difference between the side - bands associated with both dmttf and ca @xmath27 modes .
[ fig : peierls ] shows that the data points coincide within experimental error , supporting the idea that _ the same _ lattice mode is involved in the combination , and clearly indicates a soft mode behaviour .
this softening suggests that this lattice phonon is indeed the peierls mode , or to be precise , the `` effective '' peierls mode , resulting from the superposition of several modes coupled to the ct .
we can not follow the frequency evolution down to the transition temperature , since below 80 - 75 k it becomes impossible to separate the contribution of the two side - bands , letting aside the interference from the fluctuations occurring near the phase transition
. polarization ; dashed line ( @xmath46 ) polarization ( see text ) . ]
we now turn attention to dmttf - ca lt phase , where the peierls mode(s ) are active in raman in addition to ir .
we have then measured the raman spectra in the low - frequency region in order to identify the possible soft phonons .
low - frequency raman also gives indications about the cell doubling , given the difference in the number of phonons present in the two phases .
an example of the low - frequency raman spectra above and below the phase transition is shown fig .
[ fig : rlattice ] .
we report the spectra with two polarizations .
in one , both incident and scattered light are polarized perpendicularly to the stack axis ( @xmath13 spectra ) . in the other ,
the polarization of the incident light is rotated parallel to the stack axis , the polarization of the scattered light being kept perpendicular to it ( @xmath46 spectra ) .
the list of the observed bands in both polarizations is reported in table i. the number of observed phonon modes is less than predicted by the selection rules , but in any case the phonons detected in the ht phase are about a half of those detected at lt , an obvious consequence of cell doubling .
table i. dmttf - ca raman active lattice + modes in the lt and ht phases . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the temperature dependence of the raman frequencies are shown in the bottom panel of fig .
[ fig : peierls ] .
one immediately notice the usual softening for all the modes as we increase the temperature , due to lattice expansion .
however , in the lt phase the softening of some phonons is more pronounced close to the critical temperature .
the frequency lowering is not as large as in the ht phase ( top panel of fig .
[ fig : peierls ] ) , but is certainly present .
the relative weakness of the effect compared to the ht phase can be explained considering that in the ht phase we observe the softening of an `` effective '' peierls mode , superposition of several phonons all coupled to the ct electrons . in the lt phase ,
on the other hand , the softening is distributed on several modes , and the phonon description and mixing changes as we approach the phase transition .
the effect is clearly seen in fig . [
fig : peierls ] , where at about 40 k there is a case of avoided crossing of two phonons located around 70 .
in addition , we have to keep in mind that the dmttf - ca transition is second order , but can not be considered a strictly one - dimensional peierls transition , as the transition implies a change in the number of stacks per unit cell .
the actual phase transition mechanism is a complex one , as shown by the fact that just below @xmath11 there is coexistence of two slightly different degrees of ionicity on the molecular sites ( section [ sec : valence ] ) .
this finding might be explained in terms of an inequivalence of the two stacks inside the unit cell in proximity of @xmath11 .
the present work does not allow us to draw definitive conclusions about the equivalence / inequivalence of the two dmttf - ca stacks inside the unit cell of the lt phase ( anti - ferroelectric or ferrielectric arrangement ) . as just discussed , the presence of two slightly different degrees of ionicity may imply that just after the phase transition we have a temperature interval ( @xmath47 k ) in which the two stacks are inequivalent with the @xmath7 structure,@xcite , followed by a definitive structural rearrangement yielding to the 14 k @xmath9 structure.@xcite this picture would support the @xmath7 structural determination,@xcite collected at 40 k below our coexistence @xmath10 region , only assuming that the @xmath7 structure refers to a non - equilibrium phase .
such `` frozening '' of a metastable phase may be a consequence of a too fast sample cooling , a case not uncommon in organic solid state , although most of the times refers to some disordered , glassy phase.@xcite at this point we wish to underline that inequivalence of the stacks does not necessarily imply an appreciably different degree of ionicity .
dft calculations made for the @xmath7 structure at 40 k indeed found practically identical @xmath2 for the two stacks with different dimerization amplitudes.@xcite we may then have a scenario with two ( slightly ) inequivalent stacks , but practically identical @xmath2 .
ir spectra polarized parallel to the stack ( fig .
[ fig : reflpar ] ) of course can not disentangle dimerization amplitudes on different stacks .
optical spectroscopy selection rules , on the other hand , are based on the factor group ( unit cell group ) , therefore reflecting the translational long - range order of the crystal.@xcite from this perspective , two findings are in favor of inequivalent stacks , down to at least 20 k. the first fact refers to the raman - ir coincidence observed for the @xmath22 molecular modes in the lt phase ( fig .
[ fig : ramanir ] ) . if the two stacks are equivalent , and connected by an inversion center , each @xmath22 mode of one stack would be coupled in - phase and out - of - phase with the same mode on the other stack .
the in - phase mode is raman active , and the out - of - phase one ir active , therefore we should not observe precise frequency coincidence , the difference being related to the strength of inter - stack interaction .
unfortunately , our data are not conclusive in this respect , due to the frequency uncertainties associated with the kramers - kronig transformation.@xcite the other experimental observation that can be explained in terms of inequivalent stacks is the doubling of localized electronic transitions below 65 k.@xcite this experimental observation was the first one that induced aoki _ _ et al.__@xcite to suggest the coexistence of neutral and ionic species , but since then it has been almost forgotten .
et al._,@xcite as well as the present measurements , exclude such coexistence , and the only explanation we can think of the doubling is in term of ordinary davydov splitting.@xcite however , the two components of the davydov splitting can be both optically active only in the lack of inversion center relating the two stacks , otherwise the _ gerade _ component is inactive .
only the replica of structural measurements and/or of the refinement process starting from the two different hypothesis will definitely settle the question of equivalence - inequivalence of dmttf - ca stacks .
on the other hand , this question is not particularly relevant as far as the mechanism of dmttf - ca phase transition is concerned .
the present analysis departs from the previous ones@xcite only in some seemingly marginal details , but actually the resulting picture of the phase transition is completely different .
first of all , we have ascertained that the phase transition implies only a limited change of @xmath2 , dmttf - ca remaining on the _ neutral _ side down to the lowest temperature .
furthermore , the major charge rearrangement _ follows _
, by a few degrees k , the onset of cell doubling and stack dimerization .
the latter finding can be well appreciated from fig .
[ fig : ionint ] , where the inflection of the @xmath8 curve occurs around 61 k , rather than at 65 k for the symmetry breaking . close scrutiny of fig .
5 of ref . conveys the same information .
therefore the transition can hardly be termed n - i , since cell doubling and stack dimerization clearly constitute the driving force of the transition .
indeed , we can envision a scenario in which the dimerization and cell doubling lead to a better molecular packing , with an increase in the madelung energy and consequent small , continuous change in @xmath2 .
the presence of slightly differently charged molecular species before the dimerization / cell doubling has reached completion ( fig .
[ fig : ionint ] ) fits quite naturally into this picture .
disentangling the contribution of the cell doubling from that of the stack dimerization is a useless endeavor . in any case , our measurements have clearly evidenced the presence of an effective soft mode along the chain ( fig . [
fig : peierls ] , top panel ) , so a peierls - like mechanism is certainly at work in the precursor regime of the phase transition .
x - ray diffuse scattering also reveals the importance of electron - phonon coupling along the chain , and of one - dimensional correlations .
it has been interpreted in terms of lattice relaxed exciton strings ( lr - ct ) rather than in terms of a soft mode .
the phase transition is then regarded more as a disorder - order transition ( ordering of lr - ct exciton strings along and across the chains ) , and not as a displacive one , with progressive uniform softening of the peierls mode up to the final chain dimerization .
it would be interesting to re - analyze the x - ray diffuse scattering data to examine whether and to what extent they are compatible with the soft - mode picture .
the present results of course only evidence the soft - mode mechanism , and the presence of lr - ct exciton strings can not be excluded , in particular close to @xmath11 , in the region where our data can not be unambiguously interpreted .
the lr - ct exciton string picture has been invoked mainly to account for the dielectric constant anomaly at @xmath11 , attributed to the progressive ordering of the a para - electric phase before reaching anti - ferroelectric ( or ferrielectric ) ordering.@xcite on the other hand , it has been shown that the peierls mechanism is also able to _ quantitatively _ explain the experimental increase of the dielectric constant at @xmath11 , interpreted as due to charge oscillations induced by the peierls mode.@xcite we underline in this respect that although the dimerization of the stack in the i phase has been often attributed to a spin - peierls mechanism,@xcite the electronic degrees of freedom are involved as well , particularly in proximity of the n - i borderline.@xcite in addition , the dimerization transition may occur also on the n side , provided the electron - phonon interaction is strong enough .
this is just the present case , and correspondingly we have an increase of the dielectric constant less important than in the case of ttf - ca,@xcite as predicted by the calculations.@xcite in summary , the present interpretation stresses the importance of the lattice instability over that of charge instability in dmttf - ca and related compounds .
we gratefully thank n. karl for providing the dmttf - ca crystals .
the reflectivity data have been fitted by the freely available reffit program ( optics.unige.ch/alexey/reffitt.html ) .
we thank a. painelli for many useful discussions . work in italy supported by the `` ministero dell universit e ricerca '' ( mur ) , through firb - rbne01p4jf and prin2004033197_002 .
torrance , j.e .
vasquez , j.j .
mayerle , v.y .
lee , phys .
lett . * 46*,253 ( 1981 ) ; j.b .
torrance , a. girlando , j.j .
mayerle , j.i .
crowley , v.y .
lee , p. batail , s.j .
lapaca , phys .
lett . * 47 * , 1747 ( 1981 ) . | we report a detailed spectroscopic investigation of temperature - induced valence and structural instability of the mixed - stack organic charge - transfer ( ct ) crystal 4,4-dimethyltetrathiafulvalene - chloranil ( dmttf - ca ) .
dmttf - ca is a derivative of tetrathiafulvalene - chloranil ( ttf - ca ) , the first ct crystal exhibiting the neutral - ionic transition by lowering temperature .
we confirm that dmttf - ca undergoes a continuous variation of the ionicity on going from room temperature down to @xmath0 20 k , but remains on the neutral side throughout .
the stack dimerization and cell doubling , occurring at 65 k , appear to be the driving forces of the transition and of the valence instability . in a small temperature interval just below the phase transition we detect the coexistence of molecular species with slightly different ionicities .
the peierls mode(s ) precursors of the stack dimerization are identified . |
the late - time tails of black holes have been studied in much detail since price s seminal work @xcite .
the formulation of the problem is a straightforward one : place an observer in a circular orbit around a black hole , and have her measure at late times a generic perturbation field , that had compact support at some initial time .
it is generally accepted that the observer measures the late - time perturbation field to drop off as an inverse power law of time , specifically as @xmath3 .
it is the value of @xmath5 that has been controversial in the literature , with some conflicting results reported . in the case of a schwarzschild black hole , @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the multipole moment of the initial perturbation field .
namely , if the initial ( compactly supported ) perturbation field has the angular dependence of @xmath8 , the angular dependence remains unchanged ( spherical harmonics are eigenvectors of the laplacian operator " ) , and the decay rate of the field is governed by the @xmath7 value of the initial perturbation .
these results remain unchanged also for a reissner nordstrm black hole @xcite ( including the extremal case @xcite ) , that like the schwarzschild black hole is spherically symmetric .
notably , a generic perturbation is a linear superposition of @xmath7-modes , so that the tail is dominated by the slowest damped mode , or by the lowest value of @xmath7 . for rotating black holes conflicting values of @xmath5
have been reported .
obviously , the observer measures a well defined decay rate .
of the various conflicting values in the literature some are wrong ( i.e. , they report a value inconsistent with the outcome of the initial value problem ) , while other results are correct ( in the same sense , of reporting the right value for the initial value problem ) .
as it turns out , different initial value formulations may lead to different decay rate for the tails . while none of these is more correct " _ sensu stricto _ than others , it is important to understand the relationship of different initial value sets , so that the understanding may lead to some insights .
one of the correct answers to the question of the value of @xmath5 was described , e.g. , in @xcite : the late - time field decays according to the same rule as in the spherically - symmetric case , namely according to @xmath1 , where @xmath9 if @xmath10 is even , and @xmath11 if @xmath10 is odd , independently of the initial value of @xmath7 .
below , we dub this tail as
tail a. " the reason for this decay rate is that spherical harmonic modes do not evolve independently on the background of a rotating black hole ( spherical harmonics are _ not _ eigenvectors of the laplacian operator " ) . starting with an initial value for @xmath7 ,
infinitely many other @xmath7 modes are excited , respecting only the dynamical constraints ( @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is the spin of the field , and @xmath14 ) and the equatorial symmetry of the initial data ( such that even and odd modes do not mix ) .
another correct answer to the question was discussed recently in @xcite and in @xcite . according to this result ,
@xmath15 if @xmath16 , @xmath17 if @xmath18 is even , and @xmath19 if @xmath18 is odd
. this result is dubbed below as tail b. " evidently , this result is inconsistent with that of tail a. the tail b behavior was first predicted in @xcite . while either the tail a or the tail b behavior is a solution to _ some
_ initial value problem , these problems are different enough to lead to markedly different late time evolutions .
in this paper we present some explanation for these different results , that resolves the apparent discrepancy at least for some cases .
this paper s motivation is to explain some of the historical discrepancies , in what we believe is an illuminating manner .
specifically , finding the reasons for the controversy in the literature teaches us important lessons .
in particular , we consider two results , conflicting both with each other and with the results of this paper : the numerical results of @xcite , and the analytical model of @xcite .
more precisely , we consider the simplest case for which there is a disagreement in the literature , specifically the case of a massless scalar field ( @xmath20 ) perturbation of a kerr black hole , with initial @xmath21 and @xmath22 . for this case , the late time tail drops as @xmath23 according to tail a , because the monopole @xmath24 ) mode of the scalar field can and is excited , and this mode s drop off rate obeys the @xmath25 rule . according to tail b , the late time decay rate is @xmath26 .
the ( numerical ) results of @xcite suggest a drop off rate of @xmath27 that does not appear to converge to the decay rate of tail b. the poisson analytical model ( of a globally weakly curved spacetime ) predicts a drop off rate of @xmath26 if carried over to the kerr case @xcite , which may suggest a tail b behavior
. however , as we show below , the correct behavior of such tails should be that of tail a. we discuss in detail the tails developing from initial data specified on ingoing kerr silces of @xcite .
it was suggested in @xcite that the tail a results of @xcite are due to the slicing condition .
we show that this is not the case .
in fact , one can find initial condition sets with the same slicing condition as in @xcite ( slicing corresponding to the ingoing kerr coordinates ) that result in either tail a or tail b decay rates , in just the same way as with boyer
lindquist slicing .
in fact , although the boyer lindquist and ingoing kerr time slices do not coincide , we find that similar initial data lead to the same tail behavior in either .
we therefore suggest that different slicing conditions may fall into equivalency classes , and boyer lindquist and ingoing kerr slices belong to the same class .
we propose that this is the case because of the properties of the transformation from boyer lindquist and ingoing kerr coordinates . in the case of @xcite
, we attribute the ( numerically stable ! )
result of a drop off rate of @xmath27 to an intermediate tail being misidentified as an asymptotic tail .
as we show , the traditional representation of the tail in a log log plot of the field as a function of time is susceptible to lead to an optical illusion , " that may support this misidentification .
specifically , taking initial conditions that lead to a tail a decay rate , we show what may be interpreted as a tail falling off as @xmath27 , similar to what is found in @xcite , except that if the integration is carried on further in time the intermediate behavior is taken over by the true asymptotic behavior , or a tail falling off as @xmath23 .
a similar effect can also be found for the tail b case .
the reason @xcite mistook an intermediate tail for an asymptotic one is that @xcite chose parameters that make it harder to distinguish the two using the crude tools used in @xcite .
specifically , we show that the farther out the initial pulse , the longer the intermediate tail .
reference @xcite chose the initial pulse very far out , which resulted in a protracted intermediate tail . while this choice made the problem severe enough , it was even further exacerbated by making the initial pulse outgoing and by taking the kerr parameter @xmath28 .
either choice makes the beginning of the tail regime postponed . as the integration time in @xcite is rather short ,
we conclude that the tail analyzed in @xcite is an intermediate one , and that if the integration time were longer , @xcite too would have found a @xmath23 tail ( for tail a initial data ) or a @xmath26 tail ( for tail b initial data ) .
( in view of our argument below , we comment that the code of @xcite was fourth order angularly , which we find to be satisfactory for the relatively short runs done by @xcite . )
how can one then avoid misinterpreting intermediate tails as asymptotic ones ?
we provide a criterion , that we believe can be used for the identification of the asymptotic tail . by our criterion ,
a tail is asymptotic if the local power index @xcite is linear in @xmath29 both locally and globally , in a sense that we make precise . in the case of @xcite
, we explicitly follow the proposal of poisson , and evolve initial data that are a pure spherical harmonic mode with respect to spherical " coordinates , not the boyer lindquist coordinates , that are spheroidal " in the language of @xcite . according to @xcite
, such initial data should lead to a tail b behavior when applied to a kerr background .
we show that this is not the case , and tail a behavior is found .
specifically , starting with @xmath21 and @xmath22 , poisson predicts the asymptotic tail to drop off as @xmath26 . in @xcite , such time evolution
is demonstrated in a globally weak curvature spacetime ( that has no symmetries ) , and it is conjectured that such behavior is carried over to the case of a kerr black hole .
we show that this conjecture is not realized : instead , the evolution is according to tail a , and the drop off rate is according to @xmath23 .
very recently , gleiser , price , and pullin ( henceforth gpp ) have proposed a theoretical model that expands the wave equation in ( even ) powers of the black hole s spin rate @xmath30 @xcite .
the advantage of the gpp approach is that the zeroth order wave operator is identical to the spherically symmetric operator , so that it can be solved numerically using a simple 1 + 1d code .
each iteration in the gpp approach gives the field to the next order in @xmath31 , using the field of the previous iteration as the source term of a spherically symmetric wave operator .
gpp argue that their approach is superior to the 2 + 1d approach , because it frees the numerics from the subtleties of the 2 + 1d simulations , and because the 1 + 1d numerics are inherently more reliable .
we agree with these claims .
the gpp argument implies that delicate cancellations exactly cancel not only the leading tail term ( in an expansion in @xmath29 ) , but also the leading subdominant mode @xcite ( for an initial @xmath21 ; for other initial choices more subdominant modes may need to be cancelled ) .
gpp further argue that turning off the coupling term at very late times destroys the exact cancellation , so that the tail returns to the naive " decay rate .
it is quite remarkable that even if this is done at extremely late times , so that the hexadecapole field is much smaller than the monopole field , it still does not lose its ability to exactly cancel out its two leading terms ( in @xmath29 ) .
notably , gpp imply that different slicing conditions may be responsible for the apparently conflicting results of numerical simulations .
indeed , in @xcite the slicing condition was that associated with ingoing kerr coordinates , in @xcite the slicing was that of the kerr
schild coordinates , and in @xcite boyer
linquist slicing was used .
gpp argue that the translation of an initially pure @xmath21 mode , say , in some other slicing condition ( e.g. , ingoing kerr or kerr schild ) into boyer
lindquist slicing results in a mixed state of modes for the boyer
lindquist slicing , and the existing lower @xmath7 ( specifically , the quadrupole and monopole ) modes on the initial time slice are the ones responsible for the tail structure . according to gpp , among all slicing conditions the boyer
lindquist one is special , as only in this slicing an initial pure @xmath21 mode leads to a tail of @xmath26 , and in all other slicing conditions an initially pure @xmath21 mode leads to a @xmath23 tail .
we disagree with this viewpoint , as we find that also for ingoing kerr slicing the tail decays like @xmath26 .
more recently , tiglio , kidder , and teukolsky ( tkt ) @xcite performed careful 2 + 1d simulations of the axisymmetric kerr tail problem using a pseudospectral code .
the pseudospectral approach has an advantage over the finite differencing approach , in that the convergence is exponential in the former , and only a power law in the latter .
consequently , in the pseudospectral approach the noise evolution problem that permeates finite differencing computations is nearly nonexistent .
tkt studied two slicing cases : kerr schild slicing and boyer
lindquist slicing .
tkk found the tail a behavior in the former ( consistently with the conclusions of @xcite that were obtained in 3 + 1d ) and the tail b behavior in the latter ( consistently with gpp ) .
tkt correctly point out the main reason for the difference between tail a and tail b behaviors that are found in boyer
lindquist initial data and on boyer
lindquist slicing , specifically that the zero field momentum " of the former is in fact a mixed state of pure multipole modes .
we consider this question in great detail , and show that the momentum condition is a very special combination of states , as described below .
we discuss in detail the noise evolution problem that may cause a tail b masquerade as a tail a. that is , numerical noise evolves on the grid the same way that the physical signal does , so that the tail a behavior of the noise evolution overwhelms the tail b behavior of the physical field .
we then show that with care this phenomenon can be easily identified .
we next discuss how initial data with the same slicing condition could lead to either tail a or tail b behavior . as shown first by gpp and then by tkt , initial data that are a pure multipole of the angular boyer
lindquist coordinates in boyer
lindquist slicing lead to tail b behavior .
when one sets the initial conditions by requiring that the field s momentum " @xmath32 ( see below for definitions ) vanishes , the tail s behavior is that of tail a. indeed , the condition on the momentum implies that the field s multipole structure is changed , as the field
s velocity now is proportional to the field multiplied by a function of the angular coordinate @xmath33 . restricting attention to low black hole spin values ( @xmath34 ) ,
this function is proportional to @xmath35 .
therefore , one would expect that in addition to an initial hexadecupole at @xmath36 one would have now also all other ( even ) multipoles at @xmath37 .
an existing monopole on the initial slice at @xmath37 would then lead to a tail that has the same decay rate as a pure multipole that behaves like tail a , which is at @xmath37 .
however , we show that the tail is at @xmath38 , not @xmath37 .
the explanation is that the leading contribution ( in @xmath31 ) does not contribute to the monopole , so that on the initial slice the monopole is at @xmath38 , not at @xmath37 .
evolution of this mode then can dominate at late times , showing a tail that is both at @xmath38 and has the tail a behavior . nevertheless , this is not the only contribution to this tail .
the initial data contains also a quadrupole at @xmath37 , which also evolves a @xmath38 monopole because of the mode excitation effect .
however , as in this case the quadrupole has an @xmath7 value that differs from the monopole s by only @xmath39 , the behavior is again consistent with that of tail a. therefore , the tail a behavior has three sources : a pre - existing monopole at @xmath38 , a pre - existing quadrupole at @xmath37 , and a pre - existing hexadecapole at @xmath36 , all three behaving consistently with tail a. we further extend the numerical study to non - axisymmetric modes , and find that the tail a and tail b behaviors occur for such modes consistently with their behavior in the axisymmetric case , i.e. , they obey the aforementioned decay rate rules .
we then extend the argument for tail b behavior to subdominant modes .
specifically , we argue that starting with an initial mode @xmath7 , the decay rate of an ( allowed ) excited mode @xmath40 is given by @xmath41 if @xmath42 , and @xmath43 otherwise .
this rule includes that of @xcite as a particular case , when @xmath44 . in particular , we consider the axisymmetric case of @xmath45 and @xmath46 ( which is a subdominant mode , as also the monopole is excited ) . the quadrupole mode
@xmath46 then indeed decays with @xmath47 as predicted by our proposal .
we are hopeful that this paper may put some order in a confused state of affairs , in which the literature includes side by side correct results and incorrect ones , without a proper explanation of the incorrect ones , and also apparently conflicting correct results without a proper explanation of the sources for the apparent conflict .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in section [ reliability ]
we discuss the reliability of the 2 + 1d approach in calculating tails , and how carelessness can result in an incorrect value for the field . in section [ a2 ]
we discuss the decomposition of the monopole projection of the tail in powers of @xmath31 , and in section [ optical_illusion ] we discuss one possible pitfall that can cause a correct field be misinterpreted . in section [ s_ingoing_kerr ]
we study tails in ingoing kerr coordinates , and in section [ poisson_data ] we analyze a pure mode in spherical " coordinates @xcite , and show that it leads to the same tail decay rate as in spheroidal " coordinates .
the solution of the teukolsky equation in 2 + 1d is delicate and sensitive , and can lead to qualitatively wrong results if proper care is not taken . in section [ optical_illusion ] below we show that even when the numerically computed field is the correct one , careless interpretations may lead to incorrect conclusions . in this section
we first demonstrate how carelessness may lead to qualitatively wrong behavior of the solution , and then we demonstrate the reliability of the approach when proper care is taken . the standard of scientific computation in the finite difference approach has been second order algorithms for many years .
indeed , second order convergence typically implies the solution is both consistent and stable to a practical level , so that the solution is accurate enough without having to reduce the typical grid spacing to extremely low levels that would make the code too costly computationally .
normal application of the dahlquist theory ( extended to pdes ) then means that if the discrete formula approximating the differential equation has locally a positive order of accuracy ( convergence ) , and that if numerical errors do not grow unboundedly ( stability ) , then the solution is convergent , in the sense that as the grid spacing goes to zero , the solution would approach the correct one .
as we show below , the tail problem involves the dahlquist theory with a twist .
early codes to calculate the late time kerr tail were therefore designed to be second order in all coordinates , i.e. , temporally , radially , and with respect to the angular coordinate @xmath33 @xcite .
( in the 2 + 1d approach the field is decomposed into @xmath48 modes , so that one does not have numerical derivatives with respect to @xmath48 . )
while this approach seems very natural , it can mislead into qualitatively wrong solutions .
consider first a schwarzschild black hole , excited by an azimuthally symmetric ( @xmath22 ) field with @xmath21 .
the decay rate of the price tail is incontrovertible in this case : as the background is spherically symmetric , spherical harmonic modes evolve independently , and the decay rate is therefore @xmath49 .
indeed , 1 + 1d codes readily verify this result . ) for three different angular resolutions ( @xmath50 ( solid ) , @xmath51 ( dashed ) , and @xmath52 ( dotted ) ) as a function of time .
the lower panel on the right is the convergence order as a function of the time at @xmath53 .
the initial data are for a schwarzschild black hole ( @xmath54 ) , and are a gaussian centered at @xmath55 with width @xmath56 .
the radial resolution is @xmath57 , and the temporal resolution is chosen to be @xmath58 , which satisfies the courant condition .
the initial data are a pure multipole with @xmath21.,width=326 ] the numerical solution with a second - order 2 + 1d numerical code may lead however to the erroneous conclusion that the decay rate is @xmath23 : in fig .
[ 2nd_1 ] we show the late time field as a function of time for three choices of the angular grid spacing , and for fixed radial and temporal grid spacings . as can be readily inferred from the upper panel in fig .
[ 2nd_1 ] , the decay rate is @xmath23 , which is definitely wrong .
the origin of this wrong result is indicated in the same figure : the field values themselves reduce considerably in amplitude under refinement of the grid ( almost as the second power of the ratio of the grid parameters ) .
the signal seen is therefore not the physical field , but an evolved numerical noise ( leakage of multipoles " ) .
our interpretation is that while the physical signal indeed drops like @xmath49 , it is swamped by the evolved numerical noise , which has a monopole component .
the latter drops like @xmath23 , so that any very long time evolution must be dominated by numerical noise .
refinement of the grid parameter can postpone the numerical - noise dominated regime , but can not utterly eliminate it : refinement of the grid parameter reduces the level of the numerical noise , so that if the grid is fine enough , the noise level at a particular value of the time reduces to below the level of the physical field .
however , as the former drops more slowly than the latter , at very late times the field is dominated by numerical noise ( see fig .
[ 6th_1 ] below ) . here enters the twist on the dahlquist theory : the numerical noise does not grow unboundedly .
in fact , it even drops quadratically with the grid spacing , and drops with time .
it does so , notwithstanding , slower than the physical signal , so that the signal may be dominated by numerical noise even though the regular dahlquist criteria are apparently satisfied . while a second order code may in principle be sufficient to see physical tails ( for very fine grids ) , an alternative approach is to increase the order of the angular differentiation .
we first show how the same initial data and grid resolutions lead to qualitatively different results in schwarzschild , and then we discuss kerr .
figure [ 6th_1 ] shows the sixth order convergence of the field , for the same parameters that were shown in fig .
[ 2nd_1 ] with the second order code .
the field is not made of evolved noise ( leakage of multipoles " ) , as it clearly converges to a non - zero value under grid refinement .
notably , the field s amplitude even _ increases _ slightly under grid refinement .
the hallmark of noise signals is that their amplitude _ decreases _ under grid refinement , as is indeed evident in fig .
[ 2nd_1 ] .
most importantly , the price tail drops as @xmath49 , as it should .
we emphasize that these conclusions are true up to some maximal time value . for longer times the residual monopole noise , that drops slower than the physical field , will inevitably dominate .
simple extrapolations reveal that the signal noise will dominate over the physical signal for @xmath59 for our choice of angular resolution .
longer evolutions than that will be dominated by noise evolution . as noted above , it is not difficult to separate the physical signal regime from the noise signal regime by doing global convergence tests .
it is therefore crucial _ for any tail simulation _ that convergence tests are done throughout the entire computational domain , and not limited just to short integration times ( despite the temptation to save computer time e.g. , see @xcite ) . for the sixth order code .
the upper panel shows the @xmath60 norm for the full field ( integrated over a sphere at @xmath55 ) in three resolutions .
the three curves are nearly indistinguishable on this plot s scale .
the upper plot also shows the monopole projection of the field , which is pure evolved numerical noise for resolution of @xmath61 .
this figure also shows the tails local power index as a function of time ( lower left ) and the convergence order of the three resolution shown on the upper panel ( lower right).,width=326 ] in fig .
[ 6th_2 ] we demonstrate the sixth order angular convergence of kerr evolutions .
this figure summarizes the main parts for our claim that our tail results are reliable : the code is convergent to a non - zero value , and even increases in magnitude with grid refinement ( so that the signal seen is not an evolved noise signal ) , and the convergence order is global , throughout the computational domain .
notice that in fig .
[ 6th_2 ] we study the convergence with the monopole projection of the total field .
this projection is more sensitive to the created and evolved monopole numerical noise than the full field , say , as we can test its convergence also at times earlier than the instant the monopole dominates the total field for the first time .
figure [ 6th_3 ] depicts the ( @xmath60 norm of the ) full field and its monopole projection .
the parameters are chosen so that intermediate tails are minimized , so that computation time is used efficiently .
the monopole projection amplitude is many order of magnitudes higher than typical multipole leakage " noise levels ( cf . with fig .
[ 6th_1 ] ) .
indeed , it is the result of physical multipole excitations , not noise generation .
below , we also bring evidence that the observed tail is indeed asymptotic , so that we are not misled by an intermediate tail masquerading as an asymptotic one . for the monopole projection of the full field using the sixth order code for kerr .
the angular resolutions are @xmath62 ( solid ) , @xmath63 ( dashed ) , and @xmath64 ( dotted ) . the initial data are an outgoing gaussian pulse located at @xmath55 with width of @xmath56 with compact support on the boyer lindquist @xmath65 hypersurface of a kerr black hole with @xmath66 .
the initial multipole is a pure boyer
lindquist @xmath21 .
the radial resolution is @xmath67 , and the temporal resolution is chosen so that @xmath58.,width=326 ] . shown are the @xmath60 norm of the full field ( solid curve ) and the field s monopole projection ( dashed curve ) . for both ,
the angular resolution is @xmath50 and the radial resolution is @xmath57 .
the temporal resolution is chosen so that @xmath58 .
, width=326 ]
gpp argue that when expanded in powers of @xmath31 , the tail would be at @xmath38 .
when a mode @xmath68 exists at any iteration order ( in @xmath31 ) , at the next iteration three modes will result : @xmath69 ( if @xmath70 ) , @xmath68 , and @xmath71 . the mode excitation scheme is shown in fig .
[ 6th_2_1 ] . in the gpp approach , this behavior comes about because of the term @xmath72 appearing in the source term ( see @xcite for detail ) . this way ,
starting with a pure @xmath21 mode , there is just one way to create a monopole field at @xmath38 , but three ways to create a monopole field at @xmath73 .
we study two classes of initial data sets : in class a the field @xmath74 is a pure multipole ( in practice , we focus attention here mostly on the azimuthal @xmath21 mode ) and the field s momentum " @xmath75 , where @xmath76 . here , @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 ( for details see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
the @xmath80 coordinates are the boyer
lindquist ones .
class a initial data lead to tail a behavior ( i.e. , to @xmath81 ) , with the tail at @xmath38 . in class b initial data we choose the field @xmath74 in the same way as in class a , but replace the condition @xmath75 with @xmath82 or @xmath83 or a linear combination thereof ( with coefficients that are independent of @xmath84 ) .
class b initial data lead to tail b behavior ( i.e. , to @xmath85 ) , with the tail at @xmath38 .
( the momentary stationary data case @xmath83 is unique , and leads to @xmath86 in a similar way to the schwarzschild case @xcite . )
the different sets of initial data are summarized in table [ table2 ] .
.the initial data classes used in the text .
unaccented coordinates mean any of the coordinate systems described in table [ table1 ] .
see the text for more detail . [
cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ table1 ] a spherical harmonic mode in boyer
lindquist coordinates with a specific multipole @xmath7 and a specific azimuthal mode @xmath87 is therefore also a spherical harmonic mode in ingoing kerr coordinates with the same values for @xmath88 , and the difference is only in a different function of the radial coordinate .
one may therefore expect that initial data specified in ingoing kerr coordinates would lead to the same tail behavior as in boyer lindquist coordinates .
one may object to this expectation by stating that the constant @xmath89 slices in the boyer
lindquist case are not the same as the constant @xmath90 slices in the ingoing kerr case .
while this difference is certainly existing and the two hypersurfaces are not the same , we find that it does not change the tail behavior . )
mode in ingoing kerr coordinates on a @xmath91 slice . here , @xmath92 .
the initial data radial profile is a gaussian with @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
the grid resolution is @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
the dashed curve is the carve @xmath97 which is added for reference .
the local power index is calculated for three radial resolutions : @xmath98 ( dotted ) , @xmath99 ( dashed ) , and @xmath96 ( solid).,width=326 ] class a initial data were studied in detail in @xcite .
we therefore present here the results for class b initial data .
we find that starting with a pure @xmath21 azimuthal mode ( in ingoing kerr coordinates on a @xmath91 slice ) the tail has tail b behavior , similar to that of boyer lindquist coordinates and boyer
lindquist slicing .
figure [ ingoing_kerr ] shows the field and the local power index for these data .
we infer from the simulation data that the tail index is @xmath100 , a deviation of @xmath101 from the tail b prediction of 5 .
the ingoing kerr results are obtained using a code based on the penetrating teukolsky code ( ptc ) @xcite .
the ptc is written on a fixed ingoing kerr coordinate grid , which means that grid resolution becomes increasingly poor approaching the event horizon .
while simple fixed mesh refinement methods can resolve this difficulty , we were able to obtain the tail index using the following method : we first find the local power index for a number of time values for different choices of the radial ( and temporal ) resolution .
we then extrapolate the local power indices to infinite radial resolution , and then extrapolate the sequence of local power indices at different values of the time ( and with infinite resolutions ) to infinitely late times .
the result is rather close to the expected value of 5 , but suffers from somewhat higher numerical error because of the two extrapolation cycles .
as noted above , the deviation of the tail index from the tail b value is at the order of @xmath102 .
we therefore conclude that class b initial data in the ingoing kerr case lead to tail b behavior .
we therefore contend that initial time slices , even when are distinct , fall into equivalency classes in terms of the type of tail behavior that emerges ( recall that on a given slice multipoles can also mix because of coordinate transformations ) . the boyer
lindquist and ingoing kerr slices belong to the same equivalency class , in the sense that one finds the same tail b behavior for class b initial data .
schild slices belong to a distinct equivalency class , and class b initial data lead to tail a behavior .
we conjecture that the boyer lindquist and ingoing kerr slices belong to the same equivalency class because the time slices in either are related by a transformation that does not involve the polar angular coordinate and that depends only on the temporal and azimuthal angular coordinate .
one may therefore conjecture that other slicing conditions that differ from the boyer
lindquist slicing condition by similar transformations will behave accordingly .
poisson has made the argument that if class b initial data are specified in so - called spherical coordinates , " rather than in boyer
lindquist coordinates , which poisson calls spheroidal , " mode evolution is changed @xcite . in particular
, poisson proposes that in kerr spacetime such initial data lead to tail b behavior . in a spacetime with global weak curvature ( no black hole , but no assumptions on symmetry ) , poisson data indeed lead to such late time behavior
this may be surprising , as a pure mode of poisson coordinates may be written as a mixed state of boyer lindquist modes .
this mixed state of modes effectively behaves as class a initial data , so that the intuitively expected behavior is that of tail a. clearly , the assumption of globally weak curvature affects the tails , and shifts them from their tail a values to those reported by poisson
. this could be the case if the field reflects off the regular center in the poisson spacetime , so that the leading order part of the field ( in @xmath29 ) is cancelled out and one is left with the next order in @xmath29 , or if the monopole part of the field is canceled after the reflection , leaving only the dipole and higher moments present @xcite .
the following question arises : what are the tail indices for pure poisson " class b data in a kerr spacetime ? specifically , if one sets at @xmath65 a pure class b hexadecapole mode with respect to the poisson
spherical " coordinates , does the late time tail decay as @xmath103 , as appropriate for tail a , or as @xmath104 as appropriate for tail b ( and as predicted by @xcite ) ? as we are showing here , the answer is clearly @xmath103 .
mode , @xmath105 ( solid curve ) , and its projections on boyer
lindquist @xmath7 modes @xmath106 : dashed ( @xmath107 ) , dash - dotted ( @xmath46 ) , and dotted ( @xmath108 ) . here , @xmath66 .
the initial data radial profile is a gaussian with @xmath109 and @xmath110 .
the abscissa is @xmath111 or @xmath112 as is appropriate.,width=326 ] initial data that describe a
pure poisson " mode are a linear combination of boyer lindquist modes , as one may expand such a mode in the function space of boyer lindquist spherical harmonics .
importantly , as the transformation from boyer
lindquist to poisson coordinates does not involve the time , boyer
lindquist slices are identical to poisson slices .
therefore , one may use a code in which the wave equation is written in boyer
lindquist coordinates to simulate the evolution of a
pure poisson " mode , if one writes the initial data as the appropriate linear combination of boyer
lindquist modes .
this may be done as follows : denote the boyer
lindquist coordinates as @xmath80 and the poisson
spherical " coordinates as @xmath113 .
as shown in @xcite , the coordinate transformation is @xmath114 where @xmath115 is a measure of the ellipticity " of the boyer
lindquist coordinates , which in practice equals the kerr black hole s
spin @xmath30 . to specify a pure poisson
" mode , we take the field to be @xmath116 after choosing the radial function to be a gaussian of width @xmath117 centered on @xmath118 . the initial
pure poisson " field @xmath119 can be expanded in the function space of boyer
lindquist legendre polynomials as @xmath120 as shown in @xcite , the functions @xmath121 are complicated .
( in fact , only the coefficients for the _ inverse _ transformation are found in @xcite ( for @xmath21 and @xmath108 ) as a power series in the ellipticity " @xmath115 . ) in fig .
[ pd1 ] we show the functions @xmath105 , and @xmath106 for @xmath122 ( in general , these functions are non - vanishing for all values of @xmath40 , respecting the parity symmetry ) , for a high value for the ellipticity , " specifically for @xmath123 . to complete the initial data problem
, we also need to specify at @xmath65 the time derivative of the field . for class b initial data we choose @xmath124 , and for class a initial data we choose @xmath75 .
figure [ poisson_classb ] depicts the full field and its multipole projections and the local power indices for the full field and its monopole projection as functions of time for class b initial data .
the late time behavior is clearly that of tail a , with the monopole s decay rate at infinite time extrapolated to @xmath125 , within @xmath126 from the predicted value of @xmath127 . mode , and its boyer
lindquist @xmath122 modes , and the local power indices for the full field and for the boyer
lindquist monopole projection . here , @xmath66 .
the ( class b ) initial data are those of fig .
[ pd1].,width=326 ] in fig .
[ pd2 ] we consider class a initial data .
again , it suggests that the tail field drops of as @xmath103 for a scalar field with initial data that are a pure poisson " hexadecapole mode .
specifically , we show this to be the case more precisely , using the criterion based on simultaneous local and global behavior of the local power index .
comparison of the evolution of the evolution of the pure poisson " @xmath21 mode with the evolution of its boyer
lindquist @xmath107 projection suggests that the monopole projection @xmath108 at the initial time is important at late times .
the @xmath108 mode is being excited during the evolution also when it is not present at the initial time , and eventually it dominates the field at late times .
however , the generated @xmath108 mode starts dominating the total field only at a later time , as its amplitude is lower than that of the monopole part of the full @xmath21 mode .
the latter mode includes a monopole component already at the initial time , and this part of the field starts dominating the total field at an earlier time than the monopole component that is excited .
for this reason the asymptotic @xmath21 mode is much stronger than the asymptotic tail of initial data that include only the @xmath107 projection of the @xmath21 mode , even though at the initial time they are almost identical , as can be seen in fig .
[ pd1 ] .
mode ( panel a ) , and its boyer
lindquist @xmath122 modes ( panels b , c , and d , respectively ) ( solid curves ) , and the evolution of the boyer
lindquist @xmath107 projection of the pure poisson " mode and its boyer
lindquist projections ( dashed curves ) . here , @xmath66 .
the initial data are those of fig .
[ pd1].,width=326 ] projection of the class a pure poisson " @xmath21 mode .
the initial data are those of fig .
[ pd1].,width=326 ] to show that indeed the late time tail is dominated by the evolution of the @xmath108 projection of the original pure poisson " @xmath21 mode at @xmath65 , we present in fig .
[ pd3 ] the evolution of this mode .
comparison with fig .
[ pd2 ] indeed shows that the late time field of the full @xmath21 mode is dominated by the evolution of its monopole projection , not the monopole mode that is excited during the evolution because of mode coupling . for the class a pure poisson " mode @xmath21 ( solid curve ) and for its @xmath108 boyer
lindquist projection ( dashed curve ) .
the initial data are those of fig .
[ pd1 ] , and the field evolution is presented in fig .
[ pd2].,width=326 ] in fig .
[ pd4 ] we show the behavior of the local power indices for the full field of the class a pure poisson " @xmath21 mode , and for its monopole @xmath108 projection .
figure [ pd4 ] strongly suggests that the full field , and also the monopole projection , drop off at late times as @xmath103 .
indeed , the tail seen in figs .
[ pd3 ] and [ pd4 ] is asymptotic , and the local power index satisfies the ansatz ( [ ansatz ] ) both locally and globally simultaneously .
as noted in @xcite , it is not surprising that starting with the initial data of a @xmath128 mode , the @xmath129 mode is excited .
figure [ pd2 ] ( in conjunction with the conclusion that the tail is asymptotic ) shows that when starting with a pure poisson " mode , the excited monopole mode is insignificant for the asymptotic tail problem , as it is swamped by the evolution of the monopole projection of the initial data .
above , we showed that starting with class b initial data of a pure boyer
lindquist @xmath130 , the late time tail drops off according to @xmath26 , in accordance with tail b behavior , consistently with the results of @xcite . in that case , there is no monopole field present at @xmath65 , and all the monopole field present at late times is due to the excitation of the @xmath131 mode due to mode coupling .
the excited mode that has tail b behavior is overwhelmed by the evolution of the monopole mode existing at the initial time that has tail a behavior .
most importantly , we choose the initial data to be a pure spherical harmonic mode in the so - called spherical " coordinates .
the late time tail still decays according to tail a behavior , in contrast with the tail b expectations based on @xcite . in the case
presented , as the initial mode is azimuthal , the asymptotic tail drops off as @xmath23 .
the authors wish to thank richard price and jorge pullin for invaluable discussions . early work on this problem was done with elspeth allen at the university of utah .
lmb is supported in part by nasa / gsfc grant no .
ncc580 and by nasa / ssc grant no .
gk is grateful for research support from the umd college of engineering rsi fund and scea .
many of the simulations were performed on nsf s teragrid infrastructure ( under grant number tg - phy060047 t ) and the hpc consortium s facilities . | the decay rate of late time tails in the kerr spacetime have been the cause of numerous conflicting results , both analytical and numerical . in particular , there is much disagreement on whether the decay rate of an initially pure multipole moment @xmath0 is according to @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the least multipole moment whose excitation is not disallowed , or whether the decay rate is according to @xmath3 , where @xmath4 .
we do careful 2 + 1d numerical simulations , and explain the various results . in particular , we show that pure multipole outgoing initial data in either boyer lindquist on ingoing kerr coordinates on the corresponding slices lead to the same late time tail behavior .
we also show that similar initial data specified in terms of the poisson spherical coordinates lead to the simpler @xmath1 late time tail .
we generalize the rule @xmath4 to subdominant modes , and also study the behavior of non axisymmetric initial data .
we discuss some of the causes for possible errors in 2 + 1d simulations , demonstrate that our simulations are free of those errors , and argue that some conflicting past results may be attributed to them . |
the luminosity function ( lf ) is used to describe the distribution of intrinsic brightness for a particular type of celestial object , and it is always intimately connected to the physical processes leading to the formation of the object of interest .
specifically , the lf of supernovae ( sne ) , among the most luminous and exciting transients , will provide important information on their progenitor systems and their evolutionary paths .
the intrinsic lf of core - collapse sne ( cc sne , hereafter ) can constrain the distribution of ways that massive stars die at different initial masses ( smith et al .
2011a ) , and that of sne ia can illuminate how accreting white dwarfs in the various binary systems result in a thermonuclear explosion .
the observed lf of sne will provide information on the extinction they experienced in their host galaxies and their immediate environments , thus giving further clues to their physical origins . from an observational point of view
, the lf of sne is an important tool for calculating the completeness of a survey or a follow - up campaign in order to understand the involved selection biases , and for deriving meaningful sn rates .
knowledge of the sn lf will also provide guidance on the expected number and brightness distribution of sne in several new large surveys ( e.g. , pan - starrs , kaiser et al .
2002 ; palomar transient factory , law et al .
2009 ) , which can be used to estimate and coordinate the necessary resources for the follow - up efforts . until now
, however , we have had only limited knowledge on the lf of sne .
many factors contribute to the difficulties in measuring the observed sn lf , with the most important being the completeness of finding all sne in a survey and gathering follow - up photometry and spectroscopy .
to study the intrinsic lf of sne , we need further knowledge on how the sne are extinguished in their host galaxies .
there is some theoretical work on this ( e.g. , hatano , branch , & deaton 1998 ; riello & patat 2005 ) , but there are still considerable uncertainties in these models .
many previous measurements of sn rates have adopted different strategies to derive the survey completeness and control time , highlighting the uncertainties caused by limited knowledge of the sn lf .
some adopted an average luminosity plus a gaussian scatter for the sne ( e.g. , cappellaro et al .
1999 [ c99 , hereafter ] ; hardin et al .
2000 ; barris & tonry 2006 ; botticella et al .
2008 ) , while others used information from a follow - up sample with unknown completeness and biases ( e.g. , pain et al .
2002 ; blanc et al . 2004 ; sullivan et al . 2006 ; dilday et al .
some treat the lfs as observed , while others consider them as intrinsic and apply additional extinction corrections .
the host - galaxy extinction correction toward sne , however , is another poorly known quantity .
some studies adopted an arbitrary functional form , such as the positive side of a gaussian distribution ( neill et al .
2006 ; poznanski et al .
2007 ) , or an exponential function ( dilday et al . 2008 ) , while others followed the aforementioned theoretical guidance by hatano et al .
( 1998 ) and riello & patat ( 2005 ) ( e.g. , barris & tonry 2006 ; botticella et al . 2008 ; horesh et al . 2008 ) . in theory ,
the observed lf of sne can be derived from either a volume- or magnitude - limited search . for a volume - limited survey ,
the key factor is to have information ( type , luminosity , and light curve ) for all of the sne in the sample . for a magnitude - limited survey , it is important to have this information for all of the sne and then correct for the different survey volumes of sne having different brightnesses ( e.g. , bazin et al .
it is also important for a magnitude - limited survey to go fairly deep in order to sample the faint end of the lf . as discussed in detail by leaman et al .
( 2011 ; hereafter , paper i ) , there are nearly complete spectroscopic classifications for the sne discovered in our lick observatory sn search ( loss ) galaxies .
this search goes fairly deep , with a small observation interval for many nearby galaxies , so a significant fraction of our survey is in the volume - limited regime .
in particular , we identified that our survey may have almost full control for galaxies within 60 mpc and 80 mpc for cc sne and sne ia , respectively . here
we attempt to construct a complete sn sample to derive the observed lf .
this paper is organised as follows .
section 2 describes the construction of the complete sn sample , including the adopted light curves , the collection and fitting of the photometry , and the completeness study for every sn . in
3 we present the observed lfs and fractions of sne in a volume - limited survey , while 4 gives the results for a magnitude - limited survey .
section 5 discusses correlations of the lfs with the sn subtypes and host - galaxy properties , and possible limitations and caveats in our lfs .
our conclusions are summarised in 6 . throughout the study
, we adopt the wmap5 hubble constant of @xmath0 km s@xmath1 mpc@xmath1 ( spergel et al .
2007 ) , consistent with the recent direct determination based on cepheid variables and sne ia by riess et al .
paper i discussed the different subsamples of sne in our analysis . we elect to construct a complete sn sample in the season - nosmall " sample of sne , consisting of sne that were discovered `` in season '' but were not in small ( major axis @xmath2 )
early - type ( e / s0 ) galaxies .
there are considerable advantages of using in - season sne to construct the lf ; they were discovered young , so there are premaximum data to help constrain the peak magnitudes .
we also limit the sample to the sne discovered by the end of year 2006 , in accordance with the reduction of our follow - up photometry database .
the reason for the exclusion of sne in small early - type galaxies is due to the uncertain detection efficiency ( as discussed in paper i ) which results in an uncertain completeness correction ( 2.5 ) .
as discussed in 5.5 , only two sne were excluded from the lf study because their host galaxies are small early - type galaxies , and their inclusion would have negligible effect on the lfs .
we use a cutoff distance of 80 mpc for the sn ia sample and 60 mpc for sne ibc and ii ( see paper i ) . in 2.5 , we will compute the completeness of our survey for each sn selected in our lf sample . in total
, we select 74 sne ia , 25 sne ibc , and 81 sne ii , for a grand total of 180 sne .
table 1 lists some basic information on the sne and their host galaxies ( more details can be found in the galaxy and sn sample tables in paper i ) .
five of the sne ( sne 1999bw , 2000ch , 2001ac , 2002 kg , and 2003gm ) are so - called sn impostors " low - luminosity sne iin that are likely to be superoutbursts of luminous blue variable stars rather than genuine sne ( e.g. , van dyk et al .
2000 ; smith et al .
2011b ) ; they are not considered further in this analysis , but will be discussed in a future paper .
we note that since our survey is conducted without using a filter , the images are most closely matched to the @xmath3 band ( li et al .
2003a ) . in the following several sections
, we therefore focus our effort on deriving an @xmath3-band luminosity for the sne .
some discussion of lfs in other passbands can be found in 5.5 , and a full analysis of multi - colour lfs for sne ia will be presented elsewhere ( li et al .
2011b ) .
we also note that for all of the lf analysis , our photometry is corrected for the galactic extinction adopted from schlegel , finkbeiner , & davis ( 1998 ) to avoid additional scatter in the lf caused by the random galactic extinction that the sne suffered . because of this , our lf is pseudo - observed " and
only the sn host - galaxy extinctions are not corrected . when applying our lf to a known direction in the milky way
, the corresponding galactic extinction should be applied to the luminosity of the lf sne .
different types of sne exhibit a great degree of heterogeneity in their photometric behaviour ( e.g. , barbon , ciatti , & rosino 1979 ; leibundgut et al .
1991 ) . within a specific sn type
, some homogeneity and correlations are observed , but no type can be well represented by a single light curve .
ideally , it would be good to have a well - observed light curve for every sn in the lf sample , but unfortunately this is not the case ( see more details in 2.3 ) . to quantify the light - curve shape distribution for our lf sne
, we construct a family of light curves for each type of sn from the literature and/or our own database of optical photometry . with a few exceptions ( e.g. , li et al .
2001a , 2003b ; howell et al .
2006 ; foley et al . 2010b ) , sne ia are generally thought to form a one - parameter family , with the fast - declining sne also being subluminous , and slow decliners being luminous ( e.g. , phillips 1993 ) . in the left panel of figure 1 ,
we plot the @xmath3-band light curves of a sample of 83 well - observed sne ia in the loss photometry database ( solid lines ; ganeshalingam et al . 2010 ) .
the time axis show the number of days since @xmath3-band maximum , and the light curves are plotted on an absolute magnitude scale , after the sne were corrected for galactic extinction .
the distances toward the sne are calculated from the recession velocities corrected for infall of the local group toward the virgo cluster .
also overplotted are the light curves of sn 1991 t ( dash - dotted line , from lira et al .
1998 ) and the well - observed sn 1991bg - like object sn 1999by ( dashed line , from garnavich et al .
2004 ) , arbitrarily shifted to absolute magnitudes of @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively .
the published light curves of sne 1991 t and 1999by have been smoothed with a spline function ( as are all of the other template sn light curves shown in figures 13 ) . as can be seen
, the light curves of sne 1991 t and 1999by nearly encompass all of the observed sne ia in our photometry database .
we interpolate between the two curves to create 21 light curves ( so each curve has a different shoulder prominence and peak absolute magnitude ) , and use them as the light - curve family for sne ia . while our construction of the light - curve family for sne ia is not drastically different from previous approaches ( e.g. , the application of a stretch factor to a template light curve ) , we need to use interpolation ( rather than stretch ) during the construction to deal with the presence or absence of the shoulder feature in the @xmath3-band light curves .
a few sne in the sn ia lf sample belong to the so - called `` sn 2002cx - like objects '' ( filippenko 2003 ; li et al .
2003b ; jha et al . 2006b
; phillips et al . 2007 ) , which show distinct differences from the rest of the sn ia family recently , their sn ia nature has been questioned ( valenti et al . 2009 ; but see foley et al . 2009b , 2010a ) .
we constructed a template light curve from sn 2005hk ( phillips et al .
2007 ) , a well - observed sn 2002cx - like object .
compared to the wealth of published photometry for sne ia , the type ibc sne are not well observed .
it is unclear whether they can be described by a one - parameter family .
some studies suggest that they can be broadly classified into two bins ( e.g. , clocchiatti & wheeler 1997 ) : the fast - evolving and the slow - evolving subclasses . in the left panel of figure 2 , we plot the @xmath3-band light curves of 8 sne ibc from our unpublished photometry database .
there is no fast - evolving object among these 8 sne , so we adopted the photometry of sn 1994i ( dashed line , richmond et al .
1996 ) , a well - observed object in this subclass .
we have an excellent light curve for the slow - evolving sn ibc 2004dk ( dash - dotted line ) in our own photometry database which we use as a template . for the rest of the sne ibc ,
we construct an average light curve ( solid line ) .
the late - time behaviour of the average sn ibc is not well constrained by our sample , so we utilised an additional sample of sne ibc from modjaz ( 2007 ) .
this family of three light curves is used to fit the majority of the sne ibc in our lf sample ( without any stretching or interpolating ) .
for the so - called ca - rich " subclass of peculiar sne ibc , we chose the light curve of sn 2005e ( perets et al .
unfortunately , there are no premaximum data for sn 2005e , so we adopted that portion from the average sn ibc light curve .
this light curve is not shown in figure 2 .
sn ibc - pec " subclass also contains sn 2003id ( singer et al .
2003 ; hamuy & roth 2003 ) , the broad - lined sn ic 2002ap ( foley et al . 2003
; see more discussion in 3.2 ) , and sn 2004bm ( 3.2 ) .
the photometric behaviours of these sne ibc - pec are all reasonably represented by the average sn ibc light curve .
the photometric behaviour of sne ii is the most heterogeneous among all sn types , and they can be divided into a few main photometric and spectroscopic subclasses .
sne ii - p have a prominent `` plateau '' phase in their light curves , while sne ii - l decline linearly ( in magnitudes ) after maximum brightness .
sne iib show prominent hydrogen balmer lines in their early - time spectra , but morph into sne ib at late times .
in addition , the prototypical sn iib 1993j showed a double - peaked light curve ( richmond et al .
1994 ) , with a very early first peak , which we now think is most likely due to black - body emission from the expanding and cooling shock - heated stellar envelope ( e.g. , waxman et al .
2007 ) , and the regular ni@xmath6-powered main maximum .
this double - peak light curve behaviour has most recently also been seen in the type ib sn 2008d ( soderberg et al .
2008 ; modjaz et al .
while it is not clear how common and pronounced the early first peak is among other sne iib besides the well - studied sn 1993j ( e.g. , chevalier & soderberg 2009 ) , we use the smoothed light curve of sn 1993j as the light - curve template for sn iib . sne iin show a strong `` narrow '' ( actually , generally an intermediate width of @xmath7 km s@xmath1 ) component to their hydrogen balmer lines and a wide variety of light curves .
see filippenko ( 1997 ) for a detailed discussion of the classifications of these different subtypes .
the distinction between a sn ii - p and a sn ii - l in terms of photometric evolution is not well documented in the literature , especially in the @xmath3 band .
the collection of light curves for the sne ii - l in barbon et al .
( 1979 ) and young & branch ( 1989 ) are all in the @xmath8 band . for our application , we define a sn ii as being a sn ii - l if it declines by more than 0.5 mag in the @xmath3 band during the first 50 d after explosion .
the left panels of figure 3 show how the light curves of the sne ii are constructed .
the top panels show the light curves of 15 sne ii - p ( dots ) in our photometry database that have been published by poznanski et al .
as seen here , and also noted by hamuy ( 2003 ) , sne ii - p vary in the durations of their plateau phase .
we use the average light curve ( solid line ) as the template .
the second panel shows the light curves of 5 sne ii
- l in our unpublished photometry database ; again , an average is derived as the template . due to the lack of data ,
the late - time behaviour of the sn ii - l template is not well constrained and may have relatively large uncertainty .
the third panel shows the light curves of 3 sne iib : the prototypical sn iib 1993j ( richmond et al . 1994 ) , and the unfiltered light curves of sne 2003gu and 2005em from our photometry database .
we use the smoothed light curve of sn 1993j as the template .
the rising portion of the first peak is not well observed , so our manual construction is quite arbitrary after considering the earliest nondetections and detections ( e.g. , wheeler et al . 1993 ) .
the bottom - left panel of figure 3 shows the construction of the template light curves for sne iin .
eight well - observed sne iin from our photometry database are plotted , displaying a great degree of heterogeneity .
this mirrors what has been reported in the literature about the photometric behaviour of this class of objects : sne iin can range from very slowly evolving objects such as sn 1988z ( e.g. , turatto et al .
1993 ) and sn 1995 g ( pastorello et al . 2002 ) , to more typical objects like sn 1994w ( sollerman , cumming , & lundqvist 1998 ) , to very rapidly evolving objects such as sn 1998s ( fassia et al .
we use the light curve of sn 1998s ( dash - dotted line ) as the template of a fast - declining sn iin , that of sn 2003dv ( dashed line ) as the template for a slow - evolving sn iin , and the average of the remaining seven objects ( solid line ) for the average sn iin .
it is important to collect photometry for _ every _ sn in the lf sample to study the light - curve shape and derive the peak absolute magnitude ; otherwise , the sample will not be complete .
since our unfiltered survey images are most closely matched to the @xmath3 band , we use the follow - up @xmath3-band photometry for the sne whenever possible .
this is because the images taken during the follow - up campaigns have a higher cadence ( every 12 d near maximum light , every 24 d thereafter ) than the unfiltered images taken during the sn search .
moreover , accurate photometric calibrations for the fields have been obtained with the 0.76 m katzman automatic imaging telescope ( kait ) and the 1.0 m nickel telescope at lick observatory on many photometric nights .
the reduction details are described by ganeshalingam et al .
( 2010 ) , where the filtered photometry for the sne ia is also provided .
an important step in the reduction is the careful removal of the host - galaxy contamination in the sn flux by subtracting a template image taken long after the sn has faded . for sne ia ,
62 of the 74 sne ( 84% ) in the lf sample have filtered follow - up photometry .
this large fraction is due to the combined effect of the luminous nature of sne ia relative to most other sne , the early discovery , and our emphasis on studying them . for several sne ( details listed in table 3 ) , the follow - up photometry is adopted from jha et al .
( 2006a ; hereafter cfa-2 " ) and hicken et al .
( 2009 ; hereafter cfa-3 " ) . only 7 out of the 25 sne ibc ( 28% ) have follow - up photometry , and for sne ii the corresponding numbers are 18 out of 76 ( 24% ) . for the sne that do not have filtered follow - up photometry ,
we derive unfiltered light curves from the sn search images .
as discussed in paper i , our search has a relatively short observation interval , so we cover the photometric evolution of the sne rather well .
this is especially true for the sne in the lf sample , as their host galaxies are mostly in the sample that has a designed observational interval of every 5 d. to reduce the unfiltered images , a high signal - to - noise ratio template image without the sn is selected .
the host - galaxy contamination is then cleanly removed after image subtraction , similar to what is done in the follow - up data reduction described by ganeshalingam et al .
( 2010 ) . for photometric calibration
, we use the red magnitudes for the stars in the sn fields in the usno b1 catalog ( monet et al .
although the accuracy of this calibration is only @xmath90.3 mag for an individual star , there are usually more than 10 stars available in each field , so the uncertainty due to calibration is @xmath10 mag .
we have good unfiltered light curves for a majority of the sne without follow - up filtered photometry .
however , for a small fraction of the sne ( 13 out of 175 , or 7% ) , our photometric coverage is relatively poor .
some of them were discovered near the end of an observing season , so the search images did not cover the whole period around maximum light .
a few others are faint and the search images do not go deep enough to yield a constraint on the light - curve shape . the majority of them , however , are due to a combination of bad weather and relatively low cadence . for two objects ( sne 2005w and 2006dy in table 3 )
, we adopted the photometry measured by amateur astronomers posted on snweb , with good coverage around maximum light .
for the other sne , we pool all of the information on the sne together ( discovery magnitude , spectral identification and age estimate , unfiltered and filtered photometry in our database and published elsewhere ) and constrain the light curves as much as possible . some of them still have large uncertainties , as reflected in the error bars for their peak magnitudes .
we also use the average light curves according to their types for these poorly observed sne .
we use a @xmath11-minimizing technique to fit light curves constructed in 2.2 to the photometry collected in 2.3 , to determine the light - curve shape and peak magnitude for each sn , as demonstrated in the right - hand panels of figures 1 to 3 .
because we attempt to use a small set of light curves to describe the complicated observed variety of photometric behaviour for the different types of sne , the fit to the data is not always perfect , and the reduced @xmath11 of the fit can be several times larger than unity . whenever possible , the peak magnitudes are directly measured from a spline fit to the data near maximum brightness rather than measured from the light - curve fit . as noted by cappellaro et al .
( 1993 ) , the control - time calculation for a sn search is more sensitive to the adopted peak luminosity of a sn than to its light - curve shape .
the imperfections in the light - curve fits also have a chance to cancel each other out when many sne are combined in the lf .
so , the uncertainty in the light - curve shape likely has little effect on the final control - time calculation .
we visually check the fits , especially the ones with relatively large reduced @xmath11 , to make sure they are a reasonable representation of the data , and if not , to determine the possible causes . by doing this , we identified two misclassifications in the lf sne , sne 2002au and 2006p , as detailed in paper i. both sne were originally classified as possible sne ia , but their light - curve fits suggest sn iib and sn ic , respectively .
an analysis of their observed spectra confirms the suggestion from the light - curve fit .
this exercise partly validates our constructed light - curve families and the light - curve fitting process .
the peak apparent magnitudes measured for the sne are converted to absolute magnitudes using distances measured from the recession velocities corrected for the infall of the local group toward the virgo cluster . to account for peculiar velocities in the local flow , we adopt 300 km s@xmath1 as the uncertainty for the recession velocities .
the uncertainties of the absolute magnitudes include the photometry measurement error , the light - curve fit uncertainty , and the distance uncertainty added in quadrature .
columns 3 and 4 of tables 35 list the results for different types of sne .
it is important to correct for possible incompleteness of the sne in the lf sample . for a particular sn in the lf sample , the peak absolute magnitude and light - curve shape
are given in 2.4 .
with this information , we can calculate the control time for this sn for the loss galaxies in the full - nosmall " sample ( the control galaxy sample for the lf sne ; see paper i ) using their monitoring history log files [ see paper iii ( li et al .
2011a ) for details of the control - time calculation ] . the completeness of of our search to a particular sn at a given distance is then defined as the sum of the control time of that particular sn for all of the galaxies within that distance divided by the sum of the observing season time for these galaxies . to correct a sn to 100% completeness within the cutoff distance of the lf sample ,
one just needs to use the reciprocal of the completeness as the corrected number for the sn .
figure 4 shows the completeness measurements for the sne in the lf sample .
each curve represents a sn , and some of the notable sne are labeled .
the vertical dashed lines indicate the cutoff distance where the sample is constructed .
the top panel shows the completeness measurements for the sne ia .
we achieved a completeness higher than 98% for all of the sne ia because of their extreme luminosity at peak .
the total number of sne after correction for the incompleteness is 74.70 , only a 1% change from the input number of 74 .
the middle and bottom panels show the completeness measurements for the cc sne .
the majority of the sne have completeness higher than 80% at the cutoff distance of 60 mpc , but a few of them have relatively low completeness due to their extremely low luminosity .
for example , sn 1999br ( pastorello et al .
2004 ) is an intrinsically faint sn ii - p , while sn 2002hh ( pozzo et al .
2006 ) is a highly reddened sn
ii - p in the nearby galaxy ngc 6946 .
the corrected number for each sn in the lf function after applying the completeness correction factor ( hereafter ccf ) is listed in column 7 of tables 35 .
the total corrected number of sne ibc is 28.86 , an 18% increase compared to the input number of 24.5 . for sne ii ,
the corrected number of 88.50 is a 16% increase over the input number of 76.5 .
we see that even though our search does not have full control for all of the sne within the cutoff distance of the lf sample , the correction to 100% completeness is small and thus our lf should not suffer large uncertainties ( see additional discussion in 5 ) .
the pseudo - observed " lfs of the sne ( corrected for milky way extinction but not host - galaxy extinction ) are listed in tables 35 for the different types . the following information is included for each sn : the subtype , the absolute magnitude and its uncertainty , the distance of the sn , the hubble type , inclination , and mass of its host galaxy , the corrected lf number for a volume - limited sample , the corrected lf number for a magnitude - limited sample ( discussed in the next section ) , the light - curve shape of the sn , the source of the photometry , and additional comments .
each sn constitutes a discrete point in the lf , with its own peak absolute magnitude , light - curve shape , and number contribution to the total lf .
although it would be ideal to construct a lf for galaxies of every hubble type , it is impractical with the relatively small total number of sne in the lf sample . instead
, the sne are grouped into two broad bins for each sn type : e sa and sb
irr for sne ia , s0sbc and sc
irr for the cc sne .
the split of the hubble types is motivated by an attempt to include reasonable numbers of sne in each lf , rather than by physics .
for example , one may argue that splitting the sne ia by e
s0 ( early - type ) and sa irr ( late - type ) galaxies may be more physically based , but then the e s0 bin would suffer more from small - number statistics . as discussed in paper iii , the exact manner in which the sn ia lf is split has negligible effect on the final derived sn ia rates .
to study the statistical properties of the lfs , we use histograms to show their luminosity distribution , but we emphasise that the lfs should be used as discrete points when calculating the control time for a survey .
we also use the kolmogorov - smirnov ( k - s ) test exclusively to study whether two groups of objects come from the same population ( in terms of absolute magnitudes only ) .
we note that the histograms show the distributions of the _ corrected numbers _ of the lfs ; thus , the number of sne in each bin does not correctly reflect poisson statistics .
since the ccfs are always greater than 1 , the poisson uncertainty of each bin is always larger than that calculated directly from the number of sne in the bin .
for example , if one bin has a single sn with a ccf of 2.0 , the number of sne in the bin with proper poisson errors is @xmath12 ( i.e. , the error is 2.0 times the poisson error of 1.0 sn ; gehrels 1986 ) , rather than @xmath13 ( i.e. , the poisson error calculated directly from 2.0 sne ) . in the same vein , the k - s tests are also somewhat compromised due to the deviation from poisson statistics .
fortunately , the ccfs are close to 1.0 for all of the sne in the lfs except for the objects fainter than @xmath14 mag . in our subsequent discussions
, all significant k - s test results will be scrutinised by including / excluding the least luminous objects in the lfs . to properly consider the effect of the uncertainties of the lf sn absolute magnitudes on the k - s test results
, we run a monte carlo simulation 1000 times to sample the absolute magnitudes according to their gaussian errors , and study the scatter of the resultant cumulative distribution functions ( cdfs ; also called cumulative fractions ) and the probabilities of the two samples coming from the same population .
figures 57 display the histograms for the lfs of sne ia , ibc , and ii , respectively .
the second panel of each figure shows the distribution for the whole lf sample .
we note that while a gaussian distribution is an acceptable but not ideal description for the lfs of sne ibc and ii , it is a rather poor description for the lf of sne ia .
the average absolute magnitudes are @xmath15 ( with a @xmath16 dispersion of 0.76 ) , @xmath17 ( @xmath18 ) , and @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) for the sne ia , ibc , and ii , respectively .
these numbers , together with the average absolute magnitudes for several other combinations , are listed in table 6 .
richardson et al . (
2002 ) did an extensive comparative study of the peak absolute magnitude distribution for the sn discoveries compiled in the asiago sn catalog ( barbon , cappellaro , & turatto 1989 ; barbon et al .
their study was done in the @xmath8 band , although they did not distinguish among the different photometric bands for some sne .
they derived an absolute magnitude ( without extinction corrections , and converting to @xmath0 km s@xmath1 mpc@xmath1 used in our study ) of @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) for _ normal _ sne ia , @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) for sne ibc , and @xmath25 ( @xmath26 ) for sne ii - p .
we note the significant difference compared with our result for the average peak absolute magnitudes of sne ibc : the richardson et al .
sample suggests a much brighter magnitude relative to sne ia and ii . as richardson et al
. noted , there are considerable observational biases in their observed sn sample and the completeness is unknown .
in particular , the sn ibc subclass may be more heavily biased in the observed sample due to its low peak luminosity ( relative to sne ia ) and fast photometric evolution ( relative to sne ii - p ) .
figure 5 shows the histograms for the lfs of sne ia in different galaxy bins ( the two lower panels ) .
the lf in e sa galaxies shows an apparent difference from the lf in sb irr galaxies , with only a @xmath27% probability that they come from the same population ( the cumulative fractions and their 1@xmath28 scatters are plotted in the top panel ) .
this is likely caused by the observed preference of different subclasses of sne ia in host galaxies of different hubble types : the subluminous sn 1991bg - like objects in early - type galaxies and the overluminous sn 1991t - like objects in spiral galaxies ( e.g. , della valle & livio 1994 ; hamuy et al .
1996 ; howell 2001 ) .
figure 6 shows the histograms for the lfs of sne ibc in different galaxy bins ( the two lower panels )
. the k - s test does not provide evidence for a significant difference between the two lfs : the sne come from the same population at a @xmath29% probability .
sne ibc in the early - type spiral galaxies appear on average marginally fainter ( averaging @xmath30 mag ; @xmath31 mag ) than their counterparts in the late - type spirals ( average of @xmath32 mag ; @xmath33 mag ) .
figure 7 shows the histograms for the lfs of sne ii in different galaxy bins ( the two lower panels ) ; there is a marginal difference , with a @xmath34% probability that they come from the same population .
contrary to the trend shown by the sne ibc , in the early - type spirals sne ii are marginally brighter ( average of @xmath35 mag ; @xmath36 mag ) than their counterparts in the late - type spirals , which average @xmath37 mag ( @xmath38 mag ) .
the significance of the difference between the two lfs is not dramatically affected by the objects fainter than @xmath14 mag : when they are excluded from the statistics , the two lfs come from the same population with a @xmath39% probability .
it is generally expected that sne occurring in late - type galaxies should on average experience more extinction than those in early - type galaxies because of a dustier environment .
this fact should be taken into account when translating differences in the observed lfs in various hubble types into differences in the intrinsic lfs .
for example , sne ia that occurred in sc
irr galaxies should be intrinsically brighter than sne ia in e sa galaxies by a bigger margin than is shown in figure 5 . in a recent paper , bazin et al .
( 2009 ) derived an overall core - collapse sn lf from the supernova legacy survey ( snls ) . a comparison between our combined sn ibc and sn ii lf and that reported by bazin et al .
shows excellent agreement ( j. rich , 2010 , private communication ) . in the process of analysing the lf sne in detail , we are able to put them into different subclass bins .
for sne ia , the light - curve fitting sequence from 1 to 21 is a loose luminosity indicator , as we demonstrate in a forthcoming paper ( li et al .
moreover , the sne are categorised into several subclasses : normal sne ia with normal expansion velocities ( ian " in table 3 and hereafter ) , normal sne ia with high expansion velocities ( iahv , " see wang et al .
2009 for our definition of this subclass ) , sn 1991bg - like objects ( ia-91bg " ; filippenko et al .
1992b ; leibundgut et al .
1993 ) , sn 1991t - like objects ( ia-91 t " ; filippenko et al . 1992a ; phillips et al . 1992 ) , and sn 2002cx - like objects ( ia-02cx " ; filippenko 2003 ; li et al . 2003b ; jha et al .
2006b ; phillips et al .
this classification is based on the information published in the iau circulars and/or analysis of the spectra in our spectral database ( silverman et al .
2011 ) . as discussed by li et al .
( 2001b ) , there is a significant age bias " for sn 1991t - like objects , caused by the fact that such objects can only be easily identified with spectra taken prior to or near maximum brightness . because of this
, the fraction of sn 1991t - like objects should be regarded as a lower limit in this study . as discussed by wang et al .
( 2009 ) , a spectrum ( or expansion - velocity measurement ) within a week around maximum brightness is required to classify a normal sn ia into the ian " or iahv " subclasses .
fortunately , we were able to secure such information for all of the sne ia in our lf sample . for sne ibc ,
both the fast- and slow - evolving sne are relatively rare ( 10% for each subclass ) , but this conclusion is hampered by the relatively large fraction of sne ibc that are either peculiar or have poor light - curve coverage .
we put the sne ibc into three subclasses : sn ib , sn ic , or peculiar ibc or ic ( ibc - pec " or
ic - pec , " which we consider as the same subclass ) .
we note that in general , there is considerable uncertainty in classifying sne ibc into these subclasses .
sometimes the sne are simply reported as sn ibc " in the iau circulars without a more specific subclass .
other times , a sn ib would only develop strong he i lines after a few weeks , so it might be misclassified as a sn ic from an early - time spectrum .
the differences in the spectra of the different subclasses also become subtle when the sne are in the nebular phase .
although there are spectra for 21 out of the 25 lf sne ibc in our spectral database , and the other 4 sne were classified in iau circulars by experienced observers , we do not have a good series of spectra for every sn in the sample to check for a possible sn ic to sn ib transition , so the fraction of sne ic should be regarded as an upper limit in this study .
we attempt to place the sne ii into four subclasses : ii - p , ii - l , iib , or iin .
for this purpose , sne iin can often be easily distinguished from the others because of their unique spectral features ( a prominent narrow or intermediate - width emission component in the hydrogen balmer lines ) , although in rare cases a sn iin can spectroscopically evolve into a regular sn ii ( e.g. , sn 2005gl , gal - yam et al .
it is difficult to distinguish between the other three subclasses based on their spectra alone .
first , the defining features or spectral evolution have not been established to distinguish a sn ii - p from a sn ii - l .
second , even though a sn iib can be identified from its early resemblance to a sn ii and late metamorphosis into a sn ib , it is not clear whether an early sn ii will turn out to be a sn iib unless we have good spectroscopic coverage for _ every _ sn ii
. fortunately , these three subclasses have rather different photometric behaviour : sne ii - p have a prominent plateau phase , sne ii - l have a linear decline ( in magnitudes ) after maximum , and sne iib have a double - peaked light curve ( figure 3 ) .
consequently , for the majority of sne our light - curve fitting process reports a strong preference for a certain subtype . for a few sne with poor light - curve coverage
, the data can be fit by more than one template light curve , and we assign equal fractional weights to the subclasses that provide a satisfactory fit .
one surprising result from the light - curve fitting process is a possible high fraction of sne iib in the sn ii sample .
following identification of the first known sn iib , sn 1987k ( filippenko 1988 ) , detailed studies of only a few sne iib have been published in the literature .
sn 1993j , the prototypical sn iib in the nearby galaxy m81 , has been extensively studied ( e.g. , matheson et al . 2000 , and references therein ) .
another sn iib , sn 1996cb , was studied by qiu et al .
( 1999 ) . with the help of the `` supernova identification code '' ( snid ; blondin & tonry 2007 ) , some recent sne have been classified as sn iib .
the fraction of sn iib within the family of sne ii is very uncertain , but generally considered to be relatively small .
figure 8 shows all possible sne iib in our lf sample .
two of the objects , sne 2000n and 2004al , can be fit with both a sn iib and a sn ii - l , so they are assigned 0.5 for each subclass .
foley et al .
( 2004 ) classified sn 2004bm as a probable sn ic based on a low - quality spectrum .
the light curve , though with only four points , shows a distinct dip that is reminiscent of a sn iib .
reanalysis of the spectrum does not provide a confident classification for the sn , so we assign 0.5 for both iib and ibc - pec .
the light curve of sn 2005h is rather poor .
the photometric behaviours of the other seven sne are best matched by the template sn iib light curve .
considering that our template light curves are only an average of the observations , it is conceivable that a few of these sne can be fit by some variations of sne ii - l ( these sne are clearly not sne ii - p , and their spectra do not show narrow emission components so they are also not sne iin ) ; hence , the list of sne in figure 8 should be considered as an upper limit to possible sne iib in the lf sample .
we also note that for four of our sn iib candidates , there is spectroscopic confirmation of our classification : sn 2000h ( benetti et al .
2000 ) , sn 2003ed ( leonard , chornock , & filippenko 2003 ) , sn 2005u ( leonard & cenko 2005 ) , and sn 2006 t ( blondin et al .
we consider the sn iib classification for these four objects to be solid , but for the rest of the sne , we do not have spectra to corroborate the sn iib classification from the light curves .
overall , we have four solid ( 5% of all the sne ii ) , or up to 9 possible ( 12% of all the sne ii ) , sne iib in our lf sample . the observed fractions of different subclasses of sne can be illustrated with pie charts , as shown in figure 9 .
these fractions are also listed in the second column in table 7 . to calculate the uncertainties of the fractions
, we ran a monte carlo simulation to generate 1000 different versions of the lf according to poisson statistics with the _ observed _ total number of sne .
the 1@xmath28 scatter of the measurements is then reported as the uncertainty in each case . despite having a relatively large number of sne ( 175 ) in the lf sample , many of the fractions
are derived from subsets of sne in the lf sample and suffer from small - number statistics ; thus , there are considerable uncertainties in the fractions , especially for those of sne ibc .
the sne ia within 60 mpc are considered together with the cc sne in the lf sample to derive their relative fractions in the leftmost pie chart .
clearly , sne ii are the most abundant ( 57% of all ) type of sne in a volume - limited sample , while sne ia ( 24% ) and sn ibc ( 19% ) have roughly equal fractions .
the sn ia pie chart is constructed from the sn ia lf sample within 80 mpc .
normal sne ia are about 70% of the total , while the other subclasses are 15% sn 1991bg - like objects , 9% sn 1991t - like objects , and 5% sn 2002cx - like objects .
( 2001b ) studied the rate of peculiar sne ia with a sample of 45 sne ia discovered by loss during the period between 1997 and 1999 , and found a fraction of 64% normal , 16% sn 1991bg - like , and 20% sn 1991t - like .
the two studies have a similar fraction for the normal and sn 1991bg - like objects , but a different fraction for the sn 1991t - like objects .
as discussed above , the fraction of sn 1991t - like objects suffers from the age bias , which is probably more serious in this analysis than in the li et al .
( 2001b ) study . moreover , given the relatively small samples in both studies ,
the difference is within the error bars of the fractions , especially considering that the sn 2002cx - like objects can be loosely grouped with sn 1991t - like objects because they show similar strong fe iii features at early times ( but with different expansion velocities ) . the normal sne ia are further divided into the objects with normal ( ian ) and high ( iahv ) expansion velocities .
their fractions , not shown in the pie chart , are 50% for ian and 20% for iahv in the sn ia sample .
we note that the fraction for the sn 2002cx - like objects , @xmath40 5% of the total sn ia sample , is quite uncertain due to the heterogeneity of the subclass .
for example , our sn ia lf sample does not have the rapidly evolving , very subluminous sn 2002cx - like objects such as sn 2008 ha , which , according to foley et al .
( 2010a ) , could have a fraction as high as @xmath41% of the sn ia population .
the sn ibc pie chart shows that sne ic are the largest fraction ( 54% of all ) , followed by sne ibc - pec ( 24% ) and sne ib ( 21% ) . among the sne ibc - pec , each of sne 2002ap , 2003id , and 2004bm is @xmath42% of the total , while the ca - rich objects are @xmath43%
the sn ii pie chart demonstrates that the most abundant component is sne ii - p ( 70% of all ) , and the other three subclasses have similar fractions ( 10% , 12% , and 9% for sne
ii - l , iib , and iin , respectively ) . while a future paper will discuss in detail the rates for the various types of peculiar sne and transients , we note here the fractions ( or upper limits ) for several kinds of objects .
richardson et al .
( 2002 ) suggested a population of luminous sne ibc ( with peak absolute magnitude brighter than @xmath44 ) and ii - l ( brighter than @xmath45 ) .
recently , several extremely luminous cc sne have been reported , including sn 2003ma ( rest et al .
2009 ) , sn 2005ap ( quimby et al .
2007 ) , sn 2006gy ( smith et al .
2007 ; ofek et al .
2007 ) , sn 2006tf ( smith et al .
2008 ) , sn 2008es ( miller et al .
2009 ; gezari et al .
2009 ) , and sn 2008fz ( drake et al . 2010 ) . as listed in tables 4 and 5 ,
none of the 88.5 cc sne in our lf sample is brighter than @xmath46 mag .
thus , unless the very luminous cc sne have an extreme preference to occur in low - luminosity galaxies or near galaxy nuclei , making our survey strongly biased against them , our lfs suggest that they are rare ( @xmath47% of the total cc sne using poisson statistics ) . of the subclass of sne ibc - pec ,
the broad - lined sne ic deserve special attention because of their link to gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ; e.g. , galama et al . 1998 ; matheson et al . 2003 ; modjaz et al .
2006 ; pian et al .
2006 ) . in our lf sn sample
, there is only one broad - lined sn ic , sn 2002ap ( foley et al .
2003 ) , which is 3.5% of the total sne ibc .
thus , broad - lined sne ic appear to be relatively rare . a more detailed discussion of their rate and a comparison to the published grb rates will be provided in a future paper .
we emphasise that this is the first time the observed fractions of the subclasses of sne have been measured from a complete , volume - limited sn sample , with well - understood completeness measurements , and light - curve information to help with the classification .
these fractions provide strong constraints on the possible progenitor systems and their evolutionary paths for the different subclasses of sne , which is the topic of another paper ( smith et al .
2011a ) .
we note that smartt et al .
( 2009 ) recently used a volume - limited ( within 28 mpc ) sample of 132 sne to investigate the observed fractions of sne .
they based their classifications mostly on the reports in the iau circulars .
while that study and ours have similar fractions for the overall sne ia , ibc , and ii , the fractions for the subclasses of sne ii are quite different ( our study suggests a lower fraction for sne ii - p , but higher fractions for the subclasses of sne ii - l , iib , and iin ) . as noted earlier , photometric behaviour is key to distinguishing sne ii - l and iib from sne ii - p . without detailed light curves for the sne in the smartt et al .
study , some of the sne ii - l and iib might not be recognised as such , a possible explanation for the differences in the two studies .
the two sn samples are also quite different and may involve different selection biases .
in contrast to a volume - limited survey in which all of the sne within a certain volume have been discovered , a magnitude - limited survey has a limiting magnitude for the apparent brightness of the discovered sne , @xmath48 .
consequently , a sn with an observed absolute magnitude , @xmath49 , will have a survey volume within a distance of @xmath50 .
the observed lfs in a volume - limited sample discussed in 3 can thus be converted to those in a magnitude - limited sample , with each sn scaled by its survey volume .
we emphasise that this exercise is for an ideal situation where the limiting magnitude of the magnitude - limited survey is deep enough to sample the faintest end of the observed lfs , and to accumulate enough statistics for the whole range of the lfs .
moreover , the lfs can only apply to a scenario in which the survey volume is constantly monitored that is , the observation interval is minimal ( e.g. , daily ) , and _ all _ of the sne that occurred during the survey are discovered and measured .
the effect of different observation intervals is discussed in more detail in 4.3 .
it should also be noted that this is for a _ nearby _ magnitude - limited survey because it is derived from the nearby volume - limited sample ; the lfs and relative fractions of sne may evolve with redshift .
figure 10 shows the histograms of the lfs of sne in a magnitude - limited sample showing the percent of the total number of sne for each bin ( solid lines , with interval = 1 d ) , while column 8 of tables 35 lists the relative fraction of each sn assuming the total number of sne is the same as in the volume - limited sample for each type .
compared to the volume - limited lfs , the magnitude - limited lfs clearly have an enhanced fraction of more luminous objects due to their larger survey volume .
the average absolute magnitudes are @xmath51 ( @xmath52 ) , @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) , and @xmath55 ( @xmath56 ) for sne ia , ibc , and ii , respectively , which are about 0.5 , 1.2 , and 1.6 mag brighter than those in a volume - limited sample .
we also note that the scatter of the average absolute magnitude becomes smaller in a magnitude - limited sample , so the sne appear to be more standard " because of the redistribution of the sn fractions .
in other words , a magnitude - limited search will be strongly biased in favour of luminous , unextinguished objects .
one needs to be aware of this selection bias before generalizing a result derived from a magnitude - limited search .
we note the sn ibc absolute magnitude is now more in line with the average of the observed sample in richardson et al .
( 2002 ) , suggesting that a significant fraction of the observed sne ibc in their sample were discovered in magnitude - limited surveys .
because different subclasses of sne have different absolute magnitudes , their observed fractions also change in a magnitude - limited survey , as shown in figure 11 and listed in table 7 ( the column marked with
mag-1d " ) .
the uncertainties of the fractions are derived from the monte carlo simulations discussed in 3.2 .
this is again for an ideal magnitude - limited survey in which the survey volume is constantly monitored .
sne ia , the most luminous type of the three , now become the most abundant , accounting for 79% of the total .
sne ii , the most abundant in a volume - limited sample , are only 17% of the total , while sne ibc are just 4% . among sne ia ,
normal sne ia are 77% of the total , sn 1991t - like objects are 18% , while sn 1991bg - like and sn 2002cx - like objects are 3% and 2% , respectively .
the slow - evolving objects ( sn 1991t - like objects and some normal sne ia ) have enhanced numbers in a magnitude - limited survey because they are more luminous than the rest of the sne ia .
the number of fast - evolving sn 1991bg - like objects , on the other hand , is depressed due to their subluminous nature .
we also note that there may be hints that sn 1991bg - like objects constitute less than 3% of the total in some magnitude - limited surveys conducted at moderate and high redshifts , such as the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; b. dilday , 2009 , private communication ; foley et al .
2009a ) and the sn legacy survey ( a. howell , 2009 , private communication ) , suggesting further discrimination against them at large look - back times .
this , if confirmed , will constrain the progenitors of sn 1991bg - like objects to a tight range of old populations .
the fractions for the different subclasses of the cc sne also change significantly , especially among sne ii .
the fractions for sne iib and ii - l are enhanced , while that for sne ii - p is depressed .
it is worth noting that sne ii - p , the most abundant sn ii component ( 70% of all ) in a volume - limited survey , constitute only 30% of all in a magnitude - limited survey due to their subluminous nature .
the previous two sections discuss the lfs and subclass fractions of sne in an ideal magnitude - limited survey , one with the minimum observation interval ( 1 d ) . in practice ,
the observation intervals are significantly longer than 1 d in most magnitude - limited surveys , and we discuss their effect in this section .
we perform a monte carlo simulation similar to that employed by li , filippenko , & riess ( 2001 ) to achieve this goal .
the limiting magnitude of the survey is set to be 19 , and the survey period is 10 yr .
we use 10@xmath57 sne in the simulation , and they are randomly but evenly distributed in a volume with the boundary set at a distance modulus @xmath58 = 40.0 mag .
this large volume ensures that the survey is in the magnitude - limited regime even for the most luminous sne in the lfs .
each sn is randomly selected from a lf that is constructed by combining the sn ibc lf , the sn ii lf , and the sn ia lf within 80 mpc scaled to @xmath59 mpc ( by a constant equal to the ratio of the total number of sne in the two lfs ) , with a probability proportional to its number fraction .
the sn is also given a random explosion date during the 10 yr period .
the survey then goes through the series of dates of observations ( according to the observation interval ) and checks to see whether the sn is detected . in these simulations , a step function is used for the detection efficiency ; the sn is marked as being detected when it is brighter than the survey limiting magnitude at any epoch of its light curve .
the effect of the observation interval on the lfs is shown in figure 10 .
the shape of the lfs has subtle changes for all three sn types .
the most significant change , however , is that more sne ii ( with a higher percentage of total sne ) are discovered when the observation interval is longer .
this is due to the fact that sne ii - p have a long plateau phase and their discovery rate is relatively enhanced with long observation intervals .
the subclass fractions with different observation intervals are shown in figure 12 and listed in table 7 .
the upper - left panel shows the overall sn ia , ibc , and ii fractions .
the sn ibc fraction remains small , @xmath42% for all of the intervals .
the sn ia fraction decreases from 79% to 69% , while the sn ii fraction increases from 17% to 27% , when the observation interval changes from 1 d to 360 d ( or a single snapshot ) , respectively .
also shown in the panel is the curve of the detection fraction , " which is the total number of sne detected at a given observation interval divided by that with an observation interval of 1 d. the detection fraction remains high ( @xmath60% ) when the observation interval is smaller than 10 d , and then declines dramatically with longer intervals .
this is likely due to the fact that most sn light curves do not change much during the 10 d near maximum brightness . in a snapshot survey ( i.e. , with an interval of 360 d ) , only 8.6% of the sne are detected .
the other panels show the subclass fractions with different observation intervals for sne ia , ibc , and ii , respectively .
we note that when the observation interval is shorter than 10 d , all subclass fractions remain nearly unchanged . at longer intervals , the fractions of the sne with relatively slow light curves
are enhanced , e.g. , sn 1991t - like objects among sne ia and sne ii - p among sne ii . in a snapshot survey , nearly 40% of the sne ii are sne ii - p , much higher than the fraction of 30% in an ideal magnitude - limited survey .
to check whether our predicted subclass fractions of sne in a magnitude - limited sample match observations , we compare our results to those of several actual magnitude - limited samples .
although loss is a search with a targeted list of nearby galaxies , the random galaxies projected in the background of the loss target fields have a wide range of redshift , so the sne discovered in them should only be limited by the depth of our images ; they belong to a magnitude - limited sample .
gal - yam et al .
( 2008 ) compiled a list of 32 such events discovered during the years 19992006 .
here we update the list to include all of the sne discovered during the years 20072008 .
we also revise the list of gal - yam et al . to exclude three objects ( sne 2002ct , 2003im , and 2004x ; all occurred in targeted galaxies with relatively high redshift ) , and include six additional objects ( sne 2001ew , 2002je , 2002ka , 2004as , 2004eb , and 2005bu ; all occurred in the background galaxies ) .
the full list has 47 sne and is reported in table 7 .
only 1 object ( sn 2001es ) does not have a spectroscopic classification .
for the rest of the sne , 34 ( 74% ) are sne ia , 4 ( 9% ) are sne ibc , and 8 ( 17% ) are sne ii . as the observation interval of our search is on average smaller than 10 d ( paper i ) ,
the observed fractions should be compared to those predicted by an ideal magnitude - limited search ( 79% , 4% , and 17% for sne ia , ibc , and ii , respectively ) , and they show excellent agreement .
comparison with the detailed subclasses is not possible because we do not have good light - curve coverage for these sne , and the total number of cc sne ( 12 ) is small . the palomar transient factory ( ptf , law et al .
2009 ) is a wide - field survey aimed at a systematic exploration of the optical transient sky , and is a classical magnitude - limited search for sne .
two batches of sne have been reported by kasliwal et al .
( 2009 ) and quimby et al .
( 2009 ) . among the 29 spectroscopically classified sne ( out of 31 total ) , 21 ( 72% ) are sne ia , 1 ( 3% ) is a sn ibc , and 7 ( 24% ) are sne ii . considering the small total number of sne involved , and the unknown observation interval , these fractions are in sufficiently good agreement with our predictions .
in this section , we discuss the dependence of the volume - limited lfs on the environments and subclasses of sne .
we also consider possible applications of our lfs .
as described in paper i , the loss galaxy sample has an apparent deficit of low - luminosity galaxies when compared to a complete sample .
it is thus important to study the correlation between the lfs and the galaxy sizes colour ( paper i ; mannucci et al .
2005 ) . ] , and investigate whether the lfs we derived are biased because of this deficit . figure 13 shows the correlation of the lfs of sne ia with galaxy sizes .
the top panel shows the lfs for the total sne in the e sab ( left ) and sb irr ( right ) galaxies , while the middle and bottom panels split the lfs into two host - galaxy size bins according to their @xmath61-band luminosities , with roughly equal numbers of sne in each bin . galaxy size does not play a significant role in the lfs of sne ia : k
- s tests do not provide strong evidence for a significant difference in the two lfs for different galaxy sizes .
we note that the bigger sb irr galaxies host more sne in the two most luminous bins and the bins at around @xmath5 mag than the smaller galaxies , suggesting a possible more extreme lf in the bigger galaxies .
the total number of sne in the sn ibc lf sample is small ( 28.9 ) . while we do not find any significant difference in the lfs for the galaxies with different sizes , the constraint is not strong due to small - number statistics .
figure 14 shows the correlation of the lfs of sne ii with galaxy sizes .
no significant difference is found for the early - type spirals , with the sne in the two lfs coming from the same population at a @xmath62% probability .
for the late - type spirals , this probability is @xmath63% , suggesting a rather significant difference .
even when the sne fainter than @xmath14 mag are not considered , the probability is still small ( @xmath64% ) .
the sne ii in the bigger late - type spirals are on average brighter than those in the smaller galaxies ( the average is @xmath65 [ @xmath66 and @xmath67 [ @xmath68 , respectively ) .
inspection of the sne in the two lfs suggests that the difference is likely caused by the different composition of subclasses .
for the 18 sne ii in the smaller late - type spirals , there are 3 sne iib , 4 sne iin , and 11 sne ii - p , while for the 19 sne ii in the bigger late - type spirals , there are 2 sne iib , 3 sne ii - l , and 14 sne ii - p .
thus , it appears that sne iin might prefer smaller galaxies while sne ii - l prefer bigger galaxies ( but keep in mind the small - number statistics ) .
when only sne
ii - p are considered , no significant difference is found in the two lfs . in summary , we have not found a significant correlation between the lfs of sne and their host - galaxy sizes , although some subclasses of sne may have a preference to occur in certain galaxy sizes among some hubble types .
more discussion of this topic can be found in 5.4 .
it is of interest to check the lfs of sne in galaxies having different inclinations , and to investigate the effect of inclination on the amount of extinction the sne experienced in their host galaxies . for this purpose ,
the lf sne are split into three inclination bins ( @xmath69 [ hereafter ,
face - on " ] , @xmath70 [ hereafter , inclined " ] , and @xmath71 [ hereafter ,
edge - on " ] ) , and their lfs are plotted in figure 15 .
only the sne occurring in spiral galaxies ( types 3 to 7 ) are considered because the inclination is not meaningful for an early elliptical or irregular galaxy , as discussed in paper i. because of the limitation of the total number of sne in the lf sample , several lfs suffer from small - number statistics , especially sne ia and ibc in the face - on bin , and sne ibc in the edge - on bin .
the lfs of sne ia do not show a significant difference in the three inclination bins , as reflected in the average absolute magnitudes in table 6 and the k - s test results .
the inclined and the edge - on bins both have a reasonable number of sne ( 33.4 and 18.2 , respectively ) .
moreover , because of the extraordinary luminosity of sne ia , our survey should have missed very few objects ( even for sne with moderate to high , but not extreme , extinction ) , as indicated by the small corrections to 100% completeness .
thus , perhaps surprisingly ( given that many sne ia occur in young to intermediate - age populations ; e.g. , maoz et al .
2011 , and references therein ) , our data do not provide strong evidence for more extinction in more highly inclined galaxies for sne ia .
the lfs of sne ibc show a strong trend in the three inclination bins : the average absolute magnitude is the brightest in the face - on bin and the faintest in the edge - on bin .
this is consistent with more extinction in more inclined galaxies .
however , both the face - on and edge - on bins suffer from small - number statistics .
the lfs of sne ii have reasonable numbers of sne in all three inclination bins .
an unexpected result is that the lf for the objects with intermediate host - galaxy inclination ( @xmath70 ) shows a significant difference from the lfs in the other two inclination bins , with an average absolute magnitude that is 0.70.9 mag brighter ( table 6 ) .
this difference becomes insignificant when only the objects brighter than @xmath14 mag are considered .
the lfs in the face - on and edge - on bins , on the other hand , show no significant difference .
thus , the lfs of sne ii do not provide evidence for more extinction in more highly inclined galaxies , in contrast with expectations .
we note that the lfs of sne ii in the different inclination bins could be affected by different subclass distributions .
to investigate this , we plot the lfs of the most common subclass in figure 15 ( sne ii - p ; shaded histogram ) .
as can be seen , the sn ii - p lfs exhibit a trend similar to that of the total sn ii lfs .
overall , our data do not provide evidence for more extinction in more highly inclined galaxies , a puzzling result .
we emphasise , however , that because of small - number statistics and the deviation from poisson statistics ( due to the use of the corrected numbers of sne ) , this result should be considered preliminary and needs to be checked with a significantly larger sample .
for example , the lowest luminosity bin in the face - on sn ii lf has a corrected number of sne of 5.4 , but it contains only two observed objects , sne 1999br and 2002hh . when these two sne are not considered , the lfs in the face - on and the @xmath70 bins do not show a significant difference and the lf in the edge - on bin is on average fainter by @xmath72 mag , consistent with a trend due to extinction . since this is the first census of the subclasses for a complete sample of sne , it is of interest to compare the lfs of different subclasses , as shown in figure 16 .
the lfs of the different subclasses of sne ia show apparent differences .
as expected , sn 1991bg - like objects are subluminous , while sn 1991t - like objects are overluminous .
the two groups of normal sne ia with different expansion velocities exhibit a marginal 23@xmath28 difference , as indicated by the cumulative fractions shown in the top panel .
the lf of sne iahv is more skewed toward luminous objects , while it also has more objects at the faintest end . as discussed by wang et al .
( 2009 ) , sne iahv may have a different reddening law or colour evolution , and on average seem to suffer more extinction than sne ian .
in fact , the two sne in the faintest bin of the sn iahv lf are sn 1999cl ( blondin et al .
2009 ) and sn 2006x ( wang et al . 2008 ) , both highly reddened objects .
thus , sne iahv may be among the intrinsically brightest sne ia , though small - number statistics must be kept in mind .
sne ib appear to have a different lf ( brighter with a smaller scatter ) than sne ic ( the averages are @xmath73 mag [ @xmath74 and @xmath75 mag [ @xmath76 , respectively ) . however , this result is based on small - number statistics ( as reflected by the error bars of the cumulative fractions shown in the top panel ) , and as discussed in 3.2 , the classification of sne ibc into subclasses is still quite uncertain . more objects with definitive spectral classifications
are needed to verify this result .
the peculiar sne ibc are represented by only a small number of objects and exhibit a wide range of luminosities .
the different subclasses of sne ii have significant differences in their lfs .
the least to most luminous subclasses are sne ii - p ( with an average absolute magnitude of @xmath77 [ @xmath26 ] ) , sne iib ( @xmath79 [ @xmath80 ) , sne iin ( @xmath81 [ @xmath82 ) , and sne ii - l ( @xmath83 [ @xmath84 ) . the lf of sne ii - p is different from that of the other three subclasses ( even when the objects fainter than @xmath14 mag are not considered ) , while there is no significant difference between sne iib and ii - l .
sne iin have a wide range of luminosities , including several of the most luminous objects . to investigate whether the different subclasses of sne have any preference in their host - galaxy hubble types , we show the distribution in figure 17 . while the cc sne display significant differences in their lfs , their host - galaxy hubble - type distributions do not exhibit any significant differences . for sne ia ,
only sn 1991bg - like objects show a significant difference in their host - galaxy hubble - type distribution : they have a strong preference to occur in elliptical and early - type spiral galaxies .
sn 1991t - like objects , generally thought to have a strong preference to occur in spiral galaxies , are represented by only 5 objects in our lf sn sample , so their host - galaxy distribution is not well constrained .
we also note that the host galaxy of sn 1998es , a sn 1991t - like object , may be misclassified as an early s0 galaxy .
van den bergh , li , & filippenko ( 2002 ) , for example , classified the galaxy as an early - type spiral galaxy ( sab in the ddo system ) .
paper i discussed the host - galaxy properties of the full sn sample , in particular the hubble - type distribution ( its 4.2.3 and figure 5 ) . here
we examine the host - galaxy properties for the sne in the lf sample .
figure 18 illustrates the histograms for the hubble - type distribution , the @xmath85 colour , and the absolute @xmath61-band luminosity @xmath86 .
the top panels show the statistics for the `` full - nosmall '' galaxy sample , while the lower panels display the statistics for the hosts of sne ia , sne ibc , and sne ii , respectively .
the histograms for the individual sn types are drawn with solid lines for the lf sne , while the dashed lines are for the `` season - nosmall '' sn sample , scaled to the same number of sne as in the lf sample .
we note that in general , the host galaxies of individual sn types display significant differences in their properties compared to the `` full - nosmall '' galaxy sample .
this suggests that the different sn types have some degree of preference to occur in certain types of host galaxies .
the sn ia host galaxies are more skewed toward red @xmath85 colours and high @xmath61-band luminosities .
the cc sne , on the other hand , prefer galaxies with late hubble types , blue @xmath85 colours , and low @xmath61 luminosities . for a given type of sn
, there are notable differences between the sne in the season - nosmall ( dashed lines ) and lf ( solid lines ) samples .
overall , the host galaxies of the `` season - nosmall '' sn sample tend to be skewed toward earlier - type , redder , and more luminous galaxies .
this is likely caused by the evolution of the galaxy properties over distance in our sample due to selection biases , as discussed in paper i. the `` season - nosmall '' sn sample includes many sne that occurred in the galaxies that are more distant than the cutoff distance for the lf sn sample , which , as discussed in 4.2.4 and figure 4 of paper i , have a higher fraction of bright , early - type galaxies than the more nearby galaxies .
the sn ia hosts in general have properties that differ from those of the cc sn hosts .
the sn ibc and sn ii hosts , on the other hand , have similar distributions for the hubble types and @xmath85 colours , but different @xmath86 distributions ( with a 1.8% probability of coming from the same population ) .
the host galaxies of sne ii are typically less luminous than those of sne ibc , with the average @xmath87 mag ( @xmath88 mag ) and @xmath89 mag ( @xmath90 mag ) , respectively . if sne ibc come from a similar population of massive stars ( perhaps in binary systems ) as those producing sne ii , their preference to occur in more luminous galaxies may indicate a metallicity effect ( e.g. , tremonti et al .
2004 ) on the evolution of massive stars , such as by affecting the line - driven winds for the massive star that eventually explodes as the sn ( vink et al . 2001 ; heger et al . 2003 ; vink & de koter 2005 ; crowther 2007 ) .
our suggestion that sne ibc occur in galaxies of higher luminosity or metallicity than sne ii is consistent with the findings of prantzos & boissier ( 2003 ) , prieto , stanek , & beacom ( 2008 ) , and boissier & prantzos ( 2009 ) .
we also investigate whether the different sn subclasses have different host - galaxy @xmath86 distributions . for sne ia , the only significant difference is found between the host galaxies of the sne ian and sne ia-91bg subclasses , with the hosts of sne ia-91bg being more luminous on average due to the dominance of earlier hubble types .
the results for the cc sn subclasses are shown in figure 19 .
the left panels display the histograms of the @xmath86 distributions while the right panel shows the cumulative fractions .
several subclasses still suffer from small - number statistics ; nevertheless , we find the following trends with varying significance . 1 .
no significant difference is found between the host galaxies of sne ii - p and ii - l , though the total number of sne ii - l is small ( 7.5 ) .
no significant difference is found between the host galaxies of sne ib and ic , with a 28.0% probability that they come from the same population .
the average @xmath86 of the hosts of sne ib ( @xmath91 mag [ @xmath92 mag ] ) appears to be marginally more luminous than the hosts of sne ic ( @xmath93 mag [ @xmath94 mag ] ) . in the cumulative fraction plot ,
the two subclasses are combined .
3 . the host galaxies of sne iib are more luminous than those of sne ii - p , with a 6.9% probability that they come from the same population .
the average @xmath86 values are @xmath95 mag ( @xmath96 mag ) and @xmath97 mag ( @xmath98 mag ) , respectively .
furthermore , there is a relatively high probability ( 68.5% ) that the host galaxies of sne iib and ibc come from the same population , as can be seen by the similar cumulative fraction curves in the right - hand panel of figure 19 .
the host galaxies of sne iin are less luminous than those of sne ii - p , with a 10.3% probability that they come from the same population .
the average @xmath86 value is @xmath99 mag ( @xmath100 mag ) for the sn iin host galaxies .
as discussed in paper i , the loss galaxy sample involves several selection biases , and is not complete at the low - luminosity end .
nevertheless , since all of the sne were discovered in the same set of galaxies and thus suffer from the same selection biases , the above trends still reveal the general preference for the different subclasses of sne in terms of host - galaxy @xmath61-band luminosities .
recently , arcavi et al . (
2010 ) reported on the statistics of 70 cc sne found by ptf and suggested that there might be an excess of sne iib and ib in dwarf galaxies , which differs from our finding that the host galaxies of both subclasses prefer more luminous galaxies .
as ptf is conducting an untargeted , magnitude - limited survey and monitors numerous dwarf galaxies , the study by arcavi et al .
( 2010 ) is complementary to ours .
the differences in the results might be caused by the relatively small numbers of objects in both studies , although poisson statistics have nominally been taken into account .
perhaps the discrepancy is related to the dissimilar analysis methods ; we study the differences in the @xmath86 distributions of the sn host galaxies , while arcavi et al .
( 2010 ) divided the galaxies into two categories ( giant / dwarf ) and analysed the fractions of the different sn subclasses .
further studies are needed to verify the apparent discrepancy between the two results .
one limiting factor of our lfs is the total number of sne in the sample .
although much effort has been made to analyse the data for the 175 sne in our lf sample , many analyses still face small - number statistics , such as the lfs for the different subclasses of sne .
as shown in figure 4 , the cutoff distance for the sn ia lf sample can be increased to 120 mpc to include more sne without introducing large corrections due to incompleteness . for the cc
sne , the inclusion of the data in the years 20072008 will help increase the sample in the lf .
we are in the process of reducing more data to continue working along these directions , and the results will be published in a future paper .
another limiting factor of our lfs is that they are only available for the @xmath3 band . for sne ia
, a significant fraction of the lf sne have been followed in @xmath101 , and the multi - colour lfs will be presented in a future paper . for sne ibc and sne ii ,
only a small fraction of the lf sne have filtered follow - up photometry , so determining their multi - colour lfs is not possible at this time .
it will require considerable effort to obtain filtered photometry for all of the relatively low - luminosity cc sne in either a volume - limited or magnitude - limited survey to construct the lfs in different passbands .
one concern is that the lfs we derived only apply to our galaxy sample with its specific hubble type , colour , and luminosity distributions .
as discussed in detail in paper i , however , the galaxy sample within the cutoff distance for the lfs is probably _ representative _ of galaxies with moderate and large sizes , and only has an apparent deficit for small galaxies .
this deficit may cause our lfs to be biased against those sne having a preference to occur in small galaxies . in our study , we only find a possible preference for sne iin to occur in small , late - type spiral galaxies .
we excluded the sne that occurred in small ( major axis @xmath102 ) , early - type galaxies because of uncertainties in the detection efficiencies .
one concern is whether this exclusion introduces an observational bias .
no sne ibc or ii are excluded because cc sne in early - type galaxies are rare ( 4.2.3 in paper i ) . for sne
ia , only two objects ( sne 2000dk [ ian ] and 2006h [ ia-91bg ] ) are excluded .
considering that the total sn ia lf has 74 sne ia , the inclusion of the two additional sne will have negligible effect on the overall properties of the sn ia lf .
one important question is whether there is a sizable fraction of highly reddened sne that are missed in our search .
some sne certainly experience a large amount of extinction ; for example , the sn ia 2002cv mag brighter than our typical limiting magnitude . ]
( di paola et al . 2002 ; elias - rosa et al . 2008 ) has @xmath103 mag , while the sn ii - p 2002hh suffered @xmath104 mag ( pozzo et al .
searches done at near - infrared and radio wavelengths also suggest that the vast majority of sne in massive _ starburst _ galaxies , such as luminous infrared galaxies ( lirgs ) and ultraluminous infrared galaxies ( ulirgs ) , are missed by the optical searches due to dust obscuration ( e.g. , mannucci et al . 2003 ) .
we argue , however , that our lfs are not significantly affected by host - galaxy extinction for the following reasons .
first , lirgs / ulirgs constitute only a very small fraction of the galaxy population.l@xmath105 ) . ]
second , for a non - starburst galaxy , although the theoretical studies of hatano et al .
( 1998 ) and riello & patat ( 2005 ) suggest that sne should experience more extinction in more highly inclined galaxies , our investigation of the lfs in different inclination bins ( 5.2 ) does not provide strong supporting evidence .
third , statistics provided by the observed sn sample ( jha et al . 2006a ; hicken et al . 2009 ) indicate that the majority of the observed sne ia do not suffer significant amounts of extinction .
finally , our own lfs provide additional evidence for the scarcity of highly reddened events : only a few of the 175 sne in the lf sample suffer a large amount of extinction ( sne 2001ci , 2002hh , 2003bk , 2003cg , and 2005bb ) . for our typical search limiting magnitude of 19
, we can detect sne brighter than @xmath106 , @xmath107 , and @xmath108 mag within 20 , 30 , and 60 mpc , respectively .
these are several magnitudes fainter than the average sne in the lf , so we should have discovered many more moderately reddened objects ( @xmath109 of a few mag ) near our detection limit if highly reddened sne were quite common .
we conclude that our lfs are not significantly affected by the missing sne due to high extinction in the targeted sample galaxies .
our lf data ( tables and template light curves ) are made available to interested parties electronically .
these lfs have the following potential applications . 1 .
the lfs can be used to calculate the control times for the different types of sne in a sn search , which is a critical step in deriving the sn rates .
this is the main motivation for our study .
paper iii will discuss the details of how the lfs are used to calculate the control times in our sn search .
any other sn searches conducted without filters or using a passband that is similar to @xmath3 could use our lfs to help with the control - time and/or survey - completeness calculation .
a major advantage of using our lfs to calculate the control times is that they are pseudo - observed " and account for the poorly known host - galaxy extinction .
2 . the lfs can be used to simulate the expected sn subclass and brightness distribution in a sn search ( with known cadence and depth ) , to help the coordination of follow - up efforts . for this purpose ,
the sn rates derived in paper iii are needed as well .
the lfs , the light - curve distributions , and the observed subclass fractions can be used as priors in a photometry - based classification scheme , as in poznanski et al . ( 2002 ) and poznanski , maoz , & gal - yam ( 2007 ) .
4 . the lfs can be used to constrain the possible progenitor systems and their evolutionary paths for the different types of sne .
viable models should be able to explain both the luminosity distribution and the various subclass fractions ( e.g. , smith et al . 2011a ) .
historically , sn rate calculations have been plagued by two issues : the intrinsic luminosity distribution of sne and the host - galaxy extinction toward sne .
in other words , the calculations were limited by our knowledge of the _ observed _ luminosity functions of sne . in this paper ii of a series aimed to derive a precise nearby sn rate from the lick observatory sn search ,
a volume - limited sn sample is constructed for the first time , and the observed luminosity functions of sne are derived .
we first select a volume - limited sample of 175 sne ( with a cutoff distance of 80 mpc for sne ia , and 60 mpc for sne ibc and sne ii ) , and then collect photometry for _ every _ object .
families of light curves for each sn type are constructed from the literature and/or our own photometry database , and are used to fit the light curves of the sne , to generate peak absolute magnitude and light - curve shape distributions .
we further study the completeness of each sn in the lf , and correct them to 100% completeness within the considered volume .
the volume - limited lfs of sne indicate that a gaussian scatter around an average luminosity is generally not a good representation of the data .
there are also significant differences for the lfs in different host - galaxy hubble types .
for sne ia , the sne in e sab galaxies are generally fainter than those in sb irr galaxies due to the prominence of subluminous sn 1991bg - like objects in the former galaxies . for sne ibc ,
the objects in early - type spirals are , on average , slightly fainter than those in late - type spirals . for sne ii ,
the objects in early - type spirals are , on average , brighter than those in late - type spirals .
these observed trends have significant implications for their possible progenitor systems and evolutionary paths .
we also have detailed subclass information for all sne in the lf sample .
while spectral series are adequate to classify sne ia and ibc into different subclasses , detailed light - curve information is necessary to discriminate the different subclasses of sne ii , especially sne ii - p , ii - l , and iib . in a volume - limited sample ,
sne ii are the most abundant type ( 57% of all ) , while sne ia and ibc constitute 24% and 19% , respectively . for sne ia ,
normal objects are 70% of all , sn 1991bg - like objects are 18% , and the rest are sn 1991t - like and sn 2002cx - like objects ( 12% ) .
the normal sne ia are further split into objects with normal ( 50% ) and high ( 20% ) expansion velocities .
sne ic are the most abundant sne ibc ( 54% of all ) , while sne ii - p are the most abundant sne ii ( 70% of all ) . among sne ii
, there are significant fractions of sne ii - l , iib , and iin ( 10% , 12% , and 9% , respectively ) .
we further derive the observed lfs and sn subclass fractions for an ideal magnitude - limited search ( i.e. , with a short observation interval ) by scaling the sne with their survey volume .
compared to the volume - limited lfs , the magnitude - limited lfs have an enhanced fraction of luminous objects , as well as reduced scatter in the average luminosity
. the observed fractions of sne have also dramatically changed .
sne ia are the most numerous sne ( 79% ) of the three types , while the fractions of the core - collapse sne shrink to 17% and 4% for sne ii and ibc , respectively . within sne ia ,
normal sne ia are 77% of all , and sn 1991t - like objects are boosted to 18% .
sne ibc become as abundant as sne ic among the sne ibc .
the fractions of sne ii - l , iib , and iin are enhanced due to their higher luminosities than those of sne ii - p .
we compare our predicted subclass fractions to two observed magnitude - limited samples , one in the random background galaxies in our own search , and the other from ptf , and find good agreement .
we also investigate the effect of the observation interval in a magnitude - limited search on the observed lfs and sn fractions .
searches done with an observation interval smaller than 10 d have similar lfs and sn fractions , and discover a high fraction of the sne in an ideal magnitude - limited search . when the observation interval is long , the fractions for the sne with relatively slow light curves are enhanced . in a search with a very long interval ( or a single snapshot ) , only @xmath110% of the sne in an ideal magnitude - limited search are discovered , and sne ii - p become the dominant subclass ( 40% of the total ) among sne ii .
we discuss how the lfs we derived change with different environments and subclasses of sne . we have not found a persistent correlation between the lfs of sne and their host - galaxy sizes ,
although some subclasses of sne seem to have a preference to occur in certain galaxy sizes in some hubble types ( e.g. , sne iin prefer small , late - spiral galaxies ) .
surprisingly , the lfs in galaxies of different inclination do not provide strong evidence in support of greater extinction toward sne in more highly inclined galaxies .
the different subclasses of sne display significant differences in their lfs . for sne
ia , the sn 1991bg - like objects are subluminous , while the sn 1991t - like objects are overluminous .
the normal sne ia with high expansion velocities display a more extreme lf than the normal sne ia having normal expansion velocities , suggesting that they may belong to two distinct groups .
sne ib are , on average , more luminous and have a smaller scatter than sne ic , but this result should be reexamined in a larger sample with more definitive spectral identifications than our current sample .
the least to most luminous sne ii are ii - p , iib , iin , and ii - l . despite the significant difference in the lfs , the different subclasses of core - collapse sne show similar host - galaxy hubble - type distributions . for sne ia , sn 1991bg - like objects prefer to occur in elliptical and early - type spiral galaxies .
we note that some of these results have been found in previous work ( e.g. , della valle & livio 1994 ; hamuy et al .
1996 ; howell 2001 ; jha et al .
2006a ) .
we also compare the host - galaxy properties of the lf sne , and find a significant difference in the galaxy luminosity distributions for sne ii and ibc .
sne ibc prefer more massive galaxies than sne ii , suggesting an influence of metallicity on the mass - loss history in their evolution .
we also find that sne iib prefer more massive galaxies than sne ii - p , while sne iin prefer less massive galaxies .
we discuss possible limitations of our lfs ; small - number statistics are the primary one .
caution should be used when applying our lfs to low - luminosity galaxies , but our lfs do not appear to be seriously affected by sne missing due to large extinction .
our lfs can be used to help with sn rate determinations for any searches using a passband similar to the @xmath3 band .
other applications of the lfs are to coordinate follow - up efforts in large surveys , help photometry - based classification methods , and constrain viable models for the sne .
we thank the referee , enrico cappellaro , for useful comments and suggestions which improved the paper .
we are grateful to the many students , postdocs , and other collaborators who have contributed to the katzman automatic imaging telescope and the lick observatory supernova search over the past two decades , and to discussions concerning the determination of supernova rates especially frank serduke , jeffrey silverman , thea steele , and richard r. treffers .
we thank the lick observatory staff for their assistance with the operation of kait .
loss , conducted by a.v.f.s group , has been supported by many grants from the us national science foundation ( nsf ; most recently ast-0607485 and ast-0908886 ) , the tabasgo foundation , us department of energy scidac grant de - fc02 - 06er41453 , and us department of energy grant de - fg02 - 08er41563 .
kait and its ongoing operation were made possible by donations from sun microsystems , inc .
, the hewlett - packard company , autoscope corporation , lick observatory , the nsf , the university of california , the sylvia & jim katzman foundation , and the tabasgo foundation .
we give particular thanks to russell m. genet , who made kait possible with his initial special gift ; former lick director joseph s. miller , who allowed kait to be placed at lick observatory and provided staff support ; and the tabasgo foundation , without which this work would not have been completed .
j.l . is grateful for a fellowship from the nasa postdoctoral program .
is supported by an einstein fellowship . x.w .
acknowledges nsfc grants ( 10673007 , 11073013 ) and the china-973 program 2009cb824800 .
m.m . acknowledges nsf grants ast-0205808 and ast-0606772 , as well as the miller institute for basic research in science ( uc berkeley ) , for support during the time over which part of this work was conducted .
we made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with nasa .
we acknowledge use of the hyperleda database ( http://leda.univ-lyon1.fr ) .
arcavi i. , et al .
2010 , apj , 721 , 777 barbon r. , ciatti f. , rosino l. 1979 , a&a , 72 , 287 barbon r. , cappellaro e. , turatto m. 1989 , a&as , 81 , 421 barbon r. , buond v. , cappellaro e. , turatto m. 1999 , a&as , 139 , 531 barris b. j. , tonry j. l. 2006 , apj , 637 , 427 bazin g. , et al .
2009 , a&a , 499 , 653 benetti s. , cappellaro e. , turatto m. , pastorello a. 2000 , iau circ .
, 7375 , 2 blanc g. , et al .
2004 , a&a , 423 , 881 blondin s. , modjaz m. , kirshner r. , challis p. , berlind p. 2006
, iau circ .
, 8680 , 2 blondin s. , prieto j. l. , patat f. , challis p. , hicken m. , kirshner r. p. , matheson t. , modjaz m. 2009 , apj , 693 , 207 blondin s. , tonry j. l. 2007 , apj , 666 , 1024 boissier s. , prantzos n. 2009 , a&a , 503 , 137 botticella m. t. , et al .
2008 , a&a , 479 , 49 cappellaro e. , turatto m. , benetti s. , tsvetkov d. yu .
, bartunov o. s. , makarova i. n. 1993 , a&a , 268 , 472 cappellaro e. , evans r. , turatto , m. 1999 , a&a , 351 , 459 ( c99 ) chevalier r. a. , soderberg a. m. 2010 , apj , 711 , l40 clocchiatti a. , wheeler j. c. 1997 , apj , 491 , 375 crowther p. a. 2007 , ara&a , 45 , 177 della valle m. , livio m. 1994 , apj , 423 , l31 dilday b. , et al .
2008 , apj , 682 , 262 di paola a. , larionov v. , arkharov a. , bernardi f. , caratti o garatti a. , dolci m. , di carlo e. , valentini g. 2002 , a&a , 393 , l21 drake a. j. , et al .
2010 , apj , 718 , l127 elias - rosa n. , et al .
2008 , mnras , 384 , 107 fassia a. , et al .
2000 , mnras , 318 , 1093 filippenko a. v. 1988 , aj , 96 , 1941 filippenko a. v. 1997 , ara&a , 35 , 309 filippenko a. v. 2003 , in from twilight to highlight : the physics of supernovae , ed . w. hillebrandt & b. leibundgut ( berlin : springer - verlag ) , 171 filippenko a. v. , et al . 1992a , apj , 384 , l15 filippenko a. v. , et al . 1992b ,
aj , 104 , 1543 foley r. j. , brown p. j. , rest a. , challis p. j. , kirshner r. p. , wood - vasey w. m. 2010a , apj , 708 , l61 foley r. j. , narayan g. , challis p. j. , filippenko a. v. , kirshner r. p. , silverman j. m. , & steele t. n. 2010b , apj , 708 , 1748 foley r. j. , wong d. s. , ganeshalingam , m. , filippenko a. v. , chornock r. 2004 , iau circ .
, 8339 , 2 foley r. j. , et al .
2003 , pasp , 115 , 1220 foley r. j. , et al . 2009a , aj , 137 , 3731 foley r. j. , et al .
2009b , aj , 138 , 376 foley , r. j. , et al .
2010c , aj , 140 , 1321 galama t. j. , et al .
1998 , nature , 395 , 670 gal - yam a. , et al .
2007 , apj , 656 , 372 gal - yam a. , maoz d. , guhathakurta p. , filippenko a. v. 2008 , apj , 680 , 550 ganeshalingam m. , et al .
2010 , apjs , 190 , 418 ganeshalingam m. , et al .
2011 , in prep .
garnavich p. m. , et al .
2004 , apj , 613 , 1120 gehrels n. 1986 , apj , 303 , 336 gezari s. , et al .
2009 , apj , 690 , 1313 hamuy m. , phillips m. m. , suntzeff n. b. , schommer r. a. , maza j. , aviles r. 1996 , aj , 112 , 2391 hamuy m. 2003 , apj , 582 , 905 hamuy m. , roth m. 2003 , iau circ .
, 8228 , 2 hardin d. , et al . 2000 ,
a&a , 362 , 419 hatano k. , branch d. , deaton j. 1998 , apj , 502 , 177 heger a. , fryer c. l. , woosley s. e. , langer n. , hartmann d. h. 2003 , apj , 591 , 288 hicken m. , et al . 2009 , apj , 700 , 331 horesh a. , poznanski d. , ofek e. o. , maoz d. 2008 , mnras , 389 , 1871 howell d. a. 2001 , apj , 554 , l193 howell d. a. , et al .
2006 , nature , 443 , 308 jha s. , et al . 2006a , aj , 131 , 527 jha s. , branch d. , chornock r. , foley r. j. , li w. , swift b. j. , casebeer d. , filippenko a. v. 2006b , aj , 132 , 189 kaiser n. , et al .
2002 , proc .
spie , 4836 , 154 kasliwal m. m. , et al .
2009 , cbet , 1820 , 2 law n. m. , et al . 2009 ,
pasp , 121 , 1395 leaman j. , li w. , chornock r. , & filippenko a. v. 2011 , mnras , submitted ( arxiv:1006.4611 ) ( paper i ) leibundgut b. , tammann g. a. , cadonau r. , cerrito d. 1991 , a&as , 89 , 537 leibundgut b. , et al .
1993 , aj , 105 , 301 leonard d. c. , cenko s. b. 2005 , the astronomer s telegram , 431 , 1 leonard d. c. , chornock r. , filippenko a. v. 2003 , iau circ .
, 8144 , 2 li w. , filippenko a. v. , chornock r. , jha s. 2003a , pasp , 115 , 844 li w. , filippenko a. v. , riess a. g. 2001 , apj , 546 , 719 li w. , filippenko a. v. , treffers r. r. , riess a. g. , hu j. , qiu y. 2001b , apj , 546 , 734 li w. , et al .
2001a , pasp , 113 , 1178 li w. , et al .
2003b , pasp , 115 , 453 li w. , chornock r. , leaman j. , filippenko a. v. , poznanski d. , wang x. , ganeshalingam m. , mannucci f. 2011 , mnras , submitted ( arxiv:1006.4612 ) ( paper iii ) li w. , et al . 2011b , in prep .
lira p. , et al .
1998 , aj , 115 , 234 mannucci f. , et al .
2003 , a&a , 401 , 519 mannucci f. , della valle m. , panagia n. , cappellaro e. , cresci g. , maiolino r. , petrosian a. , turatto m. 2005 , a&a , 433 , 807 maoz d. , mannucci f. , li w. , filippenko , a. v. , della valle m. , panagia n. 2011 , mnras , in press ( arxiv:1002.3056 ) matheson t. , et al .
2000 , aj , 120 , 1487 matheson t. , et al .
2003 , apj , 599 , 394 mcclelland , c. m. , et al .
2010 , apj , 720 , 704 miller a. a. , et al .
2009 , apj , 690 , 1303 modjaz m. , et al . 2006 ,
apj , 645 , l21 modjaz m. 2007 , ph.d .
thesis , harvard university modjaz m. , et al .
2009 , apj , 702 , 226 monet d. g. , et al .
2003 , aj , 125 , 984 narayan , g. , et al .
2011 , submitted ( arxiv:1008.4353 ) neill j. d. , et al .
2006 , aj , 132 , 1126 ofek e. o. , et al .
2007 , apj , 659 , l13 pain r. , et al .
2002 , apj , 577 , 120 pastorello a. , et al .
2002 , mnras , 333 , 27 pastorello a. , et al .
2004 , mnras , 347 , 74 perets h. b. , et al .
2010 , nature , 465 , 322 phillips m. m. 1993 , apj , 413 , l105 phillips m. m. , wells l. a. , suntzeff n. b. , hamuy m. , leibundgut b. , kirshner r. p. , foltz c. b. 1992 , aj , 103 , 1632 phillips m. m. , et al .
2007 , pasp , 119 , 360 pian e. , et al .
2006 , nature , 442 , 1011 poznanski d. , gal - yam a. , maoz d. , filippenko a. v. , leonard d. c. , matheson t. 2002 , pasp , 114 , 833 poznanski d. , et al .
2007 , mnras , 382 , 1169 poznanski d. , maoz d. , gal - yam a. 2007 , aj , 134 , 1285 poznanski d. , et al .
2009 , apj , 694 , 1067 pozzo m. , et al .
2006 , mnras , 368 , 1169 prantzos n. , boissier s. 2003 , a&a , 406 , 259 prieto j. l. , stanek k. z. , beacom j. f. 2008 , apj , 673 , 999 qiu y. , li w. , qiao q. , hu j. 1999 , aj , 117 , 736 quimby r. m. , aldering g. , wheeler j. c. , hflich p. , akerlof c. w. , rykoff e. s. 2007 , apj , 668 , l99 quimby r. , et al .
2009 , the astronomer s telegram , 2005 , 1 rest a. , et al .
2009 , submitted ( arxiv:0911.2002 ) riello m. , patat f. 2005 , mnras , 362 , 671 richardson d. , branch d. , casebeer d. , millard j. , thomas r. c. , baron e. 2002 , aj , 123 , 745 richmond m. w. , treffers r. r. , filippenko a. v. , paik y. , leibundgut b. , schulman e. , cox c. v. 1994 , aj , 107 , 1022 richmond m. w. , et al .
1996 , aj , 111 , 327 riess a. g. , et al .
2009 , apj , 699 , 539 sanders d. b. , mazzarella j. m. , kim d .- c .
, surace j. a. , soifer b. t. 2003 , aj , 126 , 1607 schlegel d. j. , finkbeiner d. p. , davis m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 silverman j. m. , et al .
2011 , in prep .
singer d. , beutler b. , swift b. , li w. , yamaoka h. , itagaki k. 2003 , iau circ .
, 8201 , 1 smartt s. j. , eldridge j. j. , crockett r. m. , maund j. r. 2009 , mnras , 395 , 1409 smith n. , et al .
2007 , apj , 666 , 1116 smith n. , chornock r. , li w. , ganeshalingam m. , silverman j. m. , foley r. j. , filippenko a. v. , barth a. j. 2008 , apj , 686 , 467 smith n. , et al .
2011a , mnras , press ( arxiv:1006.3899 ) smith n. , et al .
2011b , mnras , submitted ( arxiv:1010.3718 ) soderberg a. m. , et al .
2008 , nature , 453 , 469 sollerman j. , cumming r. j. , lundqvist p. 1998 ,
apj , 493 , 933 spergel d. n. , et al .
2007 , apjs , 170 , 377 sullivan m. , et al .
2006 , apj , 648 , 868 tremonti c. a. , et al .
2004 , apj , 613 , 898 turatto m. , cappellaro e. , danziger i. j. , benetti s. , gouiffes c. , della valle m. 1993 , mnras , 262 , 128 valenti s. , et al .
2009 , nature , 459 , 674 van den bergh s. , li w. , filippenko a. v. 2002 , pasp , 114 , 820 van dyk s. d. , peng c. y. , king j. y. , filippenko a. v. , treffers r. r. , li w. , richmond m. w. 2000 , pasp , 112 , 1532 vink j. s. , de koter a. , lamers h. j. g. l. m. 2001 , a&a , 369 , 574 vink j. s. , de koter a. 2005 , a&a , 442 , 587 wang x. , et al .
2008 , apj , 675 , 626 wang x. , et al .
2009 , apj , 699 , l139 waxman e. , mszros p. , & campana s. 2007 , apj , 667 , 351 wheeler , j. c. , et al .
1993 , apj , 417 , l71 young t. r. , branch d. 1989 , apj , 342 , l79 | this is the second paper of a series in which we present new measurements of the observed rates of supernovae ( sne ) in the local universe , determined from the lick observatory supernova search ( loss ) . in this paper , a complete sn sample
is constructed , and the observed ( uncorrected for host - galaxy extinction ) luminosity functions ( lfs ) of sne are derived .
these lfs solve two issues that have plagued previous rate calculations for nearby sne : the luminosity distribution of sne and the host - galaxy extinction .
we select a volume - limited sample of 175 sne , collect photometry for every object , and fit a family of light curves to constrain the peak magnitudes and light - curve shapes .
the volume - limited lfs show that they are not well represented by a gaussian distribution .
there are notable differences in the lfs for galaxies of different hubble types ( especially for sne ia ) .
we derive the observed fractions for the different subclasses in a complete sn sample , and find significant fractions of sne ii - l ( 10% ) , iib ( 12% ) , and iin ( 9% ) in the sn ii sample .
furthermore , we derive the lfs and the observed fractions of different sn subclasses in a magnitude - limited survey with different observation intervals , and find that the lfs are enhanced at the high - luminosity end and appear more standard " with smaller scatter , and that the lfs and fractions of sne do not change significantly when the observation interval is shorter than 10 d. we also discuss the lfs in different galaxy sizes and inclinations , and for different sn subclasses .
some notable results are that there is not a strong correlation between the sn lfs and the host - galaxy size , but there might be a preference for sne iin to occur in small , late - type spiral galaxies .
the lfs in different inclination bins do not provide strong evidence for extreme extinction in highly inclined galaxies , though the sample is still small .
the lfs of different sn subclasses show significant differences .
we also find that sne ibc and iib come from more luminous galaxies than sne ii - p , while sne iin come from less luminous galaxies , suggesting a possible metallicity effect .
the limitations and applications of our lfs are also discussed .
supernovae : general supernovae : rates |
a basic problem in the physics of finite fermion systems such as , e.g. , atoms , nuclei , helium clusters , metal clusters , or semiconductor quantum dots , is the determination of the ground - state energy @xmath1 .
a standard decomposition , deeply rooted in the connection of classical and quantum physics , is to write @xmath1 as the sum of an average energy @xmath2 and a fluctuating part @xmath3 @xcite : @xmath4 the largest contribution , @xmath2 , is a smooth function of the number @xmath0 of fermions .
the shell correction @xmath3 has a pure quantal origin and displays , instead , an oscillatory behavior as a function of @xmath0 . equation ( [ eq1 ] ) underlies the usefulness of the so - called mass formulae , like the liquid drop model for nuclei or for metal clusters , of which the oldest example is the well - known bethe - von weizscker mass formula for the binding energy of nuclei .
the decomposition ( [ eq1 ] ) is also at the basis of semiclassical and statistical techniques that are used to investigate how the properties of global character of fermion systems vary with the particle number @xmath0 .
such is the case for instance of the celebrated thomas - fermi and wigner - kirkwood theories @xcite .
these methods often provide deep physical insights which may be otherwise obscured behind a full quantum calculation .
it is recognized , however , that the semiclassical calculations of @xmath5 for fermion systems in either external potentials or self - consistent mean fields show systematic deviations with respect to the actual average of the exact quantum results @xcite .
for example , in spherically symmetric calculations one finds that , as a function of the number @xmath0 of particles , the difference @xmath6 between the ( fluctuating ) exact value @xmath7 and the ( smooth ) semiclassical average @xmath5 _ does not _
oscillate around zero .
in general , for fermions in a fixed external potential , semiclassical calculations overbind the true average of the quantum energy .
one of our purposes in the present work is to explain the origin of this effect , and to derive an explicit formula that allows to compute the correct average behavior of @xmath7 in fermion systems .
related studies are the works of refs .
@xcite where a particle number conserving shell correction method has been pursued .
additional contributions to the average part of the ground - state energy come in fact from a careful analysis of the oscillatory term @xmath8 .
because this fluctuating function is evaluated at discrete values of the chemical potential ( that correspond to integer values of the particle number ) , its average value is generically non - zero and therefore contributes to the average part of @xmath9 .
this phenomenon is related to the different physical descriptions of quantum mechanical systems obtained from different thermodynamic ensembles , the grand canonical and the canonical in the present context .
this subtle topic has played , in recent years , a crucial role in understanding the physics of , e.g. , persistent currents in mesoscopic metallic rings @xcite , or in trapped bose - einstein condensates @xcite .
our results are illustrated with two schematic models .
namely , we study the average of @xmath9 for fermions in a harmonic oscillator ( ho ) potential , via the semiclassical wigner - kirkwood ( wk ) theory @xcite , and for fermions in a spherical cavity with sharp boundaries , via the weyl expansion @xcite . in the former case ,
analytical expressions are available . finally , and in contrast to the previous examples where the confining potential is fixed , we consider the influence of deformations and self - consistency on the average behavior of @xmath9 , as well as other related topics .
we find that for self - consistent potentials with deformation degrees of freedom the behavior of the average energy is qualitatively different .
the usual computation of the different terms in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) is as follows .
the single - particle level density @xmath10 $ ] of a quantum fermion system can be expressed as @xcite @xmath11 in terms of the phase space wigner function @xmath12 .
we have included a factor 2 to account for spin degeneracy .
then , for a set of fermions in a potential well filled up to an energy @xmath13 , the number of states ( accumulated level density ) and the ground - state energy are obtained from @xmath14 through @xmath15 inserting the wigner - kirkwood expansion of the wigner function @xmath16 in powers of @xmath17 in eq .
( [ eq14 ] ) produces a smooth function @xmath18 , where the leading order gives rise to the thomas - fermi term .
this procedure is well documented in the literature @xcite . inserting the latter series for @xmath19 into eq .
( [ eq13 ] ) yields the semiclassical @xmath17 expansions for @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
alternatively , for a fermi gas contained in a hard wall cavity , one inserts in eqs .
( [ eq13 ] ) the corresponding weyl expansion @xcite of the average single - particle level density @xmath18 . in both cases ,
eqs.([eq13 ] ) produce a series in decreasing powers of @xmath13 whose coefficients depend on the shape of the potential . these expressions provide in general accurate descriptions of the average behavior of @xmath14 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 . for instance , for an isotropic three dimensional ho potential of frequency @xmath24 one
obtains the well - known wk expressions @xcite @xmath25 \frac{1}{\hbar \omega } + \frac{17}{960 } \ , \hbar \omega \ , \delta^{\,\prime}(\varepsilon ) \
, , \label{eq19 } \\ { \bar{\cal n}}(\mu ) & = & \frac{1}{3 } \bigg(\frac{\mu}{\hbar \omega}\bigg)^3 - \frac{1}{4 } \frac{\mu}{\hbar \omega } \ , , \label{eq20 } \\ { \bar{e}}(\mu ) & = & \bigg [ \frac{1}{4 } \bigg(\frac{\mu}{\hbar \omega}\bigg)^4 - \frac{1}{8 } \bigg(\frac{\mu}{\hbar \omega}\bigg)^2 - \frac{17}{960 } \bigg ] \hbar \omega \ , .
\label{eq21 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the last term in eq .
( [ eq19 ] ) contains the derivative of the delta function @xmath26 .
this term and the last term in eq.([eq21 ] ) stem from the corrections of order @xmath27 to @xmath28 and @xmath2 , respectively . in the ho potential
the @xmath27 contribution to @xmath29 vanishes .
figure [ figure1 ] displays the comparison between the exact quantum mechanical quantities and the smooth approximations ( [ eq20])([eq21 ] ) .
the upper panel shows the accumulated level density @xmath22 for a set of fermions in a spherical ho potential , as a function of @xmath30 .
the quantum result exhibits discontinuities at each major shell ( @xmath31 , 8 , 20 , 40 , 70 , 112 in the present case ) and is represented by a staircase function which fluctuates around the smooth wk curve provided by eq .
( [ eq20 ] ) .
the oscillatory part of @xmath22 ( dashed curve ) contains the fluctuations due to shell effects .
they are seen to oscillate around zero , with a vanishing net average , as @xmath13 is varied .
the lower panel of fig .
[ figure1 ] displays the ground state energy @xmath32 for the same potential @xcite .
again , the smooth wk curve excellently averages the quantum result and the shell energy fluctuates around zero .
accumulated level density ( upper panel ) and total energy ( lower panel ) with spin - degeneracy 2 for a spherical ho potential as a function of chemical potential @xmath13 .
staircase , solid , and dashed lines correspond to the quantum , semiclassical wk , and shell correction ( quantum minus semiclassical ) values , respectively . ]
the fact that the average behavior of the remaining shell corrections is zero for @xmath23 and @xmath22 can be explicitly checked .
the general semiclassical theory expresses the fluctuating parts @xmath33 and @xmath34 as sums over the classical periodic orbits of the system at energy @xmath13 @xcite .
each term in @xmath35 and @xmath36 is an oscillatory function of the chemical potential ( through the action of the corresponding orbit ) , whose average over a chemical potential window is zero . in the particular case of the ho potential
the semiclassical approximation turns out to be exact ( see e.g. @xcite ) , and takes the form @xmath37 , \label{eq23 } \\
e(\mu ) \!\ ! & = & \!\ ! { \bar{e}}(\mu ) + 2 \sum_{m=1}^{\infty } \frac{(-1)^m}{m_r^4 } \big [ \big ( 3 \mu_r^2 - 6 - \textstyle{\frac{1}{4 } } m_r^2 \big ) \cos \mu_r \nonumber \\ & & \mbox { } + \big ( \mu_r^2 - 6 - \textstyle{\frac{1}{4 } } m_r^2 \big ) \mu_r
\sin \mu_r \big ] \hbar \omega , \label{eq24 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath38 , @xmath39 , and @xmath20 and @xmath21 are given by eqs .
( [ eq20 ] ) and ( [ eq21 ] ) , respectively .
these expressions illustrate explicitly that the average of the fluctuating parts @xmath35 and @xmath36 over a chemical potential window is zero , @xmath40 . in real physical fermi gases with a well defined number of particles the various quantities , like masses or many - body level densities , are not studied as a function of the chemical potential @xmath13 but rather as a function of the particle number @xmath0 .
for instance , the ground - state energy @xmath9 of the system consists in the sum of the single - particle energies of the @xmath0 lowest single - particle states ( taking into account spin - degeneracy ) . thus eqs.([eq23 ] ) and ( [ eq24 ] ) are related to the grand canonical ensemble .
the qualitative behavior of the function @xmath7 as a function of @xmath0 is in general quite different from the behavior of @xmath23 . based on e.g. the wigner - kirkwood method , the usual way to calculate the function @xmath7 is as follows
. having determined , in that approximation , the energy @xmath21 and the accumulated level density @xmath20 , one first fixes the chemical potential ( or fermi energy ) in terms of the particle - number @xmath0 by inverting the function @xmath41 to be consistent in the notation , we use @xmath42 to denote the value of the chemical potential for a given @xmath0 determined from the wk ( or weyl ) approximation , to stress that , in this approximation , @xmath13 is computed by inverting the smooth part @xmath29 and not the exact counting function @xmath43 .
finally , one obtains the smooth wigner - kirkwood or weyl term @xmath5 replacing @xmath13 by @xmath42 in @xmath21 , @xmath44 for example , applying this procedure to the isotropic ho potential , from the leading terms of eqs .
( [ eq20 ] ) and ( [ eq21 ] ) one straightforwardly obtains @xmath45 which is the leading - order thomas - fermi result .
it shows that in a ho the leading dependence of the average energy per particle , in units of @xmath46 , is @xmath47 .
the full wigner - kirkwood function @xmath48 computed for the ho potential including up to the fourth - order contributions in @xmath17 is plotted in fig .
[ figure2 ] ( dashed line ) as a function of the particle number @xmath0 , in units of @xmath46 .
it is compared to the exact quantum result ( solid line ) .
to better visualize the quantum oscillations with changing @xmath0 , we have subtracted the dominant @xmath49 dependence [ recall eq .
( [ eq25 ] ) ] from _ both _ the quantum and the wk curves .
the upper panel of fig .
[ figure2 ] displays the results for the isotropic ho potential .
the lower panel is for a strongly deformed potential and it will be discussed later on . focusing on the isotropic ho , one sees that , as expected , the general trend of the smooth wk result turns out to be quite correct in comparison with the global particle number dependence of the quantum energies .
there is , however , a systematic deviation in the sense that the wk curve does not pass as a function of @xmath0 through the average of the quantum values .
this is clearly seen from the large asymmetry of the shaded regions above and below the wk curve in the upper panel of fig .
[ figure2 ] .
one notices that the wk result overbinds with respect to the true average of the quantum values when @xmath0 is varied in the spherical symmetry .
the same situation prevails in other problems of atomic and nuclear physics as well as in self - consistent mean field calculations @xcite .
upper panel : quantum and wk values of the energy per particle for a spherical ho potential as a function of the number of particles , in units of @xmath50 . the leading @xmath0-dependence given by eq .
( [ eq25 ] ) is subtracted from _ both _ curves .
lower panel : the same as in the upper panel but for a strongly triaxially deformed ho potential .
notice that the wk curves are different in the spherical and deformed cases . ]
the previous results show that the function @xmath5 does not describe appropriately the average behavior of @xmath7 .
we now discuss the origin of the discrepancy , and the way to correct it . in systems with a well defined number of particles the chemical potential @xmath13 takes discrete values .
these values do not occur at random .
for instance , for an even number of particles and non - degenerate single - particle states , a standard rule is to locate the chemical potential half - way between the last occupied and the first unoccupied single - particle states . fixing a particular rule to determine the chemical potential at a given number of particles introduces a bias in the sampling of the values of @xmath13 ( with respect to a uniform , random distribution of @xmath13 ) . due to this bias , when the oscillatory part of the energy @xmath35 is evaluated over the set of discrete points it produces , generically , a function whose
average is different from zero . to compute that average we proceed as follows .
the decomposition of the single - particle level density into a smooth part and a fluctuating part , @xmath51 where @xmath18 is the wk ( or weyl ) smooth part and @xmath52 is given by the sum over periodic orbits mentioned above @xcite , induces a corresponding decomposition of the integrated density [ cf eq .
( [ eq13 ] ) ] : @xmath53 for a given number of particles @xmath0 , the chemical potential is defined by inversion of the exact accumulated level density @xmath54 as the particle number @xmath0 increases , it is natural to decompose the chemical potential into smooth and fluctuating parts : @xmath55 the average part @xmath42 satisfies eq .
( [ 106 ] ) . assuming that @xmath56 , a taylor expansion of the smooth part in powers of @xmath57 around @xmath58 in eq .
( [ 107 ] ) ( no taylor expansion is allowed for the fluctuating term @xmath59 , because it is not a regular function ) yields , to lowest order , @xmath60 where we denote @xmath61 similarly , the energy may be decomposed as @xmath62 in a system with a well - defined number of particles , the smooth part @xmath5 of the exact function @xmath63 was defined in ( [ 108 ] ) , @xmath64 .
the fluctuating part is thus defined as @xmath65 in order to compute @xmath8 , and in particular its average over some particle - number window @xmath66 around @xmath0 , it is convenient to express the energy in terms of the grand potential @xmath67 using the thermodynamic relation @xmath68 recalling the definition of @xmath69 and @xmath42 [ eqs .
( [ 106 ] ) and ( [ 110 ] ) ] , eq.([111 ] ) may be written @xmath70 where @xmath71 .
decomposing @xmath72 into its average and fluctuating parts , expanding @xmath73 around @xmath74 to second order in @xmath57 , and using the thermodynamic relations @xmath75 we get @xmath76 using eq .
