diff --git "a/data/en005/text/00000049.json" "b/data/en005/text/00000049.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/data/en005/text/00000049.json" @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +[{"audio_id": "opE7guKvfy4", "text": {"opE7guKvfy4-00000-00001968-00002984": "ah", "opE7guKvfy4-00001-00003632-00004384": "uh", "opE7guKvfy4-00002-00004664-00005784": "hmm", "opE7guKvfy4-00003-00011912-00011920": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "opKUWE6Huac", "text": {"opKUWE6Huac-00000-00000152-00000341": "Welcome to cinefileandoya", "opKUWE6Huac-00001-00000342-00000542": "in this video I will compare", "opKUWE6Huac-00002-00000542-00000695": "Dromómanos of Luis Ortega", "opKUWE6Huac-00003-00000695-00000942": "with Freaks of Todd Browning", "opKUWE6Huac-00004-00000942-00001101": "to see similarities and differences", "opKUWE6Huac-00005-00001101-00001191": "between both films", "opKUWE6Huac-00006-00001471-00001644": "I'm gonna start with the differences", "opKUWE6Huac-00007-00001644-00001844": "which saving distances between", "opKUWE6Huac-00008-00001844-00002133": "production year, budget, country", "opKUWE6Huac-00009-00002180-00002380": "They seem to me pretty remarkable", "opKUWE6Huac-00010-00002388-00002523": "and I'm gonna differentiate", "opKUWE6Huac-00011-00002523-00002723": "between a straight and a curve lines", "opKUWE6Huac-00012-00002773-00003048": "so the first, the camera", "opKUWE6Huac-00013-00003122-00003372": "In Freaks the narrative is much more conventional", "opKUWE6Huac-00014-00003377-00003577": "as they filmed / shooted in the past", "opKUWE6Huac-00015-00003577-00003684": "with the camera very static", "opKUWE6Huac-00016-00003709-00003909": "Outstands Americans Shots (AS)", "opKUWE6Huac-00017-00003909-00004130": "which are cutted up the feet / calves", "opKUWE6Huac-00018-00004152-00004352": "Also Mediums Shots (MS)", "opKUWE6Huac-00019-00004377-00004481": "cutted up the waist", "opKUWE6Huac-00020-00004481-00004681": "And if there is Long Shots (LS)", "opKUWE6Huac-00021-00004690-00004852": "theyre more like Medium Long Shots", "opKUWE6Huac-00022-00004852-00005123": "framed whre the characters stands", "opKUWE6Huac-00023-00005235-00005392": "On the other hand, in Dromómanos,", "opKUWE6Huac-00024-00005392-00005642": "there's more hetereogeneity on the Shots", "opKUWE6Huac-00025-00005711-00005911": "in one scene for example,", "opKUWE6Huac-00026-00005911-00006111": "theres a character who has the camera on the back", "opKUWE6Huac-00027-00006151-00006300": "imitating a go pro", "opKUWE6Huac-00028-00006323-00006472": "like in Enter The Void", "opKUWE6Huac-00029-00006485-00006758": "there's also a lot of high angled shots (HAS) and counter high angled shots", "opKUWE6Huac-00030-00006772-00007167": "which basically is the diagonal camera facing up or down respectively", "opKUWE6Huac-00031-00007191-00007391": "also travellings", "opKUWE6Huac-00032-00007424-00007697": "and obviously a lot of extreme close ups, big close ups", "opKUWE6Huac-00033-00007728-00008311": "and when r Long Shots theyre more open than Freaks", "opKUWE6Huac-00034-00008377-00008577": "thats in one side on the camera", "opKUWE6Huac-00035-00008690-00008963": "then, the second difference: the script slash plot", "opKUWE6Huac-00036-00009038-00009479": "in Freaks again, we have a linear structure more conventional", "opKUWE6Huac-00037-00009530-00009730": "because there is an start , knot and outcome, so lineal", "opKUWE6Huac-00038-00009879-00010079": "instead on Dromómanos", "opKUWE6Huac-00039-00010106-00010306": "there almost no knot", "opKUWE6Huac-00040-00010306-00010506": "is more like a sucession of the characters stories", "opKUWE6Huac-00041-00010507-00010767": "without a knot or specific conflict", "opKUWE6Huac-00042-00010814-00011076": "and Ortega (dir) said on interviews talking about the film", "opKUWE6Huac-00043-00011122-00011349": "that he wanted to separate a little of the script", "opKUWE6Huac-00044-00011366-00011566": "to free the artistic work", "opKUWE6Huac-00045-00011621-00011905": "so the narrative isnt that linear as Freaks", "opKUWE6Huac-00046-00012293-00012447": "Now I'm gonna pass to the coincidences", "opKUWE6Huac-00047-00012450-00012871": "which is the more insteresting to see in both movies, at least that i saw", "opKUWE6Huac-00048-00012900-00013306": "The first the What, What are these movies talking about?", "opKUWE6Huac-00049-00013344-00013758": "Although the two approach in some way a love triangle,", "opKUWE6Huac-00050-00013780-00013926": "besides that", "opKUWE6Huac-00051-00013926-00014331": "what I rescue is that the twho have a strong community sense", "opKUWE6Huac-00052-00014337-00014854": "In Freaks this is more obvious cuz the main characters live altogether in a circle", "opKUWE6Huac-00053-00014878-00015247": "-and those who already seen the film can understand why Im saying this-", "opKUWE6Huac-00054-00015340-00015650": "and in Dromómanos this is more subtle but also", "opKUWE6Huac-00055-00015680-00016027": "as the main characters live altogether in a shantytown", "opKUWE6Huac-00056-00016055-00016353": "and also it shows a religious subcommunity", "opKUWE6Huac-00057-00016520-00016853": "and the second coincidence which is the most important to me,", "opKUWE6Huac-00058-00016867-00017234": "is the Who, Who they represent these films?", "opKUWE6Huac-00059-00017296-00017588": "and both coincide on showing social outcast/ marginalized people", "opKUWE6Huac-00060-00017595-00018089": "with visible body features like people with scoliosis or dwarfs, or without", "opKUWE6Huac-00061-00018140-00018612": "and this approach shows with the contrast between \"Us\" and \"They\"", "opKUWE6Huac-00062-00018628-00019045": "in Freaks is more visible; its shows for example, in a scene at the start of the film,", "opKUWE6Huac-00063-00019090-00019331": "where there are some passersby, walking through a forest", "opKUWE6Huac-00064-00019355-00019643": "who make fun of the main characters", "opKUWE6Huac-00065-00019690-00020049": "and in Dromómanos this occurs in the territoriality", "opKUWE6Huac-00066-00020067-00020267": "at the began and during the whole film", "opKUWE6Huac-00067-00020288-00020748": "it shows that contrast of the characters collecting stuff", "opKUWE6Huac-00068-00020756-00020926": "in the center of the city,", "opKUWE6Huac-00069-00020929-00021222": "and the spaces that they inhabit, of the shantytown", "opKUWE6Huac-00070-00021565-00021765": "Well, I hope that u liked this video", "opKUWE6Huac-00071-00021765-00022003": "and when u watch or rewatch these two movies", "opKUWE6Huac-00072-00022021-00022309": "u can appreciate the conections i was just mentioning just now", "opKUWE6Huac-00073-00022309-00022509": "see u in the next video! :3"}}, {"audio_id": "opcQ6FDa2Ic", "text": {"opcQ6FDa2Ic-00000-00000522-00000943": "Malayalam actress Priya Prakash Varrier is grabbing the eyeballs across the country,", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00001-00000943-00001178": "one wink at a time (pun intended).", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00002-00001178-00001607": "The pretty lady, who has now emerged as the 'National crush' after a video song song Oru", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00003-00001607-00002034": "Adaar Love from the film Manikya Malaraya Poovi emerged and a clip from the song broke", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00004-00002034-00002168": "the Internet.", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00005-00002168-00002578": "The said clip has Priya communicating with a boy who crushes on her, only with the gestures", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00006-00002578-00002727": "of her eyes.", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00007-00002727-00003135": "She raises her eyebrows, winks, smiles and steals the hearts of the viewer in the process", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00008-00003135-00003240": "too.", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00009-00003240-00003669": "As if that wasn't enough, Priya has now set a new record on social media .", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00010-00003669-00004093": "A report on catchnews suggests that Priya has now become the 3rd celebrity worldwide", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00011-00004093-00004575": "to gain more than 606 thousand followers on Instagram in a single day.", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00012-00004575-00005047": "The report further reveals that she's next only to popular American model and TV personality", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00013-00005047-00005487": "Kylie Jenner and footballer Cristiano Ronaldo, who've recorded the same/or more number of", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00014-00005487-00005754": "followers on Instagram in a single day.", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00015-00005754-00006250": "While Kylie Jenner remains on top with 806 thousand followers in a single day, Ronaldo", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00016-00006250-00006779": "is at the second spot with 650 thousand followers on the photo-sharing platform.Priya Varrier", "opcQ6FDa2Ic-00017-00006779-00007187": "is at the third place with 606k followers on Instagram in a single day."}}, {"audio_id": "oO8WRdlTpxE", "text": {"oO8WRdlTpxE-00000-00000901-00002580": "Me.", "oO8WRdlTpxE-00001-00002580-00004258": "Going."}}, {"audio_id": "oOjyNrn7b_8", "text": {"oOjyNrn7b_8-00000-00000951-00001238": "My name is Kim and I'm a Kiwi Ranger.", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00001-00001393-00001567": "My background is genetics", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00002-00001567-00001738": "and working with parasites", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00003-00001738-00001927": "but I got tired of the lab work", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00004-00001927-00002196": "so I moved to work with this birds", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00005-00002196-00002473": "which is a really rewarding animal to work with,", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00006-00002473-00002672": "and you can really see the differences", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00007-00002672-00002852": "you're making to such a critically", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00008-00002852-00003033": "endangered population.", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00009-00003472-00003692": "So, my job is very eclectic.", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00010-00003692-00003946": "There's a lot of different things going on.", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00011-00003946-00004258": "I have to incubate and hatch chicks,", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00012-00004375-00004553": "feed the birds,", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00013-00004553-00004776": "and make sure they're growing well", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00014-00004776-00005014": "and that they're healthy for release.", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00015-00005238-00005430": "Every single chick that we release", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00016-00005430-00005615": "is very very important", "oOjyNrn7b_8-00017-00005605-00005800": "and vital for the species."}}, {"audio_id": "oOuMPB0yvRA", "text": {"oOuMPB0yvRA-00000-00000136-00000262": "the hummingbird treats", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00001-00000262-00000360": "the night like a mini", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00002-00000360-00000489": "winter. As soon as the", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00003-00000489-00000648": "air cools at sunset", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00004-00000648-00000756": "its heart rate drops", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00005-00000756-00000873": "sharply, and its body", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00006-00000873-00001006": "temperature also drops", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00007-00001006-00001127": "minimizing energy", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00008-00001127-00001235": "consumption.", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00009-00001235-00001352": "As the sun rises", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00010-00001352-00001464": "and the air warms", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00011-00001464-00001548": "everything goes back", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00012-00001548-00001624": "to normal, and they", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00013-00001624-00001703": "can start looking", "oOuMPB0yvRA-00014-00001703-00001832": "for nectar again."}}, {"audio_id": "oOzTjTH3kIY", "text": {"oOzTjTH3kIY-00000-00001188-00001689": "Hi all, this is Zachariah and today I'm going to talk a little bit about what I consider", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00001-00001689-00002163": "to be the optimal PvP gear and build for Arsenal mercs.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00002-00002163-00002790": "And by extension, Gunnery commandos in patch 4.0.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00003-00002790-00003211": "First things first, and this should go without saying but you'll want to be using the Eliminator", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00004-00003211-00003447": "set for arsenal mercs.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00005-00003447-00004009": "The main features of this set being a reduced Energy Shield cooldown and most importantly", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00006-00004009-00004521": "an autocrit Heatseeker Missile potentially once per minute following a cast of Blazing", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00007-00004521-00004836": "Bolts.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00008-00004836-00005296": "Once you have this set, ideally updated to tier 2, the first thing you're going to want", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00009-00005296-00005990": "to do is remove all but one accuracy enhancement and all but one alacrity enhancement.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00010-00005990-00006468": "Stock gear comes with somewhat suboptimal stats - it's not terrible, but you will notice", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00011-00006468-00006850": "a performance improvement with minmaxing.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00012-00006850-00007277": "You certainly don't need all the accuracy the set comes with.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00013-00007277-00007792": "I find one is plenty, which along with the legacy bonus of 1% gives you an accuracy of", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00014-00007792-00008076": "a little over 103%.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00015-00008076-00008532": "This is I think enough to compensate for extra dodge chance that sorcs and sins get.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00016-00008532-00009150": "Missing a priming shot against a sin in your face can be very painful!", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00017-00009150-00009286": "Why bother with an alacrity?", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00018-00009286-00009800": "Well this is a personal preference for me, but I do find that cast times feel a little", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00019-00009800-00010271": "slow by default, and a small nudge can give you the edge in PvP.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00020-00010271-00010681": "You can go for more, but too much and you're going to start lacking the bursty punch that", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00021-00010681-00010915": "mercs are infamous for.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00022-00010915-00011320": "Augments can go one of two ways.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00023-00011320-00011949": "My personal preference is all mastery, but another way to go would be 3 or 4 crit augments", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00024-00011949-00012182": "and the rest power.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00025-00012182-00012735": "Either way you're going to want your crit chance to be somewhere between 37 and 40 percent.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00026-00012735-00013544": "The difference between power and mastery is very very small.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00027-00013544-00014281": "Ok, on to the utility point build.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00028-00014281-00014791": "Now there are a few differences between what I'd spec for either reg warzones or ranked", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00029-00014791-00015294": "arenas, and I'll cover those as we go.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00030-00015294-00015736": "First from the Skillful tier, I tend to go with Afterburners first, which gives you a", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00031-00015736-00016366": "short duration root on Stockstrike and makes your Jet Boost knock back a little further.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00032-00016366-00016961": "This can be very handy in regs in 1v1 situations but is largely wasted in ranked.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00033-00016961-00017461": "In that situation I would advise picking up Custom Enviro Suit for the extra survivability", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00034-00017461-00017914": "for more health and slightly bigger received heals.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00035-00017914-00018115": "Second is Power Barrier.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00036-00018115-00018498": "You're almost always going to have 5 stacks of this once you're in combat so that's a", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00037-00018498-00018778": "flat 5% damage reduction.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00038-00018778-00019129": "Which isn't too shabby for a tier 1 utility.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00039-00019129-00019424": "Third is Adhesive Supplements.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00040-00019424-00019919": "This snare on tracer missile combined with your standard Blazing Bolts snare means you're", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00041-00019919-00020569": "going to pretty much always have a speed debuff on your target at all times.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00042-00020569-00020793": "On to the Masterful tier.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00043-00020793-00021108": "First pick from here for regs is Pyro Shield.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00044-00021108-00021587": "The damage this can do to attackers is not to be sniffed at, hitting frequently for over", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00045-00021587-00021764": "1k per attack.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00046-00021764-00022298": "In regs you're going to be popping your 'Energy Shield' very frequently, so this is very useful.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00047-00022298-00022677": "But less so in ranked where the damage is going to be split.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00048-00022677-00023585": "For arenas I'd recommend picking up either Protective Field or Suit FOE for more survivability.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00049-00023585-00023854": "Second here is Supercharged Defense.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00050-00023854-00024066": "This utility is pretty fantastic!", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00051-00024066-00024758": "15% defense combined with 8 seconds of interrupt immunity every time you pop Supercharged Gas", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00052-00024758-00024934": "(which is going to be a LOT!).", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00053-00024934-00025431": "You'll be popping that at the start of almost every fight and again frequently during, as", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00054-00025431-00025693": "you build stacks with every tracer.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00055-00025693-00026177": "Having a chance to dodge or resist a CC or big attack while you load up your burst can", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00056-00026177-00026562": "make or break a fight.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00057-00026562-00026774": "Finally is the Heroic tier.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00058-00026774-00027238": "Obviously you are absolutely going to want to pick up Thrill of the Hunt for the ability", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00059-00027238-00027541": "to channel Blazing Bolts on the move.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00060-00027541-00028086": "For regs I would pair that with Energy Rebounder which has some nice synergy with Pyro Shield", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00061-00028086-00028375": "from the previous tier.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00062-00028375-00028995": "For ranked however I would highly recommend picking up Stabilized Armor. 30% DR on AOE", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00063-00028995-00029554": "which is nice, but most importantly 30% damage reduction when you're stunned.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00064-00029554-00029925": "This is pretty much a mandatory pick for arenas.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00065-00029925-00030277": "Ok, that about wraps things up.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00066-00030277-00030729": "If you have any questions for me, please feel free to drop me a comment and I'll try my", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00067-00030729-00030929": "best to respond.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00068-00030929-00031349": "Please remember to hit that 'Like' button, and subscribe if this video is of any use", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00069-00031349-00031452": "to you.", "oOzTjTH3kIY-00070-00031452-00031525": "Thanks for watching!"}}, {"audio_id": "oPLnqLHz6o8", "text": {"oPLnqLHz6o8-00000-00004640-00005784": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00001-00014784-00015584": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00002-00019664-00021184": "my god has his mind snapped", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00003-00021976-00022584": "muscles", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00004-00033536-00033712": "yeah fully i am blessed this", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00005-00036200-00036584": "hmm", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00006-00036824-00037184": "it seems you have yet to translate all your codex pages nipote", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00007-00037256-00037984": "go and see leonardo and have him make sense of their contents only then can we begin", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00008-00039992-00040784": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00009-00048048-00049184": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00010-00051008-00051367": "it seems you have yet to translate all your codex pages nipote", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00011-00051440-00051984": "go and see leonardo and have him make sense of their contents only then can we begin", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00012-00052296-00052655": "it seems you have yet to translate all your codex pages nipote", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00013-00052728-00053384": "go and see leonardo and have him make sense of their contents only then can we begin", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00014-00065055-00065984": "leonardo that's you so good to see you how can i help you you found another one how exciting", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00015-00066304-00067384": "yes we just switch these two lines and then shuffle them left done", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00016-00068312-00069056": "it's you it is time uncle let us finish what you and my father started all those years ago", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00017-00069112-00069552": "indeed perhaps now we can finally make sense of this prophecy", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00018-00069552-00069896": "and put a stop to whatever it is the spaniard is plotting", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00019-00069968-00071584": "we should start by locating the vault the codex pages will lead us to it let's take a look", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00020-00072336-00072984": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00021-00073792-00074384": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00022-00084640-00085584": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00023-00086488-00087096": "it is a map of the entire world but there are lands shown here that do not exist", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00024-00087160-00087936": "apparently they do exist i imagine they've yet to be discovered or rediscovered how is this possible", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00025-00088024-00088960": "perhaps the vault will hold the answer do you see where it is then no it can't be the vault it looks", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00026-00088960-00089824": "like the vault is in roma then the spaniard this is why he became pope now i understand it's not", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00027-00089824-00090512": "the vault alone he's gained access to but the staff as well what stuff the codex always spoke", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00028-00090512-00091272": "of two keys two pieces of eden needed to open the vault one is the apple and the other is the staff", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00029-00091408-00092240": "the paypal staff is the second piece of eden for years now decades we've sought these answers", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00030-00092240-00092864": "and now at last we have them but so too could the spaniard and if he does if he finds a way", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00031-00092864-00093480": "into the vault its contents will make the apple seem a trifling thing i must go to roma and find", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00032-00093480-00094128": "the vault what are the rest of you we'll do what we do best cause some trouble in the city", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00033-00094128-00095384": "giving you the freedom to conduct your search just let me know when you are ready nipote", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00034-00096152-00096784": "roma beckons you let me know when you are ready to depart", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00035-00097216-00098184": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00036-00098760-00099584": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00037-00101608-00102384": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00038-00104383-00105183": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00039-00113568-00113583": "foreign", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00040-00114928-00116383": "oh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00041-00116583-00117783": "okay", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00042-00118280-00119183": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00043-00119688-00120583": "get this", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00044-00125392-00126183": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00045-00126648-00127583": "not enough", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00046-00129032-00130383": "we're gonna escape", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00047-00130559-00131784": "dude", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00048-00133600-00134584": "oh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00049-00135832-00137384": "i see him down", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00050-00137656-00138784": "just like that", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00051-00141392-00141584": "we work together", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00052-00142976-00144384": "very very seriously", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00053-00144544-00145784": "yes", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00054-00146136-00147184": "come get me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00055-00150432-00151384": "get him", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00056-00151968-00152784": "i see them", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00057-00153208-00154184": "we work together", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00058-00155096-00155584": "take this man very very seriously", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00059-00155880-00156984": "just like that", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00060-00157448-00158384": "this man very very", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00061-00161584-00162584": "um", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00062-00162888-00163984": "horror", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00063-00164888-00165408": "god", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00064-00165408-00166784": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00065-00166944-00168184": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00066-00170232-00170984": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00067-00173552-00173784": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00068-00174048-00175208": "there's", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00069-00175208-00176584": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00070-00178632-00179384": "you should lock me up get down strong not you there there", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00071-00181552-00182184": "go come on", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00072-00183152-00183584": "together", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00073-00184448-00184984": "this one", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00074-00185832-00186384": "this one is coming", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00075-00187320-00187784": "nothing funny", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00076-00190144-00190584": "this one is", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00077-00191480-00191984": "oh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00078-00194744-00196184": "let me go", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00079-00202760-00203184": "please", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00080-00204448-00204704": "where do you think he is huh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00081-00205056-00206023": "that man where do i know him", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00082-00206023-00207384": "my god", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00083-00208112-00208784": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00084-00210448-00211584": "come on", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00085-00212016-00212984": "i'm sure", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00086-00213616-00214384": "it better not be looking for trouble", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00087-00215071-00215784": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00088-00216119-00217184": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00089-00218280-00218584": "right here", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00090-00225519-00226864": "i thought i thought i was beyond this but i'm not i've waited too long lost too much request", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00091-00227104-00228384": "i don't think so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00092-00229223-00229360": "how is it to resist", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00093-00229576-00230000": "i see kind of you to bring me the apple now give it it", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00094-00230608-00231376": "always the fighter just like your father well rejoice my child for you will see him again soon", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00095-00231536-00232584": "you will give it to me as you wish", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00096-00232888-00233984": "fascinating an impressive power this but if you think it's going to save you another thing coming", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00097-00235184-00235384": "you cannot stop me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00098-00236432-00236784": "you are right to fear", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00099-00237936-00238184": "a clever trick but useless", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00100-00239384-00239519": "how long do you think you can keep", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00101-00241200-00242384": "i'll cut you down", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00102-00243312-00243784": "you cannot stop me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00103-00244776-00245184": "i'll shut you down assassin", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00104-00246136-00246584": "you are right to fear me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00105-00247696-00247984": "a clever trick but useless", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00106-00249623-00250784": "how everything you can keep this up", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00107-00251160-00252184": "you are right to fear me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00108-00252544-00253584": "how long do you think you can keep", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00109-00254128-00254984": "i'll cut you down", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00110-00256392-00257784": "you cannot stop me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00111-00257952-00258192": "no you will not take this from me", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00112-00258319-00258880": "it's finished rodrigo lay down your arms and i will make sure they end come", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00113-00259096-00259528": "at sweetly and would you give up so easily with it the other way around", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00114-00259984-00260584": "why don't we find out", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00115-00261064-00261144": "at last", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00116-00261928-00263384": "and now to deal with you", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00117-00266848-00267584": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00118-00270640-00271784": "ugh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00119-00272264-00273184": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00120-00274424-00274584": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00121-00276544-00277384": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00122-00284272-00284296": "i want", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00123-00285344-00285784": "this is madness", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00124-00288472-00289984": "quiet one quiet", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00125-00293480-00294184": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00126-00295304-00295584": "eh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00127-00296160-00296984": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00128-00300840-00301184": "what is this place", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00129-00302512-00303432": "no more tricks no more ancient artifacts no more weapons let us see what you are made of", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00130-00303432-00303984": "old man all right then if that's how you want to play it", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00131-00304472-00305072": "what do you even want with about rodrigo don't you know what lies within or do you mean to tell", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00132-00305072-00305920": "me the great and powerful assassins didn't figure it out figure what out god it's god", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00133-00306120-00306728": "you expect me to believe that god lives beneath the vatican a more logical location", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00134-00306728-00307264": "than a kingdom in a cloud don't you think surrounded by singing angels and cherubim", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00135-00307448-00307880": "let's say i was to believe you what do you think you'll do when you open that door", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00136-00308000-00308640": "i don't care it's not approval i'm after just power and you think you'll give it up", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00137-00308856-00309408": "whatever lies beyond that wall won't be able to resist the staff and apple they were made", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00138-00309408-00310184": "for felling gods god is meant to be all knowing all powerful do you think a couple of ancient", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00139-00310184-00311000": "relics can harm him you know nothing you take your image of the creators from an ancient book a book", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00140-00311000-00311768": "might you written by men if you are the pope and yet you dismiss the central text of your faith", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00141-00311968-00313784": "are you so naive i became po because it gave me access it gave me power you think i believe", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00142-00315088-00315736": "you can't you can't it's my destiny mine", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00143-00316200-00316584": "i am the prophet", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00144-00316728-00317752": "you never were get it over with them no killing you won't bring my family back", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00145-00319032-00319384": "a", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00146-00322792-00323584": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00147-00323888-00324984": "greetings prophet it is good you have come let us see it to give thanks", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00148-00325944-00326384": "we must speak", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00149-00328600-00329208": "you are good", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00150-00329208-00329984": "no not god we simply came before even when we walked the world your kind struggled to", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00151-00329984-00330928": "understand our existence we were more advanced in time your minds were not yet ready still", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00152-00330928-00332000": "not maybe never no matter you may not comprehend us but you will comprehend our warning you must", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00153-00332168-00332880": "and not what you are saying makes sense our words are not meant for you what are you talking about", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00154-00332960-00333384": "there is no one else here", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00155-00334368-00334832": "you anchor him but please be silent that we may commune", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00156-00335176-00336568": "listen when we were still flesh and our home still whole all kind betrayed us we", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00157-00336568-00337712": "who made you we who gave you life we were strong but you were many and both of us craved war so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00158-00337712-00338336": "busy were we with earthly concerns we failed to notice the heavens and by the time we did", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00159-00338424-00339048": "the world burned until not remained but ash it should have ended then and there", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00160-00339136-00339848": "but we built you in our own image we built you to survive and so we did", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00161-00339968-00341032": "you were our numbers your kind and mine it took sacrifice strength compassion but we rebuilt", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00162-00341120-00341832": "and as life returned to the world we endeavored to ensure this tragedy would not be repeated", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00163-00341832-00342848": "but now we are dying and time will work against us truth turned into myth and legend what we built", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00164-00342944-00343768": "misunderstood let my words preserve the message and make a record of our loss but let my words", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00165-00343768-00344480": "also bring hope you must find the other temples built by those who knew to turn away from war", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00166-00344560-00344912": "they worked to protect us to save us from the fire", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00167-00345000-00346064": "if you can find them if their work can be saved so too might this world be quick for time grows short", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00168-00346136-00347384": "and guard against the cross for there are many who will stand in your way", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00169-00347552-00348256": "hate is done the message is delivered we are gone now from this world all of us", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00170-00348360-00348880": "we can do no more the rest is up to you desmond", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00171-00348976-00350184": "what who is desmond i don't understand please wait i have so many questions", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00172-00350744-00351584": "what the [__]", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00173-00354344-00354720": "there's only about 10 minutes until i get all of my equipment ready to go before they do", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00174-00354720-00355280": "desmond yeah yeah all right sean i need you and rebecca to get everything in here packed up and", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00175-00355280-00355744": "loaded into the truck you and i will deal with the templars what they're here it was only a match of", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00176-00355744-00357184": "time before they discovered us to be honest i'm surprised it took him as long as it did let's go", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00177-00357544-00358152": "so what's the plan we ditched this place and then what there's another safe house we've got", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00178-00358568-00358688": "the company just up ahead", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00179-00359600-00360416": "mr miles this is an unexpectedly pleasant turn of events and here i thought i'd have to waste more", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00180-00360416-00361416": "men on kind of you to save me the trouble what do you want vinnick for you to come home we miss you", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00181-00361416-00361824": "there's still so much work for us to do together it's not happening warren", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00182-00361888-00362688": "you continue to disappoint in every conceivable way mister i saved your life once do you remember", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00183-00362768-00363392": "and this is how you repay me you saved me so you could keep experimenting on people destroying", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00184-00363392-00364456": "their lives and for what this tired argument again as i recall you were there at my side every step", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00185-00364456-00365584": "of the way their blood is on your hands just as much as mine you need to stop him a monitor", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00186-00365856-00366984": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00187-00367312-00368384": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00188-00371568-00372584": "uh", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00189-00372976-00373304": "uh oh doc looks like it's just you and me now", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00190-00373360-00374176": "enjoy your victory mr miles temporary as it is desmond we have to go", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00191-00374664-00375120": "there you are come on help loose into the van hurry desmond we need to go", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00192-00375344-00376120": "you'll have your turn desmond warren's gonna get what he deserves i promise so what now", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00193-00376120-00376680": "where are we headed there's a cabin up north we should be safe there at least for a little while", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00194-00376744-00377264": "i have to analyze those tapes from your session figure out what's happening and then what here", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00195-00377264-00377696": "we go i've got you all hooked up got a long drive ahead of us figured you might want to play around", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00196-00377696-00378216": "with the animus on the way all right but i got some questions first i mean what the hell was that", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00197-00378216-00378768": "in the vault what you saw proves everything i was afraid of the templars aren't our biggest threat", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00198-00378768-00379432": "not by a long shot so what the sun is what's it gonna do cook the earth i doubt it but", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00199-00379504-00379992": "i don't know there's been some speculation that the earth's magnetic field is weakening", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00200-00379992-00380408": "a sufficiently strong flare could flip the poles and cause a geomagnetic reversal", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00201-00380464-00380984": "it's all theoretical but if it happens the planet could become geologically unstable", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00202-00381048-00381448": "very unstable it's meant to be the stuff of pseudoscience but", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00203-00381504-00381848": "clearly something catastrophic happened to the people of the first civilization", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00204-00382104-00382800": "minerva was it she seemed to think we were due for a second round so either way we're [__]", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00205-00383024-00383448": "i don't know yet we'll keep reviewing the tapes and you can keep digging", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00206-00383448-00385184": "through your memories maybe there's more to discover all right guys i better get started", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00207-00388552-00389384": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00208-00389952-00390784": "so", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00209-00392712-00393584": "um", "oPLnqLHz6o8-00210-00397248-00397256": "you"}}, {"audio_id": "oPTPyypTuiM", "text": {"oPTPyypTuiM-00000-00000107-00000772": "Every year 22,000 employees and 440,000 volunteers put countless hours into our national parks.", "oPTPyypTuiM-00001-00000772-00001102": "Here at Harpers Ferry our park is made up of: Living History,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00002-00001186-00001322": "Administration,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00003-00001416-00001540": "Facility Management,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00004-00001648-00001823": "Natural Resources,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00005-00001912-00002026": "Education,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00006-00002152-00002276": "Law Enforcement,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00007-00002398-00002554": "Volunteer Management,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00008-00002638-00002806": "Visitor Services,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00009-00002870-00003002": "Archeology,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00010-00003102-00003232": "Social Media,", "oPTPyypTuiM-00011-00003332-00003468": "and even more.", "oPTPyypTuiM-00012-00003582-00003958": "We pass this stewardship to future generations.", "oPTPyypTuiM-00013-00003958-00004130": "Your Park, Your Future."}}, {"audio_id": "oPctGjZe16M", "text": {"oPctGjZe16M-00000-00001334-00002087": "Technology has become widespread and reached smartphones", "oPctGjZe16M-00001-00002087-00002563": "That's why we decided to take advantage of this", "oPctGjZe16M-00002-00002563-00003047": "To offer our stories to children through available apps", "oPctGjZe16M-00003-00003047-00003276": "We developed AnaArabi (I am an Arab)", "oPctGjZe16M-00004-00003276-00003864": "An easy app that displays our stories on the website", "oPctGjZe16M-00005-00003864-00004472": "The stories are easy to understand and the design is kids-friendly", "oPctGjZe16M-00006-00004472-00004749": "They can browse stories to read or read later", "oPctGjZe16M-00007-00005226-00005730": "For pages they like or want to read later", "oPctGjZe16M-00008-00005730-00006559": "We provided them with tools that will help them read easier", "oPctGjZe16M-00009-00006559-00006983": "Also, our apps are available on Android and iOS", "oPctGjZe16M-00010-00006983-00007554": "So they can read stories on a mobile phone or a tablet", "oPctGjZe16M-00011-00007554-00008405": "Many people, organizations and consultants supported us while launching the project", "oPctGjZe16M-00012-00008405-00008944": "I was able to develop the mobile and tablet applications", "oPctGjZe16M-00013-00008944-00009422": "and make it available for subscribers", "oPctGjZe16M-00014-00009422-00009922": "I hope this application reaches subscribers abroad", "oPctGjZe16M-00015-00009922-00010239": "And allows me to connect with more organizations abroad", "oPctGjZe16M-00016-00010239-00010466": "So we can market the project", "oPctGjZe16M-00017-00010466-00010863": "Because most of the feedback we received was encouraging", "oPctGjZe16M-00018-00010863-00011267": "So it would be unfair not to give Arab kids access to these stories", "oPctGjZe16M-00019-00011267-00011850": "I hope to market my products, my stories or AnaArabi's stories to every kid in the world", "oPctGjZe16M-00020-00011850-00012356": "Regarding monetization, we are currently selling the rights to read the story", "oPctGjZe16M-00021-00012356-00012634": "Since they can't download the story or read it", "oPctGjZe16M-00022-00012634-00012855": "We have annual subscriptions for $10 USD", "oPctGjZe16M-00023-00012855-00013488": "We launched the website a month ago (at the time of the interview)", "oPctGjZe16M-00024-00013488-00013889": "We had an encouraging number of subscriptions", "oPctGjZe16M-00025-00013889-00014550": "Looking at the number of subscriptions we think we will generate good revenues", "oPctGjZe16M-00026-00014550-00014988": "Whether on the website or on mobile mainly", "oPctGjZe16M-00027-00014988-00015593": "Because more people use mobile to access websites so I expect a revenue increase", "oPctGjZe16M-00028-00015593-00016069": "We are trying first to attract 1,000 subscribers", "oPctGjZe16M-00029-00016069-00016297": "This is our plan for the first year", "oPctGjZe16M-00030-00016297-00016772": "Hopefully we'll reach that number with the help of marketing", "oPctGjZe16M-00031-00017100-00017400": "Subtitles by the Amara.org community"}}, {"audio_id": "oQ6sR1HJCKM", "text": {"oQ6sR1HJCKM-00000-00000716-00001203": "8", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00001-00001254-00001561": "I think that's working", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00002-00001612-00002227": "If not now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00003-00002252-00002355": "Close", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00004-00002406-00003020": "Let's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00005-00003046-00003225": "Start this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00006-00003379-00003840": "Check the audio levels that just do that real quick", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00007-00004070-00004249": "Real quick", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00008-00004326-00004633": "Very Guyra", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00009-00004659-00004992": "Is a crackling now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00010-00005862-00005964": "How about now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00011-00006016-00006118": "Is that better", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00012-00006246-00006425": "Also hi colours", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00013-00006528-00007142": "Dukes time for Dukes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00014-00007168-00007782": "Hyatt sorry let's get straight to the biscuits since the last time I have coffee", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00015-00007808-00008422": "I made a coffee for myself and I forgot", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00016-00008729-00009344": "It's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00017-00009369-00009984": "So what was I doing last time let's go to the door Sparks x Repco", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00018-00010214-00010496": "That's fine the dust box x rapper", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00019-00010726-00011340": "As you can see I've installed at block ublock origin because I just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00020-00011366-00011622": "Deal with sites name pop-ups", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00021-00011673-00011904": "Especially on such a small screen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00022-00011929-00012492": "Ok it's heading noted a ute tub", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00023-00012620-00012748": "Think that's here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00024-00013030-00013568": "Chaos fix the Crackle", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00025-00013926-00014131": "Is that better", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00026-00014540-00014796": "Is this better this help", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00027-00015027-00015155": "What about this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00028-00015897-00016256": "What about this testing crackle", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00029-00016358-00016947": "Crackle ok so you're probably going to have to get 28% is that fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00030-00016972-00017126": "Look I'm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00031-00017254-00017587": "You gonna have to deal with the crack was cos I have the worst setup", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00032-00017945-00018560": "Gacha the worst setup", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00033-00018585-00018944": "Sounds set up and I've paid money I'm going to get", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00034-00018969-00019276": "I'm hiring the best sound the sound people", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00035-00019302-00019916": "They know things out sound they told me by a Mack so I bought a Mac 100% Mac", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00036-00019993-00020326": "The Apple M1 and it's going to fix all my sound problems", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00037-00020608-00021222": "April Falls ok so it's fine my issue", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00038-00021632-00021913": "Support request what's this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00039-00022041-00022579": "The networking issue let's just check the networking stuff to see if there's any issues", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00040-00022732-00022988": "Please no don't say that obs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00041-00023219-00023603": "You managed to find breakage with a work C I also hi Cass", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00042-00024089-00024704": "Just going to quickly check the issue tracker to see if there's anything important I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00043-00025164-00025446": "What the hell are you doing here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00044-00026009-00026163": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00045-00026495-00026623": "Scroll down a bit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00046-00027059-00027366": "Tudor slackware", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00047-00027443-00027724": "Their life is like hell", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00048-00027750-00027980": "This is what you get when you use slackware", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00049-00028211-00028441": "Wow he got", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00050-00028569-00028799": "I got all the windows going on there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00051-00029747-00029977": "Ulterior problem", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00052-00030105-00030489": "Good luck fixing that buds", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00053-00030643-00031257": "Alright just you just want I'm just checking to make sure there's no fix it I need to take into my port", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00054-00031334-00031513": "Branch code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00055-00031539-00031641": "For some reason", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00056-00031769-00031999": "What's this fixed issue", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00057-00032102-00032511": "Some reason I've been working too much on the networking code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00058-00032691-00032870": "Alright so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00059-00032921-00033126": "Let's go all the way down", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00060-00033254-00033459": "And you'll see we had some code review", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00061-00033561-00033689": "That's pretty cool", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00062-00033843-00034201": "And I replied using email which cut all the threading", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00063-00034252-00034483": "That's all so cool thanks github", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00064-00034662-00034867": "Let me have some discussions", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00065-00034892-00035174": "I have to read 3. Again in a bit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00066-00035199-00035635": "But it's just go to files changed and will check that out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00067-00035993-00036223": "Ctrl c makes a heart symbol", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00068-00036582-00037017": "Ok yes it is a new stable release", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00069-00037043-00037503": "So it's fine outdoor Sparks fire", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00070-00037708-00038015": "Open in a terminal so I can get work done", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00071-00038041-00038169": "It didn't what", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00072-00038374-00038502": "You've been lied to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00073-00038604-00038681": "Could", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00074-00038707-00038783": "What about", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00075-00039014-00039628": "So let's see let's get", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00076-00039654-00040268": "Fetch everything it makes a heart symbol in the VM it's weird if it happens in so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00077-00040294-00040908": "Offscreen I did a temp to make this work on Windows and we're going to look at that in a beard", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00078-00040934-00041113": "Cos they also fix some bugs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00079-00041343-00041446": "Butter", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00080-00042163-00042393": "The most dream just died", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00081-00042623-00042803": "Oh no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00082-00043007-00043212": "To God please no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00083-00043289-00043903": "No nope quite like so Twitch stream preview just froze thanks twitch", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00084-00043929-00044262": "Preview I finally found it and I'm using it today", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00085-00044467-00044979": "That's pretty cool so let's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00086-00045081-00045644": "Twitch stream preview is trash well yeah I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00087-00045721-00046284": "Creatures whole dashboard is trash well now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00088-00046412-00046847": "Oh wait let me scroll back ask you about your CI stuff at work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00089-00047180-00047513": "Can't do anything from yoghurt because keys", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00090-00047539-00048153": "Nice got a Pang of the social disparity and you feel weird", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00091-00048179-00048383": "Yeah weather Twitch alerts", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00092-00048639-00048742": "It's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00093-00048895-00049331": "So that's also check out this slurry branch", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00094-00049407-00049766": "Ok check out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00095-00049791-00050278": "Traffic to have I got the Doss box remote added", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00096-00050303-00050559": "You and your 60 followers", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00097-00050841-00051302": "You're really doing it big time with your ass 5 hours streams", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00098-00051583-00052198": "Have a quick look at what's happening develop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00099-00052454-00052787": "That was a bit Ott I can't even", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00100-00052838-00053017": "Yeah not doing it again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00101-00053043-00053529": "What's happened so they merged", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00102-00053606-00054220": "A pull request I get someone found out the peak appcode it just broken on macos", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00103-00054246-00054860": "Because the pick-up code has always been broken but windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00104-00054886-00055039": "The next hour in Target", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00105-00055091-00055628": "That's great so we can have to fix our code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00106-00055679-00055833": "Pink or purple patch", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00107-00055987-00056601": "That's actually just see Axis broken on macos", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00108-00056908-00057087": "Yeah but", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00109-00057113-00057727": "Mac OS is very finicky about it's API it often break simple thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00110-00057881-00058495": "At least it fixes it simple things forever", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00111-00058521-00059033": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00112-00059084-00059519": "It's time to rebase this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00113-00059699-00060057": "It now went lol it's go f*** after hours", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00114-00060083-00060211": "Basically", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00115-00060236-00060851": "If you've been following the dice box acts issues a lot of the frustration", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00116-00060876-00061183": "Recently it has become from", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00117-00061209-00061823": "Says you don't have permission of much just fucken xfi out candles in Mac", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00118-00061849-00062361": "Formation and Steve Jobs at mighty ape is the Apple gods ffs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00119-00062719-00063001": "Actually fix this shouldn't be open", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00120-00063539-00063743": "Might not tested it yet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00121-00063897-00064076": "But yet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00122-00064102-00064537": "Platform Macca's a whole bunch of fun for lots of different reasons", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00123-00064588-00065023": "Especially since this isn't emulator it has like dynamic code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00124-00065433-00066047": "Mainly the reason that Mac OS is so hard to develop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00125-00066073-00066508": "For is because you have to pay so much money just to Augusta develop for it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00126-00066739-00066867": "With open source", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00127-00067071-00067379": "It's really difficult to do that just cause", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00128-00067455-00067711": "What can you do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00129-00067788-00067891": "Near", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00130-00067916-00068531": "Yeah with Max you just I don't have it Mac I've never had a Mac as result I can't write code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00131-00068659-00069094": "So I'm not sure if that's gatekeeping by Big Mac", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00132-00069145-00069196": "But", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00133-00069247-00069836": "Where does not going to be able to fix bugs for it so if you own a Mac", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00134-00069862-00069939": "Don't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00135-00069964-00070348": "Keep I can fix bugs for your computer because they can't afford 1", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00136-00070604-00071219": "I'm gay Captain deep guys burger", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00137-00071449-00071910": "Let's just remind me about the Cursed McDonald's dream I had last night", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00138-00071961-00072575": "Not sure if I want to get into it but I might", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00139-00072601-00073215": "Hello", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00140-00073241-00073395": "Go ahead", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00141-00073420-00073599": "Ok so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00142-00073625-00073753": "Last night", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00143-00073830-00074137": "McDonald's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00144-00074188-00074700": "Let's hear the aside there's no aside unless like can I do I have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00145-00075059-00075340": "Toilet installed no I don't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00146-00075391-00075724": "Here's my aside screen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00147-00075827-00076083": "We just do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00148-00076185-00076799": "Perfect that crash beam", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00149-00076825-00077132": "This is my aside", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00150-00077158-00077388": "In my dream I was", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00151-00077414-00077695": "Going to the McDonald's bathroom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00152-00077772-00078387": "For some reason girls like 50 years and there was like 2 stalls", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00153-00078719-00078924": "Those two people in the stores", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00154-00078950-00079411": "And they were talking to each other which is a bit weird", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00155-00079513-00080102": "But that's ok this is McDonald's sometimes that happens I imagine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00156-00080179-00080511": "I went to use urinal because I can do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00157-00080614-00081049": "And this kid came up next next to me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00158-00081254-00081433": "I'm at 51", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00159-00081612-00082227": "I'm close to affiliate I think I've had a fillet from don't seem", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00160-00082252-00082431": "Do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00161-00082611-00083123": "See how this kid came up next to me for some reason out of all the urinals", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00162-00083276-00083455": "And then talk to me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00163-00083481-00084095": "21 m to fix a computer for his and then his mother came in and I'm just trying", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00164-00084121-00084735": "We're talking to me I told them to go away", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00165-00084761-00084915": "I'll talk to you outside", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00166-00084966-00085094": "McDonald's bathroom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00167-00085273-00085452": "And they left happily", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00168-00085503-00085887": "I was happy I thought bit we also was like you rude", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00169-00086015-00086143": "So then", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00170-00086246-00086860": "A bunch of women came in and they were pretending to use the urinal next to me and I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00171-00087039-00087398": "Don't mocking me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00172-00087628-00087987": "Since I left without you I realised", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00173-00088063-00088550": "I didn't wash my hands and so I was going back to the bathroom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00174-00088652-00089267": "Someone called me out at McDonald's saying hey if you want to use the bathroom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00175-00089292-00089599": "Just to be a big chooks", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00176-00089804-00090035": "And I don't know", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00177-00090060-00090547": "I don't know what the hell this fever dream was but I woke up and realised", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00178-00090572-00090905": "I'm never going to McDonald's again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00179-00091238-00091468": "That's my aside", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00180-00091519-00091980": "Chat is speechless I hope", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00181-00092671-00093132": "Also I got rid of a load advocado flows like 2 years ago and I'm still mad", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00182-00093235-00093491": "That's rebase this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00183-00093721-00094207": "We're going to check this out as a drip Slurpee five", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00184-00094233-00094847": "Loaded avocado fries", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00185-00095078-00095155": "Etsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00186-00095897-00096332": "Using Google's risky at the moment to show where I live", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00187-00096435-00097049": "The reason I installed Adblock is cos it's like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00188-00097075-00097459": "Chook house", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00189-00097535-00097919": "They just fries and they have avocado on them", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00190-00098918-00099123": "Alright my coffee starting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00191-00099148-00099763": "Read clean to get ripper here let's rebase this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00192-00099788-00100275": "If you've ever wanted to know how to rebase like a topic branch onto this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00193-00100300-00100735": "What you do is you find the last commit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00194-00100787-00100889": "Like this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00195-00100915-00101273": "Any do get rebase", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00196-00101299-00101785": "On to Upstream develop and then you put the command", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00197-00101913-00102220": "Sorry not upstream develop Origin develop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00198-00102502-00103116": "The crashes and stuff and that's how you rebase a topic branch yes just like normal rebasing the", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00199-00103142-00103244": "Put it on to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00200-00103347-00103961": "So now we're going to get the ne2000 issue", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00201-00103987-00104166": "Search fine head", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00202-00104191-00104806": "God I hate no see very very very long jetty", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00203-00104831-00105446": "Like that yes I didn't fact remove it I remove the code and now have two up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00204-00105651-00105830": "My other code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00205-00105932-00106137": "According to the code that was different", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00206-00106188-00106803": "Dress me up like an I hope waitress and bring you coffee sure that's fine free", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00207-00106828-00106879": "Call Debs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00208-00107801-00108236": "OK that's fine this pick up sticks I did", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00209-00109081-00109695": "3 second time out what open pick up so what did I do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00210-00110182-00110463": "Apparent", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00211-00110566-00111103": "Not that's not the parent through looking at the second parent and then we go so just have to find", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00212-00111180-00111359": "The red timeout", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00213-00111615-00111795": "In 2 players", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00214-00112076-00112204": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00215-00112255-00112870": "It's finest so negative one is in fact an invalid value", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00216-00112895-00112998": "Don't use it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00217-00113023-00113535": "I guess I miss you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00218-00113766-00113971": "Look out get def", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00219-00114022-00114227": "Forearm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00220-00114380-00114995": "What's 50 of sauce so yes that's the deaf", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00221-00115020-00115635": "Let's get bad sauce and it's continue the rebase I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00222-00115660-00116275": "So sorry developed the develop Ranch", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00223-00116300-00116915": "Yeah it's just part of the McDonald's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00224-00116940-00117401": "Experienced clown and he's like go to the bathroom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00225-00117503-00117785": "It's very weird", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00226-00117862-00118425": "Ok we rebased Incorporated at patch I think we'll have to see", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00227-00118451-00118988": "Let's look at the code of you and get through this wait first", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00228-00119039-00119654": "I have to Cherry pick something as look at yours is to not safe for work today", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00229-00119679-00119935": "Typing chat I feel sorry for you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00230-00119961-00120575": "Let's look at the code that I wrote for windows and we'll see if we can do a bit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00231-00120601-00121164": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00232-00121190-00121804": "Some stuff fixes here which I would like to copy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00233-00121830-00122291": "Including something that fixes building on men GW", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00234-00122342-00122956": "Which I'm gonna I'm going to commit anyway because", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00235-00122982-00123315": "I don't do it someone else is going to do it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00236-00123366-00123980": "I'm just going to have a hard time so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00237-00124083-00124364": "Call anchal trash there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00238-00124748-00124902": "There's a bug with", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00239-00124927-00125542": "Seaslip I think I fix that so really I just want to copy and paste", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00240-00125567-00125823": "Figured I see file for now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00241-00125849-00126463": "A bit later", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00242-00126489-00126822": "Some other refactoring so get check out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00243-00127001-00127615": "What's better than looking at", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00244-00127641-00128256": "Words on a computer nothing it's just commit this great site wait to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00245-00128281-00128665": "Todo comment alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00246-00128691-00129203": "Let's review my really quick code ideas", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00247-00129689-00129843": "Too true", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00248-00130278-00130892": "Yep yep yep yep", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00249-00130918-00131532": "Alright so one of these things I need to fix in the initial slope Camille", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00250-00131660-00132275": "Stash this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00251-00132300-00132915": "We're gonna just not upstream it's rua use upstream use", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00252-00132940-00133478": "Riding on Forza so we're going to find", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00253-00133580-00134195": "The stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00254-00134323-00134630": "And we're just going to I guess squash this into it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00255-00134681-00134912": "Hi mate how did is a separate commit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00256-00135014-00135424": "Because it's kind of a bit of a change", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00257-00135449-00136064": "And so we're just going to hit the configure it up ACU", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00258-00136089-00136704": "Find slip code and we're just gonna put the AC message result", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00259-00136729-00137036": "Above that so it doesn't get stuck", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00260-00137088-00137420": "But doesn't want the output", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00261-00137446-00138060": "You can't pass any of this therefore I'm smart", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00262-00138342-00138726": "So working Tas", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00263-00138752-00139366": "From the Coles who seems to have gone missing how's your day are you having", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00264-00139776-00139929": "Sleep", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00265-00140313-00140544": "So let's see", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00266-00142233-00142848": "Networking is enabled ad networking libraries last on Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00267-00142873-00143334": "That seems decent", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00268-00143360-00143974": "A very cold night", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00269-00144000-00144358": "Don't you have like the heater or", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00270-00144384-00144819": "A house or something", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00271-00144921-00145356": "Figure", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00272-00145459-00145894": "6", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00273-00145920-00146022": "Building", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00274-00146406-00147020": "Building slab c", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00275-00147251-00147865": "Samsung Galaxy building slab on minjee W I'm just going to ask this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00276-00147891-00148326": "Say trust me a good kind of cold like the freezing cold so like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00277-00148403-00148659": "The cold I am now when a shirt feels damp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00278-00148812-00148940": "And it's morning", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00279-00149043-00149632": "You think things happened and now you're here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00280-00149734-00150348": "That's better that's a lot of my hands", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00281-00150451-00150809": "So what do we do in this commit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00282-00151142-00151756": "Sydney libraries that should be Big W", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00283-00151782-00151910": "Slip slop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00284-00151961-00152166": "Libraries", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00285-00152192-00152601": "Linking", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00286-00152883-00153190": "Staff required", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00287-00153292-00153856": "Requires icons and networking reminder is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00288-00154470-00154803": "As STL dent", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00289-00154828-00155110": "Already record", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00290-00155136-00155724": "Cutting going over the line and they're already requires my limits", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00291-00155852-00156134": "Sorry choirs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00292-00156160-00156620": "Ori requires", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00293-00156774-00157286": "Networking libraries on Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00294-00157491-00158054": "Refactor and use that code for live slurp networking", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00295-00158080-00158208": "ABC", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00296-00158233-00158361": "Nip slips", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00297-00158387-00159001": "Library dependencies how do you feel about a certain scientific railgun Metal Gear", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00298-00159155-00159462": "Use that code for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00299-00159488-00160102": "That seems about accurate that again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00300-00161228-00161433": "You know what I'm actually going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00301-00161459-00161766": "Fixit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00302-00162995-00163609": "That we actually just fix that Sony explains in the code what's happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00303-00163635-00164249": "How do you feel about Venom snake and which and cream in your future code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00304-00164300-00164403": "Eschool", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00305-00164480-00164966": "So important that the other thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00306-00165017-00165196": "Dial would like to import", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00307-00165299-00165504": "From my windows brand", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00308-00165580-00165939": "I just quickly look", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00309-00166476-00166988": "Second I just check this out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00310-00167040-00167526": "No I don't want to check it out I want to go I'll check out the the misc thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00311-00167552-00168166": "You're not know I just figured it out later I have some code I want to separate the plat", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00312-00168192-00168473": "The platform-specific stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00313-00168524-00169139": "So do that to the other thing I want to do is fix the naming convention", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00314-00169830-00170444": "Ethernet slips stuff.co use underscore", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00315-00170470-00170572": "Yeah for some reason", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00316-00170982-00171596": "So let's see you get packets received packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00317-00171750-00172364": "Avoid toll tag oldest Romance", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00318-00172390-00172672": "Remove the underscores it's not helping anyone", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00319-00173132-00173593": "Greater second today includes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00320-00174105-00174617": "I didn't cherry picker fix sorry I have to do that the second not do that now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00321-00174643-00174899": "Get log", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00322-00174924-00175334": "Mind slash slappy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00323-00175488-00176102": "Quick fix will squash later that's just cherry-pick that I don't need the other ones and", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00324-00176128-00176358": "That was never used", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00325-00176384-00176998": "Let's get back to this so it's that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00326-00177356-00177638": "Summer just going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00327-00178099-00178713": "Find things with the underscore and remove that so received", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00328-00179481-00180096": "Timer timer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00329-00180633-00181017": "Time is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00330-00181171-00181580": "Call Paul", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00331-00181990-00182604": "Coles Coles and Edward do I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00332-00182630-00182937": "Get events is another theme", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00333-00182963-00183577": "Call get slack Silence", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00334-00183603-00184089": "Polska slurp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00335-00185292-00185600": "I think that should work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00336-00186137-00186368": "Coles", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00337-00186419-00186803": "That's so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00338-00187084-00187545": "Text underscore naming Convention and will squash that in a bit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00339-00187648-00188262": "At this point I should probably try and build this thing right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00340-00188953-00189081": "Yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00341-00189107-00189440": "No not mean GW build Evoque", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00342-00189491-00189798": "Sdl2", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00343-00189875-00190156": "So what are we doing that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00344-00190284-00190899": "Let's have a look at some of the changes we actually have to make a coin to cope with you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00345-00191897-00192512": "Let's have a look it's mega file for this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00346-00193024-00193408": "Make some notes let's take notes from what people weren't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00347-00193561-00193766": "Etsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00348-00193843-00194073": "Yep dumplings fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00349-00194227-00194790": "Alternate Shack using configure.ac Syntax alright let's try that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00350-00195225-00195660": "So what let's do that now since configuring it's still happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00351-00196070-00196428": "So where do I check for blue slip", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00352-00196454-00197068": "So use this junk here and this guy suggest so I could use this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00353-00197222-00197401": "Micro", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00354-00197734-00198169": "Alright sorry bin", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00355-00198195-00198656": "Etsy secret slip slap Libs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00356-00198886-00199040": "Phones", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00357-00199065-00199296": "Auckland tide times", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00358-00199321-00199936": "Split have lips lip down and have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00359-00199961-00200524": "So does this actually set cppflags to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00360-00200550-00200729": "Greenslopes c flags", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00361-00201190-00201548": "Just that's Etsy flags I think it does", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00362-00201600-00202214": "Select actually Adeline for that cflags =", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00363-00202240-00202547": "Cflags", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00364-00202931-00203545": "Why do I use sublime text editor and supply merge look I installed at him and I tried to use it but it's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00365-00203571-00203699": "Too complex for me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00366-00203750-00204108": "I guess I'm a boomer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00367-00204339-00204953": "You know what we're also going to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00368-00204979-00205593": "Instead of that we're going to do them please", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00369-00205823-00206438": "Slurp equals no also", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00370-00206464-00206924": "Slap = gas", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00371-00207539-00207974": "What are the icons in there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00372-00208000-00208614": "Search should be the same as STL net do it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00373-00209075-00209689": "Are you a c check stuff ok let's see if this