( [ 101 ] ) , this takes the form @xmath77 equation ( [ 102 ] ) connects the fluctuations of the grand potential ( grand - canonical ensemble ) to those of the energy at a fixed number of particles ( canonical ensemble ) .
this connection , to lowest order , has been exploited in recent years to analyze nuclear - mass fluctuations @xcite .
one may be tempted to think that the average of @xmath8 over some particle - number window @xmath66 around @xmath0 , denoted @xmath78 , is proportional , from eq .
( [ 102 ] ) , to the variance @xmath79 of @xmath80 , and that the average of @xmath7 , @xmath81 is thus lowered with respect to @xmath5 ( due to the minus sign in front of @xmath82 in eq.([102 ] ) ) .
however this is wrong because , for the same reasons as for @xmath8 , the average @xmath83 .
a detailed calculation ( cf the appendix ) shows that @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the variance of the spacing @xmath86 between two consecutive single - particle levels around @xmath87 .
taking the average with respect to the discrete points @xmath69 in eq.([102 ] ) , using eq .
( [ 103 ] ) for the average of @xmath88 and expressing , for convenience , the average @xmath79 over the discrete points @xmath69 in terms of the average @xmath89 over the continuous variable @xmath13 around @xmath69 ( cf the appendix ) , @xmath90 we get @xmath91 the final expression for the average value of the energy in a system conserving the number of particles is , according to eqs .
( [ eav ] ) and ( [ 104 ] ) , @xmath92 it follows from eq .
( [ 105 ] ) that , with respect to the wk or weyl smooth terms , the true average of the energy as a function of @xmath0 is _ increased _ by a term proportional to the variance of the accumulated level density . equation ( [ 105 ] ) contains all the relevant information on the average , and allows to understand the numerical results presented above . before making a quantitative comparison
, we first discuss the general aspects involved in that equation .
quantum and wk values of the energy per particle in a triaxially deformed ho potential .
spin degeneracy is included . ]
equation ( [ 103 ] ) is demonstrated in the appendix for a system without degeneracies ( intrinsic and/or due to spin ) .
however , it is easy to see that it is also valid in the presence of degeneracies .
this is because the thermodynamic quantities we are considering are continuous variables of a given set of external parameters @xmath93 .
assume that for some @xmath94 degeneracies occur , and that for slightly different values @xmath95 all the degeneracies are lifted ( for instance , some of the components of @xmath93 may be associated to a shape deformation , with @xmath96 the spherical case , and another component may be a magnetic field that lifts the spin degeneracy , with @xmath97 no magnetic field ) . then for @xmath95 eq .
( [ 103 ] ) is valid .
one can therefore consider the case with degeneracies as the limit @xmath98 and , by continuity , eq .
( [ 103 ] ) remains valid .
upper panel : normalized fluctuating part @xmath99 as a function of @xmath0 for a spherical cavity . @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the radius of the sphere and @xmath102 is the mass of fermions .
lower panel : average @xmath103 of the fluctuating function in the upper panel ( full line ) compared to the theoretical prediction , eq .
( [ 104 ] ) ( dashed line ) . ]
the variance @xmath104 in eq .
( [ 105 ] ) depends on the system under consideration
. however , its general properties can easily be determined . in systems where the typical size of the fluctuations is important
, then the shift of the true average @xmath105 with respect to @xmath5 will also be important .
on the other hand , in systems with small fluctuations , @xmath106 will be small , and the term @xmath5 will give not only a good approximation to @xmath105 , but also to @xmath7 as well ( since fluctuations are small ) .
in general , the more regular and/or symmetric a system is , the greater the fluctuations are , and the larger the correction @xmath107 will be .
as the regularities or symmetries are broken , the typical size of the fluctuations diminishes , and @xmath108 will be well approximated by @xmath5 .
this point is illustrated in fig .
[ figure2 ] , where the upper panel shows @xmath109 for the isotropic ho , where large fluctuations are observed and clear deviations of the average with respect to @xmath5 are found .
in contrast , the lower panel shows a strongly deformed ho , with frequencies @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 ( @xmath113 ) , where small fluctuations are observed , and as a consequence good agreement between @xmath109 and @xmath48 is found .
another manifestation of the same phenomenon is provided in fig .
[ figure4 ] , where @xmath109 is shown for @xmath114 fermions ( with spin degeneracy ) in a triaxially deformed ho potential as a function of the deformation parameter @xmath115 , where @xmath116 , @xmath117 , and @xmath118 , with @xmath119 and @xmath120 .
we see that for most deformations ( mid - shell configurations ) the quantum and the smooth wk values practically agree , up to small fluctuations .
large deviations are observed , instead , when sphericity is approached , and for other special deformations , e.g. , for @xmath121 where the frequency ratio @xmath122 is close to @xmath123 ( when the three frequencies @xmath124 , @xmath125 , and @xmath126 are integer ratios , the energy levels of the ho are degenerate and the classical trajectories of the hamiltonian become closed periodic orbits @xcite ) . we have made a quantitative check of eqs .
( [ 104 ] ) and ( [ 105 ] ) for the case of a fermi gas in a spherical cavity . the upper panel of fig .
[ figure3 ] represents the fluctuating part @xmath8 as a function of @xmath0 , defined in eq .
( [ 111 ] ) . a clear structure organized in shells ( rapid oscillations ) and supershells ( long - range modulation of the rapid oscillations ) is observed .
the lower panel shows a comparison between the average @xmath127 calculated numerically from the upper panel of that figure and the result obtained from eq .
( [ 104 ] ) as a function of @xmath0 .
the average shows a nontrivial dependence with the particle number ( which reflects , to a large extent , the supershell structure ) , that is very well reproduced by theory .
upper panel : fluctuating part @xmath128 as a function of @xmath0 for a 3d isotropic ho .
lower panel : average @xmath127 of the fluctuating function in the upper panel ( full line ) compared to the theoretical prediction , eq.([eq30 ] ) ( dashed line ) . ] in the case of the spherical ho , it is possible to get easily an analytical expression for @xmath129 .
the function @xmath36 is given by the second term in the right hand side of eq.([eq23 ] ) . squaring it , the main contribution to @xmath130 comes from terms where both indices of the double sum are equal .
hence to leading order in @xmath13 , we get : @xmath131 @xmath104 is calculated by averaging over the rapidly fluctuating factors , given by the sine terms .
this yields @xmath132 since @xmath133 is a smooth function , we replace @xmath13 by @xmath134 .
thus we can use the wk expression eq .
( [ eq20 ] ) to compute the dependence of the variance with the number of particles .
using moreover eq .
( [ eq19 ] ) we finally get , to leading order in @xmath0 , @xmath135 a comparison with the numerical average of @xmath8 , obtained from an isotropic 3d ho , is presented in fig .
[ figure5 ] .
the result shows an excellent agreement ; compared to the spherical cavity , a much simpler @xmath0 dependence is observed , due to the absence of supershells .
based on general properties of the single - particle spectrum , it is possible to estimate the typical size of the variance @xmath104 and of its @xmath0 dependence for a large class of systems , and therefore to estimate @xmath129 .
the relevant classification relies on the type of classical dynamics associated to the confining potential .
the two extreme cases that can be treated explicitly are fully regular and fully chaotic dynamics ( the case of mixed dynamics is more subtle ) . based on this classification , explicit results for the typical size of @xmath104 were obtained in ref . @xcite .
up to now we have considered fermion systems confined by an external potential .
this may be applicable to e.g. quantum dot systems or magnetically trapped atomic gases where the self - consistent mean field part plays a minor role with respect to the external confining potential
. however , many relevant systems are self bound and then the mean field potential is essentially given by the solution of the self - consistent hartree - fock equations which are obtained by minimising the energy of the system .
the mean field in these situations may turn out to be spherical , but in many cases rotational invariance will be broken and the mean field becomes deformed .
we will see that in these cases the results can show interesting differences with regard to the scenario found in the upper panel of fig .
[ figure2 ] or in fig .
[ figure5 ] for the harmonic oscillator , and in fig .
[ figure3 ] for the hard wall cavity , where the potential was kept spherical .
we want to investigate such cases now . first , to illustrate the situation
, we again consider the ho potential .
in contrast to the previous section , for each particle number we now minimise the ground - state energy of the quantum solution with respect to deformation , i.e. , with respect to free variation of @xmath124 , @xmath125 , and @xmath126 , under the constraint of volume conservation ( @xmath136 ) . this must be done in carefully checking simultaneously the optimal choice of the occupancies @xmath137 .
the semiclassical energies @xmath5 always have their absolute minimum at sphericity as given by eq.([eq21 ] ) . as a particular example of self - bound system
, we consider the case of the atomic nuclei .
we mimic the saturation properties of nuclear forces by including the standard particle - number dependence of the ho frequency @xmath138 mev @xcite with @xmath139 ( i.e. , @xmath140 here represents the mass number of a hypothetical uncharged nucleus with @xmath0 protons and @xmath0 neutrons ) .
difference between the minimised ground state energy with respect to deformations and the spherical wk energy @xmath5 for fermions in a ho potential ( squares joined by full line ) .
for comparison , the dotted curve shows the energy difference for an isotropic ho ( same curve as in the upper part of fig .
[ figure5 ] ) .
the average of both curves is shown by a long - dashed line .
the scaling @xmath141 mev has been used in the calculations . ] in fig .
[ figure6 ] we show the difference @xmath142 between the fully minimised quantum energies and the corresponding isotropic semiclassical expression @xmath5 obtained from eqs .
( [ eq20 ] ) and ( [ eq21 ] ) . for comparison
, we include in the same figure the fluctuating part @xmath8 for the spherical ho ( same curve as in the upper part of fig .
[ figure5 ] ) .
we observe that with respect to the purely spherical case , the situation changes very much . now , contrary to the spherical case , practically all values of @xmath142 from the minimised quantum solutions are negative , meaning that the minimised quantum energies stay _ below _ the semiclassical curve @xmath5 .
the minimised quantum energies coincide with the spherical ones only in a small neighborhood around the shell closures , whereas away from the latter the system is axially deformed or even , around the middle of the shells , a slight triaxiality can appear ( in the case of axial symmetry , typical deformations show an axis ratio of 2:3 ) .
it seems natural that the deformed quantum energies are more bound than the approximate energies obtained from the semiclassical theory , in spite of the fact that to our knowledge no upper bound theorem like the rayleigh - ritz principle exists for the semiclassical approach .
we wish to point out that in fig .
[ figure6 ] for most values of @xmath0 the system is actually rather well deformed and that , with the exception of a couple of particle numbers around closed shells , the energy differences are in most cases very close to the zero line , i.e. , to the semiclassical wk values .
this is consistent with the results obtained in the previous section , where it was shown that for deformed systems where degeneracies are lifted the energy @xmath9 is expected to be well approximated by the wk theory .
the magnitude of the difference @xmath142 of the minimised quantum solutions to the semiclassical values slightly increases with increasing particle number , as the average curve shows in fig .
[ figure6 ] .
however , the magnitude of the same quantity @xmath142 divided by the particle number decreases as a function of increasing @xmath0 , and the minimised deformed quantum energies per particle are extremely close to the semiclassical ones .
notice the opposite trend in fig .
[ figure6 ] of the two average curves , with and without energy minimisation .
in contrast to the latter case , for which an explicit formula for the average behavior was developed and successfully checked in the previous section , we do not yet have an equivalent result for a self - bound system .
we are interested in checking whether this simplified harmonic oscillator scenario remains valid in realistic hartree - fock - type mean field calculations . in ref .
@xcite self - consistent calculations of the ground - state binding energy of atomic nuclei were carried out using the variational wigner - kirkwood method @xcite .
the nuclear interaction was described by the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) meson exchange model @xcite .
quantum calculations for the rmf model are available in the literature .
in particular , a mass table of deformed ( axially symmetric ) quantum calculations for nuclei with an accurately calibrated rmf nuclear interaction is published in ref.@xcite . from this table
we took for each value of the mass number @xmath140 the _ most bound _
( in general deformed ) isotope and traced @xmath143 as a function of @xmath140 @xcite .
the quantum values together with the rmf semiclassical results , computed following ref .
@xcite , are shown in fig .
[ figure7 ] for nuclei with an even number of protons and neutrons .
most of the wk energies lie on top of the deformed quantum energies on the scale of the figure .
we plot in addition the rmf quantum values constrained to sphericity .
the typical arch structure found in fig .
[ figure2 ] for the spherical ho potential is then recovered .
these arches in nuclei take place between the so - called magic numbers , i.e. , the proton or neutron numbers where effects analogous to the shell closures of the ho or of the electron shells in atoms occur .
the fact that for nuclei above iron @xmath143 raises whereas in fig . [ figure2 ] it keeps decreasing is a trivial effect due to the coulomb repulsion among protons in the atomic nucleus .
energy per particle of atomic nuclei with an even number of protons and of neutrons along the periodic table , as obtained from self - consistent relativistic mean field calculations .
the deformed calculations are from ref .
@xcite . for each value of the mass number @xmath140 we plot the most bound isotope according to the tabulation of ref .
@xcite ( excepting for @xmath144 @xcite ) . ] in fig .
[ figure8 ] we display for the self - consistent rmf the difference @xmath142 between the quantum energies ( that are , as mentioned , minimised with respect to deformation ) and the corresponding semiclassical values ( that attain their absolute minima at sphericity ) . for reference , also the values of the energy difference @xmath142 obtained from experimental data @xcite instead of the quantum results are displayed .
the similarity of fig .
[ figure8 ] with fig .
[ figure6 ] for the ho is striking .
systems with the largest deformations are again located mostly around mid shells .
when the system approaches the spherical shape , @xmath142 becomes increasingly negative and displays the downward peaks seen in fig .
[ figure8 ] on reaching neutron or proton magic numbers .
it is clear that in the self - consistent case as in the schematic case of the ho with optimized shapes considered above , the average of @xmath142 as a function of particle number is , at least for the heavier systems , negative . in self - bound systems
we again find that in between shells the quantum energies are closer to the semiclassical wk values . in between shells
the system deforms in search of minimum energy and avoids the large positive shell corrections to the energy that occur if a spherical shape is kept . as the deformation increases
, symmetries are broken and the amplitude of the shell corrections diminishes .
this is in agreement with the basic ideas underlying eq .
( [ 105 ] ) , that imply an energy @xmath7 which is well approximated by the wk theory .
in this work we have revisited the old problem of the semiclassical approach to finite fermion systems , based either on the wigner - kirkwood expansion with @xmath17 corrections , or the weyl expansion .
we have addressed the nature of one of the most elusive features of the theory , namely the systematic overbinding compared to the quantum average for fermions in fixed potentials .
energy difference between the deformed quantum solutions and the wk values of fig
. 7 for the self - consistent relativistic nuclear mean field .
the result obtained by taking the difference of the experimental data @xcite to the calculated wk energies is also shown for the purpose of illustration .
the location of the magic neutron ( @xmath0 ) and proton ( @xmath145 ) numbers is indicated . ] in the first part , we have shown that this discrepancy is due to the fact that these methods do not incorporate appropriately the conservation of the particle number .
there is , generically , a contribution to the average ground - state energy that comes from the fluctuating part , or shell contribution .
we derived an explicit formula that takes into account that contribution , and have tested it for different fixed confining potentials . in all cases , a positive correction with respect to the semiclassical result is predicted [ cf eq .
( [ 105 ] ) ] , whose magnitude depends on the size of the shell effects .
when the confining potential has symmetries , the shell corrections are large , and important deviations between the exact quantum and the wk energies are observed , in agreement with our predictions .
in contrast , when symmetries are broken shell effects are smaller , and the exact energies ( and not only their average part ) are better described by the wk theory .
the description of the behavior of self - bound systems is more difficult and subtle , because at each particle number @xmath0 the energy is minimised , and hence the shape of the potential is a function of @xmath0 . in this case , a shell correction which is nearly always negative with respect to the spherical wk result is observed for the ho potential . in between shells , when the system deforms and symmetries are broken , the value of the shell correction is smaller , and the energy is well approximated by the wk theory , in agreement with the general considerations that follow from eq .
( [ 105 ] ) . interestingly , all these features have been qualitatively confirmed by a more realistic model based on a mean - field self - consistent calculation of the ground - state energy of atomic nuclei .
however , the problem of deriving an explicit formula for the average behavior of the ground - state energy of self - bound systems that correctly takes into account the @xmath0-dependence with deformation degrees of freedom is still open .
we are indebted to r. k. bhaduri and o. bohigas for valuable informations .
work partially supported by in2p3-cicyt .
x.v . and m.c .
acknowledge grants no .
fis2005 - 03142 ( mec , spain , and feder ) and no .
2005sgr-00343 ( generalitat de catalunya ) . p. l. and j.
r. acknowledge support from grants aci nanoscience 201 , anr nt05 - 2 - 42103 , anr-05-nano-008 - 02 and the ifraf institute .
we follow here appendix b of ref .
@xcite in order to prove eqs .
( [ 103 ] ) and ( [ 112 ] ) .
let us consider a single - particle spectrum @xmath146 , with @xmath147 and @xmath148 .
the accumulated level density @xmath22 is discontinuous at each energy level . at the discontinuity
, we assign to @xmath22 the `` intermediate '' value @xmath149 . for @xmath150 and @xmath151 , writing @xmath152 , making a taylor expansion of @xmath20 around @xmath153 , and using that @xmath149 , we may write @xmath154 evaluating this relation just before @xmath155 , and taking into account the value of the function at @xmath156 , we have @xmath157 where @xmath158 is the level spacing ( we neglect the dependence of @xmath28 with energy ) . taking the discrete average over @xmath0 on both sides of eq .
( [ a2 ] ) , defined as @xmath159 where @xmath66 is the number of levels in the window around the @xmath0th level , and using that @xmath160 , we obtain the ( trivial ) relation @xmath161 . on the other hand , defining the continuous average over a window @xmath162 of a function that depends on the chemical potential as @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the number of levels in the window , we have from eq .
( [ a1 ] ) @xmath165 \ d \mu \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{\delta n}{\delta \mu } \left ( \langle { \widetilde{\cal n}}(\varepsilon_{\scriptscriptstyle n } ) s_{\scriptscriptstyle
n } \rangle_{\scriptscriptstyle n }
+ \frac{\langle s_{\scriptscriptstyle n } \rangle_{\scriptscriptstyle n}}{2 } - \frac{{\bar{g}}}{2 } \langle s_{\scriptscriptstyle n}^2 \rangle_{\scriptscriptstyle n } \right ) \nonumber \\ & = & { \bar{g}}\left ( \langle { \widetilde{\cal n}}(\varepsilon_{\scriptscriptstyle n } )
s_{\scriptscriptstyle n } \rangle_{\scriptscriptstyle n } + \frac{1}{2 { \bar{g } } } - \frac{{\bar{g}}}{2 } \langle s_{\scriptscriptstyle n}^2 \rangle_{\scriptscriptstyle n } \right ) = 0 \ . \label{a3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the last equality follows because @xmath166 by definition . from eq .
( [ a3 ] ) we deduce @xmath167 squaring and computing the discrete average in both sides of eq .
( [ a2 ] ) it is possible to deduce that @xmath168 after using eq .
( [ a3b ] ) . similarly , squaring eq .
( [ a1 ] ) and computing in both sides the continuous average it is possible to relate the continuous variance of @xmath36 with discrete averages @xmath169 computing the discrete average of the third power of eq .
( [ a2 ] ) , the previous expression for the continuous variance is considerably simplified and gives @xmath170 we are now interested in the statistics at the discrete points @xmath171 . from eq .
( [ a1 ] ) we have @xmath172 from which it is easy to deduce that @xmath173 . from the discrete average of the square of eq .
( [ a6 ] ) , using the result ( [ a3b ] ) as well as eq .
( [ a5 ] ) , it follows that @xmath174 we have demonstrated eq .
( [ 112 ] ) .
let us now consider the grand potential for @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
since @xmath175 , using eq .
( [ a1 ] ) and integrating we get @xmath176 noting that @xmath177 is a continuous function , eq .
( [ a8 ] ) at @xmath178 gives @xmath179 in a similar way as it was done for the accumulated level density , by integration of eq .
( [ a8 ] ) ( knowing that @xmath180 ) , and discrete average of the product of eq .
( [ a2 ] ) and eq .
( [ a9 ] ) , we deduce @xmath181 from eq .
( [ a8 ] ) , for @xmath182 , we have @xmath183 the discrete average of this equation , together with eqs .
( [ a3b ] ) and ( [ a10 ] ) , finally leads to @xmath184 this equation , together with eq .
( [ a7 ] ) , implies eq .
( [ 103 ] ) .
99 m. brack and r. k. bhaduri , _ semiclassical physics _
( addison - wesley , reading , ma , 1997 ) .
p. ring and p. schuck , _ the nuclear many - body problem _ ( springer - verlag , berlin , 1980 ) . v. m. strutinsky , nucl .
* a95 * 420 ( 1967 ) ; nucl .
a122 * 1 ( 1968 ) . n. h. march , _ self - consistent fields in atoms _ , ( pergamon , oxford , 1975 ) .
o. bohigas , x. campi , h. krivine , and j. treiner , phys .
* b64 * , 381 ( 1976 ) .
petkov and m. v. stoitsov , _ nuclear density functional theory _
( clarendon press , oxford , 1991 ) .
m. centelles , x. vias , m. barranco , and p. schuck , ann .
( n.y . ) * 221 * , 165 ( 1993 ) .
m. centelles , p. schuck , and x. vias , nucl - th/0601092 . f. a. ivanyuk and v. m. strutinsky , z. phys .
a * 293 * , 337 ( 1979 ) ; f. a. ivanyuk , z. phys .
a * 316 * , 233 ( 1984 ) .
k. pomorski , phys .
* c70 * , 044306 ( 2004 ) b. l. altshuler , y. gefen , and y. imry phys .
rev . lett .
* 66 * ( 1991 ) 88 .
s. grossmann and m. holthaus phys .
* 79 * ( 1997 ) 3557 e. wigner , phys .
rev . * 40 * , 749 ( 1932 ) ; j. g. kirkwood , phys .
rev . * 44 * , 31 ( 1933 ) ; g. e. uhlenbeck and e. beth , physica * 3 * , 729 ( 1936 ) . h. p. baltes and e. r. hilf , _ spectra of finite systems _
, bibliographisches institut - wissenschaftsverlag , mannheim , 1976 .
r. k. bhaduri and c. k. ross , phys .
* 27 * , 606 ( 1971 ) .
m. brack and h. c. pauli , nucl .
* a207 * , 401 ( 1973 ) . b. k. jennings , nucl .
* a207 * , 538 ( 1973 ) . b. k. jennings , r. k. bhaduri , and m. brack .
* a253 * , 29 ( 1975 ) .
we use the notation @xmath185 , @xmath186 , etc . to indicate the total , average , and fluctuating parts of each magnitude .
however , in the axis labels of the figures where different approximations are compared , we shall write only @xmath1 , @xmath43 , etc . r. balian and c. bloch , ann .
( n.y . ) * 69 * ( 1972 ) 76 .
m. c. gutzwiller , j. math .
phys . * 10 * ( 1969 ) 1004 .
p. leboeuf , lect .
notes phys .
* 652 * , 245 ( 2004 ) , and nucl - th/0406064 .
m. brack and s. r. jain , phys .
rev . * a51 * , 3462 ( 1995 ) .
o. bohigas and p. leboeuf , phys .
rev . lett .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 092502 ; 129903 .
h. olofsson , s. berg , o. bohigas , and p. leboeuf phys .
* 96 * ( 2006 ) 042502 .
p. leboeuf and a. g. monastra , ann .
( ny ) * 297 * ( 2002 ) 127 .
m. centelles , x. vias , m. durand , p. schuck , and d. von - eiff , ann . phys .
( ny ) * 266 * , 207 ( 1998 ) .
b. d. serot and j. d. walecka , adv .
* 16 * , 1 ( 1986 ) .
g. a. lalazissis , s. raman , and p. ring , at .
data nuc .
data tables * 71 * , 1 ( 1999 ) .
we have made an exception to the rule of selecting the most bound isotope for each mass number in the case of @xmath144 .
the most bound @xmath144 nucleus is @xmath187ar ( @xmath188 ) .
however , in figs .
[ figure7 ] and [ figure8 ] we display the results for @xmath187ca instead of @xmath187ar , because @xmath187ca is one of the scarce examples of a stable nucleus with a double shell closure ( @xmath189 ) . | semiclassical theories like the thomas - fermi and wigner - kirkwood methods give a good description of the smooth average part of the total energy of a fermi gas in some external potential when the chemical potential is varied .
however , in systems with a fixed number of particles @xmath0 , these methods overbind the actual average of the quantum energy as @xmath0 is varied .
we describe a theory that accounts for this effect .
numerical illustrations are discussed for fermions trapped in a harmonic oscillator potential and in a hard wall cavity , and for self - consistent calculations of atomic nuclei . in the latter case ,
the influence of deformations on the average behavior of the energy is also considered . |
[ fig : randchi]a shows the temperature dependence of in - plane resistivity , @xmath30 , down to 0.5 k at zero magnetic field . at high temperatures ( @xmath46 k )
, @xmath30 shows metallic behavior , decreasing linearly with decreasing temperature .
however , further decrease in temperature reveals a resistivity minimum , followed by a logarithmic increase due to incoherent kondo scattering . below @xmath47
k , @xmath30 drops abruptly , suggesting that this is the energy scale of either cef depopulation or kondo coherence .
we will discuss these possibilities below .
the kink in resistivity observed at @xmath48 k , shown in the top inset of fig .
1a , indicates the transition to the afm phase .
this represents a 0.3 k higher ordering temperature compared to previous studies of ceagbi@xmath1 @xcite .
although this increase in @xmath23 is somewhat small , eds measurements reveal that it is caused by a substantial decrease both in the number of vacancies and in the inhomogeneity at the ag site .
the bottom inset of fig .
1a shows the linear dependence of @xmath23 on the occupation at the ag site , @xmath49 . for the most deficient samples , with ag occupation of @xmath50% , the transition temperature matches previous studies , @xmath51 k. for the best samples obtained to date , the ag occupancy reaches @xmath52% , confirming the trend that transition - metal deficiency is an intrinsic feature of this family of compounds .
we note that less deficient samples are also accompanied by higher resistance ratios and lower residual resistivity . like other ce - based bismuthides
, ceagbi@xmath1 also exhibits magnetic anisotropy .
[ fig : randchi]b shows the temperature dependence of the inverse magnetic susceptibility , @xmath53 , when a magnetic field of @xmath14 = 1 koe is applied parallel ( @xmath54 ) and perpendicular ( @xmath55 ) to the crystallographic @xmath11-axis .
the inset of fig .
[ fig : randchi]b presents the low - temperature @xmath56 data in which a sharp peak is observed at @xmath23 .
the ratio @xmath57 at @xmath23 is mainly determined by the tetragonal cef splitting and reflects the low-@xmath4 ce@xmath58 single ion anisotropy .
this ratio is smaller than what is found in other bismuthides , suggesting a smaller cef splitting between the ground state and the first excited state as well as a less anisotropic ground state .
this scenario will be confirmed below . at high temperatures ( @xmath59 k ) ,
@xmath56 is well - described by a curie - weiss ( cw ) law plus a @xmath4-independent pauli term , @xmath60 .
we obtain an effective moment of @xmath61 for both directions and also for the polycrystalline average , in agreement with the theoretical value of @xmath62 for ce@xmath58 free ions . on the other hand ,
the @xmath63 values are anisotropic , with @xmath64 k and @xmath65 k. for the polycrystalline averaged data ( not shown ) , we obtain @xmath66 k , consistent with afm order at @xmath67 6 k. 0.85@ cccccccc + + & @xmath68 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & & @xmath71 & & @xmath72 + & -1.78 k & 0.168 k & 0.71e-3
k & & -0.89 k & & 1.35 k + + + @xmath73 & & @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 + 0 & & 0 & -1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 1 & 0 + 19 & & 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 19 & & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -1 + 61 & & 0 & 0 & -1 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 61 & & 0 & 0 & 0 & -1 & 0 & 0 + we now further explore the role of anisotropic interactions and cef effects in the magnetic properties of ceagbi@xmath1 . to this end
, we analyze the experimental data using a mean field model including two mean anisotropic interactions ( @xmath80 and @xmath81 ) between nearest - neighbors , which do not contain directional information .
we also take into account the tetragonal cef hamiltonian @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the number of nearest neighbors , @xmath84 are the cef parameters , and @xmath85 are the stevens equivalent operators obtained from the angular momentum operators . a more detailed description of the model can be found in ref .
@xcite .
this model was used to simultaneously fit @xmath56 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 data in the entire range of temperature .
the best fit which reproduces the anisotropic susceptibility is shown by solid lines in fig .
[ fig : randchi]b and the extracted parameters for the cef scheme and the exchange interactions are given in table [ tab:1 ] .
we find a @xmath88 kramers doublet ground state , separated from other excited doublets by 19 k and 60 k. we also find , in fact , ( i ) the cef splitting is much smaller as compared to other bismuthides and ( ii ) the ground state is mainly @xmath88 instead of the dominantly @xmath89 found in cecubi@xmath15 and ceaubi@xmath15 .
further , the dominant cef parameter @xmath68 obtained from the fits is similar to the value obtained using the high - temperature expansion of @xmath90 : @xmath91=-1.48 $ ] k.@xcite this result suggests that the effects of anisotropic interactions at high temperatures are smaller in ceagbi@xmath1 than in cecubi@xmath1 and ceaubi@xmath1 .
we also note that although the magnetic anisotropy and @xmath23 along the @xmath11-axis are well reproduced by our simple model , the single ion cef effect is not able to capture all field - induced transition in @xmath86 data at 1.8 k. fig . [
fig : randchi]c shows the temperature dependence of the specific heat of ceagbi@xmath1 in zero field . to determine the magnetic contribution to specific heat
, the data obtained from non - magnetic reference compound laagbi@xmath1 was subtracted from the result .
there is a single peak corresponding to t@xmath92 .
we note that this sample is from an earlier batch , so it has higher silver vacancies and a lower t@xmath92 .
the top inset of fig .
1c shows the integration of specific heat over temperature , i.e. , the recovered magnetic entropy . at t@xmath92 ,
the recovered entropy is only about 80% the ground - state doublet ( r@xmath93 ) .
we note , however , that there is a broad feature centered around 8 k , which is consistent with a schottky anomaly generated by the cef splitting of 19 k. this result indicates that the first excited cef state is already partially occupied at t@xmath92 , giving an additional entropy to the expected r@xmath93 .
therefore , the reduction of entropy is larger than 20% , although a precise calculation can not be evaluated .
it is unlikely that a reduction of entropy of more than 20% can be fully accounted for by classical magnetic fluctuations .
for example , numerical calculations of the ising model on a simple cubic lattice find an entropy reduction of just under 20% at t@xmath92 , with other three dimensional geometries showing an even smaller reduction.@xcite we thus attribute this reduction to both magnetic frustration and hybridization between ce @xmath94-electrons and conduction electrons .
this conclusion is motivated by the enhanced effect masses found in dhva experiments@xcite and the magnetic frustration that often arises from competing exchange interactions . due to the similar energy scales of the first excited cef state ( @xmath95 k ) and the peak in resistance ( @xmath96 k ) , we performed high - temperature resistance measurements in several different fields .
the results are presented in inset of fig .
if the peak near 24 k were due to crystal field depopulation , then increasing the field should lead to an increase of the energy difference between the lowest zeeman split state of the ground state and the upper zeeman split state of the first excited cef state .
this in turn would lead to an increase of the temperature of the resistance peak as the field is increased , which is in fact observed experimentally .
we note that , in heavy fermion compounds where the energy difference between kondo coherence and @xmath97 is small , the onset of kondo coherence ( @xmath98 ) usually occurs at temperatures of the order of @xmath99 .
this suggests that @xmath100 k in ceagbi@xmath15 .
however , the experimental lack of two distinct resistance maxima as is typically observed when the energy difference is large@xcite leads to an ambiguity as to whether the resistance peak is due to cef splitting of kondo coherence .
we now turn to the analysis of the low - temperature phase diagram as a function of an applied magnetic field along the @xmath11-axis .
[ fig : magandmr]a shows magnetization and ( transverse ) magnetoresistance ( mr ) of ceagbi@xmath15 at 100 mk . as the field
is swept from @xmath101 to @xmath102 koe , we find a sequence of field - induced metamagnetic transitions near @xmath103 and @xmath104 koe , indicating a complex phase diagram for @xmath105 . above the @xmath104 koe transition ,
the magnetization saturates just below @xmath106 @xmath107/ce , which is slightly lower than the saturation value of @xmath108 @xmath107/ce previously reported , and may be due to a non - linearity between the deflection of the cantilever and the corresponding change in capacitance .
such large saturated value is somewhat surprising since the largest possible @xmath11-axis magnetization of a @xmath109 cef ground state is @xmath110 , i.e. , 1.29 @xmath107/ce .
hence , our results indicate that the zeeman effect induces a change in the cef ground state from @xmath109 to @xmath111 when @xmath112 koe . .
( a ) @xmath113 ( blue ) and magnetization ( green ) versus field at 100 mk .
@xmath113 data is for both increasing and decreasing fields , showing hysteresis for transitions centered near 54 and 78 koe .
( b ) magnetization versus field for decreasing field - sweep at temperatures 500 mk and lower .
sweep rate was 500 oe / min .
inset shows hysteresis in magnetization depending on field sweep direction . ] of the observed transitions , the one near 78 koe appears to be strongly first - order as shown by magnetization in fig .
[ fig : magandmr]b . as @xmath4 is lowered from 500 mk to 35 mk a sharpening of the transition
is observed and the transition eventually becomes step - like .
field sweeps performed around this transition show signs of irreversibility , namely a @xmath114 koe wide hysteresis loop , providing further evidence of first - order behavior .
this in contrast with other ce - based bismuthides .
for instance , other members of the isovalent series such as cecubi@xmath1 ( @xmath115 k ) and ceaubi@xmath1 ( @xmath116 k ) show only a single clear spin - flop transition .
we note , however , that multiple steps have been observed in previous reports on more deficient cecubi@xmath1 ( @xmath117 k ) and even cecubi@xmath1 ( @xmath115 k ) shows hints to a second transition just before the main one .
it is also noteworthy that hysteresis loops show a significant difference ( @xmath118 koe ) at the transition centered near @xmath119 koe as well .
the change in magnetization , however , is not nearly as abrupt as found in the 78 koe transition .
it is well - known that transport measurements in real materials are complicated by disorder .
thus , as this transition is clearly not strongly first - order , the slight amount of irreversibility is likely attributed to pinning due to crystallographic defects ( e.g. , inherent silver deficiency ) .
in fact , a small amount of hysteresis ( on the order of a hundred gauss ) was also observed in magnetization and transport at the remaining three transitions .
the rich phase structure in ceagbi@xmath1 is likely due to the weak anisotropy combined with anisotropic exchange parameters with opposite signs , which lead to magnetic frustration .
further , the close energy scales of the cef splitting ( @xmath120 k ) , kondo coherence ( @xmath121 k ) and the afm ( @xmath122 k ) generates a complex response of the physical properties to the application of magnetic field .
the mr also reflects the multi - step phase structure , tracking each metamagnetic transition with a sharp step , indicating the presence kondo coupling between the ce magnetic moments and itinerant @xmath123-electrons from bi .
the overall trend of mr is linear , a feature shared with the ( non - magnetic ) compounds laagbi@xmath1 and laagsb@xmath1 , where it is attributed to an underlying dirac dispersion for bi / sb itinerant electrons @xcite .
a preliminary ab initio calculation @xcite for ceagbi@xmath15 indicates that the bi @xmath123-electrons also have a dirac dispersion , suggesting a similar origin for the underlying linear mr . however , we note an alternative explanation for the increase in mr is an enhancement in spin - disorder scattering in afm materials in an applied field @xcite .
note that the mr exhibits a sharp drop and hysteretic behavior near the @xmath124 koe transition , lending further support that it is first - order .
motivated by this evidence for coupling of itinerant electrons and local moments , we performed measurements of the hall resistivity @xmath125 to further elucidate the nature of the different phases . like the mr ,
the hall effect tracks each metamagnetic transition ( fig . [ fig : halldata ] ) . ) versus field .
( a ) comparison of sweeping the field up vs. down at 150 mk .
the dotted line is a least - squares fit to @xmath126 .
the fit was made to the region of zero field up to 37 koe ( green arrow ) and extrapolated beyond that point .
( b ) in a second sample , comparison at different @xmath4 while sweeping the field downward . ]
the decrease in @xmath125 roughly parallels the increase in magnetization over the first two transitions , but then sharply deviates from this trend as the field is increased across the trio of transitions at 57 , 78 , and 84 koe , even changing its sign between @xmath127 koe .
further insight is afforded by fitting the hall resistivity to the standard form @xmath128 that includes hall effect contributions from both the applied field and the induced magnetization . using the data up to @xmath129 koe to obtain the fit parameters , we find that this model fits the data extremely well for low fields @xmath130 koe , whereupon the measured @xmath125 strongly deviates from the expectation based on the model .
while there is still some discrepancy between the fit and the data after the last transition ( @xmath131 koe ) , this is relatively small compared to the much larger deviation between fit and data in the regime @xmath119 koe @xmath132 koe .
as the temperature is raised , the magnitude of the anomaly in @xmath125 near 54 koe is decreased , as shown in fig .
[ fig : halldata]b . at present
, we do not have a complete understanding of the origin of this hall effect anomaly , but we comment on some possible scenarios below .
we note that while there is an additional deviation from linear behavior of @xmath125 above @xmath133 koe , a previous study on lower - quality samples using pulsed fields up to @xmath134 koe @xcite appears to rule out an additional transition .
our results can be summarized in the form of a phase diagram of ceagbi@xmath1 with temperature and applied field , as shown in fig . [
fig : phase_diag ] . the second @xmath135 phase ( for 34 koe @xmath136 37 koe ) is not seen above the temperature @xmath137 2.5 k , illustrating the fragility of this phase to thermal fluctuations .
note the strong agreement between the probes of specific heat , transport , and magnetic structure when the corresponding measurements overlap .
of the sequence of transitions between the different low - temperature phases , the penultimate transition near 79 koe appears to be strongly first - order , whereas the remaining transitions appear continuous .
as noted , the hall effect is well - described by a simple model including effects of both the applied field and induced magnetization very well below @xmath119 koe and reasonably well above @xmath104 koe , but exhibits a strong deviation from this simple behavior in the intermediate field regime .
heavy fermion compounds ceausb@xmath1 and ybagge both have some commonalities in the low - temperature phase diagram .
for instance , ceausb@xmath1 orders af and has at least one magnetic transition before the suppression of af order to 0 k at 54 koe.@xcite recent work suggests that the first transition might bifurcate into two at lower temperatures , similar to ceagbi@xmath1.@xcite ybagge also has a similarly complicated phase diagram as a function of field which contains a region partially bordered by a first order transition @xcite .
interestingly , in this region ybagge exhibits anomalous behavior attributed to the influence of a quantum bicritical point @xcite . unlike in ybagge ,
however , the set of transitions is only observed in ceagbi@xmath1 for @xmath138 .
further , the large anomalies in the hall resistivity appear to be a feature unique to ceagbi@xmath1 .
we now comment on potential explanations for the physics at hand .
first , we attribute the sequence of metamagnetic transitions to the frustration from competing anisotropic exchange interactions , as evinced by the susceptibility data . as in many hfs ,
the hall data is more challenging to describe @xcite .
its evident sensitivity to the magnetization suggests a significant contribution from the induced magnetization at low fields , yet a simple phenomenological model incorporating this contribution seems unable to describe the behavior at intermediate fields .
here we note that quantum oscillation measurements reveal electron effective masses in the range of 5 to 7 m@xmath139 , suggesting heavy fermion physics plays a role in transport @xcite ; this could perhaps explain the anomaly , e.g. via a fermi surface reconstruction . to explore this scenario
, one would have to investigate , for instance , band - structure calculations in the presence of a magnetic field .
we anticipate that future theoretical analysis , incorporating details of the conduction electron band structure , as well as a careful treatment of their coupling to local moments , will shed more light on these issues @xcite .
an alternative scenario involves the ` geometrical hall effect ' from a non - collinear spin texture ; while more exotic , such physics is now quite well - established as a consequence of dzyaloshinskii - moriya interactions in ferromagnets and has been also proposed to occur in anisotropic exchange afms , and recently also in heavy - fermion metals @xcite . in this case ,
an anomalous hall effect could be observed as a result of a non - vanishing berry - phase curvature @xcite . to this end
, neutron diffraction / scattering experiments would be valuable to unveil , for instance , the field regions where non - collinear spin structures are realized .
as mentioned above , our previous model was unable to capture all field - induced magnetic transitions .
finally , in the present section we introduce a spin model for the ce local moments to discuss their field - induced response .
although more experimental investigation is clearly essential in order to clarify what type of afm order is stabilized in ceagbi@xmath1 in each field region , here we sketch one possible scenario built on existing experimental data on the closely - related compound cecubi@xmath1 , where the zero - field magnetic structure has already been well - established experimentally @xcite .
we defer a detailed analysis of the spin model to future work , and here only discuss a simple mean - field picture of the magnetic order . for cecubi@xmath1 , x - ray
magnetic diffraction reveals that the ce local moments order antiferromagnetically with an ordering wave vector @xmath140 @xcite .
this corresponds to up - up - down - down " magnetic ordering along the crystallographic @xmath11-axis and ferromagnetic ( fm ) ordering across the basal @xmath141-@xmath142 plane .
( see fig .
[ suppfig:1 ] ) .
the magnetic susceptibility data shows a large anisotropy consistent with a strong easy - axis along the @xmath11-axis .
the application of a @xmath11-axis magnetic field results in a single spin - flop transition at a field of @xmath143koe ; for fields in the @xmath144 plane , no such transition was observed . within a classical approximation , a minimal spin model that may be inferred from these experimental results
incorporates a single - ion anisotropy term and dominant spin exchanges between neighboring sites : @xmath145 here , @xmath146 is the ( applied ) magnetic field and @xmath147 is the magnitude of an easy - axis single - ion anisotropy along the @xmath11-axis .
@xmath148 represents competing spin exchanges between neighboring sites ; fm and afm ( or afm and fm ) spin exchanges for two symmetry distinct neighbors along @xmath11 axis are denoted @xmath149 and @xmath150 , respectively , and a fm spin interaction in the @xmath141-@xmath142 plane is denoted as @xmath151 , as seen in fig .
[ suppfig:1 ] . the competition between alternating ferro- and antiferromagnetic spin exchanges along the @xmath11-axis stabilizes the up - up - down - down " magnetic structure along @xmath11-axis , with a spin polarized state fm on each @xmath141-@xmath142 plane . in the limit @xmath152 ,
the moments behave like @xmath11-axis ising spins , and the presence of a @xmath11-axis field leads to a direct magnetic transition from af ordering to a fully - spin - polarized , paramagnetic state .
however , a smaller single ion anisotropy @xmath153 admits a spin - flop transition at finite @xmath11-axis field , resulting in af spin canting .
this is consistent with the experimental data . given that the minimal picture of competing spin exchanges and single ion anisotropy provide a reasonable explanation of magnetic ordering and field effect of cecubi@xmath1 material , we now turn to a similar analysis of ceagbi@xmath1 . :
red , blue and green spheres represent ce , ag and bi ions respectively and solid line shows one unit - cell .
up - up - down - down " like ordering of ce moments is also shown along @xmath11 axis , which is measured to be the zero field magnetic structire in cecubi@xmath1 .
@xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath151 indicates three symmetry distinct spin exchange interactions between ce magnetic moments . ] magnetic susceptibility measurements on ceagbi@xmath1 again show the presence of magnetic anisotropy but smaller than in cecubi@xmath1 , which indicates weaker ising anisotropy of the localized moments .
furthermore , when ag substitutes for cu on the the transition metal site , spin superexchange between ce moments occurs via the @xmath156 or @xmath157 ag orbitals , as compared to the @xmath158 or @xmath159 electrons of cu , thereby changing the effective superexchange couplings @xmath160 .
moreover , the slight difference in lattice parameters and bond angles may also lead to changes in the rkky interactions induced by coupling to the itinerant electrons of bi .
in general , this confluence of competing effects may stabilize very complicated magnetic ordering .
we also note that further - neighbor interactions besides @xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath151 generally induce incommensurate _
spiral _ ordering , affording an even richer set of possibilities .
for the purposes of a preliminary analysis , we focus on our minimal spin model keeping just @xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath151 , and describing the possible ordered states as a function of the applied field .
notably , even this simple model exhibits a plethora of magnetic orders separated by a sequence of metamagnetic transitions . a convenient approach to understand the magnetic order is to separately consider every two layers of ce sites , corresponding to a single unit cell lattice spacing along the @xmath11 axis .
these two layers of ce sites then form a buckled square lattice , where the nearest and next - nearest neighbor spin - spin couplings are @xmath154 and @xmath151 respectively ; we will refer to this as a ` bilayer ' .
reasoning in analogy with the well - studied @xmath161 square - lattice heisenberg model , we anticipate that fm , nel and stripy phases can be stabilized in each bilayer depending on the relative signs and magnitudes of @xmath154 and @xmath151 .
we may then use these orders as a building block to construct the full three dimensional magnetic order by coupling the ce bilayers via an interlayer coupling @xmath155 .
we now briefly summarize how competing interactions and magnetic anisotropy can lead to several metamagnetic transitions within this approach , even if we restrict ourselves to working within a classical spin approximation . in order to have several metamagnetic phases , we require that @xmath154 , @xmath155 , @xmath151 and @xmath162 are all of the same order
; this is also consistent with expectations based on experiments and a study of lattice parameters . to describe the ordered states stabilized with this parameter regime , it is convenient to work with a magnetic unit cell 8 times larger than the original unit cell ( i.e. , containing 16 ce sites ) , and optimize the classical energy of this unit cell for a given set of parameters @xmath148 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 , we minimize the energy of eq .. fig .
[ suppfig:2 ] shows the magnetization @xmath164 ( @xmath165 is the fully polarized classical spin per site ) as a function of @xmath11-axis magnetic field for specific values of parameters @xmath166 , @xmath167 , @xmath168 and @xmath169 , which are the parameters that best describe the experimental data .
in fact , we find six distinct phases over our field range .
note that the exact same argument can be applied when @xmath154 and @xmath155 values are interchanged , due to site connectivity . the magnetic ordering pattern in each of these phases is illustrated in fig . [ suppfig:3 ] .
_ vs _ field @xmath163 applied along @xmath11 axis . in the presence of competing spin exchange interactions and anisotropy ,
there exist several magnetic phases with applying fields .
( in particular , we take @xmath166 , @xmath167 , @xmath168 and @xmath169 in eq . )
[ suppfig:3 ] describes different magnetic ordering patterns in every phase , i through vi .
inset shows experimental phase diagram from fig . 4 .
] at a zero field , each buckled square lattice bilayer forms a stripy phase , as @xmath170 and the stripy phase is robust under a small and finite magnetic field . with the chosen parameters ,
this phase is degenerate in energy with the up - up - down - down " like ordering ( discussed for the case of cecubi@xmath1 and illustrated in fig .
[ suppfig:1 ] ) . further increase of magnetic field , however , induces a transition into a phase where spins in the lower two layers are polarized along the field direction and spins in the upper two layers are anti - aligned to the field but have a finite canting .
the canted moments induce a finite magnetization , preventing perfect cancellation of magnetic moments between the upper and lower bilayers . at @xmath171 ,
a partial spin - flop transition occurs , yielding a finite magnetization jump . in this phase
, spins in the upper two layers almost form a stripy phase , similar to the phase ( i ) . in the lower two layers , however , all spins attempt to align along the field direction but four spins form a different canting angle with respect to the other four . by smoothly changing those canting angles
, this phase reaches a half - magnetization plateau region , where spins in the upper bilayer form a stripy phase and spins in the lower bilayer are fully polarized . with stronger magnetic fields , there is another partial spin - flop transition exhibiting a finite jump in the magnetization . in phase ( v ) , all 16 spins attempt to be aligned along the field direction but four of them have a different canting angle until their canting angle becomes zero and a fully polarized spin state ( vi ) is realized at a saturation field @xmath172 . based on the above analysis
, we conclude that competing exchange interactions and anisotropy can in principle lead to several metamagnetic transitions with field .
we exemplified this for a specific parameter regime in eq . and found six distinct phases that may emerge taking into account the most dominant exchange interactions .
future neutron scattering studies will be valuable to confirm such scenario , and lay a firmer foundation for theoretical studies .
more detailed theoretical and experimental analyses will be discussed in ref . , which will also discuss scenarios beyond this minimal model and attempt to connect the magnetic ordering with transport .
in conclusion , we have shown that high - quality ceagbi@xmath15 single crystals ( @xmath10 k ) present a rich field - tuned phase diagram with five metamagnetic transitions at @xmath173 mk .
in contrast to other ce@xmath174 members , a strongly first - order transition is observed at @xmath175 koe in the vicinity of the transition to the paramagnetic state .
remarkably , we unveil an anomalous hall contribution for fields @xmath13 koe which is drastically altered when @xmath14 is tuned through a trio of transitions at 57 , 78 , and 84 koe , suggesting that the fermi surface is reconstructed in a subset of the metamagnetic transitions .
our results shed light on hidden properties of ceagbi@xmath15 and open new avenues for both experimental and theoretical studies on non - collinear magnetic structures , quantum ( bi-)criticality , and fermi surface effects , to name a few .
the authors thank s. raghu , s. kivelson and leon balents for discussions .
this work was supported by nsf grant dmr-1350122 .
p. f. s. r. acknowledges fapesp grant 2013/17427 - 7 .
j. x. acknowledges sloan fellowship grant br2013 - 116 .
s.a.p . acknowledges support from nsf grant dmr-1455366 | heavy fermion ( hf ) materials exhibit a rich array of phenomena due to the strong kondo coupling between their localized moments and itinerant electrons .
a central question in their study is to understand the interplay between magnetic order and charge transport , and its role in stabilizing new quantum phases of matter . particularly promising in this regard
is a family of tetragonal intermetallic compounds ce@xmath0@xmath1 ( @xmath2 transition metal , @xmath3 pnictogen ) , that includes a variety of hf compounds showing @xmath4-linear electronic specific heat @xmath5 , with @xmath6 20 - 500 mj@xmath7mol@xmath8 k@xmath9 , reflecting an effective mass enhancement ranging from small to modest . here , we study the low - temperature field - tuned phase diagram of high - quality ceagbi@xmath1 using magnetometry and transport measurements .
we find an antiferromagnetic transition at @xmath10 k with weak magnetic anisotropy and the easy axis along the @xmath11-axis , similar to previous reports ( @xmath12 k ) .
this scenario , along with the presence of two anisotropic ruderman - kittel - kasuya - yosida ( rkky ) interactions , leads to a rich field - tuned magnetic phase diagram , consisting of five metamagnetic transitions of both first and second order .
in addition , we unveil an anomalous hall contribution for fields @xmath13 koe which is drastically altered when @xmath14 is tuned through a trio of transitions at 57 , 78 , and 84 koe , suggesting that the fermi surface is reconstructed in a subset of the metamagnetic transitions . in heavy fermion ( hf ) materials ,
the kondo coupling between local moments and itinerant electrons plays a central role in determining magnetic and transport properties , particularly at low temperatures .
classic examples of the unusual behavior include quantum criticality in ybrh@xmath15si@xmath15 @xcite , unconventional superconductivity in cecoin@xmath16 @xcite , and metamagnetism in ceru@xmath15si@xmath15 @xcite .
ce - based hf materials which host such exciting properties often crystallize in tetragonal structures and their ground state is on the border of antiferromagnetism ( afm ) .
our focus in this paper is the hf family ce__tx__@xmath1 ( @xmath17 transition metal , @xmath18 pnictogen ) , a class of intermetallic compounds that crystallize in the tetragonal zrcusi@xmath1-type structure ( space group @xmath19 ) with a stacking arrangement of ce@xmath20-@xmath4-ce@xmath20-@xmath20 layers .
great attention has been given to the antimonide ( @xmath18 sb ) members due to the presence of anomalous ferromagnetism in ceagsb@xmath15 and , more recently , due to the report of field - induced quantum criticality in ceausb@xmath15 @xcite .
although the investigation of the antimonides is abundant , fewer reports can be found on the bismuthide ( @xmath18 bi ) members .
recent studies of high - quality cecubi@xmath15 and ceaubi@xmath1 revealed afm ordering temperatures of @xmath2116 k and 12 k , respectively .
both materials show a moderate mass enhancement from @xmath4-linear electronic specific heat ( @xmath22 on the order of 100 mj@xmath7mol@xmath8 k@xmath9 ) and exhibit a single spin - flop transition with field applied along the @xmath11-axis @xcite .
, in zero applied field .
top inset shows the low-@xmath4 region where a kink is observed at @xmath23 .
bottom inset shows @xmath24 as a function of ag occupancy measured by eds .
( b ) inverse susceptibility data for fields parallel ( @xmath25 ) and perpendicular ( @xmath26 ) to the @xmath11-axis .
inset shows low temperature @xmath27 data .
the solid lines are fits to the data using the model described in the text .
( c ) magnetic contribution to specific heat in zero field .
top inset shows the integration of specific heat .
@xmath28 is defined as @xmath29 .
bottom inset shows @xmath30 in three different magnetic fields ( in koe ) . ]
ceagbi@xmath1 , a third member of the isovalent series , has been reported previously to order antiferromagnetically ( @xmath31 k ) at zero magnetic field and to undergo three field - induced magnetic transitions at 2 k ( @xmath32 koe ) @xcite .
however , a detailed analysis of the underlying interactions and a deep understanding of the phase diagram at low temperatures is still missing . single crystals of ceagbi@xmath1 were grown from bi - flux with starting composition ce : ag : bi=1:@xmath33:8 ( @xmath34 ) .
the mixture was placed in an alumina crucible and sealed in a quartz tube under vacuum .
the sealed tube was heated up to @xmath35 for 8 h and then cooled down at @xmath36 .
the excess of bi flux was removed by centrifugation after 24 h of annealing at @xmath37 .
single crystals with dimensions @xmath38 mm@xmath39 were ground and their crystal structure was checked by x - ray powder diffraction experiments using cu @xmath40 radiation at room temperature .
several single crystals from different batches were also submitted to elemental analysis using a commercial energy dispersive spectroscopy ( eds ) microprobe coupled to a feg sem microscope . from the eds analysis ,
we have extracted the actual @xmath41 concentration .
the precision of the analysis was calculated by @xmath42/@xmath43 , where @xmath42 is the standard deviation of the measurements , and @xmath44 is the number of points analyzed .
magnetization measurements were performed using a commercial superconducting quantum interference device ( squid ) down to 1.8 k. below 1.8 k , cantilever - based torque magnetometry was used to measure the magnetization in a dilution refrigerator .
electrical resistivity measurements were made using a low - frequency ac resistance bridge and a four - point configuration .
hall data was obtained by measuring in both positive and negative applied fields and taking the difference ( @xmath45/2 $ ] ) . due to hysteresis in the transitions data
was paired for subtraction based on whether the magnitude of the field was increasing or decreasing .
all measurements reported here , except for some of the magnetic susceptibility measurements , were made with the applied field parallel to the c - axis . for resistivity measurements ,
the current was applied in the ab - plane . |
forward - starting options are path dependent put / call financial contracts characterized by having a strike price expressed in terms of a pre - specified percentage @xmath0 of the asset price taken at a contractually fixed intermediate date @xmath1 $ ] , @xmath2 being the option maturity .
the time @xmath3 is known as _ strike - determination time_. the payoff of a forward starting call is therefore @xmath4 these products represent the fundamental component of the so - called cliquets ( see @xcite ) , which are indeed equivalent to a series of forward starting at - the - money options , activated along a sequence of intermediate dates , upon payment of an initial premium .
cliquets are often employed to buy protection against downside risk , though preserving an upside potential , for instance in pension plans in order to hedge the guarantees attached to embedded equity linked products .
wilmott in @xcite showed that these products are particularly sensitive to the model that one chooses for the dynamics of the underlying s price .
in this paper we study a generalization of forward starting options allowing for random strike - determination times .
that is to say , we hypothesize that we are making the forward starting option worth , if some future random event happens during the life of the contract with positive probability .
the value of the asset at this random time is then compared at maturity with the final value of the underlying , so the call s payoff ( [ fspay ] ) is replaced by @xmath5 for some appropriate random time @xmath6 , where we denoted by @xmath7 . the pricing methodology we will present is an extension of rubinstein s approach ( see @xcite ) , and it can be applied to several existing option models .
it is easy to imagine a promising application of this type of contracts in several situations , as we show with the following examples . * a first example with a speculative goal ,
could be represented by a call written ( with @xmath8 ) on the manchester united stock ( nyse:*manu * ) , starting the beginning day of the premiere league ( pl ) soccer tournament and ending the closing day of the tournament .
the call is triggered by the first time , @xmath6 , the united will eventually lead the tournament with at least three points more than all other teams . if this event happens , then the united will increase its chances to take part to the next champions league ( cl ) tournament , an event which generates substantial additional cash - flows .
if , at the end of pl tournament , the united will get the right to play cl , the share value @xmath9 of * manu * at that date will probably be larger than @xmath10 and an investor in the call contract could pocket the difference . *
another possible context we may imagine is when a firm expects an adverse market scenario that might cause a downgrading of the firm s rating in the near future .
so the firm s owner offers a contract of this type to a smart manager ( hired in the past ) , as an incentive to convince him / her to remain within the firm and to work to improve the firm s position before maturity . as an example
, the firm s owner offers this contract to the manager on january , 1st 2015 with maturity @xmath11 year ( with @xmath8 ) . if the event @xmath12 happens , for instance on june , 6th 2015 , then the manager has time until maturity to make the firm s value rise again above @xmath13 and pocket the payoff , otherwise no reward is gained .
the manager is therefore interested in assessing the correct current value of the incentive .
+ in this context , it is also interesting to consider the counterparty credit risk aspects of this type of contract from the point of view of the manager : if the firm ( the counterparty ) does not recover from the adverse market scenario , it might default a short time after the downgrading event or default could even happen before downgrading .
this leads to the problem of computing unilateral credit value adjustment ( * cva * ) for this kind of option , since the manager needs to evaluate this further risk of the contract in order to assess correctly the value of the firm s offer . *
lastly , it is also possible to consider contracts depending on more than one single random event : for example a cliquet call option could be triggered by the first time the underlying asset reaches a pre - specified upper barrier @xmath14 until the asset reaches , if before maturity @xmath2 , a new barrier level @xmath15 , at that time a second call option with strike @xmath16 and expiring at maturity gets activated .
in general , depending on the characteristics of the financial product , one can imagine to construct cliquet type options along some increasing sequence of random times .
the literature on classical forward starting options is wide in terms of underlying s dynamics model and evaluation techniques .
we shortly review the main contributions , since we will use these results as starting point in our analysis rubinstein ( 1991 ) ( see @xcite ) was the first to consider the pricing problem of a forward - start option in the black and scholes model .
later , valuation of forward starting options in stochastic volatility models was addressed by several authors .
lucic ( 2003 ) ( see @xcite ) wrote an evaluation formula by employing the asset s price at determination time as numeraire , transforming those options in plain vanilla ones , giving a closed formula for the heston s model .
kruse and ngel ( 2005 ) ( see @xcite ) , followed the same approach , but they developed a pricing formula exploiting the distributional properties of the heston s model ; they remarked the importance of such an extension ( w.r.t .
the black - scholes environment ) since forward starting options are particularly sensitive to volatility changes .
further , guo and hung ( 2008 ) ( see @xcite ) derived quasi - analytic pricing formulas in general stochastic volatility / stochastic interest rates models , presenting jumps in both the asset s price and the volatility .
this was important , since , in contrast to the plain vanilla case , the value of a forward - starting option may not always increase with maturity .
it depends on the current term structure of interest rates . in the same context , ahlip and rutkowski ( 2009 ) ( see @xcite ) chose a heston s stochastic volatility model and a cir dynamics for the interest rates , with volatility and short rate both correlated with the dynamics of the stock returns .
the main result is an analytic formula for the call case , derived by using the probabilistic approach combined with the fourier inversion technique , as developed in carr and madan ( 1999 ) ( see @xcite ) .
van haastrecht and pelsser ( 2011 ) , ( @xcite ) , exploiting fourier inversion of characteristic functions , developed a quantitative analysis of the pricing of forward starting options under stochastic volatility and stochastic interest rates ( with ornstein - uhlenbeck dynamics ) , confirming that these not only depend on future smiles , but are also very sensitive to model specifications such as volatility , interest rate and correlation movements , concluding that it is of crucial importance to take all these factors into account for a correct valuation and risk management of these securities .
more recently , ramponi ( 2012 ) ( see @xcite ) extended this fourier analysis to regime switching models for the asset price .
finally , in 2006 chicago board options exchange introduced options on its implied volatility index ( vix ) , enhancing the interest in forward starting options to forecast future volatility .
albanese , lo and mijatovic ( @xcite ) proposed a spectral method to evaluate numerically the joint distribution between the stock price and its realized variance , which gave a way of pricing consistently european , general accrued variance payoffs , forward - starting and vix options . to evaluate our generalization of fs options to random determination time
, we exploit the techniques developed in a number of papers ( refer to @xcite and to @xcite for a general exposition ) to deal with default time in credit derivatives .
the main tool we employ is the so called assumption ( h ) , that guarantees that all martingales remain as such when adding the information generated by the default time . in other words
, this means that the no - arbitrage structure is not altered by the introduction of the random time .
this leads to the so called key lemma , that allows to switch from the global information ( generated by the asset s price and the random time ) to the information generated only by the observable prices . following the intensity based approach
, we give a general expression of the pricing formula either in conditions of independence or not . under independence between the asset s price and the random time , we specialize and explicit our prices in several computable models ( black & scholes , heston , variance gamma ) and we suggest an affine dependency structure for the intensity when the independence assumption is dropped ,
showing it is still possible to recover a partially easily computable formula . finally , keeping in mind the second example presented above
, we focus on computing the credit value adjustment , due to counterparty risk , required by these products , when in presence of a further default time ( for a general reference see brigo and chourdakis ( 2009 ) , @xcite ) .
the paper is organized as follows .
section [ sec1a ] gives the set up , in section [ sec2a ] we present a general approach to the evaluation of this kind of product , in section [ sec3a ] we develop some explicitly computable cases under independence . section [ sec4a ] provides some numerical implementation of the derived pricing formulas , finally section [ sec5a ] treats briefly the counterparty risk implied by this product , when a default time for the issuer might occur .
we consider a time interval @xmath17 $ ] , with @xmath2 denoting the maturity of the contracts .
we assume that the market is made up of a single asset and a bond living in a probability space @xmath18 , with a filtration @xmath19 , made complete and right continuous to satisfy the _ usual hypotheses _
( see @xcite ) .
moreover , we assume we are in absence of arbitrage opportunity and that @xmath20 is a risk neutral measure selected by some criterion . before formalizing mathematically the new contract previously described ,
we need to recall briefly the evaluation of classical forward - start options . denoting by @xmath21 the discounting process , the price of a forward - start call with percentage @xmath0 and strike - determination time @xmath22 is given by @xmath23,\qquad 0\le t\le t.\ ] ] in market models where the price of a plain vanilla call option is represented by a deterministic homogeneous function of degree @xmath24 in two spatial variables @xmath25 , that is @xmath26 applied to the given pair @xmath27 , the price of a classical ( call ) forward - start option is @xmath28|\cf_t]={\mathbf{e}}^p[b(t , u ) call(u , s_u , s_u\alpha , t)|\cf_t]\\ \nonumber\!\!\!&=&\!\!\!{\mathbf{e}}^p[b(t , u)call(u , \gamma 1 , \gamma \alpha , t)\big |_{\gamma = s_u } |\cf_t]={\mathbf{e}}^p[b(t , u)(\gamma call(u , 1 , \alpha , t))\big |_{\gamma = s_u } |\cf_t]\\ \label{hom}\!\!\!&=&\!\!\ ! { \mathbf{e}}^p[b(t , u)s_u call(u,1,\alpha , t ) |\cf_t].\end{aligned}\ ] ] scale - invariant models ( see @xcite ) certainly hold this property . furthermore ,
if the call price is a deterministic function of the current price of the underlying and it does not include any additional stochastic factor , we may conclude that the price of the forward - start option verifies @xmath29 = { \mathbf{e}}^p[b(t , u)s_u|\cf_t ] call(u,1,\alpha , t ) = s_t \ call(u,1,\alpha , t),\ ] ] where in the last equality we used the martingale property of the discounted asset price .
notice that in such a case the portfolio having @xmath30 units of the stock replicates " the @xmath31-value of the forward - start option .
sometimes an analogous result may be achieved also in presence of stochastic factors via change of numeraire arriving at a formula of the type @xmath32 = s_t{\mathbf{e}}^{\bar p}[call(u,1,\alpha , t)|\cf_t]\ ] ] for some proper equivalent measure @xmath33 .
we want to generalize these contracts allowing the strike - determination time to be random , thus we need to consider a market model ( and hence a probability space ) where the asset price @xmath34 lives together with a random time @xmath6 .
we therefore assume that there exists a @xmath35algebra @xmath36 containing @xmath37 and a filtration @xmath38 , satisfying the usual hypotheses , that makes @xmath39 and @xmath40 adapted processes ( that is to say that @xmath6 is stopping time w.r.t .
@xmath41 ) and that we may extend the probability @xmath20 to a new probability measure @xmath42 on the measure space @xmath43 . hence , referring to the previous notation , we have @xmath44 for all @xmath45 and from now on we will assume @xmath46 where @xmath47 .
we recall that the filtration stopped at the stopping time @xmath6 will be denoted @xmath48 and it means @xmath49 besides we introduce the classical and fundamental hypothesis * ( h)*every @xmath50martingale remains a @xmath51martingale .
this assumption , known as the h - hypothesis , is widely used in the credit risk literature ( see e.g. @xcite and references therein ) . with this hypothesis , we may conclude that @xmath52 remains in general a @xmath53semimartingale and @xmath54 a martingale under the extended probability @xmath42 .
so we can replace the arbitrage free pricing formula ( [ deterministic ] ) by the more general expression @xmath55.\ ] ] from now on , this product will be called a * random time forward starting * option and we will refer to it as * rtfs * options .
notice that the payoff remains @xmath56measurable .
in what follows we treat only the call case as , under hypothesis ( h ) , a natural extension of the put - call parity holds for these products @xmath57- { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)(\alpha s_{\tau\wedge t}- s_t)^+|\cal g_t ] = s_t - \alpha s_{\tau\wedge t } b(t , \tau\wedge t).\ ] ] lastly we remark that for @xmath8 , these options are worth something only if the random occurrence happens before maturity , in a sense we could say they are triggered by the random time .
in this section we want to understand how to make formula ( [ random ] ) more explicitly computable . as a general consideration , let us notice that @xmath58\\ \nonumber & = & { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha s_{\tau})^+\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t]+(1-\alpha ) { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)s_t \mathbf 1_{\ { \tau > t\}}|\cal g_t]\\ \nonumber & = & { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha s_{\tau})^+|\cal g_t]\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}+ { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha s_{\tau})^+\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t]\\ & + & ( 1-\alpha)s_t\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau\}}- ( 1-\alpha){\mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)s_t\mathbf 1_{\ { t < \tau\le t\}})|\cal g_t].\end{aligned}\ ] ] having written @xmath59 as @xmath60 . for the first term
there is not much to say , there @xmath61 and it behaves as a call price with strike price @xmath62 , which is completely known at time @xmath31 .
the third term represents the guaranteed payoff of this contract , so we have to study the remaining terms .
hypothesis ( h ) is going to help us for the last one .
we know that @xmath63 is a martingale under @xmath36 and that the event @xmath64 ( since for any @xmath65 , @xmath66 ) , so conditioning internally w.r.t .
@xmath67 , we obtain @xmath68={\mathbf{e}}^{q}[{\mathbf{e}}^q(b(t , t)s_t\mathbf 1_{\ { t < \tau\le t\}}|\cg_\tau)|\cal g_t]\\ & = & { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[{\mathbf{e}}^{q}(b(t , t)s_t|\cal g_\tau)\mathbf 1_{\ { t
< \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t]={\mathbf{e}}^{q}(b(t,\tau)s_\tau\mathbf 1_{\ { t < \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used the optional sampling theorem , assuming enough integrability of the asset price process , as @xmath69 almost surely .
the second term may be rewritten as @xmath70={\mathbf{e}}^{q}[{\mathbf{e}}^q(b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha s_{\tau})^+\mathbf 1_{\ { t < \tau\le t\}}|\cg_\tau)|\cal g_t]\\ & = & { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t,\tau){\mathbf{e}}^{q}(b(\tau , t)(s_t-\alpha s_{\tau})^+|\cal g_\tau)\mathbf 1_{\ { t < \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t]={\mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau ) c(\tau,\tau , t)\mathbf 1_{\ { t
< \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t],\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath71 defined w.r.t . @xmath72 as in ( [ deterministic ] ) , where we extended the definition to include also @xmath73 . to proceed with our evaluation we have two possibilities .
either @xmath74 , i.e. @xmath75 is an @xmath50stopping time , or not . in the first case , some computable situations may occur .
for instance , if @xmath76 is a hitting time ( choosing the barrier level @xmath77 ) , we have @xmath78\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau \le t\}}+ { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha h)^+\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau \le t\}}|\cf_t]\\ & + & ( 1-\alpha)s_t\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau\}}- ( 1-\alpha){\mathbf{e}}^{q}[b(t , t)s_t\mathbf 1_{\ { t
< \tau\le t\}})|\cf_t].\end{aligned}\ ] ] summarizing @xmath79+(1-\alpha)s_t\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau\}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where barrier price " denotes the price of a barrier call option with strike price @xmath80 which is activated as soon as the threshold @xmath81 is reached by the asset price .
if this event does not happen before maturity @xmath2 , at maturity the contract is not going to pay zero to the holder as in standard barrier contracts , but @xmath82-percent of the terminal asset price @xmath9 , since the first three pieces of the formula are zero . therefore , if @xmath83 , this random starting forward option differs from a plain vanilla barrier option by a specific non negative value , never exceeding @xmath84 .
other situations may be more or less complex to evaluate , depending upon the definition of the stopping time @xmath6 . in general
, since the observable is the asset s price process , it would be interesting to be able to write the pricing formula in terms of @xmath85 , rather than @xmath86 . for that we have the following key lemma ( see @xcite , @xcite ) .
[ key ] for any integrable @xmath87measurable r.v .
@xmath88 , the following equality holds @xmath89=q(\tau > t|\cg_t)\frac{{\mathbf{e}}^q\big[\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\}}y|\cf_t\big]}{q(\tau > t|\cf_t)}.\ ] ] applying this lemma to the second and fourth term of ( [ general ] ) , respectively with @xmath90 and remembering that @xmath91 is @xmath51measurable , we obtain @xmath92&=&\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\ } } \frac{{\mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)c(\tau,\tau , t)\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}|\cf_t]}{q(\tau > t|\cf_t)}\\ \label{key2 } { \mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)s_\tau\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t]&=&\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\ } } \frac{{\mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)s_\tau\mathbf 1_{\{t <
\tau\le t\}}|\cf_t]}{q(\tau > t|\cf_t)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above may be rewritten following the hazard process approach .
let us denote the conditional distribution of the default time @xmath6 given @xmath85 as @xmath93 and let us notice that for @xmath94 , @xmath95 .
in order to apply the so called intensity based approach , we need to assume that @xmath96 for all @xmath97 ( which automatically excludes that @xmath98 ) to well define the so called risk or hazard process @xmath99 with this notation , we rewrite ( [ key1 ] ) and ( [ key2 ] ) as @xmath100=(1-h_t){\mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)c(\tau,\tau , t)(h_t - h_t)\mathrm e^{\gamma_t}|\cf_t]\\ \label{key4 } & & { \mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)s_\tau\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}|\cal g_t=(1-h_t){\mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)s_\tau(h_t - h_t)\mathrm e^{\gamma_t}|\cf_t],\end{aligned}\ ] ] but by proposition 5.1.1 ( ii ) page 147 of @xcite these conditional expectations may be written as @xmath101&=&{\mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)c(u , u , t ) df_u|\cf_t]\\ \label{key6 } { \mathbf{e}}^q[b(t,\tau)s_\tau(h_t - h_t)|\cf_t]&=&{\mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)s_udf_u|\cf_t].\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we have the additional hypotheses @xmath102 for all @xmath31 and ( ind ) : : @xmath103 and @xmath104 are independent , then @xmath75 is independent of @xmath85 , hypothesis ( h ) is automatically satisfied and @xmath105 is deterministic , so the previous formula becomes @xmath106={\mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)c(u , u , t ) df_u|\cf_t]\\ \nonumber&=&\int_t^t{\mathbf{e}}^q [ { \mathbf{e}}^q(b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha s_u)^+|\cf_u)|\cf_t]df_u=\int_t^t{\mathbf{e}}^q [ b(t , t)(s_t-\alpha s_u)^+|\cf_t ] df_u\\ & = & \int_t^tc(t , u , t)df_u\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the other is treated similarly .
we can summarize the above results in the following [ gener1 ] with the above notation , we have 1 . under hypothesis @xmath107 the price of a * rtfs * call option is given by @xmath108\mathbf 1_{\{0
< \tau\le t\}}+(1-\alpha)s_t\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\}}\\ & + & \mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\}}{\mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)c(u , u , t)\mathrm e^{-(\gamma_u-\gamma_t)}d\gamma_u|\cf_t]\\ & -&(1-\alpha)\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\ } } { \mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)s_u \mathrm e^{-(\gamma_u- \gamma_t)}d\gamma_u|\cf_t]\end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . under hypothesis @xmath109 the price of a * rtfs * call option is given by @xmath110\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}\\ & + & \mathbf 1_{\{\tau >
t\}}\big [ \int_t^tc(t , u , t)\mathrm e^{-(\gamma_u- \gamma_t)}d\gamma_u+(1-\alpha)s_t\mathrm e^{-(\gamma_t-\gamma_t ) } \big ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] part ( a ) is only the assembling of the various pieces previously presented . as for part ( b ) , because of independence , @xmath111 is deterministic and it gets pulled out of the expectation . since @xmath42 is a martingale measure , the integrands of the last two terms verify the martingale property w.r.t .
@xmath85 under @xmath42
. [ rem1 ] if we assume that @xmath112 is absolutely continuous w.r.t .
the lebesgue measure , that is to say @xmath113 for some @xmath50adapted and non negative process @xmath114 called intensity ( see @xcite ) , then also @xmath115 is absolutely continuous and if we denote by @xmath116 its density , necessarily we have @xmath117 in this case we have 1 . under hypothesis @xmath107 the price of a * rtfs *
call option is given by @xmath118\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}+(1-\alpha)s_t\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\}}\\ \nonumber & + & \mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\}}{\mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)c(u , u , t ) \lambda_u\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u\lambda_s ds}du|\cf_t]\\ \nonumber & -&(1-\alpha)\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\ } } { \mathbf{e}}^q[\int_t^t b(t , u)s_u \lambda_u\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u\lambda_s ds}du|\cf_t]\end{aligned}\ ] ] 2 . under hypothesis @xmath109 the price of a * rtfs *
call option is given by @xmath119\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}\\ \nonumber&+&\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\}}\big [ \int_t^tc(t , u , t ) \lambda_u\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u\lambda_s ds}du+(1-\alpha)s_t\mathrm e^{-\int_t^t\lambda_s ds } \big ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] the above formulas , either in presence of independence or not , rely on the knowledge of the model and of the conditional distribution of the default time
. hence , deriving an explicit or implementable formula for the pricing will depend heavily on the modelling choices we are going to make . of course , the independent case is much easier than the other and we focus on it in the next section , to show that there are some interesting treatable cases .
we will always take @xmath8 .
when we no longer assume independence of @xmath75 and @xmath34 , we need to resort to formula ( [ hazard1 ] ) and a reasonable choice is to make the hazard rate depend also on the price process . as a first attempt one may try an affine model , so we decide that @xmath120 where @xmath121 are deterministic , positive and bounded functions , while @xmath122 is a positive @xmath51adapted process independent of @xmath85 , @xmath123 . by using the optional projection theorem ( see @xcite theorem vi.57 ) , we may arrive at the pricing formula @xmath124\mathbf
1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}\\ \!\!\!&+&\!\!\!\int_t^t a(u)call(u,1,\alpha , t){\mathbf{e}}^q [ b(t , u)s_u^2\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u a(s ) s_sds}|\cf_t]{\mathbf{e}}^q[\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u
b(s ) z_sds}]du\\ \!\!\!&+&\!\!\!\int_t^t b(u)call(u,1,\alpha , t){\mathbf{e}}^q [ b(t , u)s_u\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u ( a(s ) s_sds}|\cf_t]{\mathbf{e}}^q[z_u\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u b(s ) z_sds}]du\\ \!\!\!&+&\!\!\!(1-\alpha){\mathbf{e}}^q[b(t ,
t)s_t\mathrm e^{-\int_t^t a(s ) s_sds}|\cf_t]{\mathbf{e } } [ \mathrm e^{-\int_t^t b(s ) z_sds}]\big \},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where all the above expectations are of the same type .
if not explicitly computable , the expectations can be evaluated via monte carlo or transform methods , once a grid of points @xmath125 in order to approximate the time integrals has been fixed .
more precisely , one applies the monte carlo approach to the inner expectations by generating @xmath126 independent paths of the processes @xmath34 and @xmath122 at the grid points .
we now show some examples where the above formulas for the rtfs options can be explicitly computed , of course the first case to analyze is the black and scholes model .
* pricing in the black & scholes market * in the classical bs market with constant risk - free rate @xmath127 and volatility @xmath128 , the price of a plain vanilla european call with maturity @xmath2 and strike @xmath129 will be denoted by @xmath130 , while the price of of a forward - start option with maturity @xmath2 , strike - determination time @xmath3 and percentage @xmath8 ( see @xcite ) is simply @xmath131 where @xmath132 @xmath133 hence in formula ( [ fs_pricebs ] ) we have @xmath134 .
let us notice that @xmath135 is always true . henceforth , under ( ind ) , the price of a ( * rtfs * ) option is given by @xmath136 the valuation of ( [ gfspricebs ] ) can be found in closed form in some simple cases . if @xmath137 , @xmath138 under @xmath42 , then for the second term we obtain @xmath139,\ ] ] where @xmath140 and it is clear that @xmath141 for all values of the parameters .
the above integrals specialize depending on the choice of the parameters . if @xmath142 we have three cases .
if @xmath143 then these integrals can be explicitly computed exploiting integration by parts and the gaussian density , obtaining ( keeping in mind that @xmath144 ) @xmath145.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath146 ( hence @xmath147 ) , then the above formulas reduce to @xmath148\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for @xmath149 we lose the gaussian integral and we arrive at @xmath150\\ \label{case3a2 } \!\!\!\!\!\!a_2(t , t)\!\!\ ! & = & \!\!\ ! \frac \lambda{\lambda\!-\ !
\big \{\mathrm e^{-r(t\!-t)}\cn ( c_2\sqrt{t\!\!-\!t})\!- \!\mathrm e^{-\lambda(t\!-t ) } \big [ \frac 12 + \!\frac{c_2}{\sqrt{2\lambda\!-\!c_1 ^ 2}}\ ! \int^{\sqrt{(2\lambda\!- c_1 ^ 2)(t\!-t)}}_0\!\ ! \frac{\mathrm e^{\frac{z^2}2}}{\sqrt{2\pi}}dz\big ] \big \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if instead condition @xmath151 holds , we arrive in any case to an explicit formula with @xmath152 the same as in ( [ case1a1 ] ) and @xmath153 given by @xmath154.\ ] ] * ( the merton market model ) * the above results can be extended with moderate computational effort to the merton jump - diffusion market model ( see e.g. @xcite ) @xmath155 where @xmath156 is a brownian motion , @xmath157 a poisson process with jump - arrival intensity @xmath158 , @xmath159 all independent of each other , @xmath160 - 1 $ ] is the jump - size expectation , @xmath128 is the volatility and @xmath127 is the risk - free rate . under ( ind ) , for @xmath8 and under the martingale @xmath42 , if @xmath161 , with @xmath162 , the price of a ( * rtfs * ) option is given by @xmath163 where @xmath164 , @xmath165 and @xmath166 are given as in ( [ a1a2bs ] ) for appropriate sets of parameters varying with @xmath167 .
the explicit formula is available from the authors , upon request .
* pricing with fourier transform : the variance gamma model * here we assume that the price dynamics is of the form @xmath168 , where @xmath169 is a lvy process .
fourier transform is a well established computational tool for derivative pricing , first introduced in @xcite and then further developed by several authors ( e.g. see @xcite or @xcite and the references therein ) .
different ways of applying this technique lead to different representation formulas for the risk neutral price of a plain vanilla call option , we choose to consider @xmath170 for @xmath171 and @xmath172 , with @xmath173 $ ] the generalized characteristic function of @xmath174 .
because of the independence of the increments , @xmath175 does not depend on @xmath52 , so the model is scale - invariant and , applying ( [ scale ] ) , we may conclude that the price of the standard forward starting option with determination time @xmath3 is @xmath176 by inserting this fourier representation of the forward starting call price into the formulas of proposition 1.1 or remark [ rem1 ] , we get a double integral representation of our rtfs call price . as usual , under hypothesis ( ind ) ,
setting @xmath8 , we obtain @xmath177\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\ } } \\ & + & \mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\ } } \frac{s_t}{2 \pi } \int_{\mathrm{i } \nu - \infty}^{\mathrm{i } \nu + \infty } \frac 1{\mathrm{i } z - z^2 } \big [ \int_t^t \mathrm{e}^{- r(t - u)(1 + \mathrm{i } z ) } \phi_{x_t- x_u}(-z ) \lambda_u\mathrm
e^{-\int_t^u\lambda_s ds}du \big ] dz.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in some cases the inner integral can be solved in closed form . as a matter of fact ,
if we choose a variance gamma model for the price dynamics @xmath178 with @xmath156 a standard brownian motion and @xmath179 a gamma process independent of @xmath156 , with parameters 1 and @xmath180 and @xmath181 ( see @xcite ) , we have @xmath182 where @xmath183 , with @xmath184 and @xmath185 , denotes the principal complex logarithm .
taking also ( for ease of computation ) a constant hazard rate @xmath186 , we may conclude @xmath187\mathbf 1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\ } } \nonumber \\ \!\!\ ! & + & \!\!\!\mathbf 1_{\{\tau > t\ } } \frac{s_t}{2 \pi}\lambda \mathrm{e}^{-\lambda(t - t ) } \int_{\mathrm{i } \nu - \infty}^{\mathrm{i } \nu + \infty}\frac 1{\mathrm{i } z - z^2}\ ; \frac { 1 - \mathrm{e}^{-[r ( 1+\mathrm{i } z)+\frac 1\mu\ln ( 1-\mathrm{i}b\mu z + c^2 \mu \frac{z^2}2 ) - \lambda](t- t)}}{r ( 1+\mathrm{i } z)+\frac 1\mu\ln ( 1-\mathrm{i}b\mu z + c^2 \mu \frac{z^2}2 ) - \lambda}dz,\end{aligned}\ ] ] leading to a computable formula .
it is reasonable that the same arguments might be extended to tempered stable distributions as well as to the carr - geman - madan - yor model ( see @xcite ) .
* pricing in the heston stochastic volatility market . * assuming independence , we can arrive to an explicit formula also in the heston stochastic volatility model , given ( under the risk neutral measure ) by @xmath188 where @xmath127 is a constant interest rate . here
@xmath85 has to be the natural filtration generated by the couple @xmath189 , which is jointly a bidimensional markov process , hence the final pricing formula will depend only upon the initial values of both @xmath34 and @xmath128 . as before , we start from the expression @xmath190\mathbf
1_{\{0 < \tau\le t\}}\\ & + & \mathbf 1_{\{\tau >
t\}}\big [ \!\int_t^t\!\!c_h(t , u , t , s_t , \sigma_t ) \lambda_u\mathrm e^{-\int_t^u\lambda_s ds}du+(1\!-\alpha)s_t\mathrm e^{-\int_t^t\lambda_s ds } \big ] .\end{aligned}\ ] ] by employing the results in @xcite ( or @xcite ) , we can find an explicit formula for the forward start option .
indeed by virtue of the scale invariant property verified also by this model , we have @xmath191 where @xmath192 is the standard price of a call option in the heston model ( for details see for instance @xcite lemma 2.1 ) and @xmath193 and @xmath194 is a modified bessel function of the first kind . the previous method can be adapted to cover also the case of affine stochastic interest rate market model proposed in @xcite , where the interest rate follows a hull and white model and the stochastic volatility is a ornstein - uhlenbeck process .
in this section we report the results of the numerical implementation of some of the models presented before : the black & scholes , the variance gamma and the heston models , with a random time @xmath195 with parameter @xmath162 . in all experiments we set @xmath8 , @xmath196 and
we assume the independent hypothesis ( ind ) .
analytical or closed - form prices , eventually requiring numerical quadrature , are compared with standard monte carlo approximations of the arbitrage free pricing formula ( [ random ] ) .
sample paths of the underlying dynamics are evaluated at the random time @xmath6 and the corresponding payoffs are collected to estimate ( [ random ] ) . in our experiments we simulated @xmath197 samples / paths and remark [ rem1 ] can be easily designed . ] . adaptive gauss - lobatto quadrature was used to approximate representation integrals ( vg and heston models ) , which required the evaluation of extended fourier transforms involving multivalued functions , such as the complex logarithm . to avoid the well - known numerical instabilities due to a wrong formulation of the characteristic function
, we used the so - called _ rotation count algorithm _ by kahl and jckel ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
all routines were coded and implemented in matlab , version 8.0 ( r2012b ) on an intel core i7 2.40 ghz machine running under windows 7 with 8 gb physical memory .
for each model we report the closed - form ( cf ) and the mc prices for different values of @xmath186 , fixing the other model parameters . in parenthesis
we report the absolute error w.r.t .
the cf price , followed by the corresponding length of the @xmath198 confidence interval . without loss of generality we set @xmath199 , @xmath200 and @xmath201 . in
the black & scholes model the rtfs price is given by formulas ( [ gfspricebs])-([case4a2 ] ) .
exact simulations of the geometrical brownian motion with @xmath202 at the random time @xmath6 are used to estimate the pricing formulas .
.*black & scholes * model for different values of @xmath186 . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] lastly , we choose the random time @xmath195 with varying @xmath203 in order to compare at time @xmath196 , the rtfs price and the price of a fs option with determination time @xmath204 . in other words
we compare @xmath205 with @xmath206 , see figure ( [ figall1 ] ) . in all the instances prices decrease as @xmath3 increases
, moreover we notice that : i ) for @xmath207 ( i.e. @xmath208 ) fs and rtfs prices both tend to the price of an atm plain vanilla call ; ii ) for @xmath209 ( i.e. @xmath210 ) the fs value trivially goes to @xmath211 , while the value of a rtfs option stays positive since @xmath212 . .
[ figall1],width=680,height=226 ]
in this section we are interested in computing the credit value adjustment ( cva ) for a rtfs option , when one of the parties is subject to a possibly additional default time .
the interest lies in the fact that those products would be otc and knowing that the cva is computable might be convenient .
we first recall what the cva is for an additive cashflow .
let us denote by @xmath213 the discounted value of the cashflow between time @xmath31 and @xmath2 ; this value has to be additive , which means that for times @xmath214 it holds @xmath215 all european contingent claims with integrable , @xmath56measurable payoff @xmath216 , trivially verify ( [ additive ] ) since @xmath217 .
we call net present value of @xmath218 @xmath219 we now look into unilateral counterparty credit risk . let us suppose that the cashflow is between two parties @xmath220 ( buyer ) and the counterparty @xmath221 , that is subject to default , with default time @xmath222
. then , the discounted value of the cashflow has to be adjusted by subtracting from the defaultless case the quantity @xmath223 where @xmath224 represents a deterministic recovery rate ( see @xcite ) . in the case of classical forward start options with fixed strike - determination time @xmath3 ,
it is possible to compute directly the cva .
we denote by @xmath225 the filtration generated by the process @xmath226 and by @xmath227 . under independence between @xmath228 and @xmath225 , taking for granted that @xmath54 remains a martingale in the enlarged filtration @xmath229 w.r.t .
a risk neutral probability measure @xmath230 which extends the risk neutral probability @xmath20 , we have @xmath231 where the key lemma and the same notation as in section 1 were used , under the assumption that @xmath232 . to extend the previous formula to the case of the rtfs options we need to consider two random times : the strike - determination time @xmath75 and the counterparty default time @xmath222 .
hence we need to extend the original filtration @xmath228 with both @xmath233 and @xmath234 , obtaining @xmath235 accordingly , we assume there exists an extension of the risk neutral probability @xmath20 to a common probability space @xmath236 that we still denote by @xmath42 and we set the corresponding key assumption * ( hc)*every @xmath85 martingale remains a @xmath72 martingale .
taking @xmath8 for simplicity , we have that the price of a defaultable rtfs call option is @xmath237.\ ] ] so , in presence of a recovery rate @xmath238 , we obtain that the cva for this product has to be @xmath239= ( 1\!-\!r ) { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau_c\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t - s_{\tau\wedge t})^+|\cal g_t].\end{aligned}\ ] ] we may decompose the expectation as @xmath240\\ \!\!\!&=&\!\!\!{\mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau_c\le t\}}\mathbf
1_{\{\tau > t\}}b(t , t)(s_t\!-\!s_{\tau\wedge t})^+|\cal g_t]\!+{\mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau_c\le t\}}\mathbf 1_{\{\tau\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t\!-\!s_{\tau\wedge t})^+|\cal g_t]\\ \!\!\!&=&\!\!\!{\mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau_c\le t\}}\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t - s_{\tau})^+|\cal g_t ] + \mathbf 1_{\{\tau\le t\}}{\mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau_c\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t - s_{\tau})^+|\cal g_t],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the last equality is justified by the fact that the first term in the first passage is equal to 0 . in the second equality
the crucial term is the first , as the second reduces to the cva of a standard forward start option , for which formula ( [ cvafs ] ) applies .
we may handle the first term under condition of independence between @xmath222 and @xmath241 . denoting by @xmath242 ,
we have @xmath243 and applying the key lemma to @xmath72 and @xmath244 we obtain @xmath245\\ & = & q(\tau_c > t|\cg_t)\frac{{\mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t<\tau_c\le t\}}\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t - s_{\tau})^+|\cf^h_t]}{q(\tau_c > t|\cf^h_t)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the independence of @xmath246 from the remaining factors gives @xmath245\\ & = & q(\tau_c > t|\cg_t)\frac
{ q(t < \tau_c\le t)}{q(\tau_c > t)}{\mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t - s_{\tau})^+|\cf^h_t]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and if @xmath247 , the above reduces to @xmath248=q(t < \tau_c\le t ) { \mathbf{e}}^{q}[\mathbf 1_{\{t < \tau\le t\}}b(t , t)(s_t - s_{\tau})^+|\cf^h_t]\ ] ] which is the weighted value of a rtfs option , exactly as it happened with the standard fs option .
summarizing we have under hypothesis ( hc ) and the condition that @xmath249 , if @xmath222 is independent of @xmath241 , then the cva of a defaultable rtfs call option of price @xmath250 , with recovery rate @xmath251 $ ] , is given by @xmath252 .
lastly we remark that if the two random times coincide , @xmath253 , then we may conclude that @xmath254 which implies that the defaultable price is @xmath255 .
the authors thank prof . c. chiarella for useful suggestions at an early stage of this work .
d. brigo , k .chourdakis , _ counterparty risk for credit default swaps : impact of default volatility and spread correlation _ , international journal of theoretical and applied finance , vol .
12 , no . 7 , 1007 - 1029 , ( 2009 ) .
g. h. cheang , c. chiarella , _ a modern view on merton s jump - diffusion model _ , in `` stochastic processes , finance and control : a festschrift in honor of robert j. elliott '' , samuel n. cohen , dilip madan , tak kuen siu and hailiang yang ( eds . ) , pg 217 - 234 , world scientific , ( 2012 ) .
a. van haastrecht , a. pelsser _
accounting for stochastic interest rates , stochastic volatility and a general correlation structure in the valuation of forward starting options _ , journal of futures markets , vol .
31 , no . 2 , 103 - 125 ( 2011 ) .
a. ramponi , _ on fourier transform methods for regime - switching jump - diffusions and the pricing of forward starting options _ , international journal of theoretical and applied finance , vol .
15 , no . 5 , ( 2012 ) | we introduce a natural generalization of the forward - starting options , first discussed by m. rubinstein ( @xcite ) .
the main feature of the contract presented here is that the strike - determination time is not fixed ex - ante , but allowed to be random , usually related to the occurrence of some event , either of financial nature or not .
we will call these options * random time forward starting ( rtfs)*. we show that , under an appropriate martingale preserving " hypothesis , we can exhibit arbitrage free prices , which can be explicitly computed in many classical market models , at least under independence between the random time and the assets prices .
practical implementations of the pricing methodologies are also provided .
finally a credit value adjustment formula for these otc options is computed for the unilateral counterparty credit risk . * keywords * : random times , forward - starting options , cva . * jel classification * : g13 |
in the experiment in which they try to detect the neutrino oscillation , by using the size of the earth and measuring the zenith angle distribution of the atmospheric neutrino events , such as , superkamiokande experiment[1 ] hereafter , simply sk , it is demanded that the measurements of the direction of the incident neutrino are being carried out as reliably as possible . among the experiments concerned on the neutrino oscillation , the analysis of fully contained events in sk
is regarded as mostly ambiguity - free one , because the essential information to extract clear conclusion is stored inside the detector . in sk , they assume that the direction of the neutrino concerned is the same as that of the produced charged lepton ( hereafter , simply sk assumption)[2,3 ] .
however , the sk assumption does not hold in the just energies concerned for neutrino events produced inside the detector , which is shown later .
+ in the energy region where fully contained events and parially contained events ( single ring events ) are analysed , quasi elastic scattering of neutrino interaction(qel ) is the dominant source for the atmospheric neutrino concerned[4 ]
the differential cross section for qel is given as follows [ 5 ] .
+ @xmath0 \notag\\ + c(q^2 ) \biggl [ \frac{s - u}{m^2 } \biggr]^2 \biggr\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the signs + and - refer to @xmath1 and @xmath2 for charged current(c.c . )
interaction , respectively .
the @xmath3 denotes four momentum transfer between the incident neutrino and the charged lepton . as for details of other symbols , see the text [ 5 ] .
the relation among @xmath3 and @xmath4 , the incident energy of neutrino , @xmath5 , the energy of the emitted charged lepton ( ( anti)muon or ( anti)electron ) and @xmath6 , the scattering angle of the charged lepton , is given as @xmath7 also , the energy of the charged lepton is given by @xmath8 for a given energy @xmath4 of the incident neutrino , we randomly sample @xmath3 through the monte carlo procedure from eq . ( 1 ) .
subsequently we obtain the scattering angle @xmath6 of the charged lepton concerned by eqs .
( 2 ) and ( 3 ) .
thus , we obtain the distribution functions for scattering angle of the charged lepton . in fig . 1
, we give such distribution functions for different incident neutrino energies .
through such a monte carlo procedure , we obtain the average scattering angles and their standard deviations , too . we give them in table 1 .
it is shown clearly from the figure and the table that the average scattering angles largely deviate from the direction of the incident neutrino , being accompanied by rather large standard deviations and consequenly we can not neglect the scattering angle in the energy region where sk was interested in , say @xmath90.1 gev to @xmath910 gev .
+ distribution function for the scattering angle @xmath6 of the muon for muon - neutrino . ]
.[tab : table1 ] the average values @xmath10 for scattering angle of the emitted charged leptons and their standard deviations @xmath11 for various primary neutrino energies @xmath4 [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
in addition to the scattering angle of the charged leptons , it should be emphaized that the azimuthal angles of the charged particles in qel play a decisive role in the determination of their zenith angles as well as the translation from fully contained events to partially contained events ( vice versa ) which are mentioned later . +
in order to examine the influence of the azimuthal angle of the charged leptons over their zenith angle , let us denote the direction cosines of the incident neutrino @xmath12 and denote the scattering angle of the charged lepton , @xmath6 , and the azimuthal angle , @xmath13 , with regard to the axis of the incident neutrino .
then , @xmath14 , the direction cosines of the charged lepton which correspond to @xmath12 are given as @xmath15 while sk assume @xmath16
by using eq . ( 4 ) , we carry out a monte carlo calculation to examine the influence of the azimuthal angle of the charged leptons over their zenith angle .
the scatter plots between @xmath17 , cosines of the zenith angles of the charged leptons and fractional energies @xmath18 of the charged leptons for diffrent directions of the incident neutrinos are given in figs .
2 to 4 . for a given @xmath3 in eq .
( 1 ) , the energy @xmath5 of the charged lepton and its scattering angle @xmath6 is uniquely determined due to the two body kinematics . in fig .
2 , we give the case of vertically incident neutrinos @xmath19 . here , as the zenith angles of the charged leptons are measured from the vertical direction in the sk case , the azimuthal angles of the charged leptons never influence over their zenith angle , and consequently the relation between their fractional energies and their zenith angles is uniquley determined as mentioned above . in fig .
3 , we give the case of horizontally incident neutrinos @xmath20 . here , the azimuthal angle of the charged leptons has a potent influence on their zenith angle through the operation of eq . ( 4 ) .
as is seen clearly from the figure , the @xmath17 is widely distributed even to the backward for the same energy of the charged lepton . in fig .
4 , we give the intermediate case of the diagonal incidence @xmath21 . + to connect our results with the analysis of the real experimental data , we finally need to take account of the energy spectrum of the incident neutrino in our calculation .
for this purpose , we adopt the neutrino energy spectrum at kamioka site obtained by fiorentini _
et al._[6 ] and have carried out the following monte carlo procedure for a given @xmath22 of the incident neutrino .
+ procedure a : we randomly sample the energy of the incident neutrino from the probability function which is composed of the combination of the neutrino energy spectrum by fiorentini it et al . , which covers from 0.1 gev to 100 gev at kamioka site , with the corresponding total cross section for qel .
procedure b : we decide whether the neutrino concerned should be attributed to the particle or the anti - particle by the random sampling from the corresponding probability functions given in procedure a. procedure c : we randomly sample @xmath3 of the neutrino concerned for a given energy of the neutrino from eq .
procedure d : we decide the energy of the charged lepton , @xmath5 , from eq .
( 3 ) and its scattering angle,@xmath23 , from eq . ( 2 ) .
procedure e : we randomly sample the azimuthal angle , @xmath24 , by using a random number between ( 0,1 ) .
procedure f : we decide the direction cosines of the charged leptons from eq .
( 4 ) , being accompanied by the scattering angle and the azimuthal angle obtained from procedures d and e. + we repeat a chain of the procedures a to f until we attain at the required trial number ( ten thousands samplings per each case ) .
+ zenith angle distribution of @xmath25 and @xmath26 for @xmath27 and @xmath27 , taking account of the overall neutrino spectrum at kamioka site.the direction of the incident neutrinos is diagonal .
the other quantities are the same as in fig .
zenith angle distribution of @xmath25 and @xmath26 for @xmath27 and @xmath27 , taking account of the overall neutrino spectrum at kamioka site.the direction of the incident neutrinos is diagonal .
the other quantities are the same as in fig .
zenith angle distribution of @xmath25 and @xmath26 for @xmath27 and @xmath27 , taking account of the overall neutrino spectrum at kamioka site.the direction of the incident neutrinos is diagonal .
the other quantities are the same as in fig .
5 . ] in figs . 5 to 7 for the three cases of @xmath28 ( @xmath29 and @xmath30 ) ,
we give the zenith angle distribution of the sum of @xmath31 and @xmath32 for a given @xmath33 , obtained by procedures a to f. if the sk assumption is valid , even if it may be of approximation , the zenith angle distribution of the charged lepton should be of the delta function type with a peak around the direction of the incident neutrino . however , it is clear from the figures that the real zenith angle distributions of the charged leptons deviate far from the delta function type distribution , and further the backward scattering is too serious to neglect , which means rather large mixture of down going muon events into upward going events .
it is also noticed that the azimuthal angles critically influence the translation from fully contained events to partially contained events ( vicer versa ) which is strongly dependent on their generation point inside the detector .
zenith angle distribution of @xmath34 and @xmath35 for @xmath36 and @xmath37 , taking account of the overall neutrino spectrum at kamioka site .
the direction of the incident neutrino is diagonal .
the other quantities are the same as in fig . 8 . ]
zenith angle distribution of @xmath34 and @xmath35 for @xmath36 and @xmath37 , taking account of the overall neutrino spectrum at kamioka site .
the direction of the incident neutrino is diagonal .
the other quantities are the same as in fig . 8 . ]
zenith angle distribution of @xmath34 and @xmath35 for @xmath36 and @xmath37 , taking account of the overall neutrino spectrum at kamioka site .
the direction of the incident neutrino is diagonal .
the other quantities are the same as in fig . 8 . ] in figs .
8 to 10 , we give similar results for @xmath34 and @xmath35 which correspond to figs .
5 to 7 .
the charcteristics of the figs . 8 to 10 for
( anti-)electron is essentially the same as in figs .
5 to 7 for ( anti-)muon .
from these figures 5 to 10 , it is surely concluded that the zenith angle distributions of the charged leptons under the sk assumption does not reflect the real zenith angle distribution of the incident neutrinos concerned .
of course , it is common sense that the direction of individual charged lepton can not determine that of the neutrino concerned uniquely , but only statistically .
however , our present results clearly shows that the direction of the charged leptons under the sk assumption can not dtermine those of the incident neutrino , even if they accumulate experimental data statistically enough .
thus , it is surely concluded that we could not extract any definite conclusion around the neutrino oscillation from the measurement on the charged leptons under sk assmption which occur inside the detector and is regarded as the most reliable one from the point of the experimental accuracy .
the relation between the zenith angle distributions of the charged leptons which are really measured experimentally and those of the parent neutrinos , taking account of the scattering angle and the azimuthal angle of the charged leptons correctly , will be shown in a subsequent paper . 00
y.fukuda _ et al . _ ,
lett . * 81 * , 1562 ( 1998 ) .
+ y.fukuda _ et al , _ phys .
. lett . * 82 * , 2642 ( 1999 ) .
t.kajita and y.totsuka , rev .
phys . * 73 * , 85 ( 2001 ) .
see p. 101 .
m.ishitsuka , ph.d thesis , university of tokyo ( 2004 ) .
see p. 138 .
p.lipari,m.lusignoli and f.sartogo , phys .
lett . * 74 * , 4384 ( 1995 ) .
p.renton , _ electro weak interaction _ ( cambdrige university press,1990 ) .
see p. 405 .
g.fiorentini,v.a.naumov and f.l.vilante , phys .
lett , * b510 * , 173 ( 2001 ) . | ( submitted to physical review d , rapid communication ) |
the characterization of the electro - magnetic properties of hadron and parton matter , which in turn can be described by quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) and quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) , gains increasing popularity among particle physicists .
one of the main gaols of the relativistic heavy - ion facilities such as the relativistic heavy - ion collider ( rhic ) at bnl , uppton - usa and the large hadron collider ( lhc ) at cern , near geneva - switzerland and the future nuclotron - based ion collider facility ( nica ) at jinr , dubna - russia , is precise determination of the hadron - parton phase - diagram , which can also be studied in lattice qcd numerical simulations @xcite and various qcd - like approaches .
the polyakov nambu - jona lasinio ( pnjl ) model @xcite , the polyakov linear-@xmath0 model ( plsm ) or the polyakov quark meson model ( pqm ) @xcite , and the dynamical quasi - particle model ( dqpm ) @xcite are examples on qcd - like models aiming to characterizing the strongly interacting matter in dense and thermal medium and also in finite electro - magnetic field .
it is conjectured that , the [ electrical and thermal ( heat ) ] conductivity and ( bulk and shear ) viscous properties of the qcd matter come up with significant modifications in the chiral phase - transition @xcite .
the influence of finite magnetic field on qcd phase - diagram , which describes the variation of the confinement - deconfinement phase - transition at various baryon chemical potentials @xcite , has been studied in lattice qcd @xcite . in relativistic heavy - ion collisions
, a huge magnetic field can be created due to the relativistic motion of charged spectators and the local momentum - imbalance of the participants . at lhc energy , the expected magnetic field @xmath12 @xcite , where @xmath13 gauss . in order to estimate the temperature dependence of the electrical conductivity , different phenomenological approaches
have been proposed @xcite . besides electrical conductivity , the magnetic catalysis , for instance , is found sensitive to the response of the strongly interacting system to finite electro - magnetic field @xcite . the chiral phase - structure of various mesonic states at finite temperatures has been evaluated with and without anomaly contributions @xcite and in presence of finite magnetic fields @xcite . in a previous work , we have presented calculations for the chiral phase - structure of ( pseudo)-scalar and ( axial)-vector meson masses in thermal and dense medium with and without polyakov corrections and/or anomaly contributions @xcite a vanishing and finite magnetic effect @xcite . the chiral phase - structure in the limit of large number of colors ( @xmath14 ) and the normalization of sixteen meson states with respect to the lowest matsubara frequency are introduced in ref .
@xcite . in finite magnetic field ,
the chiral phase - structure of ( pseudo)-scalar and ( axial)-vector meson masses has been analysed @xcite .
recently , study of qgp in presence of external magnetic field has been conducted @xcite .
furthermore , at nonzero magnetic field , viscous properties from boltzmann - uehling - uhlenbeck ( buu ) equation have been compare with the ones from green - kubo ( gk ) correlations in relaxation time approximation ( rta ) , which are based on relativistic kinetic theory @xcite .
some qcd transport coefficients have been determined , numerically and estimated , analytically @xcite .
the confrontation to lattice qcd results enables the judgement about the qcd - effective models , such as pnjl and plsm .
the transport coefficients calculated from pnjl @xcite and dqpm @xcite and thermodynamics and bulk viscosity near phase transition from @xmath15 and @xmath16 models in hartree approximation for cornwall - jackiw - tomboulis ( cjt ) formalism are summarized in ref .
the calculations of shear and bulk viscosities of hadrons @xcite and that of both hadrons and partons from parton - hadron string dynamics ( phsd ) were presented in ref .
the ratios of bulk and shear viscosity to the electrical conductivity of qgp were determined @xcite .
the transport coefficients are particularly helpful in characterizing qcd matter , such as the phase transition , the critical endpoint , etc . @xcite .
recent non - perturbative lattice qcd simulations succeeded in estimating qcd viscosities .
we examine the [ electrical and thermal ( heat ) ] conductivities and ( bulk and shear ) viscosities as diagnostic tools to studying quark - hadron phase - transition in thermal medium .
the viscous properties have been reported in ref .
we recall that the so - far different lsm - calculations have been performed in order to determine certain transport - properties of the qcd matter @xcite .
while the system approaches equilibrium , the temperature dependence of the relaxation time has been characterized . in light of this , studying the qcd regimes , where analytic calculations can be compared with , is of great relevance to recent problems in high - energy physics .
this would clarify the validity of the proposed calculations , in this case qcd - like approaches such as plsm , in determining other quantities in dense medium and measure the influence of finite electro - magnetic field . before introducing the present results , the question to
what extent the transport coefficients are sensitive to the underlying microscopic physics of the medium ? should be answered , first .
its answer determines how relevant is the present work in describing recent lattice qcd simulations .
both lattice qcd calculations and ours from the qcd - like approach , plsm , share almost same approximations , for instance , both assume a global `` equilibrium '' . in other words , even if nowadays the first - principle lattice qcd calculations become very reliable , and they are not `` dynamical '' at all
. the lattices are static assuming nonvarying temporal and spacial dimensions .
anisotropic lattices are technically not yet possible .
thus , the calculations of certain transport coefficients on lattices explicitly assumes that the qcd system is in equilibrium .
so , do our qcd - like approach , the plsm , which integrates some features and symmetries of qcd and the corresponding degrees - of - freedom . in light of this
, the answer to the above mentioned question becomes simple .
yes , we can extend " static approaches utilized in calculating thermodynamics , for instance , to transport properties , as long as we assume equilibrium .
the role of an effective translator allowing us to calculate transport coefficients from plsm is played by the relaxation time .
a good modelling for the relaxation time is therefore very crucial in enabling plsm to reproduce lattice qcd transport coefficients . in the present work ,
we introduce su(@xmath17 ) plsm calculations for electrical and heat conductivities and for bulk and shear viscosities at finite temperature but vanishing baryon chemical potential . to this end , we determine various thermodynamic quantities , such as , the equation of state , specific heat , squared speed of sound and quark number multiplicity as functions of temperatures @xcite .
the plsm approach shall be elaborated in section [ sec : model ] .
section [ structure ] summarizes the chiral phase - structure from plsm and compares the phase transition for light and strange quarks with recent lattice qcd calculations .
the relaxation time shall be calculated in section [ sec : relxtime ] .
the normalized electrical and heat conductivities are presented in section [ conductivitya ] .
the ratios of bulk and shear viscosities relative to the thermal entropy shall be given in section [ viscosity ] .
section [ conclusion ] is devoted to the conclusions .
the plsm lagrangian with @xmath18 quark flavors and @xmath19 color degrees - of - freedom consists of two parts @xmath20 the chiral part @xmath21 , which is coupled to the polyakov - loop potential with su(3)@xmath22 su(3)@xmath23 symmetry @xcite , in turn consists of the fermionic contributions from quarks , @xmath24 , coupled with a flavor - blind yukawa coupling @xmath25 of the quarks @xcite and of the mesonic contributions from gluons . *
the fermionic part reads _ q & = & _ f _ f(i^ d_-gt_a(_a+i _ 5 _ a ) ) q_f , [ lfermion ] where @xmath26 are the dirac gamma matrices of chiral spinors , @xmath27 are the scalar mesons and @xmath28 are the pseudoscalar mesons . through the covariant derivative @xmath29 , the quarks can be coupled to the euclidean gauge field @xcite @xmath30 . *
the second term , @xmath31 , refers to the mesonic contributions , _ m & = & ( _ ^^-m^2 ^ ) -_1 [ ( ^ ) ] ^2 -_2 ( ^ ) ^2 + & + & c[()+(^ ) ] + [ h(+^ ) ] , [ lmeson ] with @xmath32 is a complex @xmath33 matrix and defined as @xcite , = t_a(_a+i_a ) , where @xmath34 with @xmath35 are nine generators of @xmath36 symmetry group .
@xmath37 are gell - mann matrices while @xmath38 @xcite .
explicit symmetry - breaking is given by @xmath39 , which is ( @xmath40 ) matrix with nine parameters @xmath41 .
in vacuum , the model parameters can be fixed by six experimentally known quantities . tab .
[ tab:1a ] summarizes estimations for these parameters at sigma mass @xmath42mev @xcite .
.summary of plsm s parameters .
a detailed description is given in ref .
@xcite [ tab:1a ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] furthermore , the plsm can be extended to determine the physical masses of the degenerated light and strange quarks under the assumption that the quark chemical potentials are equivalent , @xmath43 .
it is worthwhile to devote further efforts in determining the correlations and the fluctuations between the chiral and deconfinement phase - transition(s ) . according to the direct dependence of quark masses and their condensates , @xmath44 and @xmath45 and when taken into account the flavor - blind yukawa coupling @xmath46
, one can straightforwardly deduce that the mass of the light constituent quark @xmath47mev and that of the strange constituent quark @xmath48mev .
this is a set of some plsm parameters utilized in performing the present calculations . the precise estimation of the temperature dependence of the relaxation time ( @xmath49 ) of qcd matter plays a very essential role in determining its conductivity and viscous properties in thermal medium .
for example , this quantity is very crucial for the numerical estimation of the transport properties from green - kubo correlations @xcite . in framework of plsm ,
the quark flavors represent the effective degrees - of - freedom , especially at high temperatures .
thus , the relaxation time of such a quark system , i.e. , deconfined qcd matter , is strongly relevant to the present calculations . at lower temperatures , the hadronic degrees - of - freedom ; the pion and sigma mesons ,
become dominant . for a microscopic consideration , the relaxation time can be determined from the thermal average of total elastic scattering and depends on the relative cross - section @xmath50 , = ^-1 , [ rlaxtime ] where @xmath51 is the cross section , @xmath52 is the mean relative velocity of two colliding particles , and @xmath53 are their number densities .
the relaxation time ( @xmath54 ) has been evaluated from dqpm and njl models @xcite . in dqpm , @xmath54 is found indirectly - related to the finite decay - width of the quarks ( @xmath55 ) and to that of the gluons ; @xmath56 @xcite .
the temperature dependence of @xmath54 was introduced in ref .
@xcite , in which dqpm was utilized and assumed that static quantities , such as , thermodynamics , are related to dynamic ( flow ) quantities , such as conductivity and viscosity . for the sake of simplicity
, the temperature dependence of @xmath51 can be determined according to the assumption of free ( ideal ) massless gas , where the confinement phase of mesons are conjectured to be liberated into deconfinement phase of free quarks and gluons , at very high temperatures , @xmath57 . in ultra - relativistic kinetic theory ,
the temperature dependence of the cross section ( @xmath51 ) at temperatures around the critical value have a good agreement with the @xmath58-dependence @xcite .
furthermore , from the bjorken picture @xcite , we can assume that the temperature @xmath59 and the cross section @xmath60 .
then , we obtain that @xmath61 .
should these assumptions be correct , then the relaxation time can approximately be determined from the plsm , where the temperature evolution of quark number - density becomes very obvious .
[ decays ] shows the thermal dependence of the relaxation time ( @xmath54 ) calculated from plsm at different values of baryon chemical potential @xmath62 ( solid curve ) , @xmath63 ( dotted curve ) and @xmath64mev ( dashed curve ) .
this is the only figure in which we take into consideration the influence of the baryon chemical potential .
it is obvious that the temperature dependence of @xmath54 rapidity decreases at low temperatures ( hadron phase ) and remain almost unchanged at higher temperature ( parton phase ) . on the other hand , increasing baryon chemical potential considerably increases the decline in @xmath54 . at higher temperatures
, @xmath54 remains almost independent on the temperature .
as introduced in ref .
@xcite , the transport theory with the boltzmann master equation is used in calculating the momentum loss and the relaxation time . to this end
, the screening of long - range quark - quark interactions is assumed for the process of inter - penetrating quark plasmas . for a spatially uniform quark plasma of favor
@xmath65 flowing with respect to @xmath66 plasmas with another type of flavor , the relative flow velocity is assumed to relax in a long time due to the collision expansion .
the resulting relaxation time can be utilized in calculating the transport coefficients from su(@xmath17 ) models @xcite .
it was concluded that the relaxation rates for the momentum relaxation , the electrical conduction , and the viscous properties have a universal scale & & , [ eq : taut1 ] where @xmath67 is the running strong coupling and @xmath68 stands for quark mass , but due to the singular character of the interaction for small energy and small momentum transfer , the thermal conductivity behaves , differently @xcite .
the relaxation rate for thermal conduction scales as & & .
[ eq : taut2 ] alternative to eqs .
( [ eq : taut1 ] ) and ( [ eq : taut2 ] ) , it was assumed that the relaxation time in both partonic and hadronic phases scales with the temperature @xmath69 as follow @xcite .
t < t_c : \ { cc ne^-m / t & + & + & .
e^m / t , [ taust ] and t > t_c : \ { cc nt^3 & + & + t^-2 & .
[ taugt ] at low temperatures , the fast increase of the mass gives an exponential decrease in @xmath54 with increasing @xmath69 @xcite .
in this limit , @xmath0 remains constant . at high temperatures , @xmath70 ,
the cross section becomes proportional to @xmath58 and @xmath54 linearly decreases with increasing @xmath69 . to answer the question why models used to study static properties of the qcd phases
( they might not include even the dynamics of the phase transition ) can be used in studying the transport properties , and to what extent possible defects in these models can be excused ? , we propose that the `` relaxation time '' , plays the role of a translator from
static to transport quantities and thus enables plsm to reproduce first - principle lattice calculations on both
static and transport properties .
in other words , the excellent reproduction of recent lattice qcd results should be understood due to the excellent estimation of the various plsm parameters and the good modelling of the relaxation time .
to summarize , the relaxation time was modelled in eqs .
( [ taust])-([taugt ] ) .
this modelling is not closely depending on plsm .
first , we have evaluated the plsm order - parameters as functions of temperatures by minimizing the real potential , at a saddle point .
then , we have calculated the dependence of the relaxation time on temperature , eq .
( [ rlaxtime ] ) , for which , the quark number should be calculated by defining an effective distribution function and energy - momentum dispersion relation where quark masses are coupled to the sigma fields @xmath1 and @xmath2 for light and strange quarks , respectively . as can be taken from eqs .
( [ electric_cond ] ) , ( [ heatcond ] ) , ( [ zetatmu ] ) , and ( [ etatmu ] ) , the relaxation time is an essential quantity in calculating all these transport properties .
the electrical conductivity ( @xmath71 ) is a key transport coefficient , which recently gains an increasing interest among the particle physicists .
this property is related to the flow of the charge carriers , especially in presence of an electrical field . to measure the electrical conductivity , there are two methods suggested so far . *
the first one applies an empirical methodology .
an external electrical field is applied to the system of interest . if a small uniform electric field ( @xmath72 ) is applied to the @xmath73-direction , a nonequilibrium situation results in orienting the electrical current density in that direction ( @xmath74 ) . by definition @xmath75 ,
where the proportionally constant ( @xmath71 ) is called the electrical conductivity @xcite , this relation is called ohm s law . *
the second one refers the self - interaction between quarks and gluons , i.e. , no external electrical field is needed .
the relativistic motion of the electrically charged quarks play this role .
the electrical conductivity is related to the electric flow of charged quarks .
consider light and strange quark flavors having mass ( @xmath76 ) and elementary charge ( @xmath77 ) interacting with each others , their collision time ( @xmath54 ) is determined from their scattering .
when an electrical field ( @xmath78 ) is applied in the @xmath73-direction , it gives rise to a mean @xmath73-component of the velocity ( @xmath79 ) of the charged quark flavors .
the electric current density is equal to the mean number ( @xmath80 ) crossing a unit area perpendicular to the @xmath73-direction per unit time multiplied by @xmath77 charges , i.e. , @xmath81 , j_z = ne |v_z . in a system of charged particles ,
one obtains that , @xmath82 @xcite .
furthermore , it is noteworthy highlighting that the electrical conductivity is a well known property of classical gas . at finite temperature ( @xmath69 ) and baryon chemical potential ( @xmath83 ) ,
drude - lorentz conductivity can be expressed as @xcite _ el = _
f e_f^2 , [ electric_cond ] where @xmath65 runs over quarks ( @xmath84 , @xmath85 and @xmath86 ) antiquarks ( @xmath87 , @xmath88 and @xmath89 ) and gluons @xmath25 flavors .
the electric charge of quarks are summed up as @xmath90 . in all these estimations ,
free space is assumed .
thus , the electromagnetic coupling or the fine - structure constant at zero energy is @xmath91 @xcite .
the corresponding lattice qcd calculations are normalized by @xmath92 for @xmath93 quark - flavors @xcite .
nevertheless , the electric charge of quarks is given as @xcite , e_f^2 = q^2 , where @xmath94 is the quark electric - charge fraction , @xmath95 or @xmath96 .
the functions @xmath97 , @xmath98 and @xmath99 stand for number density , collision time or relaxation time and the corresponding mass , respectively , at finite @xmath69 and finite @xmath83 . in all present calculations ,
we assume vanishing baryon chemical potential .
equation ( [ electric_cond ] ) indicates that the electrical conductivity is related to thermodynamic properties besides the relaxation time and the effective mass . as discussed in earlier section ,
having a good model for the temperature dependence of the relaxation time is very essential in enabling plsm to reproduce lattice calculation on both static ( thermodynamic quantities , for example ) and transport properties .
the left - hand panel of fig .
[ conductivity ] ( a ) shows the temperature dependence of the electrical conductivity ( @xmath100 ) at vanishing chemical potential ( @xmath62 ) . the normalized electrical conductivity calculated from plsm
is compared with difference lattice qcd calculations @xcite and with other qcd - like models such as njl and dqpm @xcite , where the circles denote lattice size @xmath101 , while the square points are calculation on @xmath102 lattice , fig .
[ conductivity ] .
both calculations assume @xmath103 quark flavors , but the lattice qcd given as closed circles @xcite , crosses @xcite and open triangles @xcite are zero - flavored .
we observe that the plsm results agree well with the lattice qcd calculations @xcite , especially at @xmath104 .
the difference between both lattice qcd simulations might be originated to the the different methods of simulations implemented on both of them .
the plsm electrical conductivity curve , which is calculated from eq .
( [ electric_cond ] ) , refers to a combination between the quark number multiplicity and their masses .
dqpm and njl results @xcite fairly agree with the lattice qcd @xcite , especially at @xmath105 . from the temperature dependence of the normalized electrical conductivity calculated from plsm and the comparison with other qcd - like models , such as njl and dqpm @xcite ,
we conclude that the plsm results are most comparable with the lattice simulations @xcite and accordingly the plsm parameters enable this qcd - like approach , in which polyakov - loop potentials are integrated , to reproduce first - principle lattice calculations .
furthermore , we conclude that , the proposed temperature dependence of the relation time , section [ sec : relxtime ] , and that of the chiral condensates and of the deconfinement order - parameters , section [ structure ] , are - besides other plsm parameters - essential in empowering su(@xmath17 ) plsm to this reliable production of the lattice qcd simulations .
the heat conductivity , @xmath106 , is related to the heat flow in relativistic fluid @xcite and gives an indicator about the rate of energy change taking place in the system of interest . a simple way to estimate the time evolution of the heat conductivity is the simulation of the likely irradiation occurring in the system through energetic ions @xcite . from specific heat ( @xmath107 ) and relaxation time ( @xmath54 )
, the heat conductivity reads @xcite , ( t , ) = _ rel c_v ( t , ) _ f _ f(t , ) , [ heatcond ] where @xmath108 is the relative velocities . all quantities in eq .
( [ heatcond ] ) are thermal averages . for simplicity , we assume that @xmath109 . for two quarks with masses @xmath110 and @xmath111 , respectively , the center - of - mass collisions result in the relative velocity @xmath112 @xcite . in the relativistic limit ,
the quark masses are negligibly small relative to the momentum , where the quark masses decrease with increase @xmath69 according to the chiral condensate , fig .
[ fig : cndst1 ] . from eq .
( [ heatcond ] ) , the heat conductivity is strongly related to the decay constant or the relaxation time of the quarks which - in tern - depends on the temperature and the baryon chemical potential .
the middle - hand panel of fig .
[ conductivity ] ( b ) shows the heat conductivity normalized to @xmath113 as a function of temperature at vanishing baryon chemical potential .
the plsm results are compared with njl and dqpm calculations @xcite .
it is worthwhile to highlight that the different models have different critical temperatures , @xmath114mev from plsm , @xmath115mev from njl and @xmath116mev from dqpm .
the temperature dependence of njl heat - conductivity normalized to @xmath113 , eq .
( [ heatcond ] ) , decreases faster than the one from plsm @xcite . from dqpm ,
the temperature dependence is the opposite . here
, increasing temperature increases the heat conductivity .
there are no lattice qcd calculations to compare with them .
equivalently , we compare our calculations on specific heat ( @xmath107 ) with recent lattice qcd calculation @xcite .
this is given in the right - hand panel ( c ) .
we find an excellent agreement , especially at low and high temperatures . at temperatures around @xmath117 ,
a peak is positioned .
it is apparently located at @xmath117 .
this can be interpreted from the definition of the specific heat ; @xmath118 , where the rapid change in the energy density ( @xmath119 ) around @xmath117 region gives a plausible interpretation of the observed peak in @xmath107 .
furthermore , this peak most - probably depends on the baryon chemical potential ( @xmath83 ) , not shown here . in a previous work
, we have shown that the peak seems to decrease with increasing the baryon chemical potential @xcite . in the present work ,
the transport properties of qcd matter in thermal medium is limited to bulk and shear viscosities .
these are strongly related to the hydrodynamical flow of relativistic fluid , qgp in our case , and the transverse motion of its constituents ( partons ) during the expansion of the strongly interacting system @xcite . in other words
, the estimation of viscosity is very crucial to characterizing the evaluation of essential physical observables such as the elliptic flow ( @xmath120 ) @xcite and the correlation functions @xcite .
corresponding to the dissipative fluxes , the green - kubo ( gk ) correlations , which are based on the linear response theory ( lrt ) @xcite , directly relate the transport coefficients to out- and in - equilibrium correlations .
it is noteworthy to emphasize that the calculation of the transport coefficients , for instance , are based on linear response to perturbation in disturbance but not perturbation in coupling .
linear response is what allows the extraction of non - equilibrium information from correlators , which are calculated in equilibrium .
the effective theory is believed to model the medium in a very different way than that in lattice qcd .
although , the lattice computation of these correlators is not the same as in an effective model , the reproduction of the first - principle calculations becomes strong evidence that certain class of correlators are correctly estimated and the parameters chosen for qcd - like approach are correctly determined .
the dissipative fluxes are treated as perturbations to local thermal - equilibrium . in doing this ,
the transport coefficients associated with conserved quantities can be formulated as expected values at equilibrium @xcite . according to green - kubo ( gk ) correlations , the bulk and shear viscosities
are given in lehmann spectral representation of two - point correlation functions as the components of the energy - momentum tensor , such as @xcite ( c + ) = _ 0^+ _ |*p*|0^+ ( c a _ ( , |*p*| ) + a _ ( , |*p*| ) ) , [ eq : matrix_field_a]where @xmath121 and @xmath122 are spectral functions @xcite a _ ( , |*p*|)&= & d^4 x e^ipx , + a _ ( , |*p*| ) & = & d^4 x e^ipx , with ( x ) & = & - t^i_i ( x ) - c_s^2 t^00 ( x ) , + ^ij(x ) & = & t^ij ( x ) - ^ij t^k_k ( x ) , and @xmath123 \rangle$ ] donates an appropriate thermal average .
the lowest - order contributions to the bulk and shear viscosity , respectively , read @xcite , ( t , ) & = & 12 _ f ^2 n_f ( t , ) , [ zetatmu ] + ( t , ) & = & 12 _ f n_f ( t , ) , [ etatmu ] where @xmath124 is the single - state energy . the factors in rhs of both expressions count for @xmath125 , spin , and particle - antiparticle degeneracies . when introducing the polyakov - loop potentials to lsm , eq .
( [ logploy ] ) , fermi - dirac distributions get modifications @xcite , @xmath126 where the corresponding functions in eq .
( [ ploykovplsm ] ) are identical . for antiquarks , @xmath3 is to be replaced by @xmath4 and the chemical potential @xmath83 by @xmath127 .
it is obvious how to assure that , in the deconfined phase , @xmath3 , @xmath128 and eq .
( [ fqaurk ] ) approaches the standard definition .
when the quarks are confined in colorless bound states , @xmath3 , @xmath129 and the boltzmann exponent will be multiplied by a factor @xmath17 . at zero polyakov loops ,
the emergence of factor @xmath17 in the boltzmann exponent assures a statistical confidence that only @xmath17-quark states and not @xmath130- or @xmath93-quark states are allowed in the statistical sum for the partition function .
the quenched lattice study of euclidean energy - momentum tensor ( @xmath131 ) correlation - function has been performed in ref .
the author aimed to introduce an analytic continuation of the lattice simulation in order to determine the real - time spectral - function and bulk viscosity .
the analyse of the spectral function [ @xmath132 in a weak coupling regime and close to the phase transition are essential quantities .
the bulk viscosity is determined as @xmath133 @xcite . at weak coupling , i.e.
, very high energies , which is related to vanishing chemical - potential , the spectral function can be calculated , perturbatively . near second - order phase - transition as found in realistic qcd , especially at the critical endpoint , scaling behaviors can be determined . in both regime , the authors of ref .
@xcite proposed to subtract perturbative contributions and by replacing the spectral function with its thermal part , the vacuum energy contribution can be removed . in left - hand panel of fig .
[ viscosity ] ( a ) , the temperature evolution of the ratio of bulk viscosity @xmath134 to the thermal entropy @xmath135 at vanishing chemical potential is presented .
the ratio of shear viscosity to the thermal entropy ( @xmath9 ) as function of temperature at vanishing chemical potential is given in the right - hand panel . at temperatures close to the critical one
, @xmath136 shows a good agreement with the lattice qcd calculations @xcite .
the agreement with lsm @xcite , dqpm and njl approaches @xcite are good , as well .
it seems that the entropy tends to vanish in order to decrease the temperature . around @xmath117 , @xmath136
rapidly decreases .
the sharp increase in bulk viscosity is positioned near the phase transition or seems to induce instability in the hydrodynamic flow of the formed qgp .
this might be responsible for some rhic observables @xcite .
thus , investigating @xmath8 would have a great impact on some experimental observables .
the shear viscosity is a very suitable quantity to understood the phase transition between hadrons and quarks . a good agreement with lattice qcd calculations @xcite and other qcd - like effective models @xcite
is observed , right - panel of fig .
[ viscosity ] ( b ) .
in particular , the lower values of the ratio of shear viscosity to entropy refers to low qgp viscosity in the partonic phase @xcite .
such decrease is caused by the stronger interactions and the effective degrees - of - freedom .
it is supported by the experimental description of the collective flow in heavy - ion collisions @xcite .
it is noteworthy noticing that the numerical estimation of viscosity normalized to entropy from plsm is higher than kss bound @xcite , which is @xmath69-independent , @xmath137 .
the left - hand panel of fig .
[ ratio_cond1_vis ] ( a ) presents the numerical estimation for @xmath138-to-@xmath139 ratio calculated from different effective su(@xmath17 ) approaches .
it is obvious that the plsm results rapidly decrease .
they are faster than the ones calculated from njl and dqpm @xcite , especially at temperatures exceeding the critical one ( @xmath117 ) .
there are no lattice qcd calculations to be compared with the present calculations . at @xmath140 ,
the ratios from the different su(@xmath17 ) approaches are distinguishable by about one order of magnitude .
the right - hand panel of fig .
[ ratio_cond1_vis ] ( b ) shows the ratio of bulk to shear viscosities ( @xmath141 ) as a function of temperature .
when the temperature approaches @xmath117 , a sudden decrease takes place and the ratio tends to be temperature - independent .
this behavior seems confirmed by recent lattice qcd calculations @xcite . in fig .
[ cond_vis ] , the ratio of bulk and shear viscosity ( each normalized to entropy ) with the electrical conductivity ( each normalized to @xmath69 ) , @xmath142 and @xmath143 , respectively , is calculated from plsm as functions of temperature .
all these quantities are dimensionless .
these predictions probably allow the check of possible scenarios for the qgp formation or when the confinement dynamics derived the hadron into parton matter .
both quantities @xmath144 and @xmath143 can be seen as pivotal insights in understanding the quarks and gluons role in the formation and the evolution of qgp . at @xmath57 ,
their temperature dependences remain constant @xcite .
the latter would be signatures of the unknown properties of qgp @xcite .
to the authors best knowledge , @xmath145 is not yet calculated in the lattice qcd .
it is found that the temperature dependence of @xmath143 is independent on the strong running coupling @xcite .
as the gluons are not charged , this ratio could be regulated by relative strength and chemical composition of the qgp @xcite at very high temperature , i.e. , @xmath146 @xcite . the reported agreement between plsm results on @xmath143 and available lattice simulations
is very convincing .
the conductivity and viscous properties are essential ingredients for the full characterization of strongly interacting qcd matter .
when the qcd system is perturbed from its equilibrium , the transport properties , such as bulk viscosity ( @xmath134 ) , shear viscosity ( @xmath147 ) , electrical conductivity ( @xmath148 ) and thermal ( heat ) conductivity ( @xmath149 ) , can be determined . for the sake of completeness , we mention that another transport coefficient that plays an important role in the hydrodynamical evolution of the qcd matter especially around phase transition , is the ratio of bulk viscosity to the thermal entropy ( @xmath9 ) .
we have employed su(@xmath17 ) plsm in charactering the temperature dependence of the transport coefficients , @xmath134 , @xmath147 , @xmath148 , and @xmath149 . in doing this , various thermodynamic quantities such as trace anomaly , speed of sound and specific heat play essential roles . also , the first- and second - order moments of the quark multiplicities , which are nothing but the quark number multiplicities and their susceptibilities , respectively , contribute to the estimation of the transport coefficients . in determining various plsm parameters ,
we have assumed a global minimization of the real potential , eq .
( [ potential ] ) . we have evaluated various plsm order - parameters including chiral condensates and polyakov - loop fields of light- and strange - quarks . for simplicity , we assume vanishing baryon chemical potential ( @xmath62 )
. the dependence of the relaxation time on the temperature is modelled .
we use eq .
( [ rlaxtime ] ) , in which the quark number is determined by defining the effective distribution - function in the presence of polyakov - loop potential .
we also use the energy - momentum dispersion - relation , where quark masses are coupled to the sigma fields for light- and strange - quarks , @xmath1 and @xmath2 , respectively .
we emphasize that the relaxation time is an essential part in our calculations for the transport coefficients from plsm , eqs .
( [ electric_cond ] ) , ( [ heatcond ] ) , ( [ zetatmu ] ) , and ( [ etatmu ] ) .
that our plsm results agree well with first - principle lattice calculations refers to good modelling for the relaxation time and precise estimation for various plsm parameters . with the introduction of the polyakov - loop potential to lsm , which have two main characteristics , namely the pure gauge potential and the absence of gluon interaction ,
we have compared the current results with the available lattice calculations .
we have found that the su(@xmath17 ) plsm fits well with the lattice qcd calculations , especially from the hot - qcd collaboration .
the chiral subtracted condensates and the order parameters are in good agreement with recent lattice calculations .
for instance , they confirm the steeper decrease around the phase transition .
the electrical conductivity has been estimated for a qcd system , in which the scattering of quarks and gluons are conjectured to be either elastic or inelastic .
this allowed the estimation of the relaxation times and decay widths .
we have deduced the dimensionless electrical conductivity normalized to @xmath113 and confronted this to recent lattice qcd .
we conclude that the present calculations , which combines the quark number multiplicity and their masses , agree well with the lattice qcd simulations , especially above @xmath117 , while the dqpm and njl obviously agree with below @xmath117 .
the temperature dependence of the plsm heat conductivity normalized to @xmath113 is compared with njl and dqpm calculations .
these different approaches have different critical temperatures , for example , in plsm @xmath114mev , njl @xmath115mev , and dqpm @xmath116mev .
we found that njl results decrease with the temperature faster than the one from plsm . from dqpm ,
the temperature dependence is the opposite to both plsm and njl .
there are no lattice qcd calculations to compare with them .
alternatively , we have compared our calculations on the specific heat with recent lattice qcd calculation .
an excellent agreement , especially at low and high temperatures , is found .
a peak at @xmath117 can be interpreted from the definition of the specific heat ; @xmath118 , where the rapid change in the energy density ( @xmath119 ) around @xmath117 region gives a plausible interpretation of the observed peak in @xmath107 .
the bulk viscosity which is related to various thermodynamic quantities , is calculated from the green - kubo correlation .
this quantity is strongly related to the phase transition and apparently responses to the instability in the hydrodynamic flow of the resulting partonic plasma . at temperatures close to @xmath117 , the ratio of bulk viscosity to entropy rapidly decreases and
a first - order phase - transition can be characterized .
there is a good agreement with the lattice qcd calculations .
the sharp increase , especially when approaching the phase transition , is conjectured to induce instability in the hydrodynamic flow of the partonic plasma .
the shear viscosity is assumed as a very suitable tool sensitive to the quark - hadron phase - transition . a good agreement with the lattice qcd calculations and with other effective qcd - like models was observed .
it is noteworthy referring to the low value of the ratio of shear viscosity to entropy ratio .
this is caused by the strong interactions and the decrease in the effective degrees of freedom .
the ratio of shear viscosity and the electrical conductivity is confronted to recent lattice qcd calculations .
a good agreement can be reported .
in particular , the low values of shear viscosity - to - entropy ratio are assumed to reflect low qgp viscosity caused by the stronger interactions and the reduction in the partonic degrees of freedom .
we argued that the ratio of both bulk and shear viscosities ( each is normalized to the thermal entropy ) and the dimensionless electrical conductivity , @xmath145 and @xmath150 would be able to favor or disfavor different phenomenological scenarios from plsm ( present work ) or pnjl or dqpm , especially when qgp cools down towards @xmath117 .
their different independent behaviors of the the different properties of qgp are regulated by the relative strength and the chemical composition of the qgp .
the transport coefficients for these different qcd - like models are apparently depending on the temperature and then chemical potential .
we conclude that the present plsm results on various transport properties , bulk viscosity ( @xmath134 ) , shear viscosity ( @xmath147 ) , electrical conductivity ( @xmath151 ) and thermal conductivity ( @xmath149 ) , show the essential ingredients that these properties would add to the study of hot and dense qcd matter .
our estimations for various plsm parameters , chiral condensates , deconfinement order - parameters and the temperature dependence of the relaxation time seem to make the qcd - like approach , plsm , able to reproduce lattice
static and transport properties .
this work is partly supported by the world laboratory for cosmology and particle physics ( wlcapp ) , http://wlcapp.net/. at would like to thank elena bratkovskaya and rudy marty for providing pnjl and dqpm results and for the fruitful discussion ! the authors gratefully thank the anonymous referee for her / his constructive comments and fruitful suggestions which helped to improve the paper !
k. fukushima , phys .
d * 77 * , 114028 ( 2008 ) . c. ratti , _ et al .
d * 73 * , 014019 ( 2005 ) .
schaefer and j. wambach , phys .
d * 75 * , 085015 ( 2007 ) .
b .- j . schaefer , j. m. pawlowski , and j. wambach , phys .
d * 76 * , 074023 ( 2007 ) .
schaefer and m. wagner , prog .
. phys . * 62 * , 381 ( 2009 ) .
schaefer , m. wagner , and j. wambach , * pos cpod * , 017 ( 2009 ) .
m. a. thaler , r. a. schneider , and w. weise , phys .
c * 69 * , 035210 ( 2004 ) .
abdel nasser tawfik and niseem magdy , phys .
c * 90 * , 015204 ( 2014 ) .
nada ezzelarab , abdel magied diab , and abdel nasser tawfik , j. phys .
. ser . * 668 * , 012102 ( 2016 ) . abdel nasser tawfik , j. phys .
. ser . * 668 * , 012082 ( 2016 ) . abdel nasser tawfik , abdel magied diab , nada ezzelarab , and asmaa g. shalaby , adv
. high energy phys . *
2016 * , 1381479 ( 2016 ) . abdel nasser tawfik , abdel magied diab , and m.t .
hussein , _ quark - hadron phase structure and qcd equations of state in vanishing and finite magnetic field _ , submitted to eur .
j. a ( 2016 ) .
abdel nasser tawfik , _ qcd phase - transition and chemical freezeout in nonzero magnetic field at nica _ , indian j. phys .
abdel nasser tawfik , abdel magied diab , and m. t. hussein , _ ``
su(@xmath17 ) polyakov linear - sigma model : magnetic properties of qcd matter in thermal and dense medium '' _ , submitted to j. phys .
g ( 2016 ) . | in mean field approximation , the grand canonical potential of su(3 ) polyakov linear-@xmath0 model ( plsm ) is analysed for chiral phase - transition , @xmath1 and @xmath2 and for deconfinement order - parameters , @xmath3 and @xmath4 of light- and strange - quarks , respectively .
various plsm parameters are determined from the assumption of global minimization of the real part of the potential .
then , we have calculated the subtracted condensates ( @xmath5 ) .
all these results are compared with recent lattice qcd simulations .
accordingly , essential plsm parameters are determined .
the modelling of the relaxation time is utilized in estimating the conductivity properties of the qcd matter in thermal medium , namely electric [ @xmath6 and heat [ @xmath7 conductivities .
we found that the plsm results on the electric conductivity and on the specific heat agree well with the available lattice qcd calculations . also , we have calculated bulk and shear viscosities normalized to the thermal entropy , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , respectively , and compared them with recent lattice qcd . predictions for @xmath10 and @xmath11 are introduced .
we conclude that our results on various transport properties show some essential ingredients , that these properties likely come up with , in studying qcd matter in thermal and dense medium . |
among the known exact solutions of einstein s field equations in general relativity there are two commonly studied metrics that describe spacetime in very different regimes .
first , the friedmann robertson
walker ( frw ) metric describes the expansion of a homogeneous and isotropic universe in terms of the scale factor @xmath4 .
the frw metric makes no reference to any particular mass points in the universe but , rather , describes a continuous , homogeneous and isotropic fluid on cosmological scales . instead of using a ` physical ' ( non - comoving ) radial coordinate @xmath1 ,
it is usually written in terms of a comoving radial coordinate @xmath5 , where @xmath6 , such that the spatial coordinates of points moving with the hubble flow do not depend on the cosmic time @xmath7 .
here the comoving coordinate @xmath5 is dimensionless , whereas the scale factor @xmath4 has units of length . for a spatially - flat frw universe , for example ,
using physical coordinates , the metric is @xmath8\,dt^2 + 2rh(t)\,dr\,dt - dr^2-r^2d\omega^2,\label{eq : frw}\ ] ] which becomes @xmath9 in comoving coordinates , where @xmath10 , @xmath11 is the hubble parameter and primes denote differentiation with respect to the cosmic time @xmath7 ( we will adopt natural units thoroughout , so that @xmath12 ) .
second , the schwarzschild metric describes the spherically symmetric static gravitational field outside a non - rotating spherical mass and can be used to model spacetime outside a star , planet or black hole .
normally the schwarzschild metric is given in ` physical ' coordinates and reads @xmath13 but another common representation of this spacetime uses the isotropic radial coordinate @xmath14 , where @xmath15 , such that @xmath16 the main problem with the schwarzschild metric in a cosmological context is that it ignores the dynamical expanding background in which the mass resides .