works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00374-00210483-00210713": "Also want to read the output", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00375-00210764-00211046": "AC message checking for the Slopes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00376-00211148-00211763": "Let's try that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00377-00211788-00212070": "Actually here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00378-00212198-00212659": "So we're just going to look at the log in the middle I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00379-00212684-00212889": "Installed atom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00380-00213017-00213401": "It's very confusing it has a lot of things happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00381-00213478-00213555": "Like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00382-00213708-00213836": "This", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00383-00213888-00214323": "This is the door Sparks directory look like this is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00384-00214348-00214937": "I can't do this it wants my password no no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00385-00215347-00215680": "Yes I guess I'll be working on this file", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00386-00215782-00216012": "You think it's purple what's a doing now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00387-00216166-00216448": "It's freaking out I'm building stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00388-00216832-00217446": "Text so longer open Stuff Netflix all these red lines under stuffing if I right click", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00389-00217932-00218214": "There's a lot of things have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00390-00218240-00218342": "Happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00391-00218547-00218854": "And I don't know how I feel about it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00392-00219008-00219187": "Adidas", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00393-00219648-00219827": "How do I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00394-00219955-00220236": "How do I get rid of a lion Sora", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00395-00220390-00220620": "Yes I have to get up tab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00396-00220646-00220825": "How do I get rid of the royals", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00397-00221798-00222080": "I just don't want these lines there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00398-00222208-00222336": "Correct spelling", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00399-00222387-00222694": "I don't want spelling how do I disable spelling", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00400-00222796-00222950": "Packages", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00401-00223334-00223718": "I installed them mode which makes it tolerable", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00402-00223744-00223897": "Sorry spell", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00403-00223923-00224256": "Spell check disabled", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00404-00224281-00224384": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00405-00224512-00224716": "Can we go that looks like better", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00406-00224793-00225126": "So what happens if I open a h file", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00407-00225305-00225715": "Set has Syntax highlighting and I don't want that either", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00408-00225996-00226176": "Preferences", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00409-00226227-00226304": "I don't know", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00410-00226560-00226790": "Syntax highlighting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00411-00227200-00227558": "Phone packages to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00412-00228070-00228198": "Themes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00413-00228403-00228582": "Core", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00414-00229145-00229401": "I just don't want Syntax highlighting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00415-00229888-00230195": "And sorry it's this point", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00416-00230220-00230553": "It's taking me way too long to configure", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00417-00230630-00230809": "Justice editor itself", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00418-00230912-00231142": "I just don't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00419-00231167-00231372": "Is it in view", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00420-00231705-00232115": "There's too many things am I happy to sell my computer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00421-00232166-00232473": "I just wanted to try it but", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00422-00232576-00233062": "A lot of things I need", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00423-00233318-00233676": "What is the config should I should I sense that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00424-00233907-00234060": "I don't know", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00425-00234188-00234547": "I don't know what any of this is style sheet is that what it is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00426-00234598-00234675": "Nope", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00427-00235110-00235571": "I just got my syntax-highlighting off and so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00428-00235673-00235929": "The main problem here is that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00429-00236006-00236211": "I would have to Google", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00430-00236262-00236492": "Search how to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00431-00236671-00236928": "Disable Syntax highlighting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00432-00237081-00237209": "Granted", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00433-00237260-00237875": "Them isn't much better but I can search up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00434-00237900-00238387": "Syntax and it has no quick start", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00435-00238464-00238796": "The switches on Syntax highlighting Syntax on", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00436-00238822-00239155": "Ok Syntax off", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00437-00239180-00239360": "And look it works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00438-00239616-00240025": "When has an entire help manual inside it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00439-00240076-00240691": "It's well worth the read so if I go help here what do I have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00440-00240767-00240896": "Documentation", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00441-00240998-00241228": "Flight manual", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00442-00241536-00241792": "Bok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00443-00241919-00242073": "Using atom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00444-00242099-00242227": "Syntax", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00445-00242457-00242611": "Syntax", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00446-00242713-00242969": "Syntax", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00447-00243200-00243584": "Syntax my Syntax team", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00448-00243686-00244223": "Shadow Dom not like this in I just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00449-00244249-00244864": "It's too much for me I just don't want the Syntax highlighting because it distracts", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00450-00245427-00245964": "How do I turn off syntaxhighlighter I'm getting so angry at something that I'm not even using", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00451-00246016-00246630": "I don't think I'm missing anything I hang on a second does the help feature", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00452-00246656-00246758": "Search feature", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00453-00247167-00247321": "Can I search for things", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00454-00247423-00247961": "Help search issues no that's probably get harder shoes Christchurch issues", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00455-00248089-00248704": "What is this website why isn't a huge big is it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00456-00249164-00249625": "I hit tab and I can barely see the indicator for focus", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00457-00249779-00250393": "What am I focusing on here if I keep the key what happens is it learn more", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00458-00250419-00250675": "Get hard on adam.com", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00459-00250956-00251571": "Cannot click the fork on github button with my keyboard you failed the", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00460-00251596-00251775": "Accessibility test buddy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00461-00251852-00252159": "Wait no that might be half that c", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00462-00252441-00252595": "Forks", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00463-00253286-00253593": "Why is there a sign in on a website", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00464-00253721-00253926": "I can sign into Adam look", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00465-00254335-00254950": "That's such it how to disable Syntax highlighting in in", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00466-00255974-00256255": "They have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00467-00256716-00257331": "Have to install package called file types and then change the extension 3 plane", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00468-00257356-00257638": "Are you kidding me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00469-00257971-00258585": "I have to set the file type to plain text I can't actually turn off Syntax highlighting do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00470-00258790-00258892": "What", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00471-00259071-00259379": "So I have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00472-00259404-00259839": "It wants me to press ctrl shift l", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00473-00259942-00260044": "File", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00474-00260147-00260326": "Could you up from the menu somewhere", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00475-00260403-00260812": "How to change the file type", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00476-00261171-00261299": "Is it in", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00477-00261555-00262041": "Is this a hidden key press ctrl shift l", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00478-00262195-00262527": "Auto-detect plaintext", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00479-00262630-00263244": "Ok so I just have to get every single extension for every file that I use including files that don't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00480-00263270-00263398": "Extensions", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00481-00263423-00263756": "I like this one that's ordered attacked", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00482-00263935-00264371": "Cell to plain text OK that's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00483-00264396-00264499": "This is fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00484-00265087-00265292": "See this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00485-00265318-00265932": "Are you Syntax highlighting on the Stream here because it helps people", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00486-00265958-00266444": "I can't turn it off and I do that in my actual at home on my other computer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00487-00266598-00267161": "Sometimes doesn't work and it confuses my eyes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00488-00267596-00268006": "So it's like I could probably use this for a stream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00489-00268287-00268518": "Let's try it you know what", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00490-00268569-00269107": "Let's try that say this is the streaming today config.log", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00491-00269286-00269542": "Let's find slurp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00492-00270207-00270387": "How do I search stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00493-00270515-00270950": "So is it the sash I've got their mode in so this would be looking for lipslut", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00494-00271052-00271129": "Ok fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00495-00271155-00271769": "Thanks for putting the screen all the way across like that checking for live slurp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00496-00271923-00272076": "Checking for slurp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00497-00272537-00272691": "Result yes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00498-00272767-00272921": "Ok so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00499-00273459-00273919": "Yes so we have to edit the slab I can turn it off", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00500-00274585-00275046": "So I forgot to put the slab here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00501-00275071-00275455": "Know what the taxi search this no no I think that make sense", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00502-00276454-00276838": "Also a c define it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00503-00276863-00277478": "I think that's what to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00504-00277503-00277708": "And then if we don't have it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00505-00277734-00278348": "We put the warning message that I'm not sure if this is the right way to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00506-00278604-00279219": "Wait let's see how other people do it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00507-00279270-00279884": "No one's using this ok well are you changing code or am I revising my own", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00508-00279910-00280345": "Set revising my own code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00509-00280371-00280985": "What is the same mix of tabs and spaces", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00510-00281036-00281548": "Use tabs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00511-00281907-00282239": "Absolute because no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00512-00282316-00282521": "AEC message warn", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00513-00282649-00283263": "We're just going to put that there and another", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00514-00283289-00283596": "I think so will they actually", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00515-00283622-00283750": "Work for us", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00516-00284083-00284364": "We'll see how it goes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00517-00284646-00284825": "Attack c", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00518-00284851-00285286": "Key this to a build output", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00519-00285798-00285900": "Merry go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00520-00285926-00286335": "I guess you're just going to try messing with this a bit more", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00521-00286515-00286847": "Sorry has false election thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00522-00287001-00287539": "That's cool you can focus to get TAB with control nine that's easy to remember", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00523-00287718-00288332": "You can total the github tablet ctrl shift I said sometimes you posted shift sometimes it Pest Control", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00524-00288383-00288537": "Ok buddy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00525-00288716-00288972": "You can focus to get opt out with control aid", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00526-00289126-00289382": "Ok whatever", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00527-00289484-00289971": "Let's go and find out ethernet code into a bit of refactoring", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00528-00290047-00290201": "With Adam", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00529-00290483-00290687": "Oh yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00530-00290713-00290841": "I have to find a dodo", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00531-00291071-00291251": "Source misc", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00532-00291327-00291404": "Ethernet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00533-00291763-00292044": "It's a nice lot of", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00534-00292326-00292607": "What is with these colours", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00535-00292915-00293145": "What's with this phone", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00536-00293273-00293427": "Is it not big enough", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00537-00293657-00294246": "Hang on if we go to them source mask", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00538-00294374-00294988": "Snap slap.com and we go and we have a look at the same type code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00539-00295091-00295321": "So what's highlighted here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00540-00295423-00295526": "The types", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00541-00295603-00295884": "So void and the return statement", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00542-00295935-00296294": "Instruct so kind of those keywords and here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00543-00296499-00296652": "Everything's highlighted", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00544-00296703-00296831": "All the types here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00545-00296959-00297113": "The call settings", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00546-00297676-00298035": "Ok whatever will do this we're going to do this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00547-00298137-00298393": "I just have to ignore the highlighting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00548-00298803-00298905": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00549-00299110-00299673": "So we're actually going to try and fact about platform-specific stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00550-00299852-00300134": "Find Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00551-00300159-00300595": "Here see how the ethernet pickup thing works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00552-00300646-00300825": "FDF win32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00553-00301055-00301337": "Alright I'm using the atmosphere let's do this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00554-00301388-00301644": "Control tab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00555-00301670-00301772": "What", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00556-00301798-00302105": "Oh you've got a big TAB switcher for me thanks", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00557-00302233-00302335": "I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00558-00302540-00302847": "That's not boring at all", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00559-00303001-00303129": "Etsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00560-00303385-00303897": "If not defined window two", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00561-00303923-00304230": "And if", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00562-00304358-00304563": "Yep", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00563-00304588-00305100": "Comfy no I'm going to use atom today", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00564-00305407-00306022": "I mean it has fancy colours", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00565-00306047-00306201": "Deep freeze", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00566-00306329-00306457": "What's happened", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00567-00306585-00306790": "It just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00568-00306867-00307020": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00569-00307148-00307532": "Something happened there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00570-00307583-00307891": "I'm sure it's nothing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00571-00307942-00308070": "Etsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00572-00308249-00308863": "Also got a card error", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00573-00309503-00310118": "No support for a Windows yet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00574-00310630-00310988": "Wait no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00575-00311244-00311372": "Then we go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00576-00311679-00311731": "Quiet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00577-00312089-00312703": "I probably shouldn't be doing win32 here should I should be there in like us", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00578-00313062-00313420": "Let's see what polar hate requires", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00579-00313471-00313625": "Red hot", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00580-00313983-00314598": "Paul is part of Q posix 2001 posing studio", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00581-00316108-00316262": "Is there an FDF", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00582-00316287-00316902": "RC cars with the pick up stuff we have Windows and then", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00583-00316953-00317107": "Other staff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00584-00317388-00317900": "So I guess we just going to do a Windows else something else Aussie", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00585-00318028-00318361": "No support for Windows 8", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00586-00318387-00318566": "Eclipse", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00587-00319052-00319308": "You know what works you just not going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00588-00319487-00320102": "We're going to always support building with Windows even if it doesn't work at runtime", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00589-00320127-00320691": "To do with this once it set up to play gambling a becoming game I'm going to continue my", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00590-00320716-00321049": "To how do you save the file", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00591-00321279-00321510": "It's not", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00592-00321561-00322175": "Control s so did regular vim while saving button doesn't work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00593-00322303-00322918": "OK well that's fine I don't need I don't need", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00594-00322943-00323327": "Use the button that vim users to save files", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00595-00323379-00323583": "I can just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00596-00323686-00323788": "Youth", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00597-00323814-00323916": "Yes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00598-00324019-00324249": "I'm happy and I'm fine with this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00599-00324300-00324505": "This is the modern world", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00600-00324531-00324812": "I'm giving it a chance", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00601-00324838-00325017": "So lipslap", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00602-00325171-00325350": "Again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00603-00325375-00325734": "Start alarm keys which should be", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00604-00325887-00326246": "Navigate checking for lipslap Resort Yass", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00605-00326297-00326425": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00606-00326527-00326963": "That's good I will have to check that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00607-00327142-00327475": "Later bit more thoroughly", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00608-00327628-00327961": "With a system that doesn't support live slurp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00609-00328012-00328294": "Add that to a list of notes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00610-00329215-00329599": "Create a list of notes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00611-00329727-00329958": "Nominees Adam fly notes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00612-00330035-00330342": "File new file", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00613-00330367-00330495": "Yes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00614-00330521-00330623": "Put have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00615-00330649-00330854": "Shaq", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00616-00330879-00331494": "Without web slur check that it builds", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00617-00331878-00332108": "Again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00618-00332159-00332415": "Tile savers", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00619-00332825-00333414": "Dos stuff today I'm feeling great I'm going to put a fart extension on it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00620-00333593-00333772": "As a treat", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00621-00334131-00334361": "Keep awake file extensions", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00622-00334617-00334950": "So what next is this building", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00623-00335641-00335948": "Looks decent", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00624-00336255-00336742": "Did I enable sleep for men GW no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00625-00336767-00336972": "I didn't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00626-00337407-00337510": "What's happened", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00627-00337715-00337894": "Out of date code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00628-00338099-00338713": "Game Dev know dos box Dev emulated app", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00629-00338739-00339046": "I bet I can be a better Game Dev than him", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00630-00339097-00339327": "Probably", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00631-00339353-00339558": "Play many video games", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00632-00339737-00339916": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00633-00339967-00340582": "The next thing we're going to do is as you can see I have some win32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00634-00340607-00340659": "Stuck here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00635-00340684-00340812": "Nice", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00636-00341068-00341683": "So what we're going to do is I will never say to we're just going to run time", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00637-00341708-00341811": "Power out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00638-00341939-00342553": "Like message step", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00639-00342579-00343193": "Turn on the website get a five 950 x 6960 PC gaming is alive", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00640-00343475-00343782": "Compile some kernels using that right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00641-00344422-00344627": "Return false", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00642-00344908-00345139": "MDF", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00643-00345395-00345881": "Kontrol S4 saving I know how to save stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00644-00345983-00346598": "So we can also have to break off all the stuff it was pole", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00645-00346828-00347033": "And in practice this means", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00646-00347059-00347238": "These three functions here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00647-00347263-00347468": "A platform specific", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00648-00347519-00347724": "And we're going to have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00649-00347801-00348083": "Take out Pole from here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00650-00348646-00348902": "And so what we're going to do is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00651-00349030-00349286": "Magnet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00652-00349388-00349567": "Pole pole you know what", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00653-00349670-00349747": "Oops", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00654-00349875-00350335": "OK this is not acceptable", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00655-00350489-00350694": "This is absolutely unacceptable", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00656-00350924-00351513": "The room plugin does not make control a jump back to where I was before", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00657-00351692-00351897": "Explain how this works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00658-00352102-00352716": "If I like 2 something like this and I go down", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00659-00352742-00353049": "Pest control 02 go back to where I was", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00660-00353126-00353382": "Which ASX is doesn't work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00661-00353407-00354022": "How does it work is jump Point somewhere control", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00662-00354534-00354943": "I think it just works whenever I move the cursor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00663-00355046-00355660": "Nope I was at work I've been using", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00664-00355993-00356326": "All the cursor position in jump list", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00665-00356479-00356863": "Jump is a command that normally moves the cursor several wines away", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00666-00356915-00357478": "Jump the position of the person before the jump is remembered alright sorry if I do like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00667-00357503-00357683": "OK I'm going to go down a screen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00668-00357811-00357964": "No I can go back a screen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00669-00357990-00358195": "Ice cream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00670-00358323-00358451": "And", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00671-00358476-00358732": "Config.get opens", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00672-00358783-00359039": "Thanks down screen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00673-00359321-00359500": "Tsconfig gas opening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00674-00359603-00359679": "You know what", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00675-00359961-00360422": "I guess forward back does it count as a job so it'd be like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00676-00360575-00360780": "I think what happens is this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00677-00360857-00361087": "You move around", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00678-00361113-00361548": "And you do some stuff with your Curtis like hi there and then you move around", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00679-00361625-00361855": "Can you do some more stuff with your cursor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00680-00361881-00362111": "If you want to go back you keep control au", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00681-00362854-00363468": "What the f*** am I doing that work sometimes see what jobs are", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00682-00363801-00364185": "Testing WhatsApp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00683-00364211-00364441": "Go down here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00684-00364723-00365030": "Testing what's not up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00685-00365183-00365337": "Patrol au", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00686-00365388-00365567": "Text me back here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00687-00365849-00366335": "Set broker", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00688-00368511-00368972": "I guess I don't need that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00689-00369151-00369766": "I think I've been using it maybe just needs me to take some time twins stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00690-00369894-00370201": "Ok work on this Aries", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00691-00370508-00370713": "Hey you up here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00692-00370841-00371302": "Change something else", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00693-00371327-00371942": "Yeah so I guess that's what what happens I guess I just have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00694-00371967-00372300": "Wait a bit of time and it will settle with the value", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00695-00372582-00373196": "Answer USD I like be working somewhere in A4 like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00696-00373222-00373606": "Copy and paste all ads", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00697-00373631-00373964": "Work down here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00698-00373990-00374399": "Delete some stuff and then I'm like I want to go back", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00699-00374527-00375014": "I don't work I hate that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00700-00375193-00375526": "Well I guess we're not using it I'm just putting that in my", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00701-00375577-00375756": "Dust up stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00702-00376396-00376627": "Weird", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00703-00376883-00377036": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00704-00377062-00377267": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00705-00377343-00377855": "We want to make it a thing called also high aquatic washing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00706-00378367-00378931": "Current political figure out a command chords", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00707-00378956-00379571": "Coles Pole", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00708-00379596-00379724": "They all the knots", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00709-00379852-00380108": "And we're going to take it timeout", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00710-00380671-00381209": "I'm sure I'm sure hang on a second", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00711-00381235-00381619": "Veeam doesn't remember jumps", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00712-00382899-00383155": "Why is via not remember my jumps", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00713-00383308-00383590": "Don't give me the Illuminati symbol please", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00714-00383999-00384179": "I'm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00715-00384665-00384819": "I'm confused", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00716-00384895-00385254": "Then you could trade me you must be trash", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00717-00385433-00385919": "Did atom break it maybe", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00718-00385945-00386406": "Remote control", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00719-00386790-00387123": "So vs code them is it at", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00720-00387532-00388019": "How does remote control car", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00721-00389017-00389529": "Jump I'm getting off track here but", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00722-00389555-00389734": "Etsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00723-00390169-00390502": "Are you using ok I see what's happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00724-00390707-00391065": "What's try looking at them again because I might just be using it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00725-00391270-00391884": "Without thinking about it cos I swear I've never had a problem just jump to it's like it out today", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00726-00392422-00392678": "I guess I edit this file", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00727-00392780-00392883": "Using", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00728-00392934-00393318": "This file vs code stuff so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00729-00393343-00393702": "Stop using item instead", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00730-00393881-00394060": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00731-00394470-00394726": "How old is an era", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00732-00395212-00395827": "Dare you give me a rose cannot find icon that's true", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00733-00395852-00396083": "That's true", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00734-00396799-00396979": "There's other stuff you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00735-00397235-00397721": "Ok so my code here is broken", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00736-00398105-00398335": "Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00737-00398361-00398591": "6 icon", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00738-00398924-00399539": "I have just hard code that in Windows alright so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00739-00399564-00400153": "Editing using the broken code I don't know", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00740-00400332-00400947": "So we going to go to sleep thing and we're going to change this to timeout", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00741-00400998-00401254": "MS", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00742-00401331-00401612": "Can use Kontrol S4 saving", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00743-00401817-00401971": "Sir", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00744-00402022-00402636": "Packets", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00745-00402662-00403276": "Pole pole and 32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00746-00403302-00403711": "MS", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00747-00403737-00404070": "And then we're going to do our open bracket", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00748-00404198-00404607": "Am I going to just put this year", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00749-00404812-00404991": "Arm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00750-00405068-00405555": "Turn rats", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00751-00405785-00406399": "Greater than -1 I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00752-00406425-00406937": "Is today it will succeed", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00753-00406988-00407475": "It's not -1 like it's not -1 or less", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00754-00407654-00408038": "So we're just going to put", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00755-00408396-00408831": "Pole pole", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00756-00409395-00409804": "See", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00757-00409830-00410060": "So it's going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00758-00410291-00410547": "Let's just remove that the gation", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00759-00410828-00411443": "No it's not going to keep it negation so this returns true if it succeeded", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00760-00411468-00411622": "Return", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00761-00411647-00412236": "Turn wrapping values ng a not ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00762-00412262-00412671": "Something to put that down here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00763-00412851-00413209": "I'm going to have pohlad pulgas rents", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00764-00413388-00413977": "And that's just put polarclear a but everything else", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00765-00414259-00414745": "So the order them in kind of the way of the program Robinson", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00766-00414822-00415103": "Good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00767-00415411-00416025": "Today FM", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00768-00416383-00416665": "What", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00769-00416895-00417049": "Jumps", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00770-00417203-00417331": "Are you kidding me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00771-00417740-00417945": "Wait", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00772-00418047-00418252": "Jump 0 there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00773-00418585-00419020": "Have I tried eating them and", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00774-00419379-00419660": "Jump 18", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00775-00419711-00420326": "Shop dating jobs 18", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00776-00420351-00420889": "Jump characters help jump", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00777-00421580-00421887": "OK so you would be 18 Patrol", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00778-00422220-00422451": "Help I'm stuck in the jump list", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00779-00422604-00423116": "What the hell is that what my issue has been", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00780-00423219-00423398": "Where am I now ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00781-00423526-00423756": "Sorry if I go down a little bit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00782-00423782-00424345": "I go back up my jump start working again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00783-00424575-00424729": "No they're not", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00784-00424780-00424959": "Yes they", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00785-00425497-00426009": "Ok I needed I think my jumps working again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00786-00426086-00426700": "Sun jump 0 there if I type some stuff here test test test", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00787-00426726-00427263": "I got here and I can't test test test black jump back", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00788-00427315-00427571": "It takes me to hear why", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00789-00427980-00428211": "I'm so angry I'm going to be", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00790-00428262-00428646": "Talking to the vroc about they took their manager", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00791-00428851-00429081": "Are you going to destroy it's our", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00792-00429183-00429414": "Yep so we go down there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00793-00429619-00430003": "Maybe I need to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00794-00430028-00430233": "Got here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00795-00430387-00430745": "Type stuff back", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00796-00430873-00431052": "It takes me to initialise", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00797-00431334-00431539": "Why what's happened to you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00798-00431667-00431846": "I was never out initialise", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00799-00432025-00432230": "How do I get to neutralise", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00800-00433023-00433254": "Put the jumps again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00801-00433791-00434406": "Tested the day as it's telecast how did I get there you know what I'm debugging this now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00802-00434559-00434713": "Turn the computer off", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00803-00434815-00435046": "Figure this out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00804-00435097-00435609": "So let's say I'm doing work here I'm at clock get nanoseconds", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00805-00435635-00436249": "Yeah what I'm going to change that to clock no time wow that's a bug I haven't noticed", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00806-00436351-00436633": "I'm going to head on down to my pole stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00807-00436863-00436966": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00808-00437145-00437324": "What are my jumps like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00809-00437427-00437606": "Exit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00810-00438451-00439065": "Why is it recording a macro now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00811-00440755-00441011": "Sorry jaqueta", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00812-00441113-00441369": "Look-see it comes now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00813-00442342-00442726": "Jumped me to back here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00814-00442751-00443084": "So is it time based", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00815-00443110-00443238": "It should be", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00816-00443263-00443494": "Alright let's try this again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00817-00443519-00444134": "We're gonna go over here I'm gonna wait there for a little bit I'm going to see if it's just figures", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00818-00444159-00444211": "Doubt", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00819-00444236-00444799": "What's happening when we do that we're going to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00820-00444953-00445183": "Yep that's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00821-00445260-00445567": "And on Windows it will do polls", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00822-00445593-00445695": "Army wall", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00823-00445798-00446054": "Not use Coles", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00824-00446515-00446924": "We might actually just want to remove that space there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00825-00447283-00447359": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00826-00447564-00447769": "That seems about right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00827-00447974-00448255": "No it's go back and look", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00828-00448588-00448742": "152", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00829-00448844-00449151": "So now if I jump down", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00830-00449203-00449433": "Only going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00831-00449459-00449612": "Right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00832-00450047-00450457": "If not death win32 oops", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00833-00450559-00450764": "So I made a mistake there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00834-00450790-00450969": "Let's look at the jump list", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00835-00451353-00451558": "Control over to go back", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00836-00451583-00452019": "And it puts me at clock at nanosecond what", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00837-00452070-00452479": "I have no idea what that was happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00838-00452505-00452838": "Is this a barking on I'm going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00839-00452991-00453478": "I'll look at it later I'll be doing dustbox stuff here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00840-00453657-00454015": "So we have the platform specific code here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00841-00454041-00454271": "I use atom for this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00842-00455628-00456115": "Using the Moses", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00843-00456140-00456601": "Australia Post square here feno32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00844-00457241-00457753": "Else and then we're just going to add dummy stuff here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00845-00457779-00458291": "Message just going to do nothing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00846-00458316-00458931": "This is going to avoid fat", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00847-00459084-00459468": "Lloyd slap events", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00848-00459494-00460108": "So like it's not using them and it's going to return", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00849-00460262-00460543": "0", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00850-00460723-00461158": "Here it's going to return false", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00851-00461183-00461747": "Always has this issue", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00852-00462233-00462847": "And then this is going to always returning 0 and void", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00853-00462873-00463257": "Radiax", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00854-00463462-00463692": "We have some search in there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00855-00463999-00464460": "What sucks that seems fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00856-00464511-00464819": "So we have some code here for Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00857-00464921-00465203": "Kodi for Linux grape", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00858-00465331-00465510": "3 Creek Parade", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00859-00465945-00466508": "Let's go check this out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00860-00466662-00467046": "Let's build this stuff from", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00861-00467532-00467942": "Ok say something bad is happening there how do I build stuff from Adam", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00862-00468095-00468300": "Bio edit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00863-00468377-00468659": "Can this buildings view", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00864-00468684-00468761": "Developer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00865-00469017-00469222": "If you get tab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00866-00469452-00469631": "How are you no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00867-00469657-00469734": "What", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00868-00470579-00470783": "I don't know it don't need that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00869-00470911-00471065": "I build stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00870-00471091-00471705": "File with f fight", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00871-00472089-00472319": "How do you build stuff in Adam", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00872-00472371-00472499": "What's the point", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00873-00472575-00472806": "Do I need a configuration", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00874-00472831-00473062": "Edit preferences", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00875-00473190-00473318": "Install", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00876-00473343-00473523": "Make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00877-00473881-00474137": "What's an attitude to run in canoe make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00878-00474265-00474572": "Is a lot of packages here for running make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00879-00474777-00475315": "8 gas I should pick the one with the most downloads", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00880-00476262-00476646": "Compile curry active c for sale", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00881-00476825-00477055": "Shortcut to compile run of 6", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00882-00477158-00477337": "Tdm-gcc", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00883-00477363-00477465": "What's that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00884-00478054-00478335": "Gcc compiler Windows friendly", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00885-00479103-00479359": "Ok well let's install this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00886-00479411-00480025": "The singer really want from a text editor as having to install plugins for function", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00887-00480204-00480819": "Is there a plugin for disabling disabling Syntax highlighting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00888-00480844-00481459": "I got I got to put it checking on Syntax off", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00889-00482073-00482329": "Disabled", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00890-00482483-00482816": "Making things happening yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00891-00482943-00483225": "Disable Anti-Aliasing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00892-00483276-00483481": "What are you talking about", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00893-00483558-00484121": "Turn text I don't want emoji Syntax", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00894-00484249-00484710": "Simple text highlighting for text plain files that's the opposite of what I want", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00895-00484915-00485120": "Sorry packages", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00896-00485555-00485683": "Settings", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00897-00485708-00485939": "What do I do how do I use", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00898-00486220-00486579": "I think I'm supposed to press F6 so let's do this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00899-00486604-00486860": "Have sex", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00900-00487091-00487270": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00901-00487654-00487782": "What are you doing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00902-00487859-00488294": "Control shift F6 to complete to make the whole project", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00903-00488422-00488576": "Like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00904-00488652-00488832": "Compartment of 6", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00905-00488857-00489164": "Run option controller control F6", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00906-00489318-00489625": "That's not working", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00907-00489651-00489907": "Commander fix I don't have a command", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00908-00489984-00490214": "Ok it might be in packages", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00909-00492006-00492288": "It's not impacted", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00910-00492313-00492928": "But it's something I can do all the time for a document so it might be in the right click menu ok control", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00911-00493056-00493337": "Toggle run options", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00912-00493491-00493644": "Capalaba", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00913-00493798-00494182": "What time just to right click on the folder into compile", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00914-00494310-00494412": "Look", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00915-00494745-00495078": "Execute makefile from preview gacha", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00916-00495129-00495513": "We just have to find the makefile and we just have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00917-00495590-00495718": "Compilot", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00918-00495743-00495820": "Run it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00919-00495923-00496000": "Make run", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00920-00496179-00496332": "Haha easy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00921-00496384-00496563": "I did it guys", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00922-00496844-00496998": "Where's my app to make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00923-00497561-00497843": "Where's the output what's it is it doing something", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00924-00498047-00498406": "Turn on this small to execute command output in console", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00925-00498918-00499148": "Is it making things still", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00926-00499712-00499839": "What's happening", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00927-00500224-00500352": "Did it work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00928-00500684-00500812": "Please", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00929-00501043-00501196": "Why you not", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00930-00501222-00501606": "Getting angry at text again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00931-00501939-00502374": "Maybe I need to naval debugmode that makes it to the console", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00932-00502451-00502681": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00933-00502707-00503142": "Where is the console new developer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00934-00503296-00503680": "Soul", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00935-00504447-00504908": "Pains it in pains", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00936-00505036-00505190": "I can't go to view", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00937-00505216-00505523": "It won't let me go to view because it's blocking", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00938-00506419-00506598": "Console", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00939-00506828-00507340": "Turn on the spider log2console", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00940-00507596-00507724": "Oh wow", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00941-00507750-00507827": "Thanks for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00942-00508134-00508672": "Just notifications are there more buttons", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00943-00508825-00509337": "Things that look exactly like text with no indication that their buttons are actually", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00944-00509414-00509516": "Buttons", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00945-00509670-00509798": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00946-00510003-00510208": "Are there any more", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00947-00510822-00511436": "Compile run maybe I need to run that again on the makefile and it will show me the console or something", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00948-00511539-00511641": "Background", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00949-00512768-00512921": "Gatton console", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00950-00513177-00513535": "Is that a package ctrl alt I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00951-00513817-00514022": "K", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00952-00514047-00514662": "Annie Mac stole console in face that's not what I want I want to control all I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00953-00514841-00514969": "Control or", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00954-00515020-00515123": "Hi", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00955-00515276-00515404": "Control", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00956-00515430-00515507": "L", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00957-00515839-00516044": "Patrol", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00958-00516096-00516403": "Case l order case I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00959-00516531-00516633": "Is that a papaya", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00960-00516966-00517196": "Number 1 i l", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00961-00517273-00517376": "Control", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00962-00517606-00518220": "I locked my computer screen I got I got", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00963-00518425-00518528": "I got tricked", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00964-00518630-00519244": "It's not controlled hell I hope because that locks my computer control shift", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00965-00519398-00519475": "No", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00966-00519577-00519884": "Console is the rightmost tab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00967-00520499-00520550": "Look", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00968-00520627-00520806": "I'm trying to like this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00969-00521318-00521702": "Control shift l is that an l", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00970-00521907-00522086": "Set an l", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00971-00522163-00522393": "Hell High", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00972-00522419-00522598": "Put the capital I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00973-00522726-00522854": "Control shift", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00974-00522880-00523008": "Capital I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00975-00523238-00523340": "Yes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00976-00523392-00523571": "Console", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00977-00523776-00524390": "Now we run make ticket the output", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00978-00524492-00524595": "Nothing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00979-00524825-00524953": "Well", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00980-00525312-00525798": "Is mate running", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00981-00526105-00526438": "I guess it's just killed", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00982-00527897-00528512": "That Killers make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00983-00528537-00529152": "Alright so I'm going to have to be using making the terminal because I guess I'm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00984-00529177-00529331": "I just can't understand", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00985-00529382-00529689": "How did run make from a text editor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00986-00530483-00530662": "Am I out of touch", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00987-00531148-00531379": "I must be right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00988-00531481-00531660": "There's no way", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00989-00531788-00532352": "Let's just have a look at our get DF", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00990-00533120-00533452": "So that should wear I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00991-00534016-00534297": "What got some space in problems now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00992-00534425-00535040": "Using TAB somewhere ok so I'm using tabs everywhere", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00993-00535065-00535449": "Sets the consistent thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00994-00535475-00535961": "So edit source missed the internet slow", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00995-00536012-00536627": "Using TAB here using tab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00996-00536652-00537190": "Yep just need to have another tap gacha", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00997-00537446-00537651": "I did it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00998-00537702-00537804": "Kinder", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-00999-00537907-00538291": "Oh it gave me a compile error here so it did work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01000-00538316-00538419": "Kinder", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01001-00538752-00538931": "That's a warning", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01002-00539187-00539340": "Maybe", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01003-00539545-00540057": "Why compile error cos I terminated", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01004-00540492-00540723": "Do you want a good old mate there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01005-00540851-00541465": "Let's look at our makefile how can figure file in see how I can fix this icons", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01006-00541491-00541696": "Stop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01007-00542156-00542259": "Put it on", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01008-00542412-00542592": "See I guess they're", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01009-00542771-00543180": "Where is wood slab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01010-00543257-00543436": "So on Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01011-00543590-00543795": "Rib slip needs icons", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01012-00544076-00544281": "How we can add that there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01013-00546483-00547046": "I'm starting to think that using package check modules isn't it work here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01014-00547174-00547788": "It's not the same as what everyone else is doing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01015-00548326-00548505": "Library test", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01016-00548915-00549350": "Nearby cons", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01017-00550272-00550886": "I'm not really convinced about that that does", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01018-00550912-00550988": "Stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01019-00551424-00551884": "Package track modules cos I need two", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01020-00552243-00552524": "I need to add icon", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01021-00552550-00552857": "Big 4 slab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01022-00552985-00553164": "If it's not windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01023-00554112-00554342": "I have to do a case host for that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01024-00554803-00555136": "But shouldn't have icon", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01025-00555443-00555750": "Ok so no decoration matches pole pole", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01026-00555904-00556083": "Unterminated f", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01027-00556800-00557107": "I end up not adding an extra end if", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01028-00557132-00557363": "Gotcha", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01029-00557440-00557875": "And then we're going to find where I used time out by accident", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01030-00558438-00558540": "Let It Go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01031-00558822-00558976": "Pole pole", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01032-00559001-00559078": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01033-00559155-00559462": "Something", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01034-00559590-00559718": "Poles poles", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01035-00560076-00560230": "West Papua", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01036-00560358-00560486": "Paul", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01037-00560614-00560947": "Paul and then we're going to do polls poll", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01038-00561024-00561126": "Replace all", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01039-00561152-00561356": "Cut and paste", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01040-00562022-00562560": "Let's see that work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01041-00562585-00562867": "Quick more at this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01042-00562892-00563148": "I do want it to build", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01043-00563174-00563379": "On men GW", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01044-00564300-00564608": "Should I do want to eventually work on in GW", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01045-00564812-00564966": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01046-00565299-00565478": "Wrath and make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01047-00565504-00565657": "It would be in RAF", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01048-00566041-00566528": "Press make that started make bowls make me Big W", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01049-00566630-00566988": "Yeah so this doesn't add slap support", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01050-00567116-00567372": "And that's probably fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01051-00567936-00568089": "Timeout", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01052-00568243-00568652": "Optus bill alright so I change that as well", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01053-00570137-00570316": "Such", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01054-00570342-00570752": "Unnecessary errors", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01055-00570982-00571187": "Put a slasher", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01056-00572057-00572518": "Dorrigo", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01057-00572569-00572672": "Save", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01058-00573056-00573235": "That's weird", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01059-00573312-00573491": "Weird and unnecessary", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01060-00575104-00575334": "I think I should be fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01061-00575539-00575872": "Ok so undefined reference to slur cleaner", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01062-00575974-00576230": "So it's not actually added to slur clip", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01063-00576256-00576358": "What is that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01064-00577152-00577561": "Package check modules is not working for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01065-00577740-00578150": "Let's check the config stuff and we'll see", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01066-00578944-00579302": "Just listening to be lipslap", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01067-00579353-00579558": "Instead of sleep because everything ended", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01068-00579968-00580121": "Make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01069-00580249-00580505": "Config got status I'm looking for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01070-00580582-00580761": "Config.log", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01071-00580787-00581248": "Slap lipslap", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01072-00581504-00581836": "Lips look alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01073-00582220-00582297": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01074-00582400-00582963": "Webslut", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01075-00582988-00583270": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01076-00583603-00583961": "Let's make this again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01077-00584012-00584371": "Try and make it a bit faster", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01078-00584473-00585088": "And just stare at this girl's on Windows it requires icon", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01079-00585676-00586240": "Why is that it should be quiet on the next dependency", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01080-00588057-00588211": "Might have to add it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01081-00588492-00588697": "In this block Butler", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01082-00589235-00589721": "Might have to be used space", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01083-00590412-00590720": "Ok so it does it work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01084-00592537-00592768": "Just pick this up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01085-00592819-00593126": "Wait no this isn't what I was testing it with was it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01086-00593152-00593382": "Just testing it with my", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01087-00593587-00593996": "Free Das machine this works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01088-00594099-00594278": "We get networking", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01089-00595404-00595916": "How many doing buddy I'm doing good at how are you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01090-00596582-00596838": "Australia ping in Google", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01091-00597401-00597939": "If your girlfriend took you to applebees on a date is it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01092-00598041-00598220": "Are you fine with I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01093-00598272-00598476": "Babinda applebee's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01094-00598809-00599372": "He gets", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01095-00599680-00599884": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01096-00600038-00600268": "That all works kind of", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01097-00600396-00600960": "And I'm split off the type from specific staff so what I'm going to do now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01098-00601472-00601881": "Define win32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01099-00601907-00602521": "And ill see if this still can I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01100-00602752-00603366": "Look at this configure", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01101-00603392-00603443": "Stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01102-00603494-00603801": "I mean", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01103-00603980-00604108": "It's better", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01104-00604160-00604288": "I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01105-00604492-00604774": "But it's gonna get my boy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01106-00604800-00605286": "Some apples they owned taxi have apples applebee's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01107-00607974-00608588": "I have to figure out how to do the window to stuff a bit late", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01108-00608614-00609049": "Perhaps on my actual Windows computer", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01109-00609075-00609228": "Ok so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01110-00609280-00609536": "Already we're getting an error here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01111-00609689-00609894": "Because it wants to use", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01112-00609945-00610073": "Win32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01113-00610201-00610816": "That makes sense because I told it to do that so it's just quickly", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01114-00610841-00611276": "Sweet that block full stop no it's just put if not definitely 32 there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01115-00611763-00612070": "I want this to at least build on win32", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01116-00612224-00612403": "So someone can", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01117-00612428-00613043": "Port it without having to go through the heck that is makefile since", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01118-00613068-00613580": "Let's see what happens if we pretend that rhyme with 32 and we're on it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01119-00614502-00614860": "See the slip say that it's failed", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01120-00615782-00616166": "Slap not implemented on Windows yet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01121-00616217-00616422": "And so this should not like", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01122-00616473-00616729": "Destroy anything yeah ok so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01123-00616883-00617088": "Yeah perfect", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01124-00617113-00617497": "So just no networking works with sleep on Windows that's good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01125-00618137-00618649": "So slap now builds on Windows which is something I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01126-00618880-00618982": "Pallets", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01127-00619008-00619238": "Yep so say that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01128-00619801-00620057": "Driver capitals", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01129-00620748-00621132": "So let's commit this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01130-00621824-00622003": "See", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01131-00622336-00622694": "Get disk digger got a c", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01132-00623667-00623820": "What is happened", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01133-00624153-00624563": "Artem have you changed the new lines", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01134-00626099-00626380": "Term", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01135-00626406-00626688": "White space", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01136-00628121-00628377": "Ignore changes in whitespace", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01137-00628864-00629376": "End of the line I don't know I'm just going to get ad configure.ac", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01138-00629401-00629990": "Stop stop stop no no no no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01139-00630041-00630144": "Help", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01140-00630195-00630630": "Talk not milk milk", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01141-00630681-00630937": "Yes no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01142-00630963-00631116": "Exit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01143-00631296-00631475": "No it's edit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01144-00631552-00632166": "If it's going to be", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01145-00632524-00632729": "I'm just sitting here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01146-00632832-00633164": "Check my rego", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01147-00633446-00634060": "Yes package.use pack is check modules I think that's what it is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01148-00634188-00634419": "Configure", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01149-00634572-00634803": "Slab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01150-00634880-00635494": "That also fixes star icon stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01151-00635520-00635878": "I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01152-00636288-00636595": "Are we going to get adsauce get", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01153-00636646-00636825": "Oh no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01154-00636851-00637465": "Has this please don't tell me this is no don't all the sauce", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01155-00637568-00638054": "Reset source", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01156-00638310-00638617": "Add sauce", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01157-00638720-00638873": "Set c", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01158-00639155-00639744": "Keith Sweat", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01159-00639820-00640051": "Factor out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01160-00640076-00640435": "Platform specific code and", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01161-00640460-00641075": "Barry Guyra", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01162-00641100-00641254": "8", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01163-00641280-00641536": "So let's look at Summit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01164-00641561-00641766": "To do list", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01165-00642483-00642969": "That needs to be done later when we try feeling in on Windows", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01166-00643174-00643584": "Check that builds without them slurp are at let's try this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01167-00643737-00644096": "So we just going to find", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01168-00644147-00644761": "I'm just going to pretend to load for wait what's happened there I funding", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01169-00644787-00645248": "To instead and then we'll just try and make it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01170-00645401-00645657": "I will see you if that works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01171-00646272-00646528": "Took it out code review", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01172-00646886-00647193": "So we've been fermented that change", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01173-00648012-00648627": "So here we bring up her about question about complaints", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01174-00648652-00649036": "Close network Coles indicate success or failure or quantity", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01175-00649062-00649446": "But I realise we not directly into facing tcp-ip", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01176-00649472-00650086": "And use p hackensack Coles to there send and receive calls not returning and it's so here I have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01177-00650112-00650291": "Get packets which doesn't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01178-00650419-00650598": "Return Any errors", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01179-00650649-00650752": "Now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01180-00650905-00651417": "The reason why I don't actually returned any roses cuz it's not much we can do about it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01181-00651596-00652057": "Const STD string backend", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01182-00652774-00653388": "Use god string backing but would most strongly suggest switching this to an email for the back in time", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01183-00653414-00654028": "That would move back in comparison to the code section which then assigns the value that's passed into this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01184-00654950-00655155": "A bit difficult", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01185-00655206-00655820": "With the configuration way things are done like I don't think there was configuration ASA", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01186-00655846-00656153": "Support synonyms", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01187-00656179-00656793": "Let's go rim sauce misc ethernet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01188-00656870-00657484": "Where do we have that strength", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01189-00657510-00657792": "Just avoids copying stuff in Maori", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01190-00658944-00659046": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01191-00659251-00659865": "Bring up a good point to do arrow logging for when things go bad", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01192-00662835-00663449": "Specifies which of the network interfaces is used for Lim pick up so it's do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01193-00663680-00664089": "Source stocks Foxtel CPP", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01194-00664473-00664857": "Splits Bose", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01195-00664883-00665497": "Which host network interface is used for the pick-up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01196-00665907-00666240": "Ok that's done", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01197-00666496-00666598": "What else", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01198-00667801-00668108": "Yeah I'm not touching code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01199-00668134-00668313": "3 factor that yet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01200-00668467-00669081": "Is not equals 0 they want me to use no point if he's not there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01201-00669107-00669721": "That's not what the existing code done is and I really don't want to just change things when copying code at", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01202-00669747-00669900": "Supposed to be copied", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01203-00669926-00670361": "Since that makes things extremely difficult to debug", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01204-00670643-00671001": "Roma screen up for now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01205-00671155-00671411": "Returns the number of bytes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01206-00671539-00671795": "Pick up send packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01207-00671974-00672256": "Should be log the number of fights", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01208-00673305-00673408": "Again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01209-00673638-00673843": "There's not really much reason to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01210-00674713-00675020": "Error loading for Peter slab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01211-00675072-00675353": "How's my bill doing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01212-00675430-00675507": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01213-00676633-00676864": "Sirocco touch search", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01214-00677299-00677606": "Slips and packet sounds confusing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01215-00677811-00678041": "Sweet boy builds yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01216-00678425-00678784": "Sorry that's fine my trash slip code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01217-00678835-00679091": "Let's look yet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01218-00679193-00679475": "Slap send packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01219-00680345-00680934": "Received packet that's change that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01220-00682393-00682675": "See if packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01221-00683468-00683724": "My name", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01222-00683929-00684262": "That's going to be that change ATSI", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01223-00684416-00684953": "Send packet uses a const and where casting away the const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01224-00685056-00685209": "Why is that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01225-00685388-00686003": "Reaction need that to not be const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01226-00686028-00686259": "Ideally that should be const right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01227-00686489-00686822": "Especially for pickup or anything", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01228-00687129-00687360": "Const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01229-00687411-00687513": "Oops", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01230-00687539-00687948": "Red Cross going to make that const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01231-00688486-00688896": "And so get packet is instead going to be const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01232-00689254-00689868": "It would do that for slurp as well I mean pick up since this is", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01233-00689894-00690073": "Change in the epi", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01234-00690252-00690636": "So we have to go to include and ethernet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01235-00691507-00691686": "Const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01236-00692070-00692684": "Resource to make the boss here const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01237-00693017-00693632": "And what does see if we can make things as concert as possible", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01238-00693657-00693990": "That's kind of how you want", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01239-00694246-00694528": "Save packet send packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01240-00694579-00695116": "It's a con stay for everyone", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01241-00695219-00695372": "Everyone gets a concert", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01242-00696806-00697420": "That's like real so use packets send packet that's a constant now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01243-00697600-00698009": "So the Abi is going to use cons to the stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01244-00698214-00698393": "Good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01245-00698444-00698700": "That will keep Cup coat like that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01246-00698905-00699110": "I don't know", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01247-00699136-00699238": "See", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01248-00699340-00699904": "Internet's biggest find currents", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01249-00700160-00700441": "Const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01250-00700467-00700672": "Space", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01251-00701593-00701824": "Are we going to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01252-00702028-00702259": "Internet pickup.com", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01253-00702361-00702464": "Various", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01254-00702668-00702950": "Alright let's find", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01255-00703001-00703334": "Faster", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01256-00703360-00703616": "Code is a bit bouncy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01257-00703641-00704179": "It's not like code supplied", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01258-00704230-00704768": "Constitute are packet data", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01259-00706073-00706355": "Rocket chain", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01260-00706483-00706841": "You know it's a bit even though it's wrong and not going to refactor it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01261-00706944-00707148": "Ok what next", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01262-00707430-00707686": "Put our college boys", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01263-00707712-00707916": "Better error message yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01264-00707968-00708300": "Slack would be needed for windows up discuss that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01265-00708377-00708608": "So timers and", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01266-00708659-00708812": "Coles stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01267-00709145-00709760": "Christian what she says man I updated my driver's I get better performance than on Windows with post-processing effects enabled", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01268-00709785-00710016": "I am so happy that's good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01269-00710118-00710553": "Are