@xcite combined the schwarzschild and frw metrics to produce a new spherically - symmetric metric that describes a point mass embedded in an expanding spatially - flat universe .
mcvittie demanded that : 1 . at large distances from the mass the metric
is given approximately by the frw metric ( [ eq : frwco ] ) ; 2 . when expansion is ignored , so that @xmath17 , one obtains the schwarzschild metric in isotropic coordinates ( [ eq : schwiso ] ) ( whereby @xmath18 , with @xmath19 defined below ) ; 3 .
the metric is a consistent solution to einstein s field equations with a perfect fluid energy - momentum tensor ; 4 .
there is no radial matter infall .
mcvittie derived a metric satisfying these criteria for a spatially - flat background universe : @xmath20 where @xmath19 has been used to indicate mcvittie s dimensionless radial coordinate , rather than our ` physical ' coordinate . in section
[ sec : coordtrans ] we will see how the two are related and point out some of the problems with ( [ eq : mcvittieflat ] ) .
one sees that ( [ eq : mcvittieflat ] ) is a natural combination of ( [ eq : frwco ] ) and ( [ eq : schwiso ] ) ; nonetheless , there has been a long debate about its physical interpretation .
this uncertainty has recently been resolved by @xcite and @xcite , who have shown that mcvittie s metric _ does _ indeed describe a point - mass in an otherwise spatially - flat frw universe .
in this paper we have also independently arrived at the same conclusion , as discussed in section [ sec : coordtrans ] .
mcvittie also generalised his solution to accommodate spatially - curved cosmologies , which are discussed further in section [ sec : mcvittiecomparison ] . for a given matter
energy - momentum tensor , einstein s field equations for the metric @xmath21 constitute a set of non - linear differential equations that are notoriously difficult to solve . moreover , the freedom to use different coordinate systems , as illustrated above , can obscure the interpretation of the physical quantities . in a previous paper ,
@xcite presented a new approach to solving the field equations . in this method ,
one begins by postulating a tetrad ( or frame ) field consistent with spherical symmetry but with unknown coefficients , and the field equations are instead solved for these coefficients . in this paper , we follow the approach of @xcite to derive afresh the metric for a point mass embedded in an expanding universe , both for spatially - flat and curved cosmologies , and compare our results with mcvittie s metrics and with work conducted by other authors on similar models .
we also discuss the physical consequences of our derived metrics , focussing in particular on particle dynamics and the force required to keep a test particle at rest relative to the point mass .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section 2 ,
we introduce the tetrad - based method for solving the einstein equations for spherically - symmetric systems , and derive the metrics for a point mass embedded in an expanding universe for spatially - flat , open and closed cosmologies . in section 3 ,
we compare our metrics with those derived by mcvittie .
the geodesic equations for our spatially - flat metric are derived and interpreted in section 4 . in section 5
, we derive a general invariant expression , valid for arbitrary spherically - symmetric spacetimes , for the force required to keep a test particle at rest relative to the central point mass , and consider the form of this force for our derived metrics .
our conclusions are presented in section 6 .
we note that this paper is the first in a set of two . in our second paper ( nandra , lasenby & hobson 2011 ; hereinafter nlh2 )
, we focus on some of the astrophysical consequences of this work .
in particular , we investigate and interpret the zeros in our derived force expression for the constitutents of galaxies and galaxy clusters .
we derive the metric for a point mass in an expanding universe using a tetrad - based approach in general relativity ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) ; our method is essentially a translation of that originally presented by @xcite in the language of geometric algebra .
first consider a riemannian spacetime in which events are labelled with a set of coordinates @xmath22 , such that each point in spacetime has corresponding coordinate basis vectors @xmath23 , related to the metric via @xmath24 . at each point
we may also define a _ local lorentz frame _ by another set of orthogonal basis vectors @xmath25 ( roman indices ) .
these are not derived from any coordinate system and are related to the minkowski metric @xmath26 via @xmath27 .
one can describe a vector @xmath28 at any point in terms of its components in either basis : for example @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
the relationship between the two sets of basis vectors is defined in terms of tetrads , or vierbeins @xmath31 , where the inverse is denoted @xmath32 : @xmath33 it is not difficult to show that the metric elements are given in terms of the tetrads by @xmath34 .
we now consider a spherically - symmetric system , in which case the tetrads may be defined in terms of four unknown functions @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 .
note that dependencies on both @xmath1 and @xmath7 will often be suppressed in the equations presented below , whereas we will usually make explicit dependency on either @xmath1 and @xmath7 alone .
we may take the non - zero tetrad components and their inverses to be @xmath39 in so doing , we have made use of the invariance of general relativity under local rotations of the lorentz frames to align @xmath40 and @xmath41 with the coordinate basis vectors @xmath42 and @xmath43 at each point .
it has been shown in @xcite that a natural gauge choice is one in which @xmath44 , which we will assume from now on .
this is called the ` newtonian gauge ' because it allows simple newtonian interpretations , as we shall see .
using the tetrads to calculate the metric coefficients leads to the line element @xmath45 we now define the two linear differential operators @xmath46 and additionally define the functions @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 by @xmath50 where @xmath2 is a constant . assuming the matter is a perfect fluid with density @xmath51 and pressure @xmath52 , einstein s field equations and the bianchi identities can be used to yield relationships between the unknown quantities , as listed below @xcite : @xmath53 from the @xmath54 equation we now see that @xmath55 plays the role of an intrinsic mass ( or energy ) interior to @xmath1 , and from the @xmath56 equation
it also becomes clear that @xmath57 is interpreted as a radial acceleration .
in such a physical set up @xmath2 is the cosmological constant . in order to determine specific forms for the above functions it is sensible to start with a definition of the mass @xmath49 .
for a static matter distribution the density is a function of @xmath1 alone , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 .
setting @xmath60 equal to a constant @xmath61 leads specifically to the exterior schwarzschild metric in ` physical ' coordinates ( [ eq : schw ] ) . for a homogeneous background cosmology , @xmath62 and @xmath63 , leading to the frw metric in ` physical ' coordinates ( [ eq : frw ] ) . in this work
we choose @xmath55 to describe a point object with constant mass @xmath61 , embedded in a background fluid with uniform but time - dependent spatial density : @xmath64 which is easily shown to be consistent with the @xmath54 equation above . we point out that the background fluid is in fact a total ` effective ' fluid , made up of two components : baryonic matter with ordinary gas pressure , and dark matter with an effective pressure that arises from the motions of dark matter particles having undergone phase - mixing and relaxation ( see @xcite and @xcite ) .
the degree of pressure support that the dark matter provides depends on the degree of phase - mixing and relaxation that the dark matter particles have undergone , which ( in the non - static , non - virialised case ) will be a variable function of space and time .
the properties of this single ` phenomenological ' fluid , with an overall density @xmath65 , are studied in more detail in our companion paper nlh2 .
here we simply calculate the total pressure @xmath52 of the background fluid required , in the presence of a point mass @xmath61 , to solve the einstein field equations in the spherically - symmetric case .
the ` boundary condition ' on this pressure ( at least for a flat or open universe , where spatial infinity can be reached ) is that the pressure tends at infinity to the value appropriate for the type of cosmological fluid assumed .
this is @xmath66 in the present case , since we are matching to a dust cosmology .
the total pressure at finite @xmath1 may be thought of as a sum of the baryonic gas pressure and dark matter pressure , but without an explicit non - linear multi - fluid treatment we do not break the fluid up into its components in the strong - field analysis presented below .
note that the central point mass in our model is inevitably surrounded by an event horizon .
the fluid contained within this region remains trapped and can not take part in the universal background expansion , and so our expression for @xmath55 in ( [ eq : mdefn ] ) is only valid outside the schwarzschild radius .
we thus expect the metric describing the spacetime to break down at this point .
however , since one is usually most interested in the region @xmath67 ( roughly equivalent to @xmath68 ) , it is appropriate to continue using this definition for @xmath55 to study particle dynamics far away from the central point mass .
we are able to use ( [ eq : mdefn ] ) to determine specific forms for the tetrad components .
we first substitute it into the @xmath69 equation from ( [ eq : alleqns ] ) and simplify to obtain @xmath70 combining this result with the @xmath71 equation from ( [ eq : alleqns ] ) and the definition of @xmath72 from ( [ eq : quantities ] ) , one quickly finds that @xmath73 this is easily solved for @xmath74 , and hence @xmath72 , to yield @xmath75 where @xmath76 is some arbitrary function of @xmath7 . substituting these expressions into the @xmath77 equation from ( [ eq : alleqns ] ) , and using the definition of @xmath55 from ( [ eq : quantities ] ) to fix the integration constant , one finds that @xmath78 where we have defined the new function @xmath79 it should be noted that , by interpreting @xmath76 as the hubble parameter , the three terms on the right - hand - side of ( [ eq : curvature ] ) correspond to @xmath80 via the friedmann equation for a homogeneous and isotropic universe , where @xmath81 is the curvature parameter and @xmath4 is the scale factor . calculating the function @xmath57 is now straightforward from its definition in ( [ eq : quantities ] ) : @xmath82 finally , the function @xmath83 can then be calculated from the @xmath84 equation in ( [ eq : alleqns ] ) .
we thus have expressions for all the required functions @xmath83 , @xmath85 , @xmath74 , @xmath72 and @xmath57 .
we conclude our general discussion by noting the relationship between the fluid pressure @xmath86 and the function @xmath83 . combining the @xmath84 and @xmath56 equations in ( [ eq : alleqns ] ) , one quickly finds @xmath87 this first - order linear differential equation can be easily solved for @xmath86 by finding the appropriate integrating factor , and one obtains @xmath88 where @xmath89 is , in general , an arbitrary function of @xmath7 . combining this result with ( [ eq : drhodt ] ) , ( [ eq : fsolution ] ) and ( [ eq : curvature ] ) , and recalling that @xmath90 , one quickly finds that @xmath91.\ ] ] using the friedmann acceleration equation for a homogeneous and isotropic universe , one then finds that @xmath92 , where @xmath93 is the equation - of - state parameter of the cosmological fluid .
hence the relationship ( [ eq : generalp ] ) between the fluid pressure and @xmath83 becomes simply @xmath94 .
\label{eq : generalp2}\ ] ] for an frw universe without a point mass ( @xmath95 ) , in which @xmath96 , we recover the relationship @xmath97 . [
sec : flatmetric ] a number of observational studies , such as wmap @xcite , indicate that the universe is spatially flat , or at least very close to being so . in this case @xmath98 and the resulting expressions for the quantities @xmath85 , @xmath74 , @xmath72 , @xmath57 and @xmath83 are easily obtained ; these are listed in the left - hand column of table [ table : params ] .
we note that the given expression for @xmath83 is obtained by imposing the boundary condition @xmath99 as @xmath100 ; from ( [ eq : generalp2 ] ) this follows from the physically reasonable boundary condition that the fluid pressure @xmath101 as @xmath102 . [
cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ] it is found that the background densities already match in both models and correspond to the density obtained from the frw metric ; this is not suprising since we are still working within an frw background .
we can use the different forms for the pressure to define a coordinate transformation : @xmath103 it is easily shown that our metric is equal to mcvittie s metric under this transformation .
the transformation actually converts our ` physical ' radial coordinate to its comoving and isotropic analogue in a single step .
hence our metric describes the same spacetime as mcvittie s metric , with the bonus that its interpretation is more transparent in our non - comoving coordinates .
note that the limit @xmath104 corresponds to @xmath105 , leading back to the frw pressure in both cases , as expected .
the limit @xmath106 on the other hand , which also corresponds to @xmath107 , is not well - defined . as pointed out by @xcite , and more recently @xcite ,
it is clear that there is a spacelike singularity in mcvittie s metric at @xmath108 , corresponding to a diverging pressure .
the interpretation of this singularity has been under debate for some time , but we now see that it corresponds simply to the physical singularity at @xmath109 in our coordinate system .
this in turn coincides with the location of the event horizon from which the background fluid is unable to escape , as discussed in section [ sec : flatmetric ] .
thus mcvittie s metric can only be valid for @xmath110 .
this transformation to ` physical ' coordinates has also previously been pointed out by @xcite and other authors @xcite .
they have also highlighted the ` accident ' by which mcvittie initially derived his metric , which in its original form does not describe a _
central _ mass .
the mass @xmath61 is located at @xmath111 in our setup , but this does not correspond to the radial coordinate @xmath112 .
instead the point mass is located at @xmath113 , which seems rather unnatural .
mcvittie s accident led to problems in the cases of spatially curved cosmologies , as we shall see shortly .
@xcite used the transformation ( [ eq : coordtrans ] ) to allow for a more intuitive analysis of the global properties of mcvittie s metric .
in particular , nolan identified the function @xmath49 in ( [ eq : mdefn ] ) as the misner sharp energy of the spacetime @xcite .
this is a measure of the ` total energy ' of each fluid sphere in terms of the work done on it by the surrounding fluid .
we note that this was the starting point in our derivation of the metric ( [ eq : flat ] ) , as opposed to an emergent feature .
it therefore clarifies a point that has been under debate for a long time ; mcvittie s metric _ does _ indeed describe a point - mass in an otherwise spatially - flat frw universe ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) .
we have already shown that an advantage of our approach is that we have a natural way of generalising to the case of a curved cosmology . for @xmath114 ,
our model still incorporates an frw background so we would again expect our form for @xmath65 not to deviate from the standard frw result ; in particular , it should be a function of @xmath7 only .
indeed , using the general metric ( [ eq : generalmetric ] ) with @xmath85 and @xmath74 given in table [ table : params ] , we find ( again assuming @xmath115 for simplicity ) @xmath116 where the series solutions for @xmath83 for the cases @xmath117 and @xmath118 are given in ( [ eq : f1approx ] ) and ( [ eq : f1powerc2 ] ) , respectively . for mcvittie s metric ( [ eq : mcvittiegeneral ] ) , however , we find the peculiar feature that the background density does depend on the radial coordinate @xmath19 : @xmath119 where @xmath120 @xcite .
this is odd since the only apparent difference between this model and the spatially - flat case is the spacetime curvature .
@xmath114 metrics hence can not describe a mass particle embedded in a background with homogeneous density . indeed the density and pressure ( [ eq : opendensity ] ) do not even asymptotically tend to the frw solutions .
our @xmath114 metrics , which are derived by explicitly assuming a model of a point mass embedded in a homogeneous background , are therefore inherently different to mcvittie s solutions .
@xcite has used a model similar to ours to obtain a metric in the @xmath117 case that is expressed in terms of an elliptic function , but we have not yet found a coordinate transformation that equates this with our solution
. a full comparison will be the subject of future research .
the motion of a test particle moving under gravity around a central point mass in a static spacetime has been very well studied . in simple terms
, we would expect the incorporation of an expanding background to provide an additional ` force ' that alters the trajectory of the test particle .
we investigate this possibility by first calculating the geodesic equations for our metric , using the usual ` lagrangian ' technique .
we restrict our attention to the @xmath121 case , since observations indicate the universe to be very close to spatially flat @xcite .
working in the equatorial plane @xmath122 , the ` lagrangian ' corresponding to our flat metric ( [ eq : flat ] ) is @xmath123\dot{t}^2+\frac{2rh(t)}{\sqrt{1-\frac{2m}{r}}}\dot{r}\dot{t}-\frac{1}{1-\frac{2m}{r}}\dot{r}^2-r^2\dot{\phi}^2,\nonumber\ ] ] where dots denote differentiation with respect to the proper time @xmath124 of the test particle .
the three remaining geodesic equations are obtained from the euler - lagrange equations @xmath125 for @xmath126 , @xmath1 and @xmath127 . for stationary , spherically - symmetric metrics , such as the schwarzschild metric , one
can immediately obtain the first integrals of the @xmath7 and @xmath127 geodesic equations .
moreover , it is usual to replace the @xmath1 geodesic equation by its first integral @xmath128 ( for timelike geodesics ) .
these three equations can then be easily combined to obtain an ` energy equation ' in terms of @xmath1 , @xmath129 and constants of the motion only . by differentiating this equation ,
a simple expression for @xmath130 can be obtained , if desired .
this procedure is followed for the schwarzschild de sitter metric by @xcite .
our metric , however , is a function of both @xmath1 and @xmath7 , and therefore this standard approach does not prove useful in finding @xmath130 and the procedure must be modified . in our case , the @xmath1 geodesic equation is not replaced since it contains an @xmath130 term .
this is of particular interest to us in determining the nature of the gravitational ` forces ' acting on the particle .
the @xmath127 geodesic equation is @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is the specific angular momentum of the test particle . substituting this into the @xmath1 equation and rearranging gives @xmath133 the @xmath134 term
can be eliminated completely using the @xmath7-equation , so that ( [ eq : grgeodesic ] ) now becomes @xmath135 note that the @xmath136 terms above , when combined , differ very slightly from that derived in @xcite ; we believe the latter to be in error .
we now use the condition @xmath128 to eliminate the @xmath136 terms . after some algebraic manipulation this finally leads to a relatively simple exact expression for @xmath130 , namely @xmath137 it is of interest to consider special cases of ( [ eq : fullgeodesic ] ) .
first we consider the weak field approximation by assuming @xmath138 and expanding to leading order in small quantities .
we also take the low - velocity limit @xmath139 , @xmath140 . in this newtonian limit
, we find @xmath141 where @xmath142 is the deceleration parameter .
this result can also be obtained directly from our flat metric ( [ eq : flat ] ) in its newtonian limit @xcite : @xmath143dt^2 + 2rh(t)drdt - dr^2-r^2d\omega^2.\ ] ] note that this incorporates the usual low velocity approximation , but the weak field condition used is simply @xmath144 . incorporating the condition
@xmath145 as well simply leads to the flat minkowski metric , which does not effectively describe the physical system in which we are interested . we may interpret ( [ eq : newtgeo ] ) as the physical acceleration of the test particle in the newtonian limit , and hence the gravitational force per unit mass acting upon it . aside from the ` centrifugal ' term depending on the specific angular momentum @xmath132 , the terms in ( [ eq : newtgeo ] ) correspond to the standard @xmath0 inwards force due to the central mass and a cosmological force proportional to @xmath1
that is directed outwards ( inwards ) when the expansion of the universe is accelerating ( decelerating ) .
an interesting feature of the cosmological force is that its direction ( and magnitude ) depends on whether the universe is accelerating or decelerating ( as determined by the sign of @xmath146 ) .
this was pointed out previously by @xcite , and highlights the common misconception of there being some force or drag associated simply with the expansion of space ; instead the force is better associated with the _ acceleration / deceleration of the expansion_. in particular , we note that if the universe is decelerating , the cosmological force is directed inwards and the test particle inevitably moves towards the central mass @xmath61 , falls through its position and joins onto the hubble flow on the other side .
this does not , however , argue against the idea of the expansion of space .
since the current deceleration parameter @xmath147 of the universe is measured to be approximately @xmath148 @xcite , we see that the present - day cosmological force is directed outwards , as one might have naively expected intuitively .
however , since the expansion history of the current concordance model of cosmology changes from a decelerating phase to an accelerating phase at a relatively recent cosmic time , the cosmological force must reverse direction at this epoch .
a realistic scale factor corresponding to the standard spatially - flat concordance model is @xcite : @xmath149^{\frac{1}{3}},\nonumber\ ] ] where @xmath150 @xcite is the current fraction of the critical density of the universe in the form of dark energy . using this expression , in fig .
[ fig : redshift ] we plot the ratio of the cosmological force relative to its present - day value , as a function of redshift @xmath151 .
as anticipated , we see that the cosmological force reverses direction ; it is an inwards force for redshifts larger than about @xmath152 .
moreover , the magnitude of the force relative to its current value increases by a factor of @xmath153 by about @xmath154 and by a factor of nearly @xmath155 by @xmath156 ; it continues to grow with redshift quickly thereafter .
the cosmological force appears to have been correctly taken into account in cosmological simulation codes .
for example , in @xcite and @xcite , dark matter and stars are modelled as self - gravitating collisionless fluids following the collisionless boltzmann equation , and this term appears in the equation of motion of the particles . for a single central mass @xmath61 , the equation of motion of a test particle
is taken as @xmath157 where @xmath5 represents comoving coordinates . converting to
` physical ' coordinates via @xmath158 recovers the result ( [ eq : newtgeo ] ) with @xmath159 .
we perform a full exploration of the astrophysical consequences of the geodesic equation ( [ eq : newtgeo ] ) in our companion paper nlh2 .
we also note that @xcite has used a very similar geodesic equation to analyse the motion of an electron orbiting a central nucleus , with a slight modification to account for the dominant electrostatic force in that problem .
an extension of this work is also presented in nlh2 .
it is , of course , of interest to calculate the ` force ' experienced by the particle in the fully general - relativistic case .
this is discussed in detail in the next section , but as a prelude let us return briefly to ( [ eq : fullgeodesic ] ) and consider a particle released from rest , for which @xmath160 .
thus , instantaneously , one has @xmath161
one should bear in mind at this point , however , that the ` physical ' coordinate @xmath1 is not a proper radial distance . hence one can not simply interpret ( [ eq : finalgeodesic ] ) as the instantaneous force on a particle released from rest , or equivalently the negative of the force required to keep a test particle at rest relative to the central point mass . the proper expression for this force
is derived in the next section .
we now derive a fully general - relativistic invariant expression , valid for any spherically - symmetric system , for the radial force required to hold a test particle at rest relative to the central point mass .
we first point out that the relationship between the ` physical ' coordinate @xmath1 and proper radial distance @xmath162 to the point mass is defined through @xmath163 .
it is therefore only in the spatially - flat case , for which @xmath164 is independent of @xmath7 , that @xmath165 or @xmath166 are equivalent conditions . in general
, one must thus choose which condition defines ` at rest ' . here
we will adopt the condition @xmath165 , which corresponds physically to keeping the test particle on the surface of a sphere with proper area @xmath167 . in practice
, it would probably be easier for an astronaut ( i.e. test particle ) to make a local measurement to determine the proper area of the sphere on which he is located , rather than to determine his proper distance to the point mass , particularly in the presence of horizons . with this proviso , our derivation is valid for arbitrary tetrad components @xmath83 , @xmath85 and @xmath74 ( but we assume the newtonian gauge @xmath44 ) . in general , the invariant force ( per unit mass ) acting on a particle is equal simply to its proper acceleration , i.e. the acceleration of the particle as measured in its instantaneous rest frame .
we must therefore find an expression for the proper acceleration of a particle held at rest relative to the central point mass .
this may be calculated directly in the coordinate basis , but it is more instructive for our purposes , and simpler , to perform the calculation in the tetrad frame .
the tetrad frame defines a family of ideal observers , such that the integral curves of the timelike unit vector field @xmath168 are the worldlines of these observers , and at each event along a given worldline , the three spacelike unit vector fields @xmath25 @xmath169 specify the spatial triad carried by the observer .
the triad may be thought of as defining the spatial coordinate axes of a local laboratory frame , which is valid very near the observer s worldline . in general , the worldlines of these observers need not be timelike geodesics , and hence the observers may be accelerating .
let us first consider the four - velocity and proper acceleration of the observer defined by our tetrad frame ( [ eq : tetrads ] ) .
the four - velocity of the observer is simply @xmath170 , so that , by construction , the components of the four - velocity in the tetrad frame are @xmath171 = [ 1,0,0,0]$ ] .
since @xmath172 , the four - velocity may be written in terms of the tetrad components and the coordinate basis vectors as @xmath173 .
thus , the components of the observer s four - velocity in the coordinate basis are simply @xmath174 = [ \dot{t},\dot{r},\dot{\theta},\dot{\phi}]=[f_1,g_2,0,0]$ ] , where dots denote differentiation with respect to the observer s proper time .
hence , for all our previously derived metrics , we see from table [ table : params ] that @xmath175 .
since the comoving radial coordinate is defined through @xmath176 , we deduce that @xmath177 .
hence the observer is not comoving with the hubble flow .
instead , since @xmath178 is negative , the observer s comoving radial coordinate is decreasing .
this behaviour is due to the presence of the central point mass , which results in our observer not moving geodesically ( except as @xmath179 ) .
this is easily seen by calculating the proper acceleration @xmath180 of our observer , which is given by @xmath181 , where @xmath182 is the four - acceleration of the observer .
it is straightforward to show that , for a body moving with general four - velocity @xmath28 , the four - acceleration is given in terms of the coordinate basis and the tetrad basis respectively by @xmath183 where @xmath184 are the connection coefficients corresponding to the metric ( [ eq : generalmetric ] ) and @xmath185 are known as ricci s coefficients of rotation or the spin - connection .
it has been shown by , for example , @xcite that these can be written in terms of the tetrad components as @xmath186 it follows that @xmath187 is anti - symmetric in the first two indices , and @xmath188 is anti - symmetric in the last two indices .
for general radial motion @xmath189 , in which case the components of the four - acceleration in the tetrad frame reduce to @xmath190 and @xmath191 .
it follows that for general radial motion only @xmath192 ( @xmath193 ) and @xmath194 ( @xmath195 ) need to be computed . using ( [ eq : cdefn ] ) , the definitions of the tetrads and their inverses ( [ eq : tetrads ] ) and the relations given in equation ( [ eq : quantities ] ) , one can show that @xmath196 this highlights that the functions @xmath72 and @xmath57 defined earlier are in fact components of the spin - connection ; indeed this is how @xcite originally defined them , but using geometric algebra .
hence the components of the four - acceleration in the tetrad frame for general radial motion are @xmath197 if we now specialise to the case where @xmath198 , the four - velocity of our observer , then @xmath171=[1,0,0,0]$ ] , and so @xmath199 = [ 0,g,0,0]$ ] .
thus the proper acceleration of our observer is @xmath200 , which coincides with our earlier identification of @xmath57 as a radial acceleration .
equivalently , the invariant force per unit rest mass @xmath201 ( provided , for example , by a rocket engine ) required to keep the observer in this state of motion has magnitude @xmath57 in the outwards radial direction .
let us now consider a particle in general radial motion such that its four - velocity components in the tetrad frame are @xmath202,\label{eq : velalpha}\ ] ] where @xmath203 is the particle s rapidity in that frame and @xmath124 is the particle s proper time . using the tetrad definitions ( [ eq : tetrads ] ) one can show that these components are related to those in the coordinate basis by @xmath204 substituting the coefficients ( [ eq : velalpha ] ) into the equations in ( [ eq : v2 ] ) , we find that the components of the particle s four - acceleration in the tetrad frame are given by @xmath205 , \nonumber \\
\hat{a}^1&=\cosh\psi(\tau)\left[\dot{\psi}(\tau ) + g\cosh\psi(\tau ) + f\sinh\psi(\tau)\right].\label{eq : v2-again}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , the particle s proper acceleration @xmath206 , and hence the invariant force per unit rest mass @xmath201 required to maintain the particle in this state of motion , is @xmath207 it is worth considering also the expression for @xmath130 in terms of the force @xmath201 applied to the particle . differentiating equation ( [ eq : rdotgeneral ] ) with respect to the proper time of the particle , one obtains @xmath208,\label{eq : ddotrpenultimate}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which , on substituting for @xmath209 from ( [ eq : forcegen ] ) , gives @xmath210\nonumber\\ & \ \times\left[g_1\cosh\psi(\tau)+g_2\sinh\psi(\tau)\right ] .
\label{eq : rddotultimate}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now consider the special case of a particle at rest relative to the central point mass . in this case ,
@xmath165 and from ( [ eq : rdotgeneral ] ) it is found that @xmath211 .
moreover , since the magnitude of the four - velocity must be unity , we deduce that @xmath212 .
hence , the four - velocity ( [ eq : velalpha ] ) may be written @xmath213 .
\label{eq : covvol}\ ] ] using these expressions for @xmath214 and @xmath215 in ( [ eq : forcegen ] ) , the force per unit rest mass @xmath201 required to keep the test particle at rest is found to be @xmath216.\label{eq : finalforcegen}\ ] ] for general radial motion , @xmath217 , but in this case @xmath165 and from ( [ eq : rdotgeneral ] ) and ( [ eq : covvol ] ) we find @xmath218 .
we thus obtain @xmath219.\label{eq : finalforcegen2}\ ] ] hence , the required force is determined by the tetrad components themselves and also some of their derivatives with respect to @xmath7 and @xmath1 ( the latter through the functions @xmath72 and @xmath57 ) .
it is of interest to compare our expression for @xmath201 in ( [ eq : finalforcegen ] ) with the expression ( [ eq : rddotultimate ] ) for @xmath130 in the special case of a particle _ released _ from rest , for which @xmath220 and @xmath165 . in this case , using ( [ eq : covvol ] ) , we find that , instantaneously , @xmath221 .
\label{eq : finalddotr}\ ] ] thus , we see that the force @xmath201 ( per unit rest mass ) in ( [ eq : finalforcegen ] ) required to keep a test particle at rest is related to the instantaneous value of @xmath130 for a particle released from rest by @xmath222 the force expression ( [ eq : finalforcegen2 ] ) in this general form can be applied to any spherically - symmetric system for which the required quantities can be computed .
below , we will obtain the expressions for @xmath201 in each of our newly - derived metrics . before we consider each metric separately
, however , it is worth noting that the force ( [ eq : finalforcegen2 ] ) becomes singular at any point where @xmath223 . in the case of our newly derived metrics , we see from table [ table : params ] that this corresponds to where @xmath224 which is valid for @xmath121 and @xmath114 .
introducing the curvature density parameter
@xmath225 ^ 2 = 1-\omega(t)$ ] , where @xmath226 is the total density parameter , the above condition becomes @xmath227 comparing this condition with ( [ eq : closedsings ] ) , we see that one has simply replaced @xmath228 by @xmath229 $ ] .
consequently , provided @xmath230 $ ] , ( [ eq : forcesings ] ) has three real roots , one of which lies at negative @xmath1 and the remaining two lie at @xmath231 and @xmath232 given by ( [ eq : cubicsols ] ) , but with @xmath4 replaced by @xmath233 . in particular , the force @xmath201 becomes infinite _ outside _ the schwarzschild radius @xmath109 and _ inside _ the ` scaled ' hubble radius @xmath234 .
the functions defining the metric for a point mass embedded in a spatially - flat universe @xmath235 are given in table [ table : params ] .
to calculate @xmath201 , we must also evaluate @xmath236 and @xmath237 , which are easily shown to be @xmath238 thus the outward force @xmath201 required to keep a test particle at rest relative to the central point mass is @xmath239 comparing ( [ eq : flatforcefull ] ) with the expression ( [ eq : finalgeodesic ] ) giving the instantaneous value of @xmath130 for a particle released from rest in this spacetime , we see that they indeed obey the relationship ( [ eq : fvsddotr ] ) . assuming @xmath240 , expanding ( [ eq : flatforcefull ] ) in small quantities one finds that the zeroth order term is simply @xmath241 , consistent with newtonian gravity .
we are interested in where the cosmological expansion parameter @xmath76 enters into the force expression , and we find that it does so at first order in small quantities . keeping the leading terms , one obtains @xmath242 which is consistent with the corresponding equation of motion ( [ eq : newtgeo ] ) in the newtonian limit for a particle moving radially under gravity .
finally , for comparison against the equivalent open and closed universe results , note that keeping all terms up to second order in small quantities leads to the expression @xmath243 the functions defining the @xmath117 metric are listed in table [ table : params ] , and it can be shown that @xmath236 and @xmath237 are given by @xmath244 thus the expression for the required outward force is @xmath245f_1}{\left(1-\frac{2m}{r}+\frac{r^2}{r^2(t ) } -r^2h^2(t)\right)^{3/2}}.\label{eq : openforcefull}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit @xmath246 , this expression reduces to the force ( [ eq : flatforcefull ] ) in the spatially - flat case , as might be expected . assuming that @xmath138 , expanding ( [ eq : openforcefull ] ) in small quantities and keeping only the leading terms at first order , the force is found to be given by equation ( [ eq : forcefinal ] ) .
thus in this limit the force in an open universe is indistiguishable from that in a spatially - flat universe .
the differences between the two become visible only when expanding up to second order in small quantities : @xmath247 the only difference between this expression and the corresponding spatially - flat result ( [ eq : forcefinalexpanded ] ) is the extra negative contribution proportional to @xmath248 .
this can be interpreted as an ` anti - gravitational ' force experienced by the test particle due to a virtual ` image ' mass dragged out to the curvature scale of the universe .
since @xmath249 this term is negligible compared to the @xmath241 term , and hence the force is not significantly altered relatively to the spatially - flat case . the functions defining the closed universe ( @xmath118 ) metric are listed in table [ table : params ] . in this case , @xmath250 thus the expression for the required outward force is @xmath251f_1}{\left(1-\frac{2m}{r } -\frac{r^2}{r^2(t ) } -r^2h^2(t)\right)^{3/2}}.\label{eq : closedforcefull}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit @xmath246 , this expression also reduces to the force ( [ eq : flatforcefull ] ) in the spatially - flat case . assuming that @xmath138 , expanding ( [ eq : closedforcefull ] ) in small quantities and keeping the leading terms up to first order , the force is once again found to be given by equation ( [ eq : forcefinal ] ) . in this limit
the force in a closed universe is thus indistiguishable from that in a spatially - flat or open universe .
any differences again only become visible when expanding up to second order in small quantities : @xmath252 thus we see that the only difference between this force and the corresponding result ( [ eq : forcefinalopen ] ) for an open universe is the sign of the extra contribution proportional to @xmath248 . in a closed universe , this contribution to the force by the ` image ' mass , which in this case can be viewed as a real object , is of the same sign as that due to the original mass .
once again , however , since @xmath249 this term is negligible compared to the @xmath241 term , and hence the force is not significantly altered relative to the spatially - flat case .
in this paper , we have presented a tetrad - based method for solving einstein s field equations in general relativity for spherically - symmetric systems .
our method is essentially a translation of the method originally presented by @xcite in the language of geometric algebra .
we use this technique to derive the metrics describing a point mass embedded in an homogeneous and isotropic expanding fluid , for a spatially - flat , open and closed universe , respectively . in the closed universe case
, the lack of the notion of spatial infinity means that considerable care is required to determine the appropriate boundary conditions on the solution .
we find that in the spatially - flat case , our metric is related by a coordinate transformation to the corresponding metric derived by @xcite .
nonetheless , our use of ` physical ' coordinates greatly facilitates the physical interpretaion of the solution . for the open and closed universes , however , our metrics differ from the corresponding mcvittie metrics , which we believe to be incorrect .
we derive the geodesic equation for the motion of a test particle under gravity in our spatially - flat metric . for radial motion in the newtonian limit
, we find that the gravitational force on a test particle consists of the standard @xmath0 inwards force due to the central mass and a cosmological force proportional to @xmath1 that is directed outwards ( inwards ) when the expansion of the universe is accelerating ( decelerating ) .
for the standard @xmath2cdm concordance cosmology , the cosmological force thus reverses direction at about @xmath3 , when the expansion of the universe makes a transition from a decelerating to an accelerating phase .
it is expected that this phenomenon has a significant impact on the growth and evolution of structure , particularly around @xmath253 ; a detailed investigation of this is a subject for further study .
nonetheless , we believe this effect is implicitly included in existing numerical simulation codes . in our companion paper nlh2 , we will show how the cosmological force leads to a maximum size for a bound object such as a galaxy or cluster , and explore the stability of bound orbits around the central mass .
we also used our tetrad - based approach to derive an invariant fully general - relativistic expression , valid for arbitrary spherically - symmetric systems , for the force required to keep a test particle at rest relative to the central mass .
we apply this result to our derived metrics in the spatially - flat , open and closed cases . to first order in small quantities
the force in all three cases is the same , but differences become visible when considering the second order terms .
interestingly , we find that the force in an open universe has an additional component that may be interpreted as a gravitationally repulsive term due to an ` image ' mass @xmath61 dragged out to the curvature scale of the universe .
a similar term , but with the opposite sign , is present in the force in a closed universe , and results from an image mass at the antipodal point of the universe . in both cases , however , the additional components are neglible at distances from the original central mass that are small compared with the curvature scale , and so in practical terms the force in a spatially - curved universe is not significantly different from that in the spatially - flat case .
it must be pointed out that our assumption that the background fluid density @xmath65 is spatially uniform may be questionable , since the point mass breaks homogeneity .
the correct treatment of the background may require @xmath254 also to depend on the radial coordinate @xmath1 , which would significantly complicate the equations and would probably not yield analytical solutions .
it is interesting that mcvittie s @xmath114 solutions do in fact yield background densities dependent on both @xmath1 and @xmath7 .
nonetheless , since the point mass in our model does not occupy any space in the background , and also because we have ultimately been interested in @xmath67 , assuming @xmath62 is a good approximation .
note that we will improve our model by accounting for the finite size of the central object in a subsequent paper .
we will consider only spatially homogenous objects for simplicity , but we leave the consideration of more general radial density profiles for future research .
we also note that our approach may be extended to systems with accretion onto the central mass by the replacement of @xmath255 in equation ( [ eq : mdefn ] ) ; a full analysis of this will also be presented in a future publication .
rn is supported by a research studentship from the science and technology facilities council ( stfc ) .
arakida h. , 2009 , new astronomy , 14 , 264 balaguera - antolnez a. , bhmer g.c . , nowakowski m. , 2006 , class .
grav . , 23 , 485 binney j. , tremaine s. , 2008 , galactic dynamics , 2nd ed . , princeton university press bolen b. , bombelli l. , puzio r. , 2001 , class
grav . , 18 , 1173 carrera m. , giulini d. , 2010 , phys .
d , 81,043521 carrera m. , giulini d. , 2010 , rev .
phys . , 82 , 169 carroll s.m . , 2003 ,
spacetime and geometry , addison wesley , new york davis t.m .
, lineweaver c.h .
, webb j.k . , 2003 , american journal of physics , 71 , 358 faraoni v. , jacques a. , 2007 , phys .
d , 76 , 063510 hobson m.p .
, efstathiou g. , lasenby a.n . , 2006 .
general relativity , cambridge university press , new york kaloper n. , kleban k. , martin d. , 2010 , phys .
d , 81 , 104044 kibble t.w.b .
, 1961 , j. math .
phys . , 2 , 212 lake k. , abdelqader m. , 2011 , phys .
d , 84 , 044045 larson d. et al .
, 2011 , apjss , 192 , 16 lasenby a. , doran c. , gull s. , 1998 , phil .
r. soc . lond .
a , 356 , 487 lynden - bell d. , 1967 , mnras , 136 , 101 mcvittie g.c . , 1933 , mnras , 93 , 325 mcvittie g.c . , 1956 , the int .
general relativity and cosmology , chapman & hall , london misner c.w .
, sharp d.h . , 1964 ,
, 136 , b571 nandra r. , lasenby a.n . ,
hobson m.p .
, 2012 , mnras ( nlh2 ) , 422 , 2945 nesseris s. , perivolaropoulos l. , 2004 , phys .
d , 70 , 123529 nolan b.c .
, 1998 , phys .
d , 58 , 064006 nolan b.c .
, 1999 , class .
grav . , 16 , 1227 nolan b.c . , 1999 , class .
grav . , 16 , 3183 price r.h . , 2005 , arxiv : gr - qc/0508052v2 springel v. , yoshida n. , white s.d.m . , 2001 , new astronomy , 6 , 79 springel v. , 2005 , mnras , 364
, 1105 uzan j .-
p . , ellis g.f.r . , larena j. , 2011 , gen . | a tetrad - based procedure is presented for solving einstein s field equations for spherically - symmetric systems ; this approach was first discussed by lasenby , doran & gull in the language of geometric algebra .
the method is used to derive metrics describing a point mass in a spatially - flat , open and closed expanding universe respectively . in the spatially - flat case
, a simple coordinate transformation relates the metric to the corresponding one derived by mcvittie .
nonetheless , our use of non - comoving ( ` physical ' ) coordinates greatly facilitates physical interpretation . for the open and closed universes ,
our metrics describe different spacetimes to the corresponding mcvittie metrics and we believe the latter to be incorrect . in the closed case ,
our metric possesses an image mass at the antipodal point of the universe .
we calculate the geodesic equations for the spatially - flat metric and interpret them . for radial motion in the newtonian limit ,
the force acting on a test particle consists of the usual @xmath0 inwards component due to the central mass and a cosmological component proportional to @xmath1 that is directed outwards ( inwards ) when the expansion of the universe is accelerating ( decelerating ) . for the standard @xmath2cdm concordance cosmology , the cosmological force reverses direction at about @xmath3 .
we also derive an invariant fully general - relativistic expression , valid for arbitrary spherically - symmetric systems , for the force required to hold a test particle at rest relative to the central point mass .
[ firstpage ] gravitation cosmology : theory black hole physics |
the first mathematical descriptions of the effects of gravity , made by galileo in his study of the free fall of bodies and by kepler in his study of planetary motions , were purely empirical . though newton offered a coherent explanation of what was behind the laws governing gravitational effects , it was only with einstein s general relativity that we had an apparently complete theory of gravity . however , at the end of the 20@xmath3 century , a new enigma concerning the motion of ` celestial bodies ' emerged , in particular , in studying rotation curves of spiral galaxies .
while newton s law of gravity predicts that the velocity of rotation in the interior of a galaxy should fall with increasing distance from the galactic center if the observed light traces mass , what is observed is the maintenance of a constant velocity with increasing radius , generating flat rotation curves @xcite .
two simple ways of dealing with this problem have been suggested : 1 . assuming that there is more mass ( _ i.e. _ , dark matter ) in galaxies than is observed ; 2 . modifying the law of gravity .
while much work has been done in the search for possible particle candidates for dark matter @xcite , very little has been done to explore the possibilities of modified gravity laws . until now
, the most popular suggestion for a modified gravitational law has been modified newtonian dynamics , or , mond @xcite . in mond the acceleration @xmath4 of a body in an external gravitational field
is not exactly equal to the acceleration @xmath5 obtained from the newtonian gravitational force .
mathematically , one can write @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is a dimensionless function of the ratio @xmath8 of the acceleration @xmath4 to an empirically determined constant @xmath9 . only in the limit
@xmath10 is newtonian gravity restored .
the strongest objection to mond is that it does not have a relativistic theory supporting it . for recent articles criticizing mond ,
see scott _
( 2001 ) @xcite and aguirre _ et al . _
( 2001 ) @xcite .
for a recent positive review of mond , see sanders ( 2001 ) @xcite .
the objective of this letter is to expand the original mond proposal by presenting mathematical alternatives for the modified gravitational law .
specifically , we present several alternative mathematical alternative formulations for the dimensionless function @xmath11 , thus following closer the structure of the pioneering work of mond by milgrom @xcite . in the next section we present the basics of mond .
simulated rotation curves for several possible mondian - like functions are given in section [ sec : formulas ] .
the final section presents some brief conclusions and perspectives for future work .
as discussed in the introduction , the original mond proposal uses the relation @xmath12 where @xmath5 is the usual newtonian acceleration and @xmath13 is a function which obeys @xmath14 therefore , in the limit of large accelerations , @xmath15 , the usual newtonian gravity law is obtained . in the other extreme , @xmath16 , however , we have @xmath17 thus , using @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the rotation velocity of the galaxy , @xmath20 which is a constant , as is observed for large galactic radii .
it is common in the literature ( _ e.g. _ @xcite , @xcite ) to use the expression @xmath21 this formula , proposed by milgrom @xcite , has the advantage of being invertible . with it one
can solve eq .
( [ mond ] ) analytically for the acceleration @xmath4 and , consequently , for the rotation velocity @xmath19 as a function of the radius @xmath22 .
however , other functions are also possible , and are discussed in the next section .
in his work on the implications of mond for galaxies @xcite , milgrom used as a model for a spiral galaxy of total mass @xmath23 , a disc of mass @xmath24 and a central spheroidal bulge of mass @xmath25 .
the fractional masses for the disc and the spherical bulge are @xmath26 and @xmath27 , respectively , so that the total fractional mass @xmath28 inside a radius @xmath29 is @xmath30 where @xcite @xmath31 \;,\ ] ] @xmath32 and @xmath33 is the incomplete gamma function . @xmath34 and @xmath35 are numerical constants .
the dimensionless variable @xmath36 is the ratio of the radius @xmath22 to the characteristic length @xmath1 .
the ratio of @xmath37 to @xmath1 , @xmath38 , is less than unity .
the radii @xmath1 and @xmath37 are obtained , in practice , by adjusting the luminosity profiles of the spheroidal and disc components , using the empirical law of de vaucoulers for the spherical bulge and an exponential function for the disc . following the mond proposal ,
we define @xmath39 where @xmath40 is a dimensionless function with a dimensionless argument @xmath41 , similar to the @xmath11 of milgrom @xcite in eq .
( [ mu ] ) .
this new function @xmath42 is such that @xmath43 we investigate the following functions @xmath44 which obey the constraints of eq .
( [ constraints ] ) : @xmath45 the behaviour of each of these functions as a function of @xmath46 can be seen in the expansions @xcite@xmath47 ^{-1 } & \\ & \simeq 1 + 27y^2/45-\left ( 27y/45\right ) ^4+\left ( 27y/45\right ) ^6 + ... & \left ( y\ll 1\right ) \end{array } \end{array } \right.\;\;.\ ] ] the functions are plotted in figure [ galmond4 ] . using these functions , together with equations ( [ gamma ] ) ,
( [ gammad ] ) and ( [ gamas ] ) , we obtain curves for the dimensionless rotation velocity @xmath48 as a function of @xmath49 for different values of @xmath23 , @xmath50 , and @xmath38 .
the curves are shown in figures [ galmond6 ] and [ galmond7 ] .
inspection of figures [ galmond6 ] and [ galmond7 ] shows clearly that all the functions @xmath42 produce flat rotation curves .
this is true not only for the particular values of @xmath23 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 of the figures , but for the entire range of physically reasonable values for these parameters .
figure [ galmond7 ] shows that a comparison between the curves obtained , using the different @xmath53 functions presented , together with the original milgrom proposal ( eq .
( [ mu ] ) ) , may be useful to distinguish between them , since each curve has a peculiar feature in the region @xmath2
. it would be interesting to test the formulas presented here against observational data , noting that @xmath54 and @xmath52 are not free parameters , but are given by the luminosity profiles of the galaxies .
the mass @xmath23 and the constant @xmath9 are the only free parameters to be adjusted .
the study of different galaxies gives a single value for @xmath9 , the mass @xmath23 and the mass - luminosity ratio , @xmath55 , of each galaxy .
@xmath11 and @xmath56 can lead to different relativistic extensions of mond , important for future studies .
for instance , using the expression for the gravitational potential @xmath57 , valid for purely radial forces , one can naively ascribe a @xmath58 to the modified gravitational laws obtained with @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 , for example , @xmath62 @xmath63 and @xmath64 + \varphi_0 \;\;,\ ] ] where @xmath65 is a constant of integration .
therefore , in the search for a complete theory for mond , it is important to study alternative mondian functions .
the mondian functions given in this letter can be seen as a step in this direction .
ssc thanks the brazilian agency fapesp for financial support under grant 00/13762 - 6 .
both ssc and ro thank fapesp for partial support under grant 00/06770 - 2 and the brazilian project pronex / finep ( 41.96.0908.00 ) for partial support . | we present new mathematical alternatives for explaining rotation curves of spiral galaxies in the mond context . for given total masses , it is shown that various mathematical alternatives to mond , while predicting flat rotation curves for large radii ( @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the characteristic radius of the galactic disc ) , predict curves with different peculiar features for smaller radii ( @xmath2 ) .
they are thus testable against observational data . , gravitation : phenomenology , galaxies : internal motions 04.90.+e , 95.30.sf , 98.62.dm |
a majority of stars are in binaries , and a substantial fraction of binaries have short enough orbital periods that they are likely to interact during either their main sequence or post - main sequence evolution .
many of the most interesting phenomena in astronomy can be directly traced to the interaction of close binaries ; an incomplete list would include binary neutron stars and white dwarfs , supernovae ia , cataclysmic variables , and blue stragglers .
there is a vast literature on the subject ( e.g. , paczynski 1971 ; wellstein & langer 1999 ; hurley , tout & pols 2002 ; belczynski , kalogera & bulik 2002b ) .
although there are many ingredients that must be considered in interacting binaries , an implicit assumption in much theoretical work has been that the lifetimes of the stars are almost always quite different .
this assumption arises naturally from two considerations .
first , the single star initial mass function ( imf ) is a steep function of mass , with low mass stars being far more numerous than high mass stars ( e.g. salpeter 1955 ) , and strong mass - lifetime relationship for all but the most massive stars implies a large lifetime difference unless the masses are very close .
second , a flat mass ratio spectrum ( see for example kuiper 1935 ) for binaries that are likely to interact is adopted in most population synthesis studies , leading to very few `` equal '' component mass binaries .
pinsonneault & stanek ( 2006 ) have argued that observations indicate the existence of a substantial population of nearly equal mass binaries ( `` twins '' ) . in such systems
a strong inequality in lifetime is not present , so there might be important qualitative differences in their evolution compared to unequal mass binaries .
survey of astronomical literature strongly suggests binary twins are a general feature of close binary population , as a peak near @xmath10 was reported by a number of investigators .
for example , halbwachs et al .
( 2003 ) studied a large sample of spectroscopic binaries type f7 to k ( masses from about 1.7 down to @xmath11 ) , including binaries in open clusters .
they find that the mass ratio has a broad peak from @xmath12 to @xmath13 , and a sharp peak for @xmath14 .
as they discuss , the strength of the peak for @xmath14 gradually decreases with the increasing orbital period , which is to be expected
. the fraction of twins can be as high as @xmath15 for periods @xmath16days and it is still significant ( as high as 35% ) for much longer periods of up to 1000 days .
a much earlier study by lucy & ricco ( 1979 ) also finds a strong and narrow peak of binaries with @xmath17 , again using a sample of spectroscopic binaries corrected for various observational errors and biases .
tokovinin ( 2000 ) confirms that finding using additional data and in fact also calls this population `` twins '' , arguing that they constitute 10 - 20% of the total binary population in the @xmath18 days regime .
additional , although perhaps more anecdotal support for the significant twin population comes from the realm of very high mass stars found in eclipsing binaries . the most massive binary known , wr 20a ( rauw et al .
2004 ; bonanos et al . 2004 ) , is an eclipsing system , so the masses of both components can be measured accurately .
the masses are @xmath19 and @xmath20 ( rauw et al .
2005 ) , giving a mass ratio of @xmath21 .
given that @xmath22 stars are extremely rare ( both due to the steepness of the mass function and their short lifetime ) , having such extremely massive secondary would be quite unlikely unless the twin phenomenon is involved .
there are also some theoretical considerations that seem to indicate that double neutron star binaries form _ only _ from twins ( bethe & brown 1998 ; chang - hwan , hong - jo & brown 2007 ) .
if this is the only double neutron star formation scenario , the twin fraction must be high to explain the observed rates of these binary systems
. however , not all evidence points towards a large population of twins .
first , there are some loopholes to the arguments pushing toward the theoretical requirement of twins to make double neutron star systems . in addition
, the existence of low - mass x - ray binaries requires some systems with very different masses ( kalogera & webbink 1998 ; fryer , burrows & benz 1998 ) .
even with the intermediate - mass progenitors of these low - mass x - ray binaries ( podsiadlowski , rappaport & pfahl 2002 ) , a large twin fraction coupled on top of a otherwise flat mass ratio distribution would have trouble explaining low - mass x - ray binaries .
finally , not all the observational evidence points toward a twin fraction .
kobulnicky & fryer ( 2007 ) argue that for their dataset of 120 o and early b stars , the twin fraction must be less than 25% .
their study used one of the largest datasets of o and early b stars focusing on a single stellar association - cygnus ob2 ( kiminki et al .
2007 ) . with observations and theory arguing both for and against twins , we investigate the effect of twin binaries on population of close ( coalescing within hubble time ) double compact objects , focusing on observations that might allow us to distinguish a twin population of stars from the more standard stellar mass ratio distributions
in this study we present the population synthesis study of double neutron star ( ns - ns ) , black hole neutron star ( bh - ns ) and double black hole ( bh - bh ) progenitors .
we employ two basic calculations ; one with the usually adopted flat mass ratio distribution and one that includes a very large ( @xmath15 ) population of twins .
the results are discussed in context of double compact object mergers that are expected to be the prime sources of gravitational radiation for ground based observatories like ligo or virgo ( e.g. , kalogera et al .
2007 ) , and are also considered as very likely short - hard gamma ray burst progenitors ( nakar 2007 ) . in a forthcoming paper ( belczynski & pinsonneault , in prep . )
we will study the influence of twins on lighter compact object binaries with white dwarfs and their connection to type ia supernovae and formation of blue stragglers .
binary population synthesis is used to calculate the merger rates and properties of double compact objects . the population synthesis code employed in this work , startrack , was initially developed for the study of double compact object mergers in the context of gamma - ray burst ( grb ) progenitors ( belczynski , bulik & rudak 2002a ) and gravitational - wave inspiral sources ( belczynski et al .
in recent years startrack has undergone major updates and revisions in the physical treatment of various binary evolution phases , and especially mass transfer phases .
the new version has already been tested and calibrated against observations and detailed binary mass transfer calculations ( belczynski et al .
2007a ) , and has been used in various applications ( e.g. , belczynski , bulik & ruiter 2005 ; belczynski et al .
2006 ; belczynski et al .
the physics updates that are most important for compact object formation and evolution include : a full numerical approach to orbital evolution due to tidal interactions , calibrated using high mass x - ray binaries and open cluster observations , a detailed treatment of mass transfer episodes fully calibrated against detailed calculations with a stellar evolution code , updated stellar winds for massive stars , and the latest determination of the natal kick velocity distribution for neutron stars ( hobbs et al .
2005 ) . for helium star evolution , which is of a crucial importance for the formation of double neutron star binaries ( e.g. , ivanova et al . 2003 ; dewi & pols 2003 ) , we have applied a treatment matching closely the results of detailed evolutionary calculations .
if the helium star fills its roche lobe , the systems are examined for the potential development of a dynamical instability , in which case they are evolved through a common envelope ( ce ) phase , otherwise a highly non - conservative mass transfer issues .
we treat ce events using the energy formalism ( webbink 1984 ) , where the binding energy of the envelope is determined from the set of helium star models calculated with the detailed evolutionary code by ivanova et al.(2003 ) .
the progenitor evolution and the roche lobe overflow episodes are now followed in much greater detail .
we note significant differences from our earlier studies . for a detailed description of the revised code
we refer the reader to belczynski et al .
( 2007a ) .
the most recent and important changes in the context of double compact object formation reflect the treatment of the dynamically unstable mass transfer and evolution into the ce phase .
first , it was pointed out that there is only ( if any ) a small chance of survival of ce phase if a donor star is on the hertzsprung gap ( hg ) , simply because there is no clear entropy jump between core and envelope so once ce inspiral is initiated it does not stop until the two binary components coalesce ( see belczynski et al .
second , we limit accretion onto compact objects during ce phase to @xmath23 of the bondi - hoyle rates based loosely on estimates of outflows ( armitage & livio 2001 ) .
we have also slightly modified our input physics in context of rejuvenation , black hole spin ( belczynski et al .
2007c ) evolution and debugged the entire code . two separate evolutionary models for massive star binaries are calculated .
they differ only in common envelope treatment . in one calculation ( model a )
that we will refer to as our reference model we do not allow for common envelope survival in case the donor star is crossing hg .
this is in effect for h - rich hg stars as well of helium hg stars .
the former reduces drastically formation ( and merger ) rates of bh - bh binaries , while the later reduces moderately rates for ns - ns systems as discussed in detail by belczynski et al ( 2007b ) . in alternative common envelope model ( model b )
we allow for ce survival for all donors ( hg included ) . it does not mean that system can survive every ce phase .
the regular standard energy balance ( e.g. webbink 1984 ) is performed to check for a potential survival . in both models we vary an assumption on the initial mass ratio ( lower - mass over higher - mass binary component ) of binaries that we evolve .
we either employ flat mass ratio distribution and we will refer to these populations as `` flat '' binaries or we impose `` twin '' distribution in which we require that @xmath15 binaries have mass ratio distributed uniformly in range @xmath24 while the remaining @xmath15 have flat distribution for @xmath25 . for each models we evolve @xmath26 binaries with solar metallicity ( @xmath27 ) .
we require that the primary mass is drawn from power - law imf with slope @xmath28 , while secondary mass is obtained through a given mass ratio distribution .
we additionally require that the primary initial mass is @xmath29 while secondary initial mass is @xmath30 .
the range of masses was chosen such that it encompasses entire possible mass range for double compact object formation .
in particular , low - mass ends take into account potential rejuvenation of stars through binary accretion .
to initialize our populations we first draw a primary mass , then mass ratio is drawn from a given distribution , and then mass of a secondary is calculated from @xmath31 .
if @xmath32 is smaller than required minimum mass ( @xmath33 ) we repeat the drawing . such a scheme , although it uses underlying flat mass ratio distribution results in skewed ( toward high-@xmath4 ) distribution .
the resulting initial mass ratio distributions are presented in figure 1 ( top panel ) .
for calibration and galactic compact object merger rate calculation we use binary fraction of @xmath34 , and we assume that star formation rate ( sfr ) was constant in galaxy through last 10 gyr at the level of @xmath35 . to calculate the synthetic sfr
we extend our imf down to hydrogen burning limit ( @xmath36 ) , with a three component broken power - law imf with slopes of @xmath37 and corresponding breaks at @xmath11 and @xmath38 ( kroupa & weidner 2003 ) . for our twin populations
we assume that twin binaries are formed independent of binary properties ( like period ) and that they form in entire mass range ( @xmath39 ) .
the mass of entire underlying stellar population ( all single and binary stars ) that corresponds to our simulations ( @xmath40 ) is @xmath41 and @xmath42 for flat and twin populations , respectively . since the star forming mass in galaxy is @xmath43 it results in calibration boost factors ( @xmath44 ) of @xmath45 and 57 for flat and twin populations , respectively .
after evolution of massive primordial binaries ( @xmath46 ) we obtain population of double compact objects in each model .
then in a given model we initiate each double compact object @xmath47 times at different starting time . starting times
are chosen from the uniform distribution within the range of @xmath48 gyr ( constant sfr ) .
the starting time is then increased by an evolutionary time that was needed for a progenitor binary to form a given double compact object ( @xmath49 myr ) .
the double compact objects are then evolved with angular momentum losses due to emission of gravitational radiation until they merge .
merger times are denoted as @xmath50 and they can span a wide range of values .
the entire lifetime of a given binary is then @xmath51 .
we record the time at which they merge .
then we calculate an average merger rate in period @xmath48 gyr .
these are our predicted galactic merger rates .
it is worth to note three things .
first , it may seem counter - intuitive that the boost factor is larger for ( more massive ) twin population .
however , one needs to realize that in the population of stars of a given mass there is a larger number of high mass binaries ( @xmath29 and @xmath52 ) in twin population as compared with flat population .
simply , it is easier to form both binary components with high masses in a population with mass ratio peaked at high values ( twins ) as opposed to population with flatter mass ratio distribution . as we have evolved the same number of twins and flat high mass binaries , it means that the number of stars in an entire underlying stellar population ( @xmath53 ) is smaller for twins than for flat binaries .
finally , since the most mass is contained in primaries and single stars , and not in secondaries ( that are heavier in twin population ) , it translates into a smaller mass of underlying stellar population containing twin binaries .
smaller the simulated mass ( @xmath40 ) higher the boost factor .
second , we have employed an optimistic ( pro - twin ) approach , as we do not put any period constraints on twin formation ( see 1 discussing evidence that twins may form preferentially at short periods ) in addition to adopting a very high fraction of twins ( @xmath15 ) . had we limited population of twins , the boost factor @xmath47 for twins would decrease , making the differences between twin and flat calculations less pronounced .
third , since , we also consider population of ultracompact ( extremely short - lived ) double neutron star binaries it is important to notice their increased contribution to merger rates .
if at formation there are similar in size populations of short- and long - lived double compact objects , the short - lived systems will dominate merger rates .
long - lived systems merge beyond our counting time of 10 gyr ( age of the disk ) unless they happen to form early on , while short - lived systems contribute to merger rate independent of their formation time ( provided that their merger times are much shorter than the age of the disk ) .
first we have calculated galactic merger rates for the two models and we have translated them into advanced ligo detection rates using method presented in belczynski et al . ( 2007b ) .
the results are presented in table 1 .
the galactic merger rates of double compact objects ( combined for ns - ns / bh - ns / bh - bh ) for flat populations are @xmath54 myr@xmath55 while for twin populations @xmath56 myr@xmath55 .
the range of the rates corresponds to our different assumption on ce evolution and formation ( or lack of thereof ) of ultracompact ns - ns systems as was discussed in detail by belczynski et al .
( 2007b ) .
the factor of @xmath2 increase in rates from flat to twin dominated populations is equally connected to _ ( i ) _ the difference in underlying star population that gives boost factor @xmath57 larger for twins than for flat binaries ( see sfr calibration 2.4 ) and _ ( ii ) _ the slightly higher ( @xmath58 ) formation efficiency of double neutron stars from massive twin binaries .
the small magnitude of the later effect may be somewhat surprising , as one would intuitively expect that with the twin population production of double compact objects would significantly increase . in the following
we explain this surprising finding .
first , we examine the mass ratio distribution of flat population for model a. there is a significant fraction ( @xmath8 ) of massive binaries that we have evolved with low mass ratios ( @xmath59 ; fig.1 ; top panel ) . on the other hand , binaries that actually produce double compact objects ( fig.1 ; middle panel ) are found predominantly with high mass ratios but in a rather wide range ( @xmath60 ) .
note that there is no significant peak for double compact object progenitors at high-@xmath61 .
second , if we go from flat to twin population we shift half of the initial binaries from the entire mass ratio range to the very high mass ratios ( fig . 1 ; top panel ) .
binaries that are shifted from the low-@xmath4 range ( @xmath58 of the population ) will become an extra component in formation of double compact object in twin population .
binaries that are shifted from the high-@xmath4 range will produce double compact objects but will not increase the overall production rate since they would have formed double compact objects anyway .
therefore , the rate increase factor from the shift of binaries from standard to twin population is only @xmath58 .
the above finding is a direct result of the shape of the mass ratio distribution of double compact object progenitors . in model
a for the flat population mass ratio is found within range @xmath62 and it falls slowly with the decreasing @xmath61 .
the lack of progenitors below @xmath63 is connected to fact that below that value the progenitor binary evolves through common envelope ( rather than stable mass transfer phase ) after primary evolved of main sequence , and the ce leads most often to a merger .
this is especially true since most of the donors will start mass transfer on hertzsprung gap as during this phase stars experience maximum radial expansion ( belczynski et al.2007b ) .
the slope of the distribution is explained by the narrow range of masses in which double neutron stars form ( and since they dominate double compact object population they set the distribution ) . if a primary is chosen within a range for ns formation ( @xmath64 )
it is easier to find potential secondary that can form ns if mass ratio is higher .
if mass ratio is too small , the primary have a greater chance to have mass below ns formation mass , and therefore mass ratio distributions falls off with decreasing @xmath61 .
intrinsically , once two stars have masses within ns formation range and their mass ratio is over 0.5 , there is no preference for ns - ns formation at higher @xmath4 . in other words
, we do not note any significant evolutionary effects that make it easier to make ns - ns at high mass ratio .
advanced ligo detection rates are listed in table 1 . as for galactic merger rates
there is a range of values for flat population : @xmath65 yr@xmath55 and for twin population @xmath66 yr@xmath55 . and as before the range corresponds to the change on assumption on ce evolution .
however , the increase in rates from model a to b is now due to the increased formation of bh - bh binaries in model b. these binaries , although a small contributor to galactic merger rates , are most important for ligo as they can be detected from much larger distances ( much higher chirp masses ) as compared to ns - ns mergers and therefore they dominate detection rates ( see also belczynski et al .
we note that the change of the detection rates for ligo from flat to twin population is rather small ( factor of @xmath2 ) and is much smaller than other model uncertainties ( e.g. ce evolution ) . in figure 2
we show the distribution of chirp mass for coalescing double compact objects . as the population of double compact objects
is dominated by double neutron stars we see that the distributions peak at @xmath67 that corresponds to the typical chirp mass of a @xmath68 and @xmath69 ns - ns binary ( see also belczynski et al .
we also note that the distributions are almost the same for the flat and twin populations .
this is the result of the underlying initial final - mass relation ( see belczynski et al .
2007a for details ) .
this relation shows that neutron stars form with the similar mass ( @xmath70 ) for a wide range of progenitor masses @xmath71 and only in the narrow range @xmath72 heavier neutron stars ( @xmath73 ) are formed .
such the initial - final mass relation leads to a rather narrow distribution of neutron star masses ( somewhat widened by accretion and mass loss in binaries ) that is obtained in both populations . if the two populations are compared in context of the flat initial - final mass relation it becomes obvious why the two distributions peak at the same value . for flat population
two neutron star progenitors are found ( on average ) farther apart in mass than for twins but still they need to fall within the narrow mass limits that allow neutron star formation ( @xmath72 ) . for twin model
the two progenitors are closer in mass , but still are within the same mass limits . since the mass of a neutron star does not depend strongly on the initial mass of progenitor the masses of neutron stars in both models are similar .
there are other heavier compact objects , namely black hole neutron star systems and double black hole systems with chirp masses reaching all the way to @xmath74 , both for twin and flat populations .
in particular we find many more heavier systems in model b as in this model black hole systems form with much higher efficiency as compared to model a ( belczynski et al .
2007b ) .
merger time distributions for flat and twin double compact object binaries are presented in figure 3 . in the top panel
we show calculations with our reference evolutionary model , while the bottom panel demonstrates results for the alternative common envelope evolution . for the reference model the two distributions are very similar , and
the number of mergers falls off rapidly with the decreasing merger time .
however , we still predict quite a significant number of double compact objects : @xmath75 with merger times shorter than 100 myr .
most of these short lived systems are double neutron stars that have formed along evolutionary channels that end in the stable mass transfer episode with a helium star donor ( e.g. , ivanova et al . 2003 ) . in the model with alternative evolution
we allow for common envelope survival even if donor stars are crossing hertzsprung gap .
although this may appear not to be supported by the current understanding of inspiral process ( see 2 and belczynski et al .
2007b for more through discussion ) the common envelope evolution and the associated inspiral is not yet fully understood .
distributions are similar for flat and twin binaries for high merger times . however , for small merger times there is a an additional component in both distributions as compared to the standard calculations . moreover ,
this additional component is much more pronounced in twin population than in flat population .
in particular we find that in flat population this component ( @xmath76 myr ) contains @xmath77 of mergers while in twin population it reaches @xmath15 .
accounting for the shape of distribution and the larger number of mergers in twin population it translates to @xmath78 times as many short - lived systems in twin population as compared to flat population .
the systems with very short merer times ( @xmath79 myr ) are so called `` ultracompact '' double neutron stars , that form through one extra common envelope phase ( additional orbit contraction ) as opposed to standard model binaries with larger merger times ( e.g. , belczynski et al . 2002b ; ivanova et al . 2003 ; belczynski et al .
2006 ) .
in table 1 we list fractions of prompt double compact object mergers . these will include potential short - hard grb progenitors : ns - ns and bh - ns mergers . although , it is noted again that these fractions are almost completely dominated by ns - ns mergers .
fractions are given for binaries that have lifetimes ( @xmath80 ) shorter than 100 ( @xmath81 ) and 1000 myr ( @xmath82 ) .
we find that in the reference model @xmath75 of the mergers are expected to occur in young hosts ( with stellar populations as young as 100 myr ) both for flat and twin models .
however , if alternative evolution is included in calculations , then the fraction increases to @xmath83 for flat population and to @xmath5 for twin population .
this is a direct result of merger time distribution that is similar for twin and flat population in the reference model ( see fig . 3 top panel ) and
different for alternative ce model , in particular twins producing many more ultracompact ns - ns binaries ( see fig
. 3 bottom panel ) .
the fractions of the mergers are also given in table 1 for significantly older ( but still rather young ) hosts : 1000 myr .
it is found that great majority of the mergers @xmath84 and @xmath85 for reference and alternative ce models is then expected to take place in hosts of this age .
at this age ( or lifetime of the double compact object population ) the ultracompacts are not so important as the classical long - lived systems play an important role in overall population and the fractions are rather independent of whether twin of flat populations are considered ( see fig . 3 ) . in the following we explain the more effective production of ultracompacts in the twin population than in the flat population for alternative ce evolution
( see fig .
3 ; model b ) . we will limit the discussion to double neutron stars and their progenitors as they constitute the vast majority ( @xmath86 ) of double compact object ( dco ) systems with ultrashort merger times ( i.e. , @xmath87 myr ) .
the distribution of initial mass ratio for progenitors of ultracompact dcos is presented in figure 4 . for the flat population ( see fig . 4 , top panel )
we notice that _
( i ) _ in model a there are rather few progenitors with high mass ratios ( @xmath88 ) in contrast to model b in which we find a prominent peak of the distribution at high mass ratios . therefore for model b , redistribution of progenitors from the flat to twin mass ratio distribution is enhancing the production of ultracompacts .
in fact , for twin population ( see fig . 4 , bottom panel )
we observe an increase of ultracompact systems by a factor of @xmath89 in model b ( see the significant increase of these systems at high-@xmath90 ) .
note that the change of the mass ratio distribution from flat to twin increases number of progenitors due to the calibration ( see 2 ) but this increase factor is only @xmath91 .
the additional increase is solely due to the peak in the number of high-@xmath90 systems for model b ultracompacts .
the shape of the mass - ratio distribution for progenitors of ultracompact systems is understood in the framework of evolution of massive stars leading to the formation of double neutron stars . in general ,
classical ( long - lived ) ns - ns binaries form from progenitors that experience only two mass transfer episodes .
the ultracompact systems progenitors usually go through an additional mass transfer episode . this third mass transfer episode is encountered just before second ns formation .
a low - mass helium star overfills its roche lobe and starts transferring he - rich material to the first born ns .
most often such a transfer occurs when a helium star is crossing hertzsprung gap ( large radial expansion ) .
depending on the mass ratio and the evolutionary stage of the helium donor ( where on hg ) the mass transfer is either stable or it evolves into ce phase .
since the most of the neutron stars in our simulations have mass @xmath92 the mass ratio is set by the mass of helium donor .
for very light helium stars ( @xmath93 ) , stable mass transfer is predicted while , for more massive donors ( @xmath94 ) , a ce develops .
the mass of the helium star is set predominantly by the initial mass of the progenitor star ( in addition to mass gain and loss in earlier binary interactions ) ; the lower the mass of the progenitor , the lower mass of helium star it forms .
since the helium star is formed out of secondary ( most cases ) and @xmath61 was defined as the ratio of the mass of secondary to primary , it is expected that systems going through the stable mass transfer ( lower mass helium star progenitor ) have initially a lower mass ratio than systems developing ces ( higher mass helium star progenitor ) . in model
a we do not allow for ce survival if donor is on hg and therefore progenitors with very high mass ratios are disfavored . in model b ,
that allows for survival of the ce phase with the hg donor , the high mass ratio progenitors are abundant and they contribute to formation of ultracompacts . additionally , the higher mass ratio systems are more likely to survive initial mass transfer episodes in the evolution of progenitor binary ( e.g. , closer in mass components so lower the probability of a merger during ce phase )
bethe & brown ( 1998 ) proposed a scenario of double neutron star formation from twin binaries . in this scenario , because the two stellar components of the binary are nearly equal mass , the system undergoes both common envelope phases prior to the collapse of either star .
in such a scenario , the neutron stars formed in collapse need not undergo a ce phase , and hence avoid accreting additional material .
this model provides a natural explanation for double neutron star systems in which both neutron stars had nearly equal masses .
but it only works when the two binary components have nearly equal mass , and hence , strongly depends on the number of twins .
bethe & brown ( 1998 ) and subsequent work by lee et al .
( 2007 ) argue that this scenario can explain all of the ns - ns binary systems observed if a large twin population exists .
they argue that any formation scenario that forces a neutron star to go through a common envelope phase will produce a low - mass black hole , not a neutron star .
the bulk of the simulations by fryer , woosley & hartmann ( 1999 ) also made this assumption , and came up with similar conclusions : with appropriate choices of the other free parameters , one can match the observed ns - ns systems .
but whether or not this scenario is the dominant formation path for double neutron star binaries hinges on the fact that the accretion onto a neutron star in a common envelope system is equal to the bondi - hoyle rate .
recall that it was realized that neutrino cooling would allow the neutron star to accrete beyond the eddington rate , causing the neutron star to accrete as much material as is fed it .
if one assumes this rate is equal to the bondi - hoyle rate , the accretion can be up to a solar mass .
but the actual accretion rate may be much less .
first , how much one accretes depends sensitively on the evolution of the common envelope phase ( fryer et al .
very few simulations have focused particularly on neutron stars in stellar mergers with giant companions .
most examples have very rough boundary conditions and/or do not model the inspiral of a neutron star in a massive companion ( e.g. ruffert 1999 ; armitage & livio 2000 ; zhang & fryer 2001 ; ricker & taam 2007 ) .
this preliminary work has yet to solve the actual merger process .
but these studies have determined a few key issues with the bondi - hoyle assumption in neutron star accretion in stellar inspiral : density / velocity gradients can alter the bondi - hoyle accretion at large scales , density / velocity gradients can lead to disk formation and outflows .
ruffert & anzer ( 1995 ) , ruffert ( 1999 ) and taam & ricker ( 2007 ) have focused on the deviation at large scales of the bondi - hoyle accretion rate . at issue here
is that angular momentum in the accreting material can provide pressure support for the infalling material , slowing the accretion .
fryer et al . (
1996 ) calculated values for the density and velocity gradients and compared these results with those of ruffert & anzer ( 1995 ) and found that this pressure support on the global scale was minimal ( @xmath95% level for quite large velocity gradients ) . since this time , ruffert ( 1999 ) studied the same effect under density gradients .
again , if we use the estimates from fryer et al .
( 1996 ) for the density gradients in 10,20m@xmath96 supergiants , we expect 10 - 20% variations away from the accretion rate predicted by the bondi - hoyle formalism .
this only changes as the neutron star spirals near the inner edge of the hydrogen envelope , where density gradients can become quite large .
fryer , benz & herant ( 1996 ) assumed that as long as bondi - hoyle accretion were unaffected , the angular momentum would somehow be transported outward , allowing the material to accrete onto the neutron star .
but subsequent studies are showing that this assumption may well be incorrect ( armitage & livio 2001 ; fryer et al .
2006 ; fryer 2007 ) .
armitage & livio ( 2001 ) showed that the angular momentum in the inflow would lead to disk formation , and ultimately , an outflow that could halt accretion .
if the material is unable to get rid of the energy produced by viscous interactions , an outflow is bound to occur ( blandford & begelman 1999 ) .
fryer et al .
( 2006 ) and fryer ( 2007 ) have specifically studied accreting neutron star systems and found that even a small amount of angular momentum would lead to outflows . in these low - angular momentum flows ,
the outflows decreased the accretion rate by 50% , but for the high - angular momentum flows in ce phases , the outflow could decrease the accretion by more than an order of magnitude ( blandford & begelman 1999 ) . because of such results , we estimate our mass accretion by assuming an accretion rate of 10% the bondi - hoyle rate
. it could even be an order - of - magnitude lower .
this reduced accretion rate allows additional scenarios for forming double neutron star systems which can also be shown to match the current observations of double neutron star systems ( this study ; belczynski et al .
it also avoids any problems over - producing ( or hiding ) the number of massive ns - ns systems .
brown & bethe ( 1998 ) turned these systems into low - mass bh - ns systems by requiring a maximum neutron star mass between 1.7 - 1.8m@xmath96 .
however , observations may indicate that the maximum neutron star mass is @xmath97 ( e.g. , ransom et al . 2005 ; barziv et al .
2001 ) while some theoretical work allows for equation of states with @xmath98 ( e.g. , morrison , baumgarte & shapiro 2004 ) .
if these systems form black holes , we also do not see the low - mass black holes in the galaxy - all black holes in the galaxy have masses above @xmath93 ( orosz 2003 ; cesares 2007 ) , although fryer & kalogera ( 2001 ) argued that this is more - likely the result of observational biases .
additionally , this new accretion estimate agrees very well with the amount of matter that is needed to mildly recycle a pulsar ( zdunik , haensel & gourgoulhon 2002 on theoretical calculations ; jacoby et al .
2005 on observational estimate ) .
this is not to say that the brown scenario requiring twin binaries does not contribute to the double neutron star population .
but in our scenario with the reduced accretion rate , it is simply not the dominant formation scenario .
because of this , our results are much less sensitive to the size of the twin population .
our calculations discussed in this paper involved a very simple twin scenario , i.e. half of all the binaries were postulated to be equal mass ( @xmath99 ) . in reality , the true fraction of twins is likely to depend on the mass of the primary , most certainly on the orbital separation of the two stars , and also possibly on the metallicity of stars . indeed ,
even the actual binary fraction is likely a function of primary mass ( e.g. , lada 2006 ) .
there was a recent report that the fraction of b - type binaries in the lmc might be significantly lower than in our galaxy ( mazeh , tamuz & north 2006 ) , indicating a possibility of strong metallicity dependence in the efficiency of binary formation . from the absolute rates point of view
, we show that effect of including twins is relatively minor : although the merger rate does indeed increase when twins are considered , the rate increase is fairly small ( @xmath2 ) .
this is the direct result of evolutionary calculations that provide numerous channels of ns - ns formation without a strong preference for the high mass ratio of progenitor binaries .
the same calculations recover the empirically estimated rates of double neutron star mergers as some of their observed properties ( belczynski et al .
also , chirp mass distribution for double compact objects formed with or without twins are almost indistinguishable .
if double compact object are short - hard grb progenitors , including twins in population synthesis calculations does not alter significantly the earlier rate predictions for the event rate .
nevertheless , there are some interesting changes when we include significant twin population . for one channel of binary evolution that allows ultracompact binaries
, introducing twins doubles the rate of very prompt ns - ns mergers ( time to merger less than @xmath3 years ) compared to models with the `` flat '' @xmath4 distribution . in that specific case
, @xmath84 of all ns - ns binaries would merge within @xmath100years after their formation ( see table 1 ) , indicating a possibility of a very significant population of short - hard gamma - ray bursts associated with star forming galaxies .
we should mention that twins are not necessary to have a significant prompt population of ns - ns binaries . even using most conservative assumptions ,
@xmath75 of all ns - ns binaries merge within @xmath100years after their formation ( see table 1 ) .
this is very interesting because of the well localized short - hard bursts , roughly 40% occured in young hosts , 15% in old hosts , and location of roughly 45% is still unknown ( berger et al .
2007 ; e. berger , private communication ) .
so not only are the `` prompt '' short - hard grbs very common , they might turn out to be the majority of this class of bursts , as the rough current limits are from 40% to even 85% .
the fact that so many short - hard burst are found in star - forming galaxies may have far reaching consequences for our understanding of binary evolution ( if indeed short - hard grbs are connected to double compact object mergers ) . if further observations find that even higher fraction of short - hard grbs is in young galaxies , that will indicate strongly that the ultracompact channel of the binary evolution does indeed lead to double compact object formation , something that otherwise is very hard to resolve observationally .
if that fraction is higher still , i.e. 70% and above , we will not only need the ultracompact channel to be allowed , we might also need a significant binary twin population to explain such a high rate ( see table 1 ) .
needless to say , more observational constraints on short - hard grbs and their hosts are needed here .
-values ( for details see 2.3 ) . note the change of vertical scale from the top panel to bottom panels .
the numbers correspond to the entire galactic population of double compact objects and their progenitors . ] ) have merger times shorter than 100 myr .
model b with an alternative approach to common envelope evolution in which we allow survival of systems with hertzsprung gap donors leads to formation of ultracompact double neutron stars that contribute to the short merger time peak ( @xmath101 myr ) . we note that in this model even more : @xmath102 and @xmath84 dcos form with short merger times for flat and twin mass ratio distributions , respectively .
the short - lived systems are natural candidates for prompt short - hard grbs observed in young host galaxies . ] | we investigate the effect of including a significant `` binary twin '' population ( binaries with almost equal mass stars , @xmath0 ) for the production of double compact objects and some resulting consequences , including ligo inspiral rate and some properties of short - hard gamma - ray bursts .
we employ very optimistic assumptions on the twin fraction ( @xmath1 ) among all binaries , and therefore our calculations place an upper limits on the influence of twins on double compact object populations . we show that for ligo the effect of including twins is relatively minor : although the merger rates does indeed increase when twins are considered , the rate increase is fairly small ( @xmath2 )
. also , chirp mass distribution for double compact objects formed with or without twins are almost indistinguishable .
if double compact object are short - hard grb progenitors , including twins in population synthesis calculations does not alter significantly the earlier rate predictions for the event rate .
however , for one channel of binary evolution , introducing twins more than doubles the rate of `` very prompt '' ns - ns mergers ( time to merger less than @xmath3 years ) compared to models with the `` flat '' @xmath4 distribution . in that case , @xmath5 of all ns - ns binaries merge within @xmath6 years after their formation , indicating a possibility of a very significant population of `` prompt '' short - hard gamma - ray bursts , associated with star forming galaxies .
we also point out that , independent of assumptions , fraction of such prompt neutron star mergers is always high , @xmath7 .
we note that recent observations ( e.g. , berger et al . ) indicate that fraction of short - hard grbs found in young hosts is at least @xmath8 and possibly even @xmath9 . |
sec : introduction the reflecting properties of mirrors and the focusing properties of lenses have been known since ancient times , general possibilities to tailor reflection and transmission of plane waves using thin metasufaces have been realized only recently . in what concerns the extended control over transmission ,
the transmitarray ( e.g. @xcite ) is the known technique based on the use of two parallel antenna arrays .
this concept has been recently generalized as the meta - transmit - array in @xcite , where subwavelength ( in the transverse plane ) elements are used .
another class of transmission - phase controlling layers is the phase - shifting surface @xcite .
most of these structures contain several layers and are considerably thick in terms of the wavelength . but using various frequency - selective surfaces ( e.g. @xcite ) including inhomogeneous in the layer plane @xcite , transmission phase can be controlled also by electrically thin layers . eliminating reflection while controlling transmission phase is possible using huygens s metasurfaces @xcite .
some general limitations on realizing thin one - way transparent sheets have been published in @xcite . in this paper , we will focus on thin composite layers which fully reflect incident waves with a possibility to engineer their phase response . a known approach to control the reflection phase is the use of reflectarrays ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
reflectarrays for microwave applications are usually realized as arrays of resonant metal patches over a metal ground plane .
all the patches of the array usually have the same shape but slightly varying dimensions , so that the resonance frequency of the individual antenna elements varies to ensure the desired variations of the reflection phase over the array surface .
alternatively , varying reactive loading of the individual antenna elements can be used . because of the use of resonant patches and considerable electrical distance between the array elements , homogenization of these layers is not possible , making realizations of conformal arrays on bent surfaces difficult .
other limitations are narrow frequency band and the presence of the metal ground plane which forbids transmission at all frequencies . other conventional structures which provide full reflection with engineered phase are artificial magnetic walls and high - impedance surfaces ( his ) .
in contrast to electric walls ( perfectly conducting surfaces ) , magnetic walls do not reverse the phase of reflected waves offering interesting possibilities for antenna and microwave applications .
magnetic walls have a high surface impedance due to zero tangential magnetic field on their surface @xcite .
corrugated conducting surface was one of the first designs introduced to exhibit a high surface impedance @xcite .
this is a transmission - line based structure utilizing many shorted quarter - wavelength transmission lines positioned close to each other , which transform the zero impedance at the end of the transmission lines to a very high reactive impedance at the open ends of the transmission - line sections .
the main shortcoming of this structure is its large electrical thickness . in order to decrease the layer thickness , it is possible to fill the grooves with a high - permittivity dielectric or meander them .
later on , various corrugated surfaces have been utilized as artificial soft and hard surfaces @xcite .
alternatively , to realize high reactive surface impedance , it is possible to use a parallel resonance with a capacitive frequency - selective surface , usually an array of metal patches ( so called _ mushroom structure _ @xcite ) .
this basic idea has been used by many researchers designing various structures realizing high surface impedance .
analytical models of these devices can be found in many papers @xcite .
the mushroom layer his proposed by sievenpiper @xcite has been used in many antenna applications : screens in mobile phones , absorbers , tunable antennas , for reducing thickness of steerable antennas , in reconfigurable antennas , e.g. @xcite . in paper
@xcite a high - impedance surface with a non - uniform distribution of the resonant frequency over the surface has been used as a reflectarray , with the advantage of a wider bandwidth as compared to the traditional designs as antenna arrays @xcite . as for any linear and passive structure , there are fundamental causality limitations on the thickness and bandwidth of high - impedance surfaces @xcite . the main feature which considerably limits the functionalities of the mushroom structure is the presence of an electric wall ( ground plane ) .
the structure interacts with a very large frequency spectrum , but the transmittance is always zero .
furthermore , the reflection coefficient seen from the side of the ground plane is always that of a conducting wall ( @xmath0 if losses are negligible ) , unless a multi - layer system is used . to realize a magnetic wall in one single sheet
, one needs to have a sheet of magnetic current .
there are no free magnetic charges in nature , and only using dense arrays of resonant magnetic moments it is possible to effectively create a sheet of magnetic current .
magnetic walls made of a dense array of single and double split - ring resonators have been proposed in @xcite and @xcite .
this design does not include any ground plane in its structure , but the possible functionalities are still limited because the reflection coefficient seen from the opposite sides of the sheet is always the same .
the main questions which we address in this paper are : what are the minimum necessary physical requirements for realizing a single - sheet full - reflection structure with different and controllable phases of reflected waves from its different sides ?
are the conventional designs of high - impedance surfaces and reflectarrays the only and optimal ways to control the reflecting properties of thin layers ? it is obvious that to be able to fully control reflection , we need to ensure that the thin layer is polarizable both electrically and magnetically .
thus , we assume that the thinnest possible realization is a planar array of small dipolar particles in which both electric and magnetic moments can be induced by the incident fields . from the earlier studies of dipolar arrays @xcite it is known that in order to be able to realize different reflectivity properties for the opposite sides of the sheet , the induced electric and magnetic dipoles must be coupled as in a bi - anisotropic particle @xcite . to the best of our knowledge
, bi - anisotropy of conventional full - reflection layers with asymmetric response of their two sides has not been noticed in earlier studies .
furthermore , an interesting question is if it is possible to have a single layer of bi - anisotropic particles which offers different reflection phase distributions on its two faces ( e.g. , a uniform reflection phase when illuminated from one side and a non - uniform reflection phase distribution from the other side ) ? to address these questions , it is necessary to find out which physical phenomena govern the response of traditional full - reflection layers and understand what parameters of reflecting sheets are required to realize arbitrary reflection phase responses . in this paper
, we will analytically and numerically show that the most general asymmetric single - layer full - reflection structures can be realized as single arrays of passive lossless bi - anisotropic particles possessing bi - anisotropic omega coupling @xcite .
it will be shown that using the proposed metasurfaces one can tailor the reflected wave phase independently for illuminations coming from the opposite sides of the composite sheet .
we will see that using the physical optics principle ( also known as the kirchhoff approximation @xcite ) the proposed method is applicable for layers with different non - uniform phase distributions on their two surfaces .
this study will also lead us to discover other extreme properties of so called _ balanced bi - anisotropic particles _ @xcite . with the ability to fully control
the phase of waves reflected from a planar composite sheet , it becomes possible to tailor reflected waves in the most general fashion .
for example , one side of a thin planar sheet can act as a focusing reflector ( emulating a parabolic mirror ) , while the other side can , for instance , deflect incident plane waves into a desired direction .
this study is limited to the case of plane - wave illuminations at normal incidence .
we consider a generic metamirror as a composite planar layer formed by periodically arranged electrically small unit cells or small particles .
these cells are polarizable both electrically and magnetically
. the electromagnetic properties of the cells we model by general linear relations between the induced electric ( @xmath1 ) and magnetic ( @xmath2 ) dipole moments and the incident fields @xmath3 and @xmath4 at the positions of the particles as = .
, eq : a where the effective polarizabilities ( marked by hats ) include the effects of particle interactions in the array . because here we are interested in layers acting as full reflectors for arbitrary polarizations of the incident field , the dyadic coefficients in the above equations should be invariant with respect to rotation around the unit vector @xmath5 normal to the layer plane : = _ ij=_ij^co_t+_ij^crj_t , formswhere @xmath6 is the transverse unit dyadic and @xmath7 is the vector - product operator .
the amplitudes of plane waves generated by the array are proportional to the surface - averaged electric and magnetic surface current densities , which are related to the induced cell dipole moments as @xmath8 , @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the area of each unit cell . assuming the normal incidence of the incident plane wave ( the induced dipole moments are the same in all unit cells )
, we can find the amplitudes of the reflected and transmitted plane waves as @xcite l _
r=-\{. + .+}_inc , + _ t=\{.
+ . - } _ inc , [ eq : b ] where @xmath11 is the free - space wave impedance ( for simplicity and without loss of generality we assume that the surrounding homogeneous , isotropic , and lossless medium is free space ) . here and thereafter , to distinguish between illuminations of the sheet from the two opposite sides , we will use double signs for these two cases , where the top and bottom signs correspond to the incident plane wave propagating in the @xmath12 and @xmath13 directions , respectively .
ideal reflectors should not change the wave polarization at reflection , so we demand that in ( [ eq : b ] ) the coefficients at the rotation operator @xmath14 equal zero . in this work ,
we limit the study to reciprocal layers , in which case the electric and magnetic polarizabilities are symmetric dyadics ( @xmath15 , @xmath16 , e.g. @xcite ) .
thus , the requirement of the absence of any cross - polarized response does not allow any chirality in the layer s topology , because both @xmath17 and @xmath18 . under these restrictions ,
the amplitudes of reflected and transmitted plane waves for normally incident plane waves read l _
r=-(- ) _ inc , + _ t= _ inc .
before studying general metamirrors , let us first consider the simplest problem of realizing electric or magnetic wall response for illumination from both sides of the array .
if we require symmetric response on illuminations from both sides of the array , then the field - coupling coefficients @xmath19 and @xmath20 in must be zero . as is obvious from
, the array behaves as an electric wall ( reflection coefficient @xmath0 , transmission coefficient @xmath21 ) if = 2sj,=0.eq : hthe effective electric polarizability @xmath22 and the effective magnetic polarizability @xmath23 , in terms of the single - particle polarizabilities and the interaction constants , and @xmath24 at the position of the particle .
the interaction constants define the values of the local fields as @xmath25 and @xmath26 . ]
can be written as = , = , eq : iwhere @xmath27 is the electric - field interaction constant and @xmath28 is its magnetic counterpart .
approximate analytical expressions for the electric and magnetic interaction constants in regular arrays of dipole particles can be found in @xcite : c = \{-(1-)e^-jk_0 } + + j(- ) + = , = eq : j ( @xmath29 is the free - space wave number and @xmath30 is the array period ) . here the expression for the imaginary part is exact , and that for the real part is an approximation valid for @xmath31 . considering the corresponding grid impedance @xmath32 @xcite defined via = z_g_j_e , eq : kwhere @xmath33 is the surface - averaged tangential electric field in the array plane and @xmath34 is the surface - averaged induced electric surface current density , we find that z_g = sj 1 - 2=0eq : lif is satisfied
. using and , we get the conditions on the polarizability of a single particle which is necessary to realize an effective electric wall response : \{-}=0,()=k_0 ^ 36_0 .
eq : mthe first condition means that the particles are at the resonance and the second condition means that there is no absorption in the particles ( the only loss term is due to dipole scattering ) .
this is a known result telling that an array of resonant lossless electric dipole particles behaves as an electric wall at the particle resonance .
the first equation also shows that the resonance frequency is the frequency at which the grid comes to a resonance , and this frequency is not the same as the resonance frequency of a single particle in free space .
let us compare the behavior of a grid of resonant electric dipoles with that of a thin homogeneous slab ( the relative permittivity @xmath35 and the thickness @xmath36 ) .
for a thin homogeneous slab the equivalent sheet impedance reads ( eq .
( 2.152 ) @xcite ) z_g =- j_0(_r-1)k_0d , eq : nand , obviously , the electric - wall response ( @xmath37 ) can be reached only if @xmath38 .
if the imaginary part of @xmath35 tends to infinity , we have the case of a perfect conductor , and if the real part of @xmath35 tends to infinity , we have the response analogous to the above case of an array of lossless resonant electric dipoles .
indeed , in the case of the dipole array the perfect electric conductor ( pec ) response is reached when the particles are at resonance and their polarizabilities in the grid tend to infinity . after appropriate homogenization , this corresponds to a thin layer of a dielectric with @xmath39 .
note that a single sheet of homogeneous surface electric current radiates symmetrically in the forward and back directions . in our case of full reflection
, the amplitude of the reflected plane wave equals to that of the incident plane wave .
the plane wave created by this array into the forward direction also has the same amplitude as the incident field , but it is out of phase with that , so that the total field behind the grid is zero .
note that the discrete nature of the grid is not essential for this interference effect ( cancellation of the incident field behind the grid ) .
it is essential in order to ensure the resonant response of the grid impedance , which in a homogeneous layer is possible only with @xmath40 .
similarly to the above case of the electric wall , inspecting we can find that the magnetic - wall response from both sides of the array ( the reflection coefficient @xmath41 and the transmission coefficient @xmath21 ) is achieved if = 0,=2sj.eq : othe effective magnetic polarizability @xmath23 is related to the polarizibility of the same particle in free space as in .
we can introduce the equivalent `` series admittance '' @xmath42 via = y_m_j_meq : q.in this definition , @xmath43 is the surface - averaged tangential magnetic field in the array plane and @xmath44 is the surface - averaged magnetic surface current density .
similarly to the case of the electric - wall response of resonant electric dipoles , we find y_m = sj 1 - 12=0.eq : rthus , an array of lossless resonant magnetic dipoles behaves as a magnetic wall from both sides of the array at the resonant frequency of the array which is determined , using and , by the following values of the particle polarizabilities : \{-}=0,()=k_0 ^ 36_0 .
eq : s let us next consider if and how one can realize a sheet reflecting plane waves symmetrically from both sides , but with an arbitrary reflection phase .
we use with @xmath45 and @xmath46 to find the effective electric and magnetic polarizabilities of the unit cells which ensure that @xmath47 and @xmath48 . here
@xmath49 is the desired phase shift of the reflected wave .
the result reads _ 0=sj(1-e^j),=
sj(1+e^j).sym_a_hatthe corresponding values of the required electric impedance and magnetic admittance for the surface - averaged current densities ( see and ) are given by z_g = sj 1 - 2=j2(/2)y_m = sj
1 - 12=j2(/2)the required polarizabilities of individual particles we find using and : \{-}=-_02s(/2 ) , ( ) = k_0 ^ 36_0.aee_sym \{-}=2_0 s(/2 ) , ( ) = k_0
^ 36_0.amm_sym this means that one should use lossless particles but not at the resonant frequency of the array , so that the real parts of the inverse polarizabilities acquire the values given in and .
next , we study metamirrors providing different reflection phases when illuminated from their two sides . equations clearly show that in order to achieve asymmetric full - reflection response from a single layer of small unit cells , we need to invoke magnetoelectric coupling of the omega type ( @xmath50 )
. follows from the reciprocity of the structure @xcite . ] in order to get more physical insight into these phenomena , as an example of asymmetric metamirrors we will first consider the classical realization of the mushroom layer high - impedance surface ( his ) . similarly to generic arrays of small particles , the mushroom layer is electrically thin , and at the resonance it has the reflection coefficient @xmath51 ( magnetic wall response ) from the side of the patch array , while the reflection coefficient from the opposite side is @xmath0 , because the structure has a pec ground plane .
the response is the same as we expect from an array of bi - anisotropic particles with appropriately designed omega coupling .
furthermore , the mushroom - layer geometry resembles that of an array of @xmath52-particles : an array of electrically polarizable patches next to a pec wall .
clearly , if this structure is excited by external uniform electric fields , the currents induced on the patch array and on the ground plane are different , meaning that applied uniform electric field induces some magnetic moment ( an effective circulating electric current ) .
what are the electric and magnetic polarizations induced in a conventional mushroom layer and what are the effective `` polarizabilities '' ?
the expectation is that the mushroom layer exhibits the same response as a resonant layer of bi - anisotropic ( omega ) particles . to understand the electromagnetic coupling which takes place in mushroom layers , we derive the effective polarizabilities of these layers by studying their excitations in external electric and magnetic fields . to find these polarizabilities , we need to excite the his layer by electric field or magnetic fields which are approximately uniform inside the his layer .
following @xcite , we choose the exciting field in form of a standing wave ( fig . [ standing ] ) : c _
e_inc=\{e_0 e^-jk_0z - e_0 e^+jk_0z}_0=-j2e_0(k_0z)_0 , + _
h_inc=\{h_0 e^-jk_0z+h_0 e^+jk_0z}_0=2h_0(k_0z)_0 eq : t ( the cartesian axes @xmath53 and @xmath54 are in the layer plane )
. + to study the excitation by external electric fields , we position the maximum of the electric field distribution of the standing wave at the middle point between the patch array and the ground plane , where @xmath55 , e.g. , assuming @xmath56 ( the normalized distance between the patch array and the ground plane is @xmath57 , where @xmath36 is the distance between the ground plane and the patch array ) .
next , we write the relations between the averaged surface current density on the ground plane @xmath58 , the averaged surface current density on the array of patches @xmath59 , and the total surface - averaged electric fields at the respective two planes as cj2e_0 ( ) -j_g - j_mete^-jk_0d = z_g j_g , + j2e_0 ( ) -j_ge^-jk_0d - j_met=0 , eq : u where @xmath32 is the effective sheet impedance ( grid impedance ) of the patch array .
the value of the grid impedance we choose so that the mushroom layer operates as a magnetic wall ( the parallel connection of @xmath32 and the input impedance of the equivalent short - circuited transmission line of length @xmath36 @xmath60 is in parallel resonance ) : z_g =- j_0(k_0d).eq : vusing ( [ eq : u ] ) and ( [ eq : v ] ) , the currents on the metal surface and on the patch grid can be found : cj_met = je_0 ( ) -j_ge^-jk_0d , + j_g=. eq : w the induced electric moment per unit area of the structure , by definition @xcite , is p_x=(j_met+j_g ) .
eq : x using and , the electric moment can be written as cp_x=. eq : y assuming that the layer is electrically thin ( @xmath57 ) , the above result simplifies to cp_x = e_0 .
eq : z dividing the induced electric moment by the amplitude of the external electric field @xmath61 in , the effective electric polarizability per unit area is found to read = = .
eq : aa by definition @xcite , the induced magnetic moment per unit area can be written as cm_y=(j_met - j_g ) .
eq : bb using and , the magnetic moment reads cm_y=. eq : cc the assumption of electrically small thickness @xmath36 simplifies this relation to cm_y=. eq : dd then , using and , we can calculate the magnetoelectric polarizability ( the omega coupling coefficient ) : c==. eq : ee at the second step , we can derive the effective magnetic and electromagnetic polarizabilities by considering excitation of the same layer by external magnetic fields . to do that
, we position the layer inside the standing wave so that the maximum of the magnetic field is between the array of patches and the ground plane ( e.g. , at @xmath62 ) , see fig .
[ standing ] . again writing the relations between the induced averaged surface current densities and the total electric fields in the plane of the patches and the ground plane cj2e_0 ( ) -j_g - j_mete^-jk_0d = z_g
j_g , + -j2e_0 ( ) -j_ge^-jk_0d - j_met=0 , eq : ff the current densities on the metal surface and on the grid array are found as cj_met =- je_0 ( ) -j_ge^-jk_0d , + j_g=. eq : gg the electric moment is calculated using : cp_x=. eq : hh assuming electrically small thickness for the structure , we get cp_x =- h_0 .
eq : ii the coupling coefficient can be found dividing the induced electric moment by the amplitude of the external magnetic field in c=-()=. eq : jj using , the magnetic moment can be written as cm_y= , eq : kk and within the same assumption of electrically small thickness , cm_y=. eq : ll the magnetic polarizability can be determined by dividing the induced magnetic moment by the external magnetic field in : c==. eq : mm the results for the polarizabilities and show that the mushroom layer at resonance indeed acts as a layer of omega particles , because the structure develops electric polarization at excitation by electric fields , magnetic polarization under excitation by magnetic fields , and , in addition , there is magneto - electric coupling effect measured by the coefficients c==1j .
eq : nn furthermore , we note that the polarizabilities are balanced as = = = 1 = 1j .
eq : ooaccording to , this is exactly the condition ensuring that the reflection coefficient from the array of bi - anisotropic particles changes sign when we illuminate the array from the opposite side .
moreover , we recall that the polarizabilities found for the mushroom layer are defined in terms of induced moments per unit area , which are related to the polarizabillities of particles ( or unit cells ) in as @xmath63 . with this in view , we see that the amplitudes of the cross polarizabilities of the mushroom layer are exactly what are required to realize @xmath64 response of an array of omega particles .
this consideration again confirms that in order to realize a single - layer full - reflection structure with asymmetric phase responses from different sides , we have to introduce bi - anisotropy inside the layer .
next , we will derive design equations for an ultimately thin full - reflection layer which has arbitrary ( asymmetric ) reflection phases for waves coming from the two opposite sides .
let us find the required polarizabilities of unit cells for realization of general asymmetric metamirrors .
these layers fully reflect plane waves coming from both sides ( the amplitude of the reflection coefficient is equal to unity ) , but the phases of the reflected waves can take any desired values .
pec , perfect magnetic conductor ( pmc ) , his , and layers with @xmath65 reflection coefficients will be considered as important special cases .
let us demand that the reflection coefficients equal to @xmath66 and @xmath67 for @xmath12 and @xmath68-directed incident plane waves , respectively : r_-_0=e^j , r_+_0=e^j .
eq : ppthe requirements for the effective polarizabilities of unit cells necessary to realize the desired response can be found , substituting in , as c= , + = = , + = .
eq : qqthe polarizabilities in refer to a layer with omega coupling .
this is physically understandable , because we demand this layer to show the same transmission properties but different reflection properties for waves incident from the opposite directions , while the polarization of the reflected and transmitted waves is the same as that of the incident waves . to find the required individual polarizabilities of single inclusions ( not interacting with other inclusions ) , we can use the explicit formulas for the collective polarizabilities of an omega particle in an array in terms of the individual polarizabilities and the interaction constants @xcite c = , + = , + = .
eq : rr here @xmath69 is the omega coupling parameter of an individual inclusion . using and , one can find the required polarizability values for the individual omega particles as c = , + = = , + = .
eq : ss these individual polarizabilities satisfy the necessary condition for lossless bi - anisotropic particles @xcite c \{(-.^-1.)^-1}= + \{+}=. eq : tt these results are quite general in the sense that we can design a layer of bi - anisotropic particles which fully reflects coming electromagnetic waves from different sides with different phases . for some applications it can be necessary to ensure a specific value of the phase of the reflected wave at some specific distance from the layer plane .
our theory can be easily modified to realize any phase requirements at any distance from the array .
suppose that we want to ensure that the phase of the reflected wave equals @xmath49 at distance @xmath70 from the upper surface of the array and phase @xmath71 for reflected waves at distance @xmath72 from the bottom surface of the array ( see fig .
[ fig : distance ] ) . to find the required effective and individual polarizabilities , we can simply substitute @xmath73 and @xmath74 in and , where @xmath75 is the free - space wavelength . and
@xmath72 from the layer . ]
the results in have been derived for periodical arrays at normal incidence , meaning that we have uniform phase distribution in reflected waves from both sides of the surface .
obviously , for many applications it is desirable to realize specific non - uniform phase distributions of reflected plane waves ( allowing , for instance , wave focusing or deflection ) .
moreover , it is of practical interest to understand if it is possible to realize _ different phase distributions _ for illuminations from the opposite sides , using just one single layer of dipolar particles . in the assumption
that the variations of the reflection phase along the surface is slow and smooth on the wavelength scale , the physical optics approximation @xcite can be used to determine the required individual properties for each particle at each point on the surface ( see an illustration in fig . [ single ] ) . knowing the required reflection phase value at each point of the surface
, one can replace each particle on the array locally by a periodic array formed by many such particles . this way the necessary collective and consequently individual polarizabilities of the particle can be calculated from and , respectively .
an interesting conclusion is that it is possible to realize a single layer of bi - anisotropic particles which offers different reflection phase distributions from two sides .
for example , a layer can exhibit uniform reflection phase distribution when illuminated from one side , and a non - uniform reflection phase distribution from the other side .
one interesting example is an ultimately thin layer of dipolar particles which works as a reflectarray from one side and as a magnetic wall from the other side .
+ interestingly , the full control over reflection phases of waves reflected from both sides of metamirrors can be achieved using dipolar particles of only one type : lossless omega particles .
there is an important point to be noticed .
the amplitudes of the reflection and transmission coefficients equal unity and zero , respectively , and the structure is obviously lossless .
however , this implies only that the particles are lossless in the sense of the overall response ( the power extracted from the fields equals to the re - radiated power ) .
because the electric and magnetic responses are coupled in these bi - anisotropic particles , it is possible , for instance , that the electric and magnetic polarizabilities provide gain , which is compensated by equivalent loss in the omega coupling term .
in what follows , we will consider special cases of this general case .
the cases of pec and pmc response have been already treated above ( section [ pec_pmc ] ) , and we will concentrate on high - impedance surfaces and surfaces providing the reflection coefficients equal to @xmath65 .
let us consider metamirrors with the reflection coefficients equal to @xmath76 when illuminated from their two sides .
note that the input impedance of such a layer seen at its two surfaces is @xmath77 .
thus , realizing these layers is the same as designing a thin structure whose input impedance has a @xmath78 phase shift from the intrinsic impedance of the background medium .
such a layer might find important applications in antenna techniques , for example .
substituting @xmath79 in and then in , we can determine the required effective polarizabilities as follows : c = j==. eq : bbbas it is seen , the effective polarizabilities have the balanced properties ( the magnitudes of all the normalized polarizabilities are equal ) .
using , the individual polarizabilities can be written as c = j==. eq : ccc it should be noted that in this case both effective and individual polarizabilities have the balanced strength .
one of the practically important cases is a single layer of bi - anisotropic particles acting as a high - impedance surface . in section [ his_polarizations ]
it was shown that there is omega coupling inside conventional his mushroom layers . here
, we find the required effective and individual polarizabilities of dipolar bi - anisotropic particles which realize the same response .
to ensure his properties of an array of bi - anisotropic particles , we demand that @xmath80 and @xmath81 in . substituting these values into
, one can get the required effective polarizabilities as c===. eq : yyas expected , these are the same relations as we have found for the effective polarizabilities ( defined per unit area ) of conventional mushroom layers . using , the individual polarizabilities can be found as c = = , + = = .
eq : zz interestingly , the effective polarizabilities are balanced , but the individual ones are not completely balanced .
the above theory determines the required polarizabilities of unit cells which ensure the desired properties of general full - reflection layers . here
we will consider example designs of particles which such polarizabilities .
it is clear that to realize pec and pmc responses from arrays of small dipole particles , we can simply use periodical array of resonant and low - loss electric and magnetic dipoles , respectively .
but what particles can have the required polarizabilities as in and ? in what follows , we will focus on asymmetric responses from different sides of the array . in the previous section
, it was shown that to realize a layer which exhibits @xmath82 reflection coefficient for waves coming from different sides of the array , one needs to have an array of balanced omega particles . in this section , as examples of omega particles for microwave applications , we will study metal - wire omega particles . figs .
[ fig : lop ] and [ fig : rop ] show two possible designs of bi - anisotropic particles possessing omega coupling . 0.5 0.5 to optimize the particle shapes and dimensions , we use the method introduced in @xcite which allows us to extract the polarizabilities of an arbitrary dipolar particle from computed or measured scattering cross sections of the particle .
the individual polarizabilities of particles optimized for the desired performance are shown in figs .
[ fig : lop - p ] and [ fig : rop - p ] .
[ fig : lop - p ] [ fig : rop - p ] as it is seen , both of these particles are balanced and can be used to realize a layer with @xmath82 reflection . here
, we utilize the particle shown in fig .
[ fig : lop ] .
the radius of the loop is @xmath83 mm , the radius of the wire is @xmath84 mm , the half - length of the electric dipole is @xmath85 mm , and the pitch is @xmath86 mm .
[ fig : lop - cr ] shows the amplitude and phase of reflected waves from an array made of these particles ( the array period is @xmath87 mm ) .
@xmath82 reflection coefficients are realized at the particle resonance ( the reference phase plane crosses the geometrical center of the particles ) .
reflection coefficients from an array made of conventional omega particles when the phase reference plane is set to the center of the array .
( b ) realizing @xmath82 reflection coefficients from an array made of conventional omega particles when the phase reference plane is set to the borders of the array.,title="fig : " ] [ fig : lop - cr ] reflection coefficients from an array made of conventional omega particles when the phase reference plane is set to the center of the array .
( b ) realizing @xmath82 reflection coefficients from an array made of conventional omega particles when the phase reference plane is set to the borders of the array.,title="fig : " ] [ fig : lop - br ] let us next consider the case when it is required to realize the reflection coefficients equal to @xmath88 at distance @xmath70 from the top of the array and @xmath89 at distance @xmath72 from the bottom of the array ( see fig .
[ fig : distance ] ) . as it was explained in the previous section
, the present theory can be modified to realize any reflection phase requirement at any distance from the array . to do this
, one can substitute @xmath90 and @xmath91 in . as it is clear from , in this case
the required polarizabilities are not balanced .
for example , the particle in fig .
[ fig : lop ] can be optimized to get a layer with @xmath82 reflection coefficients from the borders of the particle ( when the phase reference planes are set to the borders of the particle ) . in this case , the radius of the loop is @xmath92 mm and the half - length of the electric dipole is @xmath93 mm . as we see from fig
[ fig : lop - br ] , at the frequency where @xmath82 is realized , the amplitude of the reflection coefficient is not exactly equal to unity . on the other hand , at the frequency where we realize full reflection , the phases of the reflection coefficients from different sides are not exactly equal to @xmath94 .
the reason is the intrinsic relation between electric , magnetic and magnetoelectric polarizabilities of small wire omega particles ( see @xcite ) = - .
eq : oooin some cases , this condition limits the accessible properties of wire omega particles which does not allow one to fully satisfy the requirements in .
however , as is shown in @xcite , this restriction is due to specific symmetry properties of induced current distribution and does not hold for general omega particles .
it was shown above that to design a layer of bi - anisotropic particles which acts as a his one needs particles with balanced electric and magnetic polarizabilities , but the magnetoelectric coupling coefficient should not be balanced with the electric and magnetic polarizabilities ( see ) .
it is seen from that there is an intrinsic limitation for wire omega particles .
condition shows that as soon as we have a wire omega particle with balanced electric and magnetic polarizabilities , the coupling coefficient will be automatically balanced with the electric and magnetic ones .
this is in contrast with the requirement in .
let us still consider another possibility to use wire omega particles to realize @xmath95 reflection layer , which appears thanks to the freedom to choose the area of the unit cells @xmath10 so that all the polarizabilities in become balanced .
substituting the interaction constants from , the required polarizabilities in can be rewritten as c = = , + = = .
eq : ppp however , as it is seen from these requirements , the only solution when all the polarizabilities are balanced is for the infinite polarizabilities , which is not realizable .
this means that the conventional wire omega particle is not the right choice for the design of such layers and we need an omega particle which does not obey the limitation . from the applications point of view , it is better to have a layer in which we have @xmath95 reflection coefficients at the border surfaces of the layer .
[ fig : rop ] shows another topology of an omega particle . after optimizing the particle ,
the radius of the wire is @xmath84 mm , and the ellipticity is @xmath96 .
the individual polarizabilities of this optimized particle plotted in fig .
[ fig : rop - p ] show that this particle is indeed balanced , meaning that if we set the phase reference plane at the center of the array , @xmath82 reflection from the two sides will be achieved . for an array made of these particles ( the array period is @xmath97 mm ) shown in fig .
[ fig : array ] , the amplitude and phase of the reflection coefficients measured at the border surfaces of the array are plotted in fig .
[ fig : rop - br ] . as we see , because of the special geometry of the particle , we are able to realize @xmath95 reflection coefficients at the border surfaces of the array .
reflection coefficients from an array made of ellipsoidal omega particles when the phase reference plane is set to the border surfaces of the array.,title="fig : " ] [ fig : array ] reflection coefficients from an array made of ellipsoidal omega particles when the phase reference plane is set to the border surfaces of the array.,title="fig : " ] [ fig : rop - br ] it should be noted that the considered omega particles are just very simple and particular examples which were used to show the possibility of realizing different kinds of composite metamirrors . actually , in these examples the layer of these particles is not very thin electrically .
the thicknesses of the presented example arrays of conventional and ellipsoidal omega particles are @xmath98 and @xmath99 , respectively .
however , one can use any other particle which has omega coupling to realize the required polarizabilities in much smaller volumes .
it is interesting to note that the thin focusing layer presented in @xcite actually has the appropriate symmetry of the omega - type bi - anisotropic layer , although without theoretical optimization and with high losses in metal shows only moderate reflectivity .
here , we have introduced the concept of the metamirror which offers a possibility for full control over the reflection phases of its two surfaces .
we have assumed that the metamirror thickness is ultimately small , only allowing one layer of dipolar particles to fit inside the structure .
the investigation of the necessary polarization properties of the unit cells of the structure has shown that reciprocal and lossless bi - anisotropic particles with omega magnetoelectric coupling are the appropriate building blocks for the most general metamirrors .
the study has also revealed the bi - anisotropic nature of the electromagnetic response of conventional high - impedance surfaces in form of mushroom layers ( these layers provide the reflection coefficients equal to @xmath100 and @xmath101 when illuminated from the opposite sides a very special case of the general metamirror response ) . the bi - anisotropic coupling required for the metamirror operation
can be realized by selecting an appropriate shape of dipolar particles sitting in each unit cell of the planar metamirror array . for the microwave frequency range metal wire particles
can be used , and we have demonstrated by simulations the metamirror responses of some example designs . for infrared and optical frequencies , low - loss high - contrast dielectric structures of the appropriate symmetry can be possibly used for the same purpose .
this study has been done for layers providing uniform reflection phases for any point of the surface , and extended also to engineered non - uniform phase distributions using the physical optics approximation .
it has been shown that a properly designed single layer of bi - anisotropic particles possessing omega coupling can fully reflect electromagnetic waves coming from different sides with arbitrary phases , and the waves reflected from the two sides of the metamirror can be tailored independently .
this concept generalizes the reflectarray concept to the most general phase control of reflections from both sides of the layer using ultimately thin ( one layer of dipolar inclusions ) structures .
in contrast to conventional reflectarrays , metamirrors do not contain a fully reflective ground plane , thus , far from the operational frequency of the mirror these structures are weakly reflective and highly transmitting .
n. yu , p. genevet , m. a. kats , f. aieta , j .- p . tetienne , f. capasso , and z. gaburro , `` light propagation with phase discontinuities : generalized laws of reflection and refraction , '' _ science _ , vol .
334 , no .
6054 , pp . 333337 , 2011 .
m. selvanayagam and g. v. eleftheriades , `` discontinuous electromagnetic fields using orthogonal electric and magnetic currents for wavefront manipulation , '' _ optics express _ , vol . 21 , no . 12 , pp . 1440914429 , 2013 .
d. sievenpiper , l. zhang , r. f. j. broas , n. g. alexpolous , and e. yablonovitch , `` high - impedance electromagnetic surfaces with a forbidden frequency band , '' _ ieee trans .
theory techn .
_ , vol .
47 , no . 11 , pp . 20592074 , nov .
1999 .
s. clavijo , r. e. daz , and w. e. mckinzie , `` design methodology for sievenpiper high - impedance surfaces : an artificial magnetic conductor for positive gain electrically small antennas , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol .
51 , no .
10 , pp . 26782690 , oct . 2003 .
o. luukkonen , c. simovski , g. granet , g. goussetis , d. lioubtchenko , a. v. risnen , and s. a. tretyakov , `` simple and accurate analytical model of planar grids and high - impedance surfaces comprising metal strips or patches , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol .
56 , no . 6 , pp .
26782690 , june 2008 .
o. luukkonen , m. g. silveirinha , a. b. yakovlev , c. r. simovski , i. s. nefedov , and s. a. tretyakov , `` effects of spatial dispersion on reflection from mushroom - type artificial impedance surfaces , '' _ ieee trans .
theory techn .
_ , vol .
57 , no . 11 , pp . 26922699 , nov .
2009 .
f. costa , a. monorchio , and g. manara , `` analysis and design of ultra thin electromagnetic absorbers comprising resistively loaded high impedance surfaces , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol . 58 , no . 5 , pp .
15511558 , may 2010 .
y. r. padooru , a. b. yakovlev , c. s. r. kaipa , f. medina , and f. mesa , `` circuit modeling of multiband high - impedance surface absorbers in the microwave regime , '' _ phys .
b _ , vol .
84 , p. 035108
, 2011 .
zhang , p .- h .
zhou , h .-
lu , y .- q . xu , d .-
liang , and l .- j .
deng , `` resistance selection of high impedance surface absorbers for perfect and broadband absorption , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol .
61 , no . 2 , pp .
976979 , feb .
f. costa , a. monorchio , s. talarico , and f. m. valeri , `` an active high - impedance surface for low - profile tunable and steerable antennas , '' _ ieee antennas wireless propag .
_ , vol . 7 , pp .
676680 , 2008 .
p. deo , a. mehta , d. m .- syahkal , p. j. massey , and h. nakano , `` thickness reduction and performance enhancement of steerable square loop antenna using hybrid high impedance surface , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol . 58 , no . 5 , pp
14771485 , may 2010 .
y. huang , l .- s .
wu , m. tang , and j. mao , `` design of a beam reconfigurable thz antenna with graphene - based switchable high - impedance surface , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol . 11 , no . 4 , pp .
836842 , july 2012 .
c. r. simovski , m. kondratiev , and s. he , `` an explicit method for calculating the reflection from an anti - reflection structure involving array of c - shaped wire elements , '' _ journal of electromagnetic waves and applications _
14 , no .
10 , pp .
13351352 , 2000 .
f. bilotti , a. toscano , k. b. alici , e. ozbay , and l. vegni , `` design of miniaturized narrowband absorbers based on resonant - magnetic inclusions , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol .
53 , no . 1 ,
pp . 6372 , 2011 .
v. v. yatsenko , s. i. maslovski , s. a. tretyakov , s. l. prosvirnin , and s. zouhdi , `` plane - wave reflection from double arrays of small magnetoelectric scatterers , '' _ ieee trans .
antennas propag .
_ , vol .
51 , no . 1 ,
pp . 211 , jan .
i. a. faniayeu , v. s. asadchy , i. v. semchenko , and s. a. khakhomov , `` calculation and analysis of the tensors of electric , magnetic and chiral polarizabilities of the helices with optimal shape , '' _ the sixth international congress on advanced electromagnetic materials in microwaves and optics _ , st . petersburg , russia , pp . 324326 ,
s. a. tretyakov , c. r. simovski , a. a. sochava , `` the relation between co - and cross - polarizabilities of small conductive bi - anisotropic particles , '' _ advances in complex electromagnetic materials , nato asi series high technology _ , vol .
28 , pp .
271280 , 1997 . | we propose an effective route to fully control the phase of plane waves reflected from electrically ( optically ) thin sheets .
this becomes possible using engineered artificial full - reflection layers ( metamirrors ) as arrays of electrically small resonant bi - anisotropic particles . in this scenario , fully reflecting mirrors do not contain any continuous ground plane , but only arrays of small particles .
bi - anisotropic omega coupling is required to get asymmetric response in reflection phase for plane waves incident from the opposite sides of the composite mirror .
it is shown that with this concept one can independently tailor the phase of electromagnetic waves reflected from both sides of the mirror array .
radi : tailoring reflections from thin composite metamirrors reflectarray , magnetic conductor , high - impedance surface , bi - anisotropic particle , reflection , transmission , resonance . |
ballistic electron emission microscopy ( beem)@xcite is a new technique based on the scanning tunneling microscope ( stm ) . it has been primarily designed for the study of buried metal - semiconductor interfaces , in particular for the investigation of the schottky barrier .
the experimental setup consists of a stm injecting current in a metallic film deposited on a semiconductor material .
after propagation through the metal , a fraction of these electrons still has sufficient energy to surpass the schottky barrier and may enter into the semiconductor to be finally detected as beem current . using the tunneling tip
as a localized electron source gives beem its unparalleled power to provide spatially resolved information on the buried interface , that can additionally be related to the surface topography via the simultaneously recorded tunneling current .
the energy of the electrons contributing to the final beem current depends on the bias voltage between tip and metal , and is typically 1 to 10 ev above the fermi energy in the metal . for energies close to the threshold voltage
( the ones of primary interest for exclusive schottky barrier height ( sbh ) investigations ) , thin metallic layers , and low temperature , the main contribution to the beem current stems from the elastic component , which are electrons not having suffered losses from electron - electron and/or electron - phonon interaction . only in this limit can the technique be properly called _ ballistic _ @xcite , and we shall concentrate in this paper on the propagation of such electrons and their contribution to the beem current .
the au / si interface has been one of the first systems investigated by beem and has also proven to be a controversial one .
two important and apparently irreconcilable results have been ( i ) the elegant demonstration of nanometric resolution ( @xmath0 ) after propagation through films of as much as @xmath1 @xcite , and ( ii ) the very similar results obtained for the interfaces with si(111 ) and si(100 ) @xcite despite the strongly different k - space distribution of the projected conduction band minima ( cbm ) available for injection of electrons into the semiconductor .
the theoretical analysis of beem data is usually based on the so - called four step model @xcite : 1 ) tunneling from the tip to the surface , 2 ) propagation of the electrons through the metallic layer , 3 ) injection into the semiconductor and 4 ) effects associated to various current - changing processes in the semiconductor ( e.g. impact ionization and/or creation of secondary electrons ) . the last process becomes , however , only important at rather high energies and can be safely neglected when concentrating on the near threshold regime .
the standard model used to extract sbh s from the experiment is a simple quasi 1d semiclassical approximation using planar tunneling theory and wkb approximation for step 1 ) , free electron propagation plus simple exponential attenuation for step 2 ) and the qm transmission coefficient derived for a 1d step potential for step 3 ) .
this predicts a 5/2-power law for the onset of the beem current above the threshold energy and has been used extensively for the fitting of experimental data @xcite . despite its obvious merits and
especially its highly welcomed simplicity , the standard model fails for more than a mere qualitative explanation of experimental data . in particular ,
the above mentioned results for the au / si system are not comprehensible within the framework of this crude approximation . as has been pointed out recently @xcite , the major error leading to these discrepancies for au / si is the complete neglect of band structure effects inside the metal film .
the free electron treatment of the existing model predicts an electron beam propagating in normal direction through the metal film , grown in [ 111 ] direction on either si(111 ) or si(100 ) @xcite . on the other hand , it is a well known that au shows a band gap in just this direction @xcite , i.e. the au band structure clearly forbids electronic propagation normally through the film .
unfortunately , the inclusion of band structure effects into a theoretical model requires a much higher level of sophistication than for the previous simple approximation based on e - space monte - carlo and various parametrized processes .
we therefore present in this paper a linear combination of atomic orbitals ( lcao ) scheme for the fully quantum mechanical computation of the elastic component of the beem current : step 1 ) is included by coupling the tip to a semi - infinite crystal via the keldysh greens function formalism @xcite , whereas for step 2 ) we can take the au band structure fully into account via the corresponding slater - koster parameters @xcite .
this concept allows to compute the electron current distributions in real and reciprocal space in any layer inside the metal film .
we will show in this paper , that already the detailed analysis of these 2d distributions immediately resolves the previously puzzling results for au / si as a pure consequence of the band gap enforced sideward propagation of the electron beam inside the metal film .
this sideward beam is highly focused thus explaining the obtained nanometric resolution , but it is also dominated by electrons with rather high @xmath2-momentum parallel to the interface , which allows similar injection into the projected si cbm for both si(111 ) and si(100 ) interfaces .
even though our proposed model is a little more demanding than the old simple one both from a theoretical and a computational point of view , we believe that it allows to gain deeper insight into the physics involved and that it represents a step towards a more careful treatment of the beem process which ultimately will enable a much better use of the obtained experimental data .
our model is based on a hamiltonian written in a lcao basis : @xmath3 where @xmath4 defines the tip , @xmath5 designates the metal sample and @xmath6 describes the coupling between the tip and the surface in terms of a hopping matrix , @xmath7 ( @xmath8 , @xmath9 , and @xmath10 are number , creation and destruction operators defined in the usual way ) .
note , that greek indices indicate tip sites , whereas latin indices correspond to sites inside the sample .
the tight - binding parameters @xmath11 allow us to fully take into account the sample band structure and can be obtained within the empirical tight - binding framework by a fitting to _ ab - initio _ band structures @xcite .
tabulated values exist for all elemental crystals , in particular for au as used in the present paper @xcite . the hopping matrix between tip and sample @xmath7 is also expressed as a function of the different atomic orbitals of atom @xmath12 in the tip and atom @xmath13 in the sample . since beem experiments operate at high bias and rather low current , where the tip - surface distance is already of the order of @xmath14 , only tunneling between s - orbitals needs to be considered without loss of generality .
the actual matrix element for this tunneling between the s - orbitals is simply described by an exponential function , as derived from the wkb approximation @xcite .
it is important that @xmath7 is localized in a small region of @xmath15 atoms close to the tip .
a green s function formalism presents the important advantage of being free of any adjustable parameters in the strictly elastic limit , where only an arbitrarily small positive imaginary part @xmath16 is added to the energy , @xmath17 , necessary to ensure mathematical convergence : @xmath18 although in this paper we are not interested in discussing inelastic effects , which will form part of a forthcoming paper , it is worth mentioning that a finite @xmath16 can be used to give some attenuation to the wavefield , mimicking inelastic effects that draw away current from the beem experiment .
we shall see in the discussion of the k - space current distributions that a finite @xmath16 effectively defines a coherence region of size approximately given by @xmath19 . inside this region ,
quantum mechanical effects are important , but outside of it quantum coherence is lost and intensities rather than amplitudes should be added to compute the final wavefield .
the system under investigation is out of equilibrium as soon as a bias between tip and sample is applied@xcite . in order to retain the _ ab - initio _ advantage of a greens function formalism , but still to be able to couple the tip to the sample , it is convenient to use the keldysh technique @xcite , which essentially represents the generalization of many - body greens function theory to systems out of equilibrium @xcite . within this formalism ,
the current between two sites @xmath20 and @xmath13 in the sample can be written as : @xmath21 the matrices @xmath22 are non - equilibrium keldysh green s functions that can be calculated in terms of the retarded and advanced green s functions @xmath23/@xmath24 of the whole interacting tip - sample system .
we are interested only in the elastic component of the current , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the coupling between tip and sample that can be build up from the hopping matrices , @xmath27 , linking atoms in both subsystems , while @xmath28 refers to the keldysh green s functions of the uncoupled parts before any interaction has been switched on .
the retarded and advanced green s functions of the interacting system can be further obtained from a dyson - like equation that uses the green s functions of the uncoupled parts of the system , @xmath29/@xmath30 , and the coupling between the surface and the tip , @xmath26 : @xmath31 after some algebra , it is shown in appendix a that the current between two sites @xmath20 and @xmath13 in the metal can be obtained , in the lowest order of perturbation theory with respect to the coupling between tip and sample , from the following formula : @xmath32 de , \label{jreal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the integration is performed between the schottky barrier ( @xmath33 ) and the voltage ( @xmath34 ) applied between the tip and the sample .
we notice that this equation shows spectroscopic sensitivity because the green s functions , @xmath35 , and the hopping matrices , @xmath36 , depend on the energy , and also through the upper limit in the integral .
the summation runs over tunneling active atoms in the tip ( @xmath12 , @xmath37 ) and the sample ( @xmath15 , @xmath38 ) , @xmath39 is the density of states matrix : @xmath40 .
the trace denotes summation over the atomic orbitals forming the lcao basis .
note , that the detour via the keldysh technique has enabled us to arrive at an expression that only includes the ( tabulated ) tight - binding parameters @xmath41 inside the sample , the hopping elements @xmath42/@xmath43 between tip and sample , and the retarded and advanced equilibrium greens functions @xmath29/@xmath30 of the isolated tip and sample .
we shall describe the injection of electrons from the metal into the semiconductor simply by matching the corresponding states .
therefore , we shall need to compute the current distribution at the interface in reciprocal space .
working in a similar way as above for the real space , we find the following expression for the current distribution in reciprocal space defined now between planes @xmath20 and @xmath13 : @xmath44 de \label{reciprocal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in this case the sum runs over layers in the tip ( @xmath12 , @xmath37 ) and sample ( @xmath15 , @xmath38 ) that are involved in the tunneling process .
all quantities in eq .
( [ reciprocal ] ) are the @xmath45-fourier transforms of the corresponding objects in formula ( [ jreal ] ) .
the total current between planes @xmath20 and @xmath13 can be obtained by summing the current distribution @xmath46 as obtained in eq .
( [ reciprocal ] ) over the 2d brillouin zone .
it is worth mentioning , that even though the total resulting current at the given stm bias @xmath47 is obtained as an integral in energies down to the sbh , the dominant contribution will be just the one at @xmath47 itself , due to the strong exponential dependence of the tunneling coupling terms @xmath27 with energy .
this shall allow us to present qualitative results displaying only this main contribution ( calculated at the highest energy , @xmath34 ) , although we have additionally verified that essentially the same effects occur at lower energies .
> from equation ( [ jreal ] ) it is clear that the main objects of interest that still need to be calculated are the retarded and advanced equilibrium greens functions @xmath48/@xmath49 for a metallic surface .
we compute these quantities using a decimation technique @xcite , which involves an iterative process allowing in each step to double in size an existing slab ( the so - called `` superlayers '' in figure [ geometry]a ) . assuming perfect periodicity in both directions parallel to the surface one can easily calculate @xmath50 , the retarded green s function of the surface superlayer which contains the tunnel - active layers @xmath51 .
the layer doubling of the slab is then repeated until its size is so large , that the two surfaces are effectively decoupled .
hence , we obtain the greens function projected at the surface , @xmath52 , and the _ transfer matrix _ of the system@xcite . with these two quantities
it is possible to calculate the green s function @xmath53 , representing the propagation of an electron of momentum @xmath2 and energy @xmath17 from the surface superlayer @xmath54 up to the layer @xmath13 inside the semi - infinite crystal . the corresponding green s function in real space
is subsequently obtained by fourier transforming : = 0.5 @xmath55 where the summation is performed over n special points @xcite in the 2d brillouin zone with respective weights @xmath56 . finally , it is straightforward , to obtain the corresponding advanced greens function by transposing and conjugating : @xmath57^ { * } \label{advaret}\ ] ] equations ( [ jreal])-([advaret ] ) define our basic approach to the beem problem .
let us draw our attention to the full quantum - mechanical calculations in real space based on equation ( [ jreal ] ) and the decimation technique .
the total procedure outlined in this section enables the computation of 2d current distributions at any layer inside the semi - infinite crystal . using eq .
( [ jreal ] ) , and calculating @xmath58 for all atoms @xmath20 inside a given layer , with current contributions from all their respective neighbours @xmath13 in the layer above , we arrive at the current distribution in real space .
this simulates the beem current impinging on the semiconductor after propagation through a metallic film with a thickness corresponding to the chosen layer @xmath20 .
results of this type will help us to understand which spatial resolution can be expected in a beem experiment .
alternatively , the calculation of @xmath59 according to eq .
( [ reciprocal ] ) provides the current distribution between layers @xmath20 and @xmath13 inside the 2d projected brillouin zone .
since ultimately the electrons need not only to have sufficient energy to enter the semiconductor as beem current , but also to have the corresponding @xmath60 to get into the si cbm , this type of plot will permit us to investigate the onset and strength of the beem current for a certain type of interface .
when concentrating on the near threshold region , i.e. injection into the bottom of the si conduction bands , the latter may be approximated by free electron - like paraboloids with appropriate effective masses@xcite . in the 2d projection on either the au / si(111 ) or au / si(100 ) interface this will then lead to a number of ellipses inside the brillouin zone , representing areas through which transmission into the semiconductor is possible @xcite .
to arrive at quantitative results , additionally a qm transmission factor for each of the matched states has subsequently to be applied .
however , in the present paper we shall be concerned rather with qualitative results apparent from the 2d distributions themselves , and may thus leave the question of modeling the transmission factor for a forthcoming publication @xcite .
we feel that more physical insight is gained by visually comparing how the current distribution in the metal matches the available states in the semiconductor , than by presenting the final beem current , which results from a summation over all states with right matching conditions inside the 2d brillouin zone .
therefore , in this work we simply draw in the 2d brillouin zone the si cbm ellipses to aid the eye identifying the relevant regions .
we stress that the final summation tends to smooth details and , as the physically measurable observable is only the @xmath45-integrated @xmath61 curve , this might be one reason that helps to explain why the previous simple models achieve in many cases decent fits to the data , even though it is quite obvious that the underlying 2d current distribution is grossly inconsistent with the metal band structure .
we apply our quantum - mechanical formalism to describe the elastic propagation of electrons through a [ 111]-oriented au metallic layer . due to the large lattice mismatch between au ( @xmath62 ) and si ( @xmath63)@xcite ,
the formed interface is of rather poor quality .
although the growth of au layers on si has not yet been studied extensively , there is evidence from low energy electron diffraction and auger studies , that suggest that au films growing either on si(111)@xcite or on si(100)@xcite form crystals oriented in the [ 111 ] direction after the first four or five layers , which typically display heavy disorder , are completed . from the nature of our results , that show the gradual build - up of bloch waves as a function of the distance to the surface
, we deduce that the likely disorder contained in four or five layers immediate to the interface , does not provoke the automatic destruction of the formed pattern .
we therefore take the calculated 2d distributions in any given layer of the ideal semi - infinite crystal as a good approximation to the actual current arriving at the si semiconductor after propagation through a au film of corresponding thickness and passage through the disordered interface region . before discussing our full quantum - mechanical results
, it is worth analyzing the semiclassical limit , which is based on koster s approximation to compute the bulk green s functions@xcite and an appropriate symmetrization of waves reflected at the surface@xcite .
the central point in this semiclassical approach mainly valid for thick layers is that it admits a simple geometrical interpretation for the bulk propagators , relating them to the shape of the constant energy surface ( fermi surface ) of the metal band structure : applying a stationary phase condition all @xmath64-values contributing to the final green s function may be neglected except one particular @xmath65@xcite : @xmath66 @xmath67 where @xmath68 , @xmath69 are the two principal curvatures associated with the constant energy surface and the eigenvectors @xmath70 , @xmath71 are obtained diagonalizing the bulk tight - binding hamiltonian @xmath72 .
= 0.5 for a given propagation direction @xmath73 , @xmath65 is the vector linking the @xmath64-space origin to the point on the constant energy surface ( defined by the energy @xmath17 ) whose perpendicular to the surface is parallel to the initially chosen direction in real space ( see inset in fig .
[ fermisurf ] ) .
this vector perpendicular to the constant energy surface at @xmath65 represents the group velocity of electrons being propagated in the metal , @xmath74 , that needs not to be parallel to @xmath65 when the metal band structure deviates from the free electron limit .
( [ oldg ] ) reveals that the current intensity is strongly enhanced in directions corresponding to rather flat parts of the constant energy surface , where the principal curvatures @xmath68 and @xmath69 in the denominator tend towards zero ( note , that at the extremal points , where the second derivatives are exactly zero , the next term in koster s expansion is needed ) .
hence , already a simple visual analysis of the constant energy surface s shape may provide an intuitive understanding where major ballistic current contributions are to be expected when including band structure effects . as pointed out previously@xcite , for the analysis of electron propagation in au layers at typical beem energies , it is crucial to notice that for voltages larger than @xmath75v necks develop in the [ 100 ] directions , which are similar to the well known necks in the [ 111 ] directions , cf .
[ fermisurf ] . identifying the flat parts on this surface and their corresponding real space propagation directions
, we were able to make a qualitative prediction of the current distributions in real and reciprocal space after propagation through a thick au film@xcite . in fig .
[ fermisurf ] , we have drawn the au constant energy surface for 1 ev above @xmath76 , and the regions ( dashed areas ) giving the major contribution to the semiclassical beem current in k - space .
one of these areas is also shown in the figure inset : the reason why the k - space current distribution maximum is associated with the a - region , and not with the apparently equivalent a-region , is their different orientation w.r.t . the ( 111)-direction
( see . figs . 6 and 8) .
it should be kept in mind that the dashed areas of fig .
[ fermisurf ] define the momentum and velocity components of the electrons contributing most to the beem - current : the group velocity defining the semiclassical propagation in real space .
since most beem modeling up to now has been performed using e - space monte - carlo techniques , it may be interesting to notice , that apart from the neck regions where no propagation is possible , the au constant energy surface remains spherical to a good approximation ( fig . [ fermisurf ] ) : the group velocity @xmath77 perpendicular to the surface and the connecting k - vector @xmath65 do not diverge by more than @xmath78 for most directions of interest outside the necks . when properly suppressing the forbidden propagation directions corresponding to the necks , a simple application of k - space monte - carlo simulation should thus be possible , resulting in analogous results to ours in the purely ballistic limit .
this allows the simulation of inelastic interactions in an approximate but simple way through the inclusion of the appropriate k - space scattering cross sections , reaching the interesting conclusion that those effects do not significatively degrade the elastic predicted resolution in real space@xcite .
the presented semiclassical approach helps to better understand the numerical results in terms of the geometrical interpretation .
however , we have also at hand the quantum mechanical decimation technique for the computation of the greens functions , which allows us to precisely calculate these distributions and also not only for thick films , but for any thickness . since we are only interested in the qualitative evolution of injected current in a [ 111]-oriented au film , we start with a simplified tunneling geometry , in which hopping is only permitted between one tip atom @xmath79 and one sample atom @xmath54 positioning the tip directly on top of the latter at @xmath80 distance , cf .
[ geometry]b .
more realistic tunnel geometries allowing hopping to more atoms lead to essentially the same results : one advantage of properly taking the metal band structure into account is that the results are not that much dependent on the initial tunneling conditions as long as metallic films of a certain thickness are involved .
this is a strong difference between our theory and the standard ballistic e - space monte - carlo approach .
the k - space distribution arriving at the semiconductor under the assumption of free electron propagation is inappropriate for both very thick and very thin layers : ( i ) it is physically unreasonable to assume that what impinges on the interface ( after a long propagation through the metal ) is just the initial tunneling distribution , and ( ii ) on the other hand , when the film is thin enough for the details of tunneling to become important , the crude planar theory based on wkb should not be applied . on the contrary , in all the examples presented in this paper ( where we have deliberately avoided ultra thin layers )
, tunneling simply provides a starting configuration , whereas the final current distribution at the interface is dominated by the preferred propagation directions dictated by the metal band structure . in any case , should the initial tunneling distribution become important for some particular application , our formalism would permit a more realistic point of view for that part of the problem .
= 0.5 this discussion is illustrated in fig .
[ realspace1 ] , where the resulting real space current distribution after electron propagation through more and more layers is depicted . as electron energy we chose 1 ev above the fermi level of the metal .
2971 special k - points were used inside the 2d au brillouin zone to suppress possible aliasing effects in the involved fourier transforms to real space . in the second layer , very near to the surface ( fig .
[ realspace1]a ) , the current is still strongly concentrated in the atoms closest to the location in the surface layer in which the current was injected .
this behaviour , where the current still propagates in all directions and where the resulting distribution is basically a consequence of the crystal geometry and nearest neighbour hopping , can be found down to about the fifth layer .
then , however , an interesting change occurs , which is related to the gradual formation of a bloch wave inside the crystal : propagation becomes only possible in directions in accordance with the metal band structure .
the immediate consequence of the already mentioned band gap of au in the [ 111 ] direction is that the evolving beam has to make way sidewards .
this becomes obvious in fig .
[ realspace1]b , where the opening up of the injected beam can already be observed with very little current remaining in the central plane atoms lying in the [ 111 ] forward direction .
a further effect of the band structure is the formation of narrowly focused , kossel - like lines corresponding to preferred propagation directions .
after propagation through a larger number of layers , a steady state is reached and distributions for consecutive layers differ only by the natural spreading of the resulting triangle as the electrons follow these preferred propagation directions of the band structure , cf .
[ realspace1]c .
these directions have a polar angle of about @xmath81 with respect to the normal direction , and are in good agreement with our previous semiclassical analysis@xcite ( see fig . [ fermisurf ] ) .
note , how different the resulting pattern in each layer is from the prediction of the simple , free electron model : there the propagation would be solely dictated by the @xmath60-spreading of the initial tunneling distribution resulting in a current cone centered around the [ 111 ] direction .
consequently , the real space distribution in any layer parallel to the surface would be a filled circle ( or rather a filled triangle , considering the symmetry of a fcc ( 111 ) crystal @xcite ) with the major current contributions directly in the middle corresponding to normal propagation through the metal film .
= 0.5 the deeper the chosen layer , i.e. the larger the thickness of the experimental film , the more spread over a larger triangle the current would be .
the simple application of the uncertainty principle to the tunneling process plus a free electron model for the metal @xcite predicted a beem resolution for relatively thick @xmath1 au films of at best @xmath82 . on the contrary , the experiment by milliken et al .
@xcite finds typical resolutions for such films on both si(111 ) or si(100 ) of about @xmath83 . in that experiment ,
sharp sio@xmath84 steps are created on both si substrate types and subsequently covered by @xmath85 au films .
beem images of the step riser , when the tip crosses from above a part corresponding to the impenetrable sio@xmath84 to a part , where beem injection into the si is possible , give a direct reflection of the size of the electron beam at the interface .
the typical @xmath83 found are absolutely incompatible with the standard ballistic , free particle propagation used in the simple model and are difficult to justify even if parametrized electron - electron / electron - phonon interaction is taken into account@xcite . on the other hand , we believe that the observed formation of narrowly focused kossel - like lines as caused by the au band structure may already explain the experimentally obtained nanometric resolution in the purely elastic limit . as can be seen in fig .
[ realspace1]c , the width of these lines carrying the beem current is typically 3 - 4 atomic distances .
this is better appreciated in fig .
[ rprofile ] , where cuts perpendicular through these lines at two different positions were performed and the intensity vs. location is depicted .
the derived width of @xmath86 is in very good agreement with the experimentally observed value and is clearly distinct from the value derived from free electron theory , which deviates by a complete order of magnitude .
a naive interpretation of this result seems to imply that multiple images of interface objects should be observed superimposed , since several such kossel - lines are present in our distribution .
a tip scan would sweep each of these lines across the interface object , each time leading to a focused signal .
it should , however , be born in mind , that so far we have used unrealistically symmetric conditions for the current injection process : the on top tip site used , allows the current pattern to display the full threefold symmetry of the fcc crystal@xcite and hence predicts the existence of three equivalent kossel - like lines . during the scan , less symmetric tip sites are on the contrary involved , reducing logically the resulting overall symmetry of the current distribution . to verify this , we repeated the calculation , this time using a bridge site for the tip and allowing tunneling to both closest atoms on the surface , cf .
[ geometry]b .
several conclusions can be drawn from the result shown in fig .
[ realspace2 ] , which is for the limiting case after propagation through already a thick film .
first , as expected , the overall symmetry of the pattern has reduced from threefold to twofold , with one of the three kossel - like lines decreasing in intensity .
second and most importantly , the shape of the distribution has essentially not changed .
this is the confirmation of the introductory statement made at the beginning of this section : the inclusion of band structure effects reduces considerably the influence of the initial tunneling distribution .
the preferred directions of propagation are exclusively dictated by the band structure , whereas it is only the population of these directions with electrons that depends on the actual tunneling process .
in this respect , we again observe in fig .
[ realspace2 ] the @xmath87 off - normal , sideward propagation along focused lines , of which now only the two corresponding to the chosen tunnel symmetry are mainly populated .
= 0.5 as we are interested in highlighting the relevant physical phenomena , we have introduced convenient approximations : one atom tip , spherical s - wave tunneling and a perfect substrate without any tilt , nor defects on the surface . in turn
, the model neglects a number of factors that necessarily would result in a lower symmetry than the one existing in a realistic experimental setup .
however , it is plausible to accept that different factors concur in the experiment to degrade symmetry , and will eventually lead to the selection of only one of the possible kossel - like lines , whose dominant contribution will then be responsible for the observed beem image with its nanometric resolution . on the other hand ,
none of the experimental influences can change the metal band structure itself ( as long as there are at least crystal grains of the order of 100 ) , so that the formation of focused kossel - like lines will be very similar to the one seen in our idealized model calculations .
in order to understand how the current distribution in the metal matches the available states in the semiconductor , we now proceed to calculate the 2d distributions in reciprocal space using expression ( [ reciprocal ] ) .
[ kspace1]a shows the result obtained inside the au brillouin zone , again for the symmetrical on top tip site , cf .
[ geometry]b , and for an electron energy of @xmath88ev , which is still near the threshold region for au / si . as a direct reflection of the au [ 111 ] band gap , which projects onto @xmath89 in the center of the hexagon
, the distribution displays a ring - like structure , since there are no states to carry the current in the @xmath89 vicinity .
it is again interesting to notice , how different this pattern is from the free electron prediction , that would inject the main current with @xmath90 just into @xmath89 . in reality ,
complete reflection occurs for tunnel electrons with @xmath90 , permitting only injection into the au(111 ) states of rather high @xmath91-momentum .
= 0.5 we would like to stress that the use of the decimation technique , which was derived from renormalization group techniques @xcite , permits the fully quantum mechanical calculation of both required greens propagators @xmath92/@xmath93 of the semi - infinite slab .
the resulting beem current is consequently also fully quantum mechanical .
it is therefore not surprising that the distribution shown in fig .
[ kspace1]a possesses a sixfold symmetry , which relates to the symmetry of the [ 111 ] projected density of states to which @xmath94 and @xmath95 states contribute equally @xcite .
this is at variance with a semiclassical distribution , where only @xmath64-vectors representing propagation towards the interface must be considered .
these waves are classically separated from those that propagate in the opposite direction and the total vector field has thus the same symmetry as the constant energy surface , which in turn reflects the symmetry of the lattice , i.e. threefold for [ 111 ] directions in a fcc material @xcite .
hence , our previous semiclassical approach yielded threefold symmetric beem current distributions @xcite . as has already been mentioned in section ii
, the use of a finite self - energy @xmath16 in the construction of the greens functions ( [ green ] ) puts some limits on the coherence length of our quantum mechanical computation . in the purely elastic limit , corresponding to a theoretical @xmath96 in eq .
( [ green ] ) , the obtained distribution would not change at all after propagation through an infinite number of layers . in the ideal crystal ,
there are simply no processes enforcing @xmath60-changes of the elastic electrons after their injection .
numerically , we are however forced to choose a small , but finite @xmath16 to ensure convergence .
the result presented in fig .
[ kspace1]a was hence obtained for @xmath97 ev , which is very small compared to the energy @xmath98 ev considered , and corresponds to a coherence length of several thousand ngstrm .
no significant changes of the distribution can be observed during the propagation through many layers . since in this case
we are always well inside the coherence region , the symmetry is sixfold , as it should be for a quantum mechanical calculation .
= 0.5 on the other hand , we can considerably reduce the coherence length by using a much larger value for the optical potential , say @xmath99ev .
there would then exist a regime outside the coherence region where interference terms do not play a significant role any more .
this should allow us to recover the semiclassical results .
[ kspace1]b shows the obtained distribution for such a large @xmath16 and for the 30th layer in the crystal , i.e. well outside the coherence region .
it is most gratifying that not only the expected threefold symmetry appears , but that also the actual pattern matches perfectly with our semiclassical prediction , that was then only derived schematically , cf .
fig . 3 of ref .
moreover , it is interesting to notice how our greens function calculation permits to reproduce the involved change in symmetry : even for a large @xmath16 , propagation in the first layers is still inside the small coherence region and thus quantum mechanical effects are observed to produce the corresponding sixfold symmetry . during the propagation through more and more layers , the quantum coherence is gradually lost as is the symmetry , which progressively approaches its threefold limit .
this allows to study the crossover between the quantum and the semiclassical domain and provides another example of how a quantum system , under the influence of friction , becomes classical by a decoherence process @xcite . note , that the change in symmetry implies also a change of the detailed current distribution itself :
the maxima of the semiclassical pattern appear on the lines @xmath100 , whereas the quantum mechanical maxima lie along the directions @xmath101 .
this is more obvious in fig .
[ kprofile ] , where an intensity cut along the symmetry lines @xmath102 is presented : the relative weight between currents along @xmath103 and @xmath100 respectively is inversed between the two types of calculations , which is a reflection of the symmetry change .
it is interesting to notice that the evolution from the quantum symmetry to the classical one is gradually build up , and no sudden change between both regimes is found .
our calculations showed that the observed difference in reciprocal space does not significantly affect the beams in real space ( where the symmetry must always be threefold ) , but it could nevertheless in principle affect the i(v ) current injected through the projected ellipses into the semiconductor .
however , because of the gradual crossover , no dramatic effects are to be expected , unless one could experimentally break the time - reversal symmetry suddenly ( e.g. by application of a magnetic field ) .
= 0.5 as a final point we address the actual transmission of the current into the semiconductor states .
the chosen energy @xmath88ev is still in the near threshold region ( @xmath104ev , @xmath105ev @xcite ) justifying to approximate the si cbm by nearly free electron ellipsoids .
since si is an indirect semiconductor , these ellipsoids are not located around @xmath106 in the brillouin zone , but ca .
85% in direction @xmath107 @xcite and hence project differently onto the [ 111 ] and [ 100 ] directions @xcite .
the resulting ellipses for both orientations are drawn in fig .
[ remapping]a and [ remapping]b .
note , that since we are calculating inside the larger au brillouin zone , those ellipses belonging to higher si brillouin zones , but still within the first au one , have to be considered for current injection as well .
the principal difference for both au / si(111 ) and au / si(100 ) interfaces is that in the latter case si ellipsoids project directly onto @xmath89 , which is where the simple free electron picture puts the maximum current . since very little current carried by electrons with high @xmath60-momentum
is predicted in this type of model , a considerable difference in the onset and absolute magnitude of the beem current was originally anticipated between both interfaces @xcite . on the contrary , the actual , experimentally observed spectra were highly similar @xcite .
since this result was irreconcilable with the ballistic free electron theory , a variety of processes ranging from more isotropic tunnel distributions @xcite over strong elastic electron - electron interaction @xcite to @xmath2-violation at the non - epitactic interfaces @xcite were proposed in an extensive debate in the literature .
all these processes aimed at providing @xmath60-momentum to the current distribution to allow injection into the off - normal [ 111 ] ellipses , but ran into considerable trouble through the simultaneous , inherent loss of resolution @xcite . on the other hand ,
the ring - like current pattern predicted by our band structure calculation is dominated by high @xmath60-momenta , ( cf .
8) but without loss of resolution , as we have seen in the last section . the total reflection of the injected electrons around @xmath89 due to the projected au band gap renders the existence or non - existence of a si ellipse in that region completely irrelevant , since no current can enter through it into the semiconductor in any case , and the current is therefore forced to enter via any of the off - normal ellipses for both au / si(111 ) ( fig .
[ remapping]a ) and au / si(100 ) ( fig .