you still in invidious still is that what it is it called things", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01270-00710784-00711321": "So we worry really want this to be", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01271-00711372-00711705": "Available Ray so that's what that stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01272-00711808-00712140": "Coles", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01273-00712166-00712320": "And", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01274-00712678-00712985": "6800 XT inside a driver", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01275-00713702-00714112": "I suggest using a STD back to there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01276-00714137-00714316": "But I'm not sure", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01277-00714419-00714649": "If I want to do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01278-00714700-00714956": "Could be cool", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01279-00716211-00716390": "Scroll down", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01280-00716595-00716748": "F*** off", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01281-00716825-00717440": "Charism what happened to you what's this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01282-00718080-00718694": "I added config.exe not actually my code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01283-00718720-00719308": "I accidentally slipped this in and this JC thing is John Campbell so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01284-00719667-00720281": "What am I trying to do I'm just doing code review and clean up for a dos box patch that adds easy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01285-00720307-00720460": "Networking", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01286-00720486-00720896": "I thought I removed it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01287-00721843-00722150": "Yep", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01288-00722355-00722688": "Let's read through comments", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01289-00722739-00722944": "Of what people want", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01290-00724070-00724684": "Should this be done on all functions that only accept void so I think another thing this person", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01291-00724710-00724915": "Casey Jenner", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01292-00724966-00725580": "Forest to remove stylistically get rid of empty void functions", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01293-00725657-00726118": "So I'm going to ride to avoid", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01294-00726169-00726784": "To just empty the tease", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01295-00727244-00727398": "Let's sing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01296-00727680-00727910": "Cos I replied to a lot of things", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01297-00729088-00729395": "Yep I talked about and windows staff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01298-00729600-00729830": "Someone tried that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01299-00729856-00730240": "And we're going to have to get rid of a navel", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01300-00730265-00730880": "Because it's useless at the moment and useless configs", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01301-00730905-00731084": "Trash config stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01302-00731264-00731392": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01303-00731622-00732236": "That's it were going to do this stream cause such most the stuff I'm going to have to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01304-00732262-00732876": "Later just to see like the windows stuff I have to do laser", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01305-00732902-00733516": "Stream Ella find out why don't you just put this in the bottom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01306-00733542-00734156": "Cookie cap and slurp don't really want to do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01307-00734464-00735078": "At the bottom and I guess that's what we're going to be doing over", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01308-00735104-00735334": "Power ISO", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01309-00735692-00736230": "Having fun dude my boy hidpa yes I'm having a mild amount of fun", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01310-00736691-00737305": "What I do timer add time and I return a time and then", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01311-00737433-00737920": "Set timer 3 so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01312-00738124-00738457": "For the time is I just need to have a", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01313-00738483-00738713": "Large cplusplus array", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01314-00738739-00739200": "Available City Hotspots array-like m Factor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01315-00739225-00739660": "See what cplusplus version is project uses up we got an error", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01316-00739737-00740352": "No matching function call to ethernet connection get packets yes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01317-00740377-00740582": "Fair", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01318-00740761-00741145": "Because I didn't change that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01319-00741478-00742067": "Get const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01320-00742553-00742758": "It's magnet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01321-00743142-00743526": "Gotta see if we can make this texted it bigger", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01322-00743680-00743961": "Core themes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01323-00744166-00744345": "Edit that you received", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01324-00744448-00744627": "Font-size", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01325-00744652-00744908": "Let's bus that up to 14", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01326-00745190-00745702": "Is that the font size for the UE ok said it's bus that downloaded", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01327-00745856-00746035": "Well good luck thank you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01328-00746521-00747136": "So the font size doesn't seem to affect I know it does affect like the tabs at the top", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01329-00747289-00747443": "That's not very helpful", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01330-00748057-00748236": "Settings teams", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01331-00748364-00748723": "I think I need to change the Syntax in to get", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01332-00748748-00748928": "Natural text bigger", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01333-00748953-00749184": "That does look big enough", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01334-00749363-00749977": "What's a Syntax theme text inside the editor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01335-00750412-00750515": "Wonder Park", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01336-00750592-00750796": "Is there a way to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01337-00750924-00751206": "Set the front science", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01338-00751308-00751385": "No", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01339-00752025-00752537": "Just how it be I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01340-00753612-00753766": "So we can finally know that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01341-00754022-00754252": "We're going to check that it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01342-00754304-00754918": "Built without meds that's what we currently doing make polls in time is variable like Tony to see what", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01343-00754944-00755430": "Cplusplus version reusing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01344-00755660-00755891": "Cplusplus", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01345-00756044-00756275": "11 no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01346-00756608-00757068": "It doesn't look like we're really using a c plus plus version", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01347-00757913-00758144": "Daughter", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01348-00758604-00759014": "It's unclear at best", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01349-00759168-00759475": "What cplusplus motion when using", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01350-00759782-00760012": "What about this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01351-00760140-00760422": "Is that show us that we're using effective data", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01352-00760806-00761139": "Dr Carter", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01353-00761267-00761881": "OK so you are actually using a Vector here with the dot data function", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01354-00761907-00762470": "Sorry that gives us president for using a background data", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01355-00762496-00762675": "Meet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01356-00762700-00763315": "Sick", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01357-00763340-00763955": "Tight etcetera", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01358-00763980-00764544": "Groovy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01359-00765644-00766208": "I'm eating a little bit ok I'm hungry", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01360-00767180-00767795": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01361-00767820-00768281": "See what we change so far do you know what this Chai and you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01362-00768307-00768512": "Faceless", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01363-00769203-00769433": "Stage changes so how do I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01364-00769715-00770278": "How do I make this bigger", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01365-00770508-00770918": "I need more files I need to see more split left", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01366-00771123-00771584": "Even less space than I've got are sultanas", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01367-00771916-00772096": "Movies out", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01368-00772275-00772531": "Yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01369-00772556-00772736": "Pride of", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01370-00772940-00773555": "I still want the unstaged changes by I need more than this", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01371-00773580-00774067": "I need to be able to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01372-00774118-00774630": "Capel this down how do I get to see more of my own stage changes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01373-00774809-00774912": "What's that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01374-00774937-00775116": "I don't want to do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01375-00775321-00775577": "Split up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01376-00775936-00776243": "That just seems to duplicate it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01377-00776652-00776960": "Trips to Cardiff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01378-00777292-00777907": "Close all my open files", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01379-00778265-00778726": "I guess I can't undo that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01380-00778752-00778905": "Undo closed pain", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01381-00779059-00779264": "It's gone forever", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01382-00780211-00780390": "And now I have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01383-00780441-00780620": "Mum said changes is just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01384-00780672-00781107": "Compressed I can't see it all", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01385-00781132-00781260": "Why", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01386-00781644-00782259": "Apostle my files", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01387-00782284-00782771": "I didn't need it help files anyway", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01388-00782796-00783027": "So that worked", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01389-00783232-00783513": "Close atom for a bit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01390-00783539-00783795": "Find me some real work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01391-00784691-00784998": "Certsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01392-00785254-00785868": "You know what I'm going to make you get ignored", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01393-00788326-00788659": "Best joke", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01394-00788710-00789324": "It's just not even trying", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01395-00789350-00789555": "Swap files", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01396-00789708-00789888": "Jordan OG", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01397-00789939-00790553": "You know we want to track those and changes to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01398-00790579-00790988": "2015 stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01399-00791680-00792115": "There we go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01400-00792140-00792755": "No I actually have getting your stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01401-00792780-00793395": "But it still tracks changes to the VS", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01402-00793420-00793523": "15 stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01403-00793548-00794163": "I guess that's just what get does whatever is most trash", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01404-00794188-00794803": "Let's see what the get def", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01405-00795059-00795673": "There's no changes to configure.ac I think", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01406-00795699-00796134": "Call Dr new line stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01407-00796262-00796492": "Are you kidding me", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01408-00796851-00797465": "Holder au", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01409-00797875-00798233": "Did this change all the new lines on", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01410-00798310-00798489": "Any 2K stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01411-00799027-00799155": "Adam", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01412-00799846-00800460": "That's not what I wanted", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01413-00800972-00801587": "Outsourced icebox", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01414-00801612-00802124": "Documentation", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01415-00802227-00802560": "Dictionary sauce", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01416-00802867-00803481": "The sale is the rest of it just the con star", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01417-00803507-00804121": "Source of Esk is any of this mangled in horrible", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01418-00804275-00804889": "Alright got ok well Adam it looks like you failed my test of dealing with", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01419-00804915-00805094": "Files", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01420-00805145-00805632": "Yep I want to change that change that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01421-00806400-00807014": "It's sad all the stuff but not the constant strings", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01422-00807680-00808294": "Well guys live stream so far has been my experience with atom", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01423-00808320-00808780": "I'm not going to be using it again", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01424-00809036-00809446": "The end", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01425-00809548-00809907": "Centre", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01426-00809932-00810316": "It helpfully fixes stuff that I don't want it fixed", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01427-00811443-00812006": "What is that anime is that the", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01428-00812057-00812672": "Concert is holding up her hand and waving that iTube item", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01429-00812851-00813158": "Do I have anything else that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01430-00813184-00813363": "I need to commit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01431-00813414-00813670": "Tourette's", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01432-00814540-00815155": "Ethernet packet constant", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01433-00815180-00815539": "Yeah you done good good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01434-00815641-00816025": "Make packet const", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01435-00816512-00817049": "Add", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01436-00817075-00817638": "Spring thing but doesn't copy the string", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01437-00818534-00819148": "No no", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01438-00819174-00819788": "Internet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01439-00819814-00820428": "Copy ASCII string congrats and then we're going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01440-00820454-00820531": "Add", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01441-00820556-00821171": "We're gonna commit the change to the slab", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01442-00821196-00821478": "Can you sing it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01443-00821504-00822118": "Rename send packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01444-00822144-00822400": "Received", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01445-00822451-00822988": "Is that how you spell received I should probably check that before committing it right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01446-00823091-00823705": "Received with an iPhone know it has an eye afterwards", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01447-00825087-00825702": "God it even has the word receiving the file itself from the copyright holder", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01448-00825728-00825907": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01449-00826905-00827366": "So we gonna get check out source misc", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01450-00827443-00827699": "Just sauce I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01451-00827724-00828211": "Netflix", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01452-00828236-00828646": "Make the file nice make", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01453-00828774-00828979": "Trip", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01454-00829132-00829516": "And that's check on our to-do list", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01455-00829875-00830233": "Vector Fields", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01456-00830336-00830566": "I got to remove bad", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01457-00830592-00830745": "Mr Right Now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01458-00830899-00831104": "I am", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01459-00831308-00831667": "Yes 2015 complete types of backup", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01460-00831718-00832230": "Which commit introduces actress Anzac I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01461-00832640-00833203": "Rebase upstream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01462-00834150-00834636": "I see", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01463-00834687-00835302": "Stash my changes ok it's just at this one", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01464-00835328-00835891": "What was it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01465-00835916-00836147": "Source vs2015", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01466-00836172-00836428": "It might just be in the beers 20155", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01467-00836454-00836992": "Big H don't backup", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01468-00837580-00837887": "Amend", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01469-00838758-00839219": "Check out the starts", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01470-00839449-00839808": "Search", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01471-00839884-00840217": "That we go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01472-00840729-00840806": "So", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01473-00840908-00841113": "We prove that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01474-00841446-00841856": "It's ok jukes I don't know how to spell programme", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01475-00842419-00843033": "Do I have any void stuff that's just zap functions settings tablet avoid", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01476-00843187-00843801": "Boy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01477-00843827-00844236": "Void", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01478-00844364-00844800": "Is that stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01479-00845209-00845465": "So it's in the it's in the", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01480-00845747-00846079": "Did a lot of stuff so what we just going to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01481-00846208-00846822": "Not finding a place we just going to find", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01482-00846848-00847462": "And just delete that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01483-00848307-00848921": "Wired", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01484-00848947-00849561": "Boys boys boys", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01485-00849817-00850432": "Boy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01486-00850457-00850790": "Where is it where is it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01487-00850841-00851225": "Where is it that we go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01488-00851609-00852224": "Good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01489-00852300-00852915": "Beme", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01490-00853555-00853964": "Kidding me I miss the d", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01491-00854016-00854220": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01492-00854323-00854937": "Lloyd and we change that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01493-00855295-00855552": "Check the changes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01494-00856243-00856857": "Brexit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01495-00856883-00857318": "Remove enable config", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01496-00857395-00858009": "I'm going to do this yet since I still want to keep documentation in", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01497-00858035-00858649": "The Doss box configuration theme", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01498-00860441-00861056": "MyGov configuration parts don't really explained", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01499-00861312-00861875": "There's only explanations for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01500-00862156-00862361": "Options", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01501-00862387-00863001": "Find the ethernet block UCI", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01502-00863027-00863385": "In this configure the yes I have this big block", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01503-00863487-00863846": "But enabling the evening Slovak end", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01504-00864588-00865177": "And then the peacock bass back in there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01505-00865561-00866176": "And I don't think there's a way to just I might", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01506-00866201-00866585": "Shove it in the backend explanation here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01507-00866687-00867200": "Make that long we can reference it later", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01508-00867481-00867916": "That should be fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01509-00867942-00868224": "Let's go back", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01510-00869094-00869632": "Find the bathrooms", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01511-00869811-00870425": "Animal just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01512-00870579-00870809": "Fix that the second", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01513-00870860-00871372": "Can we drop you enable properties for both these", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01514-00871526-00872140": "Fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01515-00872601-00872960": "Commits I add enable in", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01516-00872985-00873318": "Are you available", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01517-00874112-00874393": "So use it in the initialise section", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01518-00874444-00874624": "Stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01519-00875264-00875520": "I didn't pick up section", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01520-00876006-00876620": "Ok so Castiel", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01521-00876646-00876876": "And for some reason", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01522-00876928-00877235": "Where we do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01523-00877491-00878105": "The migration for real", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01524-00878131-00878208": "Pick up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01525-00878822-00879436": "So let's say it's go to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01526-00879616-00880230": "We also should add the nonetype", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01527-00880256-00880870": "Icing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01528-00880895-00881510": "Me a dummy backend or something he knows doesn't matter since", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01529-00881536-00881894": "That would be adding staff at right now we just polishing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01530-00881920-00882534": "Let's go to salt in Esk", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01531-00882560-00883174": "Enable", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01532-00883430-00884044": "And only slurp you did it far out dude", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01533-00885350-00885939": "Dell deal with a headache that is making a very long configuration thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01534-00885964-00886220": "Backend", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01535-00886656-00887270": "So it's see how the dust box configuration does this for some other thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01536-00887295-00887731": "Nautical options", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01537-00888115-00888371": "Auto lock possible values", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01538-00888652-00889087": "So it says possible values and soci", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01539-00889779-00890393": "Possible values", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01540-00891340-00891545": "No this is weird", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01541-00891596-00892185": "I just wanted to give you the ad documentation for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01542-00892492-00892851": "General documentation fix stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01543-00893004-00893209": "I guess I can't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01544-00894515-00894643": "Well", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01545-00895308-00895846": "Value should be", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01546-00896870-00897484": "Identifier of an ethernet second exception", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01547-00897510-00898124": "For example to use", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01548-00898150-00898713": "Ethernet set volume two", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01549-00898816-00899020": "Slurp", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01550-00899993-00900608": "I guess I just delete this documentation", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01551-00900633-00901248": "Documentation somewhere else", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01552-00902579-00903040": "Rust like sections can of help but I don't see any of that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01553-00903065-00903679": "Adderall", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01554-00903705-00904320": "It's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01555-00904345-00904627": "I hated a bit that's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01556-00905087-00905420": "White intersection will be run at startup can I", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01557-00905574-00906035": "Add comments with different from what everyone else does so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01558-00906060-00906675": "Follow sheep going to be a sheep sorry", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01559-00906726-00907340": "Remove the enable config", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01560-00907366-00907648": "They will have to test that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01561-00907673-00908287": "So in the meanwhile we're going to be making poles look at the log in for", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01562-00909004-00909619": "Pause stop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01563-00909670-00910284": "It's a word keycap is already known", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01564-00910310-00910464": "I'm not going to touch that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01565-00910950-00911564": "Unless the original fold it loading it's check that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01566-00912819-00913433": "I'm not going to add pick up login", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01567-00913459-00913945": "See if I've lost any loving", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01568-00914048-00914380": "I don't think I did", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01569-00914406-00914841": "Wait it doesn't check about pick up close or", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01570-00915097-00915251": "Open or whatever", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01571-00915302-00915532": "That's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01572-00915891-00916249": "Does webslut have no installation headers", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01573-00917043-00917452": "Yeah look at adding slip login", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01574-00919065-00919449": "Also it's just Rafael stuff for to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01575-00919961-00920089": "Today", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01576-00920140-00920345": "Please pause the select", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01577-00920396-00921011": "So it's just the polling code and that caravan messages and stuff which river hopefully refract", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01578-00921267-00921420": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01579-00921446-00921753": "Sorry I don't have no two left in my code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01580-00922009-00922624": "So we both our now so when soap get disappear", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01581-00922982-00923161": "We're going to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01582-00923596-00924211": "What does that do get packet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01583-00924518-00925107": "What is the callback do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01584-00925158-00925542": "Play Australian log that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01585-00925568-00925926": "Like it was able to Buffett", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01586-00926131-00926489": "No not really beer driver should do that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01587-00926668-00927104": "So what about sending packets", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01588-00927155-00927385": "Opening and shutting failures", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01589-00928000-00928614": "So we'll have to open up our Dusty old copy of lipslut", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01590-00929024-00929356": "Ok so we have an Eric here", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01591-00929382-00929740": "Get packet call back should be on signs week", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01592-00929971-00930355": "Forget packet call back once", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01593-00930380-00930713": "Have I not", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01594-00931328-00931942": "Is my packet call back not good enough", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01595-00932121-00932736": "I'm not change this no I didn't", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01596-00933299-00933760": "Wireless builds I'm just going to be right back since honeydew", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01597-00933785-00934400": "Get the washroom with the boys if not with the boys alone by myself", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01598-00935705-00936012": "Back assholes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01599-00936089-00936704": "I just kidding alright let's continue on", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01600-00937062-00937676": "I just built what do I need to quickly add", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01601-00937702-00938035": "The fix", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01602-00938086-00938624": "What's get death without sauce", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01603-00938752-00939315": "Hey cuz what's up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01604-00939366-00939776": "Ipswich Road", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01605-00940160-00940774": "Fix packet const perfect spelling", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01606-00940876-00941260": "Sauce kit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01607-00941286-00941849": "You're full of apples", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01608-00941875-00942412": "Remove enable options", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01609-00942464-00943078": "Triax please ok let's see", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01610-00943104-00943257": "Received", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01611-00943334-00943462": "Run", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01612-00943871-00944230": "Yep so it's go to configuration to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01613-00944256-00944486": "Backend", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01614-00944512-00944588": "Yep", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01615-00944716-00944870": "It works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01616-00944972-00945587": "Is that pick up ethernet slurp that looks pretty good", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01617-00945843-00946457": "Let's continue booting and see if things work we're getting", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01618-00946687-00946944": "We're getting there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01619-00947046-00947507": "Sexy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01620-00947712-00948198": "Error loading for slurp I'm doing the most annoying stuff first", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01621-00948454-00949068": "Or just wait that's the order I tried to do stuff in most annoying stuff because I have like the wheel powder do it first", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01622-00949094-00949708": "Ok it's just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01623-00949734-00950348": "Clear skies for men", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01624-00950374-00950988": "I have slept current Elon Musk wants to send poor people to Mars in Hill jobs SA", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01625-00951014-00951449": "That's off did he seriously say that or use at home cos I'm not sure", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01626-00951552-00952166": "If you want to get rid of", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01627-00952192-00952422": "Flight body", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01628-00952576-00953190": "At work to stop being poor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01629-00953216-00953830": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01630-00954495-00955110": "I also like how we call people more people like that's part of their identity you're poor", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01631-00955136-00955494": "That's just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01632-00955827-00956441": "Poor people homeless people part of their identity", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01633-00956748-00956902": "Alright", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01634-00957312-00957926": "We're looking for stuff to do a slurp I want some better", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01635-00957952-00958208": "Download an error messages so let's see", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01636-00958259-00958720": "Let's find out just junk stuff folder", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01637-00959283-00959897": "Not here ok so I don't have the slip is it here Slurpee", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01638-00959923-00960000": "Yeah right", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01639-00960153-00960563": "Live slap.com", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01640-00961177-00961382": "Sing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01641-00961484-00961868": "Slap Numark failed to be loaded at", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01642-00962252-00962355": "Translate code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01643-00963123-00963251": "Start new", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01644-00963276-00963712": "Ok so we currently say slurp failed to initialise", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01645-00964454-00965068": "Is selling all his real estate and doing the Texas because there's no income tax they're the space", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01646-00965094-00965708": "Found that 30% of 1 million people to Mars by 2050 and build a fleet of 1000 Starships to Ferry", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01647-00965734-00966348": "Maths games 03 387 ft rocket SpaceX is developing for deep space", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01648-00966374-00966988": "Unless you think the trip to Mars is too pricey for most people must says he interested loans", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01649-00967014-00967500": "Those two don't have money and jobs on the red planet for colonists to pay off their debts", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01650-00967526-00967705": "Sorry he wants it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01651-00967731-00967910": "Do you want slave planet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01652-00968166-00968704": "So what you just wants to be slaves he's going to have a slave in it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01653-00968883-00969497": "Cos there's no laws and as yet although", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01654-00969523-00969804": "I mean I suppose you'll be in American business still so he", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01655-00969830-00970444": "Dinner", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01656-00971443-00972057": "Where's my lips laptop c-file", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01657-00972083-00972211": "See", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01658-00972697-00973312": "So if not fails return value with sale", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01659-00973337-00973670": "It's returns now so there's nothing we can really do about it", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01660-00973875-00974464": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01661-00974540-00974617": "Thanks", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01662-00975129-00975744": "Tomatoes parting ways of possessions also signal that is committed to going to Mars", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01663-00975769-00976384": "I'm just trying to make it stop music", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01664-00976409-00976512": "Possessions", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01665-00976537-00976819": "He's got all these houses ok now I don't have the thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01666-00977075-00977689": "That's what people upset about with you", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01667-00977715-00978329": "Bargara", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01668-00978739-00979020": "Snap update timeout", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01669-00979097-00979353": "Politix Phil", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01670-00979481-00980095": "Avoid", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01671-00980198-00980300": "Slip", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01672-00980352-00980710": "No aerofit", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01673-00980812-00981427": "Let's just double check", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01674-00981452-00981657": "It just returns ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01675-00981939-00982092": "Flirt", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01676-00982348-00982732": "Just forward ad", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01677-00982835-00983449": "Slurp connection info what's that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01678-00983475-00983961": "Anti poaching socket can receive", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01679-00984115-00984320": "SWAT state save", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01680-00984422-00984857": "What state motion slap version string", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01681-00985190-00985625": "Which actually we should definitely like that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01682-00986854-00987468": "Slap version found", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01683-00987571-00988185": "Slack string", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01684-00988211-00988825": "That's mostly if there's people wearing or complaining version", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01685-00989721-00990336": "Are we going to find", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01686-00990361-00990771": "All these star comments and get rid of them", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01687-00990796-00991155": "I think we you start on it's indoor Sparks", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01688-00991744-00992204": "Yes we do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01689-00992256-00992486": "Yeah OK that's fine", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01690-00995430-00996044": "Alright so as far as I'm concerned we have error messaging handing there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01691-00996915-00997529": "The other big thing documentation I'm going to have to put a bunch of", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01692-00997555-00997708": "Stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01693-00998809-00999423": "I will do that or screen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01694-00999833-01000012": "So what we're going to do now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01695-01000243-01000857": "It's finished probably hopefully the last of the coding workforce", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01696-01001548-01001702": "Etsy", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01697-01001727-01002342": "What what am I doing ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01698-01002367-01002982": "The most of it's gonna be focused on here one thing I actually did in my branch", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01699-01003007-01003443": "Slip on curry which we going to quickly review", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01700-01003494-01004108": "Taree is in my Windows laptop", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01701-01005593-01006003": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01702-01006028-01006335": "Time out to there", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01703-01006361-01006796": "Registering sex for sale", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01704-01006950-01007103": "Coles Clare", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01705-01007129-01007743": "I added a section or registered poll stuff why the name", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01706-01007871-01008281": "What names", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01707-01009407-01009638": "Text", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01708-01009894-01010303": "I named them after the moons of Saturn", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01709-01012684-01013171": "Crate", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01710-01013196-01013478": "Registered", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01711-01013708-01014118": "Why do you want messaging me that you cuz", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01712-01014348-01014681": "Cheers ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01713-01014707-01015295": "Coles ad registered so I added a new function could Coles add registered", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01714-01015577-01015705": "Was it Paul", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01715-01015731-01016217": "Register an unregistered", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01716-01016268-01016524": "Ok it was poll register", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01717-01017779-01018393": "So pole register", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01718-01018419-01019033": "And all that those is core hole unregister", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01719-01019059-01019289": "Registers it if it's available", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01720-01019955-01020569": "So I have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01721-01020595-01021209": "Copy paste", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01722-01021235-01021849": "Includes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01723-01022643-01023257": "So basically the idea here is I'm going to be having", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01724-01023385-01023999": "Custody list", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01725-01024025-01024639": "Registered after 2 years", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01726-01025228-01025535": "So all that is going to be putting it on", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01727-01025843-01026457": "And whatever were adding descriptors and stuff or just have to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01728-01026483-01026867": "What was the current", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01729-01027225-01027379": "STD remove", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01730-01027404-01027507": "OK yeah", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01731-01027788-01028403": "Call Register Polo registered Service SA", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01732-01028428-01029043": "Call Register", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01733-01029452-01029555": "Coles", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01734-01029631-01030246": "Add registered", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01735-01030271-01030886": "Just going to be registered for the script is that for whatever reason that wants us around to keep around", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01736-01031372-01031731": "So it's go to", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01737-01031807-01032089": "Slack code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01738-01032115-01032729": "Register and see what we're going to do", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01739-01033139-01033753": "Auto dismantlers in the function", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01740-01033779-01034393": "Call register register", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01741-01034419-01035033": "Unregister", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01742-01035238-01035852": "So you have some code that when our register", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01743-01035980-01036543": "And unregister descriptors and then we're just going to have to add", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01744-01036569-01037183": "Some commands for that see where would it be pohlad", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01745-01037311-01037926": "Purchase generic code so it's actually", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01746-01038156-01038489": "Garcia", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01747-01038822-01039436": "Whole that's what they did during the election and why Biden one sorry why", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01748-01039462-01039769": "Say something", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01749-01040255-01040870": "Call and register", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01750-01040895-01041510": "Was going to unregister first I guess", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01751-01041535-01042150": "The unregistered the polls listen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01752-01042175-01042764": "Who not how it works", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01753-01043097-01043711": "So we remove the FD is registered tractor caught that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01754-01044095-01044710": "Have to use registered Sakura greatest death head went to court registered after years", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01755-01046092-01046271": "Ok", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01756-01046476-01047091": "That's actually returning a void what's not returning anything", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01757-01047116-01047321": "Check that she wrote that down properly", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01758-01047449-01047910": "Call Register and pollen register and then I'm not going to try returning those", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01759-01048575-01049190": "Yeah very go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01760-01052723-01053158": "I just got door knocked", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01761-01053209-01053619": "I'm going to have to go", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01762-01055129-01055743": "Oh my god people", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01763-01055769-01056383": "Coming up to my door and talk and try to stream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01764-01056409-01057023": "Having a family in life ok so", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01765-01057049-01057663": "I'm going in about I know a few minutes so we just going to wrap up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01766-01057689-01058303": "Call registration stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01767-01058329-01058943": "Turns out people want to use the internet delete", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01768-01058969-01059481": "And with the way I have my streaming stuff done it just floods that work", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01769-01059583-01059942": "I got a live in a camper in the woods", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01770-01059993-01060607": "So we added to register stuff", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01771-01060633-01061017": "Coles ad registered that would be in", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01772-01061094-01061708": "To do that so what what happened is have", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01773-01061734-01062348": "Don't write a full set", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01774-01062707-01063167": "Coles ad registered", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01775-01063193-01063475": "And so what happens there is that", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01776-01063628-01064115": "Gripe", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01777-01064140-01064755": "No good so what will happen then is it just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01778-01064780-01065087": "Iterate through the musing this horrible cplusplus code", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01779-01065139-01065753": "An atom go to learn traffic skills please no I don't want to be a prepper", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01780-01065779-01066393": "No you may have noticed the code that you imported", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01781-01066419-01067033": "Absolute Trash and that's because I deliberately", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01782-01067059-01067673": "Rewriting it but I'm still copy and paste", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01783-01067699-01068134": "And so what's going to happen now", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01784-01068159-01068774": "What if you're out the woods practicing with your trash archery in a kangaroo came up and kick your ass", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01785-01068799-01069414": "Slashing open my abdomen", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01786-01069439-01070054": "Ok would you be tomorrow's to would you go further", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01787-01070079-01070694": "If I survived I probably just", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01788-01070719-01071257": "Go back to go back to you late", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01789-01071283-01071795": "Sorry it's been so there should be one more thing", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01790-01072025-01072639": "So I added list I need some junk for our greater and so do I have algorithm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01791-01072793-01073407": "Algorithm", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01792-01073433-01073766": "Let's see if this makes", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01793-01075225-01075788": "Not pohlad", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01794-01075814-01076428": "What are the kangaroo was my wife looked don't talk to me all at Kangaroo wife", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01795-01078630-01079219": "Play slap version stream the code that I added there was broken", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01796-01079244-01079577": "You wanted to ask if she was cute bro", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01797-01079603-01079884": "Why kangaroo wife will rip you up", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01798-01081497-01082086": "That Ascend the back cos you can't have a kangaroo at school", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01799-01082214-01082649": "Could not convert", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01800-01082726-01083315": "That's a c plus plus 0 which means I'm going to have to fix it off stream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01801-01083417-01083827": "It's it we mean what it's a c plus plus 0", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01802-01083852-01084467": "Anyway this is the end of the Stream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01803-01084492-01085107": "Because unfortunately I have to go because my brother needs internet", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01804-01085132-01085747": "Scully sultanas and I will end the Stream", "oQ6sR1HJCKM-01805-01085772-01086284": "Cu cu Cu"}}, {"audio_id": "oQV_bwk2IlM", "text": {"oQV_bwk2IlM-00000-00000030-00000366": "It's inconspicuous, black and surprisingly light:", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00001-00000392-00000726": "The small black hard rubber disc is hardly bigger", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00002-00000726-00000918": "than an ordinary CD.", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00003-00000960-00001282": "It is one of the first commercial records", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00004-00001282-00001739": "made for the Gramophone, recently then invented by Emile Berliner.", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00005-00001844-00002284": "In the matrix you can see the handwritten word \"Deutschland\".", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00006-00002326-00002564": "The recording was made between", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00007-00002574-00002986": "September 1889 and August 1890:", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00008-00003032-00003596": "The Deutschlandlied, which was to become the German national anthem in 1922.", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00009-00003650-00004150": "Behind the strong noise hides the still clearly recognizable melody.", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00010-00007230-00007538": "With an age of almost 130 years", "oQV_bwk2IlM-00011-00007538-00008152": "this record is the oldest preserved sound recording of this work to be known."}}, {"audio_id": "oRqgDwp5rcI", "text": {}}, {"audio_id": "oRqrRjWZp0y", "text": {"oRqrRjWZp0y-00000-00000056-00000156": "Hi!", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00001-00000156-00000337": "Today I want to improvise about \"to depend\".I looked for the meaning in dictionary and,anyway,", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00002-00000337-00000834": "\"to be tied up to,to be depending on,to hang on,to be subordinated\" but,for me to depend", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00003-00000834-00001648": "on something or on someone is something normal and natural.I depend on the air,I depend on", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00004-00001648-00003356": "\"to breath\" but I admit that I depend on creating my self problems and in the moment I make", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00005-00003356-00003764": "my self a problem,I make it!", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00006-00003764-00004569": "I mean,I increase it,I make it larger,I am looking at all the faceplate of that problem", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00007-00004569-00004983": "and the problem is getting bigger,of course,it turn sometimes hard to manage ,hard to be", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00008-00004983-00006440": "be solved.And then I am thinking that if I replace an addiction on negative to put it", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00009-00006440-00007881": "on positive it will be better and I been thinking to stop it and to realize I am doing this,to", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00010-00007881-00007981": "realize I'm heading toward to amplify the problem and to smile and to not take myself", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00011-00007981-00008261": "so much in serious.For you what does it mean \"to depend?\"", "oRqrRjWZp0y-00012-00008261-00008268": "Bye!"}}, {"audio_id": "oRvkR2aAffu", "text": {"oRvkR2aAffu-00000-00000026-00000337": "aklo", "oRvkR2aAffu-00001-00000337-00000633": "Funny", "oRvkR2aAffu-00002-00000633-00000928": "Comedy", "oRvkR2aAffu-00003-00000928-00001028": "Welcome", "oRvkR2aAffu-00004-00001131-00001375": "Smart", "oRvkR2aAffu-00005-00001450-00001550": "Troll", "oRvkR2aAffu-00006-00002062-00002222": "Kh", "oRvkR2aAffu-00007-00002313-00002560": "Thanks", "oRvkR2aAffu-00008-00002560-00002860": "For", "oRvkR2aAffu-00009-00002860-00003174": "Watching", "oRvkR2aAffu-00010-00003174-00003410": "Good", "oRvkR2aAffu-00011-00003410-00003706": "Luck"}}, {"audio_id": "oR-mpW6RPdY", "text": {"oR-mpW6RPdY-00000-00005277-00005408": "Welcome", "oR-mpW6RPdY-00044-00017594-00017794": "Click SUBSCRIBE", "oR-mpW6RPdY-00045-00017794-00017902": "THANKS"}}, {"audio_id": "oRFh-uJo8XQ", "text": {"oRFh-uJo8XQ-00000-00000003-00000485": "Hi there Guys it's Pip here from Pipwheatley.com today I just want to show", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00001-00000485-00001080": "you an awesome way that you can connect to your family and your friends across", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00002-00001080-00001500": "the world or even it within the same country if you're not going to get to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00003-00001500-00001926": "see them around Christmas now of course we all want to see as many people as we", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00004-00001926-00002421": "possibly can and but if you can't instead of ringing them up I know my", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00005-00002421-00002810": "family certainly ring up a lot of people on Christmas Day here is another way", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00006-00002810-00003189": "to do it and let me show you how so first of all you should know that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00007-00003189-00003740": "involves using YouTube and if those of you are never used YouTube help use it", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00008-00003740-00004245": "sign up well it's very very easy you can create account of literally in a couple", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00009-00004245-00004598": "of minutes it doesn't need a lot of details you don't need to pay anything", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00010-00004598-00005177": "it's completely completely free and of course you can then just create a video", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00011-00005177-00005898": "anything you want on your your camera and you can use it on your phone and", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00012-00005898-00006398": "I've got mine here it's dead easy to do and you just connect it up to your", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00013-00006398-00006831": "computer and I'm going to show you how you can upload it and what to do now so", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00014-00006831-00007656": "let's have a look at my screen so hopefully you can see that that now this", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00015-00007656-00008064": "is my youtube video and this is what we call the back office so it's got a range", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00016-00008064-00008532": "of functions and when you upload a video all you have to do is you click this", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00017-00008532-00008990": "little icon here I'm just going to zoom into that so you can see it it's a", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00018-00008990-00009390": "little image of a camera with a plus on it you just click that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00019-00009390-00009840": "and then it will take you to upload I mean if we let's click it now", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00020-00009840-00010374": "and see what it says says that you can either upload the video or you can go", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00021-00010374-00010971": "live you can actually do a live video if your computer has a camera on it you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00022-00010971-00011403": "don't actually need to and connect all your devices or for email across or", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00023-00011403-00011727": "whatever so that is sounding a bit complex just going here and just go", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00024-00011727-00012306": "click live and that you can record straight from your and from your PC or", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00025-00012306-00012772": "even from your tablet but if you click upload video", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00026-00012885-00013553": "it will take us to a brand new page and this is what it says just as it loads up", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00027-00013553-00014001": "only take a few minutes don't go so it says click files to upload so you can", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00028-00014001-00014721": "click on that and it will open up and you know your folders and your files and", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00029-00014721-00015279": "so you'll be able to find your video otherwise and you can you know just do", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00030-00015279-00015768": "it like I say so here I've got all my videos and you just click and sort of", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00031-00015768-00016365": "drag it across so so here say I wanted to upload this one you just drag it", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00032-00016365-00016914": "across like that steady you thinking you just drop it there so good thing as well", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00033-00016914-00017424": "just tonight let's just get rid of that one there is this little thing here now", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00034-00017424-00017972": "this has a range of options let's just click on that you can see it says public", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00035-00017972-00018717": "unlisted private or scheduled now just bear in mind that this one public that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00036-00018717-00019107": "will release it straight away and anyone and everyone can see that anyone can", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00037-00019107-00019578": "search for it and when they type in the title or any words relating to it and", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00038-00019578-00019935": "this one as well this is the same as being public but you get to choose what", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00039-00019935-00020424": "time what day you can release that video and so that's really useful now these", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00040-00020424-00020958": "two private and unlisted they're something different now and if you're", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00041-00020958-00021351": "doing it just for family I suggest you use one of these tape and there are some", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00042-00021351-00021903": "very very basic differences so private what will happen if you click on private", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00043-00021903-00022197": "is you will end up with something looking like this", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00044-00022197-00022779": "this video is private so doesn't matter who searches for it and if they're not", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00045-00022779-00023235": "got the link that you send them later on which will direct them straight to that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00046-00023235-00023613": "video it's like giving someone and directions in your car to your house", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00047-00023613-00024009": "that's all the link is for it's just a set of instructions the tasks can be", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00048-00024009-00024555": "used to where to go to access that specific video and but anyone else who", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00049-00024555-00024972": "doesn't have the link in just searches for a new tube or in Google and they", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00050-00024972-00025296": "won't be able to see your video so don't worry about that especially if it's you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00051-00025296-00025823": "know very private you're talking to your family or your friends now", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00052-00025823-00026518": "unlisted is kind of the same now the difference is that with these videos", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00053-00026518-00026977": "both private and unlisted they can only be viewed by those who are invited to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00054-00026977-00027592": "view them in the uploader okay so you have to send the person the link and now", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00055-00027592-00027982": "as I say this is what will happen if some research of a private now if", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00056-00027982-00028537": "someone searches for an unlisted video go back to tilt our page sorry that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00057-00028537-00029064": "unlisted video is if somebody searches for that in YouTube it won't be seen at", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00058-00029064-00029467": "all absolutely nothing won't come up it's not even on there hence the name unless", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00059-00029467-00030112": "shared and the main difference between unlisted and private is that for anyone", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00060-00030112-00030541": "to view a private video if you do send them the link the set of directions to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00061-00030541-00031083": "get them there we have to have a Google account now how to get a Google account", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00062-00031083-00031543": "well it's dead easy you just go on to Google calm and see if we can do that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00063-00031543-00032182": "here let's just type in Google commerce we're actually here that show you how to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00064-00032182-00033034": "do this so google.com and yeah this create", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00065-00033034-00033742": "account as well I'll grade account just in the YouTube bar just follow the", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00066-00033742-00034123": "instructions on there when it comes off and so I'll come up with create your", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00067-00034123-00034627": "Google account it's dead dead simple and a single username and password gets you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00068-00034627-00035128": "into gear girl and you just click create account and it's dead dead easy off you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00069-00035128-00035593": "go now of course if you're not sure if your relatives have got that all you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00070-00035593-00036082": "have to do just doing this did you don't have to have a Google account for that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00071-00036082-00036478": "anyone can see it that you send them into so they don't need to worry about", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00072-00036478-00036892": "all the faff and Technology should click on listed now I just want to show you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00073-00036892-00037288": "something what you've uploaded your file it does take away don't you show you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00074-00037288-00038220": "this oh that is the wrong one let's have a look here", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00075-00038799-00039364": "that's go back on this one I do apologize about these guys yeah this is", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00076-00039364-00039871": "a video that I've uploaded this is actually for a friend's birthday so it's", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00077-00039871-00040336": "a good friend called Angela and once it's uploaded it will just showed that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00078-00040336-00040885": "video now you can do all sorts of things you can if you need to trim it click on", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00079-00040885-00041616": "enhancements let's have a look dead dead easy here and it will say", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00080-00041616-00042166": "initially you need to have flash if you don't have flash again just type it into", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00081-00042166-00042744": "Google and download it now you can click on this button which is called trim and", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00082-00042744-00043129": "what happens when you trim the video is if at the end you've got a picture of", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00083-00043129-00043705": "you turning the camera off you can just trim it dead easily and it just not that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00084-00043705-00044026": "bit at the ends a bit more no professional you don't talk about that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00085-00044026-00044473": "too much now what you do have this and what it", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00086-00044473-00045337": "will do is on the main main page you will see this here zoom into that that", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00087-00045337-00046006": "is your set of instructions on how to get somebody to your video and otherwise", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00088-00046006-00046426": "as I say it will come up with a blank or if it's unlisted they won't be able to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00089-00046426-00046915": "see anything at all it won't even be on there and so all you have to do this is", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00090-00046915-00047683": "dead easy is you just copy and paste that link you go just easily copy and", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00091-00047683-00048469": "paste it use you can say huge cursor scroll it across and you know click copy", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00092-00048469-00049156": "and then you just go on to your emails let's get these up so here is an email", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00093-00049156-00049411": "that I've written earlier so again is this to Angela", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00094-00049411-00049906": "it's gonna be her birthday and all I've done is copy and pasted the link right", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00095-00049906-00050488": "here now as well just because this is something new for me what I've done is", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00096-00050488-00050881": "also included a link to another video in case of this video files don't worry", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00097-00050881-00051308": "about that she's going to see Stephen a Fry's part of her bear", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00098-00051308-00051749": "day but what will happen is when that link is clicked or it's tapped into a", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00099-00051749-00052157": "new tab they will be able to see your video so that's how you do that and then", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00100-00052157-00053062": "of course Bob's your uncle you just click on this and email button it goes", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00101-00053062-00053612": "so that is dead dead easy so whenever Angela clicks on that link she will be", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00102-00053612-00054405": "able to go and see this video right here and it's a lot more of a personal way to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00103-00054405-00054794": "connect with family events cinema a message doesn't have to be very many", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00104-00054794-00055244": "seconds long and that video that I've just sent is 29 seconds long or just to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00105-00055244-00055727": "say happy birthday showing a bit of cake you could do one under the Christmas", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00106-00055727-00056174": "tree with all your Christmas jumpers on I've got mine on right here and just to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00107-00056174-00056615": "say you know happy Christmas and you can send it to multiple people if you just", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00108-00056615-00057110": "want to do a black one and you know you can then send an email to lots and lots", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00109-00057110-00057398": "of family and friends and they'll be able to click that link it all it comes", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00110-00057398-00057817": "with your picture of you with your family or whoever you're with maybe", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00111-00057817-00058184": "you're even on your own beneath the Christmas tree in a Christmasy place you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00112-00058184-00058574": "could even be outside wherever you want to shoot it and all you have to say is", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00113-00058574-00059186": "Merry Christmas and that's it really it's dead dead simple and it saves you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00114-00059186-00059570": "an extra flap on Christmas Day running around trying to call everyone trying to", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00115-00059570-00059957": "text reform trying to email everybody and also the path of them getting back", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00116-00059957-00060367": "to you as well and lines getting crossed Davis too many people trying to contact", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00117-00060367-00060827": "you at the same time so that's today's tip I hope you've really really enjoyed", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00118-00060827-00061322": "the Christmas season don't forget that we've got the 7 day video series on the", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00119-00061322-00061792": "websites pip weekly calm and if you're not sure what the video series is and", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00120-00061792-00062273": "you haven't come across it yet just go on pip weekly comm what it is if I'm my", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00121-00062273-00062879": "own business owner and I started this year and um I want to show you the", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00122-00062879-00063404": "videos that started me off and got me inspired because I am actually quite an", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00123-00063404-00063805": "introverted person you know doing videos for me and and starting this business", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00124-00063805-00064175": "and I have become so much more confident as you can probably tell", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00125-00064175-00064779": "and what we're doing is this is in this month we are gonna actually", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00126-00064779-00065205": "if you want just join us and you want to join our amazing community and get some", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00127-00065205-00065605": "skills once you've watched those videos if you decide is for you and there is a", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00128-00065605-00066088": "link on Pipwheatley.com as well and where we're going to actually save you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00129-00066088-00066724": "the application fee it's usually in the UK like £24 or £25 if you're in the U.S", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00130-00066724-00067401": "it's at $29.95 dollars so you know it's Christmas let's save a bit of money", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00131-00067401-00067948": "let's get new year off to a new start you know 2019 could you know have so", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00132-00067948-00068422": "many many amazing things in store for you and I know when I started I didn't", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00133-00068422-00069064": "know what I wanted to do I didn't have a product to sell I didn't have I don't", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00134-00069064-00069600": "have a degree and I had never studied a business before not written finances", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00135-00069600-00070245": "never shot a YouTube video before and I needed a lot of help I must be honest", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00136-00070245-00070804": "but it is I already changed my life I must say and so just get on the videos", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00137-00070804-00071197": "first the absolutely free we're going to just release one every day for seven", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00138-00071197-00071572": "days for you and as I say if it's not for you just click on subscribe that's", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00139-00071572-00072118": "it all done understood and as I say it's just over at pip weekly calm so take the", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00140-00072118-00072783": "chance and you really really do deserve to have 2019 being the best year yet as", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00141-00072783-00073044": "I say don't worry if you don't have anything to sell haven't to do business", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00142-00073044-00073585": "I'm exactly the same and if I can do it anyone can so get yourself the education", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00143-00073585-00074044": "and then at least you can make an informed decision for you so that's all", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00144-00074044-00074500": "from me I hope you're having a magical magical season and until tomorrow you", "oRFh-uJo8XQ-00145-00074500-00074826": "take care bye now"}}, {"audio_id": "oRKMBkRgtCy", "text": {"oRKMBkRgtCy-00000-00000028-00000791": "welcome a while back I did a review of the River lithium power bank by Echoflow", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00001-00000791-00001317": "I'll pop a link to that that review in the description below today I", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00002-00001317-00001941": "want to have a look at their 50 watt solar cell that they retail to support", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00003-00001941-00002673": "their River power bank enabling it to be charged using the Sun I'm based here", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00004-00002673-00003357": "in Brisbane Australia and I purchased the solar sell online and it turned up", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00005-00003357-00004061": "rather promptly through DHL DHL so let's have a look at it came in this", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00006-00004061-00004853": "well sturdy cardboard box and as you can see quite nicely packaged let's", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00007-00004853-00005753": "have a look inside some quite useful instructions on the inside of the", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00008-00005753-00006684": "box but there is also instructions and specifications and the like as well", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00009-00006684-00007458": "included as you can see it's actually nicely packaged also in this nice sort", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00010-00007458-00008139": "of water-resistant cloth and these two handles here for enabling you to carry", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00011-00008139-00009135": "it weighs in about two kilos it also comes with this lead which enables you", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00012-00009135-00009918": "to connect to the solar cell to the power bank so let's so first of all see", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00013-00009918-00010653": "how we set the solar cells up this is two zippers which we unzip and then we", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00014-00010653-00011556": "can unfurl the solar cell like this these cells are SunPower made in the", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00015-00011556-00012422": "U.S. really good quality solar cells and you know around about 20 to 23 percent", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00016-00012422-00013161": "efficient so good quality cells it has this rather neat feature whereby there's", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00017-00013161-00013647": "a little a little kickstand here which enables", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00018-00013647-00014247": "the cell to be angled so we just basically you know attach it I'll do", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00019-00014247-00014479": "that now turn it around it's a bit easier from", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00020-00014479-00015372": "behind so you just do this and then basically the cell will stand stand up", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00021-00015372-00016276": "like this angled to the sun like a lot of solar cells that you can purchase so", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00022-00016276-00016770": "to connect it to the power bank you basically grab this lead which is about", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00023-00016770-00017434": "one meter in length and there's two different sizes on here one will go into", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00024-00017434-00018159": "the rear of the power bank which is the charging port and that's used for all", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00025-00018159-00018793": "charging sources we plug this in here and the other end goes into the inside", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00026-00018793-00019414": "of the little pocket here and there's a little socket there that you enables you", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00027-00019414-00020007": "to connect it in and that's all you need to do and put it in the Sun and it will", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00028-00020007-00020872": "charge away now that's great and it does a good job this is a 50 watt solar cell", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00029-00020872-00021382": "and I would suggest that this is probably this sweet point they do also", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00030-00021382-00022054": "sell a 20 watt solar cell and while that might be nice small form-factor you", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00031-00022054-00022734": "really if you're doing any serious you know use away from the grid say camping", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00032-00022734-00023445": "really 50W what would be the way to go the only real issue that I think with", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00033-00023445-00024115": "this is this lead in Australia if I put this out in the full Sun for the whole", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00034-00024115-00024547": "day which is really what I want to do I don't want this in the Sun because", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00035-00024547-00025141": "that's going to cook now I can hide it behind the solar cells and that'll", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00036-00025141-00026085": "that'll probably be okay but if it rains your battery is going to be out in the", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00037-00026085-00026561": "rain now you might say well why would you let that happen well when you", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00038-00026561-00027052": "camping for instance you often go away from the campsite for you know many", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00039-00027052-00027412": "hours on a bush walk or whatever and you really don't want to have a situation", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00040-00027412-00028270": "where you're your power bank is could be you know rained on or worse simply", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00041-00028270-00029000": "stolen this could be easily lifted so what I've done is I've made up this ten", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00042-00029000-00030127": "meter extension lead this is 7 amp cable I got from Jaycar what I found in", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00043-00030127-00030865": "real world practice with this solar cell it puts out about 40 watts out in the", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00044-00030865-00031583": "out and the full Sun which is around about 2 amps so I've the open open", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00045-00031583-00032062": "what's called the voltage open circuit on the cell is around 20 odd volts and", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00046-00032062-00032503": "then when it's connected to the power bank that drops down under load to about", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00047-00032503-00033097": "18 volts so you know in two amps so two amps it's fine with this cable and what", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00048-00033097-00033608": "I've done is I've got this little connector at the end here which I can", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00049-00033608-00034193": "plug into the solar cell little three and a half mm jack they've got plugs in", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00050-00034193-00035347": "there the other end I've actually put a regular car charging plug and then I can", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00051-00035347-00035846": "use the lead that came with the River power bank because that will plug into", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00052-00035846-00036358": "there and then this will plug into the power bank this would be normally used", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00053-00036358-00036899": "to go into a car port in your car well the old cigarette a lot of cigarette", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00054-00036899-00037591": "lighter charging port so now that's worked extremely well and now I've been", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00055-00037591-00038293": "able to then a place the solar cell you know 10 metres away from the power bank", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00056-00038293-00038944": "and have this in the shade or in a tent or in a place which I can secure it with", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00057-00038944-00039439": "it with it with a security cable or the like so that's about the only criticism", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00058-00039439-00039958": "I'd make of the unit in that you know this this one meter cable", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00059-00039958-00040662": "really isn't sufficient I know that Echoflow have mooted the release of a longer", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00060-00040662-00041688": "cable and I'm sure they will do that in time so that's pretty much is the is the", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00061-00041688-00042168": "solar cell so far being pretty happy with it I've had it out there charging", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00062-00042168-00042699": "in the full Sun for the whole day and like I said it's delivering 40 watts", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00063-00042699-00043209": "continuously you're not going to charge if this is empty you're not going to", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00064-00043209-00043561": "charge this in one day you've got to be realistic about that this is a big", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00065-00043561-00044250": "battery it's you know 400 odd watt hour battery but certainly you're going to", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00066-00044250-00044809": "get a fair bit of charge into this you know with it with a day and the Sun so I", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00067-00044809-00045331": "think this is this is a pretty nice unit if you're going to be out off the grid", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00068-00045331-00045897": "and want to charge your battery up the other thing nice thing about the River", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00069-00045897-00046425": "of course is that you can use in charge so if you've got a fridge portable", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00070-00046425-00046930": "fridge and you have that being powered by the River and you have this solar", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00071-00046930-00047683": "cell on you know you probably can actually just literally not discharge", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00072-00047683-00048450": "your battery during the day if you're in full Sun so there you are I hope you", "oRKMBkRgtCy-00073-00048450-00049311": "enjoyed the the review and found it useful thanks"}}, {"audio_id": "oSjbMcsnaqQ", "text": {"oSjbMcsnaqQ-00000-00000000-00000200": "free beat 2021", "oSjbMcsnaqQ-00001-00000200-00000400": "read description", "oSjbMcsnaqQ-00002-00000400-00000600": "subscribe :D", "oSjbMcsnaqQ-00003-00000600-00001097": "@geraldsouvenir"}}, {"audio_id": "oSpoUpJTN8Y", "text": {"oSpoUpJTN8Y-00000-00000260-00000460": "Music"}}, {"audio_id": "oSvQ_myhZXQ", "text": {"oSvQ_myhZXQ-00000-00000003-00000473": "Good morning everybody sad news everything that I thought I knew is being called into question", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00001-00001153-00001575": "So we're headed out to see Star Wars the last Jedi", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00002-00001575-00002111": "I've managed to wait almost a full week after its release to see it", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00003-00002143-00002636": "But that's because we go to the movies on Christmas as a family not on Christmas", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00004-00002636-00002927": "But so at some point while we're in town for Christmas", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00005-00003055-00003561": "but the other day we were talking about it trying to figure out how to make it work because now we have a baby and", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00006-00003747-00004052": "Sara said I don't have to see Star Wars in the theater", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00007-00004282-00004482": "And I said wait what?", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00008-00004546-00004802": "What do you mean? You don't have to see Star Wars in the theater?", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00009-00004903-00005114": "She said hmm not still have to see it", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00010-00005346-00005552": "Everything I thought I knew is being called into question", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00011-00006334-00006501": "Fun story", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00012-00006501-00006639": "at several years ago", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00013-00006639-00007326": "Sara threw me a surprise birthday party at this movie theater because I told her that I always wanted a movie theater at a party", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00014-00007420-00007620": "So she rented out the party room", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00015-00007693-00007893": "And we went and saw rated-r movie", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00016-00007978-00008276": "those parties are usually for little kids so the", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00017-00008379-00008651": "The movie theater staff didn't quite understand. What was going on?", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00018-00008775-00008968": "It was awesome", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00019-00008968-00009168": "It's movie time", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00020-00009535-00010214": "But that was friggin awesome friggin awesome come on let's get comfortable", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00021-00010464-00010754": "Hey just a few key", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00022-00011167-00011546": "Gabriel is having a little dinner before we figure out what we're gonna do this evening", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00023-00011584-00012006": "He's been in his pajamas all day man's pajamas all day your lazy kid", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00024-00012217-00012603": "I'm not allowed to wear my pajamas all day. You shouldn't be allowed to reduce", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00025-00012772-00012972": "Sound care", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00026-00013347-00013806": "All right, we're headed to the zoo for the holiday light Safari", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00027-00013900-00014204": "How excited are you about seeing animals into Christmas lights?", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00028-00014278-00014478": "Mm-hmm his first, zoo", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00029-00014551-00015197": "Experience and it's gonna be at night. You won't be able to see the animals. Maybe he was here with him leave Haven", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00030-00015306-00015998": "You may notice it's already nighttime. The movie got out the afternoon, and he was asleep he slept for two and a half hours", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00031-00016038-00016577": "I'm sorry tell some people so I'm here actually you don't have to do the videos all by yourself this week because I am", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00032-00016684-00016804": "present", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00033-00016804-00017081": "Well do something tell him something he slept for two and a half hours", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00034-00017425-00017963": "He's wearing his name quickly shoot the word his new Christmas means easily and somebody's gotta grab", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00035-00018229-00018429": "Anyway we're headed to the zoo", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00036-00018704-00018904": "Smells like a zoo out here", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00037-00020398-00020556": "So I found a wallet", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00038-00020556-00020715": "on the path and", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00039-00020715-00021146": "took it back up to the front of the zoo to return it to its rightful owner or to turn it in and", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00040-00021348-00021548": "Went back to what my people aren't and they're gone", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00041-00021712-00022046": "And so I took the wrong turn and now I'm legit lost in a zoo", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00042-00022134-00022385": "that I grew up in I grew up going to I", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00043-00022792-00023006": "Don't know to do I'm lost I'm lost", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00044-00024751-00024972": "This is a Santa number two", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00045-00028741-00029202": "This YouTube channel is on the night's list five days to go be good", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00046-00031208-00031481": "Yeah, we're just trying to get him to go in the water", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00047-00031635-00031835": "So he'll be warm in the water tonight", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00048-00032016-00032392": "But it's gonna be a little chilly, so we're just trying to push him into the water", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00049-00033193-00033393": "Big boy", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00050-00033909-00034109": "Now they're used", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00051-00034676-00034876": "This is an alligator it's an American alligator", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00052-00035966-00036166": "It's down the river", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00053-00039935-00040135": "Let's see what's in here oh?", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00054-00040532-00041001": "No, it's the snakes we got enough snakes at our house", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00055-00043730-00044224": "So fun fact number two I also had a zoo birthday party I", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00056-00044387-00044790": "Did I was at the movie theater, and I said I had a movie theater birthday party", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00057-00044790-00045027": "And I worked the zoo it was a surprise party", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00058-00045053-00045660": "He was a surprise worked really hard on this one, and she made sure that none of my friends wish me happy birthday", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00059-00045671-00046401": "And he was miserable and so mad that no one would wish him happy birthday. He was a terrible. I was really disappointed", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00060-00046459-00046761": "Hey, there was a surprise party of the zoo, and he was still kind of bad", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00061-00046828-00047028": "I had a good time", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00062-00047059-00047466": "And we saw a squirrel fall out of one of these trees. It was the most bizarre thing but", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00063-00047708-00048090": "Yeah, they were adult birthday parties at children's locations", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00064-00050873-00051073": "Isaac and escape", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00065-00052378-00052578": "It was no cute", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00066-00053744-00054028": "All right everybody we're back home, but it's time for Gabriel to go to bed", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00067-00054029-00054176": "So we're to go ahead and call it here", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00068-00054176-00054868": "Hope you enjoyed this video if you did give it a thumbs up sure to LIKE comment and subscribe on video. I'm coming", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00069-00054962-00055118": "and then", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00070-00055118-00055318": "Be sure to continue to watch", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00071-00055352-00056080": "Because coming up. We're gonna have even more fun louisiana christmas to her videos so stick around we'll see you guys a couple days", "oSvQ_myhZXQ-00072-00057590-00057790": "Oh"}}, {"audio_id": "oSZfkNGqAQ0", "text": {"oSZfkNGqAQ0-00000-00000133-00000274": "- Hi, everyone.