[ remapping]b ) .
the ring - like distribution may in zeroth order be well described as azimuthally symmetric , making it highly plausible why the beem current shows similar onset and magnitude : the exact location of the off - normal ellipses plays only a minor role .
finally , we quantify this result by comparing the actual current injected into the ( 100 ) and ( 111 ) silicon orientations .
as mentioned in the beginning , we shall not get at this stage into the separate problem of computing a suitable transmission coefficient to keep our discussion as simple as possible .
hence , we simply use @xmath108 , which is justified because we shall only present the ratio between the current injected into both silicon faces @xmath109 , where factors not very sensitive to a particular silicon orientation cancel out . in particular ,
this is the case for the transmission coefficient @xmath110 as can easily be checked with the crude 1d step - barrier approximation@xcite .
similarly , we do not need to consider inelastic effects , that are anticipated to affect equally electrons approaching the si(100 ) or the si(111 ) surface , and should in general be small when considering thin metal films . the ratio shown in fig .
[ 111vs100 ] compares well with the experimental ratio obtained from refs .
( ) , reproducing not only the correct order of magnitude , but also the overall trend with energy .
the largest difference of @xmath11130% is seen in the low voltage region where experimental currents are weak and difficult to measure , and where the total current depends most sensitively on the exact value of the sbh for both orientations , whereas we have made no effort in fitting these values , but have simply taken averages over the big number of existing experimental values ( which differ easily by 0.1 ev ) .
it is hence not surprising that the agreement in the lowest 0.2 ev above the sbh is not as convincing as it is at the higher voltages .
taking finally into account the crudeness of the applied model where we have deliberately avoided the fitting of any parameter to focus on physical insight , we believe that the presented ring - like distribution provides a satisfactory and intuitive explanation of the observed effect .
in conclusion , we have presented a theoretical model that allows the calculation of the elastic contribution to the beem current in the near threshold range . based on a lcao scheme and a keldysh greens function formalism , 2d distributions in real and reciprocal space
may be computed in any layer of a semi - infinite crystal after current is injected from a tip atom .
subsequent matching with the semiconductor states permits to extract the actual beem current , although the main emphasis in the present paper has been on the qualitative understanding that can already be obtained from the 2d patterns themselves .
the model allows for the first time to fully take into account the influence of the metal band structure in the beem process , and possesses the further advantage of being free of any adjustable parameter in the strictly elastic limit .
the application to the system au / si shows a variety of consequences of the au band gap in the [ 111 ] direction . in real space , the formation of narrowly focused kossel - like lines and a sideward beam propagation is observed , which may explain the experimentally obtained nanometric resolution . in reciprocal space
, a symmetry change between quantum mechanical and semi - classical regime can be related to the gradual breaking of quantum coherence .
the actual pattern in k - space has a ring - like shape , which calls for current injection via the off - normal si ellipses for both au / si(111 ) and au / si(100 ) .
hence , the sole inclusion of band structure effects achieves to explain the nanometric resolution and the similarity of beem spectra on both si orientations on the same footing in the purely elastic limit without any adjustable parameter and without the necessity to invoke any further scattering process .
k.r . is grateful for financial support from sfb292 ( germany ) .
we also acknowledge financial support from the spanish cicyt under contracts number pb92 - 0168c and pb94 - 53 .
we start from formula ( [ start ] ) and the keldysh green s functions defined in ( [ eqgkeldysh ] ) .
the coupling term @xmath26 can be expressed as a function of the real hopping matrices , @xmath7 , that link tunneling active atoms in the tip ( @xmath12 ) with the corresponding ones in the sample ( @xmath15 ) .
the keldysh greens function @xmath28 of the uncoupled ( and hence equilibrium ) system can be expressed as a function of the advanced and retarded green s function of the uncoupled parts @xmath116/@xmath30 and the fermi distribution functions of the tip , @xmath117 , and sample , @xmath118 : the term @xmath123 in ( [ second ] ) gives a zero contribution to the current because it corresponds to the current between sites @xmath20 and @xmath13 inside the metal in the absence of tip - sample coupling , which obviously must be zero .
let us work now with the term associated to the tip , @xmath124 .
this term can be simplified by using the well known relation between advanced and retarded green s functions : @xmath125 .
the real matrix @xmath42 is just equal to @xmath126 .
hence : the retarded and advanced green s functions for the interacting system can further be obtained from a dyson - like equation that uses the green s functions of the uncoupled parts of the system @xmath29/@xmath30 and the coupling term @xmath129/ @xmath130 ( equation [ eqgdyson ] ) : if the values of the coupling matrix @xmath7 are much smaller than hopping terms inside the metal ( as it is the case in tunneling conditions ) we can work in the lowest order perturbation theory and approximate @xmath132 and @xmath133 simply by @xmath134 and @xmath135 , respectively .
moreover , we can further simplify the expression for @xmath124 by relating @xmath136 with the density of states matrix at the tip @xmath39 by the equation @xmath137 : it is easy to demonstrate that the first term of this equation is zero because it is the real part of the difference of two magnitudes , one being the complex conjugate of the other .
hence @xmath139 can be shortened to : assuming zero temperature , we obtain the current between two sample sites @xmath20 and @xmath13 in the sample as an integral over a window of energies ranging from the schottky barrier height ( @xmath33 ) up to the applied voltage of the imaginary part of the trace of a product of matrices : | we present a green s function approach based on a lcao scheme to compute the elastic propagation of electrons injected from a stm tip into a metallic film .
the obtained 2d current distributions in real and reciprocal space furnish a good representation of the elastic component of ballistic electron emission microscopy ( beem ) currents . since this component accurately approximates the total current in the near threshold region , this procedure allows in contrast to prior analyses to take into account effects of the metal band structure in the modeling of these experiments . the au band structure , and in particular its gaps appearing in the [ 111 ] and [ 100 ] directions , provides a good explanation for the previously irreconcilable results of nanometric resolution and similarity of beem spectra on both au / si(111 ) and au / si(100 ) . |
the fascinating and rich phenomenology of high temperature cuprate superconductors has been very thoroughly studied over the past 20 years .
although there is substantial variability in detail from material to material , all cuprates exhibit robust mott insulator antiferromagnetism when the hole - doping fraction @xmath1 is very small , superconductivity which appears when @xmath1 exceeds a minimum value @xmath4 , and a maximum @xmath5 in optimally doped materials with @xmath6 . in the underdoped regime , the superconducting transition temperature is limited by phase fluctuations@xcite , and experiments hint at a wide variety of ( typically ) short - range correlations associated with competing charge and spin orders .
the underdoped regime poses a fundamental challenge to theory because its electronic properties are not fully consistent with any of the various well - understood _ fixed - point _
behaviors that often help us to classify and predict the properties of very complex materials .
the phenomenological parameter @xmath0 used to characterize phase - fluctuation stiffness in a superconductor is normally expressed in terms of the superfluid density @xmath7 by writing @xmath8 , an identification that is partly justified by bcs mean - field theory .
the increase of @xmath0 with @xmath1 in cuprate superconductors is therefore readily accounted for by theories@xcite in which superconductivity is due to the condensation of cooper pairs formed from holes in a doped mott insulator@xcite .
theories which start with this view must still explain the fact that @xmath0 vanishes at a non - zero value of @xmath1 , and deal with the awkward property that cuprate superconductivity evolves smoothly from the underdoped regime to an overdoped regime in which it appears to be explainable in terms of conventional band - quasiparticle cooper pair condensation .
in this article we propose an alternate explanation for the @xmath1-dependence of @xmath0 based on band - quasiparticle pairing .
our argument accounts for the correlation energy of a d - wave superconductor in the presence of incipient antiferromagnetism and is based on the following general expression for the phase stiffness of a superconductor : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the area of the system , @xmath11 the pairing wavevector@xcite , and @xmath12 is the total energy including both mean - field and correlation contributions : @xmath13 .
the familiar bcs theory expression for @xmath0 captures only the mean - field theory contribution to the energy .
when superconductivity is viewed as a weak - coupling instability of a fermi liquid , it is usually implicitly assumed that @xmath14 is not significantly influenced by the formation of the superconducting condensate , and certainly not by changes in the condensate s pairing momentum @xmath11 . in the case of simple models with parabolic bands and galilean
invariance , neglect of the correlation energy contribution can be justified rigorously .
we argue the correlation energy contribution is significant in underdoped cuprates because there is direct competition between the fermi sea quantum fluctuations which condense in antiferromagnetic and d - wave superconducting states .
consequently the pair - breaking effects of finite @xmath11 , which weaken superconductivity , also increase the importance of antiferromagnetic fluctuations , lowering @xmath14 and decreasing @xmath0 compared to its mean - field value . in the following sections we first use a fully phenomenological and then a partially microscopic extended - hubbard - model weak - coupling theory to expand on this idea .
the conjugate relationship@xcite between pairing and antiferromagnetic fluctuations plays an important role in the fluctuation spectrum and hence in theories of the correlation energy . in our theory of the underdoped state , the resonant magnetic mode ( insr ) observed in inelastic neutron scattering@xcite experiments
therefore has a somewhat different interpretation than in most earlier theory@xcite , appearing as a kind of magnetic plasmon .
the basic ideas of our theory are qualitative , independent of most microscopic details , and most easily described in terms of the properties of a low - energy effective - field model for the collective fluctuations of a weak - coupling d - wave superconductor .
the relationship to less transparent generalized random - phase approximation ( grpa ) correlation energy calculations is explained below .
we construct a quantum action by introducing a set of states which incorporate the coupled triplet - pairing and spin - density fluctuations on which we focus .
@xmath15\rangle$ ] is the fock - space slater determinant ground state of the quadratic hamiltonian @xmath16 \displaystyle & + \delta_0 \big [ \sum_{i\tau } ( -)^{\tau } [ \exp(i\phi_i)-1 ] c_{i\uparrow}^{\dagger } c_{i+\tau\downarrow}^{\dagger } + h.c .
\end{array } \label{h1body}\ ] ] ( for notational simplicity we have exhibited here only fluctuations with zero spin projection along the quantization direction . ) in eq .
[ [ h1body ] ] , @xmath17 labels the four neighbours of each site on a two - dimensional square lattice , and @xmath18 represents the d - wave variation of mean - field near - neighbor pair potentials . using these states as an approximate identity resolution leads to the following low - energy imaginary - time action for the collective variables @xmath19 and @xmath20 : @xmath21 \vert \partial_{\tau } \vert \psi[\phi , v ] \rangle + e[\phi , v]\ ; \big ] , \label{colaction}\ ] ] where @xmath22= \langle \psi[\phi , v ] \vert { \cal h } \vert \psi[\phi , v ] \rangle$ ] and @xmath23 is the full microscopic hamiltonian .
mean - field theory states are obtained by minimizing @xmath22 $ ] .
the first term in the action captures the berry phase coupling@xcite between pairing and spin - density fluctuations on which we now elaborate .
the potentials associated with the two types of fluctuations are : @xmath24 .
\label{forces } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the berry phase term can be evaluated explicitly for small fluctuations by using perturbation theory expressions for the wavefunctions which appear in the slater determinant @xmath15\rangle$ ] : @xmath25 where @xmath26 } { ( e_{\vec{p}+\vec{k}}+e_{\vec{p}})^{2}}. \label{curvature}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ curvature ] ) we have made the usual nambu spin - down particle - hole transformation of the mean - field hamiltonian so that it has two eigenstates at each wavevector in the square lattice brillouin zone with eigenvalues @xmath27 , one ( @xmath28 ) occupied and one ( @xmath29 ) unoccupied . in fig . [
[ fig : one ] ] we show berry curvature values calculated from this expression as a function of @xmath30 which are strongly peaked near @xmath31 ; these results are robust over a broad range of dopings , gap sizes , and band - structure models . pairing phase fluctuations
are conjugate to spin - density fluctuations for @xmath30 near @xmath32 , just as they are conjugate to charge - density fluctuations for @xmath30 near @xmath33 , because of@xcite the d - wave property @xmath34 .
( color online ) berry s curvature @xmath35 _ vs. _
@xmath30 for the @xmath3-wave mean - field state of a generalized hubbard model with @xmath36 , and @xmath37 .
@xmath38 in this case . ]
we now argue that there is competition between the correlation energy gain due to antiferromagnetic fluctuations and d - wave singlet cooper pair formation .
strong experimental evidence for this competition is provided by the apparent enhancement@xcite of antiferromagnetic fluctuations in cuprate vortex cores and in cuprates placed in an external magnetic fields .
changes in external conditions which weaken superconductivity enhance antiferromagnetism . here
we explore consequences of this competition for the correlation contribution to the superfluid density , _
i.e. _ for the dependence of correlation energy on pairing - momentum @xmath11 . in our model the quadratic fluctuation action of a d - wave superconductor is @xmath39 \displaystyle \ ; \ ; + \ ; k^{sp}_{\vec{k},\omega } \ ; |v(\vec{k},\omega)|^2 \ ; + \ ; k^{\phi}_{\vec{k},\omega } \ ; |\phi(\vec{k},\omega)|^2 \ ; \big ] . \end{array } \label{fluclagrangian}\ ] ] in eq .
[ [ fluclagrangian ] ] , @xmath40 and @xmath41 are phase and spin - density stiffnesses .
the onset of antiferromagnetism occurs when @xmath42 . in using this action
we assume that the most important quantum fluctuations are d - wave pair phase and spin - fluctuations .
the microscopic calculations grpa described in the next section support this assumption . in eq .
[ [ fluclagrangian ] ] , frequency dependence is indicated in @xmath35 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 to recognize the existence of non - adiabatic effects accounted for in these more microscopic calculations but neglected in this qualitative discussion .
the quadratic fluctuation action then describes a system with collective modes at energies @xmath45 and a corresponding zero - point energy contribution @xmath46 this adiabatic theory of the insr mode is accurate only when @xmath47 lies below the particle - hole continuum ; the prime on the wavevector sum above recognizes that this condition is satisfied only near @xmath48 .
the fluctuation correction to @xmath0 can be related to the pairing - wavevector dependence of the zero - point energy as we explain below .
we expect @xmath49 to decrease with @xmath11 because suppressed pairing favors antiferromagnetism .
the strength of this dependence can be estimated roughly from experiment by associating the magnetic length @xmath50 at the magnetic field strength required to induce antiferromagnetism in a cuprate superconductor with the value of @xmath51 at which @xmath49 goes to zero .
taking a typical value for this field @xmath52 and assuming that the resonance mode is well defined over the portion of the bz with large berry curvature ( say @xmath53 ) , gives a negative correlation energy contribution to the phase stiffness per two - dimensional cuprate layer of @xmath54 , comparable to the value of @xmath0 inferred from penetration depth measurements in optimally doped samples .
although this estimate is clearly very rough , it does establish that the correlation correction to @xmath0 can be substantial in the underdoped regime .
charge density fluctuations are not included in this analysis because their berry phase coupling to the phase fluctuations of the superconducting order parameter is large only near @xmath55 and negligible near @xmath48@xcite .
thereofore the charge density fluctuations do not play a significant roles for the physics near @xmath48 , instead they cause the instabilities near @xmath55 in the microscopic grpa calculations which we mention below .
we now evaluate the correlation energy of an extended hubbard model@xcite in the generalized random phase approximation ( grpa ) approximation .
the model we study in this article has on - site repulsive interactions @xmath56 which drive antiferromagnetism and near - neighbour attractive interactions @xmath57 which drive d - wave superconductivity : @xmath58 , @xmath59 \displaystyle h_u = u\sum_i \hat{n}_{i\uparrow}\hat{n}_{i\downarrow}\,\,\,,\,\,\,h_v =- v\sum_{<i , j>\sigma\sigma'}\hat{n}_{i\sigma}\hat{n}_{j\sigma'}. \end{array } \label{tuv}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ tuv ] ) @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 should all be thought of as effective parameters which apply at the energy scale of pairing and depend on @xmath1 .
values for @xmath57 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 can be estimated from arpes data@xcite .
spin dependent heisenberg near - neighbor interactions of the type used in @xmath62 models could also be used in the low - energy effective hamiltonian , but are neglected here for simplicity .
the conclusions we draw in this article do not depend on whether the near - neighbor effective interaction which drives d - wave superconductivity is spin - independent or spin - dependent .
the grpa correlation energy of a @xmath3-wave condensate state with pairing momentum @xmath11 is@xcite : @xmath63,\ ] ] where @xmath64 is a quasiparticle particle - hole exictation energy , and @xmath65 is the corresponding grpa excitation energy .
this equation can be derived by expanding the grpa hamiltonian to quadratic order in particle - hole excitation amplitudes approximated as independent bosons .
the correlation energy expression then drops out of a boson bogoliubov transformation .
the analysis in the preceeding qualitative discussion assummed that the @xmath11-dependence of @xmath14 is dominated by its collective mode contribution , an assumption that is largely justified by the following more microscopic calculation . in a grpa
theory excitation energies @xmath66 are obtained from a time - dependent mean - field - theory@xcite in which the quasiparticles respond to the external potential and to induced mean - field potentials : @xmath67 where @xmath68 , @xmath69\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle & + g(\vec{k},\vec{p},\vec{q})\left[\delta\langle c^\dagger_{\vec{p}+\vec{q}\sigma}\,c_{\vec{p}\sigma}\rangle c^\dagger_{\vec{k}-\vec{q}\sigma}\,c_{\vec{k}\sigma}\right]\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle & + h(\vec{k},\vec{p})\left[\delta\langle c^\dagger_{\vec{q}-\vec{p}\bar{\sigma}}\,c^\dagger_{\vec{p}\sigma}\rangle c_{\vec{k}\sigma}\,c_{\vec{q}-\vec{k}\bar{\sigma}}+h.c.\right ] , \\[2 mm ] \displaystyle h^{f2}(t)=\frac{1}{a}\sum_{\vec{p},\vec{k},\vec{q},\sigma}&i(\vec{k},\vec{p})\left[\delta\langle c^\dagger_{\vec{p}\sigma}c_{\vec{p}-\vec{q}\bar{\sigma}}\rangle c^\dagger_{\vec{k}-\vec{q}\bar{\sigma}}c_{\vec{k}\sigma}\right]\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle & + j(\vec{k},\vec{p})\left[\delta\langle c^\dagger_{\vec{q}-\vec{p}\sigma}c^\dagger_{\vec{p}\sigma}\rangle c_{\vec{k}\sigma}c_{\vec{q}-\vec{k}\sigma } + h.c.\right],\\[2 mm ] \end{array } \label{hflu}\ ] ] where @xmath70,\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle g(\vec{k},\vec{p},\vec{q})=2v[\cos(k_x - p_x - q_x)+\cos(k_y - p_y - q_y)\\[2 mm ] \,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,\,-\cos q_x-\cos q_y],\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle h(\vec{k},\vec{p})=u/2-v[\cos(k_x - p_x)+\cos(k_y - p_y)],\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle i(\vec{k},\vec{p})=[-u+2v(\cos(k_x - p_x)+\cos(k_y - p_y))],\\[2 mm ] \displaystyle j(\vec{k},\vec{p})=-v[\cos(k_x - p_x)+\cos(k_y - p_y ) ] , \end{array}\ ] ] and @xmath71 . because the d - wave bcs ground state is a spin - singlet , its elementary excitations consist of @xmath72 triplet and @xmath73 singlet branches .
@xmath74 captures the @xmath75 portions of the triplet fluctuations , studied by demler and zhang in a different context@xcite .
@xmath76 captures singlet and triplet @xmath77 fluctuations .
applying linear response theory to the quasiparticle hamiltonian @xmath78 , we can compute the change in element of density matrix @xmath79 by : @xmath80 \rangle_{h_{mf } } , \label{lrt}\ ] ] , leading to an equation of the form : @xmath81 where @xmath82 is a column representing the change in the quasiparticle density matrix .
the collective mode energies @xmath83 are the eigenvalues@xcite of the matrix @xmath84 which can be read off eq .
( [ lrt ] ) . for a given pairing momentum @xmath11 and excitation momentum @xmath85 ,
the number of particle hole pairs is proportional to the number of momenta in the brillouin - zone , which we limit by using periodic boundary conditions with a finite quantization area @xmath86 .
diagonalizing @xmath84 is equivalent to performing the boson bogoliubov transformation , and equivalent to summing the ladder and bubble diagrams used to represent the grpa in diagramatic perturbation theory .
typical grpa extended hubbard model results for the spin and pair response functions of the @xmath87 state at wavevector @xmath88 exhibit a single collective mode below the particle - hole continuum with large weight in both responses . in fig .
[ [ fig : two]],we illustrate the dependence on @xmath56 of the energy of this excitation , and of its weight in spin - density and triplet - pair response functions , with @xmath57 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 ( and hence the d - wave mean - field state ) held fixed . as @xmath56 increases , promoting antiferromagnetism , the collective mode excitation energy decreases , its weight in the spin response function increases , and its weight in the pair - excitation spectrum decreases .
these properties are consistent with our qualitative effective theory , given the expectation that @xmath89 should decrease with @xmath56 .
the opposing variations of triplet - pair and spin - density weights demonstrates that the berry phase mechanism dominates coupling between antiferromagnetic and pairing phase fluctuations as expected .
resonance mode energy and weights in spin and pair response functions _ vs. _
@xmath56 for @xmath88 and doping @xmath37 .
these results were obtained for @xmath87 and calculated with @xmath90 and @xmath91 and @xmath92 @xmath30 points in the bz . for each value of @xmath56
the vertical ( horizontal ) bar represents the collective mode weight in the spin ( pair ) response function .
the weights were evaluated using the same response function defintions as tchernyshyov _ et .
al._@xcite . ]
our qualitative discussion suggested that there should be a strong negative correlation contribution to @xmath0 because the insr near @xmath88 softens with increasing @xmath93 .
because we perform our calculations with periodic boundary conditions , we estimate the mean - field ( @xmath94 ) and correlation ( @xmath95 ) contributions to @xmath0 by comparing energies at @xmath87 and @xmath96 ; @xmath97/2\pi^2 $ ] .
[ [ fig : three ] ] illustrates the fluctuation - wavevector dependence of correlation contributions to @xmath0 .
as expected we find that@xcite modes near @xmath88 soften , making a negative contribution to @xmath0 .
this dependence of collective mode energies on the pair - momentum of the superconducting condensate is unusual and is indicative of the microscopic competition between antiferromagnetism and d - wave superconductivity .
this result contrasts strongly with the absence of any significant dependence of plasmonic collective modes on pair condensate properties in conventional superconductors . as indicated in fig .
[ [ fig : three ] ] we also find that for the model parameters chosen , collective modes at momenta near @xmath98 have complex energies for both values of @xmath11 .
this finding reflects the tendency of extended hubbard models , and of real cuprate materials , to longer period density - wave instabilities@xcite .
we do not believe that these ubiquitous instabilities , which appear to be material specific , should not play an essential role in underdoped - cuprate superfluid density suppression since long - wavelength density - wave order will have little impact on near - neighbour antiferromagnetic fluctuations .
( color online ) correlation contribution to @xmath0 from fluctuations with wavevector @xmath30 ( @xmath99 for the same model parameters as in fig .
[ [ fig : one ] ] .
@xmath100 is normalized so that its brillouin - zone average is @xmath101 , which has the value @xmath102 for these parameters .
the grpa excitation energies in the black area near @xmath103 are imaginary reflecting longer length scale instabilities@xcite of the extended hubbard model we use .
these long - wavelength instabilities are sensitive to model details and independent of the @xmath95 contributions from near @xmath104 . ]
we find that @xmath101 is negative and of order @xmath105 in the underdoped regime when extended hubbard model parameters are in the range thought to represent underdoped cuprates .
we conclude that a substantial suppression of the superfluid density due to the pairing wavevector dependence of the correlation energy occurs in underdoped cuprates and that it is responsible for the downturn in the critical temperature .
our weak - coupling theory is unable to describe physics very near the termination of superconductivity on the underdoped side , although there is some indirect evidence from experiment@xcite ( for example from the relatively weak temperature dependence of @xmath0 ) that critical fluctuations are important in a relatively narrow doping range .
our explanation for reduced superfluid density in underdoped cuprates is independent of the microscopic origin of the effective near - neighbor interaction responsible for @xmath57 and hence for d - wave superconductivity .
this work was supported by the welch foundation , the national science foundation under grants dmr-0606489 and dmr-0547875 , and a university of waterloo start - up grant .
the authors acknowledge helpful interactions with dan arovas , andrey chubukov , eugene demler , bernhard keimer , patrick a. lee , m.r .
norman , and oleg tchernyshyov .
y. j. uemura , g. m. luke , b. j. sternlieb , j. h. brewer , j. f. carolan , w. n. hardy , r. kadono , j. r. kempton , r. f. kiefl , s. r. kreitzman , p. mulhern , t. m. riseman , d. ll .
williams , b. x. yang , s. uchida , h. takagi , j. gopalakrishnan , a. w. sleight , m. a. subramanian , c. l. chien , m. z. cieplak , gang xiao , v. y. lee , b. w. statt , c. e. stronach , w. j. kossler , and x. h. yu , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 2317 ( 1989 ) .
r. liang , d.a .
bonn , w.n .
hardy and d. broun , phys . rev . lett . * 94 * , 117001 ( 2005 ) ; d.m .
broun , w.a .
huttema , p.j .
turner , s. ozcan , b. morgan , ruixing liang , w.n .
hardy , and d.a .
bonn , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 237003 ( 2007 ) . in a crystalline superconductor
the cooper - pair momentum @xmath11 is a good quantum number .
a state with pairing momentum @xmath11 has a uniform condensate phase gradient @xmath106 , hence the total energy can be expressed as @xmath107 from ref.@xcite .
fong , b. keimer , d. reznik , d.l .
milius , and i.a .
aksay , phys .
b * 54 * , 6708 ( 1996 ) ; h. f. fong , p. bourges , y. sidis , l. p. regnault , a. ivanov , g. d. gu , n. koshizuka , and b. keimer , nature * 398 * , 588 ( 1999 ) ; h.f .
fong , p. bourges , y. sidis , l.p .
regnault , j. bossy , a. ivanov , d.l .
milius , i.a .
aksay , and b. keimer , phys .
b * 61 * , 14773 ( 2000 ) ; p. bourges , y. sidis , h. f. fong , l. p. regnault , j. bossy , a. ivanov , and b. keimer , science * 288 * , 1234 ( 2000 ) . ar
abanov and a.v .
chubukov , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 1652 ( 1999 ) ; j. brinkmann and p.a .
lee , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 2915 ( 1999 ) ; m.r .
norman , phys .
b * 61 * , 14751 ( 2000 ) ; f. onufrieva and p. pfeuty , phys .
b * 65 * , 054515 ( 2002 ) ; j. brinckmann and p.a .
lee , phys .
b * 65 * , 014502 ( 2002 )
. b. lake , g. aeppli , k. n. clausen , d. f. mcmorrow , k. lefmann , n. e. hussey , n. mangkorntong , m. nohara , h. takagi , t. e. mason , and a. schroder , science * 291 * , 1759 ( 2001 ) ; e. demler , s. sachdev , and ying zhang , phys .
. lett . * 87 * , 067202 ( 2001 ) ; nicolas doiron - leyraud , cyril proust , david leboeuf , julien levallois , jean - baptiste bonnemaison , ruixing liang , d. a. bonn , w. n. hardy , and louis taillefer , nature * 447 * , 565 ( 2007 ) ; wei - qiang chen , kai - yu yang , t. m. rice , and f. c. zhang , preprint ( arxiv:0706.3556 ) ( 2007 ) .
our calculations demonstrate that @xmath108 , @xmath41 , and @xmath40 are all weakly frequency dependent and that @xmath41 decreases because of the reduction in superconducting - state particle - hole excitation energies at finite @xmath11 .
wei - cheng lee and a.h .
macdonald , unpublished . | the critical temperature of an underdoped cuprate superconductor is limited by its phase stiffness @xmath0 . in this article
we argue that the dependence of @xmath0 on doping @xmath1 should be understood as a consequence of deleterious competition with antiferromagnetism at large electron densities , rather than as evidence for pairing of holes in the @xmath2 mott insulator state .
@xmath0 is suppressed at small @xmath1 because the correlation energy of a @xmath3-wave superconductor has a significant pairing - wavevector dependence when antiferromagnetic fluctuations are strong . |
electronic transport can usually be described in terms of effectively independent electrons . recently , with the discovery and exploitation of spin - transfer torque@xcite ( stt ) effects , magnetism has joined superconductivity as an instance in which collective and quasiparticle contributions to transport are entwined in an essential way .
the similarity between the non - equilibrium properties of magnetic and superconducting@xcite systems is especially close when comparing the properties of a superconducting circuit containing a josephson junction to a magnetic circuit containing a free ferromagnetic layer with strong easy - plane anisotropy . as we explain in more detail below , the role of the josephson junction bias current in the superconducting circuit
is played in the magnetic case by the component of the spin - current injected into the nanoparticle that is perpendicular to the easy plane .
the electrical properties of a circuit containing a josephson junction typically change drastically when the junction s critical current is exceeded . in this paper
we propose that the magnetic circuit illustrated in fig .
[ fig : one ] , which we refer to as a magnetic josephson junction ( mjj ) , can exhibit similar drastic effects when a critical current related to the free magnet s in - plane anisotropy is exceeded .
we show that the resistance of an mjj can increase substantially when its critical current is exceeded provided that either source or drain currents are strongly spin polarized and magnetization relaxation in the free magnet layer is not too rapid .
the analogy we explore is closely related to the early suggestion by berger@xcite that 180@xmath0 domain walls in ferromagnets should exhibit behavior analogous to the behavior of josephson junctions . indeed the mjj geometry we propose may be viewed as a discrete version of a pinned 180@xmath0 domain wall . although the magnetization dynamics induced _
emf _ that berger predicted based on an analogy to the _ ac _ josephson relation has now@xcite been confirmed experimentally , electrical signals of magnetization texture dynamics in uniform bulk materials tend to be weak .
the mjj geometry we study is also closely related to that employed in spin - transfer torque oscillators .
@xcite it is well known that the dc resistance of an stt - oscillator tends to increase once the magnetization becomes dynamic .
@xcite the increase in bias voltage at fixed current is closely related to berger s josephson voltage . from this point of view , the issue we explore theoretically in this paper is the possibility of achieving large relative changes of resistance in an stt - oscillator when the magnetization becomes dynamic .
we believe that such an examination is motivated by recent advances in ferromagnetic metal spintronics @xcite which have enabled the injection of more highly spin polarized currents and decreased the thickness of free magnetic layers , making them easier to manipulate electrically .
mjj devices not only provide a test bed for our understanding of the fundamental physics of spin gauge fields , but could also be useful because of their unusual transport properties .
our paper is organized as following . in sec .
ii , we comment at greater length on the relationship between josephson junctions and easy - plane free magnets . in sec .
iii , we discuss the theoretical framework we used for analyzing the transport properties of an mjj . in sec .
iv and sec .
v , we identify two regimes in which the mjj could have quite different resistances . finally , in sec .
vi , we summarize our results and discuss our conclusions .
as shown in fig . [ fig : one ] , the mjj is a multilayer heterostructure consisting of ferromagnetic and non - magnetic normal metal layers .
the two ferromagnetic electrodes have opposite magnetization directions , serving as spin polarized current source and drain .
the free magnetic layer in the middle is sandwiched between two non - magnetic normal metal spacer layers to avoid direct magnetic coupling with the electrodes .
we assume that the free magnetic layer is small enough that its magnetization is spatially constant .
its magnetization direction dynamics is then described by a landau - liftshitz - gilbert ( llg ) equation , @xmath1 where @xmath2 is a unit vector along the magnetization direction of the free layer , @xmath3 is ( minus ) the gyromagnetic ratio , @xmath4 is an effective magnetic field , @xmath5 is the dimensionless gilbert damping constant and the right hand size of the equation above denotes a slonczewski@xcite spin - transfer torque term@xcite that captures the coupling between transport and collective dynamics : @xmath6 here @xmath7 is the magnitude of the total spin of the free magnetic layer , @xmath8 is the free layer volume , @xmath9 is its magnetization per unit volume , @xmath10 is the net spin current flowing out of the free layer and @xmath11 selects the component of @xmath10 that is transverse to @xmath2 .
we assume that there is no applied magnetic field . the effective magnetic field
, @xmath12 then arises mainly from the magnetostatic energy of a thin film with an elliptical cross - section : @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the magnetization orientation azimuthal angle and the anisotropy parameter @xmath15 so that the magnetization direction is always close to its easy plane .
when the magnetization direction is expressed in terms of @xmath16 and @xmath14 , and @xmath16 is assumed to be small , the llg equations take the form @xmath17 @xmath18 as discussed later we will be most interested in circumstances under which @xmath19 and @xmath20 , the component of spin - current in the azimuthal direction , vanishes . in that limit
the right hand side of the equation for @xmath21 reduces to the difference between the chemical potential of majority and minority spin electrons .
( [ mzdot ] ) is then precisely equivalent to the resistively and capacitively shunted josephson junction model@xcite with easy - plane anisotropy playing the role of the capacitance , @xmath22 in - plane anisotropy playing the role of the superconducting coupling which supports a supercurrent @xmath23 @xmath24 playing the role of a dissipative quasiparticle current , and the spin - transfer torque term playing the role of junction bias current .
it is well known that the electrical properties of a josephson junction changes drastically at its critical current . due to the connections revealed above
, we expect that similar behavior can occur in an mjj .
because the mjj bias current is a spin - current not a charge current , and its dissipationless supercurrent transports spins from up to down states not charges from one side of the junction to the other , the current - voltage relationship of a circuit in which an mjj is embedded is more subtle than in the superconducting josephson junction case , and collective effects are generally weaker . in the following ,
we analyze mjj i - v relationships with the aim of identifying circumstances under which the resistance change at the critical current can be large in circuits that are fabricated with modern spintronic materials .
for small bias voltages the nanoparticle magnetization can achieve a static value by balancing the circuit bias and collective transport terms : @xmath25 .
once @xmath26 reaches its maximum value , @xmath27 , the magnetization s azimuthal angle becomes time - dependent and the time average of @xmath26 quickly becomes negligible . in this dynamic limit @xmath28
must be balanced against the dissipative term @xmath29 .
our main goal in this section is to shed light on the requirements for a substantial relative change in circuit resistance when the mjj s critical current is exceeded . for this purpose
we use magnetoelectronic circuit theory,@xcite which simplifies the transport problem in ferromagnet / normal metal heterostructures by dropping some non - local effects and separating the circuit into normal metal and magnetic constituents within which the exchange field is taken to be constant in direction . in the following ,
we assume that the ferromagnetic layer is thicker than the magnetic coherence length @xcite which is on the order of @xmath30 in transition metals .
magnetoelectronic circuit theory s key equation relates the charge and spin currents that flow from a ferromagnet into a normal metal to the ferromagnet s chemical potential and to the chemical potential of the normal metal , including its non - equilibrium spin - accumulation contributions .
the charge current @xmath31.\ ] ] here @xmath32 and @xmath33 refer to majority and minority spins , @xmath34 is the ferromagnet s magnetization direction , @xmath35 is a dimensionless spin - dependent conductance , @xmath36 is the normal metal chemical potential averaged over spin states while @xmath37 represents the magnitude and direction in spin - space of the spin - dependent part of the normal metal s chemical potential . for static magnetization
the analogous spin - current expression@xcite is @xmath38.\ ] ] eqs .
( [ icharge ] , [ ispin ] ) apply to the four ferromagnet / normal metal interfaces in a mjj .
we assume that the normal metal nodes have sizes smaller than the spin flip diffusion length , allowing its spin flip scattering to be neglected . setting the total charge and spin - currents into each of the two normal metal nodes to zero yields eight equations for the eight unknown parameters which specify the spin - dependent chemical potentials of the two normal metal nodes . in the following two sections
, we shall calculate the resistance for both the static regime and the dynamic regime from this set of equations .
to apply magnetoelectric circuit theory to an mjj with a time - independent free magnet , we note that @xmath39 for source and drain electrodes respectively , set the source and drain chemical potentials to @xmath40 and assume that source and drain ferromagnetic electrodes are identical .
it follows from symmetry that spin - accumulation in the direction perpendicular to @xmath2 and @xmath41 vanishes in both normal metal nodes , reducing the number of free variables to six .
we separate the normal metal chemical potentials into accumulation ( @xmath42 ) and transport ( @xmath43 ) contributions defined by @xmath44 where @xmath45 for charge , free magnet , and source spin directions , and @xmath46 @xmath47 denotes the @xmath48-th normal metal node .
simple equations for @xmath49 can be obtained by adding and subtracting the charge and spin conservation conditions for the two nodes . in this way
it is easy to verify that for the static case @xmath50 , properties that also can be established by symmetry considerations .
the three remaining equations determine the chemical potential differences that drive charge and spin across the free magnetic layer , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and the accumulation of spin injected by the source and drain electrodes @xmath53 : @xmath54 where we have introduced the shorthand notations @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 for the interfaces between normal metal and source and drain electrodes .
the corresponding upper case @xmath58 s and @xmath59 refer to interfaces between the normal metals and the free magnetic layer .
the charge current is most conveniently evaluated at either source or drain electrode with the result that @xmath60 .
although the static mjj resistance @xmath61 depends on the detailed values of the various interface conductance parameters , it tends to be close to the sum of the individual interface resistances and is not especially sensitive to source or drain electrode spin - polarization ; in the limit in which all ferromagnets are fully polarized and identical , for example , the static mjj resistance is @xmath62 .
this result applies until the perpendicular spin current @xmath63 reaches its critical value @xmath64 .
the corresponding critical charge current flowing through the mjj is proportional to @xmath65 . for typical values
@xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68j ( per m@xmath69 ) and assuming that @xmath70 , the citical charge current density is on the order of @xmath71a / nm@xmath72 for a free layer with a thickness around @xmath73 nm .
when @xmath74 is substantially larger than @xmath64 a dynamic steady state is approached in which @xmath75 this precession of magnetization induced by spin current is the working principle of stt - oscillators .
because of their long spin relaxation times , the normal metal nodes do not follow this precession so that the components of the spin - dependent part of the chemical potentials vanish along directions other than @xmath41 .
this leaves four unknown chemical potentials and @xmath21 to be determined by eq .
( [ 18 ] ) and the four circuit equations for conservation of @xmath76 and @xmath77 at each node . in the dynamic case
the total spin - current @xmath78 flowing out of the free magnet includes a spin - pumping contribution : @xcite @xmath79 the induced pumping current tends to counter the bias current , effectively increasing the resistance .
following the same strategy as in the static case we find that @xmath80 while the remaining unknowns satisfy @xmath81 the third of these equations relates the spin - current out of the free nanoparticle to the spin decay rate .
the electrical properties of a mjj are most interesting when the dimensionless coupling constant formed by comparing the right and left hand sides of eq .
( [ dynamic ] ) , @xmath82 is small . taking typical values@xcite of @xmath83 ( per nm@xmath84 ) , @xmath67 and of @xmath85 yields @xmath86 $ ] , where @xmath87 is the film thickness , suggesting that small values are possible in thin magnetic films made from materials like permalloy that have small values of @xmath5 . solving eqs .
( [ dynamic ] ) for @xmath88 we find that the dynamic mjj resistance @xmath89 which diverges for @xmath90 .
when source and drain electrodes are strongly spin - polarized and @xmath91 is small , the mjj circuit should suffer a large increase in resistance at its critical current .
this drastic resistance change can be qualitatively explained as follows . in the static regime ,
the free layer magnetized in the @xmath92-plane breaks spin rotation symmetry along @xmath93-axis .
exchange - field driven spin flips then provides a path for electrical conduction between oppositely polarized electrodes . in the dynamic regime ,
precession of the free layer restores spin rotation symmetry and the @xmath93-component of the conduction electron spin is approximately conserved , increasing the electrical flow resistance . in fig .
[ fig : two ] , we plot the ratio @xmath94 , which characterizes the performance of a mjj , as a function of the damping parameter @xmath5 and the polarization @xmath95 .
@xmath96 increases as @xmath5 decreases or @xmath95 increases , and diverges in the limit @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
the influence of magnetization dynamics on electronic transport can be described by accounting for spin pumping , as in the analysis summarized above , or equivalently by accounting for a dynamics induced _
emf_. for a slowly varying magnetic texture like a domain wall in transition metal ferromagnets , a transport electron follows the local magnetization direction adiabatically .
the induced _
is@xcite then given by @xmath99 with @xmath21 being the domain wall precession frequency and @xmath95 the bulk transport current spin - polarization . for the mjj considered here ,
spin transport is no longer adiabatic . in order to relate the two perspectives we assume that the influence of precession in the mjj can also be captured by imposing an extra _ emf
_ @xmath100 that accounts for the difference between static and dynamic circuit resistances : @xmath101 the effective value of @xmath102 then depends on microscopic mjj parameters and can be evaluated by comparing eq . ( [ beta ] ) with the results of a magnetoelectronic circuit analysis
. some typical values of @xmath102 are plotted in fig .
[ fig : three ] as a function of @xmath95 ( @xmath103 ) for different values of @xmath5 . for the completely adiabatic case
, we should expect @xmath104 which is a straight line in the figure .
although the @xmath102 of a mjj generally deviates from this straight line due to nonadiabatic effects , it approaches the straight line in the @xmath105 and @xmath98 limits . for @xmath106 ,
the same result can be obtained by making a unitary transformation into the rotating frame of @xmath2 and the result amounts to a relative shift @xmath107 between the chemical potentials of the two electrodes .
we find that the magnetization dynamics damping , parameterized by @xmath5 , slightly decreases the value of @xmath102 because the dissipation of energy through damping can be regarded as an extra resistance in the circuit . from the analysis above , the current drops once bias voltage @xmath108 increases above a critical value determined by the in - plane anisotropy , i.e. when the precession of magnetization begins .
this signals a negative resistance region of the i - v curve similar to that for the gunn diode .
@xcite for mjj with high performance ( @xmath109 ) , it could be used as a good fuse link , for example , to control the maximum current that can flow through a circuit . to summarize
, we propose a ferromagnet / normal metal heterostructure which has properties analogous to those of a josephson junction .
we analyze its i - v characteristics and identify a static regime in which the magnetization configuration is static with a low resistance and a dynamic regime in which the magnetization precesses and the resistance is high .
our analysis indicates that mjj circuits which exhibit large and sudden relative change in resistance can be fabricated using modern spintronic materials with perpendicular anisotropy@xcite and strongly polarized spin currents@xcite .
besides having an academic interest , because of the insight that it provides in comparing current - induced emf and spin - pumping notions in metal spintronics , the mjj may be useful for applications .
the authors thank tomas jungwirth , jairo sinova and maxim tsoi for helpful discussions .
this work was supported by nsf ( dmr0906025 ) , the welch foundation grant f1473 , doe ( de - fg02 - 02er45958 , division of materials science and engineering ) and texas advanced research program .
parkin , c. kaiser , a. panchula , p.m. rice , b. hughes , m. samant , and s. h. yang , nature mater . * 3 * , 862 ( 2004 ) ;
s. yuasa , t. nagahama , a. fukushima , y. suzuki , and k. ando , nature mater . * 3 * , 868 ( 2004 ) .
besides slonczewski spin - transfer term , which captures the overall conservation of angular momentum , there can be other contributions to the coupling between transport currents and magnetization dynamics . | we analyze the electrical characteristics of a circuit consisting of a free thin - film magnetic layer and source and drain electrodes that have opposite magnetization orientations along the free magnet s two hard directions .
we find that when the circuit s current exceeds a critical value there is a sudden resistance increase which can be large in relative terms if the currents to source or drain are strongly spin polarized and the free magnet is thin .
this behavior can be partly understood in terms of a close analogy between the magnetic circuit and a josephson junction . |
the local density of states at the boundary of a superconductor is a crucial factor in many experiments , for example tunneling measurements . for conventional @xmath1-wave superconductors ,
the local density of states at an insulating boundary is practically the same as in the bulk . in particular ,
the specific boundary geometry is irrelevant . in the case of @xmath0-wave symmetry , however , the situation is completely different . due to andreev bound states @xcite , a drastic enhancement of the low - energy density of states can be observed at a straight flat surface appearing as a pronounced zero - bias conductance peak @xcite .
this effect is maximal if the @xmath0-wave nodal direction is perpendicular to the boundary and shrinks when the orientation is changed @xcite . for an angle of 45 degrees between nodal direction and boundary , the andreev bound states disappear completely . besides this well - known effect , it is important to realize that for @xmath0-wave symmetry also the boundary geometry itself can have strong influence on the local density of states . in this work
we examine the local density of states at the surface of a @xmath0-wave superconductor for some basic examples of polygonal boundary geometries and show that andreev bound states are sensitive to the boundary geometry .
we also consider the additional influence of a single abrikosov vortex pinned near the boundary . in a previous work we have shown , that the presence of an abrikosov vortex in the vicinity of the boundary of a @xmath0-wave superconductor has a drastic effect on the zero - energy andreev bound states .
this effect appears as a surprisingly large shadow - like suppression of the zero - energy density of states between vortex and boundary @xcite .
the suppression is due to the supercurrent flowing around the vortex , which locally shifts the quasiparticle energies and leads to a splitting of the zero - energy peak .
a similar splitting has already been studied for a homogeneous surface current@xcite .
one of the purposes of the present study is to show that this vortex shadow effect is stable and robust even if the boundary of the superconductor possesses some roughness or faceting .
the paper is divided into five sections . in the next section ,
we give a short introduction to the theoretical framework used for the calculations . in the third section
, we present some zero - energy local densities of states for simple wedge - shaped boundary geometries and discuss some elementary effects .
after that , we turn to the aspect of boundary roughness in section four , where we consider more complicated polygonal boundary structures .
finally , we end with our conclusions in section five .
in the limit @xmath2 , the equilibrium properties of a superconductor are contained in the eilenberger propagator @xmath3 .
the propagator itself can be calculated by solving a transport - like equation first introduced by eilenberger @xcite and independently by larkin and ovchinnikov @xcite . here
, we will use the so - called riccati parametrization of the eilenberger theory , which was introduced in ref . and
has proven to be very useful for the numerical computation of the propagator ( for more details see ref . ) . in order to obtain a solution for a given fermi vector @xmath4 at the point @xmath5 , the coupled eilenberger equations are parametrized along a trajectory passing through @xmath5 in direction of the fermi velocity corresponding to @xmath4 @xmath6 along this trajectory , the eilenberger equations can be transformed to two decoupled differential equations of the riccati type for the scalar functions @xmath7 and @xmath8:@xcite @xmath9
a(x ) - \delta(x ) & = & 0 \nonumber \\ \hbar v_f \partial_x b(x ) - \left [ 2 \epsilon_n + \delta(x ) b(x ) \right ] b(x ) + \delta(x)^ * & = & 0 \label{riccati}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we have already removed the vector potential @xmath10 via a gauge transformation . this can be done for the case of a single pinned abrikosov vortex in a high-@xmath11 superconductor , since we concentrate on lengthscales smaller than the penetration depth @xmath12 .
together with the starting values in the bulk @xmath13 the functions @xmath14 and @xmath15 can be integrated in an easy and numerically stable way along the trajectory .
the eilenberger propagator @xmath16 is related to the functions @xmath14 and @xmath15 by @xmath17 assuming a cylindrical fermi surface , @xmath4 depends only on an polar angle @xmath18 @xmath19 and the local density of states , normalized to the normal state density of states at the fermi level @xmath20 , is given by @xmath21_{i \epsilon_n \rightarrow e + i \delta}\ ] ] practically , this means that the integrand has to be evaluated for many angles @xmath18 , each angle corresponding to one particular trajectory through @xmath5 .
the energy @xmath22 is taken with respect to the fermi level and @xmath23 can be regarded as an effective scattering parameter which is proportional to an inverse mean free path . in the calculations presented below , the specific boundary geometry of the superconductor has to be taken into account .
since we assume that the transmission coefficient of all the boundaries is zero , the boundary conditions@xcite simplify considerably . in our case , a trajectory which hits the boundary
is simply reflected like a ray of light .
thus , for the calculations in this work , a ray tracing procedure has been used , which allows for multiple specular reflections .
the riccati equations ( [ riccati ] ) then have to be solved on such a multiply reflected trajectory ( see for example the trajectories in fig . [ alpgamn]b ) ) .
we consider gap functions @xmath24 that can be separated into @xmath25 here , the symmetry function for the @xmath26-wave is @xmath27 . in the following we want to concentrate on the part @xmath28 of the gap function , which covers the spatial dependence .
it can be factorized into modulus and phase @xmath29 where we call the modulus @xmath30 the profile function . in principle , both the profile function and the phase @xmath31 should be calculated selfconsistently via the gap equation .
for simplicity , we have taken the profile function to be constant .
this is a good approximation for low temperatures due to the kramer - pesch effect @xcite . even for higher temperatures ,
the changes in the quasiparticle spectra due to this simplification are rather of a quantitative than a qualitative nature .
compared to the constant model profile function , the relevant differences of a more realistic profile function most often reside in comparatively small intervals along the trajectories .
for the situation studied in the following , this occurs near the boundaries or close to the vortex center . in these regions , the local density of states
is somewhat smeared out or softened , if a more realistic profile function is used .
however , the main features to be presented below remain unaffected , as we have checked for specific situations . in the absence of a vortex
, the phase @xmath31 of the gap function simply is zero . for the case of a pinned abrikosov vortex in the system considered here , as an excellent approximation ,
the gradient of the phase is parallel to the current @xmath32 @xmath33 and @xmath31 is given as a solution of the laplace equation @xmath34 with a `` phase source '' of @xmath35 at the vortex position .
in other words , integrating the phase gradient along any closed path around the vortex position must add up to a total of @xmath35 .
additionally , @xmath31 has to fulfill von - neumann boundary conditions @xmath36 since currents are not allowed to cross any of the boundaries .
here , @xmath37 denotes the normal vector of the boundary under consideration . to solve the laplace equation in two dimensions , we use the method of conformal mapping .
this analytical technique can be found in many mathematical textbooks , and in some specific physical textbooks as well .
nevertheless , in the following we give the main aspects of conformal mapping in short .
first , the original two - dimensional domain , where the solution of the laplace equation is sought , is regarded as a part of the complex plane .
this domain is also referred to as physical domain , and it often includes a nontrivial boundary geometry with specific boundary conditions . the main idea and task is to map this physical domain to a simple `` model '' domain by using analytic functions . because of the latter , the laplace equation itself stays invariant under this mapping .
thus , if the solution of laplace s equation with the correct boundary conditions is known in the model domain , also the original problem is solved .
the solution in the physical domain can then be achieved by simply mapping each point to the model domain with the mapping function and taking the corresponding value of the solution there . in our case of a wedge - shaped physical domain
, the upper complex half space serves as the model plane and @xmath38 shall denote elements thereof .
then , the function @xmath39 , which is given by the formula @xmath40 is the analytical solution of laplace s equation @xmath41 in all points @xmath42 of the upper half plane with @xmath43 . integrating the phase gradient around the singularity at @xmath44 results in a total phase difference of @xmath35
. thus , @xmath45 can be regarded as the position of the phase vortex .
also , von - neumann boundary conditions are satisfied , since the phase gradient is parallel to the boundary ( the real axis ) .
of course , formula ( [ mirrormodel ] ) is analogous to the well - known mirror image ansatz in electrostatics , the first factor referring to a vortex at position @xmath46 , the second to a virtual antivortex at the mirrored position @xmath47 . -wave
superconductor with wedge - shaped boundary geometry .
@xmath48 denotes the opening angle of the wedge . the orientation between @xmath0-wave and wedge is parametrized by the angle @xmath49 , which gives the rotation of the full - gap direction with respect to the bisecting line of the wedge . the origin @xmath50 represents the corner of the wedge .
[ geometry ] ] since the correct solution of the problem in the model domain is given by ( [ mirrormodel ] ) , the next and also last step is to find an analytical function which maps the physical domain to the upper half plane .
it is well - known that the complex power function is analytic and that @xmath51 maps the upper half plane to a wedge with opening angle @xmath48 . in particular , the positive real axis is mapped onto itself .
thus , for the physical domain being a wedge with opening angle @xmath48 measured from the positive real axis , the sought mapping function is just the inversion @xmath52 however , this mapping function is only valid for @xmath53 . for opening angles @xmath54 one has to be careful about the branch cut discontinuity at the negative real axis .
a possible mapping is then given by @xmath55^\frac{\pi}{\alpha } \label{wmap2}\ ] ] finally , combining the solution ( [ mirrormodel ] ) in the model plane with the above mapping functions @xmath56 , the phase factor of the gap function for a wedge - shaped boundary is given by @xmath57 on the right hand side , @xmath58 is the position vector @xmath59 in complex notation .
analogous , the position of the vortex can be chosen with the parameter @xmath60 .
the opening angle @xmath48 of the wedge enters via the mapping functions ( [ wmap1 ] ) or ( [ wmap2 ] ) , respectively . in principle , the phase factor of more than one vortex is simply the product of several one - vortex solutions ( [ phasefactor ] ) .
however , in the following we will confine ourselves to the case of only one single vortex .
in this section , we investigate the zero - energy local density of states of @xmath26-wave superconductors with wedge - shaped boundary geometries .
the situation is sketched in fig .
[ geometry ] .
@xmath48 denotes the opening angle of the wedge , @xmath49 the angle between the bisecting line of the wedge and the direction of the maximum gap .
some examples for wedges with opening angles @xmath61 and @xmath62 can be seen in figs .
[ keil90 ] and [ keil45 ] . far away from the corner ,
the zero - energy density of states at the boundaries exhibit the well - known andreev bound states .
if the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave is perpendicular to the specific boundary line , a maximum value is reached ( e.g. fig .
[ keil90]c ) , both boundaries , or [ keil45]a ) , upper boundary ) . for other orientations , the andreev bound states are smaller ( fig .
[ keil90]b ) and [ keil45]b ) ) , or they even vanish if the direction of the maximum gap is perpendicular to the boundary ( e.g. fig .
[ keil90]a ) or [ keil45]a ) , lower boundary ) .
in all the calculations presented here and in the following sections , the effective scattering parameter is set to @xmath63 .
this leads to a nonzero value of the zero - energy density of states in the bulk and limits the absolute value of the andreev bound states at the boundaries .
-wave superconductor for a wedge - shaped boundary with opening angle @xmath61 .
the density of states is normalized to the density @xmath20 of the normal state .
the effective scattering parameter is chosen to be @xmath64 .
the rotation of the @xmath0-wave with respect to the bisecting line is a ) @xmath65 , b ) @xmath66 , c ) @xmath67 .
[ keil90 ] ] it is important to realize , however , that in a range from the corner , which is given by the lengthscale @xmath68 , the boundary geometry itself strongly influences the local density of states .
a very counterintuitive example can be seen in fig .
[ keil90]c ) .
although the zero - energy local density of states reaches its maximum height along both boundary lines , the corner of the right - angled wedge itself only exhibits the bulk value of @xmath69 . for the smaller opening angle @xmath62 , the local density of states in the tip of the wedge can even be lower than in the bulk : in fig .
[ keil45]b ) , where @xmath67 , which refers to a maximum gap direction parallel to the bisecting line , the value is @xmath70 .
this is barely larger than the bulk value corresponding to an @xmath1-wave superconductor . by just taking a look at figs .
[ keil90 ] and [ keil45 ] one might get the impression , that the zero - energy density of states in the corner is always suppressed independently of the rotation angle @xmath49 of the @xmath0-wave .
however , this is not true in general . in fig .
[ keil60 ] we examine a wedge with opening angle @xmath71 .
we can clearly see that for the the nodal direction being parallel to the bisecting line ( @xmath72 ) , there is a strong increase of the zero - energy local density of states in the corner .
-wave superconductor for a wedge - shaped boundary with opening angle @xmath62 .
the density of states is normalized to the density @xmath20 of the normal state .
the effective scattering parameter is chosen to be @xmath64 .
the rotation of the @xmath0-wave with respect to the bisecting line is a ) @xmath66 , b ) @xmath67 , c ) @xmath73 .
[ keil45 ] ] in the following , we want to concentrate on the corner point @xmath50 and systematically examine , why the local density of states seems to behave so strange .
-wave superconductor for a wedge - shaped boundary with opening angle @xmath71 .
the density of states is normalized to the density @xmath20 of the normal state .
the effective scattering parameter is chosen to be @xmath64 .
the rotation of the @xmath0-wave with respect to the bisecting line is a ) @xmath67 , b ) @xmath73 , c ) @xmath72 .
[ keil60 ] ] in fig .
[ alpgamn]a ) , the zero - energy local density of states in the corner is shown .
the opening angle @xmath48 of the wedge - shaped boundary geometry corresponds to the vertical axis .
the rotation angle @xmath49 of the @xmath0-wave is varied from @xmath74 to @xmath75 along the horizontal axis .
the absolute maximum value is right in the center of the figure . here ,
@xmath76 and @xmath72 correspond to the well - known maximum andreev bound states at a straight boundary line .
the most interesting part of the picture can be seen at smaller opening angles @xmath53 . if the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave is kept fixed parallel to the bisecting line of the wedge ( i.e. @xmath72 ) and the opening angle @xmath48 is reduced , then the zero - energy local density of states clearly oscillates between high maxima and minima .
a cut along this line showing the oscillations in the range @xmath77 is shown in fig .
[ oszi ] . clearly , the minima of the oscillating zero - energy local density of states in the corner appear for opening angles @xmath78 , while the maxima are very close to the angles @xmath79 . of a @xmath26-wave superconductor with wedge - shaped boundary geometry .
@xmath48 denotes the opening angle of the wedge , @xmath49 the rotation of the maximum gap direction with respect to the bisecting line of the wedge .
the global maximum in the middle of the picture corresponds to the well - known maximum of the andreev bound states at a straight boundary line , with the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave being perpendicular to the boundary .
b ) two examples for the relations ( [ symmbez1 ] ) and ( [ symmbez2 ] ) . the upper panel shows , that for an opening angle of @xmath61 an incoming trajectory always leaves the corner at the same angle . for an opening angle of @xmath71 ,
the directions of the incoming and outgoing trajectories are symmetric with respect to the bisecting line of the wedge ( lower panel ) .
[ alpgamn ] ] for opening angles @xmath80 , multiple reflections of a quasiparticle trajectory occur , because the boundaries are hit several times .
generally , for a given opening angle @xmath48 , the exact path of a quasiparticle trajectory has to be determined by a raytracing algorithm . however , there are some specific opening angles @xmath81 , which have useful properties and are the key in understanding the oscillations .
we denote @xmath82 $ ] the angle of an incoming trajectory before any reflection has occured , and call @xmath83 $ ] the angle of the final outgoing trajectory after all the multiple reflections .
then , the specific opening angles @xmath84 have the property , that always @xmath85 while for @xmath86 we always have @xmath87 in the first case , incoming and outgoing trajectories are parallel .
this means that the gap value is the same on the incoming and outgoing part of the trajectory .
in contrast , in the second case the angles of incoming and outgoing trajectories are symmetric with respect to the bisecting line of the wedge . for @xmath72 ( nodal direction along the bisecting line )
this means , that the gap possesses opposite sign on the incoming and outgoing part of the trajectory , which results in large contributions to the zero - energy density of states in the corner .
two typical examples for the different symmetry behaviour of in- and outgoing trajectory directions are shown in fig .
[ alpgamn]b ) . of a @xmath26-wave superconductor with wedge - shaped boundary geometry .
the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave is fixed parallel to the bisecting line of the wedge , i.e. @xmath72 . decreasing the opening angle @xmath48 leads to oscillations of the density of states in the corner , with minima appearing at @xmath78 and maxima close to @xmath79 .
both upper and lower envelope ( dotted lines ) are given analytically .
[ oszi ] ] now we turn to the calculation of the local density of states in the corner point @xmath50 of the wedge . for the trajectories passing through this point
, it is an excellent assumption to neglect all the complicated details of the multiple reflections in the corner completely , since they occur on a very small lengthscale along the trajectory path
. the only important things to keep are the relations between the angles of incoming and finally outgoing trajectories .
thus , the effect of the wedge - shaped boundary geometry is only a mixing of the bulk values ( [ bulkab ] ) of @xmath14 and @xmath15 belonging to different angles .
if we concentrate on the specific opening angles @xmath88 with the relations ( [ symmbez1 ] ) and ( [ symmbez2 ] ) , it is possible to derive an analytic expression for the local density of states in the corner . the oscillations in fig .
[ oszi ] appear for the @xmath0-wave orientation @xmath72 , where the nodal direction is parallel to the bisecting line of the wedge .
based on relation ( [ symmbez1 ] ) for opening angles @xmath84 , we find the lower envelope @xmath89 analogous , the upper envelope , which connects the values of the local density of states for opening angles @xmath86 , is given by @xmath90 here , @xmath91 and @xmath22 are elliptic integrals of the first and second kind .
both upper and lower envelope are shown as the dotted lines in fig .
[ oszi ] . as already mentioned before , we chose the effective scattering parameter @xmath63 .
for the lower envelope , all the bulk values stemming from an interval of length @xmath48 around the nodal line contribute to the local density of states in the corner . because of that , for @xmath61 the whole quasiparticle spectrum in the corner is the same as in the bulk , since contributions from the full @xmath0-wave are included . in particular ,
the zero - energy density of states in the corner is just the bulk value . when the opening angle @xmath48 is reduced , however , the result approaches the normal state value @xmath92 .
the upper envelope is dominated by bound states , which occur by the mixing due to relation ( [ symmbez2 ] ) , since the gap function changes sign at the bisecting line of the wedge . the highest contribution to the bound states
is confined by the opening angle @xmath48 .
thus , after the maximum for @xmath76 at the flat boundary , the upper envelope shrinks to the normal state value @xmath92 for smaller opening angles . if the maximum gap direction of the @xmath0-wave is parallel to the bisecting line of the wedge , i.e. @xmath67 , the sign of the gap function is symmetric with respect to the bisecting line
. then , the mixing ( [ symmbez2 ] ) of the specific opening angles @xmath93 generates nothing but bulk contributions , too .
consequently , for all the opening angles @xmath81 , no bound states appear at all .
the corresponding values of the zero - energy local densities of states in the corner are on the same curve for both @xmath94 and @xmath93 : @xmath95 for @xmath96 and again for @xmath97 , we have the same density of states both in the bulk and in the corner . for smaller opening angles ,
only the contributions from the full - gap direction remain .
the local density of states in the corner approaches the shape of a bulk @xmath1-wave spectrum . because of that
, the zero - energy weight approaches the @xmath1-wave bulk value , as already pointed out before . although there are no zero - energy bound states in the corner of the wedge for the specific opening angles @xmath81 , multiple reflections lead to considerable bound states for angles @xmath98 . for arbitrary opening angles
@xmath99 , however , the deviation of the zero - energy density of states in the corner from eq .
( [ gamma0linie ] ) determined by the @xmath88 is small . to summarize this section : whether andreev bound states appear in the corner of a wedge or not depends on both opening angle @xmath48 of the wedge and orientation @xmath49 of the @xmath0-wave .
for @xmath99 , andreev bound states in the corner are suppressed in most of the parameter space
. however , near the specific opening angles @xmath86 and for orientations about @xmath72 , andreev bound states get induced in the corner .
[ alpgamn]a ) provides a map , showing for which combinations of angles andreev bound states appear .
we already discussed the influence of a single abrikosov vortex , which is pinned near a straight smooth boundary , on the local quasiparticle spectrum in a previous work @xcite .
the result is a suppression of the zero - energy andreev bound states in a shadow - like region extending from the vortex to the boundary .
this effect is due to the flow field of the phase gradient around the vortex , which leads to a local shift of the quasiparticle energy along the trajectory . as a consequence ,
the zero - energy andreev bound states at the boundary are suppressed and the spectral weight is shifted towards higher quasiparticle energies as discussed in ref . .
-wave superconductors with wedge - shaped boundary geometries .
a single abrikosov vortex is pinned at a distance of 2 @xmath100 from each boundary line .
all pictures presented here correspond to a specific wedge and orientation already shown earlier without a vortex .
the same color palettes have been used for both the corresponding plot without vortex and the plot given here .
a ) this picture refers to fig .
[ keil90]c ) .
the vortex casts a shadow - like suppression on the andreev bound states at each boundary .
b ) this picture refers to fig .
[ keil60]a ) .
again , the andreev bound states at the boundaries are locally suppressed .
c ) this picture refers to fig .
[ keil60]c ) .
the bound states in the corner induced by the boundary geometry are also affected but remain still considerable .
please note , that b ) and c ) are given in a smaller scale than the corresponding pictures .
[ keilvortex ] ] some examples of a single abrikosov vortex , which is pinned near a wedge - shaped boundary geometry , are shown in fig .
[ keilvortex ] . here
, we have calculated the phase distribution around the vortex using the conformal mapping procedure described in section ii b. each picture corresponds to a picture with the same wedge geometry and @xmath0-wave orientation already presented in earlier figures . as a main effect ,
the existence of the vortex and its inhomogeneous phase lead to a local suppression of the zero - energy andreev bound states at the boundaries .
the center of the suppression seems to be approximately that point of the boundary , which lies closest to the vortex . if we concentrate on the very corner of the wedge , however , the characteristic changes of the local density of states induced by the boundary geometry itself are only slightly affected by the presence of the vortex .
of course , the induced bound states in the corner of fig .
[ keil60]c ) , for example , get reduced by about 30 % in fig . [ keilvortex]c ) because of the vortex .
nevertheless , the zero - energy density of states is still strongly increased in the corner compared to the bound states at the boundary nearby .
an induced suppression of the zero - energy density of states in the corner is practically not affected by the vortex as can be seen in figs .
[ keilvortex]a ) and b ) .
it is important to realize , however , that the shown suppressions of the zero - energy local density of states are not of the same nature . on the one hand ,
the suppression due to the vortex is the result of a splitting of the sharp zero - energy peak in the quasiparticle spectrum . on the other hand ,
the low value of the zero - energy density of states because of the boundary geometry is just a natural consequence , when the quasiparticle spectrum in the corner is given by a @xmath0- or even @xmath1-wave bulk spectrum .
some further examples of a wedge with opening angle @xmath101 and an abrikosov vortex at different positions can be seen in fig .
[ stumpvortex ] . in the top row
, the shadow effect can be observed again .
below , there are no bound states at the boundaries at all , and the influence of the vortex rather leads to a very small increase of the zero - energy density of states .
-wave superconductor for a wedge - shaped boundary with opening angle @xmath101 .
a single abrikosov vortex is situated at a vertical distance of @xmath102 from the corner of the wedge .
the horizontal distance of the vortex is a ) @xmath102 , b ) @xmath100 , c ) 0 . in the top row ,
the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave is perpendicular to both boundaries , which corresponds to @xmath67 .
below , the nodal direction is parallel to the bisecting line , i.e. @xmath72 . [ stumpvortex ] ]
in this section , we want to study the influence of surface roughness and surface faceting on the vortex shadow effect introduced in ref . in order to see how stable this effect is .
there have been several different suggestions in the literature how surface roughness can be implemented within eilenberger theory ( see for example refs . ) . here , we focus on the zero - energy density of states in the vicinity of a boundary line for two different models of either microscopic or macroscopic roughness with respect to the lengthscale of the coherence length .
we begin with a very simple model of microscopic roughness in the next subsection .
after that , we present results for a polygonal boundary structure , which can be regarded as a macroscopically rough , faceted surface .
in contrast to previous work we take into account the complicated current redistribution along the faceted surface using conformal mapping techniques .
-wave superconductor in the vicinity of a surface .
this corresponds to an opening angle of the wedge of @xmath76 .
a single abrikosov vortex is located at a distance of @xmath102 from the boundary . in the top row ,
the boundary is smooth . in the lower row ,
the boundary is microscopically rough .
a ) the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave is perpendicular to the boundary , which corresponds to @xmath72 .
b ) the rotation angle is @xmath103 .
compared to a ) , the orientation changed by 15 degrees . [ specular ] ] a simple model of a microscopically rough surface is given by an arrangement of randomly tilted tiny mirrors along the boundary line .
the size of each mirror is taken to be about @xmath104 , which is of an atomic lengthscale for high-@xmath105 superconductors .
each mirror is randomly tilted .
we have chosen a gaussian distribution between @xmath106 and @xmath107 for all the tilt angles , with a tilt angle of @xmath74 corresponding to a parallel alignment of mirror and boundary line .
additionally , we made the simplification , that the mirrors do not extent into the superconductor .
their only function is to reflect an incoming trajectory according to the mirror orientation , thus producing a kind of random scattering at the boundary .
there are some further consequences of the simplification made above . on the one hand , the flow field inside the superconductor
is not affected by the boundary roughness and is simply the one of a wedge - shaped boundary geometry with opening angle @xmath76 . on the other hand ,
multiple reflections at the boundary and the corresponding effects presented in the previous section are excluded .
however , it is important to note , that for any boundary orientation , there exist zero - energy bound states in some regions of the boundary line because of the microscopic roughness .
this is in agreement with earlier calculations of the zero - bias conductance peak for a rough surface @xcite .
how is the shadow effect due to a vortex affected by such a microscopically rough surface ?
the zero - energy local density of states for a boundary line with one specific randomly generated mirror arrangement and an adjacent abrikosov vortex is shown in fig .
[ specular ] . in column
a ) , the nodal line of the @xmath0-wave is perpendicular to the boundary , which corresponds to a ( 110 ) surface or @xmath72 , respectively .
although the appearance of the andreev bound states along the boundary line changes in a characteristic way because of the microscopic roughness , the suppression of the andreev bound states in a shadow - like region clearly persists . in b ) , the orientation between boundary and @xmath0-wave is changed by @xmath108 degrees .
the suppression of the bound states remains , but it is obviously no more symmetric , neither for the smooth nor the microscopically rough boundary .
since the modulus of the phase gradient around the vortex is symmetric , this asymmetry can not be explained by a doppler - shifted energy spectrum , where only local surface currents are taken into account .
in fact , generally the whole quasiparticle `` history '' along its trajectory is very important and may not be neglected . only in the case of a homogeneous flow field @xcite , for example far away from the vortex , it becomes sufficient to consider solely the local current . ]
-wave superconductor with a polygonal boundary geometry , which can be regarded as a boundary line with macroscopic roughness ( faceting ) .
a ) no vortex is present .
b ) a single abrikosov vortex is situated @xmath102 away from the averaged boundary line .
[ polygonal ] ] we now examine the zero - energy local density of states of a @xmath0-wave superconductor along a macroscopically rough boundary line . as an adequate model ,
we take a superconductor with a polygonal boundary geometry , consisting of piecewise smooth facets , each of a length of the order of @xmath100 . in contrast to the model of a microscopically rough surface presented above , the extension of the polygonal boundary geometry
is taken into account completely . for the more simple wedge - shaped boundary in section iii
, we obtained the phase of the gap function in an analytical way by conformal mapping ( cf .
section ii b ) . for the more general case of a polygonal boundary ,
it becomes necessary to calculate the schwarz - christoffel mapping @xcite numerically .
we used an implementation by driscoll@xcite to obtain the correct corresponding phase .
this toolbox uses the analytically known solution of the phase distribution for a vortex sitting in the center of a disk and conformally maps this solution onto the vortex close to the polygonal boundary , as illustrated in fig .
[ cfmapping ] .
for the disk , the lines of constant phase are just radial lines , and the phase gradient corresponds to concentric circles , fulfilling the boundary condition that the phase gradient is parallel to the surface .
the toolbox provides the mapping which maps the center of the disk onto the vortex position and the boundary of the disk onto the polygonal boundary .
the resulting lines of constant phase and phase gradient after this mapping are shown in fig .
[ cfmapping ] , right panel .
this means , that within the approximation ( [ gradandj ] ) , the currents due to a single abrikosov vortex are forced to be parallel to each facet of the polygonal boundary .
furthermore , the polygonal boundary allows for multiple reflections of quasiparticle trajectories .
thus , the effects discussed in section iii can be found here as well . in fig .
[ polygonal]a ) and b ) , the zero - energy local density of states of the @xmath0-wave superconductor with polygonal boundary structure is shown .
the main direction of the boundary is oriented in such a way , that facets parallel to it exhibit maximum andreev bound states . if we compare the local density of states shown in fig .
[ polygonal]a ) , where no vortex is present , to the case with abrikosov vortex presented in b ) , many of the effects already discussed above can be found again ( cf .
for example fig .
[ keilvortex ] ) .
the energy spectrum in the corner of a right - angled wedge is , independent of its orientation , the @xmath0-wave bulk spectrum .
thus , the nearly right - angled parts of the boundary exhibit a very low zero - energy density of states , which is hardly affected by the presence of the vortex . the main effect of the vortex is again a strong suppression of zero - energy bound states in its shadow region
this is because the zero - energy spectral weight is effectively shifted towards higher energies .
bound states at the boundary , which are further away , are reduced more moderately .
in this work , we investigated the influence of both the boundary geometry and a single pinned abrikosov vortex on the zero - energy local density of states along the boundary of a @xmath26-wave superconductor .
we found that a wedge - shaped boundary can induce a quasiparticle spectrum in the corner of the wedge , which is completely different to that farther away from the corner .
the main mechanism for this effect is the multiple reflection of quasiparticle trajectories . in the corner , this can effectively be described as a mixing of bulk trajectories belonging to different angles .
depending on the opening angle of the wedge and the orientation between @xmath0-wave and boundary geometry , this mixing can either lead to bulk spectra in the corner ( and thus to an absence of bound states ) or to the presence of induced zero - energy bound states . in fig .
[ alpgamn]a ) , we have provided a map , showing for which combinations of opening angle and @xmath0-wave orientation bound states appear .
if the wedge is oriented in such a way , that the nodal direction of the @xmath0-wave is parallel to the bisecting line , the zero - energy density of states in the corner strongly oscillates as a function of the opening angle of the wedge .
although all results presented here have been obtained using a model gap function , a fully selfconsistent calculation is not going to change the results qualitatively .
the amplitude of the oscillations mentioned above , for example , should be somewhat reduced , especially for smaller opening angles .
but in any case , it should be possible to observe the oscillations at least for larger opening angles .
another example of an induced quasiparticle spectrum is a wedge with opening angle @xmath75 : the local density of states in the corner of a right - angled wedge is always given by a @xmath0-wave bulk spectrum , even if the orientation allows the highest andreev bound states at both boundary lines .
in addition to this geometrically induced prohibition of bound states , we presented the influence of a single pinned abrikosov vortex on the zero - energy local density of states at the boundary .
bound states at the boundary are locally suppressed , in particular in a shadow - like region close to the vortex . however
, this kind of suppression is due to a splitting of the high zero - energy peak of the bound states . thus it is of a different physical origin .
the spectral weight is effectively shifted towards higher energies , because the quasiparticles `` see '' a locally varying energy shift along their trajectory , which stems from the locally varying flow field around the vortex .
both effects can be observed independently in our results .
we have studied the influence of two types of surface roughness on the vortex shadow effect : microscopic , random scattering at the surface as well as a more macroscopic faceting of the boundary . in the second case we have taken care to calculate the flow field with the appropriate boundary conditions using the conformal mapping technique . in both cases
the vortex shadow effect clearly persists .
t. a. driscoll , acm transactions on mathematical software * 22(2 ) * , 168 - 186 ( 1996 ) ; algorithm 756 .
a more recent version of the _ schwarz - christoffel toolbox for matlab _ is available at t. a. driscolls website . | besides the well - known existence of andreev bound states , the zero - energy local density of states at the boundary of a @xmath0-wave superconductor strongly depends on the boundary geometry itself . in this work , we examine the influence of both a simple wedge - shaped boundary geometry and a more complicated polygonal or faceted boundary structure on the local density of states . for a wedge - shaped boundary geometry ,
we find oscillations of the zero - energy density of states in the corner of the wedge , depending on the opening angle of the wedge . furthermore , we study the influence of a single abrikosov vortex situated near a boundary , which is of either macroscopic or microscopic roughness . |
the knowledge of the phase diagram of nuclear matter is one of the principal open questions in modern nuclear physics with far reaching cosmological consequences .
detailed investigations have been carried out in the recent years in particle - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions in a wide range of projectile energies .
the process of multifragmentation was investigated at intermediate and high energies in order to study the properties of the expected liquid - gas phase transition at sub - saturation nuclear densities .
for instance , using the calorimetry of the hot quasi - projectile nuclei formed in the damped nucleus - nucleus collisions ( see ref .
@xcite and ref .
@xcite for a review of related methods ) , thermodynamical observables of the fragmenting system such as temperature and chemical potential were extracted and a set of correlated signals of the isospin - asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition was observed . on the other hand , various properties of the observed fragments can be interpreted as signals of criticality @xcite , thus indicating an underlying second order phase transition .
the phase diagram at sub - saturation densities appears to be rather complex and detailed investigations are needed for clarification .
the recent experimental studies of the nucleus - nucleus collisions at ultrarelativistic energies provide vast amount of experimental observations which can be interpreted as signals of production and decomposition of the new state of matter with deconfined quarks , called quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) @xcite .
such matter exhibits many unique properties such as nearly perfect fluid behavior @xcite and strong medium modification of high - energy particles with a typical mach cone behavior @xcite .
one of the phenomena not yet understood there is the so - called `` hbt puzzle '' @xcite , an unexpected behavior of the source radii extracted from particle - particle correlations , which appear to be almost isotropic , in contrast with intense elliptic flow observed in such collisions .
it was suggested that spatial inhomogeneity ( typically in the form of qgp droplets ) can play a crucial role in its explanation @xcite .
the mechanism of formation of such inhomogeneity is one of the interesting open questions . in the present work ,
the mechanism of a phase transition is investigated as a phenomenon reflecting the properties of the underlying interaction .
a modified van der waals equation of state is used for the nuclear medium at sub - saturation densities and the role of isospin asymmetry will be investigated within the limitation following from the evolution of an isolated system .
an analogous treatment is used for schematic description of the system undergoing deconfinement - confinement phase transition . .
the lines represent isotherms with temperatures increasing with the step 2.5 mev , starting at zero . ,
the liquid - gas phase transition in the nuclear matter is supposed to occur after nuclear matter expands and medium becomes unstable toward density fluctuations .
the process as initially suggested in ref .
@xcite was supposed to be analogous to liquid - gas phase transitions in real gases , which is typically described by the van der waals equation of state ( eos ) .
however , unlike the van der waals gas , nuclear matter is a two - component system and it thus possesses an additional degree of freedom related to proton and neutron concentrations .
additional energy term representing the symmetry energy has to be taken into account . under assumption that the symmetry energy decreases with density , it can be favorable for the expanding system to store the excess of neutrons ( protons ) into a dilute phase and thus isospin - asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition can occur @xcite .
however , the expanding nuclear system is isolated and no heat can be transferred into or out of the system and a typical picture of phase transition under conditions of phase equilibrium , as represented by the well - known maxwell construction , is not relevant due to necessity to transfer latent heat into or out of the system . in order to study the mechanism of isospin asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition in the isolated nuclear system
, we adopt a simple eos for the symmetric nuclear matter , closely reminding the van der waals eos , where the repulsive short - range cubic interaction term is introduced as a substitute for the minimum volume @xmath0 the parameter values @xmath1 i and @xmath2 were chosen to fix zero pressure at saturation density taken as @xmath3 and preserve plausible values for both critical temperature ( @xmath4 ) and ground state energy ( @xmath5 ) .
the equation of state thus can be considered as a reasonable approximation to the results obtained using the microscopic theory of nuclear matter .
the resulting pressure and internal energy isotherms are shown in fig .
the internal energy ( obtained assuming the heat capacity @xmath6 ) exhibits a quadratic dependence on density with a minimum at saturation density , what is the expected result for the nuclear ground state .
since the system is thermally isolated , the expansion of the system is an adiabatic process .
the entropy does not change during system evolution and assuming that the heat capacity @xmath7 is constant , the following expression for temperature as a function of density @xmath8 can be derived , where @xmath9 is the temperature projected to saturation density @xmath10 .
the resulting isoentropic density dependences of the pressure and internal energy are shown in fig .
[ fg2]a , b. one can identify spinodal region where pressure grows while density falls , however , the limiting temperature appears much smaller than the one extracted from fig .
the resulting phase diagram constructed using the pressure and temperature at the spinodal contour is shown in fig .
the critical temperature appears to only slightly exceed 8 mev .
such observation is in agreement with experimental results @xcite .
two caloric curves are shown in fig .
the dashed line represents the standard caloric curve obtained using the fermi - gas formula @xmath11 where the level density parameter is chosen as @xmath12 .
such dependence is widely used in various evaporation models and represents essentially an evolution at ground state density .
it is worthwhile to note that the temperature dependence in eq .
[ fgf ] is equivalent to the heat capacity @xmath7 linearly increasing with temperature .
such dependence is in agreement with theory of the fermi gas at low excitation energies , however , its validity should be restricted only to the domain where @xmath7 does not exceed the ideal gas value 3/2 ( below temperature 7.5 mev ) , since @xmath7 saturates at this value and thus assumption of its further growth is not correct .
solid line in fig .
[ fg2]d represents the caloric curve obtained by combining the temperature at which the system enters spinodal region with the estimate of initial excitation energy taking into account also expansion of the system during initial heating . the heat capacity @xmath13 was obtained from @xmath14 where @xmath7 was determined using the formula [ fgf ] .
the system expanded according to @xmath15 which is closely related to @xmath13 . at each step of the procedure
the temperature was incremented by a small value , corresponding increase of the internal ( excitation ) energy was proportional to @xmath13 and the density was modified according to the calculated volume expansion coefficient .
finally , new value of the pressure was calculated from the equation of state using new values of density and temperature . the resulting evolution of the system is shown in fig . [ fg2]a as a nearly horizontal line starting from the ground state .
the pressure of the system appears to grow very slowly while the system expands .
the resulting caloric curve is similar but much flatter than the one obtained using the fermi gas formula . for real nuclei one can assume that the system will follow the dashed line until it has enough energy to pass the fragmentation barrier and expand toward spinodal region , thus approaching the solid line via a short plateau .
such a short plateau was observed in the experiment @xcite , where it correlated with the onset of thermal equilibrium with the nucleonic gas , as represented by agreement of the extracted double isotope - ratio temperature with the kinematic temperature of protons .
furthermore , it is interesting to note that while the fermionic system expands its fermi energy exhibits the @xmath16 density dependence , which is identical to density dependence of temperature during adiabatic expansion when one assumes the saturation value @xmath6 .
thus the ratio of the fermi energy to temperature , which is a parameter determining the occupation numbers , will remain the same during adiabatic expansion .
the ideal gas approximation @xmath6 appears justified for the isoentropic expansion where such value was reached during heating , in the fig .
[ fg2]a such situation applies to pressure curves with initial temperatures above @xmath17 . increasing with the step 2.5 mev , starting at zero .
curve in the panel a ) represents the spinodal contour and the horizontal line heating process of the nucleus . in the panel c ) is the p - t diagram for the spinodal contour and in the panel d ) are the caloric curves for the spinodal contour ( solid ) and for the fermi gas formula ( dashed ) . , width=453,height=377 ] nuclear matter is a two - component system and thus an energy term representing the symmetry energy has to be introduced in order to reflect the difference of proton and neutron concentrations @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the symmetry energy coefficient from the weiszcker formula and a @xmath16 density dependence is assumed from the behavior of the fermi energy . due to density dependence of the symmetry energy it can be favorable for the system to store the excess of neutrons ( protons ) into a dilute phase and thus the isospin - asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition can take place .
the equation of state will be modified to the form @xmath20 which allows us to investigate the behavior of the system as a function of density and isospin asymmetry @xmath21 .
the additional term in the equation of state will not modify the temperature dependence in eq .
[ tadiab ] . .
the adiabatic expansion with the temperature at saturation density @xmath22 is assumed .
thick curve represents the spinodal contour . in panel b ) is shown a detailed view onto low density region .
, width=453,height=226 ] the pressure contours determined by eq .
[ asnuceos ] using the value @xmath23 are shown in fig .
[ fg3 ] as a contour plot .
the resulting spinodal region is highlighted and its shape is similar to microscopic calculations @xcite .
the asymmetric systems will enter the spinodal region at lower densities , on the other hand the isospin - asymmetric gas remains stable at much higher densities than the symmetric one .
( solid line ) , @xmath24 ( dashed line ) and b ) vapor fraction @xmath25 for an adiabatically expanding system with @xmath26 and isospin asymmetry of the system @xmath27 .
, width=453,height=226 ] metastable state inside the spinodal contour ( @xmath28 ) is unstable toward spontaneous compression to stable liquid state at the spinodal contour , but such process would create heat . instead of heat , the released internal energy can be deposited into expansion of vapor into free volume , thus spending released energy into overcoming attractive nuclear force .
when the whole system is isolated ( @xmath29 ) the process of spinodal decomposition will be equivalent to fast transfer of particles from the metastable state at its constant pressure to the stable liquid and vapor states at their corresponding pressures and total enthalpy of the system will not change during phase transition and the relation @xmath30 will be preserved .
( solid line ) , @xmath24 ( dashed line ) and b ) vapor fraction @xmath25 for an adiabatically expanding system with @xmath26 and isospin asymmetry of the system @xmath31 .
, width=453,height=226 ] during fast transition the total volume remains constant ( @xmath32 ) and for a given combination of the stable liquid and gas states located at the spinodal contour the partial volumes of liquid and vapor are @xmath33 where @xmath34 and nucleonic fraction of the vapor is @xmath35 for which the charge conserving proton concentration ( @xmath36 ) is determined using proton concentration of a given liquid state @xmath24 @xmath37 which should agree with the proton concentration @xmath38 of the vapor state at the spinodal contour used to determine @xmath25 .
such a self - consistent stable liquid and vapor states located at the spinodal contour can be determined numerically .
total enthalpy conservation relation can be written as @xmath39 where @xmath40 , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are values of the enthalpy per particle .
( solid line ) , @xmath24 ( dashed line ) and b ) vapor fraction @xmath25 for an adiabatically expanding system with @xmath26 and isospin asymmetry of the system @xmath43 .
, width=453,height=226 ] the resulting values of @xmath38 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 for an adiabatically expanding system with @xmath26 are shown in figs .
[ fg4 ] , [ fg5 ] and [ fg6 ] for the isospin asymmetries of the system @xmath44 0.3 , 0.03 and 0.003 , respectively .
it can be seen that for the asymmetric system with @xmath44 0.3 there occurs a well pronounced isospin asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition with a sizable part of the system being converted into very isospin asymmetric vapor while the rest of the system becomes still more and more symmetric liquid .
these trends become more prominent as the density of initial meta - stable state decreases . when the system becomes more symmetric ( see figs .
[ fg5 ] and [ fg6 ] ) the vapor fraction drops very quickly while the vapor preserves its isospin asymmetry .
also the region of densities where isospin asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition can occur shrinks quickly . from the figs .
[ fg4 ] , [ fg5 ] and [ fg6 ] one can conclude that observable isospin asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition will occur for very asymmetric systems such as these observed in the experiment @xcite while for symmetric systems ( and for the remnants of liquid phase in asymmetric systems ) another mechanism will play role . in order to reach spinodal region
the system must pass the multifragmentation barrier and thus these systems will be unstable toward sudden decomposition into multiple fragments . such a scenario can provide explanation for the somewhat confusing situation where signatures of both first and second order phase transitions can be extracted from observed data ( even from the same set of data ) . the first - order behavior can be attributed to the distillation of isospin - asymmetric gas while the second - order signatures can be attributed to subsequent fragmentation ( percolation ) of the remaining symmetric liquid .
it is also interesting that the conclusions observed here are in good agreement with the assumptions used by the statistical model of multifragmentation ( smm ) @xcite where the fragment partition is considered at equilibrium with nucleonic gas .
such a scenario is supported also by experimental data @xcite .
other interesting point is that the @xmath16 density dependence of the symmetry energy used in the present work appears as satisfactorily describing the properties of asymmetric nuclear matter at sub - saturation densities .
the ultrarelativistic nucleus - nucleus collisions result in the very high energy densities where the quark matter can exist in thermally equilibrated deconfined state known as quark - gluon plasma . during the subsequent expansion energy density decreases until the critical value around 1 @xmath45 where , according to the predictions of the quantum chromodynamical calculations performed on the lattice @xcite the matter will revert to the confined state , where the interaction is dominated by a divergent confinement potential , linearly increasing with the distance .
the potential energy , stored in the one - dimensional field tubes , called strings , will be subsequently released by string fragmentation in the form of hadronic gas . in order to investigate the phase diagram ,
one can use known equations of state of initial and final states of the quark - gluonic plasma and the hadronic gas and try to interpolate the equation of state in the spinodal region , as is done in ref .
@xcite . however , since the process of hadronization typically proceeds via fragmentation of elongated strings it is also interesting to explore thermodynamical properties of the possible intermediate state of matter , where the particles of the quark gas interact via confinement potential .
such state of matter is referred here as the confined quark matter .
the properties of intermediate states can be important for the mechanism of phase transition , as was demonstrated in the case of liquid - gas phase transition at sub - saturation densities . here
we will explore thermodynamical properties of the confined quark matter in analogous way as thermodynamical properties of the asymmetric nuclear matter in previous section . in order to investigate properties of the confined quark matter a confinement potential
is defined as @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the string tension with a typical value of 1 gev / fm , as used in the string fragmentation models @xcite . in order to explore properties of the confined quark matter
, a 3-dimensional cubic lattice with a quark - quark distance @xmath48 can be assumed , where each quark interacts with six nearest sites .
then the component of the internal energy , corresponding to confinement potential , can be determined as @xmath49 where the number of quarks @xmath50 is large enough to neglect surface effects . however , an assumption that quark on the lattice interacts with all neighbors must not necessarily be satisfied , since strings are essentially one - dimensional objects .
one can modify above formula by assuming that each quark on the lattice interacts with @xmath51 neighboring quarks and one obtains the formula @xmath52 the pressure component corresponding to confinement potential can be obtained as @xmath53 thus leading to negative pressure . in order to obtain the equation of state of the confined quark matter , one has to introduce the pressure of the quark gas which in the ultrarelativistic limit can be written as @xmath54 where @xmath55 is a degeneration factor and @xmath56 is the dirichlet eta function . in order to write equation of state with the confinement potential one needs to find relation between energy density and quark density .
that is possible for zero chemical potential ( with @xmath55 accounting for equal numbers of quarks and anti - quarks ) @xmath57 and after comparing the equations ( [ purgs ] ) and ( [ durgs ] ) one arrives to @xmath58 for the equation of state . .
thick line represents quark - gluon plasma ( eqs .
( [ purgs ] ) and ( [ durgs ] ) with @xmath59 and @xmath60 ) , solid section corresponds to the region above phase transition .
thin solid line shows pressure of the confined quark matter , dashed line shows the quark gas contribution ( eqs .
( [ purgs ] ) and ( [ durgs ] ) with @xmath59 ) , dash - dotted line shows the confinement potential contribution ( eq .
( [ pconf ] ) ) .
, width=453,height=226 ] the resulting situation is shown in fig .
[ fg7 ] for @xmath61 . at energy densities below critical value 1 @xmath62 and corresponding quark densities
the confined quark matter exhibits negative pressure and also violates the mechanical stability criterion .
such a medium is indeed unstable against collapse what on the other hand is a direct consequence of the interaction rather than an interplay of short- and long - range interactions , as in the liquid - gas phase transition .
since confined quark matter is primarily unstable toward hadronization it can be assumed that the survival time against hadronization is much shorter than collapse time and the medium can be considered as a quasi - stable transitional state .
the detailed mechanism of the deconfinement - confinement phase transition is beyond the scope of this work , the lattice qcd calculations @xcite suggest a rapid crossover for the systems with small chemical potential produced at rhic . as in the liquid - gas phase transition at sub - saturation densities , one can explore the global properties of the interaction and limitations on the phase transition resulting from the isolated system and , as a consequence , an isoenthalpic transition into confined quark matter can be considered . in the present case the hot quark - gluon plasma with high thermal pressure transforms into confined quark matter with much lower ( negative ) pressure .
the hadronization phase transition then follows as a consequence of the fragmentation of the elongated strings . .
dependence of the a ) parameter @xmath51 , b ) energy density , c ) pressure and d ) temperature of the confined quark matter on quark density .
solid lines represent the low - density branch , dashed lines show the high - density branch .
, width=453,height=377 ] enthalpy of the quark - gluon plasma with @xmath63 and @xmath64 quarks and antiquarks can be expressed as @xmath65 where @xmath55 = 24 , @xmath66 = 16 and @xmath67 is the riemann zeta function . the enthalpy balance of the transition from quark - gluon plasma at temperature @xmath9 to confined quark matter at density @xmath68 and corresponding temperature @xmath69 can be written assuming ultrarelativistic fermionic gas also in the confined phase , with the additional component corresponding to confinement potential , obtained after combining the equations [ uconf ] and [ pconf ] @xmath70 and using the relation [ durgs ] one arrives to equation @xmath71 which after assuming numerical values @xmath72 ( as suggested in the refs .
@xcite , @xcite ) , @xmath73 @xcite , @xmath59 and @xmath74 leads to a numerical equation which has solutions for @xmath75 .
the solutions of eq .
( [ isenthnum ] ) are shown in the panel fig .
[ fg8]a as a dependence of the parameter @xmath51 on quark density .
a low - density branch ( solid line ) and high - density branch ( dashed line ) can be identified , separated by the point at @xmath76 corresponding to maximum value of the parameter @xmath77 .
the resulting dependence of energy density on quark density is shown in the panel fig .
[ fg8]b and one can see that the solution for @xmath77 corresponds approximately to initial energy density of quark - gluon plasma at @xmath72 .
the low - density branch corresponds to lower energy densities and thus represents possible states to which the system can transform since it corresponds to both quark and energy densities below the phase transition .
the high - density branch represents the states with higher energy densities than the critical density and thus can be considered unphysical since it is not obvious that the confinement potential is applicable to such states . from the eq .
( [ isenthnum ] ) thus implies that the phase transition can be in principle continuous in the energy density , but discontinuous in the quark density . after reaching the critical energy density ,
further expansion will be achieved by transforming an increasing amount of the quark - gluon plasma into confined quark matter with the maximum of about two thirds of quark density , temperature below 150 mev and negative pressure ( see fig . [ fg8]c ) . however , once the strings will fragment and a hadronic gas will be formed , potential energy will be released , pressure will increase dramatically and one can assume an explosion scenario .
one can imagine a sudden expansion of the bubble of hadronic gas to the radius reaching the dimensions of the whole system .
such a scenario can offer a natural explanation to the `` hbt puzzle '' where the extracted radii are essentially equal for longitudinal , sideward and outward direction and suggest an isotropic source with a short emission time .
hbt puzzle can thus be interpreted as a signature of the phase transition .
it is also interesting to note formal similarity with the cosmologic inflation , a scenario leading to isotropic causality - connected universe , which is supposed to start from the patch of matter in the state of false vacuum at negative pressure . in the present case
the confined quark matter could represent the false vacuum while the hadronic gas could be considered as the true vacuum .
thus , the ultrarelativistic nucleus - nucleus collisions may exhibit , apart from the `` little bang '' scenario @xcite and possibility of the existence of mini black holes @xcite , another cosmological analogy in the form of `` mini - inflation '' , as a possible explanation of the hbt puzzle .
it is also interesting to compare the results for the quark matter to the liquid - gas phase transition at sub - saturation density .
both systems will evolve spatial inhomogeneity with one phase at positive pressure and the other one at negative pressure , but different asymptotic behavior of the potential , one diverging at small distances while the other one at large distances , leads to reversion of some properties .
while in the liquid - gas phase transition the dense liquid phase transforms into dilute gaseous phase , in the deconfinement - confinement phase transition the dense gaseous phase transforms into dilute liquid phase , which subsequently transforms into hadronic gas .
the liquid consistence of the confined quark matter can be judged e.g. from its possible one - dimensional structure , as suggested by existing isoenthalpic solutions . in both cases
the liquid phase is unstable toward subsequent decay by fragmentation mechanism .
it is also interesting to investigate whether introduction of strangeness into the model description will lead to asymmetric phases .
one can assume that for the strange quarks the string tension will increase and thus it will be preferable for strange particles to remain in the deconfined phase .
the strangeness of the deconfined phase will increase and the strange hadrons will be formed in the latest stage of hadronization .
thermodynamical properties of the nuclear matter at sub - saturation densities were investigated using a simple van der waals - like equation of state with an additional term representing symmetry energy . for the isolated system
an enthalpy conservation rule was introduced resulting in significant limitations for the isospin - asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition , which is a sizable effect for very isospin - asymmetric systems but becomes negligible for symmetric systems .
first - order phase transition thus appears restricted to asymmetric systems while for symmetric systems and symmetric remnants of the first - order phase transition the multifragmentation decay can exhibit similarity with second - order phase transition .
the density dependence of the symmetry energy scaling with density dependence of the fermi energy satisfactorily describes the symmetry energy at sub - saturation nuclear densities .
the limitations resulting from the isolated system were investigated also for the deconfinement - confinement phase transition from the quark - gluon plasma to quark matter with the confinement potential .
it appears that the transition can be continuous in energy density while discontinuous in quark density .
a transitional state of confined quark matter has a negative pressure and explosive scenario can take place during hadronization . resulting scenario can offer an explanation for the hbt puzzle as a signature of the phase transition . | thermodynamical properties of nuclear matter at sub - saturation densities were investigated using a simple van der waals - like equation of state with an additional term representing the symmetry energy .
first - order isospin - asymmetric liquid - gas phase transition appears restricted to isolated isospin - asymmetric systems while the symmetric systems will undergo fragmentation decay resembling the second - order phase transition .
the density dependence of the symmetry energy scaling with the fermi energy satisfactorily describes the symmetry energy at sub - saturation nuclear densities .
the deconfinement - confinement phase transition from the quark - gluon plasma to the confined quark matter appears in the isolated systems continuous in energy density while discontinuous in quark density .
a transitional state of the confined quark matter has a negative pressure and after hadronization an explosion scenario can take place which can offer explanation for the hbt puzzle as a signature of the phase transition . |
in recent years , high - resolution spectroscopic analyses of samples of stars with metallicities significantly below solar have grown to the point that one can begin to establish the general behaviors of elemental abundance ratios associated with production by the first few generations of stars to form the galaxy ( for a recent review see , e.g. , frebel & norris 2015 ) .
these `` statistical '' samples are particularly valuable when the data are analysed in a self - consistent manner ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , so that comparisons of derived abundance ratios are not plagued by the scatter introduced from the different assumptions and procedures used by individual researchers , which can be sufficiently large as to obscure important details . of particular interest to this effort is the class of stars that , despite their overall low abundances of iron - peak elements , exhibit large over - abundances of c ( as well as n and o ) in their atmospheres , the so - called carbon - enhanced metal - poor ( cemp ) stars @xcite .
this class comprises a number of sub - classes ( originally defined by beers & christlieb 2005 ) , based on the behavior of their neutron - capture elements : ( 1 ) cemp-@xmath2 stars , which exhibit no over - abundances of n - capture elements , ( 2 ) cemp-@xmath3 stars , which show n - capture over - abundances consistent with the slow neutron - capture process , ( 3 ) cemp-@xmath4 stars , with n - capture over - abundances associated with the rapid neutron - capture process , and ( 4 ) cemp-@xmath5 stars , which exhibit n - capture over - abundances that suggest contribution from both the slow and rapid neutron - capture processes .
each of these sub - classes appear to be associated with different element - production histories , thus their study provides insight into the variety of astrophysical sites in the early galaxy that were primarily responsible for their origin .
the cemp-@xmath2 stars are of special importance , as the preponderance of evidence points to their being associated with elemental - abundance patterns that were produced by the very first generation of massive stars @xcite , thus they potentially provide a unique probe of the first mass function in the early universe along with providing information on the nucleosynthesis and properties of the first stars . in a previous paper , @xcite ( hereafter paper i ) provided a detailed study of the elemental abundances for a sample of four ultra metal - poor stars with @xmath0 } < -4.0 $ ] , three of which are clear examples of cemp-@xmath2 stars . here
we supplement this sample with an additional 19 stars , exploring a wider range of metallicity .
this allows for the inclusion of additional examples of cemp-@xmath2 , cemp-@xmath3 , cemp-@xmath4 , and cemp-@xmath5 stars ( two of which qualify as possible nitrogen - enhanced metal - poor ( nemp ) stars ) , providing a more complete picture of the variety of elemental - abundance patterns for stars of very low metallicity . this paper is outlined as follows .
section 2 summarizes our observations and data analysis techniques .
section 3 presents our abundance analysis results , while section 4 provides a summary and brief discussion of their implications .
our sample of 23 very metal - poor ( vmp ; [ fe / h ] @xmath8 ) , extremely metal - poor ( emp ; [ fe / h ] @xmath9 ) , ultra metal - poor ( ump ; [ fe / h ] @xmath10 ) stars presented here were originally selected from the hamburg / eso survey ( he s ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , followed up with medium - resolution spectroscopy on a variety of 2-m to 4-m class telescopes ( aat 3.9 m , ctio 4 m , ctio 1.5 m , eso 3.6 m , kpno 4 m , soar 4 m , sso 2.3 m , and ukst 1.2 m ) , and then observed at high spectral resolution with vlt / uves @xcite .
paper i describes the observations and analysis of the four ump stars in this sample .
the high - resolution spectroscopy of the stars in our sample was performed with uves using the dichroic ( dic ) beam splitter , allowing simultaneous observation with the blue and red arm , in order to cover a spectral range including a large number of chemical elements .
three different settings were used : dic ( blue central wavelength + red central wavelength ) , covering the following wavelengths
dic1 ( 390 + 580 ) blue : @xmath113260 - 4450 , red : @xmath114760 - 6840 , dic2 ( 346 + 760 ) blue : @xmath113030 - 3880 , red : @xmath115650 - 9460 , and dic2 ( 437 + 760 ) blue : @xmath113730 - 4990 , red : @xmath115650 - 9460 .
the spectral resolving power varies with the choice of wavelength setting and slit width . the average resolving power of the spectra is r @xmath12 45,000 .
positions , observation dates , exposure times , and specific settings for the individual stars in the sample are listed in table [ tab1 ] .
the spectra were reduced using the uves reduction pipeline version 4.9.8 .
radial - velocity shifts of the spectra were obtained using the iraf task fxcor .
individual spectra were cross - correlated with a template spectrum obtained during the same observation run .
for the 2005 run , he 0134@xmath131519 and hd 2796 were used as templates , for which we find @xmath14 = 244.0 km s@xmath15 and @xmath16 km s@xmath15 , respectively .
for the 2006 run , hd 140283 was used , for which we find @xmath17 km s@xmath15 . for stars with multiple observations ,
the individual spectra were co - added with the iraf scombine task .
finally the radial - velocity shifted ( and combined ) spectrum was normalized .
table [ tab2 ] lists the derived radial velocities and signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratios at specific wavelengths for the different spectra . when a wavelength region is covered by more than one setting , the one having the highest s / n ratio is listed .
note that , because the spectra were only obtained spanning at most a few nights , these data are not suitable for evaluation of the binary nature of our stars .
however , the high accuracy of our derived radial velocities ( typically better than 1 km s@xmath15 ) should prove useful for comparison with future binarity studies .
three of the stars in our sample are re - discoveries and have radial velocities reported in the literature .
these three stars are ; he 0054@xmath132542 ( cs 22942@xmath13019 , cd-26:304 ) , he 0411@xmath133558 ( cs 22186@xmath13005 ) and he 0945@xmath131435
. @xcite found he 0054@xmath132542 to be in a binary system with a period of 2800 days , while @xcite reports @xmath18 km s @xmath15 for he 0411@xmath133558 , close to our value of @xmath19 km s @xmath15 , and @xcite reports @xmath20 km s @xmath15 for he 0945@xmath131435 , where we find @xmath21 km s @xmath15 , suggesting that it is a likely binary star .
lrrrrrr & 00 13 08.9 & -34 05 55 & 2005 nov 18 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 00 57 18.0 & -25 26 09 & 2005 nov 19 & 1200 & 1.0/1.0 & 390/580 + & 01 02 58.5 & -16 06 31 & 2005 nov 18 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 01 12 08.1 & -44 54 16 & 2005 nov 18 & 3600 & 1.0/1.0 & 390/580 + & 01 37 05.4 & -15 04 23 & 2005 nov 17 & 3600 & 1.0/1.0 & 390/580 + & & & 2005 nov 20 & 10800&0.8/0.8 & 346/760 + & 02 36 29.7 & -03 30 06 & 2005 nov 17 & 3600 & 0.8/0.8 & 390/580 + & & & 2005 nov 18 & 7200 & 1.0/0.7 & 390/580 + & & & 2005 nov 19 & 4940 & 0.8/0.7 & 346/760 + & & & 2005 nov 20 & 3600 & 0.8/0.7 & 346/760 + & 02 45 16.4 & -30 32 02 & 2005 nov 18 & 5400 & 1.0/1.0 & 390/580 + & & & 2005 nov 20 & 3600 & 0.8/0.7 & 437/760 + & 04 13 09.0 & -35 50 39 & 2005 nov 17 & 3600 & 0.4/0.3 & 390/580 + & 04 42 39.7 & -10 43 24 & 2006 apr 18 & 900 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 04 42 08.1 & -34 21 13 & 2006 apr 17 & 900 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 04 49 33.0 & -48 01 08 & 2006 apr 18 & 840 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 04 51 43.3 & -48 57 25 & 2006 apr 17 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 09 47 50.7 & -14 49 07 & 2006 apr 17 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & & & 2006 apr 18 & 7200 & 0.8/0.7 & 437/760 + & 10 31 48.2 & -06 01 44 & 2006 apr 17 & 3950 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & & & 2006 apr 18 & 7200 & 0.8/0.7 & 390/580 + & 12 21 19.3 & -18 45 34 & 2006 apr 21 & 6000 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & & & 2006 apr 21 & 3000 & 0.8/0.7 & 390/580 + & 12 44 13.0 & -29 23 47 & 2006 apr 17 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 13 13 31.2 & -05 52 13 & 2006 apr 17 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & & & 2006 apr 18 & 7200 & 0.8/0.7 & 437/760 + & 14 32 26.1 & -04 00 31 & 2006 apr 17 & 1800 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & & & 2006 apr 18 & 7200 & 0.8/0.7 & 437/760 + & 22 02 16.4 & -05 36 48 & 2006 apr 18 & 900 & 0.8/0.7 & 390/580 + & 22 10 53.3 & -12 24 27 & 2006 apr 18 & 600 & 0.8/0.7 & 390/580 + & 22 41 22.6 & -41 15 57 & 2005 nov 19 & 3600 & 1.2/1.2 & 390/580 + & 22 42 26.9 & -50 04 01 & 2005 nov 17 & 10800&1.0/0.8 & 390/580 + & 23 34 36.1 & -71 38 51 & 2005 nov 17 & 3600 & 0.8/0.8 & 390/580 + & & & 2005 nov 20 & 7200 & 0.8/0.7 & 437/760 + lrrrrr & 158.8 & 0.2 & 11 & 49 & 84 + & @xmath13214.6 & 0.1 & 9 & 46 & 96 + & 28.6 & 0.3 & 3 & 17 & 39 + & 138.8 & 0.1 & 5 & 25 & 33 + & 244.0 & 1.0 & 14 & 54 & 75 + & 63.5 & 0.6 & 9 & 35 & 42 + & 39.8 & 0.3 & 9 & 14 & 32 + & 196.2 & 0.3 & 26 & 105 & 110 + & 158.9 & 3.0 & 16 & 65 & 86 + & 326.0 & 0.6 & 16 & 61 & 162 + & 133.5 & 0.7 & 10 & 44 & 68 + & 332.4 & 1.5 & 4 & 26 & 29 + & 144.8 & 0.4 & 12 & 44 & 80 + & 18.6 & 0.3 & 10 & 35 & 45 + & 147.1 & 0.5 & 4 & 19 & 33 + & 336.3 & 2.2 & 4 & 31 & 16 + & 113.2 & 1.7 & 1 & 39 & 65 + &
@xmath13143.3 & 0.4 & 3 & 71 & 129 + & @xmath13131.3 & 0.8 & 2 & 50 & 72 + & @xmath1343.1 & 0.6 & 5 & 55 & 102 + & @xmath1342.0 & 0.3 & 2 & 13 & 32 + & 368.7 & 0.5 & 9 & 44 & 43 + & 210.6 & 0.8 & 6 & 51 & 120 the stellar atmospheric parameters were determined following most of the steps outlined in @xcite and in paper i , so that the results of the abundance analyses of their sample and ours can be usefully combined .
the effective temperature ( @xmath22 ) was , for the majority of the stars , determined by fitting spectrophotometric observations of the star with model - atmosphere fluxes @xcite .
for this step , medium - resolution spectra were obtained with the wide field spectrograph ( wifes ; * ? ? ? * ) on the australian national university 2.3-m telescope at siding spring observatory during 2012 .
this is a double - beam spectrograph using a dichroic mirror to separate the blue and red regions .
the spectrograph covers the wavelength ranges 3000 - 6200 and 6000 - 9700 in the blue and red , respectively , with a resolution of 2 .
the observations , data reduction , and analysis were performed as described in section 4.1 of @xcite .
the reduced spectra were cross - correlated against a grid of marcs atmosphere models @xcite using the phyton program fitter , written by s.j .
the marcs models have parameters ranging in @xmath22 from 2500 k to 8000 k , in steps of 100 k from 2500 k to 4000 k , and in steps of 250 k from 4000 k to 8000 k. surface gravity ( @xmath23 ) values for the grid were between @xmath24 ( cgs ) and 5.5 ( cgs ) in steps of 0.5 dex , and metallicities between @xmath25 and @xmath26 in variable steps .
as the stars in this sample all have very low metallicities , @xmath1-enhanced models were used , with @xmath27}=+0.25 $ ] for @xmath28}\leq-0.5 $ ] and @xmath27}=+0.4 $ ] for @xmath29}<-1.5 $ ] . for two stars in the sample ( marked in table [ tab3 ] ) we did not have spectrophotometric observations
the effective temperatures for these stars were determined from broadband photometry , using the @xmath30 color index , as this is least affected by metallicity @xcite .
the @xmath31 and @xmath32 magnitudes for the stars are listed in table [ tab3 ] .
the 2mass @xmath32 magnitudes were converted to the johnson photometric system using the filter conversion @xmath33 = @xmath34 @xcite .
reddening values , @xmath35 , are adopted from @xcite ; values exceeding 0.1 mag were corrected according to @xcite .
these values were then converted to @xmath36 , using the relation from @xcite , @xmath37 .
the final de - reddened @xmath30 colors were thus found from the following equation : @xmath38 . to estimate the effective temperatures we used the calibration of @xcite , as this provides temperatures that are in good agreement with the scale used for the majority of our sample .
we determined temperatures using this method for as many stars in the sample as possible , in order to estimate the offset between the two temperature scales .
we found an average offset of @xmath39 k between the two temperature scales , and have corrected the temperatures determined from the @xmath30 colors accordingly ( @xmath40=@xmath41 ) .
the @xmath31 and @xmath42 photometry listed for he 0010@xmath133422 in table [ tab3 ] is almost certainly in error , as it results in a temperature @xmath43 k below what was found from the spectrophotometric observations . due to this large difference
, this star has been excluded from the determination of the offset between the two temperature scales .
surface gravity ( @xmath23 ) estimates for the stars were determined from the @xmath44 isochrones @xcite , assuming an age of 10 gyr @xcite and an @xmath1-element enhancement of @xmath27}=+0.3 $ ] ( the isochrones exists with @xmath27}=0.0 $ ] , @xmath27}=+0.3 $ ] and @xmath27}=+0.6 $ ] ) .
the isochrones extend in metallicity down to @xmath0}=-3.5 $ ] , so for the six stars in the sample with metallicities in the range @xmath45}\leq-3.5 $ ] , a linear extrapolation down to @xmath0}=-4.7 $ ] has been used to obtain the gravity estimate .
the average difference between the listed surface gravities where the actual @xmath0}$ ] have been used and the surface gravity obtained using the @xmath0}=-3.5 $ ] isochrone is small , on the order of 0.05 dex .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the @xmath22 vs. @xmath23 diagram for the program stars with isochrones for three different metallicities : @xmath0}=-1.9 $ ] , @xmath0}=-2.5 $ ] , and @xmath0}=-3.5 $ ] .
all isochrones have @xmath27}= + 0.3 $ ] and an age of 10 gyr .
the sample shows a mixture of dwarfs , subgiants , and giants . vs. @xmath23 diagram for the program stars ,
over - plotted with 10 gyr isochrones for three different metallicities : @xmath0}=-3.5 $ ] ( solid line ) , @xmath0}=-2.5 $ ] ( dotted line ) and @xmath0}=-1.9 $ ] ( dashed line ) .
all of the isochrones have @xmath27}= + 0.3 $ ] .
a representative error bar on the derived parameters is shown in the upper left .
[ fig1],width=336 ] for five of the warmer stars in the sample , he 0233@xmath130343 , he 0411@xmath133558 , he 0450@xmath134209 , he 1241@xmath132907 , and he 2239@xmath135019 , the isochrones returned two possible solutions for the gravity .
for these five stars we have tried to derive spectroscopic gravities and/or checked the isochrone gravities by fitting profiles of gravity - sensitive lines .
the gravity of stars can be determined spectroscopically by enforcing ionization equilibrium between lines formed by neutral atoms and lines formed by ions , e.g. , fe i and fe ii or ti i and ti ii , taking advantage of the fact that fe i and ti i lines are not significantly gravity sensitive , while the fe ii and ti ii lines are .
we performed this analysis for the stars where both fe i and fe ii or ti i and ti ii lines were detected .
a check of the gravity can also be performed by fitting the profiles of gravity - sensitive lines .
lines such as mg i and the ca ii h and k lines exhibit strong pressure - broadened wings in cool stars .
we performed spectral syntheses of these lines using model atmospheres with the two possible gravities , keeping all other parameters constant , in order to see which of the two possible gravities yields the best fit in the wings of these lines .
the result of these tests yielded subgiant gravities for he 0233@xmath130343 , he 0411@xmath133558 and he 2239@xmath135019 and dwarf gravities for he 0450@xmath134209 and he 1241@xmath132907 ( see table [ tab3 ] ) . the microturbulent velocity ( @xmath46 ) was computed in the usual way , by forcing the abundances from individual fe i lines to show no trend with reduced equivalent width , @xmath47 . for he
0233@xmath130343 , too few fe i line were present to determine the microturbulent velocity in this manner , so a fixed valued of @xmath48 km s@xmath15 was used for this star , following paper i. metallicities were determined from equivalent - width measurements of the fe i lines .
for a few stars we also detected a number of fe ii lines ; for these stars there is good agreement between the abundance derived from the fe ii lines and that from the fe i lines used for determining the temperature , gravity , and microturbulence .
the final stellar parameters and their estimated uncertainties are listed in table [ tab3 ] .
lcccccccccc & 15.48 & 0.095 & 1 & 0.017 & 12.34 & & 5400 & 3.1 & @xmath132.7 & 2.4 + & 12.69 & 0.880 & 2 & 0.040 & 10.65 & 1.89 & 5300 & 2.7 & @xmath132.5 & 1.3 + & 15.82 & 0.837 & 1 & 0.021 & 13.85 & 1.87 & 5400 & 3.0 & @xmath132.9 & 1.1 + & 16.01 & 0.523 & 1 & 0.011 & 14.18 & 1.75 & 5600 & 3.3 & @xmath133.0 & 1.1 + & 14.47 & 0.463 & 1 & 0.016 & 12.68 & 1.71 & 5500 & 3.2 & @xmath134.0 & 1.5 + & 15.43 & 0.437 & 1 & 0.025 & 14.06 & 1.26 & 6100 & 3.4 & @xmath134.7 & 2.0 + & 16.13 & 0.833 & 1 & 0.019 & 14.17 & 1.83 & 5400 & 3.2 & @xmath132.6 & 0.9 + & 12.96 & 0.382 & 1 & 0.011 & 11.58 & 1.31 & 6300 & 3.7 & @xmath132.8 & 3.4 + & & & & 0.107 & & & 5800 & 3.5 & @xmath133.0 & 1.6 + & 11.44 & 1.440 & 3 & 0.013 & 8.97 & 2.39 & 4800 & 1.6 & @xmath132.2 & 1.9 + & 12.35 & 1.100 & 3 & 0.021 & 11.21 & 1.04 & 5900 & 3.6 & @xmath132.3 & 1.2 + & & & & 0.009 & & & 6300 & 4.5 & @xmath133.1 & 1.2 + & & & & 0.054 & & & 6300 & 4.5 & @xmath133.9 & 1.6 + & 15.63 & 0.355 & 1 & 0.043 & 14.37 & 1.10 & 6650 & 4.3 & @xmath133.3 & 1.6 + & 16.34 & 0.493 & 1 & 0.043 & 14.70 & 1.48 & 5900 & 3.5 & @xmath133.4 & 1.8 + & & & & 0.071 & & & 6900 & 3.8 & @xmath133.0 & 1.8 + & 14.35 & 0.708 & 1 & 0.043 & 11.90 & 2.29 & 5000 & 1.9 & @xmath134.2 & 2.2 + & 13.69 & 0.687 & 1 & 0.110 & 11.41 & 1.94 & 5000 & 1.9 & @xmath132.7 & 1.5 + & & & & 0.060 & 9.85 & & 4800 & 1.5 & @xmath132.8 & 2.1 + & & & & 0.041 & & & 5100 & 2.3 & @xmath132.9 & 2.0 + & 16.10 & & & 0.013 & 13.85 & 2.17 & 5200 & 2.5 & @xmath132.8 & 1.0 + & 15.85 & 0.393 & 1 & 0.009 & 14.28 & 1.50 & 6100 & 3.5 & @xmath134.2 & 1.8 + & 11.73 & & & 0.032 & & & 4900 & 1.5 & @xmath133.7 & 2.2 + the elemental abundances were derived by synthesizing individual spectral lines and molecular bands .
all abundances are derived under the assumption of 1d and local thermodynamic equilibrium , and adopting the solar abundances from @xcite .
the 2011 version of moog @xcite was used for the synthesis ; this version of moog includes proper treatment of continuum scattering . for stars in the temperature range of our sample ,
the two main sources of opacity in stellar atmospheres are bound - free absorption from the negative hydrogen ion ( h@xmath49 ) and rayleigh scattering from neutral atomic hydrogen .
their individual contributions to the total opacity depends on temperature and metallicity ; at low temperature and low metallicity the contribution from rayleigh scattering is almost equal to the contribution from bound - free absorption .
so , when working with metal - poor stars it is especially important to model the scattering accurately to obtain the correct line intensities . to perform the synthesis we used the @xmath1-enhanced newodf grid of atlas9 atmosphere models @xcite , interpolated with software developed by c. allende prieto , to obtain the models matching the parameters of the stars ( e.g. , *
* ; * ? ? ?
the @xmath1-enhanced atlas9 models cover a range in @xmath22 , from 3500 k to 50000 k , @xmath23 , from 0.0 to 5.0 ( cgs ) , for metallicities , @xmath0}$ ] , in the range @xmath50 to @xmath510.5 and @xmath0=-4.0}$ ] . for the metallicity @xmath0 } = -3.5 $ ] , models exists with temperatures in the range 3500 k to 6500 k , and surface gravities ranging from 0.0 to 5.0 .
we used atomic data from the gaia / eso line list version 4 ( heiter et al . , in prep . ) for the analysis .
this list covers the lines between 4750 to 6850 and 8500 to 8950 . for lines not covered by the gaia / eso line list ,
atomic data from the vald database @xcite were adopted .
a number of the elements analyzed exhibit hyperfine splitting ( sc , mn , co , y , zr , la , pr , nd and eu ) . for those elements which only have lines in the region not covered by the gaia / eso line list , hyperfine splitting from @xcite was used .
the lines of li , ba , and pb have both hyperfine splitting and isotopic shifts . the lines of li and ba are included in the gaia / eso line list , while pb is not , so for this element data from @xcite was used .
carbon and nitrogen abundances ( or upper limits ) , and the isotopic ratios @xmath52c/@xmath53c , were obtained by synthesizing molecular bands , namely the 4300 ch g - band , the nh band at 3360 and the cn bands at 3890 and 4215 .
all molecular information is taken from @xcite and t. masseron ( priv .
dissociation energies of 3.47 ev , 3.42 ev , and 7.74 ev were used for the species ch , nh and cn , respectively . when possible , n abundances were determined from synthesis of the cn bands using the c abundances computed from the ch band as fixed input .
if no cn band was visible , the nitrogen abundance was derived from the nh band ( which falls in a region of the spectra with substantially lower s / n ) . for stars where abundances could be derived from both bands the resultant n abundances , derived from the nh and cn bands respectively ,
are compared in figure [ fign ] . for low n abundances ,
the results from the two bands agree well , while a discrepancy is seen at high n , with higher abundances being derived from the nh band compared to the cn band .
the reason for this discrepancy is not clear , but the physical parameters , such as line positions and gf values , are less well - established for the nh band compared to the cn band , which could account , at least in part , for it .
the carbon abundance is coupled to the oxygen abundance through the co molecule .
oxygen abundances or upper limits for the sample stars are derived from the 6300 line , but for the majority of our stars no reliable oxygen abundance could be obtained , so when deriving the carbon abundances we used a typical halo - star value of @xmath54}= + 0.4 $ ] for oxygen .
molecular @xmath53ch features were identified for 11 of the stars in our sample .
the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios were determined from the analysis of @xmath53ch features in the wavelength range from 4210 to 4235 .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the synthesis of the @xmath53ch line at 4230 in he 2208@xmath131239 for three different isotopic ratios .
the derived elemental abundances , along with propagated uncertainties arising from the effects of uncertainties of the stellar parameters , continuum placement , and line information , are listed in table [ tab4 ] for the `` normal '' metal - poor ( hereafter , nmp ) stars , table [ tab5 ] for the cemp-@xmath2 stars , table [ tab6 ] for the cemp-@xmath3 stars , and table [ tab7 ] for the cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars .
the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios , where available , are listed in table [ tab8 ] .
, width=336 ] ch line at 4230 in he 2208@xmath131239 for three different isotopic ratios ; 100% @xmath52ch ( blue ) , @xmath52c/@xmath53c = 79/21 ( red ) and @xmath52c/@xmath53c = 70/30 ( green ) .
[ fig2],width=336 ]
the abundance analysis yielded abundances or upper limits for 18 elements : li , c , n , na , mg , al , si , ca , sc , ti , cr , mn , fe , co , ni , sr , ba and eu , for all the stars in the sample , plus abundances or upper - limits of y , zr , la .
ce , pr , nd , sm , gd , dy , er and pb , for the cemp-@xmath3 , cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars in the sample .
lrrrrrrrr @xmath0 } $ ] & @xmath132.96 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.81 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.87 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.43 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.00 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.71 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.81 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath134.15 ( 0.20 ) + & & & & & & & & + a(li ) & @xmath511.46 ( 0.18)&@xmath551.44 & @xmath511.88 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath511.94 ( 0.17)&@xmath552.41 & @xmath510.62 ( 0.16)&@xmath550.44 & @xmath551.70 + & & & & & & & & + @xmath56 } $ ] & @xmath510.43 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath550.70 & @xmath552.00 & @xmath551.27 & @xmath552.00 & @xmath510.31 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath130.24 ( 0.28)&@xmath551.70 + @xmath57 } $ ] & @xmath510.57 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath551.30 & @xmath552.10 & @xmath551.70 & @xmath552.60 & @xmath511.89 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath510.88 ( 0.29)&@xmath552.70 + @xmath54 } $ ] & @xmath552.30 & @xmath552.30 & @xmath554.00 & @xmath553.30 & @xmath553.90 & @xmath510.90 ( 0.15)&@xmath551.10 & @xmath554.00 + @xmath58}$ ] & @xmath130.10 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.02 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath590.30 & @xmath130.33 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.87 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath511.00 ( 0.32 ) & @xmath510.14 ( 0.30)&@xmath590.30 + @xmath60}$ ] & @xmath510.29 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.24 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath510.11 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath510.32 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath510.18 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.28 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.41 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.45 ( 0.15 ) + @xmath61}$ ] & @xmath130.91 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.59 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath590.50 & @xmath130.57 ( 0.22)&@xmath590.60 & @xmath510.00 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath130.82 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath130.57 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath62}$ ] & @xmath510.74 ( 0.20 ) & & @xmath510.31 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.06 ( 0.18)&@xmath510.03 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.66 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.23 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.06 ( 0.15 ) + @xmath63}$ ] & @xmath510.26 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.22 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath510.12 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.60 ( 0.17)&@xmath510.21 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.49 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.17 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.23 ( 0.15 ) + @xmath64}$ ] & @xmath510.07 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.38 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath590.10 & @xmath510.12 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.34 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.08 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.13 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath510.32 ( 0.16 ) + @xmath65}$ ] & @xmath510.22 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.59 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath130.04 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.25 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.28 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.30 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.24 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.37 ( 0.17 ) + @xmath66 } $ ] & @xmath550.80 & @xmath551.00 & @xmath551.80 & @xmath551.30&@xmath551.60 & @xmath510.21 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath510.17 ( 0.23)&@xmath552.00 + @xmath67}$ ] & @xmath130.47 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath130.05 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath130.17 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath130.28 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.04 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath130.36 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath130.40 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.00 ( 0.17 ) + @xmath68}$ ] & @xmath131.02 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.62 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath590.20 & @xmath130.65 ( 0.22)&@xmath550.00 & @xmath130.70 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.45 ( 0.25)&@xmath590.10 + @xmath69}$ ] & @xmath510.47 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.16 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath551.00 & @xmath510.38 ( 0.21)&@xmath551.00 & @xmath130.11 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath130.06 ( 0.25)&@xmath551.00 + @xmath70}$ ] & @xmath510.68 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.10 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath510.17 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath130.06 ( 0.19)&@xmath510.16 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.00 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath130.03 ( 0.30 ) & @xmath510.24 ( 0.17 ) + @xmath71}$]&@xmath550.80 & @xmath550.60 & @xmath551.80 & @xmath551.50 & @xmath551.40 & @xmath510.19 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath510.36 ( 0.21)&@xmath552.00 + @xmath72}$ ] & @xmath511.00 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath130.54 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath590.90 & @xmath130.51 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.77 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.10 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.16 ( 0.22)&@xmath590.60 + @xmath73}$]&@xmath591.30 & @xmath130.95 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath740.00 & @xmath590.52 & @xmath590.30 & @xmath130.34 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath131.58 ( 0.23)&@xmath550.00 + @xmath75}$]&@xmath551.10 & @xmath551.50 & @xmath552.20 & @xmath552.00 & @xmath552.40 & @xmath510.47 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.20 ( 0.25)&@xmath552.50 + lrrrrrr @xmath0 } $ ] & @xmath132.93 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.98 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath134.68 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.02 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath134.15 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.68 ( 0.20 ) + & & & & & & + a(li ) & @xmath551.12 & @xmath511.27 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath511.77 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath512.00 ( 0.14)&@xmath550.80 & @xmath550.37 + & & & & & & + @xmath56 } $ ] & @xmath512.75 ( 0.29 ) & @xmath511.00 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath513.48 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.69 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath512.36 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.34(0.26 ) + @xmath57 } $ ] & @xmath511.90 ( 0.28 ) & @xmath551.00 & @xmath552.80 & @xmath550.62 & @xmath513.20 ( 0.37 ) & @xmath512.57 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath54 } $ ] & @xmath552.30 & @xmath552.90 & @xmath554.00 & @xmath552.50 & @xmath552.80 & @xmath551.70 + @xmath58}$]&@xmath761.00 & @xmath130.24 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath550.50 & @xmath130.04 ( 0.13 ) & @xmath510.19 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath510.46(0.30 ) + @xmath60}$ ] & @xmath510.64 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.25 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath510.59 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath510.79 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath510.42 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath511.20(0.23 ) + @xmath61}$ ] & @xmath510.46 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath130.38 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath550.03 & @xmath130.57 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.39 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath130.38 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath62}$ ] & & @xmath510.05 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.37 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath510.80 ( 0.15)&@xmath550.25 & + @xmath63}$ ] & @xmath510.49 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.10 ( 0.13 ) & @xmath510.34 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath510.50 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath510.00 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.20 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath64}$ ] & & @xmath510.00 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath550.70 & @xmath130.12 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath130.07 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.09 ( 0.25 ) + @xmath65}$ ] & @xmath510.71 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath510.11 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.18 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath510.23 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath510.35 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.26 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath66 } $ ] & @xmath510.67 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath551.20 & @xmath552.50 & @xmath550.80 & @xmath550.90 & @xmath510.30 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath67}$ ] & @xmath510.08 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath130.22 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath550.50 & @xmath130.14 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath130.49 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath130.45 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath68}$ ] & @xmath130.18 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath130.65 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath550.20 & @xmath130.60 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.79 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.96 ( 0.24 ) + @xmath69}$ ] & @xmath510.28 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath510.20 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath551.60 & @xmath510.30 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.28 ( 0.16 ) & @xmath510.30 ( 0.23 ) + @xmath70}$ ] & @xmath510.37 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.19 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath550.90 & @xmath510.18 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath130.12 ( 0.20)&@xmath130.04 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath71}$]&@xmath550.90 & @xmath551.20 & @xmath552.60 & @xmath550.80 & @xmath551.30 & @xmath550.70 + @xmath72}$ ] & @xmath510.25 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath130.30 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath510.32 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath130.30 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath131.08 ( 0.14 ) & @xmath130.85 ( 0.20 ) + @xmath73}$]&@xmath591.80 & @xmath590.50 & @xmath550.80 & @xmath131.27 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath130.50 ( 0.15 ) & @xmath130.90 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath75}$]&@xmath550.80 & @xmath551.50 & @xmath553.00 & @xmath551.50 & @xmath551.20 & @xmath550.50 + lrrrrr @xmath0 } $ ] & @xmath132.48 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.19 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.07 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath133.28 ( 0.20)&@xmath132.75 ( 0.20 ) + & & & & & + a(li ) & @xmath550.57 & @xmath550.26 & @xmath551.98 & @xmath552.00 & @xmath550.30 + & & & & & + @xmath56}$ ] & @xmath512.13 ( 0.29 ) & @xmath511.51 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath512.03 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath512.64 ( 0.20)&@xmath512.63 ( 0.32 ) + @xmath57}$ ] & @xmath510.87 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath510.78 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath512.00 ( 0.29 ) & @xmath512.90 ( 0.27)&@xmath511.04 ( 0.33 ) + @xmath54}$ ] & @xmath551.20 & @xmath510.69 ( 0.17 ) & @xmath553.50 & @xmath553.70 & @xmath551.70 + @xmath58}$]&@xmath761.20 & @xmath510.67 ( 0.30 ) & @xmath510.23 ( 0.22 ) & & @xmath761.60 + @xmath60}$ ] & @xmath510.78 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.43 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.53 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath130.03 ( 0.17)&@xmath510.87 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath61}$ ] & @xmath510.10 ( 0.21 ) & & @xmath130.78 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath590.42 & @xmath510.12 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath62}$ ] & & & @xmath510.00 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath130.03 ( 0.18 ) & + @xmath63}$ ] & @xmath510.40 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.23 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.70 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.16 ( 0.20)&@xmath510.43 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath64}$ ] & & & @xmath510.12 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.33 ( 0.21 ) & + @xmath65}$ ] & @xmath510.42 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.26 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.58 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.45 ( 0.20)&@xmath510.44(0.28 ) + @xmath66}$ ] & @xmath510.28 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath510.03 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath551.30 & @xmath551.20 & + @xmath67}$ ] & @xmath130.03 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.12 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.03 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath130.08 ( 0.18)&@xmath510.00 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath68}$ ] & @xmath130.38 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath130.63 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.73 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath130.14 ( 0.24)&@xmath130.63 ( 0.30 ) + @xmath69}$ ] & @xmath130.13 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath130.54 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath550.60 & @xmath510.90 ( 0.25)&@xmath130.02 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath70}$ ] & @xmath130.10 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath510.03 ( 0.28 ) & @xmath510.00 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.34 ( 0.17)&@xmath510.00 ( 0.34 ) + @xmath71}$]&@xmath550.08 & @xmath510.06 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath551.40 & @xmath551.60 & @xmath550.70 + @xmath72}$ ] & @xmath511.65 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.33 ( 0.18 ) & @xmath510.64 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath510.07 ( 0.24)&@xmath511.75 ( 0.27 ) + @xmath77}$ ] & @xmath511.99 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.33 ( 0.19 ) & & @xmath551.05 & @xmath512.13 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath78}$ ] & @xmath512.26 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.64 ( 0.20 ) & & @xmath551.70 & @xmath512.38 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath73}$ ] & @xmath511.52 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath510.46 ( 0.19 ) & @xmath511.21 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.80 ( 0.17)&@xmath511.80 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath79}$ ] & @xmath511.63 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath511.18 ( 0.20 ) & & & @xmath512.32 ( 0.28 ) + @xmath80}$ ] & @xmath511.50 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.89 ( 0.18 ) & & @xmath552.70 & @xmath512.35 ( 0.27 ) + @xmath81}$ ] & @xmath511.60 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.07 ( 0.20 ) & & & @xmath512.26 ( 0.27 ) + @xmath82}$ ] & @xmath510.36 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.30 ( 0.17 ) & & @xmath552.46 & @xmath511.05 ( 0.26 ) + @xmath83}$ ] & @xmath511.33 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath511.01 ( 0.24 ) & & & @xmath511.70 ( 0.31 ) + @xmath75}$ ] & @xmath510.78 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath550.62 & @xmath552.00 & @xmath552.50 & @xmath511.10 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath84}$ ] & @xmath511.10 ( 0.24 ) & & & & + @xmath85}$ ] & @xmath511.20 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.74 ( 0.21 ) & & & @xmath511.70 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath86}$ ] & & @xmath511.14 ( 0.21 ) & & & @xmath762.00 + @xmath87}$]&@xmath551.50 & @xmath511.64 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath553.00 & @xmath513.34 ( 0.23)&@xmath552.00 lrrrr @xmath0 } $ ] & @xmath132.78 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.26 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.58 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath132.88 ( 0.20 ) + & & & & + a(li ) & @xmath551.11 & @xmath551.49 & @xmath550.97 & @xmath550.77 + & & & & + @xmath56}$ ] & @xmath511.92 ( 0.31 ) & @xmath512.24 ( 0.29 ) & @xmath512.43 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath511.30 ( 0.29 ) + @xmath57}$ ] & @xmath512.60 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath511.44 ( 0.29 ) & @xmath511.48 ( 0.28 ) & @xmath511.95 ( 0.25 ) + @xmath54}$ ] & @xmath552.02 & @xmath551.90 & @xmath551.90 & @xmath551.40 + @xmath58}$ ] & @xmath511.00 ( 0.28 ) & @xmath760.70 & @xmath761.00 & + @xmath60}$ ] & @xmath510.34 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.44 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath511.08 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.59 ( 0.20 ) + @xmath61}$ ] & @xmath130.54 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath130.23 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.04 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.32 ( 0.18 ) + @xmath62}$ ] & & & & + @xmath63}$ ] & @xmath510.26 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.35 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.12 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.45 ( 0.19 ) + @xmath64}$ ] & @xmath510.45 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.25 ( 0.23 ) & & @xmath510.25 ( 0.19 ) + @xmath65}$ ] & @xmath510.59 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.50 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath510.43 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.70 ( 0.19 ) + @xmath66 } $ ] & @xmath510.73 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath510.38 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.73 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.54 ( 0.25 ) + @xmath67}$ ] & @xmath130.23 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath130.03 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath130.07 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath130.20 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath68}$ ] & @xmath130.71 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath130.37 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath130.47 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath130.83 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath69}$ ] & @xmath510.15 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath510.04 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath510.03 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath510.10 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath70}$ ] & @xmath510.01 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath510.14 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.26 ( 0.30 ) & @xmath130.10 ( 0.24 ) + @xmath71}$ ] & @xmath510.57 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.33 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath550.50 & @xmath510.36 ( 0.18 ) + @xmath72}$ ] & @xmath510.85 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath511.10 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.97 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath510.50 ( 0.17 ) + @xmath77 } $ ] & @xmath511.01 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.93 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.99 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath510.37 ( 0.20 ) + @xmath78}$ ] & @xmath511.08 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath511.10 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath511.06 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath510.84 ( 0.19 ) + @xmath73}$ ] & @xmath511.54 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath511.78 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath511.96 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath511.68 ( 0.23 ) + @xmath79}$ ] & @xmath512.21 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath512.33 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath512.51 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.96 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath80}$ ] & @xmath511.99 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath512.20 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath512.32 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath511.80 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath81}$ ] & @xmath512.00 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath512.24 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath512.48 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath511.77 ( 0.20 ) + @xmath82}$ ] & @xmath511.30 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.46 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath511.69 ( 0.20 ) & @xmath511.06 ( 0.20 ) + @xmath83}$ ] & @xmath511.97 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath512.09 ( 0.21 ) & @xmath512.18 ( 0.26 ) & @xmath511.76 ( 0.18 ) + @xmath75}$ ] & @xmath511.72 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.87 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.90 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath511.52 ( 0.21 ) + @xmath84}$ ] & & @xmath511.92 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath512.35 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.61 ( 0.22 ) + @xmath85}$ ] & & @xmath511.89 ( 0.23 ) & @xmath511.80 ( 0.24 ) & + @xmath86}$ ] & & @xmath512.78 ( 0.22 ) & @xmath512.64 ( 0.24 ) & @xmath511.97 ( 0.20 ) + @xmath87}$ ] & @xmath512.62 ( 0.27 ) & @xmath513.17 ( 0.29 ) & @xmath513.07 ( 0.25 ) & @xmath511.70 ( 0.36 ) lrc & 5 & cemp-@xmath4 + & 16 & cemp-@xmath3 + & 13 & cemp-@xmath2 + & @xmath884 & cemp-@xmath2 + & @xmath885 & cemp-@xmath2 + & 10 & cemp-@xmath5 + & 13 & cemp-@xmath3 + & 10 & cemp-@xmath4 + & 9 & cemp-@xmath3 + & 3 & cemp-@xmath2 + & 4 & cemp-@xmath5 + & 16 & cemp-@xmath3 + & 5 & cemp-@xmath2 + as many of our sample stars are carbon enhanced , resulting in blended lines , we have chosen to perform spectral synthesis to derive the abundances of individual elements , whereas abundances for the comparison sample of @xcite were derived mostly from equivalent - width measurements .
all other aspects of the analysis are the same for the two samples , thus , by combining them we have a sample of over 200 homogeneously analyzed metal - poor stars . as a demonstration
, we have derived abundances for he 0146@xmath131548 from the sample of @xcite .
these are listed in table [ tabcom ] along with the abundances listed in @xcite . as can be seen , the two sets of abundances derived for this star agree very well .
the combined sample includes examples of all the different stellar abundance patterns that are commonly found at very low metallicity , for both carbon - enhanced stars ( all four sub - classes are represented ) and non carbon - enhanced stars . with this variety , and
the fact that the combined sample includes some of the most metal - poor stars known , we are able to carry out a more detailed investigation of the signatures of our galaxy s early chemical evolution than previous possible .
lrr @xmath56}$ ] & @xmath510.84 & @xmath510.80 + @xmath58}$ ] & @xmath511.17 & @xmath511.15 + @xmath60}$ ] & @xmath510.87 & @xmath510.86 + @xmath61}$ ] & @xmath510.14 & @xmath510.10 + @xmath62}$ ] & @xmath510.50 & @xmath550.66 + @xmath63}$ ] & @xmath510.22 & @xmath510.19 + @xmath65}$ ] & @xmath510.17 & @xmath510.15 + @xmath67}$ ] & @xmath130.38 & @xmath130.39 + @xmath68}$ ] & @xmath130.59 & @xmath130.64 + @xmath69}$ ] & @xmath510.30 & + @xmath70}$ ] & @xmath510.05 & @xmath510.07 + @xmath72}$ ] & @xmath130.38 & @xmath130.34 + @xmath73}$ ] & @xmath130.71 & @xmath130.78 + @xcite did not present ba and eu abundances for all the stars in their sample .
however , abundances of these two elements are essential for the classification of cemp stars ( cemp-@xmath2 : @xmath73 } < 0 $ ] , cemp-@xmath3 : @xmath73 } > + 1 $ ] , @xmath89 } > + 0.5 $ ] , cemp-@xmath4 : @xmath75 } > + 1 $ ] , cemp-@xmath5 : @xmath90 } < + 0.5 $ ] ) , thus we have searched the literature for ba and eu abundances for the full sample of cemp stars from @xcite ; these additional abundances are listed in table [ tab9 ] .
the supplemental abundances are only used for classification of the cemp stars , and not included in the plots , as they have not been derived in the same homogeneous manner as the abundances presented here .
table [ tab9 ] also includes upper limits for ba in he 0107@xmath135240 , he 0557@xmath134840 , and he 1327@xmath132326 , as these all lie in the sparsely populated region with @xmath0}<-4.0 $ ] ; we include them in our plots .
the combined sample includes 143 nmp , 32 cemp-@xmath2 , 30 cemp-@xmath3 , 4 cemp-@xmath4 , and 4 cemp-@xmath5 stars .
lrc & @xmath130.74 & @xcite + & @xmath511.31 & @xcite + & @xmath510.99 & @xcite + & @xmath131.00 & @xcite + & @xmath130.45 & @xcite + & @xmath130.90 & @xcite + & @xmath511.45 & @xcite + & @xmath512.30 & @xcite + & @xmath511.10 & @xcite + & @xmath550.82 & @xcite + & @xmath550.03 & @xcite + & @xmath590.63 & @xcite + & @xmath551.46 & @xcite + & @xmath510.50 & @xcite + & @xmath511.64 & @xcite + & @xmath511.57 & @xcite + & @xmath511.80 & @xcite + & @xmath511.69 & @xcite + & @xmath510.20 & @xcite + & @xmath511.62 & @xcite + & @xmath511.84 & @xcite + & @xmath510.17 & @xcite + & @xmath511.46 & @xcite + & @xmath511.18 & @xcite + & @xmath550.87 & @xcite + & @xmath510.80 & @xcite + carbon and nitrogen are among the first elements to be synthesized in the universe following the big bang . yet
our understanding of the abundances of these two elements found in the most metal - poor stars of our galaxy is still limited .
it is recognized that the observed carbon and nitrogen abundances of a given star are subject to change as the star evolves past the main sequence and up the red giant branch .
material that has been c - depleted and n - enhanced in the lower layers of a stellar atmosphere is transported to the surface of the star via mixing , enhancing n at the expense of c at the surface of the star .
thus , if we require the abundances of these two elements at the time when the star was born , in order to better constrain its progenitor , we need to correct the abundances of c and n for these evolutionary effects .
@xcite have developed a method for correcting the c abundances in metal - poor stars according to the evolutionary state of the star , based on the stars stellar evolution code @xcite and thermohaline mixing as described in @xcite .
we have corrected the c abundances for the giant stars in our sample using this method ; for the @xcite sample we have used the corrections listed in @xcite , while corrections for our own sample can be seen in table [ tab10 ] ( only including the non - zero corrections ) . for the remainder of this work
we employ the corrected c abundances , unless stated otherwise .
note that no explicit correction is currently made for n. lccccc he 0054@xmath132542 & 2.69 & @xmath132.48 & @xmath512.13 & @xmath512.15 & @xmath510.87 + he 0440@xmath133426 & 1.56 & @xmath132.19 & @xmath511.51 & @xmath511.64 & @xmath510.78 + he 1310@xmath130536 & 1.85 & @xmath134.15 & @xmath512.36 & @xmath512.47 & @xmath513.20 + he 1429@xmath130347 & 1.92 & @xmath132.71 & @xmath510.31 & @xmath510.45 & @xmath511.89 + he 2159@xmath130551 & 1.46 & @xmath132.81 & @xmath130.24 & @xmath510.22 & @xmath510.88 + he 2208@xmath131239 & 2.32 & @xmath132.88 & @xmath511.30 & @xmath511.31 & @xmath511.95 + he 2238@xmath134131 & 2.53 & @xmath132.75 & @xmath512.63 & @xmath512.65 & @xmath511.04 + he 2331@xmath137155 & 1.54 & @xmath133.68 & @xmath511.34 & @xmath511.69 & @xmath512.57 many of the carbon - enhanced stars are also found to be enhanced in nitrogen .
however , the minority of vmp , emp , and ump stars have both elements detected , a deficiency that surely needs to be addressed in the near future .
only 79 of the 193 stars in the sample of @xcite have detections of both c and n. in our sample of 23 stars , we detect c and n simultaneously for as many as 14 stars , increasing the number of stars with c and n detections in the combined sample by about 20% . in the combined sample we have 104 stars with both c and n detections , plus a few with a detection of either c or n and an upper limit on the other .
roughly equal numbers of these are nmp and cemp stars .
figure [ fig3 ] shows the c and n abundances and the @xmath6}$ ] ratios of our combined sample of stars as a function of metallicity .
we have divided the stars into two groups dots indicate stars where @xmath6}>0 $ ] ( @xmath56}>\mathrm{[n / fe]}$ ] ) and triangles indicate stars where @xmath6}<0 $ ] ( @xmath56}<\mathrm{[n / fe]}$ ] ) . as we do not have the n abundance corrections corresponding to the c corrections mentioned above , this plot only includes dwarfs , subgiants , and early giants , for which the corrections in c and n will not alter the @xmath6}>0 $ ] or @xmath6}<0 $ ] status of the star . for the remainder of this paper
we refer to this subsample as the `` c / n stars '' . }
$ ] ratios for stars in this sample ( filled symbols ) and that of @xcite ( unfilled symbols ) .
circles represent stars with @xmath6}>0 $ ] ; triangles are stars with @xmath6}<0 $ ] .
symbols are color - coded according to black : `` normal '' metal - poor ( nmp ) stars , red : cemp-@xmath2 stars , green : cemp-@xmath3 stars , blue : cemp-@xmath4 stars , yellow : cemp-@xmath5 stars .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig3],width=336 ] } > 0 $ ] or @xmath6}<0 $ ] for the different types of metal - poor stars .
black : nmp stars , red : cemp-@xmath2 stars , green : cemp-@xmath3 stars , blue : cemp-@xmath4 stars , yellow : cemp-@xmath5 stars[fig4],width=336 ] figure [ fig4 ] shows the number of each type of metal - poor star with either @xmath6}>0 $ ] or @xmath6}<0 $ ] .
there are clearly more stars with @xmath6}>0 $ ] than with @xmath6}<0 $ ] . for the nmp stars the numbers are roughly equal , while the cemp-@xmath2 and especially the cemp-@xmath3 stars are of the @xmath6}>0 $ ] variety . from inspection of the bottom panel of figure [ fig3 ] ,
none of the cemp-@xmath2 stars with @xmath6}<0 $ ] are found with metallicities above @xmath0}>-3.4 $ ] ; all cemp-@xmath2 stars with @xmath6}<0 $ ] are at the extremely low - metallicity end .
examination of the abundance ratios for the remaining elements for these stars using this division between c- and n - dominated stars , plotted in figure [ fig5 ] , figure [ fig6 ] , figure [ fig7 ] , and figure [ fig8 ] , indicates that @xmath0}=-3.4 $ ] also serves as a dividing line for the na and mg abundances in cemp-@xmath2 stars . below this metallicity ,
stars with large over - abundances of these two elements appear , in contrast to the behavior above this metallicity .
two of the cemp-@xmath2 stars with @xmath6}<0 $ ] , he 1327@xmath132326 and he 2323@xmath130256 , show large enhancements in na , mg and sr , while the other two stars , he 1150@xmath130428 and he 1310@xmath130536 , both have @xmath60}\sim0.4 $ ] and subsolar @xmath72}$ ] .
for the remainder of the elements we see the well - known abundance patterns found at low metallicity in these plots moderate over - abundances of the @xmath1-elements and very low star - to - star scatter for both the @xmath1- and iron - peak elements , with a large scatter for the neutron - capture elements . }
$ ] , @xmath60}$ ] , and @xmath61}$ ] for the c / n stars .
color - coding of the stellar classes is as in figure [ fig3 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig5],width=336 ] } $ ] , @xmath63}$ ] , and @xmath65}$ ] for the c / n stars .
color - coding of the stellar classes is as in figure [ fig3 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig6],width=336 ] } $ ] , @xmath69}$ ] , and @xmath70}$ ] for the c / n stars .
color - coding of the stellar classes is as in figure [ fig3 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig7],width=336 ] } $ ] and @xmath73}$ ] for the c / n stars .
color - coding of the stellar classes is as in figure [ fig3 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig8],width=336 ] an additional sub - class of metal - poor stars has been defined for stars with @xmath57 } > + 0.5 $ ] and @xmath6 } < -0.5 $ ] , the so - called nitrogen - enhanced metal - poor ( nemp ) stars @xcite .
these stars are expected to be the result of mass transfer from an intermediate - mass agb star that has undergone hot bottom burning , and thereby produced large amounts of nitrogen .
very few of these stars are known to exist , so here we consider the six stars in our sample with @xmath6 } < 0 $ ] to see if they are possible nemp stars .
two of the stars , he 1310@xmath130536 and he 2331@xmath137155 , are cemp-@xmath2 stars , and two , he 1429@xmath130347 and he 2159@xmath130551 , are nmp stars .
none of these exhibits excesses of neutron - capture elements , as would be expected for the nemp stars , thus they can be excluded from this class .
this leaves he 0010@xmath133422 ( a cemp-@xmath4 star ) and he 2208@xmath131239 ( a cemp-@xmath5 star ) as nemp candidates .
the binary status of these two stars is not known , but future radial - velocity monitoring should be able to clarify if they are consistent with an nemp classification .
@xcite suggested the presence of two separate plateaus or `` bands '' in the distribution of c abundances , as a function of @xmath0}$ ] , for vmp and emp stars .
the c abundances for stars with metallicities @xmath0 } > -3 $ ] appeared to cluster around the solar carbon abundance ( @xmath91 . ] ) , while those with @xmath0 } < -3 $ ] ( including the lowest metallicity stars known ) cluster around a lower c abundance , @xmath92 .
these authors proposed that the two bands could be associated with differing astrophysical production sites for the c in these stars those in the higher band being the result of mass transfer of c from an asymptotic giant - branch ( agb ) companion ( i.e. , extrinsic enrichment ) , whereas those in the lower band being the result of c that is intrinsic to the star ( that is , the c was already present in the ism from which the star was born ) .
it is useful to note that @xcite only used dwarfs and turnoff stars in their study , stars where the c abundances are not expected to be altered due to evolutionary effects .
the recent paper by @xcite confirms the existence of the two carbon bands for a larger sample , including the stars from @xcite .
we consider this question again with our new sample .
figure [ fig9 ] shows the absolute carbon abundances , @xmath93 , for the stars in our new sample ( dots ) along with those of @xcite ( plusses ) , as a function of @xmath0}$ ] .
the top panel shows only the cemp stars , while the bottom panel shows both the cemp and nmp stars .
there does indeed appear to exist a difference in the c abundances for the lower metallicity and higher metallicity cemp stars , as suggested by @xcite .
our larger dataset exhibits a smoother transition between the two bands in the metallicity region @xmath0}\sim -3.4 $ ] to @xmath0 } \sim -3.2 $ ] . @xcite
identify four cemp-@xmath2 stars with c abundances on the high carbon band . in figure [ fig9 ]
it can be seen that our sample includes three cemp-@xmath2 stars with c abundances on the high band .
these three stars he 0100@xmath131622 ( @xmath73 } < -1.80 $ ] ) , he 2202@xmath134831 ( @xmath73 } = -1.28 $ ] ) and he 2356@xmath130410 ( @xmath73 } = -0.80 $ ] ) are all confirmed cemp-@xmath2 stars , hence they challenge the interpretation of the two bands as being solely due to extrinsic and intrinsic processes .
we note that the binary status of this handful of stars is not presently known , and would clearly be of great interest to constrain .
if the cemp-@xmath2 stars found on the high carbon band are indeed the result of mass transfer in a binary system , it will be difficult to explain how large amounts of carbon but no or very small amounts of @xmath3-process elements have been transferred from their agb companion .
we also see that cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars are found at both the high and the low levels of c enhancement
. it would be interesting to examine larger samples of these stars , in order to search for the possible dominance of either high or low carbon - abundance stars for either of these cemp sub - classes .
the large carbon enhancements found in the lowest metallicity stars is expected to be related to the formation of low - mass stars in the early universe .
it has been demonstrated that low - mass stars can form as a result of cooling of gas clouds via fine - structure lines of carbon and oxygen @xcite .
hence , the large c abundances found at the lowest metallicities in our sample support the formation of low - mass stars via this channel .
abundances for sample stars ( dots ) and stars from @xcite ( plusses ) .
the top panel shows only cemp stars , while all stars ( including non carbon - enhanced stars ) are shown in the bottom panel .
the two carbon bands are indicated by solid lines , and upper limits on individual c abundances are indicated by arrows .
symbols are color - coded according to black : `` normal '' metal - poor ( nmp ) stars , red : cemp-@xmath2 stars , green : cemp-@xmath3 stars , blue : cemp-@xmath4 stars , yellow : cemp-@xmath5 stars .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig9],width=336 ] when internal mixing occurs in stars , whether that mixing is due to convection driven by rapid rotation ( `` spinstars , '' see @xcite ) or convection in agb stars during their evolution @xcite , the carbon is transported from the core ( spinstars ) or from the surface ( agb stars ) to the h - burning shell where the cno cycle is active , the carbon is transformed into @xmath53c and @xmath94n .
these signatures should be detectable in the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratio of a star .
high @xmath52c/@xmath53c and @xmath6}$ ] ratios indicate only partial hydrogen burning by the cno cycle , while low @xmath52c/@xmath53c and @xmath6}$ ] ratios are a signature of more complete burning by the cno cycle @xcite .
@xcite calculated the predicted @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratio in the primordial ism from which the first low - mass stars formed , if the first - generation stars were dominated by spinstars .
they predict the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratio to be between 30 - 300 , whereas if the first stars were not dominated by spinstars , the ratio would be @xmath95 at @xmath0 } = -3.5 $ ] and as much as @xmath96 at @xmath0 } = -5.0 $ ] .
models of mixing and fallback sne events @xcite , suggested to occur in the early universe , also predicts low @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios , due to the mixing in the pre - supernova evolution stage between the he convective shell and h - rich envelope @xcite .
however , @xcite predict differences in the ratio due to the different physical conditions and timescales for the production of @xmath53c during the stellar evolution of spinstars or in the sn explosion of the mixing and fallback models . we have derived the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios for 11 of our stars , and lower limits for an additional two stars .
@xcite also investigated @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios in their sample of cemp-@xmath2 stars ( which , except for bd+44@xmath97493 and segue 1 - 7 , all belong to the @xcite sample ) , but they were able to derive isotopic ratios for only 5 of their 15 stars ; for the remaining they provided lower limits .
figure [ fig10 ] plots the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios , as a function of @xmath6}$ ] ( uncorrected c abundances ) , for the cemp stars in our sample and those of @xcite . in this plot
, dots represent stars with @xmath98 in which some internal cno cycle processing might have changed the initial @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios , and squares represent stars with @xmath99 stars , which should have preserved their initial @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios .
we find low ( @xmath100 ) @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios for all of our cemp-@xmath2 stars , consistent with the equilibrium value for cno - cycle processed material .
this shows that the material from which these stars formed has undergone mixing , whether in spinstars or in some pre - supernova evolution .
the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios found in the cemp-@xmath3 stars of our sample are generally higher ( @xmath101 ) .
this value is low enough to be a signature of h - burning via the cno cycle , which is also expected if the carbon excess found in cemp-@xmath3 stars are transferred from an agb companion , where multiple dredge up events mix the material in the star .
however , according to @xcite , current agb models do not include sufficient mixing to replicate the low @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios found in cemp-@xmath3 stars .
c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios , as a function of @xmath6}$ ] , for cemp stars in the combined sample and from @xcite .
the squares represent stars with @xmath99 ; dots represent stars with @xmath102 .
filled symbols are from the combined sample ; open symbols are from @xcite .
the color - coding of the symbols is as in figure [ fig3 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of the panel .
[ fig10],width=336 ] paper i explored the lithium abundances detected in the ump cemp-@xmath2 stars presented there , showing that all of these have li abundances below the plateau found for non carbon - enhanced metal - poor dwarfs at @xmath103 , the so - called spite plateau @xcite .
this result supplements a similar finding by @xcite , and is consistent with the possible depletion of li by the progenitors of cemp-@xmath2 stars suggested by @xcite . in this model ,
the first , presumably massive , stars that formed in the universe are believed to have destroyed all of their li .
the observed li abundances of the emp and ump stars are expected to be the result of the mixing of the li - free material ejected from the first stars with the unprocessed ism having a li abundance generated by big bang nucleosynthesis . in this sense the lithium abundances of metal - poor main - sequence and subgiant stars
can also be used to estimate the degree to which the material from the source star has been diluted . in this paper
we present three additional cemp-@xmath2 stars , he 0100@xmath131622 with @xmath104 , he 0440@xmath131049 with @xmath105 , and he 2331@xmath137155 with @xmath106 . the latter star is a giant with @xmath107 , so this star has most likely internally depleted its initial lithium .
the one star , he 0440@xmath131049 , with a higher li abundance , close to the spite plateau value also has the lowest carbon - abundance ratio among these stars ( @xmath56 } = + 0.69 $ ] ) .
we have also examined the li abundances for the cemp-@xmath3 , cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars in our new sample , but only upper limits could be derived for these .
figure [ fig11 ] shows the li abundances and upper limits detected for all the dwarf and subgiants in our sample , including those presented in paper i , as function of luminosity ( @xcite did not present li abundances for their stars ) .
the additional cemp-@xmath2 stars follow the result from paper i and @xcite that all cemp-@xmath2 stars exhibit some level of li depletion with respect to the spite plateau . and upper limits , indicated by arrows , as a function of luminosity , for the dwarf and subgiant cemp stars in our sample .
the spite plateau lithium abundance ( @xmath108 ) is indicated with a dashed line .
the color - coding of the symbols is as in figure [ fig3 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the lower right of the panel .
[ fig11],width=336 ] the strontium and barium abundances for vmp stars have received a great deal of attention over the past few years , in part because these two species are often the only neutron - capture elements for which abundances can be measured in the most metal - poor stars , making these two elements our only clue to the nature of neutron - capture processes at the earliest times in our galaxy @xcite .
we have obtained detections or strong upper limits for sr and ba for all the stars in our sample , listed in table [ tab4 ] , table [ tab5 ] , table [ tab6 ] and table [ tab7 ] .
figure [ fig12 ] and figure [ fig13 ] shows the absolute sr and ba abundances as a function of @xmath0}$ ] .
figure [ fig12 ] shows only the cemp stars , while figure [ fig13 ] shows all of the stars in our combined sample . }
$ ] , for the cemp stars .
the suggested @xmath109 floor is indicated by the solid line .
the symbols and color - coding are as in figure [ fig9 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel .
[ fig12],width=336 ] } $ ] , for all of the stars in our combined sample .
the symbols and color - coding are as in figure [ fig9 ] .
an approximate error bar for the sample stars is shown in the upper left of each panel.[fig13],width=336 ] inspection of figure [ fig12 ] and figure [ fig13 ] indicates a clear grouping of the different classes of stars considered in our study .
recall that @xmath73}$ ] is used to differentiate the cemp-@xmath2 stars from the cemp-@xmath3 and cemp-@xmath5 stars .
the nmp ( non carbon - enhanced stars ) exhibit a wide range of ba abundances , from @xmath110 to @xmath111 , while all the cemp-@xmath2 stars for which we have ba detections exhibit ba abundances of @xmath112 , independent of metallicity ( most clearly seen when plotting only the cemp stars , figure [ fig12 ] ) . in contrast , the behavior of the sr abundances for stars in our sample is substantially different .
the individual classes of the stars in our sample are mixed together in a band showing decreasing @xmath113 with decreasing @xmath0}$ ] , but with a possible change in the trend at the lowest metallicity ( around @xmath0 } \sim -4.2 $ ] ) .
we emphasize that the area below @xmath0 = -4}$ ] is only sparsely populated , with most stars only having an upper limit on sr and ba .
the current data certainly suggest the presence of a floor in ba at extremely low metallicity , but not for sr ; more detections of both species are strongly desired . in the universe today , ba is primarily produced by the main @xmath3-process in lower - mass agb stars @xcite , but as this process was not operating in the early universe , the ba found in the cemp-@xmath2 stars must have some alternative origin .
it was shown by @xcite that spinstars can produce some amount of slow neutron - capture elements such as sr and ba via the `` weak '' @xmath3-process , provided some fe seeds are available .
it is possible that these elements can also be produced by the mixing and fallback models , by ejection of a tiny fraction of the heavy elements created in the explosion @xcite .
recently , @xcite found four cemp-@xmath2 stars with clear @xmath4-process - element abundance patterns , confirming the early onset of the rapid neutron - capture process in the galaxy .
these authors also stress the need for fe seeds for the weak @xmath3-process to operate efficiently in spinstars , meaning it will not occur in a completely metal - free star .
the peculiar abundance patterns of the cemp-@xmath3 stars , showing large enhancements in carbon , nitrogen , and slow neutron - capture elements , are believed to be the result of mass transfer from an agb companion in a binary system with the presently - observed low - mass metal - poor star .
indeed , radial - velocity monitoring of cemp-@xmath3 stars are consistent with essentially all of these stars belonging to binary systems @xcite .
thus , the abundances observed in cemp-@xmath3 stars offer us a unique opportunity to constrain the properties of very metal - poor agb stars . in the above division of stars into those with either @xmath6}>0 $ ] or @xmath6}<0 $ ]
, we see that the great majority of the cemp-@xmath3 stars have @xmath6}>0 $ ] . to further investigate the properties of the agb stars that created the elemental over - abundances detected in cemp-@xmath3 stars , figure [ fig14 ] shows the observed elemental - abundance patterns of two cemp-@xmath3 stars
one having @xmath6}>0 $ ] and one with @xmath6}<0 $ ] along with the predicted yields from metal - poor ( @xmath114 ) agb models of three different masses ( 1.3m@xmath115 , 1.5m@xmath115 , and 2.0m@xmath115 ) , taken from the f.r.u.i.t.y database @xcite .
none of the models reproduce the large amounts of carbon and nitrogen detected in these stars , and none of the models have @xmath6}<0 $ ] .
the heavy neutron - capture elements for the cemp-@xmath3 star with @xmath6}>0 $ ] ( ) are well - fit by the m=1.5m@xmath115 model , but none of the models produce sufficient amounts of the light neutron - capture elements ( sr , y , and zr ) to match this star .
the star with @xmath6}<0 $ ] ( ) is also not well - fit by any of the models , but it does exhibit a general lower enhancement in @xmath3-process elements than the @xmath6}>0 $ ] star , pointing toward a lower mass agb star as the progenitor of .
figure [ fig15 ] shows the observed elemental - abundance patterns of the two cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars in our sample along with yields from the same metal - poor agb stars . for the cemp-@xmath4 stars ( left panels )
none of the agb models reproduce the observed c and n abundances , and while the most massive agb model does reproduce some of the observed abundances for the n - capture elements in he 0010@xmath133422 , none of the models are a good fit for the abundances observed in he 0448@xmath134806 . considering the cemp-@xmath5 stars ( right panels ) ,
the two most massive agb models fit the observed c abundance for he 2208@xmath131239 and also some of the n - capture element abundances observed in this star . for the other cemp-@xmath5 star
, only the abundances for sr , y , and zr can be reproduced by an agb model .
it should also be noted that the material transferred from the agb star and onto the presently - observed cemp star is expected to be mixed with the original stellar material via thermohaline mixing @xcite .
the amount of dilution for the transferred material is not presently well - constrained , hence we have not included it in the comparison between observed abundances and agb yields .
below we summarize and discuss the abundance signatures found for the cemp stars in our sample , and what can be learned about the different progenitors that are currently suggested to account for the known sub - classes of cemp stars .
however , one result which is consistently found in all abundance analysis of very metal - poor stars , both carbon - enhanced and non - carbon - enhanced ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and which we confirm with our sample , is the small over - abundance detected for the @xmath1-elements ( @xmath116 } > \sim + 0.35 $ ] ) and the very low star - to - star scatter for both the @xmath1-elements ( @xmath117 dex ) and the iron - peak elements ( @xmath118 dex ) . the progenitors for the cemp - no stars are thought to be either the massive fast - rotating stars ( spinstars ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , the proposed mixing and fallback supernovae @xcite , or possibly contributions from both .
both models explain well the observed large over - abundances of carbon and nitrogen . in the spinstar scenario , a star that exhibits @xmath6 } > 0 $ ] is the result of incomplete hydrogen burning via the cno cycle , followed by mild mixing , whereas a star with @xmath6 } < 0 $ ] is the sign of more complete hydrogen burning @xcite .
other abundance signatures detected in some cemp-@xmath2 stars , such as low @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios , which we find in all the cemp-@xmath2 stars where we could measure this ratio , and high na , mg and al abundances , as detected in two of the cemp-@xmath2 stars with @xmath6 } < 0 $ ] , can also be explained , according to @xcite , as the result of more mixing and processing of material in the spinstar .
@xcite have used `` profile fitting '' to show that the yields from mixing and fallback sne also well - fit the observed abundance patterns of cemp-@xmath2 stars . with a range of explosion energies and mass cuts , and by including mixing in some of the the models , the authors fit the abundance profiles of 12 cemp-@xmath2 stars . @xcite
also point out that the mixing and fallback sn model fits all the observed elements up to mass number @xmath119 , including the @xmath1-elements and the iron - peak elements , while the spinstar models require a complementary sn contribution to create these elements in the appropiate proportion . in our combined sample of 30 cemp-@xmath2 stars ,
we observe stars with both @xmath6 } > 0 $ ] and @xmath6 } < 0 $ ] , but stars with @xmath6 } < 0 $ ] are only found at extremely low metallicity , @xmath0 } < -3.4 $ ] , a metallicity below which the cemp-@xmath2 stars with large enhancements in na , mg and al also are found ; above this metallicity the abundance spread is smaller .
this indicates that the large degrees of internal mixing and processing required to produce the abundance pattern seen in stars such as he 1327@xmath132326 @xcite and he 2323@xmath130256 @xcite was only operating at the very earliest times .
our data also supports the claim of @xcite and @xcite for the presence of two carbon `` bands '' that comprise the distribution of the absolute carbon abundances for cemp stars , although with a smoother transition between the bands than was found by these authors .
the majority of the cemp-@xmath2 stars have carbon abundances falling on the lower band ( @xmath120 ) , but a few with metalicities above @xmath0 } > -3.0 $ ] have carbon abundances in the higher band ( @xmath91 ) , indicating a different origin for the carbon found in these three stars as opposed to those with carbon abundances in the lower band .
we have inspected the @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotope ratios for the cemp stars in our sample , and find low @xmath52c/@xmath53c ratios for the cemp-@xmath2 stars we observed ; again a signature of mixing in the progenitor stars .
as noted above , both the spinstar models and the mixing and fallback models produce small @xmath52c/@xmath53c ratios , but so far no values for expected @xmath52c/@xmath53c ratios has been published for the sne models , making a comparison difficult .
finally , we detect a `` floor '' in the absolute ba abundances of cemp-@xmath2 stars , at an abundance level @xmath121 .
this plateau only exists for the cemp-@xmath2 stars , and must as such be an unique signature for the progenitors of these stars .
as mentioned above , both the spinstar and the mixing and fallback models can produce some amount of neutron - capture elements .
for the mixing and fallback models no yields have yet been published . in any case , the spinstars require fe seeds , hence some prior sne pollution is needed .
@xcite asked the question if _ any _ stars , no matter at what low metallicity , completely lack neutron - capture elements .
the cemp-@xmath2 stars are thought to be among the first low - mass stars to have formed , and although not all have detected neutron - capture elements , the discovery of a floor for the absolute ba abundance of cemp-@xmath2 stars at extremely low metallicity supports the interpretation that some mechanism producing neutron - capture elements was present very early in the galaxy .
@xcite suggested that , in order to distinguish between spinstars and the mixing and fallback sne for cemp-@xmath2 stars , one needs to investigate the abundances in these stars for elements that are produced in the deeper layers of the progenitor stars , such as si and ca .
for our sample , the ca abundances follow the general @xmath1-element trends of vmp halo stars , and only a few of our stars have detections for si .
more predicted elemental yields , over the full range of elements both light and heavy , along with predicted @xmath52c/@xmath53c ratios for both sets of progenitor models , and additional cemp-@xmath2 stars with measured si abundances , are required to resolve this issue .
the origin of the cemp-@xmath3 stars has for some time been ascribed to mass transfer in a binary system from a now extinct agb star , however there are still abundance signatures found in cemp-@xmath3 stars which the agb models have difficulties in explaining . for the 32 cemp-@xmath3 stars in our combined sample , we find that the great majority exhibit larger c - enhancements than n - enhancements , i.e. , @xmath6}>0 $ ]
. however , we do find a few cemp-@xmath3 stars with @xmath6}<0 $ ] , suggesting a higher degree of h - burning via the cno cycle has occurred in the agb companion in such cases .
we also find higher @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios for the cemp-@xmath3 stars in this sample than found for the cemp-@xmath2 stars .
however , the observed ratios are sufficiently low to require extensive mixing , which is also expected in an agb star .
nevertheless , the observed @xmath52c/@xmath53c ratios for cemp-@xmath3 stars are not reproduced by the agb models @xcite .
the cemp-@xmath3 stars in our sample have carbon abundances that place them on the higher of the two carbon bands of @xcite , shown in figure [ fig9 ] .
thus , there appears to be a maximum carbon abundance attained for the cemp-@xmath3 stars , which provides a constraint on the efficiency of the mass transfer and/or the production of c in agb stars at very low metallicity .
small numbers of cemp-@xmath5 , and even fewer cemp-@xmath4 stars , are known , but we have identified two of each class in our sample . the first cemp-@xmath4 star to be found was cs 22892 - 052 @xcite .
this star is both classified as an @xmath4-ii star } > + 1.0 $ ] and @xmath89 } < 0.0 $ ] @xcite ] , and a cemp-@xmath4 star , and has an abundance pattern for the heavy @xmath4-process elements that well - fits the scaled solar system @xmath4-process abundance pattern .
it is not known with certainty what astrophysical site produces the carbon over - abundances for cemp-@xmath4 stars , but radial - velocity monitoring of cs 22892 - 052 shows that this star is unlikely to be in a binary system @xcite , suggesting that the carbon enhancements seen for cemp-@xmath4 stars are not the result of mass transfer in a binary system , but , more likely ( as in the case of the cemp-@xmath2 stars ) , that they were born from an ism that was previously polluted with carbon . for cemp-@xmath5 stars , which exhibit contributions from both the @xmath4- and @xmath3-process , it has been proposed that they were born with their @xmath4-process - element abundances , and then gain their carbon and @xmath3-process - element abundances via mass transfer in a binary system @xcite .
recently , it has also been suggested that these stars could be the result of the @xmath122-process , a process that is intermediate between the @xmath4- and the @xmath3-process , and thought to occur in high - mass `` super - agb '' stars @xcite .
the general abundance patterns we detect in the two cemp-@xmath4 and two cemp-@xmath5 stars in our sample follow those of the other cemp stars . however , we find both sub - classes present on both the high and the low carbon - abundance bands shown in figure [ fig9 ] .
we also find @xmath52c/@xmath53c isotopic ratios in these stars that match both what is found for the cemp-@xmath3 stars and for the cemp-@xmath2 stars .
larger samples of both cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars with available high - resolution , high - s / n spectra are clearly needed to obtain a more secure picture of the likely progenitor(s ) of these objects .
we have shown that one of the cemp-@xmath4 stars and one of the cemp-@xmath5 stars may be classified as nemp stars ; confirmation of their binary - pollution origin awaits future radial - velocity monitoring .
we require still larger samples of the variety of low - metallicity stars presented in this paper to distinguish between the abundance patterns of stars representing the general trends and those that are just peculiar outliers .
high - resolution spectroscopic follow - up of several large surveys , such as skymapper @xcite , topos @xcite , based on stars selected by sdss / segue @xcite ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) , the cemp - star searches from the hk survey , the he s , and the rave survey @xcite described by ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and in preparation ) , and stars selected from lamost @xcite have increased in recent years , and need to be expanded further .
these surveys will soon provide more examples of cemp-@xmath4 and cemp-@xmath5 stars , for which our current samples are very limited .
they will also enlarge the numbers of known cemp-@xmath3 and cemp-@xmath2 sub - classes of carbon - enhanced stars . with detailed and homogeneous analyses of these stars
, we can look forward to detecting the elemental abundance signatures that constrain the nature and sites of the nucleosynthesis events that first enriched the milky way .
this work was supported by sonderforschungsbereich sfb 881 `` the milky way system '' ( subproject a4 ) of the german research foundation ( dfg ) .
t.c.b . and
v.p.m acknowledges partial support for this work from grants phy 08 - 22648 ; physics frontier center / joint institute or nuclear astrophysics ( jina ) , and phy 14 - 30152 ; physics frontier center / jina center for the evolution of the elements ( jina - cee ) , awarded by the us national science foundation .
c.j.h.was supported by a research grant ( vkr023371 ) from villum fondation and by sonderforschungsbereich sfb 881 `` the milky way system '' ( subproject a5 ) of the german research foundation ( dfg ) .
a.f . is supported by nsf career grant ast-1255160 .
, j.e.n . , and d.y .
acknowledge support from the australian research council ( grants dp0342613 , dp0663562 and fl110100012 ) for studies of the galaxy s most metal - poor stars .
furthermore , we thank the referee for helpful comments . | we present a high - resolution elemental - abundance analysis for a sample of 23 very metal - poor ( vmp ; @xmath0 } < -2.0 $ ] ) stars , 12 of which are extremely metal - poor ( emp ; @xmath0 } < -3.0 $ ] ) , and 4 of which are ultra metal - poor ( ump ; @xmath0 } < -4.0 $ ] ) . these stars were targeted to explore differences in the abundance ratios for elements that constrain the possible astrophysical sites of element production , including li , c , n , o , the @xmath1-elements , the iron - peak elements , and a number of neutron - capture elements .
this sample substantially increases the number of known carbon - enhanced metal - poor ( cemp ) and nitrogen - enhanced metal - poor ( nemp ) stars our program stars include eight that are considered `` normal '' metal - poor stars , six cemp-@xmath2 stars , five cemp-@xmath3 stars , two cemp-@xmath4 stars , and two cemp-@xmath5 stars .
one of the cemp-@xmath4 stars and one of the cemp-@xmath5 stars are possible nemp stars .
we detect lithium for three of the six cemp-@xmath2 stars , all of which are li - depleted with respect to the spite plateau .
the majority of the cemp stars have @xmath6}>0 $ ] .
the stars with @xmath6}<0 $ ] suggest a larger degree of mixing ; the few cemp-@xmath2 stars that exhibit this signature are only found at @xmath0}<-3.4 $ ] , a metallicity below which we also find the cemp-@xmath2 stars with large enhancements in na , mg , and al .
we confirm the existence of two plateaus in the absolute carbon abundances of cemp stars , as suggested by spite et al .
we also present evidence for a `` floor '' in the absolute ba abundances of cemp-@xmath2 stars at @xmath7 . |
because they are directly associated with the mass distribution of the universe , gravitational lensing effects are powerful probes of spatial structures of the dark matter .
strong lensing phenomena , such as multiple images of background quasars and giant arcs , have been used to constrain inner mass profiles of lensing galaxies and clusters of galaxies ( e.g. , gavazzi et al .
2003 ; bartelmann & meneghetti 2004 ; ma 2003 ; zhang 2004 ) .
weak lensing effects , on the other hand , enable us to study mass distributions of clusters of galaxies out to large radii ( e.g. , bartelmann & schneider 2001 ) .
cosmic shears , coherent shape distortions of background galaxies induced by large - scale structures in the universe , provide us a promising means to map out the dark matter distribution of the universe ( e.g. , tereno et al . 2005 ; van waerbeke 2005 ) . of many important studies on lensing effects ,
the aspects of weak lensing cluster surveys attract more and more attention ( e.g. , reblinsky & bartelmann 1999 ; white et al .
2002 ; padmanabhan et al .
2003 ; hamana et al .
2004 ; haiman et al .
clusters of galaxies are the largest virialized structures in the present universe .
their formation and evolution are sensitive to cosmologies , and therefore can be used to constrain different cosmological parameters , such as @xmath3 , @xmath4 and the equation of state of dark energy , where @xmath3 is the rms of the extrapolated linear density fluctuation smoothed over @xmath5 , and @xmath4 is the present matter density in units of the critical density of the universe ( e.g. , bahcall & bode 2003 ; fan & chiueh 2001 ; fan & wu 2003 ; haiman et al . 2001 ) .
there are different ways finding clusters .
the optical identification based on the concentration of galaxies suffers severe projection effects .
x - ray and sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) effect are associated with the intracluster gas , and have been used extensively in cluster studies ( e.g. , rosati et al . 2002 ; carlstrom et al .
2002 ) . however , most of the theoretical studies concern the abundance of clusters in terms of their masses ( e.g. , press & schechter 1974 ; sheth & tormen 1999 ; jenkins et al . 2001 ) , therefore it is crucial to get reliable relations between different survey observables and clusters mass .
the properties of intracluster gas are affected significantly by gas physics , which we have not fully understood yet .
thus there are large uncertainties in relating x - ray and sz effect with the total mass of a cluster .
on the other hand , lensing effects of a cluster are determined fully by its mass distribution , and therefore clean mass - selected cluster samples are expected from weak lensing cluster surveys . however , weak lensing surveys have their own complications .
lensing effects are associated with the mass distribution between sources and observers , and thus the lensing signal of a cluster can be contaminated by other structures along the line of sight .
the intrinsic ellipticities of source galaxies can pollute the lensing map and lower the efficiency of cluster detections considerably . besides and more intrinsically , clusters themselves generally have complex mass distributions , and their lensing effects can be affected by different factors in addition to the total mass .
therefore for extracting cosmological information from a sample of lensing - selected clusters , three main theoretical issues need to be carefully studied .
firstly the lensing effects from clusters must be understood thoroughly .
secondly the significance of projection effects along the line of sights should be estimated .
thirdly the noise due to the intrinsic asphericity of source galaxies should be treated properly .
it is important to realize that the existence of noise can affect the detection of clusters considerably .
numerical studies ( hamana et al . 2004 ; white et al .
2002 ) showed that the presence of noise reduces the efficiency of cluster detection significantly .
van waerbeke ( 2000 ) investigated the properties of noise induced by the intrinsic ellipticities of source galaxies .
he found that in the weak lensing regime , the lensing signal and the noise are largely uncorrelated if the smoothed convergence @xmath0 is considered .
furthermore , to a very good approximation , the noise can be described as a two - dimensional gaussian random field with the noise correlation introduced only through smoothing procedures .
then the technique of bardeen et al .
( bardeen et al . 1986 ) can be used to calculate the number of peaks resulted purely from the noise .
this provides us a possible way to estimate the contamination of noise on the abundance of lensing - detected clusters .
the presence of noise also affects the height of peaks from real clusters . with numerical simulations , hamana et al .
( 2004 ) tried to correct this effect empirically . in our future work
, we will study the noise in great detail with the effort to establish a model to describe its effects on weak lensing cluster surveys . with the hope that this is achievable , we address in this paper the first two issues with the emphasis on the effects of the complex mass distribution of clusters themselves . even for isolated clusters without any projection effect and without any noise ,
their lensing effects can not be fully determined by their mass . thus lensing - selected clusters
can not be truly mass - selected .
hamana et al .
( 2004 ) adopted the spherical navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) ( navarro et al .
1996 , 1997 ) density profile for a cluster to relate its smoothed peak @xmath0 value with its total mass . given a detection limit on @xmath0
, they then obtained an ideal mass selection function with the redshift - dependent lower limit derived from the limit of @xmath0 .
the essence of their model is still that there is a one - to - one correspondence between the peak @xmath0 of a cluster ( at a given redshift ) and its total mass .
however , the complicated mass distribution of a cluster can make its lensing effect much more complex than that predicted solely by its total mass . in this paper
, we compare the peak @xmath0 values of clusters from numerical simulations with the results by modeling the dark matter halos of clusters as isolated and spherical ones .
large differences in @xmath0 exist for those clusters with the same expected @xmath0 from the nfw - profile analysis .
our investigation further finds that the triaxiality of the mass distribution of clusters and large substructures in them contribute to this dispersion significantly .
the paper is organized as follows . in 2 ,
we describe the lensing simulations and the cluster identification scheme from lensing convergence @xmath0-map . in 3 , we present the results of our analyses .
summary and discussion are included in 4 .
in this paper , we consider the concordance cosmological model with @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 , where @xmath4 and @xmath10 are the present matter density and the energy density of the cosmological constant in units of the critical density of the universe , @xmath11 is the shape parameter of the spectrum of the linear density fluctuations , and @xmath3 is the rms of the extrapolated linear density perturbation smoothed over @xmath5 with @xmath12 being the present hubble constant in units of @xmath13 .
the simulations we use ( jing & suto 1998 ) have the box size of @xmath14 , and @xmath15 particles . the mass of each particle is @xmath16 .
the softening length is @xmath17 .
a typical cluster has a mass of @xmath18 and a size of @xmath19 , thus both the mass resolution and the force resolution are good enough for our studies .
there are three simulation runs with different realizations of the initial conditions . for each simulation
, it evolves from redshift @xmath20 to @xmath21 with @xmath22 time steps equally spaced in terms of the cosmological scale factor .
there are total @xmath23 outputs with @xmath24 of them between @xmath25 and @xmath21 .
dark matter halos are identified with the fof algorithm with the linking length @xmath26 in units of the average separation of particles . in this paper , we focus on the weak lensing regime . in this limit , the shear @xmath27 can be directly obtained from image distortions through @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the ellipticity defined in the complex plane and @xmath30 and @xmath31 stand for image and source , respectively . because both the convergence @xmath0 and the shear @xmath27 are determined by the lensing potential , @xmath0 can be estimated from @xmath27 ( e.g. , kaiser 1998 )
. then we have @xmath32 where @xmath0 is the true lensing convergence , and @xmath33 is the noise part associated with the intrinsic ellipticity of source galaxies @xmath34 ( e.g. , van waerbeke 2000 ) . detailed analysis by van waerbeke ( 2000 ) shows that for the suitably smoothed @xmath35 , the lensing signal and the noise are uncorrelated in the weak lensing limit , and the noise can be well approximated by a two - dimensional gaussian field . in his analysis ,
van waerbeke ignored the spatial clustering and the correlation of intrinsic ellipticities of source galaxies on @xmath36 scales .
therefore the smoothed noise is equivalent to the convolution of a point process by a smoothing window . according to the central limit theorem
, the statistics of the smoothed noise is approaching gaussian when the number of source galaxies contained in the smoothing window is large enough .
although observations and numerical simulations indicate that the simplification mentioned above may be indeed valid on @xmath36 scales for source galaxies at @xmath37 ( e.g. , van waerbeke 2000 ) , the statistics of the noise can deviate from gaussian if there are significant correlations in the spatial distribution or in the intrinsic ellipticity of source galaxies . in our future studies , we will investigate in detail the noise properties with these correlations included .
it is very true that the existence of noise affects the identification of clusters significantly . on the other hand , for theoretical studies , it is fundamentally important to first understand the complexity of true lensing signals .
the knowledge of this part forms the base for further investigations .
thus in this paper , we focus on true lensing signals with the emphasis on the influence of the complicated mass distribution of clusters and the projection effect .
therefore we mainly study noise - free @xmath0 maps .
the effects of noise on lensing cluster surveys will be carefully analyzed in our follow - up studies . in theoretical studies of lensing effects , generally one obtains the deflection angle @xmath38 through ray - tracing simulations ( e.g. , jain et al .
. then the shear matrix is calculated by @xmath39 with @xmath40 the source angular position .
the convergence @xmath0 and the shear @xmath27 can be derived from @xmath41 . in terms of denisty perturbations , to a very good approximation , we have ( jain et al .
2000 ) @xmath42 where @xmath43 with @xmath44 being the comoving angular diameter distance , @xmath45 is the density fluctuation at the actual position of photons , @xmath46 is the hubble constant and @xmath47 is the speed of light . in the weak lensing limit , the born approximation is valid and the integration in eq . ( 1 ) can be approximately performed along the unperturbed light path .
we will see in 3.1 that our study presented in this paper concerns @xmath0 values of order @xmath48 for the gaussian smoothing radius of @xmath49 .
therefore the weak lensing approximation is well applicable . in this limit
, @xmath0 maps can be constructed from stacking different slices of mass distribution between sources and the observer together without intensive ray - tracing simulations .
but we should keep in mind that at sub - smoothing scales , the @xmath0 value can be much higher .
the full lensing treatment should be carried out when studying lensing effects at these smaller scales .
our method of stacking in the weak lensing limit is detailed below . to generate a @xmath0 map
, we use a multiple - lens - plane algorithm .
many other similar algorithms choose line - of - sight directions to be parallel to the box edges ( @xmath50-direction , for example ) ( e.g. , white et al .
2002 ; hamana et al .
2001 ) . to diminish the effects of periodicity ,
the simulation boxes are randomly shifted when they are stacked together . in the algorithm
we apply , the stacking is in a regular way without any shifts , but the line - of - sight directions are chosen randomly .
the effects of periodicity are minimal if we avoid special directions , such as @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 ( jing 2004 , private communications ) .
specifically , we fix the source redshift at @xmath54 .
the observer is at @xmath21 and locates at the position @xmath55 .
the comoving radial distance between @xmath54 and @xmath21 is divided into @xmath56 equal sections , whose corresponding redshifts @xmath50 or the scale factors @xmath57 can be obtained .
then each slice is filled by the outputting simulation boxes with their @xmath57 value closest to the @xmath57 value of the slice . the projected mass distribution in that slice is calculated on @xmath58 grids for a @xmath59 map .
thus along a line - of - sight direction , the convergence @xmath0 is calculated through @xmath60 where @xmath61 denotes different slices , @xmath62 is the three - dimensional density perturbation , @xmath63 is the scale factor , @xmath64 is the comoving thickness of a slice , @xmath65 and @xmath66 are the comoving angular diameter distances to the source and to the lens , respectively , @xmath67 is the comoving angular diameter distance between the lens and the source .
we smooth @xmath0 maps with a gaussian window function of the form @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the smoothing angular scale .
figure 1 shows a smoothed @xmath0-map of @xmath59 with @xmath1 .
the grey - scale indicator shown in the right is in terms of the signal - to - noise ratio explained in the next section .
the squares denote dark matter halos found in the corresponding directions with mass @xmath70 .
qualitatively , we do see good associations between peaks in the @xmath0-map and massive dark matter halos . to identify a match between a peak and a halo quantitatively ,
we adopt the algorithm of hamana et al .
specifically , the matching is carried out in two directions : whether a peak has a corresponding halo and whether a halo has an associated peak in the @xmath0-map . because it is not expected that the position of a peak coincides exactly with the central position of its corresponding halo , the matched pair candidate is searched within a radius of @xmath71 around a peak or the center of a halo .
the specific number @xmath71 is chosen to be the same as that of hamana et al .
( 2004 ) , and it corresponds to @xmath72 pixels in our @xmath0 maps .
the closest one is identified as the primary match .
then there are five different peak - halo matching classes : double primary match , missing halo , false peak , secondary peak and secondary halo .
a peak - halo pair is classified as a double primary match if both the peak and the halo are their corresponding primary matches .
a missing halo is that there is no matched peak in the searching area around the halo .
a false peak is that there is no associated halo around the peak . if a halo has a matched peak that has its own primary matched halo , this halo is classified as a secondary halo .
a secondary peak has an associated halo , but is not the primary peak of that halo ( hamana et al .
our investigation focuses on the class of double primary match .
we do @xmath59 surveys toward @xmath73 directions for each simulation run . of them
, we discard those that have nearby halos ( @xmath74 ) more massive than @xmath75 .
the final number of surveys used in our analysis is @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 for the three simulations , respectively .
the nfw density profile of a dark matter halo is described by @xmath79 where @xmath65 and @xmath80 are the characteristic scale and density of the halo , respectively . given the virial mass @xmath81 of the halo , @xmath65 can be calculated through the fitting formula @xmath82 where the concentration parameter @xmath83 with @xmath84 the virial radius of the halo , and @xmath85 for the cosmological model considered here .
then @xmath80 can be obtained by @xmath86.\ ] ] thus the density profile of a halo is fully determined by its mass .
cutting off the mass distribution of a halo at its virial radius , the surface mass density can be written as ( e.g. , hamana et al .
2004 ) @xmath87 where @xmath88 and @xmath89 the convergence @xmath0 is then @xmath90 where @xmath91 with @xmath92 , @xmath93 and @xmath94 are the angular diameter distances to the source , to the lens , and from the lens to the source , respectively , and @xmath95 then one can obtain the smoothed central @xmath0 from a dark matter halo by @xmath96 thus for a nfw spherical dark matter halo , there is a one - to - one correspondence between its @xmath97 and its mass @xmath81 .
we consider double - primary - matched halo - peak pairs .
for each halo , from its mass and redshift , we calculate the expected @xmath98 , and compare it with the real @xmath0 value of the corresponding peak .
similar to other studies ( e.g. , white et al .
2002 ; hamana et al .
2004 ) , we use the signal - to - noise ratio @xmath99 to represent the height of a peak with @xmath100 given by @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the rms of the intrinsic ellipticity of source galaxies , @xmath103 is the surface number density of source galaxies .
following hamana et al .
( 2004 ) , we take @xmath104 and @xmath105 . in
most of our analyses , we use @xmath1 . the corresponding @xmath106 . for a typical cluster of @xmath107 , the peak @xmath108 and thus @xmath109 for @xmath1
. therefore it is appropriate to choose @xmath69 in the @xmath36 scale for clusters of galaxies ( hamana et al .
2004 ) . to illustrate the effect of using a different @xmath69 , we will also present results with @xmath2 , in which @xmath110 . in figure 2
, we show the scatter plots of @xmath111 and @xmath112 for the three simulation runs , where @xmath111 stands for the expected central signal - to - noise value for a halo modeled as a spherical nfw one , and @xmath112 is the halo s matched peak value from @xmath0-maps .
we only consider halos with @xmath113 and peaks with @xmath114 . from the plots ,
we do see a correlation between @xmath111 and @xmath112 , but the dispersion is rather large .
quantitatively , we find that the dispersion @xmath115 , and @xmath116 for @xmath117 and @xmath118 , respectively .
we also note that the average @xmath119 is slightly off zero , with @xmath120 .
hamana et al .
( 2004 ) found a positive bias with @xmath121 .
it is likely that the small bias arises from simulation to simulation variances . on the other hand
, the large dispersion indicates that for a cosmological model , the lensing - selected cluster abundance can deviate significantly from that predicted based on the spherical nfw description of cluster profiles .
therefore the nfw approximation can introduce large systematic errors in extracting cosmological parameters from lensing cluster surveys .
after a rough calculation , hamana et al .
( 2004 ) attributed the dispersion to the statistical distribution of the concentration parameter of the nfw density profile , and the projection effects of uncorrelated structures along the line of sight . here
we will study in detail the reasons of the dispersion , with particular attention paid to the triaxiality of dark matter halos . with high resolution simulations , jing and suto ( 2002 ) present a nfw - like triaxial density profile for dark matter halos , which is given by @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the critical matter density of the universe at redshift @xmath50 and @xmath124 with the axial ratios @xmath125 .
the characteristic scale @xmath126 is related to the triaxial concentration parameter @xmath127 with @xmath128 defined in jing and suto ( 2002 ) .
given the mass of a halo , the average @xmath129 and @xmath130 , and @xmath131 , as well as their statistical distributions are derived explicitly from simulation results ( jing & suto 2002 ) . the effects of the triaxiality on strong lensing results , such as arc statistics and the probability of large - separation multiple images , have been studied in detail ( e.g. , oguri et al .
2003 ; oguri & keeton 2004 ) .
the associated asphericity of the intracluster gas , revealed by x - ray and sunyaev - zeldovich effect observations , has also been investigated ( e.g. , lee & suto 2003 , 2004 ; wang & fan 2004 ) . here
we analyze the dispersion between @xmath112 and @xmath111 caused by the aspherical mass distribution of dark matter halos .
the @xmath0 profile of a triaxial dark matter halo can be analytically written as ( oguri et al .
2003 ) @xmath132 where the factor @xmath133 is defined as @xmath134 with @xmath135 the polar coordinates of the line - of - sight direction .
the factor @xmath136 is the same as that in equation ( 8) but with the variable @xmath137 labeling the elliptical contours of the projected surface mass distribution .
specifically , @xmath138 where we have assumed that the lensing plane is described by @xmath139 coordinates , and @xmath140 @xmath141 and @xmath142 thus for a triaxial halo of mass @xmath81 at a fixed redshift @xmath50 , its lensing signal depends on the line - of - sight direction .
the statistical uncertainties of the axial ratios ( @xmath129 and @xmath130 ) and of the concentration parameter ( @xmath131 ) also contribute to the dispersion of lensing signals . to demonstrate the dispersion caused by different viewing directions , in figure 3 we show the simulation result ( solid line ) of the distribution of the associated peak @xmath143 values of a halo of @xmath144 at @xmath145 viewed along different line of sights .
also shown in the plot ( dashed line ) is the smoothed central @xmath143 distribution expected from a triaxial halo of this mass and redshift with its axial ratios determined from the real mass distribution of the halo .
the concentration parameter @xmath131 is taken to be the average value ( jing & suto 2002 ) .
it is seen that the lensing signal has a large dispersion , and the triaxial model does explain a large portion of it at high end .
we now analyze the distribution of @xmath143 expected from the triaxial model for a given @xmath111 .
because @xmath111 depends both on the mass and on the redshift of a halo , halos of different masses at different redshifts can have same @xmath111 .
thus the conditional distribution is @xmath146p\,[\nu|\nu_{nfw};m_{\rm vir}(\nu_{nfw},z),z]dz}{\int_0 ^ 1dz\frac{dv}{dzd\omega}n[m_{\rm vir}(\nu_{nfw},z),z]},\ ] ] where @xmath147 is the mass function of dark matter halos .
the probability function @xmath148 @xmath149 $ ] depends on the distributions of @xmath150 , @xmath151 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 . specifically , @xmath152d\nu= & & \bigg \{\int dc_x \int d(c_x / c_y)\int dc_e \int d\theta \bigg ( { \partial \nu \over \partial \phi}\bigg ) ^{-1}_{\theta , c_x , c_x / c_y , c_e } \nonumber \\ & & p(c_x)p[(c_x / c_y)|c_x]p(c_e)p(\theta)p(\phi)\bigg \ } d\nu\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the distributions on @xmath129 , @xmath153 , and @xmath131 are taken from jing and suto ( 2002 ) [ see also oguri et al . ( 2003 ; 2004 ) ] . the mass function of jenkins et al .
( 2001 ) is adopted . in figure 4
, we show the @xmath143 distribution for @xmath117 and @xmath118 , respectively .
the solid lines are the results from @xmath0 maps of three simulation runs .
the dashed lines are the results of equation ( 22 ) .
the dash - dotted lines are the results for spherical halos taking into account the uncertainties of the concentration parameter .
it is clearly seen that the dispersion solely from the distribution of the concentration parameter ( dash - dotted lines ) is small in comparison with the large dispersion shown in simulation data ( solid lines ) .
the triaxiality contributes additional dispersions , giving rise to a long tail at high @xmath143 side .
the high - end dispersion due to the triaxiality of dark matter halos has important effects on modeling the selection function for weak lensing cluster surveys .
since the lensing signal from a triaxial cluster depends not only on its mass and redshift but also on the viewing direction , the selection criteria corresponding to a detection limit @xmath154 is no longer simply a mass limit @xmath155 for each redshift @xmath50 . instead
, for each @xmath81 , there is a probability @xmath156 that its @xmath0 can be higher than @xmath154 .
eq.(23 ) is the basic equation to obtain @xmath156 .
one of our future studies is to analyze @xmath156 and further the weak lensing cluster abundances at different redshifts for different cosmologies .
it is seen from figure 4 that the triaxial model explains the dispersion better for more massive clusters .
it is notably seen , however , that the range of @xmath143 from simulations is broader than that predicted by the triaxial model , especially at the low end of @xmath143 .
for relatively weak detections ( @xmath157 ) , the differences between the results from the model predictions and the simulations show up at both low and high @xmath143 values .
possible reasons for these are discussed in the following .
the differences between the simulation results and the triaxial model predictions can be attributed to two effects .
one is the complex mass distribution of individual clusters that can not be well approximated by the triaxial model .
the other is the projection effect of uncorrelated structures along the line of sight . to see the relative importance of the two , we generate lensing surveys for matched halos only
specifically , only particles that belong to the matched halos are kept and all the other particles are removed from the simulation . in this way , we isolate the effect of the complexity of individual clusters .
the lensing signal from this artificial survey is referred to as @xmath158 ( or equivalently @xmath159 ) .
figure 5 shows the scatter plots of @xmath159 vs. @xmath112 for @xmath117 and @xmath118 , respectively , where @xmath112 is the peak @xmath143 value of matched halos from full simulations .
good correlations between the two are clearly seen .
this association indicates that for these peaks , their @xmath0 values are dominantly determined by the properties of their matched halos .
the plots also reveal that the dispersion toward high @xmath112 is larger for smaller halos ( lower @xmath111 ) .
this shows , as expected , that the line - of - sight projection effects are relatively stronger for smaller halos .
quantitatively , we calculate the quantity
@xmath160 ^ 2>^{1/2}$ ] to estimate the strength of the projection effect .
the values are @xmath161 , @xmath162 and @xmath163 for @xmath117 and @xmath118 , respectively . in the plots ,
the triangles denote clusters with more than one @xmath143 peak associated with them .
these clusters must contain large substructures .
note that we identify the @xmath143 peak closest to the central position of a halo as its matched peak . for clusters with large substructures , the closest @xmath143 peak is likely generated only by a substructure .
thus the value of matched @xmath112 underestimates the lensing signal from the full cluster .
we indeed see that the triangles concentrate on the small @xmath112 part .
this explains the lower - end extension of the distribution of @xmath112 in figure 4 .
now let us compare @xmath159 with @xmath164 calculated from the triaxial model in which we determine the axial ratios and the orientation of a cluster from its real mass distribution .
the results are shown in figure 6 .
the symbols are the same as in figure 5 .
first we do see correlations between @xmath159 and @xmath164 , with the associations better for single - peak clusters ( crosses ) .
it is noted , however , that the triaxial model predicts narrower scatters than @xmath159 for relatively small clusters . for large clusters with @xmath165 ,
the spread of @xmath164 is about the same as that of @xmath159 .
secondly , as expected , most of the triangles are in the lower right part of the plot .
but there are several triangles scattered at the upper left part .
we check individual cases , and find that multiple substructures along the line of sight can produce a higher lensing signal than that predicted by the smoothed triaxial mass distribution .
we caution that the simulations we use are relatively small - sized ( @xmath166 ) , and the number of large clusters is small . as we stack simulation boxes together to generate lensing maps , the same cluster can be surveyed many times along different directions . for @xmath117 , and @xmath118 ,
the number of matched peaks from lensing maps is , respectively , about @xmath167 , @xmath168 , and @xmath169 .
however , the corresponding total number of clusters involved in our analyses is only @xmath170 and @xmath24 .
the number of times that the most frequently surveyed clusters appear in our lensing maps can account for about @xmath171 of the total number of matched peaks .
thus our statistical results can be influenced significantly by the characteristics of only a few clusters .
similar analyses on larger simulations are desired for more robust statistical results .
we further do case - studies one by one . of the respective @xmath170 and @xmath24 clusters for @xmath117 , and @xmath118 ,
the number of clusters with apparent substructures shown in lensing maps is @xmath172 and @xmath173 , with the corresponding fraction @xmath174 , @xmath175 and @xmath176 . for these clusters ,
their lensing signals are mostly lower than those predicted by the triaxial model as explained earlier .
a specific example is plotted in figure 7 .
the @xmath50-projected mass distribution of this cluster is shown in figure 8 .
large subhalos are clearly seen .
in fact , in this case , the cluster is in its early formation stage , and different substructures are just starting to merge . for those clusters without apparent substructures ,
most of them can be well described by the triaxial model . however
, multiple hidden substructures along the line of sight can generate lensing signals higher than those from the smoothed triaxial model .
an example is shown in figure 9 .
for this cluster , the expected lensing signal from the spherical nfw mass distribution is @xmath165 .
taking into account the triaxiality of the mass distribution , the predicted lensing signals largely agree with that calculated directly from the real mass distribution of the cluster . for the extreme point where @xmath159 is much higher than @xmath164 , the mass distribution along this particular line of sight
is shown in figure 10 .
the upper panel is the real distribution and the lower one is from the smoothed triaxial model .
multiple major peaks are clearly seen in the upper panel , which explains the deviation of @xmath159 from @xmath164 .
notice that when applying the triaxial model to individual clusters , we adopt the mean concentration parameter from jing and suto ( 2002 ) for a given set of axial ratios measured from the mass distribution of a cluster .
the real concentration parameter can fluctuate around the mean .
we do find that , in a few cases ( @xmath177 or @xmath118 out of @xmath178 clusters with @xmath179 ) , the real mass distribution is much flatter than that of the triaxial model with the mean concentration parameter , which results higher @xmath159 than @xmath164 .
the above analyses were done for the smoothing radius @xmath1 . to see the effects of @xmath69
, we also perform studies with @xmath2 .
figure 11 shows the dispersions for @xmath2 .
only the results from simulations ( solid lines ) and from the triaxial model ( dashed lines ) are shown .
it is seen that the differences between the simulation results and the predictions of the triaxial model are larger than those for @xmath1 .
quantitatively , for @xmath1 and @xmath165 , the dispersions are @xmath180 and @xmath181 , respectively .
the corresponding numbers for @xmath2 are @xmath182 and @xmath183 . in figure 12
, we show the scatter plots of @xmath159 and @xmath112 .
first , as expected , the fraction of triangles is significantly less than that of @xmath1 . for @xmath2 , the fraction is @xmath184 , @xmath185 and @xmath186 for @xmath157 , @xmath177 , and @xmath118 , respectively . for @xmath1 ,
the corresponding numbers are @xmath187 , @xmath188 , and @xmath189 .
the decrease of the effect of substructures does not however reduce significantly the dispersion of @xmath112 at low end for @xmath2 .
secondly , the correlations of the two can still be seen in figure 12 , but the tightness of the association is worse than the case of @xmath1 . for @xmath2 and @xmath165 , we have @xmath190\approx 0.24 $ ] . for @xmath1 , @xmath190\approx 0.15 $ ] .
the large dispersion reflects the severe projection contamination for @xmath2 . in figure 13 , we show the particle distribution at several lens planes for a particular peak with @xmath191 .
this peak appears in both cases of @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
the corresponding primary cluster of the peak is located at plane @xmath192 .
the three circles in each panel are for angular scales of @xmath193 , @xmath194 and @xmath195 , respectively .
it is clearly seen that within the circle of @xmath193 , the cluster itself is the dominant contributor to the lensing effect , and the projection effect from other planes is relatively weak . within the circle of @xmath194 , however , besides the cluster , the mass distribution on planes @xmath196 and @xmath197 contributes significantly to the final lensing effect . specifically , @xmath198 and @xmath199 for @xmath1 and @xmath2 , respectively .
we note that the projection effect causes large dispersions at both high and low ends .
the joint effects of the stronger projection contamination and the reduction of substructures make the low - end dispersion not change greatly in comparison with that of @xmath1 . at the high end , however , the dispersion is significantly larger for @xmath2 than for @xmath1 .
thus our analysis indicates that it seems too large to use @xmath2 in weak lensing cluster surveys .
our study shows that for clusters of galaxies , their peak lensing signals appear much more complex than those predicted by the spherical mass distribution in which the total mass and the redshift of a cluster fully determine the strength of its lensing effects .
therefore the spherical model can introduce large errors to the prediction on the abundance of lensing - selected clusters .
those errors in turn will significantly bias the determination of cosmological parameters from future weak lensing cluster surveys .
hamana et al .
( 2004 ) attribute the complexity to the variation of the concentration parameter of the spherical nfw profile and the line - of - sight projection effect of uncorrelated structures . however
, our analyses with @xmath1 reveal that for relatively large clusters relevant to weak lensing cluster surveys , their lensing effects are mainly determined by the characteristics of individual clusters , and the line - of - sight projection effects play a minor role . for individual clusters , the triaxiality of their mass distribution is important and has to be taken into account in theoretical analyses on their expected lensing effects . in terms of the dispersion shown in figure 4 , the triaxiality contributes a considerable part of the high - end tail especially for massive clusters .
the low - end extension is mainly attributed to the existence of large substructures in clusters of galaxies .
multiple substructures along a line of sight can also generate higher lensing signals than those predicted by the smoothed mass distribution .
thus substructures also contribute , to a certain level , to the high - end dispersion . with @xmath2
, however , the projection effect is significant .
thus in terms of cluster detections with weak lensing surveys , the smoothing radius @xmath1 is preferable to @xmath2 .
note that our analyses are based on the @xmath0 maps generated under the born approximation .
therefore we may underestimate the projection effect because we integrate the weighted density fluctuations along the unperturbed light path . in our analysis with @xmath1 , we find that the projection effect accounts for about @xmath200 in the total dispersion of @xmath201 of @xmath202 for @xmath179 .
hamana et al .
( 2004 ) quoted a value of @xmath203 from the projection effect estimated from the contribution of large - scale structures uncorrelated with halos ( hoekstra 2001 ) .
while the number @xmath204 is not certain and the underestimate by the born approximation in the weak lensing limit may not be as large as the numbers ( @xmath200 vs. @xmath204 ) suggest , it is indeed desirable to quantitatively analyze the projection effects by full ray tracing simulations . in our analysis , we assume a fixed source redshift . for a real lensing survey , source galaxies generally have a redshift distribution , which should be taken into account in modeling the lensing effects of clusters expected from the survey . with the mass distribution and the statistics for the triaxial dark matter halos from jing and suto ( 2002 )
, the effect of the triaxiality on lensing signals can be theoretically studied .
rather than simply mass selected , a much more complicated selection function for @xmath0-limited lensing cluster surveys can be obtained .
on the other hand , it is less straightforward to include substructures in theoretical analyses without numerical simulations .
however , recent high resolution simulations have been able to present some statistics on substructures , e.g. , their mass function and the spatial distribution ( e.g. gao et al .
2004 ; natarajan & springel 2004 ) .
these , in principle , allow us to analyze the influence of substructures on lensing effects without time - intensive simulations .
weak lensing effects are powerful and clean probes to the distribution of dark matter .
cosmological studies on lensing - selected clusters avoid physical processes related to the intracluster gas that complicate the cosmological applications of x - ray and sz - selected clusters considerably .
our investigation reveals the complexities of lensing effects related to the mass distribution of clusters , which however , can be handled without fundamental difficulties . in a foreseeable future ,
weak lensing cluster surveys as well as cosmic shear observations will contribute greatly to cosmological studies .
we sincerely thank the referee for the constructive and detailed comments and suggestions .
we gratefully thank y. p. jing for kindly providing us simulation data and for useful discussions .
we also thank g. t. zhu for his @xmath0-map algorithm . this research was supported in part by the national science foundation of china under grants 10243006 and 10373001 , by the ministry of science and technology of china under grant tg1999075401 , and by the key grant project of chinese ministry of education ( no . 305001 ) .
bahcall , n. , & bode , p. 2003
, , 588 , l1 bartelmann , m. , & meneghetti , m. 2004 , a&a , 418 , 413 bartelmann , m. , & schneider , p. 2001 , phys .
340 , 291 carlstrom , j. e. , holder , g. p. , & reese , e. d. , 2002 , , 40 , 643 fan , z. h. , & chiueh , t. h. 2001 , , 550 , 547 fan , z. h. , & wu , y. l. 2003 , , 598 , 713 gao , l. , white , s. d. m. , jenkins , a. , stoehr , f. , & springel , v. 2004 , , 355 , 819 gavazzi , r. , fort , b. , mellier , y. , pello , r. , & dantel - fort , m. 2003 , a&a , 403 , 11 haiman , z. , mohr , j. , & holder , g. 2001 , , 553 , 545 haiman , z. , wang , s. , hennawi , j. f. , may , m. , spergel , d.n .
, & tyson , j. a. 2004 , american astronomical society meeting 205 , # 108.15 hamana , t. , colombi , s. , & mellier , y. 2001 , in xxxvth moriond astrophysics meeting : cosmological physics with gravitational lensing . ed . j .- p .
kneib , y. mellier , m. mon , & t. tran thanh van(france : edp ) hamana , t. , takada , m. , & yoshida , n. 2004 , , 350 , 893 hoekstra , h. 2001 , a&a , 370 , 743 jain , b. , seljak , u. , & white , s. 2000 , , 530 , 547 jenkins , a. et al .
2001 , , 321 , 372 jing , y. p. , & suto , y. 1998 , , 494 , l5 jing , y. p. , & suto , y. 2002 , , 574 , 538 jing , y. p. 2004
, private communication kaiser , n. 1998 , , 498 , 26 lee , j. , & suto , y. 2003 , , 585 , 151 lee , j. , & suto , y. 2004 , , 601 , 599 ma , c. p. 2003 , , 584 , l1 natarajan , p. , & springel , v. 2004 , , 617 , 13l oguir , m. , lee , j. , & suto , y. 2003 , , 599 , 70 oguir , m. , lee , j. , & suto , y. 2004 , , 608 , 1175 oguri , m. , & keeton , c. 2004 , , 610 , 6630 padmanabhan , n. , seljak , u. , & pen , u. l. 2003 , new astronomy , 8 , 581 press , w. h. , & schechter , p. 1974
, , 187 , 425 reblinsky , k. , & bartelmann , m. 1999 , a&a , 345 , 1 rosati , p. , borgani , s. , & norman , c. 2002 , , 40 , 539 sheth , r. , & tormen , g. 1999 , , 308 , 119 tereno , i. , dore , o. , van waerbeke , l. , & mellier , y. 2005 , a&a , 429 , 383 van waerbeke , l. 2000 , , 313 , 524 van waerbeke , l. , mellier , y. , & hoekstra , h. 2005 , a&a , 429 , 75 wang , y .- g . , & fan , z.h .
2004 , , 617 , 847 white , m. , van waerbeke , l. , & mackey , j. 2002 , , 575 , 640 zhang , t. j. 2004 , , 602 , l5 | gravitational lensing effects arise from the light ray deflection by all of the mass distribution along the line of sight .
it is then expected that weak lensing cluster surveys can provide us true mass - selected cluster samples . with numerical simulations ,
we analyze the correspondence between peaks in the lensing convergence @xmath0-map and dark matter halos .
particularly we emphasize the difference between the peak @xmath0 value expected from a dark matter halo modeled as an isolated and spherical one , which exhibits a one - to - one correspondence with the halo mass at a given redshift , and that of the associated @xmath0-peak from simulations . for halos with the same expected @xmath0 , their corresponding peak signals in the @xmath0-map present a wide dispersion . at an angular smoothing scale of @xmath1 , our study shows that for relatively large clusters , the complex mass distribution of individual clusters is the main reason for the dispersion .
the projection effect of uncorrelated structures does not play significant roles .
the triaxiality of dark matter halos accounts for a large part of the dispersion , especially for the tail at high @xmath0 side . thus lensing - selected clusters are not really mass - selected .
to better predict @xmath0-selected cluster abundance for a cosmological model , one has to take into account the triaxial mass distribution of dark matter halos . on the other hand , for a significant number of clusters , their mass distribution is even more complex than that described by the triaxial model .
our analyses find that large substructures affect the identification of lensing clusters considerably .
they could show up as separate peaks in the @xmath0-map , and cause a mis - association of the whole cluster with a peak resulted only from a large substructure .
the lower - end dispersion of @xmath0 is attributed mostly to this substructure effect . for @xmath2
, the projection effect can be significant and contributes to the dispersion at both high and low @xmath0 ends . |
the oh / ir source irc+10420 = iras19244 + 1115 identified with the peculiar high luminosity star v1302aql is a unique object , which has been carefully and comprehensively studied over the last decades but still remains a puzzle .
of the two hypotheses about its nature neither seems to be convincingly preponderant as yet . according to fix and cobb ( 1987 ) , hrivnak et al . , ( 1989 ) and others this is a degenerate core giant evolving through the proto - planetary nebula stage with a luminosity no higher than @xmath3 . according to jones et al . , ( 1993 ) , humphreys and davidson ( 1994 ) and oudmaijer et al .
( 1996 ) this is a core - burning hypergiant of @xmath4 .
the difficulty of choice is due to : * the uncertainty of fundamental observational parameters , such as spectral class and distance ; * the fact that with the difference in mass , age , even type of stellar population the evolutionary processes and their observational evidence are similar : in both alternatives the effective temperature of the star increases , there is a gaseous - dust envelope inherited from the red giant or supergiant phase , which interacts with the stellar wind ; * the presence of several competing models : thin chromosphere in the expanding gaseous - dust envelope such optically thick that we see the light of the star being multiple scaterring by circumstellar dust ( fix and cobb , 1987 ) ; a gaseous - dust disk in a clumpy envelope ( jones et al . ,
1993 ) ; jets with a small angle of opening ( oudmaijer et al . , 1994 ) ; and at last infall of circumstellar material onto photosphere ( oudmaijer , 1995 ) .
outer regions of the source of radius 2 - 3 arcsec are mainly described and mapped by radio astronomy techniques from emission of molecules ( paper by nedoluha and bowers ( 1992 ) and references therein ) .
the gas envelope has been imaged by the methods of infrared speckle interferometry and coronagraphy ( ridgway et al .
, 1986oc ; kastner and weintraub , 1995 ) .
the image of the dust envelope also extends to several seconds of arc , but the radiation is sharply enhanced in the region of about 0.1arcsec in radius . however space or ground - based speckle images in the optical range , which could refine the structure of the central region , unknown to us . here
the high resolution optical spectrum of irc+10420 , which contains the emission and absorption lines of the envelope and absorption ones of the photosphere or of the pseudophotosphere of the central star , is described .
.observation log of irc+10420 [ cols="^,^,^ " , ]
so , the optical spectrum of irc+10420 of the years from 1992 through 1996 * points to the increase in the temperature : spectral class a5 instead of f8 in 1973 ; * contains absorptions ( mainly of ions ) formed in the photosphere , apparently stationary with respect to the star center of mass ; * contains emission details too , which are formed in the expanding envelope and perhaps in its compressing layers ; * rezembles the spectra of late - type b[e ] stars ; the metallicity , which is close to solar , and the altered [ n / c]-value allow us to consider irc+10420 as a massive object at the evolution stage of at least after the first dredge - up and not to reject the hypothesis of jones et al .
( 1993 ) who suggested that irc+10420 is a true hypergiant with a mass of about @xmath5 , evolving from the red supergiant phase to the wolf - rayet stage .
the nature of irc+10420 is still open question .
new observations are necessary to obtain full chemical abundance pattern and to coordinate luminosity , distance and radial velocity of this object . besides that we need more careful indentification of extremely plentiful and variable features of the optical spectra of irc+10420 .
for example , what are the enigmatic narrow strong absorption details @xmath6 ? for the present one can say only that these are not telluric lines . it should be noted that in the frames of the study of supergiants with infrared excess ( klochkova , 1995 ; zas et al . , 1995 ) we have obtained also the spectra of the supergiant hd179821 = iras19114 + 0002 , which has been considered analogous to irc+10420 ( kastner , weintraub , 1995 ) . based on these spectra results
have recently been obtained ( zas et al . , 1996 ) for hd179821 , using the model atmosphere method : @xmath7 , logg=1.3 , iron peak elements are slightly underabundant , sc and ti are slightly overabundant . but for this object zas et al .
( 1996 ) revealed the overabundance of sodium , s - process ( y , zr ) and r - process ( eu ) elements .
the overabundance of s - process points to the post - agb stage of evolution of hd179821 .
however for more general conclusions about the nature of hd179821 and its likeness to irc+10420 , abundances of cno - triad are needed . _
_ we thank prof .
yu.n.efremov for helpful discussion on localization of irc+10420 in the galaxy and dr .
r.oudmaijer for a part of his ph.d.thesis kindly made available to us .
we are also indebted to the referee for detailed and fruitful discussion and suggestions .
chaffee f.h . ,
white r.e .
apjs , 50 , 169 fix j.d .
1981 , apj , 248 , 542 fix j.d .
, cobb m.l .
1987 , apj , 312 , 290 grevesse n. , noels a. 1993 . in : origin and evolution of the elements .
n. prantzos , e. vangioni - flam and m. gasse .
cambridge university press , p.14 gummersbach c.a .
, zickgraf f .- j . , wolf b. 1995 , a&a , 302 , 409 herbig g.h . , soderblom d.r .
apj , 252 , 610 hrivnak b.j . , kwok s. , volk k.m .
1989 , apj , 346 , 265 humphreys r.m . 1978 , apjs , 38 , 309 humphreys r.m . ,
strecker d.w . ,
murdock t.l . ,
1973 , apj , 179 , l49 humphreys r.m . , davidson k. 1994 , pasp , 106 , 1025 jones t.j . , humphreys r.m .
, gehrz r.d . ,
lawrence g.f . ,
zickgraf f .- j .
, moseley h. , casey s. , glaccum w.j . , koch c.j .
, pina r. , jones b. , venn k. , stahl o. and starrfield s.g .
1993 , apj , 411 , 323 kastner j.h . , weintraub d.a .
1995 , apj , 452 , 833 klochkova v.g .
1995 , mnras , 272 , 710 kurucz r.l . 1979 , apj suppl , 40 , 1 myers p.c . ,
dame t.m . ,
thaddeus p. , cohen r.s .
, silverberg r.f . ,
dwek e. , hauser m.g .
1986 , apj , 301 , 398 nedoluha g.e . ,
bowers p.f .
1992 , apj , 392 , 249 nieuwenhuijzen h. , de jager c. 1992 . in : instabilities in evolved super- and hypergiants .
north - holland , amsterdam / oxford / new york / tokyo .
c. de jager and h. nieuwenhuijzen .
p.127 olofsson h. , johansson l.e.b .
, hjalmarson a. , nguyen - quang - rieu , 1982 , a&a , 107 , 128 oudmaijer r.d .
1995 . ph.d . thesis .
oudmaijer r.d .
, geballe t.r . , waters l.b.f.m . , sahu k.c .
1994 , a&a , 281 , l33 oudmaijer r.d .
, groenewegen m.a.t . ,
matthews h.e .
, blommaert j.a.d.l . , and sahu k.c .
1996 , mnras , 280 , 1062 panchuk v.e . ,
klochkova v.g . ,
galazutdinov g.a .
, ryadchenko v.p .
, chentsov e.l .
1993 , sva , 19 , l1061 ridgway s.t . ,
joyce r.r .
, connors d. , pipher j.l .
, dainty ch .
1986 apj , 302 , 662 strenburg s. 1993 , a&a , 277 , 139 venn k.a .
1993 , apj , 414 , 316 venn k.a .
1995a , apjs , 99 , 659 venn k.a .
1995b , apj , 449 , 839 venn k.a . , lambert d.l .
1990 , apj , 363 , 234 walborn n.r .
, liller m.h .
1977 , apj , 211 , 181 van winckel h. 1997 , a&a , 319 , 561 zas l.a . , klochkova v.g .
, panchuk v.e .
mnras , 275 , 764 zas l.a . , klochkova v.g .
, panchuk v.e . and spelmanis r. 1996 .
mnras , 282 , 1171 zickgraf f .- j . , stahl o. , wolf b. 1992 , a&a , 260 , 205 | to understand the evolutionary stage of the peculiar supergiant irc+10420 , we have been taking spectra for several years at the 6 m telescope .
the optical spectrum of irc+10420 of the years from 1992 through 1996 points to the increase in the temperature : spectral class a5 instead of the former f8 , as was pointed out by humpreys et al . ,
( 1973 ) .
now it resembles the spectra of late - type b[e ] stars .
the spectrum contains absorptions ( mainly of ions ) formed in the photosphere , apparently stationary with respect to the star center of mass , and emissions too , which can be formed in the fossil expanding envelope as well as partly in its compressing region .
using our spectra and spectral data obtained by oudmaijer ( 1995 ) we estimated the atmospheric parameters @xmath0 , logg=1.0 , @xmath1 and concluded that metallicity of irc+10420 is solar : the average value @xmath2_{\odot } = -0.03}$ ] .
combination of results allows us to consider irc+10420 as a massive supergiant evolving to the wr - stage .
= -3 cm = -2 cm _ special astrophysical observatory , nizhnij arkhyz , 357147 russia _
* keywords : * stars : evolution stars : hypergiants stars : individual : irc+10420 |
the evolution of rotation is usually associated with an evolution of angular momentum ; changing the angular momentum of any body requires torques and stars do not escape from this law of physics . in binary stars there is a permanent source of torques : the tides .
hence , understanding the evolution of rotation of stars in a binary system demands the understanding of the action of tides .
this compulsory exercise was started more than thirty years ago by jean - paul zahn during his thse dtat " , _ les mares dans une toiles double serre _ ( zahn 1966 ) .
all the concepts needed to understand tides and their actions in the dynamical evolution of binaries are presented in this work .
surely , as in isolated stars , rotation is an important ingredient of evolution through the induced mixing processes : turbulence in stably stratified radiative zones , circulations ... all these processes will influence the abundances of elements in the atmospheres or the internal profile of angular velocity , for instance .
however , in binary stars new phenomena appear : tides .
they make the orbit evolving , force some mixing processes ( through eigenmode resonances for instance ) or may even generate instabilities leading , to some turbulence ( see below ) .
these new phenomena need also to be understood if one wishes to decipher the observations of binary stars . in this respect
binary stars offer more observables than single stars like the parametres of the orbit , masses of the stars , their radii , etc .
if the system has not exchanged mass during evolution and if other parameters like luminosity , surface gravity , abundances can also be determined unambiguously , binary stars offer new constrains on the stars which may be useful for our understanding of stellar evolution .
also , a statistical view of orbital parameters may constrain the dissipative processes at work in these stars ( mathieu et al . 1992 ) .
let us consider an isolated system made of two stars of mass m@xmath0 , m@xmath1 , of moment of inertia i@xmath0 , i@xmath1 and of spin angular velocity @xmath2 , @xmath3 .
the semi - major axis of the orbit is @xmath4 and the eccentricity @xmath5 .
for simplicity we shall assume that the angular momentum vectors are all aligned .
hence , the total ( projected ) angular momentum of the system , which is conserved during evolution , reads : @xmath6 on the other hand , the total energy of the system , namely , @xmath7 decreases because of dissipative processes . to appreciate the natural evolution of such a system ,
let us consider the even more simplified system where the angular momentum and the energy of the spin of the stars are negligible compared to their orbital equivalent . using kepler third law to eliminate the mean angular velocity of the orbital motion @xmath8 , the previous equations lead to @xmath9 during evolution the system loses energy through dissipative mechanisms , thus @xmath4 decreases which implies that @xmath5 also decreases to insure a constant angular momentum .
thus , with time the orbit slowly circularizes .
once the orbit is circular or nearly circular , the system may continue to evolve if the orbital angular velocity and spin angular velocity are not identical : this is the synchronization process after which the system has reached its minimum mechanical energy state : all the stars rotate at the same rate , i.e. @xmath10 like the moon on its terrestrial orbit . in the foregoing section we presented a global view of the evolution of the system , however the way the orbit or the spin change is controlled by the torques applied to the stars . as we said at the beginning , a permanent source of torques is given by the tides which therefore need to be studied .
but what is a tide ? the tide is the fluid flow generated by the tidal potential , i.e. the azimuth dependent part of the gravitational potential inside a star . in short ,
if you sit on a star , it is the forced flow generated by the celestial bodies orbiting around you .
if you sit on earth you feel the tides of the moon and the sun essentially .
now let us assume that the tidal forcing is milde enough so that the fluid flow obeys linear equations ; formally , we may write the system like @xmath11 where we assume that the tidal force @xmath12 can be separated into its spatial and temporal dependence . written in this way we immediately see that if the inertia of the fluid can be neglected ( i.e. the term @xmath13 ) , then the velocity field can be computed with the same temporal dependence as the exciting force .
the response is instantaneous .
moreover , if coriolis acceleration and viscosity are negligible , the only response of the fluid is through a pressure perturbation , i.e. it is purely hydrostatic .
this extremely simple , but not unrealistic , case is called the _ equilibrium tide_. on earth , this tide is enough to understand the basic properties of terrestrial tides : i.e. that there are two tides a day , that their amplitude is @xmath14 cm or that they are stronger at full or new moon ; the hydrostatic perturbation describes the famous tidal bulge which is often representing tides in elementary courses .
such a description is appropriate if you sit on the mediterranean beaches or on those of the pacific ocean ; however , if you sit on the atlantic shore , like here in cancun , you will easily notice that the tide is much larger than the expected 50 cm . in the mont saint - michel bay it easily reaches 10 meters !
the difference comes from what we neglected : the inertia of the fluid and the ensuing resonance phenomenon . for the tidal wave ,
whose wavelength is a few thousand kilometers , the atlantic ocean is a mere puddle five kilometers deep .
surface gravity waves may thus be studied using the shallow water approximation and their speed is given by @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the gravity and @xmath17 the depth . with a mean width of 5000 km
, the atlantic is crossed twice in 12.6 hours ; but the tidal forcing is back after 12.4 hours . obviously , we are close to a resonance and in this case the equilibrium tide is insufficient to describe the tidal response of the fluid . in this case
the tide will be qualified as _
dynamical_. quite clearly
, the equilibrium tide is much easier to handle than the dynamical one ; this is why it was first studied ( zahn 1966 ) ; the dynamical tide received first serious considerations by zahn ( 1970 ) and a proper treatment by zahn ( 1975 ) . in order to compute the dynamical evolution of the system , namely the parameters of the orbit and the spin of the stars it is necessary to evaluate both the torques and the dissipation inside the stars .
the torque suffered by a star results from an unsymmetrical distribution of mass with respect to the tidal potential ; mathematically , @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the density perturbation generated by the tidal potential @xmath20 ; @xmath21 is the angular azimuthal variable .
we see from this expression that torques can only exist if the excitation @xmath20 and the response @xmath19 are out of phase ( or antiphase ) .
the phase lag between these two quantities comes from the dissipative mechanisms at work in the stars and is usually a small but important quantity . from the expressions of the energy and angular momentum of the orbit
, we can derive : @xmath22 @xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 are respectively the power dissipated in the stars and the torques exerted on the orbit ( the parallelism of angular momentum vectors is still assumed ) .
the foregoing discussion therefore shows that , provided the stars do not change , all the evolution of the system is controlled by the dissipation of energy by the tidal flow . in the case stellar evolution
is important , for instance before or after the main sequence , changes in the inertia momenta will change the spin of the stars and the applied torques .
the first and most obvious physical mechanism to dissipate mechanical energy is viscosity .
however , the viscosity of stellar plasma is far too weak to be efficient and only turbulent viscosity of convection zones can significantly affect the evolution of the system .
but the effectiveness of turbulent viscosity is hampered by the fact that tidal flows are periodic in time : in any region of a convective zone where the lifetime of eddies is longer than the period of the tidal flows , the turbulent eddy viscosity is reduced .
the question is , of course , how much it is reduced compared to its usual approximation @xmath26 where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are respectively the velocity of turbulent eddies and their mean free path .
presently , two prescriptions coexist : the first by zahn ( 1966 ) says that @xmath29 which means that when the period of tides is shorter than the turnover time of the eddies , the mean - free path of the eddies should be reduced to the distance covered by an eddy during half a period .
the second prescription is originally due to goldreich and keeley ( 1977 ) but adapted by golman and mazeh ( 1991 ) ; it says that @xmath30 this prescription means that the turbulent viscosity should be such that @xmath31 namely that the dissipation by tidal currents fits the dissipation by the turbulent cascade @xmath32 ( recall that in the kolmogorov cascade @xmath33 ) .
these two prescriptions yield different exponent in the dependence of the evolution time scale with the period of the system ; in principle , they can be discriminated by observations .
however , this exercise turns out to be difficult ; moreover , using binaries in stellar clusters , mathieu et al .
( 1992 ) found that no reduction of viscosity was necessary to explain observations !
obviously , more work is needed to clarify this question .
another viscous damping process was also put forward by tassoul ( 1987 ) , namely the dissipation in ekman boundary layers . however , we have shown that because of the stress - free surfaces of the stars , such layers are rather regions with lower dissipation than the rest of the star ( see rieutord 1992 , rieutord and zahn 1997 ) . another way to dissipate energy of tidal flows is through radiative damping .
this mechanism will affect essentially radiative zones ; indeed , from the tidal excitation , one needs to generate temperature fluctuations which are dissipated by radiative diffusion .
the most natural way to generate these temperature fluctuations comes from the excitation of gravity modes since , mechanically , they are associated with the buoyancy force .
it is therefore quite clear that the dissipation and the ensuing torques will be most important when the forcing frequency is near that of an eigenmode of the star . from this remark
, it is also clear that only the dynamical tide will be relevant in this process .
on general grounds we may observe that the tidal forcing is low - frequency and that low - frequency gravity modes are high order modes which can then be described by an asymptotic theory .
this was the way chosen by zahn ( 1975 ) and later by goldreich and nicholson ( 1989 ) .
this mechanism is essentially relevant for early - type stars which own an outer radiative zone . as shown by the previous authors the tidal excitation is most intense near the core - envelope boundary but since gravity waves are only partially reflected at the star surface , they deposit their angular momentum there and these layers are synchronized first .
this argument was developed by golreich and nicholson ( 1989 ) to explain the higher synchonization rate observed in early - type stars compared to the theoretical predictions of zahn ( 1977 ) .
these studies are based on an asymptotic approach and ignore the role of the coriolis force .
this force is , however , unavoidable since the stars are always rotating and in most cases the tidal forcing is also in the band of the so - called inertial modes whose restoring force is precisely the coriolis force .
in fact inertial modes always combine with gravity modes as they are also low - frequency modes ; both together , they occupy the band @xmath34 $ ] , where @xmath35 is the brunt - visl frequency . recently , much progress was achieved in the direction of including the whole spectrum of low - frequency modes in the tidal response of an early - type star . indeed , witte and savonije ( 1999a , b,2001 ) computed numerically the response of a 10 m@xmath36 main sequence star and the ensuing evolution of the system with various inital eccentricities .
their results show many interesting features : * the efficiency of resonance crossing at decreasing the eccentricity when it is initially small ( a few percent ) . * a new phenomenon , which they called resonance locking " and
by which two resonant modes , one tending to spin - up the star and the other trying to spin it down , yield equilibrating torques which maintain the two stellar modes close to resonance and therefore force a strong evolution of eccentricity ( see figure 3 in witte and savonije 1999b ) .
the calculations of witte and savonije show that radiative damping is efficient at reducing the eccentricity of the orbit in a fraction of the lifetime of the star : in their examples , the 10 m@xmath36 star has a lifetime of 20 myrs ; an initial eccentricity of 0.02 is erased in 1 myr , but an initial eccentricity of 0.25 or 0.7 reduces to 0.1 in 3 myrs ; a further evolution apparently operates on a much longer time scale .
obviously , if the model of witte and savonije could be used as a true system , it would mean that orbits with @xmath37 may be as evolved as @xmath38 ones and differ only by initial conditions .
likely , all the mechanisms by which energy can be dissipated have not been examined .
we shall now present a new one caused by the elliptic instability and which is potentially a rather strong source of dissipation .
the elliptic instability has been studied mainly in simple geometries and even in these cases it is a difficult problem .
for a recent review we refer the reader to the work of kerswell ( 2002 ) . presently , the work closest to astrophysical applications is that of seyed - mahmoud et al .
( 2000 ) who investigated this instability in an ellipsoidal configuration for the core of the earth .
the basic result we need from fluid mechanics is the growth rate @xmath39 of this instability , namely @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the ellipticity of streamlines and @xmath42 the rotation rate of the vortex .
schematically , this instability may be seen as a parametric instability : the solid body rotating fluid feels a perturbation ( the ellipticity of the stream lines ) with a frequency @xmath43 .
such a periodic forcing can destabilize modes at half its frequency namely @xmath42 ; this is precisely the frequency of the so - called spin - over modes ( or poincar modes ) .
such modes are solid - body rotation around an axis in the equatorial plane . when the instability develops and the amplitude gets sufficiently large , the vortex start to precess and is usually completely destroyed as observed in experiments ( malkus 1989 ) .
hence , this instability may be very important as it is able to dissipate the total kinetic energy of the vortex .
but let us consider the astrophysical case .
for the sake of simplicity we consider a main sequence star in a binary system with a circular orbit .
the tidal perturbation is provided by a point - mass object .
the system is not synchronized and therefore @xmath44 . in
a reference frame rotating with the tidal potential , the main sequence star is like a strained vortex rotating with the angular velocity @xmath45 and enduring an elongation @xmath46 of the tidal potential .
in such a case the instability develop on a time scale @xmath47 .
the energy available for dissipation is @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the inertia momentum of the zone developing the elliptic instability . in this first attempt ,
we shall consider a late type stars and restrict , conservatively , the action of this instability to the convection zone so that it does not interfere with the stratification .
we note that the spin - over modes which are destabilized are rigid rotations and are thus not affected by the large turbulent viscosity of the fluid .
hence , the power dissipated is approximately @xmath50 with these two quantities , one can estimate the time scale over which synchronization occurs : this is typically the growth of the elliptical instability .
to have orders of magnitude , let us take two solar type stars orbiting their center of mass in 10 days and let their spin be twice faster ( i.e. @xmath51 ) .
the time scale is then 64 years , thus very short .
as far as circularization is concerned , we need to restrict ourselves to weakly eccentric orbits ( @xmath52 say ) . using the stars to dissipate energy while the angular momentum of the orbit is assumed constant ,
the reduction of the eccentricity also occurs on a short time scale , namely a thousand of years .
the numbers thus derived are rather robust as they depend on geometric quantities of the system . in view of the observations , which show that they are systems with a 10 days period which are not circularized nor synchronous
, we may wonder why the elliptic instability is not so efficient in binary stars .
the answer is likely in the much more complex setup yielded by stars compared to their equivalent in the laboratory . in stars ,
there are stratification , magnetic fields , time variable ellipticity ( on eccentric orbits ) , rotation etc ... all these effects have been explored but most of the time using systems which are not quite similar to a star .
nevertheless , we shall list them and speculate about their effects in a stellar situation .
* * rotation * of the frame associated with the orbital motion influences the elliptic instability through the coriolis force . craik ( 1989 ) has shown , but using an unbounded strained flow , that rotation is either stabilizing or destabilizing .
it is stabilizing if , for instance , in an inertial frame , the star does not rotate .
* * stratification : * similarly to rotation , stratification does not act in a unique sense ; using the context of an elliptical cylinder kerswell ( 1993 ) has shown that stratification is stabilizing for polar regions of a star but destabilizing for equatorial regions . * * magnetic fields * were found invariably stabilizing ( see kerswell 1994 ) . *
* time - periodic ellipticity * is likely destabilizing through parametric instabilities .
however , the only studied cases are those of an unbounded strained fluid ( kerswell 2002 ) . * * nonlinear effects * are the most difficult to appreciate .
experiments have shown that the nonlinear development is violent ( aldridge et al .
1997 ) and rapidly leads to a turbulent state ( malkus 1989 ) .
in fact , it seems that the saturated state exists only in a very narrow range of parameters and beyond this range secondary instabilities due to triadic interactions of inertial modes lead to small scale motions and a turbulent state ( mason and kerswell 1999 ) .
+ globally , the way the instability saturates may be thought as a change of the spin axis of the fluid so as to reduce the ellipticity of the streamlines .
in stars such an effect is possible if the spin axis of stars is inclined in the plane normal to the orbital plane and passing through the centres of mass .
this shows that the apparently inocuous hypothesis of angular momentum vectors alignment may be crucial to the instability .
it may also be an observational signature .
indeed , we noticed that the turbulent viscosity of convection zone could hardly inhibit the resonance of spin - over modes ; however , it can easily suppress secondaries instabilities which , in laboratory experiments lead to a turbulent state .
it may well be that the saturated state is difficult to obtain in the laboratory but much more easily in stars .
the foregoing discussion shows that many points of the elliptic instability in the stellar context remain in the shadows ; but because of its great potential dissipative power , this instability deserves more study .
born together , stars of a binary system share the same age and the same initial metallicity . in most favourable cases , their mass , radii , rotation rates can be determined .
these are of course very interesting pieces for the puzzle of stellar evolution but there is a price to pay for these additional informations : the two stars interact during their whole lifetime . in its simplest form
this interaction is of gravitational origin and generates tides .
as we have shown , tides generate various fluid flows giving rise to transport processes which may be observationnally constrained if a comparison with analogous isolated stars is possible .
the foregoing presentation which sketched out all the known mechanisms by which energy is dissipated also shows that the situation is not simple .
various processes can dissipate energy and we suggest that among them the elliptic instability plays a non negligible part . quite surprisingly , this instability has been overlooked until now . despite its strength , shown by laboratory experiments , observations do not show , yet , an evidence of this instability . in the list of the mechanisms which may inhibit this instability , we noticed the misalignement of rotation axis .
as such a misalignement may also result from a saturated state of this instability and can be an observational signature , it deserves some study . * on the theoretical side more work is obviously needed on the effects of the elliptic instability . * on models , the integration of stellar evolution combined with dynamical ( tidal ) evolution following up the works of claret and cunha ( 1997 ) and witte and savonije ( 1999b ) will be useful to understand , for instance , the statistical properties of eccentricities as a function of periods and ages , or the relative importance of pre - main sequence , main sequence , post - main sequence phases .
* on the observational side , much data are needed .
first , the elements describing the dynamics are very much desired : these are the elements of the orbit @xmath53 , the masses m@xmath0 , m@xmath1 , the spins @xmath54 and their variations with time . for instance , the motion of the apsidal line @xmath55 is a quantity constraining the mass distribution of the stars and therefore their internal rotation .
it is clear that such data will require a lot of efforts but they will help us much in our understanding of stellar evolution .
a pulsar like j0045 - 7319 , which travels around an early - type star on a highly eccentric orbit , offers a good step in this direction ( lai et al .
1995 ) .
aldridge k. , seyed - mahmoud b. , henderson g. and van wijngaarden w. , 1997 , phys .
earth plan .
int . , * 103 * , 365 claret a. and cunha n. , 1997 , , * 318 * , 187 craik a. , 1989 , j. fluid mech . , * 198 * , 275 goldreich , p. and keeley , d. , 1977 , , * 212 * , 243 kerswell , r. , 1993 , geophys
. astrophys .
fluid dyn . , * 71 * , 105 kerswell , r. , 1994 , j. fluid mech . ,
* 274 * , 219 kerswell , r. , 2002 , ann .
fluid mech . ,
* 34 * , 83 lai d. , bildsten l. and kaspi v. , 1995 , , * 452 * , 819 malkus w. , 1989 , geophys .
fluid dyn . , * 48 * , 123 mason d. and kerswell r. , 1999 , j. fluid mech . , * 396 * , 73 mathieu r. d. , duquennoy a. , latham d. w. , mayor m. , mermilliod t. , mazeh , j. c. , 1992 , binaries as tracers of stellar formation .
proceedings of a workshop held in bettmeralp , switzerland , sept .
1991 , edts a. duquennoy , m. mayor , p. 278 rieutord , m. , 1992 , , * 259 * , 581 rieutord , m. and zahn , j .-
, 1997 , , * 474 * , 760 seyed - mahmoud b. , henderson g. and aldridge k.d .
, 2000 , phys .
earth plan .
int . , * 117 * , 51 tassoul , j .- l . , 1987 , , * 322 * , 856 witte , m. and savonije , g. , 1999a , , * 341 * , 842 witte , m. and savonije , g. , 1999b , , * 350 * , 129 witte , m. and savonije , g. , 2001 , , * 366 * , 840 zahn , j .-
, 1966 , ann .
astrophys . ,
* 29 * , 313 , 489 , 565 .
zahn , j .-
, 1970 , , * 4 * , 452 zahn , j .- p . , 1975 , ,
* 41 * , 329 | in this review , we describe the physical processes driving the dynamical evolution of binary stars , namely the circularization of the orbit and the synchronization of their spin and orbital rotation . we also discuss the possible role of the elliptic instability which turns out to be an unavoidable ingredient of the evolution of binary stars .
# 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
boundary - layer theory is crucial in understanding why certain phenomena occur .
it is well known that the instability of boundary layers is sensitive to the mean velocity profile , so that a small distortion to the basic flow may have a detrimental effect on its stability .
prandtl ( 1904)*@xcite * proposed that viscous effects would be confined to thin layers adjacent to boundaries in the case of the motion of fluids with very little viscosity i.e. in the case of flows for which the characteristic reynolds number , @xmath5 , is large . in a more general sense
we will use boundary - layer theory ( blt ) to refer to any large - reynolds - number . ho and denn studied low reynolds number stability for plane poiseuille flow by using a numerical scheme based on the shooting method .
they found that at low reynolds numbers no instabilities occur , but the numerical method led to artificial instabilities.lee and finlayson used a similar numerical method to study both poiseuille and couette flow , and confirmed the absence of instabilities at low reynolds number .
r. n. ray et al * @xcite * investigated the linear stability of plane poiseuille flow at small reynolds number of a conducting oldroyd fluid in the presence of magnetic field .
they found that viscoelastic parameters have destabilizing effect and magnetic field has a stabilizing effect in the field of flow but no instabilities are found . in this paper , we study the linear stability of boundary layer in a plane + poiseuille flow . for this , we derive two fourth - order equations name modified fourth - order orr - sommerfeld equations governing the stability analysis in boundary layer for the flow .
the first is obtained by making dimensionless quantities by the inertial effects .
the second takes into account the form adopted by the rheologists i.e. make the quantities dimensionless by normalizing by the viscous effects .
this allowed us to see the effect of each type of normalization on the stability in the boundary layer .
so , we solve numerically the corresponding eigenvalues problems .
we employ matlab in all our numerical computations to find eigenvalues .
the paper is organized as follows . in the second section
the boundary layer theory is presented . in the third section we present the general formulation , highlighting the fundamental equations that model the flat - plate boundary layer flow according to the normalization by inertial and viscous effects . in the fourth section
the modified orr - sommerfeld equations governing the stability analysis in boundary layer are checked and in the fifth section , analysis of the stability is investigated .
the conclusions and perspectives are presented in the final section .
when applying the theory of complex potential around an airfoil in considering the model of inviscid incompressible irrotational plan flow , we know that the model allows to deduce the lift but the drag is zero .
this is contrary to experimental observations which show that the drag affects all flows of real fluids .
these are viscous .
they adhere to the walls and the tangential component of the velocity is zero if the wall is fixed
. the latter condition can be satisfied by the perfect fluid . moreover ,
the irrotational condition is far from reality as we know that the production of vorticity occurs at the walls . to remedy the deficiencies of the theory of perfect fluid
, it must appeal to the theory of the boundary layer which is a necessary correction for flows with high reynolds numbers .
theoris the boundary layer is due to l. prandtl**@xcite**. the boundary layer is the area of the flow which is close to the wall or of an obstacle present in a uniform flow at the upstream infinity or on the confining walls of internal flow . within
the boundary layer is a thin zone , it is estimated that viscous effects are of the same magnitude as the inertial effects .
the boundary layer is the place of intense generation of vorticity which will not diffuse into the area outside thereof .
this leads to a very modern concept of comprehensive approach to the problem by breaking it down into two areas : firstly the boundary layer where we will consider the viscous effects in a model of simplified navier - stokes and other from the outer area where we will use the complex potential theory in the inviscid incompressible flow .
this outer zone has speeds which are of the same order of magnitude as that of the incident flow .
the boundary layer along an obstacle is therefore thin since the fluid travel great distances downstream of the leading edge during the time interval during which the vortex diffuse only a small distance from the wall .
the creation of vorticity in the boundary layer allows the physical realization of the fluid flow around the profile .
this movement gives rise to a wake in the area near the trailing edge .
the importance of the wake depend on the shape of the obstacle and the angle of incidence of the upstream flow at the leading edge .
we consider incompressible flow of a fluid with constant density @xmath6 and dynamic viscosity @xmath7 , past a body with typical length @xmath8 .
we assume that a typical velocity scale is @xmath9 , and the reynolds number is given by @xmath10 for simplicity we will , for the most part , consider two - dimensional incompressible flows , although many of our statements can be generalised to three - dimensional flowsand / or compressible flows .
boundary layer theory applies to flows where there are extensive inviscid regions separated by thin shear layers , say , of typical width @xmath11 .
for one such shear layer take local dimensional cartesian coordinates @xmath12 and @xmath13 along and across the shear layer respectively .
denote the corresponding velocity components by @xmath14 and @xmath15 respectively , pressure by @xmath16 and time by @xmath17 . on the basis of scaling arguments
it then follows that @xmath18 further , it can also be deduced that the key approximations in classical boundary layer theory are that the pressure is constant across the shear layer i.e. @xmath19 and that streamwise diffusion is negligible , i.e. if @xmath20 represents any variable @xmath21 the former approximation is more significant dynamically .
now , using the transformations @xmath22 and taking the limit @xmath23 , the boundary layer theory equations can be deduced from the navier - stokes equations : @xmath24 @xmath25 for flow past a rigid body the appropriate boundary conditions are @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the inviscid slip velocity past the body .
further , from ( 6 ) evaluated at the edge of the boundary layer @xmath28 we define the viscous blowing velocity out of the boundary layer to be @xmath29 @xmath30 indicates the strength of blowing , or suction , at the edge of the boundary layer induced by viscous effects .
it is good diagnostic for dynamically significant effects within the boundary layer much better than , say , the wall shear @xmath31 which can remain regular while @xmath32 becomes unbounded .
consider an incompressible boundary layer over a flat plate as illustrated in the following figure**@xcite**. the streamwise coordinate @xmath33 is scaled with the length scale @xmath34 , which is a fixed distance from the leading edge .
the wall - normal and spanwise coordinates @xmath35 and @xmath36 , respectively , are scaled with the boundary - layer parameter @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the kinematic viscosity of the fluid and @xmath39 is the streamwise freestream velocity at the distance @xmath34 from the leading edge .
the streamwise velocity @xmath40 is scaled with @xmath39 , while the wall- normal and spanwise velocities @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively , are scaled with @xmath43 . the pressure @xmath44 is scaled with @xmath45 and the time @xmath46 is scaled with @xmath47 . the reynolds numbers used here are defined as @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
it is useful to note the relations @xmath50 .
we want to study the linear stability of a high reynolds number flow .
the non - dimensional navier
stokes equations for an incompressible flow where pressure and time are normalized by inertial effects @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 where @xmath55 are linearized around a two - dimensional , steady base flow @xmath56 to obtain the stability equations for the spatial evolution of three - dimensional , time - dependent disturbances @xmath57 .
the base flow and the disturbances are scaled in the same way .
the disturbances are taken to be periodic in the spanwise direction and time , which allows us to assume solutions of the form @xmath58 where @xmath59 represents either one of the disturbances @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 or @xmath44 .
the complex streamwise wave number @xmath60 captures the fast wavelike variation of the modes and is therefore scaled with @xmath61 .
@xmath60 itself is assumed to vary slowly with @xmath33 .
since @xmath33 is scaled with @xmath34 , the factor @xmath3 appears in front of the integral .
the @xmath33-dependence in the amplitude function @xmath62 includes the weak variation of the disturbances .
the real spanwise wave number @xmath63 and angular frequency @xmath64 are scaled in a consistent way with @xmath36 and @xmath46 , respectively . introducing the assump- tion ( 11 ) in the linearized navier
stokes equations and neglecting all third order terms in @xmath65 or higher , we arrive at the parabolized stability equations in boundary - layer scalings @xmath66 @xmath67 @xmath68 @xmath69 where @xmath70 .
if we normalize pressure and time by viscous effects i.e. @xmath46 scaled with @xmath71 and @xmath44 scaled with @xmath72 the navier - stokes equations take the following forms @xmath51 @xmath73 @xmath74 @xmath75 the linearized navier - stokes equations with the previous disturbances under the same considerations become @xmath66 @xmath76 @xmath77 @xmath78 where @xmath70 .
considering temporal the stability problem with @xmath79 and @xmath80 real , we will simplify the problem
. our strategy will be first to eliminate @xmath14 , @xmath81 , @xmath16 to leave a single equation in @xmath15 .
this can be used finally to determine the linear stability ( or instability ) in the boundary layer oy the base flow .
remember that @xmath82 and if @xmath83 , the flow is stable ; @xmath84 , the flow is unstable and we have neutral stability if @xmath4 .
taking @xmath85 + @xmath86 we get @xmath87 using the continuity equation ( 16 ) , ( 28 ) becomes @xmath88 operating across ( 29 ) with @xmath89 , using the assumptions in boundary layer and the equation ( 18 ) we get the modified orr - sommerfeld equation for the boundary layer @xmath90 considering normalization with viscous effects we would have @xmath91
we put equations ( 30)-(31 ) respectively in the form @xmath92 and @xmath93 in order to investigate the application of the squire theorem , consider first the normalization with inertial effects ( [ iner ] ) . often , however , we are only interested in the instability that appears first as the control parameter @xmath94 is increased . in this case ,
squire s theorem tells us that we need only consider @xmath0 disturbances .
consider a base state @xmath95 .
imagine a growing @xmath96 disturbance to this base state at reynolds number @xmath97 , with wavenumbers @xmath98 , @xmath99 , and @xmath100 .
this corresponds to a solution @xmath101 , @xmath15 with @xmath84 ( of the modified orr - sommerfeld equation @xmath102 now consider a @xmath0 disturbance at a reynolds number @xmath103 .
this has @xmath104 , @xmath105 and must satisfy the @xmath0 modified orr - sommerfeld equation @xmath106 for values @xmath107 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 , this @xmath0 modified orr - sommerfeld equation has the form @xmath110 which is exactly the same as [ td ] .
it must therefore have the same growing solution @xmath111 with @xmath84 .
therefore , corresponding to the growing @xmath96 disturbance at @xmath112 with @xmath98 , @xmath99 , and @xmath100 , there exists a growing @xmath0 disturbance at @xmath103 with @xmath109 and @xmath113 .
these conditions lead to @xmath114 and we get that the disturbances are two - dimensional . finally , we get @xmath115 , not @xmath116 . and so , we can not applied the squire s theorem in the boundary layer of the flow . using the same assumptions in ( [ vis ] ) , we get first @xmath117 with @xmath118 i.e. @xmath119 and
secondly @xmath120 with @xmath118 i.e. @xmath119 . so we have first @xmath121 and secondly @xmath116 because @xmath122 .
we see therefore that we must take @xmath123 and so @xmath114 . we find the same result that the disturbances are two - dimensional and then squire s theorem ca nt be applied .
finally , we still consider our three - dimensional disturbances so without using the theorem of squire .
thus we write @xmath124 with @xmath125 .
this will allow us to deduce numerically whether the application of squire s theorem in the boundary layer .
indeed @xmath1 corresponds to a two dimensional disturbance i.e @xmath126 .
we employ matlab ( windows version ) in all our numerical computations to find eigenvalues .
a poiseuille flow with the basic profile @xmath127 is considered . the eigenvalue problems ( 32)-(33 )
are solved numerically with the suitable boundary conditions .
the solutions are found in a layer bounded at @xmath128 with @xmath129 .
the results of calculations are presented in the following figures . in each group of figures ,
the first one is figure @xmath130 , the second is figure @xmath131 and the third is figure @xmath132 .
first we present the figures relatives to the eigenvalue problem ( 32 ) . for a fixed @xmath133 ,
we get figure 1 of @xmath134 vs @xmath135 for sequential values of @xmath136 in which @xmath130 shows the entire graph . @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the magnified versions of @xmath130 . for a fixed @xmath137 , we get figure 2 of @xmath134 vs @xmath135 for sequential values of @xmath136 in which @xmath130 shows the entire graph . @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the magnified versions of @xmath130 . for a fixed @xmath138
, we get figure 3 of @xmath134 vs @xmath135 for sequential values of @xmath136 in which @xmath130 shows the entire graph . @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the magnified versions of @xmath130 . secondly we present the figures relatives to the eigenvalue problem ( 33 ) . for a fixed @xmath133 ,
we get figure 4 of @xmath134 vs @xmath135 for sequential values of @xmath136 in which @xmath130 shows the entire graph . @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the magnified versions of @xmath130 . for a fixed @xmath137 , we get figure 5 of @xmath134 vs @xmath135 for sequential values of @xmath136 in which @xmath130 shows the entire graph . @xmath131 and @xmath132 are the magnified versions of @xmath130 . through the figures @xmath139 and
@xmath140 , it is easy to see that if we take a curve with @xmath141 in the instability area @xmath142 , we do nt have necessary in the two normalization @xmath143 .
we also see through the figures that the normalization of time and pressure by inertial effects or viscous effects lead to the same order of stability / instability in the boundary layer .
this confirms that in the boundary layer , viscous forces are on the same magnitude as the inertial forces i.e. the local reynolds number is on unity order .
we see also through the figures that at low reynolds number the flow is stable but if the reynolds number increase , unstability appears .
the increase of the wave number induce also the stability of the flow . by figures
@xmath144 and @xmath145 we find the first value of @xmath3 and @xmath60 for which the first transition from stability to instability occurs i.e. @xmath4 in the case @xmath1 .
we find the values @xmath146 which corresponds exactly to the one we know as critical value of the neutral stability of poiseuille flow .
note that this value is the same in figure @xmath147 which corresponds to normalization by inertial effects and in figure @xmath148 which corresponds to normalization by viscous effects .
we noticed also that for all overs values of @xmath2 in the case @xmath1 correspond the same values of @xmath3 at @xmath4 whatever the normalization . we therefore conclude that in the boundary layer with a 2d - disturbance , we have the same neutral stability curve whatever the normalization .
vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath133 ; ( b ) zoom of ( a ) to small values of k ; ( c ) zoom of ( b ) to small values of @xmath149 .
, width=377 ] vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath137 ; ( b ) zoom of ( a ) to small values of k ; ( c ) zoom of ( b ) to small values of @xmath149 . ,
width=377 ] vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath138 ; ( b ) zoom of ( a ) to small values of k ; ( c ) zoom of ( b ) to small values of @xmath149 . ,
width=377 ] vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath133 ; ( b ) zoom of ( a ) to small values of k ; ( c ) zoom of ( b ) to small values of @xmath149 . ,
width=377 ] vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath137 ; ( b ) zoom of ( a ) to small values of k ; ( c ) zoom of ( b ) to small values of @xmath149 . ,
width=377 ] vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath150 in the case of inertial effects normalization showing the critical reynolds number for @xmath0-disturbances ; ( b ) growth rate @xmath151 vs. reynolds number @xmath149 for @xmath150 in the case of viscous effects normalization showing the critical reynolds number for @xmath0-disturbances .
, width=377 ]
in this paper , we have investigated the stability of boundary layer in poiseuille flow .
we have shown that the instability of the perturbed flow is governed by a remarkably equation named modified orr - sommerfeld equation .
contrary to what one might think , we find that squire s theorem is not applicable for the boundary layer .
we find also that normalization by inertial or viscous effects leads to the same order of stability or instability .
for the @xmath0 disturbances flow ( @xmath1 ) , we found the same critical reynolds number for our two normalizations .
this value coincides with the one we know for neutral stability of the known orr - sommerfeld equation .
we noticed also that for all overs values of @xmath2 in the case @xmath1 correspond the same values of @xmath3 at @xmath4 whatever the normalization . we therefore conclude that in the boundary layer with a 2d - disturbance , we have the same neutral stability curve whatever the normalization .
the authors thank imsp - uac for financial support .
99 j. g. oldroyd .
_ on the formulation of rheological equations of state_. proc .
london ser .
a. 200 ( 1950 ) , 523541 .
mr 11,703a .
t. c. ho and m. m. denn .
_ stability of plane poiseuille flow of a highly elastic liquid_. j. non- newtonian fluid mech . 3 ( 1977 ) , 179195 .
zbl 414.76008 .
bertolotti , f. p. , herbert , t. and spalart.p .
r _ linear and nonlinear stability of the blasius boundary layer_.j .
fluid mech , 1992 , 242 , 441474 .
k. c. lee and b. a. finlayson .
_ stability of plane poiseuille and couette flow of a maxwell fluid_. j. non - newtonain fluid mech . 21 ( 1986 ) , 6578 .
zbl 587.76059 .
r. c. lock . _ the stability of the flow of an electrically conducting fluid between parallel planes under a transverse magnetic field_. proc .
london ser .
a. 233 ( 1955 ) , 105125 .
mr 18,700a .
abu - ghannam , b. and shaw , r. _ natural transition of boundary layers - the effects of turbulence , pressure gradient , and flow history_. j. mech .
sci.1980- 22 ( 5 ) , 213228 .
andersson , p. , berggren , m. and henningson , d. _ optimal disturbances and bypass transition in boundary layers .
phys_.fluids 11 ( 1),1999 , 134150 .
andersson , p. , henningson , d. and hanifi , a. _ on a stabilization procedure for the parabolic stability equations_. j. eng .
math.1998 , 33 , 311332 .
landau , l. & lifchitz , e. m. _ fluid mechanics_. butterworth heinemann , oxford , 1997 .
ray , samad , and chaudhury : department of mathematics , university of burdwan , burdwan-713104 , west bengal , india . | for applications regarding transition prediction , wing design and control of boundary layers , the fundamental understanding of disturbance growth in the flat - plate boundary layer is an important issue . in the present work
we investigate the stability of boundary layer in poiseuille flow .
we normalize pressure and time by inertial and viscous effects .
the disturbances are taken to be periodic in the spanwise direction and time .
we present a set of linear governing equations for the parabolic evolution of wavelike disturbances .
then , we derive modified orr - sommerfeld equations that can be applied in the layer .
contrary to what one might think , we find that squire s theorem is not applicable for the boundary layer .
we find also that normalization by inertial or viscous effects leads to the same order of stability or instability .
for the @xmath0 disturbances flow ( @xmath1 ) , we found the same critical reynolds number for our two normalizations .
this value coincides with the one we know for neutral stability of the known orr - sommerfeld equation .
we noticed also that for all overs values of @xmath2 in the case @xmath1 correspond the same values of @xmath3 at @xmath4 whatever the normalization .
we therefore conclude that in the boundary layer with a 2d - disturbance , we have the same neutral stability curve whatever the normalization .
we find also that for a flow with hight hydrodynamic reynolds number , the neu- tral disturbances in the boundary layer are two - dimensional . at last
, we find that transition from stability to instability or the opposite can occur according to the reynolds number and the wave number .
institut de mathmatiques et de sciences physiques , bp : 613 porto novo , bnin the abdus salam international centre for theoretical physics , trieste , italy |
deep - inelastic scattering provides one of the most direct methods to measure the strong coupling constant from precision data on the scaling violations of the nucleon structure functions @xcite .
the present accuracy of these data also allows to measure the mass of the charm , cf .
@xcite , and bottom quarks due to the heavy flavor contributions .
the wilson coefficients are known to 2-loop order in semi - analytic form @xcite in the tagged - flavor case , i.e. for the subset in which the hadronic final state contains at least one heavy quark , having been produced in the hard scattering process .
the corresponding reduced cross section does not correspond to the notion of structure functions , since those are purely inclusive quantities and terms containing massless final states contribute as well .
the heavy flavor contribution to inclusive deep - inelastic structure functions are described by five wilson coefficients in the case of pure photon exchange @xcite . in the asymptotic case @xmath7 , where @xmath8 denotes the virtuality of the exchanged gauge boson and @xmath9 the mass of the heavy quark
, analytic expressions for the wilson coefficients have been calculated .
a series of mellin moments has been computed to 3-loop order in @xcite .
all logarithmic 3-loop corrections @xcite as well as all @xmath10 terms are known @xcite .
four out of five wilson coefficients contributing to the unpolarized deep inelastic structure functions have been calculated to 3-loop order for general values of mellin @xmath11 @xcite in the asymptotic region @xmath7 . in the flavor non - singlet case also
the asymptotic 3-loop contributions to the combinations of the polarized structure functions @xmath12 @xcite and the unpolarized charged current structure function @xmath13 have been computed @xcite . in the present paper
, we calculate the complete 2-loop non - singlet heavy flavor corrections to the deep inelastic charged current structure functions @xmath14 and the neutral current structure functions @xmath15 and @xmath16 and a series of sum rules in the deep inelastic region , @xmath17 . in the asymptotic case @xmath7 the corresponding wilson coefficients have been calculated in @xcite to @xmath0 and in @xcite to @xmath18 . here
the massless wilson coefficients @xcite to @xmath18 enter . in the tagged flavor case
the corresponding corrections to @xmath0 have been calculated in @xcite and in the asymptotic charged current case in @xcite .
the associated sum rules are the adler sum rule @xcite , the unpolarized bjorken sum rule @xcite , the polarized bjorken sum rule @xcite , and the gross
llewellyn smith sum rule @xcite . a central observation in the inclusive case
is that there are no logarithmic corrections for the associated sum rules at large @xmath4 , which are present in the tagged flavor case @xcite , however .
the complete massive @xmath0 corrections to the structure functions improves the accuracy towards lower values of @xmath4 . in the case of the sum rules ,
the corresponding contributions are found to be of the order of the known massless 4-loop corrections .
we will also consider the target mass corrections to the sum rules , since they are relevant in the region of low @xmath4 .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec:2 ]
we present a general outline on the massive wilson coefficients for the structure functions which will be considered .
the @xmath0 corrections to the polarized non - singlet neutral current structure functions @xmath19 and @xmath20 are derived in detail in section [ sec:3 ] as an example . in section [ sec:4 ]
we discuss the corrections to the neutral current structure functions @xmath21 , and in section [ sec:5 ] those to the non - singlet charged current structure functions @xmath22 .
detailed numerical results are presented for all the seven non - singlet structure functions for experimental use .
the heavy flavor @xmath0 corrections and target mass corrections to the associated sum rules are computed in section [ sec:6 ] , comparing massless and massive effects and numerical results are presented for the target mass corrections .
section [ sec:7 ] contains the conclusions .
the appendices contain technical parts of the calculation .
we consider the heavy flavor corrections to deep - inelastic structure functions , which are inclusive observables , i.e. the hadronic final state in the corresponding differential scattering cross sections is summed over completely . under this condition
the kinoshita - lee - nauenberg theorem @xcite is valid and no infrared singularities , which have to be eventually cured by arbitrary cuts , are present @xcite .
as we consider deep - inelastic scattering , both the scales @xmath4 and @xmath23 have to be large enough , to probe the interior of the nucleon . here
@xmath24 denotes the nucleon mass , @xmath25 is the bjorken variable , with @xmath26 , and @xmath27 the inelasticity , and @xmath28 and @xmath29 the incoming nucleon and lepton 4-momenta .
one usually demands @xmath30 . to fully avoid the region of higher twist terms ,
a cut @xmath31 @xcite is necessary .
the structure functions are then given by @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the fully massless part of the structure function and @xmath34 contains contributions due to a heavy quark mass @xmath35 or @xmath36 .
both quantities are inclusive .
@xmath34 does not correspond to the so - called tagged flavor case , demanding a heavy quark in the hadronic final state . in the asymptotic case @xmath7 , the wilson coefficients contributing to ( [ eq : fi ] )
were calculated for the non - singlet neutral current structure functions @xmath37 and @xmath38 and the non - singlet charged current structure function @xmath39 @xcite to @xmath18 ( nnlo ) .
the unpolarized and polarized neutral current non - singlet structure functions in the case of pure photon exchange are given by @xmath40 \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{5 cm } \otimes \left[f_k(x,\mu^2,n_f ) + f_{\bar{k}}(x,\mu^2,n_f ) \right ] \\
g_{i}^{\rm ns}(x , q^2 ) & = & \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{k=1}^{n_f } e_k^2 \left[\delta c_{g_i , q}^{\rm ns}\left(x , n_f,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) + \delta l_{g_i , q}^{\rm ns}\left(x , n_f+1,\frac{q^2}{m^2 } , \frac{m^2}{\mu^2}\right)\right ] \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{5 cm } \otimes \left[\delta f_k(x,\mu^2,n_f ) + \delta f_{\bar{k}}(x,\mu^2,n_f ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath41 . here
@xmath10 is the number of active flavors , @xmath42 the electric charge of the massless quarks , and @xmath43 ; @xmath44 and @xmath45 denote the corresponding massless wilson coefficients and @xmath46 and @xmath47 the massive ones , @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the unpolarized ( polarized ) quark and anti - quark distribution functions , and @xmath50 is the factorization scale .
here we follow again the convention used in @xcite , ( 2.26 ) .
the notion ` @xmath51 ' in @xmath52 means that the wilson coefficient is calculated for @xmath10 massless and one massive flavor . for the unpolarized charged current structure functions
@xmath53 a second wilson coefficient @xmath54 contributes , which in the case of charm describes the flavor excitation @xmath55 in addition to or without heavy flavor pair production and possible virtual heavy quark corrections .
this transition contributes already at tree level . here
@xmath56 denotes the cabibbo - angle @xcite .
the complete corrections to @xmath57 have been calculated in @xcite . at @xmath0
the asymptotic heavy flavor corrections have been calculated in @xcite and for @xmath58 + @xmath59 to @xmath18 in ref .
@xcite . beyond the terms of @xmath57 we will use the results in the asymptotic case for the numerical illustrations given below .
note that the latter contributions are cabibbo suppressed @xmath60 given the present experimental accuracy , this approximation is justified , leaving the full calculation for the future .
the polarized flavor non - singlet neutral current structure functions @xmath37 receive massless and massive qcd corrections , where the latter contribute starting at @xmath70 . in the following we will give a detailed discussion of the heavy flavor contributions to @xmath71 as an example .
main aspects of the calculation are given in appendices a and b. to @xmath70 the non - singlet contribution for @xmath72 reads @xmath73 \nonumber\\ & & \otimes \frac{1}{2 } \bigl [ \frac{4}{9 } \delta u_v(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{1}{9 } \delta d_v(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{8}{9 } \delta \bar{u}(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{2}{9 } \left[\delta \bar{d}(x,\mu^2 ) + \delta \bar{s}(x,\mu^2)\right ] \bigr]~. \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath74 and @xmath75 denote the polarized valence quark densities , @xmath76 and @xmath77 are the polarized sea quark distributions , @xmath78 denotes the mellin convolution , @xmath79 and the massless wilson coefficient is given by @xmath80 with @xmath81(x ) -
\beta_0 p_{qq}^{(0)}\right\ } \ln^2\left(\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \left\{p_{qq}^{(1),{\rm ns,-}}(x ) + \left[p_{qq}^{(0 ) } \otimes c_{g_1,q}^{(1)}\right](x ) - \beta_0 c_{g_1,q}^{(1)}(x ) \right\ } \ln\left(\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) + c_{g_1,q}^{(2)}(x)~ , \nonumber\\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] cf .
e.g. @xcite . here
@xmath82 is the leading order splitting function @xmath83 with the @xmath84-prescription being defined by @xmath85_+ g(x ) = \int_0 ^ 1 dx [ g(x ) - g(1 ) ] f(x)~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the nlo non - singlet splitting functions @xmath86 were calculated in @xcite for the scale evolution operator in the renormalization group equation . ] , the quarkonic one - loop wilson coefficient @xmath87 for the structure function @xmath88 @xcite is given by @xmath89 \biggr]\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath90 has been calculated in ref .
the color factors are @xmath91 for @xmath92 and @xmath93 in quantum chromodynamics . here and in
the following we set the factorization and renormalization scales both to @xmath94 .
the @xmath70 wilson coefficient @xmath95 receives contributions from the feynman diagrams shown in figures [ qcdcomp ] and [ onelb0q ] .
the diagrams of the compton process , figure [ qcdcomp ] , describe the real production of a heavy quark pair in the kinematic range @xmath96 of the parton momentum fraction , and contain no singularities , enabling their calculation in @xmath97 dimensions .
compton diagrams at @xmath70 .
the dashed ( full ) lines denote massless ( massive ) quarks , respectively.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] we obtain @xmath98 \ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}{1-\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } + 2 \biggl [ - { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{(1-z)\left(1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}\right)}{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } } \right ) + { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{1- \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}{1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } + { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{1 - \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { 1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}\right ) - { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { 1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}\right)\biggr]\bigg\ } \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } + \bigg\{-\frac{8}{3}+\frac{4}{1-z}+\left(\frac{z}{(1-z)\xi}\right)^2\left(-16 + 32z-\frac{8}{1-z}\right)\bigg\ } \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } \times \ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}{1-\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } \right ) + \bigg\{\frac{64}{9}+\frac{112}{9}z-\frac{152}{9}\frac{1}{1-z } + \frac{z}{(1-z)\xi } \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } \times \bigg[\frac{512}{9}-\frac{128}{3}z + \frac{848}{9}z^2\bigg ] + \left(\frac{z}{(1-z)\xi}\right)^2\bigg[-\frac{640}{9}+\frac{1408}{9}z-\frac{2368}{9}z^2 \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } + \frac{1600}{9}z^3\bigg]\biggr\}\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } } \ln\left(\frac { \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } - \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}\right ) + \bigg\{-\frac{188}{27 } \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } -\frac{872}{27}z + \frac{718}{27}\frac{1}{1-z}+\frac{z}{(1-z)\xi}\bigg[-\frac{952}{27}+\frac{1520}{27}z -\frac{800}{9}z^2 \nonumber\\ & & \hspace*{-12 mm } + \frac{20}{27}\frac{1}{1-z}\bigg]\bigg\ } \sqrt{1 - \frac{4z}{(1-z ) \xi}}~~ \bigg ] \theta\left(\frac{\xi}{\xi+4 } - z\right ) , \label{eq : lns1c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath99 in appendix [ sec : a ] the principal steps of the calculation of ( [ eq : lns1c ] ) are outlined . for this contribution to @xmath100
we agree with the result given in @xcite .
the inclusive scattering cross section , however , receives also contributions from the virtual corrections shown in figure [ onelb0q ] . heavy flavor corrections .
( a ) and ( b ) bremsstrahlung amplitudes ; ( c ) interference term of the born amplitude and the vertex correction .
the graphs of the self - energy terms contributing to ( c ) are not shown , but are discussed in appendix b.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=10.0% ] heavy flavor corrections .
( a ) and ( b ) bremsstrahlung amplitudes ; ( c ) interference term of the born amplitude and the vertex correction . the graphs of the self - energy terms contributing to ( c ) are not shown , but are discussed in appendix b.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=10.0% ] heavy flavor corrections .
( a ) and ( b ) bremsstrahlung amplitudes ; ( c ) interference term of the born amplitude and the vertex correction .
the graphs of the self - energy terms contributing to ( c ) are not shown , but are discussed in appendix b.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=22.0% ] + ( a ) ( b ) ( c ) in the bremsstrahlung corrections ( a , b ) to these diagrams , the heavy flavor correction is given by the one - loop polarization function @xmath101 .
the polarization insertion @xmath102 also appears in the virtual correction ( c ) . for technical reasons we decompose
@xmath103 $ ] and combine the first term with the contributions due to ( a , b ) .
this yields the term @xmath104,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath105 .
the term ( [ eq : massless_g1 ] ) corresponds to a heavy flavor contribution in the case of massless final states .
there are also self - energy insertions contributing to ( c ) , which , however , vanish for the term ( [ eq : massless_g1 ] ) since the corresponding graphs at 1-loop vanish and @xmath101 contributes multiplicatively . for the insertion @xmath106
this is not the case , cf .
appendix b. the second term @xmath107 $ ] is now used in the interference term calculating the form factor .
the subtraction term allows to perform the calculation in @xmath97 dimensions , @xmath108 \nonumber\\ & & + \left(\frac{8}{3}-\frac{16}{\xi^2}\right)\left[{{\rm li}}_3\left(\frac{\tilde{\lambda}-1 } { \tilde{\lambda}+1}\right)+{{\rm li}}_3\left(\frac{\tilde{\lambda}+1}{\tilde{\lambda}-1}\right)\right]\biggr\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath109 .
details of the calculation are presented in appendix b. due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 including the charm and bottom quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and @xmath111 @xcite using the nlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ]
the massive wilson coefficient is given by @xmath112 in the following we will use the values @xmath113 at nnlo in the on - shell scheme @xcite for all numerical illustrations , both at @xmath70 and @xmath114 , since we consider the present results as a part of our more general nnlo project , cf .
@xcite , and would like to compare with numerical results given at @xmath114 in @xcite .
the transformation to the @xmath115 scheme for the heavy quark masses is well - known @xcite . in fitting the heavy quark masses from data one would use the corresponding formula . for the illustration given in the following
, their _ equivalent _ value in the on - shell scheme has been used for brevity . in the numerical results given below , we choose for the factorization and renormalization
scales @xmath116 . in the calculation we used the codes hplog , chaplin , hpl and harmonicsums @xcite at different steps .
due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : g1ncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : g1ncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] in figure [ fig : g1ncall ] we illustrate the massless and massive contributions to the non - singlet structure function @xmath118 to @xmath70 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 using the parton distribution functions @xcite . due to the qcd evolution
the peak of the function moves towards smaller values of @xmath117 , keeping its valence - like profile .
the contributions due to charm and bottom are illustrated in figures [ fig : g1pow10 ] and [ fig : g1pow101 ] .
here we also compare the asymptotic expressions with the complete results , which show differences for @xmath119 and become very close for @xmath120 and @xmath121 for charm and at higher scales also for bottom .
the ratio of the heavy quark contributions to the complete structure function are illustrated in figure [ fig : g1ncratios ] . in the range of smaller values of @xmath117
the fraction amounts to @xmath122 , while at larger values of @xmath117 the corrections become negative amounting to @xmath123 .
the asymptotic 3-loop corrections @xcite at @xmath124 are even larger and contribute to @xmath125 at lower values of @xmath117 and amount to @xmath126 at large @xmath117 . here and in the following we
often will make the observation that the asymptotic expressions tend to agree better in the region of small @xmath117 even at lower values of @xmath4 , where this is not expected a priori .
the reason for this is that the relevant effective scale , inside the corresponding integrals , is the hadronic mass squared @xmath127 , rather than @xmath4 itself .
due to photon exchange to the complete structure function up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : g1ncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions .
the dash - dotted line shows the asymptotic result at @xmath18 for @xmath128 . ] at leading twist , the structure function @xmath130 is obtained through the wandzura - wilczek relation @xmath131 here @xmath130 denotes the non - singlet distribution , calculated using @xmath132 , eq .
( [ eq : g1ns ] ) .
the wandzura - wilczek relation has been derived for massless quarks in @xcite , see also @xcite , but possesses a much wider validity as has been shown in later years .
it also holds for scattering off massive quarks @xcite and for the target mass corrections @xcite , as well as for non - forward @xcite and diffractive scattering @xcite and heavy flavor production in photon - gluon fusion @xcite . at leading twist the structure functions @xmath88 and @xmath133 are connected by an operator relation , cf .
representations in the covariant parton model were given in refs .
@xcite . due to photon exchange up to @xmath0
including the charm and bottom quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and @xmath111 @xcite using the nlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ]
due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : g2ncall ] . dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] in figure [ fig : g2ncall ] we illustrate the flavor non - singlet contribution at twist 2 to the structure function @xmath134 for pure photon exchange up to @xmath0 .
it takes values in the range @xmath135 to @xmath136 , with only mild scaling violations varying @xmath4 from @xmath137 to @xmath138 . in figures [ fig : g2heavy ] and [ fig : g2heavy1 ]
we illustrate the heavy flavor corrections due to charm and bottom , respectively .
the effect is of @xmath139 in the case of charm .
we also compare the exact results with those using the asymptotic due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : g2ncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
full lines : @xmath70 contributions ; dashed lines asymptotic @xmath70 contributions .
the dash - dotted line for @xmath124 corresponds to all contributions including also the asymptotic @xmath114 term .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : g2ncall ] . ] representation , in which the power corrections are disregarded , cf .
the effect is clearly visible at lower scales , and fully disappears at @xmath140 in the case of charm . in figure
[ fig : g2heavy2 ] we illustrate the combined heavy flavor effect and also show the asymptotic 3-loop corrections , which turn out to be larger than the exact corrections .
the structure of the wandzura - wilczek relation implies that the associated sum rule for the first moment yields zero . however , this is not a prediction which derives from the light - cone expansion @xcite , since the corresponding moment does not contribute to it as a term .
rather the wandzura - wilczek relation , as an analytic continuation , is compatible with the result , which is also called ( flavor non - singlet ) burkhardt - cottingham sum rule @xcite .
it results from the fact that the imaginary part of @xmath141 obeys a superconvergence relation . unlike a series of other sum rules
, it can not be expressed as an expectation value of ( axial)vector operators @xcite .
in the case of pure photon exchange , the unpolarized neutral current scattering cross section is parameterized by two deep - inelastic structure functions @xmath142 which obey @xmath143 in the absence of target mass corrections @xcite . here @xmath144 denotes the longitudinal structure function . in the following
we will refer to the structure functions @xmath145 and @xmath146 .
the calculation proceeds in a similar way to that outlined in section [ sec:3 ] . in the case of the structure function @xmath146 ,
the compton contribution is given by @xmath148 \biggr ] \nonumber\\ & & - \frac{16}{3 \xi } ( 22 z^2 - z\xi ) \sqrt{1 - \frac{4z } { \xi } } \ln\left(\frac { \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } - \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & -\frac{8}{9(1-z ) \xi } \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}\left[60 z -478 z^2 + 372 z^3 \right .
\nonumber\\ & & \left . - \xi ( 6 - 31 z + 25 z^2)\right ] + \ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}{1-\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & \times \left [ \frac{32(6 z^2 - 9z + 2 ) z^2}{(1-z)^2 \xi^2 } + 96 \frac{z^3}{\xi^2 } \ln \left(\frac{1-z}{z^2}\right)\right ] \biggr\ } \theta\left(\frac{\xi}{\xi+4 } - z\right ) \label{eq : flr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and we confirm the result given in @xcite .
the virtual contribution vanishes and the contribution corresponding to massless final states reads @xmath149 with @xcite @xmath150 expanding @xmath151 for large values of @xmath152 leads to @xmath153 , the corresponding massless 2-loop wilson coefficient @xcite , as predicted by renormalization in ref .
@xcite with no logarithmic term @xmath154 left , unlike the case where we take just the term @xmath155 into account , cf .
@xcite , where @xcite @xmath156 and @xmath157\biggr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the non - singlet structure function for @xmath146 reads @xmath158 \nonumber\\ & & \otimes \bigl [ \frac{4}{9 } u_v(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{1}{9 } d_v(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{8}{9 } \bar{u}(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{2}{9 } \left[\bar{d}(x,\mu^2 ) + \bar{s}(x,\mu^2)\right ] \bigr]~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 including the charm and bottom quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and @xmath111 @xcite using the nnlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ] where @xmath159 and @xmath160 are the unpolarized valence quark densities and @xmath161 and @xmath162 the sea quark densities , due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : flncall ] . dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : flncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] and the massless wilson coefficient is given by @xmath163 with @xcite @xmath164(x ) -
\beta_0 c_{f_l , q}^{(1)}(x)\biggr\ } \ln\left(\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) + c_{f_l ,
q}^{(2)}(x)~. \nonumber\\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] in figure [ fig : flncall ] we show the @xmath70 corrections to the non - singlet structure function @xmath165 , including the complete charm and bottom quark corrections . during evolution
this structure function grows towards small values of @xmath117 .
the absolute charm and bottom quark contributions are illustrated in figures [ fig : fllva ] , [ fig : fllva1 ] . in the present case ,
the corrections in the asymptotic limit are sufficiently close to the complete corrections only for @xmath166 in the case of charm .
it is well known that for @xmath146 the asymptotic representation holds at very high scales only , which also applies to the non - singlet case .
for the charm quark corrections the asymptotic representation holds at @xmath167 .
below there are significant differences .
the situation is correspondingly worse for the bottom quark corrections shown in figure [ fig : fllva1 ] . in general
the asymptotic corrections give larger negative corrections than found in the complete calculation .
the relative heavy flavor corrections for @xmath165 are shown in figure [ fig : flncratios ] .
they behave nearly constant in the small @xmath117 region , amounting to @xmath168 to @xmath169 in the region @xmath170 to @xmath121 , with larger asymptotic corrections . due to photon exchange to the complete structure function up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : flncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] for the structure function @xmath145 , we obtain the following compton contribution @xmath172 \nonumber\\ & & \times \biggl [ \biggl [ \ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}{1-\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}\right ) + \ln\left(\frac{1-z}{z^2}\right ) \biggr ] \ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}{1-\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + 2 \biggl [ - { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{(1-z)\left(1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}\right)}{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } } \right ) + { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{1- \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}{1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & + { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{1 - \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { 1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}\right ) - { { \rm li}}_2\left(\frac{1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { 1 + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi}}}\right ) \biggr ] \biggr ] \nonumber\\ & & + \frac{8}{9(1-z)\xi}\left[26 z -168 z^2 + 188 z^3 - ( 8 - 6z+17z^2 ) \xi\right ] \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } \nonumber\\ & & \times \ln\left(\frac { \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } + \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi } } } { \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{\xi } } - \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}\right ) + \frac{2}{27 ( 1-z)^2 \xi } \sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z ) \xi } } \nonumber\\ & & \times \left [ -1702 z + 9516 z^2 -14260 z^3 + 6456 z^4 \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left . + ( 223 - 709 z + 1108 z^2 -622 z^3 ) \xi\right]\nonumber\\ & & -\frac{4}{3(1-z)^3\xi^2}\left[6z^2(-15 + 70z-90z^2 + 36z^3)-\xi^2(1 - 3z^2 + 2z^3)\right]\nonumber\\ & & \times\ln\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}{1-\sqrt{1-\frac{4z}{(1-z)\xi}}}\right ) \biggr\}\theta\left(\frac{\xi}{\xi+4 } - z\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression agrees with a result given in @xcite .
the virtual correction is the same as in the case of the structure function @xmath118 , eq .
( [ eq : lqnsg1v ] ) , and the contribution with massless final states is given by : @xmath173,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xcite @xmath174 up to @xmath70 the non - singlet structure function @xmath175 reads @xmath176 \nonumber\\ & & \otimes \bigl [ \frac{4}{9 } u_v(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{1}{9 } d_v(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{8}{9 } \bar{u}(x,\mu^2 ) + \frac{2}{9 } \left[\bar{d}(x,\mu^2 ) + \bar{s}(x,\mu^2)\right ] \bigr]\biggr\}~,\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the massless wilson coefficient is given by @xmath177 with @xcite @xmath178(x ) - \beta_0 p_{qq}^{(0)}\right\ } \ln^2\left(\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & + \left\{p_{qq}^{(1),{\rm ns,+}}(x ) + \left[p_{qq}^{(0 ) } \otimes c_{f_2,q}^{(1)}\right](x ) -
\beta_0 c_{f_2,q}^{(1)}(x ) \right\ } \ln\left(\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) + c_{f_2,q}^{(2)}(x)~. \nonumber\\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] in figure [ fig : f2ncall ] we show @xmath179 up to @xmath70 with the complete charm and bottom corrections .
it rises for growing values of @xmath4 for small values of @xmath117 .
the absolute charm and bottom quark corrections are illustrated in figures [ fig : f2pow10 ] and [ fig : f2pow101 ] , illustrating as well the effect of the asymptotic results .
they get close to the exact ones much earlier than in the case of @xmath165 . due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 including the charm and bottom quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and @xmath111 @xcite using the nnlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ] due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2ncall ] . dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ]
the bottom quark contributions shown in figure [ fig : f2pow101 ] are about one order of magnitude smaller than those for charm quarks , still with clear differences between the exact and asymptotic result at @xmath180 .
figure [ fig : f2ncratios ] illustrates the relative contribution of the heavy flavor corrections up to @xmath70 .
the corrections are rather flat in the small @xmath117 region and amount to @xmath181 to @xmath182 for @xmath183 growing towards @xmath184 at large @xmath117 from @xmath185 to @xmath121 .
due to photon exchange up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2ncall ] .
dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ] due to photon exchange to the complete structure function up to @xmath0 as a function of @xmath117 and @xmath4 .
the conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2ncall ] . dashed lines : asymptotic representation in @xmath4 for the heavy flavor corrections ; full lines : complete heavy flavor contributions . ]
in the non - singlet charged current case we have to distinguish transitions between light flavors accompanied with heavy flavor production and the excitation of charm from massless down - type quarks .
due to the smallness of the corresponding ckm - matrix element @xcite we will not consider the excitation of bottom quarks from the massless quarks .
the current values of the contributing ckm - matrix elements are @xmath186 the corresponding flavor non - singlet combinations are given by @xmath187 \otimes \bigl [ \left(|v_{du}|^2 + |v_{su}|^2\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \times u_v(x,\mu^2 ) - |v_{du}|^2 d_v(x,\mu^2 ) \bigr ] \nonumber\\ & & - h_{f_1,q}^{\rm ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \otimes \\ \label{eq : f2cc } f_2^{\bar{\nu}p}(x , q^2 ) - f_2^{{\nu}p}(x , q^2 ) & = & 2x \biggl\{\left[c_{f_2,q}^{\rm ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) + l_{f_2,q}^{\rm ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \right ] \otimes \bigl [ \left(|v_{du}|^2 + |v_{su}|^2\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \times u_v(x,\mu^2 ) - |v_{du}|^2 d_v(x,\mu^2 ) \bigr ] \nonumber\\ & & - h_{f_2,q}^{\rm ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \otimes \\ \label{eq : f3cc } f_3^{\bar{\nu}p}(x , q^2 ) + f_3^{{\nu}p}(x , q^2 ) & = & 2 \biggl\{\left[c_{f_3,q}^{\rm ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2}\right ) + l_{f_3,q}^{\rm
ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \right ] \otimes \bigl[|v_{du}|^2 d_v(x,\mu^2 ) \nonumber\\ & & + \left(|v_{du}|^2 + |v_{su}|^2\right ) u_v(x,\mu^2 ) \bigr ] \nonumber\\ & & + h_{f_3,q}^{\rm ns}\left(x,\frac{q^2}{\mu^2},\frac{m^2}{\mu^2}\right ) \otimes @xmath188 , and @xmath189 denote the massless @xmath190 and massive wilson coefficients @xmath191 for the coupling of the weak bosons to only massless quarks @xmath192 and for charm excitation @xmath193 .
we assume that the sea quark distributions obey @xmath194 the contributions due to the wilson coefficients @xmath195 are cabbibo suppressed .
the combinations ( [ eq : f1cc][eq : f3cc ] ) are related to the unpolarized bjorken sum rule @xcite , the adler sum rule @xcite , and the gross - llewellyn smith sum rule @xcite , respectively , by their first moments .
first we consider these combinations themselves and turn to the sum rules later . up to @xmath57 the single heavy quark excitations have been calculated in refs .
@xcite correcting results in @xcite . up to @xmath0 including the charm quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and using the nnlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ] at two - loop order , only the asymptotic results for @xmath7 are available @xcite , to which we refer in the following .
we will limit our considerations to the case of the charm contributions . in figure [
fig : f1rec ] we illustrate the non - singlet structure function @xmath196 up to @xmath0 , showing its scaling violations in the range @xmath170 to @xmath121 .
its charm quark corrections up to @xmath0 , using the asymptotic corrections for the @xmath0 term of the flavor excitation contributions as a first approximation , are illustrated in figures [ fig : f1ratios4][fig : f1ratios ] for virtualities @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath199 .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f1rec ] . ] up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath185 .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f1rec ] . ]
the higher order results lower the corrections in the small @xmath117 region and enlarge it at large @xmath117 .
the asymptotic corrections work well in the whole region @xmath200~{\rm
gev}^2 $ ] for small values of @xmath117 and in the whole region at @xmath201 .
the relative corrections amount to values between @xmath202 and @xmath203 . up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath201 .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f1rec ] . ] up to @xmath0 including the charm quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and using the nnlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ] in figure [ fig : f2rec ] the charged current structure function @xmath204 is shown , including the charm quark corrections . again qcd - evolution moves the profile towards smaller values of @xmath117 .
the relative corrections due to charm are shown in figures [ fig : f2ratios4][fig : f2ratios ] for the scales @xmath197 and @xmath198 . up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath199 .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2rec ] . ] here we also compare the asymptotic result against the complete ones .
the charm contribution is found in the range of @xmath202 to @xmath205 at @xmath199 to @xmath202 to @xmath206 , at @xmath201 peaking around @xmath207 . up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath185 .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2rec ] . ] up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath201 .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2rec ] . ] up to @xmath0 including the charm quark corrections in the on - shell scheme with @xmath110 @xcite and using the nnlo parton distribution functions @xcite . ] in figure [ fig : f3rec ] the charged current structure function @xmath208 including the charm quark corrections are shown . in this case
also the asymptotic 3-loop corrections have been calculated @xcite . as shown in figures [ fig : f3ratios4][fig : f3ratios ] , the charm quark corrections vary form @xmath209 to @xmath210 from small to large @xmath117 . with rising values of @xmath4 the corrections
become more pronounced at large values of @xmath117 .
note that the asymptotic @xmath18 corrections yield significant contributions both at small and large values of @xmath117 . up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath199 .
dash - dotted line : corrections to @xmath18 in the asymptotic case .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2rec ] . ] up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath185 . dash - dotted line : corrections to @xmath18 in the asymptotic case .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2rec ] . ] up to @xmath0 to the full corrections at @xmath201 .
dash - dotted line : corrections to @xmath18 in the asymptotic case .
the other conditions are the same as in figure [ fig : f2rec ] . ]
in the following we discuss the corrections to the adler sum rule @xcite , which have to vanish , and calculate the corrections to the polarized bjorken sum rule @xcite , the unpolarized bjorken sum rule @xcite , and the gross - llewellyn smith sum rule @xcite , which are obtained as the first moments of the massive wilson coefficients calculated in the previous sections .
the combination of the parton distributions is partly different , as here differences between structure functions in the neutral current case are considered . but this affects only the normalization factor of the sum rules , which are known constants . as has been outlined in refs .
@xcite up to 3-loop order , in the asymptotic region @xmath211 the sum rules only modify the massless approximation by replacing the number of massless flavors from @xmath212 .
given the factorization of the massive wilson coefficients @xcite , this holds for all orders in the coupling constant , since the first moment of the massive non - singlet omes vanish order by order in the coupling constant due to fermion number conservation .
the 4-loop corrections to these sum rules have been calculated in refs .
earlier pad estimates were given in @xcite .
we emphasize that in the present paper the inclusive wilson coefficients are calculated for deep - inelastic scattering , but not those in the flavor tagged case .
the relations obtained do not smoothly transform into the photo - production limit @xmath213 , both for the wilson coefficients and the parton distribution functions , setting @xmath116 .
they are valid only up to a lower scale @xmath214 , which usually should be at least of @xmath215 or larger , also to stay outside the region of higher twist corrections . in the case of the sum rules discussed below , in the limit @xmath216 logarithmic contributions
survive , while this is the not the case in the limit of large virtualities @xmath217 .
the photo - production region for the corresponding structure functions needs a separate treatment . in the following
we will discuss the complete massive corrections to the four sum rules in the deep - inelastic region .
the power corrections of a single heavy quark c or b will be shown to basically interpolate between @xmath10 and @xmath218 massless flavors in the limit @xmath217 , while at lower scales @xmath4 , partly negative virtual corrections are possible .
the sum rules are observables and we represent them choosing the factorization scale @xmath116 .
the scale matching can be performed analytically in mellin space up to the respective order in @xmath219 in which the quantity is calculated , cf .
@xcite . to get closer to the unitary representation for the ckm matrix elements ,
we calculate the functions @xmath220 , ( [ eq : wil2 ] , [ eq : h3 ] ) , allowing for massive charm quarks to be pair produced also for this cabbibo suppressed term , but referring to massless @xmath221 charged current transitions for the real and virtual corrections .
finally , we also consider the target mass corrections to the deep - inelastic sum rules , as they are of relevance in the region of lower values of @xmath4 . the adler sum rule @xcite states @xmath222 = 2 [ 1 + \sin^2(\theta_c)]\end{aligned}\ ] ] for three massless flavors . here
@xmath56 denotes the cabibbo angle @xcite .
the integral ( [ eq : adler ] ) neither receives qcd nor quark- or target mass corrections , cf .
also @xcite .
the compton contribution yields @xmath223 \left [ { { \rm li}}_2\left(-\frac{1-\tilde{\lambda}}{1+\tilde{\lambda}}\right ) - { { \rm li}}_2\left(-\frac{1+\tilde{\lambda}}{1-\tilde{\lambda}}\right ) \right ] \nonumber\\ & & - \left[\frac{10}{3 } + 4 \tilde{\lambda}^2 - 2 \tilde{\lambda}^4\right ] \left [ { { \rm li}}_3\left(-\frac{1-\tilde{\lambda}}{1+\tilde{\lambda}}\right ) + { { \rm li}}_3\left(-\frac{1+\tilde{\lambda}}{1-\tilde{\lambda}}\right ) - 2 \zeta_3 \right]\biggr\ } , \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is canceled by the virtual correction @xmath224 , ( [ eq : lqnsg1v ] ) . the first moment of the contribution with massless final states @xmath225,\end{aligned}\ ] ] also vanishes , cf .