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00001-00000274-00000473": "Welcome to today's talk.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00002-00000473-00000763": "We are going to be covering what matters most", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00003-00000763-00001073": "to sustainably conscious food shoppers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00004-00001073-00001343": "We are going to walk through some research", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00005-00001343-00001668": "and we're gonna leave some time for Q&A at the end.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00006-00001773-00001997": "So for those of you who don't know us,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00007-00001997-00002373": "Suzy is an end-to-end consumer insights platform.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00008-00002373-00002788": "We help many B2B, B2C businesses,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00009-00002788-00003028": "make faster consumer-centric decisions.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00010-00003028-00003465": "So we work with over 400 companies currently.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00011-00003465-00003965": "We have quantitative and qualitative research solutions", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00012-00003982-00004092": "within our platform,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00013-00004092-00004296": "we also own our own panel.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00014-00004296-00004605": "So this really helps our customers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00015-00004605-00004935": "be able to make fast decisions,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00016-00004935-00005148": "asking quick agile questions,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00017-00005148-00005436": "but also tapping into larger research studies", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00018-00005436-00005579": "like segmentation.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00019-00005681-00005836": "So the background of the study", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00020-00005836-00006085": "that we're going to review today,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00021-00006085-00006375": "we conducted research at the beginning of April", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00022-00006375-00006840": "with around 1,000 Americans, with a census weighted sample.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00023-00006970-00007312": "So first to introduce myself, I'm Melissa Dunn,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00024-00007312-00007551": "the SVP of Marketing at Suzy.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00025-00007551-00007859": "I've been with the company for about eight months.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00026-00007859-00008244": "As I mentioned, we work with over 400 different customers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00027-00008244-00008640": "big brands like TikTok, Pepsi, Unilever,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00028-00008640-00008838": "many in the food and beverage space.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00029-00008838-00009338": "We work with over 22 verticals that we have as customers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00030-00009384-00009582": "but food and beverage is really", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00031-00009582-00009905": "one of our bread and butter verticals.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00032-00009905-00010197": "So we're excited to talk to you guys today,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00033-00010197-00010453": "I am gonna just give Eric the floor", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00034-00010453-00010690": "to introduce himself as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00035-00010793-00010965": "- Fabulous. Thanks Melissa.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00036-00010965-00011109": "Thanks everyone for joining us today.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00037-00011109-00011446": "I'm delighted that you've chosen to spend some time with us.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00038-00011446-00011529": "I'm Eric Pierce,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00039-00011529-00011868": "Vice President of Business Insights at New hope and Informa.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00040-00011868-00012161": "I'm responsible for the marketplace insights teams", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00041-00012161-00012388": "at New Hope, specifically in nutrition business journal", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00042-00012388-00012606": "and next data and insights.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00043-00012606-00012859": "My team and I see it as our role", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00044-00012859-00013054": "to help drive responsible growth", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00045-00013054-00013249": "for the natural and organic products industry,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00046-00013249-00013560": "and we work to do so by giving the marketplace a voice", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00047-00013560-00013756": "and to help use that voice through data,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00048-00013756-00014060": "to help inform decision making across the industry.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00049-00014060-00014296": "Ultimately, it is my hope that data and insights", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00050-00014296-00014399": "can help us cultivate", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00051-00014399-00014741": "a prosperous high integrity CPG ecosystem", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00052-00014741-00014991": "that creates health, joy, and justice", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00053-00014991-00015244": "for all people while regenerating the planet.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00054-00015244-00015421": "Looking forward to our conversation today, Melissa,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00055-00015421-00015700": "and thanks again for letting me join you.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00056-00015700-00015819": "- Of course.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00057-00015819-00016106": "I'm very much looking forward to diving in here.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00058-00016191-00016520": "So if we think about the word sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00059-00016520-00016737": "it's actually one of the biggest buzzword", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00060-00016737-00017006": "in the food and beverage sector,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00061-00017006-00017241": "so it seems to be everywhere.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00062-00017241-00017477": "But one thing we are going to explore is,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00063-00017477-00017762": "do consumers actually believe the buzz?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00064-00017900-00018118": "And have we paused to actually consider", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00065-00018118-00018353": "how sustainable is defined?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00066-00018353-00018569": "I think we're very quick", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00067-00018569-00019048": "to use the word sustainable in messaging and packaging,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00068-00019048-00019469": "but the question is what does this really mean to consumers?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00069-00019469-00019675": "At Suzy we've actually been focused", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00070-00019675-00019965": "the entire month on sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00071-00019965-00020254": "and one of our other survey is,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00072-00020254-00020566": "we actually talk about the brand Patagonia,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00073-00020566-00020840": "which obviously is not a food brand,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00074-00020840-00021190": "but they've stopped using the word sustainable entirely,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00075-00021190-00021367": "which is very interesting.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00076-00021367-00021745": "They acknowledge that they are for profit enterprise,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00077-00021745-00021944": "and that they are in fact part of", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00078-00021944-00022207": "the global climate change problem.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00079-00022207-00022542": "So, how are we defining this word?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00080-00022542-00022753": "How should we be defining this word,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00081-00022753-00023008": "especially in our brand language?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00082-00023109-00023532": "So the word sustainable, I think, conjures up images", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00083-00023532-00023970": "of recycling, or solar panels and saving the planet,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00084-00023970-00024186": "and one definition is obviously,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00085-00024186-00024360": "causing or made in a way", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00086-00024360-00024781": "that causes little or no damage to the environment.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00087-00024781-00025008": "But another way to look at this,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00088-00025008-00025181": "which I think is really interesting,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00089-00025181-00025483": "is that the purest definition of this word,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00090-00025483-00025652": "it actually means that something", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00091-00025652-00025950": "cannot be maintained or continued.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00092-00025950-00026322": "So if we think about extreme or fad dieting,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00093-00026322-00026771": "it's not actually sustainable over a long period of time,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00094-00026863-00027179": "so, I think shopping sustainably", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00095-00027179-00027503": "is currently very difficult to sustain.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00096-00027623-00027964": "I think consumers and everyone out there is saying,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00097-00027964-00028464": "how do I be sustainable and do it throughout my life,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00098-00028475-00028783": "or throughout a long period of time,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00099-00028783-00029002": "and it's something that they are struggling with", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00100-00029002-00029212": "on a day to day basis.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00101-00029212-00029458": "So, in this webinar, we're excited,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00102-00029458-00029702": "we're gonna explore through the lens", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00103-00029702-00029970": "of three different areas,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00104-00029970-00030311": "how food and beverage sustainability", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00105-00030311-00030489": "can become more sustainable.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00106-00030489-00030801": "So we're gonna cover the consumer lens,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00107-00030801-00031165": "the product lens, as well as the brand lens.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00108-00031377-00031522": "- Melissa, I love this idea", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00109-00031522-00031782": "and I'm gonna add just a little more context if I can.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00110-00031782-00032048": "I love the idea of how do we make sustainability", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00111-00032048-00032329": "more sustainable for consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00112-00032329-00032552": "And as many of you on the call probably know,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00113-00032552-00032849": "the reality is, that this topic is nuanced,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00114-00032849-00033090": "it's broad and it's complex.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00115-00033090-00033293": "And when we talk about sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00116-00033293-00033507": "we're often talking about environmental health,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00117-00033507-00033841": "animal welfare, carbon emissions, food waste, energy usage,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00118-00033841-00034187": "food access, the list goes on, social justice, fair wages,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00119-00034187-00034357": "supporting local communities.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00120-00034357-00034540": "And when we engage consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00121-00034540-00034782": "in conversations about sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00122-00034782-00035035": "they're often being asked to recycle, or compost,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00123-00035035-00035343": "buy organic, or buy free range, or buy fair trade,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00124-00035343-00035704": "avoid plastic, reduce consumption, oh man,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00125-00035704-00036060": "and it's all important, and it's all part of sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00126-00036060-00036299": "and seriously that is a massive list.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00127-00036299-00036590": "It's easy to get overwhelmed and confused,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00128-00036590-00036673": "and I would argue", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00129-00036673-00036976": "that it's even confusing and full of uncertainty", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00130-00036976-00037243": "for experienced industry members.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00131-00037243-00037416": "But we can't let that hold us back, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00132-00037416-00037763": "Our industry has a massive impact on the planet,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00133-00037763-00037981": "on our communities, and on our customers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00134-00037981-00038427": "Historically, much of it has been extractive or degenerative", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00135-00038427-00038640": "in nature, and I would say,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00136-00038640-00038801": "we have a massive opportunity", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00137-00038801-00038976": "for being the impetus for change.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00138-00038976-00039192": "Let me size that for you for a second.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00139-00039192-00039359": "Every day, consumers make decisions", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00140-00039359-00039588": "about the food and beverages that they consume,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00141-00039588-00039815": "adding up just in the United States,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00142-00039815-00040214": "to a total US agriculture and food value chain", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00143-00040214-00040422": "worth more than $13 trillion.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00144-00040517-00040674": "That means we as an industry,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00145-00040674-00040757": "have an opportunity", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00146-00040757-00041041": "to funnel trillions of dollars annually", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00147-00041041-00041323": "into more sustainable business practices.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00148-00041323-00041576": "How many other industries can say,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00149-00041576-00041941": "that they can make an impact on sustainable ability daily,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00150-00041941-00042441": "worth trillions annually via $3, five, $7 purchases", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00151-00042461-00042829": "at deli's, and grocery stores, and convenience stores.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00152-00042829-00043139": "Sustainability is an unwieldy and difficult conversation,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00153-00043139-00043533": "full of complexity and nuance, but one that we must act on,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00154-00043533-00043707": "and one that we can get excited about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00155-00043707-00044043": "because we can really an impact every single day.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00156-00044043-00044263": "So the challenge that we're gonna talk about today", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00157-00044263-00044511": "is figuring out how do we make sustainability", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00158-00044511-00044773": "something consumers want to engage in?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00159-00044773-00044993": "How do we figure out for ourselves, as businesses,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00160-00044993-00045172": "what commitments we can make?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00161-00045172-00045449": "How do we figure out how to simplify complex topics", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00162-00045449-00045555": "for marketing terms,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00163-00045555-00045802": "so that we can communicate in a nuanced,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00164-00045802-00046080": "but meaningful way that doesn't greenwash or mislead", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00165-00046080-00046324": "when we talk to consumers and then work to ensure", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00166-00046324-00046492": "that our brands are taking responsibility.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00167-00046492-00046621": "That's a little bit more", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00168-00046621-00046852": "about this sort of topic that we're approaching today,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00169-00046852-00047129": "and so I'm excited to do it with you, Melissa. Thanks again.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00170-00047229-00047371": "- Thanks Eric, for that.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00171-00047459-00047851": "I think you bring up a really good point.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00172-00047851-00048351": "I mean, all those points are really complex", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00173-00048416-00048595": "and I couldn't agree more.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00174-00048595-00048957": "There's a lot of complexity in this and so,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00175-00048957-00049402": "we're first gonna take a look at consumer sentiments,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00176-00049402-00049669": "as you mentioned around sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00177-00049669-00049766": "and like I said,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00178-00049766-00050009": "we've been doing a lot of research this month,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00179-00050009-00050226": "and we've actually learned that consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00180-00050226-00050596": "do have a real desire to be more sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00181-00050596-00050745": "but what this means to them,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00182-00050745-00051055": "it varies from industry to industry.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00183-00051055-00051341": "When we actually think about food and beverage,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00184-00051341-00051596": "consumers are doing a few things,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00185-00051596-00051811": "they're limiting food waste,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00186-00051811-00052157": "and they're also supporting environmental mental health,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00187-00052157-00052487": "as their sort of first and foremost tactics.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00188-00052487-00052696": "So during this section, we're gonna unpack", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00189-00052696-00052947": "how they're feeling about sustainable products", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00190-00052947-00053286": "and what sacrifices they're actually willing to make", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00191-00053286-00053509": "in the name of sustainability.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00192-00053634-00053967": "So consumers say they want food and drink", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00193-00053967-00054302": "that have a positive impact on the environment.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00194-00054462-00054821": "The number one way in which they do this is by recycling.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00195-00054821-00055158": "So 60% of consumers recycle,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00196-00055158-00055455": "and that's a choice that they make", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00197-00055455-00055809": "as a way of taking food and beverage consumption", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00198-00055809-00056038": "and making it more sustainable.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00199-00056038-00056538": "So recycling does seem pretty easy to do in most instances,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00200-00056588-00056795": "but it doesn't actually affect anything", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00201-00056795-00057188": "related to enjoyment of the product itself.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00202-00057325-00057825": "So while recycling doesn't it seem like a huge sacrifice,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00203-00057853-00058144": "consumers are saying that they are actually willing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00204-00058144-00058537": "to make certain sacrifices for the sake of sustainability.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00205-00058537-00058929": "So we're gonna dive into what some of those things are.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00206-00058929-00059390": "So almost half of consumers would choose a different brand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00207-00059390-00059646": "if they felt it was more sustainable.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00208-00059646-00060058": "So this could be an opportunity, especially for brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00209-00060058-00060395": "that are sort of rising in their category,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00210-00060395-00060605": "to really make a name for themselves,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00211-00060605-00060826": "and they can lean in and own", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00212-00060826-00061138": "what sustainability practices are following,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00213-00061138-00061465": "and really be able to walk the walk and talk the talk.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00214-00061602-00061988": "30% of consumers would actually sacrifice convenience", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00215-00061988-00062334": "to make their food shopping more sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00216-00062334-00062701": "but ultimately consumers don't wanna sacrifice", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00217-00062701-00062989": "the food and beverages that they love.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00218-00062989-00063332": "For many products, consumers can pick a different brand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00219-00063332-00063546": "because they're essentially still getting", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00220-00063546-00063810": "the same product at the end of the day,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00221-00063810-00064101": "but for many consumers, it's obviously much harder", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00222-00064101-00064315": "for them to make a swap from say,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00223-00064315-00064692": "I don't know, a beef burger to a veggie burger,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00224-00064692-00064879": "it's a bigger trade off for them.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00225-00065001-00065501": "So despite the fact that apparently avoiding meat and dairy", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00226-00065627-00066127": "is the most effective way to food shop sustainably,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00227-00066473-00066605": "what we're seeing here,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00228-00066605-00067019": "is that actually only 10% of consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00229-00067019-00067298": "are limiting both their meat consumption", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00230-00067298-00067523": "and buying non-dairy milk.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00231-00067523-00067894": "So it's interesting 'cause while the plant-based movement", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00232-00067894-00068285": "has obviously grown considerably in recent years,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00233-00068285-00068597": "we're still seeing that only 10% of consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00234-00068597-00068850": "say they are both limiting meat consumption", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00235-00068850-00069097": "and buying non-dairy milk.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00236-00069097-00069597": "In 2020, SPINS reported that 15% of retail milk sales", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00237-00069705-00069866": "were plant based.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00238-00069866-00070169": "So it's moving in the direction,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00239-00070169-00070363": "but I think people are not willing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00240-00070363-00070560": "to make the sacrifice of both,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00241-00070560-00070989": "it's sometimes an 'or' if you will, instead of an 'and'.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00242-00071155-00071508": "And for me, this was a really surprising stat,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00243-00071508-00071689": "because a quarter of people were saying", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00244-00071689-00072051": "that they're willing to compromise on flavor.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00245-00072051-00072201": "I know when I saw this research,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00246-00072201-00072603": "I was wondering if this is a case of say versus do,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00247-00072703-00072967": "but although 26% say", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00248-00072967-00073233": "they would be willing to sacrifice taste,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00249-00073233-00073413": "it's actually the last thing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00250-00073413-00073760": "that consumers are willing to sacrifice,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00251-00073760-00074053": "41% weren't willing to sacrifice", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00252-00074053-00074239": "and it was last on the list.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00253-00074446-00074946": "So why should consumers in fact have to sacrifice enjoyment?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00254-00074990-00075329": "This is something that ultimately,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00255-00075329-00075661": "I think, people want pleasure out of food and drink,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00256-00075661-00076099": "and is there a way to create sustainable practices", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00257-00076099-00076589": "within something that people care a lot about?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00258-00076589-00076903": "So our first insight here is that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00259-00076903-00077199": "people won't respond well to sustainability", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00260-00077199-00077520": "if they feel like they have to sacrifice pleasure.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00261-00077624-00077923": "This is a really important point,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00262-00077923-00078297": "I think, ultimately, it's how do we find this balance", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00263-00078297-00078752": "of giving people satisfaction in the foods that they love", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00264-00078752-00078948": "while still making them sustainable?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00265-00079202-00079429": "Eric, do you have anything to add here?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00266-00079429-00079654": "- Yeah, for sure. Not a big point.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00267-00079654-00079843": "I think you really made this one clear,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00268-00079843-00080111": "but I also just wanna reinforce", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00269-00080111-00080346": "that people accidentally get the wrong impression", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00270-00080346-00080433": "with this insight, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00271-00080433-00080697": "Consumers are motivated to engage with brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00272-00080697-00080900": "and to engage with state sustainability.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00273-00080900-00081104": "When we ask consumers what they're doing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00274-00081104-00081284": "to make their food and beverage consumption", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00275-00081284-00081367": "more sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00276-00081367-00081731": "we did see a very large number of common responses", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00277-00081731-00081981": "that a good number, if not the majority of people,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00278-00082072-00082157": "were engaging with.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00279-00082157-00082494": "Only 19% of consumers say that they aren't doing anything", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00280-00082494-00082776": "to make their consumption more sustainable.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00281-00082776-00083055": "But yeah, imagine what we could do", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00282-00083055-00083279": "if it didn't feel like a trade off,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00283-00083279-00083382": "imagine what we could do", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00284-00083382-00083635": "if sustainability felt like the easy choice,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00285-00083635-00083773": "the enjoyable choice,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00286-00083864-00084115": "and if consumers are willing to switch brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00287-00084115-00084245": "for more sustainable options,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00288-00084245-00084490": "and you can figure out how to make it not feel", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00289-00084490-00084803": "like it' a sacrifice,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00290-00084803-00085131": "maybe you're ready to market this in a way", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00291-00085131-00085389": "that gives consumers the option and the reason", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00292-00085389-00085530": "to make that switch.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00293-00085530-00085761": "We'll talk more about that soon as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00294-00085884-00086012": "- Yeah. 100% percent.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00295-00086012-00086184": "A lot of great things that you said", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00296-00086184-00086410": "that we'll cover in the brand section.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00297-00086521-00086635": "So what's the so what?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00298-00086635-00087093": "I think ultimately, make sustainability enjoyable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00299-00087093-00087386": "and make it easier for consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00300-00087386-00087760": "When we think about paper straws,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00301-00087760-00088172": "which I understand they are helping the environment,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00302-00088172-00088437": "but let's be honest, they're really hard to drink out of,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00303-00088437-00088904": "and they ultimately, sort of trival up,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00304-00088904-00089173": "and half the time you can't actually drink out of them", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00305-00089173-00089284": "once you started.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00306-00089284-00089731": "So I think there's definitely work to be done in this space.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00307-00089731-00089972": "We did want to sort of bring you", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00308-00089972-00090178": "into one really interesting brand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00309-00090178-00090481": "that we think is doing a really great job.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00310-00090481-00090981": "It is from a company called Airco and they make vodka.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00311-00091002-00091370": "They have two ingredients, it's water and CO2.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00312-00091370-00091797": "They actually extract CO2 from the atmosphere", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00313-00091797-00092036": "and they use it to create ethanol.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00314-00092036-00092210": "And this is pretty surprising,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00315-00092210-00092484": "since obviously there's a big fermentation process", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00316-00092484-00092669": "that happens with alcohol,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00317-00092669-00093017": "but they're really solving an environmental problem here", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00318-00093017-00093171": "which we thought was very cool.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00319-00093171-00093580": "So, I think it's just companies are being more innovative", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00320-00093580-00093684": "in their product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00321-00093684-00094068": "and we're gonna move into the product section,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00322-00094068-00094269": "in which Eric is gonna take us through.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00323-00094430-00094583": "- Fabulous. Thanks, Melissa.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00324-00094583-00094800": "All right. As a reminder, we've got three chapters today.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00325-00094800-00095053": "We're touching on the role consumers, which we just did,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00326-00095053-00095181": "products, which we're doing now,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00327-00095181-00095470": "and brands can play in helping make sustainability", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00328-00095470-00095755": "more sustainable for consumers over time.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00329-00095755-00095949": "So let's talk about product.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00330-00095949-00096286": "The good news is sustainable products are worth more.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00331-00096286-00096605": "One in three US consumers are willing to pay more", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00332-00096605-00096902": "for sustainable food and drink.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00333-00096902-00097053": "And given the current sentiment", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00334-00097053-00097270": "regarding issues related to sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00335-00097270-00097567": "it shouldn't surprise us or it shouldn't be a surprise,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00336-00097567-00097797": "that more than half of consumers, 54%,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00337-00097797-00098148": "say that it's important for brands to take action", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00338-00098148-00098372": "to operate sustainably.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00339-00098372-00098578": "In fact, 50% of consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00340-00098578-00098870": "believe that it is your responsibility to do so.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00341-00098870-00099144": "Specifically, 50% said", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00342-00099144-00099379": "that they believe it is your responsibility to take action", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00343-00099379-00099688": "to operate your business more sustainably.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00344-00099802-00100053": "But what exactly are consumers looking for", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00345-00100053-00100382": "when it comes to sustainable food and beverage?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00346-00100490-00100637": "Do no evil, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00347-00100637-00100887": "No evil foods is actually a brand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00348-00100887-00101243": "responding very directly, I believe,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00349-00101243-00101550": "with their branding, to what they believe consumers want.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00350-00101550-00101871": "Their mission statement is, do know evil.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00351-00101871-00102264": "I believe this is spot on for consumers who want to know", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00352-00102264-00102451": "that their purchases are helping to create", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00353-00102451-00102591": "a positive change in the world,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00354-00102591-00102876": "and that the brand that they're buying from", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00355-00102876-00103089": "simply does no evil, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00356-00103089-00103371": "Let's empathize for a second with consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00357-00103371-00103614": "Just to kind of bring some of those home for you,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00358-00103702-00103941": "what is the most common human reaction", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00359-00103941-00104296": "to fear, uncertainty, or discomfort? Right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00360-00104296-00104531": "The most common human response is to take action,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00361-00104531-00104722": "to reduce pain in this experience.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00362-00104722-00105032": "In order to reduce pain, one needs to take control,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00363-00105032-00105202": "and take action, and do something", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00364-00105202-00105403": "to remove yourself from that pain.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00365-00105403-00105660": "However in our modern food system,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00366-00105660-00105833": "there are hundreds of decisions", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00367-00105833-00106114": "that are made between seed and shelf,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00368-00106114-00106276": "hundreds of decisions that are made", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00369-00106276-00106503": "on behalf of the end consumer", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00370-00106503-00106769": "that they have almost no visibility into", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00371-00106769-00107002": "and no control over.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00372-00107002-00107251": "In, if a consumer is feeling anxious,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00373-00107251-00107460": "or they're feeling fear, or uncertainty,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00374-00107460-00107604": "or even just discomfort", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00375-00107604-00107886": "regarding the urgency to act on climate change,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00376-00107886-00108206": "or social justice, or other sustainability topics,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00377-00108206-00108642": "and they feel like they have no direct control in doing so,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00378-00108642-00108901": "your product, your brand,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00379-00108901-00109097": "the decisions you make as a business", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00380-00109097-00109376": "become the conduits for the control", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00381-00109376-00109540": "that consumers are seeking.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00382-00109540-00109843": "In this context, consumer trust in your product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00383-00109843-00110167": "in your brand, in your day to day decision making", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00384-00110167-00110323": "become critical.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00385-00110323-00110790": "In this context, the brand promise of do no evil,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00386-00110790-00111005": "feels really powerful to me.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00387-00111117-00111396": "So, consumers are willing to pay more,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00388-00111396-00111640": "they feel it's important that your business act,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00389-00111640-00111981": "they feel that it's your responsibility to take action,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00390-00111981-00112150": "then what do consumers want from you?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00391-00112150-00112353": "I've mentioned this already, Melissa has as well,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00392-00112353-00112669": "the reality is sustainability is really quite complex,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00393-00112669-00112915": "and that reality is reflected in this list.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00394-00112915-00113119": "When we ask consumers what they believe", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00395-00113119-00113422": "are the three most important things in food sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00396-00113422-00113695": "they told us the following, limiting food waste at the top,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00397-00113695-00113838": "supporting environmental health,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00398-00113838-00114194": "improving access to quality food, protecting animals,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00399-00114194-00114577": "reducing carbon emissions, supporting the local community,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00400-00114577-00114914": "providing fair wages and pursuing social equity and justice.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00401-00114914-00115054": "Only 10% of the consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00402-00115054-00115385": "said that none of the above were important to them.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00403-00115385-00115544": "What we see in this list,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00404-00115544-00115935": "is that sustainability lives in your business values,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00405-00115935-00116266": "it lives in the way in which your business does business,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00406-00116266-00116566": "it lives in the integrity of your business,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00407-00116566-00116856": "and sustainability lives deep in the operations", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00408-00116856-00117017": "of your business.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00409-00117017-00117438": "Yes, sustainability is a product feature or benefit as well,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00410-00117438-00117607": "but sustainability doesn't begin", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00411-00117607-00117789": "with marketing or product necessarily.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00412-00117789-00118138": "Sustainability starts with the integrity and intent.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00413-00118138-00118372": "Sustainability lives or dies in the details", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00414-00118372-00118461": "and the execution.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00415-00118461-00118740": "If we allow shallow or transactional,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00416-00118740-00118983": "or if we allow it to be shallow, or transactional,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00417-00118983-00119138": "or without nuance,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00418-00119138-00119305": "if we allow marketing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00419-00119305-00119486": "to drive product sustainability efforts,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00420-00119486-00119913": "then I would say we risk giving up", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00421-00119913-00120202": "when the marketing ROI isn't clear,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00422-00120202-00120438": "or we risk making empty promises", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00423-00120438-00120608": "and then being found out for them", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00424-00120608-00120802": "and doing damage to our brand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00425-00120802-00120913": "and our customer relationships.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00426-00120913-00121086": "So, kind of what I'm trying to say here is,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00427-00121086-00121438": "sustainable is complex, and it really does need to live,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00428-00121551-00121801": "be inspired by broader purpose and strategy,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00429-00121801-00121994": "and to live in operations,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00430-00121994-00122330": "and then to find its voice in marketing.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00431-00122330-00122797": "So marketing must find compelling ways to talk about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00432-00122797-00123020": "differentiating sustainability stories", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00433-00123020-00123245": "in a way that resonates with consumers as well,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00434-00123245-00123580": "and doing so in a way that communicates truthfully", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00435-00123580-00123666": "is important.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00436-00123666-00124003": "One example of this, taking really complex issues", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00437-00124003-00124321": "and finding ways to engage consumers, truthfully, I think,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00438-00124321-00124560": "is food waste and up cycling.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00439-00124560-00124773": "We saw a minute ago that reducing food waste", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00440-00124773-00124934": "resonates strongly with consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00441-00124934-00125163": "It was the number one way on the list", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00442-00125163-00125305": "that consumers were hoping brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00443-00125305-00125475": "would help improve sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00444-00125614-00125702": "but it's really hard.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00445-00125702-00125874": "I don't know if you've thought about it or done it yourself,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00446-00125874-00126218": "but it's really hard to market a product made out of trash.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00447-00126218-00126490": "Or maybe something that's just perceived as a waste product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00448-00126490-00126751": "or a byproduct, or something that inherently", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00449-00126751-00126888": "doesn't have a good perception", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00450-00126888-00127181": "at initial reaction in consumers mind.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00451-00127181-00127352": "And yet there's been a lot of innovation", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00452-00127352-00127708": "over the past five years in this very specific early area.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00453-00127708-00127845": "Early pioneers in this space", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00454-00127845-00128152": "are ReGrained and Upcycled food association.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00455-00128152-00128400": "ReGrained started as a finished goods company,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00456-00128400-00128563": "turning spent beer grain,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00457-00128563-00128771": "a byproduct of the beer brew ring process", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00458-00128771-00129082": "that is traditionally thrown away, or fed to pigs,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00459-00129082-00129283": "they take that and turn it into any drink bars", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00460-00129283-00129403": "and baked goods.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00461-00129403-00129657": "Today they're working to scale as an ingredient company,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00462-00129657-00129969": "by building a marketplace for this upcycled ingredient.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00463-00129969-00130123": "And the founders of ReGrained", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00464-00130123-00130421": "also helped to launch the upcycled food association,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00465-00130421-00130776": "growing certifier of products, repurposing food ingredients,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00466-00130776-00131121": "that otherwise would not have gone to human consumption.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00467-00131121-00131387": "Choosing to center this sustainability conversation", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00468-00131387-00131610": "on the idea of upcycling,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00469-00131610-00131842": "is a lot easier for consumers to engage with,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00470-00131842-00132136": "than talking about byproducts or turning food waste", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00471-00132136-00132358": "into food itself.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00472-00132358-00132617": "So insight number 2.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00473-00132617-00132866": "Consider both how a product made,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00474-00132866-00133206": "but also, given the difficult nature of these topics,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00475-00133206-00133407": "we also need give careful consideration", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00476-00133407-00133644": "to how we talk about sustainability with consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00477-00133644-00134022": "both how it is made and what it is called is important.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00478-00134285-00134478": "Melissa, was there something you wanted to add on this one?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00479-00134478-00134667": "- Yeah, 100% agree with that.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00480-00134667-00134981": "I think, we'll talk about it in the brand section,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00481-00134981-00135437": "but sustainability is inherent, I think,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00482-00135437-00135677": "to the brand and to the product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00483-00135677-00136019": "and ultimately, how it comes to life and marketing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00484-00136019-00136158": "is really important,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00485-00136158-00136582": "and it's not just about what it's called,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00486-00136582-00136798": "but how it's spoken about,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00487-00136798-00137044": "what the perception is to consumer,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00488-00137044-00137243": "and ultimately what the takeaway is.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00489-00137243-00137547": "And this is from both marketing speak,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00490-00137547-00137967": "but also really to your point around the operations pieces,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00491-00137967-00138348": "starting from the beginning and being able to talk about it", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00492-00138348-00138647": "in a way that makes sense and is truthful.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00493-00138877-00138960": "- Yeah, indeed.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00494-00138960-00139291": "And that's kind of our so what for this section, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00495-00139291-00139625": "There's gonna be tension between marketing and operations,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00496-00139625-00139874": "tension between the desire to simplify something,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00497-00139874-00140152": "to speak about it in consumer friendly marketing terms,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00498-00140152-00140610": "and the need to build potentially probably,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00499-00140610-00140888": "unsexy, unglamorous sustainability programs", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00500-00140888-00141041": "that get real work done.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00501-00141041-00141234": "The need to sustainability programs", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00502-00141234-00141442": "that do the messy work,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00503-00141442-00141715": "that is true to your purpose and intention.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00504-00141715-00141798": "So what?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00505-00141888-00142233": "We must work to engage and manage this tension,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00506-00142233-00142460": "and to find ways to talk about sustainability", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00507-00142460-00142823": "in a way that simplifies inherently complex programs", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00508-00142823-00143018": "and which connects with people,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00509-00143018-00143488": "but is careful not to mislead or greenwash in the process.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00510-00143488-00143730": "And with that, back to Melissa.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00511-00143904-00144031": "- Thanks Eric.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00512-00144031-00144531": "So as our last chapter, we are going to dive into brands.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00513-00144608-00144857": "We've looked at consumers and products.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00514-00144857-00145206": "What are brands doing around sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00515-00145206-00145520": "and what do consumers actually want to see from them?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00516-00145651-00145909": "So consumers want to be informed,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00517-00145909-00146175": "I think that is first and foremost.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00518-00146175-00146512": "They are looking for transparency from brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00519-00146512-00146851": "and they wanna know the impact of their purchases.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00520-00146851-00147056": "They also wanna be educated,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00521-00147056-00147439": "and they want brands to help them understand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00522-00147439-00147666": "what this all means.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00523-00147666-00148166": "So 54% want brands to give them more information,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00524-00148203-00148558": "and this goes back into what we discussed in Section 1,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00525-00148558-00148891": "just being transparent and educating,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00526-00148891-00149078": "brands have a platform", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00527-00149078-00149578": "to really help drive people's opinions,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00528-00149600-00149878": "perceptions, and change, frankly.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00529-00149878-00150122": "And so I think there's a lot of opportunity", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00530-00150122-00150414": "for brands to share more information", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00531-00150414-00150666": "and help take part in this.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00532-00150666-00151070": "So we don't wanna put the reliance on the consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00533-00151070-00151457": "and ultimately make them fully responsible.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00534-00151457-00151884": "We really believe that brands need to help consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00535-00151884-00152230": "see how their products are at aiding sustainability efforts", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00536-00152230-00152433": "and what are brands actually doing.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00537-00152433-00152613": "So you can see here", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00538-00152613-00152934": "that consumers really are looking for information", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00539-00152934-00153161": "around packaging materials,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00540-00153161-00153376": "how are things being created?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00541-00153484-00153721": "what are the recycling efforts", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00542-00153721-00153936": "that these brands are taking Part of that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00543-00153936-00154316": "in turn a consumer can actually take part in.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00544-00154316-00154549": "And how to shop more sustainably?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00545-00154549-00155049": "I think, consumer are really looking for guidance,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00546-00155066-00155392": "and I think this is a brand's responsibility.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00547-00155527-00156027": "So ultimately, we want brands to educate and not implicate.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00548-00156143-00156312": "Consumers don't wanna feel", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00549-00156312-00156593": "as though brands are holding them responsible", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00550-00156593-00156766": "or passing the buck,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00551-00156766-00157114": "consumers think that it is food and beverage brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00552-00157114-00157234": "who are responsible", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00553-00157234-00157646": "for improving sustainability in this sector.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00554-00157646-00157943": "We published a white paper earlier this month,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00555-00157943-00158241": "as I said, we've done a ton of research on this topic,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00556-00158241-00158640": "just given how timely it is, an important,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00557-00158640-00159033": "but consumers in this research that we did, said that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00558-00159033-00159220": "businesses really should be taking", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00559-00159220-00159452": "on a tad bit more responsibility", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00560-00159452-00159798": "than individuals or the government.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00561-00159798-00160117": "Only 12% actually said no one was responsible,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00562-00160117-00160435": "but they ranked corporations and businesses", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00563-00160435-00160792": "as sort of the number one entity, if you will,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00564-00160792-00161044": "to take more responsibility.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00565-00161044-00161544": "So, really we want to look at this eco-guilt,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00566-00161644-00162032": "we hear from brands, don't eat meat, be a vegan, recycle,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00567-00162032-00162479": "avoid single use plastics, stop shopping fast fashion,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00568-00162479-00162790": "and I think obviously this article showcases,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00569-00162790-00162982": "like the list goes on", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00570-00162982-00163397": "as far as telling consumers not to do certain things", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00571-00163397-00163648": "or to do certain things.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00572-00163648-00163924": "But ultimately, what can brands do", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00573-00163924-00164165": "to make it easier for consumers?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00574-00164165-00164641": "So biogradable and compostable packaging", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00575-00164641-00164944": "is a very easy example", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00576-00164944-00165332": "and something that consumers are asking for.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00577-00165332-00165783": "This in turn helps make their lives easier.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00578-00165783-00165997": "So we put in an example here,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00579-00165997-00166311": "obviously Frito-Lay is a really big company,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00580-00166311-00166697": "but they are testing out a compostable package.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00581-00166697-00166834": "Natural product companies", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00582-00166834-00167178": "have been innovating and doing this for a really long time,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00583-00167178-00167357": "But I think what's great to see", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00584-00167357-00167612": "is that a brand like Frito-Lay,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00585-00167612-00167956": "is actually testing this out,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00586-00167956-00168227": "and if we think back to what consumers said,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00587-00168227-00168613": "recycling is actually not as easy as we think it is.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00588-00168613-00168776": "They talked about recycling,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00589-00168776-00169049": "when we shareD data in the first section,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00590-00169049-00169447": "around how consumers are taking action to recycle,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00591-00169447-00169843": "but in many places, recycling actually isn't that easy", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00592-00169843-00170021": "for consumers to do.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00593-00170021-00170328": "So I think, things like compostable packaging", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00594-00170328-00170571": "where you can make eco-friendly,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00595-00170571-00170919": "and less wasteful packaging, and clearly labeling this,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00596-00171393-00171767": "it gives them the ability to actually take this action", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00597-00171767-00171937": "with something that's easy to do.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00598-00172085-00172433": "So if we look at insight Number 3,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00599-00172433-00172720": "one thing we think is pretty important,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00600-00172720-00173156": "is just easing eCo-guilt and not adding to it.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00601-00173156-00173440": "Consumers are really open about being educated,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00602-00173440-00173838": "I think they're frankly, yearning for this information.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00603-00173838-00174295": "So it's really, the responsibility of different brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00604-00174295-00174671": "to take this action and do something with it.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00605-00174957-00175040": "- Yeah.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00606-00175040-00175263": "It's a fine line between engaging guilt", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00607-00175263-00175445": "or negative emotions in marketing,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00608-00175445-00175639": "and actually providing a solution", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00609-00175639-00175924": "for somebody that relieves pain, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00610-00175924-00176176": "And so look for that fine line", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00611-00176176-00176413": "because there's a lot of pain and uncertainty", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00612-00176413-00176610": "that we can remove in consumer's lives", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00613-00176610-00177110": "without necessarily creating this feeling of guilt", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00614-00177157-00177391": "in how we market our product.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00615-00177391-00177523": "This insight in particular,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00616-00177523-00177885": "I think is really similar to the stated strategies", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00617-00177885-00178112": "of some vegan implant based food companies,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00618-00178112-00178336": "and so I'll share it because I think it could be a parallel", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00619-00178336-00178647": "for maybe how we think about the end goal,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00620-00178647-00178825": "not necessarily the expectation today,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00621-00178825-00179087": "but the end goal for sustainability efforts.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00622-00179087-00179275": "The good food Institute", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00623-00179275-00179455": "has advocated to this for a long time,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00624-00179455-00179816": "and back when Just Inc was named Hampton Creek,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00625-00179816-00180164": "and they were launching their just Mayo product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00626-00180164-00180356": "founder and CEO, Josh Tetrick,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00627-00180356-00180535": "described their strategic goal", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00628-00180535-00180815": "for disrupting animal based agriculture,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00629-00180815-00181105": "by compelling non vegans to buy vegan products.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00630-00181105-00181361": "They believed that the only way to do so", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00631-00181361-00181586": "was not by celebrating the fact that it was vegan,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00632-00181586-00181762": "the only way to do so at scale,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00633-00181762-00182057": "to get more people to buy vegan products", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00634-00182057-00182390": "that were friendlier on the earth and friendlier to animals,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00635-00182474-00182796": "was to ensure that their products performed at parody,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00636-00182796-00183044": "or outperformed animal based products,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00637-00183044-00183314": "on price, taste and availability.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00638-00183314-00183585": "Tetrick and others believed that only then,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00639-00183585-00183877": "will we be able to create sizeable change in the world.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00640-00183992-00184148": "That's sort of what we're saying here.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00641-00184148-00184452": "How do we make the sustainable choice the easy choice?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00642-00184452-00184697": "How do we make it something people will enjoy doing?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00643-00184697-00184830": "How do we remove the guilt", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00644-00184830-00185040": "and add the good feelings into the process", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00645-00185127-00185541": "so that this becomes the easier choice for consumers?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00646-00185541-00185696": "And again, I'm not saying you have to be", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00647-00185696-00185825": "at price parody now,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00648-00185942-00186176": "but maybe find other things that we can do,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00649-00186176-00186509": "where people again, are feeling good about doing good.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00650-00186680-00186976": "So, yeah. (Melissa chuckles)", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00651-00186976-00187188": "- Feeling good about feeling good. I like it too.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00652-00187188-00187384": "- Feeling good about feeling good.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00653-00187384-00187480": "All right. Oops. - Oops", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00654-00187480-00187564": "I'm sorry. - Sorry.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00655-00187564-00187730": "- And I skipped the slide.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00656-00187730-00187848": "Sorry.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00657-00187848-00188082": "So what's the so what here?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00658-00188082-00188261": "Really, we've talked about it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00659-00188261-00188683": "but taking the weight off of consumers, educating them,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00660-00188683-00188840": "coming up with initiatives", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00661-00188840-00189103": "that are really gonna help things.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00662-00189103-00189364": "We, again, in our research this month,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00663-00189364-00189814": "we found that the 25 largest global CPG companies,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00664-00189814-00190140": "and these are brands like Nestle, Proctor and Gamble,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00665-00190140-00190392": "Coca-Cola, have actually committed", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00666-00190392-00190725": "to either introducing recyclable packaging,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00667-00190818-00191082": "or minimizing packaging all together,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00668-00191082-00191273": "or reusing materials,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00669-00191273-00191772": "and this is according to the consumer brands association.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00670-00191772-00191945": "So 80% of those", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00671-00191945-00192237": "are working towards a fully recyclable packaging", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00672-00192237-00192557": "for all of their product by 2030.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00673-00192557-00192784": "So that's an incredible commitment.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00674-00192784-00192999": "Obviously it's not gonna happen overnight,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00675-00192999-00193342": "but I think the fact that these big corporations", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00676-00193342-00193657": "and organizations have goals,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00677-00193657-00193804": "that they are going to help", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00678-00193804-00194040": "basically, make consumers lives easier", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00679-00194040-00194383": "by taking the initiative of these programs.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00680-00194383-00194556": "To me, this is really key,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00681-00194642-00194890": "and I know I buried the lead here,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00682-00194890-00195150": "but we did wanna show you an example", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00683-00195150-00195533": "of a really interesting brand called Tony's Chocoloney.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00684-00195533-00195805": "It is European, so this is probably why", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00685-00195805-00195971": "many of you may not have heard of it.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00686-00195971-00196322": "This was actually the first time I had heard of it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00687-00196322-00196561": "but they're actually on a mission to make chocolate", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00688-00196561-00196785": "100% slave-free.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00689-00196785-00197073": "So they invest heavily in creating awareness", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00690-00197073-00197291": "through education, and training", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00691-00197291-00197524": "of both farmers and consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00692-00197524-00197928": "They pay a premium to farmers to ensure proper pay,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00693-00197928-00198313": "they're actively tracking down and combating child labor,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00694-00198313-00198568": "their beans are 100 % traceable", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00695-00198568-00198869": "to ensure transparency and fairness.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00696-00198869-00199058": "So instead of lecturing consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00697-00199058-00199203": "they make it really clear", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00698-00199203-00199613": "that this is their problem within the industry,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00699-00199613-00199963": "they make it easier for consumers to be sustainable", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00700-00199963-00200231": "and all they have to do is buy their chocolate.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00701-00200231-00200718": "So this is a really cool example that we found,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00702-00200718-00200899": "and I think the more brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00703-00200899-00201195": "sort of take this on as their own,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00704-00201195-00201546": "the more consumers are going to feel also", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00705-00201546-00201721": "a sense of responsibility,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00706-00201721-00201860": "but I think in a lot of ways", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00707-00201860-00202149": "find a connection with those brands as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00708-00202418-00202775": "- All right. So let us close the way we started.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00709-00202775-00202979": "Sustainability is complex, and nuanced,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00710-00202979-00203414": "and the details really matter when it comes to this.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00711-00203414-00203676": "Sustainability needs to be driven by your integrity", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00712-00203676-00203878": "and the way in which you do business,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00713-00203878-00204194": "it needs to be nuanced and thoughtfully executed.