( [ eq : cf21 ] , [ eq : pqq0 ] ) . for the charged current flavor excitation slow rescaling at tree level yields @xmath226 \nonumber\\ & = & \int_0 ^ 1 \frac{dz}{z } \left[f_2^{\bar{\nu } p}(z , q^2 ) - f_2^{{\nu } p}(z , q^2 ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ]
since the support of @xmath227 is @xmath228 $ ] . for the first order massive qcd corrections given in @xcite the first moment ( [ eq : adler ] ) vanishes .
the corresponding @xmath70 corrections have only been studied in the asymptotic case @xcite and vanish . for massless quarks ,
the adler sum rule has been checked at @xmath18 in @xcite .
it seems that in the case of massless 4-loop corrections , the validity of the sum rule has not yet been checked perturbatively @xcite .
the target mass corrections are studied in section [ sec:65 ] .
in contrast , the qcd- , quark mass- and target mass corrections to the first moments of the structure functions @xmath229 and @xmath230 do not vanish .
the polarized bjorken sum rule @xcite refers to the first moment of the flavor non - singlet combination @xmath231 = \frac{1}{6}\left|\frac{g_a}{g_v}\right| c_{\rm pbj}(\hat{a}_s),\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath232 the neutron decay constants , @xmath233 @xcite and @xmath234 the 1- @xcite , 2-@xcite , 3- @xcite and 4-loop qcd corrections @xcite in the massless case are given by @xmath235 choosing the renormalization scale @xmath116 , cf .
@xcite for @xmath236 .
here @xmath10 denotes the number of active light flavors and the labels ns and si refer to the genuine ` non - singlet ' and ` singlet ' contributions , respectively .
the expression for general color factors was given in ref .
the massless corrections for @xmath237 and @xmath238 are @xmath239 for the asymptotic massive corrections ( [ eq : wil1][eq : wil2 ] ) only the first moments of the massless wilson coefficients @xmath240 contribute , since the first moments of the massive non - singlet omes vanish due to fermion number conservation , a property holding even at higher order .
therefore , any new heavy quark changes eq .
( [ eq : bjsr ] ) by a shift in @xmath241 only , for the asymptotic corrections .
we turn now to the heavy quark corrections , which are given by @xmath242 -\frac{1}{\xi^2 } \frac{5}{12 } \ln^2\left[\frac{\sqrt{1+\frac{4}{\xi } } + 1}{\sqrt{1+\frac{4}{\xi } } -1}\right ] + \frac{\big(3 \xi ^2 + 112 \xi + 1260\big)}{5040 } \ln(\xi ) \biggr\ } , \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] see appendix c. in the asymptotic region @xmath243 , @xmath244 behaves like @xmath245 coefficients @xmath246 for charm and bottom quarks as a function of @xmath247 . ]
up to 2-loop order the massless and the massive corrections to the polarized bjorken sum rule are given by @xmath248 \right\ } + o(\hat{a}_s^3 ) , \nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] accounting for the charm and bottom quark contributions , with @xmath249 . in figure
[ fig : pbj1 ] the effect of the heavy flavor wilson coefficients @xmath246 for charm and bottom are illustrated as a function of @xmath247 .
.[tab1 ] the massless and massive 2-loop corrections to the bjorken sum rule as a function of @xmath247 .
we also indicated the respective purely massless results for @xmath250 and 5 . [ cols= " <
, > , > " , ] as in the case of the other sum rules , the charm corrections at @xmath251 turn out to be of the same size as the massless @xmath252 corrections .
@xmath258 in contrast , the first moments of the structure functions @xmath259 and @xmath230 do not vanish at higher orders in qcd both in the massless and massive cases @xcite . moreover ,
both in the unpolarized @xcite and in the polarized cases , the target mass corrections are different for different structure functions , which are usually associated to other ones by current conservation , as in the case of @xmath260 and @xmath261 . in the case of the unpolarized bjorken sum rule ,
the target mass correction factor is given by @xcite @xmath262 a_{1 + 2j}}{c_1^{1 } a_1}~. \end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath263 denotes the @xmath264th moment of the wilson coefficient contributing to the structure function @xmath265 .
the target mass corrections to the polarized bjorken sum rule are given by @xcite @xmath266 \nonumber \\ \\
\delta c_{1}^k & = & \int_0 ^ 1 dx x^{k-1 } \delta c_{1}(x , q^2),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath267 is the polarized flavor - non singlet wilson coefficient corresponding to the structure function @xmath268 . in figure
[ fig : tm ] we illustrate the effect of the target mass corrections to the unpolarized and polarized bjorken sum rule as well as the gross - llewellyn smith sum rule , as a function of @xmath272 , accounting only for the operator matrix elements @xmath273 .
we refer to the unpolarized pdfs @xcite at nnlo and polarized pdfs @xcite at nlo , and @xmath274 at nnlo , to allow for a comparison of the different contributions up to nnlo . ) and polarized bjorken sum rule ( @xmath88 ) and the gross - llewellyn smith sum tule ( @xmath230 ) . ]
the corrections diminish towards large virtualities @xmath4 . at @xmath275
they amount @xmath276 and @xmath277 for the unpolarized bjorken sum rule , the gross - llewellyn smith sum rule and the polarized bjorken sum rule , respectively .
we have calculated the complete heavy flavor corrections to the flavor non - singlet deep - inelastic structure functions @xmath278 and @xmath279 in the neutral current case , and to @xmath280 and @xmath281 for charged current reactions .
here we considered the deep - inelastic region , which at least requests scales @xmath17 or larger and @xmath282 .
for the charged current non - singlet combinations of structure functions also the cabibbo suppressed wilson coefficient @xmath283 contributes , which we have considered in the asymptotic region starting at @xmath70 as an approximation . since the deep - inelastic structure functions are inclusive observables , the formerly considered tagged flavor case @xcite is not sufficient . we have accomplished the calculation for the inclusive case , to which at @xmath70 also virtual corrections and real corrections with massless final states , containing massive virtual corrections , contribute .
we present detailed numerical results for the different unpolarized and polarized structure functions for the charm and bottom contribution in the neutral current case and the charm contributions in the charged current case , which are the most important .
we compared in all cases to the formerly calculated asymptotic corrections in the region @xmath7 , showing that except for the structure function @xmath284 this approximation holds only at higher scales , while for @xmath285 a very good agreement for @xmath286 is obtained in the case of charm . in those cases in which the asymptotic 3-loops corrections are available , we have partly compared to these corrections as well .
the @xmath70 non - singlet heavy flavor effects are of the order of several per cent of the whole non - singlet structure function and are of relevance in precision measurements reaching this accuracy .
the corrections will become even more important in the case of planned high - luminosity measurements at facilities like the eic @xcite , future neutrino factories @xcite or the lhec @xcite .
we also investigated the heavy flavor corrections for deep - inelastic scattering sum rules , such as the adler , polarized bjorken , unpolarized bjorken and gross - llewellyn smith sum rule .
while the corrections vanish in case of the adler sum rule , finite corrections are obtained to the other three sum rules .
they turn out to be of the same size as the massless @xmath287 corrections which have been calculated recently and complete the picture from the side of the heavy quarks .
here it is important to refer to the inclusive rather than to the tagged heavy flavor case , since in the latter , logarithmic terms in the region of larger @xmath4 would remain , after having already performed the renormalization completely ( e.g. in the @xmath288 scheme ) @xcite . in the inclusive case , on the other hand , the transition from @xmath212 proceeds smoothly .
we also quantified the effect of target mass corrections to the deep inelastic sum rules .
in general it turns out that for the sum rules the transition @xmath212 proceeds slowly in @xmath289 . therefore assuming scale matching at @xmath290 is , at least here , not appropriate .
in this appendix we calculate the contribution of the subprocess @xmath292 to the non - singlet coefficient function @xmath293 , which is given by compton scattering diagrams shown in figure [ qcdcomp ] .
the structure function @xmath294 is extracted from the antisymmetric part of the hadronic tensor @xmath295 , given by @xmath296,\ ] ] where @xmath297 and @xmath298 , @xmath28 and @xmath299 are the mass , momentum and spin of the incoming light quark , with @xmath300 later on we will consider the limit @xmath301 .
the term @xmath302 can be obtained by @xcite @xmath303 the hadronic tensor is given by @xmath304 ^ 2}\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{2cm}+\frac{\gamma^{\nu}(\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p_2}+m_0 ) \gamma^{\mu}(\slashed{p}_2-\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma_\rho}{\big[(p+q)^2-m^2_0\big ] \big[(p_2-q)^2-m^2_0\big]}\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{2cm}+\frac{\gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p}_2-\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma^\nu(\slashed{p}_2+m_0 ) \gamma_{\rho}(\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma^{\mu}}{\big[(p+q)^2-m^2_0\big ] \big[(p_2-q)^2-m^2_0\big]}\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{2cm}+\frac{\gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p}_2-\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma^\nu(\slashed{p}_2+m_0 ) \gamma^{\mu } ( \slashed{p}_2-\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma_\rho}{\big[(p_2-q)^2-m^2_0\big]^2}\bigg)\bigg ] \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{2cm}\times\frac{4}{\big[q_2 ^ 2\big]^2}\,\bigg[p_c^{\rho}p_{\overline{c}}^{\sigma } + p_c^{\sigma } p_{\overline{c}}^{\rho}-(p_c\cdot p_{\overline{c}}+m^2)\,g^{\rho\sigma}\bigg]\bigg\}\nonumber\\ & & \hspace{2 cm } \times(2\pi)^{3}\delta_+(p_2
^ 2-m_0 ^ 2)\delta_+(p_c^2-m^2)\delta_+(p_{\overline{c}}^2-m^2)\\ & & \hspace{-1.5 cm } \equiv { 4 \pi \alpha_s^2 \,c_f t_f}\ ; \int\,\frac{d^dp_2}{(2\pi)^d } \frac{d^dp_c}{(2\pi)^d}\frac{d^dp_{\overline{c}}}{(2\pi)^d}(2\pi)^d\delta^d(p+q - p_2-p_c - p_{\overline{c } } ) \nonumber\\ & & \hspace{-1cm}\times(2\pi)^{3}\delta_+(p_2 ^ 2-m_0 ^ 2)\delta_+(p_c^2-m^2)\delta _ + ( p_{\overline{c}}^2-m^2)\,\mathcal{t}^{\mu\nu}_{\;\rho\sigma}(p_2,q_2)\ , j_c^{\rho\sigma}(p_c , p_{\overline{c } } ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 , ( @xmath305 ) @xmath306 are the mass and four momenta of the heavy ( anti-)quark , @xmath307 and @xmath308 denotes the momentum of the light quark in the final state . the distribution @xmath309 is defined by @xmath310 the last line of eq .
( [ wamunu ] ) emphasizes that the phase space integral is factorized .
the tensors @xmath311 and @xmath312 read @xmath313 ^ 2}\,\bigg\{\text{tr } \bigg[\frac{\gamma_5\slashed{s}}{2}(\slashed{p}+m_0)\bigg(\frac{\gamma^{\nu}(\slashed{p } + \slashed{q}+m_0 ) \gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p_2}+m_0)\gamma_{\rho}(\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma^{\mu } } { \big[(p+q)^2-m^2_0\big]^2}\\ & \hspace{2cm}+\frac{\gamma^{\nu}(\slashed{p}+\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p_2}+m_0 ) \gamma^{\mu}(\slashed{p}_2 -\slashed{q}+m)\gamma_\rho}{\big[(p+q)^2-m^2_0\big]\big[(p_2-q)^2-m^2_0\big]}\\ & \hspace{2cm}+\frac{\gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p}_2-\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma^\nu(\slashed{p}_2+m_0 ) \gamma_{\rho}(\slashed{p } + \slashed{q}+m)\gamma^{\mu}}{\big[(p+q)^2-m^2_0\big]\big[(p_2-q)^2-m^2_0\big]}\\ & \hspace{2cm}+\frac{\gamma_\sigma(\slashed{p}_2-\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma^\nu(\slashed{p}_2+m_0 ) \gamma^{\mu}(\slashed{p}_2 -\slashed{q}+m_0)\gamma_\rho}{\big[(p_2-q)^2-m^2_0\big]^2}\bigg)\bigg]\bigg\},\\ j_c^{\rho\sigma}&=4\;\left[p_c^{\rho}p_{\overline{c}}^{\sigma}+p_c^{\sigma}p_{\overline{c } } ^{\rho}-(p_c\cdot p_{\overline{c}}+m^2)g^{\rho\sigma})\right ] .
\end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we consider the incoming quark directed in the @xmath314 axis .
the momentum and spin of a longitudinally polarized quark are then given by @xmath315 therefore , it is important to retain the linear terms in the mass @xmath298 , which is finally canceled by the normalization of the spin vector .
the integrals are finite in @xmath97 dimensions to which we turn from now on .
the phase space integrals can be carried out analytically leading to @xmath316 \frac{q^2(1-z)-z\mu^2}{8q^4(1-z)\mu^4}\\ & \hspace{-1cm}\times\bigg\{\frac{2}{(1-z)^2\,(z\mu^2-q^2)}\bigg[\mu^4\,z^2(4z^2 - 6z+3 ) + \mu^2q^2\,z(-8z^3 + 14z^2 - 9z+2)\\ & + 3q^4(2z^3 - 4z^2 + 3z-1)\bigg]\\ & \hspace{-1cm}+4\frac{2\mu^4\,z^3 - 2\mu^2q^2\,z(2z^2-z+1)+q^4(1+z^2)}{(q^2(1-z)-\mu^2z)}\ , \ln\left(\frac{\mu^2z^2}{(1-z)(q^2-z\mu^2)}\right)\bigg\}. \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] it is convenient to perform the @xmath50-integral over @xmath317 after applying this transformation , the integral becomes @xmath318 @xmath319 + 2(1-z)^2(\beta^2 - 1+\frac{4z}{\xi})\xi\bigg[32z^3\\ & -8z(1-z+2z^2)\xi(1-\beta^2)+(1+z^2)\xi^2(1-\beta^2)^2\bigg ] \ln\left ( \frac { \frac{4z}{\xi(1-z ) } - \frac{4z}{\xi } } { 1-\frac{4z}{\xi}-\beta^2 } \right)\bigg\}. \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this term can finally be integrated analytically to yield ( [ eq : lns1c ] ) .
the interaction of an on - shell fermion and the electromagnetic current is parameterized in terms of the dirac and pauli form factors @xmath320 , @xmath321 , respectively . in the space - like case one
has @xmath322\,u(p_1 ) , \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath323 $ ] .
the correction can be obtained by the subtracted dispersion relation for the dirac form factor .
we will first perform the calculation in the time - like case and obtain then the space - like result by analytic continuation .
one has @xmath324 which can be calculated from the diagrams in figures [ vpc ] , [ se ] and applying the ward identity of subsection [ sec : ward ] , with @xmath325 .
note that the integral ( [ eq : subdis ] ) in the case of the unsubtracted dispersion relation diverges .
the calculation proceeds in a similar way as in refs .
we will initially work in @xmath326 dimensions and use quarks of mass @xmath298 for the external particles and @xmath9 for the heavy quark in the loop .
later on we take the limit @xmath97 and @xmath327 .
the dirac form factor is projected to @xmath328.\ ] ] the contribution of the diagram in figure [ vpc ] to the vertex @xmath329 is given by @xmath330 \big[(p_1-k)^2-m^2_0+i0\big]}\\ & \!\times \left(\frac{-i}{k^2+i0}\right)^2\ , i\pi(k^2)\left(k^2g_{\rho\sigma}-k_\rho k_\sigma\right)\bigg\}\;\frac{d^dk}{(2\pi)^d } , \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath331 denotes the vacuum polarization @xmath332 leading to @xmath333\\ & \times \frac{\left(k^2g_{\rho\sigma}-k_\rho k_\sigma\right)\pi(k^2)}{\big[k^2+i0\big]^2\big[(p_1-k)^2-m^2_0+i0\big ] \big[(p_2+k)^2-m^2_0+i0\big ] } \bigg\}. \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] its imaginary part is found putting the propagators @xmath334}&\rightarrow -(2\pi i)\delta_+((p_1-k)^2-m^2_0),\\ \frac{1}{\big[(p_2+k)^2-m^2_0+i0\big]}&\rightarrow -(2\pi i)\delta_+((p_2+k)^2-m^2_0 ) , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] on shell , cf .
note that when taking the cut a minus sign has to be introduced @xcite @xmath335\frac{\left(k^2g_{\rho\sigma } -k_\rho k_\sigma\right)\pi(k^2)}{\big[k^2+i0\big]^2}\bigg\}\\ & \hspace{1.cm } \times ( 2\pi)^2\delta_+((p_1-k)^2-m^2_0)\delta_+((p_2+k)^2-m^2_0)\frac{d^dk}{(2\pi)^d}. \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the longitudinal parts of the photon polarization can be shown to vanish .
one finally obtains @xmath336 with @xcite @xmath337 we are now turning to @xmath97 and obtain @xmath338\\ & \int_0 ^ 1d\beta\frac{\beta^2(\beta^2 - 3)}{(1-\cos\theta)(1-\xi_1)+2\xi_2-\beta^2 ( 1-\xi_1)(1-\cos\theta ) } , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath339 furthermore we consider the limit @xmath340 . after integrating over @xmath341 we have @xmath342 , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath343 . trading the root in ( [ imf1m0 ] ) as a new integration variable one obtains @xmath344 .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to determine the complete expression of the form factor in the time - like region , we use again the subtracted relation ( [ eq : subdis ] ) @xmath345\\ & -\left(\frac{5}{2}+3s_\xi^2-\frac{3s_\xi^4}{2}\right)\left[\text{li}_3\left(-\frac{1-s_\xi}{1+s_\xi } \right)+\text{li}_3\left(-\frac{1+s_\xi}{1-s_\xi}\right ) - 2 \zeta_3\right]\bigg\ } , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath346 the analytic continuation of ( [ f1m0 ] ) to the space - like region is obtained by replacing @xmath347 cf .
( [ eq : lqnsg1v ] ) .
the real part of eq .
( [ f1m0 ] ) , if considered in the time - like region , may be compared with a result in @xcite , eq .
( a1 ) , for the drell - yan process and agrees . in the following we derive the relation of the self - energy insertions to @xmath348 through a ward identity .
the graphs of figure [ se ] obey @xmath349 & = ( z_2 - 1)\ , \overline{u}(p_2)\,(-ie\,\gamma_\mu)\,u(p_1 ) , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath350 denotes the electric charge . by following the notation of @xcite ,
we define @xmath351 as the proper self energy diagram in figure [ properse ] and we find the renormalization constant by taking the residue of the complete quark propagator on the mass shell . in the case of massless external fermions
we have @xmath352 so that @xmath353 at leading order .
the next step is to extract the spin structure of the self energy @xmath354 , where the latter object is a scalar function , so that we can write the renormalization constant @xmath355 as @xmath356 by introducing ( [ z2 ] ) into eq .
( [ secont ] ) , we obtain the contribution of self energy diagrams .
we consider the derivative of the self energy @xmath357\,\pi(k^2 ) , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath331 given in eq .
( [ kallen ] ) .
it reads @xmath358\,\bigg\{\frac{\gamma^\alpha\,\gamma_\mu\,\gamma^\beta}{(p - k)^2\big[k^2\big]^2}-2(p - k)_\mu\frac{\gamma^\alpha(\slashed{p}-\slashed{k})\gamma^\beta}{\big[(p - k)^2\big]^2\big[k^2\big]^2}\bigg\}\\ & = g_s^4c_ft_f\,\int\frac{d^dk}{(2\pi)^d } \pi(k^2)\bigg[k^2g_{\alpha\beta}-k_\alpha k_\beta\bigg]\,\bigg\{-\frac{\gamma^\alpha(\slashed{p}-\slashed{k})\gamma_\mu(\slashed{p}-\slashed{k})\gamma^\beta}{\big[(p - k)^2\big]\big[k^2\big]^2}\bigg\}. \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the vertex function is given by @xmath359\\ & \times\bigg\{\frac{\gamma^\alpha(\slashed{p}_2-\slashed{k } ) \gamma_\mu(\slashed{p}_1-\slashed{k})\gamma^\beta}{\big[(p_2-k)^2\big ] \big[(p_1-k)^2\big]\big[k^2\big]^2}\bigg\ } , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath360 . in the limit of zero momentum transfer , @xmath361 ,
the vertex function becomes @xmath362 . by comparing ( [ vertward ] ) and ( [ seward ] )
one gets @xmath363\bigg\{\frac{\gamma^\alpha(\slashed{p}-\slashed{k})\gamma_\mu(\slashed{p } -\slashed{k})\gamma^\beta}{\big[(p - k)^2\big]^2\big[k^2\big]^2}\bigg\ } = -\frac{\partial\sigma(p^2)}{\partial p^\mu } , \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] i.e. @xmath364 eq .
( [ wardid2 ] ) allows to write the function @xmath365 in terms of the form factor at zero momentum transfer .
therefore ( [ secont ] ) can be written as @xmath366&=\bigg[\frac{1}{2}\overline{\sigma}(p_1)+\frac{1}{2}\overline{\sigma}(p_2)\bigg]\;\overline{u}(p_2)\,(-ie\gamma_\mu)\,u(p_1)\\ & = \frac{1}{2}\overline{u}(p_2)\,\bigg(-ie\,\overline{\sigma}(p_1)\gamma_\mu\bigg)\,u(p_1)+\frac{1}{2}\overline{u}(p_2)\,\bigg(-ie\,\overline{\sigma}(p_2)\gamma_\mu\bigg)\,u(p_1)\\ & = \frac{1}{2}\,\overline{u}(p_2)\,\bigg[-ie\,\bigg(-f_1(0)\gamma_\mu-\slashed{p}_1\frac{\partial\overline{\sigma}(p_1)}{\partial{p}_1^\mu}\bigg)\bigg]\,u(p_1)\\ & \,+\frac{1}{2}\,\overline{u}(p_2)\,\bigg[-ie\,\bigg(-f_1(0)\gamma_\mu-\slashed{p}_2\frac{\partial\overline{\sigma}(p_2)}{\partial{p}_2^\mu}\bigg)\bigg]\,u(p_1 ) , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the last identity we introduced @xmath367 in terms of @xmath348 , according to the relation ( [ wardid2 ] ) . in the expression above , all the terms proportional to @xmath368 vanish because of the dirac equation , finally @xmath369=\overline{u}(p_2)\,\bigg(ie\,f_1(0)\gamma_\mu\bigg)\,u(p_1).\ ] ] in conclusion , the scattering amplitude of a massless quark and an off shell photon with momentum @xmath370 is given by the sum of the virtual correction to the proper @xmath371-gauge boson vertex , depicted in figure [ vpc ] , which we computed via dispersion relations up to an offset @xmath348 , and the self energies contributions above , which proves that the results of the subtracted dispersive approach eqs .
( [ f1m0 ] , [ eq : subdis ] ) give the complete renormalized form factor .
in the following we derive the heavy flavor contributions to the bjorken sum rule to @xmath70 .
the compton contribution is obtained by the integral @xmath372 where @xmath373 is given by the integral ( [ betaint ] ) , see also ( [ eq : lns1c ] ) . to obtain the analytic expression ,
it is easier to step back one integral and to use @xmath374 where the integrand @xmath375 is the same ( including normalization ) as in ( [ g1d4 ] ) .
the @xmath376-integral yields @xmath377\\ & \!\!+\bigg[1280x^4 + 512x^3\xi-16x\xi^3-\xi^4\bigg]\ln\left(\xi+4x\right)\\ & \!\!+192x^2(\xi-4x)^2\text{li}_2\left(\frac{\xi}{4x}\right)\bigg\ } , \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath378 .
the result of the last integration can be conveniently expressed in terms of the variables @xmath379 the @xmath117-integral results into @xmath380\\ & + \tilde{\lambda}\left(\frac{19}{18}-\frac{23}{9 \xi}\right)\bigg[\text{li}_2\left(\frac{\tilde{\lambda}+1 } { \tilde{\lambda}-1}\right)-\text{li}_2\left(\frac{\tilde{\lambda}-1 } { \tilde{\lambda}+1}\right)\bigg]-\frac{5}{12 \xi^2}\ln^2\left(\frac{\lambda+1}{\lambda-1}\right)\\ & + \lambda\ln\left(\frac{\lambda+1}{\lambda-1}\right ) \bigg[-\frac{527}{2520}-\frac{401}{420 \xi } -\frac{53\xi}{2520}-\frac{\xi^2}{1680}\bigg]\\ & + \ln(\xi)\bigg[\frac{265}{108}-\frac{55}{9 \xi}+\frac{\xi}{45}+\frac{\xi^2}{1680}\bigg ] + \frac{19591}{1260 \xi}+\frac{\xi}{840}-\frac{42047}{9072}\bigg\ } \end{split } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we have still to add the virtual contribution ( [ eq : lqnsg1v ] ) and the contribution due to the term with massless final states ( [ eq : massless_g1 ] ) which yields @xmath381 in the asymptotic limit one obtains @xmath382 note that the pure compton contribution diverges like @xmath383 . adding the virtual corrections , the term still diverges @xmath154 .
this behaviour is obtained considering tagged heavy quark production instead of the inclusive heavy flavor corrections , cf .
. * acknowledgment . *
we would like to thank a. behring , k. chetyrkin , c. schneider , and a. vogt for discussions .
the graphs have been drawn using axodraw @xcite .
this work was supported in part by the european commission through contract pitn - ga-2012 - 316704 ( higgstools ) .
100 j. blmlein , prog .
* 69 * ( 2013 )
28 [ arxiv:1208.6087 [ hep - ph ] ] . s. bethke _ et al .
_ , workshop on precision measurements of @xmath274 , arxiv:1110.0016 [ hep - ph ] ; + s. moch , s. weinzierl , _ et al .
_ , high precision fundamental constants at the tev scale , arxiv:1405.4781 [ hep - ph ] ; + s. alekhin , j. blmlein , and s. moch , desy 16 - 051 .
s. alekhin , j. blmlein , k. daum , k. lipka and s. moch , phys .
b * 720 * ( 2013 ) 172 [ arxiv:1212.2355 [ hep - ph ] ] .
e. laenen , s. riemersma , j. smith and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 392 * ( 1993 ) 162 ; 229 .
s. riemersma , j. smith and w.l .
van neerven , phys .
b * 347 * ( 1995 ) 143 [ hep - ph/9411431 ] .
i. bierenbaum , j. blmlein and s. klein , phys .
b * 672 * ( 2009 ) 401 [ arxiv:0901.0669 [ hep - ph ] ] .
alekhin and j. blmlein , phys .
b * 594 * ( 2004 ) 299 [ hep - ph/0404034 ] .
m. buza , y. matiounine , j. smith , r. migneron and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 472 * ( 1996 ) 611 [ hep - ph/9601302 ] .
m. buza , y. matiounine , j. smith and w.l .
van neerven , eur .
j. c * 1 * ( 1998 ) 301 [ hep - ph/9612398 ] .
i. bierenbaum , j. blmlein and s. klein , nucl .
b * 820 * ( 2009 ) 417 [ arxiv:0904.3563 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. behring , i. bierenbaum , j. blmlein , a. de freitas , s. klein and f. wibrock , eur .
j. c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 9 , 3033 [ arxiv:1403.6356 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. ablinger , j. blmlein , s. klein , c. schneider and f. wibrock , nucl .
b * 844 * ( 2011 ) 26 [ arxiv:1008.3347 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. blmlein , a. hasselhuhn , s. klein and c. schneider , nucl .
b * 866 * ( 2013 ) 196 [ arxiv:1205.4184 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. ablinger , a. behring , j. blmlein , a. de freitas , a. hasselhuhn , a. von manteuffel , m. round , c. schneider , and f. wibrock , nucl .
b * 886 * ( 2014 ) 733 [ arxiv:1406.4654 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. ablinger , a. behring , j. blmlein , a. de freitas , a. von manteuffel and c. schneider , nucl .
b * 890 * ( 2014 ) 48 [ arxiv:1409.1135 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. behring , j. blmlein , a. de freitas , a. von manteuffel and c. schneider , nucl .
b * 897 * ( 2015 ) 612 [ arxiv:1504.08217 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. behring , j. blmlein , a. de freitas , a. hasselhuhn , a. von manteuffel and c. schneider , + phys .
d * 92 * ( 2015 ) 11 , 114005 [ arxiv:1508.01449 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. blmlein , a. hasselhuhn and t. pfoh , nucl .
b * 881 * ( 2014 ) 1 [ arxiv:1401.4352 [ hep - ph ] ] .
vermaseren , a. vogt and s. moch , nucl .
b * 724 * ( 2005 ) 3 [ hep - ph/0504242 ] .
s. moch , j.a.m .
vermaseren and a. vogt , nucl .
b * 813 * ( 2009 ) 220 [ arxiv:0812.4168 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. buza , y. matiounine , j. smith and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 485 * ( 1997 ) 420 [ hep - ph/9608342 ] ; + i. bierenbaum , j. blmlein and s. klein , arxiv:0706.2738 [ hep - ph ] and in preparation . m. buza and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 500 * ( 1997 ) 301 [ hep - ph/9702242 ] .
adler , phys .
* 143 * ( 1966 ) 1144 .
bjorken , phys .
* 163 * ( 1967 ) 1767 .
bjorken , phys .
d * 1 * ( 1970 ) 1376 .
gross and c.h .
llewellyn smith , nucl .
b * 14 * ( 1969 ) 337 .
j. blmlein and w. l. van neerven , phys .
b * 450 * ( 1999 ) 417 [ hep - ph/9811351 ] .
van neerven , in : proceedings of the workshop hadron physics : effctive theories of low - energy qcd , coimbra , portugal , 1999 , aip conf.proc .
* 508 * ( 2000 ) pp . 162 , eds .
blin , b. hiller , m.c .
ruivo , c.a . de sousa , e. van beveren [ hep - ph/9910356 ] ; + hep - ph/9709469 .
t. kinoshita , j. math .
phys . * 3 * ( 1962 ) 650 .
lee and m. nauenberg , phys .
* 133 * ( 1964 ) b1549 .
j. blmlein , h. bttcher and a. guffanti , nucl .
b * 774 * ( 2007 ) 182 [ hep - ph/0607200 ] ; nucl .
* 135 * ( 2004 ) 152 [ hep - ph/0407089 ] .
j. ablinger , j. blmlein , a. de freitas , a. hasselhuhn , c. schneider , and f. wibrock , desy 14019 .
n. cabibbo , phys .
* 10 * ( 1963 ) 531 .
m. glck , s. kretzer and e. reya , phys . lett .
b * 398 * ( 1997 ) 381 [ erratum : phys .
b * 405 * ( 1997 ) 392 ] [ hep - ph/9701364 ] .
j. blmlein , a. hasselhuhn , p. kovacikova and s. moch , phys .
b * 700 * ( 2011 ) 294 [ arxiv:1104.3449 [ hep - ph ] ] .
t. gottschalk , phys .
d * 23 * ( 1981 ) 56 .
b. lampe and e. reya , phys .
* 332 * ( 2000 ) 1 [ hep - ph/9810270 ] .
zijlstra and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 383 * ( 1992 ) 525 ; + w.l .
van neerven and a. vogt , nucl .
b * 568 * ( 2000 ) 263 [ hep - ph/9907472 ] .
e.g. floratos , d.a .
ross and c.t .
sachrajda , nucl .
b * 129 * ( 1977 ) 66 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 139 * ( 1978 ) 545 ] ; + g. curci , w. furmanski and r. petronzio , nucl .
b * 175 * ( 1980 ) 27 .
j. kodaira , s. matsuda , t. muta , k. sasaki and t. uematsu , phys .
d * 20 * ( 1979 ) 627 .
zijlstra and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 417 * ( 1994 ) 61 , errata : ibib .
* 426 * ( 1994 ) 245 , * 773 * ( 2007 ) 105 .
olive et al .
( particle data group ) , chin .
c * 38 * ( 2014 ) 090001 and 2015 update .
j. blmlein and h. bttcher , nucl .
b * 841 * ( 2010 ) 205 [ arxiv:1005.3113 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. blmlein , a. de freitas and c. schneider , nucl .
* 261 - 262 * ( 2015 ) 185 [ arxiv:1411.5669 [ hep - ph ] ] . n. gray , d.j .
broadhurst , w. grafe and k. schilcher , z. phys .
c * 48 * , ( 1990 ) 673 ; + d.j .
broadhurst , n. gray and k. schilcher , z. phys .
c * 52 * ( 1991 ) 111 ; + k. g. chetyrkin and m. steinhauser , nucl .
b * 573 * , 617 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911434 ] ; phys .
lett . * 83 * , 4001 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9907509 ] .
t. gehrmann and e. remiddi , comput .
commun .
* 141 * ( 2001 ) 296 [ hep - ph/0107173 ] .
s. buehler and c. duhr , computer physics communication * 185 * ( 2014 ) 2703 [ arxiv:1106.5739 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. maitre , comput .
commun .
* 174 * ( 2006 ) 222 doi:10.1016/j.cpc.2005.10.008 [ hep - ph/0507152 ] . j. ablinger , pos ll * 2014 * ( 2014 ) 019 ; + j. ablinger , a computer algebra toolbox for harmonic sums related to particle physics , diploma thesis , j. kepler university linz , 2009 , arxiv:1011.1176 [ math - ph ] .
+ j. ablinger , ph.d .
thesis , j. kepler university linz , 2012 , arxiv:1305.0687 [ math - ph ] ; + j. ablinger , j. blmlein and c. schneider , j. math .
* 52 * ( 2011 ) 102301 [ arxiv:1105.6063 [ math - ph ] ] ; + j. ablinger , j. blmlein and c. schneider , j. math .
phys . * 54 * ( 2013 ) 082301 [ arxiv:1302.0378 [ math - ph ] ] ; + j. ablinger , j. blmlein , c. g. raab and c. schneider , j. math .
* 55 * ( 2014 ) 112301 [ arxiv:1407.1822 [ hep - th ] ] .
s. wandzura and f. wilczek , phys .
b * 72 * ( 1977 ) 195 .
j. blmlein and n. kochelev , phys .
b * 381 * ( 1996 ) 296 [ hep - ph/9603397 ] .
j. blmlein and n. kochelev , nucl .
b * 498 * ( 1997 ) 285 [ hep - ph/9612318 ] .
j. blmlein and a. tkabladze , nucl .
b * 553 * ( 1999 ) 427 [ hep - ph/9812478 ] .
a. piccione and g. ridolfi , nucl .
b * 513 * ( 1998 ) 301 [ hep - ph/9707478 ] .
j. blmlein , b. geyer and d. robaschik , nucl .
b * 560 * ( 1999 ) 283 [ hep - ph/9903520 ] .
j. blmlein and d. robaschik , nucl .
b * 581 * ( 2000 ) 449 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0002071 ] .
b. geyer , d. robaschik and j. eilers , nucl .
b * 704 * ( 2005 ) 279 [ hep - ph/0407300 ] .
j. blmlein and d. robaschik , phys .
d * 65 * ( 2002 ) 096002 [ hep - ph/0202077 ] .
j. blmlein , d. robaschik and b. geyer , eur .
j. c * 61 * ( 2009 ) 279 [ arxiv:0812.1899 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. blmlein , v. ravindran and w.l .
van neerven , phys .
d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 114004 [ hep - ph/0304292 ] .
jackson , g.g .
ross and r.g .
roberts , phys .
b * 226 * ( 1989 ) 159 .
roberts and g.g .
ross , phys .
b * 373 * ( 1996 ) 235 [ hep - ph/9601235 ] .
h. burkhardt and w.n .
cottingham , annals phys .
* 56 * ( 1970 ) 453 .
v. ravindran and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 605 * ( 2001 ) 517 [ hep - ph/0102280 ] .
h. georgi and h.d .
politzer , phys .
d * 14 * ( 1976 ) 1829 .
a. zee , f. wilczek and s.b .
treiman , phys .
d * 10 * ( 1974 ) 2881 .
kazakov and a.v .
kotikov , nucl .
b * 307 * ( 1988 ) 721 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 345 * ( 1990 ) 299 ] ; + d.i .
kazakov , a.v .
kotikov , g. parente , o.a .
sampayo and j. sanchez guillen , phys .
lett . * 65 * ( 1990 ) 1535 [ erratum - ibid .
* 65 * ( 1990 ) 2921 ] ; + j. sanchez guillen , j. miramontes , m. miramontes , g. parente and o.a .
sampayo , nucl .
b * 353 * ( 1991 ) 337 .
s. moch and j.a.m .
vermaseren , nucl .
b * 573 * ( 2000 ) 853 [ hep - ph/9912355 ] .
j. blmlein , a. de freitas , w.l .
van neerven and s. klein , nucl .
b * 755 * ( 2006 ) 272 [ hep - ph/0608024 ] .
s. alekhin , j. blmlein and s. moch , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 5 , 054028 [ arxiv:1310.3059 [ hep - ph ] ] .
the parameterization is available through https://lhapdf.hepforge.org/ w. furmanski and r. petronzio , z. phys .
c * 11 * ( 1982 ) 293 .
chetyrkin , talk at loops and legs in quantum field theory , weimar , april 2014 , https://indico.desy.de/conferenceotherviews.py?view=standard&confid=8107 p.a .
baikov , k.g .
chetyrkin , j.h .
khn and j. rittinger , phys .
b * 714 * ( 2012 ) 62 [ arxiv:1206.1288 [ hep - ph ] ] .
baikov , k.g .
chetyrkin and j.h .
khn , phys .
* 104 * ( 2010 ) 132004 [ arxiv:1001.3606 [ hep - ph ] ] .
kataev and v.v .
starshenko , mod .
lett . a * 10 * ( 1995 ) 235 [ hep - ph/9502348 ] .
adler , arxiv:0905.2923 [ hep - ph ] .
s. moch and m. rogal , nucl .
b * 782 * ( 2007 ) 51 [ arxiv:0704.1740 [ hep - ph ] ] .
k. chetyrkin , private communication .
d. mund , b. maerkisch , m. deissenroth , j. krempel , m. schumann , h. abele , a. petoukhov and t. soldner , phys .
* 110 * ( 2013 ) 172502 [ arxiv:1204.0013 [ hep - ex ] ] .
gorishnii and s.a .
larin , phys .
b * 172 * ( 1986 ) 109 .
larin and j.a.m .
vermaseren , phys .
b * 259 * ( 1991 ) 345 .
baikov , k.g .
chetyrkin and j.h .
khn , nucl .
* 261 - 262 * ( 2015 ) 3 [ arxiv:1501.06739 [ hep - ph ] ] .
larin , phys .
b * 723 * ( 2013 ) 348 [ arxiv:1303.4021 [ hep - ph ] ] .
bardeen , a.j .
buras , d.w . duke and t. muta , phys .
d * 18 * ( 1978 ) 3998 .
g. altarelli , r.k .
ellis and g. martinelli , nucl .
b * 143 * ( 1978 ) 521 , erratum : nucl . phys .
b * 146 * ( 1978 ) 544 .
b. humpert and w.l .
van neerven , nucl .
b * 184 * ( 1981 ) 225 .
doi:10.1016/0550 - 3213(81)90217 - 0 s.a .
larin , f.v .
tkachov and j.a.m .
vermaseren , phys .
* 66 * ( 1991 ) 862 .
van neerven and e.b .
zijlstra , phys .
b * 272 * ( 1991 ) 127 .
steffens , m.d .
brown , w. melnitchouk and s. sanches , phys . rev .
c * 86 * ( 2012 ) 065208 [ arxiv:1210.4398 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. boer , m. diehl , r. milner , r. venugopalan , w. vogelsang , d. kaplan , h. montgomery and s. vigdor _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1108.1713 [ nucl - th ] ; + a. accardi , j. l. albacete , m. anselmino , n. armesto , e. c. aschenauer , a. bacchetta , d. boer and w. brooks _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1212.1701 [ nucl - ex ] .
kaplan [ map and mice collaborations ] , epj web conf .
* 95 * ( 2015 ) 03019 [ arxiv:1412.3487 [ physics.acc-ph ] ] .
abelleira fernandez _
[ lhec study group collaboration ] , j. phys .
g * 39 * ( 2012 ) 075001 [ arxiv:1206.2913 [ physics.acc-ph ] ] .
r. barbieri , j.a .
mignaco and e. remiddi , nuovo cim . a * 11 * ( 1972 ) 824 .
r. barbieri , j.a .
mignaco and e. remiddi , nuovo cim . a * 11 * ( 1972 ) 865 .
veltman , physica * 29 * ( 1963 ) 186 .
kniehl , acta phys .
b * 27 * ( 1996 ) 3631 [ hep - ph/9607255 ] .
fichtenholz , differential- und integralrechnung , vol . 3 , ( deutscher verlag der wissenschaften , berlin , 1964 ) .
rijken and w.l .
van neerven , phys .
d * 52 * ( 1995 ) 149 [ hep - ph/9501373 ] .
yndurain , the theory of quark and gluon interactions , ( springer , berlin , 2006 ) , 474 p. j.a.m .
vermaseren , comput .
commun .
* 83 * ( 1994 ) 45 . | we calculate analytically the flavor non - singlet @xmath0 massive wilson coefficients for the inclusive neutral current non - singlet structure functions @xmath1 and @xmath2 and charged current non - singlet structure functions @xmath3 , at general virtualities @xmath4 in the deep - inelastic region .
numerical results are presented .
we illustrate the transition from low to large virtualities for these observables , which may be contrasted to basic assumptions made in the so - called variable flavor number scheme . we also derive the corresponding results for the adler sum rule , the unpolarized and polarized bjorken sum rules and the gross - llewellyn smith sum rule .
there are no logarithmic corrections at large scales @xmath4 and the effects of the power corrections due to the heavy quark mass are of the size of the known @xmath5 corrections in the case of the sum rules .
the complete charm and bottom corrections are compared to the approach using asymptotic representations in the region @xmath6 .
we also study the target mass corrections to the above sum rules .
desy 15171 + do th 15/14 + may 2016 + * the complete @xmath0 non - singlet heavy flavor corrections * johannes blmlein , giulio falcioni , and abilio de freitas + _ platanenallee 6 , d-15738 zeuthen , germany _ + |
a recent study of observations of the stellar initial mass function ( imf ) suggest there are systematic variations where the imf gets flatter , or more top - heavy , in denser regions ( elmegreen 2004 ) .
this paper proposes that the high mass part of the imf varies with density as a result of the coalescence of dense pre - stellar condensations ( pscs ) , such as those observed by motte , andr , & neri ( 1998 ) , testi & sargent ( 1998 ) , onishi et al .
( 2002 ) and nomura & miller ( 2004 ) .
these objects have densities in the range from @xmath0 @xmath1 to @xmath2 @xmath1 , and masses from 0.1 m@xmath3 to a few m@xmath3 , giving them sizes of @xmath4 au .
the largest pscs may be self - gravitating ( johnstone et al . 2000 , 2001 ; motte et al .
2001 ; umemoto et al .
2002 ) , as may those with stars ( tachihara et al . 2002 ) .
the size and spatial proximity of pscs in a cloud core suggest their coalescence might be important for the highest masses ( elmegreen & shadmehri 2003 ) .
this process is modelled to illustrate its possible effect on the imf .
consider the evolution of a distribution @xmath5 of pscs with masses @xmath6 and radii @xmath7 at positions @xmath8 inside a cloud having a mass @xmath9 and radius @xmath10 .
the cloud density profile is @xmath11 where the core radius is @xmath12 and the central density is given by the cloud mass : @xmath13}.\ ] ] the pscs are taken to have density profiles ( whitworth & ward - thompson 2001 ) @xmath14 ^ 2}}\ ] ] where central density @xmath15 is assumed to be constant and the radius @xmath16 varies with condensation mass @xmath17 and position @xmath8 in the cloud .
the positional variation assumes the density at the edge of the condensation equals the ambient cloud density , @xmath18 , so pscs of the same mass are smaller near the cloud core .
thus the density contrast between the condensation center and the edge is @xmath19 ^ 2\right)\rho_{\rm p0}/\rho_{\rm c0},\ ] ] and the psc radius can be written as @xmath20 where @xmath21-\frac{a(r)}{1+a(r)^2}\right)^{-1/3}.\ ] ] and @xmath22 @xmath23 is assumed to be the psc radius at the beginning of its collapse .
the average radius of the psc used in the collision rate should in general be smaller than @xmath16 because of psc collapse .
each psc is assumed to collapse at a rate proportional to its central dynamical rate , @xmath24 , so each psc radius drops effectively to zero as @xmath25 for parameter @xmath26 . for a distribution of formation times
@xmath27 up to the current time @xmath28 , these assumptions give the average psc radius for use in the collision cross section : @xmath29 ) d\tau}{\int_{0}^t n(r , m , \tau ) d\tau}&.\label{eq : radius}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now that the psc radius is defined , the psc collision rate and the evolution of the imf can be calculated .
two components are assumed for the imf at intermediate and high mass .
one is intrinsic to the formation of pscs and independent of coalescence .
this could be a power law if the psc formation process is scale - free , or it could be log - normal if there is a characteristic mass and some type of random multiplicative fragmentation or build - up . to illustrate how apparently power law imfs can result from imfs with a characteristic mass , the model considers a log - normal intrinsic spectrum of psc mass
, @xmath30 refers to base 10](to use the notation of scalo 1986 ) .
this is taken to be normalized so that @xmath31 for minimum and maximum stellar masses @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
power law models were also made and the results were qualitatively the same as those reported here so they are not discussed further .
the time - evolution of the number , @xmath34 , of stars between masses @xmath6 and @xmath35 at time @xmath28 and distance @xmath8 from the center of the cloud is @xmath36\right)^{1/2}}\over{<m > } } f(m)\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\nonumber\\ + 0.5 \eta \int_{m_{\rm min}}^{m - m_{\rm min } } n(r , \xi , t ) n(r , m-\xi , t ) \sigma ( \xi , m-\xi ) v d\xi\nonumber \\
- \eta n(r , m , t)\int_{m{\rm min}}^{m_{\rm max } } n(r,\xi , t ) \sigma ( \xi , m ) v d\xi,\label{eq : main}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 is the average mass in the imf , @xmath38 and @xmath39 are efficiencies , and @xmath40 and @xmath41 are the coalescence cross section and relative velocity .
the first term is the spontaneous star formation rate .
it is written to give a local rate @xmath42\right)^{1/2}$ ] in units of mass per volume per time , where @xmath38 is the fraction of the gas mass converted into star mass in each unit of dynamical time , @xmath43 ( see elmegreen 2002 ) .
typically @xmath44 from observations of cluster formation efficiencies and timescales ( lada & lada 2003 ; elmegreen 2000 ) . when divided by the average star mass in the imf , @xmath45
, it gives the number of stars formed per unit volume and time .
the function @xmath46 is the probability that a star has the mass @xmath6 between @xmath6 and @xmath35 .
multiplication of the count rate by f(m ) gives the number of stars forming per unit volume and time in a @xmath47 mass interval around @xmath6 .
note that the star formation mass per volume and time is @xmath48 , which is @xmath49 again , since @xmath50 cancels the @xmath37 in the denominator of equation ( [ eq : main ] ) . in the composite imf model
, @xmath51 should have a steep slope at intermediate to high mass so the overall imf has a steep slope ( @xmath52 ) in low density environments , as is apparently observed ( elmegreen 2004 ) .
the miller - scalo log - normal function is used here because it has this property .
scalo ( 1986 ) cautioned that the miller - scalo function is not a good representation of the field - star imf .
he replaced the log - normal with a slightly steeper function at intermediate mass and a slightly shallower function at high mass . here ,
the miller - scalo log - normal is used only as a starting point for the calculation , calling it a spontaneous imf , and then it is evolved with coalescence to get a final imf . for
this log - normal , which is defined for equal intervals of @xmath53 , the probability function @xmath54 which is defined for equal intervals of @xmath6 , is given by : @xmath55\right)^2 } } \over { m}},\ ] ] where @xmath56 is the normalization factor making @xmath57 .
the second term in equation ( [ eq : main ] ) represents the collision rate to form a psc of mass m per unit intervals of time , volume , and mass .
the cross section @xmath40 includes gravitational focusing , @xmath58.\ ] ] the collision velocity @xmath41 for pscs is not well observed .
it may be the same for all objects and comparable to the virial velocity in the whole cloud , or may be a function of distance from the center , @xmath59 , in analogy with some turbulence models . here , @xmath41 is assumed to equal a representative three - dimensional virial velocity , @xmath60 the coefficient in front of this expression to correct for the non - uniform mass distribution in the cloud is relatively unimportant ; most of its effect can be absorbed in the factor @xmath39 .
the third term in equation ( [ eq : main ] ) is the rate of loss of condensations of mass @xmath6 resulting from collisions with all other masses ( see field & saslaw 1965 ) .
equation ( [ eq : main ] ) is solved as an initial value problem by assuming @xmath61 at @xmath62 .
the number density of pscs between masses @xmath6 and @xmath35 starts out like @xmath51 for all @xmath8 , but once a few pscs form , collisions convert low and intermediate mass stars into high mass stars , changing the imf . because most of the cloud mass is at low density where collisions are relatively unimportant , the imf is not affected much overall , but at small radii it can change a lot , becoming flatter at high mass .
figure [ fig : model ] shows several solutions to equation ( [ eq : main ] ) .
the plotted quantity is an integral over radius in the cloud , @xmath63 , where the multiplication by @xmath64 converts the function @xmath34 to @xmath65 intervals for plotting .
the cloud parameters are : @xmath66 m@xmath3 , @xmath67 pc , and @xmath68 pc .
the psc central density is @xmath69 @xmath1 for mean molecular weight @xmath70 gm .
the collapse rate parameter for pscs is @xmath71 .
the efficiencies in the evolution equation are : @xmath72 and @xmath73 @xmath74 and 0.95 .
larger @xmath39 increases the effect of collisions and flattens the imf ; @xmath75 shows the spontaneous mode .
the intrinsic imf has parameters as in the other examples above : @xmath76 m@xmath3 and @xmath77 .
the red , green and blue lines represent imfs integrated out to 2 , 5 , and 10 times the cloud core radius , @xmath12 ; they illustrate how the cloud core imf is shallower than the others .
the total integration time is one dynamical time in the cloud core , @xmath78 .
evidently coalescence in dense clusters can turn a steep intrinsic imf into one that resembles a salpeter function , with a slope of @xmath79 or shallower .
the same spontaneous imf without collisions would have a slope of @xmath80 or steeper , depending on the mass range .
we considered a cluster with nonuniform density profile and known mass and radius , in which pscs can move approximately with virial velocity . considering collisions between pscs and their gravitational collapse ,
a differential equation is presented and solved numerically which gives number density distribution of pscs inside the cloud at each radius , mass interval and time . in order to control the collision and the collapse rates in a phenomenological way
, some input parameters are introduced .
we explored a wide range of input parameters and the results were qualitatively the same as those reported here . in some starburst regions
a high fraction of high mass stars compared to low mass stars has been reported which means a high mass bias ( e.g. , sternberg 1998 ; smith & gallagher 2001 ) .
our results suggest this shift in high mass part of imfs in these starburst clusters may originates from pscs coalescence .
elmegreen ( 2004 ) discussed how various physical processes operating in at least three mass regimes may lead to three components imf .
this point is demonstrated by reviewing the observations of imf variations and using two simple models showing the observed power law distributions do not necessarily imply a single scale free star formation mechanism ( elmegreen 2004 ) .
our work in this paper confirms this expectation by presenting a simple model for collisions between psc in clusters and its possible effect on imf .
of course , we did not intend to fit the imf with a particular coalescence model , but showing that the high mass part of imf in a composite model as suggested by elmegreen ( 2004 ) , may change due to interactions between pcs .
umemoto , t. , kamazaki , t. , sunada , k. , kitamura , y. , & hasegawa , t. 2002 . in proceedings of the iau 8th asian - pacific regional meeting
, volume ii , ed .
s. ikeuchi , j. hearnshaw , & t. hanawa , tokyo : astronomical society of japan , 229 | a coalescence model using the observed properties of pre - stellar condensations ( pscs ) shows how an initially steep imf that might be characteristic of primordial cloud fragmentation can change into a salpeter imf or shallower imf in a cluster of normal density after one dynamical time , even if the pscs are collapsing on their own dynamical time .
the model suggests that top - heavy imfs in some starburst clusters originate with psc coalescence .
[ firstpage ] stars : formation , stars : mass function , ism : clouds |
lovelock theories are the natural extension of the general relativity theory of gravity given by the einstein - hilbert action to higher dimensions and higher curvature interactions .
the equations of motion do not involve terms with more than two derivatives of the metric , avoiding the appearance of ghosts @xcite .
much work has been done on the main properties of lovelock gravity due to their interest as models where our knowledge of gravity can be tested and extended .
for example , the vacua structure , the existence and properties of black holes such as their mass , entropy and thermodynamics , the gravitational phase transitions , the cosmological implications , etc . have been the object of an important amount of literature during the last years .
nevertheless , the main motivation for this review article comes from the ads / cft correspondence , famously conjectured by juan maldacena some 15 years ago @xcite .
this is nowadays well - stablished as a duality between quantum gravity theories in ads space - times and conformal field theories living at the boundary .
it is in that sense that the correspondence is dubbed customarily as the _
holographic duality_. originally formulated for @xmath0-dimensional ads and @xmath1-dimensional cft , lots of evidence accumulated over the years pointing towards its validity in higher and lower dimensions .
lovelock theories have a rich structure of ads vacua , which should be in correspondence with a similarly rich structure of higher dimensional cfts .
it is worth recalling at this point , however , that little is known about these higher dimensional cfts .
not even their existence is clear .
it has been argued that , in the supersymmetric case , there can be non trivial unitary cfts in six dimensions , whose duals are seven dimensional gravity theories .
lovelock theories provide a useful framework to unravel some of the properties of higher dimensional cfts , and also to test our understanding of the holographic duality when higher curvature terms come into play from the gravity side .
the subject is vast and it is far from our aim to cover it all . at those points where we consider that our presentation reduces to a bird s eye view , we will suggest further material where the interested reader can find more detailed explanations . the article is organized as follows :
we present the main features of lovelock gravity using the first order formalism in section [ lovelock ] . in section [ adscft ]
we review how constraints on the cft parameters are obtainted by holographically computing the two - point and three - point functions of the stress - energy tensor .
the constraints come from unitarity and positivity of the energy .
section [ causality ] is devoted to the analysis of possible causality violations by considering the scattering of gravitons against shock waves propagating in a lovelock ads background .
the results are in agreement with those of section [ adscft ] and also with the ones obtained by a similar calculation performed in the perturbed black hole background dual to a thermal field theory .
in section [ final ] we present the conclusions , add some final comments , review recent developments in the subject and give some possible directions for future work .
some four decades ago , david lovelock derived a formal expression for the most general , symmetric and conserved tensor which is quasi - linear in the second derivatives of the metric without any higher derivatives in arbitrary space - time dimensionality @xcite .
they provide an interesting playground to explore the effect of higher curvature terms in the framework of the ads / cft correspondence .
very recent reviews on general aspects of this theory include @xcite . for the sake of making progress in the study of lovelock theory , it is convenient to use differential forms and the exterior algebra ( see , for instance , @xcite ) . instead of the metric and affine connection
, we will be referring to orthonormal frames ( or _ vielbein _ ) and spin connection ( or connection 1-form ) @xcite .
this formalism will make our expressions much more compact and also the manipulations much easier .
the vielbein is a non - coordinate basis which provides an orthonormal basis for the tangent space at each point on the manifold , @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the @xmath4-dimensional minkowski metric with @xmath5 signature .
the latin indices @xmath6 are _ flat _ or _ tangent space indices _ , while the greek ones @xmath7 are _ curved _ or _ spacetime indices_. in some cases we will also distinguish spacelike @xmath8 from timelike ones .
the vielbein are @xmath4 1-forms , @xmath9 that we may use in order to rewrite the metric as @xmath10 we also need to introduce the metric compatible ( antisymmetric ) connection 1-form @xmath11 that is necessary in order to deal with tensor valued differential forms .
in addition to the usual exterior derivative , @xmath12 , we define the _ covariant _ exterior derivative , @xmath13 , that reduces to the former when applied to a scalar valued form . for a general @xmath14-tensor valued form
@xmath15 we can in this way define the torsion and curvature 2-forms as derivatives of , respectively , the vielbein and the spin connection @xmath16 r^{ab } & : = & { \mathrm{d}}{\omega}^{ab}+{\omega}^{a}_{\ c}\wedge { \omega}^{cb}=\frac{1}{2 } r_{~b\mu\nu}^{a}\ ; dx^{\mu } \wedge dx^{\nu } ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] known as the cartan structure equations .
the covariant derivative of cartan s equations give the bianchi identities @xmath17 we will consider a sector of lovelock theory where the torsion vanishes .
this is not the most general situation , but it will suffice the purpose of this article . in the absence of torsion ,
the spin connection is not independent from the metric and coincides with the levi - civita connection , @xmath18 in gr the torsion tensor is constrained to vanish .
when this constraint is not imposed , we have the einstein - cartan theories .
these are very important when considering spinor fields as these generally source the spin connection . for later use ,
it is convenient to introduce some further notation : @xmath19 e^{a_1 \ldots a_n } & : = & e^{a_1}\wedge \ldots \wedge e^{a_n } ~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we will also use the antisymmetric tensor @xmath20 when writing down and manipulating the lovelock lagrangian and the derived equations of motion .
it is antisymmetric on any pair of indices with @xmath21 .
some times , in order to deal with more compact expressions , we will write scalars constructed with the antisymmetric tensor , such as @xmath22 = \e_{a_1 \ldots a_d } \psi^{a_1 \ldots a_d } ~.\ ] ] the action of lovelock theory is given by @xmath23 @xmath24 being the newton constant in @xmath4 spacetime dimensions .
@xmath25 is a set of couplings with length dimensions @xmath26 , @xmath27 being a length scale related to the cosmological constant , while @xmath28 is a positive integer , @xmath29 ~ , \label{maximalk}\ ] ] labeling the highest non - vanishing coefficient , _
i.e. _ , @xmath30 .
@xmath31 is the exterior product of @xmath32 curvature 2-forms with the required number of vielbein , @xmath33 , to construct a @xmath4-form , @xmath34 = \epsilon_{a_1 \ldots a_{d}}\ ; r^{a_1 \ldots a_{2k } } \wedge e^{a_{2k+1 } \ldots a_d } ~. \label{llaction - k}\ ] ] the zeroth and first term in ( [ llaction ] ) correspond , respectively , to the cosmological term and the einstein - hilbert action .
it is fairly easy to see that @xmath35 and @xmath36 correspond to the usual normalization of these terms , the cosmological constant having the customary negative value @xmath37 . either a positive ( @xmath38 ) or a vanishing ( @xmath39 ) cosmological constants can be easily incorporated as well .
the first non - trivial lovelock term , @xmath40 contributes just for dimensions larger than four @xcite , and corresponds to the lanczos - gauss - bonnet ( lgb ) coupling @xmath41 .
the kaluza - klein reduction of lgb theory and its corresponding cosmological scenarios have been first considered in @xcite .
we will also discuss below the case of cubic lovelock theory , whose contribution reads @xmath42 & & + 24 r^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta } r_{\alpha\beta\nu\rho } r_{\mu}^{~\rho } + 8 r_{~~\alpha\rho}^{\mu\nu } r_{~~\nu\sigma}^{\alpha\beta } r_{~~\mu\beta}^{\rho\sigma } + 2 r_{\alpha\beta\rho\sigma } r^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta } r_{~~\mu\nu}^{\rho\sigma } ~. \label{ll3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the corresponding coupling is @xmath43 .
this latter expression is cumbersome enough to shed light on the reasons why it is much more convenient to work with expressions like ( [ llaction - k ] ) rather than the usual tensorial formalism . in first order formalism
, we shall consider the vielbein and the spin connection as independent variables .
we then have two equations of motion , one for each _
field_. varying the action with respect to the spin connection 1-form results in @xmath44 \nonumber\\ [ 0.5em ] & = & k\,{\mathrm{d}}\e\!\left[\d{\omega}r^{k-1 } e^{d-2k}\right ] - k(d-2k)\,\e\!\left[\d{\omega}t r^{k-1}e^{d-2k-1}\right ] ~ , \label{spineq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used that @xmath45 , integration by parts ( we use the technology of exterior algebra and treat exterior covariant derivatives as normal derivatives inside the brackets ) , and the bianchi identity @xmath46 .
the first term in the above variation is a total derivative and does not contribute to the equations of motion whereas the second is proportional to the torsion .
we may safely restrict to the torsionless sector , allowing us to compare our results with those coming from the tensorial formalism based on the metric .
even though the first term in ( [ spineq ] ) is irrelevant for the matter of discussing solutions to the lovelock equations , it contributes to the variation of the action in such a way that we need to include boundary terms analogous to that of gibbons and hawking @xcite for general relativity .
these terms precisely cancel the previous boundary contributions so that the lovelock action defines a well posed variational problem . in the same way as the lovelock terms are the ( dimensionally continued ) euler densities for manifolds in @xmath47 dimensions , the corresponding boundary terms appear in the generalization of the gauss - bonnet theorem to manifolds with boundaries @xcite @xmath48 ~ , \label{llboundary}\ ] ]
@xmath49 is the second fundamental form associated to the extrinsic curvature , and @xmath50 these terms play also a central rle in deriving junction conditions , such as the israel conditions in general relativity @xcite , for these gravity theories @xcite .
these matching equations have been exploited extensively in @xcite for the sake of finding distributional metrics , in the absence of matter , that allow to describe new types of phase transitions between different branches of lovelock theory .
the second equation of motion is obtained by varying the action with respect to the vielbein .
it can be casted into the form @xmath51 where @xmath52 , @xmath53 being a function of the lovelock couplings .
this expression involves just the curvature 2-form and no extra covariant derivatives , making explicit the two derivative character of the lovelock equations of motion . also , for the critical dimension @xmath54 , the @xmath55 term contribution to the equations of motion vanishes . in our approach
this is simply due to the absence of vielbein fields in the corresponding action term , thus yielding zero upon variation .
more generally , the integral of that term becomes a topological invariant , the euler number for that particular dimension . in dimensions lower than the critical one the corresponding lovelock term
exactly vanishes and we are led to the restriction ( [ maximalk ] ) .
it is transparent from ( [ eqlambda ] ) that , in principle , this theory admits @xmath28 constant curvature _ vacuum _ solutions , @xmath56 indeed , inserting @xmath57 in ( [ eqlambda ] ) , one finds that the @xmath28 different effective _ cosmological constants _ are the ( real ) solutions of the @xmath58 order _ characteristic _ polynomial @xmath59 : = \sum_{k=0}^{k } c_k\ , \lambda^k = c_k \prod_{i=1}^k \left ( \lambda - \lambda_i\right ) = 0 ~ , \label{cc - algebraic}\ ] ] each one corresponding to a different _ vacuum _ , positive , negative or zero for ds , ads and flat spacetimes .
the effective cosmological constants correspond to the ( inverse squared of the ) possible radii of these ( a)ds spaces and should not be confused with the bare cosmological constant , @xmath60 appearing in the action .
the theory will have degenerate behavior whenever two or more effective cosmological constants coincide .
this is captured by the discriminant , @xmath61 that vanishes in a certain locus of the parameter space given by the coupling constants of lovelock theory where some special features arise .
the discriminant can be written as well in terms of the first derivative of the lovelock polynomial , @xmath62 , as @xmath63| ~.\ ] ] as we move forward it will become clear the preeminent rle played by this polynomial in the most diverse situations .
another property of any degenerate vacuum is the absence of linearized gravitational degrees of freedom about it .
the equations of motion for a metric perturbation around a given vacuum , @xmath64 , are easily obtained from the perturbation of the curvature @xmath65 yielding , at linear level ,
@xmath66\,\e_{a a_1 \ldots a_{d-1 } } \delta_{\!g } r^{a_1 a_2 } \wedge e^{a_3 \ldots a_{d-1 } } ~;\ ] ] thus , it is exactly zero as long as the first derivative of @xmath62 vanishes for a degenerate vacua , @xmath67=c_k\prod_{i\neq 1}(\lambda_1-\lambda_i)=0 ~.\ ] ] moreover , it is easy to verify that the equations of motion around a non - degenerate vacuum are exactly those of the einstein - hilbert gravity , multiplied by a global factor proportional to @xmath68 $ ] .
the propagator of the graviton corresponding to the vacuum @xmath64 is then proportional to @xmath68 $ ] , in such a way that when @xmath68<0 $ ] , it has the opposite sign with respect to the einstein - hilbert case and , thus , the graviton becomes a ghost .
this generalizes the observation first done by boulware and deser @xcite in the context of lgb gravity .
thus , a given vacuum of lovelock gravity , @xmath69 , must satisfy @xmath70 > 0 ~,\ ] ] in order to host gravitons propagating with the right sign of the kinetic term .
we are going to use shock wave backgrounds of the lovelock theory for holographic applications .
these are very interesting solutions with a particular structure that make them exact solutions on any gravity theory .
in fact , they are not corrected when higher curvature corrections are included and were shown to be exact solutions of string theory @xcite . a shock wave propagating on ads along the radial direction has the form @xmath71 where we have defined light - cone coordinates @xmath72 and @xmath73 , @xmath74 is the @xmath75 vector whose components are @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath78 is an arbitrary distribution with support in @xmath79 , which we will identify later as a dirac delta function , @xmath80 , for simplicity .
@xmath81 is the ads metric in poincar coordinates , which is a solution of the einstein equations with cosmological constant @xmath69 , @xmath82 the equation of motion for the shock wave profile is @xmath83 this equation admits a few solutions , depending upon the assumptions made regarding the coordinate dependence of @xmath84 , whose rle will be discussed in what follows : @xmath85 & & \varpi_3(\mathtt{x},z ) = \frac{\varpi_0\,z^{d-3}}{\left(z^2 + ( \mathtt{x } - \mathtt{x_0})^2\right)^{d-2 } } ~. \label{wsol3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] more concretely , solutions @xmath86 and @xmath87 will be relevant for our discussions below , while @xmath88 is just a coordinate redefinition @xcite .
we will not attempt to review in detail such a vast subject in the present article . in turn , let us make a highly pragmatical construction limiting our presentation just to those features that we will need .
since we are going to work in the realm of lovelock theory , whose uv completion is unknown , we will adopt a rough version of the ads / cft correspondence assuming that : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ( quantum ) gravity in ads is dual to a cft _ living _ at the boundary .
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the interested reader may find convenient to dig into the classic review @xcite . for applications of the ads
/ cft correspondence to strongly coupled phenomena in qcd - like theories , see @xcite .
the cft dynamics is entirely given by the correlation functions of its gauge invariant local operators .
the dynamical information of the ads / cft correspondence can then be embodied in the relation between the generating functional for cft correlators and the string theory / quantum gravity in ads partition function with appropriate boundary conditions @xcite . in the case of a scalar field ,
@xmath89 , for instance , we have @xmath90 ~ , \label{adscftgolden}\ ] ] where the asymptotic value ( or boundary condition ) of the scalar field in ads acts as a source for the dual scalar operator @xmath91 .
taking into account the holographic statement establishing that the degrees of freedom of the cft are confined to the boundary , we can only define local gauge invariant observables like @xmath91 precisely at @xmath92 .
the hamiltonian is realized in the cft as the dilatation operator , in such a way that the energy in ads corresponds to the conformal dimension in the dual cft , these being related as @xmath93 the same can be also generalized to operators with spin . in the cft side
the spectrum will always contain many operators with different spins and conformal dimensions .
one of them is _ universal _ in the sense that it is present for any cft and has some very specific properties .
it is the stress - energy tensor and it is sourced in the dual picture by the boundary value of the graviton field .
we shall restrict our discussion to purely gravitational theories which then amounts to the analysis of correlators involving the stress - energy tensor . in that case
, we can compute the generating function as @xmath94 ~,\ ] ] where @xmath95 is the partition function of quantum gravity in ads spacetime , the same that we use to discuss thermodynamic properties of black holes , integrated over all metrics @xmath96 satisfying the boundary condition @xmath97 . in the saddle point approximation , this partition function can be computed as just the classical contribution , @xmath98 \right ) ~ , \label{goldrule}\ ] ] _ i.e. _ , the on - shell action for the ( least action ) classical solution with the given boundary conditions . from this expression , correlators of the stress - energy tensor
can be obtained by performing functional derivatives of ( [ goldrule ] ) with respect to the boundary metric .
this , in turn , is simply given by considering gravitational fluctuations around an asymptotically ads configuration of the theory .
the bulk metric acts as a source for the stress - energy tensor in the boundary ( and viceversa ) .
the leading singularity of the @xmath99-point function of a cft in @xmath100 dimensions , when canonical normalization has been adopted for the fundamental fields , is fully characterized by a single number , @xmath101 , known as the central charge @xcite @xmath102 where the index structure is given by @xmath103 with @xmath104 for instance , @xmath101 is proportional in a four dimensional cft to the standard central charge @xmath105 that multiplies the ( weyl)@xmath106 term in the trace anomaly , @xmath107 . following the prescription presented above
, the central charge has been computed holographically in @xcite for lgb in various dimensions and in @xcite for lovelock theory .
we shall expand this computation in the following .
since we are interested in a two - point function , the action has to be computed to second order in the metric perturbation .
it can be shown that , when the background metric is an ads solution of the lovelock action with cosmological constant , say @xmath64 , then its second variation is proportional to that of the einstein - hilbert action , the proportionality being given by the derivative of the characteristic polynomial , @xmath108\,\delta^2 { \cal i}_{eh } ~. \label{desres}\ ] ] the proof goes as follows .
in the first order formalism , the variation of the lovelock action can be written as @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is the variation of the vielbein one - form .
variations with respect to the spin connection vanish since they are proportional to the torsion .
the lovelock equations of motion ( [ eqlambda ] ) are @xmath111 . for the second variation
we have @xmath112 where the first term vanishes when evaluated on - shell , @xmath113 .
the only non - vanishing contributions of the second term , in turn , come from the derivative acting on the @xmath114 factor , @xmath115 the pre - factor is easily seen to be @xmath68 $ ] , while the remaining integral is just the second variation of the einstein - hilbert action , leading to ( [ desres ] ) .
the holographic calculation of the central charge of the cft dual to a lovelock gravitational theory is then completely analogous to that of the einstein - hilbert case , provided the boundary terms and counterterms are properly taken into account @xcite .
let us briefly review this calculation , following @xcite .
for that purpose , consider the perturbation @xmath116 where the background metric @xmath117 is the ads metric in @xmath4 dimensions , @xmath118 where we have considered , for simplicity , @xmath119 ; restoring @xmath64 factors at any step is straightforward on dimensional grounds .
the boundary at @xmath92 is flat , with metric @xmath120 .
the background metric satisfies @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the background ricci tensor in the expansion @xmath123 the complete gravity action can be expanded in powers of @xmath124 . up
to total derivative contributions , which are cancelled by the boundary terms , the quadratic part is @xmath125 \int\ !
dz\,d\textbf{x}\,\sqrt{g^0 } \left [ d_\mu h d^\mu h - 2 d^\mu h d^\nu h_{\mu \nu } \right . \nonumber\\ [ 0.5em ] & & \qquad \left .
+ 2 d^\mu h^{\alpha \beta } d_\alpha h_{\mu \beta}- d^\mu h^{\alpha \beta } d_\mu h_{\alpha \beta } \right ] ~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath126 is the trace of the perturbation . using the equations of motion ,
the action becomes a total derivative which can be reduced to an integral over the boundary .
terms without derivatives in @xmath124 are cancelled by the action counterterm proportional to the boundary volume . with the appropriate choice of gauge in which @xmath127 , the action can be finally written as @xmath128 \int\ !
d\textbf{x } ~z^{2-d } ~{\bar h}^{ab } \partial_z { \bar h}_{ab } ~,\ ] ] where @xmath129 is the traceless part of the perturbation .
the generating functional for stress - energy tensor correlation functions is then the gravity action evaluated on - shell .
this implies solving the dirichlet problem for @xmath130 consisting on the einstein equation at linear order @xmath131 with the boundary conditions : @xmath132 the solution can be written as : @xmath133 in terms of the bulk to boundary green s function @xmath134 here @xmath135 is a normalization constant ensuring that the propagator becomes a @xmath136 function at @xmath92 , @xmath137 inserting this result into the quadratic action , we obtain @xmath138 \int\ ! d\textbf{x}\,d\textbf{y } ~\frac { \mathtt{h}_{ab}(\textbf{x})~{\cal i}_{ab , cd}(\textbf{x } - \textbf{y})~\mathtt{h}_{cd}(\textbf{y})}{{\left|\textbf{x } -\textbf{y}\right|^{2(d-1 ) } } } ~,\ ] ] from where we read the central charge . restoring factors of @xmath64 on dimensional grounds this yields @xmath139}{(-\lambda_1)^{\frac{d-2}{2 } } } ~.\ ] ] then , holography teaches us that the requirement that boulware - deser instabilities ( gravitons propagating with kinetic terms of the wrong sign ) are absent in lovelock gravity , @xmath68 > 0 $ ] , is equivalent to the positivity of the central charge ; _ i.e. _ , to the condition of unitarity of the corresponding dual cft .
the form of the @xmath140-point function of the stress - tensor in a @xmath100-dimensional conformal field theory is highly constrained .
it was shown in @xcite that it can always be written in the form @xmath141 where the form of the tensor structures @xmath142 will be irrelevant for us here .
energy conservation also implies a relation between the central charge @xmath101 appearing in the @xmath99-point function , and the parameters @xmath143 , namely @xmath144}\,\frac{(d-2)(d+1)\mathcal{a}-2\mathcal{b}-4 d \,\mathcal{c}}{(d-1)(d+1 ) } ~.\ ] ] since we have already computed @xmath101 in the previous section , we are left with two independent parameters to be calculated .
a convenient parameterization of the @xmath140-point function of the stress - tensor was introduced in @xcite , where a _
collision experiment is considered in an arbitrary cft@xmath145 .
one wants to measure the total energy flux per unit angle deposited in calorimeters distributed around the collision region , @xmath146 the unit vector @xmath147 pointing towards the actual direction of measure .
the expectation value of the energy on a state created by a given local gauge invariant operator @xmath148 is given by @xmath149 thus , if @xmath150 , @xmath151 will be given in terms of 2- and 3-point correlators of @xmath152 , and rotational symmetry constraints it to be of the form @xmath153 & & \left .
\qquad\qquad\qquad + \ t_4
\left(\frac{|n_i n_j\epsilon_{ij}|^2}{\epsilon^*_{ik}\epsilon_{ik}}-\frac 2{d(d-2)}\right)\right ] ~. \label{flux}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath154 is the total energy of the insertion and @xmath155 the volume of a unit @xmath156-sphere .
we have used the fact that numerator and denominator are quadratic in the polarization tensor , fixing the numerical coefficients inside the brackets so that the integration of @xmath157 over the @xmath156-sphere gives the total energy .
the energy flux is almost completely fixed by symmetry up to the coefficients @xmath158 and @xmath159 , and since it is a quotient of 2- and 3-point functions of stress - energy tensor components , these coefficients should be writable in terms of the three parameters @xmath160 , @xmath161 and @xmath162 .
this was done in @xcite yielding @xmath163 t_4&=&-\frac{d}{d-1}\bigg(\frac{(d+1)(2(d-1)^2 - 3(d-1)-3)\mathcal{a}}{(d-2)(d+1)\mathcal{a}-2\mathcal{b}-4d\mathcal{c } } ~\nonumber \\ & & \qquad \qquad
\qquad + \frac{2(d-1)^2(d+1)\mathcal{b}-4(d-1)d(d+1)\mathcal{c}}{(d-2)(d+1)\mathcal{a}-2\mathcal{b}-4d\mathcal{c } } \bigg ) ~. \label{t2t4abc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that ( [ flux ] ) contains minus signs and , furthermore , the coefficients @xmath158 and @xmath159 are not necessarily positive .
thus , the above formulas seem compatible with an energy flux that is not manifestly positive definite .
the positivity of the energy flux for any direction @xmath147 and polarization @xmath164 seems to be a physically reasonable constraint on a well - defined cft .
indeed , it holds in all known examples , and an almost complete proof of positivity can be attained @xcite ( see also @xcite for a more recent discussion ) .
it leads to constraints on the parameters @xmath158 and @xmath159 , depending upon the splitting of @xmath164 into tensor , vector and scalar components with respect to rotations in the plane perpendicular to @xmath147 , @xmath165 { \rm vector:}\qquad & & \left ( 1 - \frac{1}{d-2}\ , t_2 - \frac{2}{d(d-2)}\ , t_4 \right ) + \frac{1}{2}\ ,
t_2 \geq 0 ~ , \label{vectorboundd } \\ [ 0.5em ] { \rm scalar:}\qquad & & \left ( 1 - \frac{1}{d-2}\ , t_2 - \frac{2}{d(d-2)}\ , t_4 \right ) + \frac{d-3}{d-2 } \left ( t_2 + t_4 \right ) \geq 0 ~. \label{scalarboundd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these constraints restrict the possible values of @xmath158 and @xmath159 for any cft , in arbitrary dimensions , to lie inside a triangle whose sides are given by ( [ tensorboundd])([scalarboundd ] ) ; see figure [ triangle ] . )
([scalarboundd ] ) restrict the values of @xmath158 and @xmath159 to the interior of a triangle with vertices in @xmath166 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 ; it is depicted , for definiteness , in the @xmath169 case.,scaledwidth=85.0% ] notice that this severe restriction does not require any _ a priori _ knowledge about the cft , such as if its a lagrangian theory , what are the relevant degrees of freedom , etc .
nevertheless , each of the constraints is saturated in a free theory with , respectively , no antisymmetric tensor fields , no fermions or no scalars @xcite .
looking at the triangle , it is straightforward to see that the helicity one contribution is not restrictive for @xmath170 . in particular , this is the case for @xmath171 .
the scalar , vector and tensor constraints coming from the positivity of energy can also be written , using ( [ t2t4abc ] ) , in terms of the parameters @xmath172 and @xmath162 , leading to the following expressions : @xmath173 \frac{(d-3)(d+1)\mathcal{a}+(3d-5)\mathcal{b}-8(d-1)\mathcal{c}}{(d-2)(d+1)\mathcal{a}-2\mathcal{b}-4d\mathcal{c } } & \geq & 0 ~,\\[0.5em ] \frac{\mathcal{b}-2\mathcal{c}}{(d-2)(d+1)\mathcal{a}-2\mathcal{b}-4d\mathcal{c } } & \leq & 0 ~.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the cft@xmath145 is supersymmetric , @xmath159 vanishes .
evidence for this claim has been given in cft@xmath174 @xcite and cft@xmath175 @xcite .
on the other hand , even though there is no proof in the literature showing that lovelock theories admit a supersymmetric extension , it turns out that the holographic computation suggests that a cft@xmath145 with a weakly curved gravitational dual whose dynamics is governed by lovelock theory will have a null value of @xmath159 @xcite . to the best of our knowledge ,
a supersymmetric extension of lovelock theory has only been accomplished in the case of lgb theory in five dimensions @xcite .
inserting @xmath171 in ( [ flux ] ) , we get @xmath176 ~. \label{vevefinal}\ ] ] demanding positivity on the energy flux for any direction @xmath147 and polarization @xmath164 , leads to a series of constraints on @xmath158 . for the tensor , vector and scalar channels , we obtain , respectively , @xmath177
as argued above , the vector channel constraint becomes irrelevant . in any lovelock gravity dual to a cft@xmath145 , therefore , @xmath158 has to take values within the window @xmath178 for instance , any @xmath179 supersymmetric cft@xmath174 has @xmath180 , with @xmath181 where @xmath182 and @xmath105 are the parameters entering the trace anomaly formula , the bound being saturated for free theories @xcite . for conformal field theories with a weakly curved gravitational dual ,
it is possible to compute @xmath158 and @xmath159 holographically @xcite .
the calculation proceeds by considering the vacuum ads solution perturbed by a shock wave , which corresponds holographically to a @xmath183 insertion . by adding a transverse metric fluctuation
, one reads off the interaction vertex from the action , and from that one obtains @xmath158 and @xmath159 .
shock wave backgrounds in lovelock theory were considered in @xcite , where it was found that in the presence of the shock wave there is room for causality violation in the dual field theory .
the proviso that causality must hold in physically sensible quantum field theories places bounds on the lovelock gravitational couplings which precisely match those portrayed in ( [ tensorboundd])([scalarboundd ] ) .
let us consider , along the lines of @xcite , a helicity two perturbation @xmath184 in the shock wave background ( [ sw ] ) , @xmath185 this amounts to choosing just one non - vanishing component of the polarization tensor , @xmath186 .
leading contributions to the equations of motion , in the high momentum limit , come from the exterior derivative of the perturbation in the spin connection .
the relevant equation of motion is @xmath187 , which , after some lengthy algebra , can be written as @xcite @xmath188}{\upsilon'[\lambda_\star]}\frac{t_2}{(d-3)(d-4 ) } \right ) \partial_v^2 \phi = 0 ~ , \label{eq3}\ ] ] where @xmath189 this is nothing but the same @xmath190 appearing in @xcite .
there is an overall factor @xmath191 $ ] multiplying ( [ eq3 ] ) , as the reader may have expected from our earlier discussion regarding the unitarity properties of gravitational perturbations . for the shock wave profile
, we shall consider a solution of the form ( [ wsol3 ] ) .
such a profile has been argued in @xcite to be the dual field configuration to @xmath192 provided @xmath193 we shall only focus on those terms proportional to @xmath194 in ( [ eq3 ] ) .
the @xmath140-point function follows from evaluating the effective action for the field @xmath195 on - shell , on a particular solution which depends on all coordinates , including @xmath196 and @xmath197 @xcite .
the cubic interaction vertex of @xmath195 with the shock wave appearing in the action will be essentially the one in the equation of motion determined above .
up to an overall factor , the cubic vertex is then @xmath198}{\upsilon'[\lambda_\star]}\frac{t_2}{(d-3)(d-4 ) } \right ) ~.\ ] ] indeed , following @xcite , the relevant graviton profile is @xmath199 so that we need to impose @xmath200 and @xmath201 yielding @xmath202 and we therefore read off @xmath203}{\upsilon'[\lambda_\star ] } ~ , \quad\qquad t_4 = 0 ~. \label{t2t4}\ ] ] as announced above , the holographic value of @xmath159 vanishes in lovelock theory . combining ( [ t2window ] ) and ( [ t2t4 ] ) , in turn
, we obtain @xcite @xmath204}{\upsilon'[\lambda_\star ] } \leq d-2 ~. \label{llwindow}\ ] ] if specialized to the case of lgb gravity , equation ( [ t2t4 ] ) reproduces the results obtained in @xcite . for the general case ,
it is exactly the same as conjectured in @xcite . using these results altogether , including the holographic expression for @xmath101 , we find formulas for the usual @xmath140-point function parameters @xmath205 , in terms of the lovelock couplings : @xmath206}{\pi^{d-1}}\ , \frac{1}{(-\lambda_\star)^{d/2 } } \left(\frac{2 d \lambda_\star \upsilon''[\lambda_\star]}{(d-4)^2}+ \upsilon'[\lambda_\star]\right ) ~ , \nonumber \\[0.5em ] \mathcal{b } & = & -\frac { ( d-1 ) } { ( d-2)^3 } \frac{\gamma[d]}{\pi^{d-1 } } \frac{1}{(-\lambda_\star)^{d/2 } } \bigg(\frac { ( d-1 ) d \left(d^2 - 4 d + 6\right ) \lambda_\star \upsilon''[\lambda_\star]}{(d-4)^2 } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \left(d^3 - 4d^2 + 5 d-1\right )
\upsilon'[\lambda_\star]\bigg ) ~ , \nonumber\\ [ 0.5em ] \mathcal{c } & = & -\frac{(d-1)^2 } { 2(d-2)^3}\frac{\gamma[d]}{\pi^{d-1 } } \frac{1}{(-\lambda_\star)^{d/2 } } \bigg ( \frac { \left(d^3 - 3 d^2 + 3 d-4\right ) \lambda_\star \upsilon''[\lambda_\star]}{(d-4)^2 } \nonumber \\ & & \qquad + \frac{1}{2 } ( 2 ( d-3 ) d+3)\ , \upsilon'[\lambda_\star]\bigg ) ~. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the coming section , we will show that the region of lovelock parameters given by ( [ llwindow ] ) exactly matches the conditions we must impose to avoid causality violation .
constraints coming from positivity of the energy will be shown to agree with those coming from imposing causality at the boundary theory due to the bulk gravity background . one way of checking this is by looking at perturbations of lovelock black holes dual to thermal states of finite temperature cfts . a detailed study of maximally symmetric black holes in lovelock theory has been carried out in @xcite
. the interested reader shall find all relevant formulas in that reference . having the holographic picture in mind
, it is interesting to scrutinize the possibility , for these backgrounds , of having trajectories that start from the boundary of ads and come back to it .
these can be interpreted as bulk disturbances created by local operators in the boundary cft , and we expect micro - causality violation in this theory if there exists a bouncing graviton traveling faster than light from the point of view of the boundary theory .
this phenomenon may happen due to the fact that , in higher curvature gravity , gravitons do not propagate according to their background metric but , instead , feel an _ effective metric _ related to their equations of motion @xcite . in the large momentum limit ,
localized wave packets moving along null geodesics of this effective geometry satisfy radial equations of the form ( @xmath207 ) @xmath208 equivalent to those of a particle of energy @xmath209 moving in a potential given by @xmath210 , which corresponds to the velocity of high momentum gravitons of helicity @xmath211 in the different radial slices .
these potentials always go to one at the boundary , and they approach zero at the black hole horizon . in most cases ,
the potential is monotonic and , thereby , the graviton inevitably falls into the black hole .
whenever there is a maximum in @xmath210 , in turn , geodesics starting at the boundary can be seen to find their way back to it , with turning point @xmath212 . for a null bouncing geodesic starting and ending at the boundary ,
as the energy @xmath213 approaches the value of the speed at the maximum , @xmath214 ( _ i.e. _ , @xmath215 ) , we have @xmath216 these geodesics spend an arbitrarily long time near the maximum , traveling with an average speed which is bigger than one . interpreting this as originating from local operators in the boundary cft
, the hypothetical dual field theory will not be causal if there exists a bouncing geodesic obeying ( [ superlum ] ) . in order to avert causality violation
, we must demand these effective potentials to be always smaller than one @xcite .
given that , in particular , at the boundary we have @xmath217 , we must demand @xmath218 , as @xmath219 .
this leads to the following constraints : @xmath220+\frac{2 ( d-1)}{(d-3)(d-4)}\,\lambda_\star \upsilon''[\lambda_\star ] \geq 0 ~ , \nonumber\\[0.5em ] { \rm vector:}\qquad & & \upsilon'[\lambda_\star]-\frac { ( d-1)}{(d-3)}\,\lambda_\star \upsilon''[\lambda_\star ] \geq 0 ~ , \label{genconstraints } \\[0.5em ] { \rm scalar:}\qquad & & \upsilon'[\lambda_\star]-\frac{2 ( d-1)}{(d-3)}\,\lambda_\star \upsilon''[\lambda_\star ] \geq 0 ~. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the three channels discussed above .
these can be rewritten in terms of the dual cft parameters , using the expressions for @xmath221 in ( [ t2t4 ] ) .
strikingly enough , the result is exactly ( [ tensorboundd])([scalarboundd ] ) with @xmath222 ; that is , ( [ t2channels ] ) . ) in seven dimensions becomes , after plugging in the holographic expressions for @xmath158 and @xmath159 , the shadowed ( pink ) region with the shape of an eagle head .
the gravitational couplings of lovelock theory are constrained to belong to that region , in the ads / cft framework.,scaledwidth=94.0% ] in the seven dimensional case , the allowed window ( [ t2window ] ) reads @xmath223 . by means of ( [ t2t4 ] ) this can be translated into two curves that delimit the region of the space of lovelock couplings compatible with causality ; see figure [ causal ] .
these are , of course , the tensor and scalar channel inequalities displayed in ( [ genconstraints ] ) . in this way
, the constraints posed by causality fully match those arising from the requirement of positivity of the energy in the dual conformal field theory .
the previous computations are carried on a black hole background . as such
, they are adequate in the context of thermal cfts .
as pointed out in @xcite , causality violation should not be associated to a thermal feature , thereby one would expect to be able to perform a similar computation in a zero temperature background .
an adequate background to perform a computation that is independent of the temperature is given by a pp - wave .
in particular , it is easier to consider the simplest case , provided by shock waves @xcite , since they are not subjected to higher derivative corrections @xcite . as such , ads shock waves are exact solutions in lovelock theory ( in string theory as well )
. we will study the scattering of a graviton with an ads shock wave in lovelock theory .
this computation , originally carried out by hofman in the case of lgb gravity in 5d @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , and later extended to arbitrary higher dimensional spacetime @xcite , can also be generalized to the case of any lovelock theory @xcite .
this process is , in a sense , the gravity dual of the energy 1-point function in the cft @xcite .
we will see , once again , that causality violation poses a constraint on the allowed values of @xmath158 . for forbidden values of this parameter ,
a graviton that is emitted from the boundary would come back and _ land _ outside its own light cone .
the splitting of the graviton into different helicities will fully agree with the various polarization of the operator @xmath150 in ( [ flux ] ) , for reasons that should be clear at this point of our discussion . for definiteness , we present the computation in the helicity two channel
. this amounts to the line element already given in ( [ dssw ] ) .
the solution we are going to consider for the shock wave propagating on ads is of the type displayed in the left expression in ( [ wsol2 ] ) , which , as discussed in @xcite , can be obtained from the black hole background by boosting the solution while keeping its energy constant .
the normalization constant @xmath224 is proportional to the energy density and , as such , must be positive if the original black hole solution had a positive mass .
we will compute the time delay , @xmath225 , due to the collision of our perturbation with the shock wave , in order to analyze the occurrence ( or not ) of causality violation from the boundary point of view .
for that it will be important to make certain that the delay due to free propagation in ads is negligible compared to the shock wave contribution .
we will then need to consider the large momentum regime for our perturbation , in accordance with the analogous computation performed in the lovelock black hole background . in this limit
, the free propagation of a localized wave packet can be well approximated by geodesic motion in ads that then yields @xmath226 where @xmath227 is the radial position of the collision point .
we neglected the graviton motion in the transverse directions , thereby we see that we need @xmath228 ( that also implies @xmath229 ) .
we only keep contributions of the sort @xmath230 and @xmath231 in the equations of motion , as shown earlier in ( [ eq3 ] ) .
the latter , even if subdominant , has to be kept to provide the dynamics of the graviton outside the locus of the shock wave . inserting @xmath232 in ( [ eq3 ] ) , we get @xmath233 where @xmath234 can be written in terms of @xmath158 defined in ( [ t2t4 ] ) , @xmath235 the computation for the other two helicities is harder , but the result is alike , with @xmath234 replaced by @xmath236 , and @xmath237 taking the shock wave profile to be a delta function , @xmath238 , the equation of motion reduces to the usual wave equation @xmath239 outside the locus @xmath240 .
then , we can consider a wave packet moving with definite momentum on both sides of the shock wave .
we can find a matching condition just by integrating the corresponding equation of motion along the discontinuity , @xmath241 where @xmath242 and @xmath243 are the values of the perturbation at both sides of the discontinuity , and we used @xmath244 .
we can find the shift in the momentum in the @xmath245-direction acting with @xmath246 , @xmath247 if we consider a particle going inside ads , @xmath248 .
the momentum in the radial direction will change sign the perturbation coming back to the boundary after the collision , provided @xmath249 for sufficiently large @xmath250 ( since the black hole originating the shock wave had positive mass ) .
now , both @xmath251 and @xmath69 are negative , the former simply due to the fact that @xmath252 ( and @xmath253 must be positive for the energy to be so ) . therefore , when @xmath254 for all three helicities , the graviton will make its way back to the boundary and , as we can thoroughly read from ( [ matching ] ) , corresponds to the shock wave while the line @xmath255 corresponds to the graviton . after the collision ,
if @xmath256 , the particle lands outside its light - cone.,scaledwidth=43.0% ] it comes back shifted in the @xmath257-direction a negative amount ( see figure [ shockwave ] ) @xmath258 the graviton lands , at the boundary , outside its own light - cone .
this is an explicit break up of causality .
we conclude that the theory violates causality unless @xmath259 for the three helicity channels , which amounts exactly to the same constraints found in the black hole case and , as well , to those arising from positivity of the energy in the dual cft , displayed in ( [ t2channels ] ) .
as we have seen throughout these pages , lovelock theories of gravity appear as a very useful playground in order to analyze several aspects of the gauge / gravity duality .
the precise status of these theories is at present unclear , as they do not generally appear in the low energy action of string theory , at least not with finite coefficients , and their ultraviolet completion is unknown . although this is true , lovelock gravities are two derivative theories , the most natural extension of general relativity in higher dimensions , and there is no a priori reason why these can not appear as classical limits of a quantum theory of gravity , thus subject to the holographic principle . from the cft point of view ,
moreover , the inclusion of these higher curvature terms allows for the description of more general field theories , a notable example being strongly coupled cfts with different central charges , @xmath260 , in four dimensions @xcite at leading order in the large n limit . besides
, the analysis of the would be cft duals of lovelock gravities has lead to some very interesting and unsuspected insights .
one that has been extensively reviewed in this article is the relation between causality and positivity of the energy .
our analysis indicates that the violation of the positivity constraints leads to the appearance of superluminal modes propagating in the field theory . using purely field theory techniques
it has been shown that the same constraints are needed to avoid the presence of ghosts at finite temperature @xcite .
many efforts have been devoted in the last few years to the analysis of some of the preeminent features of lovelock theory such as its black hole solutions , their thermodynamics and phase transitions , their would be instabilities and the generic existence of more than one maximally symmetric solution or _
vacuum_. even though it seems to us that the last word has not been said , the results obtained so far indicate that there is no obvious pathology that invalidates the consideration of these theories once and for all , at least for some ( finite ) region of the parameter space that includes the einstein - hilbert case .
some authors have pointed to some instabilities that quite generically appear in these theories as being a sign of their _
sickness_. much on the contrary , these instabilities have been found to play a central rle in the dynamics of the theory .
for instance , they generically prevent the formation of naked singularities thus being instrumental in the _ cosmic censorship hypothesis _ coming into being in this context@xcite . in the present article
we have focused our discussion in a few examples where lovelock theory has been shown to yield interesting holographic connections between the gravitational and the field theory dynamics , connections that would otherwise be impossible to uncover in the simpler setup of general relativity .
many more examples exist , though , of the convenience of this extended framework for the discussion of the most diverse issues .
one such example concerns the existence of an analog of zamolodchikov s @xmath105-theorem @xcite in higher dimensions , namely for 4d cfts .
even though some previous indications existed @xcite , the existence of a would be monotonic quantity and how this would be related to the central charges of the theory in four dimensions , @xmath182 and @xmath105 , was not properly established . under a holographic rg flow , the existence of a monotonic quantity related to the central charge
@xmath182 has been pointed out in @xcite , much earlier than the actual field theoretic proof of the so - called @xmath182-theorem was found @xcite .
no monotonicity property is known for the other central charge , @xmath105 .
the use of higher curvature theories is essential here as otherwise it would be impossible to identify which is the central charge with the monotonic property , given that @xmath182 and @xmath105 have the same value if gravity is governed by the einstein - hilbert action .
another important issue that is receiving a lot of attention lately is that of entanglement entropy . the ryu - takayanagi proposal @xcite for the holographic computation of this important quantity amounts to the determination of a minimal surface enclosing the region of interest at the boundary , the entanglement entropy being simply proportional to the area of such surface .
this conjecture has recently been accounted for in @xcite .
the nave generalization of this prescription to higher curvature gravities would be that the entropy is given by the wald formula , but this has been argued to be wrong @xcite . a more educated guess would be to consider the wald - iyer formula @xcite , that reduces to the modified proposal in @xcite for lovelock gravity @xcite .
the checks performed in order to find the discrepancies involve certain specific contributions to the entanglement entropy that are completely governed by the conformal anomaly .
depending on the shape of the region of interest , those contributions have to be proportional to a different combination of the central charges of the theory .
the wald proposal , instead , yields the same combination of central charges independently of the shape .
in the case of einstein - hilbert gravity we have just one independent combination of the central charges , and this is the reason behind the fact that the simplified area prescription works . another obvious field where higher curvature gravity theories have shown their value and utility
is that of the fluid / gravity correspondence ( see , for instance , @xcite for a review of one possible approach ) . in this framework , similarly to the cft case , lovelock gravities allow for the description of relativistc fluid duals with more general transport coefficients than those resulting from the einstein - hilbert action .
the most celebrated example is that of the shear viscosity to entropy density ratio , @xmath261 ( see @xcite for a recent review , and references therein ) . in the context of higher curvature gravity theories ,
this specific transport coefficient has been considered in many papers ( see @xcite for some relevant examples ) .
higher curvature theories , lovelock in particular , have been used to disprove the longstanding kss viscosity bound conjecture @xcite .
the value of the shear viscosity to entropy density in general lovelock theories has been established in @xcite , where it was proven that the only lovelock coefficient affecting the actual value of @xmath261 is the lgb one ; any positive value of @xmath262 translating into a violation of the viscosity bound .
the causality / positivity constraints discussed in the core of this paper have been argued to impose a new bound for any lovelock theory in any number of space - time dimensions , even though also stability constraints have to be considered to avoid negative values of @xmath263 in general @xcite . in spite of the fact that higher order lovelock terms do not enter the holographic formula of the shear viscosity , they do change the actual value of the bound .
a way of lifting the causality constraints on @xmath261 has been proposed in @xcite , but stability still implies the existence of a finite bound .
it is worth mentioning at this point that higher curvature corrections that are not of the lovelock type are also relevant in this discussion as , for instance , in the case of quasi topological gravity where @xmath264 and the bound can be slightly lowered @xcite . in this respect , the lovelock setup shall be viewed as an exploratory playground where computations are under better control due to the second order nature of its equations of motion .
another possible connection between lovelock theory and the fluid / gravity correspondence may have to do with the realization in @xcite that the existence of a positive divergence entropy current in an arbitrary curved background and the onsager principle put severe constraints in the terms appearing at first order in the hydrodynamics derivative expansion .
it is natural to wonder whether similar constraints appear in gravity , restricting the space of allowed higher derivative corrections to einstein s equations @xcite
. this may be particularly relevant for those cases in which the entropy production vanishes in einstein gravity , and one might have to go to the next correction to realize which is the sign of the divergence of the entropy current .
surely many more applications of lovelock theory in the framework of the ads / cft correspondence were left into the ink pot .
it is a lively subject in which we expect to see further progress happening soon .
we wish to thank alex buchel , gastn giribet , andy gomberoff , diego hofman , manuela kulaxizi , juan maldacena , rob myers , miguel paulos and sasha zhiboedov for discussions on these subjects held over the last few years .
this work was supported in part by micinn and feder ( grant fpa2011 - 22594 ) , by xunta de galicia ( consellera de educacin and grant pgidit10pxib206075pr ) , and by the spanish consolider - ingenio 2010 programme cpan ( csd2007 - 00042 ) .
x.o.c . is thankful to the front of galician - speaking scientists for encouragement .
d. lovelock , _ the einstein tensor and its generalizations _ , _ j. math
. phys . _ * 12 * ( 1971 ) 498 .
b. zwiebach , _ curvature squared terms and string theories _ , _ phys .
b _ * 156 * ( 1985 ) 315 .
b. zumino , _ gravity theories in more than four dimensions _ , _ phys .
_ * 137 * ( 1986 ) 109 .
j. m. maldacena , _ the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity _ , _ adv .
_ * 2 * ( 1998 ) 231 . t. padmanabhan and d. kothawala , _ lanczos - lovelock models of gravity _ , arxiv:1302.2151 [ gr - qc ]
. j. d. edelstein , _ lovelock theory , black holes and holography _ , arxiv:1303.6213 [ gr - qc ] .
t. eguchi , p. b. gilkey and a. j. hanson , _ gravitation , gauge theories and differential geometry _ , _ phys .
rept . _ * 66 * ( 1980 ) 213 .
e. gravanis and s. willison , _ intersecting membranes in ads and lovelock gravity _ , _
j. math .
_ * 47 * ( 2006 ) 092503 j. zanelli , _ lecture notes on chern - simons ( super-)gravities _ , hep - th/0502193
. t. regge , _ on broken symmetries and gravity _ , _ phys .
_ * 137 * ( 1986 ) 31 . c. lanczos , _ a remarkable property of the riemann - christoffel tensor in four dimensions _
, _ annals math .
_ * 39 * ( 1938 ) 842 .
j. madore , _ kaluza - klein theory with the lanczos lagrangian _ , _ phys .
lett . a _ * 110 * ( 1985 ) 289 . g. w. gibbons and s. w. hawking , _
action integrals and partition functions in quantum gravity _ , _ phys .
d _ * 15 * ( 1977 ) 2752 .
r. myers , _ higher - derivative gravity , surface terms , and string theory _
, _ phys .
d _ * 36 * ( 1987 ) 392 .
w. israel , _ singular hypersurfaces and thin shells in general relativity _ , _
nuovo cim .
b _ * 44 * ( 1966 ) 1 [ _ erratum - ibid . b _ * 48 * ( 1967 ) 463 ] . e. gravanis and s. willison , _
israel conditions for the gauss - bonnet theory and the friedmann equation on the brane universe _ , _ phys .
b _ * 562 * ( 2003 ) 118 .
x. o. camanho , j. d. edelstein , g. giribet and a. gomberoff , _ new type of phase transition in gravitational theories _ , _ phys .
d _ * 86 * ( 2012 ) 124048 .
x. o. camanho , j. d. edelstein , g. giribet and a. gomberoff , _ generalized phase transition in lovelock theory _ , to appear , 2013 .
d. g. boulware and s. deser , _ string generated gravity models _ , _ phys .
lett . _ * 55 * ( 1985 ) 2656
. g. t. horowitz and n. itzhaki , _ black holes , shock waves , and causality in the ads / cft correspondence _ , _ jhep _ * 9902 * ( 1999 ) 010 .
d. m. hofman and j. maldacena , _ conformal collider physics : energy and charge correlations _ , _ jhep _ * 0805 * ( 2008 ) 012 .
o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , _ large n field theories , string theory and gravity _ , _ phys . rept . _ * 323 * ( 2000 ) 183 . j. d. edelstein and r. portugues , _ gauge / string duality in confining theories _ , _ fortsch .
_ * 54 * ( 2006 ) 525 .
j. casalderrey - solana , h. liu , d. mateos , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , _ gauge / string duality , hot qcd and heavy ion collisions _ , arxiv:1101.0618 [ hep - th ] .
s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , _ gauge theory correlators from non - critical string theory _ , _ phys .
b _ * 428 * ( 1998 ) 105 .
e. witten , _ anti - de sitter space and holography _ , _ adv .
_ * 2 * ( 1998 ) 253 . h. osborn and a. c. petkou , _ implications of conformal invariance in field theories for general dimensions _ , _ annals phys .
_ * 231 * ( 1994 ) 311 .
a. buchel , j. escobedo , r. c. myers , m. f. paulos , a. sinha and m. smolkin , _ holographic gb gravity in arbitrary dimensions _ , _ jhep _ * 1003 * ( 2010 ) 111 .
x. o. camanho , j. d. edelstein and m. f. paulos , _ lovelock theories , holography and the fate of the viscosity bound _ , _ jhep _ * 1105 * ( 2011 ) 127 . g. arutyunov and s. frolov , _ three point green function of the stress energy tensor in the ads / cft correspondence _ , _ phys .
d _ * 60 * ( 1999 ) 026004 .
h. liu and a. a. tseytlin , _
d=4 super yang - mills , d=5 gauged supergravity , and d=4 conformal supergravity _ , _ nucl .
b _ * 533 * ( 1998 ) 88 .
j. erdmenger and h. osborn , _ conserved currents and the energy - momentum tensor in conformally invariant theories for general dimensions _ , _ nucl .
b _ * 483 * ( 1997 ) 431 .
d. m. hofman , _ higher derivative gravity , causality and positivity of energy in a uv complete qft _ , _ nucl .
b _ * 823 * ( 2009 ) 174 .
a. zhiboedov , _ on conformal field theories with extremal a / c values _ , arxiv:1304.6075 [ hep - th ] . m. kulaxizi and a. parnachev , _ supersymmetry constraints in holographic gravities _ , _ phys .
d _ * 82 * ( 2010 ) 066001 .
j. de boer , m. kulaxizi and a. parnachev , _ holographic lovelock gravities and black holes _ , _ jhep _ * 1006 * ( 2010 ) 008 .
x. o. camanho and j. d. edelstein , _ causality in ads / cft and lovelock theory _
, _ jhep _ * 1006 * ( 2010 ) 099 . m. ozkan and y. pang , _ supersymmetric completion of gauss - bonnet combination in five dimensions _ ,
_ jhep _ * 1303 * ( 2013 ) 158 .
x. o. camanho and j. d. edelstein , _ causality constraints in ads / cft from conformal collider physics and gauss - bonnet gravity _ , _ jhep _ * 1004 * ( 2010 ) 007 .
a. buchel and r. c. myers , _ causality of holographic hydrodynamics _ , _ jhep _ * 0908 * ( 2009 ) 016
. j. de boer , m. kulaxizi and a. parnachev , _
ads@xmath265/cft@xmath175 , gauss - bonnet gravity , and viscosity bound _ , _ jhep _ * 1003 * ( 2010 ) 087 . j. t. wheeler ,
_ symmetric solutions to the gauss - bonnet extended einstein equations _ , _ nucl .
b _ * 268 * ( 1986 ) 737 .
j. t. wheeler , _ symmetric solutions to the maximally gauss - bonnet extended einstein equations _ , _ nucl .
b _ * 273 * ( 1986 ) 732 .
r. c. myers and j. z. simon , _ black hole thermodynamics in lovelock gravity _ , _ phys .
d _ * 38 * ( 1988 ) 2434 .
d. l. wiltshire , _ black holes in string generated gravity models _ , _ phys .
d _ * 38 * ( 1988 ) 2445 .
b. whitt , _ spherically symmetric solutions of general second order gravity _ , _ phys .
d _ * 38 * ( 1988 ) 3000 .
m. baados , c. teitelboim and j. zanelli , _ black hole entropy and the dimensional continuation of the gauss - bonnet theorem _ , _ phys .
lett . _ * 72 * ( 1994 ) 957 .
j. crisostomo , r. troncoso and j. zanelli , _ black hole scan _ , _ phys . rev . d _ * 62 * ( 2000 ) 084013 . c. charmousis , _ higher order gravity theories and their black hole solutions _ , _ lect .
notes phys .
_ * 769 * ( 2009 ) 299 . c. garraffo and g. giribet , _ the lovelock black holes _ , _ mod .
lett . a _ * 23 * ( 2008 ) 1801 .
x. o. camanho and j. d. edelstein , _ a lovelock black hole bestiary _ , _ class . quant
. grav . _ * 30 * ( 2013 ) 035009 .
m. brigante , h. liu , r. c. myers , s. shenker and s. yaida , _ viscosity bound violation in higher derivative gravity _ , _ phys .
d _ * 77 * ( 2008 ) 126006 .
m. brigante , h. liu , r. c. myers , s. shenker and s. yaida , _ the viscosity bound and causality violation _ , _ phys .
_ * 100 * ( 2008 ) 191601 .
g. t. horowitz and n. itzhaki , black holes , shock waves , and causality in the ads / cft correspondence , _ jhep _ * 9902 * ( 1999 ) 010 .
r. lang , _ propagation of gravitons in the shock wave geometry _ , b.sc .
thesis , mit , 2009 .
s. i .
nojiri and s. d. odintsov , _ on the conformal anomaly from higher derivative gravity in ads / cft correspondence _ , _ int .
j. mod .
phys . a _ * 15 * ( 2000 ) 413 .
m. kulaxizi and a. parnachev , _ energy flux positivity and unitarity in cfts , _ _ phys .
lett . _ * 106 * ( 2011 ) 011601 .
x. o. camanho and j. d. edelstein , _ cosmic censorship in lovelock theory _ , arxiv:1308.0304 [ hep - th ] .
a. b. zamolodchikov , _ irreversibility of the flux of the renormalization group in a 2d field theory _ , _ jetp lett . _ * 43 * ( 1986 ) 730 [ _ pisma zh
. eksp .
_ * 43 * ( 1986 ) 565 ]
. i. jack and h. osborn , _
analogs for the c - theorem for four - dimensional renormalizable field theories _ , _ nucl .
b _ * 343 * ( 1990 ) 647 .
r. c. myers and a. sinha , _ holographic c - theorems in arbitrary dimensions _ , _ jhep _ * 1101 * ( 2011 ) 125 . z. komargodski and a. schwimmer , _ on renormalization group flows in four dimensions _ , _ jhep _ * 1112 * ( 2011 ) 099 .
s. ryu and t. takayanagi , _ holographic derivation of entanglement entropy from ads / cft _ , _ phys .
lett . _ * 96 * ( 2006 ) 181602 .
a. lewkowycz and j. maldacena , _ generalized gravitational entropy _ ,
arxiv:1304.4926 [ hep - th ] . l. -y . hung , r. c. myers and m. smolkin , _ on holographic entanglement entropy and higher curvature gravity _ , _ jhep _ * 1104 * ( 2011 ) 025 .
v. iyer and r. m. wald , _ some properties of noether charge and a proposal for dynamical black hole entropy _ , _ phys .
d _ * 50 * ( 1994 ) 846 .
j. de boer , m. kulaxizi and a. parnachev , _ holographic entanglement entropy in lovelock gravities _ , _ jhep _ * 1107 * ( 2011 ) 109 .
v. e. hubeny , s. minwalla and m. rangamani , _ the fluid / gravity correspondence _ , arxiv:1107.5780 [ hep - th ] .
s. cremonini , _ the shear viscosity to entropy ratio : a status report _ , _ mod .
b _ * 25 * ( 2011 ) 1867 .
a. buchel , _ shear viscosity of cft plasma at finite coupling _ , _ phys .
b _ * 665 * ( 2008 ) 298 .
a. buchel and s. cremonini , _ viscosity bound and causality in superfluid plasma _ , _ jhep _ * 1010 * ( 2010 ) 026 .
a. buchel , m. p. heller and r. c. myers , _ sqgp as hcft _ , _ phys .
b _ * 680 * ( 2009 ) 521 .
a. buchel , r. c. myers and a. sinha , _ beyond @xmath266
_ , _ jhep _ * 0903 * ( 2009 ) 084
. y. -p .
hu , h. -f .
li and z. -y .
nie , _ the first order hydrodynamics via ads / cft correspondence in the gauss - bonnet gravity _ , _ jhep _ * 1101 * ( 2011 ) 123 .
p. kovtun , d. t. son , and a. o. starinets , _ viscosity in strongly interacting quantum field theories from black hole physics _ , _ phys .
lett . _ * 94 * ( 2005 ) 111601 .
shu , _ the quantum viscosity bound in lovelock gravity _ , _ phys .
b _ * 685 * ( 2010 ) 325 .
r. c. myers , m. f. paulos and a. sinha , _ holographic studies of quasi - topological gravity _ , _ jhep _ * 1008 * ( 2010 ) 035 .
j. bhattacharya , s. bhattacharyya , s. minwalla and a. yarom , _ a theory of first order dissipative superfluid dynamics _ , arxiv:1105.3733 [ hep - th ] .
s. minwalla , _ the entropy current in hydrodynamics , superfluid hydrodynamics and gravity _ , talk at strings 2011 . | lovelock theory is the natural extension of general relativity to higher dimensions .
it can be also thought of as a toy model for ghost - free higher curvature corrections in gravitational theories .
it admits a family of ads vacua , which provides an appealing arena to explore different holographic aspects in a broader setup within the context of the ads / cft correspondence .
we will elaborate on these features and review previous work concerning the constraints that lovelock theory entails on the cft parameters when imposing conditions like unitarity , positivity of the energy or causality . |
in quantum field theory the normal - ordered energy density does not need to be positive .
in other words the expectation value of the energy density at a point @xmath2 @xmath3 for certain states @xmath4 of the quantum field , can be arbitrarily negative .
let us give a simple example , consider the following state @xmath5 which is a superposition of the vacuum state @xmath6 and two particle state @xmath7 . and
@xmath8 i.e. @xmath9 , where for simplicity the polarization was disregarded . ]
a calculation shows that the energy density , at a certain point @xmath2 , contains two , generally non - vanishing , terms @xmath10 evidently we can choose the sign and the magnitude of @xmath11 in such a way , that @xmath12 becomes negative at the point @xmath2 . since the time that the appearance of negative energies in quantum field theory has been recognized we have learned a great deal about this phenomenon .
above all , the integrated energy density ( i.e. the total energy ) must always be positive .
therefore the negative energy densities are expected to be present only locally and are suppressed by positive ones in adjacent regions .
moreover , there is an important question about whether negative energy densities can be present at a certain point @xmath2 for a longer time . the fact that they can not was discovered by l.ford @xcite .
physically , the longer the time of measurement the less negative the energy becomes .
a whole branch of theoretical physics grew out of this pioneering work .
the so - called quantum inequalities have been proven with great generality@xcite for various types of fields , eg .
electromagnetic @xcite , dirac @xcite , even in the situation where the fields propagate in a curved spacetime ( which is far more difficult than anything we shall present here ) .
on the other hand , curiously , the type of states ( [ state ] ) have recently become a standard tool in quantum optics . known as squeezed states they arise in the process of parametric down conversion@xcite where an incident photon is converted in a non - linear crystal element into a coherent pare of two photons @xcite .
an interesting phenomenon has been observed in the presence of squeezed states : the fluctuations of the electric field are locally lower than the vacuum fluctuations , the so - called shot - noise level .
the amount of this reduction , the so - called degree of squeezing , has been the subject of intensive experimental studies . recently
this reduction has been pushed up to @xmath13 @xcite .
as far as we know quantum field theoreticians do not know that their inequalities may influence real experiments nor are quantum opticians aware of the existence of such inequalities .
an immediate question arises , namely whether there is an analogue of a quantum inequality for the reduction of the electric field fluctuations , and an even deeper one of whether the reduction of fluctuations has anything in common with negative energy densities .
we shall give an affirmative answer to the first question and an argument with regard to the second .
our paper is organized as follows : the second chapter contains a derivation of the inequality for the reduction of the electric - field fluctuation .
the inequality is presented in the most general form with an arbitrary time - probe function .
the reduction is expressed , as typically for quantum inequalities , in units of energy .
the third chapter contains three adaptations of the inequality in the context of quantum - optical experiments .
firstly , the observables are restricted in frequency , reflecting the physical situation where all detectors are characterized by a frequency - dependent sensitivity function , @xmath14 . with this step
the vacuum fluctuations become finite . secondly
, the maximal possible reduction is expressed in the @xmath15 scale ( minimal fluctuations versus vacuum fluctuations ) making it compatible with the language in which experimental results are typically presented .
thirdly , two time - probe functions are discussed , each dependent on the time - parameter @xmath16 expressing the length of the interval in which the fluctuations are registered .
those three adaptations allow for a prediction on the maximal degree of squeezing which is given in chapter four . in order to establish this prediction
we give supplementary arguments regarding the interpretation of the local oscillator phase @xmath17 in the balanced homodyne detection of the squeezed light .
the first of the appendices contains a rather technical , but elementary typical derivation of quantum inequalities .
the second appendix presents an actual calculation of the claimed maximal reductions of field fluctuations .
as we shall see in the following investigations the method typically utilized in quantum inequalities can easily be applied to certain observables which measure `` the amount of '' electric field fluctuations in quantum optics .
we shall prove an inequality for fluctuations of the electric part of the electromagnetic field similar to the one obtained by fewster and teo in @xcite and recently by pfenning @xcite ( although those authors consider a much more complicated case of background gravitational field ) .
more precisely we will be interested in the expectation value of the square of the electric field : @xmath18 the square of the electric - field operator is not a well - defined observable and @xmath19 .
in short - @xmath20 is not an operator valued distribution . ] . in order to avoid mathematical nonsense
we must therefore define the observables of interest with care . a precise definition of the square of the electric field is provided by the standard procedure of point splitting . in the present context , where the ground state is simply the vacuum state ( denoted by @xmath21 ) , the point splitting results in normal ordering .
the point splitting procedure gives a physical meaning to the normal ordering ( instead of regarding it as a dumb rule of mechanical operator ordering ) which we shall use later .
we therefore recall it briefly : * the bi - local observable @xmath22 , is a well defined observable ( operator valued bi - distribution ) , * the bi - local difference @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the identity operator and @xmath25 denotes an expectation value in the vacuum state , is also an operator - valued bi - distribution , and * the limit @xmath26 exists as an operator valued distribution .
although @xmath27 is simply the normal ordering of the square of @xmath28 we see that its expectation value in a certain state @xmath4 of the electromagnetic field gives the difference of the expectation values of the squares of the field between the state @xmath4 and the vacuum state although those expectation values alone are infinite and thus have no meaning . in the following
we will investigate the time - weighted electric field squares at a certain point in space ( say @xmath19 ) : @xmath29 here @xmath30 denotes a positive , real - valued function which is normalized in the probabilistic sense : @xmath31 we emphasize that the following considerations will be state - independent .
we shall find an inequality which is necessarily fulfilled by the quantized radiation in any physically allowed state ( be it a coherent , multi - photon , squeezed , thermal or any other state ) . we quantize the radiation field in the coulomb gauge : @xmath32 finding the standard expression for the potentials : @xmath33 where @xmath34 and @xmath35 denote the two real valued polarization vectors ( labeled by @xmath36 ) which are normalized and orthogonal to @xmath37 .
the electric field operator is found by means of @xmath38 the point - splitting ( normal - ordered ) operator of the squared electric field is @xmath39 where @xmath40 denote the 3d scalar product of the two polarization vectors . ] . in order to obtain the observable @xmath41 we integrate the above expression with @xmath30 , while using the following convention for the fourier transform : @xmath42 we obtain @xmath43 in order to find a state - independent inequality for the expectation value of @xmath41 we proceed analogously to the scalar - field case ( inequality ) presented in the appendix [ estimate ] . here , in the case of electromagnetic ( vector ) field
a slight modification is necessary in order to take care of the polarization vectors @xmath44 .
we define vector operators @xmath45 : @xmath46 and we investigate the positive operator : @xmath47 in the calculation , completely analogous to that presented in the appendix [ estimate ] for a scalar - field case , the commutation relations : @xmath48=\de(\v p-\v k ) \de_{\a\be},\ ] ] lead to a factor @xmath49 which is the essence of the inequality we were searching for . here , the factor @xmath50 is the only remainder of the polarization vectors .
we obtain an identity ( an analogue of ): @xmath51 by means of comparison with we find : @xmath52 the positivity of the operator leads , after taking an expectation value in some ( arbitrary ) state of the field @xmath4 , to the following inequality : @xmath53
the main result of this paper , the inequality , tells us that the vacuum fluctuations can be reduced only in a limited way .
the function @xmath30 on the one hand specifies the time interval in which fluctuations are recorded and on the other hand limits the amount of the reduction of the vacuum fluctuations one will be allowed to record . in the following we will investigate the practical consequences of the established inequality .
although the inequality gives an absolute value , in the units of energy , of the maximal reduction of the vacuum fluctuations , it is of little importance since it gives a finite number , the reduction , which is cut from an infinite reservoir ( because the vacuum fluctuations are infinite ) .
what seems to have a far deeper practical consequence is another quantity , namely , the reduction of the fluctuations restricted to certain frequencies .
all available detectors of the radiation , be it single atoms , photodiodes or any other device , are always sensitive only to certain frequencies of the radiation .
let @xmath54 denote a smooth sensitivity function of rapid decay ( in short @xmath55 ) .
if we exchange the measure @xmath56 in order to take into account this physical restriction , then even the vacuum fluctuations become finite : @xmath57 the inequality is also modified by means of the additional factor @xmath58 appearing on its right - hand side . of prime interest
is the logarithmic reduction of the fluctuations defined as the base-10 logarithm of the field fluctuations in the considered state @xmath4 divided by the vacuum - fluctuations ( the reduction in [ db ] ) : @xmath59 where in the presence of the sensitivity function @xmath55 @xmath60 makes sense with both quantities on the right hand side finite .
we shall compute this quantity for certain model time - probe functions @xmath30 .
the probe function @xmath30 was until now arbitrary .
nevertheless , it will be instructive to consider some examples which shed additional light on the meaning of the proven inequality .
let us consider the following function : @xmath61 the function is even , normalized as the probability density and has its maximum at the zero @xmath62 .
its half - width is connected linearly with @xmath16 c.a .
the second power of the fourier transform of the square root of @xmath30 is easily found to be @xmath64 we are now in a position to apply the proven inequality . according to we find @xmath65 the above result , when compared with the vacuum fluctuations @xmath66 , shows the merit of the fluctuation - inequality , namely although the minimal fluctuations at an instant of time the sensitivity function becomes the delta distribution @xmath67 . ]
are simply zero ( compare with ) , @xmath68 such a reduction ( according to ) can not last for a finite period of time .
the longer the probe time becomes ( bigger @xmath16 ) the bigger the square of the field @xmath69 have to be expected for all states of the electromagnetic field .
there is a certain objection which can be made against the probe function we used in the above considerations , namely , an experimentator would expect to be able to produce huge reductions of fluctuations for only relatively short periods of time only after which he would expect a period of greatly increased @xmath70 .
thus , he would not be satisfied with the fact that the probe function decays only with the inverse fourth power of the time and would rather seek a more rapidly decaying function so that the increased fluctuations do not influence the reduced ones .
indeed , we regard the point made above as a fair challenge and thus consider another probe function , namely the gaussian function @xmath71 which certainly possesses much better time - decay properties .
noting that @xmath72 we find @xmath73 now , due to @xmath74 which holds for all @xmath75 ( and the equality is approximate in the limit @xmath76 ) the same remarks as in the case of previously investigated time - probe function @xmath30 namely @xmath68 can be expressed , so that the total suppression of @xmath70 is possible only in the limit for arbitrary time - probe functions .
indeed this would be equivalent to giving a meaning to the square root of the delta distribution which however we fear of .
] @xmath76 . in the following investigations
we shall try to relate the inequality to the measured degree of squeezing in quantum - optical experiments .
suppose a beam of squeezed light is shed upon a balanced homodyne detector@xcite ( bhd ) .
putting away for a moment the theoretical description of the squeezed states in terms of the creation / annihilation operators we present an experimentally motivated argument which allows for an application of the inequality .
firstly it appears possible to phase match the squeezed light to the local oscillator field and to manipulate the relative phase @xmath17 in a controlled way@xcite .
as the phase @xmath17 is typically manipulated by means of moving back and forth a piezo - mounted mirror it appears plausible that @xmath17 should be regarded as a time - delay would move ( delay ) the pulse back and forth in time further strengthening our interpretation . ] . as a byproduct
we note that if a certain aparatus ( e.g. bhd ) were to measure the field operator restricted to a sharp frequency @xmath77 then the transformation @xmath78 would exchange the meaning of the so - called field quadratures : @xmath79 from now on we shall therefore regard @xmath17 as a time - delay .
secondly the squeezed states exhibit a typical @xmath17-dependence of the field s fluctuations ( see figure [ plot ] or e.g. @xcite ) . in accordance with the above interpretation
, @xmath80 corresponds to a measurement of the field ( and its variation - its square ) at a certain instant of time @xmath81 , whereas @xmath82 corresponds to a measurement at a later time @xmath83 , where @xmath84 is the period of the local oscillator .
if the variations of the measurement at @xmath80 are small and those at @xmath82 are huge , as on the figure , we are inclined to believe the periods of huge fluctuations come directly ( @xmath85 ) after those of small fluctuations .
furthermore all possible evidence ( e.g. @xcite ) supports the fact , that the squeezed state consists of a superposition of pairs of photons .
thus , whatever the fock - state representation of the squeezed state @xmath4 is , it only contains vectors with even photon number .
consequently , @xmath86 as the field operator @xmath28 contains only one creation and one annihilation operator so that the above relation follows from the commutation relations .
we therefore see that field s fluctuations ( variation of the field measurement ) are directly related to the expectation value of the square of the field .
given experimental precision in the control of the phase we can safely assume that the most intense squeezing lasts for @xmath87 . experimentally reported continuous squeezing for much longer periods @xcite although seemingly contradictory the above statement uses the fact the bhd reacts only in correct moments , selected by the local oscillator and therefore is sensitive only to certain sub - intervals within each period preferably to those of maximum squeezing .
the above interpretation allows finally for an application of the inequality . choosing the characteristic time interval @xmath88 and frequency range @xmath55 ( see footnote in appendix [ example ] ) of interest we can estimate the maximum possible reduction of the vacuum fluctuations . here
the concern about the fast - decrease property of the probe function becomes visible as the intervals of anti - squeezing come immediately after the intervals of squeezing .
nonetheless , the application of the inequality reveals ( see appendix [ example ] ) in the case of gaussian probe - function the best possible squeezing lasting for @xmath87 : @xmath89 the above result might have a direct impact on experiments in the near future limiting further progress in the creation of strongly - squeezed states .
it is however important to stress that the limit binds the maximal reduction to the length of the time interval of its appearance .
there is no reason not to be able to squeeze up to @xmath90 if only the phase @xmath17 could be controlled with @xmath91 precision . in short :
the deduction of the above nontrivial limitation contains three ingredients : 1 . the fluctuation inequality , 2 .
the assumption that the squeezed state contains pairs of photons and thus @xmath92 , 3 .
the interpretation that @xmath17 has a meaning of time delay so that periods of squeezed field come directly after periods of anti - squeezed field .
the first ingredient should , in the light of presented calculations , be regarded as a mathematically certainty ; its validity is as certain as the description of light in terms of quantized field .
the second ingredient appears physically certain as it is supported by overwhelming physical evidence .
the third ingredient is supported by the above arguments . in our opinion
it gives a correct interpretation of the so - called field quadratures .
let us again stress that the third ingredient specifies very short times for which the field is probed ( i.e. @xmath16 ) .
even if our interpretation of @xmath17 appears odd it is important to understand that there is little freedom left ; namely in light of the fluctuation inequality it is impossible to claim that @xmath70 was kept at say @xmath93 even for one period @xmath84 ( the maximum allowed degree of squeezing for @xmath94 is @xmath95 ) so that it would be contradictory to claim that the experimentally reported squeezing lasted longer than a fraction of @xmath84 .
a number of important issues have been left to the present section : * it should be firmly stressed that the presented inequality has hardly anything in common with the standard inequality @xmath96 typically present in the discussion of squeezed states , where @xmath97 denotes one field quadrature , say squeezed , while @xmath98 the other , anti - squeezed . indeed , if a definite time interval is considered ( say , @xmath16 ) then the above inequality does not prohibit an arbitrarily small fluctuations @xmath99 in that interval with the consequence that the fluctuations @xmath100 in the meantime explode .
on the other hand , the presented inequality prohibits exactly that . a rough statement
would be that in the light of the presented inequality @xmath99 alone is restricted from below .
* the presented inequality possesses a clear spatio - temporal interpretation . if there were any hopes to use squeezed light in order to inhibit atomic phase decays and make some relaxation times arbitrarily long @xcite they must be seriously reduced in light of the presented inequality . *
the most important question , whether squeezed states exhibit periods of negative energy densities remains to be answered . as the energy - density of the electro - magnetic field contains a square of the magnetic field : @xmath101 the question arises whether magnetic field fluctuations are also suppressed and whether the periods of their suppression coincide with periods of squeezing . as magnetic field fluctuations are not typically recorded in experiments we endeavor to infer the answer theoretically .
assume the squeezed field is linearly polarized as is the case in some experiments @xcite .
furthermore assume that the wavepackets of photons constituting the pair are compactly localized along certain momentum - vector @xmath102 and propagate in one direction only ( see figure [ supp ] ) .
the only difference between @xmath20 and @xmath103 is that instead of @xmath104 there appears a factor @xmath105 [ \v p \times \v e(\v p)]$ ] .
+ + if the expectation value of the normal ordered @xmath103 is calculated then the above factor is integrated with the wavepackets .
it is therefore allowed to restrict the @xmath106 and @xmath107 integration to the support of the wavepackets from the very beginning .
then each of the vectors may be decomposed orthogonally into @xmath108 and @xmath109 so that @xmath102 is parallel to @xmath110 .
the assumption on the support of the wavepackets tells us that @xmath111 is much greater than @xmath112 .
a calculation shows that @xmath113 [ \v p \times \v e(\v p)]=\w_k\w_p\ [ \v e(\v k ) \v e(\v p)+ o(\w^{-2})],\ ] ] so that the expectation value of @xmath20 is approximately equal to that of @xmath103 .
+ as we have argued the periods of squeezing should coincide with the periods of negative energy density .
however , squeezing is typically observed with restriction to a sharp frequency .
only recently @xcite the so - called broadband detection of squeezed light was performed .
although the squeezing at many different frequencies was indeed observed it is not clear to us whether there existed periods where squeezing occurred in all frequencies simultaneously which would be necessary in order to infer that the negative energy densities were indeed created experimentally .
if it were so , the squeezed states would provide the first known experimental example of locally negative energy densities .
it is a pleasure to thank k. fredenhagen for his encouraging remarks as well as graduiertenkolleg `` zuknftige entwicklungen in der teilchenphysik '' for financial support .
in the present appendix we outline a standard method associated with the derivation of quantum inequalities .
we consider the scalar - field case in which the derivation already contains all essential features .
let us give an outline of this derivation .
we shall consider the operator @xmath114 which corresponds to the time weighted normal ordered square of the electric field ( i.e. to the observable @xmath115 see equation and ) .
it will be shown that @xmath116 where the functional on the rhs is finite if the time - probe function is fast decreasing .
the proof consists of finding an appropriate operator @xmath117 , where @xmath77 is real number ( the operator also depends on @xmath118 and @xmath119 ) such that @xmath120 where the residue term is precisely the functional described above .
although @xmath114 will prove to be just the normal ordering of @xmath121 it should perhaps be stressed that the derivation has nothing to do with normal ordering of the square of the field operators @xmath122 in which case the residue term would prove to be infinite and the inequality would be trivial i.e. formally @xmath123 .
we now proceed with the scalar field derivation .
the operator @xmath114 corresponding to is defined as : @xmath124 and will be shown to fulfill the inequality : @xmath125 in any state @xmath126 of the quantum field .
we prove this by finding an operator @xmath117 such that @xmath127 obviously the inequality follows since @xmath128 is a positive operator .
define @xmath129 where @xmath130 is a positive square root of @xmath131 i.e. its fourier transform fulfills @xmath132 then is investigated : @xmath133 let us refer to the components above as @xmath134 .
in the second ( @xmath135 ) term we use the commutation relations and obtain @xmath136 now the first part of the above operator ( denoted by @xmath137 ) , together with the first term ( @xmath138 ) will be investigated . in @xmath137
we exchange the variables @xmath139 , make a further change @xmath140 and use the relation @xmath141 . as a result we obtain @xmath142 the integration in @xmath77 may be recognized as a convolution so that @xmath143 after a similar treatment the terms @xmath144 and @xmath145 are transformed in one of the parts , which after subsequent exchange @xmath139 allows to stretch the @xmath77 integration to the whole @xmath146 . ] into @xmath147 altogether we have @xmath148 the desired inequality now follows easily by taking the expectation value .
it should perhaps be firmly stressed that this inequality is universal in that it must be respected by all states @xmath4 of the quantum field . as a corollary we note that the sign in front of the @xmath149 term may be changed : @xmath150 and still the same inequality would be obtained if only the operator @xmath151 is utilized instead of @xmath117 .
here we shall briefly indicate what sort of limitations on the degree of squeezing are to be expected .
we take the gaussian probe function and assume a sharp frequency cut so that the function @xmath152 is sharply centered around certain fixed frequency of the sensitivity function @xmath55 .
the bandwidth of the bhd output measurement defines the shape of @xmath55 . in the following the bandwidth
is assumed to be negligibly small with respect to @xmath153 .
this assumption allows us to derive explicit result and but is by no means necessary . ]
. then the maximum reduction of fluctuations is given by .
together with the vacuum fluctuations the following maximum degree of squeezing results : @xmath154,\ ] ] where @xmath155 . introducing the error function @xmath156 we find @xmath157,\ ] ] which is the maximum reduction of fluctuations allowed by the inequality .
if , as in typical experiments with squeezed light , the period of maximum squeezing were to last for @xmath0 of the period @xmath84 ( i.e. @xmath158 ) , the squeezing can not exceed @xmath159 if on the other hand someone would insist the squeezing lasted longer - say the whole period @xmath84 or even more , it would be bounded by @xmath160 k.s .
zhang , t. coudreau , m. martinelli , a. maitre , and c. fabre .
generation of bright squeezed light at 1.06 @xmath162 using cascaded non - linearities in a triply resonant c.w .
ppln opo . ,
a64:033815 , 2001 . | we establish a connection between quantum inequalities , known from quantum field theory on curved spacetimes , and the degree of squeezing in quantum - optical experiments .
we prove an inequality which binds the reduction of the electric - field fluctuations to their duration . the bigger the level of fluctuation - suppression the shorter its duration .
as an example of an application of this inequality is the case of squeezed light whose phase is controlled with @xmath0 accuracy for which we derive a limit of @xmath1 on the allowed degree of squeezing . |
modern cosmology is one of the most exciting areas in physical science .
decades of surveying the sky have culminated in a cross - validated , `` cosmological standard model '' . yet ,
key pillars of the model dark matter and dark energy together accounting for 95% of the universe s mass - energy remain mysterious @xcite .
deep fundamental questions demand answers : what is the dark matter
? why is the universe s expansion accelerating ? what is the nature of primordial fluctuations ? should general relativity be modified ? to address these questions , ground and space - based observatories operating at multiple wavebands @xcite are aiming to unveil the true nature of the `` dark universe '' . driven by advances in semiconductor technology ,
surveys follow a version of moore s law , in terms of ccd pixels or surveyed galaxies per year . in a major leap forward , current cosmological constraints will soon be improved by an order of magnitude @xcite . as an example
, the large synoptic survey telescope ( lsst ) @xcite can be compared to today s observations from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite : in one night lsst will capture data equivalent to five years of sdss imaging ( fig .
[ dls ] ) !
interpreting future observations will be impossible without a modeling and simulation effort as revolutionary as the new surveys : the desired size and performance improvements for simulations over the next decade are measured in orders of magnitude @xcite . because the simulations to be run are memory - limited on even the largest machines available and a large number of them are necessary , very stringent requirements are simultaneously imposed on code performance and efficiency .
we show below how hacc meets these exacting conditions by attaining unprecedented sustained levels of performance , reaching up to @xmath0 of peak on certain bg / q partition sizes .
cosmic structure formation is described by the gravitational vlasov - poisson equation in an expanding universe @xcite , a 6-d pde for the liouville flow ( [ le ] ) of the phase space pdf where self - consistency is imposed by the poisson equation ( [ pe ] ) : @xmath1 the expansion of the universe is encoded in the time - dependence of the scale factor @xmath2 governed by the cosmological model , the hubble parameter , @xmath3 , @xmath4 is newton s constant , @xmath5 is the critical density , @xmath6 , the average mass density as a fraction of @xmath5 , @xmath7 is the local mass density , and @xmath8 is the dimensionless density contrast , @xmath9 the vlasov - poisson equation is very difficult to solve directly because of its high dimensionality and the development of structure including complex multistreaming on ever finer scales , driven by the gravitational jeans instability .
consequently , n - body methods , using tracer particles to sample @xmath10 are used ; the particles follow newton s equations in an expanding universe , with the forces given by the gradient of the scalar potential as computed from eq .
( [ pe ] ) @xcite . under the jeans instability ,
initial perturbations given by a smooth gaussian random field evolve into a ` cosmic web ' comprising of sheets , filaments , and local mass concentrations called halos @xcite .
the first stars and galaxies form in halos and then evolve as the halo distribution also evolves by a combination of dynamics , mass accretion and loss , and by halo mergers . to capture this complex behavior , cosmological n - body simulations
have been developed and refined over the last three decades @xcite .
in addition to gravity , gasdynamic , thermal , radiative , and other processes must also modeled , e.g. , sub - grid modeling of star formation .
large - volume simulations usually incorporate the latter effects via semi - analytic modeling . to understand the essential nature of the challenge posed by future surveys , a few elementary arguments suffice .
survey depths are of order a few gpc ( 1 @xmath11 light - years ) ; to follow typical galaxies , halos with a minimum mass of @xmath12@xmath13 m@xmath14 ( @xmath15 solar mass ) must be tracked . to properly resolve these halos ,
the tracer particle mass should be @xmath12@xmath16 m@xmath14 and the force resolution should be small compared to the halo size , i.e. , @xmath12kpc .
this last argument immediately implies a dynamic range ( ratio of smallest resolved scale to box size ) of a part in @xmath17 ( @xmath12gpc / kpc ) everywhere in the _ entire _ simulation volume ( fig .
[ zoom ] ) .
the mass resolution can be specified as the ratio of the mass of the smallest resolved halo to that of the most massive , which is @xmath12@xmath18 . in terms of the number of simulation particles ,
this yields counts in the range of hundreds of billions to trillions .
time - stepping criteria follow from a joint consideration of the force and mass resolution @xcite .
finally , stringent requirements on accuracy are imposed by the very small statistical errors in the observations
certain quantities such as lensing shear power spectra must be computed at accuracies of a _ fraction _ of a percent @xcite . for a cosmological simulation to be considered `` high - resolution '' , _ all _ of the above demands
must be met .
in addition , throughput is a significant concern .
scientific inference from sets of cosmological observations is a statistical inverse problem where many runs of the forward problem are needed to obtain estimates of cosmological parameters via markov chain monte carlo methods .
for many analyses , hundreds of large - scale , state of the art simulations will be required @xcite .
the structure of the hacc framework is based on the realization that it must not only meet the challenges of spatial dynamic range , mass resolution , accuracy , and throughput , but also overcome a final hurdle , i.e. , be fully cognizant of coming disruptive changes in computational architectures . as a validation of its design philosophy ,
hacc was among the pioneering applications proven on the heterogeneous architecture of roadrunner @xcite , the first supercomputer to break the petaflop barrier .
hacc s multi - algorithmic structure also attacks several weaknesses of conventional particle codes including limited vectorization , indirection , complex data structures , lack of threading , and short interaction lists .
it combines mpi with a variety of local programming models ( opencl , openmp ) to readily adapt to different platforms .
currently , hacc is implemented on conventional and cell / gpu - accelerated clusters , on the blue gene architecture , and is running on prototype intel mic hardware .
hacc is the first , and currently the only large - scale cosmology code suite world - wide , that can run at scale ( and beyond ) on _ all _ available supercomputer architectures . to showcase this flexibility , we present scaling results for two systems aside from the bg / q in section [ sec : results ]
; on the entire anl bg / p system and over all of roadrunner .
recent hacc science results on roadrunner include a suite of 64 billion particle runs for baryon acoustic oscillations predictions for boss ( baryon oscillation spectroscopic survey ) @xcite and a high - statistics study of galaxy cluster halo profiles @xcite .
hacc s performance and flexibility are not dependent on vendor - supplied or other high - performance libraries or linear algebra packages ; the 3-d parallel fft implementation in hacc couples high performance with a small memory footprint as compared to available libraries .
unlike some other high - performance n - body codes , hacc does not use any special hardware .
the implementation for the bg / q architecture has far more generally applicable features than ( the hacc or other ) cpu / gpu short - range force implementations .
the cosmological n - body problem is typically treated by a mix of grid and particle - based techniques .
the hacc design accepts that , as a general rule , particle and grid methods both have their limitations . for physics and algorithmic reasons ,
grid - based techniques are better suited to larger ( ` smooth ' ) lengthscales , with particle methods having the opposite property .
this suggests that higher levels of code organization should be grid - based , interacting with particle information at a lower level of the computational hierarchy . following this central idea
, hacc uses a hybrid parallel algorithmic structure , splitting the gravitational force calculation into a specially designed grid - based long / medium range spectral particle - mesh ( pm ) component that is common to all architectures , and an architecture - tunable particle - based short / close - range solver ( fig . [ haccforce ] ) .
the grid is responsible for 4 orders of magnitude of dynamic range , while the particle methods handle the critical 2 orders of magnitude at the shortest scales where particle clustering is maximal and the bulk of the time - stepping computation takes place .
the computational complexity of the pm algorithm @xcite is @xmath19+@xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the total number of particles , and @xmath22 the total number of grid points .
the short - range tree algorithms @xcite in hacc can be implemented in ways that are either @xmath23 or @xmath24 , where @xmath25 is the number of particles in individual spatial domains ( @xmath26 ) , while the close - range force computations are @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the number of particles in a tree leaf node within which all direct interactions are summed .
@xmath28 values can range from @xmath29 in a ` fat leaf ' tree , to as large as @xmath30 in the case of a cpu / gpu implementation ( no mediating tree ) .
hacc uses mixed precision computation
double precision is used for the spectral component of the code , whereas single precision is adequate for the short / close - range particle force evaluations and particle time - stepping .
hacc s long / medium range algorithm is based on a fast , spectrally filtered pm method .
the density field is generated from the particles using a cloud - in - cell ( cic ) scheme @xcite , but is then smoothed with the ( isotropizing ) spectral filter @xmath31^{n_s } , \label{filter}\ ] ] with the nominal choices @xmath32 , @xmath33 .
this reduces the anisotropy `` noise '' of the cic scheme by over an order of magnitude without requiring complex and inflexible higher - order spatial particle deposition methods .
the noise reduction allows matching the short and longer - range forces at a spacing of 3 grid cells , with important ramifications for performance .
the poisson solver uses a sixth - order , periodic , influence function ( spectral representation of the inverse laplacian ) @xcite .
the gradient of the scalar potential is obtained using higher - order spectral differencing ( fourth - order super - lanczos @xcite ) .
the `` poisson - solve '' in hacc is the composition of all the kernels above in one single fourier transform ; each component of the potential field gradient then requires an independent fft .
hacc uses its own scalable , high performance 3-d fft routine implemented using a 2-d pencil decomposition ( details are given in section [ sec : results ] . ) to obtain the short - range force , the filtered grid force is subtracted from the exact newtonian force .
the filtered grid force was obtained numerically to high accuracy using randomly sampled particle pairs and then fitted to an expression with the correct large and small distance asymptotics . because this functional form is needed only over a small , compact region , it can be simplified using a fifth - order polynomial expansion to speed up computations in the main force kernel ( section [ sec : bg ] ) .
hacc s spatial domain decomposition is in regular ( non - cubic ) 3-d blocks , but unlike the guard zones of a typical pm method , full particle replication
termed ` particle overloading ' is employed across domain boundaries ( fig
. [ overload ] ) .
the typical memory overhead cost for a large run is @xmath34 .
the point of overloading is to allow essentially exact medium / long - range force calculations with no communication of particle information and high - accuracy local force calculations with relatively sparse refreshes of the overloading zone ( for details , see ref .
the second advantage of overloading is that it frees the local force solver from handling communication tasks , which are taken care of by the long / medium - range force framework .
thus new ` on - node ' local methods can be plugged in with guaranteed scalability and only local optimizations are necessary .
note that all short - range methods in hacc are local to the mpi - rank and the locality can be fine - grained further .
this locality has the key advantage of lowering the number of levels in tree algorithms and being able to parallelize across fine - grained particle interaction sub - volumes .
the time - stepping in hacc is based on a 2nd - order split - operator symplectic scheme that sub - cycles the short / close - range evolution within long / medium - range ` kick ' maps where particle positions do not change but the velocities are updated .
the relatively slowly evolving longer range force is effectively frozen during the shorter - range time steps , which are a symmetric ` sks ' composition of stream ( position update , velocity fixed ) and kick maps for the short / close - range forces @xcite : @xmath35 the number of sub - cycles can vary , depending on the force and mass resolution of the simulation , from @xmath36 . the long / medium - range solver remains unchanged across all architectures .
the short / close - range solvers are chosen and optimized depending on the target architecture .
these solvers can use direct particle - particle interactions , i.e. , a p@xmath37 m algorithm @xcite , as on roadrunner , or use both tree and particle - particle methods as on the ibm bg / p and bg / q ( ` pptreepm ' ) .
the availability of multiple algorithms within the hacc framework allows us to carry out careful error analyses , for example , the p@xmath37 m and the pptreepm versions agree to within @xmath38 for the nonlinear power spectrum test in the code comparison suite of ref .
@xcite . for heterogeneous systems such as roadrunner , or in the near future , titan at olcf
, the long / medium - range spectral solver operates at the cpu layer . depending on the memory balance between the cpu and the accelerator , we can choose to specify two different modes , 1 ) grids held on the cpu and particles on the accelerator , or 2 ) a streaming paradigm with grid and particle information primarily resident in cpu memory with computations streamed through the accelerator . in both cases , the local force solve is a direct particle - particle interaction , i.e. , the whole is a p@xmath37 m code with hardware acceleration . for a many - core system ,
the top layer of the code remains the same , but the short - range solver changes to a tree - based algorithm which is much better suited to the blue gene and mic architectures
. we will provide an in - depth description of our blue gene / q - specific implementation in section [ sec : bg ] .
to summarize , the hacc framework integrates multiple algorithms and optimizes them across architectures ; it has several interesting performance - enhancing features , e.g. , overloading , spectral filtering and differentiation , mixed precision , and compact local trees .
hacc attacks the weaknesses of conventional particle codes in ways made fully explicit in the next section lack of vectorization , indirection , complex data structures , lack of threading , and short interaction lists .
finally , weak scaling is a function only of the spectral solver ; hacc s 2-d domain decomposed fft guarantees excellent performance and scaling properties ( see section [ sec : results ] ) .
the bg / q is the third generation of the ibm blue gene line of supercomputers targeted primarily at large - scale scientific applications , continuing the tradition of optimizing for price performance , scalability , power efficiency , and system reliability @xcite .
the new bg / q compute chip ( bqc ) is a system - on - chip ( soc ) design combining cpus , caches , network , and messaging unit on a single chip @xcite .
a single bg / q rack contains 1024 bg / q nodes like its predecessors .
each node contains the bqc and 16 gb of ddr3 memory .
each bqc uses 17 augmented 64-bit powerpc a2 cores with specific enhancements for the bg / q : 1 ) 4 hardware threads and a simd quad floating point unit ( quad processor extension , qpx ) , 2 ) a sophisticated l1 prefetching unit ( l1p ) with both stream and list prefetching , 3 ) a wake - up unit to reduce certain thread - to - thread interactions , and 4 ) transactional memory and speculative execution . of the 17 bqc cores , 16 are for user applications and one for handling os interrupts and other system services .
each core has access to a private 16 kb l1 data cache and a shared 32 mb multi - versioned l2 cache connected by a crossbar .
the a2 core runs at 1.6 ghz and the qpx allows for 4 fmas per cycle , translating to a peak performance per core of 12.8 gflops , or 204.8 gflops for the bqc chip .
the bg / q network has a 5-d torus topology ; each compute node has 10 communication links with a peak total bandwidth of 40 gb / s @xcite .
the internal bqc interconnect has a bisection bandwidth of 563 gb / s . in order to evaluate the short - range force on non - accelerated systems , such as the bg / q ,
hacc uses a recursive coordinate bisection ( rcb ) tree in conjunction with a highly - tuned short - range polynomial force kernel . the implementation of the rcb tree , although not the force evaluation scheme , generally follows the discussion in ref .
two core principles underlie the high performance of the rcb tree s design .