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00714-00204194-00204439": "As food and beverage businesses,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00715-00204439-00204736": "the decisions we make about how we run our businesses,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00716-00204736-00204891": "and how we source our ingredients,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00717-00204891-00205087": "and how we pay vendors and employees,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00718-00205087-00205298": "and how we distribute and sell our products,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00719-00205298-00205390": "have the opportunity", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00720-00205390-00205581": "to funnel trillions of dollars of change", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00721-00205581-00205787": "towards sustainability goals.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00722-00205787-00206082": "As we transition from an extractive business model", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00723-00206082-00206287": "to more sustainable ways of doing business,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00724-00206287-00206383": "and hopefully eventually,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00725-00206383-00206638": "towards regenerative ways of being in the world,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00726-00206638-00206878": "there are exciting opportunities to compete", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00727-00206878-00207023": "based on our investments", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00728-00207023-00207152": "and the investments that we're making", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00729-00207152-00207369": "in being more sustainability.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00730-00207369-00207703": "The reality is, the topic is nuanced, and broad,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00731-00207703-00207887": "and complex, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00732-00207887-00208200": "Because of this, it can be hard to engage consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00733-00208200-00208352": "in your sustainability efforts", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00734-00208352-00208544": "to compete by communicating that", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00735-00208544-00208737": "in a way that really connects.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00736-00208737-00208873": "If you choose to do so,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00737-00208873-00209085": "consider the goal of working to make", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00738-00209085-00209455": "engaging in sustainability truly sustainable for consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00739-00209455-00209727": "by figuring out how to make sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00740-00209727-00209917": "something that consumers want to engage in,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00741-00209917-00210242": "make it desirable, make it fun, make it enjoyable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00742-00210242-00210600": "figure out what commitments you as a business can make,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00743-00210600-00210841": "figure out, for marketing purposes,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00744-00210841-00211102": "how to simplify complex topics,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00745-00211102-00211262": "yet communicate with nuance", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00746-00211262-00211477": "that is careful not to greenwash or mislead,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00747-00211477-00211794": "again, kind of that idea of this needs to be operations led,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00748-00211794-00212139": "strategy led, not necessarily marketing led.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00749-00212139-00212387": "And then ensure that your business is taking responsibility", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00750-00212387-00212702": "and ownership for making your business more sustainable", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00751-00212702-00212963": "and not necessarily just passing it on to consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00752-00212963-00213147": "as an expectation for them to act.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00753-00213237-00213634": "So, I think with that, we're gonna move into Q&A.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00754-00213721-00213890": "We've got a few questions coming in,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00755-00213890-00214011": "I'll just make a quick pitch", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00756-00214011-00214293": "to get some more questions in there.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00757-00214394-00214669": "Gosh, we've got just shy of a half an hour,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00758-00214669-00215029": "so let me find the first one for us to start off with.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00759-00215358-00215507": "Oh, there's some good long questions here,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00760-00215507-00215696": "I'm gonna have to come back and read them more carefully.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00761-00215696-00215871": "All right, we've got one.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00762-00215871-00216237": "What about metal straws rather than paper straws?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00763-00216237-00216320": "I don't know that I have an answer to that one,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00764-00216320-00216569": "it was just the easiest one to read real quickly.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00765-00216936-00217102": "Let me look for another one.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00766-00217200-00217469": "Unless you've got commentary on metal straws, Melissa.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00767-00217619-00217786": "- I mean, I think", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00768-00217786-00218239": "I would prefer metal straw over a paper straw personally.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00769-00218239-00218367": "I don't know about you, Eric,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00770-00218367-00218867": "but I think that is a great product that is...", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00771-00218934-00219117": "- Maybe like bottle recycling programs.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00772-00219117-00219290": "Maybe we need a city initiative", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00773-00219290-00219407": "where people are collecting them.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00774-00219407-00219611": "So we've kept three in the glove box of our car", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00775-00219611-00219981": "that we usually remember to take into the movie theater", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00776-00219981-00220159": "or something like that, but...", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00777-00220159-00220304": "- I love that.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00778-00220304-00220540": "- Yeah. All right. Let me see here.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00779-00220540-00220810": "Meatless alternatives still have", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00780-00220810-00220984": "a negative environmental impact,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00781-00220984-00221300": "how can we convey the message that they are still better", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00782-00221300-00221767": "than meat or dairy products? And also, are they better?.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00783-00221912-00222266": "So, that's an interesting one,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00784-00222373-00222535": "before I answer the how they're better,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00785-00222535-00222910": "I'm not somebody who reads lifecycle analyses", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00786-00222910-00223009": "for these things,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00787-00223009-00223323": "so there's probably some good science behind this", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00788-00223323-00223546": "that can answer the question better than I can,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00789-00223546-00223773": "on the, are they truly a better perspective?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00790-00223892-00224065": "Virtually, everything I've seen", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00791-00224065-00224452": "says that if we compare plant-based agriculture,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00792-00224452-00224671": "which has all sorts of flaws", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00793-00224671-00224804": "and ways that we could critique it", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00794-00224804-00224988": "and say that it could be done better,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00795-00224988-00225301": "and we compare it to conventional animal agriculture,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00796-00225301-00225428": "which has a lot of flaws,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00797-00225428-00225626": "and I think most people understand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00798-00225626-00225834": "that there's an improvements that can be made there,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00799-00225834-00226114": "that plant-based really does win out,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00800-00226114-00226614": "even what I might call, sort of dirty plant based, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00801-00226621-00226769": "I think one of the real challenges", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00802-00226769-00227056": "that the plant based industry is having is,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00803-00227056-00227271": "what are the ingredients that we're growing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00804-00227271-00227715": "and using as an alternative to animal based products?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00805-00227715-00227930": "Almonds use a lot of water,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00806-00227930-00228248": "soy if not done in an non-GMO environment,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00807-00228248-00228398": "or if it's not grown organically,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00808-00228398-00228656": "there's a lot of a chemical intensive agriculture", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00809-00228656-00228860": "that goes into growing soy products,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00810-00228860-00229204": "similar for wheat, and corn, and other things", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00811-00229204-00229448": "that find their way into plant-based products.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00812-00229448-00229586": "There's stress, and there's ways", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00813-00229586-00229816": "we could be doing that better.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00814-00229816-00230269": "And even those dirty agricultural practices", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00815-00230269-00230546": "are still generally speaking, less intensive,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00816-00230546-00230871": "than growing that same soy product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00817-00230871-00231178": "and then feeding it to an animal and expecting the animal", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00818-00231178-00231398": "to create the product that we're going to eat.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00819-00231398-00231680": "And so the science to me is pretty clear", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00820-00231680-00231864": "and there's ways to improve both.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00821-00231864-00232136": "Regenerative agriculture is a very exciting practice", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00822-00232136-00232517": "that can make animal agriculture much more sustainable.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00823-00232517-00232681": "The challenge is scaling that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00824-00232681-00233181": "and can we feed the world with the meat consumption desires", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00825-00233183-00233414": "that our culture has and other cultures have", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00826-00233414-00233571": "using regenerative agriculture,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00827-00233571-00233816": "maybe, I would hope that we can.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00828-00233816-00234044": "And I think that plant-based has a real promise", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00829-00234044-00234323": "to help alleviate some of that pressure,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00830-00234323-00234777": "make crop land available for regenerative animal agriculture", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00831-00234777-00235111": "or for land reform issues and other things,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00832-00235111-00235330": "but there's improvements that can be made", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00833-00235330-00235588": "to how the average plant-based is done as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00834-00235588-00235890": "Let's do more of it organic, let's do more of it non-GMO,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00835-00235890-00236041": "let's make sure we're not growing those", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00836-00236041-00236426": "in chemicals intensive farm systems, if we can.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00837-00236426-00236810": "So, that's a way long answer on are they better?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00838-00236912-00237221": "As with anything sustainability, it's a nuanced answer.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00839-00237221-00237457": "How can we convey the message better?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00840-00237457-00237567": "I don't know, do you have any ides", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00841-00237567-00237769": "from a brand perspective, Melissa,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00842-00237769-00238077": "on how to communicate that the plant based", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00843-00238077-00238232": "might be better in these cases?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00844-00238387-00238514": "- I mean, I think, again,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00845-00238514-00238981": "it is really interesting thinking about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00846-00238981-00239273": "plant based and that comes, I think,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00847-00239273-00239538": "if you start to read the ingredients.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00848-00239538-00240020": "I think people will see that a lot of these products,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00849-00240153-00240462": "they have preservatives, they have things in them", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00850-00240462-00240931": "that are maybe not meat or animal,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00851-00241052-00241266": "but some of the things", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00852-00241266-00241521": "that people still don't even understand what they are.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00853-00241521-00241946": "So, I don't know, I think, for me plant based is,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00854-00241946-00242110": "there's the marketing side of it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00855-00242110-00242212": "but then there's also", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00856-00242212-00242442": "the actual product development side of it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00857-00242442-00242676": "and really finding ways", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00858-00242676-00242944": "to make a product that is plant based,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00859-00242944-00243281": "that actually feels like you're eating real food,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00860-00243281-00243676": "and that you're not just sacrificing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00861-00243676-00243946": "sort of the taste of what a meat product is,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00862-00243946-00244273": "but you're actually eating something healthy as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00863-00244273-00244615": "So I think for me, it's about both the product,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00864-00244615-00244963": "but then also the way we talk about it.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00865-00244963-00245183": "And this sort of leads into another question", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00866-00245183-00245404": "that we had in the chat, around,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00867-00245626-00245912": "brand shying away from using the sustainable", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00868-00245912-00246139": "and what words should we be using", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00869-00246139-00246276": "other than sustainable?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00870-00246276-00246717": "I mean, I think, trying to find vocabulary,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00871-00246717-00247007": "we talked about this a few months ago, Eric,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00872-00247007-00247329": "but if I think about natural, organic, sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00873-00247329-00247654": "there is just so much nuance and complexity,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00874-00247654-00247983": "which we've said during this hour,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00875-00247983-00248301": "but I think it's about finding real words", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00876-00248301-00248769": "to communicate what something is, and there's a lot,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00877-00248769-00249071": "that I think there's perception around natural.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00878-00249071-00249269": "There's someone I follow on Instagram", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00879-00249269-00249661": "and I was telling someone on my team this morning,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00880-00249661-00250041": "she really is taking a look and calling out brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00881-00250041-00250267": "that are calling something natural,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00882-00250267-00250527": "but if you actually look at the ingredients on the back,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00883-00250527-00250809": "it says, it's natural flavors.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00884-00250809-00251103": "It's not really natural, it's actually artificial.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00885-00251103-00251451": "And so I think we need to almost redefine", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00886-00251451-00251755": "and re-look at the vocabulary,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00887-00251755-00251976": "and say, how do we message this in a way", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00888-00251976-00252209": "that actually feels real?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00889-00252209-00252516": "What are better words to describe something?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00890-00252516-00252794": "And how do we sort of strip away", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00891-00252794-00253048": "some of, I would call it, fluff in a way?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00892-00253048-00253255": "It's like consumers are confused enough", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00893-00253255-00253434": "when the go to the grocery store", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00894-00253434-00253625": "and they have so many choices,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00895-00253625-00253942": "and then they start seeing all these labels.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00896-00253942-00254294": "Ultimately, I think we've gotta find a vocabulary", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00897-00254294-00254617": "that really resonates with consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00898-00254617-00254821": "and is truthful at the same time.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00899-00254821-00255017": "How do we bridge that?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00900-00255017-00255350": "But to me, as I've been thinking about sustainable", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00901-00255350-00255702": "and really what that word actually means,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00902-00255702-00255852": "you may've said it earlier,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00903-00255852-00256080": "but it's not just the marketing, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00904-00256080-00256506": "It is starting from the beginning as far as supply chain", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00905-00256506-00256804": "and all of the things from an operational standpoint", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00906-00256804-00256971": "that really go into this.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00907-00256971-00257471": "To me, marketing is sort of one of the last points", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00908-00257586-00258023": "on the process journey, if you will.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00909-00258023-00258273": "It's really how do we message? How do we communicate?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00910-00258273-00258603": "And we need to, I think, do a better job", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00911-00258603-00258886": "of finding the words that actually can communicate", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00912-00258886-00259191": "the right things out to consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00913-00259288-00259386": "- Yeah. I love that.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00914-00259386-00259506": "I'll say the same thing I think,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00915-00259506-00259623": "in a slightly different way.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00916-00259623-00259991": "Be specific. Sustainable is so broad and almost meaningless.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00917-00259991-00260177": "It's a concept, it's not an action,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00918-00260177-00260338": "describe what you're doing, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00919-00260338-00260506": "Like it's specific with consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00920-00260506-00260796": "that's the best way to probably avoid a lawsuit as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00921-00260796-00260915": "Claiming you're sustainable", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00922-00260915-00261189": "is like that's a big broad assumption.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00923-00261189-00261533": "Claiming that you're reducing your water impact", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00924-00261533-00261830": "by doing something specific, call that out, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00925-00261830-00262072": "Like tell people the things you're doing.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00926-00262416-00262612": "There's a question from April here,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00927-00262612-00262766": "are consumers willing to take steps", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00928-00262766-00262956": "from conventional to organic", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00929-00262956-00263185": "on a path towards more sustainable choices?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00930-00263185-00263377": "And do you have any data on this?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00931-00263504-00263739": "We didn't ask that question directly", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00932-00263739-00264020": "or anything super direct to that.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00933-00264020-00264182": "Some of the survey data that I've got", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00934-00264182-00264516": "shows that interest and engagement with organic,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00935-00264516-00264726": "we're just beginning to analyze some work", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00936-00264726-00264933": "that we're gonna be putting out later this year", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00937-00264933-00265093": "in our ways of eating report,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00938-00265212-00265361": "and I'm gonna get the number slightly wrong,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00939-00265361-00265642": "so give me couple of percentage points, fudge room on this.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00940-00265642-00265922": "But, I think in 2013, when we did a survey,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00941-00265922-00266282": "we saw that about nine or 10% of consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00942-00266282-00266559": "thought organic was important, or were engaged in that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00943-00266559-00266847": "similar number for interest in natural products.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00944-00266847-00267143": "And those numbers are now sort of more in the or 20s,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00945-00267143-00267541": "22, 23% of consumers saying that.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00946-00267541-00267747": "Similarly, I think if you wanted data,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00947-00267747-00268097": "you could look to the organic trade association.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00948-00268097-00268416": "We work with them on their market sizing report every year.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00949-00268416-00268569": "And what you could look at", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00950-00268569-00268973": "is the shift in the growth in organic, in the US,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00951-00268973-00269264": "in terms of retail sales over the years,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00952-00269264-00269502": "to at least show that that some consumers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00953-00269502-00269665": "are making that shift.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00954-00269665-00269917": "Organic is just not a perfect case study here,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00955-00269917-00270069": "it's a challenging conversation,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00956-00270069-00270304": "And one has not always been as clear", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00957-00270304-00270414": "in the mind of consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00958-00270414-00270748": "but that's the best data that I can think of, April,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00959-00270748-00270906": "on that one specifically.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00960-00271124-00271273": "- Yeah. And I just wanna comment,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00961-00271273-00271497": "Katrina, put something in here.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00962-00271497-00271678": "I'm definitely not suggesting", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00963-00271678-00272178": "that bioengineering plant-based foods isn't sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00964-00272399-00272576": "I think in a lot of ways it is.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00965-00272576-00273076": "I think, in my mind I was speaking more around,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00966-00273211-00273589": "just as to how the actual ingredients,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00967-00273589-00274089": "when you compare them to sort of real actual food itself", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00968-00274200-00274482": "and those simple ingredients,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00969-00274482-00274766": "to me, that's sort of what I was trying to get at there.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00970-00274766-00274956": "So I think you're completely right.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00971-00274956-00275197": "There's been a ton of improvements", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00972-00275197-00275593": "in you say, yield and nutritional profiles.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00973-00275593-00275951": "Through this technology, I eat a lot of plant-based food,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00974-00275951-00276190": "so I'm definitely not knocking it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00975-00276190-00276303": "but I think sometimes,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00976-00276303-00276670": "especially when we look at the stat we talked about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00977-00276670-00277003": "around meat and non dairy,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00978-00277092-00277431": "consumers are basically, being sort of push", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00979-00277431-00277592": "to eat more plant-based,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00980-00277592-00277982": "sometimes they don't necessarily know what they're getting.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00981-00277982-00278355": "Obviously the packaging helps give them that answer,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00982-00278355-00278667": "but I think when we think about pushing people", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00983-00278667-00278970": "to plant-based foods, obviously there's a huge benefit", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00984-00278970-00279162": "from a sustainability perspective,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00985-00279162-00279439": "but like we talked about, there's some times", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00986-00279439-00279781": "the sacrifice of the flavor profile", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00987-00279781-00280026": "or certain things within that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00988-00280026-00280282": "that I think we just have to take into account.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00989-00280282-00280549": "So very good point, and obviously,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00990-00280549-00280931": "not something I was trying to imply in my statement.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00991-00280931-00281180": "I did wanna make one other note that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00992-00281180-00281373": "Renee, had mentioned a company", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00993-00281373-00281724": "that we actually highlighted in a blog we wrote about.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00994-00281724-00281975": "So there's a company called TerraCycle,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00995-00281975-00282392": "and there's actually a number of other companies out there", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00996-00282392-00282571": "that are really working hand in hand", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00997-00282571-00282872": "with food and beverage companies and CEG companies", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00998-00282872-00283235": "to make recycling, and making reusable packaging,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-00999-00283235-00283662": "and making those things a lot easier for consumers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01000-00283662-00283801": "There's a ton of programs", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01001-00283801-00284135": "that we highlighted in a blog from earlier this month.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01002-00284135-00284552": "So I think there are also these third party entities", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01003-00284552-00284896": "that are taking responsibility amongst themselves", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01004-00284896-00285077": "to really partner with brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01005-00285077-00285273": "and again, sort of bridge the gap", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01006-00285273-00285678": "between brand consumer and how do you make it easier,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01007-00285678-00286039": "and how do you help them on both sides.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01008-00286221-00286304": "- Yeah.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01009-00286524-00286821": "We've got another comment from Renee, here about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01010-00286997-00287342": "how do we get more money into the supply chains", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01011-00287342-00287649": "to use products that are more sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01012-00287649-00288141": "like seaweed foam and some other examples,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01013-00288141-00288318": "warehouses using solar power,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01014-00288318-00288633": "or are only using biodegradable, or compostable packaging,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01015-00288633-00288890": "is that the essence of the question.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01016-00288890-00289013": "And I think that's a really good one,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01017-00289013-00289178": "and I don't don't think there's an easy answer.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01018-00289178-00289394": "Some of it is, yeah, some consumers are willing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01019-00289394-00289488": "to pay more for that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01020-00289488-00289632": "but I also think we need to think about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01021-00289632-00289869": "the entire value chain and say,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01022-00289869-00290176": "how do you engage all of the stakeholders", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01023-00290176-00290552": "in a conversation about, what are we willing to give,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01024-00290552-00290726": "or what are we willing to invest,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01025-00290726-00290927": "to make this more sustainable choice?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01026-00290927-00291075": "It's not easy, it's not difficult,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01027-00291075-00291336": "it don't almost always comes as a little bit of a sacrifice.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01028-00291336-00291521": "So maybe you need to bring,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01029-00291521-00291799": "if you've got investors or company owners,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01030-00291799-00292160": "maybe you need to get them sold in on the idea", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01031-00292160-00292458": "of why giving up a little bit of margin or profit", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01032-00292458-00292688": "might be of value for doing this.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01033-00292688-00292810": "You need to bring in retailers", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01034-00292810-00292941": "and to make sure they're understanding", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01035-00292941-00293179": "why they're doing that, so that when they are looking", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01036-00293179-00293407": "at your price point relative to others,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01037-00293407-00293541": "they understand what's going on,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01038-00293541-00293701": "and maybe they're willing to sacrifice", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01039-00293701-00293943": "a fraction of a margin point or something.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01040-00293943-00294231": "But have that conversation broadly, about who you are,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01041-00294231-00294314": "and what you're doing,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01042-00294314-00294514": "and why you're making these investments,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01043-00294514-00294819": "because it's not just the consumer's responsibility", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01044-00294819-00294961": "to take on that higher cost,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01045-00294961-00295195": "but if everyone across the supply chain", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01046-00295195-00295367": "shares a little bit in this,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01047-00295367-00295589": "we're making better decisions together,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01048-00295589-00296042": "I think we can begin to allow for there to be more money", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01049-00296042-00296332": "in an otherwise price and margin centric,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01050-00296332-00296469": "sort of environment,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01051-00296469-00296660": "allow more of that money to be available", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01052-00296660-00296931": "for making the right choices in the investments.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01053-00296931-00297148": "We can't pass it all onto the consumer", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01054-00297148-00297451": "and we can't take it all on as one company ourselves.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01055-00297451-00297897": "I think we need to engage the community of stakeholders", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01056-00297897-00298062": "that are involved in that decision making", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01057-00298062-00298235": "in the importance of doing it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01058-00298235-00298474": "and hopefully share the cost.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01059-00298474-00298669": "I don't know if that's the answer,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01060-00298669-00298775": "but that's one of the answers.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01061-00298775-00298992": "It's definitely important for young startup brands", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01062-00298992-00299096": "in the natural product states", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01063-00299096-00299352": "to make sure that they have the right investor money.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01064-00299352-00299646": "Somebody who's not gonna look at their margins and say,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01065-00299646-00299885": "\"You know what, go back to plastic,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01066-00299885-00300043": "the margin's more important\" right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01067-00300043-00300424": "Like if you are about sustainability, if that's your brand,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01068-00300424-00300766": "if that's your purpose and your mission, oh my gosh,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01069-00300766-00300961": "make sure you're bringing on the right investors", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01070-00300961-00301283": "so that when they flex their ownership muscle,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01071-00301283-00301622": "they're doing it way that supports your values", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01072-00301622-00301783": "as opposed to compromises them.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01073-00301885-00302028": "Sorry, there's a little soapbox", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01074-00302028-00302137": "sometimes get on with that one,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01075-00302137-00302479": "but the right money is really important, engage it.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01076-00302636-00302753": "- Yeah.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01077-00302753-00303096": "Eric, Ray, actually had a comment", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01078-00303096-00303556": "in our question in the chat, which is similar to price,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01079-00303556-00303901": "but more around our consumers willing to pay more,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01080-00303901-00304185": "and whether we saw that in the research.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01081-00304185-00304554": "I think throughout the research we've been doing,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01082-00304554-00304799": "for the past few months, I think,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01083-00304932-00305213": "it is harder for people to pay more,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01084-00305480-00305713": "I think it's really right now, even inflation,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01085-00305713-00306106": "that's impacting a lot of the prices out there.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01086-00306106-00306514": "I think people are willing to pay more", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01087-00306514-00306912": "for sustainable products, but to your point,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01088-00306912-00307182": "you make around, sort of there's a price difference", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01089-00307182-00307610": "between processed foods and more sustainably sourced foods.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01090-00307610-00307847": "I think, people are striving", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01091-00307847-00308208": "to be sustainable as best they can,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01092-00308208-00308379": "but I do think sometimes", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01093-00308379-00308581": "based on what we saw in the research,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01094-00308581-00308938": "price can definitely be a factor and a reason why", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01095-00308938-00309417": "they don't choose more sustainable products.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01096-00309417-00309822": "At the end of the day they can be more costly,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01097-00309822-00310131": "and for people especially on a budget,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01098-00310131-00310441": "especially given inflation and what's happening right now,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01099-00310441-00310941": "I think those often are some of the first to go,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01100-00310975-00311315": "when we're looking at what people are saving", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01101-00311315-00311747": "or not spending money on, things like eating out,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01102-00311747-00311906": "travel, and things like that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01103-00311906-00312301": "but I think ultimately, it's also everyday activities", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01104-00312301-00312609": "like groceries, and having to weigh", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01105-00312609-00313004": "sort of what they're able afford.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01106-00313004-00313247": "What we saw in the research is that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01107-00313247-00313474": "a lot people want to eat sustainably", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01108-00313474-00313760": "or they want to take sustainable actions,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01109-00313760-00314093": "but sometimes they're either not available to them", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01110-00314093-00314593": "or the price to do so can be prohibitive.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01111-00314647-00315005": "Eric, I don't know if you have anything to add to that but.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01112-00315005-00315209": "- Yeah. Maybe a tangent to it.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01113-00315209-00315430": "Just a reminder that sustainability,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01114-00315712-00315969": "as we've mentioned, it's not just about the environment.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01115-00315969-00316246": "Having a sustainable food system means,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01116-00316246-00316667": "are we making food accessible to those who need it?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01117-00316794-00317093": "Are we creating healthy food and making it available", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01118-00317093-00317381": "through our distribution channels and other ways?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01119-00317381-00317847": "Are we addressing social equity and racial biases", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01120-00317847-00318347": "that present in, who gets funding within our food system?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01121-00318386-00318732": "Who has access to healthy food? Where it is distributed?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01122-00318820-00319084": "What products behind the beauty counter", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01123-00319084-00319361": "are behind lock and key, versus which ones can...", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01124-00319361-00319550": "I mean, just, the number of places", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01125-00319550-00319733": "where sustainability can impact things", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01126-00319733-00320136": "beyond just the environmental conversation", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01127-00320136-00320254": "that we've been having a fair bit.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01128-00320254-00320497": "Remember this is about fair wages,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01129-00320497-00320670": "this is about food access,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01130-00320670-00320861": "this is about social justice reform,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01131-00320861-00320989": "this is about land reform,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01132-00320989-00321280": "all of these things impact.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01133-00321280-00321673": "Are we running a sustainable food and beverage industry?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01134-00321673-00321853": "No, we're not currently.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01135-00321963-00322119": "I don't think it was built this way", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01136-00322119-00322288": "with bad intention in mind,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01137-00322288-00322595": "but we found ourselves in a degenerative system", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01138-00322595-00322742": "that is extractive in nature,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01139-00322742-00323101": "that is pulling value out of communities, out of people,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01140-00323101-00323463": "out of our planet, and we need to make that shift", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01141-00323463-00323713": "and sustainability needs to be all of these things.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01142-00323713-00324014": "There's a lot of correction that needs to be made", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01143-00324014-00324214": "as we pursue a truly", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01144-00324214-00324636": "more sustainable food and beverage ecosystem.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01145-00325324-00325566": "- Great. Eric, that was awesome.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01146-00325566-00325919": "I think you you gotta shout out also in the chat,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01147-00325919-00326314": "(Eric laughs) but a lot of head nods there.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01148-00326314-00326493": "Do you wanna tackle this one?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01149-00326493-00326737": "I am not the best person to answer this,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01150-00326737-00327204": "but is there a for meat or dairy to be more sustainable?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01151-00327204-00327446": "i.e grass fed and organic.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01152-00327560-00327744": "- Yeah, if you're committed to meat and dairy", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01153-00327744-00327899": "and you want it to be more sustainable,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01154-00327899-00328225": "please research regenerative agriculture", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01155-00328225-00328327": "and regenerative systems.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01156-00328327-00328827": "Start with the savory Institute and the land market system.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01157-00328983-00329442": "They are some incredibly passionate, very smart people,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01158-00329442-00329687": "who are doing amazing work,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01159-00329841-00330341": "in reintegrating animals into agricultural systems,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01160-00330350-00330742": "and that's an important area of innovation", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01161-00330742-00331056": "within this space and an important asset.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01162-00331056-00331163": "There's the opportunity", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01163-00331163-00331646": "to actually use animals regeneratively on a farm", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01164-00331646-00331947": "that helps capture carbon out of the air", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01165-00331947-00332097": "and get it back into the soil.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01166-00332184-00332516": "I don't think any of the solutions we're talking about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01167-00332516-00332661": "are the silver bullet we're looking for,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01168-00332661-00332876": "I think we need all of the solutions.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01169-00332876-00333082": "We need to try a lot of things,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01170-00333082-00333315": "and regenerative agriculture is an important one,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01171-00333315-00333663": "and so is plant-based solutions.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01172-00333755-00333881": "But, yes, absolutely,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01173-00333881-00334177": "there's a lot of ways to do animals better than we have.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01174-00334177-00334402": "Please look at regenerative", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01175-00334402-00334573": "and feel free to reach out to me,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01176-00334573-00334790": "I'll connect you with people if need be.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01177-00335580-00335866": "Is there more we wanted to touch on?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01178-00335866-00336030": "I was debating more saying more", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01179-00336030-00336252": "on the bioengineering conversation,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01180-00336252-00336402": "but we've also moved on,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01181-00336575-00336693": "and we're running outta time.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01182-00336693-00336943": "- [Melissa] You can go back there.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01183-00336943-00337134": "- I think it's an interesting topic,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01184-00337134-00337427": "and I don't remember exactly the conclusion you guys got to,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01185-00337427-00337643": "so I'm not necessarily reacting one way or another,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01186-00337643-00337833": "but I will just say,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01187-00337833-00338147": "there is opportunity and risk, I believe,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01188-00338147-00338418": "in the conversation of bioengineering.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01189-00338418-00338650": "And just to be really clear, when I say bioengineering,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01190-00338650-00339070": "I'm talking about genetic modification in our food system,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01191-00339070-00339386": "either it directly in the crops that we're growing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01192-00339386-00339755": "or sort of behind the scenes in the technology", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01193-00339755-00340003": "or the process that is creating an ingredient.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01194-00340003-00340387": "From a sustainability practice, there's a lot of promise", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01195-00340387-00340613": "that there is a lot that can be done", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01196-00340613-00340987": "to improve sustainability with these technologies.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01197-00340987-00341288": "And I'll just caution that,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01198-00341288-00341422": "I think there are a lot of companies", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01199-00341422-00341585": "that are entering into that space", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01200-00341585-00341908": "with the right intent and purpose in mind,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01201-00341908-00342138": "and I think any tool, right?", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01202-00342348-00342574": "No tool is inherently good or evil.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01203-00342574-00342699": "And that's what I wanna say a little bit", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01204-00342699-00342953": "about bioengineer and genetic modification.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01205-00342953-00343219": "No tool is inherently good or evil,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01206-00343219-00343668": "but its application and its intent are what defines", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01207-00343668-00343845": "if somebody's gonna look at this", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01208-00343845-00344022": "as a positive or negative in the world.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01209-00344022-00344457": "And I think there's a lot of concern consumer population", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01210-00344457-00344783": "about bioengineering, about genetic modification,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01211-00344783-00345199": "and I'm afraid there are some organizations out there", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01212-00345199-00345545": "that might be pursuing this technology", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01213-00345545-00345948": "without enough transparency.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01214-00345948-00346124": "There are companies that are doing it really well", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01215-00346124-00346394": "in our industry, and I have a sense that there are some", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01216-00346394-00346595": "that maybe aren't being as transparent,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01217-00346595-00346991": "maybe more in the ingredient space necessarily", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01218-00346991-00347148": "than directly in the finished good space,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01219-00347148-00347491": "but I think there's opportunity for confusion, risk,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01220-00347491-00347891": "and for a technology that maybe when applied right,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01221-00347891-00348077": "could do a lot of good in the world", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01222-00348077-00348403": "to become the next lightning rod conversation", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01223-00348403-00348509": "in consumers minds,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01224-00348509-00348747": "where it becomes a big negative thing", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01225-00348747-00349232": "because companies used it without proper transparency,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01226-00349232-00349315": "purpose or intent,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01227-00349315-00349566": "they used it with profit as the primary motivation,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01228-00349566-00349854": "as opposed to serious sustainability solutions", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01229-00349854-00349968": "as the primary motivation.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01230-00349968-00350351": "So I would just say, if you're looking at this topic,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01231-00350351-00350678": "please make sure you're thinking long and hard about", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01232-00350678-00350840": "the risks and the benefits,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01233-00350840-00351064": "the transparency necessary in using it,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01234-00351064-00351459": "and just how we introduce this to consumers,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01235-00351459-00351690": "if we introduce it to consumers in a way,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01236-00351690-00351850": "again I'm advocating for transparency,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01237-00351850-00352224": "but do it in a way where we help them see it", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01238-00352224-00352404": "and understand it transparently.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01239-00352404-00352636": "So, tricky stuff for sure.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01240-00353109-00353487": "- Well, thank you everyone for joining us today.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01241-00353487-00353737": "Great questions, really appreciate", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01242-00353737-00354237": "the interactiveness of all the input that you gave us.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01243-00354330-00354830": "This will be available to view from a recording perspective", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01244-00354851-00355100": "and we will share that out.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01245-00355100-00355325": "Eric, thank you so much again,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01246-00355325-00355654": "for having me and having Suzy,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01247-00355654-00356035": "and letting us be a part of the narrative here", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01248-00356035-00356391": "that you guys are bringing your community through.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01249-00356391-00356557": "As a thought leader,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01250-00356557-00356799": "we feel really honored to be a part of this.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01251-00356884-00357124": "- Oh. I love doing it with you guys, it's a lot of fun,", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01252-00357124-00357234": "you guys make it easy as well.", "oSZfkNGqAQ0-01253-00357234-00357404": "So thank you, and thanks everyone."}}, {"audio_id": "oT0IPqAHxwA", "text": {"oT0IPqAHxwA-00000-00000000-00000200": "Comment Next Which Videos You are Like To Watch"}}, {"audio_id": "oT3IJ1FJ9cA", "text": {}}, {"audio_id": "oT4MAQsrRvE", "text": {"oT4MAQsrRvE-00000-00000508-00000951": "Hello! Welcome to Ask an Archaeologist! I'm Nico Tripcevich", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00001-00000951-00001440": "the host of today's show. Ask an Archaeologist is a series of live", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00002-00001440-00001889": "streamed interviews co-hosted by the Archaeological Research Facility and the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00003-00001889-00002388": "Phoebe A. Hearst Museum of Anthropology for Cal week", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00004-00002388-00002907": "2020. Each day at 11:00 and 2:00, we will interview UC Berkeley Archaeologists and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00005-00002907-00003497": "answer audience questions. If you have a question to ask, go to \"Sli.do\"", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00006-00003497-00004236": "and type in \"AskARF\", all one word,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00007-00004236-00004728": "and click on join. Then type in your question. I'll remind you of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00008-00004728-00005405": "this part way through the interview. Today's speaker is Scott Byram.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00009-00005405-00005892": "Dr. Scott Byram is a research affiliate with the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00010-00005892-00006225": "Archaeological Research Facility. He has conducted ground penetrating radar", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00011-00006225-00006761": "or GPR on Cal projects on four continents. Most of his work is in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00012-00006761-00007272": "California and in Oregon. Scott uses GPR to survey sites ranging from shellmounds", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00013-00007272-00007781": "to Adobe ruins and from historic homesteads, cemeteries,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00014-00007781-00008793": "fortifications and wreckage sites. Scott will be presenting his talk how are (inaudible)", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00015-00008793-00010131": "artifacts and ruins before they begin an excavation. Welcome Scott. My first", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00016-00010131-00010511": "question is how do archaeologists use ground-penetrating radar to map these", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00017-00010511-00011268": "things. Well I will be able to demonstrate a little more clearly with", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00018-00011268-00012000": "some imagery, but basically we're using electromagnetic waves to send radar into", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00019-00012000-00012557": "the ground and then receive a reflection back from the energy that comes back", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00020-00012557-00013179": "from the objects below the surface. The pattern in those waves, the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00021-00013179-00013604": "magnitude and the time of travel, is what we use to actually map", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00022-00013604-00014006": "archeological features below the surface.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00023-00014435-00014883": "If you have slides you want to share with us you're welcome to to bring those", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00024-00014883-00016128": "up. Okay. All right, let me pull up a presentation here. Are you able", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00025-00016128-00018534": "to see my screen yet? Not yet. Okay all right, full size there. Okay, we", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00026-00018534-00018864": "can talk about the different techniques that we use when we're using", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00027-00018864-00019254": "ground-penetrating radar and how we identify different types of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00028-00019254-00019800": "archeological features. Here I'm mapping a cemetery, actually at black diamond", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00029-00019800-00020667": "mines in the East Bay. You can see a GPR profile and a GPR slice map, and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00030-00020667-00021284": "we'll look at a few more of those. But just to put it into perspective, GPR is", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00031-00021284-00021771": "different from other techniques that archaeologists use to scan the landscape", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00032-00021771-00022371": "to identify archeological features and characterize entire archaeological sites", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00033-00022371-00023100": "and landscapes. One that's fairly common these days and very effective", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00034-00023100-00023685": "is lidar. It can be done on the ground with a instrument", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00035-00023685-00024324": "on a tripod which ARF uses but more often it's used from an airplane and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00036-00024324-00025024": "it uses laser technology and light information to characterize topography and features. For example, Mayan cities and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00037-00025024-00026274": "channels for agriculture that are present under a forest canopy in the Yucatan Peninsula", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00038-00026274-00026752": "can be characterized with lidar. Magnetometry,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00039-00026752-00027600": "seen here helped by Nico Tripcevitch and his daughter Sophie and my son Diego,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00040-00027600-00028099": "is a very effective technique. The gradiometer or magnetometers is", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00041-00028099-00028656": "great for studying subsurface magnetics. This technique is useful for", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00042-00028656-00029163": "identifying especially metal artifacts, but also burn features, bricks and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00043-00029163-00029743": "ceramics, and anything that's got an aligned magnetism to it. But, it's", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00044-00029743-00030049": "a passive technique, it doesn't send a radar wave or it doesn't send any", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00045-00030049-00030375": "information into the ground. It actually just receives whatever magnetic", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00046-00030375-00030868": "information is coming in. And then sonar, you can see here on the bottom right is", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00047-00030868-00031297": "what's used in saltwater. Ground-penetrating radar doesn't work in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00048-00031297-00031716": "salt water because the salt crystals attenuate the radar signal they keep the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00049-00031716-00032386": "radar from reflecting back towards the antenna. So with that being ineffective", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00050-00032386-00032934": "we're able to use sonar instead to identify shipwrecks that might", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00051-00032934-00033508": "be on the sea floor for example. So that's a very effective technique in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00052-00033508-00034125": "salt water. GPR can be used in freshwater, although it's rarely done so because", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00053-00034125-00034663": "salt is not an issue in freshwater, but ground-penetrating radar", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00054-00034663-00035119": "is the technique that we often use on land and it provides the greatest", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00055-00035119-00035686": "detail of any of the techniques for remote sensing below the surface. It is", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00056-00035686-00036288": "especially valuable in that it allows us to look at the depth of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00057-00036288-00036669": "different things that are identifying. In contrast, with magnetometry which is", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00058-00036669-00037269": "two-dimensional, it will only show the magnitude of the magnetic information at", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00059-00037269-00037927": "a particular location on the site. GPR will show features but also their depth.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00060-00037927-00039089": "So we can look at them in both profile and in plan with slice maps that we make.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00061-00039089-00040138": "Here's some GPR in action. This is Professor Jun Sunseri from Cal. Here, he is pulling the 900 megahertz antenna with the wheel behind it for", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00062-00040138-00040375": "measuring distance that goes along the top of the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00063-00040375-00040918": "screen as the data is being scrolled across. So there are varied features", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00064-00040918-00041325": "showing up in an individual transect profile. You can see we're working on a", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00065-00041325-00041865": "grid that we've marked out with chalk in this parking lot at Santa Clara Adobe's.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00066-00041865-00042450": "And there I am using a three wheel cart with a 400 megahertz slightly larger", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00067-00042450-00043128": "antenna. As the antenna moves across the ground surface, you can see the buried", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00068-00043128-00043537": "object below becomes more and more visible. And these are different", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00069-00043537-00044005": "objects that are similar to what you see in this diagram.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00070-00044005-00044463": "The antenna is moving across up here and then this is the depth scale on the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00071-00044463-00044869": "other side on the screen. So that's what we look at as we're doing", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00072-00044869-00045381": "the GPR. Then as we process it, we get more information. We take that same", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00073-00045381-00045886": "transect profile and then we can look at multiple transects in a grid and create", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00074-00045886-00046371": "three-dimensional imagery. Basically like a whole bunch of Lego blocks, the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00075-00046371-00046843": "entire grid would be made of and each Lego block has its own amplitude value.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00076-00046843-00047377": "That allows us to create amplitude slice Maps at various depths. Here is a", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00077-00047377-00047986": "Native American clay house floor feature in California. It shows up in this", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00078-00047986-00048777": "profile as this sort of darker black and white lines. Then with the color", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00079-00048777-00049125": "scale that we're using, red as high amplitude and yellow is relatively high,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00080-00049125-00049708": "and that's the floor of the house that's buried about 60 centimeters down at this", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00081-00049708-00050325": "site. Out in this area there aren't any features. Here is a feature closer to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00082-00050325-00051118": "the ARF here at Cal, at the Faculty Club, that we believe are foundations of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00083-00051118-00051477": "cottages that were there before the Faculty Club was built. When this was not", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00084-00051477-00051915": "actually part of campus but a place where people lived off campus in the very", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00085-00051915-00052545": "early 1900's. This is what it looks like in profile. This is where that", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00086-00052545-00053152": "transect profile crosses the grid, this red line, and so it intersects the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00087-00053152-00053594": "feature at various locations, these different foundations.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00088-00053594-00054176": "It's putting together multiple transects profiles that allow us to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00089-00054176-00055007": "generate these maps of features below the surface. Are you generally walking in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00090-00055007-00055379": "straight lines when you use this instrument? It's very important to walk", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00091-00055379-00055775": "in straight lines and keep them evenly spaced because we're going to borrow", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00092-00055775-00056462": "data from adjacent transects. If we wobble too", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00093-00056462-00056917": "much we're gonna create our own artifacts. We're basically going", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00094-00056917-00057730": "to see some errors in the data if we do that. The internet also has to maintain constant", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00095-00057730-00058244": "contact with the ground surface. I can't pick up and go over something and resume.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00096-00058244-00058973": "Unless I make a note of it my observations notebook that'd be that", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00097-00058973-00059369": "part of the transect will have to be ignored because they won't actually show", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00098-00059369-00060377": "what's below the surface. So are these different depths? Yeah (inaudible) so this is a data set looking at different depths.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00099-00060377-00060955": "This is a project, the Vallejo Petaluma Adobe. You are", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00100-00060955-00061541": "familiar with this one having done the magnetometry work out there. This", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00101-00061541-00061991": "is over in Petaluma and it's one of the largest standing", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00102-00061991-00062585": "historical Adobe structures in North America I believe. In the past there", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00103-00062585-00063209": "was a southern part of the adobe, and our work with between Cal, Sonoma", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00104-00063209-00063991": "State and California State Parks was to characterize the foundation of the adobe", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00105-00063991-00064403": "that's no longer there. One question was", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00106-00064403-00064691": "whether or not there was a roof over the adobe. I can come back to that a", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00107-00064691-00065041": "little bit later because we've got some information about that based on our GPR", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00108-00065041-00065501": "survey. Just to show you how it works, these slice maps that are made up of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00109-00065501-00066050": "individual transects and processed together with the software that we use, show us", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00110-00066050-00066461": "what things look like below the surface at different depths. Again, we are", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00111-00066461-00066854": "looking at the magnitude of reflections, high amplitude or low amplitude", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00112-00066854-00067115": "reflections, of materials that are down below. In", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00113-00067115-00067637": "different materials, whether it's an adobe brick or a stone or just the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00114-00067637-00068060": "native soil surrounding, have different magnitudes and their reflection based on", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00115-00068060-00068795": "how quickly they conduct electromagnetic waves. As we go down in depth, 25", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00116-00068795-00069413": "to 45 centimeters, you can begin to see a rectangular feature. This is 20", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00117-00069413-00069899": "meters, and this is 20 yards by 65 feet across right here. So it's a pretty", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00118-00069899-00070322": "big area as you can see in this Google Earth aerial image. Those are cars", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00119-00070322-00071102": "parked down there for scale. You can see that this is a pretty big grid. This is a", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00120-00071102-00071429": "little bit larger coverage than the grids that are in the slice map. This", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00121-00071429-00071882": "is just partial, but as we get down to 55 centimeters we've got a very distinct", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00122-00071882-00072290": "rectilinear feature here. What we have are the external walls of the Adobe,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00123-00072290-00072815": "then some internal walls, other blocks and then probably some features that", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00124-00072815-00073364": "were inside the courtyard and inside the structure itself. So this was the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00125-00073364-00073937": "planned addition that never got built? So we can expect it had the similar shape", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00126-00073937-00074519": "to the other half right? It sure seems to have been a reflection. It would have", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00127-00074519-00075044": "been a square when it was done. We know", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00128-00075044-00075386": "that the foundation was there and that some walls were built, but we don't know", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00129-00075386-00075913": "if it ever had a roof. That's one of the questions I'll come back to in a minute. mm-hmm.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00130-00075913-00076358": "Let me just take a moment to remind everyone that if you'd like to ask us", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00131-00076358-00076730": "questions. If you'd like to send Scott a question here about ground-penetrating", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00132-00076730-00077636": "radar, you can go to to the website SLI.DO and put in ASKARF.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00133-00077636-00078233": "Then you can put it put a question to Scott either anonymously or", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00134-00078233-00079103": "you can put in your name and we will share it with him. Thanks, go on Scott. So", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00135-00079103-00079757": "several Cal projects have taken place at California Mission Adobe's or Adobe", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00136-00079757-00080188": "era villages. In particular, we've been interested in looking at", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00137-00080188-00080798": "the structures that are no longer present on the surface. Some of the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00138-00080798-00081248": "historical Adobe's like Sanchez Adobe are still standing. In other cases there", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00139-00081248-00081604": "were Native American villages that were adjacent that were made from smaller", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00140-00081604-00082116": "adobe walls. We're very interested in the history of those places especially.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00141-00082116-00082927": "We've really expanded the methodology for understanding Adobe", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00142-00082927-00083500": "structures with remote sensing. In a lot of cases, archaeologists have had", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00143-00083500-00084041": "difficulty identifying them but our techniques are showing pretty clearly", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00144-00084041-00084479": "the foundations of Adobe's at several sites. In some cases, we're looking at the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00145-00084479-00085129": "sandstone blocks themselves. The San Juan Bautista, even in 1856, it was a ruin that", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00146-00085129-00085666": "was collapsing. There wasn't much left of this from this native family housing", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00147-00085666-00086200": "that was built around 1820, I believe. Our affiliate, Glen", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00148-00086200-00087004": "Ferris, took the lead on this project. We did the GPR there in 2015, I", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00149-00087004-00087577": "believe. Here's where the transect crosses to the Adobe wall and outside of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00150-00087577-00088333": "the wall. We believe that these are a series of the posts that were put in to support the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00151-00088333-00088754": "roof because the roof has to extend beyond the Adobe's. This is", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00152-00088754-00089101": "what the site looks like today. There's no evidence of the Adobe on the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00153-00089101-00089680": "surface but you can see it in the the GPR data. If we go back to the Sanchez", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00154-00089680-00090400": "Adobe, you can see those posts and the extending roof that overhangs. And to go", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00155-00090400-00090829": "back to the Vallejo Adobe, that was one of the questions they had for us when", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00156-00090829-00091345": "starting this project - was there any evidence of the roof having", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00157-00091345-00092185": "extended beyond the wall. We don't see those in the grid at the Vallejo Adobe. They", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00158-00092185-00092941": "probably didn't ever complete that part of the building. Just a couple of other examples of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00159-00092941-00093354": "places that we've done work on Adobe's. I wanted to ask,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00160-00093420-00093954": "on that previous slide it looks like you have a historic", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00161-00093954-00094785": "map of a block (inaudible), and are you able to use these historic maps to help locate old", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00162-00094785-00095442": "walls? Often we do. Yeah. We have some information but again with the Mission", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00163-00095442-00095913": "Adobe's, we have the best information about the most well known structures.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00164-00095913-00096332": "We typically don't know that much about, for example, the Native American villages", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00165-00096332-00096869": "that were adjacent to the mission compounds. So sometimes we're going with", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00166-00096869-00097431": "with known maps. In this case, these were commissioned by the mission itself - to be", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00167-00097431-00097872": "built. So we do have some records but Glenn was able to draw up this diagram", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00168-00097872-00098357": "based on his archival research. Then an archaeological test trench and some", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00169-00098357-00098700": "probing with the rod that determined where some of the stones were. Then we", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00170-00098700-00099212": "confirmed its characteristics with the GPR. Then we were able to locate and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00171-00099212-00099981": "identify the posts outside the structure as well. mm-hmm. We have a viewer question", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00172-00099981-00100410": "here. They want to know if you can find burials or skeletons with this", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00173-00100410-00101349": "technology? It really depends on the situation, I would say in in many cases", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00174-00101349-00101873": "historical cemeteries from the last couple of hundred years, we are able to see", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00175-00101873-00102273": "where the graves are located, especially the grave pits.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00176-00102273-00102774": "If the coffin was very substantial and certainly if there's any metal involved", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00177-00102774-00103479": "in its construction, we'll be able to see that typically. Often, we just see the pit", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00178-00103479-00104054": "itself and we don't see the contents too clearly, especially if it's", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00179-00104054-00104601": "just bones, deteriorated clothing, a pine box or something.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00180-00104601-00105416": "Bones don't typically show up very well but the pit itself does. If", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00181-00105416-00105884": "there's an excavation that needs to happen at that location, the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00182-00105884-00106365": "archaeologists typically follows with probing to determine what's in the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00183-00106365-00106753": "pit after I've determined where the pit is with", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00184-00106753-00107409": "GPR. So it looks like you're showing us a profile showing a void? So", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00185-00107409-00107869": "this is perhaps what these pin this look like? Yeah, actually if there is a coffin", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00186-00107869-00108556": "with an intact top, it would look a little bit like this does right here", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00187-00108556-00109171": "with the void underneath. This is a void and a cavern location just to show how", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00188-00109171-00109903": "we can locate tunnels and culverts. This would have had a reinforced roof on it", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00189-00109903-00110433": "which may provide you more reflection as well, right? Yeah, you can see the stonework", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00190-00110433-00111133": "that's in an archway here. That's pretty typical in some of these older catacomb", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00191-00111133-00111864": "type features. mm-hmm. Another setting where we've done several Cal projects,", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00192-00111864-00112659": "Dr. Kent Lightfoot, has led extensive research at Fort Ross. We've done", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00193-00112659-00113281": "several GPR projects since 2012 out there. This is probably the remains of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00194-00113281-00113749": "the flagpole pit in the center of the stockade. We identified as one example", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00195-00113749-00114256": "that's another GPR profile. Yeah Professor Lightfoot will be speaking", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00196-00114256-00116783": "with us later this week, I think Thursday or Friday. What did you find there? You were looking for a flagpole you said? Yeah, actually Glen Ferris formerly the head archeologist for California State Parks and now our affiliate was interested in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00197-00116783-00117378": "locating the historic flag pole location from that would have been put in around", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00198-00117378-00118072": "1817 based on sketches and his assessment of the archival materials. He", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00199-00118072-00118519": "thought it was within this area. He made a small grid about four by four", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00200-00118519-00118993": "meters. So within the center of the stockade, actually wasn't exactly in the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00201-00118993-00119602": "center it was offset a bit, but we ran a series of transects within that small", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00202-00119602-00120111": "grid and found a pit just about where he had put his wooden stake", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00203-00120111-00120508": "where he estimated it to be. There hasn't been any subsequent excavation but I", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00204-00120508-00120907": "think eventually there's a plan to test that and see if that's actually", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00205-00120907-00121638": "what it is. In other cases, we've looked at the Russian cemetery from were the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00206-00121638-00122409": "officers and and traders were buried and identified graves that weren't", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00207-00122409-00123111": "previously known about, for preservation that's just for monumental purposes.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00208-00123111-00123628": "Our next project involves looking at the village that was outside the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00209-00123628-00124471": "stockade. Where Russians were intermarried with Pomo native women.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00210-00124471-00125265": "There was a village there outside to the west or northwest of the stockade.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00211-00125265-00125773": "Unfortunately from my perspective, there was a ranch that was built on top", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00212-00125773-00126163": "of it, the Call Ranch, so I'll have to be differentiating ranching era features", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00213-00126163-00126633": "from the village but that's also what the archaeologists on the project and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00214-00126633-00126970": "other archaeologists will be focusing on through their excavations. They are able", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00215-00126970-00127777": "to do those. mm-hmm. So with GPR is there interference from other", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00216-00127777-00128409": "things in the area? I know that with magnetometry, you have to be very", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00217-00128409-00128932": "careful about the presence of ferrous objects, old plows, nails. It seems like", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00218-00128932-00129727": "GPR is more tolerant of noise? Yeah it does pretty well around metal. Let's see, if I'm going", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00219-00129727-00130495": "up against the metal metal chain-link fence or sheet metal that's nearby, I", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00220-00130495-00130966": "can get some reflections off of that but I could generally still get good data.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00221-00130966-00131389": "The only problem is if I'm having to go over metal. I won't be able to get much", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00222-00131389-00131926": "radar data through it. Actually within Fort Ross, State Parks has put", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00223-00131926-00132478": "down a mesh grid to protect their paths from being dug up by", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00224-00132478-00133078": "rodents - Gophers for example. I don't get any data when I go over those", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00225-00133078-00133484": "pathways. Elsewhere I can go over concrete or asphalt and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00226-00133484-00133874": "get really good data through as long as there's not too much rebar in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00227-00133874-00134801": "the concrete. But metal mesh and sheet metal things like that really just", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00228-00134801-00135230": "prevent me from seeing just straight through it but I'm not usually affected", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00229-00135230-00135950": "by nearby metal. I know if you've used this in beach settings to find", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00230-00135950-00136523": "things buried in the sand. Are there issues with being near the ocean? There", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00231-00136523-00137072": "are you can get quite a bit of information from the upper portion of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00232-00137072-00137657": "the beach. Sand is actually an ideal situation for doing GPR but once you get", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00233-00137657-00137984": "into an area where there's saltwater intrusion, which is going to happen", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00234-00137984-00138335": "before you start to see the moisture on the surface or where the waves are", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00235-00138335-00139013": "heading, the salt keeps the radar from being informative because the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00236-00139013-00139538": "salt crystals are basically sending the radar energy away from the instrument and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00237-00139538-00140249": "not reflecting it back. mm-hmm. We call that attenuation. Let me take a moment to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00238-00140249-00140866": "remind everyone that if you want to send us questions, you can go to SLI.DO and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00239-00140866-00141358": "type in ASKARF and write questions to Scott. We have about", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00240-00141358-00142010": "five or six more minutes, so there's still time to feel some", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00241-00142010-00142403": "questions. We have one that just came in from SLI.DO. They want to know similar to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00242-00142403-00142727": "what I was just asking - are there side effects or downsides or limitations to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00243-00142727-00143114": "this technology? I know that you need to contact the ground really well, right so", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00244-00143114-00144482": "maybe vegetation is an issue? Yeah, those are the sorts of limitations. You want a relatively smooth ground surface. This site that we're looking at here, the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00245-00144482-00144959": "curve is a little bit of an issue as far as running transects across it and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00246-00144959-00145427": "then of course this eroding path. It's a recreation area on the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00247-00145427-00145832": "coast but there's a shell mineral layer and you can see how well the layers show", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00248-00145832-00146462": "up down below.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00249-00146462-00146924": "If I go up and over a curve, then the radar data is gonna", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00250-00146924-00147410": "show an artificial fit because I'm basically going up and away from what's", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00251-00147410-00148010": "below and then can coming back down to it. So a nice smooth surface. You're not", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00252-00148010-00148442": "always going to get that at every archaeological site, especially an area", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00253-00148442-00148874": "big enough to do a grid. We're often confined and where we can put up grids", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00254-00148874-00149393": "based on that. There might be side effects in terms of", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00255-00149393-00149822": "like the people sometimes ask about radiation. It's radar energy. It's", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00256-00149822-00150476": "not electromagnetic energy. So it's radio waves basically. It's basically", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00257-00150476-00151661": "like cellphone energy. I assume you have to go around objects like you", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00258-00151661-00152261": "know poison oak bushes or trees. Say, you'll have a divergence from", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00259-00152261-00152836": "your grid Then you have to kind of deal with that in the interpretation?", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00260-00152836-00153403": "Yeah, and if we can use", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00261-00153403-00154463": "high-precision GPS, RTK GPS in real time, then we can have a gap in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00262-00154463-00154787": "the middle of the grid and it's not a big deal, but for the processing it's", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00263-00154787-00155474": "best to have the entire rectangle filled, adjacent transects.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00264-00155474-00155996": "In order to make that cut that slice cut? Yeah.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00265-00155996-00156833": "This is where my teenage sons are helpful for doing some clearance brush", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00266-00156833-00157187": "before we're actually out there gathering data.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00267-00157187-00157676": "You know we're often out there with our gardening tools, smoothing things off just", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00268-00157676-00158276": "to make it just the right. So we get the best data. How did you get", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00269-00158276-00159866": "into this technology? Was it difficult to get the background and learn it? Do you need to know a lot about geology or soils to know properly how to use this instrument? Yeah, I think it was really helpful but coming into this. I", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00270-00159866-00160721": "started doing GPR, well 2005 was my first project, but I didn't really do it in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00271-00160721-00161587": "earnest as my main focus within archeology until about ten years ago.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00272-00161587-00161999": "Prior to that, I'd had an extensive experience on excavations and I was", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00273-00161999-00162389": "really familiar with excavating sites in a lot of different environments in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00274-00162389-00162923": "California and Oregon. That's really helpful, that information I mean. I can't", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00275-00162923-00163358": "really envision going straight into doing GPR and archaeology without having", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00276-00163358-00163838": "a fair amount of experience at different types of archaeological sites. Knowing geo-", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00277-00163838-00164945": "archaeology is really great to understand the GPR data. Yeah, I", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00278-00164945-00165401": "think understanding stratigraphy, different types of soils and their", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00279-00165401-00165953": "properties, and of course, understanding the variation in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00280-00165953-00166493": "archaeological features. What a privy feature or you know the pit underneath", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00281-00166493-00167027": "an outhouse looks like a hundred years after it's been buried. That's", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00282-00167027-00167809": "something that you know from excavation typically translating that into", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00283-00167809-00168509": "assessment of a GPR profile. It takes a fair amount of that experience.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00284-00168509-00169211": "mm-hmm. We have a question. Somebody wants to know about the most exciting", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00285-00169211-00169525": "discovery you've made with this technology?", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00286-00169525-00170546": "hmm. Well there's been a lot of great ones. One site that I found", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00287-00170546-00171178": "with GPR that I think is pretty special. We wrote it up in the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00288-00171178-00171788": "ArcheologicalResearch Facility series. In the book, Triangulating", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00289-00171788-00172286": "Archeological Landscapes. Camp Castaway is the name of the site. it's on the", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00290-00172286-00172739": "Oregon coast actually in the dunes. Not in this study, but in a real wide open", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00291-00172739-00173555": "dune area. It was a camp that was formed in 1852 when soldiers from Benicia down", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00292-00173555-00173966": "here were on their way to Port Orford in Oregon. They got caught in a storm", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00293-00173966-00174506": "and their ship wrecked on the beach in Oregon. They formed a military camp", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00294-00174506-00175025": "for four months and they traded with Coos tribe locally and were able to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00295-00175025-00175367": "sustain themselves through those months until the end of winter. They", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00296-00175367-00175721": "salvaged the cargo of the ship and then finally were able to take it down to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00297-00175721-00176180": "Port Orford which was about 50 miles to the south. I was able to use GPR and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00298-00176180-00176648": "relocate that camp which people had thought had been washed to", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00299-00176648-00177284": "sea a hundred years ago. It hasn't been seen in over 100 almost 150 years but", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00300-00177284-00177734": "the radar showed me buried iron rods and things. Of course, in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00301-00177734-00178496": "that case, I used archival maps, historic maps, were really key in going back and", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00302-00178496-00178958": "relocating that. Luckily the US Coast Survey had done some fantastic", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00303-00178958-00179407": "mapping of that coastline. Just like what they have out around San Francisco Bay", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00304-00179407-00180605": "back in the 1850s. Sounds like an exciting find. I guess you didn't run into the problem of saltwater there", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00305-00180605-00180968": "because you were high enough on the dunes? That's right.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00306-00180968-00181385": "Although, I did do some transects down towards the beach looking for the actual", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00307-00181385-00181785": "shipwreck itself. Often the ships have ballast in them.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00308-00181785-00182277": "We might be able to identify but if that's in the intertidal zone, then I'm", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00309-00182277-00182634": "probably not gonna see it because of the saltwater. I didn't see any evidence", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00310-00182634-00183123": "of the ship itself. Most of the ship was taken apart for building", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00311-00183123-00183767": "that camp. mm-hmm. All right, well that's about all", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00312-00183767-00184257": "the time we have. So I want to thank you Scott for joining us on Ask an", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00313-00184257-00184761": "Archeologist. I want to thank the listeners and the viewers who sent in", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00314-00184761-00185400": "questions. I'd like to invite listeners to our next Ask an", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00315-00185400-00185804": "Archeologist. I'll be speaking with Professor Kim Shelton from the Classics", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00316-00185804-00186103": "Department this afternoon.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00317-00186223-00186616": "You know, 2:00 p.m. She's presenting on the topic of digging up ancient here", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00318-00186616-00187021": "heroes of ancient Greece. So please join us at 2 p.m.", "oT4MAQsrRvE-00319-00187021-00187596": "Thanks again, Scott it's great talking to you. Thanks, go bears!"}}, {"audio_id": "oTADYD7XnJc", "text": {"oTADYD7XnJc-00000-00000050-00015400": "If you were in Paris and filmed on a camera or smartphone on its streets, you can open a store on Etsy for the sale of these photos. Photos of Parisian streets here very well buy. One American did so. I went to Paris, took a lot of pictures and now sells them in my store. Etsy.com/shop/TheParisPrintShop She sells the photos in a printed (not digital) form. The price depends on the size. This photo (and many others) is sold at a price of 12 dollars (photo size - 12x18 cm) to 116 dollars (with the photo size - 60x75 cm). Parisian streets are beautiful even in cloudy weather. Where without the Eiffel Tower. Lucky Paris and its residents (if they knew that they can earn this way!). After all, what's so unusual about such pictures? Simple windows of city houses. And people buy them for 12-116 dollars. Although people buy not only photos of streets, but also photos of graffiti on the walls of houses. So if you are going to visit Paris, do not be lazy and take some beautiful pictures. And do not forget to specify the key phrase \"Paris Photography\" in their headings when registering your listings."}}, {"audio_id": "oTGD4Z4IvYY", "text": {"oTGD4Z4IvYY-00000-00002204-00002704": "A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away....", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00001-00013308-00013480": "Commander, the entrance seems to be deserted!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00002-00013480-00014247": "Okay, then we will go into the base and distract the guards, and you two go into the main storage to steal the freights.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00003-00014263-00014552": "Yes, we should take that ventilation shaft down there!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00004-00014706-00015019": "Sir, there were complications at the west entrance of the base.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00005-00015032-00015450": "Well, that's strange! Send my troops to check the area!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00006-00015450-00015650": "Yes sir!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00007-00015650-00016184": "Well gentlemen, I have to go to get my shuttle for Coruscant. Have fun guards, bye!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00008-00016213-00016308": "Okay sir!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00009-00016752-00017038": "Did you hear that? What was that?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00010-00017038-00017238": "Of course, but what the hell that was?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00011-00017238-00017638": "Hello", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00012-00017638-00017838": "Hello...............what! Aaargh", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00013-00018270-00018462": "Hands up, you rebel scum!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00014-00018634-00018724": "STORMTROOPERS!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00015-00018724-00018822": "Your report?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00016-00018822-00019346": "Hmmm, yes it's not very good, because the rebels stole our freights from the main storage", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00017-00019346-00019656": "Damn it, I can't accept this!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00018-00019676-00019910": "But it is exactly how he reported to you sir, you can trust us!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00019-00019910-00020110": "Then chase them!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00020-00020110-00020462": "Yes, but the problem is that we cannot find the rebels in our area.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00021-00020462-00020762": "Then search these rebels you two bastards!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00022-00020762-00021312": "Okay, my apologies, sir. Maybe you should just relax!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00023-00021654-00022006": "Please don't, we can talk about it, but...", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00024-00022006-00022352": "There is no but, you are all failures!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00025-00022364-00022624": "Sir, but we do all what we can!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00026-00022624-00023154": "Stop! Stop it now, or we are allowed to execute you immediately.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00027-00023154-00023402": "In the name of the galactic empire, you are under arrest!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00028-00023402-00023594": "Now it is too much, dieeeeee!!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00029-00023606-00023656": "Open fire!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00030-00023858-00024296": "And now I want these rebels, send out the interceptors!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00031-00024296-00024382": "Yes, Sir!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00032-00024384-00024584": "Good, continue!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00033-00024718-00025382": "Yes I would say.....start the interceptors guys... We have to blast some rebels!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00034-00025712-00026210": "Colonel, I have here an order from Commander Pravus to start all fighters!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00035-00026210-00026598": "Okay, thanks. Start all fighters, we will obliterate their ships in the air!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00036-00029414-00029956": "Sir, the rebels are gone. We cannot find them!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00037-00029956-00030686": "This is a very unfortunate message. Prepare my shuttle, I want to tell Lord Vader how incompetent our commander is!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00038-00031188-00031374": "Commander Pravus, Sir?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00039-00031374-00031424": "Yes?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00040-00031424-00031624": "Lord Vader is contacting you, he don't want to wait any longer!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00041-00031624-00031942": "I want to talk with him in my personal chambers! Thank you.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00042-00031942-00032142": "No problem, Sir.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00043-00032826-00033376": "My disappointment about your failure cannot be more bigger than now!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00044-00033378-00033578": "How do you explain this?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00045-00033632-00034682": "I do not really know what my mistake was. I did everything I could, but my predecessor was not brave enough to stop the rebels.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00046-00034682-00035694": "Also they got the plans of the base, but I really don't know.......why I have to talk to you now?!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00047-00035694-00035956": "Spare yourself the whole, Commander.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00048-00035956-00036692": "All I ask is that you go to Coruscant and give a statement to the Senate!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00049-00036716-00037254": "That is my last word, Commander Pravus!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00050-00037380-00037580": "Damn it!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00051-00037766-00038042": "Prepare my ship!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00052-00038148-00038594": "Contact, encrypted frequency. 2187", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00053-00038646-00039442": "Ah, Pravus. Nice to see you again! What's the reason why you contact me?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00054-00039442-00040582": "Indeed I have only a little issue. I believe that you could contact a sympathisant of the rebels for me.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00055-00040582-00041198": "Of course! But I really hope that you will pay a good price for this!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00056-00041198-00042040": "Yess....You will get the money you deserve! See you on Coruscant!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00057-00042040-00042822": "I really hope you do not forget to check the fuel of your ship, that would be very bad for my price, if you do not arrive here!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00058-00042822-00043022": "So funny!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00059-00046302-00046636": "Follow me, Commander Pravus!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00060-00048060-00048260": "Commander Pravus?!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00061-00048318-00048938": "What the hell you doing here? It's to dangerous to enter the area! Don't you know what could happen here?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00062-00048938-00049594": "I have not much time to explain, take the next shuttle to Mos Eisley and go to Jabba's Palace!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00063-00049594-00049794": "Our contact is Sir Smice.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00064-00049794-00050060": "Go to him and tell him your issue!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00065-00050060-00050662": "He have contact to the rebel fleet, but now I don't really have much time left. Do you understand?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00066-00050662-00051210": "Of course I understand, but now get the hell out of here before someone kill you!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00067-00051210-00051938": "They saw me, that's not the problem. Give me my money after your trip, but at last I have to say:", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00068-00051938-00052138": "May the force be with you!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00069-00052567-00054294": "Pass please, pass please, pass please....", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00070-00054294-00054594": "I don't think this is necessary!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00071-00054594-00054964": "Excuse me, what can I do for you?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00072-00054964-00055405": "I need a shuttle to Mos Eisley!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00073-00055405-00055826": "Ah okay! The next shuttle starts at landing platform 94!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00074-00055826-00056155": "Okay thank you! I will take this now!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00075-00056155-00056355": "Enjoy your flight!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00076-00056355-00056555": "Thank you!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00077-00056588-00056667": "Pass please!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00078-00059844-00060044": "Sir Smice, where he is?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00079-00061576-00061984": "Excuse me, are you \"Sir Smice?\"", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00080-00061984-00062122": "Who want to know this?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00081-00062122-00062322": "I want to know this!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00082-00062322-00062522": "What the hell you want?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00083-00062522-00062855": "Something special. Trust me!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00084-00062855-00063144": "Give me a reason to trust you!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00085-00063144-00063822": "Listen to me. You can trust me! I do not want to be an imperial officer any longer!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00086-00063822-00064244": "It's impossible. The discussion ends now. My rebel friends are in the desert!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00087-00064260-00064682": "I know that you know me from, Duro you must know him.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00088-00064708-00064908": "He died before my arrival.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00089-00064948-00065148": "But, THERE IS SOMETHING BEHIND YOU!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00090-00065604-00065804": "ENOUGH!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00091-00066960-00067300": "Jabba. You dumb creature of a worm of gangster. You damn hutt!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00092-00067742-00068214": "Stop! My congratulations that we don't want to kill you like the hutts. Follow me!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00093-00070754-00070954": "I'm Admiral Raddus, leader of this rebel group.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00094-00071034-00071234": "And what's your name?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00095-00071234-00071434": "I'm Commander Pravus", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00096-00071434-00072350": "Ah Okay, Pravus. I heard that you want to join us, but why?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00097-00072456-00073038": "I'm here because I want to free the galaxy from the Empire!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00098-00073038-00073238": "Because of one reason!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00099-00073238-00073684": "The empire took my family away from me, and I could't realize this.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00100-00073684-00074142": "I was well programmed by the Empire, to work for them.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00101-00074142-00074760": "And you can trust me from the deepest part of my heart that I'm telling the truth, really!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00102-00074760-00074960": "If he says the truth, we must move quickly!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00103-00074960-00075438": "Admiral, you can not be so naive as to trust an imperial officer!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00104-00075438-00076340": "Yes I know, but if he says the truth we cannot wait any longer. Don't you understand?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00105-00076340-00077454": "If they know that I'm talking to you or trying to act with you. They will kill me and I do not know how cruel.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00106-00077454-00077952": "I believe Lord Vader knows everything in my mind.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00107-00077952-00078770": "We...I need your help, the entire galaxy need your help. And believe you fight against this!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00108-00078770-00079830": "For freedom, against the Emperor and for the history of all.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00109-00079862-00080710": "I just hope that it is how I told. And we must work together, Admiral Raddus!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00110-00083134-00083334": "Oh damn!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00111-00083476-00083672": "Do you have an landing permit, Commander?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00112-00083682-00083882": "I don't need one!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00113-00083940-00084238": "I really hope that the Empire will eventually disappear!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00114-00084238-00084438": "Oh it is so nice here!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00115-00084438-00084488": "So.....arghhh", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00116-00085408-00085546": "Can I help you?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00117-00085548-00085634": "That won't be necessary!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00118-00085764-00085814": "What the hell?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00119-00088042-00088190": "Special Team, Advance!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00120-00088544-00088676": "There, this way!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00121-00088896-00089214": "The rebels overwhelm our troops on the surface!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00122-00089214-00089414": "Prepare my fighter!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00123-00089414-00089548": "Of course, my Lord!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00124-00089698-00090296": "Me and the special team will attach the detonators to the plasma hoses and power cables.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00125-00090296-00091144": "It's important to turn off all stormtroopers! Because most of them fight outside, we do not have much difficulty!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00126-00091144-00091798": "When you reach the main reactor, attach all the detonators and leave immediately. Good luck, we meet again here!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00127-00092500-00092584": "Clean Sir!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00128-00093428-00093628": "It's time to wipe out this traitor!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00129-00093942-00094142": "The detonators are activated!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00130-00094142-00094250": "Good!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00131-00094260-00094398": "Let's get the hell out here!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00132-00095470-00095908": "Now it's a good question to get out of here if we do not want to get shot by the stormtroopers!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00133-00095978-00096228": "The transport boxes, take one and hide inside!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00134-00096360-00096610": "Why you are so sure that we can escape with them?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00135-00096610-00097094": "I hope they transport the chests to a shuttle that will take us to the Star Destroyer!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00136-00097142-00097518": "Do not you think that would be a bit risky?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00137-00097518-00097804": "We take that risk now. No risk no fun!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00138-00097804-00097908": "The stormtroopers coming!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00139-00097908-00098108": "Just a moment, I don't think so!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00140-00098444-00098494": "Open Fire!!!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00141-00098668-00098718": "Shoot him!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00142-00105883-00106083": "We must bring him into his chamber!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00143-00106100-00106578": "Welcome Lord Vader, it seems you have absolutely failed!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00144-00107185-00107700": "Oh, in a moment this execution will begin. And we have no break!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00145-00107700-00108282": "Yes, that's true, every time these pointless and boring events took place, the Academy was absolutely better!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00146-00108380-00108646": "So it is, but pssssss", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00147-00108732-00109066": "Pointless comments may not count here!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00148-00109214-00109596": "Can you please continue your work and stop talking!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00149-00109596-00109796": "All systems are prepared.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00150-00109796-00109996": "Functional and full operational!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00151-00110088-00110544": "That sounds good, tell Governeur Tarkin that everything is prepared!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00152-00110652-00110754": "With plesure!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00153-00115148-00115548": "MEMBERS OF THE EMPIRE!!!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00154-00115635-00115835": "THE TIME HAS COME!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00155-00115835-00116035": "TO DESTROY THE TRAITORS AND TERRORISTS WHICH TRY TO DESTROY THE EMPIRE!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00156-00116035-00116904": "YOUR HIGHNESS EMPEROR PALPATINE, ORGANIZED AN VERY IMPORTANT AND SPECIAL SHOW TO CELEBRATE THIS DAY!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00157-00116926-00117452": "KEEP YOUR EYES OPEN TO SEE THE EXECUTION OF THOSE FOOLS WITH OUR NEW WEAPON!!!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00158-00118764-00119180": "Captain, if you here me you must land immediately on the Planet!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00159-00119338-00119538": "Copy that sir!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00160-00125970-00127150": "Your fleet is lost, it seems that there is no escape! Rebels!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00161-00127150-00127496": "Our canon will execute you now, last words left?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00162-00127496-00127552": "No!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00163-00127626-00127882": "Okay, no! Continue your program!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00164-00128064-00128342": "Seriously! You cannot do this to us!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00165-00128342-00129026": "Oh, you're wrong, we can! And now command primary ignition. You may fire when ready!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00166-00130218-00130309": "Open fire!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00167-00130404-00130476": "Yes sir!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00168-00132056-00132112": "Kill him!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00169-00133258-00133336": "Now!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00170-00134882-00135838": "I call that, salvation at the last moment. If you had not been there, no one would live and the Empire would have won again!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00171-00135922-00136676": "But I think we've brought the Empire one step closer to the end today.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00172-00141200-00141400": "Welcome my Lord!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00173-00141400-00141600": "I hope that your arrival was excellent.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00174-00141600-00141982": "Yes Vanee, everything is alright!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00175-00142116-00142448": "Very good, can Ido something for you?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00176-00142496-00143358": "I want Boba Fett and other bounty hunters here immediately, did you understand. I have a mission for them!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00177-00143390-00143590": "Of Course my Lord!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00178-00145328-00145568": "My Lord, the bounty hunters you wanted!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00179-00145580-00145780": "Okay, now I don't need you any longer today!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00180-00145804-00146004": "Thank you my Lord.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00181-00146610-00146810": "Good afternoon, Gentlemen!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00182-00146810-00147010": "From far away!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00183-00147184-00147488": "I believe that you know why you're here!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00184-00147522-00147722": "I have a mission for you, including a good price!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00185-00147866-00148294": "I am looking for a former imperial officer, his name is Pravus ....", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00186-00148294-00148694": "And I want him alive!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00187-00148694-00149076": "His rebel crew you can destroy, but not him!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00188-00149076-00149848": "That sounds very good Lord Vader, but I really hope that the price is good!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00189-00149848-00150200": "Do you understand, I want 1 million credits!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00190-00150200-00151302": "You're absolutly right, but if you don't want to choose the mission I gave you, you can leave the castle immediately!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00191-00151432-00152074": "As you wish, but if Iargghhhhh", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00192-00152718-00153010": "That is your price, bounty hunter!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00193-00154344-00154760": "I apologize for any inconvenience", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00194-00154760-00155128": "I really believe that all of you understand the situation.", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00195-00155174-00155374": "So, are you ready?", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00196-00155374-00155574": "I will not disappoint you!", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00197-00155578-00155862": "We will do the job to their satisfaction, Lord Vader", "oTGD4Z4IvYY-00198-00155992-00156370": "Good, then proceed to act !"}}, {"audio_id": "oU0fYODn3f4", "text": {"oU0fYODn3f4-00000-00000000-00000556": "thank you for being here I just tell you very briefly about the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00001-00000556-00001409": "panelists who we have today and who you'll be talking to. So um the first", "oU0fYODn3f4-00002-00001409-00001800": "person is that you're speaking to is me. Nice to meet everyone um I'm the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00003-00001800-00002322": "public lead for Creative Commons USA and I'm a lawyer who works on issues related", "oU0fYODn3f4-00004-00002322-00002880": "to copyright fair use Creative Commons licenses and open education program and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00005-00002880-00003246": "information justice and intellectual property at American University", "oU0fYODn3f4-00006-00003246-00004182": "Washington College of Law I'm joined by my colleague Peter Jaszi who is a professor emeritus of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00007-00004182-00004542": "copyright law at American University where he helped found the Glushko", "oU0fYODn3f4-00008-00004542-00005003": "Samuelson intellectual property clinic and the program on Information justice and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00009-00005003-00005828": "intellectual property he's an expert on copyright law and fair use and a leader", "oU0fYODn3f4-00010-00005828-00006203": "of our ongoing project work with communities to draft best practices in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00011-00006203-00006750": "fair use including for the oer community I'm also joined by Michael Carroll a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00012-00006750-00007154": "professor of law and the director of PIJIP he teaches and writes about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00013-00007154-00007575": "intellectual property law and cyber law and is one of the founding directors for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00014-00007575-00007995": "Creative Commons and his work is generally on copyright in the digital", "oU0fYODn3f4-00015-00007995-00008372": "world I'm also joined by Prue Adler who currently works with us at the Law", "oU0fYODn3f4-00016-00008372-00008822": "School on our best practices work prior to that she was the associate executive", "oU0fYODn3f4-00017-00008822-00009140": "director of the Marrakesh treaty an international copyright", "oU0fYODn3f4-00018-00009140-00009567": "sorry -she was the associate executive director of the association of research", "oU0fYODn3f4-00019-00009567-00010125": "libraries and at ARL she worked on the Marrakesh treaty an international", "oU0fYODn3f4-00020-00010125-00010436": "copyright treaty to facilitate access to published works for people who were", "oU0fYODn3f4-00021-00010436-00011028": "blind visually impaired or otherwise print disabled we also have well cross", "oU0fYODn3f4-00022-00011028-00011457": "who is the director of copyright and digital scholarship and the copyright in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00023-00011457-00011921": "digital scholarship Center at the NC State University Libraries and we our", "oU0fYODn3f4-00024-00011921-00012393": "research fellow he's trained as a lawyer and librarian and is a collaborator in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00025-00012393-00012866": "our project to create this best practices for oer we have Prenille Ripp ban", "oU0fYODn3f4-00026-00012866-00013337": "expert in literacy and technology integration whose research is dedicated", "oU0fYODn3f4-00027-00013337-00013590": "to developing engaged and empowered students and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00028-00013590-00014043": "communities Prenille is also the founder of the global read aloud and the author", "oU0fYODn3f4-00029-00014043-00014591": "two books passionate readers and passionate learners Carrie Russell is a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00030-00014591-00015005": "senior program director and copyright specialist for the American Library", "oU0fYODn3f4-00031-00015005-00015603": "Association's public policy and advocacy office in Washington DC her policy", "oU0fYODn3f4-00032-00015603-00015981": "portfolio includes copyright licensing and accessibility and she's also the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00033-00015981-00016350": "author of two books copyright and everyday guide for K through 12", "oU0fYODn3f4-00034-00016350-00016787": "librarians and complete copyright an everyday guide for librarians and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00035-00016787-00017295": "finally I'm happy to be joined by Kristina Ishmael who serves as the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00036-00017295-00017580": "senior project manager of the teaching learning and tech team for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00037-00017580-00017979": "the education policy program at New America which allows her to support", "oU0fYODn3f4-00038-00017979-00018303": "states districts and educators and rethinking the role of instructional", "oU0fYODn3f4-00039-00018303-00018648": "materials to create deeper learning opportunities for students before", "oU0fYODn3f4-00040-00018648-00019020": "joining New America Kristina was the K through 12 open education fellow at the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00041-00019020-00019467": "office of ed tech where she developed and grew that go up in movement and I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00042-00019467-00019860": "want to take a moment and thank Kristina and our ongoing partnership", "oU0fYODn3f4-00043-00019860-00020250": "with the education team at new America they've been our longtime collaborators", "oU0fYODn3f4-00044-00020250-00021081": "and without them this project would not be possible so very briefly I'm just going to let", "oU0fYODn3f4-00045-00021081-00021438": "you know we're gonna cover so Mike if you can go ahead to the slide with the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00046-00021438-00021848": "agenda oh so that's been taken out so I'll just let you know what we're gonna", "oU0fYODn3f4-00047-00021848-00022380": "cover and so first we have this introduction we're doing we're going talk a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00048-00022380-00022995": "little bit about why questions about copyright are even sort of in this space", "oU0fYODn3f4-00049-00022995-00023487": "when teachers are trying to make this transition we're gonna hear from Pernille", "oU0fYODn3f4-00050-00023487-00023988": "and Kristina about by reading aloud is a really crucial practice for teaching", "oU0fYODn3f4-00051-00023988-00024405": "and creating educational communities and from Kristina about why in this moment", "oU0fYODn3f4-00052-00024405-00024923": "of transition it's really important to carry those practices forward Peter", "oU0fYODn3f4-00053-00024923-00025407": "is going to talk about the relationship between the long history of reading", "oU0fYODn3f4-00054-00025407-00025851": "aloud and copyright law and we're going to hear from Carrie about specifically", "oU0fYODn3f4-00055-00025851-00026439": "the fair use analysis that goes on in that copyright law Will is going to talk about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00056-00026439-00026752": "questions that come up about how fair use applies and different", "oU0fYODn3f4-00057-00026752-00027233": "technologies and formats and how you can basically think through the same", "oU0fYODn3f4-00058-00027233-00027691": "questions to understand things even though the technological formats seem", "oU0fYODn3f4-00059-00027691-00028118": "really different and then finally I'm going to talk a little bit about some", "oU0fYODn3f4-00060-00028118-00028577": "specific scenarios that have come up over and over again for teachers and how", "oU0fYODn3f4-00061-00028577-00029099": "to think through those in a copyright framework and finally we'll hear a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00062-00029099-00029516": "little bit from Carrie about a sort of bigger perspective of how it's important", "oU0fYODn3f4-00063-00029516-00030062": "to rely on the limitations and exceptions built into the copyright", "oU0fYODn3f4-00064-00030062-00030779": "system to continue providing access to students for whom day-in day-out lack of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00065-00030779-00031298": "access is an ongoing emergency so I hope that's useful will be about an hour and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00066-00031298-00032077": "a half and as we said at the beginning all of the notes sorry all of the links", "oU0fYODn3f4-00067-00032077-00032537": "for the slides and for the recorded webcast and to submit more questions are", "oU0fYODn3f4-00068-00032537-00033179": "in the original document with the guidance and we'll be taking questions", "oU0fYODn3f4-00069-00033179-00033605": "at the end we'll be going over questions at the end so up next we had Professor", "oU0fYODn3f4-00070-00033605-00034169": "Michael Carroll right thank you so much Meredith and hello everyone thanks for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00071-00034169-00034718": "being with us I'm a lawyer and I'm also an educator and I want to talk to you in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00072-00034718-00035141": "both capacities and I've got five minutes so just have a couple of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00073-00035141-00035672": "preliminary things that we need to think about there as a lawyer we think about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00074-00035672-00036083": "what we do and and when we give legal advice it is applying the law in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00075-00036083-00036659": "particular people's facts what what has prompted us to want to do this is there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00076-00036659-00036959": "are a lot of people out there who claim they're not lawyers but then are out", "oU0fYODn3f4-00077-00036959-00037447": "there giving legal advice about how copyright applies to reading aloud in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00078-00037447-00038053": "the online environment and a lot of a lot of that advice is simply wrong and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00079-00038053-00038543": "it's causing turmoil it's causing stress where it doesn't need to be and so as", "oU0fYODn3f4-00080-00038543-00038983": "attorneys were a little bit at a disadvantage because we cannot directly", "oU0fYODn3f4-00081-00038983-00039455": "point to someone applying the law to a particular set of facts it and say", "oU0fYODn3f4-00082-00039455-00040097": "that's wrong but what we can do and and the attorneys on this call have come together", "oU0fYODn3f4-00083-00040097-00040713": "to sort of forcefully put forward legal information and a legal explanation", "oU0fYODn3f4-00084-00040713-00041244": "about how copyright and fair use applies to common educational practices even as", "oU0fYODn3f4-00085-00041244-00041634": "they get translated into the online environment and this legal explanation", "oU0fYODn3f4-00086-00041634-00042150": "is there to provide guidance and confidence that if your practices in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00087-00042150-00042612": "your own classroom in your own teaching is similar to the use cases that we're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00088-00042612-00043002": "discussing then then you have fair use rights and you should feel confident and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00089-00043002-00043449": "this is regardless of what the publishers are saying is permitted or", "oU0fYODn3f4-00090-00043449-00043896": "not because fair use is your right under the copyright law to make uses of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00091-00043896-00044424": "copyright copyrighted material regardless of what the publisher or the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00092-00044424-00045136": "copyright owner wants so think of this as the legal explanation that will tell", "oU0fYODn3f4-00093-00045136-00045522": "you what what the do's and don'ts are and there are a lot of people who want", "oU0fYODn3f4-00094-00045522-00046002": "really bright line really crisp do's and dont's and so when when we tell them", "oU0fYODn3f4-00095-00046002-00046497": "well fair use does a contextual analysis we look at why you're doing what you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00096-00046497-00046797": "doing how you're doing it they don't like that so they make up their own", "oU0fYODn3f4-00097-00046797-00047223": "rules but those are made up rules so what you're going to hear today is what", "oU0fYODn3f4-00098-00047223-00047676": "the law really is and how the law really applies to common educational practices", "oU0fYODn3f4-00099-00047676-00048309": "and how copyright is a more reasonable law than some people presented when on", "oU0fYODn3f4-00100-00048309-00048801": "social media or otherwise you say you can't do this and you can't do that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00101-00048801-00049368": "and so now we will periodically maybe use some qualifying language like it's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00102-00049368-00049980": "probably it's likely I want to be clear that when when we're using that language", "oU0fYODn3f4-00103-00049980-00050526": "it is because we can't predict what each and every use case might be but I don't", "oU0fYODn3f4-00104-00050526-00051018": "think you should take that as any signal of our lack of confidence in the legal", "oU0fYODn3f4-00105-00051018-00051354": "explanation that we're giving you about what fair use permits", "oU0fYODn3f4-00106-00051354-00051819": "we're just hedging on in the sense that we can't predict each and every possible", "oU0fYODn3f4-00107-00051819-00052245": "use and there might be some unforeseen use out there that we're where there'd", "oU0fYODn3f4-00108-00052245-00052624": "be an issue but that's not we're going to we're going to deal with the common", "oU0fYODn3f4-00109-00052624-00053086": "cases and show well why the common cases are perfectly legal and under the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00110-00053086-00053637": "copyright law and part of the and the folks who are saying", "oU0fYODn3f4-00111-00053637-00054033": "you can't do this you can't do that they might have a variety of motivations but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00112-00054033-00054680": "one of the confusions that we've seen in that is that a failure to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00113-00054680-00055128": "understand that there's a big difference between a teacher recording an audio", "oU0fYODn3f4-00114-00055128-00055626": "book and putting it out commercially to you know compete with an existing audio", "oU0fYODn3f4-00115-00055626-00056129": "book there the mere fact that you're a teacher doesn't protect you from there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00116-00056129-00056601": "being a problem but that's not what's going on we are reading aloud as part of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00117-00056601-00057066": "the educational practices and you'll hear about why it's educationally", "oU0fYODn3f4-00118-00057066-00057414": "important to read aloud and the educators in the audience are going to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00119-00057414-00057951": "be well I know that's why I'm doing it but as the lawyers we say but but you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00120-00057951-00058383": "the reasons why you are doing it the educational purpose the educational", "oU0fYODn3f4-00121-00058383-00058974": "benefits are part of why we're confident this is a fair use it's part of why we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00122-00058974-00059372": "think this is exactly the kind of use that copyright law is designed to permit", "oU0fYODn3f4-00123-00059372-00059895": "and so if you get a little impatient with us telling you why it's important", "oU0fYODn3f4-00124-00059895-00060540": "it's because it is actually part of the legal explanation now I think that's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00125-00060540-00061016": "essentially my role here I actually have to teach a class a little bit later this", "oU0fYODn3f4-00126-00061016-00061377": "afternoon and won't be able to stay all the way through to the question and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00127-00061377-00061911": "answers but I am thrilled that my colleagues really took the initiative", "oU0fYODn3f4-00128-00061911-00062415": "and made this happen we hope that this is helpful I want to take off my lawyer", "oU0fYODn3f4-00129-00062415-00062895": "hat for a minute put on my educator hat and say I'm one of you I'm struggling to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00130-00062895-00063327": "adapt my classroom to the online environment I've got 72 adult learners", "oU0fYODn3f4-00131-00063327-00063747": "I've got to go address in a few minutes you've got a lot of hungry young minds", "oU0fYODn3f4-00132-00063747-00064224": "with attentions that's all over the place and I just want to thank you thank", "oU0fYODn3f4-00133-00064224-00064686": "you for all the work you're doing and if we can at least alleviate a little bit", "oU0fYODn3f4-00134-00064686-00065154": "of stress or confusion around copyright we hope that that will at least lighten", "oU0fYODn3f4-00135-00065154-00065595": "the load just a little bit but we think the work you're doing so very important", "oU0fYODn3f4-00136-00065595-00065943": "and that meeting aloud is such a very important fundamental educational", "oU0fYODn3f4-00137-00065943-00066504": "practice that the idea that somebody may be well intentioned but misinformed is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00138-00066504-00067052": "inhibiting teachers from doing just we can't we can't do that the last", "oU0fYODn3f4-00139-00067052-00067664": "thing I'll say is this is not a lesson about how to do copyright in a pandemic", "oU0fYODn3f4-00140-00067664-00068136": "this is a lesson about how copyright and fair use work together period there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00141-00068136-00068645": "might be one or two things where the context of the pandemic adds a little", "oU0fYODn3f4-00142-00068645-00069081": "bit to the fair use analysis but in general most of what you're hearing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00143-00069081-00069614": "today is general copyright and fair use analysis that applies to the practice of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00144-00069614-00069981": "reading aloud because the purpose of doing it remains the same the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00145-00069981-00070437": "educational benefits remain the same and that's why the law remains the same", "oU0fYODn3f4-00146-00070437-00070964": "thank you so much and I hope the rest of the webinar goes great and and I'll be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00147-00070964-00071402": "ready willing and able to participate in any follow-on activities that could", "oU0fYODn3f4-00148-00071402-00072162": "arise from this thanks thank Oh next up we have a Pernille Ripp who's going to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00149-00072162-00072663": "talk a little bit of the purposes of reading aloud hi Pernille hi everyone I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00150-00072663-00073133": "hope you can hear me okay and my computer does not like zoom so we'll", "oU0fYODn3f4-00151-00073133-00073695": "make the best of it here so the purpose of reading aloud it seems incredibly", "oU0fYODn3f4-00152-00073695-00074364": "urgent right now right as we're sitting in our classrooms convey created our", "oU0fYODn3f4-00153-00074364-00074789": "houses as we're trying to figure out what this remote learning looks like I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00154-00074789-00075318": "have had so many educators how have reached out to me just wondering how can", "oU0fYODn3f4-00155-00075318-00075912": "you the read aloud and yet also abide by the and so that's what we wanted to talk", "oU0fYODn3f4-00156-00075912-00076224": "about today because there are so many things that we can do with the read", "oU0fYODn3f4-00157-00076224-00076698": "aloud when we're in our classrooms we use it to build community we use it and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00158-00076698-00077172": "still a love of reading we use it as a way to start inquiry units start hard", "oU0fYODn3f4-00159-00077172-00077586": "conversations and all of the things that we hope our students and our own", "oU0fYODn3f4-00160-00077586-00078030": "children will be immersed in in our classrooms those purposes have not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00161-00078030-00078507": "changed the read aloud is an incredible way of course of building in and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00162-00078507-00078912": "bringing in community into these very scattered learning communities we're now", "oU0fYODn3f4-00163-00078912-00079374": "sitting with however now more than ever we really have to think about what are", "oU0fYODn3f4-00164-00079374-00079808": "those purposes of read aloud that we can use you can go to the next slide please", "oU0fYODn3f4-00165-00079808-00080358": "thank you so for right now what I'm one back please for what", "oU0fYODn3f4-00166-00080358-00080841": "I'm thinking about right now is that we need to still speak books together we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00167-00080841-00081297": "need to create new shared experiences within this new world that we're sitting", "oU0fYODn3f4-00168-00081297-00081819": "in and that is where read aloud comes in we can continue the read aloud that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00169-00081819-00082221": "perhaps we were already doing in our classrooms so that kids feel that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00170-00082221-00082677": "they're still connected to that we can start a new read aloud like I'm planning", "oU0fYODn3f4-00171-00082677-00083172": "on doing as a way to build community but we can also use short stories and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00172-00083172-00083586": "picture books to create a new language together so that if we come back", "oU0fYODn3f4-00173-00083586-00084039": "together or when we come back together we can say remember what happened in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00174-00084039-00084614": "that story it also continues our shared emphasis of the value of reading when", "oU0fYODn3f4-00175-00084614-00084990": "students have an adult that they trust and hopefully have a good relationship", "oU0fYODn3f4-00176-00084990-00085524": "with continues to read aloud even in all of this craziness it shows that we see", "oU0fYODn3f4-00177-00085524-00085914": "that this whole idea of coming together through a read aloud has not left our", "oU0fYODn3f4-00178-00085914-00086406": "minds we can continue to build our community and not just rest on the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00179-00086406-00087024": "community that we already had this also gives us a chance to continue to reframe", "oU0fYODn3f4-00180-00087024-00087444": "and discuss the impact of the dominant culture in our society and how it", "oU0fYODn3f4-00181-00087444-00087888": "influences our understanding of the world right now is a great time to start", "oU0fYODn3f4-00182-00087888-00088323": "inquiry projects with students and right now it is a great time to think about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00183-00088323-00088782": "the inequities that present themselves in our world we can do the beginnings of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00184-00088782-00089154": "those conversations through our read-alouds and so when I think about my", "oU0fYODn3f4-00185-00089154-00089550": "own practice as a classroom teacher the read aloud was one of the first tools", "oU0fYODn3f4-00186-00089550-00090108": "that I embraced in order to continue the learning that we've already done. My", "oU0fYODn3f4-00187-00090108-00090501": "students can access a hard text without having to worry about whether or not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00188-00090501-00090909": "they can decode it they can connect through this text that can ask questions", "oU0fYODn3f4-00189-00090909-00091347": "and they can also continue that comprehensive decoding analysis and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00190-00091347-00091743": "critical thinking that we've already paved the way for but finally why are we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00191-00091743-00092091": "doing read aloud's my six-year-old daughter sat today and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00192-00092091-00092496": "watched her kindergarten teacher read a picture book aloud to her in Spanish and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00193-00092496-00093003": "there is no way I could have replicated the smile she saw when she saw her", "oU0fYODn3f4-00194-00093003-00093387": "teacher do exactly the same thing that she has done all those day", "oU0fYODn3f4-00195-00093387-00093786": "in their classroom but now coming through a computer screen she tucked in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00196-00093786-00094149": "a little closer to me and said there's my teacher mom and so I think right now", "oU0fYODn3f4-00197-00094149-00094479": "as we continue to navigate all of this new it's so important that we keep", "oU0fYODn3f4-00198-00094479-00094956": "something central that we've used before the read aloud to keep our to keep", "oU0fYODn3f4-00199-00094956-00095700": "connecting with our students and with the world thank you I think it's really", "oU0fYODn3f4-00200-00095700-00096057": "great to hear about you know the big picture but also the individual stories", "oU0fYODn3f4-00201-00096057-00096447": "are I think really crucial to this discussion and so thank you for bringing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00202-00096447-00096876": "that in as well um next up we have Kristina who's going to talk a little", "oU0fYODn3f4-00203-00096876-00097362": "bit about this sort of current moment yeah so I'm so glad that pernil shared", "oU0fYODn3f4-00204-00097362-00097911": "that personal anecdote as far as her her own daughter and thinking about my own", "oU0fYODn3f4-00205-00097911-00098460": "experience in the classroom in early childhood and elementary classrooms and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00206-00098460-00099015": "then even as recent as -- as late January getting to do a read aloud in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00207-00099015-00099372": "the kindergarten classroom which is what you see here and the joy that we know", "oU0fYODn3f4-00208-00099372-00099888": "read alouds can bring so we already do this as as we've already mentioned we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00209-00099888-00100266": "know know the importance or read alounds and thinking about the why of all of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00210-00100266-00100671": "that so Pernille specifically called out the US Department of Education thought", "oU0fYODn3f4-00211-00100671-00101223": "on on read-alouds as well as her own research and expertise than that but it", "oU0fYODn3f4-00212-00101223-00101544": "does start with the whys so we are an emergency right now and we want to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00213-00101544-00101970": "able to continue that community building and kind of that safe space and we just", "oU0fYODn3f4-00214-00101970-00102276": "have a different platform or a different learning environment that we're doing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00215-00102276-00102672": "that right now but we also know that there are a number of schools that have", "oU0fYODn3f4-00216-00102672-00103068": "made the transitions to blended learning or even online learning and online", "oU0fYODn3f4-00217-00103068-00103578": "schools for the past 10 to 15 years and so we've had to consider these cases", "oU0fYODn3f4-00218-00103578-00103947": "long before just where we are right now but it seems that more people are paying", "oU0fYODn3f4-00219-00103947-00104373": "attention to it so it starts with our wide and Pernille's already outlined the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00220-00104373-00104850": "reasons why and for most educators it is for that continuity of learning right", "oU0fYODn3f4-00221-00104850-00105327": "now but then when we are outside of a pandemic or outside of an emergency", "oU0fYODn3f4-00222-00105327-00105780": "situation we can certainly think about what read-alouds can do for learning and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00223-00105780-00106239": "how we contribute to the read-aloud itself where we stop and we ask", "oU0fYODn3f4-00224-00106239-00106632": "questions and we're giving context closer we're asking students to focus on", "oU0fYODn3f4-00225-00106632-00107046": "context clues really apply their their skillset to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00226-00107046-00107574": "able to decode and and comprehend the things that are happening in a book but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00227-00107574-00107979": "it's not about the tools right now and that's what's really important and so we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00228-00107979-00108611": "have a tendency in the EdTech land to be drawn in by the shiny things and there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00229-00108611-00109041": "are a lot of ed tech providers that are providing a whole slew of different", "oU0fYODn3f4-00230-00109041-00109497": "tools right now and sometimes it just comes down to the basics and going back", "oU0fYODn3f4-00231-00109497-00109989": "to what we know and so it's important to think about our books and whether they", "oU0fYODn3f4-00232-00109989-00110478": "are digital or in print and how we are providing that as a tool for our kids", "oU0fYODn3f4-00233-00110478-00110916": "that is not something necessarily shiny and new and so being able to use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00234-00110916-00111444": "different platforms like Instagram and Facebook and YouTube to be able to share", "oU0fYODn3f4-00235-00111444-00111900": "those those read-alouds are certainly important next slide please", "oU0fYODn3f4-00236-00111900-00112460": "when we think about moving to an online learning environment we actually have", "oU0fYODn3f4-00237-00112460-00112851": "the opportunity to really think about serving every learner and this is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00238-00112851-00113210": "actually one of my last group of students that I had in Omaha Nebraska", "oU0fYODn3f4-00239-00113210-00113679": "and the majority of my students I was an English language teacher and so the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00240-00113679-00114059": "majority of my students were newcomers and this is a group of newcomers that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00241-00114059-00114483": "got to experience snow for the first time and so in order to like we stopped", "oU0fYODn3f4-00242-00114483-00114939": "our lesson we were in a small group working on reading and I noticed it was", "oU0fYODn3f4-00243-00114939-00115314": "snowing outside we ran outside and had the opportunity to experience that for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00244-00115314-00115596": "the first time but then of course we brought that back into the classroom and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00245-00115596-00116060": "then we pulled all the books that we had around snow and like the science of snow", "oU0fYODn3f4-00246-00116060-00116607": "as well as just snow day and poems and and pieces that accompany that and so we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00247-00116607-00117104": "contribute so much more to our students learning experiences whenever we can add", "oU0fYODn3f4-00248-00117104-00117519": "those extra pieces and so we know that we want that to continue online so we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00249-00117519-00117945": "have some of those additional tools maybe not the shiny shiny tools we have", "oU0fYODn3f4-00250-00117945-00118508": "the capacity to be able to build on what our students are learning through some", "oU0fYODn3f4-00251-00118508-00118872": "of these digital tools so that we can scaffold vocabulary that we can send", "oU0fYODn3f4-00252-00118872-00119370": "them to an online dictionary and that we can show different vocabulary words that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00253-00119370-00119814": "they can add to their repertoire just because we have access to these tools we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00254-00119814-00120153": "can also think about our students that may need to hear things", "oU0fYODn3f4-00255-00120153-00120611": "multiple times for it to kind of stick and so we have the opportunity right now", "oU0fYODn3f4-00256-00120611-00121085": "hope to be able to record some things or even just go live and that kids could", "oU0fYODn3f4-00257-00121085-00121581": "then go back and listen to it again or for comprehension and so we have again", "oU0fYODn3f4-00258-00121581-00122001": "this opportunity to think about this as meeting students where they are and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00259-00122001-00122721": "being able to serve every single learner thanks Kristina I think that that final", "oU0fYODn3f4-00260-00122721-00123083": "point is really important and just to keep that in mind as we go forward of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00261-00123083-00123540": "how we're using you know what we're learning about fair use today and what", "oU0fYODn3f4-00262-00123540-00124176": "that enables to make sure that we are really trying to serve everyone and meet", "oU0fYODn3f4-00263-00124176-00124617": "them where they are um next up we have Professor Peter Yazzie who's going to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00264-00124617-00125172": "tell us a little bit about sort of the look back at the sort of purposes of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00265-00125172-00125526": "reading aloud and how reading aloud practices have related to copyright law", "oU0fYODn3f4-00266-00125526-00125992": "thank you Peter Thank You Meredith and and Thank You", "oU0fYODn3f4-00267-00125992-00126547": "Pernille and Kristina because really you you as as will soon become a parent", "oU0fYODn3f4-00268-00126547-00127134": "you've done most of my work for me and I will turn in a moment to the connection", "oU0fYODn3f4-00269-00127134-00127741": "between your eloquent presentations and the the things we know about the law", "oU0fYODn3f4-00270-00127741-00128458": "first though I I need to hear the four words that that always drew groans from", "oU0fYODn3f4-00271-00128458-00129421": "my own students and that is first a little history so if we can look at the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00272-00129421-00130306": "next slide we'll see that the history of copyright in the United States has", "oU0fYODn3f4-00273-00130306-00130860": "always been education friendly and that's in part because we have a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00274-00130860-00131463": "copyright law that's based on a constitutional clause that identifies", "oU0fYODn3f4-00275-00131463-00132058": "what has come in our time to be called access to knowledge as the primary", "oU0fYODn3f4-00276-00132058-00132676": "mission of our copyright system now for most of the history of copyright in the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00277-00132676-00133180": "United States the issues we're talking about today simply weren't on the radar", "oU0fYODn3f4-00278-00133180-00134013": "and that's because for most of that time non-commercial readings and displays of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00279-00134013-00134686": "printed material weren't regulated by copyright law under the laws that stood", "oU0fYODn3f4-00280-00134686-00135310": "up till 1978 the only performances and displays that to which copyright applied", "oU0fYODn3f4-00281-00135310-00136039": "were those that were done themselves for commercial purposes so in '78 when there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00282-00136039-00136648": "was a new copyright law with a lot more detail and some additional protections", "oU0fYODn3f4-00283-00136648-00137125": "for rights holders built into it the Congress realized that there needed to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00284-00137125-00137761": "be a generous carve out for a range of different face-to-face classroom", "oU0fYODn3f4-00285-00137761-00138484": "teaching practices including of course reading aloud and they designed that law", "oU0fYODn3f4-00286-00138484-00139104": "accordingly so in in effect just as was true before 1978 so it continued to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00287-00139104-00139665": "after that reading aloud in the physical classroom the only kind of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00288-00139665-00140482": "classroom we had of course in that moment was not a regulated activity of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00289-00140482-00141123": "course the nature of the classroom changed and what we've referred to lately", "oU0fYODn3f4-00290-00141123-00141786": "back in those days as distance learning became an issue in reality and also in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00291-00141786-00142850": "anticipation and in 2002 the Congress tried to update the law to authorize our", "oU0fYODn3f4-00292-00142850-00143596": "variety of uses of copyrighted material in specific terms in the virtual", "oU0fYODn3f4-00293-00143596-00144066": "classroom and the results weren't great those of you who had to grapple with the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00294-00144066-00144873": "so-called TEACH Act know that it's confusing and often frustrating and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00295-00144873-00145614": "being gentle in my description it didn't do a good job in other words of bringing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00296-00145614-00146249": "copyright law up to date for 2002 and it didn't do a very good job at all of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00297-00146249-00146874": "anticipating the next 18 years of development which have been rapid and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00298-00146874-00147520": "dramatic in so far as the application of new technology to educational practice", "oU0fYODn3f4-00299-00147520-00148542": "is concerned but one very good thing did happen in 2002 as this ultimately", "oU0fYODn3f4-00300-00148542-00149151": "unsuccessful amendment was being debated and that is that the Congress recognized", "oU0fYODn3f4-00301-00149151-00149985": "that in addition to looking to the the specific provisions of what came to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00302-00149985-00150848": "section 110- 2 of the Copyright Act educators could also look in order to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00303-00150848-00151735": "justify and and find a legal authorization for their virtual teaching", "oU0fYODn3f4-00304-00151735-00152422": "practices to the general very use doctrine that was codified", "oU0fYODn3f4-00305-00152422-00153078": "in Section 107 of the Act now that was a an important coincidence because around", "oU0fYODn3f4-00306-00153078-00153828": "the same time the law of fair use which isn't just for education but applies", "oU0fYODn3f4-00307-00153828-00154675": "with special force in education began to change as well even 25 years of very", "oU0fYODn3f4-00308-00154675-00155425": "rapid development in the courts in which fair use has become a more clearly", "oU0fYODn3f4-00309-00155425-00156153": "understood and a more useful tool for all kinds of cultural practitioners", "oU0fYODn3f4-00310-00156153-00156607": "including teachers and as well see librarians", "oU0fYODn3f4-00311-00156607-00157752": "what then does the law of fair use today amount to Mike can we have the next slide I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00312-00157890-00158446": "should begin this description by saying that again what I've said a moment ago", "oU0fYODn3f4-00313-00158446-00158890": "this is a really really good moment in the history of fair use fair use has", "oU0fYODn3f4-00314-00158890-00159504": "become over the last 24 years 25 or so years thanks to the courts easier", "oU0fYODn3f4-00315-00159504-00160252": "to understand and especially more predictable and indeed quite a lot of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00316-00160252-00160861": "what we're going to be talking about later today is an implementation of the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00317-00160861-00161434": "very positive developments that have marked that the evolution of the fair", "oU0fYODn3f4-00318-00161434-00161962": "use doctrine in the last quarter century if you look at section 107 which many of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00319-00161962-00162597": "you are familiar with the statutory embodiment of fair use you'll know", "oU0fYODn3f4-00320-00162597-00163225": "you'll learn that there are four so-called factors listed there why are", "oU0fYODn3f4-00321-00163225-00163660": "you doing something what are you doing it to what kind of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00322-00163660-00164122": "material you're using that is how much are you using and what economic effect", "oU0fYODn3f4-00323-00164122-00164753": "on the rights holder is your use having that's what the statute says it's a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00324-00164753-00165453": "comprehensive list and in its own way it's not a terribly useful one because", "oU0fYODn3f4-00325-00165453-00166084": "the criteria are so broad and the statute is so vague about their relative", "oU0fYODn3f4-00326-00166084-00166639": "importance and their interaction that much of the work of trying to understand", "oU0fYODn3f4-00327-00166639-00167146": "what fair use really means and how it really applies was thrown back on to the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00328-00167146-00167608": "courts and that's where as I said earlier he's very positive developments", "oU0fYODn3f4-00329-00167608-00168172": "have occurred right now in a situation like the one we're discussing reading", "oU0fYODn3f4-00330-00168172-00168774": "aloud using new technologies in a virtual classroom or a virtual library", "oU0fYODn3f4-00331-00168774-00169302": "storytelling the cases tell us that they were there really two important", "oU0fYODn3f4-00332-00169302-00169858": "functional questions that we need to ask in order to get to a reliable answer and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00333-00169858-00170587": "that is are you doing something new and different something transformative to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00334-00170587-00170989": "use the legal jargon that the courts have developed with the material you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00335-00170989-00171753": "using and are you providing a substitute a commercial market", "oU0fYODn3f4-00336-00171753-00172567": "substitute for the work as it was originally offered to be in the best", "oU0fYODn3f4-00337-00172567-00173053": "possible position the answer to the first question should be yes and the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00338-00173053-00173656": "answer to that second question should be no now sometimes in in fair use analysis", "oU0fYODn3f4-00339-00173656-00174210": "this issue which I referred a moment ago of whether you're using the right amount", "oU0fYODn3f4-00340-00174210-00174787": "also comes up is the amount you're using appropriate to the purpose for which", "oU0fYODn3f4-00341-00174787-00175431": "you're using it in the case of reading aloud that isn't often going to be a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00342-00175431-00175945": "dominant issue because generally speaking of course the unit the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00343-00175945-00176377": "appropriate unit for a read aloud is going to be the whole book whether", "oU0fYODn3f4-00344-00176377-00176797": "you're reading a picture book at one sitting or a chapter book over the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00345-00176797-00177412": "course of the semester let's see then a little bit more about how all of this", "oU0fYODn3f4-00346-00177412-00178213": "applies we'll take the next slide and I want to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00347-00178213-00178765": "emphasize before I get into the specifics here that there has never been", "oU0fYODn3f4-00348-00178765-00179695": "a safer time in terms of risk analysis than the present for educators to engage", "oU0fYODn3f4-00349-00179695-00180265": "with the fair use doctrine to take advantage of it to enable their reading", "oU0fYODn3f4-00350-00180265-00180658": "aloud practices and when I say there's never been a better time I mean of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00351-00180658-00181280": "course that the conditions of the present emergency change in some ways", "oU0fYODn3f4-00352-00181280-00181972": "the the perspective which we analyze these questions I also mean that for all", "oU0fYODn3f4-00353-00181972-00182788": "the reasons that I outlined previously in general even when the emergency is at", "oU0fYODn3f4-00354-00182788-00183594": "an end this will still be a golden moment for exercising fair use rights", "oU0fYODn3f4-00355-00183594-00184428": "responsibly to engage in reading aloud virtually as well as once again finally", "oU0fYODn3f4-00356-00184428-00184963": "physically now it's true that these days many publishers are opening up their", "oU0fYODn3f4-00357-00184963-00185794": "books for limited times and in limited ways for read-alouds that's great of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00358-00185794-00186515": "course and you should all take advantage of those offers if they suit your needs", "oU0fYODn3f4-00359-00186515-00186815": "but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00360-00186893-00187449": "if you look and I we've we've got a URL here to an excellent school library", "oU0fYODn3f4-00361-00187449-00188082": "journal blog entry which collects some of these policies you'll", "oU0fYODn3f4-00362-00188082-00188618": "see that they don't cover all the books you want to read and that they are", "oU0fYODn3f4-00363-00188618-00189300": "loaded more in some cases less in other cases with occasionally onerous and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00364-00189300-00190092": "often inconsistent conditions and limitations and so the the point that I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00365-00190092-00190917": "want to make in in closing is that although publishers deserve great credit", "oU0fYODn3f4-00366-00190917-00191532": "for making this effort it's also true and important for educators and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00367-00191532-00192165": "librarians to remember that none of these temporary licenses limit the scope", "oU0fYODn3f4-00368-00192165-00192729": "of your ability to rely on fair use to read aloud online they don't live in it", "oU0fYODn3f4-00369-00192729-00193227": "now and they won't limit it later and that is because as as Mike Carroll said", "oU0fYODn3f4-00370-00193227-00194049": "earlier fair use is a statutory right not a concession by rights holders now", "oU0fYODn3f4-00371-00194049-00194586": "I'm gonna turn things over to Carrie in a moment but by way of transition let me", "oU0fYODn3f4-00372-00194586-00195033": "say one thing and that is that when we heard Kristina and Pernille talk so", "oU0fYODn3f4-00373-00195033-00195596": "eloquently about the purposes of reading aloud we were actually hearing them", "oU0fYODn3f4-00374-00195596-00196454": "develop, articulate the most important premise or proposition for the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00375-00196454-00196992": "application of fair use to virtual reader alouds and that's because as I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00376-00196992-00197457": "mentioned earlier the first question you asked in assessing whether a use you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00377-00197457-00198045": "considering is fair is whether it's a transformative use and as Carrie is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00378-00198045-00198906": "going to explain transformative use analysis is a function of what you know", "oU0fYODn3f4-00379-00198906-00199832": "and believe and can articulate about the purposes of your activity", "oU0fYODn3f4-00380-00199832-00200083": "and I'll stop there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00381-00200105-00200616": "thank you Peter um Carrie will be up next Carrie I see that you're unmuted", "oU0fYODn3f4-00382-00200616-00200880": "but I don't know if you're able to unmute your video as well", "oU0fYODn3f4-00383-00200880-00201573": "I have unmuted myself okay thank you Peter I'm going to talk as you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00384-00201573-00202182": "said about some of the transformative purposes which you've heard earlier why", "oU0fYODn3f4-00385-00202182-00202743": "the why in education and in libraries these uses are transformative socially", "oU0fYODn3f4-00386-00202743-00203181": "beneficial and then to consider whether or not we're having an impact on the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00387-00203181-00204198": "market for the original use that the book or work served next slide reading", "oU0fYODn3f4-00388-00204198-00204636": "aloud transform earnest and the market when teachers and students read aloud in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00389-00204636-00205176": "the classroom it's a more of an interactive experience that serves a lot", "oU0fYODn3f4-00390-00205176-00205721": "of different functions it's not like silent reading for example sometimes", "oU0fYODn3f4-00391-00205721-00206196": "when we're reading aloud would become very very text specific over a very", "oU0fYODn3f4-00392-00206196-00206694": "special part of the book for English as a second language for people that are", "oU0fYODn3f4-00393-00206694-00207258": "slower readers highlighting task text as one speaks aloud repeating", "oU0fYODn3f4-00394-00207258-00207821": "pronunciations is a transformative way of using a work to help people learn", "oU0fYODn3f4-00395-00207821-00208308": "very different than listening passively to a professional reading for just", "oU0fYODn3f4-00396-00208308-00208911": "anybody in a philosophy class a student might be invited to share a reading of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00397-00208911-00209379": "an essay and the teacher might stop to prompt questions of the audience of the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00398-00209379-00209948": "other classroom again it's totally unlike reading by yourself concentrated", "oU0fYODn3f4-00399-00209948-00210498": "reading studying by yourself another time you might see a reading aloud being", "oU0fYODn3f4-00400-00210498-00210990": "used as a textual analysis not really getting into the expression of the work", "oU0fYODn3f4-00401-00210990-00211521": "but more of how certain words are used and it's again it's kind of a different", "oU0fYODn3f4-00402-00211521-00212117": "thing than just plain reading we know that just because students here these", "oU0fYODn3f4-00403-00212117-00212544": "read aloud's that does not mean that they're not going to buy books or buy or", "oU0fYODn3f4-00404-00212544-00213144": "not