_ spatial locality . _
the rcb tree is built by recursively dividing particles into two groups .
the dividing line is placed at the center of mass coordinate perpendicular to the longest side of the box . once this line is chosen , the particles are partitioned such that particles in each group occupy disjoint memory buffers .
local forces are then computed one leaf node at a time .
the net result is that the particle data exhibits a high degree of spatial locality after the tree build ; because the computation of the short - range force on the particles in any given leaf node , by construction , deals with particles only in nearby leaf nodes , the cache miss rate during the force computation is extremely low . _
walk minimization .
_ in a traditional tree code , an interaction list is built and evaluated for each particle . while the interaction list size scales only logarithmically with the total number of particles ( hence the overall @xmath39 complexity ) ,
the tree walk necessary to build the interaction list is a relatively slow operation .
this is because it involves the evaluation of complex conditional statements and requires `` pointer chasing '' operations .
a direct @xmath40 force calculation scales poorly as @xmath41 grows , but for a small number of particles , a thoughtfully - constructed kernel can still finish the computation in a small number of cycles .
the rcb tree exploits our highly - tuned short - range force kernels to decrease the overall force evaluation time by shifting workload away from the slow tree - walking and into the force kernel .
up to a point , doing this actually speeds up the overall calculation : the time spent in the force kernel goes up but the walk time decreases faster .
obviously , at some point this breaks down , but on many systems , tens or hundreds of particles can be in each leaf node before the crossover is reached .
we point out that the force kernel is generally more efficient as the size of the interaction list grows : the relative loop overhead is smaller , and more of the computation can be done using unrolled vectorized code .
in addition to the performance benefits of grouping multiple particles in each leaf node , doing so also increases the accuracy of the resulting force calculation : the local force is dominated by nearby particles , and as more particles are retained in each leaf node , more of the force from those nearby particles is calculated exactly . in highly - clustered regions ( with very many nearby particles ) ,
the accuracy can increase by several orders of magnitude when keeping over 100 particles per leaf node .
another important consideration is the tree - node partitioning step , which is the most expensive part of the tree build .
the particle data is stored as a collection of arrays the so - called structure - of - arrays ( soa ) format .
there are three arrays for the three spatial coordinates , three for the velocity components , in addition to arrays for mass , a particle identifier , etc .
our implementation in hacc divides the partitioning operation into three phases .
the first phase loops over the coordinate being used to divide the particles , recording which particles will need to be swapped .
next , these prerecorded swapping operations are performed on six of the arrays .
the remaining arrays are identically handled in the third phase .
dividing the work in this way allows the hardware prefetcher to effectively hide the memory transfer latency during the particle partitioning operation and reduces expensive read - after - write dependencies .
we now turn to the evaluation of the bg / q - specific short - range force kernel , where the code spends the bulk of its computation time .
due to the compactness of the short - range interaction ( cf .
section [ sec : hacc ] ) , the kernel can be represented as @xmath42 where @xmath43 , @xmath44(s)$ ] , and @xmath45 is a short - distance cutoff .
this computation must be vectorized to attain high performance ; we do this by computing the force for every neighbor of each particle at once .
the list of neighbors is generated such that each coordinate and the mass of each neighboring particle is pre - generated into a contiguous array .
this guarantees that 1 ) every particle has an independent list of particles and can be processed within a separate thread ; and 2 ) every neighbor list can be accessed with vector memory operations , because contiguity and alignment restrictions are taken care of in advance .
every particle on a leaf node shares the interaction list , therefore all particles have lists of the same size , and the computational threads are automatically balanced . the filtering of @xmath46 , i.e. , checking the short - range condition , can be processed during the generation of the neighbor list or during the force evaluation itself ; since the condition is likely violated only in a number of `` corner '' cases , it is advantageous to include it into the force evaluation in a form where ternary operators can be combined to remove the need of storing a value during the force computation .
each ternary operator can be implemented with the help of the instruction , which also has a vector equivalent .
even though these alterations introduce an ( insignificant ) increase in instruction count , the entire force evaluation routine becomes fully vectorizable . on the bg / q ,
the instruction latency is 6 cycles for most floating - point instructions ; latency is hidden from instruction dependencies by a combination of placing the dependent instructions as far as 6 instructions away by using 2-fold loop unrolling and running 4 threads per core .
register pressure for the 32 vector floating - point registers is the most important design constraint on the kernel .
half of these registers hold values common to all iterations , 6 of which store the coefficients of the polynomial .
the remaining registers hold iteration - specific values .
because of the 2-fold unrolling , this means that we are restricted to 8 of these registers per iteration . evaluating the force in eq .
( [ force ] ) requires a reciprocal square root estimate and evaluating a fifth - order polynomial , but these require only 5 and 2 iteration - specific registers respectively .
the most register - intensive phase of the kernel loop is actually the calculation of @xmath46 , requiring 3 registers for the particle coordinates , 3 registers for the components of @xmath47 , and one register for accumulating the value of @xmath46 .
there is significant flexibility in choosing the number of mpi ranks versus the number of threads on an individual bg / q node . because of the excellent performance of the memory sub - system and the low overhead of context switching ( due to use of the bqc wake - up unit ) , a large number of openmp threads
significantly larger than is considered typical can be run to optimize performance .
figure [ threads ] shows how increasing the number of threads per core increases the performance of the force kernel as a function of the size of the particle neighbor list .
the best performance is attained when running the maximum number of threads ( 4 ) per core , and at large neighbor list size . the optimum value for the current hacc runs turns out to be 16/4 as it allows for short tree walks , efficient fft computation , and a large fraction of time devoted to the force kernel . the numbers in fig .
[ threads ] show that for runs with different parameters , such as high particle loading , the broad performance plateau allows us to use smaller or higher rpn / thread ratios as appropriate .
the neighbor list sizes in representative simulations are of order 500 - 2500 . at the lower end of this neighbor list size
, performance can be further improved using assembly - level programming , if desired . at the chosen 16/4 operating point
, the code spends 80% of the time in the highly optimized force kernel , 10% in the tree walk , and 5% in the fft , all other operations ( tree build , cic deposit ) adding up to another 5% .
note that the actual fraction of peak performance attained in the force kernel is close to 80% as against a theoretical maximum value of 81% .
the 26 instructions in the kernel correspond to a maximum of 208 flops if they were all fmas , whereas in the actual implementation , 16 of them are fmas yielding a total flop count of @xmath48 implying a theoretical maximum value of @xmath49 or 81% of peak .
the high efficiency is due to successful use of the stream prefetch ; we have measured the latency of the l2 cache to be approximately 45 clock cycles , thus even a single miss per iteration would be enough to significantly degrade the kernel performance .
we present performance data for three cases : 1 ) weak scaling of the poisson solver up to 131,072 ranks on different architectures for illustrative purposes ; 2 ) weak scaling at @xmath50 parallel efficiency for the full code on the bg / q with up to 1,572,864 cores ( 96 racks ) ; and 3 ) strong scaling of the full code on the bg / q up to 16,384 cores with a fixed - size realistic problem to explore future systems with lower memory per core .
all the timing data were taken over many tens of sub - steps , each individual run taking between 4 - 5 hours . to summarize our findings ,
both the long / medium range solver and the full code exhibit perfect weak scaling out to the largest system we have had access to so far ; we achieved a performance of 13.94 pflops on 96 racks , at around 67 - 69% of peak in most cases ( up to 69.75% ) . the full code demonstrates strong scaling up to one rack on a problem with 1024@xmath37 particles .
finally , the biggest test run evolved more than 3.6 trillion particles ( 15,360@xmath37 ) , exceeding by more than an order of magnitude , the largest high - resolution cosmology run performed to date . as discussed in section [ science ] , the results of runs at this scale can be used for many scientific investigations . .fft scaling on up to 10240@xmath37 grid points on the bg / q [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the evolution of many - core based architectures is strongly biased towards a large number of ( possibly heterogeneous ) cores per compute node .
it is likely that the ( memory ) byte / flop ratio could easily evolve to being worse by a factor of 10 than it is for the bg / q , and this continuing trend will be a defining characteristic of exascale systems . for these future - looking reasons the arrival of the strong - scaling barrier for large - scale codes and for optimizing wall - clock for fixed problem size , it is important to study the robustness of the strong scaling properties of the hacc short / close - range algorithms
. we designed the test with a @xmath51 particle problem running on one rack from 512 to 16384 cores , spanning a per node memory utilization factor of approximately 57% , a typical production run value , to as low as 7% .
the actual memory utilization factor scales by a factor of 8 , instead of 32 , because on 16384 nodes we are running a ( severely ) unrealistically small simulation volume per rank with high particle overloading memory and compute cost . despite this ` abuse ' of the hacc algorithms , which are designed to run at @xmath52 of per node memory utilization to about a factor of 4 less ( @xmath53 ) , the strong scaling performance , as depicted in fig .
7 ( associated data in table [ tab : perf3 ] ) is impressive .
the performance stays near - ideal throughout , as does the push - time per particle per step up to 8192 cores , slowing down at 16384 cores , only because of the extra computations in the overloaded regions .
therefore , we expect the basic algorithms to work extremely well in situations where the byte / flop ratio is significantly smaller than that of the current optimum plateau for the bg / q .
dark energy is one of the most pressing puzzles in physics today @xcite .
hacc will be used to investigate the signatures of different dark energy models in the detail needed to analyze upcoming cosmological surveys .
the cosmology community has mostly focused on one cosmological model and a handful of ` hero ' runs to study it @xcite . with hacc
, we aim to systematically study dark energy model space at extreme scales and derive not only qualitative signatures of different dark energy scenarios but deliver quantitative predictions of unprecedented accuracy urgently needed by the next - generation surveys .
the simulations can be used to interpret observations of various kinds , such as weak gravitational lensing measurements to map the distribution of dark matter in the universe , measurements of the distribution of galaxies and clusters , from the largest to the smallest scales , measurements of the growth and distribution of cosmic structure , gravitational lensing of the cosmic microwave background , and many more .
we now show illustrative results from a science test run on 16 racks of mira , the bg / q system now under acceptance testing at the alcf . in this simulation , 10240@xmath37 particles
are evolved in a ( 9.14 gpc)@xmath37 volume box .
this leads to a particle mass , @xmath54 m@xmath14 , allowing us to resolve halos that host , e.g. , luminous red galaxies ( lrgs ) , a main target of the sloan digital sky survey .
the test simulation was started at an initial redshift of @xmath55 ( our actual science runs have @xmath56 ) and evolved until today ( redshift @xmath57 ) .
we stored a slice of the three - dimensional density at the final time ( only a small file system was available during this run ) , as well as a subset of the particles and the mass fluctuation power spectrum at 10 intermediate snapshots .
the total run time of the simulation was approximately 14 hours .
as the evolution proceeds , the particle distribution transitions from essentially uniform to extremely clustered ( see fig . [ evolv ] ) .
the local density contrast @xmath58 can increase by five orders of magnitude during the evolution .
nevertheless , the wall - clock per time step does not change much over the entire simulation .
the large dynamic range of the simulation is demonstrated in fig .
the outer image shows the full simulation volume ( 9.14 gpc on a side ) . in this case , structures are difficult to see because the visualization can not encompass the dynamic range of the simulation . successively zooming into smaller regions , down to a ( 7 mpc)@xmath37 sub - volume holding a large dark matter - dominated halo gives some impression of the enormous amount of information contained in the simulation .
the zoomed - in halo corresponds to a cluster of galaxies in the observed universe . note that in this region the actual ( formal ) force resolution of the simulation is 0.007 mpc , a further factor of 1000 smaller than the sub - volume size !
a full simulation of the type described is extremely science - rich and can be used in a variety of ways to study cosmology as well as to analyze available observations .
below we give two examples of the kind of information that can be gained from large scale structure simulations .
( we note that the test run is more than three times bigger than the largest high - resolution simulation available today . )
clusters are very useful probes of cosmology as the largest gravitationally bound structures in the universe , they form very late and are hence sensitive probes of the late - time acceleration of the universe @xcite .
figure [ cluster ] gives an example of the detailed information available in a simulation , allowing the statistics of halo mergers and halo build - up through sub - halo accretion to be studied with excellent statistics .
in addition , the number of clusters as a function of their mass ( the mass function ) , is a powerful cosmological probe .
simulations provide precision predictions that can be compared to observations .
the new hacc simulations will not only predict the mass function ( as a function of cosmological models ) at unprecedented accuracy , but also the probability of finding very massive clusters in the universe .
large - volume simulations are required to determine the abundance of these very rare objects reliably @xcite .
cosmological information resides in the nature of material structure and also in how structures grow with time . to test whether general relativity correctly describes the dynamics of the universe ,
information related to structure growth ( evolution of clustering ) is essential .
figure [ evolv ] shows how structure evolves in the simulation .
large - volume simulations are essential in producing predictions for statistical quantities such as galaxy correlation functions and the associated power spectra with small statistical errors in order to compare the predictions against observations .
figure [ power ] shows how the power spectrum evolves as a function of time in the science test run . at small wavenumbers ,
the evolution is linear , but at large wavenumbers it is highly nonlinear , and can not be obtained by any method other than direct simulation . to summarize , armed with large - scale simulations we can study and evaluate many cosmological probes .
these probes involve the statistical measurements of the matter distribution at a given epoch ( such as the power spectrum and the mass function ) as well as their evolution .
in addition , the occurrence of rare objects such as very massive clusters can be investigated in the simulations we will carry out with hacc .
these are exciting times for users of the bg / q : in the us , two large systems are undergoing acceptance at livermore ( sequoia , 96 racks ) and at argonne ( mira , 48 racks ) .
as shown here , hacc scales easily to 96 racks .
our next step is to exploit the power of the new systems with the aim of carrying out a suite of full science runs with hundreds of billions to trillions of simulation particles .
because hacc s performance and scalability do not rely on the use of vendor - supplied or other ` black box ' high - performance libraries or linear algebra packages , it retains the key advantage of allowing code optimization to be a continuous process ; we have identified several options to enhance the performance as reported here .
an initial step is to fully thread all the components of the long - range solver , in particular the forward cic algorithm .
next , we will improve ( nodal ) load balancing by using multiple trees at each rank , enabling an improved threading of the tree - build . while the force kernel already runs at very high performance
, we can improve it further with lower - level implementations in assembly .
many of the ideas and methods presented here are relatively general and can be re - purposed to benefit other hpc applications .
in addition , hacc s extreme continuous performance contrasts with the more bursty stressing of the bg / q architecture by linpack ; this feature has allowed hacc to serve as a valuable stress test in the mira and sequoia bring - up process . to summarize ,
we have demonstrated outstanding performance at close to 14 pflops on the bg / q ( 69% of peak ) using more than 1.5 million cores and mpi ranks , at a concurrency level of 6.3 million .
we are now ready to carry out detailed large - volume n - body cosmological simulations at the size scale of trillions of particles .
we are indebted to bob walkup for running hacc on a prototype bg / q system at ibm and to dewey dasher for help in arranging access . at anl
, we thank susan coghlan , paul messina , mike papka , rick stevens , and tim williams for obtaining allocations on different blue gene systems . at llnl , we are grateful to brian carnes , kim cupps , david fox , and michel mccoy for providing access to sequoia .
we thank ray loy and venkat vishwanath for their contributions to system troubleshooting and parallel i / o .
we acknowledge the efforts of the alcf operations team for their assistance in running on mira and the veas bg / q system , in particular , to paul rich , adam scovel , tisha stacey , and william scullin for their tireless efforts to keep mira and veas up and running and helping us carry out the initial long - duration science test runs .
this research used resources of the alcf , which is supported by doe / sc under contract de - ac02 - 06ch11357 .
albrecht , a. , g. bernstein , r. cahn , w.l .
freedman , j. hewitt , w. hu , j. huth , m. kamionkowski , e.w .
kolb , l. knox , j.c .
mather , s. staggs , n.b .
suntzeff , dark energy task force report , arxiv : astro - ph/0609591v1 .
chen , d. , n.a .
eisley , p. heidelberger , r.m .
senger , y. sugawara , s. kumar , v. salapura , d.l .
satterfield , b. steinmacher - burowin , and j.j .
parker , in sc11 , proceedings of the 2011 int .
conf . high performance computing networking storage and analysis ( 2011 ) .
doe ascr and doe hep joint extreme scale computing report ( 2009 )
`` challenges for understanding the quantum universe and the role of computing at the extreme scale '' , http://extremecomputing.labworks.org/highenergyphysics/index.stm haring , r.a . , m. ohmacht , t.w .
fox , m.k .
gschwind , p.a .
boyle , n.h .
christ , c. kim , d.l .
satterfield , k. sugavanam , p.w .
coteus , p. heidelberger , m.a .
blumrich , r.w .
wisniewski , a. gara , and g.l .
chiu , ieee micro * 32 * , 48 ( 2012 ) .
menanteau , f. , j.p .
hughes , c. sifon , m. hilton , j. gonzalez , l. infante , l.f .
barrientos , a.j .
baker , j.r .
bond , s. das , m.j .
devlin , j. dunkley , a. hajian , a.d .
hincks , a. kosowsky , d. marsden , t.a .
marriage , k. moodley , m.d .
niemack , m.r .
nolta , l.a .
page , e.d .
reese , n. sehgal , j. sievers , d.n .
spergel , s.t .
staggs , e. wollack , astrophys .
j. * 748 * , 1 ( 2012 ) .
pfalzner , s. , and p. gibbon , _ many - body tree methods in physics _ ( cambridge university press , 1996 ) ; see also barnes , j. , and p. hut , nature * 324 * , 446 ( 1986 ) ; warren , m.s . and j.k
. salmon , technical paper , supercomputing 1993 .
wittman , d.m .
tyson , i.p .
dellantonio , a.c .
becker , v.e .
margoniner , j. cohen , d. norman , d. loomba , g. squires , g. wilson , c. stubbs , j. hennawi , d. spergel , p. boeshaar , a. clocchiatti , m. hamuy , g. bernstein , a. gonzalez , p. guhathakurta , w. hu , u. seljak , and d. zaritsky , arxiv : astro - ph/0210118 . | remarkable observational advances have established a compelling cross - validated model of the universe . yet
, two key pillars of this model dark matter and dark energy remain mysterious .
sky surveys that map billions of galaxies to explore the ` dark universe ' , demand a corresponding extreme - scale simulation capability ; the hacc ( hybrid / hardware accelerated cosmology code ) framework has been designed to deliver this level of performance now , and into the future . with its novel algorithmic structure , hacc allows flexible tuning across diverse architectures , including accelerated and multi - core systems . on the ibm bg / q
, hacc attains unprecedented scalable performance
currently 13.94 pflops at 69.2% of peak and 90% parallel efficiency on 1,572,864 cores with an equal number of mpi ranks , and a concurrency of 6.3 million .
this level of performance was achieved at extreme problem sizes , including a benchmark run with more than 3.6 trillion particles , significantly larger than any cosmological simulation yet performed . |
classical light propagating through arrays of coupled waveguides has provided a fertile ground for the simulation of quantum physics @xcite .
these optical analogies of quantum phenomena are changing the way photonic integrated devices are designed ; e.g. one - directional couplers @xcite , light rectifiers @xcite , isolators and polarization splitters @xcite .
as the manufacturing quality for experimental devices increases @xcite , it will soon be possible to propagate non - classical light states through linear photonic devices and a full - quantum analysis of the problem is at hand . in quantum mechanics ,
propagation through an array of @xmath0 coupled linear waveguides is ruled by the schrdinger - like equation @xmath1 with a hamiltonian @xcite , @xmath2 where the real parameters @xmath3 and @xmath4 are related to the effective refractive index of the @xmath5th waveguide and to the distance between the @xmath5th and @xmath6th waveguides , in that order .
the operators @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) annihilate ( create ) a photon and @xmath9 gives the number of photons at the @xmath5th waveguide .
note that the vacuum state @xmath10 does not couple to any other states .
thus we will expect that states with an important vacuum component , e.g. coherent states @xmath11 with a small coherent parameter @xmath12 , will serve as good examples for the peculiarities of propagation in the quantum model . while bloch oscillations of noon path - entangled photons have been theoretically studied in the heisenberg picture @xcite ,
here we are interested in bringing forward a method in schrdinger picture and introduce a class of tight - binding waveguide arrays related to orthogonal polynomials .
then , we study a two - waveguide coupler and propagate fock , coherent , two - mode entangled and two - mode squeezed states . finally , we analyze the propagation of such non - classical states in a well - known photonic lattice used for the coherent transport of classical fields and close with a brief discussion .
for models with just nearest neighbor coupling , hamiltonian ( [ eq : genham ] ) reduces to the form : @xmath13 the equations of motion for the annihilation operators can be written in matrix form , @xmath14 , where the auxiliary matrix @xmath15 is tridiagonal , real and symmetric ; i.e. it is a jacobi matrix , @xmath16_{j , k } = \omega_{j } \delta_{j , j } + g_{j } \left(\delta_{j , k-1 } + \delta_{j-1,k } \right)$ ] .
we have used the notation @xmath17_{j , k}$ ] for the @xmath18th element of matrix @xmath19 and defined a vector of anihilation operators as @xmath20 .
it is straightforward to rewrite the matrix @xmath15 as a product of the eigenvector matrix @xmath21 , where each row is an eigenvector , and the diagonal eigenvalue matrix @xmath22 , @xmath23 .
the eigenvalues @xmath24 are calculated by the method of minors as the zeros of the polynomial @xmath25 with @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 @xcite .
then , we can define a set of multimode annihilation operators @xmath29 that diagonalize hamiltonian ( [ eq : spham ] ) , @xmath30 for parameters that do not depend on the propagation distance , the propagator is given by : @xmath31 some quantities of interest that can be measured in an experimental scheme and tracked analytically are the number of photons at each waveguide , @xmath32_{j}^{\dagger } \left[\mathbb{v}^{-1 } \vec{a } \right]_{j } \hat{u}(z ) \vert \psi(0 ) \rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the notation @xmath33_{j}$ ] has been used to represent the @xmath5th element of vector @xmath34 and @xmath35 is the inverse matrix `` of @xmath19 , and the two - point correlation function , @xmath36_{p}^{\dagger } \left[\mathbb{v}^{-1 } \vec{a } \right]_{p } \left[\mathbb{v}^{-1 } \vec{a } \right]_{q}^{\dagger } \left[\mathbb{v}^{-1 } \vec{a } \right]_{q } \hat{u}(z ) \vert \psi(0 ) \rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] that correlates the photon numbers detected at two waveguides .
we could choose a higher order detection probability @xmath37 @xcite ; the two - point correlation function is related to single detection @xmath38 .
we will also use the fidelity , @xmath39 that measures how similar the propagated state @xmath40 is to a given state @xmath41 ; sadly , this measurement can not be realized experimentally without full state reconstruction .
this procedure is valid for any given set of real parameters @xmath42 but here we are interested in bringing forward some specific lattices related to orthogonal polynomials .
the classical propagation of light fields has already been studied for some of these finite lattices : ( i ) identical refractive indices and identical couplings @xcite , the eigenvalues are given by the roots of the @xmath0th chebyshev polynomial , @xmath43 and the components of the eigenvector matrix @xmath44_{j , k } \propto u_{k}(\lambda_{j}/2)$ ] .
( ii ) identical refractive indices and couplings given by @xmath45 @xcite , the eigenvalues are given by the zeros of the @xmath0th hermite polynomial , @xmath46 , and the components of the eigenvector matrix @xmath44_{j , k } \propto h_{k}(\lambda_{j}/\sqrt{2})$ ] . (
iii ) binary refractive indices , @xmath47 , and identical couplings @xcite , the eigenvalues are the roots of a morgan - voyce polynomial , @xmath48 for even @xmath49 and @xmath50 for odd @xmath51 , and @xmath44_{j , k } \propto b_{k/2}(\omega^{2 } - \lambda_{j}^{2})$ ] for even @xmath6 and @xmath44_{j , k } \propto ( \omega^{2 } - \lambda_{j}^{2})b_{(k-1)/2}(\omega^{2 } - \lambda_{j}^{2})$ ] for odd @xmath6
. the method can also be applied for semi - infinite lattices ; e.g. refractive indices given by @xmath52 and couplings given by @xmath53 @xcite lead to eigenvalues @xmath54 and to elements of the eigenvectors matrix proportional to jacobi polynomials .
in order to give a practical example , let us study propagation of non - classical light states through two coupled photonic waveguides described by the hamiltonian @xcite : @xmath55 where the parameters @xmath56 is a real numbers related to the refractive indices difference and the diagonalization parameters are @xmath57 and @xmath58 with @xmath59^{-1/2}$ ] , @xmath60 , @xmath61 , @xmath62 and @xmath63 @xcite .
this hamiltonian model is related to the quantum beam splitter described by a parameter proprotional to @xmath64 @xcite .
it is straightforward to calculate the photon number at each waveguide with this method , @xmath65 and the two - point correlation function @xmath66 with @xmath67^{2 } \left [ \beta^{2 } \hat{a}_{1}^{\dagger } \hat{a}_{1 } + \alpha^{2 } \hat{a}_{2}^{\dagger } \hat{a}_{2 } + g \left ( e^{i \omega t } \hat{a}_{1}^{\dagger } \hat{a}_{2 } + e^{-i\omega t } \hat{a}_{1 } \hat{a}_{2}^{\dagger } \right)/\omega \right]$ ] and @xmath68^{2 } \left[\alpha^{2 } \hat{a}_{1}^{\dagger } \hat{a}_{1 } + \beta^{2 } \hat{a}_{2}^{\dagger } \hat{a}_{2 } - g \left ( e^{i \omega t } \hat{a}_{1}^{\dagger } \hat{a}_{2 } + e^{-i\omega t } \hat{a}_{1 } \hat{a}_{2}^{\dagger } \right)/\omega \right]$ ] .
( solid black ) , @xmath69 ( dashed blue ) and @xmath70 ( dotted red ) correlation functions ( third column ) for a single photon @xmath71 ( first row ) , a coherent state @xmath72 with @xmath73 ( second row ) , a two - mode entangled state @xmath74 ( third row ) and a two - mode squeezed vacuum @xmath75 with @xmath76 ( fourth row ) .
the two - waveguide coupler is described by the parameter set @xmath77 and @xmath78 . ]
we are used to think that light will transfer from one to the other waveguide for a classical field impinging one of two - identical waveguides , @xmath79 , but in the quantum case we have to remember that the vacuum state does not couple between the guides .
thus , whenever a non - classical state of light with a strong vacuum component impinges the two - waveguide coupler , the vacuum part of the whole state will remain at the initial waveguide ; e.g. a single photon impinging one of the waveguides will transfer to the second but something different will happen for a coherent state with a mean photon number of one or less than one photon . for the single photon impinging the first waveguide , @xmath80 , the mean photon number at the waveguides are given by @xmath81 and @xmath82 , fig .
[ fig : fig1](a ) , and the fidelity , @xmath83 , will oscillate between zero and one for identical waveguides @xmath77 , @xmath84 , fig .
[ fig : fig1](b ) .
the two - correlation functions for identical waveguides will also show a periodic transfer of the quantum state between the waveguides , fig .
[ fig : fig1](c ) . for a coherent state ,
@xmath85 , the amplitude for the vacuum state component is proportional to @xmath86 and will not transfer to the second waveguide .
thus , for a coherent state with mean photon number equal or less than one , @xmath12 , the vacuum amplitude will be large enough compared to the other amplitudes ; e.g. for @xmath73 the mean photon number at each waveguide , fig .
[ fig : fig1](d ) , looks identical to that of the single photon case but the fidelities , fig .
[ fig : fig1](e ) , and two - point correlation functions , fig .
[ fig : fig1](f ) , tell us that the initial quatum state of light is never transferred to the second waveguide .
another comparison can be made between the propagation of an initial two - mode path - entagled state @xmath74 that has a mean photon number of one half in each waveguide and will not evolve , fig .
[ fig : fig1](g)-[fig : fig1](i ) , and a two - mode squeezed state @xmath87 @xcite which also has an average photon number of one half in each waveguide for @xmath88 , fig .
[ fig : fig1](j - l ) . again the mean photon number at each waveguide for each case will look identical but the behavior of the fidelities and two - point correlation functions tell us that in the first case the initial state does not evolve while in the second case it does evolve .
( solid black ) , @xmath69 ( dashed black ) , @xmath89 ( dotted black ) , @xmath90 ( dot - dashed black ) , @xmath70 ( solid blue ) , @xmath91 ( dashed blue ) , @xmath92 ( dot - dashed blue ) , @xmath93 ( solid red ) , @xmath94 ( dashed red ) and @xmath95 ( solid green ) correlation functions ( third column ) for a single photon in the first waveguide @xmath96 ( first row ) , a coherent state @xmath97 with @xmath73 ( second row ) , a two - mode entangled state @xmath98 ( third row ) and a two - mode squeezed vacuum @xmath75 with @xmath76 ( fourth row ) .
the photonic lattice is described by the parameter set @xmath77 and @xmath99 with @xmath100 and @xmath101 . ]
recently , a lattice providing perfect transfer of classical light described by the hamiltonian @xmath102 has been proposed and demonstrated experimentally @xcite .
the size of the lattice is given by @xmath0 and the parameter @xmath103 is the distance at which the transfer from the initial to the final end is given .
the eigenvector matrix @xmath21 for this photonic lattice is given by jacobi polynomials @xcite and can transfer any given state initially impinging the @xmath5th waveguide into the @xmath104th waveguide as long as the initial state does not involve a vacuum component .
when the initial state has a strong vacuum component , this particular part of the state will not transfer and this will reflect in the fidelity at the output and the two - point correlations as shown in fig . [
fig : fig2 ] .
again we can see that the single photon input and the coherent state with a single photon mean photon number show identical mean photon number propagation , fig .
[ fig : fig2](a ) and [ fig : fig2](d ) , but the fidelities , fig .
[ fig : fig2](b ) and [ fig : fig2](e ) , and two - point correlation functions , fig .
[ fig : fig2](c ) and [ fig : fig2](f ) , tell us that only in the single photon case the initial state is faithfully transferred to the end of the lattice .
the same happens when we compare the propagation of a two - mode path - entangled state with that of a two - mode squeezed vacuum , both with a total mean photon number of one ; the mean photon number propagation at each waveguide are identical but the fidelities and two - point correlation functions will differ and point to faithful state transfer just in the case of the two - mode path - entangled state .
figure [ fig : fig2](g)-[fig : fig2](i ) show the propagation results for the two - mode entangeld state and fig.[fig : fig2](j)-[fig : fig2](l ) show the propagation of a two - mode squeezed vacuum state with a squeezing parameter @xmath76 leading to a total mean photon number of one .
we have shown a method to deal with non - classical light propagating through tight - binding arrays of coupled linear waveguides . while we focused on listing refractive indices and coupling parameters that allow us to diagonalize the quantum hamiltonian by use of multimode annihilation operators whose cofficients
are given in terms of orthogonal polynomials , the method can be used for any given set of parameters as a real symmetric tridiagonal matrix is always feasible of diagonalization . for the sake of bringing forward one of the most pronounced difference between propagation of classical and non - classical states of light
, we focused in comparing the propagation of states lacking a vacuum component , single - photon and a two - mode entangled state , with those showing a significant vacuum component , coherent and two - mode squeezed state with one or less than one mean photon number .
the author is grateful to g. s. agarwal for suggesting the study of two - mode squeezed state propagation in coupled waveguides .
20 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 longhi s 2009 _ laser photon . rev .
_ * 3 * 243 261 | we study the propagation of non - classical light through arrays of coupled linear photonic waveguides and introduce some sets of refractive indices and coupling parameters that provide a closed form propagator in terms of orthogonal polynomials .
we present propagation examples of non - classical states of light : single photon , coherent state , path - entangled state and two - mode squeezed vacuum impinging into two - waveguide couplers and a photonic lattice producing coherent transport . |
figure [ fig : bulk ] shows the magnitude of the rkky coupling as function of impurity distance @xmath21 along both the zigzag ( a ) and armchair directions ( b ) of the graphene lattice for several values of @xmath22 .
the rkky coupling in the large @xmath21-limit for non - interacting graphene is @xmath23/|{\bf r}|^3 $ ] with @xmath24 for a - a sublattice coupling , i.e. for impurities on the same sublattice , ( black ) and @xmath25 and three times larger for a - b ( or different ) sublattice coupling ( red ) @xcite . here
@xmath26 is the reciprocal vector for the dirac points .
apart from minor effects due to a small @xmath21 , these results are displayed in the lowest black and red curves in fig .
[ fig : bulk ] .
the non - oscillatory @xmath21-dependence for the armchair direction is a consequence of only sampling the @xmath27-function at the graphene lattice sites . when including electron interactions these results are , however , qualitatively modified even for small @xmath0 . for @xmath28 ( middle curve ) essentially all evidence of the @xmath29-oscillations is gone as is the factor of three difference between a - a and a - b sublattice coupling
. also , the power - law decay exponent @xmath30 changes from @xmath31 for @xmath32 to around 2.3 ( 2.6 ) for @xmath28 and 1.9 ( 2.1 ) for @xmath33 for the zigzag ( armchair ) direction .
in fact , for @xmath34 ( uppermost curve ) , the armchair and zigzag rkky couplings are equal and thus all lattice specific details have been washed out for such values of the electron interactions . with the mean - field quantum critical coupling for the afm insulating state being @xmath35 @xcite it is perhaps not surprising that the rkky coupling becomes independent of the small length scale details close to this point .
however , what is rather unexpected is that this washing " out of the lattice details is clearly present even at such low values as @xmath36 , a value which is very likely lower than the physical value of @xmath0 in graphene .
we thus conclude that including electron interactions is imperative when studying the rkky interaction in graphene . without them not only are the magnitude of the rkky coupling grossly underestimated but , more importantly , the results do not even have a qualitatively correct @xmath21-dependence .
within the non - interacting electron picture we recently showed that for impurities along a zigzag graphene edge ( a - a impurities ) the rkky interaction decays exponentially for large @xmath21 , but that , quite counterintuitively , smaller @xmath3 gives a longer decay length @xcite .
these results are a consequence of the extreme easiness by which an edge impurity can polarize the zero energy edge state .
in contrast , for a - a impurities inside a narrow zgnr , bulk properties of the rkky coupling are largely regained , notably @xmath37 . the effect of the edge is thus only limited to edge impurities in the non - interacting limit .
these results are shown in the two lowest curves in fig .
[ fig : ribbon ] for impurities along the edge ( a ) and inside the ribbon ( c ) for @xmath38 ( black ) and @xmath39 ( red ) .
when including electron interaction this picture is dramatically changed .
as is well established , any finite @xmath0 is going to spontaneously polarize the edge state @xcite , and by extension the whole ribbon @xcite , thus making it harder for an impurity spin to influence the polarization of the graphene .
the three upper curves in ( a , c ) are for @xmath40 and 2 , respectively .
as seen , the @xmath21-dependence completely disappears for @xmath21 larger than a few unit cells for any physically relevant value of @xmath0 and for all impurity sites in a narrow zgnr .
the @xmath21-independent value of the rkky coupling is analyzed as a function of @xmath22 in figs .
[ fig : ribbon](b , d ) . as in the bulk
, the fm impurity configuration is energetically favored for a - a impurities in zgnrs , whereas the afm configuration will require modification of the spontaneous graphene polarization to accommodate the impurity spin of the opposite orientation to said polarization .
there are two @xmath21-independent limiting solutions for the afm configuration of which the one with lowest energy will give an upper bound for the constant rkky coupling .
the first limiting solution has a magnetic domain wall formed between the two afm oriented impurity spins .
the magnetic domain wall formation energy per edge @xmath41 is equal to the rkky coupling for this solution and its value , calculated within eq .
( [ eq : h ] ) , is displayed with a dashed line in figs .
[ fig : ribbon ] ( b , d ) .
this limiting solution is not only independent of @xmath21 but also of @xmath3 making it especially favorable at high @xmath3-values which is also seen in fig .
[ fig : ribbon](b ) . for smaller
@xmath3 it is , however , more likely that the most favorable afm solution is one where the impurity spins do not noticably change the polarization of the underlying graphene , not even directly at the impurity site .
the limiting afm solution in this case is the unperturbed graphene plus the two impurities and has an energy @xmath42 above that of the fm solution . here
@xmath43 is the graphene polarization at the site of the wrongly oriented impurity but in the absence of impurities .
this unperturbed limiting solution is also naturally @xmath21-independent and its rkky coupling is displayed with dash dotted lines in figs .
[ fig : ribbon](b , d ) .
note that since @xmath43 is significantly lower inside a narrow zgnr than on the edge , this solution yields a smaller rkky coupling for impurities away from the edge .
also note that @xmath43 depends rather strongly on @xmath0 , which causes both limiting solutions to increase sharply with an increasing @xmath0 .
the true rkky coupling follow the lower of these two limiting solutions remarkably well for all four cases studied in fig . [ fig : ribbon ] , including jumping form one to the other around @xmath44 for edge impurities when @xmath39 .
the small deviations from the unperturbed limiting solution are due to some impact of the impurity spins on the graphene polarization which locally produces small changes in @xmath43 in favor of a lower total energy .
the only real notable discrepancy is for edge impurities when @xmath3 is large and @xmath0 moderately small . here
the domain - wall limiting solution is not followed too closely but the system lowers its energy slightly by instead creating a local , half - circle shaped , domain wall around one of the wrongly oriented impurity spin .
this solution naturally creates a spin - imbalance in the system as its domain wall does not propagate to other edge .
note that both of the limiting solutions described here are always present , and thus the qualitative rkky behavior is the same , in any system which has a spontaneous polarization in the absence of impurities , such as is the case for zgnrs for any finite @xmath0 . for edge impurities
we do not expect the width of the ribbon to change the rkky behavior as both the spontaneous edge polarization and @xmath41 are weak functions of the ribbon width .
however , for impurities inside a very wide zgnr the spontaneous polarization inside the ribbon is going to be vanishingly small and bulk properties should eventually be restored for wide ribbons and small @xmath3 .
we thus conclude that any finite electron interaction renders the long - distance rkky coupling in a zgnr @xmath21-independent and linearly dependent on @xmath3 for small @xmath3 , but independent on @xmath3 in the limit of large @xmath3 .
in addition , electron interactions make impurities inside a zgnr behave similarly to edge impurities which is opposite to the situation for non - interacting electrons .
there exist some dft results for the rkky coupling in graphene @xcite but such studies are always limited to very small @xmath21 unless chains ( or lattices ) of impurities are studied .
[ fig : dft ] shows the rkky coupling for a - a sublattice impurity chains along the zigzag direction separated a distance of @xmath45 as function of the impurity distance @xmath21 along the chains .
we see that for @xmath32 ( lowest curve ) characteristic non - interacting @xmath46-type oscillations are present but the chain configuration makes the rkky coupling somewhat more long ranged than @xmath47 .
the oscillations however quickly disappear and the decay exponent @xmath30 decreases ( see inset ) with increasing @xmath0 .
dft results using the hybrid functional b3lyp on the same chain structure is available in ref . [ ] and these results , scaled with an overall , unimportant prefactor , are displayed with a dashed red line in fig .
[ fig : dft ] .
there are no oscillations in the dft results and the exponent @xmath30 agrees when @xmath14 which also yields very well matched results as indicative in the main plot . at a first glance
, this might seem as a large value for the coulomb repulsion in graphene since the mean - field afm instability is at @xmath35 .
however , one should keep in mind that multiple recent theoretical work have classified graphene as being very close to , if not even being , an insulator in vacuum due to strong coulomb interactions @xcite .
our results point to the fact that this state might be an afm insulator which would be consistent with earlier results @xcite .
our extracted value of @xmath0 also agrees quantitatively with earlier estimations based on the b3lyp functional @xcite .
dft calculations instead using the local density ( lda ) or general gradient ( gga ) approximations have yielded a somewhat smaller @xmath48 @xcite .
it is well known that lda suffers from electron self - interaction and therefore often underestimates @xmath0 .
b3lyp on the other hand explicitly contains an element of fock exchange and thus tends to handle this deficiency better .
this becomes especially important in strongly correlated systems but b3lyp can still reproduce the lda results for weakly correlated materials . with such high value of @xmath0
it is also natural to ask about other possible electronically driven ordered states . @xmath49
increases with doping @xcite and thus undoped graphene is the strongest candidate for an afm state .
however , with increasing doping electronically driven @xmath50-wave superconductivity caused by spin - singlet nearest neighbor correlations appears for any coulomb interaction @xcite .
such correlations were already proposed by pauling and others @xcite for the @xmath51-bonded planar organic molecules of which graphene is the infinite extension . with the coulomb interaction extracted from the results in fig .
[ fig : dft ] one would need a chemical doping of @xmath52 ev to reach @xmath53 k , a value which might be achieved with , for example , chemical doping . in summary we have shown that it is of vital importance to include electron - electron interactions when studying the rkky coupling in graphene .
even relatively weak electron interactions qualitatively change the rkky coupling to be significantly longer ranged and monotonically decaying in the bulk . in a zgnr
the change is even more pronounced and the @xmath21 dependence entirely disappears . by comparing our mean - field results
we have also been able to extract a surprisingly high value for the coulomb interactions , demonstrating that graphene might be very close to an afm insulating instability . with such closeness to an afm state
it is rather natural that magnetic properties , such as the rkky coupling , are going to be heavily influenced by electron interactions .
, , , , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) , , , * * ( ) , * * , ( ) , , , , , , , , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , , , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , , , * * , ( ) , , , , * * , ( ) , , , , * * , ( ) , , , , * * , ( ) , , , , * * , ( ) , , , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , * * , ( ) , in _ _ , edited by , , ( , , ) , vol . , p. , , , * * , ( ) , , , , * * , ( ) , , , , * * , ( ) , _ _ ( , , ) , * * , ( ) | we show that the carrier - mediated exchange interaction , the so - called rkky coupling , between two magnetic impurity moments in graphene is significantly modified in the presence of electron - electron interactions . using the mean - field approximation of the hubbard-@xmath0 model
we show that the @xmath1-oscillations present in the bulk for non - interacting electrons disappear and the power - law decay become more long ranged with increasing electron interactions . in zigzag graphene nanoribbons
the effects are even larger with any finite @xmath0 rendering the long - distance rkky coupling distance independent . comparing our mean - field results with first - principles results
we also extract a surprisingly large value of @xmath0 indicating that graphene is very close to an antiferromagnetic instability .
several novel features of graphene , such as two - dimensionality , linear energy dispersion , a tunable chemical potential by gate voltage , and a high mobility have helped raising the expectation of graphene being a serious post - silicon era candidate @xcite . in this context ,
functionalization of graphene , especially with magnetic atoms or defects which also opens the door to spintronics @xcite , is of large interest .
one of the most important properties of magnetic impurities is their effective interaction propagated by the conduction electrons in the host , the so - called ruderman - kittel - kasuya - yoshida ( rkky ) coupling @xcite .
this coupling is crucial for magnetic ordering of impurities but also offers access to the intrinsic magnetic properties of the host .
several studies exist for the rkky coupling in graphene , where both the standard perturbative approach applied to a continuum field - theoretic description of graphene @xcite and exact diagonalization @xcite have been shown to give similar results .
however , consistently , the rkky coupling in graphene has been calculated for non - interacting electrons .
this is in spite of growing evidence for the importance of electron - electron interactions in graphene with theoretical results pointing to intrinsic graphene being close to a mott insulating state @xcite .
these results thus beg the question if properties such as the rkky coupling , which are intrinsically linked to the magnetic properties of graphene , can accurately be described in a non - interacting electron picture . in this letter
, we will therefore investigate the effect of electron - electron interactions on the rkky coupling , both in the bulk and in zigzag graphene nanoribbons ( zgnrs ) where the zero - energy edge states @xcite can significantly modify the rkky behavior @xcite .
we will below show that even for small to moderate strengths of the electron interactions , the rkky coupling in the bulk is qualitatively modified and gets significantly more long - ranged than in the non - interacting electron picture . for zgnrs the effect is even more striking as any finite @xmath0 causes the long - distance rkky coupling to become distance independent .
we thus conclude that it is imperative to include electron interactions when studying the rkky coupling , and , by extension , any other properties closely related to the magnetic properties of graphene .
more specifically , we will use the mean - field approximation of the one - band hubbard-@xmath0 model for graphene and include magnetic impurity spins @xmath2 which couples to a graphene atom with a kondo coupling term @xmath3 : @xmath4 here @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) annihilates ( creates ) an electron at site @xmath7 with spin @xmath8 , @xmath9 means nearest neighbors , and @xmath10 , with @xmath11 being the pauli matrices , is the electron spin .
the constants entering , apart from @xmath3 which depends on the particular impurity moment , are the nearest neighbor hopping in graphene @xmath12 ev and the on - site repulsion @xmath0 .
the value of @xmath0 is hard to determine exactly but , depending on the choice of exchange - correlation potential , @xmath13 has been shown to be consistent with density functional theory ( dft ) results @xcite .
below we are able to extract @xmath14 when comparing the rkky coupling in a spin chain with dft results @xcite . the expectation value of the spin - resolved electron density @xmath15 needs to be calculated self - consistently in eq .
( [ eq : h ] ) and gives the spin polarization density as @xmath16 .
the hubbard model has been employed before in the study of graphene and zgnrs and has been shown to yield results consistent with first - principles dft results @xcite . in standard rkky perturbation theory @xcite the leading interaction between two impurity moments at sites @xmath7 and @xmath17
is given by @xmath18 with the effective rkky coupling constant @xmath19 proportional to the static spin susceptibility of the imbedding bulk .
here we will instead self - consistently solve eq .
( [ eq : h ] ) for two impurity spins in a ferromagnetic ( fm ) and an antiferromagnetic ( afm ) configuration , respectively and explicitly calculate the rkky coupling as the energy difference between these two configurations : @xmath20/2 $ ] .
more details of our method applied to non - interacting graphene can be found in ref . [ ] . |
due to the increasing use of wireless technology in communication networks , there has been a significant amount of research on methods of improving wireless performance .
while there are many ways of measuring wireless performance , a good first step ( which has been extensively studied ) is the notion of _ capacity_. given a collection of communication links , the capacity of a network is simply the maximum number of simultaneously satisfiable links .
this can obviously depend on the exact model of wireless communication that we are using , but is clearly an upper bound on the usefulness " of the network .
there has been a large amount of research on analyzing the capacity of wireless networks ( see e.g. @xcite ) , and it has become a standard way of measuring the quality of a network . because of this , when introducing a new technology it is interesting to analyze its affect on the capacity .
for example , we know that in certain cases giving transmitters the ability to control their transmission power can increase the capacity by @xmath4 or @xmath7 @xcite , where @xmath1 is the ratio of the longest link length to the smallest transmitter - receiver distance , and can clearly never decrease the capacity . however , while the capacity might improve , it is not nearly as clear that the _ achieved _ capacity will improve . after all , we do not expect our network to actually have performance that achieves the maximum possible capacity .
we show that not only might these improved technologies not help , they might in fact _ decrease _ the achieved network capacity . following andrews and dinitz @xcite and sgeirsson and mitra @xcite , we model each link as a self - interested agent and analyze various types of game - theoretic behavior ( nash equilibria and no - regret behavior in particular ) .
we show that a version of _ braess s paradox _
@xcite holds : adding new technology to the networks ( such as the ability to control powers ) can actually decrease the average capacity at equilibrium .
our main results show that in the context of wireless networks , and particularly in the context of the sinr model , there is a version of _ braess s paradox _ @xcite . in his seminal paper ,
braess studied congestion in road networks and showed that adding additional roads to an existing network can actually make congestion _
worse _ , since agents will behave selfishly and the additional options can result in worse equilibria .
this is completely analogous to our setting , since in road networks adding extra roads can not hurt the network in terms of the value of the optimum solution , but can hurt the network since the _ achieved _ congestion gets worse . in this work
we consider the physical model ( also called the sinr model ) , pioneered by moscibroda and wattenhofer @xcite and described more formally in section [ sec : models ] .
intuitively , this model works as follows : every sender chooses a transmission power ( which may be pre - determined , e.g. due to hardware limitations ) , and the received power decreased polynomially with the distance from the sender . a transmission is successful if the received power from the sender is large enough to overcome the interference caused by other senders plus the background noise . with our baseline being the sinr model ,
we then consider four ways of improving " a network : adding power control , adding interference cancellation , adding both power control and interference cancellation , and decreasing the sinr threshold . with all of these modifications
it is easy to see that the optimal capacity can only increase , but we will show that the equilibria can become worse . thus improving " a network might actually result in worse performance . the game - theoretic setup that we use
is based on @xcite and will be formally described in section [ sec : game - theory ] , but we will give an overview here .
we start with a game in which the players are the links , and the strategies depend slightly on the model but are essentially possible power settings at which to transmit .
the utilities depend on whether or not the link was successful , and whether or not it even attempted to transmit . in a pure nash equilibrium every player has a strategy ( i.e. power setting ) and has no incentive to deviate : any other strategy would result in smaller utility . in a mixed nash equilibrium
every link has a probability distribution over the strategies , and no link has any incentive to deviate from their distribution .
finally , no - regret behavior is the empirical distribution of play when all players use _ no - regret _ algorithms , which are a widely used and studied class of learning algorithms ( see section [ sec : game - theory ] for a formal definition ) .
it is reasonably easy to see that any pure nash is a mixed nash , and any mixed nash is a no - regret behavior .
for all of these , the quality of the solution is the achieved capacity , i.e. the average number of successful links .
our first result is for interference cancellation ( ic ) , which has been widely proposed as a practical method of increasing network performance @xcite .
the basic idea of interference cancellation is quite simple .
first , the strongest interfering signal is detected and decoded .
once decoded , this signal can then be subtracted ( canceled " ) from the original signal .
subsequently , the next strongest interfering signal can be detected and decoded from the now cleaner " signal , and so on .
as long as the strongest remaining signal can be decoded in the presence of the weaker signals , this process continues until we are left with the desired transmitted signal , which can now be decoded .
this clearly can increase the capacity of the network , and even in the worst case can not decrease it . and yet due to bad game - theoretic interactions
it might make the achieved capacity worse : [ thm : ic - intro ] there exists a set of links in which the _ best _ no - regret behavior under interference cancellation achieves capacity at most @xmath8 times the _ worst _ no - regret behavior without interference cancellation , for some constant @xmath9 .
however , for every set of links the worst no - regret behavior under interference cancellation achieves capacity that is at least a constant fraction of the best no - regret behavior without interference cancellation .
thus ic can make the achieved capacity worse , but only by a constant factor .
note that since every nash equilibrium ( mixed or pure ) is also no - regret , this implies the equivalent statements for those type of equilibria as well . in this result ( as in most of our examples ) we only show a small network ( @xmath10 links ) with no background noise , but these are both only for simplicity it is easy to incorporate constant noise , and the small network can be repeated at sufficient distance to get examples with an arbitrarily large number of links .
we next consider power control ( pc ) , where senders can choose not just whether to transmit , but at what power to transmit .
it turns out that any equilibrium without power control is also an equilibrium with power control , and thus we can not hope to find an example where the best equilibrium with power control is worse than the worst equilibrium without power control ( as we did with ic ) .
instead , we show that adding power control can create worse equilibria : [ thm : pc - intro ] there exists a set of links in which there is a pure nash equilibrium with power control of value at most @xmath8 times the value of the worst no - regret behavior without power control , for some constant @xmath9 .
however , for every set of links the worst no - regret behavior with power control has value that is at least a constant fraction of the value of the _ best _ no - regret behavior without power control .
note that the first part of the theorem implies that not only is there a pure nash with low - value ( with power control ) , there are also mixed nash and no - regret behaviors with low value ( since any pure nash is also mixed and no - regret ) .
similarly , the second part of the theorem gives a bound on the gap between the worst and the best mixed nashes , and the worst and the best pure nashes .
our third set of results is on the combination of power control and interference cancellation .
it turns out that the combination of the two can be quite harmful .
when compared to either the vanilla setting ( no interference cancellation or power control ) or the presence of power control without interference cancellation , the combination of ic and pc acts essentially as in theorem [ thm : pc - intro ] : pure nash equilibria are created that are worse than the previous worst no - regret behavior , but this can only be by a constant factor .
on the other hand , this factor can be super - constant when compared to equilibria that only use interference cancellation .
let @xmath1 be the ratio of the length of the longest link to the minimum distance between any sender and any receiver .
there exists a set of links in which the worst pure nash with both pc and ic ( and thus the worst mixed nash or no - regret behavior ) has value at most @xmath11 times the value of the worst no - regret behavior with just ic .
however , for every set of links the worst no - regret behavior with both pc and ic has value at least @xmath12 times the value of the best no - regret behavior with just ic .
this theorem means that interference cancellation changes the game " : if interference control were not an option then power control can only hurt the equilibria by a constant amount ( from theorem [ thm : pc - intro ] ) , but if we assume that interference cancellation is present then adding power control can hurt us by @xmath4
. thus when deciding whether to use both power control and interference cancellation , one must be particularly careful to analyze how they act in combination .
finally , we consider the effect of decreasing the sinr threshold @xmath3 ( this value will be formally described in section [ sec : models ] ) . we show that , as with ic , there are networks in which a decrease in the sinr threshold can lead to _ every _ equilibrium being worse than even the worst equilibrium at the higher threshold , despite the capacity increasing or staying the same : there exists a set of links and constants @xmath13 in which the best no - regret behavior under threshold @xmath14 has value at most @xmath8 times the value of the worst no - regret behavior under threshold @xmath3 , for some constant @xmath9 . however , for any set of links and any @xmath13 the value of the worst no - regret behavior under @xmath14 is at least a constant fraction of the value of the best no - regret behavior under @xmath3 .
our main network constructions illustrating braess s paradox in the studied settings are summarized in fig .
[ fig : nash_all ] . schematic illustration of the main lower bounds illustrating the braess s paradox with ( a ) ic : a network in which every no - regret behavior without ic is better than any no - regret behavior solution with ic ; ( b ) pc : a network in which there exists a pure nash equilibrium with pc which is worse than any no - regret behavior with ic ; ( c ) pic : a network with a pure nash equilibrium in the pic setting which is @xmath4 worse than any no - regret behavior in the ic setting but _ without _ power control ; and ( d ) decreased sinr threshold @xmath15 : a network in which every no - regret behavior with @xmath14 has a smaller value than any no - regret behavior with higher sinr threshold @xmath3 .
edge weights represent distances .
, title="fig : " ] schematic illustration of the main lower bounds illustrating the braess s paradox with ( a ) ic : a network in which every no - regret behavior without ic is better than any no - regret behavior solution with ic ; ( b ) pc : a network in which there exists a pure nash equilibrium with pc which is worse than any no - regret behavior with ic ; ( c ) pic : a network with a pure nash equilibrium in the pic setting which is @xmath4 worse than any no - regret behavior in the ic setting but _ without _ power control ; and ( d ) decreased sinr threshold @xmath15 : a network in which every no - regret behavior with @xmath14 has a smaller value than any no - regret behavior with higher sinr threshold @xmath3 .
edge weights represent distances .
, title="fig : " ] schematic illustration of the main lower bounds illustrating the braess s paradox with ( a ) ic : a network in which every no - regret behavior without ic is better than any no - regret behavior solution with ic ; ( b ) pc : a network in which there exists a pure nash equilibrium with pc which is worse than any no - regret behavior with ic ; ( c ) pic : a network with a pure nash equilibrium in the pic setting which is @xmath4 worse than any no - regret behavior in the ic setting but _ without _ power control ; and ( d ) decreased sinr threshold @xmath15 : a network in which every no - regret behavior with @xmath14 has a smaller value than any no - regret behavior with higher sinr threshold @xmath3 .
edge weights represent distances .
, title="fig : " ] schematic illustration of the main lower bounds illustrating the braess s paradox with ( a ) ic : a network in which every no - regret behavior without ic is better than any no - regret behavior solution with ic ; ( b ) pc : a network in which there exists a pure nash equilibrium with pc which is worse than any no - regret behavior with ic ; ( c ) pic : a network with a pure nash equilibrium in the pic setting which is @xmath4 worse than any no - regret behavior in the ic setting but _ without _ power control ; and ( d ) decreased sinr threshold @xmath15 : a network in which every no - regret behavior with @xmath14 has a smaller value than any no - regret behavior with higher sinr threshold @xmath3 .
edge weights represent distances .
, title="fig : " ] the capacity of _ random _ networks was examined in the seminal paper of gupta and kumar @xcite , who proved tight bounds in a variety of models .
but only recently has there been a significant amount of work on algorithms for determining the capacity of _ arbitrary _ networks , particularly in the sinr model .
this line of work began with goussevskaia , oswald , and wattenhofer @xcite , who gave an @xmath6-approximation for the uniform power setting ( i.e. the vanilla model we consider ) .
goussevskaia , halldrson , wattenhofer , and welzl @xcite then improved this to an @xmath5-approximation ( still under uniform powers ) , while andrews and dinitz @xcite gave a similar @xmath6-approximation algorithm for the power control setting .
this line of research was essentially completed by an @xmath5-approximation for the power control setting due to kesselheim @xcite . in parallel to the work on approximation algorithms , there has been some work on using game theory ( and in particular the games used in this paper ) to help design distributed approximation algorithms .
this was begun by andrews and dinitz @xcite , who gave an upper bound of @xmath16 on the price of anarchy for the basic game defined in section [ sec : game - theory ] .
but since computing the nash equilibrium of a game is ppad - complete @xcite , we do not expect games to necessarily converge to a nash equilibrium in polynomial time .
thus dinitz @xcite strengthened the result by showing the same upper bound of @xmath16 for no - regret behavior .
this gave the first distributed algorithm with a nontrivial approximation ratio , simply by having every player use a no - regret algorithm .
the analysis of the same game was then improved to @xmath6 by sgeirsson and mitra @xcite .
there is very little work on interference cancellation in arbitrary networks from an algorithmic point of view , although it has been studied quite well from an information - theoretic point of view ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
recently avin et al .
@xcite studied the topology of _ sinr diagrams _ under interference cancellation , which are a generalization of the sinr diagrams introduced by avin et al .
@xcite and further studied by kantor et al .
@xcite for the sinr model without interference cancellation .
these diagrams specify the reception zones of transmitters in the sinr model , which turn out to have several interesting topological and geometric properties but have not led to a better understanding of the fundamental capacity question .
we model a wireless network as a set of links @xmath17 in the plane , where each link @xmath18 represents a communication request from a sender @xmath19 to a receiver @xmath20 .
the @xmath21 senders and receivers are given as points in the euclidean plane .
the euclidean distance between two points @xmath22 and @xmath23 is denoted @xmath24 .
the distance between sender @xmath25 and receiver @xmath26 is denoted by @xmath27 .
we adopt the physical model ( sometime called the sinr model ) where the received signal strength of transmitter @xmath25 at the receiver @xmath26 decays with the distance and it is given by @xmath28 , where @xmath29 $ ] is the transmission power of sender @xmath25 and @xmath30 is the path - loss exponent . receiver @xmath26 successfully receives a message from sender @xmath31 iff @xmath32 , where @xmath33 denotes the amount of background noise and @xmath34 denotes the minimum sinr required for a message to be successfully received . the _ total interference _ that receiver @xmath26 suffers from the set of links @xmath35 is given by @xmath36 . throughout , we assume that all distances @xmath27 are normalized so that @xmath37 hence the maximal link length is @xmath1 , i.e. , @xmath38 and any received signal strength @xmath39 is bounded by @xmath40 . in the vanilla sinr model
we require that @xmath41 is either @xmath42 or @xmath2 for every transmitter .
this is sometimes referred to as _ uniform _ powers .
when we have power control , we allow @xmath41 to be any integer in @xmath43 $ ] .
interference cancellation allows receivers to cancel signals that they can decode .
consider link @xmath44 .
if @xmath26 can decode the signal with the largest received signal , then it can decode it and remove it .
it can repeat this process until it decodes its desire message from @xmath31 , unless at some point it gets stuck and can not decode the strongest signal .
formally , @xmath26 can decode @xmath25 if @xmath45 ( i.e. it can decode @xmath25 in the presence of weaker signals ) and if it can decode @xmath46 for all links @xmath47 with @xmath48 .
link @xmath44 is successful if @xmath26 can decode @xmath31 .
the following key notion , which was introduced in @xcite and extended to arbitrary powers by @xcite , plays an important role in our analysis .
the _ affectance _
@xmath49 of link @xmath50 caused by another link @xmath51 with a given power assignment vector @xmath52 is defines to be @xmath53 , where @xmath54 .
informally , @xmath49 indicates the amount of ( normalized ) interference that link @xmath51 causes at link @xmath50 .
it is easy to verify that link @xmath50 is successful if and only if @xmath55 .
when the powers of @xmath52 are the same @xmath56 for every @xmath57 , ( i.e. uniform powers ) , we may omit it and simply write @xmath58 .
for a set of links @xmath35 and a link @xmath51 , the total affectance caused by @xmath51 is @xmath59 . in the same manner ,
the total affectance caused by @xmath35 on the link @xmath51 is @xmath60 .
we say that a set of links @xmath35 is _
@xmath3-feasible _ if @xmath61 for all @xmath62 , i.e. every link achieves sinr above the threshold ( and is thus successful even without interference cancellation ) .
it is easy to verify that @xmath35 is @xmath3-feasible if and only if @xmath63 for every @xmath62 .
following @xcite , we say that a link set @xmath35 is _ amenable _ if the total affectance caused by any single link is bounded by some constant , i.e. , @xmath64 for every @xmath65 .
the following basic properties of amenable sets play an important role in our analysis .
@xcite [ fc : amenable ] ( a ) every feasible set @xmath35 contains a subset @xmath66 , such that @xmath67 is amenable and @xmath68 .
+ ( b ) for every amenable set @xmath67 that is @xmath3-feasible with uniform powers , for every other link @xmath69 , it holds that @xmath70 . we will use a game that is essentially the same as the game of andrews and dinitz @xcite , modified only to account for the different models we consider .
each link @xmath71 is a player with @xmath72 possible strategies : broadcast at power @xmath42 , or at integer power @xmath73 .
a link has utility @xmath74 if it is successful , has utility @xmath75 if it uses nonzero power but is unsuccessful , and has utility @xmath42 if it does not transmit ( i.e. chooses power @xmath42 ) . note that if power control is not available , this game only has two strategies : power @xmath42 and power @xmath2 .
let @xmath76 denote the set of possible strategies .
strategy profile _ is a vector in @xmath77 , where the @xmath78th component is the strategy played by link @xmath71 . for each link @xmath71 ,
let @xmath79 be the function mapping strategy profiles to utility for link @xmath78 as described . given a strategy profile @xmath80 ,
let @xmath81 denote the profile without the @xmath78th component , and given some strategy @xmath82 let @xmath83 denote the utility of @xmath71 if it uses strategy @xmath84 and all other links use their strategies from @xmath80 .
a pure nash equilibrium is a strategy profile in which no player has any incentive to deviate from their strategy .
formally , @xmath85 is a pure nash equilibrium if @xmath86 for all @xmath82 and players @xmath87 . in a mixed nash equilibrium @xcite ,
every player @xmath71 has a probability distribution @xmath88 over @xmath76 , and the requirement is that no player has any incentive to change their distribution to some @xmath89 .
so @xmath90 \geq { \mathop{\mathbb e}}[f_i(\pi ' , a_{-i})]$ ] for all @xmath91 , where the expectation is over the random strategy profile @xmath80 drawn from the product distribution defined by the @xmath88 s , and @xmath89 is any distribution over @xmath76 . to define no - regret behavior ,
suppose that the game has been played for @xmath92 rounds and let @xmath93 be the realized strategy profile in round @xmath94 .
the _ history _
@xmath95 of the game is the sequence of the @xmath92 strategy profiles .
the _ regret _
@xmath96 of player @xmath78 in an history @xmath97 is defined to be @xmath98 the regret of a player is intuitively the amount that it lost by not playing some fixed strategy . an algorithm used by a player is known as a _ no - regret _
algorithm if it guarantees that the regret of the player tends to @xmath42 as @xmath92 tends to infinity .
there is a large amount of work on no - regret algorithms , and it turns out that many such algorithms exist ( see e.g. @xcite ) . thus we will analyze situations where every player has regret at most @xmath99 , and since this tends to @xmath42 we will be free to assume that @xmath99 is arbitrarily small , say at most @xmath100 . clearly playing
a pure or mixed nash is a no - regret algorithm ( since the fact that no one has incentive to switch to any other strategy guarantees that each player will have regret @xmath42 in the long run ) , so analyzing the worst or best history with regret at most @xmath99 is more general than analyzing the worst or best mixed or pure nash .
we will call a history in which all players have regret at most @xmath99 an @xmath99-regret history .
formally an history @xmath95 is an @xmath99-_regret _ history if @xmath101 for every player @xmath91 .
a simple but important lemma introduced in @xcite and used again in @xcite relates the average number of _ attempted _ transmissions to the average number of _ successful _ transmissions .
fix an @xmath99-regret history , let @xmath102 be the fraction of times in which @xmath69 successfully transmitted , and let @xmath103 be the fraction of times in which @xmath69 attempted to transmit .
note that the average number of successful transmissions in a time slot is exactly @xmath104 , so it is this quantity which we will typically attempt to bound .
the following lemma lets us get away with bounding the number of attempts instead .
[ lem : attempts ] @xmath105 .
[ [ notation ] ] notation : + + + + + + + + + let @xmath35 be a fixed set of @xmath21 links embedded in @xmath106 .
let @xmath107 denote the minimum number of successful links ( averaged over time ) in any @xmath99-regret history , and similarly let @xmath108 denote the maximum number of successful links ( averaged over time ) in any @xmath99-regret history .
define @xmath109 , and @xmath110 similarly for the ic setting , @xmath111 and @xmath112 for the pc setting , and @xmath113 and @xmath114 for the setting with both pc and ic . finally , let @xmath115 , @xmath116 be for the corresponding values for the vanilla model when the sinr threshold is set to @xmath3 ( this is hidden in the previous models , but we pull it out in order to compare the effect of modifying @xmath3 ) . while we will focus on comparing the equilibria of games utilizing different wireless technologies , much of the previous work on these games instead focuses on a single game and analyzes its equilibria with respect to opt , the maximum achievable capacity .
the _ price of anarchy _
( poa ) is the ratio of opt to the value of the worst mixed nash @xcite , and the _ price of total anarchy _
( pota ) is the ratio of opt to the value of the worst @xmath99-regret history @xcite .
clearly poa @xmath117 pota .
while it is not our focus , we will prove some bounds on these values as corollaries of our main results .
we begin by analyzing the effect on the equilibria of adding interference cancellation .
we would expect that using ic would result equilibria with larger values , since the capacity of the network might go up ( and can certainly not go down ) .
we show that this is not always the case : there are sets of links for which even the _ best _ @xmath99-regret history using ic is a constant factor worse than the _ worst _ @xmath99-regret history without using ic .
[ thm : ic_lower ] there exists a set of links @xmath35 such that @xmath118 for some constant @xmath119 .
let @xmath67 be the four link network depicted in figure [ fig : nash_all](a ) , with @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
we will assume that the threshold @xmath3 is equal to @xmath122 , the path - loss exponent @xmath123 is equal to @xmath124 , and the background noise @xmath125 ( none of these are crucial , but make the analysis simpler ) .
let us first consider what happens without using interference cancellation .
suppose each link has at most @xmath99-regret , and for link @xmath71 let @xmath126 denote the fraction of times at which @xmath25 attempted to transmit .
it is easy to see that link @xmath74 will always be successful , since the received signal strength at @xmath127 is @xmath74 while the total interference is at most @xmath128 .
since @xmath129 has at most @xmath99-regret , this implies that @xmath130 . on the other hand ,
whenever @xmath131 transmits it is clear that link @xmath132 can not be successful , as its sinr is at most @xmath133 .
so if @xmath134 transmitted every time it would have average utility at most @xmath135 ( since @xmath136 ) , while if it never transmitted it would have average utility @xmath42 .
thus its average utility is at least @xmath137 .
since it can succeed only an @xmath99 fraction of the time ( when link @xmath74 is not transmitting ) , we have that @xmath138 and thus @xmath139 .
since the utility of @xmath134 is at least @xmath137 , it holds that the fraction of times at which both @xmath131 and @xmath134 are transmitting is at most @xmath140 . now consider link @xmath141 .
if links @xmath129 and @xmath132 both transmit , then @xmath141 will fail since the received sinr will be at most @xmath142 . on the other hand ,
as long as link @xmath132 does not transmit then @xmath141 will be successful , as it will have sinr at least @xmath143 . thus by transmitting at every time step
@xmath141 would have average utility at least @xmath144 ( since @xmath145 ) , and thus we know that @xmath141 gets average utility of at least @xmath146 , and thus successfully transmits at least @xmath146 fraction of the times .
@xmath147 is the same by symmetry .
thus the total value of any history in which all links have regret at most @xmath99 is at least @xmath148 .
let us now analyze what happens when using interference cancellation and bound @xmath149 .
suppose each link has at most @xmath99-regret , and for link @xmath71 let @xmath150 denote the fraction of times at which @xmath25 attempted to transmit .
as before , @xmath129 can always successfully transmit and thus does so in at least @xmath151 fraction of times .
but now , by using interference cancellation it turns out that @xmath132 can also always succeed .
this is because @xmath152 can first decode the transmission from @xmath131 and cancel it , leaving a remaining sinr of at least @xmath153 .
thus @xmath132 will also transmit in at least @xmath151 fraction of times and hence so far @xmath154 . note that
since @xmath155 , it holds that @xmath156 can not cancel @xmath131 or @xmath134 before decoding @xmath157 ( i.e. , @xmath158 ) .
hence , cancellation is useless .
but now at @xmath156 the strength of @xmath131 is @xmath159 , the strength of @xmath134 is @xmath160 , and the strength of @xmath157 is @xmath161 .
thus @xmath156 can not decode any messages when @xmath162 , and @xmath157 are all transmitting since its sinr is at most @xmath163 , which implies that @xmath141 can only succeed on at most @xmath140 fraction of times .
the link @xmath147 is the same as the link @xmath141 by symmetry .
thus the total value of any history in which all links have an @xmath99-regret is at most @xmath164 . thus @xmath165 as required .
it turns out that no - regret behavior with interference cancellation can not be much worse than no - regret behavior without interference cancellation as in braess s paradox , it can only be worse by a constant factor .
[ thm : nash_ic_upper ] @xmath166 for any set of links @xmath35 and some constant @xmath167 .
consider an @xmath99-regret history without ic that maximizes the average number of successful links , i.e. one that achieves @xmath108 value .
let @xmath126 denote the fraction of times at which @xmath25 attempted to transmit in this history , so @xmath168 by lemma [ lem : attempts ] .
similarly , let @xmath150 denote that fraction of times at which @xmath25 attempted to transmit in an @xmath99-regret history _ with _
ic that achieves value of only @xmath169 , and so @xmath170 .
note that since the best average number of successful connections in the non - ic case is @xmath108 , there must exist some set of connections @xmath171 such that @xmath172 and @xmath173 is feasible without ic .
let @xmath174 and let @xmath175 . if @xmath176 then we are done , since then @xmath177 as required . so without loss of generality we will assume that @xmath178 , and thus that @xmath179 .
note that @xmath180 is a subset of @xmath173 , and so it is feasible in the non - ic setting .
now let @xmath181 be an amenable subset of @xmath180 .
by fact [ fc : amenable](a ) , it holds that @xmath182 .
fact [ fc : amenable](b ) then implies that for any link @xmath183 , its total affectance on @xmath173 is small : @xmath184 for some constant @xmath185 .
thus we have that @xmath186 on the other hand , we know that the @xmath150 values correspond to the worst history in which every link has regret at most @xmath99 ( in the ic setting ) .
let @xmath187 .
then @xmath188 , which means the average utility of link @xmath44 is at most @xmath189 .
let @xmath190 be the fraction of time @xmath31 would have succeeded had it transmitted in every round . since the average utility of the best single action is at most @xmath191 it holds that @xmath192 or the that @xmath193 . in other words , in at least @xmath194 fraction of the rounds the affectance of the other links on the link @xmath44 must be at least @xmath74 ( or else @xmath195 could succeed in those rounds even without using ic ) .
thus the expected affectance ( taken over a random choice of time slot ) on @xmath44 is at least @xmath196 .
summing over all @xmath197 , we get that @xmath198 combining equations ( [ eq : ic1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ic2 ] ) ( and switching the order of summations ) implies that @xmath199 . since @xmath200 , we get that @xmath201 as desired . as a simple corollary , we will show that this lets us bound the price of total anarchy in the interference cancellation model ( which , as far as we know , has not previously been bounded ) .
let @xmath202 denote some optimal solution without ic , i.e. , the set of transmitters forming a maximum @xmath3-feasible set , and let @xmath203 denote some optimal solution with ic .
[ cor : nash_ic_approx ] for every set of links @xmath35 it holds that the price of total anarchy with ic is @xmath6 , or @xmath204 .
in the power control setting , each transmitter @xmath19 either broadcasts at power @xmath42 or broadcasts at some arbitrary integral power level @xmath205 $ ] .
our main claim is that braess s paradox is once again possible : there are networks in which adding power control can create worse equilibria . for illustration of such a network ,
[ fig : nash_all](b ) .
we first observe the following relation between no - regret solutions with or without power control .
[ obs : nash_pc_contain ] every no - regret solution in the uniform setting , is also a no - regret solution in the pc setting .
hence , we can not expect the best no - regret solution in the pc setting to be smaller than the worst no - regret solution in the uniform setting . yet
, the paradox still holds .
[ thm : pmax_nash_lb ] there exists a configuration of links @xmath35 satisfying @xmath206 for some constant @xmath207 .
we now prove that ( as with ic ) that the paradox can not be too bad : adding power control can not cost us more than a constant .
the proof is very similar to that of thm .
[ thm : nash_ic_upper ] up to some minor yet crucial modifications .
[ thm : nash_pc_upper ] @xmath208 for any set of links @xmath35 and some constant @xmath167 .
[ cor : pmax_price ] the price of total anarchy under the power control setting with maximum transmission energy @xmath2 is @xmath209 .
in this section we consider games in the power control with ic setting where _ transmitters _ can adopt their transmission energy in the range of @xmath210 $ ] and in addition , _ receivers _ can employ interference cancelation .
this setting is denote as @xmath211 ( power control+ic ) .
we show that braess s paradox can once again happen and begin by comparing the pic setting to the setting of power control without ic and to the most basic setting of uniform powers .
[ lemma : pic_pcunilower ] there exists a set of links @xmath35 and constant @xmath207 such that + ( a ) @xmath212 .
+ ( b ) @xmath213 .
+ moreover , we proceed by showing that pic can hurt the network by more than a constant when comparing pic equilibria to ic equilibria . for an illustration of such a network ,
[ fig : nash_all](c ) .
[ theorem : ic_pc_lower ] there exists a set of links @xmath35 and constant @xmath207 such that the best pure nash solution with pic is worse by a factor of @xmath4 than the worst no - regret solution with ic .
there exists a set of links @xmath35 satisfying that @xmath214 . as in the previous sections ,
we show that our examples are essentially tight .
[ lem : nash_ic_pc_upper ] for every set of links @xmath35 it holds that there exists a constant @xmath215 such that + ( a ) @xmath216 .
+ ( b ) @xmath217 .
+ ( c ) @xmath218 . finally , as a direct consequences of our result , we obtain a tight bound for the price of total anarchy in the pic setting .
[ cor : pic_price ] for every set of links @xmath35 it holds that the price of total anarchy with pic is @xmath219 .
we begin by showing that in certain cases the ability to successfully decode a message at a lower sinr threshold results in _ every _ no - regret solution having lower value than _ any _ no - regret solution at higher @xmath3 . for an illustration of such a network ,
[ fig : nash_all](d ) .
[ thm : beta_nash_lb ] there exists a set of links @xmath35 and constants @xmath13 such that @xmath220 for some constant @xmath207 .
we now show that the gap between the values of no - regret solution for different sinr threshold values is bounded by a constant .
[ lem : beta_nash_lb ] for every @xmath221 and every set of links @xmath35 satisfying that @xmath222 for every @xmath62 , it holds that @xmath223 for some constant @xmath215 .
in this paper we have shown that braess s paradox can strike in wireless networks in the sinr model : improving technology can result in worse performance , where we measured performance by the average number of successful connections .
we considered adding power control , interference cancellation , both power control and interference cancellation , and decreasing the sinr threshold , and in all of them showed that game - theoretic equilibria can get worse with improved technology .
however , in all cases we bounded the damage that could be done .
there are several remaining interesting open problems .
first , what other examples of wireless technology exhibit the paradox ?
second , even just considering the technologies in this paper , it would be interesting to get a better understanding of when exactly the paradox occurs .
can we characterize the network topologies that are susceptible ?
is it most topologies , or is it rare ?
what about random wireless networks ? finally ,
while our results are tight up to constants , it would be interesting to actually find tight constants so we know precisely how bad the paradox can be . | when comparing new wireless technologies , it is common to consider the effect that they have on the capacity of the network ( defined as the maximum number of simultaneously satisfiable links ) .
for example , it has been shown that giving receivers the ability to do interference cancellation , or allowing transmitters to use power control , never decreases the capacity and can in certain cases increase it by @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the ratio of the longest link length to the smallest transmitter - receiver distance and @xmath2 is the maximum transmission power .
but there is no reason to expect the optimal capacity to be realized in practice , particularly since maximizing the capacity is known to be np - hard . in reality , we would expect links to behave as self - interested agents , and thus when introducing a new technology it makes more sense to compare the values reached at game - theoretic equilibria than the optimum values . in this paper
we initiate this line of work by comparing various notions of equilibria ( particularly nash equilibria and no - regret behavior ) when using a supposedly better " technology .
we show a version of braess s paradox for all of them : in certain networks , upgrading technology can actually make the equilibria _ worse _ , despite an increase in the capacity .
we construct instances where this decrease is a constant factor for power control , interference cancellation , and improvements in the sinr threshold ( @xmath3 ) , and is @xmath4 when power control is combined with interference cancellation .
however , we show that these examples are basically tight : the decrease is at most @xmath5 for power control , interference cancellation , and improved @xmath3 , and is at most @xmath6 when power control is combined with interference cancellation . |
it was noted many years ago that the form of the @xmath8-meson peak is distorted by the interference between resonant and non - resonant @xmath0 production . for the case of `` elastic '' @xmath1 photoproduction
the effect was studied by p.sding in @xcite and s.drell @xcite ( who considered the possibility to produce the pion beam via the @xmath9 process ) . at high energies
the main ( and the only ) source of background is the drell - hiida - deck process @xcite ( see fig .
the incoming photon fluctuates into the pion pair and then @xmath10-elastic scattering takes place .
thus the amplitude for the background may be written in terms of the pion - proton cross section .
recently the difractive elastic production of @xmath1-mesons was measured at hera @xcite both for the cases of photoproduction i.e. @xmath11 and of @xmath12 gev@xmath13 ( the so called deep inelastic scattering , dis , regime ) .
it was demonstrated @xcite that the interference with some non - resonant background is indeed needed to describe the distribution over the mass - @xmath14 of @xmath0 pair . in this paper
we present the results of calculation of @xmath15 with correction the numerical error published in fig.6 of @xcite . in sect .
2 the formulae for the @xmath5 background which are valid for the dis region are presented .
the expression differs slightly from the sding s one as we take into account the pion form factor and the fact that one pion propagator is off - mass shell .
we consider also the absorbtion correction comming from the diagram where both pions ( @xmath16 and @xmath17 ) directly interact with the target proton . in sect .
3 we compute the ratio @xmath15 for a pion pair production in dis . at large @xmath18 gev@xmath13
the background amplitude becomes relatively small , but still not negligible .
it changes the ratio of the longitudinal to transverse @xmath8-meson production cross section and leads to the decreasing of @xmath15 value with @xmath19 .
the cross section of @xmath1 photo- and electroproduction may be written as : @xmath20 are the resonant and non - resonant parts of the production amplitude , @xmath21 for longitudinal and transverse photons , @xmath22 -*q*@xmath23 is the momentum transfered to the proton and @xmath24 , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the azimutal and polar angles between the @xmath16 and the proton direction in the @xmath5 rest frame .
the dynamics of vector meson photo- and electroproduction was discussed in the framework of qcd in many papers ( see , e.g. [ 9 - 12 ] ) . however here
we will use the simple phenomenological parametrization of the production amplitude because our main aim is the discussion of the interference between resonant and non - resonant contributions .
so the amplitude for resonant process @xmath27 ; @xmath28 reads : @xmath29 to take into account the phase space available for the @xmath30 decay we use the width @xmath31 ( with @xmath32 mev and @xmath33 mev its mass ) ; @xmath34 is the @xmath35-slope of the `` elastic '' @xmath8 production cross section @xmath36 ( at @xmath37 ) and the functions @xmath38 describe the angular distribution of the pions produced through the @xmath8-meson decay : @xmath39 @xmath40 note that for transverse photons with polarization vector @xmath41 one has to replace the last factor @xmath42 in eq .
( 4 ) by the scalar product @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the unit vector in the pion transverse momentum direction .
the amplitude for the non - resonant process @xmath45 is : @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the @xmath35-slope of the elastic @xmath10 cross section , @xmath48 is the pion electromagnetic form factor ( @xmath49 is the virtuality of the incoming photon ) , @xmath50 is the electromagnetic coupling constant and @xmath51 the photon momentum fraction carried by the @xmath17 -meson ; @xmath52 is the total pion - proton cross section .
the factor @xmath53 is equal to @xmath54 for longitudinal photons the products @xmath55 are : @xmath56 and @xmath57 , while for the transverse photons we may put ( after averaging ) @xmath58 .
expressions ( 5 ) and ( 6 ) are the result of straitforward calculation of the feynman diagram fig .
the first term in ( 6 ) comes from the graph fig . 1 ( in which the pomeron couples to the @xmath16 ) and the second one reflects the contribution originated by the @xmath59 interaction .
the negative sign of @xmath17 electric charge leads to the minus sign of the second term .
we omit here the phases of the amplitudes .
in fact , the common phase is inessential for the cross section , and we assume that the relative phase between @xmath60 and @xmath61 is small ( equal to zero ) as in both cases the phase is generated by the same pomeron exchange .
the form factor @xmath62 is written to account for the virtuality ( @xmath63 ) of the t - channel ( vertical in fig .
1 ) pion . as in fig .
1 we do not deal with pure elastic pion - proton scattering , the amplitude may be slightly suppressed by the fact that the incoming pion is off - mass shell . to estimate this suppression we include the form factor ( chosen in the pole form ) @xmath64 the same pole form was used for @xmath65 . in the last case
the parameter @xmath66 is the mass of the @xmath8-meson the first resonance on the @xmath8-meson ( i.e. photon ) regge trajectory , but the value of @xmath67 ( in @xmath62 ) is expected to be larger .
it should be of the order of mass of the next resonance from the regge @xmath68-meson trajectory ; i.e. it should be the mass of @xmath69 or @xmath70 .
thus we put @xmath71 gev@xmath13 .
finaly we have to define @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
@xmath74 and @xmath75 in these notations @xmath76 and @xmath77 with the pion transverse ( with respect to the proton direction ) momentum @xmath78 ( in the @xmath5 rest frame ) given by expression @xmath79 .
note that the positive values of @xmath80 correspond to @xmath81 while the negative ones @xmath82 correspond to @xmath83 . to account for the screening correction we have to consider the diagram fig .
2 , where both pions interact directly with the target . note that all the rescatterings of one pion ( say @xmath16 in fig
. 1 ) are already included into the @xmath10 elastic amplitude .
the result may be written in form of eq .
( 5 ) with the new factor @xmath84 instead of the old one @xmath85 : @xmath86 where the second term is the absorptive correction ( fig .
2 ) and @xmath87 is the momentum transfered along the pomeron loop .
the factor @xmath88 reflects the contribution of the enhacement graphs with the diffractive exitation of the target proton in intermediate state . in accordance with the hera data @xcite , where the cross section of `` inelastic '' ( i.e. with the proton diffracted ) @xmath8 photoproduction was estimated as @xmath89 we choose @xmath90 .
at very large @xmath2 the background amplitude ( 5 ) becomes negligible as , even without the additional form factor ( i.e. at @xmath91 ) , the non - resonance cross section falls down as @xmath92 , one factor @xmath93 comes from the electromagnetic form factor @xmath94 and another one from the pion propagator ( term - @xmath95 in the denominator of @xmath53 ( see eq.(6 ) ) . ] while experimentally @xcite the @xmath2 behaviour of the elastic @xmath8 cross sections has been found to be @xmath96 , with @xmath97 .
nevertheless , numerically at @xmath98 the background as well as interference contributions are still important .
the background as well as interference contributions lead to the nontrivial behaviour of the ratio @xmath15 with the two pion mass @xmath99 . in the theoretical formulae which we used the index @xmath100 denotes the polarization of the incoming photon . on the other hand experimentally one measures the @xmath8-meson polarization , fitting the angular distribution of decay pions . to reproduce the procedure
we take the flows of initial longitudinal and transverse photons to be equal to each other ( @xmath101 , which is close to hera case ) and reanalyse the sum of cross sections ( @xmath102 ) in a usual way , selecting the constant and the @xmath103 parts .
@xmath104 in these terms the density matrix element @xmath105 and @xmath106 namely these last ratios ( 12 ) are presented in fig . 3 for different @xmath2 values . presented in fig .
6 of our previous paper @xcite were wrong due to a misprint in the code .
] we have to recall , that the ratio @xmath107 given by the last expression of eq .
( 12 ) strictly speaking is not identical to the ratio of the longitudinal to transverse photon cross sections @xmath4 . due to the form factor @xmath62 the background pion angular distribution ( corresponding to the non - resonant amplitude ( 5 ) , ( 6 ) ) are more complicated than the trivial @xmath108 ( for @xmath109 ) and @xmath110 ( for @xmath111 ) .
for example , even in the case of the transverse photon polarization vector ( i.e. @xmath109 ) at very large @xmath2 the non - resonant contribution @xmath112 reveals the peaks in the forward and backward ( @xmath113 ) directions instead of a pure @xmath114 behaviour . that is why in fig .
3 we present not the theoretical @xmath4 ratio , but the values of @xmath115 which are more close to the ratios measured experimentally .
one can see that they depend both on @xmath2 and @xmath14 .
note that for the resonant amplitude @xmath60 in fig .
3 we have fixed @xmath116 independently on the mass @xmath14 and @xmath2 . on the other hand for the non - resonant production ( @xmath112 ) , neglecting for simplicity the form factor ( i.e. @xmath117 ) and the absorptive corrections , one has @xmath118 . at large @xmath119 10 gev@xmath13 it gives @xmath120 .
at last we have to take into account the interference , which is positive ( constructive ) at small @xmath121 and destructive at @xmath122 .
thus the final curves 3 and 4 fall down with @xmath14 giving @xmath123 at @xmath124 gev and @xmath125 at @xmath126 gev .
of course at very large @xmath2 the background amplitude dies out but simultaneously the value of @xmath127 increases with @xmath2 . therefore the curves 3 and 4 ( which correspondent to @xmath2 = 10 gev@xmath13 and 30 gev@xmath13 ) are rather close to each other . in the region of not too large @xmath128 gev@xmath13
the non - resonant amplitude is compartible with the resonant one at @xmath129 gev . in particular , for @xmath130 gev@xmath13 ( curve 1 ) the destructive interference at @xmath131 gev cancel the main part of the transverse cross section , leading to a very large value of @xmath107 ( @xmath132 ) .
this effect depends on the @xmath2 value .
say , the maximum of the peak of @xmath107 is at @xmath133 0.03 gev@xmath13 for @xmath14 = 1.15 gev and at @xmath133 0.3 gev@xmath13 for @xmath14 = 1.25 gev
. however one must not take the presented predictions in fig .
3 too seriously for large @xmath14 .
the interference with the next ( heavier ) resonances ( say , @xmath134 ) was not taken into account in fig . 3 but at @xmath135 gev their contribution can be significant that can change the results .
we presented the results of @xmath15 ratio calculations for @xmath8-meson electroproduction with accounting for the background to elastic mechanism .
the role of @xmath8-meson background interference decreases with @xmath2 however it is not negligible even at @xmath136 gev@xmath13 . fig .
3 . the ratio @xmath15 in electroproduction process as a function of pion pair mass at @xmath137 1 gev@xmath13 ( curve 1 ) , 4 gev@xmath13 ( curve 2 ) , 10 gev@xmath13 ( curve 3 ) and 30 gev@xmath13 ( curves 4 ) with ( solid curve ) and without ( dashed curve ) form factor . 99 sding .
( 1966 ) 702 .
lett . 5 ( 1967 ) 278 .
( 1964 ) 169 .
m.derrick et al .
( zeus coll . )
c69 ( 1995 ) 39 .
m.derrick et al .
( zeus coll . )
b356 ( 1995 ) 601 .
s.aid et al .
( h1 coll . )
b463 ( 1996 ) 3 .
s.aid et al .
( h1 coll . )
b468 ( 1996 ) 3 .
m.g.ryskin and yu.m.shabelski .
hep - ph/9701407 .
s.j.brodsky et al .
d50 ( 1994)3134 .
b.z.kopeliovich , j.nemchick and n.n.nikolaev .
b324 ( 1994 ) 177 .
a.donnachie and p.v.landshoff .
b348 ( 1995 ) 213 .
a.d.martin , m.g.ryskin and t.teubner .
preprint dtp/96/64 ; hep - ph/9609448 .
s.aid et al .
( h1 coll . )
c69 ( 1995 ) 27 . | the background due to the direct diffractive dissociation of the photon into the @xmath0-pair to the `` elastic '' diffractive @xmath1-meson production in electron - proton collisions is calculated . at large @xmath2 the interference between resonant and non - resonant
@xmath3 production changes the @xmath4 ratio with the mass of the @xmath5 ( i.e. @xmath1-meson ) state .
1.5 truecm @xmath6 * in the * @xmath1 * -meson diffractive electroproproduction . *
+ m.g.ryskin and yu.m.shabelski + petersburg nuclear physics institute , + gatchina , st.petersburg 188350 russia + e - mail : @xmath7 [email protected] + e - mail : @xmath7 [email protected] + |
it is well known that the tsallis entropy and fisher information entropy ( matrix ) are very important quantities expressing information measures in nonextensive systems .
the tsallis entropy for @xmath0-unit nonextensive system is defined by @xcite-@xcite @xmath1 with @xmath2^q \:\pi_i d x_i , \label{eq : a2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath3 is the entropic index ( @xmath4 ) , and @xmath5 denotes the probability distribution of @xmath0 variables @xmath6 . in the limit of @xmath7 , the tsallis entropy reduces to the boltzman - gibbs - shannon entropy given by @xmath8 the boltzman - gibbs - shannon entropy is extensive in the sense that for a system consisting @xmath0 independent but equivalent subsystems , the total entropy is a sum of constituent subsystems : @xmath9 .
in contrast , the tsallis entropy is nonextensive : @xmath10 for @xmath11 , and @xmath12 expresses the degree of the nonextensivity of a given system .
the tsallis entropy is a basis of the nonextensive statistical mechanics , which has been successfully applied to a wide class of systems including physics , chemistry , mathematics , biology , and others @xcite .
the fisher information matrix provides us with an important measure on information .
its inverse expresses the lower bound of decoding errors for unbiased estimator in the cramr - rao inequality .
it denotes also the distance between the neighboring points in the rieman space spanned by probability distributions in the information geometry .
the fisher information matrix expresses a local measure of positive amount of information whereas the boltzman - gibbs - shannon - tsallis entropy represents a global measure of ignorance @xcite . in recent years , many authors have investigated the fisher information in nonextensive systems @xcite-@xcite . in a previous paper @xcite ,
we have pointed out that two types of _ generalized _ and _ extended _ fisher information matrices are necessary for nonextensive systems @xcite .
the generalized fisher information matrix @xmath13 obtained from the generalized kullback - leibler divergence in conformity with the tsallis entropy , is expressed by @xmath14 , \label{eq : a4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath15 $ ] denotes the average over @xmath5 [ @xmath16 characterized by a set of parameters @xmath17 . on the contrary , the extended fisher information matrix @xmath18 derived from the cramr - rao inequality in nonextensive systems , is expressed by @xcite @xmath19 , \label{eq : a5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath20 $ ] expresses the average over the escort probability @xmath21 given by @xmath22^q}{c_q^{(n)}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath23 being given by eq .
( [ eq : a2 ] ) . in the limit of @xmath24 , both the generalized and extended fisher information matrices reduce to the conventional fisher information matrix .
studies on the information entropies have been made mainly for independent ( uncorrelated ) systems .
effects of correlated noise and inputs on the fisher information matrix and shannon s mutual information have been extensively studied in neuronal ensembles ( for a recent review , see ref .
@xcite ; related references therein ) .
it is a fundamental problem in neuroscience to determine whether correlations in neural activity are important for decoding , and what is the impact of correlations on information transmission .
when neurons fire independently , the fisher information increases proportionally to the population size . in ensembles with the limited - range correlations ,
however , the fisher information is shown to saturate as a function of population size @xcite-@xcite . in recent years
the interplay between fluctuations and correlations in nonextensive systems has been investigated @xcite-@xcite .
it has been demonstrated that in some globally correlated systems , the tsallis entropy becomes extensive while the boltzman - gibbs - shannon entropy is nonextensive @xcite .
thus the correlation plays important roles in discussing the properties of information entropies in nonextensive systems .
it is the purpose of the present paper to study effects of the spatially - correlated variability on the tsallis entropy and fisher information in nonextensive systems . in sec .
2 , we will discuss information entropies of correlated nonextensive systems , by using the probability distributions derived by the maximum entropy method ( mem ) . in sec . 3
, we discuss the marginal distribution to study the properties of probability distributions obtained by the mem .
previous related studies are critically discussed also . the final sec .
4 is devoted to our conclusion . in appendix a , results of the mem for uncorrelated , nonextensive systems are briefly summarized @xcite .
we consider correlated @xmath0-unit nonextensive systems , for which the probability distribution is derived with the use of the mem under the constraints given by @xmath26 , \label{eq : c22}\\ \sigma^2 & = & \frac{1}{n } \sum_i e_q\left[(x_i-\mu)^2 \right ] , \label{eq : c23 } \\
s \:\sigma^2 & = & \frac{1}{n(n-1)}\sum_i \sum_{j ( \neq i ) } e_q\left[(x_i-\mu)(x_j-\mu ) \right ] , \label{eq : c24}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 expressing the mean , variance , and degree of the correlated variability , respectively .
cases with @xmath25 and arbitrary @xmath0 will be separately discussed in secs .
2.1 and 2.2 , respectively . for a given correlated nonextensive system with @xmath25 , the mem with constraints given by eqs .
( [ eq : c21])-([eq : c24 ] ) yields ( details being explained in appendix b ) @xmath30 , \label{eq : c5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath31 where @xmath32 denotes the beta function and @xmath33 expresses the @xmath3-exponential function defined by @xmath34^{1/(1-q)}. \label{eq : c13}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath35 with elements @xmath36 is expressed by the inverse of the covariant matrix @xmath37 given by @xmath38 with @xmath39 .
\hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ i , j=1,2 $ } \label{eq : d2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit of @xmath24 , the distribution @xmath40 reduces to @xmath41 , \label{eq : d3 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is nothing but the gaussian distribution for @xmath25 .
we have calculated information entropies , by using the distribution given by eq .
( [ eq : c5 ] ) . * tsallis entropy * we obtain @xmath42+\log(r_q^{(2 ) } ) , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ q=1 $ } \\ & = & \frac{1-c_q^{(2)}}{q-1 } , \hspace{4cm}\mbox{for $ q \neq 1 $ } \label{eq : d6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath43 where @xmath44 is given by eq .
( [ eq : c9])-([eq : c11 ] ) . from @xmath45 given by eq .
( [ eq : c8 ] ) , we may obtain the @xmath29 dependence of @xmath46 as given by @xmath47 , \hspace{2cm}\mbox{for $ \mid s \mid \ll 1 $ } \label{eq : d9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which yields @xmath48 figure [ figh](a ) shows @xmath49 as a function of the correlation @xmath29 for @xmath25 ( values of @xmath50 and @xmath51 are hereafter adopted in model calculations shown in figs .
[ figh]-[fige ] ) .
we note that tsallis entropy is decreased with increasing absolute value of @xmath29 independently of its sign .
* fisher information * by using eqs . ( [ eq : a4 ] ) and ( [ eq : a5 ] ) for @xmath52 , we obtain the fisher information matrices given by @xmath53 which show that @xmath54 is independent of @xmath3 and that the inverses of both matrices are proportional to @xmath55 .
figure [ figj ] shows the @xmath29 dependence of the extended fisher information for @xmath25 , whose inverse is increased ( decreased ) for a positive ( negative ) @xmath29 , depending on a sign of @xmath29 in contrast to @xmath56 .
it is possible to extend our approach to the case of arbitrary @xmath0 , for which the mem with the constraints given by eqs .
( [ eq : c21])-([eq : c24 ] ) lead to the distribution given by ( details being given in appendix b ) @xmath57 , \label{eq : f1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath58}{\nu_q^{(n)}\sigma^2(1-s)[1+(n-1)s ] } , \\ b & = & - \:\frac{s}{\nu_q^{(n)}\sigma^2(1-s)[1+(n-1)s ] } ,
\\ z_q^{(n ) } & = & \frac{(2 \nu_q^{(n ) } \sigma^2)^{n/2 } \ : r_q^{(n ) } } { ( q-1)^{n/2}}\;\ ; \pi_{i=1}^n \:b\left(\frac{1}{2 } , \frac{1}{q-1}-\frac{i}{2 } \right ) , \hspace{1 cm } \mbox{for $ 1 < q < 3$}\\ & = & ( 2 \pi \sigma^2)^{n/2 } \ : r_q^{(n ) } , \hspace{6 cm } \mbox{for $ q=1 $ } \\ & = & \frac{(2 \nu_q^{(n ) } \sigma^2)^{n/2 } \ : r_q^{(n ) } } { ( 1-q)^{n/2}}\;\ ; \pi_{i=1}^n \:b\left(\frac{1}{2 } , \frac{1}{1-q}+\frac{(i+1)}{2 } \right ) , \hspace{0.5 cm } \mbox{for $ 0 < q < 1 $ } \\ r_q^{(n ) } & = & \ : \{(1-s)^{n-1}[1+(n-1)s ] \}^{1/2 } , \label{eq : f3 } \\
\nu_q^{(n ) } & = & \frac{[(n+2)-nq]}{2}. \label{eq : f4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath35 is expressed by the inverse of the covariant matrix @xmath37 whose elements are given by @xmath59 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit of @xmath24 , the distribution given by eq .
( [ eq : f1 ] ) becomes the multivariate gaussian distribution given by @xmath60.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is necessary to note that there is the condition for a physically conceivable @xmath29 value given by [ see eq .
( [ eq : z6 ] ) , details being discussed in appendix c ] @xmath61 where the lower and upper critical @xmath29 values are given by @xmath62 and @xmath63 , respectively . in the case of @xmath25 and @xmath64 , for example , we obtain @xmath65 and @xmath66 , respectively . by using the probability distribution given by eq .
( [ eq : f1 ] ) , we have calculated information entropies whose @xmath29 dependences are given as follows .
* tsallis entropy * we obtain @xmath67+\log(r_q^{(n ) } ) , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ q=1 $ } \\ & = & \frac{1-c_q^{(n)}}{q-1 } , \hspace{4cm}\mbox{for $ q \neq 1 $ } \label{eq : f5b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath68 , \hspace{0.5cm}\mbox{for $ \mid s \mid \ll 2/\sqrt{n(n-1 ) } $ } \label{eq : f5c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath29 dependence of @xmath23 arises from a factor of @xmath69 in eq .
( [ eq : f3 ] ) , and @xmath70 expresses the @xmath71 value of @xmath23 .
equation ( [ eq : f5 ] ) yields the @xmath29 dependent @xmath72 given by @xmath73 s^2 , \hspace{0.5cm}\mbox{for $ \mid s \mid \ll 2/\sqrt{n(n-1 ) } $ } \label{eq : f6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath74 stands for the tsallis entropy for @xmath71 .
the region where eqs .
( [ eq : f5c ] ) and ( [ eq : f6 ] ) hold becomes narrower for larger @xmath0 .
the @xmath29 dependence of @xmath49 for @xmath64 is shown in fig . [
figh](b ) , where @xmath49 has a peak at @xmath71 and it is decreased with increasing @xmath75 . comparing fig .
[ figh](b ) with fig .
[ figh](a ) , we notice that @xmath29-dependence of @xmath49 for @xmath64 is more significant than that for @xmath25 [ eq .
( [ eq : f6 ] ) ] .
circles in figs . [ figf](a ) and [ figf](b ) show @xmath49 with @xmath71 for @xmath76 and @xmath77 , respectively , which are calculated with the use of the expressions given by eqs .
( [ eq : f5b ] ) and ( [ eq : f5 ] ) .
they are in good agreement with dashed curves showing exact results which are given by eq .
( [ eq : b5 ] ) and shown in figs .
[ fige](a ) and [ fige](b ) in appendix a. squares show @xmath49 with @xmath78 calculated by using eqs .
( [ eq : f5b ] ) and ( [ eq : f5 ] ) .
the tsallis entropy is decreased by an introduced correlation . because of a computational difficulty @xcite , calculations using eqs .
( [ eq : f5b ] ) and ( [ eq : f5 ] ) can not be performed for larger @xmath0 than those shown in figs . [ figf](a ) and [ figf](b ) . * fisher information
* the generalized and extended fisher information matrices are given by @xmath79 } , \label{eq : f10 } \\
\tilde{g}_q^{(n ) } & = & \frac{nq(q+1 ) } { \sigma^2(3-q)(2q-1 ) [ 1+(n-1 ) s]}. \label{eq : f11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the results for @xmath24 given by eqs . ( [ eq : f10 ] ) and ( [ eq : f11 ] ) are consistent with those derived with the use of the multivariate gaussian distribution @xcite . by using the fisher information matrices for @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 , given by eqs . ( [ eq : b9a ] ) and ( [ eq : b10a ] ) , we obtain @xmath83 which holds independently of @xmath3 .
inverses of the fisher information matrices approach the value of @xmath29 for @xmath84 , and are proportional to @xmath85 for @xmath71 .
in particular , they vanish at @xmath86 .
these features are clearly seen in fig .
[ figd ] where the inverses of fisher information matrices , @xmath87 and @xmath88 , are plotted as a function of @xmath0 for various @xmath29 values .
in the present study , we have obtained the probability distributions , applying the mem to spatially - correlated nonextensive systems .
we will examine our probability distributions in more detail .
the @xmath89 dependences of @xmath90 for @xmath25 given by eq .
( [ eq : c5 ] ) with @xmath71 and @xmath78 are plotted in figs . [ figc](a ) and [ figc](b ) , respectively , where @xmath91 is treated as a parameter . when @xmath71 , the distribution is symmetric with respect of @xmath89 for all @xmath91 values .
when the correlated variability of @xmath78 is introduced , peak positions of the distribution appear at finite @xmath89 for @xmath92 and 1.0 . in the limit of @xmath71 ( _ i.e. _ no correlated variability ) , @xmath90 given by eq .
( [ eq : c5 ] ) becomes @xmath93^{1/(1-q ) } , \label{eq : g8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which does not agree with the exact result ( except for @xmath24 ) , as given by @xmath94^{1/(1-q ) } , \label{eq : g } \\ & \neq & p^{(2)}(x_1,x_2),\end{aligned}\ ] ] because of the properties of the @xmath3-exponential function defined by eq .
( [ eq : c13 ] ) : @xmath95 . by using the @xmath3-product @xmath96 defined by @xcite @xmath97^{1/(1-q ) } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we may obtain the expression given by @xmath98^{1/(1-q ) } , \label{eq : g16}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which coincides with @xmath40 given by eq .
( [ eq : g8 ] ) besides a difference between @xmath99 and @xmath100 . in order to study the properties of the probability distribution of @xmath40 in more details ,
we have calculated its marginal probability ( with @xmath71 ) given by @xmath101^{1/(1-q)+1/2}. \label{eq : g4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] dashed curves in figs . [ figb](a ) and [ figb](b ) show @xmath102 in linear and logarithmic scales , respectively .
the marginal distributions are in good agreement with solid curves showing @xmath103 [ eq .
( [ eq : x4 ] ) ] , @xmath104^{1/(1-q)}. \label{eq : g7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case of @xmath105 , the distribution given by eq .
( [ eq : f1 ] ) yields its marginal distribution ( with @xmath71 ) given by @xmath106^{1/(1-q)+1}. \label{eq : g6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] chain curves in figs . [
figb](a ) and [ figb](b ) represent @xmath107 , which is again in good agreement with solid curves showing @xmath103 .
these results justify , to some extent , the probability distribution adopted in our calculation . the marginal distribution for an arbitrary @xmath0 ( with @xmath71 ) is given by @xmath108^{1/(1-q)+(n-1)/2 } , \\
& \propto & \left [ 1- \frac{(1-q_n ) x_1 ^ 2 } { 2 \nu_n \sigma^2 } \right]^{1/(1-q_n ) } , \label{eq : g11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath109 equations ( [ eq : g11])-([eq : g13 ] ) show that in the limit of @xmath84 , we obtain @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath112 reduces to the gaussian distribution .
one of typical microscopic nonextensive systems is the langevin model subjected to multiplicative noise , as given by @xcite-@xcite @xmath113 here @xmath114 expresses the relaxation rate , @xmath115 denotes a function of an external input @xmath116 , and @xmath117 and @xmath118 stand for magnitudes of multiplicative and additive noise , respectively , with zero - mean white noise given by @xmath119 and @xmath120 with the correlated variability , @xmath121 \delta(t - t'),\\ \langle \xi_i(t)\:\xi_j(t ' ) \rangle & = & \beta^2 [ \delta_{ij } + c_a(1-\delta_{ij})]\delta(t - t'),\\ \langle \eta_i(t)\:\xi_j(t ' ) \rangle & = & 0 , \label{eq : h1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath122 and @xmath123 express the degrees of correlated variabilities of additive and multiplicative noise , respectively .
the fokker - planck equation ( fpe ) for the probability distribution @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) is given by @xmath126 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{\beta^2}{2}\sum_{i}\sum_{j } [ \delta_{ij } + c_a ( 1-\delta_{ij } ) ] \frac{\partial^2}{\partial x_{i } \partial x_{j } } \:p \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{\alpha^2}{2}\sum_{i } \sum_j [ \delta_{ij}+ c_m ( 1-\delta_{ij } ) ] \frac{\partial}{\partial x_{i } } x_i \frac{\partial}{\partial x_j } ( x_j \:p ) , \label{eq : h0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the stratonovich representation .
for additive noise only ( @xmath127 ) , the stationary distribution is given by @xmath128,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath129 denotes the average of @xmath130 , and @xmath37 expresses the covariance matrix given by @xmath131.\end{aligned}\ ] ] when multiplicative noise exists @xmath132 , the calculation of even stationary distribution becomes difficult , and it is generally not given by the gaussian .
indeed , the stationary distribution for non - correlated multiplicative noise with @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 is given by @xcite@xcite-@xcite @xmath136^{1/(1-q ) } \:e^{y(x_i ) } , \label{eq : h3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath137 the probability distribution given by eq .
( [ eq : h3 ] ) for @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) agrees with that derived by the mem for @xmath140 [ eq .
( [ eq : x4 ] ) ] . for @xmath133 , @xmath141 and @xmath142 ( @xmath139 ) , eq .
( [ eq : h3 ] ) becomes @xcite @xmath143 yielding the fisher information given by @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 is the heaviside function .
the probability distribution for correlated multiplicative noise ( @xmath133 , @xmath147 ) is also the non - gaussian , which is easily confirmed by direct simulations of the langevin model with @xmath25 @xcite . in some previous studies @xcite-@xcite , the stationary distribution of the langevin model subjected to correlated multiplicative noise with @xmath147 , @xmath141 and @xmath148
is assumed to be expressed by the gaussian distribution with the covariance matrix given by @xmath149 .
\label{eq : h2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is equivalent to assume that @xmath150 & \simeq & \frac{\partial}{\partial x_i } \left [ \langle x_i \rangle \frac{\partial } { \partial x_j } ( \langle x_j \rangle \:p ) \right ] , \nonumber \\
& = & \mu_i \mu_j \frac{\partial^2 p } { \partial x_i \partial x_j } , \label{eq : h3b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the fpe given by eq .
( [ eq : h0 ] ) with @xmath151 and @xmath152 . by using such an approximation , abbott and dayan ( ad )
@xcite calculated the fisher information matrix of a neuronal ensemble with the correlated variability , which is given by @xmath153 } + 2 n k , \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{n}{\sigma_m^2 \mu^2 [ 1+(n-1)c_m]}+ \frac{2n}{\mu^2 } , \label{eq : h4 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with a spurious second term ( @xmath154 ) , where @xmath155 ^ 2=1/\mu^2 $ ] [ eq .
( 4.7 ) of ref .
@xcite in our notation ] .
equation ( [ eq : h4 ] ) is not in agreement with either eq .
( [ eq : f10 ] ) or ( [ eq : f11 ] ) derived by the mem .
furthermore , the result of ad in the limit of @xmath156 , @xmath157 , does not agree with the exact result given by eq .
( [ eq : h7 ] ) for the langevin model .
this fact casts some doubt on the results of refs .
@xcite-@xcite based on the gaussian approximation given by eq .
( [ eq : h2 ] ) or @xmath158 , which has no physical or mathematical justification .
the fisher information matrix depends on a detailed structure of the probability distribution because it is expressed by the derivative of the distribution with respect to @xmath159 , as given by @xmath160 .
\label{eq : h5 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we must take into account the non - gaussian structure of the probability distribution in discussing the fisher information of nonextensive systems .
we have discussed effects of the spatially - correlated variability on the tsallis entropy and fisher information matrix in nonextensive systems , by using the probability distribution derived by the mem . although the obtained analytical distribution in the limit of @xmath71
does not hold the relation given by @xmath161 for @xmath11 , it numerically yields good results ( fig . [ figf ] ) , reducing to the multivariate gaussian distribution in the limit of @xmath24 .
our calculations have shown that \(i ) the tsallis entropy is decreased by both positive and negative correlations , and \(ii ) the inverses of the fisher information matrices are increased ( decrease ) by a positive ( negative ) correlation .
the difference between the @xmath29 dependences of @xmath56 and @xmath162 arises from the difference in their characteristics : @xmath56 provides us with a global measure of ignorance while @xmath162 a local measure of positive amount of information @xcite .
the item ( ii ) implies that the accuracy of unbiased estimate of fluctuation is improved by the negative correlation . if there is known , and strong , negative correlation between successive pairs of data , estimating the unknown parameter as their simple average must reduce the error , as negatively correlated errors tend to cancel in taking the difference . in connection with the discussion presented in sec .
3 , it is interesting to make a detailed study on the properties of information entropies in the langevin model subjected to correlated as well as uncorrelated multiplicative noise .
such a calculation is in progress and will be reported elsewhere @xcite .
this work is partly supported by a grant - in - aid for scientific research from the japanese ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology .
we summarize results of the mem for nonextensive systems @xcite . in order to apply the mem to @xmath0-unit nonextensive systems
, we impose the three constraints given by @xmath163 , \label{eq : c2}\\ \sigma^2 & = & \frac{1}{n } \sum_i e_q\left[(x_i-\mu)^2 \right ] , \label{eq : c3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath3-dependent @xmath27 and @xmath28 correspond to @xmath164 and @xmath165 , respectively , in @xcite . for a given nonextensive system , the variational condition for the tsallis entropy given by eq .
( [ eq : a1 ] ) with the constraints ( [ eq : c1])-([eq : c3 ] ) yields the @xmath3-gaussian distribution given by @xcite with @xmath167 , \label{eq : x4}\\ z_q^{(1 ) } & = & \int \exp_q\left(-\frac{(x-\mu)^2}{2 \nu_q^{(1 ) } \sigma^2 } \right ) \:dx , \\ & = & \left(\frac{2 \nu_q^{(1 ) } \sigma^2}{q-1 } \right)^{1/2 } b\left(\frac{1}{2 } , \frac{1}{q-1}-\frac{1}{2 } \right ) , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ 1 < q < 3 $ } \label{eq : x5 } \\ & = & \sqrt{2 \pi } \sigma , \label{eq : x6 } \hspace{5.5cm}\mbox{for $ q=1.0 $ } \\ & = & \left(\frac{2 \nu_q^{(1 ) } \sigma^2}{1-q } \right)^{1/2 } b\left(\frac{1}{2 } , \frac{1}{1-q}+1 \right ) , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ 0 < q < 1 $ } \label{eq : x7 } \\ \nu_q^{(1 ) } & = & \frac{3-q}{2 } , \label{eq : x9 } \ ] ] where @xmath32 denotes the beta function . substituting the probability distribution given by eq .
( [ eq : b1 ] ) to eqs .
( [ eq : a1 ] ) and ( [ eq : a2 ] ) , we obtain the tsallis entropy expressed by @xmath67 , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ q=1 $ } \\ & = & \frac{[1-(c_q^{(1)})^n]}{(q-1 ) } , \hspace{2cm}\mbox{for $ q \neq 1 $ } \label{eq : b3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath168
. we may express @xmath72 in terms of @xmath169 by @xcite @xmath170 where @xmath171 .
equation ( [ eq : b6 ] ) clearly shows that the tsallis entropy is generally nonextensive except for @xmath24 for which @xmath172 .
figures [ fige](a ) and [ fige](b ) show the @xmath0 dependence of the tsallis entropy per element , @xmath49 , of uncorrelated systems ( @xmath71 ) , which are calculated with the use of eq .
( [ eq : b5 ] ) . with increasing @xmath0 , @xmath49 is decreased for @xmath77
whereas it is significantly increased for @xmath76 . with the use of eqs .
( [ eq : a4 ] ) and ( [ eq : a5 ] ) for @xmath52 , the generalized and extended fisher information matrices are given by @xcite @xmath173 with @xmath174 which show that fisher information matrices are extensive .
in the case of @xmath25 , the probability distribution @xmath40 given by eqs .
( [ eq : c5 ] ) and ( [ eq : c6 ] ) is rewritten as @xmath175^{1/(1-q ) } , \label{eq : y1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath176,\\ & = & \lambda_1 y_1 ^ 2+\lambda_2 y_2 ^ 2 , \label{eq : y2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath177 and @xmath178 ( @xmath179 ) are eigenvalues and eigenvectors of @xmath180 given by @xmath181 the averages of @xmath182 $ ] and @xmath183 $ ] are given by @xmath184 & = & \frac{1}{\nu_q^{(2)}\lambda_1 } , \\
e_q[y_2 ^ 2 ] & = & \frac{1}{\nu_q^{(2)}\lambda_2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which we obtain @xmath28 and @xmath185 as @xmath186 = \frac{1}{2}e_q[y_1 ^ 2+y_2 ^ 2 ] , \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{a}{\nu_q^{(2)}(a^2-b^2 ) } , \label{eq : y3}\\ s\ : \sigma^2 & = & e_q[x_1 x_2 ] = \frac{1}{2}e_q[y_1 ^ 2-y_2 ^ 2 ] , \nonumber \\
& = & - \frac{b}{\nu_q^{(2)}(a^2-b^2)}. \label{eq : y4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] by using eqs .
( [ eq : y3 ] ) and ( [ eq : y4 ] ) , @xmath187 and @xmath188 are expressed in terms of @xmath28 and @xmath29 as @xmath189 which yield the matrix of @xmath35 given by an inverse of the covariance matrix of @xmath37 [ eq .
( [ eq : d2 ] ) ] . a calculation for the case of an arbitrary @xmath0
may be similarly performed as follows .
the distribution given by eqs .
( [ eq : f1 ] ) and ( [ eq : f0 ] ) is rewritten as @xmath190^{1/(1-q ) } , \label{eq : w1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath191,\\ & = & \sum_i \lambda_i y_i^2 , \label{eq : w2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath177 and @xmath178 are eigenvalues and eigenvectors , respectively . with the use of eigenvalues given by @xmath192 , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ i=1 $ } \\ & = & \frac{1}{2}(a - b ) , \hspace{1cm}\mbox{for $ 1 < i \leq n$}\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs .
( [ eq : c23 ] ) and ( [ eq : c24 ] ) lead to @xmath193 , \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{\nu_q^{(n ) } n } \sum_i \left ( \frac{1}{\lambda_i } \right ) , \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{[a+b(n-2)]}{\nu_q^{(n ) } ( a - b)[a+(n-1)b ] } , \label{eq : w3}\\ s\:\sigma^2 & = & \frac{1}{n(n-1 ) } \sum_{i < j}e_q[y_i^2-y_j^2 ] , \nonumber\\ & = & \left ( \frac{1}{\nu_q^{(n ) } n(n-1 ) } \right ) \sum_{i < j}\left ( \frac{1}{\lambda_i}-\frac{1}{\lambda_j } \right ) , \nonumber\\ & = & -\ : \frac{b}{\nu_q^{(n ) } ( a - b)[a+(n-1)b]}. \label{eq : w4 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] from eqs .
( [ eq : w3 ] ) and ( [ eq : w4 ] ) , @xmath187 and @xmath188 are expressed in terms of @xmath28 and @xmath29 , as given by @xmath194}{\nu_q^{(n)}\sigma^2(1-s)[1+(n-1)s ] } , \\ b & = & - \:\frac{s}{\nu_q^{(n)}\sigma^2(1-s)[1+(n-1)s]}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to discuss the condition for a physically conceivable @xmath29 value , we consider the global variable @xmath195 defined by @xmath196 the first and second @xmath3 moments of @xmath195 are given by @xmath197 & = & \frac{1}{n } \sum_i e_q[x_i(t ) ] = \mu(t ) ,
\\ \label{eq : z2 } e_q[\ { \delta x(t ) \}^2 ] & = & \frac{1}{n^2 } \sum_i \sum_j e_q[\delta x_i(t)\delta x_j(t)],\\ & = & \frac{1}{n^2 } \sum_i e_q[\ { \delta x_i(t ) \}^2 ] + \frac{1}{n^2 } \sum_i \sum_{j ( \neq i ) } e_q[\delta x_i(t)\delta x_j(t ) ] , \\ & = & \frac{\sigma(t)^2}{n}[1+(n-1)s(t ) ] , \label{eq : z3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath198 and @xmath199 .
since global fluctuation in @xmath200 is smaller than the average of local fluctuation in @xmath6 , we obtain @xmath201 \leq \frac{1}{n}\sum_i e[\ { \delta x_i(t)\}^2]=\sigma(t)^2 .
\label{eq : z4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equations ( [ eq : z3 ] ) and ( [ eq : z4 ] ) yield @xmath202}{n } \leq 1.0 , \label{eq : z5}\ ] ] which leads to @xmath203 with @xmath204 and @xmath63 .
a. plastino and a. r. plastino , physica a * 222 * , 347 ( 1995 ) . c. tsallis and d. j. bukman , phys .
e * 54 * , r2197 ( 1996 ) .
a. plastino , a. r. plastino , and h. g. miller , physica a * 235 * , 577 ( 1997 ) . f. pennini , a. r. plastino , and a. plastino , physica a * 258 * , 446 ( 1998 ) .
l. borland , f. pennini , a. r. plastino , and a. plastino , eur .
j. b. * 12 * , 285 ( 1999 ) .
a. r. plastino , m. casas , and a. plastino , physica a * 280 * , 289 ( 2000 )
. s. abe , phys .
e * 68 * , 031101 ( 2003 ) .
calculations of @xmath205 for large @xmath0 with the use of eqs .
( [ eq : f5b ] ) and ( [ eq : f5 ] ) need a computer program of the gamma function with a negative ( real ) argument , which is not available in our facility . | we have calculated the tsallis entropy and fisher information matrix ( entropy ) of spatially - correlated nonextensive systems , by using an analytic non - gaussian distribution obtained by the maximum entropy method .
effects of the correlated variability on the fisher information matrix are shown to be different from those on the tsallis entropy .
the fisher information is increased ( decreased ) by a positive ( negative ) correlation , whereas the tsallis entropy is decreased with increasing an absolute magnitude of the correlation independently of its sign .
this fact arises from the difference in their characteristics .
it implies from the cramr - rao inequality that the accuracy of unbiased estimate of fluctuation is improved by the negative correlation .
a critical comparison is made between the present study and previous ones employing the gaussian approximation for the correlated variability due to multiplicative noise .
= 1.333 * effects of correlated variability on information entropies + in nonextensive systems * hideo hasegawa _ department of physics , tokyo gakugei university + koganei , tokyo 184 - 8501 , japan _
( ) pacs number(s ) : 05.70.-a,05.10.gg,05.45.-a _ key words _ : tsallis entropy , fisher information , correlated variability , nonextensive systems |
molecular machines are protein molecules which can transform chemical energy into ordered internal mechanical motions .
the classical examples of such machines are molecular motors kinesin and myosin , where internal mechanical motions are used to transport cargo along microtubules and filaments .
many enzymes operate as machines , using internal conformational motions to facilitate chemical reactions .
other kinds of machines , operating as ion pumps or involved in genetic processes , are also known . moreover ,
artificial nonequilibrium nanodevices , similar to protein machines , are being developed @xcite .
the cycle of a protein machine is typically powered by chemical energy supplied with an atp molecule .
when an atp molecule binds to a protein machine , the initial protein - atp complex is out of equilibrium and the process of ordered conformational relaxation of this complex towards its equilibrium state starts .
when this state is reached , atp is converted into adp and this product molecule leaves the complex .
the emerging free protein molecule is out of equilibrium and another conformational relaxation process , returning the free protein to its original equilibrium state begins .
thus , the cycle consists of two conformational motions .
it is important to note that the forward and back conformational motions inside each cycle do not coincide - they correspond to relaxation processes in two different physical objects , i.e. the free protein and the protein - atp complex @xcite .
recently , much attention has been attracted to microscale swimmers operating at low reynolds numbers .
generally , it can be shown that any physical object , cyclically changing its shape in such a way that the internal forward and back motions are different , propels itself through the liquid @xcite .
elementary models of such swimmers , constructed by joining together mobile links @xcite or by connecting a few spheres by several actively deformable links @xcite , have been considered .
typically , the concept of molecular swimmers is applied to explain active motion of bacteria and other microorganisms . however , individual macromolecules that operate actively as machines are also capable of self - motion @xcite if a swimmer is attached to some support , preventing its translational motion , it exhibits force acting on the mechanical support .
the generated force is equal to the stall force which needs to be applied to a swimmer to prevent its translational motion .
when many swimmers are attached to a distributed support , their collective operation produces mechanical pressure acting on the support .
this situation is , for example , encountered for molecular machines representing active protein inclusions ( such as ion pumps ) in biological membranes .
it has been shown that the combined effects of the mechanical forces generated by the machines and their lateral motions inside the membrane can lead to membrane instabilities @xcite .
the aim of this paper is to investigate a different situation involving molecular machine populations .
we consider hypothetical machines which are floating on top of a thin liquid layer and thus represent _ active surfactants _
( fig.[fig1 ] ) .
because the considered surfactant molecules are microswimmers , they generate local pressure applied to the liquid - air interface and proportional to their local concentration .
additionally , they are subject to surface diffusion and , as surfactants , also modify local surface tension .
our main analytical result , supported by numerical simulations , is that , if the surface density of machines is sufficiently high and if the rate of supply of chemical energy to the machine population exceeds a threshold , the equilibrium flat interface becomes unstable and hydrodynamical flows inside the liquid layer spontaneously develop .
this instability is accompanied by spatial redistribution of floating machines and their collective motions over the surface .
it leads to the emergence of a special kind of surface turbulence .
such phenomena can provide the basis for active microfluidics , where hydrodynamical motions in liquid layers are induced and controlled by molecular machines located at the surface .
the next two sections are devoted to the derivation and the stability analysis of a model of such molecular swimmers attached to the surface of a thin liquid film .
a collection of numerical results is presented in section iv .
finally , a model and numerical results are discussed , and some estimates of the forces of such molecules are given .
the possible experimental realization is also discussed .
population of identical molecular machines floating on the surface of a thin liquid film will be considered .
these machines perform cycles of conformational changes ( with a characteristic time @xmath0 ) enabled by the supply of energy through atp molecules present in the liquid .
we are interested in macroscopic collective effects and do not specify the details of machine operation .
it will be assumed that , on the average , each machine generates the force which is applied to the air - liquid interface .
this average force acts along the normal direction ( the forces in the lateral direction vanish after averaging because of the rotational diffusion ) .
each machine cycle is initiated by binding of an atp molecule and the average force is proportional to the cycle frequency . assuming that binding of atp molecules follows the michaelis - menten law , the average force per machine molecule is @xmath1}{k_{atp}+[atp]}. \label{atp}%\ ] ] here
, @xmath2 is the maximal force under the atp saturation conditions , @xmath3 $ ] denotes the atp concentration in the liquid , and @xmath4 is the characteristic concentration at which saturation begins . because of the cycles
, the floating machines produce additional pressure acting on the air - liquid interface .
this pressure @xmath5 is proportional to the local surface concentration of the machines and the average force generated by an individual machine , i.e. @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the force per mol of molecules ( @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the avogadro number ) .
note that the machines are still sufficiently well separated one from another and possible synchronization effects of their cycles ( cf .
@xcite ) are therefore neglected . before proceeding to the detailed formulation of the model , we want to outline the origin of the expected surface instability .
suppose that the average force , generated by machines is directed upwards and therefore the machines are pulling the liquid up in the vertical direction ( fig .
if machine concentration is increased in some region , the pulling pressure is higher in this region , inducing local rise in the liquid film thickness .
this however leads to lateral hydrodynamical flows which are directed inwards and bring even more machines into the region . as a result ,
the positive feedback , responsible for the instability , is established .
note that surface diffusion of floating machines and capillary forces are acting in the opposite direction , suppressing the instability .
thus , it is observed only if the average force @xmath10 generated by a machine is large enough , setting a threshold in terms of the energy supply rate ( i.e. , of the atp concentration in the solution ) .
the instability is not possible when the force is downwards directed , thus inducing local depressions of the liquid layer ( fig .
2b ) , then , in contrast to the previous case , hydrodynamical flows remove machines from the depression , restoring the equilibrium flat film .
temporal evolution of the surface concentration field @xmath11 is described by the equation : @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the lateral fluid velocity and @xmath14 is the surface diffusion .
floating proteins represent surfactants and reduce the surface tension of the interfaces ( see @xcite ) . to take this effect into account
, we assume that the surface tension coefficient @xmath15 decreases linearly with the machine concentration , @xmath16 hydrodynamical flows , induced by the gradients in machine concentration , should be further considered .
we assume that the liquid layer is so thin that the lubrication approximation , typically employed in microfluidics @xcite , is justified . as shown in appendix a , the evolution equation for the local hight @xmath17 of the interface has the form @xmath18 where the local pressure is @xmath19 and @xmath20 is the viscosity of the fluid . determining the lateral flow velocity at the interface ( see appendix a ) and substituting it into the evolution equation for the surface concentration ,
a closed set of two partial differential equations is obtained .
explicitly , the considered dynamics of thin films with active surfactants is described by equations : @xmath21 \nonumber\\ & + \frac{1}{\mu}\sigma_{c}\vec{\nabla}\left ( \frac{h^{2}}{2}\vec{\nabla } c\right ) , \label{dth}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath22 \nonumber\\ & + \frac{1}{\mu}\sigma_{c}\vec{\nabla}\left ( ch\vec{\nabla}c\right ) + d\nabla^{2}c . \label{dtc}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we have assumed that the active surfactant is insoluble @xcite . for subsequent analysis , it is convenient to write these equations in the dimensionless form .
the ( equilibrium ) liquid layer thickness @xmath23 will be used as the length unit , time will be measured in units of @xmath24 , and local concentration @xmath11 in units of the equilibrium machine concentration @xmath25 .
changing the variables as @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 , we obtain @xmath30 \right ) \nonumber\\ & + \frac{a}{2}\vec{\nabla}\left ( h^{2}(\vec{\nabla}c)\right ) , \label{pth2}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath31 \nonumber\\ & + a\vec{\nabla}\left [ ch\vec{\nabla}c\right ] + d\nabla^{2}c . \label{ptc2}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] the new model equations include only three dimensionless parameters @xmath32 the parameter @xmath33 specifies the characteristic strength of floating machines as the surfactant species ( decreasing the local surface tension of the interface ) .
the parameter @xmath34 specifies the magnitude of the pressure generated by the cycling molecular machines ; it is controlled by the rate of energy supply to the system .
finally , @xmath35 is the dimensionless diffusion coefficient of floating machines . comparing the last terms in equation ( [ ptc2 ] ) , we notice that spreading of floating machines , induced by changes in the surface tension , has the same functional form as surface diffusion .
if relative variations of the film thickness and machine concentration are small ( @xmath36 ) , the effective diffusion coefficient of this process is @xmath33 .
our estimates below in sect .
v indicate that the genuine diffusion constant @xmath35 of floating machines is typically much smaller than the effective diffusion constant @xmath33 . having this in mind
, we retain the terms including the coefficient @xmath35 in our analytical investigations , but put @xmath37 when numerical simulations of the model are performed .
results with non - zero diffusion coefficient have been also obtained but they are very close to the results with @xmath37 .
as shown in appendix a , the dimensionless horizontal ( @xmath38 ) and vertical ( @xmath39 ) velocities of the liquid film at hight @xmath40 and horizontal spatial location @xmath41 can be found as @xmath42 @xmath43 when the fields @xmath44 and @xmath45 are known .
both velocities vanish at the bottom of the liquid film , at @xmath46 , because of the no - penetration and no - slip boundary conditions imposed there .
the model always has the stationary uniform state @xmath47 . to perform the linear stability analysis of this state ,
small perturbations @xmath48 @xmath49 and @xmath50 @xmath49 in the form of plane waves with the wavenumber @xmath51 are introduced .
linearizing evolution equations with respect to small perturbations @xmath52 and @xmath53 and solving the linearized equations , growth rates @xmath54 of such perturbations are obtained , @xmath55 ^{2 } \nonumber\\ & + 2 \left ( 1-a\right ) \left ( \frac{a}{2}-\frac{b } { 3}\right ) k^{2 } ) ^{1/2 } .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] it can be easily checked that , in absence of the energy supply ( @xmath56 ) , both rates are real and negative , so that the equilibrium flat film is stable as should be expected . when the parameter @xmath34 is increased , the instability develops at @xmath57 where @xmath58 above the instability threshold , traveling plane waves with the wavenumbers @xmath51 near @xmath59 , @xmath60 and the frequencies near @xmath61 @xmath62 are growing.the fastest growing mode with @xmath63 and @xmath64 is characterized by the growth rate@xmath65
= \frac{3}{32 } \frac{~\left ( b - b_{c}\right)^{2}}{1-a}. \label{rate}%\ ] ] figure 3 shows dependences @xmath66 $ ] and @xmath67 $ ] at three values of the parameter @xmath34 below and above the instability boundary .
while the fastest growing mode at @xmath68is always oscillatory , with @xmath69 \neq0 $ ] , above the instability boundary
the system also always has some standing growing modes with the wavenumbers @xmath51 smaller than @xmath70 .
as the boundary is approached from above , both the wavenumber @xmath70 and the frequency @xmath71 decrease and vanish at @xmath57 .
the region with two real modes @xmath72 and @xmath73 always lies below @xmath74 ; it shrinks and vanishes at @xmath75 .
similar long - wavelength instabilities have previously been discussed for other conservative systems ( see @xcite ) .
to investigate the behavior of the system in the nonlinear regime above the instability onset , numerical simulations have been performed .
equations([pth2],[ptc2 ] ) were integrated using the semi - implicit method ( see appendix b ) for a one - dimensional system using periodic boundary conditions . as the initial condition ,
the flat interface with a uniform machine distribution was chosen and small random initial perturbations were applied .
our main observation is that the instability development results in the emergence of a complex spatiotemporal regime which can be described as _ interface turbulence_. this regime is characterized by spontaneous appearance of _ traveling machine clusters _
( i.e. , of spatial regions where the local machine concentration is increased ) and of the accompanying local interface modulations .
figure([fig4 ] ) gives an illustration of the turbulent regimes observed at different different distances from the instability threshold .
the local film thickness @xmath45 is displayed here in gray scale depending on the spatial coordinate ( the vertical axis ) and time . in the slightly supercritical regime at @xmath76 , the transient development of standing waves
is first observed , which is then followed by the emergence of an irregular pattern of traveling and colliding waves . at larger deviations from the critical point ,
the transients are faster and the irregular wave dynamics appears soon after the instability onset .
the characteristic spatial scale of the turbulence decreases with the control parameter @xmath34 , consistent with the predictions of the linear stability analysis .
the characteristic velocity of traveling waves is also growing with @xmath34 .
figure [ fig5 ] shows snapshots of computed turbulent patterns at different deviations from the instability threshold .
both the interface profiles and the corresponding concentration distributions are presented here .
again , a decrease of the characteristic wavelength of the irregular spatiotemporal patterns under an increase of the control parameter @xmath34 can be noticed .
moreover , we see that the characteristic amplitude of the waves grows with @xmath34 . to illustrate the directions of wave propagation
, arrows are placed in the insets of this figure , where examples of colliding and traveling waves are shown .
these arrows indicate the directions in which the respective concentration and interface profile maxima are shifting at the next time moment .
note that the motions of machine clusters ( i.e , of the local concentration maxima ) are typically guiding the motions of surface bumps .
temporal transients leading to turbulent patterns are characterized in fig .
[ fig6 ] . to construct it
, we have determined the maximum and the minimum values @xmath77 and @xmath78of the film thickness as function of time , starting from the initial moment .
their difference @xmath79 ( where @xmath80 is the dimensionless time ) can be chosen to describe the amplitude of the developing patterns . as seen in the two top panels in fig .
[ fig6 ] , this amplitude first grows ( exponentially ) and the undergoes saturation .
the transient is shorter for the larger deviation from the threshold ( @xmath81 ) and the final mean amplitude of the turbulent pattern is also then larger . to estimate the characteristic wavenumber @xmath82 of the developing spatial patterns ,
their fourier transforms were computed and the positions of dominant maxima in the spatial power spectra were determined at different time moments . as seen in the two bottom panels in fig .
[ fig6 ] , these wavenumbers do not significantly change during the transients .
the characteristic wavelengths of the developed turbulent patterns are therefore not much different from those of the critical modes .
figure [ fig7 ] shows temporal dependences of the hight @xmath83 and the concentration @xmath84 at a fixed point of the system in the final turbulent state .
the characteristic time of the oscillations is clearly different for the two values of the control parameter .
both properties fluctuate around some mean values .
the fluctuations are more rapid farther away from the instability threshold
. finally , fig .
[ fig8 ] displays the dependence of several selected statistical properties of the final turbulent state on the deviation @xmath85 from the critical point @xmath86 .
the characteristic wavenumbers @xmath87 and amplitudes @xmath52 have been computed as described above .
time averages of these properties and statistical dispersion of the data are shown in figs .
[ fig8 ] . the characteristic transient times @xmath88 ( fig .
[ fig8]c ) have been estimated by fitting the initial computed time dependence for @xmath89 to the exponential law , @xmath90 .
the characteristic frequency @xmath91 of the patterns ( fig .
[ fig8]d ) is estimated by computing their temporal power spectra and determining the positions of the dominant maxima .
solid curves in fig .
[ fig8 ] give fits of the simulation data to the power laws predicted by the linear stability analysis . according to equations ( [ wavenumber ] ) and ( [ frequency ] ) , @xmath92 @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
the transient time is determined by the rate of growth as @xmath95 $ ] and , according to equation ( [ rate ] ) , we expect that @xmath96 .
for the mean amplitude @xmath52 of the patterns , the quadratic fit @xmath97 has been applied .
we see that the statistical properties of nonlinear patterns in the developed turbulence regime are still in good agreement with the respective predictions based on the linear stability analysis .
can predicted interface instabilities be experimentally observed ?
this question has both chemical and physical aspects . on the chemical side
, it is known that proteins may indeed represent surfactants and thus float at the air - water interface ( see .
e.g. , @xcite ) .
although we can not give here a specific example , it seems plausible that some protein machines also belong to this class .
moreover , other protein machines , including molecular motors , can probably be made floating by chemical modification , i.e. by attaching to them a hydrophobic group .
the physical question is whether the propulsion forces generated by individual protein machines would be sufficient to induce the considered interface instability . according to equation ( [ boundary ] ) ,
the instability is reached when @xmath98 with @xmath99 .
taking into account the definitions of dimensionless properties @xmath33 , @xmath34 and @xmath35 , the instability condition implies that the propulsion force @xmath100 generated by a single machine , must exceed the threshold @xmath101 where @xmath23 is the film thickness , @xmath25 is the surface concentration of floating machines , @xmath14 is their surface diffusion constant , @xmath20 is the liquid viscosity , @xmath9 is the avogadro number , and @xmath102 specifies the surfactant capacity of the considered biomolecules ( the surface tension coefficient @xmath15 depends as @xmath103 on their concentration @xmath11 ) . for numerical order - of - magnitude estimates , we choose @xmath104 g @xmath105s@xmath106 ( the viscosity of water ) , @xmath107 @xmath108s@xmath106 ( characteristic diffusion constant of large biomolecules in water solutions @xcite ) . based on the experimental data given in ref .
@xcite , we take furthermore @xmath109 .
both terms in equation ( [ force ] ) are inversely proportional to the liquid film thickness @xmath23 and the smaller critical forces are therefore expected for the thicker layers .
note , however , that this result is based on the lubrication approximation for thin liquid films , requiring that the film thickness is much smaller than the characteristic wavelength of the flow patterns .
as we have seen , the characteristic wavelength of the interface turbulence in the considered system depends on the distance from the critical point ( cf . equation ( [ wavenumber ] ) ) and , in principle , can be arbitrarily large sufficiently close to the instability threshold . taking into account experimental limitations making it very difficult to work too close to the threshold , we choose however @xmath110 as the characteristic maximum film thickness
. concentration @xmath25 of floating proteins enters only into the second term in equation ( [ force ] ) .
this term , depending on surface diffusion of floating machines , can be neglected in comparison with the first term , if the condition @xmath111 with @xmath112 holds . substituting numerical values ,
we get @xmath113 .
thus , already for very low surface concentrations of proteins , effects of their diffusion can be neglected in the considered problem . neglecting diffusion effects , the critical propulsion force of a single machine
is estimated as @xmath114 note that it does not depend on the protein concentration .
substitution of the numerical values into equation ( [ force1 ] ) yields @xmath115 .
can a single molecular machine generate the hydrodynamical propulsion force of that magnitude ?
direct measurements of molecular propulsion forces are still not available .
it is known that molecular motors , such as myosin or kinesin , can generate mechanical forces of about @xmath116 @xcite , but these data refers to the molecules moving along microtubules and filaments , not to the swimmers . for a simple example , we consider the elementary three - body purcell swimmer @xcite .
its characteristic propulsion velocity is about @xmath117 , where @xmath118 is the displacement per single cycle and @xmath119 is the characteristic time of the cycle ( cf .
the viscous friction force of an object of linear size @xmath120 that moves with velocity @xmath121 through the liquid is by the order - of - magnitude @xmath122 .
thus , propulsion at velocity @xmath123 would require the propulsion force about @xmath124 .
choosing @xmath125 nm , @xmath126 and @xmath127 ms and considering water as the liquid , we obtain for the molecular propulsion force the rough estimate of @xmath128pn .
similar estimates are obtained for other known elementary swimmers .
note that the actual average propulsion force @xmath10 of a machine additionally depends on the frequency of machine cycles and the angle with respect the interface , therefore , according to equation ( [ atp ] ) , this gives the estimate of the maximum propulsion force under the energy - supply saturation conditions and the most efficient orientation of the machine . while molecular propulsion forces are quite small , according the above estimates they would still be sufficient to induce the film instability and lead to the interface turbulence .
therefore , we conclude that the experimental observation of the predicted effects is _ principally possible_. the experiments aimed at detecting instabilities of thin liquid layers induced by floating actively operating machines would allow to directly estimate actual propulsion forces generated by particular biomolecules
. investigations of such nonequilibrium hydrodynamical systems would be very important from the perspective of _ active microfluidics _
, where active motions in thin liquid layers are produced by floating biomolecular propellers . financial support from the eu marie curie rtn `` unifying principles in nonequilibrium pattern formation '' and from the german science foundation collaborative research center sfb 555 `` complex nonlinear processes '' is acknowledged .
we are grateful to u. steiner , d. barbero and u. thiele for valuable discussions .
we consider the situation when the film thickness @xmath23 is the smallest characteristic length of the system . in this case
, the lubrication approximation can be used which corresponds to an expansion in the small parameter @xmath129 , with @xmath130 being the characteristic wavelength of the patterns in the lateral direction .
hydrodynamical equations in the lubrication approximation are simplified and take the form ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) @xmath131 with the incompressibility condition @xmath132 here , @xmath133 is the vertical component of the fluid velocity and @xmath13 is its horizontal component ; @xmath134 is the differential operator acting only on the horizontal coordinates .
note that , as follows from these equations , pressure @xmath135 is constant along the vertical direction .
the boundary conditions at the bottom of the film , in contact with the solid support , are @xmath136 at the free air - liquid interface @xmath137 , the balance of horizontal and vertical forces should separately hold , implying that @xmath138 where @xmath15 is the surface tension coefficient and @xmath5 is the additional pressure produced by floating active molecules .
conservation of the total film volume implies moreover that the equation .
@xmath139 should hold . integrating equations.([stokes ] ) and taking into account the boundary condition ( [ p ] ) ,
the horizontal velocity of the flow can be determined , @xmath140 .\ ] ] the vertical velocity is then obtained by using the incompressibility condition , @xmath141 substituting these expressions into equation ( [ interface ] ) and integrating over @xmath142 , the final form of the interface equation is derived , @xmath143
while simple explicit euler methods are frequently employed in numerical investigations of nonlinear reaction - diffusion models , such methods easily become numerically unstable when hydrodynamical microfluidics equations are considered . therefore ,
a specially constructed numerical integration method has been employed in our study .
below , its brief description is provided .
there are two nonlinear differential equations to solve , one for the thickness @xmath45 and the other for the concentration @xmath44 of the surfactant .
we define vector @xmath144 and formally write both equations as @xmath145 the matrix operator @xmath146 can be decomposed as @xmath147 into its linear ( @xmath148 ) and nonlinear ( @xmath149 ) parts .
they are defined as@xmath150 to compute @xmath151 at the next time step @xmath152 , the mixed semi - implicit method is employed : @xmath153 thus , the implicit method is used to determine the contribution from the linear part in time @xmath152 and the explicit method is employed to compute the nonlinear part contribution .
the calculation of the inverse differential matrix operator @xmath158 is most conveniently performed by transforming the equation to the fourier space . here , it is important that the term @xmath159 is determined before applying the fourier transformation .
our simulations using this numerical method have been performed only in the one - dimensional case , @xmath160 and @xmath161 . in two dimensions ,
the method becomes complicated and such simulations have not been undertaken . | thin liquid films with floating active protein machines are considered .
cyclic mechanical motions within the machines , representing microscopic swimmers , lead to molecular propulsion forces applied to the air - liquid interface .
we show that , when the rate of energy supply to the machines exceeds a threshold , the flat interface becomes linearly unstable . as the result of this instability ,
the regime of interface turbulence , characterized by irregular traveling waves and propagating machine clusters , is established .
numerical investigations of this nonlinear regime are performed .
conditions for the experimental observation of the instability are discussed . |
in the first part of this work @xcite a collisionless plasma , generated by uv illumination localized in a central part of the plasma , was analyzed .
the ions were assumed to be cold and the fluid description was used . both plane and cylindrical geometries were treated .
an approximate analytical solution was found under the approximation of quasi - neutrality and the exact solution was computed numerically for one value of the debye length @xmath0 for each geometry , this value being much smaller than widths of both illuminated and un - illuminated regions .
it was found that the ions generated in the illuminated region are accelerated up to approximately the bohm speed inside the illuminated region . in plane geometry ,
the ions flow across the un - illuminated region towards the near - wall positive space - charge sheath with a speed which is virtually constant and slightly exceeds the bohm speed . in cylindrical geometry , the ions continue to be accelerated in the un - illuminated region and enter the near - wall space - charge sheath with a speed significantly exceeding the bohm speed . in both geometries , a double layer forms where the illuminated and un - illuminated regions meet .
a very unusual , if not unique , feature that this simple system reveals in plane geometry is the coexistence of two quasi - neutral plasmas of the same size with the ambipolar electric field being confined in one of them ( the illuminated plasma ) , while the other ( the un - illuminated plasma ) is to high accuracy electric field - free and uniform .
the latter is particularly surprising since in all known models a near - wall space - charge sheath is bordered by a nonuniform quasi - neutral presheath where the ions going to the sheath are accelerated and the voltage drop is of the order of the electron temperature measured in volts .