buy ebooks these these kinds of activities with read aloud's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00405-00213144-00213515": "do not affect the market for the commercially produced", "oU0fYODn3f4-00406-00213515-00214115": "readings next slide please I have to talk about story time because", "oU0fYODn3f4-00407-00214115-00214744": "I'm a librarian and as Peter was mentioning educational uses are pretty", "oU0fYODn3f4-00408-00214744-00215315": "special in the copyright law and libraries are the same we are treated", "oU0fYODn3f4-00409-00215315-00215780": "different in the copyright law because we are special sites where people learn", "oU0fYODn3f4-00410-00215780-00216380": "and engage with content just as in an educational situation which is a favored", "oU0fYODn3f4-00411-00216380-00216923": "use under copyright it's really why we have a lot to begin with to advance", "oU0fYODn3f4-00412-00216923-00217505": "learning so for many people for lots of kids they've grown up when they grew up", "oU0fYODn3f4-00413-00217505-00217928": "their parents were available to read to them individually as a child which is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00414-00217928-00218323": "a wonderful thing bonding with your mom or your dad", "oU0fYODn3f4-00415-00218323-00218846": "sharing the story together wonderful experience but for a lot of kids this", "oU0fYODn3f4-00416-00218846-00219571": "doesn't always happen story time at the library can fill a gap so every every", "oU0fYODn3f4-00417-00219571-00220190": "child can build a love for reading story time also provides this early community", "oU0fYODn3f4-00418-00220190-00220691": "experience and is often interactive and allows children to play roles in the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00419-00220691-00221213": "story which is different than if you're reading just by yourself I'll recall", "oU0fYODn3f4-00420-00221213-00221654": "going to the main branch of the Brooklyn Public Library and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00421-00221654-00222182": "glancing in a room that was the size of a small parking lot and seeing hundreds", "oU0fYODn3f4-00422-00222182-00222719": "of strollers in that room and going what's going on oh it's story time there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00423-00222719-00223331": "were hundreds of children there for storytime and together that group of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00424-00223331-00223985": "kids made a little community and enjoyed the story together and that storytellers", "oU0fYODn3f4-00425-00223985-00224444": "were able to link the images to the words which is shown to be a very", "oU0fYODn3f4-00426-00224444-00224981": "important part of early media literacy the other thing about libraries", "oU0fYODn3f4-00427-00224981-00225458": "storytime is that libraries select and purchase children's books that are the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00428-00225458-00225890": "best for their communities that reflect the diversity and the life circumstances", "oU0fYODn3f4-00429-00225890-00226409": "of their individual communities and a library book is that's purchased for the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00430-00226409-00226792": "library is extra special because it has an added social value", "oU0fYODn3f4-00431-00226792-00227298": "when parents come to storytime they discover books that they want to buy", "oU0fYODn3f4-00432-00227298-00227731": "from home because if that book was read in the library and if that book was", "oU0fYODn3f4-00433-00227731-00228250": "purchased by the library that means that that book is a quality book and it leads", "oU0fYODn3f4-00434-00228250-00228964": "to discovery and more purchases so I see that there's really no impact on the on", "oU0fYODn3f4-00435-00228964-00229603": "the work in terms of sales thank you Carrie", "oU0fYODn3f4-00436-00229603-00230215": "and so Carrie's given us sort of this overview of how you take the fair use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00437-00230215-00230644": "analysis that Peter sketched out the sort of basic questions and how you then", "oU0fYODn3f4-00438-00230644-00231009": "apply that to this question about reading aloud and thinking through that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00439-00231009-00231403": "and next we're lucky to have my colleague Will Cross who's going to talk", "oU0fYODn3f4-00440-00231403-00231835": "a little bit about sorry I think there's a slide out of order and Mike just to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00441-00231835-00232282": "the next slide please yeah talking a little bit about putting the theory into", "oU0fYODn3f4-00442-00232282-00232678": "practice and thinking through some considerated considerations about how", "oU0fYODn3f4-00443-00232678-00233200": "this is done in the school thank you very much Meredith thank you all for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00444-00233200-00233440": "being here and thanks to my collaborators for that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00445-00233440-00233734": "excellent introduction to the pedagogical values and importance of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00446-00233734-00234169": "reading aloud and to sort of the way fair use connects with those issues I've", "oU0fYODn3f4-00447-00234169-00234469": "been charged with talking a little bit about what fair use looks like on the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00448-00234469-00234913": "ground for educators and particularly the broad scope and reach of fair use to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00449-00234913-00235437": "support reading aloud as a practice so next slide please", "oU0fYODn3f4-00450-00235544-00236140": "fair use covers a broad range of materials as Peter and Carrie made clear", "oU0fYODn3f4-00451-00236140-00236536": "the core question that fair use asks is about the purpose and character of your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00452-00236536-00236827": "use what are you doing and why are you doing what you're doing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00453-00236827-00237169": "so what that means is when your purpose is transformative as it often is with", "oU0fYODn3f4-00454-00237169-00237396": "reading aloud in the ways that we've already discussed", "oU0fYODn3f4-00455-00237396-00237835": "fair use broadly supports your use regardless of the type of materials", "oU0fYODn3f4-00456-00237835-00238269": "being read aloud so if for example fair use powerfully supports", "oU0fYODn3f4-00457-00238269-00238669": "reading aloud for both fiction and nonfiction texts for narrative or", "oU0fYODn3f4-00458-00238669-00239131": "expository purposes a purchase copy a library book a book found online or", "oU0fYODn3f4-00459-00239131-00239533": "elsewhere where you supports all of those the integration of texts and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00460-00239533-00239921": "illustrations from picture book art to graphs and tables and a STEM", "oU0fYODn3f4-00461-00239921-00240350": "material a STEM book of some sort and it also supports that reading whether it's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00462-00240350-00240713": "done by teachers or students or others I'll say a little bit more about that in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00463-00240713-00241115": "a minute we did want to note though that when you talk about textbooks and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00464-00241115-00241567": "commercial learning materials it's not a no from fair use but you want to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00465-00241567-00241976": "extra careful because there's a greater risk of that market substitution that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00466-00241976-00242417": "Carrie mentioned a minute ago so fair use covers this wide range of materials with", "oU0fYODn3f4-00467-00242417-00242836": "a little sort of an extra eye towards carefulness when you deal with textbooks", "oU0fYODn3f4-00468-00242836-00243257": "or commercial learning materials so that's one way in which the scope of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00469-00243257-00243679": "fair use is very broad next slide please", "oU0fYODn3f4-00470-00243727-00244321": "similarly fair use covers a wide range of platforms your fair use analysis is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00471-00244321-00244735": "going to be less impacted by the type of platform you select to read aloud on if", "oU0fYODn3f4-00472-00244735-00245042": "you have the option obviously it certainly makes sense to read aloud over", "oU0fYODn3f4-00473-00245042-00245467": "a platform like a learning management system an lms that is limited to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00474-00245467-00245809": "enrolled students or on a YouTube channel that's unlisted in some way to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00475-00245809-00246164": "sort of limit the availability beyond the folks that you're trying to support", "oU0fYODn3f4-00476-00246164-00246559": "with your pedagogy and it probably strengthens your hair use analysis but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00477-00246559-00246905": "it's important to say that that limitation is by no means necessary", "oU0fYODn3f4-00478-00246905-00247304": "you might also choose to share your read aloud activities on a dedicated website", "oU0fYODn3f4-00479-00247304-00247873": "in school or hosted by the teacher or even a dedicated YouTube channel and if", "oU0fYODn3f4-00480-00247873-00248171": "you make that choice it's important to note that developing and using those", "oU0fYODn3f4-00481-00248171-00248600": "platforms doesn't create any special obligation to monitor those platforms", "oU0fYODn3f4-00482-00248600-00249121": "going forward so again it's it's a wide scope there's sort of a gold-star best", "oU0fYODn3f4-00483-00249121-00249571": "way to do it but even if you can't follow that best practice fair you still", "oU0fYODn3f4-00484-00249571-00249973": "gives you a lot of space to do what's best for your students not just what the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00485-00249973-00250358": "lawyers would really like best if they were writing up a brief next slide", "oU0fYODn3f4-00486-00250358-00250754": "please and then a third way that fair use is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00487-00250754-00251117": "gives you broad space to do what's right for your students is that fair use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00488-00251117-00251591": "covers a wide range of readers we've talked a lot about teachers reading", "oU0fYODn3f4-00489-00251591-00251971": "aloud and the way that teachers can sort of bring context or make choices but we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00490-00251971-00252302": "want to be clear that just like in the classroom reading aloud is an activity", "oU0fYODn3f4-00491-00252302-00252791": "that can and should be done by a variety of educational participants teachers", "oU0fYODn3f4-00492-00252791-00253108": "reading aloud for the reasons that Carrie Pernille and Peter described certainly", "oU0fYODn3f4-00493-00253108-00253369": "we have a straw fair-use claim but so do students", "oU0fYODn3f4-00494-00253369-00253834": "reading aloud for example to build and demonstrate fluency librarians similarly", "oU0fYODn3f4-00495-00253834-00254158": "do reading aloud that's clearly in line with the transformative pedagogical", "oU0fYODn3f4-00496-00254158-00254512": "activities supported by fair use and there are certainly others as well who", "oU0fYODn3f4-00497-00254512-00254996": "can and do read aloud in pedagogically valuable ways such as guest speakers", "oU0fYODn3f4-00498-00254996-00255439": "invited experts and those sorts of folks the picture I have here is actually it's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00499-00255439-00255841": "from Scott Air Force Base there's a program where the enlisted folks come in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00500-00255841-00256213": "and they read to individual students who live and learn on the base it would be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00501-00256213-00256540": "hard to argue that that's not also supported by fair use that's sort of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00502-00256540-00257005": "reading so I think that's most of what I wanted to say in terms of the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00503-00257005-00257425": "on-the-ground the scope of the ability that fair use gives to you I'm going to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00504-00257425-00257755": "turn it over now to Meredith to talk some about some specific practices to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00505-00257755-00258462": "think about thank you so I'm always aware that when we do these webinars", "oU0fYODn3f4-00506-00258462-00259108": "when we talk to teachers about fair use there's a hunger for sort of concrete", "oU0fYODn3f4-00507-00259108-00259633": "yes and no answers and as Michael Carroll said earlier you know we're not your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00508-00259633-00260140": "individual lawyers and so we can't give you specific legal advice but what we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00509-00260140-00260584": "think can be very useful is to talk through a set of scenarios that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00510-00260584-00261244": "hopefully represent um questions and practices that you see in your work and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00511-00261244-00261784": "talk through what parts of those scenarios can be relevant and to think", "oU0fYODn3f4-00512-00261784-00262108": "about sort of what teaching purpose is being served and how are those", "oU0fYODn3f4-00513-00262108-00262618": "considerations and questions cut through in these hypotheticals and hopefully", "oU0fYODn3f4-00514-00262618-00263143": "that between the sort of fair use background that Peter and Carrie gave", "oU0fYODn3f4-00515-00263143-00263719": "earlier and the sort of scoop that we'll just did to taking that and using it in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00516-00263719-00264292": "the context of the purposes that Pernille and Kristina talked about in your own", "oU0fYODn3f4-00517-00264292-00264793": "teaching purposes can get you to a point where you feel as Peter said that there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00518-00264793-00265327": "is predictability in understanding when what you are doing is fair use and when", "oU0fYODn3f4-00519-00265327-00266014": "it may not be and so in these scenarios in the first five I'm going to talk", "oU0fYODn3f4-00520-00266014-00266386": "through situations in which if you've thought about your purpose and you have", "oU0fYODn3f4-00521-00266386-00266966": "a clear understanding of that transformative purpose and you have done", "oU0fYODn3f4-00522-00266966-00267278": "the analysis that these scenarios have many instances that are likely to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00523-00267278-00267746": "fair use so we'll start with the first scenario now and next slide please", "oU0fYODn3f4-00524-00267746-00268058": "Mike um so the first practice we're going to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00525-00268058-00268616": "talk about is um when a teacher reads an introductory segment of a nonfiction", "oU0fYODn3f4-00526-00268616-00269015": "text provide students with some background material and then offers", "oU0fYODn3f4-00527-00269015-00269366": "different pre-recorded segments for students to choose to listen to next so", "oU0fYODn3f4-00528-00269366-00269783": "they can select their own learning paths and so here the first question", "oU0fYODn3f4-00529-00269783-00270464": "would be what is our purpose what is our educational purpose here and so there's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00530-00270464-00270886": "the purpose of getting the students sort of oriented in the text to model the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00531-00270886-00271190": "reading of the beginning to get everybody on the same page with like", "oU0fYODn3f4-00532-00271190-00271489": "you're learning and then there's a second purpose which is to allow", "oU0fYODn3f4-00533-00271489-00272096": "different students to take charge of their learning and to have some control", "oU0fYODn3f4-00534-00272096-00272498": "over what they learn next so it's important to think about not necessarily", "oU0fYODn3f4-00535-00272498-00272942": "just replicating what you do in the classroom but also taking advantage of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00536-00272942-00273329": "the flexibility offered online so students might be able to click through", "oU0fYODn3f4-00537-00273329-00273752": "and hear different recorded segments whereas in class you might just have to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00538-00273752-00274214": "read from the beginning to the end but so in this context if you're reading it", "oU0fYODn3f4-00539-00274214-00274709": "and then sort of transforming your names this student - student exploratory", "oU0fYODn3f4-00540-00274709-00275285": "work um it's if you've got a clear teaching purpose and it's not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00541-00275285-00275870": "substituting for having a copy of the text that you would read aloud and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00542-00275870-00276369": "then go into the next scenario so this is one of the questions it's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00543-00276369-00276690": "sort of how you translate what you might do in class to this new online", "oU0fYODn3f4-00544-00276690-00277101": "environment so a teacher might regularly begin a class session with a chapter of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00545-00277101-00277461": "my novel to orient students in the physical classroom and to get them", "oU0fYODn3f4-00546-00277461-00277968": "focused for learning and you want to adopt adapt to that practice for virtual", "oU0fYODn3f4-00547-00277968-00278469": "learning so as Pernille said earlier you want to replicate that sense of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00548-00278469-00278964": "community and that sort of anchoring in the classroom that you do in person to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00549-00278964-00279597": "this new online platform and so you might do this by posting one chapter per", "oU0fYODn3f4-00550-00279597-00280134": "day on a learning management system as an introductory exercise in the virtual", "oU0fYODn3f4-00551-00280134-00280683": "world you might also decide that you wanted to stream this through your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00552-00280683-00281058": "Facebook or Instagram live or something like that to get all your students", "oU0fYODn3f4-00553-00281058-00281565": "online and paying attention at the same moment and as will said earlier in that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00554-00281565-00281943": "situation if you're doing distribution not through an LMS you want to make sure", "oU0fYODn3f4-00555-00281943-00282450": "that um you've got a clear sort of community purpose there and that you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00556-00282450-00283074": "targeting those on Facebook or Instagram links or whatever as closely as you can", "oU0fYODn3f4-00557-00283074-00283542": "to your students and so this isn't a question necessarily of having a strict", "oU0fYODn3f4-00558-00283542-00284088": "it has to be logged in or you have to use some specific rights management but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00559-00284088-00284517": "if your purpose is to create a community above your classroom then the way you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00560-00284517-00285234": "should distribute that should be roughly contiguous with that purpose um on to a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00561-00285234-00285675": "next example we're going to talk a little bit about a situation in which", "oU0fYODn3f4-00562-00285675-00286143": "you could use some selections from a commercial text so as Will mentioned", "oU0fYODn3f4-00563-00286143-00286599": "earlier you need to be really careful with commercial teaching and learning", "oU0fYODn3f4-00564-00286599-00287181": "materials to not do things that sort of directly substitute for the original", "oU0fYODn3f4-00565-00287181-00287589": "because they're intended to be classroom materials and you're using them in that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00566-00287589-00287943": "same way but that doesn't mean that they're not eligible to be considered", "oU0fYODn3f4-00567-00287943-00288645": "for fair use and so one example might be in a middle school classroom for example", "oU0fYODn3f4-00568-00288645-00289119": "you might read the beginning section of a commercial textbook you write read a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00569-00289119-00289444": "couple of paragraphs and then go through the chapter", "oU0fYODn3f4-00570-00289444-00289873": "and highlight areas in the text that you want students to pay extra attention to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00571-00289873-00290314": "you might call out examples you might read the first few discussion questions", "oU0fYODn3f4-00572-00290314-00290800": "aloud and there you're doing this transformative thing of providing your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00573-00290800-00291328": "students with a roadmap through the text you're not substituting for them reading", "oU0fYODn3f4-00574-00291328-00291981": "directly through that text and then the next example we'll talk about is we've", "oU0fYODn3f4-00575-00291981-00292473": "got a lot of questions about reading storybooks too early grade readers and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00576-00292473-00292986": "here for example a teacher might read through a book and discuss it with their", "oU0fYODn3f4-00577-00292986-00293400": "class and then talk about its connection to a second book and read that out loud", "oU0fYODn3f4-00578-00293400-00294033": "so there they're providing context for the books the connection and explanation", "oU0fYODn3f4-00579-00294033-00294697": "for their students and that purpose is their purpose we're connecting the two", "oU0fYODn3f4-00580-00294697-00295007": "books we're getting the students thinking and we're providing the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00581-00295007-00295361": "explanation connection between the teachers and the students", "oU0fYODn3f4-00582-00295361-00295942": "you might also in that situation do a practice for English language learners", "oU0fYODn3f4-00583-00295942-00296296": "where you interspersed reading from the book in English with scaffolding", "oU0fYODn3f4-00584-00296296-00296634": "questions and a student's home language so you're providing a really different", "oU0fYODn3f4-00585-00296634-00297193": "purpose there in helping them build their reading competency one more", "oU0fYODn3f4-00586-00297193-00297420": "example", "oU0fYODn3f4-00587-00297424-00297805": "so another might be that this is not just practices for teachers so teachers", "oU0fYODn3f4-00588-00297805-00298165": "and students might collaborate to read text in parallel where students go", "oU0fYODn3f4-00589-00298165-00298734": "around and they read pieces to the group and contributing to a reading project", "oU0fYODn3f4-00590-00298734-00299227": "and sort of building that classroom connection and again it's important to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00591-00299227-00299728": "think that this as we'll said it is not format dependent so depending on your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00592-00299728-00300397": "students connectivity depending on their device access depending on a lot of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00593-00300397-00300901": "things you might do this in an outloud soom session or you might do it in a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00594-00300901-00301228": "situation where students recorded themselves and sent it in if that gave", "oU0fYODn3f4-00595-00301228-00301678": "them the ability to do work asynchronously and if it fit your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00596-00301678-00302056": "teaching purpose of having the students all experience themselves and their", "oU0fYODn3f4-00597-00302056-00302449": "classmates reading to each other so in all of these situations if you have a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00598-00302449-00302843": "really clear idea of your teaching purpose", "oU0fYODn3f4-00599-00302843-00303308": "either your educational purpose or the community purpose and it's not directly", "oU0fYODn3f4-00600-00303308-00303779": "substituting for the normal market so this isn't normally how people buy or", "oU0fYODn3f4-00601-00303779-00304310": "consume these works you have a strong fair use justification another way to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00602-00304310-00304739": "think about this here is that the purpose that your new transformational", "oU0fYODn3f4-00603-00304739-00305287": "purpose can be clear in a couple of different ways so it can be clear in the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00604-00305287-00305842": "context of the new thing you've created so in the example where a teacher is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00605-00305842-00306293": "introducing a text and then highlighting pieces your transformational purpose is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00606-00306293-00306737": "sort of clear on the face of that that you're doing these this explanatory", "oU0fYODn3f4-00607-00306737-00307298": "roadmap not substituting for reading the text itself that transformational", "oU0fYODn3f4-00608-00307298-00307562": "purpose may also be clear in the audience and the interpersonal", "oU0fYODn3f4-00609-00307562-00308216": "connections between the reader and the listener and so as I think Pernille and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00610-00308216-00308648": "Carrie really highlighted the importance not just of hearing the text spoken but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00611-00308648-00309071": "hearing it spoken in a way that is with someone you have a connection to with", "oU0fYODn3f4-00612-00309071-00309518": "someone in your community with someone who has anchored it in the context of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00613-00309518-00309869": "what you are learning also serves a transformational conserve a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00614-00309869-00310220": "transformational purpose so in that context if you're reading to the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00615-00310220-00310601": "students in your classroom in your school you're creating this new", "oU0fYODn3f4-00616-00310601-00311150": "community context and your educational purpose can be the community tie and the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00617-00311150-00311734": "classroom continuity and the interpersonal relationship um and so", "oU0fYODn3f4-00618-00311734-00312269": "we've told you a lot about what fair use can do but it's important to say that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00619-00312269-00312857": "you really do need to think this through and there are things that we should", "oU0fYODn3f4-00620-00312857-00313538": "caution you that either fair use doesn't sort of broadly enable or that the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00621-00313538-00314026": "specifics really matter and so you have to dig in and be really careful about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00622-00314026-00314393": "understanding your purpose and examining whether or not it's substitutional so", "oU0fYODn3f4-00623-00314393-00314942": "let's talk about the first of those cases here - can we have the next slide -", "oU0fYODn3f4-00624-00314942-00315464": "thanks Mike um so what an example that we get that I think is really attractive", "oU0fYODn3f4-00625-00315464-00316146": "to people um is an instance where our teacher just uh sort of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00626-00316146-00316680": "side-project or to get a lot of things in one place creates a free personal", "oU0fYODn3f4-00627-00316680-00317172": "public YouTube channel where they read picture books out loud and comment on", "oU0fYODn3f4-00628-00317172-00317585": "the reading as they go but it's a wide range of picture books and though they", "oU0fYODn3f4-00629-00317585-00318093": "use it in their classroom perhaps it's also sort of generally promoted as a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00630-00318093-00318645": "public resource and isn't specifically them talking to their class or another", "oU0fYODn3f4-00631-00318645-00319323": "class in their school and also doesn't add a lot of sort of other context to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00632-00319323-00319755": "the books and so in that situation you might also have a public you might post", "oU0fYODn3f4-00633-00319755-00320424": "ads in that broad public YouTube performance then you need to be really", "oU0fYODn3f4-00634-00320424-00321005": "clear about what your purpose is because there you know you run this real risk of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00635-00321005-00321536": "not having a clear enunciated teaching and learning purpose if you're just", "oU0fYODn3f4-00636-00321536-00321963": "doing this because you're like I think these are generally useful that's really", "oU0fYODn3f4-00637-00321963-00322596": "different and so in that situation I would question people that you need to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00638-00322596-00323148": "have a much sort of tighter focus on what your purpose is there so I don't", "oU0fYODn3f4-00639-00323148-00323574": "think that this webinar should be in the sort of the guidance taken as sort of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00640-00323574-00323981": "you know yes you can do it in all contexts we've talked up above about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00641-00323981-00324693": "very specific community and teaching and learning purposes that are different", "oU0fYODn3f4-00642-00324693-00325065": "than those have sort of broadly commercially available audio books", "oU0fYODn3f4-00643-00325065-00325556": "audiobooks and here with a sort of public YouTube channel and you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00644-00325556-00325953": "getting a little closer to that relationship there the other practice we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00645-00325953-00326640": "want to talk about is and the next slide is um if for example you just decided", "oU0fYODn3f4-00646-00326640-00327257": "that instead of purchasing textbooks for other learning materials you would", "oU0fYODn3f4-00647-00327257-00327738": "purchase one copy for your teacher and your teacher would read that out loud", "oU0fYODn3f4-00648-00327738-00328227": "and they would you know read questions from commercial worksheets instead of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00649-00328227-00328650": "getting copies to give out to students and so in that context of what you were", "oU0fYODn3f4-00650-00328650-00329274": "doing is using fair use just to avoid paying for more copies of stuff that is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00651-00329274-00329787": "generally not fair use and so we want to say if you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00652-00329787-00330150": "just saying I want to do exactly what the original thing did and I'm not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00653-00330150-00330627": "adding thing anything except making another copy then that's often um not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00654-00330627-00331008": "fair use and what's important to remember as we compare these two", "oU0fYODn3f4-00655-00331008-00331407": "practices that we say are less likely to be very used with the ones at the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00656-00331407-00331890": "beginning is to think that it is not about the amount you are using right", "oU0fYODn3f4-00657-00331890-00332346": "there are a couple of different contexts in the beginning where we say yes you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00658-00332346-00332709": "using the whole book but you're reading it to your students or the students in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00659-00332709-00333479": "your school or your community and you're providing all of the same modeling and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00660-00333479-00333951": "context and community that you are in the classroom and in those situations", "oU0fYODn3f4-00661-00333951-00334310": "there are absolutely lots of times where reading the whole book is fair use and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00662-00334310-00334787": "here if you're not doing that if you don't have your clear idea what your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00663-00334787-00335211": "educational purposes even though you're using the same amount or perhaps less", "oU0fYODn3f4-00664-00335211-00335576": "but if you don't have a really clear grasp on what that transformational", "oU0fYODn3f4-00665-00335576-00336348": "educational purpose is your fair use rationale is less strong and so we're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00666-00336348-00337128": "gonna go ahead and go we have a final word from Carrie talking a little bit I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00667-00337128-00337602": "think that's like it moves sorry so I'm gonna close that I guess um so going", "oU0fYODn3f4-00668-00337602-00338163": "forward I think I want to just go into these questions here we realize this is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00669-00338163-00338583": "a huge transformation for a lot of people and so um we've answered", "oU0fYODn3f4-00670-00338583-00339054": "questions that were pre submitted but there'll be a link sent out after the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00671-00339054-00339699": "webinar with a it's an automatic email from zoom but it'll have a link to form", "oU0fYODn3f4-00672-00339699-00340041": "to submit some more questions going forward we're gonna try to continue and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00673-00340041-00340602": "updated FAQ and some follow-on webinars so there's some questions we're gonna", "oU0fYODn3f4-00674-00340602-00340989": "cover today and if we don't cover your question there'll be an opportunity to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00675-00340989-00341544": "do that then um but what I want to focus on as we go into the questions is as", "oU0fYODn3f4-00676-00341544-00342105": "Mike said at the beginning all of these practices that we're talking about that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00677-00342105-00342519": "are core to the teaching and learning relationship between teachers and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00678-00342519-00342884": "students our practices that fair use enables", "oU0fYODn3f4-00679-00342884-00343389": "before the emergency it enables during the emergency and there I think the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00680-00343389-00343863": "urgency is increased and the risk is lowered but this is all continues", "oU0fYODn3f4-00681-00343863-00344475": "afterwards and so as we think through understanding fair use and understanding", "oU0fYODn3f4-00682-00344475-00344910": "how it can improve online teaching and learning I would just echo a sort of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00683-00344910-00345573": "earlier call to make sure that we're being brave about understanding", "oU0fYODn3f4-00684-00345573-00346014": "copyright law so that we do the best job reaching all of our students even", "oU0fYODn3f4-00685-00346014-00346665": "students who may in sort of regular situations have an emergency of lack of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00686-00346665-00347217": "access so students with disabilities students who have illness that causes", "oU0fYODn3f4-00687-00347217-00347712": "them to miss school and students and other vulnerable populations who may not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00688-00347712-00348288": "have the same access to reading a lot of materials or the same ability to attend", "oU0fYODn3f4-00689-00348288-00348807": "in person school reliably so that being said we have a number of questions that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00690-00348807-00349416": "um I'm going to read out loud for a bit on the phone and then we will go ahead", "oU0fYODn3f4-00691-00349416-00350169": "and talk through the answers and then we'll have a brief moment at the end for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00692-00350169-00350643": "everyone to follow up so let's start with the first question the first", "oU0fYODn3f4-00693-00350643-00351105": "question was someone who wrote that I would love the clear yes/no answer as to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00694-00351105-00351501": "whether or not it's fair used to read a book aloud and post on a closed platform", "oU0fYODn3f4-00695-00351501-00351927": "such as Google classroom or Schoology and to delete at the end of the year", "oU0fYODn3f4-00696-00351927-00352281": "regardless of publisher the information that has come out so far is very", "oU0fYODn3f4-00697-00352281-00352674": "confusing and complicated when each publisher has different rules and so", "oU0fYODn3f4-00698-00352674-00353214": "there's two parts to this question the first question is is it fair use to do", "oU0fYODn3f4-00699-00353214-00353607": "this thing and the question is is it fair use to read this whole book out", "oU0fYODn3f4-00700-00353607-00354180": "loud and post it on a closed platform and as we just said you have to have a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00701-00354180-00354585": "good idea of why you're reading that book out loud so if you're reading it", "oU0fYODn3f4-00702-00354585-00355350": "out loud because you want to continue the teacher-student relationship that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00703-00355350-00355932": "you've had in the classroom and because you would normally read this book about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00704-00355932-00356430": "frogs to introduce your frog lesson in person and now you are doing that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00705-00356430-00356901": "same work online and so you want to read it to get students thinking about frogs", "oU0fYODn3f4-00706-00356901-00357267": "and you want them to get them thinking about pond ecology and you would have", "oU0fYODn3f4-00707-00357267-00357729": "done that in the classroom and now you're doing it online then yes in those", "oU0fYODn3f4-00708-00357729-00358425": "situations you have a strong fair use argument for that and you have a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00709-00358425-00358881": "reasonable idea here about how you're going to deliver that material to your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00710-00358881-00359232": "audience um the other questions that are there", "oU0fYODn3f4-00711-00359232-00359625": "you know should you delete at the end of the year what are you how do you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00712-00359625-00360033": "evaluate these publisher policies are really actually a separate branch", "oU0fYODn3f4-00713-00360033-00360723": "because um as you heard earlier when you think about can I do this thing the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00714-00360723-00361167": "question of do I have permission is really you don't have to get to that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00715-00361167-00361674": "question if the first answer is I have the right to do this under fair use and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00716-00361674-00362274": "so um as you think through what you can do it's important to remember that if", "oU0fYODn3f4-00717-00362274-00362754": "you have the ability under fair use to do something it doesn't matter what", "oU0fYODn3f4-00718-00362754-00363255": "permission you have been given um the flip side of that is if you have clear", "oU0fYODn3f4-00719-00363255-00363612": "permission to do it you don't have to dig into the fair use analysis but those", "oU0fYODn3f4-00720-00363612-00364008": "two don't affect each other just because what you think you can do under fair use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00721-00364008-00364374": "is different than what someone who has given you permission to do it doesn't", "oU0fYODn3f4-00722-00364374-00364971": "mean that you can't do that those to run sort of in parallel and so not to take", "oU0fYODn3f4-00723-00364971-00365448": "up all the time we're gonna go on to the next question and the next question is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00724-00365448-00365955": "for Peter which is would reading several chapters of a chapter book qualify as", "oU0fYODn3f4-00725-00365955-00366194": "fair use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00726-00366243-00367069": "Thank You Meredith this has been - listening to my my fellow participants", "oU0fYODn3f4-00727-00367069-00367761": "has been you know in a way in education in itself today because what we've heard", "oU0fYODn3f4-00728-00367761-00368607": "about in in in every presentation has been the the range and and breadth of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00729-00368607-00369340": "the different positive value-added uses that teachers and librarians and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00730-00369340-00370267": "students engage in through reading aloud and I hope that if if there is one", "oU0fYODn3f4-00731-00370267-00371004": "message that has come through these presentations it is that transformative", "oU0fYODn3f4-00732-00371004-00371794": "use that concept that is the key to contemporary fair use analysis comes in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00733-00371794-00372231": "many many varieties and flavors and we've heard about some of them today and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00734-00372231-00372810": "I hope that as we carry on and this you you you helped us by submitting", "oU0fYODn3f4-00735-00372810-00373361": "additional questions we will be able to consider and and highlight still others", "oU0fYODn3f4-00736-00373361-00374365": "this is an interesting question because it goes to the issue of purpose there is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00737-00374365-00375073": "no categorical answer to this question it depends on why you're doing it but", "oU0fYODn3f4-00738-00375073-00375828": "let's say for example that you are reading a chapter book to your students", "oU0fYODn3f4-00739-00375828-00376441": "as a way of as a turn of a turn that I've learned in the in the last few days", "oU0fYODn3f4-00740-00376441-00377098": "that that seems very important to me reading them into the class building a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00741-00377098-00377872": "community of expectation and of of shared enjoyment which connects students", "oU0fYODn3f4-00742-00377872-00378381": "who may have different backgrounds and different abilities together as a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00743-00378381-00379485": "community well that is a transformative purpose and if we query the other fair", "oU0fYODn3f4-00744-00379485-00379740": "use criterion that I mentioned earlier and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00745-00379740-00380515": "that we've been rehearsing since is this going to be a a significant substitute", "oU0fYODn3f4-00746-00380515-00381504": "for the the purchase of volumes or commercially books or even commercial", "oU0fYODn3f4-00747-00381504-00382026": "audiobooks I think we all know that in almost every imaginable classroom", "oU0fYODn3f4-00748-00382026-00382695": "setting the answer to that question is going to be no so let's go back then to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00749-00382695-00383292": "the phraseology of the question would reading several chapters of a chapter", "oU0fYODn3f4-00750-00383292-00383844": "will qualify as fair use the answer I think is likely depending on purpose to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00751-00383844-00384750": "be yes and moreover if the answer is yes then it is difficult or impossible to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00752-00384750-00385383": "understand in terms of the sort of fair use analysis that we have been modeling", "oU0fYODn3f4-00753-00385383-00386450": "for you today why the whole book parsed out in chapters would not also be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00754-00386450-00387429": "eligible to read aloud online in a chapter by chapter rendition thank you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00755-00387429-00388142": "Peter the next question it would be if someone records a zoom discussion and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00756-00388142-00388680": "copyright material is discussed or read aloud in full such as like a poem for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00757-00388680-00389073": "example would that be permitted and Peter I think this question would also", "oU0fYODn3f4-00758-00389073-00389689": "be for you if you're capable to come back on and unmute of course and it's a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00759-00389689-00390471": "wonderful question because it implicates several different underlying issues one", "oU0fYODn3f4-00760-00390471-00391218": "thing that one question that a number of you have asked in advance of the webinar", "oU0fYODn3f4-00761-00391218-00391932": "and that is incorporated here is all right maybe it's okay to do these things", "oU0fYODn3f4-00762-00391932-00392595": "live but but can we record them and make those recordings available to our", "oU0fYODn3f4-00763-00392595-00392873": "students the ones who may not be in class", "oU0fYODn3f4-00764-00392873-00393658": "the ones who may want to watch again the ones who would benefit from a an", "oU0fYODn3f4-00765-00393658-00394490": "opportunity to view this content asynchronously and the answer to that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00766-00394490-00395132": "question embedded so to speak in this one is of course as we've tried to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00767-00395132-00395765": "explain the various analysis that we've been modeling is largely although not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00768-00395765-00396599": "entirely independent of the kind of material being read or shown and largely", "oU0fYODn3f4-00769-00396599-00397261": "if not entirely independent of the particular medium that is being used to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00770-00397261-00398171": "make it available and that means that potentially a recording or a recorded", "oU0fYODn3f4-00771-00398171-00399100": "session designed for the use of students would be as eligible as a live one now", "oU0fYODn3f4-00772-00399100-00399722": "here we have another example of an entire let's say an entire work being", "oU0fYODn3f4-00773-00399722-00400432": "used but of course the fact that a literature class let's say it's a let's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00774-00400432-00400976": "say it's an you know it's a it's a high school English course let's the fact", "oU0fYODn3f4-00775-00400976-00401552": "that it literature class in which the goal of the class session is to critique", "oU0fYODn3f4-00776-00401552-00402259": "or to break down or to interpret a poem necessarily involves the reading of the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00777-00402259-00402967": "poem itself well that's like almost that kind of classic garden-variety", "oU0fYODn3f4-00778-00402967-00403456": "non-controversial example of fair use and I mentioned something else too in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00779-00403456-00403904": "connection with this question and that is that especially in the this time of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00780-00403904-00404456": "emergency but even beyond this time of emergency I also think it's probably", "oU0fYODn3f4-00781-00404456-00405305": "just fine for the teacher in this case to distribute the text of this poem to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00782-00405305-00405931": "facility in advance to facilitate the online reading and discussion", "oU0fYODn3f4-00783-00405931-00406705": "fair use has a lot of flexibility and it's that flexibility that makes it", "oU0fYODn3f4-00784-00406705-00407379": "particularly attractive in contrast or comparison to some of the more specific", "oU0fYODn3f4-00785-00407379-00407959": "exceptions of copyright law light for instance that the provisions of the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00786-00407959-00408730": "teach act that I was mentioning earlier thank you Peter and our next question is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00787-00408730-00409285": "for Carrie Russell and so for Carrie we're gonna ask the question of you know do", "oU0fYODn3f4-00788-00409285-00409705": "you need to wait for an approval response from publisher before doing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00789-00409705-00410476": "your reading out loud thank you the answer to the question is no if you have", "oU0fYODn3f4-00790-00410476-00411004": "decided that your use is a fair use there's no need to contact the publisher", "oU0fYODn3f4-00791-00411004-00411391": "to begin with because you've made that determination and fair use is a right", "oU0fYODn3f4-00792-00411391-00411991": "that you should exercise now if you do ask a publisher for permission you might", "oU0fYODn3f4-00793-00411991-00412549": "not hear back from them they may never reply they may reply and say no you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00794-00412549-00412933": "can't do this but again it's not something that should", "oU0fYODn3f4-00795-00412933-00413556": "change your fair use determination I always think of it when I'm talking to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00796-00413556-00414108": "librarians and educators is that you approach fair use from the position of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00797-00414108-00414571": "what you are trying to achieve as a mission in your library or in your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00798-00414571-00415072": "school you know what you're doing more than the publisher knows what you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00799-00415072-00415605": "doing you know why you need to use the materials and you know what the goal is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00800-00415605-00416095": "you might talk to a publisher who has absolutely no idea of what you do in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00801-00416095-00416622": "your school they might have absolutely no idea what fair use is so there's no", "oU0fYODn3f4-00802-00416622-00417088": "need to wait for approval from a publisher before doing your reading if", "oU0fYODn3f4-00803-00417088-00417589": "you have already determined that your use is fair thanks very and we have a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00804-00417589-00417976": "follow-on question for that if you can see the next slide which is is there a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00805-00417976-00418368": "special way we need to give credit to authors or publishers when we read a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00806-00418368-00418891": "book that well online this is not a copyright question but really more of an", "oU0fYODn3f4-00807-00418891-00419322": "ethical kinds of kind of consideration and I feel that you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00808-00419322-00419782": "always should give credit to the author or to provide the bibliographic", "oU0fYODn3f4-00809-00419782-00420277": "information it acknowledges the publisher whenever you use any protected", "oU0fYODn3f4-00810-00420277-00420862": "work whether online or in your classroom or on course reserves it's just a good", "oU0fYODn3f4-00811-00420862-00421435": "idea to give people the fact the fact that these ideas and materials came from", "oU0fYODn3f4-00812-00421435-00422043": "these people and you want to acknowledge that work that they did do you also it's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00813-00422043-00422743": "just part of like being a good scholar or a good student to always cite where", "oU0fYODn3f4-00814-00422743-00423196": "you get your material so I think it's definitely a thing that you should do is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00815-00423196-00423667": "there a special way that you should do it I think that's up to you I think what", "oU0fYODn3f4-00816-00423667-00424276": "makes things most understandable for your listener or your reader is the best", "oU0fYODn3f4-00817-00424276-00424720": "thing to do you don't have to do all kinds of fancy legal language or", "oU0fYODn3f4-00818-00424720-00425131": "anything like that you can just say this is the author this is the publisher you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00819-00425131-00425560": "can get this book from this library if you want or you can get it online from", "oU0fYODn3f4-00820-00425560-00425905": "this publisher so that's the kind of thing that I think you always should do", "oU0fYODn3f4-00821-00425905-00426273": "and do it in a way that makes sense to the people that are receiving that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00822-00426273-00426826": "message great thanks and up next we'll have well with the next question", "oU0fYODn3f4-00823-00426826-00427333": "which says what about recording a read-aloud session and emailing it to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00824-00427333-00427921": "the individual students in a class thanks Meredith so as we've discussed", "oU0fYODn3f4-00825-00427921-00428335": "already if there's an option where you can retain some control of the recording", "oU0fYODn3f4-00826-00428335-00428800": "and explicitly situated in the educational context like an LMS that's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00827-00428800-00429229": "probably best practice in some sense but if that's not available for some of the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00828-00429229-00429522": "reasons Meredith talked about before because of their issues of bandwidth", "oU0fYODn3f4-00829-00429522-00429910": "because it's not possible for your students etc there's nothing in fair use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00830-00429910-00430300": "that limits your ability to record a read aloud ahead of time and email it to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00831-00430300-00430666": "individual students in the course as long as the purpose is supporting the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00832-00430666-00431059": "transformative sort of stuff that you're doing and you're sort of doing best", "oU0fYODn3f4-00833-00431059-00431422": "practice so going back to that North Star of what's the purpose that you're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00834-00431422-00431884": "doing that for thanks well and I think I'm gonna take moderator privileges add", "oU0fYODn3f4-00835-00431884-00432379": "one comment to that but it's really important right now you know we've", "oU0fYODn3f4-00836-00432379-00432814": "talked about how these practices are really", "oU0fYODn3f4-00837-00432814-00433500": "enabled for schools and for teachers in general they're not something that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00838-00433500-00433977": "you're allowed to do just because it's an emergency right now but one thing I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00839-00433977-00434580": "would say it is particularly important right now to make sure that you're not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00840-00434580-00435065": "letting caution about for example keeping something carefully closeted", "oU0fYODn3f4-00841-00435065-00435501": "within LMS you're not letting that caution keep you from reaching all of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00842-00435501-00435980": "your students so if you already had an LMS set up and all your students had", "oU0fYODn3f4-00843-00435980-00436380": "devices and they were regularly used to accessing that that's a really good", "oU0fYODn3f4-00844-00436380-00436892": "distribution channel but if you know that your students mostly don't have LMS", "oU0fYODn3f4-00845-00436892-00437376": "logs and logins and they are using you know their parents phones or they're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00846-00437376-00437805": "using a computer in a library or libraries are closed now but they're", "oU0fYODn3f4-00847-00437805-00438359": "using intermittently accessible materials but in those situations you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00848-00438359-00438869": "should absolutely feel like fair use enables you to do what you need to do to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00849-00438869-00439205": "reach those students and if that's emailing or if that's having something", "oU0fYODn3f4-00850-00439205-00439709": "that might be on an unlisted YouTube channel instead of a private one those", "oU0fYODn3f4-00851-00439709-00440336": "things are are enabled and it's really important that you're putting the the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00852-00440336-00441010": "goal of reaching all of your students up at the top of that fair use analysis", "oU0fYODn3f4-00853-00441010-00441330": "yeah yeah I think that's such a good point I've talked to somebody yesterday", "oU0fYODn3f4-00854-00441330-00441746": "who's parking in the parking lot of buildings to borrow their Wi-Fi for a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00855-00441746-00442196": "little bit right so so how do you reach that student in this time of crisis in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00856-00442196-00442446": "particular but how do we know there are students who wrestle with that all the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00857-00442446-00442664": "time so what do you need to do to connect", "oU0fYODn3f4-00858-00442664-00442892": "with your students is the touchstone for sure", "oU0fYODn3f4-00859-00442892-00443238": "right and so I think if you've made that fair use analysis that says yes I can do", "oU0fYODn3f4-00860-00443238-00443592": "it over the LMS and you hear from a student that's like I can't stay logged", "oU0fYODn3f4-00861-00443592-00444005": "in I need to have a copy I can download you shouldn't feel like fair-use", "oU0fYODn3f4-00862-00444005-00444665": "ties you into one technological route absolutely so the next question after", "oU0fYODn3f4-00863-00444665-00445136": "I've derailed Will on that is doesn't matter what source material you're using", "oU0fYODn3f4-00864-00445136-00445588": "for reading aloud whether it's a personal copy or a library copy or an e-book and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00865-00445588-00446025": "the answer there is it does not I think this question comes from the fact", "oU0fYODn3f4-00866-00446025-00446349": "that there are a lot of copyright exceptions that do have something to say", "oU0fYODn3f4-00867-00446349-00446727": "about that like section 108 the library exception talks about from the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00868-00446727-00447129": "collections in different ways section 110 talks about a lawfully acquired copy", "oU0fYODn3f4-00869-00447129-00447435": "so there are places in the Copyright Act that they asked that question", "oU0fYODn3f4-00870-00447435-00447795": "specifically what's the source of the material fair use is not one of those", "oU0fYODn3f4-00871-00447795-00448032": "places fair use asks that why question that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00872-00448032-00448359": "we've talked about and if your use is transformative and the ways that we've", "oU0fYODn3f4-00873-00448359-00448899": "talked about you're in good shape thanks well and so let's go into the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00874-00448899-00449547": "next question which is we had a question from someone who said that their concept", "oU0fYODn3f4-00875-00449547-00449991": "was to have poets read their own poems or a poem of their choosing which would", "oU0fYODn3f4-00876-00449991-00450389": "focus on fostering a connection amidst the loneliness and social distancing of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00877-00450389-00450912": "coded 19 their audience would be adult and young adult patients at their", "oU0fYODn3f4-00878-00450912-00451404": "hospital their platform would be Facebook and so the question here is", "oU0fYODn3f4-00879-00451404-00451701": "what if you don't have a teacher meeting what if you have someone else I guessed", "oU0fYODn3f4-00880-00451701-00452164": "like poet reading another's work and so this is a question that sort of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00881-00452164-00452616": "broadened the scope a little bit and so we're gonna call on our deep expert", "oU0fYODn3f4-00882-00452616-00453209": "bench and ask Peter to answer that Thank You Meredith I should say that that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00883-00453209-00453963": "reading reading all of the questions that work were submitted in advance many", "oU0fYODn3f4-00884-00453963-00454866": "of them very very poignant this was perhaps the one that really grabbed my", "oU0fYODn3f4-00885-00454866-00455574": "heartstrings the the the question is being asked on behalf of a of us a small", "oU0fYODn3f4-00886-00455574-00456183": "library embedded in a large Medical Center and this is a program that they", "oU0fYODn3f4-00887-00456183-00457085": "are imagining for the moment in which we all now find ourselves and embedded in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00888-00457085-00457751": "and I think our our a lot of the points that that we've been talking about in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00889-00457751-00458487": "the last few minutes so the first thing that I want to emphasize in in thinking", "oU0fYODn3f4-00890-00458487-00459082": "about not so much in giving the answer to the question because although", "oU0fYODn3f4-00891-00459082-00459601": "we can do that and and and I will suggest what my view is in a moment the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00892-00459601-00460230": "real point of this webinar of course is to help you to become more confident and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00893-00460230-00461073": "more more engaged in thinking through these issues for yourselves and making", "oU0fYODn3f4-00894-00461073-00461605": "good decisions which at least in the present moment will also be low risk", "oU0fYODn3f4-00895-00461605-00462507": "decisions so it isn't a conventional audience it's not students and it's not", "oU0fYODn3f4-00896-00462507-00463335": "a a group of attendees at a at a regularly scheduled public library read", "oU0fYODn3f4-00897-00463335-00463997": "aloud both of which we've talked about here we are talking about an audience of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00898-00463997-00464985": "adult and young adult hospital patients and the goal isn't to teach a lesson as", "oU0fYODn3f4-00899-00464985-00466078": "it would be in the case of a - a school-based online read aloud it is to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00900-00466078-00466852": "as the questioner put it better than I can address the the loneliness and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00901-00466852-00467878": "isolation that both hospitalization and social distancing in it generate is this", "oU0fYODn3f4-00902-00467878-00468713": "kind of building of a community is this kind of addressing through an activity", "oU0fYODn3f4-00903-00468713-00469521": "the the the fears and anxieties of the temporary community of of hospital", "oU0fYODn3f4-00904-00469521-00470257": "patients eight transformative purpose if if I could do it I would ask for a show", "oU0fYODn3f4-00905-00470257-00470992": "of ents and if if I won't predict to that we would get an overwhelming", "oU0fYODn3f4-00906-00470992-00471648": "response favoring this as a transformative use so then we have this", "oU0fYODn3f4-00907-00471648-00472485": "question of platform his Facebook in in the normal circumstance the best vehicle", "oU0fYODn3f4-00908-00472485-00473560": "for engaging a reading community in a read aloud activity we've already talked", "oU0fYODn3f4-00909-00473560-00474085": "about some reasons why that might be so although obviously there are ways of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00910-00474085-00474921": "managing of Facebook distribution or Facebook performance that are more and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00911-00474921-00475717": "ways that are less conducive with fair use but the point here is the point mill", "oU0fYODn3f4-00912-00475717-00476455": "made so well earlier on and that is the in this in this case the the best is the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00913-00476455-00476863": "enemy of the good Facebook is what is available the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00914-00476863-00477297": "purpose is clearly a transformative value a transformative value added", "oU0fYODn3f4-00915-00477297-00477921": "purpose and the likelihood that there is going to be some kind of competition for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00916-00477921-00478627": "the the the booming market in the booming market in pre-record read alouds", "oU0fYODn3f4-00917-00478627-00479281": "of poetry is small so then we have the last question doesn't matter who's the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00918-00479281-00479718": "reader and here we've already addressed the question but I want to make the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00919-00479718-00480522": "point literally extremely clear it's great for teachers to do realize it's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00920-00480522-00480810": "great for librarians degree to let do read aloud's", "oU0fYODn3f4-00921-00480810-00481405": "and it's great for guests in the classroom there were physical classroom", "oU0fYODn3f4-00922-00481405-00482031": "and in this case the virtual classroom or guests in the library in this case", "oU0fYODn3f4-00923-00482031-00482878": "the the poets who are going to select and read aloud and in so doing interpret", "oU0fYODn3f4-00924-00482878-00483447": "since every read aloud is an interpretation one another is work they", "oU0fYODn3f4-00925-00483447-00484215": "are fully qualified so again this this example moved me when I read it and I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00926-00484215-00485008": "hope that the the the confidence-building function that that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00927-00485008-00485707": "we have intended for this webinar will make it possible to go forward in in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00928-00485707-00486336": "this in this enterprise with - with - with with no anxiety and a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00929-00486336-00486965": "and a you know head held high thank you Peter", "oU0fYODn3f4-00930-00486965-00487651": "so we really have one last question and we have two panelists who will sorry", "oU0fYODn3f4-00931-00487651-00488085": "next slide please two panelists who will take that in turn", "oU0fYODn3f4-00932-00488085-00488874": "and the question is do you predict that current copyright concerns over sharing", "oU0fYODn3f4-00933-00488874-00489567": "books online will shift due to covin 19 second stances in other words since we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00934-00489567-00490041": "have to share online to do our jobs and to serve our educational mission which", "oU0fYODn3f4-00935-00490041-00490434": "benefit society you know will this sort of broaden our interpretation of fair", "oU0fYODn3f4-00936-00490434-00490876": "use and so to talk about sort of the current moment and then the emergency", "oU0fYODn3f4-00937-00490876-00491286": "going forward we have first Kristina Ishmael and then we'll have through", "oU0fYODn3f4-00938-00491286-00491830": "Prue Adler, so Kristina please go ahead yeah I think this goes back to thinking about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00939-00491830-00492334": "serving every student so this certainly applies again in in this instance", "oU0fYODn3f4-00940-00492334-00492660": "whether we're in an emergency whether there were applying blended learning", "oU0fYODn3f4-00941-00492660-00493305": "techniques or even online learning or online school more specifically that we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00942-00493305-00493635": "are serving all students and every student for that matter I also think", "oU0fYODn3f4-00943-00493635-00494126": "that this is a great conversation starter and kind of starting point for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00944-00494126-00494610": "talking about copyright various and Creative Commons with educators in", "oU0fYODn3f4-00945-00494610-00495009": "general so this comes up a lot in the trainings that I do I know it comes up", "oU0fYODn3f4-00946-00495009-00495526": "in trainings that you do Meredith with with educators but we need to start", "oU0fYODn3f4-00947-00495526-00495786": "having a conversation smell with in-service teachers but also with", "oU0fYODn3f4-00948-00495786-00496140": "pre-service teachers so that we can reach out to colleges of education to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00949-00496140-00496828": "address this so that educators have more confidence in being let's just say going", "oU0fYODn3f4-00950-00496828-00497284": "through the four factors of fair use and really making sure that they are are you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00951-00497284-00497634": "know using transformative kind of practices when they're doing things", "oU0fYODn3f4-00952-00497634-00498318": "online or even in the classroom so I don't know if it necessarily changes the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00953-00498318-00498651": "interpretation of fair use necessarily but I think that it certainly can", "oU0fYODn3f4-00954-00498651-00499115": "empower us as educators to have more confidence in having these conversations", "oU0fYODn3f4-00955-00499115-00499681": "thank you and Prue I know you had been a partner", "oU0fYODn3f4-00956-00499681-00500053": "with us on this project and I've worked specifically on a lot of issues of", "oU0fYODn3f4-00957-00500053-00500602": "equity and access nobody to see if you wanted to speak for a moment about your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00958-00500602-00501100": "perspective on that oh sure and thank you very much Meredith and thank you for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00959-00501100-00501607": "everybody it's been as Peter mentioned really educational and eliminating this", "oU0fYODn3f4-00960-00501607-00502438": "afternoon and I guess what I I wanted to sort of close women in part was as you", "oU0fYODn3f4-00961-00502438-00503071": "heard all this afternoon fair use is already very broad and it permits many", "oU0fYODn3f4-00962-00503071-00503793": "of the social and educational benefits to users and to you alike and I think we", "oU0fYODn3f4-00963-00503793-00504304": "all want to bring that home in that it's not necessarily that it's going to be", "oU0fYODn3f4-00964-00504304-00504822": "broadened it already is very broad and allows you to do many of the things that", "oU0fYODn3f4-00965-00504822-00505431": "you need to do both today in this current situation and going forward I", "oU0fYODn3f4-00966-00505431-00506266": "think the key goal here is equitable access for all learners so that exercising", "oU0fYODn3f4-00967-00506266-00506785": "fair use is very fundamental to achieving this goal and I'd give you one", "oU0fYODn3f4-00968-00506785-00507283": "example and Peter and others can go into more in depth about it but there was a", "oU0fYODn3f4-00969-00507283-00508054": "court decision within the last several years that allowed access to a very", "oU0fYODn3f4-00970-00508054-00508654": "large millions of volumes of digitized works a digital repository called", "oU0fYODn3f4-00971-00508654-00509341": "Hathi Trust which strongly supported access to these texts for educational", "oU0fYODn3f4-00972-00509341-00509779": "reasons in particular it noted the importance of access to the digital", "oU0fYODn3f4-00973-00509779-00510322": "library digital repository for those who are visually impaired and so I think", "oU0fYODn3f4-00974-00510322-00510928": "that it's not only that fair use empower you to do the kind of work that you want", "oU0fYODn3f4-00975-00510928-00511692": "to do for your students and your members of your community but it also supports", "oU0fYODn3f4-00976-00511692-00512377": "those learners at very different levels with very different achievement levels", "oU0fYODn3f4-00977-00512377-00513009": "in ways that empower and embrace the fairness", "oU0fYODn3f4-00978-00513009-00513460": "provisions that you should take advantage of I don't know if anybody", "oU0fYODn3f4-00979-00513460-00513939": "else wants to embellish on that but I think that is something extremely", "oU0fYODn3f4-00980-00513939-00514543": "important to look at equitable access for all learners as you consider the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00981-00514543-00515092": "fair use provisions in the context of your individual case your individual", "oU0fYODn3f4-00982-00515092-00515647": "setting thank you so much Prue I don't think we could have anyone better than", "oU0fYODn3f4-00983-00515647-00516187": "you to close out that question and so um but there we could just go to the last", "oU0fYODn3f4-00984-00516187-00516883": "slide and I want to say I think you know as Prue had had mentioned there and as", "oU0fYODn3f4-00985-00516883-00517591": "we've talked about throughout fair use enables a really wide range of practices", "oU0fYODn3f4-00986-00517591-00517996": "you need to transition to online learning and to serve all of your", "oU0fYODn3f4-00987-00517996-00518524": "students and I think um you know a lot of the discussion around this comes out", "oU0fYODn3f4-00988-00518524-00519043": "of I think a really strong sense of responsibility from teachers and", "oU0fYODn3f4-00989-00519043-00519529": "librarians to understand and follow the rules and I think that's really", "oU0fYODn3f4-00990-00519529-00520314": "admirable but I would encourage teachers and staff and librarians to think about", "oU0fYODn3f4-00991-00520314-00520645": "understanding those rules and taking advantage of them", "oU0fYODn3f4-00992-00520645-00521227": "not of staying sort of ten steps back because I think you really leave a lot", "oU0fYODn3f4-00993-00521227-00521689": "of important teaching and learning opportunities on the table on the shelf", "oU0fYODn3f4-00994-00521689-00522502": "as it were if you don't take advantage of the freedom that fair use intends to", "oU0fYODn3f4-00995-00522502-00523159": "provide for educators to really engage with existing materials so um we hope", "oU0fYODn3f4-00996-00523159-00523618": "this has been useful the URL that is displayed on the screen is the URL for", "oU0fYODn3f4-00997-00523618-00524392": "the guidance document um in the bottom of that first page it has a link to the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00998-00524392-00524863": "page of youtube channel where this will be archived it has a link to the", "oU0fYODn3f4-00999-00524863-00525403": "question form where you can submit ongoing questions it also has a link to", "oU0fYODn3f4-01000-00525403-00525815": "the bios for all the presenters and so as we go forward we know that we have", "oU0fYODn3f4-01001-00525815-00526253": "answered all of the questions we also cannot answer individual questions but", "oU0fYODn3f4-01002-00526253-00526976": "we can continue to do webinars and put a fake use and help you guys as you build", "oU0fYODn3f4-01003-00526976-00527537": "this airplane that is in flight and so um please continue to submit questions", "oU0fYODn3f4-01004-00527537-00528059": "you'll get a follow-up email tomorrow through zoom that has all this", "oU0fYODn3f4-01005-00528059-00528512": "information but it is also at this URL right now the slides are actually not up", "oU0fYODn3f4-01006-00528512-00529030": "there yet but they will be shortly I also know that as we talked through this", "oU0fYODn3f4-01007-00529030-00529559": "we addressed some questions for libraries but might try to address sort", "oU0fYODn3f4-01008-00529559-00529915": "of other library-specific questions going forward if there's demand so feel", "oU0fYODn3f4-01009-00529915-00530398": "free to put those questions in as well um I want to deep thank you to those of", "oU0fYODn3f4-01010-00530398-00530963": "you who took an hour and a half to talk about copyright law um and all of my", "oU0fYODn3f4-01011-00530963-00531821": "co-presenters thank you so much thank you so much thanks everyone", "oU0fYODn3f4-01012-00531821-00533264": "Thanks Will - oh you're muted Peter let me unmute you just wanting to add and say", "oU0fYODn3f4-01013-00533264-00533869": "again to everyone who spent this time with us thank you very very much."}}, {"audio_id": "oU7Pr0iugVo", "text": {"oU7Pr0iugVo-00000-00000348-00000564": "foreign", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00001-00001542-00002088": "hey it's Jackie and welcome back to my Vlog Channel I'm currently trying to set up a set", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00002-00002088-00002652": "for makeup tutorials so let me know if you think this lighting is good because it is natural light", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00003-00002652-00003174": "I have two different Windows facing me but then it's clutter in the back so I just hung this", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00004-00003174-00003618": "curtain let me know what you think um I wish it was like a little bit more interesting but", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00005-00003618-00004260": "I'm gonna see how it goes because I'm never happy with my setup for YouTube videos but anyways today", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00006-00004260-00004770": "I'm going to take you to shoot some fun content I've been trying to get into the vertical Style", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00007-00004770-00005274": "videos and we're doing a really fun fashion video which I don't normally do but I got an", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00008-00005274-00005760": "amazing package from my beachy side and they did a collaboration with Emily in Paris so it's pop", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00009-00005760-00006366": "culture themed and I can't wait to show you guys these amazing pieces look at the tag it is so cute", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00010-00006522-00007104": "my beachy side carries a luxury resort wear and this top Emily Wears in one of the episodes", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00011-00007338-00007992": "next up we have this super fun nautical dress so this is off the shoulders you'll see all", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00012-00007992-00008376": "these it tried on in different locations in a minute I'm not sure that these pants", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00013-00008376-00009306": "will fit I hope so I love the details here again everything is so well made let's try", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00014-00009690-00009708": "theses on", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00015-00010986-00011616": "I'll have to have a backup plan for the outfit so cute though this is one of", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00016-00011616-00012024": "my favorite pieces that drew me to the site I love this cover up for the beach", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00017-00012108-00013110": "matching top they have a similar Vibe which is fun but hopefully these shorts fit better okay perfect", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00018-00013434-00014328": "last thing in the package is this right here the box is so nautical I'm Gonna Keep The Box so cute", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00019-00014916-00015168": "now I'm gonna plan how I'm gonna style these pieces", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00020-00016110-00016236": "foreign", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00021-00016866-00017418": "filming look one we found this super cute a bakery and I loved the blue I thought it really matched", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00022-00018798-00019644": "okay so my vision for this Tiktok was something like this", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00023-00019890-00020256": "but I could not do that for the life of me me and Tyler could not figure it out", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00024-00020256-00020736": "so I think it's just gonna be opposing Tick Tock where I show off these amazing", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00025-00020736-00021228": "pieces but I really don't understand like transitions I want to learn because I think", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00026-00021228-00021588": "it's super cool but yeah me and Tyler just got real frustrated with each other", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00027-00021786-00022290": "it's not happening today but now on my shot list we are headed to the Light Tower the lighthouse", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00028-00022506-00022596": "okay", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00029-00022596-00023064": "got the dress on", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00030-00023346-00023580": "and we're here at the Lighthouse where is it", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00031-00024282-00024618": "welcome to the jungle", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00032-00026286-00026412": "foreign", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00033-00026627-00026795": "Augustine", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00034-00027072-00027630": "in the third and my favorite look from my beachy side we just got back from the lighthouse and we", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00035-00027630-00028104": "didn't even go up the stairs it was so hot in my like armpits were trapped because it", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00036-00028104-00028560": "was an off the shoulder dress so um yeah we didn't go all the way up I wanted it to be", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00037-00028560-00029112": "a very nautical but then we just found another location that was right by there and now we're", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00038-00029112-00029652": "at Anastasia State Park for the beachy look and there's Tyler staring at me oh", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00039-00029868-00030072": "Beach breezes much better", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00040-00032010-00033558": "we just passed like massive snakes there's a snake on a little girl I don't want to record", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00041-00033558-00034032": "her oh my God what the heck is wrong with people look over a snake pit to get to dinner", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00042-00034134-00034728": "Tyler hates snakes wait it's closed ...do you need a popsicle and a sangria put sangria?", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00043-00035628-00036084": "favorite restaurant was closed and I got eaten alive by bugs I have like", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00044-00036084-00036588": "20 something bites so we're in the car we're headed to a restaurant indoors", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00045-00037134-00037398": "I'm on a Cold Stone Creamery kick right now", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00046-00037470-00038250": "drunk me really wanted this good times good night I'll see you guys tomorrow", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00047-00038682-00039348": "it's a stormy day today we get so much rain in St Augustine in August and I was going over my", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00048-00039348-00039960": "footage from yesterday and I realized whenever I show food I show like the least healthy option", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00049-00039960-00040422": "and I don't eat like that all the time like when I go out and I'm buying food Thunder", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00050-00040512-00041022": "um I will get the tastiest option always but when I'm home I think I eat fairly healthy so", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00051-00041022-00041382": "I wanted to share what I eat in a day let's start out with what I have for breakfast", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00052-00041850-00042210": "the tastiest yogurt brand I love these", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00053-00042876-00042972": "hi Kitty", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00054-00043782-00043860": "hey baby", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00055-00044808-00045702": "by the way if you like this lipstick it's by Rose inc which is my new obsession I", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00056-00045702-00046176": "just think the brand is so Chic so this is the shade intuitive", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00057-00046176-00046482": "and I'm pretty sure I use this in the Haley Bieber tutorial as well", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00058-00047142-00047580": "I've been getting PR from Rose Inc and this is their latest solar collection and they", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00059-00047580-00048024": "also gifted me a wear nothing underneath classic shirt which is really cool I love", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00060-00048024-00048468": "the cream bronzer it's great for a bit of natural contour and these highlighters look", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00061-00048468-00048936": "beautiful and subtle on the skin I'm wearing this one today it is the shade brilliant", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00062-00049110-00049614": "you can just blend it in with your fingers it's not streaky at all like the Charlotte Tilbury my", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00063-00049614-00050352": "all-time favorite um Spotlight highlighter went blank for a minute that one can look streaky if", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00064-00050352-00050904": "you don't blend it out it's a little bit of a thicker formula so this is very natural", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00065-00051168-00051234": "I just love it", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00066-00051479-00052116": "also I got this new candle that I've been loving and I was just sent a copy of a interview that I", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00067-00052116-00052608": "did with San Diego Voyager so I will have this link down below if you want to read", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00068-00053610-00053982": "I'm back for lunch I'm starving and I'm wearing this really cozy sweater", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00069-00053982-00054491": "from Abercrombie and finch Lauren got me this and we're making egg salad sandwich", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00070-00054491-00054948": "sandwich sandwiches and I don't like egg salad from the store like any store-bought", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00071-00054948-00055494": "egg salad I have not liked but my mom makes an amazing version so I asked her", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00072-00055494-00056070": "to send me the recipe and let's see if I can do this Justice boiling some water", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00073-00056340-00056664": "okay as that's boiling I'm gonna cut up some carrots", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00074-00057084-00058002": "I think these cut really small this is my new technique ow don't do my technique and some celery", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00075-00058314-00059322": "sliced green onion six eggs the salmon really gently if they hit the bottom they might crack", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00076-00059429-00059820": "so you just have to just be just ease them in these tongs yes", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00077-00059928-00060360": "I don't know how many eggs do you need six this is not a plot", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00078-00060641-00061548": "oh did it crack I don't think so oh yeah I did but leave it in there leave it in there why", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00079-00062796-00062952": "okay the final egg", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00080-00063912-00064314": "you're supposed to just cover the eggs with the lid and then move it off the heat", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00081-00064379-00064860": "and I have a timer on for like five minutes because I already have it over the heat for like", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00082-00064860-00065429": "four and then I have a makeshift pan with water and a bunch of ice to pull them down", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00083-00065538-00065736": "eggs and ice for about 10 minutes", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00084-00066336-00066792": "let me first boiled egg", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00085-00067566-00067644": "looks good", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00086-00068826-00069642": "two yellow mustard adding some pepper", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00087-00069900-00070404": "salt Dill", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00088-00070692-00071334": "oh probably be good though a couple drops of vinegar", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00089-00071658-00072216": "Yep this looks like my mom's I am so proud that was such a mission I thought it was", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00090-00072216-00072642": "going to be way less steps and like way easier than that so I was gonna", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00091-00072642-00073050": "do a dinner recipe but we're just gonna stop at lunch let's give this a taste", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00092-00073272-00073296": "foreign", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00093-00074100-00074712": "Cape Cod chips on the side I freaking love these just a couple oh", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00094-00075144-00075252": "eat lit", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00095-00075510-00076008": "and there you have the best egg salad sandwich recipe give it a try and I hope", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00096-00076008-00076506": "you guys enjoyed this whole Florida day of my late Vlog some what I eat recipes and the", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00097-00076506-00076956": "Emily in Paris haul if you do make sure you give it a thumbs up and subscribe for more", "oU7Pr0iugVo-00098-00076956-00077688": "Vlogs and I'll see you in my next one bye I bring to you Tyler thank you you're welcome"}}, {"audio_id": "oUjw1UbYdbM", "text": {"oUjw1UbYdbM-00000-00000032-00000764": "In life, like there's ups and downs. Month by month, week by week, and quite frankly,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00001-00000764-00001387": "day by day, there are ups and downs in your day. And every day is not going to be sunshine", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00002-00001387-00002237": "and rainbows. But if you can find the happiness in each day, and if you can put yourself in", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00003-00002237-00002757": "a place where you're more aware of it, more cognizant of it when it's happening, then", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00004-00002757-00003393": "at the end of the day, when you look back, you can see the positives. You can see the", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00005-00003393-00004004": "happy moments, the moments that you did enjoy and not just focused on the day as a whole,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00006-00004004-00004557": "which may have been a negative connotation that you can pinpoint those bright moments", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00007-00004557-00006512": "and a dark day, and it can give you more excitement for the next day. What's up everybody? Welcome", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00008-00006512-00007204": "to the Sales Wolves Podcast. As always, I'm your host, Tyler Jack Harris and I am a Sales", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00009-00007204-00008163": "Wolf. That's right, we're back, just like we are every single week. If you're turning", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00010-00008163-00008562": "tuning in for the, turning in, you're turning in for the first time don't even know what", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00011-00008562-00009102": "that would mean. If you are tuning in for the first time, this is Episode 153. So you've", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00012-00009102-00009704": "got a lot of catching up to do. And while you're there, subscribe and leave a rating", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00013-00009704-00010286": "on the podcast, it would really help. So go do that now and then come back. Okay, now", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00014-00010286-00011072": "we're back. So Episode 153 of the Sales Wolves Podcast. And on this episode, I want to talk", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00015-00011072-00012318": "about happiness. And I want to start off by saying that success is not the key to happiness.