( we set aside cases where the ions are produced on the surface , as in q - machines or experiments with heated cavities @xcite , or inside the sheath , as in near - cathode layers of discharges burning in cathode vapour @xcite . )
moreover , the difference between illuminated and un - illuminated regions in terms of ion momentum is in the presence or absence of ionization friction force , and the fact that the ion fluid is accelerated in the illuminated plasma , where the ionization friction force is present , and is not accelerated in the un - illuminated plasma , where the friction force is absent , is somehow counterintuitive .
the above feature is extremely interesting , also from the methodological point of view ; note that the classical bohm sheath solution @xcite is sufficient to describe both the sheath and the adjacent ( un - illuminated ) plasma in such situation .
a key to this feature is the double layer , which shields the ambipolar electric field induced in the illuminated region and prevents it from penetrating the un - illuminated region .
the quasi - neutral analytical solution @xcite , while clearly being useful , does not describe the double layer , hence a more sophisticated treatment is needed in order to fully understand this feature and the underlying physics .
it is clear that this feature originates in the smallness of @xmath0 , therefore the relevant procedure is to find an asymptotic solution to the considered problem in the limiting case of small @xmath0 .
the technique of choice to this end is the method of matched asymptotic expansions ( e.g. , @xcite ) , which is a standard tool in problems with singular perturbations .
note that this method has been successfully used in the theory of plasma - wall transitions in collisionless plasmas ; e.g. , reviews @xcite .
in particular , relevant in the present context are works @xcite , where a transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless sheath was introduced ; @xcite , where a more adequate and simpler mathematical description of this layer was suggested ; and @xcite , where the plasma column in electronegative gases was studied including in the exceptional case where the column comprises an inner plasma , a double layer , an outer plasma , and a near - wall sheath .
an approximate analytical solution in the limiting case of small @xmath0 found by means of the method of matched asymptotic expansions is reported in this paper , which is thus complementary to @xcite . also reported are results of numerical calculations for different values of @xmath0 .
questions to be answered include : what is the physics of the double layer ; why the ion speed in the un - illuminated plasma deviates from the bohm speed ; how this deviation can be estimated .
the outline of the paper is as follows .
equations and boundary conditions are briefly described in sec .
[ equations ] .
an asymptotic solution for plane geometry is given and compared with numerical results in sec .
[ asymptotic solution ] . an asymptotic solution for cylindrical geometry
is outlined in sec .
[ cylindrical geometry ] . a concluding discussion
is given in sec .
[ discussion ] .
mathematical details are placed in two appendices in order not to overload the text .
we refer to @xcite for the description of the physical situation . in brief
, we consider a plane or cylindrical plasma produced by uv radiation .
governing equations are written in the fluid approximation and are well - known and the same as in @xcite ; they include the ion conservation equation , the ion momentum equation written without account of collisions , the equilibrium equation for the electrons , and the poisson equation:@xmath1@xmath2@xmath3@xmath4 where @xmath5 and @xmath6 is the distance from the plane of symmetry for plane geometry , @xmath7 and @xmath6 is the distance from the axis for cylindrical geometry , @xmath8 is the ionization rate , and other designations are the usual ones .
it is convenient for the purposes of this work to replace the ion momentum equation eq .
( [ 2a ] ) by an equivalent equation which can be derived following @xcite and reads@xmath9 + \frac { ee}{kt_{e}x^{\beta}}\frac{d\left ( x^{\beta}e\right ) } { dx}\right\ } -\frac{g}{c_{s}n_{i}}\left ( \frac{v_{i}}{c_{s}}+\frac{c_{s}}{v_{i}}\right ) + \frac{\beta}{x}.\label{6}\ ] ] here @xmath10 is the bohm speed .
note that for @xmath5 this equation coincides with the corresponding equation from @xcite except that eq .
( [ 6 ] ) does not account for ion - atom collisions .
we consider a situation where the illumination is localized in a central part of the plasma and is uniform there , so @xmath11 for @xmath12 and @xmath13 for @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is a ( positive ) constant , @xmath16 is the halfwidth of irradiated region and @xmath17 is the halfwidth of the system in the plane case , and @xmath16 is the radius of the irradiated region and @xmath17 is the discharge tube radius in the cylindrical case .
note that @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , and electrostatic potential @xmath21 are , of course , continuous at @xmath22 ; the derivatives @xmath23 and @xmath24 are also continuous , which follows from eq .
( [ 4 ] ) ; the derivative @xmath25 is continuous as well , which follows from eq .
( [ 3 ] ) ; the derivatives @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 are discontinuous , which follows from , respectively , eqs .
( [ 2a ] ) , ( [ 1 ] ) , and ( [ 4 ] ) .
boundary conditions are also well - known and the same as those in @xcite : @xmath29@xmath30 eq . (
[ 1 ] ) can be integrated directly and the result may be written in terms of the heaviside step function @xmath31 ( @xmath32 for @xmath33 ; @xmath34 for @xmath35):@xmath36 introduce dimensionless variables @xmath37 where @xmath38 is a characteristic density of the charged particles .
( note that this normalization differs from the one used in @xcite in that it employs normalization factors involving only control parameters . )
the governing equations assume the form@xmath39@xmath40 + \frac{d\phi}{d\xi}\frac{1}{\xi^{\beta}}\frac{d}{d\xi}\left ( \xi^{\beta}\frac{d\phi}{d\xi}\right ) \right\ } \label{ion_mom}\\ & -\frac{1+\beta}{\xi}\left ( v^{2}+1\right ) h\!\left ( 1-\xi\right ) + \frac{\beta}{\xi},\nonumber\end{aligned}\]]@xmath41@xmath42 where @xmath43 and @xmath44 . the next section , sec .
[ asymptotic solution ] , is concerned with plane geometry , @xmath5 . the asymptotic solution for cylindrical geometry , @xmath7 ,
is outlined in sec .
[ cylindrical geometry ] .
asymptotic zones that need to be considered may be conveniently illustrated by invoking results of numerical calculations .
the calculations have been performed in the same way as in @xcite and an example is depicted by solid lines in fig . 1 .
one can clearly see four regions with apparently different physics : the illuminated plasma , @xmath45 ; the un - illuminated plasma , @xmath46 ; a thin intermediate ( double ) layer positioned in the vicinity of the point @xmath47 and separating the two plasmas ; and a thin space - charge sheath positioned at the wall , i.e. , at @xmath48 close to @xmath49 . in the course of application of the method of matched asymptotic expansions the same four regions appear as asymptotic zones described by different asymptotic expansions .
the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas are described by straightforward expansions , i.e. , the first term of each of these expansions is of the order unity and governed by equations which are obtained from eqs .
( [ 5.2])-([5.5 ] ) by setting @xmath50 .
the latter is , of course , consistent with the plasmas in both the illuminated and un - illuminated regions being quasi - neutral .
the double layer is described by the same asymptotic expansion as the one which describes the transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless sheath @xcite .
the first term of the expansions of each of the quantities @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 is constant .
therefore , the double layer appears only in the second approximation and may be ignored in the first one .
the near - wall space - charge sheath is to the first approximation the well - known bohm space - charge sheath .
its asymptotic description in the present problem is similar to the description given in @xcite and is skipped for brevity .
the region of illuminated plasma , @xmath45 , is described by the straightforward expansion@xmath55@xmath56 + \dots,\]]@xmath57@xmath58 where @xmath59 is a small parameter which is to be found in the course of analysis as a part of solution . substituting expansion ( [ 10])-([13 ] ) into eqs .
( [ ion_mom])-([5.5 ] ) , expanding and retaining the leading terms , one obtains equations@xmath60@xmath61@xmath62 a solution subject to boundary condition @xmath63 reads@xmath64 where @xmath65 is an integration constant , @xmath66 . note that @xmath67 ( i.e. , the value of the function @xmath68 for @xmath47 ) increases with increasing @xmath65 and its maximum value is attained at @xmath69 and equals @xmath70 .
the region of un - illuminated plasma , @xmath71 , is described by the straightforward expansion @xmath72@xmath73
+ \dots,\]]@xmath74@xmath75 where @xmath76 is a small parameter which is to be found as a part of solution .
the leading terms of this expansion are governed by the equations @xmath77@xmath78@xmath79 expansion ( [ 22])-([25 ] ) is to be matched with a double layer expansion in the vicinity of the point @xmath47 and with a sheath expansion in the vicinity of the point @xmath80 .
however , the double layer needs to be taken into account only in the second and higher approximations , so the first terms of the expansions describing the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas should be patched directly , meaning that @xmath81 , @xmath82 , @xmath83 .
solutions to eqs .
( [ 26])-([28 ] ) subject to these boundary conditions are trivial : @xmath84 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 . in order that a matching with the sheath expansion be possible
, @xmath87 must satisfy the bohm criterion , i.e. , it should be @xmath88 .
since @xmath89 as discussed above , it follows that @xmath90 and @xmath69 .
it follows also that @xmath91 , @xmath92 .
the first - approximation solution is complete now . in @xcite ,
the same solution was obtained by patching solutions for the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas obtained with the use of the condition of quasi - neutrality and the bohm criterion .
this solution is depicted by the dotted lines in fig . 1 .
as expected , it provides a reasonable approximation of the ion speed .
however , in the double layer this approximation is not smooth , and the approximation of the electric field is not suitable altogether . poor approximation of derivatives of approximate solutions is a deficiency inherent to patching . in the method of matched asymptotic expansions ,
this deficiency can be removed by going to the second approximation .
it is natural to seek an asymptotic expansion describing the double layer in the same form as that of the expansion which describes the transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless sheath @xcite:@xmath93@xmath94@xmath95@xmath96 where @xmath97 .
the form of this expansion was derived in @xcite with the use of considerations stemming from matching and in @xcite by means of estimates of different terms of equation ( [ 6 ] ) . a convenient illustration of this expansion is provided by fig . 1
: the expansion implies that variations of the quantities @xmath51 , @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 in the double layer are of the order of @xmath98 and the electric field is of the order of @xmath99 , and this is consistent with fig . 1 .
substituting this expansion into eqs .
( [ ion_mom])-([5.5 ] ) , expanding and retaining the leading terms , one obtains equations@xmath100@xmath101@xmath102 as seen from eq .
( [ 36 ] ) , the plasma in the double layer is quasi - neutral not only to the first approximation , but also to the second one .
a consequence is that the derivative @xmath103 is continuous at @xmath104 . coming back to the discussion of sec .
[ equations ] , one can say that the discontinuity of derivative @xmath26 at @xmath22 occurs not in the first approximation in @xmath105 but rather in the second one .
the latter is consistent with the second term on the rhs of eq .
( [ 2a ] ) , which is responsible for the discontinuity , being of the order of @xmath98 , i.e. , asymptotically small , with respect to the first term .
( [ 34 ] ) and ( [ 35 ] ) may be integrated term by term to give@xmath106@xmath107 where @xmath108 and @xmath109 are integration constants .
note that since every term on the lhs of these equations is continuous at @xmath110 , the constants @xmath108 and @xmath109 do not switch their values between the regions @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
the system of eqs .
( [ 37 ] ) , ( [ 38 ] ) , ( [ 36 ] ) may be reduced to a single equation , for example , for the unknown @xmath113:@xmath114 a solution of this equation subject to relevant boundary conditions , which follow from the van dyke asymptotic matching principle @xcite , is found in appendix [ appendix ] and depicted in fig . 2 by the solid line for @xmath115 and dash - dotted line for @xmath116 .
( here @xmath117 . )
the constant @xmath118 is found to be equal to @xmath119 .
also shown in fig .
2 is the function @xmath120 referring to the transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless sheath @xcite .
the two functions coincide in the range @xmath121 and differ for bigger @xmath122 .
we will need for subsequent asymptotic matching the two - term asymptotic expansion of the functions @xmath123 and @xmath124 for @xmath125 , the three - term asymptotic expansion of the function @xmath126 for @xmath125 , and the one - term expansion of all these functions for @xmath127 .
these expansions may be readily found : @xmath128@xmath129 let us now consider the asymptotic matching of expansions ( [ 30])-([33 ] ) and ( [ 10])-([13 ] ) accounting for two terms in each expansion .
making use of eq .
( [ 42 ] ) , one finds that the matching is possible provided that @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 for @xmath133 .
( [ 54 ] ) represents a set of boundary conditions for differential equations governing functions @xmath134 , @xmath135 , and @xmath136 , which can be obtained by substituting expansion ( [ 10])-([13 ] ) into eqs .
( [ ion_mom])-([5.5 ] ) , expanding , and retaining second - order terms .
however , these functions represent a correction of the order of @xmath130 , which is higher than the order to which the solution is known in the double layer ( @xmath98 ) .
for this reason , we leave finding these functions beyond the scope of this work and only note that the boundary conditions ( [ 54 ] ) are compatible with the differential equations .
let us now consider the asymptotic matching of expansions ( [ 30])-([33 ] ) and ( [ 22])-([25 ] ) accounting for two terms in each expansion .
taking into account eq .
( [ 48 ] ) , one finds that the matching is possible provided that @xmath137 and @xmath138 substituting expansions ( [ 22])-([25 ] ) into eqs .
( [ ion_mom])-([5.5 ] ) , expanding , and retaining second - order terms , one obtains equations@xmath139@xmath140 solution of eqs .
( [ 50 ] ) and ( [ 52 ] ) subject to the boundary conditions eq .
( [ 50a ] ) is trivial : @xmath141 , @xmath142 , @xmath143 .
the above results ensure a description of the illuminated plasma region to the double layer to the un - illuminated region with the error of the order of @xmath144 ( which is , presumably , the order of the third terms of the expansions describing the double layer and the un - illuminated region ) .
these results allow one to construct a composite expansion @xcite uniformly valid in all these regions with the error of the order of @xmath144 ; see appendix [ composite expansions ] .
comparison of the above asymptotic solution with results of numerical calculations is shown in figs .
3 - 5 . while analyzing figs . 3b-3d
, it should be kept in mind that @xmath145 , which follows from eqs .
( [ 36 ] ) and ( [ 38 ] ) .
dotted lines in figs .
3 and 4 represent the data given by eqs .
( [ 61 ] ) , ( [ 61a ] ) , and ( [ 62a ] ) .
values of the ion speed in the un - illuminated region shown in fig .
5 have been taken at points where @xmath146 attains the minimum value except in the case @xmath147 , where variation of the ion speed in the un - illuminated region was below the usual floating - point precision .
one can see the deviation between the asymptotic and numerical results is reasonably small and decreases with decreasing @xmath105 .
one needs to consider the same four asymptotic zones as in the case of plane geometry .
a composite first - approximation solution uniformly valid from the illuminated plasma to the double layer to the un - illuminated plasma is governed by eq .
( [ ion_mom ] ) with @xmath50 and @xmath7:@xmath148 a continuous single - valued solution of this equation may be written in the implicit form:@xmath149{lll}$\frac{3^{3/4}v}{\left ( 2v^{2}+1\right ) ^{3/4}}$ & for & $ v\leq1$\\ $ \frac{1}{v}\exp\frac{v^{2}-1}{2}$ & for & $ v\geq1$\end{tabular } \
\ \right .
.\label{12}\ ] ] one can see that @xmath150 , i.e. , the sonic point is positioned at the edge of the illuminated plasma , as in the planar case .
the difference is that the solution ( [ 12 ] ) is obtained without invoking the bohm criterion ; note that eq .
( [ 8a ] ) admits continuous solutions with @xmath151 , however these solutions are multi - valued .
another difference is that @xmath152 for @xmath153 , i.e. , the plasma continues to be accelerated in the un - illuminated plasma .
most formulas of sec .
[ the second approximation ] referring to the double layer may be readily generalized in order to become applicable to both plane and cylindrical geometries .
in particular , this includes replacing the first term on the rhs of eq .
( [ 33 ] ) with @xmath154 and writing eq .
( [ 43 ] ) in the form@xmath155 a major difference between the functions @xmath123 for plane and cylindrical geometries is in their asymptotic behavior for @xmath156 : for @xmath7 the latter is governed by the term @xmath157 on the rhs of eq .
( [ 12a ] ) and reads @xmath158 , which is similar to the first relation in ( [ 42 ] ) rather than ( [ 48 ] ) .
note that this difference does not lead to significantly different behavior of the normalized electric field and space - charge density , @xmath103 and @xmath159 : both tend to zero as @xmath156 , although algebraically rather than exponentially as in plane geometry .
expansions ( [ 10])-([13 ] ) and ( [ 22])-([25 ] ) , describing regions of , respectively , illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas , remain applicable in cylindrical geometry except that @xmath160 becomes equal to @xmath161 .
the four zones with different physics revealed by numerical calculations and shown in fig . 1 , that is , the illuminated plasma , the double layer , the un - illuminated plasma , and the near - wall space - charge sheath appear in a natural way in the course of application of the method of matched asymptotic expansions .
the first - order terms of asymptotic expansions of @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath54 describing the illuminated plasma , the double layer , and the un - illuminated plasmas represent the same quasi - neutral solution that was found in @xcite by patching solutions for the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas and ( in plane geometry ) invoking the bohm criterion .
the second - order terms are of the order of @xmath144 in the illuminated plasma ; @xmath98 in the double layer ; and @xmath98 in the un - illuminated plasma in plane geometry and @xmath144 in cylindrical geometry .
it is interesting to note that these orders explain why the quasi - neutral solution for @xmath51 , @xmath52 , and @xmath54 in fig . 1 of this work and figs .
2 and 3 of @xcite is more accurate in the illuminated plasma than in the double layer and why its accuracy in the un - illuminated plasma is comparable to that in the double layer in plane geometry and in the illuminated plasma in cylindrical geometry .
the double layer separating the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas is quasi - neutral : the separation of charges here is of the order of @xmath144 , i.e. , asymptotically small , although much bigger than in the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas . the net integral space charge ( per unit cross section ) of the double layer
is asymptotically small , which can be readily seen : in the first approximation it is proportional to @xmath162 and equals zero by virtue of boundary conditions ( [ 42 ] ) and ( [ 48 ] ) .
however , in plane geometry the net integral space charge of the double layer is just sufficient to shield the ambipolar electric field existing in the illuminated region and thus to prevent it from penetrating the un - illuminated region .
the effect of the ionization friction force [ the second term on the rhs of eq .
( [ 2a ] ) ] is as well asymptotically small in the double layer , therefore the full energy of an ion is conserved as reflected by the relationship @xmath163 .
the double layer has the same mathematical nature as the intermediate transition layer separating an active plasma and a collisionless sheath , which was introduced in @xcite and revisited in , e.g. , @xcite .
the underlying physics is also the same and is related to the passage of the ion fluid through the sonic barrier @xcite .
in essence , the two layers represent the same physical object : the transonic layer , which in one case assumes the form of a double layer separating the illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas and in the other case the form of a ( positive - charge ) transition layer separating the plasma and a collisionless sheath . in the form of transition layer separating the plasma and a collisionless sheath ,
the transonic layer is difficult to identify in results of numerical solution of a full problem .
in fact , some researchers even believe that the transition layer is merely an artifact produced by the method of matched asymptotic expansions . however ,
the transonic layer at the edge of illuminated plasma , having the form of a double layer , is easily identifiable ; another proof that the transonic layer is distinguished by specific physical processes and is therefore not less real than , e.g. , the near - wall space - charge sheath .
the normalized ion speed in the un - illuminated plasma in plane geometry given by the asymptotic analysis equals @xmath164 , where @xmath165 .
given that @xmath166 equals @xmath70 when extrapolated to @xmath47 , a natural interpretation is that the ion fluid is accelerated up to @xmath70 ( the bohm speed ) in the illuminated plasma and from @xmath70 to @xmath164 in the double layer .
a similar interpretation applies to potential : the potential difference across the illuminated plasma equals @xmath167 and the potential difference across the double layer is @xmath168 .
the double layers in plane and cylindrical geometries are not qualitatively different as far as distributions of the electric field and space - charge densities are concerned .
however , distributions of the ion speed are significantly different : the ion fluid in the double layer is continually accelerated in cylindrical geometry .
this is a consequence of the appearance in the case @xmath7 of an additional term ( @xmath169 ) on the rhs of eq .
( [ 12a ] ) , which governs distribution of ion speed in the double layer .
this difference may look somewhat surprising : the double layer is asymptotically thin , i.e. , locally planar , so how can its curvature affect its structure ?
note , however , that this is not the only weak effect affecting the double layer : the ionization and separation of charges also play a role ; cf .
the first and second terms on the rhs of eq .
( [ 12a ] ) .
the reason for the latter was discussed in @xcite and applies to the curvature effect as well : the balance of forces acting over the ion fluid is delicate in the vicinity of the sonic point since the main effects ( inertia force and the electrostatic force ) cancel ; therefore , the weak effects ( ionization , curvature , and separation of charges ) also play a role .
one should stress in this connection that eq .
( [ 12a ] ) , describing acceleration of the ion fluid in the double layer , appears in the second approximation rather than in the first one .
in plane geometry , the ions enter the near - wall space - charge sheath with a speed that equals the bohm speed in the first approximation in @xmath105 . in other words , the bohm criterion is satisfied with the equality sign , which is a usual situation , and in the first approximation the near - wall sheath is the usual bohm sheath . in other words , the first term of the asymptotic expansion describing
the sheath in the considered problem is exactly the same as in situations involving an active plasma and a collisionless sheath , for example , in the problem treated in @xcite , or in a situation which would have occurred in the problem considered here if the whole plasma were illuminated .
however , the second terms of the asymptotic expansions describing the sheath in this problem and in usual situations should be different , which is due to the different behavior of the second - order term in the asymptotic zone adjacent to the sheath : in this problem , the second - order term of expansion of @xmath51 in the un - illuminated plasma is constant ( and equal to @xmath170 ) , while in usual situations the second - order term of expansion of @xmath51 in the transition layer has a pole at the wall .
thus , the near - wall space - charge sheath in the plane partially illuminated plasma is the usual bohm sheath to the first approximation in @xmath105 but not to the second approximation . in cylindrical geometry ,
the ions enter the sheath with a speed exceeding the bohm speed . in other words ,
the bohm criterion is `` oversatisfied '' ; a situation which was known to occur only in a few artificial models @xcite .
it has been known for many decades that a ( quasi - neutral ) presheath , in which the ion fluid is accelerated up to the bohm speed , must involve at least one of the following three mechanisms : ion - atom collisions , ionization , and multidimensional effects ; e.g. , @xcite . as far as ion - atom collisions and ionization are concerned , this result is somehow counterintuitive : in terms of ion momentum both ion - atom collisions and ionization represent a friction force , and why should a friction force be needed for acceleration ?
an explanation of this paradox is as follows .
of course , the ion fluid is accelerated by the electrostatic force while a friction force has a decelerating effect ; cf .
( [ 2a ] ) . on the other hand ,
the electrostatic force in a collisionless plane subsonic quasi - neutral plasma with frozen ionization would exceed the ion inertia force and the ion momentum balance can not be ensured ; cf .
( [ 6 ] ) with the rhs dropped .
in other words , a friction force , while not being the reason of acceleration of a plane subsonic ion flow under conditions of quasi - neutrality , is its necessary attribute .
the problem of plane partially illuminated plasma offers a remarkable illustration of this statement : the ion flow is accelerated in the illuminated plasma , where a friction force due to ionization is present ; there is no friction force in the un - illuminated plasma - and therefore no acceleration . in cylindrical geometry
the rhs of eq .
( [ 8a ] ) in the illuminated region equals @xmath171 and is negative . in the un - illuminated plasma the rhs of eq .
( [ 8a ] ) equals @xmath172 and is positive . in other words ,
cylindrical geometry provides a retarding effect in the subsonic region and the ion flow is accelerated due to the presence of the ionization friction force .
the sonic point occurs where the ionization friction force disappears .
cylindrical geometry provides an accelerating effect in the supersonic region .
the possibility of experimental testing was discussed in the first part of this work @xcite . in this connection ,
relevant is the case where the ionization profile is not described by the heaviside function and decays smoothly .
asymptotic structure of the solution will remain the same in this case provided that the decay is fast ( occurs on a length scale much smaller than widths of both illuminated and un - illuminated plasmas ) .
in particular , there will be a quasi - neutral double layer , where the sonic transition occurs .
the theory of the double layer developed in this work will remain applicable if length scale of the decay is much smaller than @xmath173 .
* acknowledgments * the authors appreciate stimulating discussions with r. n. franklin and j. e. allen
. work at universidade da madeira was supported by fct - fundao para a cincia e a tecnologia of portugal through the projects ptdc / fis - pla/2708/2012 and pest - oe / mat / ui0219/2011 .
in the region @xmath174 , eq .
( [ 43 ] ) does not explicitly depend on the independent variable ( is autonomous ) and admits an analytical solution , which may be found as follows . multiplying this equation by @xmath175 and integrating , one finds@xmath176 where @xmath177 is an integration constant . solving this equation for @xmath178 , choosing the sign in the square root with the use of the assumption that @xmath179 and integrating
, one obtains the desired solution in an implicit form @xmath180 where @xmath181 is a new integration constant . since the solution should exist for all positive values of @xmath169 , the integral on the lhs of eq .
( [ 45 ] ) should diverge at a certain value of @xmath113 .
the latter value should be finite , since the integral converges as @xmath182 , and should represents the double root of the cubic polynomial in the parentheses in the denominator .
such a root exists provided that @xmath183 and equals @xmath118 .
then the integral may be evaluated analytically and the solution may be transformed to an explicit form:@xmath184 the solution involves two integration constants , @xmath118 and @xmath181 , which have the meaning @xmath185 and @xmath186 .
it should be the case that @xmath187 , @xmath188 .
let us now consider eq .
( [ 43 ] ) in the region @xmath115
. the boundary condition at @xmath104 is expressed by eq .
( [ 44 ] ) with @xmath183 ; we recall that not only @xmath123 but also @xmath189 are continuous at @xmath104 as discussed in sec .
[ the second approximation ] .
another boundary condition is obtained by matching two terms of the expansion ( [ 30 ] ) with the first term of the expansion ( [ 10 ] ) and reads@xmath190 note that the problem ( [ 43 ] ) , ( [ 44 ] ) , ( [ 41 ] ) coincides with the problem describing the intermediate transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless sheath @xcite except for a different boundary condition at @xmath104 .
another substantial difference is in the way in which eq .
( [ 43 ] ) was derived : in @xcite it was derived by means of invoking the next ( third ) term of the asymptotic expansion ( [ 30])([33 ] ) , while in this work it was derived in a straightforward way from eq .
( [ ion_mom ] ) ; see discussion in @xcite .
constant @xmath118 may be eliminated from eq .
( [ 43 ] ) by means of substitution @xmath191:@xmath192 note that this equation coincides with the first painlev equation ( e.g. , @xcite ) to the accuracy of transformation @xmath193 , @xmath194 .
asymptotic behavior for @xmath195 of solutions of eq .
( [ 47a ] ) satisfying the matching condition ( [ 41 ] ) may be found to be@xmath196 \left ( 1+\dots\right ) \nonumber\\ & + \frac{c_{7}}{\left ( -x\right ) ^{1/8}}\exp\left [ -i\frac{2^{11/4}}{5}\left ( -x\right ) ^{5/4}\right ] \left ( 1+\dots\right ) , \label{16}\ ] ] where @xmath197 and @xmath198 are arbitrary constants .
the last two terms on the rhs of this expression are oscillatory and have to be eliminated in order that the asymptotic matching be possible beyond the first order ; i.e. , one should set @xmath199 .
thus , the proper boundary condition for eq .
( [ 47a ] ) is given by eq .
( [ 16 ] ) with @xmath199 and this boundary condition specifies a unique solution of eq .
( [ 47a ] ) .
note that this conclusion coincides with the corresponding conclusion in @xcite , although eq .
( [ 16 ] ) is not exactly the same . a convenient way of numerically finding the function @xmath113 for @xmath115 is as follows : eq .
( [ 47a ] ) is integrated with the initial condition @xmath200 from a large negative @xmath201 in the direction of increasing @xmath122 until the condition ( [ 44 ] ) written in the form@xmath202 has been met . the value @xmath203 at which the latter happens corresponds to @xmath104 , so one can find the constants @xmath204 and @xmath205 .
this calculation results in the function @xmath120 shown in fig . 1 by the solid line with @xmath206 , @xmath165 , @xmath207 .
also shown in fig .
1 is the dependence @xmath120 in the range @xmath208 , described by eq .
( [ 47 ] ) ; the dash - dotted line .
the dashed line represents data obtained when the numerical calculations described in the previous paragraph are not stopped when eq .
( [ 49 ] ) has been satisfied but rather continue until a pole has been encountered ; a procedure identical to the one employed in @xcite .
these data refer to the transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless sheath .
the dotted lines represent asymptotic behavior described by the first two terms on the rhs of eq .
( [ 16 ] ) and by expressions @xmath209 and @xmath210 , where @xmath211 is the position of the pole evaluated as @xmath212 times the value @xmath213 determined numerically in @xcite .
the composite expansion of the ion velocity uniformly valid in the illuminated plasma region to the double layer to the un - illuminated region is obtained by adding the expansion ( [ 30 ] ) and the first term of the expansion ( [ 10 ] ) and subtracting the common part:@xmath214 \ -\left [ 1-\sqrt{2\left ( 1-\xi\right ) } \right ] , \label{61}\ ] ] where the first and third terms on the rhs should be discarded for @xmath153 . in the illuminated plasma , the second and third terms on the rhs of eq .
( [ 61 ] ) virtually cancel and the first term is dominating as it should ; in the double layer the first and third terms virtually cancel or are discarded and the second term is dominating as it should ; in the un - illuminated plasma the first and third terms are discarded and @xmath215 , again as it should be .
error of eq .
( [ 61 ] ) is of the order of @xmath144 from the illuminated plasma to the double layer to the un - illuminated plasma .
the first - approximation composite expansion of the electric field is obtained by differentiating eq .
( [ 61a ] ) and reads @xmath217 relative error of this formula in the double layer is of the order of @xmath98 . a deficiency of eq .
( [ 62 ] ) is a discontinuity at @xmath47 , which stems from the limit for @xmath133 of the sum of the first and third term on the rhs being non - zero ( it equals @xmath218 ) .
this discontinuity is of the order @xmath98 relative to the main term and disappears in the next approximation .
imagine , for example , that the second term of the expansion of the electric field in the double layer [ i.e. , the term associated with the third term of the expansion ( [ 33 ] ) ] is @xmath219 .
then the composite expansion of the electric field would be @xmath220 -\left [ \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\left ( 1-\xi\right ) } } -1\right ] .\label{62a}\ ] ] relative error of this formula in the double layer would be of the order of @xmath144 and the rhs of eq .
( [ 62a ] ) is continuous . in reality , eq .
( [ 62a ] ) is of course no more accurate than eq .
( [ 62 ] ) : while the second term of the expansion of the electric field in the double layer is absent from eq .
( [ 62 ] ) , in ( [ 62a ] ) it is taken into account in a form which can be only qualitatively correct at best .
however , eq . ( [ 62a ] ) gives a continuous distribution of the electric field and is therefore preferable for illustrative purposes .
[ c]lfig . 2 .
asymptotic solution for distribution of ion speed in the vicinity of the sonic + barrier .
plane geometry .
solid + dash - dotted : double layer at the edge of illuminated + plasma .
solid + dashed : transition layer separating active plasma and a collisionless + sheath .
dotted : asymptotic behavior for large @xmath223 .
[ c]lfig . 3 .
distributions of normalized parameters in the double layer : the ion speed ( a ) , + the potential ( b ) , the electric field ( c ) , and the density of space charge ( d ) .
solid : + numerical calculations for @xmath221 and @xmath224 ( line 1 ) or @xmath225 ( 2 ) . + dashed : second - order term of the asymptotic expansion describing the double layer . + dotted : composite expansion .
[ c]lfig . 4 .
distributions of ion speed in the double layer and the un - illuminated plasma . +
solid : numerical calculations for @xmath221 and @xmath224 ( line 1 ) , @xmath225 ( 2 ) , + @xmath227 ( 3 ) . dotted : composite expansion . | the method of matched asymptotic expansions is applied to the problem of a collisionless plasma generated by uv illumination localized in a central part of the plasma in the limiting case of small debye length @xmath0 .
a second - approximation asymptotic solution is found for the double layer positioned at the boundary of the illuminated region and for the un - illuminated plasma for the plane geometry .
numerical calculations for different values of @xmath0 are reported and found to confirm the asymptotic results .
the net integral space charge of the double layer is asymptotically small , although in the plane geometry it is just sufficient to shield the ambipolar electric field existing in the illuminated region and thus to prevent it from penetrating into the un - illuminated region .
the double layer has the same mathematical nature as the intermediate transition layer separating an active plasma and a collisionless sheath , and the underlying physics is also the same .
in essence , the two layers represent the same physical object : a transonic layer . |
the swimming of fish and the flying of birds continue to pose challenging theoretical problems .
the physics of bird flight was first studied in detail by otto lilienthal in the nineteenth century @xcite . since then
, significant progress has been made in many years of dedicated research @xcite-@xcite .
the goal of theory is to calculate the time - averaged speed and power for given periodic shape variations of the body , at least for a simple model system .
it is assumed that the motion of the fluid is well described by the navier - stokes equations for an incompressible viscous fluid . on average over a period the force exerted by the body on the fluid vanishes , so that thrust and drag cancel . in early work by lighthill @xcite and wu @xcite
the thrust and power were calculated approximately as functions of the speed on the basis of potential flow theory for a planar strip .
this work and subsequent developments have been reviewed by childress @xcite , by wu @xcite,@xcite , and by sparenberg @xcite .
however , an independent calculation of the mean speed for given periodic shape variations is still lacking .
measurement of the power consumption has led to a surprisingly small friction coefficient , much smaller than that of an inert body , as was first observed by gray @xcite .
it was first shown by taylor @xcite that in the slow swimming of a microorganism the calculation of thrust can be circumvented . in this limiting case one can use the time - independent stokes equations .
the mean swimming velocity and mean rate of dissipation then follow from a purely kinematic calculation @xcite,@xcite . for small amplitude swimming both quantities
are quadratic in the amplitude of the stroke to lowest order . for a simple system , where the body is modeled as an assembly of rigid spheres held together by direct interaction forces and subject to periodic actuating forces which sum to zero
, we have shown that in the high viscosity limit the swimming velocity and power can be calculated for any amplitude of stroke from kinematics alone @xcite,@xcite . in the following we investigate questions of thrust , velocity , and power for swimming or flying in a fluid of any viscosity , including the limit of low viscosity , for the same mechanical model as before .
we assume for simplicity that the spheres experience stokes friction .
in addition we incorporate hydrodynamic interactions via virtual mass effects , as found from potential flow theory .
we use hamilton s equations of motion with added damping terms . in the limit of high viscosity , where resistive forces dominate ,
the earlier results are recovered .
the model provides valuable insight also in the limit of low viscosity , where reactive forces dominate . in that regime
the motion is dominated by virtual mass effects .
bernoulli forces and modified linear friction should be taken into account in a more realistic model .
nonetheless , the principle of the calculation , which exploits elimination of the fluid degrees of freedom , remains valid .
the flow is assumed to be laminar at all times .
it is now realized that the boundary layer of swimming fish is laminar even at high reynolds number @xcite .
virtual mass effects were discussed earlier by lighthill @xcite .
the numerical modeling of animal swimming and flight was reviewed by deng et al .
@xcite . as an example
a system of three equal spheres moving along a common axis is studied . for
this simple system the mean swimming speed and mean power to second order in the amplitude of stroke can be evaluated analytically .
the solution to a corresponding eigenvalue problem provides the optimal stroke to this order , as we found elsewhere in the resistive regime @xcite .
in our model the mean thrust , i.e. the frictional force exerted on the fluid averaged over a period in periodic swimming , vanishes identically .
we find that the velocity of the geometric center of the assembly is driven by a different force , which we call the impetus .
it has both a reactive and a resistive component .
the impetus determines the center velocity with retardation .
the mean impetus does not vanish .
it is known for small amplitude swimming in the resistive regime that the mean power is directly proportional to the mean velocity .
we find for our example that the relation between mean power and mean velocity is nearly linear also for large amplitude swimming .
presumably the near linearity holds also for other systems in the whole regime of viscosity .
if true , this would resolve the so - called gray paradox @xcite , which is based on the mistaken notion that the power is quadratic in the velocity , as in stokes friction .
we consider a set of @xmath0 rigid spheres of radii @xmath1 and masses @xmath2 , centered at positions @xmath3 , and immersed in an incompressible viscous fluid of shear viscosity @xmath4 and mass density @xmath5 .
the fluid is of infinite extent in all directions .
the flow velocity @xmath6 and pressure @xmath7 of the fluid are assumed to satisfy the navier - stokes equations @xmath8=\eta\nabla^2{\mbox{\boldmath $ v$}}-\nabla p,\qquad\nabla\cdot{\mbox{\boldmath $ v$}}=0.\ ] ] the flow velocity @xmath9 is assumed to satisfy the no - slip boundary condition on the surface of the spheres .
the fluid is set in motion by time - dependent motions of the spheres . at each time @xmath10
the velocity field @xmath6 tends to zero at infinity , and the pressure @xmath7 tends to the constant ambient pressure @xmath11 . as the spheres move in the fluid they experience a frictional force .
in addition there may be applied forces @xmath12 and direct interaction forces which depend on the relative positions @xmath13 of sphere centers .
we shall assume that the sum of applied forces vanishes , so that @xmath14 the sum of direct interaction forces vanishes owing to newton s third law .
we assume that the frictional forces are linear in the sphere velocities , as given by low reynolds number hydrodynamics on the slow timescale @xcite .
the spheres are freely rotating so that there are no frictional torques .
the forces exerted by pressure gradients resist instantaneous acceleration and give rise to virtual mass effects @xcite .
for a single sphere @xmath15 immersed in infinite fluid the virtual mass would be @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the mass of fluid displaced by the sphere .
the virtual mass effect for a collection of @xmath0 spheres is embodied in a @xmath18-dimensional mass matrix @xmath19 .
this can be derived from potential flow theory by considering the irrotational flow pattern generated instantaneously by a set of sudden impulses @xmath20 from a state of rest .
the total corresponding kinetic energy is @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the set of sphere velocities .
the kinetic energy is a sum of two contributions , @xmath23 , with @xmath24 where the integration is over the part of space occupied by fluid and @xmath25 is the velocity potential corresponding to the set of instantaneous velocities @xmath26 .
the potential @xmath25 is linear in the sphere velocities @xmath22 , so that the kinetic energy @xmath27 is a quadratic form in @xmath26 .
the contribution @xmath27 to the total kinetic energy defines the virtual mass .
this depends parametrically on the positions @xmath28 , leading to corresponding hydrodynamic interactions . besides the mass matrix @xmath19 it will be useful to define also the mobility matrix @xmath29 , the friction matrix @xmath30 , and the inverse mass matrix @xmath31 , @xmath32 the four matrices are symmetric and depend on the relative positions of the sphere centers .
the sphere momenta , including the virtual mass contribution , are given by @xmath33 correspondingly we postulate the equations of motion @xmath34 where @xmath35 is given by @xmath36 and @xmath37 is the potential of direct interaction forces .
the partial derivative @xmath38 is taken at constant momenta @xmath39 .
it is clear that the equations of motion ( 2.7 ) have only limited validity .
the frictional forces are assumed to be linear in the sphere velocities , and basset memory forces are neglected .
nonetheless it is of interest to explore the consequences of the equations as they stand .
we note that it follows from eq .
( 2.7 ) that total dressed sphere momentum @xmath40 is not conserved but changes due to friction with the fluid .
if an impulse @xmath41 is imparted at time @xmath42 to the spheres in a state of rest due to applied forces @xmath43 , then part of the momentum is transferred instantaneously to the fluid , reducing the sphere velocities to @xmath44 , as can be seen by integration over an infinitesimal time interval about @xmath42 and use of eq .
the remaining momentum of the spheres is transferred to the fluid in the course of time by friction .
the total momentum of spheres and fluid is conserved at all times .
we are looking for a solution of the equations of motion where the center of the assembly moves on average with uniform translational velocity and the individual spheres perform periodic motions about the moving center .
the velocity @xmath45 of the geometric center is defined by @xmath46 where the symbol @xmath47 denotes a @xmath48-dimensional vector with @xmath49 on the @xmath50 positions , @xmath51 on the @xmath52 positions , and cyclic .
the @xmath48-dimensional displacement vector @xmath53 is defined by @xmath54 with the property @xmath55 and with @xmath56 a set of equilibrium positions for which the direct interaction forces vanish .
correspondingly the velocity vector is decomposed as @xmath57 summation over repeated greek indices is implied . by substitution into eqs .
( 2.6 ) and ( 2.7 ) we find @xmath58+\frac{\partial\mathcal{k}}{\partial{{\bf\sf r}}}+{\mbox{\boldmath $ \zeta$}}\cdot(u_\beta{{\bf\sf u}}_\beta+\dot{{{\bf\sf d}}})+\frac{\partial v_{int}}{\partial{{\bf\sf r}}}={{\bf\sf e}}(t).\ ] ] multiplying from the left with the vector @xmath59 we obtain @xmath60 with mass tensor @xmath61 and friction tensor @xmath62 defined by @xmath63 we have used the fact that @xmath19 depends only on relative coordinates , so that @xmath64
. also we have used newton s third law and eq . ( 2.2 ) .
we note that in eq .
( 3.6 ) the center velocity @xmath65 occurs only in the two places explicitly shown .
we rewrite eq .
( 3.6 ) as @xmath66 with time - dependent impetus @xmath67 given by @xmath68 the mean impetus , averaged over a period @xmath69 , @xmath70 does not vanish , even though the total mean force exerted by the fluid on the assembly does vanish .
the drag exerted on the assembly by the fluid is @xmath71 the thrust @xmath72 is equal and opposite to the drag , @xmath73 .
there are frictional forces on the spheres , but on time average the total drag vanishes , @xmath74 , as follows from eqs .
( 2.2 ) , ( 2.7 ) and newton s third law for the interaction forces .
we use the fact that the integral of @xmath75 over a period vanishes by periodicity , as well as the property @xmath64 , mentioned below eq .
( 3.7 ) . from @xmath76
it follows that the mean impetus can also be expressed as @xmath77 we may regard eq .
( 3.8 ) as a balance between central and internal motion .
the equation must be solved for the center velocity @xmath45 for given impetus @xmath67 , which can be calculated from the displacement vector @xmath78 . in the resistive limit the total drag vanishes at any time @xcite and
the reactive forces vanish , so that then @xmath79 .
the displacement vector @xmath78 may be calculated from displacements in relative space by using a transformation to center and relative coordinates .
the geometric center of the assembly is given by @xmath80 with cartesian unit vectors @xmath81 .
we define relative coordinates @xmath82 with @xmath83 as @xmath84 and denote the corresponding @xmath85-vector @xmath86 .
the @xmath48-vector @xmath87 is related to the vector @xmath28 by a transformation matrix @xmath88 according to @xmath89 with explicit form given by eqs .
( 3.13 ) and ( 3.14 ) .
the displacement vector @xmath90 is derived from the displacement @xmath91 in relative space as @xmath92 therefore the impetus is determined by displacements in relative space .
the time - dependent rate of dissipation can be expressed in the same matrix formalism .
the rate of dissipation is given by @xmath93 once the center velocity @xmath45 has been calculated for known displacements we can also calculate the time - dependent rate of dissipation @xmath94 by use of eq . (
however , we derive an alternative expression which will be useful in the following .
we can solve for the product @xmath95 from the equation of motion @xmath96 where @xmath97 is the vector of mechanical forces acting on the spheres , @xmath98 which has the property @xmath99 . using this property we find for the rate of dissipation @xmath100 using here eq .
( 3.18 ) again we can rewrite this as @xmath101 with friction vector @xmath102 .
this generalizes an expression derived earlier in the resistive limit @xcite .
for vanishing displacements eq .
( 3.8 ) has the solution @xmath103 . by formal series expansion in powers of the displacement vector @xmath90
we obtain a corresponding expansion of the center velocity @xmath104 the first order velocity @xmath105 satisfies the equation @xmath106 where the superscript @xmath51 indicates that the quantity is calculated for the configuration @xmath107 . in particular for oscillating displacement , in complex notation @xmath108,\ ] ] we find correspondingly @xmath109^{-1}_{\alpha\beta}{{\bf\sf u}}_\beta\cdot(\omega^2{{\bf\sf m}}^0+i\omega{\mbox{\boldmath $ \zeta$}}^0)\cdot{{\bf\sf d}}_\omega.\ ] ] in this situation the first order velocity oscillates in time and vanishes on time average . multiplying eq .
( 3.8 ) by the mobility tensor @xmath110 and expanding to second order we obtain a more complicated equation for the second order velocity @xmath111 .
it suffices to derive an expression for the time - average over a period @xmath112 , @xmath113 using periodicity and the first order equation eq .
( 4.2 ) we obtain the expression @xmath114 alternatively the expression can be derived directly from eq . ( 3.12 ) by use of @xmath115 . here
we can use @xmath116 where @xmath117 indicates the gradient operator in configuration space , and the notation @xmath118 indicates that the value of the gradient is taken at @xmath107 .
the time average in the first term in eq .
( 4.6 ) can be expressed as @xmath119,\ ] ] with derivative friction matrix @xmath120 as introduced earlier @xcite . in the second term in eq .
( 4.6 ) we use the identity @xmath121 to show that @xmath122 with gradient vectors @xmath123 the first order velocity @xmath124 is eliminated by use of eq .
then the second order mean swimming velocity can be expressed as @xmath125,\ ] ] with frequency - dependent matrix @xmath126 given by @xmath127 with reduced derivative friction matrix @xmath128 with admittance tensor @xmath129^{-1},\ ] ] and impedance vector @xmath130 the matrix @xmath131 has the property @xmath132 since @xmath30 depends only on relative coordinates @xmath133 , and hence @xmath134 as a consequence @xmath135 these properties generalize those derived earlier at zero frequency @xcite .
to second order in the displacements the last term in eq .
( 3.21 ) can be written as @xmath136 in the average over a period the first term on the right does not contribute .
hence for periodic motion the mean second order rate of dissipation can be expressed as @xmath137\;dt.\ ] ] substituting eq .
( 4.4 ) we find @xmath138,\ ] ] with the complex matrix @xmath139 the matrix is symmetric and has the properties @xmath140={{\bf\sf 0}},\qquad\mathrm{re}[{{\bf\sf p}}(\omega)]\cdot{{\bf\sf u}}_\alpha={{\bf\sf 0}}.\ ] ] the properties eq . ( 4.20 ) and ( 4.25 ) allow us to reduce the dimension of the matrix description by three by introducing center and relative coordinates .
the transformation given by eqs . ( 3.13 ) and ( 3.14 ) can be used to reduce the calculation of the second order swimming velocity and rate of dissipation to one in relative space .
the matrices @xmath126 and @xmath141 are transformed to @xmath142 the first three rows of @xmath88 consist of @xmath143 and the first three columns of @xmath144 consist of @xmath59 .
it follows from the properties eq .
( 4.20 ) and ( 4.25 ) that the first three rows and columns of the transformed matrices @xmath145 and @xmath146 vanish identically .
hence in this representation we can drop the center coordinates and truncate the matrices by erasing the first three rows and columns .
we denote the truncated @xmath147-matrices as @xmath148 and @xmath149 and define displacements @xmath150 in relative space by @xmath151 with this notation the mean second order swimming velocity and rate of dissipation are given by @xmath152 with the matrix @xmath153\;{\mbox{\boldmath $ \hat{}$}}.\ ] ] this @xmath147 dimensional matrix consists of numerical coefficients and is obtained from the corresponding @xmath154 matrix by truncation , as indicated by the final hat symbol .
we rewrite the expressions in eq .
( 5.3 ) in a more convenient form with vectors and matrices consisting of dimensionless numbers .
we introduce the complex dimensionless vector @xmath155 where @xmath156 is a typical length scale , and define @xmath157,\nonumber\\ { { \bf\sf a}}&=&\frac{1}{b\eta}\;[\big({{\bf\sf c}}_t\cdot\hat{{{\bf\sf p}}}_t(\omega)\big|_0\big)^{s\prime}+i\big({{\bf\sf c}}_t\cdot\hat{{{\bf\sf p}}}_t(\omega)\big|_0\big)^{a\prime\prime}\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the superscript @xmath158 indicates the symmetric part , the superscript @xmath159 the antisymmetric part , the single prime the real part , and the double prime the imaginary part . with the scalar product @xmath160 the mean swimming velocity and mean rate of dissipation can then be expressed as @xmath161 the matrices @xmath162 and @xmath163 are hermitian .
we call @xmath162 the velocity matrix and @xmath163 the power matrix .
we ask for the stroke with maximum swimming velocity in a class of strokes with equal rate of dissipation for fixed values of the geometric parameters , fixed frequency @xmath164 , and given values of viscosity @xmath4 and mass density @xmath5 . maximizing the quadratic form @xmath165 with lagrange multiplier @xmath166 we obtain the generalized eigenvalue problem @xmath167 the eigenvalues @xmath168 are real .
the maximum efficiency @xmath169 for motion in direction @xmath170 is given by the maximum eigenvalue as @xmath171 the set @xmath172 depends on the choice of cartesian coordinate system .
further optimization may be possible by a rotation of axes .
in particular cases a natural choice of axes will suggest itself .
we view the swimmer or flyer as a dynamical system in periodic motion , driven by actuating forces @xmath173 satisfying @xmath174 and @xmath175 . in an expansion in powers of the actuating forces the first order displacements are given by eq .
( 4.3 ) . to second order the mean swimming velocity and mean
rate of dissipation are given by eq .
( 5.8 ) . in this section
we relate the mean power supplied by the actuating forces to the mean rate of dissipation .
the instantaneous power supplied by the actuating forces is given by @xmath176 from eq .
( 2.7 ) @xmath177 hence we find for periodic motion @xmath178 this shows that on time average over a period the power is fully dissipated by friction .
since the mean thrust vanishes the usual definition of energy wastage @xcite makes no sense here .
instead we define the energy wastage @xmath179 as the difference @xmath180 in the theory of fish swimming and bird flight the energy wastage has been associated with energy being lost to the vortical wake @xcite .
we define the corresponding froude efficiency as @xmath181 this concept may be useful for the comparison of different strokes .
in order to perform explicit calculations we must specify the form of the hydrodynamic interactions appearing in the friction matrix and the mass matrix . in practice one uses approximate expressions which are presumed to be reasonably accurate in the range of distances considered .
the friction matrix can be calculated from an approximation to the mobility matrix based on oseen s pair interaction @xcite . in this approximation
the pair mobility tensor for the pair @xmath182 is given by @xmath183(1-\delta_{jk}).\ ] ] the mobility matrix @xmath29 is composed of pair tensors , and the friction matrix @xmath30 is its inverse .
the calculation of the mass matrix @xmath19 is based on potential flow theory . a dipole approximation to the mass matrix
can be evaluated on the basis of an expression for the force on a sphere in a uniform flow in potential flow theory , as given by landau and lifshitz @xcite and by batchelor @xcite . in potential flow theory
the flow velocity is expressed as @xmath184 with a scalar potential @xmath185 , which satisfies laplace s equation @xmath186 by incompressibility .
a sphere of radius @xmath159 , centered at the origin and moving with velocity @xmath187 in a fluid at rest generates a potential @xmath188 corresponding to the dipole moment @xmath189 if the sphere is placed in a uniform flow @xmath190 this is modified to @xcite @xmath191 for a collection of @xmath0 spheres in a fluid at rest at infinity the velocities and dipole moments are related in dipole approximation as @xmath192 with dipole interaction tensor @xmath193 where @xmath194 .
we abbreviate eq .
( 7.5 ) as @xmath195 the velocity of sphere @xmath15 after a sudden impulse @xmath196 from a state of rest is given by @xcite,@xcite @xmath197 substituting from eq .
( 7.7 ) and solving for the velocities we find by use of eq . ( 7.5 ) and @xmath17 @xmath198 with matrix @xmath199^{-1},\ ] ] where the matrices @xmath200 and @xmath201 are diagonal with elements @xmath202 and @xmath203 .
the approximate effective mass matrix is @xmath204 if the spheres are neutrally buoyant one has simply @xmath205 in our application we shall consider this case .
the simplest application of the theory is to a three - sphere swimmer or flyer with the three spheres aligned on the @xmath50 axis , as studied by golestanian and ajdari @xcite in the resistive limit .
the spheres move along the @xmath50 axis , and the @xmath206 and @xmath207 coordinates can be ignored @xcite .
there are only two relative coordinates @xmath208 and @xmath209 , and the relevant parts of the matrices @xmath210 and @xmath163 are two - dimensional .
the relevant parts are denoted as @xmath211 and @xmath212 . in the bilinear theory
we consider a point @xmath213 in @xmath214-space with coordinates @xmath215 , corresponding to the configuration @xmath107 of the rest system . as an example we consider the case of equal - sized spheres with @xmath216 , equal masses @xmath217 , and equal distances between centers @xmath218 .
for this case analytic expressions for the matrices @xmath211 and @xmath212 can be derived , but are too complicated to be presented . in the high viscosity limit
the expressions reduce to those derived previously @xcite .
the matrices , defined with @xmath219 in eq .
( 5.6 ) , depend only on the ratio @xmath220 and the dimensionless viscosity @xcite @xmath221 the two eigenvalues @xmath222 , as well as the corresponding eigenvectors @xmath223 with @xmath224 , also depend only on these two variables .
the dependence on the viscosity @xmath225 is surprisingly slight over the whole range of @xmath225 values .
the absolute value @xmath226 is close to unity over the whole range . in fig .
1 we show the variation of @xmath227 and @xmath226 with @xmath225 for @xmath228 . the argument of @xmath229 increases slightly from @xmath230 at @xmath231 to @xmath232 at @xmath233 . in the bilinear theory the optimal orbit @xmath234 in relative space
is given by @xmath235 with @xmath236 and @xmath237,\ ] ] with amplitude factor @xmath238 .
the corresponding displacement vector in configuration space is given by @xmath239 in fig .
2 we show a snapshot of the spheres and their velocities in the instantaneous rest frame at @xmath42 for @xmath240 and @xmath241 . in fig . 1 of ref
. 15 we showed the elliptical orbit in relative space for @xmath228 and @xmath242 in the limit of high viscosity . in fig .
3 we compare this with the corresponding orbit in the limit of zero viscosity , corresponding to small @xmath225 .
the two plots are indistinguishable on the scale of the figure . from the periodic displacement @xmath243
we can calculate the instantaneous swimming velocity @xmath244 as a series of harmonics from eq .
the zeroth harmonic yields the mean swimming velocity @xmath245 . from @xmath244 and @xmath243
we can calculate the time - dependent rate of dissipation @xmath94 , and hence the mean @xmath246 , by use of eq .
( 3.17 ) . in fig .
4 we show the reduced mean swimming velocity @xmath247 as a function of @xmath238 for @xmath228 and @xmath241 . in fig .
5 we show the reduced mean power @xmath248 vs. the reduced mean swimming velocity @xmath247 in the range @xmath249 . in fig .
6 we show the efficiency @xmath250 as a function of @xmath238
. the efficiency increases monotonically with the amplitude factor . in fig .
7 we show the time - dependence of the impetus @xmath251 and the center velocity @xmath244 as functions of time during a period for @xmath252 .
we also plot separately the resistive contribution to the impetus . at this value of @xmath225
this is much smaller than the reactive part .
it is noteworthy that the variations in time of the center velocity are much smaller than those of the impetus .
the center velocity follows the impetus with an after - effect . in fig .
8 we show the absolute value of the fourier coefficients @xmath253 of the velocity @xmath244 , normalized to @xmath254 , for @xmath252 .
this shows that only a small number of harmonics contribute appreciably . the equality of mean power and mean rate of dissipation given by eq .
( 6.3 ) can be checked numerically .
the froude efficiency @xmath255 , defined in eq . ( 6.5 ) , for these three values of @xmath238 is @xmath256 , respectively .
it is of interest to compare the above results with values obtained from the numerical solution of the equations of motion eq .
( 2.7 ) with hydrodynamic interactions given by eqs . ( 7.1 ) and ( 7.12 ) and with prescribed oscillating actuating forces . in order to stabilize the system we consider microswimmers with internal harmonic interactions @xcite . in matrix form the forces may be expressed as @xmath257 with a real symmetric matrix @xmath258 with the property @xmath259 .
the actuating forces @xmath260 can be chosen to correspond to the eigenvector with maximum eigenvalue in the problem eq .
the first term in eq .
( 8.4 ) represents a harmonic approximation to the direct interactions .
we use harmonic interactions given by the @xmath261-matrix @xmath262 with elastic constant @xmath263 .
this corresponds to nearest neighbor interactions of equal strength @xmath263 between the three spheres .
the stiffness of the assembly is characterized by the dimensionless number @xmath264 defined by @xmath265 we use the first order equations of motion , @xmath266 to calculate the actuating forces @xmath267 corresponding to the optimal linear motion given by eqs .
( 8.3 ) and ( 4.4 ) .
these have the property @xmath268 , so that the sum of actuating forces vanishes .
we choose initial conditions corresponding to the rest configuration @xmath269 the kinetic energy term in eq .
( 2.7 ) makes the direct numerical solution of the equations of motion time - consuming .
instead we use an iterative procedure , neglecting the kinetic energy term in first approximation .
then the equations can be solved by a fast procedure . from the solution the kinetic forces , defined as @xmath270
, can be calculated as a function of time . in the next step
we include the kinetic forces and repeat the procedure .
the kinetic forces are small compared to the actuating forces and the solution converges after a few iterations . in fig .
9 we show the numerical solution of the equations of motion eqs .
( 2.6 ) and ( 2.7 ) with forces given by eq .
( 8.4 ) for @xmath228 , viscosity @xmath241 , stiffness @xmath271 , and amplitude factor @xmath272 for the first fifty periods . in fig .
10 we show the mean value of the kinetic energy for successive periods .
the orbit for the last period hardly differs from the ellipse given by eq .
( 8.3 ) , as shown in fig . 11 .
the mean swimming velocity and the mean rate of dissipation can be calculated as time - averages over the last period .
the efficiency is @xmath273 , equal to the value calculated from the periodic orbit by use of eq .
( 3.8 ) for displacements @xmath243 with @xmath272 , shown in fig .
in general the performance of a swimmer or flyer can be measured in terms of the dimensionless efficiency @xmath274 , defined as the ratio @xmath275 where @xmath159 is a conveniently chosen length scale , @xmath245 is the mean speed and @xmath276 is the mean power , averaged over a period @xmath112 .
we note that the lower bound of the efficiency @xmath274 vanishes , since for a periodic motion in relative phase space which is time - reversible the mean swimming velocity vanishes .
a striking result of the present analysis is that for the simple three - sphere model , for which analytic calculations can be performed , the maximum efficiency @xmath277 is nearly independent of the dimensionless viscosity @xmath278 , as shown in fig . 1 ,
( 5.10 ) . as a consequence
the mean speed is nearly inversely proportional to the shear viscosity @xmath4 for given power .
we expect that this is a general feature of the mechanical system defined by equations of motion of the type eq .
( 2.7 ) with hydrodynamic interactions as detailed in sec .
this explains the great advantage that birds in air have over fish in water .
a second result of the analysis is that the mean power is equal to the mean rate of dissipation , as shown in sec .
there is no additional energy loss related to the rate of change of the virtual mass .
the mean speed and mean power can be evaluated for more sophisticated model swimmers or flyers by similar analysis .
elsewhere we studied longer chains with both longitudinal and transverse excitation in the resistive limit @xcite .
that analysis can be extended to the full range of viscosity , based on the equations of motion eqs .
( 2.6 ) and ( 2.7 ) . for assumed periodic displacements
the velocity of the assembly can be derived from the equation of motion eq .
( 3.8 ) by decomposition in harmonics , as demonstrated in the three - sphere model .
the mean power is found as a collateral of the calculation .
the full range of viscosity is covered , so that the analysis provides an interesting link between the flying of birds , the swimming of fish , and the swimming of bacteria .
99 o. lilienthal , _ der vogelflug als grundlage der fliegekunst _
( r. gaertner s verlagsbuchhandlung , berlin , 1889 ) .
m. j. lighthill , _ mathematical biofluiddynamics _
( siam , philadelphia , 1975 ) .
s. childress , _ mechanics of swimming and flying _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1981 ) . c. j. pennycuick , _ modelling the flying bird _
( academic press , burlington ma , 2008 ) .
h. tennekes , _ the simple science of flight _ ( mit press , cambridge ma , 2009 ) .
m. j. lighthill , `` note on the swimming of slender fish '' , j. fluid mech .
* 9 * , 305 ( 1960 ) .
t. y. wu , `` swimming of a waving plate '' , j. fluid mech . * 10 * , 321 ( 1961 ) .
t. y. wu , `` on theoretical modeling of aquatic and aerial animal locomotion '' , adv .
38 * , 291 ( 2001 ) .
t. y. wu , `` fish swimming and bird / insect flight '' , annu . rev .
fluid mech . * 43 * , 25 ( 2011 ) .
j. a. sparenberg , `` survey of the mathematical theory of fish locomotion '' , j. eng . math . * 44 * , 395 ( 2002 ) .
j. gray , `` studies of animal locomotion '' , j. expl .
* 13 * , 192 ( 1936 ) . g. i. taylor , `` analysis of the swimming of microscopic organisms '' , proc .
london a * 209 * , 447 ( 1951 ) .
j. lighthill , `` flagellar hydrodynamics : the john von neumann lecture , 1975 '' , siam review * 18 * , 161 ( 1976 ) .
e. lauga and t. r. powers , `` the hydodynamics of swimming microorganisms '' , rep . prog .
phys . * 72 * , 09660 ( 2009 ) .
b. u. felderhof , `` swimming of an assembly of rigid spheres at low reynolds number '' , eur .
j. e * 37 * , 110 ( 2014 ) .
b. u. felderhof , `` efficient swimming of an assembly of rigid spheres at low reynolds number '' , arxiv1504.05794[physics.flu - dyn ] .
j. lighthill , `` large - amplitude elongated body theory of fish locomotion '' , proc .
b * 179 * , 125 ( 1971 ) .
deng , y .- q .
chen , h. dai , j. wian , and f .- b .
tian , `` on numerical modeling of animal swimming and flight '' , comput .
mech . * 52 * , 1221 ( 2013 ) . j. happel and h. brenner , _ low reynolds number hydrodynamics _
( noordhoff , leyden , 1973 ) .
j. lighthill , _ an informal introduction to theoretical fluid mechanics _ ( clarendon press , oxford , 1986 ) .
b. u. felderhof , `` comment on : ' ' circular motion of asymmetric self - propelling particles `` '' , phys .
rev . lett .
* 113 * , 029801 ( 2014 ) .
l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , _ fluid mchanics _ ( pergamon , oxford , 1987 ) . g. k. batchelor , _ an introduction to fluid dynamics _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1967 ) .
b. u. felderhof , `` virtual mass and drag in two - phase flow '' , j. fluid mech .
* 225 * , 177 ( 1991 ) .
r. golestanian and a. j. ajdari , `` analytic results for the three - sphere swimmer at low reynolds number '' , phys .
e * 77*. 036308 ( 2008 ) .
b. u. felderhof , `` optimization of flagellar swimming by a model sperm '' , arxiv:1412.3937 . a. s. sangani and a. prosperetti , `` numerical simulation of the motion of particles at large reynolds numbers '' in _ particulate two - phase flow _ ed .
m. c. roco ( butterworth - heinemann , boston , 1993 ) .
b. u. felderhof , `` the swimming of animalcules '' , phys .
fluids * 18 * , 063101 ( 2006 ) .
plot of the eigenvalue @xmath227 and the absolute value @xmath226 for the corresponding eigenvector @xmath279 of the three - sphere model with @xmath228 as functions of the dimensionless viscosity @xmath225 .
plot of the elliptical orbit in the @xmath280 plane corresponding to eq .
( 8.2 ) with @xmath281 and @xmath241 ( solid curve ) .
we also plot the elliptical orbit for the high viscosity limit ( dashed curve ) .
the two curves can not be distinguished on the scale of the figure .
plot of the impetus @xmath251 ( solid curve ) , the resistive contribution to the impetus ( short dashes ) and of the center velocity @xmath244 ( long dashes ) as functions of time during a period for the three - sphere swimmer for @xmath228 , @xmath241 and amplitude factor @xmath252 .
plot of the absolute values of the fourier coefficients @xmath253 of harmonics of frequency @xmath285 , normalized to @xmath254 , of the center velocity @xmath244 of the three - sphere swimmer for @xmath228 and @xmath241 with amplitude factor @xmath252 . | a mechanical model of swimming and flying in an incompressible viscous fluid in the absence of gravity is studied on the basis of assumed equations of motion .
the system is modeled as an assembly of rigid spheres subject to elastic direct interactions and to periodic actuating forces which sum to zero .
hydrodynamic interactions are taken into account in the virtual mass matrix and in the friction matrix of the assembly .
an equation of motion is derived for the velocity of the geometric center of the assembly . the mean power
is calculated as the mean rate of dissipation .
the full range of viscosity is covered , so that the theory can be applied to the flying of birds , as well as to the swimming of fish or bacteria . as an example
a system of three equal spheres moving along a common axis is studied . |
it is widely believed that the space - time , where physical process and measurements take place , might have a structure different from a continuous and differentiable manifold , when it is probed at the planck length @xmath0 .
for example , the space - time could have a foamy structure @xcite , or it could be non - commutative in a sense inspired by string theory results @xcite or in the sense of @xmath1- minkowski approach @xcite .
if this happens in the space - time , in the momentum space there must also be a scale , let say @xmath2 , that signs this change of structure of the space - time , even if the interplay between length and momentum ( @xmath3 ) will presumably change when we approach such high energy scales .
one could argue that , if the planck length gives a limit at which one expects that quantum gravity effects become relevant , then it would be independent from observers , and one should look for symmetries that reflect this property .
such argument gave rise to the so called dsr proposals , that is , a deformation of the lorentz symmetry ( in the momentum space ) with two invariant scales : the speed of light @xmath4 and @xmath2 ( or @xmath5 ) @xcite .
in this note , we will discuss this class of deformations of the lorentz symmetry and its realization in the space - time .
approaches to the problem inspired by the momentum space formulation have been presented @xcite , but our approach is quite different from these because we demand the existence of an invariant measurable physical scale compatible with the deformation of the composition law of space - time coordinates induced by the non linear transformation .
it has also been claimed that @xmath1-minkowski @xcite gives a possible realization of the dsr principles in space - time @xcite , however the construction is still not satisfactory since the former is only compatible with momentum composition law non symmetric under the exchange of particles labels ( see discussions in @xcite ) . in this work we are dealing with non linear realizations of the lorentz algebra which induce symmetric composition law and
therefore it is not compatible with the @xmath1-minkowski approach .
the main results of our studies are : _ i _ ) the strategy of defining a non linear realization of the lorentz symmetry with a consistent vector composition law can not be reconciled with the extra request of an invariant length ( time ) scale ; _ ii _ ) the request of an invariant length forces to abandon the group structure of the translations and leaves a space - time structure where points with relative distances smaller or equal to the invariant scale can not be unambiguously defined . in the next section
we will explore the approach to dsr in the momentum space and will implement these ideas in the space - time sector . in the final section conclusion and discussions are presented .
in this section we will first review the approach to dsr as a non linear realization of the lorentz transformations in the energy - momentum space , and then try to apply these ideas to the space - time . for
a more general review of dsr see for example @xcite and references therein .
dsr principles are realized in the energy - momentum space by means of a non - linear action of the lorentz group @xcite .
more precisely , if the coordinates of the physical space @xmath6 are @xmath7 , we can define a non- linear function @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the space with coordinates @xmath10 , on which the lorentz group acts linearly .
we will refer to @xmath9 as a _ classical _ momentum space . in terms of the previous variables ,
a boost of a single particle with momentum ] @xmath11 to another reference frame , where the momentum of the particle is @xmath12 , is given by @xmath13 \equiv { \cal b } [ p].\ ] ] finally , an addition law ( @xmath14 ) for momenta , which is covariant under the action of @xmath15 , is @xmath16+f[p_b]\right],\ ] ] and satisfies @xmath17 = { \cal b } [ p_a ] \hat{+ } { \cal b } [ p_b]$ ] . in this formulation ,
the requirement of having an invariant scale fixes the action of @xmath18 on some points of the real space @xmath19 .
indeed , since the lorentz transformation leaves the points @xmath20 and @xmath21 invariant , one sees that if we demand invariance of planck momentum ( @xmath22 ) ( or energy ( @xmath23 ) ) then @xmath24 $ ] ( or @xmath25 $ ] ) only can be @xmath26 or @xmath27 @xcite . a general discussion on the possible deformations is given in @xcite . in the following we explore the possibility to extend the above discussion generalizing it to define a non linear realization of lorentz symmetry in space - time . in analogy with the momentum space
, we will consider a _
real _ space - time @xmath28 with coordinates @xmath29 and will assume : @xmath30 ) the existence of an auxiliary space - time @xmath31 with coordinates @xmath32 ( called _ classical space - time _ ) , where the lorentz group acts linearly and @xmath33 ) the existence of an invertible map @xmath34 $ ] such that @xmath34:x \rightarrow { \cal x}$ ] .
boosts in the space - time will be defined in the same way as dsr boosts in the momentum space , that is @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the lorentz boost , which acts linearly on @xmath31 . as was done in the energy - momentum space ,
we want to define a space - time vector composition law covariant under the action of deformed boost : @xmath37+g[x_b]].\ ] ] this definition implies that a vector can always be written as the sum of two ( or more ) vectors and this decomposition is covariant under boosts : @xmath38-g[x_b ] \right ] = \hat{\delta}_{(ac)}~\hat{+}~\hat{\delta}_{(cb)},\ ] ] for any @xmath39 . with relation ( [ suma ] ) we can define the operation of translation of all vectors of our space by a fixed vector @xmath40 : @xmath41 with the above definition the translations behave as in the standard case under the action of boosts : @xmath42 it is easy to check that these transformations form a group .
we will call @xmath43 the neutral element of the group @xmath44 the neutral element for the composition law . from the relations ( [ suma]),([trasla ] ) we read that the neutral element is such that @xmath45=0 $ ] @xmath46 its image corresponds to the origin of the _ classical _ space . with the previous definitions we want to add the condition that , under the deformed boosts , an invariant measurable physical scale ( both a time or length scale ) has to exist . in doing that we have in mind that , eventually , this scale is related with the planck length ( or time ) .
let us call @xmath47 the vector which defines the invariant scale . by this we mean that @xmath47 is any vector of the form @xmath48 where @xmath49 is any spatial vector with modulus equal to the invariant scale and @xmath50 is the invariant time scale .
the invariance condition we impose is that a time ( length ) equal to the invariant scale is not affected by boosts .
this corresponds to the physical intuition that any planck - length segment ( whatever his time position ) or planck - time interval ( whatever his space position ) should remain unaffected by a change in reference frame : @xmath44 @xmath51 in the _ classical _ space we have the invariant @xmath52 whose image in the physical space is obviously invariant under the action of deformed boost .
this , together with the requirement of invariance under rotations , allows to demonstrate that the above relations have to satisfy @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
the above result is valid if we assume the existence of @xmath55 ) only a temporal invariant scale , @xmath56 ) only a spatial invariant scale , @xmath57 ) both a temporal and a spatial invariant scale .
for example , if we assume an invariant time scale @xmath50 , the vector @xmath58 ( with arbitrary @xmath59 ) under the action of a boost transformation has to be modified in such a way to keep @xmath50 fixed as well as to leave the casimir @xmath60 invariant .
since , in physically interesting cases , @xmath61 depends on the spatial coordinates only via the modulus @xmath62 , we get @xmath63 @xmath44 @xmath64 .
we get the interesting result that , assuming only a temporal invariant , all the vectors with time component equal to the invariant quantity ( and any @xmath59 ) keep the modulus of the spatial coordinate unchanged when boosted .
clearly this does not imply that any length scale is an invariant one since , in general , @xmath65 with @xmath66 if @xmath67 . the same analysis shows that , if we assume the existence of a length invariant , the casimir invariant implies @xmath68 for any @xmath69 value .
the final result is that our invariant vector(s ) has to satisfy the following relation @xmath70 or , equivalently , @xmath71=g[\hat{\delta}_{p}].\ ] ] the invariant points of standard lorentz transformations are @xmath26 and @xmath27 ( @xmath44 vectors where all the components are zero or infinity ) and we can only use one of this two points to ensure the condition ( [ invarianza ] ) . in dsr in the momentum space
we have a similar situation : in that case the fixed point at infinity is used to guarantee invariance of ( high ) energy or momentum scales . since we demand our model to be equivalent to usual space - time when the distances ( times ) are much bigger than the invariant scale we expect @xmath72 to approach the identity in this conditions and this implies @xmath73=\infty$ ] .
then the only possibility left is that the image of the invariant vectors under @xmath72 must be @xmath26 .
this condition is equivalent to the condition we used to define the neutral element of translations @xmath43 .
this result indicates that at this point we are getting in troubles : infinitely many different physical vectors are mapped to the same vector in the _ classical _ space @xmath44 the function @xmath72 can not be any more invertible when we approach the invariant scale .
for example if we consider two distinct points @xmath74 , @xmath75 and assume that their distance ( in space and/or time ) equals the invariant quantity we have to write @xmath76 and , after applying the @xmath72 function to previous relation , we get @xmath77=g[x_b]$ ] in contrast with our assumption of @xmath72 invertible . we conclude that , to satisfy the invariance condition , we loose the uniqueness of the neutral element of translations and therefore its group structure . , scaledwidth=32.0% ] in figure 1 we give an explicit realization of the temporal part of the @xmath72 function for a vector with a fixed spatial part and a varying temporal component in order to represent it as an ordinary one - dimensional function . as required , we recover the standard lorentz transformation for large times @xmath44 the @xmath72 function becomes the identity for @xmath78 while goes to @xmath26 once the invariant scale is reached .
it is clear that both the images of @xmath79 and @xmath80 are zero : we loose the uniqueness ( @xmath72 is not invertible at this points ) and an invertible extension of @xmath72 can not be defined on points in the interval @xmath81 $ ] .
what is happening is that , to enforce a physical invariant , we had to choose a @xmath72 function such that all the vectors of the _ classical _ space ( the vertical axis in fig .
1 ) map , in the physical space ( the horizontal axis in fig .
1 ) , into vectors with spatial or temporal length larger than the physical invariant scale . when we try to consider vectors in the physical space with spatial or temporal length equal or smaller than the invariant scale we have no counterpart in the _ classical _ space . for example , if we want to consider a vector @xmath82 that is half of the invariant vector we should write @xmath83 and this equation corresponds to @xmath34=-g[x]$ ] or , equivalently , @xmath34=0 $ ] , @xmath44 @xmath84 . with a speculative attitude
we can imagine that the model suggests that a process of space ( or time ) measurement can never give a result with a precision better than the invariant length since all points that differ by an invariant length are practically indistinguishable . in the particular example of fig .
1 , if @xmath85 is a time interval measured in a given space point , we have to conclude that we can not speak of @xmath86 or , equivalently , this can be understood as an indetermination in the measurement of time when the planck scale is reached .
therefore we can imagine this signals an intrinsic obstruction to measure a time ( distance ) when it becomes of the order of the invariant scale .
two comments are in order here .
we have demonstrated the impossibility of implementing a minimal scale ( in space , time or both ) in the space - time by means of a dsr - like approach .
however , it is clear that as occurs in dsr in the momentum space it is always possible to map the invariant scale ( space or time ) to infinity in the classical space time and to map the zero of the physical space time to the zero of the classical space time .
the resulting space - time will differ from the lorentz invariant one at large scales but it will not suffer the problems we discussed above : it will have a _ maximal scale _ ( and possibly a minimum momentum ) and will mirror the usual dsr in the momentum space . finally , let us say that the statement that the approach with a minimal scale is not possible , but the one with a maximal scale is allowed , can be understood by a dimensional argument . if we assume : _ i _ ) a continuous differentiable manifold structure for the space time , _ ii _ ) the the existence of a length scale @xmath87 , it is always possible to express any quantity depending on the coordinates as a series containing only negative powers of @xmath87 .
if we put the extra condition that _ iii _ ) it should exist a smooth limit toward the undeformed space time , it is clear the small @xmath87 limit can not be accepted .
the limit of large @xmath87 , instead , is well defined and the interpretation of the scale as a maximal scale becomes clear .
these arguments were already discussed in @xcite .
in this note we have explored a possible scenario for the a space - time with an invariant scale in a dsr based approach .
we started constructing a non linear realization of lorentz transformations defining a non linear , invertible map between the physical space and an auxiliary space where the lorentz group acts linearly . in doing that we introduce a deformed composition law for vectors in the physical space to guarantee its invariance under boosts .
up to this point we can still define a translation operator compatible with the deformed action of boosts , and this translations define a group .
then we try to impose the physical condition that some ( small ) measurable physical length ( in space or time ) should remain invariant under boosts . to define the space length we use the standard expression for the modulus of a vector ( again in full analogy with the dsr approach in momentum space ) .
we showed that the invariance requirement is incompatible with @xmath55 ) a well defined ( and invertible ) map for all the physical space vectors and @xmath56 ) with the group structure for the translations since the neutral element ( and consequently the inverse of any given translation ) can not be unique .
we understand why we encounter differences respect to the dsr approach in momentum space . for the latter
the invariant momentum is realized mapping the physical momentum space up to the maximum momentum ( energy ) to the entire _ classical _ space ( @xmath44 we obtain the invariant scale using the standard lorentz fixed point at infinity ) . in present case instead , we are forced to map the invariant scale to the first lorentz fixed point : the origin of vector space ( recall that both in coordinate and momentum space the lorentz transformations are linear and the only two fixed point are zero and infinity ) .
this procedure unavoidably leaves all vectors with spatial or temporal length smaller or equal to the invariant length without counterpart in the _ classical _ space .
the main difference of our result with other approaches in the literature @xcite , resides in the definition of the composition law ( [ suma ] ) , which has been introduced in order to extend the notion of covariance .
we think that the assumption of the standard composition law for vectors in the physical space is not correct .
to assume ( [ suma ] ) is an unavoidable step if we want to consistently construct a non linear realization of lorentz invariance . at the end of our construction
we arrive to inconsistencies .
a first possibility is , of course , to reject the idea that a dsr - like transformation can be defined in a coordinate space - time with an invariant scale . indeed
the connection of dsr models ( defined in momentum space ) with coordinate space is unclear @xcite and may be this connection will be realized only via a completely different approach . in any case , since the non - linear realizations of lorentz symmetry have been very successful in constructing new versions of particle s momentum space , we think it is worthwhile to explore the same technique further in the attempt to understand the possible structure of space - time . a possible way out is to accept that translations do not form any more a group and interpret the peculiar behavior of the non linear mapping @xmath72 as a clue for a fundamental indetermination at the scale of the invariant length .
this interpretation suggests a sort of ( space - time ) uncertainty , something that resembles what is expected to happen in a non commutative space - time .
alternatively we can speculate that defects ( as in a worm - hole qg vacuum @xcite ) might be present in space - time .
y.jack ng , lectures given at 40th winter school of theoretical physics : quantum gravity phenomenology , ladek zdroj , poland , 4 - 14 feb 2004 , _ gr - qc/0405078 _ ; a. perez , class .
20 * , 43 ( 2003 ) ; k. noui and p. roche , class .
grav.*20 * , 3175 ( 2003 ) ; y. jack ng , int . j. mod
d11 * , 1585 ( 2002 ) ; g. amelino - camelia , _ gr - qc/0104005 _ ; j. r. ellis , n. e. mavromatos and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . rev . * d63 * , 124025 ( 2001 ) ; a. perez and c. rovelli , phys . rev . * d63 * , 041501 ( 2001 ) ; l. j. garay , int . j. mod .
* a14 * , 4079 ( 1999 ) ; j. c. baez , class .
15 * , 1827 ( 1998 ) . | in this note we discuss the possibility to define a space - time with a dsr based approach .
we show that the strategy of defining a non linear realization of the lorentz symmetry with a consistent vector composition law can not be reconciled with the extra request of an invariant length ( time ) scale .
the latter request forces to abandon the group structure of the translations and leaves a space - time structure where points with relative distances smaller or equal to the invariant scale can not be unambiguously defined . |
in recent years , there has been a growing interest in testing gravitational decoherence or possible gravitational effects on quantum mechanics ( qm ) in condensed matter and quantum - optical systems @xcite .
decoherence can be studied in the framework of quantum mechanics and it does not require any additional assumptions .
the dynamics of a system which is coupled with the environment follows from the schrdinger equation .
an observer who has only access to system degrees of freedom observes a nonunitary dynamics which can be obtained by tracing out the environmental degrees of freedom from the total density matrix .
this averaging generically reduces the coherence of the reduced density matrix describing the system .
thus , a part of the phase information is distributed over the environmental variables . whether the phase information can be restored or not depends crucially on the form of the coupling and the properties of the environment .
we will address decoherence via emission of gravitational waves in section [ decoherence ] .
interestingly , it has also been argued that gravity might lead to a loss of coherence which can not be discussed in terms of standard quantum mechanics @xcite .
a prominent example of this `` intrinsic decoherence '' was discussed in @xcite .
there , it was argued that superpositions of static configurations have finite life - times and decay on a time - scale @xmath0 , where @xmath1 denotes the gravitational self - energy of the difference of the mass - distributions which are involved in the superposition .
the main motivation for such an effect is the lack of a canonical time - like killing vector when superpositions of space - times are considered . in section [ noise ] , we want to address the question whether it is possible to derive such a decoherence rate from a tensor noise model .
we point out several problems which come along when one introduces a tensor noise `` by hand '' .
every physical system is coupled to gravity via its energy - momentum tensor . in the weak - field limit
, the metric @xmath2 can be expanded around the minkowski background @xmath3 according to @xmath4 .
the resulting action is quadratic in the metric perturbations @xmath5 .
using the path integral formalism , the influence functional can be evaluated exactly .
when the metric perturbations have a time - dependent quadrupole moment , the environmental modes can carry away phase - information about the system which will lead to a real loss decoherence @xcite . in the following ,
we discuss the loss of coherence of a particle which does not move on a geodesic and radiates gravitational waves .
the analogue effect in electrodynamics due to emission of photons ( bremsstrahlung ) has been studied in @xcite . in this section ,
we follow notations used in @xcite .
the total action of a mass distribution which is centered around @xmath6 and coupled to gravity can be written as @xmath7 the action @xmath8 contains in general also gravitational self - interaction terms which are of higher order and will not be considered here .
we choose the transverse - traceless gauge , i.e. , @xmath9 .
then the graviton action adopts the simple quadratic form @xmath10 the interaction between the energy - momentum tensor @xmath11 of the system and the external graviton field is bilinear , i.e. , @xmath12 here only the spatial components of the energy - momentum tensor contribute due to the gauge choice above .
the graviton field can be expanded into plane waves according to @xmath13 where we introduced the transverse - traceless polarization tensors @xmath14 .
the time - evolution of the system s density matrix is determined by the action @xmath15 and the influence functional @xmath16 .
then the propagator of the reduced density matrix is given by @xmath17 where the subscripts @xmath18 indicate the initial and final values respectively .
the influence functional adopts the explicit form @xmath19\nonumber\\\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the correlation functions @xmath20 we assumed the environmental modes to be in a thermodynamical state with the inverse temperature @xmath21 .
the sum over polarizations gives the polarization tensor @xmath22 where the projection operators are @xmath23 .
the real and imaginary parts of the phase @xmath24 in the influence functional ( [ influence ] ) lead to dissipation and decoherence , respectively . in this section , we calculate @xmath25 from which the dependence of the decoherence rate on the various parameters of the model follows . as particular example
, we discuss the evaluation of ( [ phase ] ) using an interference device setup ( figure [ setup ] ) .
a matter distribution is in superposition of either following a right trajectory @xmath6 ( blue ) or a left one @xmath26 ( red ) . for a small angle @xmath27 ,
figure [ setup ] can be interpreted as the double - slit experiment , whereas @xmath28 corresponds to an interferometer . on both trajectories ,
the system changes its direction at time @xmath29 due to a slit or mirror .
the energy - momentum tensor of a particle in flat space - time takes the form @xmath30 with the velocity vector @xmath31 .
we assume that a particle is smeared out over a space - region determined by @xmath32 , i.e. , @xmath33\ , .
$ ] it is well - known that the divergence equation of the energy - momentum tensor gives the geodesic equation with respect to the background space - time .
however , the two possible trajectories of a particle in figure [ setup ] do not correspond to geodesics in minkowski space - time , hence @xmath34 .
generally , one would need to model a mirror , the interaction between a particle and a mirror and the interaction of gravity with the particle - mirror system . here
, we follow a simpler approach by adding momentum densities which kick a particle at @xmath29 .
thus , our system can be described now as `` particle + momentum density such that the energy - momentum tensor is divergence - free along the trajectories '' . in particular , we choose @xmath35 the time - time component @xmath36 can be chosen such that @xmath37 the additional momentum densities ensure that the divergence of the energy - momentum tensor @xmath38 vanishes along the trajectory . in order to obtain an interpretation of the momentum densities introduced , let us consider @xmath39 with @xmath40 and @xmath41
. then we have
@xmath42 we interpret this expression as follows : when @xmath43 , a particle moves straight in positive @xmath44- and @xmath45-directions . at time
@xmath46 , it gets a momentum transfer which changes its velocity in @xmath44-direction from @xmath47 to @xmath48 .
this corresponds to the right trajectory @xmath6 in figure [ setup ] .
a left trajectory @xmath49 which has a kick at @xmath46 towards the right can be constructed in the same way by defining @xmath50 .
path.eps ( 50,45)@xmath51 ( 50,110)@xmath51 ( 117,110)@xmath51 ( 133,124)@xmath52 ( 117,45)@xmath51 ( 85,40)@xmath27 ( 75,3)@xmath53 ( 45,10)@xmath44 ( 8,48)@xmath45 ( -15,76)@xmath54 ( 147,76)@xmath54 ( 75,143)@xmath55 ( 130,26)@xmath52 the dependence of decoherence rate on velocity @xmath51 of an object with temperature of gravitational waves @xmath56k and @xmath57k .
we chose the mass of an object @xmath58 kg . ] by substituting @xmath38 into ( [ phase ] ) and evaluating the thermal part of the expression ( [ phase ] ) along the trajectories , we find for velocities @xmath59 @xmath60 \sin^2\left(\frac{\theta}{2}\right)\nonumber\\ & \times\left(4\ln\left[\frac{\sinh\left(\pi t/(2\beta\right))}{\pi t/(2\beta)}\right ]
-\ln\left[\frac{\sinh\left(\pi t/\beta\right)}{\pi t\beta}\right]\right)+\mathcal{o}(v^8)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath61 is a time when two trajectories meet again . with an angle @xmath62 ,
the effect is approximately proportional to @xmath63 .
the authors of @xcite found the same velocity - dependence in the non - relativistic single - mode limit from a master equation approach . when @xmath64 and @xmath65 , we have @xmath66 the decoherence factor @xmath67 vanishes when two trajectories are parallel @xmath68 , that is , the trajectories coincide with each other . with @xmath69 ,
@xmath67 is proportional to @xmath70 , @xmath71 apart from thermal gravitational waves , vacuum fluctuations also contribute to the decoherence rate . for realistic parameters ,
this contribution is very small that it can be neglected .
its expression diverges logarithmically with the inverse of the spread of the mass distribution , @xmath72 . in figure 2
, we plotted the decoherence rate with the temperature of the gravitational waves being 1k and @xmath73k . since gravitational waves decoupled earlier from photons and have therefore a lower temperature than the cosmic microwave background
however , the actual temperature of the thermal gravitational waves background can be much lower and it depends on the details of reheating after inflation @xcite . here
, we assume a thermal contribution with 1k as the upper bound and vacuum contribution would be the lower bound on the decoherence rate .
we claim that the decoherence effect comes along with the emission of gravitational waves .
the emitted energy of a particle along one of the trajectories depicted in figure [ setup ] can be calculated classically .
the emission occurs when the direction of a particle is changed by a mirror .
as long as the emitted radiation can be distinguished for trajectories , the environment measures which path a particle is moving to some extent , and this leads to environmental gravitational decoherence .
for a trace - reversed perturbation , @xmath74 , the solution to the linearized einstein equations gives the expression @xmath75 when the particle is slowly moving , the far field is dominated by quadrupole moment tensor @xmath76 . in terms of the trace - free quadrupole moment , @xmath77 , the emitted power is @xmath78 here we will assume a smooth trajectory of a particle which moves along one path @xmath79\hat{\mathbf{x}}+ v\cos(\theta/2)[f(t,0)-f(t , t)]\hat{\mathbf{y}}\,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath80 . the time @xmath81 determines
how fast the direction of a particle is changed at a mirror , how fast a particle is accelerated initially from a source and decelerated at a detector finally . in the limit @xmath82 , the radiated energy is crucially determined by @xmath81 , @xmath83 for vacuum fluctuations , the minimal possible time @xmath81 is determined by the extension of the particle , that is @xmath84 . for finite temperatures , the effective cutoff of the gravitational modes
is determined by @xmath85 , so one should expect @xmath86 .
it has been argued that the incompatibility between general relativity and quantum mechanics may lead to a form of intrinsic decoherence @xcite .
such an effect , if it exists , is not related to any form of environmental degrees of freedom which carry away phase information from the system .
the conflict between the principle of general covariance and the superposition principle of quantum mechanics is fundamental : when gravity is dynamical , the geometry of space - time must depend on the quantum state of the matter which it contains .
thus , different matter states live in different space - times which can not be identified pointwise with each other .
one might argue that the difference of three - forces in the superposed space - times give an estimate for the typical life - time of a superposition .
this life - time @xmath87 is given by @xmath88 with @xmath89 [ \rho(\mathbf{x}')-\rho'(\mathbf{x}')]}{|\mathbf{x}-\mathbf{x'}|}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] although the relation ( [ gamma_penrose ] ) has not been derived from fundamental physics and although it is not clear yet , whether an intrinsic decoherence exists in nature at all @xcite , we want to address the question , whether this decoherence rate can be derived in some limit from a noise model .
scalar noise models have been studied in the literature , see , for example @xcite .
however , we want to couple the energy - momentum tensor to the noise which requires a tensor random current .
furthermore , we assume that the life - time ( [ gamma_penrose ] ) is the newtonian limit of a more general expression .
a possible generalization would be @xmath90 where @xmath91 is the green s function for linearized gravitational waves .
since @xmath91 is not positive definite , we are immediately confronted with a problem : the expression ( [ gamma_penrose_mod ] ) can also adopt negative values , which invalidates the interpretation of a decoherence rate . in the context of quantum mechanics , this would violate the positivity of the density matrix since the off - diagonal elements would be unbounded , @xmath92 \langle i |\hat{\rho}(0)|j\rangle , \qquad i\neq j\ , .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , it might be possible that terms such as ( [ gamma_penrose ] ) or ( [ gamma_penrose_mod ] ) are only a part of a more general _ positive _ definite quantity .
the simplest covariant terms which can be added to the fierz - pauli action take the form @xmath93 with arbitrary constants @xmath52 and @xmath94 .
here we introduced the tensor noise @xmath95 which couples to the linearized gravitational field and to the energy - momentum tensor .
the first term would correspond to a stochastic contribution of the energy - momentum tensor whereas the second part resembles stochastic gravitational fluctuations .
the gauge - invariance of the graviton field requires @xmath96 .
furthermore we assume the gaussian distribution @xmath97 of the tensor noise to be @xmath98=\frac{1}{n}\exp \left(-\frac{1}{2}\int d^4x j_{\mu\nu } j^{\mu\nu}\right)\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] contrary to section [ decoherence ] , we will use the de - donder gauge .
this includes also the instantaneous interaction between stationary matter distributions in addition to the radiation part of the gravitational perturbations . after performing the integrals over @xmath95 and @xmath5 , additional contributions to the influence functional arise due to the presence of the noise . in the non - relativistic limit
, we find for large times the expression @xmath99\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath100 denotes the influence functional due to gravitational waves .
assuming an energy - momentum tensor of the form @xmath101 , the decoherence rates @xmath102 have a simple interpretation .
@xmath103 measures the difference of the newtonian gravitational potentials in the respective spacetimes , @xmath104 @xmath105 is equal to the expression ( [ gamma_penrose ] ) up to a numerical factor and accounts for the difference of the newtonian forces , @xmath106 dimensional arguments might suggest that @xmath107 .
finally , @xmath108 incorporates the difference of the mass densities , @xmath109 it is not yet clear whether this result is a gauge - independent statement .
the time - evolution of the density matrix requires a definite choice of the time - parameter @xmath110 .
( we are not interested in scattering matrix elements where the interaction decreases adiabatically to zero for @xmath111 and lorentz - invariant quantities can be defined . ) a change in the time - parameter , corresponding to an transformation of the metric components , might alter the expression for the decoherence rate .
we studied the decrease of coherence due to the emission of gravitational waves and gave an estimate for the emitted gravitational energy .
the dominant contribution of the decoherence rate is given by thermal gravitational waves .
due to the smallness of the gravitational interaction , this effect is negligible for elementary particles . if it would be possible to send an object with mass @xmath112 kg and velocity @xmath113 m/s through an interferometer , the decoherence rate would be roughly @xmath114s@xmath115 with temperature of gravitational waves being 1k .
furthermore , we discussed a tensor noise model which partly resembles , in the newtonian limit , a form of intrinsic decoherence which was discussed in the literature before .
the coherence decrease due to this noise model depends on the difference of the mass density , the gravitational potential and the newtonian 3-force of the superposition .
the authors would like to thank g. w. semenoff , d. carney , d. scott , b. l. hu , c. anastopoulos and w. g. unruh for helpful discussions , and express our gratitude to p. c. e. stamp for support .
f. s. is partially supported by a ubc international tuition award , ubc faculty of science graduate award , the research foundation for opto - science and technology , nserc discovery grant and cfi funds for crucs .
the part of the work was supported by the templeton foundation ( grant number jtf 36838 ) .
9 marshall w , simon c , penrose r and bouwmeester d 2003 _ phys .
lett . _ * 91 * 130401 kleckner d et al .
2008 _ new journal of physics . _
* 10 * 095020 kaltenbeck r et al . 2012 _ exp astron . _
* 34 * 123 penrose r 1996 _ general relativity and gravitation . _
* 28 * 581 - 599 penrose r 1986 , in _ quantum gravity 2 : a second oxford symposium _ , oxford university press penrose r 1986 , in _ quantum concepts in space and time _ , oxford university press disi l 1987 _ phys .
lett . _ * 120 * a 377 - 381 krolyhzy f 1966 _ nuovo cim . _ * 52 * 390 krolyhzy f 1974 , magyar fizikai polyoirat * 12 * 24 komar a b 1969 , int .
j. theor .
* 2 * 157 omns r 1992 , rev .
64 * 339 unruh w g 2000 _ in relativistic quantum measurement and decoherence _ eds breuer h p and petruccione f ( springer ) pp 125 - 140 breuer h and petruccione f 2001 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 63 * 032102 - 1 breuer h and petruccione f 2002 _ the theory of open quantum systems . _ ( oxford ) anastopoulos c 1996 _ phys .
_ d * 54 * 1600 anastopoulos c and hu b l 2013 _ class .
quantum grav . _ * 30 * 165007 hu b l 2014 _ j. phys .
ser . _ * 504 * 012021 anastopoulos c and hu b l 2008 _ class .
quantum grav . _ * 25 * 154003 cloutier j and semenoff g w 1991 _ phys .
_ d * 44 * 3218 - 3229 | we discuss decrease of coherence in a massive system due to the emission of gravitational waves .
in particular we investigate environmental gravitational decoherence in the context of an interference experiment .
the time - evolution of the reduced density matrix is solved analytically using the path - integral formalism .
furthermore , we study the impact of a tensor noise onto the coherence properties of massive systems .
we discuss that a particular choice of tensor noise shows similarities to a mechanism proposed by disi and penrose . |
when the size of a magnetic system is reduced to a characteristic length , the system has a bigger surface to volume ratio giving rise to a great many outstanding thermal and magnetic properties compared to the conventional bulk systems @xcite .
advanced functional magnetic nanostructures in different geometries , such as nanowires , nanotubes , nanospheres , nanocubes are center of interest because of their technological @xcite and scientific importance as well as biomedical applications @xcite . from the experimental point of view , many studies have been carried out to discuss and understand the origin of the fascinating physical properties observed in magnetic nanoparticles @xcite .
for example ,
recently the multi - functional core - shell nanowires have been synthesized by a facile low - cost fabrication process @xcite .
based on this study , it has been shown that a multidomain state at remanence can be obtained , which is an attractive feature for the biomedical applications . in another interesting study
, the authors show the presence of a robust antiferromagnetic coupling between core and shell in ferrimagnetic soft / hard and hard / soft core - shell nanoparticles based on fe - oxides and mn - oxides @xcite .
they have also used a computational model to support the physical facts observed in the experiment . moreover
, it is a fact that core - shell nanoparticle systems exhibit two important phenomena , namely exchange bias and magnetic proximity effects .
these are completely due to the interface effects of the system . for detailed reviews on the exchange bias and magnetic proximity phenomena
, the readers may follow the references @xcite .
ferrimagnetic materials have a compensation temperature under certain conditions . at this special temperature region
, the net magnetization of the sample vanishes below its critical temperature @xcite .
the phenomenon of ferrimagnetism in bulk material is associated with the counteraction of opposite magnetic moments with unequal magnitudes located on different sublattices in the same system . according to the refs .
@xcite , interestingly coercive field presents a behavior with a rapid increment at the compensation point .
existence of such a point has a technological importance @xcite , because at this point only a small magnetic field is required and enough to change the sign of the net magnetization .
however , the origin of the compensation point found in the nanostructures is quite different from those observed in the ferrimagnetic bulk materials .
magnetic nanoparticles can exhibit a compensation point due to the existence of an antiferromagnetic interface coupling at the ferromagnetic core and ferromagnetic shell interface even if the lattice sites in the core and shell parts of the system are occupied by identical atomic spin moments .
hence , investigation of ferrimagnetism in nanoparticle systems has opened a new and an intensive field in the research of the critical phenomena in magnetic nanoparticles .
for example , the critical and compensation temperatures properties of cylindrical nanowire and nanotube systems have been performed by means of effective - field theory with single - site correlations @xcite . in these studies ,
the authors have also focused their attention on the effects of the surface and its dilution on the magnetic properties of the considered system , and it is reported that these systems display a compensation point for appropriate values of the system parameters . very recently , thermal and magnetic phase transition features of a core - shell spherical nanoparticle with binary alloy shell have been studied by making use of monte carlo simulation based on single - spin flip metropolis algorithm @xcite . here ,
the authors claim that the system may demonstrate one , two or even three compensation points depending on the selected hamiltonian as well as on the concentration parameters .
in addition to these , critical behaviors of core - shell nanoparticles with ferromagnetic materials but with antiferromagnetic interface exchange coupling are studied by means of a self - consistent local mean - field analysis @xcite .
it has been found that compensation temperature depends on all the material parameters , namely the core and shell radius , and the magnetic field .
although the mechanism and physics underlying of the critical behavior of the magnetic nanoparticles may be treated and understood with idealized interfaces and surfaces of the nanoparticle , real magnetic nanoparticles have some small defects . from this point of view
, experimental systems showing exchange bias may contain statistical distributions due to the presence of randomly located defects in the system @xcite .
recently , ho and co - workers have attempted to address the magnetic properties of a ferromagnetic / antiferromagnetic core - shell nanospherical particle including the vacancies at the antiferromagnetic interface , based on monte - carlo simulation method @xcite .
it is found that the frustrated spins at the ferromagnetic interface is another pinning - source generating exchange bias phenomenon , in addition to the antiferromagnetic shell spins .
furthermore , the influences of non - magnetic defects on the exchange bias of core - shell nanoparticles have been analyzed by benefiting from monte carlo simulation , and it is shown that exchange bias can be tuned by defects in different positions @xcite . apart from these , evans et al .
@xcite presented exchange - bias calculations for fm core / afm shell nanoparticles with roughened interfaces .
they showed that the magnitude of exchange bias is strongly correlated with the degree of roughness .
moreover , in a very recent paper , dimitriadis et al .
@xcite simulated cubic and spherical particles showing exchange bias phenomenon .
according to their results , in terms of exchange bias characters , the distinction between cubic and spherical particles is lost for moderate roughness .
based on the previously published studies , it is possible to mention that thermal and magnetic properties of the core - shell nanoparticles containing the surface and interface defects and also roughened interfaces are complicated and interesting compared to the clean nanoparticle systems .
it is certain that the studies taking these effects into account play a crucial role in having a better insight of the physics behind real magnetic nanoparticle systems .
however , much less attention has been given to determine the influences of the disorder and roughness on the critical behavior of the core - shell nanoparticles , and there are still many unresolved issues . motivated by these facts , we intend to search answers for the following questions : * what are the effects of the nonmagnetic impurities at the surface and interface of a core - shell type spherical nanoparticle on the critical and compensation behavior ?
is it possible to control the magnetic behavior of the core - shell nanoparticles by means of concentration of the vacancies ?
* what kind of physical relationships may emerge between the physical properties of the system and the interface roughness ?
the main motivation of the paper is to make an attempt to determine the physical facts underlying these questions .
furthermore , particular attention has been dedicated to elucidate the effects of the system size on the critical behavior of the system .
we believe that the findings obtained in this work would be beneficial for the future theoretical and experimental research in magnetic nanoparticles including disorder effects .
the outline of the remainder parts of the paper is as follows : in section [ formulation ] , we present the model and simulation details .
the results and discussion are given in section [ results ] , and finally section [ conclude ] includes our conclusions .
is coated by an fm shell of thickness @xmath0
. total radius of the particle is denoted by @xmath1 . at the interface ,
the outermost core and the innermost shell layers interact with an afm exchange coupling .
, title="fig:",width=226 ] + we consider a spherical nanoparticle which has been schematically depicted in fig .
[ fig1 ] with a fm core which is surrounded by a fm shell . at the core - shell interface ( which is composed of the outermost core and the innermost shell layers ) we define an afm exchange coupling .
the interface region consists of two successive monolayers . the total radius of the particle and the thickness of the shell are denoted by @xmath2 and @xmath0 , respectively .
a classical heisenberg spin resides at each lattice site of a simple cubic structure , and the nearest neighbor sites are separated from each other by unitary lattice spacing .
the system can be defined according to the following hamiltonian @xmath3 where @xmath4 represents a classical heisenberg spin vector with unit magnitude , and the former three sums are taken over the nearest - neighbor sites whereas remaining terms are taken over all the lattice sites . in practice ,
spin structure of interface in such systems is experimentally inaccessible , and it is quite a challenge to determine the magnetic nature near interface .
therefore , in order to theoretically investigate the ferrimagnetic properties of the system , we consider the following hamiltonian parameters : spin - spin interactions between core and shell spins are taken as ferromagnetic @xmath5 whereas interactions at the core - shell interface are of antiferromagnetic type @xmath6 . due to the reduced coordination number at the surface , fm exchange interactions between shell spins are usually smaller than those between core spins .
hence , we select @xmath7 with @xmath8 .
easy axis magnetization of the particle is assumed to be along the @xmath9 direction by assigning nonzero values for the @xmath9 components of the uniaxial anisotropy constants @xmath10 and @xmath11 for the particle core and shell , respectively . in order to emphasize the surface effects
, we set @xmath12 @xcite .
a variety of values for the total radius has been considered as @xmath13 and @xmath14 throughout the simulations , corresponding to the particles with @xmath15 and @xmath16 spins , respectively . however , in most cases , the shell thickness has been varied at the expense of the core which mimics the case of the production process for the surface chemically modified nanoparticles @xcite .
our simulations are based on an improved metropolis algorithm for classical heisenberg spins @xcite , and we apply free boundary conditions in all directions . following physical quantities
have been calculated in the simulation process : * thermal and configurational averages of the instantaneous magnetizations , @xmath17 where @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 denote the average magnetizations corresponding to core , shell , interface parts , and total system , respectively with corresponding number of lattice sites @xmath22 , @xmath23 , @xmath24 and @xmath25 which depend on the shell thickness and the total radius of the particle .
hence , using eq .
( [ eq2 ] ) , the magnitude of the magnetization vector can be computed via @xmath26 for any distinct region of the particle .
* internal energy and specific heat per lattice site can also be calculated using @xmath27 in order to calculate the temperature dependence of magnetization and specific heat curves , we have performed simulations with @xmath28 steps at each temperature . in order to allow the system to reach a stationary state , we have discarded the first @xmath29 steps for thermalization . in the calculations
, we set @xmath30 for simplicity .
+ + in this section , let us discuss the results for the particles with disordered surface and interfaces .
however , before presenting these results , it would be beneficial to take a glance at the magnetic properties of the pure system .
the results for the total magnetization @xmath31 and specific heat per spin @xmath32 as a function of temperature , as well as the shell and overall particle sizes are shown in fig .
these results have been obtained after averaging over 10 different sample realizations at each temperature .
the error bars obtained via jackknife method @xcite are smaller than the data symbols .
as shown in this figure , nanoparticles with different structural parameters may exhibit different magnetization profiles .
namely , according to the nel classification scheme , thermal dependence of magnetization curves can be classified in several categories .
for instance , as shown in fig .
[ fig2]a , the magnetization curves exhibit @xmath33 type behaviors with increasing shell thickness in successive order whereas for fixed shell thickness , such as @xmath34 , we obtain @xmath35 type of behaviors , respectively for increasing total radius @xmath2 , ( c.f .
see fig [ fig2]c ) .
the existence of @xmath36 type magnetization profiles is important in technological applications @xcite . from figs .
[ fig2]c and [ fig2]d , it can be deduced that the specific heat curves may exhibit two successive maximum points .
those observed at low temperature region originates due to the thermal fluctuations in the shell , however the high temperature peak is a consequence of the thermal variation of the core magnetization .
the magnitude of the both peaks are size dependent : core ( shell ) peak with a cusp - like divergent behavior becomes a broadened hump as the core ( shell ) magnetization loses its dominance with varying system size .
we also note that the temperature value corresponding to the peak located at high temperature region is the sole transition temperature @xcite since , the system becomes completely paramagnetic above this temperature . after presenting this general overview of the pure case ,
let us discuss the effects of disorder due to the surface and interfacial impurities , as well as roughened interfaces .
due to its technological importance , we will focus our attention on the variation of compensation behavior @xcite of the system in the presence of above mentioned disorder effects .
nanoparticle system in the presence of surface disorder can be simulated by considering randomly distributed non - magnetic sites on the surface and in the interior regions of the shell layer ( except the innermost shell sites which are located at the core - shell interface region ) . in this case , the modified hamiltonian defining the system reads @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the site occupancy parameter which takes values zero or unity , depending on whether the lattice site @xmath39 exhibits nonmagnetic or magnetic character , respectively . in this manner
, the total amount of disorder is controlled with a parameter @xmath40 , such that @xmath41 means all the lattice sites in the particle shell are magnetic whereas @xmath42 means that no magnetic lattice points reside in the outer shell , and in this case , the only contribution for the shell magnetization comes from the innermost shell spins ( i.e. from the interfacial shell spins ) .
taking the above mentioned model as a basis , we plot the phase diagrams in a ( @xmath43 ) versus @xmath40 plane in fig .
[ fig3 ] for three different total radius values such as @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 with a fixed shell thickness @xmath34 .
the horizontal data in fig .
[ fig3 ] denotes the transition temperature of the system which is not affected from the dilution of the shell region by non magnetic impurities . as shown in fig .
[ fig2]b , this system exhibits a compensation point below the transition temperature in the absence of disorder . by examining fig .
[ fig3 ] , one can see that bigger particles exhibit lower compensation point @xmath47 which decreases gradually with increasing disorder , and vanishes at a critical @xmath48 value .
besides , the compensation frontier in the phase diagram reaches to stronger disorder regime for smaller particles .
the representative plots for color - maps of total magnetization @xmath49 and the specific heat @xmath32 with @xmath50 and @xmath34 corresponding to the phase diagrams depicted in fig .
[ fig3 ] are given in fig .
according to fig .
[ fig4]a , the compensation behavior originates in the low temperature and weak disorder region , since the particle size is relatively big . at very low temperatures
, the total magnetization can be calculated from @xmath51 , hence it reaches its maximal value when the shell magnetization is weak due to afm exchange at the interface . in this context , by taking the afm structure of the interface exchange coupling into account , we have @xmath52 , @xmath53 for a perfectly pure particle @xmath54 .
therefore , it yields @xmath55 , whereas for fully imperfect case @xmath56 , for @xmath52 and @xmath57 , we find @xmath58 which agrees well with the results shown in fig .
[ fig4]a . according to the nel classification scheme @xcite ,
@xmath31 exhibits @xmath36 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 type of behaviors with increasing disorder . from fig .
[ fig4]b , it is clear that the specific heat exhibits two successive peaks for @xmath41 . however , as the amount of magnetic lattice sites in the shell progressively decreases then the lower temperature peak tends to disappear .
apart from these , both from fig .
[ fig4]a and [ fig4]b , one should notice that the transition temperature of the system is located around @xmath62 , and it is insensitive to the presence of shell disorder , since the major contribution to the magnetism of the particle mainly comes from the core part .
plane for the simulated particles with @xmath34 , @xmath63 .
the other system parameters are fixed as : @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , @xmath67.,title="fig:",width=226 ] + + in this subsection , we discuss and present results for nanoparticles with disordered interface sites . in this regard , one should modify the hamiltonian given in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) as @xmath68 where @xmath38 is the site occupancy parameter , as usual .
@xmath40 is the ratio of magnetic sites located at the core - shell interface with @xmath41 and @xmath69 , respectively corresponding to the cases with pure and maximally disordered situations .
[ fig5 ] shows the variation of compensation point @xmath47 and transition temperature @xmath70 as functions of @xmath40 for three different values of the total radius @xmath2 of the particle .
this figure shows that @xmath47 always decreases , but the transition temperature does not change with increasing interface disorder .
there exists a region in the disorder spectrum such as @xmath71 where @xmath47 linearly decreases with decreasing @xmath40 such as @xmath72 , and the dashed lines accompanying the simulation data denote the linear fitting curves . the linear variation region becomes narrower for bigger particles . from our data we find @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 for respective radius values @xmath76 , @xmath77 , and @xmath46 .
the statistical error due to fitting procedure is in the order of @xmath78 in all cases .
+ + the representative contour plots regarding the magnetization @xmath49 and specific heat @xmath32 as functions of temperature and parameter @xmath40 are shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] for @xmath50 and @xmath34 corresponding to the phase diagrams displayed in fig .
the variation of @xmath47 as a function of @xmath40 around @xmath79 is not clearly visible since the constant of proportionality @xmath80 is very small .
however , the system always maintains its @xmath36 type magnetization with varying @xmath40 . at the ground state ,
when @xmath41 , the total magnetization @xmath49 is given by @xmath81 as before , ( see fig . [ fig4 ] ) .
on the other hand , in the maximally disordered case , among the number of @xmath82 sites of the interface region , a number of @xmath83 and @xmath84 sites belonging to core and shell interface regions are nonmagnetic .
hence the total magnetization reads @xmath85/65267|=0.117 $ ] which is in accordance with the results given in fig .
apart from these , specific heat curves exhibit two successive peaks due to the reasons described in our previous discussions .
as a final investigation in this work , we consider magnetic nanoparticles with roughened interfaces in the following discussions . in order to simulate particles with rough interfaces
we use a method very similar to those utilized in previous works @xcite .
namely , for a given shell thickness and particle radius , we determine the radius @xmath86 of the ferromagnetic core .
then we generate a local radius @xmath87 value for each interface lattice site @xmath88 .
this local radius is drawn from a gaussian distribution which has variance @xmath89 , and it is centered at @xmath86 . in this way , we sample number of @xmath24 different random variables .
if the local radius @xmath87 of a particular interface lattice site @xmath88 satisfies the inequality @xmath90 then this lattice site remains unaltered .
in other words , if it belongs to the core interface , it remains in there throughout the generation process for the particle shape ( in our simulations , the parameter @xmath91 corresponds to @xmath92 of the unitary lattice spacing ) . on the other hand ,
if @xmath87 does not satisfy the above inequality , then we generate a random number @xmath93 within the interval @xmath94 .
if @xmath95 then the @xmath96 lattice site belongs to the core interface , else it is assigned to the shell interface . using this process , amount of roughness
is controlled by varying the gaussian distribution width @xmath89 , and we successfully create roughened interfaces without producing isolated nonmagnetic sites @xcite .
cccccccccc sample & @xmath2 & @xmath0 & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath25 + 1 & 25.0 & 2.0 & 50883 & 14384 & 5354 & 5670 & 11024 & 65267 + 2 & 25.0 & 6.0 & 28671 & 36596 & 3594 & 3854 & 7448 & 65267 + 3 & 15.0 & 2.0 & 9171 & 4976 & 1674 & 1854 & 3528 & 14147 + 4 & 15.0 & 6.0 & 3071 & 11076 & 794 & 918 & 1712 & 14147 + + + + + + + + + + + before proceeding further , it would be useful to clarify the effect of interface exchange coupling @xmath100 on the thermal and magnetic properties of the particle system . for this aim
we prepare sample realizations corresponding to four different samples ( see table [ table1 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig7 ] , we show the influence of exchange coupling @xmath100 on the thermal variation of total magnetization @xmath49 and specific heat @xmath32 curves . at first sight , it is clear that neither small nor large particles can exhibit a compensation point unless the shell thickness is greater than a critical value ( see fig .
[ fig2]a ) . furthermore ,
even if the system exhibits a compensation point @xmath47 , varying @xmath100 values do not alter the location of @xmath47 .
a similar scenario is also valid for the transition temperature .
however , varying @xmath100 values only affect the magnitude of the low temperature specific heat peaks .
these aforementioned results may indicate that the interfacial roughness may have no any significant effect on the compensation phenomenon . keeping this in mind ,
we prepare samples according to table [ table1 ] with roughened interfaces .
these structures are also schematically illustrated in fig .
[ figx ] . in fig .
[ fig9 ] , we depict the results for @xmath49 and @xmath32 curves with four distinct samples corresponding to fig .
[ figx ] from which one can deduce that the degree of roughness does not play any significant role on the variation of both the compensation point and critical temperature .
this result supports our predictions based on fig .
[ fig7 ] . finally , let us show how the interface magnetizations regarding the core and shell regions are affected from the roughness effects . in this context ,
[ fig10 ] concludes that increasing amount of roughness does not alter the transition temperature of the system , but reduces the low temperature saturation magnetizations of the core and shell interface regions .
in conclusion , by benefiting from monte carlo simulation based on an improved metropolis algorithm , we carry out a systematic investigation to elucidate the finite temperature magnetic properties of core - shell spherical nanoparticles containing quenched surface and interface disorders as well as roughened interface effects .
some efforts have also been taken to study the particle size effects on the thermal and magnetic properties of the particles .
after a detailed numerical analysis , most prominent observations underlined in the present work can be briefly summarized as follows : * for core - shell spherical nanoparticles with imperfect surface layers , it is found that bigger particles exhibit lower compensation point which decreases gradually with increasing amount of vacancies , and vanishes at a critical value . in view of the specific heat treatment as
a function of the temperature , the specific heat demonstrates two successive peaks for clean case , namely @xmath41 .
however , as the amount of magnetic lattice sites in the shell progressively decreases then the lower temperature peak tends to disappear . * for particles with diluted interface ,
our numerical results indicate that there exists a region in the disorder spectrum where compensation temperature linearly decreases with decreasing dilution parameter .
it is interesting to note that the linear variation region becomes narrower for bigger particles . *
it is found that the degree of roughness at the interface of the particle does not play any significant role on the variation of both the compensation point and critical temperature . however , the low temperature saturation magnetizations of the core and shell interface regions sensitively depend on the roughness parameter . as a final conclusion ,
we note that more work is required to match and understand the theoretical and experimental findings regarding the thermal and magnetic properties of the advanced functional core - shell nanoparticles in different geometries .
the numerical calculations reported in this paper were performed at tubitak ulakbim high performance and grid computing center ( tr - grid e - infrastructure ) .
10 natexlab#1#1bibnamefont #
1#1bibfnamefont # 1#1citenamefont # 1#1url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2]#2 [ 2][]#2 a.e .
berkowitz , r.h .
kodama , s.a .
makhlouf , f.t .
parker , f.e .
spada , e.j .
mcniff jr . , and s. foner , j. magn .
magn . mat . *
196 * , 591 ( 1999 ) .
t. hayashi , s. hirono , m. tomita , and s. umemura , nature * 381 * , 772 ( 1996 ) .
d. guo , g. xie , and j. luo , j. phys .
47 * , 013001 ( 2014 ) .
pankhurst , j. connoly , s.k .
jones , and j. dobson , j. phys .
phys . * 36 * , r167 ( 2003 ) .
k. mcnamara , and s.a.m .
tofail , advances in physics : x * 2:1 * , 54 ( 2017 ) .
y.p . ivanov , a. alfadhel , m. alnassar , j.e .
perez , m. vazquez , a. chuvilin , and j. kosel , sci . rep .
* 6 * , 24189 ( 2016 ) .
p. bhatt , a. kumar , s.s .
meena , m.d .
mukadam , and s.m .
yusuf , chem .
lett . * 651 * , 155 ( 2016 ) .
b. martnez , x. obradors , li .
balcells , a. rouanet , and c. monty , phys .
80 * , 181 ( 1998 ) .
m. estrader , a. lpez - ortega , s. estrad , i.v .
golovsky , g. salazar - alvarez , m. vasilakaki , k.n .
trohidou , m. varela , d.c .
stanley , m. sinko , m.j .
pechan , d.j .
keavney , f. peir , s. suriach , m.d .
bar , and j. nogus , nat . commun . * 4 * , 2960 ( 2013 ) .
bhowmik , j. magn .
mater . * 323 * , 311 ( 2011 ) .
manna , and s.m .
yusuf , phys .
rep . * 535 * , 61 ( 2014 ) .
m. kiwi , j. magn .
magn . mater . * 234 * , 584 ( 2001 ) .
j. nogus , j. sort , v. langlais , v. skumryev , s. suriach , j. s. muoz , and m. d. bar , phys . rep . * 422 * , 65 ( 2005 ) . a. berkowitz , and k. takano , j. magn .
mater . * 200 * , 552 ( 1999 ) .
iglesias , a. labarta , and x. battle , j. nanosci .
* 8 * , 2761 ( 2008 ) .
l. nel , ann .
paris * 3 * , 137 ( 1948 ) .
p. hansen , j. appl . phys . * 62 * , 216 ( 1987 ) . g.m .
buendia , and e. machado , phys .
b * 61 * , 14686 ( 2000 ) .
shieh , and m.h .
kryder , appl .
49 * , 473 ( 1986 ) .
m. mansuripur , j. appl . phys . * 61 * , 1580 ( 1987 ) .
t. kaneyoshi , phys .
status solidi b * 248 * , 250 ( 2011 ) .
t. kaneyoshi , physica a * 390 * , 3697 ( 2011 )
. n. zaim , a. zaim , and m. kerouad , solid state commun . * 246 * , 23 ( 2016 ) .
n.r . anderson , and r.e .
camley , phys .
b * 94 * , 134432 ( 2016 ) . r.f.l .
evans , d. bate , r.w .
chantrell , r. yanes , and o. chubykalo - fesenko , phys . rev .
b * 84 * , 09204 ( 2011 ) . r.f.l .
evans , r.w .
chantrell , and o. chubykalo - fesenko , mrs bulletin * 38 * , 909 ( 2013 ) .
l.b . ho , t.n .
lan , and t.h .
hai , physica b * 430 * , 10 ( 2013 ) .
z. mao , x. zhan , and x. chen , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 24 * , 276002 ( 2012 ) . v. dimitriadis , d. kechrakos , o. chubykalo - fesenko , and v. tsiantos , phsy .
b * 92 * , 064420 ( 2015 ) .
t. kaneyoshi , j. phys . : condens
* 3 * , 4497 ( 1991 ) .
d. hinzke , and u. nowak , comput .
. commun . * 121 - 122 * , 334 ( 1999 ) .
g. marsaglia , ann .
43 * , 645 ( 1972 ) .
evans , w.j .
fan , p. chureemart , t.a .
ostler , m.o.a .
ellis , and r.w .
chantrell , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 26 * , 103202 ( 2014 ) .
newman , and g.t .
barkema , monte carlo methods in statistical physics , clarendon press , oxford , 2001 .
t. miyazaki , h. jin 2012 the physics of ferromagnetism ( springer series in materials science 158 ) ; s. chikazumi , 1997 the physics of ferromagnetism ( oxford science publications 94 ) ; here , instead of critical temperatures observed in the thermodynamic limit , we mean a pseudo critical one , since we are dealing with a finite particle .
if a magnetic system exhibits compensation phenomenon then the spontaneous total magnetization reverses its sign at a particular temperature called as the compensation temperature . | being inspired by a recent study [ v. dimitriadis et al .
phys .
rev .
b * 92 * , 064420 ( 2015 ) ] , we study the finite temperature magnetic properties of the spherical nanoparticles with core - shell structure including quenched ( i ) surface and ( ii ) interface nonmagnetic impurities ( static holes ) as well as ( iii ) roughened interface effects .
the particle core is composed of ferromagnetic spins , and it is surrounded by a ferromagnetic shell . by means of monte carlo simulation based on an improved metropolis algorithm , we implement the nanoparticles using classical heisenberg hamiltonians .
particular attention has also been devoted to elucidate the effects of the particle size on the thermal and magnetic phase transition features of these systems . for nanoparticles with imperfect surface layers , it is found that bigger particles exhibit lower compensation point which decreases gradually with increasing amount of vacancies , and vanishes at a critical value . in view of nanoparticles with diluted interface
, our monte carlo simulation results suggest that there exists a region in the disorder spectrum where compensation temperature linearly decreases with decreasing dilution parameter . for nanoparticles with roughened interface
, it is observed that the degree of roughness does not play any significant role on the variation of both the compensation point and critical temperature .
however , the low temperature saturation magnetizations of the core and shell interface regions sensitively depend on the roughness parameter . |
hierarchical clustering governed by cold dark matter ( cdm ) is widely believed as a cosmological scenario which is responsible for the growth of the structures in the universe . according to the hierarchical scenario
, small dark matter halos should collapse earlier , but later fall into larger structures .
the process of smaller halos being assembled into a larger halo does not always destroy the smaller ones , thus hierarchical structures are seen in many objects , such as clusters of galaxies .
recent high - resolution simulations have successfully shown that hundreds of galaxy - size dm halos survive in clusters of galaxies @xcite .
a remarkable outcome of the high - resolution cosmological simulation in standard cdm model by @xcite even shows that survival of substructures or satellites occurs not only on cluster scales , but also on galactic scales .
they show that a galaxy of a similar size as the milky way should contain about 500 satellites , which is , however , much more than the number of the observationally identified satellites .
that many satellites should survive , was confirmed also by @xcite and @xcite .
klypin et al .
note that the results of the standard cdm simulation are close to those of a @xmath0cdm simulation with the same circular velocity function of substructures .
this indicates that the prediction of the presence of many satellites is a general outcome of the hierarchical scenario and not particularly dependent on the cosmological models .
compared with the observational results , these cosmological models yield a large number of the satellites , approximately a factor of 50 more than the number of satellites observed in the vicinity of the milky way .
@xcite suggest that the problem of the missing satellites could be resolved ( i ) by identification of some satellites with the high - velocity clouds observed in the local group @xcite or ( ii ) by considering dark satellites that failed to gather enough gas to form stars , because of expulsion of gas the supernova - driven winds or because of gas heating by the intergalactic ionizing background .
the latter possibility implies that the halos of galaxies may contain substantial substructures in form of numerous invisible dm clumps .
a statistic of strong gravitational lensing is an approach to identify the dark clumps in the milky way .
@xcite indeed finds evidence for the existence of the numerous satellites in the milky way .
if a great amount of the dark satellites exist within the milky way s halo , their interaction with the disk might cause disk heating . in their standard cdm model
, @xcite found that a large fraction of the substructures have very eccentric orbits , so that they could cause resonant heating of the disk , and even heating by impulsive shocking owing to their penetration through the disk . on the other hand
, it is known that the milky way has a quite thin disk , whose scale height is about 200 pc . from the `` thinness ''
@xcite have made an energetical analysis of the disk heating owing to accretion of matter , and derived the constrain that the milky way should have accumulated no more than 10 % of the disk mass within the past 5 gyr .
this estimation of the disk heating might , however , be too large because the actual interaction between the disk and satellites is more complicated .
for example , a single satellite could dissolve before reaching the disk @xcite or the energy injected into the disk could excitate coherent warping motions rather than heat the disk @xcite . for the case of the interaction of the disk with many substructures in the halo ,
additional detailed numerical investigations are necessary . @xcite
have studied the case of the @xmath0cdm cosmological model , and found that the substructures are not efficient perturbers for heating of the disk , since the masses of the clumps are lower than those of the clumps predicted in the standard cdm model , and also because the clumps are located far away from the disk and seldom get near the disk .
the disk kinematics and dynamics is a good probe not only for examining the cosmological models , but much more generally for clarifying the halo substructure that is difficult to derive from direct observations .
therefore in this study we aim to investigate disk heating by dark matter ( dm ) clumps for a wide range of parameters .
numerical experiments on the disk dynamics are not an easy task , especially when studying the vertical structure , because of the wide range of the dynamical scales among the different components in galaxies .
the smallest scale is disk , with a scale height about 200 pc , while the largest scale is the dark halo extent of @xmath1 kpc .
many numerical studies consider disks of 700 pc ( @xmath2 the disk scale length ) in thickness @xcite . the question is whether the heating rate obtained for such thick disks is the same as for thin disks like the real galactic disk . in this study
we construct our initial galactic models following @xcite , which is nearly in exact equilibrium and which allows us to set up disks as thin as the real galactic disk .
several additional observational constraints are taking into account to build the galactic models .
we study three physical effects that could affect disk heating ; first the mass spectrum of the dm clumps , second the initial thickness of the galactic disks , and the third the spatial distribution of the clumps .
this paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we present the galaxy model which provides a very stable thin disk comparable to the real milky way disk . a model of a clumpy dark matter halo
is presented in section 3 .
numerical simulations of the interaction between disk and the clumps are specified in section 4 .
section 5 presents the results of our numerical simulations on the disk heating by examining the effects on the mass spectrum of the clumps , the initial disk thickness , and the spatial distribution of the clumps .
we summarize and discuss our results in section 6 .
we use the self - consistent disk - bulge - halo galaxy model given by kuijken and dubinski ( 1995 , hereafter kd ) .
this model provides nearly exact solutions of the collisionless boltzmann and the poisson equations , so that one can control subtle differences in the initial conditions .
this is important especially to set up very thin equilibrium disks , which is the most difficult part . using this model we could successfully realize an equilibrium disk with realistic thickness of only 200 pc .
here we summarize the model properties briefly .
the configurations of the disk , bulge and halo are determined by their distribution functions .
the bulge distribution function depends only on the relative energy @xmath3 , while that of the halo depends also on the angular momentum about the symmetric axis , @xmath4 .
the halo distribution function takes the form @xmath5
\left [ \exp ( -e/\sigma_0 ^ 2 ) -1\right ] \quad & \mathrm{if } e<0 , \\ 0 & \mathrm{otherwise } , \\
\end{array } \right.\ ] ] the relative energy @xmath3 is defined so that @xmath6 at the edge of the distribution , where @xmath7 .
the halo distribution function has five free parameters : the potential at the center @xmath8 , which appears implicitly in the definition of the relative energy , the velocity scale @xmath9 , and three factors @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and @xmath12 .
the factors @xmath10 and @xmath11 control the system flattening ( @xmath13 ) and the core radius ( @xmath14 ) , respectively , and all the three factors are scaled by the density scale ( @xmath15 ) .
the bulge distribution function takes the same form of a king model @xcitewhich is given by @xmath16 & \{\exp[-(e-\psi_\mathrm{c})/\sigma_\mathrm{b}^2]-1\ } \\ & \mbox{if } e<\psi_\mathrm{c } , \\ 0 & \mbox{otherwise}. \end{array } \right.\ ] ] this distribution depends on three parameters : the cutoff potential @xmath17 , the center density @xmath18 , and the velocity dispersion @xmath19 . for halo and bulge distributions ,
the densities are given by analytic functions of @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
the disk distribution function must depend on three integrals of motion so that it can sustain a triaxial velocity ellipsoid within the disk .
since the third integral is not analytic , kd employ an approximate form of the distribution function which depends on @xmath3 , @xmath4 and the vertical energy @xmath22 .
@xmath23 is only an approximate integral , but well conserved for stars in nearly circular orbits in a warm disk .
this quantity is the only approximation in kd s model .
the distribution function takes the form @xmath24\ ] ] where @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the radius and energy of a circular orbit with angular momentum @xmath4 . @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the circular and epicyclic frequencies at radius @xmath26 , respectively .
the ` tilde ' functions @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 are free functions . therefore the density and the radial velocity dispersion are conveniently selected as @xmath33,\ ] ] and @xmath34 @xmath30 and @xmath32 are iteratively adjusted so that the densities on the mid - plane and at height @xmath35 will agree with those given by eq .
( [ eq : disk_density ] ) .
the distribution of the disk has six free parameters : the disk mass @xmath36 , the radial scale length @xmath37 , the vertical scale height @xmath38 , the disk truncation radius @xmath39 , the truncation width @xmath40 , and the central velocity dispersion of the disk @xmath41 .
the choice of the above parameters is made to satisfy observational properties of the milky way ( see also @xcite ) , that is the solar radius @xmath42 = 8 kpc , the circular velocity of the disk at the solar radius @xmath43 km / s , the total surface density within 1.1 kpc of the disk plane @xmath44 @xcite , the contribution of the disk material to @xmath45 , @xmath46 @xcite , the total galaxy mass within 50 kpc @xmath47 @xcite , and the total galaxy mass within 170 kpc @xmath48 @xcite .
we assume that the disk mass is @xmath49 , the disk scale length @xmath50 kpc , the disk scale height @xmath51 pc , and the disk truncation radius and the truncation width are @xmath52 and @xmath53 , respectively .
the bulge mass is about 15 % of that of the disk , while the tidal radius is 2.38 kpc . the contributions of the bulge and disk to the rotation curve is shown in fig .
[ fig : modelf_circ ] .
we also examined thicker disks with @xmath54 pc and 1050 pc , as described in the next section .
for the halo , we assume @xmath10=0 in eq .
[ eq : halodf ] , which means that the halo is nearly spherical , except for the flatness caused by the presence of the disk potential . as for the extent of the halo , we consider two different models .
one has the virial radius at 262 kpc , with a dark matter mass of @xmath55 .
we refer to it as the _ standard halo model_. the other has the virial radius at 1.35 mpc , with a mass of @xmath56 , which is called the _ extended halo model_. the difference between the two models lies only in the outer part of the halos .
the inner density profiles ( @xmath57 kpc ) are about the same ( fig .
[ fig : modelf_dens ] and fig .
[ fig : modelf+_dens ] ) , thus the rotation curves of the bulge , disk , and the halo are nearly equivalent between two models ( fig . [ fig : modelf_circ ] and fig .
[ fig : modelf+_circ ] ) .
the extended halo model is introduced only to produce different clump distributions as described below .
the halo and the bulge are treated as an external force , while the distribution of the disk is realized by self - consistent particles . without the substructure clumps in the halo ,
this model is fairly stable .
the net increase in the disk thickness is only due to 2-body relaxation among the disk particles , which is only @xmath58 pc after 4.76 gyr .
the numerical cosmological simulations @xcite have demonstrated the presence of the dark matter clumps within dark halos .
we distribute the clumps in a similar way as shown in the numerical results .
the dark matter clumps are represented by rigid bodies with a navarro , frenk & white s density profile @xcite .
it provides an accurate fit to the density profiles of cdm halos : @xmath59 here @xmath60 is the critical density for closure of the universe , and @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the characteristic density and the scale radius of the clump . in practice , it is more convenient to use mass and concentration to characterize each clump instead of @xmath63 and @xmath62 .
the mass of a dark matter clump , @xmath64 , is related to its virial radius @xmath65 , which is defined as the radius within which the average density equals 200 times the critical density at the present @xmath66 , by the relation @xmath67 then the characteristic density @xmath61 is expressed in terms of the concentration @xmath68 as @xmath69 each clump has two characteristic parameters , but we fix the concentration to a typical value @xmath70 . since the interaction between the clumps and the disk is dominated by distant encounters , the adopted value for the concentration does not affect the heating process so much .
the simulations of @xcite and @xcite show that the total mass of the clumps is about one tenth of the halo mass .
we therefore give the clumps 10 % of the halo mass of the standard model , which is @xmath71 in total .
the distribution of positions and velocities of the clumps is assumed to be the same as the halo distribution function ( eq.[eq : halodf ] ) , so that the clump distribution does not change in time .
this is the most reasonable assumption which is important in order to maintain an equilibrium in the whole system .
otherwise the change in the mean potential of the halo might cause undesired change in the disk thickness .
the background halo component , which is treated as an fixed external field , is reduced by 10 % .
the orbital properties of the clumps could be represented by the radii of their pericenters and apocenters .
[ fig : dist_ecc ] shows the distribution of the pericenters and the apocenters of the clumps .
the lines of the constant eccentricity , which is defined as @xmath72 are superposed in the plot .
the eccentricity distribution has a median at 0.6 , which is in a good agreement with the standard cdm simulations that predicts high eccentricity orbits with a median apocentric - to - pericentric distance of 6:1 ( moore et.al , 1999 ) . for the mass spectrum of the clumps , we examine three different possibilities .
_ model 1 _ and _ model 3 _ have only one single population of clumps with clump masses of @xmath73 and @xmath74 , respectively .
these two models are meant to be extreme cases . _
model 2 _ has a mass spectrum with a mass range of @xmath75 to @xmath76 according to the probability distribution @xmath77 following the cosmological prediction by @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
this model is considered to be the most realistic examination . in this model the masses are assigned randomly to the clumps .
these three models were designed in order to examine the role of the individual mass of the clumps on the disk heating .
two additional physical effects on disk heating are studied .
one is the initial disk thickness .
thinner disks have smaller vertical velocity dispersions , they should therefore be more sensitive to disturbances from the clumps , and might experience a large thickening . therefore we ran _
models 4 _ and _ 5 _ which have an initial disk scale height of 525 pc and 1050 pc , respectively .
both models have the same mass spectrum as model 2 .
another influential property of the clumps on disk heating is the position of their pericenter , where the gravitational tides become the largest .
the probability distribution of the pericentric radii of the dm clumps is shown in fig .
[ fig : dist_peri ] .
the abscissa shows the pericentric radii of the clumps , and the ordinate shows the cumulative fraction of the number of clumps which have pericenters less than the value on the abscissa .
about 18 % 20 % of the clumps have pericenters within the solar radius .
this is similar to the clump distribution obtained by @xcite in the standard cdm cosmology . in order to examine the effect of the position distribution of the clumps
, we created _
model 6 _ , which has the same mass spectrum as model 2 , but the milky way has the density profile , according to the _ extended halo model_. this model has two noticeable features ; ( i ) the inner density profile is the same as the standard halo model so that all the kinematical properties of the disk are equivalent , and ( ii ) the tidal radius is 5 times larger than that in the standard model .
we distribute the clumps in the same way as the halo particles .
thus their spatial distribution is also 5 times larger in radius than in the other models . in this model
, the total clump mass is the same as before .
therefore , the mass fraction of the clumps to the whole halo is 2 % .
the probability distribution of the pericenters is shown in fig .
[ fig : dist_peri ] .
the number of clumps that have pericenters within the solar radius is about 3.5 % .
this model corresponds to the clump distribution predicted from a @xmath0cdm cosmology , as demonstrated by @xcite .
the characteristic parameters of all models are summarized in table 1 .
we calculate the interactions between the disk particles by using a hierarchical tree algorithm @xcite with a tolerance parameter of @xmath78 = 0.7 .
the time integration is made with the leap - frog method and a fixed time step of 1.75 myr .
the softening length of the disk particles is 70 pc .
we use 131,072 particles in the disk .
the forces from the clumps are calculated by direct summation .
we have followed the evolution up to 4.76 gyr .
the calculations are made on pentium iii
linux workstations ( 800mhz ) .
the typical calculation time is 90 seconds per time step .
in this section we show the results of our numerical simulations on the disk heating .
three different physical effects are examined here : the mass spectrum of the clumps , the initial disk thickness , and the spatial distribution of the clumps . throughout the section
, we are measuring the disk heating by the increase of the disk thickness , @xmath79 , and by the change in the velocity dispersion , @xmath80 , @xmath81 . to calculate these quantities
, the disk is stratified in concentric annuli , each of which containing 8192 particles .
the disk thickness is evaluated simply by the mean square deviation of the @xmath82-coordinate of disk particles from the center of the disk plane , @xmath83 , within the annuli . even without the clumps , the self - heating within the disk owing to two - body relaxation among the disk particles is always taking place in numerical simulations with modest number of particles . in our simulations with 131,072 particles in the disk , the increase owing to the self - heating is typically @xmath84 pc , and @xmath85 km
/ s at the solar radius after 4.76 gyr simulations .
these values are reasonably small , but need to be taken into account when analyzing the results .
the curves corresponding to the self - heating after 4.76 gyr are shown as internal heating in fig .
[ fig : z1_z3 ] fig .
[ fig : rvrz26 ] .
the results of the disk heating obtained from the simulations of the model 1 , 2 , and 3 are shown in fig .
[ fig : z1_z3 ] and fig .
[ fig : rvrz1_3 ] .
the comparison between the results makes the effect of the mass spectrum of the dm clumps clearer .
the growth of the disk thickness in model 1 is @xmath86 615 pc , 630 pc , and 900 pc at @xmath87 , 8 , and 16 kpc , respectively , while those values in model 3 are 860 pc , 1298 pc , and 2197 pc .
it is clear that the interaction of a galactic disk with a few , but massive clumps ( model 3 ) is more effective to heat the disk than the interaction with many but less massive clumps .
this result can be explained by the estimate in an impulsive approximation , which predicts that the increase in the energy of the disk is @xmath88 .
if there is a mass spectrum , @xmath89 , @xmath90 is dominated by massive clumps .
the disk thickening obtained from model 2 ( fig .
[ fig : z1_z3]*b * ) is , in fact , much closer to that in model 3 .
this result could be also understood by the impulsive approximation , as the energy input to the disk from the logarithmic interval in the mass spectrum is dominated by the more massive clumps ; @xmath91 .
therefore the higher limit of the mass spectrum has an essential contribution on the disk heating .
a difference feature between models 2 and 3 is their dependence of the disk heating on the disk radius .
for all models the outer part of the disk is heated up more than the inner part , but this gradient is the largest in the model 2 .
the increase of the disk thickness for @xmath92 kpc is smaller in model 2 than in model 3 , while it is opposite in the outer disk . in model 2 , which imitates the results of the standard cdm model ,
the disk thickness becomes 1 kpc at the solar radius after 4.76 gyr interactions .
an alternative way to estimate the disk heating is the increase in the velocity dispersion .
[ fig : rvrz1_3 ] shows the same results as fig .
[ fig : z1_z3 ] .
the existence of a few massive clumps has a large influence on the disk heating .
this figure shows the increase in the radial ( the left panels ) and the vertical ( the right panels ) velocity dispersions . after 4.76 gyr ,
the interaction of the disk with clumps in model 2 produces @xmath93 km / s and @xmath94 km / s .
the properties of disk heating in model 2 seem to agree with those of the thick disk component at the solar radius which has @xmath95 km / s and @xmath96 km / s and a vertical scale length of 1 kpc @xcite .
it is noticeable that the initial velocity dispersion is not isotropic or @xmath97 is larger compared to @xmath98 . after 4.76 gyr ,
in the inner part of the disk ( @xmath99 kpc ) , there is no increase in the radial velocity dispersion while the vertical velocity dispersion increases a lot .
this anisotropy in the heating is seen also in the outer part of the disk in model 2 .
a possible explanation is that the heating owing to the clumps is aiming at a more isotropic velocity dispersion .
our model 2 has an initial disk thickness comparable to the observed value in the milky way , which is about 250 pc . in many simulations in other works , however , the typical initial disk thickness was chosen much larger .
for example , @xcite employ the initial disk with a thickness of 700 pc .
the susceptibility of the disks to the heating owing to the interaction with the dm clumps should depend on the initial disk thickness .
thicker disks are possibly less sensitive and suffer less heating . in order to clarify the difference in the disk heating according to the initial disk thickness , we carried out three investigations with the models 2 , 4 , and 5 .
these models have almost the same bulge , halo , and clump systems , but the initial disk thicknesses are 245 pc , 525 pc , and 1050 pc , respectively
. the results of the disk heating are shown in fig .
[ fig : z245 ] , and fig .
[ fig : rvrz245 ] . after 4.76 gyr ,
the disk in model 2 achieves a thickness of 1 kpc at the solar radius , thus the increase rate is about 400% . in models 4 and 6 , the final disk thicknesses at the solar radius are 1.1 kpc and 1.5 kpc , respectively .
the increase rates in the thickness are thus 210% and 70% .
this tendency is more pronounced in the inner regions . in the central region
@xmath100 kpc , the disk in model 5 has experienced nearly no heating . on the other hand , in the outer regions @xmath101 kpc ,
the heating owing to the interaction with the clumps is so large that the difference in the initial disk thickness is negligible .
this feature is more clearly seen in fig .
[ fig : zgrow_o16 ] .
the panels in the figure show the time variations of the disk thickness ( a ) at @xmath87 kpc , ( b ) at the solar radii , and ( c ) at @xmath102 kpc , respectively .
it is natural that the outer part of the disk experiences more heating , because it is closer to the dm clumps .
a common characteristic to all radii is that the difference in the initial disk thickness decreases in time .
the curves in the panel ( a ) indicate that the heating will be saturated at the level of @xmath103 kpc . in the outer parts the heating is still going on to make the disk even thicker . the growth of the velocity dispersions in the disks , which is shown in fig .
[ fig : rvrz245 ] , also gives the same information namely that thicker disks suffer less heating .
this flaring effect , that is the increase in the disk thickness especially in the outer part , is seen in vla observations of hi disk of galaxies ngc 100 and ugc 9242 @xcite .
the interaction with the hypothetical dm clumps would be an explanation of this feature . in our models
the clump s spatial distribution is the same as the halo distribution in order to ensure the equilibrium .
this clump distribution , however , creates more clumps in the inner part of the halo than that obtained by the cosmological simulations .
for example , font et al ( 2001 ) employ a clump distribution in which only 3 % of the clumps have pericenters within the solar radius .
our model 6 is designed to remove the clumps from the inner region .
this is accomplished by introducing a more extended equilibrium halo model .
we distribute the same clumps as in the model 2 in the extended halo .
the spatial extent of the clump distribution in this model becomes 5 times larger , and only 3.5 % of the clumps have pericenter within the solar radius ( see fig .
[ fig : dist_peri ] ) .
the increase in disk thickness and velocity dispersion is shown in fig .
[ fig : z26 ] and fig .
[ fig : rvrz26 ] . in the model 6 ,
the disk heating owing to the interaction with the clumps is comparable with the disk internal heating , up to the disk edge . in this case
, we would need more precise simulations with larger number of particles , but it is already clear that even with the presence of the many clumps surviving in the halo , tidal disk heating is negligible and the disk remains as thin as the real milky way disk for about 5 gyr .
this result is in agreement with conclusion of @xcite .
we have made a series of numerical simulations , examining heating of galactic disks that are embedded in a halo with many small dm clumps , as suggested by cosmological simulations .
we have built up the initial galaxy model as precisely in equilibrium as possible , so that we could simulate a stable disk that is as thin as the milky way .
we have shown that with the mass spectrum @xmath104 , that is consistent with cosmological simulations , the massive end of the mass spectrum determines the amount of disk heating .
the number of the clumps at the massive end could be only a few , so that the massive limit of the spectrum might fluctuate among galactic halos .
this fact suggests a variety of disk thickness because of the random fluctuation in the number of the most massive clumps . as a second result ,
the simulations demonstrate that thicker disks suffer less heating .
it is possible that a disk with 700 pc thickness shows no significant heating whereas another disk with 200 pc thickness suffers significant heating in the same circumstances .
this also means that there is a critical thickness at which the heating owing to the interaction with the clumps is saturated .
finally , we have considered the relation to cosmology .
our model 2 mimics the clump distribution found in the standard cdm cosmology @xcite .
the disk heating by the clumps has already been discussed by @xcite .
they argued by a simple impulsive approximation that disk heating would be too high to explain the age - temperature relation for disk stars @xcite .
our numerical simulations are supplementary to their analysis , and we confirm that the heating is significantly high .
the thickness of 1 kpc at the solar radii is comparable to the present thick disk , but this heating takes place within 5 gyr and even a young thin disk would have no chance to survive . on the other hand , our model 6 corresponds to the clump distribution of the @xmath0cdm cosmology , similar to the one @xcite have studied , but more closely representing the milky way .
as found by @xcite , this clump distribution causes no significant heating of the disk .
these results suggest that the @xmath0cdm cosmology is preferable with respect to the standard cdm cosmology in explaining the thickness of the milky way .
we thank burkhard fuchs and andreas just for their useful comments and suggestions .
ea is grateful to astronomisches rechen - institut ( ari ) , heidelberg , in particular rainer spurzem , for allowing her to conduct simulations on ari s unix cluster .
tt is indebted to alexander von humboldt foundation for research grant .
font , a. , navarro , j.f . , stadel , j. , and quinn , t. 2001 , , 563 , l1 freeman , k.c .
1996 , in morrison , h.l . ,
sarjedini , a. , eds , asp conf .
92 , formation of the galactic halo , inside and out .
, san francisco , p.3 crrr model 1 & @xmath75 @xmath105 & 859 & 245 pc + model 2 & @xmath106 @xmath105 & 335 & 245 pc + model 3 & @xmath107 @xmath105 & 86 & 245 pc + model 4 & @xmath108 @xmath105 & 335 & 525 pc + model 5 & @xmath108 @xmath105 & 335 & 1050 pc + model 6 & @xmath108 @xmath105 & 315 & 245 pc + | motivated by the presence of numerous dark matter clumps in the milky way s halo as expected from the cold dark matter cosmological model , we conduct numerical simulations to examine the heating of the disk . we construct an initial galaxy model in equilibrium , with a stable thin disk .
the disk interacts with dark matter clumps for about 5 gyr .
three physical effects are examined : first the mass spectrum of the dark matter clumps , second the initial thickness of the galactic disk , and third the spatial distribution of the clumps .
we find that the massive end of the mass spectrum determines the amount of disk heating .
thicker disks suffer less heating .
there is a certain thickness at which the heating owing to the interaction with the clumps becomes saturates .
we also find that the heating produced by the model which mimics the distribution found in standard cdm cosmology is significant and too high to explain the observational constraints . on the other hand , our model that corresponds to
the clump distribution in a @xmath0cdm cosmology produces no significant heating .
this result suggests that the @xmath0cdm cosmology is preferable with respect to the standard cdm cosmology in explaining the thickness of the milky way . |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.