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00016-00012318-00013180": "Happiness is the key to success. And so we're in a new year. It's 2020. What can you do", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00017-00013180-00013841": "this year to be more happy? You know I watched this video a while back and I've actually", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00018-00013841-00014509": "watched a number of times with Sadhguru, it's his interview with Tom Bilyeu on the Impact", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00019-00014509-00015151": "Theory Podcast; it's incredible. I highly recommend you go checking it out. That guy", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00020-00015151-00016156": "is like the wisest man and his laugh is like infectious because his laugh like comes from", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00021-00016156-00016915": "this place of like, \"Yeah, it's funny, but it's more funny because I know infinitely", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00022-00016915-00017472": "more about what I'm talking about the new do.\" And it's just this like deep soulful", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00023-00017472-00018141": "laugh. But I just got off on a tangent there. In that video, he talks about happiness, and", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00024-00018141-00018726": "that happiness is a choice. And that you can choose to be miserable or that you can choose", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00025-00018726-00019715": "to be happy in any and all circumstances. That if I decided that Kaytlyn makes me miserable,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00026-00019715-00020790": "then just her entering the room just now, I'm a miserable person, and I am miserable.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00027-00020790-00021744": "So if we have this choice in life, of being miserable or being happy, of course, we would", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00028-00021744-00022416": "choose happy. But do your actions prove that choice? Do the things that you're doing on", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00029-00022416-00023170": "a daily basis lead you to that happiness. And so, you know, it's it's simple to sit", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00030-00023170-00023743": "up here and say happiness is a choice. So be happy. Well, it's a far more complex process", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00031-00023743-00024734": "than that And so, I've really been in a lot of thought on what that process would look", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00032-00024734-00025614": "like, as we ended 2019 and came into 2020. And like many, or all of you, looking at goals", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00033-00025614-00026425": "for the new year, but trying to look at them, for me in a little bit of a different perspective.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00034-00026425-00027099": "And that perspective was how can I be happier in 2020? And so I started thinking about how", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00035-00027099-00027460": "could I, you know how could I figure that out? Like how, can how can, you know, there's", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00036-00027460-00027980": "a there's a process and there's a system for everything? How can I create some type of", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00037-00027980-00028984": "process or, or do some type of practice, to make it more, make myself more aware of how", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00038-00028984-00029797": "I could ultimately be happier and the things that I would need to do to be consciously", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00039-00029797-00030356": "improving on my happiness on a daily basis. And so I wanted to propose that to you. And", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00040-00030356-00030989": "it's perfect timing because I literally just did this yesterday. I came to the office,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00041-00030989-00031984": "nobody was here. I was by myself, and I spent probably three or four hours doing this. So", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00042-00031984-00032825": "I'll preface by saying it will take some time. But I came out of this process, looking back", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00043-00032825-00033702": "on that period of time as, as being invaluable and quite easily worth the time that I spent.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00044-00033702-00034313": "So here's what I did. Everyone has a phone, and they have a phone that takes pictures.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00045-00034313-00035118": "And generally, when you go about your daily life, you take pictures, you know, of important", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00046-00035118-00035881": "stuff. You take pictures of, you know, things that you're enjoying or things that for whatever", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00047-00035881-00036430": "reason, you know, made an impact. There's certainly a lot of other things we take pictures", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00048-00036430-00036980": "of, but we don't necessarily take pictures of things that were unenjoyable or that were", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00049-00036980-00037643": "miserble. Right? So I just sat here at my desk and I scrolled through my phone and I", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00050-00037643-00038429": "scrolled through every photo that I took in 2019 and 2018. Which took a long time. Because", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00051-00038429-00038858": "I take a lot of photos. This was thousands of photos that I've poured through, I've got", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00052-00038858-00039384": "like 60,000 photos on my phone. So the last two years I mean, it was thousands of photos", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00053-00039384-00039833": "that I that I scrolled through. But I tried to do it slow enough to where look at each", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00054-00039833-00040225": "individual picture. I didn't swipe left and just go through it that way. I was looking", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00055-00040225-00041313": "at them in the in the album. But I specifically was searching for pictures that I know, in", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00056-00041313-00042066": "that moment I was happy. In the picture I could be smiling, or it could just be a picture", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00057-00042066-00042716": "that I remember, like what was going on then I remember what I was doing then. And I remember", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00058-00042716-00043549": "like really, really enjoying that time. And so what I would do was I would just click", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00059-00043549-00044031": "on them and put them in an album, click on them and put them in an album, click on them", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00060-00044031-00045274": "and put them in an album. And it was, it was interesting. A very introspective process.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00061-00045274-00045917": "I would say as, as most of you who'd be willing to go and do this yourself, which I'm obviously", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00062-00045917-00046527": "recommending that there can be a lot of emotions that come into play as you go through that", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00063-00046527-00046921": "process. You were experiencing a lot of different events over the last year and that's probably", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00064-00046921-00047686": "what I'd recommend is just looking at the last year, but I want to say as a caveat to", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00065-00047686-00048539": "this, or, not really a warning, but just a caveat that if you have trouble finding a", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00066-00048539-00049084": "lot of pictures, that that's, you know, certainly a symptom of something that needs to be addressed,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00067-00049084-00049703": "right? If you're having a hard time finding pictures of yourself happy, then you need", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00068-00049703-00050024": "to get happier. And there's a lot of things that need to go into that, which I'm not going", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00069-00050024-00050689": "to go into, and I'm not qualified to go into. But what I did was I then took all those photos,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00070-00050689-00051269": "which, you know, there ended up being well over 100 photos. What I didn't do was try", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00071-00051269-00051717": "to replicate a lot of things like, you know, a picture of me, there's, there was a picture", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00072-00051717-00052251": "of me doing the Sales Wolves Podcast. I didn't put 50 pictures of there, you know, one was", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00073-00052251-00052983": "enough. So not duplicating a lot of the same feelings or same environments or same activities,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00074-00052983-00053797": "but ended up with over 100 pictures. And then I transferred those photos to my computer", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00075-00053797-00054512": "and for those that don't have any graphics background or, you know, creative background,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00076-00054512-00055140": "like myself, I just used PowerPoint. And I took all those pictures and made like a collage.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00077-00055140-00055779": "It ended up being four pages of just this collage of images from the last two years", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00078-00055779-00056500": "for me and really just the last year is most important. And I just started observing, just", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00079-00056500-00057107": "like looking at all these photos kind of all like, mapped out in front of you, and started", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00080-00057107-00057746": "looking at correlations between the things that I was doing. A lot of the majority of", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00081-00057746-00058204": "the photos for me were with family, with my wife and with my daughter in different places", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00082-00058204-00058958": "that we've been to. But the whole goal of this exercise is to figure out how you can", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00083-00058958-00059814": "do more of those things in 2020. How you can put yourself in a position to experience more", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00084-00059814-00060247": "happiness just simply by doing more of those things that you did last year that made you", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00085-00060247-00060980": "happy. Like, this is a logical, simple thought process, right? But what's logical and simple", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00086-00060980-00061455": "isn't always what we do. A lot of times, you'll say, \"Well, I'm just going to meditate on", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00087-00061455-00061988": "it. I'm just going to think about it and figure these things out.\" But I found that this exercise", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00088-00061988-00062578": "actually was tremendously helpful in figuring out like, what are the things that I do that", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00089-00062578-00063086": "I get genuine enjoyment out of? A lot of it was the social media stuff that I do. A lot", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00090-00063086-00063789": "of it was pictures of live Q and A's, pictures of speaking on stage, pictures of recording", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00091-00063789-00064366": "Modern Man episodes, and vlog episodes and various things that I've done in regards to", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00092-00064366-00065665": "my personal brand. But a lot of it was surprising, I think. That circumstances where at as a", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00093-00065665-00066373": "whole, that particular task or activity or job responsibility didn't necessarily have", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00094-00066373-00067130": "the greatest connotation or the greatest feeling when I remember it, but seeing a certain picture", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00095-00067130-00067652": "from it I'm like, \"Man, that was that part was really, really fun.\" You know, different", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00096-00067652-00068172": "things like that the trainings that I've been doing in the field with people traveling all", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00097-00068172-00068799": "over the country, the last six months of the year, that was a difficult time. Like it was", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00098-00068799-00069487": "difficult to travel, you know, to 16 different states in like 20 weeks or so. But there were", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00099-00069487-00070159": "parts of it, that I had photos of that I really, really enjoyed. Boot camp trainings that we", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00100-00070159-00070733": "do here with our new agents. When I look back, at the end of that weekend on Sunday, I'm", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00101-00070733-00071159": "usually very drained and I look back and I'm like, \"Man, that was a difficult weekend.\"", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00102-00071159-00071654": "But a lot of the pictures came from those boot camp trainings, because there's moments", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00103-00071654-00072032": "in each of those trainings that were just a lot of fun, and I genuinely enjoyed and", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00104-00072032-00072758": "was happy during that process. And other just seemingly mundane things that you go through", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00105-00072758-00073362": "in your business, that I could identify specific times that, you know, that was a good, positive", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00106-00073362-00074298": "happy moment. And so I really got a lot of clarity, going through this exercise. I was", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00107-00074298-00075703": "able to take what I saw, and start creating a new map or a new collage kind of in my head", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00108-00075703-00076584": "of how I could create more of those moments in 2020. And, you know, time will tell, but", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00109-00076584-00077188": "I believe that that is going to be a good strategy. Like I believe, you know, I've got", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00110-00077188-00077750": "a journal that I'm keeping this year and I've got those pages folded up in there, to be", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00111-00077750-00078353": "able to reference those you know, on a periodic basis just to remind myself, remind myself", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00112-00078353-00078937": "not only of the things that I, that made me happy, but it's a reminder of being more present", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00113-00078937-00079829": "in the moment and realizing how happy you are, where you are, is super important. Because", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00114-00079829-00080581": "there's some quote that I heard a while back, it was, you know, \"Not every day is good,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00115-00080581-00081173": "but there's good in every day.\" And I've used that phrase in a lot of different parallels,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00116-00081173-00081805": "like, you know, I'm not motivated every day, but every day I'm motivated. And the reality", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00117-00081805-00082605": "is in life, like there's ups and downs, month by month, week by week, and quite frankly,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00118-00082605-00083229": "day by day, there are ups and downs in your day, and every day is not going to be sunshine", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00119-00083229-00084079": "and rainbows. But if you can find the happiness in each day, and if you can put yourself in", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00120-00084079-00084599": "a place where you're more aware of it, more cognizant of it when it's happening, then", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00121-00084599-00085236": "at the end of the day, when you look back, you can see the positive. So you can see the", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00122-00085236-00085847": "happy moments, the moments that you did enjoy, and not just focus on the day as a whole,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00123-00085847-00086399": "which may have been a negative connotation that you can pinpoint those bright moments", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00124-00086399-00087099": "and a dark day. And it can give you more excitement for the next day, more drive and motivation", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00125-00087099-00087577": "for the next day. More, you know, feeling of purpose and passion when you wake up the", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00126-00087577-00088088": "next day to go do maybe the exact same thing again, but how can I create more of those", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00127-00088088-00088898": "moments tomorrow? And so I would highly recommend taking the couple hours it'll take I'm sure", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00128-00088898-00089392": "if you're just in one year, you know, I probably take more photos than the most. It shouldn't", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00129-00089392-00090073": "take you too long. But I think if you have that laid out for you visually I think you'd", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00130-00090073-00090849": "be pleasantly surprised by the amount of clarity it gives you in the direction to take your", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00131-00090849-00091477": "year. And the direction that you know, you need to take your, you know, daily activities", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00132-00091477-00092319": "and daily mindset. You know, through that process, it really gave me a lot of clarity", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00133-00092319-00093048": "on the things that I don't want to do as well, which is equally as important. But it put", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00134-00093048-00093679": "everything into perspective. You know, I'm traveling a lot, but the vast majority of", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00135-00093679-00094254": "my pictures were with my family. That creates some friction. And I've got to figure out", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00136-00094254-00095015": "a way to be home more. A lot of pictures were from my time in Nicaragua, and in my time", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00137-00095015-00095663": "where I was giving of my time and resources and energy. And I know that I've already put", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00138-00095663-00096316": "plans in place for that to be a larger, play a larger role in 2020 for me, so I know in", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00139-00096316-00096921": "and of itself that that will bring more happiness. But I think if we can just, you know, and", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00140-00096921-00097959": "the goal of this podcast is really to take the emphasis off success being monetary, taking", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00141-00097959-00098997": "emphasis off success being so transactional and allowing ourselves to measure success", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00142-00098997-00099604": "by how happy we are on a daily basis. You know how happy we are, you know, at the end", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00143-00099604-00100577": "of the week, at the end of the month, and I think in that process, the other will happen.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00144-00100577-00101527": "So, in the process of focusing more of your time and energy, on success being happiness,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00145-00101527-00102448": "I promise you more success will come in the other ways. You know, they, they say focus,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00146-00102448-00102997": "income goes we're focus flows, income flows where focus goes or where focus goes, income", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00147-00102997-00103866": "flows, like if your focus is on being happy, and again, that can be a choice you make in", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00148-00103866-00104401": "those circumstances. Or it can be by putting yourself in more of those circumstances that", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00149-00104401-00105032": "you already know, make you happy. If you can do that more, and if you can live your life", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00150-00105032-00105649": "in a happier place, then you will be more successful in the other areas that we measure", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00151-00105649-00106571": "success. It's just a fact. So that's really it. You know, a day after, that's my observation,", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00152-00106571-00106994": "we may do a follow up on this, you know, a couple months from now, and, you know, talk", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00153-00106994-00107464": "about how I've seen it play out and how I've seen changes made and how I've been more happy.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00154-00107464-00108137": "I mean, quite frankly, I I look forward to being able to talk about how it made an impact.", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00155-00108137-00108567": "And I'd really love you know, for it to do the same thing for you and for us to be able", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00156-00108567-00109285": "to have conversations about the impact that it made. But no different than the idea of", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00157-00109285-00109755": "putting together a vision board. It's kind of like putting together a happiness board", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00158-00109755-00110469": "and getting super clear on the things that bring happiness into your life and ultimately", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00159-00110469-00111133": "in the process, attracting more of that in the years to come. So with that, this is Episode", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00160-00111133-00111778": "153 of the Sales Wolves Podcast. As always, I'm your host, Tyler Jack Harris and I am", "oUjw1UbYdbM-00161-00111778-00111997": "a Sales Wolf."}}, {"audio_id": "oUtMqlATD4u", "text": {"oUtMqlATD4u-00000-00000000-00000200": "I had to remove Taylor Swift from the list."}}, {"audio_id": "oUWN2OKt9AU", "text": {"oUWN2OKt9AU-00000-00000080-00000544": "hello and welcome to a flight over the cloud native landscape my name is carson anderson i work", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00001-00000544-00001040": "for weave the weave that i work for is not the cloud native vendor you might be thinking about my", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00002-00001040-00001528": "wave is an end user company and if you're curious about what we do you can find us at getweave.com", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00003-00001528-00001807": "i'm saying this because i want you to know that i'm going to teach you about a lot of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00004-00001807-00002216": "different projects and you know we have no stake i have no personal professional stake in any of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00005-00002216-00002848": "these projects so you're not getting any sort of specific vendor pitch here now what i want to do", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00006-00002848-00003432": "in this presentation is cover the 12 graduated and 21 incubating projects in the cncf that's", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00007-00003432-00003896": "33 projects total i want you to leave this presentation having a base understanding of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00008-00003896-00004240": "what these projects do and how they relate to each other and know which ones you're curious", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00009-00004240-00004664": "about might want to learn more about or might want to use yourself before we go into the projects", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00010-00004664-00005104": "themselves let's talk about what it means to be graduated in the cncf so if i've got a project", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00011-00005104-00005536": "and that project wants to be a graduated project you have to pass a few things first you have to be", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00012-00005536-00006048": "receiving constant contribution from at least two different organizations into the project", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00013-00006048-00006376": "that that means that you know that if you're going to use a project that's graduated you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00014-00006376-00006895": "not dependent on one organization to maintain the project you also have to certify that you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00015-00006895-00007423": "passing the best practices for core infrastructure and fully open source software you have to pass a", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00016-00007423-00008016": "security audit publish some metadata around who governs the project who's in charge of the code", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00017-00008016-00008576": "and who's using the project once you do that you pass a super majority vote from the cncf", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00018-00008576-00009120": "and you've become a graduated project now notice that never in that did i talk about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00019-00009120-00009688": "something being quote unquote production ready graduated status in the cncf you don't have to be", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00020-00009688-00010192": "graduated to be production ready there are plenty of incubating and even sandbox projects that might", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00021-00010192-00010568": "be production ready for you depending on what you're trying to get so don't be afraid to use", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00022-00010568-00011112": "projects that are incubating or sandbox although it is great to be a graduated project it's not", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00023-00011112-00011656": "necessarily just a measure of production readiness but rather a measure of openness and transparency", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00024-00011816-00012184": "now let's go ahead and dig into all these projects because i have a lot to cover the first one i want", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00025-00012184-00012640": "to talk about is container d it's a daemon like you might expect from the d meaning it's a process", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00026-00012640-00013112": "that runs on your systems to help you manage containers so you can use container d directly in", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00027-00013112-00013728": "your code to build container images and to manage containers but most of us won't use container", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00028-00013728-00014312": "directly most of us will use continuity as part of something like docker or another project so when", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00029-00014312-00014704": "most of us build a container image today and we do that with docker we're doing it with container d", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00030-00014768-00015208": "so in fact this project is so useful that it's actually built into a lot of the public", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00031-00015208-00015719": "cloud kubernetes offerings and the k3s project which is in sandbox state that allows you to run", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00032-00015719-00016263": "a full or mostly full featured kubernetes cluster all in one binary and that does that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00033-00016263-00016640": "using container d so if you're curious about low level container operations check out container d", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00034-00016744-00017216": "next is tough tough stands for the update framework and it's all about dealing with managing", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00035-00017216-00017696": "updates so it's tough as a series of standards and tools that we can build into our code and use", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00036-00017696-00018152": "to deal with updates i'm being intentionally vague here because the tough standards don't prescribe", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00037-00018152-00018568": "to any one specific kind of update you might be they might be package updates or image updates", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00038-00018568-00019048": "but anything that you might want to get regular updates from and verify the source of so that's", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00039-00019048-00019464": "tough i won't cover it much because most of us won't use tough we're going to use the reference", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00040-00019464-00019968": "implementation of tough or the main implementation of tough in notary now notary takes all the tough", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00041-00019968-00020432": "ideas but it builds us some actual tools that most of us can use rather than writing our own code to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00042-00020432-00020984": "deal with update management verification and most of us will probably use notary as part of image", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00043-00020984-00021432": "signing and verification to ensure that when we get an image we get it from somebody that we trust", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00044-00021432-00021808": "and it hasn't been modified along the way so that when we pull images when we pull", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00045-00021808-00022296": "code into our infrastructure we know that we can trust where it came from so that's notary", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00046-00022296-00022648": "again tough and notary have this tight relationship where tough is the standards and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00047-00022648-00023064": "notaries and implementation of it but you should look into both those if you're curious about that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00048-00023160-00023544": "next is harbor harbor is a private image registry and it has all the features you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00049-00023544-00023976": "might expect from a private image registry you can upload oci compliant images and get things", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00050-00023976-00024664": "like validation through something like notary or even image inspection or vulnerability scanning", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00051-00024664-00025032": "and along with a bunch of other features like you might expect from a private registry it", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00052-00025032-00025504": "also has a really cool feature in that it can be a pull through cache so you can run harbor in", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00053-00025504-00026024": "your infrastructure hook it up to public image registries and then have your clients point to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00054-00026024-00026504": "harbor and when they need an image if that image exists in a public registry harper will pull it", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00055-00026504-00026904": "through cache it locally allowing your clients to pull from harbor instead of always going", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00056-00026904-00027280": "over the internet so if you need to reduce your overall image pole bandwidth you might check out", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00057-00027280-00027727": "harbor for that either way if you're curious about having a private image registry check out harbor", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00058-00027848-00028168": "next is kubernetes of course we can't talk cloud native without talking kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00059-00028168-00028760": "kubernetes was the first cncf member project to reach the graduated status and it is at its", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00060-00028760-00029336": "core container orchestration engine so when i say that i mean we've got a suite of backend", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00061-00029336-00029752": "machines in kubernetes we call these nodes and we want to run workloads on those nodes and we", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00062-00029752-00030072": "can tell communities hey i want you to run a workload here's what it should look like", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00063-00030072-00030488": "and kubernetes will put that workload somewhere we can then of course scale up run multiple", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00064-00030488-00030927": "copies of our workload in fact kubernetes can handle tons and tons of different workloads", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00065-00030927-00031368": "with different configuration and because it's an orchestrator it has things like automatic", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00066-00031439-00031800": "uh dealing with things like nodes going down so if a node goes down kubernetes sees that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00067-00031800-00032216": "and can redistribute the declared workload or it can automatically scale up and distribute", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00068-00032216-00032672": "workloads it really lets us stop worrying about nodes in fact most times when we talk kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00069-00032672-00033120": "we don't even talk nodes at all we just think of our kubernetes cluster as a whole cohesive unit", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00070-00033176-00033592": "and we run our workloads in kubernetes and it deals with the underlying infrastructure for us", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00071-00033680-00034000": "and of course i have to bring in captain cube here because they're amazing and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00072-00034056-00034512": "why wouldn't you talk about captain cube when you get a chance kubernetes is really kind", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00073-00034512-00034896": "of the heart of a lot of other things that i'm going to talk about and it is that way", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00074-00034896-00035344": "because it provides a lot of touch points a lot of integration points for other systems to build", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00075-00035344-00035760": "upon kubernetes to provide more value using kubernetes as a core so communities has the", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00076-00035760-00036208": "ability to add storage or networking layers and it can add custom resources which we'll talk about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00077-00036208-00036816": "in a second or even extend brand new apis in the kubernetes api ecosystem so really kubernetes is", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00078-00036816-00037232": "the heart of cloud native in a lot of ways now you don't have to run kubernetes to be cloud native", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00079-00037232-00037896": "but a lot of us do speaking of kubernetes helm is a package manager for kubernetes so home is", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00080-00037896-00038392": "something we do actually have to run in kubernetes because it's specifically around creating and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00081-00038392-00038872": "maintaining applications and kubernetes so we know that we can run our workloads in kubernetes and we", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00082-00038872-00039320": "call those pods but it turns out there's actually a lot of things in kubernetes that we could create", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00083-00039320-00039824": "we can create configuration or services or different routing information to all help", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00084-00039896-00040296": "tell kubernetes what our application looks like to describe our application to kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00085-00040296-00040768": "helm allows us to take all that configuration put it into one thing called a helm chart and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00086-00040768-00041176": "that chart is sort of like a package that says here's what my application looks like here's all", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00087-00041176-00041600": "the things you need to make and how they relate to each other we send that to tom and help create", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00088-00041600-00042024": "it in our trading cluster like we expect the great thing about helm and helm chart is it's", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00089-00042024-00042576": "this kind of recipe this redistributable thing we can take our chart and not only use it internally", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00090-00042576-00043000": "but give that chart to other users or distribute that chart out into the world to help other users", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00091-00043000-00043496": "install our applications into their kubernetes clusters so you'll very often see a lot of the", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00092-00043496-00043896": "things i'm going to talk about be installable into your clusters using something like helm", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00093-00044032-00044296": "another way that you might manage your applications in kubernetes is using", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00094-00044296-00044728": "something like argo argo is also an application manager but it takes a different tact than helm", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00095-00044728-00045184": "argo is a git ops-based system for kubernetes application management meaning that we set up one", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00096-00045184-00045704": "or more git repositories and in those repositories we describe what we want our application to look", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00097-00045704-00046232": "like in kubernetes we then hook argo up between the repositories and our kubernetes cluster or", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00098-00046232-00046744": "clusters and it takes the described application and makes it true in kubernetes and it's doing", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00099-00046744-00047192": "git ops so it's always watching the repository and as the repository changes it syncs those changes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00100-00047192-00047624": "into kubernetes as they happen and it allows us to take all the get ops tools we know and love", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00101-00047624-00048080": "and use them to manage our kubernetes applications so if you're interested in git ops and kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00102-00048080-00048680": "check out argo i will also say that argo you don't have to just use argo adjust you use helm argo", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00103-00048680-00049120": "actually knows how to leverage helm and customize and some other kubernetes deployment mechanisms", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00104-00049120-00049528": "that means they're not mutually exclusive you can use argo and helm together it's absolutely fine", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00105-00049672-00050144": "one other way we might manage applications or the other applications may create for us to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00106-00050144-00050568": "manage them is something called an operator the operator framework is a set of tools", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00107-00050568-00050984": "and libraries to help us build operators now my 30 second what is an operator talk", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00108-00050984-00051408": "so an operator can be thought of as an engine it's a process we run inside our kubernetes cluster", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00109-00051408-00051888": "that knows how to create applications for us and we create something kubernetes called a custom", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00110-00051888-00052432": "resource and that customer resource describes just the minimum amount of configuration that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00111-00052432-00052848": "would need to exist to describe our application and the engine we've written called an operator", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00112-00052848-00053312": "knows how to take that resource and make the application in kubernetes force based on that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00113-00053312-00053679": "resource and then if we make a different resource or different configuration the operator can", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00114-00053679-00054200": "operate on that and make that copy of the application really the focus here is these crds", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00115-00054200-00054679": "rather than build a helm chart or a git repository we actually put a resource into the kubernetes api", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00116-00054679-00055208": "describing our application and we use the operator framework or other tools to create an operator", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00117-00055208-00055728": "that knows how to take those custom resources and turn them into applications in our cluster so if", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00118-00055728-00056136": "you're curious about a more advanced way to manage your applications throughout their entire life", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00119-00056136-00056608": "cycle inside kubernetes check out the operator framework and just like before the operators and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00120-00056608-00057008": "helm and argo those are not all mutually exclusive and a lot of them can work together very well", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00121-00057167-00057655": "next is contour contour sort of fills another gap in the kubernetes ecosystem so we talked", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00122-00057655-00058096": "about kubernetes can run our workloads it can also run these things called ingress and ingress", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00123-00058096-00058576": "really is just a set of configuration it's a set of configurations like host and path-based", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00124-00058576-00059055": "information says hey if you're coming in for this host and this path go to this workload but there's", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00125-00059055-00059504": "something missing ingress is just configuration something has to exist in the kubernetes cluster", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00126-00059504-00060024": "to make that configuration real something has to run in the cluster receive user traffic read the", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00127-00060024-00060567": "ingress configuration and route to the right place based on that config and that's what it called", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00128-00060567-00060920": "is called an ingress controller in kubernetes and there are a lot of ingress controllers you can run", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00129-00060920-00061448": "in kubernetes many of them are legacy web servers kind of jammed into this ingress controller role", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00130-00061512-00062008": "but contour is built from the ground up to be an ingress controller for kubernetes so if you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00131-00062008-00062400": "looking for a cloud native ingress controller or an ingress controller that's built specifically", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00132-00062400-00062888": "for this job and to try to do the right things for you right from the start check out contour", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00133-00063055-00063520": "next is cube edge cube edge is interesting because it's orchestration built on kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00134-00063520-00064000": "so we already know kubernetes can do container orchestration but cube edge is a platform that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00135-00064000-00064512": "leverages the kubernetes apis and extension points to allow us to do edge compute management", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00136-00064512-00065016": "using the kubernetes apis so if you're curious about doing edge management and managing your", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00137-00065016-00065440": "computer at the edge and you want to use the kubernetes tools and api check out cube edge", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00138-00065576-00065960": "next is rook rook is also orchestration that runs in kubernetes but instead of managing", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00139-00065960-00066400": "other devices or containers work is about managing storage inside kubernetes so rook", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00140-00066400-00066880": "runs in kubernetes and allows you to deal with block storage or object storage and it can do", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00141-00066880-00067320": "things like provide persistent volumes for your workloads so they can have a volume that follows", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00142-00067320-00067816": "them around in your cluster or do other things like i said object storage and other kinds of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00143-00067816-00068232": "storage extensions that you would build on top of kubernetes using rook so if you're curious about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00144-00068232-00068952": "storage and kubernetes check out rook next is cryo or crio cri stands for container runtime interface", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00145-00068952-00069544": "it is kind of a layer that we described that we defined to help kubernetes run containers and o", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00146-00069544-00070056": "stands for oci compliant so every single node in our kubernetes cluster runs this thing called a", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00147-00070056-00070632": "cubelet and it's the cubelet's job to create and manage containers over their lifecycle on the node", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00148-00070632-00070992": "but there's this kind of squishy blue layer i've drawn between the cubelet and actually", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00149-00070992-00071496": "doing things with containers and that is where cri or the container runtime interface lives", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00150-00071496-00072168": "and it is definitely where crio lives because cryo is a run a container runtime interface", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00151-00072168-00072728": "built specifically for kubernetes to be simple and fast and efficient so if you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00152-00072728-00073344": "curious about container runtime for kubernetes built for kubernetes check out cryo next is cni", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00153-00073344-00073808": "cni stands for container network interface so we've got our workloads running on multiple", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00154-00073808-00074192": "nodes and often they'll talk to each other over the network sometimes that's on the same node", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00155-00074192-00074696": "but very often it's across nodes and something needs to exist to kind of define and implement", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00156-00074696-00075200": "standards for how we set up networking between our workloads in a cluster or in the cloud", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00157-00075200-00075624": "and that's what cni seeks to do it's a set of standards and tools and some kind of low-level", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00158-00075688-00076216": "helpers to help you build tools to deal with container to container networking in the cloud", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00159-00076216-00076648": "or in kubernetes so if you're interested in the low-level operations of networks check out cni", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00160-00076848-00077400": "next is grpc so we've got our applications and they need to talk to each other one way they might", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00161-00077400-00077880": "do that is over something like http it's been around for a long time it's kind of a low-level", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00162-00077880-00078392": "interrupt but http although it's great has its problems primarily it's got a lot of overhead", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00163-00078392-00078824": "because it's connectionless and stateless there's a lot of overhead in every single http request", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00164-00078824-00079496": "to describe what's going on grpc exists as an alternative or can run alongside http as another", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00165-00079496-00080056": "way for our applications to communicate with each other over a network and this is stateful and has", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00166-00080056-00080632": "less overhead so it can be a lot lot faster than http grpc also has cool things like bi-directional", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00167-00080632-00081136": "streaming where applications can stream over a single connection both ways uh if you leverage", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00168-00081136-00081608": "things like proto you can also get things like type safety using grpc so if you're looking to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00169-00081608-00082008": "do application to application communication over the network and want to go above and beyond what", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00170-00082008-00082752": "you get from http check out grpc next is core dns core dns is like you might expect a dns", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00171-00082752-00083240": "server built for the cloud so we if we're all honest with each other dns is the oldest form of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00172-00083240-00083696": "what we call service discovery right we ask for something by name dns gives us back where that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00173-00083696-00084104": "lives and even though we've got all of these cool new ways to do service discovery in the cloud we", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00174-00084104-00084728": "still tend to tend to use dns a lot and core dns exists to be a brand new dns server that is built", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00175-00084728-00085152": "for the cloud and this picture that i'm showing you seems empty seems like there's a lot missing", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00176-00085152-00085688": "and that's because coordinates really exists at the core of this big ecosystem of plug-ins core", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00177-00085688-00086224": "dns has plug-ins for multiple ways to serve dns traffic whether that's the traditional udp or", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00178-00086224-00086888": "new protocols like http 2 or grpc it also has the ability to bring in configuration and receive both", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00179-00086952-00087504": "initial configuration and constant active reconfiguration from multiple sources including", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00180-00087504-00088032": "things like kubernetes std which we'll talk about or even public clouds where core dns can privately", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00181-00088032-00088528": "serve the records that you define in your public cloud dns systems it also has plugins to help you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00182-00088528-00089080": "do things like rewrites and tracing and metrics on your dns it really brings dns into the modern age", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00183-00089184-00089544": "in fact all these features make coordinates the recommended and go-to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00184-00089544-00089968": "dns solution for doing dns inside of kubernetes and it has been that way for quite a while now", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00185-00090032-00090352": "so if you're curious about a modern dns implementation check out coordinates", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00186-00090480-00090872": "now before i talk about the next two projects i want to briefly describe what a service mesh", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00187-00090872-00091456": "is so we've got our applications they're talking to each other and if we want to add features to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00188-00091456-00091960": "this network communication of our applications features like end-to-end encryption transparency", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00189-00092016-00092560": "load balancing traces name any feature you want to add that's around networking in the past we've had", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00190-00092560-00092968": "to code that feature into every application and we've had to ensure that all those applications", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00191-00093032-00093376": "support the same amount of features and their features work the same way and it can get very", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00192-00093376-00093832": "onerous and sometimes not just not be possible to change the code of a specific application", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00193-00093904-00094360": "a service mesh says well what if we write a proxy process and this proxy process can be thought", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00194-00094360-00094832": "of as living around our application although it technically lives just between the application and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00195-00094832-00095336": "the and the network and that proxy is responsible for implementing the code to do all the things i", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00196-00095336-00095720": "just talked about transparency encryption that kind of thing well once we've got all these", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00197-00095720-00096184": "proxies distributed and running in our ecosystem we'll want a control plane that can manage these", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00198-00096184-00096624": "distributed proxies and give us a way to view what's happening with them and control them you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00199-00096624-00097040": "combine a proxy and a control plane and you get a service mesh and you get powerful features like", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00200-00097040-00097664": "metrics load balancing encryption and transparency and tracing all from the proxy without ever having", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00201-00097664-00098088": "to change your service code and this is very very powerful and there are two projects i want to talk", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00202-00098088-00098680": "about that are part of a service mesh the first one is linker d linker d is a cnn cncf project", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00203-00098680-00099168": "that is a complete service mesh offering so we've got our applications talking to each other", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00204-00099168-00099648": "linker d comes with the linker d2 proxy which is a proxy process written from the ground up", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00205-00099648-00100152": "for linker d to do this service mesh to implement these service mesh ideas it also comes with the", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00206-00100152-00100696": "linker d2 control plane that allows you to manage all the proxies so it really is a full complete", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00207-00100696-00101240": "end-to-end service mesh solution it's also very easy to get up and going and to use linker d so", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00208-00101240-00101544": "if you're looking to implement a service mesh and you want to get up and going and want a", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00209-00101544-00102056": "complete solution you can check out link or d another alternative for a service mesh is onboy", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00210-00102056-00102568": "now onboard is a bit different in that envoy just focuses on being the proxy process for the service", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00211-00102568-00103088": "mesh if you're asking where is the control plane envoy doesn't provide one it doesn't prescribe", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00212-00103088-00103583": "one it leaves that open to the implementer and this seems like a downside that blank spot may", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00213-00103583-00104016": "seem initially compared to d like it's a problem but it's actually a great power the fact that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00214-00104016-00104640": "the envoy proxy folks project focuses entirely on being a service mesh proxy or just a service proxy", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00215-00104640-00105088": "means that it can really focus on that and provide the best possible proxy that you could need and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00216-00105088-00105704": "actually envoy is the backing proxy between a lot of other cloud native projects so if you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00217-00105704-00106328": "curious about just running a service proxy check out envoy next is open tracing like you might", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00218-00106328-00106672": "guess it's all about dealing with traces so we know that we can use something like a service mesh", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00219-00106672-00107208": "to get automatic tracing between our user requests and the applications it bounces around but if we", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00220-00107208-00107704": "want to know what that user request does in each application it visits as it kind of goes from", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00221-00107704-00108072": "method to method and spends a different amount of time in each application doing different things", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00222-00108072-00108632": "we need to instrument our applications we need to write code to create these tracing these traces", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00223-00108704-00109104": "and that's what open tracing exists to do it like you might have guessed from the name open tracing", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00224-00109104-00109511": "is provider agnostic so the great thing about it is you can instrument your applications you can", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00225-00109511-00109976": "write code in your applications to generate trace data and open tracing works with a multitude of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00226-00109976-00110392": "providers meaning that it doesn't care who you use you instrument once and never have to do it again", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00227-00110464-00110968": "one place you might export this trace data from open tracing or elsewhere is to jager jaeger is a", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00228-00110968-00111488": "trace aggregation and trace management platform so we've got our trace data that we've got from our", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00229-00111488-00111944": "service mesh or some from something like open tracing we need to take that data and send it", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00230-00111944-00112392": "somewhere so that we can aggregate it all and view it and manage it and that's what jaeger", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00231-00112392-00112848": "does jaeger provides a ui where you can dig into your traces and see exactly how they break down", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00232-00112848-00113224": "if you can search through your traces and it has other api extensions that lets you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00233-00113224-00113711": "really be the core of tracing in your cloud native system so that's jaeger if you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00234-00113711-00114135": "curious about somewhere to send your traces and view your traces in the cloud check out jager", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00235-00114272-00114744": "next is prometheus prometheus is all about dealing with metrics in the cloud now we know that we run", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00236-00114744-00115200": "applications all over the place especially in the cloud and those applications are generating data", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00237-00115200-00115528": "right they want to generate data around how many requests they're making how many requests they're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00238-00115528-00116008": "succeeding and failing that kind of stuff what we used to do when we wanted application metrics was", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00239-00116072-00116448": "instrument our applications put code in there to have the applications take those metrics and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00240-00116448-00116880": "export them to a specific provider and if we ever wanted to switch metrics providers we couldn't do", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00241-00116880-00117416": "it because applications would have to be retooled uh prometheus turns out on its head community says", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00242-00117416-00117911": "well part of the prometheus spec is saying here's a standard way that you're all going to serve up", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00243-00117911-00118400": "metrics you're going to expose a web page and give me your metrics and prometheus is going to go to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00244-00118400-00118944": "each application individually and pull that metric data down and aggregate it and it knows where your", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00245-00118944-00119256": "applications live because remember we're in the cloud things are coming and going all the time", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00246-00119256-00119656": "it knows where your applications are and how to find them by having cloud integrations or", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00247-00119656-00120128": "kubernetes integrations so that azure applications come up and down and move prometheus always knows", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00248-00120128-00120680": "where to go to get that metric data and it kind of flips the whole idea of metrics on its head once", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00249-00120680-00121080": "prometheus has gone and scraped that metric data and pulled it in it pulls it into its own internal", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00250-00121080-00121616": "time series database and can give you features like charting and alerts and metric searching", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00251-00121616-00122064": "and other api integrations that really sort of like jager was with traces it lets prometheus", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00252-00122064-00122568": "be the core of metrics in the cloud so if you're interested in an open source metric system check", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00253-00122568-00123280": "out prometheus now thanos exists alongside and with prometheus to solve some specific problems", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00254-00123352-00123768": "it is very easy to get up and going with a single prometheus instance in the cloud no big", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00255-00123768-00124240": "deal you can get up and going very quickly but if you're going to run multiple prometheus instances", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00256-00124240-00124696": "and if they're going to be distributed across geographic regions or you want fault tolerance", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00257-00124696-00125159": "the prometheus project isn't really focused on solving that right now but the thanos project is", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00258-00125159-00125648": "you can think of thanos as a wrapper around one or more prometheus instances that allows you to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00259-00125648-00126080": "aggregate data and go to thanos and run a metrics query and have it go to all your prometheus", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00260-00126080-00126616": "instances and run that grave for you thanos also has the ability to take that data and export it", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00261-00126616-00127104": "into multiple cloud storage mechanisms so that you can have long-term prometheus storage because", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00262-00127104-00127616": "prometheus doesn't tend to want to keep data for very long so if you're curious about distributed", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00263-00127616-00128152": "prometheus long-term metrics from prometheus check out thanos in that same vein there's the cortex", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00264-00128152-00128608": "project now the cortex project also exists to solve the multiple prometheus problem but it works", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00265-00128608-00129104": "a bit differently it's designed to always pull all of the data rather than wrapping it just ingests", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00266-00129104-00129559": "all the data from all your prometheus instances and stores it in its own internal architecture", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00267-00129559-00129992": "that way when you query your metrics you don't even have to go to your prometheus instances", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00268-00129992-00130383": "they just act as a data source and really cortex is at the heart of your metrics at that point", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00269-00130456-00130864": "so if you're interested in long-term aggregated prometheus metrics you can check out cortex now", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00270-00130864-00131336": "i know those two projects thanos and cortex seem very similar and that's because they are you'll", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00271-00131336-00131784": "have to do your own research to find out which of these two projects might be the right one for you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00272-00131856-00132360": "next is flint d now fluid d is all about dealing with streaming text processing and very often", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00273-00132360-00132848": "log processing in the cloud and elsewhere so at its core fluentd can be set up to take in", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00274-00132848-00133352": "multiple streams of text read those streams as they come in process them internally and spit", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00275-00133352-00133952": "them out into other places to clouds to files to other integrations it really kind of exists as", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00276-00133952-00134448": "this integration and glue layer between your data sources and where you might want to put that data", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00277-00134504-00135040": "all of this makes fluentd a really great place to handle logs from kubernetes so we've got", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00278-00135040-00135440": "kubernetes we've got our workloads running and those workloads are all generating log data", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00279-00135440-00135840": "which is text data and they're generating that all the time and coming and going", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00280-00135840-00136344": "and very often fluent d is the engine behind most of the prometheus or sorry", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00281-00136344-00136752": "most of the kubernetes installations that you run where it's reading those logs as they're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00282-00136752-00137232": "generated reformatting them and sending them to some cloud integration so that even though", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00283-00137232-00137840": "you've got containers running across many many backend machines you can view all their logs", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00284-00137840-00138288": "in one place thanks to the aggregation and export and manipulation provided by something", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00285-00138288-00138728": "like fluentd so whether you're using fluentd and don't know it because it's in kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00286-00138728-00139104": "or you're interested in doing log processing directly with fluentd you should check it out", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00287-00139256-00139624": "next is by tess my test is all about dealing with relational databases in the cloud", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00288-00139712-00140128": "so it's easy easy easy to run a relational database in the cloud or in kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00289-00140128-00140560": "but the problem with these databases is they tend to have to scale vertically and that is really", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00290-00140560-00140872": "vulnerable and brittle in the cloud because we don't want things to scale vertically we", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00291-00140872-00141296": "want to scale horizontally we want to be fault tolerant and distributed so we want to split", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00292-00141296-00141752": "that big horizontal or vertically scale database into multiple smaller databases and by tests", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00293-00141752-00142440": "exists to help us do that by test is a layer that runs on top of the mysql or mariadb engine that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00294-00142440-00142904": "you already know and trust but allows for powerful features like replication and sharding and you can", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00295-00142904-00143424": "actually increase replicas and reshard and do all sorts of database manipulation using byte tests", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00296-00143424-00144032": "well while just using the standard mysql engine my test also has a proxy process that you can run", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00297-00144032-00144600": "that allows you to take in sql or grpc traffic and distribute it to these kind of more dynamic", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00298-00144600-00145144": "sharded replicated changing database instances all this allows my test to be a really great", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00299-00145144-00145528": "solution for running relational databases and kubernetes allows you to scale and distribute", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00300-00145528-00145984": "and be fault tolerant all while still using the kind of database interface that you know and trust", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00301-00146096-00146696": "so that's my tests next is titanium or thai kv type a v is a key value store so it's all about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00302-00146696-00147128": "dealing with key values so it does the things you might expect from a key value store does adds it", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00303-00147128-00147616": "does updates it does deletes but the cool thing about thai kv is that it scales horizontally like", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00304-00147616-00148120": "my test scales horizontally very very well in fact according to my test page they say that it scales", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00305-00148120-00148624": "up to petabytes worth of key value data that's huge scale another really great thing about thai", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00306-00148624-00149208": "kv is that it supports distributed acid compliant transactions so you into a kv installation you can", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00307-00149208-00149648": "say i want you to update this key delete these three keys change those two keys and i want you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00308-00149648-00150184": "to do all of those operations at once or not at all that ensures that if you're doing multiple", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00309-00150184-00150624": "key operations in your key value store you don't have to get stuck in a halfway state where one", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00310-00150624-00151056": "transact one operation worked and the other failed and you don't know how to recover so if you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00311-00151056-00151504": "interested in really high scale key value store or transactional key value stored check out taikb", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00312-00151632-00152072": "scd is also a key value store that's cloud native so it does all the same things that i've just", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00313-00152072-00152680": "described out of dates deletes but ftd rather than focusing on sheer scale has focused on simplicity", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00314-00152680-00153136": "so it's very very easy to get up and going with an std installation or an scd cluster it's often", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00315-00153136-00153656": "just a few commands or a single uh file away from having a fully functional lcd cluster", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00316-00153768-00154456": "so it has all the things you might expect leader election fault tolerance distributed load but it's", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00317-00154456-00154840": "much much simpler to run than some of the other offerings in fact the kind of combination of", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00318-00154840-00155336": "features and simplicity have made ncd the go-to back-end for the kubernetes api for a long time", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00319-00155336-00155832": "for a while it was the only back end there are a few others now but odds are really good that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00320-00155832-00156288": "if you're using kubernetes you're probably using std behind the scenes to store all the data you're", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00321-00156288-00156888": "sending into the kubernetes api but you can absolutely use etd directly for yourself as", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00322-00156888-00157488": "a key value store next is dragonfly dragonfly is all about peer-to-peer file transmission so we've", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00323-00157488-00157952": "got multiple peers they can send files to each other dragonfly is agnostic about the file content", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00324-00157952-00158432": "but it does have some first class integrations for images so dragonfly has native integrations", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00325-00158432-00158848": "to deal with image transmission peer-to-peer and that's not very interesting but what's cool about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00326-00158848-00159376": "dragonfly is it's distributed peer-to-peer transmission so you set up dragonfly nodes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00327-00159376-00159840": "throughout your system and when anybody wants to download a specific image rather than having to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00328-00159840-00160240": "go out to a single place to download the whole image they can download parts of that image or", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00329-00160240-00160792": "parts of any file from the peers that have chunks of that file rather than always having to go out", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00330-00160792-00161128": "so if you're curious about a better way to do peer-to-peer file transmission or a better way to", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00331-00161128-00161784": "do image transmission check out dragonfly next is cloud events cloud events like you might guess is", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00332-00161784-00162272": "all about dealing with event infrastructure in the cloud so we've got our applications and they have", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00333-00162272-00162768": "the ability of course to we say we decide that we want to do event-based infrastructure one thing we", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00334-00162768-00163144": "might not agree on is the exact format of our events we may want to use different structure", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00335-00163144-00163560": "different terms and it makes it really hard to say well we all want to do events but we can't agree", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00336-00163560-00164120": "on what the event should look like cloud events exist to be a series of standards and sdks for", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00337-00164120-00164560": "us to work with event-based infrastructure and all agree that we're going to use cloud events so that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00338-00164560-00164960": "we can very easily and efficiently interact with each other because we all use the same back-end", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00339-00164960-00165384": "event structure so if you're curious about event-based infrastructure check out cloud events", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00340-00165456-00165880": "in that same vein let's talk about gnats nats is at its heart really a message bus", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00341-00165880-00166320": "so you have producers and consumers where you can put messages into gnats and get them from other", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00342-00166320-00166752": "processes and that of course can run distributed and deal with lots and lots of producers and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00343-00166752-00167392": "consumers it supports a lot of different event bus systems so you could do things like uh pub", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00344-00167392-00167720": "sub where you publish a message and multiple subscribers get that message", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00345-00167720-00168160": "you can do request reply where you're sent specifically to someone and get a specific", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00346-00168160-00168800": "answer back or you can do topic based or streaming event processing all using nats that's also scales", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00347-00168800-00169304": "dynamically and very efficiently so not only is it fast and flexible and really efficient but it", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00348-00169304-00169704": "scales really well which makes it a great solution for doing event-based infrastructure in kubernetes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00349-00169784-00170120": "so that's nats if you're curious about building an event-based system check it out", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00350-00170208-00170728": "next is spiffy or the secure production identity framework for everyone and it's all about like you", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00351-00170728-00171160": "might guess identity spiffy is a set of standards and tools for dealing with identity in the cloud", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00352-00171160-00171672": "now when i say identity i don't just mean users i mean identity at the node level identity at the", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00353-00171672-00172136": "workload level or identity at processes inside the workload spiffy's really about saying well let's", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00354-00172136-00172664": "take identity and go as deep as we need to and be more dynamic and more fluid and more granular if", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00355-00172664-00173184": "we need to to help us deal with identity in the cloud spiffy is another case where you probably", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00356-00173184-00173624": "won't use it directly you probably use the spire project which takes all the implementations and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00357-00173624-00174160": "standards of spiffy and build some tools the spire server and aspire agent where you can", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00358-00174160-00174544": "implement some of the spiffy concepts and get this kind of identity stuff i've been talking about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00359-00174544-00174976": "without having to write your own code so if you're interested in identity and you want to write your", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00360-00174976-00175592": "own code check out spiffy or if you want to just leverage the spiffy concepts check out spire next", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00361-00175592-00176112": "is open policy agent it's all about dealing with policy enforcement so we feed open policy agent", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00362-00176112-00176560": "policy documents saying here's what we do and do not want to allow into a given system and then", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00363-00176560-00177024": "as we feed objects into that system opa either accepts them or rejects them based on the policy", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00364-00177024-00177552": "it's been given i'm being intentionally vague because open opa doesn't prescribe a specific", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00365-00177552-00178120": "thing that it's an enforcer of opa has been used to enforce policy for a ton of things one thing", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00366-00178120-00178624": "opa fits really well onto though is kubernetes opa can run a on top of and in front of your", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00367-00178624-00179120": "kubernetes api so that you can kind of control what you allow into your kubernetes cluster and", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00368-00179120-00179560": "what you don't based on the policy that you give opa so if you're interested in policy", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00369-00179560-00180208": "definition or policy enforcement check out opa last but not least is falco falco is all about", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00370-00180208-00180784": "container runtime security so we've got our images and we can use things like notary to validate that", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00371-00180784-00181232": "we're running images we trust but we might still want to watch these images or these containers or", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00372-00181232-00181696": "these processes the entire time they're running so falco does that falco does this to run in our", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00373-00181696-00182184": "infrastructure and watch our processes all the time and it has a set of internal rules that says", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00374-00182184-00182632": "what it expects them to do and what expects them not to do and if any of our processes", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00375-00182632-00183072": "does something we don't expect like accessing a database we didn't expect it to reach falco can", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00376-00183072-00183624": "see that and send an alert when it happens so you get always on active security for your workloads", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00377-00183624-00184088": "so if you're curious about that check out falco you can follow me at twitter at carson underscore", "oUWN2OKt9AU-00378-00184088-00184824": "ops and on github carsonoid thank you so much for all your time and i hope to see you again soon"}}, {"audio_id": "oUbICcE4Kzo", "text": {"oUbICcE4Kzo-00000-00000936-00005217": "eu cresci em uma pequena cidade com uma populacao de 5 mil", "oUbICcE4Kzo-00001-00005217-00005296": "habitantes"}}, {"audio_id": "oV0fk26DdlE", "text": {"oV0fk26DdlE-00000-00000408-00001136": "hello buddy make sure you like scrap i'll teach you how to uh get an older version of discord", "oV0fk26DdlE-00001-00001136-00001784": "2022 now i'll teach you how to do that so make sure that like it's craft if you're new", "oV0fk26DdlE-00002-00001784-00002616": "here just want to know how to do that if you want discord be on the old phone now uh manu", "oV0fk26DdlE-00003-00002616-00003168": "it thinks it's gonna harm your system but it doesn't it's false so it's going to help you", "oV0fk26DdlE-00004-00003247-00003536": "change your discord piano logo or discord", "oV0fk26DdlE-00005-00003744-00004432": "okay guys let's continue hey guys today i'll teach you how to get an older discord for free", "oV0fk26DdlE-00006-00004552-00004880": "so you don't get bugs or or nothing like that", "oV0fk26DdlE-00007-00004952-00005808": "so i'm gonna teach you how to do it i'm gonna go back home now", "oV0fk26DdlE-00008-00005808-00005944": "i'm going to show you uh", "oV0fk26DdlE-00009-00006232-00007456": "the ways of discord now in 2022 you used to had an old version of this card now discord now let", "oV0fk26DdlE-00010-00007456-00008152": "me let me tell you what is about this score now discord is a it's a website like like apps okay", "oV0fk26DdlE-00011-00008224-00008696": "now this scored is a it's an online game you can play it with friends", "oV0fk26DdlE-00012-00008864-00010000": "uh share your video with your friend now click the link and i'll send you the link", "oV0fk26DdlE-00013-00010000-00011192": "uh here do this guys now when i go back home okay i'm gonna show you this http whatever it says but", "oV0fk26DdlE-00014-00011192-00012480": "um press the leases version now i'm going to take go back in 2022 now look at the look on", "oV0fk26DdlE-00015-00012608-00013480": "generate 3 5th 2022 now you'll see when you download it click the download and", "oV0fk26DdlE-00016-00013719-00014128": "like this click it again now i already have it", "oV0fk26DdlE-00017-00014128-00014808": "only showing you now it's gonna say it's gonna harm your system but doesn't just say keep it so", "oV0fk26DdlE-00018-00015191-00015991": "when you keep it download this and then install it if you want just install it fast because", "oV0fk26DdlE-00019-00015991-00016544": "uh it's a safe website it does not have no no manners nothing like that so", "oV0fk26DdlE-00020-00016728-00017816": "oh let me just here so when it's in 2000 uh july 2023 the third now it will show like that now", "oV0fk26DdlE-00021-00017816-00018368": "click the folder download it fast and when you download click on it open the and log", "oV0fk26DdlE-00022-00018368-00019224": "into your account if you have the fortune 2022 uh that is turn 22. now if we go back", "oV0fk26DdlE-00023-00019224-00020200": "to 2022 it's an older version of discord now we need get a full discord version you'll see now", "oV0fk26DdlE-00024-00020424-00021408": "now you'll see i have discord now now you see this one compare this one you see this my discord is", "oV0fk26DdlE-00025-00021408-00022160": "newer and old version now i like an old version i use windows phone the microsoft phone so yeah", "oV0fk26DdlE-00026-00022160-00023152": "i use this before in 2019 i don't know but it was pretty old now make sure to do the steps i", "oV0fk26DdlE-00027-00023152-00023992": "said uh make sure to like subscribe and thanks uh for let's do 2.9k and comment below if you have", "oV0fk26DdlE-00028-00023992-00024936": "questions that's related guys oh yeah guys uh be safe guys also i will be um back for another video", "oV0fk26DdlE-00029-00024936-00025864": "and subscribe like scrap and 3.9k and comment below 2.5 k for chat thanks guys and make sure", "oV0fk26DdlE-00030-00025864-00026783": "to vote which is better the newer version or the old version of discord bye guys thanks"}}, {"audio_id": "oV3J_rTl8EY", "text": {"oV3J_rTl8EY-00000-00000000-00000300": "Cocaine and drinking with your friends", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00001-00000362-00000681": "You live in the dark, boy, I cannot pretend", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00002-00000755-00001075": "I'm not fazed, only here to sin", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00003-00001100-00001465": "If Eve ain't in your garden, you know that you can", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00004-00001497-00001860": "Call me when you want, call me when you need", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00005-00001887-00002261": "Call me in the morning, I'll be on the way", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00006-00002261-00002648": "Call me when you want, call me when you need", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00007-00002657-00003042": "Call me out by your name, I'll be on the way like", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00008-00003050-00003389": "Mmm, mmm, mmm", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00009-00003424-00003722": "Mmm, mmm, mmm", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00010-00003800-00004154": "Mmm, mmm, mmm", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00011-00004191-00004437": "Mmm, mmm, mmm", "oV3J_rTl8EY-00012-00004437-00004637": "Ayy, ayy"}}, {"audio_id": "oVPM9R-6PsE", "text": {}}]